PSIR 2A Notes by Mridul Shivhare, IAS
PSIR 2A Notes by Mridul Shivhare, IAS
Paper 2A
Notes
By
Mridul Shivhare, IAS
Table of Contents
1. Comparative Politics: Nature and major approaches; political economy and political
sociology perspectives; limitations of the comparative method.
(a) Rise of superpowers; strategic and ideological Bipolarity, arms race and Cold
War; nuclear threat;
(c) Collapse of the Soviet Union; Unipolarity and American hegemony; relevance
of non-alignment in the contemporary world.
9. United Nations: Envisaged role and actual record; specialized UN agencies-aims and
functioning; the need for UN reforms.
0 T , II · w ~ .fi - T ~ ,• + ; cr"';~J l ·
P.
~h W GU bC\.)r) CA1LJ - \ttr-M..p~ ~ Cri 6 ...+'.
0 hf-I-Vt w w n - ~ ~ c.. p.
~ r-. fhu.~ec{ ~ ~
. .,
~ .{. hO-.JV1~
R.l!No I \A.tu m •
V te ~~ 1-: ~~~ PcrtJ"+
iu
0 ~" re_~ -tu b -1-i, ;, 1 ½rf•.
-~ ' +u+·u6:1 ~ P.o-Ut.'w ·t½
bvJldYY; ... -fr¥
""' s a ~·&:r;,;~ .
@ ~ p e-U h'W
+ ~ u 5c..,·~i'\.h f; c. 1
bM -u ~ J_ {h cLd W
_{l_/b i'U +o ➔~
~
@ ~ -e.L M!: d ~ ~
- ~~l VLJ a}
I 1iv l ')
L~ ~
rOt th CoJ -p ~ Y\. t""Y \AQ ;"-C v\
- f c-li'f-iLo.J 0vcJ-i vi11·e .f
i , pol i'H W
~ H--Gj ~ p~L,'
h' tA..,[ p\]v'J f.. ,i_ ·
:;i¼: ~~ , H~ .,,( B ~] [ Gao
K. - " c.~ ~ k~
(.: ~ t ~ l>.ll rlu ..l '. /tn
.:n h-\ J.,u.,c_;., ·CIV) "]
TJ.i ~-'7
w
-
-'-"'U J ~ ~ I ~ ::£· "--I -
~~ cvv ~~ t., - Mti-v.n ~~ ,
~ ~ ~ u~ -~~ "fi!..1~
~ ~h,t~·~ -
~ ~d~1 , ~ ,~ bw r tcu·'-' .
G; fb-Gh~ e.U n ~ , Jrr-ij 1 ('Yo r-e..t H , t..Fc.
~ w W"'1<-, l .·J,-
______
~ At 111\. tr,,J ~ V V\J, Ci. r
). I, 1\, , r__; "" ( ( .u.Ll u.)IJ
fI '1. l"t, J
r
TYR.Clt'-h' cm~
K
wi.. -fi.t
C. '-½ ~ -o-d ~cl
-
~ urp-t 1 ~ ~~-Uf LA,~ t.
be..~ V\J w 11 . -t lt-..ffhtfL, ""llnk/~ µ,~
-f".La'Yd Bry ~
+ ~~ H)iett .
~. ~ h>-, M""-fM ,
@~
- ~~ ~1+-u .
M o ~ t·P M ~ uo-.ttc,I ~~ ~
A ru ½ °b ~ d ,~rL l~ e U\ h·s ~ w w - 21 .
~ .g ~ ~ bv.- ,' ~ -+h~ f::<u c!,u,t_r
1--1:i t. h~ tr¼ ACL-1 4\e.."1o lu..+un,') ..tn 1w t ~
~ r ~ - s () ~ ~ , \/\rl-u' L~ uJ J e..d
!g; r!.N\_.~..+-i 1-~h cm ~ ~'-i o.. ~t
~ __;_t- q '- ~ ,5u 'e. .~' < ', ./2
@~~t9--
\ ° 'f f v l ~
@) /4 1 " Y i~ k +
i~ \ S
~ ~cu_L,
G)~
I~ ~
~
~t,-1
lV
" :· -ll,
·1R,>, ~p
~ ~
'MdA.hU
--
" Ct
'
~
,~
1
I ti~
-
'
. #-
fV \. _ ~
rm. k J I g
-
~ t i :"'.
~ :°':f ~ ~~ (i) ~
..,-:;_N4MJ
v~
°:ft:1 o..L~
W-.LMU 1 *= ~~ -" '~ ~
~o.,v,d ~M~ ~ ~
~kUu -h-L- .<l ~
,
. •-v.-,
~Aj-,vn,l,1 ~ tA-l l~ V\ ~
J!l~ ~
~t.-------: ~ ~o ~
~~ ~ -t& ~1-<-t, ~ p
UACV:1/ ~ k - ? P?:f ~ (~~ ~)
~• ~I
~ ~ : . - 80 U ~tt) o/:j l'YLoJ-!,,J r
lhM ~ \u ~ hroJ J ~~ !A.n~ N~ s u R...rvcA..., ~'l,<,lj
I
f:¥-kJ ~ ~
/
~ ~ ~½ ¼u ·
~ k-0 ~ Lf - T ~ tAtt1
11
~
Cit,W """1 lM-\.-1 C.M .Uwu /- ,I-, ~-.., ®M /," ~ Mv) l-u h ~'-'-•f4:::'1
N1t i,.,.J 1-oJ -t,,
1~
ti:v"'"'-"--' ~ 1
= t-<.>c., WO)-{J - Jh.L~ ~- J
..LI •--------
'. _ ~ "-' N'd T-,,,,.,,., -da:'::':t r,,;'.::'.1
~ ~
N1'Y\ """-'1-<-0J
/21> ~ , rd - e.,,,,:; .u...,__~ 6 '7°H :'.I ~
C\f Jry -~ )J"8 tp-t,t1'~J .
~ M-- O~ t.p· ~-h mu u t.9..llLsl - (}t) ~ , p,,{,h'c..9.J ~ _ t~
M -fN •'f,i,,w 1- ~ ~ ~~ / ~ , o.N.M''.
Iii EluU dA.k T~ - di«.i.p¼••'-:i Mdw v 1- ,p,: -:r,. q d.a-nu..\ D....1-,__.d_ bj Ie .
~
~~ t-f . D~~ ~ ~ " ' w.eu ~
Q) t,p 1i /
IA gy._b-d-l: :<4LJ\( ~ ~ ~N . '
. j
~ Vi
. ' • '
u.l.lt.A M " H ~
✓.
Pt-tii ,w t u ' t."'-U I
1--
u. --_,
~,.,l
i
~~ ~ w i ~
.S t.i' U\U. " BL"l-
.-Lt-1
-
~ . ==tF A-+4Vt w w-[_ ~ llv..ui- pY ~'t.: .f
~ 1' l!>t~1-
@{rt.4 ~ ~ ltn"Sh H(_ r\tNV I B.t.htl-.1/l'fw\9-..f ~~" ) ~ f ~ -tn-- l1)1citMk,,..J
M.~ .__q _d cL - ~ ~ ~ Jbt)I) ,- ~
(\ ~31,-u.,b ~ -s~' ClAw . ~ E~( M,~ - EM"h7Y\ dM4 l«.r -h t./\.uJ. ..{
\, So S ~. -t, t9J1 1"· t. · P p.,1 - ~"'1\.1~ ~ ~ ~ --h UI.U.N Lo'V\it(.r~
~ic...
G, avr NO~ o.Ju ~ ~~ . H-t J ~ 6w,:::u.-- Bci 1T~ ~ ~
-r , ~ 1~ 1 .
lJ
15'1\ ~ ~l •I~ , r ~--:s 1--a"'-<.t o...1-\J, ~ \ . - ~ "--~
.. ~t,~~ ·~ ~ drtt¼ ~, ~ ~ ~ -d . ~ .
~~ .
• ~ ► -:II.?'"
'/ U"I.Ar\...'.} - f M -h-ri 'A °:tfY l' C\,d, ~ itrt o,J,,s ~
• lP-w I ~ ~ ~~~ l.9-..I t\-v\_o-..t,~ ;}(.~
l
.~ .
- -=~
Iv cL ~l- ---d
...:....;~
- -~
I - -'---: --:-- -~ -r-..! ._~ i_.e_
--tk.c M.,c-~ ~ L~ e_ ~ l V'( ~1~~ ~ ~tit\,('. l.
C. Yi-ti~ E V ~ .
Q) . ~~
~~ ~~ Mf~ ~d-1 n..o "Y'«~·
p; ;;_, f- "--i'f'.>:>f>:!"'-"' r". p.-t;~
, ~ u , --- oL 3 ni w-~ C,V\A..'1.+n·~ , ~ ,-
J T ro__d_;+, OY\..cu_t"'s't t. n,., ,.,.... , -;;-ff- :..r:
_n, P-'"1
~8-riv>q,<
u L' c~... ...1
0
IA1' ~ '--UM ":'.'::j t"""-"
. · ·· r U t,d,.~ , ~~ -w Uu' ~ S--u ./ ~ M hi d,i I
, e..uvu' :..i ~~
.s . ~ L..."" ~
e.tY\NU
~
-(j- ' ""J"cu,.~ ' -
_,;,\-..-,,~ Lr""' '~ • N"of- , , , _ ~ +<,., ~"'>Hh.....t,_o=,,,__, ./4
~ ~
0
-rh \ ~ ~ ~ N~ ,
® '-ivtD-11.1(.1~0 + 0WH~'Yf'\
- o· ~ ¼ - ~ ""-
O~ - .......... -
~1-t
,l;;,.,,·t,,__~ ,
1
~
4' Vl>vu<,/ UJtk,' """-<
L-! fa..irn,,c-< ~~
o M.<Vv,ifu I.Juf;q)-< f~1,'"'-l ~ <W ":J'f"'o..<l ~ t": ~ gli '-•d'cf:c:.
' <;+,._~ ~ U<:rf-,; -f'
" \I Ada.ri,.:.-. "'"""'-' ";µ l-<M
Uu.! d • v ~ -#,,
-n:r:u, J., ~
bt.<v..n, +,. ~~
--ti..;,., t ·--Q ~ "-'--'-~ fu":'/
1--,
<4 "
-"
1 <.m.,.,-t; I-cu-.:..,_, ~
~ "1d.,,,_j
~:t:;rr:i'
! ,__...---- dis"""'""'-" w /o .,,._ "--, . -+. 3ct- '-tr,-v..
"'1
:'l J.)~
A ~ "-'
ro-1,+;c_o.1
-lh..,,, ·,_,
!'.'t:'~
-'t
"--1' "-'u...~ '<.4--,_'., "'
.
C-P-
"-J .4-- -
Y\-0 En b1€..l\,1 L'1 ~V\ ~'\u .
• 9t W ""''tu~ u.--,,, F- ~ : ~ , ~ ,,
..v; 1-\'-' T ,k, • &<0v,.,•~-.... ( '--½ l..c., a "1'f',->..i.... )
.,....__,f-<.c., "" ~ ~ .
~ n-; ~ , "---' '<-r ..:, ~ .,-,..o1.u, o-,,.'..I , ~ )<-t-k ~ ';"' 4, ._. i ~ ~ +
,{ In.!,~ 1:y {l>Y ~ . , •hu ..,,_. -"'--i'"' M .... ,-."'i ~
~ .,_,~
ol,,t,1 ....
~
,{ ...__, i>...,,.J ..:.~ ·.., 'l V
e , , . ~ u>i'<--u "1 iht I-<,,,. ' ,w-4-m.d..i HOY\<l.Af • J. ~. vi d ,;,;, dLl
@ o-1-hut_ C.Jr,. h ci sM.1 " l\s • v'-"'.vle '1-- ""n, < Lv-,~ t - . I,, lr-"'--'--'-~ I,'\.,..,
• N of IJ h ivV\.-1 o.L', k,: ~e.{e,,.,.,,_,, , .u- 'JV"'
"' w,.,.. ·: +hu:"'/ --< ~
' h,.,.i l-1-"""-.I"L..
--1
~r- ~~
e,,~r-:t0. +kt -~ ~ -h~~-4- " ~~ '/-~ ~r::L~
l ~1-av,;""! t::>:L1--, w .,~,
¥"),, ~"" _ -"'-f-'\~ '¼½
i>f ~ •-
~
p tH..l¾ -f~
0 .fv_,, Lh,~
L
I
T lv-.lt M..° '--~
I
C
A ~le. "'-P~'<A,+-tM
L
5
'f ~ M~d j u-_~ ,
s
T
f
M
~' b~~ Mili;,qvv~~-A ~ , ..6 ~--~ ~ .
. 1'-~ ~ f~ ,'d~ "'-~r-i~ ~ @Wt. ~!0, ·-
7 ~~ -l~n:OV\.,j 1 ~--~ Pn,;,OJu'½, ½ . l ~ b { ~ , ~\- lPv, ~
"-1./ Poi · ~ ~ ~ •~~ ~ k d..-,,.., "', ~ , ' • J ·
~ . ~ 1-uv\ dfli · l ~ 1- c k w _ ~
n) J,
~ j ~ -1cm.., ;;':,J ~ ~ ~ I<-W.f ~
~
"' VV-.t,.vv &-.i -th,
-f=-,_n~ . -rJ o-l.iku.J ~ .
. .g n ..11-h t-- J: .. ~ ~"'«L'~w 1- Po-L'h•w L~~ - k~~
~
L~
i:-::::,_ 1 ""' 1 ,!,.,,~. ~"K.~ , "-lvr f ""'~..t
@ V<rl.'h'tJLl Ww~ ,i ~tw.u~ @ ~'<le Ai>~~
A~ E~ ~-1-~~. @ ~ i ~~~-~
(?) -1-f\f--vlM-t- lr>-"H~ . ti.,;,,~ ..,._, y-.,t!;u"'.!:/ , ¼ ,::, ~ ,i,,..,._,
~ ~ • t>-r ~ ~ ~,11~ .,,S ~ .
~~ •~ ~ 4-41 . ~ "I: rr,,, .1~
~ A ili...U,'f,'t,,_J,;,.,,,
~e_
':} MiRW
t l)~ _ '1rS-½ <./<Ltfono-..1 l'G, I ·
T ~tt"he,1 - N""'-J>r-Y.-. < 1 ~ P<;,,, . Ace . -tu 1\--/ "'""'c/
- ,.Q'
,1:,"w ~ ,,,, c,1'.::;'-::;t-
(1) ~~ l ' t ~ .~ ;__i,_ d.-,_ ..,,, -
U"YVti ·d,...ruvs
l
f \u .~ ' ?~L i\ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ 1 c3J"P .
~ -1/11
\ \ (. ·h::'Y
g - ~
t- ~n'd~
°'~~ -J ~ ~~
_,go-_tf
t il-i b-- ~ lh -L~ 1 VC,H L;,,_h
l'.b k 1 3oJ C\...~ n e .. .. ~ l'-'"Y ~.u.. 1' 'r<..\ ~O{.(f_"J
e✓ e"-c.~
• "-ti ct '\- tM k - - R~
\I-. d t,<v'\,~ Q "( p-l"--~"'-~
,, -r;~t \..\ V\ ') h "d ~ k ,__,,,, \~ \. ~ ·
• P6-\.1 \-i u' 1-11..•f·u,-~
"t (o vH < ", ~
..,,,..,.,
T u f\-UV\.bck C.~LU 4n.cl~
PM CV \. J
~1 ~
k ~ " LWv! u K.t
)
'f r, r:J ~ 'f Ol....ol~
► 1 l \ I .. '· , CJ.-'n
a. ,1 " ~ , ·.,<.
V lA .l \~ ~ V'
~ k h.•'x k l ,LJ'-!,__H
ll..
'.S tr y t,, ( -:r"'·H::':½+ e ?< p lO\.(_ J ~,LV\ ~ v\.l-<. 1 t" l~
- '-'. , ~ ~ed -_h {~o lo 5 ,"t.c:..t j r::
~h ..c _ Y',,C "Y
V' -,L ~ 1- \ L ~ 1 tn G u : ~" :<- h"-"l- j
hi ~t ... u- ..J ,-
'\., o\ C\ L~ €..\e,t..t"lt'"'t'\.
w ;r hL"1
.\ •
(.' ½ \-_ : v-o n Y\ ..~
<.l \,-{ -~ " " '~en-'-'- .
--......,..____--.
Lim..a~ttL.J.:O"Y',l ~ PD{; i;~ h- d~
~fu,uJ,0,,,w ~ Pb-4 · k,'~"'-tfS 1:1 w . -,-. 1- P- ~
~ !buvt \ n+ ~ I- 1~ ~'- -~~ ~
_Po-t . s c.. t' t..t\L,f_ ~ ~
±--r \~~ 1-1 ().,,~ ~ ~~
i<k""--ng ,< ~ WM ~ t,, l\ ~b .. di..S<-L~~
&~ ~f~ , N~ .. 1"""-h'h..Ji'~-.,,-.t.i ~
--t
~ " ~ ~~t
~h~~ ~~ .
7 ~(;.P,.(°
.rO t1._c1-f ct th,..l't\.Ul e,,.l&
~ ~ , u _ j WI ~~tHJ ~ ~ ¼ t-
~ f)L-tJ..) ~~ --:: \ ~ 0--,,, e_~
~ +l u..,( Q) b G-+t °'-ffYl> ~ I
L.
L j
I
Ad0..,-,, .SM.i ~ l8 tAYv.n' cl..t.A.e-J M
~
~ ~H ~, 1 ~.£ ~~ .it-
I
a.-! -+ht
~ ~ti ~ 1 s~~ -h ~ ww.f-1,,
~ ;ti
-~
~ tm i)
-hi ~ N~ .
Pl ~ ~ I~ ~ Mj M.oJ ~
-
1,' ( ~ c: kt .i~ 00 u ~ ~ ~
'tn
~ . Jh ~ ?~ h: u b~
.IA
~ ~. '
~ PE. ~ .. tn ~ ~ ~
~ 1r ~
Uh~
,
~ -e-v~rmu-.:t-- A-pp11>cuJ,
7
G) 1J_ f f'l-~U\_~'11_-h~ -t h-Lf\c-h'crvv;J
~ l- i..\ a. J'A-0 cluu, C\..P-M ~ ~ t... r, - S.-p ~ o..t,~ h ~
~ ' ~ ! "---h~
~ P..,,~+
f ~~1 ~ tu-n L ~ • .
--- u
V'A-t'\.~ &-~ ~ ~""'-'iawu~J
'rlNO ~ h~ .
E
:tt ClJnu.. V p . ~~a:fy,,
~
~ ~'-1
:.
C\. . ,P:fry C\.t_l,.,
-
~ptvu.-1
_'.'1 "-' "'--~ 1:- p,,,.-l~'l_o._/
pcv,_ h '-'-C"'-h.~ "'-"'-<c/ J:o-1' j., I h+cc±c_-,..,,,_
fo-l,l-i uJ 7-~ M d--<N•(,l.,. l:!d - ~'-~h.'ov, , ~LI-, .:., " Pi>lJ KtA./
::- L~~ -ll '\I -~ tft:½I b ~ ~ -rl'-( ~~,
l
~ w_ e:tt::?::'- k t t') h eh'0¥\.<l1' L~h-~"""
~
C'Y' L~ '
~ .b e._.,,._'-~ ~.(_>..t • Iv-,.,_,,,__~ ~ '-'-"'-'7)""'~"" 1: - ,,,"'.,; h' /-,. CL
~ ~ ~,.~ r (_~"-"-;~ ~- - - - - --- ----
,' """'1.,1,'l)-,;,_,, "" 3 Y,j '" ,.-,{,/ '-"'-'-"-~
-
~ '1 ~ -<9t-<'._lu, t i.., p,uJ__/ "-'VU"--~ (_4..,-,
~ ~~
l)¼~, ~-h,L-i .
4p-t.__,_~zd c.u.---=pt ·
::tt:- Luc.ia...,
He ~~
P;r:
p~
£ <-l>
K\l.;\_1 hYv) f\7Y\ ~ ~Lf>}
- 1-
~
3 h, v-N...l~k
po-L1,-!A/ U u,-; h"-,,_ Ll "'-/
PQ-{)HCP._t ~~~ -
z -"1 (iw
K~}A 4tt>wi. /
.
._,,,/"
(}) § •'-'<LI q___, f..j"--.J.'1 j"" <U..I -01.
--- ----
p•-{J h' l ,J f <Vtf-/ ':'.f"-i.;,,_, + £J"'-o.J.tf-c/
;ti:~ l~. -/ c l ~ vi -+k,
- r,_f-t_ 1, yu--i-vtt,
~
+
Gil ~ ~ ---> Jf-o..1--, :, CAE ""-; r-i ~ '.: '-'-"-< 3 d..vv\ ~ ~ f o-{ • T> w <-L~
~LLJ ~Q t\A , stJi ~ !k-4-( , ck~ h ( , , i,_., "'-~• s/n..f-< :, ts. pW !-.1 +. L"'-1':l<""-".:}"
~ La,__~ ; q +t, ·L~~l~ -U -,. --~ ~li' (.1c 1 -1-- t °'-f t\.
--
t_ 1--f <; ~ In'1 ,...ty "h _f~f ·!)P /-<,-.,
I I
,l~ A t!:L'c.,~! , -1- l 'V\.p k () C?-c{ c.., a".X 1..', ~.._,,s_e... <Jr.,
'
. t- n 't ;o ~
i ~ M d.µ.t..h,UYl
(0 TYR.Cli .\,m__c~.lt'Si-1 lUl\.o
~ + ,l,t (\ ( M _O J\_ ~ fVb ·
('A {) ~ Q_pfn ~ ~~ @)
~
I
~ f-U\ ~ ~
f v o ~ "b B~ ~vi ~ ~
1
' f. t_,~ ~
olu..h .·l'N! M .o ~ v, _('L.P-..,~
~r W O\J ~ ~ k h olo '\ Ur\ c_ _ ~ ~ ~
.J\A ~'\.o.J ~ ~
..li IU -~ p. ~ " ~ I',-1; H ~ De . , n ~/
~
'
~~M Yl)
•
u,..I w LO ~ Yt r1 , k
i C~c w
I
p~
C, - '
u,
-(_J' .e._b"~ ) ' DlA.v, d ~
Ai' tv\ _fj y', (! -~ ~ eh..e.i:i,
W t t P~l J\-u.,J ~
f'J\.o ~~ $¢
M) I
E d.wM...ol ~ e..tt
- cu " , v ~ ·_
~ I C\_ptu ~ lL~ lY )~ ,t w
W h 'u ~ ~~- t> ~ lJ ~ ~~
Ct..J r_ .
- ~~ ~ --.L e.Y\.M ( .
~J u -l-hw °'fl~MA 1 .
1~ ~ OJ\..Ll t.L "L L V'--~ \ U
~
~ --tw .r u..L. 1 ""'° C U A IA J ~ I
w { ~ G\..t.{ , -\-o ~
~ l-v"I ~
LI c :L l. M ~ _
lRV.Sr)
• l\.o-.n~ t>JJ~'c.vi
• u ~ V \. h .. .~
• t ~~i '"U>~Oi,,\
, k d - L ~ OvlttAh~ I
;; ('
71.N.\.-1 , Ad~ ~ o 'r' t.J
dA.rn tl')~cY)
OY ~ i l½-l -?!:k1v1 ~
~ 'V °' t/ 2 ._e"--l""'-Lt. .M-- ~O
u.,~ ~ h, "' E:"' d j
~ clu Io r-1" rt~ 1·
~~ h-n 'A ~~
~
fV¼ d,v u'--il..A.-h~,
w f\ l I ~ to
fvw tin\. 1 1 .. A ~ "1 ~~ r::lt ~'\"
CV~ .. - H-1 b ~~ hr\-1..1- -Y V ~
c
w f'\.At ~
·-~0 \ "<"'<'. n. '-\.J--~ l
- ~~ •1 l'V '--, ~
''.- Ci\ ., t- '-/ -
-- -
~>:-- ~ ~ 1.--t l v r""'~ - -
~ o....~ NC\.+
- I
{ in )
~-·~~_ ~1._ .
Ck\.l~\.."\.f ~ V\..d_ ~"'-o+·H r~op{~ :--t
1b:.e.,{_ ,~' I V\.~ I h fu:i
tr\-,' .e..v,. 1---o___ 4-m>-i °'-~
-+k e p b-li +-; W .)/y\_0 k"-1 ·_
'
~ ~" ~~
\,,J ~ ., 4 ~ pa.J\_,f·h.ir ~.1-~t
~
~P~· ~KM.. Ut.L~
- 1..... w,t<M .
~ 0" 1
., .,. i...;1,,.o,
-
~~ ~
4 re.~ t,.... • To, """" ,,,,,.,,,.,,, .
# ~ ~
~
&io.bY1<>J A-lnA.~ •~ 11'<>,_I-J '-<,,b• < ~/
~ ~~::-/
•• -n; C. '-4'"ll
VVv)o. ~ -ti~ bo ~k - ~ 1t'.".::-' -.-,... -h, -i;', '°"" 3:' :}½ l e"\cl.u..,
C.L4,~~
, 't.,_,, <ch_'°"'._/ S...., '-"-J ""1'l I c....._, t, "'-'u.c( +·
~ ;:1tltu.~ ~ --
~
7li~ O¼V\. ~l<\.hA
• ':;1 "'-< w cl"'- '., --hxx£\p ': 1 "~dro.l :J',r':[
"9" p\.J-_ o~14:f- • ~ d
* ~ »-1 c:JA-¼01't.J p. c. C\..,;i - f'>.,~~c. ,
t •w
• 'D O-M. d f o..,H"""' '..4
D~~ C\.r\d 1~n~ t ,
~ ~. P ~~ TirY) u.Cv½i n;·~ r.c. -tn C\.,U'._
~t 1d~rrlo(b,oJ -
J~ l'\! IVV \
c,e.J\Q..,~l':f Z---f"'--"-1
~ -k" "' t~ wkcJi ~C \.d, <l::1-i -h~'"'--., -n
~~ h F ~~-
~ 1~ ~'e.,t_/ chi-t¾t.h u : (.1(: i1 h 1..t- ~
i"C \Jv \~ ( ~) . Ex - IJk ,
1) V ._ ~ V \ '~
l,~ ~' W\C 'Y)
L
0 _'1ne PV\_1 T:1:~-
E:t - ~ '..-! ~ PO..U, ,
@) .f_""-h<-& OJu ~rr-eJ =~ -
1 /1,_'f>:<f~ .-f"-u-l, •- f"-"--/w,
-J,~ ~ -
- ~D u' "-I u...,.,
.-t,· kt ~ m -~ ·· ~
. l . A ~ · Jr,TD, vJ , 6".;..,, r.,.,._ ].
B ,r D, Bs p
~~
bC_oY,RJ
© C'..o "-l,' t,_;.,, l.i <rv1- w /, ..t, <A.L~ ~ ~ ;i,~&r,, ~ Miw _ " t> e - h~ "1,~
,. o1, t,,-.;
@ Ir.,.,.,;,"-"<.~ 1- < Wu, oJJ E""1J,'t-! '. pCVc!y ~ f<,,, -/tc~.,.,J f'-2½ 17fJ,
~ ..J ~ ~
I
~ A' h ~~"'a" C
;;:...-,
~ %' ', ~ ,1._,, Bov..,_J-<<72:'.
21~I- ['.llJ"\.fu..,
9v rn ...te. nt
..jl~ .>?u..."1..viv-td ""'--d
19 - f l ~ ~ fa
~ ~
~ +, ,_., <nPu.:, U"-1-,--a..1 -h
•°""-'A
0
"- b<,i [ "vch_._,, <n D W ! ..,_, I'. ~ ~ ct.(fi~ •y~,'
/11 " 1"-<l,.,,, /2 ";r t;'- h.;__,, :C., Ury,_
~ Lou..-.
~ " • "·•
(!) 0 ! 1V \~ ~
~
. ~ -- -v r th e ! t-'t'-H
o LT) .z.r tu .L i '1 ~
. 0
~ e.. t "'- Y ,t,, q-ri1
ov...h '11¥)
.
~ -i <- 1~ ~ .
N" $ "" L 0-.>\.e. ~~
- ~
-h> t-\v,i nol"--1 . • p ~ ~ .. .,
, H ~ lc.,~
k
L 1
(9""~ r.
r,.. >v W )v ½ bt M ..U wev1-t. • t,~ ~ l o-t M s .A ~l\.l-s
JV\M-l-41 - tl.9--M
N '( ~ ,v u .
~ JU-.rl ~
_ N .t M i yr u" u. .-\
ln ~ ' fr) ~ p ~
~
~l' V\ / . fVI ..AT '( " < ~ "' ~ .
R. • ( ~ u.J..-_q
~ ~ G) ½;.., t.-~ ~
~ r ~~ ~ ~
th ,._ k) v- ~' h' rv...-hcY1 ~ ·w
.-w
~
-r-.. o 4-- w v..i -
~ · ~V 'fv 'T Y 'I
t'.J ~
lY1 ?> v- i! w~ L-L~ ~
~
C~o.J-u~~ 1 s""~- 0, D tN t. ,~
j l, 1o ~ ~ ~ .-
~ ~ fv y M J\ /0 ~
J) r ..:..---5 ~~ ~ ~
~ ~
~ t& if}, ~
~1
1
v v -. L l~ w(l){__d 1 o\ ~ s !':l-5 ~
N IS Y I~~
~ .
'LA
=+1-N~ ~"'-
\.-
~ N ;½ol >M
L ..U\~ (7) ~ +u ~
ft>-lin•,-&1
~ ~~ - ..-! ~
-
~1 ~ u
(~-y\-
~ ~ N~ ~ d)
/ > A
-
M Y1,- "J"ef:'<';;Y "' ~ G\;(..(4 .u...,~
§
~~ 1
o L ~ ST rvvrrv . ..
l')...011) . .+h..(_ "h'~
"' - V .S A . ~- "
0,v..1 -h ~ Lo bM
J~ ,
~ ; C)__,l, u:'J "'n~
Q) ~ '.1:b ~ ~0
0%+;' l p~ ~ .
-W cV\. M Ay 'f'\
~"' - ~ . Uk , ½A .
@) b. N . V Y ~
L~ ~
~ -- h N ~ -
1 t--) t, 01
IJ b ~~ ,
.
e ~'-'U( lA-wA ~ - ~ ~- ~ .
~\~~ ~ rn tt ~
C,~
o L~ f> T
\!1 A {U l½ ) / in' ~ M, 11 V "' 0-1 ~ ~1FM~+
0 !)t \..U _... ~ . . . ,
~
o-c,
~ 1'W~ - MA-v "' .,_ ,/?
-U) •r, (A .,t ,"'- J..
1 -t "\ .~ ., P ,~ ~ l,. !'j I
"n':f h...K ~
~ ~ ~ ~
o~ ~ .s + n
1 .~~~ 6 ~
V\ t,e n b ~ D :~"'-i ~ - -
t~ ,O - ~~' ,_,,-
CAL~ / h i~ 1~ ~ ~7 .
o C(~ w ~ Sh--<.,u- ~ tJ f Vl (_ ,( 1'V\..-vy " ----~ ~
C 11-S~J vi L . ~ w IA, /\.
~ ~~
~ 'rtJt,,(,e~
0
'v ,
l) w ~ ~
~
0~ ~~ ~ ~ cJ ~h '~ V) ~
o s~ , ..A N ~f v\ .! t- t -- ~ ," 1 ~ . T '1 ~ k .M ~
~ ,; h.~ cl·~-~
¼
' \A 1>-b kH1 b ~ 1M u, w.i,,¥1,, ~ 1-v-.. ~
:. 7 .
Sc~ ,._~~d-AR 6 '~ ,.1 ""f 'Pv.\3Lcc' ~ NO"r\ ~ ~ ~ t..om."t\,U
r
'v\ d-vu.,\ 'riL(_ 1,-.J..1
0
~ ' 1: '
k,tV\,L,Cvtl- Ov11AV1Ae-
l.
''lsorcierle.s.s worLci/'
~Mll r.svi1ALL Mll cviLl,.{villr,-"c;JLobll [ vLLLci9e''
o ~ 0V1A1A.s FreLC\V1A/AV\, ('~e- w~ -M Tl.;:;
fJP-'.f ")
'
h oV1AIAS Fre L~V\,\,{AV\, t'Tht Lbt\44 .r ~~,,, -%,exorllb Le L,V\,tes vciho?:)
pf VIAllYRets, N-S1, tee.vi to ci ciegree V\,everwLtV\,e.s.seci befove"-:TOC\Cl !j
LV\,c{LvLctulAL.s, corp, NcitLoV\,s v recicviLVlg tvie worLci fcivtvie v, fcist ev,
ctee-per § cvieciper -
*"tho""i:I 9lacte.,,_s)-.,-;;:;:e""sificetip"" (4 wo,L@wi 0e t pc i eL rel etio""s
§ C-0V1Apressi,0V\, L-V\, ti,V1Ae § spcice - •
o '-10 1Ar)(;-
"Secircvt for profLts wLLL tlARe bourgeoi,se t o settt~
~ er/j wvteve § V\,estLe ever/jwvtere"
Y'rtfr.st ThoV1A .soV\,-PreseV\,t S L6L L.s ci Rvtetovi,c ov ci ~
bl,{zz wovci' ell Ltci CLst ex LoLtcihoV\,-- ;t i,s; j!,{st ci C1 Lobci L
eqciV\,sLoV\, of ellpLtciLL.sV1A.
(' ~\>lh' le"11~ tw-1
Moelels; of c;Lob~LLs~HoVv .
,,~,., .. ~c."-'14"•
·=--
• <e.seV\,t V1Aoci eL- bcisec{ o Neo-Ll berciLLsVvl Lee{ b!j ~SA~ e vtAcn-,zet
ell Ltci LLSVIA Ubevci L cieVIAOC VClC (u5V\,c{ of t-tLstov/j ")
C-viLV\,ese VVt.oGieL- f\t WEF-- L expves.seci tvt cit C-VJL-V\,ll i,s wi,LLLV\.C\.-to
~me{ the c;LbL§ C-vtL-V\,ll Leci V1Aoci eL wLLL be V1Aove LV\,cLl,{sLve 5
sl,{stciLV\,cibi,e l,{V\,LLRe ~SA .
wLv\,v\,evs §Loosevs . ·
, ,,.,,;:.::=,p...--,;;e.;;.;
tv...;.e~ .,
/il t, eveV\, f/ils vi i,011\,1,V\,C\ wvi/il t .soV\r\.e wLLecl t vi '-..e:::==--==--__..,
c1LbL cle: LV\,ecl /il bmclevle:;,:;, wNLd 1;:fse nvvi,tovi,ciLi,zcit-wV':)b1At "-1- S
t.eJ? U\ \ LI(' ) L@ LLZed ell\,Lhlj T ne;;e ( CfV\,ti,-tvieti,wL i,deC!5
=-
&k~~
r~ · ../_;V\r\.Ovterv\.~ liltL; v\. (RDbe ~ 9 i,Lpi,V\.) .
'g:f _t1Glrfs,et Gl se ecoV\.OV\r\.~es ClilV\. ovvL!j o:perGlte euectLVel rj wi,tv1L~
_u ci _
?" lil coV\.text of Leg/ill-&, socL/ilL ovvier tvililt OV\.L!j tvie stlilte ww
provi,vi e._ \
o ALtvio[.,(_g~ st/iltes, wvieV\, GlctLV\.g stplW/ilteLrj, V\r\.GI t1 vi Give GI
lilLV\r\.LV\,Lsvieol w-pG1dt!:j to coV\,troL trGIV\,SV\,GltLOV\,GIL ecoV\,OV\r\.LC
G1cdvi,tf:j, .tviefj re~~JV\, fGlci,L i,tf:j to olo so tviro[.,(_gvi vi.tGlc ro
fr/ilvi.teworRs of ecoV\,Ovi.tLc reg [.,(LGltLoV\,, Gls -provi,oleol b!:j c::; -2 0 ,
WTO, IMF
4-lH,rugvi prr{ruV\,cl c.v,ciV\,ge_c;, vicive tciReV\, pLcic.e_c;,, but 181 0
t1 c:ijLtLC%lll wtuye_c;, beiV\,c _c;,we t c:iwci c:iLto etvier. we ewe
wLtV\,e_c;,sLV\,g t vie bot vi . V\, so V1Ae cispec.t, g Lobc:iLLzc:ihoVl- Ls
WLV\,V\,L,V\,9 § LV\, otvi eY c:ispects. 5t0tes 0re holcb , ., g t he p0 ·11er;; ~
4, -s:, , ,.. ; -,~; •,i:0 Diff states aave beevc ivt<pacted d ifferevctl!j
-~ / , L
o '7\ clvci V\,c.ecl I V\,cl u5'tYLll Lstcite_c;,- Post-V1AoctevV\, V1A.uLtL-Leve
d oveYV\,ll V\,c.e
o wecirz post-c.oloV\,Lc:iL stcite_c;,- Lost _c;,ovevei,gV\,t~
o J,tloclevV\,i,si,V\,g stcite_c;, W~.e ""&R.ICS- ""&ettev po_c;,i,tLoV1-ect
Pit V1ClS effectect sovev-eis VcC ),'; of pooYeY § S,VvlllLLev V1-CltlOV1,S, L,V\, Cl
wov_c;,e wci Htvici V1- tvie bi,ggey oV\,es
·-r
OV\- ci
LA '
~ - V\, 9eV\,evc:i_c;,wV\, couV\,tnes, r WLV\,V\,er_c;,.
., f
eVLlAelAtvoVIA. ,..J '
' ,.J .,
p ve(/\1,chok'.\, o.£1
'?\SL-ClV\, c.eV\,tUY!f' § sviLft L,V\, C.O,fi of IP froV1A T-A to A-'P.
V), ~).? t.e ~Vl-CO!t1AE ec ('V\..'•VI) 1,,,1 (1scz Lt ~!l'vVeste:,:i LV'\. he Cl Lt vi ~-;ec-1.1.)
°BYll V\,~OMeL~VvOS~J•s f, Lep (lf V\,L f,k<.YVe
~VI- ?O .U)
-Ve.
CvthctA L
I ' I !
v7Glve 'C?.,~evc MO.X Cev\.PfU:.<;
AVvtC!rC!t C! sell\,, Y°CDK 'C'c0v\,OV',HC, Dev c, ,S "~-- J. ~;'".' . . ~ ¾trLe.S
vyviLcjL ioLv,,tlil nci ve beeV\,, better tVJCJV\,, tvio.se YeV1A.C1 LV\.e1i' 01,,{t.s Lc{e-- C Gl V\.
.serVe c:i.s o:p:p QV\,,L!j bkj cci:pc:icLtLl buLL1i'LV\.g of peopLe
~ tn) I ~ t:j~t)~ t
bee" tl/\cL1..t.swe
' .
,
I
' ,No p OLl/\,t Lv'v bLC!vvtl-11\,g ejLb f ov 1.;/ovLc'i'.s p ctLev-vt.s"- ~ t _CrLb~
but Al,{tov1,,<.C!hQil..§ t,11\,COYYect -poLLci,e.; of Ci O'J.t Y R/S for JOC
Lo.s.se.s- EvevL CjfC wci.s bcz c+veDuLciton) +llLl11.ve_;
"P1,n·.sui,l/\,C\ -pvotechoV'vi,.SVvt i,.s Ldze Loc~i,11\,g w.eseL.:-""i,vv f:l dcii-~
VCOV1A. ~V'v:7' lll/\,:7' '(Clt,11\, VIAC!!j be fze-pt out.si,cAe, ~ut so i,s Li,eh:
ci~ c fl y"
o c::;Lb Ls Cl "c:lol,{bLe-edged sword " but beV\,efi,ts fC! v outweLg vied t vie
-ves
o "CjLobC!L ecol/\,OVvt!j i,s bLg oceciV'v !j OU WV'vV'vOt esccrpe fro ~"
Cl
~ swecAeV'v.§ c;evv-vtC!V'vr) beV'vefi,tted bcz of steps LIi\, s}zi,LL dev,
wviLLe L{f<'.. § llS, V\,egLected t viLs . ·
MllrxLst ci,{Hcis.viA
J?rof Deepe!R NCl1;1kJClr-s-r lt Ls ul/\,ci~v str-ess wLth ~ts t-t PSl' l/\,t
~ ~svunt~d Ez f utuve u111vcevtC1LV'c ..,.,,,,,,
• pg,M-;uPLbUlt ~ -{clt:eicR f voVvt &1 [[ sLcl e§}- Worlcl cloesVv't
seeV1As so fLllt 1/\,0\;IJ,- Opa vllllSVIA r-f "el/\,cl of f'llS..IC.Q1 ., ~s i,{!,d~r
C~ll 1TeV\,C1e ''Mil f~f" b'~,f.r .
~ d.e -o Lobo LL/llhovt s :-w 1/\,Cl L 1/\, LI/\, WTO, R.Lse o vf t,,,t
B>RE X IT/ ¢VvtevLW frvst, Tvellt !d wftk11i.rgw,c;iLs P n ~ ;YTV1 ., -fh..J,·- Gi1b i,
~
,.~
~ r_,l,{ , ,r ft- .Jr V' 1~ 1,G\,V\J.. L;;",'-- "":lt2l :.. ~
e~
s~,~"~)
occup!j wc;iLL street VlAOV, Protests c;i ll LV\-St
W,5.F> WTO ( IV\, SellttLe ) Cj-20 ( s
/~u~ TeV\-Cil S, • B>ovciev coV\,t s
wovLci • +,Cj ~owt?t, , o Cl L,() V\,Cl Lshc V\,hVlAe V\,ts .
";~~~"~'. --.\lfil\fof
.......... .··--. ... ' ..-.._
~-.. '
....... ..·- ..
. ..........
-~:~:;~~~~::=~~:~- .
.. ... . . . 4 • .. .. • ... • • • :
Futu ~e Pros:pects.
.,
TenorLSVvl
.
~I:'" s tl,jlltz
LV\, LVL,.St O
f Cj .<;
<,;1 ~. """'1i:)-- A,cictvess t>emocvotic t>efcoit
.
0.0Vvle.shc.
r L
tn?V\..SltWV'v to $ owe'( C/\Y'O'.-V
' , ., i t ' * ''..S ·7:·ut-7{ ','-/ "'::{, a
I
_1 ' i ,... i
~J)ecl.
~ mt t o cl. ec L'LV\,e but L
,t viCls viClsteV\,eo! Lts v! ecLLV\,,e
fa te negt l1C)l1LV\,St ~9bg LLs1:1ti. DV\, VIC!:; S, LVIAVIAerLV\,~ , '.pt@ V'\.-o!e vi,t,LC
n~1QI' r1 fueL tp {1 \ e
' ,st\1"W~ ~to-~~
- Y~ - ~ ,1 · 'v _ j-t ~ ,
· 2 :L>r,11.glea i1 vcew wi<ve rfc<;tb obi~
O W vit cl. VL L Cl [
S, L.iJ;pLw CV)C!LV\,S row.p@ R.e-V'vCltLOV\-ClLLzC-JtLoV'v O roo!l,{chOV'v~ 1h,t~)
/ , d " n ,,-fI ri ·=
l,r:> v"~.vt
,.J e I ,,
V ,
' ,.J ,, L:;
t'.,e,.S.S \~/OVt.t/l • ,.J
V_V'vJ , • •
~ } .s er t/ );,.,,(:; Cf lA. e.s:iQV:.,L!/i.,s -. ' 6CJT"'A'-
- " ___. ...
' :, , \; ~~ bl1V'v, ~cs bl1V'vVleC'i ex-pert of wcei?u:.iV'ves 1""™
0 H-avsl-1 v. PaV\,, covi.d-1~ wLLL streV'vgtvieV'v tvie OV'vCW LV\-CI Cl ~ tL-
Lobu LLs;C-Jti.oVl voLces
st ell\, M WCJLt "'Reali.st c;IA.i.~e to coroV\-CJVi.v1A.s ol,{tbreCJ~! -
~ r[sLs [s v[v[d revi.t[111,der o ce111,traLi.t state [111, IP + proves
IV'vtL co-op i.s fragi.Le § UV'vderL!:1[111,g a111,arcl-1t:1 of c;.c; [s
pe[V\,g exposed.
o Tvie receV'vt covici crisis i.s see/I\,, C-Js tvit'be9i.ll\,,ll\,,Lll\,,C\ of
ciegLobC!Li.zuti.o/1\,, u/1\,,d t vie cow.ebClc ~ of tvie stC-Jte . n ~ttW,
= ~-
~ (~ '/~V'c _',t1JtvvtC-?v~ v ~S, Cl "Be/1\,,CI but WQ/1\,,'t brecdz cdS, ~S, "
fov CALobo.Li.zc:rtLcV\,.
5Vl !/!l'M. Sm'!/!11\,, i[>VLd VIACllj nuve s;tuLLed S LbL but ~t Ls vieruo
£!Cl1z1- ;:\ so PCl/1\,,deVvt.Lc vit:is tvLggeved c;c:iLLop L/1\,,g c;Lb ~II\,, ili@4:t:1 L
;;;011\,,Q VI.Ad1.
o/ Ricvicwd foV\,ta[V\,e- c.ovLd-19 wLLL accelerate 11\,,0t Lts /i\ eV¾ L.se
vatviev tvie W~.eLkJ resuLt wLLL be ~. 11\,,ew, dLH ere/1\,,t § w.ove __
, L
·\:' .j~~:t~~:~:o:~;,;
..... . . . ..... - ..
............
-- r ..•. -
.,..., ., ... . .
·; :.: :~:~
~ S uiw:ivcc He,Jer}-wfiile it will be impossible for co ~ tc .........
,. . ... .
...
.-~...,,
cut t t,,eV¾.s.eLve.s. off froV¾ c;Lo bGJL V¾GI YR.et el/\.,hrel , But Ye0\LOV\.,9.L
LtLGltLve.s. WLLL COV¾ t "GoL~L oc .s. o tt.ol/\., Ml .'.iiL 9.'::v1
b~\\' _c; Lobci Li,.s.citi.oV\, ::i H t JPeY-V\,Glti.oV\,GJLi..s.~
° Furtl,ier,poli.hci..s.e V¾i.grnti.oV\,, eV\,trel/\.,ct,, bi.GJ.s.1/\.,es.s. towGJrci.s. .s.eL[-
reli.ciV\,Ce § IV\,WGJrc( Loofzi.V\,g ecol/\.,oV¾t) ~ OGi~-New erGJ o-fi
E,on-o~ i,c .s.eLf- reLi.ciV\,ce viGJ.s. beguV\, '
.s.~b.s.ti.tl,{ti,Ql/\.,'~ Glrj cigcii.1/\., gcii.1/\., cuneV'vCJ,-; CE, 7-~(~ • .s. ~1
P' .,.+0 1
•'-
r
v1 .t,::,
"+
•
e , -F , , ,
0\1 v~e PV\_,:.,t "V1 ce nV\., 1'vO, ri V\, r , ,.,,..,_.,,.., I ,pr ;,pr "1/1';; " {; ,') (
rJ
,._, l... v :.,,, v r _, 1.,v~ ..::>v1,.~~1.,,1.,,_,..::, v,._......, 1,.... - ...,, _,~...,/ •
. __p ss?vi.Lt. B,l,{t tvie fo vviA Lvt 11-1vi i.cvi Lt v1ci.0vit eV'.d.l,{ve wLLL v ~~ ..1.. L~ ~_;
w; to tv1~vdz v1Aove e,vrnt~veLrj ,
o~ ~"tVI. post covid wo,-Ld. w, "' ,c1 o "-M teV1Aplote c_r c,,l
bCl.sed. o ciLvV\,e.s..s., ecil,{C!LLt viuVv\.ClV\.,ct1.,," - Tvil,{s !/\,eectevi ci
Move t,V\,cll,{.s,i,ve Cj LbL wLtn H UVv\.Cll/\.,e f C!ce" r - - - - - - -
-
~ osepvi sHgLLtz-- Re ovVvl 1V\,.s.t o Ci-Ci § gLobciL fi.V\,ciV\,uciL ~A.s+::
Wze WB, IMF + Gl(;{cfre.s..s. DeVvlocvo.ti.c De-hcLt
Fe~tures of c;Lobt:1LLzt:1Hol/\,
• CoV¾-plex -pvoces.s.-- CveGJtes. coV\,Gii.hoV\,.s. fovV¾ore e,o-o-p worlcl bl,{t GI
ClLs.o Cl VvtCljov s.ouvce of IV\,S.tClbi.LLttJ, i.V\,equGJLLti.e.s. § Col/\.,fli,ct
P 5Vvtevgen-ce of c;LobGJLi.s.Vvt-- collecti.ve ciwClreV\,e.s..s. or coV\,e,Lou.sV\,e.s..s. of
tvie wovlcC c;LobCl Li.s.eGi wGJ of LLfe.., 1
<wer
<, Pol i.hwL c;iutviori.tt1 111,ow i,s:, 111,ot tvie s:,oLe pres:,evve of
stcite bu i.s dLffus:,ed GlV1Ao111,g di.vers:,e Actors:,, Nt w::ieV\,ci.es,
NyOs, suprc;i s:,tc;ite bodLes:, 1
1
sovereLgV\,Ltt1 i.s 111,ow s:,vic;ired GlV1Ao111,g 111,c;iho111,1AL, regi.oV\,c;iL §
yLobiAL ciutviori.ti.es:, .
L;i;iJ, s,t-J Q'
Vf-ZV' . -~ •15'ClJ,jLi.s .§ SV1A[t@- A sviL~ froVlA stc;ite ceV\,tvi.c yeopoLLti.cs to eieo-
e,,-i~ ceV\,tvi.c y Lob c;i l oLi.ti.cs
of
• , mergeV\,ce "Post westp vi e1LLa111, worLvi order'-- s overei.gV\, po1.•,1 er..,§
"CJ>~ A utviori.t!j of stc;ite i.s trc;iV\,sforV1A.ed but Not eroded_
o -Cw c;eo-poLLHe,.s"- L.s eVvter L111, erci -o c; LbL--rt re.st.s Le.s.s 0111,
V¾LLLtClryj ·power§ Vvtore 0111, .so~ power ,
o "WL-V\,Le.s.s wLtvidrciwuL· of us froVvt 1rciq § Afgvici111, v evLde111,ce
tvicit .su-pevior~t!::1 i,111, v1ALLLtcirr1 -power ·L.s 111,0 Lo111,gev cibLe to vecicvi
de.sLred -poLLtLcciL outcoV¾e.s L-V\, vLoLeV\,t co111,flLct·-- us .sltld LeC1v111,
tvicit de-peV\,dLV\,g OV\, ·oLd c;eo-poLLtLc.s" wLLL bvi,111,g 0111,L!:1
§ defecit'
Role of tYClV\,$V\,CltLoV\,ClL Cl~toy5,
I11\,tyo~ ucHo IA,
v"
~ SA s vicivLV\,g opev-cihoV\,s be r1 0V\,d bov-de~ - r,,i ~,/Cs, Tos
~ oV\,veV\,HoV\,ciL rr-stcite ctv\-tv-Lc ~ut f orces of c;LbLtv-ciV\,sf or111Aed
-~ ) 1,tto "socLetyJ ceV\,trLc wov-Ld ", expLciLV\,ed blj -
:t~ Lbev-ciLs see tvieLr +ve role LV\, bv-LV\,g LV\,g Dev.
:r-"McirxLsts § fe111ALVl,Lsts Look, cit MNCs cis expLoLtev-s. ,
....,,,,,.,,
Role of MN Gs .
Mqjov- c{rLvev- of g Lob ci L ecoV\,0111ALc LV\,teg v-ciHoV\,
ReciLLsts c{ o v\-Ot v-ecog tvieLv- rn Le but LLbev-ciLs cipprecLci t e tvieLr rn Le
LV\, Dev
c;rci 111ASCLC! Vl, scvi ooL recogt vi eLrtvi eLv- rn Le GV\, soft powev- creciHo V\,
_§Mfg Wv\-Se V\,t t,V\, fci vour of c;Lobci L ccipLtci LLst Srjste111A
Mci r-x i,sts tr-cice t vidr role sLV\,ce 1-J-t vi ceV\, (5 10 ) + crLHcLze
MNCs As LV\,struV1AeV\,t of expLoLtciHoV\, cis tvi e!j perpetucites-
0
I:ep eV\,c{eV\,e,L,t t vi eov ,d
N eo L , w, tJ ~011\,Sl, ev MNC.s CIS L,V\,Stn{VIA.eV\,tS of
C,Q 011\,t,CJ LL-SvU,
0
W ST btJ W ciLLevsteLV\,
RoLe of NC.OS
ser;1 ollvl "BrowV\, (1sooR-"New Forces, oLd. Forces,,§ f l,{_tl,{_re of
World PoLLtLcs")-Nc;os viC1ve becoVv\.e "crl,{_cLCIL pC1 rttfLp etV\.,ts L-11\,
/11\,tL p oLLe,yj p rocess".
MC! rx L.st.s -evel/\, tvieLv- vole Ls 11\,0t V\.,ew . ALol/\,g wLt1'1 sic cetVv\.e
cvivL.stLC!V\, VvtL.s.sLoV\,ClYLes to bl,{_LLc{ so~-powev. Nc;os § MNCs
worR LV\, e,Lo.se V\,exu.s. MN Cs CVICll/\,1/\,eLLze CSR fl,{_1/\,c{ to tlt1es.e
rl:fl:) l_f wgtVI eLr role ilS co vcs 1A.LtiltLve 10 ocl Les ilttil Vlecl to
5COSOC.
LLRe MN c.s eveV\, tvie Cl V\,V\,UCI L budget of soVvte of N c;os Ls
VvlCIV\,LJ tLVvle bLgger tV1Cll/\, yDP of VvtCIV\,LJ SVvtCILLer cov<.1/\,trLes .
eiLobc;iLLzc;itLoV\,-tvieLr roLe becoVvte Vvtore sLg- 1--tRS C1c{vocC1e,}}
c:;eV\,der § 5V\,v cie,tLvL.st.s
ALoV\,g wLtvi M NC.s, Nc:;o.s vicive beeV\, ciccuse(i{ of citteVvt-ptL~ g
r~gLVVl.,e cvici V\, e. ReceV\,tL Russ Lei viCls ousted vtSAID r oVvt Lts
ter r Ltor ti .
He~ G)
(, . J".tu,, ~ K..,_b'::'.":, _ e
• Ll ~ ~~ ~ h ct ~~ ~
~e b ~ ~ c..,~C4l_ f;i C\_
~~ cv. 1~ ,J Mp 0
1 ~ ]V\.1,0 ~ ~uJ .
tt ~ ~~ ~
r fZ.obe.?\.f- ~ ~
-
-::?" b. ~
Re:.~e.rvl.,(.~ ~ ~ ~ - n1'Yt ~ ..--\ cc"Yl/4e,,J
j~ i..{ u\ -{\ \: ~ ~,
\,1 w
i-~ ~ M~h"k~ .
~ ~d o~ it-C-.~ ~]
-1t- IA : uJ·v1 ,,_ u 1 r, ~ .-u+ l; ,,J -1 _ l1 &~ eMrP:
dn;.trL~ ·:th! 'nvlu W"~l e
\N11 I
~ ~ 'vv1U g:% -f-- go..s--..q JuU-Nh1 , 51-.,__ l.,,,'L,' 1='1
I
.L·I · E-o
~ +z, ~
tp__., ~~ - e ~~
~ <.vi L' I · E.. 0
A Sk Gil , rt
L- r · O
.vi ~f re. -n~~ "
1-r
~j;o~ --<---d 0-0.le f ~~
0..-~
·
0- H~ /
&,, l~6cJ p--rt,·~ -Lf Y\ ~ .
l
R.t> ~l>\..t Gui p u, - '' A-11 '1''-"' ~ ..l1b.vv,J ~
~ ~~ -t0 ~~~ 1-- A.
©~ Ku tw ~ °b ~ :'1:·~
Ci) ~ft<')-t_e ~ + pL1..1,-v1,-(,, ~le- b'Yi:.A../~ .
@ ~ 'Vr-1.-VU' &·r'\.,H . l!Yd.ui_ ½ U1.z9-. ~7 jY'-H .
1-,....,~~ ~~~~~~
~
~
r
~ e..~ se * u-{d
~
WCV\. \.e...d ¾ --H--...,
~ 1 Vh.; M~ w ~ (fycUA , ~ ts
V~A M ~ ~~ f UWVL.
tvol~ ~ VS '1~
°b u.s He...,~ -
_:)°'4-f N~ 1;,~ -. So N <.w 01--l...s ;_,,
.),{1 c,, f-t \,~ ,e .
"1,,_n..~ ( f l - . ~ '.-1 N ~) '-' 6-e.., ·
• ~\A..½u A Uhl;; V) (\,b lt ~ +u ru..1-1,-, .k
WC1Yl_J 'y -+k.Ac,; ~ --SJ~ ~ e.o,. .
i
A! u~w~ ~ -fl> ~ J vK~ ,
C,~ ~ NA T O ~ I~ ~~ Ev -+
w,u ~~ • ~~ ~ --
/' 1
So , s~ ½ w~ f-n--~ -ti
DJ-\ n ~ Uu;y, €..9. ( V I<-~ t. U't f ~ )
L
it1 ~~~ ~ Nevvo-J ~ -
.S~bM tryv-f ..t) v, ~ u,. .
s~~ 4 ·~~ +n ~
M..z d-.- ~ -t So ~ - ~ ~
~~, ~
11 ~
'-- t fYD - ~~ (7 \, \,~ ui
( .
: ""fh'Lh~ ~w h r k,vi'_~t ~~
~ ~ n,(~ o-, ()J\_ f ,~1'\* ~~4-~ f>'\,1
b d ~C\.g~ ( Ml!-¾1 ·
'1e ~ - < -~ ,,... ur-nto ,~/ { - H"-t
rR 1
,·n C\.vh ~ :\ l t.l c. J h L·to.. ~ (. c l, , k, u, 11 ·h .rCj
~ 'l tt ) l \ ') \J, L~[ · Ii q \,~ ) Ll
~ __:___i · ~ .tl,
( p~~~~ ~ o h ~SI~
~ 1d.uu I {.d ,h, l.,an1",L-') m b d- ·}
~ ~~ ac., ,z. ~ a
~ 0-V,' Lf- ~ 4 ~t-i.~ "'o N f) n
, TA--t>l ~ hi( '.,s L'-U ~ d,, I
-h,.,e
w -lu ,~ ~
YIU v\. UV\J-1..,
UTY )
~
~
'
CAr'n ~ N.u ...A _ ~ ~ "'-1'1. (
~ TV\J\.JI. ~ wt-w u rn .~ T~
""'l \ t..o vt, rr,r l ~ ~~ "l ""-'-v-\. l<..-vi d ~
~ ~ tJ DUA~ _ '11ne ~~~~
\M \ t lA' r\ )'v.;rl ~, ..q~
, ~~ L '-u
~w~ . ~ t½..t ~d. .
4 lN1
~ ~I
.~ = ~:J '½ I~ t . . ~, , - ~ G) ~ ~ ~
°"1,, ~~ ~ ~ -
~ L~
lh--c.~ ~
GU 'A su,_ "~~ -Lk LL'
~
1•
~ M ·, N Ov\,(__,h' c..
De..v e..~ u ~ b- 1l i'h ~ 1 ~ p- ktb-, ~ ~ ~ ~ --h
~tt---1--e "
~ - \:iu.;1 d " Po-lCl-A-
o ~~ lAM ~ ..k'.L\<. ~ :.
1\/\G\.LA..<,(_q_ c1.i1 ~
"1j l.P8.. l
' ~ ~u ~k(_~ ~ $ LO (. b;t
~~ N0vvoJ ~l\.,U ~ t-
Lh..o lu fh-1.n.l-f .
~
:It u~ h ~ E ~~ .:=...._l~LV\.C ~ C\.(
rll .) ~I
© (»J~ ~V
L~
-±I- y, "''"'N
•✓
UA ...vvl.J ,;,.,__ ~ C~/ ')j 'n !A j LN.l>i e. V ( IVI lt'l A {,..~:._,,
- k \;-.. ~ '\ ~K
c, ""Re.rU.J-4i ' l,~ ~ "1 cJv .{\ l LG_ ~ ' /2, fn ~
\.-! ()..\ IY\.C"A-•l ill C',J ( ...fVI \.n,; h.,':w, '
✓" .. .. ~ ~
L ("'Y) tr!2., ~ ~ t .>..l.t1 ':) u.t
I
o 'J e I ll - C..v-<--<...a1 Cl. 't
c..ri.- -L.-u,,.h1!\"--\ J
e
c.h1na. 0- .h ~t tk>J1lv\ .~ \J$ f-1 ~
( ' tUOJv\
fi Cl.vy< t_ k .:U . v, N Of a. C. IA.~
[ ~ c. . l LL ""- }:I ,
A vLJ... Vu,.__b,'l.Jl-i'U_, 1j ...,.~
O..,.j
.vs 0 C. C-Y\ +,. _V l~ +o k._'---v-f rD..re I/) v'f) J--V\. 0.. "' ~
~n ~
•
we ~ ~+- ~,g , t.._h.-u •
...::....v1._
.;._ , I A
...._ '-"'-
_
' j • ~ Y)'"\C). 'L~ l r o. n,.;· bI'r) +v...,.i -1-hR.·I
. , l •I)..__,
VTl
_-_ - , .
ov,;, v cv.. +-L(J.
t: :; f-v t -llAA.vi °'- h l/ 0 ~
_s ti:L,f--e_.
1
11 c- w ~ , S<'..h.c-lAM .QJIL-i
- ~oJN ~ W .W ,4 -\kt V.S ~ ~ ~ (
BoJ, ll'Y\ u A. O-
Sh•-o,J-vef7<. .. t , ~ VV\ l.o4 ;_. -.o --
e_&l,n~ .,l,' K.t - H ~ ' ~ v ,
~ ~~#
f nu l ~ L~ a.· LA UC. .fr t~ kd - 1+- M.l I~ ~ )rv. . ~b ,, ( {')-) t C\. u,•
~:t ~
o1. ~"'-'-~~
\ ~ t ~ a= Vs. H~~ I M -
1o t 6 . a-- ~ '1lT"b b-1 . '"Th½/ Y¼-g
3 V 1-1 -
~
/J'. th,. _~ e..u ,r~4'.:'.1:·-
e k.u
,t , ,
"'-') N oL I.....\/,V.....V\/~A
' T"/ u-<-t'"~
:I I~
Bv....t.1<.
t"l ~C \;, k~
, .,........iJ
P~ _, [ 3 ~ OJ"4 BtU 4 ~d ~
...liK-, - ~ , J°'--l>"'-
I "1 .
M --ttu.,t ~ u .s.-A ·
"e,.,_,.,.,. l c. hu -,.< .
{J 5 t-\ <2. ?<- p-{_m h. ~ v u..lV\ ~~ 1 , \--u..,\ °b
a:- r. e.i,1 k b -J.u,oJ - l'V\'l..t ?: ""'--'' d d,.{ i-,, Ex M L«I """"'-= t - . if ."""1 -·
'"'Tot:;:'" CT¼.
,e L H~,q / ?>
f-nw.M "" 3 >-; d" ' + w, ., i-v u-, .?u ti'~
.(p-lli "ii"".".'"1 <kvw. 1 , =,,,_
M MA11.N..J \.v\~ , ~ ~ .,
f VVl..,1\-el..i,J-- i.n !. r-o.- l.:,1' L!'f , •~ ·f" S~ +.,
w ~ ~ c. e.-1
@ ck0 "< 'vi I I "3:'.':: el d b'i-?
:: _:_i. b"" -' ~, , T "" :i -''-J' - , T.,._,, w "-"--' '·~ "'-At
-+ . ~ aA..
U
cvu ~• ' J ·
rR.,; U,,
~~ 1
...,,, ,,.
© f:'f;'w I
,t:;--.. • I . • ~ ~ ~ K VL
UlY \
l
(2..) ~. J,.,,., .,J..L , 1 ~C, ,
,-v- n L f:.. . '
•' "> fYV'M Ti \ t..e,- StvcLk-<l½: ~
fll.J\..~ ~- "
-T ~ ·• - R.u +ive l°'-"'cli -E: '/C t r, Ti4
0
• f l~
~v114lA
LI , .J · ~
JY\. vUj l ,
JN >
4 "-"'- .
lvU¼'i u LYJ Tt\.../ wtx..Y\, ~ - I~ .
@ Pvi LJ>-.f1to- ~ -. ~ ~. 11. & V A .D j 'r\.rl.,o • p<>--<...i {~ un ,v; ~
~ f- ·, ,\V i{V ~
CWGu"t o.b,V~;( 0
1 t 'IA I
11 ~ 1 ~ c.W¼
U.l?V\. :":::1.c:..
4"' ~ UY \~ ~, ~L~ 1
1A
~-t~~ r.
lY\T'rfl
~ '
tn ~ru:-..1 dli's; ~V vt- ,. ~~
VVll t--...~ ( p ( ~d ~
I h, t ,<,'"V1 d • I ') •
~ - - ~
lh Ll.J ..... r L\ ~ p~ '\.,;,.cl.. o ..,. G) '' ~ pu~ ,.,;r Wll. \ o~ "-'-••\1- ~B o(" - ~ ' J CG ~,
--{C~ A Cl - ~ ( ~ ~o... ria.. . ' .1 rr-t k
4:~ cl....v-. l ~ 0; b c "'Io.. I rrrrt~~ .: ~
A\ t..La, • ~
- d"-L~
@P-.._e spr""-'~ +
'!\,,I A ( .lo-" V2 l, b ,:"'1 t w ;{Y) ,
\'\..o~ ~ pu,.H 'l"'-H \"--1.,v...j
.C..c-beJ j~ +{ c..e . l\l~ o .;,.
j tt. ""~ • t--,v'"\,\-c'--~
1
\iev.u
/10- <- h,( ~!r. ~ll l v1 ~{
i:., ~w..i."'le>-~
1 ·t i ~ LOY~ d.e. ~ J .... .-/'
' ~ K(. ~
(' , •O •~\., '•'-' 1
v . tJ, h.., "
_ p, G:l,'(
~o du l "-.."\,L ~ V "' \
1
L
WN-.t- IV\A lr v. x\ \- t.- \~ ~\ (A
Cl) ~eA-<lJ' Q_~ TC\Jvu_l..,,,,. ' ~ l_f--- ,.vJ
- G:) DQ.-\J
~ h O'Yl ~ ✓ /2 ~ f>c2 2y ,,& ,~ v,)·~ ~ "'-1' LI
• +l) ~·
~~ -fN w-oYY
t.J.V \J\L .,'\,( _~ -n! 1-«.in
~
~\{ v -h~
~ -uJ
~t -tu n~ · -"Thli:1:J.'JM T:::£
G) UJ\Ay\_ -
~ ~u ~ ~~~A-Ur~ ~ ~ ~
f,, ...-.--- ~ ~
t.9-Lua fr,- "L" d O~H
WCV\. j l . VJ A ·
w-r,fe,.,,.LAl<.. (1--<> I ~) •1 ~- tv ,d ~ wCV\_
<.
-n, ".,
~
o . . . ~ - T -- r4 frt,c.-• +u -4-r ~ ~ ~
~
~, ~ '4
~ Y\ ~e.. e...t-c.. -
~ ~ \A
~ ~
,K s oi--l- F ~ t :r ~ oY j ~ ~~ ~
~ ~7 ~
c:y ~ 'j' {} - ~ .JP ~ fb \,JC¾
--h, Jtn A o (;of(.. • ~ f t , ~ ,- th .t . ~~
u y ~a
,h ~ / VS' ~ ~o La--~r ~
~ t' tL h ~ v-s - ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
.-OJ -tw ~~ hA M ~ T~
~ 1•_ ·
·· ~V 'f. _~ ,(_ _ ~
~ ,0 Y- tM
;.,u uq v ~, ~ ~
u - ~
I>-.~ ~
°i~ '
ex ~r A,i (3 V ( :
.
.,_ lo "'r<½~ No -.. fl~1~ /" Jl,
~~
,' ad. L, ,-- '
~
~ - ~ &h,,t.~
~ - ~ ~ .U- lJ ~'"° ..A.¥) ~1 -,14,< i ~ t-w-,u
n --
,
a
~ ~~- ..-- ' - ' t , ~ 1- ~~ tn \-- .rr ~
Yjf X\I) r-i:d - . _ Th ~
U'YtL-h'w Bc:tUl ~
ts Y\.C ~J -'" ~
U..S ~tt u} ,M Rn ...t - CM ~ l.JJ cl i~ T~
fht.}-- J,~ ~
~ ~~ ~ ~ s u..-lc..tA
~~~ M ~ ~ O'Y\ e_'.
.lA_~ ,~
Eciwo..hd LtAMwa.k ( Bo (, ~ - T11e R.i ~Q
~ 0-A ~ -~ ~ -
( ~ w.,. . c._ -~ V JA
'
C>.. ~ u.1 ±t, U \"; jtc_ P~ c o~'" l t ic:..t )
~ N1A i teno../ g-UMN~ S~~
a,.,_c( N~ ~
~ ~·~ fr,, l Gie..t) .e c_m,~ (''. ~ ~
V~ A, ~ f 't
t,i
~- -
l o-)'\
~
• :r * ~p~
• tl v,L,~
1 wMd l ~t t -r~ ]
3 ~ -'"" " ~
• fu.v ~ b\(
G !(( ~~ ~
C>.
~u ~ _[e.te-n~H-~
ryv'J
-~M ,
N t\ .~ Y f'I \. .,
£Mt-~
l
d.,·f+-w.U- -h J, vJ L . bi t;, } " - ' ~
~- T~
-
S-1\ , l·°' .
o~ ~~ -tu ~ tWl-.l,l.Lv,._~
\.K II ~~
- ~' Ye v\ J~ P.,t.voh,. ~
_t,.. rn U tt:Jq) NA TO cw ~u,
t.~ ~ r:t
GJ1~hld ~n t.r ,
~ 'u .M J+ ,'-- ~P
;~ ;_ ;~
+ Lr) dJ ~ kd N W.s ~ J - Af-1-Vt T-:rv..~ ~-
-~ fu J""L P OI\ · '..& W1
0~ ~ e. ~
1-.1 ,K N ~ -h t i.-.~.Y7
~
\JJ kl
k~ ~ ~ - -p0v<., R<- __, A:l c
o...·¾:f
, GI..L {l. ~ w ' \ ~ ~s-h' ~ k ~
j ~tL- ~ 017 f,-~ -to U fw'nf Nw s .
tJ •f<. ~
7< 0 L .. ~
~ ·....
(i:\
O~ Vt MO\'.! r' 4 ~ 1_.-:~:_=
~ ~
I. :... ..__J V .S
.:::.::.--4-- ® T"YV-N'-f •~
. ... ,.~ •••
FP - ~d M i'S h o<-lu_,·, ;:½
~
\-it.~ V'"'l M ha d-<ix f ':½½ ·
~
Cl) c,,\f\) ·T I 1-m.'1 Wt Vt
~
d9Jv\.A_ ~ V
~ d ~- ~ I\A P ~0, ,1
11
~C"\A.1/1 {~ c/
§ 1-- ~ .- - rwcUue.Mt · Nf
'1-,v<,ta_l,i.L½ vi
-th e tk~,_:f~ lZn e..ll p-v Irr._~ I t,;v 1 v..,c,l-v_ f ,
-:tt-~ ~
¾:f v.f'''::?:~<
~:, - ~
f:\-,,,1.d " c:i~ I-
) ~J<-
V:S A
' ~ ± .q-o...,u/,
iu •= ::¼f:-..._/Jiij
~
" ;i u \I\J . J) ~
'lf-e.~ -t-h.<
-
l "-"" -i1~
hr,~
1 V<
15-nrJ.! p r ~
H t_~
~ti'\e_ {-iry- \/1 61 ~ ~ ~ e _.
o if)'\,(.Jv..,r A UJ\':o - m"" , T--nLM ~ P.p
~~ 0-ba.¼.~
.@ D ~ €. 1 Ke~ d ~revvkc/ wi i, -tu tr :'.4 +{~
..l) ~ L.-1
LI E o,
~M' ~ ~ /-
v\ ~ V v \ WO vt , ~ J ~ e DU L.. ·
~ rk l~ i> -J :r:::: !1 ¼~ 11 ~" '-- ~t i•
L< n-0 .~y y,
:., ~
0 ~~~ Llh P:½::~ OJ_+,"' r,w, J~ --l' ---- \.N 11 Cl
--1 ,-_ 'Zr cp o i\ •
D ~ 1 ~: b: k, { .
\) ~~~ °'b ~~ ~ LA r¼
0 Pu ~ 1 G, ~ 'l.c C,,oo..,l.;+-ury, :"
~~~ rt.Jh '-\A ~ ~r~
,
• t:'t'T"\VL'c )~ ~
1 r 13, ~ A , B , s. c. " \M U A .~ ;~
1l ~~ +w G ~ o 1;
1 C." lv\:.o.,t I
vi H .
H(f'W t.M- e,\ Cl.Gt. +o H~
~
'-A/ V ' - \ )
..IA V) ~'h"b!L,
0 v~ \~ J- ~~ ~ B ~¾- u ' " ~ .
\J \.m ~L f,'- c,~ ~.
J.,t..t'hm ~ A CU-U-p ~lnU½ 1 vJ \ ~ \ 4-~
~ R~~ ~ dv .~ be
l
l ~tA-t "- oH ... t~ - ~ r 1 . 1'~J >to· -h..,
~
~
•
~ ~
r" ~
~-( .,\A -(J ""' IV\)l)
U(
~ ~ rl4 ( -
•~ f ~ r1e_OJ1. +uh\./ ~~ "k w ~d '..J
~ ~ I I ~ ,\JW:f GL(,{' e.k... t; ~
--+N , w ~ '.1 j cLuv.!' .
a_.1-l-:i
~ b Iw Vs
s ~ " ~n..J A V
. ':-:W:f u .. h w ~ -~
.0--b±::?: w w
TI .
7't-ie ~ " "
w c:u ~
BUv-.C>J\_d ~
~ ~
~e..c4 'i1';i -
W a. .( ro~i.k.J
~
tT-r" !) o I 1-Ut ~
' <y~ .l
+ \J ~ H~ . Tb ~ Lr
E: O
~E"""' , ~ (:;\✓
f-- .A u-.p,h,..l
~ Im fV\AY\ ~
~ 1 wM S~
\.; I
',.! r~ "SO
(-Y....,,
~ ,
\- U-. ~ -t u' cu } rn,. ~
~ l.. c\ ..u \ h-
CT'Y\R ,., "
~~
,_) - N V, J U \ .· J
lh..fo IIVla:;:
1
.
l--uJ...t ~ -~ 1,.1;, p~ + -B v-t J,
1,, 1r y ..-! 11...H • " ~ W e- \\ - W M
w½1
1 '~\~ W G \.I \.' .
~ ~ r~
b
1- ~ ~-
" tJot- L cr -n ~
u .J
D~
Q) ~~
1-\J w Sl - s\-OJ1,, .An
'\ D ~ " '- U ~ AAt- 11
k.uJ "N
~ +t> • B
IYY1 ... A- ~
- ""''-It. l-l1 t-1 ti\. ll
1 ~ ~ q '3 'i ) A e
" w " N~ \Jv\'li... 1 ~ ¼ n ~ ~+ti ,- i w
& ll l\ l\ I ..t-,...,...t.;1
"1 6 S!::':-;J
" MAD '' ~ " b~ ~
) -
tru .} - 1
01 WW ~
~~
•
JJ,
~ ~~ s W ~ l ~ f> ~ ll " W ~
w il l~ 1
~ Wl-1 \. p, ~ 1: O f f > ~ °Ii
Gi ~ '\l:" ~ H¼ ,
.. w ~ 1 re.~ ··. b ~ +kt ~
l, :':
o.-i
:~~ u ss ~ .
t .w
'" ;; ?
~~
\ Lo-\ d +w-1- @
I •
Ir~ ~ ~~ ~ '( opt,\_~~
@ N~ ~ BOJLl>CVU>-i-1a..]
~ l
-l h t ~
~ e ~ ~°
'~~ ~ ~
~ "L ~
1- e n r~ + j~.
lAtb W <M . ~ ~-~ j
~ l
kl ,u' t.d ~ ""
-1
G) {l t w ~ ~ ~ owe.-w..,_' 1
'1_,t~ 0.>-i "~~ 8 l- 11 \J M ~ "' T°'-<-hu....l o
A U "I \.~ ~ J .. li ~
~~ ~ ~
~ ~~-~ ~ ~
~ o-fk< w w
(\ /\ ,u _ ~
'.u. .
l--1 ~ ~ ~-~ J,
~ ~ 1
U -{ ~ fl 1
(D D:½J
~ ~~ j.J- ~ ~ d ·b r
✓
kM ~ ~ - °'--~
II ~ O Jv v\ t~ U ~~
"
~...
~ 1Mi S o..-kw- ~
1
- I.) s n, o I- l,.\ ~
~ N\ 4i 1~
A ~ BIT't\,,.b
1K s fl
~ t , er , 1. > v~ , ~ t..k..
- ~ S-1-- -LI- i;, ~
wM a.
~ ~ ~~ f!)
~~ I
W OJLh.MQ
~F~ -
0. t, lM ,\ ,. ~ VJ W ~ k .J
~ u h :l .A Po t t ~ .
-h \Lu..t
~ V H t.. W.U..k
n, , p~ i . . 1, M,.:,.
@) vY l,v \.. , 1 "'ws .
O"\'\ 'J°:P °'-"'. _
~ ~ ~ Tb s. h-p v-s ~ l'L
,~rtA-~ , s\.-(L.~ ~ .T°'t~ -r T o a..,\.1--(.,\_ \-
,;__H
flu.,~,u hM :cl>«
J d 1-) ~
~
I
ty b t . . l .
..~
! ~°'-S!- ·
Jr...._~~ - C-w H·"-'\.k.A .,.;, I q tH ~1i-
• 7'Ji~W t-xf~ O....fur.,, 1 C•W
• PO'\AJ VI \/ ~
Wh-0 WM ~ ~ \-\~ ~ t..wi ..-0., u...n.~ ~ , ( .,-{
~ ~ "'-t+u d..,.,~u- 1 C, ~ ~ 1' '--(> "\Ni
(D T ~ •t"U1v, o..L1f-t - ~V~ ~ p_ w~
✓ ---- l.
R_ ~ • 1.1<· •~ o LP.A; ½f A ~~ cLr, h-; ln-Lh.m :1--
{p...pi ~ Vh\c.:I - - , J ~ · ~ t>-i'It."" "" ~ ·
~L .L..u'k,__"'-~ A-hw .,/ o~~ k < t.{4~
~ j
D
~~ ~,-, d ~ . ~ .~t.f>-e. h:t.~
fv4' ~ k ~cf:1 rY'Ljhn M -
fY\.,i ~ c. ~ I "'- ~ 1
_____~--
, I t; \
~~
(D - -~
f._e..v, .,.., v-J ~ ':~--!f"ll'M1b1<
- -\.-i-1 - 1JSA ..._ . ~d
~
~ l.u.., ~~ ry
,1.
I.AY-rvty\M ~ ~ .
• Att<'h..u 1 ~~6 _ L4t "'f¼ ~ io . .,... No • ~~ l~ w M -t,, ~ ro..~ k ~
• ~ "b 2,,"l d ~ r
J I ~jU-1\..tl ~~ ~ I . - Ut ~
- ~,J
JJ:::.,_-t..l- o-4 ~ "'b c.~ .~ -
• ~KA_~ t,', 1-u-¼c, i,, l"i ' !>;J _- f ~ « J W"-1 .Lj- ""1 '.f cL,.,..t 't..s./ WA-0_
t.~·~·-,.u..1,,.n,t., TV-}'UW -n' tI I q 33 . ~ . I- I ~ l
l)i..f i N"'fi ""' J°::::f~ -
• ._/' l'-\ 18 . h !-v-v;(_~ . f .; h L -~_ i,__I\J ·, d -u- L* ~u.t d.v.:,~u.,"",
.. ~
t, ~f,::½;1.- l:n...., l.. ~ f v"v\., ~'N. Id..<..~ ~I
,,t ~ ~ ~~ _L~ , - - -
.,tt ·
• s ~ ·" po;½¼ l~ ~
h ~~ ].
0 T. ~ o .. n ck-c.-t:nnt. -
~~ 1 hv id
' M.o\-iV't.-1
A Pb--lih.ul ~ ~
-~
- - 7~
~ ~ D~ ~
~
~ -UY}'\A,
-
-::i:\: - r ~ '--~'s Cio.tLLu
- It ~k..f
• Fn- ~CTVV'-1.<. ~
'1 \N -(1 ),~
~ -P
~ .e .- x ~ l- n
V- -M ~ h cL ' l1-1..J-<
~ I L~ ...{ t.~ ~
' ..
1~ ~ 1- c.l1'\ h ~ d Cf ~
.f a - '~ - 1 o1
~~ L i. t ~ .
riM.m1 ~ ~ 1 ,t , ~ 1)-,~~ @ l11 I~ n.crs L - -
~~ i ~~(_ ~
j ~"- 3 ~e/2 - ~ ...... M ct»...u:, ~
L
~ ·
Q)~ ~~ll_ ~e _J ~
I
p-::;oM:' ~ ~
~
lrJ~
~l. \.., v-( ~ "c:.e, f-o
t:rr:::±-•
--. ~ ½ t ~
A p~G\;W ~
i ~ o .. .. ~ Do c.. k,. -,~
.- l N~ ~~:j 1
~ ~tlu1 ~ ·
k- M • {' p
.., ..:,, r .
9
-r- --4-~- -y€ _ ,) ~ ~
r . . . ,. . ., .
t B 'Y'€.,."l.,.-1"'1/4A
J>O L ~,i 1:_)
~
~
~
fo r ~ cl- d w- nk M - , ___........--,
• t,c ,,v \.~
h.u'f kl-, ~ 1-"J-l., 1, urr,-,•••u..v,..rV\,.!
~ ~ th -t -~
t ~ L I,, ~~ av< ,,,.
r .
lJ>...,Y\.- '(..,(,<..-'>,C E€
.
°" U Y\ ~ L t ~
~ J'OV"\_h~ - ~u,I
J CAht--,-o.-i
t~ h ~~ 1, .; u. .\ ~
hn -) .
l, M l trw ~ h v Do ~ w
~ ~1~ °"1 " J,.
..:r~ ~~-
.tt ,
l½ -,-h.-wi ~ ~
•
~ 't. J ~ n . u -
L l~ -U ~ ~ 1 u,v,L.,
?~ ~ r 'b d ~ fV\..QA...1u t1i
~
-+ \K ! p._ ~~ ~ ~~ ~-~ '1, N~~~
....f i' J ~
t ~ ~I A. lf~
~~
I
~ PC>...l.\...l Kl -n f\t .J ~
[{~oo\<..- Th ( t h:1 ~ ~ ~
Fu °\ ::'.'::f''TiAJ
K...l,v _.,,,
~ ~ e\...,1,-- t5
- ~ ~~ ~ --z...'1..R. C -v .- v- ~
~ ~ f- -u , ~ V ½ f.. ~ ~~
M ..iul--M,::J ,~
~ ~ h ~ ~- ~ ~ / l . . ,k -J ~ +k {
~~ ~
jJ ~ ,_ °½ .I. ~h~
o-,.,\ E C: ,.,, \..~ I,\.,.;.,{~
4
.:,, w C). u rrl.,.'-Y -.
.Ai-, M ~ e~
~
rvu A. . \u.,1. L
\ul. h ~ ,k _ ~ o1__~
•i, J i t0 0 ~
~ L ~f-n-t\.-Uhv\.. ' ~
f l'l+t~ I M \dw h.C-:, *
iv..
"l 1-t
t.~
'1
W{
~
-
$-
H
...
•
•
..
•
•
-v
>-~
~
to- wv ~U-d
T l MLlL\/\..,,~ ,'
• ·2 ~· ~0..Wtd..4dd..l'ri \ ~
\<.hAA - N A--M L,J ll.
~ ~ ~ \ ~ .)-'\ ~ wc--M,
~ l9'h' l-- ~ ~ W\~v J- hi}<- ~- tc-M,u"I
~~ V -P~ - t'-1AM lt\U"\Uv}-<..r,iz1 a_ ~
M.o Y)~ P:::l.':, -tr\ t'\W 1:: d~ t bi.vJo.t,, ¼a\lL~
-~ ~ ~ lAA7¼l,d d.£v¼ ~t.J..l it- o~~
t~ ... ~
l'f~ - ~~ ~ 1~·~ a~
~ u t- \l\,C ~~ ~ O'y- ~
~ \ ' \ ~ 4- ~
c;oJT ~ ~ ec-~~~ ~ -
t Af ~ P~~ (~<-- ~ ~ 4
r
l!J1\ I ~~ - pct.t.f}t-<- ~~
w½J ~ ~~ "}- Nir l-f
9ltUhdh~1 C1n o~~ , ~ ~ / p y -
'
g~ 1 ~ ~ ~ h"'-j 1'~, '1 ~~
2 IN LLhPv,
i.,,v,, .
~ ~t to-/.J wcvi vltAJi 'rr7>~<.,
~
°'-1--\J
VLR - T1i ou
l\b s., p-o{,vi,b , hi> no 1, _,_, 1- "½,, ':::I
o ~ "1-- G3lo-b~ ~ - ~ le.:x
~-/-t~ _ : - J.o A~;, "'-'·'J
\,~ ~ fnv'Vv.S U--nr'\(Jt ~ ~ ,,.-:1.arl 1
~~
...,,
~e
-
N-A M
ru,+ b.c
0-
tu~,,_, .u,
l.c,-{d W<V\. ~C7'f¼~ - rw~-
-
u,_, 1 ti; 1 -uc,: .
~1
11-<-tt.d .
~ --h, ~ 1'-. du, ii J"a.,,.,/
.. r~ Ni ~jri.,ns ~- w,'f ~
:J-"'' .,,Sti-1 ~ (' ~~-.lfiY ~ t.n.-.•,..~
( .
~ ,L t" ~-i .
I,.
World Trade Organisation
Introduction
WTO along with Brettonwoods insts forms the "Architectonic
edifice" of LIEO.
It Deals with rules of trade b/w nations—to ensure smooth,
predictable & free flow of trade
Est in 1995, as a successor of GATT.
Evolution of WTO
1st Ministerial (1996- Singapore)-- Resulted in adoption of
"Singapore issues" (proposed by Devd countries)-- opposed by Devg
1. Trade facilitation
2. Govt procurement
3. Trade & investment
4. Competition policy
Hence Global civil society protests in Seattle that WTO Meeting couln't
took place.
4th Ministerial (2001- Doha)-- In Response of huge protests--
Devd realised that WTO shd address Developmental concerns-- So
1. Market access
2. Export subsidies
3. Domestic support
India's proposals
1. Change base price level to level that can take into A/C
inflation in Food items.
2. Keep public stockholding prog for food security in Green box
3. End the boxes & maintain one.
Achievements of WTO
Global Facilitation of Trade—By building binding rules, reducing barriers,
Resolving trade disputes, TFA
Improved Economic Growth—Since 1995, value of world trade has nearly
quadrupled
Increased Global Value Chains
Upliftment of Poor Countries
Global trade rules: Decisions in the WTO are typically taken by consensus among all
members and they are ratified by members’ parliaments. This leads to a more
prosperous, peaceful and accountable economic world.
Conclusion
India should actively lead the voice of 3rd world in WTO to est its
leadership + work with mid-size trading economies with a strong
interest in preserving openness
Evolv1tioi-i
O~jectives
• Est of jv1st, f t\ir t~v1itt\kile & exploitoitiovi-free view world ecoV1ovnic
order-To t\ddress poverf'-1 & vtV1der dev ivi G,lokioil sovttVJ
• Tvie"f svid vioive fv1II soverei0vif"f over its 11oitvtrnl resovtrces, ecoviovnic
oictivities & re0v1loitiovi of W\NCs operntiV10 witviivi tvieir territoY\f
• Critici2,e existiV10 l'&t S"fStevn ois kieivi0 "est oit oi tivne wvievi vnost of
Vev0 did viot exist ois iV1depevidevit stoites & it perpetvtoites Vevd oit tvie
cost of Vev0." (A.G, fro1V1k, Soiwiir Avnivi)
• Aivn~d _tp eV10 e~oviovnic ~9l0V1ioili_sm & q,epeV1deV1C"f tvirov10n, "eCQijovnic
· iV1depeV1device" .
)
~WI~ ,,, ' -h fUi ~ , Gev-vi-e..t'fh.hf
• l'rovnote tvieir iviterests ki"f N~I R..u-cv\/\Jw .
o IwiproViV10 ToT, '>1'k MN l_~ 1 t ft.n °<vU .A TuJ.,
o I Vev oissisto1V1ce to prowiote iV1dvtstrioili2,t\tiovi ivi Vev0 W-£# +D
o Spuit:ll tret-ittmewt·-- Eu1ifrttibl e &f,.rn· t r-tide dc:"-t1ls for Vev0 - viovi-
reciprocoil preferevices
o 1'rovnotiV10 5-5 Eco co-op for ttvieir collective oivttovioVYl"f & collective
self-relit\V1Ce.
(l i(,~ ¾~
• 'Restrnct «riw~ 'R«les of I\lltl t r tide &., I vit l ecoviomic system ivi ftivoi-1r Df
3 rd World co«\lltries (13y repltici\llt) 13ret t ovi Woods system)
61'-
4<:UJ ~'1"\o.-LYV tVtAlvitAtiovi of NIEO-- No si-1uess--
~v..
• \' -\"'\.J '-)J • I"stead frol'll 1ClBDs o"ward 'l?retto" woods fra!'llework
0 ~~"r.l was replaced l,,j wasVli"<:)to" Co"se"s~s & "eoli\?eralisl'll.
·. , ,r,V, \V- • NH:O's el'llpl-iasis o" ce"tral pla""i"';i &, stat&-orievrted
t '<lt-, reso1Arce tillocatiovi v,,ecviaviisrns wtis rejected, evevi tirnow1st
rf'- ' ~ OA ~ _,o/( '
tv-1- Socialist k:Jloc, i\11 favor of ecoviornic libertili2-titiovi.
Voes I vidi~'s rise ~s vn~jor VY161rket power vne61VJ tV1t,1t it is v10 loVJt3er
coviterned witvi Ni tO?
• lvlavi0e ivi IYP &world view witvi evid of wld wtir-> SA-P + L1'6t-->
evner0ed tis ~11cv ke-t eco1,1ow1\,/
• Gvtrrevitll.f--
o wtovivi0 closer to west + Ne0lectivi0 NAW\
o wtevnk:Jer of 'B'RICS- ctilled tis Neo-elites
o £xptivisiovi of ivivestv,,evit ivi 6f. Sovttvi
o overtill pictv1re-Ividia vitis tibt1~1dovied Vev0 coi-111tries
• 'Bvtt
o 5-5 co-op alwviys beevi IN1l_) tern1 t1l_)evidt1 of If-P
o I'BSA, IORA
o Ct1pt1city 'Bv1ildi~10
Africt1, C,W\LV, Cevitrvil Asiv1, Sovttvi Arnerica
• wvivit is re~vtired is vi view vivirrntive - tv,at Ividia sv,ares cornrnovi
iviterests vivid fev1tv1res witv, tvie 3rd world cov1vitries
• Avid it is ivi vi VYlvtCVl better positiovi to brivi0 abovtt covicrete cvitn10e.
Heje,n"-~ I
6Y --
-l.)\
Ub
'
Q} Fe.d~¼ [~~ A,,,d fl.o ~ ] -+kt ld~ 1- " ~~ ~ Wrri m u.ru t'( ' '<rV'ui_
B
~ Ir)'\ ~ t i t . ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ---. ri,:7 ~ B ~ ~
P. ~ <sPu, k..e. ~\~ . b - ½-r<!.f,\_cLP..J.rt e ~ r~-h..o-n 1 r~...e ~
\I
't..r I.M\.1., I~ .
1- s~v~ 'M " ~
W l\._\
Poo-l~ a --tJ~,
~ b-o½. £ ~ - E ~ 1-n~+-t..cr..i-h
I
~~~
~ ~ill~ ~¥} ~ 1 .scrvi•~ ~r~~ ~
~ E,4,-.J ""--~'1- ~ u ; f ~~~
~ IAMd M1~ - Boo-k -
'1J
I
' A w~ p~ ~~ J
© PKii-i u..,J ~'41~~
1.f- u ~ctkd !rY\ ~ ~ JJI<{ -
~~ ~ ?1'U,U " '1n, d ,, F~ fi> l I lT\A.L--1 ~
I
I
la U1 I~ l.:pI ~
~~ ~'$1.J- ~ ~ H, o-..~ ~ . ~~ - tvA-M .
l
lt-w - po-t~ ( tu-"lt~) ~ N ~ P"-¾...t 1-.~ . . . ; ~ J
1
11
u-c-p, Vi 1½-w
\J..-, 1/ ~ ~~ oJ -J 11 ~ k~e,1 "r ~ ;~~~ -
J.
~ \ . ( vV1'11 fcu-;1; 1-o...h Ut.u_~ i- 0 ~ - 3',J-<c1"-"J,...,_,_ Ne, d f,--,-
0 ~ ~
~·~ ( ~ ) . n ~ ~dA...p-e-vt~ Sfn.te +o t ~-d..it_fe
t~H - '~f'l1 .
' @ ~u'~~ L1,~~
@~ 1
9
" "½4,_f '" d., "'-<r c., 77 ' · +u
~ M ~ ,~
--
t,D.M..c( 0\.-\
~
~ 1:011-ieJ
To S~a+~
trY
_
e..i-v<vu.~ r~.~-ru½ ,· r~ °'-"'4 se.~LVL,}1./ .
@~ V\.O.. ~ ~ "'-i j-- 9'1 +vu--'-~'-+i crv, Liz o,J-~~~~
t~oJ. v~ t-1 -
.lt, ~ fn+ur Vo.!1,LU - -~ t
CL
Hl-~ ~ · - Nt, M
obru,+iw.J ~ S ~ t
.Qil'\ .U~ .
~~ INU..,~ 1r ~ .\,
ti A t t_e.,~~ ~~f~t.
e,;Ll,-n_O"'f\lU ~ ~crwiti . Lt~ ~n~ n--1 ' ' ~
'- ~
o J - M ~ u4"'
'5YI 4t"tr . . ~ . 11-i·3 M. ,, A ":lfnfW o.L-i.t ~ ' .
S · l) ~ .!.i l),_'7r1 PQk._'A di IUV\N\_Q p·V R. °'--0 l,o.-._Lu_c! .S4-A:& c o., ..,. c_~ c-\5' -
_:-~ .$ A-A---fZ t ..U Cl__pf-~ t Ck-J Lo -c:r ~ ~'--l::o/vl," "''¥ ,,.,,.,,J. ,'5::m ".
~ th Jn~~ w~Ld ~fvul ~~ 1~ 1'h-~ 5.J" "~
0-.! 1.1 N o1-- j"l d,.t) ~
.sA-A--R l. ~ a... " ~rvu..d l\,r,L l,kM ,, - B C l. 1-
t · ~ .A~ l\~~ u.
T~~ A ltmrU-,<.s\-i'nPf .
~ r"-1::A
J___ ,-~ -
}.l,i Rf ~'"re ia,A_v--_~ 1 ~ Nit- ~~ t>--J:-- S~c._ "F ~ IYl ~ ~1 1\-e.J: CTY\."-U~""M ,
It>-,·= i•~+; ~ . • : ~ ".SM\-lzc "-..J A " £ l<>w Q.oo-..l- t,
o j ~ th,,' OJ-i e_ 0-V'-t I D'l1 Cv\,J'l'YVY\,e ~ bl w tnc. rn_~ .vw ~.n) h..\ ~ r--c p ;h
A"tl / e, \.1 M 0·11--R k t (o-n Im\. ic_ 1t!'l te-'\ d~ pLl'1 dr "'-{.e,
"I tl'n'\. b--i'·e_ ,) /-c;\_·h.Lj •
Cr, O..U..hlV) Rl a, V1
o 1t M /4 ~ ~ ~ i--1 °"
(i\_~
~ ~~
(_+,,.,
!Z."-j'e,w, ~
-A"-'zr' - .it LI n, r
p-,,-½; bI< +. t ·~ -'> tvv-u-cL>v,J ,- s ~
li f ~
IN]'ti,
1,, ~
s-f_
< lh-i ""
~-fl-/
"-'-"n"""-'-'-'
I
f~<;l,(,~..,s H"-'\_~
~ - € _ ~ ~ "'r°'C_ Lrivi ~ttct ~~~
0
~ 1-'nu_ h-v-vyl ~~ J.-f- \,L-,-,' l l n o t- b (J 1
s., ~~ ~ ll..~ 1r
Q b1 e +o Lcr-d,.,' ~LH tc ~~ C.,,t' . cr 1 '
Sl\1\iZc ?
~ W u,_ -.-<:viv,cf 1 ¾,,,;, ':':;I:
~~ ..u-v,__f· ~ ~ n~ 9.>c1- -
© UN e_,'-~ ~ ~ d {=,YS t ,,
~ S· D ~ ~ - '' 4-clrJ~
~E'·/2 C'°v" • '"I V\.QJ ~.lo--cn. l J-i.J -'--00 d h.O 1\1 l\..t~e"Y)
I
1-\ e_ ~0,j +~"-I- 1V\.d.,L( Lev,' \- L(j'(\A. fd V jY\~ '..,s t1-1r - t,-v,l I ~ d ~H--. 1-
P(>._K -tu ~ +t~ h "'(,(_ r 1- J~ n-i Prn·tl.v\
stHrR c_ rz.. ~b-r~
b u.
d'"WQ k n in1 ~rv,A. .\ h A... b -~----t___dl.,{Tv\_"--r ~ k ~ o--f- l\.J-i 1n d-0, .- Ie.d M-o d~J
.X J y-t\.V\,,~ - ~~o_,f l o4"' """l°h N 1/...ii t.Ji 11\A./\.~ • 0
f- {(t_~°"'l_W¥M. "vl7 1 "'--~ b..( ~--H-,1'1.f
11 ~ ~ O\,t -_SfrfHZJ_ ~ 'o '- \Al)~ p0-{( • 7'1-uw , ..ct ·~ +~ ...Ive }<-c.. j-
~ ctv ~~ I ~ l ~ i ~,u ~l'r..-C, d✓i'( ~ t-€--! ~ K
~,Y \ ~ ~ ~ ~ °'- ~ ltrvvt..e.f t- 1-- ~ A-A-1Z c N\.,V\,l,l-,J P°"-1~,~V\..,
~ d »i J.ts ~ ~ oJ.M ..
~ r ~ ~"'-t UTI'\ H-",<:: f-- /
~ f\ ~ h'll.R - I\ g.+A-1\C ~ ' -~
M S . "°J"o...(~ Ao__.i:.d
'v"\_
'
dY\~
PM fvloc:u)
.,,,,,,.
~
14
H~ T"'-'O :?:fUA 9A---A--R,c."
~U,t_d Cl
l , I
~~ ~~~
0 :>~ l\_<--<J b ~ ,,i ~ht ,1
~~ ~ €..f t-1.thil,151~ r., :':'::1t:1➔ j
-
~J~ .
ll~t.MJ
...,....--
~ JJ4li~ h- No ~ .
~ V, f~ /.) °'1'1
~";! ul ~ 1. {;-, -l ' , \-ir t +,, ¼ 1,
~ ~ r\--11 -rh{_ ~ ~
~
cl.1 ~£- f':. ~ .
Sit4~tM,u i Bl M 5T Et
1s1"k-U.w ~ tn ~
p~~~1
Sl'Y\°'r'\A.h' s. p~ I( t ID.$ I\) ,.g"'o1 -tu vi•e..w
-+~+ ~\-1 \..v\fh-LV\ 1 nd ~ 1A crp+t.PY\. , ~he. M~ ~ D ;\ ~ ' + orN :.C11 ..ht rR .tt~ {
~ ~ ..l.h
V\"vto-n "r .Q. .,,t. .(fy \_~ u -of '. _,,,...... :toR. (~fl..1) .
✓ @ To ~~ ~~ \.Jh.-~LL-3 ~
~ ,fj ~ +-o /4 k_r -,,__+wn 1- h½ r At:t- ·
N e..i~ b ~ ~
~~c ~~
_ , ,., €.AM- M6, A s-s t.o-or 11 ~ 1-1 .
I ~f'\.~ ~O vf ht- -ik d, 3
-\~ v-o\- r l.b ~fl +o-w--v\.h)___~ few+
.fv\fvJ+i.~ :
V\'y t O"YJ 1c
~) .f..tL\J-\.'th-/
SA &i M-., '.
./2 Nc- -,V\ ...l) h PM /2
I' ~ ():, I fY\.~ rf: C. .£,5 'rt1-t..¼t.11 S /.tfr
R( ~
~ P:0i~ \,/ :b ~ 1-w .1n ¼A ~ p~ C9-..f CAn.VVA.J-iv-i' ry \M th (; I fvl ) Tt: C.
\1\0 l \
: t1<l{l'Y\.<>--Li ~ (. t e.Lp .9"'-l~ tt~ k 1rvi'-H, As£ A1\J ~
J..~
CE) ~. ~¼ vu, 1 ~ ~ s-,..,, t--,: eci ~ 5 4-4-1!, ( - { '-'"' f,, ll,w &,~ I.
.Do <..h--0, ~ J·
~ - - --
1'-n,~ ,8-yyj-- ~ U -----d
~ -- Gi lo~IM..i~ , , ..:......== ='
='==-==-
e~Uh~~pV\..\ ~\r-e •
~ ttWA+i:lNv.l ~Ii ~ b~ G ry .
~ H!Li>J \½-'-AU t.1>"' Sd-
0~ ~ .(Y) ~ n~ 1: FTA ~
N '--'.r? n ~k. d tn y , ~I- no~ ~tr (.crn,wdul
1. 0 ()
~ -h h~ .
--t--N ti0)<:_ - ~ t,~M .i~ ,.,¼LhY~ V\.--{.:.W.
~~ I✓ \.....,.~- --v--..a
- ../
'; o -• .. "f '<I ''.
"
Ch°'-U ~ ~ ME..Af\l
~ ~ ~-
(,) I..._~~ ~\n d"2 01 ~ .l1\l.t ~
H4, ~ ~ ~
@ ~~ ~~I-- ~ ~1, ~ -
\._~( 1 ~ ~ hi 'h~ i w~.
@) ~ ~ ~ -w J , ~
Af f A-N A ~ firvJVL
t,~
~ ~
~ -~ - - t k t
C.,~ ~ A-! t ,1-rJ ;_1 pC\..,1 ~
I
h ; ~~Ut ~~ ~~ ~+- -u ~ ~~
~·· ~~u.~
~e. .AJi ~ ~-1"' -<.A~ ~ - ~ :!> (>111 Uv! 1~f~
~~ '"-f ~ ~ '/ 3 1 .• T~ e .-! v, v u ~ .J;-b UiA.li s ~
!'><<#cl,,_,_, t"-,; L) i--..tu.., .
w~ ~ , '-q ' /. 1 ~b~ ~ • Eun ~ ~ T~~ u. c-p"'.
-' bo •/. 1 w ....W :., ~b p . A<Jv~ 'Q A--P H
D>-1:10
~
G) (,-m-vH:, -" D "'-' \- '.'.\ -1-k, ~ 6, J) p t
~ ~
-
F<c 0, 1'181 ,i,, -+, $1~ +, <n l'l,-1 -h $ ~,tr. ;, ½11"
- -. - ~- -n_ k_ ~~
.,_~
+-c:u
-_
~u ~~ ~ S'f-cLk f ~-~h~
o ~ ~ :} lrfEt
~n,~ ~ ~ ~ LY1 ~ - PlA.,~t-<
,·. ~ ~e.D.->v-tw I ~"--'v\iVt ~~ ~ ~ -lw
·n -tlX'n. -\·lv ur~•-n~ -k.~ tr\.\.(1.A_•I~ l•~
~ $ J. I Mlli..o, ~
-th~")\_~ I U-t.mo,C)...~ n--~
n,irre ~IC '
':lf ti " 1 , - ; \ ~ ~ ©1
bloc -. $ I r
~ . o i v u ~ _ vs ~br ~
bi u, 1q I , t, .f r,, b1 U, .,_,,,It·
U5 ~, ~ """-t.lt,, - ~ O..,,..,,J 'It - @ 6""< 1--t,J Me,,, l c,,,, f,u.,.., "< p<>t< +.
~ ~~
US A ·
~
("""'-<l ,
+ ~ flow 1 ~
j'>-,> -} -1-,,q; bi'< @ Job :.., Pr"-'h, "'f-3 . Sk/-,y .
3-<'od., .-< ~'<.w · 6) r '-f<Hh~ . Ubtw.,~ 1
UM 1 C _,q ~ 7 l'v"\i l K ~
~~ '.,,_)-i
u ,
@) v.) d.t .,~ ~t dL.fru_t-- W"'-k ~ .i © -+h t ~~
11'~ k.n t'.n _~
cr--n~ ~ 1
~ ~~ ~~~~ tn J, .
D oJ-ry S u.t, -v .
1-n .l.~ ~lu ~ hA-w ., s-'I•
tot,..,k.JI f niu~ ~ 1 ~
Lif~ OV u w~ ~ ~
L . u. N • ~
Q) P~ 1"M· rrr ~H - ~ l ? 11 f:.-) ~ ~W UJ ~ ~ 1...½..c ~ ,, ~ [N AfTA- C '1.
, •~'/ . ]
~~ Uil 't - Nt i- I~ 1 ,no o jb'°4 . } ~-" \.-t w,"11 ~ i !
llf\ 8~ ,,~ - ½ ~ ('
~ 1>u..t }CL~
1
1 f \f, ~.ooo
~ ~ p{ , @) lo...\,17'V\ ~~ -
nJ 1
4~ ~
1
Q 'i UVn.p~+>~1-&
~ v,J -~ -vi'-1
~
--hrv..~
i vs
~u -,¼
~ ,1e~ a. ~ ~ b ~k .L kJ ~
. ~ ~·h,"n,,,
~
~ - ,1 ~~ -+ Pe.No d ~
@ 'i vs ~f'7»'1
tvn i
~ ~w ~~ 1n1 · M3-1~ ~
+o Pf~ i'l..o .
\~. ~ 'v, ~ ~
{!) To b '
6v r ~ ~ ~t-M €--k , .
~ e~"'~~ ~ ~ ~ I
1-
~ ruf I~ U,,U 1 ve.-tu b:'j f - S- I \I) ~
HO~
f,o-5 l-
(' (j ( d
TY\O'ft
vw,V\
e.{~
VLO.. ' I.M-Uu
U f\1 L~ ~
d.) /2 ~ - k
f~ +he :U-UY\,{,tic:::':01 °k:: UN ; t ·5 . ~ d~ vvi ll t ; , ~ 1- s~ ,
,U, -F" ~ E.M1-- ~ 1-- ~~ '
R,,e_c h~" ~ -L~ c., civd-1 "\- l\..O" ~ 6Y) ~ ~ v\-- tn
PJvcioJ,l,.../ /2 f.Nl i 1-M,½
'1"n Wh-1'-~ VNSC ~ld ~k..e ~ HOY) !IV-<I\. • +up~.
{y ~ ~ L,_ ..,,.,,-
'- ~ lNJV. l '2--<:, 0 3 2 M_v\
J..,\ 11<\.R . .E
~ t\.l Vv~ o.. t Pow ~ hf~ ' +o - b1oI- a-n ~ yQ_ pu.J-a..--h' o-v, 4 uN
• u.Lbru" u.,Yls . ( , °' ('l-) .......- ~te.,h ~ l r-R A--e..d ~ v J
• S !TY)~ t- -VI V tt.,\,fo-.1 1r ~ j (\'I )1 ) t ~YJ b e. ./2-id ~0..~ e.c~ .J-~ ~ w~ d
..+b--j ~ ~., ( I q7 q ) e k v-- 1 ~ °'-+-e_J ~ H-€ ac M.. uY\. i c u 5 A
• "''~~Q'Y \ "'W'.10--:,' ~Y\ck - ~ tmc.lo ~ <Ak ,' i
-:9~ - ~ u-c.. • lJ N '.A "rdv. ~ Cf"Y"\
rvu Li 1--r:v/i u .5 A
w..NL./' I •
t
'J J I
.
-U, :;:::;-
s O' 10 ~ ¼ , , , ln,i 1,,.Jj . t.ovn N\,Q,c;,../ ~ r, M -R~Ld ry Ki • ,hn .. ~ ,
1/\Jcu ne..tdR.J. H
- lt.M..~ 1-ut ta.."' ~ ~~ ~
..lj., ~ 0
~ CL~ ~ l l ~ m ~ht!-< ~
I
~ ~
'h t'j ~ t ~ b,
~N~A 'Y'v~-+,_~ U9ql)
~ I
~-h.:tm ~ C\._lJ..~ ~
~ UMM.i-f'."\.."\..;eu, ~ 1·~~tcucre. { f1~l"IV 2oli rV'l f
~ , K2 I ~
.: '._'_.;
' .:,:
· -=,..~ _,Jo~
{l,
~H c..cr-m 1'.\.!¥HU'T') t'Y\ ;j n. h: l,\('{. \, \. h OY\ Cl_ I \d
j
A~ L; b~ G\
Ct.,{_,h_U'Y) ,
1) ,
±h.\.(__~~- 1) tW-to-~ "\-{_'-'\,r- [ J ~v\.,~
(~ 1--f i<{ avv r--~, . .tcc•,J.1/ ·rH~">-Ll ~ .
( ' -~ l
C)~h' ~~ ~~ u_~ t-y R.1-f ""' ~~I · ~ l ' f\ t>eo__c Q.h \.i ~ch~ t.lfTYl.-""t~
I I \\T'I)
~ de ''t 'l.hd n ' & 1,-,;., t LpI e ·b N..,,, ,. "P--"' Pn1 ~ l e"" ~G'tr.- -..---(_(~'( '-'C 4 .
~ k " ""l ~ ✓ & ~ i.
h.~ f:'L1..J- -/fvY lk_"-t("'"'-r ' ·t\J>' ~"-H. J e:., ,,,,,·1 A~
S rt'--rE ~'VV'£./\.L: JI\,'- "-1 •
I ~N O C,CVt_ ~c ~ .. ·h l~ ~ .f--u t ~ lr""'l""'v\. r
-~ t:r\.v
\.-\U'Ntw~ , ~O
Y'l'U...,'r ~'j d-{ r ·~ N ~ ~/(A. ~ l
C!\1 b..ct J-( ~ th. °'-r cd -- . y l '-d,
-
r
• ; --c\ h_ ', ~ \ t J-f1n, ~_.;bl•li' t1 -h, .,(j-J fc-<' r-½- C\.. i 'rt. V'. lJYi1-.. vi • ( Nn ( ('}1,1 !.r1 r'\')
"' n') \-,• l \- f·l --C, 1, l )
1
\,,f\.,;'t.. ~ ..,li Y\ 0 } fv,.I. - - ",.! 'I..'I •'Y-\..._.._ """'
M-1
~ ... -h n,)
· ~ , r)
J
I I --\ •'-~V1 t ~, ~ °' d - 6·\ \--.J
@ 9~ ~t U_ _+ i~ 1 MW'NV\ ~~ ®
~ uN..'
- ~o...M.l,l{ f V-N ~ ~
'
• '
~ nk , - _ _ ~ ~ l{) w fQ_"-0t_ A l-1 ~ •
_.lYt
d,..t,"
t u D1--1 ~ , '1 lj $3 , u N ~ " t , ?itt:L--L 4 ~
Pl °J ~ ~ . ~ { ~~ ~~ ~
M 1M rrt tU Pro h ~ K ,~- ~ ., -{_ k
_ _ _ ,_
-+ I
-t
dJ
h t4 _~ 0'{\
rt.Il l ~ c..t.Jim, -
1-\tVmYv.c.V) P--l' F < Cf: !)l\w
VN w~
U'\
__ , ko
_ , N'_ 1o f vN
- Hf F I
~ .s ,
WO'fl'IQ~
t k _ r ~ \-1
!U9~ )" Hf-~ .
°" ~
0~
~ ~ ..,,J M17'-nL--h'trvw
e
~ Um
N~'-'1~ ~·~~·
✓~ d b-c "r ""-Vl
A ~~~- VN G, A.,--, ~ V
~~ r·1oc,~
~ /!_
./4 , o..,; d
9 +i,.,,.
:-71~ ~r Lt~ Lctll/2
t101r- ;-, .ui~~~r H~~ .
~ Y\~
• M ~ ~es! ~~ _,,,. ~ .
. ~~ ~~ 1- ~~
• Cy-ru.J--t,. ~"' t-nvi ' D ~ .,,,./
~tn~ .
@T'Yl.l..!~ ~
Es~- h ~ -d~ ~v'h'\Jv\ {o
11 ~ ~'f11n\e.,j .
NM ..L.~ ~ t.n,.__~ ,
~ e_~ ~
N ~OY'I , ~
....
\r\lo..lf-2. L.trv'\.1\-i ~ °'-..~~ 1- P~4''{,,lf 'l
~~ ~
oti"-') M rv~
d ~., '14' ,Js,u "'Y':'.:::::J
~ trvv~ a'.-! U N ij.
~t ~ U ~ VvOk~
)~--L~--0 --' _ U
_N
__w..ov
_ 1
Q.Yvv ,¼~ +o ~
.
•
·. ~ , t - - SlV'\W o 1- \JN
it ±u::¥-!:LVA ~
1
•
YW
[A,, b,,
h ~ VJ"Y-Lj
~..01~~CUJ~Z tfn1- lo8-)
~t- U (] ~l ~~
~~ Vi ~ C1VI t = ~ 1dA...q ~ ½'.A
'' StO--H ~ ;MCl.-< o,_ ~ ~rH.cry ''.
0f"'¼.~~
r., ✓
P-<~ ~ '.
' ~ i J. Sk1 _ ~ "~ -h ~
I ~ ~~ M "'-<11- ,ru-µ- M kt..h""" ~
0\A..{--n·~ _C,~1rn k./- S~!--e ~ +vt ~ ~ 2-/ 1 Yd MAf\,r,!'f 'Ji lJ N ~ A_
+ ~ 1 P- r ~ No vt_h ~ bvv~
~ ~f-! ~l\ . ~ 1 11 s~ _ ~ f'n ,~ ~ ~
~~ ~ "' F ~~h~~ 1 ~h ~ ~~b~ k-~
~ .0~ ~ s~ / ~ _L,~ oJ--1-e.~ 2-- /3 ~ r ~'te.d + »i~ Ml
P-r ~t.M
~'t-R-k
1 H~
;h\A
tt~
w ·-th ~
O<_ l R_¼ ~
a. p~ e.-~
<:ttr"~ ~ ~~ 1-l- '1..1 qc:_~1
~~ ~ ti 1 ~ ~ (uN) h ~\~ ~ I G ~ ~\,{
~~ ~ f:'2 k-0-- -1-¼ ee.op!e. . ~ ~ ~ ~u ~
l {]) To ~~ Non ~ p-{A __,~
~ rz ,_ r ~~ ~
~ 1-- VN1 c..
iv'
'°'1 ~ ~h~~
~~ ~~~h\L.J . @) To 'l' ~\4 1- tLo 5 o c__ _v "
:J_ ~e~ u, VN ~
J ~~
-t
~
hV) M~
~ Rw ~ D ~ f ~ f',-0 a ~
-L-~ ~ ~ h,t l~ /.\A,v-o ~ ...
a-.)
t.,'V_"--f-~-cl'.
~ ~ e_, v"
~L~
WI
-~ .PtA .uKu ~
--i
/ ~ ~..,,,,..- IJ-N ~ ½c-,f- + '.t_f-r 0~ oY\ B-ro--h.t-;y ~n+ -
%-b,~I\{__J"\.U.. j -
~ 0
Ci )vw f\ .~
~ d ,U ,,\-")IJh j ~ h _IN.tl...A -41.V'{,') Lrr,t n;-v--,,._1 ,•...,,
• .11- lNi (I b~
T%H¥ :~ -tt,, R G\ e.o PyGJJ' W •y-,uJ.i-0..-:,t ~ ,,~ 1-n ~ 0-_,,{ 0\ M..R-]'11"
c~.
i:Jnt
~~"":t:?;TI
\,\J\I\J 11
8~
~ ~ h.¢+ Y$:P<l ™
4,_ P;yy~ u
~~
~~ MA
~•.Y\_,"-11\ <
LI')
~" d.0>
~
.1YJ ~-tiOVl."'--1
e.
h
i: cLl ~I ~
~ -fcvcf
-M
J
@4k utJ ~c "'=f11 ~ ~~ e~ ~~ N 1i ~ bR ~ ~r~ 1-" M rV\.vW:i ·
OW\
~ tw-::; <Av-\r't , ~
'
+, b, - ~ -~ , ~ ~ l~ V - 0..-~A
@ Ws ~c
•
' ~ -~
, E- LUve-p-l.. -L-1 · r
"v- G ~ ~HLliJ lry rJ C)·/-,.,
d-e-1,fl-~ /V\<,-V.- vrv
~ M ~ ~ ~"' ✓ ~h,oY\.l r Lfl J'Ov1..-l-h.. t ~~ Cl/½ l'u' Q fi' l1v1 \MH,,
UN
"-1 e.MJo t,\ ._.,.
<;~k,M,
~ ~ ., .,G\
I .,...-
. ~ u A LAM ~ ~ N o Y'Qf·11 UN Pe~ r i~
"":'1 ~ ~ UN R_ Ll.u-4--t ..__--
(5) ut...t .s t l~l-:1 ~ ' c. VJ<:f £M,vh'trh 1-
@ jT\ ck:Q '.-1 ,1 "'I ·~ >1 C VC\..LL.LQ...d - M.b rot; i,c.,J.s.-1
\il\J O r Ol.J ~ \ ~ ~ ) 1~ (" cfl
.ui~ ~ >t Ji l ttt.i r -h 1c, ~1 ~I- r-1 -~ t:-e CA\,,lfut::t,~ :½.1a::•:-l:!f C~ ~cm
p- r ~~ ~ .Aa.MR •
~ ~'c. ~'~ .
_;;;,,~ --h.-Lti' ~ U."'Y\l\.,,vJ ~ I - +-t, -1 n ~ J
~ O\._ ~ :":-:f 'I) I
p ~ ( A,yi..r-t) - t ~ , L•N ,
~
1 ndul. '..1 q_µuf frr MlML~ 1<-o h' ~~ _ ~~ ~ ~ l'v\.A.,~ t-
7A d Uf Q1A.Uvt -h b..ii 0v1 +iv ~~ 1- ~ '1 V O ~ ~ -~~ -+(,~ V1\J ~~
±#f: ½-¾! e:} ~ ~ ~ d ~k~L~ 1 J)~~ ~ - .
/1 ~ ~, \ l
•• ✓ 6,., --\i-v ~ I o baJ o.- (1(_h.\.lv-, ld '.t'::': ~ 0 :/,._ d,~- 6.{,,L~ ·-k.v Ie....-u>tc. '\. i- "-1 A f\.1 ' J) w ')
~'.'-J,;-:
• ~_
· I •~ n , . .L D-n'l.A L{' -I $ j_,. ,h , ,e
Y\ d0.., ~ ~ •.:::-1,'y ;..;t=:e V:::-'z?:
v,,~y[ cl , Cc " ~ '. l \ "- '1 Ld - I!,-,_ "'- \ l' <"~' J,
~ -- ,
= =- -- ✓
R..t.J.r. MA.!'-'-" ~~, f(.'-"eN"":f
I\I () lY'b cL.J -·is- Gl \ 0 6 "'-r ~ -{I'\, 'l.. '\. • ._c..,,--.. u C.::_. \. .
, 11.J,, -n ll ~ h _ _ , {n'!_:1 ( •~• l,h'f ~ L . \ \)
I' (,_( ' "'' ~ I .( ,J \I'\ k -,- " "-~ '11\\_d (" ~•1 v--'/t1 ·I • .J. ~ ~
, •
~ j'V\d-U 1A ~~~
'
n Cl,!4 ' Cl (A M . ~ (5\- \.,1 I
-frr
SC~
tv\_-0~ J.,cud -
Gi \ti boJ ~ V \,v '-p
.A ,U ·
IJ ts.I ..,1.n c_ L vv le \N \,
~
, ,U 'l_,.i L~
d,~ - u '
Ai¼~
(I)
~ 1/4 /\A.,L>"'-~ v-<--::p
~ Ll .£
~ "~
tv\_1) ,_ E \ b C.(
")'\l\.,.t) -h .,\ , ~
n- (11J o b o..l
??r '°h..M ~ A A-<-
\N I\ \ 'i,
-h , l~
Vtn' e , ~ ~ - ~
I M.~ w :, n _ ~k
u p \-1'-J M-t 1-:: u N 5l- V\ ~ te<1 ~ , bi L~
,'DR..,y " ~ . /4 G.,~}h ·m ~''.
o ~ 1_ ~ ~ ~;.:nCW<
~ cu
1
°" N Q ,L ,L ,~ g ~ ~ d.-l~ '1r c.,ocu.;Bcrn
WI l \ d ; UA...k ~
~blo..'t-110.-tilM t 9 ~W'-/4
_,_ vs ~-1) · 'Th b-< \..UVW ~ b
'l R. ~ ~
~ ~
\,J;koJ- ~ a. b:x ~l"l w L t- ~1 1
~ ~-" '~ ~ ~
(D ~ ,, °'
5 , ~'.M
1 -- °"--r:u
Y\.o \-
L.1 ~
r '"J"~r°'-"' ..)..-i~
I
12A
L l/4./ ~ ±?--½ ~
~~ ~ Vs
Oy)
I °I t I 'J'r't d.u, :. /2
Ma:1 c--1
~ V\.,~. o:Pf:u1::0 G-m.ti1 ~- ui
-h , L \1 1 ~ tr')
To...pQI') A V ~~
lv \d ~
\~ . "\- A-fY' ~ v-vJ cm
2h C Y tx \c L '~ ~
~ v'\AM / ~~ • ~ 'L
~
Lu \< .. ~ Ov'\.m
'Y'e..1--lv\1VI..M _ • ~ u_l--5 I G,u_t,- ~ ~
~ f>v"0._ :±b-
® ~nclu ~ y d l ½.-t 'L ,
.-ch s~ ?t- • ' E-z... u \ \/vu\..t ~' -
~ AU \M1 I n..o 1- i'.A,u..ef t-
CV\..d e,,i p~tM IM ~ t v ~ (2- ~~)~
~ ~
t:\-1-\, h.u
\
bl
-~
\..I
f.n."
>
~ 3
J 1
'-1
I
'11
-
'-t-
-
~ /
I
b.-e
d
h,
I
h
.,__
~
\<_ 0 fi
'
~
--- [
hrrrr,1-<.~ A
C N4v p
[ Gi - LI+ '2. A 8S~- P~1-(~)
-+ +
3 Nt'n') ~ p I Ntrn - p~ ..
U, ~J
~~
t) r~;:s~
"
e T~t-
-
V'V\t l
.~
~o,
-- ~
~
0 ~~
-
t'\.o t
\
rQ.
....
. ~
h'
-
• C. I
°'-
\
.J
I
n- N t,l,.Jv..l 1>.,tu' u} ~
.
, ,
o-'\-ir-'"l ~ ~
UL ~ rv--"'
-h
IJ ~ ~ C. - \Z .U
k-iitti_
., ~
, ~d ~0~
~
_v
u -l J w r>..,"t w c_,u i
,lJM - So ~ F -n
~ cu- -t w u ~ ~
~ ~.
~ t. ~ Cjv...U Y- ~
V N '~ l.
~~~
~J,~
w-D.A
'°d '
,~~ I
H~ ~ ~
u
M
, M_.tfl~~
1
M .16~ ~ ..Lri
'
,y 7 w ~ I ~ Ju _,~ 1 t) ~
)- \ ~ w-h ~ ~
L f-e
-1 ~ewu 11 ~ ~ ~ '.Y
Tl-lM i
:~ ---n>
~0-24 ~~~~ ~
~
2-1 Yi-- ~ ;, ,~
~.
1_
•
TV\Q.Jn1-t,t C· ~
~ ~ -s. u
~~ i b~ ~d
o- 1rlrh .cJ , f ~
ad cd __+a,\_ µ - -~- ~.J· p- \,v i,\..C..-\
, I.Z1v ;.c., ryyr r~-s1..L( .
~t\.d.~ rVt-1~ k (_tru.f\,{~, R-~~
~ N !< "'' f""':'i bu,-.,,.,, "" -:kl-1- "l ' "",
'.:'.-·>1c., M ·rh c,., ; I\ v; .-t:....hev, 'n / ' , "a
\., l'\J' (11\ titt,~ - " Ti"\{' &_1..A( J; ~ (1
:.'i '·Uj <A. b'k I\.Q.p "'I Clv\.d u:i (_ "-CLJ.( ~~ ~
IV\.(,w,, c..>v.1~;, '"'I J'-U..t,L-\..'.;?J C.C'\,(,v r:..t { •:
0 ~ 'e.-, 1 =~
" fin c, i)j d )•
'4\ ' ~
. Y ~ ~clt:e (A>LJ ~ . "
'½'.: pa. Ykb'~ kotf, C.tU-<~
cLJ..i'b.ui '\A·d .,:7 \<.Q.p ~ t"t-d Bc1- 1
o fy..._~ V\ A
Re..cd po-L,,':J-,' k
( P+ ,vp)
, ~ W f::, ,_ Bol¼ -.,J en..to~""-' ::j ~1\-0"-'- i,t, c..t,__, ..;_Q 1, "'-r :J--' e C _
I?:? {t, -lw We1
o~vor_~
~ I~
,&
r:--',
~¾') °I,
A i--r<! c....~ kA -1 \,v l"v1 + V-,Y\, (;h.0 v \.:J
,.,, g (\, ~~ -nr · r'-uw v'\/\. ( '\ J p ~ r
l'\V✓l l ~ J-c '- ?-
tI l I
r_r;JJ.zd -fr, '1 \>-~L'-hOV\ 1r v e +o, -\- r~zu_p J V u --',I M¼tl- " <' --'--11 'l , -, ""' - I k e '"" cl
.}--ff ~ r ---- -- -- +-~-,
1.,i ~ r c ', ._/1o
1