CARE Ratings Q3 & 9M FY24 Results
CARE Ratings Q3 & 9M FY24 Results
SE/2023-24/100
To,
The General Manager The National Stock Exchange India Ltd.
Corporate Relation Department Listing Department
BSE Limited Exchange Plaza
Phiroze Jeejeebhoy Towers Bandra Kurla Complex
14th Floor, Dalal Street Bandra (East)
Mumbai 400 001 Mumbai 400 051
Scrip Code: 534804 Scrip Code: CARERATING
SUB: PRESS RELEASE AND INVESTOR PRESENTATION FOR THE QUARTER AND NINE
MONTHS ENDED DECEMBER 31, 2023
Please find enclosed herewith Press Release and Investor Presentation of the CARE Ratings Limited for
the quarter and nine months ended December 31, 2023 as per the requirement of Regulation 30 and
Para A of Part A of Schedule III of the SEBI (Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements)
Regulations, 2015.
Thanking you,
Yours faithfully,
Nehal Shah
Company Secretary & Compliance Officer
Encl: As Above
4th Floor, Godrej Coliseum, Somaiya Hospital Road, Off Eastern Express Highway, Sion (East), Mumbai - 400 022.
Phone: +91-22-6754 3456 • Email: care@careedge.in • www.careedge.in
CIN-L67190MH1993PLC071691
CARE Ratings Limited
The Board of Directors of CARE Ratings Limited have declared its unaudited financial results for the
quarter ended 31st December 2023.
The Indian economy continues to remain a ‘Bright Spot’ in otherwise challenging global economic
environment. As per the First Advance Estimate, India’s GDP growth in FY24 has been pegged at
7.3% driven by government spending on infrastructure capex, improvement in domestic
manufacturing and robust services sector performance.
The corporate performance too is reflecting the improving trend as depicted by the CareEdge
Ratings credit ratio (ratio of upgrades to downgrades) which has been persistently above unity
since H2FY21. The entities in sectors like auto components, iron & steel, real estate, hospitality,
healthcare and logistics have witnessed most upgrades. The improved credit ratio indicates that
cash flow generation of corporates have remained robust, resulting in deleveraged and strong
balance sheets.
Fundraising by businesses witnessed a moderation in Q3 FY24 with corporate bond and commercial
paper issuances declining by 11.2% and 9%, respectively on a year-on-year basis. Bank credit
growth has remained healthy, rising by 16.2% in FY24 (as on November) driven by the personal
loans and services segment. Industrial credit grew by 6.1% in FY24 (as on November), lower than
13% growth in the year ago period. Credit to large industries remained muted with a growth of
3.6% in FY24 (as on November). However, it's crucial to note that the growth figures in FY24 may
appear skewed compared to FY23 due to the influence of the base effect.
Commenting on the results and performance for Q3 & 9M FY24, Mr. Mehul Pandya, Managing
Director & CEO of CARE Ratings Ltd. said:
“Despite the muted fund-raising scenario witnessed for Q2 & Q3 of FY24, our Company on a
standalone basis recorded YoY growth of 15% in income from operations for 9MFY24. The initial
ratings business continued to witness good growth. The EBITDA margin continued to remain robust
at 44% for 9MFY24. The other income, which is driven by interest income grew on back of better
yield generated on deposits. On cost parameters, the increase in employee cost is attributed to a
talent management initiative.
On a Consolidated basis, Income from operations reported growth of 20% on the back of
improvement in ratings and non-ratings businesses. The EBITDA margin for 9MFY24 continued to
remain strong at 34%.
We reiterate that our financial performance should be assessed on a cumulative basis rather than a
quarterly basis. Nevertheless, our company on a standalone basis recorded a healthy YoY growth of
22% in income from operations for Q3 FY24. The consolidated operating income also recorded a YoY
growth of 27% for Q3FY24.
Some of the key new initiatives that we would like to highlight to our shareholders are:
1. We have applied for ESG Ratings Providers (ERP) license with SEBI. We already have a
leadership team in place and would commence ESG Ratings services post regulatory
approvals.
2. We have setup an entity in South Africa to undertake Credit Ratings business. The process for
acquiring a Credit Ratings Agency license is underway.
2
CARE Ratings Limited
Ratings business is driven by capital raising both by public and private sector. We remain cautiously
optimistic in our outlook, as the key ingredients needed to stimulate private capex like deleveraged
balance sheet of Indian corporates, incentives schemes by government to boost manufacturing
sector (through performance linked incentives PLIs and other capital incentives) and strong domestic
demand are all in place.
With the government intent to maintain and intensify its push for infrastructure investments, we
expect the infrastructure financing to continue. Further, with the recent RBIs directive on change in
risk weight for certain asset classes, we expect some growth moderation in the NBFC segment.
As we move forward, it is crucial to remain vigilant and adaptable to the evolving economic
landscape. These are exciting times in the Indian economy, and with a holistic approach, we can
navigate through both the challenges and opportunities that lie ahead.”
3
CARE Ratings Limited
www.careratings.com www.sgapl.net
4
CARE Ratings Limited
Investor Presentation
Q3 & 9M FY24
Macro-Economic
Indicators
2
FUNDRAISING ACTIVITY MODERATES IN Q3FY24
Source: Prime database; Note: Data includes private placement and public issues Source: RBI
▪ Corporate Bond issuances were lower by 11.2% (y-o-y) in Q3 FY24; However, the issuances were higher by 20.5% (y-o-y) in 9M FY24.
▪ Commercial paper issuances were lower by 9% and 5% (y-o-y) in Q3 and 9M FY24, respectively.
3
BANK CREDIT TO INDUSTRY MODERATES
Y-o-Y %
15
12.0
10 10.3
6.1 10
5 3.6
5
0 0
Industry (25.1) Services (29.0) Micro and Small (19.1) Medium (7.9) Large (73.0)
Source: RBI; Note: Figures in bracket represent % share in total; Growth rates for FY24 exclude the impact of the Source: RBI; Note: Figures in bracket represent % share in total industrial credit; Growth rates for FY24 exclude the
merger of a non-bank with a bank. impact of the merger of a non-bank with a bank.
▪ Overall bank credit growth increased by 16.2% in FY24 (as on November) as against 17.2% growth in the year ago period.
▪ Credit to large industries remained relatively muted in FY24. However, it's crucial to note that the growth figures in FY24 may appear skewed compared to FY23 due to
the influence of the base effect.
4
GOVERNMENT CAPEX SUPPORTS INVESTMENT
20.4
20% 3.0%
20
15% 2.5%
15
Y-o-Y %
12.4
10% 2.0% 11.0
9.6
10 8.9
8.0 8.0
5% 1.5%
5.0
5
0% 1.0%
FY18 FY19 FY20 FY21 FY22 FY23 (RE) FY24 (BE) 1.2
Mar-22
Mar-23
Sep-21
Dec-21
Sep-22
Dec-22
Jun-22
Jun-23
Sep-23
Capex % of Expenditure Capex % of GDP (RHS)
▪ Centre’s capex (% of expenditure) is budgeted to rise to 22.2% in FY24 from 17.4% in FY23.
▪ GFCF increased by a strong 11% (y-o-y) in Q2 FY24 buoyed by healthy government capex ahead of the elections.
5
INVESTMENT PROJECTS SLOW; CAPACITY UTILIZATION MODERATES
14 75
14.5
12 70 73.6
10 65
Rs. Lakh Crore
9.4 9.7
8 60
%
6 7.4
6.8 55
5.8
4 4.6 50
4.4 4.4 4.3
2 2.8 45
1.9 2.0 2.2
0 1.3
40
Jun-20
Jun-21
Jun-22
Jun-23
Sep-20
Mar-21
Sep-21
Mar-22
Sep-22
Mar-23
Sep-23
Dec-20
Dec-21
Dec-22
Dec-23
Mar-20
Mar-21
Mar-22
Mar-23
Dec-19
Dec-20
Dec-21
Dec-22
Sep-19
Sep-20
Sep-21
Sep-22
Jun-23
Jun-19
Jun-20
Jun-21
Jun-22
Source: CMIE Source: CMIE
▪ New project announcements slowed to Rs 11.6 lakh crore in 9M FY24 as against announcements worth Rs 22.2 lakh crore in 9M FY23.
▪ Capacity utilization in the manufacturing sector witnessed a seasonal decrease to 73.6% in Q1 FY24 from 76.3% in Q4 FY23. However, it remained higher compared to
the same quarter last year.
6
Financials
7
STANDALONE: 9MFY24 KEY HIGHLIGHTS
EBITDA PAT
Rs. 208.27 Cr
(+15% YoY)
EBITDA Margin PAT Margin
44% 35%
8
STANDALONE: Q3FY24 KEY HIGHLIGHTS
EBITDA PAT
Rs. 66.68 Cr
(+22% YoY)
EBITDA Margin PAT Margin
41% 29%
9
PROFIT & LOSS STATEMENT: 9MFY24
Standalone Consolidated
Profit and Loss (Rs. Crs)
9MFY24 9MFY23 YoY 9MFY24 9MFY23 YoY
Total Operating Income (TOI) 208.27 180.79 15% 241.54 201.48 20%
Other Income 33.29 26.98 23% 36.40 27.57 32%
Total Income 241.56 207.77 16% 277.94 229.05 21%
*9MFY23 EBITDA would be Rs.79.64 Crs post adjusting for one-off items
10
PROFIT & LOSS STATEMENT: Q3FY24
Standalone Consolidated
Profit and Loss (Rs. Crs)
Q3FY24 Q3FY23 YoY Q3FY24 Q3FY23 YoY
Total Operating Income (TOI) 66.68 54.56 22% 78.68 62.14 27%
Other Income 10.58 11.03 (4%) 13.68 11.59 18%
Total Income 77.26 65.59 18% 92.36 73.73 25%
EBITDA (TOI - Op. Exp.) 27.04 22.24 22% 23.36 17.88 31%
EBITDA (%) 41% 41% 30% 29%
11
About Us
ABOUT US
Who Are We
Established in 1993, we are India’s second largest credit rating
agency.
What We Offer
Ratings
Track record of servicing diverse sectors, with leadership positions in
high-growth sectors such as BFSI and Infra.
Advisory
Providing high-quality research and advisory, including
sustainability services.
Serving the financial markets for over
Commenced Rating Operations Launched ‘CARE Loan Ratings’ for rating term loans Founding member of Association of Credit Rating Agency
Expansion of ratings operations to rating of toll Ventured into Advisory business and bagged 13 in Asia (ACRAA)
roads, electricity board, municipal corporations, assignments Launched Corporate Governance and Value Creation
structured instruments Obtained registration with SEBI when rating agencies Rating
Completed studies on central public sector came under its purview Signed MOU with NSIC for empanelment as an approved
undertakings selected by disinvestment Commission rating agency for small scale industries
2009-2012 2005-2008
Launched an initial public offering in 2012, which was subscribed over 34 times, and listed on Set up a research division catering to Industry Research, Customised Research and
both NSE and BSE Industry Risk Metrics
Acquired an application software company viz. Kalypto, renamed as CARE Risk Solutions Private Launched IPO grading services
Limited (CRSPL)
Received mandate from Ministry of Urban Development for rating 13 ULBs under
Worked closely with Asian Development bank on prestigious assignments JNNURM
Provided technical assistance to some emerging rating agencies outside India
14
CareEdge GROUP: FORESIGHT BACKED BY EXPERT INSIGHTS
CareEdge
Group
CARE Ratings Limited
(Parent Company)
Subsidiaries
100%
15
RATINGS BUSINESS
▪ Already applied for ESG Ratings Providers (ERP) license with the
regulator
Public Finance Resolution Recovery
Rating Plan Rating
16
ANALYTICS AND ADVISORY - ESG & SUSTAINABLITY SOLUTIONS
Analysis and performance tracking for pre-determined KPIs along E, S & G Funds, FIs and Corporates
ESG Benchmarking
parameters, along with a comparison against industry leaders and industry peers seeking ESG data
ESG GAP Identify gaps in compliance, policies, performance and disclosures to evaluate the Corporates seeking to enhance
Analysis maturity of sustainability performance. their ESG performance
Prioritise which areas to begin work on to roll out ESG strategy
Assist to prepare policy documents in line with the Company philosophy and ESG gaps Corporates seeking to improve
Policy Advisory
identified their ESG profile & strategy
ESG Stewardship Frame ESG Strategy and Roadmap, with a clear vision and measurable metrics for Top 1000 listed entities for
& Reporting performance over a 3-5 year time horizon, and assist in sustainability reporting & BRSR whom BRSR is mandatory
Developed India’s first tech-enabled platform, ‘SIRIUS’ which is an on- Completed coverage of over 1,100 listed companies through
demand, comprehensive data platform that brings together company, SIRIUS platform in India
Our Progress industry and ESG insights
17
ANALYTICS AND ADVISORY – CONSULTING & RESEARCH
CONSULTING RESEARCH
18
ANALYTICS AND ADVISORY - RISK & ANALYTICS
Banks rely Integrated Data Risk Focused Research on New Age Technology
on us for: Model Regulated Norms AI/ML
19
Outreach Activities
20
OUTREACH ACTIVITIES: Q3FY24
Guest Speakers
Webinars: Moderated by
21
OUTREACH ACTIVITIES: Q3FY24
• CareEdge partnered with CNBC-TV18 as the Knowledge Partner • CareEdge Analytics and Advisory achieved the 90th rank in the Chartis
for the ICAI CA 40 Under 40 Awards. In this role, CareEdge RiskTech100 2024, ascending from 93rd the previous year, signalling a
collaborated with CNBC-TV18 in various aspects of the award significant rise in the industry standings.
process, such as determining evaluation criteria, nominee
shortlisting, and results compilation for the jury's consideration. • Nehal Shah, Head of Compliance, Legal, and Secretarial at CareEdge
Additionally, Rajashree Murkute, Senior Director at CareEdge Ratings, was honoured by Legasis Private Limited for her distinguished
Ratings, contributed to the panel discussion "India’s Amrit Kaal: contributions to compliance at The Compliance 10/10 Awards.
Roadmap for a Sustained & Inclusive Economy," alongside
distinguished experts.
22
OUTREACH ACTIVITIES: Q3FY24
• Mehul Pandya, MD & CEO of CareEdge, spoke at USIIC's event honouring NASA's Dr. Ravi Margasahayam.
• Sachin Gupta, Chief Rating Officer at CareEdge Ratings, analysed India Inc.'s H1 FY2024 performance in the Hindu
Business Line.
• Sachin Gupta, Chief Rating Officer, discussed "India Credit Landscape" at The Edelweiss Annual Investors Meet.
• Nadir Bhalwani, CIO & CTO of CareEdge Ratings, presented at the Mumbai Cloud and Datacentre Convention
2023.
• Rajani Sinha, Chief Economist at CareEdge, spoke on India's potential at the PMS Bazar event.
• Sanjay Agarwal, Senior Director at CareEdge Ratings, interpreted the RBI's consumer credit circular for A.K. Capital
Services.
• Rajashree Murkute, Senior Director at CareEdge Ratings, participated in SEBI's munibond program in Chandigarh.
• Swati Agrawal and Tanvi Shah from CareEdge Analytics and Advisory held a session on AIFs for LIC Investments.
• Abhisheik Vishwakarma, President of CareEdge Analytics, spoke on data analytics at The FCBA 2023.
• CareEdge Analytics Team showcased their Risk Management Software at the National Bank Staff College,
Lucknow.
• Saurav Chatterjee, CEO of CARE Ratings Africa, moderated a panel on Sustainable Financing by Spaanda.
23
OUTREACH ACTIVITIES: Q3FY24
Top Reports:
Canada Stir Unlikely to Hit Specialised Education Loan NBFCs Portfolio View
Hospital Industry in India Set to Grow at 12 percent CAGR till FY26 View
Indian Airports: Passenger Traffic to Grow at 14 percent CAGR over FY23-25 View
Personal Loans and NBFCs Continue to Support Bank Credit Offtake View
Soda Ash Industry FY24 Margins Likely to Moderate by 400-550 bps but Long-term Growth Intact View
The Global Debt Wave Post Covid Looks More Menacing View
24
SAFE HARBOUR
This presentation and the accompanying slides (the “Presentation”), which have been prepared by CARE Ratings Ltd. (the “Company”), have
been prepared solely for information purposes and do not constitute any offer, recommendation or invitation to purchase or subscribe for any
securities, and shall not form the basis or be relied on in connection with any contract or binding commitment whatsoever. No offering of
securities of the Company will be made except by means of a statutory offering document containing detailed information about the Company.
This Presentation has been prepared by the Company based on information and data which the Company considers reliable, but the Company
makes no representation or warranty, express or implied, whatsoever, and no reliance shall be placed on, the truth, accuracy, completeness,
fairness and reasonableness of the contents of this Presentation. This Presentation may not be all inclusive and may not contain all of the
information that you may consider material. Any liability in respect of the contents of, or any omission from, this Presentation is expressly
excluded.
This presentation contains certain forward looking statements concerning the Company’s future business prospects and business profitability,
which are subject to a number of risks and uncertainties and the actual results could materially differ from those in such forward-looking
statements. The risks and uncertainties relating to these statements include, but are not limited to, risks and uncertainties regarding
fluctuations in earnings, our ability to manage growth, competition (both domestic and international), economic growth in India and abroad,
ability to attract and retain highly skilled professionals, time and cost over runs on contracts, our ability to manage our international operations,
government policies and actions regulations, interest and other fiscal costs generally prevailing in the economy. The Company does not
undertake to make any announcement in case any of these forward-looking statements become materially incorrect in future or update any
forward-looking statements made from time to time by or on behalf of the Company.
25
CONTACT US
www.careratings.com www.sgapl.net
26
Thank You!
About Us
CareEdge is a knowledge-based analytical group that aims to provide superior insights based on technology, data analytics
and detailed research. CARE Ratings Ltd, the parent company in the group, is one of the leading credit rating agencies in
India. Established in 1993, it has a credible track record of rating companies across multiple sectors and has played a pivotal
role in developing the corporate debt market in India. The wholly-owned subsidiaries of CARE Ratings are (I) CARE Advisory,
Research & Training Ltd, which offers customised advisory services, credible business research and analytical services (II)
CARE Risk Solutions Private Ltd, which provides risk management solutions.
Connect