Eyal Levinson
The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, History, Department Member
- Gender, Queer Theory, Masculinities, History of Sexuality, Medieval Jewish History, Sexuality, and 11 moreGender Studies, History, Medieval History, History of Religion, Social History, Caroline Walker Bynum, Medieval Studies, Medieval Art, Jewish - Christian Relations, Jewish History, and Jewish Studiesedit
- Dr. Eyal Levinson is currently a researcher at Contending with Crisis: The Jews in IXth Century Europe. In the past s... moreDr. Eyal Levinson is currently a researcher at Contending with Crisis: The Jews in IXth Century Europe. In the past six years he was a postdoctoral research fellow at Beyond the Elite: Jewish Daily Life in Medieval Europe. He researches youth, men, fatherhood and masculinities in medieval Ashkenaz. His book, Gender and Sexuality in Ashkenaz in the Middle Ages (in Hebrew) was recently published by the Zalman Shazar Center and the Leo Baeck Jerusalem Institute. He also co-authored with Tzafrir Barzilay and Elisheva Baumgarten Jewish Life in Medieval Northern Europe, 1080‐1350: A Sourcebook (Western Michigan Press, forthcoming). Eyal is also the author of several articles among them: “Situated Fathering in Medieval Ashkenaz” published in JSQ; “Male Friendship in Medieval Ashkenaz”, in Friendship in Jewish Culture, History, and Religion; “Eternal love I conceive for you: Traveling Jewish Men and Covenantal Bromances”, in Mittelalter. Interdis- ziplinäre Forschung und Rezeptionsgeschichte 3; and “Masculinities”, in Encyclopedia of Jewish-Christian Relations.edit
A vivid depiction of a jousting scene in an illuminated Hebrew prayerbook allows a unique pictorial representation of a custom common among Jewish young men in Northwestern Europe during the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries:... more
A vivid depiction of a jousting scene in an illuminated Hebrew prayerbook allows a unique pictorial representation of a custom common among Jewish young men in Northwestern Europe during the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries: joustinglike tournaments at Jewish weddings. The article contextualizes this image more broadly with contemporaneous sources originating in different genres, including rabbinic literature, vernacular documents, illuminated Hebrew manuscripts, frescos that decorated affluent Jewish homes, epitaphs, and archaeological findings, to describe the lives, self-image, and social expectations of medieval Ashkenazic men. Moreover, the article sheds light on the influences of the surrounding culture on medieval rabbinic gender constructs and on the constructions of gendered identities among these young men, and particularly on two indicators of identity: daily conduct and clothing. The article argues that these Jewish young men were navigating two masculinities, and that they internalized complex identities, which enabled them to identify as Jews and at the same time to feel that they were part of mainstream urban culture to some degree.
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
The Israel Science Foundation sponsored research project Contending with Crises: The Jews in XIV th Century Europe at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem under the direction of Prof. Elisheva Baumgarten is offering up to 2 Post-Doctoral... more
The Israel Science Foundation sponsored research project Contending with Crises: The Jews in XIV th Century Europe at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem under the direction of Prof. Elisheva Baumgarten is offering up to 2 Post-Doctoral scholarships beginning in the 2023-2024 academic year. Scholars who have
Fatherhood in medieval Ashkenaz was a complex sociological phenomenon, manifesting both st and a!ectionate attitudes towards children. Fathers were expected to treat misbehaving childre harshly, but this disciplinary attitude was... more
Fatherhood in medieval Ashkenaz was a complex sociological phenomenon, manifesting both st and a!ectionate attitudes towards children. Fathers were expected to treat misbehaving childre harshly, but this disciplinary attitude was inseparable from paternal love and physical contact between fathers and children. Spaces in"uenced paternal behavior: appropriate fatherly behavi the synagogue di!ered from how fathers were expected to treat their children at home. This art focuses on two internal domestic loci: the cellar and the family table. The study of the cellar demonstrates not only harsh paternal behavior, but also the limitations of fatherhood: expelling children from home was a last resort for fathers who could not otherwise exert their paternal authority when paternal attempts to motivate children to internalize normative behavior were n successful. The study of the family table sheds light on the nurturing and educative aspects of domestic fatherhood; it manifests its a!ectionate characteristics and reveals gender constructions
Research Interests:
Traveling Jewish Men and Covenantal Bromances Zusammenfassung: In diesem Artikel werden mittelalterlich-jüdische „Bromances“ diskutiert, die jüdische Männer vor dem Aufbruch auf eine längere Reise vertraglich vereinbarten. Einige jüdische... more
Traveling Jewish Men and Covenantal Bromances Zusammenfassung: In diesem Artikel werden mittelalterlich-jüdische „Bromances“ diskutiert, die jüdische Männer vor dem Aufbruch auf eine längere Reise vertraglich vereinbarten. Einige jüdische Männer des Mittelalters hielten solche nicht-sexuellen homosozialen Verbindungen für notwendig, um rabbinische Männlichkeitsideale zu stärken. Zwei spätmittelalterliche hebräische Quellen, eine des 14. Jahrhunderts aus Spanien und eine aus dem Deutschland de..
Research Interests:
Abstract: This paper discusses medieval Jewish covenantal bromances, formed by Jewish men prior to embarking on an extended journey. For some medieval Jewish men, long distance trav-eling necessitated forming non-sexual homosocial... more
Abstract: This paper discusses medieval Jewish covenantal bromances, formed by Jewish men prior to embarking on an extended journey. For some medieval Jewish men, long distance trav-eling necessitated forming non-sexual homosocial bonding, which reinforced rabbinic masculinity. Two late medieval Hebrew sources, one from 14 th century Spain and the other from 15 th century Germany, reveal that entering a covenant before a long-distance journey was a known practice among medieval European Jewish men. Although these are the only two examples of covenantal bromances I found thus far, reading them carefully and contextualizing them with other contemporary sources, we may conclude that this type of male bonding was a recognized social institution in medieval European Jewish communities. What was the content of these relationships? Which rituals were employed to seal these pacts? And how did these covenantal bromances reinforce the boundaries of normative masculinity? These are the questions I discuss in this paper. 1
Research Interests:
Two disparate worldviews, the rabbinical and the chivalric, helped shape young Jewish men’s gender identities in medieval Germany. Alongside traditional rabbinical ideals of masculinity to which Jewish youngsters were exposed from an... more
Two disparate worldviews, the rabbinical and the chivalric, helped shape young Jewish men’s gender identities in medieval Germany. Alongside traditional rabbinical ideals of masculinity to which Jewish youngsters were exposed from an early age, they encountered the values rooted in chivalric culture that were central to the formation of gender identity among young Christian men in Europe during the Middle Ages.
Some young Jewish men embraced chivalric codes of masculinity to varying degrees, from dressing like their af uent Christian counterparts, to joining armies of local lords and actually adopting the chivalric way of life. Some also engaged in activities associated with the life of a knight, such as participation in tournaments, hunting, and falconry. The ideal of masculinity espoused by the Ashkenazi rabbis was sometimes at odds with chivalric culture and its values, prompting the rabbis to attempt to infuse values such as courage, pride, respect, love, and loyalty with content more in line with the ideals they sought to impart to the younger generation.
Some young Jewish men embraced chivalric codes of masculinity to varying degrees, from dressing like their af uent Christian counterparts, to joining armies of local lords and actually adopting the chivalric way of life. Some also engaged in activities associated with the life of a knight, such as participation in tournaments, hunting, and falconry. The ideal of masculinity espoused by the Ashkenazi rabbis was sometimes at odds with chivalric culture and its values, prompting the rabbis to attempt to infuse values such as courage, pride, respect, love, and loyalty with content more in line with the ideals they sought to impart to the younger generation.
Research Interests:
The article explores the various ways in which a social elite perceives the “intra- communal Other” and examines their social implications. The test case is that of the rabbinic elite of medieval Ashkenaz and the different ways in which... more
The article explores the various ways in which a social elite perceives the “intra- communal Other” and examines their social implications. The test case is that of the rabbinic elite of medieval Ashkenaz and the different ways in which it conceptualized and perpetuated the social category of the unlearned man or am ha’aretz. The process took place on three parallel and simultaneous tracks that interacted and helped buttress the social status of the Ashkenazi rabbinic elite: the construction of a negative image of the “intra-communal Other,” in this case the am ha’aretz; the abasement of the am ha’aretz and his exclusion from the centers of social power; and the arrogation of privileges by the members of the rabbinic elite at the expense of the am ha’aretz.
Gender constructions played a major role in consolidating the rabbis’ position at the top of the social hierarchy. Prominent among these was the ideal of masculinity crystallized by the Ashkenazi rabbis on the basis of their reading of the talmudic literature, a gender construction that they successfully instilled in their communities. The Ashkenazi rabbis described the am ha’aretz as coarse and uneducated, wicked, an informer, and violent, whose sexual behavior deviates from the rabbinic norm. This violent, bestial, and depraved masculinity was contrasted with the rabbinic ideal of manliness—a scholar immersed in the Torah, with a capacity for self-control, firm but also compassionate and willing to compromise. In light of this picture of how the elite constructed and treated their “intra-communal Other,” this article rejects Yehuda Brandes’s proposal to renew the social category of the am ha’aretz, as a social and halakhic concept, to replace the notion of “secular” that has taken root in Israeli society.
Gender constructions played a major role in consolidating the rabbis’ position at the top of the social hierarchy. Prominent among these was the ideal of masculinity crystallized by the Ashkenazi rabbis on the basis of their reading of the talmudic literature, a gender construction that they successfully instilled in their communities. The Ashkenazi rabbis described the am ha’aretz as coarse and uneducated, wicked, an informer, and violent, whose sexual behavior deviates from the rabbinic norm. This violent, bestial, and depraved masculinity was contrasted with the rabbinic ideal of manliness—a scholar immersed in the Torah, with a capacity for self-control, firm but also compassionate and willing to compromise. In light of this picture of how the elite constructed and treated their “intra-communal Other,” this article rejects Yehuda Brandes’s proposal to renew the social category of the am ha’aretz, as a social and halakhic concept, to replace the notion of “secular” that has taken root in Israeli society.
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
This conference is set to take place in person, but we will remain attentive to current circumstances and open to hosting this event virtually. The final decision will be made two weeks prior to the conference.
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
there is evidence of public expressions of grief among Ashkenazi fathers during the high and late Middle Ages and this emphasized the tender and loving aspect of medieval Jewish fatherhood. By encouraging fathers to seek support and... more
there is evidence of public expressions of grief among Ashkenazi fathers during the high and late Middle Ages and this emphasized the tender and loving aspect of medieval Jewish fatherhood. By encouraging fathers to seek support and comfort among community members and its rabbinic leaders, this type of fatherhood also contributed to strengthening familial and communal bonding.
Research Interests:
Rituals were at the core of Jewish quotidian life during the high and late Middle Ages, and they were often inseparable from conceptualizations of masculinities and fatherhood. Within medieval urban Jew-ish households, the table often... more
Rituals were at the core of Jewish quotidian life during the high and late Middle Ages, and they were often inseparable from conceptualizations of masculinities and fatherhood. Within medieval urban Jew-ish households, the table often became the central locus of the home, a place for gathering and eating, studying, praying and conversing. It was also a place where business transactions were conducted and marriage contracts were negotiated. The table, therefore, was a domestic location saturated with meanings , regulations, rituals and etiquette. Even though, in many medieval urban homes the table and the dining area were not architecturally separated from other parts of the house, it nonetheless became the heart of the domestic sphere. Among the daily rituals conducted around the table were the blessings after meals. Weekly rituals included the Kiddush, the sanctification of the sabbath over a cup of wine, and once a year, during the Passover Seder, it was around the dining table where fathers imparted to their children the unfolding story of the Jewish people. Thus, the table was one place where identities were shaped, where gender hierarchies and masculinities were manifested, and where fathers performed fatherhood. Moreover, in this lecture I will argue that within medieval Jewish culture, the dining table often represented, not only the alter that once stood at the Temple in Jerusalem, but it was also a symbol of fatherhood itself. The proposed lecture will discuss the table as a locus where rituals and fatherhood often intersected and what such social interactions teach about the constructions of fatherhood amongst Ashkenazi Jews during the high and late Middle Ages.
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
We are pleased to present the second issue of our newsletter describing some of the highlights of our recent activities, publications, and achievements.
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
The Israel Science Foundation sponsored research project Contending with Crises: The Jews in XIV th Century Europe at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem under the direction of Prof. Elisheva Baumgarten is offering up to 2 Post-Doctoral... more
The Israel Science Foundation sponsored research project Contending with Crises: The Jews in XIV th Century Europe at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem under the direction of Prof. Elisheva Baumgarten is offering up to 2 Post-Doctoral scholarships beginning in the 2023-2024 academic year. Scholars who have
The Israel Science Foundation sponsored research project Contending with Crises: The Jews in XIV th Century Europe at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem under the direction of Prof. Elisheva Baumgarten is offering up to 2 visiting... more
The Israel Science Foundation sponsored research project Contending with Crises: The Jews in XIV th Century Europe at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem under the direction of Prof. Elisheva Baumgarten is offering up to 2 visiting fellowships for Ph.D. students in the fields of History, Jewish Studies, Religious Studies, Literature, or Art History starting in October 2023. Successful candidates will receive a monthly stipend of ca. 7,500 NIS. They will be given offices at the Hebrew University (Mount Scopus campus), and will expected to be present at least two days a week. They will take part in a group enterprise of creating a history of Jewish life in Europe during the XIV th century with an emphasis on challenges Jews faced as part of the centuries' crises including expulsion, migration, persecution, and plague but also return to previous homes after displacement, cultural production, changing and continuing social structures. Work on any geographic area in Europe is relevant for this project. They will participate in the project's seminar, research trips, conferences and its other activities and will confirm to the requirements of Ph.D. students at the Hebrew University. For more information see: http://www.research-students.huji.ac.il/en
New Book by Eyal Levinson: ויגדלו הנערים: מגדר ומיניות באשכנז בימי הביניים Gender and Sexuality in Ashkenaz in the Middle Ages This book examines youth culture in Ashkenaz, mainly in northern France and Germany, during the eleventh to... more
New Book by Eyal Levinson:
ויגדלו הנערים: מגדר ומיניות באשכנז בימי הביניים
Gender and Sexuality in Ashkenaz in the Middle Ages
This book examines youth culture in Ashkenaz, mainly in northern France and Germany, during the eleventh to fifteenth centuries, within the context of mainstream Christian majority culture. By examining adolescence and youth culture in medieval Ashkenaz and the values that shaped the Jewish young men’s gendered identities, this book is an initial attempt to fill a lacuna that the historian Michael Satlow recently pointed at, the absence of critical studies on medieval Jewish masculinities.
The book surveys sources from different genres, which allows for a complex and wide-ranging examination of Jewish adolescence, the social ideals that adults tried to impart to young people, the cultural images in which adults described the youth of their communities, and the daily lives of young men and women. These sources include responsa and halakhic literature, moral treatises, biblical and talmudic commentaries, custom books, folk tales and legends, Crusade chronicles, epitaphs, illustrations in medieval Hebrew books, archaeological findings, and frescoes.
The vibrant youth culture of medieval Ashkenaz that this book brings to light, features young men and women who enjoyed drinking together in taverns, who loved dancing in mixed company at weddings, dressed in their finest clothes for the occasion. There were Ashkenazic young men who participated in pseudo–tournaments at weddings, some joined real tournaments, and many protected their cities alongside their Christian neighbors.
The book argues that the lives of Jewish adolescents were not so different from those of their Christian peers. Jewish and Christian youth interacted with one another as part of their daily lives, shared values related to gender, dressed in similar fashions, danced to the same melodies, and knew the same stories and legends. Like their Christian neighbors, young Jewish men liked to run wild, behave violently, enjoyed competitions, and demonstrated their physical strength and fighting skills. And like their Christian neighbors these young Jewish men held masculine knightly ideals and were influenced by chivalric culture, esthetics, and values. Concurrently, these same men were shaped by halakhic norms and the values of rabbinic masculinity.
All in all, this study allows a path to better understanding of not only medieval Jewish culture and everyday life during this period, but also medieval urban culture at large. Readers interested in the history of childhood, adolescence, sexualities, and formations of gendered identities will also benefit from this study.
ויגדלו הנערים: מגדר ומיניות באשכנז בימי הביניים מספר את סיפורם של בחורים ובחורות שחיו בקהילות היהודיות באשכנז, במאות ה-11 עד ה-15. הסיפורים המופיעים בספר גדושים במידע היסטורי שמאיר באור חדש את חברה יהודית זו. הם מעידים, למשל, על האינטראקציה המגדרית היום-יומית שהייתה מקובלת בין צעירים וצעירות ועל תרבות הנעורים שבה הם נטלו חלק, ושהתנהלה בבתי המשתה ובבתי המחולות וגם בחצרות בתי הכנסת, בבתים פרטיים וברחובות הערים. הצעירים והצעירות אהבו לרקוד יחדיו כשהם מקושטים במיטב בגדיהם, הם שיחקו במשחקים שונים, וביניהם משחקי כדור שאפשרו מגע גופני, ומתקבל גם הרושם, שאף תופעת ההימורים לא הייתה זניחה בין הבחורים. היו בין הבחורים שבאו להשתתף בחתונות וביניהם כאלה שלא היססו לגנוב תרנגולות מתושבי המקום. כמו כן היו בחורים שנהגו לערוך כחלק מחגיגות הנישואים מעין טורנירים כמקובל אצל שכניהם האצילים. תקופת הבחרות נחשבה כפרק חיים שבו הצעירים נמצאו בשיא כוחם הפיזי ואונם המיני, וללא יכולת רבה לרסן את תשוקותיהם המיניות, שלעיתים חרגו מגבולות המיניות המותרת. אינטראקציות מגדריות פנים-קהילתית היו חלק מחיי היום יום כמו גם קשרים חברתיים בין צעירים יהודים ונוצרים, שהתרחשו במרחבים העירוניים הצפופים של צפון-מערב אירופה.
הספר חושף את קהל הקוראים והקוראות ליחסים המורכבים שהיו בין המבוגרים ובין הדור הצעיר, בין הורים לילדיהם, בין רבנים לתלמידיהם, בין בעלים צעירים לנשותיהם המבוגרות והעשירות, בין בחורים עשירים למשרתות, ובין בנות עשירים לתלמידי חכמים. עדויות היסטוריות אלו מלמדות גם על מתחים פנים-קהילתיים שצצו מפעם לפעם ודרשו את התערבות הרבנים. המקורות עליהם מתבסס הספר נבחנו באמצעות הקטגוריה האנליטית ״גבריות״, מהלך שפתח פתח להבנת המורכבות המגדרית שכוננה חברה יהודית זו. ערכי הגבריות האבירית תרמו לעיצוב זהותם המגדרית של בחורים רבים בתקופה הנדונה, יהודים ונוצרים כאחד. את הנערים היהודים לא חינכו להפנים את ערכי הגבריות האבירית; ערכים אלו הם ניכסו במרחבים התרבותיים, וערכים אלו עמדו לעיתים קרובות בסתירה לתפיסות הגבריות הרבנית. הספר מראה שבחורי אשכנז פיתחו זהויות מגדריות ויהודיות מורכבות, ושזהויות אלו אפשרו להם להרגיש שייכות מסוימת לתרבות הרוב שבה הם חיו, ובד בבד לפתח שייכות ייחודית לקהילה היהודית שבה הם גדלו, פעלו, הקימו את משפחותיהם וגידלו את ילדיהם, ובה הם סיימו את חייהם.
ויגדלו הנערים: מגדר ומיניות באשכנז בימי הביניים
Gender and Sexuality in Ashkenaz in the Middle Ages
This book examines youth culture in Ashkenaz, mainly in northern France and Germany, during the eleventh to fifteenth centuries, within the context of mainstream Christian majority culture. By examining adolescence and youth culture in medieval Ashkenaz and the values that shaped the Jewish young men’s gendered identities, this book is an initial attempt to fill a lacuna that the historian Michael Satlow recently pointed at, the absence of critical studies on medieval Jewish masculinities.
The book surveys sources from different genres, which allows for a complex and wide-ranging examination of Jewish adolescence, the social ideals that adults tried to impart to young people, the cultural images in which adults described the youth of their communities, and the daily lives of young men and women. These sources include responsa and halakhic literature, moral treatises, biblical and talmudic commentaries, custom books, folk tales and legends, Crusade chronicles, epitaphs, illustrations in medieval Hebrew books, archaeological findings, and frescoes.
The vibrant youth culture of medieval Ashkenaz that this book brings to light, features young men and women who enjoyed drinking together in taverns, who loved dancing in mixed company at weddings, dressed in their finest clothes for the occasion. There were Ashkenazic young men who participated in pseudo–tournaments at weddings, some joined real tournaments, and many protected their cities alongside their Christian neighbors.
The book argues that the lives of Jewish adolescents were not so different from those of their Christian peers. Jewish and Christian youth interacted with one another as part of their daily lives, shared values related to gender, dressed in similar fashions, danced to the same melodies, and knew the same stories and legends. Like their Christian neighbors, young Jewish men liked to run wild, behave violently, enjoyed competitions, and demonstrated their physical strength and fighting skills. And like their Christian neighbors these young Jewish men held masculine knightly ideals and were influenced by chivalric culture, esthetics, and values. Concurrently, these same men were shaped by halakhic norms and the values of rabbinic masculinity.
All in all, this study allows a path to better understanding of not only medieval Jewish culture and everyday life during this period, but also medieval urban culture at large. Readers interested in the history of childhood, adolescence, sexualities, and formations of gendered identities will also benefit from this study.
ויגדלו הנערים: מגדר ומיניות באשכנז בימי הביניים מספר את סיפורם של בחורים ובחורות שחיו בקהילות היהודיות באשכנז, במאות ה-11 עד ה-15. הסיפורים המופיעים בספר גדושים במידע היסטורי שמאיר באור חדש את חברה יהודית זו. הם מעידים, למשל, על האינטראקציה המגדרית היום-יומית שהייתה מקובלת בין צעירים וצעירות ועל תרבות הנעורים שבה הם נטלו חלק, ושהתנהלה בבתי המשתה ובבתי המחולות וגם בחצרות בתי הכנסת, בבתים פרטיים וברחובות הערים. הצעירים והצעירות אהבו לרקוד יחדיו כשהם מקושטים במיטב בגדיהם, הם שיחקו במשחקים שונים, וביניהם משחקי כדור שאפשרו מגע גופני, ומתקבל גם הרושם, שאף תופעת ההימורים לא הייתה זניחה בין הבחורים. היו בין הבחורים שבאו להשתתף בחתונות וביניהם כאלה שלא היססו לגנוב תרנגולות מתושבי המקום. כמו כן היו בחורים שנהגו לערוך כחלק מחגיגות הנישואים מעין טורנירים כמקובל אצל שכניהם האצילים. תקופת הבחרות נחשבה כפרק חיים שבו הצעירים נמצאו בשיא כוחם הפיזי ואונם המיני, וללא יכולת רבה לרסן את תשוקותיהם המיניות, שלעיתים חרגו מגבולות המיניות המותרת. אינטראקציות מגדריות פנים-קהילתית היו חלק מחיי היום יום כמו גם קשרים חברתיים בין צעירים יהודים ונוצרים, שהתרחשו במרחבים העירוניים הצפופים של צפון-מערב אירופה.
הספר חושף את קהל הקוראים והקוראות ליחסים המורכבים שהיו בין המבוגרים ובין הדור הצעיר, בין הורים לילדיהם, בין רבנים לתלמידיהם, בין בעלים צעירים לנשותיהם המבוגרות והעשירות, בין בחורים עשירים למשרתות, ובין בנות עשירים לתלמידי חכמים. עדויות היסטוריות אלו מלמדות גם על מתחים פנים-קהילתיים שצצו מפעם לפעם ודרשו את התערבות הרבנים. המקורות עליהם מתבסס הספר נבחנו באמצעות הקטגוריה האנליטית ״גבריות״, מהלך שפתח פתח להבנת המורכבות המגדרית שכוננה חברה יהודית זו. ערכי הגבריות האבירית תרמו לעיצוב זהותם המגדרית של בחורים רבים בתקופה הנדונה, יהודים ונוצרים כאחד. את הנערים היהודים לא חינכו להפנים את ערכי הגבריות האבירית; ערכים אלו הם ניכסו במרחבים התרבותיים, וערכים אלו עמדו לעיתים קרובות בסתירה לתפיסות הגבריות הרבנית. הספר מראה שבחורי אשכנז פיתחו זהויות מגדריות ויהודיות מורכבות, ושזהויות אלו אפשרו להם להרגיש שייכות מסוימת לתרבות הרוב שבה הם חיו, ובד בבד לפתח שייכות ייחודית לקהילה היהודית שבה הם גדלו, פעלו, הקימו את משפחותיהם וגידלו את ילדיהם, ובה הם סיימו את חייהם.