17 - Shiphandling Feb 18 27833
17 - Shiphandling Feb 18 27833
Issue no. 17
N vigator
 THE
                                        Inspiring professionalism in marine navigators
                                                                                         FR
                                                                                           EE
            NSTITU
          LI
                          A free publication by The Nautical Institute in association
                 TE
   ROYA
OF
       VI
    A
            G ATI
                O
NAV
                                                                                                                                     David Patraiko FNI
                                                                                                         Director of Projects, The Nautical Institute
 Poetry in motion
 You may have your certificate of                                     Probably the best way to enhance all of                shiphandling skills and encourages
 competency, but how confident do you                             these training methods is to reflect upon                  individuals to continually develop their
 feel to actually handle a ship in confined                       your experiences with someone with more                    abilities. Of all the skills a navigator
 waters or heavy weather? Could you                               knowledge than you, to identity what went                  must have, being able to handle a ship
 challenge a Master or Pilot if things                            well and where improvements can be made.                   well enough to manage its massive
 didn’t look quite right? For many years,                         To aid this formal practice of reflecting on               momentum with limited power and
 members of The Nautical Institute have                           your experiences handling a ship, The                      to control its movement in crowded
 listed ‘improving shiphandling skills’                           Nautical Institute has produced an individual              waterways with continually changing
 as a top priority for their professional                         logbook that you might like to consider using.             environmental influences could be the
 development. The problem is, it’s not that                       Recording your experiences on paper will aid               most important.
 easy to get experience – and experience                          your professional development, identify gaps                   Few people in the world will have the
 is the best way to improve.                                      in your knowledge and help justify the need                opportunity to handle a massive object like
     In this edition of The Navigator                             for further mentoring and training.                        a ship in such a dynamic environment with
 we explore some basic principles of                                  On page 4 of this issue, Captain Nigel                 such inherent risks. Good shiphandling
 shiphandling and how, as an individual, you                      Allen uses his considerable experience as                  is a skill that navigators can be proud
 can gain experience and make the most                            a Master, Pilot and instructor to explore an               to achieve. It should be cherished and
 of any opportunities to learn. The three                         understanding of ‘all the forces’ affecting                continually refined. If you have good
 best ways of learning are: onboard a ship                        a ship. Question: what turns a ship? The                   shiphandling skills, please pass these on
 in active service, using a simulator or in a                     rudder? Answer: No, it’s a culmination                     through mentoring your fellow mariners.
 manned model. Of course, learning can                            of all the forces, internal and external                   Never stop developing your own abilities
 also be achieved by reading books, joining                       around the pivot point, including the wash                 and reflecting upon your success. After all,
 discussions, undergoing computer-based                           directed by the rudder.                                    good shiphandling might be the closest
 training or even by moving ship-shaped                               In the article on page 6, Captain                      we mariners will ever get to achieving
 wooden blocks around a table top.                                George Sangil explains how he values                       poetry in motion.
                             Tel: +44 (0)20 7591 3134  Fax: +44 (0)20 7591 3131                Laura Nicholls, David Patraiko FNI
                        OF
                 G ATI
                    O
              NSTITU
            LI
                     TE
     ROYA
                        OF
     N
            VI
      A
                 G ATI
                     O
                                                                                                                                        #NavInspire
                        OF
     N
            VI
      A
                 G ATI
                     O
If you would like to get in touch with us,                           I am a long-term fan of The Navigator, since    I would like to congratulate you on this
please contact the editor, Emma Ward                                 I was a deck cadet. Whenever I receive          excellent edition of The Navigator, especially
                                                                     copies of your magazine, I discuss them with    the article An Insider’s Guide to Piloting by Ed
at navigator@nautinst.org, or look out                               my fellow officers and colleagues onboard.      Verbeek. Nothing could be more useful for
for the LinkedIn discussion. We look                                     Your issue about                                               ship’s Masters and officers
forward to hearing from you.                                         piloting (issue 16) was                                            than this insight into the way
                                                                     special because when                                               a Pilot thinks. It should be
                                                                     I talked about it with                                             compulsory reading for all
                                                                     my deck officers,                                                 navigating officers.
                                                                     everybody said that the                                           John Simpson, AFNI
                                                                     magazine improved their
                                                                     knowledge and gave                                                I am a 22-year-old deck
                                                                     them more confidence                                              cadet in my last year
                                                                     to perform their tasks                                           of maritime navigation
                                                                     during pilotage. We all                                          studies at the Lithuanian
                                                                     enjoyed reading about                                            Maritime Academy. I am
                                                                     individual personal                                              writing from Crude Oil M/T
                                                                     experiences from Pilots.                                         Cape Bellavista, where
                                                                     Dante Addug, PMMA                                               I am gaining experience
Get the app                                                          2007, Vroon-Fil Ship                                           working with officers and
                                                                     Management                                                     collecting sea-going practice
                                                                                                                     months for my diploma. This is my second
                                                                     l am second mate with an ocean-going            contract after practice on a ro-ro vessel in
Join the debate on LinkedIn                                          bulk carrier, and enjoy reading what            the Black Sea.
http://www.linkedin.com/groups/                                      The Navigator publishes to promote                 I hope to continue in a tanker fleet
Nautical-Institute-1107227                                           knowledge about safety at sea. For some         because an officer’s job here is both
                                                                     reason, however, I don’t always get the         interesting and challenging. I can’t wait
Follow us on Twitter                                                 paper version and Internet restrictions         to become a third officer and have more
https://twitter.com/NauticalInst                                     mean that we cannot reach your website.         responsibilities on my shoulders.
                                                                     Please could you send me a digital              Povilas Lubninas, M/T Cape Bellavista
We are active on Facebook                                            version of The Navigator?
https://www.facebook.com/                                            Yin Benkuan, Second Mate                        For beginners like me, The Navigator is
                                                                                                                     very helpful to understand more about the
thenauticalinstitute                                                 Editor’s note: We would be delighted to         maritime world. I believe that work at sea
Watch our videos on You Tube                                         send a digital version of The Navigator         has good prospects. You can meet and
                                                                     and are setting up an email distribution list   work with all kinds of people around the
http://www.youtube.com/
                                                                     for anyone else unable to access it in any      world. Very nice. I am trying to study hard
TheNauticalInstitute                                                 other way. If you would like to be included     in order to improve my career.
                                                                     on this list, please email us your details.     Yayan, Junior Officer, M/T Verity
You can read a digital version of The
Navigator, or download it in PDF format at
http://www.nautinst.org/publications
                                                                                                                        Putting The Navigator in
                                                                                                                        the picture
                                                                                                                        We appreciate all the pictures
                                                                                                                        we receive from readers for our
                                                                                                                        competitions – please keep them
                                                                                                                        coming! – but this one really stood
                                                                                                                        out. Carlos Mauer writes "Starting my
                                                                                                                        LNG contract on the right foot!"
S
             ome of the best shiphandlers I     at their last order to figure out the reason     ships and, whilst they got there safely, it was
             have seen and worked with are      for the problem. However, almost always,         apparent that they didn’t fully understand
             the ones who appear to do the      things had been going wrong for some time        the principles of shiphandling and so were
             least. They let the ship do the    beforehand, manifesting itself in the vessel     making hard work of it.
             work for them and only intervene   hitting the jetty. Invariably, too much speed
when the ship departs from their ‘planned       or a poor approach will be to blame. Going       Principles of shiphandling
track’. In other words, if the ship has some    slowly and methodically tends to ensure          So, what makes a ship turn? Sounds like
way and you do nothing, it will continue to     better results. A calm, measured approach        it should be an easy question: the rudder!
travel under its own inertia, sometimes quite   will instill confidence in the bridge team and   However, it is not that simple. What actually
some distance, before eventually coming         get you in the correct position more quickly     causes the hull to turn is the water pressure
to a stop. So, by controlling the speed and     and with far less drama.                         around the hull and the difference between
having enough inertia the ship can get to                                                        the pressure to port and starboard. By
the berth without too much interference.        Knowledge is power                               using the rudder, we can control this
    Having a plan is crucial to success.        STCW makes the presumption that you              pressure differential and steer the ship. We
Anticipating how the ship will behave           will learn from others. However, this means      can see that effect in practice by looking
will help you to carry out that plan. It is     that you are limited to the extent of their      at a directionally unstable ship. A ship is
important to remember that, when berthing       knowledge. Many shiphandlers who appear          considered directionally unstable if, when 20°
a ship, the faster you go, the longer the       to know what they are doing cannot explain       per minute RoT is achieved with starboard
manoeuvre will take.                            the procedure to others often due to their       rudder, and the rudder is put amidships, the
    When a manoeuvre goes wrong, it is          own lack of formal shiphandling training. I      RoT continues to increase. That’s not just the
common for shiphandlers to look back            have seen many Masters berthing their own        rudder! Something else is going on.
4 | The Navigator | February 2018
                                                                          SHIPHANDLING EXPLAINED
                  Learning how to
                    get it right
               Captain George Sangil, a Master Mariner from the Philippine Center for Advanced
               Maritime Simulation And Training, Inc. explains how the right experience, mentoring
                              and training are crucial to success in shiphandling
I
    n seafaring, competency is the foundation      Competence in action                               employing and absorb the ones you would
    of everything we achieve in terms of safety,   The very first time an officer swings the ship     be comfortable with as a Master. I have
    security and efficient shipping operations.    to pick up a Pilot can be one of the most          always promoted the concept of ‘Challenge
    One of the most essential skills for           terrifying situations one can encounter.           and Response’ during my command and
    achieving competency as a ship’s officer is       I see to it that the officer is supervised,     have consistently encouraged the crew
establishing proficiency in ship manoeuvring       either directly or indirectly. One time, I put     to be comfortable in challenging anything
and handling. This is a skill seen by many         my Second Mate to the test and had him             unusual or unsafe.
as not only the most important, but also the       bring the vessel to the pilot station without          It is crucial to understand that anyone
most difficult to attain.                          me on the bridge. Initially, he called me          can be challenged, including the Captain
    Exceptional seafarers know that factual        on the radio to ask for suggestions on             and Pilot, both of whom are effectively
knowledge and an understanding of the              what he should do. I told him to use his           part of the bridge team. Officers should
conceptual requirements of shiphandling            common sense in dealing with the situation         be trained to voice whatever challenges
is not enough. There is no substitute for          (without him knowing that I was all the time       they may see, never forgetting to be polite,
experience. Fortunately, the chance to             observing how he was handling the vessel           respectful and diplomatic.
practise shiphandling skills is now more                                                                  When dealing with a difficult situation,
accessible than ever before, thanks to                                                                good practice is to make a logbook entry
the advent of shipboard-like training              EACH AND EVERY                                     and call the Master immediately. If a
environments. A great way to translate factual
knowledge into practical applications is to use
                                                   SHIP'S OFFICER                                     ship is approaching a dock too quickly,
                                                                                                      the Master should immediately intervene
simulators; even while onboard an actual ship!     DESERVES TO                                        by verbalising take-over of the conn
    Learning by doing is how I train people                                                           (for the VDR to capture on record),
in shiphandling. Allowing them to mimic
                                                   POSSESS THE SKILL                                  immediately countermanding the Pilot’s
the techniques that I have demonstrated,           OF SHIPHANDLING. IT                                order and executing the appropriate
whenever it is safe to do so, is how they                                                             engine and helm orders to bring the vessel
get to experience multiple tasks under my          IS ONE OF THE MOST                                 to a stop.
responsibility. These can vary from picking
up a Pilot and manoeuvring in an anchorage
                                                   IMPORTANT SKILLS                                       Masters can only do this with confidence
                                                                                                      if they have trained for such scenarios via
to docking and un-docking and handling the         THERE IS - AND THERE                               a simulated environment, manned model
vessel in heavy weather, to name just a few.                                                          or in-service training. Only through these
    If the tasks at hand are not suitable for
                                                   IS NO SUBSTITUTE FOR                               type of training exercises can the Master
officers to do on the spot, it is important        EXPERIENCE.                                        recognise a dangerous manoeuvre from
to take time wherever possible to teach                                                               a safe manoeuvre. Otherwise, they might
them about the art of shiphandling through                                                            hesitate to intervene until it is too late to
mentoring, including the deck cadets.              from my porthole.) He did pretty well making       reverse an avoidable situation.
    I believe each and every one of my             the right decisions by himself, although if he
officers deserves to possess this skill.           had taken the wrong actions, I would have          Seeking excellence
Also, if I am ever indisposed, I will have         taken over. He really felt proud about what        Most importantly, teachers and students
the peace of mind of knowing that I have           he was able to do and appreciative of the          should appreciate that learning is a
ample numbers of deck officers to back             confidence that he gained under me.                dialogue. Only through efficient teaching,
me up. By training and putting my trust in             There was also an instance when                proper application of skills and sincere
these officers, they can develop the kind of       I allowed the deck cadet to manoeuvre              mentoring can growth be attained. Admiral
confidence that will take them to the highest      the vessel (under my supervision) inside           Grace Hopper couldn’t have been more
levels of their chosen profession.                 the anchorage to drop anchor. He was               correct in saying, ‘A ship in port is safe,
    Whenever a ship’s safe navigation is           able to do it safely and in accordance with        but that’s not what ships are built for.’ Like
threatened, e.g. when needing to avoid             my expectations.                                   the ship, you are built to be more than who
other watercraft, it is important to be                A critical manoeuvring situation can arise     you are today.
resourceful by using all available means at        if a ship approaches a dock too quickly.              You should seek consistently for
your disposal (such as the ship’s whistle,         Masters can intervene effectively with the         excellence in everything you do and
fog horn, helm, Aldis lamp and main engine         Pilot in this case, using the appropriate skills   never settle for mediocrity. With this as
as necessary). When in doubt, it is never          and maintaining confidence.                        your mindset, you will have a sense of
harmful to call a colleague to assist, even if         Observe the practices used by the              ownership of the great responsibility
you have been given full autonomy during a         different Pilots you have worked with              that you have to fulfil as global maritime
watchkeeping shift.                                onboard, learn from the techniques they are        professionals moving the world.
This is a summary of the main points. Want to know more? You can download the complete report from the UK MAIB at https://tinyurl.com/navigator17
                                          If you find our accident reports useful, check out The Nautical Institute’s Mariners’ Alerting and Reporting Scheme (MARS). A fully
                                          searchable database of incident reports and lessons, updated every month. Seen a problem yourself? Email the editor at
Mariners’ Alerting and Reporting Scheme   mars@nautinst.org and help others learn from your experience. All reports are confidential – we will never identify you or your ship.
  Shiphandling in action
  Chief Officer Chris Lamperts describes his career path so far and gives his thoughts on the skills
  needed for safe and effective shiphandling
Fundamentally, shiphandling is all about           Check, check and check again                     radio communications is also key, as well as
making safe and effective navigational             To ensure your own reaction is as good           ‘stored’ digital and paper-based data, such
decisions. Since a ship’s manoeuvres               as it possibly can be, it is vitally important   as charted and tidal information.
are affected and limited by the vessel’s           to keep checking the correlation of all the          We have to be cautious about relying
capabilities within the immediate                  available information. Critical information      on data from any single source. However,
environment (including wind, currents and          is received from many sources, including         if data from multiple sources is well
sea-state), navigational decisions must            what everyone on the bridge can see, hear        correlated, your perception of the situation
take into account how the ship will actually       and feel in terms of ‘body-acceleration’.        is far more likely to reflect reality. This will
handle in the particular circumstances.            Of course, onboard electronic sensors are        improve the validity of any manoeuvring
Making the best navigational decisions             very important, not least those detecting        decisions and make a successful outcome
requires increasingly expert shiphandling          changes in movement, such as rate-of-turn        far more likely, even in the tightest
knowledge as the situation intensifies.            indicators. Information from digital and voice   conditions. Our safety at sea is dominated
    Scientists and naval architects fully                                                           by the immediate position and movement
understand the detailed physics and                                                                 of the vessel we are on, even if the degree
mathematics needed to work out how a                                                                of control that we have is limited by external
specific vessel would behave in a given set                                                         conditions and the vessel’s specific design.
of circumstances. However, it is not practical                                                          Of course, any adjustments made to
to try and make accurate calculations of                                                            a ship’s controls affecting its speed and
this kind during a real-life shiphandling                                                           detailed rotation must be continuously
situation. Therefore, we rely on a                                                                  monitored against the external situation.
well-trained shiphandler to make                                                                          This allows you to refine the
good judgements about what actions                                                                          manoeuvring action, but it also
are needed to keep the ship safe.                                                                            adds to and reinforces your own
    These decisions must be based on                                                                         knowledge as a shiphandler, and will
a mixture of experience and the expert                                                                     help you when you encounter similar
use of proven concepts. For example, the                                                                 situations in the future.
concept of the pivot point is very important,
and the handler must have a good                                                                       To err is human…
understanding of this, including its effective                                                      Although we have our own expectations
position under differing circumstances.                                                             about how other vessels involved in a
    In close situations, primary navigational                                                       manoeuvre will react, what they will actually
concerns are the relative position of hazards                                                       do is a major unknown. It is not that the
and the speed and acceleration of your                                                              other vessels are being navigated badly
own ship relative to those hazards. Close                                                           – just that everybody occasionally makes
situations are particularly complex because                                                         mistakes. Even if the close-by vessel is
these relative values can vary significantly                                                        being navigated with equal competence
along both the length and beam of own                                                               to your own, remember that with two
vessel. Ships are too large to be considered                                                        ships, there is now double the possibility
a ‘single point’ in such situations – as is true                                                    of human and machine errors that could
of many hazards at sea. The question, ‘What                                                         affect your safety. Never assume that your
is your location?’ is not as easy to answer as                                                      own immediate response is the end of the
simply giving a lat/long coordinate.                                                                situation. Keep alert…
 Contact RIN at: www.rin.org.uk | 1 Kensington Gore, London, SW7 2AT | Tel: +44 (0)20 7591 3134
10 | The Navigator | February 2018
               10
take                                                                  5
                                                                      What turns a ship?
                                                                      It’s not just the rudder, all forces must be used and balanced,
                                                                      including propulsion, environment and dynamic forces.
1
Number one skill
                                                                      7
                                                                      Plan
Shiphandling skills are probably the navigator’s greatest skills –    Having a plan is crucial to success. Anticipating how the ship
both in terms of professional pride and consequences should           will behave will help you to carry out that plan.
things go wrong.
2                                                                     8
                                                                      No need for speed
Practice                                                              When berthing a ship, the faster you go, the longer it will take.
Shiphandling is probably one of the most difficult skills to master
                                                                      9
as it comes from practice – which is hard to find time for, or
specialist training – which is costly.
3
                                                                      Keep calm
                                                                      A calm, measured approach will instil confidence in the bridge
                                                                      team and get you in the correct position more quickly and with
Mentoring                                                             far less drama.
Be a mentor if you can and get a mentor if you can; learning on
                                                                      10
the job is the best way of learning to handle a ship.
4
Watch and reflect
                                                                      Logbook
                                                                      Keeping a logbook of your practice manoeuvres is invaluable.
                                                                      It allows you and your mentor to reflect on your success,
Even if you can’t handle a ship yourself, watch others, such as       demonstrates to others your capability, identifies gaps in your
the Master or Pilot, to learn what to do – or not to do… Taking       experience that may require extra training, and is a document
time to reflect on what went right and what could be improved is      to take professional pride in. The Nautical Institute provides
a powerful learning tool.                                             specialist logbooks for shiphandling.
                                                                                                                                                Tapan Bachch
                                                                                                                                                     an
                                                                                                                                       N vi gator CHAM
                                                                                                                                                                   PION
UPGR ADE
YOUR
FUTURE
                                                                                          The Nautical Institute Shiphandling Logbook is aimed at helping you to record and
                                                                                          improve your shiphandling experience (but not at teaching you how to do it!) It
                                                                                          identifies the manoeuvres that you need to master, and helps you logically deconstruct
                                                                                          and reflect on what happened and why. This is where the best learning takes place.
                                                         tions?
                                 technology & new regula
   Can you keep up with new                 pro spe cts?
                           rov  e you r job
   Want to network & imp
                              decision making?
   Want a direct line to IMO
                               ition?
   Want professional recogn
              def  ence insu ran  ce?
   Want legal
                             tions?
    Want 30% off NI publica                                                               Available for £35 from
                                 tin st .o rg                                             www.nautinst.org/shop
    jo in to da y at w w w .n au
     WE’LL GE T YOU THERE
                                                                                          10% discount for The Navigator readers.
                                                                                          Email pubs.admin@nautinst.org with code NAV10