EP0435885A1 - Metallic glass alloys for mechanically resonant target surveillance systems. - Google Patents

Abstract

The magnetic metal lens alloy described, which is characterized by a low rate of damping of mechanical resonance oscillations, is suitable for use in object monitoring systems with incorporated targets using mechanical resonance of the target. The alloy has a composition represented by the formula FeaNibMcBdSieCf, where M represents either molybdenum or chromium, the elements '' a '' to '' f '' are included in atomic ratios, '' a '' being between approximately 39 and approximately 41%, '' b '' between 37 and approximately 39%, '' c '' between 0 and approximately 3%, '' d '' between approximately 17 and approximately 19% and '' e '' and '' f '' between 0 and about 2%, provided that (i) only one of the elements '' c '', '' e '' and '' f '' can be equal to 0, (ii) '' e '' cannot be equal to 0 when '' f '' is not equal to 0 and (iii) '' f '' can only be equal to 0 when M represents Cr. A ribbon, a wire or a sheet of this alloy, having a mechanical resonance whose frequencies are between approximately 55 kHz and approximately 60 kHz, this is characterized by a time of reduction in amplitude of the resonance of at least approximately 3 ms .

Description

METALLIC GLASS ALLOYS FOR MECHANICALLY

RESONANT TARGET SURVEILLANCE SYSTEMS

BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

1. Field of the Invention

This invention relates to metallic glass alloys; and more particularly to metallic glass alloys suited for use in mechanically resonant targets of article surveillance systems.

2. Description of the prior art

Numerous article surveillance systems are available in the market today to help identify and/or secure various animate and inanimate objects. Identification of personnel for controlled access to limited areas, and securing articles of merchandise against pilferage are examples of purposes for which such systems are

employed.

An essential component of all surveillance systems is a sensing unit, or "target", that is attached to the object to be detected. Other components of the system include a transmitter and a receiver that are suitably disposed in an "interrogation" zone. When the object carrying the target enters the interrogation zone, the functional part of the target responds to a signal from the transmitter, which response is detected in the receiver. The information contained in the response signal is then processed for actions appropriate to the application: denial of access, triggering of an alarm, and the like.

Surveillance systems that employ detection modes incorporating the fundamental mechanical resonance frequency of the target material are especially

advantageous systems, in that they offer a combination of high detection sensitivity, high operating

reliability, and low operating costs. Examples of such systems are disclosed in U.S. Patent Nos. 4,510,489 and 4,510,490 (hereinafter the '489 and '490 patents).

The target in such systems is a strip, or a

plurality of strips, of known length of a ferromagnetic material, packaged with a harder ferromagnet (material with a higher coercivity) that provides a biasing field to establish peak magnetomechanical coupling. The ferromagnetic material is preferably a metallic glass alloy ribbon, since the efficiency of magnetomechanical coupling in these alloys is very high. The mechanical resonance frequency of the target material is dictated essentially by th'e length of the alloy ribbon and the biasing field strength. When an interrogating signal tuned to this resonance frequency is encountered, the target material responds with a large signal field which is detected by the receiver. The large signal field is attributable to an enhanced magnetic permeability of the target material at the resonance frequency. Various target configurations and systems for interrogation and detection that utilize the above principle have been taught in the '489 and '490 patents.

In one particularly useful system, the target material is excited into oscillations by pulses , or bursts , of signal at its resonance frequency generated by the transmitter. When the exciting pulse is over, the target material will undergo damped oscillations at its resonance frequency, i.e., the target material "rings down" following the termination of the exciting pulse. The receiver "listens" to the response signal during this ring down period. Under this arrangement, the surveillance system is relatively immune to

interferences from various radiated or power line conducted sources and, therefore, the potential for false alarms is essentially eliminated.

A broad range of alloys have been claimed in the '489 and '490 patents as suitable for target material, for the various detection systems disclosed. Other metallic glass alloys bearing high permeabilities are disclosed in U.S. Patent No. 4,152,144; the compositions of the alloys claimed in this patent fall within the broad range referred to above.

However, for the particular detection system described immediately above, metallic glass alloys with long ring down times are highly desirable so that detection efficiencies in the system may be improved. Of these, glassy metal alloys that are economical to produce would offer an additional advantage.

SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

The present invention provides magnetic alloys that are at least about 70% glassy and are characterized by long ring down times in resonance target applications. Such alloys evidence a low rate of damping of resonant oscillations, following the termination of an exciting pulse. Generally stated, the glassy metal alloys of the invention have a composition described by the formula Fe_aNi_bM_cB_dSi_eC_f, where M is one of molybdenum and chromium, "a" - "f" are in atom percent, "a" ranges from about 39 to about 41, "b" ranges from about 37 to about 39, "c" ranges from 0 to about 3, "d" ranges from about 17 to about 19, and "e" and "f" range from 0 to about 2, with the provisos that (i) only one of "c", "e" and "f" can be zero, (ii) "e" cannot be zero if "f" is not zero, and (iii) "f" can be zero only when M is Cr. Ribbons of these alloys, when mechanically resonant at frequencies ranging f rom about 55 kHz to about 60 kHz , evi dence ring down times of at least about 3 ms. Alternatively, ribbons of these alloys, when mechanically resonant at frequencies ranging from about 21 kHz to about 25 kHz, evidence ring down times of at least about 7 ms.

The metallic glasses of this invention are

especially suitable for use as the active elements in targets associated with surveillance systems that employ resonance frequency excitation and detection modes.

Other uses may be found in special magnetic amplifiers, relay cores, ground fault interrupters and the like. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

The invention will be more fully understood and further advantages will become apparent when reference is made to the following detailed description of the preferred embodiments of the invention and the

accompanying drawing, which is a schematic

representation of the exciting signal pulse and the resultant response signal of the target material, the envelopes of these signals being indicated by the thick dashed and thick continuous lines respectively, and wherein the definitions of the peak response voltage, V_r, and the ring down time, t_r, of the target material are also provided.

DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

In accordance with the present invention, there are provided magnetic metallic glass alloys that are

characterized by long ring down times in resonance target applications. These alloys evidence a low rate of damping of resonant oscillations, following the termination of an exciting pulse. Generally stated, the glassy metal alloys of the invention have a composition described by the formula Fe_aNi_bM_cB_dSi_eC_f, where M is one of molybdenum and chromium, "a" - "f" are in atom percent, "a" ranges from about 39 to about 41, "b" ranges from about 37 to about 39, "c" ranges from 0 to about 3, "d" ranges from about 17 to about 19, and "e" and "f" range from 0 to about 2, with the provisos that (i) only one of "c", "e" and "f" can be zero, (ii) "e" cannot be zero if "f" is not zero, and (iii) "f" can be zero only when M is Cr. The purity of the above

compositions is that found in normal commercial

practice. Ribbons of these alloys, at lengths ranging from about 35 mm to about 40 mm exhibit mechanical resonance in a range of frequencies from about 55 kHz to about 60 kHz. When thus resonant, such ribbons evidence ring down times of at least about 3 ms. Alternatively, ribbons of these alloys, at lengths ranging from about 85 mm to about 100 mm exhibit mechanical resonance in a range of frequencies from about 21 kHz to about 25 kHz; and, when so resonant, evidence ring down times of at least about 7 ms.

Ribbons having mechanical resonances in the range from about 55 kHz to about 60 kHz are preferred. Such ribbons are short enough to be used as disposable target materials. In addition, the resonance signals of such ribbons are well separated from the audio and commercial radio frequency ranges.

Most metallic glass alloys that are outside of the scope of this invention typically ring down, after excitation of a resonance in a frequency range from about 55 kHz to about 60 kHz, in times shorter than about 2 ms. These ring down times are unacceptable because of the increased difficulties associated with the detection of a response signal of reasonable

strength within such short time intervals.

There are a few metallic glass alloys outside of the scope of this invention that do show ring down times comparable to those from the alloys of this invention. However, these alloys invariably contain high levels of molybdenum. Aside from the increased raw material costs associated with Mo, the yield of good magnetic ribbon, suitable for use in resonance targets, from casts of alloys with high Mo content tends to be generally poor. The alloys of the present invention offer the advantageous combination of long ring down times and economy in production of usable ribbon.

Apart from the ease in detection facilitated by the longer ring down times in the alloys of this invention, such longer time intervals provide an additional, and advantageous, feature in the detection system in that the receiver may "listen" to the sample response more than once during the same ring down cycle, for

confirmation purposes. Examples of metallic glasses of the invention in elude Fe₄₀Ni₃₈Mo₂B₁₈Si₁C_l, Fe₄₀Ni₃₈Mo₃B₁₈Si_0.5 C_{0 . 5} , Fe₄₀Ni₃₈Mo₁B₁₈Si_1.5C_1.5, Fe₄₀Ni₃₈Mo_2.5B_17.5Si₁C₁,

Fe₄₀Ni₃₈Mo_1.5B_18.5Si₁C₁, Fe₄₀Ni₃₈Mo₃B₁₇Si₁ C ₁ ,

Fe₄₀Ni₃₈Cr₂B₁₈Si₂, and Fe_4.0Ni₃₈B₁₈Si₂C₂, where all numbers are in atomic percent.

The def ini ti on of the ring down time, as used in the context of the description of this invention, is provided in the Figure. This Figure also illustrates, schematically, the interrogation and detection modes of a surveillance system wherein the alloys of this

invention are beneficially employed.

The target material is exposed to a burst of exciting signal of constant amplitude, referred to as the exciting pulse, tuned to the frequency of mechanical resonance, of the target material. The exciting pulse is outlined in thick dashed lines in the Figure, and the peak-to-peak amplitude of the pulse is denoted by the quantity V₀. Although the principle of operation of the surveillance system is not dependent on the shape of the waves comprising the exciting pulse, the wave form of this signal is usually sinusoidal. The target material begins to resonate under this excitation.

The physical principle governing this resonance may be summarized as follows: When a ferromagnetic material is subjected to a magnetizing magnetic field, it experiences a change in length. The fractional change in length, over the original length, of the material is referred to as magnetostriction and denoted by the symbol λ . A positive signature is assigned to λ if an elongation occurs parallel to the magnetizing magnetic field.

When a ribbon of a material with a positive magnetostriction is subjected to a sinusoidally varying external field, applied along its length, the ribbon will undergo periodic changes in length, i.e., the ribbon will be driven into oscillations. The external field may be generated, for example, by a solenoid carrying a sinusoidally varying current. The frequency of the ribbon oscillations will be twice that of the driving field, since the magnetostriction is insensitive to the direction of the driving field at any given instant. In other words, as long as the absolute magnitude of the driving field is non-zero, there will be a change in the ribbon length. Magnetomechanical resonance occurs when the frequency of the driving field is one-half of f_r, the mechanical resonance frequency of the ribbon. The frequency f_r is given by the relation f_r = (1/2L)(E/D)^0.5,

where L is the ribbon length, E is the Young's modulus of the ribbon, and D is the density of the ribbon.

However, if a dc magnetic field, referred to as the biasing field, of suitable strength were imposed on the material concurrently with the ac field, the frequency of ribbon oscillations will be that of the driving ac field. The reason for this is that the material

responds magnetostrictively to the net instantaneous magnetic field acting upon it, and as long as this net field stays non-zero, the material will oscillate about the position where the constant dc field has placed it. Apart from providing a sensitivity to the direction of the instantaneous ac field, the biasing field serves other purposes as well.

Magnetostrictive effects are observed in a

ferromagnetic material only when the magnetization of the material proceeds through domain rotation. No magnetostriction is observed when motion of plane parallel domain walls is the mechanism for

magnetization. The biasing field places the material at, or beyond, the "knee" of hysteresis loop of the material, in which magnetic state the motion of plane parallel walls has been expended, and. further

magnetization of the sample occurs mainly by domain rotation. The efficiency of magnetomechanical response from the material has thus been improved. It is also well understood in the art that a biasing field serves to change the effective value for E in a ferromagnetic material so that t he mechanical resonance frequency of the material may be modified by a suitable choice of strength for the biasing field.

Summarizing the above, a ribbon of a positively magnetostrictive ferromagnetic material, when exposed to a driving ac magnetic field in the presence of a do biasing field, will oscillate at the frequency of the driving ac field, and when this frequency coincides with the mechanical resonance frequency, f_r, of the material, the ribbon will resonate and provide increased response signal amplitudes. In practice, the biasing field is provided by a ferromagnet with a higher coercivity than the target material present in the "target package".

The amplitude of the response signal, or voltage, from the target material increases through the duration of the exciting pulse (as dictated by inertia), and eventually reches a stable, constant value if the exciting pulse lasts for a long enough time. The peak- to-peak height of this stable amplitude is represented as V_r in the Figure. Once the exciting pulse is turned off, the target material "rings down", i.e., the

amplitude of mechanical oscillations in the material and, consequently, the response voltage amplitude reduce to zero over a period of time. In other words, in the absence of an excitation, the motion of the excited target material is damped. The profile of the amplitude of the target response voltage is outlined in thick solid lines in the Figure.

The moment when the exciting pulse is turned off is defined as time t = 0, and the monitoring of the sample response signal commences some time after t = 0, during the ring down period. The ring down time, t_r, of the target material is defined, in the notation of the Figure, as the instant when the peak-to-peak target response voltage is 10% of V_r. As used herein, the term "ring down time" means the time interval during which the amplitude of response from the ribbon is reduced to about 10% of that amplitude extant when an exciting pulse applied to the ribbon is terminated, such time interval commencing at the instant of termination of the exciting pulse.

The ring down time, t_r, is approximately a linear function of the ribbon length, L; the longer the ribbon, the longer is the ring down time. Without being bound by any theory, it is believed that the increase in t_r with increasing L is associated with the lowering of the mechanical resonance frequency in longer ribbons. The same amount of energy takes longer to dissipate at lower frequencies.

The magnitude of the response voltage sensed by a receiver is dependent on how that receiver is disposed within the system. For example, a receiver in a system requiring the insertion of an identification card into a slot will perceive a magnitude for V_r that is different from that perceived by a receiver in a system designed for employment at the exit doors of a department store, even though identical target materials are used in both systems.

There are no requirements on the magnitude of V_r as far as the choice of target material is concerned. It is, however, understood that the value for V_r should be such that the response voltage is of sufficient strength to be detected by the receiver at the instant, during the ring down period, when the receiver "listens" to the target material. Henceforth, for the reasons detailed immediately above, no further reference to V_r will be made in the description of this invention.

Table I lists the values for t_r obtained from various metallic glass alloys that are outside the scope of this invention but which happen to lie within the scope of compositions claimed in the '489 and '490 patents. With the exception of the last named alloy, the ring down times for the alloys in this Table are short. This last named alloy is prone to the

difficulties associated with the casting of alloys with high molybdenum

contents.

It has been found that the combination of the specific elements in the alloys of this invention is necessary for the attainment of long ring down times. Short ring down times result from metallic glass alloys that have any one of these elements absent from their composition. Table II lists the ring down times

obtained from representative metallic glass alloys wherein both Si and C are absent, and Table III contains a similar list derived from alloys with no C. The alloys in these Tables are outside the scope of this invention, and the undesirable ring down times obtained from these alloys are self evident from these Tables.

It is understood from the Tables II and III that the alloy Fe₄₀Ni₃₈Mo₄B₁₈ is unique in terms of its long ring down time. A lowering of the molybdenum content to make the alloy more economical to. produce invariably compromises the ring down time. It will be further understood from the Tables I to III that the long ring down times obtained in the alloys of this invention, with the stated combination of the specific elements,

TABLE III

Ring down times, t_r, obtained from ribbons of metallic glass alloys containing Fe, Ni, Mo, B, and Si, but no C. These ribbons have mechanical resonances in the range of frequencies from about 21 kHz to about 23 kHz.

are much longer than the ring down times of previous target materials.

The following examples are presented to provide a more complete understanding of the invention. The specific techniques, conditions and reported data set forth to illustrate the principles and practice of the invention are exemplary and should not be construed as limiting the scope of the invention. All alloy

compositions described in the examples are nominal compositions.

EXAMPLES Example 1: Fe-Ni-Mo-B-Si-C metallic glasses

1. Sample Preparation

Glassy metal alloys in the Fe-Ni-Mo-B-Si-C family, designated as samples no. 1 to 13 in Table IV, were rapidly quenched from the melt following the techniques taught by Narasimhan in U.S. Patent No. 4,142,571, the disclosure of which is hereby incorporated by reference thereto. All casts were made in a vacuum chamber, using 25 to 100 g melts. The resulting ribbons, typically 25 to 30 μm thick and about 6 mm wide, were determined to be free of significant crystallinity by x-ray

diffractometry using Cu-K_α radiation and differential scanning calorimetry. Each of the alloys was at least 70? glassy and, in many instances, the alloys were more than 90% glassy. Ribbons of these glassy metal alloys were strong, shiny, hard, and ductile. 2. Characterization of response as resonance targets

Ribbon samples, cut to about 38 mm in length, were used for the characterization of ring down times in the various alloys. This ribbon length is appropriate to a mechanical resonance frequency ranging from about 55 kHz to about 60 kHz in these alloys. The biasing dc field and the driving ac field were obtained from two

solenoids that were coaxially configured. The biasing solenoid, about 0.38 m in length, had a turn density of about 3400 turns/m, and the driving solenoid was about 0*3 m long with a turn density of about 1440 turns/m.

The sample was placed on the axis of these solenoids, at about the middle of their length. The sample response was sensed through a pick-up coil comprising between about 100 and 120 turns of wire wound closely around the sample and covering the entire ribbon length. The sample response (pick-up signal) and the driving ac signal were simultaneously monitored on an oscilloscope screen.

An initial estimation of the resonance frequencies of these as-cast ribbon samples was made by fixing the dc biasing field at about 440 A/m and scanning the frequency of a driving ac field of a constant amplitude of about 8 A/m. Peaks in the respective response signals identified the resonance frequencies, which were found to range from about 55 to kHz to about 60 kHz.

Following the above procedure, for any given sample, a pulse was sent through the exciting solenoid, which pulse contained a counted number of waves at the resonance frequency determined earlier as appropriate for the sample. The number of waves, or, equivalently, the duration of the pulse, was adjusted to be sufficient to ensure that the sample response had reached a stable value. Adjustments to the driving frequency, and to the biasing field strength, were also made, when necessary, to obtain a maximum sample response signal. Peak sample responses were obtained with the biasing field ranging from about 400 A/m to about 600 A/m, the driving

frequency ranging from about 56 kHz to about 58 kHz, and the exciting pulse comprising between about 80 and 100 waves.

The traces on the oscilloscope screen were as schematically illustrated in the Figure. As described above, the ring down time was determined as the time required for the sample response amplitude to reduce to 10? of the amplitude at the instant the exciting pulse was turned off. Table IV below lists the ring down times obtained from these 38 mm long as-cast metallic glass ribbons.

Each of the alloys listed in Table IV showed good castability and had a ring down time of at least about 4.2 ms, which is relatively long as compared with alloys outside the scope of the invention. Of the alloys set forth in Table IV, those selected from the group

consisting of sample Nos. 2, 4, 6, 7 and 10, having a ring down time of at least about 5 ms, are preferred.

Annealing of metallic glasses improves their soft ferromagnetic characteristics. Consequently, the ring down times of the metallic glasses of this invention are improved if these glassy alloys are annealed.

Ribbons of selected alloys from the above Table were subject to simple stress relief anneals, i.e., low temperature anneals in the absence of externally imposed magnetic fields. The anneal temperature ranged between about 473 K and 573 K, and the anneal time ranged between about 15 min. and 60 min. Ring down times from these annealed ribbons were found to be longer than in the corresponding as-cast ribbons. The extent of increase was dependent on the chemical composition of the metallic glass and on the anneal conditions for a given alloy. Other anneal conditions which may optimize the magnetomechanical coupling effects available in a metallic glass alloy ribbon, such as those including the presence of external fields applied along the ribbon width, can be employed to improve the resonance target response of the alloys of this invention.

Example 2: Fe-Ni-Cr-B-Si-C metallic glasses

Glassy metal alloys in the Fe-Ni-Cr-B-Si-C system were prepared and characterized as detailed under

Example 1. The ring down times obtained from

representative alloys in this family of metallic glasses are listed in Table V.

Example 3 Numerous casts were made of the alloy Fe₄₀Ni₃₈Mo₂- B₁₈Si₁C₁, which belongs to this invention, and of the alloy Fe₄₀Ni₃₈Mo₄B₁₈, which is outside the scope of this invention, following the procedures detailed under

Example 1. Uniformity in width, and a lack of holes and kinks were used as the criteria for selection of "good" 38 mm long ribbons, usable as target material. About 10 to 15 such ribbons could be derived from a typical cast of the alloy belonging to this invention, whereas the alloy outside the scope of this invention yielded only 4 to 8 such ribbons from a typical cast.

The above stated criteria are good indicators of the potential yield from a large scale cast of metallic glass ribbon. Kinks develop in the ribbons cast in a vacuum chamber when the ribbon, that is still hot, contacts the walls of the vacuum chamber. Under

otherwise similar casting conditions, an alloy that is more efficiently quenched into ribbon will show fewer kinks along the length of the ribbon. Similarly, it is understood that a lack of uniformity in width, and the presence of holes in the cast ribbon, evidence reduced castability of the alloy.

Haying thus described the invention in rather full detail, it will be understood that such detail need not be strictly adhered to but that further changes and modifications may suggest themselves to one skilled in the art, all falling within the scope of the invention as defined by the subjoined claims.

Claims

What is claimed is:

1. A magnetic metallic glass alloy that is at least about 70% glassy, having a composition described by the formula Fe_aNi_bM_cB_dSi_eC_f , where M is one of

molybdenum and chromium, "a" - "f" are in atom percent.

"a" ranges from about 39 to about 41, "b" ranges from about 41, "b" ranges from about 37 to about 39, "c" ranges from 0 to about 3, "d" ranges from about 17 to about 19, and "e" and "f" range from 0 to about 2, with the provisos that (i) only one of "c", "e" and "f" can be zero, (ii) "e: cannot be zero if "f" is not zero, and (iii) "f" can be zero only when M is Cr.

2. An alloy as recited by claim 1, having the form of a strip that exhibits mechanical resonance in a range of frequencies from about 55 kHz to about 60 kHz, and having a ring down time of at least about 3 ms.

3. The magnetic alloy of claim 2, wherein said ring down time is greater than about 5 ms.

4. THe magnetic alloy of claim 2, wherein "e" or "f" ranges between about 0.5 and about 2.

5. The magnetic alloy of claim 2, wherein each of "e" and "f" ranges between about 0.5 and about 1.

6. In an article surveillance system adapted to detect a signal produced by mechanical resonance of a target within an applied magnetic field, the improvement wherein said target comprises at least one strip of

ferromagnetic material that is at least about 70% glassy, and has a composition described by the formula

Fe_aNi_bM_cB_dSi_eC_f, where M is one of molybdenum

and chromium, "a" - "f" are in atom percent, "a" ranges from about 39 to about 41, "b" ranges from about 41, "b" ranges from about 37 to about 39, "c" ranges from 0 to about 3, "d" ranges from about 17 to about 19, and "e" and "f" range from 0 to about 2, with the provisos that (i) only one of "c", "e" and "f" can be zero, (ii) "e"

cannot be zero if "f" is not zero, and (iii) "f" can be zero only when M is Cr.

7. An article surveillance system as recited by claim 9, wherein said strip is selected from the group consisting of ribbon, wire and sheet.

8. An article surveillance system as recited by claim 9 , wherein said strip exhibits mechanical resonance in a range of frequencies from about 55 kHz to about 60 kHz, and has a ring down time of at least about 3 ms.

9. An article surveillance system as recited by claim 8, wherein "e" and "f" range between about 0.5 and about 1.

10. An article surveillance cyctem as recited by claim 6, wherein said strip has a composition selected from the group consisting of Fe₄₀Ni₃₈Mo₂B₁₈Si₁C₁,

Fe₄₀Ni₃₈Mo_1.5B_18.5Si₁C₁, Fe₄₀Ni₃₈Mo₂B₁₈.₅Si₁C_0.5

Fe₄₀Ni₃₈Mo₂B_18.5Si_0.5C₁ and Fe₄₀Ni₃₈Mo₃B₁₇Si₁C₁.