Academia.edu no longer supports Internet Explorer.
To browse Academia.edu and the wider internet faster and more securely, please take a few seconds to upgrade your browser.
2018, Convergences and Divergences between International Human Rights Law, International Criminal Law and International Humanitarian Law
Is human trafficking foremost a heinous crime, requiring concerted action against organized criminal networks? Or is it primarily a grave human rights violation, where the protection of victims must be the utmost priority? Human trafficking is about one person appropriating the labour, freedom and dignity of another person, it is about slavery, forced labour, debt bondage, forced marriage, organ removal and the commercial sexual exploitation of mostly women and children. Traditionally, trafficking activities have been exclusively categorized as crimes and tackled with law enforcement strategies focused on criminalization and punishment. Now that agreement seems to have been reached that trafficking is also a human rights issue and that a certain degree of complementarity between a criminal and a human rights law approach is utterly needed, important divergences persist on the degree of convergence required and on whether and how this complementarity should be translated into clear and coherent international law commitments. In the meantime, trafficking continues to flourish as a low-risk, high-profit activity for criminals, where millions of women, men and children continue to be exploited all around the word.
Slavery is often considered a historic aspect of the Roman Empire or the slave trade to the New World. However, according to official estimates there are currently around 21 million people enslaved in some way or another. Consequently, there are at present more enslaved people than at any other point in history. Many of these people are caught in a web of human trafficking reminiscent of an archaic and uncivilized world from humanities history. Even though, or probably even because, 20th century Neoliberalism promised us unlimited wealth by means of globalization the reality of the present now paints the totally different picture. One of inequality within and among nations in which consumerism has turned even human beings into a tradable good. The first part of this essay will describe what human trafficking is by determining the definition given by international law. In the second part the current international legal and normative framework will be set out and the problems the approach this framework stands for will be analyzed. The third part of this essay will strive to make clear how the effects of globalization are the main roots of human trafficking and thus an effective strategy combating the problem has to take a holistic approach with human rights considerations at its core. Finally, the fourth part of this essay will deal with the question of both the legal and moral responsibility States have in combating the problem of human trafficking. On the whole, the main argument of this essay will be that the current international legal and normative framework does not adequately combat the issue of human trafficking because it marginalizes the human rights aspect. Furthermore, it will argue that States have a legal and moral obligation to create a more holistic framework and combat the violations of a victim of human trafficking human rights, by the denial of that person’s freedom, in a more effective manner.
PROSPECTION OF INTERNATIONAL HUMAN TRAFFICKING; PERSPECTIVE OF INTERNATIONAL LAW IN THE LEGAL AND SOCIAL CONTEXT (Atena Editora)
PROSPECTION OF INTERNATIONAL HUMAN TRAFFICKING; PERSPECTIVE OF INTERNATIONAL LAW IN THE LEGAL AND SOCIAL CONTEXT (Atena Editora)2023 •
Currently, the world is experiencing a huge lack of interest – coexistence with human trafficking will become the main form of human trafficking, in addition to other forms that continue to increase more and more. The important thing is to decipher what human trafficking means and what its definition is in a general context. Human trafficking is perpetrated by actors with different levels of sophistication within their organizational structures. Due to its vastness and intricacy, this form of trafficking is the result of an association of different social, economic and political aspects that involve not only the situation of countries in general, but also the individual himself in the social context.
Caderno de Relações Internacionais
The Globalized Treatment of Human Trafficking in International Lawo Tratamento Globalizado Do Tráfico De Pessoas No Direito InternacionalThe trafficking in persons is a problem that directly affects the freedom and dignity of human beings. The globalization and transnationality inherent in this type of crime aggravates this problem and its suppression becomes more difficult. This paper aims to answer whether international human rights treaties can contribute effectively to combat this crime. Firstly, the basic concepts of globalization and trafficking in persons are presented, followed by forms of creating international treaties with their impact on public policies. Finally, an analysis of these policies in the light of the Supplementing Protocol to the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime on the Prevention, Suppression and Punishment of Trafficking in Persons, especially Women and Children, with a consequent survey of the international treaties on the subject is made. The method used was the exploratory descriptive. It was concluded that trafficking in persons is a complex phenomenon and i...
The Migration Conference 2017 Proceedings
Chapter 30. Human Trafficking: Is the Law of the Western Societies Effective or Not?The human trafficking is widely thought to be the modern form of slavery. It started before many years and still exists. Nowadays a great number of people, especially women and children, are trafficked, mainly from poor to developed states, in order to be exploited either for sex or for labor. The Western societies, including the international organizations and institutions, have taken measures, as they have tried to eliminate it. The most characteristic attempt is the Palermo Protocol. However, the legislation has been proved ineffective, therefore the states in collaboration with the organizations should realize the basic dimensions of this phenomenon and legislate based on them.
Chinese Journal of International Law
Trafficking in Human Beings, Enslavement, Crimes Against Humanity: Unravelling the Concepts2014 •
https://www.marcialpons.es/libros/the-human-rights-based-approach-to-human-trafficking-in-international-law-an-analysis-from-a-victim-protection-perspective/9788491238973/
THE HUMAN RIGHTS-BASED APPROACH TO HUMAN TRAFFICKING IN INTERNATIONAL LAW: AN ANALYSIS FROM A VICTIM PROTECTION PERSPECTIVE Marcial Pons2020 •
As opposed to the traditional law enforcement and immigration control perspective, the «human rights-based approach» (HRBA) to human trafficking puts the rights of trafficked persons at the centre of anti-trafficking strategies. What does this approach effectively mean and require? Is it sufficiently reflected in the current international law regime? Do international judicial and non-judicial bodies effectively contribute to its development? After identifying the constitutive elements of this approach as initially developed within the UN in the context of development cooperation and then applied to trafficking, this book examines whether the HRBA is properly reflected in the key elements of the victim protection regime: identification, protection, assistance, right to remain and repatriation. It provides a detailed analysis of the extent to which international instruments and international bodies’ pronouncements truly integrate this approach. The author highlights the good practices but also the existing dysfunctions in universal and regional instruments and case law and in States’ practice, which often result not only in the lack of adequate protection for victims, but also in the ineffectiveness of anti-trafficking policies. She also highlights the major contributions of a HRBA, which include how this approach broadens and clarifies the scope States’ obligations in this area, and its key role as a cross cutting paradigm of international law that contributes to the convergence of separate international law regimes.
2013 •
The notion of a ‘human trafficking chain’ is a manifestation of the fact that the transnational criminal offence of trafficking in human beings (THB) is not carried out instantaneously. On the contrary, it is perpetrated at stages and progressively: each stage depends on a previous stage having taken place, which, in its turn, is necessary for perpetrating the next step. This operates in the same way as the links of a chain: each link exists so as to allow going from the previous to the next one. Moreover, the various stages in the ‘human trafficking chain’ are perpetrated and financed by different persons and entities in the territory of numerous jurisdictions and, consequently, the various stages constitute separate criminal acts to which diverse legal systems might be applied. Notwithstanding the existence of other transnational criminal offences involving separate offences and different jurisdictions (the offence of money laundering comes to mind), it is difficult to think of other offences that have the characteristics and the complexities of human trafficking. The paper examines the various stages making up the THB crime, identifies the separate criminal acts that are perpetrated during each of these stages, and sets out pertinent issues and questions.
… Law Review, Special Issue: Proceedings of Trafficking …
SCARPA S. (2004) “Universalism and Regionalism: The Synergy to Fight against Trafficking in Human Beings” HUMAN RIGHTS LAW REVIEW p. 4-19.2003 •
مجلة جامعة السعيد للعلوم الانسانية و التطبيقية
Human Trafficking as a Human Rights Violation in a Pluralistic and Interdependent World: Obligations and Accountability of StatesHuman trafficking is a common occurrence in the modern world. It has been estimated that thousands of people are trafficked every year, the most of whom are women and children. Almost all States are impacted by trafficking, and it is estimated that traffickers earn billions of dollars a year from their illegal activities. Slavery and the slave trade, which date back thousands of years, are the roots of trafficking. However, since the start of the 20th century, the term "human trafficking" has taken on a new meaning. This paper explores some state-imposed requirements related to human rights. While there are many different obligations, this paper focuses on the four most important ones that are imposed on all States, regardless of whether they are States of Origin, Transit, or Destination: the obligation to forbid trafficking, to look into and prosecute traffickers, to protect victims, and to address the causes and effects of the phenomenon. It will be shown that thes...
Transactions of La Société Guernesiaise
Archaeology Section Report for 20182018 •
2023 •
Acta Musei Napocensis 60/I
Dan Deac, Radu Zăgreanu, Two Latin Dedications to Septimius Severus Discovered at Samum/Cășeiu (Roman Dacia)2023 •
الزوجة وراء اكتشاف فيتامين ج
ا.د. محمد لبيب سالم الزوجة وراء اكتشاف فيتامين ج2024 •
Journal of Common Market Studies
Does Populism Matter in EU-China Relations? The Cases of Italy and Czechia2024 •
2018 •
Automatica
Stabilization of a class of mixed ODE–PDE port-Hamiltonian systems with strong dissipation feedback2022 •
Journal of Hematology
Infiltrative Rash Secondary to Leukemic-Phase Diffuse Large B-Cell Lymphoma With t(14;18), CDKN2A and MLL Deletion2017 •
Advanced Materials Letters
Do the Ni binding modes on C12N12 cluster influence its H2 trapping capability?2020 •
Arabian Journal of Geosciences
Correction to: Beryl occurrences in the granitic complex of Guerioune, Laouni, Southeastern Algeria: electron microprobe, infrared spectroscopy, and fluid inclusions data2021 •
Neural, Parallel & Scientific Computations archive
A Note on the Lee–Chang–Pham–Song Software Reliability Model2018 •