1-Real Estate Law - IIB Exam IOV PPT 01.12.20
1-Real Estate Law - IIB Exam IOV PPT 01.12.20
                                                 By .Er.K.Sundarapandian,
                             BE,MBA,MRICS,LLB,(MSc,REV),FIIV,AIV,MIITArb,
                                                      Member – IIV & IOV
Syllabus at Glance
• Land Acquisition - The Right to Fair Compensation       • The Transfer of Property Act, 1882
  and Transparency in the Land Acquisition,               • Transfer of Immovable Property: Sale, Mortgage, Gift,
  Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013                 Exchange, Assignement, Charge, Lien, Tenanciers / Sub-
• General Building Rules and Regulations                    Tenancies
                                                          • Lease of Immovable Property, Lease granted by Private
• Rent Control Laws: Sections pertaining to Occupancy
                                                            and Statutory Bodies - Impact of each on Valuation -
  Rights of Tenants, Freezing of Rent and Protection        Sections: 3, 5, 6, 7, 25, 53 and 53A of the Transfer of
  against Eviction of Tenant and its effect on value of     Property Act, 1882
  property
                                                          • Laws Relating to Inheritance/Succession
• Right of Way and Section 52 - Licenses under the        • Mohammedan: Muslim Personal Law
  Indian Easements Act, 1882
                                                          • The Hindu Succession Act, 1956, the Hindu
• Salient features of the Real Estate (Regulation and       Succession
  Development) Act, 2016 and Real Estate Regulating
  Authorities established under the Act                   • (Amendment) Act, 2005 (39 of 2005)
                                                          • The Indian Succession Act, 1925: Law of succession
                                                            for person other than Hindu and Mohammedan
                                                          • - Will & Testament, Succession Certificate
                         Land Acquisition
• Land acquisition in India refers
  to the process by which the
  union or a state government in
  India acquires private land for
  the purpose of industrialisation,
  development of infrastructural
  facilities or urbanisation of the
  private land, and provides
  compensation to the
  affected land owners and their
  rehabilitation
Land Acquisition
                               Apparent
               Continuous
                                 Non –
Easement                        Apparent
             Non-Continuous
The Indian Easements Act, 1882
   • Section 4 "Easement" defined. – An easement is a right
     which the owner or occupier of certain land possesses, as
     such, for the beneficial enjoyment of that land, to do and
     continue to do something, or to prevent and continue to
     prevent something being done, in or upon, or in respect of,
     certain other land not his own.
   • Dominant and servient heritages and owners. –The land for
     the beneficial enjoyment of which the right exists is called
     the dominant heritage, and the owner or occupier thereof
     the dominant owner; the expression
   • "land" includes also things permanently attached to the
     earth; the expression
   • "beneficial enjoyment" includes also possible convenience,
     remote advantage, and even a mere amenity; and the
     expression "to do something" includes removal and
     appropriation by the dominant owner, for the beneficial
     enjoyment of the dominant heritage, of any part of the soil
     of the servient heritage, or anything growing or subsisting
     thereon.
The Indian Easements Act, 1882
• Illustrations                                 • (d) A, as owner of a certain house and farm, has
• (a) A, as the owner of a certain house, has     the right to graze his own cattle on B's field, or to
  a right of way over his neighbour B's land      take, for the purpose of being used in the house,
  for purposes connected with the beneficial      by himself, his family, guests, lodgers and
  enjoyment of the house. This is an              servants, water or fish out of c's tank, or timber
  easement.                                       out of d's wood, or to use, for the purpose of
• (b) A, as the owner of a certain house, has     manuring his land, the leaves which have fallen
  the right to go on his neighbour B's land,      from the trees in e's land. These are easements.
  and to take water for the purposes of his     • (e) A dedicates to the public the right to occupy
  household, out of a spring therein. This is
  an easement.
                                                  the surface of certain land for the purpose of
                                                  passing and re-passing. This right is not an
• (c) A, as owner of a certain house, has the     easement.
  right to conduct water from B's stream to
  supply the fountains in the garden            • (f) A is bound to cleanse a water course running
  attached to the house. This is an               through his land and keep it free from
  easement.
                                                • obstruction for the benefit of B, a lower riparian
                                                  owner. This is not an easement.
The Indian Easements Act, 1882
• Section 5 - A continuous easement is one      • (c) Rights annexed to A's land to lead water
  whose enjoyment is, or may be, continual        thither across B's land by an aqueduct and to
  without act of man. A discontinuous
  easement is one that needs the act of man       draw off water thence by a drain. The drain
  for its enjoyment. An apparent easement         would be discovered upon careful inspection
  is one the existence of which is shown by       by a person conversant with such matters.
  some
                                                • These are apparent easements.
• permanent sign which, upon careful
  inspection by a competent person, would       • (d) A right annexed to a's house to prevent B
  be visible to him.                              from building on his own land. This is a non-
• A non-apparent easement is one that has         apparent easement.
  no such sign. Illustrations
• (a) A right annexed to B's house to receive
  light by the windows without obstruction
  by his neighbour A. This is a continuous
  easement.
• (b) A right of way annexed to a's house
  over B's land. This is a discontinuous
  easement.
The Indian Easements Act, 1882
• Section 6. - Easements for limited time or on
  condition.- An easement may be permanent,         • (b) Rights to advantages arising from situation. -The right of
  or for a term of years or other limited period,     every owner of immovable property (subject to law for time
                                                      being in force) to enjoy without disturbance by another the
  or subject to periodical interruption, or           natural advantages arising from its situation.
  exercisable only at a certain place, or at        • Illustrations of the Rights referred to
  certain times, or between certain hours, or       • (a) The exclusive right of every owner of land in a town to build
  for a particular purpose, or on condition that      on such land, subject to any municipal law for the time being in
  it shall commence or become void or                 force.
  voidable on the happening of a specified          • (b) The right of every owner of land that the air passing thereto
  event or the performance or non-                    shall not be unreasonably polluted by other persons.
  performance of a specified Act. (Lease,           • (c) The right of every owner of a house that his physical comfort
                                                      shall not be interfered with materially and unreasonable by
  license)                                            noise or vibration caused by any other person.
• Section 7. Easements restrictive of certain       • (d) The right of every owner of land to so much light and air as
  rights. -Easements are restrictions of one or       pass vertically thereto.
  other of the following rights (namely):-          • (e) The right of every owner of land that such land, in its natural
                                                      condition, shall have the support naturally rendered by the
• (a) right to enjoy. -The exclusive right of         subjacent and adjacent soil of another person.
  every owner of immovable property (subject        • Explanation. -Land is in its natural condition when it is not
  to any law for the time being in force) to          excavated and not subjected to artificial pressure; and the
                                                      "subjacent and adjacent soil" mentioned in this
  enjoy and dispose of the same and all
  products thereof and accessions thereto.
The Indian Easements Act, 1882
• illustration means such soil only as in its
  natural condition would support the            • (h) The right of every owner of land that the water of every
                                                   natural stream which passes by, through or over his land in a
  dominant heritage in its natural condition.      defined natural channel shall be allowed by other persons to
                                                   flow within such owner's limits without interruption and without
• (f) The right of every owner of land that,       material alteration in quantity, direction, force or temperature;
  within his own limits, the water which           the right of every owner of land abutting on a natural lake or
                                                   pond into or out of which a natural stream flows, that the water
  naturally passes or percolates by, over or       of such lake or pond shall be allowed by other persons to remain
  through his land shall not, before so            within such owner's limits without material alteration in
                                                   quantity or temperature.
  passing or percolating, be unreasonably
                                                 • (i) Right of every owner of upper land that water naturally rising
  polluted by other persons.                       in, or falling on such land, and not passing in defined channels,
                                                   shall be allowed by owner of adjacent lower land to run
• (g) The right of every owner of land to          naturally thereto.
  collect and dispose within his own limits of   • (j) right of every owner of land abutting on a natural stream,
  all water under the land which does not          lake or pond to use and consume its water for drinking,
                                                   household purposes and watering his cattle and sheep; and the
  pass in a defined channel and all water on       right of every such owner to use and consume the water for
  its surface which does not pass in a             irrigating such land, and for the purposes of any manufactory
                                                   situate thereon, provided that he does not thereby cause
  defined channel.                                 material injury to other like owners.
                                                 • Explanation. -A natural stream is a stream, whether permanent
                                                   or intermittent, tide or tide-less, on the surface of land or
                                                   underground, which flows by the operation of nature only and in
                                                   a natural and known course.
The Indian Easements Act, 1882
                                                 • Section 10. - Lessor and mortgagor.-Subject
• Section 8. Who may impose easements? -           to the provisions of section 8, a lessor may
  An easement may be imposed by any one            impose, on the property leased, any
  in the circumstances, and to the extent, in      easement that does not derogate from the
  and to which he may transfer his interest
  in the heritage on which the liability is to
                                                   rights of the lessee as such, and a mortgagor
  be imposed.                                      may impose, on the property mortgaged, any
                                                   easement that does not render the security
• Section 9. Servient owners. -Subject to the
  provisions of section 8, a servient owner        insufficient. But a lessor or mortgag or
  may impose on the servient heritage any          cannot, without the consent of the lessee or
  easement that does not lessen the utility        mortgagee, impose any other easement on
  of the existing easement. But he cannot,         such property, unless it be to take effect on
  without the consent of the dominant              the termination of the lease of
  owner, impose an easement on the
  servient heritage which would lessen such        theredemption of the mortgage.
  utility.
The Indian Easements Act, 1882
• Section 52 "License" defined. -Where one
  person grants to another, or to a definite
  number of other persons, a right to do, or   •   59. Grantor's transferee not bound by license.
  continue to do, in or upon the immovable
  property of the grantor, something which
                                               •   60. License when revocable.-
  would, in the absence of such right, be      •   61. Revocation express or implied
  unlawful, and such right does not amount
  to an easement or an interest in the         •   62 License when deemed revoked
  property, the right is called a license.
                                               •   63. Licensee's rights on revocation
• 53 Who may grant license.
                                               •   64. Licensee's rights on eviction
• 54 Grant may be expressed or implied.
• 55. Accessory licenses annexed by law
• 56 License when transferable.
• 57. Grantor's duty to disclose defects
• 58. Grantor's duty not to render property
  unsafe
The Indian Easements Act, 1882
• Characteristics of License                        • 6) The person who grants the license must be the
                                                      owner of the property. The other
• 1) No transfer of interest:- A licence is a
  permission to do some act which, without          • person who gets the permission must be a
  such permission, would be unlawful.                 stranger or have no right in the property.
• 2) No interest in accretions :- A licensee has
                                                    • 7) Licence creates no duties and obligations upon
                                                      the person making the grant and is
  no interest in the property and therefore,he
  acquires no right by accretion                    • therefore revocable except in certain
                                                      circumstances expressly provided in the Act
• 3) Neither transferable nor heritable :- A
  licence is neither transferable; nor heritable.   • itself.
                                                    • 8) A licence is usually revocable by grantor, except
• 4) A licence is a matter purely personal            in the two cases mentioned in the
  between grantor and grantee.
                                                    • section 60 of Easement Act.
• 5) Section 52 of Easement Act does not
  require any consideration, material or non        • 9) A subsequent transfer of the property
  material,to be an element of the definition         terminates a licence.
  of licence, nor does it require that the right    • 10) A licensee cannot sue trespassers and
  under the licence must arise by way of              strangers in his own name.
  contract or as a result of mutual promises.       • 11) A license is terminated by death of either
                                                      party
Real Estate (Regulation&
Development) Act, 2016
 Real Estate and the housing sectors were highly unregulated
sectors
 The bill was passed by the Rajya Sabha on 10th March, 2016
 The Act came into force from 1 May 2016 with 69 of 92 sections notified.
 The Central and state governments are liable to notify the Rules under the Act within a statutory period of six
  months.
 To protect the interest of consumers in the Real Estate Sector and to establish an adjudicating
  mechanism for speedy dispute redressal.
 This law vests authority on the real estate regulator to govern both residential and commercial real
  estate transactions.
 This law makes it mandatory for developers to post all information on issues such as project plan,
  layout, government approvals, land title status, sub-contractors to the project, schedule for completion
  with the State Real Estate Regulatory Authority (RERA) and then in effect pass this information on to
  the consumers.
 The current practice of selling on the basis of ambiguous super built-up area for a real estate project
  will come to a stop as this law makes it illegal. Carpet area has been clearly defined in the law.
 The maximum jail term for a developer who violates the order of the appellate tribunal of the RERA is
  three years with or without a fine.
                                   SALIENT FEATURES
 Currently, if a project is delayed, then the developer does not suffer in any way. Now, the law ensures
  that any delay in project completion will make the developer liable to pay the same interest as the
  EMI being paid by the consumer to the bank back to the consumer
 The developer cannot make any changes to the plan that had been sold without the written consent of
  the buyer.
 This puts paid to a common and unpopular practice by developers to increase the cost of projects.
 Lastly, every project measuring more than 500 square metres or more than eight apartments will
  have to be registered with the RERA.
 The law mandates every builder to keep 70% of collection from every project in Separate Bank
  Account.
                         MAJOR PROVISIONS
The Major Provisions in the Act relates to following aspects:-
 REGISTRATION
 PROTECTION OF BUYERS
                                             4. Consequence
Regulations are into force now    1. Debar the promoters from accessing
                                                                                1. Time limit for registration
                                 the its website in relation to that project    For ongoing Projects – 3 months from
                                 2. Specifying his name in list of defaulters        commencement of this Act
Registration
                                              3. Revocation
                                                                                          2. Exceptions
                                          1. On complaint                         1. Area of land < 500 Sq. Meters
                                          2. Suo moto
                                                                                      2. No. Of apartments < 8
                                 Where promoters makes default or
                                 violates any terms or conditions of the
                                                                                3.In case of Renovation/ Repair/Re-
                                 approval or promoters involved in any kind
                                                                                            development
                                 of unfair      practice.
                         PROTECTION OF BUYERS
   The Act prohibits unaccounted money from being pumped into the sector.
   As now, 70 per cent of the money has to be deposited in bank accounts through
    cheques.
   A major benefit for consumers included in the Act is that builders will have to
    quote prices based on carpet area and not super built-up area
   Carpet area has been clearly defined in the Act to include usable spaces like
    kitchen and toilets.
                 REAL ESTATE REGULATORY
             AUTHORITY AND APPELLATE TRIBUNAL
   Appellate Tribunals will now be required to adjudicate cases in 60 days as against the
    earlier provision of 90 days
   Regulatory Authorities has to dispose of complaints in 60 days while no time frame was
    indicated in earlier Bill.
                 Hits & Misses of Real Estate Act
For Consumers
              HITS                                                MISSES
• Increased assertion on the timely completion of    • The timelines of approvals by regulatory
  projects and delivery to the consumer.               authorities have not been defined. Any delay
• A step towards safeguarding their investment,        in approvals from regulatory authorities could
  as 70 per cent of the sales receipt will now be
  locked in an escrow account.                         impact buyers as well.
• An increase in the quality of construction due     • The Bill may lead to slightly higher prices of
  to a defect liability period of five years.          properties due to the reduced competition.
• Balanced builder-buyer agreements.
                                                     • New project launches might be limited as
• Faster dispute resolution mechanism through          developers may not be able to launch without
  dispute settlement forums and appellate
  tribunal.                                            obtaining approvals, which could take two to
• Sale on the carpet area to help improve              three years.
  transparency.
• An increasingly-regulated broker environment.
• Greater visibility into the developer’s delivery
  track record.
                 Hits & Misses of Real Estate Act
For Developers
               HITS                                               MISSES
• Increased scope for eliminating casual             • An additional layer of approvals may be
  operators, leading to the better organization        introduced against the extended list of
  of the sector.                                       approvals already required for projects.
• Minimum standards of governance and                • No provision to rationalize the number of
  accountability have now been set to an               approvals required for a project or expedite
  extent, and there’s potential for driving            approvals through a single window
  standardization and professionalism in the           mechanism.
  sector.
                                                     • Increased reliance on external capital to
• Greater visibility into the developers’ delivery     achieve high growth.
  performances, segregating the established          • Possible   impact      on    joint    venture
  and casual operators.                                arrangements.
• Higher investment in the sector and a              • Potential delay in cash-flow realizations from
  possible reduction in the cost of funds,             projects.
  leading to a lowered cost for the end users.
Drivers and Growth for Real Estate
         and Construction
            Rising
           Tourism
Rise Of
Middle
           Real          Decline of
                            Joint
 Class    Estate          Families
             Easy
          Availability
          of Finance
         Fiscal
         Policy
          Real      Strong
Rising             Demograp
 FDI     Estate
                     hics
         Rise of
         Middle
          Class
            First
            Time
           Buyers
          Development
            of new
           Stream of
           Business
Overview of India Infrastructure
                Special Economic Zones
OBJECTIVES
                Generation of
                                       Promotion of exports
             additional economic
                                       of goods and services.
                  activities.
   Promotion of
                               Creation of              Development of
 investments from
                              employment            infrastructure facilities
domestic and foreign
                             opportunities.              in the country.
     sources.
                      Govt. Initiatives and Policy
                                                                   Range of
 There has been a                                                Government
drastic curtailment                                               benefits &
                                           Liberalization of
   in restrictive       Reforms in the                            incentives
                                          FDI rules and the
 policies such as         Integrated                               including
                                          emergence of real
 the Urban Land        Township Policy.                         residential tax
    Ceiling and                              estate funds.      breaks and the
 Regulation Act.                                               Special Economic
                                                                     Zones.
Major Players in Real Estate Sector
                                      THE
                                      BIG
                                      FIVE
DLF Group   
            
                Founded in 1946
                DLF Group is one of the biggest real estate giants
               Built many high-quality buildings across the country, specifically in
                Gurgaon
               Tied up with Hilton Group to build whopping 100 hotels in India over the
                next few years.
               In current expansion plans, DLF has over 425 million sq. ft. of
                development across its businesses, including developed, on-going and
                planned projects.
               Spread over 32 cities, mostly in metros and key urban areas across India
            Financials of DLF
               DLF is the market leader in this sector with net profit of 1547 cr.
               It was way lower than its last year profit by more than 1000 cr.
               It was well supported by the timely launch of IPL.
               The share of this co. touched the all time high of 1227 in dec. 2007 which
                was just 6 months after its issue and now trading at 337.
ANSALS    
          
              Founded by Lala Chiranji Lal Ansal
              By far most dominant activity of Ansals has been Real Estate Promotion & Development
             company has several landmark high-rise commercial building like Statesman House,
              Ambadeep, Antriksh Bhawan, Tolstoy House, Indra Prakash, Navrang House and Ansal
              Bhawan
             Ansals have also completed several residential buildings like Gauri Sadan, Upasana at
              Hailey Road & Dhawan Deep at Jantar Mantar road, all in the heart of New Delhi at
              Connaught Place.
             There is the most prestigious “Ansal Plaza” Shopping Mall associated with its work
             Also it has made elite townships, Sushant Lok and Palam Vihar in Gurgaon and several other
              places all over the country.
          Their profit declined by 81.24% in the last financial year over the last year.
          This is one of the badly hit company by the economic slowdown.
          569 is the all time high of this company in 2006 and now trading at just 10% of its all time
           high.
Parsavnath Developers
                        • It was incorporated on July 24, 1990 under the
                          Companies Act, 1956 as Parsvnath Developers
                          Limited.
Skill Shortage.
Overvaluation of Property.
Highly Fragmented.
Lack of Transparency.
IMPACT OF RECESSION ON REAL ESTATE
Represent a person (promoter) before any real estate regulatory authority for
 registration of real estate project,
Represent a person before any other competent authority for any other
 purpose under Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016.
 The passing of Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Bill, 2016 has
 opened a new opportunity for Company Secretaries holding Certificate of
 Practice in terms of consultancy services.
 By becoming an expert in the act he can indulge in providing advice in
 respect of -
a. Various applicable provision on particular real estate project;
b. Registration and extension procedure of real estate project with
   competent authority;
c. Various obligation, functions and duties of promoter in a real estate
   project;
d. Penal Provisions under the act.
 A Company Secretary holding certificate of practice as well a Company
 Secretary in employment in Promoter Company can assist a Promoter in
 registration of real estate project with the real estate Regulatory Authority
 established under the act.
Close to $7 billion to $8 billion of venture capital expected to flow into Indian
 real estate market.
A significant increase in project execution through Public- Private-Partnerships.
More demand for office and industrial space.
Current levels of investments in infrastructure are not sufficient to bridge the
 gap between demand and supply.
END
Transfer of property Act,1882
                       K.Sundarapandian, MRICS
                       IIV-RVF – On line class
                       Thanks to my Prof -
                       Dr.V.Sivaramasethu (Annamalai
                       Univewrsity) for the Notes
INTRODUCTION
• Exception
   Lease is an exception for the above rule
   A deed dedicating property to deity contained a condition absolutely restraining
    transfer is valid
Condition restraining Enjoyment
• If the transferor restraining the mode of its enjoyment the condition
  is void and the transferee is not bound by the condition
• It is applicable only where an absolute interest or ownership has been
  transferred. (In case of Sale , gift and exchange)
• Exception
      •    A condition or direction restraining the mode of enjoyment may be made by the
          transferor provided it is for beneficial enjoyment of transferor’s own adjoining property
Difference between Sec 10 and Sec 11
• Section 10                       • Section 11
• applicable to the transfers of   • It is applied to transfers of only
  absolute interest as well as       absolute interest (ownership)
  limited (partial) interest       • It refers to enjoyment
• It refers to a restraint on
  alienation
Transfer to unborn person
• The transfer should not postpone the vesting of the property in the
  unborn person beyond the attainment of the majority (Sec 14)
   • Any number of living person +18 years
The maximum limit fixed for postponing the
vesting of property
• Life or lives in existence at the date of
   transfer +minority of the ultimate beneficiary + with addition of the period of
  gestation provided gestation actually exists (i.e ultimate beneficiary is
  actually in mother womb at the death of the last person) (Sec 14)
• Where the transferor provides that the transfer shall take effect upon
  the happening of an event of must nature which is bound to occur in
  future here the nature of interest of the transferee is a vested
  interest (Sec 19)
• Ilustration : A makes a gift of his house to B. He simply executes the gift deed but does not
  specify any date on which the ownership to be transferred .The interest B is vested interest
• Nature of vested interest
    Present fixed right
    Transferable and heritable interest
    Time of vesting of interest
Contingent interest
• Contingency means uncertain future event
• Where the transferor provides that the transfer shall take effect upon the happening of an event
  that may or may not happen here the nature of interest of the transferee is contingent.(Sec21)
• Illustration
    •  A makes a gift of his property to B when he attains the age of 18 years or marries under that age with the condition neither
      attains that age nor marries with the consent of C the property goes to D . B and D both take a contingent interest in the
      property
    Nature of interest
    • Future possible interest
    • Not heritable
    • Transferable interest
Vested and Contingent Interest
Conditional Transfer
• Transfer of property with certain conditions is called conditional
  transfer
• When a property is transferred conditionally, The transfer is subject
  to conditions or limitations.
• The legal effect of the transfer may vary according to conditions (Sec
  25)
•
Three types of conditions
• Condition precedent: Conditions which is required to be fulfilled
  before the transfer of property taken place. It is prior to transfer
• Example
• A leases his property to B so long as B resides in the house of A . The
  conditions is collateral.
• The transfer(lease) remains in operation only till B fullfills the
  condition.(he continues to live With A)
• Election means choice
• it is a obligation to choose between two inconsistent alternative rights
• If through one instrument, you have two transactions – then you have to accept
  both the transactions or none. You can’t accept one and reject other.(Sec 35)
• Example: ‘The land in the Chidambaram is the property of ‘C’ and worth Rs 800/-
  A by instrument of gift proposes to transfer it to ‘B’ giving by the same
  instrument Rs 1000 to ‘C ‘. ‘C’ elects to retain the land. He forfeits the gift of Rs
  1000/-
•
Essentials of Doctrine of election
• Relationship between the parties (whether the real owner and the ostensible owner were related to
  each other or were strangers)
• Conduct of the parties in dealing with the property . (who used to take care of and had
  control over the property)
    • Essential
• Transfer of immovable property
• Made with intent to defeat the creditor
• Shall be voidable
Doctrine of part Performance
 • It is an equitable doctrine – Equity of part performance
 • A person has taken the possession of an immovable property on the basis of
   contract of sale either performed or is willing to perform his part of contract
   then he cannot of ejected on the ground the sale is unregistered (Sec 53 A)
 • After 2001 in sec 53 A –(the contract though required to be registered has not been registered) Removed
 • After 24.09.2001 .The contract of the transfer of immovable property with
   consideration as provided in 53A is now compulsorily registrable document.
          • Sec 17(1A) (to defeat the claim un registered document is not used) and Sec 49 (unregistered document
            cannot be an evidence in part performance) registration Act also amended .
Thank you