In 1894 Japan went to war with Russia over the latter’s expansion into East Asia. However, in February 1904 Japan attacked Russian forces at Port Arthur and Inchon. Japan at that time was an ally of Britain, and the US was willing...
moreIn 1894 Japan went to war with Russia over the latter’s expansion into East Asia. However, in February 1904 Japan attacked Russian forces at Port Arthur and Inchon. Japan at that time was an ally of Britain, and the US was willing to allow Japan to have control over Korea in exchange for Japan acknowledging US control over the Philippines. In 1905 Japan established a protectorate over Korea, and in 1910 Japan annexed Korea.
In August 1945 the USSR declared war on Japan and entered the northeastern section of Korea that borders on the Soviet Union. US troops didn’t arrive in Korea until September 8th. Two young State Department officers were assigned to define the American zone of occupation. They decided that an “administrative” line be established along 38th parallel. Korean Communists immediately began forming so-called People’s Committees friendly to the Soviet Union in preparation for Korean independence.
In December 1945 the foreign ministers of the United States, the United Kingdom, and the Soviet Union met in Moscow to discuss post-war issues in Europe and the Far East. It was agreed that the U.S. and Soviet military commands in Korea would establish a Joint Commission to make recommendations for a single, free government in Korea. The Americans favored a united Korean government under Syngman Rhee. Rhee opposed the U.S.-Soviet Cooperation Committee that was created and refused to negotiate with the Communists. In September the US decided to refer the matter to the UN General Assembly. In November the UN General Assembly established a UN Temporary Commission on Korea to oversee elections scheduled for May 1948. The Communists did not participate in the election, newly elected National Assembly elected Rhee as president in July, 1948. In February 1946 a provisional government named the Provisional People’s Committee was formed under Kim Il-sung.
On New Year’s Day 1949 Moscow announced that it would withdrew all Soviet troops from North Korea, and in June the last American troops left Pusan. In a speech on January 1950 at the National Press Club, Secretary of State Dean Acheson implied that both South Korea and Taiwan were outside the American “defensive perimeter.” In April Kim Il-sung visited Stalin in Moscow and asked his support for a forcible reunification of Korea. Stalin gave his support, but warned that North Korea should not expect Soviet military support for the invasion. In June the North Koreans crossed the 38th parallel into South Korea. Truman then ordered American air and naval forces to support South Korea.
By the end of June the North Koreans had taken control of the South Korean capital of Seoul. In an emergency meeting the Security Council passed a resolution calling for an immediate cessation of hostilities. The Soviet Union was boycotting the Security Council, because earlier in the year the Security Council had refused to replace Nationalist China with the Communist China in the United Nations. Truman appointed the hero of the War in the Pacific and former military governor of Japan, Douglas MacArthur as Commander of the United Nations Forces. American ground troops were quickly redeployed from Japan to South Korea to assist the Army of the Republic of Korea resist the North Korean People’s Army. But outnumbered three to one, they were forced to retreat to the port of Pusan. MacArthur came up with a plan to launch an amphibious assault on the rear of North Korean forces at the port of Inchon on the western coast of the Korean peninsula.
The Communist Chinese Foreign Minister Chou En-lai broadcast a warning that Peking would not tolerate a crossing of the 38th parallel. In early October the Eighth Army crossed the 38th parallel near Kaeson. But a South Korean force approaching the Yalu River was almost wiped out by Chinese troops. MacArthur then requested permission under the international law rule of “hot pursuit” to chase attacking aircraft for three minutes across the Manchurian border. MacArthur also requested additional forces, including Chinese Nationalists from Formosa, a naval blockade of China, and permission to bomb the Chinese mainland. Truman ordered all commands and embassies abroad not to make any speeches or issue press releases until they were cleared by the departments of State or Defense.
In March MacArthur decided to defy the President’s gag order by calling a press conference in which he predicted if he did not receive major additions to his army, there would be a military stalemate followed by a “savage slaughter” by the enemy. This was interpreted as an attempt to torpedo a diplomatic initiative made by the United States to negotiate a truce of which he had been privately informed. After a series of meetings with his advisors and the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Truman decided to relieve MacArthur of his command.
The reaction to the dismissal of MacArthur was intense. Truman’s popularity was at an all-time low, and he decided not to run for re-election in the 1952 Presidential election. The Republican nominated former general Dwight David Eisenhower, and the Democrats Adelai Stevenson. Eisenhower chose as his running mate was Richard Nixon. In a speech on October 24, 1952, Eisenhower promised to end the war, and go to Korea if he were elected. After winning the election in November, but before his inauguration as President in January, Eisenhower went to Korea in December 1952. Two weeks after his inauguration, Eisenhower in February 1953 announced that he was withdrawing the Seventh Fleet from protecting China from a possible invasion from Taiwan. Then in March Josef Stalin died after a brief illness. He was replaced by a troika. On 15 March the Kremlin moved dramatically away from the style of Soviet foreign policy of Stalin’s last years. Soon after, the Chinese Foreign Minister Chou En-lai sent a cablegram proposing the resumption of negotiations at Panmunjom.
It is informative to contrast the outcome of the Vietnam Conflict, after which the United States permitted the country to be reunited under the Communist regime in the North, to the outcome of the Korean Police Action, in which the country remained divided between the Communist North and the non-Communist South. With assistance from the Soviet Union, China tested its first nuclear weapon in 1964, and its first hydrogen bomb in 1967. In 1964 North Korea asked the Soviet Union for assistance in its nuclear program, but the Soviet Union refused. Instead, Kim Il-sung approached Pakistan for help. Pakistan began its nuclear program in response to India’s nuclear program. India tested its first nuclear device in 1974, using a reactor it obtained from Canada under the so-called “Atoms for Peace” program of the Eisenhower administration. It is alleged that Pakistan obtained technical advice from China. Kim Il-sung died in 1994, and he was succeeded by his son Kim Jong-Il, who is more autocratic and erratic than his father. In May 1998 North Korea tested five nuclear devices. Thus, one of the legacies of the Cold War was the proliferation of nuclear weapons.
In conclusion, the Korean police action demonstrates the transition from an American foreign policy based on the principle of self-determination under Franklin Delano Roosevelt to the anti-Communist ideology of the Cold War under Harry Truman. This was done under pressure of lobbyists and politicians who accused those who disagreed with them of treason. For the next 40 years (from 1950 to 1990) United States foreign policy under both Republican and Democratic administrations has been premised on the containment of the spread of Communism, not only in Asia, but Europe, Africa, and South America. This fight against an ideology and the support for those regimes, however, corrupt or dictatorial, that oppose Communism has pre-empted one of the principles on which this nation was founded—that is, self-determination. It is sad that rather from learning from this history, our foreign policy is again putting a fight against the ideology of Islamism before the underlying reasons why certain people are attracted to radicalism, namely, that they have not been allowed to change a status quo under which they have been divided and forced to live in countries not of their own making.