Classical Education Systems
Classical Education Systems
i
MODULE ONE History of Education (PDE - 101)
OBJECTIVES
At the end of this unit, you should be able to:
1. discuss the significant characteristics of early educational systems;
2. analyse their influences on later educational systems;
3. discuss what our own system has inherited from these early systems.
BACKGROUND
History as an academic discipline, is interested in looking to the back, no just for its sake, but
so that we can learn from the past, and how the past has influenced the present. In looking to
the past, history likes to dig to the very origin, to the earliest period that is relevant to the
issue at hand. In the present circumstances, we can say that education really started as soon
as man was created. This is because the business of bringing up a young person involves his
progressive education. Indeed, when we look at what we call education, we might not be
wrong in describing it as the system by which one generation imparts the ideals and cultural
practices of its society to the next generation in an unending process. In this first unit of our
module on history of education, we try to examine the very origin of what we have and
cherish today.
ACTIVITY 1
1. What would you say is the purpose of this first unit?
2. What are the two major characteristics of the earliest systems of education?
3. In what ways are these characteristics applicable to Nigerian traditional systems?
4. What can we learn today from these earliest periods?
1
MODULE ONE History of Education (PDE - 101)
Education in Mesopotamia
The civilization in Mesopotamia developed at about the same time as that in Egypt. So,
Mesopotamia developed education quite similar to that of Egypt with regard to its purpose
and training. It was practical and aimed to train scribes and priests. It was extended from
basic reading, writing and religion to higher learning in law, medicine and astrology.
Generally, youth of the nobles were trained to become scribes, who later functioned either as
copyists, librarians or teachers. Schools for priests were said to be as numerous as temples,
indicating the thoroughness and the supremacy of priestly education. Very little is known
about higher education, but the advancement of the priestly work sheds light upon the
extensive nature of intellectual pursuit.
As with Egypt, the priests in Mesopotamia dominated the intellectual and educational domain
as well as the applied. The library formed the centre of intellectual activity, which usually
operated in a temple under the supervision of renowned priests. Teachers employed
memorization, oral repetition, copying of models, and individual instruction. The period of
education was long and rigorous and discipline was harsh.
ACTIVITY II
1. What similarities can you identify in the educational systems of Egypt and
Mesopotamia? What dissimilarities can you recognize?
2. Why do you think these educational systems were dominated by the priests?
3. Discipline
Education in Northwas rigid or harsh in both systems. How would you compare this with
China
the systems today?
2
MODULE ONE History of Education (PDE - 101)
Civilization in North China began with the emergence of the Shang era. Thus, complex
educational practices began from a very early date. In fact, virtually every character (or
letter) of the Chinese orthography was already formed more than 3,000 years ago. Ancient
Chinese education was mainly secular in nature, although it at the same time, aimed to
improve the morals of the youth to develop a sense of moral sensitivity and duty toward
people and the state. Even in the early stages of civilization, harmonious human relations,
rituals, and music formed the curriculum. Formal colleges and schools probably existed by
1000 BC. Apart from the major centres in the provinces, there were less-organized
institutions, such as halls of study, village schools, and district schools. As for the methods
of education, ancient Chinese learned from bamboo books and obtained moral training and
practice in rituals by word of mouth and example. Rigid rote learning, which became the
norm in later Chinese education, did not seem to be used then. Education was regarded as the
process of individual development from within.
The Hindu tradition
India is the site of one of the most ancient civilizations in the world. From about 2000 BC
the Aryans entered, captured the land, and founded powerful kingdoms. Before long, the
Brahmans who were the intellectuals became priests and men of learning; the nobles and
soldiers constituted the next class, the agricultural and trading class was called Vaisyas; and
finally the dasas were absorbed as domestic servants. Such was the origin of the division of
the Hindus into four classes. By about 500 BC, the classes became hardned into castes.
Religion was the mainspring of all activities in ancient India. It comprised of both prayer and
worship as well as philosophy, morality, law, and government. Religion dominated
educational ideals, too and the study of Vedic literature was very important in higher classes.
There were clearly demarcated stages of instruction. During the first period, the child
received elementary education at home. The beginning of secondary education and formal
schooling was marked by a ritual, which was restricted to and compulsory for boys of the
three higher castes: at age 8 years for the Brahman boys, age 11 for boys of the next higher
class, and age 12 for the boys of the third higher class. The boy then left his father’s house
for his preceptor’s home. The preceptor would treat him as his own child, give him free
education, and not charge anything for his boarding and lodging. The pupil had to tend the
sacrificial fires, do the household work of his preceptor, and look after his cattle.
The study at this stage consisted of the recitation of the Vedic mantras, or “hymns,” and the
auxiliary sciences-phonetics, the rules for the performance of the sacrifices, grammar
astronomy, prosody, and etymology. The characteristic of education, however, differed
according to the needs of the caste. For a child of the priestly class, there was a definite
syllabus of studies. It was compulsory for him to have knowledge of the most ancient of
Hindu scriptures. During the whole course at school, or at college, the student had to wear a
simple dress, live on plain food, use a hard bed, and lead a celibate life. Learning normally
lasted for 12 years, but for those who wanted to go further, there was no age limit. After
finishing their education at an asrama, they went to a higher centre of learning or a university.
Advanced students also improved their knowledge by taking part in philosophical discussions
at an “academy”. Women were not denied education, but normally girls were taught at home.
The method differed according to the nature of the subject. Parables were employed in the
3
MODULE ONE History of Education (PDE - 101)
ACTIVITY III
1. What major similarities would you recognise between the Chinese and Hindu
systems?
2. Some that appears to be peculiar to the Hindu system is the class system. How do
you think this affected the system of education there?
3. How much of the education in each of the two systems was utilitarian and how
much of it was not.
4
MODULE ONE History of Education (PDE - 101)
ACTIVITY IV
1. From what has been presented here, do you think there was a formal school
system as in the previously discussed systems?
2. Corporal punishment was the norm during the period discussed. To what extent
did this differ from, or conform to earlier discussed system?
5
MODULE ONE History of Education (PDE - 101)
OBJECTIVES
At the end of this unit, students should be able to:
1. state clearly who the Spartans were and the era in which they lived;
2. discuss the type of education they gave their children;
3. analyse factors that made them adopt this type of education;
4. discuss what lessons we can learn from the Spartans.
THE BACKGROUND
Who were the Spartans?
Sparta was one of the ancient Greek city states. By ‘ancient’ we are referring to the era
before the present epoch, especially the period before the birth of Christ some two thousand
years ago. During the periods we are referring to, Greece as it exists today as a country did
not really exist. Rather, there were several city states, most of them rising to cultural and/or
military prominence. Among them were Sparta and Athens, two contiguous cities, but vastly
different from each other in several ways as we shall see from this and the next units.
Specifically, the era we are referring to is about 8 or 7 centuries BC, which was the period
that Sparta really reached the height of her glory as a military force.
Sparta believed so much in military exploits and cared less for beauty and culture. There is a
saying that Spartan parents owed their male children one thing: the shield, and that on
handling over this military tool, they usually accompanied the act with the saying, ‘Go, and
return with it, or on it.’ What does this terse saying mean? It signifies that the parent is
sending off the son into the wide world with the shield to defend himself against all sorts of
attack, and that he should either return in victory with it, or die and be brought home on it.
Such was the military disposition of Sparta that it soon became a force among other states.
Sparta subdued one after the other of the other states. First it was its neighbour, Messenia,
which lost its independence to Sparta in the 8th century BC and did not regain it until the
360s. Historians have asserted that it was this factor, of subjugating Messenia, ‘that
determined the peculiar development of Sparta, because it forced Spartans to adjust their
institutions to deal with a permanently hostile subject population’. Before long, Sparta
sprang out to other states, conquering one after the other including Athens too. However, it
was just this military might for which it was noted, but not for much else. So, there is not
much of poetry, drama, sculpture, etc., that we can learn from Sparta. What we can learn is
the type of education that prepared the citizens for warfare rather than for the arts, science,
governance, etc. So, what is this type of education?
6
MODULE ONE History of Education (PDE - 101)
ACTIVITY I
1. In which part of the world would you find the ancient Sparta today?
2. How long ago was the rise to glory of Sparta?
3. What does the statement to the Spartan boy tell us about Sparta?
4. Why do we not hear of Messenia today? What impact did the conquest of
Messenia have on Sparta?
EDUCATION IN SPARTA
Education in Sparta began from age 7 to 20 years. Before then, mothers brought up children,
‘in an atmosphere of severity and harshness’. Throughout life, girls were given a type of
education that prepared them for their role as wives and mothers; howbeit in an atmosphere
of severe discipline. Sickly or deformed children were eliminated through death or by simply
throwing them away, since they would not be useful for the type of life that Sparta wanted.
Although in the beginning of the state, Sparta encouraged some form of arts, music and
culture as part of the education of children, these gave way almost totally to a type of
education appropriate to a warrior state.
Boys in Sparta were enrolled into formations corresponding to successive age grade. These
were divided into smaller units under the authority of comrades of their own age or of young
officers. It was a collective education, which progressively removed them from the family
and subjected them to garrison life. Everything was organised with a view to preparation for
military service. Thus they were lightly clothed, had to sleep on the bare ground, and poorly
fed. They were told to steal to supplement their rations, and subjected to rigorous discipline.
Hardening them to blows developed their virility and combativeness. Besides, they were sent
on nocturnal expeditions designed to train the future fighter in ambushes and the ruses of
warfare. They were also directly apprenticed to the military craft, using arms and
maneuvering in close formation. The sole norm of this puritanical education, proceeding in a
climate of austerity, was the interest of the state. The Spartan was trained under a strict
discipline to obey blindly the orders of his superiors. Curiously, the child was at the same
time trained to lying, to theft, and to dissimulation, (i.e. to conceal one’s real feelings, e.g.
pretending to be happy and contented when in actual fact one was acutely sad and in
discomfort). All these were virtues when directed toward the foreigner, toward whom
distrust and Machiavellianism (i.e. cunning, deceit, and duplicity) were encouraged.
This type of ruged education enabled Sparta to remain for long the most powerful city,
militarily and diplomatically, of the entire Greek world and to triumph over its rival Athens
after the long struggle of the Peloponnesian War (431-404 BC). However, this did not
prevent Sparta’s decadence. It was not that Sparta ever relaxed its tension. On the contrary,
in the course of centuries, the rigour and ferocity were accentuated even as such behaviour
became more and more unnecessary and out of date and without real use. Rites of initiation
were transformed into barbarous tests of endurance, the boys undergoing flagellation and
competing in enduring it, sometimes to the very death, under the eyes of tourists attracted by
7
MODULE ONE History of Education (PDE - 101)
the sadistic spectacle. This occurred in times of complete peace when, under the Roman
Empire, Sparta was nothing but a little provincial city with neither independence nor army.
ACTIVITY II
1. For how long was the Spartan boy educated? How would you compare this with
the present system in Nigeria.
2. Mention at least three aspects of the education given to the Spartan boy.
3. Do you think the Spartan people had any respect for morality as it is known in our
world today? Give reasons for your view.
4. The word ‘Machiavellian’ should tell us much about the values cherished by the
people. Consult as many history books as you can to find out about the Italian
statesman called Nicholi Machiavelli and his ideas.
ACTIVITY III
1. In summary, state the major concepts of Spartan education.
2. Why does the writer stress that this type of education is not suitable for our
present world? Would you agree with him? If so, why? If not, why not?
3. From your own point of view, what type of education would you prescribe for
Nigeria of the twenty-first century? Give reasons for your answer.
8
MODULE ONE History of Education (PDE - 101)
SUMMARY
• Spartan does not exist today as a country. Rather, it was just a city state in ancient
Greece, just as other city states like Athens.
• Education in formal schools as we know it today did not exist in ancient Sparta.
Rather, boys and girls were brought up to live a hardened life that prepared them for a
military-like type of life. Indeed, invalids were intentionally killed or left to die since
they were of no use to the state and might even be an encumbrance (an impediment, a
hindrance; a burden, a useless addition) to the state.
• Life in the military dominated all aspects of Spartan life. Beside this, it did not matter
if a boy grew up to be a robber. Indeed, boys were encouraged to imbibe those traits
we would consider as immoral today, e.g. stealing, lying, cheating, etc.
• As a result of this highly regimented type of life, Sparta grew to become a military
force among other city states. It was able to subdue all others and dominate them.
• However, this state of things did not really last, as the state experienced internal decay
and fell gradually. In the end, it was destroyed in the fourth century AD.
REFERENCES
Osokoya, I.O. (1989) History and Policy of Nigerian Education in World Perspective.
Ibadan: AMD Publishers.
Good, H., & J.D. Tellar (1969) A History of Western Education. New York: Macmillan
Publishing Co. Inc.
The CD edition of the Encyclopedia Britannica, Inc 1994 – 2001.
9
MODULE ONE History of Education (PDE - 101)
OBJECTIVES
1. state clearly who the Athenians were and the era in which they lived;
2. discuss the type of education they developed then;
3. analyse factors that promoted this type of education;
4. discuss what lessons we can learn from the Athenians.
BACKGROUND
Who were the Athenians?
Athens was another Greek city-states, just like Sparta. Greece as we know it today as a
country did not yet exist then. Rather, small city states like Sparta, Corinth, Megara and
Athens were to be found in what is today the Greek peninsula. What bound these city-states
today was the common Greek language.
10
MODULE ONE History of Education (PDE - 101)
(a) the letters school for reading and writing, analogous today’s primary and secondary
schools;
(b) the music school for lyric, poetry and lyre, including learning and recitation of poems;
(c) the gymnastic school for physical training.
The foregoing did not mean that a boy would attend just one type of school and specialize in
it for life; rather, what obtained was that learners attended the letters and music schools in the
morning and the gymnastic school in the afternoon. Thus, it was like having different
institutions for different aspect of the same curriculum. From this explanation you would see
that our schools today have merely combined all these functions under the same institutions.
However, whether in a letters school, a music school or a gymnastic school, the moral aspect
of education was held in high esteem. ‘The Athenian ideal was that of the kalos k’agathos,
the “wise and good” man. The teachers were as much preoccupied with overseeing the
child’s good conduct and the formation of his character as with directing his progress in the
various subjects taught him.’ Besides, much of the morals were learned through poetry, as
the content of the poems contained a lot of the intended moral lessons. Thus it was that the
poetry of two great Athenians, Solon and Homer, became standard texts in the schools.
Solon’s poems had much to do with statecraft while Homer’s poetry concerned itself with
competition and heroic exploits.
Teaching was much more difficult than, and very different from what it is today. There were
no texts as such, and only the teacher had his manuscript to teach from. The teacher in most
cases dictated his lessons while the pupils wrote the notes down on their wax tablets for
memorization. Meanwhile, apart from the teacher, there was the pedagogue, a man-servant
employed by each rich parent to escort the boy to and from the school, and stay around to
keep him from any mischief. In case the boy was disobedient or wayward, the pedagogue
applied the whip.
There were no distinct subjects as we know them today, but much of what we learn today was
beginning to emerge and take shape. The curricu8lum consisted of reading, writing, music,
poetry, mathematics and gymnastics. Such subjects as religion, social studies, government,
etc., did not exist separately as they were taught in embedded form in writing, poetry, music,
etc.
Schooling continued till the age of eighteen. Between that age and twenty years, the boys
received military training, after which they were free to choose which career to specialize in.
However, in most cases, the Athenian boys preferred a career in state affairs. This seemed
logical enough since there were very few free educated people to start with, and since most of
the students were the children of the noble who could afford such luxury as formal education.
ACTIVITY I
1. What were the factors behind Athenian preference for civil rather than military
education?
2. Describe in as precise a manner as possible, the curriculum in Athenian schools.
3. Why did most boys end up in politics rather than in other careers?
11
MODULE ONE History of Education (PDE - 101)
12
MODULE ONE History of Education (PDE - 101)
and more essential to intending politicians and practitioners in the courts. Thirdly, they
developed the use of logic, the science of proper reasoning. When you think of these three
contributions – grammar, rhetoric, and logic – you would realize that these early lovers of
wisdom perhaps deserve their name.
This is not to say that they did not delve into some other areas. Of course, they engaged in
the nature of vietue (arête) and the bases of morality; in the history of society and the arts; in
poetry, music, and mathematics; and also in astronomy and the physical sciences, even
though individual Sophists may specialize in one area and not in the other. In general, it is
the general view today that these itinerant teachers initiated a method of higher education that
in range and method anticipated the modern humanistic approach.
ACTIVITY II
1. From the analysis of the words ‘philo’ and ‘soph’, try to think of some other
words in modern English which have these root words. Then try to work out their
meanings in the light of the explanations given.
2. Discuss factors that made the Sophists acceptable in ancient Athenian community.
Suggest factors why they might not be equally acceptable to present day society.
3. Discuss the major contributions of Sophists to education.
SUMMARY
The main thrust of this unit centres on the Athenian education. In the process, we learnt that:
• The Athenian education is drastically different from that of the Spartans. For former
is more liberal and oriented towards the civil society, while the latter is fashioned for
the development of military life.
• Girls are mainly educated at home for roles as wives and mothers, although their
training also imbibes a lot of moral upbringing.
• For boys, education lasted till the age of 18 years, after which they received military
training for two years.
• They received training in three types of schools: the letters school, the music school
and the gymnasium. The curriculum of course included far more than is suggested by
the mere names of these schools.
• The Sophists, itinerant teachers, influenced the education of youths greatly in that
they contributed to the teaching of grammar, rhetoric, logic; and in the process they
helped youths to develop their skills in public speaking and thus their preparation for
public life.
13
MODULE ONE History of Education (PDE - 101)
REFERENCES
Osokoya, I.O. (1989) History and Policy of Nigerian Education in World Perspective.
Ibadan: AMD Publishers.
The CD edition of the Encyclopaedia Britannica, Inc. 1994 – 2001.
G.W. Bowersock, Greek Sophists in the Roman Empire (1969)
14
MODULE ONE History of Education (PDE - 101)
OBJECTIVES
At the end of this unit, you should be able to:
1. enumerate similarities and differences between the educational systems practiced in
Sparta and Athens;
2. discuss the strengths and weaknesses inherent in each of the systems;
3. analyse what we can learn from each of the two systems.
BACKGROUND
It is perhaps instructive to discuss the background factors responsible for the educational
system in each of the two states. We can recall that Sparta aimed at military superiority over
its neighbours. The pertinent question we need to ask is ‘Why was there a need for such an
ambition?’ We can further ask if after achieving this ambition, Sparta was much happier for
it. This should be a good starting point for the present exercise.
We should also recall that the Athenian city-state was the first to steer away from an over-
emphasis on military superiority and military education. The instructive question here is
‘What motivated Athens to deviate from what had become the age-old philosophy of life?’
We should also further ask what the consequences of this type of new orientation were.
Finally, we should like to ask why, in spite of its defeat and subjugation by Sparta, it is
Athens as a state that survived while Sparta the conqueror was obliterated from the face of
the earth.
15
MODULE ONE History of Education (PDE - 101)
created a need for a peaceful epoch so as to enable them enjoy their wealth. You cannot
enjoy your riches if there is an unending war. Realise too that nobles who have more slaves
and attendants could have more time to think, to develop ideas. And one of the vestiges of
this is thinking of governance. Thus, the seeds of democracy had been sown.
So, we had these two city states existing side by side, one believing so much in military
exploits without thinking of morals, and the other believing in culture, morality, ideals, etc.
Almost inevitably, there was a clash in which, after a lot of dingdong results, Athens was
finally defeated. One would have thought that Sparta the victor would bestow a more
enduring legacy for mankind. No, it has been the other way round. Sparta itself was later
defeated by some other forces, and indeed was utterly destroyed. There was not much to
learn from it since there were no moral lessons worth bequeathing to mankind. Athens, on
the other hand, survived the holocaust.
The first thing we can realise about the two is that hardly can we refer to any great scholar or
philosopher from Sparta today. There are no great writings, no great plays, no great poems
from Sparta. On the contrary, there are countless scholars from Athens some of whom we
shall be learning about in the next units. Think of poets, and there are those like Homer and
Simonides; think of historians, and there are those like Thucydides and Melesias and when
we think of mathematics, we reckon with people like Pythagoras and Euclid. Though some
of these men may not have been Athenians as such, in most cases, they functioned as
Athenians or were influenced by Athenian culture and life. Most of these men left writings
or at least theories which are still cited today, almost three thousand years after they lived.
What do all these connote? It stands to reason from these that no civilization can thrive and
survive for long on militarism alone. This is a sense in which we can assert that knowledge is
superior to force, that the pen is mightier than the sword. Also, it shows that morality it is
that can build up a nation, not lack of ideals. Robbers can thrive for a while, but their doom
is certain.
ACTIVITY I
1. Why did Sparta choose the path of militarism?
2. What factors influenced Athens to deviate from militarism and choose the path of
civility?
3. What were the immediate and distant results of the two different ways of life?
16
MODULE ONE History of Education (PDE - 101)
whereas there may be a point in letting youths try it if only to realise that survival depends on
it.
However, there are very many things we should never learn from the Spartans. Lack of
morality destroys society, as it finally did Sparta. Lying, cheating, stealing, etc., are vices
that should be recognised for what they are. Besides, today, we know that killing or
abandoning deformed or invalid children is evil. Good a thing today that rather than destroy
or throw them away, our society caress for them in special institutions, for we now realise
that some disabled children are indeed very useful to society.
From Athenian education, we have learnt and can still learn a lot. To start with, the
development of subject areas is indirectly owed to them. Secondly, moral education which
was the centre of Athenian education has influenced our own system today. Perhaps, we still
need to stress more of this since our school subjects like literature, history, government,
religious studies, etc., could still contain more of moral lessons.
Besides, we need to learn to be more accommodating of other people’s ideas. Recall that the
Sophists who greatly influenced Athenian education were not Athenians themselves. But
because they were accommodated, they contributed to the glory of Athens. We should learn
to be more tolerant of others’ ideas, though we need not swallow them hook, line and sinker.
Finally, and perhaps most importantly, we need to learn from the Athenians that it is only
under a free atmosphere that education and civilization can thrive. An administrative system
that gags the press and the school system cannot sow the seeds of growth.
ACTIVITY II
1. What lessons can we learn from the educational system in Sparta? Which should
be not learned?
2. What lessons can we learn from the educational system in Athens?
3. If you are to summarise the lessons learnt from the two city-states, how would
you do it in just one sentence?
SUMMARY
The main thrust of this chapter has been that:
• Force cannot build up an enduring civilisation.
• Morality is essential for the survival of any society or nation.
• Ideas are best nurtured under a free, democratic dispensation.
• A state that builds so much on militarism cannot produce great thinkers such as
philosophers, writers, scientists, etc. On the other hand, these are the types of
products we can expect under a civil society.
17
MODULE TWO Great Athenian Educators (PDE- 101)
OBJECTIVES
At the end of this unit, students should be able to:
1. discuss who each of the three philosophers, Socrates, Plato and Aristotle, is;
2. analyse the contributions of each of these three to education;
3. identify what our own educational system can learn from each of the three.
BACKGROUND
In the annals of history, the three great Greek philosophers, Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle,
stand out gigantically. The simple reason is that they made so much contribution to the
development of human thought that they continue even today to be relevant to our world.
Indeed, it is not just to the development of education that they made significant contributions,
but indeed to so many other areas of human endeavour. For instance, Aristotle is considered
one of the first biologists. Besides, both Plato and Aristotle wrote books which are still
studied today. Finally, when you think of ideas and methods of logical thinking, it would be
difficult to beat these three.
So, who are these idealists? In this unit, we devote each of the three sections to each of them.
In each case, we first address ourselves to who the person is, and then go further by
discussing what their ideas and contributions are. We start with Socrates, the teacher of Plato
and end with Aristotle the student of Plato.
Socrates and his ides
Born 469 BC, in Athens, the son of Sophroniscus, a sculptor, and Phaenarete, a midwife,
Socrates was reportedly short and unattractive, but extremely hardy and self-controlled. He
was to live till 399 BC. He was educated in literature, music, and gymnastics, and later in the
rhetoric and dialectics of the sophists, the speculations of the Ionian philosophers, and the
general culture of Periclean Athens. Initially, Socrates followed the craft of his father. He
also served with the other male citizens of Athens in the Peloponnesian War with Sparta,
acting bravely as an infantryman at several battles.
Unlike the Sophists, he was an Athenian, and he did not sell his services. There are various
evidences that he was very close to Pericles, the ipso’facto ruler of Athens, and those in
authority in the city. So, it is logical to deduce that had he wanted power, he would have
acquired sufficient power for himself. He had a brief stint in politics but soon withdrew to
concentrate on philosophy and discussions. His wife was Xanthippe, an Athenian, with
whom he had three children.
Socrates left no writings; we know of his ideas through his pupils’ work, but the
characteristic approach of the “Socratic dialogues” and his critical application of logical
enquiry ensure his importance in later philosophy. The central idea of his philosophy was the
18
MODULE TWO Great Athenian Educators (PDE- 101)
ACTIVITY I
1. What would you think is the significance of the reference to Socrates as a short,
ugly person in the light of his contributions to knowledge?
2. What does ‘arete’ mean and what is the important of Socrates’ use of it?
3. Discuss Socrates’s real contributions to education.
4. Why do you think Socrates was arrested and finally killed?
19
MODULE TWO Great Athenian Educators (PDE- 101)
eventually became a disciple of Socrates, who had pioneered the search for ethical truth
through dialectical questions and answers with anyone claiming to have knowledge. Plato
witnessed the execution of Socrates by the Athenian democracy in 399 BC. Perhaps fearing
for his own safety, he left Athens for a time.
In 387 BC Plato founded in Athens the Academy often described as the first European
university. It provided a comprehensive curriculum, including such subjects as astronomy,
biology, mathematics, political theory, and philosophy. Aristotle became the Academy’s
most prominent student. The concluding years of his life were spent lecturing at the
Academy and writing. He died at about the age of 80 in Athens in 384 or 347 BC.
Plato’s surviving writings are all in the form of dialogues, sometimes framed by a narrator.
They depict philosophical ideas being advanced, discussed, and criticized in the context of a
conversation or debate involving two or more people. The earliest ancient collection of
Plato’s work includes 35 dialogues and 13 letters. The dialogues are conventionally divided
into the early, middle, and late dialogues. The earliest dialogues depict Socrates as Plato saw
him at work, questioning leading citizens of Athens about their beliefs. Socrates,
encountering someone who seems to know much about a particular ethical topic, professes to
be ignorant and seeks enlightenment from the person claiming knowledge. As Socrates
questions their definitions, however, it becomes clear that the one reputed to be wise does not
really know what he claims to know, and Socrates emerges as the wiser person because he at
least knows that he does not know.
Of all his several writings, The Republic is Plato’s longest, most complex, and most
ambitious. It is on the nature of justice in the soul and in the state. In it Plato tries to give a
theoretical account of the perfectly just state. Many of the book’s fundamental ideas are set
forth through analogies. Consider for instance the analogy with the mathematical entity, the
circle. A circle, he says, is a plane figure composed of a series of points, all of which are
equidistant from a given point, yet none of which itself occupies any space. An ideal circle
would be perfect, timeless, and the model for the circularity of all ordinary circles. In the
same way, abstract concepts – such as Beauty and Good – are perfect, timeless entities.
The Republic is concerned with the question of justice. Starting with the question “Does
justice pay for the individual, apart from any external rewards?” It argues that justice in the
soul is linked to justice in the city. Both soul and city have three analogous parts: the id, the
ego, and the super-ego – a desiring part, a spirited part and a rational part. Justice directs that
each part should carry out its own function. Plato argues that this means that the two non-
rational parts must be ruled by the rational part. Far from being a mere analogy, the relation
between soul and the city turns out to mean that the two lower classes in society must be
ruled by the highest class, the philosophers, who alone can use their reason to acquire
knowledge of the forms.
The political structure of the just city would thus depend on a thorough educational
programme, which selects the potential philosophers on the basis of merit, and trains them
thoroughly. His scheme is such that education should be almost life long. The most brilliant
pupils should be trained to become philosopher kings, i.e. the rulers, while those less gifted
should be trained for the armed forces and other menial professions, depending on their
capabilities. Throughout, the state should be responsible for the education of all citizens.
20
MODULE TWO Great Athenian Educators (PDE- 101)
This would sound as a communistic policy in which the state runs everything and all citizens
seem to exist for the interest of the state.
Once the philosophers are selected, their autocratic rule in the light of reason must be
safeguarded from corruption. Therefore, they are to be deprived of private property and
families, and forced to pay attention to civic affairs. Such drastic measures alone can ensure
that their rule is for the sake of the city as a whole and not for their private interests.
Plato’s influence on the later history of philosophy has been monumental. His Academy
continued in existence until AD 529, when it was closed by the Byzantine emperor Justinian I
for conflicting with Christianity.
ACTIVITY II
1. Plato invented the word ‘philosophy’ although he was not the first philosopher.
How would you reconcile these?
2. The academy of Plato is regarded as the first university, and it existed for about
800 years. Discuss what this tells us about the figure of the founder.
3. How would you sum up the real import of the philosophy of Plato?
4. What are the main educational ideas of Plato?
21
MODULE TWO Great Athenian Educators (PDE- 101)
brief excerpts have survived. Still in existence, however, is a substantial body of unpublished
writings, usually taken to be the material on which courses in the Lyceum were based.
The range of Aristotle’s interest was vast, covering most of the sciences and many of the arts.
He worked in physics, chemistry, biology, zoology, and botany; in psychology, political
theory, and ethics; in logic and metaphysics; in history, literary theory, and rhetoric. His
greatest achievements were in two distinct areas: he invented the study of formal logic,
devising for it a finished system, known as Aristotelians syllogistic; and he pioneered the
study of zoology, both observational and theoretical, in which his work was not surpassed
until the 19th century.
Even though Aristotle’s zoology is now out-of –date and his thought in the other natural
sciences has long been left behind, his importance as a scientist is unequalled. But it is now
of purely historical importance: he, like other scientists of the past, is not read by his
successors. As a philosopher Aristotle is equally stupendous; and is still very much consulted
today. Although his syllogistic is now recognised to be only a small part of formal logic, his
writings in ethical and political theory as well as in metaphysics and in the philosophy of
science are read and argued over by modern philosophers. Aristotle’s historical importance is
second to none, and his work remains a powerful component in current philosophical debate.
As for his contributions to education, Aristotle was in agreement with his master Plato on the
division of education into stages, from the lowest to the highest. However, he clearly
disagreed with the communistic stance Plato proposed. He thought that Plato’s ideas were
too ideal to be practical since it would involve indoctrinating both parents and children in
order to make the system work. As a departure from Plator’s ideas, he proposed freedom in
education, that everybody should be given the opportunity to develop his talents to the fullest
of his capacity.
He believed that the mind of the child was like pliable clay, which could be molded into any
desired shape. Education it is that should do this. The ultimate goal of human existence
should be individual happiness and this education should aim at. Education should enhance a
person’s reasoning capability, making him a wise individual that lives a good moral life.
Teachers should thus strive to enable a learner achieve all these ideals in a person. We could
end this section by asserting that Aristotle was one of the great thinkers who believed in the
importance of teachers in society.
ACTIVITY III
1. How would you justify the claim that Aristotle was a great generalist?
2. In what significant ways did Aristotle depart from his teacher Plato?
3. Discuss the main educational ideas of Aristotle.
4. How would you rate the contributions of Aristotle among the trio of Socrates,
Plato and Aristotle?
22
MODULE TWO Great Athenian Educators (PDE- 101)
SUMMARY
In this unit, we have examined very briefly the lives and contributions of the trio of the Greek
philosophers, Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle. In the process, we found that:
• Socrates was the teacher of Plato, who himself was the teacher of Aristotle.
• While not being a typical Sophist, Socrates adopted the techniques of the Sophists to a
large extent. He adopted a style of engaging his listener in argument from the stance
of one who is ignorant. But in the process of the argument, using a series of
questions, he led his listener to realise that he (the listener) was really ignorant and
needed to find out more. Thus, today the questioning technique is referred to as the
Socratic Method.
• Plato wrote profusely, in most instances referring to the experiences and teaching of
Socrates. Through his writings, especially through the greatest of his books, The
Republic, we gather that the state, like a person, is constituted of three parts: the id,
the ego, and the super-ego. He affirmed that the super-ego should rule the id and the
ego, and at the state level that the philosophers should rule the state while others
should be channeled into vocations for which their ability is suited. He thus
advocated a state-run life-long education scheme through which the various
individuals could be prepared for their roles in the state.
• Aristotle in his monumental contributions to learning wrote very many books, many
of which are still consulted. He agreed with many of Plato’s principles but disagreed
with a communistic type of state-run education. He was the first great biologist and
contributed to virtually all other science disciplines.
REFERENCE
Bowel, J. & p. Hobson (1974) Theories of Education. London: John Wiley and Sons, Ltd.
The CD version of Encyclopedia Britannica, Inc. – 1994 – 2001.
Microsoft Corporation. The CD version of Encarta Reference Library 1993 – 2001
Microsoft Corporation.
Osokoya, I.O. (1989) History and Policy of Nigerian Education in World Perspective.
Ibadan: AMD Publishers.
23
MODULE TWO Great Athenian Educators (PDE- 101)
OBJECTIVES
At the end of this unit, students should be able to:
1. discuss the significant phases of the Roman system of education;
2. analyse the influence of Greek education on Roman education system;
3. discuss what our own system can learn from the Roman system of education.
BACKGROUND
In the ancient Mediterranean world, the two civilizations that dominated others like
colossuses were Rome and Greece. In military terms, these two civilizations swept through
the Mediterranean world, although not at the same time, imposing their culture and ways of
life on countries they subjugated. The first to so dominate others was Greece, under
Alexander the Great, the young Macedonian king who, on discovering that there were no
other states to fight and conquer, burst into tears. He died at the age of 33 years, leaving the
immense territories to other less militarily competent leaders. In time, the empire
disintegrated like a pack of cards. Shortly afterwards, the Romans under great military
leaders like Pompey and Caesar, swept across the whole of the then known world, including
the present Great Britain.
With Rome now as the masters of the world, i.e. with Greece as one of its subject states, one
would have thought that Rome would be in a position to impose its civilization and
educational system on Greece. But the reverse was the case. Rome, it turned out, had no
educational system as such to pass on to Greece. Rather, it was Greece that had to pass on its
system to Rome.
Roman education before the advent of the Greeks
We need to understand a few fundamental things about the traditional Roman sequel to the
coming of the Greek influence. The first significant fact was that traditional Romans were
predominantly agrarian, mostly farmers. Thus, much of the education for boys was geared
towards farming. This involved learning about farming itself as well as farm management
and direction of slaves in the farm work.
The second is that the family was the centre of life to the Roman. To this extent, the father
and the mother matter much and they it was that handled the education of the youth, at least
up to the age of 16 years when the boy was considered to have become a man. As the head of
the family, the father was held in very high esteem and therefore had a great role to play in
educating the child. Indeed, as Osokoya (1989), himself quoting Barclay (1959) claims, the
father had the power of life and death of the child, and indeed, when a child was born, it was
laid at the feet of the father. If the father picked up the child, he was demonstrating that the
child was truly his; but if he turned away he was claiming that he had no hand in its
conception and so the child was taken away to be killed. Both the father and the mother had
a hand in the education of their child and indeed, the role of the mother extended beyond the
24
MODULE TWO Great Athenian Educators (PDE- 101)
early years and was indeed life long. In most cases, boys followed the vocations of their
fathers while in rich families boys went to important functions, including state affairs, with
their fathers. This way, a senator’s son, for instance, started to take interest in and indeed
learn the affairs of the state.
Third is the fact that as opposed to the Greek education that was oriented towards the
chivalry, as extolled in the poems of Homer, Roman education was geared to extol an
unquestioned respect for the customs of their ancestors. We should bear it in mind that the
traditional Romans were worshippers of very many gods, many of them family gods. Thus,
the Roman child was brought up to respect and learn about these ancestral figures. At the
larger level, the youth was taught to give this loyalty and devotion to the state and were
taught to revere great national ancestors. The interests of the state were supreme. The ideal
set before youth was that of the great men of history who, in difficult situations, had by their
courage and their wisdom saved the fatherland when it was in danger.
Fourth, and perhaps as carry-over from the last point, ‘education had a strong moral aspect,
aiming at inculcating rural virtues, a respect for good management of one’s patrimony, and a
sense of austerity and frugality. Even sons of nobles were taught to live a prudent life rather
live like young lords, while those of commoners were taught to make the best of whatever
they had.
Finally, although Rome was a nation of small farmers, it was equally a nation of soldiers.
Physical straining was very much a part of the boys’ education. This was oriented not
towards self-realization or competitive sport but towards military preparedness. Boys were
trained in the functions and use of arms, while exercises meant to tough of the body and the
mind were embarked upon, e.g. swimming across cold and rapid streams, horsemanship,
involving such performances as mounted acrobatics and cavalry parades under arms.
The education at home for boys ended at 16. This was when the youth was regarded as
having come of age. He had become a man, and a ceremony was held for this. Henceforth
he would wear an adult’s dress, the pure white woolen toga virilis. Thereafter, he would
devote one year to an apprenticeship in public life, no longer at his father’s side but under the
care of an old family friend, an elderly man advanced in politics and highly respected.
Then followed service in the military. Military service commenced, first as an ordinary
soldier during which he learnt to be commanded and to obey orders. He was in the process
introduced into real battle, thus given an opportunity to distinguish himself by courage. Soon
thereafter, he functioned as a staff officer under some distinguished commander. Real career
has commenced.
Whether in civil or military life, however, the Roman was to regard the family as the focal
point of his life. When he had fully weaned himself from his parents, he had his own family
which now constituted the centre of his life.
25
MODULE TWO Great Athenian Educators (PDE- 101)
ACTIVITY I
1. Discuss the major differences between traditional Roman education and that of the
Athenians.
2. In what ways are the traditional Roman education and that of Nigerian traditional
communities similar?
3. Discuss the statement that it was possible for the Roman citizen to rise to the
highest position in society without being able to read and write.
4. There is a slight inference in the write-up that the average Roman family had
slaves. Discuss where these slaves were likely to have come from, and the
circumstances that made this possible.
26
MODULE TWO Great Athenian Educators (PDE- 101)
teachers actually taught in Greek, which had become a sort of an international language.
Indeed, it was claimed that some Roman children were able to speak the Greek language
before being able to speak the Latin language, that is, in homes where the Greek
slaves/teachers actually brought up the children. In time, there was another development –
children were actually sent to Greece to lean! It was light going abroad to receive
enlightenment.
In time, Rome fully adopted Greek education. Thus, a Roman was considered truly refined
only when he had the same education, in Greek, which a native Greek had. On the other
hand, there progressively developed a parallel system of instruction that transposed into Latin
the institutions, programmes, and methods of Greek education. Of course, as we can expect,
only the children of the nobles had the privilege of receiving the complete and bilingual
education. The result of the bilingual education was that an enlightened Roman could
operate in the two leading languages of the world, and indeed many educated Romans wrote
well in the two languages.
There were of course significant modifications and adaptations. For instance, the Romans,
rather shocked by Greek athleticism, did not adopt this aspect without serious modification.
Thus, while gymnastic exercises entered into their daily life, it was under the category of
health and that of sport – so it was like studying the theory but not practicing it. Similarly, on
moral grounds, music and dance were not adopted totally, they being reserved for slaves and
not for freeborn.
With time, what had blossomed at the level of individual families soon became a state affair.
Schools were soon started on a formal level, mostly for sons and daughters of the nobles.
This was a result of social pressure, since most families wanted education. Thus, as in
Greece, public education developed at three levels: elementary, secondary and higher,
although these did not emanate at just the same time.
Osokoya recognizes these as ludus, grammaticus, and rhetoric schools. The ludus, meaning
‘play’ in Latin, is like an infant school where children learn mostly through play. It is the
equivalent of our own primary school, and specializes in the teaching of the 3R’s, i.e.
reading, writing and arithmetic, whose teaching relied very much on the abacus.
The grammaticus, is the equivalent of our own grammar school, or the secondary school.
Children entered at the age of 12 and attended school for about three or four years, learning
reading, writing, poetry, arithmetic. The grammar taught was that of Greek. The subjects
taught were most utilitarian, not liberal. The dominance of Greek remained for a long time
until Cicero, the famous Roman poet and orator, advocated that Latin should be used for
educating Roman children.
Higher education was available in rhetoric schools. Here, mature learners studied history,
philosophy, literature, science and some other subjects. Most of these were geared towards
producing orators, since statecraft which was the ultimate aim of most people required a lot
of oratory. Rhetoric schools were run mostly by Greek teachers in Rome or were available
by sending learners straight to Greece.
Is this system not similar to what obtained in Nigeria for a long time, where for so long a time
we had teachers from abroad for both the secondary and tertiary levels and many people
27
MODULE TWO Great Athenian Educators (PDE- 101)
simply went abroad to receive higher education? This is just one of the areas of comparison;
you should be able to recognize many other areas.
ACTIVITY II
1. Discuss the real meaning and implications of the statement credited to Horace.
2. Why did the writer claim that the Romans were large-hearted in adopting Greek
education after having conquered the Greeks?
3. Trace the development of Greek education in Rome from the family level to the
state level.
4. Describe the three levels of education in ancient Rome.
28
MODULE TWO Great Athenian Educators (PDE- 101)
OBJECTIVES
At the end of this unit, students should be able to:
1. discuss the significant phases of the Roman system of education;
2. analyse the influence of Greek education on Roman education system;
3. discuss what our own system can learn from the Roman system of education.
BACKGROUND
It is significant that Rome, which readily embraced the superior educational system of Greece
after overcoming the latter, should produce a number of intellectuals whose works have
continued to influence the shaping of ideas over the ages. One of these is a man called
Marcus Fabius Quintilianus, known to the present world simply as Quintilian. Who was this
man? What were his ideas? In what ways have they been of importance over the ages?
These, and some other related issues form the focus of this unit.
Quintilian’s contributions
A great man of letters, Quintilian left to posterity a voluminous book publication in 12 books.
Entitled Insstitutio oratoria, (or, ‘The Training of an Orator’) it was published shortly before
the end of his life. The Institutio was the fruit of Quintilian’s wide practical experience as a
teacher. According to him, his purpose was not to invent new theories of rhetoric but to
judge between existing ones. He stressed that he was conscious of the fact that theoretical
knowledge alone is of little use without experience and good judgment. Although not
primarily a book on how to bring up and educate a child, that in effect is its main import. The
main basis of his argument through the book is that the entire process of a child’s education
was the determining factor for his training and career as an orator. (Realise that the word
‘orator’ by then meant more than just a good speaker but also a statesman). In Book I, he
dealt with the stages of a boy’s education before entering the school of oratory. In Book II,
he discussed the boy’s career through the school of oratory. These two form the foundation
of the long work. They also contain his general observations on educational principles, some
of which are still valid today.
ACTIVITY I
1. According to the writer here, what does the fact that Quintilian was able to
produce such a significant work tell us about the attitude of Romans to education
borrowed from the Greeks?
2. Quintilian was trained as a legal practitioner, not a teacher; yet he was able to
write about the education of a youth. What does this tell us about the system of
education in that era? What does it also tell us about the man himself?
3. The meaning of the word ‘orator’ has changed over the time. What does it mean
then and what does it mean now?
29
MODULE TWO Great Athenian Educators (PDE- 101)
The greatest part of the work, from Books III to XI are on the five ‘departments’ of rhetoric;
these are invention, arrangement, style, memory, and delivery. He also dealt with the nature,
origin, value, and function of rhetoric as well as with the different types of oratory. He gave
far greater attention to forensic oratory, the type used in legal proceedings than to other types.
This should not be surprising, given that he was a legal person. In Book X, he discussed the
great Greek and Latin authors, praising their contributions and recommending them to
younger orators. Finally, in book XII, he dealt with the ideal orator in action, after training:
his character, the rules that he should follow in argument, the style of his eloquence, etc.
The main import of the work to educational practice is the emphasis on the moral training of
the orator. Throughout, his purpose was to mould the student’s character as well as to
develop his mind. He held that, first and most important, a good orator must be a good
citizen, who lives a virtuous life. This is the most crucial, no matter how eloquent he might
be. Second, he stressed that the orator should be a thoroughly professional, competent and
successful public speaker. To this end, the student should be carefully and thoroughly
prepared for this task. It would appear that he believed that the more careful the training of a
student was, the more successful he was likely to be as a practitioner.
He had some severe criticism for some of the teachers of his day for encouraging superficial
cleverness of style. This would seem to apply today to those teachers who were very clever
in looking competent without really mastering the subject matter, teachers who impressed
their learners without really contributing much to their mastery of the subject. According to
him, while this type of cleverness might give an immediate effect, at least in the eyes of their
pupils, he stressed that they in the long run did not help the future orator.
He believed that teachers should not unduly hasten their students. So, while teachers could
encourage their students to produce their best, they should at the same time let them go on at
their pace. He supported individuality and individual attention, and recommended that
students should be encouraged to find out on their own through self effort.
He was against corporal punishment, claiming that it was greatly counter-productive. He
stressed that the whipping a learner in effect generates fear in him, fear for the teacher as well
as fear about the subject matter. Besides, when a teacher has used the method, subsequent
recourse to it becomes ineffective – since the learner would have lost the fear originally
entertained. Against this, the writes, “Pupils,” he writes, “If rightly instructed regard their
teacher with affection and respect. And it is scarcely possible to say how much more
willingly we imitate those we like.” What does this imply? It implies that with the right
approach, a learner would develop a genuine and natural respect for the teacher whom he
would love to imitate.
In all, the greatest lesson we as teachers learn from Quintilian is that the student should be
brought up first and foremost as a law abiding, morally sound person, over and above his
intellectual competence although this too is very crucial.
30
MODULE TWO Great Athenian Educators (PDE- 101)
ACTIVITY II
1. Analyse the various characteristics of the young learner as specified by
Quintilian?
2. Which of these would you say are still valid to recommend today?
3. What is your own attitude towards corporal punishment as a teacher? Give
studied reasons for your stand.
31
MODULE TWO Great Athenian Educators (PDE- 101)
OBJECTIVES
At the end of this unit, students should be able to:
1. discuss the development of education in the middle ages, i.e. the period 500 – 1500
AD;
2. identify Educational institutions in the Middle Ages and their role in the development
of education during the period;
3. trace the founding and development of Universities in Europe during the Medieval
period and beyond, spanning the modern period and their changing roles.
BACKGROUND
From early in the Christian era, the spread of education continued rapidly across the continent
of Europe. We would be correct to say that with the spread of Christianity and growing
trade, education also continued to spread across the length of the continent. But then, the
coming of the Barbarians reversed what would otherwise have been a positive development.
For the Barbarians destroyed most of what they found in the lands they occupied. The
Barbarian invasions started sometime around AD 259 in the present day Switzerland and
continued to spread progressively across the continent for about the next two hundred yhears.
During those dark years, (actually referred to in history as the ‘dark ages’) much of the
learning and scholarship that had been built up were destroyed or suppressed. The only
flickers of light were to be found in the Catholic monasteries, the Jewish temples and among
the Arabs. There it was that the monks continued to hold up the light of knowledge, passing
on whatever knowledge there was from one unsteady era to another. This way it was until
the beginning of the Middle Ages (usually referred to as the renaissance).
32
MODULE TWO Great Athenian Educators (PDE- 101)
members of the higher and educated classes. This group of people wanted as good a type of
education for their children as they themselves had. These obtained their education from the
few available, Greco-Roman, non-Christian, grammar and rhetoric schools.
This trend put the Christians in a sort of dilemma. Here were institutions that were purely
secular and which did not teach their ethics and whose teachings in some cases conflicted
with the stand of the church. Several Christian leaders were opposed to sending youths to
school, but there were others too who felt that there was nothing wrong in doing nso, and
some indeed who felt that there was no real conflict between the stand of the church and the
knowledge taught in the Greco-Roman institutions. In the vast majority of cases, the choice
was to seek knowledge wherever it could be found. Things became much better when the
Christians themselves started the catechetical schools, the most notable of which was in
Alexandria in Egypt. Others too followed, and with time, it was not just religious education
that was given as the curriculum was soon much broadened. However, during most of the
early centuries AD, up till the middle of the middle ages, there were no universities, which
would be surprising since Plato had founded one century earlier and which was destroyed
during this period. For the founding of the modern universities, the world had to wait until
about the end of the first millennium AD.
ACTIVITY I
1. How did the coming of the Barbarians influence the spread of knowledge?
2. In what ways did the Christian monasteries help to preserve and spread education?
Suggest why they did these.
3. Suggest reasons why the early Christians could not help the spread of education as
much as they would have liked.
33
MODULE TWO Great Athenian Educators (PDE- 101)
The universities of Paris and Oxford were composed of colleges, which were actually
endowed residence halls for scholars. These early universities received their charters from
popes, emperors, and kings. They were free to govern themselves, so long as they taught
neither atheism nor heresy. Students and masters together elected their own rectors. As the
price of independence, however, universities had to finance themselves. So teachers charged
fees from students, whom themselves had a lot of power in the governance of the university.
Universities in those days had no permanent buildings, nor did they have substantial
corporate property. Besides, they could lose their students to other universities if the students
were for any reason dissatisfied. This was how the University of Cambridge began in 1209
when a number of dissatisfied students moved there from Oxford; and 20 years later Oxford
in turn profited by a migration of students from the University of Paris.
From the 13th century, i.e. from AD 1200, universities were established in many of Europe’s
principal cities. Thus, we had universities springing up in Montpellier (1220), Aix-en-
Provence (1409) both in France; in Padua (1222), Rome (1303), and Florence (1321) all in
Italy; at Salamanca (1218) in Spain, at Prague (1348) and Vienna (1365) in central Europe, at
Heidelberg (1386), Leipzig (1409), Freiburg (1457), and Tubingen (1477) in what is now
Germany, at Louvain (1425) in present-day Belgium, and at Saint Adrews (1411) and
Glasgow (1451) in Scotland.
ACTIVITY II
1. The writer states that the Catholic Church itself was stimulated in the founding of
the first universities by the contacts they had with the Arabs, presumably
Moslems. Discuss what this tells us of the nature of knowledge.
2. The medical school in Salerno is not given the full title of a university. Why?
3. Discuss what the writer means by referring to the Universities in Oxford and Paris
as being made up of colleges.
4. Some of the universities in Europe, according to this account are older than the
first university in Africa by about 1,000. What does this tell us about the
differences between the two continents?
For so long, till late in the 18th century, the curriculum in most universities included the seven
liberal arts: grammar, logic, rhetoric, geometry, arithmetic, astronomy, and music. After the
initial studies, students then proceeded to one of the professional faculties of medicine, law,
and theology. Final examinations were arduous and taxing; so many students failed. During
the Protestant Reformation of the 16th century and the ensuing Counter-Reformation the
ongoing struggles affected the curriculum and administration of the universities in several
ways. In the countries which became staunch Protestants, the universities became Protestant
while some new Protestant universities were founded. In some cases, those nations which
remained Catholic resisted change, especially in the sciences. There, the new learning was
discouraged, and thus many universities underwent a period of relative decline.
34
MODULE TWO Great Athenian Educators (PDE- 101)
The founding of new universities continued during this time. Among these were the ones at
Edinburgh (1583), Leiden (1575), and Strasbourg (1621). The first modern university was at
Halle, founded by Lutherans in 1694. It was a progressive-minded school, the first to
renounce religious orthodoxy of any kind, preferring instead to pursue a rational and
objective intellectual inquiry. It was the first where lectures were in German (i.e., a
vernacular language) rather than in Latin. The innovations were later adopted in the
university of Gottingen, founded 1737, and subsequently by most German and many
American universities.
In the later 18th and 19th centuries, religion was gradually replaced with secular curriculum
and objective pursuit of knowledge, as the universities became institutions of modern
learning and research. Typical in these trends was the University of Berlin (1809), in which
laboratory experimentation replaced conjecture; theological, philosophical, and other
traditional doctrines were examined with anew rigour and objectivity; and modern standards
of academic freedom became the norm. The typical German university was thus one that
embraced several graduate schools specialising in advanced research and experimentation.
Across the Atlantic, in the new world, the first universities were established by the Spaniards.
These were the University of Santo Domingo (1538) in what is now the Dominican Republic
and the University of Michoacan (1540) in Mexico. The earliest institutions of higher
learning in the USA were in Harvard (1636), William and Mary (1693), Yale (1701),
Princeton (1746), and King’s College 1754; now Columbia). Most of these were established
by the religious denominations, and most eventually evolved into full-fledged universities.
ACTIVITY III
1. Consider the seven commonest subjects in the curriculum of that period.
Comment on this curriculum vis-à-vis that of today.
2. Discuss the ways in which the reformation and counter-reformation affected the
growth of universities.
3. Consider the fact that for along time, indeed for centuries, universities in Europe
continued to use Latin as the medium of instruction until the German universities
started a new trend of using their own national language. Discuss this in the light
of developments in Nigerian universities.
4. Discuss the roles which you would want to see Nigerian universities performing
in national development.
35
MODULE TWO Great Athenian Educators (PDE- 101)
OBJECTIVES
At the end of this unit, you should be able to:
1. identify some of those great educators who have influenced the course of learning
over the centuries;
2. discuss their significant contributions to our present day educational practices;
3. discuss what each classroom practitioner can learn from each of them.
BACKGROUND
The practice of education has passed through several phases over the course of time. Each
theory of education did not just get there by chance; rather one or the other of the great
educators has proposed it, borne out of experience, and others have found it worth practicing.
Some of the educators had to work closely with young learners, observing them at play and at
work, and through this were able to formulate theories, which have stood the test of time.
Some of them were great psychologists, some great philosophers, and some in some other
walks of life which had to do with learning. What we can confidently say was common to
them all was their love for learning and for learners, their concern for human progress.
There are scores of them, but we cannot possibly take on all of them ina publication of this
nature. We have carefully selected just seven of them, selected not because these were the
greatest there were, but in a way to reflect a different age during the period from the 14th
century to the 19th century. As you read and learn about each of them, notice carefully how
each of them lived and developed, what theory each of them proposed, and with what result.
You have to read actively, i.e. you should read with your mind open, questioning each of the
educators’ viewpoints, asking yourself how valid that point is.
Vittorino da Feltre (1378 – 1440)
Vittorino was an Italian born in the town of Feltre in 1378. Considered the greatest humanist
schoolmaster of the Renaissance because of his dedication to the teaching profession, he was
educated in Padua University where he also became a lecturer. In 1423, he was asked to
become a tutor to the children of the wealthy Gonzaga family, the rulers of Mantua. He
accepted on one condition: that he would found a school for the children of the family as well
as for other children, away from the palace. He started that school and called it the ‘House of
Joy’. Apart from the royal children, there were some other 60 children.
He operated a fairly wide curriculum, which included the languages and literature of Rome
and Greece, arithmetic, geometry, music, physical education, introduced on the basis of the
Greek ideal of the development of the body and mind. He believed in education as
promoting a Christian way of life. Thus, he believed in, and practiced, love for his pupils for
whom he had never used corporal punishment. He believed in individual attention and the
adaptation of the teaching to the level of the learner. He held that the teacher should care for
the health and all round needs of learner. His school, apart from educating children of nobles
36
MODULE TWO Great Athenian Educators (PDE- 101)
and poor alike, also taught future rulers and professionals; he taught Latin to Greek to
scholars from the East so that they were able to translate Greek works, making them available
to more people. Thus, through him, knowledge was spread far and wide.
37
MODULE TWO Great Athenian Educators (PDE- 101)
ACTIVITY I
1. If you were to propound a theory of teaching and learning, what are the necessary
conditions and procedures that this would entail before it comes into reality?
2. Suggest reasons why Vittorino insisted that his school should be founded away
from the palace.
3. The issue of corporal punishment is contentious today. What is your opinion
about it? Give reasons for your stand.
Jean-Jacques Rousseau
Born in 1712, Rousseau was rather unique in the sense that he was of Swiss, French and
Italian background, although born and brought up in Switzerland. His mother died shortly
after he was born, so his watchmaker father brought him up. He had no education for many
years until his father fled Geneva to Nyon and placed him in the care of a pastor. Even then,
his education was not of regular type we are familiar with today. In the main, he received his
education mostly incidentally from the people he lived or worked with. We can say that this
was a man mostly self educated, becoming a great musician, a writer, and an idealist. As far
38
MODULE TWO Great Athenian Educators (PDE- 101)
as education is concerned, Rousseau would be reckoned with as the writer of the Emile, a
treatise in the form of a novel.
Through this work, he made the case clearly that the ideal education is one offered byu
nature, i.e. that a person would be best educated without really learning from books or in a
formal school setting. He argued that one should protect the child from the corruption of
civilization. To him, nature was the best teacher and to learn form it was to avoid the
unhealthy traits associated with modern civilization. He held that the young learner, in this
case ‘Emile’, should be saved from any contact with books until the age of 12. The book
showed rousseau as a proponent of physical education.
He argued in the book that feelings should come before thinking, and that the child should be
controlled not by adults’ wishes but by things around him, that the child is not a miniature
adult who should be judged with adults’ yardsticks. He stressed that each child is an
individual that is different from any other child and should be understood and treated as such.
Therefore, the curriculum to be used for the child should reflect the interest and standards of
the child rather than revolve around the interest of the adult world. In teaching the child, the
state of its readiness for learning should be taken into account.
Rousseau believed in discovery, especially from the environment, through a process of
problem-solving. He believed that a good teacher should study the child he is teaching and
seek to understand him thoroughly. An all, we can realize that Rousseau’s ideas do conform
to very thorough psychological principles.
ACTIVITY II
1. In what ways the contributions of John Locke and Rousseau are they similar?
2. Discuss what Joh Locke owes to Comenius.
3. What is ‘Emile’ all about?
39
MODULE TWO Great Athenian Educators (PDE- 101)
Pestalozzi believed that ‘The art of education must be significantly raised in all its facets to
become a science that is to be built on and proceeds from the deepest knowledge of human
nature. By this he meant that the business was serious enough to be taken very seriously and
studied thoroughly and conscientiously. To this end, created a new methodology for
elementary education which was introduced into teacher education both in Europe and
America. He, through his personal example, gave teachers a new philosophy for their
profession. He stimulated teaching and learning theory and practice to a very great extent.
He was particularly a supporter of the poor and took various measures to help the poor to
learn. He was much distressed by the extent of the misery existing in the world and advanced
ideas that this should be altered. His bid to help the poor tallies neatly with his ideas on
ending the misery around us, mostly through an improved educational system.
Unfortunately, most people of his time thought of him as merely a theorist, although at the
same time he had a lot of following.
John Herbert
John Herbert was born in 1776 in Germany. He was a philosopher of the Realism school of
philosophy and an educator who was considered one of the founders of modern scientific
pedagogy. Like Froebel, he was also acquainted with Pestalozzi from whom he must have
definitely learnt a few ideas. He was for several years a professor of philosophy in the
University of Konigsberg and later of Gottingen. His standing as a philosopher is due mainly
to his contributions to the philosophy of mind, on which he wrote several books.
It was in line with his philosophical theories and ideas that he developed a theory of
education as a branch of applied psychology. His theories of education, which were later to
be known as Herbartianism, were set out in two books. In these, he advocated five formal
steps in teaching which are summarised here:
40
MODULE TWO Great Athenian Educators (PDE- 101)
(1) preparation, which is a process of relating new materials to be learned to relevant past
ideas so as to give the pupil a vital interest in the topic;
(2) presentation, i.e. the process of presenting new material by means of concrete objects
or actual experience;
(3) association, thorough assimilation of the new idea through comparison with earlier
held ideas and consideration of their similarities and differences in order to implant
the new idea in the mind;
(4) generation, which is a procedure especially important to the instruction of adolescents
and which is designed to develop the mind beyond the level of insight and the
concrete; and
(5) application, i.e. using acquired knowledge not in a purely utilitarian way, but in a way
that every learned idea becomes a part of the functional mind and for every day
purposes. This step will be possible only if the student immediately applies the new
idea, making it his own.
Herbart held that a scientific study of education was possible, and that education should be a
subject for university study. His ideas were accepted in Germany in the 1860s and later
spread also to the United States. By 1900, however, the five steps had become less important
in the light of new theories.
ACTIVITY III
1. Discuss the specific contributions to education of Pestalozzi.
2. What does each of Frobel and Herbart owe to Pestalozzi?
3. Discuss the current worth of Herbart’s five steps in teaching.
41
MODULE TWO Great Athenian Educators (PDE- 101)
individuals had more intimate contact with the natural environment and this made learning
easier and meaningful. Not only that, the sense of community which took place in rural life
Dewey found out was more favourable to learning and human life than the extreme formality
and individuality that is the lot of urban life. Dewey transferred these key ideas to education
by claiming that if the school is to play any useful social function it must encourage such
contact with the natural environment as well as promote a sense of community.
John Dewey was also influenced by the type of problems and difficulties he thought people
faced in America at the time. He realized that to survive in a world of pressing problems
such as the one he grew up in, one needed to be resourceful, energetic and practical. These
concrete conditions were reinforced with ideas gained from Charles Peirce and William
James, Dewey improved upon the philosophy of pragmatism.
Dewey believed that the educational process has two sides, psychological and social, and
neither can be subordinated or neglected. On the psychological side, he maintained that
because learning depends on the psychological nature of the child, teachers must explore the
child’s nature, needs and interests in teaching. But even more than this is his believe that
genuine education is only possible through the participating of the individual in interactive
relationships with others. This made him to have faith in the project method of teaching.
Socially, he held that the school is never an institution which is separate from the outer
society. Rather, it is continuous with it. In this regard whatever is taught in schools must
draw from and illuminate experiences which learners have at home.
It is this belief in the indissoluble link between school and society that Dewey believed the
school must be a formative agency for the sustenance of democratic civilization. To achieve
this goal, he saw the teaching of civic and vocational education as guarantee. The school,
according to him can only achieve this social function if it is set as a democratic institution
whereby the values of co-operation are fostered both in teaching and in living.
An area where Dewey seems to exert the greatest influence is in his pedagogy. He criticized
formal methods which begin with definitions and in which teachers present materials from
their points of view. According to him the most useful methods are those which engage
pupils in active work. It is only after this that teaching can be organized. Always keeping the
learner at the centre of the educational process, he believed that teachers should not set out
with definite aims, nor schools do the same. He believed that education cannot have aims
because such aims are always external to the process of educating. In his opinion education
can only be conceived as the constant reconstruction of experience rather as a process of
transmission or of getting already synthesized knowledge. In this way past knowledge is
only useful as a tool in reconstructing experience or in overcoming a present problem.
42
MODULE TWO Great Athenian Educators (PDE- 101)
ACTIVITY III
1. Discuss the relationship between the social conditions Dewey grew up in and the
educational ideas he developed.
2. To what extent do you think Dewey’s educational ideas are useful in the Nigerian
system?
3. Discuss the implications of the psychological and social sides of the educative
process, according to Dewey.
43
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
INTRODUCTION:
The prime place of education in the developmental effort of nations has never been doubted
the world over. Various nations, including Nigeria, have for long been making effort to
develop this sector for optimal development. Although, much has been achieved in this
regard, a lot more needs to be done so that the ever-increasing challenges of our time and the
time to come can be most effectively confronted.
In Nigeria, for example, the challenges have been that of poverty, disease, hunger, illiteracy
and general underdevelopment. How we are able to tackle these problems will reflect on the
value and commitment we attach to education, which according to Professor Baikie “is the
biggest industry that touches on every fabric of our human endeavour”.
This unit is intended to acquaint you with the trends of the indigenous educational system in
Nigeria and how it was used as a vehicle for development. It will also reflect on the
relevance of traditional education in solving the numerous problems confronting our society.
In short, there is no doubting the fact that the traditional educational system is still considered
very vital in addressing the complex value systems of the present times.
In a nutshell, the unit treats the nature, scope and process of the traditional education in
Nigeria and how it was and is still being used to serve the purpose for which its adherents use
it.
OBJECTIVES
At the end of this unit, you should be able to:
1. explain the nature and scope of traditional education system in Nigeria;
2. describe the processes involved in the transmission of traditional education system;
3. examine the potency of traditional educational system (past and present); and
4. discuss how traditional education system could be effectively used to foster
meaningful development in the Nigeria nation.
44
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
45
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
medicine men, fishermen, warriors, carpenters, orators, spiritualists, weavers, carvers and
many more who are tested to be highly skilled in their different calling.\
ACTIVITY 1
1. Carefully identify and discuss the goals of traditional system of education in Nigeria.
2. Assess the relevance of the traditional goals of education in the context of the present
day Nigeria
3. Enumerate and discuss the nature and scope of traditional education in Nigeria.
The means (process) employed to attain the goals mentioned above is mostly through a
combination of theory and practice. Children learn the history of great men and women from
folklores and stories narrated by the elderly members of the society. Good virtues such as
valour, honesty, wisdom, respect for elders and oracy are either directly or indirectly
imparted from the stories.
The vocational training starts right from the early stage of children’s life when they begin to
follow their parents to the farms, rivers, forests, blacksmithing and weaving shops to learn the
occupations of their forebears.
Basically, there are four (4) processes through which cultural heritage are transmitted from
generation to generation in a typical traditional set up. These are:
46
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
(i) Indoctrination: Good virtues and values are handed down to the children through
different means possible. They are dogmas that cannot be compromised or
questioned.
(ii) Imitation: Children learn the skills and norms by copying what they see their elders
do.
(iii) Training: Children receive informal training to acquire skills, attitudes and values
that will make them fit to live in the society is equally through the apprenticeship
system.
(iv) Initiation: After receiving training, children are introduced to certain modes of
behaviour that are considered acceptable by the group they belong to. This is usually
marked by fanfare and ceremony at an appointed time in the community. Cultural
rites and practices are usually observed during initiation.
ACTIVITY 2
47
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
of values, attitudes and skills that would enable children to be useful members of the
society. The functionality of the traditional education system has never been doubted.
The system has produced skill oriented community members whose contributions to
the betterment of living are still being felt even now. This will continue to be
experienced as long as the values of the society remain treasured, and that the process
of acquisition of these values remains adequate.
• The essence of examining the past is truly reflected in the history of traditional
education in Nigeria, in that a lot of the aspirations of the National Policy on
Education and the discourses going on among educationists centre around those
values conceived by the traditional past. And this kind of thinking will continue to be
the same most likely till the world comes to an end. The purpose may continue to be
the same with some modifications in the process as time dictates.
ASSIGNMENT
Undertake a case study of your immediate community with a view to identifying the goals of
the traditional education system of the community, the nature and the process of education in
the community. You should then compare your findings with the content of the National
Policy on Education. Did you notice any differences? Write your findings and submit to
your Course Facilitator.
REFERENCES
Baikie, A (2002) Recurrent lessons in Nigeria Education, Tamaza Publishing Company
Ltd., Zaria, Nigeria.
Fafunwa, A (1974), History of Education in Nigeria, George Allen & Unwin, UK.
Ozigi, A & Ocho, L (1981), Education in Northern Nigeria, George Allen & Unwin,
London.
48
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
INTRODUCTION
The education that preceded the Islamic education system in Nigeria was the traditional
system as you have learnt in the previous unit. The traditional system of education has been
proven to be a potent and functional means through which societal lores and norms are
transmitted from generation to generation. You have also learnt that the system allows for
the inculcation of positive values, skills and attitudes that prepare individuals to become
useful members of their respective communities. The system is still found to be relevant in
offering solutions to the multi-faceted problems of the present day complex Nigeria.
The advent of Islam and Islamic type of education in Nigeria did not altogether condemn the
hitherto existing education of the people. Rather, it has sought to consolidate those aspects of
the beliefs and practices of the people that emphasized such virtues as valour, tolerance,
respect for others, dignity of labour and unity of purpose.
You will learn from this unit how Islamic education has been used as a vehicle for spiritual
re-awakening and social rejuvenation of the people whose belief-systems were rooted in
superstitions and hearsays. The Islamic system of education is found on the divine
revelations from Allah (S.A.W), which deals with norms and etiquettes of life for the
Muslims. The Islamic divine message is contained in the Islamic Holy Book called “Al-
Qur’an” and it is further expatiated by the “Ahadith” (sayings and practices) of the Prophet
Mohammed (S.A.W.). These primary sources of Islamic Knowledge together with the works
of the later scholars of Islam formed the fountain of Islamic system of education.
OBJECTIVES:
At the end of this unit, you should be able to:
(i) outline the historical development of Islamic education in Nigeria;
(ii) examine the contributions of Islamic education to the development of modern science
and philosophy;
(iii) mention the various factors that facilitated the growth and expansion of Islam in the
Northern and Southern parts of Nigeria.
49
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
50
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
and manufacturing which helped to boost trade among nations. It was indeed, the trading
activities that transpired between the Arabs and the Africans that brought about Islam and the
Islamic system of education to Africa.
Historical records show that Arab scholars and traders played a great role in the propagation
of Islamic faith and education in Africa and Nigeria. Great cities like Cairo, Timbuktu,
Djenne, Gao and the regions of the Western Sudan flourished as centres of commerce and
religious learning. Many notable judges, doctors, clerics and historians were produced in
these centres, which impacted significantly on the lives of the people. The civilization that
came to Africa, especially the North Africa and the Western Sudan, owe much to the
activities of the Arab traders and scholars who visited the land hundreds of years before the
coming of the Europeans.
ACTIVITY 1
1. “The modern sc
2. entific and technological breakthroughs owe a lot to the great works of the early
Muslim scholars”. To what extent do you agree with this statement?
3. “Trade rather than religion was the main factor that brought about Islamic system of
education to Africa”. Examine the statement in the light of the reasons for the
development of Islamic education in Africa.
4. What is the significance of the first verses of the Qur’an revealed to mankind through
the Prophet of Islam Muhammad (S.A.W.)
51
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
people. This was the initial problem that set the Muslim clerics against the rulers and thus
provided strong bases for the series of Jihads (holy wars) waged in the Western Sudan, which
aimed at purging the area of unIslamic practices. The Jihad of Shehu Usman Dan Fodio in
the Sokoto Caliphate was one such religious wars fought to rid the area of the heathen
practices and excesses of the Hausa rulers.
ACTIVITY II
1. Account for the claim that Islamic education in the Kanem predates the one in the
Hausa States.
2. What were the factors that led to the religious wars in the North?
3. How did Islam gain acceptance in Southern Nigeria?
52
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
other Islamic rituals of purification, ablution, prayer and ethics. “The only pleasure they
(children) derive from the system at this stage lies in the choral recitations which often follow
a sing-song pattern. The pupils seem to enjoy reciting these verses to themselves in their
homes and at play”. (Fafunwa, 1974.)
The instructional technique at this stage is such that the teacher recites the shorter surahs to
the pupils and the pupils in turn repeat after him. This routine is repeated several times until
the teacher is fully convinced that his pupils have mastered the correct pronunciation. The
pupils are then allowed to retire and continue reciting these ayats (verses) on their own until
they have been thoroughly memorized before proceeding to the next set of ayats. This way,
the pupils progress in their studies before entering the next stage of learning.
53
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
ablution, tayammum, prayer and other rituals are issued at this stage, although much of it
are to be later learnt at the next stage.
ACTIVITY II
SUMMARY
• You have learnt in this unit that Islam is a religion with a divine book called the
“Qur’an”, which was revealed in stages to the prophet of Islam, Muhammad
(S.A.W.). The religion emphasizes the importance of knowledge, which is conveyed
in the first revelation. Most disciplines in modern sciences and philosophy owe their
roots to the Islamic system of education. Islam and Islamic education came to Africa,
and indeed, Nigeria through the trans-Saharan trade between natives and the Arab
traders.
• The acceptance of Islam by the rulers facilitated the rapid expansion of the religion
and the Jihads further consolidated it. The desire among scholars to preach the
religion and teach its principles made it possible to spread through to Ilorin and
Ibadan to the South and the entire Hausa land and Kanem to the North.
54
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
• You also learnt from the unit that Islamic Education was carried out in stages, each
with its curriculum of studies. The students learn systematically from the elementary
stage to what can now be called the university stage,
ASSIGNMENT
1. Review the development of Islamic education in Nigeria from the 8th Century.
2. Carefully assess the impact of the system on the socio-political and economic life of
the people.
REFERENCES
Dambo, L (1994), Instructional Materials Development for Improvement of Qur’anic
Education in Nigeria, Conference Paper, Kaduna.
Fafunwa B. (1974); History of Education in Nigeria, George Allen & Unwin Ltd. London
Ozigi, A and Ocho, L. (1981); Education in Northern Nigeria, George Allen & Unwin Ltd,
London.
Taiwo, C. O. (1980); The Nigerian Education System Past, Present & Future, Butler &
Tanner Ltd, London.
55
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
INTRODUCTION
You will recall the historical development of Islamic education in Northern Nigeria, which,
started as early as the 11th century, and the impact of the system among Nigerians even today
when formal education seems to be accorded more prominence.
The Western Education system,on the other hand started in the Western part of the country in
the first half of the sixteenth century. The factors responsible for the introduction of the
system were not indigenous but trade. The desire of the foreign Christian Missionary to
“liberate” Africans from what they called “the dark mind, barbarism and idolatry war mainly
to further their trade mission” (Aloy, 2001). This they pursued vigorously competing with
each other through the establishment of schools and colleges.
In this unit, a careful presentation is made of the history of the western education in Nigeria,
the trends in its development and the relevance of the system to the overall
l development of the country. Attempt is also made to relate the system to the experiences of
the traditional and Islamic education systems that existed collectively and separately in the
North and Southern parts of the country. The common ideals shared by the systems in the
advancement of education in Nigeria, most of which were re-echoed by the National Policy
document on education, are presented.
OBJECTIVES
At the end of this unit, you should be able to:
(i) outline the detailed history of western education in Nigeria;
(ii) examine the objectives and relevance of the system to the educational development of
the country;
(iii) assess the significant impact the system had on Nigeria; and
(iv) establish the relationship of the system with the traditional and Islamic goals of
education in Nigeria.
56
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
5. Refer all your difficulties to your course facilitator at the study centre who is there to
offer you assistance in your studies.
6. Take all your activities and assignments to your course facilitator who will mark and
grade them accordingly.
57
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
Samuel Ajayi Crowther settled at Igbehin and established two schools – one for boys and the
other for girls, while Townsend settled in Ake, another part of the town, where he built a
mission house, a church and a school. This was the beginning of real rivalry among the
Christian Missions in Nigeria. The Methodists, who started the first evangelical work in
Nigeria, did not take this news kindly and so decided to send a lay of missionary to Abeokuta
to commence work there.
As the Catholic Mission Society was consolidating its activities around Abeokuta and
Badagry and “extending its evangelical programmes to other parts of the country, Samuel
Ajayi Crowther opened the first school in Onitsha in December 1858 for girls between the
ages of 6 and 10.” (Fafunwa)
Down Calabar and Bonny, developments in the introduction of Western education by the
Church Mission Society missionaries were taking place. The chiefs of the area were,
however, not interested in the evangelical activities of the missionaries, but would rather
want their children to be taught how to gauge palm oil and other merchantile businesses as
trading was the main interest of the people of the area. The missionaries had no option but to
accept the people’s wishes.
The Presbyterian Mission also made their presence known in 1846 and established mission
house. Another Baptist convention established itself at Ijaye Abeokuta in 1853. The society
of the African mission similarly arrived in Lagos and established their mission in 1868.
Unfortunately, however, said Fafunwa (1978), “each denomination emphasized its own
importance and spared no pains at proving that one denomination was better than the other”.
As these denominations moved further into the hinterland, they established schools for the
training of the catechists and teachers.
58
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
included door to door visits to ‘persuade parents to send their children to school’, some
parents were insisting payment from the missionaries before allowing their wards to attend
such schools. The parents considered it a big sacrifice allowing the children to attend school
instead of the farm. At a certain time, some stipends were suggested by the mission teachers
for school children living at home as an inducement to make them regular at school.
ACTIVITY 1
1. Account for the introduction of Western Education in Nigeria between 1472 – 1868.
2. Outline and discuss the aims and content of the early western education system in
Nigeria and explain the methods through which these aims were realised.
3. What were the difficulties encountered by the early missionaries in getting the
children of the natives to enroll in their schools? How did they overcome these
difficulties.
59
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
In 1877, an education ordinance for the colony of Lagos came into being. The provision of
the ordinance laid down some principles, which became the foundation of the education laws
for Nigeria.
The provisions, as listed by Taiwo (1980) are:
1. The constitution of a Board of Education, comprising the Governor, members of the
legislative council, (which was then a small body), the Inspector of Schools, the
Governor’s nominees not exceeding four in number;
2. The appointment of Her Majesty of an Inspector schools for each colony, a sub-
inspector of schools for the colony and other education officers.
3. Grant in aids to schools and teacher training institutions.
4. Power of the Board to make, alter and revoke rules for regulating the procedures of
grant-in-aid.
5. Rates and conditions of grant-in-aid to infant schools, primary schools, secondary
schools and industrial schools, based partly on subjects taught and partly on the
degree of excellence in the schools.
6. Safeguard as to religious and racial freedom.
7. Certificate of teachers.
8. Admission into an assisted school of pauper and alien children assigned to it by the
Governor.
9. Establishment of Scholarships for secondary and technical education.
10. Power of Governor to open and maintain Government schools.
A careful examination of the ordinance will reveal the re-echoing of the provisions of the
1877 provisions and the intention of government to participate with the missionaries as
partners in the provision of education to Nigerians.
The years 1889-1906, witnessed gradual development of the dual education, in which
Government participated more and more alongside the missionaries in providing education in
Nigeria.
This experience helped immensely in the administration and management of education later
in the colony and protectorate of Southern Nigeria. Not only had the number of schools
increased during the period, the curriculum of the schools also became diversified to include
subjects like geography, history, Yoruba language, drawing and sewing for girls. Others
include Latin, Greek, mathematics, photography, book keeping, botany, chemistry, physics,
French, physiology, national history, to mention but a few.
The ordinances of the 1877, became re-inforced by another ordinance exclusively made by
Nigeria for the Southern protectorate in 1886. The provision of the ordinance spelt out in
clear terms the duties and responsibility of each party mentioned as a stakeholder. The
provisions of ordinance are:
60
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
1. There shall be a board of education for the colony. The board shall consists of the
Governor, the members of the legislative council, the inspector of schools and four
other members nominated by the Governor to serve for not more than three years.
2. It shall be lawful for the board with and out of the monies so placed at its disposal,
first to assist schools and training institutions and secondly to institute scholarships:
(i) to children who shall have attended primary schools in the colony to enable
them to proceed for secondary education;
(ii) to natives of the colony who shall have attended either primary and/or
secondary education in the colony to enable them to receive a course of
technical instruction with a view to the development of natural resources of
the colony.
3. No grant shall be made in aid of any school except:
(i) that the property and management of the school be vested in managers having
power to appoint and dismiss the teachers and responsible for payment of the
teachers’ salaries and of all other expenses of the school;
(ii) that the requirements of the board rules with regard to teachers being
certificated be satisfied in the case of the school;
(iii) that the school, in public examinations shall have attained the requisite
percentage of proficiency;
(iv) that the schools at all times be open for inspection by the inspector, the sub-
inspector or any member of the board;
(v) that the school be open to children without distinction of religion or race;
(vi) that the reading and writing of the English language, Arithmetic and in the
case of females, needle work, be taught at the school and that English
Grammar, English History and Geography be taught as class subjects;
(vii) that, by the rules of the school, no child shall receive any religious instruction
to which the parent or guardians of such child objects.
4. It shall be lawful for the board to fix different rates of grants for infant schools,
primary schools, secondary schools and also industrial schools respectively, and also
in respect of different degrees of excellence in the schools and in respect of different
subjects of instruction.
5. The board may make a grant-in-aid of any training institution, in respect of every
teacher trained at such institution who shall have received at least two years
instruction in the particular institution. (Source: the Dev. Of Modern Education in
Nigeria).
The impact of this first indigenous education ordinance developed for the Southern
protectorate was felt in at least five major areas:
1. The provision of the ordinance was more workable than the one of the 1877.
61
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
ACTIVITY II
1. Examine the implications of the Education Ordinance of 1877 to the development of
Education in Lagos colony.
2. Relate the Ordinance of 1877 with 1886 Ordinance and show how the two play a
complementary role to each other.
62
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
SUMMARY
• This unit examined the trends in the historical development of western education in
Nigeria. The factors responsible for the introduction was purely religious – to convert
the natives to Christianity. This remained the primary aim of education until the
coming of the education ordinances of 1877 and 1886.
• The ordinances provided for the grant-in-aid to missionary schools and mandated
government to run and maintain public schools as well.
• Western education in Northern Nigeria was not welcome. It was greeted with some
misapprehension mostly from the fear that the Muslims might be converted to
Christianity. However, much later after it had been accepted in the Middle Belt area,
the Northern Emirs consented and allowed their children, who would take charge of
administration after them to be educated. In addition, education was provided for the
training of people who would assist the colonial administration as clerks etc.
ASSIGNMENT
In a summary form, discuss the trends in the development of education in Nigeria.
REFERENCES
Adesina, S. (1988) The Development of Modern Education in Nigeria, Heinemann
Educational Books (NIG) LTD, Ibadan, Nigeria.
Fafunwa A (1974) History of Education in Nigeria, George Allen & Unwin Ltd, Great
Britain.
Taiwo, C.O. (1980) The Nigerian Education System – Past, Present and Future, Thomas
Nelson (NIG) LTD Lagos: Nigeria.
Ozigi A, and Ocho, L (1981) Education in Northern Nigeria, George Allen & Unwin, UK.
63
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
INTRODUCTION
Having gone through the last unit, you will realise that up to 1914, western education system
in Nigeria had no definite philosophy. The British Government had not taken any decision
regarding the definite shape of education in its colonies. The education ordinances only
ridiculously complicated the system without reflecting the conditions and aspirations of the
Nigerian people for future development.
In this unit, attempt is made at getting you acquainted with the efforts made at developing a
philosophy of education based on the aspirations of Nigerians. Discussion on the educational
development that took place in Nigeria from 1919 and beyond will be made with a view to
consolidating your knowledge of the trends of educational development in Nigeria over the
years. The impacts of these developments will similarly be highlighted so that you learn how
to further the course of education in this country.
OBJECTIVES:
At the end of this unit, you should be able to:
1. discuss the background to the development of educational policies in Nigeria;
2. assess the impacts of these philosophies on the overall educational progress of our
nation;
3. identify the problems (if any) militating against the realization of the intent of the
educational planners over the years and what could possibly be done to solve these
problems.
64
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
being classically book based. They accused the missionaries for following the ideals
prevailing in their home countries, which might not work functionally in Africa. The reports
further condemned the subjects being taught to Africans as being direct copies of the subject
contents from British and America schools with little attempt to use local materials in the
teaching of the subjects like history and geography.
The two commissions however recommended that:
1. Education should be developed along the vocational and cultural lives of the people.
2. The needs of African societies be met through education so as to promote
development.
3. Educational and Religious responsibilities of Government should be effectively
organised and supervised.
These criticisms and recommendations undoubtedly laid the foundation for the evolution of
the colonial educational policies in Africa, for it influenced the British Government to assess
its responsibilities on education to its colonies. In 1923 therefore, it decided “to approve the
establishment of an advisory committee on native education in tropical areas to advise the
Secretary of state for the colonies on matters of native education and to assist him in
advancing the progress of education in the British tropical Africa”.(Adesina)
The committee worked tirelessly and produced a thirteen point memorandum, which
provided for the first time, a sound basis for Nigeria’s educational policies. They are as
follows:
1. Government should control educational policies and cooperate with educational
agencies. Each territory should have an Education Advisory Board on which all
educational interests should be represented.
2. Education should be adapted to the mentality, aptitudes, occupations and traditions of
the various peoples, conserving as far as possible, all sound and healthy elements in
the fabric of their social life; adapting them where necessary to changed
circumstances and progressive ideas, as an agent of natural growth and evolution.
3. Government should be concerned with religious and character training.
4. Education service must be made to attract the best men from Britain, whether for
permanent career or for short- service appointment.
5. Grant should be given to aid voluntary schools which satisfy the requirements.
6. African languages, as well as English, should be used in education.
7. African teaching staff must be adequate in number, in qualification, and in character,
and should include women.
8. The system of specially trained visiting teachers is commended as a means of
improving village schools.
9. A thorough system of inspection and supervision of schools is essential.
65
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
66
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
1. The Federal Government should give support for the development of new university
planned for 1955.
2. A university should be established in the North using the old site of the Nigeria
College in Zaria as its base.
3. A university should be established in Lagos with day and evening degree courses in
business, commerce and economics.
4. University College Ibadan should move from its conservative position, widen its
curriculum and develop into a full university.
5. All Universities in Nigeria should be national in outlook.
6. There should be wider diversity and greater flexibility in university education.
7. All the universities should have B.A (Education) degree courses.
8. Courses in Engineering, Medicine, Law, Commerce, Agriculture, etc, should be
offered.
9. The new Nigerian universities should be independent of one another and each should
confer its own degrees.
10. A National Universities Commission should be set up to have undisputed control over
the affairs of the universities; particularly, in terms of finance, staff and courses.
Looking at the trends in the development of education since the ‘40s’, you will notice that the
development was becoming increasingly systematic. Series of educational plans right from
1942 saw the upsurge in the development of primary, secondary, teacher and university
education. These will now be considered separately.
67
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
Government saw the root cause of all these problems as the poor quality and quantity of
secondary school teachers. The graduate teachers were in very short supply. Government
tried to have expatriate teachers to meet this demand. But paying for the passages and
allowances of the expatriate teachers meant much on the lean resources of the regional
governments. And, worse still, many of these hirelings stayed only for a term of two years or
three and refused to renew their contract.
However, to meet the increasing number of secondary school students, Government opened
many new secondary schools. Generally, the curriculum was English Language,
Mathematics, History, Geography, Religious Knowledge, Local Languages, Fine and Applied
Arts, General Science, Biology, Chemistry and Physics. French was introduced gradually to
replace Latin and Greek. The grammar school kept its lead and remained the darling of both
parents and students. The higher school i.e. sixth form was not so successful except in a few
government well established schools with enough graduate teachers and laboratory
equipment. This was because the curriculum was tailored to meet the requirement of foreign
examinations. Available resources in the schools could not meet these.
68
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
Coal Corporation had technical schools in which they trained artisans in their specific
industries. Last but not the least are the roadside mechanics who acquire their skills from
self-employed artisans while many girls acquire skills in needle work, sewing, catering and
domestic science from such roadside artisans as well.
69
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
of Technology and others for Agriculture. Each of these 21 states of the Nigerian Federation
nearly has two Universities.
70
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
However, the massive growth of private secondary schools made planned expansion very
difficult. Communities and villages competed against one another in the establishment of
secondary schools. The quality of the schools varied from school to school as revealed by the
results of the West African School Certificate Examinations. These private schools were
worst hit in terms of performance because of lack of finance which resulted in poor
equipment and personnel. However, there were isolated exceptions such as the International
School at Ibadan which was being sponsored by the University of Ibadan. In the case of
primary schools, private schools were among the best because they were very few and the
parents were prepared to pay high fees for running the schools. The aim of the parents was to
ensure that their children secured admission in the few well equipped and staffed
Government Colleges in each of the regions.
In addition to the contributions of the private enterprise in the formal system, there are
hundreds of artisans spread throughout the country who were self-employed and who train
apprentices in their respective trade. Many girls acquired skills in needle work, sewing,
catering and domestic science in this way. Many road-side mechanics acquired their skills,
which are reasonably high in a few cases, from self employed artisans.
71
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
ACTIVITY I
1. Describe the significance of the Phelps-Stokes Commission reports to the
development of the British educational policies in its colonies.
2. How did the 1925 memorandum affect the educational policies in Nigeria?
3. Examine in detail, the recommendations of the Ashby reports and its significance to
the development of higher education in Nigeria.
4. In what ways did the 1969 curriculum conference aided the development of the
Nigeria’s educational policies of the ‘70s?
72
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
ACTIVITY II
1. How has the current policy on education in the country turned around our educational
system?
2. What major threats would you say are facing the development of education in Nigeria
today?
3. How would these problems be overcome in your opinion?
4. In what ways can the value system of Nigerians be changed?
• SUMMARY
• The Unit has reviewed for you the developmental trends of education in the country
since 1919. The British government started showing interest as to which direction
education should take with the reports of the Phelps-Stokes committees that visited
West, East and Central Africa in 1920 and 1924 respectively. It therefore constituted a
committee to work out the direction, which education should take in its colonies in the
tropical Africa in 1923. The committee produced a memorandum in 1925, which for
the first time provided the sound basis for the country’s educational policies.
• The ordinances of 1926 and beyond re-echoed those recommendations of the Phelps-
Stoke’s reports and led to the decentralization of education and got government to be
more involved in the control and supervision of education.
73
MODULE 3 History of Education in Nigeria (PDE 101)
• Between 1947 and 1970, Nigeria developed steady educational policies that
culminated into the development of higher education. The Ashby’s commission
reports of 1959, for example, set the pace for the development of higher education in
Nigeria, the impact of which is still being felt. The 1969 curriculum conference was
another significant achievement in the development of education in the country. That
was the first time Nigerians of different works of life gathered together to fashion out
national education objectives for the country. These objectives provided the basis for
further developments that translated into the policy document, called the National
Policy on Education. The document was conceived and hatched at a time of economic
buoyancy, but unfortunately implemented in a depressed economic. This and other
factors, as pointed also in the unit, are responsible for the non realization of the
objectives outlined in the policy document.
• In this unit, you have equally been told of some specific developments in education
under the captions, primary, secondary, higher, teacher, technical and vocational
education as well. These levels of development are opened for your criticism and to
serve as a springboard from which you can contribute positively policy formulations,
provisions and practices of education in the country.
• Finally, the unit has challenged you with some important questions, sharpen your
mind on the expected contributions from, to enhance teaching and learning in our
school system.
ASSIGNMENT
Carefully examine the trends in the development of education from 1919 to date, pointing out
the significant achievements made, the threats confronting the system, and suggest ways of
solving them.
REFERENCES
Fafunwa, A. (1974) History of Education In Nigeria, George Allen & Unwin Ltd., London
Ozigi, A. & Ocho, L. (1981) Education in Northern Nigeria, George Allen & Unwin Ltd.,
London.
Taiwo,C.O (1980) The Nigerian Education System: Past, Present & Future, Butler &
Tanner Ltd, London.
74