James Watson
University of Arizona, Arizona State Museum, Faculty Member
Occlusal surface wear scores were examined in a sample of 200 Formative period (1,500 B.C.-A.D. 500) skeletons from the lower Azapa Valley in northwest Chile. Wear rate and plane (angle) were additionally evaluated using a subsample of... more
Occlusal surface wear scores were examined in a sample of 200 Formative period (1,500 B.C.-A.D. 500) skeletons from the lower Azapa Valley in northwest Chile. Wear rate and plane (angle) were additionally evaluated using a subsample of paired first and second mandibular molars. The Formative period represents the transition from marine foraging to agro-pastoral dependence in the region and differences in oral pathology indicate that diet varied by site location (coast vs. valley interior) but not by archaeological phase (early vs. late). We predicted that occlusal wear would demonstrate similar patterns, resulting from differences in food consistency, and therefore hypothesized that occlusal surfaces should wear faster and exhibit flat molar wear in coastal groups consuming greater quantities of foraged foods compared to slower wear rates but more angled molar wear among valley interior groups consuming greater quantities of agro-pastoral products. Heavier posterior tooth wear was identified among coastal residents but rate and angle of molar occlusal attrition did not differ significantly by location. Heavier overall wear and a steeper molar wear plane were identified during the early phase indicating that food consistency varied somewhat over the course of the Formative period. Overall, the results indicate that, although limited differences in tooth wear exist by site location, wear varied more over time likely reflecting a gradual transition from foraging to agro-pastoral dependence in the lower Azapa Valley. Although oral health indicators point to differences in dietary investment by location, maintenance of a mixed subsistence economy likely sustained a comparative consistency of foodstuffs.
Research Interests:
Indicators of oral health were recorded in a sample of 200 Formative period (1,500 B.C.-A.D. 500) skeletons from archaeological sites located in the lower Azapa Valley of northwest Chile. This period represents a major shift in... more
Indicators of oral health were recorded in a sample of 200 Formative period (1,500 B.C.-A.D. 500) skeletons from archaeological sites located in the lower Azapa Valley of northwest Chile. This period represents a major shift in subsistence strategies in the Atacama Desert, as coastal groups adopted agriculture and moved deeper into the valley. Frequencies of caries and antemortem tooth loss were compared between site locations (coast vs. valley) and by archaeological phase (early vs. late) to interpret the degree to which these incipient agriculturalists were reliant on domesticated resources. Overall, frequencies of caries (11.9%) and tooth loss (11.6%) are somewhat higher than other prehistoric groups practicing a mixed subsistence strategy. However, residents of the interior valley exhibited significantly more dental decay and tooth loss than those along the coast. Our results identify that although the Formative period residents of the lower Azapa Valley practiced a mixed subsistence strategy, the degree of reliance on agricultural production differed between the coast and the valley. We propose that these differential patterns in oral health are tied to local investment, adaptive cycles, and niche construction.
Research Interests:
Crown dimensions and occlusal surface wear rate and wear plane were evaluated using paired first and second mandibular molars from a sample of 84 Early Agricultural period (1600 B.C.-A.D. 200) skeletons from northwest Mexico. Although... more
Crown dimensions and occlusal surface wear rate and wear plane were evaluated using paired first and second mandibular molars from a sample of 84 Early Agricultural period (1600 B.C.-A.D. 200) skeletons from northwest Mexico. Although this period represents a major shift in subsistence strategies in the Sonoran Desert, from food-foraging to agriculture, archaeological and dental pathology studies have identified this period as one of relative dietary stability. It was therefore predicted that very little variation in occlusal wear would have occurred between the early phase (San Pedro: 1600-800 B.C.) and late phase (Cienega: 800 B.C.-A.D. 200). Comparison of crown diameters identified some phenotypic differences between sexes but not between archaeological phases. Molar occlusal surfaces were then divided into four quadrants, and wear scores recorded for each quadrant. Principle axis analysis was performed between total wear scores of paired, adjacent first and second mandibular molars to assess rate and occlusal wear plane over time. The analysis demonstrated that both wear rate and wear plane increased from the early to the late phase of the Early Agricultural period. These results indicate that although diet may have indeed remained stable during this period in the Sonoran Desert increases in the rate of wear and wear plane may reflect changes in food-processing techniques. It is suggested that more intensive processing of agricultural products during the Cienega phase simultaneously softened the diet to create more tooth-contact wear and introduced more grit to cause faster and more angled wear on the molar occlusal surfaces.
Research Interests:
Differences in dental health of prehistoric human groups are commonly attributed to specific subsistence practices, whereby food foragers generally have lower incidence of dental disease than agriculturalists. Dental health was assessed... more
Differences in dental health of prehistoric human groups are commonly attributed to specific subsistence practices, whereby food foragers generally have lower incidence of dental disease than agriculturalists. Dental health was assessed on a sample of 135 human skeletons from northwest Mexico that date to the Early Agricultural period (1600 B.C.-A.D. 200), which coincides with the initial introduction of domesticated cultigens into the region circa 2000 B.C. High rates of dental caries (13.46%) and antemortem tooth loss (17.57%) encountered in these prehistoric forager-farmers from the Sonoran Desert were determined to be the result of the consumption of highly cariogenic local wild resources such as cactus. These patterns mask the degree of reliance on agriculture in the area and highlight the importance of constructing local nutritional histories to better understand the unique diversity of human diets and their relationships to health and disease.
Research Interests:
Several hundred human burials have been recovered from Early Agricultural period (1200 B.C.-A.D. 50) sites located throughout the Sonoran Desert. These burials represent a substantial sample of the earliest farmers from the North American... more
Several hundred human burials have been recovered from Early Agricultural period (1200 B.C.-A.D. 50) sites located throughout the Sonoran Desert. These burials represent a substantial sample of the earliest farmers from the North American desert west and provide a unique insight into how the transition to an agricultural lifeway affected the health and lives of these peoples. The burial samples represent similar numbers of males and females of all adult age groups, lack juvenile remains, and demonstrate a wide variety of burial practices. Stature estimates reveal that these were generally relatively tall individuals, and limited evidence of infectious and degenerative diseases indicate the population enjoyed very good health. However, a high rate of trauma, some of which was violent in nature, suggests a significant level of conflict. Oral health was generally poor, although high rates of caries and tooth loss were likely the result of a balanced diet that
relied on highly cariogenic resources of local cactus, as well as a reliance on domesticated corn. This mixed subsistence economy appeared to have remained relatively stable for nearly 2,000 years, but evidence from tooth wear indicates mechanical processing of existing resources may have intensified during the Cienega phase (800 B.C.-A.D. 50).
relied on highly cariogenic resources of local cactus, as well as a reliance on domesticated corn. This mixed subsistence economy appeared to have remained relatively stable for nearly 2,000 years, but evidence from tooth wear indicates mechanical processing of existing resources may have intensified during the Cienega phase (800 B.C.-A.D. 50).
Violence is common among small-scale societies and often stems from a combination of exogenous and endogenous factors. We suggest that socialization for violence and revenge as a motivation can encourage costly signaling by warriors and... more
Violence is common among small-scale societies and often stems from a combination of exogenous and endogenous factors. We suggest that socialization for violence and revenge as a motivation can encourage costly signaling by warriors and contribute to the creation of atypical burials in archaeological contexts. We characterize mortuary patterns among early irrigation communities in the Sonoran Desert of the southwest United States/northwest Mexico (Early Agricultural period: 2100 BC–AD 50) to define normative mortuary practices and identify atypical burials. One of the principle roles the performance of mortuary rituals fulfills is to publicly integrate a shared identity or reinforce social differences within a community. This postmortem negotiation of social identities was likely an important component to ease social tensions in early farming communities. However, atypical burials from these sites appear to represent acts of violence upon the corpse at, or after, the death of the individual that fall outside of the normative conformity to prescribed mortuary ritual. We propose that these cases represent perimortem signaling, a form of costly signaling conditioned as basal violent reactions, possibly stemming from socialization for violence.
Research Interests:
The transition to agriculture has long been the subject of debate among archaeologists in the Southwest US/Northwest Mexico. Arguments suggest that cultigens and agricultural technology were brought in by migrating agriculturalists from... more
The transition to agriculture has long been the subject of debate among archaeologists in the Southwest US/Northwest Mexico. Arguments suggest that cultigens and agricultural technology were brought in by migrating agriculturalists from Mesoamerica or diffused through an interconnected network of local foraging groups. The results of either of these disparate processes would have had a significant effect on the foundation of human biological variation in the region as groups began to farm and populations expanded. Here I examine several lines of anthropological evidence to test the hypothesis that agriculture was introduced into the Sonoran Desert by migrating farmers from Mesoamerica. Linguistic models support migrations of maize-bearing proto-Uto-Aztecan peoples from central Mexico. Molecular analyses (modern mtDNA and aDNA) support diffusion of language, plants and technology and perhaps limited migration. Studies in skeletal biology of early farmers in the area support a gradual integration of agriculture into local foraging groups. Although evidence for migration appears to be limited, we still lack crucial data that would provide conclusive evidence to the contrary. The introduction of agriculture is important to understand as a process that contributed significantly to the foundation of biological variation among later complex Formative period cultures of the region.