i149
Abstracts
Study funding/competing interest(s): This trial is supported by a grant of the
Netherlands Organisation for Health Research and Development (ZonMw Clinical fellow grant 90700154).
Trial registration number: ISRCTN 48210491
Trial registration number: Not Applicable
P-076 Sucrose needs not to be added in vitrification solution for freezing
the artificial shrunken mouse blastocysts
J.K. Joo1, J.E. Jeung1, K.R. Go2, and K.S. Lee1
1
Pusan National University Hospital, OB/GY, Busan, Korea South, 2Pusan
National University Hospital, infertility clinic, Busan, Korea South
Embryology
ACCU-VIT: a new strategy for managing poor responders
G. Gandhi1, G. Allahbadia2, S. Kagalwala1, A. Allahbadia2, S. Ramesh2, K. Patel2,
R. Hinduja2, V. Chipkar1, M. Madne1, and R. Ramani1
Rotunda - Centre for Human Reproduction, Assisted Reproduction Laboratory,
Mumbai, India, 2Rotunda - Centre for Human Reproduction, Assisted
Reproduction, Mumbai, India
1
Study question: To evaluate the efficacy of serial minimal stimulation IVF cycles
with vitrification of embryos for treatment of poor responders as compared to conventional IVF protocols.
Summary answer: Accumulating vitrified embryos in serial minimal stimulation
cycles (ACCU-VIT) followed by a frozen embryo transfer is a better treatment
option for poor ovarian responders as compared to conventional IVF.
What is known already: Previous trials have shown that neither conventional
IVF nor natural cycle IVF is an effective treatment option for poor ovarian responders. However, none of the trials have examined the efficacy of accumulating
embryos with serial minimal stimulation cycles and vitrifying the resulting
embryos. Women with poor ovarian reserves, who commonly do not respond to
conventional stimulation protocols, are left with few options when planning a
family.
Study design, size, duration: This is a retrospective data analysis of poor responders from February 2011 to March 2012. A total of 140 patients were included in
the study. 55 patients were offered minimal stimulation cycles with vitrification
and embryo banking (ACCU - VIT Group) and 85 patients underwent conventional controlled ovarian stimulation for IVF.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: The inclusion criteria for ACCU-VIT
group were patients with at least one previous conventional IVF cycle with poor
response (defined as ≤ 4 MII oocytes). Embryos were vitrified using Cryotec Vitrfication protocol on Day 3. Once six embryos were banked with us, a frozen
embryo transfer was planned. A maximum of 3 embryos were transferred. Main
outcome measure was the clinical pregnancy rate defined as positive fetal heartbeat
at 12 weeks of pregnancy.
Main results and the role of chance: The mean age was 38.5 years in the
ACCU-VIT group and 35.7 years in the conventional IVF group. In the
ACC-VIT group, each patient underwent an average of 2.7 cycles of embryo accumulation before planning a frozen embryo transfer. An average of 6.2
embryos were vitrified for each patient. The cycle cancellation rate was 16.6%
in the ACCU-VIT group and was significantly higher in the conventional IVF
group (22.2%). The clinical pregnancy rate was higher in the ACCU-VIT group
(28.5%) than the conventional IVF group (18.7%). The cumulative pregnancy
rate was statistically higher in the ACCU – VIT group (41.5%) than the conventional IVF group (22.3%).
Limitations, reason for caution: A limitation of our analysis is a small sample
size. However, we are very encouraged by the better results observed in the
ACCU-VIT group and are continuing to apply this approach to more patients.
Wider implications of the findings: ACCU-VIT using minimal stimulation and
reliable vitrification methods is a successful approach to treat poor responders creating a situation similar to normal responders. This approach allows the poor responder women to have consecutive cycles of embryo accumulation before the
follicular reserve is depleted. It will maximize the ovaries’ already limited life
span, allowing patients the opportunity to store embryos while oocyte production
is still active.
Study funding/competing interest(s): No funding was used. There are no competing interests to declare.
P-077 ATP contents in immature oocytes obtained from graafian follicles
decreased compared with those from small follicles
H. Goto1, S. Hashimoto1, A. Amo1, T. Yamochi1, H. Iwata 2, and Y. Morimoto3
IVF Namba Clinic, Reserch division, Osaka, Japan, 2Tokyo University of
Agriculture, Department of Animal Science, Atsugi, Japan, 3IVF Namba Clinic,
Medical office, Osaka, Japan
1
Study question: To assess the relationships among ATP contents in oocytes,
ovarian stimulation procedures, donor age, oocyte cell cycle, and oocyte diameter,
we measured ATP contents in immature oocytes obtained from graafian and small
follicles.
Summary answer: ATP contents in immature oocytes obtained from small follicles (diameter: approx. 10-mm) followed by maturation culture was significantly
higher than that in immature oocytes obtained from graafian follicles after ovarian
stimulation and natural cycles (diameter: approx. 19-mm).
What is known already: ATP contents in oocytes have been suggested to be a
marker of oocyte quality including maturity and developmental competence.
On the other hand, it has been also reported that oocytes containing extremely
high ATP content had low developmental competence.
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
P-075
Study question: Does sucrose need to be added in vitrification solution for freezing the artificial shrunke mouse blastocysts?
Summary answer: Sucrose needs not to be added in vitrification solution for
freezing the artificial shrunken mouse blastocysts.
What is known already: Sucrose included in freezing medium causes embryos to
shrink by losing intracellular water, so that intracellular ice formation is reduced
and embryos can be frozen rapidly. Blastocyst consists of trophoblast and inner
cell mass. It may be considered that the artificial shrunken blastocyst is not
embryo but tightly packed somatic cells. Sucrose is not added to somatic cell freezing medium.
Study design, size, duration: Mouse morulae were collected from superovulated,
mated mice(C57BL/CBA), cultured in G2.2 to develop into expanded blastocysts.
Vitrification and thawing were prepared. Two vitrification solutions with and
without sucrose were prepared. Control(G25E25) and treatment(G25E25S0.5)
were composed of 25%glycerol + 25%ethyleneglycol and 25%glycerol +
25%ethyleneglycero +0.5 mol/l sucrose, respectively.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Blastocoel fluid was aspirated in the
expanded mouse blastocysts and shrunken blastocysts were equilibrated in
EBS1, EBS2. After loading capped pulled-straw blastocysts were vitrified or rehydrated. Assisted hatching was performed using assisted hatching pipette after
thawing procedure or rehydration. Rates of re-expanding and hatching were examined after culture for 6h.
Main results and the role of chance: Re-expanding rate of mouse blastocyst
exposed to VS(without and with 0.5 mol sucrose) were not different in
G25E25(98%) and G25E25S0.5(92%) (P . 0.05) and hatching rate was higher
in G25E25(95%) than in G25E25S0.5(88%) but did not differ in two treatments
(P . 0.05). Re-expanding rate of mouse blastocyst vitrified in G25E25 and
G25E25S0.5 was 95% and 90%, respectively (P . 0.05), and hatching rate was
higher in G25E25(90%) than in G25E25S0.5(76%) (P . 0.05).
Limitations, reason for caution: This study was done with mouse blastocysts.
So, we are not sure about the effect in human blastocyst. Before applying this
method to human blastocyst, we have to confirm the negative effect of sucrose-free
vitrification solution to human blastocyst.
Wider implications of the findings: It can be applied to human embryo freezing
procedure. This technique make freezing process easy, convenient, so we can
reduce laboratory mistakes in freezing precess.
Study funding/competing interest(s): None
Trial registration number: None
i150
P-078
Is ICSI yielding better clinical outcome compared to IVF in poor
responders with normal sperm analysis?
M. Koifman, S. Lahav-Baratz, E. Blais, Z. Megnazi-Wiener, D. Ishai,
R. Auslender, and M. Dirnfeld
Carmel Medical Center, Gyn/Obs IVF unit, Haifa, Israel
Study question: To compare the effect of insemination using standard In vitro fertilization (IVF) Vs Intra Cytoplasmic Sperm Injection (ICSI) on clinical pregnancy and delivery rates in poor responders with 4 or less available oocytes and
a normal sperm count.
Summary answer: Clinical pregnancy and delivery rates were higher but not statistically significant in IVF Vs ICSI in poor responders with normospermia.
Significantly lower fertilization rates and more "NO embryo transfer " events
occurred with ICSI Vs IVF.
In poor responders with normal sperm the use of ICSI was not beneficial.
What is known already: The introduction of ICSI has led to dramatic improvement in pregnancy rates in severe male factor and cases with failed fertilization. In
view of high pregnancy rates and take home baby rates and reports on the relative
safety of the ICSI technique, centers have considered using ICSI for other indications than Male factor.
With only few available oocytes retrieved, embryologists and clinicians face a
real dilemma regarding the choice of the insemination technique.
Study design, size, duration: The study reviewed 195 treatment cycles of known
poor responders, with 4 or less retrieved oocytes.
Only cases with normal sperm count were included.
The study group included 148 cycles in which standard IVF was used and 47
cycles with ICSI.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: The parameters studied were age,
number of retrieved oocytes, basal day 3-5 serum FSH, number of MII oocytes,
fertilization rates, cleavage rate, number of embryos transferred, the percentage
of cycles with embryo transfer, clinical pregnancy and delivery rates, analyzed
in the group of IVF and ICSI cycles.
Main results and the role of chance: There was no difference between the groups
of IVF and ICSI cycles in the parameters of age, number of oocytes retrieved, FSH,
number of MII oocytes per cycle and cleavage rates.
A significantly higher fertilization rate was observed in the IVF group as compared with ICSI group (81.51% and 67.73% respectively, p ¼ 0.004).
The mean number of transferred embryos after IVF was 1.54 + 0.83 Vs 1.21 +
1.10 with ICSI (p ¼ 0.019). A "No embryo transfer" event was observed in 32%
of the ICSI group Vs 11.50% in the IVF group (p ¼ 0.004).
Clinical pregnancy rates and delivery rates were higher but not statistically significant in IVF Vs ICSI (24.2% Vs 15.6%, 8.1% Vs 6.4% respectively).
Limitations, reason for caution: This study is retrospective. As all cases
included were treatments with normal sperm count, the decision to choose the
use of IVF or ICSI was based on patients’ and clinicians’ request and therefore
the IVF group was larger as compared to the ICSI group.
Wider implications of the findings: In view of the above results and recent
reports on increased malformation rates in ICSI, it is reasonably to advise that
in the presence of normal sperm counts, the technique of choice for insemination
in poor responders should be IVF rather than ICSI.
Study funding/competing interest(s): The researchers declare that this study is
free of any financial support or other interests.
Trial registration number: N/A
P-079 A modified cryotop vitrification protocol with polimer cryoprotectant agent ficoll in the cryopreservation of human oocytes
V. Zaletova1, E. Zakharova 2, I. Krivokharchenko 2, and S. Zaletov1
1
MAMA Fertility Center, Medical Department, Moscow, Russia C.I.S, 2MAMA
Fertility Center, Embryology and Genetic Laboratory, Moscow, Russia C.I.S
Study question: We examined a modified cryotop vitrification protocol in the
cryopreservation of human oocytes. Suggested modification had an additional
polimer cryoprotectant agent ficoll in vitrification medium with standard cryoprotectants compound.
Summary answer: Applying of modified cryotop vitrification protocol with
ficoll enables a high survival rate of thawed oocytes, a high rate of blastocyst formation and pregnancy rate.
What is known already: Until now all standard human oocytes vitrification protocols used two- and tree-component vitrification mediums with different sets of
cryoprotectants, excluding polimers. Ficoll is a neutral, highly branched, highmass, hydrophilic polysaccharide. Cryoprotectant effect of ficoll is that this
polimer increases viscocity of vitrification medium, and therefore hinders formation of crystals. A number of published articles on cryopreservation of animals
oocytes demonstrated efficiency of protocols with polimer cryoprotectants, including ficoll.
Study design, size, duration: 388 oocytes were obtaned from 54 anonymous
donors and vitrified using modified cryotop vitrification protocol with ficoll. Vitrified oocytes were stored in Cryobank for 1 to 6 months. Thawed oocytes of good
quality were donated for IVF treatment, in 30 cases. Then oocytes were fertilized
by husband’s sperm. Embryos were transferred on Day 5 after fertilization (blastocyst stage, 1-2 embryos), in 28 cycles.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: During ccryopreservation oocytes
were successively exposed to three vitrification mediums with increased concentrations of ethylen glycol (3,75 - 15%); DMSO (3,75 - 15%); ficoll (2,5 - 10%);
sucrose (0,125 - 0,5 M) at 370 C. Oocyte exposure time to each solution varied
from 1 to 6 min. Oocytes were vitrified by cryotop method. Thawing oocytes
were successively exposed to four sucrose solutions with decreased concentration
(1M - 0,125 M). Then oocytes were fertilized 3 hours after thawing by ICSI
method.
Main results and the role of chance: In 30 IVF cycles 263 donor’s oocytes
were thawed. After thawing 19 out of 263 oocytes degenerated (7,2% – 19/
263), 244 oocytes showed no signes of degeneration (92,8% – 244/263).
Normal fertilization occured in 207 oocytes (84,8% – 207/224), all zygotes
started to cleave at 48 hours after fertilization. By Day 5 of their culture, we
had 98 embryos of good quality (47,3% - 98/207). Embryos were transferred
into the uterus in 28 IVF cycles. 10 out of 28 patients had a positive beta-hCG
blood test. All 10 pregnancies were clinically recognized (35,7% for an
embryo transfer - 10/28), 8 out of which resulted in the birth of healthy children an one - of healthy twins.
Limitations, reason for caution: Four-component vitrification medium containing ficoll was used only for human oocytes vitrification and not for cryopresevation of embryos/sperm.
Wider implications of the findings: Applying modified cryotop vitrification
protocol with ficoll resulted in laboratory and clinical data comparable to those
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
Study design, size, duration: This was an experimental study using 97 immature
oocytes obtained from graafian follicles (diameter: approx. 19-mm) after ovarian
stimulation or natural cycles and 79 immature oocytes obtained from small follicles (diameter: approx. 10-mm) followed by maturation culture between April
2012 and October 2012. The local IRB approved this study.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Donated oocytes were used after
informed consent. ATP contents in oocytes were measured individually after
the measurement of their diameter and the removal of their cumulus cells. The
ATP assay was performed individually based on the luminescence reaction. Luminescence was measured using a luminometer. Data were compared using student
t-test.
Main results and the role of chance: There were no differences in the ATP contents between GV (6.7 pM, n: 110) and MI stage oocytes (6.2 pM, n: 66), and
between stimulation (5.0 pM, n: 66) and natural cycles (4.4 pM, n: 32). Moreover,
there were no relationships between the ATP contents and oocyte diameter (diameter: 107.5-135.0 mm, 120.5 mm, n: 147, r2 ¼ 0.01, P ¼ 0.2), and between the
ATP contents and donor age (age: 25-45 years old, n: 176, r2 ¼ 0.02, P ¼
0.06). However, the ATP content in oocytes obtained from small follicles (8.6
pM, n: 79) was significantly higher (P , 0.05) than that in oocytes obtained
from graafian follicles (4.8 pM, n: 97).
Limitations, reason for caution: Further studies are required to clarify the link
between a decrease of ATP contents in immature oocytes obtained from large follicles compared with oocytes obtained from small follicles.
Wider implications of the findings: This study provided new insights on the
implications of a decrease of ATP contents during follicle growth.
Study funding/competing interest(s): Part of this work was supported by a grant
from the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JPS-RFTF 23580397 to
S.H.). No other competing interests are declared.
Trial registration number: None.
Abstracts
Abstracts
published in regard to early known vitrification protocols. We demonstrated its
stable efficiency, which enables us to create and successfully use Cryobank of
donor’s oocytes.
Study funding/competing interest(s): None.
Trial registration number: None.
P-080
Cryopreservation of cleavage stage embryo or blastocyst: which
option is better
L. Zhu, Y. Li, H. Zhang, J. Ai, and L. Jin
Tongji Hospital Affiliated to Tongji Medical College, Huazhong University of
Science and technology, Wuhan, China
P-081
Quantitative analysis of operator-dependent variability in blastocyst vitrification with a High Security Vessel (HSV) vitrification system
X. Zhang, N. Rajan, A. Kovacs, C. Foley, J. Flanagan, J. O’Callaghan,
J. Waterstone, and T. Dineen
Cork Fertility Centre, Embryology, Cork, Ireland
Study question: This study was performed as part of process validation when
embryo vitrification was introduced at the fertility center. The purpose of this
study was to quantify variability in the performance of blastocyst vitrification
with a closed HSV system by a number of operators with a wide-spectrum of experience.
Summary answer: Survival rates after blastocyst vitrification were high and did
not vary significantly between operators both with and without previous embryo
vitrification experience. Quantitative analysis of operator-dependent variability
provides a practical approach for training when implementing a successful vitrification program.
What is known already: A successful outcome in vitrification is highly operator
dependent, and a quite different skill set is necessary compared to that required for
slow rate freezing. The embryologist needs to be aware of several critical procedural details that can impact negatively on results. Skill variations for all operators
must be monitored and compared in order to achieve consistent and predictable
results.
Study design, size, duration: 347 Blastocysts (day5/6) derived from IVF treatment were vitrified and 130 were warmed between Dec 2010 and Dec 2012. Six
embryologists, with experiences of vitrification ranging from 0 to 5 years, all
underwent vitrification training, practicing with silicone beads and mock procedures before participating in the study.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Blastocyst survival rates post
warming were used to compare for different operators. The performance of vitrification was also quantified by recording a number of key parameters: loading
time, loading volume, warming speed, and speed of handling the HSV straws.
Main results and the role of chance: Operators with less experience showed
higher coefficients of variation (CVs) in comparison with experienced operators
with regard to loading volume (28.5% vs. 18.1%) and loading time (10.4% vs.
6.7%), but not warming speed (13.7% vs. 12.8%) nor straw handling (13.4%
vs. 13.1%). However, all operator-dependent parameters remained within protocol limits, even though they varied among individuals. 130 vitrified blastocysts
were warmed. The overall survival rate post warming was 93.8% (122/130)
with 93.3% (84/90) for inexperienced and 95.0% (38/40) for experienced operators. These rates were not significantly different.
Limitations, reason for caution: This audit of operator performance is being continued as vitrification is applied clinically and will be supplemented by success
data.
Wider implications of the findings: Quantitative analysis of operator-dependent
variability is both practical and essential when implementing a successful vitrification program.
Study funding/competing interest(s): N/A
Trial registration number: N/A
P-082 For now, I would rather have the transfer of one fresh blastocyst.
The surplus, please, vitrify them!
E.M. Dahdouh1, P. St-Michel2, L. Granger 1, B. Carranza-Mamane3, F. Faruqi 2,
T.V. Kattygnarath2, and F.L.A. Ferreira Gomes2
1
PROCREA Clinics & University of Montreal, ART Centre, Montreal, Canada,
2
PROCREA Clinics, ART Centre, Montreal, Canada, 3PROCREA Clinics &
University of Sherbrooke, ART Centre, Montreal, Canada
Study question: Is a frozen elective single-embryo transfer (eSET) at the blastocyst stage effective for good prognosis patients?
Summary answer: Though less effective than fresh single blastocyst transfer,
frozen SET (FET) at the blastocyst stage yields adequate clinical outcomes.
This will further contribute in decreasing multiple pregnancy rates, and improving
the cumulative pregnancy rate in the setting of an eSET policy.
What is known already: Vitrified blastocysts retained good developmental competency after warming. High pregnancy and implantation rates can be expected
once the blastocysts go through vitrification and warming because they have adequate developmental potential as fresh blastocysts.
Study design, size, duration: This is a prospective non-randomized control study
including 244 women who underwent a SET at the blastocyst stage (fresh - eSET
and frozen- FET) in a 11 months period between January 9th 2012 and December
15th 2012.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Women aged 34 years or younger
undergoing a fresh elective single blastocyst transfer cycle (eSET) (n ¼ 152) or
a frozen-thawed single blastocyst transfer (FET) (n ¼ 92). The study was performed in a tertiary private infertility clinic.
Main results and the role of chance: Patients in both groups (fresh and frozen)
were homogeneous for age, duration and cause of infertility, and for levels of
day 3 FSH. In the Fresh group, the biochemical pregnancy rate was 52.6%
while in the Frozen group it was 33.7% (p ¼ 0.0052). Implantation rate was
higher in the Fresh group compared to the Frozen group (47.4% and 31.5% respectively, p ¼ 0.0161). Ongoing pregnancy rates (41.4% and 28.3% respectively, p ¼ 0.0406) were also significantly higher in the Fresh group. Patients who
underwent a fresh eSET had a median of two surplus blastocysts cryopreserved
after transfer. Multiple pregnancy rates were very low, 0.7% and 1.1% for the
Fresh and the Frozen group, respectively.
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
Study question: Surplus embryos available for cryopreservation in fresh cycle
have been considered as a good resource for future use. However, the optimal
stage of embryo cryopreservation remains unclear.
Summary answer: Blastocyst cryopreservation is more time-effective and costeffective as compared to cleavage stage embryo cryopreservation though blastocyst culture will not improve the embryo developmental potential. It is a more preferable option to patients with surplus embryos destined for future use.
What is known already: Blastocyst culture is an effective tool to aid embryo selection. But the benefits of blastocyst transfer versus cleavage stage embryo transfer are usually evaluated in fresh cycles. Few studied have compared the results in
frozen-thawed embryo transfer (FET) cycles in a prospective way.
Study design, size, duration: A prospective cohort study was performed. Patients
in a university-based IVF center with failed pregnancy in fresh cycle and surplus
embryos available on Day 3 were enrolled during March 2011 and September
2011. Each patient was followed up at least one year.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: A total of 627 patients were enrolled
in the study. Patients were divided into two groups: cleavage stage embryo cryopreservation group (309 patients) and blastocyst cryopreservation group (318
patients). Clinical outcomes of the FET cycles in each patient were evaluated.
Main results and the role of chance: Cycle characteristics in terms of female age,
duration of infertility, basal FSH, mean number of retrieved oocytes, mean number
of available embryos/top quality embryos were comparable between the two
groups. Although a decreased cryopreservation rate (74.5%, 237/318), the blastocyst group achieved significantly higher rates of pregnancy/cycle (42.8% vs
31.7%, P
Limitations, reason for caution: This study was not designed for randomized
fashion. Patients made the assignment decision mainly by themselves.
However, the two groups had similar cycle characteristics, supporting the
absence of any selection bias.
Wider implications of the findings: The conclusion will be helpful in counseling
patients regarding the optimal stage of cryopreservation of surplus embryos in
fresh cycles and utilization of cryopreserved embryos in future FET cycles.
Study funding/competing interest(s): The authors have no connection to any
companies or products mentioned in this article.
Trial registration number: None
i151
i152
Limitations, reason for caution: This is a non-randomized study and therefore
subject to bias. Primary clinical outcomes do not include live birth rates, so
results must be interpreted with caution.
Wider implications of the findings: Improvement in cryopreservation techniques and better synchronization between the endometrium and the embryo development, will further contribute to increase FET efficiency. Blastocysts can be
vitrified in patients for whom fresh blastocyst transfer is unsuitable, such as
patients at risk of OHSS, or those in need for preimplantation genetic diagnosis.
Cumulative pregnancy rate might offset the lower pregnancy rate for fresh blastocyst transfer observed in this study.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This study received no funding and there
are no conflicts of interests to be declared.
Trial registration number: None.
Effectiveness of vitrification in women undergoing elective
freezing of oocytes and/or embryos when embryo transfer conditions are
suboptimal
N. Christoforidis, C. Ioakimidou, C. Papas, M. Moisidou, and A. Chatziparasidou
Embryolab Assisted Reproduction Unit, IVF Unit, Thessaloniki, Greece
Study question: Certain conditions that are associated with reduced ARToutcome
following controlled ovarian stimulation, such as raised progesterone levels on day
of hCG triggering, ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome, endometrial polyps and thin
endometrium. Elective vitirification of all oocytes/embryos and frozen embryo
transfer in subsequent cycles may provide a valid alternative approach.
Summary answer: Elective vitrification of oocytes/embryos after controlled
ovarian stimulation in suboptimal conditions for embryo transfer, is associated
with high survival rates of oocytes/embryos and high pregnancy rates in frozen
embryo replacement cycles.
What is known already: Successful implantation relies on both embryological
features and endometrial receptivity. It is known that certain conditions have a
negative impact on endometrial receptivity, in particular, raised progesterone
levels on the day of hCG triggering, hyperoestrogenemia associated with
ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome, as well as endometrial pathology, such as
endometrial polyps and presence of endometrial fluid. Vitrification is an effective
procedure that allows preservation of oocytes/embryos and transfer of embryos in
cycles with optimal endometrial recpetivity.
Study design, size, duration: Retrospective analysis of 88 cases undergoing
elective freeze-all with vitrification of oocytes/embryos following controlled
ovarian stimulation, when endometrial conditions were deemed suboptimal,
from March 2011 to March 2012.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Cases were categorized according to
indication of elective freeze-all procedure as follows: repeated implantation
failure, endometrial polyp, raised progesterone on day of hCG triggering,
OHSS, embryo collection for PGD, endometrial fluid, thin endometrium. Survival rate of oocytes/embryos post thawing and pregnancy rates in subsequent
embryo transfers were evaluated.
Main results and the role of chance: Survival rate of oocytes/embryos and CPR
per category were recorded as follows: repeated implantation failure: 95% oocyte
survival, 50% CPR, endometrial polyp: 96% oocyte survival, 98% embryo survival, 85% CPR, raised progesterone: 98% oocyte survival, 54.8% CPR,
embryo collection for PGD: 98% embryo survival, 48% CPR, OHSS: 97%
oocyte survival, 64.5% CPR, endometrial fluid: 99% embryo survival, 25%
CPR, thin endometrium: 96% embryo survival, 46% CPR.
Limitations, reason for caution: Number of cases that underwent elective crypreservation for endometrial receptivity reasons may not be large enough.
Wider implications of the findings: Oocyte and embryo survival rates after vitirification are quite high and pregnancy rates are very satisfactory following embryo
transfer in a subsequent endometrial preparation cycle. It is suggested that whenever endometrial conditions are deemed suboptimal oocyte and/or embryo vitrification may be a valid option to allow optimal endometrial preparation and
hence, high pregnancy rates. Elective vitirification may minimize the risk of developing OHSS, augment the number of available embryos for PGD.
Study funding/competing interest(s): None
Trial registration number: None
P-084 Cleavage stage embryo versus blastocyst transfer in patients with
3 failed IVF/ ICSI cycles, a retrospective cohort study
M. Klaver, K. Tilleman, and P. De Sutter
University Hospital Gent, Assisted reproduction, Gent, Belgium
Study question: Does day 5 embryo transfer (ET) in patients with repeated implantation failure (3 failed IVF/ICSI cycles) increase pregnancy rates in the
fourth cycle if necessary after correction of thrombophilic or autoimmune pathology?
Summary answer: Day 5 ET in patients with 3 failed IVF/ICSI cycles and in
whom thrombophilia or autoimmune disorders are treated if present, increases
the pregnancy rate per embryo transfer significantly until 67% when compared
to 37% after day 3 ET.
What is known already: Pregnancy rate in the fourth cycle after 3 failed IVF/ICSI
cycles is usually rather low, making this a therapeutically challenging group of
patients. There is a lot of controversy about testing for auto-immunity or thrombophilia and about which is the best therapeutic strategy for this group.
Study design, size, duration: This is a monocentric retrospective study. We
included 72 patients with 4 consecutive IVF or ICSI treatment cycles in our
centre between 2007 and 2012. The first 3 cycles had ET at cleavage stage (day
2 or 3) and negative HCG as outcome. Patients aged above 36 years were
excluded.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: In the fourth cycle 51 patients were
planned for ETat cleavage stage and 21 for blastocyst transfer.A repeated implantation failure protocol (RIF), including testing for thrombofilia, auto-immunity,
karyotype disorders and hysteroscopy was performed. Depending on the test
results treatment consisted of operative hysteroscopy, prednisolon, heparin or
aspirinaccordingly.
Main results and the role of chance: In the group scheduled for day 5 ET 81%
(17 of 21 patients) were tested and 28.5% of the tests (6 patients) were abnormal
and treated. In one patient (4.7%) the embryos did not reach the blastocyst stage
and no transfer was performed. In the cleavage stage group 63% (32 of 51 patients)
were tested and 37.5% (12 patients) were abnormal and treated. Pregnancy rate per
transfer in cleavage stage transfer was 37% (19 out of 51 patients). Pregnancy rate
per transfer in the blastocyst group (day 5) was 67% ( 14 out of 21 patients). This
difference is statistically significant (x2-test, P ¼ 0.023.).
Limitations, reason for caution: The patient group is rather small, but still results
are significant. These are preliminary results and the cohort will be expanded to
include patients with 3 IVF/ICSI cycles of which the first 2 have failed. Results
from frozen embryo’s and subsequent cryo cycles have not been included in
this study.
Wider implications of the findings: With blastocyst transfer chances for patients
with repeated implantation failure increase significantly. Besides correcting for
implantation hindering pathology, performing day 5 embryo culture also allows
to discriminate between real implantation and embryo quality problems. This provides useful information, allowing better counselling of patients regarding further
steps of treatment.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This study was not funded and there were
no competing interests.
Trial registration number: not applicable
P-085
Effect of female underweight on embryo morphokinetic using
time-lapse
J. Lammers, T. Freour, C. Splingart, and P. Barriere
CHU Nantes, 38 Bd Jean Monnet, Nantes Cedex 01, France
Study question: The aim of our study was to compare early embryo morphokinetic parameters with a time-lapse monitoring system (Embryoscope) according
to female BMI (Body Mass Index) category, in order to identify an eventual detrimental effect of underweight on in vitro embryo development.
Summary answer: We showed that morphokinetics differs according to female
BMI category, with almost all cellular events delayed in underweight women.
We also found that Zona Pellucida (ZP) thickness was different according to
female BMI. However, IVF cycle outcome does not appear to be affected in underweight women.
What is known already: Consequences of underweight (BMI , 18.5 kg/m2) on
reproductive age women’s health are numerous, including fertility. Indeed, these
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
P-083
Abstracts
Abstracts
P-086
Effect of oocyte activation by calcium ionophore A23187 or
strontium chloride in patients with low fertilization rates
T. Ikeno1, Y. Nakajyo2, Y. Sato 1, K. Hirata1, T. Kyoya 1, and K. Kyono1
Kyono ART Clinic, Department of Gynechology, Sendai, Japan, 2Kyono ART
Clinic Takanawa, Department of Gynechology, Tokyo, Japan
1
Study question: To evaluate the effectiveness of oocyte activation (OA) by
calcium ionophore A23187 or strontium chloride in patients with low fertilization
rates.
Summary answer: Artificial OA using A23187 or SrCl2 is beneficial to patients
with low or no fertility.
Further studies are needed to confirm the safety of oocyte activation.
What is known already: Oocytes unfertilised after ICSI have been subsequently
activated using chemical, mechanical, and electrical stimulation, and these
oocytes have been able to form pronuclei.
Study design, size, duration: We obtained informed consent from 144 couples
who had had unsuccessful ICSI treatment at our clinic between April 2004 and
August 2012. These were then divided into two groups.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Ninety two couples who had unsuccessful ICSI treatments sequentially received A23187 OA after ICSI. We compared the clinical results with and without OA.
Fifty two couples who had unsuccessful previous ICSI treatments sequentially received SrCl2 OA after ICSI. We compared the clinical results with and
without OA.
Main results and the role of chance: Comparing the results without and with
A23187, the results were as follows: two pronucleus (2PN) zygote rates, 24.3%
(85/350) vs. 61.2.% (316/516): P , 0.01; top quality embryo rates, 26.1%
(23/88) vs. 43.4%(115/265): P , 0.01; expanded blastocyst rates, 13.8% (9/65)
vs. 15.6% (30/192): NS; clinical pregnancy rates, 2.7% (1/36) vs. 14.9% (26/
174): NS; and miscarriage rates, 100% (1/1) vs. 38.5% (10/26): NS.
Comparing the results without and with SrCl2, the results were as follows: 2PN
zygote rates, 24.5% (81/330) vs. 57.5% (192/334): P , 0.01; top quality embryo
rates, 27.0% (24/89) vs. 25.3% (42/166): NS; expanded blastocyst rates, 14.1%
(9/64) vs. 8.4% (11/131): NS; clinical pregnancy rates, 0%(0/52) vs. 19.2% (14/
73) :P , 0.05; and miscarriage rates, 0% (0/0) vs. 21.4% (3/14): NS.
Limitations, reason for caution: None.
Wider implications of the findings: In conclusion, AOA using A23187 or SrCl2
is beneficial for patients with low or no fertilization by ICSI.
Comparing the results for babies with A23187 and SrCl2 OA showed no significant difference between babies born after OA and naturally conceived babies.
As with all assisted reproductive technology treatment, we must inform patients
of the risks and benefits of undergoing fertility treatment and possible implications
for the future health of their children.
Study funding/competing interest(s): None.
Trial registration number: This study is not RCT.
P-087 Are there any differences in terms of kinetic parameters between
male or female embryos - a time lapse analysis
F. Bronet Campos1, M. Meseguer2, M. Nogales3, E. Martinez3, M. Ariza3,
D. Agudo1, L. Rodrigo 3, and J.A. Garcia-Velasco4
1
IVI Madrid, IVF, Madrid, Spain, 2IVI Valencia, IVF, Valencia, Spain, 3IVI
Madrid, PGD, Madrid, Spain, 4IVI Madrid, Gynaecology, Madrid, Spain
Study question: Is it possible to estimate embryo gender according to the embryo
cleavage timing?
Summary answer: There is no correlation between sex ratio and developing
embryo rate.
What is known already: In some species male and female embryos develop at
different rate during preimplantational period. It has been suggested that XY
human embryos could have faster growing rate and also they could reach blastocyst stage earlier. However, no time lapse studies have been reported so far.
Study design, size, duration: Retrospective, observational study including 365
embryos from our PGS (preimplantation genetic screening) program from
January 2012 to December 2012. Embryos were grouped according to their sex:
male (166 embryos) and female (161 embryos). Additionally another group was
included with 38 embryos with Turner Syndrome (TS).
Participants/materials, setting, methods: All embryos were cultured in an incubator with time lapse technology, Embryoscope. Cleavage timing from insemination to day 3 was studied and all kinetic parameters that have been described in
previous studies by our group have been taken into account and compared
among the three groups
Main results and the role of chance: Chromosomal abnormal rate was similar in
both groups (male: 61.4%; female: 57.7%, p ¼ 0.4955). We did not find any statistical differences between male or female embryos according to the growing rate
in any specific cleavage check point.
Surprisingly, we found statistical differences in cleavage time from one cell to
two cells (T2) in TS embryos compared with male or female embryos (TS: 27.6 +
3.7; male: 26.3 + 3.0; female: 26.3 + 2.8; p ¼ 0.032).
Limitations, reason for caution: Sample size may limit our findings
Wider implications of the findings: Embryo development is not affected by
embryo gender and sex ratio is not affected by the embryo selected to transfer
based on kinetic parameters.
Study funding/competing interest(s): The authors declare no conflicts of interest. The study did not receive any external grant.
Trial registration number: None
P-088 Blastocyst survival, re-expansion, and % live cells following vitrification and warming using two commercially-available vitrification systems
A.S. Lopes, V. Frederickx, G. Vankerkhoven, A. Serneels, P. Roziers,
P. Puttermans, R. Campo, and S. Gordts
LIFE (Leuven Institute for Fertility and Embryology), Unit for Reproductive
Medicine, Leuven, Belgium
Study question: The aim of this study was to evaluate and compare survival,
re-expansion, and % live cells of individual Day 5-6 human blastocysts, vitrified
and warmed with the Vit Kit Freeze/Thaw (Irvine Scientific, CA), or with two protocols using the Global Fast Freeze/Thaw Kits (LifeGlobal, Canada).
Summary answer: Survival, re-expansion, and % live cells were not different for
blastocysts vitrified and warmed between the two vitrification/warming kits, or
between the two protocols for the Global Fast Freeze/Thaw Kits.
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
women often face with infertility, anovulation, high miscarriage rate and obstetrical complications, leading to lower live birth rate after ARTcycles. Whether underweight affects preimplantatory embryo development in underweight women
undergoing IVF remains to be explored.
Study design, size, duration: This retrospective study was conducted on all ICSI
cycles performed between 2011 and 2012 with the Embryoscopew. All clinical,
ovarian reserve, ovarian stimulation and embryonic parameters (conventional
morphology and kinetic events in hours post injection) were recorded.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: This study was conducted at the University Hospital of Nantes, France, on all ICSI cycles. After oocyte retrieval and
ICSI, all oocytes were incubated in the Embryoscopew until transfer. Clinical,
ovarian reserve, ovarian stimulation and embryo morphokinetic parameters
were compared according to female BMI category.
Main results and the role of chance: Among the 366 couples included (2270
oocytes collected), 34 women had low BMI (,18.5 kg/m2), 224 had a normal
BMI (18.5-25), 65 were overweight (25-30) and 43 were obese (.30). Patients’
clinical characteristics were not significantly different between the 4 groups
(age, smoking status, infertility, AMH, semen characteristics and stimulation parameters). Day 3 FSH, E2 and LH and peak E2 were significantly higher, whereas
total FSH dose was lower in underweight group than in others. Number of
oocytes retrieved, fertilization rate, number and quality of cleaved embryos (conventional morphology) were not significantly different between underweight and
others groups. Most embryo development events (4 cell, 5 cell, 8 cell stages) occurred significantly later in underweight than in other groups. ZP was also thicker
in underweight women.
Limitations, reason for caution: This retrospective study was conducted in a
limited cohort of patients.
Wider implications of the findings: Time-lapse analysis is a relevant method for
the evaluation of female clinical characteristics’ influence on early embryo development. Not only obesity, but also female underweight, should be studied as a cofactor potentially leading to modifications in early embryo development.
Study funding/competing interest(s): None
Trial registration number: Local IRB approved study
i153
i154
P-089
Analysis of mitochondrial DNA copy number provides an insight
into the ploidy and implantation potential of human blastocysts
E. Fragouli1, S. Alfarawati2, K. Spath 3, and D. Wells1
1
Reprogenetics UK/ University of Oxford, Institute of Reproductive Sciences,
Oxford, United Kingdom, 2Reprogenetics UK, Institute of Reproductive Sciences,
Oxford, United Kingdom, 3University of Oxford, Institute of Reproductive
Sciences, Oxford, United Kingdom
Abstract withdrawn by the author.
P-090
Serum anti-Mullerian hormone measurements and human
blastocyst development after IVF
J. Liss, K. Lukaszuk, J. Glowacka, and A. Bruszczynska
Invicta, Fertility and Reproductive Center, Gdansk, Poland
Study question: To report on relationships among baseline AMH level, blastocyst
development and other selected embryology parameters observed in non-donor
oocyte IVF cycles.
Summary answer: The current investigation present that baseline serum AMH
level can be a useful parameter to estimate blastocyst developmental potential
during IVF.
What is known already: AMH was a predictive correlate for ovarian reserve and
the number of oocytes retrieved, with a high positive value compared with age,
early follicular FSH level and pregnancy after IVF. Its role in forecasting in
vitro embryo morphology and developmental potential to the blastocyst stage is
still emerging.
Study design, size, duration: Between January and December 2011, 830 patients
without endometriosis, who had their AMH levels analyzed were incorporated
into this prospective study.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Mean age, AMH level, antral follicle
count (AFC), number of follicles, oocyte retrieved, MII oocytes, early cleavage
embryos, blastocyst for transfer were evaluated.
Main results and the role of chance: Three groups were formed according to the
AMH level: 1: ,0.6 ng/ml (n ¼ 55), 2: 0.6-1.4 ng/ml (n ¼ 134) and 3: .1.4 ng/
ml (n ¼ 641). Blastocyst formation was significantly lower (p ¼ 0.001) in group
1 and 2 compared to group 3 (23.6%, 43.3% and 67% respectively). There were
statistical differences in first group of AMH with age (p ¼ 0.001) and early cleavage embryos (p ¼ 0.02). By multivariate analysis, only age (OR ¼ 0.81; 95% CI,
0.66-0.98) showed significant association with the blastocyst formation in this
group. All parameters were found to be associated with blastocyst formation in
AMH group 2 and 3. By multivariate analysis, only early cleavage embryos
(OR ¼ 2.56; 95% CI, 1.58-4.13 and OR ¼ 1.71; 95% CI, 1.52-1.93 respectively)
showed significant association with the blastocyst formation in these two groups.
Limitations, reason for caution: Different types of reproductive pathology
might impact serum AMH in different ways (endometriosis, PCOS). Culture to
the blastocyst stage require strict environmental. This can affect the results
obtained in other laboratories.
Wider implications of the findings: Our study confirmed correlation between
AMH level and age, AFC, total number of retrieved oocytes as well as the
number of MII oocytes and early cleavage embryos. The correlation between
early cleavage embryos and blastocyst formation suggests that early cleavage observation (e.g. time laps procedure) will be a good prognostic factor for patient
with different AMH level. Decision about embryo transfer with smaller amount
of good quality embryos could be taken earlier, without long culture.
Study funding/competing interest(s): There are not any commercial association
of the author of any coauthors that might pose a
P-091 Effect of sperm selection using hyaluronic acid binding on reproductive outcome with donated oocyte cycles
S. Cortés Gallego, L. Ortega López, E. Olaya Vila, M. Gago Garcı́a, C. Luna Cañas,
A. Garcı́a Segovia, A. Guijarro Ponce, R. Núñez Calonge, and P. Caballero Peregrı́n
Clinica Quirurgica Tambre, Laboratorio FIV / Andrologia, Madrid, Spain
Study question: Compare the efficiency of routine sperm selection method polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) with HA-selection method (Sperm-Slow) for fertilization
rate (FR), cleavage rate (CR), embryo quality (EQ) and pregnancy rate (PR) as
well as evaluating the relationship between HA-binding ability with sperm protamine deficiency and DNA fragmentation using donated oocyte cycles.
Summary answer: Contrary to our expectation, selection of HA-bound
spermato-zoa had no benefits in terms of fertilization, em-bryo cleavage,
embryo quality and pregnancy rate in ICSI cycles.
In conclusion, our prospective and randomized trial suggests that both,
PVP and Sperm-Slow allow a comparable clinical efficiency in selecting
spermatozoa.
What is known already: Intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) using hyaluronic acid (HA) containing media has been suggested to have higher specificity
and lower biological risk than other selection methods. HA-binding ability of
spermatozoa is related to sperm membrane maturity and fertilizing potential,
thus it has been suggested that sperm selection using HA before ICSI might
help to optimize the treatment. However, there are conflicting data regarding
subsequent improvement of FR, CR and PR after ICSI using HA-bound
spermatozoa.
Study design, size, duration: This was a single-center, prospective, randomized
study of 144 ICSI cycles (2012) with donated oocytes to avoid female infertility as
a bias factor, randomly carried out with PVP (1119 ovocites microinjectated) or
with Sperm-Slow (1104 ovocites microinjectated) for sperm selection.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Our primary outcome was to compare
FR, CR, EQ and PR between two groups.
A secondary outcome was to better de?ne the role of HA for selection of spermatozoa with normal chromatin content to optimize ICSI outcome. To determine the
value of Sperm DNA fragmentation (SDF) levels, the Sperm Chromatin Dispersion test (SCD) was measured.
Between groups differences of normally distributed continuous variables were
assessed with a parametric statistic (Student’s t test).Between-group differences in
no continuous variables were assessed using the c2 method. Differences were considered significant when a P value was ,.05.
Main results and the role of chance: There were no significant differences in
regard the total number of injected MII oocytes, semen quality or SDF.
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
What is known already: Vitrification is a modern method for cryopreservation of
human embryos, currently available in most IVF centers. Several cryoprotectants
and devices are available in the market but some require excellent training skills
and others led to inconsistent survival rates following thawing.
Study design, size, duration: Group 1 blastocysts were vitrified with the Vit Kit
(n ¼ 41) and Hemi-Straw devices, Group 2 (n ¼ 50) and Group 3 (n ¼ 57) blastocysts were cryopreserved with the Global Fast Freeze Kit and 0.25 ml straws,
using a direct plunge or a -1008C holding step, respectively. Group 4 (Controls,
n ¼ 31) were not vitrified.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Frozen/thawed Day 2-3 or discarded
embryos were cultured to blastocyst (culture day 5-6). After vitrification/
warming, blastocysts were cultured for 24h. All embryos were stained individually with propidium iodide and Hoechst. Live and total cell number was assessed
with ImageJ (NIH), and the percentage of live cells calculated for each blastocyst.
Main results and the role of chance: Survival immediately following thawing
was 90%, 94%, and 83% for Groups 1, 2 and 3, respectively, and not significantly
different (P . 0.05). Following 24h culture, survival was 72%, 74% and 77%,
and not significantly different. Re-expansion at 24h after thawing was 55%,
68% and 68%, and not significantly different. Mean (+ SD) % live cells were
90.1 + 2.5, 92.7 + 2.5, 90.4 + 2.2, and 95.8 + 1.1, for Groups 1, 2, 3, and 4, respectively. There was no significant effect of treatment, culture day (Day 5 or 6), or
interaction between treatment and culture day.
Limitations, reason for caution: The power of the comparisons of proportions is
low (, 0.40) due to the relatively small sample sizes.
Wider implications of the findings: The simplicity of blastocyst vitrification
using the Global Fast Freeze/Thaw Kits using freezing straws may provide
increased safety, and efficiency with lower cost, compared with vitrification
using specialized embryo vitrification devices.
Study funding/competing interest(s): Global Fast Freeze/Thaw Kits were provided by IVFonline. A.S. Lopes is a paid technical consultant for IVFonline.
Trial registration number: Not applicable
Abstracts
Abstracts
P-092
Does growth retardation in human blastocysts decrease implantation potential after embryo transfer through an increase of the abnormal
spindles
S. Hashimoto1, A. Amo1, K. Ito2, Y. Nakaoka2, and Y. Morimoto2
IVF Namba Clinic, Research division, Osaka, Japan, 2IVF Namba Clinic,
Medical office, Osaka, Japan
1
Study question: To assess the potential of growth-retarded embryos, the implantation potential and the spindle shape of vitrified–warmed blastocysts were
assessed among normally developing and growth-retarded blastocysts.
Summary answer: The incidence of abnormal spindle morphology increased and
the implantation competence decreased following vitrification in growth-retarded
embryos compared with normally developing embryos, but there were no significant differences in the chromosomal abnormalities of abortuses and the incidences
of peromelus of babies between 2 groups.
What is known already: There are conflicting data on whether the human embryo
growth rate affects the outcome of vitrified–warmed blastocyst transfer. Various
types of spindle abnormality occur in human cleavage- and blastocyst-stage
embryos. A recent systematic review and meta-analysis concluded that
growth-retarded embryos that develop to the blastocyst stage by day 6 have the
same implantation potential as their day 5 counterparts if the morphology of
day 6 blastocyst is similar to that of day 5 blastocyst.
Study design, size, duration: This was a retrospective cohort study including 878
single vitrified–warmed blastocyst transfers between January 2010 and July 2012,
and an experimental study using 108 vitrified–warmed blastocysts donated to research. The local IRB of IVF Namba clinic approved this study. Data were compared using the Mann– Whitney nonparametric U-test.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: In a clinical study, we compared the
implantation rates of vitrified–warmed embryos that developed to the blastocyst
stage on day 5 after insemination with those that required culture to day 6. In an
experimental study, vitrified blastocysts were immunostained with an anti-atubulin antibody, an anti-g-tubulin antibody and DAPI.
Main results and the role of chance: In the clinical study, the implantation rate
of growth-retarded embryos (47%, n: 270) was significantly lower (P n:
608). However, there were no differences in the chromosomal abnormalities
of abortuses and the incidences of peromelus of babies between 2 groups. In
the experimental study, a total of 533 spindles were analyzed in both day 5
and day 6 blastocysts. Confocal image analysis was accomplished by capturing a z-series stack of 0.5-mm-thick optical sections encompassing the entire
blastocyst. Only spindles with fusiform poles and with chromosomes aligned
at the equator were classified as normal. The incidence of abnormal spindles
in growth-retarded embryos (47%, n: 274) was significantly higher
(P n: 259).
Limitations, reason for caution: Further studies are required to clarify the link
between an increase in abnormal spindle formation and a decrease in embryonic
implantation potential.
Wider implications of the findings: This study provided new insights on the
implications of an increase in abnormal spindle formation in growth-retarded
human blastocysts.
Study funding/competing interest(s): Part of this work was supported by a grant
from the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JPS-RFTF 23580397 to
S.H.). No other competing interests are declared.
Trial registration number: None.
P-093 In vitro maturation of human oocytes selected by Brilliant Cresyl
Blue staining
D.D. Alcoba1, E.G. Valério2, M. Conzatti 1, J. Tornquist1, A.P. Kussler3,
A.M. Pimentel3, H.E. Corleta3, and I.S. Brum1
1
Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul, Departamento de Fisiologia, Porto
Alegre, Brazil, 2Hospital de Clı́nicas de Porto Alegre, Serviço de Ginecologia e
Obstetrı́cia, Porto Alegre, Brazil, 3Hospital Moinhos de Vento, Núcleo de
Reprodução Humana Gerar, Porto Alegre, Brazil
Study question: Evaluate the efficiency and safety of Brilliant Cresyl Blue (BCB)
staining as a selection of developmentally competent immature human oocytes
before in vitro maturation (IVM).
Summary answer: BCB test can be a good marker in pre-selection procedures of
developmentally competent human oocytes and, apparently, it is not toxic to the
gamete.
What is known already: Growing oocytes synthesize glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PDH), but this enzyme is inactivated in oocytes that have completed their growth phase. Once BCB can be reduced by G6PDH, the selection
of developmentally competent oocytes before IVM by BCB staining is widely
used for many animal species (bovine, porcine, mice, etc). Using animal
models, it has been already demonstrated that this selection can improve not
only nuclear and cytoplasmic oocyte maturation, but also fertilization and blastocyst rates.
Study design, size, duration: Cross sectional experiment – control versus treatment groups. Three kinds of patients were included in the study: 6 hormonal stimulated patients with immature oocytes at retrieval (17 oocytes); 3
ooforectomized patients (20 oocytes recovered); and 32 pregnant patients
during cesarean section (92 oocytes recovered).
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Immature oocytes were divided into
groups: control (disposed directly to IVM) and treated - exposed to BCB
26 mM during 60 minutes. After staining, treated group was classified as cytoplasm coloration, BCB positive or negative, and then disposed to IVM. After 24
and 48 hours of IVM nuclear status was checked.
Main results and the role of chance: The IVM rate of immature oocytes recovered from stimulated and ooforectomized patients was equal among groups
(control, BCB positive and BCB negative) either after 24 or 48 hours of IVM.
Nevertheless, IVM was higher in BCB positive compared to BCB negative after
24 and 48 hours of IVM analyzing oocytes recovered from all patients (P ¼
0.024 and P ¼ 0.015) and from cesarean patients (P ¼ 0.004 and P ¼ 0.032).
The control group was equal to BCB positive. The meiosis resumption rate
(absence of germinal vesicle) after 24 hours of IVM was equal among groups,
but higher in BCB positive compared to other groups after 48 hours when all
gametes were analyzed jointly (P ¼ 0.035). Degeneration rate was lower in
BCB positive compared to their counterparts when oocytes were analyzed
jointly (P ¼ 0.002).
Limitations, reason for caution: Human oocytes that can be destined to research
are limited. We have to look for effects of ovarian puncture during cesarean section
after some years. As the eggs were not fertilized, embryo characteristics were not
accessed; so the effects of BCB on human embryo development remain unknown.
Wider implications of the findings: In human oocytes the IVM rate of BCB positive was higher than that observed for BCB negative, but equal to control group.
The degeneration rate was lower in BCB positive oocytes, compared to other
groups (control and BCB negative). These results were similar to that described
in animals.
Study funding/competing interest(s): The experiment was supported by university hospital and it has not any vested conflict.
Trial registration number: Not applicable.
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
No statistical difference was found regarding FR p: 0,961), CR (p: 0,884), EQ
(0,848) and PR (0,329). Oocytes injected with HA-bound spermatozoa had not
different FR (82, 33) than the conventional group (82, 46) neither CR (96, 71 vs
97, 03), or EQ (74, 23 vs 75, 6). Lower pregnancy rate was observed in oocytes
injected with HA-bound spermatozoa than the conventional group, but the difference was not significant (61, 0 vs 53, 2).
When the study population was divided by the SDF level (cutoff 30 %), there
were no statistical differences regarding FR, CR, EQ and PR when HA-selected
spermatozoa were used.
Limitations, reason for caution: We haveńt limitations in our study
Wider implications of the findings: The majority of studies have consistently
reported that HA-binding method is effective in selection of spermatozoa
without DNA fragmentation and with normal nucleus.
This is the first report with HA-bound spermatozoa using oocytes obtained from
young and fertile donors in previous cycles and this way to isolate the real influence of HA in clinical results.
Study funding/competing interest(s): No study funding or competing interest
Trial registration number: No trial registration numbre
i155
i156
P-094
Abstracts
Local evaluation and validation of open system oocyte vitrification
method
P. Boyer, D. Montjean, P. Tourame, and M. Gervoise-Boyer
Hopital Saint Joseph, Reproductive Medicine and Embryology Department,
Marseille, France
P-095
Oocyte ERM proteins play a crucial role in gamete adhesion/
fusion
J. Cohen, B. Lefevre, C. Ialy Radio, J.P. Wolf, and A. Ziyyat
Universite Paris Descartes Institut Cochin, Inserm U1016, Paris, France
Study question: Using siRNA intracytoplasmic injection in mouse oocytes, the
purpose of the study was to determine the role of oocyte Ezrin, Radixin and
Moesin (ERM) proteins in gamete adhesion/fusion.
Summary answer: We found that fertilization index (mean number of sperm
fused by zona pellucida free egg) was 57% decreased, and that oocyte microvilli
were thicker after oocyte ERM inhibition.
What is known already: On the mammalian oocyte, Cd9 is the only molecule
known to be essential for gamete membrane adhesion/fusion. In the absence of
Cd9, oocyte microvilli are thicker and adhesion exists but remains abortive.
Cd9 generates adhesion sites, named pro-fusional, with strong adhesion. This adhesion is strong because of the connection between the membrane and the cytoskeleton, which is realized indirectly through other molecules, Cd9 partners,
such as ERM that connect actin cytoskeleton to plasma membrane.
P-096 Clinical outcome of vitrified single blastocyst transfer as related to
blastocyst morphology before vitrification
I. De Croo, A. Tolpe, S. Degheselle, A. Van de Velde, K. Tilleman, P. De Sutter,
and E. Van den Abbeel
Ghent University Hospital, Centre for Reproductive Medicine, Ghent, Belgium
Study question: How does the clinical outcome of vitrified single blastocyst
transfer compare between poor-quality and good-quality blastocysts before vitrification?
Summary answer: Vitrification and warming of poor-quality blastocysts has
clinical significance since in our hands acceptable clinical outcome is achieved
as compared to vitrification and warming of good-quality blastocysts.
What is known already: Results with blastocyst transfer allow the use of single
embryo transfer, thereby reducing the incidence of multiple pregnancies. With
successful vitrification techniques, cryopreserved embryo transfer cycles have
become an integral part of IVF treatment. In fresh cycles, several reports have indicated the importance of the blastocyst morphology on clinical outcome after transfer. In most IVF centers poor-quality blastocysts are not cryopreserved and
therefore little is known about their clinical outcome after vitrification.
Study design, size, duration: Between February 1st 2012 to October 10th 2012,
462 vitrified blastocysts were warmed in 366 warming cycles. After warming and
overnight culture, we retrospectively investigated clinical pregnancy rates (CPR)
as related to blastocyst morphology before vitrification in 223 single vitrified
blastocyst transfer (SVBT).
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Blastocysts were graded according to
Schoolcraft&Gardner (1999). Early, full, expanded and hatching blastocysts were
vitrified. On day 5, early, full and expanded/hatching blastocysts with an ICM C
and/or a TE C were considered poor-quality blastocysts. Full and expanded/hatching blastocysts with ICM A/B and/or TE A/B were considered good-quality blastocysts.
Main results and the role of chance: Morphological survival rate immediately
after warming was 85.7% (396/462). After overnight culture, we performed
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
Study question: Is there a really need to validate oocyte vitrification technique in
an IVF laboratory before establishing it in daily practice?
Summary answer: Validation of micromanipulation-based technique, in this
case oocyte vitrification, is essential to evaluate its efficiency prior to enlarging
the use of the system to routine practice.
What is known already: Oocyte vitrification is a new worldwide used technique
and legal recently in France. This micromanipulation needs to be performed by a
confirmed embryologist and requires an internal assessment in each IVF unit
before any wide use.
Study design, size, duration: We designed a prospective study, from September
2011 to July 2012, using sibling oocytes from women who recovered more than 12
Metaphase II oocytes. A part of freshly recovered oocytes underwent immediate
ICSI while the remaining oocytes were vitrified.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: 62 couples (872 Metaphase II
oocytes) undergoing ICSI were selected based on number of oocytes available
at recovery. 405 Metaphase II oocytes were microinjected after retrieval and
467 were vitrified using an open system (Cryotopw).
Main results and the role of chance: To date, 145 oocytes have been thawed for
24 couples. This allowed us to estimate both the mean survival rate (84.9 %
+17.9) and fertilisation rate after oocytes thawing at 66.9 %+ 32.9 compared
to 56.4 % +27.8 in freshly recovered oocyte sub-group No statistical difference
was found.
The number of embryos transferred/number of Metaphase II ratio is 38/157 for
fresh oocytes and 39/145 for warmed oocytes (p . 0.05). Among the 62 included
couples, 21 clinical pregnancies were recorded in the fresh ICSI oocytes and 6
were registered in the vitrified/warmed oocyte cohort. Interestingly, the present
evaluation led to a satisfactory cumulative pregnancy rate: 43.5%. One additional
benefit of such practice is the limitation of embryo freezing.
Limitations, reason for caution: The study design delays oocytes warming
cycles, due to pregnancies triggered by the transfer of fresh derived oocyte
embryos and to the priority to transfer all the frozen embryos before starting
oocytes warming. Furthermore, no data is available about children’ health.
Wider implications of the findings: Oocyte vitrification represents a dramatic
change in our daily practice. Indeed, it enables us to be in line with the will of
local authorities to decrease the number of cryopreserved embryos while ensuring
satisfactory pregnancy chances. The encouraging results suggest that oocyte vitrification may also be used for a larger panel of purposes including oocyte storing
in cases of sperm retrieval failure, fertility preservation or egg donation.
Study funding/competing interest(s): Kitazato BioPharma provided Cryotop
safety Kits.
Trial registration number: Clinical Trials Registration number: 209 R02
Study design, size, duration: We performed a cross sectional (control versus
treatment) study. Number of oocytes: 149 (siRNA control injected¼ 82 /
siRNA ERM injected ¼ 67). The oocytes where injected at the germinal-vesicle
stage oocytes (GV).
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Animals were 6 weeks-old females
B6CBAF1 mice.
We realized RNA silencing by oocyte intracytoplasmic siRNA microinjection
under microscopic control at GV stage oocytes.
Zona pellucida was removed before IVF. Efficiency of the protein silencing and
Fertilization Index (FI) were assessed by immunofluorescence (Dapi). Oocyte
microvilli morphology was studied by electronic microscopy.
Main results and the role of chance: Efficiency of the silencing was assessed by
the decrease or the disappearance of oocyte membrane ERM. The fluorescence
intensity was quantified with specialized software.
After ERM combined siRNAs injection (N ¼ 67 oocytes), Fertilization Index
was 1.2 sperm per egg and 2.8 after control si RNA injection (N ¼ 82 oocytes),
which means a 57% decrease (p , 0,001).
After ERM siRNAs injection (N microvilli ¼ 521; N oocytes ¼ 5), oocyte
microvilli radius of curvature was 37.8% increased (34.6 nm versus 47.7 nm;
p , 0,001) compared to control injected siRNA (N microvilli ¼ 350;
N oocytes ¼ 5).
Fertilization Index was not reduced when silencing separately Ezrin, Radixin or
Moesin.
Limitations, reason for caution: The main limitation of this study is the partial
inhibition provided by RNA silencing. It was impossible to use a triple knock-out
model because of the premature lethality of Ezrin 2/- mice.
Wider implications of the findings: This work provides new elements in the
understanding of Cd9 mechanisms in gamete adhesion/fusion. These observations are a strong argument in favor of the cis-action of Cd9, which is the most
likely mechanism: gamete fusion could succeed thanks to a strong link between
plasma membrane and its underlying cytoskeleton mediated by Cd9 and ERM
proteins.
Study funding/competing interest(s): We declare no competing interest.
Trial registration number: No registration number.
i157
Abstracts
P-097
A comparison of two different vitrification methods for cryopreservation of mature human oocytes
S. Kagalwala1, G. Gandhi1, G. Allahbadia 2, M. Kuwayama3, A. Allahbadia2,
V. Chipkar1, A. Khatoon1, R. Ramani1, M. Madne1, and S. Alsule1
1
Rotunda CHR, Assisted Reproduction Laboratory, Mumbai, India, 2Rotunda
CHR, Assisted Reproduction, Mumbai, India, 3Repro-Support Medical Research
Center, Assisted Reproduction, Tokyo, Japan
Study question: To compare the efficacy of two different methods of vitrification
for cryopreservation of human oocytes: The Cryotop method and the Cryotech
method.
Summary answer: Cryotech vitrification method for oocyte cryopreservation
gives slightly higher survival and fertilization rates and significantly higher cleavage rate compared to the Cryotop method.
What is known already: Vitrification is a highly effective method for successful
cryopreservation of oocytes. Various media, methods and carrier devices are being
used for optimizing the vitrification technique. Cryotop vitrification method is
known to give excellent results. The Cryotech method is different from the
Cryotop method in terms of the constituents of its solutions as well as the
design of the plates and the carrier device.
Study design, size, duration: This is a retrospective data analysis of donor egg
-IVF cycles using vitrified oocytes from October 2010 to August 2012. The
oocytes were vitrified using either the cryotop or cryotech vitrification method.
A total of 611 mature oocytes were vitrified and 131 embryo transfer cycles
were performed using the embryos created after fertilizing the warmed oocytes
with ICSI.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Donor oocytes were vitrified using
either cryotech or cryotop vitrification method. The frozen oocytes were then
warmed using the respective warming media. The surviving oocytes were fertilized by ICSI. Embryo transfer was performed in the recipients using these
embryos. The survival, fertilization, cleavage and the clinical pregnancy rates
were compared in the two groups.
Main results and the role of chance: A total of 275 mature oocytes were vitrified
using cryotech method and 336 mature oocytes using cryotop method. The mean
age of the egg donors was 25.3 + 2.8 years and 24.8 + 2.4 years for Cryotech and
Cryotop methods respectively. The survival rate of warmed oocytes with Cryotech
media was 97.1% (n ¼ 267/275) while for Cryotop media it was 95.1% (n ¼ 319/
336; p ¼ 0.19). The fertilization rate of Cryotech group was 90.7% (n ¼ 240/267)
and Cryotop group was 86.1% (n ¼ 274/319; p ¼ 0.05). The cleavage rate for
Cryotech group was 96.8% (n ¼ 232/240) and Cryotop group was 91.9% (n ¼
251/274; p ¼ 0.01). The clinical pregnancy rate for Cryotech group was 54.8%
(n ¼ 34/62) and Cryotop group was 40.6% (n¼ 28/69).
Limitations, reason for caution: A limitation of this study is that it is not done
using sibling oocytes. However, there was no statistically significant difference
in the age and fertility parameters of the donors of both the groups.
Wider implications of the findings: Even though the survival rate of oocytes in
both the groups did not show a statistically significant difference, the embryo development was better in the Cryotech group, as reflected by higher cleavage rate.
This may be attributed to less trauma to the oocytes vitrified and warmed using
Cryotech method. The Cryotech method would be very useful in building donor
oocyte banks and fertility preservation of cancer patients.
Study funding/competing interest(s): No funding was used.
Trial registration number: Not Applicable
P-098
Influence of storage period of vitrified embryos on clinical outcome
Inaba1,
M.
A. Ohgaki1, A. Ohtani1, H. Matsumoto1, S. Mizuno1, R. Mori2,
A. Fukuda2, and Y. Morimoto3
1
IVF osaka clinic, Division of reproductive technology, Osaka, Japan, 2IVF osaka
clinic, Doctor, Osaka, Japan, 3IVF namba clinic, Doctor, Osaka, Japan
Study question: The present study was conducted to investigate the influence of
vitrification on laboratory and clinical outcomes depending on the period of
storage in the stage of 2PN, cleaved embryo and blastocyst.
Summary answer: The present study suggested that cryopreservation of embryos
at any stages by vitrification had no detrimental effect on cryosurvival and clinical
outcome.
What is known already: Frozen-thawed or vitrified-warmed embryo transfer
(FET) in ART has been recently increasing with not only an advancement of cryopreservation technique such as vitrification, but also a trend of single embryo transfer (SET) to prevent multiple pregnancy. Cryopreservation of embryos by slow
freezing method has been used more than 30 years and the influence of this
method has been evaluated. However, vittrificaion is a relatively new technique
and influence of vitrification on clinical outcome has not been elucidated.
Study design, size, duration: In 3392 FET cycles of SET (1674 patients), 8796
embryos (6069 2PNs, 1573 cleaved embryos and 1154 blastocysts) were
warmed for transfer from January 2010 to December 2012. Data obtained from
these embryos were analyzed retrospectively.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Those embryos were divided into 4
groups based on the storage period, A: ,1 year, B: 1-2 years, C: 2-3 years, D:
.3 years. Survival after warming in each period was compared in each stage of
embryos. Moreover, the influence of storage period on the rates pregnancy and
live birth were compared.
Main results and the role of chance: 1. Survival rates in group A, B, C, D and
average were as follows. 2PN: 98.0%, 98.7%, 100.0%, 100.0% and 98.1%.
Cleaved embryo: 96.3%, 95.1%, 94.9%, 100.0% and 96.1%, respectively. Blastocyst: 97.9%, 97.8%, 100.0%, 100.0% and 97.9%, respectively. There were no significant differences among these 4 groups in each stage.
2. Pregnancy rates in group A, B, C, D and average were as follows. Cleaved
embryos: 32.6%, 42.9%, 26.7 % and 25.0% and 33.0%. Blastocyst: 42.9%,
45.7%, 56.3% and 41.7%, and 43.7%, respectively. Live birth rates were as
follows. Cleaved embryos: 76.5%, 83.3 %, 100.0%, 50.0%, and 77.1%. Blastocyst: 80.5%, 79.3%, 77.8%, 60.0%, and 80.0%, respectively. There were no significant differences among 4 groups either in cleaved embryo or blastocyst.
Limitations, reason for caution: None
Wider implications of the findings: The present study suggested that cryopreservation of embryos at any stages by vitrification had no detrimental effect on cryosurvival and clinical outcome regardless of storage period for at least 3 years. The
longest period was 5 years and 6 months with healthy baby born. Vitrification is
very effective, laboratory friendly and safe cryopreservation method.
Study funding/competing interest(s): None
Trial registration number: None
P-099 Outcome of blastocyst vitrification with cryoloops: clinical
outcome of 2,924 cycles comparing with 2,003 fresh blastocyst transfer cycles
Y. Umekawa, A. Yoshida, S. Tanigiwa, K. Seida, H. Suzuki, and M. Tanaka
Kiba Park Clinic, Tokyo, Japan
Study question: Is ultra rapid vitrification method of blastocysts using a cryoloop
safe and effective?
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
278 vitrified blastocyst transfers. Overall pregnancy rate (% positive HCG)
was 40.3%/ET and 30.6% per warming cycle. CPR was 29.1%/ET with an
implantation rate of 21.4% (99/462) per warmed blastocyst. More specifically and independent of ICM and TE quality, CPR per SVBT was 19.1% (14/
73), 27.9% (17/61) and 27.0% (24/89) for early, full and expanded blastocysts respectively (p ¼ 0.3). In the expanded blastocyst group with ICM or
TE grade C, CPR was 25.9% (7/27) compared to 28.4% (35/123) in the
group with ICM and TE grade A and B. Taken together the CPR per
SVTB was 21% (21/100) for poor-quality blastocysts versus 28.4% 35/
123) for good-quality blastocysts (p ¼ 0.2).
Limitations, reason for caution: Much larger study groups are required to evaluate clinical pregnancy and miscarriage rates by the specific blastocyst morphological scores especially as related to the different types of ICM and TE in full
and expanded/expanding blastocysts.
Wider implications of the findings: Our findings could change cryopreservation
policies in IVF centres performing blastocyst vitrification because so far in most
centres only good-quality blastocysts are considered eligible for vitrification.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This study was not funded and there were
no competing interests.
Trial registration number: Inapplicable.
i158
P-100
Anthocyanin improves viability and maturation of sheep oocytes
cultured In the presence of cAMP modulators
Z. Vahabi1, P. Eftekhari Yazdi1, A. Dalman1, B. Ebrahimi1, F. Mostafaei 2, and
M. Rajabpour Niknam1
1
Department of Embryology Reproductive Biomedicine Research Center, Royan
Institute for Reproductive Biomedicine ACECR, Tehran, Iran, 2Animal Core
Facility Reproductive Biomedicine Research Center, Royan Institute for Animal
Biotechnology ACECR, Tehran, Iran
Study question: Can high levels of cAMP alone support sheep cultured oocytes
from apoptosis?
Summary answer: Our findings showed that, cAMP modulators couldn’t
support maturation and viability of sheep oocytes. While the Pre-IVM and IVM
mediums supplemented with delphinidin chloride could significantly Decrease
apoptosis and increase maturation of sheep oocytes.
What is known already: To our knowledge, no studies to data have focused on
apoptosis repression in sheep oocytes cultured at high levels of cAMP.
Study design, size, duration: Cumulus-oocyte complexes (COCs) were cultured
in two biphasic mediums: 1) Pre-IVM and IVM mediums supplemented with delphinidin chloride and 2) Pre-IVM and IVM mediums without delphinidin chloride. Differences in maturation and viability rates between COCs cultured in two
experimental groups were determined by the Chi-square test.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: COCs were recovered from ovine
ovaries collected at a local slaughterhouse. Good-quality COCs were randomly
transferred into two biphasic IVM mediums. After maturation period, oocytes
were denuded from cumulus cells and MII oocytes with first polar body were
counted. Oocyte viability was determined by means of the TUNEL technique.
Main results and the role of chance: The percentage of oocytes that reached
metaphase II was significantly higher for group 1 (93.5% and 73.0%, respectively
P , 0.0001) than group 2 oocytes. The percentage of viable oocytes at group 1
was higher ( 98.9% and 85.1%, respectively P , 0.001) than group 2 oocytes.
Maturation rate and viability detection by TUNEL kit in two experimental
groups in sheep oocytes.
Limitations, reason for caution: We have any limitation.
Wider implications of the findings: Some studies reported that, High levels of
cAMP suppress apoptosis by inhibition of Caspase 3 activation. In addition
Arnault and Colleagues (2008) showed that caspases may be dispensable for
final oocyte death in mouse. In this study we used delphinidin chloride, the activator of GSH synthesis. Based on our findings, it seems that GSH synthesis
Experimental
groups
Oocytes
Matured
oocytes
Oocytes
for
TUNEL
Viable
oocytes
.........................................................................................
0.1 mg/ml
delphinidin
chloride (group 1)
217
202 (93.5%)
90
89
without
delphinidin
chloride (group 2)
215
175 (73.0%)
87
74
activators more effective than inhibitors of Caspase-3 activators in oocyte death
control.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This work was supported by Embryology
Department of Royan Institute.
Trial registration number: Our study wasn’t clinical trial
P-101 Correlation of the duration of the first cleavage cycle of embryos
with good quality blastocyst and implantation rates in single frozen-thawed
blastocyst transfer
S. Watanabe1, M. Kamihata1, T. Tanaka1, R. Matsunaga1, N. Yamanaka1, C. Kani1,
T. Ishikawa1, T. Wada1, H. Morita1, H. Miyamura2, E. Nishio2, M. Ito3, A. Kuwahata3,
M. Ochi3, and T. Horiuchi4
1
Ochi Yume Clinic Nagoya, ART lab., Nagoya, Japan, 2Fujita Health University
Hospital, Obstetrics and Gynecology, Toyoake, Japan, 3Ochi Yume Clinic
Nagoya, Reproductive Medicine, Nagoya, Japan, 4Prefectural University of
Hiroshima, Graduate School of Comprehensive Scientific Research, Shobara,
Japan
Study question: Is there any correlation of the first cleavage duration of embryos
with the success rate of obtaining good quality blastocysts and the implantation
rates in single frozen-thawed blastocyst transfer cycles?
Summary answer: There is a correlation between the duration of the first cleavage cycle of embryos and good quality blastocyst and implantation rates.
What is known already: It has been reported that there is a correlation between
the duration of the first cleavage cycle of an embryo and the formation of a viable
blastocyst.
Study design, size, duration: A retrospective study on 357 embryos from 182
cycles which were cultured to the blastocyst stage by using a time-lapse incubator
between July and October 2012.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: We recorded and analyzed the duration of the first cleavage of embryos by using a time-lapse incubator (EmbryoScope, Unisense Fertilitech, Denmark), to examine the correlation of the first
cleavage duration with the success rate of obtaining good quality blastocysts
and with the pregnancy rate in single frozen-thawed blastocyst transfer cycles.
Main results and the role of chance: Among the 357 normal fertilized embryos
cultured by using the ES, 124 (34.7%) were good quality blastocysts. The duration
of the first cleavage in the good blastocyst group and the non-good-quality blastocyst group (mean + SD) was 25.4 + 2.8 and 28.7 + 4.6 hours, respectively,
which showed a significant difference (P , 0.01). Seventy-three single
frozen-thawed blastocyst transfers were performed in the good blastocyst
group. The pregnancy rate of the group with a first cleavage duration of 24–25
hours (69.2%, 9 of 13) tended to be greater than that of the 20– 24 hours group
(44.4%, 12 of 27) (P ¼ 0.186), and significantly greater than that of the 25–35
hours group (27.3%, 9 of 33) (P , 0.05).
Limitations, reason for caution: None.
Wider implications of the findings: We confirmed that the duration of the first
cleavage cycle of embryos might be an effective parameter for ensuring viable
high- quality blastocysts for transfer.
Study funding/competing interest(s): No external funding was obtained for
this study.
Trial registration number: None.
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
Summary answer: Ultra rapid vitrification method of blastocysts using a cryoloop is a safe and valid method as a result of comparison between vitrified-thawed
blastocyst ET and fresh blastocyst ET cycles.
What is known already: Blastocyst transfer has become a promising option to get
the higher pregnancy rate, comparing with cleavage stage embryo transfer. Vitrification is expected to achieve a high rate of survival because of the absence of ice.
Vitrification has become the method to cryopreserve blastocysts.
Study design, size, duration: This is a retrospective analysis of clinical outcome
in 2,924 vitrified-thawed blastocyst ET cycles and 2,003 fresh blastocyst ET
cycles conducted for women under the age of 40 from 2002 to 2011.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: IVF and ICSI procedures were carried
out with sequential media. The protocol for the cryoloop vitrification of blastocysts from IVF/ICSI patients was adopted. Embryo transfers were performed
under ultrasound examination using a soft catheter.
Main results and the role of chance: The average embryo transfer number of
vitrified-thawed blastocyst transfer was significantly lower than that of fresh
blastocyst transfer (1.4 + 0.5 vs 1.5 + 0.6: P
Limitations, reason for caution: Long term follow-up of children from ultra
rapid vitrification method of blastocysts using a cryoloop, including motor and
psychological development, is recommended.
Wider implications of the findings: Ultra rapid cryoloop vitrification method
of blastocysts is easy-to use, safe and effective. Outcome of ultra rapid cryoloop
vitrification method of blastocysts is comparable with that of fresh blastocyst
transfer.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This study was not funded and there are no
conflicts of interest.
Trial registration number: n/a
Abstracts
i159
Abstracts
P-102
In vitro maturation does not affect the morphology of the metaphase II spindle in oocytes collected from antral follicles in IVM cycles
M. Dal Canto1, M.C. Guglielmo1, R. Fadini1, M. Mignini Renzini1, D.F. Albertini2,
P. Novara1, M. Lain1, F. Brambillasca1, D. Turchi1, M. Sottocornola1, and
G. Coticchio1
1
Biogenesi Reproductive Medicine Centre, Istituti Clinici Zucchi, Monza, Italy,
2
Department of Molecular and Integrative Physiology, University of Kansas
Medical Center, Kansas City, U.S.A
P-103
Effects of sperm concentration after swim-up on conventional in
vitro fertilization rates: Analysis of sperm motility using a sperm motility
analysis system
M. Kato 1, N. Fukunaga2, R. Nagai1, H. Kitasaka2, T. Yoshimura1, F. Tamura2,
N. Hasegawa1, K. Nakayama 2, M. Takeuchi2, H. Ohno2, N. Aoyagi 1, E. Kojima1,
F. Itoi3, Y. Hashiba4, and Y. Asada5
Asada Ladies Kachigawa Clinic, Laboratory, Aichi, Japan, 2Asada Ladies
Nagoya Clinic, Laboratory, Aichi, Japan, 3The Asada Institute for Reproductive
Medicine, Laboratory, Aichi, Japan, 4Asada Ladies Kachigawa Clinic, Doctor,
Aichi, Japan, 5Asada Ladies Nagoya Clinic, Doctor, Aichi, Japan
Study question: Does sperm concentration after swim-up affect fertilization rates
in conventional in vitro fertilization (C-IVF)?
Summary answer: It is thought that using a high concentration of spermatozoa
with motility after swim-up and high curve speed and head amplitude improve
the normal fertilization rate of C-IVF.
What is known already: In conventional in vitro fertilization, it is important to
improve the rate of normal fertilization. Our C-IVF procedure entails adjusting
the count to 200,000 spermatozoa after swim-up. However, there may be differences in some cases regarding the normal fertilization rate with our procedure,
and the reason for this is currently not clear. To address this problem, we used a
sperm motility analysis system (SMAS) for the first time in our clinic.
Study design, size, duration: Concentration of spermatozoa with motility after
swim-up was divided into two groups: not less than 1.0 × 106/ml and not more
than 2.0 × 106/ml (Group A); and not less than 2.1 × 106/ml and not more than
14.9 × 106/ml (Group B). Fertilization rates were compared in this retrospective
study.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: From January through May 2011, we
conducted a review of 524 cycles in 483 patients. In addition, we conducted a
review of 42 cycles in 42 patients between May 2012 and September 2012. The
motility rates of Group A and group B were analyzed via SMAS.
Main results and the role of chance: The normal fertilization rate of Group Awas
48%; that of Group B was 63.0%. Thus, the normal fertilization rate was significantly higher in Group B compared to Group A (P , /SSF . , 0.01). The rate
of abnormal fertilization (1PN, ≥3PN) of Group A was 6.1%; that of Group B
was 5.8%. With SMAS, the straight line speed, straight advancement, curve
speed, and head amplitude were 31.5 mm/s, 0.36, 96.1 mm/s, and 2.04 mm, respectively for Group A and 34.8 mm/s, 0.34, 112.5 mm/s, 2.68 mm, respectively
for Group B. Group B had a higher curve speed and head amplitude than Group A.
Limitations, reason for caution: These are preliminary data from a retrospective
analysis with a limited sample size.
Wider implications of the findings: Not determinable until further studies using
SMAS with a larger sample have been performed.
Study funding/competing interest(s): None.
Trial registration number: None.
P-104
Study of the most effective embryo transfer with blastocyst grade
H. Kikuchi, Y. Iwasa, T. Kamono, A. Suzuki, K. Yamada, H. Kanno, K. Sasaki,
H. Murakawa, M. Matsubara, and H. Yoshida
Yoshida Ladies Clinic, Center for Reproductive Medicine, Sendai, Japan
Study question: It has reported that blastocyst transfer is able to obtain better
result by synchronization with endometrium. However, depends on the situation,
such as priming egg retrieval or patient’s offer, it is necessary to screen the blastocyst for fresh transfer.
Summary answer: Regarding to blastocyst ICM and TE grade, grade A blastocyst
resulted in significantly high pregnancy rate in frozen-thawed cycle. It is proved
that frozen-thawed cycle is susceptible to improve the pregnancy rate by classification of grade. It is suggested that not only good embryos but inferior ones are
worth cryopreservation.
What is known already: Recently, the viability after thawing is getting remarkably high through the improvement of cryopreservation vitrification. It has
reported that blastocyst transfer is able to obtain better result by synchronization
with endometrium.
Study design, size, duration: We classified 141 cases (138 patients) in fresh cycle
and 673 cases (473 patients) in frozen-thawed cycle, which underwent single
blastocyst transfer from January 2010 through October 2012 in our clinic.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: We compared the clinical offspring
and abortion rate in fresh cycle and frozen-thawed cycle with Gardner’s classification which were Inner Cell Mass (ICM) and Trophectoderm (TE) cell numbers.
Main results and the role of chance: The patient mean age was 33.8 + 3.8 years
old in fresh cycle, 35.6 + 4.0 years old in frozen-thawed, so there was a significant
difference (P , 0.05). In the view of ICM grade, the pregnancy rate in
frozen-thawed cycle is significantly high in ICM grade A (P , 0.05) although
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
Study question: In vitro maturation (IVM) might affect the organization and function of the metaphase II (MII) spindle, compromising oocyte quality. The study
object was to assess comparatively the morphology of the MII spindle in
oocytes matured in vitro from IVM cycles and oocytes matured in vivo in stimulated cycles (IVO).
Summary answer: IVM does not alter the geometry of the MII spindle in human
oocytes recovered in IVM cycles matured in vitro. In addition, distribution of cortical actin appears to be polarized showing an accumulation in proximity of the
spindle, perhaps to ensure localization and anchorage of this cytoskeletal component.
What is known already: In the mouse, it is widely recognized that in vitro maturation can alter the structure of the oocyte MII spindle. This could have implications for chromatid segregation and embryo chromosome status. In the human, it
has been repeatedly reported that IVM oocytes may be affected by spindle anomalies, but such findings are questionable because were generated using a rather inappropriate model, i.e. leftover denuded germinal vesicle (GV) oocytes obtained
from conventional ovarian stimulation cycles.
Study design, size, duration: Fifty-nine IVO and 10 IVM oocytes were analysed.
No leftovers GV oocytes from stimulated cycles were included. Chromosomes
were classified as displaced or aligned at MII plate. Their internal and external arrangement was classified as two perfect rings or partially/totally disarranged. Cortical and cytoplasmic actin was also compared.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: IVO oocytes derived from women
undergoing conventional ovarian stimulation. IVM oocytes matured in vitro
from cumulus-oocyte complexes in the presence of FSH/HCG. Chromatin,
tubulin and actin were detected by fluorescence confocal microscopy. Spindles
were reconstructed as 3D images. P ,0.05 was adopted as criterion to consider
differences statistically significant.
Main results and the role of chance: The MII spindles of the two groups were
morphologically equivalent as shown by comparing pole-to-pole axis (11.8 +
2.6 mm in IVO vs. 12.0 + 2.3 mm in IVM oocytes), equatorial axis (8.9 +
1.7 mm in IVO vs. 8.6 + 1.5 mm in IVM oocytes), and area of maximum projection
(88.8 + 29.5 mm2 in IVO vs. 94.7 + 18.1 mm2 in IVM oocytes). Chromosome
alignment and internal/external disposition were not related to spindle characteristics. Proportions of normal chromosome arrangement were 64.5% and 60.0% in
IVO and IVM oocytes respectively. Signal intensity of cortical actin was higher
near the spindle, in both oocyte types. Conversely, the mean intensity of cytoplasmic
actin in IVM oocytes was higher than in IVO oocytes. (21.1 vs. 35.0).
Limitations, reason for caution: Data regarding IVM oocytes are numerically
limited and require further confirmation.
Wider implications of the findings: This is the first study focusing on spindle characteristics in oocytes obtained from normo-ovulatory patients undergoing IVM.
Data suggest that IVM conditions do not affect the structure of the MII spindle, disputing a widespread preconception. Moreover, this study introduces new criteria for
the analysis of chromosome arrangement and reveals a polarization of cortical actin.
Accumulation of cytoplasmic actin in immature oocytes suggests the basis for
futures studies aimed at understanding spindle morphogenesis during IVM.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This study was partly funded by the Italian
Ministry of Health. The authors declare to have no interests conflicting with the study.
Trial registration number: Not applicable
1
i160
no significant difference in fresh pregnancy cycle (P , 0.005). In the view of TE
grade, the pregnancy rate in frozen-thawed cycle is significantly high in TE grade
A (P , 0.025). As compared with each grade in same group, TE grade A has significantly high rate, and grade B was the following in frozen-thawed cycle though
no significant difference was observed in fresh cycle.
Limitations, reason for caution: None.
Wider implications of the findings: We suggested that the best way to improve
total pregnancy rate per oocyte pick-up is need to cryopreservation for effective
frozen-thawed cycle in case of good quality embryo was obtained, and then
perform fresh second grade embryo transfer.
Study funding/competing interest(s): No competing interest is declared.
Trial registration number: None.
Comparison of four techniques for artificial shrinkage of the
blastocoele cavity pre-vitrification
C. Valdespin1, M. Elhelaly2, P. Chen3, M. Pangestu3, and S. Catt3
Nascere, Reproductive Medicine, Mexico City, Mexico, 2Al-ahram Fertility
Center, Embryology, Mansoura, Egypt, 3Monash University, Obstetrics &
Gynecology, Melbourne, Australia
1
Study question: Pre-vitrification artificial shrinkage: are hyperosmotic solutions
as effective as laser pulse or micro-puncture techniques?.
Summary answer: Collapsing expanded mouse blastocysts prior to vitrification
by either laser, micro-puncture/suction or the hyperosmotic solutions: sucrose and
trehalose is associated with greater survival, expansion and hatching rates when
compared to non-collapsed controls. The novel use of trehalose provides an excellent low cost, low skill option with proven implantation.
What is known already: Improvements in survival and implantation rates of
expanded blastocysts have been demonstrated with laser pulse and micropuncture collapse, but these techniques require expensive equipment or advanced
skill sets. A simple hyperosmotic pre-vitrification collapsing technique using
sucrose has been tested successfully as an alternative method. We have postulated
that trehalose may be a superior sugar to use due to its membrane stabilization
properties.
Study design, size, duration: 367 expanded blastocysts were assigned to 5
groups: laser-pulse [LP], micro-puncture/suction [MS], use of trehalose previtrification [TPV], and use of sucrose pre-vitrification [SPV] and compared to
a control group (CG). 30 embryos/group were assigned for transfer (at 4h postwarm) to pseudo-pregnant female mice while the remaining blastocysts were cultured overnight.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Blastocysts were vitrified, using a
short protocol on Cryotops. Blastocysts were assessed prior to transfer for survival
and re-expansion (classed as .70% of blastocoel re-expanded) and then, for implantation on day 12 post-transfer. The remaining cultured blastocysts were evaluated for re-expansion, and hatching rates at 24h post-warm.
Main results and the role of chance: Overall 98.7% of all warmed blastocysts
survived as assessed at 4h, but ,50% were classed as re-expanded at transfer.
At 24h, re-expansion rates were higher for the combined collapsed groups
(82%, P , 0.05, Chi Square) compared to CG (66%), with TPVand LP exhibiting
the highest rates of expansion (87% and 82% respectively), and TSV and MS
slightly lower (80% and 76.3% respectively). Hatching rates were also higher
for the combined collapsed groups (40%, P , 0.05) compared to the control
(22%), with TVP and SVP having the highest rates (56.5% and 40% respectively),
compared to CG (P, 0.01 and p , 0.05 respectively). All five groups had at least
one blastocyst implant and the highest rate was 6/30 for TPV.
Limitations, reason for caution: Although we have demonstrated that collapsing
gives better outcomes and hyperosmotic treatments was successful, further studies
are required to examine these findings. Implantation was demonstrated but future
transfers would benefit from improved synchronization as, in this study, we transferred day 4.5 blastocysts into surrogate female mice 2.5 days after mating.
Wider implications of the findings: Vitrification has become the popular choice
for blastocyst preservation, and in general, studies have shown that the expanded
blastocyst benefits from collapse prior to vitrification. We have demonstrated that
passing through two hyperosmotic solutions, just prior to the equilibration step in
the vitrification process, can improve post-warm outcomes, particularly when trehalose is used. Thus, collapse can be performed cheaply and efficiently without
the need for specialized equipment or advanced technical skill.
Study funding/competing interest(s): No direct funding or competing interests.
Trial registration number: NA
P-106 Morphokinetics of embryos acquired from poor responders aged
40 years and above: comparison between natural and stimulated cycles
N. Hojnik, B. Kovacic, P. Roglic, M. Taborin, M. Zafosnik, J. Knez, and
V. Vlaisavljevic
University Medical Centre Maribor, Department of Reproductive Medicine and
Gynaecologic Endocrinology, Maribor, Slovenia
Study question: Is there a difference in morphokinetics of embryos derived from
natural cycles compared to stimulated cycles within the group of poor responders
aged ≥40 years?
Summary answer: There is no difference in morphokinetic parameters in group
of poor responders aged ≥40 years whether embryos derive from natural or stimulated cycles.
What is known already: In patients with previous unsuccessful IVF attempts
with hormonal stimulation of high dosages and low number of cells retrieved,
natural cycle is used as an alternative. Although the success of natural cycles in
this group of patients is relatively low, controlled ovarian hyperstimulation resulting in small number of oocytes might not be better choice. Our interest is to define
the quality of the embryos with the morphokinetic parameters.
Study design, size, duration: Prospective study included 42 poor-responder
patients, aged ≥40 years, treated in our center in year 2012. Natural cycles
group: 28 patients, 27 embryos for analysis. Stimulated cycles group: 14 patients,
23 embryos for analysis
Participants/materials, setting, methods
During 3-day cultivation pictures of embryos were taken in 5-minute intervals.
Timing of the appearance and disappearance of the pronuclei, the formation of the
cleavage furrow of the first and second mitosis and the beginning of the 2,3,4-cell
stage was monitored. Time intervals (TI) were compared with Mann-Whitney test.
Main results and the role of chance: TI from fertilization to disappearance of the
pronuclei (p ¼ 0,42), TI from fertilization to 1st cleavage furrow (p ¼ 0,9), TI
from fertilization to 2-cell stage (p ¼ 0,88), TI from 2-cell stage to 2nd cleavage
furrow (p ¼ 0,33), TI from 3-cell stage to 4-cell stage (p ¼ 0,14), TI from fertilization to 4-cell stage (p ¼ 0,19). We also compared the development (TI from
3-cell stage to 4-cell stage) of the subset of embryos without the occurence of aberrant or reverse divisions (14 embryo from the natural cycle group compared to
the 7 embryos from the stimulated group; p ¼ 0,09).
There seems to be no significant difference in morphokinetics of embryos from
the two groups studied.
Limitations, reason for caution: Selection of the treatment (natural/stimulated)
was done according to previous attempts and patient preferences. Nevertheless
both approaches seemed equally suitable for all patients. Small sample size
poses limitations of our study.
Wider implications of the findings: Our findings are in agreement with the literature that find the two approaches for treating poor responders comparable.
Study funding/competing interest(s): .
Trial registration number: .
P-107 Hydroxypropyl Cellulose as a novel cryoprotectant for oocyte/
embryo vitrification
C. Mori, A. Yabuuchi, K. Ezoe, Y. Takayama, F. Aono, and K. Kato
Kato Ladies Clinic, Advancedmedical Research Institute of Fertility, Tokyo,
Japan
Study question: To determine hydroxypropyl cellulose (HPC) serves as a substitute for serum substitute solution (SSS) as a novel cryoprotectant for oocyte/
embryo vitrification.
Summary answer: The use of HPC as a novel cryoprotectant is advantageous
with the higher embryo survival rate after vitrification.
What is known already: Despite the proposal toward designing chemically
defined media in human ART, SSS still has been supplemented widely in the vitrification solution.
HPC is an inert viscoelastic polymer, harmless and non-ionic water-soluble cellulose known as a material for food and medical-supply additive agent and also a
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
P-105
Abstracts
Abstracts
P-108
Morphokinetics and time-lapse technique as a predictor of embryo
development to the blastocyst stage
P. Radwan, R. Krasinski, K. Chorobik, and M. Radwan
Gameta Szpital, Department of Repoduction, Rzgów, Poland
Study question: Does the dynamic parameters of cell division assessed by timelapse analysis predicts selection of most viable embryos for embryotransfer ?
Summary answer: Adapted for embryology, the time lapse analysis enables the
continous monitoring of embryo development and observation of cell division abnormalities and can optimize the selection of most viable embryos for embryotransfer.
What is known already: The standard assessment of embryo morphology at
given time points not always allows to transfer the embryo with highest implantation potential. The effect of transfer of the improper embryo is the lack
of pregnancy or miscarriage and, as a consequence, exposure of patient to
unnecessary emotional stress and necessity to perform the frozen embryo
transfer
Study design, size, duration: Prospective cohort study. Development of
50 embryos was continuously monitored with the use of Primo Visio system
(Cryo Innovation, Hungary), with image acquisition every 10 minutes. January
2012- May 2012.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: The following parameters were
analysed: t2 – time after ICSI to the division to two cells; t3 - time after ICSI
to the division to three cells; t4 - time after ICSI to the division to four cells; t3
– t2 – time from division to two cells until division to three blastomeres; t4 –
t3 – time from division to three cells until division to four blastomeres.
Main results and the role of chance: The embryos developing to the blastocyst
stage reached the two cell stage earlier (25,94 +2,17 h vs 28,89 +3,75 h). The
time between division to 2 cells and subsequent division to three cells and the
time between three- and four cell stage were shorter comparing to the arrested
embryos (t3: 37,36 +2,55 h vs 42,09 +5,23 h; t4: 38,49 +2,63 h vs 42,93
+5,01 h). The time interwal between the two- and three cell stage (t3 – t2) in
case of embryos developing to the blastocyst stage was shorter. (11,42 +0,80 h
vs 13,20 +2,25 h). The direct transition of zygote to the three blastomere stage
or too short second cell cycle (t3 – t2), ,5h, was the negative predictive factor.
No difference in the duration of third cell cycle (t4 – t3) was observed (0,88
+0,80 h vs 0,84 +1,28 h).
Limitations, reason for caution: The study was not powered to test differences in
pregnancy rates
Wider implications of the findings: Adapted for embryology, the time-lapse analysis can optimize the selection of most viable embryos for embryotransfer.
Study funding/competing interest(s): No specific funding was obtained for this
study; it was solely funded by Gameta Ferility Center. None of the authors have
any economic affiliation.
Trial registration number: Not applicable.
P-109 Effect of early blastomere multinucleation on pre-implantation
developmental timings of human embryos
M. Stoppa1, R. Maggiulli1, A. Capalbo1, E. Ievoli 1, L. Dovere1, C. Scarica1,
L. Albricci1, S. Romano1, F. Sanges1, N. Barnocchi2, L. Papini2, A. Vivarelli1,
F.M. Ubaldi1, and L. Rienzi1
1
Genera Center for Reproductive Medicine, Clinica Valle Giulia, Rome, Italy,
2
Genera, Center for Reproductive Medicine, Umbertide (PG), Italy
Study question: The aim of the study was to evaluate whether or not the occurrence of blastomeres multinucleation may disturb the early developmental
events of preimplantation embryos.
Summary answer: We observed a different behavior in the early events of development of multinucleated embryos with respect to the sibling mononucleated
counterpart.
What is known already: The occurrence of blastomeres multinucleation may be
due to nuclear replication without cytokinesis, nuclear fragmentation or defective
migration at mitotic anaphase leading to errors in DNA packaging. Retrospective
analyses of human embryo development have previously showed an association of
multinucleation with impaired cleavage, increased incidence of aneuploidy and
low implantation rates in IVF cycles. Time-lapse cinematography has been recently applied in human IVF, as useful tool to optimize embryo assessment without
interfering with embryo growth.
Study design, size, duration: The influence of early blastomere multinucleation
on cleavage timing was retrospectively evaluated by comparing the developmental behavior of 114 sibling embryos. To avoid confounding factors, each embryo
showing multinucleation at 2-cell stage (MNBs group ¼ 38) was compared with
two randomly selected sibling embryos from the same cohort with mononucleated
blastomeres (NBs group ¼ 76).
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Microinjected oocytes were cultured
in a time-lapse incubation system (Embryoscope, Unisense). Early events of development (timing of pronuclear appearance, syngamy, 1st to 7th cell division
and cell cycle duration) were monitored and recorded. Multinucleation was
assessed as the presence of two or more nuclei in both blastomeres, at 2-cells stage.
Main results and the role of chance: Embryonic cohorts of 32 patients (mean
female age ¼ 35.8 + 3.5) containing at least one MNB embryo and two randomly
selected sibling NB embryos were evaluated. We observed a different behavior of
multinucleated embryos with respect to the sibling mononucleated counterpart.
The median time value of third (T3) cell cycle was found to be significantly different between NBs (T3 ¼ 37.5 + 4.7, CI:36.4-38.7) and MNBs group (T3 ¼
40.4 + 4.2, CI:39.0-41.9) (p ¼ 0.003). No significant difference in the median
time value of first (T2), third (T4), fourth (T5), seventh (T8) cell cycle was highlighted, although the MNBs group showed consistently slower cleavage timings
(T2 ¼ 28.3 + 3.3, CI:27.2-29.3, T4 ¼ 41.3 + 4.4, CI ¼ 39.8-42.8; T5 ¼
51.4 + 8.5,CI:48.4-54.4, T8 ¼ 61.1 + 7.4,CI:58.2-63.9) compared to the NBs
group (T2 ¼ 27.7 + 3.8, CI:26.8-28.6, T4 ¼ 40.0 + 4.9, CI ¼ 38.8-41.2; T5 ¼
49.8 + 6.9,CI:48.1-51.5, T8 ¼ 59.2 + 10.7,CI:56.6-61.9).
Limitations, reason for caution: The main limitation of the study is the rather low
number of embryos enrolled (N ¼ 114).
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
free-water retentive polymer which may acts as cryoprotectant of the vitrification
solution.
Study design, size, duration: Inbred and hybrid mouse blastocysts with/without
zona pellucid (ZP) with different cryoresistance (inbred: C57BL/6J, n ¼ 80,
hybrid: C57BL/6JxDBA/2, n ¼ 30) were selected. Generally, hybrid embryos
show better freezing tolerance than inbred. Embryos were vitrified/thawed in
HPC or SSS supplemented solution with Cryotop and there survival rates were
compared using a cell viability assay kit.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: 2-cell embryos were collected from
superovulated mice and cultured in KSOM media (37C, 5%CO2, 95% Air) for 4
days to obtain blastocyts. ZP-free blastocysts were obtained by the treatment
with acid tyrode’s solution. The survival rate of these blastocysts vitrified/
thawed in HPC (1%/vol) or SSS (1%/vol) solutions was assessed.
Main results and the role of chance: The rate of blastocyst development in inbred
(C57BL/6) and hybrid (C57BL/6JxDBA/2: B6D2F1) 2-cell embryos was 85.3%
and 86.8%, respectively. The survival rate of inbred blastocysts with ZP was significantly higher in HPC 83.4% (121/145) than in SSS 50% (70/140), whereas in
hybrid blastocysts, the survival rate in both HPC and SSS was 100% (32/32 in
HPC, 33/33 in SSS). The survival rate of ZP free inbred blastocysts in HPC and
SSS was 67.9% (38/56) and 19.6% (9/46), respectively. The survival rate was significantly higher in HPS than SSS when embryos with less freezing tolerance
(inbred blastocysts, ZP blastocysts) were selected. In addition, we observed the
stickiness of different blastocysts to the Cryotop using HPC and SSS. When
using SSS, the blastocyst stuck to the Cryotop, but when using HPC it didn’t
stick at all.
Limitations, reason for caution: The limitation of this work was the use of animal
model only. Monitoring of outcomes with human embryos vitrified/thawed in
HPC supplemented solution is imperative to convince the safety and efficacy
for transferring in the clinical settings.
Wider implications of the findings: We demonstrated that HPC is advantageous
with higher survival rates of blastocysts even without ZP revealing that HPC is an
effective cyroprotectant as a substitute for SSS. We also observed that HPC overcame the stickiness of embryos during the thawing procedure suggesting that HPC
may minimize technical complications. Our study shows that the use of HPC as a
cryoprotectant will be applicable and would be a standard agent in human ART.
Study funding/competing interest(s): The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest in the research.
Trial registration number: N/A
i161
i162
Wider implications of the findings: We identified distinctive early cleavage
timing ranges for mononucleated and multinucleated embryos. When continuous
monitoring of embryo development cannot be performed, the choice of the best
embryo to transfer usually relies on the static evaluation of morphological
aspect of the embryo. According to confidence intervals observed in our
dataset, the persistence of 3-cell stage later than 39.0 hours post insemination suggests the occurrence of blastomere multinucleation at 2-cell stage.
Study funding/competing interest(s): none
Trial registration number: none
P-110
Human embryo aneuploidies cannot be predicted by morphokinetic assessment during the first phases of in vitro culture
F. Fiorentino2
Genera c/o Clinica Valle Giulia, Reproductive Medicine, Roma, Italy, 2Genoma,
Molecular biology, Roma, Italy, 3IVIOMICS, Molecular Cytogenetics Lab,
Valencia, Spain
1
Study question: The aim of our study was to evaluate the reliability of morphokinetic assessments in predicting embryo aneuploidies as assessed by array comparative genomic hybridization (aCGH).
Summary answer: No correlation has been found between morphokinetics variables and embryo aneuploidies.
What is known already: Preimplantation genetic screening (PGS) has been
introduced in IVF to avoid the transfer of aneuploid embryos. However, PGS is
an invasive procedure, technically challenging that requires embryo extramanipulation and thus potentially detrimental. For this reason there is an imperative search for new non-invasive techniques able to identify healthy embryos in a
reliable way. Time lapse cinematography and embryo morphokinetic assessments
is a promising approach. This technology has been recently correlated with significant improvements in pregnancy rate.
Study design, size, duration: Embryos were individually monitored by time
lapse cinematography (Embryoscope, Unisense). Subsequently, biopsy and
chromosomal screening by aCGH (Bluegnome, UK) were performed either at
day 3 (N ¼ 137) or at day 5 (N ¼ 158). Finally, embryos were categorized as
euploid (group1), single aneuploid (group 2) or complex aneuploid (≥errors,
group 3).
Participants/materials, setting, methods: 295 embryos from 64 PGS patients
were enrolled. Morphokinetic variables assessed were: timing of pronuclear formation (PN), 2-cells (T2), 3-cells (T3), 4-cells (T4), 5-cells (T5) and 8-cells (T8)
divisions, length of the second cell cycle (cc2) and the synchrony in the division
from two to four cells (s2).
Main results and the role of chance: 83/295 (28.1%), 69/295 (23.4%), and 143/
295 (48.5%) embryos were euploid or had single or multiple aneuploidies, respectively. No statistically significant differences were observed for all the variables analyzed. The timings of PN formation were: 12.09 (CI 11,56-12,63)
11,50 (CI 11,00-12,01) and 11,97 (CI11,56-12,39), of T2: 26,37 (CI
25,73-27,02), 26.69 (CI 25,89-27,49) and 27,00 (CI 26,40-27,61), of T3: 37,24
(CI 35,98-38,49), 36,60 (CI 34,96-38,25) and 37,46 (CI 36,45-38,47), of T4:
39,07 (CI 38,22-39,91), 39,04 (CI 37,80-40,28) and 39,99 (CI 38,94-41,04), of
T5: 49,97 (CI 47,81-52,13), 48,94 (CI 46,61-51,28) and 51,72 (50,31-52,12),
of T8: 53,05 (CI 48,92-57,18), 54,68 (CI 49,67-59,69) and 56,52 (CI
53,23-59,81) in group 1, 2, and 3, respectively (NS). No significant differences
were also found for cc2 and s2 variables. Irregular cell divisions (transition
from 1- to 3- and 2- to 5- cell stage) were observed in 2/83 euploid embryos
(2,4%), 0/69 (0%) single aneuploid embryos and 5/143 (3,4%) multiple aneuploid
ambryos (NS). Finally, direct cleavage (second cell division in less than 4 hours)
was found in 3/83 (3,6%), 9/69 (13,0%) and 9/143 (6,3%) embryos in group 1, 2
and 3, respectively (NS).
Limitations, reason for caution: A relatively low number of euploid embryos
were transferred (52). For this reason it has been impossible to compare the behavior of implanted (22) vs non implanted euploid embryos (30). It cannot be
excluded that extending the observations up to day 5 some correlations between
morphokinetics behavior and aneuploidies could be found.
Wider implications of the findings: Embryo behavior in the first 3 days of in
vitro culture is not useful to select embryos for chromosomal aneuploidies.
What remains to be understood is if morphokinetics assessment may provide
an effective tool in determining embryo developmental competence and
thus be helpful in optimizing euploid embryo selection in combination to
PGS approach.
Study funding/competing interest(s): none
Trial registration number: none
P-111 Cleavage and blastocyst development rate is diminished and sex
ratio is shifted by oocyte exposure to bisphenol A in Bos taurus
J. Ferris, L.A. Favetta, N. MacLusky, and W.A. King
University of Guelph, Biomedical Sciences, Guelph, Canada
Study question: The primary objective of the current study is to evaluate the
effects of bovine oocyte exposure to bisphenol A (BPA) on embryo cleavage
and blastocyst development rates, as well as the sex ratio of resulting embryos surviving to blastocyst.
Summary answer: In comparison to various controls, oocyte exposure to BPA
during maturation resulted in a decrease in cleavage and blastocyst rates, and a
higher proportion of female embryos in comparison to multiple controls.
What is known already: Optimal hormone levels are important for the occurrence and maintenance of a successful pregnancy. BPA, an endocrine disrupting
chemical, can have detrimental effects on fertility and reproductive success,
having been linked to reproductive issues such as reduced in vitro fertilization
(IVF) success in humans and recurrent miscarriage. Feminization of males and
a sex skew towards females have been found in fish and amphibia in vivo as a
result of early exposure to BPA.
Study design, size, duration: Oocytes were matured in in vitro maturation media
under various conditions. Controls included no-treatment, vehicle and estradiol
controls. Treatment group media were supplemented with BPA (3 and 30 mg/
mL). Blastocysts were collected at day 8 post fertilization, treated briefly with
pronase to remove the zona pellucida and frozen individually.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Standard IVF was completed following maturation. Cleavage was calculated at 2 days post-fertilization (dpf) and
blastocyst rate at 8dpf. PCR was used to lyse blastocysts and positive controls,
and amplify TSPY and GAPDH. Embryos displaying GAPDH and TSPY bands
were deemed male; GAPDH without TSPY band were deemed female.
Main results and the role of chance: Cleavage rates in the 30 mg/mL BPA treatment group were significantly lower compared to both the no-treatment and
vehicle controls (p ¼ 0.0297 and p ¼ 0.0049 respectively, Fisher’s exact, twotailed). The number of cultured embryos to reach blastocyst were significantly
lower in the 30 mg/mL BPA treatment group compared to the no-treatment and
vehicle controls (p ¼ 0.0087 and p ¼ 0.0035 respectively, Fisher’s exact, twotailed). There is a trend showing that oocyte treatment with high BPA results in
a higher number of females surviving to blastocyst (80% females compared to
54% in the no-treatment control, p ¼ 0.0872, Fisher’s exact, two-tailed). All
results are dose-dependent with the high BPA, but not low BPA, treatment
showing significant decreases in cleavage and blastocyst rates and a trend
towards increased number of female embryos.
Limitations, reason for caution: The sexing analysis is limited by the number of
embryos analyzed; between 25 to 45 embryos per group. Additional analyses are
underway to increase sample size. Analyses were conducted solely in vitro using
Bos taurus. Fertility and mortality rates are underway using Onchorynchus mykiss
under the same treatment conditions.
Wider implications of the findings: BPA supplementation to maturation media
resulted in a significant and dose-dependent decrease in cleavage and blastocyst
rates, and a trend towards a female sex skew. These results suggest that bovine
oocyte exposure to BPA can compromise the resulting embryo’s early developmental competence, and influence sex ratio of surviving blastocysts. Considering
the high prevalence of human exposure, these results may provide insight
into oocyte viability of reproductive aged women who are regularly exposed
to BPA.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This research was funded by the Natural
Sciences and Engineering Research Council (Canada), with no competing
interests.
Trial registration number: N/A
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
L. Rienzi1, S. Bono2, A. Capalbo1, L. Spizzichino2, C. Rubio3, F.M. Ubaldi1, and
Abstracts
Abstracts
P-112
The impact of laser-assisted hatching (LAH) on clinical outcome of
assisted reproduction technology and the role of maternal age
T. Madani, N. Jahangiri, and R. Aflatoonian
Department of Endocrinology and Female Infertility at Reproductive Biomedicine
Research Center, Royan Institute for Reproductive Biomedicine, ACECR, Tehran,
Iran
P-113
Retrospective analysis of clinical outcome of vitrified blastocyst
post thaw using time-lapse imaging and standard incubation
E. Cater 1, D. Hulme1, K. Berrisford1, L. Jenner1, A. Campbell2, and S. Fishel1
1
CARE Fertility, Embryology, Nottingham, United Kingdom, 2CARE Fertility,
Embryology, Manchester, United Kingdom
Study question: Does a continuous incubation (ES), Embryoscope, (Unisense
Fertilitech) environment and time-lapse imaging improve the clinical outcome
of blastocyst transfer post thaw compared to standard incubation (SI)?
Summary answer: Blastocysts incubated in a continuous environment have an
improved chance of pregnancy and significantly improved clinical outcome compared to SI. Time-lapse imaging may give more information but as yet does not
appear to contribute to the increased outcome.
What is known already: Many papers such as Kirkegaard K. et al (2012) and
Meseguer, M. et al (2012) report a significant increase in clinical outcome in comparison to SI.
Time-lapse imaging has also been used to investigate embryo morphokinetics
(I. Rubio, 2012), prognostic markers of viability (J. Herrero, 2012) and the
impact of ploidy on embryo development (A Campbell 2012,2013).
However, little evidence is documented regarding the use of continuous incubation and time-lapse imaging for embryos post thaw.
Study design, size, duration: 96 vitrified/ warmed day 5/ 6 blastocyst cycles from
July to October 2012 were included in the data analysis. Group A (n ¼ 52, average
maternal age 36.3 + /-3.99) were cultured in a standard incubator (HeraCell) and
Group B (n ¼ 44, average maternal age 32.2 ¼ /-5.58) in a continuous time-lapse
incubator.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Embryos were warmed as per protocol. Retrospective analysis examined the achievement of an embryo transfer
(ET), positive bhCG, presence of a foetal heart (FH) per embryo(s) transferred,
clinical pregnancy (CP), time of re-expansion and time of full recovery. Two
tailed Fishers exact test will be used to assess significance.
Main results and the role of chance: 88.5% (46/52) of Group A achieved an ET.
39.1% had a positive bhCG/ET (18/46) and 21.7% (10/46) a CP/ET. Of the 56
embryos transferred, 12 (21.4%) achieved FH, with an average of 1.22
embryos/ET.
88.6% (39/44) of Group B achieved an ET. 59.0% (23/39) achieved a positive
bhCG/ETand 46.2% (18/39) a CP/ET. FH/embryo transferred was 34.0% (16/47)
with an average of 1.02 embryos/ET.
CP rate was found to be significantly greater in Group B (p ¼ 0.0215). All other
comparisons were non significant.
In Group B, embryos that implanted were found to begin re-expansion (average
0.95hrs) and be fully recovered (average 1.35hrs) faster than those that didn’t
(re-expansion begins, average 2.82 hrs, fully recovered 3.35hrs. Time lapse
imaging played no role in embryo selection for transfer.
Limitations, reason for caution: The decision to culture in the ES or SI was based
on availability of the ES rather than randomisation. Culture dishes varied between
Group A and B and there is a difference in age between the groups. These factors
cannot be dismissed as contributory.
Wider implications of the findings: The use of uninterrupted culture is considered likely to increase implantation in most fresh culture cycles but the data presented suggests that it also has a role in increasing the outcome of frozen
embryo replacements, allowing the thaw and transfer of a single blastocyst to
maximise positive outcome and minimise multiple births.
To assess this further, we propose a randomised study to eliminate the limitations above.
Study funding/competing interest(s): None
Trial registration number: None
P-114 Minimal waste of healthy human embryos due to chromosomal
mosaicism
X.Y. Zhang, A. Yilmaz, H. Hananel, and A. Ao
McGill University Health Center, Obstetrics and Gynecology, Montreal QC,
Canada
Study question: What is the extent and clinical relevance of chromosomal mosaicism in the ’spare’ preimplantation embryos (i.e., embryos that are found to be unsuitable for freezing or transfer based on the results of chromosome screening
performed on a single blastomere).
Summary answer: Only 3.5% of the 454 embryos were mosaic which had sufficient quality grade, not arrested, and thus, expected to implant if transferred.
What is known already: Previous studies have shown that the presence of over
38% abnormal cells in mosaic embryos is detrimental and prevent implantation.
However, the extent of mosaicism that may result in healthy births in spare preimplantation human embryos in the literature is subject to controversy.
Study design, size, duration: The embryos were collected from 122 patients in
148 preimplantation genetic screening cycles performed at a hospital-based reproductive center from January 2006 to March 2011. The embryos were analyzed on
day 4 or 5 post-insemination.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Fluorescent in situ hybridization
(FISH) procedure for chromosomes 13, 15, 16, 17, 18, 21, 22, X and Y was
used to determine chromosomal complement in each of the 5,455 nuclei obtained
from 454 spare embryos.
Main results and the role of chance: 165 of the 454 spare embryos (36.3%) were
developmentally arrested. 26.1% (43/165) of the arrested and 24.6% of the nonarrested (70/ 284) embryos had over 38% diploid cells. However, only 16 of these
454 (3.5%) embryos were mosaic, not arrested and were of good quality,
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
Study question: This study was considered for further assessment of the LAH for
promoting implantation and evaluating impact of maternal age on the embryonic
hatching.
Summary answer: Zona thickness appears to be impacted by a woman’s age, and
LAH procedure seems to be effective in improving pregnancy and implantation
rates in patients with advanced female age.
What is known already: Despite great effort, there is still debate among scientists
about the reported benefits of AH.
Study design, size, duration: This retrospective cross-sectional study was conducted from December 2010 until March 2012 at the Reproductive Biomedicine
Research Center. The total number of patients entered in this study was 273 in the
study group (LAH was performed) and 434 in the control group (LAH was not performed).
Participants/materials, setting, methods: The participants were women aged
20-45 years undergoing IVF or ICSI using their own gametes with history of ≤
3 ART cycles. LAH was performed on cleavage stage fresh embryos and the outcomes were compared with the intact control group. These two groups were further
subdivided into women of advanced age (.36 y) and younger (≤ 36).
Main results and the role of chance: The developmental rate of embryos at different stages and also rate of women with male factor infertility were comparable in
both groups. With respect to age, our data showed that LAH is of no benefit in
women ≤ 36 years of age. As the chemical pregnancy and clinical pregnancy
rates after LAH were insignificantly lower among women aged ≤ 36 years in
the study group compared to control group (32.5% vs. 39.2%, P ¼ 0.131;
31.3% vs. 36.4%, P ¼ 0.249). However the only statistically significant difference
observed in implantation rate (16.5% vs. 23.2%, P ¼ 0.005). In women aged over
36 years, the chemical pregnancy, clinical pregnancy and implantation rates were
higher in the study group than controls, but these differences were not statistically
significant (29% vs. 6.3%, P ¼ 0.053, 21.5% vs. 6.3%, P ¼ 0.193 and 9.9% vs.
2.8%, P¼ 0.162 respectively).
Limitations, reason for caution: Wider implications of the findings: Some investigators introduce this method as
a routine plan in ART, whilst others do not. No published studies recommend AH
for younger women. Some researchers also claim that LAH of embryos is effective
in improving the pregnancy and implantation rates of women with advanced maternal age. These disputes may be related to the type of AH and quality and stage of
embryos selected for AH technique.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This study has .
Trial registration number: This study is a retrospective study.
i163
i164
P-115 Near-equilibrium rapid freezing versus cryotop vitrification of
2-cell mouse embryos
T. Vutyavanich, W. Piromlertamorn, U. Saenganan, and S. Samchimchom
Chiang Mai university, Obstetrics and Gynecology Faculty of medicine, Chiang
Mai, Thailand
Study question: We aimed to develop a novel method of freezing that combines
the advantages of both the non-equilibrium vitrification and slow equilibrium
freezing.
Summary answer: Our method gave comparable results to vitrification in terms
of embryo survival and developmental competence. The method is user friendly,
and allows fast and simple cryopreservation of embryos in a large volume of cryoprotectants in a closed container.
What is known already: Slow cooling and vitrification are the most commonly
used methods for cryopreservation. Vitrification can be done rapidly and achieves
a high survival rate of embryos, without the need of a programmable freezing.
However, it is time and operator dependent. Slow freezing, on the other hand,
can be done in a closed container, and the volume and time of exposure to cryoprotectants, as well as the thawing speed, are not as critical as the vitrification
method.
Study design, size, duration: Mouse 2-cell embryos (n ¼ 723) were divided into
controls (n ¼ 211), vitrification (n ¼ 192) and near-equilibrium rapid freezing
(n ¼ 320) groups in a ratio of 1:1:1.5. After one week of storage in liquid nitrogen,
embryos were warm/thawed and culture up to the blastocyst stage.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Embryos were exposed to 10% EG,
5% PROH, 0.2M trehalose in PBS for five minutes, loaded into sealed straws,
and inserted into holes inside an aluminum cylinder, pre-cooled in liquid nitrogen.
They were thawed at 37oC in serial dilutions of Trehalose. In another group,
embryos were vitrified/warmed using Cryotop kits.
Main results and the role of chance: The survival, further cleavage, and blastocyst formation rate of 2-cell mouse embryos in both groups was comparable by
Chi-squared tests (98.8% vs. 96.4%, P ¼ 0.06; 94.9 vs. 95.1%, P ¼ 1.00; and
86.7% vs. 88.1%, P ¼ 0.67 in the rapid freezing and vitrification groups, respectively, but further cleavage and blastocyst formation was lower than those in the
controls (99.1% and 98.1%, P , 0.05). There was no significant difference
(ANOVA tests) in the average number of inner cell mass (35.5 + 7.2, 36.2 +
6.4 and 35.8 + 5.6: P ¼ 0.856), trophectoderm cells (50.9 + 9.3, 52.1 + 9.9
and 53.2 + 6.4: P ¼ 0.293), and total cells (86.4 + 15.2, 88.3 + 14.8 and
88.9 + 10.4: P ¼ 0.228) in blastocysts in the rapid freezing, vitrification and
control groups, respectively.
Limitations, reason for caution: Another study is now underway to transfer
frozen/thawed embryos into pseudo-pregnant mice to evaluate the implantation
and pregnancy rates. We also plan to employ this freezing protocol on discarded
human embryos, as data obtained from the mouse might not be directly applicable
to the human.
Wider implications of the findings: We postulated that this novel method created
a “hybrid” condition, i.e. the co-existence of small ice crystals interspersed among
the vitrified extracellular fluid, in contrast to the presence of large ice crystals in
slow freezing or the total absence of any ice crystal in vitrification. The method
requires lower cooling and warming rates, and the volume is not critical. It is
equally effective, but less demanding and easier to perform than the current vitrification techniques.
Study funding/competing interest(s): The funding was provided by the Faculty
of Medicine Endowment Fund for Medical Research, Chiang Mai University. The
authors declared s that could influence the study results.
Trial registration number: (Not applicable)
P-116
Aseptic oocyte vitrification to circumvent oocyte aging as strategy
when semen sample production is delayed
B. Wirleitner1, B. Lejeune2, N.H. Zech1, and P. Vanderzwalmen2
IVF-Centers Prof. Zech-Bregenz GmbH, Bregenz, Austria, 2Centre Hospitalier
Inter Regional Cavell, (CHIREC), Braine-l’Alleud, Belgium
1
Study question: When production of the semen sample on the day of oocyte
pick-up (OPU) is delayed or impossible, e.g. due to erectile dysfunction or azoospermia, aging of oocytes becomes a matter. The efficiency of a rescue strategy
where oocytes are vitrified and warmed when sperm collection is possible was
tested.
Summary answer: Our results show that in all centers with a good, standardized
protocol, aseptic oocyte cryopreservation can safely be applied in cases of unexpended failure of sperm production.
What is known already: Although several articles deal with the efficiency of
oocyte vitrification using open vitrification devices in donor cycles, still little is
known about vitrification in closed aseptic conditions and its application in standard IVF-patients. To apply the oocyte vitrification technique on a larger scale and
lift its experimental label, it is important also to test its efficiency, especially of the
aseptic closed devices, on our daily clientele in routine IVF-work.
Study design, size, duration: This retrospective study included 56 IVF-cycles
where aseptic oocyte vitrification was performed due to absence of sperm production at least 3 hours after OPU during January - December 2011.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: In all cycles no sperm was retrieved
until 3 hours after the OPU. Oocytes were vitrified in a closed vitrification
device (VitriSafe) ensuring aseptic conditions during vitrification and storage.
After sperm retrieval in a subsequent cryo-cylce, oocytes were warmed and fertilized. As main outcome live-birth rate was evaluated.
Main results and the role of chance: For 56 patients 455 oocytes were vitrified of
which 416 were fertilized after warming and ICSI/IMSI. The cleavage rate on day
3 was 95.3%. Embryo transfer was performed on day 5 (blastocyst selection). An
ongoing pregnancy rate of 43.8% and a birth rate of 35.7% was obtained and 26
healthy babies were born. These results are encouraging, especially as mean
age of women in this study was 34.5 years and sperm parameter were very
poor. The additionally safety and efficiency of aseptic vitrification (i.e. reducing
the risks of contamination and increasing the viability after warming) during
cooling and storage turn this strategy in to the focus not only when its application
is inevitable but also when sperm parameters are very poor (e.g. after recent infections).
Limitations, reason for caution: Although baby-take-home rates and health of
babies born do not give any reason for concern, a long-time follow-up will be necessary to exclude any later appearing health problems originating from the
applied techniques.
Wider implications of the findings: In contrast to earlier findings, we report very
high efficiency of aseptic vitrification in closed carriers. The reduced cooling rates
in closed carriers as compared to open devices can be overcome by a slightly modified vitrification protocol. Aseptic vitrification achieves the same warming rates as
open devices and thereby ensures high survival rates.
Study funding/competing interest(s): None
Trial registration number: None
P-117
Sequential versus single step media in a time lapse system: is there
a difference in pregnancy rate?
E. Albani, V. Parini, A. Smeraldi, F. Menduni, R. Antonacci, A. Marras, S. Levi,
G. Morreale, B. Pisano, A. Di Biase, A. Di Rosa, and P.E. Levi Setti
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
suggesting that they had the potential to implant. Percentage of diploid cells in the
non-arrested spare embryos were not associated with changes in maternal age,
number of cumulus oocyte complexes (COC) collected, or the number of chromosomally normal embryos obtained per cycle. Pearson’s coefficients for the correlations of percent diploid cells with the maternal age (r ¼ -0.10), number of COC
collected (r ¼ 0.10), and number of normal embryos obtained per cycle (r ¼
0.07) were all small.
Limitations, reason for caution: Only nine pairs of chromosomes were analyzed
in this study. Screening of a larger number of chromosomes may detect mosaicism
rates higher than those found in our study. FISH has an error rate of 5 to 7% resulting from inaccuracy of probe hybridization.
Wider implications of the findings: Only 3.5% of the non-arrested mosaic spare
embryos analyzed in this study had over 38% diploid cells, were of sufficient
quality, and thus, had the potential to implant if transferred. These results are in
agreement with some of the previous publications reporting less than 5% of misdiagnosis due to mosaicism in spare embryos using FISH. These results suggest
that waste of healthy human embryos due to mosaicism after chromosome screening is minimal.
Study funding/competing interest(s): N/ATrial registration number N/A
Abstracts
Abstracts
IRCCS Istituto Clinico Humanitas, Department of Gynecology Division of
Gynecology and Reproductive Medicine, Rozzano, Italy
P-118
Reverse phase protein array (RPPA): a new approach for the
identification of cumulus cells biomarkers of oocyte quality
V. Puard1, V. Cadoret2, T. Tranchant2, C. Gauthier2, E. Reiter 2, F. Guérif1, and
D. Royère1
1
CHRU Tours - Hôpital Bretonneau, GYN-OBS 1 REPRODUCTION, Tours
Cedex 1, France, 2INRA, UMR85 Physiologie de la Reproduction et des
Comportements, Nouzilly, France
Study question: We proposed to evaluate the Reverse Phase Protein Array
(RPPA) to detect and analyze potential biomarkers related to oocyte developmental competence through a non-invasive procedure involving each individual
cumulus (CCs) in human.
Summary answer: Reverse Phase Protein Array allowed us to detect specific proteins at a level as low as the equivalent of one cell of one human cumulus.
What is known already: Morphological criteria are mostly used in ART laboratories but remain poorly predictive of embryo potential to develop. Various approaches
involving transcriptomics, proteomics, and metabolomics on the embryo or its cellular or non cellular environment have been proposed. RPPA is a sensitive and quantitative technique which allowed the detection of specific proteins in very low
quantities of biological samples to help clinical management of cancer.
Study design, size, duration: Six patients undergoing intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) for male infertility from January to May 2012 were included in this
study. Thirteen human individual cumulus from 4 patients and a pool of 16
cumulus from 2 patients were collected during ICSI procedure.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: The expression of the targeted proteins was suppressed by siRNA in HEK293 and the antibodies used for RPPA
were validated by correlating the signal observed by Western Blot (WB) and
RPPA. Proteins were detected in a pool of cells of 16 cumulus, then in 13 individual
cumulus.
Main results and the role of chance: Specificity of antibodies targeting the proteins of interest was assessed by WB. The expression of 4 proteins was partly suppressed in HEK293 cells by siRNA. The correlation of knockdown efficiencies of
the VCL and SRC proteins between WB and RPPA validated the antibodies for
RPPA used. We detected in cells of a pool of 16 cumulus the proteins VCL,
SRC and ERK2 at the level of less than one equivalent cell of one cumulus.
Then, these proteins were detected at the same sensibility in individual
cumulus. No correlation was observed for the antibody targeting RGS2 and led
us to reject it for RPPA used. Therefore, validation the antibodies is a crucial
step for RPPA used and its application for biomarkers identification.
Limitations, reason for caution: Antibody validation remains a challenging
problem for RPPA. While suppressing the expression of the proteins by siRNA approach is efficiency, this technique required heavy development. Overexpression
the proteins in HEK293 cells might be an interesting alternative for high throughput validation.
Wider implications of the findings: Once validated antibodies targeting potential
biomarkers of oocyte quality at protein level and assessed their robustness by
taking into account the patient variability, RPPA might be used in ART laboratory.
Indeed RPPA is a sensitive, high throughput, cost and material effective technique
which might be used to predict the developmental ability and implantation of the
embryos in ART laboratory to increase single embryo transfer and limit multiple
pregnancies.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This work was supported by Merck
Serono Grant for Fertility Innovation Award 2010.
Trial registration number: -
P-119 Abnormal distribution of type 1 Inositol 1,4,5 tri-phosphate receptor in fertilization failed human eggs
S.Y. Yoon, J.H. Eum, E.A. Park, T.Y. Kim, T.K. Yoon, D.R. Lee, and W.S. Lee
CHA University, Department of Biomedical Science, Seoul, Korea South
Study question: IP3R1 is a key protein to induce intracellular Ca2+-oscillation
during fertilization. Does fertilization failed human eggs have normal IP3R1
distribution?
Summary answer: Fertilization failed human eggs showed abnormal IP3R1 distribution including inconsistent clusters in cytoplasm instead of cortical clusters.
What is known already: The capacity of [Ca2+]i oscillation is acquired during
egg maturation and coincides with an increase in the sensitivity of the IP3R1
and their localization in cytoplasm. Cluster formation of IP3R1 in the egg
cortex is important to initiation of [Ca2+]I oscillations during egg and sperm
fusion.
Study design, size, duration: Immunofluorescence analysis of IP3R1 in in vitro
matured egg, fertilization failed egg and tripronuclear human eggs.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Patients enrolled in the assisted reproduction program at the Fertility Center of CHA Gangnam Medical Center were
participated with written consent in this study. Total 62 eggs (GV, 8 eggs; NF 42
eggs, 3PN; 12 eggs) were immunostained with anti IP3R1 antibody, and examined
with a confocal laser-scanning microscope.
Main results and the role of chance: Distribution of IP3R1 in human eggs
change gradually from GV stage to MII stage. In GV stage, most of the eggs
shows progressively disperse from GV to cortex. In MII stage, 6 out of 8 eggs
have that IP3R1 distributed in whole cytoplasm including clusters which is
more 3 ≏ 6um in diameter on the cortex. After fertilization, in PN stage with
3PN, most of the eggs have IP3R1distribution with gradually disperse from PN
to cortex, but they do not have cortical clusters. In fertilization failed MII eggs
on the next morning post fertilization, more than 50% of eggs have several
IP3R1 aggregates in the middle of the cytoplasm, which is more than 10um in
diameter instead of cortical clusters as in MII.
Limitations, reason for caution: The low numbers of human eggs analysed may
not be ideal for conclusive statistical analysis. Also, evaluation of other IP3R1 biochemical changes would be need to conclusion.
Wider implications of the findings: The present findings provide new understanding the reason of the fertilization failure during ART program, and suggest
further evidence for the clinical application as maker of egg quality.
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
Study question: Is the pregnancy rate, in infertile patients, influenced by the type
of culture media used in association with time lapse analysis?
Summary answer: According to our experience, the use of universal media
instead of sequential media could improve the pregnancy rate.
What is known already: Recent studies of different culture media on human
embryo development show that there are no differences in implantation rate and
clinical pregnancy rate. Furthermore embryo evaluation is often based on a
static observation.
Study design, size, duration: In a retrospective study, from June 2012 to December 2012, 141 infertile patients/cycles underwent Intracytoplasmic Sperm Injection (ICSI) cycles with embryo transfer. After which ICSI oocytes were
incubated in a time lapse system (Unisense FertiliTech A/S Embryoscope).
Participants/materials, setting, methods: The 141 patients were divided in two
groups, group A and B. In group A (n ¼ 90) we used a sequential media (Sagew)
and B (n ¼ 51) a single step media (Irvine Scientificw). The variables studied were
the fertilisation, implantation, pregnancy, and blastocyst cryopreservation rate.
Main results and the role of chance: In Group A 1217 oocytes were retrieved,
722 injected (8.02 + 1.42), 511 fertilised (FR ¼ 70.8) and 201 embryos were
transferred; in B 618 retrieved, 383 injected (7.5 + 1.5), 269 fertilised (FR ¼
70.2) and 120 transferred.No differences in mean age (A¼ 36.6 + 3.8; B ¼
36.6 + 3.8), fertilisation rate (A ¼ 70.8%; B ¼ 70.2%) and transferred embryos
(A ¼ 2.2 + 0.54; B ¼ 2.3 + 0.5). Furthermore there are no differences in time
lapse analysis at two, four, eight, morula and blastocycsts development between
two groups. A pregnancy rate (A ¼ 34.4%; B ¼ 47%) and percentage of cryopreserved sovrannumerary blastocysts (A ¼ 25.5%; B ¼ 33.3%) positive trend was
observed, although not statistically significantly different.
Limitations, reason for caution: The use of time lapse systems without comparison with 3 gas incubators normally used in clinical practice. The sample considered had not sufficient statistical power to detect the difference observed in this
study.
Wider implications of the findings: Although not statistically different, our
results show a clinical interesting increase in pregnancy rate between the two
studied groups, to be confirmed in a larger sample comparing 3 gas incubators
and time lapse systems.
Study funding/competing interest(s): None
Trial registration number: Not applicable
i165
i166
Abstracts
Study funding/competing interest(s): This work was supported by a grant from
the Korea Healthcare Technology R&D Project, Ministry for Health, Welfare &
Family affairs, Republic of Korea (A084923).
Trial registration number: Basic research
P-120
The shipment of oocytes or embryos vitrified in minimum volume
by means of dry shipper containers does not impair the clinical outcome
A. Cobo Cabal1, B. Vallejo1, P. Campos1, E. Sánchez1, J. Serrano1, and J. Remohi2
Instituto Valenciano de Infertilidad, IVF laboratory, Valencia, Spain, 2Instituto
Valenciano de Infertilidad, Ob. Gyn., Valencia, Spain
1
P-121
Cleavage timing of euploid embryo development is age-related
V. Nagornyy1, P. Mazur1, D. Mykytenko2, L. Semeniuk1, and V. Zukin1
1
Clinic of Reproductive Medicine ’NADIYA’, Embryology department, Kiev,
Ukraine, 2Clinic of Reproductive Medicine ’NADIYA’, Department of molecular
diagnostics, Kiev, Ukraine
Study question: Can age-related differences in timing of embryo development be
indentified and do they correlate with embryo ploidy?
P-122 Does the type of culture media or oxygen tension affect embryo
fertilization and development - analysis of sibling o ocytes
P. Guilherme1, C. Madaschi1, T.C.S. Bonetti2, G. Fassolas3, and C.R. Izzo4
1
Originare - Centro de Reprodução Humana, IVF Laboratory, São Paulo SP,
Brazil, 2Universidade Federal de São Paulo, Laboratory of Molecular
Gynecology and Proteomics, São Paulo SP, Brazil, 3Originare - Centro de
Reprodução Humana, Laboratory director, São Paulo SP, Brazil, 4Originare Centro de Reprodução Humana, Clinical director, São Paulo SP, Brazil
Study question: Are the morphokinetics of growing embryos affected by the type
of culture media utilized and does the oxygen tension of the incubator may influence sequencial or single step media?
Summary answer: The oxygen tension does not influence the fertilization, but
the GlobalTM (single-step) media presents better fertilization rate. On the other
hand, embryo development was not affected by the type of culture media, but
for the oxygen tension. Lower oxygen tension gives rise to better quality
embryo, and subsequently better blastocysts.
What is known already: Optimal culture conditions and media composition are
critical for the development of embryos in vitro. It is commercially available single
step and sequential media for embryo culture; however the best type of media for
embryo development is not defined yet. Besides the type of media, the atmosphere
culture conditions are equally important. It is known that laboratory culture of
embryos with oxygen at atmospheric tension impairs embryo metabolism and
blastocyst development in several species
Study design, size, duration: Retrospective cohort study carried out in
private infertility clinic. We analyzed 253 ICSI cycles with ejaculated
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
Study question: Is shipping impairing survival or clinical outcome of vitrified
oocytes or embryos?
Summary answer: Oocytes or embryos vitrified in minimum volume with an open
system can be safely transported by means of dry shippers equipped with temperature
monitoring devices without impairment of survival or clinical outcome.
What is known already: Vitrification has revealed as most efficient method for
oocyte cryopreservation, especially by means of open systems using minimum
volume for loading samples. Shipping vitrified material could be of great utility
for donor egg-banks as well as for patients needing the transportation of their
oocytes or embryos due to change of residence or clinic. Usually cryopreserved
samples are transported in vapor dry shippers. Serious concerns have been
raised about the shipping of micro-drop- vitrified samples in this type of containers, due to possible deleterious changes in temperature caused by the manipulation
needed to load the containers or during transportation.
Study design, size, duration: Retrospective cohorts study, January 2007- April
2011.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: University affiliated infertility center.
674 oocytes (N¼ 72 cycles) and 304 embryos (N ¼ 132 cycles) were shipped to
different Spanish cities. Matched controls consisted of IVF and warming cycles
conducted in situ including 1436 non-shipped vitrified oocytes (N ¼ 144
cycles) and 524 non-shipped vitrified embryos (N ¼ 272 cycles). All samples
were vitrified using Cryotop method. MEV vapor dry shipperw equipped with a
temperature tracking system (ShipslogTM) was employed for monitoring the temperature of the device throughout the trip. Any air-contact was avoided when
loading the dry shipper. Full history of temperature throughout the journey was
downloaded. Survival and ongoing pregnancy rate (OPR) were analyzed as
main outcome measurements. x2 test was used for statistical analysis and odds
ratios (OR) with CI 95% were calculated with significance under 0.05.
Main results and the role of chance: The shipment of oocytes orembryos does not
impair survival and clinical outcome. 89.8 % vs. 91% (NS) and 94.9% vs. 97.8%
(NS) embryo transfers were performed when oocytes and embryos were shipped
compared to controls respectively. The odds ratio (OR) for survival and OPR/
cycle in the case of shipped oocytes was 1.134 (CI95% 0.838-1.534; P ¼ 0.433)
and 0.912 (CI95% 0.498-1.670; P ¼ 0.877). Similarly, no statistical differences
were found for shipped embryos vs. controls: OR ¼ 0.751 (CI95% 0.325-1.738;
P ¼ 0.548) and 1.051(CI95% 0.682-1.622; P ¼ 0.912) for survival and OPR/cycle.
Limitations, reason for caution: Heterogeneity of study sample including ovum
donation and autologous oocytes cycles and natural cycles or hormonal replacement therapy for vitrified embryo transfers, although matched controls have been
included.
Wider implications of the findings: The safe shipment of vitrified oocytes
and embryos has great implications for the flexibility of ovum donation and
IVF programs.
Study funding/competing interest(s): None of the authors are affiliated to the
brands that commercialize the devices employed in the study.
Trial registration number: N/A
Summary answer: According to our investigation, transfer quality embryos of
women of advanced age show delayed cleavage times, especially those with
correct chromosomal constitution confirmed by array comparative genome hybridization (aCGH) analysis.
What is known already: Time-lapse analysis of human embryo morphokinetics
had already produced sufficient amount of data to help improve selection of
embryos with higher implantation potential. However, there is little evidence
for connection of morphokinetic parameters with embryo ploidy status and
womens age
Study design, size, duration: This cross-sectional study included 878 embryos of
133 patients, cultured in time-lapse imaging system during one year period. From
these, 113 embryos of 24 patients were analysed for ploidy by aCGH. Of aCGH
embryos 45 originated from 10 women over 34 years, other 68 embryos were
from 14 younger women.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Embryos were cultured in EmbryoScopeTM (UnisenseFertiliTech A/S, Denmark). Array CGH, if applied, was performed after trophectoderm biopsy, using 24surew kit (BlueGnome, United
Kingdom). After 5 or 6 days of embryo culture, time-lapse image data were analysed and event times determined.
Main results and the role of chance: In general group, embryos were compared
by timing of first divisions. No differences between mean values for young and
advanced age women were found.
Embryos analysed by aCGH have developed to blastocyst at day 5 or day 6,
allowing trophectoderm biopsy. Thus, timing was also established for later
embryo development events, e.g. morula formation, cavitation and expansion
start. Morphokinetic data were compared by women’s age and embryo ploidy.
Euploid embryos of women aged 35 years or more, showed significantly slower
times of early development when compared to euploid embryos of younger
patients. First cleavage time was 29.10h (CI95% 26.97 to 31.33h) compared to
24.57h (CI95% 23.92 to 25.22h), second cleavage was at 41.93h (CI95% 39.60
to 44.26) compared to 35.91h (CI95% 34.94 to 36.88h)
Limitations, reason for caution: Presented data shows only limited possibility of
noninvasive embryo ploidy assessment.
Wider implications of the findings: Our findings suggest that currently used
time-lapse imaging analysis criteria should be adjusted when applied to
embryos of women of advanced age. In this group of patients optimal time
points of cytokinesis are delayed.
Study funding/competing interest(s): Authors have nothing to disclose.No
funding was received for this research.
Trial registration number: None
i167
Abstracts
P-123
Is intrafollicular retinoic acid associate with nuclear oocyte
maturation
M.J. De Los Santos1, D. Beltrán1, V. Garcı́a-Láez1, M.J. Escribá1, N. Grau 1,
L. Escrich1, C. Albert1, J.L. Zuzuarregui2, and A. Pellicer1
1
IVI Valencia, Clinical embriology, Valencia, Spain, 2IVI Valencia, Clinical
analysis, Valencia, Spain
Study question: Does intrafollicular concentration of retinoic acid (RA) correlate
with nuclear maturity of human oocytes?
Summary answer: Despite the presence of RA in follicular fluids (FF), it seems
that the concentration of RA is not directly associated with the resume of meoisis.
What is known already: RA synthesis is a requirement to sustain meiosis in
human ovary. ALDH1A2 gene expression which converts Vitamine A to retinoic
acid have been found in human cumulus cells (CC) from both unstimulated and
stimulated cycles and it seems that, at least in the bovine, is associated with the acquisition of oocyte cytoplasmic competence through the promoting growth
factors, COX2 expression suppression.
Study design, size, duration: This sampling procedure study was performed from
2007 to 2009. A total of 39 FF were analysed; 13 FF from immature oocytes and 26
FF from mature oocytes. Oocyte retrieval was schedule 36 hours after hCG administration.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: All FF were measured and centrifuged, aliquoted and stored at -80C for subsequent analysis. All the oocytes associated to the aspirated follicles were kept in culture individually. FF were analyzed
for RA by means of liquid chromatography. Student T-test was used for statistical
comparisons.
Main results and the role of chance: We observed no differences between the
groups of immature and mature oocytes in terms of age of the patients (35.5 +
3.6 vs. 34.5 + 6.5 years), size of the follicle (4.1 + 2.1 ml vs. 4.2 + 1.6 ml )
and RA concentration (4.3 + 2.3 ug/ml vs. 4.1 + 1.2 ug/ml) respectively.
Limitations, reason for caution: Sample size may be a limitation of the study,
however since the RA concentration frame was very narrow among samples we
believe results will not vary that much.
Wider implications of the findings: Despite meiosis initiation in the human
ovary relies partially on RA, it seem that is not important in later steps of
meiosis since no differences were found in FF from preovulatory follicles containing metaphase II oocytes an immature ones.
Study funding/competing interest(s): The present project was supported by the
R + D programme from the Generalitat Valenciana (Regional Valencian Goverment).Project identification number: IMPIVA IMDTG/2008/26 and IMIDTF/
2009/142
Trial registration number: This is not a clinical trial
P-124
Evaluation of calcium machinery in a meiosis defect mouse model
Y. LU 1, D. Nikiforaki1, F. Vanden Meerschaut 1, J. Neupane1, W.H. De Vos2,
S. Lierman1, T. Deroo 1, B. Heindryckx1, and P. De Sutter 1
1
University Hospital Ghent, Department for Reproductive Medicine, Gent,
Belgium, 2Ghent University, Department of Molecular Biotechnology, Gent,
Belgium
Study question: Is nuclear and cytoplasmic maturation impaired in in vivo and
in vitro matured oocytes from LT/Sv mice, a mouse model showing oocyte
meiotic arrest?
Summary answer: In addition to abnormal spindle-chromosome complexes, defective intracellular calcium (Ca2+) signalling during in vitro maturation (IVM)
points to both a nuclear and cytoplasmic maturation defect in LT/Sv oocytes.
What is known already: Acquisition of oocyte meiotic competence coincides with
spontaneous Ca2+- oscillations during germinal vesicle breakdown (GVBD)
mediated by the type 1 inositol 1, 4, 5-triphosphate receptor (IP3R1). In addition,
the occurrence of Ca2+-oscillations during fertilization serves as a marker of efficient cytoplasmic maturation. LT/Sv mice show a significant proportion of arrested
metaphase I (MI) oocytes. Furthermore, LT/Sv GVoocytes that are in vitro matured
to the MI and MII stage show aberrant Ca2+-responses at fertilization.
Study design, size, duration: Spontaneous Ca2+-oscillations were analyzed in GV
oocytes following 16h IVM from LT/Sv (n ¼ 38) and B6D2F1 mice
(n ¼ 40). Strontium-induced Ca2+-oscillations were measured for 2h in in vivo and
IVM LT/Sv (n ¼ 91) and B6D2F1 oocytes (n ¼ 94). IP3R1 localization and spindlechromosome complexes were assessed in in vivo and IVM LT/Sv oocytes (n ¼ 72).
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Oocytes were collected from 6- to 10week-old LT/Sv and control B6D2F1 mice 48h after FSH (GV) and 14h after hCG
injection (MI and MII). Spontaneous and strontium-induced Ca2+-responses were
measured by fluorescence time lapse imaging. IP3R1 localization and spindlechromosome complexes were analysed by immunostaining and confocal microscopy.
Main results and the role of chance: During maturation none of the IVM MI and
25% of the IVM MII oocytes from LT/Sv mice showed spontaneous Ca2+oscillations compared to 60% (P , 0.01) and 64% of B6D2F1 oocytes, respectively. After strontium activation, the number of Ca2+-rises was significantly
decreased in IVM LT/Sv-MI (5.50 + 3.73) and IVM LT/Sv-MII oocytes
(4.59 + 2.34) compared to in vivo LT/Sv-MI (14.28 + 5.83) and in vivo LT/
Sv-MII oocytes (11.25 + 4.23) (P , 0.01) respectively. Furthermore, in vivo
LT/Sv-MI oocytes showed more Ca2+-oscillations than in vivo LT/Sv-MII
(P , 0.05) and B6D2F1 in vivo MII oocytes (P , 0.05). IP3R1 localization was
similar in both in vivo and IVM LT/Sv-MI and LT/Sv-MII oocytes. However, a significantly lower number of normal spindle-chromosome complexes was observed
in IVM LT/Sv-MI and LT/Sv-MII oocytes compared to in vivo matured LT/Sv-MI
and LT/Sv-MII oocytes (P , 0.05).
Limitations, reason for caution: LT/Sv mice are a good model for human clinical
mixed MI arrest cases, yet the findings are species-specific and cannot be fully
extended to the human. The mechanism and pattern of strontium-induced Ca2+oscillations may differ from those of fertilization.
Wider implications of the findings: Defective Ca2+ signalling during oocyte
maturation might underlie certain types of oocyte maturation arrest. Nuclear transfer may be a way to overcome this, but given the high rate of spindle abnormalities
in in vitro matured oocytes, this should be applied to collected in vivo matured
oocytes. Further studies are needed to determine the contribution of the IP3R1
and other signalling pathways to impaired cytoplasmic maturation.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This study was supported by the China
Scholarship Council and Special Research Fund from Ghent University (Bijzonder Onderzoeksfonds, BOF). No competing interest declared.
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
sperm between January,2011 and December,2012. Embryos were cultured
with two different types of media, single-step ( GlobalTM ) or sequential
(VitrolifeTM ), in tri-gas (5% CO2, 378C, 6% O2) or conventional incubator
(5% CO2, 378C, 20% O2).
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Oocytes were split according to media
and incubator: A: atmospheric O2 tension/single-step media; B: atmospheric O2
tension/sequential media; C: 6% O2 tension/single-step media; D: 6% O2
tension/sequential media. Variables studied included normal fertilization,
embryo grade on day 3, and blastocyst expansion on day 5. p ≤ 0.05 was considered statistically significant.
Main results and the role of chance: When normal fertilization rate was evaluated,
it seems the single step media result in higher rates as groupA (77.6%) versus groupB
(68.5%) (p ¼ 0.286) and groupC (80.9%) versus groupD (67.5%)(p , 0.001)
showed numerical and statistical significant differences, respectively. No differences
were observed in relation to the oxygen tension. When we analyzed the embryo
morphology on day 3, the low oxygen tension was relevant, as we observed statistically significant difference between groupA (67.8%) and groupC (80.3%), p ¼ 0.020.
No difference was seen between groupB and groupD, showing that for sequencial
media, the oxygen tension does not matter. In spite of seem that group A had
lower blastocyst rate (39.1%) than other groups (B: 51.6%, C:49.3% and D:
44.2%), there is no statistical difference among them.
Limitations, reason for caution: The study was not powered to test differences in
pregnancy rates between the two culture media, as embryos from different groups
were transferred for the most of patients.
Wider implications of the findings: The absence of differences in the development of blastocyst between two different media concepts validates the algorithm
for embryo selection in diverse culture conditions. On the other hand, the low
oxygen tension seems to lead to improved embryo quality on day 3, and should
be adopted specially in short time cultures.
Study funding/competing interest(s): No specific funding was obtained for this
study; it was solely funded by ORIGINARE. None of the authors have any economic affiliation any culture media company.
Trial registration number: Not applicable.
i168
Abstracts
Trial registration number: No trial registration number.
P-125
Embryonic human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) in spent culture
medium may tell embryo viability in IVF-ET program: a multi-center study
Study question: Could embryonic beta-hCG be as a biomarker for embryo selection in IVF-ET procedure?
Summary answer: A higher embryonic beta-hCG level was found in embryos
with higher morphologic grading or implantation potential and beta-hCG might
be a predictor for embryo viability, especially in blastocyst transfer program.
What is known already: hCG was one of the first found embryonic secretions and
detected at variable levels by different methods in spent embryo culture medium
since 1984. A highly sensitive electrochemiluminescence immunoassay (ECLIA)
with strong repeatability, efficiency and stability was performed to detect
beta-hCG in culture medium in our previous study.
Study design, size, duration: It’s a cross sectional experiment study. Total 719
samples were individually collected at day3 (n ¼ 300) and day5 (n ¼ 419)
which included fresh (n ¼ 161), frozen-thawed (n ¼ 55) and further culture to
blastocyst after thawing (n ¼ 203) from 382 women in 6 IVF centers from Nov.
2011 to Oct. 2012 in China.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: A sequential culture system was performed from 2PN to blastocyst stage. Samples were collected individually and
stored at -808C until beta-hCG detection by ECLIA. Clinical data of these participants were collected at the same time.
Main results and the role of chance: 1) Beta-hCG was found in culture media at
fresh day3 (87.7%, 263/300), fresh day5 (98.1%, 158/161), further culture to day5
after thawing (96.6%, 196/203) and thawed day5 (100%, 55/55). 2) There was no
difference among conventional IVF group, ICSI group and PGD group ( p ¼
0.067). 3) A higher beta-hCG concentration appeared in subgroups of fresh
blastocysts with expanded cavity or high trophectoderm grading (A OR B)
( p ¼ 0.042) and day5 (fresh/thawed and single/double embryos transferred). 5)
The concentration of embryonic beta-hCG correlated positively with implantation
rate (r ¼ 0.56, p , 0.001).
Limitations, reason for caution: 1) Embryo transferred was still dependent on
the morphology grading rather than beta-hCG concentration in spent culture
medium in this study. 2) The sample size of single embryo transfer (n ¼ 88)
was relatively small to describe the predictive power of beta-hCG for embryo viability assessment.
Wider implications of the findings: Selecting the embryo with highest competence by embryonic beta-hCG detection in spent culture media with ECLIA
alone and/or combined with morphology grading may reduce the number of
embryos transferred, resulting in a decrease of multiple pregnancies rate in clinical
application.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This study was supported by Nature
Science Foundation of China (2008; no.30872762) and the Science Foundation
of Guangdong Province (2009B030801022).
Trial registration number: None.
P-126
Viability markers: optimal dynamic range for implantation in
competent blastocyst
L. Muela1, M. Roldan1, B. Gadea1, M. Martinez1, I. Perez1, M. Meseguer2, and
M. Muñoz3
1
IVI Alicante, IVF Laboratory, Alicante, Spain, 2IVI Valencia, IVF Laboratory,
Alicante, Spain, 3IVI Alicante, Medical Director, Alicante, Spain
Probability to implant.
..............................................................
Outside optimum
kinetic range
Inside optimum
kinetic range
.........................................................................................
t5 (47- 60 h)
28.8 % (n ¼ 73)
42.9% (n ¼ 92)*
t5t2 (22-33h)
26.4% (n ¼ 14)
42.6% (n ¼ 78)*
t8 (49-62h)
32.5 % (n ¼ 38)
45.4% (n ¼ 54)*
tm (82-92h)
32.2% (n ¼ 58)
60.7% (n ¼ 34)*
tb (92-105h )
30.3% (n ¼ 46)
54.8% (n ¼ 92)*
* p values , 0.05.
Study question: Is there an optimal range in cleavage kinetics that increases implantation potential?
Summary answer: For five of the morphokinetic parameters studied, we have
found a higher significant implantation probability for those embryos within an
optimal timing range.
What is known already: Evaluation of embryos outside the incubator enables the
assessment of timing of events, but also exposes embryos to undesirable changes
in temperature, humidity and gas composition (Zhang et al., 2010). Culture of
embryos in a time-lapse monitoring system improves pregnancy outcome compared with a standard incubator. (Meseguer et al 2012). Addition of kinetics to
conventional morphological assessment can be used as predictor of embryo implantation. (Meseguer et al 2011)
Study design, size, duration: In a retrospective cohort study, we analyzed 236
embryos with known implantation from 240 cycles included in our egg donation
program. Embryos were culture in a time-lapse incubator after intracytoplasmic
injection or conventional in vitro fertilization and monitored until transfer on
day5. It was conducted from November-2009 till December-2012.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: The current study took place in a
private IVF clinic, on embryos with Known Implantation Data (KID). We
included in the study embryos with 100% implantation (KIDpositive) and
embryos failing to implant 0% (KIDnegative).
For each embryo, the timing of each cellular event was annotated: pronuclear
formation and fading, cleavage to 2 cells (t2), t3,t4,t5,t6,t7,t8,t9, Morula(tM),
early blastocyst(tB), and expanded blastocyst. We also evaluated the duration
of the second cycle cc2 (t3-t2), time between 2 and 5 cells(t5-t2), and the blastomere synchrony s2 (t4-t3)
Selection of embryos for transfer was exclusively based on morphological
criteria.
The optimum timing range is established according to embryo distribution for
each parameter studied depending on implantation status.
Pearson’s Chi-square was performed, p values , 0.05 were considered
significant.
Main results and the role of chance
The implantation rate (IR) of the study was 40.4%, KID IR was 39.0%, pregnancy rate was 64.8%. These results showed how the probability to implant
rises when a blastocyst is selected inside the optimal timing range.
Limitations, reason for caution
These are data from a retrospective analysis, although sample size is considerably high. Results are based on observations with embryos from oocyte donors
and need to be repeated with embryos from infertile patients of different ages.
Wider implications of the findings: Inclusion of kinetics parameters within
embryo morphology classification may increase pregnancy rates. The finding of
the optimal kinetic range is the first step in this study. From now on, we will
include this optimal kinetic range in our embryo selection criteria to demonstrate
an improvement on pregnancy rates, although previous studies already did it. The
present analysis will be evaluated by logistic regression in order to develop an algorithm for blastocyst selection.
Study funding/competing interest(s): Not applicable
Trial registration number: Not applicable
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
J. Li1, X.Y. Chen1, G. Lin2, G.N. Huang3, Z.Y. Sun4, Y. Zhong5, B. Zhang6, T. Li 1,
S.P. Zhang2, H. Ye 3, S.B. Han3, S.Y. Liu5, J. Zhou4, G.X. Lu2, and G.L. Zhuang1
1
The First Affiliated Hospital Sun Yat-Sen University, IVF Center-Dept. of Ob/
Gyn, Guang Zhou, China, 2Central South University, Institute of Reproduction
and Stem Cell, Changsha, China, 3Chongqing Obstetrics and Gynecology
Hospital, Chongqing Reproductive and Genetics Institute, Chongqing, China,
4
Peking Union Medical College Hospital, Department of Obstetrics and
Gynecology, Beijing, China, 5Chengdu Xinan Gynecological Hospital,
Reproductive Center, Chengdu, China, 6Maternal and Child Health Hospital of
Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region, Obstetrics and Gynecology, Nanning,
China
Timing of
cellular event
Abstracts
P-127
Impact of exposure to music during in vitro culture on embryo
development
C. Castelló1, M. Asensio1, P. Fernández1, A. Farreras1, S. Rovira1, J.M. Capdevila
1, E. Velilla 1, and M. López-Teijón 2
1
Instituto Marques, Reproductive Biology, Barcelona, Spain, 2Instituto Marques,
Reproduction Medicine Service, Barcelona, Spain
P-128
Can a composite score based on time lapse observation aid embryo
selection for single embryo transfer ñ an interim report
P. Kovács1, S.Z. Mátyás1, V. Forgács2, A. Reichart2, F. Rárosi3, A. Bernárd1,
A. Török 4, S.G. Kaáli1, A. Sajgó1, and C.S. Pribenszky 5
1
Kaáli Institute, IVF Center, Budapest, Hungary, 2Forgács Intézet, IVF Center,
Budapest, Hungary, 3Department of Medical Physics and Informatics Bolyai
Institute, University of Szeged Hungary, Szeged, Hungary, 4Pannon Reprodukciós
Intézet, IVF Center, Tapolca, Hungary, 5St. Istvan University Faculty of Veterinary
Science, Department of Animal Breeding and Genetics, Budapest, Hungary
Study question: The aim of this study is to compare pregnancy rates in human
in-vitro fertilization treatments when embryos are monitored and evaluated
using Primo Vision time-lapse system (Vitrolife Ltd., Hungary) (TL) or cultured
and evaluated in the traditional way to support the selection of a single blastocyst
for transfer (ET).
Summary answer: Based on the interim results of this ongoing study TL monitoring may assist embryo selection for single blastocyst transfer. The 32% increase in
pregnancy rate (PR) in the TL group is encouraging.
What is known already: A multiple pregnancy is an undesired outcome of
assisted reproduction. Current embryo classification is inefficient in identifying
the embryo with the highest implantation potential. Time-lapse embryo monitoring provides additional information about embryo development and therefore may
aid embryo selection. It appears that the kinetics and dynamics (fragmentation,
blastocyst formation) of embryo development predict embryo viability.
Study design, size, duration: Ongoing, prospective, randomized, multicenter
trial started in Jan/2012. All patients use the long agonist protocol with
recombinant-FSH stimulation. The single blastocyst for ET is selected based on
day-5 morphology (Control) or on composite score based on TL observations.
Fifty patients are planned to be included per protocol.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Eligible patients are randomized to
TL vs. standard daily embryo monitoring. For the TL monitoring a scoring
system was developed including: timing of 1st division, duration of 2-cell cytokonesis, timing of 2-3 and 3-4 cell divisions, time to reach the 5-cell stage, fragmentation, blastocyst morphology). Patient/ cycle, parameters were compared.
Main results and the role of chance: This report is based on the first 59 randomized patients (28 TL vs 31 control). 12 patients dropped out (5 TL, 7 control)
for various reasons. Patient and stimulation parameters are comparable between
the groups.
The per randomization pregnancy rates (PR): 14/28 (50%, TL) vs 13/31 (41.9%
control) and ongoing PR: 13/28 (46.4% TL) vs 12/31 (38.7% control) were not
significantly different (p ¼ 0.5).
The per protocol PR: 14/23 (60.8% TL) vs 11/24 (45.8% control) and ongoing
PR: 13/23 (56.52% TL) vs 10/24 (41.6% control) were not significantly different
(p ¼ 0.3). The mean time lapse score was higher among those who achieved pregnancy in the TL group: (14.5 + /2 1.8 vs 13.1 + /2 2.0; p ¼ 0.09).
Limitations, reason for caution: The sample size is relatively small to allow firm
conclusions but we observed a favorable trend with TL monitoring. The scoring
system that was developed based on currently available time-lapse findings and
own experience also needs to be validated on a larger dataset.
Wider implications of the findings: The development of effective embryo selection tools could lead to further reductions in the number of embryos transferred for
an even wider patient population without affecting pregnancy rates in the fresh
cycle. TL monitoring provides immediate information, is non-invasive and
allows us to keep the embryos under ideal culturing conditions throughout the observation.
Study funding/competing interest(s): None
Trial registration number: NCT01694641
P-129 p38 MAPK signal activity is critical for GLUT1 and GLUT4
expressions, maintaining pluripotency and survival of early mouse embryos
B. Sozen1, S. Ozturk1, A. Yaba-Ucar2, and N. Demir1
1
Akdeniz University Faculty of Medicine, Histology and Embryology, Antalya,
Turkey, 2Istanbul Bilim University Faculty of Medicine, Histology and
Embryology, Istanbul, Turkey
Study question: Does p38 MAPK signaling pathway has any role on the regulation of GLUT1 (glucose transporter 1) and GLUT4 (glucose transporter 4) expressions, cell death, pluripotency and, thus cell fate in the preimplantation embryo
development?
Summary answer: The suppression of p38 MAPK activity affected the expression of GLUT1 and GLUT4 proteins and mRNA levels; increased cell death
and altered expression of the pluripotency markers in preimplantation embryos.
What is known already: Cleavage divisions after 8-cell stage generate differentiation within the preimplantation embryos, namely the segregation of primitive
endoderm, epiblast, trophectoderm lineages. Nanog, Sox2, Oct4/Pou5f are
known as cell fate and pluripotency regulators during this period. On the other
hand, to accomplish proper preimplantation development, glucose transport in
early embryo achieved by facilitative glucose transporters, GLUTs. However, although some signaling pathways associated with these processes have been identified, the role of p38 MAPK signaling is remained elusive.
Study design, size, duration: Two cell stage embryos were cultured up to 8-cell,
compact morula and blastocyst stages in three microdrop culture treatments;
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
Study question: The aim of this work is to determine whether or not exposure to
music during in vitro culture conditions could improve outcomes in terms of
oocyte fertilization and embryo quality.
Summary answer: Our preliminary results show a statistically significant increase in fertilization rate in oocytes exposed to music, but no statistically significant differences were found regarding embryo quality in terms of cleavage stage
and multinucleation.
What is known already: Mechanical micro-vibration can alter both the expression of some molecules and neurogenesis itself (Alladi 2005). It has been reported
that exposure of in vitro cultured human embryos to 5s intervals 44hz/h of microvibrations can improve embryo development and quality (Heo 2010; Matsura
2010). Nothing is known about music as a source of mechanical vibrations and
its effect on human embryos whilst undergoing in vitro development prior to implantation.
Study design, size, duration: 985 oocytes from 114 patients were analyzed
(01-08/2012). Inseminated oocytes from each patient were divided in groups:
A (culture with music (n ¼ 497)) and B (culture without music (n ¼ 488)). Fertilization rates and embryo quality were compared. We tested 3 types of music
(A1:Pop,A2:Heavymetal,A3:Classical) by placing speakers inside standard incubators (Labotec C200).
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Sibling embryos were randomly
assigned to groups A/B. Morphological quality was established (scale 1-10,
quality 7-10 ¼ first-choice embryos). Generalised Linear-Mixed model. Oocyte
fertilization rates, embryo quality (10-7 score), cleavage and multinucleation
were analysed. Two (patient/cycle) or three levels (patient/cycle/day of transfer)
were considered. Bayesian inferences were made using Integrated Nested Laplace(INLA).
Main results and the role of chance: Fertilisation rates in group A (music) were
4.82% higher than in Group B (no music). Regarding the parameters used to assess
embryo quality, no statistically significant difference was found in embryo cleavage rates or the percentage of multinucleated embryos created. In group A there
was no statistical difference in the percentage of first choice transfer embryos
(score 10-7) created, compared with those in group B. However, no statistically
significant difference was observed between the different types of music used
(pop, heavy metal and classical).
Limitations, reason for caution: Bayesian inferences were made using integrated
Nested Laplace (INLA).
Wider implications of the findings: Limited number of Publications . The routine
use of music inside the incubators during in vitro culture would appear to be a
useful tool to improve fertilisation rates. It is important to evaluate the effect of
music on embryo development to day 5. We would recommend confirming
these results in a larger series of cases.
Study funding/competing interest(s): Not applicable.
Trial registration number: Not applicable.
i169
i170
P-130
A prospective study evaluating the effect of high (21%) and low
(5%) oxygen levels on the human embryo development
N. Gelo, P. Stanic, V. Hlavati, S. ogoric, D. Pavicic-Baldani, M. prem-Goldtajn,
B. Radakovic, M. Kasum, M. Strelec, T. Canic, V. imunic, and H. Vrcic
University Hospital Centre Zagreb, Department of Gynecology and Obstetrics,
Zagreb, Croatia
Study question: The purpose of this study was to examine effect of low O2 (5%)
levels in order to obtain more embryos with excellent morphology (grade
Z1,A,AA) as well as higher clinical pregnancy rates (CPR).
Summary answer: Cultivation of embryos in incubators with low oxygen (5%)
levels contributes their better development on day 2, enhances the rate of blastocysts and those blastocysts results with higher number of CPR.
What is known already: Oxygen is the major factor in embryo development in
vitro along with cultivation medium. Excess of reactive oxygen species (ROS)
results with damage known as oxidative stress (OS) which can cause DNA fragmentation, apoptosis, slowing or even stopping of embryo development. Excess
of ROS is more common in cultures with high (21%) oxygen levels.
Study design, size, duration: Between March 2012 and May 2012, 70 IVF and
ICSI stimulated cycles were prospectively randomized for cultivation with high
(21%) or low (5%) oxygen level. Until the time of fertilization all oocytes were
cultivated with high (21%) oxygen level and after that cultivated according to
the prior randomization.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Embryo development was monitored
every 24 hours (except on day 4) for 3 - 5 days according to the day of transfer.
Statistical analysis was performed with StatSoft program and results were compared with chi-square test with Yates correction with df ¼ 1. A P value ≤0. 05
was considered statistically significant.
Main results and the role of chance: Statistically significant difference was
observed with embryos on day 2 – 52.2% (47/90) grade A embryos developed
with 5% O2 and 37.4% (34/91) with 21% O2, number of embryos that stopped
in development – 5.6% (5/90) with low oxygen and 15.4% (14/91) with high
oxygen levels and number of embryos that reached blastocyst stadium – 21.1%
(19/90) with 5% O2 versus 6.6% (6/91) with 21% O2.Number of transfers on
day 3 showed statistically significant difference for cultivation with high (21%)
oxygen levels while number of transfers on day 5 showed statistically significant
difference for cultivation with low (5%) oxygen levels-88% versus 71.2% and
26% versus 8.9%.Number of CPR after transfer of blastocyst was statistically significant after cultivation in incubator with 5% O2 –46.6% versus 10%.
Limitations, reason for caution: Results are specific and limited due to our restrictive law in that period - maximum of 3 oocytes per couple were fertilized.
Wider implications of the findings: The most interesting result is statistically significant difference observed with more grade A embryos on day 2 in favor of low
oxygen cultivation. These results are in contrast with those of some previous
studies that found no benefit of culturing human embryos at lower O2 concentrations at this stage of development (Dumoulin et al.,1999; Bahceci et al., 2005).
Other results are in correlation with previous findings (Kovacic et al.,2010;
Meintjes et al.,2009; Waldenstrom et al.,2009).
Study funding/competing interest(s): We have no relevant interests to declare.
Trial registration number: None
P-131
Growth factors status in follicular fluid of patients undergoing
ICSI
M. Ajina1, D. Negra 1, H. Ben-Ali2, S. Jallad1, I. Zidi1, S. Meddeb3, M. Bibi 3,
H. Khairi3, and A. Saad3
1
Unit of Reproductive Medicine, University hospital F.Hached, Sousse, Tunisia,
2
Laboratories of Cytogenetic Molecular Biology and Human Biology of
Reproduction, University hospital F.Hached, Sousse, Tunisia, 3Department of
Obstetrics and Gynaecology, University hospital F.Hached, Sousse, Tunisia
Study question: we try to find any association between follicular fluid (FF) levels
of TGFb1, IGF 1 and EGF from individual follicles and the subsequent fertilization results after ICSI of the oocytes derived from the same follicles.
Summary answer: The intrafollicular concentrations of growth factors were not
correlated with ICSI outcomes but TGF b1 expression in the ovary seems to be
regulated differentially by FSH and LH since recombinant- FSH group produced
higher levels of TGF b1 compared to HMG one.TGF b1 production appears to
decrease with age.
What is known already: Although the exact role of each growth factor is not entirely known, a large body of evidence suggests that their harmonic cooperation is
of crucial importance for the development of mature and competent oocyte. By
using ICSI as the fertilization technique, the fertilization or even pregnancy
outcome seems to be mainly dependant on the quality of the oocytes, and consequently, the relationship between oocyte and its environment and fertilization
outcome could be investigate.
Study design, size, duration: A prospective study during one year , including 100
women aged under than 38 years old undergoing ovarian stimulation following
standard long agonist protocol, divided in two groups for analysis according to
the treatment modalities, HMG(n¼ 35) or recombinant FSH(n¼ 65) for ICSI
treatment with an indication of male factor infertility.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Follicular Fluid and its matched
oocyte from each single follicle were collected individually during oocyte retrieval and stored at -208c until subsequent assays for TGF b1, IGF1 and EGF
by ELISA using commercially available kits. After ICSI the levels of these
factors and the subsequent fertilization results were analyzed.
Main results and the role of chance: total retrieve and metaphase II oocyte
numbers were significantly higher in the r-FSH group (p ¼ 0.0001), cleavage
and pregnancy rates were higher in this group (p ¼ 0.0001,), in contrast with
lower rates of fertilization and top embryos. r-FSH group produced higher
levels of TGF b1 (p , 0.05) and IGF 1(p . 0.05). The intrafollicular concentrations of the above factors were not significantly associated with the ICSI outcomes. However, a strong positive correlation was found between TGF b1
levels and IGF1 (r ¼ 0.467; p ¼ 0.0001), but a negative one between TGF b1
or IGF1 and EGF(r ¼ -0.222, p ¼ 0.029; r ¼ -0.237, p ¼ 0.028. TGF b1 levels
appeared significantly higher in patients aged less than 30 years old (p ¼ 0.04)
in whose pregnancy rate was higher and correlated negatively with age after 30
years (r ¼ -0.262, p ¼ 0.03).
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
control (n ¼ 195), vehicle (%0.1 DMSO-treated, n ¼ 195), SB203580-treated
(p38 MAPK specific inhibitor, CSAIDTM, n ¼ 223). Statistical analysis were performed by one-way ANOVA test.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: 6-week-old Balb/C female mice
superovulated with 5 IU/mouse PMSG/hCG. Cell death was assayed by
TUNEL and whole mount immunofuorescence staining used for p-MK2,
p-hsp27, GLUT1, GLUT4. The relative Glut1, Glut4 mRNA levels were determined by quantitative RT-PCR. Expression of Oct4/Pou5f, Nanog, Sox2 determined by RT-PCR , /SSF . and analysed by Image-J software.
Main results and the role of chance: With the inhibition of p38 MAPK activity,
embryos displayed morphological abnormalities, developmental blockade at 8-16
cells onwards (P , 0.05). In the presence of SB203580, blastocysts contained
fewer cells (mean 62 + 2.35) and an increased percentage of TUNEL positive
nuclei (8.25 + 1.32%) compared to control (1.11 + 0.33%) and vehicle groups
(1.08 + 0,34%) (P , 0.05). Expectedly, SB-treated embryos displayed a complete loss of p-MK2 and p-hsp27 expressions in all groups confirming the effectiveness of inhibitor. Besides, dramatically decreased both GLUT1 and GLUT4
protein expressions and increased mRNA levels in SB-treated blastocysts were
observed, indicating an altered glucose metabolism. Pluripotency related genes
Nanog, Sox2, and Oct4/Pou5f showed altered expressions in SB-treated
embryos. Nanog, a transcription factor key for epiblast differentiation, mRNA
levels significantly decreased at 8-cell stage onwards in the presence of
SB203580 (P , 0.05).
Limitations, reason for caution: This study was performed in vitro conditions and
shown only in mice. In vivo applications of CSAIDTM molecules is not appropriate
to determine the effects of p38 MAPK inhibition on preimplantation embryos.
Wider implications of the findings: These results demonstrated how the inhibition of p38 MAPK activity could affect the preimplantation development. As
clearly shown in the present study, the expression of glucose transporters and pluripotency genes to ensure lineage allocation are most likely regulated by p38
MAPK activity in early mouse embryos. Therefore, our study might provide
new insights into the mechanism of regulation of preimplantation development
and new approaches for idiopatic infertility problems.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This study was supported by Akdeniz
University Research Project Coordination Unit (Project no: 2011.02.0122.005).
Trial registration number: None.
Abstracts
i171
Abstracts
P-132
Detailed kinetics and morphology analyis of human triplonucleated embryos: a comparison with correctly fertilized transferred embryos
L. Escrich, N. Grau, M. Meseguer, P. Gámiz, T. Viloria, and M.J. Escribá
IVI Valencia, FIV, Valencia, Spain
Study question: Is the in vitro dynamics of tripronucleated embryos (TPN) comparable to the morphokinetics of correctly fertilized transferred embryos (BPN)?
Summary answer: TPN and BPN embryos showed different dynamic features
which became reflected into a different embryo morphokinetic quality distribution.
What is known already: Classical assessment have shown that ICSI-TPN cleave
into two cells as BPN embryos do, but on day 3, the number of cells and ability to
progress in vitro to the blastocyst stage are inferior to that observed in TPN
embryos.
Using time lapse technology, six discriminative morphokinetic parameters
(t2-t3-t4-t5-cc2-s2) were defined for implantation of BPN. Using these parameters
and a hierarchical classification procedure (A-E) we identified embryos with high
implantation potential (Meseguer et al 2011).
Study design, size, duration: Retrospective study of the morphokinetic parameters of 378 BPN transferred embryos and 163 TPN embryos.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Embryos were evaluated by detailed
time-lapse analysis, which measured the exact timing of t2, t3, t4, t5, cc2, s2 (in
hours post-ICSI). They were then classified according to a hierarchy based on
these parameters. These parameters were compared in the two embryo groups
(BPN and TPN).
Main results and the role of chance: We observed significant differences
between BPN and TPN embryos in t2(25.9hrs vs 31.1hrs), t3(36.9hrs vs
39.7hrs), t4(38.4 vs 44.2), cc2(11.0 vs 9.4hrs), cc3(14.7hrs vs 13.1hrs),
s2(1.5hrs vs 4.6hrs), s3(8.2hrs vs 10.4hr) and t5-t2(25.6hrs vs 23.4hrs). Concerning t5, timings were comparable in both groups.
Differences in the hierarchical embryoclassification were evident. Significantly
more BPN embryos were classified as “A” and “B” than TPN embryos (49.5% vs
22.2%), whereas more embryos were classified as “E” in the TPN than in the BPN
group (44.4% vs 6.9%, respectively). Comparable percentages of BPN and TPN
embryos were classified as “D” (16.1% vs 11.1%, respectively).
Limitations, reason for caution: Although none of our TPN embryos were eventually transferred, the results reported here suggest that embryo quality is impaired
in these abnormally fertilized embryos.
Wider implications of the findings: Normally and abnormally fertilized embryos
seem to be distinguished by the morphokinetics of in vitro embryo development.
The present results reinforce the relevance of morphokinetics as a reliable marker
of embryo quality.
Study funding/competing interest(s): None
Trial registration number: Not Applicable
P-133
Embryo morphokinetic after artificial oocyte activation by using
calcium ionophore
E. Taboas Lima1, M. Pérez Fernández1, J.A. Aguilar Prieto 1, M. Ojeda Varela 1,
D. Kassa1, and E. Muñoz Muñoz2
1
IVI Vigo, FIV laboratory, Vigo, Spain, 2IVI Vigo, Gynelogy, Vigo, Spain
Control
iCa
Sig
.........................................................................................
Age
39.35 + 2.7
38 + 2.9
.0.05
Fertilization rate
66.28 + 19.63
58.88 + 21.77
.0.05
% TQE
41.01 + 29.84
47.18 + 33.66
.0.05
.0.05
1.74 + 0.53
1.80 + 0.52
Pn Fading
26.15 + 3.40
23.50 +3.65
0.03
T4
41.70 + 5.57
38.24 + 3.47
,0.01
T5
54.92 +5.60
50.17 + 7.38
,0.01
Number ET
Study question: Is embryo morphokinetic affected after artificial oocyte activation (AOA) with Calcium ionophore?
Summary answer: Pronucleus fading(PN fading), The time from 3 to 4 cells (T4)
and the time from 4 to 5 cells (T5) occurred earlier in the Calcium ionophore (iCa)
group than in the control group, although this may not affect the pregnancy and live
birth rates.
What is known already: Total fertilization failure occurs in almost 10% of ICSI
cycles. Artificial oocyte activation (AOA) with calcium ionophore (iCa) showed
acceptable fertilization rates and successful pregnancies and deliveries of a healthy
infant however, previous animal studies have demostrated that the use of AOA
may influence the embryonic development to blastocyst stage.
Study design, size, duration: Between January 2011 and January 2013, 13
couples who had experienced previous total failed fertilization after ICSI cycles
with oligoasthenozoospermic sperm characteristics (iCa group) were compared
with 12 couples with similar sperm quality (control group). Written informed
consent to share the outcomes for research purposes was obtained from all them.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: The AOA consisted of sperm injection
with buffered medium containing iCa (Ionomicym from Streptomyces conglobatus). After sperm injection, oocytes were incubated for 20 minutes in culture
medium with iCa. In the control group conventional ICSI was performed.
To evaluate the embryo morphokinetic, oocytes were cultured in a tri-gas timelapse incubator.
Main results and the role of chance: No significant differences were observed
between groups for age, fertilization rate, proportion of TQE and number of
embryos transferred.Significant differences were shown in embryo morphokinetics.
The implantation rate was 29.41% in control versus 30% in ICa group and
ongoing pregnancy rate was 80% and 83.33%, respectively. To date 4 live births
were achieved in the control group and 5 in iCa group.
Limitations, reason for caution: Total fertilization failure occurs in almost 10%
of ICSI cycles. The AOA with Ionomicym from Streptomyces conglobatus is an
experimental technique, at this moment.
Wider implications of the findings: AOA induced by microinjecting sperm and
calcium ionophore is an acceptable technique in couples who faced previous failed
fertilization cycles.
Pronucleus fading, T4 and T5 occurred earlier in the studied group than in
control group, although this not affect the pregnancy and live birth rates.
Study funding/competing interest(s): None
Trial registration number: no RCT trial
P-134
Improvement of blastocyst culture by a time-lapse incubator
Morita 1,
H.
S. Watanabe1, M. Kamihata1, R. Matsunaga1, T. Wada1, K. Kani1,
T. Ishikawa1, H. Miyamura2, M. Ito2, A. Kuwahata3, M. Ochi3, and T. Horiuchi4
1
Ochi Yume Clinic Nagoya, ART laboratory, Nagoya, Japan, 2Fujita Health
University Hospital, Obstetrics and Gynecology, Nagoya, Japan, 3Ochi Yume
Clinic Nagoya, Reproductive medicine, Nagoya, Japan, 4Prefectural University of
Hiroshima Graduate School, Comprehensive Scientific Research, Hiroshima,
Japan
Study question: We compared the results of embryos incubated in the conventional incubator and those cultured in the time-lapse incubator.
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
Limitations, reason for caution: IGF 1 tented to be higher in r-FSH group although the difference was not significant (p . 0.05) and that was correlated positively with TGF b1, so this result could be explained by our small sample size.
EGF levels were very low and slightly detected coming probably through blood
passive diffusion.
Wider implications of the findings: The intrafollicular concentrations of growth
factors can not predict ICSI outcomes but TGF b1 expression in the ovary seems to
be regulated differentially by FSH and LH; it is stimulated by FSH and inhibited by
LH. The lower IGFI levels in HMG group may suggest that LH inhibits IGF1 and/
or stimulates IGF binding protein 1. We suggest that TGFb1 together with IGF I,
may regulate ovarian follicle growth in response to gonadotropin stimulation.
Study funding/competing interest(s): TGF b1 production is stimulated par FSH
and inhibited by LH and appears to decrease with age; So Studies on the follicular
features of the aging ovary are much needed.
Trial registration number: BASIC SCIENCE
i172
P-135
The effect of piezo-assisted biopsy on preimplantation mouse
embryo development and gene expression
M.N.K. Nor-Ashikin1, J.M.Y. Norhazlin 1, S. Norita1, W.J. Wan-Hafizah1,
M. Mohd-Fazirul1, D. Razif2, and B.P. Hoh1
1
Institute of Medical Molecular Biotechnology, Faculty of Medicine Universiti
Teknologi MARA, Sungai Buloh Selangor, Malaysia, 2Faculty of Health Science,
Universiti Teknologi MARA, Puncak Alam Selangor, Malaysia
Study question: Are the development and genes expressed by piezo-biopsied
embryos significantly different from non-biopsied embryos, at morula and blastocyst stages?
Summary answer: A significant difference ( p , 0.05) was observed between the
development of piezo-biopsied and non-biopsied embryos at the blastocyst stage,
and a total of 75 and 66 genes of piezo-biopsied embryos were found significantly
different in expression ( p , 0.05) compared to non-biopsied controls, at morula
and blastocyst stages respectively.
What is known already: Zona breaching by chemical and laser drilling are implicated in delayed development and abnormal hatching of blastocysts. Although it
has been reported that acid Tyrodes biopsy did not significantly affect development and gene expression of blastocysts, the effect of piezo-assisted biopsy on
gene expression has not been examined.
Study design, size, duration: A 2 x 2 factorial study design was used to compare
development and gene expression profiles of non-biopsied with piezo-biopsied
embryos at morula and blastocyst stages. The development of 291 embryos
were observed. Thirty embryos were pooled from each treatment group for
RNA extraction, with three replicates per group.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Piezo-assisted (Eppendorf PiezoXpertw) single-blastomere biopsies were performed on 8-cell ICR mouse
embryos (68 h post-human Chorionic Gonadotropin injection) in Ca2+/
Mg2+-free M2 medium. Biopsied embryos were cultured in M16 medium until
RNA extraction. cDNAwas amplified, labelled and hybridized on the AffymetrixGeneChipw. Microarray was analysed using Gene Spring GX 12.
Main results and the role of chance: Significant difference ( p , 0.05) between
the development of non-biopsied and piezo-biopsied embryos was observed only
at the blastocyst stage (96.8% versus 89.0%, respectively). Gene expression of
non-biopsied and piezo-biopsied mouse embryos were compared at morula and
blastocyst stages, using the unpaired t-test ( p , 0.05), including fold change
of ≥ 1.5 for each gene. At the morula stage, 32 genes were found upregulated
and 43 genes downregulated. At the blastocyst stage, 43 genes were upregulated
and 23 genes downregulated. DAVID pathway analysis software was used for annotation and visualization of statistically significant genes. KEGG database annotated 14 genes for morula and 11 genes for blastocyst into different categories of
pathways. Both stages showed regulation of genes involved in oxidative phosphorylation and fatty acid metabolism.
Limitations, reason for caution: The use of in vivo instead of in vitro fertilized
embryos may have reduced the impact on gene expression profiles. Critical
changes in gene expression profiles may be diluted because of the pooling of
embryos for RNA extraction.
Wider implications of the findings: Elucidation of gene expression of preimplantation embryos after biopsy will add to a better understanding of the effect
of piezo-assisted blastomere biopsy on early development. This knowledge can
subsequently contribute towards the improvement of Assisted Reproductive
Technology (ART) outcomes.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This research was supported by our institutional grant (600-RMI/ST/DANA5/3/Dst(337/2011) and national Fundamental
Research Grant Scheme (600-RMI/ST/FRGS5/3/FST(71/210). Animal procedures were approved by institutional Animal Care and Use Committee
(ACUC-7/11).
Trial registration number: Not applicable
P-136 Retrospective analysis of sperm incubation time pre IVF
insemination
S. Dale, E. Cater, G. Woodhead, L. Jenner, and S. Fishel
CARE Fertility, Embryology, Nottingham, United Kingdom
Study question: Does sperm incubation pre IVF effect fertilisation, embryo transfer and clinical outcome?
Summary answer: From the data presented in the abstract, clinical outcome was
not significantly affected by duration of sperm incubation pre IVF fertilisation.
What is known already: Hyperactivation and capacitation of sperm is known to
be induced by warming to body temperature, as would occur naturally in the
female genital tract, and this is a prerequisite for fertilisation. Seminal plasma inhibits this hyperactivation (Mortimer et al 1998).
Ragaa et al (2008) reported the rate of acrosomally reacted sperm was greatest
after incubation for 5 hours but that a better fertilisation rate was achieved with 3
hours incubation pre-ICSI.
Study design, size, duration: Retrospective analysis, non randomised analysis of
IVF cycles from a single independent UK clinic. 153 continuous IVF cycles
included in analysis from January to October 2012, regardless of age, previous
history, sperm or oocyte source.
Results to be statistically analysed using unpaired t-test and Fisher’s exact test.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Cycle preparation and stimulation
varied as per consultant recommendation based on previous history. Oocyte recovery, insemination, culture and embryo transfer were performed as per protocol.
Transfer day varied between day 3 and day 5 based on embryo development, and
number of embryos transferred varied based on age and previous history.
Main results and the role of chance: 222 patients were included in the study. Of
these 201 achieved embryo transfer. These patients were divided into 2 groups depending on pre IVF sperm incubation times (Group 1 60-89 mins and Group 2
90-119 mins). Fertilisation rates were comparable (71.9%, 72.9%, p ¼ 0.8308 respectively) as were the abnormal fertilisation rates (3pn) (4.3%, 4.4%, p ¼ 0.9222
respectively). Both were analysed using unpaired t tests. Patients that didn’t
achieve embryo transfer due to failed fertilisation, embryo development or
freeze all due to OHSS risk were analysed but showed no correlation. Positive
bhCG (55.4%, 60.6%), clinical pregnancy (47.5%, 47.9%) and biochemical
loss rate (14.3%, 20.9%) were analysed using Fisher’s exact test but showed no
significance (p ¼ 0.5339, p ¼ 1.000 & p ¼ 0.4286 respectively).
Limitations, reason for caution: The study was limited due to a change in laboratory protocol in January 2012. Sperm was incubated for 1-2 hours prior to insemination, therefore data pre 1 hour and post 2 hours is limited. The majority of cases
performed at the clinic are ICSI, giving low numbers for analysis.
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
Summary answer: Culture using the time-lapse incubator largely reduced the frequency of removal and the time required to remove embryos from the culture
chamber, and improved the development rate of blastocysts. Furthermore,
frozen-thawed embryo transfer had high success rates.
What is known already: A time-lapse imaging incubator for embryos facilitates
the observation of embryos within the culture chamber. This can minimize stress
factors such as decrease in temperature, change in culture medium pH, and light
exposure, and may allow ’gentle culturing of ovum
Study design, size, duration: The time-lapse imaging incubator culture group
comprised 428 procedures (350 individuals; average age, 40.1 years) from
whom oocytes were collected from August to December 2012. The conventional
culture group comprised 1273 procedures (757 individuals; average age, 38.5
years) from whom oocytes were collected in 2011.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Embryos were placed in the timelapse imaging incubators (TLI) or the conventional culture incubators (CCI) for
up to 7 days. We removed embryos form culture chamber twice in TLI group
and up to 17 times in CCI group for inspection and changing the medium.
Good quality blastocysts were cryopreserved.
Main results and the role of chance: The rate of obtaining a good quality blastocyst was 43.5% (486 of 1116) in the ES culture group and 33.1% (1032 of 3120) in
the conventional culture group, and the difference was significant (P , 0.05). The
pregnancy rate from frozen-thawed blastocyst transfer in the the time-lapse
imaging incubators culture group and the conventional culture group was
48.9% (65 of 133) and 52.7% (371 of 704), respectively, and there was no significant difference.
Limitations, reason for caution: none
Wider implications of the findings: The improvement of the culture environment by using the time-lapse imaging incubators increased the success rate of
obtaining good quality blastocysts.
Study funding/competing interest(s): No ezternal funding was obtained for this
study.
Trial registration number: Nothing
Abstracts
i173
Abstracts
Wider implications of the findings: There is little literature available regarding
length of time sperm should be incubated for IVF inseminations. There are
many studies discussing sperm activity and capacitation upon which laboratories
must base their protocols for incubation pre insemination. Many of these studies
assess acrosome activity but do not relate to IVF outcome. This study, although
limited, provides evidence that for the specific times of incubation included
there is no statistical difference in outcome.
Study funding/competing interest(s): None
Trial registration number: None
damage. A larger sample in a prospective study will be required to confirm these findings are robust, and whether there is an effect on embryos of younger women.
Study funding/competing interest(s): None
Trial registration number: N/A
P-138 Cyclin E1 as a new ICM marker identifies a discrete lineage in epiblast cells of the human blastocyst
M. Krivega1 and H. Van de Velde2
Vrije Universiteit Brussel, Reproduction and Genetics - REGE, Brussels,
Belgium, 2Vrije Universiteit Brussel and UZ Brussel, Reproduction and Genetics
(REGE) and Centre for Reproductive Medicine (CRG), Brussels, Belgium
1
P-137
The effect of CO2 levels in embryo culture on clinical outcome
Study question: We sought to determine whether a change in CO2 level supplied
to IVF incubators from 6.0% to 5.5% had an effect on fertilization rate (FR) and
clinical pregnancy rate (CPR). This retrospective analysis of women ≤34 and
≥35 years of age was conducted in the context of the recommendations of the
culture media manufacturer.
Summary answer: Although not statistically significant, overall FR was higher with
a CO2 supply of 5.5% compared to 6.0%. In contrast to younger women, a statistically
significant decrease in CPR was observed in the older group of patients when
embryos were cultured under 5.5% rather than 6% CO2 level. There was no statistical
difference in FR for either of the groups under the different CO2 conditions.
What is known already: Most culture media utilize a bicarbonate/CO2 buffer
system to keep pH in the range of 7.2-7.4. Media manufacturing companies recommend a value of CO2, having taken into consideration the Henderson-Hasselbach
equation, under which their media will achieve the desired pH. In theory 1% difference in CO2 should only alter the pH by 0.1. However, as pH is a fundamental
factor impacting oocyte viability and subsequent embryo development, any slight
fluctuation may affect the resulting embryo’s developmental potential.
Study design, size, duration: A retrospective analysis to examine the effects of
changes in CO2 levels on FR and CPR in 384 ART cycles over a 12 month
period from January -December 2012. Results were compared among two different age groups (≤34 and ≥35 years old). A proprietary commercially available
medium was used for gamete/embryo culture.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: In 209 cycles the gametes/embryos
were cultured under 6.0% CO2 supply (Condition A) and in the remaining 175
cycles under 5.5% CO2 supply (Condition B). These conditions were compared
among two different age groups. 72 cycles of Condition A were compared to 54
cycles of Condition B in patients ≤34 years (Group I). 137 cycles of Condition
A were compared to 121 cycles of Condition B in patients ≥35 years (Group
II). T-test was employed to examine the difference in the mean maternal age
among the groups. One sample Z-test with significance level of 0.05 was used
for statistical analysis of FR and CPR.
Main results and the role of chance: The mean maternal age of Group I under
Condition Awas comparable to the mean maternal age of Group I under Condition
B (30.6 years + 3.0 vs. 31.4 years + 2.5, NS). Similar results were observed for
Group II (Condition A: 38.7 years + 2.5 vs. Condition B: 38.4 years + 2.3, NS).
FR in Group I was slightly higher under Condition B than in cycles under Condition A (63.2% vs. 58.4%, NS). Almost identical results were observed when FR
of Group II was compared under different CO2 conditions (Condition B: 60.8% vs.
Condition A: 60.0%; NS).
CPR in Group I under Condition Awas comparable to CPR under Condition B
(41.7% vs. 40.7%, NS). However, a statistically significant decrease in CPR
was observed in Group II under the different CO2 conditions (Condition
A: 28.5 % vs. Condition B: 17.4%; p ≤ 0.05).
Limitations, reason for caution: Though the findings are intriguing, more data is
required to determine whether these findings are valid. Ideally, the pH of the media
should be measured as well as the CO2 levels.
Wider implications of the findings: The data demonstrated that slight difference in
CO2 levels in the IVF culture had significant impact on clinical outcome among older
women. One possible explanation is that when handling gametes/embryos outside
their normal environment, replacing them into an incubator with a higher CO2
level allows for a faster recovery to physiological pH levels; older patients’
embryos due to poorer quality may be more prone to pH fluctuation induced
Study question: This study was aimed to describe new molecular players in
human embryonic cells. In particular, we investigated Cyclin E1 (CCNE1) as a potential regulator of inner cell mass (ICM) in human embryos.
Summary answer: The new marker of ICM in expanding blastocysts, CCNE1, is
restricted to a defined cell type in human blastocysts at the moment of implantation.
What is known already: Cyclin E1 is one of the major regulators of the cell cycle.
It forms a complex with CDK2 (cyclin-dependent kinase 2) and together they
promote transition from G1 to S phases of the cell cycle. CCNE1 protein is
known to be sustained to high levels in pluripotent cells. CCNE1 is necessary
for re-entry of G0 cells into the cell cycle and for oncogenic transformation.
Knock-out studies in mice proved redundancy for CCNE1 and CDK2.
Study design, size, duration: We analyzed the expression pattern of CCNE1 in
human preimplantation embryos and hESC in combination with pluripotency
and early differentiation markers. Day 3 frozen-thawed embryos were cultured
in presence of Roscovitine and harvested on day 6 for gene expression analysis.
HESC were cultured on matrigel and transfected with FUGENE.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: The study was approved by the Local
and Federal Ethical Committees for research on human embryos. Human embryos
were obtained from patients treated for infertility at our IVF Centre. Human embryonic stem cell (hESC) lines had been derived by our group. Samples were analyzed by qRT-PCR and immunocytochemistry.
Main results and the role of chance: CCNE1 protein is exclusively expressed in
nuclei of all ICM cells in expanded blastocysts. Later at the moment of implantation (day 6-7) CCNE1-positive cells only mark NANOG-negative cells of the
epiblast. Inhibition of CCNE1 function during the cell cycle using Roscovitine
did not affect preimplantation embryo development and expression of general embryonic markers for pluripotency and differentiation. Moreover, CCNE1 was
found in hESC, particularly in VIMENTIN-positive cells acquiring epithelialmesenchymal transition and VIMENTIN-negative cells, but not in NANOG
expressing cells. Overexpression of CCNE1 in hESC strongly upregulated
SOX17 and mildly induced GATA4 and GATA6. This effect implies specification
into the endodermal lineage, although SOX17 marks both endoderm progenitors
and PGCs. We currently investigate this hypothesis to find out the nature of
CCNE1-positive epiblast cells.
Limitations, reason for caution: There are limited numbers of good quality
human embryos donated for research.
Wider implications of the findings: The improved knowledge on human preimplantation development will contribute to refine artificial reproductive techniques
and consequently increase live birth rates.
Study funding/competing interest(s): Our research is supported by grants from
the Fund for Scientific Research - Flanders (FWO-Vlaanderen) and the Methusalem (METH) of the VUB.
Trial registration number: none
P-139 Correlation of PRSS35 and SERPINE2 gene expression levels in
cumulus cells with oocyte maturation and the potential as a biomarker to
predict embryo quality
R.K. Lee 1, Y.M. Hwu1, C.H. Lu2, and S.H. Li2
Mackay Memorial Hospital, Department of Obstetrics and Gyneocology, Taipei,
Taiwan R.O.C, 2Mackay Memorial Hospital, Department of Medical Research,
New Taipei, Taiwan R.O.C
1
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
S. Andronikou, G. Francis, S. Tailor, M. Vourliotis, and P.A. Almeida
Chelsea & Westminster Hospital, ACU, London, United Kingdom
i174
P-140
Biologic efficiency of fresh oocytes in a large Italian ART program
in relation to International benchmarks
A. Vaiarelli, R. Antonacci, A. Smeraldi, M. Desgro, E. Albani, A. Baggiani,
E. Zannoni, and P.E. Levi Setti
IRCCS Istituto Clinico Humanitas, Department of Gynecology Division of
Gynecology and Reproductive Medicine, Rozzano, Italy
Study question: Is the ratio of babies delivered in relation to number of utilized
oocytes a constant element in different infertile populations and countries? Aim
of the present study was to compare retrospectively the biological efficiency of
our ART program in relation to USA and European benchmark published data.
Summary answer: Although great differences in term of delivery rates have been
reported between European and USA results, representing still a matter of debate.
The mean number of oocytes utilized to obtain a single baby delivered seems not
significantly different among our results and European and USA benchmarks.
What is known already: A large and constant number of oocytes is needed to
reach a delivered baby. This number seems a constant biological limitation, although improvements in ART technology during the last 30 years have been
implemented. According to the American data “live birth” per oocyte retrieved
was 4.6 %. European data shows that 4.4% to 3.8% (according to the age of
patients) oocytes are needed to deliver a baby.
Study design, size, duration: Retrospective analysis of clinical and embryological data of cycles performed at the Humanitas Clinical and Research Institute (Italy)
in the period from 1 January 2011 – to 31 December 2011.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: 1739 patient’s cycles with 9194
oocytes inseminated (7989 ICSI and 1205 IVF) were analyzed. Mean female
age was 37 + 3.9 years. Data were divided by age into two groups (≤38 A and
≥39 B). Live born rate was calculated from the total number of oocytes including
only fresh embryo transfer.
Main results and the role of chance: The live baby born rate per inseminated
oocytes was 3.5%. In group A and B the live baby born rate was respectively 4.4
% and 2.1% per oocyte used. The number of eggs needed to have a baby was 22.6
in group A while 48.4 in group B. American and European data show no increase
in babies born if . 15-20 oocytes were collected. This range of oocytes could be
the optimal number to maximise delivery rate, minimizing the risk of OHSS in
fresh ART cycles. Our results even without considering pregnancies obtained
from oocytes and embryos cryopreservation are not so far from benchmark results.
Limitations, reason for caution: Our results do not consider cumulative delivery
rate, because most of patients have still cryopreserved oocytes and embryos. Our
data consider only used oocytes and not all mature retrieved oocytes.
Wider implications of the findings: A strict correlation exists between the
number of the eggs collected and babies born in ART cycles. This enormous biological wastage is probably due to the great number of intrinsically abnormal
oocytes. This knowledge could be important in couple’s counseling. Our efforts
should be addressed to modify earlier stages of folliculogenesis, to improve
oocyte intrinsic quality, before ovulation induction, were little could be done.
Study funding/competing interest(s): None
Trial registration number: Not applicable
P-141 Factors affecting the twin-delivery rate in sperm donation
programme
L. Bacer Kermavner1, I. Virant Klun1, B. Pinter2, and E. Vrtacnik-Bokal2
University Medical Centre Ljubljana, Dep. of Obstetrics and Gynaecology - IVF
Laboratory, Ljubljana, Slovenia, 2University Medical Centre Ljubljana, Dep. of
Obstetrics and Gynaecology Reproductive unit, Ljubljana, Slovenia
1
Study question: In our sperm donation programme there is still twin-pregnancy
rate 20%, therefore the aim of this study was to elucidate if the female age and the
number of retrieved or transferred blastocysts affect the twin-delivery rate and the
potential role of elective single embryo transfer (eSET) in these couples.
Summary answer: eSET is recommended in sperm donation programme when at
least 4 good quality blastocysts are developed after prolonged embryo culture regardless the female age.
What is known already: eSET has already became a practice in the in vitro fertilization programme using autologous fresh partner’s semen to prevent the twinpregnancy and to avoid the risk for both the woman and the baby. It is less known
about the factors affecting the twin-pregnancy in the sperm donation programme
using frozen-thawed sperm.
Study design, size, duration: The data on 497 in vitro fertilization cycles using
frozen-thawed donated sperm were performed at our department during the time
period from 2001 to 2011 and were retrospectively analyzed to elucidate the effect
of female age and number of retrieved or transferred blastocysts on twin-delivery
rate in these couples.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: One or two blastocysts were transferred. The couples were divided into three groups: 1.) non-pregnant, 2.) with
single-delivery or 3.) with twin-delivery. All groups were divided according to
the female age (≤36 or .36 years) and compared in terms of the number of
retrieved and transferred blastocysts by the Chi-Square test. Statistical significance was set up at P , 0.05.
Main results and the role of chance: In couples with transferred one blastocyst
the mean number of blastocysts per cycle was lower than in couples with a transfer
of two blastocysts; after the transfer of two blastocyts there was a higher number of
blastocyts per cycle in couples with pregnancy/delivery than in couples with no
pregnancy regardless the female age. In couples with twin-delivery there was a
higher number of blastocysts per cycle (younger: 3.8, older: 4.0) than in
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
Study question: Are PRSS35 and SERPINE2 gene expression levels in cumulus
cells correlated with oocyte maturation, fertilization, and embryo quality?
Summary answer: PRSS35 and SERPINE2 gene expression levels in cumulus
cells were correlated with oocyte maturation and fertilization as well as good
embryo quality.
What is known already: The oocyte is surrounded by several layers of cumulus
cells and that bi-directional communication between the oocyte and the
cumulus cells is crucial for oocyte developmental competence and embryo development. PRSS35, SERPINE2, PTX3, and GJA1 are expressed in human
cumulus cells. PTX3 and GJA1 mRNA levels are known to be associated
with embryo quality. However, the correlation of PRSS35 and SERPINE2 expression levels with oocyte maturation and embryo developmental potential
remains to be clarified.
Study design, size, duration: Total 211 cumulus cell samples of individual
oocytes were obtained from 30 patients in the IVF laboratory. Patients undergoing intracytoplasmic sperm injection treatment program were recruited into
the study.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: PRSS35, SERPINE2, PTX3, and
GJA1 mRNA levels were assessed in cumulus cells of individual oocytes
using quantitative RT-PCR. PTX3 and GJA1 expression levels were also
assayed for reference. The housekeeping gene RPL19, ribosomal protein
L19, was used as the internal loading control to normalize the relative gene
expression levels. Differences were analyzed by one-way analysis of variance
followed by the Bonferroni post hoc test using GraphPad software. P , 0.05
was considered significant.
Main results and the role of chance: Cumulus cells from mature oocytes
expressed significantly lower PRSS35 and SERPINE2 mRNA levels than those
from immature oocytes (P , 0.05 and P , 0.0001, respectively). Conversely,
Cumulus cells surrounding mature oocytes expressed significantly higher PTX3
mRNA levels than those encircling immature oocytes (P , 0.05). GJA1 mRNA
levels also showed the tendency, although there was no significant differences.
PRSS35 mRNA levels were 5-fold lower in cumulus cells from mature and fertilized oocytes than those from mature but non-fertilized oocytes. GJA1, PRSS35,
and SERPINE2 mRNA levels in cumulus cells from mature oocytes that developed to high quality embryos (grades 1 and 2) were also significantly lower
than those developed to poor quality embryos (grades 3 and 4) (P , 0.05).
However, PTX3 mRNA levels exhibited the reverse tendency, which is similar
to the previously published results.
Limitations, reason for caution: A small sample size may cause insufficient
power. Thus, further large cohort studies are required.
Wider implications of the findings: PRSS35 and SERPINE2 mRNA levels in
cumulus cells correlate with oocyte maturation, fertilization, and good-embryo
quality. This may provide novel biomarkers to predict oocyte developmental competence and embryo development.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This work was funded by a grant, NSC
101-2314-B-195-009-MY3, from the National Science Council of Taiwan. is
declared.
Trial registration number: none
Abstracts
i175
Abstracts
couples with single delivery (younger: 2.9, older: 2.1). This indicated that the
number of at least 4 blastocysts retrieved per cycle is an important tool to introduce
the eSET into the embryo transfer strategy regardless the female age. In all couples
with twin-delivery number of blastocyst per cycle was significantly higher than in
couples with single delivery.
Limitations, reason for caution: The number of cycles was realtively low.
Wider implications of the findings: These results indicated that developmental
potential of embryos and a number of blastocysts per cycle may be a good prognostic factor for twin-pregnancy/delivery and an important tool to introduce the
eSET in the sperm donation programme regardless the female age.
Study funding/competing interest(s): The study was performed in the frame of
our clinical programme. There are no competing interests to be declared.
Trial registration number: 0
Differentiation during early human embryogenesis
C. De Paepe1, G. Cauffman2, G. Verheyen2, D. Stoop2, I. Liebaers3, and
H. Van de Velde2
1
Vrije Universiteit Brussel, Department of Reproduction and Genetics (REGE),
Jette, Belgium, 2Universitair Ziekenhuis Brussel, Centre for Reproductive
Medicine (CRM), Jette, Belgium, 3Universitair Ziekenhuis Brussel, Centre for
Medical Genetics (CMG), Jette, Belgium
Study question: How are the trophectoderm (TE) key regulators CDX2, TEAD4
and YAP expressed during early human embryogenesis?
Summary answer: In human embryos, the restriction of TE-specific components
to the TE occurs after expansion of the embryo, when the two cell lineages (TE
versus inner cells mass (ICM)) are morphologically distinguishable, suggesting a
role for other molecules in the initial segregation between the ICM and TE lineages.
What is known already: In mice, the Hippo Signaling pathway has been described
in the first lineage segregation (Nishioka et al. 2009). Differences in cell-cell contacts
through differences in cell position lead to activation or inactivation of YAP, which
subsequently can activate or inactivate TEAD4 in the nucleus and consequently
regulate CDX2 expression in the inner versus outer cells. In the human it is not
known how these Hippo signaling pathway components regulate TE specification.
Study design, size, duration: In this study, human preimplantation embryos were
analysed for the expression of the transcription factors CDX2 and TEAD4, and the
co-activator protein YAP. Both localization within the embryo and the timespecific expression were analysed.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: The study was approved by the Local
and Federal Ethical Committees for research on human embryos. Good quality
embryos were obtained at our IVF Laboratory after informed consent of the
patients. They were fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde, permeabilized with 0,1%
triton and stained for the respective proteins using immunocytochemistry.
Main results and the role of chance: In cleavage-stage embryos, compaction and
early blastocyst stages CDX2 was found weakly cytoplasmic. From the full blastocyst
stage onwards, some cells showed nuclear CDX2 expression. In expanded blastocysts CDX2 was found either in the TE nuclei or in the ICM and TE nuclei. In hatching/hatched blastocysts CDX2 was found in the ICM and TE nuclei except for one big
hatched blastocyst that started to downregulate CDX2 expression in ICM nuclei. YAP
and TEAD4 started to be expressed in the nuclei of some cells of late cleavage-stage
and compacted embryos. In expanded, hatching and hatched blastocysts TEAD4 and
YAP were expressed in ICM and TE nuclei, except for one big hatched blastocyst in
which YAP started to become downregulated in the nuclei of ICM cells.
Limitations, reason for caution: Due to ethical concerns the amount of material
is limited. This work is rather descriptive, but functional studies will be performed
in the future.
Wider implications of the findings: Information about the key players leading to
the first lineage segregation in the human embryo and the mechanisms underlying
differentiation will contribute to our basic knowledge on human embryogenesis.
This fundamental research is unique and crucial to the field of reproductive medicine. Even though a lot is known about this subject in mice, results obtained in the
human are different. This study shows that data obtained in mice cannot always be
extrapolated to humans.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This research is supported by grants
from the Scientific Research Foundation- Flanders (FWO-Vlaanderen) and the
Research Council (OZR) of the VUB.
Trial registration number: None
A. Stecher, B. Wirleitner, P. Vanderzwalmen, M. Zintz, A. Neyer, M. Bach,
B. Baramsai, D. Schwerda, and N.H. Zech
IVF-Centers Prof. Zech Bregenz GmbH, Bregenz, Austria
Study question: Low fertilization rates (FR) -predominantly observed in severe
male factor patients- negatively affects IVF outcome. We evaluated whether activation with calcium ionophore after sperm injection increases FR in these patients
and studied the impact on blastocyst development, implantation rates (IR) and
pregnancy rates (PR) in a sibling study.
Summary answer: Oocyte activation significantly increased FR in male factor infertility (e.g. severe OAT, testicular sperm extraction) and unexplained fertilization
failure. Activation did not compromise blastocyst development but led to a higher
number of fertilized embryos. Thus, overall more blastocysts with similar potential
to implant are achieved per cycle.
What is known already: To release the meiotic arrest in the oocyte and initiate the
fertilization process, repeated calcium oscillations are essential. One main trigger
for this intracellular signal was identified as the sperm-specific phospholipase C
zeta I. Therefore failed fertilization is thought to be mainly a sperm factor. FR
was shown to be increased with oocyte activation by calcium ionophore in patients
with previous implantation failure and case series described no impact on health of
babies born.
Study design, size, duration: This prospective study included 62 IVF-cycles
between November 2009 and December 2012. Inclusion criteria were severe male
factor infertility and/or unexplained fertilization failure (,30%) in previous cycles.
Sibling analysis was performed. Injected oocytes were randomly grouped in half
and allocated either to the active or non-activated group for direct comparison.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: ICSI or IMSI was performed 2-3
hours post-OPU. Half of the injected oocytes of each patient were activated
with calcium ionophore. FR was checked 17 hours post injection, embryo
quality on day 3 and blastocyst rate on day 5 before embryo transfer. IR was calculated by embryonic heart beat/embryo transferred.
Main results and the role of chance: In 62 OPUs 966 oocytes were retrieved and
798 MII oocytes were injected. Of 397 non-activated oocytes 256 (64.5%) were
fertilized on day 1 as compared to 302/401 in activated (75.3%; p , 0.001). In
the further development the blastocyst rate/ MII oocyte was 31.8% without activation as compared to 36.6% with calcium ionophore. On day 5 the best blastocysts
were chosen for transfer by morphological criteria. In the male-factor group the
number of transferred blastocysts was the same in both groups, but in the
non-male factor patients more embryos from the non-activated group were
chosen. Similar pregnancy rates (54.5% vs. 52.9%) were obtained with nonactivated and activated, the IR was 35.3% vs. 29.6% and the ongoing PR 45.5%
vs. 41.2%.
Limitations, reason for caution: A higher number of cases as well as a long-term
follow-up of the children’s health will be necessary to prove the safety of this procedure.
Wider implications of the findings: Our results are in line with the literature.
Additionally, we show for the first time, that oocyte activation does not negatively
impact on blastocyst development. Similar IR and ongoing PR for activated and
non-activated sibling embryos were observed. By applying this technique the
total number of developing blastocysts/ cycle is increased. This may lead to a
higher cumulative PR.
Study funding/competing interest(s): None
Trial registration number: Informed consent was signed by all patients.
P-144 Synchronized blastomere cleavage at cryopreservation: Effect on
subsequent embryo survival, pregnancy and live birth rates
Z. Wiener-Megnazi, M. Fridman, M. Koifman, S. Lahav-Baratz, I. Blais,
R. Auslender, and M. Dirnfeld
Carmel Medical Hospital, IVF Unit Obstetrics and Gynecology, Haifa, Israel
Study question: To evaluate the effect of blastomere synchronicity of frozen
embryos on post - thaw survival, morphological grading and outcome parameters
in frozen embryo transfer (FET) cycles.
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
P-142
P-143 Oocyte activation increases fertilization rate resulting in a higher
final number of blastocysts without compromising implantation potential
per transferred embryo: a sibling prospective study
i176
Abstracts
P-145
Histidine-rich glycoprotein improves embryo development
H. Åkerud, K. Lindgren, K. Kårehed, K. Wånggren, and J. Hreinsson
Department of Women’s and Children’s Health, Uppsala University, Uppsala,
Sweden
Study question: Does a Histidine-rich glycoprotein (HRG) peptide improve
human embryo development and is the Embryoscope useful for evaluation of
embryo development?
Summary answer: A 35 amino-acid long HRG peptide seems to improve human
embryo development and maturation when added to culture media. An Embryoscope is useful for monitoring embryo development.
What is known already: Histidine-rich glycoprotein (HRG) is a protein known to
interact with a number of different biological pathways. We have previously
shown that a single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) in the HRG gene (HRG
C633T) is associated with recurrent miscarriages and pregnancy success rate
after IVF treatment. In addition, infertility seems to associate with the HRG genotype. The different pathways through which HRG affects embryo development,
implantation and placentation are not yet well established.
Study design, size, duration: The study was designed as a case-control study and
was approved by the regional ethics committe. Fourty-eight couples donated their
surplus embryos which were cultured for four days and continoulsy monitored by
a time-lapse methodology using an Embryoscope (UniSense Fertilitech, Denmark).
Participants/materials, setting, methods: The study was carried out at the Reproductive Center, Akademiska sjukhuset, Uppsala, Sweden. Embryos frozen
on day two after fertilization were thawed and cultured with or without HRG
peptide added to culture media. Time-lapse sequences were used for timing of developmental events and to set final blastocyst scores.
Main results and the role of chance: After four days of culture 71% of the
embryos in the peptide group (n ¼ 24) and 58% of the embryos in the control
group (n ¼ 24) had developed to blastocysts. 46% of the embryos in the
peptide group and 25% of the embryos in the control group were given the
highest final blastocyst scores. The time needed from first cleavage to development of morula differed significantly between the groups (43.1 + 9.8 h peptide
group vs 34.6 + 14.3 h control group, p ¼ 0.049). In conclusion, the embryos
cultured with the HRG peptide added developed slower and the difference in
time needed between first cleavage and development of morula might reflect a
better timing of events of relevance for adequate maturation of an embryo.
Limitations, reason for caution: This is a relatively small study and the results
need to be confirmed in a larger study population. Also, the protocol for scoring
the embryos is new and needs to be evaluated further. The results are although significant and the protocol was easy to use and reproducible.
Wider implications of the findings: The results indicate that HRG is a protein of
importance in human embryo development and that the HRG peptide might be of
interest to add to culture media to optimize maturation of embryos and also to
improve IVF treatment results. The Embryoscope is useful for evaluation of
human embryo development.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This study was funded by Swedish
Society of Medicine and the Family Planning Foundation in Uppsala, Sweden.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Trial registration number: Not applicable
P-146 The efficacy of hyaluronate (HA): a comparative study to evaluate
the selection of mature sperm in ICSI-IMSI cycles
S. Rovira1, J.M. Capdevila1, B. Freijomil1, C. Castelló 1, A. Farreras1,
P. Fernández1, M. Asensio1, M. López-Teijón2, and E. Velilla 1
1
Instituto Marques, Reproductive Biology, Barcelona, Spain, 2Instituto Marques,
Reproduction Medicine Service, Barcelona, Spain
Study question: The objective of the study is to determine whether or not sperm
selection by means of hyaluronate selection by SpermSlow is better than polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) in terms of the subsequent embryo fertilisation rates, viability, and pregnancy rates, in patients with teratozoospermia who undergo ICSI or
ICSI-IMSI.
Summary answer: There is a statistically significant increase in the number of
viable embryos created when hyaluronate rather than PVP is used to select
sperm prior to ICSI. This difference was not noted if IMSI is used. No statistically
significant difference was noted in fertilisation rates or pregnancy rates with hyaluronate.
What is known already: Mature sperm have receptors for hyaluronic acid, a
protein found on the outer membrane of the oocyte. These sperm can then
remodel the protein on the oocyte. Hyaluronidate in the microinjection media
improves the selection of sperm with greater DNA integrity (Gabor Huszar,
2003), improves fertilisation rates (Nasr-Esfahani, 2008) and improves embryo
quality, development and implantation (Parmegiani, 2009; 2010). However,
these improvements have not been noted in all groups (Van der Bergh, 2009).
Study design, size, duration: A prospective year-long study was set up in 2012 to
compare hyaluronate (HA) by SpermSlow media (Medicult) and polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) (Vitrolife). The comparison was made both in patients who
used ICSI and those who used IMSI-ICSI, resulting in the creation of 4
groups:G1: PVP-ICSI, G2: HA-ICSI, G3: PVP-IMSI-ICSI; G4: HA-IMSI-ICSI.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Inclusion criteria included all
pacients who required egg donation, and whose partner’s sperm showed a
severe teratozoospermia (normal morphology ,4%, Kruger et al, 1988).
Main results and the role of chance: 537 oocytes were fertilised, 323 using
PVP-ICSI (G1) and 214 using HA-ICSI (G2). No significant differences were
noted between the two groups in terms of fertilisation rates (76,47% vs 77,1%
p ¼ 0,8652), nor pregnancy rates (41,46% vs 46,43 p ¼ 0,6829). There was
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
Summary answer: Embryos with both synchronous and asynchronous blastomere cleavage can be safely cryopreserved. Embryos for cryopreservation
should be selected by classical embryo grading and not by the criteria of synchronicity of blastomere cleavage.
What is known already: While morphologic scoring of embryos in IVF is
estimated subjectively, number of blastomeres and the distinction between
synchronous and asynchronous cleavage are objective parameters. Embryos with
synchronized blastomere cleavage are usually preferentially selected for cryopreservation. Time-lapse analysis techniques implicated synchronicity of blastomere
cleavage as a possible predictor of treatment success.
Study design, size, duration: Retrospective analysis of 1060 FET cycles performed from 2004 - 2006. Cycles were divided into 3 groups: 1: cycles with
only embryos with synchronous blastomere cleavage were frozen; 2: cycles
with only embryos with asynchronous blastomere cleavage were frozen; 3:
cycles with both, synchronous and asynchronous blastomere cleavage embryos
frozen.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: One thousand and sixty FET cycles
were analyzed. Clinical and laboratory data was recorded and analyzed. Main
outcome parameters were: Post - thaw embryo survival, morphologic grading,
pregnancy and live birth rates.
Main results and the role of chance: Out of 1863 embryos, embryo survival rate
was 68%; in 90%, ≥1 embryo survived. This was similar among all groups. Full
blastomere survival rate was higher among the synchronous group (62.7%,
43.3%, 38.3% respectively, P ¼ 0.0001). Mean and maximal embryo grading at
cryopreservation and at thawing were higher among the synchronous group
(P ¼ 0.0001, P ¼ 0.037, P ¼ 0.004, P ¼ 0.03, respectively). When controlled
for number of thawed embryos, differences remained significant for 2 embryos
(P ¼ 0.028). Mean and maximal thawing parameters were in association with
conception. (P ¼ 0.056, P ¼ 0.023, respectively). Groups were similar regarding
pregnancy and live birth rates. In a multivariate regression analysis, number of
transferred embryos and maximal embryo grading at thawing affected the occurrence of conception (P ¼ 0.021, P ¼ 0.027, respectively).
Limitations, reason for caution: Validity of results may be limited due to the
retrospective nature of the study.
Wider implications of the findings: Our study suggests that synchronicity of
blastomere cleavage at cryopreservation should not serve as a criteria to select
embryos for freezing. Although some of the embryo survival parameters were
better among synchronous embryos, this was not associated with the chances of
implantation. Therefore, the implantation potential of asynchronous and synchronous thawed embryos should be regarded as equal, in the same manner as
fresh embryos, and not be discarded from being candidates for cryopreservation
as such.
Study funding/competing interest(s): The study was not funded by any commercial company. There were no competing interests in the study.
Trial registration number: The study is not an RCT, so there is no need for a study
registration number.
i177
Abstracts
P-147
Oocyte maturity rate as function of time from ovulation trigger to
oocyte aspiration in IVF-ICSI cycles
A. Weiss 1, R. Neril2, J. Geslevich 1, R. Beck-Fruchter1, M. Lavee1, J. Golan1,
A. Ermoshkin1, and E. Shalev2
1
Emek Medical Center, Obstetrics and Gynecology, Afula, Israel, 2TechnionIsrael Institute of Technology, Rappaport Faculty of Medicine, Haifa, Israel
Study question: Is the rate of oocyte maturity dependent on the time from ovulation trigger to oocyte aspiration within a four hour time frame during which the
pickup procedures take place and does variation in this time interval warrant individualized scheduling of ovulation induction injection and oocyte aspiration?
Summary answer: Thirty four hours is the minimum time required from oocyte maturation injection to ovum pickup. Variation in time between 34 and 37 hours did not
affect the maturity rate of oocytes. Within this time frame there is no need for indivualized scheduling of ovulation induction injection and oocyte aspiration.
What is known already: In spite of the prevalence of IVF, few studies have
addressed the exact timing of oocyte aspiration after ovulation trigger. While 36
hours is an accepted time interval, the outpatient nature of the procedure may
make meticulous timing of oocyte pickup difficult. Furthermore, advances in
IVF, such as the emergence of antagonist protocols and the introduction of
GnRH agonist for ovulation trigger in high responders, may make older studies
obsolete.
Study design, size, duration: A retrospective study analyzing 526 IVF/ICSI
cycles from January 2010 to May 2012.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Patients were instructed to inject HCG
(or GNRH agonist for high responders) at 23:00 two days prior to ovum pickup.
Patients were aspirated in the order they arrived at the clinic. The time of ovum
pickup, laboratory and patient records were analyzed retrospectively.
Main results and the role of chance: A total of 526 ICSI cycles were analyzed.
On average 8.38 + 6.22 oocytes were aspirated per cycle. Overall, 64 + 28% of
aspirated oocytes were MII oocytes. A one-way ANOVA demonstrated that
oocyte maturity differed significantly among four different time groups: 33.45
to 34 hours (n ¼ 94), 34 to 35 hours (n ¼ 256), 35 to 36 hours (n ¼ 125) and
36 to 37 hours (n ¼ 34); [F (3,506) ¼ 5.244, P , .001]. Tukey post hoc comparison of the four groups, showed that only the first group differed significantly from
each of the other three groups (54 + 31%, 66 + 27%, 66 + 27% and 72 + 25%
respectively). The time groups did not differ regarding other clinical and treatment
parameters.
Limitations, reason for caution: The study is limited by its retrospective nature.
The sample size was sufficient to reach significance, though the fourth time group
is smaller than the other three time groups.
Wider implications of the findings: Simply changing the time patients are
instructed to administer the ovulation triggering agent from 23:00 to 22:00
should increase the rate of MII oocytes in our unit. There is no need to individualize
and meticulously schedule injections and ovum pickups as long as between 34 and
37 hours transpire. Further studies should reveal if an even longer delay will increase or decrease MII oocyte maturity rates.
Study funding/competing interest(s): We declare no outside funding or competing interest.
Trial registration number: The study was approved by the local ethics committee. Due to its retrospective non-interventional nature, trial registration is not
required.
P-148 Factors related to clinical pregnancy of vitrified-warmed embryo
transfer: a retrospective and multivariate logistic regression analysis of
2313 transfer cycles
W. Shi, S. Zhang, W. Zhao, X.I.A. Xue, M.I.N. Wang, H. Bai, and J. Shi
Maternal & Child Health Care Hospital, Assisted Reproduction Center,
Xi’anShaan’xi, China
Study question: what factors affect clinical pregnancy in vitrified-warmed
embryo transfer (VET)?
Summary answer: Assisted hatching (AH) had a positive effect on clinical
pregnancy and the reason of freezing was one of the most significant factors
related to the clinical pregnancy of VET.No. of embryos transferred showed
the lowest relative importance in 8 variables on the effect of successful clinical
pregnancy.
What is known already: Most previous studies have analyzed some of the factors
related to the outcome of VET using one-factor analysis. To take account of confounding factors such as patient age, embryo quality, number of embryos to transfer, different laboratory procedure and clinical alternations, it is important to
perform a multivariate logistic regression analysis to determine which one or a
group of factors are most related to clinical pregnancy of VET.
Study design, size, duration: The study was a retrospective analysis of 2313 VET
cycles from 1481 patients performed between January 2008 and April 2012.
A multivariate logistic regression analysis was performed to identify the factors
to affect clinical pregnancy outcome of VET.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: There were 22 candidate variables
identified from clinical experiences and the literature. Eleven variables were
chosen by a bootstrapping stepwise variable selection algorithm (n ¼ 1000)
with the thresholds of aentry ¼ aremoval ¼ 0.05 for both variable entry and variable
removal.3 factors were excluded and 8 factors were chosen to contribute the
model.
Main results and the role of chance: For the reason of freezing, OHSS group
showed a high OR than the other groups (OHSS vs Other, OR: 2.145 CI:
1.4-3.286; Supplement vs Other, OR: 1.152 CI: 0.761-1.743). Assisted hatching
also showed a high OR (OR: 2.105, CI: 1.554-2.85). The 3 variables (age of COH,
damaged blastomere, and presence of blood on catheter) had an adverse effect on
the outcome of VET (b , 0).
The number of good-quality embryos showed the highest marginal PEV and
partial PEV (marginal PEV 3.91%, partial PEV 2.28%). The reason of freezing
showed the second highest marginal PEV (2.77%). However, No. of embryos
transferred showed the lowest marginal PEV and partial PEV (marginal PEV
0.21%, partial PEV 0.46%).
Limitations, reason for caution: This was a retrospective multivariate analysis of
the data obtained in 5 years from a single IVF center. Prospective analysis of large
data sites from a multicentre study is necessary to confirm this finding .
Wider implications of the findings: Except for the quality of embryos and the
number of good embryos, assisted hatching and the reason for freezing were
two important variables on clcinical pregnancy of VET.No. of embryos transferred
showed less relative importance on the effect of successful clinical pregnancy
Study funding/competing interest(s): This study was financially supported by
the Scientific and Technological Research Projects of Shaanxi Province (project
number: 2011k15-02-01). All the authors have to declare.
Trial registration number: N/A
P-149 Understanding the impact of Assisted Reproductive Technologies
(ART) on embryo health, child health and disease and longevity in later life
H.L. Smith1, L. Shaw1, S. Kimber1, and D. Brison2
1
University of Manchester, reproductive medicine, Manchester, United Kingdom,
2
St. Mary’s Hospital, reproductive medicine, Manchester, United Kingdom
Study question: To use existing microarray data and amplified cDNAs from different stages of human embryo development to investigate the expression of
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
however a significant difference in the number of embryos that continued to evolve
– i.e. the number of viable embryos created (G1: 112: 45,34% - vs G2: 102:
61,82%, p ¼ 0,001).
516 oocytes were fertilised, 361 using PVP-IMSI-ICSI (G3) and 155 using
HA-IMSI-ICSI (G4). No significant differences were noted between the two
groups in terms of fertilisation rates (70,91% vs 69,03% p ¼ 0,6679), pregnancy
rates (47,73% vs 35,29 p ¼ 0,3807), or in the number of viable embryos created
(G3: 179: 69,92% - vs G4: 69: 64,49%, p ¼ 0,3101).
Limitations, reason for caution: The study was not randomised.
Wider implications of the findings: The use of hyaluronate in order to select
mature sperm prior to ICSI would appear to be a good technique to improve
embryo viability in patients with teratozoospermia, and therefore could be used
as an alternative to IMSI.
Study funding/competing interest(s): Not applicable.
Trial registration number: Not applicable.
i178
P-150
Developmental regulation of apoptosis related-genes during early
embryonic development: a comparison between human and mouse species
I. Boumela1, S. Assou1, D. Haouzi1, O. Ait Ahmed1, H. Dechaud2, and
S. Hamamah3
1
CHU Montpellier Institute for Research in Biotherapy Hôpital Saint-Eloi,
INSERM U1040, Montpellier Cedex5, France, 2CHU Montpellier Institute for
Research in Biotherapy Hôpital Saint-Eloi, Hôpital Arnaud de Villeneuve Dept. of
Ob/Gyn, Montpellier Cedex5, France, 3CHU Montpellier Institute for Research
in Biotherapy Hôpital Saint-Eloi, INSERM U1040 Hôpital Arnaud de Villeneuve
Dept. of ART/PGD, Montpellier Cedex5, France
Study question: What are the apoptotic-regulatory genes expressed during early
embryonic development in humans and mice and are they comparable between the
two species?
Summary answer: The apoptotic machinery is expressed during human and
mouse early embryonic development. Although some differences may exist,
most apoptosis-related genes exhibit similar expression patterns in both species.
What is known already: Apoptotic cell death has been reported in human and
mouse oocytes and pre-implantation embryos in vivo and in vitro, but its regulation and the conservation of the molecular factors between human and mice are not
well known.
Study design, size, duration: This experimental study included 15 patients referred to our ART department for IVF treatment and 25 mice (B6CBAF1)
between 2010 and 2012. Both patients and female mice underwent controlled
ovarian stimulation.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Human mature MII oocytes, 8-cell
stage embryos and blastocysts were included after informed consent of the patients
and IRB approval. Mouse MII oocytes, 2-cell stage embryos and balstocysts were
collected from mice in vivo. Using DNA microarray, the expression profiles of
apoptosis-related genes were determined before and after embryonic genome activation (EGA) in human and mouse.
Main results and the role of chance: In human, genes involved in the extrinsic
pathway of apoptosis are overexpressed in MII oocytes (Edar, ×11, p ¼ 0.008)
and day5 blastocysts (Tnfrsf10b, ×10, p ¼ 0.03; Tnfrsf21, ×115, p ¼ 0.04)
while in mouse Tnfrsf25 and Tnfsf12 are constitutively expressed. Several
members of the Bcl2 family, that regulate the intrinsic pathway, show similar
expression patterns in human and mouse such as for Bcl2l10 which followed a maternal profile (×10, p ¼ 0.01; ×3.5, p ¼ 0.03) and Mcl1 which was overexpressed after EGA at the 8- and 2-cell stages in human and mouse respectively
(×8, p ¼ 0.008; ×6, p ¼ 0.002). Among the numerous caspase genes expressed
during preimplantation development, Caspase6 showed differential expression
patterns between the two species with abundant levels in human MII oocytes
(×7, p ¼ 0.01) and a specific increase in mouse blastocysts (×12, p ¼ 0.008).
Limitations, reason for caution: Human and mouse oocytes and embryos were
obtained after controlled ovarian stimulation, and thus the gene expression profiles of apoptosis-related genes could have been influenced. In addition, the in
vitro culture conditions of human embryos may also have an impact.
Wider implications of the findings: This study opens new perspectives for
understanding the molecular regulation of oocyte and pre-implantation embryo
survival and death.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This work was partially supported by a
grant from Ferring Pharmaceuticals company. The authors of the study have no
competing interests to report.
Trial registration number: Not applicable
P-151 Ultrastructural alterations in different developmental stages of
in vivo and in vitro preimplantation murine embryos exposed to
cryopreservation
R. Dasiman1, A.R. Nor-Shahida2, W.J. Wan-Hafizah2, J.M.Y. Norhazlin 2,
M. Mohd-Fazirul2, O. Salina2, R.A.F. Gabriele2, and M.N.K. Nor-Ashikin2
1
Universiti Teknologi Mara, Faculty Of Health Science, Puncak Alam Selangor,
Malaysia, 2Universiti Teknologi Mara, Faculty Of Medicine, Sungai Buloh
Selangor, Malaysia
Study question: This study was designed to address the issues listed below:
1) Which stage of development is best for cryopreservation in vivo and in vitro
embryos?
2) What are the effects of cryopreservation using vitrification and slow
freezing methods on ultrastructural organizations of the in vivo and in vitro
embryos?
Summary answer: The findings indicated that 8-cell stage of in vivo and in vitro
embryos is more suitable for cryopreservation in terms of embryonic cryotolerance and ultrastructural damages. Highly significant changes were observed in
the ultrastructural organizations of both in vivo and in vitro cryopreserved
embryos (p , 0.001).
What is known already: Ultrastructural organizations of the preimplantation
embryos are highly unique and consist of a fragile intracellular network of microfilaments and microtubules that is essential for embryonic development. The organizations undergo dramatic architectural changes which show variable
physiological necessities and requirements in order to survive. Cryopreservation
reduced embryonic survivability and caused deleterious changes on the
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
metabolic and epigenetic pathways identified as important in embryonic health,
disease and longevity, e.g. mTOR, IGF, AMPK and zfp57.
Summary answer: Genetic variability between embryos results in inconsistent
expression of many of the key genes. However, several alternative genetic and epigenetic pathway members appear to be differentially expressed between different
stages of development, indicating potential points of control in embryo development.
What is known already: Many studies have shown the relationship between the
maternal environment and offspring health, using animal models and epidemiological data. Children with diabetic mothers/ pre-blastocyst stage embryos
removed from a diabetic environment have an increased risk of developing
obesity, diabetes and metabolic syndrome in later life. Mouse studies demonstrate
the importance of epigenetic methylation stability during embryonic development. However few studies have attempted to clarify the link between the environment/ART technology and human embryo health.
Study design, size, duration: To use existing microarray data and amplified
cDNAs from different stages of human embryo development. Initial analysis conducted on oocytes, 4cell and blastocyst stage embryos, 3 samples per developmental stage.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Embryos were donated by patients
undergoing IVF at St. Mary’s hospital, Manchester, UK. cDNA was amplified
via polyAPCR and analysed using the Affymetrix microarray HG U133 plus 2
chip, at the Paterson cancer Institute, Manchester. CEL. files are downloaded
and statistical analysis performed within Partek and Metacore.
Main results and the role of chance: The epigenetic regulator Trim28 was shown
to be expressed during early human embryonic development. Although Trim28
was not differentially expressed between stages, its co-repressing binding
partner MM-1 was 98 fold over-expressed in oocytes/4cell stage, but not at the
blastocyst stage. MM-1 over-expression may lead to increased methylated
regions, transcription factor inhibition and a point of gene silencing within
oocyte/embryo development. IGF-related genes are also suggested as key
points of metabolic control, relating the maternal nutrient availability to downstream pathways in the embryo. IGFBP1 was heavily (373 fold) over-expressed
in oocytes compared to blastocysts. IGFBPs bind and inhibit IGF’s therefore
the differential regulation is an apparent point of control in oocyte and embryo development. A number of other genes were upregulated by the blastocyst stage.
Limitations, reason for caution: The number of samples was kept low in order to
focus on genetic variability, however; utilisation of other microarray samples
within the database will help clarify/verify findings. Embryos are inherently different to one another and therefore less stringent settings need to be applied to
identify trends in gene expression.
Wider implications of the findings: Understanding developmentally important
pathways which may be perturbed by ARTaids our understanding of potential risk
factors to which human embryos are subject in vitro. Assessing the perturbation of
such genes in response to ART is an essential part of a fully-informed risk assessment. This will ultimately lead to increased understanding of long term health outcomes for ART children and will help to improve ART conditions to avoid
unwanted impacts.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This research is funded by the European
Commission under the FP7 Health programme, as part of the EpiHealth consortium (co-ordinator Professor Andras Dinnyes)
Trial registration number: no trial registration number
Abstracts
Abstracts
P-152
Time-lapse microscopic analysis for exploring the dynamics of
embryonic cell cycles following blastomere biopsy
D. Ben-Yosef, T. Shwartz, T. Cohen, A. Carmon, N. Mey Raz, M. Malcov,
T. Frumkin, B. Almog, I. Vagman, R. Kapustiansky, A. Reches, F. Azem, and
A. Amit
Tel Aviv Sourasky Medical Center, Racine IVF Unit, Tel Aviv, Israel
Study question: Preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) involves the aspiration
of single blastomeres from a 6-8 cell embryo at day 3 of development. This study
explored the dynamics of the developmental events following blastomere biopsy
by determining the timing of subsequent cleavages and compaction following
culture in the EmbryoScopeTM concomitantly with time-lapse analysis.
Summary answer: Analysis of morphokinetic parameters enables unraveling of
developmental events associated with blastomere biopsy. Synchronized cleaving
embryos biopsied at the 8-cell stage enter the next cell cycle later than nonsynchronized ones. The latter are biopsied during the M phase of the cycle, thus
resuming cleavage or entering compaction shortly after biopsy.
What is known already: Morphokenetics evaluated by time-lapse analysis was
recently added to the embryo scoring system to assist in embryo selection. To
date, selection of healthy embryos following PGD was based mainly on their
dynamic development following biopsy as observed by static evaluation, i.e., addition of cells following cleavage and/or compaction. There is only one publication
(Kirkegaard et al., 2012) in which time-lapse analysis was performed following
blastomere biopsy in order to study its effect on embryo development.
Study design, size, duration: Embryos from all PGD treatments from September,
2012 to date were cultured in a time-lapse incubator (EmbryoScopeTM) until days
4-5 after fertilization. Images of 178 embryos from 24 couples carriers of genetic
disorders were acquired every 20 min. Time-points of key embryonic events
before and after embryo biopsy were registered.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Participants included 13 couple carriers of monogenic disorders and 11 couple carriers of chromosomal translocations. The acquired images of each embryo were retrospectively analyzed with
the EmbryoViewer by image analysis software. All the selected embryo developmental events were annotated together with their corresponding time points (in
hours) after insemination.
Main results and the role of chance: Blastomere biopsy was performed at
71.2 + 2.9h post ICSI on embryos with 8.6 + 1.4 cells. A dynamic in embryo development was observed within 7.8 + 4.7h following biopsy: most embryos
(77.5%) initially cleaved, as evidenced by the addition of blastomeres, followed
by compaction. Interestingly, embryos biopsied at the 8-cell stage took longer to
progress into subsequent developmental stages compared to embryos which
underwent biopsy at a stage 8 cells (median 8.8h vs. 4.4h until cleavage and
22h vs. 10h until compaction, respectively). Fifty of the 178 cultured embryos
were diagnosed as inheriting the normal allele (41 embryos transferred; 9
frozen). In 21 cycles 41 healthy embryos were transferred resulting in 8 pregnancies and 9 beating hearts (38% ongoing pregnancy rate; 22% implantation rate).
Limitations, reason for caution: These new findings warrant validation in a
larger cohort of embryos.
Wider implications of the findings: Blastomere biopsy at ≏70 h postfertilization probably does not interfere with the embryonic cell cycle. This supports our previous observations that non-synchronized cleaving embryos with a
good cleavage pattern probably have the same potential for further development
as synchronized cleaving embryos. These findings make it possible to explore
the timing of developmental events characterizing human preimplantation
embryos, and they may have broader implications in choosing the optimal
timing for blastomere biopsy for PGD.
Study funding/competing interest(s): No funding,
Trial registration number: 06/214
P-153 An additive model using morphokinetics to predict embryos of
highest implantation potential
M. Cetinkaya, C. Pirkevi, H. Yelke, Y. Kumtepe, Z. Atayurt, and S. Kahraman
Istanbul Memorial Hospital, Assisted Reproductive Technologies and
Reproductive Genetics Center, Istanbul, Turkey
Study question: Can we predict embryos with highest implantation potential from
morphokinetic parameters obtained until day3?
Summary answer: The five formulas cited below were used to identify cleavage
synchronicity: (F1): (t8-t2)/((t3-t2) + (t5-t4)); (F2): (t8-t5)/(t8-t4); (F3): (t4-t3)/
(t4-t2); (F4): (t4-t2)/(t8-t4); (F5): (t3-t2), additionally two criteria (irregular divisions and evenness of blastomeres at 2 and 4-cell stages) were applied to build an
additive embryo scoring model predicting implantation.
What is known already: A hierarchical model, predicting embryo implantation,
was built through the retrospective morphokinetic analysis of 247 embryos (Meseguer et al., 2011). The most predictive parameters were described as being; first, the
time of division to 5 cells (t5), followed by, the time between division to 3 cells and
subsequent division to 4 cells (s2) and the time between division to 2 cells and division to 3 cells (cc2).
Study design, size, duration: This retrospective cohort study was conducted
between October 2011 and October 2012 in a private ART Center and approved
by the institutional review board. The study included 454 embryo having a (t8)
with known implantation data (KID ¼ 0 or1) from 257 infertile patients
(Female age: 33.1 + 5.1; BMI: 24.4 + 6.8; MII: 5.3 + 4.1).
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Embryos were cultured in a single step
culture medium, which was refreshed on day3. Incubation was performed under
oil at 378C, 5%O2 and 6%CO2. Each time of cleavage was recorded. Clinical pregnancy was defined as the presence of a gestational sac with fetal heartbeat detected
on ultrasound on week7.
Main results and the role of chance: Embryos should mainly stay in even cell
stages, which should be balanced when compared to each other, ideally reflecting
cleavage synchronicity. Each formula was applied to KID embryos, which were
classified in 5%groups and implantation rates (IR) were computed for the 20intervals. In order to follow mathematically the natural trends obtained in IR, the
average of ≥3consecutive 5%groups was subtracted from the average of the
two following groups, and divided to the initial IR until the theoretical threshold
set at 0.3 was reached. Each class had a mean IR, which was subtracted from
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
ultrastructural elements. However, to date, limited information is available about
the ultracellular alterations in in vivo and in vitro cryopreserved embryos.
Study design, size, duration: This study is carried out using a 2 x 3 x 2 factorial
design. The sample size is 50 embryos for each treatment arm. The cryopreserved
in vivo and in vitro produces embryos at 2-, 4-, and 8-cell stages were used in
this study.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: The ultrastructural elements of the
embryos namely tubulin, actin and nucleus were labelled by immunofluorescent
staining, after being cryopreserved by either vitrification or slow freezing
method. The embryos were then viewed under Confocal Laser Scanning Microscope and finally the intensities of the labelled elements were analyzed using
QWin Software V.3.
Main results and the role of chance: The results clearly showed that both cryopreservation methods caused highly significant changes in ultrastructural elements of in vivo and in vitro embryos as compared to non-cryopreserved
embryos (p , 0.001). In all cryopreserved group, as the number of cells increased,
fluorescent intensities of tubulin, actin and nucleus were decreased slightly as
compared to non-cryopreserved groups. Vitrification and slow freezing caused
highly significant changes in tubulin intensities (p , 0.001), but the intensities
of actin and nucleus were not significant between 4- and 8-cell in in vivo
embryos. In the in vitro embryos, the differences between intensities of tubulin,
actin and nucleus were highly significantly between 2-, 4- and 8-cell (p , 0.001).
Limitations, reason for caution: The use laser with high energy and wavelengths
during confocal microscopy observations is absorbed by the pigment granules that
can cause intense local heating and contribute to ultrastructural alterations. Other
than that, the fluorescent signals may be overlapped during the immunofluorescent
staining and confocal analysis.
Wider implications of the findings: Information obtained from this study will
provide vital information needed in the selection of the best stage and cryotolerant
embryo candidates for cryopreservation and directly reduce the cost of long term
storage by eliminating unnecessary storage of non-viable embryos.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This research was funded by Dana Kecemerlangan Universiti Teknologi MARA (DANA-600-RMI/ST/DANA5/3/Dst/
37/2009) and Fundamental Research Grant Scheme (FRGS-600-RMI/ST/
FRGS/5/3/SFT/71/2010), Ministry of Science, Technology and Innovation
(MOSTI), Malaysia.
Trial registration number: None
i179
i180
P-154
Safespeed technology - the myth of ultrahigh cooling rates: a close
device and a serum-free media for the vitrification human oocytes/embryos
with the highest recovery rates
R. Risco1, M. Hebles2, A.M. Saa3, M.A. Vilches-Ferron 4, P. Sanchez-Martin5,
E. Lucena3, and M. Lucena6
1
Engineering School, University of Seville, Seville, Spain, 2Clinica Ginemed, IVF
Laboratory, Seville, Spain, 3Cecolfes, Fertility Laboratory, Bogota, Colombia,
4
Hospital Torrecardenas, Ginecology Department, Almeria, Spain, 5Clinica
Ginemed, IVF Laboratory, Sevilla, Spain, 6Nidacon International, Product
Development, Mölndal, Sweden
Study question: While no studies have demonstrated unintentional uptake by a
human or mammalian oocyte or embryo of any pathogen during vitrification or
storage, under experimental conditions such contamination may occur (Bielanski
et al., 2000); Also the presence in the vitrificationsolutions of substances of human
or animal origin is a drawback
Summary answer: SafeSpeed is brand new technology that accomplishes the
optimal requirements unveiled in recent studies for oocyte vitrification (Mazur
et al., 2011), although with evidences since 1990 (Steponkus et. al, 1990). We
have reached the highest recovery rates of human oocytes by optimizing the
cooling and warming rates
What is known already: Various techniques have been developed in the past to
overcome this difficulty by improving the heat transfer, such as Open Pulled
Straws, ‘‘solid-surface vitrification’’, the use of electron microscope copper
grids, cryoloops, and more recently cryotop and cryotip (Kuwayama, 2007).
However, in each of those systems, the philosophy underneath is increasing,
but not optimizing, the cooling/warming rate (Mazur, 2011). SafeSpeed has
born as the best optimization of those parameters in a close system.
Study design, size, duration: Experimental trials have been performed with
mouse and human oocytes. Out of 1700 samples, ninety five percent of vitrified
mouse oocytes survived after warming, and ninety three percent of human
oocytes (out of 94) were recovered (Ginemed, Torrecardenas Hospital, Spain) .
Fertilization rate observed after ICSI was 70 %.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Currently transfer trials are carried
out in Cecolfes (Colombia). Images of fluorescence immunochemistry with
tubulin-specific antibodies to visualize microtubular structures of human
oocytes vitrified with SafePreservation technology were excellent, showing the
good behavior of the cryoprotectant as well (Torrecardenas).
Main results and the role of chance: This work has been possible thanks to an
international collaboration of several partners: Nidacon, SafePreservation,
Cecolfes, Clinica Ginemed, Hospital Torrecardenas and the Engineering School
of the University of Seville.
Limitations, reason for caution: By optimizing the cooling/warming rates, we
have been able to maintain the use of conventional liquid nitrogen for our close
device.
Wider implications of the findings: In SafeSpeed, the container is heat-sealed at
both ends, and consequently the solution containing the oocyte or embryo and the
liquid nitrogen is hermetical isolated during cooling and storage. The technique is
simple and robust, without sophisticated devices and easy to learn. Our system
does not require special cryogenic agents, like slush nitrogen or other special mixtures (Risco et al., 2007), what would make the everyday practice very cumbersome, and would elevate the costs
Study funding/competing interest(s): This study is relevant in the field of oocyte
and ambryo vitrification
Trial registration number: 1
P-155 Vitrification: a useful tool in IVF lab when fresh embryo transfer
can not be performed
M. De Las Heras1, J.A. Agirregoikoa2, E. Martinez1, G. Barrenetxea2, and
J.L. De Pablo 1
1
Quirón Bilbao, IVF Lab, Bilbao, Spain, 2Quirón Bilbao, Gynaecology, Bilbao,
Spain
Study question: The aim of this retrospective observational study is to assess the
effectiveness of embryo vitrification on day 3 of embryo development comparing
pregnancy rate, implantation rate and ongoing pregnancy rate between fresh
embryo transfer and warmed embryo transfer.
Summary answer: Vitrification could be not only a good cryopreservation
method for good quality embryos that are not transferred in the fresh cycle but
it is also a good strategy when the fresh embryo transfer must be postponed
What is known already: Cryopreservation allows improving the costeffectiveness of IVF and expanding the options available to infertile couples.
Many studies have shown that vitrification in contrast to slow freezing offers a
higher survival rate, minimal deleterious effects on post-warming embryo morphology and it can improve clinical outcomes. Other studies show a better
embryo-endometrial synchrony in frozen-thawed embryo transfer cycles than
fresh embryo transfer with higher pregnancy and implantation rates after the transfer of warmed embryos.
Study design, size, duration: This retrospective observational study includes
887 fresh and 690 warmed embryo transfers performed on day 3 between 2009
and 2012. Only transfers in which the two embryos transferred had the same
score or single embryo transfers were included. A total number of 1456 fresh
and 1153 warmed embryos were transferred.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Patients were ≤ 39 years old and their
own oocytes were used. Embryos were scored according to the Spanish Association for Reproductive Biology. Vitrification and warming was performed using
cryotop method. Clinical pregnancy was determined 7 weeks after embryo transfer. Statistical analysis was done using the Fisher test (p , 0,05).
Main results and the role of chance: The pregnancy rate after warmed embryo
transfer of two very good quality embryos was 43,7%, 29,9% when only one very
good quality embryo was transferred, 32,3% when the transfer included two good
quality embryos and 26,6% when two medium quality embryos were transferred.
The pregnancy rates after fresh cycles were 42,1%, 22,9%, 24,1% and 20,2% respectively not showing significant differences with those from warmed cycles
(p . 0,05). The implantation rates did not show significant differences between
the two groups either (29,4% vs. 27,7%; 29,9% vs. 22,9%; 18,2% vs. 24,1%
and 14,4% vs. 10,6%) (p . 0,05). There were not significant differences
between ongoing pregnancy rate (12 weeks after embryo transfer) (20,7% vs.
23,6%; 22,4% vs. 18,3%; 14,6% vs. 18,2% and 13,3% vs. 9,6%) (p . 0,05).
Limitations, reason for caution: Although the study included many patients, a
prospective randomized study should be carried out in order to confirm our data.
Wider implications of the findings: It is neccesary an efficient cryopreservation
method that allows the storage of the remaining embryos maximizing the cumulative effectiveness of an in vitro fertilization cycle. Our data show that vitrification offers the patient the same pregnancy rate as fresh cycles so it could be a good
strategy when transfer must be postponed for personal or medical reasons such as
in the ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome or when the endometrium is not prepared.
Study funding/competing interest(s): no
Trial registration number: no
P-156 Embryo density in group culture of human embryos may influence
embryo quality
A. Lehner1, C. Pribenszky2, A. Murber1, J. Rigó Jr. 1, J. Urbancsek1, and
P. Fancsovits 1
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
the initial IR, giving a positive or negative score. Obtained scores were added for
the final prediction of the implantation potential. The logistic regression model
built gave an AUC ¼ 0.684 (95% CI 0.628-0.740).
Limitations, reason for caution: Embryos having a (t8) were exclusively
included in the additive model, leaving out evaluation of day2 embryo transfers.
The cohort studied involved only infertile patients (female, male or combined) and
is in this respect a heterogeneous population.
Wider implications of the findings: Time points defining precise embryo cleavage events may not be generalized to infertile patients with different etiologies.
However, using ratios based on selected cleavage cycles defining synchronicity
of embryos, allows in this retrospective cohort study an individualized analysis
giving high predictivity of implantation. The proposed additive model has to be
further tested in a randomized prospective trial to evaluate its efficacy, and may
in the future improve embryo selection in IVF treatments.
Study funding/competing interest(s): Authors have nothing to disclose.
Trial registration number: The study was approved by the institutional review
board.
Abstracts
i181
Abstracts
1
Semmelweis University, First Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology
Division of Assisted Reproduction, Budapest, Hungary, 2Szent István University,
Department of Animal Breeding and Genetics Faculty of Veterinary Sciences,
Budapest, Hungary
Trial registration number: This investigation is a retrospective analysis of a subgroup of data obtained from a larger prospective randomized study (ClinicalTrials.gov: NCT01774006).
Study question: The aim of this study was to analyze the effect of embryo density
on embryo quality and development when culturing in Well-of-the-Well (WOW)
Petri dishes (Primo Dish, Vitrolife Hungary) in human IVF treatments.
Summary answer: According to our results 3.5-5 ml/embryo density seems to
have a beneficial effect on the embryo quality compared to lower and higher densities. Embryo density can affect embryo development when culturing embryos in
groups.
What is known already: Group culture of human embryos is a widely used
culture method, which may have a beneficial effect via autocrine and paracrine
mechanisms. However an optimal embryo density (volume of culture media
divided by the number of embryos ¼ ml/embryo) in human in vitro culture has
not been defined yet. The WOW dish, which contains 9 + 1 microwells in the
center of the dish, allows us to identify individual embryos cultured together in
the same microdrop.
Study design, size, duration: Data of 675 normally fertilized oocytes from 119
IVF cycles were retrospectively analyzed. Embryos were classified into four
groups: Group A (n ¼ 336): individual culture, Group B (n ¼ 62): 2-4
embryos, Group C (n ¼ 152): 5-7 embryos, Group D (n ¼ 125): 8-10 embryos
cultured in a single droplet of 25 ml media in WOW dishes.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Embryo densities were the following:
Group A: 25 ml/embryo, Group B: 6-12.5 ml/embryo, Group C: 3.5-5 ml/embryo,
Group D: 2.5-3 ml/embryo. Number of blastomeres, fragmentation and morphology score on Day 2 and Day 3 were analyzed with one-way ANOVA and
Tukey HSD test. Frequency of top quality embryos were compared with
Chi-squared test.
Main results and the role of chance: Number of blastomeres was similar in the
four groups (P ¼ 0.36) on Day 2. However cell number in Group C was significantly higher than in Group A (7.5 + 2.1 vs. 6.4 + 2.2; P , 0.001) and in
Group D (7.5 + 2.1 vs. 6.6 + 2.0; P ¼ 0.007) on Day 3. Fragmentation rate
was significantly lower in Group C compared to Group A (11.5 + 8.3% vs.
15.1 + 11.9%; P ¼ 0.01) on Day 2. The ratio of top quality embryos were
higher in Group C compared to Group A (29.3% vs. 17.2%; P ¼ 0.004) and to
Group B (29.3% vs. 8.3%; P ¼ 0.003), as well as in Group D compared to
Group B (22.6% vs. 8.3%; P ¼ 0.03) on Day 3.
Limitations, reason for caution: This study presents preliminary data. A larger
study is needed to have more exact information about the effect of embryo
density on embryo quality.
Wider implications of the findings: Embryo density of 3.5-5 ml/embryo seems to
have the most beneficial effect on embryo development. Culturing embryos in a
WOW group culture dish may increase embryo quality and allows assessment
and tracing of individual embryos.
Study funding/competing interest(s): -
P-157
Effect of oil density in donor oocyte IVF cycles
D. Gumbao Baño1, A. Sánchez-León 1, J. Marcos1, M. Mollá1, B. Amorocho1,
M. Nicolás2, L. Fernández2, and J. Landeras2
1
IVI Murcia, FIV Laboratory, Murcia, Spain, 2IVI Murcia, Gynecologist, Murcia,
Spain
High-density oil
Low-density oil
p
Nº of treatments
34
57
Nº of transfers
32
55
Age
40.6
39.6
Average nº embryo transfers
1.5
1.7
Fertilisation rate
76.8 %(298/388)
77.9 %(514/660)
0.69
Clinical pregnancy rate
65.6 %(21/32)
69.1 %(38/55)
0.74
...............................................................................................................................................................................................
Implantation rate
50 %(24/48)
55.3 %(52/94)
0.55
Biochemical pregnancy rate
4.5 %(1/22)
11.6 %(5/43)
0.27
Clinical miscarriage rate
33 %(7/21)*
5.3 %(2/38)*
0.02
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
Study question: The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of two different
culture oils with different densities on the donor oocyte clinical outcome rates at
day five of embryo development using a time-lapse culture system.
Summary answer: The density of the oils used in a time-lapse culture
system at day five of embryo development may have some impact on ART
outcomes.
What is known already: The quality of oil used in an embryo culture is one of the
most critical issues for successful IVF treatment. In fact, different quality oils may
affect embryonic development in vitro by containing inappropriate or toxic
organic substances.
Study design, size, duration: To evaluate the oil density influence in the clinical
outcomes on our embryo culture system, two different densities of the same oil
were evaluated retrospectively. 91 FIV-ICSI treatments were carried out
between 2011 and 2012 with patients who were included in our oocyte donor
program.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Embryos were divided into two
groups and cultured to day 5 in a time-lapse system using culture plates with 12
wells including 24 mL of medium and overlaid with 1400 mL of the two different
culture oils. The statistical t-student software analysis significance was defined
when P , 0.05.
Main results and the role of chance: No significant differences were found
except in clinical miscarriage rate which was significantly lower in the group of
embryos cultured in light oil. The results are shown in Table 1.
Table 1. Clinical outcome rates. * statistical significance p ,0.05.
Limitations, reason for caution: Although culture oil density did not affect pregnancy and implantation rates, statistic differences in the miscarriage rates were
observed, so further prospective and randomised studies are underway in order
to discover something else related with the oil density including fertilization to
day 5 time-lapse division parameters analysis.
Wider implications of the findings: The results appear to point towards the importance of the oil using in culture. These results would be in agreement with the
literature and the results obtained by other groups that also defend the role played
by oil and the idea that further studies will be necessary in order to provide new
proofs.
Study funding/competing interest(s): The present study was supported by IVI
Murcia SL. Murcia. Spain
Trial registration number: No trial registration number.
i182
P-158
A comparative gene expression analysis of slow frozen and vitrified metaphase II human oocytes
O.A. Adeniyi, S.M. Ehbish, and D.R. Brison
Central Manchester University Hospitals, NHS Foundation Trust, Manchester
Academic Health Science Centre
P-159
Comparison of two different cryo-devices for vitrified-warmed
single blastocyst transfer using chemically defined vitrification/warming
solutions supplemented with recombinant human albumin
A. Egashira1, M. Murakami2, E. Nagafuchi1, K. Tanaka1, A. Tomohara1, C. Mine
H. Otsubo1, A. Nakashima 3, M. Otsuka3, N. Yoshioka3, and T. Kuramoto4
1,
1
Kuramoto Women’s Clinic, IVF Laboratory, Hakata-ku Fukuoka City, Japan,
Kuramoto Women’s Clinic, Reseach Laboratory, Hakata-ku Fukuoka City,
Japan, 3Kuramoto Women’s Clinic, Reproductive Medicine, Hakata-ku Fukuoka
City, Japan, 4Kuramoto Women’s Clinic, Clinical Department, Hakata-ku
Fukuoka City, Japan
2
Study question: To investigate whether a closed devise (Rapid-i) is useful for
human blastocyst vitrification compared with an open vitrification devises
(Cryotop)
Summary answer: Closed vitrification system using recHAwere effective for the
cryopreservation of human blastocysts to obtain good clinical outcome and to
avoid the possibility of disease transmission and potential risk of crosscontamination.
What is known already: The vitrification/warning solutions supplemented with
recHA used for human blastocysts vitrification with cryotop were first validated in
a preclinical study (Murakami et al. 2012, abstract O-183 ESHRE). However,
there are no proven viral transmissions between embryos or to the patient at
embryo transfer, the use of an open system for vitrification potentially introduces
a risk of cross-contamination during liquid nitrogen storage.
Study design, size, duration: From August 2012 to December 2012, 79 patients
forvitrified-warmed single blastocyst transfer under a hormone-replacement cycle
were divided into two groups (group A: Cryotop, n ¼ 41; group B: Rapid-i,
n ¼ 38). On day 5 and day 6, blastocysts with ICM and trophectoderm type A
or B (Gardner’s scoring system) were vitrified.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: The base solution was PBS with
2.5 mg/ml recHA. Blastocysts were exposed to two solutions: equilibration
(10% EG) and vitrification (15% EG + 15% DMSO + 0.5 mol/l sucrose). For
thawing, embryos were placed into four sucrose solutions (0.5M, 0.25M, 0.1M,
and 0M respectively). Data were analysed by x2 test.
Main results and the role of chance: There were 41 warmed cycles in group A
and 38 warmed cycles in group B. Mean female age was 35.8 + 3.9 years in group
A and 35.1+ 2.5 years in group B.There were no significant different in embryo
survival rates (100% [41/41] vs. 100% [38/38]) and the implantation rates (53.7%
[22/41] vs. 63.2% [24/38]) between groups A and B. The ongoing pregnancy rates
per embryo transfer were no significant different between group A and group B
(43.9% [18/41] vs. 52.6% [20/38]).
Limitations, reason for caution: In our study, study population and number of
vitrified blastocysts were small. Therefore, large-scale investigation including
follow-up of children born after embryos vitrification using a Rapid-i are required.
Wider implications of the findings: Closed vitrification method used in this
study useable each blastocyst to be vitrified in super-cooled air and loaded in a
closed straw. As a result, the blastocyst has supposed to have low risk of disease
transmission and cross-contamination from liquid nitrogen, without impairing developmental competence. This method will be useful vitrified-warmed single
blastocyst transfer in the future.
Study funding/competing interest(s): None
Trial registration number: None
P-160 Fresh embryo transfer versus frozen embryo transfer with
GnRH-antagonist protocol in ART
D. Choi, H. Yang, J.H. Park, J.H. Jung, H.G. Hwang, J.H. Lee, J.E. Lee, A.S. Kang
, J.H. Yoo, H.C. Kwon, and S.J. Lee
Mirae and Heemang Ob/Gyn Clinic, Obstetrics and Gynecology, Seoul, Korea
South
Study question: In ART of high ovarian responders undergoing a
GnRH-antagonist protocol, which has benefit for patients between fresh
embryo transfer (FT) and frozen-thawed embryo transfer (FTT)?
Summary answer: If fresh embryo transfer(FT) could be replace by
frozen-thawed embryo transfer(FTT) in high ovarian responder undergoing
ART with GnRH-antagonist protocol, the patients will have some advantages in
both higher pregnancy rate and avoiding OHSS
What is known already: Some studies reported that in ART, the pregnancy rate
of FTTare higher than FT. Also several meta-analyses mentioned similar results.
The endometrial receptivity during ART is very important in implantation of the
transferred embryo. The endometrial receptivity can be controlled more precisely
in FTT than in FT.
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
Study question: To investigate the impact of metaphase II (MII) oocyte cryopreservation by slow freezing and by vitrification on the expression of genes
involved in oocyte cryo-survival and in-vitro developmental competence.
Summary answer: Oocytes showed a higher survival rate (86.7%) from vitrification compared to slow freezing (76.2%). This was not significantly associated with
maternal age. Gene expression data for BRCA 1 and 2, OCT4, TUBB4Q and a
number of other candidate genes show differences between the vitrified and
slow frozen oocytes.
What is known already: Routine application of oocyte cryopreservation procedures for both long and short-term fertility preservation and treatment has been
widely accepted. Several modifications in the processes of vitrification and
slow oocyte freezing, have significantly improved the survival rates, pregnancy
and live-birth rates obtained from both procedures. However, vitrification
seems to produce better results than slow oocyte freezing. Unfortunately, the
safety of these procedures and their impact on oocytes at the molecular level is
not completely understood.
Study design, size, duration: A prospective study of 15 consenting patients in the
vitrification group had controlled ovarian stimulation between May and October
2012. Oocytes were vitrified using a closed system. Two patients in the slow freezing group had oocytes cryopreserved between 2002 and 2003. A minimum of 10
oocytes were analysed per group.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Fifteen pairs of unfertilised MII
oocytes were obtained from fresh ICSI cycles in a standard NHS public sector hospital, of which 15 were vitrified and 15 sham treated as paired controls. Fertility
preservation patients donated 21 slow frozen MII oocytes. Survival rates were
compared and cDNA was analysed by polyAPCR and qPCR
Main results and the role of chance: The average age of patients and oocyte survival rates from slow freezing, vitrification and control groups were 31.4yrs and
76.2%, 32.8yrs and 85.7% and 32.8yrs respectively. The survival rate in the vitrification group was not statistically significant, when compared with the slow
freezing group (p ¼ 0.6897). Ongoing gene expression analysis of genes including TUBB4Q, OCT 4, BRCA 1, BRCA 2 and some specific genes associated with
oocyte cryo-survival, show different gene expression patterns in both groups compared with the study control group.
Limitations, reason for caution: The use of unfertilised MII oocytes from ICSI
cycles in the vitrification and control groups can be argued to be a sub-optimal
source of MII oocytes, pre-exposed to micromanipulation and overnight
culture. However, this did not appear to compromise the higher survival rate
obtained, compared with slow freezing group. Moreover we have made genetically normal embryonic stem cell lines from this source of oocytes demonstrating
that they retain developmental capacity.
Wider implications of the findings: Our preliminary results show that MII
oocyte vitrification using a closed system produces better survival outcome compared with slow freezing. Vitrification can be argued to be essential in optimising
outcomes involving fertility preservation and treatment. However, further investigations involving sibling MII oocytes to compare cryopreservation techniques is
warranted. In particular, gene expression patterns in pre and post-cryopreserved
MII oocytes can allow us to fully evaluate the association between oocytes cryopreservation techniques and molecular gene expression.
Study funding/competing interest(s): Adeniyi, OA and Brison, DR are funded
by Central Manchester NHS Trust; Ehbish, SM is funded by the Libyan Government.
Trial registration number: None
Abstracts
i183
Abstracts
P-161
Induction of autophagy in the vitrified-warmed mouse oocytes
S. Bang, H. Shin, and H.J. Lim
Konkuk University, Biomedical Science & Technology, Seoul, Korea South
Study question: Is autophagy induced during vitrification-warming process in
mouse oocytes?
Summary answer: Autophagy is induced in mouse oocytes during vitrificationwarming process.
What is known already: Vitrification uses cryoprotectants and liquid nitrogen,
which may cause osmotic stress and cryodamage to oocytes. Autophagy is
widely considered as a survival or responsive mechanism to various environmental and cellular stresses. However, the status of autophagy in vitrified-warmed
oocytes has not been studied. In this work, we investigated if vitrification-warming
process induces autophagy in mouse oocytes.
Study design, size, duration: Oocytes obtained from several mice were pooled
and divided into three groups. Group1: fresh oocytes. Group2: oocytes treated
with vitification solutions (1.3M EG + 1.1M DMSO and 2.7M EG + 2.1M
DMSO + 0.5M sucrose) and warming solutions. Group3: vitrified-warmed
oocytes (loaded onto an EM copper grid, and were stored in LN2 for 2weeks).
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Four-week-old female ICR mice and
GFP-LC3 transgenic mice were used. The mice were superovulated with 5IU
PMSG and 5IU hCG and ovulated MII oocytes were collected from oviducts.
RT-PCR and confocal live imaging of GFP-LC3 were performed to examine the
effects of vitrification-warming process on autophagy in oocytes.
Main results and the role of chance: In RT-PCR analyses, the expression of
autophagy related (Atg) genes, such as Atg5, Atg7, Atg12, LC3a, LC3b, and
Beclin1 were examined. In Group 2, the expression of Beclin1 was increased in
comparison to fresh oocytes (Group 1), and it was recovered in Group 3. Thus, induction of Beclin1 mRNA is associated with the exposure to the vitrification solution. The expression of other Atg genes did not change. Confocal live
imaging analysis using oocytes from GFP-LC3 transgenic mice revealed that
some vitrified-warmed oocytes showed green puncta which indicate autophagic
activation. All oocytes of Group 1 and Group 2 show no puncta formation. Each
experiment was performed three times.
Limitations, reason for caution: Increased autophagy was only confirmed by
live imaging of GFP-LC3 as a qualitative analysis, thus quantitative analysis
such as Western blotting needs to be performed. Further investigation is warranted
to address the role for autophagic activation in vitrified-warmed oocytes.
Wider implications of the findings: Induction of autophagy may serve as an indicator of conditions of vitrification-warming process. Moreover, it offers the possibility that development of methods to modulate autophagic response during
cryopreservation could improve efficacy of oocyte cryopreservation.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This study was supported by a grant of the
Korea Health technology R&D Project, Ministry of Health & Welfare, Republic of
Korea (A120080).
Trial registration number: N/A
P-162 Forced blastocoele collapse of the blastocoel improves developmental potential in cryopreserved bovine blastocysts by vitrification and
slow-rate freezing methods
S.H. Min, J.Y. Yeon, and D.B. Koo
Daegu University, Department of Biotechnology, Daegu, Korea South
Study question: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of
forced blastocoele collapse of the blastocoel before vitrification and slow-rate
freezing of bovine blastocysts.
Summary answer: Cryopreservation of bovine blastocysts has been proposed as
a tool to improve the feasibility of cattle production by using embryo transfer technique.
What is known already: In general, the slow-rate freezing using a programmed
cryo-machine are traditionally employed for the cryopreservation of embryos. Vitrification with higher concentrations of cryoprotectants and a fast cooling rate, it
transforms cells into a glassy state without ice crystal formation.
Study design, size, duration: Bovine in vivo and in vitro blastocysts were slowrate frozen and vitrified after forced blastocoele collapse of the blastocoel by puncturing the blastocoele with a pulled pasteur pipet.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: The differences in survival and pregnancy rates of blastocysts derived from forced blastocoele collapse and non-forced
blastocoele collapse groups were found in both slow-rate freezing and vitrification. Furthermore, we examined the total cell numbers and apoptosis index of blastocysts.
Main results and the role of chance: We found that the total cell numbers of blastocysts in forced blastocoele collapse groups were increased and the numbers of
blastomeres undergoing apoptosis in forced blastocoele collapse groups were
decreased. Consistent with the results, qPCR data showed that the expression of
anti-apoptotic gene (Bcl-xL) was significantly increased by forced blastocoele
collapse groups, whereas the expression of pro-apoptotic gene (Bax) was significantly decreased. Furthermore, pregnancy rates in the both slow-rate frozen and
vitrified bovine in vivo blastocysts could be improved by reducing the fluid
content after forced blastocoele collapse of the blastocoel.
Limitations, reason for caution: However, the low efficiency of frozen-thawed
embryos survival and further development is a crucial problem.
Wider implications of the findings: The forced blastocoele collapse of the blastocoel method suggesting that it could be improving the developmental competence and qualities of frozen-thowed bovine embryos that may be used for
mammalian embryo preservation.
Study funding/competing interest(s): We have no conpeting interest.
Trial registration number: We have no trial registration number.
P-163 Effect of Hydroxypropyl cellulose on survival of bovine and
human oocytes after vitrification
M. Kuwayama1, S. Higo1, and L. Ruvalcaba 2
1
Repro-Support Medical Research Center, Research & Development, Tokyo,
Japan, 2Infertility Institute of Mexico, Research & Development, Guadalajara,
Mexico
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
Study design, size, duration: All ART cycles were performed from January 1,
2012 to December 31, 2012. FT were divided into three sub-groups: FT-LR:
low-ovarian-responder (344 cycles), FT-NR : normal-ovarian-responder
(227-cycles), FT-HR : high-ovarian-responder (104 cycles). Also, FTT were
divided into three sub-groups: FTT-LR: low-ovarian-responder (16 cycles),
FTT-NR; normal-ovarian-responder (78 cycles), FTT-HR: high-ovarian-responder (104 cycles).
Participants/materials, setting, methods: All patients had GnRH-antagonist
protocol. The embryos used in FTT were cryopreserved by vitrification method.
We classified the patients in low, normal and high ovarian responder, according
to the number of retrieval oocytes: low-ovarian-responder: from 1 oocyte to 9
oocyte, normal-ovarian-responder: from 10 to 19 oocytes, high-ovarian-responder: over 20. Main results and the role of chance By analyzing the results, we
investigated the clinical-pregnancy rate, the implantation rate and the ongoingpregnancy of all groups and compared them. However, we failed to find statistically significant difference in comparison of FT-LR and FTT-LR [the clinical pregnancy rate: 26.8% vs. 25%, the implantation rate: 9.8% vs. 13.5%, the on-going
pregnancy rate: 16.8% vs. 18.8%] or in FT-NR and FTT-NR [the clinical pregnancy rate: 39.6% vs. 38.5%; the implantation rate: 12.4% vs. 15.4%; the
on-going pregnancy rate: 28.2% vs. 29.5%.]. However, in comparison with
FT-HR and FTT-HR, we could finally find significant difference (FT-HR
vs. FTT-HR: the clinical pregnancy rate; 42.3% vs. 50.9%, p < 0.01; the implantation rate: 10.5% vs. 18.9%, p < 0.01, ongoing-pregnancy rate: 25.9%
vs. 30.7%, p < 0.05) Limitations, reason for caution There were some variation
in this study, including GnRH dosage, the day of antagonist treatment, and classification of patients.
Wider implications of the findings: The High ovarian responder undergoing
GnRH-antigonist treatment can choose the strategy of cryopreservation of all
embryos and transferring them subsequently in optimal conditions and this protocol increases the synchrony between embryo and endometrial development, and
therefore, improves the ongoing pregnancy rate and outcome of ART cycles
Study funding/competing interest(s): none
Trial registration number: none
i184
P-164
Restoration of developmental competence of oxidatively damaged
oocytes by meiotic spindle transfer
M. Kobayashi1, T. Takeuchi2, and A. Yoshida1
Kiba Park Clinic, Tokyo, Japan, 2Kyono ART Clinic Takanaw, Tokyo, Japan
1
Study question: Whether induced oxidative damage compromise the maturational and developmental capabilities of maturing oocytes as well as such insult can be
reversed by spindle transfer (ST).
Summary answer: Oxidative stress impaired meiotic and mitotic development of
mammalian oocytes with reduced mitochondrial activity and aberrant spindle formation. Ooplasmic replenishment by STwas able to conquer such injuries on maturing oocytes.
What is known already: Oxidative stress during the in vitro maturation (IVM)
process compromises the oocyte maturation. In addition, it is suggested that oxidative stress confronted during oocyte maturation might contribute to the
age-related oocyte aneuploidy and consequent infertility in the human.
However, the ability of ooplasmic replenishment by ST at the metaphase I (MI)
stage to treat oxidatively damaged oocytes has not yet been assessed.
Study design, size, duration: The spindle morphology, mitochondrial membrane
potential (MMP), maturation rate and developmental ability were compared
between intact MI oocytes and those treated with H2O2. In order to assess the
ability of ST to treat oxidatively damaged oocytes, spindles isolated from
oocytes exposed to H2O2 were transferred to intact ooplasts.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Mouse MI oocytes were exposed to
50 mM H2O2 for 15 min. H2O2 treated MI spindle was transferred into an enucleated intact oocyte with inactivated Sendai virus. After IVM, morphology of
MII spindle was examined immunohistochemically, MMP was evaluated with
JC-1 dye, and matured oocytes were fertilized by ICSI.
Main results and the role of chance: Maturation rate of the H2O2 treated MI
oocytes was significantly lower than the control (51.7% vs. 79.4%, p , 0.05).
In oocytes reached MII stage after H2O2 treatment, length of the spindle was remarkably shorter, and MMP was lower than that of simply in vitro matured
oocytes. After ICSI, only 34.1% of the H2O2 treated oocytes developed to the
2-cell stage, and none reached to the blastocyst stage. However, following ST,
73.5% of the H2O2 treated oocytes matured normally exhibiting MII spindle
with normal morphology. MMP in the ST oocytes was higher than the H2O2
treated oocytes. In addition, all of the ST oocytes were fertilized normally after
ICSI, and 20.5% developed to the blastocyst stage.
Limitations, reason for caution: This study was conducted using a mouse model
with artificially induced oxidative stress. This finding does not directly represent
human infertility.
Wider implications of the findings: This study shows clearly that the oxidative
damage induced in cytoplasm/mitochondria of mammalian oocytes impairs their
developmental competence. Such ooplasmic damage can be reversed by replenishment of ooplasm, indicating that STcan play an important role in understanding
age-related oocyte pathology.
Study funding/competing interest(s): There are no conflicts of interest to
declare.
Trial registration number: n/a
P-165 Avoiding the occurrence of smooth endoplasmic reticulum clusters in oocytes improves ART outcomes
A. Miwa, Y. Nagai, Y. Momma, K. Takahashi, M. Chuko, A. Nagai, and J. Otsuki
Nagai Clinic, Obstetrics and Gynecology, Saitama, Japan
Study question: Is it possible to prevent the presence of smooth endoplasmic reticulum clusters (sERC) in human oocytes and improve the take home baby rate?
Summary answer: In this study, it was found that presence of sERC in oocytes
could be avoided in most patients. About 30% of patients who previously had
sERC positive oocytes and had failed to become pregnant were able to have
healthy babies in their sERC negative cycles.
What is known already: The presence of sERC in MII human oocytes indicates
cytoplasmic damage. We have previously reported that the presence of sERC
decreased pregnancy rates and increased the miscarriage rate (ESHRE 2002,
Hum Reprod 2004) and that elevated oestradiol and progesterone concentrations
and larger follicles induced sERC formation (ESHRE 2003, Hum Reprod 2004).
Study design, size, duration: Consecutive ICSI and combined IVF and ICSI
attempts from April 2002 to December 2012 in our clinic are included in this
study. Based on our previous findings three procedures described below were
carried out for patients previously positive for sERC.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: The following three procedures, i)
earlier administration of hCG than in previous sERC positive cycles, ii) alternative
ovarian stimulation methods, iii) exclusion of even smaller sized sERC, were
carried out and pregnancy outcomes were subsequently investigated. sERC positive oocytes rates were also compared in seven different stimulation procedures.
Main results and the role of chance: Unfavorable sERCs were present in 12.1%
(68/564) of patients representing 7.3% (86/1174) of cycles. Among the 68 patients
who had sERC positive cycles, 14 (20.6%) patients delivered healthy babies.
Among the 54 couples who failed to deliver, 46 couples had further ART treatment
using the three procedures described above and 41 out of 46 (89.1%) patients were
found to have sERC negative cycles. In their sERC negative cycles 12 (29.3%)
patients delivered healthy babies. The following are the sERC positive rates for
each stimulation protocol: long, 8.9% (31/349); short, 25.0% (2/8);
FSH-antagonist, 6.3% (32/512); CC-antagonist, 6.7% (11/164); CC, 6.9% (2/
29); FSH, 9.1% (1/11) and letrozole-antagonist, 0% (0/29). The short protocol
had statistically lower sERC rates than the letrozole-antagonist (p , 0.01) and
the FSH-antagonist protocols (p , 0.05).
Limitations, reason for caution: Since we previously proposed that the transfer
of embryos derived from sERC positive oocytes should be avoided (Hum Reprod
2004), sERC positive oocytes in this study were not fertilized in all sERC positive
cycles. Thus, the pregnancy outcomes derived from sERC positive oocytes cannot
be investigated in this study.
Wider implications of the findings: As reports show that babies derived from
sERC positive oocytes had multiple abnormalities, it is important to avoid the occurrence of sERC formation. Since there were no sERC positive oocytes in the
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
Study question: Is Hydroxypropyl cellulose in vitrification solution effective on
post-warm survival of bovine oocytes and blastocysts, and human oocytes after
vitrification ?
Summary answer: Hydroxypropyl cellulose was very effective as a macromolecule supplement in vitrification solution on post-warm survival of bovine
oocytes and blastocysts, and human oocytes after vitrification. It is more effective
than conventional synthetic serm substitute which has been normaly used in
human IVF .
What is known already: Supplementation of synthetic macromolecule to the
cryopreservation solution is necessary to obtain stable and high post-warm survival for human and animal oocytes and embryos vitrification.
Study design, size, duration: Perspective study. Comparison of in vitro survival
and growth of oocytes after treatment. Total number of oocytes and embryos was
874, the duration is 20 months from 04/2011.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Four experiments were conducted to
assess the efficacy of HPC for use in vitrification solutions for bovine oocytes and
blastocysts and for human oocytes. Four-hundred and twenty bovine oocytes and
300 blastocysts and 154 human oocytes were vitrified by the Cryotop method
(Kuwayama, 2005). The solutions for vitrification were supplemented with
0.06 mg/ml HPC or with 10% commercial Synthetic Serum Substitute (SSS) or
with no added macromolecule (NA). Some HPC solutions and SSS solutions
were stored at 48C or -808C for 12months before vitrification.
Main results and the role of chance: The survival rates of bovine oocytes vitrified in HPC, SSS and NAwere 100%, 100% and 86% and the respective blastocyst
rates were 22%, 18% and 8%, respectively. The survival rates of bovine blastocysts vitrified in HPC, SSS and NA were 99%, 93% and 88%, respectively.The
survival rate of bovine oocytes vitrified in HPC solutions stored for 12 months
at 48C or -808C was 100%; the rates for those vitrified in SSS solutions were somewhat lower than HPC. The survival rates of human oocytes vitrified in HPC, SSS
and NA were 100%, 98% and 92%, respectively.
Limitations, reason for caution: This study is in vitro only.
Wider implications of the findings: Found macromolecule hydroxypropyl cellulose may be used effectively for embryo culture media and freezing solutions for
sperm.
Study funding/competing interest(s): The study was performed by an ordinary
research expenses in the clinic
Trial registration number: The study does’t contain clinical trials.
Abstracts
Abstracts
letrozole protocol, it could be used as a stimulation method for patients who have
recurrent sERC positive cycles.
Study funding/competing interest(s): The authors received no funding for this
study and there is .
Trial registration number: 0022654
P-166
Thawing in the day of embryo transfer had improved pregnancy
rate in HRT cycles, but not in the natural cycles
S.G. Kim1, J.H. Lee1, Y.Y. Kim1, H.J. Kim1, I.H. Park 1, H.G. Sun1, K.H. Lee1, and
H.J. Song2
1
Mamapapa&baby Obstetrics Gynecology Clinic, Infertility Lab., Ulsan city,
Korea South 2Bucheon Seoul Women’s Hospital, BuCheon City, Korea South
P-167
Single medium culture in a time-lapse incubator until the blastocyst stage with or without medium renewal on Day-3: a prospective randomised study with donor oocytes
N. Costa-Borges1, M. Belles1, J. Herreros1, J. Teruel1, A. Ballesteros2, A. Pellicer3,
and G. Calderón1
1
IVI Barcelona, IVF Laboratory, Barcelona, Spain, 2IVI Barcelona, Clinical
Department, Barcelona, Spain, 3IVI, Clinical Department, Valencia, Spain
Study question: Is it really necessary to renew the medium on Day-3 when using a
single medium for embryo culture to the blastocyst stage?
Summary answer: Our preliminary data suggest that embryo quality, morphokinetics, and clinical performance are not affected by single-step (uninterrupted)
embryo culture in a single medium. The same medium can be used throughout
the 5 days of culture with no replacement on Day-3. Moreover, this strategy
does not affect embryo kinetics.
What is known already: Embryo culture to blastocyst stage can be accomplished
using either a single medium or sequential media. Traditionally, culture in a single
medium includes medium renewal on Day-3. There are insufficient data to conclude that this step can be avoided without affecting embryo quality and clinical
performance.
In this study, we wanted to clarify this question and evaluate whether embryo
culture until blastocyst stage in single medium can be performed safely without
medium replacement on Day-3.
Study design, size, duration: We compared embryo development and quality,
morphokinetics, and clinical outcomes (implantation and clinical and ongoing
pregnancy rates) between single-step culture (without renewal) and two-step
culture (Day 3 renewal) culture. This prospective, randomised study comprised
302 embryos (from donor oocytes) from 29 patients. ICSI was performed on all
oocytes.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Injected oocytes were evenly distributed in EmbryoSlidesw of a time-lapse incubator (EmbryoScope TM, Unisense,
FertiliTech). Slides were prepared with Global Totalw medium (LifeGlobal),
equilibrated overnight, and randomised for medium renewal or no renewal on
Day-3. Results were compared by Student’s t-test or X-test, P , 0.05 was considered statistically significant.
Main results and the role of chance Blastocyst rates (67.5 vs 64.9%, P ¼
0.751), percentages of frozen (49.0 vs 58.2%, p ¼ 0.248) and discarded
embryos (22.5 vs 25.5%, P ¼ 0.745) were similar between two-step and singlestep culture groups. The proportion of good-quality blastocysts (transferred plus
frozen) was also identical for both groups (77.5 vs 74.5%, P ¼ 0.745). Morphokinetic variables from early cleavage until late blastocyst stage were not different
between culture treatment groups. No differences (P . 0.05) were found in clinical and ongoing pregnancy rates between transfers performed with embryos from
two-step culture (69.2 and 77.8%), single-step culture (75.0 and 100%) and mixed
transfers (42.9 and 66.7%). A total of 24 of 45 transferred embryos implanted and
no significant differences were found among pure and mixed transfers.
Limitations, reason for caution: These are preliminary results of an ongoing
study and a larger sample size is required to increase statistical power. Results
are based on observations with embryos from oocyte donors and need to be confirmed with embryos from infertile patients of different ages.
Wider implications of the findings: Simplified laboratory protocols, lower costs
and fewer human errors are associated with the use of a single step culture system
without medium renewal on Day-3. The absence of differences in morphokinetics
between both groups demonstrates that medium renewal does not affect timings of
embryo development events.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This study was funded by IVI-Barcelona.
The authors do not have any
P-168 Regulation of inositol 1,4,5-trisphosphate receptor during human
oocyte maturation and fertilization
D. Nikiforaki1, L. Vossaert2, F. Vanden Meerschaut1, C. Qian 1, Y. Lu1, J.B. Parys3,
W.H. De Vos4, D. Deforce2, T. Deroo 1, E. Van den Abbeel1, L. Leybaert5,
B. Heindryckx1, and P. De Sutter 1
1
University Hospital Ghent, Department for Reproductive Medicine, Ghent,
Belgium, 2Ghent University, Laboratory for Pharmaceutical Biotechnology,
Ghent, Belgium, 3KU Leuven, Department of Cellular and Molecular Medicine,
Leuven, Belgium, 4Ghent University, Department of Molecular Biotechnology,
Ghent, Belgium, 5Ghent University, Department of Basic Medical Sciences,
Ghent, Belgium
Study question: What are the modifications occurring to the inositol
1,4,5-trisphosphate receptor type 1 (IP3R1) during human oocyte maturation
that enhance its sensitivity for intracellular Ca2+ release during fertilization?
Summary answer: During human oocyte maturation, the IP3R1 level increases
with a concomitant rise of its phosphorylation. Simultaneously, the IP3R1,
which is located in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER), relocalizes and forms
dense clusters that decrease after fertilization. The amount of Ca2+ stored in the
ER ([Ca2+]ER) increases significantly during in vitro maturation (IVM).
What is known already: Intracellular [Ca2+] oscillations mediated by the IP3R1
regulate oocyte activation and embryo development. Prior to fertilization, the
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
Study question: What is the optimal thawing time in day 3 frozen-thawed embryo
transfer(FET) during natural and hormone replacement therapy(HRT) cycles?
Summary answer: Immediate embryo transfer after thawing in the morning had
improved pregnancy rate compared with thawing in the evening 1 day before
embryo transfer in HRT cycles.
What is known already: Embryo-endometrial synchronization seems to be
improved by control of thawing day in FET cycles. However, the optimal
timing for thawing still remains uncertain.
Study design, size, duration: In a retrospective study, the relationship between
thawing time and pregnancy rate has been studied in 678 FET cycles between
Jan 2008 and Dec 2011. FET cycles were divided into four groups according to
thawing time and endometrium preparation methods.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Embryos which were thawed evening
1day before ET were cultured overnight and transferred the next day morning
(group A: in natural cycle(n ¼ 160), group B: in HRT cycle (n ¼ 277)), while
embryos from thawed in the morning were transferred within 3h (group C:
natural cycle (n ¼ 138), group D: in HRT cycle (n ¼ 103)).
Main results and the role of chance: There were no differences among four
groups in patient age(group A: 34.7 + 4.0, group B: 34.7 + 4.5, group C:
33.9 + 3.5 and group D: 34.2 + 4.2), the mean number of transferred
embryos(2.2 + 0.4, 2.1 + 0.4, 2.5 + 0.5 and 2.1 + 0.3), the mean number of
cryopreserved embryos(9.4 + 4.8, 10.9 + 6.2, 10.9 + 5.9 and 11.3 + 5.6), endometrial thickness(10.4 + 1.9, 10.3 + 2.0, 9.9 + 1.5 and 10.1 + 1.6) and embryo
quality. The mean embryo survival index before transfer was comparable in the
four groups(72.4%, 71.7%, 70.6% and 71.4% p ¼ 0.30). The clinical pregnancy
rates in natural cycles were no significant difference between group A(28.1%) and
group C(37.7%, p ¼ 0.19). However, the clinical pregnancy rates in HRT cycles
were significantly higher in group D(50.5%) than group B(31.0%, p , 0.01).
Limitations, reason for caution: The number of cycles between each group was
different. In particular, the number of HRT cycles was small.
Wider implications of the findings: In our results, the overall pregnancy rate in
FET cycles had improved in immediate embryo transfer after thawing in the
morning. Especially, pregnancy rate was significantly higher in the HRT cycles.
We do not know the exact reason for the high pregnancy rate in the HRT cycles.
Probably, it seems that better embryo-endometrial synchronization was achieved
in HRT cycles.
Study funding/competing interest(s): None
Trial registration number: None
i185
i186
multivesicular bodies, and are frequently fused with the neighboring cells.
Various cell types are carrying exosomes. To date, their characterization, based
on morphology and, more importantly, biochemical and functional activity has
not been provided.
Study design, size, duration: Total of 35 embryos, having 6C to 8C, with various
degrees of fragmentation, are stopped at Day 3 and examined. Overall cohort of
embryos were developed under standardized IVF clinical programme and
donated for science with written informed consent provided from couples.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Using transmission electron microscopy (TEM) on human preimplantation embryos, we observe presence, distribution and ultrastructural details of various membranous extracellular structures.
A prospective observational ongoing study was initiated at ObGin Clinic - Clinical
Centre of Serbia and Faculty of Biology – Belgrade University.
Main results and the role of chance: The blastomeres certainly do shed exosomes and show their agglomerations in sub-plasmalemal area. Released
exosomes are observed in inter-blastomeric space and not clearly confirmed in
perivitelline space. Release zone was characterized with sER vesicles and mitochondria presence. TEM shows characteristic cup-shaped exosomes with their
mean size of 165 nm + 0.5 nm. Standard bell-shaped curve indicates homogeneous population. We observed exosome production in A-class embryos and
slightly negative correlation between their number and embryo quality. Presence
of various multivesicular bodies and structures resembling apoptotic bodies
increases with lower embryo score. There are clear signs of exosome uptake by
blastomeres, and it correlates with fragmentation degree. Fragments showed
retained capability to endocytose exosomes as well. Rather excessive exosome
uptake was found in embryos showing apoptotic blastomeres.
Limitations, reason for caution: Embryo-derived exosomes are mostly located
in the central inter-blastomere environment. Their position, small quantity and
highly dynamic uptake make their isolation, purification and content depiction
very challenging, when compared with other cell systems. Revealing their
spatial dynamics is the first step for their future molecular and physiological
mapping.
Wider implications of the findings: To our knowledge, this is the first report that
embryos release exosomes. Studies on various cell types showed immunomodulatory, antigen and transcriptomic activity. Excessive exosome uptake by dying
blastomeres suggests their involvement in activation-induced cell death. Their
presence in good embryos implies their role in normogenesis and deserves great
attention. In future, improved purification and nomenclature strategies will help
to illuminate their place in complex and fragile biological system - early human
embryo.
Study funding/competing interest(s): Study has institutional review board approval and no conflicts of interest exist.
Trial registration number: This work was supported by Serbian Ministry of
Education, Science and Technological Development, Grant #173054.
P-169
Exosomes as bioactive messengers in a critical time for preimplantation embryos ñ an ultrastructural study
L. Surlan1, V. Otasevic2, K. Velickovic3, I. Golic3, M. Vucetic3, V. Stankovic 1,
J. Stojnic4, N. Radunovic4, I. Tulic4, B. Korac 2, and A. Korac3
1
Clinic for Obstetrics and Gynaecology Clinical Centre of Serbia, ART
Department, Belgrade, Serbia, 2University of Belgrade Institute for Biological
Research “Sinisa Stankovic”, Physiology Department, Belgrade, Serbia,
3
University of Belgrade Faculty of Biology, Cell Biology, Belgrade, Serbia,
4
Clinic for Obstetrics and Gynaecology Clinical Centre of Serbia, Faculty of
Medicine, Belgrade, Serbia
Study question: Among the embryo fragments and blastomeres, various populations of smaller but distinctive membranous extracellular organelles: exosomes,
shedding microvesicles and apoptotic blebs deserve particular attention. The
goal of this study was to provide an ultrastructural characterization of blastomerederived exosomes in a critical period of embryo blastulation and fragmentation.
Summary answer: Based on morphology, size and origin we defined the release
of exosomes from both intact and fragmented blastomeres, their uptake by fragments and other blastomeres, and we provide their first extensive characterization
in human IVF embryos.
What is known already: IVF embryos show rather crafty developmental capacity
and various phenotype markers. Recent works confirmed exosomes as important
intercellular communication mediators – they carry proteins, miRNAs and menu
of other molecules. They are formed by the inward budding and releasing of
P-170 Prospective randomized study comparing human embryo culture
in group in the Well-of-the-Well dish or individually in droplets. Results from
an intermediate analysis
P. Fancsovits 1, C. Pribenszky 2, A. Lehner1, A. Murber1, J. Rigo Jr.1, and
J. Urbancsek1
1
Semmelweis University, Division of Assisted Reproduction First Department of
Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Budapest, Hungary, 2Szent István University,
Department of Animal Breeding and Genetics Faculty of Veterinary Sciences,
Budapest, Hungary
Study question: The aim of this study is to compare embryo development and
pregnancy rate in human in vitro fertilization treatments when embryos are cultured individually or in group culture in Well-of-the-Well (WOW) Petri dish
(Primo Dish, Vitrolife Hungary).
Summary answer: Group culture in WOW Petri dish results in a higher cell
number and better embryo morphology than individual culture on Day 3 of
embryo development. A non-significant increased clinical pregnancy rate is
observed after group culture.
What is known already: Embryos in human IVF treatment are frequently cultured individually in microdrops allowing individual assessment and tracing of
embryo quality. Culturing more than one embryo in the same microdrop may
result in accumulation of autocrine and paracrine factors in culture media
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
oocyte’s Ca2+ machinery is optimized. In animal models, multiple IP3R1 modifications occur during maturation from the germinal vesicle (GV) to metaphase
II (MII) stage, affecting its sensitivity and ensuring that the optimum Ca2+ response concurs with fertilization. These IP3R1 modifications include its redistribution, elevated level, enhanced Ca2+-releasing ability and relative IP3R1
phosphorylation (p-IP3R1) potentially by M-phase kinases.
Study design, size, duration: Immature, in vivo-matured and failed-fertilized
oocytes were obtained with informed consent (2010/182) from 98 women
(32.2 + 4.6 years old) undergoing infertility treatment. Fifty oocytes were used
for immunoblotting to assess the p-IP3R1 status, 35 for [Ca2+]ER evaluation
and 37 for IP3R1 immunostaining and confocal microscopy.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: GV and MI oocytes were matured in
the presence of inhibitors of Polo-like kinase 1 (Plk1) (BI 2536) and cyclindependent kinase 1(CDK1) (roscovitine, RO-3306) respectively. MPM-2 and
Rbt03-IP3R1 antibodies were used for immunoblotting and CT1-IP3R1 for immunostaining. [Ca2+]ER was assessed after thapsigargin treatment in Ca2+-free
medium. Results are expressed as median (interquartile range).
Main results and the role of chance: Immunoblotting analysis indicated a
2.2-fold maturation-associated increase in IP3R1 level between the GV and MII
stage. The p-IP3R1 increased by 75% from the GV to GV breakdown (GVBD)
stage and reached a maximum level in MII oocytes. Specific inhibition of Plk1
(until GVBD stage) and CDK1 (until MII stage) decreased the p-IP3R1 by 30%
and 50% respectively. During maturation, IP3R1 redistributed from a diffuse
pattern to an increasingly localized pattern in both in vitro- and in vivo-matured
oocytes with prominent clusters that decreased in size after fertilization and in
vitro aging. [Ca2+]ER increased from 0.4 (0.3-0.5) AU at the GV stage to 1
(0.8-1.4) AU at the GVBD, 1.4 (1.2-1.7) AU at the MI and 1.8 (1.7-2.1) AU at
the MII stage (P , 0.05).
Limitations, reason for caution: It is currently unclear which is the critical IP3R1
modification underlying its increased sensitivity. Further analysis is required to
clarify the effect of M-phase kinases on IP3R1 phosphorylation and IP3R1 Ca2+releasing ability in human oocytes.
Wider implications of the findings: This is the first report showing that various
components of cytoplasmic maturation can render human oocytes competent to
initiate [Ca2+] oscillations at fertilization. These not only include the increase
in [Ca2+]ER and IP3R1 redistribution but also the rise in IP3R1 level and phosphorylation, which in animal models lead to increased sensitivity for Ca2+ release. Any
perturbations of these processes could potentially hinder normal human fertilization and embryo development.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This work was supported by a Ghent University grant to B.H. The authors have no competing interests to declare.
Trial registration number: Not applicable.
Abstracts
Abstracts
P-171
Origin and role of transient DNA strand breaks during
spermiogenesis
R. Elias 1, Q.V. Neri1, T. Fields1, P.N. Schlegel2, Z. Rosenwaks1, and G.D. Palermo
1
1
Weill Cornell Medical College, Reproductive Medicine, New York, U.S.A, 2Weill
Cornell Medical College, Urology Department, New York, U.S.A
Study question: To assess the etiology, localization, and meaning of DNA strand
breaks occurring during sperm production versus those generated in the male
genital tract.
Summary answer: From this preliminary data, it appears that the origin of DNA
fragmentation in these infertile men is caused by a post-spermatogenic insult.
Therefore, the utilization of testicular specimen may enhance pregnancy outcome.
What is known already: Tests for sperm DNA integrity have been proposed to
assess male gamete competence. They are currently gaining popularity and are
more often used as a supplemental assay to traditional semen analysis. Sperm
DNA nicks and breaks are considered the culprits for the impaired reproductive
capacity in natural and assisted reproduction, however, it remains to be elucidated
when and at what level during sperm production the mishap occurs.
Study design, size, duration: In patients with recurrent ICSI failure in ejaculated
spermatozoa, DNA fragmentation was assessed. To determine whether a testicular
biopsy would yield spermatozoa with a healthier chromatin, men underwent ICSI
with this specimen. Embryo developmental capacity and pregnancy outcome were
compared among the two semen source.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: We identified infertile men (n ¼ 9)
with high DNA fragmentation in their ejaculates that agreed to undergo testicular
biopsy for this indication. Chromatin fragmentation index was assessed by SCSA
or TUNEL on both types of sperm sources. Reproductive outcomes of ICSI cycles
utilizing the two sperm sources were analyzed and compared.
Main results and the role of chance: In 9 men with recurrent ICSI failure (3.2
cycles) their sperm yielded 60.9 + 29% fragmentation (up to 96%). After counseling, eight underwent TESE with 6.5 + 5% DFI.
In a paired analysis the ejaculated cycle closest to the TESE cycle, gave a fertilization of 55.9% and 50.0%, respectively. The embryo cleavage was lower in the
ejaculate at 63.6% with a pregnancy rate of 12.5%, while in the TESE cohort all
embryos cleaved resulting in a 25.0% clinical pregnancy.
When the overall ejaculated cycles (n ¼ 28) and TESE (n ¼ 13) were analyzed,
fertilization was higher in the former (60.0 vs 46.9%;P , 0.01) with a comparable
embryo cleavage rate. Following the replacement of an average of 2.8 conceptuses, the clinical pregnancy was 10.7% (3/28) in the ejaculate and 30.8%
(4/13) for the TESE.
Limitations, reason for caution: Patients need to be informed of the risks with
regards to the surgery, anesthesia, and the possibility that even with TESE a pregnancy may not occur. Therefore, appropriate counseling should be conducted
since these men have spermatozoa in their ejaculate.
Wider implications of the findings: When couples have recurrent pregnancy failures after ICSI, associated with a high sperm DNA fragmentation, they should be
offered the option to undergo testicular biopsy.
Study funding/competing interest(s): Institutional
Trial registration number: Not applicable
P-172 Clinical outcomes following the transfer of vitrified blastocysts
derived from a single or sequential culture medium
A. Gilson, N. Piront, B. Heens, C. Vastersaegher, A. Vansteenbrugge, and
P.C.P. Pauwels
Centre Hospitalier Régional de Namur, Procréation Médicalement Assistée,
Namur, Belgium
Study question: The purpose of this study was to examine the effect of single
versus sequential culture medium on the survival of post-thawed blastocysts
and their related chances of implantation and pregnancy rates.
Summary answer: No statistical differences in terms of survival, implantation
and pregnancy rates of post-thawed blastocysts were observed between the two
culture media studied.
What is known already: Both single and sequential culture media contribute to
the development of zygote to the blastocyst stage. A large number of clinical
studies have shown that blastocyst transfer results in higher implantation and pregnancy rates than cleavage-stage embryo transfer. Obtaining good quality blastocysts before a vitrification procedure is a crucial step in predicting successful
pregnancy rates. However, the impact of culture medium on blastocyst cryotolerance remains poorly studied.
Study design, size, duration: The current study includes a total of 177 warming
cycles of blastocysts from infertile women with a mean age of 32. Among these,
101 were derived from culture in the single medium and 76 from culture in the sequential medium. Data were retrospectively analysed for blastocyst survival, implantation and pregnancy rates. Chi-square test was used for statistical analysis.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Embryos arising from IVF cycles
were randomly cultured in four-well dishes containing either Global (single) or
Sage (sequential) medium covered with oil. Surplus embryos meeting our laboratory standards for cryopreservation were vitrified in closed condition. Following
warming, blastocysts were incubated for 3 hours prior to their transfer. Morphological assessment was used to evaluate embryo viability/survival before and
after vitrification. Only blastocysts that show sign of reexpansion and with a cell
viability above 50% were considered for transfer.
Main results and the role of chance: There were 142 thawed embryos vitrified
after a 5 day culture in Global medium and 96 thawed embryos vitrified after a
5 days culture in Sage medium.
The survival of post-warmed blastocysts was similar for both Global and Sage
culture medium (78.9% vs. 82.3% respectively). Similarly, no significant differences were observed between the two culture medium studied with respect to implantation rate (35.7% vs. 43.0%), clinical pregnancy rate (38.4% vs. 46.6%) and
ongoing pregnancy rate (32.6% vs. 34.6%).
Limitations, reason for caution: N/A
Wider implications of the findings: This study shows that the use of single or sequential culture medium does not affect the recovery of vitrified blastocysts and
that both media ensure similar chances of implantation and pregnancy following
frozen blastocyst transfer.
Study funding/competing interest(s): N/A
Trial registration number: N/A
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
having a beneficial effect on embryo development. The WOW dish contains 9 + 1
microwells in the center of the dish allowing identification of individual embryos
cultured together in the same microdrop.
Study design, size, duration: One hundred nineteen consecutive IVF-ET cycles
were enrolled in this prospective randomized study between September and December 2012. Cycles were randomized using a computer generated table. Five
hundred thirty-five embryos from 57 cycles were cultured in WOW dish and
581 embryos from 62 cycles were cultured individually (Control group).
Participants/materials, setting, methods: IVF cycles were randomized into
WOW group or individual culture. In WOW group up to 10 embryos were cultured
together in 25 ml culture media. In Control group embryos were placed into a 25 ml
droplet individually. Pregnancy rate and embryo morphology were compared.
Main results and the role of chance: Fertilization rate in ICSI cycles -where
oocytes were placed into culture dish immediately after sperm injection- were significantly higher in WOW than in Control group (74.5% vs. 66.7 %, P ¼ 0.022).
Number of blastomeres was similar in the two groups on Day 2. However, degree
of fragmentation was significantly lower in WOW than in Control group (12.7 +
8.4% vs. 15.0 + 11.8; P ¼ 0.005). We observed a higher number of blastomeres
(7.0 + 2.0 vs. 6.5 + 2.1; P ¼ 0.002) and a lower degree of fragmentation (13.5 +
10.6% vs. 15.5 + 12.8; P ¼ 0.045) in WOW group on day 3. A higher proportion
of embryos were available for cryopreservation in WOW group (41.3% vs. 32.9%;
P ¼ 0.024). Clinical pregnancy rate was 50.9% in WOW and 38.7% in Control
group but the difference did not reach significance (P ¼ 0.182).
Limitations, reason for caution: These are preliminary data of a larger study.
There is more than 10% difference in clinical pregnancy rate which is not significant due to limited case numbers.
Wider implications of the findings: Our intermediate findings suggest that using
WOW group culture dish may have a beneficial effect on IVF outcome. This is in
agreement with previous findings on the superiority of group culture, however,
WOW system allows for individual assessment and tracing of individual
embryo quality. A larger study is currently ongoing.
Study funding/competing interest(s): Trial registration number: ClinicalTrials.gov: NCT01774006
i187
i188
P-173
Embryo culture under two different incubator temperature:
a double blind randomized clinical trial
M.F. Abdel-Raheem1, M.Y. Abdel-Rahman2, H.M. Abdel-Gaffar2, M. Sabry2,
H. Kasem3, S.M. Rasheed 2, M. Amin2, A. Abdelmonem2, and A.S. Ait-Allah2
1
IBN-SINA IVF/ICSI Center, IVF Lab, Sohag, Egypt, 2Sohag University, OB/
GYN, Sohag, Egypt, 3Akhmim General Hospital, OB/GYN, Sohag, Egypt
P-174
An uninterrupted culture medium protocol in conjunction with a
non-humidified incubation environment can provide more patient treatment
options for IVF programs
M. VerMilyea, J. Anthony, J. Bucci, S. Croly, and C. Coutifaris
University of Pennsylvania, Penn Fertility Care, Philadelphia, U.S.A
Study question: The purpose of this study was to investigate the effects of embryo
development and alternative patient treatment options when using a renewed
two-step sequential media protocol and traditional “big-box” incubators compared to a continuous uninterrupted single-medium protocol and benchtop incubators with no humidity.
Summary answer: Embryos grown in a non-invasive single culture medium
under oil and retained in humidity-free benchtop incubators are three-times
more likely to become usable blastocysts thereby doubling the number of day-5
embryo transfers and providing supernumerary blastocysts for vitrification for
use in subsequent frozen embryo transfer cycles.
What is known already: Culture media is based on either a sequential (two/threestep) media protocol, which requires the use of one media followed by a different
media, or a single step culture medium. Previous reports have often suggested that
a sequential series of media are necessary to accommodate changes in the physiology and metabolism of embryos but recent studies have shown comparable
pregnancy outcomes but improved blastocyst development when embryos are cultured in an uninterrupted media and humid environment.
Study design, size, duration: This retrospective study consisted of data from 956
zygotes, which resulted in 179 embryo transfers over the course of nine months.
304 embryos were cultured in a sequential culture media system in standard size
incubators while 652 embryos were place in a single-step medium in nonhumidified benchtop incubators.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Irvine Scientific’s Continuous Single
Culture (CSC) was compared with LifeGlobal’s Fertilization and Global sequential renewed-medium with respect to human embryo development, blastocyst utilization rates and patient treatment options. Embryos cultured in CSC and
K-Systems G-185 incubator were compared to GF and G media in Forma 3130
incubators.
Main results and the role of chance: Overall, significantly more embryos cultured in CSC and non-humidified benchtop incubators were transferred on
day-5, compared to those cultured in Global sequential medium in humidity controlled “big-box” incubators (57% vs. 29%, P ¼ 0.0013). Autologous patients in
different age groups (,35, 35-37, 38-40, .40) had more blastocyst transfers as a
result of CSC compared to Global (74% vs. 47%, 60% vs. 28%, 27% vs. 21%, 33%
vs. 0%, respectively). In addition, surplus blastocysts available for cryopreservation, which were cultured in CSC compared to LifeGlobal medium, were significantly greater (30% vs. 6%, P ¼ 0.0001). Ultimately, patients across all age
groups had a significantly higher blastocyst utilization rate when cultured in a noninvasive one-step embryo culture protocol (45% vs. 16%, P ¼ 0.0001 respectively). Data were analyzed by Chi-square analysis or Fisher’s exact test with P ≤
0.005 regarded as statically significant.
Limitations, reason for caution: Although the data set is not extremely large, this
observation clearly shows an upward trend supporting the benefit of a noninvasive culture system, which incorporates an uninterrupted single culture
medium (from day-0 to -6) and benchtop incubators. Further investigation into
pregnancy outcomes will also soon be reviewed.
Wider implications of the findings: The interest in single step culture medium
has grown due to several practical and theoretical advantages over a sequential
media protocol. A non-invasive static approach to embryo culture, where unwarranted embryonic stresses from varying composition of media, potential osmotic
shock and deprivation of any paracrine or autocrine factors has recently been
shown to be beneficial for embryo development. Practical advantages of using a
single step protocol include a substantial reduction in labor, error and cost.
Study funding/competing interest(s): None
Trial registration number: None
P-175
Efficiency of biopsy strategy and vitrification procedure in PGS
cycles
R. Maggiulli1, L. Rienzi1, D. Cimadomo1, A. Capalbo1, L. Dusi2, S. Colamaria1,
E. Baroni1, M. Giuliani1, A. Vaiarelli1, F. Sapienza1, L. Buffo2, and F.M. Ubaldi1
1
Genera Center for Reproductive Medicine, Clinica Valle Giulia, Rome, Italy,
2
Genera Center for Reproductive Medicine, Clinica Salus, Marostica, Italy
Study question: We aim to evaluate the efficiency of biopsy strategy and vitrification procedure, assessed as impact on implantation potential of euploid embryos
and on laboratory workload, in PGS cycles.
Summary answer: Embryo implantation potential of euploid embryos seems not
to be affected by the biopsy day and/or the vitrification procedure at blastocyst
stage. Laboratory workload is higher for day 3 biopsy, without any advantage
on the clinical outcome.
What is known already: The prevalence of aneuploidy in human embryos provides a likely explanation for the relatively low success observed during IVF
cycles, especially in advanced maternal age patients. Unfortunately, a poor correlation between conventional embryo morphological evaluation and chromosomal
complement has been shown. This observation led to the introduction of PGS to
avoid the transfer of aneuploid embryos. However, there is not yet a clear consensus about the impact of embryo biopsy strategy on implantation potential.
Study design, size, duration: We compared day 3 biopsy (of one blastomere) and
transfer on day 5 (strategy 1) (36 cycles); day 5 biopsy (of 5-10 trofoectoderm
cells) and transfer on day 6 (strategy 2) (11 cycles) and day 5 biopsy, vitrification
and transfer in a subsequent prepared cycle (strategy 3) (10 cycles).
Participants/materials, setting, methods: The patients enrolled in this study
underwent ICSI/PGS cycles due to advanced maternal age (N ¼ 57). The mean
female age was 38.1 + 2,9, 37,5 + 3,4 and 37,9 + 3,5 years for strategy 1, 2,
and 3 respectively. No differences were observed in the basic patients characteristics between the 3 groups. Aneuploidies were assessed by whole genome
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
Study question: Does embryo culture at 36.5 degree Celsius result in better pregnancy rate compared with embryo culture at the traditional 37 degree Celsius incubator temperature?
Summary answer: There is a statistically significant increase (*P ¼ 0.0196) in
the pregnancy rate at the group cultured at incubators with lower temperature
36.5 degree Celsius (65.79%) compared to the pregnancy rate at the group cultured at incubators with traditional 37 degree Celsius (44.44%).
What is known already: To date all IVF/ICSI procedures are conducted at 37
degree Celsius, yet little studies had discussed the effect of temperature on development of embryos. It was principally accepted that 37 degree Celsius is the best
temperature for all aspects of human in vitro procedure. The ‘quiet embryo hypothesis’ proposed that viable embryos have a ‘quiet’ metabolism. Others proposed that gametes and early embryos function in vivo at a lower temperature
than core body temperature.
Study design, size, duration: This is a double blind randomized controlled clinical trial conducted at a private IVF/ICSI center comprising 130 participant at the
period between October 2012 to January 2012.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: One hundred thirty women undergoing fresh IVF/ICSI cycles in a private center were randomly assigned either to 36.5
degree Celsius incubator temperature (Group I, N¼ 76) or 37 degree Celsius incubator temperature (Group II, N¼ 54).
Main results and the role of chance: There was a clear statistical significant increase (*P ¼ 0.0196) in the pregnancy rate at (group I) which cultured at incubators with lower temperature 36.5 degree Celsius 50/76 (65.79%) compared to the
pregnancy rate at (group II) which cultured at incubators with traditional 37 degree
Celsius 30/54 (44.44%).
Limitations, reason for caution: Lack of clear molecular background that can
explain the interesting increase of the pregnancy rate in the group cultured at
lower temperature.
Wider implications of the findings: To change the traditional incubator temperature to 36.5 degree Celsius.
Study funding/competing interest(s): There was no study funding or competing
interests.
Trial registration number: ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT01706900
Abstracts
i189
Abstracts
P-176
Use of culture media amino acid mass spectrometry/liquid chromotography (LCMS) measurments in identifing the embryo with the best implantation potential
E. Zivi1, E. Aizenman 1, D. Barash2, D. Gibson2, and Y. Shufaro 1
Hadassah Ein Kerem, IVF unit, Jerusalem, Israel, 2Hebrew university, Institute
for Drug Research School of Pharmacy, Jerusalem, Israel
1
Study question: Is there an assocoation between culture media amino acids’
(serine, proline, taurine, aspartic acid) alterations, as detected in mass spectrometry (MS), with reproductive outcome?
Summary answer: Serine and proline excretion into the fertilization media was
found to be in association with pregnancy.
What is known already: Several studies investigated the correlation between
pyruvate and glucose uptake with embryo viability and pregnancy. Others
found that an increased uptake is correlative with embryo development and implantation. Amino-acids metabolism has also been investigated. Studies have
found an association between low concentrations of glycine and leucine and
high concentration of aspargine in the culture media, with high pregnancy rate.
High glutamate levels also correlate with pregnancy and live birth.
Study design, size, duration: The study is observational.45 IVF patients of
various ages, infertility etiologies and different embryo qualities undergoing treatment, are included. Exclusion criteria: patients with a significant male factor abnormality, structural anomaly of the uterus, endometriosis and pregestational
diagnosis embryos. Spent culture media samples are collected and analyzed
on MS.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Day 1 and day 3 samples of spent
media are collected from each embryo, and analyzed on MS, in comparison to
control empty medium droplets incubated identically. The samples preparation
includes adding distilled water and hexane in order to remove the oil phase that
coats the incubated embryos.
Main results and the role of chance: Spent medium samples from each oocyte/
embryo were obtained in 45 IVF cycles, performed in different patients, were analyzed by LCMS. 22 patients conceived after fresh embryo transfer (all singletons).
Day 1 spent fertilization media of 219 oocytes was analyzed, of which 84 embryos
were transferred fresh.
On day 1, excretion of serine and / or proline were found highly predictive for
pregnancy; for proline excretion the PR’s were 40% compared to 18.5% (OR2.9,
95% CI 1.1-8, p ¼ 0.04). For serine excretion the PR’s were 50% compared to
17% (OR 5, 95% CI 1.75-14.28, p ¼ 0.003).
No significant differences in PRs were found in regard to aspartic acid and
taurine excretion or uptake.
The results of day 3 embryo culture media are currently analyzed.
Limitations, reason for caution: Thechnical limitations due to difficulties in
sample preparations regarded to the oil phase in the incubation.
Wider implications of the findings: Serine and proline excretion into the fertilization media was found to be in association with pregnancy. The biological significance of this observation is that an embryo’s quality and implantation potential
can be determined even immediately after fertilization. Accurate measurements of
media minute amino acid concentration changes are feasible even at this early
stage.
Study funding/competing interest(s): research fund of the hospital. there is no
competing interests.
Trial registration number: the study is observational - not a clinical trial
P-177 Pronuclear score does not predict embryo implantaion.
Retrospective study on different checkpoint times
M. Pérez 1, J. Aguilar 1, E. Táboas1, M. Ojeda1, L. Suárez 1, and E. Muñoz2
IVI VIGO, IVF Lab, Vigo (Pontevedra), Spain, 2IVI VIGO, IVF Unit, Vigo
(Pontevedra), Spain
1
Study question: Can pronuclear score predict the embryo implantation?
Summary answer: The aim of this study is to compare the pronuclear score
(Z-score) at 17 hours post-insemination and at the frame before both pronucleus
(PN) disappear to correlate them with implantation rate by using a time-lapse system.
What is known already: A major objective of IVF laboratories is the identification and selection of embryos with the highest implantation potential after transfer,
avoiding multiple pregnancies.
Pronuclear evaluation under light microscopy has been employed as a determining method for embryo fertilization assessment, and also for embryo selection.
Previous studies endorse the prognostic effect of pronuclear evaluation for
embryo viability and chromosomal abnormalities, while other authors have not
been able to find any correlation.
Study design, size, duration: Retrospective study of 2697 microinyected oocytes
from 420 ICSI patients between January 2011 and November 2012, all of them
incubated in an incubator with time-lapse technology.
A x2-test was performed as the statistical analysis to assess the influence of the
multinucleation in the implantation rate, and Yates correction when applicable.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: The embryos which either failed to
implant or fully implanted, with full implantation meaning that all transferred
embryos in a treatment implanted, were defined as KID (Known Implantation
Data) positive (+) and negative (-) respectively. Only they were included in the
study.
The distribution of nuclear precursor bodies (NPB) is classified into four groups
given Z-scores 1, 2, 3 and 4. Score group 1 includes zygotes with three to seven
polarized NPB; score group 2 consists of zygotes with homogeneously dispersed
NPB; score group 3 covers all the zygotes with a NPB distribution not included in
the other three groups, i.e., more than seven polarized NPB, one PN polarized and
the other dispersed or both dispersed but not homogeneously; and score group 4 is
formed of zygotes with only one or two NPB as described by Gamiz et al (2003).
Z-score was registered at 17 hours post-insemination and the frame before the
pronuclear disappearance (BPD).
Embryo transfer was performed on day 2-3 of development and embryo implantation was confirmed at an ultrasound scanning for gestational sacs.
Main results and the role of chance: 268 KID embryos wereanalyzed. 33.5%
(n ¼ 90) KID + , and 66.5% (n ¼ 178) KID-6. At 17h post-insemination,the
Z-score was Z1 ¼ 10% (n ¼ 27); Z2 ¼ 7.8 (n ¼ 21); Z3 ¼ 15,6% (n ¼ 42) and
Z4 ¼ 0% for theKID+ embryos, and Z1 ¼ 17.1% (n ¼ 46); Z2 ¼ 14.2% (n ¼
38); Z3 ¼ 32.8% (n ¼ 88); andZ4 ¼ 2.2% (n ¼ 6) for the KID- embryos. At
BPF, the Z-score was Z1 ¼ 14.9% (n ¼ 40);Z2 ¼ 3.7% (n ¼ 10); Z3 ¼ 13.8%
(n ¼ 37) and Z4 ¼ 1,1% (n ¼ 3) for the KID + , and Z1 ¼ 23.13%(n ¼ 62);
Z2 ¼ 7.5% (n ¼ 20); Z3 ¼ 30.9% (n ¼ 83) and Z4 ¼ 4.8% (n ¼ 13) for KID-.
Statistical analysisshowed no significant differences in implantation rate and
Z-score between groups,(p ¼ 0.30) and p ¼ (0.32) respectively. It showed an increase in the percentage ofZ1, Z3 and Z4 and a decrease in Z2 which could be
observed comparing 17h vs.BPD (p , 0,05).
Limitations, reason for caution: Limitations due to the number of embryos analysed.
Wider implications of the findings: The two PN show a dynamic pattern and
Z-score depends on when it is performed. As closer to BPD, NPB tend to be
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
amplification and array CGH (Bluegnome, UK). The primary outcome measure
was ongoing implantation rate (.12 weeks of gestation), while secondary outcomes measures were related to number of biopsied embryos and euploid blastocyts obtained.
Main results and the role of chance: A significant higher mean number of
embryos per cycle were biopsied on day 3 vs day 5 (8,3 + 2,5 vs 4,9 + 2,2 and
4,8 + 1,3 respectively, p , 0.001). A similar percentage of embryos were diagnosed as euploid when strategy 1 was applied: 81/300 (27,0%), vs 20/54
(37,0%) strategy 2 and 18/48 (37,5%) strategy 3 (NS). Moreover, the mean
number of euploid embryos that reached the blastocyst stage (thus available for
transfer and/or vitrification) per cycle was also comparable (1,9 + 0,7 (70/36),
1,8 + 0.9 (20/11), 1,8 + 0,6 (18/10), for strategy 1,2,3 respectively). In
warming cycles, blastocyst survival rate was 100% (16/16). Ongoing implantation
rate was similar in the 3 groups [40,0% (28/70), 44,4% (8/18) and 43,8% (7/16)]
for strategy 1,2,3 respectively).
Limitations, reason for caution: The main limitation of this study is the relatively
low number of embryos included (402 biopsied, 104 transferred) and the retrospective approach.
Wider implications of the findings: Since embryo biopsy strategy and/or cryopreservation procedure do not seem to have any impact on embryo developmental
potential, the most appropriate PGS strategy (day 3 or day 5 biopsy) can be adopted
according to the required genetic information and the laboratory workload.
Study funding/competing interest(s): none
Trial registration number: none
i190
polarized. According to our data, there is not any prognostic effect of pronuclear
evaluation at 17h or at BPD on implantation rate.
Further studies with a greater number of embryos analyzed are necessary to
confirm these preliminary results.
Study funding/competing interest(s): No commercial interest
Trial registration number: Trial none
Abstracts
Study funding/competing interest(s): No external funding was obtained for the
present study; has to be declared with any financial organization regarding the material discussed in the manuscript.
Trial registration number: Not applicable
P-179
Time affects time: increased maternal age delays embryo morpho-
kinetics
P-178
Time laps monitoring of embryo development in patients with testicular or ejaculated sperm: a comparative study
Study question: Our purpose was to compare, with the use of time-lapse technology, the developmental stages of embryos obtained with intracytoplasmic injection of spermatozoa retrieved either by ejaculation or by the testicles, in order to
find out possible differences in the developmental kinetics between the two
groups.
Summary answer: No difference appeared in the fertilization timing between testicular and normal ejaculated sperm, except a very slight anticipation of the second
polar body (IIPB) extrusion. In the following cellular divisions, it was possible to
observe a significant retardation in the 4-cells stage in embryos deriving from testicular sperm.
What is known already: It is well known that ejaculated and testicular sperm
differ in the degree of nuclear maturation. During spermiogenesis, the transit of
spermatozoa in the epididymal tract favors DNA packaging by stabilizing the
chromatin structure through protamine dephosphorilation and the formation of
molecular bridges. Additional difference in sperm maturity may involve the centriols as structures implicated in embryo cleavage. Based on these observations,
sperm maturity can affect the timing of fertilization and later cellular divisions.
Study design, size, duration: In this retrospective observational study (September 2012-January 2013), we analyzed the developmental kinetics of embryos
obtained either with testicular sperm (N ¼ 40 embryos; TS-group) or with
normal (WHO, 2010) ejaculated sperm (N ¼ 101 embryos; ES-group). The developmental markers observed were: IIPB extrusion, 2PN appearance, 2PN disappearance, divisions at 2 to 8-cells.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Development timings were recorded
for all embryos (TS-group: 9 ICSI cycles, female mean age ¼ 33.78 + 4.58;
ES-group: 25 cycles, mean age ¼ 35.57 + 4.09). Only correctly fertilized
oocytes were observed (40/50 ¼ 80% in TS; 101/117 ¼ 86.3% in ES, NS). Student’s t-test was used for statistical analyses. Average hour + SD from ICSI insemination are reported for all stages.
Main results and the role of chance: In TS versus ES groups respectively, IIPB
was extruded at 3.86 + 1.48h (N ¼ 38) and 4.03 + 1.39h (N ¼ 88) (p ¼ 0.035);
2PN appeared at 10.05 + 1.77h (N ¼ 40) and 10.33 + 2.78h (N¼ 101); 2PN disappeared at 24.93 + 3.59h (N ¼ 32) and 23.91 + 2.48h (N ¼ 100); cleavage at
2-cells was at 27.94 + 3.75h (N ¼ 25) and 26.66 + 3.00h (N¼ 92); 3-cells at
39.07 + 6.27h (N ¼ 18) and 38.65 + 4.68h (N ¼ 53); 4-cells at 42.08 + 4.62h
(N ¼ 23) and 39.70 + 3.65h N ¼ 88) (p ¼ 0.019); 5-cells at 52.23 + 9.45h
(N ¼ 16) and 51.08 + 7.87h (N ¼ 70); 6-cells at 54.09 + 10.08h (N ¼ 17) and
53.18 + 5.05h (N ¼ 53); 7-cells 52.65 + 9.21h (N ¼ 16) and 52.26 + 3.95h
(N ¼ 58); 8-cells 54.99 + 9.73h (N ¼ 12) and 57.56 + 6.63h (N ¼ 60). In
brackets are reported numbers of embryos at a specific developmental stage.
Data on embryos are relative to cultures up to day-2 or day-3.
Limitations, reason for caution: A limitation of the present study is the small size
of our population due to the fact that we have started using the time-lapse technology only in September 2012. An additional limitation may relates to the imaging
system of such technology that allows the visualization of only 7 focal layers.
Wider implications of the findings: Differences in maturity of ejaculated and testicular sperm seem not to interfere with fertilization when ICSI is performed.
Sperm factors involved in oocyte activation are likely present in testicular spermatozoa in similar amount and with similar biological activity as in normal ejaculated sperm. The retardation in the 4-cell stage observed with testicular sperm
could be due to immaturity at different levels which may involve the sperm
head as well as other structures participating in cellular divisions.
Study question: To determine whether maternal age affects embryo morphokinetic parameters.
Summary answer: Embryos derived from older mothers have a slower development to the morula and blastocyst stage compared to embryos derived from
younger mothers.
What is known already: Maternal age is the most significant factor to affect
embryo implantation potential due to the increased incidence of aneuploidy in
embryos derived from older patients. Aneuploid embryos have been shown to
have delayed embryo morphokinetics. Therefore, it was hypothesized that
increased maternal age delays embryo development.
Study design, size, duration: This blind retrospective study in an IVF clinic
assessed morphokinetic parameters of 348 human embryos cultured using a timelapse imaging system (EmbryoscopeTM, Unisense-Fertilitech, Denmark) from
April to October 2012. Embryos were categorized as derived from older (age
greater or equal to 37 years) versus younger (36 years and under) patients.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Morphokinetic data was collected
from 24 ICSI patients cultured in the EmbryoScopeTM (sensitivity: 15 minutes).
Following ICSI, hours for embryos to reach the 2-cell, 3-cell, 4-cell, 5-cell,
6-cell, 7-cell, 8-cell, 9 + cell, morula, expanded and hatched blastocyst were
recorded and compared between 10 older and 14 younger patients.
Main results and the role of chance: Embryo morphokinetic parameters were
compared between embryos derived from older and younger patients and differences tested for significance using a two-tailed two sample t-test. Differences
were found to be significant at p , 0.05. Data are presented as mean+ standard
deviation. Patient age did not significantly affect the time for embryos to reach the
2-cell, 3-cell, 4-cell, 5-cell, 6-cell, 7-cell, 8-cell or 9 + cell stages. Younger
patients reached the morula (92.9 + 11 vs 98.8 + 14 hours post insemination,
hpi, p ¼ 0.03), expanded blastocyst (111.7 + 8.4 vs 118 + 8.8hpi, p ¼ 0.008)
and hatched blastocyst (115.1 + 7.5 vs 129 + 10.7hpi, p , 0.001) stages faster
than older patients (younger vs older patients respectively).
Limitations, reason for caution: As expected, the mean FSH dose for older
patients (3069 + 1531,n ¼ 144) was significantly greater (p , 0.001) than for
younger patients (2148 + 1052, n ¼ 204). Therefore, further studies are required
to determine whether the differences between the two treatments were due to maternal age or differences in dose of FSH.
Wider implications of the findings: Time-lapse technology has the potential to
improve embryo selection if parameters are identified as accurate predictors of implantation potential. Improving our understanding of how these parameters interact with current established predictors of implantation, such as age, may aid in the
formation of models to predict implantation. Such models would have considerable clinical value, with the potential to improve IVF success rates.
Study funding/competing interest(s): None
Trial registration number: None
The effect of Sildenafil Citrate (Viagraw) in vivo on endometrial
receptivity, ovulation and embryo development in mice
P-180
L. Asgari, D. Paouneskou, K. Jayaprakasan, W. Maalouf, and B.K. Campbell
University of Nottingham, School of Clinical Sciences, Nottingham, United
Kingdom
Study question: What are the effects of pre-conception sildenafil treatment on:
subsequent embryo development through culturing of embryos until the blastocyst stage, endometrial receptivity through assessment of the thickness of the epithelial cell layer and oocyte yield through the estimation of the number of corpora
lutea in mice.
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
V. Casciani1, M.G. Minasi1, F. Scarselli1, M. Terribile1, D. Zavaglia1,
A. Colasante1, G. Franco 2, and E. Greco 1
1
European Hospital, Centre for Reproductive Medicine, Rome, Italy, 2Sapienza
University, Gynaecological-Obstetrical and Urological Sciences, Rome, Italy
C. Hickman, C. Cook, D. Gwinnett, G. Trew, A. Carby, and S. Lavery
Boston Place Clinic, Embryology, London, United Kingdom
i191
Abstracts
P-181
Binucleation versus multinucleation in 2-cells embryos how do
they affect to implantation rate?
J. Aguilar1, E. Taboas1, M. Perez1, E. Muñoz2, M. Ojeda1, and J. Remohi3
IVI Vigo, FIV, Vigo, Spain, 2IVI Vigo, Gynecology, Vigo, Spain, 3IVI Valencia,
Gynecology, Valencia, Spain
1
Study question: How do binucleation and multinucleation in 2-cells embryo
affect the implantation rate
Summary answer: Embryos with one blastomere multinucleated (more than two
nuclei per cell) have a lower implantation rate than those with one binucleated
blastomere and those with both blastomeres multinucleated (binucleated or multinucleated)
What is known already: Multinucleation has been related with an increase in the
aneuplody rate, in chromosomal anomalies and a lower blastocyst rate, although
the impact of multinucleation on live birth rate remains elusive. Nucleation
errors are relatively frequent and, can be transitory phenomenon. They are classified either as binucleation (2 nuclei per cell), multinucleation (3 or more nuclei per
cell).
Study design, size, duration: Cross-sectional study of 2697 microinjected
oocytes from 420 ICSI patients between January 2011 and November 2012, all
of them incubated in an incubator with time-lapse technology.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Only KID (Known Implantation
Data) embryos were analized.They were classified in 6 groups according to implantation (positive/negative),and the number of multinucleated blastomeres on
2-cells stage, (group 0¼ none; group 1 ¼ one; group 2 ¼ two)
Multinucleation on 4-cells embryo was employed as exclusion criteria. x2-test
and a Fisher exact t-test were performed
Main results and the role of chance: 245 out 475 embryos transferred provided
known implantation information and were analyzed, whereas 32.24% (n ¼ 79)
fully implanted and 67.75% (n ¼ 166) failed to implant. Multinucleation was
present in 46.17% of the embryos.
17.1% (n ¼ 42) fully implanted embryos were group 0, 8.97% embryos (n ¼
22) were group 1, and 6.1% (n ¼ 15) group 2. The distribution for the
not-implanted embryos was (n ¼ 90) 36.7 % of embryos group 0, 17.5%, one
cell multinucleated (group 1) (n ¼ 43), and 13.46% both cells multinucleated
(group 2) (n ¼ 33).
In group 1, those embryos binucleated (n ¼ 17) showed greater implantation
rate than those multinucleated (n ¼ 5), 26.15% v.s 7.69% (p ¼ 0.02)
In group 2, three subcategories were analyzed, 2 binucleated cells, 2 multinucleated cells, 1 binucleated + 1 multinucleated. No significant differences were
found among them.
Limitations, reason for caution: Studies with a greater number of embryos analyzed are necessary to confirm these preliminary results
Wider implications of the findings: Multinucleation in 2 cells embryos is relatively frequent during the embryo development, even in those transferred
embryos selected by morphology and could disappear when embryos develop
into 4-cells.The early cleavage checkpoint helps to improve embryo selection
criteria.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This work has not received any financial
support from any commercial entity.
None of the authors have any particular benefit to run this project.
Trial registration number: none
P-182 Improvement in blastocysts formation by selecting hyaluronic acid
binding sperm
E. Rega, A. Alteri, R.P. Cotarelo, P. Rubino, A. Colicchia, and P. Giannini
Ferticlinic-Villa Margherita, Laboratorio PMA, Roma, Italy
Study question: To evaluate the ability of hyaluronic acid (HA) binding sperm to
increase the efficiency of intracytoplamic sperm injection (ICSI) in terms of blastocysts formation.
Summary answer: The selection of normal sperm for ICSI with hyaluronic acid
binding assay (HA-ICSI) led to increase of the blastocyst formation rate, in comparison with the conventionally selected spermatozoa.
What is known already: The majority of studies are focused on the use of
HA-binding as a method to select spermatozoa with normal nucleus and intact
DNA. These parameters play a critical role in the paternal contribution to successful preimplantation embryogenesis; however, there are conflicting data about the
positive correlation between HA-ICSI and improvement of fertilization rate and
embryo development.
Study design, size, duration: In this cohort study, we retrospectively analyzed the
percentage of blastocysts obtained, between July and December 2012, from 67
sibling oocytes injected with either HA-bound (n ¼ 33) or conventionally
selected spermatozoa (n ¼ 34) in a randomized way.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Patients using testicular or criopreserved sperm were excluded from the study. Half of the oocytes of women retrieving more than 4 metaphase II oocytes were injected by the HA procedures. Semen
samples were treated via swim-u and placed in two different ICSI dishes with HA
and PVP drops.
Main results and the role of chance: A clear trend towards a higher blastocyst
formation rate in oocytes injected with HA-bound spermatozoa has been
observed: the frequency of blastocyst formation in HA-ICSI was 62.0%, while
for PVP-ICSI was 40.0% (p ¼ 0,0598). These data suggest that the embryos
developed from HA-ICSI seem to have a greater chance of developing to the
blastocyst stage.
Limitations, reason for caution: Low number of oocytes available for the study.
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
Summary answer: Pre-conception administration of sildenafil at both the lower
and higher doses tested impaired embryonic development relative to vehicle
treated controls and the median dose of sildenafil. Further, the higher dose
increased endometrial thickness but none of the doses had any effect on ovulation
rate or follicle number.
What is known already: Sildenafil has been suggested as a useful adjuvant
therapy in women undergoing ART to increase the blood flow to both the developing endometrium and the ovary. Previous studies from our laboratory have
shown that while addition of sildenafil to mouse embryos cultured in vitro had
no effect on embryo development at doses in the normal physiological range,
higher concentrations had a detrimental effect. This study therefore tested
whether preconception sildenafil administration had a similar negative effect.
Study design, size, duration: Mice were randomly assigned to either vehicle controls (n ¼ 16) or three different doses of sildenafil (S1:1.25 mg/kg n ¼ 16,
S2:2.5 mg/kg n ¼ 16, S3:5 mg/kg n ¼ 16) administered by oral gavage twice
daily over 2 days before mating on the morning of Day 3 before sacrifice for
tissue recovery on Day 4.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Day 1 zygotes were collected and cultured in vitro to the blastocyst stage before being scored and the total cell number
(TCN) counted. Ovaries were analysed histologically for number of corpora lutea
(CL) and follicles whereas in the uterus endometrial thickness and number of
blood vessels (neo-vascularisation) were counted.
Main results and the role of chance: Relative to vehicle treated controls, cleavage rates, speed of cleavage and blastocyst rates were significantly lower (P ,
0.05) in embryos from mice treated with the lowest and highest doses of sildenafil
(S1 and S3, P , 0.05), while there was no significant difference with the middle S2
dose. No difference was detected in the TCN of blastocysts formed (P . 0.05).
Sildenafil at the highest concentration (S3: 5 mg/kg) also caused a significant
increase in the uterine thickness (P , 0.05), while ovulation rate and follicular development remained unaffected (P . 0.05). These results suggest therefore that sildenafil may be acting via different mechanisms at different
concentrations.
Limitations, reason for caution: This work has been carried out in mice so
caution is needed when translating to the human situation as it is known that
the pharmacokinetics of sildenafil differ between species.
Wider implications of the findings Although our study supports the possible
use of sildenafil as adjuvant therapy to improve endometrial receptivity it also
raises concerns over the possible safety of this drug in terms of possible detrimental
effects on embryo development. Further animal studies on the potentially deleterious effects of pre-conception sildenafil treatment of females on subsequent
embryo and fetal development are required before the introduction of sildenafil
as an adjuvant therapy could be adopted.
Study funding/competing interest(s): Study funding came from my beloved
father, Mohandes Ehsan Asgari and the University of Nottingham.
Trial registration number: NA
i192
Wider implications of the findings: This study suggest that the selection of
normal sperm with HA might overcome potential embryo arresting due to pathogenesis inherent in the paternal genome.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This study received no funding and there
are no conflicts of interests to be declared.
Trial registration number: This was a coohort study and a trial registration does
not apply
P-183
Embryo quality predictive models based on cumulus cells gene
expression for clinical application
Study question: The aim of the study was to use cumulus cells (CC) gene expression differences of leukemia inhibitory factor (LIF), anti – Mullerian horomone
receptor, type II (AMHR2), follicle stimulating hormone receptor (FSHR), vascular endothelial growth factor C (VEGFC) and serpin E2 (SERPINE2) to differentiate high grade and low grade embryos.
Summary answer: As significant resulted AMHR2 (p ¼ 0.03) and LIF showed a
tendency to significance (p ¼ 0.11) between high grade and low grade embryos
where their combination resulted in the area under the curve (AUC) 0.72 +
0.08 and 0.73 + 0.03 for binary logistic or decision tree prediction model,
respectively.
What is known already: Cumulus cells (CC) have a specific gene expression
profile according to the developmental potential of the oocyte they are surrounding and therefore specific gene expression could be used as a biomarkers. So far no
single uniform biomarker has been found to be accurate enough for clinical application. The combination of several biomarkers and various statistical models
might improve the usefulness of CC biomarkers in the clinics.
Study design, size, duration: The CC samples from oocytes developed in high
grade embryos (n ¼ 26) and low grade embryos (n ¼ 32) from 21 patients were
analyzed. The CC expressions of LIF, AMHR2, FSHR, VEGFC and SERPINE2
were compared between high grade and low grade embryos and two models
were used to test their prediction value.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Infertile women with tubal, unexplained infertility, aged less than 35 years and normal partners’ spermiograms
were included in the study. Quantitative PCR was used to analyze CC expression.
A Mann – Whitney test was used for testing differences and a binary logistic
model and data a decision tree model were used.
Main results and the role of chance: The CC gene expression between high
grade and low grade embryos was significantly different at AMHR2 (p ¼ 0.03)
and among other genes only LIF showed a tendency to significance (p ¼ 0.11).
The CC expression values of AMHR2 and LIF were used in two models for prediction of high grade embryos. The first, binary logistic model yielded in AUC
0.69 + 0.08 for AMHR2 and AUC 0.63 + 0.08 for LIF alone. Combining both
genes the binary logistic model yielded in AUC 0.72 + 0.08. The second, decision tree model yielded in AUC 0.67 + 0.01 for AMHR2 and AUC 0.57 +
0.02 for LIF alone. Combining both genes in the decision tree model yielded an
AUC 0.73 + 0.03.
Limitations, reason for caution: Only two genes were significant enough for implementation in models. With more genes in the model the predictive power would
improve.
Wider implications of the findings: The present study indicates that prediction of
high grade embryos with CC expression is dependent on a type and number of CC
biomarkers used. Even though LIF is not significantly different between high
grade and low grade embryos it improves prediction value of AMHR2 in both
tested models. In term of eventual use in clinical practice the decision tree
model has easy rules which can be applicable when making clinical decisions.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This work was supported by Slovenian
Research Agency (www.arrs.gov.si) grants P1-0104 and L3-4162.
Trial registration number: Not a clinical trial.
P-184
Pronuclear behavior and timing of embryo development:
a time-lapse point of view
C. Scarica1, F.M. Ubaldi1, M. Stoppa1, R. Maggiulli1, A. Capalbo1, E. Ievoli1,
L. Dovere1, L. Albricci1, S. Romano1, F. Sanges1, A. Vaiarelli1, and B. Iussig2
1
GENERA, Center for Reproductive Medicine Clinica Valle Giulia, Rome, Italy,
2
GENERA, Center for Reproductive Medicine Clinica Salus, Marostica (VI), Italy
Study question: Evaluate whether specific morphodynamic events during pronuclear (PN) formation are correlated with the early stages of embryo development, investigated with time-lapse cinematography.
Summary answer: Through the use of time-lapse cinematography is possible to
highlight that a delay in the PN appearance is predictive for abnormal PN formation. Moreover, PN eccentricity, asymmetry in size and failure of juxtaposition are
related to a delay in timing of cleavage.
What is known already: It was hypothesized that the PN evaluation at 16-18h
post-ICSI is correlated with embryo development and chromosomal abnormalities and proposed as an important embryo selection parameter. However, conflicting data are available in literature. Parameters analyzed are normally related to the
number and distribution of nuclear precursors bodies in PNs, the size and the position of the PN. Due to the dynamicity of PN formation events, static evaluation is
probably insufficient evaluating this stage of embryo development.
Study design, size, duration: We retrospectively evaluated the impact of specific
PN abnormal characteristics (eccentricity, asymmetry in size and failure of juxtaposition) on timing of embryo development by comparing 86 sibling embryos,
cultured in a time-lapse incubator. To avoid confounding factor, each embryo
with abnormal PN dynamics was compared with two sibling embryos with
normal PN dynamics of the same cohort.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: All the embryos analyzed derived
from oocytes microinjected and cultured in a time-lapse incubator system
(Embryoscope, Unisense). Events of development, such as timing of PN appearance, syngamy, timing of 1st to 7th cell division and cell cycle duration were evaluated by time-lapse cinematography.
Main results and the role of chance: The morphokinetic parameters analyzed
show that the timing of appearance of the PNs is significantly lower in zygotes
with normal PN dynamics (10,6 + 1,75 hours, CI 10,10-11,12), than those with
abnormal PN dynamics (12,01 + 1,96 hours, CI 11,27-12,45) p ¼ 0,002. This
delay is reflected in the subsequent development and, in particular, in the time division into 4 cells (39,56 + 5,01 hours CI38,15-40,57, vs 42,83 + 9,7 hours
CI38,43-46,52 respectively) p ¼ 0,05
Limitations, reason for caution: Further analysis is necessary to confirm this
data on a larger population and to understand the impact of abnormal PN behavior
on implantation potential and chromosomal abnormality of the deriving embryos.
Wider implications of the findings: Due to the high dynamicity of pronuclear
formation, different events can be missed during static evaluation normally performed at 16-18 hours post ICSI procedure. Our results suggest the predictive
value of pronuclear appearance on successive abnormal PN behavior. An evaluation around half past 11 hours could help to avoid the selection of embryos
that have the risk to display PN eccentricity, abnormal size and/or failure of juxtaposition during early formation.
Study funding/competing interest(s): none
Trial registration number: none
P-185 Artificial collapse of blastocoelic cavity improves clinical outcome
of closed blastocyst vitrification: a randomized controlled trial
A. Gala1, A. Ferrières1, S. Assou1, C. Vincens2, S. Bringer-Deutsch2, C. Brunet2,
and S. Hamamah1
1
Université Montpellier 1 Inserm U1040 CHU Montpellier, ART/PGD
Department Institut de Recherche en Biothérapie, Montpellier Cédex 5, France,
2
CHU Montpellier, ART/PGD Department, Montpellier Cédex 5, France
Study question: Does blastocyst artificial shrinkage (AS) prior to vitrification in a
closed carrier device improve clinical outcomes?
Summary answer: Artificial shrinkage of blastocoelic cavity significantly
improves clinical pregnancy rate after closed vitrified blastocysts transfer.
What is known already: Expanded blastocysts on day 5/6 are more sensitive to
vitrification than early blastocysts because of an insufficient dehydration of the
blastocoelic cavity. Based on this hypothesis, several authors have described techniques to reduce the blastocoele and prevent the formation of damaging ice crystals. However, all those studies have been realized with opened devices.
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
R. Devjak1, T. Burnik Papler1, K. Fon Tacer 2, and I. Verdenik1
University Medical Centre Ljubljana, Departmen of Obstetrics and Gynecology,
Ljubljana, Slovenia, 2University of Ljubljana Veterinary Faculty, Institute for
Hygiene and Pathology of Animal Nutrition, Ljubljana, Slovenia
1
Abstracts
Abstracts
P-186
Dynamic assessment of early embryo fragmentation by time-lapse
analysis may improve cell cycle timing-based embryo selection
J. Conaghan1, L. Tan2, M. Gvakharia3, K. Ivani4, A. Chen2, and R. Reijo Pera 5
1
Pacific Fertility Center, IVF Lab, San Fransisco CA, U.S.A, 2Auxogyn Inc.,
Clinical R&D, Menlo Park CA, U.S.A, 3Fertility and Reproductive Health,
Reproductive Laboratories, San Jose CA, U.S.A, 4RSC of the SF Bay Area, IVF
Lab, San Ramon CA, U.S.A, 5Stanford University, Stem Cell Biology and
Regenerative Medicine, Stanford CA, U.S.A
Study question: What are the fragmentation dynamics in human embryos from 1to -4-cell stages, and could time-lapse assessment of fragmentation improve
embryo selection when used together with early cell cycle timings?
Summary answer: For most embryos, fragmentation occurs between the 2- and
4-cell stages; time-lapse analysis of early embryo fragmentation can augment the
predictive power of cell cycle timing parameters for selecting the embryo with the
highest chance of implantation.
What is known already: Fragmentation is commonly associated with decreased
embryo viability, and most clinics assess fragmentation on Day 2 and/or 3 (4- to
8-cell stage). However, a recent paper by Chavez et al. (Nat Comm, 2012) suggests
that dynamic assessment of embryo fragmentation, together with cell cycle timing
parameters, is indicative of human embryo ploidy at the 4-cell stage. The current
study examined the incidence and outcomes for embryos with early fragmentation
in a clinical IVF setting.
Study design, size, duration: Retrospective analysis of 850 embryos from 95
patients (6/2011-10/2012) with embryos imaged using the EevaTM Test, a platform
that makes blastocyst predictions by integrating time-lapse imaging and automated analysis of cell cycle timing parameters P2 (time between cytokinesis 1
and 2) and P3 (time between cytokinesis 2 and 3).
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Embryo videos were analyzed
between the 1- to 4-cell stages for fragmentation appearance, volume and
pattern over time. This data was used to determine if fragmentation analysis
could augment P2 and P3 to better predict implantation. Statistical significance
was determined by Fischer’s Exact or Chi-Square test.
Main results and the role of chance: Dynamic assessment offragmentation by timelapse imaging revealed that fragmentation was present in 94% (795/850) of embryos,
and a majority of fragments first appeared at the 2-cell stage (90%, 720/795). At Day
3, conventional fragmentation reported that only 77% (653/850) of embryos had fragmentation, suggesting that time-lapse may be more sensitive in detecting fragments.
Time-lapse assessment also showed that the percentage of fragmentation was persistent
to the 4-cell stage for 89% (707/795) of embryos. Without the fragmentation assessment, specific ‘in-window’ cell cycle timings (P2, P3) were predictive of embryo implantation (implantation 39% vs. 6%, in window vs. out of window, p , 0.0001).
The addition of the early fragmentation assessment to ‘in-window’ cell cycle timings
(P2, P3) resulted in a further improvement to implantation (46%).
Limitations, reason for caution: The dynamic fragmentation assessment was
done manually and thus subject to inter-observer variances. Automated and
more quantitative fragmentation assessment based on state-of-the-art computer
vision technologies is currently underway to address this limitation.
Wider implications of the findings: Our results support previous findings suggesting that early fragmentation assessment from 1 to 4-cell stages, together with cell
cycle timings P2 and P3, is predictive of embryo developmental competence, including aneuploidy status. Furthermore, our findings provided two additional insights: 1)
time-lapse assessment of fragmentation is more sensitive than traditional Day 3
evaluation; 2) adding early fragmentation assessment may further augment cell
cycle timing-based embryo selection and improve implantation rates.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This work was supported by Auxogyn, Inc.
Trial registration number: ClinicalTrials.gov # NCT01369446 and NCT01617993
P-187 Comparison of clinical results, between standard and uninterrupted embryo culture, when there are no embryos to select between
N. Bowman1, S. Montgomery 1, L. Best1, A. Campbell2, S. Duffy 1, and S. Fishel2
1
CARE Manchester, Embryology, Manchester, United Kingdom, 2CARE Fertility,
CARE Fertility Group, Nottingham, United Kingdom
Study question: Is there a benefit of uninterrupted (time-lapse) incubation over
standard incubation for ICSI patients who only have the number of embryos available that they require for transfer?
Summary answer: When there is no selection of embryos required, as all created
are transferred and where female age is ≥38 years, there appears to be a significant
benefit of uninterrupted embryo culture compared to standard (interrupted)
methods.
What is known already: Meseguer et al (2012) reported a significant improvement in the relative probability of clinical pregnancy (CP) when the EmbryoScopeTM (ES)(Unisense Fertilitech, Denmark) was used compared to standard
incubation methods for ICSI patients. This uplift was reported likely to be due
to a combination of uninterrupted culture and the enhanced embryo selection,
made possible by the time-lapse imaging.
Study design, size, duration: Retrospective analysis of CP and implantation rates
in a private IVF centre between May 2011 and October 2012. 85 embryos were
incubated in the ES’s uninterrupted conditions and 591 in Galaxy incubators
(SI), both 5%O2, 5.5%CO2, 89.5%N2.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: All patients undergoing ICSI treatment under either incubation condition were included, when they only had the
number of embryos they required for transfer. IVF patients and oocyte recipients
were excluded. 53 patients underwent ES culture and 391 SI.
Main results and the role of chance: There were no significant differences
between the CP rates and implantation rates when embryos were cultured in SI
and ES culture when patients were aged ≤35 (n ¼ 244 patients SI, n ¼ 19ES).
When two embryos were transferred, the CP rate was 27.3% SI vs 33.3% ES
(p ¼ 0.7381 not significant (NS)) and the implantation rate, per embryo was
16.4% SI vs 20.8% ES (p ¼ 0.5703 NS). For patients aged ≥36 there was a
trend towards an increased CP and implantation rate in ES. For patients ≥38,
there was a significant increase in implantation rate under ES incubation when
two embryos were transferred (n ¼ 51 patients SI, n ¼ 16 ES, 3.9% SI vs
15.6% ES p ¼ 0.035) and a trend towards an increased CP rate (7.8% SI vs
25% ES p ¼ 0.085).
Limitations, reason for caution: Embryos were cultured under different incubation conditions at patient request. Therefore, other than age, patient history, has not
been taken into account. The number of ‘interruptions’ during SI was variable
when door openings of the 48L incubators and dish removal for developmental
progress checks are included.
Wider implications of the findings: This relatively new technology is not widely
available. Clinics commonly run both ES and SI and may prioritise which embryo
cohorts are placed into ES culture. Our previous data showed overall increased CP
rates for patients over 36(Best 2013, ACE) but these findings suggest an
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
Concerning the income of artificial shrinkage (AS) prior to vitrification in closed
systems, data remain unclear.
Study design, size, duration: Prior to vitrification with closed device, blastocysts
were either collapsed by laser pulse or non treated at all according to a randomized
procedure. Clinical pregnancy rate was assessed in 147 warming cycles from April
2011 to December 2012.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: On day 5/6, full (3), expanded (4) or
hatching (5-6) blastocysts with at least a trophectoderm quality type B according
to Gardner classification were cryopreserved. Clinical pregnancy rate was compared between blastocysts with AS (n¼ 35 cycles) and blastocysts without AS
(n ¼ 112 cycles). The mean women age was 33.2 + 4.9 years.
Main results and the role of chance: The overall clinical pregnancy rate after
transfer was 41.8% (59/141). The clinical pregnancy rate was significantly
higher in the AS group (19/35; 54.2%) compared with the control group (40/
106; 37.7%) (1 ¼2.414, p , 0.02). The survival rate was higher in the AS
group but no significantly (52/53, 98.1% Vs. 157/170, 92.3%; 1 ¼1.468, p .
0.09). The two groups were similar concerning women age, endometrial preparation and vitrification day
Limitations, reason for caution: This results need to be completed with the living
birth rates to ensure the efficiency of our treatment.
Wider implications of the findings: To our knowledge, this is the first randomized controlled trial assessing the impact of AS prior to vitrification in a
closed device. This study reveals that blastocyst AS with laser pulse is a successful
technique to improve clinical pregnancy rate after closed vitrification. Our results
are in line with previous publications on the benefit of AS.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This work was partially supported by a
grant from Ferring Pharmaceuticals company. The authors declare that there is .
Trial registration number: Not applicable
i193
i194
implantation rate benefit to ES incubation for patients ≥38 even without embryo
selection. Therefore, this may encourage units to culture embryos for this patient
group in ES culture.
Study funding/competing interest(s): None.
Trial registration number: None.
P-188
The zona pellucida thickness of a human embryo is associated
with implantation potential in fresh blastocyst transfer but not in day
3 transfer
Study question: Is the zona pellucida thickness (ZPT) of cleavage embryo associated with implantation potential in a fresh cycle?
Summary answer: The day 5 embryos with thickened zona pellucida (ZP) on day
3 had a lower implantation rate compared with normal embryos. Assisted hatching
(AH) could be beneficial for fresh day 5 transfer. However, the day 3 embryo had
no difference in implantation rate regardless of ZPT.
What is known already: The ZPT is considered to be a good indicator for embryo
potential. However, several studies have reported that the notion of a relationship
between ZPT and implantation has not been supported.
Study design, size, duration: This study was a retrospective analysis of implantation rate after fresh elective single-embryo transfer cycles. A total of 376 embryos
were included between 2010 and 2012.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: The AH procedure was performed on
patients who had ≥2 failed IVF cycles, or were ≥38 years of age, by laser, regardless of ZPT. The measurement of ZPT was performed by Zilos imaging software
on day 3 embryo images.
Main results and the role of chance: The overall mean of ZPT was 18.44 +
2.4 mm. In day 3 transfer, ZPT did not correlate with implantation rate whether
AH was performed or not. In day 5 transfer, unhatched embryos whose zona
were thicker than 20 mm on day 3 had a significantly lower implantation rate compared with the embryos with a normal ZP of 15-19 mm (30.8% vs. 54.8% respectively, P , 0.05). However, in day 5 transfer with AH treatment, no significant
differences were observed between the thick ZP group and normal ZP group in
the rates of implantation (42.9% vs. 36.7% respectively).
Limitations, reason for caution: The characteristics of the two groups; the
AH-treated group and non-treated group, are not comparable because the AH
was performed on patients with a poor prognosis; those with ≥2 failed IVF
cycles and older women (≥38 years of age).
Wider implications of the findings: Our results suggest that the AH procedure is
useful for embryos with a thick ZP in day 5 transfer but not in day 3 transfer.
Extended embryo culture may affect the hatching of embryos, especially in
embryos that have a thick ZP.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This study received no funding and there
are no conflicts of interests to be declared.
Trial registration number: Not applicabe.
P-189
A novel biological role of embryo derived oxytocin in early
stages of embryo development in mice
V. Dinopoulou, G.A. Partsinevelos, R. Bletsa, D. Mavrogianni, E. Anagnostou,
K. Stefanidis, P. Drakakis, and D. Loutradis
Athens University Medical School, Division of Human Reproduction IVF Unit 1st
Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology Alexandra Hospital, Athens, Greece
Study question: What is questioned in this study is whether oxytocin levels measured in the culture medium post-fertilization are correlated with the stage of
embryo development (2-cell, 4-cell, morula/blastocyst and blastocyst stage)
and whether these levels reflect embryo implantation potential in mice.
Summary answer: Oxytocin was secreted at all stages of early embryo development, although a gradual decrease until morula-early blastocyst stage was found,
which was followed by an increase at the blastocyst stage. These findings suggest a
role of oxytocin in early embryo development as well as in the implantation
process in mice.
What is known already: Oxytocin receptor (OTR) is downregulated at the endometrial areas surrounding the attaching embryo, but is upregulated at the periimplantation areas, throughout the later stages of implantation. OTR mRNA is
detected in mouse oocytes and embryos up to the blastocyst stage. The increase
in OTR expression immediately after fertilization suggests a possible role of oxytocin in this process, whereas the gradual decrease after the 4-cell stage implies a
possible role in implantation.
Study design, size, duration: This prospective observational animal study was
performed on a study population consisted of 10 female mice and 10 male mice
(C57BL/6 x CBA) F1 hybrids, which were allocated in two sequential experiments of 5 female and 5 male mice each.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Female mice, superovulated and
paired with male, were sacrificed and zygotes were flushed from the fallopian
tubes. Two-cell embryos were cultured in groups of 20. The culture medium
was sampled and stored at -20o C at 2-cell, 8-to-16-cell, morula-blastocyst and
blastocyst stage for oxytocin determination using an enzyme immunoassay kit.
Main results and the role of chance: Baseline oxytocin levels in the medium
used to culture mouse embryos was 0.03 + 0.000 ng/ml (mean + SEM) on
Day 0. On day 2, 56 hours post-hCG injection, at the 4- to 8-cell embryo stage,
oxytocin levels were 0.070 + 0.009 ng/ml (mean + SEM). On day 3, 76 hours
post-hCG injection, at the 8- to 16-cell embryo stage, oxytocin levels were
0.068 + 0.014 ng/ml (mean + SEM). On day 4, 109 hours post-hCG injection,
at the morula-blastocyst embryo stage, oxytocin levels were 0.054 + 0.055 ng/
ml (mean + SEM). On day 5, 131 hours post-hCG injection, at the blastocyst
embryo stage, oxytocin levels were 0.079 + 0.007 ng/ml (mean + SEM).
Limitations, reason for caution: A possible limitation of our study is the use of a
restricted number (20) of mouse embryos for 5-day culture. We believe that a
greater difference in oxytocin levels would have probably been seen between
stages of embryo development in case a higher number of mouse embryos had
been utilized.
Wider implications of the findings: Taking into account that oxytocin might
have some biological role at the early stages of development of fertilized
oocytes and the fact that embryos and their secreted oxytocin may exert local
effects, we could implement measurement of oxytocin levels in the culture
medium as a biological marker in the selection of the best embryos, in terms of
implantation potential, for transfer in IVF protocols.
Study funding/competing interest(s): No funding supported this study and no
competing interest is declared.
Trial registration number: The study was registered to Local University Hospital Ethics Committee (registration number: 15/26-01-2009).
P-190
Incidence of live birth using hyaluronic acid (HA) for sperm
selection
J. Hernandez 1, C. Lorenzo León 1, M. Puopolo2, and A. Palumbo1
Centro de Asistencia a la Reproducción Humana de Canarias, La Laguna,
Spain, 2Istituto Superiore di Sanitá, Department of Cell Biology and
Neurosciences, Rome, Italy
1
Study question: PICSI has been proposed as a sperm selection technique capable
of improving pregnancy rates in couples with male factor infertility. Since 2009 we
have introduced this technique in our IVF laboratory for selected couples to test its
effect on live birth rates.
Summary answer: Our data suggest that use of hyaluronic acid for sperm selection by PICSI may have a beneficial effect in patients with male factor by reducing
the miscarriage rate and improving the live birth rate.
What is known already: PICSI is a technique of sperm selection based on the
ability of mature sperm to bind to hyaluronic acid in vitro. Although some
reports suggest a beneficial effect of PISCI in male factor cases, current literature
is controversial.
Study design, size, duration: This is a retrospective observational study on 44
patients recruited from 11/2009 to 12/2012 who underwent a treatment cycle
using HA for sperm selection (PICSI). We selected an historical control group
recruited from 1/2008 to 10/2009 composed of 104 ICSI cycles in couples with
sperm parameters comparable to the study population.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Patients in the study group had a
sperm count in the range 5.000.000-20.000.000/ml. Variables analyzed included
patientś and partnerś age, fertilization rate, viable, transferred and top quality
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
R. Hirata1,2, Y. Aoi1, T. Habara1, and N. Hayashi1
Okayama Couplès Clinic, Gynecology, Okayama, Japan, 2Laboratory of
Reproductive Physiology, Graduate School of Environmental and Life Science,
Okayama University
1
Abstracts
i195
Abstracts
P-191
Impact of seminal trace elements and glutathione levels on sperm
DNA fragmentation and assisted reproductive techniques outcome
Atig1,
Kerkeni2,
Saad3,
Ajina 3
A.
A.
and M.
F.
University Farhat Hached Hospital, Unit of reproductive medicine, Soussa,
Tunisia, 2University of Monastir, Research Laboratory of “Trace elements free
radicals and antioxidants” Biophysical Department Faculty of Medicine,
Monastir, Tunisia, 3University Farhat Hached Hospital, Unit of reproductive
medicine, Monastir, Tunisia
1
Study question: Can seminal non-enzymatic antioxidants and sperm DNA fragmentation help to predict the in vitro fertilization (IVF) outcome of Tunisian infertile couples?
Summary answer: Standard semen parameters were poor predictors of the IVF
outcome. Besides; sperm genome quality, seminal trace elements “Zinc and Selenium” and glutathione levels were strongly inter-related and demonstrated significant and close relationships with the in vitro early embryogenesis, thus with
the success of IVF attempt.
What is known already: Valuable evidence has emerged about the crucial role of
seminal trace elements and glutathione as non-enzymatic antioxidants that protect
spermatozoa against lipid peroxidation and oxidative damages. Nevertheless, contrary to the seminal reactive oxygen species, there is no clear consensus about the
involvement of these antioxidants to protect sperm from oxidative DNA fragmentation and to predict the success of the early embryonic development after IVF.
Study design, size, duration: This is a prospective controlled study carried out on
Tunisian infertile men participating in the conventional IVF program at our Unit of
Reproductive Biology, Farhat Hached University Hospital (Tunisia). A total of
200 consecutive males (24-50 years) were recruited in our investigation
between June 2011 and July 2012.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Obtained semen samples were analyzed according to WHO criteria (1999) and divided into four groups: nomozoospermics (controls, n ¼ 70), oligozoospermics (n ¼ 40), asthenozoospemics (n ¼
45) and teratozoospermics (n ¼ 45). Seminal zinc and selenium concentrations
were determined using flame and furnace atomic absorption. The different
forms of glutathione and sperm DNA fragmentation levels were measured spectrophotometrically and by TUNEL assay, respectively. IVF outcome was presented
as follows: fertilization, cleavage and embryo quality (Grade I, II and III).
Main results and the role of chance: The key results in this study were: (1)
increased seminal trace element amounts were observed in normozoospermics
when compared with abnormal groups mainly with Asthenozoodpermics and Teratozoospermics. Total and reduced forms of glutathione (GSHt and GSHr) were
also significantly elevated in seminal plasma of controls than asthenozoospermics
(P ¼ 0.002, P ¼ 0.003; respectively). (2) Controls established highly significant
decline of sperm DNA fragmentation levels compared to the three abnormal
groups (P , 0.001). (3) Negative correlations were found between enhanced
seminal antioxidant profile and sperm DNA fragmentation (zinc [r ¼ -0.71**,
P , 0.001], selenium [r ¼ 0.63**, P , 0.001], GSHt [r ¼ -0.21*, P ¼ 0.01],
GSHr [r ¼ -0.72**, P , 0.001]). (4) Inversely to the non-enzymatic antioxidants,
sperm DNA fragmentation was strongly correlated to poor fertilization rate (r ¼
-0.53*, P ¼ 0.02), cleavage (r ¼ -0.71**, P , 0.001) rate and embryo quality
(Grade III) (r ¼ 0.62*, P ¼ 0.01).
Limitations, reason for caution: The results may be biased by the determination
of sperm DNA fragmentation on the same day as the IVF procedure. It would be
interesting to measure the sperm DNA fragmentation and antioxidant levels before
IVF, in order to predict their role in the procedure.
Wider implications of the findings: We identified that the routine determination
of non-enzymatic antioxidants and sperm DNA fragmentation levels is a more reliable prognostic tool for male infertility assessment which can help selection of
semen samples with the least amount of sperm DNA fragmentation and thus
reduce the risks associated with the use of DNA-fragmented sperm for fertilization
and avoid financial, social and emotional problems associated with failed IVF
attempts.
Study funding/competing interest(s): None of the authors have any competing
interest. This work is part of a scientific project (Thesis).
Trial registration number: None.
P-192 Matured human oocytes with cumulus cells and assisted reproduction techniques
G. D’Ommar, A.K. Herrera, L. Lozano, and M. Majerfeld
Centro Medico Docente La Trinidad, Fertility Clinic, Caracas, Venezuela
Study question: Determine effects in fertilization rate and quality of embryos
obtained from oocytes remnants of assisted reproduction techniques (ART),
matured with or without their cumulus cells (CC).
Summary answer: Mature oocytes with CC, equates the fertilization rate and
embryo quality to levels similar to those obtained with mature oocytes collected.
What is known already: The oocyte plays an important role regulating its own
development, by the production of paracrine growth factors that affect the surrounding granulosa cells (Gilchrist et al., 2008). These cells represent an essential
component in the maturation and fertilization of oocytes. Because oocytes
undergo intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) are denuded, the potential positive effects of cumulus cells in future development cannot be observed (Ebner
et al., 2006).
Study design, size, duration: Retrospective analysis of the effect of CC on completion of oocyte maturation. Population: 124 patients (n ¼ 1239 oocytes), age:
33.0 + 3.9 years, performing ART and ICSI, is compared fertilization and
embryo quality.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Oocytes classification:
Denuded: Appeared to be mature, were immature when denuded. (n¼ 198)
Not denuded: Appeared to be immature, were not denuded. (n¼ 360)
Control group: Were mature by crown classification, resulting MII when denuded
(n ¼ 681).
Results were analyzed by the chi-square test.
Main results and the role of chance: In collected mature oocyte, fertilization rate
was 69.6 %; in Denuded group 35.2 %; in Not denuded group 68.3 %. With values
of P¼ 0.000001 between mature oocytes and Denuded group, P¼ 0.000002
between Denuded group and Not denuded group, but with P¼ 0.8426 between
mature oocytes and Not denuded group.
In relation to embryos quality, in mature oocytes 43.7 % corresponds to good
quality embryos; 24 % of good quality embryos in Denuded group; in Not
denuded group 43.3 %. With values of P¼ 0.003271 between mature oocytes
and Denuded group, P¼ 0.003874 between Denuded group and Not denuded
group, but with P¼ 0.9586 between mature oocytes and Not denuded group.
For values ??of P ,0.05 there is no association between the variables.
Limitations, reason for caution: The main limitation in this study because it is
human oocytes was obtaining informed consent, which was reflected in the
sample size.
Wider implications of the findings: Was observed that coculture with cumulus
cells promotes maturation and meiotic progression, which is reflected in the
high rates of fertilization in vitro matured oocytes with cumulus cells, which is consistent with other studies.
Study funding/competing interest(s): Clı́nica de Fertilidad, Centro Médico
Docente La Trinidad, Caracas, Venezuela.
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
embryos, clinical pregnancy and miscarriage rate. Statistical analysis was performed using t-test for continuous variables and Fisher’s exact probability test
for categorical variables.
[Maria1]era nei parametri fissati per la selezione dei controlli?
Main results and the role of chance: The study group and the control group did
not differ in terms of mean patientś age and partners’ age (35.8 + 1 vs 36.4 + 0.4
and 40.76 + 0.9 vs 39.1 + 0.6 respectively); fertilization rate (64.4% vs 65.9%),
and pregnancy rate [50% (22/44) vs 40% (42/104)]. There was a trend towards a
lower miscarriage rate in the study group [9% (2/22)] vs 21% (9/42) in controls,
however this difference did not reach statistical significance, which may be due
to the small sample analyzed.
Limitations, reason for caution: The main limitation is the retrospective design
and the small number of cases in the PICSI group. A further weakness is the use of
an historical control group which might be biased due to improvements in clinical
practice, however no major changes occurred in our center during this time frame.
Wider implications of the findings: The possibility that the PICSI technique
reduces the miscarriage rate increasing live birth rates is attractive and further prospective randomized studies are warranted.
Study funding/competing interest(s): None
Trial registration number: Not applicable
i196
Trial registration number: No
P-193
Direct unequal cleavages: Cell stage onsets, embryo developmental potential and chromosomal abnormalities
Z. Ye, N. Zaninovic, R. Clarke, R. Bodine, and Z. Rosenwaks
Center for Reproductive Medicine, Reproductive Medicine, New York, U.S.A
P-194
Can timing of post-cleavage embryo development stages reveal
ploidy or implantation potential?
P. Mazur1, V. Nagorny1, D. Mykytenko2, L. Semeniuk1, and V. Zukin1
Clinic Of Reproductive Medicine "Nadiya", Embryology, Kyiv, Ukraine, 2Clinic
Of Reproductive Medicine "Nadiya", Department of Molecular Diagnostics,
Kyiv, Ukraine
1
Study question: Can detailed time-lapse observation of embryo post-cleavage
development stages suggest embryo ploidy or its enhanced implantation?
Summary answer: Although ploidy is not related with timing of compaction,
cavitation and expansion, thorough analysis of blastocyst expansion may help
in assessment of embryo implantation potential.
What is known already: Limited data connects timing of embryo development
with its ploidy. Human embryo genome activation is known to start at day 3 of cultivation in-vitro, so analysis of late stages of in-vitro culture seems promising.
Study design, size, duration: This cross-sectional study includes 84 patients
whose embryos were cultured in time-lapse imaging system. Of those, 106
blastocysts of 60 patients were transferred in fresh cycles and have known pregnancy outcome. Second group consisted of 24 infertility treatment patients
where embryo ploidy was established by array comparative genome hybridization
(aCGH).
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Embryos were cultured in EmbryoScopeTM (Unisense FertiliTech, Denmark). After 5 or 6 days of embryo
culture, time-lapse image data were analysed. Array CGH, if applied, was performed after trophectoderm biopsy, using 24surew kit (BlueGnome, United
Kingdom). In aCGH group of 113 analysed embryos 58 were euploid and 56
were aneuploid.
Main results and the role of chance: Using time-lapse observation, development
time points like morula formation, cavity appearance and expansion time were
defined. Efficient expansion was presumed when expanding blastocyst started
to stretch zona pellucida (ZP). To locate this moment, inner ZP diameter was calculated from image data with 1h interval and subsequent linear regression analysis
performed. In aCGH group assisted hatching performed at day 3 of culture caused
expansion time to match with moment of trophectoderm protrusion trough ZP
opening.
No correlation was seen between timing of late in-vitro culture events when
embryos were compared by ploidy or implantation fate. However graphic interpretation of blastocyst volume expansion speed in group of embryos with
known implantation showed that implanted embryos usually had uniform midspeed expansion without deep collapsing or oversized growth.
Limitations, reason for caution: Comparison of timing of late in-vitro development events is complicated by lags often observed in pre compaction and morula
stages. It is possible that in future investigations these difficulties will be overcomed.
Wider implications of the findings: To the date, assuming that each embryo is
unique, we cannot recommend to select embryos for transfer relying on their
timing of post-cleavage stages. Blastulation dynamics, after development of
labour-saving software, can be applied for embryo scoring.
Study funding/competing interest(s): The authors have nothing to disclose. No
external funding was received for this work.
Trial registration number: This study was not an RCT.
P-195 Prospective trial of vitrification of all embryos in cycles of ART:
implantation and pregnancy rate
A. Zabala1, T. Pessino2, S. Outeda2, L. Blanco2, F. Leocata 2, and R. Asch3
1
Hospital Interzonal de Agudos Jose de San Martin, Ginecology, La Plata,
Argentina, 2PROCREARTE, Ginecology, C.A.B.A, Argentina, 3Ministerio de
Salud de la Provincia de Buenos Aires, Ginecology, La Plata, Argentina
Study question: To determine the pregnancy outcome after vitrification of all
fresh embryos produced in stimulated assisted reproduction technique cycles
(ART) and replacing them in subseuqemt non-gonadotropin stimulated cycle
Summary answer: Vitrification of all fresh embryos produced in stimulated
ART cycles and replacing them in subsequent non-gonadotropin stimulated
cycles resulted in highly successful implantation rate and cumulative pregnancy
rates.
What is known already: It has bee propoced that supraphysiological hormone
levels during ovarian stimulation may adversely affect embryo implantation in
assisted reproductive treatments. Very few studies have advocated the elective
cryopreservation of all embryos as a methos to avert the undesirable effect of gonadotropin ovarian stimulation on implantation and pregnancy rate, as well as to
prevent the occurrence of iatrogenic events such as ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome (OHSS).
Study design, size, duration: A prospective trial of series of cases in a private fertility center-ART program. 122 patients (average age 35 years) with risk to
develop OHSS or with uterin factor (poor endometrium or difficult transfer)
who underment vitrificaion of all fresh embryos from Junuary 2011 to December
2012
Participants/materials, setting, methods: 1000 embryos were vitrified at 8 blastomeres or blastocyst stage. Embryo survival rate (at last 80% of blastomeres intact
post-thawing) was 97%. After thawing, 527 embryos were transferred into
hormone replacement cycles in a total of 215 cycles. the average number of
embryos transferred per cycle was 2,4.
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
Study question: To investigate cell stage occurrence, developmental potential,
and chromosomal abnormalities in embryos displaying direct unequal cleavages
(DUC).
Summary answer: When identified correctly, direct unequal cleavages at early
cell stages have a greater negative impact on subsequent embryo development
than later stage onsets, and are correlated with a high incidence of chromosomal
abnormalities, but not triploidy.
What is known already: The occurrence of DUC (1 to 3 cells) has been reported
in many IVF labs, a phenomenon unrelated to specific patient population, culture
media or fertilization technique. A recent multicenter study showed limited implantation potential of embryos with direct unequal cleavages at first mitosis. Triploidy has been suggested as a cause; however developmental potential and
chromosomal composition of these embryos in relation to the cell stage onset
was not reported.
Study design, size, duration: Fertilized oocytes (n ¼ 5604 from 408 patients)
were cultured in time-lapse EmbryoScope incubators (Unisense Fertilitech) and
annotated for patterns and times of cleavage. PGS analysis was performed on
the subset of patients (n ¼ 26, avg. age 37.7) that demonstrated DUC.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Direct unequal cleavages were
defined as cleavage of one cell directly to three or more cells which were annotated
during the first, second or third cleavage division. PGS analysis (biopsy day 3 or 5)
was performed on 26 patients exhibiting DUC using FISH, CGH or SNP array.
Main results and the role of chance: DUC were observed in 12% of the embryos:
58% at 1st cleavage, 25% at 2nd cleavage and 6.7% at 3rd cleavage division. DUC
embryos were developmentally compromised, and only 9% reached blastocyst
stage and were frozen. The developmental potential of DUC embryos was associated with cell stage onset, where DUC occurrence at first cleavage is more critical to development than DUC at second or third division. 255 PGS embryos were
analyzed; 74 (29%) annotated as DUC. Chromosome abnormalities were detected
in 89% of DUC embryos, which included different patterns of chromosomal aberrations (but not triploidy), and were not of specific maternal or paternal origin. The
detailed analysis of PGS normal embryos, originally annotated as DUC, revealed
ambiguous cell or fragment identification, and/or cell fusion.
Limitations, reason for caution: N/A
Wider implications of the findings: When identified correctly with time-lapse
microscopy, DUC at various cleavage stages can be a useful tool for selecting
embryos for transfer. Embryos demonstrating DUC have limited developmental
potential and are associated with high level of chromosomal abnormalities; therefore they should be avoided for ET or freezing.
Study funding/competing interest(s): Institutional
Trial registration number: N/A
Abstracts
i197
Abstracts
P-196
Early cleaving mouse embryos are better candidates for
vitrification
W.J. Wan-Hafizah1, M.H. Rajikin2, A.S. Nuraliza2, M. Mohd-Fazirul 3,
J.M.Y. Norhazlin 3, D. Razif4, and M.N.K. Nor-Ashikin3
1
Faculty of Medicine, Universiti Kuala Lumpur-Royal College of Medicine Perak,
Ipoh, Malaysia, 2Faculty of Medicine, Universiti Teknologi MARA, Sungai Buloh,
Malaysia, 3Institute of Medical Molecular Biotechnology Faculty of Medicine,
Universiti Teknologi MARA, Sungai Buloh, Malaysia, 4Faculty of Health Sciences
Puncak Alam, Universiti Teknologi MARA, Sungai Buloh, Malaysia
Study question: Do early cleaving (EC) embryos make better candidates for
vitrification compared to late-cleaving (LC) embryos?
Summary answer: EC embryos make better vitrification candidates compared to
LC embryos, because they exhibit significantly higher post-vitrification survival
rate and viability.
What is known already: The use of EC embryos has been suggested for embryo
transfer in Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART) because of their good quality
and high viability. However, no study has been conducted to investigate whether
these EC embryos also make better vitrification candidates
Study design, size, duration: In a prospective study, post vitrification survivability and viability were compared between EC embryos and LC embryos. A total of
124 EC embryos and 156 LC embryos were vitrified in liquid nitrogen for 1 hour.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Embryos were retrieved from in vivofertilized ICR mice, 28 hours after human Chorionic Gonadotrophin injection.
Two-cell embryos were categorized as EC embryos and two-pronuclear zygotes as
LC embryos. Vitrification using EFS20/40 method was performed at 2-cell stage.
Post-vitrification viability of EC and LC embryos was compared using chi-square test.
Main results and the role of chance: The survival rate was significantly higher in
vitrified EC embryos (96.8%) compared to vitrified LC embryos (89.2%) (p ,
0.05). A significantly higher proportions of vitrified EC embryos developed to
the blastocyst stage, compared with vitrified LC embryos (90% versus 57.1%,
p , 0.0001). This may be related to the ability of early cleaving embryos to
survive the high cooling rates, high osmotic changes and toxicity of cryoprotectant
during the vitrification process.
Limitations, reason for caution: The use of in vivo- instead of in vitro-derived
embryos may have resulted in greater cryotolerance, as in vivo-derived embryos
exhibit reduced sensitivity to chilling and freezing due to their lower lipid to
protein ratio compared with in vitro-derived embryos.
Wider implications of the findings: The selection of early cleaving embryos as
vitrification candidates could provide better cryopreservation outcomes. This
finding can subsequently contribute towards the improvement of ART outcomes
and reduce the cost related to procedures in ART.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This research was supported by institutional grant [600-RMI/ST/DANA5/3/Dst(335/2011)] and national grant
[600-RMI/ST/FRGS5/3/FST(71/2010)]. There were no competing interests.
Trial registration number: Not applicable
P-197
A novel method for human oocyte vitrification with a closed device
using super-cooled air
S. Machac1, V. Hubinka2, M. Larman3, and M. Koudelka1
1
Reprofit International s.r.o., Gyneacology, Brno, Czech Republic, 2Reprofit
International s.r.o., Embryology, Brno, Czech Republic, 3Vitrolife, Research
Department, Englewood, U.S.A
Abstract withdrawn by the author
P-198
Is embryo quality affected by different approaches to stimulation
in IVF?
T. Pehlivan Budak1, O. Oliana Membrado1, E. Sevillano Martinez1, P. Wilson1,
A. McClure1, and G. Nargund2
1
Create Health Clinics, IVF Laboratory, London, United Kingdom, 2Create
Health Clinics, Obstetrics and Gynecology, London, United Kingdom
Study question: Does stimulation protocol affect embryo quality on day 2 in different age groups?
Summary answer: In patients ,40 years and ≥40 years of age, higher percentage of Grade A and B embryos were obtained from patients submitted to natural
cycle IVF compared to stimulated cycles. The differences were statistically significant in the group ≥40 years of age.
What is known already: In previous studies, natural cycle approaches to stimulation in IVF have been associated with better embryo quality and IVF outcome.
Study design, size, duration: This retrospective observational data included 3044
embryos assessed on day 2 of embryo development during 2011 and 2012.
Embryos scored based on ASEBIR criteria were compared in patients ,40
years and ≥40 years of age whom underwent following treatment protocols:
Natural cycles(NC), Modified Natural cycles(MN) and stimulated cycles (SC).
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Three main groups were made: NC,
MN and SC (Group 1, 2 and 3 respectively).
Group 1a(,40 years, 73 embryos) and Group 1b(≥40 years, 104 embryos).
Group 2a(,40 years, 167 embryos) and Group 2b(≥40 years, 392 embryos).
Group 3a(,40 years, 1644 embryos ) and Group 3b (≥40 years, 743 embryos).
Main results and the role of chance: In Group 1a, 65.8% were grade A and B,
34.2% were grade C and D.
In Group 1b, 73.1% were grade A and B, 26.9% were grade C and D.
In Group 2a, 64.1% were grade A and B, 35.9 % were grade C and D.
In Group 2b, 65% were grade A and B, 35% were grade C and D.
In Group 3a, 58.9% were grade A and B, 41.1% were grade C and D.
In Group 3b, 62.2% were grade A and B, 37.8 were grade C and D.
In general, independent of age, there was a tendency for better embryo quality in
NC, and MN compared to SC.
The difference was statistically significant between groups 1b and 3b (p ¼ 0.04).
Limitations, reason for caution: Due to the study design, selection bias and confounding factors may have affected the results.
Wider implications of the findings: In women undergoing IVF, natural cycle approach to IVF seems to yield better quality embryos on Day 2 compared to stimulated
cycles. This finding is more significant in women with advanced maternal age .
Study funding/competing interest(s): None
Trial registration number: None
P-199 Accumulation of vitrified oocyte: a successful strategy to achieve
an elective embryo transfer in young low responders patients
D. Raso1, M.F. Insua2, B. Lotti1, S. Giordana2, C. Baldi2, J. Barattini1, M. Cogorno
1, N. Fernandez Peri 1, and F. Neuspiller 1
1
Instituto Valenciano de Infertilidad, Ginecology, C.A.B.A., Argentina, 2Instituto
Valenciano de Infertilidad, FIV Laboratory, C.A.B.A., Argentina
Study question: To describe the results of vitrified oocytes accumulation (VOA)
in low responder (LR) patients as a way of achieving an elective embryo transfer.
Summary answer: The pregnancy rate in low responder patients is usually suboptimal due to the low number of embryos. Vitrification techniques allow oocytes
to accumulate several cycles of ovarian stimulation, increasing the possibilities of
elective embryo transfer.
What is known already: The low response represents a difficulty to the management within women who must undergo assisted reproductive treatment. Reduced
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
Main results and the role of chance: 103 pregnancies were achieved for a cumulative clinical Pregnancy Rate (CCPR) of 84% per patient and 48% per cycle.
These results are higher than fresh embryos transfer cycles for the center and
study period (48% vs 31%). Implantation Rate (IR) was 22%. Pregnancies were
achieved 57% in the first, 29% in the second, 11% in the third and 3% in the
fourth cycle of thawing per patient, respectively. Of those patients that did not
achieved successful clinical pregnancies, 57 % sill have embryos vitrified (4,5
embryos/ patient).
Limitations, reason for caution: Descriptive measure of prospective trial.
Wider implications of the findings: These results reassure the role of embryo vitrification in an IVF program, and could also be a possible approach to prevent the
alleged adverse effects of ovarian hyperstimulacion on the implantation process,
and it is tempting to propose its use routinely in ART cycles in the future.
Study funding/competing interest(s): no
Trial registration number: no
i198
P-200
Cryopreserved versus fresh blastocyst transfer: a way to improve
implantation rate
S. Resta, A. Filannino, E. Maggi, G. Cafueri, A.P. Ferraretti, M.C. Magli, and
L. Gianaroli
S.I.S.M.E.R. s.r.l., Reproductive Medicine Unit, Bologna, Italy
Study question: Do blastocysts belonging to the same cohort have different
chances of implantation when transferred in fresh or a frozen cycles?
Summary answer: Blastocysts transferred in frozen cycles seem to have higher implantation rates compared to the sibling blastocysts transferred in the fresh cycle.
What is known already: Traditionally, the tendency in ART is to give priority to
the fresh cycle by selecting the best quality embryos for transfer. Several reports
support the culture to the blastocyst stage with the aim of improving the selection
criteria.
More recently, in view of the high efficiency of vitrification, the advantages of
transferring warmed blastocysts have been underlined. Actually, the rates of pregnancy and implantation seem to be increased compared with fresh blastocyst transfer cycles.
Study design, size, duration: Between 2008 and 2012, 437 blastocysts transfer
were performed (309 fresh, 128 frozen). A subset of 36 patients who did not
achieve term pregnancy in fresh cycles and had spare cryopreserved blastocysts
were included in the study for a total of 36 fresh transfers and 38 cryopreserved
transfers.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Private center. Blastocyst development and quality, and implantation were evaluated in 36 patients that transferred
at the blastocyst stage in the fresh cycle and cryopreserved one or more spare blastocysts for further attempts. The studied parameters were compared between fresh
and cryopreserved cycles.
Main results and the role of chance: In all, 136 blastocysts were obtained (73%
blastocyst rate over 185 fertilized oocytes). As priority was given to fresh transfers, 35 patients (97%) transferred their best quality blastocysts (all day-5 blastocysts) in the fresh cycle (1.7 + 0.5 mean embryos transferred) with a pregnancy
rate of 14% (5/36) and an implantation rate of 6% (4/62).
After the transfer of the cryopreserved blastocysts in subsequent 38 cycles
(1.3 + 0.4 mean embryos transferred), the pregnancy rate was 40% per transfer
(15/38, P , 0.05) and 42% per patient (15/36, P , 0.025). The implantation
rate of 31% (15/48) was significantly higher when compared to fresh cycles
(P , 0.005). In the group of frozen cycles, 29 transferred day-5 blastocysts and
9 day-6 blastocysts with implantation rates of 29.7% and 36.4% respectively.
Limitations, reason for caution: An extremely efficient cryopreservation
program is necessary to minimize the possible damage to blastocysts during the
procedure. The results reported here regard a special group of patients that did
not achieve a term pregnancy in the fresh cycle, and should be verified on a
larger set of data.
Wider implications of the findings: The high implantation rate after the transfer
of spare blastocysts in frozen cycles suggests an improved endometrial receptivity,
especially when considering that the best quality blastocysts were selected for
fresh transfers. Transfers in frozen cycles have the additional advantages of 1) reducing the risk of OHSS, 2) increasing the cumulative pregnancy rate due to the
higher implantation, and 3) providing the better obstetric and perinatal outcome
that are associated with the transfer of thawed embryos.
Study funding/competing interest(s): None.
Trial registration number: Not applicable.
P-201 Vitrification of cleavage and morula stage mouse embryos with
DMSO/ EG and PROH/ EG: effects on blastomere viability, cytoskeleton
and development
A. Sioga1, Z. Oikonomou1, K. Chatzimeletiou2, L. Oikonomou1, E. Kolibianakis2,
and B.C. Tarlatzis2
1
Aristotle University Medical School, Lab. of Histology - Embryology,
Thessaloniki, Greece, 2Aristotle University Medical School, 1st Department of
Obstetrics and Gynaecology Papageorgiou Hospital, Thessaloniki, Greece
Study question: Is there a difference in blastomere viability, cytoskeletal abnormalities and development of cleavage and morula stage mouse embryos vitrified
with a DMSO/EG kit compared with those vitrified with a PROH/EG kit and fresh
embryos?
Summary answer: There was no significant difference in blastomere viability,
cytoskeletal abnormalities and development between the DMSO/EG and the
PROH/EG groups but fresh embryos showed a lower incidence of spindle abnormalities compared to the vitrified groups.
What is known already: Morula and blastocyst stage vitrification has successfully been applied in human and mouse embryos. Most studies assess feasibility of
the methodology based on survival rates and development and only limited
studies in human blastocysts report on the incidence of cytoskeletal abnormalities.
Here, we investigate in the mouse immediate effects on blastomere viability following staining with viability markers and any potential effects on the cytoskeleton, by analysing spindle and chromosome configurations by confocal
scanning microscopy.
Study design, size, duration: This study was performed between January
2011-January 2013 in an Embryology Laboratory. 280 embryos were flushed
out of BalbC female mice oviducts. 215 were vitrified with DMSO/EG (n¼
110) and PROH/EG (n¼ 105) and 65 were used fresh for comparison of Immediate effects (n ¼ 15(4-6cell),n ¼ 15(8-cell),n ¼ 15morulae) and cytoskeleta analysis, n ¼ 20 blastocysts).
Participants/materials, setting, methods: 50 DMSO/EG (n ¼ 15(4-6 cell), n ¼
18(8-cell), n ¼ 17morulae) and 45 PROH/EG (n ¼ 15(4-6 cell), n ¼ 15(8-cell),
n ¼ 15morulae) vitrified embryos were subjected to viability CFSE/ PI staining.
60 DMSO/EG (n ¼ 20(4-6 cell), n ¼ 20(8-cell), n ¼ 20morulae) and 60 PROH/
EG (n ¼ 20(4-6 cell), n ¼ 20(8-cell), and n ¼ 20morulae) vitrified embryos were
cultured to the blastocyst stage and stained with a-tubulin/DAPI.
Main results and the role of chance: This is the first study to examine in detail
using viability markers the immediate effects of DMSO/EG and PROH/EG vitrification on blastomere survival and compares the type and incidence of cytoskeletal abnormalities in vitrified cleavage and morula stage embryos with fresh
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
number of oocytes obtained in these patients is usually associated to poor egg
quality, low number of embryos and high rate of cancellation of their cycles.
The pregnancy rate in this group of patients is usually suboptimal due to the inability to perform an elective embryo transfer.
Study design, size, duration: We carried out an observational, retrospective,
comparative and descriptive study. During the period from January 1st 2011 to
July 31st 2012, 705 assisted reproduction cycles were performed, 20% (140)
out of which behaved as low responders. LR was defined as those patients who
obtained ≤4 oocytes after puncture.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: VOA was offered to 87 patients (22
accepted). Patients were divided in two groups: ≤39 years and ≥40 years.
Each group was also divided in those that did not accumulate oocytes (A), and
those who did (B).
Stimulation was performed with clomiphene citrate and hMG. Oocytes were
cryopreserved (Cryotop method).
Main results and the role of chance: Average age was 36.4 [31-43]. Average
cycles/ patient were 2.2 + 0.4. Main retrieved oocytes/aspiration were 4.1 +
2.1; average MII was 2.9 + 1.3; main retrieved oocytes/patient were 9.1 + 4.3
and main retrieved MII 6.4 + 2.1. Oocytes survival rate was 81.8%. Global fertilization rate (FR) was 62.1%. Pregnancy rate (PR)/transfer was 34.7% and PR/
patient was 36.3%.
Women ,40 years of GroupB exhibit significantly better results than their
peers in GroupA. Elective embryo transfer was 50% vs. 25%, PR 33.3% vs
15% and the implantation rate (IR) 25% vs 8.3%, respectively. The main age
was 37.2 + 1.74 vs 35.81 + 2.46.
In patients ≥40 years, results for GroupA and GroupB elective embryo transfer
were 28.6% vs 23.5%, PR 14.3% vs 18.8%, IR 14.3% vs 11.4%. The main age for
these sub groups was 41.9 + 1.5 vs 41.9 + 1.4.
Limitations, reason for caution: None
Wider implications of the findings: Oocyte vitrification is a useful technique to
accumulate oocytes of different stimulation cycles, increasing the initial pool.
According to our results, in women ,40 years, this procedure significantly
improves the possibility of an elective transfer, impacting positively on pregnancy
rates. For ≥40 years, this strategy would not provide significant benefits when
compared with fresh cycles. This could be due to oocyte ageing, which in turn
impacts negatively on reproductive outcomes.
Study funding/competing interest(s): None
Trial registration number: None
Abstracts
i199
Abstracts
embryos. There was no significant difference in the survival rates following
warming between the two vitrified groups at all stages (p . 0.05). Cytoskeletal
analysis revealed that fresh embryos that had developed to the blastocyst stage
had a significantly higher incidence of normal spindles (72.2%) and lower incidence of abnormally shaped (22.2%) or multipolar spindles (2.8%) compared to
both DMSO/EG and PROH/EG vitrified embryos (p,0.05). The level of abnormal spindle/chromosome configurations including abnormal shape, and multipolarity, was similar between the two vitrified groups (p.0.05).
Limitations, reason for caution: Mouse embryos may differ from human
embryos in the way they survive post-warming.
Wider implications of the findings: The results presented in this study document
high survival rates post warming and no major immediate effects following staining with viability markers. This suggests that vitrification with both the DMSO/EG
and PROH/EG kits at cleavage and morula stages is a safe procedure that can be
applied in routine clinical IVF practice.
Study funding/competing interest(s): No external funding was raised for this study.
Trial registration number: Not applicable
Impact of oxygen concentration on early human embryo
development in vitro
M. Roychoudhury Sarkar1, D. Ray 1, and J. Bhattacharya2
1
A.H IVF & Infertility Research Centre Pvt Ltd, Embryology, Kolkata, India, 2A.H
IVF & Infertility Research Centre Pvt Ltd, IVF Specialist, Kolkata, India
Study question: How do the oxygen concentration affect early human embryo development in - vitro from fertilized oocytes to blastocyst?
Summary answer: Result in this study demonstrated that embryo culture in
higher oxygen concentration reduce the human embryo developmental rate
in vitro.
What is known already: Early embryo development in-vitro is not only dependent
on the culture media but also upon the physical environment of incubator such as concentration of CO2 and O2 gas.Studies on mammalian embryo culture have demonstrated that culture at reduced O2 results in better embryo development. However,
it has also been observed that embryo can also grow in elevated O2 level, this has
led to some confusion regarding the role of oxygen in human embryo culture.
Study design, size, duration: Retrospective study. Embryos cultured in 3 different groups:- Group-I: Fertilisation upto blastocyst in 20% Oxygen, Group-II:
Fertilisation(day O) in 20% Oxygen, followed by (day 1 to day 5)of embryo
culture in 5% Oxygen and Group-III: Fertilisation upto blastocyst in 5%
Oxygen. Only (PN2) oocytes were scored from (day 1-5).
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Patients selected with a criteria of ≥
35 years of age, devoid of endometriosis and PID and ≥ 8 oocytes after IVF / ICSI.
Group-I: 60 patients with 421 normally fertilized oocytes. Group-II: 40 patients
with 289 normally fertilized oocytes and Group-III: 45 patients with 311 normally fertilized oocytes.
Main results and the role of chance: Result in this study shows that proportion of
development of 2-celled, 4-celled embryo are almost similar in the three groups
and from this stage, embryo development is significantly reduced in group-I compared to that of group-II and group-III. Therefore, percentages of compact embryo
and blastocyst development in the 3 groups are as follows:
Group-I: 45.1% and 39.9% Group-II: 63.4% and 57.09% and Group-III:
65.8% and 59.16% respectively.We observed that there was no significant differences in any parameters in group-II and group-III.
Limitations, reason for caution: Care was taken to ensure that other parameters
such as culture time and CO2 (6%) were kept constant.
Wider implications of the findings: Significant dip in the growth rate is observed
after day-3. The delay in the late cleavage stage is probably due to maturation arrest
of embryos cultured at 20% O2 before reaching the blastocyst stage.
Study funding/competing interest(s): NA
Trial registration number: NA
P-203
Randomised assisted localised hatching in cryopreserved
blastocyst transfers
J. Marcos Alises1, D. Gumbao1, A. Sánchez-León1, B. Amorocho1, M. Mollá1,
M. Nicolás2, L. Fernández2, and J. Landeras2
1
IVI Murcia, Infertility, Murcia, Spain, 2IVI Murcia, Gynecologist, Murcia, Spain
AH TRP
N
72
76
Nº transfer
68
76
Age
37
38
p
Average nº embryo transfers
1.6
1.5
Pregnancy %
51.4 (35/68)
42.1 (32/76)
0.26
Implantation %
36.4 (39/107)
34.5 (39/113)
0.77
Biochemical miscarriage %
16.7 (7/42)
17.9 (7/39)
0.88
Clinical miscarriage %
17.1 (6/35)
15.6 (5/32)
0.87
Study question: The aim of this work was to evaluate if there was any difference
when the assisted hatching (AH) was carried out at the level of the inner cell mass
(ICM) or the trophoectoderm (TRP)
Summary answer: The results appear to point towards a favourable trend in applying assisted hatching techniques at the level of the ICM and may explain the role
played by the ICM in the embryo hatching process
What is known already: In order for implantation to take place, the blastocyst
must be hatched from the zona pellucida (ZP). In fact, different ART techniques
try to simulate this process in vitro, a process which is known as ‘Assisted Hatching’ (AH). Despite the reported results, the effectiveness of AH dose not seem entirely clear
Study design, size, duration: Prospectively, 148 treatments from frozen-thawed
day-five blastocysts were randomly selected in the period since 2010 to undergo
AH treatment in the area corresponding to the ICM or TRP
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Blastocysts were vitrified-devitrified
using Kuwayama method and the laser-zona-thining technique was carried out
randomly in the area corresponding to the ICM or TRP after their re–expansion.
Clinical outcomes were analysed computationally and t-student significance was
defined when p , 0.05
Main results and the role of chance: In the clinical outcomes no statistic differences were observed when either MCI or TRP assisted hatching was performed .
However a small trend in the pregnancy rate was shown (table 1)Table 1
Limitations, reason for caution: This study could be limited by the number or
treatments and our vitrification system so further prospective and randomised
studies must be necessary in order to provide new evidence
Wider implications of the findings: Although no statistically significant differences were observed, the pregnancy rate results appear to point towards a favourable trend in applying assisted hatching techniques at the level of the inner cell
mass. These results would be in agreement with the results obtained by other
groups that also defend the role played by the ICM in the embryo hatching
process, but further studies will be necessary in order to provide proof.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This study was supported by IVI Murcia
SL. Murcia. Spain
Trial registration number: No trial registration number
P-204 Does gender affect pre-implantation embryonic developmental
rates?- looking back at the baby pictures
S. Duffy1, A. Campbell2, S. Montgomery1, C.F.L. Hickman3, and S. Fishel2
CARE Fertility, Embryology, Manchester, United Kingdom, 2CARE Fertility,
Embryology, Nottingham, United Kingdom, 3Mouwasat CARE Fertility,
Embryology, Damamm, Saudi Arabia
1
Study question: The study objective was to establish whether time-lapse derived
morphokinetic variables differ between male and female embryos.
Summary answer: Only 1 out of 11 morphokinetic variables studied showed a
significant difference according to embryo gender. A trend for male embryos to
develop at a faster rate up to 8 cells, take less time to achieve full compaction,
but to blastulate and expand at a slower rate was observed.
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
P-202
AH ICM
........................................................................................
i200
P-205
Bovine embryo development in vitro: a sensitive assay to evaluate
plga peg nanoparticle toxicity
I. Fiorentino1, R. Gualtieri1, V. Barbato 1, S. Braun1, V. Mollo2, P. Netti2, and
R. Talevi1
1
University of Naples Federico II, structural and functional biology, Naples, Italy,
2
University of Naples Federico II, Materials and Production Engineering,
Naples, Italy
Study question: The heterogeneity of nanoparticles (NPs) developed for biomedical use emphasizes the need of sensitive toxicity tests. Data on somatic cells were
controversial and only a few studies were done on extremely sensitive processes
such as embryo development.
Summary answer: Biodegradable 65nm rhodaminated poly(d,l-lactic-co-glycolic acid)-block-polyethylene glycol (PLGA-PEG) NPs exert a cytotoxic
effect on embryo development, directly affecting 8 cell embryo (day 3) and blastocyst (day 8) rates, in a dose-dependent manner.
What is known already: Most studies were performed on somatic cells. NPs, depending on their chemical and physical features, may promote sperm apoptosis
and ROS production in a dose and size-dependent manner. NPs may also
impair folliculogenesis in mouse. Toxicity assays on zebrafish indicate that NPs
may damage embryo development, but no data are available in mammals.
Study design, size, duration: The study was performed on 594 oocytes. Cleavage
and 8 cell embryo rates were scored at day 3, blastocyst rates at day 8. Moreover,
NP internalization, blastocyst mean cell numbers (MCN) and percentage of nuclei
with fragmented DNA were assessed by confocal and transmission electron microscopy (TEM).
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Fertilized oocytes treated with NPs
(10 or 50 mg/mL) or vehicle for 8 days, were assessed for cleavage and 8 cell
embryos (day +3) and blastocyst rates (day +8). Blastocyst MCN was analyzed
through labelling with Hoechst 33342; DNA fragmentation was investigated
through TUNEL assay and NPs internalization by TEM.
Main results and the role of chance: NPs treatment did not affect cleavage competence at day 3 after insemination. NPs at 50ug/ml reduced 8 cell embryo and
blastocyst rates (treated vs control: 8 cell, 40 vs 60%, P , 0,05; blastocyst, 34
vs 46,6%, P , 0,05) but MCN and DNA fragmentation were not influenced
(treated vs control: MCN, 134+ 40 vs 132 + 65; DNA fragmentation,
7,06%+ 3,44 vs 7,09% + 4,14). The confocal z-sectioning showed that
PLGA/PEG-NPs were efficiently internalized by embryos and at higher magnification their localization was cytoplasmic and particulated. In agreement with confocal data, TEM analysis showed NPs localized in cytoplasmic vacuoles and
vesicles.
Limitations, reason for caution: NPs behavior toward biological systems and
their toxic effects are not fully understood. Contrasting finding could depend on
the chemical-physical nature of NPs, the variety of cell types and experimental
conditions used in different studies.
Wider implications of the findings: In conclusion, PLGA-PEG-NPs exert a
cytotoxic effect on embryo development in a dose-dependent manner. In vitro
embryo development in animal models may represent a sensitive and predictive
assay of NP toxicity before their application in biomedicine.
Study funding/competing interest(s): Department of Biology, Department of
Materials and Production Engineering
Trial registration number: none
P-206 The relationship of morphokinetic events and euploidy in human
cleavage-stage embryos
A. Bayram1, N. Findikli2, M. Serdarogullari1, O. Sahin1, U. Ulug3, S.B. Tosun3,
and M. Bahceci4
1
Bahceci Umut IVF Center, Embryology, Istanbul, Turkey, 2Bahceci Fulya IVF
Center, Embryology, Istanbul, Turkey, 3Bahceci Umut IVF Center, Clinical
Department, Istanbul, Turkey, 4Bahceci Fulya IVF Center, Clinical Department,
Istanbul, Turkey
Study question: This study questions whether there is a link between early morphokinetic parameters and aneuploidy/euploidy status of human embryos in preimplantation genetic screening (PGS) cycles.
Summary answer: Our results show that embryos that are eligible for
embryo biopsy in PGS cycles reveal similar cleavage profiles irrespective of the
euploidy status. The possible use of time lapse technology in PGS cycles in
order to pinpoint euploidy status of embryos may therefore require larger
sample size and a different study design that includes post compaction follow-up
and analysis until blastocyst stage.
What is known already: Recent studies indicate that embryos carrying
chromosomal abnormalities can show a variety of cleavage disturbances during
preimplantation development. However, current literature correlating the developmental competence and euploidy status of human embryos are mostly performed on static embryo culture hence data regarding early cleavage division
characteristics of such embryos are very limited.
Study design, size, duration: Embryos obtained from 43 PGS cycles in which
chromosomes 13, 15, 16, 17, 18, 21, 22, X and Y were analyzed by fluorescent
in situ hybridization have been monitored in a special tri-gas incubator with
built-in time-lapse monitoring system. The morphokinetic characteristics of
each embryo were traced until day 3 of embryo development. All embryo
biopsy procedures were performed on day 3. The data consisted of embryos and
PGS results of patients that were admitted in our clinics between March
2011-December 2012.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Morphokinetic parameters of 254 biopsied day 3 embryos were retrospectively analyzed and grouped according to the
chromosomal status after PGS as euploid (normal) or aneuploid (including monosomies, trisomies and complex abnormalities). Grouped data were than compared
for each time points (T2 through T8) as well as the duration between these cleavages such as S2, S3 and cc2. Data has been analyzed with Student’s t test and
a P-value less than 0.05 has been considered statistically significant.
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
What is known already: No studies published to-date using time lapse cite a relationship between embryo morphokinetics and offspring gender. Alfarawati et al
(2011) discussed a possible connection between blastocyst morphology and
embryo gender when considering a correlation between embryo morphology
and chromosomal status. Results of their study demonstrated that male embryos
achieved full blastulation at a faster rate than female embryos and a significantly
increased number of male embryos were of a higher grade than the female cohort.
Study design, size, duration: This observational study included the retrospective
analysis of the morphokinetic parameters of 29 ICSI embryos following embryo
transfer and live birth. These embryos had undergone time-lapse imaging in the
EmbryoscopeTM (Unisense Fertilitech, Denmark) for between 3 and 5 days
before being selected for embryo transfer.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Patient data was obtained from 58
fresh ICSI cycles that had utilized EmbryoScopeTM culture in a private IVF
clinic setting and had achieved a live birth. Only embryo transfers that resulted
in 100% implantation were included in the data analysis to ensure complete accuracy of embryo gender.
Main results and the role of chance: The time-points in hours post insemination
(hpi) of the first cleavage (t2) up to the 9+ cell stage (t9+) and the time to reach
morula (tM), full blastocyst (tB) and expanded blastocyst (tEB) were recorded
for embryos of known gender. The mean time-points for male and female
embryos respectively were; (t2) 23.01 vs 24.2, (t3) 33.54 vs 35.14, (t4) 35.41
vs 36.77, (t5) 45.44 vs 47.61, (t6) 47.34 vs 49.94, (t7) 50.72 vs 54.02, (t8)
53.47 vs 55.07, (t9+) 62.17 vs 59.71, (tM) 73.96 vs 77.42, (tB) 102.08 vs
101.37, (tEB) 110.65 vs 107.71. A two sample t-test was performed to statistically
compare the mean time-points of known gender embryos using a p value ,0.05.
Statistical significance was observed only at t7( p ¼ 0.037).
Limitations, reason for caution: Data set size is a limiting factor, making reliable
statistical analyses difficult. Morphokinetic analyses of known gender embryos is
ongoing as more live births occur, which, in addition to the continual availability of
time lapse in this clinic setting, will allow analysis of a larger data set to be presented.
Wider implications of the findings: The concept of differing morphokinetic
values according to embryo gender is of scientific interest. The results of our preliminary analysis, disagree with recent publications, but this may alter as the data
set increases. The morphokinetic differences between the known gender embryos,
although too subtle to be observed in standard incubation, may be observed in
embryos cultured in other time lapse systems.
Study funding/competing interest(s): N/A
Trial registration number: N/A
Abstracts
i201
Abstracts
Euploid
Monosomy
Trisomy
Complex Abnormality
...............................................................................................................................................................................................
T2
27,03 + 3,58 (45)
27,41 + 3,42 (56)
26,82 + 4,069 (46)
T3
37,21 + 5,085 (45)
37,22 + 5,07 (56)
37,41 + 4,767 (46)
28,044 + 4,038 (89)
35,73 + 5,59 (89)
T4
39,99 + 4,50 (45)
40,23 + 6,468 (56)
39,77 + 5,479 (46)
39,22 + 5,95 (89)
T5
50,8 + 7,44 (44)
49,24 + 7,28 (54)
49,07 + 6,78 (43)
46,251 + 8,138 (86)
T6
53,6 + 6,058 (43)
51,48 + 7,40 (53)
52,16 + 6,393 (42)
50,128 + 7,467 (81)
T7
55,48 + 5,45 (40)
54,54 + 6,30 (46)
54,92 + 5,427 (38)
53,343 + 7,296 (74)
T8
56,75 + 5,89 (35)
56,11 + 6,31 (39)
56,94 + 5,531 (35)
55,149 + 6,685 (63)
10,17 + 4,024 (45)
9,59 + 4,98 (56)
2,78 + 3,764 (45)
3,001 + 4,37 (56)
2,356 + 3,717 (46)
3,537 + 5,096 (88)
S3 (t8-t5)
6,93 + 5,81 (35)
8,423 + 6,28 (39)
8,448 + 6,28 (35)
9,628 + 6,502 (63)
Main results and the role of chance: Morphokinetic parameters of 45 euploid
and 209 aneuploid embryos carrying single or complex chromosomal abnormalities shows similar cleavage time characteristics on each time points and parameters analyzed as shown in the Table. This may indicate that although they
have different chromosome constitutions, embryos that are selected for embryo
biopsy with a certain selection criteria are indifferent in their cell division kinetics
until day 3 embryo development.
p . 0.05 for all the parameters compared among groups.
Limitations, reason for caution: Our study includes only embryos that are suitable for biopsy hence the possible correlation for embryos with developmental abnormalities could not be assessed in this setting. Data including extended embryo
culture parameters as well as reanalysis of PGS results on day 5 could also contribute more to our study.
Wider implications of the findings: Our results can indicate that morphokinetic
parameters on early developmental stages fail to indicate any distinct chromosomal abnormality pattern hence cannot be used as an additional indicator for aneuploidy in good quality cleavage stage embryos.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This study received no funding and there
are no conflicts of interests to be declared.
Trial registration number: This study was not an RCT and therefore there is no
registration number.
10,593 + 3,46 (46)
7,928 + 5,218 (88)
Study design, size, duration: Three experiments were designed between 2010
and 2012. In the first experiment 86 treatments from our oocyte donation
program were analyzed. Furthermore, 28 metaphase II matured oocytes remainig
from donor treatments were studied morphometrically. In the third experiment
oocyte hardening was assessed in 47 fresh vs 37 vitrified oocytes
Participants/materials, setting, methods: The metaphase II matured oocytes
were vitrified-devitrified using the Kuwayama method and the clinical outcomes
treatments were studied depending on oocyte origin.The morphometric measurements were performed using an image capture software and to study the ZP hardening the time of digestion mediated by an acidific tyrodes solution was evaluated
Main results and the role of chance: No clinical otucomes differences were
observed when different oocytes were used (Table 1). Focusing on the morphometry, no differences were found (Table 2). when oocyte hardening was studied no
differences were observed in fresh vs vitrified oocytes (23.1 sec vs 19.8 sec; p ¼
0.18 ). Statistical differences were analysed computationally and t-student significance was defined when P , 0.05.Table 1 Table 2
Vitrified
oocytes
Fresh
oocytes
p
.........................................................................................
P-207
Vitrification effect on the oocyte morphometry and the hardening
of zona pellucida
Age
40.4
39.8
Fertilization %
80.5
77.9
0.34
A. Sanchez Leon1, D. Gumbao 1, J. Marcos 1, M. Mollá1, B. Amorocho1,
M. Nicolás2, L. Fernández2, and J. Landeras2
1
IVI Murcia, IVF Laboratory, Murcia, Spain, 2IVI Murcia, Gynecologist, Murcia,
Spain
Clinical pregnancy %
77.8
66.0
0.27
Implantation %
56.5
55.8
0.94
Biochemical %
16
5.4
0.21
Study question: The aim of this study was to focus on the possible morphological
and developmental alterations in our oocyte vitrification system, paying particular
attention to the oocyte zona pellucida (ZP) and its morphological peculiarities,
whilst studying different oocyte morphometric measurements and the possible
hardening effect associated with the cryopreservation process
Summary answer: We may conclude that in our oocyte vitrification system no
negative effect was evidenced on the embryo clinical outcomes when either
fresh or vitrified oocytes were used and neither morphometric nor ZP hardening
changes after vitrification were caused
What is known already: The ability to cryopreserve human oocytes confers significant advantages in IVF-ICSI cycles, not only for the improvement of clinical
results but also when considering ethical and legal aspects. Since the first
human vitrification studies different alterations have been reported and it is
clear that all oocytes and embryos could suffer considerable morphological and
functional damage during the cryopreservation process that may affect in vitro
embryo development and IVF results.
Clinical
miscarriage %
19
11.4
0.24
Vitrified
oocytes
Fresh
oocytes
p
.........................................................................................
ZP diameter (mm)
Oocyte diameter (mm)
19.4
163
19.1
162
0.91
0.74
Ooleme diameter (mm)
113
112
0.89
Polar body size (mm2)
332.2
355.1
0.57
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
cc2 (t3-t2)
S2 (t4-t3)
i202
Abstracts
Limitations, reason for caution: These studies could be limited to our vitrification system and because of the results obtained further prospective and randomised studies must be necessary in order to provide new evidence
Wider implications of the findings: The results show that, in our oocyte vitrification system, no negative effect was seen in embryo development when either
fresh or vitrified oocytes were used. So we may conclude that the vitrification
method works well adn also no morphometric changes after vitrification were
found. On the other hand, the hardening associated process was discarted in
order to know if any hatching assisted method would be necessary to use
Study funding/competing interest(s): This study was supported by IVI Murcia
SL. Murcia. Spain
Trial registration number: No trial registration number
The influence of sequential scoring in determining the best embryo
classification for transfer when not using time lapse technology
M.C.A. Cardoso1, A.P.S. Aguiar1, C. Sartorio2, A. Evangelista2, P. Gallo-Sá2, and
M.C. Erthal-Martins2
1
Vida Centro de Fertilidade da Rede D’Or, IVF Laboratory, Rio de Janeiro,
Brazil, 2Vida Centro de Fertilidade da Rede D’Or, Clinic, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
Study question: What are the benefits of removing the embryos out of the incubator on day 2 (D2) to fulfill the classification scores for the before transfer?
Summary answer: The ASEBIR morphological classification assesses embryo
evolution from D2 to day 3 (D3): similar embryos can be graded differently on
D3 depending on classification they had on D2. On the other hand, taking the
embryos out of the incubator increases stress on them, probably decreasing
their chance in implanting.
What is known already: Embryo morphology classification is still an important
tool of selection for transfer, no matter if the transfer is on day 2, day 3 or blastocyst. The ASEBIR embryo morphological classification takes in account the
embryo evolution from day 2 to day 3. This is the method for embryo classification
which best correlated with the pregnancy outcomes in our clinic and it was the
chosen method, since 2010.
Study design, size, duration: Cases were randomly selected to be either classified
or not on D2. PGD cases, D2 transfers, oocyte donation and when all the embryos
were vitrified (no fresh transfer) were not included. A total of 112 IVF cycles were
analyzed. The study was conducted from April to December of 2012.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: The study groups were divided in
two: Group 1 ¼ D2 + D3 scoring and Group 2 ¼ D3 only scoring. Clinical pregnancy and implantation rates were compared between groups. In Group 1, a blind
reclassification was made as if the D2 assessment had not been done.
Main results and the role of chance: Group 1 had 59 cycles and Group 2, 53
cycles. The groups were similar among patients age (34,3 and 35 years). The pregnancy rate and implantation rate were 22.0% and 15.5% for Group 1, and 34.0%
and 24.5% for Group 2 (p ¼ 0.15 and p ¼ 0.09 respectively). Group 1 had 116
embryos transferred in which 40.5% were grade A, 26.7% grade B, 19.0%
grade C and 13.8% grade D. Group 2 had 101 embryos transferred in which in
which 69.6% were grade A, 17.7% grade B, 7.8% grade C and 4.9% grade
D. In Group 1, if the classification had been done only in D3, the score would
be different (higher) in 11.2% of embryos transferred.
Limitations, reason for caution: When assessments were made only on Day 3, it
was presumed that the embryos had the best score on Day 2, which falsely
increases the scores of some embryos.
Wider implications of the findings: There was no significant difference between
Groups 1 and 2 in pregnancy and implantation rates, but the validity of considering
the embryo development profile until the day of transfer, while not having a timelapse incubator, is still questionable. Subtracting one day of observation
diminishes exposure of the embryos. The loss in accuracy on embryo grading
affects only a few percentage of them, not impairing their implantation potential.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This study was conducted in a private
clinic without third party sponsorship.
Trial registration number: None
P-209
embryos
Factors affecting the transcriptome of human preimplantation
Study question: What is the relative effect of common environmental and biological factors on the transcriptome changes during human preimplantation development?
Summary answer: Developmental stage and maternal age have a larger effect on
the global gene expression profile of human preimplantation embryos than the
culture medium or oxygen concentration used in in-vitro culture.
What is known already: Studies on mouse and bovine embryos have shown that
different conditions in the in-vitro culture of embryos can lead to changes in transcriptome profiles. For humans this is not yet known. An effect of developmental
stage on the transcriptome profile of embryos has been demonstrated, but studies
on the effect of maternal age or various culture conditions are lacking.
Study design, size, duration: Human preimplantation embryos were randomised
to two culture-media (G5-medium or HTF-medium) and to two oxygen concentrations (5% or 20%), with stratification for maternal age. Next to these variables,
developmental stage after culture was also taken into account in the transcriptome
analysis.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: After thawing, donated human
embryos that were cryopreserved on day four, were cultured for two days under
the randomized conditions (N¼ 89). Only embryos developing to morula or
blastocyst stage (N ¼ 39) were assessed for genome-wide gene expression
using microarrays and a regression model was built to select the contributing
factors.
Main results and the role of chance: Based on the number of differentially
expressed genes (DEGs), developmental stage (3,519 DEGs) and maternal age
(1,258 DEGs) had a larger effect on the global gene expression profile of
human preimplantation embryos than either tested culture medium (596 DEGs)
or oxygen concentration (492 DEGs) used during in-vitro culture. Interactions
between the factors were found, indicating that culture conditions might have a
different effect depending on the developmental stage or the maternal age of the
embryos. Affected pathways included metabolism, cell cycle processes and oxidative phosphorylation.
Limitations, reason for caution: Culture of embryos for only two days might
have limited the effect on global gene expression by the investigated culture conditions. Earlier stages of development (day 0 until day 4) were not analyzed and
might respond differently to the experimental conditions.
Wider implications of the findings: Our results show that when studying gene
expression in single human preimplantation embryos under various experimental
conditions, one should take into account the confounding effect of biological variables, such as developmental stage and maternal age. This makes these experiments different from gene expression experiments where these variables can be
tightly controlled, for example when using cell lines.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This study received no external funding
and there were no competing interests.
Trial registration number: None
P-210
Can completion of compaction predict implantation outcome?
E. Power, S. Montgomery, S. Duffy, K. Jordan, A. Campbell, and S. Fishel
CARE Fertility, Manchester embryology, Manchester, United Kingdom
Study question: If cellular material is excluded from the embryo at the stage of
compaction (defined as incomplete compaction), does this affect the ability of
the embryo to implant successfully?
Summary answer: Significantly more embryos where compaction was incomplete failed to implant, compared to embryos with complete compaction
(p ¼ 0.033).
What is known already: There is evidence with conventional microscopy
showing snap shots of embryo development, that incomplete compaction may
be related to the ability to form a blastocyst (Ivec et. al.). Time lapse technology
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
P-208
E. Mantikou1, M.J. Jonker2, M. de Jong2, K.M. Wong1, A.P.A. van Montfoort3,
T.M. Breit2, S. Repping1, and S. Mastenbroek1
1
Center for Reproductive Medicine, Academic Medical Center University of
Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 2Swammerdam Institute for Life
Sciences Faculty of Science (FNWI) University of Amsterdam, MicroArray
Department and Integrative Bioinformatics Unit (MAD-IBU), Amsterdam, The
Netherlands, 3Maastricht University Medical Center, Obstetrics and
Gynaecology, Maastricht, The Netherlands
i203
Abstracts
P-211
Vitrification/warming before embryo biopsy can positively
contribute to clinical outcome in Preimplantation Genetic Screening
cases
N. Findikli1, T. Aksoy1, M. Gultomruk1, A. Aktan2, C. Goktas1, U. Ulug3, and
M. Bahceci2
1
Bahceci Fulya IVF Centre, Embryology Laboratory, Istanbul, Turkey, 2Bahceci
Fulya IVF Centre, Clinical Department, Istanbul, Turkey, 3Bahceci Umut IVF
Centre, Clinical Department, Istanbul, Turkey
Study question: Does vitrification/warming before embryo biopsy have any
effect or additional role in cases where Preimplantation Genetic Screening
(PGS) is performed?
Summary answer: The use of vitrified/warmed cleavage stage embryos before
biopsy can positively contribute to cycle outcome compared to cases in which
only embryos obtained in fresh cycles are biopsied.
What is known already: Numerous studies report that cryopreserving embryos
following biopsy for PGS may affect the clinical outcome. However, the
data about the efficiency of vitrification/warming of cleavage stage embryos
before biopsy for PGS and subsequent embryo transfer are scarce and contains
limited data.
Study design, size, duration: This retrospective cohort study includes 222
patients undergoing a total of 231 PGS cycles performed for numerical and
structural chromosomal abnormalities between August 2010 – December 2012
in Fulya and Umut Bahceci Assisted Reproductive Technology Centers.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: PGS cycles that were included in this
study were grouped into three according to the nature of biopsied embryos: Group
1 includes 110 PGS cycles in which 792 fresh embryos were biopsied, group 2 consists of 38 PGS cycles in which a total of 350 fresh and vitrified/warmed embryos
were biopsied and group 3 includes 83 PGS cycles that utilized only vitrified/
warmed embryos (803 embryos biopsied). Upon availability of chromosomally
competent embryos, cycles in group 1 and group 2 proceeded with fresh
embryo transfers, embryos in 3 were transferred in frozen embryo transfer
setting with proper endometrial preparation.
Main results and the role of chance: A total of 1945 embryos (fresh and vitrified/
warmed) were biopsied and an informative PGS result were obtained in 1903/1945
(97.8%). Depending on the availability of chromosomally normal embryos, 71
cycles in group 1 (65%), 25 cycles in group 2 (66%) and 65 cycles in group 3
(79%) reached embryo transfer stage. Average number of embryos transferred
in each group was 1.36, 1.52 and 1.46 respectively. Likewise, clinical pregnancy
rates in group 1, 2 and 3 were 38%, 48%, 53.8% and implantation rates were found
to be 29%, 34% and 41%, respectively. In group 2 and 3, a total of 1060 embryos
were warmed in which 952 were utilized for embryo biopsy on day 3 of embryo
development (90.8%).
Limitations, reason for caution: This study includes cases in which fluorescent in
situ hybridisation (FISH)-based PGS were performed for 5, 7 or 9 chromosomes, respectively. Clinical outcome can be improved if array comparative genomic hybridization (aCGH) or similar technologies can be utilized in the same approach.
Wider implications of the findings: This study may be generalized in PGS cases
in which the number of embryos in a fresh cycle is very limited and there is a high
probability of not finding a chromosomally normal embryo after analysis. In such
cases, embryos of consecutive IVF cycles can be vitrified and pooled. Also, PGS in
combination with frozen embryo transfer programmes can produce better clinical
outcome with more physiological endometrial environment.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This study received no funding and there
are no conflicts of interests to be declared.
Trial registration number: This study was not an RCT and therefore there is no
registration number.
P-212
Impact of HIV infection in women submitted to ICSI cycles
R. Petracco, L. Okada, R. Azambuja, F. Badalotti, J. Michelon, V. Reig, D. Kvitko,
A. Tagliani-Ribeiro, M. Badalotti, and A. Petracco
Fertilitat, Centro de Medicina Reprodutiva, Porto Alegre, Brazil
Study question: Analyze the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection in
women submitted to assisted reproduction technology on the oocyte quality,
embryo quality and overall pregnancy rate.
Summary answer: Our data showed that HIV patients have no difference when
submitted to intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) cycles regarding to stimulation response, laboratory and pregnancy outcome.
What is known already: There are 34.2 million people infected by HIV around
the world. Half of this population is women and three quarters are in their reproductive years. Considering best quality of life and higher survival rates using
anti retroviral therapies, the patients are considering pregnancy planning using
assisted reproductive technologies. Cumulative evidence suggests that ART is
safe and effective for avoiding horizontal and vertical transmission in HIV serodiscordant couples. The literature is controversial about the HIV patient results, but
some of the publications relates worse IVF/ICSI outcome in this population.
Study design, size, duration: Retrospective cohort study with 11 HIV serodiscordant couples, whose women were infected, submitted to ICSI between 2002 and
2012.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: The HIV patients were matched to
two different control patients according to infertility cause, age, semen quality
and ovarian stimulation protocol. In the HIV patients group, mean age was 38.7
years old and 22 cycles were performed, in the control groups was 39 years old
and were performed 44 cycles. The results were compared using t test (P , 0.05).
Main results and the role of chance: The number of oocytes retrieved, mature
(MII) oocytes, oocytes fertilized, number of embryos transferred and embryo
quality were compared. In the serodiscordant group, there were 18 cycles with
embryo transfer. Out of those, there were 9 pregnancies (50%), from those 1 biochemical and 8 clinical. Out of the clinical pregnancy there were 2 miscarriages, 2
ongoing pregnancy and 4 newborn. In the control group there were 41 cycles with
embryo transfer. Out of those, there were 18 pregnancies (43%), from these 4 biochemical and 14 clinical. Out of the clinical pregnancies 3 miscarriage, 2 are
ongoing and 9 newborn. There were no statistical differences between the groups.
Limitations, reason for caution: The study was conducted with a small number
of patients.
Wider implications of the findings: Our data showed that HIV patients presented
similar results to the control group regarding to stimulation, laboratory and pregnancy outcome, however the number of embryos transferred had a trend to significance in the control group (p ¼ 0,054).
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
has allowed us to study this in greater detail and retrospectively compare this to
implantation outcome.
Study design, size, duration: The use of time lapse technology in the IVF laboratory has facilitated the ability to study embryo development as a dynamic process
and to retrospectively assess how compaction may affect embryo development and
ultimately implantation. Using the EmbryoScopeTM (Unisense Fertilitech,
Denmark) it has been possible to compare the process and degree of compaction,
whether cellular material is excluded, in those embryos that are known to have
implanted to those that are known to have not.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Embryos cultured in the EmbryoScope (ES) with a minimum of 5% fragmentation (by volume) at the cleavage
stage (up to 8 cell) that had developed to full blastocyst stage were included.
This group was further restricted to embryos of known implantation outcome
(KID) where a single embryo was replaced and implanted, or 2 embryos were
replaced and both implanted (KID +) and those where no implantation occurred
(KID -). A database of the embryo development videos was set up in the ES viewer
and all were viewed and annotated according to whether or not any cellular material was excluded at compaction. The end point of compaction was taken as the start
of blastulation. The data was then exported to excel and compared to implantation
outcome.
Main results and the role of chance: In the 75 embryos studied, there was a significant difference (p ¼ 0.033) in the number of embryos that completely compacted and went on to implant (48% 29/61), compared to the number with
incomplete compaction that went on to implant (14% 2/14).
Limitations, reason for caution: The embryo numbers are restricted by the fact
that the embryos from many double embryo transfers where a single implantation
occurred have been excluded. Data from the KID embryos will continue to be collected.
Wider implications of the findings: This may be a useful clinical tool, in conjunction with time lapse technology, in de-selecting embryos with a reduced potential
to implant.
Study funding/competing interest(s): N/A
Trial registration number: N/A
i204
Study funding/competing interest(s): There were no competing interests in this
study
Trial registration number: Not available
P-213
Synchronicity of cleavage cycles predicts blastocyst formation
and quality
C. Pirkevi, M. Cetinkaya, H. Yelke, Y. Kumtepe, Z. Atayurt, and S. Kahraman
Istanbul Memorial Hospital, Assisted Reproductive Technologies and
Reproductive Genetics Center, Istanbul, Turkey
P-214
The relationship between homocysteine, embryo quality and
pregnancy in embryo culture medium in assisted reproductive techniques
B. Aydin and I. Cepni
Cerrahpasa Tip Fakültesi (Medical Faculty), Obstetric and Gynecology, Fatih
Istanbul, Turkey
Study question: Can homocysteine in embryo culture medium affect the embryo
quality?
Summary answer: Homocysteine in embryo culture medium affect the embryo
quality.
What is known already: Homocysteine is an oxidant aminoacid product that
affect the reproductive process.
Study design, size, duration: Our study is acase control study. The study has been
completed in 1 year.40 cases are included.23 cases are non pregnant and 16 cases
are pregnant.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: 40 cases which admitted to our clinic
with fertility desire were included into study. In each case; the level of homocysteine in culture medium was measured by spectrophotometry. Also the correlation
between Hcy levels in culture medium and embryo quality were investigated.
Main results and the role of chance: Age, the duration of infertility, infertility
type, VKI, FSH levels in 3 th day of the menstruation, serum AMH levels were
not statistically significant between pregnant and non-pregnant group in which
Hcy levels were detected in embryo culture medium. And also total dosage of gonadotropin, the number of total oocyte and oocyte which ICSI was performed, the
daytime in which the stimulation performed were not significant between two
groups. . Positive correlation was detected between Hcy in embryo culture
medium and embryo grade (r:0,376, p , 0.034). 24 of 40 patients were not pregnant
and 16 of 40 were pregnant. Also significant correlation was found between being
not able to conceive and Hcy levels in culture medium (r:0,5131, p , 0.0004).
Limitations, reason for caution: Our case numbers are so low. We can redouble
the case numbers and also the validity of the study.
Wider implications of the findings: In other studies, homocysteine in semen and
follicular fluid has been also found as an oxidant product that affect inversly the
reproductive parameters.
Study funding/competing interest(s): Homocysteine is an important marker for
embryo quality.
Trial registration number: There is no registration number.
P-215 Comparison of gender-specific human embryo development
characteristics by time lapse technology
M. Serdarogullari1, N. Findikli2, A. Bayram1, C. Goktas2, O. Sahin1, U. Ulug3,
and M. Bahceci4
1
Bahceci Umut IVF Centre, Embryology Laboratory, Istanbul, Turkey, 2Bahceci
Fulya IVF Centre, Embryology Laboratory, Istanbul, Turkey, 3Bahceci Umut IVF
Centre, Clinical Department, Istanbul, Turkey, 4Bahceci Fulya IVF Centre,
Clinical Department, Istanbul, Turkey
Study question: This study asks whether there exist gender-specific embryo development kinetics or parameters between human male and female embryos that
can be observed and distinguished by time lapse technology.
Summary answer: Our results indicate that the cavitation time of a female
embryo was slightly earlier compared to the male embryos. However, other morphokinetic parameters used, such as early cleavage time points, duration between
each cleavages, early signs of compaction, cavitation and blastocoel expansion do
not show any variation.
What is known already: Numerous studies in laboratory animals and mammals
indicate that there might be differences in embryo growth dynamics between male
and female embryos. However, current data and literature that had analyzed
gender-specific preimplantation growth parameters in humans so far are scarce
and the results are inconclusive or conflicting.
Study design, size, duration: Embryos were cultured in special tri-gas incubators
with built-in time-lapse monitoring system in 116 cycles. In these cycles, gender
of the off-springs was also assessed through ultrasonography performed at 14-16
weeks of gestation. Study included data from cycles performed between March
2011-December 2012 in Bahceci Assisted Reproductive Technology Centers.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Embryos of 18 cycles were excluded
from analysis since they were twin pregnancies of different genders. Remaining
114 embryos were analysed for parameters including cleavage time points and
duration in each cleavage from two cells - until hatching blastocyst stages (t2 to
tHB), time interval between cleavages (cc2, S2 andS3).
Main results and the role of chance: Morphokinetic parameters 62 female and
52 male embryos from a total of 98 cycles processed for data analysis. Table shows
the time kinetics of each observed parameter and the number of embryos scored.
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
Study question: Can we predict high quality blastocyst formation potential from
day3 embryos using morphokinetics?
Summary answer: The five formulas cited below were used to identify cleavage
synchronicity: (F1): (t8-t2)/((t3-t2) + (t5-t4)); (F2): (t8-t5)/(t8-t4); (F3): (t4-t3)/
(t4-t2); (F4): (t4-t2)/(t8-t4); (F5): (t3-t2), additionally two criteria (irregular divisions and evenness of blastomeres at 2 and 4-cell stages) were applied to build an
additive embryo scoring model predicting high quality blastocyst formation.
What is known already: The blastocyst formation was found to correlate with
cc2 (time between division to 2 cells and division to 3 cells), s2 (time between division to 3 cells and subsequent division to 4 cells) and with the duration of the first
cytokinesis (Wong, 2010). Cruz et al. have added t4 and t5 and Dal Canto et al.
used different subtractions giving the duration of cell cycles (t3-t2; t4-t3; t4-t2;
t8-t4; t8-t5) to predict blastocyst quality.
Study design, size, duration: This retrospective cohort study was conducted
between October 2011 and October 2012 in a private ART Center and approved
by the institutional review board. The study included 1199 embryo having a
(t8) from 190 infertile patients transferred on day5 (Female age: 31.7 + 4.4; Previous ART cycles: 1.6 + 1.8; BMI: 24.4 + 6.2; MII: 8.2 + 3.4).
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Embryos were cultured in a single
step culture medium, which was refreshed on day3. Incubation was performed
under oil at 378C, 5%O2 and 6%CO2. Each time of cleavage was recorded. Blastocysts were scored before transfer according to Gardner’s classification
(115-120h post ICSI).
Main results and the role of chance: Embryos should mainly stay in even cell
stages, which should be balanced when compared to each other, ideally reflecting
cleavage synchronicity. Each formula was applied and embryos were classified in
5%groups and good/ top quality blastocyst rate (BR) was computed for the
20intervals. In order to follow mathematically the natural trends obtained in
BR, the average of ≥3consecutive 5%groups was subtracted from the average
of the 2following groups, and divided to the initial BR until the theoretical threshold set at 0.15 was reached. Each class had a mean BR, which was subtracted from
the initial BR, giving a positive or negative score. Obtained scores were added for
the final prediction of the blastocyst formation potential. The logistic regression
model built gave an AUC ¼ 0.841 (95%CI 0.819-0.861).
Limitations, reason for caution: The model described may depend on culture
conditions applied in this particular IVF laboratory (low O2, single step
medium, mainly antagonist ovarian stimulation protocol). The cohort studied
involved only infertile patients (female, male or combined) and is in this
respect a heterogeneous population.
Wider implications of the findings: Time points defining precise embryo cleavage events may not be generalized to infertile patients with different etiologies.
However, using ratios based on selected cleavage cycles defining synchronicity
of embryos, allows in this retrospective cohort study an individualized analysis
giving high predictivity of blastocyst formation and quality. The proposed
model has to be further tested in a randomized prospective trial to evaluate its
ef?cacy, and may in the future improve embryo selection in IVF treatments.
Study funding/competing interest(s): Authors have nothing to disclose.
Trial registration number: Not applicable
Abstracts
i205
Abstracts
Female
Final outcome of embryo transfers on day 3, 4 and 5 using own and
donated oocytes
D. Rodrı́guez-Arnedo1, J. Ten1, J. Guerrero1, I. Ochando1, M. Pérez 2, and
R. Bernabeu3
1
Instituto Bernabeu, Embryology Dept., Alicante, Spain, 2Instituto Bernabeu,
Embryology Dept., Cartagena, Spain, 3Instituto Bernabeu, Reproductive
Medicine Dept., Alicante, Spain
Study question: Is transfer on day 4 a reasonable alternative in ART (assisted reproduction treatments) and are there differences between own or donated oocytes
in term of clinical pregnancy and implantation rates?
Summary answer: Transfer on day 4 is a reasonable alternative to day 5 in treatments using own and donated oocytes considering that at this time of development
the embryo has full genomic activation.
What is known already: The day 4 human embryo appears as a mass of cells
composed of 16-32 blastomeres; the morula. The blastomere adherence process
is mediated by changes in distribution of E-cadherin proteins from the cytoplasm to the cell membrane. This process has been linked to activation of
the embryonic genome (Desai et al., 2000). Transfer on day 4 occurs postgenome activation and allows us to select the highest developmental potential
embryo from a cohort.
Study design, size, duration: A cross-sectional study was performed in a retrospective analysis of 2,685 IVF/ICSI treatments with own oocytes (670) and
donated oocytes (2015) between January 2008 and December 2012. Embryo
transfers were performed on day 3, 4 or 5.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: A multivariant analysis was performed including confusing factors like maternal age, number of oocytes collected, embryo quality on day 3, number of transferred embryos and their
quality. A multiple lineal regression for quantitative dependent variables and
binary logistic regression for categorical dependent variables were applied. We
compared clinical pregnancy rates (CPR) and implantation rates (IR) in 3
groups: day 3, 4 and 5 transfers.
Main results and the role of chance: In case of own oocytes, there were no statistically significant differences between CPR and transfers on day 3, 4 and 5
(43.3%; 49.4%; 50.5%, respectively). In terms of IR, we found a significant difference between day 3 and day 5 (28.00 vs 38.86, respectively, p ¼ 0.004). With
donated eggs, there were statistically significant differences between day 3 vs.
day 4 and 5 with respect to CPR (44.1%, 51.0%, 56.4% respectively), p ¼
0.044(day 3 with day 4), p ¼ 0.001 (day 3 with day 5), IR (28.71%, 37.26%,
42.57% respectively), p ¼ 0.002 (day 3 with day 4), p ¼ 0.001 (day 3 with day
5) and number of useful embryos (transferred plus frozen) (3.26, 3.68, 3.82, respectively), p¼ 0.003(day 3 with day 4), p ¼ 0.001 (day 3 with day 5).
Limitations, reason for caution: According to our results, day 4 is a reasonable
alternative for transfer in treatments of own and donated oocytes, but this study is
retrospective and has some limitations. A prospective randomized study should be
done to confirm our findings.
Wider implications of the findings: These results confirm the contributions of
other authors on the subject, considering the transfer on day 4 as an alternative
to transfer on day 5 without reducing success rates. In this case we have analyzed
a total of 2,685 cycles, coming from day 3 transfers (901), day 4 (430) and day 5
(1354); probably the greatest number of cases analyzed.
P
T2
25,5 +2,7(62)
25,6 + 3,51(52)
0.86
T3
36,3 + 4,1 (62)
36,4 + 3,93 (52)
0.89
T4
37,5 + 3,5 (62)
37,96 + 3,52 (51)
0.48
T5
48,3 + 6,5 (61)
48,83 + 6,14 (48)
0.66
T6
51,1 + 4,8 (61)
51,21 + 4,95 (48)
0.90
T7
53,2 + 5,2 (61)
53,1 + 5,5(47)
0.92
T8
55,9 + 5,6 (61)
56,98 + 8,2 (46)
0.42
T9
65,07 + 7,6 (54)
66,91 + 8,22 (45)
0.25
70,4 + 8,2 (48)
71,14 + 9,84 (41)
0.69
Tcomp
P-216
Male
.........................................................................................
Tm
Tcav
81,25 + 8,6 (46)
81,4 + 12,4 (41)
0.94
90,9+ 8,1 (42)
94,4 + 9,65 (37)
0.08
Teb
103,1 +6,7 (40)
104,7+ 6,1 (33)
0.29
Thb
112,2 + 6,05( 14)
112,2 + 2,06 (4)
1.0
cc2 (t3-t2)
10,8 + 2,2 (62)
10,72 + 3,08 (52)
0.87
S2 (t4-t3)
1,2 +2,1 (62)
1,58 + 2,61 (51)
0.67
S3 (t8-t5)
7,5 +5,9 (61)
8,35 + 7,63 (46)
0.51
Study funding/competing interest(s): Conflicts of interest and source of funding
not declared.
Trial registration number: There is not trial registration number
P-217 Pregnancy rates comparison between fresh versus frozen blastocyst transfers
L. Okada, R. Petracco, R. Azambuja, F. Badalotti, J. Michelon, V. Reig,
A. Tagliani-Ribeiro, D. Kvitko, M. Badalotti, and A. Petracco
Fertilitat-Centro de Medicina Reprodutiva, Center for Medicine Reproductive,
Porto Alegre, Brazil
Study question: To compare the pregnancy rates of transferred blastocysts
derived from fresh or frozen cycles.
Summary answer: Our data suggest that frozen blastocyst transfer does not
reduce the chances of pregnancy
What is known already: The embryo cryopreservation has become a fundamental technique in assisted reproduction to store indefinitely and viably the surplus
embryos. The culture of embryos to the blastocyst stage has shown to be a more
efficient way of selection and with better chances of implantation.
Study design, size, duration: Retrospective cohort study with only cycles transferring blastocysts embryos (fresh ¼ 116 or frozen ¼ 58), during the year 2012.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: The results of blastocyst transfer
cycles were evaluated. The mean age of patients in the fresh cycle and FET
(frozen embryo transfer) were 33.8 and 34.8, respectively. The technique of cryopreservation was vitrification (Kuwayama et al. 1998). Statistical analysis was performed using Fisher’s exact test (p ,0.05).
Main results and the role of chance: The number of embryos transferred in both
groups (fresh and FET) were 238 and 109, respectively, with an average of 2.1 and
1.9 per patient. The rates of pregnancies and clinical pregnancies were 45.7% and
40.5% for fresh embryos and 50.0% and 43.1% transferring frozen/thawed blastocysts. No statistically significant difference (p. 0.05) was observed in the
results obtained.
Limitations, reason for caution: The study was conducted with a small number
of patients in a short period of time.
Wider implications of the findings: The results suggest that frozen blastocyst
transfer does not reduce the chances of pregnancy, according to published data.
Study funding/competing interest(s): There were no competing interests in this
study
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
Limitations, reason for caution: The number of embryos and cycles included in
the study. To use of time lapse technology in predicting the gender-specific development of the human embryos may require further research and larger sample size
with the current parameters and technical setting.
Wider implications of the findings: Results of this study may indicate that although there is a trend of early cavitation in females, there are no distinct genderspecific differences in embryo development kinetics in human preimplantation
embryos. Therefore, either novel dynamic embryo culture and selection or conventional embryo culture and scoring systems are not expected to change sex-ratio
of the resulting pregnancies irrespective of the day of embryo transfer.
Study funding/competing interest(s): This study received no funding and there
are no conflicts of interests to be declared.
Trial registration number: This study was not an RCT and therefore there is no
registration number.
i206
Trial registration number: Not available
P-218
Transfer of frozen/thawed embryos: pregnancy comparison
between blastocysts and cleavage stage embryos
V. Reig, D. Kvitko, A. Tagliani-Ribeiro, L. Okada, R. Azambuja, R. Petracco,
J. Michelon, F. Badalotti, A. Petracco, and M. Badalotti
Fertilitat, Centro de Med. Reprodutiva, Porto Alegre, Brazil
Endometriosis, endometrium, implantation and
fallopian tube
P-219
Down-regulation of dipeptidyl peptidase 4 under hypoxia could
enhance endometrial stromal cell migration in endometriosis
C.W. Tan1, Y.H. Lee1, M. Choolani2, H.H. Tan3, L. Griffith 4, and J. Chan5
1
Singapore-MIT Alliance for Research and Technology (SMART), BioSystems
and Micromechanics, Singapore, Singapore Rep. of, 2National University of
Singapore (NUS), Yong Loo Lin School of Medicine, Singapore, Singapore Rep.
of, 3KK Women & Children Hospital, Department of Reproductive Medicine,
Singapore, Singapore Rep. of, 4Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT),
Department of Biological & Mechanical Engineering, Boston, U.S.A, 5Duke
NUS Graduate Medical School, Cancer & Stem Cell Biology Program,
Singapore, Singapore Rep. of
Study question: To determine whether hypoxic microenvironment might be a
factor in influencing cell migration of endometrial stromal cells in endometriosis
Summary answer: Endometrial stromal cells (ESCs) derived from endometriotic
patients could migrate and invade more aggressively than control ESCs under
hypoxia and this phenomenon may act through a downregulation of dipeptidyl
peptidase 4 (DPPIV/CD26)- involved pathway and enhanced expression of
angiogenesis- related genes.
What is known already: Previous reports showed that hypoxia-induciblefactor-1(HIF-1) was significantly higher in endometriotic women. Besides,
increased expression of focal adhesion kinase (FAK) in endometriotic tissue
also alluded to altered cell motility in endometriosis, yet there is little known
about the relationship between hypoxia and cellular migration in the pathogenesis
of such lesions.
Study design, size, duration: ESCs were isolated from endometrial curettage
samples obtained from women with endometriosis (Stage IV AFS, n ¼ 3) or
other benign gynaecological disease (Stage 0 AFS, n ¼ 3) undergoing laparoscopic surgery.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: Cells were exposed to hypoxia (2%
O2) and assayed for motility with Oris Pro Cell migration/ invasion assay. Total
RNA was extracted for PCR Array Human Cell Motility (SA Biosciences).
DPPIV/CD26 expression was determined by flow cytometry whereas conditioned
medium was applied to Human Angiogenesis Antibody Array (R&D Systems).
Main results and the role of chance: Endometriotic ESCs could migrate and
invade through collagen gel (p , 0.005) more under hypoxic condition as compared
to ESCs derived from healthy patients. PCR array revealed down-regulation of migration inhibitors (Fibroblast activation protein (FAP), DPPIV/CD26) in patient ESCs
under hypoxia and was confirmed via flow cytometry (normoxia: 30.62% vs
hypoxia: 12.37%; p ¼ 0.004) Protein array studies showed that angiogenesisrelated genes such as TIMP-1, angiogenin and IGFBP-3 was aberrantly upregulated
in endometriotic cells when being exposed to hypoxic environment. This could imply
that ESCs from endometriosis patients may be enhanced their cell motility under
hypoxic microenvironment, leading to up- regulation of migration/ angiogenesisrelated genes while keeping the migratory inhibitors at low concentration.
Limitations, reason for caution: One limitation is the ability to test downstream
gene expression of DPPIV/CD26 pathway. Since DPPIV/CD26 is proven to
modulate Stromal Cell Derived Factor-1 (SDF-1 / CXCL12) and its receptor,
CXCR4, inhibiting DPPIV/CD26 may be possible to test whether DPPIV/
CD26 down- regulation of in endometriosis is SDF- 1/ CXCL12-CXCR4 axis
dependent.
Wider implications of the findings: This is the first study to show a statistically
significant difference in DPPIV/CD26 expression associated with this disease.
DPPIV/CD26, a membrane-bound extracellular peptidase, is found to be able
to cleave CXCL12 and thereby immobilize hematopoietic stem and progenitor
cell (HSCs/HPCs) populations. Overexpressing DPPIV/CD26 to modulate
SDF-1 / CXCL12 and their subsequent chemotactic activity may represent new
targets for novel therapies in women with endometriosis.
Study funding/competing interest(s): The authors declare no competing financial interests.
Trial registration number: N.A.
P-220 Inhibition of annexin A2 by prostaglandin E2 results in reduced
phagocytic ability of peritoneal macrophages and contributes to the development of endometriosis
P.C. Chuang1, M.H. Wu2, Y.J. Lin3, and S.J. Tsai4
1
Chang-Gung Memorial Hospital Kaohsiung, Department of Medical Research,
Kaohsiung City, Taiwan R.O.C, 2National Cheng Kung University Medical
College, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Tainan City, Taiwan R.O.C,
3
Chung Hwa University of Medical Technology, Department of Nursing, Tainan
City, Taiwan R.O.C, 4National Cheng Kung University Medical College,
Department of Physiology, Tainan City, Taiwan R.O.C
Study question: Is annexin A2 involved in the reduced phagocytic ability of
macrophages in endometriosis?
Summary answer: Data from women with endometriosis and a murine model
of the disease show that expression of annexin A2 in peritoneal macrophages is
inhibited by prostaglandin E2 (PGE2) and this impairs the phagocytic ability of
macrophages.
What is known already: Endometriosis is a chronic inflammatory disease that
recruits many immune cells, especially macrophages, to the peritoneal cavity.
The phagocytic ability of peritoneal macrophages isolated from women with
endometriosis is reduced.
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/28/suppl_1/i149/660892 by guest on 22 January 2023
Study question: To compare the pregnancy rate in patients submitted to FET
(Frozen Embryos Transfer) of cleavage stage embryos (Group 1), or at the blastocyst stage (Group 2).
Summary answer: Our data showed that the transfer of frozen blastocysts has a
better pregnancy rate than cleavage embryos.
What is known already: The first birth of a baby arising from a cryopreserved
embryo occurred in 1983. Since then, improvements in embryo cryopreservation
have occurred. However since early 90′ s a vitrification technique has also been
developed to cryopreserve embryos in any stage of development.
Study design, size, duration: Retrospective cohort study during 2012, with a
total of 132 cycles.
Participants/materials, setting, methods: In the group 1 the embryos had been
frozen on the 2nd, 3rd or 4th day after fertilization, while in the group 2 the embryos
were frozen on 5th or 6th day at blastocyst stage. All embryos were cryopreserved
by vitrification followed Kuwayama et al, 1998 protocol. The pregnancy rates
were compared through the chi-square test (p , 0.05).
Main results and the role of chance: The Group 1 consisted of 74 patients, which
pregnancy and clinical pregnancy rate were 27.0% (20/74) and 21.6% (16/74), respectively. The Group 2 had 58 patients, and pregnancy and clinical pregnancy
rate were 50.0% (29/58) and 43.1% (25/58) respectively. There was statistical difference between the groups (P¼ 0.0107). The mean age were 34.8 and years old
for groups 1 and 2 respectively.
Limitations, reason for caution: The study was conducted during a short period
of time.
Wider implications of the findings: This result suggests that the transfer of
embryos at the blastocyst stage would be the best choice for IVF clinics.
Study funding/competing interest(s): There were no competing interests in this
study.
Trial registration number: Not Available
Abstracts