- Dr Paul J. Vardanega joined the University of Bristol in September 2013 as a Lecturer in Civil Engineering. He then s... moreDr Paul J. Vardanega joined the University of Bristol in September 2013 as a Lecturer in Civil Engineering. He then served as a Senior Lecturer in Civil Engineering from August 2018 to July 2021 at the same institution. Since August 2021 he has been an Associate Professor in Civil Engineering also at the University of Bristol.edit
Visual inspection remains key for assessing the condition of bridges and hence assisting with planning and maintenance activities. There have been many efforts to improve or supplement visual inspection processes using new sensing... more
Visual inspection remains key for assessing the condition of bridges and hence assisting with planning and
maintenance activities. There have been many efforts to improve or supplement visual inspection processes using new sensing technologies and data capture methods to usher in an era of ‘smart bridges’ or ‘smart infrastructure’. One method to improve data capture is a ‘remote inspection’ where inspectors use digital photographs of a bridge to identify and grade structural defects to the standard of a ‘general inspection’. In this paper, survey data are presented to help formulate a preliminary assessment of the potential for engineers to implement this possible evolution of the visual inspection process. A potential schema for remote visual inspections is developed and presented as a conceptual web application. The focus on the development of the schema includes the need for ease of use by inspectors and integration of collected digital data into bridge management systems. The suggested platform is seen as a transitional method to aid in the long-term implementation of further automation of the inspection process. The system architecture is provided along with possible technologies that may support or enhance it, as well as a discussion of the potential barriers to implementation.
maintenance activities. There have been many efforts to improve or supplement visual inspection processes using new sensing technologies and data capture methods to usher in an era of ‘smart bridges’ or ‘smart infrastructure’. One method to improve data capture is a ‘remote inspection’ where inspectors use digital photographs of a bridge to identify and grade structural defects to the standard of a ‘general inspection’. In this paper, survey data are presented to help formulate a preliminary assessment of the potential for engineers to implement this possible evolution of the visual inspection process. A potential schema for remote visual inspections is developed and presented as a conceptual web application. The focus on the development of the schema includes the need for ease of use by inspectors and integration of collected digital data into bridge management systems. The suggested platform is seen as a transitional method to aid in the long-term implementation of further automation of the inspection process. The system architecture is provided along with possible technologies that may support or enhance it, as well as a discussion of the potential barriers to implementation.
Research Interests:
This paper presents laboratory data from tests on four fine-grained soils: reconstituted Kaolinite, destructured Bothkennar clay, reconstituted Bothkennar clay, and reconstituted Gault clay. The soil samples were conditioned in an... more
This paper presents laboratory data from tests on four fine-grained soils: reconstituted Kaolinite, destructured Bothkennar clay, reconstituted Bothkennar clay, and reconstituted Gault clay. The soil samples were conditioned in an oedometer cell while being subjected to varying numbers of freezing and thawing cycles. The influence of freeze-thaw cycles on key soil parameters, including the hydraulic conductivity, Atterberg limits, compression and swelling index was studied. The experimental results were then compared with the analysis of a previously published database of hydraulic conductivity measurements on fine-grained soils called FG/KSAT-1358. The paper demonstrates that while multiple cycles of freezing and thawing affect some of the studied soil parameters, such as the Atterberg limits and the compression characteristics, the effects on the hydraulic conductivity transformation model parameters, linking the water content ratio to hydraulic conductivity are less apparent. The results are useful for geotechnical and pavement engineers when making assessments of freeze-thaw effects on subgrade materials in cold regions.
Research Interests:
The UK has a large stock of highway bridges that is ageing and deteriorating. This paper presents the results of a programme of work to understand the reliability of the visual inspection data that are used to inform the management of... more
The UK has a large stock of highway bridges that is ageing and deteriorating. This paper presents the results of a programme of work to understand the reliability of the visual inspection data that are used to inform the management of Highways England’s structures. This paper presents a data set comprising evidence collected during the presence of research team inspectors at the principal inspection and/or testing of 200 bridges randomly sampled from Highways England’s bridge network, coupled with asset-management data for Highways England’s entire bridge stock. Recommendations are made for future improvements in visual inspection practice and use of such data in future asset-management efforts.
Research Interests:
Seismic hazard assessment often relies on static piezocone penetration tests (CPTu) to estimate the cyclic resistance ratio (CRR) and for the evaluation of in situ soil behavior. This article presents CPTu data acquired in the Kathmandu... more
Seismic hazard assessment often relies on static piezocone penetration tests (CPTu) to estimate the cyclic resistance ratio (CRR) and for the evaluation of in situ soil behavior. This article presents CPTu data acquired in the Kathmandu valley sediments and makes use of established CPTu interpretation procedures to assess the soil in situ properties. Up to this point predominantly SPT data and limited shear wave velocity measurements have been relied upon to assess the variability and seismic response of soil deposits underlying Kathmandu. This article provides 1) additional data to add to the existing SAFER/GEO-591 database, 2) new shear-wave velocity measurements, and 3) initial estimates of CRR at the sites visited. Based on the work presented in this article, it is concluded that a more detailed methodology is needed for liquefaction assessment mainly due to the presence of saturated silts in the valley.
Research Interests:
Geostatistical methods are valuable to better understand the spatial distribution of geotechnical parameters at regional scale and to optimize the locations of future ground investigations. This article investigates the use of the kriging... more
Geostatistical methods are valuable to better understand the spatial distribution of geotechnical parameters at regional scale and to optimize the locations of future ground investigations. This article investigates the use of the kriging interpolation method to extend the knowledge of a specific geotechnical property from a few sites to a broader geographical area with a focus on the Kathmandu valley (Nepal). A Bayesian form of kriging is proposed in this article. The estimation of the shear wave velocity in the uppermost 30 m of soil (V S30) in the Kathmandu valley is examined. Slope-based V S30 estimates from the United States Geological Survey are used as prior information, and 15 V S30 measurements are used as more precise data. Considering the limited number of high-quality V S30 measurements available in the valley, it is shown that the Bayesian scheme can lead to a more robust estimation of V S30 than that obtained with the ordinary kriging approach. A methodology for conditioning prior low-precision data to the measurements is also presented.
Research Interests:
A new database called AC/k-1624 containing over 1600 measurements of saturated hydraulic conductivity of asphalt concrete has been assembled and analysed. AC/k-1624 was used to investigate the effect of the grading entropy parameters on... more
A new database called AC/k-1624 containing over 1600 measurements of saturated hydraulic conductivity of asphalt concrete has been assembled and analysed. AC/k-1624 was used to investigate the effect of the grading entropy parameters on saturated hydraulic conductivity. A new prediction model comprising both air voids and grading entropy is presented. The database analysis using different predictors of asphalt hydraulic conductivity reveals that the gradation does affect the hydraulic conductivity, but the air void level is necessary to make reasonable a-priori assessments of hydraulic conductivity for asphalt concrete. The new empirical model is shown to have a good predictive capacity for hydraulic conductivity fitting more securely at higher values with more scatter observed at lower values. The effects of test type, gradation classification and Nominal Maximum Aggregate Size (NMAS) are also studied, revealing in general relatively modest influences on the computed regression coefficients.
Research Interests:
During construction, the mobilisation of undrained shear strength must be limited to avoid soil failure. Soil strains must be controlled to avoid compromising structural serviceability. To assess foundation performance by strength... more
During construction, the mobilisation of undrained shear strength must be limited to avoid soil failure. Soil strains must be controlled to avoid compromising structural serviceability. To assess foundation performance by strength mobilisation, an understanding of soil strains at various levels of strength mobilisation is required. In practice, ground investigation data is often limited, and assessment of the expected variation of stress-strain and undrained shear strength is improved with empirical correlations calibrated with a database. The new database RFG/TXCU-278 contains data of 278 consolidated undrained triaxial tests on reconstituted fine-grained soil samples compiled from the literature. Analysis of the database to evaluate the variability of undrained strength ratio (cu /σ'v0) and a reference shear strain with shear mode is undertaken in this paper. The new database provides evidence that shear strain (like undrained shear strength) is sensitive to the consolidation (isotropic or K0) and shear mode (triaxial compression or extension) applied in the test. For the materials included in the database, the strength mobilisation parameters obtained from a triaxial compression test can be used to predict the corresponding triaxial extension parameters to a reasonable accuracy.
Research Interests:
This paper presents experimental investigations on the feasibility of using a sand-rubber deformable granular layer as a low-cost seismic isolation strategy for developing countries. The mechanical characteristics of a potential failure... more
This paper presents experimental investigations on the feasibility of using a sand-rubber deformable granular layer as a low-cost seismic isolation strategy for developing countries. The mechanical characteristics of a potential failure mechanism inside the sand-rubber layer are investigated. Direct shear testing is performed to quantify the angle of friction of three different sand-rubber mixtures subjected to different vertical stress levels. The experimentally derived mechanical characteristics are compared to the corresponding values for pure rubber and pure sand samples. The frictional characteristics of sliding between a sand-rubber layer and a timber interface are identified. Direct shear testing is performed to quantify the quasi-static friction of the same sand-rubber mixtures against a timber interface, that is part of the foundation casting, subjected to alternative vertical stresses. The effect of the shear rate and the saturation of the sand-rubber mixture on the aforementioned mechanical characteristics is presented. A uniaxial shaking table experimental setup is used for the investigation of the dynamics of a rigid sliding block and the quantification of the kinetic friction of different sliding interfaces against two different sand-rubber mixtures for two different sand-rubber layer heights. The rigid sliding block designed to slide against the sand-rubber layer is subjected to both a harmonic ramp loading and earthquake ground motion excitation. The design outcome of this static and dynamic experimental investigation is the determination of the optimum grain size ratio and the height of the sand-rubber layer, that corresponds to the lower (and more favourable from a seismic isolation view point) friction coefficient between the sand-rubber layer and the foundation. The quantification of these fundamental parameters paves the way for a holistic design of a response modification strategy for mitigating seismic damage in developing countries.
Research Interests:
This paper reports the results of 120 low-cycle fatigue tests on steel reinforcing bars with varying slenderness ratios at varying strain amplitudes. The failure modes of the fractured bars were investigated through analysis of the... more
This paper reports the results of 120 low-cycle fatigue tests on steel reinforcing bars with varying slenderness ratios at varying strain amplitudes. The failure modes of the fractured bars were investigated through analysis of the fracture mechanisms of bars. The results of experimental testing were used to update empirical models of low-cycle fatigue life for such bars. The newly improved empirical models were then incorporated into a recently developed constitutive material model that accounts for bar buckling and fatigue. The experimental results show that the size effect is significant for short steel reinforcing bars where there is no buckling. The results also show that as the slenderness ratio of the steel reinforcing bars increases, the influence of the bar diameter on low-cycle fatigue reduces.
Research Interests:
Asset management organisations collect large quantities of data on the inventory, condition and maintenance of their bridge structures. A key objective in the collection of these asset data is that these can be processed into useful... more
Asset management organisations collect large quantities of data on the inventory, condition and maintenance of their bridge structures. A key objective in the collection of these asset data is that these can be processed into useful information that can inform best practice for the design of new structures and the management of existing stocks. As a leading bridge asset owner, Highways England, UK, is applying insights from mining of its asset data to contribute to continual improvement in the management of structures and its understanding of their performance. This paper presents the application of modern data science tools and optimal decision tree learning to Highways England's asset information database comprising bridge inventory, inspection records and historic and current defects for its stock of thousands of bridges. Trends are observed in the factors affecting the current condition of bridges and their rate of deterioration. Optimal decision trees are used to identify the most influential factors in the performance of bridge structures and present complex multifactor trends in a format readily digested by managers and decision makers, to inform standards and policy.
The Clifton Suspension Bridge is an emblematic structure in Bristol, UK. In this paper, a rapid deployment of a structural health monitoring (SHM) system for short-term monitoring is described. The system, deployed in a single day,... more
The Clifton Suspension Bridge is an emblematic structure in Bristol, UK. In this paper, a rapid deployment of a structural health monitoring (SHM) system for short-term monitoring is described. The system, deployed in a single day, integrates wireless SHM and open-source data management systems to gather valuable information about the bridge use (loading). The deployed system can be used to inform structural response models as well as studies for traffic engineering purposes. The use of open-source software was critical to the successful deployment.
Research Interests:
Among current approaches for fatigue strength assessment, the effective notch stress method is widely employed by practising engineers designing welded joints. This is particularly important in the situation where the nominal stress and... more
Among current approaches for fatigue strength assessment, the effective notch stress method is widely employed by practising engineers designing welded joints. This is particularly important in the situation where the nominal stress and structural stress cannot be easily quantified. In this paper, the applicability of the so called effective notch stress approach on large-size T-joints in truss bridges is investigated through a comprehensive experimental programme supported by numerical analysis. A series of large-scale fatigue tests on prototype large-size T-joints with cope holes were conducted. These types of joints are normally used in fully welded truss bridges. Furthermore , a simple parametric study was conducted using finite element analysis to investigate the effect of plate thickness and cope-hole radius on effective notch stress. Comparison of the results with commonly used design guidance documents reveals that the effective notch stress approach provides a conservative estimate of the fatigue strength of the specimens tested in this experimental programme.
Research Interests:
This paper begins with an extensive review of the literature covering the development of design rules for geostructural systems, beginning with traditional global safety factors and developing through partial factors for loads and... more
This paper begins with an extensive review of the literature covering the development of design rules for geostructural systems, beginning with traditional global safety factors and developing through partial factors for loads and resistances, and then considering the use of mobilization factors to limit soil strains. The paper then aims to distinguish two possible functions for geotechnical factors: to compensate for the uncertainty regarding soil strength, and to limit soil deformations that could compromise the associated structure before the soil strength can be fully mobilized, whatever it is. At present, design procedures generally conflate and confuse ultimate limit state (ULS) checks and serviceability limit state (SLS) deformation checks. Furthermore, most geotechnical engineers wrongly associate ULS with soil failure rather than with structural failure. The paper addresses this fundamental confusion by advocating mobilizable strength design (MSD), which is based on assumed soil-structure deformation mechanisms rather than soil failure mechanisms. It is argued that designs using MSD can guard against damaging structural deformations, either small deformations giving SLS or large structural deformations that must be regarded as ULS even though the associated soil strength may not yet be fully mobilized. This distinction effectively challenges much of the previous literature on limit state design principles for geotechnical applications, even when probabilistic approaches have been proposed. Nevertheless, the paper is informed by the concepts and techniques of decision making under uncertainty, and the paper concludes by considering whether MSD can also be placed in a reliability framework.
Research Interests:
The liquid limit is defined as the point at which a clay's behaviour changes from liquid to plastic. This transition is in reality gradual, rather than sudden. The definition of when this transition has been crossed must therefore be... more
The liquid limit is defined as the point at which a clay's behaviour changes from liquid to plastic. This transition is in reality gradual, rather than sudden. The definition of when this transition has been crossed must therefore be determined based on some arbitrary criterion. The percussion cup method of determining liquid limit in the manner suggested by Atterberg and subsequently standardised by Casagrande determines liquid limit as the water content at which 25 standard blows are required to cause closure of a standard groove. In order to speed up the determination of the liquid limit, a single-point method is defined in ASTM D4318, and in many other codes, to interpret liquid limit from groove closure at a different numbers of blows by assuming a relationship between water content and the number of blows required for groove closure. These methods differ considerably between different codes of practice currently in use worldwide. This paper examines the procedures for single-point determination of the liquid limit and offers some fundamental explanations that underpin the applicability of these procedures. This paper demonstrates that the variation in single-point liquid limit procedures suggested by various codes of practice can be attributed to the variability of liquid limit devices, rather than to variation in the soils being tested.
Research Interests:
Recent research has clarified the sequence of ground deformation mechanisms that manifest themselves when excavations are made in soft ground. Furthermore, a new framework to describe the deformability of clays in the working stress range... more
Recent research has clarified the sequence of ground deformation mechanisms that manifest themselves when excavations are made in soft ground. Furthermore, a new framework to describe the deformability of clays in the working stress range has been devised using a large database of previously published soil tests. This paper aims to capitalize on these advances, by analyzing an expanded database of ground movements associated with braced excavations in Shanghai. It is shown that conventional design charts fail to take account either of the characteristics of soil deformability or the relevant deformation mechanisms, and therefore introduce significant scatter. A new method of presentation is found which provides a set of design charts that clarify the influence of soil deformability, wall stiffness, and the geometry of the excavation in relation to the depth of soft ground.
Research Interests:
A database of 641 fall cone tests on 101 soil samples from twelve countries has been analysed to determine the best mathematical relationship linking undrained shear strength with liquidity index. From the database, it is shown that the... more
A database of 641 fall cone tests on 101 soil samples from twelve countries has been analysed to determine the best mathematical relationship linking undrained shear strength with liquidity index. From the database, it is shown that the use of a linear relationship linking liquidity index and the logarithm of undrained shear strength that uses the commonly assumed 100-fold factor increase in strength from liquid to plastic limit
over-predicts the measured data of soil strength. The use of a factor of about 35 for the ratio between the strength at liquid limit and that extrapolated to plastic limit is shown to be more realistic. Logarithmic liquidity index is examined and found to also correlate strongly with the logarithm of undrained shear strength, however it is shown that no great statistical improvement is present compared with the semilogarithmic
formulation. When considering data of individual soils a power law fitting is shown statistically to be the preferred mathematical function.
over-predicts the measured data of soil strength. The use of a factor of about 35 for the ratio between the strength at liquid limit and that extrapolated to plastic limit is shown to be more realistic. Logarithmic liquidity index is examined and found to also correlate strongly with the logarithm of undrained shear strength, however it is shown that no great statistical improvement is present compared with the semilogarithmic
formulation. When considering data of individual soils a power law fitting is shown statistically to be the preferred mathematical function.
Research Interests:
A large database has recently been published that details the development of new empirical expressions for the stiffness reduction with strain of clays and silts. In this note, the same database is used to examine two major considerations... more
A large database has recently been published that details the development of new empirical expressions for the stiffness reduction with strain of clays and silts. In this note, the same database is used to examine two major considerations for engineers using these expressions in numerical analyses: the transformation from secant to tangent stiffness and the effect of stress history.
Research Interests:
The findings of an extensive literature review on the permeability of hot-mix asphalt concrete are detailed in a state-of-the-art report on the measurement and interpretation of asphalt concrete permeability data. The permeability of... more
The findings of an extensive literature review on the permeability of hot-mix asphalt concrete are detailed in a state-of-the-art report on the measurement and interpretation of asphalt concrete permeability data. The permeability of asphalt concrete is affected by a range of factors with various levels of importance, which are reviewed along with their impact on the coefficient of permeability. Many theoretical, empirical, semiempirical, and numerical models have been developed to predict permeability, using a range of indicators. Some of these models are reviewed and their advantages and shortcomings discussed. Recent advances in X-ray tomography studies are also summarized. The review reveals that field permeability measurements are not reported to match numerically well with laboratory measurements, though there is some correlation. The reviewed test methods for permeability all rely on an assumption of laminar flow that is unlikely in more porous mixtures. Attempts to measure connected air voids improve the chances of obtaining more meaningful correlations between permeability and air voids, regardless of the mathematical model used to link the two quantities. The lift-thickness to nominal maximum aggregate size (NMAS) ratio and/or changes in the binder content has a less significant effect on permeability than changes in the porosity and/or mix gradation. Air void gradients and distributions in compacted asphalt concrete mixtures can now be assessed with X-ray techniques: the distribution of air voids appears to be nonuniform in laboratory-prepared specimens.
Research Interests:
An analysis is presented of a database of 67 tests on 21 clays and silts of undrained shear stress-strain data of fine-grained soils. Normalizations of secant G in terms of initial mean effective stress p' (i.e., G/p' versus log gamma) or... more
An analysis is presented of a database of 67 tests on 21 clays and silts of undrained shear stress-strain data of fine-grained soils. Normalizations of secant G in terms of initial mean effective stress p' (i.e., G/p' versus log gamma) or undrained shear strength c(u) (i.e., G/c(u) versus log gamma) are shown to be much less successful in reducing the scatter between different clays than the approach that uses the maximum shear modulus, G(max), a technique still not universally adopted by geotechnical researchers and constitutive modelers. Analysis of semiempirical expressions for G(max) is presented and a simple expression that uses only a void-ratio function and a confining-stress function is proposed. This is shown to be superior to a Hardin-style equation, and the void ratio function is demonstrated as an alternative to an overconsolidation ratio (OCR) function. To derive correlations that offer reliable estimates of secant stiffness at any required magnitude of working strain, secant shear modulus G is normalized with respect to its small-strain value G(max), and shear strain gamma is normalized with respect to a reference strain gamma(ref) at which this stiffness has halved. The data are corrected to two standard strain rates to reduce the discrepancy between data obtained from static and cyclic testing. The reference strain gamma(ref) is approximated as a function of the plasticity index. A unique normalized shear modulus reduction curve in the shape of a modified hyperbola is fitted to all the available data up to shear strains of the order of 1%. As a result, good estimates can be made of the modulus reduction G/G(max) +/- 30% across all strain levels in approximately 90% of the cases studied. New design charts are proposed to update the commonly used design curves.
Research Interests:
A-priori estimates of maximum scour depth are important for bridge engineers, managers and owners. HEC-18 is an established method which uses empirical equations to estimate bridge scour. This paper applies the HEC-18 methodology to... more
A-priori estimates of maximum scour depth are important for bridge engineers, managers and owners. HEC-18 is an established method which uses empirical equations to estimate bridge scour. This paper applies the HEC-18 methodology to compute maximum scour depth for 936 bridge piers for which field scour depth measurements are available from an online database from the United States Geological Survey (USGS). The results are in general agreement with past research efforts which suggest that the HEC-18 methodology tends to overestimate maximum bridge pier scour depth. The database is also categorized into various sub-sets to study the effect of different particle sizes and devices used to measure scour in the field.
Research Interests:
To investigate the variation of undrained shear strength with changes in water content, determination of a value of undrained shear strength at the liquid limit is needed. There is debate as to the extent of the typical range of values of... more
To investigate the variation of undrained shear strength with changes in water content, determination of a value of undrained shear strength at the liquid limit is needed. There is debate as to the extent of the typical range of values of undrained shear strength at the liquid limit. In this paper, the undrained shear strength is measured using the miniature laboratory shear vane apparatus and compared with values back-analysed from British Standard fall-cone test data. Four geomaterials: Kaolin, Bentonite, Chalk and Bothkennar clay were selected for testing. The variation of the undrained shear strength values from both testing approaches with changing water content was also studied and compared with the results of previous work. The paper reports a narrow range of undrained shear strength values at the liquid limit for the geomaterials tested.
Research Interests:
Bridges are important infrastructure assets that are vital for the connectivity of communities. Visual inspections remain a key method for bridge condition monitoring. However, visual inspections are often considered to be highly... more
Bridges are important infrastructure assets that are vital for the connectivity of communities. Visual inspections remain a key method for bridge condition monitoring. However, visual inspections are often considered to be highly subjective and therefore alternative technologies are often proposed as a means of replacing or enhancing current visual inspection practices. This paper presents the results of a survey which aims to document the emerging trends for future visual inspection practice related to bridges. The implementation of new technological solutions has the potential to improve the quality of inspection data, reduce the safety risks posed to visual inspectors by moving more of the process off-site and improve the quantification of the rate of change in condition. The survey covers two key topics: (i) Emerging data capture methods and (ii) Emerging data analysis methods. Emerging data capture methods include: use of uncrewed vehicles, 360°cameras, photogrammetry, laser scanners, point cloud systems, and Interferometric Synthetic Aperture Radar (InSar). Emerging data analysis methods include: remote inspection, augmented reality and virtual reality, digital image correlation, artificial intelligence, Big Data and the Internet of Things. The survey concludes with a detailed discussion on the opportunities and barriers to implementation of the reviewed technologies and approaches.
Research Interests:
Bridge scour is a major cause of bridge collapse worldwide. Various approaches are available to estimate levels of scouring due to hydraulic loading. Such scour depth assessment methodologies typically employ a series of empirical and... more
Bridge scour is a major cause of bridge collapse worldwide. Various approaches are available to estimate levels of scouring due to hydraulic loading. Such scour depth assessment methodologies typically employ a series of empirical and semi-empirical equations to estimate scour around a bridge element. This work examines three such methodologies, namely the Hydraulic Engineering Circular Number 18 method (HEC-18) 4 th edition, the HEC-18 5 th edition method and the Texas A&M University method (TAMU). The paper compares the results from these three calculation methods with field data from 23 bridge piers (eight bridges) located in the State of Maine (USA). The paper investigates the levels of conservatism in the estimates of scour depth calculated using these three methodologies. All three approaches tend to give conservative estimates of maximum scour depth, especially for low values of scour depth, when compared to the field dataset examined in this paper.
Research Interests:
Piled foundations generally fail due to excessive settlements causing damage to the supported structure. While various methods are available to predict pile settlements, historically codes of practice have relied upon large factors of... more
Piled foundations generally fail due to excessive settlements causing damage to the supported structure. While various methods are available to predict pile settlements, historically codes of practice have relied upon large factors of safety to ensure pile plunging is sufficiently unlikely. This can lead to confusion between serviceability and collapse limit states as both are concerned with limiting settlements. Modern codes of practice do require the serviceability limit state to be considered independently. However, guidance is rarely provided as to the specific method of predicting settlement and in some cases the expressed expectation is that this condition is satisfied for a pile designed according to the collapse limit state. Therefore, quantifying the settlement reduction provided by a design code is of interest to the engineer as this allows the level of design conservatism to be evaluated. However, this can only be done with a sufficiently large database of pile load tests in the soil deposit of interest. In this paper, two design codes are applied to a dataset of pile tests in London clay. Measured settlements are then obtained from load-test results and compared with those obtained from an unfactored ‘α-method’ analysis to obtain the settlement reduction provided by the design code.
Research Interests:
Quito, Ecuador, is a city at risk of many hazards including earthquakes, volcanic eruptions and landslides, compounded by the widespread presence of problematic volcanic soils known as Cangahua. This paper presents the preliminary results... more
Quito, Ecuador, is a city at risk of many hazards including earthquakes, volcanic eruptions and landslides, compounded by the widespread presence of problematic volcanic soils known as Cangahua. This paper presents the preliminary results of data analyses undertaken on a new geotechnical database for Quito, compiled from a variety of sources. It is envisaged that this database will be utilised primarily for improving our understanding of landslide hazard drivers in communities in and around the city. The preliminary statistical analyses include probability density functions and regression models for soil parameters. A difference in geotechnical variability between the north and the south of the city was observed. The study also presents data from unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) mapping of an informally constructed hillside community in Quito, identifying house-scale slope features (e.g. cut slopes and house loading) that may affect local landslide hazard processes. Together, the statistical analyses of these datasets will provide the inputs for physics-based stochastic slope stability modelling. Recommendations for future data collection are given to support the development of a higher resolution Quito database and facilitate the improvement of community-scale slope stability assessments.
Research Interests:
The Mobilisable Strength Design (MSD) philosophy has been used in various applications related to underground construction, e.g. for analysis of deep foundation and retaining wall performance. MSD requires simple models for the... more
The Mobilisable Strength Design (MSD) philosophy has been used in various applications related to underground construction, e.g. for analysis of deep foundation and retaining wall performance. MSD requires simple models for the stress-strain behaviour of soils. The use of a mobilisation factor on undrained strength to limit soil mobilisation was introduced in BS8002 in 1994. To assist with MSD calculations, the mobilisation strain framework (MSF) has been developed to allow geotechnical engineers to account for the non-linear behaviour of fine-grained soils in routine geotechnical design. In this paper, triaxial and pressuremeter test data from the London Clay deposit are analysed, using the MSF, to study the effects of anisotropy on both the mobilisation strains and non-linearity exponent. The implications for design of underground constructions are also discussed.
Research Interests:
The feasibility of a tunnel, foundation or excavation project is to some extent dependent on limiting the potential ground movements during construction. To make such an assessment it is important to quantify the stress-path dependent... more
The feasibility of a tunnel, foundation or excavation project is to some extent dependent on limiting the potential ground movements during construction. To make such an assessment it is important to quantify the stress-path dependent behaviour of the soil undergoing undrained lateral and vertical stress relief. At an early stage in the project, site-specific test data is limited and so predictions must necessarily be based upon expected characteristics of the soil deposit. Analysis of a recently compiled database RFG/TXCU-278 has demonstrated a method of quantifying the variability of stress-strain data from stress-path tests that are more frequently encountered in commercial practice (consolidated-undrained triaxial compression and extension tests) for use in design sensitivity analyses. A soil non-linearity parameter (b) is investigated using the database RFG/TXCU-278 and a series of previously reported tests performed on intact Bothkennar Clay. Evidence from both databases suggests that the variability of b is not strongly linked to the effects of shear mode, OCR, strain rate, or plasticity. It is shown that reasonable predictions of nonlinear behaviour up to a load factor (σmob/σfailure) of 0.8 can be achieved using the MSD-MSF method for a rigid pad test.
Research Interests:
Bridge engineers specifying, designing and installing Structural Health Monitoring (SHM) systems need to be able to provide reliable information over the very long design lives expected of critical infrastructure assets such as bridges.... more
Bridge engineers specifying, designing and installing Structural Health Monitoring (SHM) systems need to be able to provide reliable information over the very long design lives expected of critical infrastructure assets such as bridges. It is essential that asset managers can have confidence that any significant anomalies or changes in the performance of the structure will be detected. The resources and planning needed to keep such systems functioning is rarely reported as many research deployments are of short duration. In 2007 a wireless sensor network was installed in the Hessle Anchorage chambers of the Humber Bridge in the United Kingdom to monitor parameters that could affect the durability of the main suspension cables of the bridge. This deployment was part of a wider project aimed at examining the potential for using wireless network systems to monitor infrastructure assets. The initial planned duration of the project was six months. It has however now been in place and operational for over ten years. This paper discusses the maintenance undertaken, modifications required, and long-term performance of this installation along with the significance of the long-term data set that has been collected.
Research Interests:
The Seismic Safety and Resilience of Schools in Nepal (SAFER) project has an important aim of producing improved tools for geotechnical and earthquake engineers to assess seismic hazard in the Kathmandu Valley, Nepal. Geo-databases have... more
The Seismic Safety and Resilience of Schools in Nepal (SAFER) project has an important aim of producing improved tools for geotechnical and earthquake engineers to assess seismic hazard in the Kathmandu Valley, Nepal. Geo-databases have the potential to offer geotechnical practitioners means to improve a-priori predictions of important soil parameters in geotechnical design. In this paper, some recent work to develop a new database of geotechnical information (SAFER/GEO-591) including shear wave velocity measurements is reported. Attempts to develop new transformation models to better predict shear wave velocity from more basic parameters such as SPT-N values are presented. Use of kriging to better map shear wave velocity for the study area is recommended as a suitable alternative to the presented correlations.
Research Interests:
Prediction of ground movements requires a reliable estimation of soil representative stress-strain behaviour. To do this an assessment of in-situ (‘preshear’) conditions and the associated influence on the average mobilised soil strength... more
Prediction of ground movements requires a reliable estimation of soil representative stress-strain behaviour. To do this an assessment of in-situ (‘preshear’) conditions and the associated influence on the average mobilised soil strength and strain is needed. While many studies focus on undrained shear strength, less effort has been reported for soil shear strain in the context of foundation design. The influence of different experimental and prediction techniques to determine representative soil shear stress-strain design parameters is worthy of study. In this paper, new experimental data is presented from a series of triaxial and oedometer tests on kaolin. The results demonstrate increasing values of normalised undrained shear strength and reference shear strain with increasing OCR.
Research Interests:
Visual inspection is the most common form of condition monitoring used by bridge owners. Information derived from visual inspection data is commonly used to indicate the performance of bridge stocks and inform bridge management decisions.... more
Visual inspection is the most common form of condition monitoring used by bridge owners. Information derived from visual inspection data is commonly used to indicate the performance of bridge stocks and inform bridge management decisions. However, several studies have highlighted that the inherently subjective nature of the methods used to record this data can result in uncertainty, due to differences between different inspectors' perceptions of the severity and extent of defects. It is important for asset managers to understand the nature of this uncertainty and the implications for decision making. This paper reports the results of a study which compared scoring of bridge defects by pairs of independent inspectors across 200 bridge structures on England's strategic road network. A sample of 200 structures was selected to be representative of Highways England's stock with regard to, inter alia, age, condition and structural form. Routine Principal Inspections for these sample structures, undertaken every six years by the relevant maintaining agents, were also attended by inspectors from WSP Ltd, with defects scored independently by each inspector. The results of these comparisons were used to derive an empirical profile of the uncertainty in different individual defect severity and extent scores. Statistical methods were then used to derive empirical probability density functions for the values of bridge and stock level condition metrics according to the widely adopted Bridge Condition Indicator system. The reported results highlight trends in the reliability of individual defect scores and the impact of uncertainty on commonly used performance metrics.
Research Interests:
Pile settlement is a key geotechnical design consideration. The serviceability limit state for deep foundations cannot be ignored and yet many design methods merely assume that large factors of safety are sufficient to prevent excessive... more
Pile settlement is a key geotechnical design consideration. The serviceability limit state for deep foundations cannot be ignored and yet many design methods merely assume that large factors of safety are sufficient to prevent excessive settlements. A simple model, supported by previously published databases of load testing on bored piles founded in London clay, is used to make predictions of settlement for bored pile foundations in the same geological deposit. The results of a detailed sensitivity study of the key parameters that affect the performance of bored piled foundations are presented. The parameters studied include: the mobilisation factor; the mobilisation strain; the elastic modulus of the concrete; the undrained shear strength profile; the pile length and the pile diameter. Based on the preliminary results of this sensitivity study, design guidance is presented and a rank of order of the parameters is given in order of their influence on the settlement calculation result. The influence of soil non-linearity is also studied.
Research Interests:
The Atterberg Limits are the most common tests specified by practicing geotechnical and pavement engineers the world over. They are used to classify soils using the framework pioneered by Terzaghi and Casagrande during their work with the... more
The Atterberg Limits are the most common tests specified by practicing geotechnical and pavement engineers the world over. They are used to classify soils using the framework pioneered by Terzaghi and Casagrande during their work with the US Public Roads Bureau in the 1920s and 1930s and are also correlated with many fundamental soil parameters, used in design and construction projects. In the 21 st century the Atterberg Limits remain a key component of the testing armory of practicing geotechnical engineers as they can be obtained easily for the large numbers of samples that are needed on major construction projects and allow for rapid assessments of key soil parameters. Their fundamental definitions are worthy of review; the thread-rolling test for plastic limit has remained largely unchanged since Atterberg first described it in 1911 but the definition and measurement of liquid limit varies across the globe. The fundamental mechanics of the Casagrande Cup liquid limit have been the subject of recent study showing clearly that liquid limit determined in this way relates to a fixed value of specific soil strength (i.e. strength per unit density) as opposed to a fixed strength value when liquid limit is measured by the fall-cone method. These findings explain the deviation between liquid limits measured by the two methods for high plasticity soils without the need to invoke different strength regimes. The brittle failure mechanism in the thread-rolling test has also been recently reexamined. It is proposed that the brittle failure observed in the plastic limit test is caused by either air entry or cavitation in the clay and plastic limit and does not correspond to a fixed strength. The Atterberg Limits are used to compute liquidity index which is widely related to clay strength variation, this is critical for many areas of construction (especially when rapid assessments of strength are required). The Russian code for the design of piled foundations, for example, uses liquidity index values to assess shaft friction. Recent research outcomes at the University of Cambridge have challenged certain assumptions pertaining to widely-used correlations between liquidity index and undrained strength.
Research Interests:
When designing geotechnical structures engineers need to assign soil parameters. Soil design parameters are often inferred through correlations with basic site investigation data. The objective of this work is to determine the shape of... more
When designing geotechnical structures engineers need to assign soil parameters. Soil design parameters are often inferred through correlations with basic site investigation data. The objective of this work is to determine the shape of the undrained stress-strain curve of a heavily overconsolidated Eocene clay in such a way that it may conveniently be used in simplified deformation mechanisms to predict ground movements due to construction. A database of London clay triaxial test data is presented. Use of a power model to predict strength mobilization is demonstrated for 17 previously published triaxial tests on high quality cores of London clay. A novel method of normalising these mobilization curves is demonstrated (using a reference strain at 50% mobilization of shear strength), and different relations are shown to apply to different magnitudes of strain. The parameters that influence the variation of the reference strain are studied.
Research Interests:
The use of databases in geotechnical engineering allows engineers to make a priori estimates of soil behaviour. Based on a study of the published literature, a database of 20 clays and silts is presented that allows predictions to be made... more
The use of databases in geotechnical engineering allows engineers to make a priori estimates of soil behaviour. Based on a study of the published literature, a database of 20 clays and silts is presented that allows predictions to be made of the strain-dependent stiffness of fine-grained soils, based on simple soil parameters. The significance of rate effects is discussed and corrections are made. The use of a reference strain γ ref to normalize shear strain values γ in relation to modulus reduction G/G 0 is discussed. Empirical formulations are presented based on a rigorous regression analysis, and design charts are constructed.
Research Interests:
The design of piles in clay is an important engineering design task. This paper compares the effect two codes of practice and two calculation approaches have on the computed design capacity of a bored pile in London clay. It is shown that... more
The design of piles in clay is an important engineering design task. This paper compares the effect two codes of practice and two calculation approaches have on the computed design capacity of a bored pile in London clay. It is shown that the choice of a design line to describe the soil strength profile is the major factor that affects the length of pile required.
Research Interests:
Vardanega, P.J. (2021). Editorial. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers – Engineering Sustainability, 174(5): 211-212 https://doi.org/10.1680/jensu.2021.174.5.211
Research Interests:
Vardanega, P.J., Moinet, W.W. & Castellanza, R. (2021). Editorial. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers – Geotechnical Engineering, 174(4): 331–333 https://doi.org/10.1680/jgeen.2021.174.4.331
Research Interests:
Vardanega, P.J., Elia, G. & Yao, K. (2021). Editorial. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers - Geotechnical Engineering, 174(2): 99–101 https://doi.org/10.1680/jgeen.2021.174.2.99
Research Interests:
Vardanega, P.J. (2020). Editorial. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers – Engineering Sustainability, 173(3): 107-108 https://doi.org/10.1680/jensu.2020.173.3.107
Research Interests:
Vardanega, P.J. (2020). Editorial. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers – Geotechnical Engineering, 173(1): 1-2 https://doi.org/10.1680/jgeen.2020.173.1.1
Research Interests:
Vardanega, P.J. (2019). Editorial. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers – Engineering Sustainability, 172(8): 415 https://doi.org/10.1680/jensu.2019.172.8.415
Go, J. & Vardanega, P.J. (2019). Editorial. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers - Geotechnical Engineering, 172(1): 1-3 https://doi.org/10.1680/jgeen.2019.172.1.1
Research Interests:
Vardanega, P.J. & Haigh, S.K. (2017). Discussion of "Water Content Ratio: An Effective Substitute for Liquidity Index for Prediction of Shear Strength of Clays" by Beshy Kuriakose, Benny Mathews Abraham, A. Sridharan & Babu T. Jose.... more
Vardanega, P.J. & Haigh, S.K. (2017). Discussion of "Water Content Ratio: An Effective Substitute for Liquidity Index for Prediction of Shear Strength of Clays" by Beshy Kuriakose, Benny Mathews Abraham, A. Sridharan & Babu T. Jose. Geotechnical and Geological Engineering, 35(6): 3039-3044 https://doi.org/10.1007/s10706-017-0290-0
Research Interests:
Vardanega, P.J. (2017). Editorial. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers – Geotechnical Engineering, 170(2): 95-96 https://doi.org/10.1680/jgeen.2017.170.2.95
Research Interests:
Vardanega, P.J. & Bolton, M.D. (2016). Discussion of “Undrained Young’s Modulus of Fine-Grained Soils” by B. Casey, J. T. Germaine, N. O. Abdulhadim, N. S. Kontopoulos and C. A. Jones. Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental... more
Vardanega, P.J. & Bolton, M.D. (2016). Discussion of “Undrained Young’s Modulus of Fine-Grained Soils” by B. Casey, J. T. Germaine, N. O. Abdulhadim, N. S. Kontopoulos and C. A. Jones. Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering (ASCE), 142(10): [07016023] https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)GT.1943-5606.0001571
Research Interests:
Vardanega, P.J. & Bolton, M.D. (2016). Discussion of “Characterization of Model Uncertainty for Cantilever Deflections in Undrained Clay” by D.M. Zhang, K.K. Phoon, H.W. Huang and Q.F. Hu. Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental... more
Vardanega, P.J. & Bolton, M.D. (2016). Discussion of “Characterization of Model Uncertainty for Cantilever Deflections in Undrained Clay” by D.M. Zhang, K.K. Phoon, H.W. Huang and Q.F. Hu. Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering (ASCE), 142(1): [07015036] https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)GT.1943-5606.0001395
Research Interests:
Vardanega, P.J. & Waters, T.J. (2015). Discussion of "Evaluating the relationship between permeability and moisture damage of asphalt concrete pavements" by Rafiqul A. Tarefder and Mohiuddin Ahmad. Journal of Materials in Civil... more
Vardanega, P.J. & Waters, T.J. (2015). Discussion of "Evaluating the relationship between permeability and moisture damage of asphalt concrete pavements" by Rafiqul A. Tarefder and Mohiuddin Ahmad. Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering (ASCE), 27(12): [07015009] https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)MT.1943-5533.0001411
Research Interests:
Vardanega, P.J. (2014). Discussion of “A New Model on the Hydraulic Conductivity of Asphalt Mixtures” by J. Norambuena-Contreras, E. Asanza Izquierdo, D. Castro-Fresno, Manfred N. Partl and Alvaro Garcia. International Journal of Pavement... more
Vardanega, P.J. (2014). Discussion of “A New Model on the Hydraulic Conductivity of Asphalt Mixtures” by J. Norambuena-Contreras, E. Asanza Izquierdo, D. Castro-Fresno, Manfred N. Partl and Alvaro Garcia. International Journal of Pavement Research and Technology, 7(3): 223-224.
Research Interests:
Vardanega, P.J., Lau, B.H., Lam, S.Y., Haigh, S.K., Madabhushi, S.P.G., Bolton, M.D. & Mayne, P.W. (2013). Discussion: Laboratory measurement of strength mobilization in kaolin: link to stress history. Géotechnique Letters, 3(1): 16-17... more
Vardanega, P.J., Lau, B.H., Lam, S.Y., Haigh, S.K., Madabhushi, S.P.G., Bolton, M.D. & Mayne, P.W. (2013). Discussion: Laboratory measurement of strength mobilization in kaolin: link to stress history. Géotechnique Letters, 3(1): 16-17 https://doi.org/10.1680/geolett.13.00005
Research Interests:
Haigh, S.K. & Vardanega, P.J. (2012) Discussion of “Re-examination of undrained strength at Atterberg Limits Water Contents” by H. B. Nagaraj, A. Sridharan and H. M. Mallikarjuna. Geotechnical and Geological Engineering, 30(6): 1389-1391... more
Haigh, S.K. & Vardanega, P.J. (2012) Discussion of “Re-examination of undrained strength at Atterberg Limits Water Contents” by H. B. Nagaraj, A. Sridharan and H. M. Mallikarjuna. Geotechnical and Geological Engineering, 30(6): 1389-1391 https://doi.org/10.1007/s10706-012-9543-0
Research Interests:
Structural health monitoring (SHM) has the potential to transform the bridge engineering industry by providing stakeholders with additional information to inform decisions about the design, operation, and management of bridges throughout... more
Structural health monitoring (SHM) has the potential to transform the bridge engineering industry by providing stakeholders with additional information to inform decisions about the design, operation, and management of bridges throughout their life. This chapter gives guidance on SHM for engineers who design, build, operate and maintain bridges. There remain numerous technical challenges to overcome when deploying SHM systems, but the most important issues to be considered are how to decide what information is required and then how to develop a strategy to deliver this information in a form that is easy to interpret so as to inform decision making. This chapter presents a series of case studies to show how SHM systems can be used in practice to obtain valuable data and to explore the challenges faced during such projects. Future directions for emerging technologies and approaches for future research and management of bridge SHM systems are also discussed.
Research Interests:
Supplementary data for "Use of hydraulic radius to estimate the permeability of coarse-grained materials using a new geodatabase"