qrrqFqt fu qtfr 6qq-s: {sx$qt, wr{rlT s frqrHFrf rtgqf "ffbQea il:q-wEw ,{T.l -Fozs-{ "[ts?n< +.rcq wFT]B )T<-$'f{ (1846-1917) "I{ s$ffi "fRftE {N T'{ r fta"|+r rcr dm aeq'tqlM sr-Tcq{ r til-< <lal, ,islr{"tq-f,$l< ?li \3 "lkl fr-R B*trsq,, mtrR Q qcte FffiEt qf{|{ qqxEEF ,ga qq<w #e q<-{sf< frrrT{ r <Rrx<b"fqmx {.lfr< a"Rfa'f b ftrs \ir< srfr qtdl Q (rsae) GfrrEEE q{sM frrfirflE{ cercst qtf, (1823-1888) <ii{-qflA rca {t$} € 1qa31 &E >p-d= eryt€< 3q ifta "f++fi<.i-<tfr Tgr ?T< q'F!"D='€ 33 qft3ra ;n'1 qC{ i "ip_q q<K 'qtqa $sTT qt:fl '$s I firbx aGcw ffi fr-z=tr*r, torflxtc-n s-+-?-cat okEfr "nrb lt €w, EftE €q{, frfrs &tq rfrs <"+qe firq<&fu <GxtqrlTReo 4fur at rnmqi) uq+ fro, ft.v qfi efiE n r fr-e tsi<slg <-rc-T<l urfiIxrrc{< qrx +t< ec${ qa3, qr{TqR-<-{ tqsITqK EEI e||&6, ft-ryIil5mF qcm e"l, E?F €C\e? {tul <t&s, {lll Eflfiis, ffiq <ftsi xfu s{{q-Exx. qtfrsF {.l $lqts rcE ql.lq eci, slETCs {ffi \3(qN6t ss-!D-q q-f,{T< 6d?r+r}= orv.roq I r41 {iF <E-ftss i<Grr< r (krx mn 1e73 t. ses-u Equ^i effisctEIT cq-<5-it eo<.r< ffi m<[ rIfT, q]-n \srfls[ct erflt 9|I{ qun-< eiFH6< sd-cg< <D;rt qr{E-E-{ qa' q1u1g {'1, ft<q r ft-e frcq< TlqE ql? frE fttr al.lqeq fti<ligmrcq *, q-'{{wd <fi"[<tqE:TE-q ql<-.4sF IUs fra-{ qEsx-{TR d mtr<< s'ett <G(q{: q1-{ q("t EIFl.e- dl wrlp{ <mt{}<ir-T{ <tqy4 I frgmarr, q-sFfs-{, nq4rflq{ ru6ner<-t qV& q-$6< ,Ic<f <tq-{'F ffi{rs-K-cq q-<q.f q{ K<rffis Tr€(I.t1.{ <r.{Iteft<iH r s €q qNtffi-f uzr< <-r 16d; srqT{ 'r{ qlxtn={ {q.e, fr.e 'LaTr< <]sFIr{ {effi"s &R &cE{ \iR< frRE <rryi "I{B1I: egfrm 6$cdk{, ft-E & m egE6aql 1reEft stEEt src"r Errat d1t srq<tfr TF" daq $.i{B-{ vm<rFns I qfr q*/q'ffitm<d,ci.rt +o >l $6{fiiB <lqqti 8lq ;TE <fr$ $rq F:' ;,Rr iow< F"n q&& sffi, fs-q sRlt.5 ql qzq sfr (BEol' ",ffi iliq I s-.lq' lRiTtR Er1-cq Rr, at q'lR qfr<E I (&) (< orrtejft "to,e "n,c$< s-fl R?,s efir< TsGflEr Tfiil"ll<llT csfcil g s.fird6{s 6r,.{<, 1 1fi4 qeq, -\fiF qs 1813T, \q'srTqK Rqi'ffi'lc{'{ EE iB2cNt tsry,]u<, ffi<-cq ?t€c{]-€ 1w"E4 RT+zEffi<Qni 5Eqq 6t[A< E${c{ftfrs q{ -d$-qE r F<-({q, 'qru'rstsifts s{l< fr-tTl-{i r rfiqlr-s &fi qr{r<q *ftq1afffisj R e .t*r 6qq-,{K srsr+:* qrx o=r* cflE <slm Rq r qdl,rdl' :ifr&', 6{{4, -ffi4 (<1 c{t'I) 6{HRF-a ry,a-x ftfi qT{ e196541 q?FF qq?Fe$-<' {cq, <r1ff3[ w-q usls azqs \ilg ffi1 lk{ r s? R{q cq.q qqE rrcs's, fr.qri!1oi.cs'< mclB qqrq frH | $Frslgl f,+{FrryHT-q< a&&r< (1s57) I {Esrsl cqtrE B'Ectlt"liq m.ir s Rqfir'lor{ \5r{ lcs {g_ Rr"FI qesffi qf<ts 1l€rqEl <-{( Ftsl frsrQ;{ .{IEF koilF4lut3 $E-<lslfrqfqdqT-'s< etl{, 1860*4T q-arsr T7:ss.lqz<-< fufi Wx q-l6 sfiat $-c<d., xfr.s lreZnf6' [aiC{ {F I fr'afi {l{, te70-'a qr$e e w(at "ttss frR erf<'6 iwcsl l<p fr.e. urr< (rTlg1frs) kEjftrirlq{-q< <Isril, ft'orcur "i-fu( ffi eto cl<rqil qlffi-< 'ettr< e+< c+lqa611 fr.g <en-x g-.r+,Qcar< s?ft;-sr< s<fe &-R{ ffiTro <r+r< frQx +re T?cFf1". <r7r4r<11t:< ft.71<arx. ('1te' ;{) Fi3Qf, 1846-€ I €< dln @' "nqf fulrE et-Tfg.-"T' +4'4<( *rcrl , =iqB frq ffio, :{i fic.$< qrsm ?<fr&, laF frcs <Isql l?G& g< dt6 <q{ ui*K qn fu | oei]E)rs, ADVANTAGES, AND PLEAiLIREi aF sctENCE i -{rcq ffi{el qs5{T{r< ( 1 851 I El{\3 4F <q< r 4(Ke qsq f;.fi RqrFryt5.l(ffi 6<lr<il?T ) s.l € tf&-r fiT{t "lqfeftqfi, w6gf !qs1-{E1t-q-{ I1T <lsql orro3 fiscq qra-+ Rtrq <fi{r{ q-6 r frqiFTtu6 s etqm'?&-{cq qs-{ q6' qle I TlecTRa tircr's cur* $ €<fi T{ <lsql ffi.Rl;r <sEIvl$m &B qa oKE{ I q {eq\g lir< ilq R rfttrq fum 36fo+a <lnr{ qI t qq36q {<-r'r{ rt-c<'{T s frqFI qig'.t cfu ffia {c =1a6 qt"t& EuERGiq <?-q-d1q I sfl lsrflqL-;K Em.c*kdr c:fi Tlecflar{-{ qq-Cds' a1al x-"rrdaa, df< e€. csffr{ rqef+cq-{ qt-Cq :trqffi qlfi={< @| @q-$E ls.rr< TfE-st s 'Illre{lt8-sl qS.I'-*U ene$r+gt c{slm-s 13crfiE{ <rqn"flsm-R6s "f64 qrqtFs <svl$ \3 <t(sl qcq qsTt Tk{K cEB Fffi (rFrc<q I urffi zozc s{{ w-qB e{rR T{crillqq ffi.r*-ti< EIR} sTE{lq-{ sft- I (r_s. 10,i989 }r.."dn-e wqfrE}_s--cqeft. S{8. rynr ,J. 216) qt{ft_ !$fr <,cil $F TtrIcs E{R r 1rczrpQ fr-e serq Eq"flb e ( mrE, frfts.*{i< qxeft)Jq]sstx GI1IK 65A o;<Er*<, er<?*fi]fri zrk:,sTRo -iq<furq f'ofr eeriknq r cs FmT l&a <le €i.$-T[T oaifi-T- s(t GliJ, kTi5j, ,3.i, Elrt ff{fic{fco-s f;p"tt qa fr I .g, firc1 .qt,T61 ffi s-+rg,.< r?E .q.iR Rq;Fflrlt-f,{ q!-+F q'S{}-S S3-$'1T re 'ii-q.cqq ql? {E4'leiTlir[-{ 'qf6.f <iw'-l', 'qfi q.}o11,?g;j]fr <5a1<G-atrd. I sK '"jfQft Epiai'-Ksqil <-{ffi&ril|fluf< s qq.r-{ETl{ mb?+s ."tfB& <isaTt, FHq fr r ,qr*r xr'rsr "r,*'rs-{ CIcq 6q qffi, fr"i ,r'(s-{ fh=sJx strq-s "nh+rt's {{ lqm dm< rr?fl 'r-srp ,r<rcT ir r -\5is €Tfr S.r{+ q-<tQ srr ssc-T (qe-s) "1q-{ <I-<E1Rrfttq m& qT$s pi<"{ rT rqlri?.6T frqrg1E6n glfs c*. ffi qs31$r,tt"3-{ cq-e"tB kd mE T$rEEcq-{ ,icB kr 4.t fi d eqr frm< ffiqre frkTfrjeg6q ffi-s5;1q .<riq sft.l-< qaN r ffi'3'"64 (r-i. Tcfiaf 11, 1989, <iierfficm oerx aE ,cJB qre, <.m fi{.} {8, 1. ttz)t q<EesB -"8 st<m ftnRcan [fl"ifE eE?K I er$ {isl ftqi rtd-{ ma*{rqf q$, fifr*qGTr{ e-yfrx era6 kArE ffis<:- <tsqi fl7frrn qq IE, qam c{-\elr< a1stflK $D qcfrJs s fiTcs <IoJlT slrl $-c_q ox_c:i{ c{q€F4 \e 63cl "-{fls *"tro qnRs sr{ <IBEI Tqf{ {l6fqqrs {E o-<f r e+E qe, q"f<E Eq, ftu ft frnimarzr-< fiqru-s{rr e$ctt (;<u-q.H(qE 1, 1972, r Vfisi, 1. qtt) R'fi.,u*{,irlr5.fs <isEt-{ ffiEq <'u{K<qrq firgffi 6q{-{ "[f6sr stlc-fuffi< crs ffitr€efr-s fr-q,Tc srukqry, dF qr-cer c+b $HG aft-T{ fr r'sl< "iVF {h"-T F"itra aeln cflToo {@, pi"ltrq .,t$E qqfum qs-f\s crR q(q--.qT{ x&Tw.J frr-t1:nEn<A qI(51Ef{ f+t E-<-re I <rw$E{ g ftkxqril<rr qrs <s {lBqf sFr{, frrR p[3 qqe "flf.Eq R ai;E, 6.1-6qftq *r{n qq-q qs r 6 1 ?&{!-fi \iRq-{ EFars Enr< oBr \qlir$? sci(q{, .!?F\e G{t{E-ir +r<-+rfr-e cq EE {fu-{ s{t €4r< <-fl qcfl cr 1fr a@ q".tefrT | $[.1 Elrt.r { <rei flqE? fuSruls qG&-*..t, geN ,G- * +'l-$ls Es ft-e @Gr-{ <Fqrc-< trqst q< tlc-qq s qqf_qE-{ Eq< crer{ Rs{E "{ril"Ifrfrllam; m'n* s&rts qqq-q.4Eim <il{;g s{t61 ffii olqjK r afr e*/arflrtE'{cs.xt ao ."1 qE:GrFs rFpt$fr$, ffiql ,s<( rr-TE "rsgfr'fr"{5" efr$ frrnslqr{ <T(Et qixl c{l-si{'l{ {frixe"fq, (&) sr"-{R.Fq, fre:1nrs EeITI-S <mm figg qrr-+rx 'M s "tfr"1fst'< ftrT EEir +e-* froc- rn-<q R TSC{qT{< 6m \SST-f:$6-{ g,E4B--fu'l(r< :rrFm Ool S&Q--q(H,T '"fqr3fri Tr-<l r +t h, ,D 1 l i { .qrry 1*f"i$1, fius E-K -*df< &f.gqlfrs tftg == E{r ri I