Geogr. Fis. Dinam. Quat.
41 (2018). 65-79, 12 figg., 2 tabb.
DOI 10.4461/ GFDQ.2018.41.13
GIUSEPPE MASTRONUZZI 1,2*, MAURILLIO MILELLA 2, ARCANGELO PISCITELLI 2,
ORONZO SIMONE 3, GIANLUCA QUARTA 4, TEODORO SCARANO 5,6,
LUCIO CALCAGNILE 4 & ITALO SPADA 7
LANDSCAPE ANALYSIS IN TORRE GUACETO AREA (BRINDISI)
AIMED AT THE RECONSTRUCTION
OF THE LATE HOLOCENE SEA LEVEL CURVE
ABSTRACT: M ASTRONUZZI M., MILELLA M., PISCITELLI A., SIMONE
O., QUARTA G., SCARANO T., CALCAGNILE L. & SPADA I., Landscape analysis in Torre Guaceto area (Brindisi) aimed at the reconstruction of the late
Holocene sea level curve. (IT ISSN 0391-9838, 2018).
This paper focuses on four different cores drilled in the Area
Marina Protetta e Riserva dello Stato di Torre Guaceto (Carovigno,
Brindisi). The stratigraphic, sedimentological and paleontological
characteristics were related to the geomorphologic features of the
whole area and to the radiometric dating of the peaty levels identified in the stratigraphic sequence; the results have been compared
with the available geo-archaeological data. The complete data-set
allowed to reconstruct the succession of sedimentary environments
over time and to place these across the last 2200 years, thanks to
radiometric dating. In the stratigraphic sequence, it was possible to
highlight layers that indicate coastal areas marked by the presence
1 Dipartimento di Scienze della Terra e Geoambientali, Università degli Studi di Bari “Aldo Moro”, Bari, Italy.
2 Environmental Surveys s.r.l., Taranto, Italy.
3 SIGEA Puglia.
4 CEDAD, Centre for Dating and Diagnostics, Department of Mathematics and Physics “Ennio de Giorgi”, Università del Salento, Lecce, Italy.
5 Dipartimento di Beni Culturali, Università del Salento, Lecce, Italy.
6 Consorzio di Gestione dell’AMP Torre Guaceto, Carovigno, Brindisi.,
Italy.
7 CETMA, Engineering, Design & Materials Technologies Centre,
Brindisi, Italy.
* Corresponding author: GIUSEPPE M ASTRONUZZI, giuseppeantonio.
mastronuzzi@uniba.it
This paper is the result of a productive collaboration between CETMA and Environmental Survey s.r.l., the Natural Reserve and Protected
Marine Area of Torre Guaceto and the Dipartimento di Scienze della Terra
e Geoambientali of Università degli Studi di Bari. This last research unit
has been involved in the framework of the Project COFIN MIUR 20102011 “Response of morphoclimatic system dynamics to global changes and
related geomorphological hazard” (Nat. Resp.: C. Baroni; Local Resp.; G.
Mastronuzzi), carried out under the umbrella of the l’IGCP Project n. 639
“Sea-level change from minutes to millennia” (Project Leaders: S. Engelhart, G. Hoffmann, F. Yu and A. Rosentau).
We are thankful to the anonymous reviewers for their useful comments
and precious suggestions to improve the present paper, as well as to Prof.ssa
Angela Teatino for her contribution to improve the English text.
of inlets in connection with the sea, areas submerged during tides and
brackish or continental areas. In particular, the research demonstrated, with good approximation, that the sea level had to be stationed at
about -1.1 ± 0.1 m approximately 2200 years BP; then it went to about
-0.65 ± 0.1 m about 1900 years BP and continued its rise to the current
position. Finally, the comparison of the stratigraphic data with the
geophysical predicted sea level curve for the late Holocene indicates
that vertical movements in this span of time did not affect this area.
This confirms what has recently been established for this area as regards the stability of the Adriatic side of the Apulian foreland.
KEY WORDS: sea level change; coastal landscape, coastal environment, Torre Guaceto, Puglia, Italy
RIASSUNTO: M ASTRONUZZI M., MILELLA M., PISCITELLI A., SIMONE
O., QUARTA G., SCARANO T., CALCAGNILE L. & SPADA I., Analisi del paesaggio di Torre Guaceto (Brindisi) per la ricostruzione delle variazioni tardo
oloceniche del livello del mare. (IT ISSN 0391-9838, 2018).
Nell’Area Marina protetta e Riserva dello Stato di Torre Guaceto,
presso Carovigno in Provincia di Brindisi, sono stati realizzati quattro
differenti carotaggi. Le caratteristiche stratigrafiche, sedimentologiche e della malacofauna contenuta sono state messe in relazione con
quelle geomorfologiche dell’area di studio e con datazioni radiometriche di livelli di torba provenienti dai carotaggi, oltre che correlate con
dati geoarcheologici derivanti da studi precedenti. L’insieme dei dati
disponibili ha permesso di ricostruire la successione degli ambienti
sedimentari nel tempo e di collocare questi, grazie alle datazioni radiometriche, negli ultimi 2200 anni circa. Aree costiere segnate dalla
presenza di insenature in connessione con il mare, aree inondate durante le maree e aree salmastre o schiettamente continentali sono riconoscibili nei carotaggi. In particolare, è possibile affermare con buona approssimazione che il livello del mare dovette stazionare a circa
-1.1 ± 0.1 m circa 2200 anni dal presente per poi passare a circa
-0.65 ± 0.1 m circa 1900 anni e quindi continuare la sua risalita sino
alla posizione attuale. Infine, il confronto con le più recenti curve di
variazioni del livello del mare relative al tardo Olocene indicano che
quest’area non è stata interessata da movimenti verticali in questo intervallo di tempo, confermando quanto recentemente appurato per
questa zona dell’avampaese Apulo.
TERMINI CHIAVE: variazioni del livello del mare, paesaggio costiero;
ambiente costiero, Torre Guaceto, Puglia, Italia.
INTRODUCTION
The instantaneous sea level derives from the equilibrium between the water mass available for the oceanic basins and the land movements. Water quantity is a function
of the ice caps extension, which is influenced by climatic
changes. At different time scale, geodynamic, tectonic and
climatic factors – these last ones, up to the recent, only astronomically conditioned – all together define the global
(eustatic) and local (relative) sea level and draw the coastal
landscape. Its articulation and extension are both functions
of the continental and marine processes that discharge
their energy depending on the sea level position, which defines the morphological diversity of the coastal area and a
series of condition for the biological activity (e.g.: Cowell
& Thom, 1994; Mastronuzzi & alii, 2005; 2017a; Mastronuzzi & Sansò, 2006 and references therein). The Earth
movements and changing geodynamic and climatic factors cause the constant changes in the sea level: this never
stabilizes all along the coasts of the whole world (Mörner,
1986). The coastal landscape records the local (relative)
sea level changes; in the case of tectonically stable areas, it
corresponds to the eustatic one. Conservative coasts like lagoons, marshes and swamps keep traces of sea level change
in the sedimentary sequences, whereas sea movements and
bioactivities sculpture rocky coasts. Both those coastal
systems derive their structure from a temporary stability
of the balance of mass and energy connected to every sea
level standing during a long-term eustatic change (e.g.: Antonioli & alii, 2015). This is due to ice caps melting, which
can cause significant sea level changes, up to one hundred
and fifty meters of within some thousands of years. The
corresponding sea level defined in a limited coastal area
derives from the sum of the eustatic contributions with the
glacio-hydro isostasy and tectonics components (Lambeck
& Purcell, 2005; Lambeck & alii, 2004; 2011). The last 20
ka of the history of the Earth have been characterised by a
general warming that caused the melting of the continental ice caps and the world wide rapid eustatic sea level rise
from the LGM up to about 6/7 ka BP (e.g.: Antonioli & alii,
2009). During the initial phase, the coastal landscape was
quickly built, submerged and destroyed, whereas during
the last 6 millennia the decrease of the sea level rise rate
allowed the gradual submersion of the coastal landscape
and, when possible, its slow inland migration.
This last phenomenon – more or less explained by Bruun’s model (Bruun, 1962) and other theories (e.g.: Lorenzo-Trueba & alii, 2014) – was possible in particular for the
“mobile coasts” characterised by the presence of beachdune systems, lagoons, marshes, swamps, river mouths,
coastal plains and lakes, functionally related to each others.
The coasts of the Mediterranean basin do not represent an
exception and there are several studies that highlight how
coastal surveys can identify sea level history, environmental
changes, impact of tsunamis and storms in conservative environments (e.g.: De Martini & alii, 2003, 2010; Amorosi &
alii, 2004; Caldara & Simone, 2005; Switzer & Jones, 2008;
Vott & alii, 2008; Primavera & alii, 2011; Di Rita & alii,
2011; Smedile & alii, 2011; Orru & alii, 2014 and references
therein). The predictive geophysical model based on mul66
tidisciplinary surveys of the sea level markers, chronologically attributed to the Holocene transgression, generally
confirms the recent sea level history (Lambeck & alii, 2004,
2011). On the other hand, in order to improve the dataset
that allowed its construction, more detailed field surveys
are needed; geological, geomorphological and archaeological sea level markers together with well defined chronological constrains (radiometric or archaeological ones) can
contribute to a better definition of the predictive relative
sea level model (e.g.: Auriemma & Solinas, 2009; Anzidei &
alii, 2011, Mastronuzzi & alii, 2017b and references therein). This research approach may be particularly effective if
the data used in the study come from areas considered stable at long time scale. In the context of the Mediterranean
basin, which is really complex from a geodynamic point
of view (e.g.: Anzidei & alii, 2014), the Adriatic side of the
Murgia plateau – part of the Apulian foreland – might play
a key role in the study of the Holocene sea level change due
to its stability at medium-long time scale. The presence of
archaeological coastal sites and the microtidal regime allow estimating the sea level change along the rocky coasts
with a small error bar (e.g.: Mastronuzzi & Sansò, 2002a,
Ferranti & alii, 2006; Antonioli & alii, 2009; Mastronuzzi
& alii, 2017b). On the other hand, due to the prevalence of
rocky coasts in this area, until now there has been no study
by using cores derived from wetlands, with the exception
of the rich – but local – dataset from the Gargano Promontory, Tavoliere delle Puglia plain to the North (Caldara
& alii, 2008; Caldara & Simone, 2005; Di Rita & alii, 2011)
and from the Alimini Lakes in the Southernmost Salento
(Primavera & alii, 2011). When compared to the Murgia
area, both these areas seem to have had different geodynamic behaviours during the Pleistocene and, maybe, also
during the Holocene.
In the following page, an interdisciplinary dataset (geological, radiometric, paleontological and morphological)
deriving from news surveys performed in the wetlands of
the Natural Reserve and Protected Marine Area of Torre
Guaceto (Carovigno, Brindisi) (fig. 1) is presented and analyzed together with some data deriving from the geoarchaeological studies carried out recently along the Adriatic side
of the Murgia Plateau (Milella & alii, 2006; Scarano & alii,
2008; Scarano & Guglielmino, 2017; Mastronuzzi & alii,
2017b and references therein). The following pages aim to:
FIG. 1 - Location of studied area.
i) recognize the change in physical landscape; ii) reconstruct the sea level history of the South Adriatic; iii) validate the efficiency of the most recent regional geophysical
model of relative sea level changes.
GEOMORPHOLOGIC FEATURES
AND HUMAN SETTLEMENTS
The Natural Reserve and Protected Marine Area of
Torre Guaceto (fig. 2) extends for about 1000 ha inland
and 2000 ha seaward along 8 km of the Adriatic coast of
Apulia on the limit between three well defined morphological areas: the Murge plateau inland and the pediment
of Fasano and the Brindisi plain seaward; these last two
are separated by the Canale Reale river that crosses over
the Torre Guaceto area (Mastronuzzi & alii, 2011; Mastronuzzi & Sansò, 2017).
To the North of Canale Reale, the landscape is dominated by a low climbed surface which extends from the
feet of the Murgia scarp to the sea level shaped on the Mesozoic unit of the Calcari di Bari and on the Cenozoic unit
of Calcarenite di Gravina Fm (Late Pliocene - Early Pleistocene); seaward, the surface is covered discontinuously by
more recent deposits which consist of a cemented beachdune system ascribed to the last interglacial time (LIT), in
turn ascribed to the high sea level stand occurred on 125
ka (Late Pleistocene, MIS 5.5). The surface and the body of
Calcarenite di Gravina Fm are crossed by well-defined incisions that show the features of “box valleys” due to sapping
processes (Mastronuzzi & Sansò, 2002a), locally named
“lame”. Seaward, sapping valleys cut the Pleistocene sedimentary cover and the LIT dune belts – beach sediments;
this indicates that they were formed due to the increase of
FIG. 2 - The promontory of Torre Guaceto is sculptured on a sequence
of Calcarenite di Gravina (Late Pliocene - Early Pleistocene) overlayered
by a younger calcarenite ascribed to the Late Pleistocene - Tyrrhenian
(generic MIS5). On the left is the marsh-swamp area and in the back is
the inlets with pocket beaches.
the relief energy, caused by the lowering of the sea level, which was connected to the cooling of the last glacial
time (LGT). Sapping valleys are well distinct also below
the present sea level, as for example just below the tower
that gives the name to the studied area. They extend up to
a depth probably corresponding to the interface between
the Mesozoic and Cenozoic units. Their maximum shaping
may correspond to the lowermost sea level stand occurred
about 20 ka BP during the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM).
The relative frequency of these incisions draws a very indented coastline locally named “costa merlata” (= crowned
coast) marked by narrow and deep inlets (fig. 2). Usually,
they host small beaches, surrounded inland by low dunes
(Mastronuzzi & Sansò, 2002b).
To the south of the Canale Reale, Calcarenite di Gravina Fm is covered by Middle Pleistocene sandy-silt units
and, on top of those, by the beach-dune system of the LIT.
In this area the coastline is more regular and marked by
cliffs, not higher than 3 m, in rapid regression. The relict of the beach system of the MIS 5.5 constitutes the top
of the small islands placed along the Torre Guaceto area,
since they were isolated by the sea level rise during the
last phases of the Holocene transgression. Where inlets
are larger, poliphasic stationary beach-dune systems tend
to isolate coastal lakes; they are represented by aeolianites
partially cemented, ascribed to three phases of dune shaping occurred since the Middle Holocene (Mastronuzzi &
Sansò, 2002b).
During the Bronze Age and the historical time, inlets
facilitated the maritime traffic allowing the use of sheltered areas to load/unload ships used for coastal trade
and supply of fresh water. The uninterrupted human
occupation from the Bronze Age up to the Middle Ages
along the Adriatic coasts of the Murge plateau allows us
to collect numerous archaeological markers of the past
sea level stands useful in the reconstruction of its history
(e.g.: Auriemma & alii, 2005; Scarano & alii, 2008; Mastronuzzi & alii, 2017b). In particular, Torre Guaceto has
been well known as a safe harbour since ancient times;
the name seems to derive from the arabic word gawsit that
means “place of the fresh water” supplied by the springs,
the extended marshes and the Apani and Reale streams
(Scarano & alii, 2008). In the 2nd millennium BC walled
settlements were placed in the areas of the present Torre
Guaceto promontory and Scogli di Apani islets that towered over the salt and swampy territories (Mastronuzzi
& alii, 2017b). Hundreds of postholes of varying shapes
and sizes occur along the washed and eroded coastal profiles, now some centimetres below the current mean sea
level, testifying to the presence of large villages during
the Bronze Age. In most recent times, sandstone quarries
dating to the Late Middle Ages were carved in coastal
zones and right now they are some centimetres below the
mean current sea level. Both these archaeological remains
suggest that mean sea level was about 2.25 ± 0.2 m below
the current one at 3.5 ka BP and about 0.9 ± 0.2 m below
the current one between the 1st Century BC and 1500 AD
(Mastronuzzi & alii, 2017b).
67
MATERIAL AND METHODS
Immediately behind the promontory that hosts Torre
Guaceto (fig. 2), there is a marsh area limited by beaches
with low dunes. The area was extensively reclaimed during
the last century; so, stratigraphically, it does not contain natural features although the wildness of its current biological
environments. The only area never involved in the reclamation process is placed on its southern limit, at the border
of Canale Reale. This area has been chosen to coring up to
the local basement. In the entire area, four different cores
(fig. 3; tab. 1) have been drilled; only in correspondence of
the site TGS3 and TGS4 it was possible to reach the Calcarenie di Gravina formation. Cores have been drilled using
a “Peatsampler set Eijkelkamp”; this tool allows to collect
different samples of 0.5 m each. The longest core (TGS4 –
about 2.5 m below the present topographic surface = b.p.t.s.)
is the sum of three different segments made by levelling
each base to the top of the closest and deepest one (fig. 4).
FIG. 3 - Coring sites location.
Both data collection and analysis were carried out
through six succeeding steps: i) elevation measurements of
the topographic surface on which core were drilled; ii) tidal
correction of the elevations at the time of surveys, using
sea level data from the Italian tide gauge network (www.
idromare.it); iii) paleontological analysis of the level documented in the core; iv) AMS age determinations of the peat
documented in the level that suggested a sea level stand; v)
correlation of the observed sea levels with the bibliographic data on sea level changes supplied by archaeological
indicators; vi) comparison of the obtained sea level curve
with the geophysical models (Lambeck & alii, 2004, 2011).
The elevation of the top of the cores has been determined with respect to the instantaneous sea level using
optical and mechanical instruments in condition of calm
sea; this aimed at the georeferencing by DGPS technique
of each core that was performed.
The studied area, as all the Apulian coast, has the micro-tidal features of the majority of the Mediterranean basin; here the tidal range is within 0.45 cm (www.idromare.
it). In order to reduce the topographical elevation data
to a local mean sea level, tidal data from the nearest tide
gauge station located in Bari were used during the surveys.
The mean sea level of the Bari tide gauge station has been
chosen after a correction of the instantaneous sea level in
function of the barometric features surveyed at the time
of the coring, according to the methodology proposed by
Anzidei & alii (2011). In particular, core TGS4 was drilled
at 09.45 local time (07.45 London GMT) on 2015, June 23
(fig. 5); the top of the core was at + 0.52 m above the instantaneous sea level in condition of high pressure (about
1017 hPa). The hydrometric sea level in tide gauge station
of Bari is lower of that ISPRA of about 0.25 m. This means
that at the moment of the sampling the core top was 0.12 m
above the local mean sea level. Considering the local tidal
range, the core was sampled in the intertidal area. Moreover, the compaction due to the coring activities suggests
that the depth of the samples could be considered with
respect to the local mean sea level with a vertical error bar
of ± 0.1 m.
In the third phase, the stratigraphic description of the
sampled corers has been limited to the core TGS4 (for a total lenght of about 2.5 m) and to the core TGS3 (for a lenght
of 1.0 m corresponding to the lowest section of core TGS4)
TABLE 1 - Observational data for the analyzed sites; depth must be considered with an error bar of about ± 0.1 m (see text) (a.i.s.l. = above instantaneous
sea level; a.p.m.s.l. above current mean sea level referred to the ISPRA).
Core
Latitude
(N)
Longitude
(E Gr)
Environment
TGS4c
TGS4b
TGS4a
TGS3
TGS1
TGS2
40° 42’ 17”
40° 42’ 17”
40° 42’ 17”
40° 42’ 18”
40° 42’ 53”
40° 42’ 24”
17° 48’ 22”
17° 48’ 22”
17° 48’ 22”
17° 48’ 23”
17° 47’ 54”
17° 48’ 12”
dune crest
dune base
shoreface
submerged beach
back beach
marsh
68
Surveyed
elevation
(m a.i.s.l.)
1.5
0.7
0.52
-0.3
0.6
0.7
Corrected
elevation
(m a.p.m.s.l.)
1.12
0.32
0.12
-0.42
0.2
0.3
Depth
(m)
Local basement
1.15
1.0
0.35
-
TGS4b
TGS4a
Calcarenite di Gravina Fm
Calcarenite di Gravina Fm
Late Pleistocene calcarenite
vegetation
FIG. 4 - Schematic relation between
different cores.
FIG. 5 - Area in which core TGS4
was drilled; in the insert a sketch of
the relations between TGS4a, b and
c segments are shown (horizontal
scale is only indicative).
(figg. 6 and 7). They have been collected respectively on the
present shore face/dune area and in the submerged beach.
Afterwards, detailed descriptive analyses were carried out
on the TSG4 core, due to the complete correspondence between the stratigraphy identifiable in the TGS4c segment
and to the TGS3 core. Different levels have been identified
due to their macroscopic features like difference in colour
and granulometry, content in malacofauna, etc. Samples
have been collected for every change in these features and,
in particular, in correspondence of presumable organic levels marked by dark grey/black colour or shells. When apparent homogeneity represented a significant thickness of
the stratigraphy, more samples at different depth were collected. A total of 25 samples were analysed for an average
distribution of 1 sample every 0.1 m (fig. 6b) investigating
faunal assemblage for environmental reconstruction and, in
case of environments indicative of the sea level, to identify
materials which could be useful for 14C age determinations.
Samples have been wet-sieved in fresh water without any use
of chemicals to avoid the destruction of the organic components. They were sifted using 500 µm and 63 µm pore sieves.
The coarsest fraction was used for the study of macro-fossiliferous assemblages, essentially malacofauna; the finest was
examined for the study of the microfauna represented by
foraminifera and ostracods. The entire assemblage allowed
identifying four different levels that suggest the sea level
with an elevated approximation and a low error bar. Samples of “peat” derived by them were submitted for AMS age
determinations (tab. 2).
Their age has been established by means of AMS (Accelerator Mass Spectrometry) radiocarbon determinations
performed at CEDAD (Centre for Dating and Diagnostics),
at the University of Salento (Calcagnile & alii, 2004).
The analysis of the selected samples by means of an
optical microscope allowed highlighting the possible presence of particles of contaminants and exogenous mate69
A
FIG. 6 - A) part of the TGS4 core still in the peat sampler and B) the
entire TGS4a core from the bottom (left) to the top (right) on which
analyzed samples are indicated.
rials, which were removed by handpicking. The samples
were then chemically processed following the protocol
employed for organic sediments and consisting in a first
strong acid attack with HCl in order to remove the inorganic, carbonatic fraction followed by an alkali (NaOH)
and a final acid (HCl) attack. From all the selected samples
it was possible to extract a quantity of organic material
sufficient for the AMS analysis. The AMS analysis were
carried out with the 3MVTandetron accelerator installed
at CEDAD (Calcagnile & alii, 2005) on the graphite obtained through the catalytic reduction of the carbon dioxide obtained from the combustion at 900 °C of the purified
fraction of the samples (D’Elia & alii, 2004). Conventional radiocarbon ages were calculated from the measured
14C/12C ratios after correction for machine and processing background and isotopic fractionation as detailed by
Stuiver & Polach (1977). Measurement uncertainty was
calculated as the largest between the scattering of the ten
repeated measurements carried out on each sample and
the radiocarbon counting error (tab. 2).
STRATIGRAPHY AND ENVIRONMENTS
RECONSTRUCTION
The core TGS4 (fig. 6) cuts a Holocene sediment succession overlying the local basement (Calcarenite di Gravi70
na Fm). The succession (fig. 7) could be split in two intervals; the lower (up to about 0.4 m a.p.m.s.l., samples 1-18)
is characterised by a succession of alternating clay, silty
clay, silt and fine sand, interbedded with thin dark horizons, mostly made of vegetal organic matter, whose aspect
recalls a peat accumulation. The most recent part of the
succession (samples 19-25) turned out to be made of loose
fine and medium-sized sand.
The stratigraphic sequence is described from the bottom to the top as follows. Several among the most representative biological remains are shown in figg. 8-11.
1) Section 1 (samples 1-4): shallow brackish water environment.
Grayish mud and fine sand horizons thickly interbedded with organic deposits. Locally the sediment is made
up of partially decomposed vegetal material (e.g., samples
1 and 4).
Mollusc assemblages are rich in individuals belonging
to few species. The gastropods found are mainly attributable to the Hydrobiidae Family, among which were identified Hydrobia acuta and Ecrobia ventrosa. Young specimens
of Cerastoderma glaucum, Abra cf. segmentum and fragments of Lucinidae represent bivalves; rounded (worn-out)
fragments of larger valves testify to the presence of adult
individuals of these species.
The microfauna is characterised by poor assemblages
(few individuals and few species). Foraminifera are mainly
FIG. 7 - Stratigraphy, paleontological data
and paleogeographic reconstruction of the
entire TGS4 sequence. Red dottes indicate
the position of dated samples.
TABLE 2 - Summary of radiocarbon dating analyses. Calibration were performed using CALIB 7.1 (Stuiver & alii, 2018).
Section
Laboraty
Code
Material
Elevation
m (m.s.l)
Conventional
14C age (BP)
δ13 (‰)
Calibrated 14C age
(2s)
TGS4 C13
7
LTL16023
peat
-0.3 ± 0.1
1782 ± 45
-21.3 ± 0.6
128 AD - 356 AD (93.6%)
366 AD - 380 AD ( 1.8%)
TGS4 C11
5
LTL17353A
peat
-0.65 ± 0.1
1895± 45
-24.9 ± 0.1
79 BC - 220 AD (95.2%)
TGS4 C10
5
LTL16022A
peat
-0.75 ± 0.1
2416 ± 45
-25.3 ± 0.5
752 BC - 682 BC (18.1%)
669 BC - 612 BC ( 9.6%)
593 BC - 399 BC (67.7%)
TGS4 C1
1
LTL16021A
peat
-1.10 ± 0.1
2220 ± 45
-23.3 ± 0.5
390 BC - 184 BC (95.4%)
Sample
71
represented by young tests referable to opportunistic taxa.
In particular, Ammonia beccarii is dominant on Haynesina
sp., Elphidium cf. excavatum and Rosalina sp.; frequently,
A. beccarii tests show irregular coiling and an abnormal
proloculus size.
Ostracods are mainly represented by valves of Cyprideis
torosa belonged to organisms of different ages.
A few vegetal remains have been found scattered within
the clayey deposits. These are mainly represented by a few
oogonia of the Characeae green algae and seeds of Ruppia
maritima water plant (samples 3 and 4).
The assemblages found in this section could suggest the
main features of the original accumulation environment.
H. acuta is herbivorous and feeds on aquatic plants, sandy
and muddy bottoms (Evagelopoulos & alii, 2009). Due to
its adaptability, this species can thrive under a large range
of salinity conditions and it is commonly found in coastal
water bodies such as lagoons, estuaries, hyperhaline ponds
and fully marine conditions (Britton, 1985; Evagelopoulos & alii, 2007, 2009). E. ventrosa (= Hydrobia ventrosa)
is frequently found in mesohaline waters, such as brackish
lagoons (Giusti & Pezzoli, 1984). These two Hydrobiidae
species frequently live together (Barnes, 2005) in water basins characterised by a salinity ranging from 2‰ to 34‰,
even if they prefer the narrower range 6‰ - 25‰ (Fretter
& Graham, 1978).
Bivalves C. glaucum and A. segmentum are widespread
in brackish waters (Pérès & Picard, 1964; Picard, 1965;
Pérès, 1967). In particular, C. glaucum commonly lives in
water bodies characterised by a salinity between 18‰ and
37‰ (Vatova, 1981); A. segmentum lives in waters whose
salt content is between 14‰ and 27‰. Both species tolerate
water salinity as low as 5‰ (Cognetti & Maltagliati, 2000).
The foraminiferal assemblages are dominated by the
opportunistic Ammonia beccarii. The most represented
accompanying species are Rosalina sp., Haynesina sp. and
Elphidium cf. excavatum.
These foraminifers commonly live in brackish lagoons
and river mouths, but are also found in littoral marine
waters (Murray, 1991a, 1991b). In particular, A. beccarii is
considered an opportunistic species, capable to live (and
reproduce) in extreme environments, such as polluted areas, water bodies characterised by salinity fluctuations and
hyper saline basins (Boltovskoy & alii, 1991; Almogi-Labin
& alii, 1992, 1995; Stouff & alii, 1999, Pascual & alii, 2002).
The ostracoda are mostly represented by the dominant
euryhaline taxon C. torosa, usually considered a brackish
organism capable to live in environments characterised by
varying salinity over short (diurnal) timescales, as well as
adjusting to longer-term changes (Boomer & alii, 2017).
The other accompanying species are represented by a very
small number of individuals.
The plant R. maritima (whose presence is testified by
seeds; fig. 11) grows in clean, well oxygenated and shallow
water basins characterised by low hydrodynamics. Considered a brackish plant, it colonises water bodies with salinity
conditions ranging from 0‰ to 70‰ (Kantrud, 1991), but
do not tolerate quick fluctuations (La Peyree Rowe, 2003).
The Characeae algae (represented by a few oogonia) are
generally considered freshwater species.
72
All these pieces of evidence suggest that the original
accumulation environment was a brackish water body
characterised by the presence of sea grass meadows. The
presence of submerged vegetation is suggested by the occurrence of the foraminifer Rosalina sp., an epiphytic taxon
that lives attached to flat leaves and stems.
The occurrence of Characeae oogonia shows that freshwater environments were not too far from the sampling
place.
The collected evidence highlights that possible stress
factors affected the deposition environment. In fact, abnormal coiling patterns and few other growth anomalies
have been observed on a number of A. beccarii tests (fig. 9).
Specific studies proved that such kind of phenomena are
directly connected to a stressed environment (Boltovskoy
& alii, 1991; Almogi-Labin & alii, 1992; Stouff & alii, 1999;
Samir, 2000; Geslin & alii, 2002). Unfavourable life conditions are also suggested by the structure of faunal assemblages, characterised by few opportunistic species often
represented by juvenile individuals that were not able to
develop the adult stage.
In brief, the first investigated core section could have
been originated in a brackish water body characterised by
limited water exchange with the open sea, characterised by
environmental instability, possibly due to both natural pollution (decomposing organic matter, low oxygen levels) and
rapid fluctuations of salinity and bathymetry.
2) Section 2 (sample 5): subaerial environment close to a
brackish wetland.
This section is characterised by greyish silt with secondary weakly cemented calcium carbonate encrustations.
Scattered within the sediment, few shell fragments have
been found mostly belonging to the Hydrobiidae group.
Microfauna is represented by young specimens of the foraminifer A. beccarii and few C. torosa ostracods. The organisms found occur in small numbers, suggesting an environment not suitable to water life.
These horizons have been interpreted as accumulated in a subaerial environment bordering a brackish
wetland.
3) Section 3 (samples 6-7): intertidal environment bordering a brackish wetland.
Dark mud alternating with thin organic horizons made
up of vegetal detritus whose aspect recalls a somewhat
peaty deposit. The analysed samples (6 and 7) yielded a
macrofaunal assemblage characterised by a few species
belonging to the Hydrobiidae Family, among which the
brackish H. acuta, E. ventrosa and several Pseudamnicola
cf. conovula.
Microfauna is scarce, mostly represented by A. beccarii and Rosalina sp.; these species are accompanied by few
specimens of Trochammina inflata, several of them buried
in the early stages of life.
Ostracods are mainly represented by C. torosa at different stages of development, several exoskeletons still preserve coupled valves; a few shells of the freshwater species
Pseudocandona sp. have also been found.
FIG. 8 - The main recognised mollusc species that form the section 1
assemblages are: 1) Hydrobiidae; 2) Abra segmentum; 3) Cerastoderma
glaucum; the inset 4) shows how the samples appear after their preparation (scale: 2 mm).
FIG. 10 - Molluscs that characterise sections from 2 to 8; 1) Cochicella
barbara; 2) Pseudamnicola cf. conovula; 3) Planorbidae; 4) Ovatella myosotis; 5) Theodoxus fluviatilis; 6) Truncatella subcylindrica, juvenal (left) and
adult (right) (scale: 2 mm).
FIG. 11 - Seeds of plant like R. maritima and Characeae algae represented
by a few oogonia from the TGS4 core (scale: 1 mm).
FIG. 9 - Microfauna is characterised by a few species; the most represented are the foraminifers 1) A. beccarii; 2) several A. beccarii individuals
show abnormal tests; 3) T. inflata; 4) Haynesina sp.; 5) Rosalina sp.; 6) the
ostracod Cyprideis torosa (scale: 1 mm).
The faunal assemblage is characterised by few brackish species accompanied by freshwater organisms. This
information, together with the laminated aspect of the
deposit, suggests that this part of the succession accumulated in an intertidal zone periodically flooded by brackish waters.
The presence of T. inflata, one of the few intertidal foraminifers that live in flat muddy grounds slightly above the
mean sea level, covered by halophilic vegetation and periodically submerged by tide, allows a comparison with the
“barene” areas of the lagoon of Venice (Favero & Serandrei
Barbero, 1981; Serandrei Barbero & alii, 2004, 2011).
Finally, the occurrence of freshwater species suggests
the occasional inundation by inland waters, possibly channelled.
4) Section 4 (samples 8-9): subaerial environment close to a
brackish wetland.
This section shows alternating greyish mud and vegetal
detritus laminae with scattered biological remains (a few
tests of A. beccarii, most likely displaced).
5) Section 5 (sample 10): periodically submerged environment bordering a brackish wetland.
Light greyish mud with scattered lumps of partially decomposed vegetal detritus. The molluscs found are scattered shells of the Hydrobiidae P. cf. conovula. Foraminifers occur with small sized specimens of T. inflata. Several
juvenile ostracod valves (C. torosa) have been found. Characeae oogonia and R. maritima seeds represent few identifiable vegetal remains.
The poor biological assemblages suggest that the original accumulation environment was occasionally (perhaps
seasonally) submerged. The occurrence of T. inflata suggests the nearby presence of an intertidal area.
73
6) Section 6 (samples 11-12): brackish wetland.
This section could be subdivided into two intervals a
few centimetres thick. The lowest appears thickly laminated due to the presence of thin dark accumulations of partially decomposed vegetal detritus (sample 11); the upper
part is mainly constituted by greyish mud (sample 12).
The molluscan assemblages are dominated by the gastropod P. cf. conovula, the accompanying taxa are Teodoxus
fluviatilis, Ovatella myosotis and Truncatella subcylindrica.
The Planorbidae Family and the species Cochlicella barbara
are represented by just one specimen each.
Among the recognised molluscs, two taxa are capable
to bear extreme conditions. O. myosotis is commonly considered a typical inhabitant of saline environments (Cesari
1976; 1988). This gastropod is widespread, in emerged wetlands not far from water bodies (ponds, lagoons etc.), hiding under stones or dead vegetal remains; adult individuals
could tolerate a wide range of salinity (between 0‰ and
90‰). T. subcylindrica lives (often buried) on soft muddy
bottoms, in either subaqueous or occasionally submerged
environments whose salinity ranges from 18‰ to 40‰. It
can also be found under hips of decomposing vegetal remains (Fretter & Graham, 1978).
T. fluviatilis is considered an opportunistic species capable to thrive in fresh, brackish and fully marine waters,
feeding on flat surfaces such as stones or logs; it easily tolerate low oxygen conditions, but cannot stand long dry periods (Falkner & alii, 2001; Zettler & alii, 2004; Bunje, 2005).
Among the microfauna, the foraminifer Rosalina sp.
occurs in numbers; ostracods are mainly represented by
C. torosa, few individuals of Cyclocypris sp. and Darwinula
stevensoni have been also found.
Characeae algae are represented by few oogonia.
Aside from the occurrence of Rosalina sp., microfaunal
assemblages seem originated from a somewhat fresh (or
slightly brackish) wetland.
In brief, all these pieces of evidence suggest that the
original environment was a brackish wetland subjected to
periodic inundations from adjacent water bodies (either
fresh or saline). In particular, saltwater contribution is testified by the occurrence of brackish molluscs. The presence
of the sole foraminifer Rosalina sp. (a form living attached
on flat surfaces) could be supposed as due to the stranding,
from an adjacent brackish or marine environment, of either
algae or aquatic plants carrying foraminifers attached to
their leaves.
On the other hand, the occurrence of the ostracods Cyclocypris sp. and Darwinula stevensoni and of the green algae Characeae suggests freshwater inputs from the inland.
7) Section 7 (samples 13-15): periodically submerged environment bordering a brackish wetland.
Greyish mud horizons alternating with partially decomposed dark vegetal detritus. Part of the inorganic
components of the deposit is formed by calcium carbonate
granules, in some cases encrusting marine shells fragments
(sample 14).
Malacofauna is dominated by T. subcylindrica and O.
myosotis, several of them juvenile; a few P. cf. conovula
74
shells and C. barbara fragments have also been observed.
The number of shell fragments seems to decrease upward
(sample 15).
Foraminifers (T. inflata, Rosalina sp. and a number of
young unidentifiable individuals) are more represented in
the upper part of the section (samples 14 and 15).
Apart from several C. torosa specimens, most of ostracod valves belonged to some juvenile individuals not
easily identifiable.
Overall, faunal assemblages suggest that the paleoenvironment was a brackish wetland, possibly periodically
submerged by tide or by wave overflooding (compare to
Section 5).
Finally, from calcium carbonate encrustations that
characterise the sample 14 it is possible to hypothesize an
episodic super saturation of the interstitial waters caused
by a marked evaporation.
8) Section 8 (samples 16-18): subaerial environment close to
a brackish wetland.
The section 8 can be subdivided into three parts. The
lower tract is characterised by a thick succession of alternating greyish mud and thin dark organic laminae (sample
16). The middle part is made up of greyish laminated mud
that, upward, gradually becomes reddish in colour. Under
the stereo microscope the sample 18 (upper part of the section) resulted characterised by a number of scattered reddish lumps of residual red earth.
In the whole section the number of shell fragments
decreases upwards; the malacofauna resulted mainly composed of the brackish species O. myosotis and T. subcylindrica whose shells appear often intact and not worn, suggesting a negligible displacement.
Microfauna resulted scarcely represented; the few individuals found belong to the species A. beccarii and C.
torosa.
Faunal assemblages suggest an accumulation occurred
in a subaerial environment very close to a shallow brackish
water body.
The horizons of this section recorded the early phases
of accumulation of sediments originated inland (red earth
lumps) and washed inside the basin. The study of the very
upper part of the TGS4 core has confirmed this hypothesis.
9) Section 9 (samples 19-25): dry subaerial environment.
The most recent deposits of the studied succession are
made up of well-sorted loose fine sands. Bedding surfaces
are virtually invisible in the lower part of this interval (samples 19-22) but become apparent upcore (samples 23-25).
Biological remains are scarce and limited to the terrestrial O. myosotis, C. barbara, Pomatias elegans and fragments of Helicidae. Small charcoal fragments represent the
vegetal component. The nature of the sediment and the
concomitant occurrence of C. barbara (lives in dry and vegetated sandy environments not far from the coastline), P.
elegans (lives on calcareous grounds and sand dunes) and
Helicidae suggest that this section accumulated in a back
beach-sand dune environment.
DISCUSSION
The palaeontological, geochronological and topographic
dataset derived by the TGS4 core, the most representative of
the entire drill campaign, allows the morphodynamics evolution of the studied area also thanks to the possible direct
correlation with geoarchaeological data deriving from the
area of Torre Guaceto and the not far Torre Santa Sabina
locality (Carovigno), San Vito (Polignano) and Egnatia (Fasano), all placed at the foot of the Murgia plateau (Scarano &
alii, 2008; Mastronuzzi & alii, 2017b) (fig. 12).
The TGS4 core results from the sum of TGS4a, TGS4b
and TGS4c cores; it recorded the local evolution of the
sedimentary environments. The lower part of the succession (section 1) originated in an apparently well-established brackish water body characterised by a low but perhaps continuous water exchange with the open sea. The
accumulation continued through a series of environments
settled at the edge of a brackish wetland. In several cases,
these were muddy grounds periodically submerged by shallow brackish waters in intertidal area or by waves flooding
exceeding the beach and the embryonal dune (sections 3,
5, 7). In some cases, the accumulation occurred in subaerial
(muddy) grounds bordering a brackish wetland (sections
2, 4, 8). A single section of the investigated core originated
in a very shallow and brackish water body (section 6). The
upper part of the core (section 9) was created in a dry terrestrial environment.
In particular, the lower part of the sequence (sections
1-8) is characterised by soft fine and organic deposits containing remains of opportunistic species whose life is closely related to the paralic domain (either brackish shallow
water bodies or somewhat wet environments).
The undisturbed flat laminations, at some levels rich in
vegetal organic matter (often assuming the aspect of peaty
deposits), the lack of bioturbation (and/or deposit homogenisation), seem to point to a calm environment subjected
to rather reducing conditions that hampered the oxidation
of the organic compounds. In brief, collected evidence suggests that these sediments accumulated in a wetland dominated by low energy deposition processes. The section 8 recorded the early phases of changing accumulation mechanisms at the coring place. In the upper part of the TGS4 sequence the deposit became a fine reddish loose sand poor in
biological remains. The occurrence of terrestrial gastropods
and charcoal fragments shows that these deposits accumulated in a dry coastal environment either a beach or dune.
The transition between wet and dry environments appears
gradual, clearly appreciable, but seems not marked by any
erosion surface. Thus, it might be hypothesised that the reddish sand accumulated directly above the brackish horizons
without significant interruptions of sedimentation processes.
Actually, the reconstruction of the original sedimentary
environments allowed identifying some levels that should
correspond to the sea level stands with an error bar of ± 0.1
m. The lowermost (section 1) seems to correspond to an environment that had a continuous, although low, exchange
with the open sea. A peaty sample was collected from the
lowermost part of this section. Peaty sample submitted to
AMS age determinations on the section 1 (TGS4 C1) is the
most representative of the position of past sea level stands.
This may confirm the identifications of past sea levels with
an approximation of ± 0.1 m. The general features indicate
with good approximation the sea level. On the other hand,
sections 3, 5 and section 7 keep evidence of an environment
periodically submerged at the border of brackish wetland
suggesting a possible connection to the open sea during
the main tide.
FIG. 12 - Reconstruction of
the paleogeography of the
Torre Guaceto area during the
Bronze age (about 3.5 ka BP)
75
FIG. 13 - Aged samples that
indicate possible position of
the sea level reported on the
relative sea level curve for the
studied area fit with the geophysical predictive models.
The tonality of green dottes
indicates the largest (dark
green) or less (light green)
significance in the indication
of sea level; horizontal diameter indicates the error in
the age definition (± 45 years);
vertical diameter indicates the
error bar in elevation determination (± 0.1 m) (for explanation see text).
Samples were collected in these two sections but not
in the section 3 because of lack of material to be analyzed.
Samples from these levels were submitted to AMS age determinations; results are shown in tab. 2. Ages obtained from
samples TGS4 C1, C11 and C13 seem to be validated by
their gradual rejuvenation upward in the core stratigraphy;
unluckily, sample TGS4 C10 gave an age that seems to be
invalidated by possible re-accumulation. Moreover, it is important to underline that sample TGS4 C13 seems to be less
indicative of an intertidal area because of the presence of
fragments of marine shell may be re-accumulated not by tide
but, probably, by waves that exceeded the beach-dune system or imposed a temporary sea surge in the more sheltered
areas of a back dune/lagoon area derived by waves impact.
The chronological correlation with regional geoarchaeological data (Mastronuzzi & alii, 2017b) and to the geophysical model of the relative sea level history during the
last thousands of years derived by the entire Mediterranean
basin (e.g.: Lambeck & alii, 2004; 2011; Antonioli & alii,
2009; Anzidei & alii, 2014), allows to extend the affirmation that during the last two millennia the entire coasts at
the foot of Murgia plateau were characterised by a substantial tectonic stability validating the predictive geophysical
models (fig. 13). No direct comparisons seem to be possible
with sea level curves obtained in the Gargano and Tavoliere delle Puglie areas at the North of Torre Guaceto and
respect to that obtained in the Alimini area at the South
(Caldara & alii., 2008; Caldara & Simone, 2005; Di Rita &
alii, 2011; Primavera & alii, 2011). In fact, these basins are
located in geological contexts characterized by different
tectonic behaviors.
On the other hand, the correlation with the geophysical models suggests the following reconstruction of the sea
level rise:
76
– the hut postholes surveyed in the near area of Torre
Santa Sabina together with those of Torre Guaceto suggest a sea level rise from the Bronze Age (3.5 ka BP) of
at least 2.25 ± 0.2 m
– approximately 2200 years BP the sea level stand at
about -1.1 ± 0.1 m below the present position; the area
of Torre Guaceto was marked by a constellation of islands and inlets already well-identified;
– about 2000 years BP the sea has been stationed at a
level of -1.0 ± 0.1 m from the present as suggested by
archaeological remains; at this time the coastal strip of
Torre Guaceto, was marked by the presence of a beach
with a low embrional dune and typical back-beach environments;
– about 1900 years BP the sea level stand at about -0.65 ±
0.1 cm; the presence of a beach may be in progradation
allowed the development of a coastal environment with
the characteristics of a brackish area;
– approximately 1700 years BP the sea level probably
stands for a very short span of time around -0,3 ± 0,1m
below the present one; the back beach-dune system,
marked by the presence of discontinuous dry area, likely temporarily flooded by waves probably during severe
storms;
– from this time and up to about 150 years ago, with the
continuous slow rise of the sea level, the coastal area was
marked by the vertical and lateral variation between occasionally submerged environments, always close to a
brackish area, and a more appropriately emerged environment; the presence of a brackish area is, however, a
dominant character in the vertical succession;
– approximately 150 years ago, the rising sea level determined the beach’s accumulation that persists up to the
present.
CONCLUSIONS
From the study of the palaeontological association, considerable changes in physical landscape have been highlighted. Such changes were characterized by the slow adaptation of the sedimentary environments to the slow sea level
rise and to the dynamics imposed in a coastal environment
by every change in the hydraulic regimes connected to the
rain events and exceptional waves impacts. As a matter of
fact, data indicate a natural coastal system – free from any
constraint associated with anthropic activity aimed at controlling its physical dynamics – which is particularly prone
not only to any sea level change but also changes in wave
energy or of drying or humidifying caused by meteorological events on limited areas. They determine the vertical
and horizontal expansion/contraction of the biological environments that can persist in a limited span of time up
to a new change in the meteorological or in wave climate
conditions. At the same time, the malacofauna association
together with sedimentological analysis have shown different levels connected to sea level stand, in turn highlighted
by salt water features.
Finally, the complete dataset composed of the data deriving from the cores drilled in the Torre Guaceto area and
from the archaeological markers as the hut postholes seem
to indicate a sea level rise from the Bronze Age at a rate of
about 0.6 mm a-1. In more recent times, core TGS4 suggests a sea level rise of about 1,10 m during the last 2200 at
a rate of 0.5 mm a-1 and finally a sea level rise of about 0.65
m during the last 1900 years (0.3 mm a-1) confirming the
sea level position at 0.9 ± 0.2 m about 2.0/1.5 ka inferred
geoarchaeological data from this side of Murgia. These
data indicate only an average rate for the last 2000 years;
they are useful to confirm the trend of sea level changes
during the analyzed time span. Nevertheless, the IPCC
AR5 curve indicates an impressive increase of the sea level
rise since the industrial time at the middle of XIX century; the correspondent sea level rise is assessed at about 2.3
mm a-1 between the 1870 and the 2000 AD. At planetary
scale, the present sea level rise is valued at about 3 mm a-1
with an impressive increase up to 1.8 mm a-1 during the
last two centuries for the Mediterranean basin. These data
highlights the flooding of the Adriatic coastal areas that
may occur in the next decades as consequence of the continuous sea level rise induced by the global warming, which
has been dramatically increasing in recent years.
With regards to point iii, compared to the predicted sea
level, the data available correspond to the supposed tectonic stability/low rate uplift of the Adriatic sides of the Murge
area in opposition to the still invaluable Holocene tectonic
behaviour of the far area of the Tavoliere delle Puglie or of
the Salento area at the south of Canale Reale. Actually, in
both case the geodynamic behaviours can be reasonably
considered different due to the difference in the geological
context; geological, paleontological and geoarchaeological
data seem to be in contrast with the data of the Adriatic
side of Apulia along the Murge plateau; in particular, additional data on the Salento region could highlight interesting aspects of its recent history in the complex context of
the Euroasia and Africa plate kinematics.
REFERENCES
A LMOGI-LABIN A., PERELIS-GROSSOVICZ L. & R AAB M. (1992) - Living
Ammonia from an hypersalineinland pool, Dead Sea area, Israel. Journal of Foraminiferal Research, 22, 257-266.
A LMOGI-LABIN A., SIMANTOV R., ROSENFELD A. & DEBARD E. (1995) Occurrence and distribution of the foraminifer Ammonia beccarii tepida (Cushman) in water bodies, Recent and Quaternary of the Dead Sea
Rift, Israel. Marine Micropaleontology, 26, 153-159.
A MOROSI A., COLALONGO, M.L., FIORINI F., FUSCO F., PASINI G., VAIANI
S.C. & SARTI G. (2004) - Palaeogeographic and palaeoclimatic evolution of the Po Plain from 150-ka core records. Global and Planetary
Change, 40, 55-78.
ANTONIOLI F., FERRANTI L., FONTANA A., A MOROSI A., BONDESAN A.,
BRAITENBERG C., DUTTON A., FONTOLAN G., FURLANI S., LAMBECK
K., M ASTRONUZZI G., MONACO C., SPADA G. & STOCCHI P. (2009) Holocene relative sea-level changes and tectonic movements along the
Italian coastline. Quaternary International, 206, 102-133.
ANTONIOLI F., LO PRESTI V., ROVERE A., FERRANTI L., ANZIDEI M., FURLANI S., M ASTRONUZZI G., ORRU P. E., SCICCHITANO G., SANNINO G.,
SPAMPINATO C., PAGLIARULO R., DEIANA G., DE SABATA E., SANSÒ P.,
VACCHI M. & VECCHIO A. (2015). Tidal notches in Mediterranean Sea:
a comprehensive analysis. Quaternary Science Reviews, 119, 66-84.
A NZIDEI M., A NTONIOLI F., FURLANI S., LAMBECK K., M ASTRONUZZI
G., SERPELLONI E. & VANNUCCI G. (2014). Coastal structure, sea
level changes and vertical motion of the land in the Mediterranean.
M ARTINI I. P., WANLESS, H. R. (Eds.), Sedimentary Coastal Zones
from High to Low Latitudes: Similarities and Differences. Geological Society, London, Special Publ., 388. http://dx.doi.org/10.1144/
SP388.20
ANZIDEI M., ANTONIOLI F., LAMBECK K., BENINI A. & SOUSSI M. (2011) New insights on the relative sea level change during Holocene along the
coasts of Tunisia and western Libya from archaeological and geomorphological markers. Quaternary International, 232, 5-12.
AURIEMMA R., M ASTRONUZZI G., SANSÒ P. & ZONGOLO F. (2005) - The
harbor of the mansion ad speluncas (Brindisi, Italy): a key to the lecture
of sea level changes in the past 3500 years? In: Maritime Heritage and
Modern Ports, Wit Press, 5-14.
AURIEMMA R. & SOLINAS E. (2009) - Archaeological remains as sea level
change markers: a review. Quaternary International, 206, 134-146.
BARNES R.S.K. (2005) - Interspecific competition and rarity in mudsnails:
feeding interactions between and within Hydrobia acuta neglecta
and sympatric Hydrobia species. Aquatic Conservation: Marine and
Freshwater Ecosystems, 15, 485-493.
BOLTOVSKOY E., SCOTT D.B. & MEDIOLI F.S. (1991) - Morphological variations of benthic foraminiferal tests in response to changes in ecological
parameters: a review. Journal of Palaeontology, 65, 175-185.
BOOMER I., FRENZEL P. & FEIKE M. (2017) - Salinity-driven size variability
in Cyprideis torosa (Ostracoda, Crustacea). Journal of Micropalaeontology, 36 (1), 63-69.
BRITTON R.H. (1985) - Life cycle and production of Hydrobia acuta Drap.
(Gastropoda: Prosobranchia) in a hypersaline coastal lagoon. Hydrobiologia, 122, 219-230.
BRUUN P. (1962) - Sea-level rise as a cause of shore erosion. Journal of Waterways and Harbors Division, 88, 117-130.
BUNJE P.M.E. (2005) - Pan-European phylogeography of the aquatic snail
Theodoxus fluviatilis (Gastropoda: Neritidae). Molecular Ecology, 14
(14), 4323-4340.
CALDARA M. & SIMONE O. (2005) - Coastal changes in the eastern Tavoliere Plain (Apulia, Italy) during the Late Holocene: natural or anthropic? Quaternary Science Reviews, 24, 2137-2145.
77
CALDARA M., CAROLI I. & SIMONE O. (2008) - Holocene evolution and
sea-level changes in the Battaglia basin area (eastern Gargano coast,
Apulia, Italy). Quaternary International, 183, 102-114.
CALCAGNILE L., QUARTA G. & D’ELIA M. (2005) - High Resolution acceleration mass spectrometry: precision, accuracy and background. Applied Radiation and Isotopes, 62 (4), 623-626.
CALCAGNILE L., QUARTA G., D’ELIA M., R IZZO A., GOTTDANG A., K LEIN
M. & MOUS D.J.W. (2004) - A new accelerator mass spectrometry facility in Lecce, Italy. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics
Research, 223-224, 16-20.
CESARI P. (1976) - Caratteristiche specifiche e polimorfismo fisiologico infraspecifico di Ovatella (Myosotella) myosotis (Draparnaud) (Mollusca
Pulmonata). Lavori della Società Veneziana di Scienze Naturali, 1,
3-19.
CESARI P. (1988) - La malacofauna della Laguna Veneta. I Gasteropodi terrestri, dulciacquicoli e salmastri dei litorali di Pellestrina, Lido e Cavallino (MolluscaProsobranchia e Pulmonata). Bollettino del Museo
Civico di Storia Naturale, Venezia, 38, 7-42.
COGNETTI G. & M ALTAGLIATI F. (2000) - Biodiversity and adaptive mechanisms in brackish water fauna. Marine Pollution Bulletin, 40, 7-14.
COWELL P. J. & THOM B.G. (1994) - Morphodynamics of coastal evolution.
In: CARTER R.W.G., WOODROFFE C.D. (Eds.), Coastal evolution, late
quaternary shoreline morphodynamics. Cambridge University Press,
33-66.
D’ELIA M., CALCAGNILE L., QUARTA G., SANAPO C., LAUDISA M.,
TOMA U. & R IZZO A. (2004) - Sample preparation and blank values
at the AMS radiocarbon facility of the University of Lecce. Nucl. Instruments Methods Phys. Res. Sect. B Beam Interact. with Mater.
Atoms 223-224, 278-283.
DE M ARTINI P.M., BARBANO M.S., SMEDILE A., GERARDI F., PANTOSTI
D., DEL CARLO P. & PIRROTTA C. (2010) - A unique 4000 year long
geological recordof multiple tsunami inundations in the Augusta Bay
(eastern Sicily, Italy):paleoseismological implications. Marine Geology,
276, 42-57.
DE M ARTINI P.M., BURRATO P., PANTOSTI D., M ARAMAI A., GRAZIANI
L. & A BRAMSON H. (2003) - Identification of tsunami deposits and
liquefaction features in the Gargano area (Italy): paleosismological implication. Annals of Geophysics, 46, 883-902.
DI R ITA F., SIMONE O., CALDARA M., GEHERELS R. & M AGRI D. (2011)
- Holocene environmental changes in the coastal Tavoliere Plain (Apulia, southern Italy): A multiproxy approach. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 310, 139-151.
EVAGELOPOULOS A., SPYRAKOS E. & KOUTSOUBAS D. (2007) - The biological system of the lower salinity ponds in KalloniSaltworks (NE Aegean
Sea, Greece): phytoplankton and macrobenthic invertebrates. Transitional Waters Bulletin, 3, 23-25.
EVAGELOPOULOS A., SPYRAKOS E. & KOUTSOUBAS D. (2009) - Phytoplankton and macrofauna in the low salinity ponds of a productive solar saltworks: spatial variability of community structure and its major abiotic
determinants. Global NEST Journal, 11 (2), 64-72.
FALKNER G., OBRDLÍK P., CASTELLA E. & SPEIGHT M.C.D. (2001) - Shelled
Gastropoda of Western Europe. München: Friedrich-Held-Gesellschaft, 267 pp.
FAVERO V. & SERANDREI BARBERO R. (1981) - Evoluzione paleoambientale della laguna di Venezia nell’area archeologica tra Burano e Canale
S. Felice. Lavori della Società Veneziana di Scienze Naturali, 6, 119134.
FERRANTI L., ANTONIOLI F., M AUZ B., A MOROSI A., DAI PRÀ G., M ASTRONUZZI G., MONACO C., ORRÙ P., PAPPALARDO M., R ADTKE U.,
R ENDA P., ROMANO P., SANSÒ P. & VERRUBBI V. (2006) - Markers of
the last interglacial sea level high stand along the coast of Italy: tectonic
implications. Quaternary International, 145-146, 30-54.
FRETTER V. & GRAHAM A. (1978) - The prosobranch mollusch molluscs
of Britain and Denmark. Part. 3 - Neritacea, Viviparacea, Valvatacea,
Terrestrial and Freshwater Littorinacea and Rissoacea. The Journal
of Molluscan Studies, Suppl. 5, 101-152.
GESLIN E., DEBENAY J.P., DULEBA W. & BONETTI C. (2002) - Morphological abnormalities of foraminiferal tests in Brazilian environments:
comparison between polluted and non-polluted areas. Marine Micropaleontology, 45, 151-168.
GIUSTI F. & PEZZOLI E. (1984) - Notulae Malacologicae, XXIX: Gli Hydrobiidae salmastri delle acque costiere Italiane: primi cenni sulla sistematica del gruppo e sui caratteri distintivi delle singole morfospecie.
Atti del Simposio Sistematico dei prosobranchi del Mediterraneo,
Bologna, 24-26 settembre 1982. Lavori della Societa Società Italiana
di Malacologia, 21, 117-148.
K ANTRUD H.A. (1991) - Wigeongrass (Ruppia maritima L.): A Literature
Review. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Fish and Wildlife Research,
Vol. 10, 58 pp.
LA PEYRE M.K. & ROWE S. (2003) - Effects of salinity changes on growth
of Ruppia maritima L. Aquatic Botany, 77, 235-241.
LAMBECK K., ANTONIOLI F., ANZIDEI M., FERRANTI L., LEONI G., SCICCHITANO G. & SILENZI S. (2011) - Sea level change along the Italian
coast during the Holocene and projections for the future. Quaternary
International, 232, 250-257.
LAMBECK K., ANTONIOLI F., PURCELL A. & SILENZI S. (2004) - Sea level
change along the Italian coast for the past 10,000 yrs. Quaternary Science Reviews, 23, 1567-1598.
LAMBECK K. & PURCELL A. (2005) - Sea-level change in the Mediterranean
Sea since theLGM: model predictions for tectonically stable areas. Quaternay Science Reviews, 24, 1969-1988.
LORENZO-TRUEBA J. & ASHTON A. D. (2014) - Rollover, drowning, and discontinuous retreat: Distinct modes of barrier response to sea-level rise
arising from a simple morphodynamic model. Journal of Geophysical
Research: Earth Surface, 119 (4), 779-801.
M ASTRONUZZI G., A RINGOLI D., AUCELLI P.C., BALDASSARRE M.A.,
BELLOTTI P., BINI M., BIOLCHI S., BONTEMPI S., BRANDOLINI P.,
CHELLI A., DAVOLI L., DEIANA G., DE MURO S., DEVOTO S., DI
PAOLA G., D ONADIO C., FAGO P., FERRARI M., F URLANI S., I BBA A.,
LUPIA PALMIERI E., M ARSICO A., M ELIS R.T., M ILELLA M., MUCERINO L., NESCI O., ORRÚ P.E., PANIZZA V., P ENNETTA M., P IACENTINI
D., P ISCITELLI A., P USCEDDU N., R AFFI R., ROSSKOPF C.M., SANSÓ
P., STANISLAO C., TARRAGONI C. & VALENTE A. (2017a) - Geomorphological map of the Italian coast: from a descriptive to a morphodynamic approach. Geografia Fisica e Dinamica Quaternaria, 40 (2),
161-196.
M ASTRONUZZI G., ANTONIOLI F., ANZIDEI M., AURIEMMA R., A LFONSO
C. & SCARANO T. (2017b). Evidence of relative sea level rise along the
coasts of central Apulia (Italy) during the late Holocene via maritime
archaeological indicators. Quaternary International, 439, 65-78.
M ASTRONUZZI G., CAPUTO R., DI BUCCI D., FRACASSI U., MILELLA M.,
PIGNATELLI C., SANSÒ P. & SELLERI G. (2011) - Middle-Late Pleistocene Evolution of the Adriatic Coastline of Southern Apulia (Italy) in
Response to Relative Sea-level Changes. Geografia Fisica e Dinamica
Quaternaria, 34 (2), 207-222.
M ASTRONUZZI G. & SANSÒ P. (2002a) - Holocene uplift rates and historical
rapid sea-level changes at the Gargano promontory, Italy. Journal of
Quaternary Science, 17 (5-6), 593-606.
M ASTRONUZZI G. & SANSÒ P. (2002b) - Holocene coastal dune development and environmental changes in Apulia (Southern Italy). Sedimentary Geology, 150, 139-152.
M ASTRONUZZI G. & SANSÒ S. (2006) - Coastal area: a recorder of environmental changes. Geografia Fisica e Dinamica Quaternaria, 29 (2), 5-9.
M ASTRONUZZI G. & SANSÒ P. (2017) - The Salento peninsula (Apulia,
Southern Italy): a water-shaped landscape without rivers. In: M ARCHETTI M. & SOLDATI M. (Eds.), Landscapes and Landforms of Italy,
World Geomorphological Landscapes, Springer, 421-430. doi.org/10.
1080/17445647.2014.999136
M ASTRONUZZI G., SANSÒ P., MURRAY-WALLACE C.V. & SHENNAN I.
(2005) - Quaternary coastal morphology and sea-level changes - an introduction. Quaternary Science Review, 24, 18-19, 1963-1968.
SMEDILE A., DE M ARTINI P.M. & PANTOSTI D. (2012) - Combining inland
and offshore paleotsunami evidence: the Augusta Bay (eastern Sicily,
ITALY) case study. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 12,
2557-2567.
STOUFF V., GESLIN E., DEBENAY J.P. & LESOURD M. (1999) - Origin of
morphological abnormalities in Ammonia (Foraminifera): studies in
laboratory and natural environments. Journal of Foraminiferal Research 29, 152-170.
MILELLA M., PIGNATELLI C., DONNALOIA M. & M ASTRONUZZI G. (2006) Sea Level during 4th-2nd century B.C. in Egnazia (Italy) from archaeological and hydrogeological data. Il Quaternario, Italian Journal of
Quaternary Sciences, 19 (2), 251-258.
STUIVER M. & POLACH H.A. (1977) - Discussion reporting of
Radiocarbon, 19 (3), 355-363.
MÖRNER N.-A. (1986) - The concept of eustasy: a redefinition. Journal of
Coastal Research, 1, 49-51.
SWITZER A.D. & JONES B.G. (2008) - Large-scale washover sedimentation
in a freshwaterlagoon from the southeast Australian coast: sea level
change, tsunami or exceptionally large storm?. The Holocene, 18, 787803.
MURRAY J.W. (1991a) - Ecology and distribution of benthic foraminifera. In:
LEE J.J. & ANDERSON O.R. (Eds.), Biology of foraminifera. Academic
Press, San Diego, 221-253.
MURRAY J.W. (1991b) - Ecology and Palaeoecology of Benthic Foraminifera.
Longman Scientific & Technical, New York, 397 pp.
14C
data.
STUIVER M., R EIMER P.J. & R EIMER R.W. (2018) - CALIB 7.1 [WWW
program] at http://calib.org.
VATOVA A. (1981) - Recherches comparatives sur le “valli” salées de peche
de la haute Adriatique. Rapp. Comm. Int. Mer Mediterranee, 27 (4),
93-94, Monaco.
ORRÙ P.E., M ASTRONUZZI G., DEIANA G., PIGNATELLI C., PISCITELLI A.,
SOLINAS E., SPANU P.G. & ZUCCA R. (2014) - Sea level changes and
geoarchaeology between Malfatano Bay and Piscinnì Bay (SW Sardinia)
in the last 4 ka. Quaternary International, 336, 180-189.
VÖTT A., BRÜCKNER H., BROCKMÜLLE S., H ANDL M., M AY S.M., GAKI-PAPANASTASSIOU K., H ERD R., LANG F., M AROUKIAN H., NELLE
O. & PAPANASTASSIOU D. (2008) - Traces of Holocene tsunami across
the Sound of Lefkada, NW Greece. Global and Planetary Change, 66
(1-2), 112-128.
PASCUAL A., RODRIGUEZ-LAZARO J., WEBER O. & JOUANNEAU J.M. (2002) Late Holocene pollution in the Gernika estuary (southern Bay of Biscay) evidenced by the study of Foraminifera and Ostracoda. Hydrobiologia, 475 (476), 477-491.
ZETTLER M. L., FRANKOWSKI J., BOCHERT R. & RÖHNER M. (2004) - Morphological and ecological features of Theodoxus fluviatilis (Linnaeus,
1758) from Baltic brackish water and German freshwater populations.
Journal of Conchology, 38 (3), 305-316.
PÉRÈS J.M. (1967) - The Mediterranean benthos. Oceanography Marine
Biology Annual Review, 5, 449-533.
(Ms. received 12 March 2018; accepted 20 September 2018)
PÉRÈS J.M. & PICARD J. (1964) - Nouveau manuel de bionomie bentique de
la Mer Méditerranée. Recueil de la Station Marine d’Edoume - XIV
(23), 1-114.
PICARD J. (1965) - Recherches qualitatives sur les Biocoenoses marines
des substrats meubles dragables de la région marseillaise. RecueildesTravaux de la Station Marine d’Endoume, DII (36), 1-102.
PRIMAVERA M., SIMONE O., FIORENTINO G. & CALDARA M. (2011) - The
palaeoenvironmental study of the Alimini Piccolo lake enables a reconstruction of Holocene sea-level changes in southeast Italy. The Holocene, 21 (4), 553-563.
SAMIR A.M. (2000) - The response of benthonic foraminifera and ostracods
to various pollution sources: a study from two lagoons in Egypt. Journal
of Foraminiferal Research, 30, 83-98.
SCARANO T., AURIEMMA R., M ASTRONUZZI G. & SANSÒ P. (2008) - L’archeologia del paesaggio costiero e la ricostruzione delle trasformazioni
ambientali: gli insediamenti di Torre Santa Sabina e Torre Guaceto
(Carovigno, BR). In: Atti del II Simposio Internazionale “Monitoraggio costiero Mediterraneo: problematiche e tecniche di misura”,
Firenze, 391-402.
SCARANO T. & GUGLIELMINO R. (2017) - L’insediamento fortificato della
media età del Bronzo di Scogli di Apani (BR): le campagne di scavo
2008, 2009, 2011. in: 47th Scientific Conference of the Italian Institute for Prehistory and Protohistory, “Prehistory and Protohistory of
Apulia”, Ostuni, Brindisi (Italy), October 9-13, 2012, 497-504.
SERANDREI BARBERO R., A LBANI A.D. & BONARDI M. (2004) - Ancient
and modern saltmarshes in the lagoon of Venice. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 202 (3-4), 229-244.
SERANDREI BARBERO R., DONNICI S. & M ADRICARDO F. (2011) - Supratidal foraminifera as ecological indicators in anthropically modified
wetlands (Lagoon of Venice, Italy). Ecological Engineering, 37 (8),
1140-1148.