Tharindu Dissanayake's Reviews > The Song of Achilles
The Song of Achilles
by
by
"The never-ending ache of love and sorrow."
There are a few books I come across everyday while going through my GR feed, and The Song of Achilles is at top of that list. Rightly so, I have to agree, the heart-wrenching ending notwithstanding. Spoiling this book for future readers would be a crime, so while I'm sharing my thoughts, I'll do my best not to overshare.
"We obey our kings, but only within reason."
Patroclus - the lesser known hero - being the protagonist helps narrate the story of Achilles from a very unique standpoint. While the sequence of events does follow the Trojan war, war part only feels like a sub-plot which complements the main plot beautifully. The reader would rarely await the outcomes of war, for, the amazing and somewhat poetic narrative keeps one deeply immersed in the feelings of the main character. Still, you'll come across the brutalities of war as well, and how they change the characters and their personalities as the story progresses.
"I find the folly of men amusing."
As I was finishing the first half of the book, it didn't feel that eventful or impressive in itself. Sure, it was interesting and had a nice flow to it, with some intricate details about both Achilles and Patroclus, but it didn't feel like anything new: a regular romance novel. But as you finish through the last chapters, those seemingly uneventful - though quite emotional - first half will deepen the reader's emotions profoundly. I think a re-read of this might prove very difficult, especially with the first half, with being familiar with the ending. Still, you'll definitely re-read this.
"No man is worth more than another, wherever he is from."
It might be easy to hate Achilles during the latter half of the story, based on some of his decisions, and rightly so. But, I think it's a good thing that the author did not alter his character to fix those flows. The objective of the story was never to portrait the greatness of Achilles. And as for the ending: it was as emotional and beautiful as it could be. Madeline Miller had done justice to Patroclus with The Song of Achilles perfectly.
There are a few books I come across everyday while going through my GR feed, and The Song of Achilles is at top of that list. Rightly so, I have to agree, the heart-wrenching ending notwithstanding. Spoiling this book for future readers would be a crime, so while I'm sharing my thoughts, I'll do my best not to overshare.
"We obey our kings, but only within reason."
Patroclus - the lesser known hero - being the protagonist helps narrate the story of Achilles from a very unique standpoint. While the sequence of events does follow the Trojan war, war part only feels like a sub-plot which complements the main plot beautifully. The reader would rarely await the outcomes of war, for, the amazing and somewhat poetic narrative keeps one deeply immersed in the feelings of the main character. Still, you'll come across the brutalities of war as well, and how they change the characters and their personalities as the story progresses.
"I find the folly of men amusing."
As I was finishing the first half of the book, it didn't feel that eventful or impressive in itself. Sure, it was interesting and had a nice flow to it, with some intricate details about both Achilles and Patroclus, but it didn't feel like anything new: a regular romance novel. But as you finish through the last chapters, those seemingly uneventful - though quite emotional - first half will deepen the reader's emotions profoundly. I think a re-read of this might prove very difficult, especially with the first half, with being familiar with the ending. Still, you'll definitely re-read this.
"No man is worth more than another, wherever he is from."
It might be easy to hate Achilles during the latter half of the story, based on some of his decisions, and rightly so. But, I think it's a good thing that the author did not alter his character to fix those flows. The objective of the story was never to portrait the greatness of Achilles. And as for the ending: it was as emotional and beautiful as it could be. Madeline Miller had done justice to Patroclus with The Song of Achilles perfectly.
" 'Go,' she says. 'He waits for you.' "
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
The Song of Achilles.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Comments Showing 1-50 of 55 (55 new)
message 1:
by
Andy
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Mar 02, 2021 10:09PM
I hope you are enjoying it, Tharindu. Miller had me under her spell with Circe. Mesmerizing pen, really.
reply
|
flag
andy wrote: "I hope you are enjoying it, Tharindu. Miller had me under her spell with Circe. Mesmerizing pen, really."Thanks a lot, Andy! 😊 After this one, I'm hoping to read Circe as well.
andy wrote: "And I will read The Song Of Achilles soon, so we will get to exchange thoughts about both. :)"Looking forward to it! :) :)
Amazing review, Tharindu! I've been waiting so long to read TSoA and honestly I feel like I'm not ready. Again, amazing review!!!
So good to see the 4 stars and a great review, Tharindu! A close friend has also recently read this story and highly recommends it. I must think long and hard about that since I have a colossal WTR pile!
I loved the romance in this book, but specially the end was epic✨ Glad you enjoyed it, Tharindu! Great review! 😊
ale ♡ wrote: "Amazing review, Tharindu! I've been waiting so long to read TSoA and honestly I feel like I'm not ready. Again, amazing review!!!"Thank you, ale! 😊 Don't put it off for too long though 😄
Debbie wrote: "So good to see the 4 stars and a great review, Tharindu! A close friend has also recently read this story and highly recommends it. I must think long and hard about that since I have a colossal WTR..."Thank you, Debbie! 😊 Hope you'll get to start reading this one soon..
Donna wrote: "I’m planning to read this book this year. Your splendid review has me excited to do so! Thanks!"Thank you, Donna! Glad to hear it helped. Hope you'll love it! 😊
Lau wrote: "I loved the romance in this book, but specially the end was epic✨ Glad you enjoyed it, Tharindu! Great review! 😊"Thank you, Lau! 😊 The end was epic!
"Wait, is this a kissing book?" (Fred Savage in "The Princess Bride')Actually, I just started reading "Song."
4 stars, I'll take it! So happy you read my recommendation!Great points about the unique narration and viewpoint from Patroclus, and how we remain immersed in the character's emotions instead of focusing on the war.
And this quote sobs " 'Go,' she says. 'He waits for you.' " 😭😢😢
Michael wrote: ""Wait, is this a kissing book?" (Fred Savage in "The Princess Bride')Actually, I just started reading "Song.""
😄
Great review. I have read Circe a couple of years ago and this one has been on the TBR since then. Might pick this up soon following your review. :)
☾Sabrina♡༄ wrote: "4 stars, I'll take it! So happy you read my recommendation!Great points about the unique narration and viewpoint from Patroclus, and how we remain immersed in the character's emotions instead of ..."
Thank you, Sabrina! There're three more of your recommendations left and I'm sure they'll be just as great! 😊
Aesaan wrote: "Really looking forward to reading this book. Amazing review!"Thank you, Aesaan! 😊 Hope you'll love it!
Nisha wrote: "Great review. I have read Circe a couple of years ago and this one has been on the TBR since then. Might pick this up soon following your review. :)"Thank you, Nisha! 😊 I'm sure you'll love this. I'm hoping to start Circe next.
I really like this book, but I loved Circe even more. Another wonderful and thoughtful review, Tharindu.
So glad to see you enjoyed Miller's take on this ancient legend of my country's history/mythology, Tharindu!
Nancy wrote: "I really like this book, but I loved Circe even more. Another wonderful and thoughtful review, Tharindu."Thank you, Nancy! 😊 Looking forward to Circe...
Violeta wrote: "So glad to see you enjoyed Miller's take on this ancient legend of my country's history/mythology, Tharindu!"With a whole month of Percy Jackson and then now this.. Greek Mythology has become one of my favorite subjects!😊
Gizem-in-Wonderland wrote: "I just love Miller's storytelling skills and the magic she creates with mythology!"😊😊
Superb review as always, Tharindu. I too have been seeing this book on my GR newsfeed almost everyday. Now your review has convinced me to add this book to my TBR. Thanks.
Great review! How familiar were you with the stories around Achilles and Patroclus before starting the book?
Thaj wrote: "Superb review as always, Tharindu. I too have been seeing this book on my GR newsfeed almost everyday. Now your review has convinced me to add this book to my TBR. Thanks."Thank you, Thaj! Hope you'll have a great time reading it! 😊
Kathrin wrote: "Great review! How familiar were you with the stories around Achilles and Patroclus before starting the book?"Thank you, Kathrin! 😊 To be honest, I've never even heard of Patroclus before TSoA. I've only watched Troy a long time before and could only recall (vaguely) that there was this cousin of Achilles there.
Antonia wrote: "Really looking forward to reading this book. Amazing review, Tharindu! :)"Thank you, Antonia! 😊 Hope you'll love it!
Sonja ✧・゚。★・゚☾ wrote: "Glad you loved this, too!!"Thank you, Sonja! 😊 Do give a chance to Circe as well.. so far, it's better in many ways.
Sonja ✧・゚。★・゚☾ wrote: "Ahh, I'm glad to hear that! I'm going to buddy-read Circe next month 😄"Great! Let's see how how it'll do 😄
Great review 😊 I’m just about to start this one Tharindu. I loved Circe, so am hoping I will enjoy this one too!
Fantastic review, Tharindu! Always look forward to reading your insightful thoughts, and the quotes are the cherry on top! = )
Amanda wrote: "Great review 😊 I’m just about to start this one Tharindu. I loved Circe, so am hoping I will enjoy this one too!"Thank you, Amanda! 😊 I hope you'll love it..
Tracy wrote: "Fantastic review, Tharindu! Always look forward to reading your insightful thoughts, and the quotes are the cherry on top! = )"Thank you, Tracy! 😊 And thanks again for the wonderful complement.. 😊😊 It's great to hear you like them...
Sherry wrote: "Nice review! I also thoroughly enjoyed “The Song of Achilles.”"Thank you, Sherry! 😊 Glad to hear you enjoyed it!












