DRA.

ELIZABETH DE GUIA VS WILLIAM GO GODINO

ISSUANCE OF TPO/PPO
CIVIL CASE NO. 12-0112
BRANCH 274 PARAÑAQUE RTC – JUDGE FORTUNITO L. MADRONA
EDG’s Motions/Pleadings
WG’s Motions/Pleadings
COURT ORDER

VOLUME I
DATE STATUS
April 17, 2012 EDG filed Issuance of Ex-Parte TPO/PPO under RA 9262 – CIVIL CASE NO. 12-0112.
May 7, 2012 Parañaque RTC Branch 194 issued an Order granting the TPO filed by EDG.
May 10, 2012 EDG Request Letter to implement the TPO dated May 7, 2012.
May 11, 2012 WG’s Manifestation – saying that EDG forcibly opened his padlocked room which contained his valuables
and EDG left bringing with her WG’s attaché case.

Entry of Appearance of WG’s counsel – Andres Marcelo Padernal Guerrero & Paras.
Atty. Maricris Pahate
May 15, 2012 WG filed
1. Manifestation
2. Opposition (Re: Petition dated 17 April 2012
3. Motion to Dismiss – Lack of Jurisdiction of the court; failure to disclose the residence of petitioner
when the petition was filed; lack of jurisdiction because Jolo is emancipated.

May 19, 2012 EDG filed for a Motion for Issuance of Hold Departure Order
May 22, 2012 WG filed Very Urgent Motion to Retrieve Philippine Passports – because he was scheduled to travel to
Taiwan
May 23, 2012 WG filed Motion for Parties to Submit to DNA Testing Ex Abundante Ad Cautelam – to determine whether
or not respondent has the obligation to give support to Juan Lorenzo.
May 25, 2012 Court Order
1. Motion for Issuance of HDO – DENIED – Mere Speculation, no sufficient evidence. And not a
criminal case.
2. Very Urgent Motion to Retrieve Philippine Passports – GRANTED – Right to Travel
May 28, 2012 EDG filed Motion for Reconsideration (Re: Denial of the Motion for Issuance of Hold Departure Order)
May 30, 2012 WG filed Urgent Motion to Maintain Status Quo – because EDG is removing and taking out several
properties inside the Parañaque House.
May 31, 2012 EDG filed Manifestation of Respondent’s Violations of the TPO & Motion for Issuance of Subpoenas Ad
Testificandum
June 1, 2012 Court Order
WG filed Urgent Motion to Maintain Status Quo – GRANTED

EDG Compliance (Re: Judicial Affidavits of Witnesses Filed and Served Three days before Trial)
June 5, 2012 EDG List of Documentary Exhibits
June 6, 2012 WG List of Documentary Exhibits

WG Comment/Opposition With Motion to Direct Petitioner to Return the MAZDA 3 and Mazda CX9 (Re:
Manifestation of Respondent’s Violations of the TPO & Motion for Issuance of Subpoenas Ad
Testificandum dated 31 May 2012) – THE VEHICLES WERE REGISTERED UNDER WG’S
CORPORATION SAFEWAY BROKERAGE & SAFEWAY PROPERTY AND HAS DISTINCT
PERSONALITY FROM THE BOD.

WG Manifestation – saying that EDG only went to Jaleville only 4 times from May 10 – May 30, 2012 which
serves the Issuance of TPO Inutile.

WG filed Comment/Opposition (Re: Motion for Reconsideration dated 28 May 2012)

June 6, 2012 EDG Comment/Opposition (Re: Motion for DNA Testing)

EDG Comment/Opposition (Re: Motion to Dismiss)

June 8, 2012 Court Order

TPO Extended for another 30 days
June 11, 2012 WG filed
1. Reply (Re: Comment/Opposition to the Motion to Dismiss; and
2. Reply (Re: Comment to Motion for Parties to Submit to DNA Testing)
 EDG’s Motions/Pleadings
WG’s Motions/Pleadings
COURT ORDER

VOLUME 2
DATE STATUS
June 18, 2012 EDG filed a Reply (Re: Comment/ Opposition with Motion to Direct Petitioner to Return the
MAZDA 3 and MAZDA CX9) – IT SHOULD HAVE BEEN THE CORPORATION WHO HAS
A DISTINCT PERSONALITY TO FILE ITS RELIEF AND NOT WG.

EDG Comment/Counter-Manifestation (Re: Manifestation dated June 6, 2012)

June 21, 2012 WG filed a Motion to Modify Temporary Protection Order dated June 8, 2012
July 3, 2012 EDG filed a Motion to Extend Temporary Protection Order from July 9 – August 8, 2012

July 6, 2012 Court Order

1. Motion to Modify Temporary Protection Order – DENIED
2. Motion to Extend TPO from July 9 – August 8, 2012 - GRANTED
July 18, 2012 WITHDRAWAL OF APPEARANCE with the CONSENT OF CLIENT - EDG

July 26, 2012 WG filed Urgent Motion for Inhibition of Judge Marie Grace Javier Ibay
August 1, 2012 ENTRY OF APPEARNCE of EDG Counsel
August 1, 2012 EDG filed Urgent Motion to Extend and Modify Temporary Protection Order from August 9 –
September 8, 2012.
August 2, 2012 EDG Comment/Opposition (Re: Motion to Modify Temporary Protection Order)
August 3, 2012 EDG Comment/Opposition to Respondent’s Motion for Inhibition
August 13, 2012 Court Order
1. Motion to Dismiss (May 15, 2012) – DENIED
2. Motion for Parties to Submit to DNA Testing Ex Abundante Ad Cautelam - DENIED
August 17, 2012 Court Order
1. Motion to Extend TPO – GRANTED. Automatically extended for 30 days until
petitioner’s Petition for PPO shall have been finally resolved.
2. Urgent Motion for Inhibition – GRANTED.
August 22, 2012 EDG filed Motion to Declare William Go, Atty. Jospeh Banguis, Felix Ruado and John Does in
Contempt of Court and for Violation of TPO (pursuant to Section 21, R.A. 9262)
August 28, 2012 OCC re-raffled the case to Branch 260 Parañaque RTC. Judge Jaime M. Guray
September 10, 2012 WG filed Motion to Nullify and Set Aside Temporary Protection Order
September 18, 2012 EDG filed Urgent Ex-Parte Motion to Withdraw (Motion to Declare William Go Godino, Et. Al.
in Contempt of Court and for Violation of TPO.
October 31, 2012 EDG filed Urgent Ex-Parte Motion to Produce the Recorded Tapes of the Hearings of October
17,2012 and Septmber 17, 2012 To Correct the TSN of October 17, and to Produce the TSN of
September 17, 2012.
November 27, 2012 EDG filed Urgent Motion for Inhibition of Judge Jaime M. Guray
January 2, 2013 WG filed Comment/Opposition (Re: Urgent Motion for Inhibition 27 November 2012)
January 11, 2013 EDG filed a Motion to Expunge (Respondent’s Comment/Opposition dated January 2, 2013
January 28, 2013 Court Order
1. Motion for Inhibition – GRANTED
2. WG’s Comment/Opposition - DENIED
January 29, 2013 OCC re-raffled the case to Branch 274 Parañaque RTC. Judge Fortunito L. Madrona
March 12, 2013 Court Order
1. EDG Motion for Reconsideration (Re denial of the Motion for Issuance of HDO dated
May 28, 2012) – DENIED
2. WG Motion to Direct Petitioner to Return the Mazda 3 and Mazda CX9 dated June 6,
2012 – DENIED
3. WG Motion to Nullify and Set Aside Temporary Protection Order dated September 10,
2012 – DENIED
4. EDG Urgent Ex-Parte Motion to Withdraw Motion to Declare William Go Godino, et.al.
in contempt of court and for violation of TPO dated September 18, 2012 – NOTED and
APPROVED
March 14, 2013 WG filed a Motion for Partial Summary Judgment – praying that the Court Dismiss the causes
of action for psychological, physical and economic abuse that occurred prior to the effectivity of
RA 9262.

EDG’s Motions/Pleadings
WG’s Motions/Pleadings
COURT ORDER
 VOLUME 3
DATE STATUS
April 4, 2013 EDG Comment/Opposition (On the Motion for Partial Summary Judgment)
April 12, 2013 EDG Judicial Affidavit
May 6, 2013 EDG filed
1. Motion for Leave of Court to Admit the Attached Formal Offer of Evidence
2. Formal Offer of Evidence
May 10, 2013 EDG Manifestation – Lacking Exhiits “BB”, “CC”, and “CC-1”

May 24, 2013 WG filed Motion for Additional Time to File Comment (Re: Motion for Leave of Court to
Admit the Attached Formal Offer of Evidence dated May 6, 2013) – Additional 5 days -
GRANTED
May 27, 2013 WG filed Objections/Comments (Re: Petitioner’s Formal Offer of Evidence dated May 6,
2013)
May 30, 2013 Court Order
1. EDG Motion for Leave of Court to Admit the Attached Formal Offer of Evidence –
GRANTED
2. EDG Formal Offer of Evidence – ALL ADMITTED
June 26, 2013 WG filed Demurrer to Evidence – Praying that the Court Dismiss the Petition datedApril
17, 2012, for failure of the petitioner to present sufficient and competent evidence, to prove
the causes of action alleged therein, and to support the issuance of a Permanent Protection
Order under RA 9262.

EDG’s Motions/Pleadings
WG’s Motions/Pleadings
COURT ORDER

VOLUME 4
 DATE STATUS
July 12, 2013 EDG Comment/Opposition (To WG’s Demurrer to Evidence)
July 30, 2013 EDG Petition to Declare in Contempt – praying that WG be declared in contempt of court
for blatant violations of the TPO dated May 7, 2012.
July 31, 2013 Court Order
1. EDG Petition to Declare in Contempt – DISMISSED without prejudice – for not
complying with Sec 4, Rule 71 of the 1997 Rules of Civil Procedure and pursuant to
Sec 3, Rule 17, of said Rules.
August 6, 2013 WG’s Reply (Comment/Opposition to Demurrer to Evidence)

September 3, 2013 EDG Manifestation of pending VAWC case

October 3, 2013 Court Order

1. WG Demurrer to Evidence - DENIED
November 26, 2013 WG’s Motion to Reset Hearing – Court Reset Hearing to January 30, 2014

January 23, 2014 Judicial Affidavit of Emilia Abriam – on WG side.

March 24, 2014 NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL OF APPEARNCE of EDG counsel.

Oct 13, 2014 Judicial Affidavit of Rosa del Monte – on WG side
Oct 22, 2014 EDG Manifestation and Very Urgent Motion to Cancel Hearing – to December 11, 2014 -
GRANTED
November 26, 2014 WG’s filed Motion to Lift Temporary Protection Order – RTC Manila Branch 43 declared
their marriage Null and Void dated August 5, 2014.
December 12, 2014 EDG filed
1. Motion to Admit (Comment/Opposition (Re: Motion to Lift Temporary Protection
Order)
2. Comment/Opposition (Re: Motion to Lift Temporary Protection Order)
February 16, 2015 Court Order
1. WG Motion to Lift Temporary Protection Order dated November 26, 2014 0
DENIED
May 11, 2015 WG filed Petition for Certiorari before the Court of Appeals – praying to Reverse and Set
Aside the First and Second Assailed Orders (March 12, 2013 & February 16, 2015); and to
Lift the TPO dated August 17, 2012.
May 15, 2015 Judicial Affidavit of Maribel Samson – on WG side
July 31, 2015 EDG filed
1. Motion to Admit Attached Comment/Opposition before CA
2. Comment/Opposition On the Petition for Certiorar before CA
August 17, 2015 Judicial Affidavit of WG

EDG’s Motions/Pleadings
WG’s Motions/Pleadings
COURT ORDER

VOLUME 5
DATE STATUS
August 9, 2015 WG filed Motion for Extension of Time to File Reply before CA
August 15, 2015 WG filed a Reply before CA
October 1, 2015 WG filed a Motion for Early Resolution before CA
February 15, 2016 Judicial Affidavit of Dr. Arnulfo V. Lopez, C.Ht, Ph.D., Rp. – Expert Witness

February 29, 2016 WG filed Formal Offer of Evidence

March 16, 2016 EDG filed Motion for Extension of Time (To File Comment on the Motion to Recover
Residence and Personal Properties)
March 28, 2016 EDG filed Motion for Extension of Time (To File Comment on Formal Offer of Evidence of
WG)
March 31, 2016 Court of Appeals Order
1. March 12, 2013 & February 16, 2015 Orders of the public respondent are
ANNULED and SET ASIDE and the TPO dated August 17, 2012 is LIFTED
April 8, 2016 EDG Comment on Formal Offer of Evidence of WG
April 20, 2016 WG filed Motion to Recover Residence and Personal Properties – because the CA Annuled
and Set Aside the Orders & Lifted the TPO order dated August 17, 2012 – before Br. 274
RTC Parañaque
April 27, 2016 EDG filed Motion for Reconsideration – to reconsider March 31, 2016 Decision before CA
May 13, 2016 Court Order
1. WG Formal Offer of Evidence – ALL ADMITTED
May 26, 2016 EDG filed Verified Comment/Opposition (Re: Motion to Recover Residence and Personal
Properties dated April 20, 2016)
June 3, 2016 WG filed a Reply (Verified Comment/Opposition dated May 26, 2016)
June 16, 2016 WG Comment/Opposition (Motion for Reconsideration dated April 27, 2016) before CA
July 14, 2016 Court Judgment
1. EDG Prayer for Permanent Protection Order - DENIED

EDG’s Motions/Pleadings
WG’s Motions/Pleadings
COURT ORDER

VOLUME 6
DATE STATUS
July 22, 2016 WG filed Motion to Reinstate Status Quo Ante – praying to Vacate EDG & to Deliver the
personal properties enumerated in the Manifestation dated May 11, 2016.
 WG filed Manifestation / Motion before the CA – praying that EDG Motion for
Reconsideration dated April 27, 2016 is moot and academic in light of the executor
Judgment dated July 14, 2016.
August 18, 2016 EDG filed Motion for Reconsideration – praying that the Judgment dated July 14, 2016 be
reconsidered and set aside.
September 14, 2016 EDG Comment/Opposition (To Manifestation/Motion & Motion for Status Quo Ante)
September 26, 2016 WG Comment (Re: Motion for Reconsideration dated August 18, 2016)

WG Reply (Re: Comment/Opposition dated September 14, 2016)

October 5, 2016 Court of Appeals Resolution
1. EDG Motion for Reconsideration – DENIED for being moot and academic. Instant
case is now CLOSED and TERMINATED.
October 14, 2016 WG Manifestation – CA Resolution supports WG’s Motion to Reinstate Status Quo Ante.
DECEMBER 9, COURT ORDER
2016 1. WG MOTION TO REINSTATE STATUS QUO ANTE – HE IS ALLOWED TO
COME BACK, BUT THE MOTION TO RECOVER PROPERTIES IS DENIED.
January 4, 2017 WG filed Motion for Partial Reconsideration (Re Court Order dated December 9, 2016)
MARCH 27, 2017 COURT ORDER
1. WG MOTION FOR PARTIAL RECONSIDERATION (RE ORDER DATED
DECEMBER 9, 2016) - DENIED
May 23, 2017 Court Certification
1. No Motion for Reconsideration / Appeal been filed within the reglementary period,
the Judgement dated December 9, 2016 is now final and executory
June 22, 2017 WG filed Petition for Certiorari before CA – to review, annul and set aside the
Order dated December 9, 2016 and March 27, 2017.
SEPTEMBER 28, COURT OF APPEALS DECISION
2018 1. WG ASSAILED THE DECEMBER 9, 2016 & MARCH 27, 2017 ORDER –
PETITION FOR CERTIORARI – DENIED FOR LACK OF MERIT.
July 4, 2019 WG filed Motion for Extension of Time to File Petition for Review on Certiorari before SC
August 6, 2019 WG filed Petition for Review on Certiorari before SC – praying that the Decision of CA
dated September 28, 2018 and Resolution dated June 14, 2019 be Reverse and Set Aside.
September 19, 2019 WG filed Motion to Modify Orders (Re: Orders dated December 9, 2016 & March 27, 2017).

September 26, 2019 Court Order

1. EDG given 15 days to file Comment to WG Motion to Modify Orders.
September 30, 2019 EDG filed Comment/Opposition (WG’s Motion to Modify Orders)

VOLUME 7
DATE STATUS
June 1, 2012 TSN - Manifestation
June 4, 2012 TSN – Pre-Trial
June 6, 2012 TSN – Estrelita Singson
June 25, 2012 TSN – Manifestation

June 27, 2012 TSN – Cynthia De Guia & Jaime C. Diomampo

June 29, 2012 TSN – Dra. Angela Aida Halili-Jao

October 17, 2012 TSN – Cross Examination on Dr. Angela Aida Jao
March 13, 2013 TSN – Hearing on the PPO
April 18, 2013 TSN – Continuance of the Hearing on the PPO
March 14, 2014 TSN – Hearing
September 18, 2014 TSN – Hearing
May 21, 2015 TSN – Trial
August 19, 2015 TSN – Hearing
September 30, 2015 TSN – Hearing
November 4, 2015 TSN – Hearing
February 17, 2016 TSN - Hearing