Mantiq Guide for English Readers
Mantiq Guide for English Readers
1
Foreword
Bismillah
This is the 2nd version of the Mantiq Notes & Diagrams in English. These
notes and diagrams are based on the Urdu book titled آسان منطقby Mufti Saeed
Palalanpuri Saheb (DB). These were made as the kitaab was being taught.
There are 120 terms with brief explanations and examples. Diagrams
corresponding to the terms have been placed in the appropriate places. Tamreens
(exercises) from the original Urdu book have also added. The answers to the
tamreens are at the end of the book.
I thank Allah first and then I thank the students who have tremendously
assisted in typing the notes and diagrams. (Some of those students are ‘ulama’
now, Ma-sha-allah.) I also ask Allah to grant ikhlas and qabuliat.
There are still many revisions to be made and mistakes to be corrected;
Insha-allah, by next year we plan to have a better 3rd version. For any
suggestions, corrections and advices, feel free to contact: suhel@duny.us.
Sincerely,
Darul Uloom New York Publications committee.
2
Part 1:تصورات
Lesson 1(P.8): Types of علم
)1(العلم
The image of something in one's mind.
For example:
When the word "Zaid" is mentioned, an image of Zaid comes to mind.
Add later: hashia page 8 -- parable about mirror
)2(التصديق
The knowledge of a certain thing being something or that a certain thing is not something.
A statement which can be classified as being true or false.
For example:
Zaid is Umar's father.
or
Zaid is not Umar's father.
)3(التصور
The knowledge of an idea or concept in such a manner that it would not be placed in the category of
tasdeeq.
Add later: hashia page 9---about being without any ‘nisbah tammah khabariyyah’. ‘Nisbah tammah khabariyyah’ means …??.
For example:
the knowledge of only “Zaid”.
or
the knowledge of only “Zaid’s slave”
3
Tamreen #1 (P.9)
4
Lesson 2(P.9): Types of تصورand تصديق
)4(التصور البديھي
A tasawwur (idea/concept) which is understood without a need for much explanation.
For example:
water, fire, heat, cold
)5(التصور النظري
A tasawwur (idea/concept) which cannot be understood unless it is explained and/or proven.
For example:
ism, fi’l, harf, mu’rab, mabni, angels, jinn
)6(التصديق البديھي
A tasdeeq (statement) which is understandable without need for much explanation.
For example:
2 is half of 4.
and
1 is one-fourth of 4.
)7(التصديق النظري
A tasdeeq which cannot be understood unless it is explained and/or proven.
For example:
Fairies (small female jinns) exist.
and
Allah is one pure being.
Diagram #1
5
Tamreen #2 (P.11)
Identify each as being a تصورor a تصديقas well as بديہىor نظرى.
Type: Arabic Urdu/English
تصديق/ تصور
پل صراط 1
Bridge of Siraat
جنت 2
Paradise
دوزخ 3
Hell
قبر کا عذاب 4
the punishment of the grave
چاند 5
moon
سورج 6
sun
آسمان 7
sky
زمین 8
Earth
دوزخ موجود ہے 9
Hell is real
میزان عمل 10
The scale of deeds
6
جنت کی نعمتیں 11
The bounty’s of paradise
عمرو کا بیٹا کھڑا ہے 12
Umar’s son is standing
حوض کوثر 13
the fountain of Kowthar
کوثر جنت کی نہر ہے 14
Kauthar is a river in paradise
آفتاب روشن ہے 15
The sun is bright/shinning
بغداد 16
Baghdad
امريکہ 17
America
معبود برحق صرف ہللا تعالی ہے 18
Allah is the only true deity
Lesson 3 (P.11)
7
)9(الدلیل والحجة
The acquiring and derivation of an unknown conclusion by combining two or more known تصديقات
(statements/postulates).
For example:
A person has the knowledge that “Humans are living creatures”.
And he also knows that “Every living creation possesses a physical body structure”.
So, when he combines both statements/postulates, he acquires the knowledge that “Human beings
possess physical body structures”.
)10(النظر والفكر
The acquiring and derivation of unknown knowledge/information by combining two or more known ideas
or pieces of information.
Examples are mentioned above in #8 and #9.
)11(الترتیب
To arrange the known statements/postulates ( )تصديقاتand ideas/concepts ()تصورات
ّ in their proper method or
order.
)12(المنطق
That knowledge which prevents one from making errors in نظر و فكر.
)13(الموضوع
The topics and subject matter that are discussed about in any field of knowledge.
For example:
The موضوعof ( نحوArabic grammar) is words and sentences ()كلمة و كالم.
)14(موضوع المنطق
The topics and subject matter that are discussed in Mantiq are those definitions ( )تعريفاتand proofs ()دلیل
through which the knowledge/information of unknown statements and ideas is obtained.
)15(غرض المنطق
The aim and goal of Mantiq is to correct the نظر و فكر.
8
Lesson 4 (P.15): Review Terms 1-15
Diagram #2A
9
Diagram #2B
Types of
داللة لفظیة
(Indicated) (Indicator)
مدلول دال
The being of Mr. Zaid. The word زيد * داللة لفظیة وضعیة
Difficulty, pain. The sound of آہ آہ لفظیة طبعیة
Diagram #2C
Types of
داللة غیر لفظیة
(Indicated) (Indicator)
مدلول دال
specific letters (A,B,C) inscriptions/letters غیر لفظیة وضعیة
the horse desires fodder the neighing of a horse غیر لفظیة طبعیة
fire smoke غیر لفظیة عقلیة
10
Diagram #2D
*Types of
داللة لفظیة وضعیة
(Indicated) (Indicator)
مدلول دال
towards the indication of
داللة مطابقیة
حیوان ناطق ""انسان
towards " "حیوانonly
the indication of
or داللة تضمنیة
""انسان
towards " "ناطقonly
the indication of
towards the “capability of understanding داللة التزامیة
""انسان
)16(الداللة
For something to indicate and give knowledge/information about an unknown thing--whether this indication
is done automatically/naturally or by stipulation.
For example:
By hearing the word “pen” one understands that it is a tool for writing.
And, by seeing “smoke” one understands that there is a fire nearby.
)17(الدال
The first thing (the indicator); which indicates towards the second thing.
Ex: the word “pen” or the smoke.
)18(المدلول
The second thing; which is indicated towards by the ( الدالthe indicator).
For example:
The tool of writing, or the fire.
11
)19(الوضع
One piece of information which is made specific (intentionally and deliberately) for another bit of
information in such a way, that when the first piece is comprehended, the other is understood and derived
from it.
For example:
Tthe word “pen” has been coined (and stipulated) to refer to an instrument of writing, and the word
“knife” has been coined to refer to a tool of cutting. By hearing the word “pen”, a writing tool is
understood,and by hearing the word “knife”, a tool of cutting is understood.
Another example: In bowling, the word strike means the hitting and dropping of all 10 pins, while in
baseball it means for a batter to miss the ball.
)20(الموضوع
The first word which is used to coin a term.
موضوعis a specific type of دال. (In other words, every موضوعis a دال, but every دالis not a موضوع.)
)21(الموضوع له
The second word; the term for which the موضوعis specified.
موضوع لهis specific type of مدلول. (In other words, every موضوع لهis a مدلول, but every مدلولis not a موضوع
له.)
)22(الداللة اللفظیة
That type of indication in which the indicator (the )دالis a spoken word.
For example:
The word “Zaid” indicates toward the being and physical body of Zaid.
12
)24(الداللة اللفظیة الوضعیة
That type of indication in which the indicator (the )دالis a spoken word and the indication is achieved
through stipulation/coinage.
For example:
The word “Zaid” indicates toward the being/person of Zaid himself.
13
)29(الداللة غیر اللفظیة العقلیة
That type of indication in which the indicator is not a spoken word and the indication is achieved through
intelligence/deduction.
For example:
Physical smoke indicates towards a fire.
Tamreen #3 (P.15)
In #5-#9, identify which type of داللةis going on. Also, identify which is the the دالand
which is the مدلول.
In #5-#9, only the دالis written. Thus, not only identify which type of داللةis going on,
but also give the مدلول.
Type of داللة Arabic Urdu
shaking the head- سر کا ہالنا- 1
yes or no ہاں يا نہیں
red flag- سرخ جھنڑی- 2
the train stopping ريل کا ٹھہرنا
sunlight- آفتاب- دھوپ 3
sun
Ah! Ah!- - اُوہ، اُوہ 4
sadness/grief رنج و صدمہ
pen قلم 5
Zaid زيد 8
human انسان 9
14
Lesson 7 (P.15): Types ofالداللة اللفظیه الوضعیه
)30(الداللة المطابقیة
That type of indication in which the word indicates towards its full and entire ( موضوع لهstipulated meaning);
and it does not indicate towards just a part of موضوع له.
For example:
The word انسانsaid with the intention to indicate fully towards حیوان ناطق.
Also, the word “knife” being said with the intention to indicate towards the entire knife, i.e. the word
“knife” being said with the intention to indicate towards the combination of the blade plus the
handle. The word “knife” is not said with the intention to just indicate towards the blade only, nor
just indicate towards the handle only; but rather the intention is both the blade and the handle.
)31(الداللة التضمنیة
That type of ( داللتindication) in which the word is intended to refer to only a part of the ; موضوع له
the word does not refer to the entire موضوع له.
For example:
The indication of ( انسانhuman being) with the intention that it refers only to ( حیوانliving creature),
or, the indication of ( انسانhuman being) with the intention that it refers only to ( ناطقcreature with
the capability of speech).
Another example:
The indication of the word “knife” with the intention that it refers only to the “handle”, or with the
intention that it refers only to the “blade”, and not referring to the handle and blade together. In the
same strain, when it is said: “The knife is very sharp”, the word knife is intended to mean the blade
only, not the handle. Why? Because blades are sharp while handles are not sharp.
Another example:
The basketball team scored a basket.” The intention was made that only 1 player scored a basket,
because all 5 players cannot score one basket all at the same time; but rather only 1 player can score
a basket at a time.
)32(الداللة اإللتزامیة
That type of ( داللتindication) in which the word is intended to refer to something attached to the موضوع له.
15
For example:
The indication of ( انسانhuman being) with the intention that it refers only to “the ability to possess
knowledge”. Since this is a quality attached or related to the haqeeqat of انسان, and it is not a quality
which is an integral part of the haqeeqat of انسان, thus it is a type of التزامیة داللة
Tamreen #4 (P.17)
Identify which is the the دالand which is the مدلول.
Type of Arabic Urdu
داللة
Blind- eye آنکھ-نابینا 1
Lame-Leg ٹانگ-لنگڑا 2
Tree- Branch شاخیں-درخت 3
Nose ring- Nose ناک-نکٹا 4
Al-Hidaayah - کتاب الصوم-ہدايۃ 5
The chapter of Sowm (Fasting)
Haatim Taai - the quality of سخاوت-حاتم طائی 6
generosity
)34(المركب
That word ( )موضوعin which the meanings of individual parts do indicate toward parts of the موضوع له.
16
In a مركبterm, the word ( )موضوعhas parts, and those parts are meaningful, and also each part of the word
( )موضوعindicates toward some part of the موضوع له, and such an indication ( )داللتis actually intended by
the speaker.
For example:
The statement: “Zaid is standing”. In this statement, the word “Zaid” indicates towards the being of
the person Mr. Zaid, while “standing” refers to a condition of the person Mr. Zaid, and the word “is”
indicates towards existence; and all of these indications are intended.
Tamreen #5 (P.19)
(35) المفھوم
Everything which can be imaged and understood in the mind.
(36) الجزئي
That مفھومwhose name is not shared by multiple individuals. In other words, it is a مفھومwhich refers to one
particular individual.
17
(37) الكلي
That مفھومwhose name is be shared between multiple individuals. In other words,it is a مفھومwhich refers to
multiple individuals.
Tamreen #6 (P.20)
Identify each as being a كلىor a ُجزي.
Type Arabic English Urdu
گھوڑا 1
بکری 2
میری بکری 3
زيد کا غالم 4
سورج 5
يہ سورج 6
آسمان 7
يہ آسمان 8
سفید چادر 9
سیاہ کرتہ 10
ستارہ 11
ديوار 12
يہ مسجد 13
يہ پانی 14
میرا قلم 15
18
Diagram #3A, p. 20-21
The ماھیة/ حقیقةof that كلي Name of كلي
English Arabic English Urdu
speaking/thinking creature = انسان Human انسان
حیوان ناطق
mooing creature = ثور Cow بیل
حیوان ذو خوار
braying creature = حمار Donkey گدھا
حیوان ناہق
neighing creature = فرس Horse گہوڑا
حیوان صاہل
bleating creature = غنم Goat بکری
حیوان ذو رغاء
19
Diagram #4, p. 20-21
20
Diagram #5
+ +
= (Plain Pizza)
21
(40) العوارض
Everything other than the ماھیة/ حقیقة. Those “extras” which are BESIDES the basic fundamental
components/elements which make up a thing. Those things on which the existence/identity of an object or
perception is NOT dependent upon.
For example:
To be “dark-skinned” or “fair-skinned” or to be “knowledgeable” or “ignorant” are the عوارضof
a انسان, because these qualities are not part of the ماھیة/حقیقةof انسان.
22
Tamreen #7 (P21)
(44) النوع
That collective noun which refers to a group of individuals whose ماھیة/ حقیقةare all the same.
For example:
انسانis a “ ”نوعbecause it refers to Zaid, Umar, Muaz, etc. and the ماھیة/ حقیقةof each one of these
are all the same.
(45) الفصل
That collective noun which refers to a group of individuals whose ماھیة/ حقیقةare the same AND that same
ماھیة/ حقیقةis the specific trait that acts as a differentiator/separator between it and other ماھیة/ حقیقة.
For example:
23
( ناطقability to speak) is the ( فصلdifferentiator/separator) for انسانbecause it refers to Zaid, Umar,
Muaz, etc. The ماھیة/ حقیقةof all these are the same AND ناطقdifferentiates and separates the / حقیقة
ماھیةof ( انسانhumans) from the ماھیة/ حقیقةof ( بقرcow), (غنمgoat), ( فرسhorse), ( حمارdonkey).
Diagram #6 p.21
عمق+ عرض+ طول+ جوھر Physical body =جسم 1
)Depth( )Width( )Length( )Tangible(
growing =نامي 2
ريح/ ہوآWind
24
Tamreen #8 (P.22)
For each pair mentioned, identify their relationship to one other in terms of being نوع, جنس,
or فصل.
English Arabic Urdu
Body- horse -حیوان 1
فرس
Pomegranate tree - جسم نامی2
درخت انار
Animal-hasaas -حیوان 3
حساس
Horse- neighing - فرس 4
صاہل
Horse - جسم مطلق5
فرس
Donkey- braying ناہق- حمار6
25
Lesson 13 (P.22): Types of الكلي العرض
(46) الخاصة
That type of كلي عرضيwhich is specific for one group of individuals--all of whose ماھیة/ حقیقةare identical.
For example:
The trait of ضاحكlaughing is specific for انسانhumans, because it is a trait specific for Zaid, Umar,
Bakr, etc. And the ماھیة/ حقیقةof each and every human (Zaid, Umar, Bakr, etc.) are all identical.
26
Diagram #4 (p. 22)
mafhoom—entity, idea
kulle dhaatee—main components
kullee ardhee—qualities, traits
khassah—traits/characteristics specific to only one group
ardhi aam— traits/characteristics that are shared with multiple groups
27
Diagram #5 (p. 24-25)
A جنسconsists of many ( انواعplural of )نوع.
A فصلdifferentiates between the many انواع.
Another Example
" "الصف الثالثis جنس قريبfor Zubair, Hamdan, Kahis,Ahmad, etc.
“DUNY Alim Course" is جنس بعیدfor Zubair, Hamdan, Kahis, Ahmad, etc
28
29
Diagram #7 p.20-22
Types of kullees
كلّي
عرضى كلّى
عام عرض
خاصة
ذاتى كلّى
فصل
نوع
جسم
30
Diagram #8 p.23
Khaassah vs. Ardh-Aaam
Example of صه
ّ خا:
31
Diagram # 9, p. 24-26
Thus:
جسم +نامى +متحرك باإلرادة +ناطق انسان =
32
Tamreen #9 (P.23)
For each pair mentioned, identify their relationship to one another in terms of being خاصہ
or عرض عام.
English Urdu Arabic
کاتب-انسان 1
قائم-انسان 2
ماشی-غنم 3
ہندی-انسان 4
33
Tamreen #10 (P.24)
Answer Arabic Translation Urdu #
34
Lesson 15 (P.25): Types of الجنسandالفصل
(51) الفصل القريب
That فصلwhich separates the ماھیة/ حقیقةof one individual from other individuals in the same جنس قريب.
Identify each as being قريب جنسor جنس بعیدor قريب فصلor بعید فصل.
English Urdu Arabic
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
35
Lesson 17 (P.27): Types of نسبتbetween 2 الكلي
(53) التساوي
That type of relationship between 2 كليin which each كليrefers to every individual of the other. Basically,
the 2 كليare synonymous to one another, and the individuals in each of the 2 كليare identical to one
another.
For example:
The relationship between انسانhuman and ناطقhuman, is a relationship of تساوي, because every انسان
(human) is ناطقand every ناطقis ( انسانhuman).
(54) التباين
That type of relationship between كليin which each كليdoes NOT refer to any individual of the other.
For example:
The relationship between (انسانhuman) and ( فرسhorse) is a relationship of تباين, because no انسان
(human) is a ( فرسhorse), and because no ( فرسhorse) is an ( انسانhuman).
1.تباين.2 تساوى
37
Tamreen #12 (P.28)
For each pair, identify which type of nisbat is occurring.
Type of nisbat English Urdu Arbic
فرس-حیوان 1
حجر-انسان 2
حمار-جسم 3
اسود-حیوان 4
كھجر-جسم نامى 5
كا درخت
جسم-حجر 6
غنم- انسان 7
انسان-رومى 8
حمار-غنم 9
صاھل- فرس 10
حیوان-حساس 11
38
الرسم الناقص )(60
.خاصه & جنس بعید which is a combination ofتعريف The type of
For example:
.ضاحك or onlyجسم ضاحك isانسان ofرسم ناقص The
39
)Tamreen #13 (P.29
معرف Identify the type of each
ّ given.
Type English
جوھر ناطق 1
جسم نامي ناطق 2
جسم حساس 3
جسم متحرک باإلرادہ 4
حیوان صا ھل 5
حیوان ناھق 6
جسم ناھق 7
حساس 8
ناطق 9
الكلمة لفظ وضع لمعنى مفرد 10
على معنى في نفسھا
الفعل كلمة دلت ٰ 11
.مقترنا بأح ِد األزمنة الثالثة
40
Lesson 20 (P.29): Review Terms 52-60
Part 2: تصديقات
41
42
43
(64) القضیة الحملیة
That ( قضیةstatement) which affirms something for something else (whether it is positive or negative).
In terms of nahw (Arabic grammar), a حملیة قضیةis usually classified as a jumlah ismiyyah.
(65) الموضوع
The 1st part of a حملیة قضیة. In terms of nahw, the 1st part of a حملیةقضیةis usually classified as a mubtada of
a jumlah ismiyyah.
For example:
The word “Zaid”, in the sentence “Zaid is standing.”
(66) المحمول
The 2nd part of a حملیة قضیة. In terms of nahw, the 2nd part of a حملیة قضیةis usually termed as a khabr of a
jumlah ismiyyah.
For example:
The word “standing”, in the sentence “Zaid is standing.”
(67) الرابطة
The “connector” that is between the ( موضوعthe 1st part of ) حملیة قضیةand the ( محمولthe 2nd part of the
)حملیة قضیة
For example:
The word(s) “is” or “is not”
Lesson 22 (P.32): Types of القضیة الحملیة
(68) القضیة المخصوصة
That type of حملیة قضیةin which the ( موضوعthe 1st part of ) حملیةقضیةis a specific person.
For example:
Zaid is standing.
45
السالبة الجزئیة )(75
.كلي is being applied to only some individuals of thatحكم which is negative AND theقضیة That type of
For example:
Some living creatures are not insaan.
46
Lesson 24 (P.34): Types of القضیة الشرطیة
(76) القضیة الشرطیة
That قضیةwhich is made by combining two smaller قضیة.
For example:
If the sun has risen, then it is day.
(77) المقدم
The first part of a قضیة شرطیة,
For example:
The sun has risen….
(78) التالي
The second part of قضیة شرطیة,
For example:
…it is day.
47
(80) الشرطیة المنفصلة
That type of in which between two smaller قضیةthere is affirmation (or negation) of both being true
together (or not). It is a قضیةwhich it states that the two smaller قضیةtruly exist together simultaneously or
it states that the two smaller قضیةcan never truly exist simultaneously.
For example:
This object is either a tree or it (this object) is a rock. [The speaker is stating that the object cannot
be a tree and a rock together.]
It can never be such that if the sun is out, that it is not daytime. [The speaker is stating that the sun
being out can never be in such a condition when it is not daytime, i.e. the sun being out can never be
in such a condition when it is not daytime. When the sun is out it must be daytime and vice versa:
When it is daytime the sun must be out.]
48
Diagram #15 p.35-37
Taqseem B for
قضیة الشرطیة منفصلة
Option 1 Option 2 Option 3 Option 4
Only A is true. Only B is true. A & B are both Neither A nor B
(B is not true) (A is not true) true together. is present.
قضیة الشرطیة Possible Possible Not Possible Not Possible
منفصلة عنادية
حقیقیة
(2 out of 4)
Possible Possible Not Possible Possible
قضیة الشرطیة
منفصلة عنادية
مانعة الجمع
(3 out of 4)
Possible Possible Possible Not Possible
قضیة الشرطیة
منفصلة عنادية
مانعة الخلو
(3 out of 4)
49
Note # 1:
If the statement is شرطیة منفصلة قضیةand is عنادية,
then this عنادية شرطیة منفصلة قضیةwill either be:
1. حقیقیةor it will be
2. مانعة الجمعor it will be
3. مانعة الخلو. (i.e. Taqseem B only applies on عنادية.)
Note # 2: If the statement is منفصلة اتفاقیة شرطیة, then Taqseem B will not apply.
50
Diagram #16 page 37
مانعة الجمع
This is either a tree [A] or a it is a rock [B].
The following 3 scenarios ARE possible:
Neither A nor B is
Only A allowed/possible allowed/possible
Only B allowed/possible
while (the object could be books,
while
B is not allowed/possible. or a pen, or a desk, etc.)
A is not allowed/possible.
The following 1 scenario is NOT possible: Both statements can never be true together. i.e. the object being
pointed at can never be a tree and a rock together at the same time (i.e. there is no such thing as a “tr-ock”)
This scenario
cannot exist:
51
Diagram # 17, p. 45
مانعة الخلو
A: Basheer is in the water B: Basheer is not drowning
The qualities of being kaatib and shaair are not related to one another; they are not connected, nor
are they attached to one another, nor are they dependent on one another.
53
Tamreen #15 (P.36)
Identify each type of قضیة.
Type Translation Arabic Urdu #
54
(86) مانعة الجمع
That قضیة منفصلةin which the nature of the حكمof the مقدمand تاليis such that both matters/qualities cannot be
together at the same time; but it is possible that neither exist simultaneously.
For example:
This thing is a tree or a rock. In other words, it can be a tree, or it can be a rock, or it can be neither
of the 2 because it is a desk, or it is a building or it is a book. But it can never be such that the thing
is a tree and a rock simultaneously.
55
)Tamreen #16 (P.38
.قضیة Identify each type of
This thing is a horse orمنفصلة عنادية يہ شے گہوڑا ہے يا گدھا ھذا الشيء اما فرس او 1
مانعة الجمع a donkey. حمار
منفصلة اتفاقیة This thing is either يہ چیز يا تو جان دار ہے يا ھذا الشيء اما حیوان او 2
living or white. سفید ہے ابیض
منفصلة عنادية Is Zaid an Alim or an زيد عالم ہے يا جابل ہے؟ زيد عالم او جاھل 3
حقیقیىة ?illiterate
منفصلة عنادية Does Amr speak or is عمرو يا تو بولتا ہے يا عمرو اما متكلم او ابكم 4
حقیقیىة he mute گونگا ہے
منفصلة اتفاقیة Is Bakr a poet or writer بکر شاعر ہے يا کاتب؟ بكر اما شاعر او كاتب 5
منفصلة عنادية Is Zaid in the masjid or زيد مسجد میں ہے يا گہر زيد اما في الدار او في 6
مانعة الجمع in the house میں المسجد
منفصلة عنادية Is Khalid sick or is he خالد بیماری ہے خالد اما مريض او صحیح 7
حقیقیىة healthy
منفصلة عنادية Is Zaid standing or زيد کھڑا ہے بیٹھا ہے زيد اما قائم او قاعد 8
مانعة الجمع sitting
منفصلة عنادية Man is either fortunate االدمي اما سعید او شقي 9
حقیقیىة or unfortunate.
56
Lesson 27 (P.38): Review Terms 61-87
(89) النقیض
Whenever there are two قضیةwhich have تناقض, each قضیةis a نقیضfor the other.
For example:
Zaid is an alim. & Zaid is not an alim
(90) النقیضین
The two قضیةin which there is تناقض.
57
وحدات ثمانیة Lesson 29 (P.40):
وحدات ثمانیة Lesson 30 (P.41): Remaining
59
قضايا محصورة میں تناقض Lesson 31 (P.42):
Diagram #19, P. 42
نقیض
سالبة جزئیة موجبه كلیة
بعض انسان جاندار نہیں ہیں جاندار ہے ہرانسان
بعض االنسان لیس حیوانا حیوان انسان کل
Some humans are not living. All humans are living.
60
Diagram #20
61
Tamreen #17 (P.42)
If only 1 statement is written, give its naqeedh.
If 2 statements are written, figure out if they are naqeedh of eachother or not. If not, explain
which shart is missing.
English Arabic Urdu #
All horses are animals-
Some horses aren’t animals
Some animals are goats-
Not all animals are goats
No humans are trees-
Some humans are trees
Umar is in the masjid-
Umar is not home
Bakr is Zaid’s son- Bakr is not
Umar’s son
The Englishman is white-
The Englishman is not white
Every human has a body-
Some humans don’t have a
body
Some white things are living-
No white things are living
Some animals are not donkeys-
All animals are donkeys
Some humans are writers-
No humans are writers
Some goats are not black-
All goats are black
Zaid sleeps at night- Zaid
doesn’t sleep in the day
62
)Tamreen #18 (P.44
63
Lesson 33 (P.44): Review Terms 88-91
???Unable to turn Horizontal
قیاسLesson 34 (P.45):
محمول موضوع
حد اوسط
اصغر
صغري حیوان
انسان كل
اكبر
اصغر
نتیجة جسم
جسم انسان كل
64
(92) القیاس
To derive a conclusion from two قضیةin such a manner that when both are accepted as being true, it
automatically necessitates the acceptance of another قضیة.
For example:
“Every human is a living creature.” and “Every living creature has a body.” If these 2 statements are
accepted as being true, then it must be accepted that “Every human has a body.”
So the first 2 قضیةare the قیاس, and the 3rd derived statement is the نتیجةof that قیاس.
(93) األصغر
The موضوعof the نتیجة.
For example:
“Human” ( )اإلنسانas in the mentioned example.
(94) األكبر
The محمولof the نتیجة.
For example:
“has a body” ( ) جسمas in the previously mentioned example.
(95) المقدمة
Those قضیةwhich become part of the قیاس.
For example:
In the mentioned example, “Every human is a living creature.” is the 1 st مقدمة, and “Every living
creature has a body.” is the 2nd مقدمة.
(96) الصغرى
The مقدمةof the قیاسwhich contains the اصغر.
For example:
“Every human is a living creature.” in the mentioned example.
65
(97) الكبرى
The مقدمةof the قیاسwhich contains the اكبر.
For example:
“Every living creature has a body.” in the mentioned example.
66
Pg 47--DIAGRAM #22
4 Shakals--QIYAS SET-UP
# 1شكل
محمول موضوع
حد اوسط
كلیه موجبه
اصغر )(+ )(+
صغر حیوان
ي انسان كل
اكبر
كلیه موجبه
اصغر )(+ )(+
نتیجة جسم
جسم انسان ك
ل
67
# 2شكل
محمول موضوع
حد اوسط
كلیه موجبه
اصغر )(+ )(+
صغري حیوان
انسان كل
68
# 3شكل
محمول موضوع
اصغر
كلیه موجبه
حد اوسط )(+ )(+
حیوان انسان
صغري
كل
69
# 4شكل
محمول موضوع
اصغر
كلیه موجبه
حد اوسط )(+ )(+
حیوان
صغري انسان كل
70
Lesson 36 (P.48): Types of قیاس
(100) القیاس اإلستثنائي
The type of قیاسin which the نتیجةor the نقیضof the نتیجةis mentioned therein.
For example:
When the sun is out, then the day is present ()صغرى.
But the sun is out ()كبرى.
So the day is present ()نتیجة.
71
Kulliya vs Juzziyah
نتیجہ کبری صغری
کلیہ ()+ کلیہ ()+ ) (+کلیہ 1
جزءيہ ()- جزءيہ ()- ) (-جزءيہ 2
جزءيہ ()- جزءيہ ()- ) (+کلیہ 3
جزءيہ ()- کلیہ ()+ ) (-جزءيہ 4
72
Diagram #23 P. 48-49
قیاس استثنائ
فانھار موجود صغري لو كانت الشمس طالعة تو دن موجود ے جب سورج نكال ئو
لكن الشمس طالعة كبري لیكن سورج نكال ئواے
فانھار موجود نتیجة پس دن موجود ے
………………………………………………
فانھار موجود صغري لو كانت الشمس طالعة تو دن موجود ے جب سورج نكال ئو
لكن النھار لیس موجود كبري لیكن دن موجود نہیے
فالشمس لیست طالعة نتیجة پس سورج نكال ئو نہی ے
73
Lesson 36 (P.48): Types of قیاس
(100) القیاس اإلستثنائي
The type of قیاسin which the نتیجةor the نقیضof the نتیجةis mentioned therein.
For example:
When the sun is out, then the day is present ()صغرى.
But the sun is out ()كبرى.
So the day is present ()نتیجة.
74
(104) االصل
The first جزءيin which the حكمis found. Another name is مقیاس علیه
(105) الفرع
The second جزءيin which that same حكمis applied to and extrapolated to. Another nameis مقیس
(106) العلة
The reason which was pondered about and concluded to exist in the first ( جزءيand exists in the second
جزءيas well.)
(107) الحكم
The حكمwhich exists in the first ( جزءيand is also applied to the second جزءي.)
……………………………………………………………………….
75
76
قیاس إقتراني
صغري كل
كبري كل
نتیجة كل
77
الدلیل العلمي و الدلیل اإلنيp52
ل ّمي
…………………………………………
إني
78
Trans. of Footnote on pg. 52
#1 ???
#2 Forming a conclusion using ّ الدلیل ال ِل ّمis termed as تعلیل
ي
Forming a conclusion using ّ ّالدلیل اإلنis termed as استدالل
ي
#3 (The word) ( حقیقتin the book) and (the word) ( واقعin the book) are
interchangeable
#4 It should effortlessly be noted that establishing a حكمvia its true origin
(cause) is termed ي ّ الدلیل ال ِل ّم
ّ ّالدلیل اإلن
While establishing a حكمvia its عالمةis called ي
e.g., “fire” is the cause for “smoke”
while “smoke” is an indication towards “fire”.
Therefore, if a person were to see a blazing fire (whose smoke exits through
the chimney), and had not seen the smoke, and then says to himself, “There
is a fire present, and since there is a fire, that means there is smoke present
as well”, then this is an example of ي ّ الدلیل ال ِل ّم.
On the other hand, if the person were to only see smoke coming out of a
chimney and had not seen the fire, and then says to himself, “There is a
smoke present, and since there is a smoke, that means there is a fire present
ّ ّالدلیل اإلن
as well”, then this is an example of ي
79
Lesson 41 (P.44): Explanation of مادہَ قیاس
1 يقین
قیاس برھاني 100%
certain
2 ظن
قیاس خطابي 51 – 99% (educated گمان
guess) Probable
4 وھم
قیاس شعري 1 – 49%
(wild guess)
5 Lies
قیاس سفسطي 0% كذب
چھوٹے
80
Trans. of Footnote on pg. 54
If the existence of one of the two seems likelier than the other, then the one
with the higher probability is called ظن,
and the one with the lower probability is called وھم
If there occurs no doubt about the existence of one of the two then that is
called يقین
81
Lesson 42 (P.55): Remaining types of قیاس
(112) القیاس الخطابي
That قیاسwhich consists of such مقدماتstatements which the mind has a predominant feeling that they are
true.
For example:
Sughraa: Farming is beneficial.
Kubraa: Every beneficial thing should be adopted.
Nateejah: Farming should be adopted.
82
Lesson 43 (P.55)
(115) االولیات
Those ( مقدماتstatements) which the mind is instantaneously inclined towards just by mentioning the
mowdhoo and the mahmool.
For example:
The whole (kul) is made up of the parts (juz).
(116) الفطريات
Those ( مقدماتstatements) which are such that when they come to mind the daleel does not disappear from
the mind.
For example:
The number 4 is even, the number 3 is odd.
(117) الحدسیات
Those ( مقدماتstatements) which the mind is instantaneously inclined towards and no need is there for
putting a sughraa and kubraa together.
For example:
If an expert in nahw was asked, what is the word “”مساجدmasaajid, he would immediately reply that
it is ghair-munsarif jama-muntah’l-jumoo.
(118) المشاھدات
Those statements which are known though the five external senses or five internals senses.
For example:
The sun is bright, we feel hungry/thirsty
(119) التجربیات
Those statements which are proven through repeated experiences.
For example:
The violet flower is good as a cold remedy
83
(120) المتواترات
The statements which are known by such a large quantity of people, that to agree upon the fact that the
statements are lies cannot be accepted by the mind.
Ex: The Quran is word of Allah (swt)
Muhammad (sallahu –alayhi-wasallam) is his messenger.
Lesson 45 (P.57)
Tamreen #20 (P.47)???---MISSING
84
Answer Key
for Tamreens
85
)Tamreen #1 (P.9
87
تصديق بدہیہی الشمس مشرقة/منیرة آفتاب روشن ہے 15
The sun is bright/shinning
تصور بدہیہی/نظريہ بغداد بغداد 16
Baghdad
تصور بدہیہى/يقینني األمريكة امريکہ 17
America
تصور بدہیہی المعبود الحقیقي ھو ہللا فقط معبود برحق صرف ہللا تعالی ہے 18
Allah is the only true deity
)Tamreen #3 (P.15
دال is going on. Also, identify which is the theداللة In #5-#9, identify which type of
.مدلول and which is the
is goingداللة is written. Thus, not only identify which type ofدال In #5-#9, only the
.مدلول on, but also give the
داللة Type of Arabic Urdu
داللت غیر لفظیہ تحرك الرئیس- shaking the head- سر کا ہالنا- 1
وضعیہ نعم و ال yes or no ہاں يا نہیں
داللت غیر لفظیہ األحمر-
ُ العلم red flag- سرخ جھنڑی- 2
وضعیہ وقف القطار the train stopping ريل کا ٹھہرنا
داللت غیر لفظیہ شواعًالشمس - sunlight- دھوپً -آفتاب 3
عقلیہ الشمس sun
داللت لفظیہ أوهًً،أوه - Ah! Ah!- اُوهًً،اُوه - 4
طبعیہ الحزن sadness/grief رنج و صدمہ
داللت لفظیہ القلم pen قلم 5
وضعیہ
داللت لفظیہ اللوح writing board تختی 6
وضعیہ
داللت لفظیہ المدرسه )madrasah (school مدرسہ 7
وضعیہ
داللت لفظیہ زيد Zaid زيد 8
وضعیہ
داللت لفظیہ االنسان human انسان 9
وضعیہ
88
Tamreen #4 (P.17)
Identify which is the the دالand which is the مدلول.
Type of Arabic Urdu
ً ًداللة
داللت تضمنی عین-أعمى Blind- eye آنکھ-نابینا 1
داللت تضمنی رجل-اَعْرج Lame-Leg ٹانگ-لنگڑا 2
داللت تضمنی ِ فُ ُر-شجرة
ع Tree- Branch شاخیں-درخت 3
داللت التزامی Nose ring- Nose ناک-نکٹا 4
داللت تضمنی Al-Hidaayah - کتاب الصوم-ہدايۃ 5
The chapter of Sowm (Fasting)
داللت التزامی Haatim Taai - the quality of سخاوت-حاتم طائی 6
generosity
Tamreen #5 (P.19)
89
)Tamreen #6 (P.20
ُ .جزي or aكلى Identify each as being a
Type Arabic English Urdu
كلى فرس horse گھوڑا 1
كلى غنم goat بکری 2
ُجزي غنمي my goat میری بکری 3
كلى غالم زيد Zaid’s slave زيد کا غالم 4
كلى الشمس Sun سورج 5
كلى ھذا الشمس this sun يہ سورج 6
كلى السمآء sky آسمان 7
ُجزي ھذا السمآء this sky يہ آسمان 8
كلى رداءًأبيض white sheet سفید چادر 9
كلى قميصًأسود black shirt سیاہ کرتہ 10
كلى نجم star ستارہ 11
كلى لجدار wall ديوار 12
ُجزي ھذا مسجد this masjid يہ مسجد 13
ُجزي ھذا ماء this water يہ پانی 14
ُجزي قلمي my pen میرا قلم 15
)Tamreen #7 (P21
90
Tamreen #8 (P.22)
For each pair mentioned, identify their relationship to one other in terms of being جنس, نوع,
or فصل.
English Arabic Urdu
حیوانis a جنس قريبfor فرس Body- horse -حیوان 1
and فرس
فرسis a نوعfor حیوان
جسم نامیis a جنس بعیدfor درخت انار Pomegranate tree - جسم نامی2
درخت انار
) حساسi.e ) متحرک باألرادہis a فصل Animal-hasaas -حیوان 3
for حیوان حساس
صاہلis the فصلfor فرس Horse- neighing - فرس 4
صاہل
جسم مطلقis the جنس بعیدfor فرس Horse - جسم مطلق5
فرس
ناہقis the فصلfor حمار Donkey- braying ناہق- حمار6
Tamreen #9 (P.23)
For each pair mentioned, identify their relationship to one another in terms of being خاصہ
or عرض عام.
English Urdu Arabic
خاصہ human- writer کاتب-انسان 1
عرض عام human- standing قائم-انسان 2
عرض عام goat-walking ماشی-غنم 3
ہندی-عرض human- Indian ہندی-انسان 4
91
)Tamreen #10 (P.24
Answer Arabic English Urdu #
حیوان What are a Humanاالنسان والفرس ماھما؟ انسان اور گہرا کیا چیز 1
?and a horse ہیں؟
حیوان الفرس وشاة ما ھما؟ What are a horse گہوڑا اور بکری کیا ہیں؟ 2
?and a goat/sheep
جسم مطلق شجر عنب و حجر ما درخت انگور اور پتہر کی What is the reality 3
ھم؟ of a grape tree and حقیقت کیا ہے؟
?a stone
جسم مطلق اسماء واألرض و زيد What are these: آسمان ،زمین اور زيد کیا 4
ما ھم؟ sky, earth/land, ہیں؟
?And Zaid
جسم مطلق الشمس ،القمر و شجر What are these سورج ،چاند اور آم کا 5
منجاء ما ھم؟ things: the sun, درخت کیا ہے؟
the moon, and a
?mango tree
حیوان الذباب ،عصفور مکہی ،چڑيا اور گرجا کیا What are these: 6
والحمار ما ھم؟ fly, bird/sparrow, ہیں؟
?and a donkey
حیوان ناطق ھل انسان ما ھو؟ انسان کی حقیقت کیا ہے؟ What is the reality 7
?)if human (insaan
حیوان صاھل الفرس ما ھو الحقیقة؟ What is the گہڑے کی ماہیت کیا ہے؟ 8
maahiyat of a
?horse
حیوان ناھق الحمار ما ھو الحقیقة؟ What is the reality گدہے کی حقیقت کیا ہے؟ 9
?of a donkey
جسم مطلق شاة و لبنان و حجر ما What are these: 10
ھم؟ sheep, brick, and بکری اينٹ اور پتھر کیا
?stone ہیں؟
جوھر الماء و ريح و حیوان ما What are these: پانی ہوا اور حیوان کیا 11
ھم؟ water, air, and ہیں؟
?animal
92
Tamreen #11 (P.23)
Identify each as being جنس قريبor جنس بعیدor فصل قريبor فصل بعید.
English Urdu Arabic
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
93
)Tamreen #13 (P.29
معرف Identify the type of each
ّ given.
Type English
حد ناقص لإلنسان جوھر ناطق 1
حد ناقص لإلنسان Growing, Intelligent Body جسم نامي ناطق 2
حد ناقص للحیوان Being with free will جسم حساس 3
حد ناقص للحیوان Body that has free will جسم متحرک باإلرادہ 4
حد تام للفرس Neighing animal حیوان صا ھل 5
حد تام للحمار Braying animal حیوان ناھق 6
حد ناقص للحمار Braying Body جسم ناھق 7
حد ناقص للحیوان Free will حساس 8
حد ناقص لإلنسان Intelligence/ability to speak ناطق 9
حد تام للكلمة A word stipulated for a singular meaning الكلمة لفظ وضع لمعنى مفرد 10
حد تام للفعل A word that can be understood by itself على معنى في نفسھا
الفعل كلمة دلت ٰ 11
and is contained in one of the three tenses .مقترنا بأح ِد األزمنة الثالثة
94
Part 2: تصديقات
95
)Tamreen #15 (P.36
.قضیة Identify each type of
Type Translation Arabic Urdu #
متصلة If this thing is a horse then لو كان ھذا الشئ فرسا فھو 1اگر يہ شے گہوڑا ہےتو جسم
لزومیة its body is definite. جسم ضرور ہے
متصلة If a horse neighs than a لو كان فرس صاھل فا إلنسان اگر گہوڑا ہنہنا واال ہے تو 2
اتفاقیة human is a possessor of a جسم انسان جسم واال ہے
body.
متصلة لو كان لیال فالشمس طالعةThis is not the issue that if . يہ بات نہیں ہے کہ اگر رات 3
لزومیة it is night then the sun is ہوگی تو سورج نکال ہوا ہو
out.
متصلة If the sun rises then the لو كانت الشمس طالعة اگر سورج نکلے گا تو زمین 4
لزومیة land will be bright. فاألرض مشرقة روشن ہوگی
متصلة If you perform wudu then إن توضأت فالصلوة صحیحة اگر وضو کرو گے تو نماز 5
لزومیة salah will be correct. صحیح ہوگی
متصلة If you do good deeds then لو عملت الصاحات باإليمان اگر ايمان کے ساتھ اعمال 6
لزومیة you will go to Jannah. دخلت الجنة صالحہ کرو گے تو جنت میں
جاؤ گے
96
)Tamreen #16 (P.38
.قضیة Identify each type of
This thing is a horse orمنفصلة عنادية يہ شے گہوڑا ہے يا گدھا ھذا الشيء اما فرس او 1
مانعة الجمع a donkey. حمار
منفصلة اتفاقیة This thing is either يہ چیز يا تو جان دار ہے يا ھذا الشيء اما حیوان او 2
living or white. سفید ہے ابیض
منفصلة عنادية Is Zaid an Alim or an زيد عالم ہے يا جابل ہے؟ زيد عالم او جاھل 3
حقیقیىة ?illiterate
منفصلة عنادية Does Amr speak or is عمرو يا تو بولتا ہے يا گونگا عمرو اما متكلم او ابكم 4
حقیقیىة he mute ہے
منفصلة اتفاقیة Is Bakr a poet or writer بکر شاعر ہے يا کاتب؟ بكر اما شاعر او كاتب 5
منفصلة عنادية Is Zaid in the masjid or زيد مسجد میں ہے يا گہر زيد اما في الدار او في 6
مانعة الجمع in the house میں المسجد
منفصلة عنادية Is Khalid sick or is he خالد بیماری ہے خالد اما مريض او صحیح 7
حقیقیىة healthy
منفصلة عنادية Is Zaid standing or زيد کھڑا ہے بیٹھا ہے زيد اما قائم او قاعد 8
مانعة الجمع sitting
منفصلة عنادية Man is either fortunate االدمي اما سعید او شقي 9
حقیقیىة or unfortunate.
97
Tamreen #17 (P.42)
If only 1 statement is written, give its naqeedh.
If 2 statements are written, figure out if they are naqeedh of eachother or not. If not, explain
which shart is missing.
English Arabic Urdu #
تناقض All horses are animals- -كل فرس حیوان 1
Some horses aren’t بعض
animals الفرس لیس حیوانا
98
تناقض Some goats are not -بعض الشاة لیس اسود 1
black- كل شاة اسود 1
All goats are black
نھار الى لیل-وحدة زمان Zaid sleeps at night- Zaid -زيد نائم في اللیل 1
doesn’t sleep in the day 2
Day to night زيد لیس نائم في النھار
99
الصائم مسلم
100