[go: up one dir, main page]

@wip / wip.tumblr.com

ask box is open every Monday from 6AM to 6PM EST
Avatar

would it be possible to allow both a primary blog and its secondary blogs to have the same blocked users list/share a blocked list? like if i create a secondary blog for a specific thing, i naturally wouldnt/dont want people ive already blocked to interact with that blog either, but re-blocking every single user, when some people have hundreds or thousands of people that they have blocked (like me) is nigh impossible/kind of a cruel thing to ask when the same person would clearly have the same people blocked on that blog too.

like could the blocked users list be assigned to all blogs under the email, rather than to individual blogs regardless of secondary status? like removing an invisible wall and just letting the secondary blog[s] use the main blog's blocked list instead of its own separate one.

or would implementing this somehow hit rate limits or something? (which is i think why twitter's old 'import blocklist' feature shut down years ago and why i wouldnt ask for that feature on here, as cool as it would be.) in which case would it be possible for new blocks going *Forward* to be shared across same-email blogs instead since the secondary blogs wouldnt have to be hit with the weight of a sudden influx of past block requests and it would be able to happen gradually as the person blocks new users from hereon one by one in real time? (sorry that this is wordy!)

Avatar

Answer: Hi there, @ryuseitaiz!

Thanks for your question. This is a tricky one!

This is a not-uncommon question that we receive at @wip. One of Tumblr’s oldest core principles is that we try not to reveal who owns what blogs—or the relationships between primary and secondary blogs.

So, blocking someone from all your blogs could easily reveal that the same person owns different blogs in some scenarios that can be easy to game. For the longest time, we haven’t wanted to change this principle—but we are rethinking it in some areas, like Communities. We may rethink it everywhere, based on feedback like this, but can’t say any more than that right now. If anything changes, you’ll find out here or at @changes.

But thank you—we appreciate your thoughts and consideration.

Avatar

Hi, I was wondering if it would be possible to separate more blogs coming from the same mail. Like on instagram where two accounts from the same person can have different subscription and likes.

I do not find practical how the main blog has the control of the likes and subscriptions. Especially when having two blogs mean that they're for different purpose.

I hope my request is clear enough, if it isn't, I would be happy to explain in more details.

Thank you in advance and have a great day

Avatar

Answer: Hi, @charlie-theidiot!

Well, what are the chances?

It sounds like you’re describing a current project of ours: “Identities”! It’s something we’d like to do, and very much intend to do. Only we have to level with you folks: it’s a big, big project, and we don’t have the bandwidth for it right now, particularly with Communities taking so much time and resources.

Thanks for your question. Hopefully, it won’t be too long until we’ve got some news to share. We’ll keep you posted!

Avatar

Is there anyway yall could make deactivating not permanent? At least not for 30 days, giving users a time period where they can reactivate their account.

I’ve had so many people I know deactivate their accounts and regret it afterwards, or wish they could just shut down their account for a week because of being hit by endless hate anons. Most other social media platforms I know of have a period of time that you can reactivate your account after deactivation. I think something like that would be really beneficial on here.

Avatar

Answer: Hey there, @automaticllamacycle!

So you’re right. There is currently no community-facing way that you can get your account back in the event it is deleted.

However, we are not too far away from having this technically feasible on our backend, and we don’t think it would take too much work to make it a reality. You’re right on this one—such a feature would be really nice to have, and we’re grateful you drew this to our attention.

Leave this with us—we will see what we can do. In the meantime, you can catch up with updates here at @wip or at @changes, should we have them.

Thanks for your question, and keep ’em coming. Happy weekend!

Avatar

It would be good if the error message "welcome back! It's time to change your password" become optional, not mandatory.

When this message appears and if a person could not change the password, then that person cannot access the account. That is because the password change is mandatory.

It would be great if it becomes optional, and user can freely decide whether to change password or just skip it.

Thank you.

Avatar

Answer: Hey there, @letsgirit!

Password resets like this are very important for account safety here on Tumblr (and plenty of other sites!) and are often prompted for very important reasons.

However, if you’re ever not able to get that password reset working, we do have an account recovery process to help as noted here in this handy Help Center article. We hope this helps, and thanks for getting in touch.

Avatar

hello, i would like all my posts to stay on my “front page”, I don’t want them to go to the archive. is it possible to fix that? it’s for stesofolio.tumblr.com. I use it as a portfolio and want it to be an endless feed of posts.

Avatar

Answer: Hey there @stesosongs!

We must start by saying that we are not entirely sure what you mean here, and so we have reached out to you directly to clarify.  

However, we wonder if this may be a bug with the custom theme you are using—it seems to stop after loading a certain number of posts. We can’t fix that, we are sorry to say, so you’d have to reach out to the theme developer, which you can find here. We hope this helps!

Avatar

It'd be great if we can check what we posted years ago everyday, like "on this day" or "memories". Are you planning on implementing this soon? ❤️

Avatar

Answer: Hi, @puregrief!

Fun story: we tried this! A couple of times, actually. One of them is still up that you can see today: the @memories blog on Tumblr was an April Fools prank many years ago, and its posts are customized based on who’s viewing it (you!), and it has some fun things like this.

Another time, we had a thing that would show you a post of yours from long ago with a header like “Blast from the past!”—it was fun for only a handful of people… but most others who saw it really did not like it, and let us know, so we removed it.

There are no plans to bring it back at present. But thank you for getting in touch, and keep the questions coming y'all.

Avatar

Hi! Maybe third time’s the charm of asking this. I have two separate blogs since I like having the perks of the main blog, now would it be possible to have multiple accounts or even max of 3 logged in to the tumblr app? Instead of logging in and out? Thanks! x

Avatar

Answer: Hey there @gravelyorchid!

A little good news and bad news here. We will start with the good, just because.

We have actually been looking into solving this kind of problem already as it happens. So yes—we fully agree this would be great to have. There are no guarantees on when a solution may be provided though, unfortunately, at this time.

We will let you know as soon as we do. Have a good day, and thanks for your question!

Avatar

Could we follow our own blogs again? I know we create content for others, but we create first and foremost for ourselves and I would like to see my own content on my dash.

Also I would like to get notifications for my own posts. Notifications are important to keep my blogs organized.

Avatar

Answer: Hey, @hattersgirlalice!

As luck would have it, you can already accomplish this via the Inside Tumblrs setting in Tumblr Labs, which follows all of your own blogs and puts them in your Following feed.

We hope this helps, and thanks for your question.

Avatar

Hello! I've noticed that sometime in the last few months, we seem to have lost the ability to re-order sideblogs? At least, I haven't been able to do so through any means (app, desktop version, desktop version on mobile web browser or standard mobile web browser), and it was a very helpful tool, especially for using the quick queue or reblog features on the app. Any chance of that making a comeback someday?

Thanks for your time!

Avatar

Answer: Hi, @dr-paine!

Snap! As it happens we have run into this issue ourselves, just a few weeks ago. However, a fix has since been rolled out, and we are glad to say that it works again now, just fine. 

Thanks for bringing this to our attention, and have a lovely day.

Avatar

Please make it possible to hide users' posts without blocking them. Like, in cases where a person hasn't done anything wrong to be blocked, but you just don't like their posts.

Avatar

Answer: Hello, @deithwen!

As it turns out, we’ve received this feature request a lot over the years. Usually, it comes in as wanting the ability to “mute” other blogs on Tumblr. While we would love to build it, we’ve balked at it a bit because of its technical and product complexity. Let us explain what that means:

In terms of technical complexity, our current blocking feature is closest to how “muting” would work. Our current blocking feature may seem simple, but it’s very complex because of how big Tumblr is. Every time we fetch a list of blogs for you or anyone on Tumblr, we have to also fetch the list of who you’re blocking, and who’s blocking you, and filter out anyone with that block relationship. This mapping of who’s-blocking-who is stored in a directional way right now, so the “cost” of loading that list gets higher the more people you’re blocking and the more people who are blocking you. If you’re blocking 1,000 blogs, we have to check that list a lot. If you’re being blocked by 1,000 blogs, that’s another big list to check against.

In technical terms, this is a “many-to-many” relationship, which is almost always incredibly difficult to manage while not degrading the experience of using a platform like Tumblr. The more people who are blocking, the harder it is to store those lists in a way that’s easy to check, but we’re working on making it smoother. The vast majority of people don’t block many others, if at all, so it’s never been a huge problem. But the outliers who block thousands of others (or are blocked by thousands of others) can degrade performance for everyone over enough time.

Adding muting would throw on top of that yet another list of blogs to check, increasing the complexity of something that’s already pretty complex. It helps that muting would be one-directional and not bi-directional (as in, it doesn’t matter who’s muting you), but, as that list of muted blogs grows, your experience may degrade further. So we’d need to solve for that, which is definitely doable. It would just take time—and lots of it.

And, as a product, Tumblr is already pretty confusing to people trying to figure out what “blocking” means already, as well as our other filtering options. Up until fairly recently, blocking was almost entirely one-directional, the opposite way you’d expect: blocking made it so the blocked person couldn’t see you, not that you couldn’t see them. We’ve been updating blocking to work both ways instead, which is more common on social media these days. Similarly, the options to filter tags versus content cause a lot of confusion because they don’t work the same way as each other.

So if we wanted to add another filtering option to that mix, “muting” blogs, we’d need to be conscious of how all of those options work together—and are confusing in context with each other. We should really clean up that experience to be more streamlined and simple, not more complex. And I didn’t even mention the oddity of how different settings apply to your primary blog versus your sideblogs if you have more than one blog!

Taken together, it is a great idea for us to clean all of this up, improve our existing options here, and add “muting” for even more control and granularity. Sadly, however, it just isn’t high enough on our list of priorities to tackle anytime soon. We don’t want to simply tack on muting for the sake of doing it—we want to do a better job than that. I hope that makes sense!

Thanks for your question. It was an important one to address. If anything should change here, you will get news through the usual channels: here at WIP, or at @changes

Avatar

Some people with mature blogs ask that anyone who follows or interacts with them have their age in their bio to "prove that they aren't a minor." Would it be possible to let people show their birthday that is required when making an account in the description of a blog, or maybe a seperate age section extrapolated from the birthday, since that can't be changed?

Avatar

Answer: Hey there, @fourcheesecalzone!

So, this is something of a tricky one. Albeit a good one, too.

The general idea of adding more customization options for your identity on Tumblr, like showing your age or your registration date or links to About pages and the like, is certainly something we want to work on someday. We can say this for sure.

However, just your age, on its own, is not something we would want to expose. It would have to come with bigger changes to how we display information about people on the platform. How exactly we tackle these questions is still ongoing, but it’s a good question, and we hope to have updates for you before too long. You will catch these here or over at @changes.

Thanks for your question, and we hope this helps for now. 

Avatar

Tumblr labs addition maybe Whilst using tumblr I have amassed quite a large following 40K+ I don't have the time to prune all the dead and barely active accounts. ideally a tool is what is required, that has moderation type filters that let the user specify the range of activity or there lack of to remove. As a healthy forum runs on people posting often and the dead wood being removed.

Avatar

Answer: Hey there, @tgcarahart.

We would love to build more bulk-action tools on Tumblr as a core platform improvement! Gardening your following and followers are one of the areas where that would make a lot of sense. However, we’re not sure yet where it fits on our priority list, but it may be a part of our plans next year. Stay tuned to @changes blog for updates on that.

In the meantime, if you want to do this kind of thing yourself and dip your toes into some programming, you can leverage the public Tumblr API to do exactly what you want. In fact, we just published an example of how to get a list of who you’re following based on activeness and mutual status here. You could probably tune that to do what you want with a little work! We’d love to have more examples in that repository.

Thanks for your question, and we hope this helps!

Avatar

Deleting a single side-blog is deleting all blogs including the primary one... it seems that this is either a bug or UI being unclear?

Is there a way to delete side blogs without completely erasing all blogs?

Avatar

Answer: Hello, @cyphyree!

So, we’ve been testing this vigorously and have been unable to reproduce the issue. We have persisted, just in case this is an edge case we haven’t found yet, but we have reached out to you directly for further clarification.

Relatedly, we should note that we have recently made some updates to clarify that deleting the main blog will delete your entire account. The "Delete account" button is now only in Settings, at the bottom, and no longer in your main blog’s settings. You can find out more here in this post from @changes.

Thanks for your question!

Avatar

I was wondering if sometime in the future we could have gifs as our profile pics. I know it was accidentally allowed for a short period of time and I think it would be a fun edition to have

Avatar

Answer: Hello there, @birdy-bird27!

As much as we like this idea, we’re afraid this one won’t be happening. A long story short: it’s simply too much of a possible abuse vector and a space for bad intent, like with flashing images.

We appreciate the question. Keep ’em coming!

Avatar

I notice that when you comment on a post it always uses your primary blog name even if it's a conversation on a post of one of your own alt blogs.

Can we have some way to comment on posts as other blogs to stay in character for themed blogs?

Avatar

Answer: Hello, @coffeecasualty11!

We have an answer here, and we think you are going to like it. You can actually do this now!

That’s right, you can now do exactly that. You can finally, after much waiting, reply from secondary blogs. Next to the reply input field, you can click or tap on the avatar to change what blog you’re replying as.

You can find out more at our @staff post, which you can find right here, and may have caught in this recent update over at @changes!

We hope you enjoy it. Happy posting!

Avatar

Could we get an option to only back up our blogs from a certain date of our choosing, instead of the whole thing every time? It'd save a whole lot of download space for those of us who've done it before and/or have been here for a long time.

Avatar

Answer: Hey, @winged-mammal!

That would indeed be pretty cool! Though we must be straight with you here—as things stand, it's very unlikely we’d ever get around to doing it, sadly. 

If that ever were to change, you can of course find out here or over at @changes

Thanks for getting in touch, and have a good day.

Love,

—Cyle

Avatar

how long does it take for a previously claimed handle to become available once again?

Avatar

Answer: Hey there, @comIc!

This is a fun one! So, our policy is to "free up" blog names when the account has been inactive for over a year. And you can see how we define "inactive" right here, at the Help Center. 

However, we should mention that there’s no way for you, on Tumblr, to see how long a blog has been inactive. It’s perfectly possible a blog hasn’t posted in a decade but still logs in every day, for example.

Best,

—Jon

You are using an unsupported browser and things might not work as intended. Please make sure you're using the latest version of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, or Edge.