Even when things get better, when Covid cases plummet, when Congress actually acts, when a police department get reformed, when greenhouse gases get cut… the framing of the news doesn’t change. It remains the same: Vibrating with anxiety, reflexively disappointed, rarely delighted.
It’s like that friend you have — who always sees the worst in everything. You go out for coffee and feel empty afterward. Finally, you stop going.
I like this comparison — that the news is that person who’s always a drag.
So what would be better? In the essay, I make the case for routinely and systematically reporting out Hope, Agency and Dignity in every story.
Hope and agency for sure; right now the news feels disempowering and hope-draining — and that it’s intended to! The publisher’s goal is the clickbait headline, which often preys on your fears or manipulates you through your sense of identity — but in being so endlessly negative they support the fascists who want you to give up on social justice because there’s no hope, they back the corporations who want you to give up on climate change because there’s no hope, and they further divisions by turning you against the outgroup — whoever isn’t like you.
We need to see signs of agency and hope so we will risk action even when the stakes are high — especially when those in danger are someone unlike us.
See also: don’t read the news
5 replies on “The news is a drag”
This Article was mentioned on tracydurnell.com
How can our society resist fascism and become more equitable? Last updated 2024 October 12 | More of my big questions Sub-questions What should we expect from fascists? What are the common approaches and arguments they use? How have people resisted fascism in the past? How can I help others safely? How can women be…
Replied to Twitter is dying by Natasha Lomas (techcrunch.com)
Society isn’t equipped to prevent the willful destruction of things that give power to the masses by the elites who wish to uphold the status quo.
Musk buying Twitter (with Saudi financing 😒) to drive out the libs and boost the incels is like LJ when it was taken over by the Russians to drive out the gays. The site may continue to exist, but any value it once had to society has been destroyed. Twitter will surely use the vestiges of its former power to do harm too.
Authoritarians and the wealthy will always use every tool at their disposal to suppress free speech by the masses, because it benefits us far more than it does them.
I have serious qualms about the US government banning TikTok, especially in light of Twitter’s functional collapse. I don’t have an account, but I’m referred there more and more often instead of Twitter, as people use video to communicate critiques and news that I would have gotten on Twitter in the past.
I don’t read news in the traditional sense of going to a paper’s website and reading the headlines, but instead in recent years have relied on following a large pool of pro-labor, queer, academic and expert and artistic and techy folks. Through them I’ve gotten excellent commentary and context around the kinds of stories I care about, which are often not covered by mainstream news or lacking the underlying info that makes it fit into the world. This way, I hear about things like protests and labor movements and attacks on personal liberties and the environment, and only hear about the worst mass shootings so I can have some emotional space to recover between incidents. I might not hear about everything instantly, but I feel I get a better source of information.
Mastodon is not (yet?) a viable replacement for Twitter or TokTok’s cultural commentary and awareness of advocacy. I find Mastodon threads overwhelming since they don’t have threading and you can’t tell who / what someone’s replying to, and sometimes replies appear to be missing. It’s basically useless to engage in an existing long conversation that you weren’t following from the start because unravelling it is too complicated. I followed some interesting folks on Mastodon via micro.blog but might unfollow them given the opacity of conversations. Mastodon may well be a better place for people to form community, but it is not substituting as an information, news, and commentary source for me.
Last week, I updated my blogroll to include everyone in my RSS feed reader. While I read a lot of topical blogs and…
Stories provide a scaffold for understanding When I read non-fiction, I’m less interested in learning facts than gaining understanding (though sometimes facts support the understanding).…