About this ebook
“Superb . . . This emotional, informative and brilliant page-turner resonates with resilience and humanity.”—The Washington Post (One of the Best Books of the Year)
San Francisco, 1938: A world’s fair is preparing to open on Treasure Island, a war is brewing overseas, and the city is alive with possibilities. Talented Grace, traditional Helen, and defiant Ruby, three young women from very different backgrounds, meet by chance at the exclusive and glamorous Forbidden City nightclub. The girls become fast friends, relying on one another through unexpected challenges and shifting fortunes. When their dark secrets are exposed and the invisible thread of fate binds them even tighter, they find the strength and resilience to reach for their dreams. But after the Japanese attack Pearl Harbor, paranoia and suspicion threaten to destroy their lives, and a shocking act of betrayal changes everything.
Praise for China Dolls
“A sweeping, turbulent tale of passion, friendship, good fortune, bad fortune, perfidy and the hope of reconciliation.”—Los Angeles Times
“Bravo! Here’s a roaring standing ovation for this heartwarming journey into the glittering golden age of Chinese nightclubs.”—Jamie Ford, author of Hotel on the Corner of Bitter and Sweet
“Lisa See masterfully creates unforgettable characters that linger in your memory long after you close the pages.”—Bookreporter
“Stellar . . . The depth of See’s characters and her winning prose make this book a wonderful journey through love and loss.”—Publishers Weekly (starred review)
Lisa See
Lisa See (París, 1955) se crió en el seno de una familia china asentada en Estados Unidos. Biznieta del patriarca del Barrio Chino de Los Ángeles, ciudad en la que reside, narró en On Gold Mountain la epopeya americana de su bisabuelo Fong See. Con El abanico de seda, que se convirtió en un best-seller internacional, alcanzó una repercusión que se vio confirmada con sus siguientes novelas: Elpabellón de las peonías, Dos chicas de Shanghai, La isla de las mujeres del mar y El círculo de mujeres de la doctora Tan, traducidas a unos cuarenta idiomas y publicadas en español por Salamandra.
Read more from Lisa See
Lady Tan's Circle of Women: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Tea Girl of Hummingbird Lane: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Snow Flower and the Secret Fan: A Novel Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsOn Gold Mountain: The One-Hundred-Year Odyssey of My Chinese-American Family Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsPeony in Love: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Related to China Dolls
Literary Fiction For You
I Who Have Never Known Men Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The 7 1/2 Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5A Man Called Ove: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Demon Copperhead: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5We Have Always Lived in the Castle Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Handmaid's Tale Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Covenant of Water (Oprah's Book Club) Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Tender Is the Flesh Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Shift: Book Two of the Silo Series Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Alchemist Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Lord Of The Rings: One Volume Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The God of the Woods: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Alchemist: A Graphic Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Piranesi Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Midnight Library: A GMA Book Club Pick: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Babel: Or the Necessity of Violence: An Arcane History of the Oxford Translators' Revolution Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5I'm Thinking of Ending Things: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Catch-22: 50th Anniversary Edition Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Ministry of Time: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5James (Pulitzer Prize Winner): A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Ocean at the End of the Lane: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Silmarillion Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Rebecca Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Measure: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5One Hundred Years of Solitude Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5All the Ugly and Wonderful Things: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Sympathizer: A Novel (Pulitzer Prize for Fiction) Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Where the Crawdads Sing: Reese's Book Club Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Lord of the Flies Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5All the Colors of the Dark: A Read with Jenna Pick Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Reviews for China Dolls
360 ratings49 reviews
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Mar 25, 2024
Digital audiobook narrated by Jodi Long
This work of historical fiction begins in 1938. Three young women – Helen Fong, Grace Lee and Ruby Tom – meet just as the World’s Fair is set to begin on Treasure Island. They’re from different backgrounds but all are drawn to the glamorous Forbidden City nightclub by their dreams of success. World War II will soon interrupt their career paths, and their friendship will suffer, but they will endure. See follows the young women through the war years and includes an epilogue set in 1988.
I really enjoyed this book. I was in vested in these young women and their aspirations. While my background is different from theirs, we share the push/pull of traditional culture (and the expectations that result) vs the desire to see our dreams fulfilled. I loved, also, the detail See included from costumes to scenery to social issues – these elements really took me back to this era and culture.
See invented her heroines and the majority of characters, but includes a number of actual performers / entertainers of the time period. She did extensive research, including many in-person interviews with now elderly past performers on the “Chop Suey Circuit.”
Jodi Long does a marvelous job of narrating the audiobook. I admit, however, that I sometimes didn’t pay close enough attention to which character was narrating which chapter. (See does state the character at the beginning of each chapter.) Until I got used to the constant changing of point of view, I found myself occasionally confused. That was my fault, not Long’s narration. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
May 28, 2020
As the blurb suggests, China Dolls follows the lives of three Chinese-American women working in San Francisco's nightclubs in the 1930s and 40s: Grace, a young runaway from an abusive father in the Midwest; Ruby, a promiscuous Japanese woman who pretends to be Chinese (with good reason); and Helen, slightly older than the other two and from a rich family that lives in a compound.
It took me a while to get into China Dolls, because the writing style is deceptively simple (especially Grace's chapters…) and for a while I was wondering if I'd picked up a YA book inadvertently. It certainly begins when the trio of protagonists are rather young (I'd guess that Grace and Ruby are both still teenagers, though probably not Helen) and the narrative has strong "coming of age" themes – trying to work out your place in the world, struggling with your identity, relationships with crappy boys, friendship. Overall, if the conventions of the young adult genre weren't so prudish (which this book is not!) you could fairly characterise it as that.
That said, the book was really good, and I got completely sucked in. Being "young-adult-like" does not make it bad quality! If you like historical fiction and strong female characters, are interested in the Chinese and Japanese communities in the US, or women there during the Second World War, or how the US entertainment industry used to be, this novel has got you covered.
I do agree with some other reviewers who've said this novel may have worked better if it had stuck to Grace's perspective. Grace is the real protagonist of the three. She's by far the most likeable, she gets a fair few more POV chapters than either of the other two, and what's more, even when Ruby and Helen have POV chapters they conveniently never think about anything they happen to be hiding from Grace at the time, ensuring that whatever is unknown to Grace is unknown to the reader – but of course, if she should hide something from the others the reader is in on it. It just seemed strange not to formalise the deal by having the novel expressly from Grace's perspective, instead of nominally being about all three.
As well, if you're looking to read a novel about the strength of women's friendships, this is not really the one to read. What it depicts far more is their fragility. I found it telling that early in the book, the three young women pledge never to let a man get in the way of their friendship, and, well…
I thought the ending was good, if not uplifting. I didn't think Helen's self-described motives for dobbing Ruby in to the FBI and then blaming Grace made a hell of a lot of sense though – was it because she was traumatised by her husband and son being murdered by "Japs" in China? or because she was jealous of Ruby and wanted Grace all for herself? if she really wanted Grace to get all the opportunities she claimed, why did she then turn everyone in the nightclub against her to get her fired, before Ruby was even out of the damn internment camp to need lying to?! All in all it just made her seem deeply irrational and selfish, which was out of character. I was also irritated that Grace would forgive Joe and agree to marry him after he'd already broken her heart twice, even if I appreciated the depiction of returned servicemen as traumatised, not cheerful heroes. But I was relieved that she finally cut the poisonous Helen and Ruby (mostly) out of her life, even if it resulted in the awkward conclusion of choosing a man over your female friends being the path to happiness.
I think I'll have to read more of Lisa See's books! (Jul 2014) - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
May 19, 2020
Man - I really enjoyed this book! Three young Chinese Americans meet up in San Francisco during the late thirties and become fast friends. They bond through their love of the spotlight. They love being on the stage and dancing, dazzling the audience with the grace and wit. From Forbidden City Nightclub to other venues; they delight in sequins, lace, and silk. Grace is outgoing but escaping a hard past in Plain City, Ohio. Helen is smothered in her family compound in San Francisco's Chinatown. Ruby left her parents in Hawaii to find stardom in California. The three share many ups and downs, lots of prejudice from White Americans, especially when America enters the war. Can their friendship survive all? Told through alternating perspectives; this is a timeless, complicated, and unique story of friendship. Wonderful! - Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5
Nov 20, 2019
China Dolls by Lisa See is set against the backdrop of Chinese American nightclubs and their performers during the 1940s. We are introduced to three Asian-American girls who work as dancers in these nightclubs and dream of becoming stars. Unfortunately the onset of World War II changes things dramatically for all of them.
The point-of-view shifts equally between the three main characters as Grace, Helen and Ruby meet each other, connect as friends, work and live together and eventually fall out over lies and secrets. Unfortunately, I found it difficult to believe that these particular girls would ever bond together so I never felt all that invested in their relationship. There was however a great deal of period detail and local color that was fascinating. The author caught the 1940s accurately through her descriptions of the music, personalities, fashion and slang of the day. With the backdrop of the Forbidden City nightclub in San Francisco as well as the Chop-Suey Circuit, the author gives us a vivid and rich portrayal of conditions that Chinese-American entertainers faced.
While China Dolls is not destined to become one of my favorite Lisa See novels, it was an interesting and educating read. Although this novel was a bit of a miss for me, I certainly look forward to reading more from this author who has previously delivered some excellent books. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Jul 21, 2019
I am very glad that this novel was suggested as a book club selection. I did not like the first Lisa See Book I read, but I really enjoyed this one. I learned a lot about Chinese Americans, the prevalent racism against Asians, and the Chinese nightclub circuit. I also learned a bit about the Japanese internment camps during WWII, as well as the treatment of Japanese Americans.
This novel follows Grace, Helen, and Ruby as they struggle to break into show business, and navigate through the end of the Depression and through WWII.
This is a novel that covers a great deal of history and I thought Lisa See did a great job with it.
#ChinaDolls #LisaSee - Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5
Jun 29, 2019
The first half of the book was intriguing. I cared about the main characters, but I found myself less interested in the second half. It's still a book I'll recommend, but not as good as Snowflower. - Rating: 2 out of 5 stars2/5
May 6, 2018
I have enjoyed all of Lisa See's books, but this one was a disappointment. It was disjointed and predictable. I had a hard time liking any of the characters, and the character development was mediocre at best. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Apr 25, 2018
It’s 1938. Grace is from small-town Ohio, where she and her parents were the only Orientals, though her parents brought her up to be completely American, and has left her abusive home to go to San Francisco to try out as a dancer at an expo. While trying to find her way around Chinatown, she meets Helen, who was raised in a very traditional Chinese family/home. She convinces Helen to come with her to try out, as well. At the tryouts, they meet Ruby, another dancer, who wants to become famous. They become friends and live through WWII trying to make ends meet as entertainers in the Oriental clubs, and later on, touring the “Chop-Suey Circuit”.
I really liked this! I have to admit, I liked Grace best of the three girls, and I found her story the most interesting. The book is told in alternating chapters from each of the girls’ points of view. Each chapter is titled with the girl’s name, so I was able to follow this quite easily. It was really interesting to learn about the Chinese entertainers from the time period. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Dec 30, 2017
whoops, accidentally read through this in a day... definitely a perspective you don't see as often in fiction (Chinese nightclubs in the 40s). I called the betrayal fairly early, though things like that and some parts of the girls' backstories keep this from being purely chick lit. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Sep 27, 2017
China Dolls is the story of San Francisco's Chinatown in the mid twentieth century. As the story begins, America is in the midst of the depression. The plot continues through World War II. What makes this novel fascinating is Lisa See's decision to cover this subject from the points of view of three showgirls.
Grace, Helen, and Ruby, meet at auditions for a new nightclub, Forbidden City, which is located just outside of Chinatown. The idea is to feature “oriental” performers for an “occidental” audience. (Both of those terms were used during that period.) Grace Lee has come to San Francisco from the mid west with the hope of winning a role at the world's fair on Treasure Island, but she didn't succeed. She's on her way to her next option. Helen Fong, who is from a wealthy, local, very traditional, family, hears Grace asking for directions and offers to lead her there. Once there, they meet Ruby Tom, another dancer. All three audition and all win roles.
The three young women become close friends. This friendship is the novel's greatest strength. They help each other through tough times, but also compete with each other, hold secrets from each other, and betray each other along the way.
Steve Lindahl author of Hopatcong Vision Quest, White Horse Regressions, and Motherless Soul - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Jul 3, 2017
This is the sort of book that gives women a bad name. Wow, these women are pretty backhanded. The friendships are all transactional - they help each other with jobs, clothes and make up but don't share any deep emotions. No warm fuzzies here, but there's so much information I'd never known of before particularly about the Chinese Nightclub era, the Chop-Suey circuit, the harassment of single women during WWII with VD testing combined with the ability to incarcerate them for the duration of the war if positive (anyone else ever hear of this?), and of course eavesdropping on Japanese Americans. Ed Sullivan comes off pretty poorly.
Once again I'm left wishing See could write another book as emotionally satisfying as Snowflower and the Secret Fan rather than just an interesting book about Chinese or Chinese-American culture. - Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5
May 28, 2017
I loved this story. I found the characters entertaining. The stories of all the different girls was fascinating. Grace, Ruby, Helen are all Asian young ladies and meet each other under different circumstances. They befriend each other and support each other as they try to live in America during the second world war.
They experience so much together. Fall in love with men and fight over them. Have children. Start families, and so much more. The trouble of being a Chinese or Japanese woman during a time when they could only marry their own kind.
To learn things about how they were treated by people during that time. They were somewhat exploited being women and of Oriental/Asian decent even though they were born in America. To just think that people can even now think the way they did back then. - Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5
May 12, 2017
In this sweeping historical drama, we follow three Asian girls with a thirst for stardom growing up in San Francisco in the 30s. The three meet in Chinatown at an audition for dancers at a new nightclub. They come from different backgrounds and each has secrets but they recognize a kinship in each other. Together they will navigate the rocky world of show business and survive WWII. They will share hardships and trials of all kinds and learn how to keep dancing while their hearts are breaking. A powerful story from an often overlooked perspective.
I loved the historical setting, but this book fell a little flat for me in the character department. I didn't like any of the main characters. Ruby is genuine but so self-centered that all other people are something less than human to her. Grace is such a naive doormat I was almost glad when bad things happened to her. She's just too stupid to live. And Helen is such an underdeveloped figure her personality completely changes from chapter to chapter. In the beginning she's almost as naive as Grace having been raised in a secluded compound. Later she's the worldly one explaining to Grace about homosexuality and all the different slang terms for it. In the final half she has devolved into a one-dimensional Chines stereotype constantly peppering the dialogue with quasi-Confucian proverbs. By the end of the book I was getting a headache from rolling my eyes.
Helen is also basically a sociopath. She spends so much time blatantly lying to the other two (supposedly her best friends) and manipulating them to sabotage their relationships. She's an unrepentant racist and basically a soulless baby who refuses to "share" Grace's affections. After the scene where all secrets are revealed, I felt there was no sufficient resolution. They all just shrug their shoulders and go on being friends? Sorry! Not gonna happen! Especially not with Grace who, like I said, has some serious personality disorders and is frankly dangerous to be around. She's the sort of person who would harbor unresolved grievances that she mostly imagined for years and will probably end bathing in your blood. Eeeesh.
Countless times throughout this book I wondered aloud why they were friends if they hated each other so much. There are more than three people in the world, you can make new friends who won't constantly lie, cheat, betray, and report you to the cops. Like, why torture yourselves? - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Feb 7, 2017
This is a tale of three young women who have careers performing in Chinese nightclubs in the 1930's and 1940's. I felt that it was steeped in the atmosphere of the time. I appreciated the complexity of their relationships with each other as they struggled to advance their careers and live their lives amidst World War II. - Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5
Apr 17, 2016
This is the third novel by Lisa See I've read this year & her themes and style are starting to feel a tad bit repetitive. This novel tackles three women who meet in San Francisco in 1938 and who aim to be stars - Grace, Helen, and Ruby. Their friendship manages to endure despite the challenges of ambition, war, internment, and betrayals. I like this book overall, and enjoyed its portrayal of the Asian American experience. - Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5
Jan 17, 2016
In 1938, three young Asian women meet at nightclub auditions at Charlie Low's Forbidden City in San Francisco's Chinatown. Grace, Helen and Ruby are each a hiding a secret but swear enduring friendship with each other. Grace is a Chinese born American whose parents moved to the Midwest to raise her as far from other Chinese as possible. Helen is an American born Chinese, but her parents are living the traditional Chinese lifestyle in a cloistered compound in San Francisco's Chinatown. Ruby is the girl who wants to be American in every way but who is hiding the biggest secret of them all....she's Japanese. We learn about each of these characters as they narrate their own story in alternating chapters.
I found the history of the Chop Suey Circuit and the Asian nightclubs to be very interesting. There are a number of historical facts interspersed into the fictional accounts of Grace, Helen and Ruby. The story itself is very readable but I never thought of it as a “Lisa See” novel. Usually her books explore complex issues like child abuse and the horrors of war on a deep level but I felt like the many real issues the characters experienced were dealt with on a superficial level. I never felt a real connection with the characters and thought most of them were very unappealing. It was hard to see these girls as friends because they never exhibited the loyalty and friendship to one another that we've seen in Lisa See's previous work. Overall, it was a good book; it just wasn't my favorite Lisa See book. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Jan 16, 2015
Zipping through my latest haul from the library, I found this gem. The story is centered on three Asian-American young women in pre-World War II San Fransisco. They all have different stories - Helen is the daughter in a wealthy Chinatown family, Grace has fled to SF to escape an abusive father, and Ruby is hiding her background. They bond and make it dancing in the pre-war Chinese nightclub Forbidden City. The story follows them until shortly after the end of World War II. The nightclub life and performing life were entertaining, but what makes the story is the will of these women. The story takes us through racism, poverty, friendship, deceit and love in a renewing journey. Recommended. - Rating: 2 out of 5 stars2/5
Nov 11, 2014
great premise, disappointing execution - Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5
Oct 23, 2014
In 1938 three young women, Grace, Helen, and Ruby, meet and begin their quest for fame and fortune in the entertainment world in San Francisco. Getting jobs is difficult as they are of Asian background. Eventually their dancing skills land them a job with a nightclub that specializes in "Chinese girls". The tale, told in alternating voices, follows the ups and downs of their careers through the war years and after.
I started reading and I could not stop (which for me is unusual as I tend to read in spurts). Three young women of vary different personalities and backgrounds, who harbor secrets under all that glamor. A work of historical fiction that was liberally sprinkled with real names of the entertainment world, both of Hollywood and the Chinese-American nightclub circuit. When I finished I found some old videos of a few of the performers from the old Chop Suey Circuit. - Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5
Oct 16, 2014
I found this book a little YA(ish) but I still enjoyed it. The story was some what predictable, but character development was really good. - Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5
Aug 31, 2014
Lisa See is always on the top of my list when looking for women’s historical fiction. This time she takes us to San Francisco’s pre-WWII Chinatown. Three women’s lives intertwine. Grace, a runaway from the Midwest, Ruby, a Japanese girl, who is posing as Chinese, and Helen, from a wealthy Chinese family forge a friendship as they look search for jobs in the nightclub business. World War II breaks out and their friendship is strained. Although this isn’t my favorite Lisa See book, I always appreciate looking at aspects of history about which I knew nothing—in this case the “Chop Suey” entertainment circuit and the animosity between the Chinese and the Japanese during WWII. Ed Sullivan, a gossip columnist, also shows up in the books. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Aug 24, 2014
What a wonderful story Lisa See delivers to us once again. We follow the lives of these three women who are introduced to us at a young age in San Francisco, as we share in their friendships and heartaches. The story is told from the perspectives of each of our main characters, Grace, Helen, and Ruby, so we get a glimpse into the reasons for their actions.
Grace is a young and innocent chinese girl that has fled to San Francisco in search of a better life. Grace is probably the most talented of our characters, but she will not experience success until later in the novel. Grace is an honorable friend who would do anything for those that she loves, so when her friendships with Helen and Ruby become stressed, her whole world is cast into turmoil.
Helen comes from a noble and wealthy Chinese family and lives with her entire family in a compound in the middle of Chinatown. Her family's status has given Helen a life of privilege, allowing her to not really want for anything. There is more to Helen that meets the eye as she fled from Shanghai with her family during the war, so she struggles to start her life over again.
Our third main character is Ruby, whose actions are wild and unpredictable. Ruby uses her body and beauty to help her advance quickly among the Chinese nightclubs. Ruby has her own dark secret, that once uncovered, will knock her status rank out from under her.
The main characters are brought together from odd circumstances, and even though they have different roles in various nightclubs, their friendship remains strong. After the bombing of Pearl Harbor the boundaries of their friendship becomes tested, sending the girls lives in separate directions. Lies and secrets keep them apart for years afterward leaving them yearning for the lost relationships.
Lisa See does a great job, as she always does, of setting up the time period for us. I learned several things from this novel about how oriental people were treated during this time, even before the bombing of Pearl Harbor. With themes of love, friendship, secrets, and forgiveness, I think you would enjoy this book as much as I did. It would be a great novel to read for personal leisure or as a book club discussion. - Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5
Aug 7, 2014
I listened to the audio version of this book. The narrator irrated me to no end. Despite this, I did finish listening to it. The subject matter was interesting: Asian-American singer/performers during the 1930's through the 1950's, covering pre-war to post-war America. In particular, the author spoke of the animosity between Japanese and Chinese-Americans; especially by the Chinese who lived in their native country during the time Japan attacked them - very brutal warfare. The author also included the internment of Japanese-Americans during WWII. Thus, she illustrated an epoch from several different points-of-view. See also made clear the nature of prejudice, and the fact that it exists among and between all races in varying degrees. We cannot seem to escape this fact. The main purpose of See's book was to make people aware of the part Asian-Americans played in the entertainment field during this time, and how this contributed to the disintegration of traditional cultural barriers.
Overall, I received this historical fiction novel favorably, despite the narration. It was not mind-altering, but it was informative within its context. It was not my favorite novel by Lisa See, but I did gleen a little entertainment and knowledge from her book. In that regard, it was a relative success. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Aug 3, 2014
This sage of three Oriental women spanned decades, but the story presented a fascinating adventure into the lives of these women. The story begins before the beginning of WWII and ends in 50 years later in 1988. The journey centers in San Francisco, but encompasses Ohio, Florida, and other areas. I listened to an audiobook read by Jodi Long, who presented the book in an interesting manner. I enjoy learning and this book taught me many lessons: friendship, loyalty, and passion. Lisa See balances the ups and downs of these three women, and their deep secrets from one another. I will truly miss hearing of Ruby, Grace, and Helen. - Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5
Aug 2, 2014
Another good novel by Lisa See. China Dolls is the story of Three young women who meet in SanFrancisco in 1938 and become dancers in a nightclub. The novel spans the war years and ends in 1988. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Jul 14, 2014
Helen, Grace, and Ruby are three young Oriental girls in San Francisco who meet and become friends as dancers in The Forbidden City nightclub. The book takes them from 1938 to 1948, through loves and losses, a World War, and times of happiness, sadness, and anger.
Each chapter of the book is narrated by one of the girls, but I found it difficult to keep them apart. There was very little that was different enough about each of them to be able to tell by the reading who was speaking. I also didn't find that their behavior rang true much of the time.
I'm usually a big fan of Lisa See's books, but this one was a little bit disappointing. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Jul 7, 2014
Engaging story about three Asian dancers (two Chinese, one Japanese) in San Francisco during WW II. It was a bit overly dramatic at times, but the characters were well drawn and the story held my attention. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Jul 5, 2014
The story of Grace, Helen and Ruby, Chinese Americans coming of age during the World War II era, is told in alternating points of view from each of the three women. They meet by chance while auditioning for the part of showgirl at a nightclub in San Francisco, and soon become good friends, vowing to never let anything come between them. But through the years their friendships are tested as each tries to outshine the other; secrets are revealed and loyalties are betrayed.
The women’s characters are well-developed, as are their family, friends and coworkers. Rich with historical detail, the World War II era comes to life. After the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor, paranoia and suspicion are heightened, and we vividly experience the prejudice, discrimination and racism of the times through each of the women’s eyes. Written with cringe-worthy realism, the author vividly portrays an unfortunate period of history where bigotry became acceptable, and even encouraged, to promote patriotism.
Perhaps it was the alternating viewpoints, the large number or characters or the need to fill in a lot of back story, but for me, the book had a slow start. At first the women seemed a lot alike. But once war broke out, their lives took different paths and the plot began to accelerate, following each woman’s life through the end of the war. The novel closes with a jump 50 years into the future, providing a satisfying epilogue to each of their stories.
Audio Production:
Jodi Lang’s narration was performed with emotion and enthusiasm. It took me an hour or so to get comfortable with her style, but once I did, the characters came alive.
Having multiple points-of-view and only one narrator, as opposed to using an ensemble cast, made the audio a little more difficult to follow, especially in the early part of the novel when we are still learning the back story. Plus, there were many secondary characters and their relationships to each women to remember. Jodi did change her voice while performing the narration for each of the girls, but Helen and Grace sounded too similar at times. While this book requires some additional concentration, experienced audio listeners should enjoy the production. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Jul 4, 2014
Three young women with ambitions to perform meet in San Francisco before the outbreak of WW II, and vow to be friends forever. Of course, reality gets in the way, along with secrets, history, race, cultural identity, jealousy, and especially secrets. The novel spans the war years in particular, and then ends in 1988. - Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5
Jun 27, 2014
“China Dolls”, begins at the end of the 1930’s, when three young women of Asian descent and highly different backgrounds, meet and become friends. The effects of the Depression are still evident, and WWII is about to begin. The book, however, doesn’t concentrate on the German involvement, but rather on the involvement of the Japanese, and it reaches back into history to expose the cruelty of the Japanese when they bombed China in 1937, at the beginning of the second Sino-Japanese War. It exposes the fury that the Chinese people harbor toward the Japanese, and also the racial bias that existed towards those of Japanese heritage after the bombing of Pearl Harbor, but it also clearly illuminates the generalized prejudice of Americans toward all those of Asian background, particularly the Chinese, whom they insultingly refer to with many racial slurs, i.e, slant eyes, chinks, etc. The Chinese are inhibited from getting gainful employment, even after being trained in a profession. Helen’s brother was a dentist but was only able to work as a chauffeur. Marriage between the races was a crime. Hate and prejudice reigned. The book also exposes homophobia at that time, and the general atmosphere of disapproval that existed for the performers who worked in the nightclubs, even as they flocked to their shows.
Grace Lee was well brought up. She came from a small town in Ohio and was woefully naïve. Her parents operated a laundry. Helen came from a wealthy family in San Francisco’s Chinatown, her family supplied businesses. She was sheltered and controlled by her family. Ruby came from a traditional Japanese family, a family of fishermen. She was a free spirit. Each had a secret.
Grace ran away from home at 17, because of her father’s physical abuse, and while interviewing for a job as a dancer at The San Francisco Exposition, essentially a World’s Fair to begin in 1939, she met a young man named Joe, with whom she was immediately smitten. She, however, does not get the job dancing there; they are not interested in Asian dancers, so she and Joe part ways. As the story develops, their paths cross again.
After being turned down for that job, Grace meets Ruby. Ruby, like Grace, is looking for a job as a dancer in the flourishing nightclub business of Chinatown, and they unexpectedly become friends. They serendipitously meet Helen, who offers to help them find an apartment. They quickly form a triumvirate. A very properly brought up Chinese young lady, with very strict rules to follow, Helen is surprisingly persuaded by them to also apply for a job as a dancer, although she has no experience dancing or working in show business, they offer to teach her. Helen is unsure, her father would be horrified. She knows he would believe that this kind of a job would bring shame upon the family, and as a traditional Chinese, he believes a woman is of less value than even the worst man. Helen decides to defy her father and take the job when she gets it. The money is better than what she earns in her position at the Telephone Exchange, and she convinces her father that she can better help with their finances by adding more money to her brother Monroe’s school fund. The money persuades her father to allow his “worthless” daughter to take the job. Over the next decade, all three women experience ups and downs, romance, success, failure, joy and tragedy. Chinese proverbs pepper the pages. Sometimes, their friendship stretches the bonds of loyalty and sometimes it ignores them. The effect of world events on their lives and individual futures, rolls out over the pages.
The injustice of the Japanese internment camps is exposed and described in detail. The roundups, helplessness of the victims and panic of the accusers is objectively presented. The cruelty of those in power, their bias and mistrust are all evident. Japanese-Americans were treated almost as poorly as the Jews in Germany, when they were rounded up, although their ultimate fate was far better than those who fell under the hammer of Hitler. They were suspect, and therefore interned like criminals, forced to give up their homes and possessions, confronted by armed guards and vicious dogs, not because of anything they did, but because of the behavior of their Emperor, Emperor Hirohito, who declared war on the United States. America’s behavior was shameful and inexplicable, regardless of its fear of the unknown enemy.
The narrative uncovers the strict culture of the Chinese almost 8 decades ago, the misogyny, the need for a woman to know her place in the world and the family structure. She was required to be absolutely obedient to the patriarch and to provide support for all the males in the family, financially, and in terms of housekeeping and cooking. A hopefully propitious marriage was arranged for her, and her future was planned by her parents.
Ultimately, it felt like it took too long for the war and the racism to be introduced into the narrative. Almost half the book passed before the issue of the Japanese Internment Camps came up. It also seemed to take too long for the issues between the Chinese and Japanese to be introduced. America’s Japanese-American families lost many young men who volunteered to fight for America, in spite of the injustice and cruelty of being uprooted, carted off like animals, and placed in camps. They were Americans, after all; they loved America and wanted to support its war effort. Some made the ultimate sacrifice.
This story begins when Grace is 17, and except for a brief foray into a time forty years later when the story is summed up, it ends when she is 27. She reinvents herself as necessary in order to survive the lean years that come and go. All three women have surprising strength and ability to endure. When Ruby‘s cultural background was betrayed by an unknown person, there were dreadful consequences. The guilty person is not exposed until the very end of the book, but the reader may very well guess who the culprit is, before the last page. The ghastly reason for Helen’s secret shame and behavior is also revealed near the end of the book.
In the time period in which this book occurs, all stripes of prejudice are aired and put on trial, and prejudice is found guilty. The background of the story in the nightclubs of Chinatown is based on historic facts. Charlie Low did open up The Forbidden City, there were famous Chinese dancers and performers and famous Hollywood stars frequented the clubs. There was a “Chinese Frank Sinatra”.
I discovered that there is another book from which Lisa See did a lot of research, for when I looked into the history of Chinatown nightclubs, it popped up on the screen. I thought I was reading a review of “China Dolls” and didn’t realize until after that it was a review of a non-fiction book, written by Trina Robbins, Forbidden City: The Golden Age of Chinese Nightclubs. Lisa See lists it in her bibliography.
The reader of this audio was good, but she was not able to develop a clear individual voice for each woman and so I was often confused, was it Grace or Ruby speaking? That said, it did not inhibit my enjoyment of the book.
Book preview
China Dolls - Lisa See
GRACE
A Measly Girl
I traveled west—alone—on the cheapest bus routes I could find. Every mile took me farther from Plain City, Ohio, where I’d been a flyspeck on the wallpaper of small-town life. Each new state I passed through loosened another rope around my heart, my legs, my arms, yet my whole body ached and I couldn’t shake my vertigo. I lived on aspirin, crackers, and soda pop. I cried and cried and cried. On the eighth day, California. Many hours after crossing the boundary, I got off the bus and pulled my sweater a little more tightly around me. I expected sun and warmth, but on that October afternoon, fog hung over San Francisco, damp, and shockingly cold.
Picking up my suitcase, I left the bus station and started to walk. The receptionists at the cheap hotels I visited told me they were full. Go to Chinatown,
they suggested. You can get a room there.
I had no idea where Chinatown was, so that didn’t help me. And I’ll say this about San Francisco: lots of hills, water on practically every side, and, it seemed to me, not a single street ran purely in any one direction. Finally, a man at a fleabag took my money—a dollar a day, in advance—and gave me a key to a room.
I washed my hair in the basin and put it up in pin curls, then leaned in to the mirror to examine what remained of my injuries. My forehead had healed completely, but the inside of my skull continued to swim from being banged against the kitchen floor. The skin over my ribs was mottled green, gray, and purple. My shoulder still felt swollen and stiff from being dislocated and then jammed back into place, but the cut on my lip had nearly disappeared. I turned away and sat on the edge of the bed, hungry but too frightened to go out, and listening to the sound of God knows what coming through the walls.
I opened my purse and pulled out the magazine clipping Miss Miller, who’d taught me dance from the age of four, had torn from a magazine and given to me a few months earlier. I smoothed the advertisement with my palm so I could study the artist’s sketch of the Golden Gate International Exposition. Even its location on Treasure Island seemed to beckon. See, Grace, they’re looking for six thousand workers,
Miss Miller had said. Dancers, singers, welders, carpenters. The whole works.
She’d sighed then. I wanted to go so many places when I was young, but it takes guts—and talent—to leave everything and everyone you know. You could do it, though.
Her few words and that slip of paper had given me the courage to believe I actually could. After all, I’d won first prize at the Plain City Fair for my tap dancing and singing when I was seven and had held the title ever since.
You always planned to leave home, I told myself. Just because you had to escape sooner than expected doesn’t mean you can’t still fly to the stars.
But my pep talk—in a scary hotel room, in a strange city, in the middle of the night—did little to ease my fears. Once in bed, I could practically see the walls closing in around me. To calm myself, I began a routine I’d invented as a small child, running my hands the length of my arms (a broken radius when I was three; my mom told Doc Haverford I fell down the stairs), slipping along my sides (several broken and fractured ribs over the years), and then lifting each leg and squeezing all the way to my feet (my legs had been a frequent target until I started dancing). The ritual both strengthened and soothed me. I was now alone in the world, with no home to return to and no one to rely on, but if I could survive my father’s beatings and the petty prejudices of my hometown, then I could triumph over whatever obstacles the future threw my way. Maybe. Hopefully.
THE NEXT MORNING, I combed out my hair, sweeping up the sides and letting the curls billow below, the way Carole Lombard did in My Man Godfrey. I put on the dress my dad bought for me when he took us to Cincinnati to buy supplies for the laundry. I’d chosen a dusty-rose-colored cotton frock, with a geometric print composed of interlocking mustard-yellow and steel-gray squares. Mom said the pattern of the fabric and cut of the dress looked too mature for me—and maybe that was so—but now I considered myself lucky to be wearing something so sophisticated.
Filled with a sense of determination, I went downstairs and onto the street. I asked directions on nearly every corner and managed to find my way to the Ferry Building, where I boarded the boat to Treasure Island, about halfway across the bay and just under the Bay Bridge. I imagined everyone onboard was seeking a job at the Golden Gate International Exposition. As excited as I was, the pulse of the ferry through the choppy water roused my vertigo and my hunger until I felt, once again, dizzy and sick. Once we reached the dock, everyone walked fast, wanting to be first in line for interviews. Me too. I spotted my first palm trees, which was thrilling because they meant I surely was in California. I’d never seen anything like the fair’s entrance. Giant towers composed of stacked cubes crowned by stylized elephants bookended the gate. Beyond, I glimpsed spires still clothed in scaffolding. My ears pounded from the sounds of hammers, the buzz of electric saws, the rumble of tractors, bulldozers, and flatbed trucks, and the shouts of men calling out orders and cursing the way they do on construction sites.
Will they be done on time?
a man’s voice asked very close to my ear.
I jumped, spiraling into the terror I experienced around my dad. I swung around to find a young Occidental man about six feet tall, with broad shoulders and sandy-colored hair. He put up his hands in surrender.
I’m sorry I scared you.
His mouth spread into a contrite smile as I met his deep blue eyes. He looked older than I—maybe around twenty. He extended his hand. My name’s Joe.
I’m Grace.
No last names. I liked that.
I’m looking for a job as a rolling-chair boy.
He didn’t bother to explain what that was. But the real reason I’m here is that I love planes, and I love to fly.
Up ahead, the others from the ferry disappeared through the gate.
I love planes so much that my parents told me if I got straight As in high school they’d let me take flying lessons,
Joe continued, sure of my interest. I trained in a Piper Cub. I learned how to take off, land, what to do in a stall, and how to pull out of a spin. Now I have my pilot’s license.
This told me, among other things, that his family had to be pretty well-off.
What does that have to do with rolling chairs?
He laughed and ran a hand through his hair. Pan Am’s Clipper ships are going to be taking off and landing right here at Treasure Island!
I nodded, pretending interest when I didn’t know what in the heck he was talking about.
I’ve been chewing your ear off,
Joe acknowledged. Sorry about that. What are you doing here?
I’m a dancer.
Neat.
He pointed his chin toward the gate. We’d better catch up.
When I stumbled a bit in my low-slung heels, he grabbed my arm to steady me, and I instinctively pulled away. His eyes went banjo big. I could tell he was about to apologize again.
Where are you from?
I blurted, hoping to shift his attention.
Winnetka, Illinois. I’m going to Cal.
Seeing my confusion, he explained, The University of California. It’s over there.
He pointed east. In Berkeley. I live in a fraternity house. How about you?
Plain City, Ohio.
Haven’t heard of it, but we’re both from the Midwest, and our states are practically neighbors. Friends?
I nodded. He sure was a nice guy—good-looking, and I liked the way the left side of his mouth tweaked up when he smiled.
Whew!
He wiped his forehead in mock relief.
He was funny too.
When we had all reached the trailer, a man—wearing gray flannel trousers, a leather jacket zipped halfway up his chest, and a charcoal-colored trilby pulled down to shield his eyes from the sun—jumped on a crate and spoke above the din around us: A lot of you have come from far away. That’s great! We need plenty of folks to get this place up and running. If you’re a painter, electrician, or plumber, head over to the Court of the Seven Seas. Harry will lead the way.
Half the folks followed the man pointed out as Harry.
I figure the rest of you are here to apply for either service or performance jobs,
the man in the trilby continued. If you want to drive one of the elephant trams, work in a concession, become a rolling-chair boy, barker, waitress, fireman, or cop, then go to the Court of Flowers. No flowers there yet, just another trailer like this one.
That’s my cue,
Joe whispered. Then, Good luck!
He peeled away with a large group. He turned to look back at me, gave me a thumbs-up and another smile, both of which I returned. He strode with such confidence that dust kicked up around his shoes. Through the racket around me, I could just make out him whistling All of Me.
I loved that song.
The man in the hat sized up those who remained. All right then,
he said. If you’re here to be models, dancers, or musicians, you’re with me. I’ll see you one at a time. After a preliminary look-see, I’ll send you on to auditions. If you make the cut … Aw, hell,
he said with a casual wave of his hand. You know the drill. Line up here.
One person after another entered the trailer and then exited five or so minutes later with either a grin or a grimace. I tried to prepare myself for the questions I might be asked about my dance experience, and once again my father came into my mind. He may have beat me at home, but he liked to boast to others about how many ribbons and apple-pie prizes I’d won. He’d pushed me to be an all-American girl,
which meant that he let me go to the Rialto to watch musicals to inspire me to practice even harder. I adored Eleanor Powell in Broadway Melody of 1936, in which she danced without music. I saw that movie maybe ten times, and then tried to re-create her steps at every opportunity: on the sidewalk outside the theater, at Miss Miller’s studio, and in our family’s laundry. Of course, the kids in school made fun of me when I said I wanted to be a star. You? An Oriental girl?
They had a point. It wasn’t like there were any famous Chinese movie stars apart from Anna May Wong, and she didn’t sing or dance as far as I knew. Then I saw Dorothy Toy and Paul Wing—a Chinese dance team—in the whimsically titled With Best Dishes. I decided if they could make it, why not me? But would any of that help me now? I suddenly felt very apprehensive and very alone.
When my turn came, I entered the trailer and closed the door behind me as I’d seen others do. The man motioned for me to sit.
Your name?
Grace Lee.
How old are you?
Old enough to sing and dance,
I answered pertly. I wanted to be a star, so no matter how desperate I was, I had to act like one. I’m good.
The man pinched his chin as he considered my response.
You’re Oriental,
he observed, and you’re quite the knockout. Problem is, I don’t have anything for you.
I opened my purse, pulled out Miss Miller’s clipping, and pushed it across the desk. It says here you need performers for the Cavalcade of the Golden West—
That’s a big show. Hundreds of performers. But I don’t need an Oriental girl.
What about at the Japanese Pavilion?
I asked, my false confidence instantly eroding. I came from so far away. I really need a job.
It’s the Depression, kid. Everyone needs a job.
He glanced again at my application. And I hate to break it to you, but you aren’t Japanese. Grace Lee, that’s Chinese, right?
Will anyone know?
Kid, I doubt anyone can tell the difference. Can you?
I shrugged. I’d never seen a Japanese. I’d never seen a Chinese either other than my mother, my father, and my own reflection in the mirror—and Anna May Wong, Toy and Wing, and a couple of Orientals playing maids and butlers on the silver screen, but those weren’t in real life—so how could I be certain of the difference between a Japanese and a Chinese? I only knew my mother’s thin cheeks and chapped hands and my father’s weathered face and wiry arms. Like that, my eyes began to well. What if I failed? What if I had to go home?
We don’t have Orientals where I’m from,
I admitted, but I’ve always heard that they all look alike.
Be that as it may, I’ve been told to be authentic …
He snapped his fingers. I’ve got it. There’s going to be a Chinese Village. Those folks are doing their own hiring. Maybe I can get you set as a dancer from China.
"I’m not from China. I was born here."
Unconcerned, he picked up the phone. I listened as he suggested me to the person I assumed was in charge of the Chinese Village. He dropped the receiver back in the cradle. They aren’t hiring dancers in a permanent way. With all the troubles in China, it wouldn’t be right.
Troubles in China? I’d read about Germany’s aggression in Europe in the Plain City Advocate, but the newspaper came out only once a week. It barely covered events in Europe and never in Asia, so I was ignorant about all things Chinese except Chinese rice wine, which my mom made and sold out our back door on Friday and Saturday nights to the men in Plain City—a place as dry as chalk even after Prohibition ended. My mind pondered these things, but they were just a diversion from my panic.
What about on the Gayway?
I remembered that from Miss Miller’s advertisement.
That’s a carnival. I don’t see you there at all.
I’ve been to a carnival before—
Not like this one.
I can do it,
I insisted, but he’d better not try sending me to a hoochie-coochie tent like they had for men at the Plain City Fair. I’d never do that.
He shook his head. You’re a regular China doll. If I put you in the Gayway, the men would eat you up.
My five minutes were done, but the man didn’t dismiss me. Instead, he stared at me, taking in my dress, my shoes, the way I’d curled and combed my hair. I lowered my eyes and sat quietly. Perhaps it was proof of how the most innocent can remain safe—or that the man really was of good character—that he didn’t try or even suggest any funny business.
I’ll do anything,
I said, my voice now shaking, even if it’s boring or menial—
That’s not the way to sell yourself, kid.
I could work in a hamburger stand if I had to. Maybe one of the performers in the Cavalcade of the Golden West will get sick. You should have someone like me around, just in case.
You can try the concessions,
he responded dubiously. But you’ve got a big problem. Your gams are good, and your contours and promontories are in the right places. You’ve got a face that could crush a lily. But your accent—
My accent?
Yeah. You don’t have one. You’ve got to stop talking all perfect. You need to do the ching-chong thing.
Never! My father spoke in heavily accented English, even though he was born here. He always blamed it on the fact that he’d grown up in a lumber camp in the Sierras, where he lived with his father, who conversed only in Chinese. My mother’s English was flawless. She was born in China but came to America so early that she’d lost her accent entirely. How she was raised—somehow living far enough from other Chinese that she didn’t have an accent—was never discussed. The one time I asked, my father smacked me. In any case, the three of us could understand each other only if we communicated in English. And even if we all had spoken the same dialect, my father would never have allowed us to use it. Speaking English means you are American, and we must be American at all times. Reciting sentences like I hear you cut school again and what’s the big deal? showed we were assimilated. But all that didn’t mean Dad wouldn’t exaggerate his accent for his customers if he calculated it would make them happy.
I’m sorry,
I said. But I can’t do what you ask.
With nothing left to add, I got up to leave. In just these few minutes I’d learned two things about myself: I would never lower myself by faking an accent like my dad did (or Charlie Chan did in the movies), nor would I work naked as a hoochie-coochie dancer. All right, so I had pride. But what price would I have to pay for it? I felt sick with fear and despair.
Hey, kid, wait a sec.
The man reached into a drawer, pulled out a brown paper bag, and then met me at the door. A ham sandwich and an apple.
Heat crept up my face. I already hadn’t gotten the job. Did he have to humiliate me further? Did I appear that down at the heels?
Take it,
he said, pressing the bag into my hands. From the wife and me.
Thank you.
It would be my first real meal since leaving home.
He gave me a last pitying look. Have you tried the new nightclubs in Chinatown? I hear they’re looking for ponies and canaries.
Seeing my confused expression, he explained, I’m talking about dancers and singers—ponies and canaries. Aw, don’t worry about it. You’ll learn soon enough. Now head on back to your side of town. Ask anyone. They’ll tell you where to go to find an audition.
He gave me a gentle push out the door and called, Next.
On my way back to the dock, I conjured a nightclub in my mind. Top Hat, Swing Time, and A Star Is Born all had nightclubs, so I knew just what they looked like: white banquettes, hatcheck and cigarette girls, champagne bubbling in thin-stemmed glasses, men wearing top hats, white ties, and tails, and women swanning about in satin slip gowns cut on the bias that draped over their bodies like whispered kisses. My heart had been set on getting a job at the exposition, but working in a nightclub would be even better. A dollop of confidence: I will succeed.
But I still didn’t have an inkling about where Chinatown was or where to look once I got there, and that knowledge brought on a horrible wave of anxiety that all but drowned my momentary optimism. For now, I had nowhere to go except back to my hotel room. I already hated that place, with its cockroaches, women with their too-rouged cheeks, and men in their dirty undershirts who came and went, but I wouldn’t give up. I couldn’t give up, because that would mean going home to my father.
THE NEXT DAY, I put on my same rose-colored dress, bought a map, and followed its lines toward Chinatown. The clammy air was depressing. Passing all the soup lines and people—Okies, I guessed—dressed in tattered clothes, gaunt, just standing around, didn’t help either. I could end up like them if I wasn’t careful. And my body ached from the damp. My ribs and shoulder throbbed when I breathed or raised my arms, but I reminded myself that I’d danced through pain more times than I could count. I swallowed three aspirin dry and silently prayed that I wouldn’t have to do a ton of turns if I got an audition, which would be nearly impossible with my lingering vertigo.
At the corner of California Street and Grant Avenue, two peculiar-looking multiple-storied edifices with green-glazed tile roofs sat like guards: Sing Chong Bazaar and Sing Fat Bazaar. What crazy names! Behind the big plate-glass windows were things I’d never seen before: Chinese furniture, silks, and vases. Then I turned onto Grant and into another world. Coiling dragons painted in bright green, red, and gold decorated the streetlamps. Eaves curled skyward. I passed markets with produce stacked in baskets right on the sidewalk and restaurants advertising chop suey—whatever that was. And the smells! I couldn’t tell if they were good or bad—just odd.
But nothing unnerved me more than encountering so many Chinese eyes, mouths, noses, arms, and legs. Here were hundreds—maybe thousands—of Chinese men. They were tall and short, fat and thin, some light-skinned and some very dark. None of them looked like my father. I spotted a couple of older women, moving furtively along the sidewalk, doing their best to be invisible. Farther along, I saw five high school girls, wearing matching uniforms and carrying books. My knowledge of Chinese hair was limited to three examples: my mother’s tresses, which she kept in a bun; my father’s close-shaved head; and my own manufactured curls. So even the hair was different—long and silky, short bobs, permanent waves, marcels, spiky, wispy, balding, and in so many variations of black. Everything was as foreign and strange as if I’d just disembarked from a boat in Hong Kong, Canton, or Shanghai—not that I’d been to any of those places—making me both elated and petrified. Chinatown felt frighteningly enchanted in the way certain fairy tales had once left me unable to sleep. Was that why my parents had insisted on living so far from all this?
I needed help.
Can you direct me to a nightclub?
I asked a woman wearing what looked like black pajamas and carrying two bags overflowing with onion greens. She refused to acknowledge me. Next I tried to stop a newspaper boy, but he ignored me too. I gazed up the street: so many men here—some dressed as laborers, others as businessmen. Everyone seemed to be in a hurry, moving much faster than folks ever did back home, except for that time the Smith house caught fire and we all rushed to watch the volunteer fire department try to put it out. Now that was a night.
At the corner of Grant and Washington, I found three boys I guessed to be between ten and twelve years old playing in a sandpile dumped in the middle of the intersection. Their pants were rolled up to their knees, their sleeves smashed to their elbows, and their caps askew from roughhousing. Workmen shoveled the perimeter of the pile as cars and trucks honked at the traffic obstacle as though the added noise would cure the problem. I watched it all from the curb for a few minutes. Finally, I stepped into the street. My shoes sank into the sand as I delicately made my way to the little trio, who stopped their horseplay to watch me approach. The oldest boy grabbed two handfuls of sand and let the grains flow through his fingers.
No one said we couldn’t be out here,
he said by way of greeting.
I didn’t say they did,
I replied.
Then what do you want, lady?
My face crinkled. I’d never been called lady before. Measly girl. Hog face. Chink. Chinaman. Little one. Apple-pie winner. Heart dumpling. Kid and China doll just yesterday, but never lady. Act the part!
I’m hoping you can assist me,
I said.
What’s in it for us?
the oldest boy asked impudently.
A nickel each, if you help me.
I pulled out my coin purse, picked through it for three nickels, and held them in my palm. I’m looking for a nightclub—
Oh,
he said, his voice rising and falling knowingly. Won’t you get in trouble?
I dropped one of the nickels back into the coin purse.
So you’re familiar with the clubs,
I said. Every boy was curious about the forbidden, and my comment set off all three boys.
They’re barely better than bars—
No one wants them in the neighborhood—
My dad says they’re just a rat’s hair above a speakeasy—
I dropped another nickel into my coin purse.
You win, lady,
the ringleader conceded. You want to work in a big-thigh show, that’s your headache.
Big-thigh show?
Don’t you know anything?
he asked. You really want to let people see your legs?
As long as it’s just my legs …
Please tell me where to go,
I said.
I waited while he exchanged looks with his buddies. All I needed was one name to give me a start.
At last, he said, Wilbert Wong has the Li Po—a cocktail lounge on the next block. He’s changing it into more of a club. Andy Wong—not related—runs the Chinese Penthouse. It opened last December with all-Chinese entertainment.
He rattled this off like a town booster. This place was turning out to be a lot more like Plain City than it looked on the surface: a small town, where everyone knew everyone else’s business, especially when it came to the taboo.
I heard Andy Wong is going to change the name to the Sky Room,
the smallest boy ventured, which earned him an elbow to the ribs.
There’s Charlie Low’s new club. It’s not even open yet,
the oldest boy continued. Two years ago, he opened a bar here on Grant Avenue. No Chinese girls or women allowed. What am I saying? No Chinese went, period!
How would you know?
I asked, challenging him.
"I know," he responded.
Any boy could spout off about the birds and the bees—and other naughty things—but he often got the details wrong. It would now be up to me to figure out how much of what this little boy said was accurate and how much was gobbledygook picked up from listening to the whispers of older kids.
Charlie Low’s wife is a singer,
he continued, and he’s giving her a showplace called the Forbidden City. It’s on Sutter Street—
Not even in Chinatown,
the smallest boy interrupted again.
That appealed to me, because Chinatown was too scary for me.
Can you point the way?
I asked.
First, you go …
His voice trailed off, and his eyes widened. The other two boys stared gape-mouthed at something over my shoulder. I turned to see what they were ogling and saw a girl about my age gingerly step off the curb and come toward us. She wore a practical outfit: a gray wool pleated skirt, a long-sleeved black sweater, charcoal-gray wool stockings, and oxfords. She was Chinese, with flawless porcelain skin. She looked rich, like out of a movie, except that I’d never seen a Chinese who looked like her in the darkness of the Rialto.
I know how to get to the Forbidden City,
she said in melodious voice. I’ll take you.
Although Joe and the man on Treasure Island had both been perfectly nice to me, I wasn’t accustomed to kindness. Now here was a girl, offering to help, as if magically sent. I glanced down at the boys, trying to get a sense of what I should do.
She’s Helen Fong,
the ringleader said in awe. If she wants to help you, let her!
The other two boys, acting their young ages at last, covered their mouths and giggled. The girl named Helen gave them an unyielding look, and they went quiet but fast.
Kew, Chuen, Yee, I don’t think your mothers will be too happy to hear you aren’t in school,
she observed coolly. You’d better hurry along now.
The boys stood and brushed the sand off themselves. When they held out their palms, I paid them their promised nickels. Once they scampered off, I turned to Helen.
Where to?
HELEN
Calling to the Heavens
This way,
I answered, but what in the world was I thinking—skipping work, walking through Chinatown unescorted, and talking to a total stranger?
My pace was brisk, and I felt the girl wordlessly tagging along behind me as I wove down Grant. She caught up at a red light.
My name’s Grace,
she said.
Nice to meet you.
Thanks so much for helping me,
she went on, trying to appear composed, I thought, but actually sounding as scared as a fawn panting in fear at the sight of the moon.
It’s nothing,
I responded, but it was everything. This morning, my brother Monroe had walked me to the door of the Chinese Telephone Exchange, where I worked. After he left me, I’d simply stood there, unable to bring myself to enter the building. I couldn’t face another day of listening to the other women talk between calls about what they were going to make for dinner that night for their husbands, how clever their children were, or how hard it was to make ends meet. Those women just weren’t pleasant to me. I understood, I suppose. I earned the same five dollars a week they earned and gave every dime to my father for my upkeep,
but everyone knew my family was one of the best and most important in Chinatown.
So there I’d been, outside the telephone exchange, daydreaming about how the thousands of women—wives and concubines—in China’s imperial court had once spent their entire lives hidden inside the walls of the palace with no family or friends to love them. To amuse themselves, the women used to catch crickets and keep them in cages near their pillows. The crickets’ songs—haunting, calling to the heavens of their loneliness—told not only of their own lives but also of the women who were cared for, but equally helpless, in the cage of the palace. I lived in a traditional Chinese compound right in the heart of Chinatown, with twenty-nine of my closest relatives. A sense of futility had nearly overwhelmed me as I realized my life wasn’t all that different from those of the crickets who belonged to the women, who, in turn, belonged to the emperor. Right then, I’d noticed the girl in the street, talking to those silly boys. She looked as lost and lonely as I felt. She wasn’t fresh off the boat from China, but she was new to town, of that I was certain—a country bumpkin in her tatty store-bought dress. I’d edged to the intersection. As I’d listened to her conversation with the boys … I don’t know … I felt compelled to help her.
Once Grace and I were clearly out of Chinatown, my spirits lifted. No one from the neighborhood was watching me, hoping to curry favor with my father by reporting on my actions. We crossed the street, turned right on Sutter, and continued until we reached a sign that read FORBIDDEN CITY AUDITIONS. NO EXPERIENCE NEEDED. Music wafted down the stairs, enveloping us right on the street.
Here it is,
I said.
Come with me. Try out with me.
I shook my head. I can’t. I’ve never had a dance lesson.
It says no experience needed. We’ll stick together. I promise.
Before I could protest further, Grace took my hand. I never would have expected that from a Chinese girl. I shivered. Didn’t she know it was rude to touch like that? I guess not, because she gave me an encouraging smile and pulled me up the stairs. I had leapt so far out of my cage—out of myself—that I followed Grace like I was the one who was lost and she was now leading the way. Or maybe she was desperate and afraid to go in alone.
In the entry hall, workers—dressed in baggy pants, sleeveless undershirts, and painters’ caps—carried lumber and other construction materials. A Chinese woman, sitting at a table made from two-by-fours and a sheet of plywood, handed us forms with spaces for our names, heights, weights, and ages. I wrote down the address of my family’s compound. I glanced over Grace’s shoulder as she scribbled the name of a hotel in a seedy part of town.
The woman, who I was sure recognized me, took Grace’s form and scanned it. You’re seventeen?
she asked, not bothering to look up.
Is that all right?
"We’ve got younger inside. We just don’t want you to be too young. She pointed down the hall.
You can change in that room on the right. After that, sit with the other girls trying out today. They’ll call you when they’re ready. She didn’t specify who
they" were.
I lingered by the table when Grace walked down the hall.
If I get the job, how much will you pay?
I inquired.
Twenty a week,
the receptionist answered. I could almost hear additional words pouring out of her mouth. As though you need it. Then she bent back to her paperwork.
I could have walked out right then, but I was intrigued. Maybe I could do this. I traced the path Grace had taken and entered the half-finished ladies’ room. She had changed into a soft pink one-piece playsuit with short puffed sleeves and little shorts.
I made this,
she boasted, "after I saw Eleanor Powell wear something like it in Born to Dance. I couldn’t tell the color of the playsuit in the film, but I thought this fabric would look pretty against my skin."
I hadn’t been to many movies, so I didn’t know what to say.
She glanced in the mirror, squished her curls a couple of times to perk them up, and covered a cut with lipstick. I’d never be so rude as to ask her what had happened, but then she turned in my direction, frowned, and asked me a totally inappropriate question.
You don’t know how to doll up, do you?
she said with a laugh. She poked around in her bag and fished out a slippery thin pink hair ribbon, which she tucked between her lips. She turned me toward the mirror, ran her fingers through my hair, and then whisked the ribbon from her lips, passed it behind my neck, and pulled the satin strips to the top of my head, where she tied a bow. That’s better!
And it was, because the pink lifted my cheeks’ natural color.
We exited the restroom and followed the sound of music and rhythmic tapping. At the end of the hallway, I saw construction framing—for what looked like a bar to the left and a large central room. The stage looked done, though. The place was still a skeleton, but as my mind put flesh on it I began to see a nightclub like the one in Shanghai where I’d once danced the fox-trot …
Onstage, as if testing it for the first time, a Chinese man, twenty-six or twenty-seven, or maybe older, wearing cream-colored pants and a blue button-down linen shirt, slid across the floor, spun, and then resumed tapping. His arms appeared simultaneously loose and taut. The slap of his shoes as they hit the parquet—tat-a-tat—reverberated through the floorboards and shivered up my spine. His hair was slicked back with pomade, but his athletic steps—rattling now foot over foot across the front of the stage—caused strands to break loose and flop across his forehead. This, in turn, made him flip his head back after every dance phrase to clear his vision. And he was tall—almost six feet—which was extraordinary for a Chinese. He had no musical accompaniment, but his feet tapped out a rhythm that continued to build. Rah-cha, rah-cha, tat, tat, tat. Spin. Slide. Now his arms and legs flew—like a windmill. A group of forty or so girls, who sat cross-legged on the floor before the stage, clapped and cheered. Next to me, Grace radiated delight. I couldn’t help feeling the same way, because this was a lot better than the Chinese Telephone Exchange.
When the performance ended, the dancer picked up a towel and wiped the sweat from his face. He loped down the stairs, dropped onto a folding chair next to a woman and two men, all of whom had their backs to us. I focused on the girls by the stage. A couple of them were attired in playsuits like Grace, but the rest wore street clothes. I didn’t recognize a single girl. Not one of them was from Chinatown. The air I sucked in felt clean and free.
That’s when I saw her, one particular girl, who had a spot to herself. Suddenly I wanted out of there, but Grace gripped my hand tightly and pulled me across the floor toward the creature, who was strikingly different from all the rest. Light seemed to glow out of her skin. Her black hair was highlighted by a pair of shockingly white gardenias pinned just above her left ear. Her eyes sparkled, and her lips formed a perfect bow. She wore tap pants and a pale pink blouse with puffed sleeves not all that different from Grace’s, only hers had embroidery on the collar and cuffs. Her bare legs ended in ankle socks with delicate lace ruffles and basic black shoes with two-inch heels.
Sit with me,
she trilled when we reached her. I don’t know anyone either. I’m Ruby Tom.
Helen.
Grace pointed to me before putting her hand on her chest. Grace.
Ruby, excited, continued, Can you believe Eddie Wu?
Eddie Wu?
Grace echoed even as the three of us scrutinized each other to see where we fit in. Ruby and Grace looked poor in their homemade outfits; I was better-dressed than anyone in the room. Ruby’s features were willow-delicate, Grace had perfect cheekbones, while my face was a little rounder and softer. Ruby sparkled; Grace could be summed up in four words—skinny legs, big bosom. Otherwise, we looked quite similar: petite, slim, with black curls falling over our shoulders, except that Ruby wore those gardenias in her hair, which made her look like a glamorous crane amidst a flock of chickens. We shifted slightly. We’d finished with our evaluations. No wind; no waves.
The guy who was just dancing,
Ruby picked up as though no time had passed. Isn’t Eddie amazing? He’s a regular Fred Astaire.
But he’s Chinese,
Grace pointed out in a low voice.
That’s why they call him the Chinese Fred Astaire!
Ruby slapped her thigh. Then, "Are you two
