Mackie
22 Followers
Recent papers in Mackie
Moral error theorists argue that moral thought and discourse are systematically in error, and that nothing is, or can ever be, morally permissible, required or forbidden. I begin by discussing how error theorists arrive at this... more
Another Compilation of Informations in which the overall objective is to carefully draw attention to our ever-changing universe in which we exist in, and how to make notice of these astronomical observations in changes as how they relate... more
Many proponents of the Abrahamic religions assume that the Theory of Evolution is ipso facto opposed to religion, and therefore, since religion derives from scripture, which is the divinely inspired word of an infallible God, the Theory... more
My aim in this paper is to critically assess two opposing theses about the epistemology of religious belief. The first one, developed by John Mackie, claims that belief in God can be justified or warranted only if there is a good argument... more
Questo lavoro esamina il pensiero metaetico di John L. Mackie per l’importanza e l’ancora attualità che riveste in ambito etico il dibattito tra realismo e anti-realismo morale e l’indubbia importanza che la sua opera del 1977 "Ethics" ha... more
Religious diversity is a key topic in contemporary philosophy of religion. One way religious diversity has been of interest to philosophers is in the epistemological questions it gives rise to. In other words, religious diversity has been... more
Was Nietzsche a nihilist? Yes, because, like J. L. Mackie, he was an error-theorist about morality, including the elitist morality to which he himself subscribed. But he was variously a diagnostician, an opponent and a survivor of certain... more
When one deliberates one has reasons both for and against doing something. Could the reasons for OBJECTIVELY outweigh the reasons against, in the sense that someone who thought otherwise would simply be wrong? (This is not the same... more
Richard Swinburne, in his The Existence of God (2004), presents a cosmological argument in defence of theism (Swinburne, 1991, p119, p135). God, Swinburne argues, is more likely to bring about an ordered universe than other states (ibid.,... more
In an earlier paper, 'Peter Geach on nonsense, confusion and sin' 1 , I suggested that what one can say in explanation of one's own actions suffers from a severe limitation: one can shed little light on the question why one acted on one's... more
Given ht as the hypothesis of theism, hm as the hypothesis of materialism, and e as the evidence of a complex life-bearing universe, Swinburne presents these arguments in his "The Existence of God" (2004): (1) That this ordered universe... more
The aim of this thesis is to articulate an actual consent account of legitimate government as appointed by a free association of people, to protect them from harm, with the power to use coercion both to apprehend wrongdoers and to collect... more
Mackie’s claim that in general courage benefits its possessor seems inconsistent with his ‘error theory’ of value. But how plausible is it in itself? I suggest that his arguments for the claim fail in the same way as the arguments of... more
I argue that Mackie's thesis about courage and self-interest is neither consistent with his 'error theory' of value nor convincing in itself. The question of the objectivity of value needs to be distinguished from that of whether one... more
This is English translation of the abstract of a paper that is published in Farsi (Persian).
علیت یکی از مسائل مهم فلسفی است که تحلیلهای هیوم آن را با چالشها و معضلات زیادی روبرو ساخته و تئورسینهای بسیاری را به نظریهپردازی در این خصوص واداشته است. از جملۀ این نظریهپردازان میتوان به تلاشهای دو فیلسوف تحلیلی یعنی؛ لوئیس و... more
In “The possibility of morality,” Phil Brown considers whether moral error theory is best understood as a necessary or contingent thesis. Among other things, Brown contends that the argument from relativity, offered by John Mackie—error... more