Studia Bobolanum 27,
nr 4 (2016): 17-37
Monaci – enfants terribles della Chiesa antica
+ൾඇඋඒ3ංൾඍඋൺඌ63RQWL¿FLD8QLYHUVLWj*UHJRULDQD
5RPD
/D YLWD PRQDVWLFD KD GDWR DOOD &KLHVD L QXPHURVL VDQWL XRPLQL GL
IHGHHGLDVFHVLHGDOODORURVSLULWXDOLWjSRVVLDPRLPSDUDUHPROWRDQFKH
RJJL,QTXHVWDSUHVHQWD]LRQHYRUUHLVRIIHUPDUPLVXJOLDOWULPRQDFLTXHOOL
FKHFUHDYDQRGLVRUGLQLORWWDYDQRWUDGLORURRFRQLYHVFRYLVLLPPLVFKLD
YDQR±RVRQRVWDWLLPPLVFKLDWL±QHOOHFRQWURYHUVLHWHRORJLFKHHLQFHUWL
JLRFKLGLDPEL]LRQHWUDLYHVFRYLVRSUDWWXWWRWUDTXHOOLGL$OHVVDQGULDHGL
&RVWDQWLQRSROL
'DOVLQRGRGL*DQJUDVDSSLDPRFKHFHUWLPRQDFLVHJXDFLGL(XVWD
]LRGL6HEDVWHQHOODORURDVFHVLGLVSUH]]DYDQRLOPDWULPRQLR F
FRQGDQQDYDQRLOFRQVXPRGHOODFDUQH UL¿XWDYDQRO¶(XFDULVWLDFHOHEUDWD
GDXQSUHVELWHURVSRVDWR RUJDQL]]DYDQROHFHOHEUD]LRQLOLWXUJLFKHIXRUL
GHOODFKLHVDHVHQ]DODSUHVHQ]DGLXQPLQLVWURDXWRUL]]DWRGDOOD&KLHVD
FRQODVFXVDGHOO¶DVFHVLGLJLXQDYDQRODGRPHQLFD HLQFLWDYDQRJOL
VFKLDYLDOODIXJDGDLORURVLJQRUL 4XHVWLSUREOHPLQRQHUDQRULVHUYDWL
DOOD&KLHVDGL*DQJUDLQ*DOD]LDSHUFKpTXHLFDQRQLVLVRQRFRQVHUYDWLQRQ
VRORLQJUHFRPDDQFKHLOODWLQRVLULDFRDUPHQRJHRUJLDQRDUDERHWLRSLFR
HSDOHRVODYRTXLQGLLQWXWWLJOLDPELHQWLLQFXLODVLWXD]LRQHHUDVLPLOH-HDQ
*ULERPRQW FKLDPDYD OD ORUR SUDVVL DVFHWLFD ³PRQDFKHVLPR HQWXVLDVWLFR´
FRPHHUDQRFKLDPDWLDQFKHLPHVVDOLDQLHPRVWUDYDLOORURLQÀXVVRVX%D
VLOLR GL &HVDUHD PD %DVLOLR VDSHYD VWDFFDUVL GDOOH VWUDQH]]H GL (XVWD]LR
(UDXQXRPRSLXWWRVWRLQTXLHWRFRQGDQQDWRDYDULHULSUHVHGDLQLFHQLGRSR
*DQJUD FD 6&/ &I * 'DJURQ ³/H PRQDFKLVPH
D&RQVWDQWLQRSOHMXVTXDX&RQFLOHGH&KDOFpGRLQH´&HQWUHGH5HFKHUFKH
G¶+LVWRLUHHW&LYLOLVDWLRQ%\]DQWLQHVTravaux et Mémoires
(XVWD]LR GL 6HEDVWH FD XQR GHL SULQFLSDOL IRQGDWRUL GHOOD YLWD
PRQDVWLFDLQ$VLDGDOSULQFLSLRDQWLDULDQRDSSURYzLOFUHGRQLFHQRVROWDQWR
QHO$YHYDJUDQGHLQÀXVVRVX%DVLOLRGL&HVDUHD
7HRGRUHWR+( Historia Ecclesiastica ,9
17
Henryk Pietras SJ
18
FKHGDJOLDULDQLPDSULPDGDVXRSDGUHDQFKH¶HJOLYHVFRYRSHUFKpXVDYD
DELWL³QRQFRQYHQLHQWLDOODGLJQLWjVDFHUGRWDOH´1RQRVWDQWHODVXDDGHVLRQH
DJOLSQHXPDWRPDFKLQHJOLDQQLVHWWDQWDGHO,9VHFRORULPDVHWXWWDYLDXQR
GHLSLIDPRVLHLQÀXHQWLSDGULGHOPRQDFKHVLPR8QDWWHJJLDPHQWRVLPLOH
DVVXPHYDQRSXUHLPRQDFLSULVFLOOLDQLVHJXHQGRFHUWLabstinentesGLFXL
VFULYH)LODVWULRGL%UHVFLD
,PHVVDOLDQLFHUFDYDQRODSHUIH]LRQHQHOODSUHJKLHUDHQHOO¶DVFHVLULJR
URVDSRVVLELOPHQWHVHQ]DSHUGHUHWHPSRDODYRUDUH3HUPHWWHYDQRGLYLYHUH
QHOOR VWHVVR PRQDVWHUR DOOH GRQQH H DJOL XRPLQL /D ORUR DVFHVL HVDJHUD
WDqVWDWDFRQGDQQDWDDYDULHULSUHVHSRLFKpULWHQHYDQRFKHO¶HI¿FDFLDGHO
EDWWHVLPRGLSHQGHGDOO¶DVFHVLSUDWLFDWDFRQVLGHUDQGRODSLLPSRUWDQWHGHL
VDFUDPHQWLHGHOOD&KLHVDVWHVVD3DOODGLRPHQ]LRQDXQPRQDFRQRQQH
FHVVDULDPHQWH PHVVDOLDQR PD GRWDWR GHOOR VSLULWR VLPLOH FKH ULWHQHYD GL
QRQDYHUELVRJQRGHOODFRPXQLRQHHXFDULVWLFDSHUFKpDYHYDXQDYLVLRQHGL
&ULVWRFKHDQGDYDGDOXLHTXHOOREDVWDYDLFRQIUDWHOOLORUHJRODURQRFRQXQ
DQQRGLFKLXVXUDVWUHWWDQHOOHFDWHQH,PHVVDOLDQLVLHUDQRLQVHGLDWLLQFHUWL
PRQDVWHULHLOYHVFRYRGL0HOLWHQHXQFHUWR/HWRLRDOOD¿QHGHO,9VHFROR
VHPSOLFHPHQWHOLIHFHEUXFLDUH,QYHFH)ODYLDQRYHVFRYRGL$QWLRFKLDWUD
HVFULYH7HRGRUHWRGL&LUR³VDSXWRFKHHVVLVLWURYDYDQRLQ(GHVVD
HVSDUJHYDQRWUDLYLFLQLLOORURYHOHQRLQYLDWDXQDVFKLHUDGLPRQDFLULFRQ
GXVVHTXHOOLHUHWLFLDG$QWLRFKLDHOLFRVWULQVHDULQQHJDUHODORURPDODWWLD
LQTXHVWRPRGR´
6RFUDWH+(6XYHGD-*ULERPRQWEustazio di Sebaste (300 ca. – 380
ca.),1'3$&,
&I6R]RPHQR+(9,,,
&I6DUDJRVVD Synodi et Collectiones Legum 6&/ .UDNyZ:\
GDZQLFWZR:$0 0DGULG%$&
)LODVWULXV%UL[HQVLVDe haeresibus/;;;,93/ VHFRQGD
PHWjGHO,9VHFROR
&I-*ULERPRQW³/HGRVVLHUGHVRULJLQHVGXPHVVDOLDQLVPH´LQEpektasis
0pODQJHV-'DQLpORX 3DULV%HDXFKHVQH
7HRGRUHWR+(,9VLQRGRGL$QWLRFKLD 6LGH VHQ]DDWWL
FRQVHUYDWL &RQFLOLRGL(IHVR Definitio contra impios messalianitas...,
Dokumenty SoborówPowszechnych '63 .UDNyZ:\GDZQLFWZR:$0
&RQVWDQWLQRSROLV 6&/XQIUDPPHQWRLQ)R]LR
BibliotecaE
3DOODGLRGL(OHQRSROL FDSULPDGHO PRQDFRHVWRULFRGHOO¶DVFHWL
VPR$XWRUHGLHistoria LausiacaVXJOLDVFHWLGL(JLWWRHGL3DOHVWLQDHGHO
Dialogo sulla vita di Giovanni Crisostomo
3DOODGLRHistoria Lausiaca
&I7HRGRUHWR+(,9
Ibidem,
Monaci – enfants terribles della Chiesa antica
9DOHODSHQDDQQRWDUHDQFKHLOPRYLPHQWRGHJOL$FHPHWLFRORURFKH
QRQ GRUPRQR FKH YROHYDQR FRQVDFUDUH WXWWR LO WHPSR SRVVLELOH DOOD SUH
JKLHUD ,O ORUR SULPR PRQDVWHUR q VWDWR IRQGDWR GD XQ FHUWR $OHVVDQGUR
D*RPRQYLFLQRD&DOFHGRQLDYHUVRLO1RQVRQRVWDWLPDLFRQGDQQDWL
QRQRVWDQWHLOULJRULVPRPROWRDXGDFH6RWWR*LXVWLQLDQRKDQQRSHUVRODORUR
SRVL]LRQHPDGDXQDSROLFURPLDQHOPRQDVWHUR³GHJOLDQJHOL´D'RQJRODLQ
1XEELDVLSRWUHEEHGHGXUUHFKHFHUWLLGHDOLGLXQDSUHJKLHUDFRVWDQWHHUDQR
YLYLDQFRUDQHOO¶RWWDYRRQRQRVHFROR,QHVVDVLYHGHOD¿JXUDGLXQPRQDFR
FRQ OH PDQL DO]DWH LQ SUHJKLHUD H FRQ L FDSSHOOL DJJDQFLDWL DO FKLRGR QHO
PXURSHUULPDQHUHLQSLHGL
$QFKH D 5RPD QHJOL DQQL RWWDQWD GHO ,9 VHFROR F¶HUDQR GHJOL DEXVL
LOFKHWURYDHFRLQXQFDQRQHVLQRGDOHGHO6LSDUODGLPRQDFLGLDPER
LVHVVLFKHFRQWURLOSURSRVLWRGHOODFRQWLQHQ]DVRWWRODVFXVDGHOODYLWDUH
OLJLRVDVLXQLYDQRWUDGLORURHJHQHUDYDQR¿JOL'RYHYDQRHVVHUHFKLXVLQHO
FDUFHUH¿QRDOWHUPLQHGHOODYLWDHVRORDOORUDDYUHEEHURSRWXWRULFHYHUHODFR
PXQLRQH/DFLUFRVWDQ]DULHYRFDWDFLRqsub monasteriorum praetextuLQGLFD
FKHVLSDUODGHLPRQDVWHULGRSSLGRYHYLYHYDQRVLDJOLXRPLQLVLDOHGRQQH
,SUREOHPLOHJDWLDOO¶HFFHVVLYDYLFLQDQ]DGHJOLDOORJJLGHOOHPRQDFKHHGHL
PRQDFLVRQRVHJQDODWLDQFKHDOWURYH,Q*DOOLDDOO¶LQL]LRGHO9,VHFRORVLVWDELOL
VFHFKHLPRQDVWHULIHPPLQLOLGHYRQRHVVHUHFRVWUXLWLORQWDQRGDTXHOOLPDVFKL
OL/DSUHVFUL]LRQHVHUYLYDSHUSUHFLVDUHLOFDQRQHSUHFHGHQWHFKHVWDELOLYDFKH
RJQLPRQDVWHURGHY¶HVVHUHFRVWUXLWRFRQO¶DSSURYD]LRQHGHOYHVFRYR
$OHVVDQGURO¶$FHPHWD FD QDWRLQXQDLVRODJUHFDHGXFDWRD&R
VWDQWLQRSROLPRQDFRLQFHUFDGHOULJRULVPRSLDXGDFH
&IVie d’Alexandre l’Acémète32
5RPD F9,6&/De monachis et virginibus propositum non
servantibus.
³3UDHWHUHD PRQDFKRUXP TXRVGDP DWTXH PRQDFKDUXP DELHFWR SURSRVLWR
VDQFWLWDWLVLQWDQWDPSURWHVWDULVGHPHUVRVHVVHODVFLYLDPXWSULXVFODQFX
ORYHOXWVXEPRQDVWHULRUXPSUDHWH[WXLOOLFLWDDFVDFULOHJDVHFRQWDJLRQH
PLVFXHULQW SRVWHD YHUR LQ DEUXSWXP FRQVFLHQWLDH GHVSHUDWLRQH SHUGXFWL
GHLOOLFLWLVFRPSOH[LEXVOLEHUH¿OLRVSURFUHDYHULQWTXRGHWSXEOLFDHOHJHV
HWHFFOHVLDVWLFDLXUDFRQGHPQDQW,OODVHUJRLPSXGLFDVGHWHVWDELOHVTXHSHU
VRQDVDPRQDVWHULRUXPFRHWXHFFOHVLDUXPTXHFRQYHQWLEXVHOLPLQDQGDVHVVH
PDQGDPXVTXDWHQXVUHWUXVDHLQVXLVHUJDVWXOLVWDQWXPIDFLQXVFRQWLQXD
ODPHQWDWLRQHGHÀHQWHVSXUL¿FDWRULRSRVVLQWSRHQLWXGLQLVLJQHGHFRTXHUH
XWHLVYHODGPRUWHPVDOWHPVROLXVPLVHULFRUGLDHLQWXLWXSHUFRPPXQLRQLV
JUDWLDPSRVVLWLQGXOJHQWLDVXEYHQLUH´
$JDWKD F 6&/ ³0RQDVWHULDSXHOODUXPORQJLXVDPRQDVWHULLV
PRQDFKRUXPDXWSURSWHULQVLGLDVGLDEROLDXWSURSWHUREORFXWLRQHVKRPLQXP
FROORFHQWXU´
$JDWKD F 6&/ (SDR F 6&/
19
Henryk Pietras SJ
20
/H DXWRULWj FLYLOL HG HFFOHVLDVWLFKH FHUFDYDQR GL FDQDOL]]DUH WXWWD OD
YLWDPRQDVWLFDLQXQDGHOOHGXHIRUPHXI¿FLDOLFLRqFHQRELWLFKHRDQDFRUH
WLFKH,PRQDFLYDJDQWLSHUVWUDGHHFLWWjHUDQRLQGRPDELOLHSHUFLzULWHQXWL
SHULFRORVL6DQ*LURODPRVFULYHGLORURPROWRPDOHLQXQDOHWWHUDD(XVWR
FKLXP³,Q(JLWWRFLVRQRWUHFDWHJRULHGLPRQDFLLFHQRELWLFKHQHOODSDU
ODWDORFDOHVRQRGHWWLsaubesFKHSRWUHPPRGH¿QLUHªFRORURFKHYLYRQRLQ
FRPXQLWj©JOLDQDFRUHWLFKHDELWDQRVROLQHOGHVHUWRGHQRPLQDWLFRVuSHU
FKpYLYRQRVHSDUDWLGDOUHVWRGHOO¶XPDQLWjODWHU]DFDWHJRULDqFRVWLWXLWDGD
FRVLGGHWWLremnouthSHVVLPDVRUWDGLPRQDFLGDWXWWLGLVSUH]]DWDODVROD
RDOPHQRODSLQXPHURVDQHOODPLDSURYLQFLD(VVLDELWDQRDJUXSSLGLGXH
RWUHRSRFRSLHFLDVFXQRVLUHJRODGLVXDWHVWDVHQ]DGLSHQGHUHGDQHV
VXQRLQFRPXQHPHWWRQRVROWDQWRTXHOODTXRWDGLGHQDURJXDGDJQDWRFRQ
ODYRURFKHqLQGLVSHQVDELOHSHUSURYYHGHUHDOODPHQVDFRPXQH/DPDJJLRU
SDUWHGHOWHPSRDELWDQRLQFLWWjRLQTXDOFKHERUJDWDHLORURSURGRWWLOL
YHQGRQRPDJJLRUDWLFRPHVHODVDQWLWjVLWURYDVVHQHOO¶RSHUDPDQXDOHHQRQ
QHOODYLWD)UDORURVRQRIUHTXHQWLLOLWLJLYLYHQGRRJQXQRGHOSURSULRJXD
GDJQRQRQVLDPPHWWHGLVWDUHVRJJHWWLDGDOWUL)DQQRSHUVLQRODJDUDDFKL
GLJLXQDGLSLVLYDQWDQRG¶DYHUYLQWRLQXQDSUDWLFDFKHGRYUHEEHUHVWDUH
VHJUHWD FI0W ,QHVVLWXWWRqDUWL¿FLRVRPDQLFKHDPSLHVFDUSH
DVRI¿HWWRWXQLFKHUR]]HDGRJQLLVWDQWHHPHWWRQRXQVRVSLURIDQQRYLVLWH
DOOHYHUJLQLGHQLJUDQRLFKLHULFLHQHOOHIHVWHSLVROHQQLVLULPSLQ]DQR¿QR
DOODJROD´
*LURODPRVLULIHULVFHDOODVLWXD]LRQHLQ(JLWWRPDORVWHVVRHUDLQSR¶
G¶RYXQTXH , remnouth FRPH OL FKLDPD R sarakote FRPH GLFHYDQR LQ
(JLWWRVDUHEEHURVWDWLDGGLULWWXUDLQPDJJLRUDQ]Dnella nostra provincia
/DOHWWHUDqVWDWDVFULWWDGD5RPDLQWRUQRDOTXLQGLVLSRWUHEEHWUDWWDUH
GHOO¶,WDOLDRSSXUHGHOOD'DOPD]LDODSURYLQFLDQDWLDGL*LURODPR&RQWUR
TXHVWL PRQDFL VL SURQXQFLDYD DQFKH *LRYDQQL &ULVRVWRPR ULWHQHQGR FKH
YHVFRYL H SUHVELWHUL GRYUHEEHUR JRYHUQDUH QHOOD &KLHVD PHQWUH LO SRVWR
GHLPRQDFLqQHOGHVHUWRLQVROLWXGLQHGRYHSRVVRQRFRJOLHUHLIUXWWLGHOOD
YHUD¿ORVR¿D
*LURODPREpist
7UDGX]LRQHGL6LOYDQR&ROD &LWWj1XRYD
3HUODVLWXD]LRQHLQ(JLWWRVLYHGD(ZD:LSV]\FNDDrugi dar Nilu, czyli
o mnichach i klasztorach e póĨnoantycznym EgipcieħUyGáD0RQDVW\F]QH±
PRQRJUD¿H .UDNyZ7\QLHF:\GDZQLFWZR%HQHG\NW\QyZ &I
'&DQHUWandering Begging MonksSpiritual Authority and the Promotion
of Monasticism in Late Antiquity %HUNHOH\
*LRYDQQL &ULVRVWRPR Adversus oppugnatores vitae monasticae ,
3*]]]
Monaci – enfants terribles della Chiesa antica
, GLVRUGLQL FRQWLQXL SURYRFDWL GDL PRQDFL D &RVWDQWLQRSROL VSLQVHUR
O¶LPSHUDWRUH7HRGRVLR,DFDFFLDUOLGDOODFLWWj4XHVWDOHJJHQRQQHFHVVD
ULDPHQWHGHYHHVVHUHOHJDWDDXQFRQFUHWRDYYHQLPHQWRSHUFKpqWXWWDFRQ
IRUPHDOOHSDUROHGL&ULVRVWRPRFKHSDUODQHOVHQVRJHQHUDOH(QRQSRFKL
GRYHYDQRHVVHULJOLHVHPSLGHOODFRQGRWWDGHVWDELOL]]DQWHGLTXHLPRQDFLVH
LO&RQFLOLRGL&DOFHGRQLDYLULWRUQDLQYDULFDQRQLORYHGUHPRSLWDUGL0L
SHUPHWWRGLDJJLXQJHUHTXDXQ¶RVVHUYD]LRQHFKHULJXDUGDLWHPSLSRVWHULRUL
SHUFKpDQFKHDOORUDF¶HUDQRSUREOHPLFRQLPRQDFLYDJDQWL,Q*DOOLDVLYLHWD
DLPRQDFLGLYDJDUHVHQ]DXQDOHWWHUDFRPPHQGDWRULDGHLVXSHULRULFRQOD
SHQDGLVFRPXQLFDRSSXUHGLIUXVWDWH
,OFRQFLOLRGL$QJHUVQHOKDVWDELOLWR³&DQ,PRQDFLFKHDEEDQ
GRQDQRODYLDJLjLQWUDSUHVDGHOO¶REEHGLHQ]DHVHQ]DDXWRUL]]D]LRQHVFULWWD
VHQ]DLQFDULFKLVWDELOLWLRSDUWLFRODULFLUFRVWDQ]HYDJDQRQHLWHUULWRULDOWUXL
HVVHQGR QRWD OD VHYHULWj ULVHUYDWD D WDOL WUDVJUHVVRUL QRQ GHYRQR HVVHUH
DPPHVVLGDLORURDEDWLRGDLYHVFRYLDOODFRPXQLRQHDOPHQRFKHQRQDE
ELDQRIDWWRDPPHQGD´
,OIDWWRFKHTXHVWDSURVFUL]LRQHLQYHUVLRQHWHVWXDOHGL2UOpDQVULSRUWD
WDQHOODQRWDSUHFHGHQWHVLqWURYDWDQHODecretoGL*UD]LDQRGLPRVWUDFKHOD
SUDVVLFRQWLQXDYD/RVWHVVRVLQRGRGHQXQFLDODSUDWLFDGLFHUFDUVLXQDVFX
VDSHUHYLWDUHJOLREEOLJKLGLYLWDFRPXQHHGLXVFLUHGDOPRQDVWHURSHUYLYHUH
GDVROL6LWUDWWDTXHVWRFRPHPDQLIHVWD]LRQHGLRUJRJOLRHGLDPEL]LRQH
&7K;9,,PSSS9DOHQWLQLDQXV7KHRGRVLXVHW$UFDGLXV$$$7DWLDQR
SUDHIHFWRSUDHWRULR4XLFXPTXHVXESURIHVVLRQHPRQDFKLUHSSHULXQWXUGH
VHUWDORFDHWYDVWDVVROLWXGLQHVVHTXLDGTXHKDELWDUHLXEHDQWXU'DW,,,,QRQ
VHSW9HURQDH9DOHQWLQLDQR$,,,,HW1HRWHULRFRQVV 6HSWHPEULV
$QGHJDYLXP ; F6&/³0RQDFKLTXRTXHTXLFRHSWDP
REVHUYDWLRQLVYLDPUHOLQTXXQWHWDEVTXHHSLVWROLVHWDEVTXHFHUWLVQHJRWLLVYHO
QHFHVVLWDWLEXVSHUUHJLRQHVYDJDQWXUDOLHQDVFRJQLWDGLVWULFWLRQHVLVHQRQ
HPHQGDYHULQWDEDEEDWLEXVVXLVYHODVDFHUGRWLEXVDGFRPPXQLRQHP
QRQUHFLSLDQWXU´HG,WDOLDQDDFXUDGL$QJHOR'L%HUDUGLQRI Canonni dei
concili della Chiesa antica,,,,6($5RPD$XJXVWLQLDQXP
&I9HQHWLLQ%UHWDQLD F6&/³,QPRQDFKLVTXRTXH
SDUVHQWHQWLDHIRUPDVHUYHWXUTXRVVLYHUERUXPLQFUHSDWLRQRQHPHQGDYHULW
HWLDPYHUEHULEXVVWDWXLPXVFRHUFHUL´$XUHOLDQXP F 6&/
³,SVLDXWHPTXLIXHULQWSHUYDJDWLXELLQYHQWLIXHULQWFXPDX[LOLRHSLVFRSL
WDPTXDPIXJDFHVVXEFXVWRGLDUHYRFHQWXUHWUHXPVHLOOHDEEDIXWXUXP
HVVH FRJQRVFDW TXL LQ KXLXVPXGL SHUVRQDV QRQ UHJXODUL DQLPDGYHUVLRQH
GLVWULQ[HULWYHOTXLPRQDFKXPVXVFHSHULWDOLHQXP´
Decretum Gratiani&;9,,,TF
$XUHOLDQXP F 6&/³1XOOXVPRQDFKXVFRQJUHJDWLRQH
PRQDVWHULLVGHUHOLFWDDPELWLRQLVHWYDQLWDWLVLQSXOVXFHOOXODPFRQVWUXHUH
VLQHHSLVFRSLSHUPLVVLRQHYHODEEDWLVVXLYROXQWDWHSUDHVXPDW´
21
Henryk Pietras SJ
22
6HPEUDFKHLQ6LULDLOSUREOHPDVLDVWDWRSLDFXWRSHUFKpLOVLQRGR
GL6DOLTLQ6HOHXFLDQHWUDWWDDOXQJR6LSDUODGHLIDOVLPRQDFLFKHYDJDQR
SHULSDHVLHGLYXOJDQRLIDOVLLQVHJQDPHQWLVXOO¶LQFDUQD]LRQHYLHWDQRLPD
WULPRQLHLOFRQVXPRGHLFLELFUHDWLGD'LRSUREDELOPHQWHVRWWRO¶LQÀXVVR
GHOOHSUHVFUL]LRQLYHWHURWHVWDPHQWDULHVXLFLELSXULHLPSXULSHULQJDQQDUH
OD JHQWH VL YHVWRQR GL QHUR H DELWDQR QHO GHVHUWR IDOVDPHQWH ULFKLDPDQGR
O¶HVHPSLRGHJOLDQWLFKLPDHVWUL$ORURqHVSUHVVDPHQWHYLHWDWRGLHQWUDUH
QHLSDHVLHQHOOHFLWWjSHUQRQFUHDUHLQVLGLHWUDLOSRSRORHLOFOHUR1RQSRV
VRQRJHVWLUHSURSULEDWWLVWHULLQGLSHQGHQWHPHQWHGDLYHVFRYLQpFHOHEUDUH
OHPHVVH'HYRQRVWDUHQHLPRQDVWHULVRWWRODJLXULVGL]LRQHGHLYHVFRYLHGHL
SUHVELWHULUHVSRQVDELOLHVWDELOLWLFRPHORURVXSHULRUL/DPDQFDQ]DGLVRW
WRPLVVLRQHVDUjSXQLWDFRQODGHSRVL]LRQHGHLSUHVELWHULHODVFRPXQLFDGHL
ODLFL$QFKHLOYHVFRYRRSUHVELWHURFKHDYHVVHDFFHWWDWRODORURSUHVHQ]D
QHOODVXDFLWWjRSDHVHVDUHEEHVWDWRGHSRVWRGDOVXRJUDGRHXQODLFRUHR
GHOORVWHVVRGHOLWWRVDUHEEHVWDWRVFRPXQLFDWR
,SUREOHPLJUDYLQHOOHJUDQGLFLWWjWUDLYHVFRYLHLPRQDFLULPDQJRQR
LQ OHJDPH FRQ OD ULYDOLWj WUD OH VHGL GL $OHVVDQGULD H GL &RVWDQWLQRSROL
/D TXHVWLRQH QDVFH FRQ OD IRQGD]LRQH GHOOD FDSLWDOH FRVWDQWLQRSROLWDQD
LOFKHFRVWLWXuXQDPLQDFFLDSHU$OHVVDQGULDRUJRJOLRVDGLHVVHUHODFLWWj
SLLPSRUWDQWHGHOPRQGRJUHFR,QTXHVWLJLRFKLGLSRWHUHVLXVDYDQRGHJOL
DUJRPHQWLWHRORJLFLVLDFFXVDYDQRDYLFHQGDG¶HUHVLDHLPRQDFLVLODVFLD
YDQRSURYRFDUH
1. Ostilità dei monaci a Gregorio Nazianzeno
4XDQGR*UHJRULRGL1D]LDQ]RVLqVWDELOLWRD&RVWDQWLQRSROLQHO
qVWDWRFRQWHVWDWRGDFHUWLPRQDFLHTXDOFXQRGHOSRSROR1RQVLVDQLHQWH
VXOOD VXD HOH]LRQH R QRPLQD PD VHPSOLFHPHQWH FKH q DUULYDWR LQ FLWWj
SUREDELOPHQWHLQYLWDWRGDXQDFRPXQLWjGLSURIHVVLRQHQLFHQDPROWRSLF
FRODHKDSUHVLHGXWROHIXQ]LRQLLQXQDSLFFRODFDSSHOODGHWWDAnastasia.
&RVWDQWLQRSROLDOORUDQRQHUDSULYDGHOYHVFRYRSHUFKpFRQWXWWHOHFDUWH
LQUHJRODORHUD'HPR¿ORGHWWR³DULDQRPRGHUDWR´PDVDUHEEHSLDS
6DOLTLQ6HOHXFLD F,,,6&/
*UHJRULRGL1D]LDQ]R FD GL&DSSDGRFLDRUGLQDWRYHVFRYRGD
%DVLOLR QHO SHU XQD VWD]LRQH SRVWDOH GL 6DVLPD VL UL¿XWz GL DQGDUFL
HULPDVHYHVFRYRVHQ]DVHGHFRQWUDULDPHQWHDLFDQRQL
&I*UHJRULXV1D]De vita suaYY*'DJURQCosantinopoli,
nascita di una capitale (330-451) 7RULQR *LXOLR (LQDXGL HGLWRUH
'HPR¿ORGL&RVWDQWLQRSROL PRUWRQHO YHVFRYRDQWLQLFHQRQHO
HVLOLDWRGDOO¶LPSHUDWRUH7HRGRVLR
Monaci – enfants terribles della Chiesa antica
SURSULDWRFKLDPDUORVHPSOLFHPHQWHDQWLQLFHQRHULFRUGDUHFKHQRQRVWDQWH
OHHWLFKHWWHGLVWULEXLWHGD$WDQDVLRQRQWXWWLJOLDQWLQLFHQLHUDQRDULDQL
/D QRWWH GL 3DVTXD GXUDQWH LO EDWWHVLPR DPPLQLVWUDWR GD *UHJRULR
QHOOD³VXD´FDSSHOODTXDOFXQRJOLWLUDGHOOHSLHWUH*UHJRULRVWHVVRVFULYH
FKHVLWUDWWDGLPRQDFLYHUJLQLHSRYHUL/¶HGLWRUHGHOODWUDGX]LRQHIUDQFH
VHGHOOHOHWWHUHVSLHJDLQQRWDFKHHUDQRVWDWLJOLDULDQLDUDJJUXSSDUHWXWWL
TXDQWL SHUFKp VL VFKLHUDVVHUR FRQWUR LO YHVFRYR 1RQ GRYHYD HVVHUH QH
FHVVDULDPHQWHFRVuSHUFKpSRWHYDQRHVVHUHDQFKHPHPEULGLXQDFRPXQLWj
GL XRPLQL H GRQQH IRQGDWD GD 0DUDWRQLR OHJDWR D 0DFHGRQLR H YHVFRYR
GL1LFRPHGLD6XOFUHGRSURIHVVDWRDOORUDGDTXHOODJHQWHQRQVLSXzGLUH
QLHQWHGLSUHFLVRPDQRQHUDQLFHQR3XzGDUVLFKHTXHOOLVLRSSRQHYDQR
D*UHJRULRSHUFKpYHVFRYRLQWUXVRLOOHJDOHHGHVWUDQHR
9L SRWHYDQR HVVHUH DQFKH L PRQDFL FKH IDFHYDQR FDSR D XQ FHUWR
,VDFFR (JOL IRQGz XQ PRQDVWHUR D &RVWDQWLQRSROL TXDOFKH WHPSR GRSR
ODPRUWHGL9DOHQWHDYYHQXWDQHOFKHHUDVXRQHPLFRJLXUDWRVHFRQ
GR7HRGRUHWRGL&LURDYUHEEHULSURYDWR9DOHQWHSULPDGHOODEDWWDJOLDFRQ
L*RWLGLFHQGRJOLFKHHUDVWDWR'LRVWHVVR³DVXVFLWDUHLEDUEDULFRQWURGLWH
SHUFKpWXKDLVXVFLWDWRPROWHOLQJXHDOODEHVWHPPLDFRQWURGLOXLHFDFFLDWR
GDLVDFULWHPSOLTXHOOLFKHORORGDYDQR´/¶,PSHUDWRUHULVSRVHFKHGRSRLO
VXRULWRUQRORDYUHEEHXFFLVRPDSHUVHODEDWWDJOLDHQRQWRUQzPDL*LDFFKp
9DOHQWH DSSRJJLDYD LO SDUWLWR GHJOL DQWL QLFHQL H ,VDFFR OR ELDVLPDYD SHU
TXHVWRDEELDPRXQ¶DOWUDSURYDFKHLPRQDFL&RVWDQWLQRSROLQRQQHFHVVD
ULDPHQWHIRVVHURFRQWUDULD*UHJRULR1D]LDQ]HQRDFDXVDGHOFUHGRSURIHV
VDWRQLFHQRRPHQRPDSHUDOWULPRWLYL4XLFLLQWHUHVVDFKHLOPRQDVWHUR
GL,VDFFRHUDJLjIRQGDWRQHOSHULRGRLQFXL*UHJRULRFHUFDYDGLLVWDOODUVL
D&RVWDQWLQRSROLFRPHYHVFRYR1RQVDSSLDPRFKHUHJRODVHJXLVVHLOVXR
PRQDVWHURHVHFHQHIRVVHTXDOFXQDPDXQDFRPXQLWjF¶HUD(VVDGXUz¿QR
DOODPRUWHGL,VDFFRQHO,QWDOPRGRHJOLSRWpRSHUDUHDQFRUDSHUWXWWR
*UHJRULXV1D]Epist
6DLQW*UpJRLUHGH1D]LDQ]HLettresW,SDU3DXO*DOOD\ 3DULV/H%HOOHV
/HWWHUHV
0DUDWRQLR ,9VHF GLDFRQRHIRQGDWRUHGLXQPRQDVWHURD&RVWDQWLQRSROL
DQWLQLFHQRYHVFRYRGL1LFRPHGLDGDO,QVLHPHD0DFHGRQLRFRPEDWWHYD
ODIHGHQHOODGLYLQLWjGHOOR6SLULWR6DQWR&I6RFUDWH+(,,6R]RPHQRV
+(,9
&I*'DJURQLe monachisme a Constantinople jusquau Concile de Chalcédoine--DQQLF³,VDFFR´Biblioteca Sanctorum V
7HRGRUHWR+(,9WUDG$QWRQLQR*DOOLFR 5RPD&LWWj1XRYD
FI6R]RPHQR9,
&I-3DURLUH³'DWHGHODPRUWGHVDLQW,VDDF´Echos d’Orient
23
Henryk Pietras SJ
LOWHPSRGHOSRQWL¿FDWRGL*LRYDQQL&ULVRVWRPRHGLQHYLWDELOPHQWHHQWUzLQ
FRQWUDVWRFRQOXL3DOODGLRVFULYHGL,VDFFR³,OSLFFROR6LURXQIUHTXHQWDWR
UHGHOOHSLD]]HFDSRGHLIDOVLPRQDFLVHPSUHRFFXSDWRQHOGLIIRQGHUHYRFL
PDOH¿FKHFRQWURLYHVFRYL´
$EELDPRYLVWRFKHHUDQLFHQRPDTXHVWRQRQHUDLPSRUWDQWHLQTXH
VWDIDFFHQGDSHUFKp±FRPHYHGUHPRLQVHJXLWR±LPRQDFLHUDQRFRQWUDUL
DOODVRWWRPLVVLRQHGHLPRQDVWHULDTXDOVLDVLYHVFRYRSUHVFLQGHQGRGDOVXR
FUHGR
2. Il conflitto tra i monaci “origenisti” e antropomorfiti
24
/HFRQWURYHUVLHRULJHQLDQHVRQRVRUWHDOOD¿QHGHO,9VHFRORFRPHXQ
FRQÀLWWRWUDLPRQDFLFKHFHUFDYDQRGLVHJXLUH2ULJHQHSXUWURSSRVHQ]D
FRPSUHQGHUHPROWRHGDOWULFKHORULSXGLDYDQRGHOWXWWR$*HUXVDOHPPH
LOYHVFRYR*LRYDQQLHUDWUDLVXRLDPPLUDWRULLQHPLFLLQYHFHVLVFKLHUD
URQRLQWRUQRDVDQ*LURODPRHVXRIUDWHOOR3DXOLQLDQR*LRYDQQLFKLHVHOD
PHGLD]LRQHGL7HR¿OR$OHVVDQGULQRGLFXLVDSHYDFKHHUDRULJHQLVWD(JOL
WHQWzODPHGLD]LRQHPDTXDQGRVLUHVHFRQWRFKHODVWHVVDFRQWHVDDYHYD
OXRJRDQFKHLQ(JLWWRHFKHJOLDQWLRULJHQLVWLHUDQRSLQXPHURVLFDPELz
O¶DWWHJJLDPHQWR,QIDWWLOHGXHFRORQLHGHLPRQDFLHJL]LVLWXDWHQHOGHVHUWR
DVXGRYHVWULVSHWWRDG$OHVVDQGULDHUDQRGLYLVHVXTXHOSXQWR6HFRQGR
JOLVWRULFLLPRQDFLGL1LWULDHUDQRLQWHOOHWWXDOLRULJHQLVWLLQYHFHTXHOOLGL
6NHWLV±UXGLLJQRUDQWL,OJLXGL]LRVXJOL³LJQRUDQWL´GL6NHWLVYDSUHVRFRQ
FDXWHODSHUFKpVHPEUDHVVHUHXQDRSLQLRQHWURSSRJHQHUDOL]]DQWHQRQFRQ
IHUPDWDGDOOHDOWUHIRQWL
4XDQGR7HR¿ORQHOODOHWWHUDSDVTXDOHGHOVLSURQXQFLzQXRYDPHQ
WH FRQWUR JOL DQWURSRPRU¿VPL QHO OLQJXDJJLR WHRORJLFR VX 'LR VHJXHQGR
2ULJHQHLPRQDFLGL6NHWLVVLVHQWLURQRRIIHVL6HFRQGR6DFUDWHVDUHEEHUR
VWDWLPLJOLDLDLPRQDFLDYHQLUHDG$OHVVDQGULDDSURWHVWDUHFRQWURLOYHVFR
3DOODGLRDialogo sulla vita di Giovanni Crisostomo9,DFXUDGL/RUHQ]R
'DWWULQR 5RPD&LWWj1XRYD
*LRYDQQLGL*HUXVDOHPPH PRUWRLO VXFFHVVRUHGL&LULOORGLIHQVRUH
GHOODPHPRULDGL2ULJHQH
&I$JRVWLQR)DYDOHTeofilo d’Alessandria (345 c. – 412) 7RULQR6RFLHWj
(GLWULFH,QWHUQD]LRQDOH
7HR¿ORYHVFRYRGL$OHVVDQGULDQHJOLDQQLYLROHQWRFRQWURLOSDJD
QHVLPRKDSURPRVVRODGLVWUX]LRQHGL6HUDSHLRQFRVWUXWWRUHGLQXPHURVH
FKLHVHQHPLFRRVWLOHGHOODVHGHFRVWDQWLQRSROLWDQDVYROVHUXRORGHFLVLYR
QHOSURFHVVRFRQWUR*LRYDQQL&ULVRVWRPR
6RFUDWH+(6R]RPHQR+(
&I:LSV]\FNDDrugi dar Nilu
Monaci – enfants terribles della Chiesa antica
YR0LQDFFLDYDQRGLSXQLUORFRPHHUHWLFRVHQRQDYHVVHFRQGDQQDWR2UL
JHQHHLVXRLVFULWWL,QTXHOODFLUFRVWDQ]D7HR¿ORVXELWRPRGL¿FzODSURSULD
RSLQLRQH GLHGH UDJLRQH DL ULEHOOL HG HVSUHVVDPHQWH GLFKLDUz ³)DUz FRPH
YRUUHWHSHUFKpDQFK¶LRGLVDSSURYRLOLEULGL2ULJHQHHFRQGDQQRFRORURFKH
OLGLIHQGRQR´'RSRXQWDOHGLVFRUVRLPRQDFLVHQHDQGDURQRFRQYLQWLGL
³FRQYHUWLUH´LOYHVFRYRHOXLSHUDYHUHORURGDOODVXDSDUWHSDVVzDHVVHUH
DQWLRULJHQLVWD&RQFLzSHUzHQWUzLQFRQÀLWWRFRQLPRQDFLGL1LWULDVR
SUDWWXWWRFRQTXDWWURGLORURGHWWL/XQJKL)UDWHOOLDFDXVDGHOODORURVWDWXUD
IDPRVL GL VDSLHQ]D H YLUW ¿QRUD VXRL DPLFL 8QR GL ORUR 'LRVFRUR HUD
VWDWRGDSRFRRUGLQDWRYHVFRYR/DVLWXD]LRQHVLDJJUDYzTXDQGR7HR¿OR
RUGLQzDWXWWLYHVFRYLGL1LWULDHGL&HOOHO¶HVSXOVLRQHGHLPRQDFLRULJHQLVWL
3LRPHQRDOORVWHVVRWHPSR7HR¿ORHQWUzLQFRQWURYHUVLDFRQ,VLGRUR
O¶(OHPRVLQLHUHDQFKHOXL¿QRDTXHOPRPHQWRVXRXRPRGL¿GXFLDHRULJH
QLVWD /¶DPLFL]LD WHUPLQz TXDQGR ,VLGRUR QRQ YROOH WHVWLPRQLDUH D IDYRUH
GLXQD¿WWL]LDHUHGLWjFKHVDUHEEHVWDWDODVFLDWDDOODVRUHOODGL7HR¿OR FLRq
ODPDGUHGL&LULOOR$OHVVDQGULQR 3HUGLSLO¶(OHPRVLQLHUHDYHYDULFHYXWR
GDXQDVLJQRUDVROLGLSHULSRYHULHDYHYDVWDELOLWRFRQOHLFKHQRQO¶D
YUHEEHURGHWWRDOYHVFRYRSHUFKpOXLDYHYDVHPSUHELVRJQRGLGHQDURSHUOH
VXHLPSUHVHHGLOL]LHHODGRQDWULFHWHPHYDFKHDQFKHTXHVWLVROGLVDUHEEHUR
¿QLWLFRVu&RVu7HR¿ORSHUOLEHUDUVLGL,VLGRURORDYHYDSUHVHQWDWRFRPH
FDSRGHJOLRULJHQLVWLHVLHUDVHUYLWRGHLPRQDFLFRQWURGROXL6FULVVHD*L
URODPRLQIRUPDQGRORVXOODVXDQXRYDRSLQLRQHDQWLRULJHQLDQDHULFHYHWWH
XQDULVSRVWDOXVLQJKLHUD
3HUVHPLQDUHXOWHULRUPHQWH]L]]DQLDWUDLPRQDFL7HR¿ORVFULVVHORUR
GLQRQDVFROWDUHLOYHVFRYR'LRVFRURXQRGHL/XQJKL)UDWHOOLLQTXDQWRVH
JXDFHGL2ULJHQHHDJJLXQVHULSHWHQGRORVORJDQGHJOLDQWLRULJHQLVWLFKH
'LRDEELDRUHFFKLRFFKLPDQLHSLHGL³VHFRQGROH6FULWWXUH´7UDLPRQDFL
VLPDQLIHVWzXQDVFLVVLRQHHTXHOOLGL6FHWLVFKLDPDURQR7HR¿ORLQVRFFRU
VR±RSSXUHOXLVWHVVRVLIHFHLQYLWDUH,OYHVFRYRVLUHFzVXELWRGDORURFRQ
PROWLYHVFRYLORFDOLSHUIDUHXQVLQRGRin situHFRQGDQQDUHJOLRULJHQLVWL
ORGHVFULYHODOHWWHUDVLQRGDOHULSRUWDWDGD*LURODPR9DOHODSHQDFLWDUQHXQ
IUDPPHQWRDVVDLSLWWRUHVFR³3HQVRFKHSULPDDQFRUDGHOODQRVWUDOHWWHUDYL
qJLXQWDODQRWL]LDGLIIXVDVLLQXQEDWWHUG¶RFFKLRFKHFHUWHSHUVRQHKDQQR
WHQWDWRGLIDUDWWHFFKLUHO¶HUHVLDGL2ULJHQHQHLPRQDVWHULGL1LWULDHGLIDU
EHUHLQDFTXHVSRUFKHTXHOODFRPSDJQLDLQFRQWDPLQDWDGLPRQDFL4XHVWR
IDWWRFLKDVSLQWRDGDQGDUHGLSHUVRQDVXOSRVWR
$)DYDOHTeofilo d’Alessandria (345 c. – 412)
&I6R]RPHQR+(3DOODGLRDialogo sulla vita di Giovanni Crisostomo
DFXUDGL/RUHQ]D'DWWULQR5RPD&LWWj1XRYD
*LURODPREpist
6RFUDWH+(
25
Henryk Pietras SJ
26
/DQRVWUDSDXUDLQVHJXLWRDOOHSUHJKLHUHGLTXHLVDQWLHLQPRGRSDU
WLFRODUHGHLSDGULHGHLVDFHUGRWLFKHGLULJRQRLPRQDVWHULHUDTXHVWDFKHVH
WDUGDYDPRDGDQGDUFLTXHLWDOLFKHVDQQRDFFDUH]]DUHGROFHPHQWHOHRUHF
FKLHDYLGHGLFRVHSLDFHYROLDYUHEEHURSHUYHUWLWRLFXRULGHLVHPSOLFL3HU
ORURLOGHOLWWRqXQWLWRORGLQRELOWjHGKDQQRXQIXURUHWDOPHQWHUDEELRVR
TXDQGR O¶LJQRUDQ]D H OD VXSHUELD PHWWH ORUR LQ WHVWD XQD TXDOXQTXH VFHO
OHUDWH]]DGDFRPSLHUHFKHYLVLEXWWDQRDFDSR¿WWRVHQ]DDYHUHXQVHQVR
GHO OLPLWH VL FUHGRQR VDSLHQWL TXHVWD q OD UDGLFH GHO ORUR HUURUH H VRQR
FRQYLQWL GL HVVHUH GHOOH FLPH PHQWUH q SURSULR O¶RSSRVWR 0D QRQ EDVWD
ODORURSD]]LDVLVFDWHQDDOSXQWRFKHFRPPHWWRQRDWWHQWDWLFRQWURVHVWHV
VLDXWRPXWLODQGRVLFRQFROWHOOL/DORURVWXSLGDIDQWDVLDOLSRUWDDFUHGHUH
FKHqXQDSURYDGHOORURDWWDFFDPHQWRDOODUHOLJLRQHHDOO¶XPLOWjLOIDWWRGL
DQGDUVHQHSHUOHVWUDGHFRQODIURQWHVIUHJLDWDHOHRUHFFKLHPR]]H8QRGL
FRVWRURV¶qWDJOLDWRFRLGHQWLSDUWHGHOODOLQJXDSHUIDUYHGHUHDQFKHDJOL
LPEHFLOOL TXDQWR IRVVH WLPRUDWR QHO VDOYDJXDUGDUH L GLULWWL GL 'LR H GDYD
DFDSLUHSURSULRDWWUDYHUVRO¶LQFDSDFLWjGLDUWLFRODUSDURODFRQVFLROWH]]D
FKHUD]]DGLIXURUHJOLEUXFLDYDGHQWUR
+RSRLVFRSHUWRFKHTXHLWLSLDVVLHPHDGDOFXQLSHOOHJULQLFKHSDVVDYD
QRTXDOFKHWHPSRLQ(JLWWRVLVRQRVSRVWDWLQHOODYRVWUDSURYLQFLD LQTXDQWR
DJUD]LDTXHVWLXRPLQLQHKDQQRSRFDPDqLOGHQDURFKHOLDGHVFDPHQWUH
GRYUHEEHURSURFXUDUVLLOYLWWRFRQLOODYRURPDQXDOH HV¶qDYYHUDWDFRVuVX
GLORUROD6FULWWXUDª*OLHPSLDQGUDQQRD]RQ]RGLTXDHGLOj© 3V ´
6HPEUDFKHFLVLDVWDWDXQDEDWWDJOLDUHJRODUHWUDLPRQDFLFKHDTXHVWR
SURSRVLWRUHFOXWDURQRDQFKHGHJOLVFKLDYLHGHLFRQWDGLQLGHOOHYLFLQDQ]HGD
TXDQWR7HR¿ORVFULYHDOOD¿QHGHOODOHWWHUD³1RQPLIHUPRVXJOLDOWULIDWWL
TXHOOR GL DYHU WHQWDWR GL DPPD]]DUFL DG HVHPSLR VHQ]D FRQWDUH WXWWH OH
LQVLGLHHVFRJLWDWHSHUDUULYDUFLFRPHTXDQGRKDQQRRFFXSDWR±GRSRHVVHUH
VWDWLFRQGDQQDWL±SHUVLQRODFKLHVDFKHVLWURYDQHOPRQDVWHURGL1LWULDLP
SHGHQGRFLGLHQWUDUYLVLDDPHHDLPROWLYHVFRYLFKHPLDFFRPSDJQDYDQR
VLDDPROWLVXSHULRULGLPRQDVWHURYHQHUDELOLSHUYLWDHSHUHWj6LVRQRVHU
YLWLGLOLEHUWLHGLVFKLDYLSUH]]RODWLDUPDWLVLDSSRVLWDPHQWHSHURJQLVRUWD
GLGHOLWWRSXUGLVRGGLVIDUHODJRODHLOYHQWUH2FFXSDYDQRLSXQWLVWUDWHJLFL
GHOODFKLHVDFRPHVLWUDWWDVVHGHOO¶DVVHGLRGLXQDFLWWjHPDVFKHUDYDQRFRQ
UDPLGLSDOPDUDQGHOOLHEDVWRQLFRQLVLPEROLGHOODSDFHPLPHWL]]DYDQR
LOORURDQLPRGLVSRVWRDIDUVWUDJH,Q¿QHDI¿QFKpODORURID]LRQHDYHVVH
SLFRQVLVWHQ]DHLOORURIURQWHG¶DWWDFFRIRVVHSLSURQWRDGRJQLDXGDFLD
GLHGHURGHOGHQDURDXQEXRQQXPHURGLSHUVRQHLJQDUHGLWXWWR4XHVWHVH
ORLQWDVFDURQRQRQSHUIDUVLFRPSOLFLGHOO¶D]LRQHGHOLWWXRVDPDSHUVYHODUFL
$PPRQLR PRQDFR GL 1LWULD VL WDJOLz O¶RUHFFKLR SHU QRQ HVVHUH RUGLQDWR
YHVFRYR
*LURODPREpist
Monaci – enfants terribles della Chiesa antica
LORURSLDQLHSHUIDUFLFRQRVFHUHLWUDERFFKHWWLFKHFLHUDQRVWDWLSUHSDUDWL
HUDSHUIDUFLVWDUHLQJXDUGLD
$OOD YLVWD GL FLz TXHOOD IROOD GL PRQDFL FKH QRQ ¿QLYD SL FRPLQFLz
WXWWDTXDQWDDJULGDUHORVFRSRHUDGLPHWWHUSDXUDIDFHQGRVFKLDPD]]RWXWWL
LQVLHPHDTXHLSRFKLIRUVHQQDWLLQPRGRFKHTXHVWLFLGHVVHURODSRVVLELOLWj
±VHQRQDOWURSHUFKpYLQWDGDOODSDXUD±GLFHOHEUDUHOD6LQDVVLHGLVDOYDJXDU
GDUHFRVuLGLULWWLGHOOD&KLHVD6HQRQIRVVHVWDWDODJUD]LDGL'LRDIUHQDUHOR
VODQFLRLVWLQWLYRGHOODIROODVDUHEEHVXFFHVVRVHQ]¶DOWURTXDQWRQRUPDOPHQWH
DFFDGHQHOOHVHGL]LRQLSHUFKpDGLUHLOYHURTXHLWLSLVFHOOHUDWLVLHUDQRVFD
WHQDWLFRQXQDWDOHWHPHUDULHWjDQ]LGLUHLFRQXQDWDOHSD]]LDFKHSHUVLQR
LPRQDFLGLXQDFHUWDVDQWLWjGLYLWDHG¶XQDPDQVXHWXGLQHVHPSUHHTXLOLEUD
WLVVLPDQRQFHO¶DYUHEEHURIDWWDDWUDWWHQHUVLGLIURQWHDOORURIXURUH´
&HUWR7HR¿ORVFULYHSHUFUHDUHLPSUHVVLRQHFKHL³EXRQL´VRQRDQWUR
SRPRU¿WLL³FDWWLYL´LQYHFHRULJHQLVWL$OWUHIRQWLGLFRQRLOFRQWUDULR
$FRQGDQQDIDWWD7HR¿ORIHFHVuFKHDQFKHLOSUHIHWWRHQWUDVVHLQJLR
FRFRQODIDOVDDFFXVDFRQWURL/XQJKL)UDWHOOLGLDYHUSURYRFDWRXQDULEHO
OLRQHFRQWURLOYHVFRYR'DOSUHIHWWRDYHYDRWWHQXWRO¶HGLWWRLPSHULDOHPD
QRQ¿GDQGRVLGHOOHVROHSDUROHSHUVRQDOPHQWHUDGXQzXQJUXSSRGLJHQWH
YLROHQWDVHFRQGRTXDQWRVFULVVH3DOODGLRRSSXUHDUPzL³VXRL´PRQDFL
DQWURSRPRU¿WLHGRUJDQL]]zXQDVSHGL]LRQHSXQLWLYDVHFRQGR6RFUDWH*OL
HUHPLGHJOLRULJHQLVWLIXURQRGLVWUXWWLHEUXFLDWLFRQWXWWRFLzFKHQRQVLSR
WHYDUXEDUHLFRGLFLGHOOD%LEELDLQFOXVL8QJLRYDQHVDUHEEHDQFKHPRUWR
WUDOH¿DPPH,/XQJKL)UDWHOOLHDOWULPRQDFLIXURQRFRVWUHWWLDIXJJLUH
LVLUHFDURQRD*HUXVDOHPPHPROWLDOWULVLGLVSHUVHUR7HR¿ORFRQWLQXzOD
ORWWDFRQOHWWHUHHPHVVDJJHULLQYLDWLLQ3DOHVWLQDHD5RPDGRYXQTXHSRWH
YDQRIXJJLUHLSHUVHJXLWDWLLQVLVWHQGRVXJOLHUURULGL2ULJHQHHVXOO¶RSHUDUH
QRFLYRGHJOLRULJHQLVWL*LURODPRORVRVWHQHYDFRQHQWXVLDVPR
,QWXWWDTXHVWDYLFHQGDYHGLDPRLPRQDFLLPSHJQDWLSURIRQGDPHQWH
PDDQFKHPDQLSRODWLGD7HR¿OR6SHVVRDFFDGUjFRVuDQFKHLQIXWXUR
3. I monaci contro Giovanni Crisostomo
,OFRQÀLWWRWUDLOPRQDFR,VDFFRH*LRYDQQL&ULVRVWRPRJOLVWRULFLOR
GHVFULYRQRSRQHQGRO¶DFFHQWRVXOODFULWLFDGDSDUWHGHOYHVFRYRGHOO¶DWWHJ
JLDPHQWRGHLPRQDFLFKHSUHIHULYDQRXQ¶DWWLYLWjLQFLWWjDOODYLWDDVFHWLFD
QHOPRQDVWHUR'RYHYDTXLQGLWUDWWDUVLGLXQDUHD]LRQHDLWHQWDWLYLGL*LR
YDQQLGLVRWWRPHWWHUHLPRQDFLDOODVXDDXWRULWjHGDTXHOODGHLFKLHULFLLQ
*LURODPREpist
3DOODGLRDialogo
6RFUDWH+(
6R]RPHQR+(6RFUDWH+(
27
Henryk Pietras SJ
28
JHQHUDOH 6GHJQDWR GD TXHVWL WHQWDWLYL ,VDFFR FRQWULEXu DOOD FRQGDQQD GL
&ULVRVWRPRQHOVLQRGRAd quercumQHOFLRqDOOD5X¿QLDQDGRYHF¶HUD
XQ PRQDVWHUR DEEDQGRQDWR GD DQQL PD GD SRFR SUHVR LQ SRVVHVVR GD WUH
DVFHWL WUD FXL ,SD]LR PROWR IDPRVL SL WDUGL )R]LR ULSRUWD VHGLFL SXQWL
G¶DFFXVDFRQWUR&ULVRVWRPRIRUPXODWLSURSULRGDOXLLQDJJLXQWDDYHQWLQR
YHSUHVHQWDWHGDXQGLDFRQR*LRYDQQL
)R]LRVFULYHFKH,VDFFRHUDYHVFRYRPDVHPEUDHVVHUHTXHVWRXQHUUR
UH *UD]LHDOO¶DSSRJJLRPDVVLFFLRGL7HR¿ORGL$OHVVDQGULDLOVLQRGRGH
SRVH*LRYDQQLHTXHJOLDQGzLQHVLOLR6HFRQGROHSDUROHGL3DOODGLRFLWDWH
VRSUD,VDFFRQRQHUDVROWDQWRQHPLFRGL*LRYDQQLPDFRPSORWWDYDDQFKH
FRQWURDOWULYHVFRYL±VHQ]DSUHFLVDUHGLSL*LOEHUW'DJURQKDULFKLDPDWR
DWWHQ]LRQHVXOWHVWRGL=RVLPRORVWRULFRSDJDQRGHOO¶HSRFDLOTXDOHVFULVVH
GHLGLVRUGLQLYHUL¿FDWLVLDFDXVDGHLPRQDFLGRSRODSDUWHQ]DGL&ULVRVWRPR
3HU LPSHGLUH D TXDOFXQR QRQ YROXWR GD ORUR GL HQWUDUH QHOOD FDWWHGUDOH
LPRQDFLDYHYDQRRFFXSDWRODFKLHVDGL*LRYDQQL=RVLPRVFULYHDOSOXUDOH
GHOOH FKLHVH RFFXSDWH PD OD FRUUH]LRQH DO VLQJRODUH GHJOL HGLWRUL VHPEUD
ORJLFDHUHQGHLOUDFFRQWRSLYHURVLPLOH4XHOO¶RFFXSD]LRQHDYUHEEHSUR
YRFDWRO¶LUDGHOSRSRORFKHLQDFFRUGRFRQLVROGDWLDYUHEEHFHUFDWRGLULFRQ
TXLVWDUHODFDWWHGUDOHXFFLGHQGRPROWLPRQDFL6HFRQGR=RVLPRO¶D]LRQH
GRYHYD HVVHUH DVVDL FDRWLFD SHUFKp OD JHQWH FHUFDQGR L PRQDFL H GLVWLQ
JXHQGROLVRORSHULLYHVWLWLQHULVHODSUHVHFRQWXWWLTXHOOLYHVWLWLGLQHURSHU
OXWWRRSHUFDVRXFFLGHQGRDQFKHSDUHFFKL³LQQRFHQWL´,QFRQVHJXHQ]DGL
TXHVWLDYYHQLPHQWL,VDFFRIXFRVWUHWWRDIXJJLUHGD&RVWDQWLQRSROLFRQ7H
R¿ORG¶$OHVVDQGULDFRPHGLFRQRJOLVWRULFL/DVHGHGL&ULVRVWRPRqVWDWD
ULVLHGXWDSHUEUHYHWHPSRGD$UVDNLRVHGDOO¶DQQR±GD$WWLNRV$O
SRVWRGL,VDFFRDFDSRGHOPRQDVWHURVLLVWDOOz'DOPD]LRFRQO¶DSSRJJLR
,SD]LR FD PRQDFRGLIHQVRUHGHOOHOLEHUWjGHLPRQDFLQHPLFRGL
&ULVRVWRPRHGL1HVWRULR&I&DOOLQLFRVita di IpazioDFXUDGL&DUPHOR
&DSL]]L 5RPD&LWWj1XRYD
Ad quercum 6&/)R]LRBiblioteca
=RVLPR1XRYD6WRULD9HGL]LRQH=RVLPHHistoire nuovelle,,,SDU
)3DVFKRXG 3DULV/HV%HOOHV/HWWUHV FI*'DJURQLe monachisme
a Constantinople jusquau Concile de Chalcédoine
=RVLPHHistoire nuovelle,,,SDSSDUDWRFULWLFRSOD¿QHGHOOD
QRWDHVSOLFDWLYD
&I7(*UHJRU\³=RVLPRVDQGWKH3HRSOHRI&RQVWDQWLQRSOH´Byzantion
6RFUDWH+(9,6R]RPHQR+(9,,,
&I6RFUDWH+(9,
&I 9 *UXPHO ³'DOPDWR´ '+*( Vita Dalmatii $FWD
6DQFWRUXP9,,,]]]
Monaci – enfants terribles della Chiesa antica
GHOYHVFRYR$WWLFRHVLULYHOzGHJQRVXFFHVVRUHGL,VDFFRDQFKHVXOFDPSR
GLEDWWDJOLDDOORUDFRQWUR1HVWRULR
4. Il ruolo dei monaci nella controversia nestoriana
,SURWDJRQLVWLGHOODFRQWHVDGDSDUWHGHLPRQDFLHUDQR,SD]LRH'DO
PD]LRGXHDUFKLPDQGULWLFKHFRPLQFLDURQRXQ¶RIIHQVLYDFRQWURLOYHVFRYR
1HVWRULRDQFRUDSULPDFKHTXHVWLLQL]LDVVHOHVXHSUHGLFKHFRQWURLOWLWROR
Theotokos*HQLWULFHGL'LRFRQLOTXDOHWUDGL]LRQDOPHQWHVLRQRUDYD0DULD
9HUJLQH,SD]LRDYHYDSUHYLVWRODFRQGDQQDGL1HVWRULRDQFRUDTXDQGRHJOL
HUDLQYLDJJLRSHU&RVWDQWLQRSROLSHUULFHYHUHO¶HSLVFRSDWRLQFLWWj$YUHEEH
GHWWRDLFRQIUDWHOOL³)LJOLLRQRQPLGRSHQVLHURGLFLzFKHVXFFHGHUjSHU
FKpKRDYXWRXQDYLVLRQHVXOFRQWRGLOXLHGKRVDSXWRFKHHJOLGHYLHUjGDOOD
IHGHPDUHJQHUjVROWDQWRWUHDQQLHPH]]R´
/DVita di IpazioqVWDWDVFULWWDGRSRODVXDPRUWHFRQLOFKLDURLQWHQWR
GLORGDUORHFRQWDQWRGLPLUDFROL3RVVLDPRWXWWDYLDVXSSRUUHFKHSHUO¶DX
WRUHHUDFHUWRFKHLOVXRSURWDJRQLVWDHUDGDOODSDUWHGLFRORURFKHFRQGDQ
QDURQR1HVWRULR
&RPHFRQWUR&ULVRVWRPRDQFKHFRQWUR1HVWRULRLPRQDFLULYROJRQRDF
FXVHGLWLUDQQLDULVSHWWRDLPRQDVWHUL1RQVROWDQWRLPRQDFLSHUFKpFRQ]HOR
GDYYHUR HFFHVVLYR 1HVWRULR SHUVHJXLWDYD PROWL 1DX FLWD QHOO¶LQWURGX]LRQH
DOOHRSHUHGL1HVWRULRXQEUDQRGHOODOHJHQGDVLULDFDGL1HVWRULRGRYHOHJ
JLDPR³&RVWXLKDVRSSUHVVRJLRFKLWHDWURFDQWLFRQFHUWLEDOOLHDOWULGLYHU
WLPHQWLGHL5RPDQLSHUTXHVWRPRWLYRODFLWWjORRGLDYDSURIRQGDPHQWH´
*LjGRSRSRFKHVHWWLPDQHGDOVXRLQJUHVVRLOYHVFRYRqULXVFLWRDRW
WHQHUHGD7HRGRVLRXQDOHJJHFRQWURWXWWLLSRVVLELOLHUHWLFLWUDFXLDQFKHJOL
HXFKLWLFLRqLPRQDFL³HQWXVLDVWL´FKHJRGHYDQRGLXQDSSRJJLRSRSRODUH
DFDXVDGHOO¶DXVWHULWjGLYLWD/RVWHVVR1HVWRULRVFULYHFKHLVXRLQHPLFL
HUDQR ULXVFLWL D UDGXQDUH PROWL VYHQWXUDWL Pro domo sua 1HVWRULR HVLOLD
WR VFULYHYD FKH GRSR OD FRQGDQQD LQ (IHVR FKH O¶LPSHUDWRUH QRQ YROHYD
DFFHWWDUH±ULDVVXPLDPROHVXHSDUROH±LVXRLQHPLFLHEEHURO¶DXGDFLDGL
,QFLzFKHVHJXHGHYRPROWRD*LOEHUW'DJURQLe monachisme a Constantinople jusquau Concile de ChalcédoineApologia Dalmatii0DQVL
&I Epistola missa a sancta synodo [ephesina] ad dominum Dalmatium
0DQVL-HDQ5XIXVPlérophories329,,,1DXS
&DOOLQLFRVita di Ipazio
0DQVL 1HVWRULXV Le livre d’Héraclide SDU ) 1DX 3DULV
/HWRX]H\HWDQp 9,
1HVWRULXVLe livre d’HéraclideLQWURGX]LRQH9,,
&RGLFHGL7HRGRVLR;9,6&/
29
Henryk Pietras SJ
30
UDGXQDUHFRORURFKHVLHUDQRVHSDUDWLHGDOORQWDQDWLGDLPRQDVWHULDFDXVD
GHOODFRQGRWWDGLYLWDHGHLFRVWXPLVLQJRODULRSSXUHHUDQRVWDWLFDFFLDWLSHU
JOL VWHVVL PRWLYL HG DGGLULWWXUD TXHOOL SURYHQLHQWL GD YDULH VHWWH HUHWLFKH
2UJDQL]]DYDQRGHLUDGXQLGLSUHWLHGLPRQDFLSHUGHOLEHUDUHFRQWURGLOXL
$YHYDQR GDOOD ORUR SDUWH SHU¿QR GHJOL HXQXFKL GHOO¶LPSHUDWRUH 6LFFRPH
7HRGRVLR DSSUH]]DYD PROWR L PRQDFL ORUR VL XQLURQR FRQ O¶LQWHQ]LRQH GL
SHUVXDGHUORDI¿QFKpDSSURYDVVHOHVDQ]LRQLFRQFLOLDUL7XWWLLPRQDFLVLDF
FRUGDURQRDQFKHVHWUDGLORURHUDQRGLYLVLHSLHQLG¶LQYLGLDVRSUDWWXWWRSHU
JOLRQRULPRQGDQL6FHOVHURFRPHORURFDSRO¶DUFKLPDQGULWD'DOPDVLRFKH
SHUTXDUDQWRWWRDQQLQRQHUDXVFLWRGDOPRQDVWHUR/DVFHOWDHUDEHQIDWWD
SHUFKpHUDXQPRQDFRPROWRDSSUH]]DWRGDOO¶LPSHUDWRUH7HRGRVLRLOTXDOH
JOLDYHYDSURSRVWRGLDVVXPHUHLOFDULFRGLYHVFRYRSULPDGHOODQRPLQDGL
1HVWRULRPDFROXLUL¿XWzGLFKLDUDQGRVLSRFRLVWUXLWR6RWWRODVXDJXLGD
LPRQDFLVLUDGXQDURQRSHUOHVWUDGHFDQWDQGROHDQWLIRQHFRQO¶LQWHQ]LRQH
GLULXQLUHWXWWDODFLWWjHDQGDUHLQVLHPHGDOO¶LPSHUDWRUHSHULQÀXHQ]DUHOD
VXD YRORQWj /¶LPSHUDWRUH SHUz JOL ULFRUGz FKH OD FROSD HUD ORUR SHUFKp
QRQVDSHYDQRPHWWHUVLG¶DFFRUGRVXOFDQGLGDWRDOO¶HSLVFRSDWRUHVSLQJHYDQR
OHSURSRVWHGHOO¶LPSHUDWRUHHSHUFLzOXLHUDFRVWUHWWRDFHUFDUHXQRIXRUL
&RQ OH EXRQH LQWHQ]LRQL DYHYD IDWWR YHQLUH 1HVWRULR G¶$QWLRFKLD SHUFKp
HUDHVWUDQHRDJOLLQWULJKLGHOODFDSLWDOHHTXDQGRHUDQRVWDWHIRUPXODWHOH
DFFXVHFRQWURGLOXLDYHYDRUGLQDWRFKHIRVVHXQFRQFLOLRUHJRODUHDJLXGL
FDUHODFDXVD,QHPLFLGL1HVWRULRIHFHURXQFRQFLOLRLUUHJRODUHFRQWUROD
YRORQWjGHOO¶LPSHUDWRUHVHQ]DDVSHWWDUHFKHDUULYDVVHURD(IHVRWXWWLJOLLQ
YLWDWLVRORSHUFKpFRVuDYHYDYROXWR&LULOORG¶$OHVVDQGULD4XLQGL7HRGRVLR
QRQYROHYDDFFHWWDUHODFRQGDQQDGL1HVWRULRPD'DOPD]LRORWUDQTXLOOL]]z
DVVLFXUDQGRFKHOXLSHUVRQDOPHQWHSUHQGHYDVXOODVXDFRVFLHQ]DTXHVWDFRQ
GDQQDHGHUDSURQWRDULVSRQGHUHG¶DYDQWLDOWULEXQDOHGL&ULVWR&RVu7HRGR
VLRDFFRQVHQWuHLPRQDFLHJOLHUHWLFLFRQGDQQDWLLQSUHFHGHQ]DGD1HVWRULR
SUHVHURFRPHXQDORURYLWWRULD
1RQHQWULDPRQHOPHULWRGHO&RQFLOLRGL(IHVRGHOPDLOUXRORGL
PRQDFLYLIXFRQVLGHUHYROH'REELDPRDPPHWWHUHFKHORVWHVVR1HVWRULRQHL
SRFKLDQQLGHOVXRHSLVFRSDWRDQGzLQFHUFDGLPROWLJXDLDFDXVDGHOVXR
]HORFKHORSRUWDYDDGDYHUHJOLDWWHJJLDPHQWLSRFRIHOLFLSHUFKpWURSSRUD
GLFDOL6HQ]¶DOWURHUDXQXRPRRQHVWRPDSRFRSUXGHQWHQHOO¶DPPLQLVWUDUH
ODSURSULDRQHVWj6LVRQRFRQIHUPDWHOHSDUROHFKH7HRGRURGL0RSVXHVWLD
&I Epistola missa a sancta synodo [ephesina] ad dominum Dalmatium
0DQVL
1HVWRULXVLe livre d’Héraclide,,>@±>@
7HRGRURGL0RSVXHVWLD FD HVHJHWDHWHRORJRDQWLRFKHQRDPLFR
GL1HVWRULRGRSRODPRUWHDFFXVDWRGLSURIHVVDUHODFULVWRORJLDGL1HVWRULR
FRQGDQQDWDQHOD(IHVR
Monaci – enfants terribles della Chiesa antica
DYUHEEHULYROWRD1HVWRULRFRQJHGDQGRVLGDOXLSULPDFKHTXHVWLDUULYDVVH
D&RVWDQWLQRSROL6HFRQGRORVFULWWRVLULDFRGHOTXDOHKRJLjFLWDWRXQDIUDVH
7HRGRURJOLDYUHEEHGHWWR³,RWLFRQRVFR¿JOLRPLRQHVVXQDGRQQDDYHYD
SDUWRULWRXQ¿JOLRFRVu]HODQWHFRPHWH3HUFLzWLUDFFRPDQGRGLPRGHUDUHLO
WXR]HORQHOFRPEDWWHUHOHRSLQLRQLGHJOLDOWUL&RPHXQRFKHKDXQD¿JOLD
YHUJLQHHPROWREHOODGDXQDSDUWHVLUDOOHJUDGHOODVXDEHOOH]]DHG¶DOWUD
SDUWHWHPHFKHHVVDQRQFDGDQHOOHPDQLGHJOLXRPLQLLQRQHVWLHFKHQRQVLD
GLVRQRUDWDDFDXVDGHOODVXDEHOOH]]DFRVuDQFK¶LRPLUDOOHJURGHOWXR]HOR
PDGDYYHURWHPRFKHWXSHULVFDSHURSHUDGHJOLXRPLQLFDWWLYL´
/HVXHSUHRFFXSD]LRQLHUDQREHQIRQGDWH
,OYHURYLQFLWRUHGLWXWWDODFRQWURYHUVLDIXVHQ]¶DOWURO¶DUFKLPDQGULWD
'DOPD]LRD&RVWDQWLQRSROLFKHRWWHQQHFRQIHUPDGHOODVXDDXWRULWjGLYHQ
QHXQSLODVWURG¶RUWRGRVVLDHIHGHGHOPRQDFKHVLPRFRVWDQWLQRSROLWDQRXQD
IRU]DGLSULPRRUGLQHQHOODFKLHVD
5. Il monaco Eutiche e la lotta contro il vescovo Flaviano71
1HOODULYROWDFRQWUR1HVWRULRDFFDQWRD'DOPD]LRVLHUDIDWWRFRQRVFHUH
(XWLFKHXQPRQDFRFKHFRQGXFHYDYLWDPRQDVWLFDGDOODSULPDDGROHVFHQ]D
QHOVLYDQWDYDGLDYHUSDVVDWRVHWWDQWDDQQLQHOPRQDVWHUR$OWHPSRGHO
&RQFLOLRGL(IHVRDQFKHOXLHUDVWDWRLQYLWDWR±QRQVROR'DOPD]LR±DLQWHU
YHQLUHSUHVVRO¶LPSHUDWRUH&LULOORORFRQVLGHUDYDWDQWRDOSXQWRGLDYHUJOL
IDWWRPDQGDUHXQDFRSLDGHOOHGHFLVLRQLFRQFLOLDUL,OPRQDVWHURFKHGLUL
JHYDFRPHDUFKLPDQGULWDFRQWDYDFLUFDWUHFHQWRPRQDFL(UDIRUVHLOSL
JUDQGHWUDLPRQDVWHULGL&RVWDQWLQRSROLHSHUFLz(XWLFKHVLFRQVLGHUDYDFDSR
GLWXWWLLPRQDFLGHOODFDSLWDOHPDQRQVHPEUDFKHWXWWLQHIRVVHURG¶DFFRUGR
5LSRUWRXQDOLEHUDWUDGX]LRQHGDOIUDQFHVHGD1HVWRULXVLe livre d’HéraclideLQWURGX]LRQHGL)1DX9,
(XWLFKH FD PRQDFRHDUFKLPDQGULWDD&RVWDQWLQRSROL)ODYLDQR
YHVFRYRGL&RVWDQWLQRSROLQHJOLDQQL,OVXRLQVHJQDPHQWRVXOODGXH
QDWXUHGL&ULVWRLQXQDLSRVWDVLSURYRFzDVSUHDFFXVHGDSDUWHGL(XWLFKHFKH
O¶DFFXVzGLQHVWRULDQLVPR1HOODULFHUFDGHOOHIRQWLVHJXR+HIHOH/HFUHUFT
+/ Histoire des Conciles,, 3DULV/HWRX]H\HW$Qp
H*LOEHUW'DJURQLe monachisme a Constantinople jusquau Concile
de Chalcédoine$WWLGHLVLQRGLGL&RVWDQWLQRSROLGHOH
VHFRQGRO¶HGL]LRQHELOLQJXDLQ6&/
&IEpistola Eutychetis… ad papam Leonem >¿QLV@6\QRGLFRQ0DQVL
3*]]]
(SKHVXP Expositio fidei Eutychis0DQVL6&/
&IEpistola PRQDFKRUXP qui sub Eutyche ad concilium Ephesinum secundum0DQVL
31
Henryk Pietras SJ
32
6LFRQRVFRQRLQRPLGLYHQWLWUpDUFKLPDQGULWLFKHVRWWRVFULVVHURODFRQGDQQD
GL(XWLFKHQHO¿UPDWDGDWUHQWDYHVFRYLDOORUDO¶DPELHQWHPRQDVWLFR
GRYHYDHVVHUHSLXWWRVWRGLYLVR,OVXRRSHUDWRD&RVWDQWLQRSROLqGHVFULWWRGD
1HVWRULRHDQFKHVHqOHFLWRVRVSHWWDUHTXDOFKHHVDJHUD]LRQHQHOODVXDQDUUD
]LRQHSLXWWRVWRSDU]LDOHLIDWWLWURYDQRULVFRQWURQHOOHDOWUHIRQWL
1HVWRULRGLFHFKH)ODYLDQRXRPREXRQRHPRGHVWRHUDSRFRFDSDFH
GLSDUODUHLQSXEEOLFR,QTXHOOHFLUFRVWDQ]H(XWLFKHSXUQRQHVVHQGRYH
VFRYRVLGLFKLDYDYHVFRYRGHLYHVFRYLHGDOVXRPRQDVWHURGLULJHYDWXWWDOD
FKLHVDFRVWDQWLQRSROLWDQDWUDWWDQGR)ODYLDQRFRPHVHIRVVHXQVXRLQVHU
YLHQWH $YHYD O¶DSSRJJLR LPSHULDOH H FRVu VL SHUPHWWHYD GL FDFFLDUH GDOOD
FKLHVDFRORURFKHQRQFRQGLYLGHYDQROHVXHRSLQLRQLDSSRJJLDQGRLQYHFH
LVXRLDGXODWRUL)ODYLDQRUHQGHQGRVLFRQWRFKHWUDLPRQDVWHULVLFUHDYDQR
GHOOHGLVFRUGLHORLQYLWDYDDOODPRGHUD]LRQHHDOODSDFHPDOXLQRQYROHYD
DVFROWDUH&RQWLQXDYDDQHJDUHOHGXHQDWXUHGL&ULVWRHODVXDFRQVRVWDQ
]LDOLWjFRQJOLXRPLQL$OORUD(XVHELRYHVFRYRGL'RULOHRLQ)ULJLDFKH
DQQLSULPDDQFRUDODLFRHUDLOSULQFLSDOHDFFXVDWRUHGL1HVWRULRDGHVVRVL
qVGHJQDWRG¶DYDQWLDOODSRVL]LRQHUDGLFDOPHQWHRSSRVWDDTXHOODGL1HVWRULR
HVFULVVHXQ¶DFFXVDXI¿FLDOHHODGLUHVVHD)ODYLDQR,OYHVFRYRFRQYRFzXQ
VLQRGRRSSXUHXQDVHULHGLVHVVLRQLGHOVLQRGRendemuosaGRYHVLFHUFz
GLLQWHUURJDUH(XWLFKHPDTXHOORVLUL¿XWDYDGLYHQLUH'XUDQWHXQDGHOOH
VHGXWH(XVHELRGL'RULOHRGLVVHGLDYHUDSSUHVRFKH(XWLFKHDYHYDVFULWWR
OHWWHUHDYDULPRQDVWHULVXVFLWDQGRLPRQDFLDOODULEHOOLRQHFRQWURLOYHVFR
YR6ROWDQWRGRSRLOWHU]RLQYLWRLOQRYHPEUH(XWLFKHVLGHJQzGLSUH
VHQWDUVLFRQXQDVFRUWDGLQXPHURVLVROGDWLPRQDFLHSHUVLQRFRQODJXDUGLD
JXLGDWDGDOFRPDQGDQWHGHLSUHWRULDQLFRQLOsilentiarius0DJQR'RSR
O¶LQWHUURJD]LRQH(XWLFKHYHQQHFRQGDQQDWRHGHSRVWRGDOVXRLQFDULFRGLDU
FKLPDQGULWD&RPHJLjDYHYRGHWWRIXURQRYHQWLWUpDUFKLPDQGULWLD¿UPDUH
ODFRQGDQQD4XHVWRLQTXLHWz(XWLFKHWDQWRFKHLQXQDOHWWHUDDOSDSD/HRQH
SDUODGLHVVRFRPHGLXQDFRVDLQDXGLWDLOFKHVDUHEEHFKLHGHUHOH¿UPHGHL
PRQDFLFRQWURXQDOWURPRQDFR6RSUDWWXWWRJUD]LHDOOHPDFFKLQD]LRQLGL
XQ&ULVD¿RLOSULPRWUDJOLHXQXFKLGLFRUWHO¶LPSHUDWRUHQRQDSSURYzOD
FRQGDQQDHLQGLVVHLOFRQFLOLRD(IHVRFLWWjGHOODTXDOHGLFH1HVWRULRFKH
³IRVVHGHVWLQDWDHIRQGDWDSHUODGHSRVL]LRQHGHLYHVFRYLGL&RVWDQWLQRSR
&I6&/
&I06LPRQHWWL³(XVHELRGL'RULOHR´1'3$&,
1HVWRULXVLe livre d’Héraclide,,>@>@
&RQVWDQWLQRSROLV ;, 6&/
6&/
(XWLFKHEpistola ad LeonemQHOO¶HSLVWRODULRGL/HRQHEpist3/
Monaci – enfants terribles della Chiesa antica
OL´+HIHOHVFULYHDGGLULWWXUDGLWULXQYLUDWRIRUPDWRGD'LRVFRUR(XWLFKH
H&ULVD¿RFRQWURLOYHVFRYR)ODYLDQR
$FRQFLOLRULXQLWRLPRQDFLYHQXWLSHUVRVWHQHUH(XWLFKHSUHVHURSRV
VHVVRGHOODFLWWjFRPHVFULYH1HVWRULR(UDQRGDSSHUWXWWR6SLDYDQRLSRV
VLELOL VRVWHQLWRUL GL )ODYLDQR LQWLPRULYDQR JOL FRVWULQJHYDQR DOOD IXJD
(UDQRSUHVHQWLDQFKHQHOO¶DXODVLQRGDOHSHUWHQHUHRUGLQHFRPHDYHYDRUGL
QDWR'LRVFRURG¶$OHVVDQGULDDREEOLJDUHLYHVFRYLDULWUDWWDUHORUR¿UPDGL
FRQGDQQDGHOO¶DQQR)ODYLDQRYLHQHSHUVLQRSUHVRDERWWH(XVHELRGL
'RULOHRKDVFULWWRSRFRGRSRLOFRQFLOLRXQVXRUHVRFRQWRGHOORVYROJLPHQWR
GHOOHVHVVLRQL$QFKHDOWULKDQQRSDUODWRD&DOFHGRQLDFKH'LRVFRURFRQ
LVXRLVROGDWLHPRQDFLLPSHGLYDDLYHVFRYLSUHVHQWLGLDQQRWDUHTXDOVLDVL
FRVDSHUFRQWRSURSULR±ORSRWHYDQRIDUHVROWDQWRLVXRLQRWDULDLYHVFRYL
IDFHYD ¿UPDUH LQ ELDQFR VRWWR FRQWLQXH PLQDFFH &KL QRQ YROHYD VRWWR
VFULYHUHODFRQGDQQDGL)ODYLDQRULPDQHYDFKLXVRLQFKLHVDSHUODQRWWHLQ
FRPSDJQLDGHLPRQDFLDUPDWLGLVSDGHHEDVWRQLFKHIRU]DYDQRDOOD¿UPD
'LRJHQHGL&L]LFRSHUVLQRDFFXVzO¶DUFKLPDQGULWD%DUVXPDGLXFFLGHUHSHU
VRQDOPHQWH)ODYLDQR$QFKH%DVLOLRGL6HOHXFLDKDWHVWLPRQLDWRD&DOFH
GRQLDFKH'LRVFRURVLVHUYuGHLPRQDFLGL%DUVXPDHGHLSDUDODEDQLDOHV
VDQGULQL/DVXDWHVWLPRQLDQ]DSXzSHUzHVVHUHVRVSHWWDSHUFKpVHPEUD
FKHVLDVWDWRXRPRIDFLOHDFDPELDUHRSLQLRQLQHO¿UPzODFRQGDQQDGL
(XWLFKHHUDDQFKHOjQHOD(IHVRVHPSUHQHOULWUDWWzD&DO
FHGRQLR FHUFz GL GLVFROSDUVL GL TXHVWR )DFLOPHQWH VL SXz LQGRYLQDUH FKH
TXHVWDVXDRVFLOOD]LRQHSURYRFzDVSUHFULWLFKHGHLPRQDFL
'RSRWXWWHTXHVWHWHVWLPRQLDQ]HLSDGULFRQFLOLDULGHFLVHURGLIRUPXOD
UHGHLFDQRQLSHUUHJRODUHORVWDWRGHLPRQDFLHGHLPRQDVWHUL³&DQRQH
1HVWRULXVLe livre d’Héraclide,,>@
+/,,
1HVWRULXVLe livre d’Héraclide,,>@
Ibidem,>@
0DQVL+/,,
(YDJULR+(,,FI$-)HVWXJLqUH³eYDJUH+LVWRLUH(FFOpVLDVWLTXH´
Byzantion Q
0DQVL+/,,3DUDODEDQLFI&7K;9,6&/
FRQOHQRWH
&RQVWDQWLQRSROLV ;, 6&/
&RQVWDQWLQRSROLV DSULOLV 6&/
(SKHVXP 9,,, 6&/
&I -RKDQQHV 5XIXV Plérophories. Témoignages et révélations contre le
Concil de ChalcédoinepGSDU)1DX3DWURORJLD2ULHQWDOLV 3DULV
)LUPLQ'LGRWHW&R 1DXS
4XHVWLFDQRQLVRQRFLWDWLHEUHYHPHQWHFRPPHQWDWLLQ*'DJURQCosantinopoli, nascita di una capitale (330-451) 8QD WUDWWD]LRQH SL
33
Henryk Pietras SJ
34
, monaci non devono far nulla contro la volontà del proprio vescovo né
costruire un monastero, o occuparsi di cose mondane
4XHOOLFKHFRQVSLULWRYHURHVLQFHURLQWUDSUHQGRQRODYLWDVROLWDULDGH
YRQRHVVHUHVWLPDWLFRQYHQLHQWHPHQWH0DSRLFKpDOFXQLFROSUHWHVWRGHOOR
VWDWRPRQDVWLFRVFRQYROJRQROHFKLHVHHLSXEEOLFLDIIDULYDQQRGLFLWWjLQ
FLWWjVHQ]DDOFXQGLVFHUQLPHQWRHSUHVXPRQRDGGLULWWXUDGLFRVWUXLUVLGHL
PRQDVWHULqVHPEUDWREHQHFKHQHVVXQRLQTXDOVLDVLOXRJRSRVVDFRVWUXLUH
HIRQGDUHXQPRQDVWHURRXQRUDWRULRFRQWURLOYROHUHGHOYHVFRYRGHOODFLWWj
,PRQDFLLQROWUHLQFLDVFXQDFLWWjHUHJLRQHGHYRQRHVVHUVRWWRSRVWLDOYH
VFRYRGHYRQRDYHUFDUDODSDFHHDWWHQGHUHVRORDOGLJLXQRHDOODSUHJKLHUD
QHLOXRJKLORURDVVHJQDWLQRQGLDQRIDVWLGLRQpLQFRVHGLFDUDWWHUHHFFOHVLD
VWLFRQpLQFLzFKHULJXDUGDODYLWDG¶RJQLJLRUQRQpSUHQGDQRSDUWHDGHVVH
ODVFLDQGRLSURSULPRQDVWHULDPHQRFKHWDOYROWDQRQVLDORURFRPDQGDWRGDO
YHVFRYRGHOODFLWWjSHUXQDQHFHVVLWj1HVVXQRSXzDFFRJOLHUHQHLPRQDVWHUL
XQRVFKLDYRSHUFKpVLIDFFLDPRQDFRFRQWURODYRORQWjGHOVXRSDGURQH
(DEELDPRVWDELOLWRFKHFKLXQTXHWUDVJUHGLVFHTXHVWDQRVWUDGLVSRVL]LRQH
VLDVFRPXQLFDWRSHUFKpQRQVLGLDRFFDVLRQHGLEHVWHPPLDUHLOQRPHGHO
6LJQRUH%LVRJQDLQ¿QHFKHLOYHVFRYRGHOODFLWWjGHGLFKLOHQHFHVVDULHFXUH
DLPRQDVWHUL
&DQRQHGli ospizi dei poveri, i luoghi consacrati ai martiri e i monasteri siano sotto la potestà del vescovo
,FKLHULFLGHJOLRVSL]LSHULSRYHULGHLPRQDVWHULGHLVDQWXDULGHLPDU
WLULVLDQRVRJJHWWLDOO¶DXWRULWjGHLYHVFRYLGLFLDVFXQDFLWWjVHFRQGRO¶XVR
WUDPDQGDWRGDLVDQWLSDGULHQRQULFXVLQRSHUVXSHUELDGLHVVHUHVRWWRSRVWL
DOSURSULRYHVFRYR&KLWHQWHUjGLWUDVJUHGLUHTXHVWDGLVSRVL]LRQHLQTXDOVL
DVLPRGRHQRQVLVRWWRPHWWHUjDOSURSULRYHVFRYRVHFKLHULFRVLDSXQLWRVH
FRQGRLVDFULFDQRQLVHLQYHFHPRQDFRRODLFRVLDSULYDWRGHOODFRPXQLRQH
&DQRQHI membri dell’ordine sacerdotale non possono congiurare
o cospirare
,O GHOLWWR GL FRQJLXUD H GL FRVSLUD]LRQH q SURLELWR DQFKH GDOOH OHJJL
FLYLOLWDQWRSLGHY¶HVVHUHSURLELWRQHOODFKLHVDGL'LR6HTXLQGLDOFXQR
FKLHULFRRPRQDFRSUHQGHUjSDUWHDFRQJLXUHHQWUHUjLQVRFLHWjFRVSLUD
WLYLRSSXUHRUGLUjLQVLGLHFRQWURLYHVFRYLRFRQWURLFROOHJKLFKLHULFLVLD
VHQ]¶DOWURGLFKLDUDWRGHFDGXWRGDOVXRJUDGR
&DQRQHChe siano cacciati da Costantinopoli i chierici e i monaci
forestieri che fanno confusione
(¶JLXQWRDOOHRUHFFKLHGHOVDQWRVLQRGRFKHDOFXQLFKLHULFLRPRQD
FLVHQ]DPDQGDWRGHOORURYHVFRYRHDQ]LDGGLULWWXUDVFRPXQLFDWLGDOXL
DPSLD+/,,4XLqULSRUWDWDODWUDGX]LRQHGL*LXVHSSH$OEHULJR
Decisioni dei Concili ecumenici7RULQR87(7
&I*DQJUD FD F6&/
Monaci – enfants terribles della Chiesa antica
YHQXWLQHOODFLWWjLPSHULDOHGL&RVWDQWLQRSROLYLYLYRQRGDPROWRSURYR
FDQGRVRPPRVVHWXUEDQGRO¶RUGLQHQHOODFKLHVDHVDFFKHJJLDQGROHFDVH
GLTXDOFXQR3HUWDQWRTXHVWRVDQWRVLQRGRRUGLQDFKHFRVWRURVLDQRSULPD
DPPRQLWLGDOSXEEOLFRGLIHQVRUHGHOODFKLHVDVDQWLVVLPDGL&RVWDQWLQRSROL
SHUFKp VH QH YDGDQR GDOOD FLWWj LPSHULDOH 6H SRL FRQWLQXDQR QHOOD VWHVVD
FRQGRWWD VHQ]D DOFXQD YHUJRJQD VLDQR VFDFFLDWL GDO PHGHVLPR GLIHQVRUH
DQFKHFRQWURODORURYRORQWjHUDJJLXQJDQROHORURFLWWj´
4XHVWLSURYYHGLPHQWLQRQSLDFTXHURFHUWRDWXWWLFRPHDQFKHO¶DF
FHWWD]LRQHGHOTomoGL/HRQHD)ODYLDQRFRQXQDQHWWDGLVWLQ]LRQHWUDOH
QDWXUHGL&ULVWRHVRSUDWWXWWRQRQSLDFTXHLOFDQRQHFKHGDYDDOODFKLHVD
FRVWDQWLQRSROLWDQDSUHURJDWLYHPDLYLVWH
/D ULYDOLWj WUD $OHVVDQGULD H &RVWDQWLQRSROL DYUj XQD PRYLPHQWDWD
FRQWLQXD]LRQHHLPRQDFLDYUDQQRLOORURUXRORGDJLRFDUH6XELWRGRSRLO
&RQFLOLRFHUWLGLORURVLPLVHURDOO¶RSHUD(YDJULRVFULYH³1RQDYHYDQRSL
SDFHLOXRJKLGHOGHVHUWRYLFLQRD*HUXVDOHPPH(UDQRLQIDWWLDUULYDWLLQ
3DOHVWLQDFHUWLPRQDFLLTXDOLDYHYDQRDVVLVWLWRDOFRQFLOLRHDYHYDQRVFHOWR
SRVL]LRQLFRQWUDULHDTXHVWRODPHQWDQGRLOWUDGLPHQWRGHOODIHGHFRVWRUR
FHUFDYDQRGLHFFLWDUHHVRELOODUHO¶DPELHQWHPRQDVWLFR5LHQWUDWRQHOODSUR
SULDVHGH*LRYHQDOHSRLFKpYHQLYDIRU]DWRGDTXHLIDQDWLFLDUHVSLQJHUH
HDGDQDWHPL]]DUHODSURSULDIHGHULSDUzQHOODFLWWjLPSHULDOH$OORUDJOL
RSSRVLWRULDOFRQFLOLRGL&DOFHGRQLDGHLTXDOLV¶qDSSHQDSDUODWRUDGXQDWLVL
QHOODFKLHVDGHOOD6DQWD5HVXUUH]LRQHRUGLQDURQR7HRGRVLRFKHHUDVWDWRLO
SLWXUEROHQWRDOFRQFLOLRGL&DOFHGRQLDHSHUSULPRQHDYHYDGHQXQFLDWR
O¶HVLWRDLPRQDFL´
=DFFDULDGHVFULYHVXFFHVVLYLDYYHQLPHQWL³4XDQGRODQRWL]LDGHOO¶DF
FDGXWRDUULYzD0DUFLDQRTXHOORULPDQGz*LRYHQDOHD*HUXVDOHPPHFRQ
LOFRQWH'RURWHRHXQHVHUFLWRLQDSSRJJLR/jLOYHVFRYRDYUHEEHGHSRVWR
7HRGRVLRHWXWWLLYHVFRYLGDOXLRUGLQDWLHFHUFzGLFRQYLQFHUHLPRQDFLFKH
ULWRUQDVVHURDOODFRPXQLRQHFRQOXL(VVLUL¿XWDURQRSRQHQGRFRPHFRQGL
]LRQHO¶DQDWHPDGHO&RQFLOLRGL&DOFHGRQLD1RQULXVFHQGRFRQOHEXRQH
*LRYHQDOHSDVVzDOOHPLQDFFHHULFRUGzORURFKHODYRORQWjGHOO¶LPSHUDWRUH
HUDGLDFFHWWDUHLOFRQFLOLR,PRQDFLQRQVLDUUHVHURQHDQFKHDOORUDTXLQGL
RUGLQzDL5RPDQLHDL6DPDULWDQLFLRqDLOHJLRQDULGLXFFLGHUHWXWWLTXDQ
WL&¶HUDWUDL5RPDQLFKLDYHYDSLHWjGLORURPDO¶RUGLQHYHQQHHVHJXLWR
3LSUREDELOPHQWHIXLOFRPDQGDQWH'RURWHRDGDUHTXHVWRRUGLQHQRQLO
*LRYHQDOHYHVFRYRGL*HUXVDOHPPHQHJOLDQQLVHPSUHGDSDUWH
GHLYLQFLWRULH(IHVRQHOFRQWUR1HVWRULRQHOFRQWUR)ODYLDQRPD
D&DOFHGRQLDQHOFRQWUR(XWLFKHLFXLVRVWHQLWRULQRQJOLHORSHUGRQDVVHUR
'LTXHVWRSDUODLOIUDPPHQWRFLWDWR
(YDJULR+(,, WUDG)LOLSSR&DUFLRQH
35
Henryk Pietras SJ
36
YHVFRYRPD=DFFDULDVLPSDWL]]DYDFRQJOLDQWLFDOFHGRQHVLTXLQGLQRQJOL
GLVSLDFTXHGLPHWWHUHLQFDWWLYDOXFH*LRYHQDOHHLOVXRPRGRGLRSHUDUH´
'DOSXQWRGLYLVWDGHLFDOFHGRQHVLLPRQDFLGL3DOHVWLQDHUDQRenfants
terriblesSHUFKpVLRSSRQHYDQRDOYHVFRYROHJLWWLPR/RURDYHYDQRSHUz
OHORURUDJLRQLSHUFKpGLIHQGHYDQRODSURSULDIHGHQRQRVWDQWHO¶DSSRJJLR
LPSHULDOH H PLOLWDUH GL *LRYHQDOH 6HPEUD FKH 7HRGRVLR VLD VWDWR LO YHUR
UHVSRQVDELOHGHOODULYROWDQRQVROWDQWRHUDDUGHQWHVRVWHQLWRUHGHOODWHR
ORJLDFLULOOLDQDPDSHUVLQRXQVRVWHQLWRUHIDQDWLFR(YDJULRVFULYHGLXQD
OHWWHUDGHLPRQDFLSDOHVWLQHVLGLSURIHVVLRQHFDOFHGRQHVHLQFXLVLOHJJHFKH
FRVWXLHQWURLQFRQÀLWWRFRQLOSURSULRYHVFRYRDQFRUDSULPDGHOFRQFLOLR
HIHVLQR,,³FRQGDQQDWRGDOVXRYHVFRYRSHUSUDWLFKHYL]LRVHHGHVSXOVRGDO
VXRPRQDVWHURV¶HUDVSRVWDWRDG$OHVVDQGULDRYHHUDHQWUDWRLQFRQÀLWWR
FRQ'LRVFRURTXLQGLEDWWXWRLQTXDQWRVHGL]LRVRFRQPROWHSHUFRUVHHUD
VWDWRSRUWDWRLQJLURSHUODFLWWjVXOGRUVRG¶XQFDPPHOORFRPHDYYLHQHSHU
LFULPLQDOL´
1RQVDSSLDPRGLFKHVLWUDWWDVVHQHDQFKHVLDPRVLFXULVHIRVVHYHUR
)DWWRVWDFKHGRSRLOFRQFLOLRGL&DOFHGRQLDGRYHHUDSUHVHQWHGLYHQQHLO
VXRIHURFHRSSRVLWRUH%LVRJQDDQQRWDUHDQFKHFKHXQRGHLPRWLYLDVFHWLFL
GHLPRQDFLFRQWURLOFRQFLOLRHUDOHJDWRDOIDWWRFKHO¶LPSHUDWULFH3XOFKH
ULD FKH FRQ VXR PDULWR 0DUFLDQR DYHYD FRQYRFDWR LO FRQFLOLR HUD SULPD
XQDYHUJLQHFRQVDFUDWDHDYHYDURWWRLYRWLSHUVSRVDUVL,PRQDFLQHHUDQR
IRUWHPHQWHVGHJQDWLWDQWRSLFKHVHPEUDVLDVWDWRSURSULRDOEHQH¿FLR
GHOO¶LPSHUDWULFH FKH LO FRQFLOLR KD FRUUHWWR OD OHJJH PHQWUH D $QFLUD QHO
VLVWDELOLYDFKHXQDYHUJLQHFKHDYHVVHURWWRLOYRWRGLFDVWLWjHVLIRVVH
VSRVDWDGHYHIDUHXQDSHQLWHQ]DFRPHFKLFRQWUDHXQVHFRQGRPDWULPRQLR
HVDQ%DVLOLRUDFFRPDQGDYDGLWUDWWDUODFRPHXQ¶DGXOWHUDDOFRQFLOLRYHQ
QHSUHVFULWWR
³&DQRQHLe vergini consacrate a Dio non devono sposarsi.
1RQqOHFLWRDXQDYHUJLQHFKHVLVLDFRQVDFUDWDDO6LJQRUH,GGLRHFRVu
SXUHDXQPRQDFRFRQWUDUUHPDWULPRQLR&KLFLzIDFHVVHVLDVFRPXQLFDWR
&I3V=DFFDULD+(,,,
&I/RUHQ]R3HUURQHLa chiesa di Palestina e le controversie cristologiche
dal concilio di Efeso (431) al secondo concilio di Costantinopoli (553) %UH
VFLD3DLGHLD(GLWULFH
(YDJULR+(,,
-RKDQQHV5XIXVPlérophories. Témoignages et révélations contre le Concil
de ChalcédoinepGSDU)1DX3DWURORJLD2ULHQWDOLV 3DULV)LUPLQ'L
GRWHW&R 1DXS
-RKDQQHV5XIXVPlérophories1DX S
$QFLUD F6&/
%DVLOLXVFCanones Patrum Graecorum6&/
Monaci – enfants terribles della Chiesa antica
$EELDPRWXWWDYLDVWDELOLWRHVVHUHLQSRWHUHGHOYHVFRYRORFDOHPRVWUDUHYHU
VRGLHVVLXQDPLVHULFRUGLRVDFRPSUHQVLRQH´
9HGLDPRTXLQGLFKHLPRQDFLFRVWLWXLYDQRXQDIRU]DQRQLQGLIIHUHQWH
QHOOD &KLHVD /RWWDYDQR SHU OD SURSULD OLEHUWj H LQGLSHQGHQ]D GDO SRWHUH
GHLYHVFRYLPDDQFKHVLQFHUDPHQWHGLIHQGHYDQRODIHGHWDOHFRPHHUDVWD
DORURWUDVPHVVD/¶LVWUX]LRQHDVVDLOLPLWDWDQRQUHQGHYDIDFLOHXQGLDORJR
WHRORJLFR FRQ ORUR PD DQFKH YHGLDPR FKH FHUWL YHVFRYL VL VRQR DSSRVL
WDPHQWHVHUYLWLGLORURVXVFLWDQGROLDOOHUHD]LRQLYLROHQWHFRQODVFXVDGL
GLIHQGHUHODIHGHPDFRQXQLQWHQWRQDVFRVWRGLFRPEDWWHUHLSURSULULYDOL
37