Alexander J Smith
State University of New York @ Brockport, Anthropology, Faculty Member
- I am an Assistant Professor of Anthropology at SUNY Brockport as an archaeologist of the Western Mediterranean (Balea... moreI am an Assistant Professor of Anthropology at SUNY Brockport as an archaeologist of the Western Mediterranean (Balearic Islands) and Western New York (Finger Lakes Region). I'm the director of Frost Town Archaeology (frosttownarchaeology.com) and a co-director of the Menorca Archaeological Project.edit
Edited By Daniel Fisher-Livne, Michelle May-Curry Archaeological practice is generally not accessible to the public. Despite the popularity of archaeology in film and television, the process of excavation has traditionally been... more
Edited By Daniel Fisher-Livne, Michelle May-Curry
Archaeological practice is generally not accessible to the public. Despite the popularity of archaeology in film and television, the process of excavation has traditionally been closed-off to non-experts. Among those most frequently excluded are young students, local community members, and even descendant groups. In the last 30 years, academic archaeology has tried to push against this through public outreach programs and accessible excavations. Yet many barriers to entry remain for the discipline, including costs of participation for students, requisite credentials that preclude many community members, and a dearth of professional archaeologists willing to engage in public archaeology.
In response to these barriers to entry, Frost Town Archaeology (FTA) was established in 2017 to engage with publics outside of academia and to foster bridges between university structures of learning and local, accessible heritage in New York’s Finger Lakes Region. Frost Town was a small Euro-American logging settlement that witnessed the ecological destruction of the region in the 19th century. The town was abandoned by the early 20th century due to the failure of commercial agriculture after the forests were logged out. Today, the remains of Frost Town are clustered in and around the property of the Cumming Nature Center in South Bristol, New York.
Working closely with the Cumming Nature Center, FTA has developed multiple avenues of public engagement, including archaeological summer camps for ages 9-15 and family archaeology weekends open to the local rural community. Since 2019, the project has offered a biannual, low-cost field school for students at SUNY Brockport where they are shown the basic techniques of archaeological practice, including public pedagogy.
This chapter will discuss the creation of FTA as a project that challenges the exclusionary nature of academic archaeological praxis while building a community of scholars, students, locals, and descendants around the archaeology of Frost Town.
Archaeological practice is generally not accessible to the public. Despite the popularity of archaeology in film and television, the process of excavation has traditionally been closed-off to non-experts. Among those most frequently excluded are young students, local community members, and even descendant groups. In the last 30 years, academic archaeology has tried to push against this through public outreach programs and accessible excavations. Yet many barriers to entry remain for the discipline, including costs of participation for students, requisite credentials that preclude many community members, and a dearth of professional archaeologists willing to engage in public archaeology.
In response to these barriers to entry, Frost Town Archaeology (FTA) was established in 2017 to engage with publics outside of academia and to foster bridges between university structures of learning and local, accessible heritage in New York’s Finger Lakes Region. Frost Town was a small Euro-American logging settlement that witnessed the ecological destruction of the region in the 19th century. The town was abandoned by the early 20th century due to the failure of commercial agriculture after the forests were logged out. Today, the remains of Frost Town are clustered in and around the property of the Cumming Nature Center in South Bristol, New York.
Working closely with the Cumming Nature Center, FTA has developed multiple avenues of public engagement, including archaeological summer camps for ages 9-15 and family archaeology weekends open to the local rural community. Since 2019, the project has offered a biannual, low-cost field school for students at SUNY Brockport where they are shown the basic techniques of archaeological practice, including public pedagogy.
This chapter will discuss the creation of FTA as a project that challenges the exclusionary nature of academic archaeological praxis while building a community of scholars, students, locals, and descendants around the archaeology of Frost Town.
Research Interests:
Over the past 20 years, Menorcan megalithic houses dating to the Late Talayotic Culture (roughly the end of the 6th to 1st centuries BCE) have been subject to multiple excavation campaigns, resulting in a wealth of information regarding... more
Over the past 20 years, Menorcan megalithic houses dating to the Late Talayotic Culture (roughly the end of the 6th to 1st centuries BCE) have been subject to multiple excavation campaigns, resulting in a wealth of information regarding Late Iron Age domestic architecture and practices. Exhibiting both a circular ground plan and megalithic construction methods, the material culture in many of these structures can be dated to as late as the 1st centuries BCE or CE.
This study will argue that in the face of increased exposure to external influences indigenous elements within these household structures were emphasized or hyperbolized, pointing to a sense of indigenous identity or indigeneity among the islanders. Such elements included circular ground plans, hypostyle halls, and megalithic roof supports that referenced cult sites, all of which were associated with large, elite dwellings. During this period much of Menorca’s extra-island interaction stemmed from Carthaginian and Roman contacts as the island was gradually exposed to and integrated into the networks of these global powers. As a whole, the domestic evidence showcases a culture that was persistent during a time of change in the western Mediterranean, but also self-referential and creative, emphasizing its local traditions while utilizing foreign material culture. In considering themes of globalization and the local experience through the lens of Late Talayotic Menorca, this study will conclude by discussing the concept of indigeneity from an anthropological perspective and its potential application to Mediterranean archaeology in the Late Iron Age.
This study will argue that in the face of increased exposure to external influences indigenous elements within these household structures were emphasized or hyperbolized, pointing to a sense of indigenous identity or indigeneity among the islanders. Such elements included circular ground plans, hypostyle halls, and megalithic roof supports that referenced cult sites, all of which were associated with large, elite dwellings. During this period much of Menorca’s extra-island interaction stemmed from Carthaginian and Roman contacts as the island was gradually exposed to and integrated into the networks of these global powers. As a whole, the domestic evidence showcases a culture that was persistent during a time of change in the western Mediterranean, but also self-referential and creative, emphasizing its local traditions while utilizing foreign material culture. In considering themes of globalization and the local experience through the lens of Late Talayotic Menorca, this study will conclude by discussing the concept of indigeneity from an anthropological perspective and its potential application to Mediterranean archaeology in the Late Iron Age.
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
Building on Richard Bradley’s notion of the ‘afterlife of monuments’ (1987) and fueled by chance and survey finds of Classical and Roman pottery in and around nuraghi and talayots, it has been noted for some time that the great... more
Building on Richard Bradley’s notion of the ‘afterlife of monuments’ (1987) and fueled by chance and survey finds of Classical and Roman pottery in and around nuraghi and talayots, it has been noted for some time that the great prehistoric monuments of the West Mediterranean islands continued to be occupied well beyond prehistory; in one way or another, they may have remained in use until the present day, albeit it more often as a field shelter than a monumental dwelling (e.g. Pala 1990; Blake 1998).
Ongoing fieldwork has begun to demonstrate that both the chronologies and trajectories of building, use, adaptation, reconfiguration, abandonment, and reoccupation of these monuments were not only quite complex but also very different across the various islands and among the various types of monuments. This emerging observation is important in our view, because it belies any easy equation between nuraghi, torri, talayots, tombe di giganti, taulas and navetas beyond the evident similarities of size and building materials.
Variability and difference need not impede comparison, however, and in this contribution we explore how local inhabitants and foreign settlers on Sardinia, Mallorca and Menorca organized their lives and encounters in and around nuraghi and talayots. Drawing on recent evidence from key sites like nuraghe S’Urachi and Torre d’en Galmes, we examine the physical and symbolic roles that these monuments continued to play, albeit in very different ways, in the daily lives of these islanders throughout much of the first millennium BCE.
Blake, E.
1998 Sardinia's nuraghi: four millennia of becoming. World Archaeology 30.1: 59-71.
Bradley, R.
1987 Time regained - the creation of continuity. Journal of the British Archaeological Association 140: 1-17.
Pala, P.
1990 Osservazioni preliminari per uno studio della riutilizzazione dei nuraghi in epoca romana. In A. Mastino (ed.), L'Africa Romana VII. Atti del 7o Convegno di Studio, Sassari, 15-17 dicembre 1989. 549-56. Sassari: Edizioni Gallizzi.
Ongoing fieldwork has begun to demonstrate that both the chronologies and trajectories of building, use, adaptation, reconfiguration, abandonment, and reoccupation of these monuments were not only quite complex but also very different across the various islands and among the various types of monuments. This emerging observation is important in our view, because it belies any easy equation between nuraghi, torri, talayots, tombe di giganti, taulas and navetas beyond the evident similarities of size and building materials.
Variability and difference need not impede comparison, however, and in this contribution we explore how local inhabitants and foreign settlers on Sardinia, Mallorca and Menorca organized their lives and encounters in and around nuraghi and talayots. Drawing on recent evidence from key sites like nuraghe S’Urachi and Torre d’en Galmes, we examine the physical and symbolic roles that these monuments continued to play, albeit in very different ways, in the daily lives of these islanders throughout much of the first millennium BCE.
Blake, E.
1998 Sardinia's nuraghi: four millennia of becoming. World Archaeology 30.1: 59-71.
Bradley, R.
1987 Time regained - the creation of continuity. Journal of the British Archaeological Association 140: 1-17.
Pala, P.
1990 Osservazioni preliminari per uno studio della riutilizzazione dei nuraghi in epoca romana. In A. Mastino (ed.), L'Africa Romana VII. Atti del 7o Convegno di Studio, Sassari, 15-17 dicembre 1989. 549-56. Sassari: Edizioni Gallizzi.
Research Interests:
Undergraduate Senior Honors Thesis for Brandeis University's Department of Classical Studies, 2009.
Research Interests:
Society for American Archaeology 2019 The Cumming Nature Center of Naples, New York contains a significant portion of the remains of a 19 th century logging settlement, once known as Frost Town. The site, home to many Euro-American... more
Society for American Archaeology 2019 The Cumming Nature Center of Naples, New York contains a significant portion of the remains of a 19 th century logging settlement, once known as Frost Town. The site, home to many Euro-American settlers throughout the 19 th century, saw the rapid rise of a logging-based economy associated with the growing industrialization of Western New York, following the construction of the Erie Canal. Frost Town subsequently saw the decline of this industry as environmental circumstances changed and the old-growth forests disappeared due to over-logging. This led to some failed attempts at farming, followed by the eventual abandonment of the site in the early 20 th century. The Cumming Nature Center is part of the Rochester Museum and Science Center (RMSC). In recent years, the center has increased its efforts to engage with the museum’s public via Family Archaeology Weekends and collaborations with the College at Brockport. This poster will showcase the work being done at Frost Town by undergraduate archaeology majors, local archaeology enthusiasts and area children during our outreach events. This poster and project will add to the continuing conversations on how best to responsibly integrate students and the public into archaeological excavations at Frost Town and beyond.
Research Interests:
The nuraghe of S’Urachi is a Bronze Age stone monument that has served a central place in the landscape of west-Central Sardinia for millennia. Since 2013, the archaeological site has been the subject of an ongoing investigation into the... more
The nuraghe of S’Urachi is a Bronze Age stone monument that has served a central place in the landscape of west-Central Sardinia for millennia. Since 2013, the archaeological site has been the subject of an ongoing investigation into the daily lives of local inhabitants living around the nuraghe from the Bronze Age through the Roman period. The project—a joint effort of an international team funded by Brown Universtiy and the Comune di San Vero Milis—has investigated the immediate surroundings of S’Urachi through micro-topographical, soil, and geophysical survey as well as targeted excavation. In complement to this research, we carried out intensive pedestrian survey in 2015 to investigate the long-term trends in occupation and use of the site. The unplowed landscape with heavy vegetation required an innovative, more intrusive survey approach than is traditionally used in Mediterranean survey. The results shed light on trends of occupation in the late Iron Age and Roman periods and patterns of garbage deposition from the Early Modern period onwards. This poster presents our preliminary results, highlighting the methodology developed for coping with the environmental challenges at S’Urachi and the future plans for prospection in and around the site.
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
Society for American Archaeology 2019 The Cumming Nature Center of Naples, New York contains a significant portion of the remains of a 19 th century logging settlement, once known as Frost Town. The site, home to many Euro-American... more
Society for American Archaeology 2019
The Cumming Nature Center of Naples, New York contains a significant portion of the remains of a 19 th century logging settlement, once known as Frost Town. The site, home to many Euro-American settlers throughout the 19 th century, saw the rapid rise of a logging-based economy associated with the growing industrialization of Western New York, following the construction of the Erie Canal. Frost Town subsequently saw the decline of this industry as environmental circumstances changed and the old-growth forests disappeared due to over-logging. This led to some failed attempts at farming, followed by the eventual abandonment of the site in the early 20 th century.
The Cumming Nature Center is part of the Rochester Museum and Science Center (RMSC). In recent years, the center has increased its efforts to engage with the museum’s public via Family Archaeology Weekends and collaborations with the College at Brockport. This poster will showcase the work being done at Frost Town by undergraduate archaeology majors, local archaeology enthusiasts and area children during our outreach events. This poster and project will add to the continuing conversations on how best to responsibly integrate students and the public into archaeological excavations at Frost Town and beyond.
The Cumming Nature Center of Naples, New York contains a significant portion of the remains of a 19 th century logging settlement, once known as Frost Town. The site, home to many Euro-American settlers throughout the 19 th century, saw the rapid rise of a logging-based economy associated with the growing industrialization of Western New York, following the construction of the Erie Canal. Frost Town subsequently saw the decline of this industry as environmental circumstances changed and the old-growth forests disappeared due to over-logging. This led to some failed attempts at farming, followed by the eventual abandonment of the site in the early 20 th century.
The Cumming Nature Center is part of the Rochester Museum and Science Center (RMSC). In recent years, the center has increased its efforts to engage with the museum’s public via Family Archaeology Weekends and collaborations with the College at Brockport. This poster will showcase the work being done at Frost Town by undergraduate archaeology majors, local archaeology enthusiasts and area children during our outreach events. This poster and project will add to the continuing conversations on how best to responsibly integrate students and the public into archaeological excavations at Frost Town and beyond.
Isla del Rey is a small islet located in the harbor of Mahón on Menorca. The island is well known for a historical naval hospital as well as a Paleochristian basilica, roughly dating to the late sixth to early seventh centuries C.E. The... more
Isla del Rey is a small islet located in the harbor of Mahón on Menorca. The island is well known for a historical naval hospital as well as a Paleochristian basilica, roughly dating to the late sixth to early seventh centuries C.E. The hospital is now home to a museum, primarily highlighting the British occupation and Spanish possession of the island, which was used as a hospital until the 1960s. Although much of the island is covered with military buildings or is a cordoned off archaeological zone surrounding the basilica, approximately one third of the islet does not have any standing structures, nor does it have any particular historical or archaeological evidence attributed to it.
In 2013, the Boston University Field School in Archaeology and Heritage Management began investigating this northern third of the island. The resulting survey was a collaborative effort that brought together students from Boston University and Brown University who worked along with the staff of the Amics de la l’Illa del l’Hospital. With a mix of prehistoric, Roman, and historical archaeological experience, our team began to produce a diachronic picture of the previously unexplored portion of the island through systematic analysis. This poster will showcase the survey project’s methodology, analytical techniques and some results from the 2013 season, and will look ahead toward Boston University’s 2014 operations.
In 2013, the Boston University Field School in Archaeology and Heritage Management began investigating this northern third of the island. The resulting survey was a collaborative effort that brought together students from Boston University and Brown University who worked along with the staff of the Amics de la l’Illa del l’Hospital. With a mix of prehistoric, Roman, and historical archaeological experience, our team began to produce a diachronic picture of the previously unexplored portion of the island through systematic analysis. This poster will showcase the survey project’s methodology, analytical techniques and some results from the 2013 season, and will look ahead toward Boston University’s 2014 operations.
Research Interests:
The Iberian Peninsula is rich in archaeological remains of global importance from Neanderthal tools to Phoenician ports and from Roman arches to mass graves from the Spanish Civil War. In spite of this, the archaeology of Iberia is little... more
The Iberian Peninsula is rich in archaeological remains of global importance from Neanderthal tools to Phoenician ports and from Roman arches to mass graves from the Spanish Civil War. In spite of this, the archaeology of Iberia is little studied outside of the peninsula itself. Political and linguistic factors have resulted in relatively isolated academic and archaeological communities in Spain and Portugal in stark contrast to other Mediterranean nations, such as Italy and Greece, with long histories of international collaboration. In recent decades, however, the involvement of international scholars in cooperative projects in Iberia has increased notably; indeed, Brown University has been a part of that development, with its recently concluded fieldwork project at the Iron Age and Roman site of Tongobriga in northwest Portugal. Nonetheless, there remain some stubborn divisions amongst Iberian archaeologists that hinder progress — for example, about the most appropriate types of archaeological method and theory, or between differing traditions in prehistoric and Classical archaeology. The time is ripe for conversation and debate about such issues. In March 2014, Linda Gosner and Alexander Smith (Joukowsky Institute for Archaeology and the Ancient World) will host a three-day conference and seminar series called “Archaeology of Iberia: State of the Field.” The event will provide a forum for international scholars across disciplines, temporal foci, and theoretical schools to discuss ongoing obstacles and future directions in the archaeology of this region.
Research Interests:
Cumberlandite is an iron ore located primarily in Cumberland, Rhode Island. During the Colonial era, the ore became a significant source of raw iron in New England. Rich in titanium, cumberlandite presents a unique opportunity to source... more
Cumberlandite is an iron ore located primarily in Cumberland, Rhode Island. During the Colonial era, the ore became a significant source of raw iron in New England. Rich in titanium, cumberlandite presents a unique opportunity to source excavated ore samples, byproducts, and artifacts. Using both XRF and SEM-EDS analyses, we have established a basic fingerprint of cumberlandite to analyze a set of samples from two early iron manufacturing sites in Rhode Island. Due to the singular concentration of the ore in Cumberland, these analyses may highlight patterns of iron distribution within Rhode Island, and with future application, throughout New England.
Research Interests:
"“The mode of being of the new intellectual can no longer exist in eloquence, which is an exterior and momentary mover of feelings and passions, but in active participation in practical life, as constructor, organizer, ‘permanent... more
"“The mode of being of the new intellectual can no longer exist in eloquence, which is an exterior and momentary mover of feelings and passions, but in active participation in practical life, as constructor, organizer, ‘permanent persuader’ and not just a simple orator.” -Antonio Gramsci (1971)
Archaeology is engrained in the socio-political fabric of modern nation-states. Its consequences are frequently subtle, however, when archaeology becomes the focus of contested claims of nationality, social identity, or possession, it takes on a significance beyond the bounds of academia. Under such circumstances, academics are often tempted to retreat to the sidelines and claim an apolitical objectivity in presenting their research. This TAG session will examine the intersection of archaeology and politics within divergent political ‘truth-claims.’ It will also seek to address the responsibility of the archaeologist to recognize the wider political implications of their work and the ethical demands created by such engagement."
Archaeology is engrained in the socio-political fabric of modern nation-states. Its consequences are frequently subtle, however, when archaeology becomes the focus of contested claims of nationality, social identity, or possession, it takes on a significance beyond the bounds of academia. Under such circumstances, academics are often tempted to retreat to the sidelines and claim an apolitical objectivity in presenting their research. This TAG session will examine the intersection of archaeology and politics within divergent political ‘truth-claims.’ It will also seek to address the responsibility of the archaeologist to recognize the wider political implications of their work and the ethical demands created by such engagement."
Book Review of "Insularity and Identity in the Roman Mediterranean" Edited by Anna Kouremenos, Oxbow: 2018.
https://www.ajaonline.org/book-review/3847
https://www.ajaonline.org/book-review/3847