Chapter 4 Purcom
Chapter 4 Purcom
Second Semester
Academic Year 2023-2024
PROPERTY OF:
__________________________________________________
Name of Student/Course and Year
EVALUATING MESSAGES
This chapter introduces you to the different modes by which messages are conveyed. More
important is the ultimate goal of delineating personal judgments on the ideas presented that would
engage you toward the diversity of cultures manifested. Necessarily, the goal to objectify the
attack against a particular set of images/objects that create meaning is highlighted in this part.
Grand narratives have come to extinction. Those pieces of history that the great Napoleon
Bonaparte considers ‘one-sided account’ no longer stand as sell-outs. These are no longer sufficient
to make people understand the phenomena around them.
As issues arise the determination to comprehend them more than ever can be seen in how
advertisements emerge in the limelight as ground-breaking technology that advances advocacies.
People realize of their importance. Gradually, tiny details manage to awaken their sensibilities.
Evaluating messages in this era is made simpler. Looking at them through several lenses is helpful
as culture is arbitrary in nature. It conveys ideas that are distinct and rooted in myriad sensibilities.
What one experiences is what one brings to the table to further explain what is depicted in the
picture, video or any form of illustration. Unlocking messages is central to evaluation. So be
mindful of the elements that make up the bulk of the illustration, as these are the ones you will be
assessing as you read on.
GUIDE QUESTIONS IN UNLOCKING MESSAGES
1. What is the general motif of the picture?
2. How does the motif reflect interrelatedness of the elements?
3. What objects/elements stand out?
4. What objects/words seem out of place?
5. What culture prevails in understanding the meaning conveyed?
6. What general note can be drawn from the picture?
INFO CORNER:
A MOTIF is a usually recurring salient thematic element
(As in the arts) especially: a dominant idea or central theme
TASK #1
This idiom suggests that a picture contains far more in its colors, forms, textures, and
content than 1,000 words ever could. While words convey one idea, a simple picture has
the capacity to convey multiple at the same time while also engaging the viewer on a
different level.
Post/attach at least two pictures you like most which communicate the best message
you love from among the most favorite collections of images you keep without saying
any word.
“Our interpersonal effectiveness depends on more than words. Nonverbal messages add to or
detract from our words. In effect, we become the message, with our nonverbal cues announcing our
state of mind, and sense of self. Our entire beings chatter incessantly, revealing what we really
feel and think.” (www.sagepub.com/gambleic)
Listening to someone talking gives the privilege of proving his sincerity to the addressees. Like
many politicians, anyone finds common gestures along with words uttered. This is based on the
premise that human beings share commonalities. Standing before a crowd, for example, not
Rich expressions provide rich meanings. The eyes primarily reflect the totality of an
individual. They are considered as the windows of the soul. The sample images are
snapshots from HBO’s World Premiere of Game of Thrones Season 7, Episode 6.
Characters (Jon, Arya, Sansa, and Daenerys) are immensely celebrated by fans all
over the world for their unparalleled artistry in evoking emotions that intensify the impact
of what needs to be delivered.
Disclaimer: The inclusion of information from Game of Thrones is giving credit to the world-renowned characters that
specifically highlight the impact of careful communicative strategies employed in a given context.
Read carefully the line below taken from the book Overcoming Fake Talk: How to Hold
Real Conversations that Create Respect, Build Relationships, and Get Results by John
Stroker.
“93/7 Rule: 93% of communication occurs through non-verbal behavior and tone; only 7%
of communication takes place through the use of words.”
Do you agree with Stoker’s claim? What does the 93/7 rule suggest? Explain/elaborate the
rule supported by your own communication experiences in a short essay form.
Text is not literal text, but in semiotics refers to a combination of signs, signifies and
mechanism like metonymy. A text could be a sentence, paragraph an image, a story, or a
collection of stories. Collection of signs in a single photograph or painting, a video clip, a television
show, a feature film and whenever these signs come together in the land of semiotics, they become
texts. These texts can be understood, rearranged and put together in different combinations, with
different meanings to different groups of people. But cultural texts are not one-dimensional. A text
is not simply representative of one culture; it does not belong to one culture, even if it purposely
excludes others semiotically. Cultural texts are multi-dimensional, they are dynamic.
A cultural text is perhaps better understood as having cultural layers of understanding where
groups different in age, race, nationality, sexual orientation may read and understand a
collection of signs in different ways. Depending on the producer or the audience, the text itself
has a kind of flexibility in meaning to different people when it starts to operate culturally.
LESSON 4: MULTIMODALITY
LET’S READ!
GEC-15, PURPOSIVE COMMUNICATION Chapter 4
Multimodality refers to the interplay between different representational modes, for instance,
between images and written/spoken word. Multimodal representations mediate the sociocultural
ways in which these modes are combined in the communication process (Kress & Van Leeuwen 2001,
p. 20). Nowadays, it is difficult to draw lines between reading, speech, watching and writing. Humans are
not only targets of messages but also producers of communications and meanings and participants in
meaning-making communities and networks (Lankshear & Knobel 2006). Using video games as a
research target, Gee (2003) has outlined the relationship between literacy and learning.
According to Gee, language is not the only important communication system in digital media,
since visual symbols and signs are as significant as written or spoken language. The idea of visual
literacy as a part of new literacies is an important one. Words and images are integrated in a
variety of ways in web pages, newspapers and magazines, as well as in textbooks. Gee stresses
that in specific domains, content is generated, debated and transformed via distinctive ways of
thinking, talking, valuing, acting and, often, writing and reading.
Multimodality is an inter-disciplinary approach that understands communication and
representation to be more than about language. It has been developed over the past decade
to systematically address much-debated questions about changes in society, for instance in
relation to new media and technologies.
Multimodal approaches have provided concepts, methods and a framework for the
collection and analysis of visual, aural, embodied, and spatial aspects of interaction and
environments, and the relationships between these. It is the application of multiple literacies
within one medium. For example, understanding a televised weather forecast (medium) involves
understanding spoken language, written language, weather specific language (such as
temperature scales), geography, and symbols (clouds, sun, rain, etc.).
Multiple literacies or "modes" contribute to an audience's understanding of a composition.
Everything from the placement of images to the organization of the content to the method
of delivery creates meaning. This is the result of a shift from isolated text being relied on as
the primary source of communication, to the image being utilized more frequently in the digital
age. Multimodality describes communication practices in terms of the textual, aural, linguistic,
spatial, and visual resources used to compose messages.
Multimodality is a theory which looks at the many different modes that people use to
communicate with each other and to express themselves. This theory is relevant as an increase
in technology tools, and associated access to multimedia composing software, has led to people
being able to easily use many modes in art, writing, music, and dance and every-day
interactions with each other.
A mode is generally defined as a communication channel that a culture recognizes.
Examples of modes are writing, gesture, posture, gaze, font choice and color, images, video,
and even the interactions between them.
While many of these modes have always existed, they have not always been recognized as a
legitimate or culturally accepted form of communication or expression. Learning theorists who
advocate for multimodality emphasize that people communicate in a variety of ways, and
that in order to completely understand someone, the many modes they use to communicate
must be observed and recognized.
The theory of multimodality can be found in writings and discussions related to communication
theory, linguistics, media literacy, visual literacy, anthropological studies, and design studies.
MODES
The following overview of how meaning can be composed through different semiotic
resources for each mode (spoken language, written language, visual, audio, gestural, and spatial)
is informed by The New London Group (2000), Cope and Kalantzis, (2009), and Kalantzis, Cope,
Chan, and Dalley-Trim (2016). Learners engage with all of these meaning making practices
through multicultural and/or multilingual lens.
Currently, there is extensive pedagogic support for teaching meaning making through spoken and
written language, and some resources developed to support teaching meaning making in the visual
mode, through ‘viewing’. However, as yet there are few resources available for teaching young
students how to comprehend and compose meaning in the other modes.
Written Meaning - Conveyed through written language via handwriting, the printed
page, and the screen. Choices of words, phrases, and sentences are organised through
linguistic grammar convention register (where language is varied according to
context), and genre (knowledge of how a text type is organised and staged to meet a
specific purpose). In bilingual or multilingual texts, written meaning may be conveyed
through different scripts and laid out differently, whether typed or handwritten. Learners
may also write words from their home languages using English letters (transliteration).
Spoken (oral) Meaning - Conveyed through spoken language via live or recorded speech
and can be monologic or dialogic. Choice of words, phrases, and sentences are
organised through linguistic grammar conventions, register, and genre. Composing oral
meaning includes choices around mood, emotion, emphasis, fluency, speed, volume, tempo,
pitch, rhythm, pronunciation, intonation, and dialect. EAL/D learners may make additional
choices around the use of home languages to create mood or emphasise meaning.
Visual Meaning - Conveyed through choices of visual resources and includes both still
image and moving images. Images may include diverse cultural connotations, symbolism
and portray different people, cultures and practices. Visual resources include: framing,
vectors, symbols, perspective, gaze, point of view, colour, texture, line, shape, casting,
saliency, distance, angles, form, power, involvement/detachment, contrast, lighting,
naturalistic/non-naturalistic, camera movement, and subject movement.
Audio Meaning - Conveyed through sound, including choices of music representing
different cultures, ambient sounds, noises, alerts, silence, natural/unnatural sounds, and use
of volume, beat, tempo, pitch, and rhythm. Lyrics in a song may also include multiple
languages.
Spatial Meaning - Conveyed through design of spaces, using choices of spatial resources
including: scale, proximity, boundaries, direction, layout, and organisation of objects in the
LESSON 6:
Communication requires language. That language can be aural as in the spoken word, it can be
gestural as in sign language, or it can be visual as in design. The more you understand any
language the better you can communicate using that language. The visual language of design is no
exception.
Design elements are like letters and words. When we add design principles and apply them
to our elements, our words, we form a visual grammar. As we learn to use both we enable
ourselves to communicate visually.
DEFINING VISUAL GRAMMAR
Most of the information in this lesson is coming from Christian Leborg’s book; from the preface of
the book:
The reason for writing a grammar of visual language is the same as for any language: to define its
basic elements, describe its patterns and processes, and to understand the relationship between the
individual elements in the system. Visual language has no formal syntax or semantics, but the visual
objects themselves can be classified.
The last point in the quote above is important. It would be great if we could place a circle on the
page, a rectangle to the right of it, and a curved line to the right of the rectangle and have it
mean the same thing to all people. It won’t. That makes it harder to think and communicate visually,
though also much more interesting. It’s one reason a single design problem can have so many
different design solutions.
However, we can classify much of this visual grammar. I’m going to deviate just a bit from the way
Christian organizes his book and organize visual grammar as:
Objects – The basic elements we have to work with. Can be abstract or concrete.
Structures – The patterns formed from our basic elements. Can be abstract or
concrete.
Activities – The processes we can represent with our basic elements and patterns.
Relations – The relationships between objects, patterns, and processes. They’re the
way everything in your design relates to each other and the viewer.
OBJECTS - Objects are the basic elements at our disposal. They’re akin to letters and words. We
use objects to express different ideas and concepts. A circle is an object as is a line as is a single
character of type. A single point is an object as is an image of a person holding your product.
Objects are the most basic elements we can add to any design.
Objects can be abstract or concrete.
ABSTRACT OBJECTS - Abstract objects are idealized shapes that can’t physically be created. For
example take a point. A point by definition has no area. It only has a position. Any point we try to
draw will have some kind of area if we are to see it and once it does, it ceases to become a point.
It can only exist as an abstract concept and not as a physical thing.
Abstract objects include:
Points – A position on a coordinate system without area. Points have no dimensions
Lines – A series of points adjacent to each other. Points have one dimensions
Surfaces – A series of lines that are adjacent to each other and perpendicular to
their direction. Surfaces have two dimensions.
Concrete objects are perceived within defined limits called contours. Inside and including the
contour itself is our object, our shape, our form, and outside the contour is everything else. Forms or
shapes can be geometric, organic, or random (sometimes called abstract). A circle is an example
of a concrete object. It’s contour being the curved line that encloses it.
Concrete objects have:
Form – defined by a contour of surfaces and lines. A form is how a thing looks.
Size – Forms can be large or small. They are perceived relative to the person viewing,
other forms in the composition, and the format of the design.
Color – we perceive different wavelengths of light as color. A form can be any color,
though we are limited to seeing only those colors in the visual spectrum
Any element we place on the page is a concrete object. Remember abstract objects can not
physically be created. Abstract objects exist to talk about objects in general in order to better
describe them.
STRUCTURES - Whenever we place two or more objects in relation to one another we form a
structure. We describe these structures by the patterns they form. We must be able to recognize
the presence of a pattern in order to describe the structure.
Structures have structure lines connecting objects. These lines are the axis along which the objects
are arranged. Structure lines may be visible or invisible and they may be active or inactive.
As with objects, structures can be abstract or concrete.
ABSTRACT STRUCTURES - When the structure lines of a structure are invisible and inactive the
structure is considered to be abstract. Consider the image below. The circles are clearly
arranged in a pattern. There is a structure present, but the lines defining that structure are invisible.
Even when the structure lines are invisible we can often see them in our minds. Through
the gestalt principle closure we fill in what’s missing to complete the picture. Again consider the
image above. While no lines are visibly connecting the circles, it’s easy to imagine straight lines
from the center of one circle to the next. Structure lines are not limited to running through the
center of objects though.
Active structures are those where the structure lines influence the form of the objects within the
structure. In an active structure the objects need to be present, but the structure lines can be
absent as long as their influence is seen. In the image below both structures are active despite
the absence of any visible structure lines in the second one.
Structures that can be seen and/or felt are textures. Textures can be formed from either objects
or structure lines or both. Textures can be ornamental, random, or mechanical and we can classify
them in the same way we classify abstract structures. They can be formal, informal, gradations,
radiations, or spirals.