When Women Were Dragons: A Novel
4/5
()
About this ebook
"Ferociously imagined…and as exhilarating as a ride on dragonback." —Lev Grossman, bestselling author of The Magicians Trilogy
"Completely fierce, unmistakably feminist, and subversively funny." —Bonnie Garmus, bestselling author of Lessons in Chemistry
In the first adult novel by the New York Times bestselling author of The Ogress and The Orphans, Alex Green is a young girl in a world much like ours, except for its most seminal event: the Mass Dragoning of 1955, when hundreds of thousands of ordinary wives and mothers sprouted wings, scales, and talons; left a trail of fiery destruction in their path; and took to the skies. Was it their choice? What will become of those left behind? Why did Alex’s beloved aunt Marla transform but her mother did not? Alex doesn’t know. It’s taboo to speak of.
Forced into silence, Alex nevertheless must face the consequences of this astonishing event: a mother more protective than ever; an absentee father; the upsetting insistence that her aunt never even existed; and
watching her beloved cousin Bea become dangerously obsessed with the forbidden.
In this timely and timeless speculative novel, award-winning author Kelly Barnhill boldly explores rage, memory, and the tyranny of forced limitations. When Women Were Dragons exposes a world that wants to keep women small—their lives and their prospects—and examines what happens when they rise en masse and take up the space they deserve.
Kelly Barnhill
KELLY BARNHILL lives in Minnesota with her husband and three children. She is the author of four novels, most recently The Girl Who Drank the Moon, winner of the 2017 John Newbery Medal. She is also the winner of the World Fantasy Award and has been a finalist for the Minnesota Book Award, a Nebula Award, and the PEN/USA literary prize. Visit her online at www.kellybarnhill.com or on Twitter: @kellybarnhill.
Read more from Kelly Barnhill
- The Crane Husband Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Related to When Women Were Dragons
Related ebooks
- The Bone Season Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- A Short Walk Through a Wide World: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- A Day of Fallen Night Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- The Book Eaters Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- Atalanta: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- The Crescent Moon Tearoom: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- Weyward: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- The Ministry of Time: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- The Mime Order Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratings
Feminist Fiction For You
- The Handmaid's Tale Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- I Who Have Never Known Men Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- The Bell Jar: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- Stone Blind: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- Lessons in Chemistry: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- Clytemnestra: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- The Lioness of Boston: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- Woo Woo: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- Ariel: The Restored Edition Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- Poor Things: A Novel Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratings
- The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas: A Story Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5
- A Certain Hunger Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- Animal: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- A Woman Is No Man: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- A Resistance of Witches: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- The Family Fang: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- They Never Learn Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- Ripe: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- Lady Macbeth: A Novel Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5
- The Visitors Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- Lilith: A Novel Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratings
- Reservoir Bitches: Stories Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- A Botanist's Guide to Parties and Poisons Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- Breasts and Eggs: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- Switchboard Soldiers: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- Perfume and Pain: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- They Drown Our Daughters Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- The Book of Joan: A Novel Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5
- Canary Girls: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
- The Society of Shame Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5
Related categories
Reviews for When Women Were Dragons
302 ratings27 reviews
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Jan 15, 2025 Magically beautiful and so real. This book captures so many complex cultural concepts so completely.
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Feb 9, 2025 This was really beautiful and quite sad. At the end, I was left feeling more bittersweet than I anticipated. I was really absorbed the Alex's journey and often found myself wondering how I would feel if I were in her position. I appreciated the setting and the little scientific notes sprinkled between some of the chapters - I think they added just enough context without pulling too much away from our main character's story. I'm not sure if I was supposed to be feeling so sad at the end, but I was. I don't know, this is one of those books that I just really loved and can't find the right words to describe!
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Jul 4, 2025 2024: Interesting that I've read this book in years that were significant(ly bad) for women; of course, I have no idea what will happen next under the orange man and will try to remain...hopeful? I would love a mass dragoning to happen right now. Would the men listen? Would any of the women that voted orange dragon? I am trying to not be sad, but my disappointment is heavy.
 I listened to the audio this time and would listen again. Still excited to share this book with others and hopefully will find my voice again soon. Being willing to put oneself out into the world, share opinions, that has been very difficult for me since it started feeling dangerous to have any idea that the extremes don't like. Especially when everyone's idea about "extreme" varies.
 UGH. This world. I want to run away into nature and be free with the birds.
 2022: I LOVED this book. I can't wait to buy it in paperback to read it over and over and over and to share it with G when she's older. The desire for freedom, I FELT that. Feeling stuck, feeling like you have to bury yourself under societal expectations.
 Writing this review AFTER the overturning of Roe v Wade, it just makes me want to read the book again now. I have a feeling it'll hit harder.
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Sep 19, 2025 Yes to everything about this book! I loved all the characters, the nuance, how it made me think.
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Jul 20, 2025 I thoroughly enjoyed reading When Women Were Dragons by Kelly Barnhill. It’s a novel with well-developed, interesting characters from a scientist masquerading as a librarian, to a remote father, to a mother trying to hold off cancer so she can raise her children. The book makes you think about male-female roles, the joy of being a woman, freedom of the press, keeping secrets, and choices. And if that sounds too serious, don’t despair. It’s also an absorbing story that will draw you in and keep you reading to the very last page. It’s referred been labelled a fantasy novel, but that’s far, far too limiting.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5May 23, 2025 This sizzling feminist fantasy about women who spontaneously turn into dragons and how the phenomenon is handled by the rest of the world is original and bright and occasionally very funny.
 On April 25, 1955, between the hours of 11:45 a.m. and 2:50 p.m., central time, 642,987 American women – wives and mothers, all – became dragons … and no fewer than 1,246 philandering husbands [were] extracted from the embrace of their mistresses and devoured on the spot.
 Now, come on – how could you not applaud a book that drops that on you on page 41?
 Kelly Barnhill’s perfectly logical takeoff point (you should excuse the pun) is the pressure-cooker conformity imposed on so many Americans in the mid-50s, but particularly on women. With their avenues of self-expression, professional opportunities, and personal freedom as relentlessly compressed by church and legislature and public opinion as their bodies were compressed by ironclad girdles and rocket-nosecone bras, what sane person would not opt to be huge and ferocious and utterly magnificent? And, given an era dominated by the McCarthy Hearings and the House Un-American Activities Committee, how could the public response be anything but denial, denial, denial?
 The novel operates both on a personal level, following Alex Green and her family as they deal with the dragoning of Alex’s aunt Marla, and on a much wider scale looking at the ways in which truth becomes malleable and certain segments of the population become marginalized for their differences. As Alex grows up, she is constantly torn between her love of and responsibility for her cousin Beatrice, left functionally orphaned by Marla’s departure, and Alex’s own academic goals, more or less constantly thwarted by the prevalent “girls can’t” philosophy, the loss of her mother, and the actions of one of the most despicable fictional fathers ever created.
 And here’s where the first of the problems arise with the tale. Alex’s father is drawn as such a villain that he veers into straw man territory. His only function in the book seems to be being mean, until his final scene with Alex, wherein his emotional turnaround is utterly unbelievable. Even the dragons mellow toward the end of the novel, changing from fierce and fearsome manifestations of female power to nurturing aunties who go around succoring orphans and stopping wars. You know, as dragons do.
 Barnhill uses a wonderful and original ongoing metaphor dealing with knots – the drawing together and binding of power they represent, the intricate patterning not always immediately obvious to the eye, and the sense of overarching design and purpose. It’s a beautiful subtext throughout the narrative, and helps keep things afloat when the action threatens to bog down near the conclusion.
 The underlying power of the narrative and the strong family bonds that do survive manage to keep this novel well worth reading, but it’s certainly not without flaws.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Aug 28, 2024 A story about women, this historical fiction about women in the 1950s and 1960s, dysfunctional relationships and the different ways women (and girls) have had to cope, this is an interesting twist with a little bit of fantasy. I was hoping for *more* dragons, or more examination of the magic part of things, ultimately it seems like they were more of a metaphor for female rage, or strength.
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Aug 11, 2024 WHEN WOMEN WERE DRAGONS was a fascinating story of our recent past with one significant change. On April 25, 1955, there was a mass dragoning when more than 600,000 women spontaneously turned into dragons and the government instituted a massive coverup to hide dragoning.
 Alex Green was a young girl when the dragoning took place. She was four when she saw her first dragon who happened to be a neighbor who had been kind to her. Alex's mother had cancer and was away for treatment during that same time period. Alex was cared for by her Aunt Marla, her mother's older sister. She was eight when the mass dragoning happened and her Aunt Marla was one of those women who dragoned.
 It was a repressive time. No one ever talked about dragoning or cancer or women's health issues. But Alex tried to stifle her curiosity but had many questions. She didn't know how to feel when her mother brought Marla's infant daughter home and declared that Bea had always been her sister and that Aunt Marla had never existed. Alex quickly became Bea's greatest protector which didn't change when her mother died of cancer when Alex was in eighth grade and when her father remarried and established Alex and Bea in an apartment and sent financial support but never visited his daughters again.
 Alex was left alone with responsibilities that should never have been placed on a child's shoulders, but she was determined to study and even attend college one day despite her father's refusal to support that dream. She did have a friend and supporter in Mrs. Gyzinska who was the head librarian at the local Carnegie Library.
 The story is told not only in Alex's voice but through newspaper articles and excerpts from the work of Dr. H. N. Gantz who had lost his positions as a university professor and doctor of medicine when he refused to stop researching and writing about dragons.
 This was an intriguing story. I enjoyed the rich language and deep emotions. Alex was a character who wasn't going to let the common values of the day stop her from becoming who she was meant to be. I liked the whole underground rebellion against the repression of facts in which Mrs. Gyzinska and Professor Gantz were deeply involved.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Apr 1, 2024 In general, there were good parts to the book, but it was repetetive, with some plot holes. The idea of this book is that women, throughout history, have had the ability to transform into dragons fueled by anger or other passions. There was a mass dragoning event in the 50's, when a large number of women transformed to dragons, left homes and families, leaving a certain amount of destruction.
 So in general, a woman's empowerment story. I would probably give this one 3 or 3.5 stars; and I'd say that if you liked [Lessons in Chemistry] you might like this as some of the themes are similar.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Mar 5, 2024 Very interesting book. A very feminist tale. So many paralells with our world today.
 I really enjoyed it. Definitely recommend it.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Jan 23, 2024 In this novel, women sometimes become dragons - sometimes in individual instances and others in mass. For all that this is a fantastical element, these dragons exist in a world that is very much our own. The Mass Dragoning of 1955 centers this novel, which is very much about one family and the impact of members leaving, staying, and returning. The process of becoming a dragon is something only addressed in whispers and discouraged by society even as it continues to happen. Metaphors abound in this novel and while one could certainly read this novel as a metaphor for many things, one could also simply enjoy it as a great story.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Jan 12, 2024 This book is rather obviously an allegory for women's rights, gay rights, civil rights, and an exploration of the anger of women. But it doesn't creak though it repeats, and repetition is part of the structure. It's is a bit impeded by wanting to tell more story than quite fits into a compact plot so there is some roughness in the flow when the thrust of the rather slow quiet action shifts.
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Jan 2, 2024 Beautiful book. Everything well-described, great characters who are distinct and varied. Great story.
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Oct 11, 2023 A wonderful, melancholy, frustrating read.
 The main character suffers so many indignities and so much unfairness. If I found it frustrating to read, imagine the frustration of living through it. While this book is fiction, the societal problems it represents are all too real.
 Themes of feminism, sexism, homophobia, racism, family mutability, motherhood, grief, abuse, emotional maturity, and many more, all entwined together.
 I wish I had kept notes while I read, because When Women Were Dragons forced me to think deeply, brought many memories back from my childhood, and showed me my own social offenses.
 The melancholy ending left me feeling... I don't know. Grief? Hope? A poignant ending to a poignant book.
 The main character often didn't have the words or the context to explain her feelings, much less understand them. She repeated this time and again. This shared lack is something from my own past, and one that I try to keep from my daughters.
 I recommend this book without reservation.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Jul 23, 2023 It was a bit slow to start and I almost put it down. I took a moment to read more about the book and was intrigued to continue. And I am glad I did. There were some very touching parts in there.
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Jan 2, 2023 On April 25, 1955, 642,987 women spontaneously turned into dragons and flew away from their previous lives.
 It was considered a shameful act and these women were never acknowledged again. It was as if they had never existed at all.
 Such was the case with Alex’s aunt Marla, who dragoned on that day leaving her young daughter Beatrice and a shiftless drunk husband behind. Beatrice came to live with Alex’s family; it was never admitted that she had had a previous life.
 Scientists were forbidden from studying the phenomena. Those scientists who persisted were actively persecuted.
 Slowly it became realized that the new dragons had previously been living lives that were smaller than they were: unfit husbands, careers that were open to women in the 1950’s, even loving other women.
 And as the daughters (and the rare son) of this generation of unspeakable women grew up, magical things begin to happen.
 I loved this book. Never make yourself smaller than you are!
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Oct 31, 2022 Protagonist Alexandra (Alex) Green is eight years old in 1955, when the first “Mass Dragoning” occurs. Her Aunt Marla is one of hundreds of thousands of women who take to the skies as dragons, leaving behind her baby daughter, Beatrice. The storyline follows Alex from childhood through her early twenties, as told by her older self, looking back on her life. Alex is a gifted mathematician. She must surmount many obstacles to care for her sister-cousin and pursue higher education. The “Mass Dragoning” is denied by the government, and penalties are enforced for speaking openly about it.
 I do not often read fantasy, so I was not sure if I would enjoy it. I was pleasantly surprised to find that the dragons are the only fantasy aspect. It falls mainly in the categories of historical and speculative fiction. It is a book about women and the difficulties they have faced in the past due to systemic discrimination, but it is written in a way that it also pertains to people of color and the LBGTQ community. I think the structure is pretty clever and well executed.
 While it showcases the obstacles and difficulties, it also portrays the profound sense of joy at finding the freedom to be oneself, and to break free of societal bonds. It also conveys a strong sense of acceptance of others. This all takes place during the era of McCarthy and the House Un-American Activities Committee. Scientists find themselves running afoul of the Committee if they try to study it. Basically, life proceeds as if the “Mass Dragoning” never happened. It also provides a message of the damage done to society through suppression or denial of the truth, which is, of course, a currently relevant topic.
 There are a few drawbacks. Do not expect any explanations of why some people become dragons and others do not. The male characters come across as a bit stereotypical. But overall, quite a lot is accomplished in this book, and I liked this much more than expected.
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Oct 29, 2022 My latest fiction obsession has been mid-century feminist fiction and When Women Were Dragons fits the bill magnificently. I appreciate the perspective of our protagonist, Alex, being central to the storytelling, alternating between her childhood, when the Mass Dragoning takes place, and contemporary knowledge and research of the Dragons. In addition to Alex’s first person POV, we, as readers, are treated to various interludes from the foremost (underground) expert on Dragoning, Dr. Gantz, and I appreciated his overwhelming desire to understand and discuss what was happening to the women who dragooned, rather than ignore it like most of his contemporaries. As a person whose mother also suffered from cancer when I was a young girl, I greatly appreciated how Kelly handled showing Mother’s sickness from child and teenage Alex’s perspectives. I tremendously enjoyed When Women Were Dragons and am very excited to add it to my shelf of favorite books at home.
- Rating: 2 out of 5 stars2/5Sep 20, 2022 Pedestrian YA about a girl growing up in suburban USA in the 1950's & '60's. It has the usual tropes - distant father, downtrodden but brave mother, feisty unconventional aunt, et al. - but does nothing new or inventive with them. And the dragons are utterly pointless. A book with this title should have fire and fury, power and rage - this has a few houses burned down at the beginning, then the dragons disappear, then return at the end of the book as domesticated cozy aunties. Why bother?
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Aug 29, 2022 Feminism and dragons. Set in an alternative 1950s and '60s America. f/f love story is not the main story line. What makes "family" is.
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Aug 28, 2022 "Alex is a young girl in a world much like ours, except for it's most seminal event: the Mass Dragoning of 1955, when hundreds of thousands of ordinary wives and mothers sprouted wings, scales, and talons; left a trail of fiery destruction in their paths; and took to the skies."
 I loved this book! It was hard to put down and when I had to put it down to feed the pups or help with dinner I couldn't stop thinking about it! My thanks to the library patron who included a note when she returned this book thanking the librarians for this book which in turn was handed to me by our library director! What would we do without our libraries and librarians? They have been such an important part of my life since I was a little girl!
- Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Aug 6, 2022 This book started off very strong. I loved the concept of women turning into dragons. And I wanted to like this book a lot more than I did.
 There's a shallowness to the "Men All Bad / Women All Good" dichotomy. I don't think anyone is all good or all bad - instead we're all a mix of both at different times and in different situations.
 I also wanted to see a lot more people being eaten by dragons! I mean why turn women into dragons just to have them sit around and knit??? It was more like a great "Old Ladying".
 This book isn't identified as YA, but it's definitely got a YA vibe.
 The storyline isn't very clear. It just bumps along without a clear conflict and resolution. Characters come and go, the ending is very rushed, interactions are very simplistic, and most of the book I was a little bored.
- Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Jul 26, 2022 Women are magic. In 1955, hundreds of thousands of women turned into dragons and left behind their husbands, children, and ordinary lives. During the mass dragoning, Alex lost her aunt Marla. Dragoning, considered taboo, is not talked about, discussed, and the women who dragoned are never mentioned again. Marla's daughter Bea, was quietly taken in by Alex's mother. Years later, Alex's mother becomes sick and dies. Her father quickly marries and shuffles Alex and Bea off to an apartment and orders teenage Alex to take charge. Determined to graduate, Alex struggles to come to terms with her aunt's dragoning, her mother's death, and her father's abandonment.
 This was a very interesting premise. I thought it was a clever and intriguing idea. The story itself was a bit dry and slow moving. The characters were a bit bland and stereotypical. I liked the bits of history the author threw in between chapters, it added to the lore of dragoning. Overall, 3 out of 5 stars.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Jul 15, 2022 When the Mass Dragoning event of 1955 occurred, Alex's aunt Marla dragoned and left her daughter, Beatrice, behind. Alex's mother stayed human, and pretended it never happened. Beatrice was Alex's sister. We don't talk about dragons. This is Alex's story as she grows up in a patriarchal world of secrets and cover-ups, as she struggles to come into her own and discover what she wants.
 The story is written from Alex's perspective, interspersed with articles or interview transcriptions that tell us more about the history of dragoning - because, as we come to find out, it's not just this one occurrence. Women have been becoming dragons all over the world all over time, just not as obviously as the one in Alex's lifetime. I loved the idea behind the book, but struggled a bit with its execution. I enjoyed Alex's narration and watching her grow up in the 1950s and 60s, dealing with her parents' expectations and rules and changing her opinions over the years even as the story of what caused dragoning changes. That last, I think, was really the sticking point for me. At first, I thought dragoning was a metaphor for female rage. But that's not quite right, and every time I thought I had a handle on it, the meaning changed again. It was distracting rather than adding to Alex's coming of age story and deciding what kind of person she wanted to be.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Jul 6, 2022 At first I was unsure about how much I would enjoy this book. It goes back and forth between Alex's story and government and scientific reports about the occurrences of dragoning in America (and those got a little dry). But I persisted and it was well worth it. Definitely an original story blending the fantasy notion of dragons in 1950's America. It's also a revealing story about how women were treated and how they chose freedom as a dragon over the human bonds of family, work or societal demands. Definitely add this to your feminist/LGBTQ list of wonderful reads.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Jun 8, 2022 On April 25, 1955, thousands of American women simultaneously became dragons and flew away. Alex Green's mother did not leave, but her aunt Marla did, leaving behind Beatrice, Alex's adored baby cousin. Alex's mother informs Alex that Beatrice is her sister, has always been her sister, and she never had an Aunt Marla. That's pretty much how the whole country deals with the issue of spontaneous dragoning: pretend it doesn't happen, and never speak of it. After all, it's one of those feminine things, like menstruation, not to be discussed in mixed company (or at all, if one can help it). But although the 1955 dragoning event was the largest on record, it was neither the first nor the last case of women becoming dragons. Alex has questions, and she's not the only one. Her world is on the verge of a change of mindset about women, dragons, and their place in it.
 I found this to be a rather more serious and message-heavy book than I was expecting, more about Alex as she grows up, with relatively few dragons appearing on the page for most of the book. That's not to say I didn't enjoy it -- the ideas the author plays with are both interesting and well-presented. (I was just hoping for more dragons.)
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5May 3, 2022 A difficult one to review—viscerally beautiful, and you can feel the impulses of rage and joy that led to the writing of the novel, but the story is sometimes hard to follow and doesn't hold together in a few places.
Book preview
When Women Were Dragons - Kelly Barnhill
When Women Were Dragons
Being the Truthful Accounting of the Life of Alex Green—Physicist, Professor, Activist. Still Human.
A memoir, of sorts.
Greetings, Mother—
I do not have much time. This change (this wondrous, wondrous change) is at this very moment upon me. I could not stop it if I tried. And I have no interest in trying.
It is not from any place of sorrow that I write these words. There is no room for sorrow in a heart full of fire. You will tell people that you did not raise me to be an angry woman, and that statement will be correct. I was never allowed to be angry, was I? My ability to discover and understand the power of my own raging was a thing denied to me. Until, at last, I learned to stop denying myself.
You told me on my wedding day that I was marrying a hard man whom I shall have the pleasure to sweeten. It is a good woman,
 you said, who brings out the goodness in a man.
 That lie became evident on our very first night together. My husband was not a good man, and nothing ever would have made him so. I married a man who was petulant, volatile, weak-willed, and morally vile. You knew this, and yet you whispered matronly secrets into my ear and told me that the pain would be worth the babies that I would bring to you one day. 
But there were no babies, were there? My husband’s beatings saw to that. And now I shall see to him. Tooth and claw. The downtrodden becomes the bearer of a heavenly, righteous flame. It burns me, even now. I find myself unbound by earth, unbound by man, unbound by wifely duty and womanly pain.
I regret nothing.
I shall not miss you, Mother. Perhaps I won’t even remember you. Does a flower remember its life as a seed? Does a phoenix recall itself as it burns anew? You will not see me again. I shall be but a shadow streaking across the sky—fleeting, speeding, and utterly gone.
—From a letter written by Marya Tilman, a housewife from Lincoln, Nebraska, and the earliest scientifically confirmed case of spontaneous dragoning within the United States prior to the Mass Dragoning of 1955—also known as the Day of Missing Mothers. The dragoning, per reports from eyewitnesses, happened during the day, on September 18, 1898, as a lemonade social was underway in the garden of next-door neighbors, to celebrate an engagement. Information and data regarding Mrs. Tilman’s case was suppressed by authorities. Despite the sheer amount of corroborating evidence, including the accidental capture on a daguerreotype taken next door which showed in shocking clarity the dragoning at its midpoint, and signed affidavits by witnesses, it was not covered by a single newspaper—local or national—and all studies organized to research the phenomenon were barred from both funding and publication. Scientists, journalists, and researchers were fired and blacklisted for simply asking questions about the Tilman case. It was not the first time such research blackouts occurred, but the sheer quality of the evidence, and the vigor of the governmental effort to suppress it, was enough to trigger the formation of the Wyvern Research Collective, an underground association of doctors, scientists, and students, all dedicated to the preservation of information and study (peer-reviewed when possible) of both spontaneous and intentional dragoning, in order to better understand the phenomenon.
Gentlemen, it is not my place to tell you how to do your jobs. I am a scientist, not a congressman. My task is to raise questions, carefully record observations, and vigorously analyze the data, in hopes that others might raise more questions after me. There cannot be science without the interrogation of closely held beliefs, as well as the demolition of personal aversions and biases. There cannot be science without the free and unfettered dissemination of truth. When you, as the creators of policy, seek to use your power to curtail understanding and thwart the free exchange of knowledge and ideas, it is not I who will suffer the consequences of this, but rather the whole nation, and, indeed, the entire world.
Our country lost hundreds of thousands of its wives and mothers on April 25, 1955, due to a process that we can barely understand—not because it is by its nature unknowable, but because science has been both forbidden from searching for answers and hobbled in its response. This is an untenable situation. How can a nation respond to a crisis like this without the collaboration of scientists and doctors, without sharing clinical findings and laboratory data? The mass transformation that occurred on April 25, 1955, was unprecedented in terms of its size and scope, but it was not—please, sirs, it is important that you let me finish—it was not an anomaly. Such things have happened before, and I will tell you plainly that so-called dragoning continues to this day, a fact which would be more widely known and understood if the doctors and researchers who studied this phenomenon hadn’t lost their positions and livelihoods, or faced the horror of their labs and records being rifled through and destroyed by authorities. I know full well that speaking frankly and candidly to you today puts me at grave risk of harpooning what is left of my career. But I am a scientist, sirs, and my allegiance is not to this body, nor even to myself, but only to the truth. Who benefits when knowledge is buried? Who gains when science succumbs to political expediency? Not I, Congressmen. And certainly not the American people, whom you are honor-bound to serve.
—From the opening statement given by Dr. H. N. Gantz (former chief of Internal Medicine at Johns Hopkins University Hospital and erstwhile research fellow at the National Institutes of Health, the Army Medical Corps, and the National Science Administration) to the House Committee on Un-American Activities, February 9, 1957
1.
I was four years old when I first met a dragon. I never told my mother. I didn’t think she’d understand.
(I was wrong, obviously. But I was wrong about a lot of things when it came to her. This is not particularly unusual. I think, perhaps, none of us ever know our mothers, not really. Or at least, not until it’s too late.)
The day I met a dragon, was, for me, a day of loss, set in a time of instability. My mother had been gone for over two months. My father, whose face had become as empty and expressionless as a hand in a glove, gave me no explanation. My auntie Marla, who had come to stay with us to take care of me while my mother was gone, was similarly blank. Neither spoke of my mother’s status or whereabouts. They did not tell me when she would be back. I was a child, and was therefore given no information, no frame of reference, and no means by which I might ask a question. They told me to be a good girl. They hoped I would forget.
There was, back then, a little old lady who lived across our alley. She had a garden and a beautiful shed and several chickens who lived in a small coop with a faux owl perched on top. Sometimes, when I wandered into her yard to say hello, she would give me a bundle of carrots. Sometimes she would hand me an egg. Or a cookie. Or a basket full of strawberries. I loved her. She was, for me, the one sensible thing in a too-often senseless world. She spoke with a heavy accent—Polish, I learned much later—and called me her little żabko, as I was always jumping about like a frog, and then would put me to work picking ground-cherries or early tomatoes or nasturtiums or sweet peas. And then, after a bit, she would take my hand and walk me home, admonishing my mother (before her disappearance) or my aunt (during those long months of mother-missing). You must keep your eyes on this one,
 she’d scold, or one day she’ll sprout wings and fly away.
 
It was the very end of July when I met the dragon, on an oppressively hot and humid afternoon. One of those days when thunderstorms linger just at the edge of the sky, hulking in raggedy murmurs for hours, waiting to bring in their whirlwinds of opposites—making the light dark, howling at silences, and wringing all the wetness out of the air like a great, soaked sponge. At this moment, though, the storm had not yet hit, and the whole world simply waited. The air was so damp and warm that it was nearly solid. My scalp sweated into my braids, and my smocked dress had become crinkled with my grubby handprints.
I remember the staccato barking of a neighborhood dog.
I remember the far-off rumble of a revving engine. This was likely my aunt, fixing yet another neighbor’s car. My aunt was a mechanic, and people said she had magic hands. She could take any broken machine and make it live again.
I remember the strange, electric hum of cicadas calling to one another from tree to tree to tree.
I remember the floating motes of dust and pollen hanging in the air, glinting in the slant of light.
I remember a series of sounds from my neighbor’s backyard. A man’s roar. A woman’s scream. A panicked gasping. A scrabble and a thud. And then, a quiet, awestruck Oh!
Each one of these memories is clear and keen as broken glass. I had no means to understand them at the time—no way to find the link between distinct and seemingly unrelated moments and bits of information. It took years for me to learn how to piece them together. I have stored these memories the way any child stores memory—a haphazard collection of sharp, bright objects socked away on the darkest shelves in the dustiest corners of our mental filing systems. They stay there, those memories, rattling in the dark. Scratching at the walls. Disrupting our careful ordering of what we think is true. And injuring us when we forget how dangerous they are, and we grasp too hard.
I opened the back gate and walked into the old lady’s yard, as I had done a hundred times. The chickens were silent. The cicadas stopped humming and the birds stopped calling. The old lady was nowhere to be seen. Instead, there in the center of the yard, I saw a dragon sitting on its bottom, midway between the tomatoes and the shed. It had an astonished expression on its enormous face. It stared at its hands. It stared at its feet. It craned its neck behind itself to get a load of its wings. I didn’t cry out. I didn’t run away. I didn’t even move. I simply stood, rooted to the ground, and stared at the dragon.
Finally, because I had come to see the little old lady, and I was nothing if not a purposeful little girl, I cleared my throat and demanded to know where she was. The dragon looked at me, startled. It said nothing. It winked one eye. It held one finger to its lipless jaws as though to say Shh.
 And then, without waiting for anything else, it curled its legs under its great body like a spring, tilted its face upward toward the clouds overhead, unfurled its wings, and, with a grunt, pushed the earth away, leaping toward the sky. I watched it ascend higher and higher, eventually arcing westward, disappearing over the wide crowns of the elm trees. 
I didn’t see the little old lady again after that. No one mentioned her. It was as though she never existed. I tried to ask, but I didn’t have enough information to even form a question. I looked to the adults in my life to provide reason or reassurance, but found none. Only silence. The little old lady was gone. I saw something that I couldn’t understand. There was no space to mention it.
Eventually, her house was boarded up and her yard grew over and her garden became a tangled mass. People walked by her house without giving it a second glance.
I was four years old when I first saw a dragon. I was four years old when I first learned to be silent about dragons. Perhaps this is how we learn silence—an absence of words, an absence of context, a hole in the universe where the truth should be.
2.
My mother returned to me on a Tuesday. There was, again, no explanation, no reassurance; just a silence on the matter that was cold, heavy, and immovable, like a block of ice frozen to the ground; it was one more thing that was simply unmentionable. It was, if I remember correctly, a little more than two weeks after the old lady across the alley had disappeared. And when her husband, coincidentally, also disappeared. (No one mentioned that, either.)
On the day my mother returned, my auntie Marla was in a frenzy, cleaning the house and attacking my face with a hot washcloth, again and again, and brushing my hair obsessively, until it gleamed. I complained, loudly, and tried unsuccessfully to wriggle out of her firm grasp.
Come now,
 my aunt said tersely, that’s enough of that. We want you to look your best, now, don’t we?
 
What for?
 I asked, and I stuck out my tongue. 
For no reason at all.
 Her tone was final—or she had clearly attempted it to be so. But even as a child I could hear the question mark hiding there. Auntie Marla released me and flushed a bit. She stood and looked out the window. She wrinkled her brow. And then she returned to vacuuming. She polished the chrome accents on the oven and scoured the floor. Every window shone like water. Every surface shimmered like oil. I sat in my room with my dolls (which I did not enjoy) and my blocks (which I did) and pouted. 
I heard the low rumble of my father’s car arriving at our house around lunchtime. This was highly unusual because he never came home during a workday. I approached the window and pressed my nose to the glass, making a singular, round smudge. He curled out of the driver’s-side door and adjusted his hat. He patted the smooth curves of the hood as he crossed over and opened the passenger door, his hand extended. Another hand reached out. I held my breath.
A stranger stepped out of the car, wearing my mother’s clothes. A stranger with a face similar to my mother’s, but not—puffy where it should be delicate, and thin where it should be plump. She was paler than my mother, and her hair was sparse and dull—all wisps and feathers and bits of scalp peeking out. Her gait was unsteady and halting—she had none of my mother’s footsure stride. I twisted my mouth into a knot.
They began walking slowly toward the house, my father and this stranger. My father’s right arm curled around her birdlike shoulders and held her body close. His hat sat on his head at a front-leaning angle, tilted slightly to the side, hiding his face in shadow. I couldn’t see his expression. Once they crossed the midpoint of the front walkway, I tore out of my room at a run and arrived, breathless, in the entryway. I wiped my nose with the back of my hand as I watched the door, and waited.
My aunt gave a strangled cry and peeled out of the kitchen, an apron tied around her waist, its lace edge whispering against the knees of her dungarees. She threw open the front door and let them inside. I watched the way her cheeks flushed at the sight of this figure in my mother’s clothes, the way her eyes reddened and slicked with tears.
Welcome home,
 my aunt said, her voice catching. She pressed one hand to her mouth, and the other to her heart. 
I looked at my aunt. I looked at the stranger. I looked at my father. I waited for an explanation, but nothing came. I stamped my foot. They didn’t react. Finally, my father cleared his throat.
Alexandra,
 he said. 
It’s Alex,
 I whispered. 
My father ignored this. Alexandra, don’t stand there gawping. Kiss your mother.
 He checked his watch. 
The stranger looked at me. She smiled. Her smile sort of looked like my mother’s, but her body was all wrong, and her face was all wrong, and her hair was all wrong, and her smell was all wrong, and the wrongness of the situation felt insurmountable. My knees went wobbly and my head began to pound. I was a serious child in those days—sober and introspective and not particularly prone to crying or tantrums. But I remember a distinct burning sensation at the back of my eyes. I remember my breath turning into hiccups. I couldn’t take a single step.
The stranger smiled and swayed, and clutched my father’s left arm. He didn’t seem to notice. He turned his body slightly away and checked his watch again. Then he gave me a stern look. Alexandra,
 he said flatly. Don’t make me ask again. Think of how your mother must feel.
 
My face felt very hot.
My aunt was at my side in a moment, sweeping me upward and hoisting me onto her hip, as though I was a baby. Kisses are better when we can all do them together,
 she said. Come on, Alex.
 And without another word, she hooked one arm around the stranger’s waist and placed her cheek against the stranger’s cheek, forcing my face right into the notch between the stranger’s neck and shoulder. 
I felt my mother’s breath on my scalp.
I heard my mother’s sigh caress my ear.
I ran my fingers along the roomy fabric of her floral dress and curled it into my fist.
Oh,
 I said, my voice more breath than sound, and I wrapped one arm around the back of the stranger’s neck. I don’t remember crying. I do remember my mother’s scarf and collar and skin becoming wet. I remember the taste of salt. 
Well, that’s my cue,
 my father said. Be a good girl, Alexandra.
 He extended the sharp point of his chin. Marla,
 he nodded at my aunt. Make sure she lies down,
 he added. He didn’t say anything to the stranger. My mother, I mean. He didn’t say anything to my mother. Maybe we were all strangers now. 
After that day, Auntie Marla continued to come by the house early each morning and stay long after my father came home from work, only returning to her own home after the nighttime dishes were done and the floors were swept and my mother and father were in bed. She cooked and managed and played with me during my mother’s endless afternoon lie-downs. She ran the house, and only went to her job at the mechanic’s shop on Saturdays, though this made my father cross, as he had no idea what to do with me, or my mother, for a whole day by himself.
Rent isn’t free, after all,
 she reminded him as my father sat petulantly in his favorite chair. 
During the rest of the week, Auntie Marla was the pillar that held up the roof of my family’s life. She said she was happy to do it. She said that the only thing worth doing was helping her sister heal. She said it was her favorite of all possible jobs. And I think this must have been so.
My mother, meanwhile, moved through the house like a ghost. Prior to her disappearance, she was small and light and delicate. Tiny feet. Tiny features. Long and fragile hands, like blades of grass tied up with ribbon. When she returned, she was, impossibly, even lighter and more fragile. She was like the discarded husk of a cricket after it outgrows itself. No one mentioned this. It was unmentionable. Her face was as pale as clouds, except the storm-dark skin around her eyes. She tired easily and slept much.
My aunt made sure she had pressed skirts to wear. And starched gloves. And polished shoes. And smart tops. She made sure there were belts properly sized to cinch her roomy clothing to her tiny frame. Once the bald spots began to disappear and my mother’s hair returned, Marla arranged for the hairdresser to come by the house, and later the Avon lady. She painted my mother’s nails and praised her when she ate and often reminded her that she was looking so much like herself. I wondered at this. I didn’t know who else my mother would look like. I wanted to question it. But had no words to form such a question.
Auntie Marla, during this time, became my mother in opposite. She was tall, broad shouldered, and took a wide stance. She could lift heavy objects that my father could not. I never once saw her in a skirt. Or a pair of pumps. She wore trousers belted high and stomped about in her military-issued boots. Sometimes she put on a man’s hat, which she wore at an angle over her pinned curls, which she always kept short. She wore dark red lipstick, which my mother found shocking, but she kept her fingernails trimmed, blunt, and unpainted, like a man’s, which my mother also found shocking.
My aunt, once upon a time, flew planes—first in the Air Transport Auxiliary, and then in the Women’s Army Corps, and then briefly in the Women Airforce Service Pilots during the first part of the war until they grounded her for reasons that I was never told, and had her fixing engines instead. And she was good at fixing engines. Everyone wanted her help. She left the WASP abruptly when my grandparents died, and worked as a mechanic in an auto repair shop to support my mother through college, and then simply continued. I didn’t know this was a strange occupation for a young woman until much later. At work she spent the day bent over or slid under revving machinery, her magic hands coaxing them back to life. And I think she liked her work. But even as a little girl, I noticed the way her eyes lifted always to the sky, like someone longing for home.
I loved my aunt, but I hated her too. I was a child, after all. And I wanted my mother to make my breakfast and my mother to take me to the park and my mother to glare at my father when he was, once again, out of line. But now it was my aunt who did all those things, and I couldn’t forgive her for it. It was the first time I noticed that a person can feel opposite things at the same time.
Once, when I was supposed to be napping, I crept out of bed and tiptoed into my father’s study, which adjoined the master bathroom, which adjoined my parents’ bedroom. I opened the door just a crack and peeked inside. I was a curious child. And I was hungry for information.
My mother lay on the bed with no clothes on, which was unusual. My aunt sat next to her, rubbing oil into my mother’s skin with long, sure strokes. My mother’s body was covered in scars—wide, deep burns. I pressed my hand to my mouth. Had my mother been attacked by a monster? Would anyone have told me if she had? I set my teeth on the fleshy part of my fingers and bit down hard to keep myself from crying out as I watched. In the places where her breasts should have been, two bulbous smiles bit into her skin, bright pink and garish. I couldn’t look at them for very long. My aunt ran her oily thumbs gently along each scar, one after another. I winced as my mother winced.
They’re getting better,
 Auntie Marla said. Before you know it, they’ll be so pale you’ll barely notice them.
 
You’re lying again,
 my mother said, her voice small and dry. No one’s meant to keep on like—
 
Oh, come now,
 Marla said briskly. Enough of that talk. I saw men with worse during the war, and they kept on with things, didn’t they. So can you. Just you wait. You’ll outlive us all. After all my prayers, I wouldn’t be surprised if you turn immortal. Next leg.
 
My mother complied, turning away from me and lying on her side so my aunt could massage oil into her left leg and lower torso, the heels of her hands going deep into the muscle. She had burns on her back as well. My mother shook her head and sighed. You’d wish me to be Tithonus, would you?
 
Marla shrugged. Unlike you, I didn’t have a big sister to browbeat me into finishing college, so I don’t know all your fancy references, Miss Smartypants. But sure. You can be just like whoever that is.
 
My mother buried her face into the crook of her arm. It’s mythology,
 she explained. Also it’s a poem I used to love. Tithonus was a man—a mortal—in ancient Greece who fell in love with a goddess and they decided to get married. The goddess, though, hated the very thought that her husband would die someday, and so she granted him immortality.
 
How romantic,
 my aunt said. Left arm, please.
 
Not really,
 my mother sighed. Gods are stupid and shortsighted. They’re like children.
 She shook her head. "No. They’re worse. They’re like men—no sense of unintended consequences or follow-through. The goddess took away his ability to die. But he still aged, because she hadn’t thought to also give him eternal youth. So each year he became older, sicker, weaker. He dried out and shriveled, getting smaller and smaller until finally he was the size of a cricket. The goddess just carried him in her pocket for the rest of time, often completely forgetting he was there. He was broken and useless and was utterly without hope that anything could change. It wasn’t romantic at all." 
Roll all the way onto your stomach, darling,
 my aunt said, eager to change the subject. My mother groaned as she readjusted herself. Marla tinkered with my mother’s muscles the way she tinkered with cars—smoothing, adjusting, righting what once was wrong. If anyone could fix my mother, it was my aunt. She clicked her tongue. Well, with this much oil, I can’t imagine you drying out all that much. But after the scare we had, after you almost—
 Auntie Marla’s voice cracked just a bit. She pressed the back of her hand to her mouth and pretended to cough. But even then, as young as I was, I knew it was pretend. She shook her head and resumed her work on my mother’s body. Well. Carrying you around with me in my pocket forever doesn’t sound half-bad. I’d take it, actually.
 She cleared her throat, but her words became thick. I’d take it any old day you like.
 
I shouldn’t remember any of this exchange, but strangely, I do. I remember every word of it. For me, this isn’t entirely unusual—I spent most of my childhood memorizing things by accident. Filing things away. I didn’t know what any of their conversation meant, but I knew how it made me feel. My head felt hot and my skin felt cold, and the space around my body seemed to vibrate and spin. I needed my mother. I needed my mother to be well. And in the irrational reasoning of a child, I thought that the way to do this was to get my aunt to leave—if she left, my thinking went, then surely my mother would be all right. If Auntie Marla left, then no one would need to feed my mother, or do her tasks around the house, or rub her muscles, or make sure she got dressed, or keep her safe in any kind of pocket. My mother would simply be my mother. And the world would be as it should.
I went back to my room, and I thought about the dragon in my neighbor’s yard. How it seemed to marvel at its clawed hands and gnarled feet. How it peered behind itself to look at its wings. I remembered the gasp and the Oh! I remembered the way it curled its haunches and arched its back. The ripple of muscles under iridescent skin. The way it readied its wings. And that astonishing launch skyward. I remember my own sharp gasp as the dragon disappeared into the clouds. I closed my eyes and imagined my aunt growing wings. My aunt’s muscles shining with metallic scales. My aunt’s gaze tilting to the sky. My aunt flying away.
I wrapped myself in a blanket and closed my eyes tight—trying as a child tries to imagine it true.
The earliest known documentation of spontaneous dragoning in recorded history can be found in the formerly lost writings of Timaeus of Tauromenium, written around 310 BC. These manuscripts were discovered originally during the excavation of the vast, underground libraries located in the heart of the Palace of Nestor, but remained unread and unstudied until recently, due to a misclassification of its storage vault. The Timaeus fragments, among other things, shed new light on the historical person of Queen Dido of Carthage: priestess of Astarte, swindler of kings, and trickster of the high seas. The accounts of her life in literature (from Cicero to Virgil to Plutarch and every insufferable boor in between) all vary wildly—each portraying various aspects of an undeniably complex, inscrutable, and fundamentally defiant woman. The accounts of her death, on the other hand, are fairly uniform. Specifically, that Dido—either because of grief, or rage, or revenge, or simply as an act of self-sacrifice to save the city that she founded and built and loved—calmly ascended her own funeral pyre and threw herself upon her husband’s sword, breathing her last as the flames engulfed her.
And perhaps that’s true.
But the Timaeus writings provide an alternate view. The fragments of Book 19, Book 24, and Book 49 of Timaeus’s Historiai provide both brief and casual references to a separate fate of Queen Dido, presented in a way that assumes the reader already knows and understands the story mentioned in the text. This casual referencing, one might argue, is significant, as it implies that the writer does not see the need to argue his view of the events—instead, he simply references a narrative to his contemporaneous audience in a way that suggests it is both accepted and acceptable. Timaeus describes how Queen Dido, flanked by her priestesses on either side, stood upon the shore and watched as the ocean turned dark with Trojan ships, hungry for Carthage’s harbor, and riches, and resources, and women. Timaeus describes Carthage as a flowing breast from which Aeneas and his entourage longed to feed, and how the whole city quaked before the terrible hunger of men.
The Timaeus fragments provide tantalizing clues. In Book 19, he describes that the queen and her priestesses opened their garments and let them fall to the ground. They stepped out of their robes like nymphs, and they stepped out of their bodies like monsters,
 Timaeus writes, adding that the sea burned with a thousand pyres.
 What sort of monsters? And whose pyres burned? Timaeus does not say. In Book 24, he writes, Oh, Carthage! City of dragons! Woe to you for turning your back on your holy protectresses! Inside a generation, Dido’s noble city lay in waste upon the ground.
 And in Book 49, describing Dido’s earlier swindle of King Pygmalion and her subsequent escape across the sea, Timaeus writes, During her journey, the young Queen traveled to islands that did not appear on any map and bade her men wait for her in the ships as she swam to the land on her own. Each time she returned with women—to be both priestesses and wives, the men were told. The men shivered when they saw these women, and could not account for why. Oh, how their eyes glittered! Oh, how their robes rustled like wings! And oh, how a forcefulness burned in their bellies. They were strong like men, these priestesses. They sunned themselves like lizards upon the decks. The sailors agreed to give the women a wide berth. And those who forgot themselves, who reached lustfully where one should not, had often disappeared by the next morning, their names never spoken again.
 
Did Dido dragon? Did her priestesses transform? We cannot know. But two things should give us ample reason to pay close attention to the Historiai. First, the Timaeus account is the earliest recording of these events, and therefore less likely to be tainted by the political pressures of revisionism. Men, after all, delight in nothing so much as to recast themselves in the center of the story. And second, throughout history, the occasional and seemingly spontaneous bouts of female dragoning (they are not, in truth, spontaneous, but we will get to that later in this paper) are almost universally followed by a collective refusal to accept incontrovertible facts, and a society-wide decision to forget verifiable events that are determined to be too alarming, too messy, too unsettling. This practice did not start with Queen Dido, and it did not end with her either.
I shall now explore twenty-five discrete historical examples of mass dragoning and their subsequent memory repression, ending, of course, with the astonishing events here in the United States in 1955. Our own Mass Dragoning, while admittedly unusual in terms of its numbers and scope, was not unique in the context of world history. Spontaneous dragoning, I intend to prove, is not a new phenomenon. But given the sheer number of transformations in 1955, it is imperative that we learn from history’s mistakes, and chart a different path. It is my thesis that every mass dragoning in history is followed by a phenomenon that I call a mass forgetting.
 And indeed, it is the forgetting, I argue, which proves to be far more damaging, and results in more scars on the psyche, and scars on the culture. Furthermore, it is my conclusion that the United States is, at present, in the midst of another such forgetting, with repercussions that are both trackable and quantifiable—and hopefully reversible if coordinated action is taken now. 
—A Brief History of Dragons
 by Professor H. N. Gantz, MD, PhD, originally published in the Annals of Public Health Research, by the United States Department of Health, Education, and Welfare on February 3, 1956. It was redacted three days later and all copies, except this one, were destroyed. 
3.
Looking back, I think perhaps my mother had similarly complicated feelings toward my aunt. She loved her sister. And yet. As my mother recovered, a chilliness spread
