34th INTERNATIONAL
SYMPOSIUM ON
ARCHAEOMETRY
3-7 May 2004
Zaragoza, Spain
Organising Institutions
Department of Analytical Chemistry
University of Zaragoza, Spain
Institución «Fernando el Católico» (C.S.I.C.)
Patrimoni-UB Group
Excma. Diputación de Zaragoza
University of Barcelona, Spain
Z ARAGOZ A, 2006
CREDITS
PREFACE
COLLABORATORS
INDEX
ARTICLES
34th INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON ARCHAEOMETRY
3-7 May 2004, Zaragoza, Spain
STANDING COMMITTEE
M.J. Aitken (Oxford) President
M.S. Tite (Oxford) Chairman
L. Barba (Mexico City)
K. T. Biro (Budapest)
R. M. Farquahar (Toronto)
H. Kars (Amsterdam)
Y. Maniatis (Athens)
P. Meyers (Los Angeles)
A. M. Özer (Ankara)
J. Pérez-Arantegui (Zaragoza)
G. A. Wagner (Heilderberg)
Ch. Wang (China)
S. U. Wisseman (Urbana)
•
LOCAL ORGANISING COMMITTEE
Josefina Pérez-Arantegui, Chairperson
Francisco Laborda (Zaragoza)
Gemma Cepriá (Zaragoza)
Pedro Paracuellos (Zaragoza)
Pilar Lapuente (Zaragoza)
Judit Molera (Barcelona)
Lorena Merino (Barcelona)
Mario Vendrell (Barcelona)
The logo on the front cover represents a piece of lustre pottery from Muel (16th
century), Museum of Zaragoza. The shadow is a TEM image of Cu nanocrystals
forming the lustre layer.
START
Preface
On behalf of the organising committee and the University of Zaragoza
I would like to welcome all participants to Zaragoza for the 34th International
Symposium on Archaeometry.
We are very grateful to the institutions and individuals who assisted in
making this conference possible and supported our work during its preparation.
I would want to thank the financial supporters and in particular to the Aragonese
Government, the University of Zaragoza and the Ministry of Science and
Technology, for their important collaboration. Special thanks are due to Gres de
Aragon and Euroarce that have supported the special session of this symposium:
“Evolution and Technology of glazes”.
Finally, Archaeometry 2004 would not have taken place without the
collaboration and support of many other people, from Zaragoza and Barcelona,
and I would like to thank them too, but there is not enough place in this page to
write all their names.
I hope that all of you will enjoy this conference and the scientific work, but
also that you will have enough time to visit and enjoy Zaragoza.
Josefina Pérez-Arantegui
Zaragoza, 2004
START
PUBLICACIÓN NÚMERO
2.621
DE LA
INSTITUCIÓN «FERNANDO EL CATÓLICO» (EXCMA. DIPUTACIÓN DE ZARAGOZA)
PLAZA DE ESPAÑA, 2 · 50071 ZARAGOZA (ESPAÑA)
TELS. [34] 976 28 88 78/79 · FAX [34] 976 28 88 69
ifc@dpz.es
www. ifc.dpz.es
© Los autores.
© De la presente edición, Institución «Fernando el Católico».
ISBN: 84-7820-848-8
DEPÓSITO LEGAL: Z-1.368/2006
PREIMPRESIÓN: Ebro Composición, S.L. Zaragoza.
IMPRESIÓN: Sociedad Cooperativa, Librería General. Zaragoza.
IMPRESO EN ESPAÑA. UNIÓN EUROPEA.
34th INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON ARCHAEOMETRY
3-7 May 2004, Zaragoza, Spain
Organising Institutions
Department of Analytical Chemistry of the University of Zaragoza
Patrimoni-UB Group of the University of Barcelona
Rectorado
Universidad de Zaragoza
Consejo Social
Universidad de Zaragoza
MINISTERIO
DE CIENCIA
Y TECNOLOGÍA
Departamento de Ciencia,
Tecnología y Universidad
Sponsors of the special session Evolution and Technology of Glazes
Collaborating institutions
CORTES DE ARAGÓN
INSTITUCIÓN
FERNANDO
EL CATÓLICO
START
Departamento de Educación,
Cultura y Deporte
1. FIELD ARCHAEOLOGY...........................................................................
13
Geophysics and Archaeology at la Mesa Site, Chiclana de la Frontera,
Cádiz (Spain), Luis Barba Pingarrón, Salvador Domínguez-Bella, José Ramos
Muñoz, Vicente Castañeda Fernández, Manuela Pérez Rodríguez and María
Sánchez Aragón.................................................................................................
15
Geophysics and Archaeology at Santa Cruz Atizapan, Central Mexico,
Luis Barba, Agustín Ortiz, Jorge Blancas and Yoko Sugiura ..........................
21
Remote Sensing And Fieldwalking Survey Applied To The Study Of
Ancient Landscapes: An Integrated Approach, Stefano Campana,
Cristina Felici ....................................................................................................
27
Geophysical Survey and Archaeological Verification of Prehistoric iron
production areas and medieval glass-woeking sites, Kr#ivánek Roman ...
33
Chemical Residues of Human Activities in San Vincenzo al Volturno,
Alessandra Pecci, Federico Marazzi .................................................................
39
2. DATING .......................................................................................................
45
Irsl and GLSL Dating Studies of Samples From Neolithic Site, ÇatalhöyükTurkey, AkogÛ lu, K.G., Özbakan, M., Özer, A. M. ..........................................
47
Paleomagnetic Dating of Pollen Stratigraphy From Lake Sediment Based
on PSV Master Curve From Central Finland, Teija Alenius, Antti Ojala
and Mia Tiljander..............................................................................................
53
Thermoluminescence and 14C dating of brick structures in S. Lorenzo
church in Milano. Late Antique and Medieval phases, Laura Fieni,
A. Galli, M. Martini, E. Sibilia, T. Mannoni...................................................
55
Artificial Fluorine Enrichment in Bones: Diagenesis as Restricting Factor
for Exposure Age Dating by Fluorine Diffusion, A. A.-M. Gaschen,
U. Krähenbühl, M. Döbeli, A. Markwitz, B. Barry .........................................
61
34th INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM
INDEX
5
INDEX
3-7 May 2004 • Zaragoza, Spain
34th INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM
TL-dating of Mousterian open air sites of the Isle valley: Les Forêts and
Petit Bost (Dordogne, France), Pierre Guibert, Christelle Lahaye, Matthieu
Duttine, Françoise Bechtel ................................................................................
67
AMS Radiocarbon Dating of Protoclassic Maya Lime Plasters from Aguateca,
Guatemala, G. W. L. Hodgins, A. J. Vonarx and B. Bachand........................
73
Accelerator Mass Spectrometry dating of archaeological samples from
Nola area (Naples, ItalyCampania), C. Lubritto, F. Terrasi, A. D’Onofrio,
C. Sabbarese, F. Marzaioli, I. Passariello, D. Rogalla, M. Rubino, N. De Cesare,
M. Romano, L. Gialanella, V. Roca, C. Rolfs, C. Albore Livadie, G. Vecchio..
79
Toward a Chrono-Seriation Method Based on European Trade White Beads
in Northeastern North America, Jean-François Moreau, R.G.V. Hancock,
Marcel Moussette .............................................................................................
85
Petrographic investigations and 14 C dating for approximating the age
of lime mortars, Danuta Nawrocka, Jacek Michniewicz................................
91
Simulations of the Statistical Archaeomagnetic Dating Method,
Rob Sternberg, Jeffrey L. Eighmy ....................................................................
97
Investigation of the Effects of the Sampling and Breaking Techniques
on the TL Signal and Mineralogical Composition of the ‘Fines Grains’,
N.C. Tsirliganis, Z. Loukou, D. Papadopoulou, G. Polymeris, G. Papathanasiou,
P. Kotsanidis ......................................................................................................
103
Application of Fine-Grain TL and Single-Aliquot osl Datin Techniques to
well and not well Fired Ancient Ceramic Materials, N.C. Tsirliganis,
D. Tsiafaki, Z. Loukou, G. Polymeris ...............................................................
109
Exploration of the possibilities to date medieval building construction
by OSL: the case of the brickbuilt citadel of Termez (Uzbekistan),
Emmanuelle Vieillevigne, Pierre Guibert, Françoise Bechtel ...........................
115
3. TECHNOLOGY AND PROVENANCEOF METALS............................
121
Metallurgic Process used in the “Farga Rosell”Ancient Bloomery Fire
(Andorra), Aureli Álvarez, Antoni Vila, Josep M. Bosch, Olivier Codina,
Xavier Clop ......................................................................................................
123
The lead metal from two Hellenistic towns in east central Greece,
E. Asderaki, Th. Rehren ....................................................................................
131
Manufactured Technology and Materials of an Early Hellenistic Funerary
Bronze Urn, E. Asderaki, K. Tsatsouli, A. G. Karydas ...................................
137
Roman and medieval litharge cakes: structure and composition, Justine
Bayley, Kerstin Eckstein....................................................................................
145
Strontium Isotopes Provenance Ancient Iron Artifacts, P. Degryse, P. Muchez,
J. Schneider, M. Brauns, U. Haack, N. Kellens, M. Waelkens.........................
155
6
INDEX
Early Cycladic Metallurgy in a Sttlement Context: Examination of
Metallurgical Remains from Daskaleio-Kavos, Keros (Cyclades, Greece),
Myrto Georgakopoulou .....................................................................................
169
Archeometallurgical Studies with a Movable EDXRF Spectrometer on
Messenian Gold. The methodological approach, George Styl Korres, Giovanni
E. Gigante, Stefano Ridolfi................................................................................
175
Non-destructive* Pb isotope analysis of Harappan Lead Artifacts using
Ethylenediaminetetraacetic Acid and ICP-MS. (*practically), Randall W. Law
and James H. Burton.........................................................................................
181
Investigation of a Pre - Columbian Vicus Nose Filigree, Laura Limata,
Aaron Shugar, Mike Notis, Dale Newbury ......................................................
187
Archaeometry and the international evolution of studies on metallurgy:
a bibliometrical perspective, Elías López-Romero González de la Aleja,
Ignacio Montero-Ruiz ......................................................................................
195
Laboratory investigation of inlays and surface treatments for the
decoration of copper-base alloy objects from the imperial roman period,
François Mathis, Dominique Robcis, Thierry Borel, Marc Aucouturier,
Sophie Descamps ...............................................................................................
201
The Question of Early Copper Production at Almizaraque, SE Spain,
Roland Mueller, Thilo Rehren, Salvador Rovira Llorens ................................
209
“Free silica type” slags of silver production in the Iberian Peninsula,
Salvador Rovira, Mark A. Hunt .......................................................................
217
Provenance of Iron Artefacts from the Celtic Oppidum of Manching
(Bavaria), R. Schwab, B. Höppner, E. Pernicka ..............................................
223
Tracking Chronological Developments in Chalcolithic Metallurgy:
An Assessment of Possible Correlations between Radiocarbon Data
and Compositional Analyses, Aaron N. Shugar, Christopher J. Gohm ......
231
Early Chinese Scissors and Shears: Category, Design and Shape: A
Metallurgical Study, Aaron Shugar, Mike Notis, Laura Limata, DongNing
Wong, Parsaoran Hutapea and Han Rubin .....................................................
237
Iron Smelting Slag Formation at Tell Hammeh (az-Zarqa), Jordan, Xander
Veldhuijzen and Thilo Rehren...........................................................................
245
4. TECHNOLOGY AND PROVENANCE OF STONE, PIGMENTS AND
PLASTERS...................................................................................................
Scientific Study of Græco-Roman Wall Plasters & Pigments in Alexandria,
Egypt, Dr. Safaa Abd El Salam .......................................................................
251
253
3-7 May 2004 • Zaragoza, Spain
161
34th INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM
Analysis of Cu-Based Alloys and their Corrosion Products from the Bilbilis
Arachaeological context by SEM-EDS, M. Gener, A. Martín Costea,
V. López, E. Otero, M. Morcillo........................................................................
7
INDEX
3-7 May 2004 • Zaragoza, Spain
34th INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM
Non-Destructive Raman Characterisation of Pigment on Byzantine
Frescoes in Some Cave Churches of Salento (Puglia, Italy), G. E. De Benedetto,
R. Vatinno .........................................................................................................
261
Carpathian obsidians: Myth and reality, T. Biró, Katalin ..........................
267
Raw Materials characteristics and Durability of Some Medieval Painted
Plasters in Anatolia, Evin Caner, S, ahinde Demirci, Emine N. Caner-Saltik
279
Direct determination of chrome yellow by a harmless electroanalytical
technique, Cepriá, G., Campos, M. T., Pérez-Arantegui, J. ..........................
285
Use of granitoid stones from Calabria (Southern Italy) in antiquity:
petrographic and geochemical characterization of ancient quarries of Roman
Age, Cirrincione, R., Crisci, G. M., De Vuono, E., Pezzino, A., Punturo, R. ......
289
Examination of Burnt mud Brick and Plaster From Şapinuwa- Hittite City
for the Characterization of Their Technological Properties, Gülnur Güdücü,
Emine N. Caner-Saltik, Şahinde Demirci .......................................................
295
Fingerprinting Carpathian Obsidians by PGAA: First Results on Geological
and Archaeological Specimens, Zsolt Kasztovszky, Katalin T. Biró ...........
301
A Technique for Determining the Provenance of Harappan Banded
Limestone “Ringstones” using ICP-AES, Randall W. Law and James
H. Burton ..........................................................................................................
309
Non-Destructive Characterisation of Pigments by Means of the
Complementary use of Pixe-Alpha and XRD portable Systems,
Lighea Pappalardo, Giuseppe Pappalardo, Francesco Paolo Romano, Francesca
Amorini, Ermelinda Scafiri, Maria Grazia Branciforti, Agata Taormina........
315
e-Visarch: An On-Line Raman Spectra Data Base of Archaeological
Materials on Stone and Plaster Supports, M. Pérez Alonso, K. Castro,
M. A. Olazabal and J. M. Madariaga...............................................................
321
Non-destructive analysis of paintings layers based on Reflectance
Spectroscopy and Energy Dispersive XRF, Gianluca Poldi, Letizia Bonizzoni,
Nicola Ludwig, Ilaria Mascheroni, Mario Milazzo............................................
327
Non-destructive investigations of Indian Miniatures by a Combined
Spectroscopic approach: PIXE, 3D-μXRF and UV-VIS spectroscopy,
Ina Reiche, Raffael Dedo Gadebusch, Oliver Hahn, Uwe Reinholz, Birgit
Kanngießer, Wolfgang Malzer ..........................................................................
333
Discovering of the Egyptian blue employment for the decoration in
a 10 th century manuscript, characterised by absorption in diffuse
reflectance spectrometry, P. Roger, J. N. Barrandon, A. Bos.......................
341
8
INDEX
347
Where does Lapis Lazuli come from? Non-Destructive Provenance
Analysis by PGAA, J. Zöldföldi, S. Richter, Zs. Kasztovszky, J. Mihály......
353
5. TECHNOLOGY AND PROVENANCE OF CERAMICS AND
GLASSES .....................................................................................................
363
Sgrafito ceramic from Florentine area (XVI Century): Archaeometric
Characterization of Paste and Coating, Francesca Amato, Bruno Fabbri,
Sabrina Gualtieri, Andrea Ruffini, Anna Valeri Moore...................................
365
Early Bronze age Faience from North Italy and Slovakia: A Comparative
Archaeometric Study, Ivana Angelini, Gilberto Artioli, Angela Polla,
Raffaele C. de Marinis.......................................................................................
371
Archaeometrical investigations on ceramics of the late-Middle Age in
Calabria (South-Italy), S. Aragona, F. A. Cuteri, L. Mavilia, M. Rotili,
R. Ponterio, S. Trusso, C. Vasi..........................................................................
379
Characterization of Bricks and Tiles from 17 -Century Maryland, Ruth
Ann Armitage, Leah Minc, David V. Hill, Silas D. Hurry .............................
387
An investigation of the ceramic technology of a late Iznik ceramic
production (XVIIth century AD), Ayed Ben Amara, Max Schvoerer,
Maïa Cuin, Mohamed Baji Ben Mami .............................................................
393
Interaction between leads glazes and bodies: Research on the mode of
application of the glazing mixture, Ayed Ben Amara, Max Schvoerer ......
399
Trade patterns in Philistine Pottery, David Ben-Shlomo.............................
405
Petrographic Anaysis of Roman-Bizantine roof tiles: Preliminary results,
David Ben-Shlomo ............................................................................................
413
‘Potting Histories’ Ceramic Production and Consumption in Almohad
Seville, Rebecca Bridgman ...............................................................................
419
Metallic lustre of glazed ceramics: evolution of decorations In search
for discriminating elements, D. Chabanne, O. Bobin, M. Schvoerer, C. Ney,
Ph. Sciau............................................................................................................
427
Cathodoluminescence in Archaeometry through case studies: classification
of Chalcolithic ceramics from Syria, English glass stems (XVI-XVIIth
c.AD), and glass/paste interface of glazed Islamic ceramics (X-XIIth c. AD),
Rémy Chapoulie, Floréal Daniel .......................................................................
433
Study and Characterization of Islamic Ceramic Tiles from Onda-Castellon
(Spain), L. Chiva, J.J. Gómez, V. Estall, I. Núñez, J.B. Carda ........................
439
th
3-7 May 2004 • Zaragoza, Spain
Stone materials of the baroque town of Noto (Italy): Petrographic
and geochemical features and their behaviour in decay, L. G. Russo,
P. Mazzoleni, A. Pezzino ..................................................................................
34th INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM
th
9
INDEX
3-7 May 2004 • Zaragoza, Spain
34th INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM
Experimental petrology of the firing process of renaissance pottery from
deruta (Umbria, Italy), Claudia Conti, Beatrice Moroni...............................
447
The ‘Invention’ of Lead Crystal Glass, David Dungworth, Colin Brain ...
453
Analyzing a mirror from the mirror’s hall at La Granja Royal Palace,
Segovia, Spain. Some problems in composition, conservation and
heritage management, Angel Fuentes, Joaquín Barrio, Rosario García,
Pilar Da Silva, Paloma Pastor, Victoria Muñoz...............................................
459
Oil lamps from Two Spanish Roman Archaeological Sites. I. Chemical
Characterization and multivariate analysis, Rosario García Giménez,
Raquel Vigil de la Villa, María Dolores Petit Domínguez and María Isabel
Rucandi Sáez .....................................................................................................
465
Oil lamps from two Spanish Roman Archaeological Sites. II. Physical
Characterization and Multivariante Analysis, Rosario García Giménez,
Raquel Vigil de la Villa, María Dolores Petit Domínguez and María Isabel
Rucandio Sáez ...................................................................................................
471
Experimental tests for recognizing application technology and firing
conditions of archaeological glazed ceramics, Sabrina Gualtieri, Giampaolo
Ercolani, Andrea Ruffini, Idema Venturi .........................................................
477
Evidence for the period of distribution of European glass beads at the
Spanish mission of Tipu in Belize, R.G.V. Hancock, E. Graham ................
483
The Early Islamic Glazed Ceramics of Akhsiket, Uzbekistan, C. Henshaw,
Th. Rehren, O. Papachristou, A.A. Anarbaev ..................................................
489
European glass trade beads, neutron activation analysis, and the historial
implications of dating seasonal basque whaling stations in the new Word,
A. Herzog, J.-F. Moreau ....................................................................................
495
Comparative Ceramic Petrology of “Aguada Portezuelo” Ceramic Style
(ca. 650-900 A.D.): a Technological Approach for its Study at the
Catamarca Valley (Catamarca Valley, Province of Catamarca,
Northwestern Argentine), Guillermo A. De La Fuente, Néstor Kristcautzky,
Gustavo Toselli ..................................................................................................
503
The “Mystery” of the Post-Medieval triangular crucibles reconsidered
– A global perspective, Marcos Martinón-Torres and Thilo Rehren ............
515
Mapping and confocal microraman spectroscopy: Non-invasive analysis
of weathered stained glass windows, S. Murcia-Mascarós, C. Domingo,
S. Sánchez-Cortés J. V. García-Ramos, A. Muñoz-Ruiz ..................................
525
Lustre pottery in inland Spain: Analytical study of the ceramic decoration
produced in Muel (Aragon) in the 16th century, Josefina Pérez-Arantegui,
Ángel Larrea......................................................................................................
531
10
INDEX
TEM-EELS Investigation of Ancient Ceramics, Ph. Sciau, S. Relaix and
Y. Khin...............................................................................................................
543
Early Neolithic Pottery Production in Hungary: a Comparative
Archaeometrical Study of Körös and Starc# evo Ceramics, György Szakmány,
Katalin Gherdán and Elisabetta Starnini .........................................................
549
Archaeometrical investigation of pottery of the 10th century, Edelény,
North-East Hungary, Veronika Szilágyi, György Szakmány, Mária Wolf,
Tamás Weiszburg...............................................................................................
555
The wandering scientist, or the quest for intercalibration, S.Y. Waksman..
563
6. BIOMATERIALS.........................................................................................
569
Anatomo-pathological study of the human remains coming from the
Dolmen de Cañada Real housed at the Archaeological Museum of
Seville (Spain), Rosario Cabrero García, Assumpciò Malgosa Morera, Santiago
Safont Mas, M. Eulàlia Subirà de Galdàcano and Ezequiel Gómez Murga ...
571
Reconstructing the Diet of Rancho del Rio’s Inhabitants by Paleoecological
and Archaeological Approaches, Alison Diefenderfer, David Small, Zicheng Yu
and Aaron Shugar .............................................................................................
577
Cooking activities in a building yard during the Middle Age. Organic
residues in potsherds recovered from the Carmine Convent in Siena,
Alessandra Pecci, Francesca Grassi and Laura Salvini, Gianluca Giorgi .......
583
3-7 May 2004 • Zaragoza, Spain
537
34th INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM
Non-destructive quantiative determination of trace elements in fine
ceramics by using a portable beam staility controlled XRF Sepctrometer
(BSC-XRF), Francesco Paolo Romano, Giuseppe Pappalardo, Lighea Pappalardo,
Francesca Rizzo, Salvatore Garraffo, Rossella Gigli, Antonella Pautasso .......
11
INDEX
ACCELERATOR MASS SPECTROMETRY DATING
OF ARCHAEOLOGICAL SAMPLES FROM NOLA
AREA (NAPLES, ITALYCAMPANIA)
C. LUBRITTO*, F. TERRASI, A. D’ONOFRIO, C. SABBARESE, F. MARZAIOLI, I. PASSARIELLO,
+D. ROGALLA, M. RUBINO
Dipartimento di Scienze Ambientali, Seconda Università di Napoli
N. DE CESARE
Dipartimento di Scienze della Vita, Seconda Università di Napoli
M. ROMANO, L. GIALANELLA, V. ROCA
Dipartimento di Scienze Fisiche and INFN Sezione di Napoli (Italy)
C. ROLFS
Institut für Physik mit Ionenstrahlen, Ruhr-Universität Bochum, Bochum (Germany)
C. ALBORE LIVADIE
Centre Camille Jullian, Aix-en-Provence (Francia)
G. VECCHIO
Soprintendenza per i Beni Archeologici delle Province di Napoli e Caserta (Italy)
A systematic investigation on dates of samples from different archaeological sites
related to Bronze age settlements in Campania region (Nola, S. Paolo Belsito, ecc.)
has been undertaken, using the 14C method. A significant marker in this context is the
Avellino pumice eruption: charred wood and bone samples have been collected in
layers both below and above the eruption material, with the aim of reconstructing the
cronology of anthropic activity from the old bronze age to the middle bronze age, as
well as the impact of the plinian eruption.
Samples were treated in the Mass Spectrometry Laboratory of the
Environmental Science Department of the II University of Naples, and measured at
the Accelerator Mass Spectrometry (AMS) facility set-up at the Dinamitron Tandem
Laboratory of the Ruhr Universitaet in Bochum (D).
* corresponding author; e-mail: lubritto@sa.infn.it
+ Marie Curie fellow, contract N. HPMD-CT-2001-00088
INDEX
34th INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM
ABSTRACT
79
3-7 May 2004 • Zaragoza, Spain
34th INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM
80
1. INTRODUCTION: THE NOLA BRONZE AGE VILLAGE
In May 2001, in the immediate outskirts of Nola (an important city 25 km
east from Naples), an early bronze age village, in locality Croce del Papa (CdP),
was discovered buried by the products of a Plinian eruption of Vesuvius, the
Avellino Pumices eruption of 3500 BP (Livadie Albore et al 2001). Three huts,
originally part of a more extended settlement, were found six metres below the
ground level, next to an enclosed area which included a threshing floor, some
covered structures and an animal pen made out of wattle and daub (fig.1). The
humidity of the soil conserved not only human footprints, but the hoof marks
of domestic animals (sheeps, goats, cows and pigs) in the enclosures where
they fled from at the time of the eruption (AA.VV. 2002). Nine pregnant goats
were discovered in the animal fence (fig. 2). All other inhabitants escaped at the
time of the eruption. After the fall of grey pumices that covered the huts
without causing their collapse, a wave of mud penetrated slowly within the
structures providing a counterforce to the pumices accumulated outside, and
allowing their preservation. Recent excavations, in the place named Masseria
Rossa (MR), few km apart from CdP, highlighted hut’s remains above
rearranged pumices of Avellino’s eruption (AA.VV. 2002). This discover
emphasizes the reinstallation of anthropic activity on the old environment after
the eruption, that probably was mainly characterized by agriculture and stock
farm activities characterizing the Palma Campania facies. Aim of this work is
the historical reconstruction of this paleoenvironment by radiocarbon (14C)
dating of organic materials (bone, charcoal) collected in layers below and above
the eruption materials. In particular, the main goal is to confirm the eruption
date and to characterize the human resumption, in the lands involved by the
eruption.
Figure 1. General plan of the site of Croce del Papa. 1,2 Wells; 3 Subcircular
enclosure, threshing floor; 4 Hut 2; 5 Hut 3; 6 Hut 4; 7 Cage with goats;
8 Waterhole.
INDEX
3-7 May 2004 • Zaragoza, Spain
Figure 2. Animal pen with nine pregnant goats.
14
C - AMS DATING
C is a radioactive isotope that enters as 14CO2 in living photosynthetic
organisms or, indirectly, as “organic 14C” through the feeding in the
etherothrophes. Therefore, 14C concentrations inside the biosphere and the
environment in which organism lives are the same (isotopic equilibrium). The
metabolic processes, which continually bring carbon and realise the isotopic
equilibrium, will be ended with the organism’s death. From this time, 14C
content decreases according to the radioactive decay law and the isotopic
ratio between 14C and 12C supplies information about the time elapsed since
the metabolic activities ended (organism’s death). In this work, radiocarbon
dating is performed by Accelerator Mass Spectrometry (AMS): an
ultrasensitive analytic technique which measures the abundance of the rare
isotope (14C) with respect to the corresponding abundant one (12C). This
isotopic ratio represents a very sensitive indicator of natural and
anthropogenic processes that characterize past environment (Terrasi 2001).
AMS technique offers the opportunity to use small amount of material (few
milligrams) and to measure its isotopic ratio in a few minutes. Therefore,
being a non destructive technique, AMS becomes an important tool to date
rare and precious finds, like those of Nola archaeological site. Measurable age
intervals (from hundreds to 50000 of years), together with the cited features,
make the AMS a powerful tool for the study of an archaeologicalenvironmental site.
14
INDEX
34th INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM
2.
81
3-7 May 2004 • Zaragoza, Spain
2.1. Method and sample preparation
The AMS technique needs a set of physical and chemical pretreatments:
their principal purpose is to isolate the carbon fraction and to eliminate carbon
contaminating the sample. The physical and chemical pretreatments depend on
the nature of the sample and on the organic fraction to be extract. The physical
treatment includes the removal of obvious contaminants and the sample
grinding. After these steps, the sample chemical pretreatment starts. Typically,
the chemical treatments include the AAA method (Acid-Alkali-Acid) for
charcoal, wood, peat and vegetation (Mook, Streurman 1983); collagen
extraction from bone (Longin 1971); alpha-cellulose extraction from tree ring
(Green 1963), and phosphoric acid method for shell and marine carbonates
(Hoefs 1987). In fig. 3, it is shown the distribution of different kinds of samples,
treated so far at the Mass Spectrometry Laboratory of the Environmental Science
Department of the II University of Naples, and measured at the Accelerator Mass
Spectrometry (AMS) system of the Ruhr Universitaet in Bochum (D) (Lubritto et
al 2004). Moreover the pretreatments used for bone and charcoal samples,
collected in CdP and S. Paolo Belsito (SPB), has been summarized in tab. 1.
Sample’s Pretreatment’s
kind
kind
34th INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM
Charcoal Treatment AAA
(Acid/Alkali/Acid):
Acid (HCl 3%) - Alkali
(HCl 3%). (NaOH 3%)- Acid
Between each phase, there are
dilution with distilled water.
Bone Bone is pulverized and
immersed in an acid bath
(HCl 0,6 N) at 0°C, where
the organic fraction of the
bone, collagen, is extracted.
This cycle is repeated different
times, depending from the
bone preservation.
82
Figure 3. Cake diagram: % kind of samples
treated in Mass Spectrometry Lab DSA SUN.
Typic
used
mass
(mg)
1-10
50-200
Table 1. Different pretreatments applied to
bone and charcoal samples, collected in Croce
del Papa and S. Paolo Belsito.
Then the sample has been dried and pyrolized by means of a quartz tube
under a nitrogen (N2) flow at 600°C. The pretreated sample is mixed with
CuO and silver wires and put in a quartz test tube where a high vacuum with
a membrane-turbomolecular pump system is achieved. Then, the test tube is
sealed and heated to 900°C in order to oxidise the sample to CO2. The CO2 is
cryogenically transferred to a “graphitization line” where it is reduced to
graphite at 700°C. During the cryogenic transfer, the gas passes through a
cold trap (dry ice-ethanol) in order to remove the water vapour impurities.
The reaction takes place, tipically, during 4 hr in a 15 ml reaction chamber
INDEX
3-7 May 2004 • Zaragoza, Spain
filled with an hydrogen atmosphere at a partial pressure double than the CO2
partial pressure and using iron powder catalyst (Dee et al 2000). The graphite,
togheter with silver powder, is pressed into a target holder (an aluminum
cylinder) and placed in the accelerator ion source of the Bochum Universitaet
Accelerator Mass Spectrometry system (Lubritto et al 2004). The graphite,
placed in the ion source, is converted to a single negatively charged ion beam
by means of the sputtering process and injected, after the mass selection
occurring in the injection magnet, into the Tandem Accelerator. Here, the
carbon ions are accelerated in the first acceleration stage till the gas stripper
where they are converted to positive ions. Subsequently, these cations are
accelerated again from the stripper to the accelerator exit. The positive ion
beam passes through further electric and magnetic selections in order to
identificate and count the 14C ions in a 6E-E detector.
Figure 4. Calendarial intervals of Nola land’s samples.
To confirm the eruption date and to characterize the time of the human
resumption, finds coming from CdP site (a goat bone found in the animal fence
and two charcoals found near the goat’s furnace), SPB site (bone and charcoal),
MR site (bone and two charcoals) and Palma Campania site (charcoal) were
measured. In figure 4, for each sample, the calendarial age intervals, obtained by
the calibration software CALIB 3.0 (Stuiver, Reimer 1993) and expressed as Before
Christ years (BC), with the corresponding statistical 1 sigma (s) error, are
represented. In particular, measurements performed on the samples coming from
CDP site , indicated in figure 4 by the circle A, give a more accurate indication
about the date of the eruption, with respect to previous studies (Livadie Albore
et al 1998), fixed to 1880 – 1680 B.C. and whose central value is represented in
figure 4 by continuos vertical line. Indeed, the calendarial age interval, obtained
INDEX
34th INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM
3. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS
83
3-7 May 2004 • Zaragoza, Spain
from the dating of a goat bone buried by eruption, fixs the eruption calendarial
age interval to 1782-1686 BC. Results of measurements of sample coming from
MR site (circle C) and SPB site (circle B) represent the calendarial age intervals
characterizing the anthropic activity resumption, after the eruption, in the two
sites. For SPB site, the human resumption happened in a time interval of about
250 years , while for the MR one, it happened around 150 years after the eruption.
These results show an installation’s fracture after the eruption: as a matter of fact
the cultural development of the resumption in SPB e MR have the same
characteristic as previous Palma Campania facies, as shown by the hut shapes and
ceramic finds. Finally, the measurement of a charcoal coming from a layer, below
the eruption one, at Palma Campania (circle D) demonstrates the existence of an
older settlement abandoned shortly before the eruption.
34th INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM
REFERENCES
84
AA.VV., 2002. Nola Quattromila anni fa- Il villaggio del Bronzo Antico distrutto dal
Vesuvio. Catalogo della mostra inaugurata a Nola il 20 giugno 2002. L’Arca e
L’Arco s.r.l. Nola (Na).
Dee M., Bronk Ramsey C., 2000. Refinement of graphite target production at ORAU.
Nuclear Instrument and Methods in Physics Research B, 172, 449-450
Green J.W., 1963. Methods of Carbohydrates Chemistry III (Ed. R.I. Whistler). Academic
Press, New York NK, pp.9-21.
Hoefs J., Stable Isotope Geochemistry. Third Edition, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1987.
Livadie Albore C., Castaldo N., Mastrolorenzo G., Vecchio G., 2001. Effetti delle
eruzioni del Somma-Vesuvio sul territorio di Nola dall’età del Bronzo all’epoca
romana tardiva. In: Tephras-chronologie et archéologie, Congrès “Tèphrochronologie et
coexistence hommes-volcans”. Brivs-Charensac 24-29 agosto 1998, Dossiers de
l’Archéo-Logis n°1, Clermont-Ferrand.
Livadie Albore C., Campatola L., Roca V., Romano M., Terrasi F., D’Onofrio A., Russo
F., 1998. Sulla datazione dell’eruzione delle “Pomici di Avellino” e il suo impatto
sui siti archeologici del Bronzo antico della Campania. IV Giornata delle Scienze
della Terra e L’Archeometria. Ed.CUEN, pp.201-203.
Longin R., 1971. New method of collagen extraction for radiocarbon dating. Nature
230:241-2
Lubritto C., Rogalla D., Rubino M., Marzaioli F., Passariello I., Romano M., Spadaccini
G., Casa G., Di Leva A., Gialanella L., Imbriani G., Calmieri A., Roca V., Rolfs C.,
Sabbarese C., Strieder F., Schuermann D., Terrasi F., 2004. Accelerator Mass
Spectrometry at the 4 MV Dynamitron Tandem in Bochum. Nuclear Instruments
and Methods in Physics Research B, 222, 255-260.
Mook W.G. & Streurman H.J., 1983. Section B: The chemical aspects. Physical and
chemical aspects of radiocarbon dating. PACT 8-II. 1. 47-53
Stuiver M., Reimer P.J., 1993. Extended 14C Data Base and Revised CALIB 3.0 14C Age
Calibration Program. Radiocarbon 35, 215-230.
Terrasi F., 2001. Metodo di datazione mediante Spettrometria di Massa Ultrasensibile
(AMS). In: Elementi di Archeometria, metodi fisici per i beni culturali (Castellano A.,
Martini M., Sibilia E., eds.) pp. 64-80. Egea
INDEX