Crystallization PDF
Crystallization PDF
Crystallization PDF
CRYSTALLISATION
293 K (20o C) is 35.5 kg MgSO4 per 100 kg water. Solubility data are plotted as solubility
curves-curves wherein solubilities are plotted against temperature.
The solubility of the solute in a given solvent is different at different temperatures
and it forms the basis of crystallisation by cooling.
Saturation :
Consider a process of dissolving copper sulphate in water (solvent) at a given
temperature. Initially, when some amount of copper sulphate is added, all of it goes in the
solution (i.e., it dissolves in water). Additional amount can be dissolved further till a stage
comes when no more copper sulphate can be dissolved in a given amount (i.e. a fixed
amount) of the solvent. At this stage, the solution is called a saturated solution.
A saturated solution is defined as the one which is in equilibrium with an excess of solid
solute at a given temperature.
If the temperature of the solution is increased, more solute [CuSO4] can be dissolved.
Therefore, a saturated solution will contain different amounts of the solute dissolved in it at
different temperatures. When a saturated solution at a higher temperature (say at T1) is
cooled to a lower temperature say to T2, then theoretically the amount of the solute
corresponding to the difference in solubilities of the solute at these two temperatures will
come out of the solution in the form of crystals.
Solubility Curves :
A graphical relationship between the solubility of a solute and temperature is termed as
the solubility curve.
The concentration necessary for crystal formation and chemical species that separate can
be determined from solubility curves. Such curves are obtained by plotting the solubility of a
solute as a function of temperature (solubilities against temperature). It shows the effect of
temperature on the solubility of the solute. The solubility of solutes in a given solvent may
increase, decrease, or remains more or less constant with temperature. Solubility curves have
no general shape or slope.
O
Parts solute/100 parts water
. H2
SO4
Fe
2O
FeS
Curve 4
4 .7
H
Solubility curves of potassium chlorate, sodium chloride are continuous solubility curves
as they show no sharp breaks anywhere. Sometime, the solubility curve exhibit sudden
changes of direction and these curves are therefore referred to as discontinuous solubility
curves, e.g., that of FeSO4, Na2SO4, etc.
For some substances, their solubility decreases with increase in temperature and
in such cases their solubility curves are called as inverted solubility curves (e.g., that of
MnSO4 · H2O in H2O).
Usually, an increase in temperature of the solution increases the solubility of the solute
when no true compounds are formed between the solute and solvent, e.g., KClO3, KNO3 in
H2O. In case of a hydrated salt, the solubility increases with increase in temperature over a
certain temperature range and then decreases. Fig. 11.1 shows solubility curves for a number
of salts in water. In case of potassium chlorate, the solubility increases with temperature so it
can be readily crystallised by cooling its saturated solution. The solubility of NaCl in water is
almost independent of temperature (a slight increase in the solubility results by a large
increase in temperature), so for crystallisation to occur, some of the solvent should be
evaporated.
Supersaturation :
Consider an equilibrium solution (solid solute + liquid solvent). If we disturb this
equilibrium either by cooling the solution or evaporating a portion of the solvent, then the
quantity of solute will exceed the equilibrium concentration and the system will try to attain
a new state of equilibrium by expelling (precipitating) an excess solute present in it in the
form of crystals. This process of forming crystals is called crystallisation from solution and
the concentration difference driving force is called supersaturation.
Supersaturation : It is the quantity of solute present in a solution (in which crystals are
growing) compared with the quantity of solute that is in equilibrium with the solution
(i.e., the equilibrium solubility at the temperature under consideration). The supersaturation
is expressed as a coefficient, given as
(Parts solute / 100 parts solvent) at prevailing condition
s = (Parts solute / 100 parts solvent) at equilibrium ≥ 1.0
Crystallisation cannot take place/occur (i.e., crystals can neither form nor grow) unless a
solution is supersaturated. The amount of crystals formed however depend upon the
difference in saturation concentration since once the crystallisation begins the extra solute
held in the solution due to supersaturation also comes out of the solution in the form of
crystals.
Mechanism of crystallisation / crystal formation :
A knowledge of the mechanism by which crystals form and grow is required in the
design and operation of an equipment used for crystallisation. The formation of a crystal
from a solution is a two-step process.
The first step is called nucleation (the birth of new small particles or nuclei) and the
second one is called crystal growth (growth of crystals to macroscopic size).
Unit Operations – II 11.4 Crystallisation
The generation of a new solid phase (i.e., new small particles) either on an inert material
in the solution or in the solution itself is called nucleation. The increase in size of these
nuclei with a layer-by-layer addition of solute is called crystal growth. Supersaturation is the
common driving force for nucleation and crystal growth. Crystals can neither form nor grow
unless a solution is supersaturated.
The number of nuclei formed and the rate of growth of crystals depend upon the
temperature of operation. The number of nuclei and growth rate of crystals increase with
increase in temperature upto a certain point and then decreases. The temperature
corresponding to a maximum number of nuclei formation is different than the temperature at
which a growth rate is maximum.
If initially a large number of nuclei is formed, then the yield of the process contains many
small or tiny crystals and if a few nuclei are formed initially (at the start), then the yield of
the process contains large size crystals. Slow cooling results in the formation of a less
number of nuclei and hence large size crystals are formed (as the material deposits on a
relatively few nuclei), whereas rapid cooling results in the/leads to the formation of a large
number of nuclei, giving the yield containing a large number of tiny crystals.
Methods of Supersaturation :
Unless a solution is supersaturated, neither nucleation nor crystal growth occurs
(i.e., crystals can neither form nor grow). Thus, for crystallisation to occur, supersaturation
can be generated by any one of the following methods :
(a) By cooling a concentrated, hot solution through indirect heat exchange.
(b) By evaporating a part of the solvent/By evaporating a solution.
(c) By adiabatic evaporation and cooling (i.e., by vacuum cooling) : by flashing of a
feed solution adiabatically to a lower temperature and inducing/causing
crystallisation by simultaneous cooling and evaporation of the solvent.
(d) By adding a new substance (i.e., a third substance) which reduces the solubility of
the original solute, i.e., by salting.
(e) By chemical reaction with a third substance.
When the solubility of the solute increases with increase in temperature, a saturated
solution becomes supersaturated, i.e., supersaturation is generated by cooling and
temperature reduction. This is the case with many inorganic salts and organic substances
(e.g. potassium nitrate, potassium chlorate, oxalic acid, etc.). When the solubility of the
solute is relatively independent of temperature (as is the case with common salt (NaCl) in
H2O), supersaturation is generated by evaporating a part of the solvent. When the solubility
of the solute is very high then neither cooling nor evaporation helps and supersaturation may
be generated by adding a new substance (a third component). The added component may get
mixed physically with the original solvent to form a mixed solvent in which the solubility of
the solute is reduced. This technique is called salting. The third component added may react
with the original solute and form an insoluble substance. This technique is called
precipitation and it is used in wet quantitative analysis. The rapid creation of very large
Unit Operations – II 11.5 Crystallisation
D C
CDE path
Q of solution
on cooling
E
B
Temperature
Fig. 11.2 : The Miers' Supersaturation Theory
Yield of crystallisation process :
Usually, crystallisation processes are carried out slowly and the mother liquor is in
contact with sufficiently large crystals so that at the end of the process, the mother liquor is
saturated at the final temperature. In such cases, the yield of crystallization process is
calculated from the initial solution composition and the solubility of the solute material at the
final temperature. If appreciable evaporation of the solvent occurs during the crystallisation
process, the solvent evaporated must be taken into account in determining the yield.
Whenever crystals are anhydrous, the yield is obtained by taking the difference between the
initial composition of the solution and the solubility of the solute corresponding the final
Unit Operations – II 11.6 Crystallisation
temperature of the process. In cases where material precipitates as a hydrated salt, we have to
take into account the water of crystallisation (in crystals), as this water is not available for
retaining solute in the solution. Under these circumstances, the key to the calculations of
yields is to express all the compositions in terms of hydrated salt and excess water (free
water), as the excess water remains constant during crystallisation operation and the
compositions or amounts thus expressed on the basis of excess water can be deducted in
order to obtain the correct results.
The percentage yield of a crystallisation process is the amount of the solute crystallised/
expressed as a percentage of the amount of the solute present in the feed solution.
Crystal form :
The constituent particles of a crystal are arranged in an orderly and repetitive manner.
The constituent particles may be atoms, molecules or ions. They are arranged in orderly three
dimensional arrays called space lattices. Crystals are classified according to the angle
between the faces and this is the area of the science of crystallography. Different forms of
crystals based upon the angle between faces and lengths of axes are : cubic, tetragonal,
orthorhombic, hexagonal, monoclinic, triclinic and trigonal.
Caking of Crystals :
Caking of crystalline materials is caused by a small amount of dissolution occuring at the
surface of crystals and subsequent re-evaporation of the solvent. Due to caking, the crystals
can get very tightly bonded together.
Since the vapour pressure of a saturated solution of a crystalline solid is less than that of
pure water at a given temperature, condensation can take place on the surface of the crystals
even though the atmospheric relative humidity is less than 100 percent. The solution thus
formed enters into/penetrates into the pack of crystals as a result of capillary action of the
small gaps between the crystals and caking can result due to subsequent evaporation of
moisture when the atmospheric humidity falls. Crystalline materials can also cake at a
constant relative humidity, as the vapour pressure of a solution is less in a small capillary as
compared to it in a large capillary as a result of temperature effect. As condensation occurs,
the small particles get first dissolved and therefore average size of capillaries increases and
the vapour pressure of the solution may increase sufficiently for evaporation to take place.
When the particle size is non-uniform, a crystalline material will cake more rapidly as the
porosity of a bed of particles of mixed sizes is less and fine particles are more readily
soluble. Thus, the tendency of crystalline materials to cake can be reduced by forming
crystals of relatively large and uniform sizes or by adding a water repellent agent, such as
stearic acid.
Magma : It is a two-phase mixture of mother liquor and crystals that occupies the
crystalliser and withdrawn as a product.
In order to reduce the load on a crystalliser, evaporation may be carried out to remove the
excess solvent from a solution. Crystallisation is generally followed by filtration for the
separation of crystals from the mother liquor.
Unit Operations – II 11.7 Crystallisation
Cooling coil
Vessel
Paddle
This type of crystalliser is used to produce fine chemicals, pharmaceutical products and
dye intermediates.
Scrapped surface crystalliser :
(i) Swenson-Walker crystalliser and (ii) Double pipe crystalliser.
Swenson-Walker Crystalliser :
The Swenson-Walker crystalliser is a cooling type, continuous, jacketed trough
crystalliser. It is an example of the scrapped surface crystalliser and is probably the most
widely used crystalliser.
Construction :
It consists of a long open rectangular trough with a semi-cylindrical bottom,
i.e., U-shaped trough, of width 0.6 m and length 3 to 6 m. The trough is jacketed externally
for circulating the coolant during operation. A spiral agitator rotating at about 7 rpm is
incorporated in the trough in such a way that it is as close to the bottom of the trough as
possible. The capacity of this crystalliser can be increased by arranging a number of units in
series (four troughs of 3 metre length each may be arranged). At one end of the crystalliser,
an inlet for the hot solution is provided and at the other end of the crystalliser, an overflow
gate for the crystals and mother liquor discharge is provided. The functions of the spiral
agitator are : (i) to scrap the crystals from the cooling surface (i.e., to prevent accumulation
of the crystals on the heat transfer surface), (ii) to lift and shower the crystals through the
solution so that the crystals will be held in suspension and thereby the crystals of uniform
size can be obtained (as deposition occurs mainly by build up on previously formed crystals)
and (iii) to convey the crystals from one end of equipment to the other end.
The trough is formed out of metal sheets welded to an angle-iron frame at the top.
A jacket is usually made of mild steel. The spiral agitator is supported at either ends outside
the trough. A stuffing box assembly is attached to the cover on either ends that prevents
leakage of the liquor from the opening provided for a shaft. The shaft is driven by belt, etc.
Jacket Spiral agitator Feed
Trough
Crystal
+ Mother liquor
Working :
A hot concentrated solution is fed at one end of the open trough and flows slowly
towards the other end of the trough. Water is fed to the jacket in such a way that it flows in a
counter current fashion with respect to the solution. The solution while flowing through the
trough cools by heat transfer to water. Once the solution becomes supersaturated, crystals
start forming and building. A spiral agitator keeps the crystals in suspension so that
previously formed crystals grow instead of formation of new crystals and ultimately the two
phase mixture of crystals and liquor leaves the crystalliser through an overflow gate.
Advantages of this crystalliser include : saving in floor space, in material in process and
saving in labour.
This crystalliser is suitable only when supersaturation can be achieved by cooling alone.
Double pipe scrapped surface crystalliser :
Less common type of continuous scrapped surface crystalliser that is somewhat similar to
the jacketed trough crystalliser, i.e., Swenson-Walker crystalliser is a double pipe
crystalliser. It consists of a concentric double pipe, the outer pipe acting as a jacket. Cooling
water flows through the annular space between the two pipes and a long pitch spiral agitator
rotates in the inner pipe at 5 to 30 rpm. These are also arranged in series (3 pipes each of 3 m
long). The other constructional features and the method of operation is the same as of the
Swenson-Walker crystalliser.
It is used in crystallising ice cream and plasticizing margarine.
Vacuum Crystalliser :
In this crystallizer, supersaturation is achieved by adiabatic evaporative cooling. A hot
solution (feed) is introduced into a vessel wherein a vacuum is maintained that corresponds
to the boiling point of the solution lower than the temperature of the feed solution.
Evaporation will result due to flashing. The energy needed for vaporisation is taken from the
feed (sensible heat), so that the temperature of a liquor-vapour mixture after flashing
becomes much lower than the temperature of the liquor before flashing.
Vacuum crystallisers often operated continuously but they can also be operated batch-
wise. These crystallisers are very simple and contain no moving parts and therefore, they can
be constructed out of corrosion resistant materials or lead or rubber lined mild steel.
Construction :
A continuous vacuum crystalliser consists of a tall vertical cylindrical vessel with a
conical bottom, a circulating pump (screw pump) of low head and a vertical tubular heater on
the shell side of which, steam is condensing. A low pressure (i.e., vacuum) in the vertical
cylindrical vessel (crystallising body) is maintained by a condenser, usually with the help of a
steam jet ejector. A tangential inlet is provided on the cylindrical vessel for introducing a hot
solution into it and a vapour outlet is provided on the top. A discharge connection for mother
liquor and crystal is provided on a down-pipe just above the feed connection.
Unit Operations – II 11.11 Crystallisation
Barometric condenser
Crystalliser body
Steam
Magma
Heater
Motherliquor
Product Drips
Bleed
Centrifuge
Pump
Feed
Fig. 11.5 : Continuous Vacuum Crystalliser / Circulating magma vacuum crystalliser
Working :
The magma from the bottom of a cylindrical vessel goes to a pump via a down-pipe and
is pumped through a vertical tubular heater where it is heated by means of condensing steam
and finally a hot stream enters the cylindrical vessel tangentially just below the level of the
magma surface. Flash evaporation of the solution takes place and produces rapid cooling,
resulting into supersaturation, which is the driving force for nucleation and growth. Fresh
solution enters the down pipe just before the suction of the circulating pump and a
suspension of crystals is continuously taken out from a discharge pipe located above the feed
inlet in the down pipe. The suspension of crystals is fed to a centrifuge machine, the crystals
are taken out as a product, and the mother liquor is recycled to the down-pipe with a small
part of it continuously bled.
It is used for the production of large crystals.
Krystal or Oslo Crystalliser :
It is used whenever large quantities of crystals of controlled size are to be produced.
In this crystalliser, a supersaturated solution is passed upward through a bed of crystals
which are maintained in a fluidised state whereby uniform temperature is maintained and the
crystals segregate in the bed with large ones at the bottom and small ones at the top.
Unit Operations – II 11.12 Crystallisation
Feed
Coolant out A
P
Cooler
E
Coolant in
V
Pump
Vapour head
Steam
Heater
Feed
Drips
Pump
Central duct
Crystallising
chamber
Product
Feed
Crystalliser Mother liquor (L)
solution
(F, X'F)
Crystals (C)
Fig. 11.8
Consider the crystallisation process carried out under steady state conditions and shown
in Fig. 11.8.
Let
F be the mass flow rate of feed solution in kg/h
X' be the weight fraction of anhydrous solute in the feed solution
F
SOLVED EXAMPLES
Example 11.1 : A solution of sodium nitrate in water contains 48 % NaNO3 by weight at
313 K (40o C) temperature. Calculate the percentage yield of NaNO3 crystals that may be
obtained when the temperature is reduced to 283 K (10o C). Also, calculate the quantity of
NaNO3 crystals obtained from 100 kg of the solution.
Data : Solubility of NaNO3 in water at 283 K (10o C) is 80.18 kg NaNO3 per 100 kg
water.
Solution : Basis : 100 kg feed solution.
F = 100 kg
48
X'F = 100 = 0.48 weight fraction of NaNO3 in the feed
C = yield of crystals (kg of NaNO3 crystals obtained)
X' = solubility of NaNO3 at 283 K
= 80.18 kg/100 kg water
L' = kg of solvent in mother liquor
Water (solvent) balance :
Solvent in feed = Solvent in mother liquor
F (1 – X'F) = L'
100 (1 – 0.48) = L'
∴ L' = 52 kg
NaNO3 balance – (Anhydrous salt as crystal) :
NaNO3 in feed = NaNO3 obtained as crystals + NaNO3 in mother liquor
6.3
= 48 × 100
= 13.12 % … Ans.
Unit Operations – II 11.17 Crystallisation
Example 11.2 : Find the yield of Na2S2O3. 5H2O crystals when 100 kg of 48% Na2S2O3
solution is cooled to 293 K (20o C). Also calculate the percentage yield of the hydrated
crystals. (At. Wt. : Na = 23, S = 32, O = 16, H = 1)
Data : Solubility of Na2S2O3 is 70 parts per 100 parts water at 293 K (20o C).
Solution : Basis : 100 kg of feed solution.
It contains 48 kg of Na2S2O3 and 52 kg of water. Let 'C' be the yield of crystals.
M1 = Molecular weight of Na2S2O3 = 158
M2 = Molecular weight of Na2S2O3 · 5 H2O = 248
C [248 – 158]
L' = 52 – 248
Material balance of solute :
Solute in feed = Solute in crystals produced + Solute in mother liquor
30.3
= 73.34 × 100 = 41.31 … Ans.
Unit Operations – II 11.18 Crystallisation
Example 11.3 : Calculate the yield of MgSO4 · 7 H2O crystals when 1000 kg saturated
solution of MgSO4 at 353 K (80o C) is cooled to 303 K (30o C) assuming 10 % of the water is
lost by evaporation during cooling.
Data : Solubility of MgSO4 at 353 K (80o C) = 64.2 kg/100 kg water
Solubility of MgSO4 at 303 K (30o C) = 40.8 kg/100 kg water
At. Wt. : Mg = 24, S = 32, H = 1 and O = 16
Solution : Basis : 1000 kg of solution at 353 K (80o C)
∴ F = 1000 kg
M1 = 120
M2 = 246
= 32/100 = 0.32
M1 = Mol. Wt. of Na2SO4 = 142
M2 = Mol. Wt. of Na2SO4 · 10 H2O = 322
Material balance of water :
Water in feed = Water of crystallisation + Water in mother liquor
(M2 – M1)
0.68 × 100 = C M2 + L'
68 = C 322 + L'
322 – 142
68 = 0.559 C + L'
L' = 68 – 0.559
Unit Operations – II 11.22 Crystallisation
56.55
% yield of Glauber salt = 72.56 × 100 = 77.93 … Ans.
Alternate method :
Basis : 100 kg free water
100 kg of the original solution contain 32 kg Na2SO4 and 68 kg water.
Water associated with Mol. Wt. of 10 H2O
32 kg Na2SO4 in 100 kg solution = Mol. Wt. of Na SO × 32
2 4
(10 × 18)
= 142 × 32 = 40.56 kg
142
2220 = 322 C + 0.224 L'
where F = 100 kg
X'F = 39.1/100 = 0.391
V = 4 kg
40.8
X' = 100 = 0.408
48 = x + 0.445 y … (2)
Unit Operations – II 11.26 Crystallisation
= 13.12 … Ans.
Note : You can adopt the same procedure to solve the previous problems.
Example 11.10 : Calculate the yield of MgSO4 · 7H2O crystals when 1000 kg saturated
solution of MgSO4 at 353 K is cooled to 303 K assuming 10% of water is lost by evaporation
during cooling.
Data : Solubility of MgSO4 at 353 K = 64.2 kg/100 kg water
Solubility of MgSO4 at 303 K = 40.8 kg/100 kg water
Mol. Wt. of MgSO4 = 120, Mol. Wt. of MgSO4 · 7 H2O = 246
Solution : Basis : 1000 kg of saturated solution at 353 K.
Let us solve this problem without using notation.
Let x be the kg of MgSO4 · 7 H2O crystals obtained, y be the kg of mother liquor
obtained.
Saturated solution = 1000 kg
Solubility at 353 K = 64.2 kg/100 kg water
i.e., 164.2 kg (100 + 64.2) of saturated solution contains 64.2 kg of MgSO4 and 100 kg of
water.
100
Water in the saturated solution = 164.2 × 1000
= 609 kg
MgSO4 in the saturated solution = 1000 – 609 = 391 kg
Water lost by evaporation = 10% of original water
Water lost by evaporation = 0.10 (609) = 60.9 kg
Unit Operations – II 11.27 Crystallisation
EXERCISE
1. Fill in the blanks :
(a) ............ and ........... are the phases involved in crystallisation. Ans. Liquid, solid
(b) In crystallisation from solution, simultaneous ................ and mass transfer takes
place. Ans. heat
(c) In crystallisation, mass transfer occurs from the solution to ....... phase. Ans. solid
(d) ............... is the driving force for crystallisation. Ans. supersaturation
(e) For common salt (NaCl) ...... is independent of variation in temperature.
Ans. solubility
(f) Solubility is generally expressed as parts by weight ......... per ......... parts by weight
solvent. Ans. solute, 100
Unit Operations – II 11.28 Crystallisation
(g) For solutes whose solubility increases within increase in temperature, supersaturation
is achieved by .......... alone. Ans. cooling
(h) For solutes whose solubility remains more or less constant with temperature,
supersaturation is achieved by .......... of a part of the solvent. Ans. evaporation
(i) Vacuum crystalliser is used for ........... sensitive materials. Ans. heat
(j) ............ and crystal growth are the two basic steps in the overall process of
crystallisation. Ans. Nucleation.
2. Define the following terms :
(a) crystallisation (b) solubility (c) nucleation
(d) crystal growth (e) supersaturation.
3. Explain in brief solubility curves.
4. State various methods of generating supersaturation.
5. Give the classification of crystallisers.
6. Discuss in brief crystal formation.
7. Explain in brief with a neat sketch Swenson-Walker crystalliser.
8. Explain with a neat sketch Oslo-cooling crystalliser.
9. Draw a neat sketch of agitated tank crystalliser.
10. Draw a neat sketch of vacuum crystalliser and explain its construction.
❐❐❐