Stability of Electric Drives
Dr. K. R. Rajagopal
                  Associate Professor
         Electrical Engineering Department
    Indian Institute of Technology, Delhi – 110016
            E.mail: rgopal@ee.iitd.ernet.in
            Website: http://krrg.tripod.com
                                           Dr. K. R. Rajagopal
Steady State Stability of an Electric           IIT Delhi
Drive
 The drive is said to be in equilibrium if the torque
  developed by the motor is exactly equal to the
  load torque.
 If the drive comes out of the state of equilibrium
  due to some disturbance, it comes back to steady
  state for stable equilibrium but for unstable
  equilibrium the speed of the drive increases
  uncontrollably or decreases to zero. When the
  drive coming out of the state of equilibrium
  preserves it steady state at different speed (lying
  in small range), it is said to be in neutral range.
                                           Dr. K. R. Rajagopal
Steady State Stability of an Electric           IIT Delhi
Drive (Cont.)
  The stability of the motor load combination is defined
   as the capacity of the system which enables it to
   develop forces of such a nature as to restore
   equilibrium after any small departure therefore.
 Equilibrium state of the drive mainly disturbs because
   of the following two types of disturbances,
1. Changes from the state of equilibrium takes place
   slowly and the effect of either the inertia or the
   inductance is insignificant – Steady state stability.
2. Sudden and fast changes from the equilibrium state so
   effect of both inertia and inductance can not be
   neglected- Dynamic or transient stability.
                                                  Dr. K. R. Rajagopal
Steady State Stability of an Electric                   IIT Delhi
Drive (Cont.)
  Criteria for steady state stability:-
 Let the equilibrium of the torques and speed is TM, TL
  and ω and the small deviations are ΔTm, ΔTL and Δω.
  After the displacement from the equilibrium state the
  torque equation becomes,
          d       d   
        J      J            TL  TL  TM  TM  0
          dt          dt
                d
        but, J       TL  TM  0, so
                dt
          d   
        J           TL  TM  0
             dt
                                           Dr. K. R. Rajagopal
Steady State Stability of an Electric           IIT Delhi
Drive (Cont.)
   Considering the small deviation, changes can be
    expressed as a linear function of change in speed,
                dTM                 dTL
          TM       ,      TL      
                d                  d
   From the torque equation, where all quantities are
    expressed in terms of their deviations from the
    equilibrium,
           Jd
                  dTL dTM 
                                0
                dt    d d  
                                           Dr. K. R. Rajagopal
Steady State Stability of an Electric           IIT Delhi
Drive (Cont.)
   Solution is,
                         dTL dTM 
          0 e1/ J
                         d  d  t
 Where, (Δω)0 is the initial value of the deviation in
  speed. For the stable system the exponent must be
  negative, so speed increment will disappear with
  time. The exponent will always be negative if,
               dTL dTM
                           0
               d d
                                              Dr. K. R. Rajagopal
Steady State Stability of an Electric              IIT Delhi
Drive (Cont.)
   Criteria for the steady state stability is for a
    decrease in the speed the motor torque must
    exceeds the load torque and for increase in speed
    the motor torque must be less than the load torque.
                                  Load torque TL’ results
                                   in a stable equilibrium
                                   point, and the load
                                   torque TL’’ results in an
                                   unstable situation.
                                              Dr. K. R. Rajagopal
Steady State Stability of an Electric              IIT Delhi
Drive (Cont.)
   To check the stability at an operating point of the
    motor, if an increase in speed brings greater
    increase in load torque than the motor torque, the
    speed will tend to decrease and return to its original
    value, so operating point will be a stable point else
    operating point will be an unstable point.
                                         Dr. K. R. Rajagopal
Steady State Stability of an Electric         IIT Delhi
Drive (Cont.)
                            Cases (a), (b) and (c)
                             represents          stable
                             operation of drive.
                            Cases (d), (e) and (f)
                             represents        unstable
                             operation of drive.
                            Case     (g)    represents
                             indeterminate condition.
Various Speed and Torque
Curves of Motor and Load