Updated Company Law Notes 300 Accounting
Updated Company Law Notes 300 Accounting
Updated Company Law Notes 300 Accounting
4. Business Name
CAMA provides that the Registrar shall cause business names to be registered in accordance
with the provisions of this part of this Act. That is, a firm or company having a place of business
in Nigeria and carrying on business under a business name must register in the manner provided
by the Act.
It is cheaper, has privacy and can be easily dissolved but has no limited liability or
perpetual succession. It need not be registered but can be registered where a company, firm or
individual wants to carry a name other than his real surname(s). Instances where there is a minor,
the minor’s signature must be counter-signed by a senior police officer or a lawyer, and the word
‘minor’ must be written opposite his name.
4. INCORPORATED COMPANIES
Incorporated companies are also referred to as body corporate or registered companies.
They have legal personality, that is, they can sue and be sued because they are legal entities
distinct and separate from the persons of which they consist upon registration.
This is the most common type of companies in Nigeria today and the most suitable
business organisation for running an investment for profit. For the purpose of our class, we shall
be concerned mainly with incorporated companies.
Basically, there are three types of companies provided by CAMA:
1. Company Limited by Shares.
2. Unlimited Company and
3. Company limited by guarantee.
Any of these three companies may either be a private or public company. From this, the
picture of six will emerge:
a. Public Company limited by shares.
b. Private Company limited by shares.
c. Public Company limited by guarantee.
d. Private Company limited by guarantee.
e. Public Unlimited Company and
f. Private Unlimited Company.
Limited Liability Company
A company where the liability of its members limited by the memorandum, as to the
amount, if any, unpaid on the shares respectively held by them. It is the largest type of
companies which is normally employed for business purposes. The shares create very valuable
security and the limitation of liability enables the shareholder to determine the limit of his
liability and indebtedness. The shares, as the unit of holding, represent the involvement and
commitment of the interest of the holders. Apart from special circumstances when the liability
may be extended, for example, where a company carries on business with less than the minimum
number of members or the authorized minimum share capital.
Remuneration of Promoters
The services of promoters are very peculiar, and a great skill, energy and ingenuity may
be required and employed in the promotion exercise. Though, a promoter has no right against the
company to payment for his promotion services and expenses unless there is a valid contract for
him to do so – Re English and Colonial Produce Company (1906) 2 CH. 435 CA. And, since
pre-incorporation contracts are not binding on, or enforceable by, or against the company, it may
be difficult for promoters to have an enforceable contractual right to remuneration for their
services and indemnify for their expenses.
Unlike the common law position, a promoter can now recover remuneration by action
against the company if the contract is ratified or adopted by the company after incorporation
since, such a contract or transaction may now be ratified. In Garba v. Sheba (supra) at 401, the
court held that it has always been the case that a promoter has no right against the company for
payment of services rendered before the incorporation of the company and that a promise to pay
him by the company is neither binding nor enforceable against the company because the
consideration is a past consideration.
Doctrine of ultra-vires
The company being an artificial person must act through its designated officers and
human agents. If the agents of the company (the general meeting and directors) make a decision
we can say that the decision is an act of the company. The essence of the MEMART is for the
company to act within the scope of its objects and other rules it sets for itself. It is possible that
the company is not empowered to do the act in the memorandum of association. The
memorandum is the document that specifies the type of businesses or activities that the company
may legitimately embark upon, where the company therefore does any other business or actively
not within the objects clause of the memorandum it is regarded as ultra vires of the company and
the law regards such act as a nullity. There has been much modification and amendment to the
common law position by legislation (CAMA).
Anybody planning to deal with a company must be interested in the capacity and powers
of the company. The capacity and powers of the company are spelt out in the Memorandum of
the company. Anything outside the object clause cannot be done by the company as the company
exist only for the matters within the object clause, whatever therefore is not within the objects of
the company as stated in the objects clause is therefore ultra vires the company or it is beyond its
powers and it is illegal for the company to do it.
Before the promulgation of CAMA, a person can neither sue nor be sued on an ultra
vires contract that is still executory. If the ultra vires contract is executed, a supplier of goods
cannot sue to recover the price. He can also follow the goods he had supplied and recover them
if he could still identify them. But where the goods have been consumed, then he is not entitled
to anything as was decided in the case of Re: Jon Beauforte (1953) 1 CH. 131.
This doctrine was laid down in the case of Ashbury Railway Carriage &Imen Co. v
Riche (1875) LR7 H.L. In the case, the objects of the company are to make and sell or lend or
hire railway carriages and wagons, and all kinds of railway plants, fittings, machinery and rolling
stocks, to carry on the business of mechanical engineers, and general contractors, to purchase,
issue, work and sell, mines, minerals, or other materials and to buy any such materials on
commission as agents. A contract to finance the construction of a railway in Belgium was
entered into by the directors, subsequently, the company repudiated the contract and pleaded it
was ultra vires when sued, the court held that the company was not liable the contract was ultra
vires the directors and the company and since it was therefore void and not voidable the whole
body of shareholders could not ratify it. Lord Coirns in his judgment said;
“This contract was entirely, beyond the objects in the
Memorandum of Association….it is not a question of whether the
contract ever was ratified or was not ratified. If it was a contract
void at its beginning, it was because the company could not make
the contract. If every shareholder had said “that is a contract which
we desire to make, which we authorize the directors to make, to
which we sanction the placing of the seal of the company; the case
would not have stood in any different position from that in which it
stands now, the shareholders would have been attempting to do the
very thing which the Act of Raiment, they were prohibited from
doing”.
In Nigeria, CAMA whittled down the harsh position of the common law above. A
company shall not carry on any business not authorised by its Memorandum and shall not exceed
the powers conferred upon it by its Memorandum or the CAMA. Where a company engages in
an ultra vires transaction, a member may bring an action either under the law. On the application
of a member, the court may by injunction or declaration restrain the company from the
following:
a. Entering into illegal or ultra vires transaction.
b. Committing fraud.
c. Benefiting from their negligence or from their breach of duty.
makes provision for those who may sue on ultra vires transaction.
These are:
a. A member or a shareholder of the company.
b. A creditor or holder of a debenture secured by a floating charge.
It should be noted that CAMA has whittled down the provision by encouraging a company to
engage in an ultra vires transaction since it declares that the property can be kept under such
transaction. The implication of these provisions is that ultra vires acts can go on unabated in a
company until shareholders or creditors sue. However, when they sue, the court can, by way of
injunction, prohibit such transaction not stated in the object clause.
Also, on the application of a minority shareholder, the court may prohibit by way of
injunction the doing of any act or the transfer of any property in breach. If the transaction sought
to be prohibited under the proceedings are in respect of a contract to which the company is a
party, the court may set aside the contract and prohibit its performance and may allow to the
company and the other party compensation for loss or damage sustained thereby.
Classes of Shares
Shares are of different classes and have different rights attaching to them. The main types of
shares are,
a. Preference shares;
b. Ordinary shares; and
c. Deferred shares.
Preference Shares
CAMA defines preference share as a share, by whatever name designated, which does
not entitle the holder of it to any right to participate beyond a specified amount in any
distribution, whether by way of dividend or on redemption, in a winding up or otherwise. Where
dividend is declared, preference shareholders are entitled to a specified percentage even if
dividend is not paid to ordinary shareholders. They are more or less ‘creditors of the company’.
If authorised by its Articles of Association, shall issue preference shares which shall, or
at the option of the company be liable to be redeemed unless they are fully paid, and redemption
shall be made only out of profit; or the proceeds of a fresh issue of share.
These are shares which give their holders priority over other classes of shareholders in
relation to dividend before anything is paid on other classes of shares. The main feature of this
type of shares is that it entitles the holder to a fixed preferential dividend – this means that the
dividend payable by the company to the holder of such shares is fixed at a specific figure; it may
be 5% or 100% etc.
The dividend must be must not be paid out of capital but out of profits because this will
amount to an illegal return of capital to the preference shareholder. The dividend must be paid
before the ordinary shareholders receive their own dividends, that is, preference shares has
priority over ordinary shares.
As between ordinary shares, preference shares and deferred shares, preference shares are
usually more expensive so that if an ordinary share goes for N1.00, for instance, a unit of
preference share may go for as much as N20.00.
In the event of winding-up of a company and unless it is expressly stated in the Articles of
Association, preference shareholders have no inherent priority as to the repayment of capital. If
the assets are not enough to pay the preference and ordinary shares in full, both preference and
ordinary shares are paid off rateably according to the nominal value of the shares.
Ordinary Shares
These are sharers that do not attract special rights or privileges over other shares, but they
form bulk of the company’s capital. They are the risk bearers as they are only entitled to
dividend when one is declared provided the company has made a profit to warrant the
declaration of the dividend. The holders have an equal right to share in the profit of the company
declared by way of dividend. In the event of liquidation, they rank after the preference
shareholders except the Articles of Association otherwise provide.
Ordinary shares usually attract no special rights and carry no fixed rate of dividend or
interest. They bear the major financial risk of the company and are, therefore, often the “equity
shares of the company”. They carry the remaining of distributed profits after the preference
shareholders have been paid their fixed dividend. Therefore, they assume greater risk than
preference shares. When the business is unsuccessful, ordinary shareholders bear the loss.
However, an obvious advantage of ordinary shares to ordinary shareholders is that their
dividends are not fixed and they may rise considerably with the level of profitability of the
company. Another advantage of ordinary shares is that voting power and strength of the ordinary
shareholders in general meeting allow them to control the resolution of the meetings. Ordinary
shares carry the remaining of distributed shares after the preference shares have been paid their
fixed dividend.
Deferred Shares
These shares are usually held by the founders of the company. They are so called because
payment of dividend and return on capital are deferred until payment has been made in respect of
other classes of shares.
“Without prejudice to any special rights previously conferred on
the holders of any existing shares or class of shares, any share in a
company may be issued with such preferred, deferred or other
special rights or such restrictions, whether with regard to dividend,
return of capital or otherwise, as the company may, from time to
time, determine by ordinary resolution”.
Deferred shares are so called because payment of dividends and return of capital are
deferred until payment has been made in respect of other classes of shares.
Deferred or founders shares are usually taken up by the founders or the promoters of the
company. For instance, a promoter of a company may sell his property to the company in
exchange for deferred or founders shares which gives special rights. Dividend must be paid to
deferred shareholders before ordinary shareholders receive their own dividends. In other words,
it has priority over ordinary shares.
Convertible Debentures
Debentures may be issued upon the terms that in lieu of redemption or repayment, they
may, at the option of the holder or the company, be converted into shares in the company upon
such terms as may be stated in the debentures.
These are debentures issued on the terms that they are convertible to shares of the
company in lieu of redemption and at the option of the holder upon such terms as may be stated
in the debentures. That is, it is issued upon the terms that in lieu of redemption or repayment, a
right of option is given to the holder of the company to convert the debentures into shares at
some future date. If a debenture holder exercises this right of conversion, he ceases to be a
creditor and becomes a shareholder instead.
Redeemable Debentures
These are debentures that are liable to be redeemed at the option of the company. A
company limited by shares may issue debentures which are, or at the option of the company are
to be liable to be redeemed.
Membership of a Company
A member of a company is a person having constituent proprietary interest in the
company and whose name has been entered in the Register of Members. The members may be
either the subscribers or every other person who agrees in writing to become members of the
company after its incorporation.
A person may become a member of company in either of the following ways:
1. By subscription;
2. By allotment and registration;
3. By transfer; or
4. By transmission.
Subscription
Upon registration, the subscribers of the memorandum of association shall become
members and their names must be inserted in the register of members. In essence, they shall be
deemed to have agreed to become members. The first members acquire their membership by
subscription. They must together subscribe to shares amounting in value to at least 25 per cent of
the authorised share capital.
A subscriber must take and pay for all the shares subscribed by him when calls are duly
made – Alexander v. Automatic Telephone Co. (1900) 2 Ch. 56 CA, and the shares must be
taken from the company. Where a subscriber takes equivalent shares from another member, he is
still liable to pay for all the shares he subscribed for – Migotti’s case (1867) LR 4 Eq. 238.
Transfer
This is done from one member to another followed by registration or by transmission
from a deceased shareholder to his personal representatives.
The transfer from an existing member to another may be by sale, gift or some other transaction
which, to all intents and purposes, must be lawful. Consequently, a holder of shares of a
company may validly elect to transfer those shares; and a person to whom the shares are
transferred becomes the holder of the shares, and a member when his name is entered in the
Register of Members to replace the former holder.
Transmission
This is an involuntary transfer occurring on the death or bankruptcy of a member. The
owner of the shares on the occurrence of such events will automatically vest (by operation of
law) in the personal representatives in the case of a dead member, and trustee in bankruptcy in
the case of a bankrupt member respectively, and he shall become a member of the company upon
the registration of his name in the Register of members.
Capacity to be a Member
As a general rule, any legal person may become a member of a company but infants,
personal representatives of deceased persons, companies and aliens are subject to special rules.
Infants
The Act provides that where an infant becomes a member of a company, he will not be
counted in determining the legal minimum number of members.
Note, however, that any person under the age of 18 years may still subscribe to the
memorandum or otherwise become a member, subject to the general disability of an infant to
contract under the general law. Thus, his contract to take shares in a company is voidable at his
instance any time before he attains the age of 18 or within a reasonable time thereafter. Unless
he repudiates his liability within this period, an infant will be liable to pay any calls made on his
shares and if he decides to repudiate, his liability on future calls will cease.
Married Women
Under the Married Women’s Property Laws of the States, a woman has the same contractual
rights and is liable to the same obligations as anyone else as regards the holding of shares.
Personal Representatives
On the death of a shareholder, the shares are transmitted to his personal representatives,
that is, his executors or administrators and the production of the probate of the Will or Letters of
Administration of the estate of the deceased person is sufficient evidence of the grant.
The personal representatives of deceased persons are the only persons recognised as
having any title to the deceased interest in the shares. They can sell and transfer the shares
without being first registered as members.
However, until the personal representative of a deceased shareholder complies with the
provision of Section 155(3) of the Act, he cannot, unless otherwise provided in the Articles, be
entitled to exercise any right conferred by membership in relation to meetings of the company.
Section 155(3) of the Act provides that:
“If the person so becoming entitled elects to be registered himself,
he shall deliver or send to the company a notice in writing signed
by him stating that he so elects and if he elects to have another
person registered, he shall testify his election by executing to that
person a transfer of the shares.”
Companies
A company is regarded in law as a person and, therefore, by virtue of Section 18 of the
Act which requires two or more persons to form and incorporate a company, it may be one of the
subscribers of the memorandum of another company. Just as an individual that subscribes the
memorandum is to sign it, a company that subscribes the memorandum is to sign by the
Secretary or Director of the company. Liquidation shall not be capable of becoming a member
of a company.
Aliens
An alien may acquire shares in a company and become a member by complying with the
various requirements of the law regulating the rights and capacity of aliens to engage in trade or
business in Nigeria.
Termination of Membership
1. Transfer of the Shares: The transfer, which is a voluntary process on the part of the
shareholder, shall be by instrument of transfer and shall be without restrictions. The
transferor ceases to be a member when the transferee’s name is entered in the Register of
Members.
2. Forfeiture of the Shares: This occurs where a member fails to pay on calls of shares by
the company (non-payment of calls).
3. Surrender of the Shares: This is a short cut to forfeiture in order to avoid the formalities
required in a situation where shares are to be forfeited.
4. Transmission to Personal Representatives on Death of Member: This occurs by operation
of law. In essence, it is an involuntary transfer since death can be regarded as the end of
all. Transmission requires no instrument of transfer. The dead person only ceases to be a
member of the company when some other person is registered in his place.
5. Transmission to trustee in bankruptcy.
6. Disclaimer by trustee in bankruptcy of members.
7. Redemption of redeemable preference shares.
8. Purchase by the company of its own shares. This may be under a court order or
satisfying the claim of a dissenting shareholder.
9. Rescission of the contract to take the shares arising out of fraud or misrepresentation in
the prospectus or reason of irregular allotment.
10. Repudiation by infant.