Meike's Reviews > Columbine
Columbine
by
by
Columbine: Two heavily armed students go on a killing spree because they were bullied and ostracized, so they set out to take revenge against the jocks and all the other popular kids. Except that's not what actually happened. Dave Cullen's investigative book shines when he dissects how the tragedy was portrayed by different sides and why: The police tried to cover up that they had gotten hints regarding Eric Harris, one of the perptetrators, for over a year; the media has the duty to inform and the public wants to know, but depending on how they report, this means helping the aims of the shooters (and what kind of coverage is better for the ratings?); the media, the church and some Evangelicals turned one of the victims into a martyr based on a false story; and then there's the NRA, politicians, parents of dead and surviving students, the parents of the killers, the school administration and of course: The surviving students themselves, many struggling with PTSD and survivor's guilt, who suddenly found themsleves attending a school that has became an international symbol for human malice.
Cullen does a great job disentangling this web of perspectives and piecing the whole picture back together. He states the facts and dives into the psychologies of the killers and those they affected, which leads to a haunting and fascinating portrayal of how the survivors dealt with grief and anger. The most upsetting part though is that the shooting at Columbine did not lead to a serious reform of American gun laws. In Parkland: Birth of a Movement, Cullen then discusses how the survivors themselves, meaning some high school kids, have taken matters into their own hands, because they were sick and tired of legislators sending them "thoughts and prayers" instead of doing their job.
All in all, this is a very insightful book and there's lots to learn from it. Unfortunately, the first part is by far the weakest, so just keep at it, you will be rewarded.
Cullen does a great job disentangling this web of perspectives and piecing the whole picture back together. He states the facts and dives into the psychologies of the killers and those they affected, which leads to a haunting and fascinating portrayal of how the survivors dealt with grief and anger. The most upsetting part though is that the shooting at Columbine did not lead to a serious reform of American gun laws. In Parkland: Birth of a Movement, Cullen then discusses how the survivors themselves, meaning some high school kids, have taken matters into their own hands, because they were sick and tired of legislators sending them "thoughts and prayers" instead of doing their job.
All in all, this is a very insightful book and there's lots to learn from it. Unfortunately, the first part is by far the weakest, so just keep at it, you will be rewarded.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Columbine.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Comments Showing 1-13 of 13 (13 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Sarah
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
May 07, 2019 03:15AM
How many ARCs do you have to get through? Good luck!
reply
|
flag
Sarah wrote: "How many ARCs do you have to get through? Good luck!"Thanks, I need it! :-) Currently, I've got 13 digital ARCs, 1 print and 1 audio - it's nuts!! How many do you have on your ever-growing pile? :-)
Sadie wrote: "Oooooh, you're reading it, very good. This is so chilling and haunting."Oh yes, Dave Cullen just knows his stuff! I can't wait for Soldiers First.
Meike wrote: "Sadie wrote: "Oooooh, you're reading it, very good. This is so chilling and haunting."Oh yes, Dave Cullen just knows his stuff! I can't wait for Soldiers First."
Neither can I! It will be grand, no doubts.
Meike wrote: "Sarah wrote: "How many ARCs do you have to get through? Good luck!"Thanks, I need it! :-) Currently, I've got 13 digital ARCs, 1 print and 1 audio - it's nuts!! How many do you have on your ever-..."
Ahh you'll get through them easily then I'm sure :) are there any you're really excited about?
I'm down to 9, and have been better at holding off requesting things recently! I kind of just want to focus on my own books over the summer, so hopefully I manage to keep it up...
Sarah wrote: "Ahh you'll get through them easily then I'm sure :) are there any you're really excited about?I'm down to 9, and have been better at holding off requesting things recently! I kind of just want to focus on my own books over the summer, so hopefully I manage to keep it up..."
I've got This Is Memorial Device (in German), a Brazilian short story collection and a book by a survivor of the Charlie Hebdo massacre, so there is certainly some interesting stuff, it's just too much! :-)
Oh yes, I should also stop requesting ARCs, but let's face it: It won't happen, although I should follow your example and focus on my own books!! :-)
Meike wrote: "Sarah wrote: "Ahh you'll get through them easily then I'm sure :) are there any you're really excited about?I'm down to 9, and have been better at holding off requesting things recently! I kind of..."
Ooh yes, they all sound very interesting!
Very good review, reminds me of the fact that this is one of the book I really want to get back to for a reread at some point. But before that, A Mother's Reckoning: Living in the Aftermath of Tragedy finally needs to be read.
Sadie wrote: "Very good review, reminds me of the fact that this is one of the book I really want to get back to for a reread at some point. But before that, [book:A Mother's Reckoning: Living in the Aftermath o..."Thank you, Sadie! Aaaah, I'm super-interested in what you'll say about Sue Klebold's book, especially as Cullen gives such an ambivalent portrayal of the Klebold family.
Meike wrote: "I'm super-interested in what you'll say about Sue Klebold's book, especially as Cullen gives such an ambivalent portrayal of the Klebold family.."Yes, I'm very interested, too (and let you know), especially since the book got quite good reviews. I hope it'll be better than Brooks' book (No Easy Answers: The Truth Behind Death at Columbine).
Sadie wrote: "Yes, I'm very interested, too (and let you know), especially since the book got quite good reviews. I hope it'll be better than Brooks' book (No Easy Answers: The Truth Behind Death at Columbine)."Okay, I'll definitely skip that one! :-)

