Genetic Variability Among Cowpea (Vigna: Unguiculata L. Walp) Mini Core Collection
Genetic Variability Among Cowpea (Vigna: Unguiculata L. Walp) Mini Core Collection
Genetic Variability Among Cowpea (Vigna: Unguiculata L. Walp) Mini Core Collection
Authors’ contributions
This work was carried out jointly by the two authors. Author TO carried out the experiment and
statistical analysis under the supervision of author BO. The two authors wrote the first draft of the
manuscript, read and approved the final manuscript.
Article Information
DOI: 10.9734/AJRCS/2018/46260
Editor(s):
(1) Dr. Tatiana Eugenia Sesan, Professor, University of Bucharest, Faculty of Biology, Romania and National Research-
Development-Institute for Chemistry and Petrochemistry Bucharest, Romania.
Reviewers:
(1) S. A. C. N. Perera, University of Peradeniya, Sri Lanka.
(2) Paul Benyamin Timotiwu, University of Lampung, Indonesia.
(3) Godwin Michael Ubi, University of Calabar, Nigeria.
Complete Peer review History: http://www.sdiarticle3.com/review-history/46260
ABSTRACT
Aims: To evaluate cowpea genotypes selected from mini core collection for variability that can be
exploited in breeding programme and also to provide information on high yielding genotypes to aid
further use of the genotypes in cowpea improvement programmes.
Study Design: A completely randomized design in two replications was used for the study.
Place and Duration of Study: International Institute of Tropical Agriculture (IITA), Ibadan, Oyo
State, Nigeria between March and August, 2017.
Methodology: Two hundred cowpea genotypes were grown in the glass house at IITA. Data were
collected on twelve agronomic characters including plant height, chlorophyll content, days to first
flower initiation, days to first pod harvest, hundred-seed weight, pod length, number of pods per
plant, mean number of seeds per pod, grain yield per plant, seed length, seed width and seed
thickness. The data were subjected to analysis of variance, cluster and principal component
analyses.
Results: Significant genetic variability was observed among the cowpea genotypes for all the
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
agronomic characters investigated in this study. The genotypes were grouped into five clusters with
TVu1059 and TVu43 identified as the most distinct. The first four principal components (PC) with
eigen values > 1 accounted for 72.5% of the total variation among the cowpea genotypes with
loadings of hundred-seed weight, seed length, seed width, seed thickness, days to first pod harvest,
days to first flower, pod length, mean number of seeds per pod, pods per plant and grain yield per
plant.
Conclusion: The broad genetic variation observed among the cowpea genotypes evaluated in this
study for yield and yield-related characters can be explored to improve cowpea.
Keywords: Cowpea mini core collection; principal component analysis; cluster analysis; agronomic
characters of cowpea.
2
Osho and Olasanmi; AJRCS, 2(4): 1-10, 2018; Article no.AJRCS.46260
The genotypes were planted in plastic pots was then used for determination of nutrients
arranged in a completely randomized design with composition of the soil following the standard
two replicates. Thoroughly mixed top soil sample procedures (Table 2). The plastic pots were each
was collected and taken to microbiology filled with 5 kg top soil and then watered to field
laboratory for soil analysis to determine the capacity before planting the seeds. All the seeds
nutrients composition. Dried soil sample (at 65°C were treated with apron star (active ingredients:
for 48 hours) was grounded and passed through Imidacloprid (10%), metalaxyl (10%) and
0.5 mm sieve. 0.5 ml of distilled water was added carbendazim (10%)) at a dosage of 10 g per 4 kg
and the mixture was stirred vigorously and of seeds to prevent insect attack. Five seeds of
allowed to stand for 30 minutes. The solution each of the two hundred genotypes were planted
3
Osho and Olasanmi; AJRCS, 2(4): 1-10, 2018; Article no.AJRCS.46260
per pot. After two weeks, the plants were thinned average distance of 250, the dendrogram
to two plants per pot to achieve required plant showed five sub-clusters containing 2, 18, 8, 76
population. White flies were controlled using a and 96 genotypes, respectively which indicates
mixture of Courage (imidacloprid (17.8% SL)) the existence of genetic diversity among the
and Karate (50 g/l lambda-cyhalothrin) at dosage genotypes used (Table 3). Conservation of
of 25 ml and 75 ml per 20 litres of water, cowpea genetic variability is essential for future
respectively. Leaf thrips were also controlled by use and the actual utilization of the accessions is
spraying plants with Dynamic (abamectin (1.84% equally important [16]. The genotypes joining
w/w) and cyclohexanol) at dosage of 20 ml per different clusters at different average distances
20 litres of water. Pod borers were controlled showed the relationship among the genotypes
with Termex (chlorpyriphos) at dosage of 80 ml and also indicates that they are genetically
per 20 litres of water. Harvesting was done when distant thereby creating a chance for
the pods had dried. improvement. TVu1059 and TVu43 in cluster V
belong to the same cluster and also have distant
2.2 Data Collection and Analysis relationship with other genotypes because they
had the highest quantity of yield. Selection of
Data were collected on agronomic traits such as highly divergent clusters is expected to express
plant height (cm), days to first flower initiation, wide variability, therefore the variability between
days to first pod harvest, hundred-seed weight groups could be useful in hybridization while
(g), pod length (cm), number of pods per plant, within group variability could be useful for
mean number of seeds per pod, grain yield per selection process.
plant (g) from which yield per hectare (kg/ha)
was estimated, seed length (mm), seed width There were highly significant (P ≤ .0001)
(mm) and seed thickness (mm). differences among the genotypes for all the traits
evaluated (Table 4). From the mean performance
Chlorophyll content (chlorophyll b) present in the of 20 selected cowpea genotypes for
leaves of the cowpea plants were determined phenological, yield and yield related traits based
with the use of SPAD-502 chlorophyll meter on rank summation index method, TVu12873 (61
(Konica-Minolta, Japan), that measures the days) had the shortest days to first pod harvest
absorbance of leaf in the red (650 nm) and while TVu9259 (185 days) took the longest days
infrared (940 nm) regions of the electromagnetic to first pod harvest (Table 2). TVu8262 (17.85 g)
spectrum [14]. had the highest value for hundred-seed weight
while TVu2968 (4.80 g) had the lowest value.
Data were subjected to analysis of variance The highest value for pods per plant was
(ANOVA) to determine if there are significant observed in Tvu12873 (28) while TVu15913 had
differences among the genotypes using SAS 9.4 the lowest value of 2.75. TVu3310 (16.10) had
version software. The means for each trait were the highest mean number of seeds per pod while
subjected to Cluster Analysis and Principal TVu14253 (6.20) had the lowest value. The
Component Analysis (PCA) to determine the highest grain yield value was observed in
pattern of variability and relationships among TVu8631 (1,470 kg/ha) while the lowest value
evaluated genotypes using SAS 9.4 version was observed in TVu15861 (131.67 kg/ha). For
software. Rank summation index (RSI) [15] was seed length, TVu12873 (10.44 mm) had the
used to rank genotypes and selection was done highest value while the lowest was recorded in
based on their performances across the traits TVu14970 (5.70 mm). The highest seed
considered. Means were compared using LSD at thickness was observed in TVu109 (5.52 mm)
5% probability level. while the lowest value was observed in TVu8262
(3.16 mm). Genotype TVu8631, followed closely
3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION by TVu109 had the best performance across the
traits considered. The cowpea genotypes are
The 200 cowpea genotypes were evaluated genetically diverse for the traits considered for
based on their phenological, yield and yield the study thereby suggesting the existence of
related traits. The cluster pattern showed two variability among the genotypes which makes
main clusters with the first cluster having two them amenable to selection pressure. This
members and the other containing the remaining agrees with the reports of Yadav et al. [17] and
198 genotypes (Fig. 1). The dendrogram further Ali et al. [18] who worked on chickpea and
divided the cluster into sub-clusters using the soybean, respectively.
average distance between cluster procedure. At
4
Osho and Olasanmi; AJRCS, 2(4): 1-10, 2018; Article no.AJRCS.46260
Table 2. Physico-chemical properties of the soil used for evaluation of cowpea genotypes at Ibadan in 2017
Sample pH: H2O (1:1) OC (%) N (%) Bray P (ppm) Particle size (%) Ca Mg K Na Zn Cu Mn Fe
Sand Silt Clay (cmolc/Kg) (ppm)
1 6.94 1.01 0.15 10.97 90 8 2 7.19 1.63 0.88 4.88 7.78 1.10 88.04 55.76
5
Osho and Olasanmi; AJRCS, 2(4): 1-10, 2018; Article no.AJRCS.46260
Table 4. Mean performance for phenological, yield and yield-related traits in the best 10, 5 intermediate and 5 lowest genotypes evaluated at
Ibadan in 2017
Genotype No. Genotype DTH (days) 100SWT Number of Number of Yield (kg/ha) Seed Seed Rank
name (g) pods/plant seeds/pod length thickness summation
(mm) (mm) index
92 TVu8631 89.50 12.95 11.75 12.00 1470.00 10.38 5.37 316
5 TVu109 73.00 11.00 20.00 12.10 586.67 8.73 5.52 352
22 TVu1059 67.50 19.95 18.50 10.20 870.00 7.13 4.09 372
72 TVu4669 81.00 16.25 14.75 8.70 776.67 8.72 4.90 385
189 TVu16408 75.50 12.25 10.00 14.70 731.67 7.57 5.03 400
118 TVu12873 60.50 8.80 28.00 7.80 1383.33 10.44 4.36 402
75 TVu4783 79.00 13.30 18.75 10.40 531.67 9.42 4.68 412
132 TVu14253 76.50 12.40 15.25 6.20 1466.67 9.94 4.47 420
27 TVu8072 77.00 8.95 16.00 11.40 668.33 9.78 4.63 428
2 TVu21 75.00 13.75 10.25 8.50 938.33 8.38 4.84 429
58 TVu3310 116.00 10.00 7.25 16.10 616.65 8.16 4.24 688
175 TVu15913 166.50 11.05 2.75 15.90 593.33 8.76 4.48 690
24 TVu1330 90.50 12.40 7.00 14.40 656.67 7.02 3.91 692
95 TVu8673 112.00 11.25 7.75 13.60 346.67 8.01 4.91 693
176 TVu15926 81.50 5.90 23.00 11.80 581.67 7.02 3.90 694
153 TVu14970 113.00 13.80 6.75 7.00 575.00 5.70 3.40 1031
51 TVu2968 134.50 4.80 8.50 8.20 516.67 6.76 3.98 1036
89 TVu8262 129.00 17.85 4.75 7.00 611.67 5.99 3.16 1036
173 TVu15861 108.00 8.70 4.00 9.50 131.67 6.92 3.91 1102
103 TVu9259 185.00 11.10 5.50 7.20 228.33 5.91 3.56 1193
Overall mean 87.50 11.90 10.65 10.03 659.49 7.45 4.12
Mean squares 760.66 32.70 61.61 12.36 205199.76 3.24 0.96
Error 324.66 0.82 2.79 3.83 10112.9 0.25 0.39
CV (%) 20.60 8.03 15.68 19.50 15.25 6.70 15.09
LSD (0.05) 30.91 1.78 2.99 3.72 192.60 0.93 1.22
All mean square values are significant at P ≤ .0001; DTH- Days to first pod harvest; 100SWT- Hundred-seed weight
6
Osho and Olasanmi; AJRCS, 2(4): 1-10, 2018; Article no.AJRCS.46260
Fig. 1. Dendrogram demonstrating the relationships among 200 cowpea genotypes based on phenological, yield and yield-related traits
7
Osho and Olasanmi; AJRCS, 2(4): 1-10, 2018; Article no.AJRCS.46260
Table 5. Principal component analysis of agronomic traits of 200 cowpea genotypes evaluated
at Ibadan in 2017
The principal component analysis revealed that variability within the breeding population. Similar
the first four principal components (PC) each with observations were made by Doumbia et al. [19]
eigen values >1 accounted for 72.5% of the total in an evaluation of 94 cowpea genotypes from
variation in the data set (Table 5). The first Mali and Ghana. The study also identified seed
principal component which captured 28.7% of the weight, seed length, seed width and seed
total variation had the highest eigen value of thickness as important traits in diversity analysis.
3.45. The second principal component with eigen Bozokalfa et al. [20] observed that wide variation
value of 2.27 accounted for 18.9% while the third found in the quantitative characters can be useful
and fourth principal components with eigen in the development of variety description and
values of 1.61 and 1.37 contributed 13.4% and identification.
11.4% of the total variation in the population,
respectively. The hundred-seed weight (0.515), 4. CONCLUSION
seed length (0.472), seed width (0.497) and seed
thickness (0.372) were strongly correlated and TVu1059 and TVu43 formed separate cluster
loaded on the first principal component (PC). The from the rest of the genotypes with respect to
second PC was loaded with days to first pod yield potential. This shows their distinctness from
harvest (0.588) and days to first flower initiation the population of cowpea used in this study and
(0.581). Pod length (0.646) and mean number of can therefore be used as parents to cross with
seed per pod (0.588) were loaded on the third genotypes in other clusters for cowpea
PC while the fourth PC was loaded with number improvement.
of pods per plant (0.396) and grain yield (0.629).
The loadings of hundred-seed weight, seed Significant differences were observed among the
length, seed width and seed thickness on the first 200 cowpea genotypes for phenological, yield
principal component indicates that the four traits and related traits. TVu8631 had the highest
are the characters that chiefly accounted for worth based on RSI and the highest grain yield.
most of the variation among the genotypes and This genotype can therefore be directly selected
that maximum variability occurred in the first PC. for further evaluation at advanced breeding
Days to first pod harvest, days to first flower stages before nomination for release to farmers.
initiation, pods per plant, grain yield, pod length Also the ten top ranking genotypes identified in
and mean number of seeds per pod also this study can be selected for further improve-
contributed highly to the variation observed in the ment in cowpea breeding programmes at IITA
population. This suggests that the ten traits and other research institutes.
should be considered for selection in cowpea
improvement programme. It also suggests that Considerable genetic variability existed among
these traits are very important to maintain the cowpea genotypes used in this study. Most
8
Osho and Olasanmi; AJRCS, 2(4): 1-10, 2018; Article no.AJRCS.46260
9
Osho and Olasanmi; AJRCS, 2(4): 1-10, 2018; Article no.AJRCS.46260
Peer-review history:
The peer review history for this paper can be accessed here:
http://www.sdiarticle3.com/review-history/46260
10