N vigator            Inspiring professionalism in marine navigators
Situational awareness
         The sense of everything
     A free publication by The Nautical Institute in
     association with the Royal Institute of Navigation
                                                                                                                     David Patraiko FNI
                                                                                       Director of Projects, The Nautical Institute
 Situational Awareness
 We are always being told about the                    risk of overload in yourself and others and to       is being aware that you might not have
 importance of situational awareness, and it           have a plan B such as delegating, prioritising       all the facts necessary – or perhaps even
 really is absolutely critical for the navigator.      or calling the Master for assistance.                noticing and coping with the fact that some
 So much of Bridge Resource Management                     Good situational awareness is not                of the information you have is incorrect.
 is about ensuring situational awareness,              just about observing something in the                Chart data can be wrong, particularly if it is
 and operating as a team to fill in any gaps           environment, but being able to correctly             old or changed by environmental factors.
 in our own perception, sharing our mental             identify it and how best to deal with it.            GNSS systems can be interrupted or even
 picture of what is going on and what                  This is where experience comes into play,            spoofed, AIS data can be incorrect and
 should happen next.                                   and why it is important to learn from all            radar data can be misinterpreted.
     Maintaining good situational awareness            your encounters. They will prepare you                   Good situational awareness should be a
 can be challenging and there are many                 for similar situations in the future. In the         shared activity. When working with a team,
 things on a bridge that can cause distraction         accident report on page 8 there is an                share your observations. Don’t assume that
 or overload. ‘Look out of the window’                 unfortunate example of how inexperienced             everyone has the same mental picture as
 is a classic mantra – and one which                   officers were not able to identify a tanker          you, or even that your own mental picture is
 The Navigator continues to emphasise.                 coming off its berth as a moving object,             correct. In many instances good situational
 Remember, though, that human vision is                leading to huge damages and a sinking.               awareness is just common sense, but it is a
 not perfect and needs to be complemented                  Navigators must be aware of everything           sense that can be refined with practice and
 with other tools such as radar, AIS, and even         around them. Certainly, you must look                benefits from experience and a good attitude.
 listening to VHF radio traffic. At the same           ahead – but don’t forget to look behind                  As always, The Navigator magazine
 time, it is very possible for navigators to           you for overtaking threats. Watch the sky            is about sharing knowledge and starting
 become overloaded with target information,            for weather and be aware of what is below            discussions. Please share this magazine
 especially if there are also other tasks going        your keel and where unseen risks might be            and your thoughts with your team
 on on the bridge. It is important to identify the     lying. A big part of situational awareness           members for the benefit of all.
  03 ALL AT SEA                                    at The Nautical             how we can make it work to               in the world – and the
  Contributions and                                Institute, discusses        our advantage                            most scared!
  comments from                                    why good situational
                                                                               08 WATCH OUT                             10 WAY POINT
  readers of The                               awareness involves every
  Navigator                                    single one of our human         How inexperience and poor                Dr Andy Norris considers
                                          senses                               situational awareness on the             the significance of relative
  04–05 MAKING                                                                 bridge led to a collision at night       positioning.
  SENSE OF                                06–07 REVIEWING
  SITUATIONAL                             THE SITUATION                        09 WHO’S NAVIGATING?                     11 TAKE TEN
  AWARENESS                               Captain Andrew Liebmann              Third Officer Emma Carofano              Ten top tips to hone your
  David Patraiko,                         outlines what situational            on why her first day at sea              situational awareness skills
  Director of Projects                    awareness really means and           made her the happiest person             at sea
                                                                               Editorial committee:                     Published by
                                                                               Editor Emma Ward                         The Nautical Institute
                                                                               Design Phil McAllister                   The Navigator (Print) – ISSN 2058-6043
                                                                               For The Nautical Institute               The Navigator (Online) – ISSN 2058-6051
                   With support from: 1 Kensington Gore, London, SW7 2AT, UK   Bridget Hogan, Lucy Budd,                Printed in the UK by
                   Tel: +44 (0)20 7591 3134 Fax: +44 (0)20 7591 3131           David Patraiko FNI                       Stephens & George,
                   www.rin.org.uk                                              For the RIN Dr Andy Norris FRIN FNI      Merthyr Tydfil, UK
2 | The Navigator | February 2020
                                                                                                                                Emma Ward
We welcome your news, comments and opinions on the topics covered in The Navigator
If you would like to get in touch with us,
please contact the editor, Emma Ward                                                                         Working on board can be very draining. But
                                                                                                             witnessing the wonder of this colony of birds
at navigator@nautinst.org, or look out                                                                       taking shelter and flying around the ship
for the LinkedIn discussion. We look                                                                         absolutely lifts the spirits!
forward to hearing from you.                                                                                 Gil Gerarcas
                                                                                                             Songa Dream
                                                                     On the subject of bridge navigation               If one can remember that no-one
                                                                     safety, I believe we are starting to turn a   is infallible and that one is actually not
                                                                     corner. This is partly because of bridge      expected to know absolutely everything,
Get the app                                                          management styles changing and partly         it will go a long way towards bringing the
                                                                     because the youngsters coming up are far      whole team together. For instance, I’m a
                                                                     better educated on the dangers of over-       keen student of celestial navigation and
                                                                     reliance on electronics. A lot of the young   regularly use the sextant on board to keep
Join the debate on LinkedIn                                          deck officers are an enormous help to me      fresh. However, I totally understand that
https://www.linkedin.com/                                            on the IT front. They know far more than      it’s a dying art and never berate my junior
groups/1107227/                                                      me about running systems of equipment         officers for not always knowing too much
                                                                     and are keen to help when requested.          about it. That said, I encourage them to
Follow us on Twitter                                                     Being a Master on any vessel can          have a go if they show an interest and I’m
https://twitter.com/NauticalInst                                     be highly stressful and how this stress       happy to say most do.
                                                                     is handled can make a huge difference.            Keep up the good work!
We are active on Facebook                                            Back in the day, the ‘Old Man’ was            Paul Kersey
https://www.facebook.com/                                            someone to be in awe of. They could do        Master, P&O Maritime Logistics
                                                                     no wrong, never made mistakes and,
thenauticalinstitute                                                 even when they did occasionally, to pull
Watch our videos on You Tube                                         them up on it as a junior was a decidedly
                                                                     dodgy area.
http://www.youtube.com/
                                                                         Nowadays, I believe things have
TheNauticalInstitute                                                 changed a lot.
                                                                         I totally encourage all my crew and
You can read a digital version of The
                                                                     especially the bridge team to question
Navigator, or download it in PDF format at                           me at any time if they are not sure what
http://www.nautinst.org/publications                                 I’m doing or why I’m doing it. Tool
                                                                     box talks and pre-voyage briefings
                                                                     are a great way of letting everyone
                                                                     know what’s expected and what the
                                                                     contingencies are. Just because as
                                                                     Master you have overall responsibility
                                                                     that does not mean you have to shut
                                                                     yourself off from valuable resources,
                                                                     such as a young OOW fresh out of
                                                                     college with all the new innovations
                                                                     and ideas still freshly imprinted.
We welcome your news, comments and opinions on the topics
covered in The Navigator. We reserve the right to edit letters for
space reasons if necessary. Views expressed by letter contributors
do not necessarily reflect those held by The Nautical Institute      Find us on social media and let us know what you think #NautInst
                                                                                                                                   February 2020 | The Navigator | 3
    Making sense of
    situational awareness
    David Patraiko, Director of Projects for The
    Nautical Institute, examines what good situational
    awareness looks like and why it involves every
    single one of our human senses – including that
    all-important sixth sense
4 | The Navigator | February 2020
G
                ood situational awareness is     No ‘I’ in TEAM                                 optics and Augmented Reality (AR) to try to
                about how you perceive the       When things get busy, it may not be            ‘improve’ mariners’ situational awareness.
                environment around you, how      possible for one person to maintain good       The challenge for the industry will be to
                you understand it and how you    situational awareness alone. There are         develop these systems so they are fit for
                are aware of the ways in which   just too many things to take account           purpose, and then ensure mariners are well
that environment will change with time. Good     of. Instead, the task must be shared           trained in their use and understand their
situational awareness is important to humans     among the team. It may be necessary to         strengths and weaknesses.
at all times, but it is especially important     have people focused solely on lookout,
to mariners, and navigators in particular.       navigation, communication and collision        Check your understanding
Critical decisions for your own safety and the   avoidance. In these cases, all members         It is important for navigators to focus on
safety of the ship rely on your having good      of the bridge team need to communicate         ensuring good situational awareness, and to
situational awareness.                           effectively so the officer in charge can       recognise signs of its loss in themselves and
    For the best situational awareness, it       maintain overall situational awareness.        others. One positive indicator is that team
is important to use all your senses: sight,      For example, if the ship is picking up a       members are cross-checking systems with
hearing, smell, touch – even taste. Some         pilot or approaching a dock, is someone        other systems or observations. What might
would argue that good situational awareness      monitoring the other sectors to ensure         this look like in practice?
also includes an elusive ‘sixth sense’, where    there are no surprises?                             Do members of the bridge team share
a ‘gut feeling’ based on experience can offer        Many accident reports cite loss of         information and try to ensure that that they
real insights. Not all senses are used equally   situational awareness as the root cause.       have a shared ‘mental image’? For example,
but they must all be taken into account to       Good situational awareness is not a state      when a lookout observes a light, does the
help us recognise, organise and understand       of being; it is an activity that needs to be   OOW check the radar (or vice versa)?
our environment. One report suggests that        focused on, discussed, and even trained for.        Does everyone try to anticipate risk and
30% of our brain cortex is devoted to seeing,    It has many enemies, including boredom,        compare ideas about contingency plans?
8% to touch and 3% to hearing.                   distraction and overload. Most ships ban            Do bridge officers monitor the weather
    On an individual basis, all mariners         personal mobile phones for this reason.        against forecasts and try to anticipate
should use all their senses all the time.            Situational awareness is a very            how a change in the weather may affect
Observing the weather will give an               human activity involving perception,           other departments on board and the
indication of predicted ship movement            comprehension and projection. Technology       seaworthiness of the vessel?
and risks. Hearing an odd sound may give         can aid us by offering additional sources of        Situational awareness, and the lack of
an indication of cargo coming loose – the        information. However, it can also become       it, is not limited to the maritime sector.
absence of sound has certainly woken me          confusing if too much emphasis is placed       Most car accidents can be traced to
from sleep (ship blackout)! Smells can warn      on adding more and more technology for         poor situational awareness and most
of burning or leaks, while even taste can be     its own sake. Today’s ship’s bridge bristles   industries have some sort of guidance
used to identify a contaminated water tank.      with more information sources than ever        on best practice. However, good
    On the bridge, situational awareness         before. Automatic plotting, weather/tidal      situational awareness is vitally important
is crucial for safe navigation and collision     overlays, MSI and even decision support        to mariners in all departments for all tasks,
avoidance. Sight is used both externally (out    systems for collision avoidance all aim to     even when asleep.
the window) and internally (Radar, ECDIS,        help navigators improve their situational           Take any opportunity to consider how
etc.) and is backed up by the sounds of          awareness. Sometimes they do, but              you can increase your own situational
alarms and VHF and the feel of vibrations,       sometimes they can distract.                   awareness, how you can check your
for example when running into shallow                The amount of data and information will    understanding of your environment and
water. Changes in smell can indicate             only increase, with some ships already using   risks, compare event forecasts with reality
problems with cargo.                             tools like Lidar, sonar, infrared, low light   and reflect on any differences you may find.
                                                                                                                   February 2020 | The Navigator | 5
 Reviewing the situation
              Master and Marine Consultant Captain Andrew Liebmann AFNI asks what situational
                  awareness means in reality, and how can we make it work to our advantage
6 | The Navigator | February 2020
S
              ituational awareness is the           detract from situational awareness include       immediately, instead of when we are
              opposite of tunnel vision. It’s the   the multitude of paper log books, nuisance       already turning into danger.
              difference between looking and        alarms and false alarms, poor ergonomics             I believe that the best way to achieve
              seeing. To maintain situational       or sight lines, the expectation that we          good situational awareness is a team
              awareness, at least one member        can ‘multitask’ items of lesser importance,      approach. This is partly because individuals
of the team needs to be looking away from           side conversations, fatigue and                  have a tendency to see what they expect
the area of primary focus, and making sure          uncomfortable environments.                      or want to see, and each of us has our
that there’s a ‘Big Picture’ observation.               The good news is that there have             own comfortable areas of focus – acting
    For instance: when everyone else is             been many procedural and technical               as a team cancels out these blind spots.
looking down at the ship’s side while               enhancements over the years that help            That does not relieve any member of the
docking, someone should be on the                   us achieve and maintain good situational         team from keeping the big picture in mind.
opposite side and reporting anything                awareness. For example, the modern               Even when seafarers operate alone, as
relevant. When planning an alteration               Integrated Bridge System (IBS) puts a            is increasingly the case (on the bridge,
to avoid a close quarters situation,                massive amount of information where              on deck or in the machinery spaces), we
checking astern and further past the                we can understand it visually (primarily         can employ personal techniques such as
immediate area can prevent the vessel               on ECDIS and radar screens). When                stopping to scan sensors and surroundings,
from altering away from one danger into             properly configured and well understood,         breaking tasks into smaller intermediate
another. If there is an emergency inside the        this allows for excellent interpretation         objectives and using appropriate checklists
ship, someone needs to keep navigating              of many sensors, giving a much more              for technically complex tasks. Even setting a
safely while it is addressed.                       complete understanding than the bad old          simple kitchen timer as a reminder to check
    Ideally, every individual in the team           days of manual measurements and paper            on a ballast transfer pump is a useful tool
should have good situational awareness,             plotting. CCTV cameras allow the quick           to help us break out of the tendency to get
but at minimum, team tasks should be                and accurate assessment of unmanned              absorbed in other tasks.
divided so that all relevant areas of focus         spaces and monitoring of machines, which
are given enough attention and there are            is useful for both normal operations and         Say what you see
no surprises. As Master, I try to delegate          emergency response.                              When there is no one to check your work,
as much of the detailed work (including                                                              verbalising observations and plans, as
conning, communicating, and recording)              Teamwork works                                   you do in BRM, is a good way to remain
to the lowest rank person who can handle            Procedure can also help us avoid traps.          conscious of what you are going to do. For
the job. This leaves the most experienced           I try to get all my bridge personnel to          instance, I was recently bringing a newbuild
person free to step back from the hands-on          name out loud the alarm we are silencing         ship on sea trials into a berth. During the
execution of any particular task. That allows       or cancelling. When the annoying beep            manoeuvre to get the ship lined up for
both the OOW and, if present, the Master to         sounds, it is all too easy to just mash the      final approach, I was looking astern and to
personally keep good situational awareness,         button that makes it go away, especially         starboard from one corner of the bridge, so
which can then be passed on to the team             when there are repetitive, false or irrelevant   I had my Chief Mate looking ahead and to
where appropriate. When I am focused on             alarms. This can lead to ignoring an             port from across the bridge.
a specific task (such as manoeuvring the            important alarm. Naming the alarm can                As I manipulated the controls and
ship onto the dock, or making complex               alert us to whether there is something that      monitored the way the wind was setting the
arrangements on the radio), having the              needs to be checked before the alarm is          ship, I reported what I was seeing, doing,
OOW look out and around is critical to my           dismissed. Of course, the endless quest to       and planning through long-established
peace of mind.                                      remove nuisance alarms also needs more           habit even though none of my team could
                                                    attention from our friends in the design and     hear me. Noting distances, speeds, and
Focus and drive                                     regulation parts of the industry.                planned actions out loud kept me in the
As we gain more experience and                          Even standard Bridge Resource                routine of thinking through my cycle of
proficiency, we can keep track of more              Management (BRM) practices are often             observation, intention, execution and back
(and more complex) tasks without losing             under-appreciated aids to maintaining            to observation.
situational awareness. When we start our            good situational awareness. When the                 Losing situational awareness can be
careers, even a simple task like steering a         OOW announces what he or she sees,               catastrophic. I have had the experience of
compass course may require every bit of our         and states his or her planned actions,           being surprised by something that could
focus, and we might lose track of what else         the whole team shares a mental model             have been noticed earlier. By adopting good
is happening around us if we are not part           that ensures we all have good situational        design, policy, and practice we can develop
of an effective team. Knowing the abilities         awareness. When the OOW corrects                 and maintain good situational awareness.
of each team member helps keep everyone             my mistakes, it is because they are              That should make those surprises rarer and
from being overloaded.                              checking what I am saying rather than            less severe. Finally, to the old salts who
    There are many threats to situational           just accepting it. Instinctively checking the    actually remember plotting positions on a
awareness, and we should do all                     response from a helm, engine, or thruster        chart, good situational awareness is a sign
we can to combat them. Things that                  order means we catch a malfunction               that you have not ‘lost the plot!’
                                                                                                                        February 2020 | The Navigator | 7
In this series, we take a look at maritime accident reports and the lessons that can be learned
Inexperience and poor situational
awareness led to collision
     What happened?                                          Why did it happen?                                        What changes have been made?
     A frigate was heading south through                             he OOW and other bridge
                                                                    T                                                      Improved training around situational
     confined waters at approximately 18                            officers on the frigate were young                      awareness, watch-standing and
     knots. It was dark, but visibility was                         and inexperienced. Poor overall                         teamwork on the bridge has
     otherwise clear and weather conditions                         communication, organisation                            been implemented
     good. The frigate’s officers notified the                      and teamwork further exacerbated                     Career paths for officers on the frigate
     local VTS that they were entering the                          the situation                                         have been reconsidered to allow
     area. However, the vessel’s AIS system                     The deck lights on the tanker                            officers to gain time for training and
     was set in passive mode, meaning that                       obscured its navigational lights,                        experience before they are promoted
     no AIS signals were being transmitted.                      making it harder for the frigate to                      The use of AIS on the frigate has been
         About an hour after the frigate                         identify it as a moving vessel                            reviewed, as has the use of deck
     entered the VTS area, an oil tanker was                     The frigate officers did not use                         lights on the tanker to avoid obscuring
     preparing to leave a terminal in the same                    technical aids to inform and correct                     navigational lights in future
     stretch of water and move northwards.                        their flawed situational awareness,
     VTS assumed that the two vessels were                        relying instead on their own perceived
     aware of each other and would work                           view of the situation
     together to avoid collision. The operator                    The VTS operator received the report           There is an excellent summary and
     did not inform other nearby vessels of                        of the frigate entering the area, but did      animation of the incident at
     the tanker’s intention to depart.                             not monitor the area closely enough,           https://www.youtube.com/
         The tanker’s bridge officers spotted                      nor inform vessels in the area of the          watch?v=HVGe6ltIxQs
     the frigate moving towards them but                           tanker’s intention to depart.                  – we recommend having a look!
     assumed that the OOW had seen                                 The frigate’s AIS was in passive
     them too and would change course.                              mode, preventing the tanker or
     Unfortunately, the OOW and two other                           any other vessels from seeing
     key members of the bridge team                                 transmitted signals.
     mistook the deck lights on the tanker
     for a stationary object. They did not
     make use of the technical tools at their
     disposal to double check this, and
     proceeded as if the tanker was not
     moving. This brought them right into the
     path of the vessel.
         No-one on the frigate was aware of                                THE FRIGATE OFFICERS RELIED ON
     the mistake until it was too late. The
     two vessels collided, causing damage,
                                                                           THEIR OWN PERCEIVED VIEW OF
     water ingress and some minor injuries.                                THE SITUATION, iNSTEAD OF USING
                                                                           TECHNICAL AIDS THAT COULD HAVE
                                                                           HELPED HIGHLIGHT THE DANGER.
                   The Nautical Institute’s Mariners’ Alerting and Reporting Scheme (MARS) - https://www.nautinst.org/resource-library/mars.html - comprises a fully
                   searchable database of incident reports and lessons, updated every month. If you have witnessed an accident or seen a problem, email Captain
                   Paul Drouin at mars@ nautinst.org and help others learn from your experience. All reports are confidential – we will never identify you or your ship.
8 | The Navigator | February 2020
Like father, like daughter: life on
the ocean wave
Navigation officer, Anna Carofano, discusses how her father’s career inspired her to follow her sea-faring dreams, what
it’s like to work on a cruise ship and how fatigue can often be the biggest threat to effective situational awareness
What interested you in a career at sea?                                                      lead to a lack of situational awareness.
You know the saying, ‘follow in your                                                         Eliminating tiredness is impossible, but
father’s footsteps’? Well, that’s what I did!                                                monitoring how people are coping with
My father is a bosun on board ferries and                                                    it is the best way to avoid accidents. On
I have always been fascinated by his job.                                                    our ship, fatigue levels are monitored
I think he found it hard at first to have his                                                continuously, making sure that everyone
only daughter away from him, but I’m sure                                                    has enough hours of rest, opportunities
that now he is very proud of me! I love                                                      to spend time with other people and the
the sea and I love to travel and share my                                                    chance to go out and explore the ports
culture with different nationalities, so this is                                             we are visiting.
the perfect job for me.
                                                                                             How do you personally ensure
What career path has led to your                                                             you practise good situational
current position?                                                                            awareness?
I started at nautical school when I was                                                      I try to maintain high situational
13. After finishing my studies, I sailed                                                     awareness by knowing what is going on
on a chemical tanker as a deck cadet. I                                                      around me and using the three ‘levels’
remember my first day on board, when I                                                       of perception, comprehension and
was the happiest person in the world, but                                                    projection. I always ask myself: ‘What is
also the most scared! After working for a                                                    happening? What does it mean and what
while on tankers, I joined the cruise ship                                                   might happen next?’ Today’s bridges are
family, where my life changed completely,          WORKING FOR A CRUISE                      highly advanced with lots of screens and
once again.                                        SHIP… GIVES YOU THE                       information, but I always remember to
                                                                                             watch what’s going on outside in the ‘real
What do you like best about working                CHANCE TO EXPLORE                         world’ as well, and to share my thoughts
at sea?                                            DIFFERENT PARTS OF                        with the rest of my team.
Usually on board ship we have more than
100 different nationalities and thanks
                                                   THE WORLD AND TO                          What do you think the wider
to this, I now know more about many                SHARE SOME AMAZING                        maritime industry could do to help
                                                                                             navigators hone their situational
different cultures and mentalities. Working
for a cruise ship also gives you the chance
                                                   EXPERIENCES WITH                          awareness skills?
to explore different parts of the world and        OTHER PEOPLE                              The maritime industry is doing a lot for
to share some amazing experiences with                                                       young navigators, improving our skills with
other people. What a wonderful job!                all be in different watches with senior   specific training and investments in our
                                                   officers. During the watches we must      future. What could be improved further,
How does your current position differ              focus and be able to multitask without    however, is the background. We only
from your previous role?                           being worried to speak up and give our    begin much of our main training after our
I’m currently a Third Officer, which is very       opinion as necessary.                     time as a cadet, which doesn’t allow us a
different from being a deck cadet. When                                                      lot of time to understand what situational
you are a cadet, your goal is to learn as          What do you think is the biggest          awareness is like in a real-life situation. It
much as you can because, once you are              threat to good situational awareness      would be much better to learn more about
in my current position, there is far less          on board?                                 situational awareness during nautical
time to ask questions! We usually have             When an officer is affected by fatigue    college, even before joining a ship for the
three Third Officers on board, who must            or an overdose of information, this can   very first time.
                                                                                                                February 2020 | The Navigator | 9
                                                                                        Dr Andy Norris FRIN FNI
Critical positioning
Dr Andy Norris, an active Fellow of The Nautical Institute and the Royal Institute of Navigation, examines
the significance of relative position-based sensors for improving situational awareness
Information based on absolute                                                                          check on the integrity of displayed
position – knowing where you are                                                                         absolute position data, including
on the surface of the earth – is                                                                         most charted features. However,
highly important to safe navigation.                                                                     you should also bear in mind the
So, too, is relative position – where              NEVER PUT 100% RELIANCE                            particular weaknesses of such aids
you are in relation to everything else in             ON THE POSITIONAL                          when assessing the complete scene.
the area, including other vessels,                  ACCURACY OF CHARTED                          Not least, the further away the target is,
navigational aids and any hazards to                                                             the more their performance degrades,
                                                   FEATURES. THE SITUATION
navigation. Good situational awareness                                                           declining steadily to zero. It is possible to
should make use of both.                             MIGHT HAVE CHANGED                          jam or spoof most relative position sensors
    The concept of absolute position was            SINCE THE LAST SURVEY                        available today, but in reality this is rarely
developed some centuries ago, with the                                                           encountered outside of war zones.
realisation that the Earth was near-spherical,
and that astronomical objects, such as the                                                       Into the future
Sun, stars and planets, could be used (when                                                      In the future, inertial sensors will increasingly
visible) to determine the unique position of                                                     contribute to the safety of maritime
the observer on the Earth’s surface.             Some transmissions could even be spoofs.        navigation, including enhancing the
    GNSS is based on a very similar basic        Even when this information is accurate, AIS     accuracy of transmitted AIS data. They are
concept to astronavigation but, of course,       does not tell the whole story. Numerous         relative position based aids that determine
gives massively higher accuracy and              navigational hazards do not transmit AIS        the actual movement of the vessel from
availability. Not least, AIS allows vessels      information, including many small craft         any known position and are achieving ever
and navigational marks to transmit their         and navigational marks – and, not least,        greater accuracy. This enables an estimate
own determined absolute position to all          floating or submerged wreckage. Never put       of the vessel’s current absolute position
vessels in the vicinity, greatly aiding safe     100% reliance on the positional accuracy of     to be independently and automatically
navigation for everyone.                         charted features, either. The situation might   determined, potentially over hours or even
    However, we should never rely too much       have changed since the last survey.             days. Importantly, they are totally immune to
on the integrity of any information that is          Real-time hazard avoidance is               jamming and spoofing.
solely referenced to absolute position.          fundamentally based on relative position:           Unfortunately, they will not prevent
Even when using multiple satellite services,     how far away are any potential hazards          spoof data being transmitted from other
there are many possibilities for significant     in the area, and what is their bearing and      vessels. Therefore, the optical, radar and
inaccuracies when estimating our own             relative speed? Key navigational aids, such     sonar scenes will remain just as important
absolute position. These include failure         as the human eye, radar and sonar, all give     as they are today.
to receive signals from satellites in certain    independent estimates of the presence and           GNSS, when sensibly used, makes
areas and the ever-growing menace of             relative motion of potential hazards, with      a valuable contribution to the safety of
GNSS jamming and spoofing.                       no fundamental dependency on GNSS               navigation, but we must always bear in
                                                 and/or knowing their absolute position.         mind its weaknesses and the fact that
Proceed with caution                             Neither do they need any additional             collision avoidance is fundamentally based
Positional information received by AIS           information from the target, although           on the concept of relative navigation. The
should always be treated with caution.           detecting the target can be greatly aided       importance of always using information
We have no knowledge of whether the              by lights and radar reflectors, etc.            from relative position based sensors when
equipment on the vessel sending the signal           Navigation aids based on relative           making real-time navigational decisions
has been properly set up and maintained.         position provide a totally independent          must never be overlooked.
 Contact RIN at: www.rin.org.uk | 1 Kensington Gore, London, SW7 2AT | Tel: +44 (0)20 7591 3134
10 | The Navigator | February 2020
              10
take                                                                5
                                                                    Overburdening
                                                                    It is easy to become distracted and lose situational awareness
                                                                    on the bridge of a ship. Know how to spot it in yourself and
                                                                    others and have a plan to deal with it.
                                                                    6
                                                                    Under burdening
                                                                    It is possible to lose situational awareness when things become
                                                                    quiet. Find ways to keep yourself focused and alert. Unforeseen
                                                                    events at sea can be devastating!
Ten top tips for improving and enhancing
your situational awareness on board
                                                                    7
                                                                    Fake news
                                                                    Not all information is correct. Chart data can be inaccurate,
                                                                    AIS data can be wrong and, in this cyber age, misinformation
1
                                                                    can be given.
Most important
Situational awareness is absolutely critical to navigators. You
need to be aware of your environment at all times, understand it
                                                                    8
                                                                    Be aware on board
and then act correctly.                                             Situational awareness is just as important off the bridge. A good
                                                                    mariner is always alert to unexpected smells, vibrations, noises,
2
                                                                    and ship movements. Learn to trust your sixth sense and don’t
                                                                    ignore the sense that something just isn't right.
                                                                    9
All available means
Use all available means, all your senses (eyes, ears, touch, nose
etc…) and all available tools (Radar, AIS, GNSS, radio, etc…)
                                                                    Learn from others
3
                                                                    Poor situational awareness is often cited in accident
                                                                    investigation reports. Learn from these reports, whether they
                                                                    are from The Nautical Institute in MARS, other industry schemes
Always question                                                     such as Maritime CHIRP, or national reports such as the UK
Always seek to test your understanding of the environment by        MAIB, US NTSB or Australia’s ATSB.
cross checking. Try never to trust just one sense or tool.
4                                                                   10
                                                                    Mentoring
Share with others                                                   Situational awareness can be continually improved and
Share your observations and interpretations with others in your     taught to others. Work with your team to improve your skills.
team, never assume that they have seen something as well, or        Experience is key to making sense of your environment and
that your interpretation is the best.                               making good decisions.
                                                                                              #NavInspire
                                                                                                            February 2020 | The Navigator | 11
                               W I N A N i PA D                                at or  on  Tw   itt er, in clu ding the hashtag #N
                                                                                                                                   AVsnap,
                                                      you with your Navig                    o attached (www.fa
                                                                                                                       cebook.com/
                               Just post a picture of              ok  wi th  yo ur   ph  ot                                 have one. Let us
                                                   ge on Facebo                                        your college, if you
                               or send us a messa                       m   e  of  yo  ur  sh  ip  or
                                                                                                                               in the draw,
                                                     and tell us the na                                   ryone gets entered
                               thenauticalinstitute)                         l In st itu te , to o  (e ve
                                                       ber of The Nautica                  e information in an
                                                                                                                      email!
                                know if you’re a mem            no t!) Or  se  nd  us   th
                                                      ember or
                                whether you are a m
AND the winner
                                         this issue is…
Our Navsnap winner
                     for this issue is Geor
from the bridge of LN                       ge. He sends us this
                      G tanker LNG Akwa                          photo
                                           Ibom.
                                                                                                           @coolgeorge8
                                                                                                                  4
                                                                                                    N vi gator CHAM
                                                                                                                           PION