AEDGE: Atomic experiment for dark matter and gravity exploration in space

This article contains a summary of the White Paper submitted in 2019 by the same authors to the ESA Voyage 2050 process, and also mentions a few subsequent scientific and technical developments. The paper was published in EPJ Quantum Technology [1], where we have welcomed as supporting authors participants in the Workshop on Atomic Experiments for Dark Matter and Gravity Exploration held at CERN [2], as well as other interested scientists.

Two of the most important issues in fundamental physics, astrophysics and cosmology are the nature of dark matter (DM) and the exploration of the gravitational wave (GW) spectrum.

Multiple observations from the dynamics of galaxies and clusters to the spectrum of the cosmological microwave background (CMB) radiation measured by ESA’s Planck satellite and other [3] experiments indicate that there is far more DM than conventional matter in the Universe, but its physical composition remains a complete mystery. The two most popular classes of DM scenario invoke either coherent waves of ultra-light bosonic fields, or weakly-interacting massive particles (WIMPs). In the absence so far of any positive indications for WIMPs from accelerator and other laboratory experiments, there is increasing interest in ultra-light bosonic candidates, many of which appear in theories that address other problems in fundamental physics. Such bosons are among the priority targets for AEDGE.

The discovery of GWs by the LIGO [4] and Virgo [5] laser interferometer experiments has opened a new window on the Universe, through which waves over a wide range of frequencies can provide new information about high-energy astrophysics and cosmology. Just as astronomical observations at different wavelengths provide complementary information about electromagnetic sources, measurements of GWs in different frequency bands are complementary and synergistic. In addition to the ongoing LIGO and Virgo experiments at relatively high frequencies \(\gtrsim 10\) Hz, which will soon be joined by the KAGRA [6] detector in Japan and the INDIGO project [7] to build a LIGO detector in India, with the Einstein Telescope (ET) [8, 9] and Cosmic Explorer (CE) [10] experiments being planned for similar frequency ranges, ESA has approved for launch before the period being considered for Voyage 2050 missions the LISA mission, which will be most sensitive at frequencies \(\lesssim 10^{-1}\) Hz, and the Taiji [11] and TianQin [12] missions proposed in China will have similar sensitivity to LISA. AEDGE is optimized for the mid-frequency range between LISA/Taiji/TianQin and LIGO/Virgo/KAGRA/INDIGO/ET/CE ^{Footnote 1}. This range is ideal for probing the formation of the super-massive black holes known to be present in many galaxies. Also, AEDGE’s observations of astrophysical sources will complement those by other GW experiments at lower and higher frequencies, completing sets of measurements from inspiral to merger and ringdown, yielding important synergies as we illustrate below. GWs are the other priority targets for AEDGE.

In addition to these primary scientific objectives, several other potential objectives for cold atom experiments in space are under study. These may include constraining possible variations in fundamental constants, probing dark energy, and probing basic physical principles such as Lorentz invariance and quantum mechanics. Cold quantum gases provide powerful technologies that are already mature for the AEDGE goals, while also developing rapidly [18]. The developments of these technologies can be expected to offer AEDGE more possibilities on the Voyage 2050 time scale. AEDGE is a uniquely interdiscplinary and versatile mission.

The design of AEDGE requires two satellites operating along a single line-of-sight and separated by a long distance. The payload of each satellite will consist of cold atom technology as developed for state-of-the-art atom interferometry and atomic clocks. As two satellites are needed to accomplish its science goals, the AEDGE mission planning costs are estimated to be in the range of an L-class mission. However, in view of the international interest in the AEDGE science goals, the possibility of international cooperation and co-funding of the mission may be investigated.

There are several cold atom projects based on various technologies that are currently under construction, planned or proposed, which address the principal technical challenges and could be considered in a detailed design for a mission proposal and corresponding satellite payload. However, all of these options require the same basic detector and mission configuration outlined above. For the option presented in the White Paper we chose to base our discussion on the concept outlined in in [19,20,21,22], which is currently the most advanced design for a space mission (Fig. 1).

Space-time diagram of the operation of a pair of cold-atom interferometers based on single-photon transitions between the ground state (blue) and the excited state (red dashed). The laser pulses (wavy lines) travelling across the baseline from opposite sides are used to divide, redirect, and recombine the atomic de Broglie waves, yielding interference patterns that are sensitive to the modulation of the light travel time caused by DM or GWs (from [19]). For clarity, the sizes of the atom interferometers are shown on an exaggerated scale

Full size image

This concept links clouds of cold atomic strontium in a pair of satellites in medium earth orbit (MEO) via pulsed continuous-wave lasers that induce the 698 nm atomic clock transition, and detect momentum transfers from the electromagnetic field to the strontium atoms, which act as test masses in a double atom interferometer scheme.

AEDGE will benefit from the experience gained with LISA Pathfinder in free-fall control and LISA itself in operating laser interferometers over large distances. We have identified the following three additional high-level technical requirements that are critical for AEDGE:

• Demonstrate reliable functioning of atom interferometry on a large terrestrial scale \(\gtrsim 100\)m;

• Demonstrate that the design parameters assumed here, such as the LMT enhancement, phase noise control, interrogation time, etc., can be achieved;

• Demonstrate the robustness of cold atom technology in the space environment.

Several terrestrial atom interferometer projects that would serve as demonstrators for different technologies are under construction, planned or proposed.

These include three large-scale prototype projects at the 100-m scale that are funded and currently under construction, namely MAGIS-100 in the US [21], MIGA in France [23], ZAIGA in China [24] and now the first stage of AION in the UK [25], and there are projects to build one or several more km-scale detectors in the US (at the Sanford Underground Research facility, SURF), in Europe (MAGIA-advanced [26, 27], ELGAR [28]) and in China (advanced ZAIGA) that would serve as the ultimate technology readiness demonstrators for AEDGE. In parallel to these large-scale prototype projects, several other cold atom projects are in progress or planned, demonstrating the general readiness of the technology including the scaling of the basic parameters that are required for AEDGE.

Moreover, several cold atom experiments (CACES [29], MAIUS [30], CAL [31]) and underlying optical key technologies (FOKUS [32], KALEXUS [33], JOKARUS [34]) have already demonstrated reliable operation in space, and much more experience will be gained in the coming years.

In addition there are ongoing NASA, Chinese, ESA, German and French projects to conduct cold atom experiments in space, some of which have already provided operational experience with cold atoms in space or microgravity environments. These include the Cold Atom Laboratory (CAL) experiment on the ISS [31], the Chinese Atomic Clock Ensemble in Space (CACES) that has demonstrated in-orbit operation of an atomic clock based on laser-cooled rubidium atoms [29], the Atomic Clock Ensemble in Space (ACES/PHARAO) project led by ESA plans to install ultra-stable atomic cesium clocks on the ISS [35, 36], the Bose-Einstein Condensate and Cold Atom Laboratory (BECCAL) project [37], the ICE experiment that recently reported the all-optical formation of a BEC in the microgravity environment obtained on an Einstein elevator [38], and the ISS Space Optical Clock (I-SOC) project of ESA [39, 40] to use cold strontium atoms in space to compare and synchronize atomic clocks worldwide.

Other proposals for atomic experiments in space to probe fundamental physics include STE-QUEST [41], the Space Atomic Gravity Explorer (SAGE) mission [22], the SagnAc interferometer for Gravitational wavE proposal (also called SAGE) [42] and the Atomic Interferometric Gravitational-Wave Space Observatory (AIGSO) proposed in China [43].

The nature of DM is one of the most important and pressing in particle physics and cosmology, and one of the favoured possibilities is that it is provided by coherent waves of some ultra-light boson. AEDGE will be able to explore large ranges of the parameter spaces of such models, complementing the capabilities of other experiments.

Experience with electromagnetic waves shows the advantages of making astronomical observations in a range of different frequencies, and the same is expected to hold in the era of gravitational astronomy. There are advanced projects to explore the GW spectrum with maximum sensitivities at frequencies \(\gtrsim 10\) Hz and below \(\lesssim 10^{-2}\) Hz, but no approved project has peak sensitivity in the mid-frequency band between them. AEDGE would be ideal for exploiting the scientific opportunities in the mid-frequency band, complementing other experiments and offering synergies with them.

Other possible opportunities for AEDGE in fundamental physics, astrophysics and cosmology have been identified, but not yet explored in detail.

The roadmap towards the AEDGE mission includes the following elements:

• Today to 2025: Prototype 10-m facilities in the US, Europe and China, being extended to \({\mathcal O}(100)\)m;

• 2025 to 2035: scaling of 100-m facilities to km-scale infrastructures;

• These experiments will demonstrate the reliability of cold-atom interferometers capable of achieving or surpassing the technical requirements for AEDGE;

• Operation of LISA will demonstrate the operation of large-scale laser interferometry in space;

• In parallel, a vigorous technology development programme should be set up, pursued and coordinated on a European-wide level in order to maximize efficiency and avoid duplication.

AEDGE is a uniquely interdisciplinary mission that will harness cold atom technologies to address key issues in fundamental physics, astrophysics and cosmology that can be realized within the Voyage 2050 Science Programme of ESA. The worldwide spread of the authors of this article indicate that there could be global interest in participating in this mission.

Following submission of this White Paper, an expanded version with over 100 additional authors was published [1]. This contains a number of refinements of the science arguments, notably a discussion of the synergies to be obtained by including AEDGE in a network of complementary detectors including LISA, LIGO, Virgo et al. The expanded version also stresses the abilities of AEDGE to measure and localize prospective mergers during their early infall phases and predict accurately the times before the mergers themselves, which are of great interest for multi-messenger astronomy. These AEDGE measurements would also provide precise tests of general relativity, e.g., by constraining the gravitino mass [44].

An interesting and exciting new technical development is the possibility of doing data analysis and alert generation on-board using neural networks. On-board data processing can become quite important for overcoming the massive limitations on the speed of data transfer, in order to generate alerts for space or Earth observatories in the context of multi-messenger observations. The proposed solution, making on-board data analysis and processing on space-qualified FPGAs using neural networks, has been already presented to ESA, and its implementation for future missions has been encouraged.

As mentioned in the White Paper, there is an urgent need to raise the Technology Readiness Level (TRL) of cold atom devices for space applications, including but not limited to interferometers. We note in this connection the recent successful observation of Bose-Einstein condensation on the ISS by the BEC Collaboration [45], as well as recent progress in the development of technologies for quantum communication [46].

Finally, we also note that the proposal for the AION ground-based atom interferometer project [25] has recently been approved in the UK, joining the MAGIS project in the US, the MIGA project in France, and the ZAIGA project in China, which had been approved previously.