Mechanics of Materials 142 (2020) 103279
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Mechanics of Materials
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/mechmat
Research paper
Study on size-dependent vibration and stability of DWCNTs subjected to
moving nanoparticles and embedded on two-parameter foundations
Mostafa Pirmoradiana, Ehsan Torkanb, Davood Toghraiea,
a
b
T
⁎
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Khomeinishahr Branch, Islamic Azad University, Khomeinishahr Branch, Khomeinishahr 84175-119, Iran
Young Researchers and Elite Club, Khomeinishahr Branch, Islamic Azad University, Khomeinishahr, Iran
A R T I C LE I N FO
A B S T R A C T
Keywords:
Double-walled carbon nanotubes
Dynamic stability
Incremental harmonic balance method
Nanoparticle delivery
Van der Waals effect
Eringen's nonlocal elasticity theory
Parametric resonance is an important phenomenon that may be evinced in applying carbon nanotubes for the
delivery of nanoparticles. This paper aims to investigate dynamics instability of double-walled carbon nanotubes
(DWCNTs) surrounded by elastic medium and excited by a sequence of moving nanoparticles. The DWCNT is
modeled as two Euler-Bernoulli beams interacting between them through van der Waals (vdW) forces. Based on
Eringen's nonlocal elastic theory to consider the small-scale effects, the governing equations are derived by using
Hamilton's principle. All inertial terms of the moving nanoparticles are taken into account. In addition, the van
der Waals force between the constitutive atoms of the moving nanoparticle and those of the nanotube is considered. By utilization of the Galerkin method, the partial differential equations (PDEs) of motion are reduced to
couple ordinary differential equations with time-varying coefficients describing a parametrically excited nanosystem. Then, an incremental harmonic balance (IHB) method is implemented to calculate the instability
regions of the DWCNT. The results show that considering the vdW effects, increasing the amplitude of the static
axial tensile force, reducing the amplitude of axial oscillating force, and increasing the stiffness of the elastic
medium improve stability of the system. A comparison between the results with those reported in the literature is
performed to verify the precision of the presented analyses.
1. Introduction
Nearly after three decades of carbon nanotube (CNT) discovery by
Iijima (1991), researchers have not stopped investigating for identification of their new properties to use them in nanostructural applications. This is due to the unique properties of CNTs, such as especial
physical, mechanical, chemical, thermal and electronic characteristics.
Among too many proposed industrial applications for CNTs, applying
them as Hydrogen storages, fluid conveyance, and nanoparticle delivery systems are attended thoroughly notable because of their great
mechanical properties besides their unique molecular structures, that is,
cylindrical shape with inner hollow space (Ajayan and Zhou, 2001).
The issue of drug delivery can be understood by considering the
interior hollow space of CNTs as the container, and the fullerenes, e.g.
C60, C70, C80, and C84 as the nanoparticles. Accordingly, numerous
researchers have studied different aspects of applying CNTs as drugs
delivery systems. For example, Rezapour and Araghi (2019b) analyzed
dynamics of a viscoelastic single-walled carbon nanotube (SWCNT) in
nanoparticle delivery and showed that the interaction and friction force
effects between nanoparticle and SWCNTs reveals significant influence
⁎
on dynamic response of the system. In another study, Rezapour and
Araghi (2019a) concerned dynamic behavior of CNTs delivering a nanoparticle with constant velocity. In his study, Kiani (2014) employed
the nonlocal Rayleigh beam theory to study nonlinear vibrations of
SWCNTs as nanoparticle delivery systems. The results showed that a
nonlinear analysis is necessary especially for large amounts of the mass
and velocity of the moving nanoparticle. Another study by Lee and
Chang (2010) studied dynamic behavior of SWCNTs for nanoparticle
delivery. Their numerical results show that increasing the non-local
parameter decreases the dynamic displacement of SWCNT while increasing the velocity of nanoparticle increases the maximum displacement.
When applications like drug delivery systems or systems conveying
fluids are considered, investigating vibrational response of CNTs as the
containers is unavoidable. It is because of the nanostructure-nanoparticle interaction and the small-scale effect. Therefore, dynamic
analysis and the study of induced dynamic instability of a CNT due to
passage of nanoparticles or fluids through it become important and are
of great academic as well as practical concern. Molecular dynamics
(MD) simulation, hybrid atomistic-continuum mechanics, experimental
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: Toghraee@iaukhsh.ac.ir (D. Toghraie).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mechmat.2019.103279
Received 11 June 2019; Received in revised form 8 December 2019; Accepted 10 December 2019
Available online 11 December 2019
0167-6636/ © 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Mechanics of Materials 142 (2020) 103279
M. Pirmoradian, et al.
These forces influence vibrational characteristics of CNTs according to
the nonlocal interaction of carbon atoms of different layers on each
other. The effect of vdW interaction on the vibration characteristics of
MWCNTs was studied by modeling it as a radius-dependent function
(He et al., 2006). The natural frequencies were calculated for MWCNTs
with various number of tubes and radii. It was reported that the vdW
interaction plays a significant role on the vibration of MWCNTs with
small radii. Wang et al. (2012) investigates rigorous vdW interaction
effect on vibration characteristics of MWCNTs under a transverse
magnetic field. Their results showed that the rigorous vdW force considerably
influences
the
frequency
of
MWCNTs.
Also,
Budarapu et al. (2014) estimated the natural frequencies of MWCNTs
embedded in an elastic medium by modeling the interaction between
adjacent nanotubes through the vdW forces. Nonlinear vibration of
DWCNTs embedded in an elastic medium was investigated by
Ansari and Hemmatnezhad (2012). They showed that the governing
equations of layers were coupled due to the vdW interlayer forces.
Tylikowski (2008) investigated the effect of vdW interaction force on
dynamic stability of CNTs under a time-dependent axial load.
Fu et al. (2009) investigated the nonlinear dynamic instability of DWNT
taking into account the effects of vdW forces. Their results show that
when the vdW forces are sufficiently strong, the DWNT can be assumed
as a single column. Ke and Wang (2011) studied vibration and stability
of fluid-conveying DWNTs and obtained the resonance frequencies of
the system. Their results show that the critical flow velocity of the fluidconveying DWNTs increases with an increase in the length scale parameter. Lei et al. (2012) studied the vibrational frequencies of DWCNTs,
as latent materials for drug carriers, using the nonlocal Timoshenko
beam model. Their results show that the vibrational frequency is significantly influenced by the aspect ratio, vibration mode and the nonlocal parameter.
Investigating dynamics of CNTs under periodic excitations caused
by time-dependent axial loads (Tylikowski, 2008), magnetic and electrical fields (Wang et al., 2012), fluid flows (Ke and Wang, 2011) and
repetitive delivery of drugs (Lee and Chang, 2010) is of great interest.
In these cases, it is expected that inter-layer radial displacements of
MWNTs would come to play an important role. A review on the open
literature shows that no comprehensive investigation has been done on
the instability of MWCNTs excited by a series of moving nanoparticles
until now. Addressing the necessity to bridge to this technical gap, the
present study is dedicated to examine dynamic instability of DWCNTs
loaded by successive nanoparticles through drug delivery process. In
addition, the van der Waals force between the constitutive atoms of the
moving nanoparticle and those of the nanotube, which has been ignored in most of previous studies, is considered. To this end, two
consisting layers of a DWCNT are simulated using Euler–Bernoulli
beams based on the nonlocal continuum theory. An elastic layer introducing the vdW interaction force between two adjacent tubes connects the beams. In addition, using a confined spring connecting the
nanoparticle to the innermost CNT the vdW effect is taken into account.
After applying the Hamilton's principle to find the nonlocal partial
differential equations of the motion, the Galerkin procedure is used to
discretize the unknown fields in the spatial domain. Then, the incremental harmonic balance method is applied to explore stability characteristics of the system and the effects of nonlocal parameter, the
elastic medium stiffness and the vdW interaction forces on the system
stability are investigated, comprehensively.
research and continuum mechanics (Farokhi and Ghayesh, 2017, 2018;
Ghayesh and Farajpour, 2018; Kazemirad et al., 2013; Farokhi et al.,
2013; Ghayesh et al., 2013c; Ghayesh, 2018b,c ; Ghayesh and
Farokhi, 2015) are four common methods which are used to study
mechanical behavior of CNTs. The first two methods are especially
complex and time-consuming and just may be used for systems with
small number of atoms. In addition, performing exact and reliable experiments at nanoscale is difficult and expensive. However, because of
dependency of nanostructures mechanical behavior on the length scale,
application of classical continuum mechanics may lead to erroneous
results. Consequently, in recent years significant investigation has been
done to explore dynamic behavior of CNTs by employing several nonclassical continuum theories including the nonlocal elasticity
(Eringen, 1983), the coupled stress (Yang et al., 2002), the surface
stress (Gurtin and Murdoch, 1978) and the strain gradient (Lam et al.,
2003) theories, where the scale effect is considered in analyses. Some
investigations done to find vibrational characteristics of CNTs using the
non-classical continuum theories are as the following.the study by Lü
et al. (2015) investigated the transverse vibration of simply supported
DWCNTs both conveying moving nanoparticles. Effect of some system
parameters was analyzed on the tubes dynamics. Their results show
that the maximum transverse deflections of both coupled tubes can be
reduced because of the time lag. In another study, Hashemi and
Khaniki (2018) examined nonlocal continuum model of simply supported Euler–Bernoulli nanobeams under a moving nanoparticle using
Eringen's nonlocal theory. Beam layers were coupled by Winkler elastic
medium. Their results show that small-scale parameter has an important role on dynamic response of nanobeams under moving nanoparticles. The work of Kiani and Roshan (2019) investigated transverse
vibrations of doubly parallel nanotubes acted by doubly lagged-moving
nanoparticles applying the nonlocal Rayleigh and higher-order beam
models. They considered the nonlocal inertial force as well as the lag of
moving nanoparticles. The effect of nonlocality, shear deformation, lag
effect, and kinematic properties of the moving nanoparticles on the
dynamic deflections of the tubes was studied. Furthermore, Karličić
et al. (2017) using the nonlocal continuum theory studied the nonlinear
vibrations of SWCNTs influenced by a time-varying axial load and a
longitudinal magnetic field. Using the method of multiple scales the
amplitude-frequency relationship was derived. They approximated an
analytical expression for nonlinear frequency. They presented instability regions for the linear vibration of the system. It was shown that
the magnetic field, the nonlocal parameter, and stiffness coefficient of
the viscoelastic medium have important effects on the vibration and
instability behavior of the nanobeam. In their study,
Pourseifi et al. (2015) evaluated active vibration control of nanotubes
under action of a moving nanoscale particle. The effects of the moving
nanoparticle velocity, small scale effect parameter and slenderness ratio
of nanotube on the dynamic deflection were investigated. They showed
the efficiency of the control algorithm in suppressing the vibrations of
the nanostructure. Hołubowski et al. (2019) based on non-local elasticity theory studied dynamics of SWCNTs under distributed random
loads. They examined the influence of load standard deviation and nonlocal parameters on dynamic response and showed that random load
perturbations should not be neglected in dynamic analyses. Based on
different beam theories and using the nonlocal continuum theory of
Kiani and Wang (2012) studied the interaction of a moving nanoparticle with a single-walled carbon nanotube. Examining forced vibration of a simply supported SWCNT excited by a moving harmonic
load, Şimşek (2010) investigated the effects of aspect ratio, nonlocal
parameter, and velocity and the excitation frequency of the moving
load on the dynamic response of SWCNTs.
Based on the number of consisting rolled graphene sheets, CNTs are
divided into single-, double- and multi-walled carbon nanotubes. While
the outer layer of MWCNTs may keep the inner tubes away from chemical interactions with outside environs, each of the nested tubes interacts with the adjacent nanotubes through the vdW interlayer forces.
2. Model development
A schematic of a DWCNT which has been modeled as a double-tube
pipe with length of l, inner tube of radius r1, outer tube of radius r2,
Young's modulus of E, the density of ρ, and Poisson's ratio of ν is shown
in Fig. 1. The surrounding medium is described by a Pasternak foundation modeled with shear constant ks and spring constant kw. The
DWCNT is simply-supported at both ends. A nanoparticle of mass m
2
Mechanics of Materials 142 (2020) 103279
M. Pirmoradian, et al.
where t is time and ui(x, t) and wi(x, t) represent axial and transverse
displacement components of the ith tube, respectively. Assuming smalldeflection and linear vibration of the DWCNT, the only nonzero strain
component based on Euler-Bernoulli beam theory can be written as:
εxx =
∂u¯ i
∂ui
∂ 2w
=
− z 2i
∂x
∂x
∂x
(5)
Considering that the CNT deforms within its linear elastic range,
Hooke's law is predominant as follows
σxx = Eεxx .
(6)
The strain energy (PE)s stored in the DWCNT is given by:
PEs =
1
2
Fig. 1. Schematic of a DWCNT carrying moving nanoparticles.
∫0
l
i = 1, 2.
σxi εxi dx ,
(7)
Substituting Eqs. (5) and (6) into Eq. (7) yields to:
moves through the inner tube of the DWCNT at a constant speed of V
from left to right. It is assumed that when the nanoparticle leaves the
DWCNT, another one enters and moves immediately. The consecutive
transition of moving nano-particles provides a varying mass system
which leads to have a so-called “open” system.
PEs =
∫t
δ (L)o dt +
1
∫t
δH dt =0
1
where
δH = δW +
→
u ·δ→
r )( VB − →
u ). →
n ds
∫∫(ρm →
Bo (t )
PEf =
∫t
(δ KE − δ PE + δW )dt =0 ,
1
w¯ i (x , z , t ) = wi (x , t )
1
2
∫0
PE vdW = −
2
2
⎝
⎢
⎣ A1
⎠
⎜
⎟
⎝
⎜
A2
−z
2
⎤
∂ 2w 2 ⎞
dA ⎥ dx ,
∂x 2 ⎠
⎥
⎦
⎟
l
2
⎛k w w2 − ks ∂ w2 ⎞ w2 dx
∂x 2 ⎠
⎝
⎜
⎟
(9)
1
2
∫0
p12 w1 dx −
l
1
2
∫0
l
p21 w2 dx
(10)
where p12 is the force applied to the outer tube by the inner one and p21
is the force applied to the inner tube by the outer one. It should also be
noted that p12 = −p21 = pvdW . For small-deflection and considering just
linear vibrations of the system, the vdW force at any point should be a
linear function of the distance between two adjacent nanotubes at that
point. So, the vdW pressure per unit length of the DWCNT is given by:
(1)
(2)
p VdW = c (w2 − w1)
(11)
where c is the intertube interaction coefficient and can be estimated by:
c = 2r1
∂ 2U
∂Δ2
Δ = Δe
(12)
The interlayer cohesive energy U can be stated in terms of the interlayer spacingΔ as:
Δ 4
Δ 10
U (Δ) = kL ⎡ ⎛ 0 ⎞ − 0.4 ⎛ 0 ⎞ ⎤
⎢
⎝Δ⎠ ⎥
⎣⎝ Δ ⎠
⎦
(13)
where kL is calculated to be 0.4089101874 J/m and Δ0 = 0.34 nm
(Ansari et al., 2012). Also, the equilibrium interfacial spacing is
Δe = Δ0 .
The work done by the moving nanoparticle in contact with the inner
tube of the DWCNT is given by:
2
(3)
where KE is the kinetic energy of the nanostructure and PE introduces
its potential energy including strain energy of the nanotube PEs, the
potential energy resulted by the Pasternak foundation PEf, and the
potential energy due to vdW interaction forces PEvdW. Based on the
well-known Euler–Bernoulli beam theory (Ghayesh, 2011, 2018a,
2019; Gholipour et al., 2015; Ghayesh et al., 2013a,b,d, 2016;
Ghayesh and Farajpour, 2019), the displacement fields are expressed as:
u¯ i (x , z , t ) = ui (x , t ) −
⎡
Moreover, the potential energy resulted by vdW forces between the
tubes may be expressed as:
The Lagrangian of the system, which has been confined by the open
control volume, is denoted by(L)o = (KE − PE)o and δWrepresents the
u = D→
r /Dt is
virtual work done by external forces on the system. Also →
→
the material time derivative of the nano-particle position vector, r , and
→
→
VB is the velocity of control surface. Moreover, n introduces the normal
vector on the differential surface element with area ds. In other term,
the last term in Eq. (2) may be supposed as a virtual momentum
→ → →
u ·δ→
r ) which arises with a rate ( VB − u )· n across the
transport (ρm →
open surface Bo(t). For the case of simply supported or cantilevered
→
boundary conditions, there is no virtual displacement at ends (δ r = 0) .
Therefore, the second term in right side of Eq. (2) will vanish. Finally,
applying all above-mentioned consideration on Eq. (1) leads to:
t2
l
(8)
For an open system, the entrances and exits of nano-particles across
the DWCNT can be perceived as intermittent momentum transfer
through the CNT. To derive the governing equations of such problems,
the conventional Hamilton's principle cannot be applied, since the set of
particles involved is flowing across the boundaries and does not permit
a system formulation approach (Torkan et al., 2019a,b; Torkan et al.,
2017; Torkan and Pirmoradian, 2019) So, the extended Hamilton's
principle (Pirmoradian and Karimpour, 2017; Pirmoradian et al., 2015,
2018) for a system of changing mass is written as
t2
∫0 ⎢∫ ⎛ ∂∂ux1 − z ∂∂xw21 ⎞ dA + ∫ ⎛ ∂∂ux2
where A1 and A2 are the cross-sectional areas of inner and outer tubes,
respectively. The surrounding elastic medium is simulated by Pasternak
foundation, which is generally referred as a two-parametric mechanical
model which assumes the foundation is formed from some separate
springs and a shear layer over the springs. The potential imposed to the
system due to this type of foundation can be written as:
2.1. Derivation of motion equations
t2
E
2
W=−
∫0
l
F (x , t ) w1 dx
(14)
where F(x, t) is the loading function. Considering all inertial effects of
the moving nanoparticle, this function is defined as:
F (x , t ) = mg − m
∂w (x , t )
z i∂x
= ⎡m g − V 2
⎣
(
(4)
3
(
∂2w
1
∂x 2
d2w1
dt2
− 2V ∂x ∂t1 −
∂2w
− k v w1 δ¯ (x − x m)
∂2w
)
1
∂t 2
) − k w ⎤⎦ δ¯ (x − Vt )
v
1
(15)
Mechanics of Materials 142 (2020) 103279
M. Pirmoradian, et al.
where Dirac-delta function δ̄ is used to determine the position of the
nanoparticle throughout the DWCNT. Also, kv is a linear spring constant, which is utilized to simulate the vdW force between the moving
nanoparticle and the DWCNT. In addition, the kinetic energy KE of the
DWCNT is given by:
KE
=
ρ
2
∫0 ⎨∫ ⎡⎢ ⎛⎝ ∂∂ut1 ⎞⎠
l
⎧
⎩
2
A1
⎣
∂w
+ ⎛ 1 ⎞ ⎤ dA1 +
⎝ ∂t ⎠ ⎥
⎦
2
∫ ⎡⎢ ⎛⎝ ∂∂ut2 ⎞⎠
2
A2
⎣
ρA1
(
(
+µ2 c
(16)
ρA2
∂2u1
∂N1
−
= 0,
∂t 2
∂x
(17)
∂2u2
∂N2
−
= 0,
∂t 2
∂x
(18)
ρA1
∂ 2w 1
∂2M1
∂ 2w
∂ 2w 1
∂ 2w 1 ⎞
−
− ⎡m ⎛g − V 2 21 − 2V
−
− k v w1⎤ δ¯
⎢ ⎝
⎥
∂t 2
∂x 2
x
x
t
∂
∂
∂
∂t 2 ⎠
⎣
⎦
(x − Vt ) − c (w2 − w1) = 0,
(19)
ρA2
∂ 2w 2 ⎞
∂2M2
∂ 2w 2
+ c (w2 − w1) = 0.
+ ⎛k w w2 − ks
−
∂x 2 ⎠
∂x 2
∂t 2
⎝
⎜
⎜
ρA2
∫ σxi dAi ,
Mi =
V
(20)
(22)
ρA2
∂2w 2
∂t 2
∂2w 2
∂x 2
(24)
∂2u2
∂ 2u
∂ 4u
− EA2 22 − µ2 ρA2 2 2 2 = 0,
2
∂t
∂x
∂x ∂t
(25)
−
∂ 4w
∂2w1
∂x 2
− µ2 ρA2
∂ 4w
∂2w1
∂t 2
) − k w ⎞⎠ δ¯ (x − Vt )
) − k ⎞⎠ δ¯ (x − Vt )
∂ 4w
v
1
∂x 2∂t 2
1
∂2w1
v ∂x 2
)=0
∂ 4w 2
∂x 2∂t 2
+ EI2
(
∂2w 2
∂x 2
(26)
∂ 4w 2
∂x 4
−
+ k w w 2 − ks
∂2w1
∂x 2
)=0
∂2w 2
∂x 2
− µ2 k w
∂2w 2
∂x 2
+ µ2 ks
∂ 4w 2
∂x 4
∞
w1 (x , t ) =
∑ φ1i (x ) q1i (t )
w2 (x , t ) =
∑ φ2i (x ) q2i (t )
i=1
(28)
∞
i=1
(29)
M (t ) q¨ 1 (t ) + C (t ) q˙ 1 (t ) + K (t ) q1 (t ) + T q 2 (t ) = F (t )
(30)
˜ q (t ) + T
˜ q (t ) = 0
˜ q¨ (t ) + K
M
2
1
2
(31)
where q1 (t ) = {q11 (t ), q21 (t ), ...}T , q2 (t ) = {q12 (t ), q22 (t ), ...}T are the
modal coordinates vectors and components of the matrices can be
achieved as:
(23)
∂2u1
∂ 2u
∂ 4u
− EA1 21 − µ2 ρA1 2 1 2 = 0,
2
∂t
∂x
∂x ∂t
∂2w
where φ(x) is the spatial mode shape, q(t) introduces the time dependent modal amplitude and i represents the number of modes. In order to
reduce the coupled PDEs of motion to corresponding coupled ordinary
differential equations, Eqs. (28) and (29) are substituted into Eqs. (26)
and (27), then the results are multiplied by φ1j(x) and φ2j(x) respectively, and at last integrating is performed over the domain [0, L]
leading to the following equations:
where σij and σijnl denote local and nonlocal stresses, respectively, ∇2 is
the Laplacian operator, and µ = e0 a is the nonlocal parameter in which
a is an internal characteristic length and e0 is a constant. Using Eqs.
(17)–(20) and (22) and performing some arithmetic operations, the
final nonlocal form of PDEs governing the motion can be obtained as:
ρA1
(
(21)
τ inwhere σij(X) is the nonlocal stress tensor in point X, K(|X − X ′|,˜)
troduces the nonlocal modulus, Cijkl is the elasticity tensors of forthorder, ɛkl presents the linear strain tensor and τ̃ is the material constant.
To avoid the difficulties of spatial integrating in Eq. (22),
Eringen (1983) presented an equivalent differential constitutive relation using Green's function as (Oveissi et al., 2019; Liu and Lv, 2018):
(1 − µ2 ∇2 ) σijnl = σij
− 2V ∂x ∂t1 −
The motion equations describing flexural and longitudinal vibrations of the DWCNT were derived in last section. Generally, the flexural
modes occur at low frequencies and longitudinal modes are excited at
high operating frequencies. In addition, the transverse modes are more
prone to get excited by common types of external excitations like what
happens for the motion of a moving nanoparticle inside a CNT.
Accordingly, in the following the lateral vibration of the DWCNT excited by constitutive motion of moving nanoparticles is investigated. In
order to discretize the equations of motion by applying the Galerkin
method, the transverse displacements of the DWCNT tubes are considered as (Pirmoradian et al., 2014, 2018, 2019; Torkan et al., 2018):
⎟
∫ K( X − X ′ , τ˜)Cijkl εkl (X ′) d V(X ′)
∂ 4 w1
∂x 4
2.2. Discretization of motion equations
In classical local elasticity theory, stress at an arbitrary point depends only on the strain at same point, whereas, in nonlocal elasticity
theory, the stress at a point is a function of the strains at that point and
also on strains at all other points of the continuum as following
(Eringen, 1983, 2002):
σij (X ) =
+ EI1
(27)
⎟
∫ σxi z dAi ,
∂2w1
∂x 2
+c (w2 − w1) − µ2 c
where resultants stress are defined as:
Ni =
∂ 4 w1
∂x 2∂t 2
+µ2 ⎛m −V 2 41 − 2V 3 1 −
∂x
∂x ∂t
⎝
− c (w2 − w1)
where A1 and A2 are the cross-sections of the inner and outer tubes.
Substituting Eqs. (8)–(10), (14) and (16) into Eq. (3) and taking variation with respect to u1, u2, w1 and w2, the governing coupled PDEs of
motion are derived as:
ρA1
− µ2 ρA1
−⎛m g − V 2
⎝
⎫
∂w 2
+ ⎛ 2 ⎞ ⎤ dA2
⎬
⎝ ∂t ⎠ ⎥
⎦
⎭
dx
∂2w1
∂t 2
4
Mechanics of Materials 142 (2020) 103279
M. Pirmoradian, et al.
Mij = ρA1 ∫0 φ1i φ1j dx − µ2 ρA1 ∫0
l ∂2φ1i
φ (x )dx
∂x 2 1j
l
∂φ1i
Cij = 2mV
∂x
Kij
= ∫0 EI1
φ1j −
∂ 4φ1i
l
∂3φ
2µ2 mVµ2 31i φ1j
∂x
∂x 4
φ1j dx + mV 2
dx − µ2 c ∫
∂2φ1i
l ∂2φ1i
φ dx
0 ∂x 2 1j
∂2φ1i
+k v φ1i φ1j − µ2 k v
∂x 2
φ1j − mµ2 V 2
∂x 2
+ m φ1i φ1j − µ2 m
∂ 4φ1i
∂x 4
Tij = −c ∫ φ2i φ1j dx + µ2 c ∫0
l ∂2φ2i
Fj = mg φ1j
−ks ∫0
∂ 4φ2i
∂x 4
∂x 2
+(1 − 2ζ Ω2 sin2 (τ ) − 2ζµ*Ω2π 2 sin2 (τ ) + 2k v*sin2 (τ ) + 2k v*µ*π 2 sin2
(τ ) + c1* + µ*π 2c1*) Q1
−(c1* + µ*π 2c1*) Q2 = 2 ζg *sin(τ )
(37)
φ1j dx
Ω2 (1 + µ*π 2) Q″2 + (1 + k w* + µ*π 2k w* + ks* + µ*π 2ks* + c2* + µ*π 2c2*) Q2
−(c2* + µ*π 2c2*) Q1 = 0
φ2j (x )dx + k w ∫0 φ2i φ2j dx − µ2 k w ∫0
l ∂2φ2i
l
− µ2 c ∫0
Ω2 (1 + π 2µ* + 2ζ sin2 (τ ) + 2ζπ 2µ*sin2 (τ )) Q″1
+(4ζ Ω2 cos(τ ) sin (τ ) + 4ζµ*Ω2π 2 cos(τ ) sin (τ )) Q′1
l
l ∂2φ2i
φ dx
0 ∂x 2 2j
l ∂2φ2i
φ dx
∂x 2 2j
as:
φ1j
φ1j + c ∫0 φ1i φ1j
˜ ij = ρA2 ∫ φ φ dx − µ2 ρA2 ∫
M
2i 2j
l
T˜ij = EI2 ∫0
∂x 2
φ1j ,
l
0
l
0
∂2φ1i
+ µ2 ks ∫0
l ∂ 4φ2i
φ dx
∂x 4 2j
l ∂2φ2i
φ dx
∂x 2 2j
l
l
K˜ ij = −c ∫0 φ1i φ2j dx + µ2 c ∫0
∂2φ1i
∂x 2
∂x 2
+ c ∫0 φ2i φ2j dx
(38)
φ2j dx
where the prime superscript indicates the non-dimensional time derivative.
l
2.3. Consecutive loading
φ2j dx
(32)
The coefficients of Eq. (37) change with time as long as the nanoparticle moves inside the CNT. Once the particle exits the CNT, the
time-varying coefficients will disappear resulting in removal of any
growth of vibrational amplitude. Therefore, a sequential transition of
nanoparticles with period of T = l/ V is considered to investigate the
conditions of system dynamic instability. To reflect this statement in the
motion equations, the Fourier expansion of the time-varying coefficients of Eq. (37) is written as:
By selecting the following mode shape functions
φ1i (x ) =
2
l
φ2i (x ) =
2
l
( )
sin ( )
iπx
l
sin
iπx
l
(33)
which satisfy the boundary conditions of simply supported boundary
conditions (Oveissi et al., 2016, 2018) and substituting them into expressions for aforementioned matrices components, the governing
equations of the modal coordinates for the fundamental mode of the
system (i = 1) are obtained as follows:
⎡ρA1 + µ2 ρA1
⎣
+⎡4mV
⎣
π
l2
( ) + 2µ m
cos ( ) sin ( ) + 4mµ V
π2
l2
+ 2 l sin2
m
πVt
l
πVt
l
+⎡EI1 4 − 2mV 2 3 sin2
l
l
⎢
⎣
π4
k π2
+2µ2 v 3
l
= mg
2
l
πVt
l
π2
( )
πVt
l
( )+c+µc
sin ( ) ,
πVt
l
sin2
2
2
π2
l3
2
π3
l4
( ) ⎤⎦ q¨
cos ( ) sin ( ) ⎤ q˙
⎦
sin2
πVt
l
π4
l2
1
πVt
l
− 2mµ2 V 2 l5 sin2
π2
Ω2 (1 + π 2µ* + ζ (1 − cos(2τ )) + ζπ 2µ* (1 − cos(2τ ))) Q″1
+ (2ζ Ω2sin (2τ ) + 2ζβ 2µ*π 2sin (2τ )) Q′1
+ (1 − ζ Ω2 (1 − cos(2τ )) − ζµ*Ω2π 2 (1 − cos(2τ )) + k v* (1 − cos(2τ ))
+ k v*µ*π 2 (1 − cos(2τ )) + c1* + µ*π 2c1*) Q1
πVt
l
( )
πVt
l
− (c1* + µ*π 2c1*) Q2 =
+ 2 lv sin2
k
( )
+ ⎡EI2
⎣
π4
l4
+ k w + µ2 k w
−⎡c + µ2 c 2 ⎤ q1 = 0
l ⎦
⎣
π2
l2
+ ks
⎤ q − ⎡c + µ2 c ⎤ q
l2 ⎦ 2
⎥ 1 ⎣
⎦
π2
l2
+ µ2 ks
π4
l2
+ c + µ2 c
π2
⎤q
l2 ⎦ 2
π2
(35)
It should be noted that in most of mechanical loading problems, the
most amount of energy is stored in modes with lower orders (frequencies) like what happens in Fourier components which are larger in
magnitude for lower frequencies and smaller for higher frequencies. In
other words, the energy which is required to excite higher modes of
vibration may not be available in many applications. By defining the
following non-dimensional parameters
Δ m
ζ = ρA l ,
1
Δ kw l 4
,
π 4EI2
k w* =
Δ Vl
π
Ω=
ρA
EI
,
Δ ks l 2
,
π 2EI2
ks* =
Δ πVt
,
l
τ=
Δ kv l 3
,
π 4EI1
k v* =
Δ q
Q=
l3/2
,
+ ∑k = 1
∞
4
π (1 − 4k2)
cos(2kτ )
)
Ω2 (1 + π 2µ* + ζ (1 − cos(2τ )) + ζπ 2µ* (1 − cos(2τ ))) Q″1
+(2ζ Ω2sin (2τ ) + 2ζ Ω2µ*π 2sin (2τ )) Q′1
+(1 − ζ Ω2 (1 − cos(2τ )) − ζµ*Ω2π 2 (1 − cos(2τ )) + k v* (1 − cos(2τ ))
+k v*µ*π 2 (1 − cos(2τ )) + c1* + µ*π 2c1* − (γ + λ cos(2τ )) − µ*π 2
Δ c l4
,
π 4EI1
c1* =
Δ c l4
,
π 4EI2
c2* =
2
π
According to some uncertainty due to reaction force of non-ideal
supports or undesired external loadings, an axial force involving static
and periodic parts(P0 + P cos(2τ )) is applied to the DWCNT. It is assumed that the frequency of the oscillating part is twice the frequency
of the nanoparticles passage (Karimpour et al., 2016). This term has to
be entered alongside the CNT stiffness term due to the recognized effect
of axial forces on flexibility of systems. In addition, it is noteworthy that
although investigating external resonance of the system may be of interest because of appearance of the direct forcing term in right side of
Eq. (39), the moving nanoparticles inertia terms individually render the
modal Eq. (39) parametrically excited where dynamic instability can
occur due to parametric resonance. Accordingly, the right side of
Eq. (39) is omitted by refraining the gravity effect of passing nanoparticles. Finally, considering the small-scale effects, the non-dimensional coupled homogeneous motion equations of the DWCNT surrounded by an elastic medium and excited by moving nanoparticles are
obtained as follows:
π2
(34)
π2
⎤ q¨
l2 ⎦ 2
(
(39)
πVt
l
πVt
l
⎡ρA2 + µ2 ρA2
⎣
2 ζg *
1
(γ + λ cos(2τ ))) Q1
−(c1* + µ*π 2c1*) Q2 = 0
Δ ρAg l3
g* = 4 ,
π EI1
(36)
(40)
the governing equations of motion in dimensionless form are resulted
5
Mechanics of Materials 142 (2020) 103279
M. Pirmoradian, et al.
Fig. 2. Stable and unstable regions in the parameters plane.
Fig. 3. Phase plane of the DWCNT carrying moving nanoparticles for parameters belonging to the unstable region.
Ω2 (1 + µ*π 2) Q″2
+ (1 + k w* +
+ ks* +
+ c2* +
−µ*π 2 (γ + λ cos(2τ ))) Q2 − (c2* + µ*π 2c2*) Q1 = 0
µ*π 2k w*
where
Δ
γ = P0/ Pcr ,
Δ
λ = P / Pcr ,
µ*π 2ks*
and Pcr = π 2EI / l 2 .
µ*π 2c2*
The incremental procedure is the first step of the IHB method. If
(ζ*, Ω*) is an initial point located on one instability boundary corresponding to a periodic response of Q*(τ ) = [Q1, Q2]T , the next point can
be measured by adding the related increments as the following:
− (γ + λ cos(2τ ))
Q (τ ) = Q*(τ ) + ΔQ (τ ),
(41)
ζ = ζ * + Δζ ,
Ω = Ω* + ΔΩ,
(42)
where Δζ, ΔΩ and ΔQ(τ) are small increments. By substituting Eq. (42)
into Eqs. (40) and (41), and omitting the nonlinear terms of small increments, the linear incremental equation is extracted as follows:
3. Solution procedure
Ω* (M1 + ζ *M2 (τ ))ΔQ″ + 2ζ *Ω* C1 (τ )ΔQ′
2
As stated in the last section, the consecutive passage of nanoparticles through the DWCNT results in presence of periodic coefficients
in motion equations. Based on Floquet theory for periodic systems with
period T, there exist periodic solutions of period T and 2T on the
transition curves in the parameters plane which separate stable and
unstable regions. Therefore, any method capable to find solutions with
period of T or 2T for the differential equations governing the problem
may be applied to find these boundary curves. In this paper, the IHB
method is utilized to determine the transition curves in the mass-velocity plane of the passing nanoparticles.
2
+ ⎜⎛K1 + ζ *Ω* K2 (τ ) + K3 (τ ) ⎟⎞ ΔQ
⎠
⎝
2
=R − ⎧Ω* (M2 (τ ) Q*″ + 2C1 (τ ) Q*′ + K2 (τ ) Q*) ⎫ Δζ
⎬
⎨
⎭
⎩
−{2Ω*((M1 + ζ *M2 (τ )) Q*″ + 2ζ *C1 (τ ) Q*′ + ζ *K2 (τ ) Q*)}ΔΩ
2
(43)
where R is the residual vector and its value will approach to zero when
Q*(τ) tends to its exact value. The values of R and the matrices of M1,
6
Mechanics of Materials 142 (2020) 103279
M. Pirmoradian, et al.
Fig. 4. Phase plane of the DWCNT carrying moving nanoparticles for parameters belonging to the stable region.
Fig. 5. Effect of vdW interacting force between layers on the unstable region.
2
−c2* − π 2µ*c2*
⎤
⎡1 + c1* + π µ*c1*
2 * *
*
K1 = ⎢
1 + k w* + µ*π 2k w* + ks* + µ*π 2 ⎥
⎥,
⎢ −c1 − π µ c1
2
⎥
⎢
ks* + c2* + µ*π c2*
⎦
⎣
M2, C1, K1, and K2 are
R = −Ω* (M1 + ζ *M2 (τ )) Q*″ − 2ζ *Ω* C1 (τ ) Q*′
2
2
− ⎜⎛K1 + ζ *Ω* K2 (τ ) + K3 (τ ) ⎟⎞ Q*,
⎠
⎝
1 + π 2µ*
0
⎤
⎡
M1 =
,
⎢
0
1 + π 2µ* ⎥
⎦
⎣
−1 + cos(2τ ) − π 2µ* (1 − cos(2τ )) 0 ⎤
K2 = ⎡
,
⎢
0
0⎥
⎣
⎦
2
M2
1 − cos(2τ ) + π 2µ* (1 − cos(2τ ))
=⎡
⎢
0
⎣
sin(2τ ) + π 2µ*sin(2τ ) 0 ⎤
,
C1 = ⎡
⎢
0
0⎥
⎦
⎣
0
0
⎡ −(γ + λ cos(2τ )) − π 2µ*
⎤
⎢
⎥
+
(
cos(2
))
γ
λ
τ
⎢
⎥
⎢ *
⎥
+k v (1 − cos(2τ )) + k v*µ*
0
⎢
⎥.
K3 =
⎢ π 2 (1 − cos(2τ ))
⎥
⎢
⎥
⎢0
−(γ + λ cos(2τ )) − π 2µ* ⎥
⎢
⎥
(γ + λ cos(2τ ))
⎢
⎥
⎣
⎦
⎤,
⎥
⎦
(44)
The harmonic balance procedure is the second step of the IHB
method which obtains periodic solutions of Eqs. (40) and (41) by expanding Q* and ΔQ* to finite Fourier series and applying the Galerkin
method. For periodic solutions with period of 2T, Qi* (τ ) and ΔQi(τ) are
7
Mechanics of Materials 142 (2020) 103279
M. Pirmoradian, et al.
Fig. 6. Effect of vdW force between nanoparticle and inner tube on the unstable region.
Fig. 7. Effect of nonlocal parameter on the unstable region.
expressed in the following form:
Qi* (τ ) = ∑p = 1,3,5, … [aip cos(pτ ) + bip sin(pτ )] = Todd ai, odd,
Q*′ = Y′A,
i = 1, 2
ΔQ*′ = Y′ΔA,
⎡
π
0
(45)
in which:
Todd = [cos(τ ), cos(3τ ), …, sin(τ ), sin(3τ ), …]
ai, odd = [ai1, ai3, ai5, …, bi1, bi3, …]T
2
where Y = diag (T) and coefficients A and ΔA are expressed as:
A = [a1T , a T2 ] ,
T
ΔA = [Δa1T , Δa T2 ]
T
2
⎣
2
⎤
ΔQ′ + ⎜⎛K1 + ζ *Ω* K2 (τ ) + K3 (τ ) ⎟⎞ ΔQ⎥ dτ
⎝
⎠ ⎦
2
⎡
= ∫ δ (ΔQ)T ⎢R − ⎧Ω* (M2 (τ ) Q*″ + 2C1 (τ ) Q*′ + K2 (τ ) Q*) ⎫ Δζ
⎬
⎨
0
⎭
⎩
⎣
−{2Ω*((M1 + ζ *M2 (τ )) Q*″ + 2ζ *C1 (τ ) Q*′ + ζ *K2 (τ ) Q*)}ΔΩ] dτ
π
(46)
Using the following terse form:
ΔQ = YΔA
(49)
∫ δ (ΔQ)T ⎢Ω* (M1 + ζ *M2 (τ ))ΔQ″ + 2ζ *Ω* C1 (τ )
i = 1, 2
Q* = YA,
ΔQ*″ = Y″ΔA
Applying the Galerkin method to Eq. (43) for one period leads to
ΔQi (τ ) = ∑p = 1,3,5, … [Δaip cos(pτ ) + Δbip sin(pτ )] = Todd Δai, odd,
Δai, odd = [Δai1, Δai3, Δai5, …, Δbi1, Δbi3, …]T
Q*″ = Y″A,
(50)
(47)
Substituting Eqs. (47) and (49) into Eq. (50), the following linear
equations are achieved in terms of parameters ΔA, Δζ and ΔΩ
˜
SΔA ΔA + SΔζ Δζ + SΔβ ΔΩ = R
(48)
where
one may have:
8
(51)
Mechanics of Materials 142 (2020) 103279
M. Pirmoradian, et al.
Fig. 8. Effect of oscillatory axial force amplitude on the unstable region.
Fig. 9. Effect of static axial force amplitude on the unstable region.
Eq. (51) is used to find the instability boundaries for terms A, ζ*,
and Ω*. Since the number of unknown variables exceeds the number of
equations by two, without reducing the generality of problem solving,
an element of A is equated to one and its corresponding increment in
ΔA is set to zero. Also, by choosing ζ as the active parameter in solving
procedure, Δζ is considered to be zero. Then, the number of equations
and unknowns is equal in Eq. (51) and it can be solved using a recursive
algorithm. The details of the algorithm can be found in references
(Torkan et al., 2017; Pirmoradian et al., 2018).
SΔA
2
⎡ 2
= ∫ Y T ⎢Ω* (M1 + ζ *M2 (τ )) Y″ + 2ζ *Ω* C1 (τ )
0
⎣
π
2
⎤
Y′ + ⎜⎛K1 + ζ *Ω* K2 (τ ) + K3 (τ ) ⎟⎞ Y⎥ dτ
⎠ ⎦
⎝
SΔζ = ∫ Y T ⎡Ω* (M2 (τ ) Y″ + 2C1 (τ ) Y′ + K2 (τ ) Y) ⎤ A dτ
⎥
⎢
0
⎦
⎣
π
2
SΔβ = ∫ Y T [2Ω*((M1 + ζ *M2 (τ )) Y″ + 2ζ *C1 (τ ) Y′ + ζ *K2 (τ ) Y)] A dτ
π
0
˜
R
4. Results and discussion
2
⎡ 2
= − ∫ Y T ⎢Ω* (M1 + ζ *M2 (τ )) Y″ + 2ζ *Ω* C1 (τ )
0
⎣
π
The present parametric-type excitation problem, which was produced by successive passage of nanoparticles, may lead to instability in
transverse vibrations of the DWCNT. Accordingly, the amplitude of
DWCNT vibrations can be bounded for some system parameters or it
may grow without any bound for some other parameters. Actually,
dynamic instability arises for some regions in the mass-velocity plane of
the transiting nanoparticles. This study emphasizes on finding these
2
⎤
Y′ + ⎜⎛K1 + ζ *Ω* K2 (τ ) + K3 (τ ) ⎟⎞ Y⎥ A dτ
⎠ ⎦
⎝
(52)
9
Mechanics of Materials 142 (2020) 103279
M. Pirmoradian, et al.
Fig. 10. The unstable region for tensile (λ = 1, γ = 0.1) and compressive (λ = −1, γ = −0.1) axial loadings.
Fig. 11. Effect of springs stiffness of elastic foundation on the unstable region.
parameters e0 a = 0.5 nm , k w = 0 , ks = 0 , λ = 1 and γ = 0 . Moreover, in
this step of analyses the vdW forces are neglected. Stable and unstable
regions are shown in Fig. 2. From a dynamic point of view, selecting the
nanoparticle parameters (mass and speed) from the unstable region will
lead to unbounded increase of the DWCNT vibrational amplitude with
time. In addition, as shown in Fig. 2, the convergence analysis of the
IHB method has been performed to find the suitable number of harmonic terms of Eq. (46). As can be seen, the results of three and four
harmonic terms converge. So, for the rest of the study, the first three
harmonic terms of Eq. (46) are considered in the analyses.
To approve the regions obtained in Fig. 2, phase plane of the system
response is plotted for parameters picked from stable and unstable regions by solving the governing Eqs. (40) and (41) by using Runge-Kutta
method. The first point (Ω = 0.91, ζ = 0.13) is selected in the vicinity of
the boundary from the unstable region, and the second point
(Ω = 0.94, ζ = 0.13) is selected near the boundary but from the stable
region. The phase plane plots are shown in Figs. 3 and 4. As shown in
Fig. 3, the amplitude of transverse vibrations of the DWCNT for the
selected parameters from the unstable region increases and instability
occurs. However, Fig. 4 illustrates the bounded amplitude of the
DWCNT oscillations representing its stability for the selected
regions. The stable regions are separated from unstable ones by transition curves from which picking system parameters results in presence
of a periodic solution of period T or 2T for the system. The regions
associated with solutions of period 2T are wider than those of period T.
This makes them more important in practical applications
(Torkan et al., 2019a; Bolotin, 1962). In fact, these regions are correlated to happening of principle parametric resonance in the mentioned
system. This kind of resonance occurs in self-excited systems when the
exciting frequency is near twice the fundamental natural frequency of
the system (Pirmoradian and Karimpour, 2017; Pirmoradian et al.,
2014; Torkan et al., 2018; Nayfeh and Mook, 1979).
The geometric properties considered for the DWCNT in the present
analyses are like those used in Ansari et al. (2012), i.e., the nanotube
density is ρ = 1300 Kg/m3, the Poisson's ratio is ν = 0.3, and its Young's
modulus is considered to be E = 1.1 TPa . Also, the inner radius is assumed to be r1 = 0.82 nm , the outer radius is r2 = 1.5 nm , the thickness is
t = 0.34 nm and the length of nanotube is considered as l = 45 nm . By
using the IHB method, the curves corresponding to 2T-period solutions
were obtained and plotted in Fig. 2. In this figure, the horizontal and
vertical axes represent the dimensionless passing frequency of nanoparticles and the mass ratio, respectively. The curves are obtained for
10
Mechanics of Materials 142 (2020) 103279
M. Pirmoradian, et al.
Fig. 12. Effect of shear layer stiffness of elastic foundation on the unstable region.
Fig. 13. Stability diagram of the SWCNT under the influence of axial harmonic loading.
moving nanoparticles.
The effect of nonlocal parameter on the DWCNT dynamic instability
is studied in Fig. 7. The parameters are considered to be k w = 0 , ks = 0 ,
λ = 1 and γ = 0 . The figure shows that when the nonlocal parameter
increases, the unstable region shifts to lower frequencies of the passing
nanoparticles and consequently the DWCNT will become more unstable. This is because increasing the nonlocal parameter reduces the
interaction forces between the CNT atoms which results in having a
softer nanostructure. This emphasizes the significance of considering
size-dependent theories such as nonlocal elasticity theory in the analyses of nanostructures.
The effect of the oscillatory axial force amplitude, λ, on the parametric region of the Ω − ζ plane is shown in Fig. 8. In this analysis, the
system parameters are set as e0 a = 0.5 nm , k w = 0 , ks = 0 , and γ = 0 . As
can be seen, decreasing the amplitude of the axial oscillatory force does
not change the origin of the unstable region but causes two boundary
curves to come closer. Therefore, the area of unstable region is reduced
leading to a more stable system.
In the analyzes performed so far, the static axial force amplitude
parameters. The results of numerical simulations indicate high precision of the IHB method in predicting dynamic behavior of the system.
The effect of vdW forces on the DWCNT instability is investigated in
Fig. 5. The value of parameters are selected as e0 a = 0.5 nm , k w = 0 ,
ks = 0 , λ = 1, and γ = 0 . The figure shows that considering the vdW
forces in the analysis leads to a more stable system which can be seen as
a movement of the unstable region to higher frequencies of nanoparticles passage. It may be inferred that inclusion of the vdW forces
makes the DWCNT stiffer. Also, Figs. 2 and 5 show that by increasing
the relative mass parameter ζ, the DWCNT will experience parametric
resonance for a wider range of nanoparticle transition frequencies
which means that increasing the mass of the nanoparticle will increase
the probability of the DWCNT instability.
Fig. 6 shows the effect of vdW force between the moving nanoparticle and the inner tube of the DWCNT. It should be noted that this
term appears in motion equations as a time-varying coefficient in
stiffness matrix. As can be seen, when the vdW force is considered in the
analysis, the unstable zone will become smaller and stability of the
DWCNT is guaranteed for a wider range of masses and speeds of the
11
Mechanics of Materials 142 (2020) 103279
M. Pirmoradian, et al.
parameter, γ, was considered to be zero. The effect of this parameter on
the dynamic stability of the DWCNT under consecutive transition of
moving nanoparticles is studied in Fig. 9. The figure shows that when
the amplitude of the static compressive axial force grows, the unstable
region shifts to lower frequencies of the passing nanoparticles. In fact,
increasing the amplitude of the compressive force reduces the natural
frequency of the DWCNT and makes it softer. In addition, a comparison
between the results of compressive and tensile axial loadings is performed and shown in Fig. 10. It can be concluded that the DWCNT is
more stable in the case of tensile axial loading.
The effect of foundation stiffness on the dynamic instability of the
DWCNT is examined in Fig. 11. The system parameters are set to be
e0 a = 0.5 nm , ks = 0 , λ = 1, and γ = 0.2 in the analysis. The figure
shows that the elastic foundation stiffness has a progressive effect on
the system stability. So that, an increase in the value of foundation
stiffness moves the unstable region to higher frequencies of the nanoparticles passage and so the DWCNT will become unstable for higher
values of the nanoparticle velocities. Fig. 12 illustrates the effect of the
shear layer stiffness on the stability of the system. Again, when the
shear layer stiffness increases, the critical velocities of the moving nanoparticles will also increase.
•
•
•
•
•
•
analyses, the DWCNT carrying moving nanoparticles becomes more
stable.
By increasing the nonlocal parameter, the unstable region shifts to
lower frequencies of the passing nanoparticles which means the
critical velocities of the nanoparticles decrease.
As the amplitude of the static tensile axial force increases, the instability of the DWCNT occurs for higher velocities of the passing
nanoparticles.
By reducing the amplitude of the oscillatory axial force, the width of
the unstable region decreases and subsequently the DWCNT will
become more stable.
The DWCNT is more stable in the case of static tensile axial force in
comparison with the case of compressive force.
Increasing the stiffness of the springs and the shear layer of the
foundation improves stability of the system, so that the DWCNT will
experience instability for higher values of the nanoparticles velocities.
The results of numerical simulations show that the IHB method is
accurate in analyzing stability of nonlocal transverse vibrations of
DWCNTs excited by moving nanoparticles.
Declaration of Competing Interest
5. Validation study
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial
interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
In order to certify the results of the implemented method, a simplification on the problem is performed which makes us able to compare the results of the present study with those of existing literature. For
this purpose, by neglecting the passing nanoparticles and eliminating
one tube from the model, a single-walled carbon nanotube under axial
oscillatory force is considered. The geometric and mechanical properties are chosen as E = 1 TPa , ρ = 1300 Kg/m3, l = 45 nm , outer diameter
d1 = 1.64 nm , and inner diameter d 0 = 0.96 nm like those were considered in reference Karličić et al. (2017). The SWCNT is embedded in a
Winkler foundation with stiffness of k w = 106 N/m2 , and the nonlocal
parameter value is set to zero. The nanotube is subjected to axial oscillatory force Pcos (2ωt) with the oscillation frequency of 2ω. Fig. 13
compares the boundaries obtained by the IHB method used in this paper
by those of reference (Karličić et al., 2017). The horizontal axis represents the ratio of the excitation frequency to the natural frequency of
the SWCNT and the vertical axis is the axial oscillatory force amplitude.
The nice agreement between the results confirms the accuracy of the
IHB method in the study of DWCNTs stability under loading.
References
Ajayan, P.M., Zhou, O.Z., 2001. Applications of Carbon Nanotubes. Springer, pp.
391–425.
Ansari, R., Gholami, R., Darabi, M.A., 2012. Nonlinear free vibration of embedded
double-walled carbon nanotubes with layerwise boundary conditions. Acta Mech.
223, 2523–2536.
Ansari, R., Hemmatnezhad, M., 2012. Nonlinear finite element analysis for vibrations of
double-walled carbon nanotubes. Nonlinear Dyn. 67, 373–383.
Bolotin, V., Dynamic Stability of Elastic Systems. (1962).
Budarapu, P.R., Yb, S.S., Javvaji, B., Mahapatra, D.R., 2014. Vibration analysis of multiwalled carbon nanotubes embedded in elastic medium. Front. Struct. Civ. Eng. 8,
151–159.
Eringen, A.C., 1983. On differential equations of nonlocal elasticity and solutions of screw
dislocation and surface waves. J. Appl. Phys. 54, 4703–4710.
Eringen, A.C., 2002. Nonlocal Continuum Field Theories. Springer Science & Business
Media.
Farokhi, H., Ghayesh, M.H., 2017. Nonlinear resonant response of imperfect extensible
Timoshenko microbeams. Int. J. Mech. Mater. Des. 13, 43–55.
Farokhi, H., Ghayesh, M.H., 2018. Supercritical nonlinear parametric dynamics of
Timoshenko microbeams. Commun. Nonlinear Sci. Numer. Simul. 59, 592–605.
Farokhi, H., Ghayesh, M.H., Amabili, M., 2013. Nonlinear resonant behavior of microbeams over the buckled state. Appl. Phys. A 113, 297–307.
Fu, Y., Bi, R., Zhang, P., 2009. Nonlinear dynamic instability of double-walled carbon
nanotubes under periodic excitation. Acta Mech. Solida Sin. 22, 206–212.
Ghayesh, M.H., 2011. Nonlinear forced dynamics of an axially moving viscoelastic beam
with an internal resonance. Int. J. Mech. Sci. 53, 1022–1037.
Ghayesh, M.H., 2018a. Dynamics of functionally graded viscoelastic microbeams. Int. J.
Eng. Sci. 124, 115–131.
Ghayesh, M.H., 2018b. Nonlinear vibration analysis of axially functionally graded sheardeformable tapered beams. Appl. Math. Model. 59, 583–596.
Ghayesh, M.H., 2018c. Functionally graded microbeams: simultaneous presence of imperfection and viscoelasticity. Int. J. Mech. Sci. 140, 339–350.
Ghayesh, M.H., 2019. Viscoelastic dynamics of axially FG microbeams. Int. J. Eng. Sci.
135, 75–85.
Ghayesh, M.H., Amabili, M., Farokhi, H., 2013a. Three-dimensional nonlinear size-dependent behaviour of Timoshenko microbeams. Int. J. Eng. Sci. 71, 1–14.
Ghayesh, M.H., Amabili, M., Farokhi, H., 2013b. Nonlinear forced vibrations of a microbeam based on the strain gradient elasticity theory. Int. J. Eng. Sci. 63, 52–60.
Ghayesh, M.H., Amabili, M., Farokhi, H., 2013c. Coupled global dynamics of an axially
moving viscoelastic beam. Int. J. Non. Linear. Mech. 51, 54–74.
Ghayesh, M.H., Farajpour, A., 2018. Nonlinear mechanics of nanoscale tubes via nonlocal
strain gradient theory. Int. J. Eng. Sci. 129, 84–95.
Ghayesh, M.H., Farajpour, A., 2019. A review on the mechanics of functionally graded
nanoscale and microscale structures. Int. J. Eng. Sci. 137, 8–36.
Ghayesh, M.H., Farokhi, H., 2015. Chaotic motion of a parametrically excited microbeam.
Int. J. Eng. Sci. 96, 34–45.
Ghayesh, M.H., Farokhi, H., Alici, G., 2016. Size-dependent performance of microgyroscopes. Int. J. Eng. Sci. 100, 99–111.
Ghayesh, M.H., Farokhi, H., Amabili, M., 2013d. Nonlinear behaviour of electrically
6. Conclusions
In this research, the linear dynamic instability analysis of a simply
supported DWCNT carrying successive moving nanoparticles surrounded by an elastic medium was performed. Based on Eringen's
nonlocal elasticity theory and applying Euler-Bernoulli beam theory,
the dynamic formulation of the system was extracted. Then, the coupled ODEs with periodic coefficients describing a parametrically excited system were obtained. In order to present a real model, all inertial
effects of the nanoparticles were considered in the governing equations.
In addition, the van der Waals force between the constitutive atoms of
the moving nanoparticle and those of the inner tube was considered.
The IHB method was utilized to calculate the boundaries of instability.
The effects of different parameters like nonlocal parameter, vdW forces,
amplitude of axial oscillatory and static forces, and the stiffness of
Pasternak foundation on the system stability were investigated. The
results of this study are in agreement with those of the available literature. The following illustrations are obtained from the study:
• Continuous entrance and exit of nanoparticles along the DWCNTs
•
may lead to instability of the DWCNT for some values of mass and
velocity of the passing nanoparticles.
When the inter-layer vdW forces are taken into account in the
12
Mechanics of Materials 142 (2020) 103279
M. Pirmoradian, et al.
Oveissi, S., Toghraie, D., Eftekhari, S.A., Chamkha, A.J., 2019. Instabilities of SWCNT
conveying laminar, incompressible and viscous fluid flow: effects of Knudsen
number, the Winkler, the Pasternak elastic and the viscoelastic medium. Int. J.
Numer. Methods Heat Fluid Flow.
Pirmoradian, M., Karimpour, H., 2017. Parametric resonance and jump analysis of a beam
subjected to periodic mass transition. Nonlinear Dyn. 89, 2141–2154.
Pirmoradian, M., Keshmiri, M., Karimpour, H., 2014. Instability and resonance analysis of
a beam subjected to moving mass loading via incremental harmonic balance method.
J. Vibroeng. 16, 2779–2789.
Pirmoradian, M., Keshmiri, M., Karimpour, H., 2015. On the parametric excitation of a
Timoshenko beam due to intermittent passage of moving masses: instability and resonance analysis. Acta Mech 226, 1241–1253.
Pirmoradian, M., Torkan, E., Abdali, N., Hashemian, M., Toghraie, D., 2019. Thermomechanical stability of single-layered graphene sheets embedded in an elastic
medium under action of a moving nanoparticle. Mech. Mater., 103248.
Pirmoradian, M., Torkan, E., Karimpour, H., 2018. Parametric resonance analysis of
rectangular plates subjected to moving inertial loads via IHB method. Int. J. Mech.
Sci. 142, 191–215.
Pourseifi, M., Rahmani, O., Hoseini, S.A.H., 2015. Active vibration control of nanotube
structures under a moving nanoparticle based on the nonlocal continuum theories.
Meccanica 50, 1351–1369.
Rezapour, B., Araghi, M.A.F., 2019a. Nanoparticle delivery through single walled carbon
nanotube subjected to various boundary conditions. Microsyst. Technol. 25,
1345–1356.
Rezapour, B., Araghi, M.A.F., 2019b. Semi-analytical investigation on dynamic response
of viscoelastic single-walled carbon nanotube in nanoparticle delivery. J. Braz. Soc.
Mech. Sci. Eng. 41, 117.
Şimşek, M., 2010. Vibration analysis of a single-walled carbon nanotube under action of a
moving harmonic load based on nonlocal elasticity theory. Phys. E Low-dimensional
Syst. Nanostruct. 43, 182–191.
Torkan, E., Pirmoradian, M., 2019. Efficient higher-order shear deformation theories for
instability analysis of plates carrying a mass moving on an elliptical path. J. Solid
Mech. https://doi.org/10.22034/JSM.2019.668763.
Torkan, E., Pirmoradian, M., Hashemian, M., 2017. Occurrence of parametric resonance
in vibrations of rectangular plates resting on elastic foundation under passage of
continuous series of moving masses. Modares Mech. Eng. 17, 225–236.
Torkan, E., Pirmoradian, M., Hashemian, M., 2018. On the parametric and external resonances of rectangular plates on an elastic foundation traversed by sequential
masses. Arch. Appl. Mech. 88, 1411–1428.
Torkan, E., Pirmoradian, M., Hashemian, M., 2019a. Instability inspection of parametric
vibrating rectangular Mindlin plates lying on Winkler foundations under periodic
loading of moving masses. Acta Mech. Sin. 35, 242–263.
Torkan, E., Pirmoradian, M., Hashemian, M., 2019b. Dynamic instability analysis of
moderately thick rectangular plates influenced by an orbiting mass based on the firstorder shear deformation theory. Modares Mech. Eng. 19, 2203–2213.
Tylikowski, A., 2008. Instability of thermally induced vibrations of carbon nanotubes.
Arch. Appl. Mech. 78, 49–60.
Wang, X., Shen, J.X., Liu, Y., Shen, G.G., Lu, G., 2012. Rigorous van der Waals effect on
vibration characteristics of multi-walled carbon nanotubes under a transverse magnetic field. Appl. Math. Model. 36, 648–656.
Yang, F., Chong, A.C.M., Lam, D.C.C., Tong, P., 2002. Couple stress based strain gradient
theory for elasticity. Int. J. Solids Struct. 39, 2731–2743.
actuated MEMS resonators. Int. J. Eng. Sci. 71, 137–155.
Gholipour, A., Farokhi, H., Ghayesh, M.H., 2015. In-plane and out-of-plane nonlinear
size-dependent dynamics of microplates. Nonlinear Dyn. 79, 1771–1785.
Gurtin, M.E., Murdoch, A.I., 1978. Surface stress in solids. Int. J. Solids Struct. 14,
431–440.
Hashemi, S.H., Khaniki, H.B., 2018. Dynamic response of multiple nanobeam system
under a moving nanoparticle. Alexandria Eng. J. 57, 343–356.
He, X.Q., Eisenberger, M., Liew, K.M., 2006. The effect of van der Waals interaction
modeling on the vibration characteristics of multiwalled carbon nanotubes. J. Appl.
Phys. 100, 124317.
Hołubowski, R., Glabisz, W., Jarczewska, K., 2019. Transverse vibration analysis of a
single-walled carbon nanotube under a random load action. Phys. E Low-dimensional
Syst. Nanostruct. 109, 242–247.
Iijima, S., 1991. Helical microtubules of graphitic carbon. Nature 354, 56–58.
Karimpour, H., Pirmoradian, M., Keshmiri, M., 2016. Instance of hidden instability traps
in intermittent transition of moving masses along a flexible beam. Acta Mech 227,
1213–1224.
Karličić, D., Kozić, P., Pavlović, R., Nešić, N., 2017. Dynamic stability of single-walled
carbon nanotube embedded in a viscoelastic medium under the influence of the
axially harmonic load. Compos. Struct. 162, 227–243.
Kazemirad, S., Ghayesh, M.H., Amabili, M., 2013. Thermo-mechanical nonlinear dynamics of a buckled axially moving beam. Arch. Appl. Mech. 83, 25–42.
Ke, L.-.L., Wang, Y.-.S., 2011. Flow-induced vibration and instability of embedded doublewalled carbon nanotubes based on a modified couple stress theory. Phys. E Lowdimensional Syst. Nanostruct. 43, 1031–1039.
Kiani, K., 2014. Nonlinear vibrations of a single-walled carbon nanotube for delivering of
nanoparticles. Nonlinear Dyn. 76, 1885–1903.
Kiani, K., Roshan, M., 2019. Nonlocal dynamic response of double-nanotube-systems for
delivery of lagged-inertial-nanoparticles. Int. J. Mech. Sci. 152, 576–595.
Kiani, K., Wang, Q., 2012. On the interaction of a single-walled carbon nanotube with a
moving nanoparticle using nonlocal Rayleigh, Timoshenko, and higher-order beam
theories. Eur. J. Mech. 31, 179–202.
Lam, D.C.C., Yang, F., Chong, A.C.M., Wang, J., Tong, P., 2003. Experiments and theory
in strain gradient elasticity. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 51, 1477–1508.
Lee, H.-.L., Chang, W.-.J., 2010. Dynamic modelling of a single-walled carbon nanotube
for nanoparticle delivery. Proc. R. Soc. A Math. Phys. Eng. Sci. 467, 860–868.
Lei, X., Natsuki, T., Shi, J., Ni, Q., 2012. Surface effects on the vibrational frequency of
double-walled carbon nanotubes using the nonlocal Timoshenko beam model.
Compos. Part B Eng. 43, 64–69.
Liu, H., Lv, Z., 2018. Vibration and instability analysis of flow-conveying carbon nanotubes in the presence of material uncertainties. Phys. A Stat. Mech. Appl. 511,
85–103.
Lü, L., Hu, Y., Wang, X., 2015. Forced vibration of two coupled carbon nanotubes conveying lagged moving nano-particles. Phys. E Low-dimensional Syst. Nanostruct. 68,
72–80.
Nayfeh, A.H., Mook, D.T., 1979. Nonlinear Oscillations. John Wiley.
Oveissi, S., Eftekhari, S.A., Toghraie, D., 2016. Longitudinal vibration and instabilities of
carbon nanotubes conveying fluid considering size effects of nanoflow and nanostructure. Phys. E Low-dimensional Syst. Nanostruct. 83, 164–173.
Oveissi, S., Toghraie, D.S., Eftekhari, S.A., 2018. Investigation on the effect of axially
moving carbon nanotube, nanoflow, and Knudsen number on the vibrational behavior of the system. Int. J. Fluid Mech. Res. 45.
13