Argon Help
Argon Help
TABLE OF CONTENTS
The following section outline the four steps required to carry out the safety criteria derivation process.
Note 1: The higher outage rates occur in northern Note 2: The lower outage rates occur in southern
Australia where there is more frequent high Australia and New Zealand where there is
wind and lightning storms. less frequent high wind and lower lightning
activity.
Note: The primary protection clearing times for >100kV are based on National Electricity Code fault
clearing time requirements for remote end.
If we assume a fault radius of 1.5km with OHEW, the faults ‘seen’ per structure = 3/100 * fault rate/year.
For example:
Fault Duration The user can dial-up a fault duration from 0.01sec to 10 sec. It is also possible
to manually enter the desired fault duration. This field has a maximum time resolution of 0.01 sec for
clearing times between 0.01 and 0.1 sec and a maximum resolution of 0.1 sec for clearing times between
0.1 and 10 sec. The default duration is set to 0.1 sec. This value is used for both the determination of the
probability of coincidence and the Probability of Fibrillation in Step B.
Coincidence Reduction
Reduction Method The default for this field is “None” and should remain as that for the initial iteration
of the assessment process. If, after the initial pass through of the process, the design is considered high
or unacceptable risk, the designer may choose to alter the coincidence profile for the scenario by
implementing one of the predefined Coincidence Reduction Factors (CRF) or adding a design specific
Reduction Factor. Assumptions used to define this factor should be documented in the free text field in
Step D.
Contact Scenario (UNIFORM – Time Independent) There are a number of predefined scenarios
that may be selected which automatically populate the required fields of Contacts/year and Contact
Duration. “Other” may be selected to input a user-defined access profile. The access assumptions may
be added to the adjacent text box for the user-defined profile. This information will be included in the
design report generated by the program.
Contact Scenario (GATHERING – Time Dependent) When the “Other” option is selected for the
contact scenario, there are a number of different fields that are required for Individual and Societal
calculations, related to the duration of the gathering and contacts/hour while the gathering is underway.
Note: The Contacts/year field when considering Individual probabilities refers to the number of
contacts that at least 95% of individuals can be expected to make over the period under consideration.
Override Coincidence Calculations This button may be checked when a coincidence calculation has
been performed external to the calculator to allow the user to input the coincidence value only. Information
relating to the calculation of the probability of coincidence in this instance should be added by the designer
in the free text field when the report is being generated. It is only possible to override the coincidence
calculation when considering individual probabilities. It is not available for societal calculations.
Note: When the coincidence calculation has been overridden, it is not possible to generate a
voltage/time curve for the design. It is, however, possible to assess the input voltage and clearing time
against the target criteria (refer to risk slider bar).
Pcoinc This is the calculated probability of coincidence for an individual given the input parameters already
outlined (or in the case of the override button being selected, the value of coincidence probability input by
the user). The following simplified expression may be used to evaluate the individual probability of
coincidence:
f p (f + pd ) * T
PCoinc = n n d
365 * 24 * 60 * 60
where
fn = fault frequency/year
pn = number of presences/individual/year
fd = fault duration (seconds)
pd = presence duration (seconds)
T = Exposure duration (years) – assumed to be 1 year for all Argon calculations
Note: If the individual probability of coincidence is less than the target probability of fatality (1e-06),
then it is not necessary to enter fibrillation data in Step B as the design is compliant even if the
probability of fibrillation is 1. However, in order to generate a design curve, the fibrillation data must be
entered.
As various combinations of impedance are selected using the buttons and drop-down menus, other
options will appear/disappear based on the table above.
If ‘No Footwear (Barefeet)’ is selected, no additional impedance for footwear is included in the
calculation.
If ‘Safety Gumboots’ is selected, gumboots are included in the fault circuit as per the impedances and
flashover voltages shown in the following table:
The gumboot distribution is conservatively based on high voltage testing of 58 new and used
gumboots in 2014. Boots were immersed in and filled with water for the testing with the lowest
flashover voltage reported for each impedance grouping used. Bare feet (0 ohms, 0 flashover voltage)
corresponds to 5% of the gumboot population allowing for damaged boots which provide no additional
series impedance. Due to the tested sample size and condition of boots, there is a wide variation in
tested results as evidenced by the gumboot distribution.
Appropriate footwear can significantly reduce the current that can pass through a body. Under dry
conditions any enclosed leather or non-conductive rubber or plastic footwear in good condition is as
effective as electrical safety boots in reducing the risk. Without such footwear the risk is equivalent to
bare feet.
Appropriate gum boots are those which pass the following test to ensure that material from which they
are made is adequately insulating:
Fill the boot to approximately 90% of it’s height with salt water and place it in a container of salt
water that reaches the same water level. The resistance between electrodes inserted in the
water inside the boot and outside of the boot should be determined with a high voltage
resistance tester. The resistance should not be less than 1 mega ohm.
Gum boots should be maintained in good condition and replaced if any splits or cracks appear.
2.2.4.2 Asphalt
Asphalt may also be used to limit body current flow and allow trafficability of vehicles and people.
Unfortunately asphalt exhibits highly variable electrical properties as shown in HV testing research
[see ENA EG-0]. Therefore care must be taken in the specification of asphalt for body current limiting
purposes. Key aspects to be considered include:
• Preparation: Use of compacted road base (and possibly plastic underlay for weed control)
• Material: Well compacted hot mix at least 50mm thickness compacted (as cold mix electrical
properties compromised in wet condition).
• Electrical Properties: As it is difficult to type test a batch of hot asphalt, conservative values
of resistance and voltage withstand are often used.
• Asphalt Resistivity – 10,000 Ω-m
• Asphalt Voltage withstand – 3kV
The probability of fatality for an individual is calculated using the following expression and positioned on
the Risk slider bar.
Risk Slider Bar If the probability of fatality is less than 1e-6, the risk is considered negligible
and the design should be accepted. If the probability of fatality is greater than 1e-4, the risk is considered
intolerable and coincidence or voltage reducing mitigation should be employed to lower the risk. For the
intermediate risk zone between these two bounds, the designer can use the ALARP (As Low As
Reasonably Practical) principle to determine risk acceptance.
Design Curve A voltage/time design curve is generated for the combination of input variables
irrespective of whether the design is compliant. Once the design risk is accepted, the design curve may
be used to determine compliance for other scenarios with the same contact profile and fault frequency
(irrespective of clearing time).
Note: If the risk level has been accepted, the design curve can be generated for probabilities of fatality
greater than 1e-6. However, the design curve does not get updated for an individual probability of
fatality of less than 1e-6 as any probability less than this will automatically be compliant with the
voltage being below the upper limit specified by the curve.
Clicking on the ‘View Design Curve’ control or double clicking on the Design Curve opens the chart in a
separate window. The chart data can then be exported to a .csv file to allow the curve to be opened in
a spreadsheet. The .csv file includes both the line / voltage coordinates and the scenario input values.
When the Exposed Population Size is greater than 1 (set in Access Assumptions Societal), an F-N curve
can be used to demonstrate compliance. The F-N curve has predefined zones according to the
Intolerable, ALARP, and Negligible risk levels. Calculations of the frequency of N or more fatalities for
values of N up to the Exposed Population Size are plotted on the F-N curve to demonstrate compliance
across the whole range of N.
View Design Curve A design curve can be generated for the societal case which corresponds to
the highest voltage at each clearing time where all points on the F-N curve are in the Negligible risk
region. Note that this curve does not correspond to a specific probability of fatality and cannot be
generated to correspond to designs which exist for some part in the ALARP or Intolerable region.
Double clicking on the Design Curve opens the chart in a separate window. The chart data can then be
exported to a .csv file to allow the curve to be opened in a spreadsheet. The .csv file includes both the
line / voltage coordinates and the scenario input values.
Generate Report Once the risk for the design has been accepted, the design report can be
produced. The program will automatically generate the design report with some prompting for required
information. The report can then be saved as a PDF file.
Refer to ENA EG-0 (Power System Earthing Guide) for additional information.
It is now possible to view a collection of standard design curves within Argon. There are four categories
of design curves that can be displayed and these are listed as follows.
• EG-0 Standard Curves
• IEEE80 Standard Curves
• IEC60479 Standard Curves
• Imported Curves (see section 3.1 for more information)
These design curves can be superimposed onto the current Argon design curve for comparison.
Alternatively they can be viewed by accessing the main menu entry View → Standard Curves as shown
in the following screen shot.
The Standard Curve viewing utility is then presented to the user. Note that the IEEE80 and the IEC60479
curves can be viewed by clicking on the Other Standard Curves button as highlighted in the following
screenshot.
Note this is only an issue when editing in a text editor. This is not required when working within
Microsoft Excel as the software manages this when the file is saved as “csv” format.
The “selection controls” for the above sample (once imported) may be visualised in the User Interface similar to
the following …
Argon design curves can now be curve fitted to a rational form expression (ratio of 2 polynomials). The
curve fitting utility is available in the Argon Design Curve window.
Clicking on the Curve Fitting button as highlighted in the following screen shot, will show the Enable
Rational Curve Fit checkbox.
Enabling this utility will present the user with Argon’s best estimate at a suitable curve fit. The best results
are displayed in the bottom right hand side of the screen once all combinations have been evaluated.
The maximum number of terms to be used for the numerator and denominator expressions defaults to 7
but can be set to any value from 3 to 20.
A given curve fit expression is displayed in the Curve Expression text box on the bottom left hand side of
the screen. The x-variable name identified in this expression defaults to “A1” but can be modified as
required in order to enable easy integration into 3 rd party applications (e.g. Microsoft Excel).
Note: Although a given curve fit result may be identified as the best result, it is always necessary to carry
out a visual check on how best it corresponds to the original design curve.
The Batch Processing module provides for multiple single studies to be grouped into a single
determination. This grouping allows for an overall risk value to be identified. Argon batch assessment files
may be saved and reopened using the file menu in the Batch Processing module. Batch files are saved
with a *.rbb extension. Reporting and template utilities are also supported in this module.
The Batch Processing module can be accessed using the application menu entry Tools→Batch
Processing.