Exp Study On Builtup Cfs Beam
Exp Study On Builtup Cfs Beam
Francisco J. Meza, Ph.D. 1; Jurgen Becque, Ph.D. 2; and Iman Hajirasouliha, Ph.D. 3
Abstract: This paper describes a comprehensive experimental program on cold-formed steel built-up beams with two different cross-
Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by "National Institute of Technology, Raipur" on 08/08/23. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.
sectional geometries. The work aimed to experimentally investigate the interaction between the individual components under increasing
loading and to quantify the effect of the connector spacing on the cross-sectional moment capacity and the behavior of the beams. In total,
12 specimens were tested in a four-point bending configuration, with lateral restraints provided at the loading points in order to avoid global
instabilities. The built-up specimens were composed of three or four plain channels with nominal thicknesses of 1.2 and 1.5 mm, which were
joined together using M6 bolts. Each built-up geometry was tested with three different connector spacings. The specimens were designed to
fail by local buckling of their components. Additionally, strut buckling of the channel comprising the top flange in between connector points
was observed. The local buckling deformations and the beam deflections were recorded during the tests. The material properties of the test
specimens were determined by means of coupon tests and the geometric imperfections were measured prior to testing. The experimental
results showed clear evidence of interaction between the local buckling patterns of the components, with the interaction being affected by the
connector spacing and the type of geometry. However, the connector spacing showed a less significant effect on the ultimate capacity when
failure was governed by local instabilities of the components. DOI: 10.1061/(ASCE)ST.1943-541X.0002677. © 2020 American Society of
Civil Engineers.
Author keywords: Built-up column; Experiment; Cold-formed steel; Stability; Buckling; Imperfection measurements.
Specimen Geometry
of the beam between the end supports and the loading points, fur- Finally, the components were bolted together using grade 8.8 M6
ther referred to as the shear spans, had a length of 700 mm. The bolts, and the clamps were removed. All bolts were tightened with a
built-up specimens were designed with either zero, two, or three controlled torque of 10 Nm. This is representative of the torque
equally spaced rows of connectors along the constant moment span, exerted by a spanner when hand-tightening the bolts and did not
in addition to the connectors placed in the cross sections under the introduce any significant pretensioning in the bolts. Fig. 4 shows
loading points. A close connector spacing along the shear spans of the specimens after the assembly process.
100 mm was maintained in all test specimens, as shown in Fig. 3, in
order to promote load sharing between all components, as well as to
avoid failure outside the constant moment region. Two identical Material Properties
beams were fabricated for each configuration in order to gain in-
creased confidence in the results. A series of coupon tests was carried out in order to determine the
A labeling system was used for both the individual components material properties of the beams. The coupons were cut along the
of the cross section (as indicated in Fig. 1) and the test specimens. rolling direction of the material (i.e., the longitudinal direction of
The latter consisted of a B followed by a 1 or a 2 to indicate the the beam) near the end section of one of the test specimens after
cross-sectional configuration (with reference to Fig. 1), the number testing. This location was chosen because the material had not been
of intermediate rows of connectors between the loading points, and subjected to significant stress in this region during the test. For each
the letter a or b to differentiate between the first and the second of type of channel component, two flat coupons were cut along the
twin test specimens. The actual cross-sectional dimensions of each center line of the web and two corner coupons were taken from
component were measured at several locations along the length be- the web-flange junction. The flat coupons had a nominal width of
fore assembly. The dimensions of the web and the flanges were mea- 12.5 mm, while the corner coupons had a nominal width of 6 mm.
sured using a digital Vernier caliper with a precision of 0.03 mm. All coupons were instrumented with an extensometer of 50 mm
All measurements were taken of the outside dimensions. The thick- gauge length. In addition, each flat coupon was instrumented with
ness of the cross section was measured with a micrometer with one 5-mm strain gauge on each side of the coupon, while each cor-
a precision of 0.002 mm. The measured cross-sectional dimen- ner coupon was instrumented with a 5-mm strain gauge on the
sions are listed in Tables 2 and 3 for all the specimens belonging outside of the corner. Due to the asymmetric shape of the corner
to Geometries 1 and 2, respectively. It should be noted that the val- coupons they were tested in pairs with a square bar placed between
ues reported in the tables are those obtained after accounting for the the gripped ends of the coupons, as illustrated in Fig. 5.
0.04 mm nominal thickness of the zinc coating. The cross-sectional area of the curved corner coupon was
In order to assemble the specimens, holes with a nominal diam- determined by taking a macro photograph of the cross section
eter of 6.25 mm were first drilled in one of the components at the using the reversed lens technique. The images were then imported
appropriate locations, as indicated in Fig. 3. The components were into AutoCAD software version 19.1 and scaled based on the
then positioned in their built-up configuration and secured with measurement of the width of the gripped end of the coupon, as
clamps. Next, the first component (containing the holes) was used illustrated in Fig. 6. The measured width of the coupon along the
as a template to drill the holes in the adjacent components. This gauge length was then superimposed on the photograph, allowing
allowed for an easy assembly, avoiding any mismatch of the holes. the area to be automatically calculated by the software. The process
was repeated with pictures taken from the other end of the coupon Fig. 7. Stress-strain curves of flat and corner coupons.
and a difference in the calculated areas of less than 1.5% was ob-
tained for all coupons.
The tensile coupons were tested in a 300-kN Shimadzu AGS-X
(Kyoto, Japan) universal testing machine, while applying a displace-
by taking readings of the nominally flat table in the absence of a test
ment rate of 2 mm=min. Each test was halted for 2 min at regular
specimen, and these imperfections were deducted from the readings.
intervals in order to allow the load to settle down to static values and
Thus, an accuracy of approximately 0.06 mm was obtained, as this
eliminate strain rate effects. The static stress-strain curves are shown
was the guaranteed flatness of the table. Readings were taken along
in Fig. 7 for all coupons. Table 4 lists the (static) engineering values
of the material properties obtained for each coupon, as well as aver- different longitudinal lines on the specimen, as illustrated in Fig. 9,
age values for corresponding pairs. σ0.2% corresponds to the 0.2% within the constant moment span. Whenever possible, the imperfec-
proof stress, σu is the ultimate tensile strength, and εf is the elon- tions were recorded in the assembled state (as indicated by the red
gation after fracture measured over a gauge length of 50 mm. arrows in Fig. 9). However, the imperfections in the webs of the
built-up specimens were recorded before assembling the top and
bottom channels, as access was partially blocked in the assembled
Imperfection Measurements state (black arrows in Fig. 9).
The laser sensor was moved at a constant speed of 5 mm=s,
The capacity and behavior of thin-walled structural members in while readings were taken with a sampling rate of 50 Hz, resulting
many cases exhibit pronounced sensitivity to geometric imperfec- in a reading every 0.1 mm.
tions (Van der Neut 1969; Becque 2014). For this reason the im- The recorded imperfections were used to determine represen-
perfections of all specimens were recorded before testing using the tative out-of-plane imperfections in the web (δ web ) and the flanges
measuring rig developed by Meza et. al (2018), which consisted of (δ flange ) of the channels. δ web was determined as the out-of-plane
a nominally flat steel table and a traverse system powered by two imperfection recorded along the center line of the web relative to
electric motors (Fig. 8). The motors allowed the movement of a the imperfections recorded along the corners. δ flange was deter-
laser displacement sensor in two orthogonal directions along guid- mined by first computing the out-of-plane imperfections along the
ing bars. The imperfections in the guiding system were determined flange tip relative to the imperfections recorded along the corner.
Connector Behavior
A series of single lap shear tests with two fasteners in the line of
stress was carried out to determine the behavior of the connectors
used to assemble the built-up beams. The specimens were fabri-
cated from steel strips taken from spare sections and a total of
six tests were carried out. The specimens labeled CB15-12 com-
prised ply thicknesses and connectors identical to the configuration
encountered in the flanges of the built-up beams, while specimens
CB15-15 were representative of the connectors located in the web.
Three identical specimens were fabricated for each configuration in
order to account for statistical variability in the results (i.e., six tests
were carried out in total). Fig. 11 shows the test setup. The dimen-
sions of the test specimens were chosen following the recommen-
dations given in ECCS TC7 (2009) and the specimens were
assembled in the same way as the built-up beams. In particular,
Fig. 8. Imperfection measurement rig. the same controlled torque of 10 N · m was used. All specimens
were tested in a 300-kN Shimadzu universal testing machine and
were loaded to failure at a displacement rate of 0.5 mm=min. Fig. 12
shows the typical recorded load-elongation behavior. Further infor-
mation about the connector tests, as well as complete results for all
However, because it was not possible to place the web of the connector specimens, can be found in Meza (2018).
channel in a vertical position with perfect accuracy during the read-
ings, these initial values still contained an arbitrary constant offset,
which was eliminated by expressing δ flange relative to its average Test Setup
value along the beam. Fig. 10 shows typical imperfection profiles in
a representative beam. The vertical dashed lines indicate the loca- All 12 specimens were bent about their major axis using a four-point
tions of the connectors. The complete imperfection data of all spec- bending configuration, as illustrated in Fig. 13(a). The test speci-
imens can be found in Meza (2018). The maximum and the average mens were supported at their ends on rollers located 3,000 mm
values of δweb and δ flange are listed in Table 5 for the components of apart. The actuator was connected to a spreader beam, which exerted
each geometry. concentrated loads onto the specimen through loading points which
Test Results
were implemented as simple supports (one roller and one pin)
located 1,600 mm apart. An adjustable lateral support system was
used to restrain the spreader beam against any out-of-plane move- Geometry 1
ment, as shown in Fig. 13(b). Nylon blocks were used as bearing All test specimens with Geometry 1 failed within the constant mo-
pads between the spreader beam and the uprights of the support ment span as a result of local buckling, with significant interaction
system in order to reduce friction. The loading points under the taking place between the top channel and the channels comprising
spreader beam consisted of top and bottom assemblies (Fig. 14), the web of the built-up cross section. The top channel consistently
which were bolted to the spreader beam and the test specimen, re- buckled first, before buckling was observed in the channels com-
spectively, and contained vertical flanges to prevent out-of-plane prising the webs. Fig. 17 illustrates the local buckling pattern,
displacements of the top flange of the test specimen. which typically contained 15 or 16 half-waves of fairly similar
Fig. 13. (a) Four-point bending test rig; and (b) lateral support system.
Fig. 14. Loading devices: (a) pin support; and (b) roller support.
half-wavelength along the constant moment span. These buckles the connectors. It is important to note that the observed half-
were estimated to have an average half-wavelength of around wavelength of 100 mm was very close to the natural local buckle
100 mm. A slight exception occurred in beams B1-3, which dis- half-wavelength of 110 mm, calculated using CUFSM version 4.05
played 17 half-waves, with two of the buckles being noticeably (Schafer 2006) for the top channel in isolation. The web channels
smaller than the others. This was attributed to the presence of had a similar (calculated) natural local buckle half-wavelength of
Fig. 19. Yield line mechanism in B1-2a: (a) top channel; and (b) channels comprising the web.
was more significant, causing the top channel to twist with a half-
Geometry 2
wavelength of approximately 750 mm before the specimen reached
In general, the specimens with Geometry 2 failed within the con- its ultimate capacity, as shown in Fig. 23.
stant moment span by local buckling. Fig. 21 illustrates the typical In all test specimens the top channel buckled locally before the
local buckling pattern. However, in the beams without intermediate web channels, and the amplitude of its buckles was significantly
connectors (B2-0), flexural-torsional buckling of the top channel as larger. The top channel displayed between 14 and 16 half-waves
an individual component was observed to interact with local buck- along the constant moment span with fairly similar half-wavelength.
ling near the peak load. In the case of beam B2-0a this occurred Although the number of half-waves generated in the web channels
shortly after the local buckling deformations in the top channel was not easily discerned due to their small amplitude, it was noted
localized near midspan, resulting in localized twisting, as illustrated that in specimens B2-2 one of the buckles had a half-wavelength
in Fig. 22. However, in specimen B2-0b the interaction between significantly larger than the others. Despite the difficulty in distin-
local buckling and flexural-torsional buckling of the top channel guishing the half-waves in the web channels, it was estimated to
Fig. 26. Yield line mechanism in B2-2a: (a) top channel; and (b) channels comprising the web.
Fig. 28. Distance between the centroid of the top channel and the centroid of the built-up cross section.
local modes is notoriously imperfection sensitive, which might The specimens with Geometry 1 showed a relatively modest
explain why the flexural-torsional mode appeared slightly earlier increase in the ultimate capacity when reducing the connector spac-
over the loading history in specimen B2-0b and the interaction ing, while the ultimate capacity of the specimens with Geometry 2
was somewhat more pronounced, resulting in a lower ultimate was more significantly affected by the connector spacing. More
capacity. In beams B2-2 and B2-3, on the other hand, the difference specifically, reducing the connector spacing from 1,500 mm to
in ultimate capacity between twin specimens was 2% and 1%, 375 mm resulted in increases in the ultimate capacity of 11% and
respectively. 36% for the specimens with Geometries 1 and 2, respectively.
The test results showed that reducing the connector spacing The presented research is part of a wider investigation into built-
in the constant moment span resulted in a modest increase in the up cold-formed structural members (Meza et al. 2016; Meza 2018;
ultimate capacity of the specimens with Geometry 1. The beams Meza et al. 2020). The data gathered from the experiments will be
with two rows of intermediate connectors experienced an average used to develop accurate FE models which will serve as a tool to
increase in ultimate capacity of 3% relative to the beam without further study the behavior of built-up CFS members through para-
connectors, while the specimens with three rows of connectors ex- metric studies. The eventual goal is to develop accurate, safe, and
hibited an average increase of 11%. reliable design guidelines for these types of structural members for
The specimens with Geometry 2 showed a more substantial in- the benefit of practitioners.
crease in ultimate capacity when the spacing between the con-
nectors was reduced. The beams with two intermediate rows of
connectors along the constant moment span experienced an average Data Availability Statement
increase in ultimate capacity of 22% relative to the beams without
intermediate connectors, while the beams with three rows of inter- Some or all data, models, or code generated or used during the
mediate connectors displayed an average increase of 36%. This can study are available from the corresponding author by request,
in part be attributed to the elimination of the flexural-torsional including material properties data, geometric imperfections data,
mode for shorter connector spacings. connector behavior data, and out-of-plane deformation data.
Conclusions Acknowledgments
An experimental program investigating CFS built-up beams, en- The authors are grateful for the financial support provided by the
compassing 12 specimens with two different cross-sectional geom- EPSRC through Grant No. EP/M011976/1.
etries, is presented in this paper. The built-up specimens were
composed of plain channel components assembled using M6 bolts,
while varying the connector spacing among specimens. All beams References
were tested in a four-point bending configuration and lateral re-
straints were provided at the loading points in order to avoid global AISI (American Iron and Steel Institute). 2016. North American specifica-
instability of the built-up specimen. The geometric imperfections of tion for the design of cold-formed steel structural members. AISI S136.
Toronto: AISI.
the test specimens were measured using a laser sensor prior to test-
Becque, J. 2014. “Local-overall interaction buckling of inelastic columns:
ing, while the material properties of the constituent channels were
A numerical study of the inelastic Van der Neut column.” Thin Walled
determined by testing a series of tensile coupons. Struct. 81 (Aug): 101–107. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tws.2013.07.010.
The specimens with Geometry 1 all failed by local buckling, Blum, H. B., and K. J. R. Rasmussen. 2019. “Experimental investigation of
with the top channel consistently being the first component to long-span cold-formed steel double channel portal frames.” J. Constr.
buckle. The observed buckle half-wavelengths were close to the Steel Res. 155 (Apr): 316–330. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcsr.2018.11
natural half-wavelengths of the isolated components, regardless of .020.
the connector spacing. However, a comparison of the experimen- CEN (European Committee for Standardization). 2004. Continuously
tally derived critical buckling stresses of the top channel with the hot-dip coated strip and sheet of structural steels—Technical delivery
theoretical buckling stress of the channel in isolation revealed that conditions. EN 10326. Brussels, Belgium: CEN.
the top channel benefited significantly from the restraint provided CEN (European Committee for Standardization). 2005. Design of steel
structures, Part 1.1: General rules and rules for buildings. EN 1993-
by the web channels.
1-1. Brussels, Belgium: CEN.
The specimens with Geometry 2 failed by local buckling, while
CEN (European Committee for Standardization). 2016. Designation sys-
flexural-torsional buckling of the top channel in between connector tems for steels, Part 1: Steel names. EN 10024-1. Brussels, Belgium:
points was also observed in the specimens with the largest connector CEN.
spacing. The experimentally measured buckle half-wavelengths and Dang, K. P., and K. J. R. Rasmussen. 2019. “Flexural rigidity of cold-formed
critical buckling stresses of the top channel agreed well with those steel built-up members.” Thin Walled Struct. 140 (Jul): 438–449. https://
calculated for the isolated channel, indicating a minimal amount of doi.org/10.1016/j.tws.2019.03.051.