Direct Realism
33 Followers
Recent papers in Direct Realism
Cite as:
Bianca Trovò. (2013, January 7). Dall'approccio ecologico all'embodiment: l'inemendabilità del reale secondo l'ottica gibsoniana (Version 1). Zenodo. http://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.3830118
Bianca Trovò. (2013, January 7). Dall'approccio ecologico all'embodiment: l'inemendabilità del reale secondo l'ottica gibsoniana (Version 1). Zenodo. http://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.3830118
Umberto Eco (1975; 1985) has invariantly maintained that specular images have no semiosic status, basically because they stand in front rather than instead of an object. In his Kant and the Platypus (1997), Eco returns offering reasons to... more
The question whether God knows particular individuals has traditionally attracted the attention of Islamic scholars: Does the perishability of worldly individuals entail problems about the perishability of God's corresponding knowledge?... more
An attempt to take back ‘direct realism’ as a name for a plausible view from those who have recently tried to co-opt it to name a suite of implausible views. (1) Direct realism is true, when properly understood. Descartes and Arnauld... more
In this paper, I explore and examine different ways in which affectivity is related to perception within ecological psychology. I assess whether some of those ways compromise the realist and direct aspects of traditional ecological... more
Naïve realism, often overlooked among philosophical theories of perception, has in recent years attracted a surge of interest. Broadly speaking, the central commitment of naïve realism is that mind-independent objects are essential to the... more
This thesis aims at laying the groundwork for a research program in philosophy of mind by arguing for two theoretical positions, internalism and representationalism (intentionalism), which are rarely defended jointly, but which together... more
My aim in this paper is to consider various forms of perceptual realism, including, for purposes of comparison, the largely abandoned indirect or representative realism. After surveying the variety of perceptual realisms and considering... more
Phenomenal objectivism explains perceptual phenomenal character by reducing it to an awareness of mind-independent objects, properties, and relations. A challenge for this view is that there is a sense in which a distant tree looks... more
This paper investigates the debate about mental images in early-modern scholasticism, by means of a close reading of two Spanish authors, the Pedro Hurtado de Mendoza (1578-1641, a Jesuit reputed for his leaning towards nominalism) and... more
3rd chapter from my dissertation, discussing interpretations of Descartes' notion of "idea".
This paper aims to defend the thesis that we can only perceive what we understand. Such a theory would seem to be unable to account for our learning to perceive what we do not yet understand. To address this objection, the paper presents... more
Unlike “Virtual Reality” in “Augmented Reality” (AR) the stress is put on the word “reality”. However, it seems that we still lack a concept of reality which can fit the world of both humans and computers. In connection with this... more
Review of books about Thomas Reid and Common Sense Philosophy
In recent years, it has become popular again to endorse relationalism about perception. According to this view, perceptions are essentially relational experiences and thus differ in nature from non-relational hallucinations. In this... more
C. S. Peirce introduced the term “icon” for sign-vehicles that signify their objects in virtue of some shared quality. This qualitative kinship, however, threatens to collapse the relata of the sign into one and the same thing.... more
Naïve realists traditionally reject the time lag argument by replying that we can be in a direct visual perceptual relation to temporally distant facts or objects. I first show that this answer entails that some visual perceptions – i.e.... more
Kant posits the schema as a hybrid bridging the generality of pure concepts and the particularity of sensible intuitions. However, I argue that countenancing such schemata leads to a third-man regress. Siding with those who think that the... more
Thomas Reid describes visible figure as both a ‘real and external object to the eye’ and as the ‘immediate object’ of sight. This generates an apparent challenge to Reid’s direct realism since if the ‘immediate’ object of sight is also... more
In this paper I show that, in Husserl’s phenomenology of perception, the consciousness of any perceiving subject can take up space. What Husserl calls “noema” just is some intentional object. Thus any noema of perception just is the... more
What are the proper objects of perception? Two famous responses to this question hold that they are either the images of extramental objects, that is, the way in which they appear to us (representationalism), or they are the objects... more
The purpose of this paper is to contextualize Bergson's panpsychist thought into the panpsychism debate that is being revived in contemporary analytic metaphysics, thus giving it an accurate characterization and clarifying Bergson's place... more
Philosophical Review, Vol. 126, No. 3, 2017
Epistemic Indirect Realism (EIR) is the position that justification for contingent propositions about the extra-mental world requires an inference based on a subjective, experiential mental state. One objection against EIR is that it runs... more
Michael Bergmann (2006) has argued that an internalistic view of justification faces a dilemma. Assuming as internalism does that to have a justified belief, subjects must be aware of the justifiers of the belief and of their relevance to... more
The debate in the philosophy of perception between direct realists and representationalists should influence the debate in epistemology between internalists and externalists about justification. If direct realists are correct, there are... more
Direct realists about episodic memory claim that a rememberer has direct contact with a past event. But how is it possible to be acquainted with an event that ceased to exist? That's the so-called cotemporality problem. The standard... more
This paper aims to challenge the idea claimed by Putnam in his Dewey Lectures that internal realism presupposed sense data theory so that it would have been unable to account for the fundamental intuition of common sense realism that... more
This paper argues that there is a conflict between two theses held by John McDowell, namely i) the claim that we are under a standing obligation to revise our beliefs if reflection demands it; and ii) the view that veridical experience is... more
The enactivist tradition, out of which neurophenomenology arose, rejects various internalisms – including the representationalist and information-processing metaphors – but remains wedded to one further internalism:the claim that the... more
Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) causes behavioral and emotional problems. The emotions associated with the disorder, research has shown, literally change and individual’s perception. Those who study the effects of emotion on... more
Most inferentialists hope to bypass givenness by tracking the conditionals claimants are implicitly committed to. I argue that this approach is underdetermined because one can always construct parallel trees of conditionals. I illustrate... more
In this paper I show that, on Husserl's phenomenology of perception, the consciousness of any perceiving subject can take up space. What Husserl calls "noema" just is some intentional object. Thus any noema of perception just is the... more
This paper postulates and explores an epistemic state which is inherent to all phenomenal experiences: Direct acquaintance with possibilities. Relying on a representationalist framework and a common-factor theory of perception and... more
In his well-known Mind and World and in line with Wilfrid Sellars’ (1991) or “that great foe of ‘immediacy’” (ibid., 127) Hegel, McDowell claims that “when Evans argues that judgments of experience are based on non-conceptual content, he... more
This is a selection from my book, The Roots of Representationism: An Introduction to Everett Hall. It is an attempt to put naïve realism back where it belongs--with intentionalism/representationism.
In this paper, I respond to Millar’s recent criticism of naïve realism. Millar provides several arguments for the thesis that there are powerful phenomenological grounds for preferring the content view (the view that to perceive is to... more
Both traditional and naturalistic epistemologists have long assumed that the examination of human psychology has no relevance to the goal of traditional epistemology, that of providing first-person guidance in determining the truth.... more