Department of Jewish Studies

It is a truism that Jewish polemical/apologetic texts have been written since Late
Antiquity with the main purpose of strengthening the faint-hearted members of Jewish communities
throughout the globe. Hence the existence of this kind of text implicitly suggests the presence of some
form of “religious scepticism” or feeling of uncertainty in the ranks of the Jewish population. On the
other hand, since the beginning of the early modern period a radical change can be felt in the genre.
The sceptical figure, who had been present previously only hidden in the background of the texts,
now came forth from behind the scenes, and took a clearly identifiable shape, like Shimi, one of the
protagonists of the polemical drama, written by the Italian playwright Matityahu Nissim Terni (1745–
1810), entitled Derech Emunah (“The Way of Faith”). In this paper an attempt will be made to analyse
Terni’s drama as a very sensitive psychological portrayal of the complex personality of an average
Italian Jew of the ghetto age, reconciling successfully the technical requirements of contemporary
dramaturgy with the specific values, expectations and tantalizing questions of the Jewish community
of his age.