VALUE IN HEALTH
Volume 17 Number 7 November 2014 ISSN 1098-3015
IN
HEALTH
VOLUME 17 NUMBER 7 NOVEMBER 2014
ISPOR 17th Annual European Congress Research Abstracts
November 8-12, 2014, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
ISPOR 6th Asia-Pacific Conference Abstracts
September 6-9, 2014, Beijing, China
Research Podium Abstracts
Research Poster Abstracts
PAGES A323–A822
ELSEVIER
www.ispor.org
EDITORIAL BOARD
Co-Editor-in-Chief
Michael Drummond, PhD
University of York
Heslington, York, UK
michael.drummond@york.ac.uk
Co-Editor-in-Chief
C. Daniel Mullins, PhD
University of Maryland
Baltimore, MD, USA
dmullins@rx.umaryland.edu
CO-EDITORS
Maiwenn Al, PhD
iMTA - Erasmus University Rotterdam
Rotterdam, The Netherlands
al@bmg.eur.nl
Ulla S. Skjoldborg, PhD, MA
Novo Nordisk A/S
Copenhagen, Denmark
ulla@skjoldborg.biz
Peter Neumann, ScD
Tufts University School of Medicine,
Boston, MA, USA
pneumann@tuftsmedicalcenter.org
Kalipso Chalkidou, MD, PhD
NICE
London, UK
kalipso.chalkidou@gmail.com
David Veenstra, PhD, PharmD
University of Washington
Seattle, WA, USA
veenstra@u.washington.edu
Chris L. Pashos, PhD
United BioSource Corporation
Lexington, MA, USA
chris.pashos@unitedbiosource.com
Joshua Cohen, PhD
Tufts CSDD
Boston, MA, USA
joshua.cohen@tufts.edu
Allan Wailoo, PhD, BSc, MA
University of Sheffield
Sheffield, UK
A.J.Wailoo@sheffield.ac.uk
Shelby Reed, PhD, RPH
Duke Clinical Research Institute
Durham, NC, USA
shelby.reed@duke.edu
Jalpa Doshi, PhD
University of Pennsylvania
Philadelphia, PA, USA
jdoshi@mail.med.upenn.edu
Danielle Whicher, PhD, MHS
PCORI
Washington, DC, USA
dwhicher@jhsph.edu
Uwe Seibert, MD, MPH, MSc, ScD
University of Health Sciences,
Medical Informatics & Technology
Hall i.T., Austria
uwe.siebert@umit.at
Sheri Fehnel, PhD, MA
RTI Health Solutions
Research Triangle Park, NC, USA
sfehnel@rti.org
Alex Z. Fu, PhD
Georgetown University
Washington, DC, USA
zf54@georgetown.edu
Benjamin P. Geisler, MD, MPH
Health Care Value Strategies
Somerville, MA, USA
ben.geisler@gmail.com
Ron Goeree, MA
PATH Research Institute, McMaster University
Hamilton, ON, Canada
goereer@mcmaster.ca
Dan Greenberg, PhD
Ben-Gurion University of the Negev
Beer-Sheva, Israel
dangr@bgu.ac.il
Teresa Kauf, PhD
University of Florida
Gainesville, FL, USA
tkandrb@gmail.com
Andrew Lloyd, DPhil, BSc
ICON
Oxford, UK
andrew.lloyd@oxfordoutcomes.com
Andrea Manca, PhD, MSc
University of York
York, UK
andrea.manca@york.ac.uk
Richard Willke, PhD
Pfizer Inc.
New York, NY, USA
Richard.J.Willke@pfizer.com
EDITORIAL ADVISORY BOARD
Alan Brennan, PhD
University of Sheffield
Sheffield, UK
A.Brennan@sheffield.ac.uk
Andrew Briggs, DPhil
University of Glasgow
Glasgow, UK
a.briggs@clinmed.gla.ac.uk
John Hornberger, MD, MS
Cedar Associates, LLC
Menlo Park, CA, USA
jhornberger@cedarecon.com
Johan L. (Hans) Severens, PhD
Erasmus University
Rotterdam, The Netherlands
severens@bmg.eur.nl
Sean Sullivan, PhD
University of Washington
Seattle, WA, USA
sdsull@u.washington.edu
Milton C. Weinstein, PhD
Harvard School of Public Health
Boston, MA, USA
mcw@hsph.harvard.edu
MANAGEMENT ADVISORY BOARD
Maarten J. IJzerman, PhD (Chair)
University of Twente
Enschede, The Netherlands
m.j.ijzerman@utwente.nl
Don Husereau, MSc, BSc
University of Ottawa
Ottawa, ON, Canada
don.husereau@gmail.com
Josephine Mauskopf, PhD
RTI Health Solutions
Triangle Park, NC, USA
jmauskopf@rti.org
Pablo Lapuerta, MD
Lexicon Pharmaceuticals
Princeton, NJ, USA
lapuertp@yahoo.com
Jan Busschbach, PhD
Erasmus University
Rotterdam, Netherlands
j.vanbusschbach@erasmusmc.nl
Adrian Levy, PhD
Dalhousie University
Halifax, NS, Canada
adrian.levy@dal.ca
EDITORIAL OFFICE
Managing Editor
Paul Scuffham, PhD, BA
Griffith University - School of Medicine
Queensland, Australia
p.scuffham@griffith.edu.au
Bryan Luce, PhD, MBA
PCORI
Washington, DC USA
bluce@pcori.org
Ya-Chen (Tina) Shih, PhD, MS
University of Chicago
Chicago, IL, USA
tshih@medicine.bsb.uchicago.edu
Richard J. Milne, PhD
University of Auckland
Auckland, New Zealand
rj.milne@auckland.ac.nz
Stephen L. Priori
ISPOR
Lawrenceville, NJ, USA
spriori@ispor.org
Editorial Assistant
Angela Buziak
ISPOR
Lawrenceville, NJ, USA
abuziak@ispor.org
VOLUME 17
NUMBER 7
NOVEMBER 2014
ISPOR 17TH ANNUAL EUROPEAN CONGRESS RESEARCH ABSTRACTS
A323
A324
A324
A325
A326
A326
Research Podium Presentations – Session I
Cancer Outcomes Research Studies: CN1–CN4
Conceptual Papers: CP1–CP4
Diagnostic Research Studies: DI1–DI4
Health Care Expenditure Studies: HC1–HC4
Research on Methods – Modeling Studies: MO1–MO4
QALY-Related Studies: QA1–QA4
A327
A328
A329
A329
A330
A331
Research Podium Presentations – Session II
Cardiovascular Disease Research Studies: CV1–CV4
Health Services Research Studies: HS1–HS4
Medication Adherence Studies: MA1–MA4
Studies on NICE Assessments: NI1–NI4
Research on Methods – Preference Studies: PR1–PR4
Quality of Life and Utility Studies: QL1–QL4
A332
A337
A353
A357
Research Poster Presentations – Session I
Disease-Specific Studies
Diabetes/Endocrine Disorders – Clinical Outcomes Studies: PDB1–PDB32
Diabetes/Endocrine Disorders – Cost Studies: PDB33–PDB119
Diabetes/Endocrine Disorders – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference Studies: PDB120–PDB143
Diabetes/Endocrine Disorders – Health Care Use & Policy Studies: PDB144–PDB174
A362
A363
A368
A370
Gastrointestinal Disorders – Clinical Outcomes Studies: PGI1–PGI6
Gastrointestinal Disorders – Cost Studies: PGI7–PGI33
Gastrointestinal Disorders – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference Studies: PGI34–PGI42
Gastrointestinal Disorders – Health Care Use & Policy Studies: PGI43–PGI56
A372
A375
A383
A388
Muscular-Skeletal Disorders – Clinical Outcomes Studies: PMS1–PMS13
Muscular-Skeletal Disorders – Cost Studies: PMS14–PMS62
Muscular-Skeletal Disorders – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference Studies: PMS63–PMS84
Muscular-Skeletal Disorders – Health Care Use & Policy Studies: PMS85–PMS97
A390
A393
A400
A403
Neurological Disorders – Clinical Outcomes Studies: PND1–PND16
Neurological Disorders – Cost Studies: PND17–PND55
Neurological Disorders – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference Studies: PND56–PND73
Neurological Disorders – Health Care Use & Policy Studies: PND74–PND80
A405
A405
A406
A406
A417
A418
A418
A432
A436
Research Poster Presentations – Session II
Health Care Use & Policy Studies
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Consumer Role In Health Care: PHP1–PHP4
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Diagnosis Related Group: PHP5–PHP6
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Disease Management: PHP8–PHP10
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Drug/Device/Diagnostic Use & Policy: PHP11–PHP74
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Equity and Access: PHP75–PHP82
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Formulary Development: PHP83–PHP86
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Health Care Costs & Management: PHP87–PHP168
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Health Care Research & Education: PHP169–PHP193
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Health Technology Assessment Programs: PHP194–PHP247
VALUE IN HEALTH 17 (2014)
A445
A446
A447
A447
A448
A448
A449
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Patient Registries & Post-Marketing Studies: PHP248–PHP249
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Population Health: PHP250–PHP254
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Prescribing Behavior & Treatment Guidelines: PHP255–PHP258
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Quality Of Care: PHP259–PHP260
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Regulation Of Health Care Sector: PHP261–PHP265
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Risk Sharing/Performance-Based Agreements: PHP266–PHP271
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Conceptual Papers: PHP272–PHP297
A453
A456
A460
A463
Disease-Specific Studies
Mental Health – Clinical Outcomes Studies: PMH1–PMH15
Mental Health – Cost Studies: PMH16–PMH38
Mental Health – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference Studies: PMH39–PMH56
Mental Health – Health Care Use & Policy Studies: PMH57–PMH74
A466
A467
A471
A472
Urinary/Kidney Disorders – Clinical Outcomes Studies: PUK1–PUK4
Urinary/Kidney Disorders – Cost Studies: PUK5–PUK26
Urinary/Kidney Disorders – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference Studies: PUK27–PUK34
Urinary/Kidney Disorders – Health Care Use & Policy Studies: PUK35
A472
A478
A492
A497
Research Poster Presentations – Session III
Disease–Specific Studies
Cardiovascular Disorders – Clinical Outcomes Studies: PCV1–PCV35
Cardiovascular Disorders – Cost Studies: PCV36–PCV113
Cardiovascular Disorders – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference Studies: PCV114–PCV140
Cardiovascular Disorders – Health Care Use & Policy Studies: PCV141–PCV183
A505
A506
A512
A518
Individual’s Health – Clinical Outcomes Studies: PIH1–PIH11
Individual’s Health – Cost Studies: PIH13–PIH44
Individual’s Health – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference Studies: PIH45–PIH82
Individual’s Health – Health Care Use & Policy Studies: PIH83–PIH99
A512
A525
A534
A539
Systemic Disorders/Conditions – Clinical Outcomes Studies: PSY1–PSY18
Systemic Disorders/Conditions – Cost Studies: PSY20–PSY73
Systemic Disorders/Conditions – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference Studies: PSY74–PSY97
Systemic Disorders/Conditions – Health Care Use & Policy Studies: PSY98–PSY121
A543
A547
A553
A555
A567
A576
A580
A583
Research Poster Presentations – Session IV
Research on Methods Studies
Research on Methods – Clinical Outcomes Methods: PRM1–PRM25
Research on Methods – Cost Methods: PRM26–PRM55
Research on Methods – Databases & Management Methods: PRM56–PRM72
Research on Methods – Modeling Methods: PRM73–PRM134
Research on Methods – Patient-Reported Outcomes Studies: PRM135–PRM184
Research on Methods – Statistical Methods: PRM186–PRM211
Research on Methods – Study Design: PRM212–PRM228
Research on Methods – Conceptual Papers: PRM229–PRM256
A588
A591
A599
A602
Disease-Specific Studies
Respiratory-Related Disorders – Clinical Outcomes Studies: PRS1–PRS16
Respiratory-Related Disorders – Cost Studies: PRS17–PRS65
Respiratory-Related Disorders – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference Studies: PRS66–PRS81
Respiratory-Related Disorders – Health Care Use & Policy Studies: PRS82–PRS89
A604
A605
A610
A612
Sensory Systems Disorders – Clinical Outcomes Studies: PSS1–PSS9
Sensory Systems Disorders – Cost Studies: PSS10–PSS36
Sensory Systems Disorders – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference Studies: PSS37–PSS51
Sensory Systems Disorders – Health Care Use & Policy Studies: PSS52–PSS59
VALUE IN HEALTH 17 (2014)
A614
A621
A645
A651
Research Poster Presentations – Session V
Disease-Specific Studies
Cancer – Clinical Outcomes Studies: PCN1–PCN40
Cancer – Cost Studies: PCN41–PCN176
Cancer – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference Studies: PCN177-PCN212
Cancer – Health Care Use & Policy Studies: PCN212–PCN281
A664
A667
A681
A682
Infection – Clinical Outcomes Studies: PIN1–PIN20
Infection – Cost Studies: PIN21–PIN97
Infection – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference Studies: PIN98–PIN103
Infection – Health Care Use & Policy Studies: PIN104–PIN125
A687
ISPOR 17TH ANNUAL EUROPEAN CONGRESS DISCLOSURE INFORMATION
A700
ISPOR 17TH ANNUAL EUROPEAN CONGRESS RESEARCH ABSTRACTS AUTHOR INDEX
ISPOR 6TH ASIA-PACIFIC CONFERENCE ABSTRACTS
A719
A719
A720
A721
A722
Research Podium Presentations – Session I
Cancer Outcomes Research Studies: CN1–CN4
Diabetes Outcomes Research Studies: DB1–DB4
Drug Use Studies: DU1–DU4
Health Services Research Studies: HS1–HS4
Mental Health Outcomes Research Studies: MH1–MH4
A722
A723
A724
A725
A725
Research Podium Presentations – Session II
Cardiovascular Disease Outcomes Research Studies: CV1–CV4
Health Care Reimbursement Studies: HC1–HC4
Infectious Disease Outcomes Research Studies: IN1–IN4
QALY-Related Studies: QA1–QA4
Respiratory-Related Disorders Outcomes Research Studies: RR1–RR4
A726
A727
A728
A729
A730
A731
A731
A732
Research Poster Presentations – Session I
Research on Methods Studies
Research on Methods – Clinical Outcomes Methods: PRM1–PRM7
Research on Methods – Cost Methods: PRM8–PRM10
Research on Methods – Databases & Management Methods: PRM11–PRM16
Research on Methods – Modeling Methods: PRM17–PRM24
Research on Methods – Patient-Reported Outcomes Studies: PRM25–PRM31
Research on Methods – Statistical Methods: PRM32
Research on Methods – Study Design: PRM33–PRM34
Research on Methods – Conceptual Papers: PRM35–PRM40
A733
A734
A737
A739
Disease-Specific Studies
Cancer – Clinical Outcomes Studies: PCN1–PCN5
Cancer – Cost Studies: PCN6–PCN28
Cancer – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference Studies: PCN29–PCN36
Cancer – Health Care Use & Policy Studies: PCN37–PCN48
A740
A743
A746
A747
Diabetes/Endocrine Disorders – Clinical Outcomes Studies: PDB1–PDB12
Diabetes/Endocrine Disorders – Cost Studies: PDB13–PDB30
Diabetes/Endocrine Disorders – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference Studies: PDB31–PDB40
Diabetes/Endocrine Disorders – Health Care Use & Policy Studies: PDB41–PDB48
A749
A749
A750
Gastrointestinal Disorders – Clinical Outcomes Studies: PGI1–PGI4
Gastrointestinal Disorders – Cost Studies: PGI5
Gastrointestinal Disorders – Health Care Use & Policy Studies: PGI6
VALUE IN HEALTH 17 (2014)
A750
A751
A752
A754
Individual’s Health – Clinical Outcomes Studies: PIH1–PIH8
Individual’s Health – Cost Studies: PIH10–PIH13
Individual’s Health – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference Studies: PIH15–PIH27
Individual’s Health – Health Care Use & Policy Studies: PIH28–PIH37
A756
A759
A763
A764
Research Poster Presentations – Session II
Cardiovascular Disorders – Clinical Outcomes Studies: PCV1–PCV23
Cardiovascular Disorders – Cost Studies: PCV25–PCV44
Cardiovascular Disorders – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference Studies: PCV45–PCV51
Cardiovascular Disorders – Health Care Use & Policy Studies: PCV52–PCV58
A765
A767
A769
A770
Mental Health – Clinical Outcomes Studies: PMH1–PMH9
Mental Health – Cost Studies: PMH10–PMH23
Mental Health – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference Studies: PMH25–PMH30
Mental Health – Health Care Use & Policy Studies: PMH32–PMH36
A771
A772
A774
A775
Muscular-Skeletal Disorders – Clinical Outcomes Studies: PMS1–PMS7
Muscular-Skeletal Disorders – Cost Studies: PMS8–PMS19
Muscular-Skeletal Disorders – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference Studies: PMS20–PMS27
Muscular-Skeletal Disorders – Health Care Use & Policy Studies: PMS28–PMS32
A776
A777
A779
A780
Respiratory-Related Disorders – Clinical Outcomes Studies: PRS1–PRS8
Respiratory-Related Disorders – Cost Studies: PRS9–PRS19
Respiratory-Related Disorders – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference Studies: PRS20–PRS22
Respiratory-Related Disorders – Health Care Use & Policy Studies: PRS23–PRS28
A781
A781
A783
A783
Sensory Systems Disorders – Clinical Outcomes Studies: PSS1–PSS2
Sensory Systems Disorders – Cost Studies: PSS3–PSS9
Sensory Systems Disorders – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference Studies: PSS10–PSS12
Sensory Systems Disorders – Health Care Use & Policy Studies: PSS13
A783
A784
A784
A785
Systemic Disorders/Conditions – Clinical Outcomes Studies: PSY1–PSY4
Systemic Disorders/Conditions – Cost Studies: PSY5–PSY6
Systemic Disorders/Conditions – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference Studies: PSY7–PSY8
Systemic Disorders/Conditions – Health Care Use & Policy: PSY9–PSY11
A785
A785
A786
A786
A789
A790
A790
A796
A797
A798
A799
A799
A800
A800
A801
Research Poster Presentations – Session III
Health Care Use & Policy Studies
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Consumer Role in Health Care: PHP1–PHP2
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Diagnosis Related Group: PHP3
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Disease Management: PHP4–PHP5
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Drug/Device/Diagnostic Use & Policy: PHP6–PHP25
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Equity and Access: PHP26–PHP29
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Formulary Development: PHP31
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Health Care Costs & Management: PHP32–PHP70
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Health Care Research & Education: PHP71–PHP79
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Health Technology Assessment Programs: PHP81–PHP87
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Population Health: PHP88
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Prescribing Behavior & Treatment Guidelines: PHP89–PHP92
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Quality of Care: PHP93–PHP94
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Regulation of Health Care Sector: PHP95–PHP98
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Risk Sharing/Performance-Based Agreements: PHP100–PHP104
Health Care Use & Policy Studies – Conceptual Papers: PHP105–PHP113
A802
A804
A807
A808
InfectIon – Clinical Outcomes Studies: PIN1–PIN12
InfectIon – Cost Studies: PIN14–PIN27
InfectIon – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference Studies: PIN28–PIN31
InfectIon – Health Care Use & Policy Studies: PIN32–PIN35
VALUE IN HEALTH 17 (2014)
A808
A809
A809
A810
Neurological Disorders – Clinical Outcomes Studies: PND1
Neurological Disorders – Cost Studies: PND2–PND4
Neurological Disorders – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference Studies: PND5–PND6
Neurological Disorders – Health Care Use & Policy Studies: PND7–PND11
A810
A811
A812
Urinary/Kidney Disorders – Clinical Outcomes Studies: PUK1–PUK6
Urinary/Kidney Disorders – Cost Studies: PUK7–PUK13
Urinary/Kidney Disorders – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference Studies: PUK14–PUK16
A814
ISPOR 6TH ASIA-PACIFIC CONFERENCE ABSTRACTS DISCLOSURE INFORMATION
A818
ISPOR 6TH ASIA-PACIFIC CONFERENCE ABSTRACTS AUTHOR INDEX
Editorial Office. Value in Health, ISPOR, 505 Lawrence Square Blvd. South,
Lawrenceville, NJ 08648.
ISPOR Office. Marilyn Dix Smith, RPh, PhD, Executive Director, 505
Lawrence Square Blvd. South, Lawrenceville, NJ 08648.
Tel: (609) 586-4981, Fax: (609) 586-4982, E-mail: info@ispor.org,
Web site: http://www.ispor.org/valueinhealth_index.asp.
CUSTOMER SERVICE (orders, claims, online, change of address): Elsevier
Health Sciences Division, Subscription Customer Service, 3251 Riverport Lane,
Maryland Heights, MO 63043. Tel: (800) 654-2452 (U.S. and Canada); (314)
447-8871 (outside U.S. and Canada). Fax: (314) 447-8029. E-mail:
JournalsCustomerService-usa@elsevier.com (for print support);
JournalsOnlineSupport-usa@elsevier.com (for online support). Address changes
must be submitted four weeks in advance.
YEARLY SUBSCRIPTION RATES: United States and possessions: Individual
$298.00. All other countries (prices include airspeed delivery): Individual
$298.00. To receive student/resident rate, orders must be accompanied by
name of affiliated institution, date of term and the signature of program/residency
coordinator on institution letterhead. Orders will be billed at the individual rate
until proof of status is received. Current prices are in effect for back volumes
and back issues.
Further information on this journal is available from the Publisher or from this
journal’s website (http://www.elsevier.com/locate/jval). Information on other
Elsevier products is available through Elsevier’s website (http://www.
elsevier.com).
Author inquiries
For inquiries relating to the submission of articles (including electronic
submission where available), visit http:/www.elsevier.com/authors. The site also
provides the facility to track accepted articles and set up e-mail alerts to inform
you of when an article’s status has changed, as well as detailed artwork
guidelines, copyright information, frequently asked questions, and more. Please
see Information for Authors for individual journal. Contact details for questions
arising after acceptance of an article, especially those relating to proofs, are
provided after registration of an article for publication.
English language help service: Upon request, Elsevier will direct authors to
an agent who can check and improve the English of their paper
(before submission). Please contact authorsupport@elsevier.com for further
information.
Reprints. For queries about author offprints, e-mail authorsupport@
elsevier.com. To order 100 or more reprints for educational, commercial, or
promotional use, contact Derrick Imasa at (212) 633-3874, Elsevier Inc.,
360 Park Avenue South, New York, NY 10010-1710. Fax: (212) 462-1935; e-mail
reprints@elsevier.com. Reprints of single articles available online may be
obtained by purchasing Pay-Per-View access for $31.50 per article on the journal
website http://www.elsevier.com/locate/jval.
Copyright © 2014, International Society for Pharmacoeconomics and Outcomes
Research (ISPOR). Published by Elsevier Inc.
This journal and the individual contributions contained in it are protected under
copyright by International Society for Pharmacoeconomics and Outcomes
Research, and the following terms and conditions apply to their use:
Photocopying
Single photocopies of single articles may be made for personal use as allowed
by national copyright laws. Permission of the Publisher and payment of a fee is
required for all other photocopying, including multiple or systematic copying,
copying for advertising or promotional purposes, resale, and all forms of
document delivery. Special rates are available for educational institutions that
wish to make photocopies for non-profit educational classroom use.
Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier’s Rights Department in
Oxford, UK: phone +44 (0) 1865 843830, fax +44 (0) 1865 853333.
Requests may also be completed online via the Elsevier homepage
(http://www.elsevier.com/authors/obtaining-permission-to-re-use-elsevier-material).
In the USA, users may clear permissions and make payments through the
Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA;
phone: (978) 750-8400, fax: (978) 750-4744, and in the UK through the Copyright
Licensing Agency Rapid Clearance Service (CLARCS), 90 Tottenham Court Road,
London W1P 0LP, UK; phone: (+44) 20 7631 5555; fax: (+44) 20 7631 5500.
Other countries may have a local reprographic rights agency for payments.
Derivative Works
Subscribers may reproduce tables of contents or prepare lists of articles
including abstracts for internal circulation within their institutions. Permission of
the Publisher is required for resale or distribution outside the institution.
Permission of the Publisher is required for all other derivative works, including
compilations and translations.
Electronic Storage or Usage
Permission of the Publisher is required to store or use electronically any
material contained in this journal, including any article or part of an article.
Except as outlined above, no part of this publication may be reproduced, stored
in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic,
mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior written
permission of the Publisher.
Address permissions requests to: Elsevier Rights Department, at the fax and
e-mail addresses noted above.
Abstracting and Indexing
Value in Health is indexed in Index Medicus/MEDLINE, Current Contents/Social &
Behavioral Sciences, SciSearch/SCI Expanded, Social Sciences Citation Index,
International Pharmaceutical Abstracts, Embase/Excerpta Medica, SciVerse
Scopus and PsychInfo/Psychological Abstracts, and Journal Citation Reports/
Science Edition (Thomson ISI).
Notice
No responsibility is assumed by the Publisher or the International Society for
Pharmacoeconomics and Outcomes Research for any injury and/or damage to
persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise,
or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas
contained in the material herein. Because of rapid advances in the medical
sciences, in particular, independent verification of diagnoses and drug dosages
should be made.
Although all advertising material is expected to conform to ethical (medical)
standards, inclusion in this publication does not constitute a guarantee or
endorsement of the quality or value of such product or of the claims made of it
by its manufacturer.
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Available online at www.sciencedirect.com
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jval
ABSTRACTS
ISPOR 17TH ANNUAL EUROPEAN CONGRESS RESEARCH ABSTRACTS
intermediate-risk prostate cancer at relatively low cost/QALY thresholds,
and RP is expected to be the most cost-effective of available treatments at the
prevailing range of cost/QALY thresholds (i.e. ₤20,000-₤30,000) . However, large
decision uncertainty exists and acquiring further information is likely cost-effective. Future research on costs and utilities associated with treatment outcome and
adverse events is expected to be most valuable.
Research Podium Presentations – Session I
Cancer Outcomes Research Studies
CN1
Long-Term Impact of the Dutch Colorectal Cancer Screening
Programme on Cancer Incidence: Exploration of the Serrated
Pathway
Greuter M J 1, Lew J B 2, Berkhof J 1, Canfell K 2, Dekker E 3, Meijer G A 1, Coupe V M 1
1VU University Medical Center, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 2University of New South Wales,
Sydney, Australia, 3Academic Medical Center, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The Netherlands has recently started with the stepwise implementation of biennial faecal immunochemical testing for colorectal cancer (CRC). We
evaluated the impact of the transition to, and the fully implemented screening programme on the long-term CRC incidence and colonoscopy demand. Methods: The
previously reported and calibrated ASCCA model was set up to simulate the Dutch
CRC screening programme between 2014 and 2044. We adopted an open-model
approach by simulating multiple birth cohorts and combining the results while
accounting for the ageing of the population. Besides a no screening scenario, we
evaluated the impact of screening under three sets of natural history assumptions
which differed in the contribution of the serrated pathway to the CRC incidence
(0%, 15% and 30%). Model-predicted outcomes were CRC incidence and colonoscopy
demand per year. Results: Due to ageing, the model-predicted CRC incidence in
the no screening scenario increased from 77/100,000 in 2014 to 109/100,000 in 2044.
Under screening, the predicted CRC incidence in 2014 was between 105/100,000
(assuming all CRCs originate from adenomas) and 109/100,000 (assuming that 30% of
CRCs arises from serrated lesions) due to the detection of asymptomatic, prevalent
tumours. After this peak, the predicted incidence gradually decreased until in 2039 a
new equilibrium was reached, ranging between 65/100,000 and 71/100,000 assuming
that 100% versus 70% of CRCs originate from adenomas, respectively. Due to the
stepwise implementation, the predicted number of colonoscopies required for the
screening programme increased gradually over time from 38,000 (752,199 invitees)
in 2014 to 117,000 (2,154,875 invitees) in 2044. Conclusions: The Dutch screening
programme will markedly decrease CRC incidence in the next 25 years. The conclusions about the impact of screening were robust to key natural history assumptions.
With the results of this study, decision-makers can anticipate the expected change
in CRC-related health care use and colonoscopy demand.
CN2
Primary Treatments for Intermediate-Risk Prostate Cancer: a CostEffectiveness and Value-of-Information Analysis
M 1, IJzerman
M J 2, Steuten
LMG3
Piena
1PANAXEA bv, Enschede, The Netherlands, 2University of Twente and MIRA institute for
Biomedical Technology & Technical Medicine, Enschede, The Netherlands, 3University of Twente,
Enschede, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Intermediate-risk prostate cancer patients are recommended primary treatment with either radical prostatectomy (RP), external beam radiotherapy (EBRT), brachytherapy (BT), or EBRT plus high-dose rate BT boost (EBRT
+ HDR-BT); or expectant management with active surveillance (AS). The costs
of these treatments differ considerably, whilst the amount and quality of evidence for their comparative effectiveness in terms of disease progression,
adverse events and health-related quality of life is unbalanced and inconclusive.
Therefore, we undertook a cost-effectiveness analysis of RP, EBRT, BT, EBRT +
HDR-BT and AS, and performed a value-of-information analysis to direct future
research. Methods: We developed a probabilistic Markov model estimating the
expected incremental cost/(Quality Adjusted) Life Years from a UK-NHS perspective, with a time horizon of 10 years. Input data were obtained from the best
available literature. We explored the uncertainty around the model outcomes by
identifying the most influential parameters and estimating the expected value
of perfect (parameter) information. Results: AS is most likely to be cost-effective at a cost/QALY threshold (λ ) < ₤3,000/QALY, BT for λ ₤3,000 to ₤12,000/QALY
and RP for λ > ₤12,000/QALY. One-way sensitivity analysis shows that utilities
and probabilities of adverse events are main effect drivers and initial treatment
costs are main cost drivers. Large decision uncertainty exists around λ ₤11,000
with a population EVPI of nearly ₤100 million. The EVPPI suggests that eliminating uncertainty around costs and utilities is most worthwhile. Conclusions:
With current information AS and BT are cost-effective treatments for
CN3
Early Stage Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of a Brca1-Like Test to
Detect Triple Negative Breast Cancers Responsive to High Dose
Alkylating Chemotherapy
Miquel Cases A 1, Steuten L M G 2, Retèl V P 1, van Harten W H 2
1Netherlands Cancer Institute, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 2University of Twente, Enschede, The
Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Triple negative breast cancers (TNBC) with a BRCA1-like profile may
benefit from high dose alkylating chemotherapy (HDAC). This study examines
whether treating TNBC with personalized HDAC based on BRCA1-like testing can
be more cost-effective than current clinical practice. Additionally we estimated
the minimum required prevalence of BRCA1-likeness and the required positive
predictive value (PPV) for a BRCA1-like test to render this strategy cost-effective. Methods: Our markov model compared the outcomes of treating TNBC
women with personalized HDAC based on BRCA1-like testing vs. current clinical
practice from a societal Dutch perspective and a 20-year time horizon. From our
base-case model we assessed: 1) the incremental number of respondents; 2) the
incremental number of Quality Adjusted Life Years, 3) the incremental costs, and
4) the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER). We performed one-way sensitivity analysis (SA) of all model parameters, and two-way SA of prevalence and
PPV. Data were obtained from a current trial (NCT01057069), published literature
and expert opinions where necessary. Results: Based on our base-case analysis
with 68% BRCA1-like prevalence, 100% PPV, and costs of € 164 / test, treating TNBC
according to BRCA1-like testing would be cost-effective (€ 16.192/QALY). One-way
SA on the prevalence and PPV demonstrated that only the PPV drives the ICER
changes. In two-way SA, the lower bound for the two parameters was: prevalence
39.6% and PPV 46.4%. Regardless of prevalence, at PPVs > 46.4% BRCA1-like testing
was always cost-effective. Conclusions: Treating TNBC with personalized HDAC
based on BRCA1-like testing is expected to be cost-effective at a minimum PPV of
46%. This information can help test developers in decisions on further research
and development.
CN4
The Cost of Costing Treatments Incorrectly: Errors in the
Application of Drug Prices in Economic Models Due to Differing
Patient Weights
Hatswell A J 1, Porter J 1, Hertel N 2, Lee D 1
1BresMed, Sheffield, UK, 2Bristol Myers Squibb, Uxbridge, UK
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Drug costs are generally a key driver of the results of economic models.
We tested the impact on drug cost estimates for the following common approaches:
using mean patient weight, individual patient weights or fitting a distribution to the
observed patient weights. Methods: For the analysis, we utilised patient weight
and height data from trial CA184-024 (517 patients) in metastatic melanoma. Based
on this dataset, costs of a single administration of drug therapy were calculated
using UK list prices. Costs were calculated for four recently licensed treatments
with different posologies: ipilimumab (mg/kg, with 2 vial sizes), cabazitaxel (mg/
m2), ustekinumab (doubled dosage over 100kg patient weight) and romiplostim (µg/
kg, with a large, single vial size). Results: Cost estimates using the mean patient
weight were £18,750, £3,696, £2,147 and £482 per administration of ipilimumab,
cabazitaxel, ustekinumab and romiplostim, respectively. These results increased
by 4.9%, 2.3%, 10.3% and 36.6% when costing individual patient weights, and by
5.2%, 2.3%, 11.8% and 36.9% when fitting a distribution to the patient weights. The
use of only mean patient weight consistently underestimated costs compared to
methods that incorporated the distribution of weight data. Sampling from the
observed patient weight distribution provides a more accurate estimation of costs;
however, it is subject to over- or under-estimation, depending on enrolment in
a trial programme, particularly amongst patients who are substantially over- or
under-weight. Conclusions: Accurate estimation of drug costs requires an understanding of the distribution of patient weights. Failing to take this into account can
result in cost estimates that are substantially lower than will be seen in practice,
which could (in turn) impact treatment (implementation) decisions. These errors
would be further compounded should drug wastage not be adequately captured.
Modellers should be mindful of these issues when costing therapies or conducting
health technology assessment submissions.
Copyright © 2014, International Society for Pharmacoeconomics and Outcomes Research (ISPOR). Published by Elsevier Inc.
A324
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Conceptual Papers
CP1
The Evaluation of Economic Methods to Assess the Social Value of
Medical Interventions for Ultra-Rare Disorders (URDS)
Schlander M 1, Garattini S 2, Holm S 3, Kolominsky-Rabas P L 4, Nord E 5, Persson U 6,
Postma M J 7, Richardson J 8, Simoens S 9, de Sola-Morales O 10, Tolley K 11, Toumi M 12
1Institute for Innovation & Valuation in Health Care (InnoVal-HC), Wiesbaden, Germany, 2Mario
Negri Institute for Pharmacological Research, Milano, Italy, 3University of Manchester, Manchester,
UK, 4University of Erlangen, Erlangen, Germany, 5Norwegian Institute of Public Health, Oslo,
Norway, 6The Swedish Institute for Health Economics (IHE), Lund, Sweden, 7University of
Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands, 8Monash University, Clayton, Victoria, Australia, 9KU
Leuven, Leuven, Belgium, 10Sabirmedical, Barcelona, Spain, 11Tolley Health Economics Ltd.,
Buxton, Derbyshire, UK, 12University Claude Bernard Lyon 1, Lyon, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To develop a set of criteria to critically appraise the strengths and
weaknesses of health economic methods for the systematic valuation of interventions for ultra-rare disorders (URDs). Methods: An international group of clinical
and health economic experts met in conjunction with the Annual European ISPOR
Congresses in Berlin/Germany and Dublin/Ireland, November 2012 and 2013, to
deliberate and agree on a set of criteria to assess the potential of the various methods, which have been used or proposed to estimate the social value of medical
interventions for URDs. Results: The group identified a broad set of potential
criteria, which may be grouped according to the following dimensions: theoretical foundations (normative premises, i.e., links to moral and economic theories,
including - but not limited to – nonutilitarian consequentialist and deontological
reasoning, definition and treatment of core concepts of economic thinking such
as opportunity costs and efficiency), empirical underpinnings (social preferences
related to attributes of the health condition or of the person afflicted with it), and
pragmatic aspects (feasibility of implementation and potential for bias and misuse).
For each of the dimensions, a set of criteria has been agreed upon, which in turn
will need further scrutiny and justification. Conclusions: Previously, a need had
been identified for modifications or alternatives to the conventional logic of cost
effectiveness applying benchmarks for the maximum allowable cost per qualityadjusted life year (QALY). We propose a framework for the systematic assessment
how well different evaluation approaches reflect prevalent social norms and value
judgments. As a next step, the framework shall be applied on multi-criteria decision
analysis methods and social cost value analysis, either using the person trade-off
(PTO) or the relative social willingness-to-pay (RS-WTP) instrument.
validity of network meta-analysis; and (iv) the possibility of disagreement between
direct evidence and indirect evidence. We illustrate the framework using a network
meta-analysis of topical antibiotics without steroids for chronically discharging ears
with underlying eardrum perforations.
CP4
Amending the Guide to Methods of Technology Appraisal at Nice to
Incorporate two New Value Elements: Burden of Illness And Wider
Societal Impact
Knight H 1, Boysen M 1, Stevens A 2, Longson C 1
Institute for Health and Care Excellence, Manchester, UK, 2University of Birmingham,
Birmingham, UK
.
.
.
.
1National
Background: In July 2013 the Department of Health referred terms of reference for value based assessment of health technologies to NICE. Objective: We
present the approach taken over the past 11 months to amending the Guide to
Methods of Technology Appraisal to incorporate burden of illness and wider societal
impact. Methods: Given the time frame available, NICE built on prior work undertaken by the Department of Health (in the context of value based pricing) on the
concepts of burden of illness and wider societal benefits by commissioning the NICE
Decision Support Unit to review and critique this existing work. NICE reconvened the
working party from the Guide to the Methods of Technology Appraisal review which
took place in 2012, which included standing membership drawn from the stakeholder communities such as patient and professional organisations, academia and
pharmaceutical industry. The working party considered the prior work undertaken
by the Department of Health and the Decision Support Unit’s critique for burden of
illness and wider societal benefit, and provided advice on the incorporation of the
2 new value elements into NICE’s current methods at 4 meetings. A consultation
paper describing NICE’s proposals and draft of the amended sections of the methods
guide was published in March 2014, and consultation ran for 12 weeks. It is anticipated that the final amendment of the methods guide will be considered by the
NICE Board in advance of the ISPOR conference. Results: Key points drawn from
the discussion at the working party and consultation responses regarding burden
of illness and wider societal impact, will be discussed. Discussion: Considering
NICE’s ‘position’ in the world of health technology assessment and appraisal, the
conclusions from this latest amendment of the Guide to Methods of Technology
Appraisal to incorporate value based assessment will be (highly) anticipated.
Diagnostic Research Studies
CP2
Value in the Making: Harvesting the Value of Complex Medical
Innovations in Practice
Abrishami P 1, Boer A 2, Horstman K 1
University, Maastricht, The Netherlands, 2National Health Care Institute, Diemen, The
Netherlands
.
.
.
1Maastricht
Rapid development of medical innovations in the face of rising health care costs have
been calling for a more value-conscious adoption and diffusions of innovations. This
conceptual paper departs from swift adoption of the da Vinci surgical robot in the
Netherlands. It describes three challenges facing health care systems to evaluate
promising, yet complex and often expensive medical innovations. Firstly, they are
often adopted and diffused prior to their evidence-based superiority being proven.
Secondly, formal evaluation frameworks are somehow detached from the dynamics
of and incentives for adoption and diffusion of these innovations. Third, the real risks
and benefits of these innovations are not easily amenable to an experimental inquiry.
Unlike pharmaceuticals, whose impact is intrinsic to its biochemical components and
thus can be subject to experiment, the value of complex surgical devices, imaging
equipments, or targeted therapy interventions are inseparable from actual patterns
of human practices and clinical pathways that utilize them. Multi-stakeholder (early)
deliberation has often been proposed to better align value requirements with the
adoption and diffusion processes. This article examines the importance of developing
a shared value perspective on the implementation of complex innovations through
early deliberation. Product developers, (potential) adopters (providers or patients),
purchasers, and policy makers may engage in an upfront iterative deliberation on all
the particularities and (pre)conditions that account for delivering value of a certain
innovation during early adoption in a given care delivery setting. Such deliberation
offers a cumulative learning as to how to reduce true-to-life uncertainties and risks
‘along the way’, thereby serving for value ‘fulfillment’ in practice. Implication of such
situated deliberative platforms for technology (outcome) assessment and for the role
of authorities is discussed. A concrete framework for multi-stakeholder deliberation
applied to the case of the da Vinci surgical robot in the Netherlands is also proposed.
CP3
Evaluating the Quality of Evidence from a Network Meta-Analysis
Higgins J P 1, Del Giovane C 2, Chaimani A 3, Caldwell D M 1, Salanti G 3
1University of Bristol, Bristol, UK, 2University of Modena and Reggio Emilia, Modena, Italy,
3University of Ioannina School of Medicine, Ioannina, Greece
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Systematic reviews that collate data about the relative effects of multiple interventions via network meta-analysis are highly informative for decision-making
purposes. A network meta-analysis provides two types of findings for a specific
outcome: the relative treatment effect for all pairwise comparisons, and a ranking of the treatments. It is important to consider the confidence with which these
two types of results can enable clinicians, policy makers and patients to make
informed decisions. We propose an approach to determining confidence in the
output of a network meta-analysis, based on methodology developed by the Grading
of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) Working
Group for pairwise meta-analyses. The suggested framework for evaluating a
network meta-analysis acknowledges (i) the key role of indirect comparisons (ii)
the contributions of each piece of direct evidence to the network meta-analysis
estimates of effect size; (iii) the importance of the transitivity assumption to the
DI1
Cost-Effectiveness (CE) of Imaging-Guided Strategies for the
Diagnosis of Coronary Artery Disease (CAD): Results From the Evinci
Study
Lorenzoni V 1, Pierotti F 1, Bellelli S 1, Neglia D 2, Rovai D 2, Turchetti G 1
Superiore Sant’Anna, Pisa, Italy, 2National Research Council, Pisa, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Scuola
Objectives: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness (CE) of imaging-guided strategies
for the diagnosis of significant coronary artery disease (CAD) in patients with intermediate pre-test likelihood. Methods: Significant CAD was defined at invasive
coronary angiography (ICA) as > 50% stenosis in the left main or > 70% stenosis in
a major coronary vessel or 30-70% stenosis with fractional flow reserve ≤ 0.8.Nine
diagnostic strategies were compared using a CE analysis. Strategies included the use
of one single or two combined non-invasive imaging tests (CTCA as first line test
and then stress ECHO, CMR, PET or SPECT) followed by ICA in the case of positivity
of the single test or both non-invasive examinations in the case of combinations.
ICERs were obtained using per-patient data collected throughout the EVINCI multicentre European study. Strategy costs were calculated using examination countryspecific reimbursements, while effectiveness was defined as the percentage of
correct diagnosis. All costs were converted to Euro 2012 and adjusted using PPP. A
propensity-score adjustment was used in the analysis and 95%CI were obtained
with non-parametric bootstrap. Results: Among the strategies analysed only three
resulted cost-effective for the diagnosis of significant CAD. These included stress
ECHO and CTCA as single non-invasive test, CTCA first then ECHO, CTCA first and
then stress PET, all followed by ICA when required. Stress ECHO approach was the
least costly but also the least effective, while CTCA alone [ICER: 2345 (2287-2400)] or
in combination with PET [ICER: 5227(5161-5296)] had increasingly higher effectiveness for a willingness to pay (WTP) exceeding 2,000 Euro and 5,000 Euro, respectively. Conclusions: Results from the health-economic analysis of the EVINCI
study showed that stress ECHO guided diagnostic strategy could be cost-effective
when the WTP is low. Strategies involving CTCA alone or as first line exam followed
by stress PET could allow a more accurate diagnostic workflow for higher WTP.
DI2
The Value of Risk-Stratified Information in the National Lung
Cancer Screening Trial
Soeteman D I 1, Cohen J T 1, Neumann P J 2, Wong J B 1, Kent D M 1
1Tufts Medical Center/Tufts University School of Medicine, Boston, MA, USA, 2Tufts Medical
Center, Boston, MA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Clinical guideline recommendations are generally informed by population-based evidence. However, interventions that are (cost-)effective on average
may not be (cost-)effective for many (even for most) patients meeting trial inclusion
criteria. This study aims to investigate the value of risk-stratified recommendations
for lung cancer screening among current or former smokers between the ages of
55 and 74 years compared to a screen-all policy. Methods: Using data from the
National Lung Cancer Screening Trial (NLST), we calculated the costs and QALYs
for low-dose computed tomography (CT) versus chest radiography (X-ray) from
empirically observed health states and 6 years life expectancy. Based on Kovalchik’s
risk of lung cancer death prediction model, we stratified 53,454 NLST trial patients
into quintiles. The expected value of individualized care (EVIC) was calculated to
A325
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
quantify the value of using stratified information over population-based information. Results: The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of CT versus X-ray
was $31,942 per QALY, for the “average” trial patient, indicating that CT would be
the preferred option at a cost-effectiveness threshold of $50,000 per QALY. However,
when stratified into quintiles, CT is dominated for the lowest risk quintile (i.e., X-ray
is the preferred option for quintile 1) and CT is preferred for higher risk groups (quintiles 2 to 5). The EVIC was calculated at around $180 per person for cost-effectiveness
thresholds of $50,000 per QALY and higher. Conclusions: Tailoring screening
strategies to avoid CT scan in the lowest risk quintile of patients appears to be a
superior strategy compared to population-wide CT scan screening, although results
were sensitive to the cost-effectiveness threshold and the level of granularity of the
analysis. This study shows the value of considering the risk-based heterogeneity
of cost-effectiveness in clinical guideline recommendations and policy decisions.
DI3
Effect of Self-Monitoring of Blood Glucose on Glycemic Control,
Clinical Outcomes, and Health Care Costs in Diabetic Patients Using
Insulin: a Retrospective Analysis
Degli Esposti L , Saragoni S , Blini V , Buda S
CliCon Srl, Ravenna, Italy
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Self-monitoring of blood glucose (SMBG) may improve diabetes management. We analyzed the effect of SMBG on glycemic control, clinical outcomes
and health care costs among insulin-users diabetic patients in a clinical practice
setting. Methods: A retrospective analysis using data from the administrative
databases, clinical registries containing laboratory results and medical devices databases including SMBG strips data of two Italian Local Health Units was performed.
Insulin-users were defined if they had at least one prescription of insulin agents from
November, 2009 and April, 2011. The first prescription was selected as index-date.
Patients were divided into two groups based on testing frequency of SMBG during
the 18 months after the index-date: no test strip claims (no SMBG use) and more
than two test strips per day. We calculated incidence rates to estimate the risk for
fasting blood glucose levels < 70 mg/dl and for diabetes-related hospitalizations or
death occurrence during the 18-months follow-up period. Total annual costs included
hypoglycemic therapy and the direct costs due to diabetes-related hospitalizations
and outpatient services. Results: We identified 394 insulin-users patients with no
SMBG use and 1350 with SMBG performed more than twice per day. Compared with
non-SMBG use group, patients using SMBG showed a significant reduced risk of glucose levels < 70 mg/dl (unadjusted rate was 10,6 vs 27,3 per 100 person-years, p<0.001)
and of diabetes-related hospitalizations or death (30,0 vs 60,8 per 100 person-years,
p<0.001). The higher hospitalization rate resulted in higher hospitalization costs per
patient (€ 2.419 vs € 1.512 of those with SMBG use) and consequently higher total
annual direct costs per patient (€3.060 vs €2.738 of those using SMBG). Conclusions:
Results indicate that patients using SMBG, compared with non-SMBG patients, are
associated with better glycemic control and reduced risk of diabetes-related hospitalizations and consequently with lower overall total annual cost per patient.
DI4
Diagnosing Anxiety Disorders in Primary Care: a Systematic Review
and Meta-Analysis
Olariu E 1, Rodrigo M 2, Alvarez Lopez P 3, Castro-Rodriguez J I 3, Martin-Lopez L M 3,
Alonso J 4, Garcia Forero C 1
1PRBB - IMIM Instituto Hospital del Mar de Investigaciones Médicas, Barcelona, Spain, 2Pompeu
Fabra University, Barcelona, Spain, 3Institut de Neuropsiquiatria i Addiccions, Barcelona, Spain,
4IMIM-Research Institute Hospital del Mar, Barcelona, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Anxiety and mood disorders are highly prevalent in Primary Care but
research shows that general practitioners (GPs) fail to diagnose up to half of cases. In
this study we try to determine the diagnostic accuracy of GPs’ diagnoses of anxiety
disorders with and without any help from diagnostic (assisted vs unassisted diagnosis). Methods: We searched for articles published from January 1980 to June 2014 in
7 databases. We included studies in English, Spanish, French, and German reporting
the ability of GPs to identify any anxiety disorder (DSM III/ IV/ IV-TR diagnostic criteria) in Primary Care community samples. We excluded studies from general population and those addressing specific physical or mental disorders, along with vignette
and case-series studies. Two authors independently performed abstract and full-text
reviews and data extraction. Study was assessed with the QUADAS-2. Coupled forest
plots summarized estimated studies’ sensitivity and specificity and 95% confidence
intervals. We fitted random-effects meta-analysis models and undertook a bivariate meta-analysis to construct a summary Receiver Operator Characteristic Curve
(sROC). Results: From a total 17.964 detected papers, 443 were included for full text
review. So far, we have analyzed 111 papers, out of which 8 studies were included
with N= 3608 patients with pooled anxiety prevalence 26% (CI=25-27%). Preliminary
results shows an overall ROC curve with lower GP diagnostic accuracy when performing unassisted diagnoses for a total diagnostic accuracy 80% (CI= 79.4-80.1) with
overall sensitivity= 49% (CI= 45-53), and Specificity = 92% (CI= 90-94). GP’s accuracy
was higher with assisted diagnoses (86.7%, CI=85%-89%) than unassisted diagnoses
(45.5%; CI= 43.7%-47.3%). Specificity was lower in assisted (89.15%; CI= 87.9-90.4)
than unassisted diagnosis (92.5%; CI= 91.9-93.1). Conclusions: Low diagnostic
sensitivity might hinder the adequate detection and management of anxiety in
primary care. Results suggest that detection might be improved by using diagnostic
tools. Results for all included articles will be presented.
Health Care Expenditure Studies
HC1
Determinants of Increasing the Likelihood for a Positive Drug
Reimbursement Recommendation in Scotland
Pantiri K , Baeten S , Majer I M , Heeg B , Charokopou M
Pharmerit International, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: A binary reimbursement prediction model was previously developed
based on a dataset of submissions to the Scottish Medicines Consortium (SMC)
between 2006 and 2014. The objective of this study is to build on the previous model
by identifying factors that influence the different levels of SMC recommendation,
defined as “recommend”, “restrict” or “not recommend” pharmaceutical technologies for use in Scotland. Methods: Univariate and multivariate ordered logistic
regression analyses were performed to assess the impact by means of odds ratios
(OR) of the submitted evidence to the SMC on the decision. The proportional odds
assumption underlying the current approach was tested. Results: Out of 463 applications, 115 received positive recommendation (25%), 150 received restricted recommendation (32%) and 198 (43%) were not recommended. Univariate analyses showed
that 14 variables significantly affected the SMC decision. The multivariate analyses
showed significant associations (p≤ 0.05) between the SMC decision and several
variables, including: (1) a product demonstrating cost savings and QALY gains
[OR= 6.11], (2) a product not being cost-effective (ICER≥ £30,000/QALY) [OR= 0.50], (3)
a non-superior efficacy outcome versus placebo [OR= 0.15], (4) the product’s therapeutic indication (nervous system [OR= 0.51], blood forming organs [OR= 2.29]), (5)
whether the product was indicated for non-chronic use [OR= 1.48] and (6) whether
the submission was performed by a big company [OR= 1.86]. The proportional odds
assumption was not violated, proving the appropriateness of the current model. The
present model yielded similar results with the previously developed binary logistic
one, further ensuring face validity, yet this approach is considered to better fit the
multidimensional nature of SMC’s decision and increase the predictive power of
the model. Conclusions: This study identified superior efficacy using an active
comparator as well as a beneficial cost-effectiveness outcome to increase the likelihood of receiving a positive recommendation by the SMC.
HC2
Biosimilars Versus Brands for Rheumatoid Arthritis: Eu5 Payers and
Prescribers Place their Bets
Cox J 1, Fletcher-Louis M 1, Kang B 2
1Decision Resources Group, London, UK, 2Decision Resources Group, Burlington, MA, USA
.
.
.
Objectives: The entrenched positioning of biologics to treat moderate-to-severe
rheumatoid arthritis (RA) has generated a lucrative market. However, amid ongoing economic constraints, the EU5 (France, Germany, Italy, Spain, and the UK) must
tighten their health care belts. As biosimilars versions of key brands appear on
the horizon, this study explored the expected impact of these cheaper options
on reimbursement and prescribing for RA in each country. Methods: Across the
EU5, 254 rheumatologists were surveyed regarding their views on biosimilars for
RA and on current and expected prescribing patterns. In addition, 15 payers who
influence reimbursement at national or regional level were interviewed. Results:
Considering 54-week Phase III data, ≥80% of surveyed rheumatologists in each country believe CT-P13 (biosimilar infliximab) has similar efficacy to branded Remicade;
however, respondents are less confident in the biosimilar’s safety. Furthermore,
> 80% of respondents in most countries are willing to prescribe biosimilars of infliximab, and of etanercept and rituximab, though largely not before branded biologics. Unsurprisingly, given likely price discounts, interviewed payers will somewhat
encourage biosimilar uptake. However, excluding those in Germany, consensus is
that discounts offered on biosimilars will not significantly impact their budgets.
German payers, however, report that additional rebates to statutory insurers are
expected; they admit to financial incentives for physicians to prescribe rebated
drugs, thus manufacturers may consider robust uptake will compensate for hefty
discounts. Conclusions: Available data have inspired prescriber confidence in
biosimilar efficacy, although safety concerns, likely stemming from complex biosimilar manufacturing and lack of long-term safety data, will ensure continued
brand uptake, at least initially. Furthermore, the expected modesty of biosimilar
discounts in most countries will somewhat curb payer policy promoting use of such
agents. However, as prescribers become more familiar with biosimilars, and, as the
full extent of cost savings are revealed, increasing uptake of biosimilars is probable.
HC3
Preferences for Prioritizing Patients with Rare Diseases: a Survey
of the General Population in Sweden
Wiss J , Levin L Å
Linköping University, Linköping, Sweden
.
.
.
Objectives: Incentives are offered to pharmaceutical companies in order to
increase the number of treatments for patients with rare diseases. As a consequence, a number of new drugs have been introduced on the market—drugs that
often fail to meet traditional cost-effectiveness criteria. This study aims to investigate if there are societal preferences for treating patients with rare diseases differently in priority setting situations compared with common diseases. Moreover,
psychological mechanisms that potentially could explain such preferences are
explored. Methods: A postal questionnaire in three versions was sent out to a
representative sample of the general Swedish population. Respondents were asked
to choose to give treatment to a patient with a rare or a common disease in eight
different scenarios. Rarity of the disease, different alternative costs, and group/
individual level decisions was investigated. Psychological aspects in the presented
scenaros that varied between subjects was related to proportion dominance, the
identifiability of the patient, pseudo-inefficacy and if the scenario was expressed in
priority or rationing terms. Results: Response rate was 41 % (n= 1239). For equal
cost scenarios, 42.3 % were indifferent between the rare and the common group,
23.9 % chose to prioritize the rare disease and 33.4 % the common disease. When
questions were framed to be on an individul as opposed to a group level repondents were significantly (p< .001) more likely to be indifferent. Proportion dominance
increased individuals’ preferences to prioritize rare diseases (p<.001). Identifiability
and pseudo-inefficacy had no major effect on respondents’ choices. Conclusions:
All else equal we see no strong support that a societal preference for rarity exists.
However, we observe psychological effects influencing the judgments individuals
make when setting priorities related to rare diseases. Whether or not these should
A326
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
be viewed as biases or an expression of true preferences is a matter for further
discussion.
HC4
Understanding the Payer Dilemma with Biosimilar Mabs: Striking
the Right Balance Between Budget Needs and Patient Outcomes
Vidal Pinheiro A , Ziai Buetas A , Storer M
ICON, London, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: The first infliximab biosimilars reached the EU in September 2013,
representing the first biosimilar monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) to obtain EMA
approval. Although commercialization in the major European markets will only
start in February 2015, payers in Nordic and Eastern European countries have already
faced the dilemma of striking the balance between potential savings accrued from
use of less expensive infliximab biosimilars and demands for robust proof of clinical
efficacy and safety. This work identifies payers’ evidence expectations, their reliance on regulators’ decisions and how potential savings can influence access and
recommendations to target patient populations. Methods: Exploratory qualitative primary research with payers (N= 12) from France, Italy, Spain, UK, Germany
and Netherlands. Collection of data about the current and future attitudes towards
biosimilar health technology assessments at the national and, if applicable, local
levels will be conducted, as well as perceived price and access trade-offs. Results:
(1) Payers will mainly defer to the EMA the decision on acceptability of biosimilar
indication extrapolation (indications where biosimilars do not have direct clinical
trial data); (2) It is understood that mAb biosimilar clinical development is more
onerous and costly than small molecule generics, thus payers do not expect the
same magnitude of discounts offered vs. originator; (3) Although eager to obtain
savings from broad patient populations, payers will not implement pharmacy-level
substitution or enforce biosimilar use in originator-experienced patients; (4) Use in
naïve patients will be recommended in most markets. Conclusions: Across the
EU5, payers acknowledge physicians’ concerns over long term safety and efficacy
of biosimilars. Nonetheless, they will rely on the regulators evaluations and expert
panels to justify implementing recommendations, and in some markets, restrict
formularies based exclusively on cost. Moreover, they have conservative discount
expectations at launch, with the long-term aim of incentivizing further competition
from other biosimilar manufacturers.
Research On Methods – Modeling Studies
MO1
Quasi-Monte Carlo Simulation and Variance Reduction Techniques
Substantially Reduce Computational Requirements of Patient-Level
Simulation Models: an Application to a Discrete Event Simulation
Model
Treur M 1, Postma M 2
International, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 2University of Groningen, Groningen, The
Netherlands
.
.
1Pharmerit
Objectives: Patient-level simulation models provide increased flexibility to overcome the limitations of cohort-based approaches in health-economic analysis.
However, computational requirements of reaching convergence is a notorious
barrier. The objective was to assess the impact of using quasi-monte carlo simulation (QMCS) and variance reduction techniques (VRTs) on computational requirements. Methods: A recently published discrete event simulation model assessing
the cost-effectiveness of an adjunctive antipsychotic treatment for depression was
used. The following VRTs were implemented: antithetic variables, common random
numbers (CRN) and the combination (Anti_CRN). In addition, QMCS was conducted
using the Sobol low discrepancy sequence. The minimal number of patients required
to reach equal precision as the reference situation of 1,000,000 simple monte carlo
simulations (MCS) was recorded. Precision was defined by the standard error (SE)
of the incremental net monetary benefit (INMB) at a willingness to pay of € 20,000
per quality adjusted life year gained. VRT simulations were replicated 100 times.
INMB estimates were compared with the reference situation using mean squared
error (MSE), mean absolute error (MAE) and percentage of under- and overestimations. Results: Reference INMB (SE) was € 1,413 (76). The average number of
patients required to reach reference precision were 929,628, 35,692, 41,683 and
36,803 for antithetic variables, CRN, Anti_CRN and Sobol respectively. This implied
a computation time reduction ranging between 7% and 96% compared to simple
MCS. MSE was 346,036, 16,314, 155,950 and 7,475 respectively. MAE was 588, 105,
387 and 86 respectively. Antithetic variables and Anti_CRN structurally underestimated INMB (99% and 100%). CRN marginally overestimated INMB in 76 replications. Conclusions: QMCS and VRT reduce computational requirements in terms
of simulated patients and computational time up to 96%, enhancing the practical
feasibility of patient-level simulation models. This particularly applies to Sobol and
CRN. Antithetic variables should be used with caution and its structural bias warrants further research.
MO2
Transition Probability Estimation Using Repeated Sampling from a
Fitted Mixed Model
Gupta S 1, Bhattacharyya S 1, Sonathi V 1, Bakuli A 1, Mathur A K 1, Leteneux C 2
1Novartis Healthcare Pvt. Ltd., Hyderabad, India, 2Novartis Pharma AG, Basel, Switzerland
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Markov model is one of the most used decision analytic models in
health care. Transitions between health states in a Markov model is driven by transition probability matrix. When the number of patients and observed transitions
are limited, transition probability estimation becomes challenging. The objective
of this exercise is to demonstrate how transition probabilities can be estimated by
simulating data from a statistical model fitted to patient-level data. Methods:
An economic model for ranibizumab in mCNV secondary to pathological myopia
(submitted to NICE in June 2013) was adapted for forthcoming Asian reimbursement
submissions. BCVA (Best Corrected Visual Acuity) scores were available for limited
number of East Asian patients (N= 35) from a phase III, 12-month, randomized,
double-masked, multicenter, active-controlled study (RADIANCE). To populate a
transition probability matrix with 8 health states based on BCVA scores, a statistical model was proposed to simulate a larger hypothetical patient cohort. A mixedeffect model was fitted on the observed BCVA scores with baseline BCVA score as
covariate, patients as random effect and an autoregressive AR(1) error correlation
structure amongst the repeated observations. This model was used to simulate a
patient cohort of 35,000. Transition probabilities were estimated using traditional
division by row sum method. Several simulations were run to confirm consistency
of results. Results: From baseline to month 3, percentage of patients with BCVA
≥ 20 letters gain was 22.45% in observed data vs 22.49% in simulated data, and
percentage of patients with BCVA ≥ 20 letters loss was 0.008% in observed data
vs 0.009% in simulated data. BCVA change from baseline to month 3 in simulated
data (mean= 13.3, SD= 8.3) was verified with that of the observed data (mean= 13.3,
SD= 8.8). Conclusions: Transition probability estimation by simulation from a
fitted statistical model can overcome the challenges posed by small patient cohorts
and multiple state transitions.
MO3
Extrapolation of Trial-Based Survival Curves Using External
Information
Guyot P 1, Welton N J 2, Beasley M 3, Ades A E 2
1Mapi, Houten, The Netherlands, 2University of Bristol, Bristol, UK, 3Bristol Haematology and
Oncology Centre, Bristol, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In cost-effectiveness analysis (CEA), mean survival difference (QALYadjusted) over a lifetime horizon is required. Parametric models are necessary to
extrapolate survival outcomes beyond the Randomized Controlled Trial (RCT) period.
However, mean survival is very sensitive to the assumed model and different mean
survival times may result from models fitting similarly well to the RCT data. We
investigate the idea that other sources of information, external to the trial data,
could be used to inform model choice and estimation. Methods: We explored
various survival models and we show how external information can be used to
put constraints on spline-based survival models. We illustrate with a Technology
Appraisal (TA) of head and neck cancer where RCT evidence had 5 year follow up.
A US cancer database (SEER), general population data and expert opinion were
used to impose constraints on overall survival, conditional survival, and hazard
ratio. RCT and external data were fitted simultaneously within a Bayesian framework. Results: Standard survival time distributions were insufficiently flexible
to simultaneously fit both the RCT data and general population constraints. Spline
models were sufficiently flexible, although there were difficulties choosing initial
values. A good fit to all sources of internal and external evidence was achieved
within one integrated model using splines on the log hazard. Cetuximab in addition to radiotherapy improves the expected survival by 4.7 months [95% CrL: 0.4;
9.1] compared to radiotherapy alone. Conclusions: The method enabled us to
estimate models consistent with all evidence. Clinical knowledge is essential to
guide the interpretation of the external data sources. The method could be used
to analyze other RCTs on other cancers and with other treatments. Other flexible
models than splines could be investigated.
MO4
Estimating Survival Data from Published Kaplan-Meier Curves: a
Comparison of Methods
Perry R 1, Taylor M 2, Lewis L 2, Yellowlees A 1, Fleetwood K 1, Barata T 1
1Quantics Consulting Ltd, Edinburgh, UK, 2York Health Economics Consortium, York, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Health technology assessment of treatments often requires estimates
of their survival curves. Individual patient data (IPD) are often unavailable and the
survival curves are usually calculated by fitting a nonlinear least squares (NLS)
model directly to Kaplan Meier plots provided in the published literature. This
method does not account for the uncertainty associated with the Kaplan Meier
curve and can lead to biased estimates. Although the IPD are often missing, the
Kaplan Meier curve itself can be digitised and used to approximate what the original IPD could have been. Methods: We simulated trial IPD data from different
survival distributions in order to assess the accuracy of the IPD reconstruction
methods. The assessment of accuracy is made at multiple stages and ultimately
the effects on the incremental cost effectiveness ratio (ICER) estimates are compared. To do so, a simple cost-effectiveness model was developed, assuming two
health states (alive and dead), and assigning costs (£1,000 per month plus drug
costs) and a utility score (0.70) to generate ICERs. Two additional methods to curve
fitting are compared against the NLS approach – those suggested by Guyot (G), and
by Hoyle & Henley (HH). Results: We find that the methods differ in accuracy at
each of the following two stages; (a) model selection via the AIC and secondly (b)
survival model parameter estimation. When an underlying Weibull function was
assumed, the ‘true’ ICER should be £28,924, compared against £31,182 £33,449 and
£31,650 for the NLS, HH and G methods respectively. When an underlying loglogistic
function was assumed, the NLS, HH and GG methods produced ICERs of £26,507,
£25,559 and £25,857, compared to a ‘true’ ICER of £25,779. Conclusions: These
findings suggest that inherent biases may be apparent in each of the approaches,
and these may manifest themselves differently, depending upon the ‘true’ shape
of the underlying data.
Qaly-Related Studies
QA1
Economic orphans? the prevalence of child-specific utilities in nice
appraisals for paediatric indications
Montgomery S , Hassan M , Kusel J
Costello Medical Consulting Ltd., Cambridge, UK
.
.
.
A327
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: Children have been termed “therapeutic orphans” due to the paucity
of age-specific therapeutic data. Here we review the extent to which utility data
derived from under-18s were used to inform National Institute for Health and Care
Excellence (NICE) Technology Appraisals (TAs) providing cost-effectiveness guidance in paediatric indications, in line with the NICE reference case. Methods:
All 311 published TAs up to April 2014 were initially sifted to identify therapeutic recommendations for children. Identified TAs were reviewed to determine if a
cost-utility analysis (CUA) was performed. For each CUA, the published TA along
with the manufacturer’s submission (single TAs) or the assessment report (multiple
TAs) were examined to determine the origin of the utilities used. Results: Of 35
published TAs reviewed, 27 analysed cost-per-QALY and made recommendations
for treatment of under-18s. Of these, 17 used adult utilities, 1 of which attempted
to adjust the adult values for children; 3 considered child and adult populations
as one, with child-derived data used within the overall model inputs for the whole
population, 1 of which adjusted both child and adult utilities by age. Only 6 studies
used child-specific utilities: 1 assumed a specified change from treatment on a
generic QoL instrument, 2 used parent-reported utilities on a generic QoL instrument, 1 used parent-reported utilities mapped from a disease-specific scale and
2 used child-reported utilities mapped from a disease-specific scale. One MTA
contained diverging submissions, 1 adult-derived and 1 child-reported. No trends
over time in the types of utilities used were apparent from visual examination of
the results. Conclusions: Despite NICE’s reference case specifying that utilities
should be measured in the population in question, children may also be termed
“economic orphans” with the majority of cost-utility submissions applying adultderived utilities to paediatric indications and no trend away from this apparent
over time.
QA2
Cost-Utility of Cancer Therapies – the ‘Cost’ of Different Utility
Generation Strategies
Meads D M 1, McCabe C 2, Hulme C T 1, Edlin R 3, Kharroubi S A 4, Browne C 5, Ford H 6, Dunn
J 7, Marshall A 7
1University of Leeds, Leeds, UK, 2University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada, 3University
of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand, 4University of York, York, UK, 5Evidera, London, UK,
6Addenbrooke’s Hospital, Cambridge, UK, 7University of Warwick, Coventry, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To explore the impact of different utility measurement strategies on the
results of a cost-effectiveness analysis, funding decisions, decision uncertainty and
value of information. Methods: Data from a UK trial of two cancer therapies (active
versus standard care) were analysed using NICE reference case methods. Within-trial,
cost-utility analyses were conducted with utility based on a number of strategies: A)
Observed EQ-5D; cancer-specific utility based on the EORTC QLQ-C30 B) the EORTC-8D
and C) the QLQ_U; Mapping from QLQ-C30 to EQ-5D using an algorithm generated
in D) the same cancer patient group and E) a different cancer group. Incremental
cost-effectiveness ratios (ICERS) were calculated. Bootstrapped net benefit estimates
allowed generation of cost-effectiveness acceptability curves (CEACs) and population expected value of perfect information (EVPI) was calculated using incremental
cost scenarios. Results were compared across utility strategies. Results: There were
small but important differences observed in the incremental QALYs which ranged
from 0.067 (EQ-5D) to 0.036 (EORTC-8D). Large differences were observed in the ICERs
generated; for strategies A to E these were: £57,513; £106,264; £102,785; £90,049;
£78,885. Using an incremental cost scenario of £3,000 only strategy A yielded an ICER
<£30,000. At a QALY willingness to pay threshold (WTPT) of £20,000 there was little
decision uncertainty. However, assuming WTPT=£50,000, the probability the active
treatment was cost-effective ranged 0.34 (EQ-5D) to 0.025 (EORTC-8D). Using this
threshold, the population EVPI for the strategies were: £3,597,844; £120,621; £155,858;
£354,094; £805,847. Conclusions: Different utility sources can lead to very different
estimates of cost-effectiveness and value of further research and change funding
decisions. Estimates of cost-effectiveness based on mapping (even when the algorithm appears to perform well) can differ substantively from those based on observed
scores. The lowest ICERs were obtained with the EQ-5D but this may not capture
side-effects picked up by the cancer-specific utility measures.
QA3
Do new cancer drugs offer good value for money? the perspective
of oncologists, payers, patients, and general population
Dilla T 1, Lizán L 2, Paz S 2, Garrido P 3, Avendaño C 4, Cruz J J 5, Espinosa J 6, Sacristan J A 1
1Lilly S.A., Madrid, Spain, 2Outcomes 10, Castellon, Spain, 3Hospital Ramon y Cajal, Madrid,
Spain, 4Hospital Puerta de Hierro, Madrid, Spain, 5Hospital Clinico Universitario, Salamanca,
Spain, 6Hospital La Paz, Madrid, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To analyze oncologists’, payers’, patients’, and general population´
views on the cost and value of new cancer treatments. Methods: An electronic
self-administered questionnaire was developed and randomly distributed, to assess
participants’ attitudes towards new cancer treatment outcomes and costs during reimbursement decisions. Among the questions asked were two hypothetical
scenarios. First, participants were asked to indicate the minimum survival benefit
that a new treatment, that cost € 50,000 more than the standard therapy, should
have to be funded by the Spanish National Health System (NHS). Second, participants were requested to state the highest costs to be afforded by the NHS for a
medication increasing patient’s quality of life (QoL) twofold with no changes in
survival. Responses were used to calculate incremental cost-effectiveness ratios
(ICER). Results: 53 oncologists, 60 patients, 25 payers, and 50 individuals from general population answered the questionnaire. The minimum improvement median
in patient survival that justified the inclusion into the NHS was 5.66 months for
oncologists, 8.16 for patients, 9.08 for general population and 10.44 for payers;
implying different ICER for oncologists (€ 106,000/QALY), patients (€ 73,520/QALY),
general population (€ 66,074/QALY) and payers (€ 57,471/QALY). The cost stated in
QoL-enhancing scenario was € 33,167 for patients, € 30,200 for general population,
€ 26,000 for oncologists and € 17,040 for payers; resulting in ICERs of € 82,917/QALY
for patients, €75,500/QALY for general population, €65,000/QALY for oncologists, and
€42,600/QALY for payers. Conclusions: All the estimated ICER values were higher
than the thresholds usually described in the literature (€ 20,000-30,000/QALY), with
relevant differences among the groups. In both scenarios, payers were less prone
to pay for therapeutic improvements compared to the rest of the participants. On
the other hand, oncologists were the ones that most valued gains in survival for
a new treatment while patients assigned a higher value for money to a treatment
that enhanced the quality of life.
QA4
Reimbursement Decisions for Pharmaceuticals in Sweden: the
Impact of Cost-Effectiveness and Disease Severity
Nilsson F O L 1, Svensson M 2, Arnberg K 1
1Dental and Pharmaceutical Benefits Agency, Stockholm, Sweden, 2Örebro University, Örebro,
Sweden
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The purpose of this study is to evaluate the impact of cost-effectiveness and disease severity on the drug reimbursement decisions made by the
reimbursement agency TLV in Sweden. Methods: Cost-effectiveness is measured
through the continuous variable cost per QALY, while disease severity is measured by a dichotomous variable indicating high- or not high disease severity. We
analyze all reimbursement decisions from 2005 through 2011 where there is data
available on cost per QALY and disease severity. Logistic regressions are used to
evaluate the impact of cost-effectiveness and disease severity on the drug reimbursement decisions. Results: There are 102 decisions with the required data
available, 86 where reimbursement was granted and 16 where reimbursement was
denied. The median cost per QALY for the drugs that were granted reimbursement
was 39 000 euro (9sek/euro), ranging from a negative cost per QALY (better and
cheaper) to 136 000 euro. The median cost per QALY for the drugs that were denied
reimbursement was 111 000 euro, ranging from 78 000 euro to 1 111 000 euro. The
results from the logistic regression analysis show that both the cost per QALY and
the level of disease severity are statistically significantly related to the probability
of a drug being granted reimbursement. When the cost per QALY exceeds 56 000
euro for non-severe diseases, and 92 000 euro for severe diseases, the probability
that reimbursement is denied is higher than the probability that reimbursement
is granted. Conclusions: In Sweden, it is sometimes stated as a rule of thumb
that 55 000 euro per QALY is a threshold for cost-effective interventions. Our model
shows that at this cost-effectiveness ratio, the probability of a new drug becoming
reimbursed is 91 % or 98 %, depending on disease severity.
Research Podium Presentations – Session II
Cardiovascular Disease Research Studies
CV1
The Importance of Treatment Classifications that Account for
Concomitant Treatments in the Context of a Network MetaAnalysis Comparing Pharmacological Treatments for Chronic
Heart Failure
Burnett H 1, Cope S 1, Vieira M C 2, Sagkriotis A 3, Senni M 4, Deschaseaux C 3
Pharma, Health Economics and Outcomes Research, USA,
East Hanover, NJ, USA, 3Novartis Pharma AG, Basel, Switzerland, 4Scompenso e Trapianti di
Cuore, Bergamo, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Mapi, Toronto, ON, Canada, 2Novartis
Objectives: The aim of the study was to assess the comparative efficacy of recommended treatment for chronic heart failure with reduced ejection fraction in
terms of all-cause mortality based on a network met-analysis (NMA) of randomized
controlled trials (RCTs) and to explore the impact of alternative treatment classifications depending on concomitant treatments. Methods: A systematic literature
search identified 56 relevant RCTs (1980-2013) that reported mortality data that
were synthesized using a Bayesian Poisson regression NMA model. Treatments
were classified as angiotensin converting enzyme inhibitors (ACEI), beta-blockers
(BB), angiotensin II receptor blockers (ARB), mineralocorticoid/aldosterone receptor
antagonists (MRA) and the Ifchannel inhibitor (IF) ivabradine. Analysis 1 classified
treatments according to the main drugs of interest, whereas Analysis 2 defined
treatments according to the main drugs of interest as well as the concomitant
treatments belonging to classes of interest if more than 50% of patients were taking concomitant drugs. Results: Six regimens were compared in Analysis 1 and
10 regimens were compared in Analysis 2. Analysis 1 resulted in the following rate
ratios (RR) versus placebo: ACEI: 0.81 (95% Credible Interval 0.61, 0.95); BB: 0.71 (0.60,
0.80); ARB: 0.90 (0.75, 1.02); ACEI+BB: 0.48 (0.30, 0.76). Analysis 2 resulted in the following RRs versus placebo: ACEI: 0.81 (0.68, 0.95); BB: 0.57 (0.35, 0.87); ARB: 0.81 (0.61,
1.01); ACEI+BB: 0.61 (0.54, 0.68). The treatments that are expected to be most efficacious depended on the treatment classification: Analysis 1 supported ACEI+BB and
BB, whereas Analysis 2 supported ACEI+BB+MRA+IF and ACEI+BB+MRA [RR: 0.44
(0.34, 0.58) and 0.48 (0.38, 0.60), respectively]. Conclusions: Combination treatments were likely to be more efficacious than monotherapy and adding a class to a
regimen was likely to make it more efficacious regardless of the approach. However,
treatment classifications affect the results and interpretation. The approach that
accounts for concomitant treatments is preferred.
CV2
Work Productivity Loss and Indirect Costs Associated with New
Cardiovascular Events in High-Risk Patients with Hyperlipidemia Estimates from Population-Based Register Data in Sweden
Banefelt J 1, Hallberg S 1, Fox K M 2, Mesterton J 1, Paoli C J 3, Johansson G 4, Levin L Å 5,
Sobocki P 6, Gandra S R 3
1Quantify Research, Stockholm, Sweden, 2Strategic Healthcare Solutions, LLC, Monkton, MD,
USA, 3Amgen, Inc., Thousand Oaks, CA, USA, 4Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden, 5Linköping
University, Linköping, Sweden, 6IMS Health, Stockholm, Sweden
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A328
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: To estimate productivity loss and associated indirect costs in working-age high-risk patients treated for hyperlipidemia who experience new cardiovascular (CV) events. Methods: A retrospective population-based cohort study
was conducted using Swedish electronic medical records linked to national health
registers and the Social Insurance Register. Patients were included based on a prescription of lipid-lowering therapy between January 1, 2006 and December 31, 2011
and followed until December 31, 2012 for identification of CV events and estimation
of work productivity loss (e.g. sick leave and disability pension) and indirect cost.
Patients were stratified into two cohorts based on CV risk level. Propensity score
matching was applied to compare patients with new events (cases) to patients
without new events (controls). For all outcomes, the incremental effect estimate of
a new CV event was the difference between cases and controls in the differences
between the year before and the year after the cases’ new event. Results: The
incremental effect estimate on mean indirect costs of sick leave was largest in the
CV risk-equivalent (RE) cohort (n= 2,946) at 38,395 SEK. The corresponding figure
in the CV event history cohort (n= 4,508) was 23,931 SEK. There was substantial
variation in work productivity loss with regard to type of new CV event. Transient
ischemic attack and percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty had no significant effect on indirect cost. Other types of CV events yielded a substantial incremental cost estimate, such as myocardial infarction (38,002 SEK), unstable angina
(27,189 SEK) and most notably ischemic stroke at 61,500 SEK. New CV events did not
have a significant impact on disability pension in either cohort. Conclusions:
High indirect costs are related to work productivity losses associated with new CV
events in high-risk patients treated for hyperlipidemia. The effect of new CV events
on indirect costs varied by event type.
CV3
Incidence Description and Costs of Acute Heart Failure in the
Netherlands
Stevanovic J 1, Denee L 2, Koenders J M 2, Postma M J 1
of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands, 2Novartis Pharma B.V., Arnhem, The
Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: Acute heart failure (AHF) is frequent, severe and costly, however
detailed population-based epidemiological data are currently unavailable for
the Netherlands. Our aim was to characterize the incidence, clinical features
and outcomes of AHF, and estimate associated hospitalization costs in the
Netherlands. Methods: Using the 2010 Dutch Hospital Data (DHD), we identified
all patients admitted to hospital with AHF as a primary diagnosis. DHD provide data
on patient characteristics, primary diagnosis, date of admission and discharge, surgical procedures, prior location and discharge destination. We applied contemporary
estimates of health care activity associated with AHF in order to calculate its cost
in 2014. Major components of health care activity included in this estimate were
hospital admissions associated with a primary diagnosis of AHF, associated drug utilization generally observed in those patients, major surgeries conducted during the
hospital stay and autopsy associated with inhospital mortality. Results: Primary
analysis of the data identified 7,717 patients to be admitted at least once into Dutch
hospitals in 2010 due to primary diagnosis of AHF. The mean age of patients was 77.1
(±11.5) and 51% were women. The most common comorbid conditions were cardiac
dysrhythmias, essential hypertension, old myocardial infarction, other diseases of
endocardium and diabetes. The mean hospital length of stay was 8.67 days during
the first admission. Inhospital mortality was 11.3% and readmission to hospital
was observed in 13.8% of the patients. Finally, the cost of an AHF hospitalization in
the Netherlands was estimated to be € 4,623. Conclusions: Our study provided
important insights into the clinical characteristics and costs of AHF hospitalizations
in the Netherlands. Further analysis including secondary diagnosis will indicate
what the exact number of AHF hospitalizations is, and whether this resembles
previously published figures from the National Institute for Public Health and the
Environment of 29,838 patients hospitalized and diagnosed with congestive HF.
CV4
Health Utility in Patients Following Cardiovascular Events
Pockett R D 1, McEwan P 2, Beckham C3, Shutler S 4, Martin S 5, Yousef Z 6, Bakhai A 7
University, Cardiff, UK, 2Health Economics and Outcomes Research Ltd, Cardiff, UK,
3Roche Products Ltd, Welwyn Garden City, UK, 4F. Hoffmann-La Roche Ltd, Basel, Switzerland,
5Peterborough and Stamford Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Peterborough, UK, 6University
Hospital of Wales, Cardiff, UK, 7Barnet and Chase Farm Hospitals NHS Trust, Barnet, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
Health Services Research Studies
HS1
Follow-UP Autoantibody Testing and Health Care Utilization
Among Patients with (Sustained) Celiac Disease Activity in the
Netherlands
Kuiper J G 1, Penning-van Beest F J A 1, Naessens D 2, Leon F 3, Herings R M C 1
1PHARMO Institute for Drug Outcomes Research, Utrecht, The Netherlands, 2Janssen BVBA,
Beerse, Belgium, 3Janssen Research & Development, Spring House, PA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To examine follow-up of autoantibody testing and health care utilization among patients with (sustained) celiac disease. Methods: From the PHARMO
Database Network, patients with a positive autoantibody test for deamidated gliadin
peptide (anti-DGP), endomysial (EMA) or tissue transglutaminase (anti-tTG) (period
1998-2011) were classified as celiac disease patients. The first positive test served
as index date. For patients with ≥ 12 months follow-up, autoantibody tests in the
year after index date were assessed. Patients with a second positive test, using the
same cut-off, between 6-12 months after index date were classified as ‘sustained
celiac disease’ patients and matched 1:1 on gender, birth year and year of index
date to celiac disease patients without a second positive test. For these patients,
health care utilization in 2012 was determined. Results: 1,815 patients had at
least one positive autoantibody test, of which anti-tTG was most common (86%).
1,724 patients had ≥ 12 months follow-up, of which 75% did not have any type of
autoantibody test in the year after index date. 183 patients (11%) were classified as
‘sustained celiac disease’ patients. Of these, 63 were active in the database in 2012
and could be matched. The proportion of patients with at least one GP visit and/
or hospitalization in 2012 was lower among sustained celiac disease patients: 76%
and 14% vs. 83% and 24% for patients without sustained celiac disease. However,
the mean (±SD) number of GP visits was higher among sustained celiac disease
patients (4.3 ± 7.3 vs. 3.4 ± 3.5) as was the mean (±SD) number of outpatient drug
dispensings (21.6 ± 96.3 vs.10.5 ± 17.5). Conclusions: This study shows limited
follow-up autoantibody testing among patients with celiac disease and does not
suggest higher health care utilization with sustained celiac disease. These findings
are consistent with notion of patients managing the disease without engaging the
health care system.
HS2
The Impact of Different Levels of Clinical Pharmacist
Interventions on the Therapeutic Plan and Cost Saving
Alkhalaf M S
Dammam Medical Complex, MOH, Dammam, Saudi Arabia
.
.
Objectives: To assess the impact of different levels of clinical pharmacy intervention (CPI) on therapeutic plan and cost saving through monitoring and follow-up of
some medications (including 20% Human Albumin, Meropenem and Cefepime) over
three separated months. Methods: A prospective observational study. Includes
three phases, first phase: NO-CPI. While the second phase: partial clinical pharmacy
intervention (PCPI) in which the clinical pharmacist contacted physicians directly
or indirectly by telephone and give suggestions without evidence based supported
or follow up. And third phase: an effective clinical pharmacy intervention (ECPI)
defined by direct contact between the clinical pharmacist and physician through
daily round supported by evidence based and follow up for patients and physician’s
orders. Results: The percentage of quantity saved of Human Albumin was 46.5%
during PCPI and 76.7% in ECPI. Also, there was monthly cost saving by both PCPI
and ECPI (4880 $ and 8052 $ respectively). This means that ECPI resulted in more
increment in cost saving in comparison to PCPI (39.4%). For Meropenem, 47.7% of the
dispensed quantity was saved by PCPI and 90% by ECPI. Likewise there was a significant cost saving per month that is 3052.4 $ for PCPI and 5799.5 $ for ECPI. Thereby
47.4% more cost saving resulted from ECPI. Regarding Cefepime, although both PCPI
and ECPI reduced the dispensed quantity, interestingly PCPI saved more than ECPI
(25% and 4.58% respectively). This could be due to the clinical pharmacist recommendation according to local antibiogram. Conclusions: CPI generally results
in cost saving of therapeutic plan. ECPI can lead to more remarkable cost saving.
.
1Swansea
Objectives: Cardiovascular (CV) disease is a major contributor to morbidity and
mortality in the UK. Health-related quality of life (HRQoL) data is an important
requirement of the development process and is used to inform the health state
utilities within economic models. Methods: EuroQol-5 dimension (EQ-5D) surveys
were sent to patients (age ≥ 18 years) from three centres in the UK (Barnet, Cardiff,
Peterborough) 1 month following hospital admission for a myocardial infarction
(MI), unstable angina (UA) or stroke. Patient demographics, lifestyle and baseline
utility score were collected in the first survey. Follow-up surveys were sent at 6,
12, 18 and 24 months capturing utility and subsequent health events. Descriptive
statistics and general linear regression models were used to describe the patients
and to identify changes in utility over time. Results: 1350 patients (mean age 68.8
years; SD 12.3) were recruited. Of these, 755 (55.9%) suffered a MI, 571 (42.3%) had UA,
and 24 (1.8%) had a stroke; 345 (25.6%) patients also had diabetes. Baseline utilities
were 0.690 (SD 0.322) in patients with a MI and 0.623 (SD 0.322) in patients with UA.
Using regression, mean utility was 0.767 (MI) and 0.724 (UA) at 1 month, changing
to 0.846 (MI) and 0.807 (UA) at 6 months, 0.877 (MI) and 0.845 (UA) at 12 months,
0.855 (MI) and 0.841 (UA) at 18 months, and 0.885 (MI) and 0.836 (UA) at 24 months.
Diabetes was associated with a decrement of 0.106, 0.046, 0.074, 0.076 and 0.059 at
1, 6, 12, 18 and 24 months, respectively. Conclusions: In this prospective, robustly
conducted study with good follow up, HRQoL associated with CV events appeared
to improve in the 6 months post-event. However, over the next 18 months HRQoL
plateaued with little to no improvement in this time period. Diabetic patients had
lower scores at each timepoint.
HS3
Impact of Morbidity in Populations of North London Clinical
Commissioning Groups on Patient Admission Rates and Gp Referrals
Groom Z C , Burgon J , Eddowes L A , Wilson T , Kusel J
Costello Medical Consulting Ltd., Cambridge, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To ascertain whether disease prevalence alone explains elective
and non-elective patient admission rates, general practitioner (GP) referral rates
and prescribing spends in 20 North London Clinical Commissioning Groups
(CCGs). Methods: Using information provided by National Health Service (NHS)
England CCG Information packs and the NHS CCG Outcomes Tool, age and sex standardised elective and non-elective admissions rates, GP referral rates and average
prescribing spends were extracted and compared to national averages and to the
prevalence of 19 commonly occurring diseases available through the Outcomes Tool
(2011). Results: Of the 20 North London CCGs included in this analysis, 4 reported
a higher non-elective admission rate (per 1,000 of the population) than the national
average. For CCGs reporting a higher than average non-elective admission rate the
disease prevalence was, on average, higher in only 6/19 diseases compared to those
CCGs reporting lower than average non-elective rates. Four CCGs reported higher
than national average elective admission rates (per 1,000 of the population); of these,
the disease prevalence was, on average, higher in 13/19 diseases than CCGs reporting
lower than average elective rates. Sixteen CCGs reported higher than national average GP referral rates, and in these CCGs 10/19 diseases had a higher prevalence compared to those CCGs reporting lower than average rates. No CCGs reported a higher
than national average prescribing spend (£, per person, per 1,000). Conclusions:
Disease prevalence appears to explain rates of elective admissions and GP referrals
relatively well in North London CCGs compared to non-elective admission rates.
Non-elective admissions commonly occur in emergency situations, thus making
A329
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
the prediction of these events challenging for primary care management and NHS
community provision. This could potentially result in increased hospital admissions,
irrespective of morbidity in the population. Alternatively, the discrepancy may be
influenced by patient proximity to accident and emergency (A&E).
HS4
Information Used in the Decision-Making Process Regarding
Influenza Vaccination Policy: Perceptions of Stakeholders in
France and the Netherlands
Silva M L 1, Perrier L 2, Paget J 3, Mosnier A 4, Buthion V 5, Cohen J M 4, Späth H M 6
Group in Health Economics (GATE, UMR 5824, CNRS); University Lyon 2, Ecully, France,
2Cancer Centre Léon Bérard, Lyon, France, 3Netherlands Institute For Health Services Research
(NIVEL), Utrecht, The Netherlands, 4Regional Group for the Surveillance of Influenza - GROG,
Open Rome, Paris, France, 5COACTIS EA 4161, University of Lyon, Lyon, France, 6University
Claude Bernard, Lyon 1 EAM 4128, Lyon, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Research
Objectives: To minimize the medical and societal impact of influenza, most WHO
countries recommend seasonal vaccination in targeted populations; however, little is known about the decision-making procedures at a country-level. In Europe,
the Netherlands has the highest rate of influenza vaccination and France is not far
behind. Our purpose was to analyze differences and similarities in the information
used in the decision-making process between these two countries, according to the
stakeholders involved. Methods: A preliminary documentary analysis identified
all stakeholders, at national level in both countries, as decision-makers (governmental authorities), advisors and information providers (research institutions, groups of
experts), and vaccine manufacturers. We undertook a qualitative study including at
least one actor from each stakeholder group involved in the process. Thirty-three faceto-face or telephone semi-structured interviews were conducted during summer 2013
in France (n=16), and autumn 2013 in the Netherlands (n=17). Every interview was
recorded and transcribed. NVivo10® was used for the qualitative analysis. Results:
Stakeholders in France and the Netherlands follow international recommendations. The most relevant information is clinical trials and epidemiological studies.
Economic models gained importance after the 2009 influenza pandemic, especially
in the Netherlands. In both countries, the advice of experts is crucial. All types of
studies are assessed through a standard checklist for public health vaccinations in
the Netherlands. In France, the assessment is not standardized, but based on general
checklists. Decision-makers are increasingly worried about the quality of studies,
due to the lack of standardized methods and influenza uncertainty. When published
studies are not generalizable, local studies are required. Conclusions: Information
used in the decision-making process is similar in both countries, although economic
models have greater importance in the Netherlands. The excellence of the process is
challenged by the poor quality of influenza data. Efforts should be made on standardization of study methods, together with harmonization of European policy.
Medication Adherence Studies
MA1
Cost-Effectiveness of Real-Time Medication Monitoring in Children
with Asthma
Goossens L M A 1, Vasbinder E C 2, Van den Bemt P M L A 3, Rutten-van Mölken M P M H 1
University, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 2Groene Hart Hospital, Gouda,
The Netherlands, 3Erasmus University Medical Center, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
survey from a representative sample of adults from France, Germany, Italy, Spain and
UK stratified by age and gender. Out of 62,000 respondents, 8,462 (11%) reported a
diagnosis of depression and 3,937 (6%) having a prescription medication for depression (Rx). Respondents classified as adherent according to the Morisky Medication
Adherence Scale (MMAS) were compared to the non-adherent on severity (PHQ-9),
sociodemographics, health characteristics, health-related quality of life (SF-36), work
productivity and activity impairment (WPAI) and health care resource use (physician, hospital and emergency visits). Results: Compared to adherent respondents
(54%), the non-adherent (46%) were more severe (37% vs. 31% with PHQ-9 score ≥ 15);
had lower Mental Component Summary (MCS: 32 vs. 33); higher Absenteeism
(18 vs. 16); more emergency visits in the previous 6 months (0.49 vs. 0.42); and their
satisfaction with medication was lower (4.97 vs. 5.27) (All p< 0.05). About 75% of
both groups were participating in psychotherapy at the time of survey and showed
no significant difference in Physical Component Summary (PCS); Presenteeism;
and number of hospitalizations. Conclusions: While efficacy measured during
clinical trials is one of the most influential measures in treatment assessment,
its ecological validity may be jeopardized by non-adherence to medication in real
life. The current study shows that low adherence is associated with more severe
depression, lower treatment satisfaction and lower mental quality of life (MCS)
in respondents taking antidepressants. These results point at the importance of
combining adherence and efficacy in the assessment of treatments for depression.
MA3
Assessing the Relationship Between Patient Compliance to Blood
Glucose Monitoring and Health Related Quality of Life
Dierick K 1, Mcbride M 2, Pike I 3
Disease Atlas, Brussels, Belgium, 2GfK USA, New York, NY, USA, 3GfK NOP, London, UK
.
.
.
1GfK
Objectives: The objective of our research was to evaluate whether there is a relationship between patient compliance to blood glucose monitoring (BGM) and HRQoL.
Moreover we wanted to understand what drives patients not to be compliant to
BGM. Methods: Data were taken from the ROPER Diabetes program which captures
information direct from diabetes patients across 27 countries on a regular basis. For
this specific study data from a sample of 1480 diabetes patients living in the USA
were collected from June to August 2013. Each patient completed a questionnaire
comprising some 2000+ variables, which included the EQ-5D-5L instrument and
accompanying VAS. Patients were asked to state their recommended frequency of
BGM and what their actual BGM frequency was during the past month. Moreover
patients were asked to explain why they were not compliant to the recommended
BGM frequency. Results: Not being compliant explained 52% (R² = 0,52) of the
variations in HRQoL. The main reasons for not being compliant to the recommended
BGM frequency were: no coverage of strips by the insurance, pain and discomfort
related to blood testing, not willing to know the test result. Other less important
drivers of non-compliance were: inconvenience, issues with food intake and meter
malfunction. Conclusions: Meter manufacturers are right when they reckon that
BGM is crucial to diabetes patients’ disease management. Manufacturers have been
innovating to make the blood testing as convenient as possible. Yet an important
driver for not complying to the recommended BGM frequency remains to be pain
and discomfort during blood testing. Manufacturers should also continue their
efforts to ensure coverage of strips by the different insurance providers in the USA.
.
1Erasmus
Objectives: Poor asthma control in children is partly caused by poor adherence
to medication. The aim of this study was to investigate the effectiveness and costeffectiveness of a Real-Time Medication Monitoring system (RTMM) to improve
adherence to inhalation corticosteroids. Methods: We performed a multi-center,
randomized controlled trial. Included were 209 children (< 12 years) with moderate to severe asthma, who had used inhaled corticosteroids (ICS) for at least 3
months. Patients were followed for 12 months. All children received an RTMM
device, but only in the intervention group text messages were sent to the parents
whose child appeared to forget an inhalation. The effectiveness measures were
adherence (percentage of inhalations taken within the correct timeframe), clinically relevant improvement in asthma control score (ACT, ≥ 3) and asthma-related
quality of life (PAQLQ, ≥ 0.5) at the end of the study. Costs were calculated from
a health care perspective (including GP, hospital, medication and RTMM device
costs) and from a societal perspective (additionally including costs of parents’
absence from work). Uncertainty around the point estimates was assessed using
bootstrapping. Results: Adherence was 73% in the treatment group and 58% in the
control group (difference 15%-pt, 95%-CIL 8.6%-22.0%). Of the RTMM patients, 33%
showed clinically relevant improvement in ACT and 22% in PAQLQ. In the control
group, these numbers were 37% and 38% respectively (differences not statistically
significant). Costs were higher in the intervention group: € 825 versus € 713, a difference of € 112 (95%-CI:-€ 139- € 338) from the health care perspective and € 1084
versus € 845 from a societal perspective (difference 239, 95%-CI: -€ 84 – € 565).The
incremental costs per 10% improvement from each perspective were € 74 and € 157
respectively. Conclusions: RTMM increases inhalation adherence, but there is no
evidence of better health outcomes in this patient population within the first year.
In these circumstances, this is not a cost-effective intervention.
MA2
The Burden Associated with Non-Adherence in European Patients
with Depression
MA4
Adherence to Antiretroviral Therapy (Art) Among Adult Hiv
Positive Patients in Volta Regional Hospital, Ghana
Okotah A N 1, Korbuvi J 2
1Volta Regional Health Directorate, Ghana Health Service, Ho, Ghana, 2Volta Regional Hospital,
Ho, Ghana
.
.
.
Objectives: Adherence to antiretroviral therapy (ART) is a critical element towards
reducing the emergence and spread of drug resistant strains of the virus. To achieve
a sustained virological suppression, at least a 95% optimal adherence is necessary. This study sought to explore the level of adherence and also identify the factors contributing to non adherence to therapy among people living with the HIV/
AIDS. Methods: The study was a descriptive cross sectional type. A systematic
sampling method was used to recruit 146 adult ARV users who have been on therapy
for at least 3 months and attended the ART clinic between March to May, 2014.
Using a structured and pretested questionnaire, data on medication adherence
were collected by adopting a one month visual analogue scale (VAS) recall, a 4 days
self reported adherence, and a pill identification test technique (PIT). A multivariate logistic regression was then used to determine key factors that were associated with adherence. Results: Of the three methods used, the optimal adherence
( ≥ 95%) for the pill identification test (PIT) was 76%, followed by the visual analogue
scale (71.2%). The 4 days self report recorded the least adherence rate (65.1%). The
overall rate of high optimal adherence was found to be 51.4%. Respondents aged
46years or more were highly adherent (61%) than their counterparts who are less
than 25years (60.0%). Those between 25 to 45years of age were the least adherent
(45.0%). However, the association between the level of adherence and the sociodemographic variables (sex, age, employment, and marital status) were not statistically significant. Conclusions: The overall optimal adherence was found to be
relatively low and fell below the minimum expected adherence of ≥ 95%. Adherence
to ART should aim at improving the pre treatment counselling and ensure the availability of ARV’S at all times.
Pedersini R , Kuehl M
Kantar Health, Epsom, UK
Studies on Nice Assessments
Objectives: Adherence to medication is regarded as an important factor for predicting clinical outcomes in mental disorders such as depression, bipolar disorder
or schizophrenia. The current study investigates the relation between adherence
and the burden of depression on society and individuals. Methods: Data were
from the 2013 EU National Health and Wellness Survey (NHWS), an internet-based
NI1
Exploring the Flaws in Clinical Data that Lead to Rejection of
Nice Submissions
.
.
Hendrich J , Griffiths E A
PAREXEL, London, UK
.
.
.
A330
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: New health technologies are required to demonstrate clinical- and
cost-effectiveness before being recommended by NICE for use in the National
Health Service. A large proportion of submissions are rejected, at least in part,
due to poor trial design or flaws in the presented clinical data. Published NICE
guidance includes a comprehensive critique of submitted clinical evidence.
Therefore, the flaws in clinical data leading to rejection by NICE were examined,
as a means of providing guidance for future submissions. Methods: All single
technology appraisals from January 2006 to May 2014 from NICE were included
in the analysis. Multiple technology appraisals, resubmissions, vaccination programmes, and requests for advice were excluded. The recommendation and reasoning behind each decision were assessed, focusing on the critique of the clinical
evidence. Results: 121 NICE submissions met the inclusion criteria, of which 28
(19.8%) were rejected. Notable flaws in the presented clinical data were reported
in 22 (78.6%) of the submissions. Major drivers of rejection due to clinical flaws
included: uncertainty in the clinical evidence (32.1%), statistical flaws in trial
design (28.6%), flaws in the choice of comparator (17.9%), and a perceived lack
of transparency in trial design (14.3%). These factors contributed to a perceived
failure to demonstrate clinical superiority over the comparator in 42.9% of the
rejected submissions. Conclusions: A failure to convincingly demonstrate clinical superiority is a major driver in the rejection of submissions to NICE, often
due to clinical trial design weaknesses or uncertainty surrounding the data presented. Manufacturers should not underestimate the need for effective planning
and review of trial design early in the clinical development process, in order to
avoid rejection by HTA agencies in later development stages.
NI2
Predicting the Impact of Value-Based Assessment on Future
Nice Appraisals
Beale R C , Maruszczak M , Kusel J
Costello Medical Consulting Ltd., Cambridge, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Value-based assessment will be introduced into National Institute for
Health and Care Excellence (NICE) appraisals where the willingness-to-pay above
£20,000 will depend upon the wider societal impact (absolute shortfall of qualityadjusted life years [QALYs]) and burden of illness (proportional QALY shortfall). The
objective of this research was to re-evaluate past appraisals and determine whether
there was a relationship between the absolute and proportional QALY shortfalls and
the NICE decision. Methods: Final incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICERs)
were identified from NICE single technology appraisals published between January
2013 and May 2014. The age that treatment commenced was taken from manufacturer submissions and combined with the average life expectancy in the UK to
calculate the discounted QALYs accrued by a healthy person (X). Discounted QALYs
accrued by current treatment were extracted from manufacturer submissions (Y).
Consequently, absolute (X-Y) and proportional (absolute/X) QALY shortfalls were
calculated for each condition. Logistic regression (LR) was performed on the data.
Appraisals were excluded if the manufacturer submission was missing. Results:
Of the appraisals assessed, 23 appraisals met the selection criteria; 13 were recommended and 10 not recommended by NICE. The LR confirmed that the probability
of an intervention being recommended was reduced significantly if the ICER was
> £30,000 (p< 0.05). Taking into account the ICER, LR analysis demonstrated that
neither the proportional nor absolute QALY shortfall had a significant effect on
recommendation by NICE (p> 0.05). Conclusions: These results suggest that in
recent appraisals, proportional and absolute QALY shortfalls have had no significant
effect on the NICE committee’s decisions, and that the introduction of value-based
assessment may therefore cause a substantial change in the future outcomes of HTA
processes. It is recognised that further appraisals before 2013 should be evaluated
to confirm these results, as the sample size was small.
NI3
Nice’s Proposed Value-Based Assessment of Health Technologies:
Concerns of Inconsistent Consideration of Social Values
Paulden M 1, O’Mahony J F 2, Culyer A J 3, McCabe C 1
of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada, 2Trinity College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland,
3University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada
.
.
.
.
.
.
1University
Background: The UK’s National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE)
recently proposed amendments to its health technology appraisal methods. Previous
amendments in 2009 and 2011 placed a greater value on the health of patients at the
“end of life” and in cases where “treatment effects are both substantial in restoring
health and sustained over a very long period”. The recent proposals repeal “end of
life” considerations but add consideration of the “proportional” and “absolute” QALY
loss from illness. NICE’s cost-effectiveness threshold may increase from £20,000 to
£50,000 per QALY based upon these and four other considerations: “certainty of
the ICER”; if health related quality of life is “inadequately captured”; the “innovative nature” of the technology; and “non-health objectives of the NHS”. Analysis:
We demonstrate that NICE’s previous amendments are flawed for two reasons:
they contain logical inconsistencies which can result in different values being
placed on health gains for identical patients, and they do not apply value weights
to patients bearing the opportunity cost of NICE’s recommendations. The newly
proposed amendments also suffer from a third flaw that the suggested weightings
are poorly justified. The second of the three flaws is particularly significant, as the
failure to apply special considerations to displaced services may result in NICE’s
cost-effectiveness threshold being too high to adequately represent opportunity
cost. Furthermore, the baseline threshold of £20,000 per QALY is greater than current
estimates of the opportunity cost. Overall, these flaws likely lead to several undesirable consequences including age discrimination, a systematic bias in favour of new
interventions over existing services, and the displacement of effective interventions
by less effective interventions. Conclusion: NICE’s proposed threshold range is
too high, for empirical and methodological reasons. NICE’s proposals will harm
the health of unidentified patients, whilst privileging the identified beneficiaries
of new health technologies.
NI4
Do health technology agencies accept methods for dealing with
treatment switching?
Maervoet J 1, Skaltsa K 2, Ivanescu C 1, Van Engen A 1
1Quintiles Consulting, Hoofddorp, The Netherlands, 2Quintiles Consulting, Barcelona, Spain
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Upon disease progression or early termination of a trial, cancer
patients in the control arm of clinical studies commonly switch to the experimental
drug or receive other post-study treatments. The objective of this study was to assess
the willingness of HTA agencies to accept the statistical methods that are available
to adjust overall survival (OS) estimates for resulting bias. Methods: PubMed and
the ADIS R&D Insights database were searched to identify pivotal trials involving treatment switching. Related HTA appraisals, published between January 2011
and February 2014, were then selected from the HTA agencies websites for further
analysis. Reports from 10 agencies were considered for review. Results: Sixteen
pivotal trials and 45 related HTA appraisals were selected for in-depth analysis.
It was widely acknowledged by all HTA agencies that treatment switching could
confound the OS estimates when an inferior drug is used as a comparator. Our
analysis suggests that statistical adjustment methods are discussed more often
and more thoroughly by agencies that base their decisions on cost-effectiveness
outcomes. On one end, NICE accepts and reviews the selection and implementation
of such methods in detail, and has recently developed its own guidelines on the
appropriate handling of treatment switching. Various examples have been identified and accepted in SMC and PBAC submissions. TLV, ZiNL, pCODR and INESSS
have accepted statistical adjustments in at least one case. No evidence of such
adjustments was identified in the selected HAS reports. On the other end, recent
case examples among IQWiG submissions suggest that they do not accept the use
of these methods. Conclusions: The rationale to adjust for treatment switching
and the methods used need to be justified towards agencies accepting the correction techniques. Other payers will rather want to base their decision on results of
the last “unbiased” dataset.
Research on Methods - Preference Studies
PR1
Survival or Mortality: Framing of the Risk Attribute in a Discrete
Choice Experiment
Veldwijk J 1, Essers B A B 2, Dirksen C D 3, Smit H A 4, Lambooij M S 1, de Wit G A 1
Institute for Public Health and the Environment, Bilthoven, The Netherlands, 2Clinical
and Medical Technology Assessment, Maastricht University Medical Centre; CAPHRI, Maastricht
University, Maastricht, The Netherlands, 3Department of Clinical Epidemiology and Medical
Technology Assessment, Maastricht University Medical Centre, Maastricht, The Netherlands,
4University Medical Center Utrecht, Utrecht, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1National
Objectives: To empirically test whether and how framing of a risk attribute
in a Discrete Choice Experiment (DCE) affects study results with respect to the
relative importance of the attributes, trading behavior and potential uptake
rates. Methods: By means of ongoing data collection, two versions of a DCEquestionnaire containing nine D-efficiently designed choice tasks were distributed among a representative sample of the Dutch population aged 55-65years. The
DCE consisted of four attributes related to the decision whether to participate in
genetic screening for colorectal cancer (CRC). Three fixed attributes were; risk of
being genetically predisposed, risk of developing CRC, and frequency of follow-up
colonoscopies. The included risk attribute was framed positively as survival rate
and negatively as mortality rate. Mixed logit models were conducted to estimate the
relative importance of the attributes. Dominant decision behavior was determined
and potential uptake rates were calculated. Results: Overall, risk attribute framing significantly interacted with most of the attribute level estimates. Based on
the positive frame, the frequency of follow-up colonoscopies was most important
followed by survival rate, while based on the negative fame, mortality rate was
most important. Twice as many respondents dominated on the survival attribute
compared to the mortality attribute. Potential uptake rates were calculated for multiple hypothetical scenarios, in all cases they were lower based on the data of the
negative frame. Conclusions: The use of a positive frame leads to significantly
increased frequency of dominant choices. Negative framing of the risk attribute
resulted in a different relative importance of the attributes and a lower willingness
to participate in genetic screening for CRC compared to positive framing. These
results call for greater attention and more research with regard to the impact of
framing of risk attributes in DCEs aiming to elicit preferences within the health
care or public health context.
PR2
Mapping from SF-6D to EQ-5D: Changes in Estimates Based on the
Choice of Algorithm
Hatswell A J 1, Ito T 2, Ganguly R 3, Nassens D 4, Almond C 1
1BresMed, Sheffield, UK, 2Janssen-Cilag Ltd, High Wycombe, UK, 3Janssen R&D, LLC, Spring
House, PA, USA, 4Janssen BVBA, Beerse, Belgium
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Where data collected using a preferred utility instrument are not available, mappings may be available to link either disease specific or generic quality
of life instruments to the preferred measure. The objective of this study was to
investigate the similarity of a widely used older mapping from SF-36 to EQ-5D and
a more recently published mapping linking the same two instruments. Methods:
Patient level SF-36 data from the PSUMMIT trials of ustekinumab versus placebo in
psoriatic arthritis (PsA) were used to generate EQ-5D utilities based upon the older
algorithm (Gray) and the newer algorithm (Rowen). A regression linking disease
specific instruments to the resulting EQ-5D utilities, used in a published economic
evaluation of anti-TNFα treatments for PsA, was also replicated to investigate the
difference the choice of mapping would make if the results were used in economic
analysis. Results: The mapping algorithms showed similar mean values (Gray
= 0.572, Rowen = 0.568) and a large degree of agreement in estimates (R2 = 0.95).
A331
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Replicating a published regression predicting EQ-5D based on Health Assessment
Questionnaire (HAQ) and Psoriasis Area and Severity Index (PASI) scores, however,
led to subtle yet statistically significant differences in coefficients (Gray EQ-5D =
0.782 -0.196xHAQ -0.00227xPASI vs. Rowen EQ-5D = 0.816 -0.220xHAQ –0.0231xPASI).
In this analysis the Rowen algorithm was more sensitive to changes in disease status, which is potentially important in a disease area with multiple available therapies. Conclusions: The choice of mapping algorithm has the potential to affect
the results of analyses performed. Although mean values obtained from different
mapping algorithms may be similar, regression coefficients were shown to differ by
mapping algorithm. Analyses using all available mappings should be presented to
avoid accusations of ‘cherry picking’ the most favourable estimate. When suggesting
the most appropriate analysis, clear justification should be provided.
PR3
Investigating the Impact of Perspective on Weighting Qalys:
a Discrete Choice Experiment
Butt T 1, Longworth L 2, Rubin G 1, Orr S 1
1University College London, London, UK, 2Brunel University, Uxbridge, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Discrete choice experiments (DCEs) are increasingly used to elicit
preferences for weighting QALYs by other characteristics. Recent studies for weighting QALYs have asked respondents to take the role of decision maker and prioritize
treatment options for groups of patients (‘someone else’). The procedure normally
used to obtain preferences for health states is for respondents to consider oneself in
that state from behind a veil of ignorance. The aim of this study was to elicit public
preferences for weighting QALYs by other characteristics, and to test if the decisionmaker perspective or naming the condition is equivalent to choosing for oneself
from behind a veil of ignorance. Methods: A DCE was developed with attributes
for health gain, severity, unmet need and process of care. Four questionnaires were
designed to reflect three different perspectives and one alternative framing: a) ‘oneself’ b) ‘someone like oneself’ c) ‘someone else’ d) ‘someone else’ with a disease label
(age-related macular degeneration). 800 members of the public were recruited via an
online survey panel, with 200 completing each of the four questionnaires. Results
were analysed using a conditional logit model and utility weights derived using
Hicksian compensating variation. Results: Attributes of health gain, severity and
process of care were significant for all perspectives (p< 0.05). Respondents preferred
treatments that offered greater health gain, for a higher severity (lower starting
level of health), and more convenient process. Unmet need was significant only in
the ‘oneself’ perspective with respondents preferring treatments that addressed
an unmet need. Conclusions: Members of the public are willing to trade health
gain for other characteristics. These include severity, process of care, and in some
cases unmet need. There is evidence that preferences for weighting QALYs vary by
perspective. The study may help inform criteria for decision-making when prioritizing health care resources.
PR4
Valuing EQ-5D-5L: Does the Ordering of the Health Dimensions
Impact on Health State Valuations?
Mulhern B 1, Shah K 2
1University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK, 2Office of Health Economics, London, UK
.
QL2
The Impact of Discrimination, Victimization and Social Standing on
Health-Related Quality of Life
Samnaliev M
Boston Childrens Hospital, Boston, MA, USA
.
Objectives: To examine the link between discrimination, victimization and social
standing on health-related quality of life (HRQL). This information is currently not
known, but is crucial as it can aid decision makers in the design of cost-effective policies to reduce such victimization among specific minority populations. Methods:
We used data from 6,194 females and males from a prospective cohort of youth
that has been tracked for over 15 years. We specifically examined the impact of
discrimination, victimization and social standing of sexual orientation minorities
on their HRQL (using EQ-5D-5L). In 2013, participants reported sexual orientation
(Completely Heterosexual [CH], Mostly Heterosexual [MH], Bisexual [B], and Lesbian/
Gay [LG])). Participants previously reported past-year bullying victimization and
discrimination (range: 1 [never] to 5 [several times/week]) and self-perceived social
standing (range: 1 [top] to 10 [bottom]) in adolescence. Longitudinal, multivariable
linear regression models were used to assess the effect of bullying and social standing in adolescence on sexual orientation HRQL score disparities in young adulthood, controlling for gender and age. Results: Compared to CHs, sexual minorities
reported more bullying and lower social standing in adolescence and lower HRQL
in young adulthood: MH HRQL score= 0.880; B 0.845; LG 0.870 vs. CH 0.916 (all differences had p-values< 0.05). When discrimination, victimization and social standing
were added to the multivariable models, orientation-group effect estimates were
attenuated ~10%, suggesting adolescent bullying and lower social standing partly
explained HRQL disparities in young adulthood. Conclusions: Our findings are
a proof of concept that victimization is not only a social justice issue but imposes
an economic burden on society, as evidenced by its impact on HRQL.Our findings
can also be used in cost-effectiveness analyses of interventions to reduce stigma
against sexual orientation minorities.
.
Objectives: Health states defined by multi-attribute instruments such as the
EQ-5D-5L can be valued using Time Trade Off (TTO) or Discrete Choice Experiment
(DCE) methods. A key feature of the tasks is the order in which the health state
dimensions are presented to respondents. This is because respondents may use
a variety of heuristics to answer the questions (for example focusing on the first
dimension presented), and therefore the order of the dimensions may impact on
the importance assigned to particular health state descriptions. The objective of
this study is to assess the impact of different EQ-5D-5L dimension orderings on
health state valuations. Methods: Preferences for EQ-5D-5L health states were
elicited from a broadly representative sample of members of the UK general public.
Respondents were allocated to one of three EQ-5D-5L dimension orderings, and
completed 10 TTO and 9 DCE tasks via a computer assisted personal interview
carried out in their home. Differences in mean values and the relative importance
of the coefficients across the arms were compared using difference testing and
regression analyses. Results: Descriptive analysis suggests that there are minimal
differences between the mean TTO health state values across the different dimension orderings. Regression analysis suggests that the magnitude of the dimension
coefficients differs across the different dimension orders (for both TTO and DCE),
but there is no clear pattern. Conclusions: There is some evidence that the
order in which the dimensions are presented impacts on the coefficients, which may
impact on the health state values provided. The order of dimensions is an important
consideration in the design of health state valuation studies.
Quality of Life and Utility Studies
QL1
Elicitation of Health State Utilities Associated with Varying
Severities of Flare in Systemic Lupus Erythematosus
Hartz S 1, Liu-Leage S 2, Paget M A 2, Pollard C 3, Cook J 3, Enstone A 3
Research Centre, Surrey, UK, 2Lilly France, Cedex, France, 3Adelphi Values, Bollington, UK
.
during face-to-face interviews with a minimum representative sample (n= 100) of
the general population, per-country, in Australia, Canada, France, Japan, Spain and
the UK. Visual Analog Scale (VAS) scores were obtained to validate TTO scores. TTO
scores were converted into utility values. Results: The highest mean TTO utility
scores (range 0.66-0.82) were observed for the anchor HS (minimal disease activity)
across all countries. All flare HS were associated with a disutility compared with the
anchor HS: mild flare HS (0.55-0.71), moderate flare HS (0.38-0.53), severe renal flare
HS (0.33-0.45), severe Central Nervous System (CNS) flare HS (0.30-0.45) and severe
generalised flare HS (0.19-0.33). Significant differences were reported between the
anchor state and each flare state across all countries (p< 0.05). Mean VAS scores
followed the same trend. The severe generalised flare HS received the lowest mean
TTO utility score across all six countries suggesting that the perceived day-to-day
impact of a severe generalised flare was greater than a severe CNS or severe renal
flare. Conclusions: These results show that a decrease in utility, representing a
detrimental impact on HRQoL, was observed with increasing severity of flare. These
results could be applied in cost-utility analyses for interventions for SLE.
.
.
.
.
.
QL3
Quality of Life Decrements after Stroke
Dewilde S 1, Thijs V 2, Annemans L 3, Peeters A 4, Belgian Stroke Council N P 5
1SHE, Brussels, Belgium, 2KULeuven, Leuven, Belgium, 3Ghent University & Brussels University,
Ghent, Belgium, 4Cliniques universitaires Saint-Luc, Bruxelles, Belgium, 5Virga Jesseziekenhuis,
Hasselt, Belgium
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To quantify which factors affect the quality of life valuations (QoL) of
patients after stroke. Methods: 569 ischemic stroke patients were recruited into
a retrospective, observational study in 10 teaching and regional hospitals across
Belgium. Patients were stratified according to their modified Rankin Score (mRS)
ranging from 0 (full health) to 5 (severely dependent). QoL as measured by the EQ5D
and the VAS were collected for their health status before and after the index stroke.
Utility decrements were calculated and using a general linear model the relationship
between a set of variables and quality of life evaluation and its decrement associated with the stroke experience was investigated. Different distributions and link
functions were tested against each other using the AICC and BIC criterion. Results:
Stroke had a significant effect on patient’s QoL: a positive relationship with the
degree of disability was found: EQ5D decrements were 0.08, 0.17, 0.25, 0.40, 0.64 and
0.75 for mRS categories 0 to 5; and equivalent decrements on the VAS scale were
7, 11, 20, 27, 33 and 39. The EQ5D and VAS decrements were significantly related
to each other (r= 0.49, p< 0.001) and the decrements were also correlated with their
baseline values (r= -0.74 for EQ5D baseline measurement and its decrement; r= -0.55
for VAS baseline value and decrement, p< 0.001). The decrements were of higher
magnitude when measured by the EQ5D compared to the VAS. Furthermore the
utility decrements were significantly associated with being female, being diabetic,
having atrial fibrillation, being in a wheelchair, experiencing a change in one’s living
situation and the number of days spent in an inpatient care facility during the first
3 months after stroke. Conclusions: Stroke results in a significant decrease in
patient’s QoL, the magnitude of which is related to patient characteristics, disease
severity measures, clinical risk factors and living circumstances.
.
1Lilly
Objectives: Systemic Lupus Erythematosus (SLE) is characterised by fluctuating periods of minimal disease activity and ‘flare’. Flare is an important outcome
variable impacting the economic and humanistic burden of SLE. The objective of
this study was to obtain population-based utility values for varying severities of
flare to measure the impact on health-related quality of life (HRQoL). Methods:
Six health states (HS) for varying severities of flare were developed based on literature, patient blogs, and interviews with patients (n= 12), rheumatologists (n= 7)
and nurses (n= 2). HS were verified by independent clinical experts (n= 6) and pilot
interviews (n= 10, UK). HS were evaluated using the time-trade-off (TTO) method
Ql4
Differences Between Hypothetical and Experience-Based Value Sets
for Eq-5d: Implications for Decision Makers
Aronsson M , Husberg M , Kalkan A , Eckard N , Alwin J
Linköping University, Linköping, Sweden
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The aim of the study was to analyse the differences between hypothetical and experience-based EQ-5D value sets. Furthermore, the aim was to evaluate the health economic implications of such differences for policy decisions in
health care. Methods: We studied the differences in hypothetical and experiencebased value sets using three different methods: numerical comparison, empirical
A332
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
comparison, and health economic examples. In the numerical comparison, the
valuations of all 243 different EQ-5D states and all pure improvements were compared. In the empirical study, a database of 23,925 individuals was used to identify
patient groups that could be influenced by the implementation of experience-based
value sets. Two hypothetical health economic examples were used to examine the
implication of the choice of value set for decision makers. Results: The numerical comparison showed that only three health states were assigned a lower QALYweight in the experience-based value set. The empirical comparison showed that
severe conditions were assigned higher values in case of experience-based value set.
Furthermore, the health economic examples showed the choice of a value set has an
effect on the health economic result. Conclusions: Shifting to experience-based
QALY-weights would increase the estimated level of quality of life in virtually all
health conditions. In extension, quality of life enhancing interventions are given
higher priority in decision making situations where hypothetical values are used to
construct QALY-weights. On the other hand, in situations where experience-based
QALY-weights are used, life-prolonging interventions will be prioritised.
RESEARCH POSTER PRESENTATIONS – SESSION I
Disease-Specific Studies
Diabetes/Endocrine Disorders – Clinical Outcomes Studies
PDB1
Hipos-ER (Hypoglycemia in Portugal Observational Study –
Emergency Room): Outcomes with Different Anti-Hyperglycemic
Agents
J 1, Laires
P 1, Dores J 2, Araújo
F 3, Carr
R 4, Brodovicz
K 5, Radican
L 6, Vicente V 7,
Conceição
Nogueira A M 1
1Merck Sharp & Dohme, Oeiras, Portugal, 2Hospital de Santo António, Porto, Portugal, 3Hospital
Beatriz Ângelo, Loures, Portugal, 4Merck Sharp & Dohme, Ballerup, Denmark, 5Merck & Co., North
Wales, PA, USA, 6Merck & Co., Inc., Whitehouse Station, NJ, USA, 7Eurotrials, Lisbon, Portugal
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: HIPOS-ER is an observational study to describe the patient population of
Type 2 Diabetics treated with an anti-hyperglycemic agent (AHA) and admitted to the
emergency room (ER) with a hypoglycemic event. In this analysis we aim to describe
the hypoglycemia events by AHA class. Methods: The study enrolled patients from 7
centers in mainland Portugal from Jan 2013 – Jan 2014. Sociodemographic and clinical
data were collected at the emergency room and patients who required hospital admission were followed up. Episodes were enrolled consecutively within the sampling
period. AHA therapy classes were Insulin - Group 1, secretagogue based - Group 2, oral
AHA excluding secretagogue - Group 3 and Insulin+secretagogue – Group 4. Results:
A total of 238 patients were admitted to the ER with severe hypoglycemia and 105
(44%) were hospitalized. The distribution based on AHA therapy: 55% (131) Group 1,
32% (75) Group 2, 7% (16) Group 3 and 7% (16) Group 4. Previous severe hypoglycemia
in the last 12 months was more frequent in Group 1 vs. Group 2 (p= 0.009). Group
2 patients were more often followed up in Primary Care vs. Group 1 (84% vs. 48%;
p<0.001) and Group 4 (44%, p=0.002). Group 2 patients were more often hospitalized vs.
Group 1 (71% vs. 29%; p<0.001) and Group 4 (31%; p=0.003). There was no difference in
terms of the length of stay or hospitalization outcome. 9 deaths occurred: 5 in Group
1, 3 in Group 2 and 1 in Group 3. Conclusions: In the first national study on severe
hypoglycemia in Type 2 diabetics, patients treated with Group 2 drugs were followed
mainly in Primary care setting. More patients on Group 2 drugs were hospitalized.
Within our sample there is little clinical difference in the hypoglycemia events with
different therapys besides the need for hospitalization.
PDB3
Regional Assessment of Severe Hypoglycemic Coma Events in
Finland
Vattulainen P 1, Mushnikov V 1, Hoti F 1, Saukkonen T 2, Korhonen P 1
1EPID Research, Espoo, Finland,, 2Novo Nordisk Farma, Espoo, Finland
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In a previous study about severe hypoglycemic coma events (SH)
among diabetes mellitus (DM) patients we saw regional variation in SH occurrence.
The purpose was to compare the incidence of SH between hospital districts in
Finland. Methods: This study among type 1 (T1) and 2 (T2) diabetic patients was
based on nationwide health care registers. The study cohort contained insulin naïve
diabetic patients who had filled at least one prescription of insulin during follow-up
in 2006-2009. SH was defined as a hospitalization or a secondary health care visit
due to hypoglycemic coma (ICD-10: E10.00 and E11.00). Stratified incidence rates and
adjusted hazard ratio (HR) estimates with 95% confidence intervals (CI) were calculated. Analyses were performed for the first and recurrent SHs. Results: The population comprised 5271 (17.6%) patients with T1 and 24602 (82.4%) with T2. Altogether
3.1% patients experienced at least one SH during the follow-up. In different hospital
districts the rate of first SHs varied from 5.6 (Varsinais-Suomi) to 47.8 (Länsi-Pohja)
for T1, and from 4.8 (Pohjois-Karjala) to 50.3 (Länsi-Pohja) for T2. Compared to the
capital area, the risks of first SHs varied differently for T1 and T2, but were commonly higher in Länsi-Pohja (T1: HR 3.46, CI 1.41-8.46; T2: HR 1.60, CI 1.13-2.29) and
lower in Pohjois-Karjala (T1: no events; T2: HR 0.275, CI 0.14-0.56). Taking all SH
events into account did not change these differences remarkably. Conclusions:
We found differences between regions in risk of hospital-treated SH in both DM
types. Further analyses will be performed for e. g. ambulance density.
PDB4
Hipos-ER (Hypoglycemia in Portugal Observational Study –
Emergency Room): Clinical Outcomes in Admitted Patients
Conceição J 1, Dores J 2, Araújo F 3, Laires P 1, Carr R 4, Brodovicz K 5, Radican L 6, Nogueira
AM1
1Merck Sharp & Dohme, Oeiras, Portugal, 2Hospital de Santo António, Porto, Portugal, 3Hospital
Beatriz Ângelo, Loures, Portugal, 4Merck Sharp & Dohme, Ballerup, Denmark, 5Merck & Co., North
Wales, PA, USA, 6Merck & Co., Inc., Whitehouse Station, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
PDB2
Hipos-ER (Hypoglycemia in Portugal Observational Study –
Emergency Room): Clinical Outcomes in the Emergency Room
Objectives: HIPOS-ER is an observational, cross-sectional, multicenter study to
describe the patient population of Type 2 diabetics treated with an anti-hyperglycemic agent (AHA) and admitted to the emergency room (ER) with a hypoglycemic
event. This is the first national hypoglycemia study in Portugal and the first study
collecting hypoglycemia specific resource data directly in this setting. Here we aim
to describe the clinical features of hospitalized patients. Methods: The study
enrolled patients from 7 centers in mainland Portugal for a period of 12 months
(Jan 2013 – Jan 2014). Sociodemographic and clinical data were collected at the
emergency room and patients who required hospital admission were followed up.
Episodes were enrolled consecutively within the sampling period. Results: A total
of 238 patients were enrolled, and 105 (44%) were hospitalized and 2 (1%) were
transferred outside the hospital center for likely need of hospitalization. Mean age
was 78 years, average disease duration was 19 years, 51% were female, 36% were
on insulin, 51% on a secretagogue, 9% on an oral AHA excluding secretagogue and
5% on insulin+secretagogue. 26% had complications diagnosed in the ER: Trauma
(37%) and Cardiovascular (22%) and Infection/Sepsis (22%) were the most frequent.
Mean and median hospitalization time was 9 and 5 days, respectively. Most (95%)
patients were admitted to a medical department: Internal medicine (80%) and the ER
observation/short stay unit (15%) were the most frequent. 6% of patients were admitted to an intensive care unit. 8% (9) of hospitalized patients died. Conclusions:
Hospitalized diabetic patients following an ER episode due to hypoglycemia were
treated mainly with secretagogue type drugs. Internal medicine was key in the
hospital approach of these patients. The length of stay exceeded the 48-72h typical
surveillance period for secretagogue-induced hypoglycemia. Severe hypoglycemia
in Portugal is associated with several complications which also include death.
Conceição J 1, Dores J 2, Araújo F 3, Laires P 1, Carr R 4, Brodovicz K 5, Radican L 6,
Nogueira A M 1
1Merck Sharp & Dohme, Oeiras, Portugal, 2Hospital de Santo António, Porto, Portugal, 3Hospital
Beatriz Ângelo, Loures, Portugal, 4Merck Sharp & Dohme, Ballerup, Denmark, 5Merck & Co., North
Wales, PA, USA, 6Merck & Co., Inc., Whitehouse Station, NJ, USA
PDB5
Comparative Efficacy and Safety of Empagliflozin with Other
Anti-Diabetic Drugs for the Treatment of Patients with Type 2
Diabetes Mellitus Who are Failing Insulin
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: HIPOS-ER is an observational, cross-sectional, multicenter study to
characterize the population of Type 2 Diabetics treated with an anti-hyperglycemic
agent (AHA) who were admitted to the emergency room (ER) with a hypoglycemic
event. This is the first national ER hypoglycemia study and the first study collecting
primary resource data in this setting. Here we aim to describe this population and
the hospital management. Methods: The study enrolled patients from 7 centers
in mainland Portugal from Jan 2013 – Jan 2014. Sociodemographic and clinical data
were collected within the emergency room and patients who required hospital
admission were followed-up. Results: A total of 238 events were recorded. Mean
age: 76 years; average disease duration: 19 years; 58% female; 80.9% were not
living alone; 83% no formal education or schooling < 4 years; 25% had a previous
episode of severe hypoglycemia in the preceding 12 months and 61% were treated
in a primary care setting. Regarding drug treatment: 55% on insulin; 32% on a
secretagogue; 7% on other oral AHA and 7% on insulin+secretagogue. Missing a
meal was the most frequent immediate cause of hypoglycemia (56%). All patients
received lab evaluations. 71% underwent radiological procedures. Time spent in
the ER was 11 hours (mean) and the average medical and nurse time utilized was
85 and 71 min respectively. AHA therapy was changed in 65% of cases: insulin
adjustment (56%) being the most frequent modification. 56% (132) of patients were
discharged. Conclusions: Diabetic patients admitted to the ER have several
markers of frailty and low educational status. Strategies to mitigate hypoglycemia
underline the need to avoid missed meals. ER episodes are lengthy and consume
significant physician and nurse time as well as laboratory and other diagnostic
procedures. Primary care stakeholders should be involved in actions to mitigate
hypoglycemia in type 2 diabetes.
Thorlund K 1, Siliman G 1, Eapen S 1, Lund S 2, Palencia R 3
Outcomes, Vancouver, BC, Canada, 2Boehringer Ingelheim Pharma GmbH & Co. KG,
Ingelheim am Rhein, Germany, 3Boehringer Ingelheim GmbH, Ingelheim am Rhein, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
1Redwood
Objectives: The aim of the present network meta-analysis is to compare the efficacy and safety of empagliflozin versus other anti-diabetic drugs, in patients with
type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) who are inadequately controlled with any insulin
treatment and with or without other anti-diabetic drugs (ADs). Methods: We
performed a systematic review of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and Bayesian
network meta-analysis to establish the comparative efficacy and safety of SGLT-2s,
DPP-4s, GLP-1s and TZDs in T2DM patients. The principal outcome of this analysis
was the effect of these drugs on HbA1c, weight, systolic blood pressure (SBP), incidence of hypoglycaemia and urinary tract infections (UTIs) at 24 weeks. Results:
Sixteen RCTs were included. All patients received insulin treatment (any type) with
or without other additional ADs. Compared with placebo, mean changes in HbA1c
were -0.51 % [95% confidence interval (CI) -0.93 to -0.11%] and -0.60% [95%CI -1.03 to
-0.19%] for empagliflozin 10mg and 25mg, respectively. HbA1c reduction was similar
for all other interventions, and no significant differences were detected. Compared
with placebo, Empagliflozin 10mg and 25mg significantly reduced patients weight by
approximately -1.5kg. Other SLGT-2s and all GLP-1s were associated with a similar
weight loss, not change was observed for DPP-4s, and non-significant weight gains
were observed for TZDs. Empagliflozin was also associated with significant reductions in SBP, and no significant differences between treatments were detected. For
hypoglycaemic events, empagliflozin 10mg and 25mg were associated with nonsignificant relative risks of 1.03 and 1.23. All interventions had non-significant relative risks of UTIs. Conclusions: Compared with other treatments, empagliflozin
A333
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
offers similar or reduced HbA1c reduction, had comparable significant weight loss
to other SLGT-2s and GLP-1s, and appeared to have a superior weight loss profile
compared with DPP-4s and TZDs.. No increased risk of adverse events were observed
for empagliflozin compared with placebo and other ADs.
PDB6
Comparative Efficacy and Safety of Empagliflozin with Other
Antidiabetic Drugs for the Third Line Treatment of Type 2 Diabetes
Mellitus
Thorlund K 1, Siliman G 1, Eapen S 1, Lund S 2, Palencia R 3
Outcomes, Vancouver, BC, Canada, 2Boehringer Ingelheim Pharma GmbH & Co. KG,
Ingelheim am Rhein, Germany, 3Boehringer Ingelheim GmbH, Ingelheim am Rhein, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
1Redwood
Objectives: The aim of the present network meta-analysis is to compare the efficacy and safety of empagliflozin versus other antidiabetic drugs used in third line
for the treatment of patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM). Methods: We
conducted a systematic review randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and Bayesian
network meta-analysis to establish the comparative efficacy and safety of SGLT-2s,
DPP-4s, GLP-1s, and TZDs. RCTs enrolling subjects with T2DM inadequately controlled on metformin plus sulfonylurea were included. The principal outcome of
this analysis was the effect of these drugs on HbA1c, weight, systolic blood pressure (SBP), incidence of hypoglycaemia and urinary tract infections (UTIs) at 24
weeks. Results: From 6969 abstracts, 13 were included in the analysis. No RCTs
involving TZDs were identified. Compared with placebo, mean changes in HbA1c
were -0.65% [95% confidence interval (CI) -1.59 to -0.08%] and -0.60% [95%CI -1.14 to
-0.14%] for empagliflozin 10mg and 25mg. No significant differences were detected
between interventions. Mean changes in weight with empagliflozin 10mg and 25mg
were -1.77 [95%CI -2.19 to -1.35) and -2.00 (95%CI -2.44 to -1.57), respectively. Mean
weight losses were fairly similar across SLGT-2s and GLP-1s ranging between -1.26
to -2.12. All DPP-4s were associated weight gains, ranging form 0.33 to 0.98, of which
most were statistically significant. SBP data were only available for SGLT-2s and
DPP-4s. Empagliflozin 10mg and 25mg compared with placebo had statistically significant reductions of -2.70 and -2.09. All interventions (except exenatide) yielded
relative risk of hypoglycaemia greater than 1.00. For UTIs, no differences were found
between SLGT-2s or DPP-4s and placebo. Conclusions: Compared with other
SGLT-2s, DPP-4s, and GLP-1s, empagliflozin generally offers similar HbA1c control
at week 24, an advantageous profile in weight loss and reduction of SBP, as well as
similar safety profile.
PDB7
Comparative Efficacy and Safety of Empagliflozin with Other Oral
Antidiabetic Drugs for the Second Line Treatment of Type 2 Diabetes
Mellitus
Thorlund K 1, Siliman G 1, Eapen S 1, Lund S 2, Palencia R 3
1Redwood Outcomes, Vancouver, BC, Canada, 2Boehringer Ingelheim Pharma GmbH & Co. KG,
Ingelheim am Rhein, Germany, 3Boehringer Ingelheim GmbH, Ingelheim am Rhein, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To compare the efficacy and safety of empagliflozin versus other second-line treatment for patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM). Methods: A
systematic review and Bayesian network meta-analysis were performed to identify
randomized controlled trials (RCTs) assessing the efficacy and safety of SGLT-2s,
DPP-4s, GLP-1s, TZDs, and SUs in patients with T2DM. RCTs enrolling subjects with
T2DM inadequately controlled with metformin monotherapy were included. The
principal outcomes were HbA1c, weight, systolic blood pressure (SBP), hypoglycaemia, and urinary tract infections (UTIs) at 24 weeks. Results: Forty-eight RCTs
were included. The mean differences (MD) in HbA1c were -0.56% [95% confidence
interval (CI) -1.06% to -0.08%] and -0.64% [95%CI -1.14 to -0.14%] for Empagliflozin
10mg and 25mg vs placebo. All other interventions yielded similar reductions and
no significant differences were detected between interventions. Empagliflozin 10mg
and 25mg significantly changed patients’ weight by -1.63kg (95%CI -2.66 to -0.64)
and -2.01kg (95%CI -3.02 to -1.02), versus placebo. Other SLGT-2s had similar MDs, all
DPP-4s had no change, and GLP-1s fell in between. All SUs and TZDs were associated
with significant weight gain versus placebo. For SBP, the MDs for Empagliflozin 10mg
and 25mg versus placebo were -4.09mmHg (95%CI -6.97 to -1.18) and -4.81mmHg
(95%CI -7.69 to -2.00). No significant differences between Empagliflozin and other
interventions were detected. Incidence of hypoglycaemia for empagliflozin 10 and
25 mg relative to placebo was 2.71 [95%CI 0.46 to 11.44] and 1.97 [95%CI 0.23 to 9.57],
respectively. No significant differences were detected between emplagliflozin and
other interventions. For UTIs, all yielded relative risks close to 1.00 when compared
with placebo. Conclusions: Compared with other SGLT-2s, DPP-4s, GLP-1s, TZDs,
and SUs, empagliflozin offers similar HbA1c control at 24 weeks, a marked reduction in weight compared with DPP-4s, TZDs, and SUs, and a similar safety profile
as other interventions.
PDB8
Long-Term Modeling of Using Manually Coded and Autocoded
Blood Glucose Meters in Diabetes Treatment
Yagudina R , Kulikov A , Babiy V
I. M. Sechenov First Moscow State Medical University, Moscow, Russia
.
.
26 years period was associated with 18,59 LYG. At the same time use of autocoded
blood glucose meters was associated with 18,92 LYG. In case of using autocoded
meters instead of using manually coding meters patients obtained 0,33 LYG more
(120 days). Conclusions: Obtained results showed that difference in glucose
measurement errors between manually coded and autocoded blood glucose meters
can lead to the difference in long-term outcomes in diabetes treatment.
PDB9
Assessing the Relationship between Improved Life Expectancy
Due to Better Cardiovascular Risk Factor Management and the
Likelihood of Microvascular Complications in Type 2 Diabetes
Mellitus
McEwan P 1, Grant D 2, Foos V 3
1Health Economics and Outcomes Research Ltd, Cardiff, UK, 2IMS Health, London, UK, 3IMS
Health, Basel, Switzerland
.
.
.
Objectives: Type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) is a chronic disease associated
with increased risk of cardiovascular (CV) and microvascular complications.
Improvements in blood pressure and cholesterol control have resulted in a reduction in CV event rates in clinical practice. The objective of this study was to assess
the relationship between increased life expectancy, due to reduction in CV event
rates, and the risk of microvascular disease for a range of glycemic control levels. Methods: A lifetime analysis was conducted using the CORE diabetes model
(CDM). Newly diagnosed T2DM simulated patients aged 52 years at baseline with
HbA1c 7.1%, SBP 135.1 mmHg, total cholesterol: HDL 5.2 mmol/l were modelled. The
impact of HbA1c on microvascular complications was assessed by running the CDM
with baseline HbA1c ±1% for scenario 1: 100% of patient receiving CV risk factor
management; and scenario 2: no CV risk factor management. Results: Improved
CV risk factor management reduced the predicted cumulative incidence of fatal
myocardial infarction (MI) from 27% to 18%, increasing life expectancy by an average of 2 years. For scenario 1, baseline HbA1c +1% versus -1% was associated with
a 20%, 11% and 4% increase in microalbuminuria (MA), gross proteinuria (GRP) and
end stage renal disease (ESRD), respectively; for scenario 2, the increase was 15.5%
for MA, 7.6% for GRP and 2.5% for ESRD. Cumulative incidence of neuropathy ranged
from 68.4% (baseline HbA1c +1%) to 42.1% (baseline HbA1c -1%) for scenario 1 and
from 65.2% (baseline HbA1c +1%) to 39.7% (baseline HbA1 c-1%) for scenario 2.
Cumulative retinopathy rates were similar across both scenarios: 56.7% versus 56.0%
for scenarios 1 and 2, respectively. Conclusions: This modeling study suggests
that improvements in blood pressure and cholesterol management may result in
increased rates of microvascular complications, in particular renal disease, over the
long term as patient survival increases.
PDB11
A Systematic Review and Network Meta-Analysis Assessing the
Effectiveness and Tolerability of Gliptins and Sulfonylureas as
Monotherapy in Patients with Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus If Metformin
is not Considered Appropriate
Bartmus T , Mansmann U
Institut für medizinische Informationsverarbeitung, Biometrie und Epidemiologie, LudwigMaximilians-Universität, Munich, Germany
.
.
Objectives: A significant proportion of patients with type-2-diabetes mellitus
(T2DM) are unable to take Metformin as recommended first-line therapy due to
gastrointestinal intolerance or contraindications such as chronic kidney disease.
In contrast to combination therapy no network meta-analysis (NMA) has been
undertaken for oral anti-diabetic drugs (OAD) as monotherapy in this population particularly with respect to gliptins and sulfonylureas as second-line options. The
purpose of this study is to assess the comparative effectiveness and tolerability of
gliptins versus sulfonylureas in terms of glycated hemoglobin (HbA1c), body weight
and hypoglycemia. Methods: A systematic review was conducted searching bibliographic databases, reports of regulatory authorities and clinical trial registries
through July 2012 to identify randomized controlled trials in adult T2DM patients
receiving at least 12 weeks of OAD monotherapy or placebo. A Bayesian NMA was
performed to yield mixed treatment comparisons. Consistency was examined by the
node split method. Results: A total of 62 studies enrolling 21,302 patients informed
the entire network. Due to their improved model fit estimates from random effect
models are reported to account for heterogeneity across the set of studies. After a
mean follow-up of 32 weeks, the difference in mean HbA1c was 0.26, 0. 95 credible
interval (CrI0.95): [0.1; 0.42], in favour of sulfonylureas. However, gliptins induced
weight loss (difference in means: -1.21 kg; CrI0.95: [-1.57; -0.84] ) and were associated
with a considerably lower incidence of any hypoglycemia compared to sulfonylureas
(odds ratio: 0.22; CrI0.95: [0.15; 0.31] ). All effect estimates were statistically significant
and consistent in terms of combining direct and indirect evidence. Conclusions:
This is the first network assessing OAD monotherapy that can readily be extended
to emerging therapies. With regard to glycemic control gliptins were slightly inferior
to sulfonylureas, whereas they positively affected body weight and risk of hypoglycemia, confirming their role in second-line monotherapy.
.
Objectives: To obtain long-term clinical outcomes of using manually coded
and autocoded blood glucose meters in diabetes treatment in the Russian
Federation. Methods: The model used in this study analyzed the influence of
errors in blood glucose measurements (due to using manually or autocoded glucose meters) on the treatment of patients with Type 1 and Type 2 diabetes during
the 26 years period (the life-time period). Life years gained (LYG) was chosen as an
outcome measure in assessment of health intervention. Calculation of LYG was
based on prior clinical studies that evaluated glucose meters’ errors in glucose
level measurements and risk of complications associated with blood glucose level.
Data for patients with diabetes was obtained from prior epidemiological studies
that had been provided in Russian Federation. Results: Use of manually coded
blood glucose meters in the analyzed population with median age of 53 years during
PDB12
Glycemic, Lipid, and Blood Pressure Control Among Individuals
with Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus in Saudi Arabia
Osenenko K M 1, Szabo S M 1, Donato B M K 2, Korol E E 1, Qatami L 3, Al Jaser S 4, Al Saggabi A 4,
El Seid M E 4, Maclean R 5, Levy A R 1
1ICON Epidemiology, Vancouver, BC, Canada, 2Bristol-Myers Squibb Company, Wallingford, CT,
USA, 3Bristol-Myers Squibb Company, Dubai, United Arab Emirates, 4King Fahad National Guard
Hospital, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, 5Bristol-Myers Squibb Company, Plainsboro, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Inadequate glycemic, blood pressure (BP), and low-density lipoprotein (LDL) control among persons with type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) increases
the risk of T2DM-related complications, which require more intensive and costly
therapy. Extending on a recently-conducted study in Dubai, UAE, we assessed levels
of glycemic, LDL, and BP control, and estimated the proportion of those meeting
A334
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
guideline targets, among a cohort of individuals treated for T2DM in Riyadh, Saudi
Arabia. Methods: Charts from 455 adults with T2DM who visited the King Fahad
National Guard Hospital from October 2009 to March 2010 (enrolment period) were
systematically sampled until the target (n= 250) was reached. Haemoglobin A1c
(HbA1c), LDL, and BP test results from enrolment to September 2011 were abstracted.
The most recent test values were compared to guideline targets. The proportion
of well-controlled (target met on all tests) and never-controlled (target not met on
any test) subjects over the study period was calculated. Analyses were stratified
by T2DM duration. Results: Forty-four percent of the cohort was male; at enrolment, mean (SD) age was 61 (13) years and mean T2DM duration was 11 (8) years.
At the most recent assessment, 36 subjects (14%) had HbA1c < 7%, 91 (36%) had
HbA1c ≥ 9%, and 177 (72%) had LDL < 100mg/dL. Although 109 subjects (44%) met
BP targets (< 130/80mmHg), 30% had BP ≥ 140/90mmHg. HbA1c, LDL and BP were
well-controlled in 5.2%, 45.9%, and 8.4% of subjects, respectively, while 71.2%, 13.4%
and 22.9% were never-controlled, respectively. The proportion of the cohort that
was never-controlled for HbA1c increased with T2DM duration. Conclusions:
While rates of HbA1c control were low among subjects with T2DM, nearly half met
BP targets and nearly three quarters met LDL targets. Given the increased risk of
complications associated with poor control, achieving higher rates of control could
reduce the burden of T2DM in Saudi Arabia.
PDB13
Budget Impect Analysis
Sun T
chian pharmaceyical university, nanjing, China
.
Objectives: To quantify the number and costs of relapses avoided over 2
years in the first-line treatment of RRMS based on the findings of the Cochrane
report. Methods: An Excel-based financial model estimated the relapses and costs
incurred by a hypothetical cohort of 1000 RRMS patients treated with first-line
disease-modifying drugs (DMDs). The modelled cohort evaluated the consequences
of treatment with subcutaneous (SC) interferon beta-1a versus intramuscular
(IM) interferon beta-1a, as this was the only comparison whose data quality was
assessed as ‘high’ by the Cochrane Review (Filippini et al., 2013). Risk of relapse
was based on the 2-year data from the Cochrane Review network meta-analysis.
The analysis was performed from a US payer perspective. The cost of a relapse was
sourced from Panitch et al., 2005, and adjusted to 2012 US dollars. Net annual cost
of therapy was based on wholesale acquisition cost. Given the model’s short time
horizon, disability-related costs were not included as these tend to be an important
economic driver only over the long-term progression of the disease. In order to test
how variability in the model’s inputs might impact the analysis’ results, two-way
sensitivity analyses were performed based on the reported 95% risk of relapse credible intervals for SC interferon beta-1a and IM interferon beta-1a. Results: In a
hypothetical cohort of 1000 RRMS patients, treatment with SC interferon beta-1a
is expected to result in the avoidance of 173 (sensitivity analysis range: -20 to 399)
relapses versus IM interferon beta-1a over 2 years. Assuming a direct cost of relapse
of $5141, this represents a savings of $890,212 (sensitivity analysis range: -$102,138
to $2,052,934) versus IM interferon beta-1a. Conclusions: Subcutaneous interferon beta-1a is likely to result in fewer relapses and lower direct costs of relapse
versus IM interferon beta-1a over a 2-year period treatment.
PDB14
A Decision-Focused Mixed Treatment Comparison (MTC) of
Alternative Dpp-4 Inhibitors (Dpp-4i’s) Used in Combination With
Metformin or a Sulfonylurea for the Treatment of Type 2 Diabetes
Mellitus (T2DM)
Tolley K 1, Strickson A 2, Kay S 2, Benson E 2, Selby R 2
1Tolley Health Economics Ltd., Buxton, Derbyshire, UK,, 2Hardwick House, Buxton, Derbyshire, UK
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To conduct decision-focused mixed treatment comparisons (MTCs)
of the relative efficacy and safety of a new DPP-4 inhibitor (DPP-4i), alogliptin 25mg
daily compared to current DPP-4i’s used in UK clinical practice (sitagliptin, saxagliptin, linagliptin, vildagliptin) in dual therapy for the treatment of type 2 diabetes
mellitus (T2DM) in combination with metformin or sulfonylurea (SU). Methods: A
decision-focused systematic review was conducted to identify RCTs comparing the
DPP-4i’s in combination with metformin or SU compared to metformin or SU alone
or against each other in the target patient population. Separate Bayesian MTCs were
conducted for each DPP-4i combination. Outcomes of interest were change in HbA1c
from baseline (primary), weight change, proportion of patients HbA 1c < 7%, and
proportion of patients ≥ 1 hypoglycaemic episode. Fixed and random effects models
were run with sensitivity analysis conducted to account for confounding factors
(study length, baseline HbA1c), study heterogeneity and inconsistency. Results:
Twenty-five RCTs met inclusion criteria for the MTCs. For the primary outcome,
fixed effects models suffered from heterogeneity problems whilst random effect
models struggled to estimate between trial heterogeneity. However, the base case
and all sensitivity analyses showed the same results - alogliptin in combination with
metformin or SU had a high probability of non-inferiority to comparator DPP-4’s in
HbA1c change (61%-100% at a 0.3% HbA1cmargin). Deletion of trial outliers via leverage plots vastly improved model fit within fixed effects models whilst not changing
underlying results. For all other outcomes alogliptin was shown to be comparable to
alternative DPP-4i’s. Conclusions: Alogliptin 25mg has comparable efficacy and
safety as other DPP-4i’s at their recommended doses in UK clinical practice. This
is in line with expectations based on prior meta-analyses of DPP-4i’s. The use of a
decision-focused approach to the MTC enables a focus on the data of direct interest
for clinical and HTA based decision making.
PDB15
Identifying Consistent Inconsistency in Network Meta-Analyses An Illustration In Type 2 Diabetes
Hawkins N 1, Scott D A 2
PLC, Oxford, UK, 2ICON Health Economics, Oxford, UK
.
1ICON
.
.
Objectives: Network meta-analyses (NMA) provide estimates of comparative
efficacy for multiple treatments based on an analysis of connected networks of
trial comparisons. A key concern is the comparability of treatment effect estimates
from different trials. Where there is both indirect and direct evidence for one or
more comparisons (‘loops’ in the network) it is possible to evaluate empirically the
‘consistency’ of the network. Methods: A variety of methods have been proposed
to examine inconsistency including: (i) node-splitting where the direct and indirect
estimates are compared across the network (ii) comparison to an ‘inconsistency’
model where estimates for each treatment comparison are allowed to be independent, (iii) inclusion of treatment by design interaction terms, (iv) investigation
of residual deviance estimates for individual trial arms, and (v) investigation of
mixed predictive p-values. We compare the implementation and, most importantly, the interpretation of these methods using a previously published NMA in
type 2 diabetes. In this analysis HbA1c was compared across six treatments in
a network of 22 studies with multiple ‘loops’. Results: The methods agreed in
showing the presence of inconsistency with the network. For example, the inconsistency model showed an improved fit (DIC -62.35) compared to the consistency
model (DIC -60.25). The node splitting method identified statistically significant
inconsistency in two treatment arcs (liraglutide 1.8mg vs placebo and liraglutide
1.8mg vs exenatide QW). Conclusions: The alternative methods vary in their
ability to provide an omnibus ‘test’ of inconsistency across the network and their
ability to identify which parts of the network contain inconsistencies. We highlight
that none of the methods alone can identify individual studies as being the cause
of inconsistencies and argue that we need to consider the whole structure of the
network and the characteristics of the studies (in terms of treatments, subjects
and design) within the network.
PDB17
The Efficacy and Effectiveness in HBA1C-Lowering is Dependent on
Baseline Body Mass Index (BMI) for Sitagliptin but not Canagliflozin
in the Treatment of Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus (T2DM)
Diels J 1, Angermund R 2, Schroeder M 3, Worbes-Cerezo M 3, Thompson G 3
1Janssen Research & Development, Beerse, Belgium, 2Janssen-Cilag Germany, Mainz, Germany,
3Janssen-Cilag UK, High Wycombe, UK
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To investigate HbA1c-reduction by baseline BMI in patients treated
with canagliflozin or sitagliptin, using clinical trial and electronic medical record
(EMR) data. Methods: Patient-level data from two randomised controlled trials (RCTs) were used to explore HbA1c-reduction from baseline after 52 weeks
treatment with canagliflozin (100/300mg) or sitagliptin (100mg) by baseline
BMI. Ordinary least squares (OLS) regression was performed with HbA1c, BMI,
eGFR and demographics as covariates, in patients with metformin (MET) or
metformin+glimepiride (MET+SU) background therapy. EMR-data (UK General
Practitioner data from CPRD) on HbA1c over time in patients treated with sitagliptin were analysed by background therapy using repeated measures analysis,
with baseline BMI, HbA1c and demographics as covariates. Results: In both RCTs
sitagliptin showed a decreasing HbA1c-reduction by increasing baseline BMI, while
efficacy of canagliflozin was independent of BMI. The estimated HbA1c-reduction
(%) from baseline for sitagliptin in patients with baseline BMI of 25 vs. 40 varied
between -0.87 to -0.58 (MET; Δ = 0.29, p= 0.01) and -0.87 to -0.54 (MET+SU; Δ = 0.33,
p= 0.0014), while a non-significant increase in HbA1c-reduction was observed in
high BMI-patients in all canagliflozin-arms (Δ between -0.04 and -0.07). EMRdata showed similar decreasing effectiveness of sitagliptin in high BMI-patients.
Estimated HbA1c-reduction (month 10; baseline HbA1c 9%) was significantly less
(MET: Δ = 0.30, MET+SU: Δ = 0.35, p< 0.0001) in patients with BMI 40 vs. 25. No data
for canagliflozin were yet available. Lower efficacy of sitagliptin in obese patients
has been previously reported in the literature. Conclusions: RCT and EMRdata consistently show that the relative efficacy of anti-diabetic treatments may
depend on baseline BMI. Reduced efficacy of sitagliptin and DPP-4 inhibitors in
general in obese patients may be explained by a higher degree of insulin-resistance. Efficacy of canagliflozin is independent of BMI, due to its insulin-independent mechanism of action. Patients’ BMI should be taken into account to select
effective therapeutic options for patients with T2DM.
PDB18
Treatment Maintenance Duration of Dual Therapy with Metformin
and Sitagliptin in Type 2 Diabetes – Real-World Data From Odyssee
Study
Leproust S 1, Dallongeville J 2, Valensi P 3, Boutmy E 4, Moisan C 1, chanut-Vogel C 5,
de Pouvourville G 6
1Merck (MSD France), Paris, France, 2INSERM U744, Lille, France, 3Service d’EndocrinologieDiabétologie-Nutrition, Bondy, France, 4Cegedim Strategic Data, Boulogne-Billancourt, France,
5Laboratoires MSD France, Courbevoie, France, 6ESSEC, Cergy-Pontoise, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: comparative effectiveness of new oral anti-diabetic drugs in primary
care practice remains poorly characterized. This presentation focus on the relevant
statistical methods used to handle common potential bias related to real-world
observational designs. Methods: multicenter, longitudinal, observational study,
conducted in primary care in France. Participating physicians were to include
adult type 2 diabetes patients initiating a treatment with metformin and sitagliptin dual therapy (M-Sit group) or metformin and sulfonylurea dual therapy
(M-SU group). Planned follow-up period was three years. The primary endpoint
was the treatment maintenance duration, from initiation of dual therapy to a
strict change, defined as the addition, replacement or withdrawal of an agent used
for initial dual therapy. Survival Kaplan-Meier analysis, multivariate Cox model
adjusted on the propensity score in order to limit bias due to baseline imbalance
between the two groups and sensitivity analyses including multiple imputations to
deal with missing data have been performed. Results: a total of 3 453 patients
have been analyzed: 1 874 in the M-Sit group and 733 in the M-SU group.
In the principal analysis, the median treatment maintenance duration was
20.2 months in the M-SU group and 43.2 months in the M-Sit group (p < 0.0001).
A335
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Multivariate Cox model adjusted for propensity score and sensitivity analysis
confirmed a reduced risk of treatment change for M-Sit versus M-SU with a relative risk of 0.70 [0.62; 0.78] (p< 0.0001). Conclusions: We observed an approximate two-fold increase in the median treatment maintenance duration in the
met-Sit group versus the met-SU group. Given the observational design, confounding factors on the primary outcome cannot be excluded. However, multivariate
and sensitivity analyses showed no qualitative change in the principal finding,
providing some confidence in the observed difference between the two dual
therapies.
PDB19
Assessing Consistency in a Network Meta-Analysis to Compare
Once Weekly Dulaglutide Versus Other Glp-1 Receptor Agonists in
Patients with Type 2 Diabetes
Hawkins N 1, Padhiar A 1, Thompson J 1, Scott D A 1, Eaton J N 1, Varol N 2, Norrbacka K 2,
Boye K S 3, Nicolay C 4
1ICON Clinical Research UK Ltd., Oxford, UK, 2Eli Lilly and Company, Windlesham, UK, 3Eli Lilly
and Company, Indianapolis, IN, USA, 4Eli Lilly and Company, Bad Homburg, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To demonstrate the use and interpretation of alternative approaches
to evaluate and understand inconsistency within network meta-analyses
(NMA). Methods: A network meta-analysis was performed to compare the efficacy
of once weekly dulaglutide 1.5mg to licensed doses of liraglutide, exenatide, lixisenatide, and albiglutide for the treatment of type 2 diabetes. The primary endpoint
was reduction in HbA1c. To allow for potential heterogeneity, networks were stratified by background therapy: add-on to metformin (MET) and add-on to metformin in
combination with sulfonylurea and/or thiazolidinediones (MET±SU±TZD). Networks
were further stratified by time of evaluation (16-36 weeks and 37-56 weeks). The
‘node-splitting’ approach and models including treatment-by-design interaction
effects (where ‘design’ refers to the study comparator set), were used to examine
inconsistency. Results: For the 37-56 week add-on to MET network there were no
trials linking to dulaglutide 1.5mg; therefore, a NMA could not be conducted. For the
37-56 week combination network there were no comparisons for which there were
both direct and indirect evidence. For the 16-36 week add-on to MET network, there
were no comparisons with statistically significant inconsistency in HbA1c reduction
in the node splitting model and no significant design by treatment interactions. For
the 16-36 week add-on to Met±SU±TZD network there was statistically significant
variation between the direct and indirect estimates for the comparison between
glargine and placebo and the comparison between glargine with liraglutide 1.80mg.
Further sensitivity analyses were conducted removing the LEAD 5 trial (comparing
placebo, glargine and liraglutide 1.80mg) from the network. Conclusions: The
node-splitting and treatment-by-design interaction models showed no evidence
of inconsistency in the 16-36 week monotherapy network. Following removal of
the LEAD 5 trial, the 16-36 week combination network also showed no evidence of
inconsistency. The analyses were useful in investigating potential inconsistency
across the network.
PDB20
Management of Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus Among Patients Attending
a Primary Health Care Setting in Qatar: A Study on Medication Use
Pattern and Clinical Outcomes
Mohamed Ibrahim M I 1, Awaisu A 1, Berzou S 1, Abu Samaha R 1, Elshami S 1, Elhafiz M 2,
Babiker I 2
1Qatar University, Doha, Qatar, 2Primary Health Care, Doha, Qatar
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate the pattern and clinical outcomes of insulin therapies
compared to oral antidiabetic therapies in the management of T2DM. Methods: A
retrospective cohort study of patients with T2DM attending the Mesaimeer Primary
HealthCare Center in Doha, Qatar. Inclusion criteria included were adult patients
with at least with T2DM for 12 months period. Exclusion criteria included were age
below 18 yrs, T2DM history less than 1 year, pregnant women and patients with
kidney/hepatic disease. Patients’ medical records were reviewed for a period of
one year. Data collected included socio-demographic profiles, clinical and laboratory data, medication regimens, and regimen cost per year. Data were analyzed
descriptively and using Chi-Square test with priori alpha level of 0.05. Results: A
total of 295 patients with T2DM attending the primary health center were included
in the study. Majority of the patients were male (n= 210, 71.2%), age between 25-64
years old (n= 241, 82.3%) and obese (n= 163, 55.3%). Metformin was the most frequently used oral anti-diabetic medication (89.8%), followed by gliclazide (30.6%)
and sitagliptin (26.2%). 32.3% of the patients were on insulin at the end of the 12
month follow-up period. The most common treatment regimen at both time points
was oral dual therapy (28.3%), followed by oral monotherapy (21.3%) and triple oral
therapy (20.2%). The mean HbA1c was 8.0+1.6% at both the beginning and endpoint of the 12 month follow-up period, indicating uncontrolled DM. Those patients
receiving insulin-containing therapy had a significantly higher proportion of uncontrolled DM than those who did not receive insulin (98% vs. 81%; p< 0.001) at the
endpoint of 12-month follow-up period. Conclusions: The findings of this study
showed that T2DM patients attending primary health care clinics in Qatar were not
achieving glycemic control.
PDB21
Preventing the Progression to Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus in Adults
at High Risk: A Systematic Review And Network Meta-Analysis of
Lifestyle, Pharmacological and Surgical Interventions
Stevens J W 1, Harvey R C 1, Johnson M 1, Khunti K 2
of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK, 2University of Leicester, Leicester, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: Individuals with impaired fasting glucose (IFG) or impaired glucose
tolerance (IGT) have an increased risk of progression to Type 2 diabetes mellitus.
The objective of this study was to quantify the effectiveness of lifestyle, pharmacological and surgical interventions in reducing the progression to Type 2 diabetes
mellitus in people with IFG or IGT. Methods: A systematic review was carried out
and a Bayesian network meta-analysis of log-hazard ratios was performed. The
primary outcome of the network meta-analysis was the time to progression to Type
2 diabetes mellitus. Results are presented as hazard ratios and the probabilities of
treatment rankings. Results: 30 studies were included in the network meta-analysis. There was a reduced hazard of progression to Type 2 diabetes mellitus associated with all interventions versus standard care. The most effective interventions
compared to standard care were diet plus pioglitazone (HR 0.17, 95% CrI [0.09, 0.
33] ), glipizide (HR 0.16, 95% CrI [0.02, 1.62] ), diet plus exercise plus metformin
plus rosiglitazone (HR 0.20, 95% CrI [0.11, 0.39] ), diet plus exercise plus orlistat (HR
0.31, 95% CrI [0.16, 0.61] ) and diet plus exercise plus pedometer (HR 0.35 95% CrI
[0.11, 1.14] ). The least effective intervention was ramipril (HR 0.91, 95% CrI [0.72,
1.14] ). Conclusions: Pharmacological and lifestyle interventions are beneficial
in reducing the risk of progression to Type 2 diabetes mellitus. Lifestyle interventions require significant behaviour changes and this may be achieved through
incentives such as the use of pedometers. Lifestyle interventions alone, whilst
beneficial, are unlikely to be as effective as pharmacological interventions alone
or in combination with lifestyle interventions. Adverse events and costs of
pharmacological interventions should be taken into account when considering potential risks and benefits, and their cost-effectiveness relative to lifestyle
interventions.
PDB22
New Meta-Analysis of Patient-Level Data on Efficacy And
Hypoglycaemia with Insulin Glargine or Nph Insulin in Type 2
Diabetes Mellitus (T2DM) According to Concomitant Oral Therapy
Owens D R 1, Trayor L 2, Landgraf W 3, Mullins P 4
of Life Sciences, Swansea University, Swansea, UK, 2Sanofi US, Inc., Bridgewater, NJ,
USA, 3Sanofi, Frankfurt, Germany, 4Department of Statistics, University of Auckland, Auckland,
New Zealand
.
.
.
.
.
1Institute
Objectives: Previous meta-analyses show inconsistent results regarding benefits
of insulin glargine (GLA) over NPH insulin (NPH) in terms of nocturnal hypoglycaemia. We analysed standardized efficacy and safety outcomes in uncontrolled
insulin-naïve subjects with T2DM treated with GLA or NPH according to the oral
antidiabetic drug (OAD) to which insulin was added (sulfonylurea [SU] ± metformin
[MET] ). Methods: Patient-level data from 4 Treat-To-Target (TTT) RCTs (FPG < 100
mg/dL) of ≥ 24 weeks duration were pooled. HbA1c, weight, dose, and hypoglycaemia
(overall and nocturnal, plasma glucose < 56 mg/dL) were assessed. Results: 2,091
subjects were analysed; 49% male, mean age 57.8 years. SU-treated subjects had
longer T2DM duration, higher baseline HbA1c, and were less obese than MET+SUtreated subjects. Endpoint HbA1c values were similar for GLA and NPH overall (7.4
vs 7.5%). Subjects adding GLA or NPH to MET+SU had numerically lower weightadjusted endpoint insulin doses (GLA 0.40 vs 0.44 U/kg; NPH 0.36 vs 0.42 U/kg),
with less weight gain (GLA: +1.9 vs +3.7 kg; NPH: +1.8 vs +3.0 kg) versus subjects
adding insulin to SU. Hypoglycaemia incidence (overall: odds ratio [OR] 0.79 [95% CI
0.66−0.95]; P= 0.011, nocturnal: OR 0.64 [0.51−0.81]; P< 0.001) and event rates (overall: rate ratio [RR] 0.78 [0.65−0.93]; P= 0.006, nocturnal: RR 0.54 [0.42−0.69]; P< 0.001)
were significantly lower in GLA-treated subjects versus NPH, irrespective of concomitant OAD. In general, higher hypoglycaemia incidences/rates were observed
in the MET+SU groups versus the SU only groups. MET+SU-treated subjects were
more likely to achieve HbA1c < 7.0% without overall hypoglycemia versus SU-treated
subjects (GLA: 24.6 vs 16.1%; NPH: 24.2 vs 13.0%). Conclusions: In insulin-naive
T2DM patients from 4 TTT RCTs, GLA significantly reduced overall and nocturnal
hypoglycemia risk versus NPH, irrespective of concomitant OAD. Subjects adding
GLA or NPH to MET+SU had better efficacy outcomes than those adding to SU only,
with slightly increased hypoglycaemia risk.
PDB23
Efficacy and Safety of Dipeptidyl Peptidase-4 Inhibitors: Systematic
Review and Meta-Analysis
Pérez A 1, Franch J 2, Fuster E 3, Paz S 4, Prades M 4, Granell M 3
1Hospital de la Santa Creu I Sant Pau, Barcelona, Spain, 2EAP Raval Sud- Institut Català de
la Salut - USR Barcelona ciutat - IDIAP Jordi Gol, Barcelona, Spain, 3Novartis Farmaceutica,
Barcelona, Spain, 4Outcomes’10, Castellon, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To determine the efficacy and safety of dipeptidyl peptidase-4 (DPP4) inhibitors in type 2 diabetes patients according to published data. Methods:
A systematic review of randomized clinical trials (RCT) in MEDLINE, Cochrane,
ISI WOK, SCOPUS and clinicaltrials. gov databases was performed. Eligible studies were RCT with a treatment duration of at least 24 weeks evaluating efficacy
(HbA1c, fasting plasma glucose-FPG- and weight variation from baseline) and/or
safety (hypoglycemia rate) of DPP4 inhibitors (linagliptin, saxagliptin, sitagliptin,
vildagliptin) compared with placebo or non-insulin monotherapy or combination,
published in English or Spanish until June 2013. A meta-analysis was conducted
using a random effects model. Standardized mean difference (SMD) for efficacy
variables and relative risk (RR) for safety variable with 95% confidence intervals
(CI) were calculated. Results: Of the 4,582 publications retrieved, 3,807 were
deleted by duplicate review, 581 by title/abstract review and 139 by criteria compliance. Finally, 55 RCT were selected. DPP-4 inhibitor monotherapy was associated to greater reductions in HbA1c and FPG compared with placebo [SMD= -0.60,
95% CI= -0.75; -0.46 and SMD= -0.51, 95% CI= -0.62; -0.39, respectively] while compared with metformin the reductions were lower [SMD= 0.28, 95% CI= 0.20; 0.26
and SMD= 0.36, 95% CI= 0.27; 0.44, respectively]. DPP-4 inhibitors added to metformin lowered HbA1c and FPG significantly more than metformin monotherapy
[SMD= -0.52, 95% CI= -0.62; -0.41 and SMD= -0.41, 95% CI= -0.51; -0.30, respectively],
and achieved a greater decrease in weight and hypoglycemia risk versus sulfonylurea plus metformin [SMD= -0.55, 95% CI= -0.64; -0.45 y RR= 0.16, 95% CI= 0.11;
0.21, respectively]. Moreover, the addition of DPP-4 inhibitors to sulfonylurea
showed a greater reduction in HbA1c compared with sulfonylurea monotherapy [SMD= -0.54, 95% CI= -0.70; -0.37]. Conclusions: DPP-4 inhibitors added to
metformin achieved a better glycemic control compared with metformin mono-
A336
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
therapy, with a lower risk of hypoglycemia and without affecting weight versus
sulfonilurea and metformin combination.
PDB24
Recombinant Growth Hormone Therapy in Children with GH
Deficiency: First Interventional Study in Armenia
Markosyan R , Perikhanyan A
Yerevan State Medical University, Yerevan, Armenia
.
.
Objectives: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness and safety
of treatment with recombinant growth hormone (RGH) in children with GH deficiency. Methods: This was an interventional study with 6 and 12 months followup. Treatment was received by 15 children. The patients were receiving the RGH in
0.033 mg/kg (0.1 Unit/kg) at the same time each day (9-10 pm) for period of 1 year.
The effectiveness of treatment was evaluated based on change in growing speed,
growth SDS and bone age maturation. Results: The mean age of children was
9.5±3.6 years. In the given sample 6 children had MHPD, other 9 children had IGHD.
There was a great improvement in absolute growth at 6 and 12 months period of
treatment (p-0.001; p-0.001). The same was found for growth SDS (p-0.001; p-0.001).
Effectiveness of RGH therapy on bone age maturation also showed great improvement (p-0.001; p-0.001). The level of IGF-1 was increased (p-0.001; p-0.001); at 12
months the level of IGF-1 reached to 248.72±70.7 ng/mL and remained consistently
high. The same improvement was in IGF-pb3 levels (p-0.001; p-0.001). The lipidemic
analysis showed that the blood cholesterol levels were from 3.21 to 12.39 mmol/L
(norm 5.68±1.55 mmol/L) and the level of LDL - 1.3 to 10.86 mmol/L (norm 3.83±1.44
mmol/L). During the treatment period we observed the significant improvement in
cholesterol levels (p-0.001; p-0.001). High density lipoprotein and triglyceride levels
did not change significantly (p. 0.05). Conclusions: It can be concluded that the
treatment with RGH in patient with GH deficiency is beneficial as it normalized the
levels of cholesterol and LDL. During the treatment there were no any changes in
indicators of kidney’s function, indicators of liver’s function as well as the indicators
of carbohydrate metabolism.
PDB25
Effectiveness, Safety and Patients’ Subjective Feelings of Insulin
Pen-Needle: A Systematic Review
Sun L , Sun J , Chen B , Sun S , Wang R , Ren X
Shenyang Pharmaceutical University, Shenyang, China
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To compare the differences of effectiveness, safety and patients’
subjective feelings for using different lengths of insulin pen-needle in diabetic
patients. Methods: A retrospective analysis of relevant publications that were
identified via electronic searches of databases using multiple search terms related
to insulin pen-needle. Results: Totally, 21 literatures were included. Firstly,
for the effectiveness, 85.71% of the studies suggested that there was no difference between longer and shorter needle in controlling HbA1c, 14.29% thought
the shorter needle was better than the longer. No changes were observed with
respect to fructosamine, glycated albumin and body mass index. Secondly, about
the safety, all of the studies proved that the shorter needle was better in intramuscular injections, adverse device effects, subcutaneous lipodystrophy and barb
phenomenon. 33.33% reported less hypoglycemic events, bleeding, bruising and
needle bending with the shorter needle, the others showed no difference. All of
the studies considered the shorter needle was undifferentiated with the longer in
the needle break, hyperglycemia and lipohypertrophy. 6.25% have pointed out that
the shorter needle was better than the longer in leakage, while 81.25% showed no
difference in the length. Thirdly, in terms of subjective feelings, for convenience
and acceptance, all studies agreed that shorter needle was superior to the longer.
For fear and pain, half of studies suggested that shorter needle was superior to the
longer one; the other half thought that there was no difference. In all the studies,
69.23% suggested patients prefer the shorter, 23.08% suggested the patients not
prefer a particular needle length. Conclusions: Overall, the effectiveness of
insulin pens with longer and shorter needle are comparable in treating diabetes,
but the shorter needle is little better in parts of the safety indexes. As for patients’
subjective feeling, our findings show that patients are generally willing to accept
shorter needle.
PDB26
Economic Impact of Combining Metformin with Dipeptidyl Peptidase
Inhibitors In Diabetic Patients With Renal Failure
PDB27
Uses of Electronic Patient Information Systems and National
Registers – Implementation of the Clinical Practice Guideline and
Evaluation of Costs and Use of Resources in Patients with Incident
Type 2 Diabetes in Finland
Prami T 1, Sulamaa A 2, Sipilä R 3, Linna M 4, Hahl J 5, Miettinen T 5, Leppä E 6, Haukka J 1,
Tuomilehto J 7, Enlund H 8, Niskanen L 8, Korhonen P 1
1EPID Research, Espoo, Finland, 2Pharma Industry Finland, Helsinki, Finland, 3Finnish Medical
Society Duodecim, Helsinki, Finland, 4Aalto University, HEMA Institute, Espoo, Finland, 5AT
Medical Affairs Consulting, Espoo, Finland, 6Pharmaceutical Information Centre, Helsinki, Finland,
7University of Helsinki, Helsinki, Finland, 8Finnish Medicines Agency Fimea, Helsinki, Finland
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Effective management of diabetes is the cornerstone for prevention
of diabetic complications. However, how well the Finnish Current Care guideline
for diabetes is implemented in practice is unknown. Combining local and nationwide patient registers provide a valuable resource for evaluating risks, benefits
and costs. The purpose of this study was to identify how the Finnish electronic
patient information systems and national registers can be used to explore the treatment for patients with incident type 2 diabetes. Methods: Selected primary and
specialty care organizations representing different geographical areas and patient
information system providers were invited to participate in the study. Study permits were obtained from several local and nationwide register holders. The study
protocol was reviewed by the Ethical Review Board of Hospital District of Helsinki
and Uusimaa. Results: Register linkage is accomplished using unique personal
identification numbers. We collect nationwide data on prescriptions, hospital and
primary care, reimbursed dental care, and the causes of death. Cost data are based
on hospital benchmarking database, sickness allowances and rehabilitations. We
use local registers as a source of information on diagnoses, medical procedures,
prescriptions and contact types. High quality laboratory data are also included from
several local providers. Conclusions: Register linkages enable longitudinal follow-up of patients for research purposes in Finland. In our study a unique combined
register database of diabetic patient cohort is created that improves the evaluation
of prognosis and care of diabetic patients. This is a promising and versatile source
for research in pharmacoepidemiology.
PDB28
Epidemiology and Unmet Medical Need in Diabetes Mellitus Type 2 in
Germany –Results of a Literature Search
Greiner R A 1, Paulus G 1, Driedger J 1, Schröder C 1, Timtschenko V 1, Batscheider A 1,
Eheberg D 2, Vosgerau S 1
1IMS Health, Munich, Germany, 2IMS HEALTH, Munich, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Diabetes mellitus Typ2 (T2DM) is a metabolic disease characterized
by hyperglycemia with a high risk-potential of microvascular and macrovascular
complications. In addition to glycemic control important therapy targets are the
prevention of hypoglycemia and weight gain as well as blood pressure control due
to national guidelines (German Medical Association 2013). To describe the current
state of T2DM epidemiology and therapeutic needs in Germany which is mandatory
when submitting AMNOG dossiers. Methods: To describe epidemiology of diabetes
a targeted literature research was conducted in PubMed in 2014 using the search
terms (epidemiology OR incidence OR prevalence). To identify relevant comorbidity
information the following terms were used (metabolic syndrome OR glycemic control OR hypoglycemia OR obesity OR blood pressure) and combined with AND diabetes AND Germany. PubMed research was supplemented by additional searches in
guidelines in German/English. Results: The screening of the epidemiologic results
identified nine relevant publications: two specified a T2DM-prevalence of 15.3% and
14.7% (Wittchen et al 2007, Huppertz et al 2009) and two studies estimated a T2DM
incidence of 15.8 per 1000 patient years (KORA, MONICA). Treatment prevalence
increased from 5.9% in 1998 to 8.9% in 2007 related to the total population (Hauner
2013). Arterial hypertension was the most frequent comorbity (83%) of T2DM (Hagen
et al. 2010). In 2010, a disease management program in North Rhine showed that only
15% of participants with T2DM achieved a BMI < 25 (Hagen et al. 2010). Long-term
trials investigating the efficacy of antidiabetics on the prevention of macrovascular
complications are limited (Drug Commission of German Medical Association 2009;
Matthaei et al. 2009). Conclusions: While treatment prevalence is increasing and
glycemic control seems to be sufficiently achieved a substantial unmet medical need
is identified for antidiabetics with a significant effect on weight reduction and blood
pressure control in patients with T2DM in Germany.
PDB29
Progression of Physiological Parameters Over Time in Type 1
Diabetes Mellitus Patients in France
Objectives: To evaluate resource use and health costs due to the combination
of metformin and dipeptidyl peptidase-4 (DPP-4) inhibitors in patients with diabetes and renal failure (RF) in routine clinical practice. Methods: An observational, retrospective study was performed. Patients aged ≥ 30 years treated with
metformin who initiated a second oral antidiabetic treatment in 2008-2009 were
included. Two groups of patients were analysed: a) metformin + DPP-4 inhibitors
and b) other oral antidiabetics. The main measures were: compliance, persistence,
metabolic control (glycosylated haemoglobin < 7%) and complications (hypoglycemia, cardiovascular events) and total costs. Patients were followed up for two
years. Results: We included 395 patients, mean age 70.2 years, 56.5% male: 135
patients received metformin + DPP-4 inhibitors and 260 patients received metformin + other oral diabetics. Patients receiving DPP-4 inhibitors showed better
compliance (66.0% vs. 60.1%), persistence (57.6% vs. 50.0%) and metabolic control
(63.9% vs. 57.3%), respectively, compared with those receiving other oral diabetics
(p < 0.05), and also had a lower rate of hypoglycemia (20.0% vs. 47.7%) and lower
total costs (€ 2,486 vs. € 3,002), p = 0.001. Conclusions: Despite the limitations
of the study, patients with renal failure treated with DPP-4 inhibitors had better
metabolic control, lower rates of hypoglycaemia, and lower health costs for the
Spanish national health system.
Beaudet A , Ong R C
IMS Health, Basel, Switzerland
.
.
.
.
Sicras-Mainar A 1, Navarro-Artieda R 2
Serveis Assistencials, Badalona. Barcelona, Spain, 2Hospital Universitari Germans
Trias i Pujol, Badalona, Spain
1Badalona
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The objective of this study was to understand the progression over
time of physiological parameters, including HbA1c, body mass index (BMI), systolic blood pressure (SBP), total cholesterol, LDL-cholesterol, HDL-cholesterol and
triglycerides, in type 1 diabetes mellitus (T1DM) patients to inform disease modeling. Methods: This was a cross-sectional analysis of T1DM patients based on
the IMS LifeLink Diabetes Cohort in France, which prospectively collects clinical,
biological and treatment information from general practitioners. Patient age, gender, year of diagnosis, BMI, HbA1c, cardiovascular risk factors, renal function and
lab test results were collected at baseline and subsequent visits. Data were analyzed using R Studio. T1DM patients who visited their general physician between
May 2011 and May 2014 and have received at least one insulin prescription were
included in the analysis. Results: A cohort of 605 T1DM patients was included
in this analysis. Forty-three percent of patients were male. Average patient age at
first visit was 58 years of age. Mean HbA1c was 7.8%, mean SBP was 132 mmHg,
and mean BMI was 27.6 kg/m2. Linear regression showed that BMI increased by
0.092 kg/m2 (p< 0.001) for each additional year of age. SBP was projected to increase
by 0.248 mmHg (p< 0.001) per additional year of age, LDL-cholesterol decreased by
A337
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
0.624 mg/dL for each additional (p= 0.017) year of age and triglycerides increased by
1.417 mg/dL for each additional (p= 0.041) year of age. Changes in HbA1c, total cholesterol and HDL-cholesterol over time were not significantly correlated with patient
age or time since diagnosis. Therefore, health economic modelers may assume that
these parameters remain stable over time. Sensitivity analyses were performed to
address the potential mislabeling of T2DM as T1DM patients. Conclusions: These
results provide relevant inputs for the progression of physiological parameters to
model the economic and clinical impacts of T1DM therapies over time.
PDB30
Trend in Prevalence and Distribution of Diabetes Mellitus Type I
and Type II in the Netherlands
Overbeek J A 1, Penning F J A 1, van Dongen E 2, Herings R M C 1
Institute for Drug Outcomes Research, Utrecht, The Netherlands, 2Novo Nordisk B.V.,
Alphen a/d Rijn, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
medications and obstetric medical history. Set-up was non-random, convenience
sampling with 40 women’s data with mean age 33.7± 3.6, between August 2013 –
February 2014. Friedmann ANOVA and t-test was applied for analysis with software
Statistics for Windows. Results: Progresses the gestation period significant reduction of TSH values was observed in hypothyroid patients (p= 0,0075). Comparing
successive TSH values of the individual patients showed the same significant difference. Significant negative correlation was founded between TSH value and thyroxin dose in group of hypothyroid patients (r= -0,35; p< 0,05). Premature birth and
other obstetric complications occured more frequently in the thyreotoxical group,
especially among older women giving birth. Conclusions: In case of hypothyroid
pregnant with increasing dose of thyroxin the TSH levels are well balanced, and
obstetric complications did not occur, while in hyperthyroid patients can be reported
obstetric complications in addition to proper care.
1PHARMO
Objectives: To quantify the trend in prevalence and distribution of diabetes mellitus (DM) type I (T1DM) and type II (T2DM) in the Netherlands. Methods: Using
the General Practitioner Database and the Out-patient Pharmacy Database of the
PHARMO Database Network, the trend in prevalence of DM and distribution of
T1DM and T2DM from 2005 to 2012 was assessed. Per year, patients with ≥ 2 antidiabetic drug dispensings within 6 months were selected as DM patient. Patient
numbers were extrapolated to the Netherlands to determine prevalence of DM.
For all patients, diabetes treatment at September 30 of that year was assessed. For
patients with a GP recorded diagnosis for T1DM or T2DM, distribution of T1DM/T2DM
was stratified by treatment. This distribution of DM type by treatment was applied
to the treatment of patients with no GP recorded DM type to assess the distribution
of T1DM/T2DM. Results: The prevalence of DM in the Netherlands increased from
38 per 1000 males and 40 per 1000 females in 2005 to 54 per 1000 males and 52 per
1000 females in 2012. The distribution of T1DM versus T2DM among patients with
DM changed from 15% versus 85% in 2005 to 8% versus 92% in 2012. Among patients
with T1DM mean (±SD) age decreased from 48 (±22) years in 2005 to 44 (±22) years
in 2012. Among patients with T2DM mean age increased from 63 (±12) years in 2005
to 67 (±12) years in 2012. Conclusions: This study describes the epidemiology of
DM in the Netherlands over 2005-2012. Prevalence of DM increased and relatively
more patients were diagnosed with T2DM. These changes can be explained by the
ageing Dutch population, better survival, more obesity and early detection of T2DM.
Furthermore, introduction of the T2DM care program in 2005 probably has led to a
better registration of T2DM patients.
PDB31
Factors Associated with Hospitalization of Type 2 Diabetic Patients
with Hypoglycemic Episodes Assisted at Emergency Departments
Conceição J 1, Laires P 1, Araújo F 2, Dores J 3, Vicente V 4, Silva C 4, Carr R 5, Brodovicz K 6,
Radican L 7, Nogueira A M 1
Sharp & Dohme, Oeiras, Portugal, 2Hospital Beatriz Ângelo, Loures, Portugal, 3Hospital
de Santo António, Porto, Portugal, 4Eurotrials, Lisbon, Portugal, 5Merck Sharp & Dohme, Ballerup,
Denmark, 6Merck & Co., North Wales, PA, USA, 7Merck & Co., Inc., Whitehouse Station, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Diabetes/Endocrine Disorders – Cost Studies
PDB33
Budget Impact Analysis of Adding Dapaglifozin To The Therapy of
Diabetes Mellitus Type 2 In Bulgaria
Manova M 1, Petkova E 1, Yordanova S 1, Petkova V 1, Petrova G 2
1Medical University of Sofia, Faculty of Pharmacy, Sofia, Bulgaria, 2Medical University Sofia,
Faculty of Pharmacy, Sofia, Bulgaria
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Dapaglifozin is a highly potent, selective and reversible inhibitor of
sodium-glucose co-transporter 2 (SGLT2) and is approved for the treatment of T2DM
in adults. Diabetes type 2 is one of the most prevalent chronic diseases that can
lead to serious complications and disability. The largest costs are those associated
with hospitalizations due to the complications, the prevention of which requires a
good glycemic control. The objective of the study is to estimate the budget impact
of adding dapaglifozin to the therapy of type 2 diabetes in Bulgaria. Methods: The
budget impact model was used from the payer perspective for population 7 284 552
people, and out of them 450000 are type 2 diabetics. The retail pharmacy prices were
used from the Positive Drug List. Official IMS data for antidiabetic medicines were
incorporated in the model. Net budget impact is presented as costs per-member
per-month (PMPM) and costs per-patient per-year (PPPY). Results: An increase in
the estimated net budget impact from 70 592 € first year to 1 290 716 € for the fifth
year was observed after adding dapaglifozin to T2DM therapy, with a cumulative
net budget impact of 3 258 047 € . PMPM and PPPY costs show minimal growth with
respective cumulative values of 0.06 € and of 65.63 € . The cost for dapaglifozin
therapy is comparable to that of DPP-4 inhibitors and is lower than the cost of
treatment with a GLP- 1. Conclusions: The results show that adding dapaglifozin
to standard therapy will lead to minimal increase in the diabetes type 2 budget in
Bulgaria. This increase is considered acceptable in terms of better glycemic control
with safe and effective therapy for diabetes type 2.
1Merck
Objectives: HIPOS-ER is an observational, cross-sectional, multicenter study to
describe the patient population of Type 2 diabetics treated with an anti-hyperglycemic agent (AHA) and admitted to the emergency room (ER) with a hypoglycemic
event. In this analysis we aim to identify factors associated with hospitalization
following admission in the ER. Methods: The study enrolled patients from
7 centers in mainland Portugal for a period of 12 months (Jan 2013 – Jan 2014).
Sociodemographic and clinical data were collected at the ER and patients who
required hospital admission were followed up. Multiple logistic regression was
used to identify factors associated with hospitalization. Results: A total of 238
patients were enrolled of whom 105 (44%) were hospitalized. These patients were
older than non-hospitalized (mean: 78 years vs. 75 years; p= 0.020). About half of
the hospitalized patients were on secretagogue based regimen. Glasgow coma scale
score was not statistically different between hospitalized and non-hospitalized
patients (p= 0.270), however hospital admissions showed lower values of the lowest
recorded plasma/capillary glycemia (mean: 35 mg/dL vs. 41 mg/dL; p= 0.004) and a
higher prevalence of hypoglycemia complications (26% vs. 9%; p< 0.001). Obesity
and higher plasma capillary glycaemia level are associated with a lower risk of
hospitalization (OR= 0.29 and OR= 0.96, respectively; p< 0.010) while treatment with
secretagogue based regimen, presence of hypoglycemia complications and other
atherosclerotic disease are associated with a higher risk (OR= 5.71, OR= 3.89 and
OR= 2.87, respectively; p< 0.010). Conclusions: Almost half of the patients with
diabetes suffering a hypoglycemic event who required medical assistance at the ER
were hospitalized. Presence of some factors may increase the risk of these expensive
cases which are also surrogates for the potential severity of the hypoglycemic episodes. Identification of these predictors may help assist physicians at the emergency
room to proactively act upon patients at higher risk of hospitalization and generate
substantial health and economic gains to the hospitals.
PDB32
The Impact of Treatment of Thyreoid Disease in Pregnant Women to
the Outcome of Giving Birth
Ferenczy M 1, Póhr K 1, Lőcsei Z 2, Oláh A 3, Boncz I 4, Karácsony I 1, Salamonné Toldy E 2
of Pécs, Szombathely, Hungary, 2Markusovszky University Teaching Hospital,
Szombathely, Hungary, 3University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary, 4Faculty of Health Sciences, University
of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary
.
.
.
.
.
.
PDB34
Assessment of The Economic Value Of Dpp-4 Inhibitor Alogliptin
Compared With Sitagliptin, Saxagliptin, And Linagliptin
Pedrazzoli M 1, Pasquini F 1, Minda K 2
1LSC Lifesciences Consultants, Milan, Italy, 2Takeda Pharmaceuticals, Glattpark-Opfikon (Zurich),
Switzerland
.
.
.
Objectives: Objective of this study is to provide additional evidence for decision
making to payers assessing health care resource utilization, economic impact, and
cost-effectiveness of DPP-4 inhibitor alogliptin compared with sitagliptin, saxagliptin and linagliptin, for the treatment of type-2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM). Methods:
29 comparable, randomized clinical trials were selected out of a panel of 58 studies.
6 different clinical endpoints (efficacy and safety) were compared across 5 different
combinations: DPP-4 Monotherapy, +metformin (MET), +sulfonylurea (SU), +thiazolidinedione (TZD), +insulin (INS). For each endpoint and combination, alogliptin clinical endpoints were compared with respective average endpoints of other
DPP-4s. Differentials were calculated after adjustment for baseline characteristics.
Each endpoint was associated with the impact on patient outcomes and related
health care costs (T2DM-related complications, treatment escalation, costs associated with adverse events: hypoglycemia, cardiovascular mortality, hospitalization
due to heart failure, lipids profile) obtained from published data. Economic value
saving of alogliptin was calculated and compared to the other DPP-4s. Results:
The proportion of patients at target (HbA1c< 7%) as well as the reduced need for
treatment escalation with alogliptin could generate annual savings for a health care
system of € 69.62 and € 22.97 per patient-year, respectively. Improved lipids profile
and proven CV safety of alogliptin can generate savings of € 40.86 and € 21.47 per
patient-year, respectively. Impact of lower hypoglycemia and increased adherence
with fixed dose combinations with TZD may generate additional savings (€ 1.53
and € 1.60/ patient-year, respectively). Conclusions: This study suggests that
alogliptin could generate significant savings for a Healthcare System, even at price
parity with other DPP-4s, thanks to its efficacy and safety profile, particularly in the
widely used DPP-4+MET combination. Total savings of up to € 158 per patient-year
compare favorably with an overall cost of treatment with a DPP-4i ranging from
€ 350 to € 481 per patient-year.
.
1University
PDB35
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Autocoded and Manually Coded
Blood Glucose Meters In Diabetes Treatment
Objectives: The most common endocrine clinical symptom is thyroid disease
which has impact to pregnant women and fetus. Leading international references about its treatments are well known, there is no relevant experiences in the
Hungarian context. Aim of this study is to inspect the thyroid disease and impact
of its treatment to outcome of pregnancy. Methods: Survey was carried out at
Markusovszky Hospital in Vas County, Hungary. Retrospective study made by data
analysis of pregnant patient with thyroid disease, including hormone parameters,
Yagudina R , Kulikov A , Babiy V
I. M. Sechenov First Moscow State Medical University, Moscow, Russia
.
.
.
Objectives: To conduct a cost-effectiveness assessment of glucose meters (manually
coded and autocoded) in diabetes treatment in the Russian Federation. Methods:
Clinical effectiveness assessment was based on the results of modeling of the treatment of patients with diabetes that use manually coded and autocoded blood glucose
meters. Cost analysis included assessment of direct and indirect costs that can be
A338
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
associated with manually coded meters (model 1 and model 2) and autocoded meters
(model 3). Cost data was based on median prices for medicines, devices, medical
services in National health care system in the Russian Federation. Results: Annual
direct costs per patient in the group of manually coded glucose meters were 1533 euro
(model 1) and 1574 euro (model 2), and in the group of autocoded meters were 1557
euro (model 3). Annual total costs per patient in the group of manually coded glucose
meters were 2992 euro (model 1) and 2921 euro (model 2), and in the group of autocoded meters were 3034 euro (model 3). Cost-effectiveness ratio for autocoded meters
was 1875 euro (model 3) and for manually coded meters was 1954 euro (model 1) and
1982 euro (model 2) per 1 LYG, respectively (discounted at 3%). Budget impact analysis
showed that use of autocoded meters (model 3) instead of manually coded (model
1 and model 2) leads to the annually cost savings of 33 euro and 53 euro per patient,
respectively (discounted at 3%). Conclusions: Obtained results approve the use of
autocoded blood glucose meters instead of manually coded blood glucose meters to
administrate blood glucose level as part of intensive glucose-lowering therapy from
a pharmacoeconomic point of view.
PDB36
Health Economic Impact of Bariatric Surgery Revisted: Structured
Review of Literature and Health Technology Assessments
Chawla A S 1, Tao C 2, Faulkner E C 3, Hsiao C W 4, Patkar A D 5, Romney M 6
1Quintiles Consulting, Durham, NC, USA, 2Quintiles Consulting, Cambridge, MA, USA, 3Institute
for Pharmacogenomics and Individualized Therapy, Eshelman School of Pharmacy, University of
North Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC, USA, 4Johnson and Johnson Medical Companies, Markham, ON,
Canada, 5Ethicon, Inc, Somerville, NJ, USA, 6Jefferson School of Population Health, Philadelphia,
PA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The costs of obesity are staggering, accounting for 2-6% of global
health care costs. The health economic benefits of bariatric surgery while notable,
are multi-faceted, resulting in heterogeneous reporting in the literature. To that
end, this study seeks to 1) highlight available evidence of the health economic
impact of bariatric surgery, and to 2) identify key gaps in current evidence that
may influence uptake by health care systems. Methods: Evidence of the health
economic impact was collated from 107 scientific articles, of which 19 were systematic reviews, published between 2010-March 2014 and archived in MEDLINE and
PubMed. Additionally, HTAWatch identified 10 HTAs, largely from North America
and the EU that evaluated economic benefits. Results: In all countries where
evaluated, bariatric surgery was cost-effective compared to non-surgical therapy.
The surgery was likely more cost-effective with higher patient BMI and with comorbidities, especially for BMI> 40kg/m2, although estimates varied. Furthermore,
resolution of underlying comorbidities resulted in reduced utilization of health
care services, pharmaceutical utilization, and improved work productivity, among
others, resulting in cost saving of 60-70% relative to standard care over a 3-year
period. Importantly, time to break even was typically in the 4-7 years range, and
was shorter for patients with Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus (T2DM) and with BMI> 40kg/
m2, typically in the 1.25-5 year range. Three key evidence gaps were identified: few
studies computed long-term cost-effectiveness; no head-to-head trials have directly
compared different surgical procedures; and heterogeneity across populations and
health system impede meta-analyses of patient outcomes such as QoL and longterm health benefits. Conclusions: Although heterogeneous, reports of health
economic benefits of bariatric surgery indicate an overall positive trend, largely
via reduction of health resource utilization. To firmly establish its impact, future
studies need to conduct head-to-head comparisons, determine optimal patient
populations, and employ standard clinical endpoints to demonstrate real world,
long-term benefits.
PDB37
Association of Changes In Body Weight With Health Care Costs
Among Patients With Newly-Diagnosed Type-2 Diabetes In Sweden
Sabale U 1, Bodegård J 1, Sundström J 2, Svennblad B 3, Östgren C J 4, Nilsson P 5,
Johansson G 3, Henriksson M 1
1AstraZeneca Nordic-Baltic, Södertälje, Sweden, 2Uppsala University, Uppsala, Australia,
3Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden, 4Linköping University, Linköping, Sweden, 5Lund
University, Malmö, Sweden
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Type 2-diabetes and excess weight incur large costs to health care
systems, but the association between weight progression in diabetes and health
care costs is unknown. We investigated those relations using real world data
in a sample of newly diagnosed diabetes patients in Sweden by using repeated
body mass index (BMI) measurement and health care resource utilization
data Methods: Patients with a BMI (kg/m2) measure at diagnosis and subsequent
BMI measures at 12,24,36,48, and 60 months were identified from a previously
conducted register study. Individuals were classified into three groups based on
their BMI change over 5 years: increase (> 1 BMI unit increase), decrease (> 1 BMI
unit decrease), and stable (≤ 1 BMI unit change). Each group was stratified by BMI
at diagnosis (BMI 18-25; 25-30; ≥ 30). Health care costs for each group were estimated by applying Swedish unit costs to the health care resource data extracted
from electronic patient journals and a national patient register. Results: The
study included 903 T2D patients (women, 43%; mean age, 62; mean HbA1c, 6.78%;
mean BMI, 30.9). The BMI increased, decreased, or remained stable in 178 (20%),
387 (43%), and 338 (37%) patients, respectively. Among patients with baseline BMI
18-25 (n= 104), the five year cumulative health care costs were € 13,695, € 9,059,
€ 8,936, in the increase, decrease, and stable group, respectively. Corresponding
figures were € 11,470, € 7,950, € 8,683 for patients with baseline BMI 25-30 (n= 321),
€ 14,387, € 9,465, and € 9,302 for patients with BMI ≥ 30 (n= 478). Conclusions: In
newly diagnosed diabetes, an increase in BMI lead to increased health care costs,
irrespective of baseline BMI. Linking registry data on repeated BMI measurements
and health care utilization is a valuable approach to investigate the association
between weight changes and costs. Costs of interventions that maintain weight
in patients with diabetes should be considered in the context of costs associated
with weight gain.
PDB38
Effect of Smoking Status on Health Care Costs In Patients With
Type 2 Diabetes: A Retrospective Nested Case-Control Economic
Study In Routine Clinical Practice
Sicras Mainar A 1, Rejas Gutiérrez J 2, Navarro Artieda R 3, Ibánez Nolla J 4,
De Lossada Juste A 5
1Badalona Serveis Assistencials SA, Badalona (Barcelona), Spain, 2Pfizer S.L.U., Alcobendas/
Madrid, Spain, 3Hospital Germans Trias i Pujol, Badalona (Barcelona), Spain, 4Badalona Serveis
Assistencials, Badalona, Spain, 5Pfizer, S.L.U, Alcobendas/Madrid, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Smoking in diabetics is associated with a worse prognosis and vascular
complications. The available evidence on health care resources utilization and associated costs in diabetics who smoke is limited or nonexistent. Thus, the objective was
to compare health care resource utilization and costs according to smoking status in
patients with type 2 diabetes in clinical practice. Methods: A retrospective cohort
nested case-control study was designed. Cases were current smokers, while two types
of controls (former smokers and never smokers) were matched, two controls per
case, for age, sex, duration of diabetes, and burden of comorbidity using data from
electronic medical records. Non-institutionalized diabetics, both genders, age > 18
years, seen consecutively over a 5-year period before the index date were enrolled.
Perspective of both the National Health System and the Society were chosen and costs
of health care resource utilization and loss of productivity due to sick leaves were
compared among groups using a linear general model with covariates. Results: A
total of 2,490 records were analyzed: 498 from cases, 996 from former smokers, and
996 from never smokers. Mean age was 63.4 years (64.9% male). Smokers had higher
HbA1c (7.4% vs. 7.2% and 7.2%, respectively, p = 0.013) and a lower degree of metabolic
control (49.2 % vs. 54.7% and 55.8%, p = 0.036). Smokers had higher average annual
costs (€3,583) than former smokers (€2,885) and never smokers (€2,183), p<0.001. Mean
annual health care cost saving per patient was associated with elapsed time of quitting smoking from €950 in subjects quitting smoking 2-year to € 1173 5-year or more,
p<0.05. Conclusions: Diabetic smoker patients had lower metabolic control, higher
health resource utilization, and more sick leave, resulting in higher health care costs
and lost productivity compared with both former and never diabetic smokers. Health
care cost-savings was associated with elapsed time from quitting smoking.
PDB39
Evaluation of Potential Waste Of Growth Hormone Across
Available Growth Hormone Pen Devices And An Electronic Growth
Hormone Delivery Device
Locklear J 1, Edwards N 2, Phillips A L 1
Serono, Inc., Rockland, MA, USA, 2Health Services Consulting Corporation, Boxborough,
MA, USA
.
.
.
.
1EMD
Objectives: The aim of this analysis was to estimate the potential GH waste per
patient with pen devices and the easypod® device, and to quantify the potential
economic impact of expected GH waste from patient and health care organization
perspectives. Methods: A Waste Calculator Model was developed to examine GH
waste. All somatropin products available in pen or electronic devices were included.
The user may define distribution across cartridges sizes. The mechanical/priming
loss applied to each product was based upon each product’s prescribing information
and/or instructions for use. The base case model utilizes a US patient daily dose of 1.4
mg. The model assumes that the easypod® dose adjustment feature is activated by
the clinician (±25%). Model assumes that 42.6% of caregivers discard the remaining
amount left in the cartridge (eg waste) if less than a full dose. Annual amount of GH
waste (mg, cartridges, dollars) per patient and per population (based on US national
market shares) for each pen/device is reported. Results: The expected annual
amount of waste per patient was lowest for easypod®. The expected annual amount
of waste per patient was highest for Omnitrope®. The expected annual amount of
waste ranged from 0 to 38.9mg per patient per year, which is equal to 0 to 8 cartridges
per patient per year and/or 0 to $2,935 per patient per year. For a patient population
of 100 GH-treated patients, the annual amount of waste is estimated at 2,009 mg,
which can be translated into approximately 342 cartridges or about $162,000 per year.
The results in GH waste fluctuated depending upon daily dose, cartridge size, and
dose spread assumptions. Conclusions: The expected annual amount of GH waste
evaluated in this Waste Calculator was lowest with easypod®. Cost of GH waste can
be an important consideration when evaluating GH delivery devices.
PDB40
Benefit Of Positive Airway Pressure (Pap) Therapy In Sleep Apnoea
(Sa) Patients With Type Ii Diabetes Mellitus (T2dm) In Germany:
A Retrospective Comparative Cohort Analysis Based On A
Statutory Health Insurance Database
Doess A 1, Zucca F 2, Woehrle H 3, Brueggenjuergen B 4
1ResMed Germany Inc., Martinsried, Germany, 2HGC GesundheitsConsult, Duesseldorf, Germany,
3ResMed Science Center, Martinsried, Germany, 4Institut für Sozialmedizin, Epidemiologie und
Gesundheitsökonomie, Charité - Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Berlin, Germany
.
.
.
.
Objectives: It is estimated that the prevalence of moderate-to-severe SA (apnoeahypopnoea index > 15/h) is 10%. Patients with T2DM have a particularly high incidence of SA. T2DM and SA influence the development and progression of each
other. This study investigated the effects of PAP therapy in SA patients with T2DM
on all-cause mortality and cost of illness (COI) in Germany from a statutory health
insurance (SHI) perspective. Methods: A total of > 4 million individuals covered by
the SHI database were analysed (≈5% of the German SHI population). PAP therapy
was initiated in 4,068 patients with SA (PAP group). Propensity score matching
was used to define a control group (CG) of 4,068 SA patients matched for age, sex,
risk factors/aetiology, region and medication who received usual care (no PAP). Of
these, 1,280 patients in the PAP group and 1,186 patients in the CG had comorbid
T2DM. This subgroup of patients was followed for 3 years after initiation of PAP
therapy. Results: Total COI was higher in the PAP group versus CG in year 1 (€8,105
vs € 7,037, p< 0.0001). After 2 years’ follow-up, COI in the PAP group decreased but
remained higher versus CG (€ 6,842 vs € 6,625, p< 0.001). After 3 years, PAP group COI
A339
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
was significantly reduced versus CG (€ 6,798 vs € 6,954, p< 0.001). PAP recipients had
a significantly lower 3-year mortality rate versus CG (7.2% vs 10.9%, p< 0.008; relative risk reduction 33.8%). Conclusions: SA patients with T2DM treated with PAP
showed significantly reduced mortality and morbidity. Total COI was higher in PAP
recipients versus CG in the first two years of follow-up, but during year 3 COI was
significantly lower in the PAP group versus CG. In addition to the known advantages
of PAP therapy in SA patients with T2DM (e. g. improved glycaemic control), PAP
therapy may be beneficial from an economic perspective.
PDB41
ARE TOTAL HEALTH CARE EXPENDITURES IMPACTED BY A NEW DIABETES
DIAGNOSTIC FACTOR: HBA1C?
Bhounsule P 1, Peterson A M 2
of the Sciences in Philadelphia, Philadelphia, PA, USA, 2University of the Sciences,
Philadelphia, PA, USA
.
.
.
22700 diabetic patients in Madrid was used to estimate transition probabilities in
the model. Time horizon was 10 years. Prices were taken from the health care tariffs
published by the Regional Health Service in Madrid and from Spanish literature. They
were updated to 2013 price levels and adjusted to subsequent years by a 3% inflation rate. We used the perspective of the Regional Health Service in Madrid (public
payer). Results: The model included an acute event and 3 health states. The increase
in total costs in 10 years was € 1,328 per DM patient (133 € per year). In patients
with hypertension the costs increased by 1,519€ in 10 years (152 € ); whereas the
total increase in costs in patients with obesity was 1,535 € (153 €). Conclusions:
IS has a relevant impact on the costs of management of DM. Hypertension and
obesity increase these costs even further. Prevention of DM complications and an
adequate control of risk factors can lead to cost savings for the management of DM.
Understanding future costs of DM might be valuable for economic evaluations.
1University
Objectives: To determine differences in total health care expenditures among
general diabetics and newly diagnosed diabetics before and after HbA1c was
implemented as the standard diagnostic factor. Methods: Medical Expenditure
Panel Survey-Household component 2009 and 2011 databases were used. Annual
health care expenditures formed the dependent variable. Demographic factors,
comorbidities, prescription drug costs, medical events and utilization variables for
health care services like visits to office-based, outpatient and inpatient facilities,
emergency rooms, home health care for 2009 and 2011 formed the independent
variables. Patients diagnosed within the 2009 and 2011 years, were categorized into
a dichotomous new diagnosis variable. General linear regression was conducted
to compare predictors of total diabetes health care expenditures in 2009 and
2011. Results: The mean total health care expenditure decreased in 2011 compared to 2009 among general diabetics {$10,901 (95%CI= $9,013-$11,836) vs $11,458
(95%CI= $10,715-$12,201)} and the newly diagnosed ones {$9,462 (95%CI= $6201$12,721) vs $8,429 (95%CI= $6793- $10,064)}. Among general diabetics in 2009, total
expenditures showed significant relationships with prescription drugs, emergency
room, home health care, outpatient facility and physician services expenses (all
values p< 0.0001). The 2011 model was similar, but included associations between
office-based provider visits (p< 0.0001) and previous incidences of heart attacks
(p= 0.008). In 2009, among newly diagnosed patients, total expenditures were
significantly associated with home health facilities expenditure (p< 0.0001) as
opposed to no association in 2011. In both years, prescription medication, emergency room and hospital inpatient facilities expenses contributed to spending.
Visits to office-based and outpatient department providers, number of homehealth provider days (all values p< 0.0001) and hospital discharges (p= 0.0011)
impacted total expenditures in 2009 and 2011 respectively. Conclusions: Due
to the many variables significantly affecting diabetes health expenditures, reduction in costs could not be solely attributed to the implementation of the HbA1c
diagnostic criteria. Further research on cost-effectiveness of the HbA1c factor is
warranted to establish any possible association.
PDB42
Direct Costs Of Diabetes Mellitus In Poland
Kawalec P
Jagiellonian University Medical College, Krakow, Poland
.
.
.
.
.
Background: High prevalence and chronic complications are key determinants
of management costs of Diabetes Mellitus (DM). Given that DM affects more than 4
million people in Spain, the costs associated with this disease require an efficient
management. Cardiovascular diseases are complications associated with DM with
a major impact in health care budgets. Objectives: Develop a model to predict
future costs of DM in Spain. Estimate the increase in health care costs in DM patients
associated with potential cardiovascular diseases. We used the perspective of the
Regional Health Service in Madrid (public payer). Methods: Foro Gerendia is an
initiative constituted by health care professional, experts in DM management. A
Markov model for DM was developed based on the opinion of Foro Gerendia and on
previous works in this area. A 5-year primary care data registry of 22700 diabetic
patients in Madrid was used to estimate transition probabilities in the model. Time
horizon was 10 years. Prices were taken from the health care tariffs published by the
Regional Health Service in Madrid and from Spanish literature. They were updated to
2013 price levels and adjusted to subsequent years by a 3% inflation rate. Results:
Cardiovascular complications included in the model were ischemic heart diseases
(acute myocardial infarction and angina) and heart failure with a total of 5 health
states. The estimated increase in costs was € 1,080 per patient in 10 years (€ 108
per year). Considering an 8% prevalence of DM in Madrid, the increase in costs of
DM due to cardiovascular diseases would be € 52 million per year. Conclusions:
Cardiovascular diseases in DM patients have a relevant impact on health care
expenditure. Prevention of cardiovascular complications can lead to significant
cost savings for the management of DM. Understanding future costs of DM might
be valuable in terms of budget allocation and economic evaluation.
PDB45
Cost and Burden Of Hypercholesterolemia In Portugal
Gouveia M 1, Borges M 2, Augusto M 2, Caldeira D 2, Alarcão J 2, Pinheiro L 2, Sousa R 2,
Fareleira F 2, Ascenção R 2, Costa J 3, Laires P 4, Fiuza M 5, Dias N C 5, Martins S 5, Belo A 5,
Vaz-Carneiro A 2
1Católica Lisbon School of Business and Economics, Lisbon, Portugal, 2Center for Evidence Based
Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, University of Lisbon, Lisbon, Portugal, 3Institute of Molecular
Medicine, Lisbon, Portugal, 4Merck Sharp & Dohme, Oeiras, Portugal, 5Sociedade Portuguesa de
Cardiologia, Lisbon, Portugal
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
PDB43
Estimation of Costs Associated With Stroke In Diabetic Patients in
Madrid (Spain) Using A New Simulation Model
.
García-Pérez S , Sánchez-Piedra C , Sarría-Santamera A
Instituto de Salud Carlos III, Madrid, Spain
.
Objectives: The aim of this study was to assess the direct costs of ambulatory
treatment associated with types 1 and 2 diabetes mellitus (DM) from the public
payer perspective in Poland, and to explore the relative contribution of different cost
components in the total direct cost of DM. Methods: The estimates were based
on reimbursement data from the years 2012 and 2013 provided by the public payer
in Poland. Reimbursement costs of insulin, oral anti-diabetes drugs and monitoring
strips were taken into account. Costs were presented in Polish zloty (PLN). Results:
Total reimbursement costs for the public payer of anti-diabetes treatment were 1.3
billion PLN in 2012 and 1.5 billion PLN in 2013, representing 19% and 21% of the
total Polish reimbursement expenditures in 2012 and 2013, respectively. The highest
component of anti-diabetes treatment costs was monitoring strips (645 million PLN
in 2012 and 793 million PLN in 2013, 49% and 52%, respectively). Insulin costs (518
million PLN in 2012 and 583 million PLN in 2013) and anti-diabetes oral drug costs
(144 million PLN in 2012 and 155 million PLN in 2013) constitute 38-40% and 10-11%
of total reimbursement costs, respectively. Regarding insulin, human insulin had a
larger share of the costs (60-62%) than insulin analogs (38-40%). Premixed human
insulin (65-66% reimbursement costs) and premixed insulin analogs (47-52% reimbursement costs) represent the largest share of the reimbursement costs of human
insulin and insulin analogs, respectively. Reimbursement costs of biguanides and
sulphonylureas represent 49-54% and 40-44% of total reimbursement costs of oral
anti-diabetes drugs, respectively. Conclusions: Total direct costs of diabetes mellitus treatment constitute a major part of reimbursement expenditures in Poland
and are still growing. The main cost driver was reimbursement of monitoring strips,
and the costs of insulin reimbursement were slightly lower.
Sánchez-Piedra C , García-Pérez S , Sarría-Santamera A
Instituto de Salud Carlos III, Madrid, Spain
PDB44
Estimation of Costs Associated With Cardiovascular
Complications of Diabetic Patients In Madrid (Spain) Using A New
Simulation Model
.
Background: Diabetes (DM) has a relevant impact on health care budgets mainly
due to its high prevalence and its chronic and acute complications. Isquemic stroke
(IS) is one of the macrovascular complications associated with DM and its incidence
increases with the presence of some risk factors such as hypertension and obesity. Objectives: Develop a model to predict future costs of DM in Spain. Estimate the
increase in health care costs associated with potential IS in DM patients. Methods:
Foro Gerendia is an initiative constituted by health care professional, experts in DM
management. A Markov model for DM was developed based on the opinion of Foro
Gerendia and on previous works in this area. A 5-year primary care data registry of
Objectives: Hypercholesterolemia is a risk factor for ciculatory diseases. This study
estimates the impact of hypercholesterolemia on populations’ health levels and its
economic impact in Portugal. Methods: The impact on health status is measured
by the loss of life years adjusted for disability (DALYs - Disability Adjusted Life Years).
The economic impact analysis includes two components. The first estimates the
direct costs generated by hypercholesterolemia including consumption of health
care, social support, and other associated costs (e. g. transport). The second estimates indirect costs, those related to the losses of productivity. The disease burden
and the costs of illness attributable to hypercholesterolemia include also the complications attributable to this risk factor, namely ischemic stroke and ischemic heart
disease. In order to estimate the attributable fractions to hypercholesterolemia (total
cholesterol ≥ 200mg/dL or statin use) of the diseases considered, a microsimulation
approach was employed by using Framingham equations on the national database
(VALSIM). In a counterfactual scenario hypercholesterolemia was eliminated from
these observations and the resulting proportional change in the probability of CV
events was taken as the hypercholesterolemia attributable fractions. These fractions were used to estimate the contribution of hypercholesterolemia to the burden
and the annual costs of the aforementioned circulatory diseases. Results: 1,689
deaths can be attributed to hypercholesterolemia, which corresponds to 1.6% of the
total deaths in Portugal in 2010. The DALYs resulting from disability and premature
deaths caused by hypercholesterolemia in 2010 totaled 12,174. The estimated direct
cost attributable to hypercholesterolemia in 2013 prices is € 320 million (€ 32 million
for in-patient care and €288 million for ambulatory care). Indirect costs generated by
disability attributable to hypercholesterolemia add up to € 198 million. The overall
costs of disease are therefore estimated at € 518 million, about 0.3% of Portuguese
GDP. Conclusions: In Portugal, we observed substantial burden and costs associated with Hypercholesterolemia.
PDB46
Metformin in Combination With Dipeptidyl Peptidase-4 Inhibitors
or Sulfonylureas in The Treatment of Type 2 Diabetes: Clinical And
Economic Impact
Sicras-Mainar A 1, Navarro-Artieda R 2
Serveis Assistencials, Badalona. Barcelona, Spain, 2Hospital Universitari Germans
Trias i Pujol, Badalona, Spain
.
1Badalona
.
A340
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: To determine the clinical (compliance, metabolic control, hypoglycaemia and cardiovascular events [CVE]) and economic (resources and costs) impact
of metformin in combination with dipeptidyl peptidase-4 inhibitors (DPP4-I) or
sulfonylureas in patients with type 2 diabetes. Methods: Design: Multicentre,
observational retrospective study. Patients aged ≥ 30 years under treatment with
metformin who initiated a second oral antidiabetic treatment in 2008-2009 were
evaluated. Two study groups were established: a) metformin + DPP4-I, b) metformin + sulfonylureas. Main measures: comorbidity, metabolic control (HbA1c <
7%), compliance and complications (hypoglycaemia, CVE). Patients were followed
for 2 years. The cost model considered direct (primary/specialised care) and indirect (productivity) health care costs. Statistical analysis: logistic regression models
and ANCOVA, p < 0.05. Results: We recruited 1,405 patients (men age 67.1 years,
56.2% male) of whom 37% initiated a second treatment with DPP4-I and 63% with
sulfonylureas. At 2 years follow-up, patients treated with DPP4-I showed better
compliance (70.3% vs 60.6%), better metabolic control (64.3% vs 60.6%), and a lower
proportion of hypoglycaemia (13.9% vs 40.4%) (p < 0.05). The mean unit costs of the
total adjusted costs were € 2,341 vs € 2,512, respectively; p = 0.038. Rates of CVE
and renal failure were 3.7% vs 6.4%; p = 0.027. Vildagliptin was the most commonly
used DPP4-I. Conclusions: Sulfonylureas were the most frequently used drugs
for the treatment of diabetes. Patients treated with DPP4-I had better compliance
and control of diabetes, with lower rates of hypoglycaemia and CVE, resulting in
reduced health care costs.
PDB47
Patient-Level Estimates of Diabetic Complications on Direct
Medical Cost
Jiao FF, Lam C L K , Wong C K H , Fung C S C , McGhee S
The University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong Island, Hong Kong
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate the impact of diabetic complications on immediate and
long-term direct medical costs in Hong Kong. Methods: A retrospective cohort
study was conducted among 137,634 diabetic subjects from a territory-wide administrative database over six years (2008-2013). The trends of annual direct medical costs were analyzed by three groups: group 1) subjects without complications
over study period; group 2) subjects with existing complications at baseline; and
group 3) subjects developing new complications during follow-up. We employed
panel data regression to investigate the impact of each diabetic complication on
direct medical costs in the event year and subsequent years, adjusting for age and
Charlson Comorbidity Score. Results: We found 10,322 subjects with existing
diabetic complications at baseline (January 1st, 2009), and 14,349 newly developed
diabetic complications over 5 years. The annual direct medical costs increased from
$US4,629 to $US15,585 in the new complications group, which is substantially higher
than the modest rise in the no complication group (from $US1,157 to $US1,984). The
annual direct medical cost of baseline case was $US1,062 (62 year-old, no complication, Charlson Comorbidity Score= 0). After adjusting for age and comorbidity,
compared to the baseline case, the multipliers of annual direct medical costs in
the event year were: acute myocardial infarction (AMI) 10.61; other ischemic heart
disease (IHD) 3.67; congestive heart failure (CHF) 8.46; stroke 10.17; sight threatening diabetic retinopathy (STDR) 3.41; blindness 2.78; end stage renal disease (ESRD)
12.16; peripheral vascular disease (PVD) 3.00; amputation: 3.48. The multipliers in
subsequent years were: AMI 1.45; other IHD 1.32; CHF 1.86; stroke 1.37; STDR 2.16;
blind 1.32; ESRD 1.86; PVD 1.42; amputation 1.32. Conclusions: There were wide
variations in direct medical cost in event year and subsequent years across different major complications. These data would be useful for economic evaluations of
diabetes prevention or treatment programs.
PDB48
Cost Of Diabetes Related Chronic Complication In South Korea 2011
Yu J 1, Park S 2
.
.
1Sungkyunkwan
University, Suwon, South Korea, 2Handok Inc., Seoul, South Korea
Objectives: This study aimed to analyze the direct medical cost of diabetes related
micro- and macrovascular complications in Korean people with diabetes mellitus. Methods: Using the Health Insurance Review & Assessment Service-National
Patients Sample (about 1.3 million patients), which was a stratified sampling from
the entire population (about 46 million persons) under the Korean national health
security system (2011), estimation of direct medical cost complication for patients
who have diabetes related chronic complications were performed. We used the
6th revision of Korean Standard Classification of Diseases (KCD-6) which had been
developed with the reference of the 10th version of International Classification (ICD10). All statistical analyses were performed using the Statistical Analysis System
(SAS, version 9.3). Results: The mean age of the subjects was 61.4 years, 52.1% were
male and 47.9% were female. Of the 91,463 patients with DM, 20,584 patients (22%)
had at least one microvascular or macrovascular complication, 70,879 patients (78%)
had no complication. The average annual direct medical cost in patients who had
no complications was 351,660 won in 2011. The average annual direct medical cost
in patients who had microvascular complications such as retinopathy, nephropathy,
neuropathy was 506,160 won, 1.4 times higher than without DM complications, who
had macrovascular complications such as MI, CVA, ESRD was 1,362,928 won, 3.8
times higher than without DM complications. Conclusions: Diabetic complications have a substantial impact on the direct medical costs of DM patients. As the
number of people with diabetes continues to rise, early detection of the disease and
implementation of timely and appropriate therapeutic strategies could decrease
the burden of diabetes chronic complications and also huge related expenditures.
PDB49
Medical Expenditure for People With Diabetes in Urban Employee
Basic Medical Insureance in Fujian
Yu L 1, Zhang C 2
Office, China Labour and Social Security News, Fuzhou, China, 2Shenyang Pharmaceutical
University, Shenyang, China
.
1Fujian
.
Objectives: To estimate medical expenditure for people with diabetes covered
by Urban Employee Basic Medical Insurance (UEBMI) in Fujian. Methods: Claims
data were extracted from UEBMIF database during 2012.1. 1 to 2012.12.31. People
with diabetes were identified by keyword – diabetes. To estimate expenditures, we
used Sum_All Medical method. Descriptive analyses were conducted by using EXCEL
2010. Results: In 2012, one of the Fujian UEBMI database recorded claims data of
240079 patients, including 5953 with diabetes (2.48%), among which 68.81% were male
and 91.03% were age over 50. The number of General Outpatient (GO)/Catastrophic
Outpatient (CO)/inpatient with diabetes was 5196/4964/2325. GO/CO with diabetes
visited physicians averagely 24.13/46.02 times, almost 60% of the visits happened in
tertiary hospitals. People with diabetes each used inpatient services 1.70 times; the
mean number of LOS was 16.52 days. Total Direct Medical Expenditure for people with
Diabetes (TDMED) was CNY 132 million (16.33% of total direct medical expenditure);
out-of-pocket spending accounted for 27.20%. GO/CO/inpatient medical expenditures
were CNY 3824.16/7960.88/31365.25 per person and CNY 158.49/172.97/18396.62 per
visit. Expenses for medicine was CNY 89 million (67.01% of TDMED), only CNY 17 million (13.03% of TDMED) was spent on anti-glycaemic medicine. 94.56% of people with
diabetes took prescribed anti-glycaemic medicine, including OAD (88.34%), insulin
(41.21%) and traditional Chinese medicine (23.13%). For CO, 47.26% of the visits were
due to diabetes and the medical expenditure accounted for 43.40%. Among hospitalized people with diabetes, only 10.68% of their primary diagnoses were diabetes.
Inpatient with diabetes whose primary diagnoses were diabetes consumed less health
care resources (average LOS/medical expenditure per person/medical expenditure
per visit) than those whose primary diagnoses were diabetic complications or other
diseases (15.47days/CNY 14567.57/CNY 12481.90 vs. 16.65days/CNY 27666.67/CNY
19161.66). Conclusions: Diabetes, as one of the major chronic diseases, consumed
a large amount of medical resources in Fujian. Majority of direct medical expenditure
were spent on treating diabetic complications and other diseases.
PDB50
Indirect Costs of Diabetes Mellitus (Dm) From the Perspective of The
Social Insurance Institution (Zus) In Poland
Kawalec P
Jagiellonian University Medical College, Krakow, Poland
.
Objectives: The aim of this study was to assess the indirect costs associated with
types 1 and 2 diabetes mellitus (DM) from the perspective of the Social Insurance
Institution (ZUS) in Poland. Methods: The estimates were based on data from the
year 2012 concerning absence from work due to the illness (sick leave) the amount
of short term disability, the sufferers of which claim rehabilitation benefit, and the
amount of permanent (or long term) disability, the sufferers of which claim disability pension. Costs were presented in Polish zloty (PLN). Results: Total indirect
costs of DM types 1 and type 2 in the year 2012 in Poland were 59 013 912 PLN and
66 597 701 PLN, respectively. The highest component of indirect costs of DM type 1
was sick leave (61%). Long and short term disability costs constitute 28% and 11%
of total indirect costs of DM type 1, respectively. A slightly different situation was
reported in the case of type 2 diabetes: long term disability costs were only 1% of
total indirect costs, and short term disability had a slightly larger part of indirect
costs (less than 5%). The highest component of indirect costs of DM type 2 was sick
leave (95%). One sick leave of a person with types 1 or 2 diabetes generated a cost
of lost productivity equal to 1 771 PLN or 1 585 PLN, respectively. The cost of disability pension per one person was higher than rehabilitation benefit, and equalled
41 398 PLN compared with 17 249 PLN (the average value of one short and long
term benefit payment was the same for both types of diabetes). Conclusions:
DM in Poland generated high indirect costs. The main component was sick leave;
rehabilitation benefit and disability pension generated much lower costs for Social
Insurance Institution.
PDB51
Key Cost Drivers Of Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: an International
Literature Review
Villoro R 1, Zozaya N 1, Hidalgo A 2, Oliva J 2, Rubio M 3
Economía y Salud, Madrid, Spain, 2University of Castilla La Mancha, Toledo, Spain,
3Sanofi, Barcelona, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
1Weber
Objectives: Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus (T2DM) is a worldwide prevalent chronic
disease, related to high morbidity and mortality, and to significant socioeconomic
costs. However, the magnitude of cost varies significantly among empirical studies.
The objective of this literature review is to identify the main drivers that influence the costs of T2DM. Methods: We searched relevant databases for studies
estimating T2DM costs, published in English and Spanish in the USA and Europe
(1995-2014). Search terms included “diabetes”, “costs”, “burden”, and “economic
impact”. No exclusion was made based on study design. Cost drivers and differences
in methodologies across studies were identified. Results: A total of 25 papers
were included out of 618 relevant titles identified. Costing methodologies and cost
drivers vary significantly causing important variations in results. The main difference in methodology refers to estimating T2DM costs versus the costs of people
living with T2DM, which include all direct sanitary costs -whether directly related
to T2DM or not- and may increase total costs by up to 74%. Direct sanitary costs
range between 40% and 75% of total costs depending partially on whether productivity losses and caregiving are considered. The relative weight of hospitalizations
range between 20% and 60% of sanitary costs depending on the categories included.
Pharmacologic costs range between 13% and 46%, which include antidiabetic drugs
and treatments for complications derived from poor control. Optimal glycemic control reduces costs but is not always considered in the studies. Microvascular and/
or macrovascular complications and hypoglycemic events increase total cost per
patient. Conclusions: Differences in costing methodology, the type of cost categories included in the analysis and the source of data greatly influence the results
of the studies and impede reaching accurate conclusions regarding the cost of T2DM.
Designing standardized costing methodology guidelines would help future studies
estimate the real burden of T2DM.
A341
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PDB52
How to Estimate The Cost Of Diabetes Based on Information From
The French Health Insurance Database (Sniiram)?
Aguadé A S 1, Gastaldi-Menager C 1, Denis P 1, Fagot-Campagna A 1, Gissot C 2, Polton D 2
(National Health Insurance), Paris Cedex 20, France, 2CNAMTS (National Health
Insurance), paris cedex 20, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1CNAMTS
Objectives: The aim of this study is to assess for 2012 the cost of diabetes from a
payer perspective, based on the French health insurance database and using two
different approaches (top down versus bottom-up). Methods: Using information
about 60 millions of individuals from the general scheme insurance database (85%
of the French population), we developed algorithms to identify all people who
received care for each of 56 groups of diseases or medical events or treatments,
which are frequent, severe and/or costly. Algorithms have been applied to each
patient. For diabetes, we used ICD-10 diagnoses for long-term chronic diseases,
reimbursement for anti-diabetic drugs. Costs of all reimbursed expenditures (outpatient/inpatient care, disability/sickness benefits) were extracted per individual.
The top-down method allocated expenditure to each of the 56 diseases based
on the average expenditure by disease calculated for individuals with only one
disease. All expenditures were thereafter extrapolated to the whole population
to fit national health account aggregates. For the bottom-up approach, diabetes
expenditures were estimated by identifying finely in our database expenditure
items which are partly or wholly directly related to diabetes according to expert
judgment. Results: Based on the top-down approach, among the 146 billion
euros of expenditures reimbursed by national health insurance (all insurance
schemes) in 2012, 7. 5 billion (5%) are attributable directly to diabetes. Expenditures
for chronic renal insufficiency and cardio-vascular disease, frequent diabetes complications, have been assessed separately. Drugs and medical devices (3.8 billion € )
represents more than 50% of the diabetes expenditures, other outpatient care
34% (2.5 billion), inpatient care 9% (700 millions) and disability/sickness benefits
7% (500 millions). Based on our bottom-up, around 8 billion would be directly
attributable to diabetes. Conclusions: Our study provides estimation of the
cost of diabetes from a payer perspective, according to two different approaches
but with concordant results.
PDB53
Direct Cost of Diffuse Toxic Goiter and Its Complications In Ukraine
Vadziuk I
Ivan Horbachevsky Ternopil State Medical University, Ternopil, Ukraine
.
Objectives: To determine the direct cost of health care technologies used for
treatment of diffuse toxic goiter in Ukraine. Methods: We made the retrospective analysis of 52 patients’s medical records with DTG that were hospitalized to
the endocrinology department of Ternopil University Hospital (Jan-Dec 2012). The
method of pharmacoeconomic analysis “cost of illness” was used to estimate the
cost of health care for patients with DTG. We have made calculations of costs: the
cost of laboratory analysis, the cost of instrumental analysis, the cost of drug treatment, doctor’s consultations, costs of patient’s stay in hospital. While determining
the direct costs of medical services in monetary terms we used the rates for medical
services that were in Ternopil University Hospital. Results: The study found that
among the patients there were 11 (21.15%) men and 41 (78.85%) women aged 20 to
65 years (46.88±8.9). All patients have got to the hospital in stage of medication subcompensation. The average duration of stay in hospital for patients was 10.67±2.07
days. The total cost of laboratory tests was EUR 1,555.53. The costs of instrumental
methods of patients examination amounted EUR 204.25. The cost of consultations
by specialists was EUR 285.97. In determining the amount of direct costs for medicines we found that the cost of drug treatment of the underlying disease is EUR
211.83, the cost of drug therapy of DTG complications is EUR 1,163.64. Total cost of
patients stay in hospital was EUR 3,513.45. After calculation of all direct costs we
determined that the total cost of DTG per patient is EUR 133.36 per course of treatment. Conclusions: In the cost structure of health care provision for patients
with diffuse toxic goiter the most significant costs were spent for laboratory tests
and for patient’s stay in hospital. The presence of underlying disease complications
significantly increases cost of drugs.
PDB54
Comparison of the Economic Burden and Health care Utilizations
of u.S. Veteran Patients Diagnosed with Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus
Xie L 1, Kariburyo M F 1, Wang Y 1, Baser O 2
1STATinMED Research, Ann Arbor, MI, USA, 2STATinMED Research and The University of
Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate the economic burden and health care utilizations of Type
2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) among U.S. veteran patients. Methods: T2DM patients
(International Classification of Disease 9th Revision Clinical Modification [ICD-9-CM]
diagnosis codes 250.x0, 250.x2) were identified using the U.S. Veterans Health
Administration Medical SAS datasets (01OCT2008-31SEP2011). The first diagnosis
date was defined as the index date. A comparison cohort of patients without a T2DM
diagnosis but of the same age, region, gender and index year were identified and
matched according to baseline Charlson Comorbidity Index scores, with a randomly
chosen index date to minimize selection bias. Patients in both cohorts were required
to be at least age 18 years, with 1-year continuous health plan enrollment pre- and
post-index date. Baseline body mass index (BMI) and glycated hemoglobin (HbA1c)
values and follow-up health care costs and utilizations were compared using 1:
1 propensity score matching (PSM). Results: A total of 1,211,748 T2DM patients
were identified for study. T2DM patients had significantly higher HbA1c (7.25 vs.
5.78, p< 0.0001) and BMI (31.75 vs. 29.16, p< 0.0001) results during the baseline period.
After 1: 1 PSM, each cohort included 323,962 patients, with well-balanced baseline
demographic and clinical characteristics. A higher percentage of T2DM patients had
inpatient admissions (8.65% vs. 1.58%, p< 0.0001), emergency room (ER) (13.12% vs.
4.44%, p< 0.0001) and physician office visits (99.54% vs. 45.22%, p< 0.0001) and prescription fills (84.55% vs. 45.43%, p< 0.0001). The T2DM cohort also incurred higher
inpatient ($3,051 vs. $424, p< 0.0001), ER ($127 vs. $39, p< 0.0001), physician office
($2,934 vs. $875, p< 0.0001), outpatient ($3,299 vs. $971, p< 0.0001), pharmacy ($610
vs. $224, p< 0.0001) and total costs ($6,958 vs. $1,618, p< 0.0001) than the comparison
cohort. Conclusions: Study results suggest that patients diagnosed with T2DM
utilized more health resources and incurred four times higher costs compared to
those without a T2DM diagnosis.
PDB55
Medical Expenditures Associated With Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus in
Japan: A Large Claims Database Study
Fukuda H 1, Ikeda S 2, Shiroiwa T 3, Igarashi A 4, Fukuda T 3
1Kyushu University, Graduate School of Medical Sciences, Fukuoka, Japan, 2International
University of Health and Welfare, Otawara City, Tochigi, Japan, 3National Institute of Public
Health, Saitama, Japan, 4University of Tokyo, Graduate School of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Tokyo,
Japan
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The objective of the study was to estimate the excess costs associated
with type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) and diabetes-related complications in Japan
through the use of a large claims database. Methods: We performed a retrospective cohort analysis using a large commercial claims database obtained from the
Japan Medical Data Center Co., Ltd. (Tokyo, Japan). Data from the period between
January 2005 and June 2012 were analyzed. Patients diagnosed with T2DM were
identified using the International Classification of Diseases 10th revision (ICD-10)
diagnosis codes E11–E14, with the month of initial diagnosis designated as the
index month. Cost and health care utilization data from claims for outpatient,
inpatient, and dispensing services during the study period were summarized to
per-patient-per-month (PPPM) levels. Costs were calculated from the perspective of
a public health care payer. Diabetes-related complications were identified through
the occurrence of the following diseases after the index month and/or their associated treatment: retinopathy, nephropathy, neuropathy/extremity disease, ischemic
heart disease, and cerebrovascular disease. Regression-adjusted medical costs
associated with each health state of T2DM were estimated using a fixed-effects
model. Results: A total of 8,063,139 PPPM records from 152,791 T2DM patients
were identified and examined. The average follow-up duration per patient was
52.8 months. The average incremental cost for T2DM was US$123 PPPM. The
average incremental costs for diabetes-related complications were US$94
(retinopathy without surgery), US$1,933 (retinopathy with surgery), US$17 (renal
proteinuria), US$319 (renal failure), US$3,677 (dialysis), US$131 (neuropathy
and/or extremity disease without surgery), US$4,498 (neuropathy and/or
extremity disease with surgery), US$93 (ischemic heart disease without surgery), US$13,280 (ischemic heart disease with surgery), US$56 (cerebrovascular
disease with surgery), and US$2,605 (cerebrovascular disease with hospitalization). Conclusions: These estimates of incremental medical expenditure in relation to health state may contribute to economic evaluations of various aspects
of health care in Japan.
PDB56
Health Care Costs in Patients With Type 2 Diabetes in Flanders
Based on A Combination of Clinical And Health Insurance Data
Odnoletkova I 1, Annemans L 2, Ceuppens A 3, Aertgeerts B 1, Ramaekers D 1
1University of Leuven, Leuven, Belgium, 2Ghent University & Brussels University, Ghent, Belgium,
3Independant Health Insurance Fund, Brussels, Belgium
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To analyse the annual health care costs of patients with type 2 diabetes
in Flanders from the perspective of the health care system and to assess the impact
of comorbidities on total cost. Methods: Study participants were selected from
the Independent Sickness Fund database on consumption of hypoglycemic agents
and invited to participate in a clinical trial on diabetes education. Information on
resource utilization during 12 months preceding inclusion was extracted from the
database and combined with baseline clinical assessment data. Total health care
costs consisted of costs paid by the public health insurance and patient co-payments
and was analyzed as function of reported comorbidities through stepwise multiple
regression. Results: 574 patients agreed to participate. Mean age was 64 years (35 75) and type 2 diabetes was diagnosed since 7 years on average. 62% were men, 86%
were treated with oral antidiabetics. 38% reported to have at least one comorbidity.
30% were hospitalized in the study period. Hospitalizations accounted for 41% of
the total cost, followed by outpatient prescription medications (22%) and physician
consults (8%). The mean (95% CI) health care cost was € 4,522 (€ 3,799 to € 5,245). The
mean annual cost of patients with no comorbidities was € 3,357 (€ 2,599 to € 4,116)
and increased till € 4,750 (€ 3,511 to € 5,990) for those with one comorbidity (p= .001)
and till € 7,303 (€ 3,909 to € 10,697) and € 9,868 (€ 4,685 to € 15,051) for those with two
and three comorbidities respectively (p= .039 and. 057). Coronary heart disease was
the main contributor to the cost variability (R2= 0.063, p= .000). Conclusions: Our
study updates the knowledge on the actual annual cost of diabetes treatment in
Flanders. Combination of clinical information and health insurance claims data
allowed analysis based on the patient medical condition. The high marginal cost
of people with comorbidities emphasises the importance of prevention for people
diagnosed with type 2 diabetes.
PDB57
Multimorbidity Pharmaceutical Cost of Diabetes Mellitus
Vivas-Consuelo D 1, Alvis-Estrada L 2, Uso-Talamantes R 3, Caballer-Tarazona V 1, BuiguesPastor L 3, Sancho-Mestre C 1
1Universitat Politecnica de Valencia, Valencia, Spain, 2Universidad de Cartagena, Cartgena,
Colombia, 3Conselleria de Sanidad. Generalitat de Valencia, Valencia, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate the multimorbity associated with diabetes mellitus
type 2 and its relation to pharmaceutical cost in a primary health care setting. Methods: Cross-sectional study during 2012. A health region of 5,150,540
population was analysed to determine the diabetic individuals. 350,015 diabetic
individuals were identified through clinical codes using the ICD-9-MC classification and the 3M Clinical Risk Groups software. We analyzed the consumption of
A342
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
pharmaceutical and blood glucose reagent strips. All measurements were obtained
at individual level. Results: The raw prevalence of diabetes was 6.7%. All patients
were stratified into four morbitity groups. The first group corresponded to the initial state (CRG 1-4); the second group included the core multimorbidity patients in
the intermediate and advanced stages (CRG 5-7); the third group included patients
with diabetes and malignancies; the last group was of patients with catastrophic
statuses, manly ERSD. The most common comorbitities in the patient group for
CRG 5 to 7 were hypertension (47% - 97%), dislipemia (50.9% - 59%) and cardiovascular disease (18% - 39.9%). The average cost of insulin was € 117.1. The average
cost of oral antidiabetic agents secretagogues was € 15.2 and was highest in the
CRG 5 to 7 group at € 16.3. The average cost of non-secretagogue oral antidiabetic
agents was € 212.9 and was highest in the CRG 5 to 7 group at € 232.8. The total
average cost was € 476.5 in CRG 1-4 group, € 1350.5 in CRG 5-7 group, € 2174.1 in
CRG 8 group and € 2840.5 in CRG 9 group. Conclusions: Diabetes is characterised by a strong presence of other chronic conditions and events related to
its development throughout life. This multimorbidity has a great impact on the
pharmaceutical cost.
PDB58
Impact of Early Microbiologic Culture in the Economic Burden of
Care for Patients With Infected Diabetic Foot Ulcers At A Model Of
Secondary Level Imss’ Hospitals in Mexico
Balderas-Peña L M A 1, Sat-Muñoz D 2, Alvarado-Iñiguez M R 3, Salcedo-Rocha A L 4,
Ramírez-Conchas R E 1, Sánchez-Sandoval F H 5, Macías-López G G 6, Ruíz-Quezada S L 6,
Chagollán-Ramírez J M 3, Prieto-Miranda S E 5, García de Alba-García J E 4
1UMAE Hospital de Especialidades Centro Médico Nacional de Occidente IMSS, Guadalajara,
Jalisco, Mexico, 2UMAE Hospital de Gineco-Obstetricia Centro Médico Nacional de Occidente
IMSS, Guadalajara, Jalisco, Mexico, 3Centro Universitario de Ciencias Económico Administrativas.
Universidad de Guadalajara, Zapopan, Jalisco, Mexico, 4Delegación Jalisco IMSS, Guadalajara,
Jalisco, Mexico, 5Instituto Mexicano del Seguro Social, Hospital General Regional N° 46,
Guadalajara,, Mexico, 6Universidad de Guadalajara, Centro Universitario de Ciencias Exactas e
Ingenierias, Guadalajara, Mexico
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Estimate the economic impact of the early microbiological culture
in the cost-reduction associated to the attendance process of the infected ulcers
in diabetic foot through an economic model based on a Monte Carlo simulation. Methods: Economic model of Monte Carlo simulation in two steps: The
first step was a descriptive and longitudinal study. Were included diabetic subjects
with infected ulcers in diabetic foot, patients were initially treated in Emergency
Room of Mexican IMSS’ secondary level hospital in a period from January 1st to
April 30th2010. Results: Micro-Costing Analysis Results: Total costs for the sample
were $502,438.04 USD, the mean cost per patient was $7,177.69 (±$5,043.51) USD,
the median cost was $6,422.99 (p25 $3,502.93; p75 $9,298.33). 72.75% ($365,527.45)
of the total cost was related to hospital stay. 10.6% ($53,240.86) of the expenditure
during treatment was associated to wound healing care, 9.98% ($50,132.94) surgeries, 1.87% ($9,389.27), anti-diabetic drugs and concomitant chronic diseases. 1.79%
($9,008.47) to clinical chemistry tests, 1% ($5,405.98) antibiotics, similar percentage
to the imaging studies ($5,000.08), 0.66% ($3,309.88) acute phase reactants, 0.19%
($965.65) microbiologic cultures, and the lowest percentage was destined to intravenous fluids. Monte Carlo Modelling Results: Antibiotic cost analysis showed: If
the physician takes a secretion sample in the first 48 hours of the patient admission
in emergency room and begin the empirical antibiotic treatment, and modifies the
criteria according microbiological results from the culture, the cost will be reduced
(through antibiotic expenditure) 9 to 15%. The reduction could be 20 to 32% associated to reduce the hospital stay days. The total cost for the attendance process could
be reduced 10 to 25%. Conclusions: According Monte Carlo Modelling results the
early microbiological culture as the base of antibiotic selection can reduce treatment cost in more than 30%.
PDB59
Direct Costs of Diabetic Foot Ulcers in Russia
Ignatyeva V 1, Avxentyeva
.
M 1, Galstyan
.
G R 2, Bregovskiy V 3, Udovichenko
.
.
.
O4
.
1The
PDB60
Health Economics Evaluation for Insulin Injection Pen-Needle with
Different Lengths in Patients With Diabetes in China
Sun L , Ren X , Zhu S , Liu Y , Chen Y , Sun J , Chen B , Sun S , Wang R
Shenyang Pharmaceutical University, Shenyang, China
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To perform a health economics evaluation for insulin injection penneedle with different lengths in diabetic patients in China. Methods: With the
relationship between HbA1C level and diabetes-related complications obtained from
literature, cost-benefit analysis was applied to evaluate the net cost saving (including the cost of needles and cost of complications and adverse events treatment) of
shorter pen-needle compared to the longer one, from the perspective of society. The
unit costs were retrieved from published sources and outcomes of the effectiveness
were derived from meta-analysis of relevant literatures related to different lengths
insulin pen-needle. One-way sensitivity analysis was conducted to demonstrate the
robustness of results. Results: The meta-analysis showed that compared to the
longer needle, the shorter one decreased HbA1C by an average of 0.11% and reduced
the risk of hypoglycaemic events by 17%. A net saving of $27 per patient based on
shorter needle resulted from decreased adverse events, while the costs of needles
were increased by $9 during the trial time. If the retinopathy was included, shorter
needle produced a net saving of $320 per patient due to decreased complications,
and the economic evaluation revealed shorter needle can totally save $338 per
patient compared to the longer one. If without retinopathy, the net saving was $129
per patient due to decreased complications, and the totally saving was $147 per
patient. Sensitivity analysis showed that the results were stable. Conclusions:
Current findings indicate that shorter insulin injection pen-needle lead to a decreasing of complications and adverse reaction compared to longer needle, and subsequently could lead to a reduction in health costs.
PDB61
Burden of Non-Adherence To Type 1 Diabetes Mellitus Therapeutic
Guidelines In France
Beaudet A , Ong R C
IMS Health, Basel, Switzerland
.
.
.
Objectives: To investigate the burden of type 1 diabetes mellitus (T1DM) in France
associated with non-adherence to clinical guidelines using the IMS CORE Diabetes
Model (CDM) and clinical data from the IMS Lifelink Diabetes Cohort. Methods:
The CDM is a health economic model based on 17 inter-dependent sub-models
that simulate micro- and macrovascular complications associated with diabetes.
Physiological parameter inputs such as HbA1c, blood lipids, body mass index (BMI),
and systolic blood pressure (SBP) were taken from real-life data and compared with
guidelines from the “Haute Autorité de Santé”. T1DM patients (age ≥ 18) who visited
a general physician between May 2011 and May 2014 and have received at least
one insulin prescription were included in the analysis. Costs and outcomes were
discounted at 4% per annum. Costs of complications were taken from published
sources. Results: A cohort of 605 T1DM patients (43% male) was analyzed. Mean
age at first visit was 58 years, HbA1c was 7.8%, SBP was 132 mmHg, and BMI was 28
kg/m2. Smokers represented 23% of the cohort. Results from economic modeling
using the CDM suggest that for prevalent T1DM patients in France, potential savings for the health care system associated with meeting the therapeutic guidelines
would be on average of 1,661 EUR per patient from a lifetime perspective. Most of
the savings would come from the prevention of renal complications. Any new complication would be delayed by 2.4 months on average. Conclusions: The “Haute
Autorité de Santé” recommends that T1DM patients maintain their HbA1c lower
than 7.5%, SBP lower than 130 mmHg, BMI lower than 25 kg/m2 and quit smoking.
Our results showed that these recommendations were not strictly followed among
T1DM patients in France. Better adherence to the T1DM guidelines would lead to
cost savings in the French health care system and improved patient outcomes.
PDB62
Health Economic Evaluation of Canagliflozin in the Treatment of
Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus in Czech Republic
Troelsgaard A 1, Pitcher A 2, Veselá Š 3, Lovato E 2, Hemels M 1
Health, London, UK, 3Janssen-Cilag Czech Republic,
Prague, Czech Republic
Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration, Moscow,
Russia, 2The Endocrinological Scientific Center, Moscow, Russia, 3Federal Almazov Medical
Research Center, St. Petersburg, Russia, 4Moscow Municipal outpatient clinic #22, Moscow, Russia
1Janssen A/S, Birkerød, Denmark, 2IMS
Objectives: To evaluate the outcomes and current costs of 4 different scenarios of diabetic foot ulcers (DFU) treatment in Russian current medical practice. Methods: We developed a decision tree model estimating annual number
of outcomes (major and minor amputations) and costs for 4 simplified possible
scenarios of medical care: 1) outpatient diabetic foot clinic, 2) non-specialized
outpatient care, 3) cessation of the outpatient treatment by patient after the second visit and 4) care provided only at hospital (without previous visits to any
outpatient clinic). The distribution of the patient cohort (1000 patients) among the
scenarios and rates of possible events were based on published Russian data and
experts’ survey. Costs were calculated from the overall governmental budget point
of view and included inpatient and outpatient care for DFU treatment, total contact casting, medications and dressings provided in the outpatient care, prosthetic
devices and services. Cost data was derived from published retrospective study
comparing provision of care to DFU patients in specialized and non-specialized
clinics in Russia and reimbursement rates in public medical insurance and social
care. Results: The lowest rate of amputations per patient (0.07 for minor and 0.01
for major) is expected for those receiving treatment in the outpatient diabetic foot
clinic with mean annual cost € 279.68 per patient. The highest costs (€ 1141.17) and
amputation rates (0.29 for minor and 0.19 for major) per patient are observed in
the group treated at hospital only. The minor amputation rate and annual costs are
higher for patients following non-specialized outpatient care than for those ceasing the outpatient treatment – 0.11 vs 0.09 and € 449.82 vs € 381.30, and the reverse
was observed for the rate of major amputations - 0.03 vs 0.06. Conclusions:
Referring DFU patients to the outpatient diabetic foot clinics as early as possible
appears to be the most cost-effective way of treating them.
Objectives: Canagliflozin is a novel drug for treatment of diabetes belonging
to the drug class known as sodium glucose co-transporter-2 (SGLT2) inhibitors
which method of action is insulin independent. Canagliflozin has been shown to
not only reduce glucose levels, but also weight and blood pressure. The objective is
to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of canagliflozin 100mg in dual therapy (add-on
to metformin) compared to sitagliptin and glimepiride, in triple therapy (add-on
to metformin and sulfonylurea) compared to sitagliptin and as an insulin add-on
compared to dapagliflozin in the Czech Republic setting from a payer perspective. Methods: The IMS CORE Diabetes Model was used to evaluate the costeffectiveness of canagliflozin using clinical trial data and network meta-analysis
data, combined with Czech Republic specific data, where available. Results: The
cost-effectiveness analyses indicate that in dual therapy when compared with
sitagliptin and glimepiride, canagliflozin 100mg is found to be cost-effective with
an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of 242,783 Kč per QALY gained and
626,939 Kč per QALY gained, respectively. In triple therapy when compared to sitagliptin, canagliflozin 100mg is found to be cost-effective with an ICER of 335,759
Kč per QALY gained. As an add-on to insulin (with or without metformin), canagliflozin compared to dapagliflozin appears to be cost-effective with an ICER of 375 Kč
per QALY gained. A wide range of deterministic sensitivity analyses revealed that
in the majority of scenarios, canagliflozin remained cost-effective with ICERs well
below the willingness-to-pay threshold of 1,100,000 Kč per QALY. Conclusions:
Canagliflozin 100mg represents a cost-effective option for the treatment of type 2
diabetes in the Czech Republic. Canagliflozin 100mg offers greater health benefits
than the included alternatives in this study, at a cost that provides good value
for money.
.
.
.
.
.
A343
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PDB63
Short-Term Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Insulin Detemir Versus
Insulin Neutral Protamine Hagedorn (Nph) In Patients With Type 2
Diabetes Mellitus in Spain
Ramírez de Arellano A 1, Morales C 2, De Luis D 3, Ferrario M G 4, Lizán L 5
Nordisk Pharma SA, Madrid, Spain, 2Hospital Virgen de la Macarena, Sevilla, Spain,
3Hospital Rio Hortega, Valladolid, Spain, 4Outcomes’10, Castellon, Spain, 5Outcomes 10,
Castellon, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Novo
Objectives: To estimate the short-term cost-effectiveness of insulin detemir
compared with Neutral Protamine Hagedorn (NPH) insulin when initiating insulin
treatment in patients with Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus (T2DM) in Spain. Methods: A
short-term (1 year) cost-effectiveness model was adapted to the Spanish public health
care system. Based on a head-to-head randomized controlled trial (NCT00104182)
that showed similar efficacy in glycemic control for both insulin types, weight gain
(Δ=0.9Kg) and the rate of non-severe hypoglycemia (between-arms RR= 0.52; IC95%
0.44-0.61) of detemir vs. NPH were selected as clinical outcomes. Costs (Euros 2014)
were estimated from the perspective of the Spanish national health system and
derived from national public sources. Only insulin treatment and management costs
associated with non-severe hypoglycemic episodes were included in the analysis.
According to a published study, non-severe hypoglycemia (a self-managed event)
was assumed to imply the use of 5.3 glucometer strips and a visit to a general practitioner for 25% of patients (Orozco-Beltrán et al., 2014). The disutility value associated
to weight gain was -0.0100 per BMI unit (Lee et al., 2005). The disutility associated to
daytime and nocturnal non-severe hypoglycemia was -0.0041 and -0.0067 per event,
respectively (Evans et al., 2013). Results: The yearly gain in quality-adjusted life
years (QALY) associated to insulin detemir versus NPH was 0.015. The estimated
incremental cost of treating patients with insulin detemir versus NPH was € 244.03.
The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of insulin detemir versus NPH in
insulin-naïve T2DM patients was estimated to be €16,381.18/QALY in Spain. This
value is lower than those published for other European countries (€21,768-28,349/
QALY) and is beneath the ICER threshold commonly accepted for Spain (€30,000/
QALY). Conclusions: Insulin detemir is a cost-effective alternative to NPH insulin in
the first and subsequent years of treatment of insulin-naïve T2DM patients in Spain.
PDB64
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Insulin Detemir Versus Insulin
Neutral Protamine Hagedorn (Nph) In Patients With Type 1 Diabetes
Mellitus In Spain
Ramírez de Arellano A 1, Lizán L 2, Prades M 2, Morales C 3, De Luis D 4
1Novo Nordisk Pharma SA, Madrid, Spain, 2Outcomes 10, Castellon, Spain, 3Hospital Virgen de la
Macarena, Sevilla, Spain, 4Hospital Rio Hortega, Valladolid, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate the short-term cost-effectiveness of insulin detemir
compared with Neutral Protamine Hagedorn (NPH) insulin when initiating insulin
treatment in patients with Type 1 Diabetes Mellitus (T1DM) in Spain. Methods: A
short-term (1 year) cost-effectiveness model was adapted to the Spanish public health
care system. Based on the Update of CADTH Technology Report No. 92 (2008) that
showed similar efficacy in glycemic control for both insulin types, the rate of hypoglycemia with detemir vs. NPH (RR=0.84; IC95% 0.74-0.97) was the considered clinical
outcome. Costs, expressed in Euros 2014, were estimated from the perspective of the
Spanish national health system and derived from national health care cost databases
and publications. Only insulin treatment and management costs associated with
non-severe hypoglycemic episodes were included in the analysis. Non-severe hypoglycemia, defined as a self-managed event, was assumed to imply the use of extra 5.3
glucometer strips during the following week and a visit to a general practitioner for
25% of patients (Orozco-Beltrán et al., 2014). The disutility associated to daytime and
nocturnal non-severe hypoglycemia was -0.0041 and -0.0067 per event, respectively
(Evans et al., 2013). Results: The gain in quality-adjusted life years (QALY) associated
to determir versus NPH was 0.108. The estimated incremental cost of determir versus
NPH was €247.40. The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of detemir vs. NPH
in patients with T1DM was estimated to be € 2,286.67/QALY in Spain. This value is
significantly lower than those reported for other European countries (€10,938-13,310/
QALY) and are much lower than the ICER threshold commonly accepted for Spain
(€30,000/QALY). Conclusions: Detemir is a cost-effective alternative to NPH insulin
in the first year of treatment of insulin-naive T1DM patients in Spain.
PDB65
Cost-Effectiveness-Analysis of The New-Born Screening in Austria
Walter E 1, Kasper D C 2
1Institute for Pharmaeconomic Research, Vienna, Austria, 2Department of Pediatrics and
Adolescent Medicine, Vienna, Austria
.
.
infant in comparison to no-screening strategy. Transferred to the entire birth cohort
newborn screening is able to reduce total costs by 14 million € from the Austrian
health care systems perspective each year. Conclusions: Funding the new-born
screening saves money and is cost-effective for the Austrian health care system.
.
Objectives: Since more than 45 years, a preventive program for the detection of
congenital metabolic and endocrine diseases is carried out successfully in Austria. The
goal is to investigate every new-born a few days after birth to initiate a quality assured
therapy as quickly as possible. Since 1966, this program is carried out by the Federal
Ministry of Health at the University Clinic for Child and Adolescent Medicine, Medical
University of Vienna. The aim of this study was to determine cost-effectiveness of
the new-born screening. Methods: We developed a decision-analytic model, which
include specific Markov processes for the core disorders: Cystic Fibrosis (CF), phenylketonuria (PKU), medium-chain acyl-CoA (MCAD), congenital hypothyroidism (CH),
galactosemia (GAL) and Maple syrup urine disease (MSUD). Costs and health benefits
were estimated for a cohort of new-borns in Austria in 1 year. The analysis focused
on lifetime consequences. This encompassed direct costs (including screening costs
and cost of illness), quality-adjusted-life-years (QALYs) and reduced expectation of
life. Costs were presented per child and for the Austrian birth cohort. Costs from
published sources were used (2014 Euro) from the health care systems perspective.
QALYs, life-years (LYs) and costs were projected over a life-time horizon and discounted at 3% p. a. Results: We found ten-times higher lifetime costs per child
without screening compared to screening. The incremental costs of screening ranged
from 12.308 € (MCAD) to 291.332 € (PKU). Screening saved 181 € and 0.09 QALYs per
PDB66
The Impact of Long-Term Clinical Evidence on Cost-Effectiveness
of Exenatide Once Weekly (Bydureon®) Versus Insulin Glargine
for Patients With Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus (T2dm) From A Uk Nhs
Perspective
Charokopou M 1, Vioix H 2, Verheggen B G 1, Bratt T 2, Franks D 2
1Pharmerit International, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 2AstraZeneca UK Ltd., Luton, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: When patients start their first injectable therapy, clinicians can choose
between glucagon-like peptide-1 (GLP-1) agonists and basal insulins. This study
investigates the cost-effectiveness of exenatide once weekly (Bydureon®), a GLP-1
agonist, compared with insulin glargine in patients inadequately controlled with
metformin (±sulfonylureas) based on long-term clinical evidence. Methods: The
validated CARDIFF model was used to conduct the analyses. Clinical inputs were
derived from a randomized clinical trial and a 3-year follow-up study of it comparing
exenatide once weekly (ExQW) versus insulin glargine once daily. Based on these clinical inputs and the United Kingdom Prospective Diabetes Study (UKPDS) equations,
the model predicts disease progression and the number of micro- and macro-vascular
complications, along with diabetes-specific and all-cause mortality. The perspective
of the National Health Service in the UK was adopted over a lifetime horizon. Local
unit costs and utility data were assigned to the appropriate model parameters to
calculate total Quality-Adjusted-Life-Years (QALYs) and total costs. Deterministic
and probabilistic sensitivity analyses (PSA) were conducted. Results: Long-term
treatment with ExQW was well tolerated and associated with sustained glycaemic
control and sustained weight loss over at least 3 years. Compared to glargine, ExQW
in combination with metformin was associated with an incremental benefit of 0.123
QALYs (95%CI: 0.057; 0.178) at an additional cost of £1,722 (95%CI: £1,396; £2,089),
resulting in an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio of £13,967 per QALY gained. The
PSA showed that at a willingness-to-pay threshold of £20,000 per QALY gained, ExQW
treatment had an 83% probability to be cost-effective compared to the strategy including glargine. Sensitivity analyses showed that results were robust to variation in
model parameters that carry uncertainty. Conclusions: Exenatide once weekly in
combination with metformin was shown to be a cost-effective treatment option as
first injectable therapy in patients inadequately controlled with metformin within
established UK cost-effectiveness thresholds.
PDB67
Dapagliflozin (Forxiga®) Versus Glipizide As Add-On Therapies In
Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus (T2dm); An Update of The Cost-Effectiveness
Based On Long-Term Clinical Evidence From Uk Nhs Perspective
Charokopou M 1, Vioix H 2, Verheggen B G 1, Dillon S 2, Franks D 2
1Pharmerit International, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 2AstraZeneca UK Ltd., Luton, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To update the cost-effectiveness of dapagliflozin (Forxiga®), a selective
sodium-glucose co-transporter-2 (SGLT-2) inhibitor, compared with a sulphonylurea
(SU) when added to metformin in patients inadequately controlled with metformin
mono-therapy based on long-term clinical evidence. Methods: The published
and validated CARDIFF diabetes model was used to conduct the analyses. Clinical
inputs were derived from a 4-year follow-up study of a randomized clinical trial
comparing dapagliflozin and glipizide in combination with metformin. Based on
these clinical inputs and the United Kingdom Prospective Diabetes Study (UKPDS)
equations, the model predicts disease progression and the number of micro- and
macro-vascular complications, along with diabetes-specific and all-cause mortality. The perspective of the National Health Service in England and Wales was
adopted over a lifetime horizon. Local unit costs and utility data were assigned to
the appropriate model parameters to calculate total Quality-Adjusted-Life-Years
(QALYs) and total costs. Deterministic and probabilistic sensitivity analyses (PSA)
were conducted. Results: Dapagliflozin showed greater durability of HbA1c reduction compared with SU and sustained weight loss over 4 years. Compared to SU
added on top of metformin, dapagliflozin add-on to metformin was associated with
an incremental benefit of 0.181 QALYs (95%CI: 0.088; 0.268) at an additional cost of
£819 (95%CI: £415; £1,259), resulting in an ICER point estimate of £4,521 per QALY
gained. The univariate analyses showed that no input parameter change inflated the
ICER above £15,000 per QALY. The PSA showed that at a willingness-to-pay threshold
of £20,000 per QALY gained, dapagliflozin treatment had an estimated 100% probability to be cost-effective compared to an SU treatment strategy. These findings
were shown to be robust with all sensitivity analyses. Conclusions: Dapagliflozin
in combination with metformin was shown to be a cost-effective treatment option
for patients who are inadequately controlled with metformin mono-therapy within
established UK cost-effectiveness thresholds.
PDB68
Health Economic Evaluation of Canagliflozin in the Treatment of
Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus in Portugal
Troelsgaard A 1, Knudsen M 2, Maia-Lopes S 3, Luz M 3, Hemels M 1
Health, Hellerup, Denmark, 3Janssen-Cilag Farmacêutica,
Barcarena, Portugal
.
.
.
.
.
1Janssen A/S, Birkerød, Denmark, 2IMS
Objectives: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of canagliflozin in dual therapy as
add-on to metformin compared to sitagliptin and in triple therapy as add-on to metformin (MET) and sulfonylurea (SU) compared to sitagliptin. Methods: The IMS
CORE Diabetes Model was used to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of canagliflozin
100 mg and 300 mg versus sitagliptin 100 mg using data from both clinical trials and
network meta-analysis, combined with Portuguese-specific data when available. The
perspective of the analysis is societal in accordance with Guidelines for Economic
Drug Evaluation Studies from INFARMED. Results: The cost-effectiveness analyses
indicate that canagliflozin (100 mg and 300 mg weighted average 65: 35) is cost-saving
A344
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
and results in higher QALYs in comparison with sitagliptin 100 mg in dual therapy as
add-on to metformin and in triple therapy as add-on to MET plus SU. In dual therapy
as add-on to MET, canagliflozin (100 mg and 300 mg weighted average 65: 35) has
an average cost saving of 24 € and an average QALY gain of 0.036. In triple therapy
as add-on to MET+SU, canagliflozin (100 mg and 300 mg weighted average 65: 35)
has an average cost saving of 171 € and an average QALY gain of 0.033. Probabilistic
analysis suggests a likelihood of 59% of canagliflozin being cost-effective compared to
sitagliptin in dual therapy and 59% in triple therapy at a willingness-to-pay of 30,000
€ per gained QALY. Sensitivity analyses showed that canagliflozin is cost-effective
also from a payer perspective and even when the time horizon, which is 30 years in
the base case, is reduced to 10 years. Conclusions: Canagliflozin 100 mg and 300
mg will be a cost-effective alternative to sitagliptin in both dual and triple therapies,
as add-on to MET or as add-on to MET+SU, respectively.
PDB69
Health Economic Evaluation of Canagliflozin in the Treatment of
Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus in France
Granados D 1, Maurel F 2, Knudsen M 3, Troelsgaard A 4, Hemels M 4
1Janssen, Paris, France, 2IMS Health, Paris, France, 3IMS Health, Hellerup, Denmark, 4Janssen A/S,
Birkerød, Denmark
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Canagliflozin is a sodium glucose co-transporter 2 (SGLT2) inhibitor
developed for the treatment of adult patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM).
To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of canagliflozin in dual therapy as add-on to
metformin (MET) compared to sitagliptin, and in triple therapy (add on to MET
and sulphonylurea (SU)) compared to sitagliptin, liraglutide and a mixed strategy
with both drugs. Methods: The IMS CORE Diabetes Model was used to evaluate
the cost-effectiveness of canagliflozin versus the aforementioned comparators
using French-specific data, where available. Results: In dual therapy, as addon to metformin versus sitagliptin, canagliflozin (100 mg and 300 mg weighted
average 50: 50) resulted in an incremental cost of 392 € and an average QALY gain
of 0.013, which leads to an ICER of 30,154 € . In triple therapy canagliflozin (100
mg and 300 mg weighted average 50: 50) dominates sitagliptin with average cost
savings of 286 € and an average QALY gain of 0.050. Canagliflozin was estimated
to be cost-saving (1,280 € ) compared to liraglutide (distribution liraglutide 1.2
mg / 1.8 mg= 0.71/0.29 based on French market research data) with incremental QALYs of -0.015. Canagliflozin (100 mg and 300 mg weighted average 50: 50)
dominates a mixed strategy with liraglutide (12.5%) and sitagliptin (87.5%) average
cost saving of 410 € and average QALY gain of 0.041. Sensitivity analyses showed
that HbA1cand SBP treatment effects were key drivers of the cost effectiveness
results. Conclusions: Canagliflozin 100 mg and 300 mg will be a cost-effective
alternative to sitagliptin in dual therapy as add-on to metformin. In triple therapy
as add-on to metformin and SU, canagliflozin dominates in comparison with a
mix of patients treated with sitagliptin or liraglutide. Canagliflozin 100 mg or
300 mg is expected to be considered good value for money for the treatment of
T2DM in France.
PDB70
The Cost-Effectiveness of Exenatide Bid Versus Insulin Lispro Tid As
Add-On Therapy to Titrated Insulin Glargine in Patients With Type 2
Diabetes – An Analysis From The Swedish Health Care Perspective
Gordon J 1, McEwan P 1, Sabale U 2, Kartman B 2
Economics and Outcomes Research Ltd, Cardiff, UK, 2AstraZeneca Nordic-Baltic,
Södertälje, Sweden
.
.
.
.
1Health
Objectives: In patients with type 2 diabetes (T2D) receiving basal insulin therapy,
the addition of bolus insulin is a common therapeutic strategy once glycated hemoglobin (HbA1c) becomes uncontrolled. However, this strategy is associated with
weight gain and increased risk of hypoglycemia. The objective was to assess the
cost-effectiveness of exenatide twice daily (BID) (‘ExBID’) versus insulin lispro three
times daily (TID) (‘LisTID’) as add-on therapy to titrated insulin glargine in patients
with T2D, from the Swedish health care perspective. Methods: This analysis utilized the Cardiff Model, a previously published T2D disease model. Treatment effects
were taken from the 4B Study, where ExBID and LisTID resulted in similar glycemic
control with less hypoglycemia with ExBID. Furthermore, ExBID was associated
with a weight loss of 2.6kg and LisTID with a weight gain of 1.9kg. An assumption
made in this analysis is that once the HbA1c level returned to its baseline value,
patients escalated to intensified basal-bolus therapy based on published treatment
effects. Quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) were calculated, with health-state utilities applied to weight changes, hypoglycemia, and T2D-related complications. Costs
(Swedish kronor, SEK) included medication and T2D-related complications. The
model was run over a 40-year time horizon. Costs and QALYs were discounted at
3% annually. Results: Cost/patient with ExBID and LisTID was SEK 381,177 and
SEK 364,381, respectively. ExBID was associated with a QALY gain of 0.64 per patient
versus LisTID (11.51 and 10.86 QALYs, respectively). This result was driven by the
difference in weight between ExBID and LisTID. The cost/QALY gained with ExBID
versus LisTID was SEK 26,292. Conclusions: With a cost/QALY gained of SEK
26,292 (3,039 Euros, 2,582 British pounds, 4,033 US dollars), evaluated against commonly used cost-effectiveness threshold values, ExBID represents a cost-effective
treatment alternative to LisTID as add-on therapy to titrated insulin glargine in
patients with T2D in Sweden.
PDB71
The Cost-Effectiveness OF Canagliflozin (Cana) Versus Dapagliflozin
(Dapa) In Patients With Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus (T2dm) With
Inadequate Control On Metformin (Met) Monotherapy In The United
Kingdom
Schroeder M 1, Johansen P 2, Thompson G 1, Willis M 3, Neslusan C 4
UK, High Wycombe, UK, 2The Swedish Institute for Health Economics (IHE), Lund,
Sweden, 3The Swedish Institute for Health Economics, Lund, Sweden, 4Janssen Global Services,
LLC, Raritan, NJ, USA
.
1Janssen-Cilag
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Two SGLT-2 inhibitors, CANA and DAPA, are recommended in the UK
for combination therapy in T2DM. Through an insulin-independent mechanism of
action, SGLT-2 inhibitors improve glucose levels, blood pressure, and weight with a
low inherent risk of hypoglycaemia. The cost-effectiveness of using CANA or DAPA
in combination with MET was evaluated in patients inadequately controlled with
MET monotherapy, from the perspective of the UK NHS. Methods: The ECHOT2DM model was used to estimate 40-year outcomes and costs associated with
using CANA (100mg or 300mg) versus DAPA 10mg in dual therapy. HbA1c efficacy
estimates were obtained from a Network Meta-Analysis (NMA). Analyses of pooled
data from trials investigating CANA dual therapy (with MET) were used for parameters unavailable in the NMA (i. e., SBP, LDL, HDL and AEs). A broad set of sensitivity analyses were performed. Results: Both doses of CANA were associated with
more QALYs (0.01,0. 03 for 100mg and 300mg, respectively) and higher costs (£101,
£594, respectively). The associated incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICERs) were
£7,423 and £17,734, respectively; both below the willingness-to-pay for QALY threshold in the UK. The key driver of the result for CANA 300mg was the greater HbA1c
efficacy versus DAPA 10mg, and for CANA 100mg, a lower need for insulin rescue
since CANA (but not DAPA) can be used in persons with moderate renal impairment. The ICERs were robust under all scenarios tested. Only use of UK-specific and
not clinical trial patient characteristics substantively impacted the results; none
reversed the interpretation of CANA as cost-effective versus DAPA. Conclusions:
SGLT-2 inhibitors reduce HbA1C, body weight, and blood pressure, and thus the risk
of micro- and macrovascular complications. Economic simulations suggest that
both doses of CANA are cost-effective versus DAPA in dual therapy treatment of
T2DM (with MET) in the UK.
PDB72
Health-Economic Comparison of Sensor-Augmented Pump With Low
Glucose Suspend Versus Insulin Pump Alone For The Treatment of
Hypo-Prone Type 1 Diabetes In Hungary
Roze S 1, Lynch P 2, Boncz I 3, Dunne N 2, Varga C 4, Klots M 2, Karamalis M 2, Felszeghy E 5
1HEVA HEOR, Lyon, France, 2Medtronic, Tolochenaz, Switzerland, 3Faculty of Health Sciences,
University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary, 4Medtronic Hungary, Budapest, Hungary, 5University of
Debrecen, Medical School and Health Science Centre, Pediatric Dept., Debrecen, Hungary
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To project the long-term costs and outcomes of sensor-augmented
pump (SAP) with low glucose suspend (LGS) versus insulin pump (CSII) alone for the
treatment of hypo-prone Type 1 diabetes in Hungary. Methods: The CORE Diabetes
Model is a peer-reviewed, validated model, which employs standard Markov/Monte
Carlo simulation techniques to describe the long-term incidence and progression
of diabetes-related complications. It was used to simulate disease progression in a
cohort of patients with baseline characteristics (mean age 18.6 years, duration of
diabetes 12 years, mean HbA1c 7.5%) and clinical outcomes (severe hypoglycaemic
event rates; Quality of Life; HbA1c) taken from a recent randomised controlled
trial (Ly et al, 2013). Local treatment and complication cost data was used. The
main scenario considered in this cost-effectiveness analysis was the comparison
of sensor-augmented insulin pump (SAP) with low glucose suspend (LGS) versus
pump alone (CSII). The target population was hypo-prone type I diabetes patients
with the analysis based on a deterministic microsimulation of 1,000 patients, using
a 1 to 5 year time horizon. Direct costs were calculated from a third-party payer
perspective. Discount rates of 3.7% per annum were applied to both costs and
clinical outcomes. Results: The Incremental-Cost-Effectiveness-Ratio (ICER) for
SAP+LGS vs CSII was HUF 6,196,086 (€ 20,298) per Quality-Adjusted-Life-Year gained
over a 1 year time horizon. Results were similar using a 5 year time horizon (HUF
6,125,823 [€ 20,068] per QALY gained). Extensive sensitivity analyses showed the
robustness of the results. Conclusions: Using a payer’s perspective, our analysis
showed that SAP (w LGS) is cost-effective over a short term (1-5 year) time horizon
in hypo prone patients with Type 1 Diabetes in Hungary (using a WTP threshold of
3x Hungary GDP).
PDB73
Economic Assessment of Delaying Insulin Treatment Through
The Use of Newer Anti-Diabetic Agents, Dapagliflozin (Forxiga®)
And Exenatide (Bydureon®), Both As Add-On To Metformin; A CostEffectiveness Analysis From A Uk Nhs Perspective
Charokopou M 1, Vioix H 2, Verheggen B G 1, Maddocks D 2, Bratt T 2, Franks D 2
International, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 2AstraZeneca UK Ltd., Luton, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Pharmerit
Objectives: New classes of anti-diabetes drugs may delay the onset of Insulin
treatment. This study investigates the cost-effectiveness of a treatment pathway starting with dapagliflozin (Forxiga®), followed by exenatide once weekly
(Bydureon®) - both as add-on to metformin - and insulin treatment, compared
with a treatment pathway recommended in clinical guidelines that commences
with SU add-on to metformin, followed by the addition of insulin regimens in
patients inadequately controlled with metformin alone. Methods: The validated
CARDIFF model was used for the analyses. Clinical inputs for dapagliflozin versus SU, both as add-on to metformin, and exenatide once weekly were derived
from relevant head-to-head clinical trials and long-term follow up studies. Based
on these and the United Kingdom Prospective Diabetes Study (UKPDS) equations,
the model predicts disease progression and number of micro- and macro-vascular
complications, along with diabetes-specific and all-cause mortality. The perspective of the National Health Service in UK was adopted over a lifetime horizon. Local
unit costs and utility data were assigned to the appropriate model parameters
to calculate total Quality-Adjusted-Life-Years (QALYs) and costs. Deterministic
and probabilistic sensitivity analyses (PSA) were conducted. Results: Long-term
evidence showed that the durability of the treatment effects of dapagliflozin and
exenatide can delay the onset of insulin treatment by 5-6 years. Compared to the
traditional clinical practice, treatment with dapagliflozin+metformin followed by
exenatide+metformin, was associated with an incremental benefit of 0.343 QALYs
(95%CI: 0.239; 0.450) at an additional cost of £2,827 (95%CI: £2,352; £3,267), resulting in an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio of £8,233 per QALY gained. The PSA
A345
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
showed that at a willingness-to-pay threshold of £20,000 per QALY, the proposed
treatment pathway had a 100% probability to be cost-effective. Conclusions:
The proposed alternative treatment sequence was shown to be a cost-effective
treatment option in patients inadequately controlled with metformin alone within
established UK cost-effectiveness thresholds.
PDB74
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Liraglutide Versus Sitagliptin or
Exenatide in Patients With Inadequately Controlled Type 2 Diabetes
On Oral Antidiabetic Drugs In Greece
Tzanetakos C 1, Melidonis A 2, Verras C 2, Kourlaba G 3, Maniadakis N 1
1National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece, 2Tzanio General Hospital, Piraeus, Greece,
3National and Kapodistrian University of Athens School of Medicine, Athens, Greece
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate the long-term cost-effectiveness of liraglutide versus sitagliptin or exenatide, added to oral antidiabetic drug mono- or combination therapy respectively, in patients with Type 2 diabetes in Greece. Methods: The CORE
Diabetes Model, a validated computer simulation model developed to determine
the long-term health and economic outcomes of interventions in Type 2 diabetes, was adapted to the Greek health care setting. Patient and intervention effects
data were gathered from a clinical trial comparing liraglutide 1.2mg once daily
vs. sitagliptin 100mg once daily, both combined with metformin, and a clinical
trial comparing liraglutide 1.8mg once daily vs. exenatide 10μ g twice daily, both as
add-on to metformin, glimepiride or both. Direct costs were reported in 2013 Euros
and calculated based on published and local sources. All future outcomes were
discounted at 3.5% per annum, and the analysis was conducted from the perspective of a third-party payer in Greece. Results: Over a patient’s lifetime, treatment
with liraglutide 1.2mg vs. sitagliptin drove a mean increase in discounted life expectancy of 0.13 (SD 0.23) years and in discounted quality-adjusted life expectancy
of 0.19 (0.16) quality-adjusted life years (QALYs), whereas therapy with liraglutide
1.8mg vs. exenatide yielded increases of 0.14 (0.23) years and 0.19 (0.16) QALYs
respectively. As regards lifetime direct costs, liraglutide 1.2mg resulted in greater
costs of € 2797 (€ 1468) versus sitagliptin, and so did liraglutide 1.8mg compared
with exenatide (€ 1302 [€ 1492]). Liraglutide 1.2 and 1.8mg doses were associated
with incremental cost effectiveness ratios of € 15101 and € 6818 per QALY gained,
respectively. Conclusions: Liraglutide is likely to be a cost-effective option for
the treatment of Type 2 diabetes in a Greek setting.
PDB75
Health Economic Evaluation of Canagliflozin In The Treatment of
Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus In Slovakia
Troelsgaard A 1, Pitcher A 2, Binder R 3, Stetka R 4, Ondrusova M 5, Lovato E 2, Hemels M 1
Health, London, UK, 3Janssen, Bratislava, Slovak Republic,
4Pharm-In, Ltd, Bratislava, Slovak Republic, 5Pharm-In Ltd, Bratislava, Slovak Republic
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Janssen A/S, Birkerød, Denmark, 2IMS
Objectives: Canagliflozin is a novel drug for treatment of diabetes belonging to
the drug class known as sodium glucose co-transporter–2 (SGLT-2) inhibitors. To
evaluate the cost-effectiveness of canagliflozin 100 mg in the Slovakian setting
from a payer perspective when compared to sitagliptin in dual therapy (add-on to
metformin), sitagliptin in triple therapy (add-on to metformin plus sulfonylurea) and
dapagliflozin in combination with insulin (with or without metformin). Methods:
The IMS CORE Diabetes Model was used to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of canagliflozin versus comparators using Slovakia specific data, where available. Results:
The cost-effectiveness analyses indicated that canagliflozin 100 mg in dual therapy
when compared with sitagliptin, was found to be cost-effective with an incremental
cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of 14,930 € per QALY gained. In triple therapy when
compared to sitagliptin, canagliflozin 100 mg was found to be cost-effective with
an ICER of 5,251 € per QALY gained and in combination with insulin, canagliflozin
100 mg was a dominant alternative compared to dapagliflozin with a cost saving of
118 € per patient and higher QALYs. One-way sensitivity analyses revealed that in
the majority of scenarios considered canagliflozin remained cost-effective in the
dual therapy, triple therapy and add-on to insulin comparisons. Conclusions:
Based on calculations performed using the CORE Diabetes model, canagliflozin 100
mg appear to represent a cost-effective option for the treatment of type 2 diabetes
in Slovakia. Canagliflozin 100 mg was found to offer greater health benefits than
currently available alternatives and to be a cost-effective treatment option when
used in dual and triple therapy instead of sitagliptin or as an add-on to insulin
instead of dapagliflozin.
PDB76
Is Canagliflozin Cost-Effective Compared to Sitagliptin Across
Multiple Lines of Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus (T2dm) Therapy In Ireland?
Bacon T 1, Willis M 2, Johansen P 2, Neslusan C 3, Nuhoho S 4, Worbes-Cerezo M 5
1Janssen-Cilag Ltd, Dublin, Ireland, 2The Swedish Institute for Health Economics, Lund, Sweden,
3Janssen Global Services, LLC, Raritan, NJ, USA, 4Janssen-Cilag A/S, Birkerød, Denmark,
5Janssen-Cilag UK, High Wycombe, UK
.
.
.
.
were sourced from the literature. Both costs and outcomes were discounted at
5%. Results: Incremental costs, QALYs and ICERs for canagliflozin vs. sitagliptin
were € 1,360, 0.059 QALYs and € 23,118 per QALY, respectively, in dual therapy; € 108,
0.093 QALYs and € 1,172 per QALY, respectively, in triple therapy; and € 550, 0.068
QALYs and € 8,047 per QALY, respectively, in add-on to insulin. In all three scenarios,
canagliflozin was cost-effective using the acceptable willingness-to-pay threshold in
Ireland. Sensitivity analyses suggest that these results are robust. Conclusions:
These simulations suggest that the use of canagliflozin in patients in need of additional glycaemic control in dual, triple and add-on to insulin lines of therapy is a
more efficient use of health care funds than the use of sitagliptin in the Irish setting.
.
.
Objectives: Canagliflozin is a new oral agent for the treatment of T2DM that inhibits sodium-glucose co-transporter 2 (SGLT2), thereby leading to inhibition of glucose
reabsorption and urinary glucose excretion which results in reductions in blood
glucose, weight, and blood pressure. The purpose of this analysis was to evaluate
the cost-effectiveness of canagliflozin vs. sitagliptin – a recommended and widely
used dipeptidyl peptidase-4 inhibitor (DPP4) – in dual (with metformin), triple (with
metformin + sulphonylurea) and add-on to basal insulin (with or without other
anti-hyperglycaemic agents) therapy lines in Ireland. Methods: The Economic and
Health Outcomes Model of T2DM (ECHO-T2DM) [using updated UKPDS 82 mortality
and risk equations] was used to simulate lifetime outcomes and costs of patients
on either canagliflozin (100mg, titrated to 300mg as needed to maintain glycaemic
control) or sitagliptin 100mg. Patient characteristics and treatment effects were
sourced from head to head randomized clinical trials for dual and triple therapy.
For the add-on to insulin therapy simulations, treatment effects were sourced from
a network meta-analysis. Costs were localised and inflated to 2013 euros. Utilities
PDB77
The Cost-Effectiveness Of Canagliflozin VersUS Liraglutide In
Patients With Type 2 Diabetes (T2dm) Failing To Achieve Glycaemic
Control On Metformin Monotherapy In Ireland
Bacon T 1, Willis M 2, Johansen P 2, Neslusan C 3, Nuhoho S 4, Worbes-Cerezo M 5
1Janssen-Cilag Ltd, Dublin, Ireland, 2The Swedish Institute for Health Economics, Lund, Sweden,
3Janssen Global Services, LLC, Raritan, NJ, USA, 4Janssen-Cilag A/S, Birkerød, Denmark, 5JanssenCilag UK, High Wycombe, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Canagliflozin is a novel oral agent for the treatment of T2DM that
inhibits sodium-glucose co-transporter 2 (SGLT2), a mechanism that is complementary to other anti-hyperglycaemic drug classes, including insulin. SGLT2
inhibition leads to inhibition of glucose reabsorption and urinary glucose excretion, thereby reducing blood glucose, weight, and blood pressure. An economic
(cost-effectiveness) evaluation of new technologies versus routine care is required
prior to uptake in Ireland to ensure good value-for-money. This study evaluates
the cost-effectiveness of canagliflozin compared to liraglutide – a currently reimbursed and routinely used glucagon-like peptide 1 (GLP-1) agonist – as dual therapy
in combination with metformin from the payer perspective in the Irish health
care setting. Methods: The Economic and Health Outcomes Model of T2DM
(ECHO-T2DM) [using updated UKPDS 82 mortality and risk equations] was used
to simulate 40-year costs and outcomes associated with canagliflozin (100mg
titrated to 300mg in patients requiring tighter glycaemic control) compared to
liraglutide 1.2mg. Patient characteristics were sourced from canagliflozin RCTs
in patients uncontrolled on metformin monotherapy and treatment effects were
obtained from a network meta-analysis. The costs of treatments and outcomes
were localised and inflated to 2013 values where possible. Utilities were sourced
from the literature. Costs and outcomes were discounted at 5% annually. Results:
In the base case, canagliflozin was associated with incremental cost savings of
€ 3,382 compared to liraglutide 1.2mg. It was also associated with a 0.022 more life
years and 0.020 more quality adjusted life years (QALYs), suggesting that canagliflozin dominates liraglutide. Results were driven by lower acquisition costs for
canagliflozin. Sensitivity analyses indicated that the dominance observed was
robust. Conclusions: In these simulations, canagliflozin dominated liraglutide
1.2mg in dual therapy (add-on to metformin) in the Irish setting. These results
suggest that canagliflozin represents good ‘value for money’ in treating these
patients, compared to a routinely used GLP-1 agonist.
PDB78
Health Economic Evaluation of Canagliflozin In The Treatment of
Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus In Norway
Troelsgaard A 1, Huetson P 2, Kjellberg J 3, Hemels M 1, Knudsen M 4
1Janssen A/S, Birkerød, Denmark, 2IMS Health, Stockholm, Sweden, 3Zefferin Farma AB,
Stockholm, Sweden, 4IMS Health, Hellerup, Denmark
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Canagliflozin is a novel drug for treatment of diabetes belonging to the
drug class known as sodium glucose co-transporter 2 (SGLT2) inhibitors. To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of canagliflozin in dual therapy (add-on to metformin)
compared to sitagliptin and sulfonylurea (SU), in triple therapy (add on to metformin
and SU) compared to sitagliptin and as add-on to insulin versus placebo. Methods:
The IMS CORE Diabetes Model was used to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of canagliflozin (using a weighted average of 80/20 for the 100 mg and 300 mg dosage,
respectively) versus the aforementioned comparators using Norwegian-specific
data, where available. Results: In dual therapy, as add-on to metformin versus
sitagliptin, canagliflozin appears to dominate sitagliptin with average cost savings of 606 NOK and an average QALY gain of 0.030 and as add on to metformin
canagliflozin is cost-effective versus SU, with an incremental cost-effectiveness
ratio (ICER) of 79,309 NOK and an incremental cost of 5,757.80 NOK and an average QALY gain of 0.0726. As add on to insulin canagliflozin appears to dominate
placebo with an incremental cost saving of 13,506 NOK and an incremental QALY
of 0.080. In triple therapy as add on to metformin and SU canagliflozin appears to
dominate sitagliptin with average cost savings of 556 NOK and an average QALY
gain of 0.021. Conclusions: Canagliflozin is associated with cost savings and
QALY gain compared to sitagliptin in dual therapy as add-on to metformin, and in
triple therapy as add on to metformin and SU. Canagliflozin will be a cost-effective
alternative to SU in dual therapy as add on to metformin. Adding canagliflozin to
insulin will be cost-effective compared with placebo i. e. it is cost-effective to add
canagliflozin treatment rather than not.
PDB79
Health-Economic Comparison of Sensor-Augmented Pump With Low
Glucose Suspend Versus Insulin Pump Alone For The Treatment Of
Hypo-Prone Type 1 Diabetes In Slovakia
Roze S 1, Lynch P 2, Machova R 3, Micieta V 3, Dunne N 2, Klots M 2, Karamalis M 2, Martinka E 4
1HEVA HEOR, Lyon, France, 2Medtronic, Tolochenaz, Switzerland, 3Medtronic Slovakia, Bratislava,
Slovak Republic, 4National Endo and Diabetes Center, Bratislava, Slovak Republic
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To project the long-term costs and outcomes of sensor-augmented
pump (SAP) with low glucose suspend (LGS) versus insulin pump alone (CSII) for
the treatment of hypo-prone Type 1 diabetes in Slovakia. Methods: The CORE
Diabetes Model is a peer-reviewed, validated model, which employs standard
A346
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Markov/Monte Carlo simulation techniques to describe the long-term incidence
and progression of diabetes-related complications. It was used to simulate disease
progression in a cohort of patients with baseline characteristics (mean age 18.6
years, duration of diabetes 12 years, mean HbA1c 7.5%) and clinical outcomes
(severe hypoglycaemic event rates; Quality of Life; HbA1c) taken from a recent
randomised controlled trial (Ly et al, 2013). Local treatment and complication cost
data was used. The main scenario considered in this cost-effectiveness analysis
was the comparison of sensor-augmented insulin pump (SAP) with low glucose
suspend (LGS) versus insulin pump alone (CSII). The target population was type I
hypo-prone diabetes patients with the analysis based on a deterministic microsimulation of 1,000 patients, using a 5 year time horizon. Direct costs were calculated from a third-party payer perspective. Discount rates of 3% per annum were
applied to both costs and clinical outcomes. Results: The Incremental-CostEffectiveness-Ratio (ICER) for SAP+LGS (vs CSII) was € 17,893 per Quality-AdjustedLife-Year gained over a 5 year time horizon. Results were similar across a 1 to 10
year time horizon. Other extensive sensitivity analyses showed the robustness
of the results. Conclusions: Using a payer’s perspective, our analysis showed
that SAP (w LGS) is cost-effective over a short term (5 year) time horizon in hypoprone Type 1 Diabetes patients in Slovakia (using a WTP threshold of 1x [€ 18,000]
or 3x [€ 54,000] Slovakia GDP).
PDB80
Is a Home Based Video Teleconcultation Setup Cost Effective For
Lowering Hba1c For Patients With Type-2 Diabetes Over A Six-Month
Period?
Jensen M S 1, Rasmussen O W 2
1Region of Southern Denmark, Middelfart, Denmark, 2Kolding Hospital, Kolding, Denmark
.
.
.
.
Objectives: A RCT assessed the effectiveness and costs of a home based video
teleconsultation (HVT) setup to lower HbA1c in patients with type-2 diabetes
against usual out-patient treatment on the hospital. The HVT equipment was
delivered to the patients by the hospital. This analysis shows the potential incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of using a HVT setup on six-months health
care effects and costs. Methods: The study effectiveness outcome was HbA1c
level in %. The economic analysis was performed with a spreadsheet decision
tree model with a Danish hospital payer’s direct cost perspective. Cost data were
based on study measured time consumption pr. HVT, consultations at out-patient
clinic, HVT-equipment, -subscription, -support costs, and hospital operating cost.
Medicine costs weren’t included in the model. Model output included the cost
of a 1 % point reduction of HbA1c, ICER, with a probabilistic sensitivity analysis
(PSA). Two scenario analyses (SA) were made to capture costs of patient transport
to the hospital and a future online platform, were patients can use their own
computer/tablet to the video teleconsultations. Results: A total of 39 patients
(mean age 62, HbA1c 8.5%) were randomized to either usual care (UC) or HVT. At
6 months follow up the HVT group showed greater improvements from baseline
HbA1c levels (-1.38% vs. -0.92%) and less costly (€ 199.9 vs. € 208.2) against UC. The
base case ICER showed a potential € –17.58 saving per reduction of 1% HbA1c point.
A PSA confirmed the ICER trends despite data uncertainties. Both SA showed
further savings (ICER: € -67.85 and € -69.13). Compliance was 100% for HVT group
were several planned visits were cancelled in the UC group. Conclusions: The
present analysis shows the potential benefits of a HVT setup on 6-months health
care cost and effects against UC. Further savings could include cost associated
with lost work days.
PDB81
The Cost-Effectiveness of Canagliflozin VersUS InsulinSecretagogues (Sulphonylureas) or Insulin In Patients With Type 2
Diabetes Mellitus (T2dm) As An Add-On To Metformin In Ireland
Bacon T 1, Willis M 2, Johansen P 2, Neslusan C 3, Nuhoho S 4, Worbes-Cerezo M 5
1Janssen-Cilag Ltd, Dublin, Ireland, 2The Swedish Institute for Health Economics, Lund, Sweden,
3Janssen Global Services, LLC, Raritan, NJ, USA, 4Janssen-Cilag A/S, Birkerød, Denmark,
5Janssen-Cilag UK, High Wycombe, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Sulphonylureas (SU) and insulin are used routinely in the management of T2DM but are associated with weight gain and increased risk of hypoglycaemia. Canagliflozin is a new insulin-independent oral glucose lowering agent
with added benefits of weight loss, blood pressure reduction and no increased risk
of hypoglycaemia. This analysis estimated the cost-effectiveness of canagliflozin
compared to either SU or insulin in patients failing to achieve glycaemic control
on metformin monotherapy in Ireland. Methods: The Economic and Health
Outcomes Model of T2DM (ECHO-T2DM) was used to simulate the lifetime outcomes and costs associated with canagliflozin (100mg, titrated to 300mg as needed
to maintain glycaemic control) versus SU and versus insulin glargine. Patient
characteristics and treatment effects for the SU comparison were sourced from a
head-to-head randomized clinical trial vs. glimepiride. Hypoglycaemia rates were
halved to reflect gliclazide MR (the preferred SU in Ireland). Patient characteristics
for the insulin glargine comparison were obtained from the pooled canagliflozin add-on to metformin RCTs; treatment effects were sourced from a network
meta-analysis. Costs were localised and inflated to 2013 euros. Utilities were
sourced from the literature. Costs and outcomes were discounted at 5% annually. Results: The incremental costs, QALY gains and ICERs associated with
canagliflozin were € 2,404, 0.215 QALYs and € 11,191 per QALY gained, respectively,
versus SU and € 2,352, 0.228 QALYs and € 10,305 per QALY gained, respectively,
versus insulin glargine. Key drivers were decreased hypoglycaemia and lower
weight-related disutility versus both comparators, as well as better HbA 1c durability versus SU. In both cases, using an acceptable Irish willingness-to-pay threshold,
the probability of being cost-effective was in excess of 97%. Sensitivity analyses
support the robustness of these results. Conclusions: These simulations suggest that canagliflozin is a cost-effective treatment choice versus both gliclazide
MR and insulin glargine in patients failing to control glycaemia on metformin
alone.
PDB82
Cost Effectiveness Evaluation of Canagliflozin In Combination
With Metformin in the Treatment Of Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus In
Poland
Szmurlo D 1, Drzal R 1, Plisko R 1, Schubert A 2, Skrzekowska-Baran I 3
1HTA Consulting, Krakow, Poland, 2Janssen Cilag Poland, Warszawa, Poland, 3Janssen-Cilag
Polska, Warszawa, Poland
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of canagliflozin, an active inhibitor of sodium glucose co-transporter – 2 (SGLT2) in dual therapy as add-on to
metformin compared to sitagliptin and glimepiride. Canagliflozin in clinical trial
results showed effective glucose reduction, along with other benefits in diabetes
treatment including weight loss and SBP reduction. Cost effectiveness analyses
were conducted in the Polish setting from a public perspective in accordance with
guidelines of Polish HTA Agency (PolAHTA). Methods: The IMS CORE Diabetes
Model was used to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of canagliflozin versus the
aforementioned comparators using Polish-specific data, where available. Direct
costs were reported in Polish zloty and an annual discount rate of 5% and 3.5%
were applied on costs and effects respectively. Results: In dual therapy as add-on
to metformin, canagliflozin 100 mg dominates sitagliptin with average cost savings
of 2 811 zł and an average QALY gain of 0.06, canagliflozin 300 mg is cost effective
option in comparison to sitagliptin with an incremental cost effectiveness ratio
(ICER) of 45 008 zł per QALY and QALY gain of 0.09. As add-on to metformin canagliflozin is a cost effectiveness option in comparison with glimepiride with ICER
of 28 454 zł and 73 102 zł, QALY gain 0,112 QALY and 0,140 QALY for canagliflozin
100 mg and 300 mg respectively. All results are below defined in Polish reimbursement act cost-effectiveness threshold. Conclusions: These results suggest that
adding Canagliflozin to metformin versus sitagliptin or glimepiride in patients
inadequately controlled with metformin would be a more efficient use of health
care resources in the Polish setting.
PDB84
Cost-Effectiveness of Interventions Aimed at Decreasing The
Number of Amputations Among Patients With Diabetes Mellitus
Ignatyeva V 1, Avxentyeva M 1, Galstyan G R 2, Bregovskiy V 3, Udovichenko O 4
1The Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration, Moscow,
Russia, 2The Endocrinological Scientific Center, Moscow, Russia, 3Federal Almazov Medical
Research Center, St. Petersburg, Russia, 4Moscow Municipal outpatient clinic #22, Moscow, Russia
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of interventions aimed at decreasing the number of amputations among patients with diabetic foot ulcers (DFU) in
Russia. Methods: We have modeled the changes in the annual outcomes (minor
and major amputations) and costs (services provided in outpatient clinics and hospitals, medications, orthopedic shoes and prosthetic devices and services provided
in case of amputation) from the perspective of public health and social care. Two
interventions were assessed: preventive services for patients with the very high risk
of DFU (additional outpatient visits for foot care and orthopedic shoes) and provision of care for DFU patients at hospital by multidisciplinary foot care team (MDT).
The current number of amputations and costs among DFU patients in Russia was
assessed on the basis of published Russian data and experts’ survey. The expected
effectiveness of interventions was derived from the international publications. Costs
were estimated on the basis on reimbursement rates in public medical insurance
and social care. Results: The implementation of hospital care by MDT for cohort
of 1000 DFU patients at the current rate of hospitalizations will require additional
annual spending of € 532,520, and the expected annual number of major amputations will decrease by 41. The ICER for this intervention is € 12,988 per prevented
amputation, which is almost 2 times higher than the costs associated with major
amputation at the current moment. For the preventive services, if all patients are
compliant, additional costs per prevented amputation are slightly lower - € 10,216,
but also well above the costs of major amputation. Conclusions: Both interventions require considerable additional budget spending. Preventive measures, if all
the patients follow the recommendations, are more cost effective than introduction
of hospital MDT.
PDB85
The Cost-Effectiveness of Canagliflozin Compared With Liraglutide
in Patients With Type 2 Diabetes Inadequately Controlled With
Metformin and Sulfonylurea In France
Troelsgaard A 1, Pitcher A 2, Granados D 3, Hemels M 1, Lloyd A 2
1Janssen A/S, Birkerød, Denmark, 2IMS Health, London, UK, 3Janssen, Paris, France
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Canagliflozin is a sodium-glucose co-transporter 2 (SGLT2) inhibitor
used in treatment of patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM). The objective
is to estimate the cost-effectiveness of canagliflozin (100mg once daily and 300mg
once daily) compared with liraglutide in combination with metformin and sulfonylurea (SU) for the treatment of T2DM inadequately controlled with metformin and
SU in France. Methods: The IMS CORE Diabetes Model was used to project clinical
and economic outcomes for patients with T2DM treated with canagliflozin or liraglutide, each in combination with metformin and SU. Since direct trial data were not
available, the relative treatment effects on HbA1c, SBP and BMI for liraglutide 1.8mg
in combination with metformin and SU were derived from a network meta-analysis
(NMA) of treatment effects at 26 weeks. This study is limited by the absence of direct
or indirect data on the effect of liraglutide 1.2mg in combination with metformin
and SU, therefore the relative treatment effects on HbA1cand BMI at 26 weeks for
liraglutide 1.2mg were estimated using the dose-response relationship from a NMA
based on treatments in combination with metformin only. French market share
data were used to weight the results of liraglutide 1.8mg and 1.2mg. Results:
Canagliflozin 100mg showed cost savings when compared to treatment with liraglutide (1,388 € ); incremental QALYs were estimated as -0,035. Canagliflozin 300
mg was dominant, with cost savings of 1,411 € and relatively small incremental
QALY gain of 0.003. Conclusions: The analyses found that treatment of T2DM
with canagliflozin 100mg or 300mg instead of liraglutide as add on to metformin
A347
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
and SU would generate substantial cost savings in France. Canagliflozin 300mg
showed similar outcomes to liraglutide, suggesting that the treatments are similar
in effectiveness, and is thus likely to be a highly cost-effective treatment option.
PDB86
Layering Interventions for Type-2 Diabetes Prevention Using The
Sphr Diabetes Model
Thomas C 1, Watson P 1, Greaves C 2, Squires H 1, Chilcott J 1, Brennan A 1
of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK, 2University of Exeter, Exeter, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: We have developed a model to evaluate type-2 diabetes prevention
interventions. The model allows flexible layering of multiple interventions in order to
determine the optimal combination of strategies for maximal cost-effectiveness. Our
objective was to demonstrate the utility of the model for analysis of multiple interventions in different population sub-groups. Methods: A model of type-2 diabetes
prevention was developed using a micro-simulation framework. Individual patients
have simulated trajectories of metabolic factors such as BMI, HbA1c, systolic blood
pressure and total cholesterol, and can be diagnosed with diabetes, cardiovascular
disease, cancer, osteoarthritis or microvascular complications of diabetes over the
course of a lifetime. Interventions targeting metabolic factors influence the likelihood
of patients developing ill health and dying prematurely. Five interventions were chosen for layering analyses: soft drinks taxation; retail policy; a workplace intervention;
an educational intervention aimed at deprived individuals; and a diabetes screening
programme followed by intensive intervention for high risk individuals. Eight different intervention combinations were modelled, using the assumption of either
additive, synergistic or antagonistic effects in individuals subject to multiple interventions. Results: All interventions generated cost-savings and QALY gains, with the
screening intervention performing particularly well, followed by the soft drinks tax.
Combining interventions results in roughly additive effects; this holds whether the
layering is additive, synergistic or antagonistic due to the relatively low proportions
of individuals subject to multiple interventions. Certain pairs of interventions were
found to be almost as cost-effective as combining all five interventions, in particular,
a soft drinks tax combined with a screening programme is likely to be one of the most
cost-effective options. Conclusions: The SPHR Diabetes Model is a useful tool for
analysing the cost-effectiveness of different diabetes prevention interventions, either
singly or in combination. This will enable development of intervention strategies
tailored to the needs of the target population.
PDB87
Cost-Effectiveness of Dapagliflozin Versus Dpp-4 Inhibitors as
Monotherapy in the Treatment of Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus From A
Uk Health Care Perspective
Charokopou M 1, Vioix H 2, Verheggen B 1, Eddowes L A 3, Griffiths M 3, Gabriel Z 2, Tolley K 4,
Franks D 2
1Pharmerit International, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 2AstraZeneca UK Ltd., Luton, UK, 3Costello
Medical Consulting Ltd., Cambridge, UK, 4Tolley Health Economics Ltd., Buxton, Derbyshire, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To explore the cost-effectiveness of dapagliflozin, the first-in-class
sodium-glucose co-transporter-2 (SGLT-2) inhibitor, compared to the dipeptidyl
peptidase-4 inhibitor (DPP4i) class, as monotherapy for the treatment of type 2
diabetes mellitus (T2DM) that is inadequately controlled by diet and exercise alone
in patients who are intolerant to metformin. Methods: The validated CARDIFF
diabetes model was used. Clinical inputs for the model were sourced from a systematic review and network meta-analysis (NMA) in monotherapy. A UK health
care perspective was used for costs, and quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) were
calculated from utility data in the published literature. A range of assumptions to
reflect potential clinical practice were utilised. Alterations to the HbA1c switching
threshold and assumptions on weight extrapolation were considered, in order to
investigate the impact of different profiles of weight change and longer-term evidence for the maintenance of weight loss. The cost-effectiveness was reported as an
incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER). Results: When the model assumptions
were varied around the HbA1c switching threshold and around the profile of maintenance of weight loss to better reflect clinical practice, the ICER point estimates
ranged from £1,847 to £30,795. The lowest ICER point estimate was associated with
an assumption of maintaining the weight differential that is created at treatment
initiation, which is generated by the better weight profile of dapagliflozin compared
to DPP4i, over the whole time horizon. The highest estimate arose when the weight
differential was maintained for 2 years and there was a higher switching threshold
for initiating insulin. Conclusions: Dapagliflozin monotherapy has potential as
a cost-effective treatment option from a UK health care perspective for patients
with T2DM who are intolerant to metformin and are inadequately controlled by
diet and exercise alone, based upon a range of explored scenarios. This study also
demonstrates the value of performing scenario analysis to inform decision-making.
PDB88
Cost-Effectiveness of Dapagliflozin Compared To Dpp-4 Inhibitors
as Triple Therapy In Combination With Metformin and A
Sulphonylurea In The Treatment Of Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus From
A Uk Health Care Perspective
Charokopou M 1, Vioix H 2, Eddowes L A 3, Griffiths M 3, Verheggen B G 1, Gabriel Z 2, Tolley K 4
International, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 2AstraZeneca UK Ltd., Luton, UK, 3Costello
Medical Consulting Ltd., Cambridge, UK, 4Tolley Health Economics Ltd., Buxton, Derbyshire, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Pharmerit
Objectives: To assess the cost-effectiveness of dapagliflozin, the first-in-class
sodium-glucose co-transporter-2 (SGLT-2) inhibitor, compared to the dipeptidyl
peptidase-4 inhibitor (DPP4i) class, when used as triple oral therapy in combination with metformin and a sulphonylurea (met+SU) for the treatment of patients
with type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) who are inadequately controlled on met+SU
alone. Methods: The validated CARDIFF diabetes model was used. Clinical
inputs for the model were sourced from a systematic review and network metaanalysis (NMA) in triple therapy that found clinically relevant differences between
dapagliflozin and DPP4i’s. A UK health care perspective was used for costs, and
quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) were calculated from utility data sourced from
the published literature. The cost-effectiveness was reported as an incremental
cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER). To assess uncertainty, univariate deterministic and
multivariate probabilistic sensitivity analyses (PSA) were performed. Results:
Compared to the DPP4i class, dapagliflozin was associated with 0.023 incremental
QALYs (95% CI: -0.058, 0.105), at an additional cost of £253 (95% CI: -£302, £741). This
resulted in an ICER of £10,995 per QALY gained. The incremental cost associated with
dapagliflozin was primarily due to the additional drug acquisition cost, whereas the
QALY gain estimated was associated with superior weight reduction and its impact
on health-related quality of life for dapagliflozin relative to the DPP4i’s. Univariate
analyses demonstrated that the ICER was most sensitive to varying the weight
change parameter for the comparator DPP4i’s according to the 95% credible intervals
in the NMA, giving ICER estimates ranging from £3,937 to £16,727. Dapagliflozin
had a 59% probability of being cost-effective versus DPP4i’s at a willingness-topay threshold of £20,000 per QALY gained. Conclusions: Dapagliflozin as triple
therapy in combination with met+SU was shown to be a cost-effective treatment
option from a UK health care perspective for patients with T2DM who are inadequately controlled on met+SU.
PDB89
Cost-Effectiveness of Saxagliptin Compared To Glp-1 Analogues As
An Add-On To Insulin in the Treatment of Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus
From A Uk Health Care Perspective
Charokopou M 1, Vioix H 2, Verheggen B 1, Eddowes L A 3, Griffiths M 4, Gabriel Z 2, Tolley K 5,
Sibartie M 2
1Pharmerit International, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 2AstraZeneca UK Ltd., Luton, UK, 3Costello
Medical Consulting Ltd., Cambridge, UK, 4Costello Medical Consulting, Cambridge, UK,
5Tolley Health Economics Ltd., Buxton, Derbyshire, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess the cost-effectiveness of saxagliptin, a dipeptidyl peptidase-4 inhibitor (DPP4i), compared to the glucagon-like peptide-1 (GLP-1) analogues,
exenatide twice-daily or lixisenatide, when added to insulin (±metformin) for the
treatment of patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) who are inadequately
controlled on insulin. Methods: The validated CARDIFF diabetes model was used
to conduct the analyses. Clinical inputs for the model were sourced from a systematic review and network meta-analysis (NMA), which found that the treatments
were similarly effective at lowering HbA1c and that the GLP-1 analogues resulted
in greater and clinically relevant weight loss. A UK health care perspective was
used for costs, and quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) were calculated from utility data sourced from the published literature. To assess uncertainty, univariate
deterministic and multivariate probabilistic sensitivity analyses (PSA) were performed. Results: Saxagliptin was found to dominate lixisenatide in the base case,
being associated with lower costs (-£472 [95%CI: -1,378, -223]) and slightly more
QALYs (0.010 [95%CI: -0.040, 0.076]). Saxagliptin was less costly (-£1,402 [95%CI:
-£1,932, -£1,218]) and slightly less effective (-0.012 QALYs [95%CI: -0.054, 0.035]) than
exenatide twice-daily. The lower costs associated with saxagliptin were primarily
due to the lower drug acquisition costs. The estimated QALY differences were small
and associated with the impact of weight reduction on health-related quality of
life. Univariate sensitivity analyses demonstrated that the results were most sensitive to varying the HbA1c treatment effect and the effect of saxagliptin on weight
change. The PSA estimated that saxagliptin had a 70.4% and 34.3% probability of
being dominant, and a 99.4% and 100% probability of being cost-saving compared to
lixisenatide and exenatide twice-daily, respectively. Conclusions: Saxagliptin as
add-on to insulin was shown to be a cost-saving treatment option from a UK health
care perspective for patients with T2DM who are inadequately controlled on insulin.
PDB90
The Place of Dpp-4 Inhibitors in the Treatment Algorithm of
Diabetes Type 2: A Systematic Review of Cost-Effectiveness Studies
Baptista A 1, Teixeira I 1, Romano S 1, Vaz Carneiro A 2, Perelman J 3
of Health Research & Evaluation (CEFAR), National Association of Pharmacies (ANF),
Lisbon, Portugal, 2Center for Evidence Based Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, University of Lisbon,
Lisbon, Portugal, 3Escola Nacional de Saúde Pública, Universidade Nova de Lisboa, Lisboa,
Portugal
.
.
.
.
.
1Centre
Objectives: To conduct a systematic review of cost-effectiveness, cost-utility and
cost-benefit studies of new inhibitors of DPP-4 for diabetes treatment versus other
antidiabetics. Methods: We searched the CRD York, NICE Health Technology
Assessment, Tufts CEA Registry, and MEDLINE (PubMed) databases, and grey literature through 2014 to identify cost-effectiveness, cost-utility and cost-benefit studies
of new inhibitors of DPP-4 versus other antidiabetics for diabetes treatment. Three
investigators independently reviewed all potentially relevant titles and abstracts (1st
screening), and subsequently screened full-text articles (2nd screening), according to
pre-established inclusion criteria. We restricted our sample to studies with a lifetime
or near-lifetime horizon, and adopting either a societal or a health care perspective.
The studies should be available as a full-text publication and published in English,
French, Spanish, or Portuguese language. A critical appraisal of the methodology and
reporting was performed using the 35item version of the BMJ checklist. Results:
A total of 57 studies were identified. From these, 17 studies were accepted after the
1st screening, of which 11 were accepted after the 2nd screening. All selected studies
consisted in cost-utility analyses. Most studies were based on a single randomized
trial per therapy. Saxagliptin was assessed in 6 studies, Sitagliptin in 4, and vildagliptin in 1. Liraglutide was cost-effective versus sitagliptin as second line therapy
(ranged from 12,164 to 27,289€ /QALY across countries). Saxagliptin (ranged from
771 to 10,065 € /QALY across countries), Sitagliptin (ranged from 5,949 € /QALY to
20,350 € /QALY across countries) and vildagliptin (ICER of 9,072 € / QALY in Portugal)
were cost-effective versus sulfonylureas as second line therapy. Conclusions:
According to commonly accepted thresholds, there is consistent evidence about the
cost-effectiveness of DDP-4 inhibitors as second line therapy for diabetes type 2.
Though, more evidence (including head-to-head) is necessary to define which DDP-4
inhibitor is the most cost-effective.
A348
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PDB91
Systematic Review of Economic Evaluations of Dipeptidyl
Peptidase-4 Inhibitors for the Treatment of Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus
Lizán L 1, Aceituno S 1, Franch J 2, Pérez A 3, Granell M 4, Fuster E 4
Raval Sud- Institut Català de la Salut - USR Barcelona
ciutat - IDIAP Jordi Gol, Barcelona, Spain, 3Hospital de la Santa Creu I Sant Pau, Barcelona, Spain,
4Novartis Farmaceutica, Barcelona, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Outcomes’10, Castellon, Spain, 2EAP
Objectives: To synthesize and analyze the available information on the therapeutic value of dipeptidyl peptidase-4 inhibitors (DPP-4) for the treatment of type 2
diabetes mellitus (T2DM) from the point of view of their efficiency or cost-effectiveness. Methods: A systematic review of national (MEDES, IBECS) and international
(MedLine/PubMed, Cochrane Library, ISI WOK, SCOPUS) databases was performed.
Eligible studies were economic evaluations (cost-effectiveness, cost-utility and costbenefit analysis) comparing costs and clinical benefits of two alternatives for the
T2DM treatment including DPP-4 inhibitors, published in English or Spanish until
June 2013. Studies providing data concerning costs and/or disease burden only were
excluded. Results: Of 1,634 publications initially selected, 284 were excluded by
duplicate review, 1,330 by title/abstract review and 8 by criteria accomplishment. A
total of 12 publications [1 conducted in 6 countries including Spain, 4 in Europe, 4
in USA and 3 in others] were selected. All studies were cost-effectiveness or costutility analysis [discrete-event simulation (n= 8), Markov (n= 3) and others (n= 1)]
Time horizon ranged from one year (n= 1) to lifetime (n= 7), considering 20 years
(n= 1), 35 years (n= 2), and 40 years (n= 1). National Health System perspective was
adopted in all publications (n= 12). One study did not include a sensitivity analysis.
Results showed that T2DM therapy with DPP-4 inhibitors and metformin resulted
cost-effective compared with sulfonylureas plus metformin in all countries which
were evaluated (Sweden, UK, Germany, Portugal, Austria, Finland, Spain, USA and
Argentina). Although DPP-4 inhibitors cost was higher compared with sulfonylureas,
DPP-4 inhibitors plus metformin were associated to higher clinical benefits versus
sulfonylureas plus metformin in terms of decreasing hypoglycemia incidence and
T2DM complications. Conclusions: DPP-4 inhibitors added to metformin are a
cost-effective alternative compared with sulfonylureas plus metformin in T2DM
patients, mainly due to a lower hypoglycemia incidence and T2DM complications.
PDB92
Projection of Long Term Health-Economic Benefits of Sensor
Augmented Pump (Sap) Versus Pump Therapy Alone (Csii) In Type 1
Diabetes, A Uk Perspective
Roze S 1, Cook M 2, Jethwa M 2, de Portu S 3
1HEVA HEOR, Lyon, France, 2Medtronic UK, Watford, UK, 3Medtronic International Sàrl,
Tolochenaz, Switzerland
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The main objective of this study was to estimate the health-economic
impact of sensor augmented pump (SAP) compared to pump therapy alone (CSII) of
type 1 diabetes (T1DM) in the UK. Methods: The Core Diabetes Model was used
to project the incidence of diabetes-related complications over a lifetime horizon,
based on A) a published meta-analysis comparing SAP versus CSII, and B) a real
life observational study. The meta-analysis showed that for the analysed cohort of
T1DM with average baseline HbA1c of 10%, every day use of SAP led to a reduction
of -1.49% versus -0.62% HbA1c, for CGM and CSII respectively. The mean baseline
age of the simulated cohort was 27 years, with a mean duration of diabetes of 13
years. SAP effects also included a decrease in the annual rate of major hypoglycaemic events from 2.2 events per 100 patients’ month for CSII to 0. The quality of life
was adjusted for a reduced fear of hypoglycaemic event in the SAP arm. Sensitivity
analyses were carried out on several key parameters. Results: The incremental
cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) was 16,986 GBP (£) per Quality Adjusted Life Year
gained (QALY). The improvement in discounted QALY was 3.1 years in favour of SAP.
Additional SAP related costs were partially offset by the savings due to the reduction
in diabetes related complications and the lower frequency of SMBG tests. Remaining
extra costs due to SAP were on average 1,143£ per year. When a societal perspective
was considered, ICER was reduced to 8,462 £ per QALY. Conclusions: Projection
of the improvement in HbA1c of SAP versus CSII translated into cost-effective ratio,
generally considered as very good value for money in the UK. Extensive sensitivity
analysis on key drivers confirmed the robustness of results under a wide range of
assumptions.
PDB93
Projection of Long Term Health Economic Benefits of Sensor
Augmented Pump (Sap) Versus Pump Therapy Alone (Csii) In
Uncontrolled Type 1 Diabetes In France
Roze S 1, Payet V 2, Debroucker F 2, de Portu S 3, Cucherat M 4
HEOR, Lyon, France, 2Medtronic France SAS, Boulogne-Billancourt, France, 3Medtronic
International Sàrl, Tolochenaz, Switzerland, 4UMR CNRS 5558, Faculté de Médecine Laennec,
Lyon, France
.
.
.
.
.
reduction in diabetes related complications and the lower frequency of SMBG
tests. Remaining extra annual costs for SAP were 1,258 € per patient. When indirect
costs were considered, the ICER was reduced to 23,300 € per QALY. Conclusions:
Using a well-accepted simulation model in an uncontrolled T1DM, projection of
the improvement in HbA1c of SAP versus CSII translated into cost-effective ratio,
generally considered as very good value for money in France. Extensive sensitivity
analysis on key drivers confirmed the robustness of results under a wide range
of assumptions.
PDB94
Cost-Effectiveness of A Short Message Service (Sms) Intervention
To Prevent Type 2 Diabetes Among Adults With Impaired Glucose
Tolerance
Wong C K H 1, Jiao F F 1, Siu S C 2, Fung C S C 1, Wong K W 2, Lam C L K 1
1The University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong Island, Hong Kong, 2Tung Wah Eastern Hospital, Hong
Kong Island, Hong Kong
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To investigate the costs and cost-effectiveness of a short message
service (SMS) intervention to prevent the onset of type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM)
in subjects with impaired glucose tolerance (IGT). Methods: A Markov model was
developed to simulate the cost and effectiveness outcomes of the SMS intervention and usual clinical practice from the health service provider’s perspective. The
annual transition probabilities between health states were taken from several
data sources, including Diabetes Prevention Program and Diabetes Prevention
Program Outcome Study. The direct program costs and the two-year SMS intervention costs were evaluated in subjects with IGT. All costs were expressed in year
2011 U.S. dollars. The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio were calculated as cost
per T2DM onset prevented, cost per life year gained and cost per quality adjusted
life year (QALY) gained. Both base-case scenario and sensitivity analysis were
conducted. Results: Within the two-year trial period, the net intervention cost
of the SMS group was $42.03 per subject. The SMS intervention managed to reduce
5.05% onset of diabetes, resulting in saving $118.39 per subject over two years.
In the lifetime model, the SMS intervention dominated the control by gaining
an additional 0.071 QALY and saving $1020.35 per person. The SMS intervention remained dominance in all sensitivity analyses. Conclusions: This study
revealed that the SMS intervention for subjects with IGT had the superiority of
lower monetary cost and a considerable improvement in preventing or delaying
the T2DM onset.
PDB95
Cost-Minimisation Analysis of Dapagliflozin Compared To
Lixisenatide As An Add-On To Insulin In The Treatment of Type 2
Diabetes Mellitus From A Uk Health Care Perspective
Vioix H 1, Eddowes L A 2, Griffiths M 2, Gabriel Z 1
1AstraZeneca UK Ltd., Luton, UK, 2Costello Medical Consulting Ltd., Cambridge, UK
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate the cost of using the first-in-class sodium-glucose cotransporter-2 (SGLT-2) inhibitor dapagliflozin compared to the glucagon-like peptide-1 (GLP-1) analogue lixisenatide, when added to insulin for the treatment of
patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) who are inadequately controlled on
insulin alone. Methods: Bucher indirect comparisons and a network meta-analysis were performed in the add-on to insulin population with regards to the key T2DM
outcomes of HbA1c, weight and hypoglycaemia. Dapagliflozin had similar treatment effects to lixisenatide, with no statistically significant differences between
dapagliflozin and lixisenatide in these outcomes. Therefore, a cost-minimisation
analysis over a 1-year time horizon was developed from a UK health care perspective. Drug and administration costs, including a nurse consultation, were considered
in the model. Drug costs were those of the British National Formulary (September
2013), device costs were taken from the Information Services Division Drug Tariff
2013 and the cost of a nurse consultation was estimated using the Unit Costs of
Health and Social Care report compiled by the Personal Social Services Research
Unit. The application of an annual discount rate of 3.5% and use of a longer time
horizon (up to 5 years) were explored in scenario analyses. Results: Dapagliflozin
was associated with a yearly cost of £476.96 per patient. The cost per patient for
lixisenatide was £765.76 in the first year and £752.07 in subsequent years. Therefore,
dapagliflozin was cost-saving compared to lixisenatide, driven by the difference
in drug and administration costs. Applying the annual discount rate and using a
longer time horizon, dapagliflozin was associated with savings of £1,255.30 over 5
years compared to lixisenatide. Conclusions: Dapagliflozin in combination with
insulin was shown to be a cost-saving treatment option compared to lixisenatide
from a UK health care perspective for patients with T2DM who are inadequately
controlled on insulin alone.
1HEVA
Objectives: The main objective of this study was to estimate the health-economic
impact of sensor augmented pump (SAP) compared to pump therapy alone (CSII)
in uncontrolled type 1 diabetes (T1DM) in France. Methods: The Core Diabetes
Model was used to project the incidence of diabetes-related complications over
a lifetime horizon, based on a recently performed meta-analysis comparing SAP
versus CSII. The meta-analysis showed that for the analysed cohort of T1DM using
exclusively Medtronic devices with average baseline HbA1c of 9%, 70% use of SAP
led to a reduction of -0.88% versus -0.47% HbA1c, for SAP and CSII respectively.
The mean baseline age of the simulated cohort was, according to a French typical TD1M population, 36 years, with a mean duration of diabetes of 17 years. The
quality of life was adjusted for a reduced fear of hypoglycaemic event in the SAP
arm. Sensitivity analyses were carried out on several key parameters. Results:
The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) was 27,796 € per Quality Adjusted
Life Year gained (QALY). The improvement in discounted QALY was 1.27 years in
favour of SAP. Undiscounted life expectancy was increased by 1 year for SAP versus
CSII. Additional SAP related costs were partially offset by the savings due to the
PDB96
Economic Evaluation of Lanreotide Autogel in the Management of
Acromegaly in Greece
Kousoulakou H 1, Panayiotou-Pazaitou K 2, Pantazi E 3, Tsentidis C 4, Tzanela M 5, Vryonidou
A 6, Markussis V 7, Eleftheriou C 7, Geitona M 1
of Peloponnese, Corinth, Greece, 2Theageneion Anticancer Hospital, Thessaloniki,
Greece, 3Alexandra Hospital, Athens, Greece, 4Nikaia Hospital, Nikaia, Greece, 5Evangelismos
Hospital, Athens, Greece, 6Red Cross Hospital, Athens, Greece, 7Ipsen, Athens, Greece
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: Acromegaly is a chronic and debilitating disease, which can lead
to significant increases in health care costs. The objective of the present study
was to undertake an economic evaluation of Lanreotide Autogel compared with
Octreotide LAR in the management of acromegaly in the Greek health care setting. Methods: A cost minimization model was developed for the analysis which
only considers the costs of treatment, as the two drugs have equal efficacy. The
time horizon was 30 years; future costs were discounted at 3.5%. In addition,
a budget impact analysis was conducted, with a time horizon of 5 years. The
perspective for both analyses was that of Social Insurance. Data on resource use
(administration setting, drug wastage and time required for the administration of
A349
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
each drug), as well as lab and imaging tests, were collected with the Delphi technique via an expert panel with 11 experienced endocrinologists, from University
and Public Hospital specialized units. Local unit cost data were collected from
officially published sources (Ministry of Health and Social Insurance Funds). One
way sensitivity analyses were performed to test the results. Results: Lanreotide
Autogel reduced total costs of acromegaly treatment by € 29,896 per patient over
the 30-year time horizon. 93% of the savings were attributed to the reduction in
drug acquisition and administration costs. Discount rate was the most influential
parameter in the sensitivity analysis. The total cost of managing acromegaly in
Greece, including lab and imaging tests, over a 5-year time horizon was estimated
to range between € 22.9 and € 22.2 million, with a 30% and 60% market share for
Lanreotide Autogel, respectively. Therefore, doubling Lanreotide Autogel’s share
would lead to total savings of € 781,604. Conclusions: Lanreotide Autogel in
comparison with Octreotide LAR may result in a reduction of the total cost in the
management of acromegaly in Greece.
PDB97
The Opportunity of Treating Type Ii Diabetes With Dpp4i: An Economic
Evaluation VersUS Conventional Treatment in the Italian Setting
Lorenzoni V , Pierotti F , Turchetti G
Scuola Superiore Sant’Anna, Pisa, Italy
.
.
.
Objectives: To compare dipeptdyl-peptidase 4 inhibitors (DPP4i) and sulfonylurea
(SU) for the treatment of type II diabetes mellitus in terms of economic impact and
considering both the Italian National Health System (NHS) and the societal perspective. Methods: The economic evaluation was performed as a model-based costminimization analysis for the comparison DPP4i and SU as second line therapy, in
add-on to metformin, over 1-year period. Clinical events to be included in the model
were selected from literature review and the opinion of a panel of clinical experts.
Resources used were quantified and valued adopting costs and tariffs related to
drugs used, glycaemic auto-monitoring, established control visits, incidence of
hypoglicaemic events, macrovascular complications and the switch to insulin
therapy. One-way sensitivity analyses for model inputs were conducted. Results:
Due to the higher cost for drug acquisition in the base case analysis total direct costs
for the Italian NHS were about 728 Euro per patient/year in the case of DPP4i and
on average 702 Euro for SU. The overall yearly cost for the society was estimated to
be about 728 Euro per patient in the case of DPP4i while it was on average 770 Euro
when considering SU because DPP4i induced lower direct non-health costs related
to stroke and an overall saving of 20.88 Euro per patient/year due to lower costs
of productivity loss for hypoglicaemic events and stroke. Conclusions: The use
of DPP4i was cost-saving from the societal perspective and just the high cost for drug
acquistion made the adoption of DPP4i more costly than SU for the Italian NHS. This
result outlined that DPP4i represents a valuable alternative for the management of
diabetes both from a clinical and economic perspective and costs will be lowered
overall just intervening on cost for drug acquisition.
PDB98
Cost-Minimisation Analysis of Saxagliptin Compared to Sitagliptin
And Linagliptin As Triple Therapy In Combination With Metformin
And A Sulphonylurea In The Treatment Of Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus
From A Uk Health Care Perspective
Vioix H 1, Eddowes L A 2, Griffiths M 2, Gabriel Z 1
1AstraZeneca UK Ltd., Luton, UK, 2Costello Medical Consulting Ltd., Cambridge, UK
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate the cost of using the dipeptidyl peptidase-4 inhibitor
(DPP4i), saxagliptin, compared to sitagliptin and linagliptin, when used as triple
therapy in combination with metformin and sulphonylurea (met+SU) for the
treatment of patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) who are inadequately
controlled on met+SU alone. Methods: Bucher adjusted indirect treatment comparisons (ITCs) were performed with regards to the key T2DM outcomes of HbA1c,
weight and hypoglycaemia compared to sitagliptin and linagliptin. The ITCs found
no statistically significant differences between saxagliptin compared to either sitagliptin or linagliptin in terms of effectiveness (as measured by Hb1Ac change from
baseline), and saxagliptin was found to be at least as safe as the other therapies.
Therefore, a cost-minimisation analysis over a 1-year time horizon was developed
from a UK health care perspective. Drug costs were considered in the model, sourced
from the British National Formulary (BNF; September 2013). The application of an
annual discount rate of 3.5% and use of a longer time horizon (up to 5 years) were
explored in a scenario analysis. Results: Saxagliptin was associated with a yearly
cost of £410.80 per patient. The yearly cost per patient for sitagliptin was £432.38,
and the yearly cost per patient for linagliptin was also £432.38, based on drug costs.
Therefore, saxagliptin has similar costs compared to the other DPP4i’s. Applying the
annual discount rate and using a longer time horizon, saxagliptin was associated
with cost-savings of £97.43 per patient over 5 years compared to both sitagliptin
and linagliptin. Conclusions: Saxagliptin as triple therapy in combination with
met+SU was shown to be a cost-saving treatment option from a UK health care
perspective for patients with T2DM who are inadequately controlled on met+SU
alone. The cost-saving per patient over 5 years was modest, although this may be
important in a large patient population.
PDB99
Cost-Effectiveness of Sitagliptin Versus Sulfonylurea As An Add-On
Therapy To Metformin In Patients With Type 2 Diabetes In A Belgium
Setting
Chen J 1, Radican L 2, Shankar R 2, Hiver M 3, Qiu Y 2
1Merck Research Laboratories, North Wales, PA, USA, 2Merck Sharp & Dohme Corp., Whitehouse
Station, NJ, USA, 3MSD Belgium BVBA, Brussels, Belgium
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Assess the cost-effectiveness of sitagliptin versus sulfonylurea as
an add-on therapy to metformin among type 2 diabetes patients currently on
metformin but not achieving HbA1c goal in Belgium. Methods: We employed
a previously published individual-level simulation model that incorporated risk
equations/algorithms from the UKPDS Outcomes Model (68) to predict the long
term risks of type 2 diabetes-related complications. The impact of treatments
on risk factors and side effects was based on clinical trials, observational studies, systematic reviews and meta-analyses of relevant RCTs, as well as the most
recent findings on the potential benefit of DPP4 on other-cause mortality and
cardiovascular diseases and the possible detrimental effect of sulfonylurea on
myocardial infarction (MI). European patient profiles and Belgium-specific data
on drug prices, diabetes-related complication treatment costs, treatment patterns
and guidelines were used. Results: A sitagliptin-based treatment strategy was
projected to cost € 1,102 more than a sulfonylurea-based treatment strategy per
patient lifetime, with the majority of excess costs from prescription drugs. Life
expectancy was 0.077 years greater per patient on a sitagliptin-based strategy
compared to a sulfonylurea-based strategy. The discounted gain in QALY was 0.082
years with the sitagliptin-based strategy, driven by better hypoglycemia, weight,
and MI risk profile. The estimated ICER was € 13,460/QALY. Sensitivity analyses
demonstrated that the ICER was somewhat sensitive to the price of sulfonylureas
and the weight utility decrement, and most sensitive to assumptions on relative
risk parameters. When no relative risk reduction on MI or other-cause mortality
was assumed, the ICER was € 17,543/QALY and € 17,053/QALY, respectively. When
no relative risk reduction on either MI or other-cause mortality was assumed, the
ICER increased to € 23,691/QALY. Conclusions: Using a threshold of € 15,000 per
QALY gained, compared to a sulfonylurea-based treatment strategy, a sitagliptinbased treatment strategy was cost-effective in metformin-failed patients with
type 2 diabetes in Belgium.
PDB100
Cost-Effectiveness of Exenatide Twice Daily (Bid) Added To Basal
Insulin Compared To A Bolus Insulin Add-On In Turkey
Malhan S 1, Güler S 2, Yetkin I 3, Baeten S 4, Verheggen B 4
University, Ankara, Turkey, 2Hitit University, Faculty of Medicine, Çorum, Turkey,
3Gazi University, Faculty of Medicine, Ankara, Turkey, 4Pharmerit International, Rotterdam, The
Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
1Baskent
Objectives: Type 2 diabetes (T2D) patients on basal insulin with uncontrolled
HbA1c levels often receive an add-on with bolus insulin to lower HbA1c levels.
The aim of this analysis is to estimate long-term cost-effectiveness of treating
T2D patients with – a recently introduced – twice daily (BID) exenatide add-on to
basal insulin strategy from a Turkish health care perspective. Methods: Clinical
inputs for both treatment strategies were taken from the GWDM clinical trial. The
strategies were assessed using a micro-simulation disease model (CARDIFF). The
model predicted micro-and macro-vascular complications based on the UKPDS
equations. The incidence of adverse events, diabetes related complications and
changes in body weight yielded estimates of health care costs and health utilities.
The direct (T2D and complication) costs in the model reflect the Social Security
Institution costs. Discounting both costs and effects at 3% over the 40 year followup of the model, resulted in life time estimates of costs and quality-adjusted life
years (QALYs) on both treatment strategies. Deterministic and probabilistic sensitivity analyses, as well as elaborate scenario analyses were performed. Results:
Results showed that exenatide treatment significantly improves QALYs by 0.60 (95%
CI: 0.24 to 0.97). Health effects were reached at an additional cost of 217 $ (95% CI:
-356$ to 976$), resulting in an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio of 362 $ per QALY
gained. Scenario analyses showed that these results were robust to changes in
input parameters. At a willingness-to-pay threshold of 30,000 $/QALY the exenatide
strategy had a near 100% probability of being cost-effective compared to bolus insulin. Conclusions: A twice daily exenatide add-on to basal insulin treatment for
T2DM patients with uncontrolled HbA1c levels is considered a highly cost-effective
strategy from the Turkish public health care perspective.
PDB101
Comparative Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Adding Twice-Daily
Exenatide To Insulin Glargine Versus Adding Insulin Lispro To Treat
Type 2 Diabetes In Spain
Sánchez-Covisa J 1, Capel M 1, Baeten S 2, Verheggen B G 2
International, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
1AstraZeneca, Madrid, Spain, 2Pharmerit
Objectives: When HbA1c is elevated above target in Type 2 diabetes (T2D) patients
treated with basal insulin, the widespread strategy consists of adding mealtime
insulin. An alternative option is adding twice-daily exenatide (BID), a glucagon-like
peptide-1 receptor agonist. The objective was to estimate the cost-effectiveness in
Spain of exenatide BID compared to mealtime bolus insulin lispro, both added to
insulin glargine and metformin. Methods: The published and validated CARDIFF
long-term diabetes model was used to estimate the direct medical costs and qualityadjusted life years (QALYs) associated with each strategy. Patient characteristics at
baseline, efficacy and safety inputs were all derived from a head-to-head, doubleblind, randomized controlled trial (NCT00960661), comparing both strategies for
30 weeks. Based on the United Kingdom Prospective Diabetes Study-68 equations,
the model predicted long-term disease progression and occurrence of microand macro-vascular complications, including mortality. Costs and utilities were
assigned to complications, hypoglycaemias, adverse events and body mass index
changes. The analyses were performed from the perspective of the Spanish health
care payer, over a lifetime horizon, at a discount rate of 3% (costs and health outcomes). Univariate and probabilistic sensitivity analyses were conducted. Results:
Treatment with exenatide BID was projected to produce an incremental benefit of
0.61 QALYs (95 % CI: 0.26 to 0.99) compared to treatment with insulin lispro, at an
additional cost of € 146 (95% CI: -€ 1,114 to € 1,679) resulting in an incremental costeffectiveness ratio of € 239 per QALY gained. The exenatide BID strategy reached a
probability near 100% of being cost-effective at a willingness-to-pay threshold of
€2,500 per QALY gained. Sensitivity analyses showed that results were robust to variation in range of model parameters. Conclusions: Exenatide BID was predicted
to be a cost-effective treatment alternative to mealtime bolus insulin in Spain for
T2D patients not at target with insulin glargine.
A350
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PDB102
Retrospective analysis of the economic burden among cushing’s
disease patients in the u.S. Medicaid program
Li L 1, Shrestha S 1, Baser O 2, Wang L 1
Research, Plano, TX, USA, 2STATinMED Research and The University of Michigan,
Ann Arbor, MI, USA
.
.
.
.
1STATinMED
Objectives: To evaluate the economic burden among patients diagnosed with
Cushing’s disease (CD) in the U.S. Medicaid program. Methods: Patients diagnosed
with CD (International Classification of Disease, 9thRevision, Clinical Modification
(ICD-9-CM) diagnosis code 255.0) were identified using U.S. Medicaid data from 01
January 2008 through 31 December 2010. The initial diagnosis date was designated
as the index date. A matching comparator cohort was created including patients of
the same age, race and gender but without a CD diagnosis, and a randomly-chosen
index date to minimize selection bias. Patients in both cohorts were required to be
age ≥18 years, with continuous medical and pharmacy benefits for 1 year pre- and
1 year post-index date. One-to-one propensity score matching (PSM) was used to
compare health care costs and utilizations during the follow-up period between the
diseased and comparison cohorts, and was adjusted for baseline demographic and
clinical characteristics. Results: After risk adjustment by PSM, a total of 340 patients
in each cohort were matched. CD patients had significantly higher health care utilization, including inpatient admissions (36.18% vs. 12.53%, p< 0.0001) and long-term
care (5.29% vs. 2.06%, p<0.05), other service (100% vs. 94.12%, p<0.0001) and pharmacy
visits (84.41% vs. 78.24%, p<0.05), compared to those without the disease. CD patients
incurred significantly higher inpatient ($4,688 vs. $1,139, p<0.05) and pharmacy costs
($4,054 vs. $2,100, p<0.001) compared to those without CD. Long-term care and other
service costs incurred were higher for CD patients, compared to comparison patients,
but were not statistically significant. Conclusions: In the current study, CD patients
in the U.S. Medicaid program had a higher burden of illness in terms of health care
resource utilization and costs, compared to those without a CD diagnosis.
PDB103
The Potential Value of Ongoing Support In Type-1 Diabetes Mellitus
With Dafneplus: Exploratory Pre-Trial Cost-Effectiveness
Analysis On Proposed Trial End-Point Target For 12-Month Hba1c
Improvement
Basarir H , Pollard D , Brennan A , Elliott J , Heller S , Campbell M J
University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The Dose Adjustment For Normal Eating (DAFNE) structured education
programme is shown to be effective both in terms of clinical outcomes and costeffectiveness outcomes in the treatment of T1DM. DAFNEPlus aims to revise the
DAFNE 5-day curriculum based on psychological and sociological findings in DAFNE,
input from DAFNE graduates and emerging knowledge around behavioural science
and technological developments. The current suggested primary endpoint is for the
DAFNEplus programme to have an additional 20% DAFNE participants (70% in total)
achieve either, (a) a reduction of at least 0.5% in HbA1c, or (b) to have an HbA1c below
7.5% (58.5 mmol/mol), at 12 months. This paper undertakes pre-trial what-if costeffectiveness analyses concerning the DAFNEPlus programme, which aim to be useful both in the design of the intervention itself and of the proposed trial. Methods:
The Sheffield Type 1 Diabetes Policy Model is an individual patient-level simulation
model of T1DM. It includes long-term microvascular (retinopathy, neuropathy and
nephropathy) and macrovascular (myocardial infarction, stroke, revascularization
and angina) diabetes-related complications and acute adverse events (severe hypoglycaemia and diabetic ketoacidosis). Econometric methods were used to obtain
the target level of HbA1c responders in the DAFNEPlus arm. Results: DAFNEplus
would be considered as cost-effective if the additional spending on the intervention
would be limited to £455-£751 per patient per year, depending on the assumptions
on the length of maintenance period for the HbA1c benefit and the target HbA1c
responder endpoint (70% in total) being achieved in the future trial. To achieve a
more favourable cost-effectiveness probability of 80%, for example, the additional
per patient per year cost should be restricted to £393-£574 range. Conclusions:
Pre-trial modelling has enabled a clear understanding of the threshold range for the
annual cost of DAFNEplus, which is still being designed, in order to be considered
as cost-effective at the £20,000/QALY threshold.
PDB104
The Cost-Effectiveness Of Saxagliptin When Added To Metformin
And Sulphonylurea In The Treatment Of Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus In
Spain
Sánchez-Covisa J 1, Franch J 2, Mauricio D 3, López-Martínez N 4, Chuang L H 5, Capel M 1
Raval Sud- Institut Català de la Salut - USR Barcelona ciutat IDIAP Jordi Gol, Barcelona, Spain, 3Germans Trias i Pujol University Hospital, Barcelona, Spain,
4Oblikue Consulting, Barcelona, Spain, 5Pharmerit International, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1AstraZeneca, Madrid, Spain, 2EAP
Objectives: In patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM), when blood glucose
is not adequately controlled by the combination of metformin (MET) and sulphonylurea (SU), the clinician has to choose between adding a third oral drug or starting
insulin therapy. The objective of this study was to assess the cost-effectiveness in the
Spanish setting of adding saxagliptin (SAXA) to MET and SU, compared to adding basal
insulin (INS). Additionally, the SAXA strategy was compared with a thiazolidinedione
(TZD), also added on top of MET and SU. Methods: The published and validated
CARDIFF long-term diabetes model was used to estimate the direct medical costs and
quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) associated with each strategy. Clinical inputs were
obtained from a network meta-analysis. Based on the United Kingdom Prospective
Diabetes Study equations, the model predicted disease progression and occurrence
of micro- and macro-vascular complications, including mortality. Costs and utilities
were applied to complications, hypoglycaemias and body mass index changes. The
perspective of the Spanish Healthcare System was adopted over a lifetime horizon,
at a discount rate of 3% (costs and health outcomes). Univariate and probabilistic
sensitivity analyses were conducted. Results: SAXA add-on to MET plus SU resulted
in a dominant strategy compared to INS add-on to MET plus SU, providing a gain of
0.377 QALYs (95% CI: -0.227 to 0.754) and cost savings of € 264 (95% CI: -€ 1,879 to €
2,768).. At a willingness-to-pay threshold of €30,000 per QALY gained, SAXA strategy
had an 82% probability to be cost-effective. Compared to TZD add-on to MET plus SU,
the triple therapy with SAXA reached an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio of € 2,610
per QALY gained. Conclusions: Saxagliptin was predicted to be a cost-effective
option in Spain when a new drug needs to be added in T2DM patients inadequately
controlled with metformin and sulphonylurea alone.
PDB105
The Cost-Effectiveness of Dapagliflozin In Combination With
Insulin for the Treatment of Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus (T2dm) In Spain
Sánchez-Covisa J 1, Capel M 1, Schmidt R 2, Charokopou M 2, Verheggen B G 2
International, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
1AstraZeneca, Madrid, Spain, 2Pharmerit
Objectives: To assess the cost-effectiveness of dapagliflozin, a sodium-glucose
co-transporter-2 (SGLT-2) inhibitor versus dipeptidyl peptidase-4 inhibitor (DPP4i)
both added on top of insulin, or compared to insulin alone (±oral anti-diabetes
agents) for patients who are inadequately controlled on insulin strategy. Methods:
The CARDIFF diabetes model was used. Clinical inputs were derived from a randomized clinical trial comparing dapagliflozin add-on to insulin with insulin alone,
and network-meta-analysis for the comparison with DPP4i. Together with United
Kingdom Prospective Diabetes Study (UKPDS) equations, the model predicts disease
progression and the number of micro- and macro-vascular complications, along
with diabetes-specific and all-cause mortality. The perspective of the Spanish health
care payer was adopted over a lifetime horizon. Costs and utilities were assigned
to the appropriate model parameters to calculate total Quality-Adjusted-Life-Years
(QALYs) and total costs. Deterministic and probabilistic sensitivity analyses were
conducted. Results: Compared to insulin alone, dapagliflozin added to insulin was
associated with 0.698 incremental QALYs (95%CI: 0.442; 1.211) at an additional cost
of € 1,508 (95%CI: € 611; € 1,517), resulting in an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio
(ICER) point estimate of € 2,159/QALY. Dapagliflozin was found to dominate DPP4i
add-on to insulin, being associated with slightly less costs (-€51; 95%CI: -€ 913; € 553)
and higher QALYs (0.168; 95%CI: -0.007; 0.417). At a willingness-to-pay threshold of
€ 20,000/QALY, the dapagliflozin strategy was estimated to have a 100% probability
of being cost-effective when compared to the insulin alone, and a 98% probability
when compared to the DPP4i strategy. These findings were shown to be robust to
variation in range of model parameters. Conclusions: Dapagliflozin added on
top of Insulin was predicted to be a cost-effective (vs. insulin alone) and cost saving (vs DPP4i) alternative in Spain in combination with insulin for patients who are
inadequately controlled with insulin treatment regimens.
PDB106
The Cost-Effectiveness of Tolvaptan for the Treatment of
Hyponatraemia Secondary To Syndrome Of Inappropriate
Antidiuretic Hormone Secretion in Sweden
Trueman D 1, Robinson P 2, Dale P 2, O’Reilly K 2, Lundberg J 3, Jamookeeah C 2
1Decision Resources Group, London, UK, 2Otsuka Pharmaceutical Europe Ltd, Wexham, UK,
3Otsuka Pharma Scandinavia, Stockholm, Sweden
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Tolvaptan is a selective vasopressin V2-receptor antagonist indicated
for the treatment of adult patients with hyponatraemia (HN) secondary to syndrome
of inappropriate antidiuretic hormone secretion (SIADH). To date there have been
no published economic evaluations assessing the cost effectiveness of tolvaptan
in this indication. The aim of this study was to evaluate the cost effectiveness
of tolvaptan versus no active treatment (NAT) from a Swedish societal perspective. Methods: The economic evaluation considers a hypothetical population of
individuals with HN secondary to SIADH who have either failed to respond to fluid
restriction or for whom the use of fluid restriction is not suitable. The analysis considers three clinically relevant patient populations within the SIADH indication: ‘all
SIADH’, small-cell lung cancer (SCLC) and pneumonia. A discrete event simulation
was developed to model the progression of individuals through multiple inpatient
admissions over a 30 day time horizon (180 days in the SCLC scenario). Key sources
of evidence included randomised controlled trials (SALT I & II) and observational
data sources. Unit costs were collected from publicly available sources. Utility values
were obtained from mapping the SF-12 scores from the SALT I & II trials to EQ-5D.
The primary outcome of the analysis was the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio
(ICER) expressed as a cost per quality-adjusted life-year (QALY). Results: In the
‘all SIADH’ population tolvaptan was associated with reduced costs (SEK 5,778) and
increased QALYs (0.0019) versus NAT and was therefore dominant. In the SCLC and
pneumonia subgroups tolvaptan was also associated with reduced costs and QALY
improvements. The results were most sensitive to the duration of tolvaptan treatment and the assumptions around duration of hospitalisation. Conclusions: In
all populations considered (all SIADH, SCLC and pneumonia) tolvaptan was dominant compared to NAT being associated with reduced costs and increased QALYs.
PDB107
Cost-Effectiveness of Empagliflozin (Jardiance®) 10 Mg And 25
Mg Administered As An Add-on To Metformin Compared To Other
Sodium-Glucose Co-Transporter 2 Inhibitors (Sglt2is) for Patients
With Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus (T2dm) In The UK
Aguiar-Ibáñez R 1, Palencia R 2, Kandaswamy P 3, Li L 1
1Amaris Consulting UK, London, UK, 2Boehringer Ingelheim GmbH, Ingelheim am Rhein, Germany,
3Boehringer Ingelheim UK, Bracknell, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess the cost-effectiveness of the novel SGLT2is empagliflozin 10mg
and 25mg compared to other SGLT2is (canagliflozin 100mg, canagliflozin 300mg, and
dapagliflozin 10mg) when administered as an add-on to metformin for the treatment of patients with T2DM in the UK. Methods: A micro-simulation model was
developed, based on the United Kingdom Prospective Diabetes Study (UKPDS68) and
the Januvia Diabetes Economic (JADE) model, to estimate long-term diabetes-related
complications, QALYs and costs in a cohort of T2DM patients initiating dual therapy.
The model was populated with the results of a network meta-analysis that estimated
A351
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
the comparative efficacy and safety across SGLT2is. Data gaps were completed with
information derived from published sources, including previous cost-effectiveness
analyses. The UK National Health Service (NHS) perspective was considered to estimate costs and QALYs over a patients’ lifetime. Results: There were small differences in efficacy and safety across SGLT2is, which resulted in minor QALY and cost
differences across treatment combinations. On average, empagliflozin 25mg obtained
incremental QALYs of 0.029 versus dapagliflozin 10mg and 0.019 versus canagliflozin
100mg, and incremental costs of £178 and £86, respectively, whereas both canagliflozin 300mg and empagliflozin 10mg were dominated by empagliflozin 25mg. This
resulted in an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of £4,858 per QALY gained
with empagliflozin 25mg vs. canagliflozin 100mg. However, the differences across
treatments were not significant when 95% percentile confidence intervals were
considered. These results were robust to a number of sensitivity analyses including
a 10-year time horizon, BMI impact, discount rates and parameter values related
to utilities, disutilities, adverse events, and discontinuation rates. Conclusions:
Overall, differences in QALYs and costs were minor between SGLT2is used as add-on
to metformin in UK T2DM patients. On average, empagliflozin 25mg was the most
cost-effective strategy, with an ICER of £4,858 per QALY gained vs. canagliflozin 100mg.
PDB108
Cost Effectiveness Analysis of Flash Glucose Monitoring for Type 2
Diabetes Patients Receiving Insulin Treatment In The Uk
Li H 1, Bilir S P 2, Donga P 3, Samiian A 4, Munakata J 2
Health, Alexandria, CA, USA, 2IMS Health, San Francisco, CA, USA, 3IMS Health, Plymouth
Meeting, PA, USA, 4Abbott Diabetes Care, Alameda, CA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
1IMS
Objectives: A small, minimally-invasive flash glucose monitor (FGM) has recently
been developed. Arm sensors worn up to 14 days interact with a hand-held reader
to convey 8 hours of continuous glucose level data. The reader stores data, communicating glucose control via trend charts. Economic evaluation of FGM vs. conventional blood glucose monitoring (BGM) has not been conducted. This analysis
estimates potential cost-effectiveness of using FGM in UK insulin-treated type 2
diabetes mellitus (T2DM) patients. Methods: The IMS Core Diabetes Model (CDM)
was used for analyses, assuming a lifetime horizon (40 years). Patient characteristics
were based on early FGM feasibility trial data. Effectiveness was measured in life
years (LY) and quality-adjusted life years (QALY), with assumptions around FGM
effectiveness based on expected benefits of use. These include: a) lower HbA1c by
0.35%-0.5% compared to BGM over the horizon; b) utility improvement due to fewer
finger pricks of 0-0.03; c) minor hypoglycaemic event rate reduction of 0% or 50%
compared to BGM due to potential improved glycaemic control. Cost data (direct
costs only) were extracted from published literature and government sources, and
inflated to 2013 GBP. Incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICERs) were estimated,
and threshold analysis was performed to estimate potential total FGM sensor costs
for each scenario. Results: Based on assumptions above, the ICER for FGM vs.
BGM ranges from £10,034-£29,068/QALY. With 0.5% HbA1c improvement, 0.01 utility benefit, and no difference in hypoglycaemic events, the ICER is £17,808/QALY.
Assumptions around utility improvement have a larger ICER impact than HbA1c
benefit or change in minor hypoglycaemic events. Threshold analysis shows that
with a conventional ICER threshold (£30,000/QALY), £14,606-£27,956 can be spent on
sensors over a lifetime across scenarios. Conclusions: Using an alternate glucose
monitoring method could be cost-effective across a variety of clinical benefit and
cost assumptions in T2DM (T1DM analysis forthcoming).
PDB109
Cost Effectiveness Evaluation of Canagliflozin in Combination
with Metformin and Sulfonylurea in Comparison To Nph Insulin in
the Treatment of Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus In Poland
Szmurlo D 1, Drzal R 1, Plisko R 1, Schubert A 2, Skrzekowska-Baran I 3
1HTA Consulting, Krakow, Poland, 2Janssen Cilag Poland, Warszawa, Poland, 3Janssen-Cilag
Polska, Warszawa, Poland
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of canagliflozin, an active inhibitor
of sodium glucose co-transporter – 2 (SGLT2), in triple therapy of diabetes as addon to metformin and sulfonylurea compared to NPH insulin in combination with
oral antidiabetics. Canagliflozin in clinical trial results showed effective glucose
reduction, along with other benefits in diabetes treatment including weight loss
and SBP reduction. Cost effectiveness analyses were conducted in the Polish setting from a public perspective in accordance with guidelines of Polish HTA Agency
(PolAHTA). Methods: The IMS CORE Diabetes Model was used to evaluate the
cost-effectiveness of canagliflozin in triple therapy versus NPH insulin using Polishspecific data, where available. Clinical data were derived from mixed treatment
comparison analysis of published studies, as there is no head to head trial comparing canagliflozin with NPH insulin. Direct costs were reported in Polish zloty
and an annual discount rate of 5% and 3.5% were applied on costs and effects
respectively. Results: In a triple therapy as add-on to metformin and sulfonylurea
canagliflozin is a cost- effective treatment option in comparison with NPH insulin
with ICERs of 4 477 z³ and 69 081 z³ for canagliflozin 100 mg and 300 mg respectively. Associated QALY gains were 0,084 and 0,106. Both results are below defined
in Polish reimbursement act cost-effectiveness threshold. Conclusions: These
results suggest that adding Canagliflozin to dual therapy versus insulin intensification in patients inadequately controlled with MET+ SU would be a more efficient
use of health care resources in the Polish setting.
PDB110
Cost-Effectiveness of Empagliflozin (Jardiance®) 10 Mg And 25 Mg
Administered As An Add-On To Metformin And Sulfonilurea (Met+Su)
Compared To Other Sodium-Glucose Co-Transporter 2 Inhibitors
(Sglt2is) in Patients with Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus (T2dm) In The Uk
Aguiar-Ibáñez R 1, Palencia R 2, Kandaswamy P 3, Li L 1
1Amaris Consulting UK, London, UK, 2Boehringer Ingelheim GmbH, Ingelheim am Rhein, Germany,
3Boehringer Ingelheim UK, Bracknell, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess the cost-effectiveness of the SGLT2is empagliflozin 10mg
and 25mg compared to other SGLT2is (canagliflozin 100mg and canagliflozin
300mg) when administered as an add-on to MET+SU in patients with T2DM in
the UK. Methods: Long-term diabetes-related complications, QALYs, and costs
were estimated for T2DM patients failing MET+SU. A micro-simulation model was
developed based on the United Kingdom Prospective Diabetes Study (UKPDS68) and
the Januvia Diabetes Economic (JADE) model. A network meta-analysis comparing
efficacy and safety across SGLT2is was used to populate the model. Data gaps were
completed with information derived from published sources, including previous
cost-effectiveness models. Costs and QALYs were estimated over a patients’ lifetime
from the UK National Health Service perspective. Results: Empagliflozin 10mg
attained the highest QALYs (6.991, compared to 6.98 for canagliflozin 100mg, 6.978
for empagliflozin 25mg and 6.976 for canagliflozin 300mg) due to slightly better
HbA1c, SBP and weight control, and a small number of non-severe hypoglycaemias, compared to higher doses. Canagliflozin 300mg was the most costly strategy
(£32,087, vs. £31,217 for canagliflozin 100mg, £31,409 for empagliflozin 10mg and
£31,557 for empagliflozin 25mg). Therefore, empagliflozin 10mg dominated both
canagliflozin 300mg and empagliflozin 25mg, and resulted in an incremental costeffectiveness ratio of £17,445 per QALY gained vs. canagliflozin 100mg. However,
incremental QALY and cost differences were not significant based on 95% percentile
confidence intervals. These results remained robust when sensitivity analyses were
conducted, including utilities, adverse events, discontinuation, modelling of weight,
impact of BMI, duration of effect, time horizon and discount rates. Conclusions:
Differences in QALYs and costs between SGLT2is as add-ons to MET+SU were minor.
On average, empagliflozin 10mg resulted to be the most cost-effective option for
T2DM patients failing MET+SU when commonly accepted thresholds in the UK
were considered, with an incremental cost per QALY of £17,445 compared to canagliflozin 100mg.
PDB111
Absenteeism and Presenteeism in A Population of Patients with
Diabetic Foot Ulcers in Poland
Zalewska U 1, Macioch T 1, Sobol E 2, Mrozikiewicz-Rakowska B 1, Krakowiecki A 3,
Hermanowski T 1
1Medical University of Warsaw, Warsaw, Poland, 2Medical University of Warsaw Central Clinical
Hospital, Warsaw, Poland, 3PODOS, Warsaw, Poland
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Diabetic Foot Syndrome (DFS) is a serious and common complication of diabetes, often leading to limb amputation and disability. Disability and
productivity loss in patients with DFS can generate significant indirect costs and
potentially significant economic consequences. The purpose of the study is to estimate productivity loss and indirect costs associated with foot ulceration in patients
with DFS. Methods: We conducted a prospective survey in a population of DFS
patients with foot ulceration. Loss of productivity was measured with a modified
WPAI questionnaire. Indirect costs of both absenteeism and presenteeism were
estimated using the human capital approach on the basis of the measure of gross
value added per employee. Results: Nearly one third of respondents (32%) declared
that foot ulceration was the direct reason why they abandoned their professional
activity. 40% and 34% of respondents, respectively, were forced to limit or change
their professional activity at some point in the past because of the foot ulceration.
More than 40% of respondents who changed or limited their professional activity
because of the foot ulceration experienced reduction in earnings by 22.9% on average. Mean absenteeism was estimated at 32.63% of the nominal working time, while
presenteeism was estimated at 23.48% of real working time. Total annual indirect
costs associated with productivity loss amounted to EUR 170.8 million, including
EUR 117.3 million of the costs of sickness absence and EUR 53.5 million of the costs
of presenteeism. Conclusions: Foot ulceration in patients with DFS is a common cause why patients are forced to give up or change their professional activity,
which usually leads to a reduction in earnings. Indirect costs associated with foot
ulceration in DFS impose a significant burden on the Polish economy. There is no
rationale that would clearly link productivity loss associated with ulceration in DFS
and the ulceration severity.
PDB112
Examining The Role Of Insulin Pen Devices In Acute Care Settings:
A Review And Analysis of Health Resource Utilization
Smallwood C A 1, Lamarche D 2, Chevrier A 2
Dickinson, Mississauga, ON, Canada, 2McGill University Health Centre,
Montreal, QC, Canada
.
.
.
.
1Becton
Objectives: Insulin administration in the acute care setting is an integral component of inpatient diabetes management. The current method of administration
in acute care settings is by vial and syringe. The aim of this study was to evaluate the impact of insulin pen implementation in the acute care setting on patient
and health care worker safety, and health resource utilization (HRU). Methods: A
review of published literature was conducted to identify how insulin pen devices
in the acute care setting may impact inpatient diabetes management. Additionally,
nurse researchers from the McGill University Health Centre conducted a pilot study
in a 52-bed unit to quantify this impact in a local context. Together, the results of
the literature search and the pilot served as the inputs to an economic model,
developed in Excel v14. Costs for the volume of insulin dispensed, injection supplies, needlestick injury management, and nursing labour were assessed. Results:
Previous published studies have revealed that insulin pen devices have the potential to improve inpatient management through better glycemic control, increased
adherence and improved self-management education. The combined results from
the literature and pilot indicate that moving from vial and non-safety syringe to
a passive safety pen in acute care results in total estimated annual cost savings
of $43,339.66, and 191.42 hours of nursing time saved (site with 52 beds dedicated
to patients with diabetes). Cost savings from the adoption of a passive safety
insulin pen were predicted based on reductions in insulin volume and needlestick injuries. For an institution of similar size using safety syringes, the move to a
A352
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
passive safety pen device would result in total estimated cost savings of $17,865.40
annually. Conclusions: The implementation of insulin pen devices in acute care
results in cost savings, as well as time savings for nurses that may be re-directed to
increased time at the patient bedside.
PDB113
Epidemiology and Direct Health Care Costs of Diabetic Retinopathy:
Results From a Population-Based Study
Ciampichini R 1, Cortesi P A 1, Cozzolino P 2, Fornari C 1, Madotto F 1, Chiodini V 1,
Mantovani L G 3, Cesana G 1
1University of Milano - Bicocca, Monza, Italy, 2Charta Foundation, Milan, Italy, 3Federico II
University of Naples, Naples, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The aim of this study was to assess the epidemiologic and economic
burden of diabetic retinopathy (DR) in terms of incidence, treatment patterns
and cost by a population-based study. Methods: Eligible patients were identified through a data warehouse (DENALI), which matches demographic, clinical
and economic data of about 9.9 million individuals of Lombardy region. The study
population consists of all individuals with a diagnosis of diabetes who, during the
period 1-1-2000 to 31-12-2010 received one of the following health care services:
hospital admission (HA) for diabetes with ophthalmic manifestations or retinal
disorders, fluorescein angiography or angioscopy of eye, destruction of chorioretinal
lesion, repair of retinal tear, injection of vitreous substitute, and repeated ophthalmic examinations. The study population was followed for a minimum of 1 to
a maximum of 10 years. We evaluated demographic characteristics of the study
population and costs from the National Health Service’s perspective. Results: The
2000-2010 DR population was estimated to be around 127,000 (52% male). The average incidence per year and the 2010-prevalence were 6.1 and 24.2 per 100 diabetic
patients. Median age (min-max) at the index event was 68.6 (0.3-104.4) with 37%
younger than 65-years. Around 15% of the population had Charlson Comorbidity
Index> = 1 and the overall mortality was 41.8 deaths/100 patient-years. The 10-year
mean cost for DR patients were 17,361€ (95%C.I. 12,673-22,050) compared with 4,771€
in a control diabetic population without complications. HA costs represented the
driver of total costs, ranging from 45% (index year) to 36% (last year of follow-up), followed by drug (30-34.4%) and outpatient (25-29.7%). During the index year 13% of HA
and outpatient costs were attributed to eye-specialist departments. Approximately
1% received intravitreal injections in 2010. Conclusions: This study attempted
to describe the burden of DR in Italy revealing socio-economic aspects relevant in
terms of incidence and costs.
PDB114
Evaluation of the Burden of Illness of u.S. Medicare Patients
Diagnosed with Hyperpotassemia
Xie L 1, Dysinger A H 1, Kariburyo M F 1, Du J 1, Baser O 2
Research, Ann Arbor, MI, USA, 2STATinMED Research and The University of
Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1STATinMED
Objectives: To evaluate the economic burden and health care utilization of patients
diagnosed with hyperpotassemia in the U.S. Medicare population. Methods:
Hyperpotassemia patients (International Classification of Disease 9 thRevision
Clinical Modification ICD-9-CM diagnosis codes 276.7) were identified from the U.S.
national Medicare claims from 01JAN2009 through 31DEC2011. The first diagnosis
date was designated as the index date for the hyperpotassemia cohort. Patients
without a hyperpotassemia diagnosis but of the same age, region, gender, index
year and matched baseline Charlson Comorbidity Index score were identified for
the comparison cohort, with a randomly-chosen index date to minimize selection bias. Patients were required to have continuous medical and pharmacy benefits 1 year before and after the index date. Study outcomes (health care costs and
utilizations) were compared between the disease and comparator cohorts using
1: 1 propensity score matching (PSM). Results: A total of 90,528 patients were
included in the hyperpotassemia and comparison cohorts. After 1: 1 PSM, 28,929
patients were matched from each cohort, and baseline characteristics were proportionate. Patients diagnosed with hyperpotassemia were more likely to utilize
health care resources, including Medicare carrier (98.4% vs. 77.8%), Durable Medical
Equipment (DME; 36.7% vs. 23.6%) and Home Health Agency (HHA; 18.4% vs. 7.3%)
claims, outpatient visits (75.5% vs. 47.7%), inpatient (37.4% vs. 3.4%), skilled nursing
facility (SNF, 13.3% vs. 3.4%) and hospice stays (1.1% vs. 0.8%) and prescription drug
claims (54.1% vs. 50.7%). Patients diagnosed with hyperpotassemia also incurred
higher Medicare carrier ($3,447 vs. $1,636), DME ($343 vs. $167), HHA ($938 vs. $412),
outpatient ($11,006 vs. $4,534), inpatient ($7,156 vs. $1,463), SNF ($2,688 vs. $612),
hospice ($244 vs. $198), pharmacy ($1,104 vs. $812) and total costs ($26,926 vs. $9,834)
(p<0.05). Conclusions: The economic burden and health care resource utilization
were significantly higher for patients diagnosed with hyperpotassemia.
PDB115
Costs of Hospitalization of Type 2 Diabetic Patients Associated
with Severe Hypoglycemia
Laires P 1, Conceição J 1, Araújo F 2, Dores J 3, Silva C 4, Radican L 5, Nogueira A M 1
Sharp & Dohme, Oeiras, Portugal, 2Hospital Beatriz Ângelo, Loures, Portugal, 3Hospital
de Santo António, Porto, Portugal, 4Eurotrials, Lisbon, Portugal, 5Merck & Co., Inc., Whitehouse
Station, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Merck
Objectives: HIPOS-ER is an observational, cross-sectional, multicenter study aimed
(a) to describe type 2 diabetes patients treated with an anti-hyperglycemic agent
(AHA) and admitted to the emergency room (ER) due to a hypoglycemic event and (b)
to estimate health care resources use and its costs related with the ER hypoglycemic
episode. In this analysis, costs within hospitalized patients following severe hypoglycemia assisted at the ER were specifically calculated. Methods: The study was
conducted in 7 centers in mainland Portugal for a period of 12 months (Jan 2013 – Jan
2014). Costs related with these hospitalized patients were calculated considering the
hospital perspective. Unit costs for 2014 were extracted from official sources and
reported in euros. Patient level data were used to calculate average costs. Regarding
ER attendance, costs were calculated multiplying resource use by corresponding unit
costs. Regarding hospitalization, length of stay was multiplied by daily cost obtained
through hospitals accountancy. Both costs were summed and descriptive statistics
were calculated. Productivity loss cost within ER admission and hospitalization was
calculated for employed patients using the Human Capital Approach. Results: 238
patients were enrolled and 105 (44%) were hospitalized. These patients had a median
length of stay of 5.4 days and were most commonly hospitalized at the Internal
Medicine department (n= 80; 76%). Nine patients (8.6%) died during hospitalization.
Hospitalized patients had the following average (range) costs: pre-hospital care and
transport € 34 (€ 0-€ 92); emergency room € 218 (€ 58-€ 1,348); hospitalization € 2,880
(€ 140-€ 26,486); productivity loss costs due to ER and hospitalization € 31 (€ 0-€ 1,579).
Thus, mean total cost per hypoglycemic event leading to hospitalization was € 3,163
(€ 230-€ 26,818). Conclusions: We conclude that severe hypoglycemia represent a
substantial cost to Society and to the public hospitals of the National Health System
in particular for those cases requiring hospitalization.
PDB116
The Health Service and Economic Impact of Glucagon Rescue
Administration During Severe Hypoglycemic Events
Leinwand B , Hughes K E , Inocencio T
Avalere Health, Washington, DC, DC, USA
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Hypoglycemia, which if left untreated, can be severe and result in seizures, unconsciousness, and coma, during which another person’s help is required to
administer a rescue dose of glucagon. Injectable glucagon kits are difficult to use and
require training to administer. This study aimed to quantify the economic impact of
using glucagon kits on resource use and costs, and identify evidentiary gaps requiring
future research. Methods: A conceptual model was developed illustrating the series
of events resulting from a SHE: successful administration of glucagon, ambulance
calls, transport to the ED, inpatient admission, and outpatient follow-up. A literature
search was conducted to assess service use and costs associated with severe hypoglycemia events (SHE). English language articles were reviewed in PubMed, EMBASE
and Cochrane databases. Results: Resource use associated with SHE, as a function
of successful administration of glucagon, has not been systematically evaluated in the
literature. Uncertainty exists for the probability of receiving a glucagon prescription
for diabetics and successful use of glucagon kits. Furthermore, based on successful administration of glucagon, the probability of ambulance calls, transports to the
ED, inpatient admissions, and frequency of outpatient follow-up are lacking in the
literature. Conclusions: Diabetes is a costly condition for payers, and a common
complication is hypoglycemia. Glucagon kits are effective in stabilizing diabetics’
blood glucose levels during SHE; however, oftentimes physicians do not prescribe,
patients do not fill, or caregivers do not successfully administer glucagon due to
the complex administration procedures. As less complicated glucagon products are
developed, their value propositions must be informed by the economic implications
resulting from the complex administration requirements of current kits. However, the
current literature does not systematically evaluate these implications. Consequently,
future research is needed to quantify the impact of non-successful administration of
glucagon rescue kits, as well as the extent of under-utilization.
PDB117
Hipos-Er (Hypoglycemia in Portugal Observational Study –
Emergency Room): Costs And Health Care Resource Consumption
Data
Laires P 1, Conceição J 1, Araújo F 2, Dores J 3, Silva C 4, Radican L 5, Nogueira A M 1
Sharp & Dohme, Oeiras, Portugal, 2Hospital Beatriz Ângelo, Loures, Portugal, 3Hospital
de Santo António, Porto, Portugal, 4Eurotrials, Lisbon, Portugal, 5Merck & Co., Inc., Whitehouse
Station, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Merck
Objectives: HIPOS-ER is an observational, cross-sectional, multicenter national
study to describe the patient population of type 2 diabetics with hypoglycemic episodes that enter the emergency department caused by an anti-hyperglycemic agent
(AHA). A key secondary objective is to estimate health care resource consumption
and costs associated with this type of hypoglycemias. Methods: The study was conducted in 7 centers in mainland Portugal for a period of 12 months (Jan2013-Jan2014).
Patient level data and resource utilization were collected. Average costs were assessed
by multiplying 2014 unit costs (available from public sources) with all relevant health
care resource consumption items registered in the emergency room following the
hypoglycemia events and through hospital accountancy for the hospitalized patients
(length of stay x daily mean cost of hospitalization). Results: The study enrolled 238
patients and the calculated proportion of hypoglycemic episodes among all emergency events in the same period was 0.075% (95%CI: 0.067%, 0.083%). In this population, 55.0% of the patients were using insulin, 31.5% were treated with a secretagogue,
6.7% were on a combination of insulin and a secretagogue oral agent and 6.7% were on
oral non-secretagogue based AHA therapy. Mean patient age was 76 years and 57.6%
were females. Estimated mean (range) of direct costs assessed in the emergency room
were: emergency transportation €33 (€0-€92), drugs €4 (€0-€45), laboratory workup 56€
(€8-€212), other exams €72 (€0-€944), physician and nurse time €30 (€4-€211) and €14
(€1-€90), respectively. Mean hospitalization cost was €1,271 (€0-€26,486). Mean indirect
cost related with productivity loss within employed patients was €15 (€0-€1,579). Total
cost, including direct and indirect costs, was € 1,493 (€34-€26,818) per hypoglycemic
event. Hospitalization was the main cost driver (85% of total costs). Conclusions:
We conclude that hypoglycemia represent a substantial cost for the Society and in
particular for the public hospitals of the National Health System.
PDB118
Cost Analysis of Severe Hypoglycemia in Treated Type 2 Diabetic
Patients According to Anti-Hyperglycemic Agent Therapy
Laires P 1, Conceição J 1, Dores J 2, Araújo F 3, Silva C 4, Radican L 5, Nogueira A M 1
Sharp & Dohme, Oeiras, Portugal, 2Hospital de Santo António, Porto, Portugal, 3Hospital
Beatriz Ângelo, Loures, Portugal, 4Eurotrials, Lisbon, Portugal, 5Merck & Co., Inc., Whitehouse
Station, NJ, USA
.
1Merck
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A353
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: HIPOS-ER is the first national Hypoglycemia study in Portugal collecting specific resource data directly in the hospitals. Here we aim to describe
the average cost of severe hypoglycemic event by anti-hyperglycemic agent (AHA)
class. Methods: The study was conducted in 7 centers in mainland Portugal for
a period of 12 months (Jan13-Jan14). Patient level data and resource utilization
were collected. Unit costs for 2014 were extracted from official sources. Regarding
emergency room (ER) attendance, costs were calculated multiplying resource use by
corresponding unit costs. For hospitalization, length of stay was multiplied by daily
cost obtained through hospital account record. AHA therapy classes were: Group 1
(insulin), Group 2 (secretagogue), Group 3 (oral AHA excluding secretagogue), and
Group 4 (at least one insulin and one secretagogue). Results: 238 patients were
enrolled and 105 (44%) were hospitalized. The distribution based on AHA therapy:
55% (131) Group 1, 32% (75) Group 2, 7% (16) Group 3 and 7% (16) Group 4. After ER
episode, Group 2 patients were more often hospitalized versus Group 1 (71% vs. 29%;
p< 0.001) and Group 4 (31%; p= 0.003). The global cost was 1,493€ (34€ -26,818€ ) and
hospitalization was the main cost driver accounting for 85% of costs. The total cost
per AHA class was: Group 1: 1,309€ ; Group 2: 1,880€ ; Group 3: 1,350€ ; Group 4: 1,330€ .
When comparing ER-only vs. hospitalized: Group 1: 167€ vs. 4,105€ ; Group 2: 185€
vs. 2,583€ ; Group 3: 156€ vs. 2,278€ ; Group 4: 237€ vs. 3,734€ . Group 1 accounted for
48% of overall costs, Group 2 40%, Groups 3 and 4, 6% each. Group 2 had the highest
hospitalization rate (70.7%). Conclusions: AHA classes may contribute differently
for costs associated with severe hypoglycemia. Insulin based therapy had the greatest overall cost followed closely by secretagogue type drugs, which were associated
with more hospitalizations.
PDB119
The Burden of Severe Hypoglicaemias and Diabetes Ketoacidosis:
A Population-Based Study
Ciampichini R 1, Cozzolino P 2, Cortesi P A 1, Fornari C 1, Madotto F 1, Chiodini V 1,
Mantovani L G 3, Cesana G 1
1University of Milano - Bicocca, Monza, Italy, 2Charta Foundation, Milan, Italy, 3Federico II
University of Naples, Naples, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The aim of this study was to assess the burden of severe hypoglycemia (HYPO) and diabetes ketoacidosis (DKA) in terms of incidence, treatment
patterns and cost in Italy. Methods: Eligible patients were identified through a
data warehouse (DENALI), which matches with a probabilistic linkage demographic,
clinical and economic data of about 9.9 million individuals of Lombardy region. The
study population was made of all individuals with a diagnosis of type-1 diabetes
(T1DM) who, during the period 1-1-2000 to 31-12-2010 developed a first episode of
severe HYPO (ICD-9-CM: 251.0-251.2) or DKA (ICD-9-CM: 250.10-250.13) leading to
hospitalization (index event). The identified individuals were followed-up from the
index event to a maximum of 10 years. We evaluated demographic characteristics
of the study population and costs (hospitalizations, drugs and outpatient examinations/visits) from the National Health Service’s perspective. Results: During
the observational period 1,321 T1DM subjects had at least one hospital admission
for HYPO (27.5%) or DKA (72.5%) event. Median age (min-max) at the first HYPO
or DKA event was 66.9 (1.3-96.7) and 39.4 (1.0-95.7) years, respectively. The overall
mortality was 14.3 deaths/100 patient-years among HYPO subjects and 7.0 among
DKA ones: the difference in mortality rates between groups disappeared once
controlling for age. The mean costs with 95% C.I. (€ /patient-year) for HYPO and
DKA patients were, respectively 10,442 (8,755-12,129) and 9,720 (8,659-10,782) in
the event year, 10,296 (8,446-12,145) and 5,805 (4,539-7,071) in the year before the
event, and 5,619 (3,841-7,398) and 4,974 (3,912-6,035) in the year after the event.
Hospitalizations represented the driver of total costs: in the year of event and in the
year after it varied from 70 to 56% and 76 to 60% for HYPO and DKA patients, respectively. Conclusions: This study attempted to address the burden of severe T1DM
HYPO and DKA events in Italy in an unselected population. The burden showed to
be relevant in terms of incidence, mortality and costs.
p= 0.03), use of 3rd generation SU (OR= 0.86 [0.78 - 0.95]; p= 0.002), and chronic renal
disease (OR= 1.34 [1.07 - 1.67]; p= 0.01). Conclusions: In conclusion, multiple factors, including efficacy and hypoglycemia, are associated with discontinuation of
SU treatment after insulin initiation.
PDB121
Impact of Hypoglycemia on Discontinuing or Down-Titrating
Sulfonylurea Among Type 2 Diabetes Patients Without Insulin
Laires P 1, Iglay K 2, Fan C P S 3, Li Z 3, Tang J 3, Qiu Y 2
Sharp & Dohme, Oeiras, Portugal, 2Merck Sharp & Dohme Corp., Whitehouse Station, NJ,
USA, 3AscelpiusAnalytics Ltd., Hong Kong, Hong Kong
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Merck
Objectives: Sulfonylurea (SU) may be discontinued or down-titrated due to
hypoglycemia. Hypoglycemia may be more concerning for patients not receiving
aggressive efficacy-driven treatment such as the dual-therapy of SU and insulin. A
retrospective cohort study using the MarketScan database was conducted to assess
the association between hypoglycemia and therapy changes (discontinuation or
down-titration) among adults receiving SU therapy without insulin. Methods:
Patients with the first SU prescription (Rx) (index date) in 2009-2011, ≥ 18 years
of age on the index date, and with ≥ 1 year continuous enrollment pre- and postindex were included. Patients were excluded if they received insulin within the
1-year pre- or post-index, had ≥ 2 SUs on the index date, or had type 1, gestational
or secondary diabetes. Therapy changes were determined during the 1-year postindex period. Discontinuation occurred when consecutive SU fills were ≥ 90 days
apart. Down-titration occurred when an SU fill had a lower equivalent dose than
the index dose. Hypoglycemic events were identified using ICD-9 code between the
index date and the therapy change or the end of the 1-year post-index period. Cox
regression was used to evaluate the association between hypoglycemic events and
therapy changes. Results: 97,570 patients were included in the study, of which
50,854 (52.1%) experienced therapy changes within 1-year post-index. Patients with
hypoglycemic events were at significantly higher risk for therapy changes (HR=
1.86 [1.75, 1.97]; p< . 01). Specifically, they were 197% more likely to down-titrate
(HR= 2.97 [2.53, 3.46]; p<. 01) and 80% more likely to discontinue (HR=1.80 [1.69, 1.92];
p< . 01). Conclusions: Post-index hypoglycemic events are significantly associated with therapy changes among patients receiving SU without insulin, especially
down-titration.
PDB122
Guideline Adherence and Control Of Diabetes Mellitus With
Co-Morbidities in a Tertiary-Care Hospital in Malaysia
Iqbal M Z 1, Iqbal M S 1, Khan A H 2, Sulaiman S A 2, Iqbal M W 3
of Clinical Pharmacy, Faculty of Pharmacy, AIMST University, Kedah, Malaysia,
2Department of Clinical Pharmacy, School of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Universiti Sains Malaysia,
Pulau Pinang,,,, Malaysia, 3Faculty of Law, Universiti Malaya,, Kualalumpur, Malaysia
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Department
DIABETES/ENDOCRINE DISORDERS – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient
Preference Studies
Objectives: To evaluate doctors’ adherence to Malaysian Clinical Practice
Guideline (CPG) 2009 in the management of diabetes mellitus with co-morbidities
in Malaysia. Methods: Cross-sectional study was done at a tertiary-care hospital
in Malaysia. Total 51 physicians and 1020 patients’ prescriptions written by same
physicians (20 prescriptions per physician) were analyzed. All patients had diabetes
mellitus with co-morbidities. Depending on the recommendations of CPG 2009,
the prescriptions were clustered as adherent and non-adherent prescriptions. All
obtained data were analyzed using descriptive and inferential statistics. Results: A
statistically significant negative association (Ф= 0.094, p-value= 0.003) was observed
between diabetes mellitus control and co-morbidities. CPG adherent had statistically weak negative association (Ф= - 0.081, p-value= 0.010) with patients having
co-morbidities (41.6%). No statistically significant association was observed between
CPG adherence and any other co-morbidity. Majority of the patients received guidelines-compliant pharmacotherapy. The overall good level of physician adherence
with CPG 2009 was observed in the management of diabetes mellitus with comorbidities. Conclusions: The study explored several features of prescription
pattern of the physicians involved in the management of diabetes mellitus with
co-morbidities and recognized the need for improvement in their prescription pattern for treating the diabetes mellitus.
PDB120
Factors Associated With Discontinuation of Sulfonylurea Therapy
In Type 2 Diabetes Patients Who Initiate Insulin
PDB123
The Relationship Between Macular Edema and Health Outcomes
Among Patients With Diabetes in Western Europe
1Merck
Laires P 1, Fu A Z 2, Iglay K 3, Qiu Y 3
Sharp & Dohme, Oeiras, Portugal, 2Georgetown University, Washington, DC, DC, USA,
3Merck Sharp & Dohme Corp., Whitehouse Station, NJ, USA
Pignot M 1, DiBonaventura M 2
1Kantar Health, München, Germany, 2Kantar Health, New York, NY, USA
Objectives: Sulfonylureas (SU) represent a common treatment for type 2 diabetes
(T2DM), but they are associated with hypoglycemia, weight gain, and possibly cardiovascular events. The purpose of this study is to evaluate factors associated with
SU discontinuation after insulin initiation. Methods: Patients ≥ 21 years old with
a T2DM diagnosis between 2005 and 2012 were identified using the GE electronic
medical records database. Index date was defined as the first insulin prescription
(Rx) between 2006 and 2011. Patients were required to be on SU at the index date.
Patients were excluded if they did not have medical records available ≥ 12 months
before and after index date, were receiving insulin in the 12 months prior to index
date, or had other forms of diabetes. Treatment with other diabetes medications in
addition to SU and insulin were permitted in this study. SU discontinuation occurred
when the gap between the end date of current SU Rx supply and the start date of
subsequent SU supply was ≥ 90 days apart. Multivariate logistic regression was
performed to identify factors associated with SU discontinuation. Results: A total
of 8,185 patients were selected, with mean age 64 years and 49% were male. 60.4%
discontinued their SU Rxs within 1 year, with a median time from insulin initiation to SU discontinuation of 88 days. In the logistic regression, baseline diagnosed
hypoglycemia (OR= 2.29 [95% CI 1.03 - 5.10]; p= 0.04) and baseline HbA1c (OR= 1.04
[1.01 - 1.06]; p= 0.004) were identified as factors associated with SU discontinuation.
Additional factors included BMI (< 25 kg/m2 vs. ≥ 30 kg/m2; OR= 1.23 [1.03 - 1.46];
Objectives: Diabetes is associated with a number of microvascular and macrovascular complications. Diabetic macular edema (DME) is one of these complications
and is among the leading causes of vision impairment. However, little data exists
as to the patient-related burden of DME in Europe and the aim of the current study
was to address this gap. Methods: Data from the 2013 5EU (France, Germany, Italy,
Spain, and UK) National Health and Wellness Survey (NHWS) were used (N= 62,000).
The NHWS is a patient-reported survey administered to a demographically representative sample of adults (with respect to age, sex, and region). Patients who
reported experiencing DME were compared with a propensity-scored matched control group of patients with diabetes but without DME. Matching variables included
demographics, comorbidities (Charlson comorbidity index [CCI]), and diabetes
history. Post-match, patients with DME and matched controls were compared on
health outcomes (SF-36v2, Work Productivity and Activity Impairment, and selfreported health care resource utilization) using general linear models. Results:
4,088 patients reported diabetes (6.6%). Of these, 296 (7.2%) reported having DME.
Patients with DME were more likely to have type 1 diabetes (26.4% vs. 8.5%), had been
diagnosed with diabetes for longer (54.4% vs. 20.7% were diagnosed 16+ years), were
more likely to use insulin (68.6% vs. 27.3%), and had a greater comorbidity burden
(CCI = 2.2 vs. 1.6) (all p< .05), among other differences. After matching on these
variables, patients with DME (n= 286) reported significantly worse physical health
status (PCS: 41.1 vs. 43.2), greater overall work impairment (36.2% vs. 25.64%), and
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A354
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
more health care provider visits in the past six months (11.7 vs. 8.9) compared with
matched controls (n= 286) (all p< .05). Conclusions: DME was more commonly
reported by patients with diabetes and its presence was associated with a significant
humanistic and economic burden in the 5EU.
PDB124
EQ-5D Scores In Patients Receiving Tolvaptan for the Treatment
Of Hyponatraemia Secondary to the Syndrome of Inappropriate
Antidiuretic Hormone Secretion
Trueman D 1, Hancock E 1, Robinson P 2, Dale P 2, O’Reilly K 2, Gisby M 2
1Decision Resources Group, London, UK, 2Otsuka Pharmaceutical Europe Ltd, Wexham, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Hyponatraemia (HN) is estimated to occur in 15% of all hospitalised
patients with syndrome of inappropriate antidiuretic hormone secretion (SIADH)
being one of the most common aetiologies. Patients treated with tolvaptan have
demonstrated improvements in health related quality of life (HRQL) in the SALT I
& II randomised controlled trials. The objective of this study was to map the SF-12
responses from SALT I & II to EQ-5D using a publically available algorithm and
predict the change in EQ-5D associated with tolvaptan. Methods: SF-12 scores
from the pooled SALT I & II studies were converted to EQ-5D scores using a mapping algorithm developed by Gray, et. al 2006. Simulated EQ-5D scores were then
used to estimate changes in EQ-5D from baseline at day 30 using ordinary least
squares regression (OLS) as a function of baseline characteristics, treatment arm and
achievement of sodium correction (NA+) at day 4 (> 135 mmol/l). A preferred model
was selected based on the highest adjusted R-squared. Secondary analyses looked
at change from baseline in EQ-5D at day 7, day 14 and at 7 day follow-up following
treatment discontinuation. Results: The preferred model included baseline age,
gender, sodium level, EQ-5D and a tolvaptan indicator variable. Based on this model,
tolvaptan was associated with a positive increase in simulated EQ-5D of 0.10 (n=164,
p=0.03) at day 30 vs. placebo. After 7 days follow-up, tolvaptan was associated with a
positive, but non- statistically significant effect of 0.04 (n=74, p= 0.54). No effect was
observed at day 7 (n= 76, p= 0.90) or at day 14 (n= 85, p= 0.84). Sodium correction did
not appear to be a statistically significant predictor of HRQL. Conclusions: The
preferred model indicated a statistically significant improvement in HRQL associated with tolvaptan use at day 30. Further research is required to establish whether
sodium correction has an effect of HRQL.
PDB125
Patient Experience With The Single-Use Pen For Injection of Once
Weekly Dulaglutide in Injection-Naive Patients With Type 2 Diabetes
Van Brunt K 1, Ignaut D A 2, Zimmermann A G 2, Threlkeld R J 2, Matfin G 3
Lilly and Company, UK, Windlesham, Surrey, UK, 2Eli Lilly and Company, Indianapolis, IN,
USA, 3International Diabetes Center, Minneapolis, MN, USA
.
.
.
.
.
re-use of eDiaries previously used by patients doing fingerstick tests poses a low and
acceptable risk; flexibility for handling measurements should be incorporated in the
eDiary design including batch and individual reporting, reporting hypoglycaemic
events as part of a meal event or as a standalone event and edit checks should be
included to identify where a number of low measurements relate to the same event;
there should be clear guidance to patientson how to transfer measurements to the
eDiary; a method for managing control test measurementsshould be incorporated;
and integrating glucometer measurements decreases patient burden and increases
patient engagement.
.
.
.
PDB127
The Development of an Integrated Ecoa Solution To Improve The
Quality of Data Capture In Diabetes Clinical Trials
McEvoy K
CRF Health, London, UK
.
Objectives: The 347 million people who live with diabetes face an array of daily
disease management tasks, e. g. measuring blood glucose, keeping track of the nutritional value of meals, and monitoring insulin usage. Diabetes trials vary in methodology, level of patient burden, volume of data captured and patient compliance. Our
aim was to develop an electronic data capture system for use in clinical trials which
would decrease patient burden while increasing compliance and improving data
quality. Methods: We developed a diabetes specific, electronic, event driven diary
for capturing data relevant for clinical trials. Iterations of the diary were tested in
diabetes patients via focus groups and one-on-one usability evaluations. Feedback
was analysed to understand the typical day-to-day experience of living with diabetes, and to examine the impact and acceptability of a tailored electronic solution.
Feedback was incorporated into a refined solution for use in clinical trials. Results:
The nature of diabetes means that patients are typically very actively engaged in
managing their disease, although a lot of variation was seen in patients and their
management routines. The requirement for multiple devices and high volume of
data was also reported as burdensome. The focus groups and usability studies highlighted the benefit of providing a flexible solution, as well as redesigning the diary
from unstructured blood glucose measurement reporting to event driven reporting.
This redesign met the needs of patients, as well as the requirements of clinical trial
protocols. Patients agreed that they would prefer this integrated, intuitive solution
over traditional paper and electronic solutions. Conclusions: When faced with
the task of recording patient data in diabetes, a well-designed and thoroughly tested
electronic solution can reduce burden and increase patient satisfaction. This in turn
improves compliance, data quality and overall study efficiency, while meeting the
needs of all stakeholders.
1Eli
Objectives: This 4-wk, Phase 3b, multicentre, open-label, single-arm, outpatient
study evaluated the safe and effective use of the Single-Use Pen (SUP) in patients
with type 2 diabetes (T2D) who were naïve to self-injection or injecting others. The
SUP contains a pre-filled syringe and automates needle insertion, retraction, and
drug delivery; specifically designed for once-weekly glucagon-like peptide-1 receptor agonist, dulaglutide. Patient-reported outcomes (PROs) related to self-injection
and to the SUP were important secondary outcomes. Methods: Patients (N= 211)
were trained on correct injection technique with the SUP containing 0.5 mL placebo
prior to initial self-injection. PRO measures were completed by patients after final
injection or at early termination to evaluate device ease of use, experience (including
satisfaction/confidence), and key device features. Site trainers rated how easy/difficult it was to train the patient to use the SUP. Results: 99.0% of patients found the
device easy to use. Patients found it easy to hold the SUP when injecting and to push
the button to inject (97.6% and 98.1%, respectively). 97.1% of patients were satisfied
with the overall injection experience, 96.7% of patients were confident they could
identify when the full dose was delivered, and 99.0% were confident in their overall
ability to use the SUP. Patients liked not having to attach (99.0%), touch (98.6%), or see
(95.7%) the needle. 95.7% of patients also liked hearing the click indicating the dose
was complete and 94.8% liked the automatic needle insertion. Finally, 92.4% of site
trainers found it easy to train patients on how to use the SUP. Conclusions: This
study demonstrated the SUP could be used safely and effectively by injection-naïve
patients with T2D; PRO results indicated patient satisfaction with the SUP injection
experience. A positive injection experience may be an important factor for some
patients and providers when initiating injectable therapy.
PDB126
Best Practices in Integrating Home Glucometer Measurements With
Electronic Patient Reported Outcomes (Epro) In Clinical Trials
Garner K
CRF Health, London, UK
.
Objectives: Monitoring glycaemic control is important in diabetes clinical trials
and is also relevant for some oncology trials. It is possible to seamlessly integrate
blood glucose measurements with clinical trial data via Bluetooth. This integration
reduces transcription errors and improves accuracy and completeness of data, while
reducing burden on patients. Our aim was to explore best practices in integrating
measurements with ePRO. Methods: A review of best practice and experience in
blood glucose measurement data integration was undertaken and the findings were
incorporated into a solution for use in clinical trials. A systematic literature review
was also undertaken to assess the contamination risk to individuals handling and
re-using electronic diaries (eDiary) previously used by patients doing fingerstick
tests for blood glucose measurement. We defined search terms and undertook a
PubMed and internet search. All documents that were identified as possibly relevant
were reviewed and summarised. Results: The review revealed key features and
activities related to planning, design, testing and delivery that are important for
successful integration of blood glucose measurements with ePRO data. The literature review confirmed that the risk in handling and re-using eDiaries previously
used by patients doing fingerstick tests was very low. Conclusions: Handling and
PDB128
German Patients’ Preferences for Attributes Of Type 2 Diabetes
Medications
Gelhorn H 1, Stringer S 2, Reinders S 3, Schreeb K 4
1Evidera, Bethesda, MD, USA, 2Evidera, Inc., Bethesda, MD, USA, 3Evidera, London, UK,
4Boehringer Ingelheim Pharma GmbH & Co. KG, Ingelheim am Rhein, Germany
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Treatments for Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus (T2DM) are associated with
varying effectiveness and safety profiles. Patients’ preferences for each of the medication characteristics that yield these varying profiles can be assessed through
discrete choice experiments (DCEs). This study expands on the knowledge from
two previous T2DM DCE studies conducted in the United Kingdom (UK) and the
United States (US), and was aimed at evaluating the relative importance of medication attributes that influence medication choice among participants with T2DM
from Germany. Methods: A web-based DCE was conducted among patients with
self-reported T2DM from Germany. The DCE was designed to examine 7 attributes
of T2DM medications (efficacy, urinary tract infection/genital infection side effects,
nausea/other gastrointestinal side effects, weight change, and hypoglycemic events,
treatment in case of low blood sugar, and blood pressure). Part-worth utilities were
estimated using multi-logit models, and relative importance [RI] values were calculated for each attribute. Results: N= 600 Participants with T2DM completed the
study (50% male; mean age= 58.2 years SD= 10.0; BMI= 32.4, SD= 6.8). The RI values
for the attributes in order of importance were: treatment in case of low blood sugar
(22.5%), hypoglycemic events (18.1%), weight change (17.5%), efficacy (15.0%), nausea/other gastrointestinal side effects (12.9%), UTI/genital infection side effects
(7.9%), and blood pressure (6.0%). Conclusions: The results of this study suggest
that hypoglycemic events and the interventions required in the case of such events
are of great importance to patients; these two attributes represent over 40% of the
variance in patients’ medication decisions. Change in body weight as a consequence
of treatment was also an important attribute to patients. The results may help treatment providers and payers to understand the preferences of patients with T2DM.
Understanding these preferences may be useful in devising strategies for successfully engaging and maintaining patients on T2DM treatments.
PDB129
Self-Reported Frequency and Impact of Non-Severe Hypoglycaemia
in Insulin-Treated Adults in the UK
Chubb B 1, Jensen M M 2, Frier B M 3
Nordisk Limited, Gatwick, UK, 2Novo Nordisk Scandinavia AB, Copenhagen, Denmark, 3The
Queen’s Medical Research Institute, Edinburgh, UK
.
.
.
.
.
1Novo
Objectives: Hypoglycaemia is the main side-effect of insulin therapy and can
prevent optimal diabetes management. Real-world data on the frequency and
impact of non-severe (self-treated) hypoglycaemic events are scarce. Self-reported
frequency of non-severe hypoglycaemic events (NSHEs), their impact on personal
well-being, work productivity and health care resource use, and patient–physician
communication following non-severe events, were examined in people taking insulin. Methods: Adults in the UK aged >15 years with Type 1 or insulin-treated Type 2
diabetes mellitus (T1DM or T2DM) completed ≤ 4 questionnaires at weekly intervals
(7-day recall). Severe hypoglycaemic events (requiring external assistance) are not
A355
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
reported here. Results: Overall, 1,038 respondents (T1DM= 466, T2DM= 572) completed 3,528 questionnaires. Mean insulin treatment duration was 11.7 years and
mean HbA1c was 8.2% (66.2 mmol/mol). Mean NSHE/week was 2.4 (T1DM) and 0.8
(T2DM); 23% (T1DM) and 26% (T2DM) occurred at night. Fatigue and reduced alertness were the commonest sequelae of NSHEs (78% and 51% of respondents, respectively). Effects of nocturnal NSHEs lasted significantly longer than effects of daytime
events: T1DM= 10.6 vs. 4.9 hours (p= 0.0002); T2DM= 15.3 vs. 5.1 hours (p< 0.0001).
In the week following a NSHE, blood glucose testing increased 12% (T1DM) and
21% (T2DM). In employed respondents (47% of total), 20% of NSHEs caused loss of
work-time, which was longer following nocturnal NSHEs: T1DM= 2.7 vs. 1.1 hours
(p= 0.0184); T2DM= 2.5 vs. 1.6 hours (p= 0.1340). Over a third of employed respondents experienced difficulty concentrating at work following NSHEs (T1DM= 39%;
T2DM= 44%). Respondents contacted a health care professional (HCP) after 3%
(T1DM) and 7% (T2DM) of NSHEs. Overall, respondents rarely or never informed
HCPs about NSHEs (T1DM= 82%; T2DM= 69%). Conclusions: NSHEs are common
in adults with insulin-treated diabetes in the UK, and have a negative impact on
personal well-being, work productivity, and health care resource use. As they are
seldom reported to HCPs, the burden of hypoglycaemia may be underestimated.
PDB130
Patients’ Preferences in Oral Diabetes Treatment: A Discrete Choice
Experiment in Type2 Diabetes Mellitus
Mühlbacher A C , Bethge S
Hochschule Neubrandenburg, Neubrandenburg, Germany
.
.
.
Objectives: The aim of the empirical study is to evaluate patients’ preferences for
different characteristics of treatment in type2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM). As T2DM
treatment asks for strict adherence, patient’s needs and preferences should be taken
into consideration. Methods: Based on a qualitative and quantitative analysis
a Discrete Choice Experiment (DCE) was applied to identify patient preferences.
Apart from six identical attributes (adjustment of glycated hemoglobin [HbA1c],
prevention of hypoglycemia, risk of genital infection, risk of gastrointestinal problems, risk of urinary tract infection and weight change) one continuous variable of
either healthy life years equivalents (HYE) or money equivalents (ME) was included.
The DCE was conducted using a fractional factorial design and the statistical data
analysis used random effect logit models. Results: In total N= 626 (N= 318 HYE +
N=308 ME) T2DM patients participated in the survey. The estimation revealed a clear
dominance for prevention of hypoglycemia (coefficient: 0,937) and adjustment of
HbA1c (coefficient: 0,541). The attributes, additional healthy life years (coefficient:
0,458) or additional cost (coefficient: 0,420) were in the middle rank and both of
significant impact. The side effects, risk of genital infection (coefficient: 0,301), risk
of gastrointestinal problems (coefficient: 0,296) and risk of urinary tract infection
(coefficient: 0,241) followed in this order. Possible weight change (coefficient: 0,047)
was of less importance (last rank) to the patients in this evaluation. Conclusions:
These survey results demonstrate how much a treatment characteristic of a (hypothetical) oral diabetes treatment affects the treatment decision Understanding how
patients perceive and value different aspects of oral T2DM treatment is vital to the
optimal design and evaluation of treatment options. (IB 209403011/14).
PDB131
Hye and me as Identical Currencies in Preference Studies?
A Discrete-Choice Experiment in Type2 Diabetes Mellitus
Mühlbacher A C , Bethge S
Hochschule Neubrandenburg, Neubrandenburg, Germany
.
.
.
Objectives: Only a few studies have explored deriving clinically relevant timeequivalents in comparison to money-equivalents from Discrete-Choice Experiment
(DCE) data. By separating the decision model and including a) healthy life-years
equivalents (HYEsurvey) or b) money equivalents (MEsurvey) it could be derived
if both lead to similar preference patterns and allow answering the question: Can
HYE or ME serve as identical “currency” for patients with type2 diabetes mellitus
(T2DM) patients? Methods: A DCE, separated into two versions, was applied to
identify patient preferences in oral diabetes treatment. Six identical attributes and
one continuous variable of either HYE or ME were included. To be able to test the
rescaling effect a scope test has been included, by using different level ranges of
the time/money attribute. DCE used a fractional factorial design and random effectlogit-models (Stata, xtlogit and gllamm). Results: The estimation of the N= 626
(N= 318HYE+N= 308ME) datasets of T2DM patients revealed similar preference patterns for both survey version were prevention of hypoglycemia (coefficient. HYE:
0,937; coefficient. ME: 0,847) and adjustment of hemoglobin A1c (HbA1c) (coefficient.
HYE: 0,541; coefficient. ME: 0,649) occurred on first rank. Additional healthy life years
(coefficient. HYE: 0,458) or additional cost (coefficient. ME: 0,420) ranked in middle
positions. Side effects of risk of genital infection (coefficient. HYE: 0,301; coefficient.
ME: 0,416), risk of gastrointestinal problems (coefficient. HYE: 0,296; coefficient. ME:
0,408) and risk of urinary tract infection (coefficient. HYE: 0,241; coefficient. ME:
0,355) followed accordingly. Possible weight change (coefficient. HYE: 0,047; coefficient. ME: 0,067) showed no significant effect in this evaluation. Conclusions:
For the first time the methods of HYE and ME were used in one study to be able to
compare patients’ preferences regarding those two continuous currencies (HYE/
ME) of treatment in T2DM, as well as the influence of those criteria on the patient
decision patterns and patient benefit. Therefore, as HYE and ME led to comparable
preference patterns, both can be discussed as summary measures of health outcome, in interchangeable ways, but further research is needed. (IB 209203011/14)
PDB132
Sagit©: A Novel Clinician-Reported Outcome for Managing
Acromegaly in Clinical Practice
Giustina A 1, Bevan J 2, Bronstein M 3, Casanueva F 4, Chanson P 5, Petersenn S 6,
Truong Thanh X M 7, Massien C 7, Dias-Barbosa C 8, Guillemin I 8, Arnould B 8, Melmed S 9
1University of Brescia, Brescia, Italy, 2Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, Aberdeen, UK, 3Hospital das
Clinicas, Sao Paulo, Brazil, 4Universidad de Santiago de Compostela, Santiago de Compostela,
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Spain, 5Hôpital Bicêtre, Kremlin-Bicêtre, France, 6ENDOC Center for Endocrine Tumors, Hamburg,
Germany, 7Ipsen Pharma, Boulogne Billancourt Cedex, France, 8Mapi, Lyon, France, 9Cedars Sinai
Medical Center, Los Angeles, CA, USA
Objectives: SAGIT is a clinician-reported outcome tool designed to help endocrinologists describe acromegaly patients and disease activity in their everyday practice. SAGIT records five elements of the disease: Signs and symptoms (S), Associated
comorbidities (A), GH concentration (G - either assessed as GH nadir after oral glucose tolerance test or GH random or series), IGF-1 concentration (I) and Tumor (T).
The objectives of the present work were to assess acceptability, understanding
and possible uses of SAGIT with endocrinologists in real conditions. Methods:
Endocrinologists from France (n= 2), Germany (n= 1), Italy (n= 2), Spain (n= 2) and
United States (n= 2) completed SAGIT for patients with active acromegaly (n= 9),
controlled/stable acromegaly (n=10) and treatment-naïve patients (n=7). After completion of SAGIT, endocrinologist’s reported their perception and opinion of the tool
using the PRAgmatic Content and face validity Test. Results: Endocrinologists
had no difficulties completing the S, A, I and T elements of SAGIT and reporting the
respective scores based on their patients’ data. Both GH nadir after oral glucose load
and GH random or series were informed by most endocrinologists while information for one of the two elements only is required. The majority of endocrinologists
deemed the information retrieved from SAGIT useful, either for research purpose
(n= 7), decision-making (n= 6), or response therapy assessment (n= 5). They found
it concise, easy to understand and unbiased (n= 8), and simple, quick to complete
and informative (n= 7). Scores and decision rules and interpretation were among
the aspects that required improvement. Scores of each elements of SAGIT vary
according to patient’s acromegaly status. Conclusions: Face and content validity
of SAGIT are demonstrated, as is its applicability in clinical practice and research. It
seems a promising tool for staging and classifying acromegaly patients. The planned
validation study will allow the definition of scoring rules, interpretation and recommendations for managing patients in clinical practice.
PDB133
Patient-Reported Outcomes of Dipeptidyl Peptidase-4 Inhibitors:
A Systematic Review
Franch J 1, Pérez A 2, Lizán L 3, Aceituno S 3, Lopez F 4, Fuster E 4, Granell M 4
1EAP Raval Sud- Institut Català de la Salut - USR Barcelona ciutat - IDIAP Jordi Gol, Barcelona,
Spain, 2Hospital de la Santa Creu I Sant Pau, Barcelona, Spain, 3Outcomes’10, Castellon, Spain,
4Novartis Farmaceutica, Barcelona, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To synthesize the available information on the therapeutic value of
dipeptidyl peptidase-4 inhibitors (DPP-4) for the treatment of type 2 diabetes mellitus
(T2DM) from the point of view of the patient-reported outcomes (PROs). Methods:
A systematic review was performed on International (Pub Med, WOK, Scopus,
Cochrane Library) and Spanish (IBECS, MEDES) databases. Observational studies and
narrative or systematic reviews regarding T2DM patients and use of DPP-4 inhibitors
until June 2013 were selected. Results: We identified 1,713 publications; 317 were
excluded after duplicate review, 1,383 by title/abstract review and 9 after applying
inclusion criteria (n= 9). A total of 4 studies conducted in Italy (n= 1), Germany (n= 1),
USA (n=1), and one international (including Spain) were selected. Three publications
had a retrospective design and 1 was prospective. Two studies reported information
about adherence/persistence, one about satisfaction and one about preferences. No
information about HRQoL was identified. Patients receiving DPP-4 inhibitors were
more likely to be adherent than those treated with Glucagon-like peptide-1 (GLP-1)
agonists [Odds Ratio= 0.40; 95% CI= 0.37-0.42], sulfonylurea [OR= 0.49; 95% CI= 0.460.52] or thiazolidinediones [OR= 0.54; 95% CI= 0.51-0.57]; moreover, DPP-4 inhibitors
were associated with a lower risk of treatment discontinuation [Hazard Ratio= 0.74;
95% CI= 0.71-0.76], explained by a greater tolerability and a lower risk of hypoglycemia. Combination of DPP-4 inhibitors and metformin increased patient’s satisfaction by a 30%, associated with higher control of glucose levels. Most of the patients
preferred DPP-4 inhibitors to GLP-1 agonists (85% vs. 15%; p< 0.001) as first option. In
the Spanish population, the proportion of patients preferring DPP-4 inhibitors was
even higher (90.4% vs. 9.6%; p< 0.001). Conclusions: PROs in DPP-4 inhibitors are
poorly described in the literature. Nevertheless DPP-4 inhibitors are preferred as first
option and are associated with higher persistence and satisfaction, mainly due to
higher perception of glycemic control of glucose level and lower hypoglycemia risk.
PDB134
Assessment of Effect of Continuous Subcutaneous Insulin Infusion
Treatment, Insulin Analog And Human Insulin of Children With
Diabetes
Petkova E 1, Petkova V 1, Petrova G 2, Dimitrova M 1, Konstantinova M 3
1Medical University of Sofia, Faculty of Pharmacy, Sofia, Bulgaria, 2Medical University Sofia,
Faculty of Pharmacy, Sofia, Bulgaria, 3Medical University of Sofia, Pediatric Endocrinology Clinic,
Sofia, Bulgaria
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The objective of the study is to assess the cost of continuous subcutaneous insulin infusion (CSII) application for children with diabetes type 1 in
Sofia, Bulgaria and to compare the changes in BMI and HbA (1c), of three groups of
children- with diabetes – applying insulin pens with human insulin, with analog
insulin and children with insulin pumps. Methods: The study was performed from
the point of view of the health insurance fund and patients. The data collected from
the patients’ dossier including demographics about their age, sex, weight, duration
of disease and HbA (1c) and type of treatment (CSII or analogue insulin treatment
with a pen device). Cost of CSII, blood glucose monitoring system and strips was
calculated. The primary outcome observed was the variation in HbA (1c) and the
secondary was the BMI change. 51 children were observed. The data collected from
the patients’ dossier including demographics about their age, sex, weight, duration
of disease and HbA (1c) and type of treatment (CSII or analogue insulin treatment
with a pen device). Results: The total yearly cost weighed with the duration of
the disease is 1850 Euro (30% reimbursed). The average improvement of HbA (1c)
after the CSII introduction is 1.72 and the average BMI was 37.03. Conclusions:
Improvements in glycemic control associated with CSII led to reduced HbA (1c)
A356
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
that can guarantee good diabetes management, but its control over BMI in growing
children is still unclear. The insulin pumps have too many advantages: reduction
in insulin requirements, reduced variability of insulin absorption, decreased hypoglycemia incidents, avoided pain, improved quality of life.
PDB135
Patient Preferences in Treatment of Diabetes Mellitus: A Systematic
Review of Stated Preference Surveys
Mühlbacher A C , Kaczynski A
Hochschule Neubrandenburg, Neubrandenburg, Germany
.
.
.
Objectives: Diabetes Mellitus is one of the most expensive common diseases.
Because of the great socio-economic importance of this indication, it seems necessary to consider the expectations and needs of all patients with regard to treatment characteristics. To evaluate patient preferences stated-preference methods
are increasingly used. The aim was to analyze and compare the available evidence
from patient preference studies regarding the treatment characteristics and to display which target criteria are most important from the patients view. Methods: A
literature review in PubMed was conducted to identify stated preference studies in
the indication of diabetes and show which properties of a treatment are relevant
to the patient’s benefit. By means of level difference calculation and a subsequent
normalization uniform weights for the attributes of the studies were determined.
Based on a final ranking the key criteria according to their value proposition from
the perspective of affected populations are demonstrated. Results: N= 13 studies
could be included in the analysis. By calculating the level difference and performing
a normalization it was possible to obtain a uniform representation of all attributes
of each study. The analysis includes the presentation and analysis of DCE-studies
which have illustrated the determined coefficients. The studies show that blood
sugar control, side effects (such as hypoglycemia, nausea/stomach discomfort,
weight changes), long-term complications (especially cardiovascular disease) and
mode of administration represent the most patient-relevant outcomes in diabetes
therapy. Blood glucose control achieved the highest ranking within the relative
importance score. Conclusions: Based on the findings of this systematic review
the evidence of patient preferences in diabetes treatment is synthesized. The results
show the relative importance based on a derived ranking score of the used patientrelevant endpoints. The determined ranking allows the comparison of the results of
the identified preference studies and might solve the problem of scale heterogeneity.
PDB136
Psychometric Evaluation of the Hypoglycaemia Perspectives
Questionnaire in Patients With Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus
Ong S H 1, Kawata A K 2, Kulich K 1, Wilson H 3, Coyne K S 2, Evripidou P 4, Koutsides P 5,
Kyriakidou-Himonas M 6, Loizou T 7, Olympios G 8, Pastellas C 4, Picolos M 9, Stylianou A 8,
Toufexis C 10, Therapontos C 11
1Novartis Pharma AG, Basel, Switzerland, 2Evidera, Bethesda, MD, USA, 3Evidera, Seattle, WA,
USA, 4Private Practice, Limassol, Cyprus, 5Limassol General Hospital, Limassol, Cyprus, 6Private
Practice, Larnaca, Cyprus, 7Iatrodiagnosis Medical Centre, Nicosia, Cyprus, 8Larnaca General
Hospital, Larnaca, Cyprus, 9Alithias Endocrinology Center, Nicosia, Cyprus, 10Hippocrateon
Private Hospital, Nicosia, Cyprus, 11Novartis Pharma Services Inc., Nicosia, Cyprus
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The Hypoglycaemia Perspectives Questionnaire (HPQ) is a patientreported outcomes (PRO) instrument assessing diabetic patients’ experience
and perceptions of hypoglycaemia. The aim of this study is to evaluate the factor
structure and psychometric characteristics of the HPQ in type 2 diabetic patients
(T2DM). Methods: HPQ was administered to adults with T2DM in a clinical sample
from Cyprus and a community sample in the US from 2011 US National Health and
Wellness Survey. Demographic and clinical data were collected. Participants completed the Audit of Diabetes Dependent Quality of Life (ADDQoL-19), treatment satisfaction items, and EuroQol-5 Dimensions (EQ-5D) (Cyprus only). HPQ items assess
hypoglycaemia attitudes and behaviours on an 11-point numeric rating scale (NRS).
Item performance and factor structure were examined and measurement properties
(reliability, construct validity, known-groups validity) evaluated. Results: Cyprus
(n=500) and US (n= 1,257) T2DM samples were of similar age (Cyprus 61.0±10 years,
US 59.9±11 years). Cyprus had more males (67.4% vs. 54.2%) and fewer obese subjects (BMI ≥30) 45.6% vs. 67.8%) than the US. More US subjects reported hypoglycaemia events in the past seven days (27.7% vs. 16.6% with ≥ 1 event). Prescription oral
diabetes medications were used by 90.3% of Cyprus participants and 83.6% of US
participants, and insulin by 32.9% and 25.3%, respectively. Analyses supported three
HPQ domains: Symptom Concern (six items), Compensatory Behavior (five items),
and Worry (five items). Internal consistency was high for all three domains (all ≥0.75),
supporting reliability. Convergent validity was supported by moderate correlations
between HPQ domain scores and ADDQoL-19 total score. Patients with recent hypoglycaemia events had significantly higher HPQ scores supporting known-group validity. Conclusions: HPQ is a valid and reliable measure capturing the experience and
impact of hypoglycaemia and can be useful in clinical trial and community-based
settings.
PDB137
The Prevalence of Hypoglycemia and Its Impact on The Quality of
Life of Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus Patients in Greece (The Hypo Study)
Yfantopoulos J 1, Hatzikou M 2, Rombopoulos G 2, Panitti E 2, Latsou D 3
and Kapodistrian University of Athens, Athens, Greece, 2Novartis Hellas, Metamorfosis,
Greece, 3University of Peloponnese, Corinth, Greece
.
.
.
.
.
1National
Hypoglycemia (Hypo) is a common adverse effect of type 2 diabetes (T2D) therapy.
Hypo has a negative impact on health care resources and quality of life (QoL) and
can affect compliance and T2D control. Objectives: To estimate the impact of
Hypo on the QoL as well as its prevalence on T2D patients in Greece. Methods: A
cross-sectional epidemiological study was conducted in 6631 patients with T2DM.
Hypo events with different treatment regimens, T2D control rates and QoL were
assessed. Hypo episodes were defined as laboratory-confirmed (< 70 mg/dl) symptomatic events. QoL was measured using the patient-administered ADDQoL-19
questionnaire. Diabetes control was defined as Hb1Ac ≤ 7%. Results: The majority of the sample were male (55%) and overweight (59% had BMI 25-29.9). 20.4% of
T2DM patients had a history of laboratory-confirmed hypoglycemia. In total, 59%
had HbA1c > 7%. The mean age was 60 and the mean T2D duration was 10 years. The
mean QoL score of the total sample was -3.1± 1.9, the mean score of non-hypoglycemic patients was -3.05 ± 2.0 while the respective score of hypoglycemic patients
was -3.26 ±1.8, (p≤ 0.005). Similar results were observed in the group of controlled
patients and uncontrolled patients, who scored -2.73±1.7 and -3.33±1.9, respectively
(p≤ 0.005). Comparable results were identified in the majority of the ADDQoL-19
instruments’ dimensions. According to the logistic regression analysis the majority
of the ADDQoL-19 dimensions were significantly affected by hypoglycemia, as well
as by high levels of HbA1c. Conclusions: The study confirmed that the QoL of
Greek T2D patients is negatively affected by hypoglycemic events and the level of
the disease control. In T2D, treatment should attain good glycemic control without
debilitating hypoglycemic episodes, which compromise patients’ QoL.
PDB138
The Impact Of Daytime And Nocturnal Non-Severe Hypoglycaemic
Events On People With Diabetes In Turkey
Emral R
Ankara University Medical Faculty, Ankara, Turkey
.
Objectives: Two surveys were conducted to assess the impact of nocturnal and
daytime hypoglycaemia on the individual and on the Turkish economy. Methods:
People with diabetes who had experienced a non-severe hypoglycaemic event in
the 4 weeks prior to the survey were eligible for inclusion. The surveys were conducted face to face; all information, including hypoglycaemic events, was selfreported. Results: In the Turkish cohort, 95 people responded (50 for the nocturnal
survey [N]; 55 for the daytime survey [D]). Mean age was 49 years/48 years (N/D),
mean weight was 76.9 kg/75.2 kg (N/D), 40%/31% (N/D) of respondents were male,
and 64%/80% (N/D) had type 2 diabetes. Among respondents with type 2 diabetes,
63%/48% (N/D) received insulin ± OADs and 63%/66% (N/D) received OADs ± insulin. Non-severe hypoglycaemic episodes were experienced at least once/week by
20%/35% (N/D) and at least once/month by 58%/73% (N/D) of respondents. After the
non-severe nocturnal (N) /daytime (D) hypoglycaemic event, 16% and 9% (N/D) of
respondents decreased their insulin dose and 16% and 20%, respectively, contacted
a health care professional. On average, respondents used 1.5 or 1.6 (N/D) extra blood
glucose tests the following week, and 34%/26% (N/D) of those surveyed reported a
high level of fear of a hypoglycaemic event. Of respondents who worked for pay
(n= 22/17), 59%/77% (N/D) reported a high/medium impact on work productivity following a hypoglycaemic event. Mean time to return to sleep following a nocturnal
event was 60 minutes; 28% reported that the event had a high impact on sleep, and
54% had difficulty focusing at work the next day. Conclusions: In Turkey, nocturnal and daytime non-severe hypoglycaemic events impact quality of life, utilisation
of health care resources and productivity in people with diabetes.
PDB139
Health Related Quality of Life Outcomes (Hrqol) and Resource
Use Associated With Type 2 Diabetes Patients Taking Steps To Lose
Weight In 5 European Countries
Nuhoho S 1, Vietri J 2, Isherwood G 3, Worbes-Cerezo M 4
Health, Milan, Italy, 3Kantar Health, Epsom, UK,
4Janssen-Cilag UK, High Wycombe, UK
.
.
.
.
1Janssen-Cilag A/S, Birkerød, Denmark, 2Kantar
Objectives: Weight control is a cornerstone of type 2 diabetes (T2DM) management,
but the impact of losing small to moderate amounts of weight relative to gaining
weight on patient-reported outcomes and resource use among T2DM patients is
not widely reported. This study was conducted to describe the association of weight
change in T2DM patients taking steps to lose weight (TSLW) with HRQoL, work productivity and resource use in European T2DM patients. Methods: Data came from
the 2013 5EU National Health and Wellness Survey, representative of adults in France,
Germany, Italy, Spain and the United Kingdom. Respondents TSLW who lost ≤5kg were
compared to respondents who gained weight. Outcome measures included SF-36v2,
Work Productivity & Activity Impairment Questionnaire, and 6-month self-reported
health care use. Comparisons used pairwise t-tests and chi-square tests for continuous and categorical variables, respectively. Results: Of 1,985 respondents taking
steps to lose weight, 61% were male, 37% were employed with mean BMI 32.3 kg/
m2. Relative to respondents who gained weight (n= 354), respondents who lost ≤5kg
(n= 560) had higher scores on mental component summary by 3.9 points (p<0.05),
higher physical component summary by 2.3 points (p<0.05), and SF-6D health utility
by 0.05 points (p< 0.05). This group reported lower work and activity impairment as
well as lower health care resource utilisation relative to those who gained weight, with
lower mean presenteeism (22% vs. 28%, p< 0.05), activity impairment (34% vs. 44%,
p<0.05), health care provider visits (7.8 vs. 10.2 p<0.05), emergency room visits (0.2
vs. 0.6; p<0.05) and hospitalizations (0.2 vs. 0.4; p< 0.05). Conclusions: Treatments
which facilitate small to moderate weight loss may offer T2DM patients better HRQoL
and potentially offer savings to the health care system when compared to treatments
which promote weight gain. Further research is required to explain this observation.
PDB140
Racial Disparities in Type 2 Diabetes Health Care Utilization in
Medicaid Adults With Developmental Disabilities
Patel I 1, Erickson S 2, Bagozzi R P 1, Chang J 3, Caldwell C 4, Woolford S 4, Balkrishnan R 1
1University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA, 2The University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA,
3Samford University, Birmingham, AL, USA, 4University of Michigan, ANN ARBOR, MI, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Adults with developmental disabilities have higher prevalence of chronic
disease conditions such as diabetes, obesity, high blood pressure, arthritis, CVD and
chronic pain. They also have poor health care utilization and screened less for chronic
disease conditions. The objective of this study was to examine the association of race,
and medication adherence, and their interaction with health care utilization and
health care costs in Medicaid enrollees with developmental disabilities (DD) and type
A357
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
2 diabetes. Methods: This was a retrospective cohort study that identified the DD
adults with type 2 diabetes from the MarketScan® Multi-State Medicaid Database.
Enrollees aged 18-64 years who received new anti-diabetic medications from January 1,
2004 and December 31, 2006 were included. An index diagnosis date was assigned to
each patient and adults with a continuous enrollment for at least 12 months were
included. Multivariate negative binomial regression was used to measure the rate of
change in type 2 diabetes related health care utilization (inpatient, outpatient and
emergency department visits) in DD patients. Multivariate linear regression with logtransformation was used to determine type 2 diabetes related health care costs in DD
Medicaid enrollees. Results: The study population comprised of 1529 patients. After
controlling for all the covariates, compared to DD Caucasians, DD African Americans
were more likely to have type diabetes related inpatient (OR= 1.71; 95% CI, 1.02-2.85)
and emergency department visits (OR, 1.67; 95% CI, 1.02-2.73). After holding all the
other covariates constant, among DD patients with type 2 diabetes, compared to
Caucasians, African American patients had 23% significantly higher medication
costs, 26% significantly higher medical costs and 21% significantly higher overall
costs respectively. Conclusions: Racial disparities exist in health care utilization in
DD Medicaid patients with type 2 diabetes. Access to culturally competent health care
providers, providers who accept Medicaid patients and continuous care can reduce
inpatient visits and emergency room visits in racial minorities.
PDB141
Association of Hypoglycemia With Different Oral Antidiabetic
Treatments and Its Impact on Quality of Life and Disease Control
In Patients With Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus (The Hypo Study)
Rombopoulos G 1, Hatzikou M 1, Panitti E 1, Latsou D 2, Yfantopoulos J 3
1Novartis Hellas, Metamorfosis, Greece, 2University of Peloponnese, Corinth, Greece, 3National and
Kapodistrian University of Athens, Athens, Greece
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The current prevalence of Diabetes Mellitus (DM) in Slovakia ranges
in about 340000 cases. Insulin therapy is realised in the group about 44000 patients,
including about 21000 men and 23000 women in the patients older than 19 years.
Till now in the Czech Republic and in the Slovak Republic there was not realised the
study oriented on the quality of life (QolL) in relation to young people with DM type
I, treated by insulin pens or insulin pumps. Methods: 102 patients with type 1 diabetes mellitus aged from 18 to 35 attending diabetes centres and clinics in Brno and
its surroundings were studied. The method of quantitative research was used to collect the data obtained by standardized questionnaire ADDQoL and DTSQs with the
confirmed copyright. Results: The general value of QoL was 5.65 on the numeric
scale from 0 to 10 (0 for the worst results, 10 for the best results). The positive statistical significance with “p” lesser than 0.05 was find out comparing insulin pump
vs insulin pen: hobby and free time physical activities, family life, recommendation
treatment by pump, and satisfaction with the form of treatment and continuing
of the treatment. The evaluation of these categories has no statistical significance:
too high level of glucose in the blood, too small level of glucose in the blood, the
adaptation to the treatment, and the understanding to the illness. Conclusions:
Statistical evaluation of the hypotheses confirmed a better quality of life in patients
with insulin pump. On the contrary, the difference in perception of the quality of life
between the sexes was not proved. Our research confirmed that the insulin pump
is a modern way of compensation and has a positive impact on the quality of life
in young patients with diabetes.
DIABETES/ENDOCRINE DISORDERS – Health Care Use & Policy Studies
.
Hypoglycemia (Hypo) is a common adverse effect of type 2 diabetes (T2D) therapy.
Oral antidiabetic (OAD) agents differ in their propensity to cause Hypo. Hypo has
a negative impact on health care resources and quality of life (QoL) and can affect
compliance and T2D control. Objectives: To estimate the impact of different
OADs on Hypo prevalence and on the QoL of T2D patients in Greece. Methods:
A cross-sectional epidemiological study was conducted in 6631 patients with T2D.
Hypo events with different treatment regimens, T2D control rates and QoL were
assessed. Hypo episodes were defined as laboratory-confirmed (< 70 mg/dl) symptomatic events. QoL was measured using the patient-administered ADDQoL-19
questionnaire. Diabetes control was defined as Hb1Ac ≤ 7%. Results: Mean age
was 60 and mean T2D duration 10 years. 59% of patients had HbA1c > 7%; 20.4% had
Hypo. Most patients (82%) were on combination therapies, while 14.5% were on oral
monotherapy and the remaining were on insulin or GLP-1 analog treatment. The
overall QoL in the three OAD monotherapy groups [biguanides, DPP4is and sulfonylureas (SUs)] were not statistically significant between groups, regardless of Hypo
status. However, patients treated with biguanide or DPP4i monotherapy had lower
rates of Hypo vs. patients on SU monotherapy (p≤ 0.001) and QoL in Hypo patients
treated with biguanides or DPP-4is was better compared to SUs (p< 0.001). Similarly,
more patients on biguanides and DPP4i monotherapies achieved HbA1c ≤ 7% than
on SU (p≤ 0.001). Patients receiving combinations of biguanides with DPP4is vs.
biguanides with SUs had significantly less Hypo (p≤ 0.001), better diabetes control
(respectively; p≤ 0.001) and better QoL (p≤ 0.05). Conclusions: Biguanides, DPP4is
and their combinations are associated with lower rates of Hypo, better QoL and
T2D control, compared with SUs alone or in combination with biguanides. In T2D,
treatment should attain good glycemic control without debilitating hypoglycemic
episodes, which compromise patients’ QoL.
PDB144
Is the rule of halves applicable in Diabetes Type 2? Evidence from
Greece
Tsiantou V , Karampli E , Zavras D , Athanasakis K , Pavi E , Kyriopoulos J
National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The “rule of halves” (ROH) applies in most common chronic disorders
and suggests that half of the patients are undiagnosed, half of those diagnosed are
not treated, and half of those treated are not controlled. The aim of the present
study was to examine whether the ROH is applicable in the case of Diabetes type 2
in Greece. Methods: Physicians who monitor patients with type 2 diabetes were
invited to participate and complete the online version of a purpose-made questionnaire during a specified time period. An invitation was sent to the national associations of general practitioners (GPs), diabetologists and endocrinologists. The study
took place between April and May 2014. Fully completed questionnaires were included
in the analysis. Data analysis was conducted using STATA 9. Results: 176 physicians
completed the questionnaire of whom 68.7% were men. Mean age was 47.8 years. The
majority were internists and GPs (38.3% and 32.7%, respectively). Physicians estimated
that in Greece 62% of those diagnosed with diabetes type 2 receive some kind of treatment (lifestyle or pharmacotherapy). 59.3% of those diagnosed will present at least
one complication because of the disease. Less than half (43.3%) of those treated are
controlled and achieve treatment targets (HbA1c≤7%). Of those not controlled, 73.3%
will present at least one complication because of diabetes type 2. Conclusions:
According to our findings, in Greece more than half of the diagnosed patients with
diabetes type 2 receive treatment in a regular basis. However, less than half achieve
treatment targets and manage to stay controlled. Emphasis should be given in selfmanagement, patient education and policies raising awareness for the early detection and management of diabetes type 2 in order to increase controlled patients and
decrease the incidence of complications due to the disease.
PDB142
Evaluation of The Impact of Pharmaceutical Cognitive Service on
Quality of Life in Diabetic Patients
PDB145
Physicians Estimation Regarding The Impact Of Recession on Patient
Adherence To Treatment In Diabetes Type 2 In Greece
Yordanova S 1, Petrova G 1, Naseva E 2, Manova M 1
1Medical University Sofia, Faculty of Pharmacy, Sofia, Bulgaria, 2Medical University Sofia, Faculty
of Public Health, Sofia, Bulgaria
Tsiantou V , Zavras D , Karampli E , Athanasakis K , Pavi E , Kyriopoulos J
National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Comparison of the changes in QoL of diabetic patients after pharmaceutical cognitive service with SF-6D. Methods: Tree step methodology was
created and applied towards the patients with type 1 and type 2 diabetes. On first
the QoL of 146 diabetic patients was assessed with the Bulgarian version of SF-6D.
Then educational program for the diabetic patients was developed and applied
during the day of their visits in community pharmacy from June to September 2013.
At the end the changes in the QoL after the pharmaceutical cognitive service was
assessed in the group of 24 patients. Results: The mean age of patients included
in the first step was 57.39 years (SD 17.087; 95%CI 54.60-60.19). 76% of them were
with type 2 diabetes and 73% suffers from diabetes complications. The mean SF-6D
score was 0.629 (SD 0.289; 95%CI 0.58-0.68). After the pharmacy program the type
2 diabetic patients showed better quality of life index 0.7133 that was 10% higher
than the initial score 0.6089. In the patients with type 1 diabetes the improvement of
QoL score is with 3 %. The patients were with mean SF-6D scores: 0.667 on the first
visit in the pharmacy and 0.690 after the educational service. Conclusions: The
study suggests the SF-6D is a valuable tool for QoL assessment of diabetes patients
in Bulgaria. It also shows that SF-6D could be used for pharmacy program evaluation in diabetes patients. Regarding the pharmaceutical cognitive service in diabetic
patients is evident that they have a potential to improve the QoL in patients with
diabetes mellitus and their impact could be measured with SF-6D.
PDB143
Quality Of Life in Teenagers and Young Adolescent Patients With
Diabetes Mellitus Type I With Insulin Pens Or Insulin Pumps In The
Czech Republic
Mastiliakova D 1, Cikova Z 1, Gerlichova K 1, Matisakova I 2, Bielik J 1
1Trencin University, Trencin, Slovak Republic, 2Trencin University of Alexander Dubcek, Trencin,
Slovak Republic
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Adherence to treatment plan and lifestyle advice is crucial for good
health outcomes in diabetic patients. Given that Greece in the last years faces an
unprecedented economic crisis which affects all sectors of economic and social life,
the aim of the present study was to examine whether recession, austerity measures
and implemented health policies had an impact on patient adherence to treatment
in Diabetes type 2 (dt2) in Greece. Methods: A questionnaire was developed for
the purpose of the study. Only Physicians who monitor patients with dt2 (general
practitioners (GPs), diabetologists and endocrinologists) were invited to participate in
the study and complete the online version of a purpose-made questionnaire during a
specified time period. Physicians were recruited through their national associations.
The study took place between April and May 2014. Results: Of the 176 physicians
completing the questionnaire, 68.7% were men. Mean age was 47.8 years. The majority
were internists (38.3%) and GPs (32,7%). Physicians estimated that during the previous year 22.9% of their patients had to quit or modify their treatment plan due to
economic reasons. A somewhat higher percentage (26.9%) was found regarding the
modification of the dietary habits during the previous year due to economic reasons
which led to negative health outcomes. According to the participating physicians the
main reasons for which patients modified or quitted their treatment were the higher
copayments for pharmaceuticals, loss of insurance coverage and barriers of access
to a physician in order to prescribe their medicines. Conclusions: Recession and
recent health policies had a negative impact on patients’ adherence to treatment
leading to poor adherence almost a quarter of patients with dt2, based on the experience of physicians. Equally critical is the fact that patients were forced to modify
their dietary habits.
PDB146
Effect of A Pharmacy-Based Diabetes Management Program on
Glycemic Control in an Inpatient General Medicine Population
Efird L 1, Shermock K M 2
.
.
.
A358
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
1The Johns Hopkins Hospital, Baltimore, MD, USA, 2The Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions,
Baltimore, MD, USA
Objectives: A pharmacy-based inpatient diabetes management program was
evaluated to determine if improved glycemic control could be achieved in a general medicine patient population. Methods: A retrospective chart review of 151
patients with blood glucose (BG) values outside the range 70-180 mg/dL was conducted. Observations for the baseline group (n=84) were derived from July 2010 and
for the intervention group (n= 67) in October 2010. The odds of poor glycemic control
for patients in the intervention versus baseline groups were assessed by multivariate generalized estimating equations. These methods were also used to assess
patient characteristics associated with poor glycemic control. Results: Across all
patients, no evidence was observed indicating the pharmacy program decreased the
proportion of days spent out of the targeted blood glucose range [70-180 mg/dL: OR
0.91 (95% CI: 0.83 – 1.02); 70-250 mg/dL: OR 1.03 (95% CI: 0.88 – 1.24)]. However, the
subgroup of patients whose admission blood glucose was less than 200 mg/dL (55%
of intervention group) experienced a significant reduction in days out of range for
both ranges [70-180 mg/dL (OR: 0.72, 95% CI: 0.61– 0.88) and 70-250 mg/dL (OR: 0.5,
95% CI: 0.33 – 0.71)]. No improvement in glycemic control was observed in patients
with an admission BG 200 mg/dL or greater. These patients had more disease- and
social-related factors associated with poor glycemic control. Conclusions: A subpopulation, patients whose admission glucose was less than 200 mg/dL, experienced
improvement in glycemic control in the pharmacy-based program. The remaining
patients were generally more complicated from a disease-state and social perspective and experienced no improvement. These patients may require a more intense,
multi-disciplinary approach that is better matched to the constellation of factors
responsible for their condition.
PDB147
Compliance to Hemoglobin A1c Testing Recommendations Following
Initial Diabetes Diagnosis
Palmer L A 1, Hansen L G 2
1Truven Health Analytics, Bethesda, MD, USA, 2Truven Health Analytics, Northwood, NH, USA
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The hemoglobin A1c test (HbA1c) is the favored measure of glycemic control for patients with diabetes. Compliance to recommended testing
continues to be a challenge. The current analysis evaluates how compliance to
HbA1c testing varies based on initial HbA1c results. Methods: Newly diagnosed
patients with Type II diabetes were identified using the Truven Health MarketScan
Lab Database (1/1/2010-10/31/2013). Continuous eligibility for the 6 months prior
and 12 months following diagnosis were required for study inclusion. Patient
cohorts were created based on first HbA1c test value (< 7.0% [controlled], ≥ 7.0%
[uncontrolled]). Presence of a subsequent HbA1c test, including test result and
time to test, were evaluated for these cohorts. Results: A total of 133,011
patients met the study inclusion criteria; approximately 40% had evidence of
an initial HbA1c test (n= 33,616 with HbA1c < 7.0%; n= 19,033 with HbA1c ≥ 7.0%).
Approximately 64% (n= 21,497) of controlled patients had a subsequent HbA1c
test (86% with HbA1c < 7.0%, 14% with HbA1c ≥ 7.0%); 91% (n= 17,344) of uncontrolled patients had a subsequent HbA1c test (36% with HbA1c < 7.0%, 64% with
HbA1c ≥ 7.0%). Mean times (in days [d]) to subsequent HbA1c test (and result)
were as follows: Among initially controlled patients: 231d (controlled) and 370d
(uncontrolled); among initially uncontrolled patients: 238d (controlled) and 212d
(uncontrolled). Mean time to HbA1c test was significantly longer for controlled
patients with HbA1c ≥ 7.0% for subsequent test relative to controlled patients
with HbA1c < 7.0% and to uncontrolled patients with HbA1c ≥ 7.0% for subsequent
tests. Conclusions: Compliance to recommended timing for HbA1c testing
is suboptimal in the majority of patients regardless of initial glycemic control.
Importance of regular HbA1c evaluation should continue to be part of patient
education – particular for patients who may initial appear to have favorable glycemic control.
PDB148
Cost-Effectiveness of Theintroduction of A National Adherence
Program for Type 2 Diabetes In Hungary
Zsólyom A 1, Nagy B 1, Nagyjánosi L 2, Dessewffy Z 3, Steiner T 4, Kaló Z 5, Vokó Z 1
1Eötvös Loránd University, Budapest, Hungary, 2University of Debrecen, Debrecen, Hungary,
3Novartis Hungary, Budapest, Hungary, 4St. John’s Hospital and North-Buda United Institutions,
Budapest, Hungary, 5Eötvös Loránd University (ELTE), Budapest, Hungary
.
.
.
.
.
.
PDB149
Which Newly-Diagnosed Diabetics Should Receive Dietary
Counseling Services? Estimating Individualized Treatment
Allocations that Optimize cost-Effectiveness in Real-World Data
Signorovitch J 1, Betts K A 1, Meng X 1, Zhuo Y 2, Wu E Q 1, Shi L 3
1Analysis Group, Inc., Boston, MA, USA, 2MIT, Cambridge, MA, USA, 3Tulane University, New
Orleans, LA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: All people with type 2 diabetes should receive dietary advice. Some
patients may benefit from additional dietary counseling. This study used recently
developed statistical methods to estimate the efficiency frontier for individualized
allocation of dietary counseling services. I. e., for each level of total health care
expenditure, we estimate the individualized allocation of services that maximizes
clinical benefit in the population. Methods: People newly diagnosed with type 2
diabetes were identified retrospectively from electronic health records and classified
as receiving vs. not receiving dietary counseling. An individualized effectiveness
score for achievement of HbA1c < 7% with vs. without counseling was estimated
using multivariable logistic regression. Demographics, vitals, comorbidities and
lab values served as candidate predictors. Prediction models were validated in a
held-out sample. The efficiency frontier was estimated as the convex hull of the
set of HbA1c control rates and total costs achievable by allocation of dietary counseling based on the effectiveness score. Results: Among 11,819 patients newly
diagnosed with type 2 diabetes, 22% received dietary counseling and 74% achieved
HbA1c control. Greater HbA1c, body mass index and age at the time of diagnosis
were associated with greater effectiveness of dietary counseling. Allocation of all
newly diagnosed diabetics to dietary counseling was estimated to increase the
rate of HbA1c control to 80% at a cost of 56 USD per patient vs. current practice. An
efficient allocation rule (counseling only the 55% of patients predicted to benefit
most) achieved the same 80% control rate with an incremental cost of 6 USD per
patient. Conclusions: Retrospective analysis of real-world data identified opportunities to improve diabetes outcomes vs. current practice with minimal expense
through individualized allocation of dietary counseling. This result warrants validation in separate data. The analytical methods warrant broader use to investigate
efficient allocation of treatments.
PDB150
Chronic Care Management
Gajdos O , Jurickova I
Czech Technical University in Prague, Kladno, Czech Republic
.
.
Objectives: Chronic illness is a prolonging health defect, which is causing a big
use of financial means for its medical care. These means are not being coordinated
and used effectively. The aim of this study was to suggest a management care
system of the chronically ill in the Czech Republic, which should increase the
quality of medical care and decrease the costs of it. Methods: There was chosen
an appropriate diagnosis and concept for the management care, which were based
on analysis of the current state. The type 2 diabetes mellitus was chosen as an
appropriate chronic illness and for the management care concept was chosen
Patient-Centered Medical Home.. The randomized selection of 100 patients was
made in ordinary diabetes ambulance. The cost of illness was counted from the
direct costs from the perspective of the society, of the payer and of the patient.
The cost effectiveness analysis, which was comparing a standard treatment and
chosen concept, was based on randomized selection, studies of Patient-Centered
Medical Home and recommended standards of professional society. There were
also used methods of value engineering especially Saaty matrix and multi-criteria decision making, mainly TOPSIS method for setting the scales of criteria
and effect. Results: The average costs of one patient are from the perspective
of the society 29 531 CZK, the payer 20 976 CZK and of the patient 9 196 CZK. The
Patient–Centered Medical Home has taken the first place in comparison with a
standard treatment, which was based on the cost of effectiveness analysis. The
payer will obtain a 25.7x10-5 of the effect for Patient-Centered Medical Home
according a spent monetary unit. Conclusions: The costs of the chosen concept
can be more effective. The concept would provide greater prevention, quality and
coordinated care and can be used for other chronic diseases.
.
Objectives: The Syreon health economic model was developed to predict long
term effects of screening, treatment and control of type 2 diabetes, by taking into
account baseline patient characteristics, history of complications, changes in physiological parameters, diabetes treatment and management strategies and screening
programs. The aim of this analysis was to assess the cost-effectiveness of introducing a national public health program in Hungary to improve diabetes patient’s
adherence in comparison to not introducing the program. Methods: According
to the guideline of the Hungarian National Diabetes Association, the target HbA1c
level is below 7%, except for special cases, where it is 8% or less. Without an organized patient education program 45% of the patients with known diabetes have
higher than the target HbA1c level. In the studied scenario, the education program
improves the patient adherence by 30% and increases the proportion of diabetic
patients achieving the target HbA1c level to 72%. Patients reaching the target HbA1c
level fully enjoy the benefits of efficient treatment. Non-adherent patients have
higher HbA1c levels and face higher risk for diabetes-related complications, e. g.
stroke, neuropathy or retinopathy. Results: The Syreon diabetes model is capable
of analyzing the consequences of introducing the adherence program for patients
with diagnosed diabetes. The results of the cost-effectiveness analysis were sensitive to the starting age of the target population and the effectiveness of the training
program. Conclusions: Organized patient education program was predicted to
be cost-effective compared with no program in Hungary. The education program
contributes to better patient adherence resulting in better health and less disease
related complications.
PDB151
A Comparative Analysis on The Reimbursement Status Of Sensor
Augmented Pump Therapy in Turkey and Other Selected Countries
Seyhun O , Erdol S , Can H , Erdogan E
Medtronic, Inc., Istanbul, Turkey
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Sensor augmented therapy (SAP) with automated insulin suspension is the most advanced technology for the treatment of severe and moderate
hypoglisemia in patients with type 1 diabetes mellitus. In order to sustain a better uptake of sensor augmented therapy for patients, it is crucial for this technology to be included in the reimbursement scheme of Turkey and in the other
countries. Thus, we aimed to study and analyze reimbursement status of this
technology in Turkey and across other selected countries of Western Asia, North
America and Western Pacific. Methods: Mainly official web resources such as
health authority web pages, direct contact with authority responsibles and published articles on SAP are utilized. Results: Most of the countries examined
have either reimbursement or limited status of SAP. European countries such
as Ireland, The Netherlands, Sweden, Estonia, Czech Republic; Israel in Western
Asia, Japan in Western Pacific and USA are the ones where this technology is reimbursed mainly for patients with Type 1 Diabetes. Within these selected countries,
Turkey has a position of having reasonably well defined reimbursement status
for SAP despite insufficient number of sensors reimbursed - 2 sensors instead
of 5 sensors a month; which potentially causes an incomplete therapy for the
patients. Conclusions: Despite the operational hurdles and insufficient number
of sensors reimbursed per patient in Turkey, the country still stands as a successful example of reimbursement practice, by making this technology available for
the indicated patients.
A359
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PDB152
Prescription of Rosiglitazone and Pioglitazone Folowing Safety
Warnings: A Comparative Analysis of Trends in Dispensing Patterns
in Denmark and Germany From 2007 To 2013
Hostenkamp G 1, Fischer K E 2
of Health Economics Research (COHERE), Odense M, Denmark, 2University of Hamburg,
Hamburg, Germany
.
.
.
1Center
Objectives: Investigate how official drug safety warnings for thiazolidinediones
(TZDs, rosiglitazone and pioglitazone) affected prescription trends for TZDs in
Denmark and Germany and to compare the prescription patterns to data published
for Australia, UK and the US. Methods: Identified the timing and content of all
drug warnings for TZDs using the FDA’s and EMA’s databases. Using pharmaceutical
claims data on all diabetes patients in Denmark and a large public health insurance
fund in Germany, plotted the number of defined daily dosages (DDDs) per month for
rosiglitazone and pioglitazone normalized per 1000 insurees for both countries from
January 2007 -December 2013. Results: In Denmark rosiglitazone monotherapy
prescriptions remained almost constant after publication of the safety warnings
in May 2007 until drug suspension in September 2010, but declined fairly fast in
Germany. Prescription of rosiglitazone combined with metformin declined by 1/3
compared to their May 2007 levels in both countries. Overall market penetration of
rosiglitazone prior to the drug warnings was ~1 DDD per day per 1000 insurees in
Germany and 0.36 in Denmark, and therefore much lower than in Australia where
rosiglitazone peaked at about 2 DDDs per 1000 insurees. The FDA’s safety warning
for increased risk of heart failure for all TZDs in August 2007 did not affect prescription growth rates for pioglitazone in Germany or Denmark. However, pioglitazone prescriptions declined after the FDA’s and EMA’s safety warning for possibly
increased risk of bladder cancer for pioglitazone patients in June and July 2011 in
both countries. Conclusions: TZD prescriptions in Germany and Denmark did not
decline as radically after the publication of safety warnings as in other countries.
Differences in reaction speed may reflect different levels of market penetration prior
to the drug safety warnings and differences in the intensity of the safety warning
issued by the drug administration authority.
PDB154
Assessing The Medication Use Among Diabetic Patients With
Comorbid Diseases
Azmi S 1, Mustapha F I 2, Abdul Aziz S H 1
Burhani Consulting, Petaling Jaya, Malaysia, 2Disease Control Division, Putrajaya,
Malaysia
.
.
.
.
.
1Azmi
Objectives: Type 2 Diabetes is on the rise in many Asian countries with growing
economic prosperity. Treatment patterns of diabetic patients in South East Asia have
rarely been studied using administrative data. Our objective was to understand medication use patterns among Malaysian patients with diabetes with comorbidities in
the primary health care setting. This may be useful for understanding treatment
strategies in subgroups of patients with diabetes who tend to pose more complex
challenges in clinical decision-making. Methods: Data was obtained from diabetic
patients who were audited in the NDR in 2012. Descriptive analysis was used to
describe medication usage for patients with various comorbidities. Medications of
interest were antiplatelet medications, lipid-lowering agents, anti-hypertensive and
various classes of anti-diabetic medications including insulin. Results: A total of
130,270 patients were identified with comorbidities. Mean age of patients was 59.8
years old and 60.2% were female. A majority of patients were hypertensive (70.3%),
more than half were dyslipidemic (55.1%). Other comorbidities such as retinopathy,
ischemic heart disease (IHD), cerebrovascular disease, nephropathy, diabetic foot
ulcer, amputation, hypertension and dyslipidemia were recorded among less than
10% of patients. Among non-diabetes medications, statins was the most commonly
used ranging from 64.6% to 86.3% for various comorbidities. This was followed by
ACE-inhibitors and aspirin. Among anti-diabetic medications, metformin was the
most commonly prescribed followed by sulfonylureas and insulins. Conclusions:
The registry data was able to shed light on patterns of medication usage among
diabetic patients with comorbidities. Perhaps in the future, this data can be used
to evaluate long-term outcomes among patients on various treatment plans and
finally to inform more evidence-based clinical management strategies relating to
medication use.
PDB155
Six Years Of Incretin-Based Agents in Diabetes 2nd Type Treatment
in the Czech Republic: The Utilization And Expenditure
Fuksa L 1, Vytrisalova M 2
1General Health Insurance Company of the Czech Republic, Praha, Czech Republic, 2Charles
University, Faculty of Pharmacy, Hradec Kralove, Czech Republic
.
.
Objectives: The objective was to analyze evolving consumption, public costs as
well as prescription practice pattern of the newer anti-diabetic drugs interfering
with incretin system, i. e. DPP-IV inhibitors (“gliptins”) and GLP-1 mimetics, and
compare it to other drugs in the anti-diabetic portfolio. Methods: The pharmacy claims-based database of the General Health Insurance Company of the
Czech Republic (VZP CR) was used as the data source. An insured person with a
recorded prescription for any of the drugs of interest (ATC3 classification A10B:
blood glucose-lowering drugs excl. insulins) between 2008 and 2013 was defined as
a patient. Information on pricing and reimbursement were obtained from the files
of administrative proceedings at the State Institute for Drug Control. Results:
Since the introduction of sitagliptin in autumn 2008 its utilization rose to 2.1 DDD/
TID in 2013, which makes it the most prescribed incretin-based drug. Overall consumption of all incretin-based therapies was 5.4 DDD/TID in 2013 and the patient
number represents 9 % of all patients taking any anti-diabetic drug of the ATC A10B
group (except for insulins). However, in terms of public costs incretin-based agents
represent already 55% of all the blood glucose-lowering therapy of the evaluated
A10B group (insulines excluded). In comparison, the utilization of the 1st line drug
metformin between 2008 and 2013 has been annually rising by 5 % to 10 %, while in
other groups, namely sulfonylureas and thiazolidinediones, it has been declining
each year on average by 2 % and 15 %, respectively. Conclusions: The uptake of
incretin-based drugs since 2008 has been rapid and their utilization keeps rising,
apparently at the expense of other drugs, namely older sulfonylurea derivatives and
thiazolidinediones. Consequently the overall public expenditure on anti-diabetic
therapy has been increasing.
PDB156
Non-Adherence And Non-Persistence Related To Glp-1 Therapy
In Patients With Diabetes Mellitus Type 2 (T2dm): Analysis of A
Large German Claims-Based Dataset And Comparison To Oral AntiDiabetics
Wilke T 1, Groth A 1, Berg B 1, Sikirica M 2, Martin A A 3, Fuchs A 4, Maywald U 5
1IPAM - Institute for Pharmacoeconomics and Medication Logistics, Wismar, Germany,
2GlaxoSmithKline, King of Prussia, PA, USA, 3GlaxoSmithKline, Uxbridge, UK, 4AOK Plus, Dresden,
Germany, 5AOK Plus - Die Gesundheitskasse für Sachsen und Thüringen, Dresden, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: This study describes the extent of non-adherence (NA) and non-persistence (NP) with Glucagon-like peptide 1 agonists (GLP-1) and oral anti-diabetic
(OAD) therapy in T2DM patients in clinical practice in Germany. Methods: Claims
data from a German sickness fund (AOK Plus) from 2010-2012 were used to identify
patients with ≥ 1 diagnosis for T2DM. NA/NP were measured for patients initiating new T2DM medication (no prescription of respective medication in prior 6
months) over a minimum of 12 months. A 100% adherence to therapy was assumed
equivalent to the drug-specific DDD (defined daily dosage). NP was defined as a
medication gap ≥ 90 days. Adherence was calculated via medication possession
ratios (MPR), NA was defined as MPR< 80%. Descriptive analyses with percentage
of patients affected by NP and/or NA were conducted. Results: The NP analysis,
included 2,490/42,891 T2DM patients initiating GLP-1s/OADs. Among GLP-1 patients,
408/1,727/135 received twice-daily (BID; exenatide)/once-daily (OD; liraglutide)/onceweekly (OW; exenatide) therapies. Average age for GLP-1/OAD users was 56 (SD
10.8) /67 (SD 12.6) years. After 12 months, the percentage of patients with NP was
36.83% (all GLP-1s), 42.65% (BID), 37.64% (OD), 27.41% (OW), and 55.87% (OAD). The
NA analysis included 2,154/34,128 T2DM patients initiating GLP-1/OAD therapy with
≥ 1 follow-up prescription. Average age was 56 (SD 10.6) /66 (SD 12.2) years. Average
MPR was 88.2% (all GLP-1s), 87.8% (BID), 88.2% (OD), 95.0% (OW), and 63.2% (OAD).
Percentage of patients affected by NA was 21.96% (all GLP-1s), 23.98% (BID), 22.00%
(OD), 5.74% (OW), and 65.82% (OAD). Conclusions: In this German dataset, overall
patients with T2DM had low rates of adherence and persistence despite the chronic
nature of the disease and clinical sequelae. Higher adherence and persistence rates
were observed with GLP-1s than with OAD medications and also with less frequently
dosed GLP-1s.
PDB157
Type 2 Diabetes Treatment Patterns Across Europe
Heintjes E 1, Overbeek J A 1, Blin P 2, Hall G C 3, Lapi F 4, Prieto Alhambra D 5, Bezemer I D 1
Institute for Drug Outcomes Research, Utrecht, The Netherlands, 2INSERM CIC
Bordeaux CIC1401, Univ. Bordeaux, Bordeaux, France, 3Grimsdyke House, London, UK,
4Genomedics SRL, Firenze, Italy, 5IDIAP Jordi Gol, Barcelona, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1PHARMO
Objectives: To describe the sequential treatment classes of type 2 diabetes (T2DM)
patients initiating antidiabetic drug therapy in the Netherlands, UK (UK), Spain,
Italy and France. To describe treatment scaling (intensification or de-intensification)
in the overall T2DM population. Methods: Antidiabetic drug use during a 5-year
study period (2007-2011/2008-2012) (n= 639,088) was obtained from electronic health
care databases. A standardized analytic tool performed treatment pattern analyses
in each database for the overall population and those initiating treatment. Oral
monotherapy was defined as first line, oral dual therapy as second line, multiple oral
treatments or oral in combination with an injectable as third line and injectables
only as fourth line therapy. Results: Newly treated patients represented 33-42%
of the overall T2DM population. Metformin monotherapy was the most common
initial therapy (65%-87%). Around 35% (Netherlands, Italy, UK) to 45% (Spain, France)
switched treatment within the study period. The first switch was most often to metformin plus a sulfonylurea (SU) in the Netherlands (47%), UK (45%), Spain (22%), Italy
(17%), but to DPP4 inhibitors in France (15%). DPP4 inhibitor use increased during
the study period (France 0% to 27%, UK and Spain < 1% to 9%) but remained limited
in the Netherlands (4%) and Italy (2%). In the total cohort, first line treatment was
most prevalent over all the years in all countries (around 50%). Intensification was
the most common switch. Switching patients mostly stepped up or down one line
at a time, but larger steps were also observed. Fourth line therapy was uncommon
in France (1-2%) but accounted for about 10% in the other countries. Conclusions:
SU remained the most common add-on treatment to metformin in most European
countries while DPP4 inhibitor use was common in France and increased in other
countries. Most T2DM patients are treated with oral monotherapy.
PDB158
Exploring The Determinants of Endocrinologist Visits In France
Andrade L F 1, Rapp T 2, Sevilla-Dedieu C 1
Foundation for Public Health, Paris, France, 2University of Paris Descartes, Paris, France
.
.
.
.
1MGEN
Objectives: Recent studies reported that seeing an endocrinologist is associated
with better compliance with guidelines on diabetes management. This study aims
at investigating the socioeconomic determinants of endocrinologist visits among a
French population of diabetics. Methods: We used claim data collected for 66,508
affiliates of a French social security provider (MGEN). Patients were aged over 18
and treated for diabetes (types I and II). We ran logistic regressions to explore which
factors were associated with the probability of consulting an endocrinologist. We
controlled for patients’ socioeconomic characteristics (sex, age, income, marital
status, activity status), type of treatment, medical care and health status. We also
controlled for macro-level variables, such as the cost for a visit, the distance to the
office and the medical density. Results: Women, married patients, and those working are more likely to consult an endocrinologist (p< 0.001). Age has a non-linear
A360
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
association with the probability of seeing an endocrinologist: rates of specialist
visits are the largest under the age of 25 (p< 0.05). In addition, people treated with
insulin and those with another endocrine disorder are more likely to see a specialist (p< 0.001). In contrast, the newly diagnosed and patients followed by a general
practitioner (GP) present lower probabilities of specialist visits (p< 0.001). Moreover,
the probability of specialist visit rises when the density of endocrinologists is large
in the patients’ neighbourhood, while it decreases with the distance (in kilometres) from the patients’ house to the endocrinologist’s office. Finally, the chances
of seeing a specialist increase with income and decrease as the cost for a visit
rises. Conclusions: Our results are consistent with previous literature showing
evidence of the existence of a substitution effect between GPs and specialists in
diabetes care. We show that financial barriers exist even in a population of patients
receiving national health insurance coverage.
PDB159
Payer’s Perceptions of Glucagon Kits Aimed at Reducing
Administration Complexity During Severe Hypoglycemic Events
Leinwand B , Hughes K E , Bartelme A
Avalere Health, Washington, DC, DC, USA
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Severe hypoglycemic events (SHE) contribute to health care utilization for insulin-dependent diabetics, and may drive expenditures by health care
payers. Rescue treatment for SHE includes glucagon kits, which are administered
by caregivers and difficult to use. Consequently, there are high rates of unsuccessful administration, leading to increased health care service use. A new kit under
development aims to ease the burden of administration by reducing the complexity. The new device aims to increase successful use and lower rates of health care
service utilization. This study aimed to understand payers’ receptivity to this value
proposition. Methods: Seven medical directors from US payers were interviewed,
representing commercial, Medicare, Medicaid and other covered lives. The interview
was designed to understand plans’ focus on diabetes and hypoglycemia, coverage/reimbursement of current kits, and impressions of characteristics of the new
kit. Results: The prevention of SHE is not a concern for insurers; the risk of SHE
is largely a type 1 problem, representing a small subset of their overall diabetic
population. While payers are confident in current kits’ effectiveness, they are not
focused on managing access to such a low-volume treatment. Current kits are covered by insurers without restrictions, and contracting is not prevalent due to low
volume. Payers believe the new kit will be an improvement over current kits, but do
not believe it will reduce the cost of SHE. Conclusions: Payers feel that the new
kit will be an improvement over currently available kits, but are skeptical that the
ease of use will translate into lower health care service use. Additionally, SHE is not
a major cost driver among their diabetic population; therefore, SHE is not a highpriority condition. Consequently, for optimal market access and reimbursement, the
new kit must demonstrate significant reductions in high-cost health care utilization
(e.g., ED, hospitalizations) to justify a premium price without coverage restrictions.
PDB160
An Observational Cohort Study of Diabetes-Associated Secondary
Health Care Utilisation in Patients With Type 2 Diabetes Prescribed
Dual Combination Therapy With Oral Anti-Hyperglycaemic Agents
in the UK
Das R 1, Langerman H 1, D’Oca K 2, Strongman H 3
1Merck Sharp & Dohme, Hoddesdon, UK, 2Merck Sharp and Dohme Ltd, Hoddesdon, UK, 3CPRD,
London, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The primary objective was to assess the impact of using ‘metformin
plus sulphonylureas’ (Met+SU) in comparison with ‘metformin plus other oral
anti-hyperglycaemic agents’ (Met+OHA) in patients with Type 2 Diabetes (T2D)
on diabetes-associated secondary health care utilisation in the UK. The secondary objectives included investigating individual components of the primary objective. Methods: This retrospective cohort study used data from the Clinical Practice
Research Datalink (CPRD) linked to Hospital Episodes Statistics. Adults (≥ 40 years)
with T2D initiated on dual therapy with Met+SU or Met+OHA following metformin
monotherapy were identified during the period April 2003–March 2012 and comprised the two study cohorts. Propensity scores were estimated and Met+SU patients
caliper matched to Met+OHA patients to balance the covariates (including HbA1C
and duration of diabetes at baseline). Diabetes-associated secondary health care
utilisation (inpatient admissions and outpatient visits) were measured from > 6
months post-initiation of dual therapy until treatment change or end of follow-up.
Outcomes were calculated as rate ratios (RR), adjusted for over dispersion using
negative binomial regression and propensity score for covariates. Results: 14,416
patients in total were identified and in the directly matched analysis, 1,704 patients
were included in each cohort. For the primary objective, the Met+SU cohort had a
numerically higher rate of diabetes-related secondary health care utilisation than
Met+OHAs (adjusted RR 1.12, 95% confidence interval [95%CI]: 0.97-1.29). For the
secondary endpoints examining individual components, the adjusted RR for Met+SU
cohort for inpatient admissions was 1.34 (95%CI 0.92–1.96) and 1.10 (95%CI 0.95-1.28)
for outpatient visits. Macrovascular complications, accounting for 68.7% of inpatient admissions, occurred at a significantly higher rate in the Met+SU cohort than
Met+OHA (adjusted RR 1.77, 95%CI: 1.15-2.71). Conclusions: Glucose-lowering
combination therapy with metformin plus sulphonylurea is associated with a directionally higher rate of secondary health care utilisation than metformin plus other
oral anti-hyperglycaemic agents.
PDB161
Factors Associated With Weight Gain and Hypoglycaemia and The
Impact Upon Hospitalisation in Type 2 Diabetes Patients Managed
With Metformin Plus Sulphonylurea
McEwan P 1, Gordon J 1, Evans M 2, Puelles J 3
Economics and Outcomes Research Ltd, Cardiff, UK, 2University Hospital Llandough,
Cardiff, UK, 3Takeda UK Ltd, London, UK
.
1Health
.
.
.
Objectives: The relationship between resource utilisation and patient phenotype
in type 2 diabetes (T2D) is not well characterised. This study aimed to assess factors associated with weight gain (WG) and the occurrence of hypoglycaemia in
T2D patients managed with metformin plus sulfonylurea (M+S) and any associated
impact upon hospital resource utilisation. Methods: The study was a retrospective cohort study using the UK Clinical Practice Research Datalink (CPRD) and the
Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) database. The association between phenotypic
factors at baseline (therapy escalation from metformin to M+S) with WG (> 2kg
weight change over 12 months) and presence of any recorded hypoglycaemia over
12 months following therapy escalation was assessed using logistic regression.
Hospitalisation associated with increasing body mass index (BMI) and hypoglycaemia was also assessed. Results: A total of 11,071 patients met the study inclusion/
exclusion criteria. WG was observed in 28.35% of patients and was significantly
associated with baseline age (OR= 0.99), female gender (OR= 0.87), baseline weight
(OR= 1.003) and HbA1c (OR= 1.06). Hypoglycaemia occurred in 1.3% of patients and
was significantly associated with duration of diabetes (OR= 1.04), baseline HbA1c
(OR=0.86) and prior complications status (OR=1.92). Hospitalisation occurred in 10%
of patients and was significantly associated with BMI (OR= 1.02) but not hypoglycaemia. The mean number of hospital admissions over the follow-up period was 1.7, 1.8,
1.9 and 3.1 in those with BMIs at the time of admission in the normal, overweight,
obese and morbidly obese categories respectively. Conclusions: This real-world
observational analysis suggests there are identifiable phenotypic characteristics
predictive of WG and hypoglycaemia. This study also shows a general relationship
between increasing BMI and hospitalisation that may not be adequately captured
in widely used vascular risk equations such as UKPDS in which BMI has minimal
influence on risk. Consequently, the value of diabetes management strategies that
minimise WG may be underestimated.
PDB162
The Use of Real World Data in the Decision-Making Process:
An Example Using Blood Glucose Test Strip Use In Patients With
Type 2 Diabetes In Ireland
O’Leary A 1, Usher C 2, Barlow J 1, Gallagher P 1
College of Surgeons in Ireland, Dublin, Ireland, 2National Centre for Pharmacoeconomics,
Dublin, Ireland
.
.
.
.
1Royal
Objectives: Frequency of self-monitoring of blood glucose (SMBG) varies in
patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) and there is debate as to the true
benefit it plays in the management of the condition. The aim of this study was to
compare the frequency of SMBG using patient medication record (PMR) dispensed
data, with self-reported data, and to assess the relationship between type of glucose-lowering therapy to SMBG frequency among patients with T2DM dispensed
glucose test strips. Methods: Patients with T2DM were identified in communitypharmacies (n= 116) using PMRs in 2012. Patients who consented to participation
were surveyed in a face-to-face interview where self-reported (SR) frequency
of SMBG was determined. Dispensed data were classified by the mechanism of
action of the blood glucose lowering regimen, (secretagogues vs. sensitisers). Test
strip use over a 12 month period was calculated and compared to SR use from
the patient survey. Analysis was performed in MS Excel® and SAS®. Results:
Data from 484 patients were analysed (mean age 65yrs). Sensitising agents alone
accounted for 45% of the cohort, secretagogues alone - 8%, a combination of both
- 42%, and diet 5%. Approximately 52% of patients reported frequency of SMBG as
once or twice daily vs 56% in the dispensed data. 13% of patients reported a frequency of at least 3 times daily vs 21% for PMR data. There was no statistically significant difference in SR frequency among those on the various glucose-lowering
regimens. No correlations were found between frequency of use and age, gender,
place of residence or number of prescribed medicines. Conclusions: Results
from this study highlight (i) differences in frequency of blood glucose monitoring
between dispensed data and SR data and (ii) the difficulty in accurately capturing
this type of data. A reliance on either type of data alone may be insufficient to
accurately inform decision making.
PDB163
Cost of Severe Hypoglycaemia in Hospitalized Patients In Poland- Is
It Financed and Reported in a Right Way?
Czech M 1, Jaron N 1, Pietrzyk A 1, Franek E 2
University of Technology, Warsaw, Poland, 2Central Clinical Hospital, Ministry of Interior
in Warsaw, Warsaw, Poland
.
.
.
.
1Warsaw
Objectives: Hypoglycaemia is common in diabetic patients, often as a side effect
of a treatment. Its occurrence can influence patients’ professional life and generate extra direct costs to the health care system. Severe (requiring another person’s
assistance) hypoglycaemic events (SHEs), especially leading to hospitalisation, are
associated with the highest burden and for that reason their real frequency and
costs should be calculated properly. The aim of the study was to assess the accuracy
of reporting of hypoglycaemia to the National Health Fund in Poland. Methods:
A combination of prospective and retrospective designs was applied. A detailed
retrospective analysis of 117 hospitalised patients’ case histories was performed
from the period of February-March 2013. In addition, prospectively, in March and
April 2013, 45 patients were interviewed and their clinical records were analysed.
Information was collected in special case report forms. Real hospitalisation costs
were also calculated. Results: In the retrospective arm hypoglycaemia affected 42
patients (55% of type 1 and 25% of type 2) and 85 SHEs were recorded. Only 2 patients
were reported in the hypoglycaemia DRG group compared to a broader diabetes/
hyperglycaemia DRG group, where the financing level is higher. A financial difference equal to 7,082 EUR was generated due to more favourable classification of these
cases. In the prospective arm 20 patients experienced hypoglycaemia, whereas only
one was coded as hypoglycaemic. It has generated 2,247 EUR difference. Even with
this financially more favourable, (still clinically justified but less precise) coding
hypoglycaemic patients generated losses equal to 23,628 EUR in retrospective and
5,053 EUR in prospective group. Conclusions: Our study provided a direct proof
A361
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
of underreporting of hypoglycaemia in clinical hospital settings in Poland caused
by DRG- based financing standards. There is a need of reflecting real treatment cost
in the level of reimbursement in this group of patients.
PDB164
Patient Specific Landscape of Information Technology Solutions
for Diabetes Self-Management
Xenakis J 1, Garfield S 2
.
.
1GfK, Wayland, MA, USA, 2GfK
Market Access, Wayland, MA, USA
Objectives: Diabetes Mellitus affects approximately 60 million Europeans, with
prevalence increasing. Diabetes is associated with a number of severe comorbidities, including visual impairment, lower extremity conditions/amputation, neuropathy, renal disease and cardiovascular disease. Managing underlying disease
can significantly improve disease outcomes, though adherence remains a challenge.
With the major expansion of consumer technology-based health care solutions and
European initiatives like the REACTION project, diabetic patients are more involved
in care than ever before. Our study looks at patient centric drivers of adherence to
technology based diabetes self-management in Europe. Methods: An in-depth
analysis of current European initiatives implementing digital health management
solutions was performed, as well as overall demographic and statistical research
of the European diabetes population. Additionally, using dual data collection methods, involving telephone-based interviews and internet-based questionnaires, a
total of 2,307 diabetes patients in the US were sampled. Questions focused on
demographic, lifestyle, treatment, access to information, and socioeconomic status. Data from US diabetic patient preferences related to digital health solutions
and patient engagement strategies were reviewed in the context of diabetes selfmanagement solutions being deployed in Europe. Results: Socioeconomic disadvantage amongst European citizens has been shown to significantly contribute to
development of diabetes and related complications. Among our study population,
diabetics with a lower socioeconomic status and the elderly showed drastically
lower rates of access to internet at home or at work (58.1% and 66.3%, respectively),
as compared to those who were employed with an average income >$60,000 (92.2%).
This same group preferred to get information from their health care providers versus the internet. Conclusions: While programs are being developed to impact
diabetic treatment adherence via IT based diabetes self-management solutions,
patient characteristics and preferences need to be understood to optimize impact.
Additional research is required to understand the best methods to reach these
at-risk populations.
PDB165
Using Modern Information Technology For Medical and
Pharmaceutical Care Of Patients With Diabetes Mellitus In Ukraine
Boyko A , Parnovskiy B
Danylo Halytsky National Medical University, Lviv, Ukraine
.
.
Objectives: In Ukraine, 1.2 million people have diabetes mellitus (DM). 80 insulins and 169 oral hypoglycemic preparations are registered. However, incomplete
information on DM patients results in problems with providing their medicines.
To develop a computer information retrieval system (CIS) for the registration of
patients with DM and their pharmacotherapy (including financing sources) and
to optimize the requirements for medicines; the CIS can be used to analyse the
pharmaceutical care of patients with DM. Methods: This study includes designin
a CIS, entering pharmacotherapy information of DM patients, and use of the CIS
to analyze the quality of pharmaceutical care of DM patients. Results: The study
was conducted at the Ternopil Region, Ukraine. The study was based in 2 hospitals,
2 dispensaries, and 12 pharmacies and examined the public and private sectors.
The CIS was developed for use at national level and contains information on
individual pharmacotherapy (27 insulins, 46 oral hypoglycemic preparations) of
2,186 patients (282 DM type I). The CIS consists of 4 blocks: “Patient” (935 men,
1261 women; from them 12 child) “Pharmacotherapy” (371 - insulin therapy, 1727 oral hypoglycemic agents) and “Financing sources” blocks contain information on
the centralized and local budgets, funds on maintenance of people that suffered
from the Chernobyl accident, humanitarian help, and self-financing. The 4th block
contains information on interactions of medicines. The analyses of individuals’
pharmacotherapies has shown that the CIS is an effective tool and can support
endocrinologists in monitoring consumption of medicines by each patient. The
system also provides expert analyses of changes of schemes, doses of medicines,
and financing sources for individual patients. Conclusions: The CIS provides
the doctor with the ability to precisely define what medicines are necessary for
the patient, define availability of medicines, and raise rationality and safety of
use of antidiabetic medicines.
PDB166
Quality of Diabetes Care Among Obese and Overweight Patients at
Nhg Polyclinics
Thaung Y M , Toh MPHS, Lee L J
National Healthcare Group, Singapore
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The study aimed to examine the disparity of risk factor screening and
clinical outcomes depending on bodyweight of patients with diabetes mellitus at 9
National Healthcare Group (NHG) Polyclinics in Singapore. Methods: Data were
extracted from NHG Diabetes Registry. Diabetes care bundle measures of 8 process
indicators (biannual blood pressure (BP), bodyweight and HbA1c test measurement,
annual serum cholesterol level, smoking, eye, foot and nephropathy assessment)
and 3 intermediate outcome indicators (HbA1c ≤ 7%, BP < 130/80 mmHg and LDL-C
< 2.6mmol/L) were measured. Rates of these indicators were compared by BMI
according to WHO classification. Multivariate logistic regression for achieving the
individual indicators was referenced to the normal BMI group. Results: In 2012,
87,552 patients were enrolled for diabetes care at 9 NHG Polyclinics. Mean age was
64.1± 11.6. 51.8% were female. 70.6% were Chinese. 40.4% were overweight and 20.8%
were obese. After adjusting for age, gender and ethnicity, overweight and obese
patients were more likely to have annual cholesterol test, smoking status assessed,
eye and renal function screening than normal weight patients. However, the overweight and obese class I/II patients were less likely to achieve optimal HbA1c (7%
or less) and BP (< 130/80 mmHg) than normal BMI patients. The AdjOR for achieving
optimal HbA1c decreased from 0.88 (95%CI 0.86-0.91) for overweight to 0.77 (0.720.83) for obese class II; and BP decreased from 0.74 (0.99-1.05) for overweight to 0.48
(0.45-0.52) for obesity class II. More obese class II and III patients had optimal LDLcholesterol control compared to normal BMI patients, AdjOR 1.11 (1.03-1.19) and
1.16 (1.04-1.29) respectively. Conclusions: Overweight and obese patients with
diabetes were less likely to achieve the optimal HbA1c and BP control than normal
BMI patients. Clinicians can identify the patients with higher BMI and poor risk
factor control for more intense intervention to improve diabetes care and outcomes.
PDB167
Data Sources of Disease Epidemiology in German Drug
Reimbursement Dossiers: Case Study Of Diabetes Mellitus Type II
Zhou M , Sandmann F G , ten Thoren C , Voelskow V , Mostardt S , Gerber-Grote A U
Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care (IQWiG), Cologne, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Investigating and comparing the sources of prevalence data used in
German drug reimbursement dossiers within the AMNOG-framework in order to
explore causes for deviating prevalence estimates. Methods: All publicly available dossiers on diabetes mellitus type II were retrieved from the Federal Joint
Committee’s homepage (http://www.g-ba.de). We investigated the epidemiological
sources in the dossiers on their representativity (i. e., population-level epidemiological data), actuality (year of data collection), method of data collection, data quality,
and open access. Results: As of early June 2014, 13 dossiers were published on
diabetes mellitus type II. Overall, 23 different sources for quantifying the prevalence were used, which can be grouped into 5 categories: clinical trials, registries,
health insurances’ claims data, commercial data-providers, and a governmental
data-provider. Data was mostly collected 5 or more years ago (except for the commercial and governmental data-providers). Data was retrieved by means of physicians’ statements; patient surveys with voluntary disclosure; diagnostic tests (such
as the oral glucose tolerance test); national registries; secondary data from health
insurances, and (raw) secondary data of pharmacy prescriptions with physician
diagnoses. Besides differences in diagnostic criteria, reasons for deviation among
sources include: the sample size and making adjustments to improve representativity for Germany; the chosen approach to analyze secondary data; differentiation of
type II from type I diabetes mellitus, and (not) considering undiagnosed or untreated
cases. While accessing the data of publications and of the commercial providers
requires a payment, health insurance data is not freely available in Germany (yet).
The governmental data-provider is accessible without restrictions and free of
charge. Conclusions: The need for accurate population-level data and access to
it is highlighted by the present case-study. Sources for prevalence data in diabetes
mellitus type II were characterized by a variety of differences in the methods applied
to derive (the) data, leading to deviating estimates.
PDB169
Examining the Economic Benefits of Lifestyle Intervention in
Segments of A Prediabetic Population
Storm M 1, Dall T 1, Semilla A P 1, Su W 1, Blanchard T 2
Global Inc., Washington, DC, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
1IHS, Washington, DC, USA, 2IHS
Objectives: Published studies have shown that lifestyle intervention in adults
with prediabetes can improve health outcomes and reduce or delay onset of type
2 diabetes. Improved health translates to lower medical costs, reduced mortality,
and higher levels of employment and productivity. This study examined patient
characteristics that help predict future medical expenditures avoided and economic
benefits to society associated with lifestyle intervention. Methods: A Markovbased microsimulation model utilizing Monte Carlo simulation was constructed to
simulate patient health and economic outcomes over ten years with and without
a lifestyle intervention. The population examined was a nationally representative
sample (n= 2,887) of US adults with prediabetes from the 2003-2010 National Health
and Nutrition Examination Survey who meet the American Diabetes Association’s
screening criteria for diabetes. Prediction equations for diabetes and sequelae, medical expenditures, economic outcomes, mortality, and quality of life came from the
published trials and studies, such as the UK Prospective Diabetes Study. The analysis simulated body weight and hemoglobin A1c benefits reported in the 10-year
follow-up results from the lifestyle arm of the Diabetes Prevention Program and
Outcomes Study (DPPOS). OLS regression was subsequently used to analyze the
initial patient characteristics and their relation to subsequent outcomes. Results:
Simulated outcomes suggest that age, sex, race, obese status, and HbA1c at time
of intervention are strong predictors of successful economic outcomes (medical
expenditures and societal benefit). Intervention impact on medical savings generally
increased with age through age 65, while total economic benefits of the intervention increase through age 60. Women had $4,200 in higher medical savings then
men. Obese participants had $3,000 higher medical savings than non-obese participants. Conclusions: The expected economic benefit of lifestyle intervention
varies systematically by patient characteristics. Patients age 55-64 experienced the
most medical savings, while patients age 45-54 experienced the largest societal
economic impact.
PDB170
Efficacy of The Automated Target Glucose Control: A Systematic
Review
Yoo K J
NECA, Seoul, South Korea
.
.
Objectives: Tight glucose control in critically ill patients is difficult and labor
intensive, resulting in poor efficacy of glycemic control and increased hypoglycemia rate. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the safety and effectiveness
of the automated target glucose control using computer-based insulin algo-
A362
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
rithms compared to the conventinal glucose control using paper-based protocols. Methods: A systematic literature review and meta-analysis was used to
evaluate the safety and effectiveness for the automated target glucose control.
The 14 randomized control trials of 2537 articles were selected and two reviewers
evaluated independently the quality of this selected articles using the Scottish
Intercollegiate Guidelines Network (SIGN) tool. Results: The computer-based
insulin protocols resulted in a shorter time to reach within target range (MD -1.03,
95%CI -1.70~-0.35, p= .003, I2= 77%) and a higher percentage of glucose readings
within target range (MD 11.98, 95%CI 8.83~15.14, p< .001, I2= 89%) than the paperbased protocols. The incidence rates of above or below target range in computerbased insulin protocols were acceptable levels and the incidence rates of severe
hypoglycemia below 40mg/dL in computer-based insulin protocol was significantly
lower than the paper-based insulin protocols (MD -23.41, 95%CI -32.35~-14.46, p< .
001, I2= 0%). Conclusions: The automated target glucose control using computer-based algorithms resulted in tighter glycemic control without an increased
risk of hypoglycemic events compared to the paper-based protocols. But taking
into account the high heterogeneity between studies, these results must be interpreted with caution.
PDB171
Comparison in Methods Between National Institute for Health
And Care Excellence (Nice) Submissions For Sodium-Glucose
Co-Transporter 2 Inhibitors (Sglt-2i)
Kandaswamy P , Daacke I M
Boehringer Ingelheim UK, Bracknell, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: A comparisons of economic methods across all NICE submissions
for SGLT-2is (dapagliflozin, canagliflozin and empagliflozin) and exploring potential opportunities for optimising the appraisals of treatment classes. Methods:
The NICE website was searched for: manufacturer submissions, clarification
letters, evidence review group (ERG) reports and NICE guidance relating to the
SGLT-2is. Data extracted included the sources of inputs and key assumptions to
the economic analysis in particular the evidence synthesis, modelling approach
and key cost-effectiveness results. Comparisons were then made across appraisals in reference to the ERG and NICE comments to identify any areas of uncertainty. Results: The results of the review indicated the following similarities
between submissions: The lines of therapies explored; the use of United Kingdom
Prospective Diabetes Study equations to link surrogate to clinically relevant outcomes; use of Bayesian network meta-analyses to derive clinical inputs which
were all based on the same studies, outcomes and time period; the sources of
cost and utility inputs were mainly derived from UKPDS studies; and the relative
differences in costs and QALYS. The main differences identified included: the economic models used (pre-existing versus de Novo); treatments included in decision
space; the modelling of weight gain; definitions of adverse effects included; and
the total costs and QALYs between appraisals. Conclusions: The NICE appraisals for SGLT-2is were broadly similar in their overall design. This is apparent from
the similar results of the appraisals in terms of relative outcomes. Given this, it is
arguable whether the resources required to develop these separate submissions
was essential. It would be of value for HTA organisations to develop reference
cases including standard inputs for the modelling of significant conditions such
as diabetes especially where there is such consistency. This would improve the
comparability of analyses and reduce the costs to manufacturers and ERGs in
developing and reviewing submissions respectively.
PDB172
Adherence to Nice Guidance For Initiating Glp-1 Mimetics Among
Patients With Type 2 Diabetes In Primary Care In England And
Wales - An Evaluation Using The Clinical Practice Research
Datalink (Cprd)
Jameson K 1, D’Oca K 1, Murray-Thomas T 2, O’Regan C 3, Leigh P 1
1Merck Sharp and Dohme Ltd, Hoddesdon, UK, 2Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulatory
Agency, London, UK, 3Merck Sharp & Dohme Limited, Hertfordshire, UK
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess adherence to UK NICE guidance/guidelines for initiating
therapy with Glucagon-Like Peptide-1 [GLP-1] mimetics - exenatide, prolongedrelease exenatide [Exen-PR] and liraglutide – in patients with Type 2 diabetes
(T2D). Methods: A retrospective cohort study of T2D patients in primary care
identified in the CPRD. Patients were ≥ 40 years at GLP-1 initiation, had ≥ 12 months
of CPRD history, with first GLP-1 prescription recorded on/after publication of the
respective NICE guidance/guideline. The primary outcome was the proportion of
patients initiating/not initiating GLP-1 as part of a NICE-recommended regimen (recommended dual therapy: liraglutide or Exen-PR added to metformin or sulphonylureas; recommended triple therapy: any GLP-1 added to metformin+sulphonylureas
or metformin+thiazolidinedione). For patients initiating GLP-1 as triple therapy,
the proportion meeting NICE initiation criteria (HbA1c ≥ 7.5% and body mass
index [BMI] ≥ 35kg/m2) was assessed. Results: Mean age of the study cohort initiating GLP-1 (7,133 patients) was 58.2 years (SD 9.4), BMI 38.4 kg/m2 (SD 6.8) and
HbA1c 9.2% (SD 3.2%). Overall, only 25% (1,772/7,133) of patients were initiated on
GLP-1 as part of a NICE-recommended regimen. Approximately 13% of patients
initiated liraglutide (443/3,438) and 13% initiated Exen-PR (45/346) as part of NICErecommended dual therapy regimen, with a higher proportion initiating a GLP-1 as
part of NICE-recommended triple therapy (exenatide: 19% [637/3,349], liraglutide:
17% [588/3,438], Exen-PR: 17% [59/346]). Of those patients initiated on a recommended triple therapy regimen, 50% fulfilled both NICE HbA1c and BMI initiation
criteria. The majority of the study cohort (75%) initiated GLP-1 in combination regimens not recommended by NICE: 12% non-recommended dual therapy; 21% nonrecommended triple therapy; 16% monotherapy, and 25% quadruple therapy/add-on
to insulin. Conclusions: Many patients are initiated on GLP-1 in combination
regimens which are not recommended by NICE. The rationale for these decisions
may warrant further research to better understand the observed low adherence to
NICE-recommended regimens.
PDB173
Treatment Patterns Among Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus Patients in
Saudi Arabia
Levy A R 1, Szabo S M 1, Osenenko K M 1, Korol E E 1, Qatami L 2, Al Jaser S 3, Al Saggabi A 3, Al
Suwaidan S 3, Maclean R 4, Donato B M K 5
1ICON Epidemiology, Vancouver, BC, Canada, 2Bristol-Myers Squibb Company, Dubai, United Arab
Emirates, 3King Fahad National Guard Hospital, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, 4Bristol-Myers Squibb
Company, Plainsboro, NJ, USA, 5Bristol-Myers Squibb Company, Wallingford, CT, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Due to its dramatically increasing prevalence, type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) is a serious public health concern in Saudi Arabia. Few data have been
published that describe how persons with T2DM are managed in clinical practice;
we aimed to characterize recent treatment patterns among individuals treated
for T2DM in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. Methods: Charts from 455 adults with T2DM
who visited the King Fahad National Guard Hospital from October 2009 to March
2010 (enrolment period) were systematically sampled until the target (n= 250)
was reached. Treatment data from enrolment to September 2011 were abstracted
from subject charts. Treatment regimens, their frequency of use, and the number of switches (drug replacement/removal/addition) over the study period were
calculated. Analyses were stratified by T2DM duration; data for those recentlydiagnosed (< 5 years; n= 29) and with longstanding disease (≥ 20 years; n= 67) are
presented. Results: Forty-four percent of subjects were male; at enrolment, mean
(SD) age was 61 (13) years, and mean T2DM duration was 11 (8) years. At enrolment,
42% of subjects had received prior insulin treatment (recently-diagnosed: 23%; longstanding disease: 52%). During the study period, the most common regimens were
oral combination therapy (41%) and insulin+oral combination therapy (32%). Overall,
44% received any insulin therapy during the study period (recently-diagnosed: 25%;
longstanding disease: 54%). By study end, 49% had received any prior insulin therapy
(recently-diagnosed: 29%; longstanding disease: 58%). On average, T2DM subjects
had 1.3 treatment switches over the period; little variation was seen by T2DM duration. Conclusions: Although the frequency of insulin treatment was lower than
reported in other studies from the region, treatment switches are indicative of
attempts to improve T2DM control. Novel therapies may improve clinical outcomes
among T2DM patients and this study provides valuable baseline data with which to
compare the effectiveness of new T2DM treatments in Saudi Arabia.
PDB174
Usage of Self-Monitoring of Blood Glucose (Smbg) By Diabetes
Therapy Type in India
Mast O 1, Tan A 2, Punjabi K 3
1Roche Diagnostics, Diabetes Care, Mannheim, Germany, 2Cegedim Strategic Data, Singapore,
3Cegedim Strategic Data, Mumbai, India
.
.
.
Objectives: SMBG is a core component of diabetes therapy, supporting a safe and
effective drug therapy and providing feedback on the impact of diet and lifestyle. In
2014 an Indian guideline on glycemic monitoring was published. This study aims
to assess the level of SMBG usage in patients by diabetes therapies. Methods:
Source data for this explorative analysis is the CSD-PDS Diabetes survey covering
drug treated patients with diabetes. All 2,250 cases were documented in the 2nd
half of 2013. PDS Diabetes is a syndicated research with a fixed representative
panel of doctors from larger Indian cities using a standardized documentation of
cases. SMBG usage is analyzed by therapeutic subgroups: oral diabetes therapy
(OAD 75%), basal supported oral therapy (BOT 9%), conventional insulin therapy
(CT 8%), intensive insulin therapy (IIT 5%) and others (3%, excluded). Results:
Diabetes type 2: 93%. 1,180 patients (52.4%) have a meter for home-testing.
Shares of testers by therapies (OAD/ BOT/CT/IIT) are 50.7%, 63.4%, 53.1% and
67.3%. An HbA1c-goal of 8% is achieved by 62/49/45/37%, an HbA1c-goal of 7% by
29/20/19/18%. Average weekly test frequencies are 2.4, 2.8, 2.9 and 2.2 respectively.
In the OAD/BOT/CT groups 13/14/16% test at least once daily (recommended), less
than 2% in IIT test 3 times daily (recommended). HbA1c levels are by 0.3%, 0.2%,
1.1% and 0.0% lower in SMBG users. Conclusions: Many patients in this sample
do not achieve HbA1c targets and many do not test their blood glucose. Below 1
in 5 patients follows the recommended test frequency. In IIT SMBG is needed to
support insulin dose adjustments: below 1 in 50 test enough. In CT patients the
differences in HbA1c between testers and non-testers are largest. Lacking benefit
in IIT treated patients might indicate the insufficiency of current testing. The new
guideline might help to close these gaps.
Gastrointestinal Disorders – Clinical Outcomes Studies
PGI1
The Comparison Of Clinical Impact Between Entecavir And
Tenofovir In Chronic Hbv Infection
Shen W C , Tsai P Y , Kuo L N
Taipei Medical University and Wan Fang Hospital, Taipei, Taiwan
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To compare the efficacy and safety of Entecavir and Tenofovir in
nucleos(t) ide-naïve CHB patients with HBV DNA in a medical center. Methods: We
included patients in WFH had used Entecavir or Tenofovir from 2011/07 to 2012/12,
and excluded patients who had (1) co-infection with the HCV, HIV, TB, (2) the history of malignancy within 3 years before the first time use of ETV or TDF, (3) the
history of alcohol abuse, and (4) used other anti-HBV drugs. In Statistics, we used
Kaplan–Meier survival analysis to present the HBV DNA suppression and the normalization of ALT. Results: We identified 124 consencutive patients treated with
ETV and 24 patients treated with TDF. After 18 months, the probability of complete
viral suppression was 67.7% in the ETV group and 45.8% in the TDF group (P= 0.49).
The probability of complete ALT normalization was 87.1% in the ETV group and
83.3% in the TDF group (P= 0.159). In the adverse side effects of neurologic, malaise
was observed in the patients treated with ETV more than TDF (11.3% vs. 0%), but in
gastrointestinal disorders, diarrhea was observed in the patients treated with TDF
more than ETV (25.0% vs. 3.2%). Conclusions: Entecavir and Tenofovir have no
A363
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
significance difference in the efficacy and safety in nucleos(t) ide-naïve CHB patients
with HBV DNA greater than 6 log10 in the medical center.
PGI2
Effectiveness Of Probiotics In Irritable Bowel Syndrome:
A Systematic Review With Meta-Analysis
Nikfar S, Mozafari S, Didari T, Abdollahi M
Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
Objectives: To investigate the efficacy of probiotics in irritable bowel syndrome
(IBS) patients, this meta-analysis was performed. Methods: The collected data
contained twenty-four clinical trials which fifteen were eligible for meta-analysis
and nine were reviewed systematically. All studies were randomized placebo-controlled trials in patients with IBS that investigated the efficacy of probiotics in IBS
improvement. Trials were evaluated with Relative Risk (RR) with 95% confidence
interval (95% CI). Cochran Q test was used to test heterogeneity with P value 0.05
(P< 0.05). Egger and Begg-Mazumdar tests in funnel plot were calculated as publication bias indicators. Results: Probiotics reduced pain severity, symptom severity
score and induced adequate general symptom improvement. Distension, bloating,
and flatulence were not improved after probiotics treatment when compared to
placebo. Conclusions: Collectively, the results demonstrated the beneficial efficacy of probiotics compared with placebo in IBS patients.
PGI3
Establishment Of A Hepatitis C Virus (Hcv) Cohort In A Large Israeli
Hmo
Shalev V 1, Weil C 2, Nwankwo C 3, Friedman M 1, Kenet G 2, Chodick G 4
1Medical Division, Maccabi Healthcare Services, Tel Aviv, Israel, 2Maccabi Healthcare Services,
Tel Aviv, Israel, 3Merck, Whitehouse Station, NJ, USA, 4Maccabi Healthcare Services and Tel Aviv
University, Tel Aviv, Israel
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Hepatitis C virus (HCV) affects an estimated 130 million people worldwide and is a major cause of chronic liver disease. Real-world data is needed to better understand the epidemiology of HCV and its complications, as well as treatment
patterns and outcomes. The objectve of this study is to establish a cohort of HCV
carriers in a large health maintenance organization, with comprehensive data on
treatment and disease outcomes. Methods: The HCV cohort will use data available
since 1998 from the computerized databases of Maccabi Healthcare Services, the
second largest HMO in Israel, with approximately 2 million members. HCV cases are
included based on diagnostic codes (ICD9-CM), laboratory data (e. g. detection of HCV
antibodies and RNA) and dispensed prescriptions for HCV treatment. The cohort
includes demographic data (age, sex, immigration and socioeconomic status), clinical data (e. g. BMI; comorbidities), treatment patterns, virological outcomes, and HCV
complications – including cirrhosis, hepatocellular carcinoma, liver transplants, and
mortality. Results: At the end of 2012, HCV infection was identified among 10,648
patients, corresponding to an age-adjusted prevalence rate of 5 per thousand. The
highest prevalence was found among males and in the age group 35-55 yrs. Two
thirds of HCV patients were immigrants from Eastern Europe. HCV genotype 1 was
predominant (67%). Over a third of patients had at least one recorded purchase of
interferon, and treated patients were less likely to have chronic diseases such as
diabetes or cardiovascular disease, compared to untreated patients. Conclusions:
The establishment of a HCV cohort in MHS can serve as a basis for retrospective
database studies and can be periodically updated to follow up existing patients and
identify incident HCV cases. For example, future studies can examine the adherence
and efficacy of treatments, and associations between HCV and chronic diseases
such as chronic kidney disease.
PGI4
The Incidence Of Upper And Lower Gastrointestinal Complications:
A Retrospective Study Using A Japanese Health Care Database
1Ben Gurion University of the Negev, Beer-Sheva, Israel, 2Soroka University Medical Center,
Beer-Sheva, Israel
Objectives: To study possible associations and assess the impact of socio-demographic, quality-of-life and coping factors on the severity of Crohn’s disease patients
in Israel. Methods: Consecutive Crohn’s disease patients undergoing clinical followup at the Inflammatory Bowel Diseases Clinic completed the following questionnaires: SF-36 quality-of-life, Ways of Coping, and socio-demographic details. Crohn’s
disease severity was measured by Harvey-Bradshaw Index (HBI) expanded to include
pharmaceutical and surgical therapies as well as medical and surgical hospitalization
information. Based on these data, a multifactorial model was built using multivariate
linear regression. Results: There were altogether 192 patients: 81 (42.2%) men (age
36.8 ± 14.5 years, disease duration 11.4 ± 8.6 years, education 13.7 ± 2.7 years, HBI 7.6
± 4.9) and 111 (57.8%) women (age 41.4 ± 15.6*, duration 14.0 ± 9.3*, education 14.2 ±
2.8, HBI 8.4 ± 4.8; *p < 0.05 vs. men). The multifactorial model showed the following
significant predictors of disease severity: age (beta = −0.250, p = 0.006), number of
children (beta = 0.245, p = 0.008), SF-36 General Health score (beta = −0.378, p < 0.01),
coping/sense of humor (beta = 0.209, p = 0.011), and coping/acceptance (beta = −0.183,
p = 0.024). The model accounted for 29% of explained variance, with Adjusted R2 =
0.26. Gender, education and socio-economic status were not predictors of disease
severity. Conclusions: All of the indicated factors (age, family size, coping skills)
had a significant effect on the severity of Crohn’s disease. In addition to prescribing
medications, physicians should pay special attention to these factors as part of an
overall management plan for their Crohn’s disease patients.
PGI6
Development And External Validation Of A Risk Calculator For
Predicting Anemia In Patients Treated With Triple Therapy (Tt)
Containing Boceprevir (Boc), Pegylated Interferon And Ribavirin (Pr)
Nwankwo C 1, Kattan M 2, Luan A 3, Wahl J 1
Station, NJ, USA, 2Cleveland Clinic, Columbia, SC, USA, 3Agile 1, Torrance,
CA, USA
.
.
.
.
1Merck, Whitehouse
Objectives: To develop and validate a risk calculator for the prediction of anemia
occurring after 8 weeks of TT using BOC+PR among Hepatitis C Virus (HCV) genotype
1 patients based on risk factors. Methods: Data for all randomized HCV genotype
1 patients starting therapy with BOC+PR and who received at least one dose of BOC
in three phase 3 clinical trials (PN05101, PN5216 and PN5514) were included. The
outcome of interest was the prediction of anemia, defined as hemoglobin < 10 g/L
after 12 weeks of TT with BOC+PR (this included 4 weeks of lead-in treatment using
PR). Logistic regression was used to develop the risk calculator model by analyzing
the association of each variable with the likelihood of developing anemia while on
treatment. Baseline variables were included as covariates in the model. Linearity
assumptions were relaxed with the use of restricted cubic splines. Bootstrapping,
with 1000 resamples, were used in conjunction with estimation of discrimination
and calibration. Results: Following a stepdown procedure that eliminated predictors that did not contribute to the overall model concordance index, nine variables
remained in the final model: age, hemoglobin, gender, cirrhosis, hematologic counts,
Alkaline phosphatases levels, and creatinine. This model had a boostrap corrected
concordance index of 0.775. The model was cross-validated by sequentially omitting each of the three randomized trials from the model development and using the
omitted trial as a test set; the concordance indices following this procedure ranged
from 0.75 to 0.85. Calibration of the model, assessed graphically, indicated reasonably close agreement between predicted and observed proportions. Calibration held
following trial cross validation as well. Conclusions: The model calibrated well
and demonstrated good predictive ability. This tool may be useful for identifying
and subsequently managing HCV patients at relatively high risk for developing
anemia if treated with BOC+PR.
Kawaguchi I 1, Nakazuru Y 1, Yamamoto Y 2, Nagayasu S 2, Fujimoto Y 1
1Pfizer Japan Inc, Tokyo, Japan, 2MinaCare co. ltd, Tokyo, Japan
Gastrointestinal Disorders – Cost Studies
Objectives: The objective of this study was to investigate the incidence of complications (bleeding and perforation) with hospitalization from both upper and lower GI
tract in Japanese population using a health care claims database (HDB). Methods:
All of the claims data of the patients who have a history of hospitalization due to
complications from GI tracts between January 2011 and December 2012 were extracted
from the HDB which holds about 1.8 million peoples’ claims data under employmentbased health insurance. In order to identify upper and lower GI events precisely, we
confirmed them when a diagnosis of a GI event in the claims (ICD-10 code) was accompanied by a record of examination and/or endoscopic or surgical treatment relevant
to upper and lower GI complications. Results: The total number of person-years at
risk was 1.2 million person-years in 2012. The incidence rates in upper and lower GI
events were 48 and 41 per 100,000 person-years, respectively. Twenty-one percent of
the lower events originated in bleeding from hemorrhoid or related treatments (eg.
hemorrhoidectomy). Age-group analyses in the upper vs. lower events, except those
from hemorrhoid, were 27 vs. 17, 57 vs. 46 and 184 vs. 104 per 100,000 person-years
in 20-39, 40-59, and 60+ years groups, respectively. Data from 2011 were consistent
with these observations on the ratio of upper to lower GI events and the age-based
incidence, indicating the robustness of the results. Conclusions: This was the first
study to investigate the incidence from both upper and lower GI complications with
hospitalization in a real clinical setting in Japan using a single large data source. We
confirmed that a number of GI events occurred in both upper and lower GI tract and
the incidence rates of both events were increased with age in a real world setting.
PGI7
Budget Impact Analysis Of Sofosbuvir For The Treatment Of
Hepatitis C In The Veneto Region, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
PGI5
Associations Between Crohn’s Disease Severity And Specific SocioDemographic, Quality-Of-Life And Coping Factors
Friger M 1, Sarid O 1, Slonim-Nevo V 1, Vardi H 1, Greenberg D 1, Ben Yaakov G 2, Gaspar N 2,
Dizengof V 2, Moshkelo A 2, Munteau D 2, Rozental A 2, Abu Freha N 2, Schwartz D 2,
Krugliak P 2, Eidelman L 2, Fich A 2, Odes S 2
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Adami S 1, Aiello A 2, Magrì M R 2, Nocera S 2, Piovesan S 3, Alberti A 3, Scroccaro G 1
Farmaceutico - Regione Veneto, Venezia, Italy, 2CRUF Centro Regionale Unico sul Farmaco Regione Veneto, Verona, Italy, 3Dipartimento Medicina Molecolare - Università degli studi di
Padova, Padova, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Settore
Objectives: Hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection is one of the main causes of chronic
liver disease worldwide. Sofosbuvir, a nucleotide analogue inhibitor of HCV RNAdependent RNA polymerase, has been approved in Europe for the treatment of
chronic hepatitis C genotypes 1-6. This study aims to estimate the budget impact
of sofosbuvir in patients who live in the Veneto Region. Methods: Population data
were obtained from a regional survey. The survey was conducted by the Department
of Molecular Medicine of Padua University in order to identify the number of
patients with advanced stage disease or more rapid disease progression. At the
time of this study, the Italian price of sofosbuvir has not been defined so it was estimated that a full 12 week course of sofosbuvir would cost as Swedish price: 42.653
€ (85.306€ for a 24 week treatment). Total costs include costs for other drugs which
might be used in combination. Results: In Veneto Region, there are 835 patients
with severe Hepatitis C genotype 1 (n= 493); genotype 2 (n= 94), genotype 3 (n= 178),
genotype 4 (n= 70) and about 40% of them need a 24 week treatment. Moreover,
there are 100 patients awaiting liver transplantation and 70 patients with posttransplant recurrence of HCV infection. Therefore, the total estimated expenditure
would be about € 66.000.000 for all the 1005 patients and about € 34.000.000 for the
455 patients (45%) with very high priority to treatment. Conclusions: High prices
for new drugs are a growing concern to payers, given the large number of innovative drugs in development and the limited health care resources. Due to high costs,
economic analyses are needed to estimate the budgetary impact for the Regional
Health System (RHS) with sofosbuvir.
A364
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PGI8
Budget Impact Analysis Of Biosimilar Infliximab For The Treatment
Of Crohn’s Disease In Six Central Eastern European Countries
Brodszky V , Gulacsi L , Balogh O , Baji P, Rencz F , Péntek M
Corvinus University of Budapest, Budapest, Hungary
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Biosimilar infliximab (CT-P13) is the first licensed biosimilar in EU for
Crohn’s disease (CD). It is expected that spread of biosimilars in the treatment of
CD will lead to cost savings and it might improve access to biological therapies. The
main aim of this study was to analyse the budget impact of introducing biosimilar
infliximab for the treatment of CD in six Central Eastern European (CEE) countries’ – Bulgaria, Czech Republic, Hungary, Poland, Romania and Slovakia – health
care systems. Methods: This budget impact model estimates potential impact of
biosimilar infliximab on health care budget over three-year time frame from thirdparty payer perspective. Spreadsheet-based country specific population model was
developed functioning in quarter year time units. The model tracked movement of
CD population between main states: 1) immune therapy, 2) infliximab, 3) biosimilar
infliximab, 4) adalimumab. Switching between biologics and biosimilar infliximab
was taken into consideration as well. In scenario analyses different rates of interchanging and switching were analysed. A -25% price difference was assumed for
biosimilar infliximab compared to originator. Budget impact was calculated as difference in total cost of scenarios with and without biosimilar infliximab. Results:
In 2013,4, 625 CD patients were treated with biologicals in the CEE. Over the 3-year
period with gradually interchanging 80% of infliximab to biosimilar infliximab is
expected to lead to a net benefit of 16,635,000 euros compared to the scenario in
which biosimilar infliximab would not be available. In scenario in which interchangeabilty was disallowed the budget savings amounted to 7,842,000 euros. If
budget savings were spent on reimbursement of additional biosimilar infliximab
treatments, approximately further 889 or 420 patients could be treated in the six
countries, respectively. Conclusions: Introduction of biosimilar infliximab treatment for CD in CEE is predicted to bring substantial cost savings or increase of the
number of patients with access to biological therapy.
PGI9
Proton Pump Inhibitors In South Africa: Role Of Branded Generics
Truter I
Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University, Port Elizabeth, South Africa
.
Objectives: Originator products dominate the market, and as soon as patents
expire prescribing patterns change as branded generics become the most often
prescribed due to mandatory generic substitution in South Africa. This study investigated the prescribing patterns of proton pump inhibitors (PPIs). Methods: A
retrospective, cross-sectional drug utilisation study was conducted on prescription
data of a medical insurance scheme administrator in South Africa for 2011. The
database contained 2 298 312 records for medicine, medical devices and procedures. Results: A total of 22 198 PPIs were prescribed to 7 504 patients (average age:
45.09 (SD= 15.82) years) at a cost of R3 931 241.43. The average cost per PPI prescription was R177.10 (SD= R140.62). The average cost for a generic PPI prescription was
R147.01 compared to R276.17 for a prescription for an originator product. Five different PPIs were prescribed. Omeprazole, lansoprazole and pantoprazole had branded
generics available on the market, whereas esomeprazole and rabeprazole only had
originator products on the market. Omeprazole was the most frequently prescribed
(47.05% of all PPI prescriptions). Nearly all (98.90%) omeprazole prescriptions were
for one of its eight branded generics. Esomeprazole had the highest average cost
per prescription of R289.23. The 40mg tablet formulation of esomeprazole was the
most commonly prescribed. Less than 2% of PPI prescriptions were for rabeprazole.
Most prescriptions were for Schedule 4 products (prescription-only), with only 3.91%
Schedule 2 prescriptions (over-the-counter, prescribed in lower dosages for acute
symptoms over a short period of time). Overall in this study, 76.70% of PPI prescriptions were for branded generics. Conclusions: Omeprazole dominated PPI prescribing, whilst esomeprazole was the most expensive PPI. It will be important to
further investigate the impact of patent expiry and the introduction of new branded
generics on PPI prescribing patterns. The study confirmed the significant price differences for PPIs between branded generics and originator products.
PGI10
Direct Treatment Costs Of Cirrhosis In The Brazilian Public Health
Care System: A 2008-2012 Retrospecteve Analysis
Magno L A 1, Morais A D 2
1Janssen, Sao Paulo, Brazil, 2Janssen Cilag Farmaceutica, São Paulo, Brazil
.
.
.
.
Objectives: estimate direct health care costs associated with cirrhosis from a brazilian public payer perspective (SUS). Methods: A retrospective study of a public
claims database (DATASUS) was used to assess direct health care costs associated
with cirrhosis between 2008 and 2012. Patients with cirrhosis were identified based
on ICD-10 codes (K70.3, K71.7, K74.3-K74.6). The retrospective analysis considered
inpatient costs and outpatient treatment costs of patients during the 4 year time
frame. Medication costs were defined as a weighted average during the period of
analysis considering official government price lists available at www. comprasnet. gov. br. A sub analysis was carried out for cirrhotic patients with hepatitis C
(HCV) treatment, defined as patients treated with peg-interferon with ribavirin
(PR). Results: Between 2008-2012, 120,082 patients were hospitalized due to cirrhosis (49% of patients accounted by ICD K746) with a total treatment cost of R$ 404
million, 68% accounting for transplant (R$ 276 million), 30% for outpatient procedures (R$ 121 million), 2% for surgical procedures (R$ 6 million) and the remainder
for exams and diagnostics. Patients were hospitalized for an average of 10,1 days
per year, with an average cost of R$ 2,806 (R$2.149- R$ 3,757) per hospitalization
event and R$ 3.378 (R$ 2.523-4.579) per patient. The average cost for transplant was
R$ 52.912 (R$43.304-70.274). Between 2008 and 2012 2.933 patients were hospitalized for cirrhosis having received HCV treatment with a total cost of R$ 19 million.
The average inpatient cost for HCV-cirrhosis patients was R$ 4,999 for 11,2 days of
hospitalization. Organ transplants-associated costs accounted for R$ 15 million,
77% of total costs, with an average cost of R$ 67,319 per transplant. Conclusions:
Organ transplant accounts for the majority of hospital health care costs in cirrhosis
patients in the Brazilian public health care system. Considering patients with HCV
treatment and cirrhosis, the average cost per patient was around 78% higher than
the general cirrhosis patient.
PGI11
Burden Of Hospitalizations Related To Chronic Hepatitis C In
France: Evolution Between 2009 And 2012
Rotily M 1, Abergel A 2, Branchoux S 3, De Léotoing L 1, Vainchtock A 1, Akremi R 3,
Gaudin A F 3
1HEVA, Lyon, France, 2centre hospitalier universitaire CHU Estaing, Clermont-Ferrand, France,
3Bristol-Myers Squibb, Rueil-Malmaison, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess the burden of hospitalizations related to Chronic Hepatitis
C (CHC) in France in 2012 and to benchmark it to the 2009 estimate. Methods: All
hospital stays with chronic viral hepatitis C (ICD-10 code B18.2) as principal, related
or significantly associated diagnosis were extracted from the PMSI 2012 (French
Medical Information System Program) database. Through an algorithm and a medical review, hospitalizations not related to CHC were excluded. Patients were assigned
to a liver disease stage: F0-F3; compensated cirrhosis; decompensated cirrhosis;
hepatocellular carcinoma; liver transplant. Same database and method (without
making the distinction between compensated/decompensated cirrhosis) were used
in 2009 allowing descriptive benchmark. Valuation was performed on French official
tariffs for 2009 and 2012 and expressed in 2013 value (Euros). Results: 22,056 hospitalizations were extracted in 2012 vs 27,258 in 2009 corresponding to 12,040 and
15,482 patients, respectively. Sex-ratio M/F increased between 2009 and 2012 (1.66
vs 1.78), as well as proportion of patients aged of 50 years old and over (60% vs 70%).
In 2012, 5,834 patients were in F0-F3 fibrosis stage, 3,547 had cirrhosis and 2,105
had hepatocellular carcinoma. Crude estimates for the evolution for these stages
between 2009 and 2012 was -32%, -36% and +17%, respectively. Between 2009 and
2012, number of liver biopsies was reduced by one third, and also less liver transplants were performed (293 vs 254). Overall, the economic burden of hospitalizations
related to CHC was € 60 millions in 2012, 8% lower than in 2009. Conclusions:
3 major facts were highlighted: the decline in the number of liver biopsies, the
decrease in the number of patients hospitalized for cirrhosis and the increase in
patients hospitalized for hepatocellular carcinoma. This increase might be due to
an improvement in screening techniques and aging of the population.
PGI12
Mean Annual Cost Of Patients Hospitalized For Chronic Hepatitis C
In France: The Hepc-Lone Study
Abergel A 1, Rotily M 2, Gaudin A F 3, De Léotoing L 2, Vainchtock A 2, Akremi R 3,
Branchoux S 3
1centre hospitalier universitaire CHU Estaing, Clermont-Ferrand, France, 2HEVA, Lyon, France,
3Bristol-Myers Squibb, Rueil-Malmaison, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess the mean annual cost of patients hospitalized for Chronic
Hepatitis C (CHC) in France stratified by liver disease stage. Methods: Patients
hospitalized for chronic viral hepatitis C (ICD-10 code B18.2) were identified in
the PMSI-MCO 2010-2012 database (French Medical Information System ProgramMedicine, Surgery, Obstetric) between January, 1st 2010 and December, 31st 2012 and
tracked in the PMSI-SSR/HAD databases (post-acute care/hospitalizations at home:
alternative management of care). An algorithm and a medical review excluded
people under 18 years old, viral co-infected patients and non CHC related stays.
During the study period, patients were followed from their first stay to censoring
(i. e December 31st 2012 or death). For each patient, cumulative time in days in the
different liver disease stages (F0-F3 fibrosis; compensated cirrhosis; decompensated
cirrhosis; hepatocellular carcinoma; liver transplant) were calculated. Associated
costs during these periods were added up and a mean annual cost per patient per
liver disease stage estimated. As only inpatient deaths are captured into the PMSI,
estimated outpatient deaths were imputed. Valuation was performed considering
the national costs study (ENCC) expressed in 2013 Euro. Results: 58,405 stays
were identified, extracted and considered as directly related to CHC corresponding
to 26,621 patients. 743 additional hospitalizations were extracted from PMSI SSR/
HAD. Patients were 56±13.5 years old on average, 62% were male. Mean annual costs
of patients hospitalized for CHC reason were: € 1,107 for F0-F3 fibrosis; € 2,104 for
compensated cirrhosis; €10,400 for decompensated cirrhosis; €11,739 for hepatocellular carcinoma; € 62,098 for 1st year of liver transplant and € 7,449 for subsequent
year. Conclusions: CHC patients are mainly managed in acute care. Costs associated to CHC complications are important. These estimated hospital-related costs
will be useful to populate cost-effectiveness and disease cost models.
PGI13
Direct Health Care Costs Associated With Opioid-Induced
Constipation
Lawson R 1, Haycock L 2, Laxman K 2, King F 3, Gardner K 2
.
.
.
.
.
1AstraZeneca, Cheshire, UK, 2Evidera, London, UK, 3AstraZeneca, Gaithersberg, MD, USA
Objectives: Opioid-induced constipation (OIC) is the most common and distressing side effect of opioid treatment in patients with chronic pain. There are limited
data to estimate the occurrence of OIC; however, estimates in non-cancer patients
range from 40-50% and can be as high as 90% in cancer patients. Increased resource
utilisation is associated with the diagnosis and management of OIC; however, the
economic burden of OIC remains under-reported. Methods: This review considered the cost of illness associated with OIC. A targeted literature review was
conducted for all publications since 2000 that evaluated the economic burden of
OIC. Databases used for the literature search were PubMed, Embase, and HEED.
All costs were converted to a 2014 USD cost base. Results: Eleven studies were
identified which reported direct health care costs associated with OIC. All studies reported increased direct costs related to OIC; however, estimates per country varied significantly. Direct health care costs specifically related to OIC ranged
A365
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
from $1,747 to $48,782 per patient year. Per patient episode, direct costs associated
with OIC ranged from $54 to $11,705. This was further supported by a large international study which reported significantly more physician visits and alternative
care provider visits among patients with OIC than those without OIC. Two studies
reported on a subgroup of patients with OIC who failed to respond to laxatives;
these patients reported higher direct costs than patients who had a response to
laxatives. Conclusions: The management of OIC is associated with potentially
significant health care resource utilisation and financial burden. Patients with OIC
incur higher direct health care costs than those without OIC and costs are increased
further if patients with OIC have failed to respond to laxatives. There remains a
paucity of data on health care resource utilisation in OIC and further research into
the economic burden of OIC is needed.
PGI14
Economic And Quality-Of-Life Burden Of Moderate-To-Severe
Irritable Bowel Syndrome With Constipation (Ibs-C) In Spain: The
Ibis-C Study
Mearin F 1, Cortes X 2, Mackinnon J 3, Bertsch J 3, Fortea J 2, Tack J 4
médico Teknon, Barcelona, Spain, 2Laboratorios Almirall S. A., Barcelona, Spain, 3TFS
Develop S. L., Barcelona, Spain, 4University of Leuven, Leuven, Belgium
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Centro
Objectives: This study is the first study to assess the burden of IBS-C in 6 European
countries (France, Germany, Italy, Spain, Sweden, UK). Here we present the results
for Spain. Methods: Observational, retrospective-prospective (6 months each)
study in patients diagnosed with moderate-to-severe IBS-C in the last five years
(Rome-III criteria). Moderate-to-severe IBS-C was defined as IBS-Symptom Severity
Score (IBS-SSS) ≥ 175. Quality-of-life (QoL) was assessed with EuroQoL-5D (EQ-5D)
and IBS-QoL. Results: 112 patients were included (58% severe, mean age (±SD)
46.8±13.7 years, 86% female). At baseline, symptom severity (IBS-SSS; severe > 300)
was 315.4±82.9; presenteeism (WPA: IBS-C questionnaire; mean [±SD] % time in
week prior to inclusion): 32.3±27.2; absenteeism: 6.1±15.8; work productivity loss:
29.2±27.5; and daily activity impairment 39.6±27.2. Mean IBS-QoL was 41.0±21.2,
(scale: 0-100 [best-to-worst]), and the most affected domains were “food avoidance”
(mean: 60.4) and “health worry” (54.6). Mean EQ-5D was 57±21 (scale: 0-100 [worstto-best]) and 86% and 63% of patients reported moderate-to-severe problems in
pain/discomfort, anxiety/depression respectively. The most prevalent symptoms
were: constipation (84%), abdominal pain (80%), abdominal distention (80%) and
bloating (59%). Over the year, 88% of patients consulted a primary care physician,
and 82% a gastroenterologist; mean (95%CI): 3.8 and 2.3 visits, respectively. 20% of
patients required emergency department visits or hospitalization (mean stay: 1.5
(0.6-2.4) days). 58% of patients underwent a diagnostic test (mean: 2.4 (1.8-2.9)).
85% of patients took pharmacological medication (80% took some pharmacological
medication for their IBS-C) 30% received complementary therapies. After 6 months
of follow-up, only 1 in 5 patients had no or mild symptoms. The mean (95%CI) annual
direct cost for the Spanish National Health System (NHS) was 1067€ (730-1447) and
the mean cost for the patient was 568€ (333-841). 13% of patients took sick leave
(mean: 6.3 times; mean duration: 52 days) and 28% had productivity losses (mean:
55 hours). Mean indirect costs were 1362€ (313-2866). Total costs amounted to 2997€
(1799-4515) /year. Conclusions: Moderate-to-severe IBS-C has a great impact on
patient QoL, productivity, and health care resource utilization.
PGI15
Hospitalization Costs Associated With Liver Cirrhosis
Silva M 1, Laires P 2, Costa M 1, Leão R 1, Roque A 1, Calinas F 1
de Santo António dos Capuchos, Lisbon, Portugal, 2Merck Sharp & Dohme, Oeiras,
Portugal
.
.
.
.
.
costs associated with the treatment of IBS in England. Methods: Hospital Episode
Statistics (HES) data for 2012-13 for all clinical commissioning groups (CCGs) in
England were analysed to calculate the tariff cost of IBS. IBS diagnosis codes were
included in the analysis. Prescribing data and cost (PACT) data for 2012-13 were
also analysed. Results: During 2012/13 there were 1,217,993 outpatient appointments in gastroenterology and colorectal surgery specialities, with a total tariff cost
of £365,868,937. Despite this, only 1,982 patients were recorded with IBS-specific
codes, with a total estimated tariff cost of £812,336. In addition, 28,849 patients
were recorded with IBS-related symptom codes at a cost of £11,002,874. There were
also 658,698 diagnostic lower GI endoscopies at a tariff cost of £169,676,704. Of
these, 323,752 (49%) had no further follow-up in secondary care in the subsequent
12 months. PACT data indicated that £44,977,959 and £25,582,752 was spent on
selected laxatives and antispasmodics, respectively, commonly used to treat IBS in
primary care. Conclusions: Despite being poorly clinically coded, it is clear that
IBS places a significant cost burden on the NHS. Notably, 49% of patients seen for
lower GI endoscopies had no further activity provided by the Hospital Provider Trust
as an inpatient or outpatient over the subsequent 12 months, implying functional
symptoms. Better diagnosis and subsequent management of IBS within a primary
care setting may provide direct savings in the cost of IBS management. This study
was financially supported by Almirall. Hospital Episode Statistics Data were provided via Harvey Walsh Ltd under commercial reuse licence.
PGI17
A Cost Of Care Model For Inflammatory Bowel Disease With A Uk
Nhs Perspective
Miles G 1, Leonard S A 1, Ghosh N 2, Premchand P 2
1Costello Medical Consulting, Cambridge, UK, 2Barking, Havering and Redbridge University
Hospitals NHS Trust, Romford, UK
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: There are an estimated 620,000 patients with inflammatory bowel
disease (IBD) in the UK. The rising incidence of IBD combined with its incurability
has significant cost implications, with the National IBD Audit estimating that cost
to the National Health Service (NHS) exceeded £1 billion in 2010. The aim of this
cost of care model was to calculate the annual cost per patient of treating ulcerative
colitis (UC) and Crohn’s disease (CD) from an NHS perspective, and to enable areas
of potential cost savings to be explored. Methods: The cost of IBD was calculated
by summing the costs of treatment, treatment side effects and disease-related complications, accounting for the proportions of patients incurring these costs. The
model included detailed costs for each treatment (eg. brand of mesalazine), major
side effects for each treatment (eg. pancreatitis from thiopurines) and complications (eg. pyoderma gangrenosum). Default input values for costs, the percentage
of patients receiving each treatment, and the percentage of patients experiencing
side effects or complications were determined from national sources and published
literature. However, the model permitted the user to input local or alternative data
(eg. to reflect brand preferences for oral mesalazines) and conduct scenario analyses. Results: Using default input values, the annual cost of treating any UC patient
was estimated to be £3,084. For a UC patient in remission, in relapse with mild-tomoderate UC or in relapse with severe UC, annual cost per patient was estimated
to be £1,693, £2,903 and £10,760, respectively. The annual cost for any CD patient
was estimated to be £6,156 (£1,800 for patients in remission; £10,513 for patients in
relapse). Conclusions: IBD is a costly, chronic condition and this model facilitates
calculation of annual costs per UC and CD patient. The models’ customisability will
help hospitals to identify areas where savings could be made.
.
1Hospital
Objectives: The burden and cost of liver disease is known to be substantial, but accurate data on this subject is still scarce in Portugal. So far most estimates are obtained
from diagnosis-related groups (DRGs) associated with hospital financing and from
expert panels. In this analysis we aimed to calculate the real costs associated with
hospital admissions due to liver cirrhosis (LC) in a large hospital. Methods: All hospitalizations in the gastroenterology department from a tertiary hospital in Portugal
(Centro Hospitalar Lisboa Central) during 2012 were analyzed. Patient level data was
used to retrieve relevant demographic and clinical information. Costs assumed to be
specific for LC admissions, namely medication, imaging and other techniques, were
estimated directly. Department-specific hospital accountancy was used to include
the remaining hospital costs associated with these hospitalizations. Results: A
total of 644 admissions were analyzed, from which 135 (21.0%) were due to LC, corresponding to 82 patients. 74.4% (n= 61) were males, median age was 55 years. The
main cause of LC was alcohol (58.5%). In the admissions due to LC, average length
of stay (LoS) was 15.3 days and total mean hospitalization cost was 3,979.5€ . For all
analyzed admissions, average LoS and mean total cost were 8.1 days and 2,323.8€ ,
respectively. Average cost for medications in admissions for LC amounted to 492.7€ ,
compared to 228.7€ for all admissions. Within admissions for LC, costs were not
significantly different for hospitalizations with or without hepatocellular carcinoma. Conclusions: The estimated overall cost of a hospital admission for LC in
a gastroenterology department was superior to the average value of hospitalizations
for all causes, and approximately twice the official DRG value. This study highlights
the current economic burden of liver cirrhosis faced by a tertiary hospital and the possible need to revise some of the assumptions used for financing Portuguese hospitals.
PGI16
The Cost Of Irritable Bowel Syndrome (Ibs) In England
Soubieres A1, Wilson PDP1, Poullis A1, Wilkins J2, Rance M3
1St George’s Healthcare NHS Trust, London, UK, 2Harvey Walsh Ltd, Runcorn, UK, 3Almirall,
Uxbridge, UK
Objectives: The NHS is faced with increasing cost pressures that make the efficient use of resources paramount. Patients with IBS may consume considerable
NHS resource through inpatient and outpatient visits, diagnostic tests and treatment. This study aimed to estimate admission costs and primary care prescribing
PGI18
Health Care Cost Associated To Constipation Predominant Irritable
Bowel Syndrome In Spain
Raya A 1, Barrull C 2, Roset M 2, Cortes X 1, Fortea J 1
1Almirall S. A, Barcelona, Spain,, 2IMS Health, Barcelona, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate health care resource use and costs associated with the management and treatment of constipation predominant irritable bowel syndrome (IBS-C)
in Spanish clinical practice. Methods: The 2011 primary care (PC) IASIST database,
which includes 3,678,522 clinical charts corresponding to PC sites from the National
Health System (NHS), was used to estimate the number of patients with IBS-C (identified by a combination of ICD code and prescription of IBS-C drugs) and obtain data
on the number of hospitalizations (service, frequency and duration), scheduled and
emergency visits to PC, referrals to specialist care, and IBS-C treatments prescribed
and dispensed in retail pharmacies and their associated costs. Based on data from
IASIST database and unit costs retrieved from the e-Salud database, health care costs
associated with IBS-C from the NHS perspective were calculated. Results: A total of
5,649 IBS-C patients were indentified in the database, corresponding to a prevalence
of 0.15% of patients attending PC. Total costs associated with IBS-C in the sample were
estimated to be €4,755,725; highest costs were associated with PC visits (€2,791,725,
corresponding to 58.7% of total IBS-C costs). This high cost of PC visits is explained by
the high number of visits by IBS-C patients (17.4 visits annually per patient). Costs of
PC visits are followed by hospitalization costs (€ 610,859, 12.8% of total cost), medical
visits to specialists (€556,164, 11.7%) and emergency room visits to PC (€491,142,10.3%).
Costs of pharmacological treatment (€305,707) represented only 6.4% of total IBS-C
costs. Conclusions: The low prevalence of IBS-C observed may be due to the underregistration or under-diagnosis of IBS-C. Costs associated with the management of
IBS-C are driven mainly by the high number of PC visits, which may be associated
with the current unmet medical needs in IBS-C.
PGI19
Economic Evaluation Of Various Strategies For Antiviral Therapy
For Previously Treated Patients With Chronic Hcv Genotipe 1
Infection
Avxentyeva M , Pyadushkina E , Derkach E V
The Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration,
Moscow, Russia
.
.
.
.
A366
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: To estimate health care costs of alternative therapeutic strategies:
no treatment versus peginterferon and ribavirin (PR) versus protease inhibitor (PI) boceprevir added to PR for Russian treatment experienced chronic HCV
patients, who had failure previous treatment, in short- and long-term time horizon. Methods: An Excel-based model was developed to evaluate costs and
outcomes of chronic HCV treated with dual therapy with PR and triple therapy
with boceprevir in combination with PR. Costs for two time periods were analysed: antiviral therapy costs (0-48 weeks) and disease-progression related costs
(from 48 weeks to 25 years), depending on the chosen therapy. Antiviral drug costs
were calculated on the base of registered prices from the list of vital and essential
drugs. Incidence of compensated and decompensated cirrhosis, hepatocellular
carcinoma, liver transplant and post-liver transplant in the outcome of chronic
HCV in long-term period was derived from available published data. Treatment
costs of liver disease progression events were estimated according to the tariffs
of the Russian health care system in 2014. Results: Boceprevir +PR compared
to no treatment strategy and PR therapy was associated with more avoided
liver-disease progression events at lesser costs, resulting in boceprevir+PR as
the dominant treatment option in patients with chronic HCV genotype 1 nonresponders to previous treatment in Russia. Additional costs per avoided event of
liver-disease progression for boceprevir plus PR and dual PR therapy were €
12,654.26 and € 45,082.82 respectively. Conclusions: Antiviral therapy with
boceprevir plus PR in comparison with only PR therapy and no treatment strategy is cost effective due to reduced frequency of disease progression events and
associated costs.
PGI20
Lubiprostone In Chronic Idiopathic Constipation: A CostEffectiveness Analysis
Pennington B 1, Marriott E 1, Sophia H 2, Lichtlen P 3, Hatswell A J 1
1BresMed, Sheffield, UK, 2Sucampo Pharma Europe, Oxfordshire, UK, 3Sucampo, Zug, Switzerland
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The clinical efficacy of lubiprostone in chronic idiopathic constipation has been demonstrated in three randomised clinical trials (RCTs). This analysis assesses the cost effectiveness of lubiprostone compared to prucalopride (the
current standard of care), placebo and immediate referral to secondary care from
the perspective of the UK National Health Service (NHS). Methods: A statetransition model was constructed to represent the treatment pathway for chronic
idiopathic constipation from an NHS perspective with a 1-year time horizon. The
model considered treatment continuation rules, at Week 2 for lubiprostone and
Week 4 for prucalopride. Clinical data were taken from RCTs and an indirect comparison with prucalopride. Long-term duration of treatment was estimated by fitting curves to open-label study data. Costs included drug costs, medical resource
use, and the cost of the pathway including primary and secondary care, obtained
from published sources. Quality of life was modelled according to whether constipation was resolved or unresolved, with values taken from a large published
study (n= 1,200). Results: Compared to placebo, lubiprostone delayed referral to
secondary care and improved quality of life, but resulted in increased costs due to
treatment, the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio was £2,924. Lubiprostone and
prucalopride were found to have similar efficacy, with lubiprostone generating an
additional 0.0014 QALYs in the base case. The cost per day for lubiprostone is lower
than for prucalopride; leading to lower total costs (£1,596 v £1,655), and meaning
lubiprostone dominated prucalopride (lower cost and higher QALYs). Probabilistic
sensitivity analysis showed lubiprostone to have an 84% chance of being the
most cost-effective treatment at a threshold of £20,000 per QALY. Conclusions:
Treatment with lubiprostone provides substantial value to both patients and the
NHS, being highly cost effective compared to placebo and dominant compared to
the current standard of care.
PGI21
Cost-Effectiveness Of Linaclotide: A Valuable Option In The
Treatment Of Irritable Bowel Syndrome
Almeida J , Vandewalle B , Félix J
Exigo Consultores, Lisbon, Portugal
.
.
.
Objectives: Constipation-predominant irritable bowel syndrome (IBS-C) affects
more than 2% of the population carrying a heavy burden in developed countries
and leading to significant losses in patients’ quality of life. Treatment goals are
to provide relief of abdominal pain, restore the bowel transit and alleviate associated symptoms. Linaclotide has been shown to significantly improve abdominal
and bowel symptoms in two phase III trials being the only EMA approved therapy
indicated for the treatment of IBS-C. Therefore, this study aimed to perform a
cost-effectiveness analysis comparing linaclotide with no active treatment for
the treatment of IBS-C from the Portuguese societal perspective. Methods: A
Markov model was developed to simulate the natural course and treatment of the
disease. Patient-level satisfaction data from linaclotide’s randomised clinical trials
was used to define 4 health states: ‘Not Satisfied’, ‘Moderately Satisfied’, ‘Satisfied’
and ‘Dead’. These data were linked to utility scores based on patients’ responses
to the EuroQol-5D questionnaire. Transitions between health states were assumed
to occur every 4 weeks, with probabilities derived from observed efficacy data
up to 20-weeks. Extrapolation beyond this period was based on last observation
carried forward data. Effectiveness was measured in quality-adjusted life years
(QALY). Only direct costs were incorporated. Resource utilization was estimated
from a literature review. Unit costs came from official Portuguese databases and
pricing lists. Time horizon was fixed at 10 years. Probabilistic sensitivity analysis was conducted with Monte Carlo simulations. Results: A mean gain of 0.22
QALY (95%CI: [0.1; 0.35]) was estimated for each patient treated with linaclotide
versus no treatment. Additionally, linaclotide utilization led to an overall average cost reduction of 402€ (95%CI: [-1,735; 536]) thus representing a dominant
option. Conclusions: When compared with no active treatment, linaclotide
is a cost-saving and more effective therapeutic option for the treatment of IBS-C
from the Portuguese societal perspective.
PGI22
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis Of A Personalized Therapy For Genotype
1, Naive, Chronic Hepatitis C Patients In Italy
Iannazzo S 1, Colombatto P 2, Bonino F 2, Brunetto M R 2
1SIHS Health Economics Consulting, Torino, Italy, 2University Hospital (AOUP), Cisanello (Pi), Italy
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Rapid Virologic Response (RVR) is currently used as the best predictor
of Sustained Virologic Response (SVR) with dual therapy (DT) in genotype-1 chronic
hepatitis C (G1-CHC), to optimize the adoption of the triple therapy (TT) with
direct-acting antivirals (boceprevir: BOC and telaprevir: TVR). Bio-mathematical
modelling of viral dynamics during DT has potentially higher accuracy than RVR
in the identification of SVR patients. The objective of this study was to analyse
the cost-effectiveness profile of a personalized anti-HCV therapy in F0-F2 G1-CHC
based on a bio-mathematical model (model-guided strategy: MG) rather than on
the RVR (guideline-guided strategy: GG). Methods: A deterministic bio-mathematical model of the infected cell dynamics was validated in a cohort of 135
G1-CHC patients treated with DT at the University Hospital in Pisa, Italy. A lifetime
health economic (HE) model was then developed to compare MG and GG strategies
in the perspective of the Italian National Health Service. The model was alimented
with observed data in the validation cohort, clinical variables and economic
data available in the literature. A 3.5% discount rate was applied to outcomes
and costs. One-way and probabilistic sensitivity analyses were run. Results:
the outcomes with MG- and GG-strategy were 19.1-19.4 and 18.9-19.3 qualityadjusted-life-years (QALY). Total per-patient lifetime costs were € 25,200-€ 26,000
with MG-strategy and € 28,800-€ 29,900 with GG-strategy. When comparing MGwith GG-strategy the former resulted more effective and less costly, being defined
as dominant. Conclusions: The adoption of a SVR predictive criterion based
on a bio-mathematical model, has the potential to improve the cost-effectiveness
of a personalized anti-HCV therapy, allowing a more accurate identification of
patients who can be effectively treated with DT and reserving high-cost BOC- and
TVR-based TT for those who really need it.
PGI23
Sofosbuvir For The Treatment Of Chronic Hepatitis C: A
Comprehensive Cost-Effectiveness Analysis Across Hcv Genotypes,
Pretreatment Conditions And Hiv Co-Infection
Silva M 1, Félix J 1, Ferreira D 1, Vandewalle B 1, Guerra I 2, Cure S 2, Aldir I 3, Carvalho A 4,
Macedo G 5, Marinho R T 6, Pedroto I 7, Ramalho F 6
Consultores, Alhos Vedros, Portugal, 2OptumInsight, Uxbridge, UK, 3Hospital Egas Moniz,
Centro Hospitalar de Lisboa Ocidental, Lisboa, Portugal, 4Centro Hospitalar e Universitário de
Coimbra, Coimbra, Portugal, 5Hospital de São João, Porto, Portugal, 6Centro Hospitalar Lisboa
Norte. Hospital de Santa Maria, Lisboa, Portugal, 7Centro Hospitalar do Porto, Porto, Portugal
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Exigo
Objectives: Pegylated interferon-α plus ribavirin (PR) has been the standard of
care for Chronic Hepatitis C (CHC). Therapy adding boceprevir (BOC) or telaprevir
(TVR) to PR in HCV genotype-1 patients has failed to achieve generalized market
acceptance, in part due to the approval of newer more efficacious and safer options
like sofosbuvir (SOF), a new pan-genotypic RNA-polymerase inhibitor. Objective: To
assess the cost-effectiveness of sofosbuvir based therapy for CHC across HCV genotypes, pretreatment conditions and HIV co-infection in Portugal. Methods: Costs
and effectiveness were estimated based on discrete-time Markov-type model for
CHC evolution accounting for different subpopulations in terms of HCV genotype,
fibrosis progression, HIV co-infection status and previous treatment experience.
The model incorporates 13 health states: 5 Metavir score, 2 SVR (with and without
cirrhosis) and 3 advanced liver disease states (decompensated cirrhosis, hepatocellular carcinoma, liver transplant). Results are expressed in incremental costs per
life year (LY) and quality-adjusted life year (QALY). Results: Overall sofosbuvircontaining regimens are expected to result in an increment of 3.49 LY (3.05 QALY)
after weighting for the different subpopulations assuming Portuguese epidemiology. The corresponding weighted incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICER) was
14,649€ /LY (16,720€ /QALY). In the comparison against the BOC and TVR containing
regimens (genotype-1), ICER of 10,675€ /LY (12,238€ /QALY) and 14,618€ /LY (16,495€ /
QALY) were obtained, respectively. For HIV co-infected and PegIFN eligible/tolerant
patients, estimated ICER varied between 6,463€ /LY (6,902€ /QALY) and 21,281€ /LY
(28,245€/QALY), for G1 and G2, respectively, when comparing against treatment with
PR. Additionally, in HCV/HIV coinfected patients ineligible/intolerant to PegIFN, the
comparison against lack-of-therapy resulted in ICER of 15,656€ /LY (17,756€ /QALY)
and 12,915€ /LY (19,077€ /QALY), for HCV G1 and G3, respectively. Conclusions:
Sofosbuvir-containing regimens for the treatment of adult CHC patients, irrespective of HIV co-infection status, are expected to result in significant health gains at
an incremental cost within the range of European Health Authorities acceptability.
PGI24
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis Of Antiviral Pharmacotherapies For
Treatment Of Chronic Hepatitis C Virus Infection In Russia
Pyadushkina E 1, Avxentyeva M 1, Omelyanovsky V V 1, Treur M 2, Westerhout K Y 2
1The Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration, Moscow,
Russia, 2Pharmerit International, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate the clinical and economic expediency of adding simeprevir
(SMV) to pegylated-interferon and ribavirin (PR) versus PR only, or triple therapies with PR plus boceprevir (BOC) or telaprevir (TVR) for treatment of genotype
1 chronic hepatitis C (CHC) virus infection in patients who have failed previous
therapy with interferon and ribavirin in Russia. Methods: A Markov model developed earlier was adapted to the Russian settings. The analysis consists of 2 time
periods: 1st the antiviral therapy (AVT) phase and 24 week follow-up (0-72 weeks)
and 2ndthe disease progression of CHC (72 weeks - lifetime). Incidences of disease
progression health-states (decompensated cirrhosis, hepatocellular carcinoma, liver
transplant, post-liver transplant and death, associated with high health care costs,
high mortality rates) based on available published data. Costs and outcomes (life
years, LY) were analyzed for treatment experienced CHC patients from Russian
health care system perspective. The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) per
A367
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
LY was calculated. Sensitivity analyses were performed. Results: Model results for
treatment-experienced patients show that SMV is the dominant treatment compared to TVR+PR and BOC+PR therapies as more total LYs are saved and less costs
accrued. ICER of SMV+PR vs PR was € 22,967 per LY. Results were robust in sensitivity
analyses. Conclusions: SMV + PR is cost-effective compared to dual PR-therapy
and appears the dominant strategy compared to other PI (telaprevir, boceprevir) for
CHC treatment-experienced patients in Russia.
PGI25
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis Of Triple Therapy With Peginterferon,
Ribavirin, And Boceprevir For The Treatment Of Chronic Hepatitis C
Virus Genotype 1 With Severe Fibrosis Under “Real-Life” Conditions
Ruiz-Antorán B 1, Pascasio J M 2, Gea F 3, Barcena R 4, Larrubia J 5, Pérez Álvarez R 6, Sousa J 2,
Romero Gómez M 7, Solá R 8, de la Revilla J 9, Crespo J 10, Navarro J 11, Arenas J 12,
Delgado M 13, Fernández Rodríguez C 14, Planas R15, Buti M 16, Forns X 17, Calleja J L 9
1University Hospital Puerta de Hierro, Madrid, Spain, 2Unidad de Gestión Clínica de Enfermedades
Digestivas, IBIS (Instituto de Biomedicina de Sevilla (IBIS), H. Virgen del Rocío, Sevilla, Spain,
3University Hospital La Paz, Madrid, Spain, 4University Hospital Ramón y Cajal, Madrid, Spain,
5Guadalajara University Hospital. University of Alcalá. Spain, Guadalajara, Spain, 6Asturias
Central Hospital University, Oviedo, Spain, 7Valme University Hospital, University of Seville,
Sevilla, Spain, 8Hospital del Mar, Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona,, Barcelona, Spain,
9University Hospital Puerta de Hierro, Madrid, Spain, 10Hospital Universitario Marqués de
Valdecilla, Insituto de Investigación Valdecilla. IDIVAL, Santander, Spain, 11Hospital Costa del
Sol. Marbella, Malaga, Spain, 12University Hospital Donostia, San Sebastian, Spain, 13University
Hospital La Coruña, La Coruña, Spain, 14Hospital Universitario Fundación Alcorcon, Madrid,
Spain, 15Hospital Germans Trias i Pujol, Barcelona, Spain, 16Vall d’Hebron University Hospital,
Barcelona, Spain, 17Hospital Clinic, Barcelona, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Studies based on the data of clinical trials have proved that the triple
therapy for hepatitis C is cost effective. This study we assessed the cost-effectiveness of triple therapy in treatment of Chronic Hepatitis C with Severe Fibrosis under
“real-life” conditions. Methods: The analysis was conducted from the data included
in the prospective, multicentre, Spanish registry that includes patients with HCVgenotype-1 infection, who had severe fibrosis and were treated with triple therapy
(peginterferon alfa-2a or 2b, ribavirin, and boceprevir). The cost effectiveness analysis
of antiviral treatment includes the costs of antiviral treatment, of concomitant treatments and costs in relation to health care resources (in relation to clinical practice
and the adverse events). Results: 170 patients were included. 68.2% male, mean
age of 53 (29-76) years. 80% had received prior treatment. 36.5% of patients reported
at least one SAEs. The overall percentage of patients with SVRw12 was 46.5%. The
cost of triple therapy represented a total of 4,916,652.84€ , the pharmacological cost
(triple therapy+concomitant treatment) involved a total cost of 5,161,168.98€ . The
consumption of health resources generated an additional cost of 240,000 € , which is
about 1,500€ /patient. The total cost per patient cured was 70,262€ . This cost varies
greatly based on different baseline characteristics of the patients, with significant
differences in patients with albumin <3.5, 120,597€; prior null response 120,727€ and
platelets <90,000,104,464€. Conclusions: The current scenario of the hepatitis C
treatment is changing. Triple therapy is more costly for patients with severe fibrosis
and predictors of poor response. However, keeping in mind that the timeframe for the
release of IFN-free regimens remains uncertain and considered that the actual access
to the new DAA in the real world setting could be delayed, boceprevir could remain
as an option for patients with intact liver function and a high unmet medical need,
regardless of the degree of liver fibrosis, in locations where a delay in the access to
the newer therapies is foreseen and hepatic transplant would not be readily available.
PGI26
The Cost Effectiveness Analysis Of The Oral Anti-Viral Treatments
Alternatives For The Chronic Hepatitis B In Turkey
Objectives: Prolonged exposure to CNI-based immunosuppressant therapy (IS)
in liver transplant (LTx) recipients is associated with long-term complications.
In the global registration trial H2304, patients receiving everolimus + reduced
tacrolimus (EVR + reduced TAC) demonstrated non-inferior efficacy and superior renal function at Month 12 that was sustained at 36 months compared to
tacrolimus alone (TAC). A peer-reviewed Markov model has been adapted to the
Italian setting to explore the cost-effectiveness of EVR + reduced TAC compared to
TAC, in de novo liver-recipients. Methods: The model estimates long-term outcomes associated with IS following LTx along two independent pathways: 1. liverrelated (acute rejection, hepatocellular carcinoma, hepatitis C [HCV] recurrence,
graft loss); 2. kidney-related (chronic kidney disease, dialysis, renal transplantation) and death. All patients, stratified by liver diagnosis, entered the model at time
of LTx and followed both pathways, allowing for multiple combinations of liver
and kidney health states. The lifetime model used an annual cycle length
except for the 1styear post LTx (quarterly). Efficacy and safety of IS strategies
were assessed through the risk of acute rejection, change in renal function, HCV
fibrosis progression and frequency of adverse events. Utilities and costs were
assigned to each renal and liver state. Subgroup and sensitivity analyses were
performed. Results: With a mean life expectancy of 18 years, the model predicts
patients treated with EVR + reduced TAC gain on average 1.84 years of life and 1.55
QALYs vs. TAC. The risk of acute rejection was reduced by 20%. The incremental
cost of EVR + TAC was € 38,884 per life year gained and € 46,103 per QALY gained
vs. TAC. Conclusions: This model shows a strategy of EVR + reduced TAC postLTx improves survival and quality of life. Higher treatment costs are offset by
slower progression of renal deterioration predicted in the first 10 years and fewer
lifetime liver complications.
PGI28
Cost-Utility Analysis Of Screening Strategies For Nonalcoholic
Steatohepatitis
Zhang E 1, Wartelle-Bladou C 1, Lepanto L 1, Lachaine J 2, Cloutier G 1, Tang A 1
Hospital, Montreal, QC, Canada, 2University of Montreal, Montreal, QC, Canada
.
.
.
.
.
.
1CHUM-St-Luc
Objectives: Nonalcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD) is the most common liver
condition in Western countries. To date, no studies have examined the costeffectiveness of screening for nonalcoholic steatohepatitis (NASH), its advanced
form. Methods: We performed a cost-utility analysis of annual non-invasive
screening strategies using a third-party payer perspective in a general population
and compared it to screening in a high-risk obese or diabetic population. Screening
algorithms involved well-studied non-invasive techniques including NAFLD fibrosis score, ultrasound transient elastography (TE), and ultrasound acoustic radiation
force impulse (ARFI) imaging for detecting advanced fibrosis (≥ F3); and plasma
cytokeratin-18 for NASH detection. Liver biopsy and magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) were compared as confirmation methods. Model uncertainties
were tested using sensitivity analyses. Canadian dollar costs were adjusted for
inflation and discounted at 5%. Incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of
$C50,000 per quality-adjusted life year (QALY) or less was considered cost-effective. Results: Compared with no screening, screening with NAFLD fibrosis score/
TE/CK-18 algorithm with MRE as confirmation for advanced fibrosis had an ICER
of $C26,143 per QALY gained. Screening in high-risk obese or diabetic populations
was more cost-effective, with an ICER of $C9,051 and $C7,991 per QALY gained
respectively. Screening algorithms with liver biopsy confirmation were not found
to be cost-effective. Sensitivity analyses revealed that the screening starting age,
the annual transition probability from simple steatosis to NASH, and the cost of
a TE exam had the most impact on the results. Conclusions: Our model suggests that annual NASH screening in high-risk obese or diabetic populations can
be cost-effective.
Kockaya G 1, Kose A 1, Dalgic C 1, Yenilmez F B 2, Ozdemir O 3, Kucuksayrac E 1, Tayfun K 1
1Gilead Science, Istanbul, Turkey, 2Hacettepe University, Ankara, Turkey, 3Yorum Consultancy,
ISTANBUL, Turkey
PGI29
The Cost-Effectiveness Of Sofosbuvir And Ribavirin Treatment In
Hcv-Infected Patients Listed For Liver Transplantation
Objectives: The aim of this study is to compare the cost effectiveness of oral antiviral treatment strategies in CHB for Turkey using lamuvidine, telbuvidine, entecavir,
and tenofovir as medications. Methods: The analysis was conducted using Markov
model. Inadequate response or resistance after receiving 12 months of the treatment
with entecavir and telbivudine were compared to the results found from switching
from entecavir to tenofovir or from switching from telbuvidine to tenofovir. In additional, inadequate response or resistance after receiving 6 months of the treatment
for lamivudine was compared to the results found from switching from lamivudine
to tenofovir. The model duration was constructed to evaluate a treatment strategy
duration of 40 years. Years of Potential Life Lost (YPLL) was used as the health
outcome. An incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) analysis of the results was
conducted. Results: In a life time period, the lowest YPLL and the cost of treatment
were calculated for the NS. Tenofovir treatment with 0.54 years and 37,213.75 TL.
Depending on the results, the lowest YPLL and the cost of treatment were served
by NS. Tenofovir treatment with 2.06 years and 276,468.45 TL. The highest YPLL and
the cost of treatment were calculated for the NS. The ICER analysis found that all
treatment strategies were dominated by NS. Tenofovir and S. Entecavir. Only these
two treatment strategies were found to be cost-effective. Conclusions: The cost
of providing 40 years of treatment for patients with CHB, if reimbursement agencies includes Tenofovir and Entecavir as part of the first line treatment strategy for
CHB, it can be expected that this approach would result in a positive contribution
to the health budget in Turkey.
Cortesi P A 1, Mantovani L 2, Ciaccio A 1, Rota M 1, Cesana G 1, Strazzabosco M 1, Belli L S 3
1University of Milano - Bicocca, Monza, Italy, 2Federico II University of Naples, Naples, Italy,
3Niguarda Hospital, Milan, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
PGI27
Cost-Effectiveness Of Everolimus Plus Reduced Tacrolimus In De
Novo Liver-Recipients In The Italian Setting
Bianic F 1, Campbell R 2, De Simone P 3, Roccia A 4, Gregson G 5
1OptumInsight, Paris, France, 2OptumInsight, Uxbridge, UK, 3University of Pisa Medical School
Hospital, Pisa, Italy, 4Novartis Farma, Origgio, Italy, 5Novartis Pharma AG, Basel, Switzerland
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Sofosbuvir in combination with ribavirin (SOF/RBV) is a novel treatment able to suppress HCV viremia when applied to HCV patients listed for
transplant, preventing HCV recurrence. Aim of this study was to assess the costeffectiveness of this regimen in HCV patients listed for transplant for cirrhosis (HCVcirrhosis) or for hepatocellular carcinoma (HCV-HCC). Methods: a semi-Markov
model was developed. The model simulates the progression of HCV-cirrhosis or
HCV-HCC patients from the time of listing until death considering the risk of HCV
recurrence post-transplant. The model compared 2 different strategies: 1) SOF/RBV
up to a maximum of 24 weeks or until OLT if performed before the 24th week, 2)
No antiviral treatment. The model estimated the costs related to the treatment
with SOF/RBV, the costs associated to each health state, the life-years (LYSs), the
quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs), and the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio
(ICER) expressed as € per QALY gained. The analysis was performed from the Italian
National Health System perspective with a lifetime time horizon and one-month
Markov cycles. Future costs and clinical benefits, expressed as QALYs, were discounted at 3% per year. Results: in the base-case analysis the ICER for 24 weeks
of SOF/RBVR was € 30,518 per QALY gained in HCV-cirrhosis patients and € 41,610
in HCV-HCC patients. The reliability of our results was confirmed by the one way
sensitivity-analysis and by the cost-effectiveness acceptability curve. Further, SOF/
RBV cost-effectiveness was clearly sensitive to the duration of treatment; assuming 12 weeks SOF/RBV treatment duration, the ICER decreased to € 19,317 in HCVCirrhosis and € 29,540 in HCV-HCC. Conclusions: our study shows that treating
patients with HCV-cirrhosis or HCV-HCC listed for transplant with SOF/RBV is costeffective and may become the new standard of care for these patients. However a
well-defined prospective study is needed to confirm the value of the parameters
assumed in the model and the results.
A368
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PGI30
Cost-Utility Analysis Of Sofosbuvir For Treatment Of Genotype2
Chronic Hepatitis C In Japan
Igarashi A 1, Tang W 1, Cure S 2, Guerra I 2, Lopresti M 3, Tsutani K 1
of Tokyo, Graduate School of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Tokyo, Japan, 2OptumInsight,
Uxbridge, UK, 3Junicon Japan Inc., Minato Tokyo, Japan
.
.
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: To conduct a cost-utility analysis of sofosbuvir for genotype 2
chronic hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection in Japan. Methods: The Markov-model,
“Sofosbuvir cost-effectiveness model”, which was constructed originally for similar
study in UK, was modified and used for this analysis, while imputed data were
replaced with Japanese data, as far as possible. Various health states, such as noncirrhotic hepatitis, sustained virological response (SVR), compensated cirrhosis,
decompensated cirrhosis and hepatocellular carcinoma were incorporated to the
model. Analyses were conducted for 4 scenarios, classified by treatment history
(naive/experienced) and eligibility for interferon. Peg-interferon alpha with ribavirin
was set as a comparator for those who were eligible for interferon. No treatment
was selected for those who were not eligible for interferon. Probability of SVR was
derived from clinical trials conducted in Japan. Other transition probabilities and
utility scores of each health state were obtained from published data in Japan.
Cost data for interferon-alpha and ribavirin were derived from national drug tariff
(2014). For sofosbuvir, average European price was adopted since it was not yet
approved in Japan. Other cost data, such as costs related to health states, were
mainly obtained from claim data, provided by JMDC (Japan Medical Data Center).
Inc. Time-horizon was set to lifetime. Costs and outcomes were discounted with 2%
per annum, according to Japanese guideline. Results: For interferon-unsuitable
patients, sofosbuvir was dominant to no-treatment. Sofosbuvir would save overall
costs for JPY990,000 (USD9,900, JPY100= USD1) and prolonged 6.20QALY for treatment naive patients. It would save JPY 837,000 and prolonged 6.08QALY for treatment experienced group, For interferon-suitable patients, sofosbuvir would increase
overall costs for JPY3,270,000 and prolonged 2.23QALY for treatment-naives. It would
increase JPY1,551,000 and prolonged 2.36QALY for treatment-experienced. ICER
were JPY1,470,000 and JPY657,000 per QALY gained, respectively. Conclusions:
Sofosbuvir was considered to be cost-effective for treatment of genotype-2 HCV
patients in Japan.
PGI31
Cost-Utility Analysis Of Fidaxomicin Compared To Vancomycin In
The Management Of Severe Clostridium Difficile Infection In Poland
Petryszyn P , Well A
Wroclaw University of Medicine, Wroclaw, Poland
.
.
Objectives: In recent years a number of infections caused by Clostridium difficile
has been significantly increasing. In Poland oral metronidazole constitutes the therapy of choice of non-severe infection and first-recurrence, while oral vancomycin
is recommended to be given in case of severe disease and subsequent recurrences.
Fidaxomicin is a novel treatment for Clostridium difficile infections (CDI). The aim
of this study was to perform a cost-utility analysis of fidaxomicin for the treatment
of severe CDI compared to vancomycin. Methods: A meta-analysis of two randomized clinical trials phase III comparing oral fidaxomicin and oral vancomycin
in CDI was conducted. A Markov model was used to determine the cost-utility of
fidaxomicin in patients with severe CDI. The cycle length was 10 days and the time
horizon was 1 year. The patient entered the model in the severe CDI health state
and was given either fidaxomycin or vancomycin for 10 days. The analysis was
performed from the third-party payer perspective – the Polish National Health Fund.
Only direct health care costs (drug costs, hospitalization) were included. Given the
lack of formal utility measures for CDI, the utilities for the alternative health states
described in the literature were adapted. Results: In the base case, fidaxomicin
was dominant compared to vancomycin, resulting in cost savings of PLN 905 and
an incremental QALY gain of 0.015. Fidaxomicin was associated with higher cost
savings (PLN 30,883) assuming that patients with severe CDI would be hospitalized at intensive care unit. One-way sensitivity analyses revealed that fidaxomicin
remained dominant even if considering marginal values of both antibiotics’ acquisition cost. Conclusions: Fidaxomicin was dominant compared to vancomycin,
generating additional QALYs with cost-savings in severe CDI patients in Poland.
PGI32
Economic Evaluation Studies In Gastroenterology In Brazil:
A Systematic Review
Haddad L 1, Decimoni T 2, Turri A 1, Leandro R 2, Soarez P 2
Paulo University, Sao Paulo, Brazil, 2Sao Paulo University, São Paulo, Brazil
.
.
.
.
.
1Sao
Objectives: The aim of this study was to systematically review the economic
assessment studies carried out in Brazil, published between January 1980 and
December 2013, assessing the technologies studied, study types, the and temporal evolution and quality. Methods: We systematically searched in MEDLINE
(PubMed), EMBASE, LILACS, SciELO, NHS EED, HTA Database (CRD), BVS ECOS,
SCOPUS, Web of Science, and SISREBRATS. We selected partial and full economic
evaluation studies in gastroenterology, where at least one of the authors was affiliated to a Brazilian institution. Two authors performed study selection and data
extraction independently. Disagreements were resolved through discussion or
through consultation with a third reviewer. The study characteristics were summarized in figures and summary tables. Results: Forty studies were included. The
first studies were published in the 80s, but most occurred after 2000, with greater
frequency in the last 4 years. Seventeen economic evaluations were incomplete
(42.5%) and 23 complete (57.5%). In the 23 complete reviews, 11 (47.8%) studies
were cost-utility analysis, 7 (30.4%) were cost-effectiveness analysis, 4 (17.4%) costconsequence analysis, and 1 (4.3%) cost-minimization analysis. The type of technology evaluated was mainly medications in 25 studies (62.5%), 7 (17.5%) medical and
surgical procedures, 3 (7.5%) medical and hospital equipment, 1 (2.5%) vaccines and
4 (10%) evaluated more than one type of technology. When classified by disease, 22
(55%) were studies on viral hepatitis, and in its most published after the year 2010
(63.4%). Five studies were related to digestive cancers and other included peptic
diseases, hernias and other. Conclusions: There was a considerable increase in
publications of economic evaluations in Gastroenterology in Brazil, being mostly
studies of drugs for treatment of viral hepatitis. The high cost of these treatments
and increased of lawsuits seem to account for this increase.
PGI33
Estimating The Cost Of Liver Transplantation In Patients Diagnosed
With Chronic Hepatitis C And B In The Uk
Singh J , Longworth L
Brunel University, Uxbridge, UK
.
.
Objectives: Liver transplantation is an effective treatment option for end-stage
liver disease and acute liver failure, including patients with hepatitis C (HCV) and
hepatitis B (HBV). Recent health technology assessments of treatments for HCV
and HBV have relied on data from a large cohort study of transplanted patients to
inform estimates of costs of liver tranplantations; however this was conducted in
the 1990s. The overall aim of this study was to estimate the current cost of liver
transplant for patients with HCV and HBV in the UK. Methods: Historical summary data from the original cohort study were updated to reflect current unit costs
and key changes in clinical practice. Semi-structured interviews were conducted
with experts and a computer-based user-interface was developed to elicit estimates
of key resource use items. Uncertainty in the experts’ estimates was captured by
eliciting probability distributions for each item from each expert. Updated unit costs
were obtained from national sources. Data were analysed by phase of the transplant
procedure. Results: The expert elicitation exercise included two hepatologists,
three transplant surgeons and one liver transplant coordinator. Few patients with
HBV are now being transplanted due to improvements in anti-viral treatments.
Mean total costs for patients with HCV were £18,055 pre-transplantation, £64,452
during the transplant phase and £36,009 in two years post-transplant. The average
cost per transplanted patient with HCV from assessment to two years post-transplant is £111,810. Conclusions: There have been some significant changes in
clinical practice since the original study such as change in standard immunosuppressant therapy, more patients with co-morbidities being placed on the transplant
waiting list, increased use of sub-optimal organs and reluctance to re-transplant
patients with graft failure and recurrence of HCV.
Gastrointestinal Disorders – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient
Preference Studies
PGI34
Adherence Rates For Peginterferon + Ribavirin Compared With
Telaprevir + Peginterferon + Ribavirin In Medicaid And Commercial
Patients Treated For Chronic Hepatitis C
Samp J C , Walker D , Manthena S , Juday T
AbbVie, North Chicago, IL, USA
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Prior to approval of telaprevir (TPV), the treatment for chronic hepatitis
C virus (HCV) included peginterferon (P) weekly injections and ribavirin (R) orally
twice daily. In 2011, TPV was approved for coadministration with P+R during the
first 12 weeks. Though TPV improved viral clearance, it also increased the treatment complexity by 2 pills given 3 times a day. The impact of increased regimen
complexity on adherence is not well understood. This study compared treatment
adherence over 24 weeks in HCV patients treated with TPV+PR compared to those
on PR. Methods: Large US commercial and Medicaid health insurance claims
databases were used to identify HCV patients initiating treatment with PR (pre-TPV
[2007 to 2009]) or TPV+PR (post-TPV [2011 to 2013]). The index date was the date of
HCV treatment initiation. Adherence was measured by medication possession ratio
for all patients at 4 week intervals thru 24 weeks. Regression analyses adjusted for
age, sex, comorbidities, liver disease severity, and pill count prior to HCV treatment. Results: The study included 7,601 and 1,487 treated HCV patients in the
commercial and Medicaid databases. Unadjusted and adjusted adherence was high
for both cohorts throughout the study period (> 88% for Medicaid and > 82% for the
commercial at 24 weeks). Adherence was not significantly different between the
PR and T+PR cohorts at any time point in the Medicaid patients (88.9% [TPV+PR]
and 90.5% [PR] at 24 weeks). Adherence was also similar between the cohorts in the
commercial patients (82.7% [TPV+PR] and 83.2% [PR] at 24 weeks) but was statistically different at weeks 8 and 12, though not clinically meaningful. Age was the
only factor consistently associated with adherence. Conclusions: Among HCV
patients, adherence rates were high and were similar between the cohorts, despite
the higher daily pill count for patients on TPV+PR.
PGI35
Quality Of Life Of Diarrheal Children And Caregivers In Thailand
Rochanathimoke O 1, Postma M 2, Thavorncharoensap M 1, Riewpaiboon A 1,
Thinyounyong W 3
1Faculty of Pharmacy, Mahidol University, Bangkok, Thailand, 2Unit of PharmacoEpidemiology
& PharmacoEconomics (PE2), Department of Pharmacy, University of Groningen, Groningen, The
Netherlands, 3Phetchabun Provincial Public Health Office, Phetchbun, Thailand
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate the utility scores for diarrheal children aged under 5
years and their caregivers and to identify the influencing factors which affected
on these. Methods: Hospitalized diarrheal children aged between 2 months and
5 years and their caregivers at were recruited in this cross-sectional study at three
hospitals in Phetchabun province. The EQ-5D instrument was used to collect the
quality of life (QoL) data at the first date of admission. Quality of life of diarrheal
children was measured as proxy report from caregiver while QoL of caregiver was
measured as self-report. The raw data was converted to utility values using the Thai
algorithm. The clinical severity of diarrheal children was rated using the Vesikari
clinical severity scoring system. Stepwise multivariate linear regression was applied
to explore the impact of the various factors on the utility value of children and
A369
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
caregivers. Results: 468 children and caregivers were included in this study. Mean
children’s age was 1.77 years. The caregivers rated the mean child’s utility and
themselves as 0.604 (95%CI: 0.592, 0.615) and 0.618 (95%CI: 0.606, 0.629), respectively.
Mainly domains of diarrheal children were affected as pain/discomfort and anxiety/
depression similarly to their caregivers. On multivariate regression analysis, factors
which affected the children’s utility significantly were Vesikari score, child’s age and
child’s gender. Next, reduced QoL of their caregivers related to caregiver’s gender and
Vesikari score. Conclusions: Diarrhea had an impact on quality of life of children
and their caregivers. It appeared that QoL of children with diarrhea was impacted
worse in girls, those with high severity score and was associated with age. In addition, the diarrheal severity and female gender reduced the impact of diarrhea on
QoL of caregivers. These results can be useful to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of
vaccines against diarrhea such as rotavirus vaccines.
PGI36
How Does Non-Malignant Opioid Induced Constipation (Oic) Impact
Health State Utility?
Lawson R 1, Marsh K 2, Altincatal A 3, King F 4
1AstraZeneca, Cheshire, UK, 2Evidera, London, UK, 3Evidera, Lexington, MA, USA, 4AstraZeneca,
Gaithersberg, MD, USA
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Little is known about the impact of OIC and treatments for OIC on
health state utility. Studies often focus on collecting data on changes in OIC status.
The objective of this paper is to examine if the utility impact of treatment is driven
by change in OIC status, and what the magnitude of the change in utility associated with changes in OIC status is. Methods: 1352 patients with non-malignant
OIC were allocated to one of two, phase III, 12 week randomised controlled trials
to study naloxegol. These trials were pooled and prospective analyses on these
data were undertaken. Both trials collected the three level EQ-5D at baseline,
week 4 and week 12. EQ-5D scores were converted into estimates of utility using a
tariff generated based on UK general population preferences. A repeated measure
mixed model (RMMM) regression analysis was conducted to identify the impact
of the following factors on utility: age, gender, race, BMI, duration of opioid use,
treatment (naloxegol 12.5mg, 25mg or placebo), baseline utility and OIC status (OIC
or non-OIC). Results: Baseline utility across all patients was 0.559. The regression demonstrated that baseline utility score (β = -0.532, SE= 0.023) and OIC status
(β = 0.032, SE= 0.012) were the only significant predictors of change in utility score
(p< 0.0001and p= 0.008 respectively). Further univariate analyses examined the
effect of OIC status in patient subgroups that had different experiences of laxative
treatment. OIC status had an increased and meaningful impact on patients who
had previously responded inadequately to laxatives. Conclusions: OIC status
is a significant factor on the impact of treatment on patient’s utility. Furthermore
the impact of OIC status is increased in patients who had previously responded
inadequately to laxatives.
PGI37
Mapping May Cause Straining: The Inconsistent Relationship
Between A Disease- Specific Questionnaire (Pac-Qol) And Eq-5d
Mapping In Constipation
Vegter S 1, Hatswell A J 2
1Vegter Health Economic Research, Amersfoort, The Netherlands, 2BresMed, Sheffield, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: A recent double-blind, placebo-controlled clinical study with lubiprostone in opioid-induced constipation (OIC), OBD-1033, included the EQ-5D generic
quality-of-life instrument, and the PAC-QOL, a constipation-specific disease measure. This study calculated utility values for patients with OIC using the direct EQ-5D
responses, and compared the resulting utilities to those calculated from a published
mapping formula between the PAC-QOL and EQ-5D that was derived in chronic idiopathic constipation. Methods: EQ-5D responses from OBD-1033 were converted
to utilities using the EQ-5D UK value set. These were compared with utilities generated with the published mapping algorithm. Following this step, an attempt was
made to map the PAC-QOL to the EQ-5D in OIC. The root mean squared error (RMSE),
adjusted R2, and predicted/observed plots were used to assess the quality of mappings. Results: Patients in OBD-1033 had low utility values at baseline: mean= 0.45
(Standard Deviation 0.33, n=439). Using the published algorithm, the predicted mean
utility was much higher: 0.74. This led to a high RMSE (0.43), indicating a poor fit
to the data. Replicating the mapping using OBD-1033 PAC-QOL and EQ-5D data
showed the PAC-QOL, although correlated with the EQ-5D, had a poor predictive
value (RMSE= 0.31; R2< 0.10). High utilities were underestimated and low utilities
overestimated. Conclusions: Mapping algorithms are a vital tool for generating
utility values when none are available. However, the relationship derived between
instruments should be assessed cautiously. Mappings with the same instruments
may not be reliable if crossing disease areas – even if the symptoms experienced
by patients appear similar. Data show patients in OBD-1033 entered the study with
poorer health status than those in the chronic constipation mapping (utility of
0.45 vs 0.81), likely due to comorbid conditions (the reason for opioid prescribing).
This led to a different relationship between the PAC-QOL and EQ-5D, compared to
the previous estimate.
PGI38
A Comparison Between The Health-Related Quality Of Life Reported
By The General Population And By Patients With Major Liver
Diseases
Cortesi P A 1, Rota M 1, Scalone L 1, Cozzolino P 2, Cesana G 1, Mantovani L 3, Okolicsanyi S 1,
Ciaccio A 1, Gemma M 1, Fagiuoli S 4, Valsecchi M G 1, Belli L S 5, Strazzabosco M 1
1University of Milano - Bicocca, Monza, Italy, 2CHARTA Foundation, Milano, Italy, 3Federico II
University of Naples, Naples, Italy, 4Papa Giovanni XXIII Hospital, Bergamo, Italy, 5Niguarda
Hospital, Milan, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: the impact of liver diseases (LDs) on health-related quality of life
(HRQoL) is an important aspect to understand the burden of these conditions
and improve their management. A well characterized impact of the major LDs
on HRQoL of the general population is still lacking. The aim of our study was to
fill this GAP. Methods: a dataset with HRQoL data of a representative sample
of the general population of most populated Italian region was matched with the
dataset from a multicenter study conducted in the same region and time period
to generate and validate a set of health care outcomes indicators for the major
LDs (hepatitis B (HBV), hepatitis C (HCV), compensated cirrhosis (CC), decompensated cirrhosis (DC), hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC), autoimmune hepatitis
(AIH), primary biliary cirrhosis (PBC), primary sclerosing cholangitis (PSC), NAFLD/
NASH and patients listed for liver transplant (LTL)). Within both datasets, HRQoL
data were collected using the EQ-5D-3L. Multivariate logistic and Tobit regressions were then performed adjusting for possible confounders (age, sex, education
and working status). Results: a total of 6,800 “healthy subjects” and 3,105 subjects with LDs were included in the analyses. Multivariate logistic analyses showed
that DC, HCC, and LTL had significantly (p< 0.05) higher risk to have problems in
mobility, self-care, and usual activities compared to “healthy subjects”. AIH had
significantly higher risk to have problems in self-care; while HCV, CC, DC, and
NAFLD/NASH in Anxiety/depression. Similar results were obtained with the Tobit
model performed using VAS and Utility-index. DC, HCC, AIH and LTL reported
the highest decrease in VAS and Utility score. Conclusions: HRQoL decreased
in advanced LDs (DC, HCC, LTL) and AIH. This study provides an actual true estimate of the impact of major LDs on the patients’ HRQoL compare to the general
population, and therefore is a key tool for decision-making in care delivery for
liver diseases.
PGI39
Translation And Cultural Adaptation Difficulties Encountered
During Linguistic Validation Of The Bristol Stool Scale
Edwards A , Williams H , Anderson H
ICON plc, Oxford, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: The aims of this study were: (1) to investigate translation difficulties
encountered during linguistic validation of the Bristol Stool Scale; (2) to discover
whether certain items consistently posed problems across different languages;
and (3) to analyse how solutions were reached and what types of solutions were
appropriate. Methods: The investigation was made up of the following stages:
(1) collation of back translation reviews of the Bristol Stool Scale for 30 European
and Asia-Pacific languages; (2) identification of problematic words and phrases,
based on written discussion between lead translators and project managers; (3)
investigation of patterns that became apparent across different languages; (4)
review of methods used to overcome the translation difficulties. Results: For
more than a third of the languages reviewed (2 European and 9 Asia-Pacific, including 7 Indian), difficulties were experienced when attempting to translate certain
items word-for-word. The majority of these difficulties centred on the food-related
similes used in the scale to describe the different stool types. In all of the Indian
languages in this study, alternative food-related similes were deemed necessary
(e. g. ‘banana’ replacing ‘sausage’) in order to ensure that the wording was culturally relevant. Of the other languages, Thai and Romanian preferred similes that
did not relate to food (‘bullets’ and ‘beads/little round bits’ respectively, instead of
‘nuts’), while for Singapore Chinese and Polish it was decided to remove certain
similes altogether (‘like nuts’/‘like a sausage’). Conclusions: Certain items in
the Bristol Stool Scale, in particular the two food-related similes, cause translation difficulties for some languages. For such items, it may not be appropriate to
produce a word-for-word translation. In these cases, alternative solutions must
be sought, taking into account cultural considerations, in order to achieve conceptual equivalence.
PGI40
Self-Reported Health Related Quality Of Life Of Hepatitis C Virus
(Hcv) Genotype 1 Patients With And Without Comorbid Conditions
Nwankwo C 1, Sung A H 2, Pike J 3
Station, NJ, USA, 2St. John’s University, Queens, NY, USA, 3Adelphi Real
World, Macclesfield, UK
.
.
.
.
1Merck, Whitehouse
Objectives: To describe and compare self-reported health-related quality of
life (HRQL) in HCV Genotype-1 infected patients with and without comorbid
conditions (e. g. depression, hypertension, obesity, arthritis, anemia and diabetes). Methods: A Cross-sectional survey of physicians and their consulting
patients was conducted from October 2012 to January 2013 as part of the Adelphi
Real World Hepatitis C Disease Specific Programme. Overall, 348 patients from USA
and France (231 with comorbidities and 117 without comorbidities) completed an
EQ5D-3L and/or a Multidimensional-Assessment-of-Fatigue (MAF) scale. HRQL was
evaluated by estimating EQ5D health-state-index (EQ5D-HSI), Visual-AnalogueScale (EQ5D-VAS) score, Domain-dimension score and MAF Global-Fatigue-Index
(MAF-GFI). Further analysis compared HRQL reported by patients with comorbidities who completed treatment for HCV and were cured versus those who were
not cured. Results: HRQL reported by untreated patients were better for those
without comorbidities than those with comorbidities. For three of the five EQ5D
domains, more patients without comorbidities versus patients with comorbidities
reported no problems performing usual activities (85% versus 49%, p< 0.001), no
pain or discomfort (70% versus 33%, p< 0.001) and not being anxious/depressed
(67% versus 37%, p= 0.004). The corresponding mean HQRL estimates were EQ5DHSI 0.89 vs 0.77, p= 0.001; EQ5D-VAS 79 vs. 69, p= 0.014 and MAF-GFI 11 vs. 19,
p= 0.016 for patients without comorbidities versus those with comorbidities.
Among treated patients with comorbidities, those cured had significantly higher
HRQL than those not cured (EQ5D-HSI 0.84 versus 0.67, p= 0.008, EQ5D-VAS 74
vs. 57, p= 0.003 and MAF-GFI 18 versus 32, p< 0.001). Conclusions: The results
from this study suggest that patients with comorbidities have a poorer HRQL than
patients without comorbidities, and that the treatment and cure of HCV in these
patients is associated with higher HRQL compared with treatment and no cure.
This implies that treatment and subsequent cure of HCV genotype 1 patients with
comorbidities may help improve their HRQL.
A370
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PGI41
Should Cost-Effectiveness Analysis Include The Cost Of
Consumption Activities? An Empirical Investigation
Adarkwah C C 1, Sadoghi A 2, Gandjour A 2
University, Maastricht, The Netherlands, 2Frankfurt School of Finance & Management,
Frankfurt, Germany
.
.
.
.
1Maastricht
Objectives: There has been a debate on whether cost-effectiveness analysis
should consider the cost of consumption and leisure time activities when using
the quality-adjusted life year as a measure of health outcome under a societal
perspective. The purpose of this study was to investigate whether the effects of ill
health on consumptive activities are spontaneously considered in a health state
valuation exercise and how much this matters. Methods: The survey enrolled
patients with inflammatory bowel disease in Germany (n = 104). Patients were
randomized to explicit and no explicit instruction for the consideration of consumption and leisure effects in a time trade-off (TTO) exercise. Results: Explicit
instruction to consider non-health-related utility in TTO exercises did not influence
TTO scores. However, spontaneous consideration of non-health-related utility in
patients without explicit instruction (60% of respondents) led to significantly lower
TTO scores. Conclusions: Results suggest an inclusion of consumption costs
in the numerator of the cost-effectiveness ratio, at least for those respondents
who spontaneously consider non-health-related utility from treatment. Given the
importance of this question for the conduct of cost-effectiveness analysis in health
care, confirmation in additional studies that are conducted outside Germany and
consider other health-state valuation techniques and diseases is recommended.
PGI42
Impact Of Irritable Bowel Syndrome With Constipation On Work
Productivity And Daily Activity Among Commercially Insured
Patients In The United States
Stephenson J J 1, Buono J L 2, Spalding W M 3, Cai Q 1, Tan H 1, Carson R T 2, Doshi J A 4
1HealthCore Inc, Wilmington, DE, USA, 2Forest Research Institute, Jersey City, NJ, USA, 3Ironwood
Pharmaceuticals, Cambridge, MA, USA, 4University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess work productivity and daily activity impairment among
irritable bowel syndrome with constipation (IBS-C) patients in the United
States. Methods: IBS-C patients aged ≥ 18 years with continuous medical and
pharmacy benefit eligibility (03/01/2011–02/28/2013) were identified from claims
in the HealthCore Integrated Research Database and invited to complete a crosssectional patient survey. Survey questions based on modified Rome III criteria
confirmed IBS-C claims-based diagnoses. Patients who met both claims-based
and Rome criteria completed the full survey, including the Work Productivity and
Activity Impairment Questionnaire: General Health (WPAI: GH), which assessed the
impact of general health problems on patients’ ability to work and function. WPAI:
GH scores for absenteeism (work hours missed), presenteeism (lost productivity at
work), and overall work productivity loss (absenteeism + presenteeism) over the
previous week were calculated for employed respondents; daily activity impairment
(functional impairment) was computed for all respondents. Follow-up questions
adapted from the WPAI: GH evaluated work and activity impairment due to IBS-C.
Scores are expressed as percentages, with higher percentages indicating greater
impairment and less productivity. Indirect costs were calculated based on overall
work productivity loss due to IBS-C using the human capital method. Results:
Of 53 respondents (mean age: 40±15 years; 84.9% female), 35 were employed.
Absenteeism averaged 10.6%, presenteeism averaged 37.4%, overall work productivity loss averaged 39.3%, and daily activity impairment averaged 45.7% due to
general health problems over the past week. Of this, 7.5%, 21.5%, 23.8%, and 14.2%
was attributed to IBS-C, respectively. The economic cost due to lost productivity attributable to IBS-C was estimated at $155±$321 USD per employed patient/
week. Conclusions: IBS-C–related impairment at work and in daily activities
represents a significant burden for patients and employers. Treatments that effectively manage IBS-C symptoms may represent cost savings in the form of avoided
work productivity losses associated with IBS-C.
Gastrointestinal Disorders – Health Care Use & Policy Studies
PGI43
Utilization Of Total Parenteral Nutrition In A South Indian
Tertiary Care Hospital
Sreedharan N 1, Vinitha M 1, John P 1, Girish T 1, Vijayanarayana K 1, Gabriel R 2
1Manipal University, Manipal, India, 2New Medical Center Specality Hospital, Madinat Zayed,
United Arab Emirates
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Total Parenteral Nutrition (TPN) is an essential pharmaceutical preparation used in hospitalized patients to whom enteral feeding is not possible or
for critical care patients with compromised gastrointestinal tract function. Use of
TPN reduce the incidence of malnutrition, which is a leading complication associated with various medical and surgical conditions. Hence the purpose of the study
is to assess TPN utilization in surgical in-patients and its outcomes. Methods:
Retrospective analysis of surgical in-patients receiving TPN from Jan 2011 to Dec
2012 in a tertiary care hospital was carried out. Patients who were administered
TPN were included in the study. Patient characteristics and treatment details were
collected. Data were analyzed using SPSS ® version 20.0. Results: A total of 120
patients were enrolled in the study. The mean age of patients taking TPN was
48.9±17.7 years. Majority of patients (67.5%) were males. A large proportion (40.8%)
of the patients receiving TPN were those w underwent surgical procedures and
had intestinal obstruction. Major metabolic complication included hypernatremia
(26.5%) followed by hyperglycemia. Higher (79.5%) recovery rate was observed in
patients who received TPN peripherally compared to those who received it via a
central line. Among the patients receiving TNP, mortality was higher in patients
with infections (31.9%) than without infection. In 93.3% of the cases, TPN starts
were considered to be appropriate indications and rest inappropriate. From an eco-
nomical standpoint, the total avoidable cost with TPN mounted to 2,48,200 Indian
Rupees. Conclusions: Proper use of TPN reduced mortality in post-surgical
patients. Greater attention to nutritional assessment to determine calorific need
and nutritional requirement for individual patients should further improve benefits,
reduce mortality and save treatment costs in hospitalized patients.
PGI44
A Health Technology-Related Cost Description Concerning Italian
Ibd Centres Dealing With Crohn’s Disease: Results From Sole Study
Lazzaro C 1, Cappello M 2, Cortelezzi C 3, Costantino G 4, Fiorino G 5, Mastronardi M 6,
Giannotta M 7, Galletti B 8, Cicala M 9, Vadalà di Prampero S 10, Gualberti G 11, Caprioli F 12,
Gasbarrini A 13, Fattore G 14
1Studio di Economia Sanitaria, Milan, Italy, 2Università di Palermo, Palermo, Italy, 3AOU di
Circolo - Fondazione Macchi, Varese, Italy, 4Università di Messina, Messina, Italy, 5Istituto Clinico
Humanitas, Rozzano (MI), Italy, 6IRCCS S. De Bellis, Castellana Grotte, Italy, 7Azienda Ospedaliero
Universitaria di Careggi, Firenze, Italy, 8Ospedale S. Salvatore, L’Aquila, Italy, 9Università Campus
Bio Medico, Roma, Italy, 10Azienda Ospedaliero-Universitaria S. Maria della Misericordia di
Udine, Udine, Italy, 11AbbVie, Campoverde di Aprilia (LT), Italy, 12Università degli Studi di Milano,
Milano, Italy, 13Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Rome, Italy, 14Bocconi University, Milan, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To investigate the health technology-related costs of Italian inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) centers dealing with Crohn’s disease (CD). Methods:
Following the hospital standpoint, a questionnaire-supported cost description
was performed on a convenience sample of 38 Italian IBD centers participating
in the ongoing Survey on Quality Of Life in Crohn’s Patients (SOLE). Consistently with
their average useful life, a 5-year straight-line depreciation approach was adopted
for calculating the yearly cost for each health technology. Cost description was
undertaken either considering all centers as an undifferentiated sample, or stratifying them according to their complexity (number of beds for inward and dayhospital; personnel dedicated to CD patients; number of cross-border CD patients;
availability of dedicated rooms for biological drugs administration; feasibility of
electronic patient forms). Costs (€ 2012) were reported as mean (standard deviation, SD). Results: Half of centers (19/38) were public teaching hospitals, whereas
39.5% were regional referral centers for CD (15/38). The study sites were located in
Northern (12/38, 31.6%), Central (11/38, 28.9%) and Southern (15/38, 39.5%) Italy, and
could be classified as high (32/38, 84.2%), moderate (1/38), mild (3/38), and low (2/38)
complexity centers. Endoscopy, capsule endoscopy and ultrasonography were the
most widespread health technologies available in 92.1%, 78.9% and 34.2% centers,
respectively. Considering the undifferentiated sample, mean yearly cost for health
technologies amounts to € 23,557.50 (€ 24,277.90). High complexity centers report the
highest mean yearly cost of € 25,580.38 (€ 25,706.92), whereas the lowest mean yearly
cost of € 5,113 (€ 0) refers to the unique moderate complexity center. Regardless of
site complexity, the cost-driver was endoscopy, which accounts for a percentage
of the mean yearly cost that ranges from 36.9% (high complexity) to 97.8% (moderate complexity). Conclusions: SOLE results show that when Italian IBD centers
complexity is taken into account, remarkable differences exist about costs for health
technologies for managing CD patients.
PGI45
Diagnosis And Management Of Moderate-To-Severe Irritable Bowel
Syndrome With Constipation (Ibs-C) In Spain: The Ibis-C Study
Mearin F 1, Cortes X 2, Mackinnon J 3, Bertsch J 3, Fortea J 2, Tack J 4
médico Teknon, Barcelona, Spain, 2Laboratorios Almirall S.A., Barcelona, Spain, 3TFS
Develop S.L., Barcelona, Spain, 4University of Leuven, Leuven, Belgium
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Centro
Objectives: The IBIS-C study assessed the burden of IBS-C in 6 European countries
(France, Germany, Italy, Spain, Sweden, and UK). Here we present the diagnosis and
management results for the Spanish cohort. Methods: Observational, retrospective-prospective (6 months each) study in patients diagnosed with moderate-tosevere IBS-C in the last five years (Rome-III criteria). Moderate-to-severe IBS-C was
defined as an IBS-Symptom Severity Score (IBS-SSS) ≥ 175. Results: 112 patients
were included (58% severe, mean age [±SD] 46.8 ± 13.7 years, 86% female). Mean time
since diagnosis: 2.3 ± 2.7 years; mean symptom duration: 9.6 ± 9.9 years. Diagnostic
procedures were highly variable; the most common were blood tests (71%), colonoscopy (56%) and abdominal ultrasound (54%). At inclusion the most prevalent
symptoms were constipation (84%), abdominal pain (80%), abdominal distention
(80%) and bloating (59%). Main ongoing comorbidities were dyspepsia (41%), anxiety
(38%), depression (21%), headache (25%), or insomnia (25%). 58% of patients had an
average of 4.1 ± 2.5 diagnostic tests during follow-up. 85% of patients took pharmacological medication (80% took some pharmacological medication for their IBS-C).
The most common prescription drugs were plantago ovata (35%), otilonium bromide
(22%), macrogol plus electrolites (13%) and cinitapride tartrate (10%). Likewise, common drug combinations were laxative monotherapy (21%), laxatives and antispasmodics (14%), and antispasmodic monotherapy (5%). In addition, 30% of patients
received complementary therapies. Overall, marginal improvement was noted in
symptom severity (IBS-SSS total score) between baseline (315±83) and the 6-month
visit (234±98). Conclusions: Moderate-to-severe IBS-C symptoms often remain
undiagnosed for many years. With frequent visits to health care professionals IBS-C
continues to be a burden despite the availability of therapeutic interventions. Finally,
current health care resource utilization is high even though there is a high degree
of prescription medication use.
PGI46
Real World Studies Using Japanese Administrative Databases:
Chronic Hepatitis C Treatment Pattern And Resource Use
Crawford B 1, Tang A 2, Li H 3, Burns L 4, Wada K 1, McDonald J 5
KK, Tokyo, Japan, 3Bristol Myers Squibb,
Wallingford, CT, USA, 4Bristol-Myers Squibb, Hopewell, NJ, USA, 5Adelphi Values, Boston,
MA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Adelphi Values, Tokyo, Japan, 2Bristol-Myers
Objectives: While discussions on health technology assessment (HTA) in Japan
continue, platforms for real-world population-based studies are lacking. We attempt
A371
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
to compare two large commercial databases focusing on CHC patient characteristics
and treatment patterns. Methods: We analyzed the Japan Medical Data Center
(JMDC) database containing employer-based health insurance claims and the
Medical Data Vision (MDV) database containing administrative data from acute care
hospitals. Patients aged 20 years or above and diagnosed with CHC were included in
the study. Patients co-infected with hepatitis B and/or human immunodeficiency
viruses were excluded. Patient characteristics and treatment patterns for CHC were
compared. Results: 3,590 (JMDC) and 29,702 (MDV) confirmed CHC patients were
included in the analysis. Patients in JMDC were younger than those in MDV (age
51.6±11.9 and 63.2±13.4) and had fewer comorbidities (Charlson Comorbidity Index
1.3±1.7 and 1.9±2.1). More patients in JMDC were found to have prior CHC treatment
(37.2%) than in MDV (24.6%). With an index date of September 2011, about a third of
the patients (n=1,271, 35.4%; JMDC and n=9,791, 33.0%; MDV) received treatments for
CHC, comprised of 10.2% (n= 365; JMDC) and 5.5% (n= 1,620; MDV) on antiviral treatments (interferon or direct acting antiviral combinations) and 25.2% (n= 906; JMDC)
and 27.5% (n= 8,171; MDV) on liver protection drugs only. Among patients treated
with triple therapy (telapravir/peginterferon/ribavirin), the mean total treatment
duration was 19.3 weeks (JMDC) versus 21.9 weeks (MDV). The mean duration of telaprevir therapy was 10.8 weeks (JMDC) and 10.1 weeks (MDV), followed by 11.7 weeks
(JMDC) and 14.1 weeks (MDV) of peginterferon/ribavirin therapy. Conclusions:
Both databases found low treatment rates for CHC. Although the findings are consistent, there are differences in database populations and treatment patterns that
warrant further research. Using these administrative databases for real-world
research may be useful depending on research objectives.
PGI47
Cohort Of Hcv Patients In Italy: Sizing And Treatments In A Sample
Of Italian Hepatology Centers
Lanati E P 1, Lidonnici D 1, Gasbarrini A 2, Ruggeri M 3, Sacchini D 3, Caporaso N 4, Fagiuoli S 5
Provider, Milano, Italy, 2Policlinico Gemelli, Rome, Italy, 3Università Cattolica del Sacro
Cuore, Rome, Italy, 4Universita’ di Napoli Federico II, Napoli, Italy, 5Papa Giovanni XXIII Hospital,
Bergamo, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1MA
Objectives: The aim of this study is to give an overview of the treatment available
for the patients with Hepatitis C Virus (HCV) through the segmentation of HCV
patients in Italy. Methods: The study was carried out in 9 hepatology centers,
treating HCV patients in 9 Italian Regions. The structures selected constitute a
representative sample of the Italian scenario, being Centers of Excellence in HCV
management in northern, southern, and center of Italy (representing about 24%
of the 2.000 patients treated with first generation Triple Therapy in Italy according
to AIFA Data). The patients’ distribution has been investigated in terms of fibrosis
stage (F0 to F4), therapy type (Triple, TT, or Double therapy, DT) and treatment
status (naive or experienced patients). Results: Data (collected from structures
and Workshop of Pharmacoeconomics in Hepatology) show that HCV patients
are more concentrated in the two fibrosis stage extremes: 43% in F0-F1 Range,
23% in F2, 32% in F3-F4 Range and 2% unclassified. Data about drug administration demonstrate that, at national level, patients are equally distributed between
therapy type (56% TT and 44% DT) and treatment status (49% naive and 51% experienced). On the contrary, at Regional level many differences were found in all of
the three parameters examined. In the structure investigated in Campania, for
example, 72% of patients receive TT and 76% are experienced, while in Lazio 72%
of patients receive DT and 72% are naive. Furthermore, considering the fibrosis
stage, the 46% of patients treated in a center operating in Bari is in the range
F3-F4, whilst in the center in Milan the 56% of the HCV patients treated is in range
F0-F1. Conclusions: The study demonstrate that, concerning the treatment of
HCV, there are significant differences among the hepatology centers, both in terms
of patients’ health status and therapy pathways.
PGI48
The Costs-Effectiveness Of Sofosbuvir VersUS Standard Of
Care (Soc) In Chronic Hepatitis C From A Belgian Reimbursement
Perspective
De Groote K 1, Delwaide J 2, Michielsen P 3
1INNOSENS bvba, Brakel, Belgium, 2Centre Hospitalier Sart-Tilman, Liège, Belgium, 3UZ Antwerp,
Edegem, Belgium
.
.
.
Objectives: Hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection resulting in chronic liver disease has
an estimated prevalence in Belgium of 0,87% (Beutels, 1997) with 59% of patients
having genotype 1 HCV (GT1), 6% GT2, 19% GT3 and 16% GT4-5-6. Sofosbuvir
(SOF), a novel HCV treatment, has demonstrated high rates of sustained virological
response (SVR) when given with ribavirin to subjects with chronic HCV infections
(all GT’s). The objective of this analysis was to assess the cost-effectiveness of
sofosbuvir vs SoC in the treatment of chronic hepatitis C (CHC) in the following
indications: GT 1 (Treatment Naïve (TN), INF-eligible and IFN-ineligible patients);
GT2 & 3 (TN & Treatment Experienced (TE), both INF-eligible and IFN-ineligible
patients) and GT 4/5/6, treatment-naïve patients in Belgium. Patients ineligible to
IFN have no treatment options today. Methods: Based on a Markov model, this
cost-utility analysis models the cost-effectiveness of SOF versus SoC in Belgium
from the perspective of the RIZIV/INAMI and taking into account the proposed
reimbursement criteria for SOF in Belgium and the guidelines of the Knowledge
Centre (KCE) (KCE report 78C, 2008). Results: Weighted ICER’s were calculated
taking into account patient eligibility for treatment with IFN and treatment
duration with SOF: GT 1, 3, 4, 5 or 6 patients who are IFN-eligible and are being
treated with SOF (+ subcutaneous pegylated interferon-alpha (IFN-α ) plus daily
oral ribavirin (RBV)) for 12 weeks (€ 19,954/QALY); GT 1, 3, 4, 5 or 6 patients who are
IFN-ineligible due to intolerance and/or contra-indications and are being treated
with SOF (+ RBV) for 24 weeks (€ 35,086/QALY) and GT 2 patients that are being
treated with SOF (+ RBV) for 12 weeks (€ 28,121/QALY). Overall, the weighted PANgenotypic ICER was € 21,651. Conclusions: PAN-genotypic cost-effectiveness
has been demonstrated for sofosbuvir in comparison to the current standard of
care in HCV in Belgium.
PGI49
Which Metric To Choose For Indirect Comparison Of Treatments
When Multiple Comparisons Are Feasible: Lubiprostone VersUS
Prucalopride In Chronic Constipation
Hatswell A J 1, Griffiths A 2, Lichtlen P 3, Losch-Beridon T 4, Pennington B 1
Economics, Solihull, UK, 3Sucampo, Zug, Switzerland,
4Sucampo Pharma Americas, Bethesda, MD, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
1BresMed, Sheffield, UK, 2Research
Objectives: For a recent health technology appraisal in the treatment of chronic
idiopathic constipation, direct evidence of the effectiveness of a new intervention
(lubiprostone) against the standard of care (prucalopride) was not available. The
aim of this study was to review the available data from clinical trials and perform
indirect comparisons between the two treatments where possible. Methods: A
literature search (in Medline and other databases) was conducted in December
2013 for trials of lubiprostone or prucalopride. Data for any comparable endpoints
were extracted from the papers, and indirect comparisons performed using the
Bucher method. Results: Four clinical trials for lubiprostone were identified (three
company-sponsored, and a small clinician-led trial), as well as three companysponsored clinical trials for prucalopride. After data extraction, indirect comparisons were possible for seven different endpoints, including the primary efficacy
parameter of the lubiprostone studies (Spontaneous Bowel Movements; the relative
risk was 1.12 in favour of lubiprostone, 95% CI 0.77-1.64). Other endpoints included
the primary efficacy parameter of the prucalopride studies (Spontaneous Complete
Bowel Movements), and a range of symptom comparisons. In total, five of the seven
indirect comparisons favoured lubiprostone, with statistical significance reached
in favour of lubiprostone once and prucalopride once. Conclusions: The indirect
comparisons showed that lubiprostone is likely to be at least as effective as prucalopride, with numerical superiority in five out of seven comparisons. However,
the number of feasible indirect comparisons on a range of endpoints raises a wider
question: which to use in cost-effectiveness modelling? Although analyses generally have a ‘base case’, each of the indirect comparisons adds different information
about the relative efficacy of the two products. Given the range of endpoints with
associated relative risks, to reduce these to a single comparison (as is current practice) may omit important and relevant information about relative efficacy.
PGI50
High Therapeutic Efficiency With Sofosbuvir For The Treatment Of
Chronic Hepatitis C
Félix J 1, Silva M 1, Ferreira D 1, Vandewalle B 1, Guerra I 2, Cure S 2, Aldir I 3, Carvalho A 4,
Macedo G 5, Marinho R T 6, Pedroto I 7, Ramalho F 6
1Exigo Consultores, Alhos Vedros, Portugal, 2OptumInsight, Uxbridge, UK, 3Hospital Egas Moniz,
Centro Hospitalar de Lisboa Ocidental, Lisboa, Portugal, 4Centro Hospitalar e Universitário de
Coimbra, Coimbra, Portugal, 5Hospital de São João, Porto, Portugal, 6Centro Hospitalar Lisboa
Norte. Hospital de Santa Maria, Lisboa, Portugal, 7Centro Hospitalar do Porto, Porto, Portugal
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Chronic hepatitis C (CHC) is a major public health problem contributing
to more than 86,000 premature deaths in Europe. Pegylated interferon-α plus ribavirin
(PR) based therapy, including regimens with boceprevir (BOC) or telaprevir (TVR) in
HCV genotype-1 patients, have failed to provide more extensive therapeutic benefit leaving space for substantial outcomes improvement. Sofosbuvir (SOF) – a pangenotypic RNA polymerase inhibitor – has shown unprecedented sustained virologic
response rates and tolerability profiles. The objective of this study was to estimate SOF
contribution to public health by exhausting CHC therapeutic efficiency. Methods:
Therapeutic efficiency was defined as maximum capacity to benefit from treatment in
terms of life years (LY) relative to the general population’s life expectancy. The natural
history of CHC and treatment implication was modelled with a discrete-time Markov
allowing for long term assessment in terms of HCV genotype, fibrosis progression, HIV
co-infection status and previous treatment experience. Treatment options compared
were dependent on interferon eligibility/tolerance and genotype: PR, SOF/PR, BOC/
PR and TVR/PR in elegible/tolerant patients (BOC/TRV regimens in genotype-1 only;
SOF/ribavirin in genotype-2). For ineligible/intolerant patients, comparison of SOF/
ribavirin was performed against lack-of-therapy. Results: In mono-infected HCV
genotype-1 patients SOF/PR treatment is estimated to result in 4.3 LY, 7.0 LY or 8.0
LY gained in comparison to TRV/PR, BOC/PR or PR, respectively. In genotype-1 and
genotype-2 HIV-coinfected patients elegible for interferon treatment, the estimated
LY gained with SOF treatment is 11.8yrs and 5.0yrs, respectively. In patients ineligible
for interferon treatment, SOF is expected to almost double life expectancy irrespective
of the genotype, with therapeutic efficiency ranging from 79% to 95%. In co-infected
patients, therapeutic efficiency of SOF is expected to range between 84.3% and 92.4%
of general population life expectancy. Conclusions: Sofosbuvir-containing regimens are expected to maximize years of life lived and maximize efficiency relative
CHC patients residual life expectancy.
PGI52
Comparison Of The Burden Of Ibs With Constipation On HealthRelated Quality Of Life (Hrqol), Work Productivity, And Health Care
Utilization To Asthma, Migraine, And Rheumatoid Arthritis In The
Us, Uk, And France
Taylor D C A 1, Kosinski M 2, Reilly K 2, Lindner L 3
Pharmaceuticals, Inc., Cambridge, MA, USA, 2QualityMetric, OptumInsight Life
Sciences, Lincoln, RI, USA, 3Almirall S.A., Barcelona, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Ironwood
Objectives: Studies have shown that irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) and its subtype
with constipation (IBS-C) are associated with poorer HRQoL, decreased work productivity and increased health care utilization. However, no studies have compared the
burden of IBS-C to similar chronic conditions. Objective was to evaluate burden of
IBS-C compared with no functional gastrointestinal disorders (non-FGID), asthma,
migraine, and rheumatoid arthritis (RA), on HRQoL, work productivity and health
care utilization. Methods: Data come from the 2011 National Health and Wellness
Survey (nationally representative sample of adults including the US, UK and France),
which includes health-related topics such as HRQoL (SF-12 Health Survey), work
productivity (Work Productivity and Activity Impairment) and health care utiliza-
A372
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
tion (6-month ER visits and hospitalizations). Comparisons in each of these healthrelated topics were made between respondents with IBS-C versus non-FGID, asthma,
migraine, and RA. Comparisons controlled for age and gender. Results: Prevalence
of IBS-C was 0.67%, 1.03%, and 0.91% in the US, UK, and France, respectively. Most
respondents were female (> 65%) and mean age ranged from 47.7 to 49.8 years. In
each country, mean SF-12 physical (PCS) and mental (MCS) summary scores were
statistically (p< 0.001) and clinically meaningfully (> = 2.5) lower than the non-FGID
group. With few exceptions, PCS and MCS scores of IBS-C were significantly (p< 0.05)
lower than scores for asthma, migraine, and RA. In each country, IBS-C reported
significantly (p< 0.001) greater absenteeism and worse presenteeism and greater
overall work productivity loss and daily activity impairment than non-FGID, and
with few exceptions, worse than asthma, migraine, and RA. Lastly, in each country
the number of ER and hospital visits was significantly higher (p< 0.01) for IBS-C
compared to non-FGID and, with few exceptions, higher than asthma, migraine,
and RA. Conclusions: In the three countries respondents with IBS -C showed
significant and clinically meaningful deficits in HRQoL and work productivity and
elevated health care utilization compared with other chronic conditions.
PGI53
Assesment Of Serial Transverse Enteroplasty: Systematic Review
Yoo K J
NECA, Seoul, South Korea
.
.
Objectives: The purpose of this study was to evalute the safety and effectiveness
of serial transverse enteroplasty (STEP). Methods: The clinical utility of STEP was
first reviewed in three textbooks and secondly the safety and the effectiveness of
the STEP were assessed based on a systematic revew. 575 articles were searched
using database (KoreaMed, Ovid-MEDLINE, Ovid-EMBASE and Cochrane Library, etc.)
and eliminated acoording to inclusion/exclusion criteria, duplicate search results.
Finally, 9 articles (2 cohort studied and 7 case studies) were used. Two evaluators
performed independently throuout each process. The article’s quality evaluated by
the SIGN’s tool and the grade of recommendation were selected. Results: A review
of the textbooks revealed that STEP is conducted on patients with refractory SBS. And
the advantages of STEP are that it is technically straightforward, can form a uniform
bowel channel regardless of variable underlying bowel dilation, and can be repeated
if the bowel subsequently radilated. The safety of STEP was assessed based on procedure-related complications in 6 articles. The complication rate of STEP was overall
6.3~25%, bleeding 6.3~12.5%, obstruction 6.3~22%, anastomosis leak 2.3~16.7% and
stricture 11~20%. The complication rate of the STEP versus the Bianchi LILT was no
significantly difference. The effectiveness of STEP was assessed based on the enteral
autonomy and survival rate in 9 articles. There was a trend toward a decreased rate of
PN after STEP. As a result, the 33~56% patients who underwent STEP were weaned off
within one year and 83~88% after one year. Survival was 83% with maximum followup of 68 months. Conclusions: The safety of STEP was at an acceptable level as
complications reported in studies generally occur after an intestinal operations and
such problems can be corrected surgically. The clinical utility of STEP was described
in the textbooks as a non-transplantation procedure and all the selected articles
was reported on wean-off parenteral nutrition. Therefore, there is evidence for the
safety and effectiveness of STEP performed on patients with refractory short bowel
syndrome for promoting eneteral nutrition (Recommendation grade C).
PGI54
Prescribing Pattern Of Drugs For Ulcerative Colitis In Japan
.
PGI55
Patients Diagnostic Therapeutic Pathways For Hcv Patients In Italy:
Impact Of Regionalization In Treatments And Guidelines
Lanati E P 1, Lidonnici D 1, Gasbarrini A 2, Ruggeri M 3, Sacchini D 3, Caporaso N 4, Fagiuoli S 5
Provider, Milano, Italy, 2Policlinico Gemelli, Rome, Italy, 3Università Cattolica del Sacro
Cuore, Rome, Italy, 4Universita’ di Napoli Federico II, Napoli, Italy, 5Papa Giovanni XXIII Hospital,
Bergamo, Italy
.
Murata T , Hanada K , Shibahara H
CRECON Research & Consulting Inc., Tokyo, Japan
.
.
.
Objectives: This retrospective study aimed to evaluate the actual chronic hepatitis
C (CHC) treatment in Japan including interferon (IFN) treatment using Japanese
claims data provided by Japan Medical Data Center Co., Ltd (JMDC). Methods:
All claims data for 9,634 patients having a history of diagnosis related to CHC,
liver cirrhosis (LC), or hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) among Japanese claims data
from January 2005 to October 2013 provided by JMDC were analyzed in this study.
Treatment patterns and costs were evaluated in CHC patients newly diagnosed during the study period. Results: 3,546 newly diagnosed CHC patients were included
in this analysis. The median follow-up period was 21.0 months. The CHC treatment
including IFN was not implemented in most cases (76.8%) during the follow-up
period. The rate of IFN treatment was 7.0%. The combination therapy of IFN and
ribavirin (RBV) was the most frequently used in IFN treatment. Median period of
first line treatment to the discontinuation was 7.0 months in patients with IFN +
RBV. The mean annual total cost in CHC patients with IFN, CHC patients without
IFN with other drugs (e. g. ursodeoxycholic acid), CLC patients were 3.5 million yen
($35,000), 2.0 million yen ($20,000), 3.1 million yen ($31,000), respectively. The mean
annual number of outpatient visits in patients with IFN + RBV, patients without
IFN with other drugs were 56.7 and 37.5 visits, respectively. Conclusions: The
CHC treatment including IFN was not implemented in most cases despite having
the CHC diagnosis. Furthermore, IFN treatment completion rate are low. One of the
main causes of these facts would be adverse effects associated with IFN treatment.
New drugs with fewer adverse effects are awaited for the future.
.
Objectives: Ulcerative colitis is one of 56 designated diseases for the Specified
Disease Treatment Research Program that provides co-payment reduction or exemption according to disease severity and patients’ income levels. Under the fee-for-service
payment system, such financial assistance program may influence drug utilisation. The objective of this study is to assess the overall drug prescribing pattern for
ulcerative colitis. Methods: Claims data with indication for ulcerative colitis were
extracted from the Social Health Insurance claims data processed from December 2009
to February 2010 and from February to April 2011. Extracted data were analysed and
compared in terms of patients’ age, types of public subsidy, prescribed places (clinic/
hospital or pharmacy) and pharmacologic classes. Results: Total numbers of patients
were 67,480 for the former duration and 84,450 for the latter duration. Among them,
patients who were entitled to the Specified Disease Treatment Research Programme
were 47,103 and 60,231 respectively. The most commonly used drug was mesalazine
which accounted for 56% and 59%. Infliximab was prescribed mainly for those entitled
to the Specified Disease Treatment Research Program. Of total infliximab dose, 23 %
and 30% were with steroid and 33% and 38% were with mesalazine. Generic utilisation rate for patients entitled to the Specified Disease Treatment Research Programme
or other financial assistance programs was low. Conclusions: The highest utilization of infliximab and low generic utilization were observed for patients entitled to
the Specified Disease Treatment Research Programme. Prescribing pattern of drugs
suggested that some cases did not follow clinical guidelines. Adherence to clinical
guideline recommendations should be promoted.
.
PGI56
Claims Database Analysis Of Patients With Chronic Hepatitis C In
Japan
Muscular-Skeletal Disorders – Clinical Outcomes Studies
Tomita N 1, Kanatani Y 1, Nakagawa Y 2
1National Institute of Public Health, Saitama, Japan, 2National Hospital Organization Shikoku
Medical Center for Children and Adults, Zentuji city, Japan
.
the PDTAs of the most representative Regions. The analysis investigates the following Regional characteristics: establishment of a working group to define the PDTA,
the gap of criteria for prescribing centers with the AISF guidelines, indication of
therapeutic scheme for the different kind of patients, budget allocation, characteristics of the management model and existence of a follow up system. Results:
The results of the study show that, besides some common characteristics observed
in all Regions (e. g. the presence of working group and criteria for the eligibility of
patients and identification of prescribing centers), there is a substantial heterogeneity in Regional guidelines, especially regarding budget allocation, management
model and follow up system. Indeed, if in some Regions like Basilicata and Veneto
there is a specific budget allocation (respectively €1,2 ml and € 12 ml in 2014), the
management model is based on Hub and Spoke system and the follow up mechanism is clearly set up, in other Regions like Lombardy and Liguria the guidelines are
more vague, detailing only few criteria. These Regional differences are confirmed
by other two data: the timespan between the market authorization of the Triple
Therapy for HCV patients and the integration in Regional guidelines (e. g. 17 days
in Veneto and 147 days in Emilia Romagna) and the number of prescribing centers
per million inhabitants (6,92 in Basilicata and 1,85 in Veneto). Conclusions: The
study demonstrate that, with a view to the future novel drugs, a common disease
management model, including common guidelines and organizational model, is
essential to avoid regional disparities in HCV therapies access.
.
.
.
.
.
.
PMS1
Impact of Apremilast on Physical Function over 52 weeks in
Patients with Active Psoriatic Arthritis
Mughal F 1, Tencer T 2, Clancy Z 2, Zhang F 2
Corporation, Uxbridge, UK, 2Celgene Corporation, Warren, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
1Celgene
Objectives: The PALACE studies compared the efficacy and safety of apremilast
(APR) with placebo in patients with active psoriatic arthritis (PsA) despite prior
conventional disease-modifying antirheumatic drugs and/or biologics. The objective
was to assess the impact of APR on physical functioning in patients enrolled in the
PALACE trials. Methods: The pooled analysis included data from PALACE 1-3, three
52-week, randomized, placebo-controlled studies evaluating APR in subjects with
active PsA. Patients were randomized (1: 1: 1) to placebo, APR 20 mg BID (APR20), or
APR 30 mg BID (APR30). Patients with < 20% reduction from baseline in swollen and
tender joint counts at Week 16 were required to be re-randomized (1: 1) to APR20 or
APR30 if initially randomized to placebo, or continued their initial APR dose. At Week
24, all remaining placebo patients were re-randomized to APR20 or APR30. The analysis reports data from the APR-exposure period (Weeks 0 to 52). Physical function,
a pre-specified secondary end point, was measured using the Health Assessment
Questionnaire-Disability Index (HAQ-DI) and the 36-item Short-Form Health Survey
version 2 Physical Functioning (PF) domain and physical component summary (PCS)
scores. Results: At Week 16, the observed physical function change from baseline
was improved with APR20 and APR30 vs. placebo, as measured by the HAQ-DI (-0.17
[P< 0.001] and -0.23 [P< 0.001] vs. -0.07), PF (2.73 [P< 0.007] and 4.08 [P< 0.001] vs. 1.52),
and PCS (3.44 [P< 0.002] and 4.46 [P< 0.001] vs. 2.03). At Week 52, among patients who
were treated with APR continuously, the physical function change from baseline for
APR20 and APR30 was improved, as measured by the HAQ-DI (-0.30 and -0.33), PF
(5.55 and 5.53), and PCS (6.37 and 6.23). Conclusions: Patients treated with APR30
reported improvement in physical function compared with placebo, as measured by
the HAQ-DI, PF, and PCS. This response was maintained over 52 weeks.
1MA
Objectives: The aim of this study is to describe the differences in Patients
Diagnostic Therapeutic Pathways (PDTA) among Italian Regions, as the Italian scenario shows substantial differences in terms of Regional guidelines, organization
and allocated budget. Methods: The Regional policies were examined analyzing
PMS2
Work Productivity Improvement Associated With Apremilast, An
Oral Phosphodiesterase 4 Inhibitor, in Patients With Psoriatic
Arthritis Results Of A Phase 3, Randomized, Controlled Trial
Zhang F 1, Tencer T 1, Li S 1, Strand V 2
Corporation, Warren, NJ, USA, 2Biopharmaceutical Consultant, Portola Valley, CA, USA
.
1Celgene
.
.
.
A373
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: The Work Limitations Questionnaire (WLQ) measures the degree to
which employed individuals are experiencing health-related limitations at work,
as well as health-related productivity loss. The PALACE 1 study compared the
efficacy and safety of apremilast (APR) with placebo in patients with active psoriatic arthritis (PsA) despite prior or concurrent conventional disease-modifying
antirheumatic drugs (DMARDs) and/or prior biologics. The objective of the current
analysis was to assess the effect of APR on the work productivity of employed
patients in PALACE 1. Methods: Patients were randomized (1: 1: 1) to receive
placebo, APR 20 mg BID (APR20), or APR 30 mg BID (APR30). Treatment efficacy
was assessed at Week 16 based on the intent-to-treat population. Employed
patients completed the WLQ at baseline and Week 16. Work limitations were categorized into 4 domains, which were then used to calculate the WLQ index: physical demands (PDS), mental demands (MDS), time management demands (TMS),
and output demands (ODS). Improvement in the WLQ index, and its 4 domains,
is represented by a negative change from baseline. Improvement in work productivity is represented by a positive improvement in percentage of productivity
loss. Results: 504 patients were randomized (mean age: 50.4 years; male: 49.4%).
Of these, 261 who were employed and completed at least 1 component of the
WLQ were analyzed. At Week 16, APR20 and APR30, vs. placebo, were associated
with a greater mean change from baseline in PDS (-5.58 and -6.24 vs. -2.14), MDS
(-2.22 and -5.18 vs. 1.15), TMS (-4.03 and -8.76 vs. -4.25), and ODS (-5.92 and -10.3
vs. -1.34), resulting in a greater mean improvement in the WLQ index (-0.01 and
-0.03 vs. 0.00), which corresponds to a higher median percent improvement of
productivity loss (18.9% and 24.7% vs. -3.7%). Conclusions: APR20 and APR30
increased work productivity among patients with active PsA.
PMS3
Network Meta-Analysis With Baseline Risk Adjustment To Assess
The Relative Efficacy Of Ustekinumab In Adult Patients With Active
Psoriatic Arthritis
Van Sanden S 1, Diels J 2, Van Laer J 2, Hemels M 3
1University Hospital Leuven, Leuven, Belgium, 2Janssen Pharmaceutica N.V., Beerse, Belgium,
3Janssen A/S, Birkerød, Denmark
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To compare the relative efficacy of ustekinumab to alternative therapies in anti-TNF treatment-naïve adult patients with active PsA, while adjusting
for the variability in placebo response rates across trials. Methods: A Bayesian
network meta-analysis (NMA) was performed to compare ustekinumab with
adalimumab, golimumab, etanercept, certolizumab pegol and infliximab. Four outcomes (PASI75, PASI90, PSARC, ACR20) were analysed after 12-16 and 24 weeks.
The NMA was conducted using a meta-regression model, with the trial-specific
estimated baseline risk included as a covariate (Dias et al., 2013). A sceptical prior
was used for this covariate. Both fixed (FE) and random effects models were considered. Results: Nine placebo-controlled trials were identified for inclusion in
the NMA based on systematic literature review, including 2 ustekinumab trials. The
placebo response rates varied significantly across trials, with ustekinumab trials
having generally higher values. The median value of the meta-regression coefficient
ranged between -0.02 and -1.69 (P [coef<0] between 50% and 95%) over the different
scenarios and models, suggesting an interaction effect between baseline risk and
treatment effects. At week 24 using the FE, the probability for ustekinumab 45mg
and 90mg to be more effective than the comparators based on the PASI75 ranged
from 87% (etanercept) to 46% (golimumab 100mg) and from 88% (etanercept) to 50%
(golimumab 100mg), respectively. The variability around the point estimates was
however large. Conclusions: This analysis indicates baseline risk in PsA-trials
to be a treatment effect modifier. Any NMA not correcting for baseline risk might
generate biased results. After adjusting for differences in baseline risk between the
trials, ustekinumab indicates comparable efficacy to alternative therapies, however
with high uncertainty around the point estimates.
PMS4
Comparison Of Disease Status And Outcomes Of Patients With
Psoriatic Arthritis (Psa) Receiving Adalimumab Or Etanercept
Monotherapy In Europe
Narayanan S 1, Lu Y 2, Hutchings R 2, Baynton E 2
1Ipsos Healthcare, Columbia, MD, USA, 2Ipsos Healthcare, London, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To compare the disease status and outcomes of patients with PsA
receiving adalimumab and etanercept monotherapy in Europe. Methods: A
multi-country, multi-center medical chart-review study of AS patients was conducted among rheumatologists in UK/France/Germany/Italy/Spain to collect deidentified data on patients who were recently treated with a biologic as part of
usual care. Physicians were screened for duration of practice (3-30yrs) and patient
volume (incl. > 5PsA biologic patients/month) and recruited from a large panel to
be geographically representative in each country. Eligible patient charts (≥ 3) were
randomly selected from a sample of prospective patients visiting each center/practice during the screening period. Physicians abstracted patient diagnosis, treatment patterns/dynamics and patient symptomatology/disease status/outcomes.
Patients on adalimumab/etanercept monotherapy were analyzed. Results: 249
eligible PsA patient charts were abstracted; 120 on adalimumab (male: 58%, age:
46.2yrs, average months on adalimumab: 23.9, 95% on first biologic) and 81 on
etanercept (male: 51%, age: 47.6yrs, average months on etanercept: 22.7, 94% on
first biologic). Top-3 comorbidites (adalimumab vs. etanercept) were obesity: 12%
(range: 4% (France) -20% (Germany)) vs. 9% (range: 0% (France) -25% (UK)), dyslipidemia: 8% (range: 0% (Italy) -13% (UK)) vs. 16% (range: 0% (UK) -24% (Italy)) and
anxiety/depression: 12% (range: 7% (UK) -22% (France)) vs. 6% (range: 0% (UK) -12%
(Spain)). Among patients with available data, latest lab measures documented were
(adalimumab vs. etanercept): ESR: 19.2mm/h (range: 16.0 (France) -23.6 (Italy)) vs.
22.0mm/h (range: 13.0 (Germany) -30.1 (Italy)), CRP: 6.5mg/dl (range: 1.3 (Spain)
-10.8 (UK)) vs. 13.7mg/dl (range: 6.7 (Germany) -24.0 (UK)), rheumatoid factorpositive: 10% (range: 0% (UK/Spain) -19% (Germany)) vs. 17% (range: 7% (Spain)
-50% (UK)), and anti-CPP-positive: 5% (range: 0% (France/Italy/Spain) -50% (UK))
vs. 7% (range: 0% (Germany/Spain) -25% (UK)). Latest disease severity measures
documented were (adalimumab vs. etanercept): Swollen Joint Counts: 1.6 (range:
0.4 (Spain) -2.9 (UK)) vs. 2.7 (1.4 (Germany) -8.0 (UK)), Tender Joint Counts: 2.4
(range: 0.9 (Spain) -3.5 (Italy)) vs. 4.1 (range: 1.9 (Germany) -9.8 (UK)), and HAQ
rating: 1.2 (range: 0.4 (Spain) -2.7 (Germany)) vs. 1.5 (range: 1.3 (Germany) -2.0
(France)). Conclusions: Among PsA patients receiving adalimumab or etanercept monotherapy, disease severity differed within the EU5, with patients on
etanercept, and patients in Italy and UK, having relatively higher burden and
poorer outcomes. Factors influencing the observed patterns of geographic variation and the impact of specific biologic treatments on observed patterns warrant
further scrutiny to optimize therapeutic interventions and improve outcomes.
PMS5
Relative Efficacy And Safety of Ustekinumab Compared to
Anti-TNF-Alfa Therapies in Patients With Active Psoriatic Arthritis
Huszti Z
National Institute for Quality- and Organizational Development in Healthcare and Medicines,
Budapest, Hungary
.
Objectives: Assess the relative efficacy and safety of ustekinumab compared
to reimbursed anti-TNF-alfa therapies in patients with active psoriatic arthritis
(PsA). Methods: Randomized, placebo-controlled, at least 24-week-long, pivotal
studies were searched in PubMed and EMBASE databases. Patients, participating
in these trials, had active psoriatic arthritis. They were treated with DMARD and/
or NSAID therapies and had not received any biological treatment before. Metaanalysis was based on ACR20, ACR50, ACR70, PASI75, HAQ-DI, AE and SAE endpoints.
The quality assessment of evidences was based on EUnetHTA guidelines. For the
applicability evaluation Aetkin’s method was used, while the meta-analysis used
Frequentist approach. The mean and the 95% confidence interval of odd ratios (OR)
were estimated with the Mantel-Haenszel test and with the fixed effect method.
Statistical heterogeneity was tested using the Chi-squared-test, publication bias
was checked with funnel plot. Results: During the literature search 8 studies were
identified. One study was excluded from the evaluation due to inadequate treatment
dose. Due to altering placebo arm treatment and a high risk of bias at study level, two
studies were involved in sensitivity analyses. Anti-TNF-alfa treatments had significantly better results on primary and accentuated secondary endpoints (ACR20 week
24 - ustekinumab vs. placebo: OR= 2,56 (95%CI= 1,74; 3,74); anti-TNF-alfa vs. placebo:
OR= 7,89 (95%CI= 5,65; 11,1); ACR50 week 24 – ustekinumab vs. placebo: OR= 3,46
(95%CI= 1,94; 6,17); anti-TNF-alfa vs. placebo: OR= 14,21 (95%CI= 8,01; 25,23)). On the
other secondary endpoints the differences were not significant, however results
have shown subservient tendency for anti-TNF-alfa treatment against ustekinumab.
During the safety comparisons we did not find a substantial difference between
these treatments. Conclusions: Based on our evaluation the anti-TNF-alfa treatment appears more effective than ustekinumab in the first line biologic treatment
of psoriatic arthritis.
PMS6
Drug Usage Analysis and Health Care Resources Consumption in
Patients With Rheumatoid Arthritis
Degli Esposti L 1, Sangiorgi D 1, Calandriello M 2, Buda S 1
1CliCon Srl, Ravenna, Italy, 2HE OR Unit - Bristol-Myers Squibb S.r.l., Rome, Italy
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To prevent irreversible joint damage in rheumatoid arthritis (RA), biological drugs have been developed; when insufficient response is observed, the initial dosage could be increased (dose escalation). The aim of the study was to assess
dose escalation among different therapeutic strategies and associated health care
resources use. Methods: An observational retrospective cohort analysis based
on 3 Local Health Units administrative databases was conducted. Patients who
filled at least one prescription for biologic agents with a diagnosis of RA between
01/01/2009-31/12/2011 (enrolment period) were included. Patients were followedup for 12 months and characterized on the basis of the previous 12 months. Dose
escalation and cost of illness were calculated on naïve patients (patients with no
prior prescriptions of the index biologic); dose escalation was defined as having ≥2
consecutive claims with an average weekly dose 130% greater than the initial average weekly dose. Results: 594 patients were analyzed, female: male ratio=3: 1, age
54±14. Biologic at index date were Etanercept (39%), Adalimumab (25%), Infliximab
(14%), Abatacept (10%), Tocilizumab (9%), Golimumab (3%). Naïve patients to index
biologic were 293 (49%); among them, dose escalation was observed in 21.4%
patients on Infliximab, 11.5% Adalimumab, 5.6% Abatacept, 4.0% Tocilizumab, 3.8%
Etanercept. Hospitalized patients with RA as main discharge diagnosis were 9.6%
Infliximab, 6.7% Golimumab, 6.6% Adalimumab, 2.9% Tocilizumab, 2.8% Etanercept,
2.4% Abatacept. Overall, 95% of cost of illness was driven by biologics, 2% traditional DMARDs, 3% non pharmacological costs; annual cost of illness was € 13,622
for Golimumab, € 12,803 Adalimumab, € 11,924 Etanercept, € 11,830 Tocilizumab,
€ 11,201 Infliximab, € 10,943 Abatacept. Dose escalation was associated with a higher
expenditure for biologic (€ 12,248 VS € 11,232, p= 0.023) and no difference on other
costs (€ 464 VS € 566, p= 0.349). Conclusions: Among patients with RA, Abatacept
was associated to a lower cost of illness and hospitalization ratio, due to a low dose
escalation rate.
PMS7
Comparative Effectiveness of Biological Agents With Diseases
Modifying Anti-Rheumatic Drugs For Methotrexate Failure
Rheumatoid Arthritis Patients: A Baysian Mixed Treatment
Comparison
Choi M 1, Hyun M K 1, Choi S 1, Tchoe H J 1, Lee S Y 2, Son K M 2, Jung Y O 2, Kim H A 2
Evidence-based Healthcare Collaborating Agency, Seoul, South Korea, 2Hallym
University, Chuncheon, South Korea
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1National
Objectives: Recently biological agents with a mechanism of action targeting the
pathogenesis of rheumatoid arthritis (RA) have emerged as an important treatment.
Especially, as anti-TNF (anti-tumor necrosis factor antagonist) drugs are effective
A374
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
for patients who do not respond to traditional disease modifying anti-rheumatic
drugs (DMARDs). This study aimed to compare the efficacy of biological agents with
traditional DMARDs for methotrexate (MTX) treatment failure patients. Methods:
Four DMARDs (hydroxychloroquine, sulfasalazine, methotrexate, leflunomide) and
five anti-TNF drugs (adalimumab, etanercept, golimumab, infliximab, certolizumab)
were selected according to expert consensus. A systematic search of the published
systematic reviews was performed including MEDLINE, EMBASE and Cochrane
Library. Among the identified 52 systematic reviews, 3 systematic reviews were
finally selected and updated to July 2013. Data extraction and methodological quality assessment using Cochrane Risk of Bias was performed in pairs. Comparative
efficacy was analyzed using Baysian mixed treatment comparison (MTC). Results:
A total of 85 trials from 7,938 citations were included. Nineteen trials were grouped
as MTX failure patients (mean age: 52.9 years, mean of rheumatoid factor positive rate: 76.6%). Nine studies were included in the analysis of Health Assessment
Questionnaire (HAQ). The best treatment was certolizumab combined with MTX (MD
-0.40,95% CrI -0.95 to 0.13). For comparative effects on DAS 28-ESR < 2.6 (remission),
4 trials were included in analysis. The best treatment was golimumab combined
with MTX (OR 24.5, 95% CrI 3.51 to 99.52). For comparative effects on ACR 70, the best
treatment was certolizumab combination with MTX (OR 10.46, 95% CrI 3.66 to 24.41)
in 11 trials. Conclusions: In the MTX failure patients, certolizumab combination
with MTX lowered HAQ score than MTX. The result of DAS 28- ESR< 2.6 (remission),
golimumab combined with MTX was the most effective treatment. Certolizumab
combined with MTX was best treatment for the ACR 70 response.
PMS8
Quality Of Life Assessments In Korean Patients With Rheumatoid
Arthritis (Ra): An Analysis From The Phase Iii Trial To Evaluate
Equivalence Of The Etanercept Biosimilar Hd203 And Enbrel®
In Combination With Methotrexate (Mtx) In Patients With Ra;
The Hera Study
Bae S C 1, Lee S R 2, Ahn Y 3
1Hanyang University Hospital for Rheumatic Diseases, Seoul, South Korea, 2Hanwha Chemical
Biologics, Seoul, South Korea,, 3Hanwha Chemical, Daejeon, South Korea
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Quality of Life (QoL) is important for patients with RA and Enbrel® has
demonstrated QoL benefits in this patient group. HD203 is an etanercept biosimilar,
which reported pharmacokinetic bioequivalence to the reference product Enbrel®
in a Phase I trial and, more recently, demonstrated equivalent efficacy and comparable safety in a phase III randomized trial in Korean patients with RA. Assessing
QoL was a secondary objective of the HERA study, the results of which are reported
here. Methods: Patients (male or female aged ≥ 20 years) with active RA were
randomized (1: 1) to 25 mg HD203 or Enbrel®, administered subcutaneously twice
weekly with MTX for 48 weeks. QoL assessments (Short Form 36, SF-36; Functional
Assessment of Chronic Illness Therapy-Fatigue, FACIT-F; EuroQol-5 dimension,
EQ5D) were undertaken at weeks 24 and 48. Results: In total, 294 patients were
randomized (147 to HD203; 147 to Enbrel®). There was no significant difference
between groups on QoL assessments at baseline. QoL assessments were similar
for HD203 and Enbrel® at week 24 and 48 overall. However, SF-36 Role Emotional
and Bodily Pain subscales showed significant increase in favour of HD203 at week
24 (p= 0.0252) and week 48 (p= 0.0243) respectively. No significant difference was
observed between HD203 and Enbrel® for FACIT-F scores at week 24 or 48, except at
week 48 for the Emotional Well-being domain, which was significantly improved
with Enbrel® vs. HD203 (p= 0.0360). No significant differences between groups in
EQ5D scores were observed at any time. Conclusions: Together with previous
reports of equivalent pharmacokinetics and efficacy, and comparable safety, these
data support the biosimilarity of HD203 vs. Enbrel®.
PMS9
Comparison of Disease Status And Outcomes of Patients With
Rheumatoid Arthritis (Ra) Receiving Adalimumab or Etanercept
Monotherapy In Europe
Narayanan S1, Lu Y 2, Hutchings R 2, Baynton E 2, Hautamaki E 1
Healthcare, Columbia, MD, USA, 2Ipsos Healthcare, London, UK
.
.
.
.
1Ipsos
Objectives: To compare the disease status and outcomes of patients with RA
receiving adalimumab and etanercept monotherapy in Europe. Methods: A
multi-country, multi-center medical chart-review study of RA patients was conducted among rheumatologists in UK/France/Germany/Italy/Spain to collect deidentified data on patients who were recently treated with a biologic as part of
usual care. Physicians were screened for duration of practice (3-30 yrs) and patient
volume (incl. > 5 RA biologic patients/month) and recruited from a large panel to
be geographically representative in each country. Eligible patient charts (≥ 3) were
randomly selected from a sample of prospective patients visiting each center/practice during the screening period. Physicians abstracted patient diagnosis, treatment patterns/dynamics and patient symptomatology/disease status/outcomes.
Patients on adalimumab/etanercept monotherapy were analyzed. Results: 428
eligible RA patient charts were abstracted; 152 on adalimumab (female: 68%, age:
52.1yrs, average months on adalimumab: 22.8, 90% on first biologic) and 142 on
etanercept (female: 70%, age: 50.5yrs, average months on etanercept: 24.6, 97%
on first biologic). Among patients with available data, latest lab measures documented were (adalimumab vs. etanercept): ESR: 21.0mm/h (range: 16.1 (UK) -24.6
(Germany)) vs. 23.4mm/h (range: 13.5 (France) -29.8 (Italy)), CRP: 9.9mg/dl (range:
5.0 (Italy) -17.0 (Germany)) vs. 13.1mg/dl (range: 7.7 (France) -15.6 (Italy)), rheumatoid factor-positive: 81% (range: 68% (Germany) -86% (Spain)) vs. 85% (range:
62% (Germany) -95% (Spain)), and anti-CPP-positive: 69% (range: 47% (Germany)
-83% (France)) vs. 74% (range: 61% (Spain) -83% (France)). Latest disease severity
measures documented were (adalimumab vs. etanercept): Swollen Joint Counts:
2.7 (range: 2.2 (Spain) -3.5 (Germany)) vs. 2.6 (range: 0.7 (Spain) -6.3 (UK)), Tender
Joint Counts were 3.9 (range: 3.2 (France) -5.1 (Germany)) vs. 3.7 (range: 1.5 (Spain)
-7.1 (UK)), Health Assessment Questionnaire (HAQ) rating: 1.6 (range: 0.1 (Spain)
-2.3 (Germany)) vs. 1.4 (0.3 (Spain) -2.5 (Germany), DAS28 score: 3.8 (range: 2.5
(UK) -4.8 (Spain)) vs. 3.2 (1.5 (Germany) -6.6 (Spain), VAS score: 3.8 (range: 3.0 (UK)
-4.8 (Italy)) vs. 3.1 (range: 1.9 (Germany) -3.9 (Italy)). Conclusions: Among RA
patients receiving adalimumab or etanercept monotherapy, disease severity was
similar across the EU5, with patients in Spain and France having relatively lower,
and patients in Italy, Germany, and UK having relatively higher burden and poorer
treatment response. Factors influencing the observed patterns of geographic variation warrant further scrutiny to optimize therapeutic interventions and improve
outcomes.
PMS10
Efficacy Of Novel Dmards In Early Active Rheumatoid Arthritis: An
Indirect Comparison
Sawyer L 1, Chang S 1, Diamantopoulos A 2, Dejonckheere F 3
1Symmetron Limited, Herts, UK, 2Symmetron Limited, Borehamwood, UK, 3F. Hoffmann-La Roche,
Basel, Switzerland
.
.
.
.
Objectives: We evaluated the effectiveness of traditional disease-modifying
antirheumatic drugs (tDMARDs) and novel DMARDs, alone and in combination,
in methotrexate- and biologic-naive adults with moderate to severe early rheumatoid arthritis (ERA; < 3-year duration). Methods: Literature review identified
randomized controlled trials (RCTs) of tDMARDs and novel DMARDs reporting
efficacy outcomes (American College of Rheumatology [ACR] 20/50/70/90 response
and Disease Activity Score at 28 joints [DAS28] remission). Data were pooled using
Bayesian network meta-analysis techniques. For ACR response, data were analyzed
using a fixed-effects ordered probit model, which makes efficient use of ordered
categorical data and guarantees coherent prediction of multinomial response probabilities. For DAS28 remission, data were analyzed with a fixed-effects binomial
logit model. Sensitivity analyses tested the effects of grouping treatments by class
and broadening/narrowing inclusion criteria. Results: Results from a synthesis
of 16 RCTs of tDMARDs (methotrexate, sulfasalazine, hydroxychloroquine) and
novel DMARDs (biologics [abatacept, adalimumab, etanercept, infliximab, golimumab, tocilizumab] and tofacitinib) indicated that biologics+methotrexate, triple
tDMARDs, and tocilizumab and tofacitinib monotherapy significantly increased
response across all ACR categories versus methotrexate. ACR response probabilities
for biologics+methotrexate were not significantly different between agents. ACR
response probabilities to novel DMARD monotherapy varied, trending toward higher
values for tofacitinib and tocilizumab than etanercept or adalimumab. In studies
reporting DAS28 remission, treatment with tofacitinib or biologics±methotrexate,
except adalimumab alone, improved remission likelihood versus methotrexate.
Tocilizumab±methotrexate generated the highest probability of remission among
biologics and was significantly more effective than other biologics±methotrexate
and tofacitinib. Results across outcomes were robust to alternative grouping of
interventions and change in inclusion criteria. Conclusions: Based on ACR
response, the expected efficacy of biologics+methotrexate, tofacitinib and tocilizumab monotherapy, and triple tDMARD therapy appeared higher than MTX in
ERA. Tocilizumab±methotrexate was expected to have the highest probability
of generating DAS28 remission and was significantly more effective than other
biologics±methotrexate and tofacitinib.
PMS11
Using Health Assessment Questionnaire – Disability Index To
Estimate Eq-5d Utility Values for Patients With Rheumatoid
Arthritis in Taiwan
Tang C H 1, Hsu J Y 1, Hsu P N 2
1Taipei Medical University, Taipei, Taiwan, 2National Taiwan University, Taipei, Taiwan
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: This study aims to provide estimates of EQ-5D as a function of Health
Assessment Questionnaire – Disability Index (HAQ-DI) scores in patients with
rheumatoid arthritis (RA) in Taiwan. Methods: Face-to-face patient interviews
on a total of 140 patients aged between 30 and 70 years old were recruited at the
rheumatology outpatient clinics of four hospitals located in northern, central and
southern Taiwan during June 2013-May 2014. The severity distribution of patients
was mild RA (Disease Activity Score [DAS 28] < 3.2) (N= 57), moderate RA (3.2□…
DAS< 5.1) (N= 44), and severe RA (DAS≥ a5.1) (N= 39). Socio-demographic and clinical
information were collected, and the HAQ-DI and the EQ-5D questionnaires were
completed. Generalized linear regression models were used to predict EQ-5D utility values as functions of HAQ-DI scores, age, and gender. Results: Patient mean
age was 50.8 years old (standard deviation [SD], 11.3 years); 81.4% of the patients
were women and mean disease duration was 9.65 years (SD, 6.84 years). HAQ-DI
<0.5, 58%; 0.5□…HAQ-DI<1.1, 16%; 1.1□…HAQ-DI<1.6, 9%, 1.6□… HAQ-DI<2.1, 12%;
and HAQ-DI≥ a2.1, 4%. HAQ-DI and EQ-5D mean scores were 12.01 (SD, 7.8) and 0.67
(SD, 0.34), respectively. The models were able to predict actual EQ-5D across the
range of the HAQ DI. Age and gender were found to be significant determinants in
estimating the utility functions. Conclusions: Utility values have very often not
been assessed in the data collection process in a clinical trial. This study showed
that HAQ-DI scores can be used to derive EQ-5D utility values for patients with RA
in Taiwan to facilitate conducting a cost-utility analysis.
PMS12
Heal Rate In 4,190 Fresh Fractures Treated With Low-Intensity
Pulsed Ultrasound (Lipus)
Zura R 1, Mehta S 2, Della Rocca G 3, Jones J 4, Steen R G 4
1Duke University Medical Center, Durham, NC, USA, 2Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania,
Philadelphia, PA, USA, 3University of Missouri, Columbia, MO, USA, 4Bioventus, LLC, Durham,
NC, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Patient age is one of many potential risk factors for fracture nonunion.
We evaluate impact of age on heal rate (HR) in patients with fresh fracture (≤ 90
days old). Our hypothesis is that age is not a risk factor for nonunion if fractures
are treated with LIPUS. Methods: A LIPUS device was approved in 1994 to accelerate fresh fracture healing, though the FDA required a Post-Market Registry. Patient
data were collected from October 1994 until October 1998 and were reviewed and
A375
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
validated by a registered nurse. We required 4 data elements to report a patient: date
when fracture occurred; date when treatment began; date when treatment ended;
and outcome (healed vs. failed, by clinical and radiological criteria). Data were used
to calculate: days to treatment (DTT); and days on treatment (DOT). All fresh fractures with DTT, DOT, and outcome are reported. Results: 5,765 patients in the registry had fresh fracture; 73% of patients (N= 4,190) are reported; 13% of patients were
lost to follow-up; 11% withdrew or were noncompliant; and 3% died or are missing outcome. Among compliant patients, HR was 96.2%. Logistic estimates of the
odds ratio for healing are equivalent for patients aged 30 to 79 years. Nevertheless,
patients who failed treatment were 4.5 years older than patients who healed (p <
0.0009). DTT was significantly shorter for patients who healed (p < 0.0001). Data
show that obesity, smoking, diabetes, vascular insufficiency, osteoporosis, cancer,
rheumatoid arthritis, and chronic use of NSAIDs reduce HR. Conclusions: LIPUS
mitigates the effect of age on fracture HR. Patients who used LIPUS had a 96% HR,
whereas the expected HR averages 93%. Time to treatment was significantly shorter
among patients who healed (p < 0.0001), suggesting it is beneficial to begin treatment early. Comorbid conditions in conjunction with aging can reduce fracture HR.
PMS13
Pain Therapy for Osteoarthritis in Germany: Analysis of Sickness
Fund Claims Data
Tomeczkowski J 1, Wimmer A 2, Pappert K 2
1Janssen-Cilag GmbH, Neuss, Germany, 2Janssen-Cilag, Neuss, Germany
.
.
.
Objectives: Using sickness fund claims data, we sought to determine osteoarthritis rate, drug compound class, pain therapy prevalence and type of medical
specialists providing treatment. Methods: A group of company health-sickness
funds (approx. 2.1 million insured patients in 2010; 2.5 million insured patients in
2011) was used. Osteoarthritis was identified based on ICD-10 diagnoses (M16.0-9,
M17.0-5, M17.9, M19.05, M19.25, M19.85, M19.95), then linked to prescriptions using
the ATC codes: M01A (nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, NSAIDS), N02B (analgesics and antipyretics), and N02A (opioids). Furthermore, we determined which
groups of medical specialists prescribed the drugs. Results: Osteoarthritis was
diagnosed in 7.8% (in 2010) and in 7.1% (in 2011) of patients. In one year, 65.4% of
patients received a prescription for at least one drug from the analysed ATC codes:
81.4% of patients received at least one NSAID, 36.4% an analgesic and antipyretic,
and 27.4% an opioid. For M01A, diclofenac (54%) was most frequently prescribed;
the proportion of coxibs was 6%. For N02B, 99% of prescriptions were for metamizol; 1% for paracetamol. For N02A, most prescriptions were for tramadol (29%) or
tilidin (28%). General practitioners most frequently prescribed these drugs (42.2%
[M01A]/46.2% [N02B]/45.9% [N02A]). Conclusions: In Germany in 2010-2011, OA
prevalence was 7-8%, and associated with analgesic prescriptions for the majority
of evaluated patients. Diclofenac (NSAIDs, metamizol (analgesics and antipyretics),
and tramadol or tilidin (opioids) were most frequently prescribed in each group.
General practitioners were the most frequent painkiller prescribers.
Muscular-Skeletal Disorders – Cost Studies
PMS14
A Budget Impact Analysis of Ustekinumab in the Management of
Psoriatic Arthritis in Greece
Kousoulakou H 1, Natsikas C 2, Geitona M 1
of Peloponnese, Corinth, Greece, 2Janssen Pharmaceutical Greece, Pefki, Greece
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: Ustekinumab was approved for the treatment of psoriatic arthritis (PsA)
in September 2013. The objective of the study was to estimate the budget impact
of ustekinumab in the management of PsA in Greece. Methods: A budget impact
model was developed in Excel 2010 comparing the total PsA treatment costs in the
current treatment pathway (including golimumab, adalimumab, etanercept and infliximab) with the respective costs of a treatment mix with the inclusion of ustekinumab. Market share data for the current treatment pathway were based on market
research. Epidemiology data were taken from the published literature. Due to lack
of published data on resource use, a 60-field questionnaire was developed in order
to collect local data relating to the management of PsA in Greece. Two expert panels
were convened, one with 8 KOL dermatologists and one with 8 KOL rheumatologists, with the Delphi technique. Unit costs were retrieved from publically available
sources. The time horizon was five years and the analysis was conducted from the
Social Insurance Fund perspective. Results: The total number of eligible patients
(incident and prevalent cases) was estimated to increase from 6,448 in Year 1 to 7,754
in Year 5. The total cost in the current treatment pathway was estimated to range
between €48.4 million in Year 1 and €20 million in Year 5. The costs in the treatment
pathway including ustekinumab were €47.8 and €18.5 million, in the respective years.
Therefore, the addition of ustekinumab in the treatment mix can lead to cumulative
savings for the Social Insurance Funds of € 7.7 million, over the 5-year time horizon.
This cost reduction is mainly attributed to the less frequent administration of ustekinumab. Conclusions: Inclusion of ustekinumab in the treatment mix appears to
be a cost saving treatment option in the management of PsA in Greece.
PMS15
Budget Impact Analysis of Certolizumab Pegol in the Management
of Patients With Moderate-To-Severe Active Rheumatoid Arthritis
in Greece
Tzanetakos C 1, Maniadakis N 1, Kourlaba G 2, Tzioufas A 3, Goules A 3, Theodoratou T 4,
Christou P 4
1National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece, 2Collaborative Center for Clinical Epidemiology
and Outcomes Research (CLEO), Athens, Greece, 3Athens Medical School, Athens, Greece, 4UCB
Pharma, Athens, Greece
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To investigate the budgetary impact of increasing the patient share of
certolizumab pegol (CZP) versus the other recommended biologic disease modifying
anti-rheumatic drugs (bDMARDs; etanercept, adalimumab, golimumab, infliximab,
abatacept, tocilizumab) for the treatment of moderate-to-severe active rheumatoid
arthritis (RA) in Greece. Methods: A budget impact model was adapted from a thirdparty payer perspective (National Organization for Healthcare Services Provision
[EOPYY]) to evaluate economic aspects of RA treatment over 5 years (2014–2018).
The model assumed Greek epidemiological data and local reimbursement requirements. Two main scenarios, following either a conservative or an increased market
uptake of CZP in the Greek health care market, were estimated and individually
compared to the current market trend scenario, which incorporates original biologics
erosion from biosimilars entry in the coming year. Costs pertaining to drug acquisition, administration (only for intravenous drugs), and monitoring were included in
the analysis and corresponded to 2014 costing year. Officially published sources were
used to derive unit costs. The outcome measures were the annual cost of treatment
with bDMARD presented as total cost and disaggregated by drug cost, administration
cost and monitoring cost, as well as the incremental cost savings per year. Results:
Comparing CZP current versus conservative market uptake scenarios, the total budget
was slightly increased by € 0.05 million. In contrast, comparing CZP current versus
increased market uptake scenarios, the total budgetary savings were €0.23 million. In
the latter comparison setting, the cost savings were attributed to reduced drug and
administration costs. More specifically, the greater replacement of an intravenously
administered bDMARD (infliximab) conduced to the greater reduction of administration costs than in the former comparison setting (cost savings: € 0.17 vs. € 0.14
million). Conclusions: A potential increased use of CZP treatment was shown to
be associated with cost savings over the next 5 years in Greece.
PMS16
Pharmacoeconomic Evaluation of Biologic Therapies in Russian
Patients With Rheumatoid Arthritis and Intolerance or Inadequate
Response to Conventional Basic Therap
Ryazhenov V V 1, Gorokhova S G 1, Maximkin S A 2
First Moscow State Medical University, Moscow, Russia, 2Center for strategic
research in healthcare, Moscow, Russia
.
.
.
.
.
.
1I.M. Sechenov
Objectives: About 2.79% of patientswith rheumatoid arthritis (RA) in Russia receive
TNF-α inhibitors; this value may vary significantly and depends on limitations of
regional budgets. In this respect, the aim of our study was to conduct a comparative pharmacoeconomic analysis of the most prevalent TNF-α inhibitors in Russian
patients with rheumatoid arthritis and intolerance or inadequate response to conventional basic therapy. Methods: An pharmacoeconomic model was developed
based on the data from indirect comparison of anti-TNF-α agents. The model considers the use of infliximab, etanercept, certulizumab pegol, adalimumab in patients
with RA who lost response to conventional basic therapy. Cost-effectiveness and
costs of TNF-α inhibitors for health care budget were estimated. The cost analysis
included costs of pharmacotherapy. Infliximab and etanercept are included into the
list of vital and essential medicines and were considered as accepted technologies
in budget impact analysis: certulizumab pegol and adalimumab were novel tecnologies in our model. A 24-weeks horizon was adopted. Sensitivity analysis (SA) was
performed by changing costs of medicines Results: the costs of therapy in certulizumab pegol and etanercept groups were significantly lower than in infliximab and
adalimumab groups. The cost-effectiveness ratios (CERs) in terms of ACR20 in 24
weeks were 703 625.00, 587 776.09, and 4 119 260.82 for certulizumab pegol, etanercept and infliximab groups, respectively. The same was observed in case of ACR50
and ACR70: a strategy of drug use in certulizumab pegol and etanercept groups
was preferable in comparison with infliximab and adalimumab groups. Budgetary
costs for health care system were higher in case of infliximab and adalimumab. SA
confirmed the robustness of the model Conclusions: The study demonstrated
that certulizumab pegol and etanercept are an economically effective strategy for
Russian patients with RA and lost response to conventional basic therapy.
PMS17
Mast (Minimal Access Spinal Technologies) Versus Open Surgery:
Cost Analysis From Hospital Perspective
Lukyanov V 1, Melik-Gusseinov D 1, Borgman B 2, Demourenko D 3, Mlyavykh S 4
1Center of Social Economics, Moscow, Russia, 2Medtronic International, Tolochenaz, Switzerland,
3Medtronic LLC, Moscow, Russia, 4Scientific Research Institute of Traumatology and Orthopedics,
Nizhniy Novgorod, Russia
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The objective of this study was to determine and compare the resource
consumption associated with open vs. minimal invasive surgery in patients with
degenerative spinal disorders in the Russian hospital setting. Methods: Conducted
cost-analysis was based on Moscow hospital setting, where resource utilization
associated with average one-level spinal operation was determined through interviews with KOLs in spinal surgery. Costs were retrieved from public sources and
hospital data for the following categories 1) hospital stay; 2) blood transfusion 3)
consumables (suture materials, hemostatic sponges, disposable instruments); 4)
time in the operating room; 5) spinal implants/instrumentation; and 6) complications. Results: The results of the calculations have confirmed MAST economic
advantages over open surgery (OS). MAST was associated with fewer costs, mainly
due to shorter stay in intensive care unit (1 vs. 2 days) and general ward (9 vs. 15
days), no need for blood transfusion and less rate of complications. The difference
in the duration of surgery, which depends mainly on the speed of approach and
the installation of implantable structures, is approximately 20 minutes in favor of
MAST. With the cost of one-hour long surgery at about 6,000 rubles (167$), excluding
the cost of implantable structures, the use of MAST instead of OS translates into
savings of 2,000 rubles (56$) per each surgical intervention. As for overall budget
savings, the use of MAST translates into savings of between 14,783 ($410) and 35,000
($970) rubles per whole hospital visit, depending on what materials and structures
are used. Conclusions: The economic evaluation confirms economic domination
of MAST over OS. Despite initial higher investments, MAST appears to be a cost
saving alternative to OS, in terms of diminution of actual surgery time, reduction of
blood transfusion costs, and prevention of post-surgery complications and shorter
overall length of hospital stay.
A376
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
1HERESCON
GmbH, Hannover, Germany, 2Medtronic International, Tolochenaz, Switzerland,
GmbH, Meerbusch, Germany, 4Spine Center Osnabrueck, Osnabrueck, Germany,
5Klinik für Wirbelsäulenchirurgie, Dortmund, Germany
PMS18
Cost Comparison of Surgical and Non-Surgical Treated Lumbar
Spinal Stenosis Patients
3Medtronic
Jacob C 1, Brasseur P 2, Haas J S 1, Braun S 1
1HERESCON GmbH, Hannover, Germany, 2Medtronic International Trading Sarl, Tolochenaz,
Switzerland
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Lumbar spinal stenosis (LSS) occurs as a degeneration of the spine
in aging populations. Treatment options comprise surgical and non-surgical
intervention. The aim of this study was to compare annual costs between LSS
patients treated with instrumental spinal surgery (ISS) and those non-surgically
treated. Methods: A retrospective claims data analysis was conducted using
anonymized claims data from the Health Risk Institute research database. The study
period comprised 01 January 2009 to 31 December 2011. LSS patients receiving an
ISS were compared to an age and gender matched non-operated control group with
comparable disease state. Patients were identified by ICD-10-GM code M48.0* in the
inpatient setting. Operation and procedure codes (OPS) were used to identify ISS.
Comparable disease state was achieved by matching total costs in an individual
period of 12 months before the first LSS caused hospitalization. Annual costs after
surgical treatment were compared for LSS patients receiving ISS and those with no
surgical treatment. Results: A total of 2,027 patients with LSS were identified in
2010 records. Surgical treatment with ISS was applied in 542 cases whereas 1,485
individuals received non-surgical treatment. After matching both groups for age,
gender, and comparable disease state, 393 patients in each group were available for
the cost comparison. Mean annual costs were €8,458 higher in the ISS-treated group;
clearly due to average ISS-cost of € 9,644. In contrast, costs for outpatient care and
pharmaceuticals decrease after the surgery. Conclusions: Surgical treatment for
LSS patients exceeds the cost of non-surgical treatment in the first year after surgery. A cost offset is not achievable in this period due to the high cost of the surgical
intervention. Nevertheless, cost savings were already observed in pharmaceutical
therapy and outpatient care. Further research is needed to determine if overall cost
savings could be achieved in an extended timeframe.
.
Tencer T , Clancy Z , Zhang F
Celgene Corporation, Warren, NJ, USA
.
.
Objectives: The purpose of this study was to estimate the annual costs and the
cost per responder for psoriatic arthritis (PsA) patients treated with apremilast,
etanercept, and adalimumab in adults with PsA in the United States. Methods:
Comparative efficacy data were obtained from a Bayesian network meta-analysis
of biologic and non-biologic disease-modifying antirheumatic drugs as of October
2013. The primary outcome was ACR20 response at Week 24. Response rate differences from the clinical trials were assumed to be maintained for 52 weeks. US
wholesale acquisition cost as of June 2014 and approved labeled dosing were used
to derive drug treatment costs. Results: At Week 24, the adjusted ACR20 response
rate was 40.3% for apremilast, 53.4% for etanercept, and 57.8% for adalimumab.
The cost per ACR20 responder at Week 24 was $23,562 for apremilast, $30,346 for
etanercept, and $25,978 for adalimumab. By Week 52, the cost per ACR20 responder
was $53,704 for apremilast, $65,750 for etanercept, and $56,273 for adalimumab. The
annual cost to achieve 100 responders was $5,370,387 for apremilast, $6,574,981 for
etanercept, and $5,627,336 for adalimumab. Conclusions: Apremilast had the
lowest wholesale acquisition costs per ACR20 responder and the lowest annual cost
to achieve 100 ACR20 responders, as compared with etanercept and adalimumab
through 52 weeks in PsA patients.
PMS20
Direct Non-Medical Costs Of Rheumatoid Arthritis By Disease Level
In Portugal
Mateus C , Moura A
Escola Nacional de Saúde Pública, Universidade Nova de Lisboa, Lisboa, Portugal
.
.
Objectives: Direct non-medical costs may be difficult to assess, so these are often
disregarded in cost-of-illness studies. This analysis aims to estimate the annual
direct non-medical costs of treating a patient with Rheumatoid Arthritis (AR) in
Portugal, per level of disease activity. Methods: Patients with RA followed by 5
different rheumatologists across the country, were asked to participate in a survey,
and informed consent was given by all patients. Besides socio-economic data, the
survey included questions regarding the following cost components: number of
medical appointments and treatments attended by the patient and its associated
travel expenses; expenditures related to adaptations made to their homes and the
purchase of medical devices; amount of domiciliary support received, both paid
and unpaid. In case of paid domiciliary support patients were also asked about the
associated amount. That figure was then used in order to assess the value of unpaid
domiciliary support. Disease activity was measured by the DAS28 score. Results:
Our final sample consists of 90 patients and descriptive statistics are in line with
RA epidemiology (73 women, mean age 56.9). The percentage of patients with low
disease activity was 27.7%, whereas, of 43.3% and 28.8% for those with moderate
and high disease activity, respectively. Estimated direct non-medical costs ranged
from €1,339 to €5,475 per year, for patients with low and high disease activity, respectively. More than 70% of these costs were related to paid and unpaid domiciliary
support. Conclusions: Direct non-medical costs are positively associated with
disease activity. Estimated costs have a non-negligible magnitude and are entirely
borne by patients. Our results confirm the heavy economic burden that RA places
on patients and their families.
PMS21
Claims Data Analysis on the Annual Frequency and Incremental
Cost of Reoperations in Instrumental Spinal Surgeries in Germany
Jacob C 1, Annoni E 2, Haas J S 1, Witthohn A 3, Braun S 1, Grünert J 3, Winking M 4, Franke J 5
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
PMS22
Current and Future Costs of Osteoporotic Fractures in the
Netherlands
Lötters F J B 1, de Vries F 2, van den Bergh J 2, Rutten-van Mölken M 1
1Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 2Maastricht University Medical
Center, Maastricht, The Netherlands
PMS19
Cost Per Responder Of Apremilast Versus Etanercept And
Adalimumab In Patients With Active Psoriatic Arthritis
.
Objectives: Complications in instrumental spinal surgeries (ISS) pose a considerable burden on patients. Necessary reoperations are associated with significant
resource utilization and cost and from the perspective of the German Statutory
Health Insurance (SHI). Dependable data on the frequency of reoperations and
associated costs are lacking for Germany. The aim of this study was to estimate
the incidence of ISS and consecutive reoperations, and to calculate the related
costs. Methods: We conducted a retrospective claims data analysis using the
Health Risk Institute research database, which contains anonymized claims data
and covers approximately 5.42% of the German population. The study period
comprised 01 January 2009 to 31 December 2011. An algorithm of operation and procedure codes (OPS) identified primary ISS and following reoperations. Reoperation
rates were calculated for an individual period of 12 months after the primary ISS in
2010. Annual costs for reoperations were calculated based on group comparison of
patients with reoperation and those without reoperation (control group). Existing
differences in cost levels in the year before the primary ISS were adjusted by the
difference in differences approach. Results: A total of 3,316 individuals had a
primary ISS in 2010. The reoperation rate was 9.98% (95% CI = 8.98% to 11.02%).
Mean cost per ISS was € 11,331 for all patients (€ 13,358 reoperation group, € 11,106
control group). The mean adjusted annual cost for a reoperation was € 11,370, with
€ 8,432 directly attributed to the reoperation procedure and € 2,938 to excess costs
in the first year after the primary ISS. Conclusions: The direct cost of ISS has a
significant impact on health insurance budgets. With 10% of primary ISS patients
requiring a reoperation in Germany, their associated annual costs are relevant from
the SHI perspective. As demonstrated elsewhere, these cost might be partly avoidable by using intra-operative 3-D imaging with navigation.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: This study aims to estimate the incidence and costs of osteoporotic
fractures in The Netherlands in 2010 and project them to 2030. Methods: The
incidence and health care costs of fractures were derived from claims data of
all health care insurers in The Netherlands. We obtained 5-year age- and gender-specific costs of patients with and without fractures. Cost included hospital admission, physical therapy, occupational therapy, general practitioner and
medication. In order to attribute fractures to osteoporosis we used a large dataset
from a general hospital that included patients with a fracture screened with Dexa
scan. Future projections were based on four different scenarios: 1. demographic
scenario, 2. demographic+trend in incidence scenario, 3. demographic+trend in
incidence+trend in cost scenario, and 4. increased treatment scenario. Results:
Of all registered fractures 32% could be attributed to osteoporosis. In women this
percentage was larger than in men (36 versus 21 %). This resulted in an incidence
for all osteoporotic fractures of 964 per 100.000 in women and 245 per 100.000 in
men for 2010. Over time (2010-2030) the overall increase in incidence of osteoporotic fractures was 40% (scenario 1). The increase in hip fractures ranged from
60% (scenario 1) to 79% (scenario2). In 2010 approximately 200 million Euros was
spend on treatment of osteoporotic fractures. The costs for osteoporotic fractures
increased with 50% from 2010 till 2030 (scenario 1). The increase in costs for hip
fractures was highest, ranging from 60% (scenario1) to 148% (scenario 3&4 combined), resulting in cost estimates in 2030 of 161 and 249 million, respectively.
Prevention of osteoporotic fractures in general can lead to cost-savings of 92 million in 2030 (scenario 4 & 1 combined). Conclusions: The expected high increase
in incidence and costs of osteoporotic fractures calls for a wider use of prevention
and treatment options.
PMS23
Burden Of Disease Analysis Of Ankylosing Spondylitis In Hungary
Hegyi R 1, Nagy B 1, Koncz A 2, Huybrechts I 3, Lavicky J 4, Ferenczik A 1
Consulting Ltd., Budapest, Hungary, 2UCB Pharma, Budapest, Hungary, 3UCB
Pharma, Brussels, Belgium, 4UCB Pharma, Prague, Czech Republic
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Healthware
Objectives: Ankylosing spondylitis (AS) entails an individual burden to patients
and ties up resources. This study aimed to assess the total costs of AS, including the indirect burden of AS patients in Hungary and to obtain an overview of
patients’ status, demographics, morbidity, working capacity and other characteristics. Methods: Between January–March 2014, a questionnaire survey was
conducted among AS patients, which was filled out voluntarily and anonymously.
Missing data was not imputed in the analysis; considered patient number is presented next to results if lower than total patient number. Results: 152 patients
completed the questionnaire, of which 37% were women. Mean age was 51 years
(Standard Deviation [SD]: 13 years) and average disease duration was 17 years
(SD: 12 years). At primary diagnosis of AS, 80% of patients had a full-time job, 2%
a part-time job, and only 8% received disability pension. At time of survey, only
36% of patients worked full-time, 1% part-time, and the proportion of disability
pensioners increased to 42%. Cost calculation results* showed that the average
annual total cost per AS patient was 5,155€ . Within this, average annual direct nonmedical cost was over 1,976€ and average annual indirect cost per patient was
approximately 3,129€ (145 patients). Wage loss due to disability pension generated
the highest average annual indirect cost per patient (3,290€ – 124 patients). In the
working-age population (118 patients, 31–62 years), total average cost per patient
was 5,996€ . Conclusions: Due to their disease, AS patients can become partially or completely disabled, which imposes a significant burden directly on their
environment and indirectly to society. Average costs were associated with disease
duration. Patients may already be driven out from the labour market in their active
A377
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
ages because of the disease’s symptoms and variability, leading to reduced social
engagement. *exchange rate: 303,59HUF/EUR
PMS24
Early Retirement Indirect Costs Attributable to Rheumatic Diseases
in Portugal
Laires P A 1, Canhão H 2, Gouveia M 3
Portuguesa de Reumatologia, Lisbon, Portugal, 2Faculdade de Medicina, Universidade
de Lisboa, Lisboa, Portugal, 3Católica Lisbon School of Business and Economics, Lisbon, Portugal
.
.
.
.
1Sociedade
Objectives: Rheumatic diseases (RD) cause physical disability that may lead to
early retirement, generating high indirect costs to society. We estimate these costs
in the Portuguese population approaching the statutory retirement age. Methods:
Health, sociodemographic and occupational data was retrieved from the 4th
National Health Survey (2005/2006), for all people between 50 and 64 years of age
(3,762 men and 4,241 women), whilst an official wage national database was used
to estimate productivity values by gender, age-group and region, using the human
capital approach. The effects of RD on the likelihood of early retirement and the
attributable fractions estimates were obtained at the individual level by logistic
regression. Results: At the time of the survey, 37.2% of the population with ages
50-64 years old self-reported at least one RD and among these 22.7% were officially
retired, compared with 17.6% of those without RD (p< 0.001). Females had higher
prevalence of RD (49.8% vs. 23.4% for males; p< 0.001). Presence of RD was associated
with early retirement regardless of age, gender and region (OR=1.3; CI 95%: 1.0 - 1.6).
The estimated annual indirect costs following premature retirement attributable
to RD were € 367 million (€ 504 per RD patient). Age-groups closer to the statutory
retirement age contribute more to the overall indirect costs and also have higher
individual productivity values. For instance, 60-64 years old age-group contribute
with 52% of overall costs and had an average indirect cost of 699€ per RD patient.
Females were responsible for about 55% of these costs, however males contribute with higher individual productivity losses (cost per patient: 788€ vs. 390€ , for
males and females respectively). Conclusions: Annual early retirement indirect
costs attributable to RD are considerable. These results highlight the need to target
patients with rheumatic conditions in order to obtain health and productivity gains
and reduce early retirement in society.
PMS25
Burden of Disease Analysis of Psoriatic Arthritis In Hungary
Hegyi R 1, Nagy B 1, Koncz A 2, Huybrechts I 3, Lavicky J 4, Ferenczik A 1
Consulting Ltd., Budapest, Hungary, 2UCB Pharma, Budapest, Hungary, 3UCB
Pharma, Brussels, Belgium, 4UCB Pharma, Prague, Czech Republic
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Psoriatic arthritis (PsA) entails an individual burden to patients and
ties up resources. This study aimed to assess the total costs of PsA, including the
indirect burden of PsA patients in Hungary and to obtain an overview of patients’
status, demographics, morbidity, and working capacity. Methods: Between
January–March 2014, a questionnaire survey was conducted among PsA patients
and filled out voluntarily and anonymously. Missing data was not imputed in the
analysis; considered patient number is presented next to results if lower than total
patient number. Results: 145 patients completed the questionnaire, of which 57%
were women. Mean age was 54 years (Standard Deviation [SD]: 14 years) and average disease duration was 17 years (SD: 11 years). At primary diagnosis of PsA, 79%
of patients had a full-time job, 4% a part-time job and only 3% received disability
pension. At time of survey, only 32% of patients worked full-time, 4% part-time, and
the proportion of disability pensioners increased to 28%. Cost calculation results*
showed that the average annual total cost per PsA patient was 3,842€ . Within this,
average annual direct non-medical cost was approximately 1,318€ (141 patients) and
average annual indirect cost per patient was approximately 2,635€ (142 patients).
Wage loss due to disability pension generated the highest average annual indirect
cost per patient (2,734€ – 119 patients). In the working-age population (95 patients,
31–62 years) total average cost per patient was 5,334€ . Conclusions: PsA can
cause patients to become partially or completely disabled, which imposes a significant burden directly on their environment and indirectly to society. Average direct/
indirect costs are higher with longer disease duration and greater skin manifestations. Patients may already be driven out from the labour market in their active
ages because of the disease’s symptoms and variability, leading to reduced social
engagement. *exchange rate: 303,59HUF/EUR
PMS26
Economic Modeling of The Use of Botulinum Toxin A in A
Homogenous Patient Population Based on Real-Life Clinical
Practice: Ulis-Ii (The Upper Limb International Spasticity Study)
Dinet J 1, Lambrelli D 2, Balcaitiene J 1
1IPSEN Pharma, Boulogne-Billancourt, France, 2Evidera, London, UK
.
PMS27
Hospitalization Burden Among Dialysis Patients In Brazil: an
Analysis of The Public Health System Database
Coutinho M B 1, Custodio M R 2, Pecoits-Filho R 3, Borges L 4, Guersoni A C 1
Brazil, Sao Paulo, Brazil, 2Federal University of Uberlandia, Sao Paulo, Brazil, 3Pontifícia
Universidade Católica do Paraná, Curitiba, Brazil, 4Evidências, Campinas, Brazil
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Amgen
Objectives: The objective is to compare the hospitalization length of stay and
costs associated with comorbidities between dialysis patients and non-dialysis
patients. Methods: This was a cross-sectional observational study (from January
to December 2010) of a national hospitalization database from the Brazilian Unified
Public Healthcare System (Sistema Único de Saúde – SUS). Patients included in
the study were hospitalized due to 3 predefined comorbidities categories: heart
disease, vascular disease, and osteometabolic diseases, identified using ICD-10
codes. Results: A total of 491,644 admissions were observed in patients not on
dialysis (control group), while 2,627 admissions were identified in dialysis patients.
The comparative analysis of causes of hospitalization showed that a larger proportion of admissions due to heart disease was observed in patients on dialysis (61%)
compared to the control group (47.9%), the opposite was observed for vascular and
osteometabolic hospitalizations. For all 3 categories, cost of hospitalization for dialysis
patients is at least two-fold higher and the length of stay almost 3 times longer (21
days for dialysis patients versus 8 days for non-dialysis) than non-dialysis patients.
The greatest differences between these two patient populations are in average costs
among dialysis patients hospitalized for osteometabolic disorders versus control
group and the highest burden regarding length of hospital stay, due to heart disease. Conclusions: There is a high hospitalization burden among CKD-5D patients
in the Brazil health care system. Since inpatient costs were the key cost drivers for
CKD, strategies that reduce the risk of hospitalization and increase prevention of
comorbidities may substantially decrease the overall health care economic burden.
.
1Healthware
.
235 U (108)/200 U (100-440) was injected. Based on a BoNT-A injection interval of 12
weeks, the annual cost per patient in the UK would be 1,068 GBP for abobotulinumtoxinA, 1,198 GBP for onabotulinumtoxinA and 1,399 GBP for incobotulinumtoxinA. Conclusions: Considering the real life practice of BoNT-A injections and the
comparison of treatment groups treated for the same limb segment, this analysis
suggests that the use of abobotulinumtoxinA would result potentially in a reduction
in the health care cost for the treatment of spasticity and that more patients could
be treated with abobotulinumtoxinA with a given budget.
.
Objectives: To evaluate the real life practice of the use of botulinum toxin A
(BoNT-A) in post-stroke upper limb spasticity and the economic consequences of
fair comparisons of the dosing between either abobotulinumtoxinA (Dysport®) or
onabotulinumtoxinA (Botox®) or incobotulinumtoxinA (Xeomin®). Methods:
ULIS-II is an observational, prospective study, conducted in 84 centers in 22 countries. Of 456 adults with post-stroke upper limb spasticity presenting for treatment
with BoNT-A, 193 patients with the same injected limb segments “upper arm and
lower arm” were analyzed for the dose injected for one cycle of BoNT-A. Treatment
and concomitant interventions were in accordance with routine local clinical practice. Sample size, mean (SD)/median dose (min-max) in Unit for each BoNT-A and
annual cost per patient were calculated using the mean dose administered and
considering no vial sharing. An injection interval of 12 weeks was simulated for
all BoNT-A treatments and the UK listed public price was used to ascertain annual
cost. Results: For the abobotulinumtoxinA group (N= 141) a mean (SD)/median
(min-max) dose of 665 U (280)/500 U (150-1500) was injected, for the onabotulinumtoxinA group (N= 37) a mean (SD)/median dose of 183 U (99)/200 U (50-500)
was injected and for incobotulinumtoxinA (N= 15), a mean (SD)/median dose of
PMS28
The Costs of Diagnosis and Treatment of Ankle Sprains and
Fractures, 1980-2013: A Systematic Review
Bielska I A , Wang X , Johnson A P
Queen’s University, Kingston, ON, Canada
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Ankle sprains and fractures are common injuries affecting many
individuals, often requiring substantial and costly medical interventions. Ankle
injuries can have significant physical and economic consequences. Therefore, the
objectives of this study were to systematically review and describe the literature
on the direct and indirect costs related to the diagnosis and treatment of ankle
sprains and fractures. Methods: A systematic literature review of Ovid MEDLINE,
EMBASE, Cochrane DSR, ACP Journal Club, AMED, Ovid Healthstar, and CINAHL was
conducted for English-language studies on ankle sprains and fractures published
from January 1980 to December 2013. Two reviewers assessed the articles for study
quality using available giudelines and abstracted the data. Results: Overall, 1,415
studies were identified of which 16 were selected for analysis. A majority of the
studies were published in the last decade. The costs of ankle sprain diagnosis and
management ranged from $495 to $4,667 per patient (2014 USD). The costs of stable
ankle fracture diagnosis and management ranged from $89 to $602 per patient.
However, the management costs were higher for unstable ankle fractures ($2,680
to $15,095) and open fractures and varied depending on the severity of injury. The
economic evaluations were conducted from the societal or health care system perspective. Conclusions: The costs of diagnosing and treating ankle sprains and
fractures varied among the studies mostly due to differences in injury severity
and the study characteristics. Future studies undertaking economic evaluations
should follow the available guidelines and ensure that their methods are transparent and understandable especially the study perspective and the valuation of the
costs and outcomes.
PMS29
The Pension Costs of Musculoskeletal Diseases. Estimation of the
Economic Burden Borne by the Italian Social Security System
Russo S 1, Mariani T T 2, Migliorini R 2, Marcellusi A 1, Mennini F S 3
1University of Rome “Tor Vergata”, Rome, Italy, 2Istituto Nazionale della Previdenza Sociale, Rome,
Italy, 3University of Rome “Tor Vergata”, Italy, Rome, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The aim of the study is to estimate the pension costs (social security system in Italy is financed by public expenditure) induced by patients with
musculoskeletal disorders (MD) and specifically for rheumatoid arthritis (RA),
ankylosing spondylitis (AS) and psoriatic arthritis (PsA) in Italy, between 2009 and
2012. Methods: We analysed the database of National Institute of Social Security
(INPS) to estimate for MD, RA, AS and PsA, the total costs of for three types of
social security benefits: disability benefits (for people with reduced work ability),
disability pensions (for people who are not eligible to be considered as workers)
and incapacity pensions (for people without work ability). Also was estimated the
productivity loss for RA in the 2013 with data from the National Institute of Statistics
and from national literature review. Results: From 2009 to 2012 were paid about
320 thousand benefits at a cost of approximately € 1.7 billion, for an average of just
over 80,000 performances a year with a cost of € 432 million per year. Specifically
the total pension burden for RA was about € 99 million, for AS was € 26 million and
for PsA was € 12 million. The loss of productivity for AR in 2013 amounted to €
707,425,191 due to 162,360 workers with RA that determine 9,174,221 working days
A378
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
lost. Conclusions: The most important indirect costs in Italy from 2009 to 2012
was represented by disability benefits (69% of the total indirect cost), followed by
disability pensions (28% of cost) and incapacity pensions (3% of cost). A better prescription appropriateness and rapid access to innovative treatments (Italy, among
the EU Countries, is the one with the greatest delay in access) would reduce the
costs incurred by the social security system accompanied by an improvement on
the effectiveness of interventions.
PMS30
Systematic Review of Societal Cost of Illness Evidence in Patients
With Psoriatic Arthritis
King D 1, Mitchell S A 1, Keyzor I 2, Kiri S 2
International, Bicester, UK, 2Novartis Pharmaceuticals UK Limited, Camberley, UK
.
.
.
.
.
1Abacus
Objectives: Societal cost evidence relating to patients with psoriatic arthritis (PsA)
is required to understand the overall economic impact of the disease. The objective
of this research was to systematically review the published data relating to the societal burden of PsA. Methods: Embase, Medline, and Cochrane databases (accessed
November 2013) were interrogated. Studies reporting on non-health sector costs or
work disability associated with PsA were eligible for inclusion with no geographical
restriction. Results: In total, 19 studies met eligibility criteria of the review; nine
studies reported indirect costs associated with PsA and 11 studies reported PsArelated work disability. Studies were conducted across Europe, USA, Canada, and
Asia. Methodology used to calculate indirect cost estimates differed among studies;
seven studies defined indirect costs as costs associated with productivity loss only,
and two studies adopted a wider definition whereby indirect costs included productivity loss and out-of-pocket costs expenses (e. g. transportation, informal care, and
home aids). Annual indirect cost associated with PsA, calculated using the human
capital or friction capital approach, ranged from € 1,261 (Spain) to € 7,919 (Germany),
with the majority of studies (71%) reporting annual indirect costs of less than €4,000
per person. Considerable heterogeneity was reported, with indirect costs of € 74,009
over a two year period estimated in Norway, compared with 6-month costs of € 576
in Italy. Indirect costs accounted for between 38% and 72% of total costs. Work
disability estimates ranged from 5% to 39%. Disease severity, age, and gender were
reported as main drivers of indirect costs and work disability. Conclusions: Cost
associated with productivity loss represented the majority of indirect costs associated with PsA. Comparison of studies is confounded by heterogeneity between
studies. Further research into the societal costs associated with patients with PsA
in the UK is required as no studies reporting UK specific costs were identified.
PMS31
Systematic Review of Societal Cost of Illness Evidence in Patients
With Ankylosing Spondylitis
King D 1, Mitchell S A 1, Keyzor I 2, Kiri S 2
International, Bicester, UK, 2Novartis Pharmaceuticals UK Limited, Camberley, UK
.
.
.
.
.
1Abacus
Objectives: Ankylosing spondylitis (AS), one of the most common spondyloarthritides, is a chronic condition with a significant impact on patient quality of life
(QoL), particularly physical functioning. The objective of this research was to systematically review published data relating to the societal burden of AS. Methods:
Embase, Medline, and Cochrane databases (accessed November 2013) were interrogated. Studies reporting on non-health sector costs or work disability associated with
AS were eligible for inclusion. Results: In total, 42 studies met eligibility criteria; 19
studies reported indirect costs associated with AS and 23 studies reported AS-related
work disability. Studies were conducted across Europe, Africa, North America, and
Asia. All studies defined indirect costs as costs associated with productivity loss.
Annual indirect costs, calculated using the human capital approach, ranged from €595
(Belgium) to €9,837 (Germany). Friction costs calculated ranged from € 428 (France) to
€6,843 (Spain). Considerable heterogeneity was reported, with 2-year indirect costs
of €66,907 estimated in Norway. Despite heterogeneity between studies, 75% of publications reported indirect costs of less than € 4,500 per patient/year, representing
between 34% and 74% of total costs. Non-medical costs such as informal care, and
transportation ranged from $65 (US) to $3,663 (US), indicating that loss of productivity
was the main driver of indirect costs. Estimates of work disability varied greatly across
studies primarily due to heterogeneous populations and the lack of standardised
questionnaires. The work disability of AS was multifactorial with regression analyses
identifying several factors associated with both indirect costs and disability including demographic factors, disease and job characteristics. Conclusions: Although
reported indirect costs and work disability estimates varied between studies, findings
from this systematic review indicate that AS represents a substantial burden both on
society and individuals with AS. A lack of UK-based data illustrates the challenge of
incorporating societal costs into future UK reimbursement submissions.
PMS32
Determination Of The Annual Health Insurance Cost Of Outpatient
Care Physiotherapy Services For Low Back Pain
3.83% prevalence. The 20 most frequent treatments accounts for 82.12 % (1016057) of
total services. The following top-10 medical procedure were responsible for 58,05%
(718.276) of total activities: 1) Ultrasound therapy 118806 (9.60%), 2) Iontophoresis
100788 (8.15%), 3) Passive movement 80424 (6.50%), 4) Mid-frequency treatment
77434 (6.26%), 5) Muscle strengthening exercises 62049 (5.02%), 6) Hand Massage
62026 (5.01%), 7) Ergo therapy 60462 (4.89%), 8) Spinal Mobilization 57609 (4.66%),
9) Diadynamic interference management 54092 (4.37%), 10) Training for circulation improvement 44586 (3.60%). Physiotherapy out-patient care for Low Back Pain
patients were 1.23 million cases with 294 million Hungarian Forint (0.96 million
Euro) health insurance subsidy. Conclusions: The list of the 20 most frequent
types of services reflects to the demand for the combination of active and passive
exercises in Hungary. In case of capacity planning for diagnostic and therapeutic
procedures, these findings should be considered.
PMS33
Cost of Treating Hip Fractures With Cephalomedullary Nails: A
Retrospective Claims Database Review
Menzie A M 1, Daskiran M 2, Abbott T A III2
and Johnson, Boston, MA, USA, 2Johnson & Johnson, New Brunswick, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
.
1Johnson
Objectives: The number of hip fracture hospitalizations in the U. S. was approximately 352,000 in 2011 and expected to rise. The consequences of hip fractures are
significant regarding the associated negative impacts on functioning and quality of
life. Intertrochanteric hip fractures are frequently stabilized surgically using cephalomedullary nails (CM). Complications may include post-operative femoral-shaft
fracture, mechanical complications, and delayed/non-union, requiring reoperations
that increase risk to the patient and cost to the health care system. Methods: A
retrospective analysis of the Premier research database was conducted. Patients
diagnosed with open and/or closed intertrochanteric fractures (ICD-9-CM codes
820.2x or 820.3x) and treated for Hip Fracture (MS-DRG 480-482) from 1-JAN-2008
through 30-JUN-2012 were included in the study. Among this population, patients
treated with IM were identified using standard charge descriptions within orthopedic-implant hardware charges. To identify patients who had a reoperation, patientlevel admission records starting from index admission up to 12-months post-index
procedure were investigated within the same MS-DRG classifications. Results:
Overall, 73,745 patients qualified for the study (71% female; 74% ≥ 75-years-old).
Of these, 32,175 (44%) were treated using CM. The average hospital cost of the
index procedure was $15,798USD per patient (inclusive of fixed and variable costs),
of which the average cost of the orthopedic nails was $1,704USD. Among these
patients, a total of 419 (1.3%) patients were readmitted at 427 occasions within the
12-month study period. The mean hospital cost of treating these readmissions was
$16,352USD, and the primary diagnoses codes for these readmissions included femoral fractures, nonunions, and device/mechanical complications. Conclusions:
Although the incidence of readmission following a hip fracture is low, the economic burden placed on the health care system and the humanistic burden are
both significant. The incidence rate and long-term sequelae for hip fractures are
well documented in the literature; however, the mean costs to a hospital have not
yet been published.
PMS34
Cost Related to the Waiting List of Patients With Vertebral
Malformation
Gresz M 1, Varga S 2, Boncföldi K 3, Boncz I 4
Institute for Quality- and Organizational Development in Healthcare and Medicines,
Budapest, Hungary, 2University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary, 3Semmelweis University, Budapest,
4
Hungary, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary
.
.
.
.
1National
Objectives: The Hungarian health budget does not allow all candidates to be
promptly operated on with vertebral malformation. The budget is enough for
approximately 4000 stabilizations by implant. The rest have to be put on the waiting list. The aim of our study is to analyse the costs related to the patients being on
waiting list for surgery of vertebral malformation. Methods: Data derived from
the nationwide financial database of the Hungarian National Health Insurance Fund
Administration. 71 patients on waiting list of an institute in 2005-2006 were studied.
We analysed the average waiting time and the costs related to patients either operated on or without operation. Results: The average age of all candidates was 55
year and the average waiting time was 32 months. The treatment cost during the
waiting time was US$ 103 per month per patient. The average age of candidates
operated on was 57 years and their average waiting time was 15 months with a costs
of US$ 155 per month per patients. The average age of candidates not operated on
was 54 years and their average waiting time was 15 months with a cost of US$ 92
per month per patient. Conclusions: Half of candidates have not been operated
on, because at the appointed date they postponed the operation. But they seem not
to really want to be operated on. The reason could be they were not sure enough to
be able to get job after the operation at their age.
Járomi M 1, Hanzel A 1, Endrei D 1, Zemplényi A 1, Csákvári T 2, Danku N 1, Boncz I 3, Molics B 1
of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary, 2University of Pécs, Zalaegerszeg, Hungary, 3Faculty of Health
Sciences, University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary
PMS35
Treating to the Target of Das28 < 2.6 in Rheumatoid Arthritis: the
Impact of Efficacy on Cost Effectiveness
Objectives: The aim of our study is to assess amount and frequency of the physiotherapy services in Low Back Pain disease and determine the total health insurance
reimbursement. Methods: Data were derived from the countrywide database of
Hungarian Health Insurance Administration (HHIA), based on official reports of
outpatient care institutes in 2009. The total numbers of different physiotherapy
services were determined by selecting the reported specific diagnoses codes and
counting the number treatments provided for that specific diagnosis code. The different types of treatment codes are listed in the chapter of the Guidelines of HHIA
for `Physiotherapists, massage-therapists, conductors and other physiotherapy
practices`. The Low Back Pain was reported according to WHO ICD diagnosis code
M5450. Results: Low Back Pain account for 1237263 cases in the annual number
of the physiotherapy-related activities (32318413 cases) showing an approximately
Alemao E 1, Johal S 2, Al M J 3, Rutten-van Mölken M 3
Squibb, Princeton, NJ, USA, 2Parexel International, London, UK, 3Erasmus
University, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1University
.
.
.
.
.
1Bristol-Myers
Objectives: Target measures such as DAS-28 < 2.6 are the goal of treatment in
rheumatoid arthritis (RA). In general, DAS-28< 2.6 is associated with improved functionality and reduced resource use but with higher treatment costs. This study
evaluated whether treatment strategies that were more effective but more expensive in achieving DAS-28< 2.6 in moderate to severe RA patients were cost effective
(CE). Methods: A micro-simulation model of 10,000 RA patients was developed
that estimated lifetime Health Assessment Questionnaire (HAQ) progression, quality
adjusted life years (QALYs) and direct costs from a UK NHS perspective. The model
incorporated an initial response criterion of achieving a DAS-28 < 2.6 at 6 months
A379
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
after initiating treatment that triggered treatment switching to subsequent therapies upon failure. Scenario 1 compared a treatment sequence of a high efficacy
biologic therapy followed by conventional DMARD therapy versus a less efficacious
biologic therapy followed by a cDMARD. Scenario 2 compared two multiple biologic
treatment sequences with a difference in efficacy between the first biologic in each
sequence. A sensitivity analysis and a CE efficiency frontier analysis examined the
effect of varying the difference in DAS-28 < 2.6 rates (Δ Rem) between first-line
therapies. Results: In scenario 1, a Δ Rem of 10% between the bDMARDs yielded
a mean per-patient gain of 0.117 QALYs and a mean per-patient increase in total
cost £2,590, giving an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of £22,112 per
QALY. In scenario 2, the higher efficacy bDMARD strategy had an ICER of £6,720
when Δ Rem = 10%. Conclusions: Over a lifetime, treating to the target of DAS28< 2.6 with more efficacious therapies in RA patients was cost-effective at various
levels of efficacy differences. The higher costs of longer term treatment were offset
by the increased quality of life for patients with DAS-28 < 2.6 as well as reduced
hospitalisation costs.
PMS36
Cost-Effectiveness Of Routine Testing For Hla-B*5801 In Caucasian
Patients Newly Diagnosed With Gout In Portuguese Nhs Hospitals
Araújo M 1, Pinto C G 2
1Faculty of Pharmacy - University of Coimbra, Coimbra, Portugal, 2Research Centre on the
Portuguese Economy – CISEP, ULisboa, Lisboa, Portugal
.
.
.
Objectives: Routine testing for HLA-B*5801 in European patients has been proposed before allopurinol treatment aiming to reduce the incidence of StevensJohnson syndrome/toxic epidermal necrolysis (SJS/TEN). Having some discretion
in the allocation of financial resources, Portuguese NHS hospitals may be particularly interested in this issue as extra costs with the treatment of SJS/TEN episodes
may be avoided. This study aims to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of HLA-B*5801
genotyping versus no genotyping (usual care) in Portuguese adult patients newly
diagnosed with gout before allopurinol treatment. Methods: A decision tree model
was constructed to structure the sequences of clinical events that may occur after
the diagnosis of the disease, over a period of three months. Effectiveness data were
estimated for Portuguese patients based on published literature and Portuguese
population databases. All costs were obtained from official prices published for
the Portuguese NHS. Admitting that NHS hospitals objective is to lower costs in the
treatment of gout, the incremental cost per SJS/TEN reaction avoided was the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) considered. One way sensitivity analysis was
performed for each relevant parameter. Results: The use of HLA-B*5801 genotyping versus no genotyping was associated with a decrease of 1.24 SJS/TEN reactions
and an incremental total cost of 42, 401.03€ , resulting in an ICER of 34, 194.38€ per
SJS/TEN reaction avoided. Sensitivity analysis results showed that base-case results
are very sensitive to variations in the baseline odds ratio of gene-disease association, epidemiological data used to estimate the incidence of SJS/TEN and genotyping cost. Conclusions: Widespread use of HLA-B*5801 genotyping in Portuguese
hospitals is not cost-effective at the current unit price of 45.30€ as it leads to a
substantial increase in expenditure compared to usual care. However, it may be an
advantageous option if its maximum price would equal 6,37€ .
PMS37
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Tocilizumab VersUS Infliximab for
the Patients With Rheumatoid Arthritis in Kazakhstan
Bektur C 1, Kayir F 2, Nurgozhin T 1
University, The Center for Life Sciences, Astana, Kazakhstan, 2Nazarbayev
University, Astana, Kazakhstan
.
.
.
1Nazarbayev
Objectives: The purpose of present study was to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of
tocilizumab (TCZ) vs. infliximab (IFX) for the treatment of patients with rheumatoid
arthritis (RA) from the perspective of Ministry of Health (MoH) over a patient lifetime
horizon in Kazakhstan. Methods: A decision analytic model was constructed in
MS-Excel to estimate effects and directs costs of methotrexate (MTX) combination
with TCZ or IFX in hypothetical cohorts of RA patients. Treatment efficacy and
transition probabilities were synthesized through a meta-analysis of data from
relevant clinical trials and literature. The characteristics of patient cohort and treatment costs (drug, monitoring, RA-related hospitalisation, adverse effects management) in year 2014 Kazakhstani tenge (KZT) were estimated from republican official
sources. Primary efficacy outcome was defined as an improvement of 70% in ACR
response (ACR70), which can be regarded as a close measure of remission. Annual
3% discounting rate and 6-month cycles were utilized for the model. Robustness of
the model parameters was explored by one-way and probabilistic sensitivity analysis. Results: For an average 70-kg patient, discounted direct costs per year were
estimated at 4 456 000 KZT for TCZ+MTX and 3 190 000 KZT for IFX+MTX. Adjusted
ACR70 rates were higher in TCZ+MTX group (23%) than in IFX+MTX group (17%). As
a result of a lifetime stimulation (average 12 years) of the model, TCZ incurred 1.89
times higher costs, and 1.67 times more achievements of ACR70 than IFX. The ICER
was estimated to be 3 218 900 KZT per achieved ACR70, which is within the costeffectiveness threshold values recommended by WHO. Overall, model was sensitive
to the changes in drug costs and patient weight. Conclusions: TCZ+MTX incurred
significantly higher costs compared to IFX+MTX, although ICER per achieved ACR70
lays within the recommendations of WHO. Further research is necessary for other
ACR rates. These findings may better inform decision makers regarding formulary
inclusion and reimbursement in the treatment of RA patients in Kazakhstan.
PMS38
Cost-Effectiveness of Certolizumab Pegol in the Treatment
of Active Rheumatoid Arthritis, Axial Spondyloarthritis, and
Psoriatic Arthritis In Romania
Codreanu C 1, Mogosanu C 1, Joita M 2, Purcaru O 3
1Rheumatology, Dr. Ion Stoia Rheumatic Disease Center, Bucharest, Romania, 2UCB Pharma,
Bucharest, Romania, 3UCB Pharma, Brussels, Belgium
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of certolizumab pegol (CZP) versus
other subcutaneous (SC) anti-tumour necrosis factors (anti-TNFs) currently licensed
and reimbursed in Romania (etanercept [ETA] and adalimumab [ADA]) in the treatment of adult patients with active rheumatoid arthritis (RA), axial spondyloarthritis (axSpA; comprising ankylosing spondylitis [AS] and non-radiographic axSpA
[nr-axSpA]) and psoriatic arthritis (PsA). Methods: Cost-utility models (Markov
structure) were developed for each condition, following the EULAR, ASAS and NICE
guidelines. Clinical efficacy data, disease history and resource use data came from
published literature. Utilities were derived from EQ-5D data assessed in CZP pivotal clinical trials. Published 2013 unit costs were taken from local sources/expert
opinion. A willingness-to-pay threshold of 3xGDP/capita (87600RON) was considered. Base-case analysis was conducted from the payer perspective, with lifetime
horizon, costs and outcomes discounting rates of 3.5%. Sensitivity analyses were
conducted to test the robustness of the results. Results: In AS, CZP dominates
ADA and ETA (quality-adjusted life years [QALYs] gain of 0,098 and 0,021; total costs
lower by 48499.73RON and 8350.28RON, vs ADA and ETA respectively). In nr-axSpA,
CZP dominates ADA (QALYs gain of 0,257; total costs lower by 13955.14RON). In RA,
CZP dominates ADA (QALY gain of 0,226; total costs lower by 108694RON) and is
marginally as effective, but slightly more costly vs ETA (QALYs gain of 0,056, total
costs higher by 6356RON). In PsA, CZP dominates ADA (QALY gain of 0.05; total
costs lower by 9397RON) and is less costly, but marginally less effective versus ETA
(QALYs difference of -0.08, total costs lower by 21484RON). Probabilistic sensitivity
analysis indicated that CZP has a similar or higher probability of being cost-effective
when compared to comparators. Conclusions: CZP is a cost-effective treatment
compared to currently available SC anti-TNFs for the treatment of RA, axSpA and
PsA in Romania.
PMS39
Estimating the Cost-Effective Intervention Thresholds for
Osteoporotic Fractures Based on Frax® in the Greek Setting
Athanasakis K 1, Makras P 2, Boubouchairopoulou N 1, Rizou S 3, Kyriopoulos J 1, Lyritis G 3
1National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece, 2251 Hellenic Air Force General Hospital,
Athens, Greece, 3Hellenic Osteoporosis Foundation, Athens, Greece
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Osteoporosis is a condition consisting in reduced bone mass and
density, thus resulting in an increased risk of fragility fractures. Considering the
aforementioned, and in conjunction with the complications that osteoporosis
engenders, a considerable economic burden is imposed on industrialized countries. The purpose of this study was to determine the thresholds at which treatment initiation becomes cost-effective in Greece, using the fracture risk assessment
algorithm (FRAX®) developed by WHO and recently adjusted for Greece. Methods:
A previously developed state transition Markov model was populated employing
epidemiological and economic data from Greece. The analysis calculated the costeffective intervention thresholds using the Greek FRAX® model, which estimates
the 10-year probability of a major osteoporotic fracture in subjects with a fracture
risk equivalent to that of a woman with a prior fragility fracture and no other risk
fracture. The analysis was undertaken from a third-party payer perspective, assuming a willingness to pay of 30,000€ per QALY gained. Results: In Greece, the drug
intervention aiming at reducing the fracture risk, was found to be cost-effective
with a 10-year probability for a major osteoporotic fracture at/or above 12.3% (range:
7.8%-20.4%) for women and 18.2% (range: 9.6%-34.2%) for men aged from 50 to 59
years old. When considering women and men aged between 60 and 74 years, the
threshold was estimated ≥ 8.9% (range: 8.5%-9.2%) and ≥ 9.4% respectively (range:
8.9%-10.0%), whereas for women and men over 75 years old, the cost-effective
thresholds were calculated to be ≥ 15.0% (range: 13.0% to 16.0%) and ≥ 11.0% (range:
10.6%-11.2%) accordingly. Significant age-variations were generally not noticed,
some exceptions apart, especially for the age-range of 50-55. Conclusions: As
expected, the cost-effective thresholds obtained via FRAX® were age-dependent in
both sexes. Therefore, considering these thresholds should lead to cost-effective
access to therapy of patients with high fracture probability, and ipso facto significantly reduce the economic burden of osteoporotic fractures in Greece.
PMS40
Cost-Effectiveness of Celecoxib and Non Selective Non Steroidal
Anti-Inflammatory Drug (Nsaid) Therapy for the Treatment of
Osteoarthritis in Spain: A Decision-Tree Model
De Lossada Juste A 1, Rejas Gutiérrez J 2, Oteo Álvaro Á 3
1Pfizer, S.L.U, Alcobendas/Madrid, Spain, 2Pfizer S.L.U., Alcobendas/Madrid, Spain, 3Hospital
General Universitario Gregorio Marañón, Madrid, Spain
.
.
.
Objectives: Treat Osteoarthritis (OA) with traditional non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (t-NSAIDs) may be associated with significant gastrointestinal (GI) and
cardiovascular (CV) events. The objective was to assess the cost-effectiveness (CE)
of Celecoxib and non selective non steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs therapy for
the treatment of OA in clinical practice in Spain. Methods: The CE was assessed
in patients aged 55+ years with OA and was based on a retrospective decision-tree
model using distribution, dose and duration of therapies and incidence of GI and
CV events observed in the pragmatic PROBE-designed 6-month “GI Reasons” trial.
Effectiveness was expressed in terms of event averted and quality-adjusted lifeyears (QALYs) gained. Utility loss in case of adverse events both in values and time
duration were derived from the published literature. Perspective of the analysis
was that of the National Health System (NHS) in Spain; cost calculations included
actual prices of drugs plus cost of adverse events occurred during trial only. The
analysis was expressed as an incremental CE ratio (ICER) per QALY gained and per
event averted. Probabilistic and univariate sensitivity analyses, including celecoxibprice-threshold analysis, were carried out. Results: Data from 7,939 patients were
included in the analysis. Compared with traditional NSAIDs, celecoxib treatment
had higher drug costs than traditional NSAIDs (€ 119 vs. € 34), and the overall treatment cost was estimated at € 201 and € 157, respectively. Moreover, celecoxib was
associated with slightly increase in QALY gain and significant lower incidence of
gastrointestinal events (p< 0.001) with mean ICERs of € 13,286 per QALY gained and
A380
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
€ 4,471 per event averted. Probabilistic and univariate sensitivity analyses were
robust and confirmed results of the base case scenario. Conclusions: This economic evaluation modeling suggests that celecoxib may be considered as a costeffective alternative vs. t-NSAIDs in the treatment of osteoarthritis in daily practice
in the Spanish NHS.
PMS41
The Cost-Effectiveness of Biologic Dmards in Patients With Severe
or Mild-To-Severe Rheumatoid Arthritis After Conventional
Dmards
Wailoo A J 1, Stevenson M 2, Tosh J 2, Hernández M 2, Stevens J W 2, Archer R 2, Simpson E 2,
everson Hock E 2, Scott D 3, Young A 4, Paisley S 5, Williams K 5
1NICE Decision Support Uni, Sheffield, UK, 2University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK, 3KCL, London,
UK, 4adam. young@nhs. net, Heertford, UK, 5The University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate the cost-effectiveness of biologic disease modifying antirheumatic drugs (bDMARDs) following failure of conventional disease modifying
anti-rheumatic drugs (cDMARDs) in patients with severe or mild-to-severe active
rheumatoid arthritis from a UK, NHS perspective, as part of an ongoing National
Institute of Health and Care Excellence (NICE) appraisal. Methods: Systematic
review of clinical effectiveness of seven bDMARDs: abatacept; adalimumab; certolizumab pegol; etanercept; golimumab; infliximab; and tocilizumab. Network
meta-analyses (NMA) of randomised controlled trials (RCTs) reporting European
League Against Rheumatism (EULAR) response and for RCTs reporting American
College of Rheumatology (ACR) outcome data. An individual patient model was
constructed to estimate costs and outcomes in terms of quality adjusted life years
(QALY). Large observational databases, published literature and the results of the
NMAs were used to provide data for the model. Following failure of two cDMARDs
two broad strategies were evaluated i) a bDMARD, followed by, if necessary, rituximab then tocilizumab then cDMARDs and ii) remaining on cDMARDs. Results:
The estimated incremental costs per QALY of bDMARD strategies compared with
a cDMARD alone strategy were typically over £50,000 regardless of the severity
of rheumatoid arthritis or whether the EULAR or the ACR RCTs were used. The
cost per QALY is greater for those who receive bDMARD monotherapy. One key
parameter affecting the results was the estimated trajectory of HAQ progression whilst a patient received cDMARDs; using rates previously assumed in NICE
appraisals reduced estimates to approximately £30,000. Conclusions: bDMARDs
are unlikely to be as cost-effective as has been estimated previously. The costs
per QALYs generated within our base case analyses are greater than commonly
reported cost-effective thresholds in England and Wales.
PMS42
A Cost-Effectiveness Analysis for Total Knee Arthroplasty
Telerehabilitation: Proof of Concept of A Decision Model
Fusco F 1, Turchetti G 2
1Scuola Superiore Sant’Anna, Pisa, Italy, 2Scuola Superiore Sant’Anna, Pisa, Italy
.
(BMD) testing with dual energy x-ray absorptiometry (DXA) and received five years
alendronate therapy if the percent young adult mean (%YAM) for BMD was less
than 70%. Lifelong drug therapy for secondary fracture prevention was assumed
for patients who had a osteoporotic fracture. For the base-case analysis, we ran
the model with different age groups (65-69, 70-74, and 75-79 years). Results:
In the women aged 65-69 years, screening strategy incurred an additional lifetime cost of $1,486 per person and conferred an additional 0.029 QALY, resulting
in an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio of $51,195per QALY gained. For those
aged 70-74 and 75-79 years, ICER was estimated to be $23,375 and $17,742per
QALY, respectively. Probabilistic sensitivity analysis showed that in women aged
65-69,70-74 and 75-79 years, screening strategy was cost-effective in 48.9%, 58.9%,
and 59.7% of the simulations, respectively, if society is willing to pay $50,000 per
QALY. Conclusions: Osteoporosis screening and treatment strategy would be
cost-effective in the Japanese women aged ≥70 years.
PMS44
Cost-Effectiveness of Use of Barricaid® In Lumbar Discectomy
Surgery in Turkey
Tatar M 1, Senturk A 2, Dalgali Y 3
University, Ankara, Turkey, 2Polar Polar Health Economics & Policy, Ankara, Turkey,
3Intrinsic Therapeutics, Inc., Wouburn, MA, USA
.
.
.
1Hacettepe
Objectives: While widely perceived as a successful procedure, discectomy surgery
has a high failure rate over time. The overall risk of recurrent disc herniation varies
between 2-18% in reported literature. The Barricaid® anular closure device was
designed as an adjunct to lumbar limited microdiscectomy to block large anular
defects while maintaining as much native nucleus within the disc space. Patients
that are considered for anular closure have a minimum posterior disc height of
5mm, and an intra-operatively measured anular defect between 5mm and 12mm
wide. The aim of this study was determined as to assess the cost effectiveness of the
use of Barricaid® in this group of patients in Turkey. Methods: A simple decision
analysis model was used to assess the cost effectiveness of the use of Barricaid®.
The primary clinical endpoint was determined as the number of prevented reherniations. According to the literature, the use of Barricaid® reduced the number of
reherniations by 18%. Resource utilization data were obtained via expert clinical
opinion and included pre-op, post-op and follow-up costs, etc. Unit costs were taken
from the Social Security Institution’s official price list. Results were presented as
incremental cost/number of prevented reherniations. The comparison was made
between using and not using the Barricaid®. Results: According to the results of
the cost effectiveness analysis, the incremental number of prevented reherniation
was 4.398 with Barricaid® and incremental cost was 119.343.000 TL. The ICER was
within the limits of the threshold recommended by the World Health Organization
with 27.136 TL. Conclusions: Use of Barriciad® in lumbar discectomy surgery is
a cost-effective treatment option in Turkey.
.
PMS45
Pharmacoeconomic Evaluation of Treatment With Tocilizumab in
Russian Children With Systemic Juvenile Idiopathic Arthritis
Objectives: The study aims to assess the cost-effectiveness of telerehabilitation
for Total Knee Arthroplasty (TKA) patients in Italy. TKA was performed 64,936
times in Italy in 2012, reasonably leading to the same number of rehabilitation
processes. The most recent cost analysis showed rehabilitation to account for Euro
158 million per year. Therefore, new strategies aiming at optimizing resources
and preserve patients’ wellbeing are claimed. Methods: A four-state Markov
model (successful TKA; revision; successful revision; death) forecasted costs
and clinical outcome over 10 years (cycle length: 1 year) for 1,000 individuals
undergoing usual care rehabilitation (UC) or a mixed UC-telerehabilitation (UC-T)
program. Published literature provided transition probabilities and clinical outcome (active knee flexion Range Of Motion-ROM); while UC and telerehabilitation
costs were estimated through Italian tariffs and panel of experts. Each surgery
was assumed to lead to rehabilitation or telerehabilitation, resulting in direct
medical and indirect costs (human capital approach). Results were adjusted
applying half-cycle correction method and discount rate of 3%. A Probabilistic
Sensitivity Analysis described parameters uncertainty and results were reported
using Incremental Cost-Effectiveness Ratios (ICER) from societal and Italian-NHS
perspectives. Results: Expected mean health care costs for UC were 1,253.2€ /
patient over ten years, and UC-T costs were on average 33.7€ /patient higher (95%CI
€ 10.8). ROM-degrees for UC and UC-T were respectively 24.5 and 26.8 (mean difference= 2.3, 95%CI 0.002). The resulting ICER was 14.5€ /ROM-degree (ItalianNHS perspective). Adopting a societal perspective, UC-T was more effective yet
appeared cheaper than UC (respectively 1,429 and 1,457€ /patient, mean difference -28/patient (95% CI € 10.8)). Conclusions: Although the preliminary results
have shown that UC-T could be a cost-saving procedure if societal perspective is
adopted; these findings are uncertain due to the model assumptions. Therefore,
further investigations with patient-level data and generic outcome measures
(e. g. QALY) are required to draw definitive conclusions about cost-effectiveness
in telerehabilitation.
Objectives: To evaluate the use of tocilizumab in Russian patients with systemic
juvenile idiopathic arthritis (SJIA) in terms of cost-effectiveness and impact on
social and economic burden of the disease. Methods: The model was based on
TENDER clinical study (De Benedetti F et al., 2012). First, a pharmacoeconomical
cost-efficiency of tocilizumab and a standard basic therapy of SJIA were compared. The analysis included direct medical costs in two comparable groups (1st
with routine administration of methotrexate and prednisolone, and 2nd with
tocilizumab prescribed in case of refractoriness to NSAID and glucocorticosteroids). The efficacy of therapies was evaluated according to ACR criteria. After that,
the influence of tocilizumab on cost and burden of illness was assessed. The
analysis included direct medical costs and government expenditures on hospitalization, work incapacity insurance, monthly social pensions, benefits for care
for a disabled children below 18 y. o. and GDP losses. 12-week time horizon was
adopted in the CEA model, and a 1-year horizon for the assessment of burden
of illness. Results: The cost-effectiveness in terms of ACR 90 and 70 was 4 428
262.96 and 2 952 175.31 RUB for the group of standard treatment, and 1 166 111.66
and 615 218.74 RUB for tocilizumab group. Tocilizumab demonstrated the same
benefits in terms of ACR 50, 30. Analysis of burden of illness revealed a different
structure of financial expenditures in considered strategies: pharmacotherapy
constituted > 50% costs in tocilizumab group, but hospitalization costs were 12
times less than in standard therapy. Annual budget losses due to social burden of
this disease were 426 144.63 RUB per patient in the group of standard treatment
and 226 729.10 RUB in tocilizumab group. Conclusions: The use of tocilizumab
in SJIA is justified by better cost efficiency and reduced of social and economic
losses of state budget connected with the burden of the disease.
PMS43
Health Economic Evaluation of Osteoporosis Screening and
Treatment Strategy in the Elderly Japanese Women
PMS46
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Etanercept in the Treatment of
Rheumatoid Arthritis In Portugal
Yoshimura M 1, Moriwaki K 2, Noto S 3, Takiguchi T 3
1Graduate School of Health and Welfare, Niigata Universitiy of Health and Welfare, Niigata, Japan,
2Kobe Pharmaceutical University, Kobe, Japan, 3Niigata University of Health and Welfare, Niigata,
Japan
Mateus C 1, Moura A 2
1Escola Nacional de Saúde Pública, Universidade Nova de Lisboa, Lisbon, Portugal, 2Escola
Nacional de Saúde Pública, Universidade Nova de Lisboa, Lisboa, Portugal
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The objective of this study was to estimate the cost-effectiveness of
osteoporosis screening and treatment with alendronate in the Japanese women
aged ≥65 years without a fragility fracture history. Methods: A Markov model
with ten health states (no event, seven types of post-fracture, bedridden, and
death) was developed to predict lifetime costs and quality-adjusted life years
(QALY) of screening and treatment strategy, comparing with no screening. In the
screening arm, 1,000 hypothetical cohort experienced a bone mineral density
Ryazhenov V V , Gorokhova S G , Emchenko IV
I.M. Sechenov First Moscow State Medical University, Moscow, Russia
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The present study aims to estimate the cost-effectiveness of etanercept compared to golimumab in the treatment of patients with Rheumatoid
Arthritis (RA) in Portugal. Methods: A model was adapted to assess the costeffectiveness of etanercept in the treatment of RA. We performed a comparison
of the combination of etanercept + methotrexate and golimumab + methotrexate.
Dosage of etanercept was 50mg on a weekly basis, whereas for golimumab it was
50 mg once a month. The model is an individual simulation model and takes
a lifetime perspective. Outcomes are expressed in QALYs, using the HAQ score
A381
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
to measure quality of life. The clinical parameters used in the model take into
account the results from a MTC of clinical trials. In order to adapt the model to
the Portuguese context, several adjustments were made to its original version.
These mainly relate to mortality rates by gender and to the unit costs of medical
resources, such as drugs, medical visits, admissions, ancillary tests and so on,
that were obtained from public official sources. We applied a 5% discount rate and
conducted an analysis for a hypothetical cohort of 1,000 patients. Results: The
treatment of RA with etanercept is more expensive than that with the comparator.
Nevertheless, QALYs gained do compensate for the additional costs. Overall, ICER
is € 12,853, which is below the usual willingness to pay threshold used in Portugal.
A sensitivity analysis was carried out, which confirmed the robustness of these
results. Conclusions: According to our analysis, etanercept is a cost-effective
alternative versus golimumab for the treatment of rheumatoid arthritis. Its main
advantage over the selected comparator relates to the associated improvements
in health related quality of life.
PMS47
The Impact of Disease Modification on the Cost-Effectiveness of
Pegloticase for the Treatment of Severe Debilitating Chronic
Tophaceous Gout In Adult Patients
Wallerstein K 1, Tolley K 2, Vegter S 3
1Access Partnership, Horsham, PA, USA, 2Tolley Health Economics Ltd., Buxton, Derbyshire, UK,
3Vegter Health Economic Research, Amersfoort, The Netherlands
.
.
.
Objectives: To determine the cost-effectiveness of pegloticase (Krystexxa®) for
patients with severe debilitating chronic tophaceous gout (SDCTG), from a UK health
care perspective. Methods: Severe debilitating chronic tophaceous gout (SDCTG)
is a debilitating disease, with high unmet medical need. Existing treatments mainly
provide symptom relief and do not modify the disease course. Pegloticase has the
potential to be a disease modifying agent. A decision analytical model was built to
compare the use of pegloticase in patients with SDCTG with best supportive care
(BSC) with a Markov model used to extrapolate outcomes to a 20 year time-horizon.
In the basecase, the disease modifying properties of pegloticase were modelled.
In scenario analyses only symptomatic relief of pegloticase on acute attacks and
tophi was included. Results: In the basecase, the cost-effectiveness of pegloticase compared to BSC was £31,027 per QALY gained. In this basecase, pegloticase
dramatically reduced the uric acid burden in over 60% of patients who completed a
six month course and were assumed could then be controlled on xanthine oxidase
inhibitor maintenance treatment. In a pessimistic scenario whereby pegloticase was
assumed to only provide symptomatic relief, the ICER was £48,672/QALY gained. In a
further scenario whereby utility benefits were limited to only short-term reduction
in acute flares and presence of tophi, the ICER was £54,345/QALY. Apart from these
two drivers, the cost-effectiveness estimates were relatively stable across a range
of sensitivity analyses. Conclusions: In the context of a highly severe and debilitating form of gout, with small patient numbers and a lack of alternative effective
treatment options, pegloticase can be considered good value-for-money. Further
clinical evidence is required to demonstrate the disease modifying properties of
pegloticase. However, such data collection and hence the ability to perform robust
economic evaluations for HTA purposes is difficult especially when the sponsoring
company is small with limited funds.
PMS48
Comparison of Diagnostic Strategies to Detect Prevalent Vertebral
Fracture for Adults Over Age 50: Use of Vertebral Fracture
Assessment or Spine Radiography
Oh S H 1, Lee Y E 1, Kim D Y 2, Lee J H 3, Kim D 2, Hwang J S 4, Bae S C 2, Ahn J H 1, Sung Y K 2
1National Evidence-based Healthcare Collaborating Agency, Seoul, South Korea, 2Hanyang
University Hospital for Rheumatic Diseases, Seoul, South Korea, 3Inje University Ilsan paik
Hospital, Seoul, South Korea, 4National Evidence-based Healthcare Collaborating Agency (NECA),
Seoul, South Korea
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of dualmobility cups (MBH) when used instead of conventional cups (FBH) to help reduce
dislocation rates following total hip replacement (THR) in France. Methods: A
Markov model simulated two cohorts of patients: one with MBH and one with FBH.
Three different states of health were considered: “stable”, “dislocation/revision” and
“death”. The model adopted a collective perspective and the time horizon of the
model was lifetime. Dislocation/revision rates were estimated using two different
sources: literature review and expert opinions (analysis 1) and analysis of the PMSI
(French hospital database) of Patients having one THR in 2009 followed through the
end of 2012 (analysis 2). Costs considered were hospitalization costs (reduction/
revision for dislocation performed in acute care unit and care in rehabilitation
units), valued using the National Scale Costs with Common methodology (ENCC).
Outpatients’ costs were considered for patients going back home after hospitalization and valued by expert opinions and literature data. The model estimated the
number of dislocations/revisions for each cohort and differences between the two
groups in terms of QALY gained, costs and cost-effectiveness ratio. Deterministic
and probabilistic sensitivity analyses (PSA) were conducted. Results: In analysis
1 for a 100,000 THR cohort, 4,626 dislocations and 1,243 revisions were avoided.
Total number of QALY gained was 894 and total economic gain € 44.7 million. In
analysis 2, 3, 176 dislocations and 854 revisions were avoided for an economic gain
of € 30.7 million and a gain of 611 QALY. Reported to 100,000 THR, the economic gain
per MBH cup was € 447 or € 307. PSA estimated the mean ICER to € -55,693 per QALY
gained. Conclusions: Because of the current rules of tariffs used in France and
given the absence of additional costs associated with the use of DM prosthesis, this
strategy can be considered dominant in THR.
PMS50
Cost-Effectiveness of Multiple Anti-Osteoporotic Therapies for
Secondary Fracture Prevention in Japan
Moriwaki K 1, Yoshimura M 2, Izumi R 3, Noto S 3
Pharmaceutical University, Kobe, Japan, 2Graduate School of Health and Welfare, Niigata
Universitiy of Health and Welfare, Niigata, Japan, 3Niigata University of Health and Welfare,
Niigata, Japan
.
.
.
.
1Kobe
Objectives: The purpose of this study was to estimate the cost-effectiveness of
multiple anti-osteoporotic drug therapies for secondary prevention of fractures in
elderly women with osteoporosis in Japan. Methods: A state transition model
with nine health states (seven types of post-fracture, bedridden, and death) was
developed to predict lifetime costs and quality-adjusted life years (QALY) of no antiosteoporotic therapy and eight drug therapies in patients with a previous vertebral
fracture. Incidence of hip, vertebral, and other fracture associated with age and
bone mineral density (BMD) was estimated by using a regression approach based
on epidemiologic studies in Japan. Comparative effectiveness of anti-osteoporotic drug therapies was derived from a published network meta-analysis. For the
base-case analysis, we ran the model with T-score of -2.5 and different age (65, 70,
and 75 years). Probabilistic sensitivity analysis was performed to assess parameter uncertainty. Results: Alendronate therapy dominated all other strategies,
resulting in 11.746 QALY and lifetime costs of $34,568. Compared to no preventive
therapy, alendronate conferred an additional 0.458 QALY and saved lifetime costs of
$13,753. Risedronate was equally cost-effective, resulting in 11.731 QALY and costs
of $34,932. Applying a willingness to pay threshold of $50,000 per QALY, the probability of being cost-effective were estimated to 76.2 % and 23.8% for alendronate
and risedronate, respectively. These results did not change in women aged 70 and 75
years. Conclusions: Bisphosphonate therapies for secondary prevention of fractures in elderly women would be cost-effective in terms of Japan health care system.
.
PMS51
Pharmacoeconomic Analysis Tofacitinib Use in Rheumatoid
Arthritis Treatment Scheme
Kulikov A , Komarov I
First Moscow State Medical University named after I.M. Sechenov, Moscow, Russia
.
.
Objectives: The prevalent vertebral fracture (VF) is a risk factor for future VF, which
can be decreased with drug therapy. However, most VFs are not recognized clinically.
Vertebral fracture assessment (VFA) by dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry (DXA) and
spine x-ray can be performed to detect these prevalent VFs. This study aimed to
estimate the costs, effectiveness, and radiation exposure of VF diagnostic strategies. Methods: Markov model over a 10-year period was used to calculate the
medical costs for diagnostic tests and VF treatment, the reduction of incident VFs
of patients who have experienced a VF, and the radiation doses in target population
aged over 50. We compared three strategies: ‘VFA followed by confirmatory radiography (VFA screening)’, ‘only VFA’ and ‘only x-ray’ every 2 years, to ‘no screening
before recognition’. We assumed that all patients tested positive for VF received drug
therapy. A discount rate of 5% was applied in cost. Results: The results showed the
incremental costs for women over age 50 who had VFA screening, only VFA, and only
x-ray were $1,112, $1,546, and $1,270 per person, respectively. Future VF incidence
was reduced by 29% in both VFA screening and only VFA and 35% in only x-ray as
compared with no screening for 10 years. Radiation exposure was highest in the
only x-ray strategy. Also, the effectiveness and medical costs were more increased
in female and old age people than in male and over age 50. The sensitivity analyses
showed that these results are robust to variety assumptions including cycle length,
medical costs, and diagnostic accuracy. Conclusions: This study suggests that
VFA screening strategy can be relevant option for new VF prevention as considering
lower cost and less radiation. This study is expected to provide useful information
as establishing the VF diagnostic strategy in clinical practice.
Objectives: Evaluate most rationale medical technology in the rheumatoid
arthritis therapy (RA) (comparison of alternatives – GEBDs Tofacitinib and biologics: Infliximab, Abatacept, Certolizumab pegol, Golimumab, Adalimumab and
Tocilizumab) from pharmacoeconomic analysis point of view. Methods: Analysis
based on the assessment for one statistically average patient suffering from RA,
and weighing 70 kilograms, over a one year course of treatment (52 weeks). The
analysis done of direct costs included: cost of DMARDs and biologics therapy use;
costs of drug introduction; physician visits cost. Cost-minimization and missed
opportunities analysis were used. Results: During the effectiveness analysis
of RA treatment, based on the meta-analyses of randomized placebo-controlled
trials data (including meta-analyses P. Kawalec, 2013; E. Salgado, 2013), Russian
and international RA treatment recommendations, it was concluded that there
was no statistically significant difference in efficacy and toxicity of the Tofacitinib
and the biologics used in the RA treatment. One year treatment course with
Tofacitinib, Infliximab, Abatacept, Golimumab, Certolizumab pegol, Adalimumab
and Tocilizumab cost, include subcutaneous route of administration, will amount
to 12.818 EUR, 20.932 EUR, 14.855 EUR, 18.104 EUR, 19.642 EUR, 20.120 EUR and 21.664
EUR, respectively. Conclusions: During pharmacoeconomic analysis was defined
that therapy with Tofacitinib in comparison with biologics use will reduce the cost
of a one year course of treatment for each RA patient from 2.037 EUR to 8.846 EUR.
Transition of 100 RA patients onto a treatment regimen, includes Tofacitinib use,
will make it possible to treat from 15 to 69 patients more suffering from this disease.
PMS49
Cost-Effectiveness Model of Dual-Mobility Cups for Total Hip
Replacement in France
PMS52
Rehabilitation In Resurfacing Hip Arthroplasty Patients:
Preliminary Cost-Effectiveness Results From A Clinical Trial
Epinette J A 1, Robert J 2, Rodriguez J 3, Lafuma A 2
1Clinique Medico-Chirurgicale, Bruay-Labuissière, France, 2Cemka-Eval, Bourg la Reine, France,
3Stryker, PUSIGNAN, France
Fusco F 1, Campbell H 2, Newman M 3, Barker K 2
1Scuola Superiore Sant’Anna, Pisa, Italy, 2University of Oxford, Oxford, UK, 3University of Oxford,
Oxford, UK., UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A382
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: A tailored accelerated physiotherapy (AP) program following
Resurfacing Hip Arthroplasty (RHA) has been shown to be effective in improving hip
function and range of motion in young male patients; however no evidence has been
provided on its cost-effectiveness. The aim of this UK trial-based economic evaluation was to assess the cost-effectiveness of AP versus a standard rehabilitation
protocol (SRP). Methods: Trial participants were randomized post-RHA to AP or
SRP. The experimental arm followed an 8-week programme with no hip precautions,
full-weight bearing from day one, tailored exercises and an additional physiotherapy
session. The control group received the standard 8-week course of rehabilitation. At
6, 16, and 52 weeks, patients reported primary and secondary health care contacts,
use of equipment, and private health care contacts. These data were valued using
2012/2013 national average unit costs. The 3-level EuroQol EQ-5D questionnaire was
completed by patients at baseline, 6, 16 and 52 weeks and used to calculate Quality
Adjusted Life Years (QALYs) to 12 months. Results: 80 young males (median age:
55.8 years) were randomized to AP (n= 40) or SRP (n= 40). Preliminary results showed
mean (SE) health care costs to 52 weeks were £375 (£76) in the AP arm and £612 (£150)
in the SRP arm (mean (95% CI) difference -£237 (-£582 to £108)). There were more
visits to secondary care and primary care practitioners in the SRP arm. Mean (SE)
QALYs were 0.84 (0.02) with AP and 0.72 (0.03) with SRP (mean (95% CI) difference
0.12 (0.04 to 0.21)). The probability that AP is cost-effective at a maximum willingness to pay of £20,000 per QALY is 99%. Conclusions: From the perspective of the
health care provider, a tailored accelerated physiotherapy programme for younger
male patients undergoing RHA appears cost-effective when compared to a standard
rehabilitation programme.
PMS53
Rituximab as First Choice for Patients With Refractory Rheumatoid
Arthritis: Cost-Effectiveness Analysis in Iran Based on A
Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
Ahmadiani S , Nikfar S , Karimi S , Jamshidi A R , Akbari-Sari A , Kebriaeezadeh A
Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The aim of this study is evaluation of the effectiveness and costeffectiveness of using rituximab as first line of treatment for patients with refractory rheumatoid arthritis in comparison to continuing conventional DMARDs,
from a perspective of health service governors. Methods: A systematic review
was implemented through searching PubMed, Scopus and Cochrane Library.
Quality assessment was performed by JADAD questionnaire. After meta-analysis
of ACR (American College of Rheumatology) index results, QALY (Quality Adjusted
Life Years) gained were calculated through mapping ACR index to HAQ (Health
Assessment Questionnaire) and utility index. To measure the direct and indirect
medical costs, a set of interviews with patients were applied. Thirty two patients
were selected from three referral rheumatology clinics in Tehran with definite diagnosis of refractory rheumatoid arthritis one year before, and treatment regimen of
either rituximab or DMARDs within last year. Incremental cost-effectiveness ratio
were calculated for a period of six months for base case and generic rituximab
scenario. Three fold of GDP (Gross Domestic Product) per capita was considered as
threshold of cost-effectiveness. Results: Four studies were eligible to be considered in this systematic review. Total risk difference of 0.3 for ACR20 criteria, 0.21
for ACR50 and 0.1 for ACR70 were resulted from meta-analysis. Also mean of total
medical costs of patients for 24 weeks were $3985 in rituximab group and $932 for
DMARDs group in the base case analysis. Thus, the incremental cost per QALY ratio
will be $45900 to $70223 in the base case, and $32386 to $49550 for generic scenario,
while the threshold of cost-effectiveness was $21684. Conclusions: Rituximab
cannot be considered as cost-effective for the treatment of patients with refractory
rheumatoid arthritis in Iran.
PMS54
Cost-Utility Analysis of Certolizumab Pegol Plus Methotrexate for
the Treatment of Moderate-To-Severe Active Rheumatoid Arthritis
In Greece
Tzanetakos C 1, Maniadakis N 1, Kourlaba G 2, Tzioufas A 3, Goules A 3, Theodoratou T 4,
Christou P 4
1National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece, 2Collaborative Center for Clinical Epidemiology
and Outcomes Research (CLEO), Athens, Greece, 3Athens Medical School, Athens, Greece, 4UCB
Pharma, Athens, Greece
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of certolizumab pegol (CZP) as an
add-on therapy to methotrexate (MTX) versus etanercept, adalimumab or golimumab in patients with moderate-to-severe active rheumatoid arthritis (RA) who
did not respond adequately to conventional synthetic disease-modifying anti-rheumatic drugs (csDMARDs) including MTX in Greece. Methods: A Markov model
with a cycle length of 6 months was used to assess cost and health outcomes of
CZP versus other TNF-α inhibitors recommended in Greece over a patient’s lifetime.
On the discontinuation of first-line treatment with CZP or comparator, patients
were switched to a second anti-TNF agent, and after failing that, they moved on to
a third biologic agent with another mode of action. A sequential use of csDMARDs
was assigned after the last biologic therapy. Clinical data and utility values were
extracted from published literature. The analysis was conducted from a third-party
payer perspective in Greece. Costs related to drug acquisition, administration, monitoring and patient management were considered (2014). All results were presented
as incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICERs) per quality-adjusted life year (QALY).
Probabilistic sensitivity analysis (PSA) was performed to ascertain the robustness of
the base-case findings. Results: The base-case analysis indicated that compared
with etanercept+MTX, CZP+MTX was cost-effective (ICER: €3,177/QALY), and versus
adalimumab or golimumab, CZP was the dominant strategy (less costly and more
effective). For all comparisons, CZP treatment resulted in greater improvements in
life expectancy and QALYs. PSA indicated that at the willingness-to-pay threshold
of € 34,000 per QALY gained, CZP+MTX was associated with a 71.6%, 97.9% or 99.2%
probability of being cost-effective versus etanercept, golimumab or adalimumab as
combination therapies with MTX, respectively. Conclusions: This analysis shows
that CZP+MTX seems to be a cost-effective alternative when compared to approved
subcutaneous anti-TNFs for the management of RA in Greece.
PMS55
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Strontium Ranelate VersUS
Alendronate for Management of Osteoporosis Among PostMenopausal Women in Malaysia Using A Markov Modelling
Approach
Wu D B C 1, Hussain S 2, Mak V 1, Lee K K C 1
University Malaysia, Selangor, Malaysia, 2University of Malaya, Kuala Lumpur,
Malaysia
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Monash
Objectives: Osteoporotic fractures are common in older adults and are often associated with high morbidity and mortality. As the incidence increases with age, it
is natural that osteoporotic fractures have become a major health problem worldwide. Increasing number of patients with osteoporotic fracture will have a serious
economic impact on the patient themselves and the society. The objective of
this study is to study the cost-effectiveness of strontium ranelate compared
to alendronate for patients with post-menopausal osteoporotic fractures in
Malaysia. Methods: A Markov model was developed to project clinical and economic benefits of strontium in a hypothetical cohort of patients (N= 1,000) over a
5-year time horizon. This study was conducted from a payer perspective. Model
parameters including transition probabilities and costs of treating fracture at various sites were Malaysia-specific. Drug costs were obtained from a public teaching hospital in Kuala Lumpur. Utilities were derived from previous literatures and
efficacy data were derived from two pivotal trials, i. e. SOTI and TROPOS trials.
Outcomes were presented as cost per quality-adjusted life year (QALY) gained. A
discount rate of 3% was applied. Both 1-way and multivariate probabilistic sensitivity analyses were undertaken to evaluate robustness of results. Results:
Compared to alendronate, strontium could prevent 328 wrist, 192 hip, 7 vertebra
and 115 multiple fractures respectively over 5 years, which was translated into
27.9 QALYs gained. Using strontium can lead to cost reduction of MYR1,416,595
(USD442,685), MYR478,257 (USD149,455), MYR22,784 (USD7,120) and MYR61,883
(USD113,088) due to reduced episodes of fractures at wrist/hip/vertebra/multiple sites respectively. The total reduction of direct medical costs of MYR2,279,519
(USD712,349) was larger than the extra drug cost, hence making strontium a costsaving therapy. Conclusions: It was shown that strontium appeared to be more
cost-effective compared to alendronate and hence should be recommended in the
public sector in Malaysia.
PMS56
Mabthera® (Rituximab) for the Treatment of Severe Granulomatosis
With Polyangiitis (Gpa) and Microscopic Polyangiitis (Mpa) – A CostUtility Model for the United Kingdom
Harland D 1, Naisbett-Groet B 1, Chang S 2, Sungher D K 3, Sawyer L 2, Diamantopoulos A 4
Products Limited, Welwyn Garden City, UK, 2Symmetron Limited, Herts, UK, 3Symmetron
Limited, Elstree, UK, 4Symmetron Limited, Borehamwood, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Roche
Objectives: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of MabThera in patients with severe
GPA and MPA in the United Kingdom (UK). Background: In March 2014 NICE
issued positive guidance for the use of MabThera in patients with severe GPA and
MPA [TA 308]. Methods: An economic model was developed to reflect the health
care system and the current treatment pathway in the UK. The cost-effectiveness
analysis employs a Markov model with four health states: complete remission,
non- remission, uncontrolled disease and death. Patients were assumed to start in
the non-remission health state, transitioning based on their response to treatment.
Relapsing patients who have exhausted all available treatment options they are
assumed to enter the uncontrolled disease health state where they remain until
death. The efficacy data for the intervention and comparator arm were taken from
the RAVE study (Stone et al 2010) which demonstrated that MabThera was noninferior to cyclophosphamide (CYC). In a subgroup of patients who had received
prior therapy, MabThera was superior to CYC. Benefits were expressed as QALYs.
Costs were calculated from a National Health Service and Personal Social Services
perspective. The analysis calculated incremental costs and benefits associated with
the addition of MabThera to the treatment paradigm which was assumed to consist
of CYC and azathioprine. For patients intolerant to CYC, MabThera was assumed to
substitute for CYC. The RAVE trial reports health related quality of life using SF-36.
The SF-36 scores were converted to EQ-5D in a post-hoc analysis using a published
model [Ara and Brazier 2008]. Results: Base case results estimated incremental
costs of approximately £3,700 and incremental QALYs of 0.306. The incremental
cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) was £12,100 per QALY gained. Conclusions: The
results of this analysis suggest that MabThera is a cost-effective treatment for severe
GPA and MPA.
PMS57
Work Productivity Loss Due To Rheumatoid Arthtiris (Ra), Crohn’s
Disease (Cd) And Psoriasis (Ps) In Poland
Wladysiuk M , Bebrysz M , Fedyna M , Haldas M , Rutkowski J
HTA Consulting, Krakow, Poland
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess the indirect costs of RA, CD and Ps in an employed population
in Poland. Methods: Data on presenteeism and absenteeism related with analyzed
diagnoses were collected in a cross-sectional study from patients of ambulatory
specialist care around Poland (30 rheumatology, 30 dermatology and 29 gastroenterology centers). Lost productivity was measured with Work Productivity and Activity
Impairment (WPAI) questionnaire and patients’ disease activity was assessed on
standardized, disease specific scales (DAS28, PASI, and CDAI). 328 (RA), 460 (Ps), 256
(CD) working patients were included in the analyses conducted separately for each
diagnosis. Unit cost of lost productivity was estimated using 2012 GDP per worker
per hour corrected for diminishing marginal productivity and added up to PLN
33.18. Results: Mean age of M2W respondents was 36 for CD, 42 for Ps and 46 for
RA patients (only patients in productive age – 18-60/65 were included in the study).
A383
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Ps patients had dominantly (54%) low disease activity, in RA group mostly (51%) the
moderate activity was observed, while the most frequent disease activity category
for CD patients was remission (39%). Mean annual cost of overall work impairment
(presenteeism and absenteeism cost together) amounted to PLN 29 727 for RA, PLN
24 434 for Ps and PLN 23 682 for CD. Cost of loss of productivity due to RA ranged
from PLN 15 069 for patients in remission to PLN 41 296 for highly active disease. For
Ps it was respectively PLN 13 846 and PLN 44 009 and for CD PLN 15 543 and PLN 63
771. Conclusions: Productivity loss among workers with CD, Ps and RA generates
significant costs for society which rises with disease activity.
PMS58
Long-Term Work Productivity Costs Among Subjects With Early
Rheumatoid Arthritis - A Nationwide Analysis Based on 7,831
Subjects’ Sickness Absence Days and Income
Martikainen J A 1, Krol M 2, Rantalaiho V 3, Kautiainen H 4, Puolakka K 5
of Eastern Finland, Kuopio, Finland, 2Erasmus University, Rotterdam, The Netherlands,
3Tampere University Hospital, Tampere, Finland, 4Helsinki University Central Hospital, Helsinki,
Finland, 5Lappeenranta Central Hospital, Lappeenranta, Finland
.
.
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: To estimate the long-term productivity costs (PC) and their determinants
associated with absenteeism and permanent work disability (WD) in Finnish patients
with early rheumatoid arthritis (RA) available to workforce at baseline. Methods:
A cohort of subjects with early RA was created by identifying the new cases of RA
from the national register of the Social Insurance Institution (SII) in Finland, who
were granted a special reimbursement of anti-rheumatic medications for rheumatoid
factor positive (ICD-10 code: M05) or negative RA (M06) in 2000 – 2007. The obtained
dataset was enriched by cross-linking with the national databases about the subjects’ annual incomes, WD days, and permanent disability pensions. The human
capital approach was applied to estimate PC based on subjects’ the annual number of
absenteeism days and incomes. The PC were estimated and expressed as per patientobservation year. Hurdle regression analysis was applied to study the determinants
of PC. Sensitivity analyses were conducted to test the robustness of the obtained
results. Results: The study cohort comprised 7,831 subjects with early RA in paid
jobs. The mean age (SD) of subjects was 46 years (11) and 71 % were women. Mean
(bootstrapped 95%CI) annual PC per patient-observation year was 4,574€ (95% CI
4,469€ to 4,680€). The PC increased progressively over the years. The use of methotrexate-based combination therapies during the first three months after RA diagnosis
reduced significantly the cumulative PC during the follow-up. Conclusions: So
far the majority of the productivity cost studies have been based on cross-sectional
data. However, the results of the present study provide unique evidence about the
longitudinal economic burden of RA over the course of disease. The results highlight
the need for treatment strategies with predefined targets and tight control of disease
activity in the early course of disease to reduce the long-term burden of RA.
PMS59
Characterizing Work Productivity Loss In Incident Rheumatoid
Arthritis In Sweden
Banefelt J 1, Gustavsson A 1, Borgström F 1, Alemao E 2
Research, Stockholm, Sweden, 2Bristol-Myers Squibb, Princeton, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
1Quantify
Objectives: To study the trends in work productivity loss pre- and post-diagnosis
of incident rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and compare it to patients with osteoarthritis
(OA) undergoing knee or hip replacement surgery. Methods: Retrospective register
study conducted using Swedish national registers. Patients of working age with an
incident diagnosis of RA between 2003 and 2009 were identified in the National
Patient Register (n= 14900). OA patients undergoing surgery were identified during
the same period and considered as a reference group (n= 34240). Monthly productivity loss twelve months pre-diagnosis to twelve months post-diagnosis was evaluated
in the base case. Productivity loss was defined as the sum of net sick leave days and
net disability pension days as recorded in the Social Insurance Register. Results:
Monthly productivity loss gradually increased during the months leading up to RA
diagnosis, peaking the month after diagnosis (mean 14.7 days/month). The same
pattern was observed in the OA group in relation to time of surgery, although the
increase in productivity loss the months post-surgery was considerably larger than
the corresponding increase in the RA patients, peaking the second month following
surgery (28.5 days/month). Twelve months post-surgery, the OA patients returned
to levels of productivity loss similar to those seen six months pre-surgery (12.3
days/month vs. 12.7 days/month, respectively). This reversal was not mirrored by
the RA patients, who stabilized at an elevated level of productivity loss post- compared to pre-diagnosis levels (12.1 days/month vs. 9.6 days/month). Conclusions:
This study illustrates the unmet needs in RA. The partial reversal in work ability
post-diagnosis, in contrast to the almost complete reversal seen in OA patients
post-surgery, highlights the need for improved treatment options in RA; while the
gradual loss of work ability leading up to diagnosis highlights the need for intervention earlier in the disease process.
PMS60
A Comparison of the Impact of Rheumatic Diseases and Other
Chronic Diseases on Early Retirement in Portugal
Laires P A 1, Canhão H 2, Gouveia M 3
Portuguesa de Reumatologia, Lisbon, Portugal, 2Faculdade de Medicina, Universidade
de Lisboa, Lisboa, Portugal, 3Católica Lisbon School of Business and Economics, Lisbon, Portugal
.
.
.
individual level by logistic regression. Results: At the time of the survey, 19.5%
of the Portuguese population with ages between 50 and 64 years old were officially
retired. A larger average number of major chronic diseases per capita was found
among those with early retirement when compared to active workers in the same
range of age (2.0 vs. 1.4 p<0.001). RD were particularly prevalent among early retirees
when compared with employees (43.3% vs. 32.1%, p< 0.001). The following OR and
PAF (adjusted by age, sex and region and unadjusted) were obtained: RD (OR:1.31.4; PAF:7.3-9.7), chronic pain (OR:1.4-1.4; PAF:6.6-7.2), hypertension [OR:1 (NS)
-1.3; PAF:1.1-7.1], diabetes [OR:1 (NS) -1.2 (NS); PAF:0-2.4], renal impairment (OR:3.3
-3.4; PAF:2.7-3.2), respiratory diseases (OR:1.5-1.7; PAF:1.5-2.1), stroke (OR:3.2-3.6;
PAF:2.6-3.2), myocardial infarction [OR:1.2 (NS) -1.9; PAF:0.3-1.1], cancer (OR:2.11.9; PAF:2.1-2.1), depression (OR:1.5-1.2 (NS); PAF:4.8-2.8) and anxiety (OR:1.6-1.5;
PAF:3.7-3.5) with NS standing for not statically significant. Conclusions: From a
public health angle, PAF is a good measure of the importance of a risk factor, taking
into account both the strength of the association with the outcome and its prevalence in the population. Among all major chronic diseases, RD had the highest PAF
estimates for early retirement in Portugal.
PMS61
Cost of Pharmacotherapy in Polish Patients With Rheumatoid
Arthritis
Szafraniec-Burylo S 1, Orlewska E 2
Institute of Public Health - National Institute of Hygiene, Warsaw, Poland, 2Jan
Kochanowski University, Kielce, Poland
.
.
1National
Objectives: To assess cost of pharmacotherapy in Polish patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) in relation to disease activity (DAS28-CRP) and disability
(HAQ-DI). Methods: Data on drug consumption was collected during a prospective one center cohort observational study of non-selected RA patients discharged
from tertiary academic hospital. At enrollment patients were divided according
to DAS28-CRP and HAQ-DI. Observational period was 6 months. Spearman rang
correlation coefficient and test of its significance were used to investigate the relationship of cost of pharmacotherapy with disease activity and disability. Mean total
cost of drugs and mean cost of drugs covered by public payer were calculated in
PLN at 2014 prices (1 EURO= 4.2 PLN in 2014). Results: DAS28-CRP was ≤ 5.1 in 124
patients (group A) and > 5.1 in 83 patients (group B). HAQ-DI was > 2 in 51 patients
(group I), > 1 and ≤ 2 in 88 patients (group II), ≤ 1 in 66 patients (group III). Mean cost
of pharmacotherapy per patient was 1010 PLN in group A and 858 PLN in group B,
1078 PLN in group 1, 981 PLN in group II and 745 in group III. The differences between
groups were not statistically significant. Public payer covers only 36-40% of the drugs
cost. Conclusions: These results represent the current use of drugs in the population of Polish RA patients under real-life conditions and indicate that there is no
impact of disease activity and disability on the cost of pharmacotherapy due to RA.
PMS62
Organizational and Management Impact Analysis of Using the
New Subcutaneous Formulation of Tocilizumab in Selected Italian
Rheumatology Centers
Ravera S 1, Tomic R 1, Adami S 2, Viapiana O 2, Paolini D 1, Bianchino L 1, Canciani M 3,
Farina M 3, Ciancio G 4, Govoni M 4
1Roche S.p.A., Monza, Italy, 2University of Verona, Verona, Italy, 3Emmeffe S.r.l., Milano, Italy,
4Ferrara University, Ferrara, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In the light of future arrival of subcutaneous (SC) formulation of
tocilizumab for the treatment of moderate to severe active rheumatoid arthritis,
a multidimensional analysis has been performed in order to evaluate potential
impact of introducing SC formulation vs. intra-venous (IV) one from the perspective
of both patients and hospitals in Italy. Methods: The analysis was conducted in
three Italian Rheumatology centers (AO-S. Anna-Ferrara, AO-Verona, UOS-Valeggiosul-Mincio) through a questionnaire administered to clinicians and nurses. A 60
minutes day-hospital administration for IV and 20 seconds-1 minute administration
for SC selfinjector or pre-filled syringe administered at home (excluding the first
administration) were assumed. Monitoring visits were considered as 1 per month
for IV and 1 every three months for SC. Four impact areas were evaluated: patient’s
drug-administration time and costs (including transportation time and cost and loss
of productivity), drug-administration related hospital-personnel time, drug wastage
and patient risk profile evaluated through Failure Models and Effect Analysis. A one
year time horizon was considered. Results: The analysis showed that the new SC
formulation, compared to IV, could have a significant impact in terms of: patient
time saving (- 91% of the time for the administration of therapy), patient costs
(-86%), clinicians and nurses time saving measured as Full Time Equivalent (- 59%
for clinicians and -94 % for nurses), drug wastage (-100%), and patient risk profile
(-93%). Conclusions: The subcutaneous formulation of tocilizumab could have
several organizational and management impacts. From the hospital perspective it
could lead to reduction of medical resources consumption with the possibility to
re-allocate them in other medical activities. From the patient perspective the new
SC formulation could lead to time savings and costs reduction with a potential
improvement of patient quality of life.
.
1Sociedade
Objectives: Chronic diseases and in particular rheumatic diseases (RD) may lead
to early retirement, generating substantial indirect costs to society. We compare
RD to other major chronic diseases regarding their impact on the likelihood of
early retirement in the Portuguese population. Methods: The study population
consisted of all people between 50 and 64 years of age (3,762 men and 4,241 women)
who participated in the Portuguese National Health Survey, conducted in 2005/2006.
Self-reported data were collected on health, sociodemographic and occupational
factors. The effects of RD and other chronic diseases on the likelihood of early retirement and the population attributable fractions (PAF) estimates were obtained at the
Muscular-Skeletal Disorders – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient
Preference Studies
PMS63
Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Persistence With
Denosumab in Patients With Osteoporosis
Jonsson E 1, Cheng L I 2, Ström O 1, Intorcia M 3, Karlsson L 1
Research, Stockholm, Sweden, 2Amgen Inc., Thousand Oaks, CA, USA, 3Amgen (Europe)
GmbH, Zug, Switzerland
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Quantify
Objectives: Conduct a systematic review and meta-analysis of published literature on persistence with denosumab in patients with osteoporosis. Methods:
A384
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
A systematic review identified retrospective and prospective observational studies reporting 12-, 18-, or 24-month persistence with denosumab, an osteoporosis
therapy approved in 2010. Searches covered the period January 2011─May 2014 and
were conducted in the PubMed and EMBASE databases, and conference abstract
supplements from ACR, AMCP, ASBMR, WCO-IOF-ESCEO, and ISPOR. To be eligible,
studies needed to report at least one estimate of persistence with denosumab in
patients with osteoporosis, have a clear definition of persistence, and be in English
language. Using a random effects model, pooled estimates of denosumab persistence were calculated for retrospective and prospective studies separately. A
subgroup analysis was conducted based on geographical regions. Results: The
search identified 338 unique citations in PubMed and EMBASE, and 200 conference abstracts. After applying the eligibility criteria, 11 studies were included in the
final review and meta-analysis (7 retrospective; 4 prospective). All studies reported
at least one estimate of 12-month persistence; 9 studies included females only.
For retrospective studies, the pooled persistence estimates were 74.6% (95% CI:
65.4-82.9) at 12 months, 67.6% (65.2-70.0) at 18 months, and 57.2% (51.8-62.5) at 24
months. For prospective studies, the pooled estimate of 12-month persistence was
89.0% (95% CI: 84.6-92.7). In the subgroup analysis, European studies had higher
pooled 12-month persistence estimates compared with North American studies
(retrospective: 78.6% vs. 68.9%; prospective: 91.5% vs. 85.3%). Conclusions: To
our knowledge, this is the first systematic review and meta-analysis of persistence
with denosumab in patients with osteoporosis. We identified a growing body of
evidence, both prospective and retrospective, suggesting persistence to denosumab
is higher than previously reported for other OP therapies1.1. Kothawala P, et al. Mayo
Clinic. 2007; 82 (12): 1493-501.
PMS64
Persistence Rate With Subcutaneous Biologic Therapies in Patients
With Rheumatoid Arthritis (Ra)
Lyu R 1, Ding Q 2, Govoni M 3, Fan T 1
& Co., Inc, Whitehouse Station, NJ, USA, 2Temple University, Philadelphia, PA, USA,
3Merck Sharp & Dohme Limited, Rome, Italy
.
.
.
.
1Merck
Objectives: This study examined persistence over 12 months for RA patients who
were newly treated with subcutaneous biologics, and assessed if there are differences between patients with and without prior DMARDs experience. Methods:
In this retrospective cohort study using Electronic Medical Record database of IMS
Disease Analyzer-Germany, adult (≥ 18 years old) RA patients with exposure to a
subcutaneous biologic between January 1, 2009 and June 30, 2012 were identified.
The first prescription date for the subcutaneous biologic agent was defined as
their index date. Patients were excluded from the study if they were prescribed
a biologic agent during the pre-index period, and/or diagnosed with ankylosing
spondilitis, psoriatic arthritis, or other conditions treated with subcutaneous biologics either pre- or post-index. A chi-square test was used to assess significant
differences in the percentage of persistent patients between those with and without DMARD use and a logistic regression model was used to control for differences
in baseline demographic and clinical characteristics. Results: A total of 576 RA
patients without prior biologic experience met the study selection criteria; 471
were DMARD experienced and 105 were DMARD naive. The mean (SD) age of the
patients was 57 (13), with 75% being female. The majority of patients indexed
on etanercept (46%) or adalimumab (40%). Forty eight percent of the patients
persisted on their index biologic over the 12 months post-index period, with the
rate significantly higher among those with pre-index DMARD use (51% vs. 31%;
p= 0.0012). After controlling for pre-index characteristics, patients with pre-index
DMARD had 2.23 times the odds of being persistent compared to those without
pre-index DMARDs (OR: 2.23, 95% CI: 1.37-3.62). Conclusions: Approximately
half of biologic naïve RA patients were persistent over a 12-month period with
their index subcutaneous biologic, with rates significantly higher among patients
with pre-index DMARD.
PMS65
Persistence Rate With Subcutaneous Biologic Therapies in Patients
With Ankylosing Spondylitis (As)
Govoni M 1, Lyu R 2, Ding Q 3, Fan T 2
Sharp & Dohme Limited, Rome, Italy, 2Merck & Co., Inc, Whitehouse Station, NJ, USA,
3Temple University, Philadelphia, PA, USA
.
.
.
.
1Merck
Objectives: This study aimed to describe persistence with subcutaneous biologics
among biologic naïve AS patients over 12 months, and to identify differences among
patients with and without NSAID drug experience. Methods: This retrospective
study used IMS Disease Analyzer-Germany, an electronic medical records database.
Data for adult (≥ 18 years of age) AS patients with a prescription for subcutaneous
biologic between January 1, 2009 and June 30, 2012 were used for this analysis. The
index date was the date of the first subcutaneous biologic prescription. Prescription
for any biologic during the pre-index period or diagnosis for rheumatoid arthritis,
psoriatic arthritis or other conditions treated with subcutaneous biologics either
in pre- or post-index qualified patients for exclusion from the study. Differences
between pre-index NSAID naïve and experienced patients were measured using a
chi-square test. A logistic regression model was used to further assess the impact
of NSAID use on persistence, controlling for baseline characteristics. Results: The
study cohort included a total of 108 biologic naïve AS patients, 72 with use of NSAIDs
in the pre-index period. The mean age of the AS cohort was 42 years, with 70% of
patients being male. Adalimumab, etanercept, and golimumab were initiated by
61%, 28%, and 11% of patients, respectively. Persistence for at least 12 months with
the index subcutaneous biologic was observed in 46.3% of the overall cohort, with
similar results among those with and without NSAID use (47% vs 44%, respectively).
Multivariate analysis confirmed similar persistence between those with and without
pre-index NSAID (OR: 0.97; 95% CI: 0.39-2.44). Conclusions: Findings from this
German study showed that less than half of AS patients are persistent with the
index subcutaneous biologic over a 12 month period. Results were similar irrespective of prior use of NSAIDs.
PMS66
Determinants of Non-Persistence to Antiosteoporotic Drugs by
Using Administrative Database
Orlando V 1, Guerriero F 1, Monetti V M 1, Putignano D 1, Moretti A 2, Iolascon G 2, Menditto E 1
Center of Pharmacoeconomics, Naples, Italy, 2Second University of Naples, Naples, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1CIRFF-
Objectives: Osteoporosis treatment involves several therapeutic tools, including long-term drug therapy. Subjects with chronic disorders are more likely to be
non-adherent and/or non-persistent to treatment than those with other diseases.
Adherence is the extent to which patients take medication as prescribed by their
physicians, whereas persistence is the time from treatment initiation to discontinuation. Lack of persistence is common among subjects using oral anti-osteoporotic
drugs, and leads to increased risk of fragility fracture. The aim of our study is to
analyze the rates and reasons for discontinuation of anti-osteoporotic drugs in the
Campania Region. Methods: The study was a retrospective cohort study. Patients,
aged ≥ 40 years, were enrolled if at least one prescription for any antiosteoporotic
drugs had been filled from July 1, 2009 through June 30, 2010. Data were retrieved
from an administrative database of medications prescription in Campania region.
Patients were followed from the index date until the antiosteoporotic therapy discontinuation or end of the observation period (June, 30, 2011). Results: A total of
30,048 were incident users of anti-osteoporotic drugs: 1, 731 (5.8%) males and 28,317
(94.2%) females. The mean age [SD] of the cohort was 69.0 [10.0] years. Weekly bisphosphonate (51.1%), was the most commonly prescribed drug. In the overall cohort
study, persistence rates were 34, 8% after 6 months, 13, 4% at one year. A multivariate
Cox proportional hazard analysis showed that daily regimen (HR 1,9) treatments
remained at a higher risk of early discontinuation compared to weekly regimen
therapies. Patients who started treatment with a co-prescription with calcium and
vitamin D had a lower risk of early discontinuation (HR 0.7). Conclusions: Our
data showed that the persistence to osteoporosis therapy is significantly worse
than reported in literature. A better osteoporosis management should include drugs
with less frequent dosing, to obtain both an increase in rate of persistence and a
reduction in side-effect.
PMS67
Use of Medication Reminders in Patients With Rheumatoid Arthritis
Bruera S 1, Lopez-Olivo M A 2, Barbo A 2, Suarez-Almazor M E 2
College of Medicine, Houston, TX, USA, 2The University of Texas, MD Anderson Cancer
Center, Houston, TX, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Baylor
Objectives: In this study we determined the characteristics of patients with RA who
used these aids, and the association of reminder use with adherence. Methods:
201 patients with RA were included in this prospective cohort study examining
treatment adherence. At baseline patients were asked if they used any special
reminders such as pill containers, calendars, or diaries. Patients completed two selfreported adherence questionnaires: the Compliance Questionnaire Rheumatology
and the Adult AIDS Clinical Trials Group adherence questionnaire. Disease activity
measures included number of swollen joints, number of tender joints, disease activity score (DAS28), and patient global assessment. Functional status was evaluated
with the modified Health Assessment Questionnaire (MHAQ). Results: Mean age
of the patients was 51 years, 75% were female, 53% were Hispanic, 25% white, and
21% African American. Sixty-eight (34%) patients reported using a reminder: 53
(26%) used special pill containers, 12 (6%) used calendars, and 3 (1%) diaries. Factors
associated with the use of reminders were older age (p= 0.004), being white vs.
Hispanic or African American (p= 0.003), being male vs. female (p= 0.005). Working
patients were less likely to report using reminders (p= 0.006). No association was
observed between education levels and use of aids. Use of reminders was associated with domains of self-reported adherence: adherence while away from home
(r= 0.16, p= 0.03), when busy (r= 0.16, p= 0.03), and when running out of pills (r= 0.15,
p= 0.04). Conclusions: Older patients, males, and whites were more likely to use
these aids, more often pill containers. Our study shows that reminders can assist
patients with RA in taking their medications, particularly in situations when they
are most prone to forget including being away from home or busy. Use of reminders
should be encouraged by providers as a low cost aid to enhance adherence.
PMS68
Treatment Persistence With Subcutaneous Biologic Therapies in
Patients With Psoriatic Arthritis (Psa)
Lyu R 1, Ding Q 2, Govoni M 3, Fan T 1
& Co., Inc, Whitehouse Station, NJ, USA, 2Temple University, Philadelphia, PA, USA,
3Merck Sharp & Dohme Limited, Rome, Italy
.
.
.
.
1Merck
Objectives: The objective of this study was to describe persistence with subcutaneous biologic over 12 months for newly treated PsA patients and evaluate the
impact of prior DMARD use. Methods: This was a retrospective analysis using IMS
Disease Analyzer-Germany, an electronic medical records database. Adult (≥18 years
of age) PsA patients who initiated therapy with subcutaneous biologics between
January 1, 2009 and June 30, 2012 were included in the analysis. The first subcutaneous biologic prescription date served as their index date. Continuous observation
of at least 12 months pre- and post-index date was required. Patients who were
prescribed any biologic during the pre-index period or diagnosed with rheumatoid
arthritis, ankylosing spondylitis, crohn’s disease, or ulcerative colitis during the
study period were excluded from the study population. A chi-square test was used
to measure differences between patients with and without use of pre-index DMARD.
A multivariate logistic regression was created to assess the impact of DMARD use
on persistence, controlling for baseline characteristics. Results: A total of 197
biologic-naïve PsA patients were selected. Of these, 89 were free of PsO. The mean
(SD) age of the patients was 49 (11) years, with 50% being female. The majority of
patients (61%) indexed on adalimumab, while the remainder indexed on etanercept
(35%) and golimumab (4%). In the overall PsA population, the persistence rate with
the index subcutaneous biologic was 54.3%, with similar results among those with
and without DMARD use (53% vs 56%, respectively). Multivariate analysis did not
identify any significant predictors for persistence, including DMARD use (OR: 1.05;
A385
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
95% CI: 0.53-2.07) and psoriasis (OR: 1.07; 95% CI: 0.56-2.03). Conclusions: More
than half of the PsA patients were persistent with the index subcutaneous biologic
over a 12-month period with similar persistence rates observed among those with
and without psoriasis and DMARD use.
PMS69
Impact of Medication Adherence by Using Indian Version Compliance
Questionnaire Rheumatology (Cqr) and Medication Adherence
Report Scale (Mars) Tools on Quality of Life of Patients With
Rheumatoid Arthritis
Shetty R 1, Reddy K 2, Inam S 2, Khera K 1
1Manipal College of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Manipal, India, 2Manipal Univiersity, Manipal, India
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess medication adherence to DMARD in patients with
Rheumatoid Arthritis using CQR and MARS tools, identification of factors affecting
adherence and its effect on quality of life. Methods: A randomly selected sample
of 110 adult patients with RA on DMARDs admitted to hospital were asked about
their medication adherence, through self-report questionnaire [CQR and MARS] and
quality of life was assessed by HAQ (Health Assessment Questionnaire). Additionally,
various factors affecting adherence were identified. Results: According to the tools
used, 86.4% (CQR), 74.29% (MARS -mean cut point) and 95.45% (MARS -prior study
cut point) of patients showed adherence towards DMARD. Better adherence was
seen in patients with primary education (COR- 94%) or secondary education (MARS
-83%). Patients who suffered from RA for more than 2yrs showed better adherence
(CQR- 93%) compared to those with recent disease (< 2yrs) (CQR- 89%). Non adherence was seen in patients having co-morbidities compared to patients with only RA
(CQR- 91% vs 94%; MARS- 62% vs 82%). Mean HAQ of adherent patients was better
(2.83±1.05) than non-adherent patients (3.23 ± 0.74). Adherent patients showed moderately active disease state (Mean DAS – 5.96 ± 1.67) whereas, non-adherent patients
showed highly active disease state (Mean DAS – 6.70 ± 0.84). Conclusions: Patient
reported questionnaires showed disease duration of less of 2yrs, and patients with
co-morbidities lead to Non-adherence which worsened disease activity which lead
to decreased quality of life.
PMS70
Quality of Life in Psoriatic Arthritis: Consistent and Stable
Across Datasets
Hatswell A J 1, Almond C 1, Nassens D 2, Ganguly R 3, Ito T 4
1BresMed, Sheffield, UK, 2Janssen BVBA, Beerse, Belgium, 3Janssen R&D, LLC, Spring House, PA,
USA, 4Janssen-Cilag Ltd, High Wycombe, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Psoriatic arthritis (PsA) is a multi-factorial disease that affects the skin,
joints and soft tissues. Two of the commonly used measures for PsA are the Psoriasis
Area and Severity Index (PASI, 0-100 scale) and the Health Assessment Questionnaire
(HAQ, 0-3 scale) for skin and joints symptoms, respectively. Previous work in the
area has estimated a relationship between these patient-reported instruments and
utility (SF-36 mapped to the EQ-5D). The objectives of this study were to calculate
patient-reported utility and investigate the consistency of the relationship between
PASI, HAQ and utility with previously published estimates, based on the PSUMMIT
trials of ustekinumab versus placebo. Methods: Patient level data from PSUMMIT1
(anti-TNFα naïve) and PSUMMIT2 (both anti-TNFα naïve and experienced) were
analysed in Stata 11. SF-36 data were converted to EQ-5D using the mapping by
Rowen et al., with regression analysis used to estimate the relationship between
PASI, HAQ and the resulting utility (including multiplicative terms). Goodness of fit
was determined by the adjusted R2 and Root Mean Squared Error (RMSE). Results:
Anti-TNFα naïve and experienced patients had a baseline utility of 0.50 and 0.48,
respectively. Utility improved over the 24-week blinded period by 0.04/0.06 in the
placebo arms for anti-TNFα naïve and experienced, and 0.11/0.13 in the treatment
arms. In regression analysis utility was predicted as 0.897 – 0.004xPASI - 0.298xHAQ
(adjusted R2 0.60, RMSE 0.12), similar to previously published estimates. Adding a
multiplicative term for PASI and HAQ did not improve goodness of fit statistics,
although baseline methotrexate use was linked to a lower utility. Conclusions:
Patients with PsA have a low level of health-related quality of life that improves with
treatment. The determinants of utility in the PSUMMIT trials were the skin and joint
symptoms faced by patients, in keeping with previous estimates.
PMS71
Patient Preferences in the Choice of Disease Modifying
Anti-Rheumatic Drugs
Schiffner-Rohe J 1, Alten R 2, Krüger K 3, Behmer O S 4, Schiffhorst G 5, Rellecke J 5,
Nolting H D 5
1Pfizer Deutschland GmbH, Berlin, Germany, 2Schlosspark Klinik, Berlin, Germany, 3n.a., Munich,
Germany, 4Pfizer Pharma GmbH, Berlin, Germany, 5IGES Institut GmbH, Berlin, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: There is a variety of biologic and non-biologic disease modifying antirheumatic drugs (DMARDs) available for the treatment of rheumatoid arthritis (RA).
These DMARDs are associated with different characteristics in key attributes such as
mode of administration, side effects, etc. The current study assessed the importance
of treatment characteristics for RA patients’ preferences. Methods: In a discrete
choice experiment (DCE), 1570 RA patients are asked to choose the most and the
least preferred DMARD (best-worst-scaling) among hypothetical multi-attribute
treatment alternatives with varying levels of key attributes, as defined in focus
groups: mode of administration, frequency of administration, time till onset of
drug effect, necessity of combination therapy with methotrexate, and side effects.
The multi-profile case design simulates a real choice situation between different
hypothetical treatment alternatives. Interim analysis was conducted after half the
sample size had been reached. Results: Interim analysis included 836 patients
from 33 office based rheumatologists across Germany. Majority of patients were
female (74%), 50 to 64 years of age (46%), with < 10 years of disease duration (54%),
and reported experience with injectable DMARDs (63%). Mode of administration
appeared the most important attribute guiding patients’ preferences, with ‘oral
application’ being most desired (selected as best option in 51% of the cases) and
infusion being least preferred (worst option in 45% of the cases). The second most
relevant attribute was “necessity of combination therapy with methotrexate”,
with DMARDs not requiring such combination being most preferred (in 43% of the
cases). Conclusions: Our data indicate that, of the included attributes, the most
important ones are route of administration (oral being the number one choice by
majority) and combination therapy with methotrexate (with DMARDs not requiring
such combination being the most preferred) for RA patients’ choice. This research
was funded by Pfizer GmbH.
PMS72
Are Patients’ Preferences Transferable Between Countries? A CrossEuropean Discrete-Choice Experiment to Elicit Patients’ Preferences
for Osteoporosis Drug Treatment
Hiligsmann M 1, Dellaert B 2, Dirksen C 1, Van der Weijden T 3, Watson V 4, Goemaere S 5,
Reginster J Y 6, Bours S 1, Roux C 7, McGowan B 8, Silke C 8, Whelan B 8, Diez Perez A 9,
Papadakis G 10, Torres E 9, Rizzoli R 10, Cooper C 11, Pearson G 11, Boonen A1
1Maastricht University, Maastricht, The Netherlands, 2Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam,
The Netherlands, 3CAPHRI, Maastricht, The Netherlands, 4Health Economics Research Unit,
University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen, UK, 5Ghent University Hospital, Ghent, Belgium, 6University
of Liège, Liège, Belgium, 7Paris Descartes University, Paris, France, 8Our Lady’s Hospital,
Manorhamilton, Ireland, 9Hospital del Mar-IMIM and RETICEF, Barcelona, Spain, 10Geneva
University Hospitals, Geneva, Switzerland, 11University of Southampton, Southampton, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Discrete-choice experiments are increasingly used to assess preferences in health care. To date, very little is known about the transferability of
patients’ preferences between jurisdictions. In this study, we aim to evaluate the
preferences of patients with, or at risk of, osteoporosis for medication attributes
in six European countries, and to assess whether preferences are transferable
across these countries Methods: A discrete-choice experiment was conducted
using a questionnaire in Belgium, France, Ireland, Spain, Switzerland and United
Kingdom. Patients were asked to choose between two hypothetical unlabelled
drug treatments (and an opt-out option) that vary in several attributes: efficacy
in reducing the risk of fracture, type of potential common side-effects, mode
and frequency of administration and out-of-pocket costs (only in countries with
patients´ contribution on the cost of treatment). An efficient design was used to
construct the treatment option choice sets and a mixed logit model was used to
estimate patients’ preferences. Results: A total of 1,124 patients completed the
experiment, with at least 100 patients per country. As expected, in all countries,
patients preferred treatment with higher effectiveness and lower cost was preferred in the three countries in which a cost-attribute was part of the experiment.
In all countries, patients preferred 6-monthly subcutaneous injection over weekly
oral tablets. In most countries, patients also preferred monthly oral tablet and
yearly intravenous injections over weekly oral tablets. Patients disliked being at
risk of gastro-intestinal disorders more than being at risk of skin reactions and
flu-like symptoms, except in Spain. There were significant differences between
countries for some levels of attributes. Conclusions: This study suggests that
the preferences of patients for osteoporotic drug therapy did not substantially
differ between six European countries. However, for levels of some attributes,
significant differences were observed.
PMS73
Long-Term Maintenance of Improvements in Patient-Reported
Outcomes With Certolizumab Pegol in Patients With Axial
Spondyloarthritis, Including Ankylosing Spondylitis and NonRadiographic Axial Spondyloarthritis: 96-Week Results of the
Rapid-Axspa Study
Sieper J 1, Kivitz A 2, van Tubergen A 3, Deodhar A 4, Szegvari B 5, Nurminen T 6, Landewé R 7
Hospital Charité, Berlin, Germany, 2Altoona Center for Clinical Research, Duncansville,
PA, USA, 3Maastricht University Medical Center, Maastricht, The Netherlands, 4Oregon Health
and Science University, Portland, OR, USA, 5UCB Pharma, Brussels, Belgium, 6UCB Pharma,
Monheim, Germany, 7Amsterdam and Atrium Medical Center, Heerlen, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: To report the effect of certolizumab pegol (CZP), a PEGylated Fc-free
anti-TNF, on patient-reported outcomes (PROs) in axial spondyloarthritis (axSpA),
including ankylosing spondylitis (AS) and non-radiographic axSpA (nr-axSpA),
over 96 weeks (wks) of the RAPID-axSpA trial. Methods: The RAPID-axSpA trial
(NCT01087762) is double-blind and placebo-controlled to Wk24, dose-blind to
Wk48, and open-label to Wk204. Patients fulfilled ASAS criteria and had active
axSpA. Patients originally randomized to CZP (200mg Q2W or 400mg Q4W, following 400mg loading dose at Wks 0, 2, 4) continued on their assigned dose in
the dose-blind phase and OLE. Here we report PRO data for the CZP-treated randomized set, including mean change from baseline and the proportion of patients
achieving a Minimal Clinically Important Difference (MCID). Missing data were
imputed by LOCF. Correlations between clinical and patient-reported outcomes
were also investigated. Results: Of 218 patients randomized to CZP, 203 (93%)
completed Wk24, 191 (88%) Wk48, and 174 (80%) Wk96. Rapid improvements from
baseline to Wk24 were maintained to Wk96 in all patient subpopulations (overall
axSpA, AS, nr-axSpA) in pain (Wk24: -3.2, -3.2, -3.3; Wk96: -3.6, -3.6, -3.7); fatigue
(Wk24: -2.7, -2.5, -2.9; Wk96: -2.9, -2.8, -3.1); BASFI (Wk24: -2.4, -2.3, -2.4; Wk96:
-2.6, -2.6, -2.6); ASQoL (Wk24: -5.1, -4.8, -5.5; Wk96: -5.7, -5.5, -6.1) and sleep (Wk24:
-12.8, -10.5, -15.7; Wk96: -13.9, -11.6, -16.7). CZP-treated patients also maintained
improvements in SF-36 components and domains. Sustained improvements in
the proportion of patients (overall axSpA, AS, nr-axSpA) achieving MCID (%) were
observed in fatigue (Wk24: 78.4, 76.0, 81.4; Wk96: 67.0, 70.2, 62.9); BASFI (Wk24:
67.4, 68.6, 66.0; Wk96: 64.2, 68.6, 58.8) and ASQoL (Wk24: 69.3, 71.1, 67.0; Wk96: 65.6,
66.9, 63.9). Similar outcomes were seen with both dosing regimens. Correlations
were observed between improvements in PROs (pain/fatigue/SF-36) and clinical
outcomes (ASDAS) (data not shown). Conclusions: Improvements in PROs
(including pain, fatigue and ASQoL) were maintained over 96 wks in both the
AS and nr-axSpA subpopulations. Sustained improvements in the proportion of
patients achieving MCID were also reported.
A386
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PMS74
Inadequate Pain Relief Among Patients With Primary Knee
Osteoarthritis - Analysis From The Portuguese Sample Of The Survey
Of Osteoarthritis Real World Therapies (Sort)
Laires P 1, Laíns J 2, Miranda L 3, Cernadas R 4, Pereira da Silva J 5, Gomes J M 6, Peloso P M 7,
Taylor S D 7, Silva J C 8
1Merck Sharp & Dohme, Oeiras, Portugal, 2Centro de Medicina e Reabilitação da Região Centro,
Coimbra, Portugal, 3Instituto Português de Reumatologia, Lisbon, Portugal, 4ARS Norte,
Oporto, Portugal, 5Centro Hospitalar e Universitário de Coimbra, Coimbra, Portugal, 6Clínica
Reumatológica Dr. Melo Gomes, Lisbon, Portugal, 7Merck Sharp & Dohme Corp., a subsidiary of
Merck & Co., Inc., Whitehouse Station, NJ, USA, 8Hospital Garcia de Orta, Almada, Portugal
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Despite widespread treatments for Osteoarthritis (OA), data on
treatment patterns, adequacy of pain relief, and quality of life are limited. The
prospective multinational Survey of Osteoarthritis Real World Therapies (SORT)
was designed to investigate these aspects. This analysis aims to describe the clinical characteristics and the patient reported outcomes of the Portuguese dataset
of SORT baseline. Methods: The statistical analysis included, from January to
December of 2011, 192 participants ≥ 50 years or older with primary knee OA
from 7 health care centers in Portugal who were receiving oral or topic analgesics.
Inadequate Pain Relief (IPR) was defined as a score > 4/10 in item 5 of the Brief Pain
Inventory (BPI), indicating moderate to severe pain. Results: Overall, the median
age was 67.0 ± 8.7 years and 77.6% were female. Mean duration of knee OA was
6.3 ± 6.3 years. IPR was reported by 52.0% of the patients. The most prescribed
analgesics were NSAIDs (88.1%), alternative therapies, including glucosamine,
chondroitin and hyaluronate (44.3%) and paracetamol (28.6%). Patients with IPR
scored higher than non-IPR patients in WOMAC – Stiffness (61.0 vs 39.7, p< 0.001)
and WOMAC – physical function (59.2 vs 39.4, p< 0.001), meaning worse condition. Patients with IPR had worse quality of life related to knee osteoarthritis as
measured by the SF-12 questionnaire (fair/poor: 86.9% vs. 72.0%, p< 0.001). 62.0%
of patients with IPR were dissatisfied or very dissatisfied with the effects of analgesics versus 34.0% of patients with non-IPR (p< 0.05). Conclusions: Despite the
use of analgesics, over half of the Portuguese patients in SORT reported moderate
to severe knee pain. Worse outcomes were also observed in this group regarding
other symptoms of knee OA and general quality of life. These findings suggest
that if an improvement of pain management in knee OA can be achieved, it may
have high impact on patients’ lives.
PMS75
Qualitative Equivalence Between A Paper and Electronic Tablet
Version of the Womac®Nrs3.1 and Patient Global Assessment
Eremenco S 1, Fleming S 2, Riordan D 3, Stringer S 1, Gleeson S 1, Sanga P 4, Kelly K 5
1Evidera, Inc., Bethesda, MD, USA, 2Janssen Global Services, Titusville, NJ, USA, 3Janssen Research
and Development, Raritan, NJ, USA, 4Janssen Research and Development, Titusville, NJ, USA,
5Janssen Research and Development L.L.C., Titusville, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Prior equivalence work with the WOMAC® scale was published for
the VAS scale and older touchscreen computer technology. Additional equivalence
evaluation of the WOMAC®NRS3.1 and the Patient Global Assessment (PGA) in a
newer tablet with stylus was needed to document suitability of this mode of data
collection for these instruments in upcoming clinical trials. Methods: A cross-sectional qualitative study was conducted involving cognitive and usability interviews
with patients diagnosed with osteoarthritis of the hip or knee who were taking
pain medication for their condition. Interviews were conducted in two waves of 10
participants each, with revisions to the PGA made in between the rounds, which
allowed for changes to the electronic version to be evaluated. Results: Mean age
of the sample (N= 20) was 66 years, (range 43-78), 90% over 60 years old; 60% were
female; 95% were white; 75% were retired; 70% had completed secondary school or
some college, while 30% had completed college or a post-graduate degree. In wave
1, minor issues were found with completing the WOMAC®, mainly with using the
stylus to select responses and glare on the screen. There were no issues identified
in interpreting the response scale. For the PGA, 50% (5/10) used the wrong recall
period (48 hours or longer). The PGA recall period was revised from “at this time”
to “over the past 24 hours” and bolded for emphasis. In wave 2, similar issues with
glare and stylus response were found, while 80% used the correct recall period on
the PGA, with 20% using 48 hours. Conclusions: The study showed excellent
qualitative equivalence between the paper and electronic WOMAC® with only minor
usability issues. The two wave study design provided the opportunity to detect and
make changes to the PGA recall period and formatting that showed improvement
in the second wave.
PMS76
Long-Term Maintenance of Improvements in Multiple Facets of
Psoriatic Arthritis With Certolizumab Pegol: 96-Week PatientReported Outcome Results Of The Rapid-Psa Study
Gladman D 1, Fleischmann R 2, Szegvari B 3, Peterson L 4, Mease P J 5
Research Institute, Toronto, Ontario, ON, Canada, 2Metroplex Clinical Research
Center, Dallas, TX, USA, 3UCB Pharma, Brussels, Belgium, 4UCB Pharma, Raleigh, NC, USA,
5Swedish Medical Center and University of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Toronto Western
Objectives: To report the effect of certolizumab pegol (CZP), a PEGylated Fc-free
anti-TNF, on patient-reported outcomes (PROs) in psoriatic arthritis (PsA) over 96
weeks (wks) of the RAPID-PsA trial. Methods: The RAPID-PsA trial (NCT01087788)
is double-blind and placebo-controlled to Wk24, dose-blind to Wk48 and open-label
to Wk216. Patients had active PsA and had failed ≥ 1 DMARD. Patients originally randomized to CZP (200mg Q2W or 400mg Q4W, following 400mg loading dose at Wk0,
Wk2, Wk4) continued on their assigned dose in the dose-blind phase and OLE. Here
we present PRO data for the CZP-treated randomized set, including mean change
from baseline (CFB) and Minimal Clinically Important Differences (MCIDs). Data
were also analysed for CZP-randomized patients with (19.8%) or without (80.2%)
prior anti-TNF exposure. Missing data were imputed by LOCF. Correlations between
clinical outcomes and PROs were also investigated. Results: Of 273 patients
randomized to CZP at Wk0, 91% completed Wk24, 87% Wk48, and 80% Wk96. Rapid
improvements observed to Wk24 were maintained to Wk96 for pain (Wk24 and
Wk96; CFB: -28.5 and -31.3; MCID: 69.2% and 66.3%), fatigue (Wk24 and Wk96; CFB:
-2.0 and -2.4; MCID: 64.1% and 60.4%), HAQ-DI (Wk24 and Wk96; CFB: -0.48 and
-0.52; MCID: 48.7% and 48.0%), SF-36 PCS (Wk24 and Wk96; CFB: 8.01 and 9.01; MCID:
67.4% and 60.1%), SF-36 MCS (Wk24 and Wk96; CFB: 4.50 and 3.92; MCID: 50.9% and
43.6%), PsAQoL (Wk24 and Wk96; CFB: -3.87 and -4.50), and DLQI (Wk24 and Wk96;
CFB: -5.8 and -6.0; MCID: 40.7% and 41.0%). Similar improvements were observed
with both dosing regimens and in patients with or without prior anti-TNF exposure.
Correlations were observed between improvements in PROs and DAS28 (data not
shown). Conclusions: Improvements observed to Wk24 in generic and diseasespecific PROs were sustained to Wk96 of the RAPID-PsA trial for both CZP dosing
regimens.
PMS77
Usability Testing of A Novel Pain Medication Diary Administered
Electronically
Eremenco S 1, Fleming S 2, Riordan D 3, Stringer S 1, Gleeson S 1, Sanga P 4, Kelly K5
1Evidera, Inc., Bethesda, MD, USA, 2Janssen Global Services, Titusville, NJ, USA, 3Janssen Research
and Development, Raritan, NJ, USA, 4Janssen Research and Development, Titusville, NJ, USA,
5Janssen Research and Development L.L.C., Titusville, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Pain medication diaries have traditionally been collected via paper
due to challenges of patients entering unlimited medications, units, dosages, and
administration schedules. This study developed an electronic diary that permits site
staff to enter medications that patients are taking, enables the patient to update
medication taken and to enter new medications within the reporting period, and
reduces the possibility of cheating behaviors during the study. Usability of this
electronic diary was evaluated to ensure that patients in a clinical trial setting could
successfully update their diaries in real-time to accurately track pain medication
intake. Methods: A cross-sectional qualitative study was conducted involving
usability interviews with patients diagnosed with osteoarthritis of the hip or knee
who were taking pain medication. Interviews were conducted in two waves of 10
participants each, allowing for evaluation of findings and revisions to the eDiary
between waves. Results: Mean age of the sample (N= 20) was 66 years (range
43-78), 90% over 60 years old; 60% were female; 95% were white; 70% completed
secondary school or some college. In wave 1, issues were noted with training, selecting responses, exiting to send data, and some wording. For wave 2, the training
module was revised to more closely match the diary, wording was revised, and a
screen added to facilitate exiting the diary. No issues were noted with training, 4
had trouble selecting responses, and 3 suggested additional instructions on the
new screen. No additional changes were made following wave 2. Conclusions:
The study showed it is possible to develop an electronic pain medication diary
that allows patients to update their medications during a study. Extensive training
was critical to the usability of the electronic version. The two wave study design
provided the opportunity to detect and make changes to the eDiary with marked
improvement in wave 2.
PMS78
Quality of Life in Patients With Axial Spondyloarthritis in Clinical
Practice In Sweden: Baseline Results From A Longitudinal Study
Jacobsson L T 1, Husmark T 2, Theander E 3, Henriksson K 4, Johansson M 5, Büsch K 5
1Sahlgrenska Academy, University of Gothenburg, Gothenburg, Sweden, 2Falu Hospital, Falun,
Sweden, 3Lund University, Malmo, Sweden, 4Rheumatology city clinic, Stockholm, Sweden,
5AbbVie AB, Solna, Sweden
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Spondyloarthritis (SpA) is a group of diseases that share common clinical, radiographic and genetic features. Axial SpA is one major subgroup including
patients with radiographic (rad-axSpA) and non-radiographic axSpA (nr-axSpA).
There has been limited research on axSpA patients in clinical practice and the
impact of the disease on patient’s health-related quality of life (HrQoL). The aim
of this study was to characterize patients with axSpA in clinical practice and to
investigate similarities/differences between rad-axSpA and nr-axSpA with respect
to their HrQoL. Methods: This is a longitudinal, multi-center cohort study where
patients were consecutively recruited from Swedish clinical practice and followed
for 3 months. At baseline, the rheumatologists registered information on disease
history, extra articular manifestations and treatments. The patients answered
online questionnaires capturing patient demographics, disease activity, function
and HrQoL. HrQoL was measured using the EQ-5D and the Ankylosing Spondylitis
Quality of Life Questionnaire (ASQoL). While higher scores in the EQ-5D indicate better HrQoL, the opposite is true for the ASQoL. Results: 251 patients were included
of whom 197 (78%) were classified as axial SpA. Of those, 125 (63%) were classified as rad-axSpA and 72 (37%) as nr-axSpA according to the ASAS axSpA criteria.
There were more women in the nr-axSpA group (50%) compared with the rad-axSpA
group (38%). The nr-axSpA patients had a shorter time between symptom onset and
diagnosis than the rad-axSpA patients (6.7 vs. 9.0 years) and a significantly higher
disease activity (BASDAI= 4.1 vs 2.7, p< 0.001). Mean EQ-5D score at baseline was
0.66 for rad-axSpA and 0.61 for nr-axSpA, lower than the Swedish general population (0.84). ASQoL scores was significantly higher in the nr-axSpA group (8.8 vs 6.4,
p= 0.016). Conclusions: HRQoL is poorer in axial SpA patients compared to the
general population and patients with nr-axSpA reported a higher impact on HRQoL
than patients with rad-axSpA.
PMS79
Functional Status, Quality of Life And Work Disability for Patients
With Rheumatic Diseases in Greece
Athanasiadi E 1, Fragoulakis V 2, Vozikis A 2
1Medical School of Athens, Athens, Greece, 2University of Piraeus, Pireaus, Greece
.
.
.
Objectives: Rheumatic diseases (RD) have been associated with functional and
work-related disability due to the deliberating and progressive nature of these
diseases and have many deleterious consequences on patients’ life. The aim of the
A387
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
present study was to measure the functional status and quality of life in RD patients receiving
the biologic agent golimumab in Greece Methods: A descriptive study was conducted
estimating the annual Quality-of-Life (QoL) improvement for 148 patients diagnosed
with rheumatoid arthritis (RA), psoriatic arthritis (PS) and ankylosing spondylitis
(AS). QoL was estimated with standardized questionnaires such as EQ-5D and HAQ
questionnaire. In addition, twenty specific parameters including “general health”,
“severity of pain”, “productivity level” etcetera wereassessed on 10-point Likert scale.
Data was collected by doctors across the country at 3 month intervals (4 waves of
questionnaires during the year). Results: Patients with RA reported improved QoL
by 14%, followed by 0.67 decrease of average HAQ score. They also reported a 7.5 hours
gain of working hours and an overall 14% gain in productivity per week. Patients with
AS were estimated to present 30% improvement in general health condition according
to their doctors with similar self-reported estimations. Additionally, their QoL was
improved by 17%. Similarly, patients with PS estimated their QoL improved by 17%
with a 6hr/week gain in working hours otherwise missed, while the average HAQ score
fell by 0.71 Findings are in accordance with similar published studies all contributing
to the general assumption that patients receiving biological agents experience greater
QoL improvement compared to conservative treatment options. Conclusions:
Statistical analysis revealed significant improvement of functional status, quality of
life, productivity gains and decrease of disease activity for those receiving Golimumab
in Greece for all three disease groups. Amongst limitations, both number of the study
group and follow-up period should be taken into consideration.
PMS80
Quality of Life in Patients With Chronic Lumbosciatic Syndrome in
the Slovak Republic
Matisakova I 1, Kamenska E 1, Mastiliakova D 2, Melus V 1, Bielik J 2, Novak I 3, Andrasova E 3
University of Alexander Dubcek, Trencin, Slovak Republic, 2Trencin University, Trencin,
Slovak Republic, 3Novartis Slovakia, Bratislava, Slovak Republic
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Trencin
Objectives: The current prevalence of Chronic Lumbosciatic Syndrome (CLSS) in
Slovakia ranges in about 170000 cases. The CLSS has a great impact on quality
of life (QoL) and the ability to work too. Till now in Slovakia was not realised the
study like this. Methods: 86 patients with CLSS were studied. The “hospital” and
the “out-patients clinic” group had 43 vs 43 patients. The average age was 50.36 vs
51.79 y., weight – 61.04 vs 77.95 kg, duration of illness – 5.3 vs 5.0 years, symptoms
of illness before diagnosis – 2.27 vs 2.16 years. QoL and the ability to work was
evaluated on the numeric scale from 0 to 10 (0 for the worst, 10 for the best) by
patients themselves. Results: The “hospital” and the “out-patients clinic” group
had these results: the average of hospitalisation – 1.51 vs 1.44 times, incapacity to
work – 3.06 vs 2.90 months. QoL in the time of good health was 8.2 vs 8.04, in the
time of diagnosis – 5.86 vs 6.74, and in the current time – 4.58 vs 3.95. The work
ability (WA) had these results: WA in time of good health was 8.97 vs 9.04 in the
time of diagnosis – 8.16 vs 8.13, and in the current time – 3.83 vs 3.83. The impact
of the treatment on the QoL was 5.37 vs 6.06 and on the patients families QoL it
was 6.16 vs 6.13. The willingness to pay for the perfect cure was 477.90 € vs 524.41 €
per month (the average salary in Slovakia in 2013 was 824 € ). Conclusions: CLSS
has a great impact on QoL and on the WA too. There was not statistical difference
between both “hospital and out-patient clinic” patients in the QoL and WA. Early
diagnosis is important to effective treatment.
PMS81
Reasons for Treatment Discontinuation of Biologics – Development
and Validation of A Questionnaire
Meyer-Moock S 1, Schiffner-Rohe J 2, Kohlmann T 3
Greifswald, Greifswald, Germany, 2Pfizer Deutschland GmbH, Berlin,
Germany, 3University Medicine Greifswald, Greifswald, Germany
.
.
.
1Universitätsmedizin
Objectives: For patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and inadequate response
to traditional therapy, treatment with biologics is recommended to reduce disease progression and improve HRQol. Nevertheless, up to 30% of patients stop
treatment on their own initiative. Aim of the study is to develop and validate an
instrument to assess reasons for treatment discontinuation of biologics in patients
with RA. Methods: We conducted expert interviews with rheumatologists (n= 5)
to develop a questioning route, which was used in 2 focus groups with a total of
15 RA patients who dropped out therapy (phase 1). Based on these results a draft
questionnaire was developed and pre-tested (phase 2; n= 6), resulting in the pilot
questionnaire. In the validation phase (phase 3) the questionnaire is completed by
approx. 200 patients, with an interim analysis planned after recruitment of half
the sample size. Quantitative data analyses will focus on psychometric properties: missing data, floor/ceiling effects, factorial validity, distribution of properties.
Patients are recruited at 40 German office based rheumatologists, with 5 patients
per center. Results: The final questionnaire consists of 82 items covering sociodemographic aspects, HRQoL, history of treatment and disease, treatment information, expectations and satisfaction and ”reasons for discontinuation”. Piloting
showed that HRQoL, treatment and working-life aspects have impact on treatment
discontinuation. Particularly, information about treatment options, patient-doctor
relationship and financial burden were addressed. The questionnaire has proven
to be feasible in field-test. Validation phase is currently ongoing; results from the
interim analysis will be presented. Conclusions: Interviews with experts and
patients demonstrated that treatment discontinuation is triggered by multiple reasons. A targeted developed questionnaire is necessary to identify latent reasons for
treatment discontinuation. Furthermore, an “easy-to-use” questionnaire could be
used in daily routine to identify patients likely to withdraw treatment and need
special patient adherence programs.This research was funded by Pfizer GmbH.
PMS82
Assessing Willigness to Pay Among Psoriasis and Psoriatic Arthritis
Patients
Dierick K 1, Rose A 2
1GfK Disease Atlas, Brussels, Belgium, 2GfK Disease Atlas, London, UK
.
.
Objectives: It is estimated that 30% of psoriasis (PSO) patients also develops psoriatic arthritis (PSA). This potential disease evolution brings along new symptoms
such as swollen and painful joints and mobility problems. Since both diseases are
potentially degenerative, the aim of this study was to measure which group of
patients (PSO or PSA) is willing to pay most out of pocket to avoid their health related
quality of life (HRQoL) to worsen. Methods: 395 US patients diagnosed with either
psoriasis (n= 151) or psoriatic arthritis (n= 247) completed a questionnaire as part of
a broader survey of treatment of PSO/PSA. The questionnaire included the EQ-5D-5L
instrument and accompanying VAS. Patients were additionally asked to indicate by
reference to the EQ-5D VAS scale the amount of money per month they would be
willing to pay for treatments that would prevent a decline in HRQoL by 10 points.
Price sensitivity curves were created by means of linear regression analysis that
predict the proportion of patients willing to pay a certain amount of $ out of pocket
per month. Results: For both PSO (R² = 0,82) and PSA (R² = 0,86) monthly cost out of
pocket (x-variable) was a good predictor of the proportion of patients that is willing
to pay a certain amount out of pocket per month (y-variable). Regression models
look as follows. For PSO: y = 0,77e-0,005x for PSA: y = 0,86e-0,007x. To give a specific
example 42% of the PSA patients is willing to pay $100 per month out of pocket
whereas this is 47% among PSO patients. Conclusions: PSO patients are prepared
to pay more out of pocket on a monthly basis to avoid their HRQoL to worsen than
PSA patients. Further research is required to understand what drives this difference.
PMS83
Sustained Improvements in Workplace and Household Productivity
and Social Participation With Certolizumab Pegol Over 96 Weeks
in Patients With Axial Spondyloarthritis, Including Ankylosing
Spondylitis and Non-Radiographic Axial Spondyloarthritis
van der Heijde D 1, Braun J 2, Rudwaleit M 3, Purcaru O 4, Kavanaugh A 5
University Medical Centre, Leiden, The Netherlands, 2Rheumazentrum Ruhrgebiet, Herne,
Germany, 3Endokrinologikum Berlin, Berlin, Germany, 4UCB Pharma, Brussels, Belgium, 5UCSD,
San Diego, CA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
1Leiden
Objectives: To report the long-term effect of certolizumab pegol (CZP) on workplace and household productivity up to 96 weeks (wks) in patients with axial
spondyloarthritis (axSpA), including ankylosing spondylitis (AS, meeting modified New York criteria) and non-radiographic axSpA (nr-axSpA). Methods: The
ongoing RAPID-axSpA trial (NCT01087762), is double-blind and PBO-controlled to
Wk24, dose-blind to Wk48 and open-label to Wk204. Patients had active axSpA,
according to ASAS criteria, including AS and nr-axSpA patients. Patients originally
randomized to CZP (200mg Q2W or 400mg Q4W, following 400mg loading dose [LD]
at Wks 0, 2, 4) continued on their assigned dose in the OLE; PBO patients entering dose-blind phase were re-randomized to CZP LD followed by CZP 200mg Q2W
or CZP 400mg Q4W after Wk24 or, for non-responders, after Wk16. The validated
arthritis-specific Work Productivity Survey (WPS; administered Q4W) assessed the
impact of axSpA on workplace and household productivity. WPS responses (LOCF
imputation) in patients originally randomized to CZP are summarized descriptively
over 96 wks. Results: 325 patients were randomized, of whom 218 received CZP
(200mg Q2W or 400mg Q4W) from Wk0. Of patients randomized to CZP at baseline
(BL), 93% completed Wk24, 88% Wk48 and 80% Wk96. At BL, 72% of CZP patients
were employed outside of the home. Employed CZP patients reported reductions
in workplace absenteeism and presenteeism to Wk24, with continued improvements to Wk96 (BL: mean 1.8 days missed/month, mean 5.2 days with reduced
productivity/month vs Wk96: mean 0.6 days missed/month, mean 1.4 days with
reduced productivity/month). CZP patients also reported continued improvements
in household productivity and social participation to Wk96 in both dose regimens,
and similar improvements were observed in AS and nr-axSpA. Conclusions:
The initial improvements with CZP in workplace and household productivity and
increased participation in social/leisure activities were continued to Wk96 in axSpA,
AS and nr-axSpA patients.
PMS84
Sustained Improvements in Workplace and Household Productivity
and Social Participation With Certolizumab Pegol Over 96 Weeks in
Patients With Psoriatic Arthritis
Kavanaugh A 1, Gladman D 2, van der Heijde D 3, Purcaru O 4, Mease P J 5
1UCSD, San Diego, CA, USA, 2Toronto Western Research Institute, Toronto, Ontario, ON, Canada,
3Leiden University Medical Centre, Leiden, The Netherlands, 4UCB Pharma, Brussels, Belgium,
5Swedish Medical Center and University of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To examine the long-term effect of certolizumab pegol (CZP) on
workplace and household productivity up to 96 weeks (wks) in patients with active
psoriatic arthritis (PsA). Methods: The ongoing RAPID-PsA trial (NCT01087788)
is double-blind and PBO-controlled to Wk24, dose-blind to Wk48 and open-label
to Wk216. Patients had active PsA and had failed ≥ 1 DMARD. Patients originally
randomized to CZP (200mg Q2W or 400mg Q4W, following 400mg loading dose [LD]
at Wks 0, 2, 4) continued on their assigned dose in the OLE; PBO patients entering
dose-blind phase were re-randomized to CZP LD followed by CZP 200mg Q2W or
400mg Q4W after Wk24 or, for non-responders, Wk16. The validated arthritis-specific Work Productivity Survey (WPS) administered Q4W from baseline (BL), assessed
the impact of PsA on workplace and household productivity in the randomized set.
WPS responses (LOCF imputation) in patients originally randomized to CZP groups
are summarized descriptively over 96 wks. Results: 409 patients were randomized,
of whom 273 received CZP 200mg Q2W or CZP 400mg Q4W. Of patients randomized
to CZP, 91% completed Wk24, 87% Wk48 and 80% Wk96. In employed patients in both
CZP groups (60.8% of all CZP patients at BL), decreases in absenteeism and presenteeism to Wk24 were continued up to Wk96 (BL: mean 2.0 and 1.6 days missed/
month in the CZP 200mg Q2W and 400mg Q4W groups, respectively; mean 5.2 and
5.1 days with reduced productivity/month vs Wk96: mean 0.3 and 0.4 days missed/
month; mean 0.7 and 1.5 days with reduced productivity/month). Improvements in
household productivity and social participation reported in both CZP groups over
24 wks were also maintained to Wk96. Conclusions: The initial improvements
A388
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
with CZP in workplace and household productivity, and social participation were
sustained up to 96 wks in PsA patients.
Muscular-Skeletal Disorders – Health Care Use & Policy Studies
PMS85
Market Access of Implantable Medical Devices - Part Ii: Decision
Drivers Across Global Markets
Chawla A S 1, Tao C 2, Spinner D S 3, Faulkner E C 4, Doyle J J 5
1Quintiles Consulting, Durham, NC, USA, 2Quintiles Consulting, Cambridge, MA, USA, 3Quintiles,
Durham, NC, USA, 4Institute for Pharmacogenomics and Individualized Therapy, Eshelman School
of Pharmacy, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC, USA, 5Quintiles, Hawthorne, NY, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: With rising pressures on health care budgets, health technology
assessment (HTA) agencies are increasingly scrutinizing medical devices (MDs) for
economic benefits in addition to clinical benefits. This level of scrutiny has resulted
in many unfavorable recommendations from agencies and only a small proportion
of unconditionally favorable reviews. As an extension of our work reported at 2013
ISPOR Annual Congress (Dublin, IR) this study aims to: 1) Identify key criteria cited
by HTA agencies as major decision drivers, 2) Note common criteria among reviews
that were positive, negative, or positive with reservations, and 3) Analyze temporal or geographic trends among decision drivers. Methods: A review of 68 HTAs
and reimbursement decisions of implantable MD with a variety of indications was
conducted, focusing on decisions published from 2008-2013 identified by Quintiles’
HTA Watch from North America, Europe, and Australia. Clinical, economic, and other
factors noted as pivotal to HTA and reimbursement decisions were registered and
compared. Importantly, care was exercised to note only the criteria that triggered
a HTA to make a favorable or unfavorable decision, as opposed to criteria that were
only correlative. Results: Key product attributes affecting HTA decisions include
1) sufficiency and quality of evidence, 2) cost offsets and budget impact, 3) adverse
event profiles, and 4) comparison to existing alternatives where available. Notab
ly, 33% of HTA decisions were negative, with many decisions citing insufficient
evidence. Additionally, a majority of favorable HTA decisions were reserved in their
recommendations, citing a need for additional evidence to uphold the initially
favorable recommendation. The relative importance of economic considerations
varied across countries. Conclusions: HTA agencies’ scrutiny of sufficiency of
evidence, among others, may significantly impact market access of medical devices.
As such, manufacturers need careful planning to align evidence development, pricing and access plans with HTA agency, payer and pricing authority requirements.
PMS86
Anti-Tnf Biosimilars Indicated for Rheumatoid Arthritis
are Increasingly Available in Europe: How Do Payers and Key
Stakeholders Perceive Them?
Sewak N P S , Jones C
Double Helix Consulting, London, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The process of bringing a biosimilar to market in Europe is quicker,
easier and cheaper than developing a new biologic. As a class, rheumatoid arthritis
(RA) has the greatest number of anti-TNF biosimilar molecules in development, with
more expected to follow. This research was focussed on the key issues reported by
payers and Key Opinion Leaders (KOLs) in France, Germany and Italy. Methods:
Supported by secondary research our study entailed conducting one hour telephone interviews with influential senior payers involved in budgetary decision
making at the national and regional level in addition to KOLs. These structured
interviews explored how stakeholders perceived the introduction of anti-TNFs biosimilars. Results: Payers see anti-TNF biosimilars as an opportunity to reduce the
biologic budget but KOLs want to treat more patients within the same budget. Payers
in Germany and France reported a greater perception of the efficacy of biosimilars
than their counterparts in Italy. Treatment naïve patients are considered most suitable for anti-TNF biosimilars while automatic substitution was not favoured by
any respondents. Nonetheless, price played a role and some KOLs stated they may
attempt to switch existing patients who have a low risk of acute complications with
very close monitoring. Conclusions: Biosimilars may be perceived unequally
across markets. Manufacturers are likely to require the use of differentiated value
stories when presenting their biosimilar products to payers and KOLs, with the latter
more inclined to perceive them as an opportunity to treat more patients with the
same expenditure instead of reducing budgets. Manufacturers will likely struggle
to encourage the switching of existing patients onto biosimilars without offering a
significant discount. In France and Germany, anti-TNF RA biosimilars are currently
generating demand that closely matches their increasing prevalence.
PMS87
Comparison of Clinical Characteristics of Patients With
Rheumatoid Arthritis (Ra) Receiving Biologic Monotherapy and
Biologic-Containing Combination Therapy in Europe
Narayanan S 1, Lu Y 2, Hutchings R 2, Baynton E 2
1Ipsos Healthcare, Columbia, MD, USA, 2Ipsos Healthcare, London, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess the clinical characteristics of patients with RA who received
biologic monotherapy (“Mono”) or biologic-containing combination therapy (“Combo”)
in Europe. Methods: A multi-country, multi-center medical chart review study of
patients with RA was conducted in Q42012 among physicians in hospitals and private practices to collect de-identified data on patients who were recently treated
with a biologic as part of usual care in France/Germany/Italy/Spain/UK. Physicians
were screened for duration of practice (3-30yrs) and patient volume (≥2 RA biologic
patients/week) and recruited from a large panel to be geographically representative
in each country. Eligible patient charts (≥ 5) were randomly selected from among
the patients visiting each center/practice during the screening period. Physicians
abstracted date of diagnosis, treatment patterns/dynamics, and symptomatology/
disease status. Mono and Combo patients were compared used descriptive statis-
tics. Results: 1534 eligible RA patients were assessed; Mono: 428 (28%), Combo:
1106 (72%). Patient characteristics (Mono/Combo) included: age 51.8/51.7; female
71%/75%; weight 68.6/68.5kg; top three comorbidities: dyslipidemia (16%/19%), depression/anxiety (9%/13%), obesity (8%/12%). Time since diagnosis: 68.6/78.2mo. Current
line of biologic therapy: first-line 86%/75%, second-line 11%/18%, ≥ third-line 3%/6%.
Top four biologics used across the two patient groups: etanercept (33%)/adalimumab
(30%)/tocilizumab (9%)/certolizumab pegol (7%). Current lab values/disease severity
measures: ESR (mm/h) 21.7/23.2; CRP (mg/l) 10.3/10.3; rheumatoid factor (positive)
84%/87%; anti-CCP (positive) 70%/80%; current disease stage per physician judgment: mild 65%/52%, moderate 32%/40%, severe 3%/8%; mean VAS 3.4/3.6; mean HAQ
1.4/1.1; mean DAS 28 3.6/3.3; mean tender joint count 3.5/4.1; mean swollen joint
count 2.4/2.6. Conclusions: In this cohort of RA patients in Europe, the majority
of patients on monotherapy and combination therapy had mild disease per physician judgment and were on first-line biologic therapy. Lab measures and joint counts
indicated only slightly higher disease burden among combination therapy patients.
The impact of specific biologic treatments on observed patterns and the need for
therapeutic sequencing may warrant further research.
PMS88
Coping With A New Biologic Paradigm: Payer Strategies for the
Purchasing of Complex Biosimilars
Ziai Buetas A , Vidal Pinheiro A , Storer M
ICON, London, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: In Europe, biosimilars of complex molecules such as monoclonal
antibodies have started to enter the market. In this research we aim to provide an
understanding of the current expectations for the purchasing of these products
as well as an overview of the tools that payers expect to employ to encourage biosimilar use. Methods: Qualitative survey of payers across national, regional and
local levels in France, Germany, Italy, Spain, the UK and Netherlands. Collection and
analysis of data on (1) current and future attitudes relative to expected biosimilar
purchasing systems; and (2) the tools that payers expect to use to drive biosimilar
use, assuming this is a payer goal. Results: (1) The method of biosimilar purchase
in the short term will vary by country, with the majority of countries using tenders
to procure these products; (2) While tenders restricting choice of product to a single
winner will not be used extensively in the short term, these will be common across
most countries in the future; (3) Payers will also use a number of other tools such
as formal and informal recommendations, prescription incentives and auditing or
prescription targets in order to encourage use of the product they have chosen; (4)
New procurement pathways and tools are being developed to introduce biosimilars,
as highlighted by the new biosimilar law in Italy which defines a level of discount
at the national level. Conclusions: Payer strategies should maximize savings by
introducing less expensive biosimilars, but also must consider physician preferences, especially when influenced by potentially valid concerns about lack of data.
In order to do this, payers are creating novel purchasing frameworks and tools, and
while they are currently reticent to use restrictive methods to encourage use of
biosimilars, this is expected to rapidly change in a short timeframe.
PMS89
An Assessment of the Association Between Rural Status and Health
Service Resource Use Among Patients With Ankle Sprains in Ontario
Lucas G H , Bielska I A , Fong R K , Johnson A P
Queen’s University, Kingston, ON, Canada
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Despite Ontario’s universal health care system, differences exist
in health care accessibility and quality across the province. The objective of this
study is to assess health care resource utilization for patients with ankle sprains
based on rurality. Methods: Data on individuals who sought medical attention
for ankle sprains between 2003 and 2011 in Ontario were obtained from multiple
databases linked through the Institute for Clinical Evaluative Sciences (ICES). The
Rurality Index of Ontario (RIO) was used to measure the rurality level of patients
based on their population density and geographic distance to health care facilities. Demographic characteristics were obtained for each of five RIO categories.
Health care utilization (number of visits to primary care physicians, specialists and
ambulatory care) and physician billing costs were obtained and compared among
the RIO categories. Results: Between 2003 and 2011, the Ontario Health Insurance
Program was billed $64 million and $36 million (2013 CAD) by specialists and general practitioners, respectively, for the treatment of ankle sprains and dislocations.
Approximately $116 million was spent on direct and indirect costs of emergency
room visits for ankle sprains and dislocations. The largest proportion of rural injuries occurred in the top income quintile. Patients in the most rural RIO category
saw specialists least often and had the highest number of ambulatory care visits.
However, specialist visits constituted higher costs when compared to GP visits. The
highest specialist costs found were for males, elderly patients, and those who sought
medical attention during winter. The observed statistical differences in cost of GP
visits across RIO categories were not clinically meaningful. Conclusions: The
differences in health care utilization between RIO categories may indicate a lack
of access to specialist care with those residing in rural areas relying on emergency
departments for care. These results may be useful in allocating future resources to
better serve rural patients.
PMS90
Predicting the Burden of Knee Arthroplasty Revision Over A 20-Year
Horizon
Comas M 1, Guerrero-Ludueña R E 1, Espallargues M 2, Coll M 3, Pons M 4, Sabatés S 5,
Allepuz A 2, Castells X 1
(Hospital del Mar Medical Research Institute; Red de Investigación en Servicios de Salud en
Enfermedades Crónicas (REDISSEC), Barcelona, Spain, 2Agència de Qualitat i Avaluació Sanitàries
de Catalunya (AQuAS); Red de Investigación en Servicios de Salud en Enfermedades Crónicas
(REDISSEC), Barcelona, Spain, 3Hospital de Mataró, Mataró, Spain, 4Hospital de Sant Rafael,
Barcelona, Spain, 5Hospital Mútua de Terrassa, Terrassa, Spain
.
.
.
1IMIM
.
.
.
.
.
.
A389
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: To estimate future scenarios of utilization of knee arthroplasty (KA)
revision in the Spanish National Health System at the short and long term and its
impact on primary KA utilization. Methods: A discrete event simulation model
was built to represent the utilization of KA for 20 years (2011–2031) in the Spanish
National Health System, especially the burden of KA revision according to different scenarios of utilization and protheses survival. Data on KA utilization from
1997 to 2011 was obtained from the Spanish Minimum Data Set. Three scenarios
of future utilization of primary KA were estimated: 1) fixed number since 2011; 2)
fixed age and sex adjusted rates since 2011; and 3) projection using a linear regression model. These three scenarios were combined with two prostheses survival
functions L) from a study including primary KA from 1995 to 2000; and H) from
the Catalan Registry of Arthroplasty, including primary KA from 2005 to 2013. The
model was programmed using ARENA. The simulation results were analyzed at the
short (2015) and long-term (2030). Results: Variations in the number of revisions
depended on both the primary utilization rate and the survival function applied,
ranging from 8.3% to 31.6% increase at the short-term and from 38.3% to 176.9%
at the long term, percentages corresponding to the combinations of scenario 1
(low primary utilization rate) and survival function H (better survival) versus scenario 3 (high primary utilization rate) and survival function L (worse survival),
respectively. The prediction of increase on overall surgeries ranged from 0.1% to
22.3% at the short-term and from 3.7% to 98.2% at the long-term. Conclusions:
Projections of the burden of knee arthroplasty provide a quantitative basis for
future policy decisions relating to concentration of high complexity procedures,
the number of orthopaedic surgeons required to perform these procedures and
the number of resources needed.
PMS91
Cachexia in the Us Health Care System
Noone J 1, Blanchette C M 1, Roy D 2, Van Doren B 2, Arthur S 1
of North Carolina at Charlotte, Charlotte, NC, USA, 2University of North Carolina,
Charlotte, Charlotte, NC, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: Cachexia is a medical syndrome associated with several chronic
health conditions including many cancers, COPD, HIV, and kidney disease.
Cachexia is a wasting type syndrome characterized as a loss in body mass or
metabolic dysfunction. The loss in mass is associated with decreases in strength
and functional capacity. Currently there is little research into cachexia and our
objective is to characterize cachexia patients, their health care utilization and
costs. Methods: For this study we utilized one year (2009) of the Nationwide
Inpatient Sample (NIS). The NIS represents all inpatient stays at a random 20%
sample of hospitals within the United States. We grouped cachexia individuals
by primary or secondary diagnosis and then compared those with cachexia to all
others in terms of length of stay (LOS) and total cost. Finally we looked into factor
predicting increased LOS using a negative binomial model. Results: We estimated US prevalence for cachexia related admissions at 161,898 cases. Cachexia
patients were older with an average age of 67.95 versus 48.10 in their non-cachexia
peers. Hospitalizations associated with cachexia had an increased LOS compared
to non-cachexia patients (6 days versus 3) with average costs per stay $4,641.30
greater. Differences were seen in loss of function (LOF) with cachexia patients
mostly in the major LOF category (52.60%) whereas non-cachexia patients were
spread between minor, moderate, and major LOF (36.28%, 36.11%, and 21.26%).
Significant positive predictors of increased LOS among cachexia patients included
urban hospital (IRR= 1.21 non-teaching urban, IRR= 1.23 teaching urban), having
either major (IRR= 1.41) or extreme (IRR= 2.64) LOF, and having a primary diagnosis
of pneumonia (IRR= 1.15). Conclusions: Cachexia is a diverse syndrome associated with a number of chronic diseases. We have characterized cachexia and seen
it associated with increased length of stay, increased cost, and more severe loss
of function compared to those without cachexia.
PMS92
Increased Bone Mineral Density (Bmd) In Postmenopausal Women
With Osteoporosis (Op) Receiving Two Denosumab Injections In
Routine Clinical Practice In Bulgaria
Boyanov M 1, Shinkov A 2, Psachoulia E 3, Intorcia M 3, Petkova R 4
1University Alexandrovska Hospital, Sofia, Bulgaria, 2University Hospital of Endocrinology, Sofia,
Bulgaria, 3Amgen (Europe) GmbH, Zug, Switzerland, 4Amgen Bulgaria, Sofia, Bulgaria
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To describe baseline characteristics and changes in BMD T-scores at
1 year, in postmenopausal women with OP receiving 2 denosumab injections in
routine clinical practice in Bulgaria. Methods: This retrospective observational
study, conducted in 11 specialist (endocrinology or rheumatology) practices scattered geographically across Bulgaria, included postmenopausal women ≥50 years
old with a clinical diagnosis of OP, who initiated denosumab 60 mg Q6M on or after
Oct 2011 (regulatory approval of denosumab in Bulgaria) and received a follow-up
injection within 7 months (until Aug 2013). All study outcomes were recorded as per
routine clinical practice/reimbursement requirements, with BMD T-scores recorded
(at ≥ 1 site) at first denosumab injection (baseline) and 1-year follow-up. Descriptive
statistics were conducted. Results: 222 women met the inclusion criteria with a
mean (SD) age of 64.2 (±8.54) years; approximately half (49.5%) were < 65 years old
and13.1% ≥ 75 years. Mean (SD) age at menopause was 48.1 (±3.98) years. 26.6%
reported a prior fragility fracture, with vertebral the most common site (71.2%)
followed by hip (6.8%) and other sites (32.2%, excluding hip). At baseline, 2.7% were
receiving vitamin D only, 5.9% calcium supplements only and 35.1% both; 31.5% had
received prior OP therapy. At baseline, mean (SD) BMD T-score was -3.2 (±0.63) at
the lumbar spine (LS; n= 189), -2.3 (±0.81) at the total hip (TH; n= 75) and -2.7 (±0.71)
at the femoral neck (FN; n= 137). At 1-year follow-up, all women had BMD assessed
at ≥ 1 site; T-scores increased to -2.7 (±0.57) at the LS (n= 187), -2.1 (±0.91) at the TH
(n= 65) and -2.4 (±0.68) at the FN (n= 123). Conclusions: Postmenopausal women
with OP receiving 2 denosumab injections in Bulgarian clinical practice had a mean
age of 64.2 years and experienced improved mean BMD T-scores at the LS, TH, and
FN after 1 year. Study funded by Amgen.
PMS93
Baseline Patient Characteristics of A Prospective Observational
Study to Evaluate the Care Map of Women With Postmenopausal
Osteoporosis (Pmo) in Switzerland (Campos)
Lippuner K 1, Lamy O 2, Theiler R 3, Merlin C 4, Pendl G 5, Del Ponte A 5, Murigande C 5,
Schwenkglenks M 6
1University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland, 2Lausanne University Hospital, Lausanne, Switzerland,
3Triemli Hospital, Zurich, Switzerland, 4Rheumatology Practice and Osteoporosis Center, Baden,
Switzerland, 5Amgen Switzerland AG, Zug, Switzerland, 6University of Basel, Basel, Switzerland
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Report baseline patient characteristics of the CAMPOS study, which
is evaluating the PMO care map in Swiss clinical practice. Methods: Between
June 2012„ŸMay 2013, specialist osteoporosis centers operating a DXA machine
enrolled women diagnosed with PMO who initiated intravenous (IV) ibandronate
or zolendronate, or subcutaneous (SC) denosumab (index date) within 6 months
prior to center initiation. Study outcomes are recorded at index date (baseline)
and any visit in the 24-month observation period thereafter, as available from routine practice. Results: Twenty-one centers, mainly in urban regions (81%), of a
non-academic nature (76%), and specializing in rheumatology (71%), recruited 275
women. Two-hundred-sixty-three met the inclusion criteria and were included in
this baseline analysis; 180 (68%) of these received follow-up care at the specialist
center and 83 (32%) were referred back to general practice. At baseline, mean (SD)
age was 70.9 (9.7) years and mean time since diagnosis 5.4 (5.4) years (n= 248). The
following diagnostic parameters and risk factors were assessed at the time of PMO
diagnosis: prior osteoporotic fracture, 258 [94%] patients, with 60% reporting this
risk factor; DXA bone mineral density (BMD) scan, 255 (97%) patients (hip and either
lumbar spine or forearm BMD measured in 231 [88%] patients), mean (SD) BMD
T-scores at the femoral neck and lumbar spine -2.34 (0.79; n=230) and -2.89 (1.28;
n= 232), respectively; calcium and vitamin D status, 260 (99%) patients; fracture
history, 258 [98%] patients. Conclusions: In the current study, prevalent fractures were assessed in almost all women initiating IV ibandronate or zolendronate,
or SC denosumab, and the majority reported at least one prior fracture. Calcium
and vitamin D status, DXA BMD scans and/or fracture history were also routinely
assessed at PMO diagnosis.
PMS94
What Could the Future Hold? Simulating the Demand for
Osteoarthritis (oa) Care in Alberta to Plan a Sustainable Oa
Care System
Marshall D 1, Vanderby S 2, Carter M 3, Wasylak T 4, Mosher D P 1, Noseworthy T 5, Maxwell C 6,
MacDonald K 1, Frank C 7
1University of Calgary, Calgary, AB, Canada, 2University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, SK,
Canada, 3University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada, 4Alberta Health Services, Calgary, AB,
Canada, 5University of Calgary, Alberta Health Services, Calgary, AB, Canada, 6University of
Waterloo, Waterloo, ON, Canada, 7Alberta Innovates Health Solutions, Calgary, AB, Canada
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Osteoarthritis (OA) and the demand for OA care are increasing with
the aging population. Policy-makers seek to identify policies to sustainably manage
this growing demand, yet envisioning the short- and long-term effects of policy
options is difficult within chronic care. We aimed to develop a decision-support
tool enabling policy-makers to explore policies and their effects. Methods: We
developed a system dynamics (SD) simulation of patient flow across the continuum
of OA care in Alberta: from self-directed to primary and specialist care, through
surgical interventions, post-surgical follow-up and subsequent re-operations. The
simulation was developed using SD modeling principles and an iterative, integrated
knowledge translation process, including multiple workshops with clinicians and
administrators to define the problem, system boundaries and current patient flow.
The resulting simulation was populated with data extracted from administrative
databases (e. g. physician claims, inpatient records). Results: The model yields
patient population, OA care resource requirements and associated cost results at
each stage of care over 10 years by region and patient characteristics (e. g. sex). If
current practices continue, annual hip and knee replacement surgery volumes are
estimated to increase by more than 5,000 between 2015 and 2025. If a 14 week surgical wait-time is implemented in 2015, 600 additional surgeries must be performed
in the first year to “catch-up” on the existing surgical queue, yet long-term surgery
rates are similar to those without the wait-time target. The costs of the additional
surgeries are partly offset by the savings achieved by fewer patients requiring care
while awaiting surgery. Conclusions: This simulation can be used as a decisionsupport tool to estimate changes in patient populations, resource requirements
and costs over time that may result from various OA management scenarios. Such
results can equip policy makers with additional evidence to make more informed
OA care policy decisions.
PMS95
The Use of Clinical Data Repository for the Establishment of an
Osteoporosis Registry in A Large Health Organization in Israel:
Epidemiologic and Pharmaepidemiologic Findings
Goldshtein I 1, Shalev V 2, Chodick G 3, Chandler J 4, Martin Nguyen A 5, ish Shalom S 6
1Maccabi Healthcare Services, Tel Aviv, Israel, 2Medical Division, Maccabi Healthcare Services, Tel
Aviv, Israel, 3Maccabi Healthcare Services and Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv, Israel, 4Merck, North
Wales, PA, USA, 5Merck, North wales, PA, USA, 6Technion university, Haifa, Israel
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Osteoporosis is an important public health issue due to its rising prevalence and excess morbidity and mortality among this population. The present study
aimed to demonstrate the use of clinical data repository in Israel’s second largest
health organization (Maccabi Healthcare Services) to establish a registry of osteoporosis patients and assess its early findings with respect to the epidemiology and burden of the disease, high risk populations, and quality of care. Methods: Included
in the registry are patients with history of osteoporosis diagnosis, typical fractures
(e. g. closed fractures of proximal femur, vertebral, Colles’ and proximal humerus)
and or purchases of relevant medications, documented since 2000. In addition, we
included patients with low bone density from over 140,000 measurements, using an
A390
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
automated Optical Character Recognition (OCR) system. Patients younger than 18
years of age, diagnosed with Paget’s disease or purchasing pamidronic or zoledrnic
acid due to cancer were excluded. Registry entry date was defined as the first medical event consistent with any of inclusion and all exclusion criteria. Results: We
identified 118,141 patients with osteoporosis, with a point prevalence of 19% in 2013
among members aged 50+, and an average incidence of approximately 6,300 cases
a year. Average age at registry entry was 61 y/o for women and 66 y/o for men. 66%
of the patients had more than one qualifying criteria. 28% of the registry patients
were never treated. Conclusions: The methods and results described may provide
a model for the development of an important tool to assess the substantial burden
of osteoporosis and to monitor the quality of care over time.
PMS96
Concomitant Use of Non-Steroidal Anti-Inflammatory Drugs
(Nsaids) And Proton Pump Inhibitors (Ppis) in Newly Diagnosed
Patients With Osteoarthritis (Oa), Rheumatoid Arthritis (Ra) or
Ankylosing Spondylitis (As)
Dziarmaga A 1, Reidel K 2, White R 1, Tarride J E 1, Corner N 2
1AstraZeneca Canada Inc., Mississauga, ON, Canada, 2IMS Brogan Canada, Kirkland, QC, Canada
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The use of PPIs to reduce the risk of upper GI events caused by
NSAIDs is well documented. The aim of this study was to understand whether
newly diagnosed patients with OA, RA or AS not previously exposed to PPIs, receive
a gastro-protectant with their NSAID treatment at initiation or follow up in a
primary care setting. Methods: We analyzed data from primary care Electronic
Medical Records in Ontario, Canada. Patients ≥ 18 years, who were new users of
NSAIDs, NSAID plus a PPI, a fixed combination of diclofenac and misoprostol, or
Celecoxib between January 1st 2010 and May 31st 2012 were selected. Patients must
have had a diagnosis for OA, RA, or AS within 6 months of treatment initiation,
but no diagnosis in the year prior. Patients were followed for 6 months to assess
for subsequent PPI prescription. Patients prescribed a PPI in the last 12 months
were excluded. Results were compared to Canadian longitudinal pharmacy
data. Results: There were 692 patients included, 56% females and a mean age of
44 years (SD 15). Naproxen was the most commonly used treatment (41%), followed
by diclofenac (26%), celecoxib (14%) and diclofenac with misoprostol (19%). PPIs
were added at treatment initiation in 2.5% of naproxen patients, 1.7% of diclofenac
patients and 3.7% of patients with fixed combination of diclofenac and misoprostol. PPI prescription patterns within 6 months were similar and consistent with
patterns observed in the Canadian longitudinal pharmacy data. Conclusions:
Results suggest that primary care physicians in Canada do not prescribe PPIs
with NSAIDs at or within 6 months after NSAID initiation. Limitations include
small sample size and young patient cohort. Further studies are required to better understand the impact of low PPI concomitant use with NSAIDs, especially in
older patients or those at a higher risk of GI events.
PMS97
Gastrointestinal Risk Factors and Treatment Pattenrs of
Rheumatoid Arthritis Versus Osteoarthritis Patients in Korea
Lee S H 1, Lee E Y 2, Kim H J 3
1Konkuk University College of Medicine, Seoul, South Korea, 2Seoul National University College of
Medicine, Seoul, South Korea, 3Pfizer Pharmaceuticals Korea Limited, Seoul, South Korea
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: This study aimed to investigate and compare the gastrointestinal (GI)
risk factors and treatment patterns of rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and osteoarthritis
(OA) patients in real clinical practice of Korea. Methods: This was a nationwide,
cross-sectional study of patients taking non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs
(NSAID, either non-selective or selective COX-2 inhibitor (COX2i)) from 20 hospitals
between December 2012 and September 2013. Total 1,896 patients who were ≥ 20
years old (RA: 981 OA: 915) and were taking NSAID at least 1 month were enrolled.
Data were collected through medical chart review and patients survey. The GI risk
factors included NSAID duration (≥ 3 months), high-dose of NSIAD use, drinking,
smoking, comorbid disease, aspirin use, anticoagulant (warfarin) use, steroid use,
Helicobacter pylori infection, experience of GI event (i. e. GI bleeding or ulcer). The
treatment patterns were identified as non-selective NSAID (ns-NSAID) or COX2i
with/without gastroprotective agents respectively. Results: In RA, proportion of
patients taking NSAID≥ 3 months, smoker and steroid users were higher than in
OA patients (p< . 0001). In OA, proportion of patients who have comorbid disease
and take aspirin were higher than in RA patients (p< . 0001). The rest of the GI
risk factors were present as a similar proportion in both groups. The percentage
of treatment with COX2i (RA: 54.3% vs OA: 44.2%, p< . 001) and gastroprotective
agents (RA: 83.0% vs OA: 78.3%, p= . 009) in RA patients was higher than that in
OA patients. In older aged patients (age≥ 60) in both groups, there was tendency
to get more treatment of COX2i (RA: 60.9%, OA: 50.2%) compared to ns-NSAID.
Interestingly, as patients get more numbers of GI risk factors, there seemed to get
more proportions of ns-NSAIDs users in both RA and OA patients. Conclusions:
The proportion of GI risk factors found in OA patients was comparable to that
in RA patients. There was a tendency to show preferential ns-NSAID treatment
pattern rather than COX2i especially in the presence of multiple GI risk factors
in arthritis patients.
Neurological Disorders – Clinical Outcomes Studies
PND1
Modelling the Impact of Persistence Improvements with an
Electronic Injection Device on Escalation to 2nd Line Treatment in
Patients with Relapsing Remitting Multiple Sclerosis (RRMS)
Meletiche D M 1, Rutkowski T 2, Martin de Bustamante M A 3, Chowdhury C A 4,
Beckerman R 2
1EMD Serono, Inc., Rockland, MA, USA, 2CBPartners, New York City, NY, USA, 3CBPartners, San
Francisco, CA, USA, 4CBPartners, New York, NY, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The purpose of this analysis was to estimate how higher persistence
in RRMS patients treated with interferon beta 1-a and its electronic injection device
(Rebismart®) affects the rate of escalation to 2nd line therapies. Methods: A 2-year,
decision-analytic model was developed to track a hypothetical cohort of 1,000 RRMS
patients initiating treatment with either interferon beta 1-a and Rebismart® or
another 1st line self-injectable disease modifying drug (DMD). The model calculated
the expected probability of escalating to 2nd line therapy, which was defined as either
Gilenya® or Tysabri®. Persistence curves were estimated from a real-world dataset
collected from the UK NHS where at 2 years Rebismart® users had 83% persistence vs.
60% in non- Rebismart® users. A market research study was utilized to determine the
treatment pathways for non-persistent patients, where 39% transitioned to another
1st line DMD; 21% abandoned therapy and 40% escalated to 2nd line therapies. Oneway sensitivity analyses (OWSAs) varied the probability of non-persistent 1st line
patients escalating to 2nd line therapies from 5% to 100%. Results: The model estimated that over two years 5.4% of patients on the Rebismart® device are expected to
escalate to 2nd line therapy, while 18.3% of patients that initiated treatment on other
DMDs are expected to escalate. At the lower bound of the OWSA, 0.68% of patients are
expected to escalate on Rebismart®, vs. 2.3%; while at the upper bound of the OWSA,
13.3% of Rebismart® patients are expected to escalate vs. 42.7%. Conclusions:
Higher persistence rates in RRMS patients initiating treatment with interferon beta
1-a and the Rebismart® electronic device are expected to result in fewer escalations
to 2nd line therapies relative to other self-injectable DMDs.
PND2
A Systematic Review and Network Meta-Analysis of
Pharmacological Therapies Used for Patients with Advanced
Parkinson’s Disease
Ren S 1, Cooper K 2, Cooper J A 3, Smith H T 3, Shaikh S 3
1Sheffield University, Sheffield, UK, 2University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK, 3GSK, Brentford, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess the relative efficacy and safety of modified-release levodopa
(IPX066), controlled-release levodopa and add-on therapy to immediate-release
levodopa (including dopamine agonists, monoamine oxidase-B inhibitors (MAOBI),
and catechol-O-methyl transferase inhibitors (COMTI)) using network meta-analysis (NMA). Methods: A systematic literature search was conducted in MEDLINE,
MEDLINE In-Process, EMBASE, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, Cochrane
Central Register of Controlled Trials, DARE and HTA. A random effects NMA was used
to determine the relative efficacy and safety of treatments on off-time reduction,
three Unified Parkinson’s Disease Rating Scale (UPDRS) scores, patient withdrawals,
and six adverse events in WinBUGS. An additional analysis was conducted to assess
treatment class effects. Node-splitting approach was used to assess the assumption of
consistency when direct and indirect evidence was combined. Results: Forty-three
trials with 9,453 patients were identified. Immediate-release levodopa plus pramipexole produced the greatest reduction in off-time relative to immediate-release
levodopa plus placebo (-1.71 hours a day; 95% CrI: -2.11, -1.35), followed by IPX066
(-1.40; 95% CrI: -2.19, -0.67). The greatest improvement on UPDRS ADL score was given
by add-on ropinirole (-2.33 points; 95% CrI: -3.53, -1.06); on UPDRS motor and total
score was given by add-on pramipexole (-5.88 points; 95% CrI: -7.22, -4.63 and -10.09
points; 95% CrI: -13.75, -6.56, respectively). Dyskinesia was increased with IPX066 and
adjuvant therapy classes except for MAOBIs. Patient withdrawals were also increased
with IPX066 and controlled-release levodopa. Conclusions: The NMA showed that
all treatments except controlled-release levodopa were associated with a statistically
significant reduction in off-time. Dopamine agonist class as adjunctive to levodopa
therapy had the greatest reduction. IPX066 was broadly comparable with add-on
dopamine agonists on off-time reduction, and comparable with add-on MAOBIs and
COMTIs on UPDRS scores. However, the treatments were associated with an increase
in the risk of having dopaminergic side effects, particularly dyskinesia.
PND3
The Burden of Parkinson Disease Amongst Caregivers in Spain Over
4 Years
Martinez P 1, Rodriguez-Blazquez C 1, Paz S 2, Lizán L 3, Forjaz M J 4, Frades B 5, Jimenez O L 6
Center for Epidemiology and CIBERNED, Carlos III Institute of Health, Madrid, Spain,
2Outcomes’10, Castellon, Spain, 3Outcomes 10, Castellon, Spain, 4National School of Public Health
and REDISSEC, Carlos III Institute of Health, Madrid, Spain, 5Alzheimer Center Reina Sofia
Foundation, Carlos III Institute of Health, Madrid, Spain, 6H. U. de Gran Canaria Dr. Negrín, Las
Palmas de Gran Canaria, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1National
Objectives: To describe caregivers’ Health Related Quality of Life (HRQoL), burden,
anxiety and depression and their relation with patients’ symptoms in Parkinson
disease (PD). Methods: A descriptive, observational, longitudinal design in PD
patients and their caregivers of ELEP study (2006-2010), in Spain. Information
collected during 3 month per year for 4 years, included sociodemographic characteristics, motor symptoms (SCOPA-Motor) and HRQoL (EQ-5D: index and VAS)
from PD patients and burden (Zarit’s CBI), anxiety (HADS-A), depression (HADS-D)
and HRQoL from their caregivers. Linear mixed models were performed to assess
the relation between caregivers’ burden with the patients’ motor symptoms and
HRQoL. Results: 174 PD patients, mean age: 63±11, 50% male, PD duration: 8±6
years; 173 caregivers, 66.5% female, mean number of years taking care of patients:
6±5, were included. Patients’ SCOPA-Motor varied from 39.3±8.4 in year 1 to 42.5±9.5
in year 4; EQ-5D index and VAS from 0.7±0.3 and 63.7±20.3 to 0.6±0.3 and 60.3±17.9,
respectively. Caregivers’ ZCBI varied from 17.6±12.6 to 20.0±14.8; EQ-5D index
remained unchanged at 0.8±0.2, while VAS varied from 73.7±18.6 to 75.0±16.2;
HADS-D scores changed between 4.0±3.7 and 4.4±4.3, and HADS-A from 6.7± 3.8
to 6.9±4.3. Linear mixed models revealed that caregivers’ anxiety and depression
negatively influenced their own perception of disease burden [HADS-A, Estimated
coefficient (EC): 1.02 (SE: 0.15), p<0.000; HADS-D, EC: 1.19 (SE: 0.17), p<0.000]. Patients’
motor symptoms predicted worse caregiver burden [SCOPA-Motor EC: 0.22 (SE: 0.09),
p= 0.014]. Decline in patients HRQoL implied a higher caregiver burden [EQ-5D index
EC: -5.56 (SE: 2.70), p< 0.041]. Conclusions: PD patients’ moderate motor symptoms and fair HRQoL worsened over time as did caregivers’ anxiety and disease
A391
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
burden. Improving the control of PD motor symptoms on patients may contribute
to prevent anxiety and HRQoL deterioration in caregivers.
PND4
A Comprehensive Literature Review of the Burden of Gaucher
Disease
Nalysnyk L 1, Hamed A 1, Hurwitz G 1, Simeone J 2, Rotella P 2
1Genzyme, a Sanofi Company, Cambridge, MA, USA, 2Evidera, Lexington, MA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Gaucher disease (GD) is an inherited, rare, lysosomal storage disorder
caused by a genetic deficiency of glucocerebrosidase. The result is the accumulation
of the substrate, glucosylceramide, in the lysosomes of macrophage cells in the liver,
spleen, bones, lungs, and other vital tissues. Three subtypes of Gaucher disease are
recognized: type 1 (GD1, non-neuropathic), type 2 (GD2, acute neuropathic), and type
3 (GD3, subacute/chronic neuropathic). Clinical manifestations of the disease are multisystemic, clinically heterogeneous and require lifelong management. Methods:
To better understand the burden of GD, a comprehensive review of the published
literature was conducted. MEDLINE, EMBASE, CENTRAL and “grey” literature sources
published in English between January 1990 and February 2013 were searched for relevant publications. Results: A total of 97 publications focusing on the epidemiologic,
clinical, and socioeconomic burden of GD, treatment options and guidelines were
summarized. The standardized incidence and prevalence of GD in the general population varies from 0.30 to 5.80 per 100,000 and 0.33 to 1.75 per 100,000, respectively,
and GD1 is the predominant type in most regions. The risk of mortality is highest in
GD patients younger than age 5 years and generally increased after age 55; the life
expectancy is lower than the general population. Common manifestations of GD such
as anemia, thrombocytopenia, splenomegaly, hepatomegaly and bone disease lead
to a decreased quality of life. Reported GD comorbidities include Parkinson’s disease
and cancer. Current treatment options consist of enzyme replacement therapy (ERT,
standard of care) and substrate reduction therapy (SRT). ERT is the standard of care,
though unmet needs still exist, especially for GD2 and GD3. Conclusions: GD is a
rare, chronic disease associated with significant burden to patients and caregivers.
While ERT is an effective and well-established treatment for GD patients, several
unmet needs exist and further research is needed in this area.
PND5
Restless Leg Syndrome Detection in Hemodialysis
Castejón N 1, Arenas M D 2, Rebollo P 1, Sellés Galiana F 3, Delgado Conde P 2, Gil González
M T 2, Gutierrez Rivas P 2, Reichert García J 2
1LASER ANALYTICA, Oviedo, Spain, 2Hospital Vithas Perpetuo Socorro, Alicante, Spain, 3Hospital
General Universitario de Alicante, Alicante, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
AD dementia. The effectiveness of this test was evaluated for diagnostic accuracy.
Diagnostic accuracy for identifying AD by ELISA was high (pooled sensitivity, 0.772
(95% CI 0.747–0.796); pooled specificity, 0.732 (95% CI 0.699–0.762). Conclusions:
Reduced CSF Ab1–42 levels are of potential utility in the differential diagnosis of AD
versus non-AD dementias and healthy controls.
PND7
Prevalence of Cystic Fibrosis Among the U.S. National Medicaid
Population
Xie L 1, Dysinger A H 1, Wang Y 1, Kariburyo M F 1, Baser O 2
Research, Ann Arbor, MI, USA, 2STATinMED Research and The University of
Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1STATinMED
Objectives: Cystic fibrosis (CF) prevalence according to U. S. geographic region as
well as patient age, gender and race was examined in the U. S. Medicaid population
for patients younger than age 45. Methods: Patients ≤ 45 years from the Medicaid
fee-for-service (FFS) population (2008-2009) were identified using International
Classification of Disease 9th Revision Clinical Modification (ICD-9-CM) diagnosis
code 277.0x. Patients were required to have continuous Medicaid FFS enrollment
in both years and no evidence of managed care enrollment. CF prevalence was
stratified by U. S. region, state, age group, gender and race, and was measured by
number and percentage of patients in each category. Results: A total of 2,142
patients were diagnosed with CF among the Medicaid FFS population under age 45
years in 2008 and 2009. Prevalence was the highest (0.17%) for patients under age 17
years, followed by those age 18-35 (0.14%), and 36-45 years (0.06%). However, some
states had the highest CF prevalence in the 18-35 age range (Colorado: 0.92%; North
Dakota: 0.50%; Kentucky: 0.54%). CF prevalence by race was also examined with
the following results: White (0.17%), Hispanic (0.10%), Asian (0.07%), Black (0.06%)
and Native American (0.03%). Male patients had a relatively higher prevalence
than female patients (0.14% vs. 0.12%). The highest CF prevalence was observed in
Colorado (0.47%), followed by Maryland (0.46%), North Dakota (0.31%), Ohio (0.28%)
and Pennsylvania (0.27%). Patients residing in the Midwest U. S. region had the
highest prevalence rate (0.15%), compared to the South (0.15%), Northeast (0.12%)
and West (0.04%) regions. Conclusions: CF prevalence was the highest in patients
age < 17 years nationwide, however, certain states showed the highest prevalence
among patients age 18 to 35. White and male patients residing in the Midwest U. S.
region were found to be at higher risk of a CF diagnosis.
.
.
Objectives: Restless leg syndrome (RLS) is a condition with possibly high prevalence
in hemodialysis (6-60% according to the literature), and a specific treatment available.
Thus it’s important to identify it among other conditions present in this population
that might confound diagnosis (such as peripheral vascular disease or neuropathies).
An approach based on a self-completed screening test will be assessed in this study,
along with an estimation of RLS prevalence in hemodialysis. Methods: Patients
from two hemodialysis units answered a RLS screening test. Those with a positive
screening completed the International Restless Legs Syndrome Study Group Rating
Scale (IRLS) that assesses symptom severity. A neurophysiologist performed a clinical interview to confirm the diagnosis, including a supervised administration of the
IRLS. Results: 164 patients were recruited. Mean age was 65.7 years (range 33-87;
Pct25-75: 55.5-77.5), 67% were male and mean time in dialysis was 64.16 months.
Self-completed screening test identified 69 possible cases of RLS (42.07%). 44 (26.8%)
patients had RLS symptoms according to the self-completed IRLS, and 79% of them
were classified as having moderate to severe RLS symptoms. The clinician confirmed
just 22 of those cases (13.4% of the total sample), with a demographic profile similar
to the sample. The screening test had in this sample a sensitivity of 100%, specificity
66.43% and positive predictive value 31.88%. Conclusions: This study found RLS is
a relatively common condition in hemodialysis patients. The screening test showed
a high sensitivity to detect RLS, but very low specificity, so the confirmation of an
expert neurologist or neurophysiologist is neccesary.
PND6
Cerebrospinal Fluid f”-Amyloid1-42 Levels in the Differential
Diagnosis of Alzheimer’s Disease - Systematic Review and
Meta-Analysis
Mo J
National Evidence-based Health Care Collaborating Agency & Inha University, SEOUL, South
Korea
.
Objectives: The purpose of this study was to carry out systematic review of the
literature and meta-analysis to evaluate the diagnostic utility of cerebrospinal fluid
(CSF) levels of the 42 amino acid form of amyloid-b (Ab1−42) as a biomarker for differentiating Alzheimer’s disease (AD) from non-AD dementia. Methods: Design Systematic literature review was used to evaluate the effectiveness of the Ab for the
diagnosis of Alzheimer’s disease. The Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network
(SIGN) tool was used by two evaluators to evaluate independently the quality of the
15 studies. Data sources - The literature review covered from October 27, 1946, to
October 22, 2013, and searched eight domestic databases including Korea Med and
international databases including Ovid-MEDLINE, EMBASE, and Cochrane Library.
Eligibility criteria for selecting studies - Primary criteria for inclusion were valid
studies on (i) patients with mild cognitive impairment with confirmed or suspected
AD and non-AD dementia, and (ii) assessment of Ab1−42levels using appropriate
comparative tests. Results: A total of 15 studies (15 diagnostic evaluation studies) were identified in which levels of CSF Ab1−42 were assessed. Meta-analysis
was performed on nine robust studies that compared confirmed AD with healthy
individuals (n = 1587), 10 studies that compared AD with non-AD dementias (n =
860), and four studies that compared a-MCI (amnestic mild cognitive impairment)
with na-MCI (non-amnestic mild cognitive impairment) subjects (n = 857). Overall,
Ab1–42levels were reduced in CSF from AD patients versus healthy controls or non-
PND8
Risk of Relapse Among Propensity Score Matched Multiple Sclerosis
Patients Receiving Natalizumab or Platform Therapy in the US
Watson C 1, Bonafede M M 2, Johnson B H 2
Idec Inc., Weston, MA, USA, 2Truven Health Analytics, Cambridge, MA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
1Biogen
Objectives: To examine claims-based relapse rates and time to relapse among multiple sclerosis (MS) patients treated with natalizumab or propensity score matched
patients treated with platform therapy (interferon beta/glatiramer acetate) in the
US. Methods: The Truven Health MarketScan Research Databases were used to
identify adults with a MS (ICD-9-CM code 340) diagnosis treated with natalizumab
or platform therapy; the first claim between January 1, 2009 and April 1, 2012 was the
index. Patients had to have one year continuous enrollment pre- and post-index and
remain on index therapy for 12 months. Patients were excluded if they used a nonindex therapy in the pre-index. Natalizumab and platform patients were propensity
scored matched using nearest neighbor matching on demographic characteristics,
selected comorbid conditions and medications, MS severity (using an adaptation
of Kurtzke’s Functional System), pre-index relapse and pre-index expenditures.
MS-relapse was defined as MS-related inpatient (IP) admission, IV or oral corticosteroid use. Cox Proportional Hazard models were used to evaluate time to relapse,
controlling for demographic and pre-index clinical characteristics. Results: A total
of 897 natalizumab patients met the study criteria, 882 of which were 1: 1 matched to
882 platform therapy patients (mean age 45 years, 70% female) with a standardized
difference < 10 on all matching measures. Compared to platform patients, natalizumab patients were significantly less likely to have MS-relapse post-index (26.5%
vs. 35.5%, p< 0.001), with lower post-index rates of MS-related IP admissions (1.0%
vs. 2.6%), IV-corticosteroid use (15.6% vs. 19.0%) and oral corticosteroid use (15.4% vs.
23.1%) (all p<0.001). Natalizumab patients also had 25 more relapse-free days (308 vs.
283 days, p< 0.001). Post-index MS-relapse risk was lower for natalizumab patients
(HR= 0.69, p< 0.001) after controlling for baseline characteristics. Conclusions:
Natalizumab was associated with a significantly lower risk and rate of MS-relapse
and had longer time to a MS-relapse compared to platform therapy.
PND9
Image-Guided Navigation Systems (IGNS) Improve Accuracy of
Catheter Placement in Shunted Hydrocephalus Patients
Annoni E 1, Joedicke H 1, Birinyi-Strachan L 2
1Medtronic International, Tolochenaz, Switzerland, 2Medtronic Australasia, Sydney, Australia
.
.
.
Background: The most common surgical complication associated with shunt
placement in Hydrocephalus patients is obstruction causing shunt malfunction.
The primary cause of obstruction is incorrect placement of the catheter tip, most
notably in the choroid plexus. Objectives: To investigate the clinical and economic value of IGNS use in the accurate placement of catheters in Hydrocephalus
patients. Methods: A search of the Embase and PubMed electronic databases was
conducted to identify studies evaluating the accuracy, effectiveness, quality-of-life
(QOL) and economic aspects of IGNS in patients with Hydrocephalus. No language
restrictions were applied. Results: We conducted a meta-analysis of studies reporting accuracy of ventricular catheter placement in patients with hydrocephalus
undergoing shunt placement with stereotactic IGNS versus freehand technique. The
definition of accurate catheter placement was similar in all studies. The meta-analysis
showed the odds of achieving an accurate catheter placement for surgeons who utilize
IGNS was almost 6 times higher (odds ratio 5.55, 95% CI [2.84, 10.85], P< 0.00001) than
surgeons who used freehand placement techniques. Furthermore, accurate place-
A392
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
ment of the catheter tip was associated with fewer shunt failures, as demonstrated in
9 clinical studies investigating accurate catheter placement using the AxiEM™ IGNS
(Medtronic Inc). In addition to being costly, studies showed shunt revision surgery
was associated with significant morbidity and lower long-term QOL. In a study of 80
paediatric Hydrocephalus patients, investigators found that patients with a history
of two or more shunt revision surgeries had a significantly worse QOL (p< 0.02), as
measured by the Hydrocephalus Outcomes Questionnaire (HOQ). Conclusions: The
use of IGNS significantly increases the accuracy of ventricular catheter placement
compared to freehand techniques in hydrocephalus patients undergoing ventricular
shunt insertion. Clinical studies have shown the use of IGNS in shunt placement
surgery results in lower shunt failure rates, which improve QOL and lowers the economic impact to payers.
PND10
Assessing the Comparative Outcomes from Teriflunomide and
Dimethyl Fumarate Studies in Relapsing Ms: Use of “Number Needed
to Treat” Analysis
Freedman M S 1, Montalban X 2, Miller A E 3, Dive-Pouletty C 4, Leist T P 5
1University of Ottawa and the Ottawa Hospital Research Institute, Ottawa, ON, Canada, 2Vall
d’Hebron University Hospital, Barcelona, Spain, 3Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai,
New York, NY, USA, 4Genzyme, a Sanofi company, Chilly-Mazarin, France, 5Thomas Jefferson
University Hospital, Philadelphia, PA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Teriflunomide and dimethyl fumarate (DMF), oral therapies for relapsing–remitting multiple sclerosis (RRMS), have demonstrated efficacy in clinical trials.
Despite challenges in comparing outcomes across studies, exploratory analyses
of treatment effects can be compared informally using relative reductions in a
specific endpoint. However, these outcomes do not account for differences in disease severity among study populations or differences on very low event rates. The
number needed to treat (NNT) to prevent an event is an important outcome to
consider for any comparisons within the field of MS. Methods: NNTs were derived
using data from studies with teriflunomide 14 mg (TEMSO, NCT00134563; TOWER,
NCT00751881) or DMF (DEFINE, NCT00420212; CONFIRM, NCT00451451) based on
inverse of absolute differences between treatment and placebo groups. Results:
Teriflunomide studies included patients with progressive disease; patients in
DEFINE had slightly lower Expanded Disability Status Scale scores. Teriflunomide
and DMF significantly reduced risk of relapse (all studies). NNTs to prevent one
relapse were similar across studies (5.9 [TEMSO], 5.6 [TOWER], 5.3 [DEFINE], 5.6
[CONFIRM]). Risk of disability progression sustained for 12 weeks was significantly
reduced in TEMSO, TOWER, and DEFINE but not CONFIRM. Corresponding NNTs to
prevent disability progression were 13.8, 17.4, 10.8, and 30.2. Risk of relapse leading
to hospitalization was significantly reduced in TEMSO and TOWER but not in DEFINE
and CONFIRM. Corresponding NNTs were lower in TEMSO (12.5) and TOWER (20)
than in DEFINE (50) and CONFIRM (50). Conclusions: Using the NNT approach, we
demonstrate a comparable effect size for teriflunomide and DMF on relapse. NNTs
to prevent disability progression with teriflunomide showed a consistent significant reduction in risk versus placebo in both TEMSO and TOWER, whereas for DMF,
comparable NNTs were observed only in DEFINE, and not in CONFIRM. Reduction
of risk for relapse leading to hospitalization was significant only for teriflunomide.
PND11
The Clinical Evidence Base of Treatment Options in Alzheimer’s
Disease: A Systematic Literature Search
Droeschel D 1, Kaier K 2, Walzer S 1
1MArS Market Access & Pricing Strategy GmbH, Weil am Rhein, Germany, 2University of Freiburg,
Freiburg, Germany
.
.
.
Objectives: Alzheimer’s Disease (AD) destroys brain cells, causing problems
with memory, thinking, and behavior severe enough to affect work, family and
social relationships, and basic activities of daily living. AD gets worse over time,
it is incurable and fatal. Donepezil, galantamine, rivastigmine and memantine
are the current treatment options but the latest evidence was not systematically
reviewed recently. Methods: PubMed, Health Technology Assessment Database,
NHS Economic Evaluation Database, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled
Trials, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, DAHTA-Datenbank, PSYNDEX
and PsycINFOwere searched systematically for randomized-controlled studies.
For the abstracts that met the pre-defined inclusion criteria, full text articles were
obtained. The abstracts that did not meet the search criteria were excluded. Based
on these manuscripts it was evaluated whether each study meets the selection criteria. Results: After elimination of duplicates the search indicated above yielded
418 articles of which another 299 were excluded based on the title selection; after
abstract review, 82 articles have been reviewed in full text which were also deemed
to be relevant based on the research question. For donepezil 24 RCTs were available
for which another 4 subgroup and exploratory analyses have been published. For
galantamine 11 RCTs with 6 exploratory analysis are available. For rivastigmine 10
RCTs are available with 7 exploratory papers. For memantine 14 RCTs with 6 exploratory analysis were found. Out of those studies eleven head-to-head studies are available; 5 studies comparing donepezil vs memantine, 3 studies comparing donepezil vs
rivastigmine and one study each comparing donepezil vs galatamine, rivastagmine
vs memantine. There was one study comparing rivastagmine vs donepezil vs galantamine. In comparison the clinical evidence seems diverse dependent on the patient
characteristics, study duration, and severity of disease. Conclusions: Appropriate
evidence assessment for the approved AD treatments requires clinical expertise and
close review of the study characteristics.
PND12
Evaluation of Disability Progression as an Endpoint in Clinical
Trials for Relapsing-Remitting Multiple Sclerosis (RRMS):
Comparison of the Define and Confirm Studies
Viglietta V , O’Gorman J , Yang M , Zhang R , Raghupathi K
Biogen Idec Inc., Cambridge, MA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Time to 12-week confirmed disability progression, measured by the
Expanded Disability Status Scale (EDSS), is a key endpoint in RRMS trials. However,
the EDSS has widely discussed limitations, and several therapies have shown
inconsistent results for this endpoint in terms of statistical significance. Here
we contextualize differences in 12-week confirmed disability progression results
in the Phase 3 studies of gastro-resistant dimethyl fumarate (DMF), DEFINE and
CONFIRM. Methods: Time to 12-week confirmed disability progression at 2 years
was a secondary endpoint in both studies; however, the studies were not powered
to detect statistical significance for this endpoint. Patients had the option of discontinuing study treatment and initiating alternative therapy at any time due to
12-week confirmed disability progression or after completing 48 weeks of study
treatment and experiencing one confirmed relapse after 24 weeks (DEFINE) or two
confirmed relapses at any time (CONFIRM). Results: Although gastro-resistant
DMF 240mg BID demonstrated consistent reductions on 12-week confirmed disability progression, statistical significance was achieved in DEFINE (p= 0.0050) but
not CONFIRM (p= 0.2536). There was an apparent difference in the placebo rate
of 12-week confirmed disability progression at 2 years (DEFINE, 27%; CONFIRM,
17%). In CONFIRM, a relatively higher percentage of placebo patients (4.1%) versus
gastro-resistant DMF patients (1.7%) switched to alternative MS therapy or withdrew after the time of tentative disability progression without a subsequent EDSS
assessment. Additionally, a relatively higher percentage of placebo patients who
switched to alternative MS therapy had ≥ 2 relapses without 12-week confirmed
disability progression prior to switch in CONFIRM (45%) compared with DEFINE
(16%). Conclusions: Relapse-based criteria for switching to alternative therapy
may have contributed to the lower placebo progression rate and decreased assay
sensitivity for this particular endpoint in CONFIRM. The totality of evidence needs
to be taken into account when assessing a therapy’s effect on disability progression.
PND13
A Real-World Assessment of Annual Multiple Sclerosis
Prevalence and Disease-Modifying Drug Treatment Rates
Using an Administrative Claims Database
Phillips A L 1, Munsell M J 2, Menzin J 2, Dangond F 1, Locklear J C 1
Serono, Inc., Rockland, MA, USA, 2Boston Health Economics, Inc., Waltham, MA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1EMD
Objectives: To examine annual prevalence and treatment rates of multiple
sclerosis (MS) patients using a large US commercial administrative claims database. Methods: Random sample of 5 million lives from the IMS LifeLink Plus
database was used for this analysis. Individuals with ≥ 1 month eligibility were
included in the denominator; those with ≥ 1 month eligibility and an MS diagnosis
(ICD-9-CM: 340. xx) were included in the numerator. Presence of a disease-modifying
drug (DMD) was defined as ≥ 1 claim during the calendar year of interest. Baseline
demographics and clinical characteristics were evaluated for each group. Annual
prevalence (per 10,000) and treatment rates were reported for each calendar year
(2006–2012) and were further stratified by age and gender. Results: MS patients
were older than patients without MS (mean age range 46.8–47.7 vs. 34.4-35.1, respectively) and more likely to be female (73% vs. 51%, respectively). Comorbidities such as
gastrointestinal disorders (42.8%), hypertension (43.5%), arthritis (24.8%) and anxiety
(22.8%) were common among MS patients (2006 estimates). MS prevalence ranged
from 16.4/10,000 (2006) to 17.8/10,000 (2010). Similar patterns over the years were
observed when data were stratified by sex and age, with absolute rates being higher
among women vs. men (24.4/10,000 vs. 8.2/10,000, respectively; 2012; P< 0.001) and
patients aged 45–64 years (29.4/10,000 vs. 0.4/, 15.6/ and 18.2/10,000 patients aged
< 18, 18–44 and ≥ 65, respectively; P< 0.001). The proportion of MS patients receiving a DMD increased from 2006 (42.5%) to 2012 (51.2%) (P< 0.001). Similar rates and
trends in the proportion of patients with a DMD were observed when stratified
by gender (42.8% (2006) and 51.3% (2012) [female]; 41.5% (2006) and 50.7% (2012)
[male]; both P< 0.001). Conclusions: In a recent 5-year period, MS prevalence
in a large US insured population increased slightly, with a greater increase in the
likelihood of DMD use.
PND14
The Characteristics of Multiple Sclerosis in Iran
Khanizadeh H 1, Nikkhah K 2, Izham M 3
SAINS MALAYSIA, penang, Malaysia, 2Mashhad University of Medical Sciences,
Mashhad, Khorasan, Iran, 3Universiti Sains Malaysia, Pinang, Palau Pinang, Malaysia
.
.
.
1UNIVERSITY
Objectives: Multiple Sclerosis (MS) is a chronic disease of the Central Nerve
System. The aim of this paper is to characterize the various clinical and demographical feature of the MS population. Methods: In a 6-month cross-sectional study248
patients were investigated in Khorasan provinces. Data was collected by employing
a 32- item self-administered questionnaire in a face to face interview. Results:
A total of 248 patients were recruited (186 female, 75%; 62 male, 25%). The mean
age was 31.9±8.7, the mean onset age was 26.3 (26.3±8: 1) and the median duration of illness was 3.8 years. The prevalence and incidence were estimated to be
25/100000 and 2.5/100,000 respectively. Significantly more patients had a Relapsing
Remitting MS course. Self reported character of MS individuals were significantly
more (193, 77.8%) regarding nervous character (p value= .000). A family history of
ms was reported in 11%. However, there was no a significant difference between
men and women with respect to age, age of onset, BMI, disease duration and gap
between clinical onset and diagnosis. The education level was reported as 154 (62%)
had a bachelor and greater degree and 94 (38%) had a diploma or under-diploma
degree. Thirty six percents of the patients were born in the spring. Conclusions:
In contrast to reports from Caucasians, the Iranian differs with respect to age, age
of onset of illness, disease duration, family history, sex ratio. The sex ratio of 3: 1
in this study is somewhat higher than the usual 2: 1 in the standard text and seen
in Asia or the neighboring Arab countries. This might reflect the role of hormone
or genetic factors or much more visiting by women, or women stressful life. These
included BMI, birth season, education stand. The educated people in developing
country are probably likely to adopt a “western” lifestyle, therefore more probably
to get the risk of developing Western disease.
A393
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PND15
Epidemiology of Multiple Sclerosis in Latin America: Critical
Analysis of the Literature
Einarson T R 1, Bereza B 1, Machado M 2
1University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada, 2Biogen Idec, São Paulo, Brazil
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To summarize rates of prevalence, incidence and types of multiple
sclerosis (MS) in Latin America. Methods: We searched Medline, Embase, Scielo
and LILACS using key words “multiple sclerosis” and “esclerosis múltiple”, plus
“Latin America” and all country names. Accepted were full articles or abstracts
reporting original research in any language at any time, with MS diagnosed using
any acceptable criteria. Clinically isolated syndrome was excluded. Results: 1482
articles were identified and 203 reviewed in full; 88 were rejected and 115 were
analyzed (38 prevalence, 3 incidence, 2 both, 72 clinical epidemiology), including
68 (59%) full text and 47 (41%) abstracts. Studies originated in 14 countries, mostly
larger, more affluent nations (47% Brazil, 15% Argentina, 8% Mexico). Prevalence
studies examined 19,357 MS cases from 1968-2012; rates ranged from 0 in a group
of Mexican natives to 52/100,000 in Puerto Rico, with a mean of 13.9/100,000. This
range would be classified as low to medium, with 83,000 (CI95%: 62,000-104,000)
prevalent cases in Latin America. Incidences ranged from 0.15/100,000 personyears in Panama to 1.76 in Argentina (median= 1.32, mean= 1.35), or 7,887-8,365 new
cases/year in Latin America. Authors noted increasing prevalence and incidence
rates over time. Clinical epidemiology MS data were obtained from 94 studies; 66%
used Poser criteria, 48% McDonald (various versions), and 14% other, from 19,893
patients (72% females). The average age at assessment was 38.2 and 32.2 at disease
onset with average EDSS of 3.1. The relapsing-remitting form was most prevalent
(74% of cases), followed by secondary progressive (12%) and primary progressive
(10%). Conclusions: MS prevalence and incidence rates vary widely in Latin
America in a low to medium range, but are increasing as reported in the reviewed
studies. Information is scant with many gaps. More research is needed to provide
a basis for decision making and budget allocation.
PND16
Entacapone did not Increase Prostate Cancer Risk or Mortality
in Patients with Parkinson’s Disease
Korhonen P 1, Kuoppamäki M 2, Prami T 1, Hoti F 1, Christopher S 1, Ellmén J 2, Aho V 2,
Vahteristo M 2, Pukkala E 3, Haukka J 1
Research, Espoo, Finland, 2Orion Corporation, Espoo, Finland, 3Finnish Cancer Registry,
Helsinki, Finland
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1EPID
Objectives: The association between Parkinson’s disease (PD) and prostate cancer (PCA) is under discussion. We investigated whether exposure to entacapone
increases risk of PCA by comparing PCA incidence and mortality rates in PD patients
treated with levodopa and dopa decarboxylase inhibitors (DDCIs) with or without
entacapone as an adjuvant. Methods: This was a retrospective population-based
register cohort study in Finland. Male PD patients exposed to levodopa/DDCI with
entacapone and patients on levodopa/DDCI without entacapone between 1998 and
2009 were identified from the Finnish Prescription Register. Concomitant treatment with dopamine agonists (DA) and monoamine oxidase B (MAO-B) inhibitors
was allowed. PCA cases and PCA deaths were identified from the Finnish Cancer
Register and from the Cause of Death Register. PCA Incidence and mortality of
PCA were modeled by Cox’s proportional hazards model with adjustments for relevant baseline and time-dependent variables. The robustness of the findings for
PCA incidence was evaluated in sensitivity analyses with alternative definitions
for exposure and by using a nested case-control study setting with 4-5 individually
matched controls randomly selected for each incident prostate cancer case within
the cohort. Results: The study cohort consisted of 11 396 male patients. During a
mean follow-up time of 4.7 years 359 PCA cases and 89 PCA deaths were observed.
Entacapone use with levodopa/DDCI did not increase the risk of PCA incidence
[hazard ratio (HR) 1.05, 95% CI 0.76-1.44] or PCA mortality (HR 0.93,95% CI 0.43-1.98)
when compared to levodopa/DDCI without entacapone. For cumulative entacapone
use (exposure > 360 days vs. never use) the HR was 0.82 (95% CI 0.56-1.18) for PCA
incidence and 1.27 (95% CI 0.60-2.72) for PCA mortality. The results for PCA incidence
were found robust in the sensitivity analyses. Conclusions: No increased risk in
PCA incidence or PCA mortality was seen in relation to entacapone use.
Neurological Disorders – Cost Studies
PND17
The Clinical and Economic Value of Antibiotic-Impregnated Shunt
Catheters (AISC) in the Treatment of Hydrocephalus
Annoni E 1, Joedicke H 1, Birinyi-Strachan L 2
1Medtronic International, Tolochenaz, Switzerland, 2Medtronic Australasia, Sydney, Australia
.
.
.
Background: Shunt infections are one of the most serious and costly complications associated with shunt therapy. They can have long-term consequences
to the patient and impose significant burden on the family and health care system. Objectives: To investigate the clinical and economic value of AISC in the
treatment of Hydrocephalus. Methods: A search of the Embase, PubMed, and NHS
EED electronic databases was conducted to identify studies evaluating the effectiveness, efficacy and economic aspects of AISC’s in patients with Hydrocephalus. No
language restrictions were applied. Results: Twenty-three clinical and 9 economic
studies were included for review. The majority of published studies using AISC
in the treatment of hydrocephalus demonstrated a statistically significant reduction in shunt-associated infections when AISC vs. standard shunt (SS) catheters
were used. One meta-analysis of 14 studies that compared patients implanted with
AISC to SS catheters showed AISC to be protective against shunt infection in both
paediatric and adult Hydrocephalus patients. The pooled infection rate decreased
from 7.0% in the SS catheter group to 3.5% in the AISC group. Economic studies
conducted globally reported significant cost savings associated with using AISC.
One study in paediatric Hydrocephalus patients found that ongoing management
of shunt infections uses a disproportionate amount of hospital expenditure (71% of
total management costs or € 57,650 per patient) when compared to shunt revision
surgery (29% of total costs or € 6,720 per patient). Using shunt implant data from
the UK Hospital Episode Statistics (HES), procedures and interventions database,
we estimated the potential cost savings to the UK Health Care system in 2012-13
was £1,461,207 if all new lumboperitoneal or ventriculoperitoneal shunt surgeries
were performed using AISC systems. Conclusions: Current clinical evidence has
demonstrated AISC reduce infection rates in shunted Hydrocephalus patients. The
potential health care savings associated with reduced infection rates are significant.
PND18
Budget Impact Analysis of Fingolimod in Relapsing Remitting
Multiple Sclerosis
Ruggeri M 1, D’Ausilio A 2, Lo Muto R 3, Cottone S 4, Ghezzi A 5, Mecozzi A 6, Sacchini D 7,
Mangone M 8
1Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Rome, Italy, 2Creativ Ceutical, Milano, Italy, 3CreativCeutical, Milan, Italy, 4Azienda Ospedaliera Ospedali Riuniti Villa Sofia- Cervello, Palermo, Italy,
5Azienda Ospedaliera di Gallarate, Gallarate, Italy, 6Regione Lazio, Roma, Italy, 7Università
Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, ROMA, Italy, 8Novartis Farma S.p.A., Origgio, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In recent years, fingolimod and natalizumab - though expensive - have
brought significant improvements in second-line treatment of Multiple Sclerosis
(MS). In Italy, fingolimod was acknowledged in 2011 the therapeutic innovation
criterion which exempts the manufacturer from a mandatory discount of 5% on
the ex-factory price for a three-year period. Since the innovation period is soon
expiring and in order to assess the affordability of this therapy for the National and
Regional Healthcare Systems (HSs), we performed a Budget Impact Analysis (BIA)
of fingolimod in second-line treatment of MS, enclosed an ethical assessment of
justice issues. Methods: A model in MSExcel was built to perform the BIA on five
Regions located in the Nord, Centre and South of Italy. Interviews with regional
stakeholders/clinicians provided information about epidemiology, market share,
patient journey and resource consumption in the respective regions. Costs were
calculated using regional tariffs for outpatient/inpatient health care services. The
time horizon is three years which is the timeframe mostly requested by Healthcare
Authorities. Results: Preliminary results conducted for Lazio and Sicily show that,
in second line, the use of fingolimod compared to natalizumab leads to savings of
€ 2,500 per patient in Lazio and € 2,700 in Sicily due to lower consumption of health
care resources (different drug administration and patient management). The BIA
shows that fingolimod can determine savings up to € 3.4 million approximately
in Lazio and € 2.2 million in Sicily. Furthermore, if patients with frequent relapses
in first line were early switched to second line, savings could be even higher: an
additional € 2.0 million for Lazio and € 0.6 million for Sicily in the first year of treatment. Conclusions: The present analysis shows that, despite innovation expiry,
spending remains sustainable for fingolimod in the Italian and Regional HSs.
Analyses on the other Regions must be performed to confirm such results.
PND19
The Cost Burden of Switching Patients with Relapsing-Remitting
Multiple Sclerosis from Glatiramer Acetate To Newly-Approved
Disease Modifying Therapies
Blackney M 1, Kelly M 2, Zeidman R 2, Andreykiv M 3, Plich A 4
Inc., London, UK, 2Covance, Inc., London, UK, 3Teva Pharmaceuticals Europe B. V.,
Amsterdam, The Netherlands,, 4Teva Pharmaceuticals Europe B. V, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
1Covance
Objectives: Relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis (RRMS), the most common
form of MS, imposes a considerable cost burden on health care systems. Glatiramer
acetate 20mg/mL, a once-daily injectable disease modifying therapy (DMT), has
long-term real-world efficacy (more than two million patient/years exposure) for
the treatment of RRMS. An economic model was developed to estimate the financial
impact on the UK health care system of switching RRMS treatments from glatiramer acetate to emerging oral (teriflunomide and dimethyl fumarate) and infused
(alemtuzumab) DMTs over five years. Methods: The eligible patient population
in the model was estimated based on RRMS incidence rates, and the proportion
of people receiving glatiramer acetate in the UK in 2013 (based on market share
data). Medication costs were derived from British National Formulary list prices,
while treatment administration, initiation and monitoring costs were calculated
from UK health care unit and hospital tariff codes taking account of requirements
specified in Summary of Product Characteristics documentation. Results: The
model estimated that 5,900 people with RRMS were receiving glatiramer acetate in
the UK in 2013, corresponding to 17.8% of those currently receiving DMTs. Assuming
progressive switching within the eligible RRMS population from glatiramer acetate
to teriflunomide (from 1–6% in year one to five), dimethyl fumarate (1–6%) and
alemtuzumab (1–3%), additional spending of £17.0 million, £65.3 million and £147.6
million over one, three and five years, respectively, was incurred. This was primarily
driven by higher acquisition costs compared with glatiramer acetate. Administration
requirements associated with alemtuzumab, and the initiation and monitoring
requirements of the oral DMTs also contributed to additional costs. Conclusions:
No data exist supporting the clinical superiority – and therefore associated economic benefit – of the emerging DMTs over glatiramer acetate; switching patients
from glatiramer acetate to new therapies may be associated with substantial costs
for the UK health care system.
PND20
Improving Clinical Outcomes and Health Care Resources
Utilization in Multiple Sclerosis: A Portuguese Hospital Perspective
Viriato D , Carrasco J , Fonseca J, Pacheco R
Novartis, Porto Salvo, Portugal
.
.
.
Objectives: In Portugal there are about 2,694 patients treated with interferon
beta (IFNB) and it is estimated that 30.4% are poor responders. Fingolimod treatment costs are an obstacle to treatment escalation, despite the fact that early
initiation of fingolimod may impact favorably on long-term clinical outcomes.
A394
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
This analysis aimed to assess if the early switch from IFNB to fingolimod impacts
MS clinical outcomes and promotes better resource utilization in a Portuguese
hospital perspective. Methods: This analysis was based on TRANSFORMS phase
III trial extension data. A cost-effectiveness model was developed to calculate the
cost per relapse avoided with 4.5 years of continuous treatment with fingolimod
(early treatment) versus 1 year of treatment with IFNB followed by a 3.5 years of
treatment with fingolimod (delayed treatment). A Portuguese hospital perspective was adopted addressing only direct costs: drug, monitoring and relapses’
treatment. Drug costs were based on Portuguese list prices, while the unit cost
of each complication was obtained from the Diagnosis Related Groups tariff. The
costs of relapses were derived from the Portuguese literature. Results: Assuming
there are 819 patients treated with IFNB that are poor responders, the early treatment with fingolimod resulted in more relapses avoided when compared with
delayed treatment with fingolimod (2,211 versus 1,843). The early treatment with
fingolimod led to an increase of drug acquisition costs, but reduced costs associated to monitoring and relapses’ treatment. The total costs were 86,380,820€
for early treatment versus 79,257,091€ for delayed treatment. This represents an
average incremental investment of 1,933€ per patient per year. The early strategy
resulted an incremental cost effectiveness ratio of 19,358€ per relapse avoided
when compared with the delayed strategy. Conclusions: Under the Portuguese
hospital perspective, early treatment with fingolimod is expected to result in
better clinical outcomes associated with a more efficient health care resources
allocation.
Embase, Scielo and LILACS using the key words “multiple sclerosis” and “esclerosis
múltiple” plus “Latin America” and all country names. Full articles or abstracts from
meetings reporting original research on cost or economic analyses, budget impact
or resource utilization were obtained. No restrictions were placed on publication
date or language. All work was done in duplicate by two independent reviewers
with adjudication by consensus discussion. Results: We identified 1482 papers,
of which 27 were considered for analysis. There were 7 economic analyses (5 costeffectiveness, 2 cost-utility), 5 budget impact analyses, 10 cost analyses (6 drug
expenditures and 4 cost of illness), 4 on resource utilization and 1 on productivity
loss. Studies were obtained from 5 countries (18 Brazil, 3 Argentina, 3 Colombia, 2
Mexico, 1 Chile). Mostly (22/27, 81%) were published as abstracts; 5 were published
as full text articles (19%). Dates for these publications ranged from 2002 to 2013,
with an exponential increase over time. The number of MS patients is increasing
rapidly (71% increase in Brazil between 2006 and 2009). However, hospitalization
rates (overall and per patient) have been decreasing, as newer more effective drugs
have been increasingly used. Disease modulating therapies are predominantly
used. Costs of care are quite high and have risen dramatically, e. g. > 200% in Brazil
between 2007-2012, with beta-interferons mostly used (78%). Some high cost drugs
such as fingolimod and natalizumab have been found cost-effective over older drugs
such as beta-interferons or glatiramer acetate in Mexico, Brazil and Colombia, with
modest impact on budgets. Conclusions: Very little evidence related to cost of
MS has been produced in Latin America. More research is needed to better support
decisions regarding care of MS patients.
PND21
Cost Analysis of two Aftercare Strategies in Chronic Continuous
Intrathecal Baclofen Therapy in Patients with Intractable
Spasticity
PND24
Alzheimer’s Disease: Medication Costs and Impact of Generic
Substitution
Burgers L T 1, Goslinga-van der Gaag S M E2, Delhaas E M 2, Redekop W K 3
University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 2Erasmus Medical Center,
Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 3Erasmus University, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Erasmus
Objectives: Intrathecal baclofen (ITB) therapy is indicated for use in the management of intractable spasticity. Patients treated with ITB are required to receive a
pump refill at least once every three months in the hospital (standard care (SC)).
Since SC can be very burdensome for both patients and informal caregivers, an
alternative approach (Care4homecare) has been developed which enables patients
to receive pump refills at home. Moreover, the use of specially trained nurse practitioners ensures that there is no reduction in effectiveness. We compared the
costs of both strategies. Methods: Resource use in both strategies was estimated
using observational data of 38 adult patients with spasticity (due to e. g. multiple
sclerosis or spinal cord injury) that are currently living at home. We then combined this data with expert opinion and the Dutch costing manual to estimate
the total one-year costs from a societal perspective. Results: Patients included
in the analysis had on average an age of 52±14.4 years, 50% was men and patients
scored on average 44±12.5 points on the Care Dependency Scale. The Care4homecare
strategy involves care that is almost identical to SC and therefore can result in
comparable direct medical costs. However, patients receiving Care4homecare do
not incur any travel costs compared with SC patients (€ 489). In addition, the productivity costs of informal caregivers (SC € 195; Care4homecare € 40) and of patients
treated with Care4homecare are less than the costs of patients receiving SC. From
a societal perspective, the total costs of Care4homecare can be lower than that of
SC. Conclusions: Care4homecare is an alternative approach to treat patients
with intrathecal baclofen that can be cost-neutral from a health care sector perspective and cost-saving from a societal perspective. Moreover, it can be a welcome
option for many patients and caregivers who want to avoid the burden of regular
hospital visits.
PND22
Cost Analysis of the Use of Glatiramer Acetate Compared to
Interferon-Â in Patients with Relapsing-Remitting Multiple
Sclerosis and Spasticity in Spain
R 1, Garcia
L 2, Meca
J3
Sanchez de la Rosa
Bujalance
Lallana
1Teva Pharma, Madrid, Spain, 2Teva Pharmaceuticals, Madrid, Spain, 3Virgen de la Arrixaca
Hospital, Murcia, Spain
.
.
.
Objectives: To analyze the costs associated with first-line use of glatiramer acetate
(GA) compared to interferon-B (INF-β ) in patients with relapsing-remitting multiple
sclerosis (RRMS) and spasticity from the perspective of the National Health System
of Spain. Methods: A cost analysis of treatment and spasticity management with
INF-β compared to GA for 6 months were analyzed. The clinical data were taken from
the ESCALA study, which showed an improvement in spasticity in terms of spasm
frequencies, muscle tone, and pain 3 and 6 months after the start of GA therapy.
Unit costs for the resources used were taken from the BOTPLUS 2.0 database and
available literature. The cost analysis is expressed in euros as of 2014, and a price
discount of 7.5% was applied as set forth in Spanish Royal Decree 8/2010. Results:
The costs associated with the management of RRMS, spasticity, and relapses using
GA and INF-β were € 4,671.31 and € 7,078.02, respectively, generating a cost savings
of € 2,406.72/patient, in favour of GA. Conclusions: The use of AG in the firstline treatment of patients with RRMS not only improves spasticity but it could be
a strategy that offers savings cost after 6 months from the start of treatment. To
initiate the treatment with AG and keep it in patients with optimal response would
be a more efficient treatment option than INF-β .
PND23
Systematic Review of the Economics of Multiple Sclerosis in Latin
America
Einarson T R 1, Bereza B 1, Machado M 2
1University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada, 2Biogen Idec, São Paulo, Brazil
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To summarize published articles dealing with economic issues related
to multiple sclerosis (MS) in Latin America. Methods: We searched Medline,
Truter I
Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University, Port Elizabeth, South Africa
.
Objectives: Alzheimer’s disease has a substantial economic impact on patients,
their caregivers and society. There are four cognitive enhancers commonly used in
the treatment of Alzheimer’s disease: three cholinesterase inhibitors (donepezil,
rivastigmine and galantamine) and one NMDA receptor antagonist (memantine).
Studies have indicated that the cost of cholinesterase treatment may be offset by
savings in other health care costs. Methods: The cost of medication on the South
African market for Alzheimer’s disease was analysed using June 2014 retail prices
with the Defined Daily Dose (DDD) as unit cost indicator. A retrospective drug utilisation study was conducted on prescription data of a medical insurance scheme
administrator for 2012. Results: The cost per DDD for memantine was R26.20
(20 mg, two 10 mg tablets). For rivastigmine, the cost was R41.02 per DDD and for
galantamine R27.72 per DDD (using the most convenient dosage strengths). These
three products were all originator products. For donepezil, the originator and three
branded generics were available. The cost of the originator was R27.86 per DDD, and
for all three generics R16.29 per DDD. Only 32 patients were included in the drug
utilisation study since not all medical aids reimburse these products. The average age of patients was 74.17 (SD= 9.54) years, with 50% females. Only memantine
and donepezil were prescribed. Donepezil accounted for 77.48% of prescriptions
(of which 60.93% were generic prescriptions). The average Prescribed Daily Doses
(PDDs) were 16.30 (SD=4.92) mg for memantine and 8.73 (SD=2.84) mg for donepezil.
The most frequent PDDs for memantine was 20 mg (62.96% of prescriptions) and
10 mg (37.04% of prescriptions), and for donepezil 10 mg (65.96% of prescriptions)
and 5 mg (29.79% of prescriptions). Conclusions: More South African studies on
Alzheimer’s disease treatment cost are needed that include the stage of the disease
and adherence to treatment.
PND25
Costs Associated with the Use of Enzyme-Inducing Anti-Epileptic
Drugs Versus Non-Enzyme-Inducing Anti-Epileptic Drugs:
A Systematic Review
Xiong T 1, Gallagher E 2, MacGilchrist K S 1, Thieffry S 2
1Abacus International, Oxfordshire, UK, 2UCB Pharma, Brussels, Belgium
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Several commonly prescribed enzyme-inducing anti-epileptic drugs
(EIAEDs) stimulate the synthesis of some hepatic enzymes responsible for drug
metabolism. This synthesis can lead to complications by altering endogenous
metabolic pathways or by affecting the elimination of concomitant drugs thus
increasing health care costs. This study aimed to systematically review published
estimates of direct and indirect costs associated with the use of EIAEDs compared
with non-enzyme-inducing anti-epileptic drugs (nEIAEDs) in patients with focal
and generalised seizures, and to evaluate methodological differences between the
studies. Methods: Comprehensive electronic searches were undertaken using
MEDLINE, EMBASE, Cochrane Library, EconLit, relevant conference proceedings
and cost effectiveness analysis registries. All studies reporting any direct and
indirect costs of AEDs for the treatment of patients with epileptic seizures were
included. Study quality assessment was performed for every included study
using a predesigned check list. Results: Thirty-seven full-length articles and
two abstracts reporting costs were reviewed. Two studies reported AED costs,
drug-specific adverse event costs and non-drug health care costs subsequent to
the initiation of each individual AED (medical visits, MRI scans, etc.). Six studies
reported specific AED costs and the overall subsequent non-drug health care cost
without stratification by event. Eighteen studies reported AED acquisition costs
but did not report any other subsequent AED-related health care costs stratified
by treatment. Thirteen studies reported the whole cost of illness with only a list
of AEDs included. To date, no study has been specifically designed to compare
the total costs between EIAED and nEIAED use, although some studies compared
direct and indirect costs of several newer AEDs versus older AEDs. Conclusions:
Insufficient data and heterogeneity in methodology prevent valid comparisons
being made between the total cost of EIAEDs and nEIAEDs. More research is
required to identify if meaningful differences in the total cost of treatment exist
between EIAEDs and nEIAEDs.
A395
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PND26
Pharmacoeconomic Study of Botulinium Toxin Type a in Treatment
of Post-Stroke Spasticity in the Russian Federation:
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis
Yagudina R , Kulikov A , Ugrekhelidze D
I.M. Sechenov First Moscow State Medical University, Moscow, Russia
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess the cost-effectiveness of abobotulinumtoxinA, onabotulinumtoxinA, incobotulinumtoxinA and local standard therapy (oral muscle relaxers)
in patients with post-stroke spasticity in Russia for 1-year period. Physical therapy
was used in all therapy schemes. Methods: A decision tree was used to simulate
the effects of abobotulinumtoxinA, onabotulinumtoxinA, incobotulinumtoxinA and
standard therapy. The data on drugs efficacy (measured as decrease in the Modified
Ashworth scale (MAS) score) was obtained from available clinical trials [1-3]. The following costs were taken into account:, the costs of BTA and other drugs, costs of inpatient and outpatient care in the Russian Federation, costs of adverse events, disability
pensions, GDP loss due to post-stroke spasticity. Costs of BTA and other drugs were
taken from the essential drug list and the database of drugs prices. Medical care costs
were estimated from the Standard of treatment of stroke consequences developed by
Ministry of Health of the Russian Federation. Costs of adverse events were calculated
basing on Russian clinical guidelines and database of drugs prices. Disability pensions were taken from Russian Pension Fund database. GDP loss was based on the
GDP information from World Bank. Cost-effectiveness ratio (CER) of BTA and standard therapy was calculated and compared in four treatment schemes. Results:
Therapy with abobotulinumtoxinA showed most prominent decrease of Modified
Ashworth score equal to 1,67, as for onabotulinumtoxinA – 1,17, incobotulinumtoxinA – 0,87, standard therapy – 0,67. The calculated CER in USD per 1 spasticity decrease point according to MAS was lowest for abobotulinumtoxinA (389524
RUB/11356 $) in comparison with onabotulinumtoxinA (635631 RUB/18532 $); incobotulinumtoxinA (798750 RUB/23287 $) and standard therapy (873312 RUB/25461 $).
Conclusions: Therapy conversion to abobotulinumtoxinA comparing with standard therapy, onabotulinumtoxinA and incobotulinumtoxinA was associated with
decrease of spasticity. Transfer to abobotulinumtoxinA is considered cost-effective
in patients with post-stroke spasticity, given a cost-effectiveness ratio 389524
RUB/11356 $.
PND27
Cost Comparison of Deep Drain Stimulation (DBS) and Continued
Subcutaneous Apomorphine Infusion (CSAI) in Patients with
Advanced Parkinson’s Disease
Walleser Autiero S 1, Eggington S 1, Valyi A 2
1Medtronic International Trading Sarl, Tolochenaz, Switzerland, 2Medtronic Ltd UK & Ireland,
Watford, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: Deep Brain Stimulation (DBS) for the treatment of advanced
Parkinson’s Disease (PD) is a therapy supported with high level evidence, however
no direct comparative studies exist of DBS against other therapy options, such as
continued subcutaneous apomorphine infusion (CSAI) exists. The objective of this
study was to evaluate the 5-year cost profiles of two therapies for advanced PD, DBS
and CSAI, from a UK payer perspective. Methods: A Markov model, previously used
to model cost-effectiveness of DBS+BMT vs BMT alone (Eggington 2013), served to
evaluate the cost profile of DBS and CSAI over five-years. Equal efficacy of the two
therapies was assumed. The cost analysis covered: device acquisition, implantation, adverse event management, concomitant drug use, device replacements and
follow-up. Cost data were taken from UK national tariffs, combined with device/
drug price lists and data from previous economic studies of interventions for PD.
Disease-related inputs were based on recent studies of DBS and CSAI in patients
with advanced PD, plus long-term data from the literature. Costs were discounted
at 3.5% per annum. Results: Total discounted costs over 5 years were £69,566 and
£80,843 for DBS and CSAI, respectively, leading to cost savings of £11,277 of DBS
compared to CSAI over 5 years. DBS is cost saving compared to CSAI from 3 years
onwards, with the initial costs of DBS device acquisition shown to be offset by the
on-going provision of CSAI. Conclusions: The results indicate that DBS requires
less health care resources than CSAI over five-years. Comparative clinical data are
needed to formally assess the relative cost-effectiveness of the two interventions.
PND28
Retrospective Analysis of the Economic Burden of U. S. Long-Term
Care Facility Residents Diagnosed with Parkinson’s Disease
Huang A 1, Shrestha S 1, Baser O 2, Wang L 1
1STATinMED Research, Plano, TX, USA, 2STATinMED Research and The University of Michigan,
Ann Arbor, MI, USA
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To examine the health care utilizations and costs of long-term care
facility patients diagnosed with Parkinson’s disease (PD). Methods: Patients
diagnosed with PD (International Classification of Disease, 9thRevision, Clinical
Modification [ICD-9-CM] diagnosis code 332) were identified using the Minimum
Data Set (MDS) linked to 5% Medicare data from 01JAN2009 through 31DEC 2010.
The initial diagnosis date was designated as the index date. A comparison cohort
was created for patients without a PD diagnosis, using 1: 1 propensity score matching (PSM) to control for age, region, gender, index year and baseline Charlson
Comorbidity Index score. The index date for the comparison group was randomly
chosen to reduce selection bias. Patients in both cohorts were required to be at
least age 65 years, have at least two consecutive quarterly assessments in MDS
data in the 6 months prior to the index date, and have continuous medical and
pharmacy benefits 1 year before and after index date. Study outcomes, (health
care costs and utilizations) were compared between the disease and comparator
cohorts, based on the matched sample. Results: After applying PSM, a total of
986 patients were included in each group (diseased and comparator cohorts), and
baseline characteristics were balanced. A higher percentage of patients with PD
had inpatient admissions (35.09% vs. 30.32%, p= 0.02), outpatient visits (93.91%
vs. 89.45%, p< 0.001) and durable medical equipment (DME) utilization (27.69% vs.
21.91%, p< 0.01), compared to those without a PD diagnosis. The PD cohort also
incurred significantly higher skilled nursing facility ($6,458 vs. $5,182, p= 0.03), DME
($344 vs. $206, p< 0.01) and pharmacy costs ($6,025 vs. $4,998, p< 0.0001) compared
to the comparison cohort. Conclusions: Study results suggest that patients
diagnosed with PD incurred significantly higher costs and had higher resource
utilization than those without a PD diagnosis.
PND29
Relationship Between the Direct Medical Costs and Direct
Non-Medical Costs of Parkinson’s Disease According to
Disease Severity During 4 Years of Follow-Up in Spain
Martinez P 1, Rodriguez-Blazquez C 1, Paz S 2, Lizán L 3, Forjaz M J 4, Frades B 5, Moreno R 6
Center for Epidemiology and CIBERNED, Carlos III Institute of Health, Madrid, Spain,
2Outcomes’10, Castellon, Spain, 3Outcomes 10, Castellon, Spain, 4National School of Public Health
and REDISSEC, Carlos III Institute of Health, Madrid, Spain, 5Alzheimer Center Reina Sofia
Foundation, Carlos III Institute of Health, Madrid, Spain, 6Infanta Cristina Hospital, Madrid, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1National
Objectives: To describe the medical and non-medical direct costs of PD in relation to the total direct cost and its variation with disease severity during 4 years
of follow-up. Methods: A descriptive, observational, longitudinal study in PD
patients belonging to the ELEP study (2007-2010). Data on disease severity and use
of resources were collected for three consecutive months, yearly, for 4 years. Direct
medical (funded medical equipment, medications and medical assistance) and
direct non-medical costs (alternative care, home assistance, non-funded medical
equipment and medications) for 4 years depending on severity by Hoehn and Yahr
(HY) was described. Costs were estimated by multiplying rates obtained from the
database Oblikue (http://www.oblikue.com) and pharmacy costs from the BotPlus
Web (https://botplusweb.portalfarma.com) by the number of resources used,
updated to Spanish € , 2012. Results: 198 patients were included. Average age:
63±11 years, 50% male, mean PD duration of 8±6 years. Mild (HYI-II) and moderate
(HYIII) PD varied from 76% and 21% to 64% and 29%, respectively during follow-up.
Total direct cost was higher in severe stages, being in year 4, € 1,477.32 HYI (95%CI:
219.55-2,735.10) and € 3,606.66 HYIV (95%CI: 893.97-6,319.35) compared to year 1,
€ 1,093.32 HYI (95%CI: 624.99-1,561.65) to € 2,656.27 HYIV (95%CI: -53.14-5,365.68).
Direct medical costs ranged from € 886.62 (95%CI: 475.13-1,298.11) HYI and € 2,376.30
HYIV (95%CI: -53.12-4,805.73) in year 1 to € 909.96 HYI (95%CI: 942.43-1,327.49) and
€ 2,768.49 HYIV (95%CI: 34.21-5,502.76) at year 4. Direct non-medical cost variation
were determined by PD temporal evolution, increasing between year 1 and 4 within
each stage, € 723.47 to € 4,255.20 HYI and € 653.27 to € 1,676.35 HYIV. Conclusions:
The economic burden of PD rises with duration and severity of the disease, progressively increasing the direct, medical and non-medical costs. Besides to improve
patients’ HRQoL, therapies aimed at controlling the symptoms severity will favor a
more efficient management of the disease.
PND30
Does Current Portuguese Financing Model for Multiple Sclerosis
Covers for Estimated Needs?
Montóia B 1, Guerreiro T 1, Viana R 2
1Novartis Farma – Produtos Farmaceuticos S. A., Porto Salvo, Portugal, 2Novartis Farma-Produtos
Farmacêuticos S. A., Portugal, Porto Salvo, Portugal
.
.
.
Objectives: Portuguese financing model set for Multiple Sclerosis (MS) establishes
a comprehensive price of 1.031,65€ per remitting patient/month. This study aimed
to estimate global and individual direct costs of MS in Portugal and evaluate the
coverage of MS Financing model for Relapsing-Remiting Multiple Sclerosis (RRMS)
patients. Methods: A cost-of-illness (COI) approach was taken to assess direct
costs/per RRMS patient by EDSS level, both for remission and relapse status using
Delphi methodology for clinical practice measurement. Portuguese epidemiological
data available for prevalence and relative distribution by EDSS level was used to
estimate global MS costs and an average cost per RRMS patient. Results: The global
cost for RRMS in Portugal is estimated to be approximately 83M€ /year for patients
treated with 1st line Disease Modifying Therapies (DMT). Relapse treatment costs
account for 8M€ . Direct costs estimated per disability level show that disability
levels are directly related with expenditure in RRMS patients in remission (EDSS≤ 3:
10.754,90€ ; 3,5≤ EDSS≤ 4,5: 20.113,99€ ; 5≤ EDSS≤ 6: 21.170,36€ ; EDSS≥ 6,5: 24.945,94€ ).
The same was observed for relapse cost (EDSS≤3: 4.952,23€; 3,5≤EDSS≤4,5: 5.568,49€;
5≤ EDSS≤ 6: 8.801,03€ ; EDSS≥ 6,5: 9.265,31€ ). An average cost of 14.563,48€ per
RRMS patient was estimated based on Portuguese EDSS epidemiological distribution. Conclusions: Current comprehensive financing model per patient does
not cover the costs associated with an average RRMS patient. We demonstrated
that considering the epidemiological distribution per EDSS level there is a gap of
2.183,68€ (14.563,48€ vs. 12.379,80€ ). In addition, it was estimated that 2nd line high
efficacy treatments (additional investment of 76% in treatment costs) may lead up to
4.3M€ savings in relapse treatment total costs by reducing annualized relapse rate.
Further studies should be developed to assess the budget impact of 2nd line high
efficacy treatments on disability progression since lower EDSS scales are associated
with less expenditure per patient (EDSS≤ 3: 10.754,90€ vs EDSS ≥ 6,5: 24.945,94€ ).
PND31
Pharmacoeconomic Aspects of Multiple Sclerosis Treatments in
Iran
Khanizadeh H 1, Izham M 2, Nikkhah K 3
SAINS MALAYSIA, penang, Malaysia, 2Universiti Sains Malaysia, Pinang, Palau
Pinang, Malaysia, 3Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Khorasan, Iran
.
.
.
1UNIVERSITY
Objectives: Multiple Sclerosis (MS) is a chronic and progressive which represents
a catastrophic payment to patient, society and health care system. Iran, differing
to the other countries in Middle- east, is considered to have a medium to high
prevalence of MS. Although much is known about the MS cost in the world, there
is a very paucity of the MS cost study in Iran. The aim of study was to estimate the
costs and QOL in MS individuals and determine whether these costs increase as
disability progress. Methods: We studied 160 MS patients who attended in the MS
A396
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
association of Khorasan privence (the widest province in Iran ). Quality of life was
measured with MSQOL-54 instrument. Data was collected by employing a 32- item
self-administered questionnaire in a face to face interview. Parametric, nonparametric tests and descriptive statistics analysis were applied (p value<0.05). Patients
were grouped into three disability stages according to their Expanded Disability
Scale Score (EDSS). Results: The Patients mean age was 31.78 (SD: 9.67 ) years,
% 73.8 were female and %26.3 were male, and their mean EDSS was 2.4 (SD; 1.26)
whereas EDSS increases, the costs also increases, which is a positive correlation.
The mean QOL was 0.54 that as QOL increases, the costs decreases, which is a negative correlation. The MS medications (Interferon) have a cost around $ 46625 per
year for each patient that are subsidized about $ 24452 IR by governmental sector.
Up to $ 17104 are paid by insurance and $ 5263 directly by patients. The costs per
patient-year were calculated as $ 11560) - 27970.5591 (EDSS= 1-2.5), $ 29916.90930015.645 (EDSS= 3-4.5) and $34678.776- 34793.22 (EDSS= 5- 7.5). Conclusions:
We conclude that the costs are relevant in MS, especially when disability increases.
The catastrophic cost has a high burden to patients, society and health care system
PND32
Whole Exome Sequencing as a Diagnostic Tool for Complex
Neurological Disorders
Frederix G W 1, Monroe G 2, Hövels A M 1, van Haaften G 2
University, Utrecht, The Netherlands, 2Utrecht University Medical Center, Utrecht, The
Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
apy. Methods: Observational, non-interventional, prospective, single-center study
of 1 year follow-up from ITB implant onward. Results: 20 consecutive patients with
ITB indication were recruited; 13 received an ITB implant during the study period;
1 implant was rejected and thus explanted. 12 patients, of whom 10 had spasticity
due to spinal-cord injury, 1 to multiple sclerosis and 1 to adrenoleukodistrophy, provided data for the study and 9 completed follow-up. After 12 months of ITB, mean
changes from baseline were: -2.6 on the Penn scale (p= 0.011), -1.1 (p=0.059) and -2.8
(p=0.011) on the Ashworth upper and lower scale, respectively and +4.4 on the FIM
scale (p=0.075). Mean utility gain, assessed with the HUI3 scale, was 0.054 (p= 0.091)
after 1 year. Mean total ITB test and permanent implant cost per patient were € 528
and € 14,225, respectively. Mean quarterly spending on oral antispastics decreased
by € 42 at month 12, while consumption of intrathecal baclofen stabilized after 6
months at € 39. At baseline, 4 patients received botulinum injections, while none
did at the end of follow-up. Catheter-related adverse events occurred in 2 out of 12
patients, with a total mean cost per event of € 2.387. While waiting to receive ITB,
spasticity-related hospitalizations due to urological complications occurred in 2 out of
20 patients, with a mean cost of € 9.044 per event; no such events were observed after
ITB implant. Conclusions: Clinical outcomes of patients with N-FDS improved
after ITB. Initial therapy costs were considerable, but were partially offset by savings
in drugs and spasticity-related events after 1 year follow-up. Results should be interpreted cautiously because of the small number of observations.
1Utrecht
Objectives: The primary objective of this study is to elucidate the effect of whole
exome sequencing (WES) in diagnosing children with a developmental delay due to
unexplained conditions presumed to be genetic. A secondary objective is to collect
all resources used by these children to gain insight into the total costs over time for
the traditional diagnostic pathway and the additional costs to diagnose a patient
using WES. Methods: We included twenty children at the Sylvia Toth Centre (STC)
in Utrecht, the Netherlands, who have underwent previously extensive clinical diagnostic workups and for whom no diagnosis was found after the last extensive workup.
On all twenty children and parents WES will be performed, thereby obtaining a list
of exonic candidate mutations for each patient. In parallel all resources used were
collected by assessing the clinical records of patients. These resources were linked
to unit costs to obtain the total cost per patient. Total cost per patient was then compared to the cost of care using WES, assessed for each individual patient. Results:
The diagnostic yield from the 13 patients sequenced thus far is 23% indicating a 23%
increase in number of diagnoses compared to the current diagnostic pathway. On
average these patients have had numerous visits to the hospital, overnight stays
and different diagnostic workups to unravel the genetic cause of their neurological disorder. Total cost of the current diagnostic pathway is therefore up to ten fold
higher compared to the total cost of only providing WES. Conclusions: Comparing
the diagnosis and costs with and without the use of WES gives a clear picture of the
clinical and economic feasibility of putting WES into standard diagnostic practice at
the STC and similar genetic centers over the world.
PND33
Financial and Clinical Implications of Intramuscular Versus
Subcutaneous Interferon Beta-1a in Portugal, Based on the
Findings from the Cochrane Collaboration Review of First-Line
Treatments for Relapsing-Remitting Multiple Sclerosis
Silverio N 1, Sequeira L 1, Meletiche D 2
1Merck SA, Alges, Portugal, 2EMD Serono, rockland, ME, USA
.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate the clinical and financial impact of Interferon beta-1a
intramuscular (IM) and subcutaneous (SC) formulations in Portugal, based on the
findings from Cochrane review regarding first-line treatments for relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis. Methods: An Excel-based model estimated the number of
relapses and costs incurred by a hypothetical cohort of 1000 patients treated with
two types of interferon beta-1a. The model evaluated the consequences of treatment
with SC versus IM interferon beta-1a, as this was the only comparison whose data
quality was assessed as ‘high’ by the Cochrane Review (Filippini 2013). Risk of relapse
was based on the 2-year data from the Cochrane meta-analysis. The analysis was
performed from a Portuguese National Health Service (NHS) perspective including
only direct costs. Although efficacy was kept constant as Cochrane did not report
outcomes based on Expanded Disability Status Scale (EDSS), costs of relapse were
available for patients with different EDSS values, thus allowing estimation of cost
impact for different types of population. Results: According to the model, treatment with IM interferon beta-1a is expected to result in a total of 743 episodes of
relapse, whereas SC interferon beta-1a is expected to result in a total of 570 cases,
less 173 cases, over a 2-year period. Use of the SC formulation in a population with
EDSS ≤ 3 will result in savings of € 690,213.04 over the 2-year period due to avoided
relapses. In a more severe population, with EDSS between 3.5 and 4.5, these savings
are expected to be € 889,865.74 over the same 2-year period. Conclusions: When
compared with the IM formulation, the use of SC interferon beta-1a seems to be
associated with fewer cases of relapse, resulting over a 2-year period in considerable
potential savings to the NHS in terms of relapses avoided.
PND34
Clinical Outcomes and Health Care Resource Utilization in a
1-Year Observational Study of Patients with Non-focal Disabling
Spasticity who are Resistant or Intolerant to Oral Therapy
Treated with Intrathecal Baclofen Therapy at the Institut
Guttmann (Spain). Epice Study
PND35
Nuedexta for the Treatment of Pseudobulbar Affect: Estimating the
Financial Impact to the Scottish NHS
Kiff C 1, Mealing S 1, Singh M 1, Baculea S 1, Badhan A 1, Yonan C 2
1ICON Health Economics, Oxford, UK, 2Avanir Pharmaceuticals, Inc., Aliso Viejo, CA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Pseudobulbar Affect (PBA) is a neurologic disorder of emotional
expression, resulting in frequent and involuntary episodes of crying and/or laughing. Common neurological conditions associated with PBA include: Alzheimer’s
disease, amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, multiple sclerosis, Parkinson’s disease, stroke
and traumatic brain injury. Nuedexta® (Avanir Pharmaceuticals Inc.) is the only
EMA-approved PBA treatment. The financial impact of introducing Nuedexta to
a national health care system, including Scotland, has never been formally estimated. Methods: An Excel® based cost-calculator was developed. Prevalence,
epidemiology and mortality estimates for causative neurological conditions as
well as PBA prevalence in those conditions were sourced from the literature. Unit
costs (drugs, hospitalisation etc.) were taken from national databases and standard
care treatment mix and resource use were derived from a US claims database. A
range of market uptake rates were used with further sensitivity analyses undertaken. Results: The estimated cost of standard care in Scotland for PBA is circa
£32.4 million annually (circa 22,500 patients). In year 1 following introduction, 67
patients are expected to receive Nuedexta, resulting in a cost increase by £0.1 million to £32.5 million. By year five, 836 patients are estimated to receive Nuedexta,
resulting in a projected total annual cost of £34.6 million. Therefore the estimated
annual budget impact of Nuedexta ranges from £0.15 million (year 1) to £1.88 million (year 5). The incremental cost per patient is £2,246. The model was sensitive
to changes in uptake rates, cost of background therapy and PBA symptom severity.
When patients with moderate to severe PBA symptoms receive treatment, the projected cumulative year 5 budget impact estimate is £7.56 million. Conclusions:
The estimated financial impact of introducing Nuedexta in Scotland is modest. Even
if more patients are identified, the relatively small incremental cost per-patient of
Nuedexta is unlikely to have a major impact on the Scottish NHS.
PND36
Analysis of Expenditure in Multiple Sclerosis Disease Modifying
Therapies Evolution Between 2004-2013 in Spain
Villoro R 1, Hidalgo A 2
Max Weber, Madrid, Spain, 2University of Castilla La Mancha, Toledo, Spain
.
.
1Instituto
Objectives: To analyze factors of recent evolution of Multiple Sclerosis (MS) Disease
Modifying Therapies (DMT) budgets in Spain between 2004 and 2013. Methods:
2004-2013 single DMT monthly expenditure was provided by IMS Health. Monthly and
annually evolution of number of patients, billing, drug cost per patient and cost per
year of treatment were calculated. Two periods: 2004-2013 and 2007 (start marketing
second lines DMT) -2013 period were analyzed for each DMT line. (First line: subcutaneous and intramuscular interferon (IFN) β -1a, subcutaneous IFN β -1b and glatiramer acetate
injection. Second line: natalizumab and fingolimod). Results: During 2004-2013 DMT
expenditure increased from €115.5M to €319.3M due to: A greater number of patients
147% (10.60 % annual growth per year) and a further growth of annual cost per patient:
12% (1.29 % annual growth per year). In December 2013 second lines correspond to
a 29.61% of DMT expenditure. Annual cost per patient in second line represents 70%
over cost per treated patient and 83% greater than first line DMT cost per year. If
year 2007 is omitted from analysis (Only 68 second-line treatments and M1.44€ of
associated expense) and is analyzed 2008-2013 period, second-line DMT represent
43% of new treatments causing a 60% increase in DMT expenditure. In 2013 second
line DMT participation reaches 64% of new regimens causing the 79% of increase DMT
expenditure. Conclusions: The growing incorporation of new therapies and the
noticeable rise in the number of treated patients (10.60 % annual growth per year) are
components to consider in the pharmaceutical budget management.
PND37
Health Care Resource Use and Cost Of Multiple Sclerosis in
Slovakia: Results from the National Cross-Sectional Study
Slof J 1, Serrano D 2, Álvarez López-Dóriga M 3, Álvarez M 3, Marqués T 4, Benito J 4, Vidal J 4
1Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, Bellaterra, Spain, 2Autonomous Consultant, Barbera del
Valles, Spain, 3Medtronic Ibérica, S. A., Madrid, Spain, 4Institut Guttmann, Barcelona, Spain
Ondrusova M1, Psenkova M1, Donath V2
1Pharm-In Ltd, Bratislava, Slovak Republic, 2F.D. Roosvelt University Hospital, Banska Bystrica,
Slovak Republic
Objectives: To assess clinical outcomes, health care resource utilization and associated costs of intrathecal baclofen therapy (ITB) for the treatment of non-focal
disabling spasticity (N-FDS) in patients who are resistant or intolerant to oral ther-
Objectives: Comprehensive economic costs of multiple sclerosis (MS) according to EDSS states can only be assessed by evaluating MS management in real
clinical practice. The objective of this cross-sectional study was to measure the
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A397
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
resource utilisation and the costs associated with health care management of MS
in Slovakia and to provide a basis for cost-effectiveness evaluations. Methods:
Descriptive epidemiological data of 2,552 MS patients from 27 MS-centers across
Slovakia were collected electronically and analyzed. In 152 selected patients followed up in 2011-2012 in 34 MS centers, all types of health care services and costs
were analyzed. These patients were randomly included in the study. Continuous
variables were calculated using standard descriptive statistical methods. Results:
77% of patients had the relapsing-remitting form of MS (RRMS); 60 % of patients
were in EDSS 1-3, mean age of patients at the time of diagnosis was 32.3 (± 9.7) years,
and 68% of patients were females. Total direct health care costs, DMT excluded,
ranged from € 752 to EDSS 1 to € 2,839 to EDSS 7, being the lowest for EDSS9 (at
€ 963). Costs for DMT ranged from € 8,584 for EDSS1 to € 13,026 in EDSS4, being lower
for EDSS6 (€ 1,668) and none for EDSS7-9.67% patients were receiving 1st line DMT,
and 14 % receiving 2nd line treatment. DMT was mostly applied in EDSS 2 (97%).
The most frequently used DMTs were glatiramer acetate (20%), interferon beta1a IM (15%), natalizumab (9%) and fingolimod (5%). The most expensive grade 1/2
adverse events were abdominal pain (46.62 €), pain in joints, back and arms (39.35 €).
Conclusions: This cross-sectional study determined the average annual direct
cost per MS patient to be € 1,640; DMT excluded. As the EDSS increases, DMT costs
decrease (except of EDSS1-2) and the costs of medical devices rise.
PND38
Cost of Health Care Services Offered by Parkinson Disease
Associations in Spain
Galvez M 1, Prades M 2, Paz S 2, Lizán L 2
Española de Párkinson, Madrid, Spain, 2Outcomes’10, Castellon, Spain
.
.
.
.
1Federación
Objectives: In Spain, Parkinson Disease Associations (PDA) offers a wide range of
care services with partial and variable financial support from the government. The
study objective was to estimate the costs of PDA services and to calculate the potential savings that they represent to the National Health System (NHS). Methods:
A survey conducted by the Federation of PDA collected information on their location, number of members, type and use by patients of the offered services. Services
were classified according to whether or not they were financed by the NHS, based
on the existing national portfolio for reimbursed services. Weekly use was recorded
and costs were calculated upon official rates (updated to € , 2014). Potential savings
for the NHS were estimated by calculating the weekly cost associated to unfinanced
services that were provided by the PDA. Results: 42 Spanish PDA that embraced a
total of 11,420 patients participated in the study. From the 26 services offered, speech
therapy (n=41), physiotherapy (n=39), cognitive stimulation (n=23) and occupational therapy (n=23) were the most frequently offered and used. The weekly cost
associated to the provided services was €655,219.87 [mean: €15,980.97 (SD: 22,662.98)]
per PDA. 53.8% of services were classified as potentially refundable by the NHS. Costs
assaignable to potentially financed services represented 78.29%, reaching savings for
the NHS of €512,971.60/week. The cost of physiotherapy (27.3%) and of the adapted
transport (21.3%) were the main components. Costs attributable to services not usually
financed by the NHS accounted for 21.71% (€142,248.23), mostly attributable to cognitive
stimulation costs (63.39%). Conclusions: PDA offer valuable services to patients and
carers and afford a major proportion of the costs of the supportive and complementary
care of the disease. Their economic efforts imply great savings to the NHS in Spain.
PND39
The Impact of Adherence and Development of Neutralizing
Antibodies to Interferons β on Treatment of Multiple Sclerosis
in the Czech Republic
Kruntoradova K 1, Klimes J 1, Dolezal T 1, Mandelikova M 1, Pavlikova P 2
OUTCOMES, Prague, Czech Republic,, 2Biogen Idec, Prague, Czech Republic
.
.
.
.
.
1VALUE
Objectives: To compare clinical outcomes (reduction in relapse number) and
costs associated with multiple sclerosis (MS) treatment with one of the interferon
β in the Czech Republic in five-year horizon based on development of neutralizing antibodies (NAbs) and patient non-adherence. Intramuscular (IM) interferon
β -1a is characterized by very high adherence rate and low rate of NAbs production. Methods: Markov cohort model was developed with one-year cycle length.
In the Czech Republic, patients with MS initiate treatment with one of the interferon
β. NAbs-positive patients (in the model, NAbs are detected during the second year of
treatment and thereafter) are switched/escalated to a different disease modifying
drugs; DMD (glatiramer acetate, fingolimod, natalizumab). If patients experience
two or more relapses during one year of treatment, they are escalated to fingolimod or natalizumab. Adherence data, development of NAbs, relapse rate and costs
were sourced from the literature. Results: One hundred patients, who initiated
treatment with IM interferon β -1a, experienced 287 relapses over 5 years. Those,
who started treatment with subcutaneous (SC) interferon β -1a and interferon β -1b,
experienced by 15 and 19 relapses more. In one hundred patients, total cost of
treatment with IM interferon β -1a was 6.4 million € . This was about 139-200 thousand € less compared to SC interferon β -1a and interferon β -1b. Hence incremental
cost-effectiveness ratio was -262 thousand € /relapse avoided and -285 thousand
€ /relapse avoided. Conclusions: Intramuscular interferon β -1a represents dominant intervention in MS treatment, i. e. cost-saving treatment from payer’s perspective and simultaneously more efficacy intervention in terms of reduction in number
of relapses due to better patient adherence and lower incidence of NAbs compare
to the other interferons β in the Czech Republic. The one-way sensitivity analyses
showed that results are the most sensitive to DMD costs and relapse rate.
PND40
An Economic Evaluation of Subcutaneous and Intramuscular
Interferon Beta-1a in Multiple Sclerosis Using a Direct Head-ToHead Study
Phillips A L 1, Edwards N C 2, Locklear J C 1
1EMD Serono, Inc., Rockland, MA, USA, 2Health Services Consulting Corporation, Boxborough,
MA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To use health economic modeling techniques to quantify and compare
the clinical and economic outcomes associated with the use of subcutaneous interferon beta-1a (scIFNβ1a) vs. intramuscular interferon beta-1a (imIFNβ1a) over 2 years
in the management of relapsing forms of multiple sclerosis (MS) from a US health
care payer perspective. Methods: The 2-year decision analytic model was populated with IMS LifeLink Plus prevalence and treatment data, and clinical data from
the EVIDENCE (EVidence of Interferon Dose-response: European North American
Comparative Efficacy) study, a direct head-to-head comparison of 44 mcg scIFNβ 1a
three times a week vs. 30 mcg imIFNβ 1a once a week. Relapse data from 16-month
results were extrapolated for the 2-year model. Disease-modifying drug (DMD) costs
were based on 2014 wholesale average cost with consideration of patient copayment in the base case. The model was created with the ability to customize the rate
of copayment as well as to incorporate contractual discounts, if desired. One-way
sensitivity analyses were conducted on key parameters using alternate plausible
values, including the rates of real-world DMD adherence. Results: For a hypothetical health plan with 1 million members, it is estimated that 911 patients with MS
would be treated with DMDs. More relapses were avoided with scIFNβ1a over 2 years
(979) than with imIFNβ1a over 2 years (778). The average cost-effectiveness of 44 mcg
scIFNβ 1a was lower (more favourable) than the average cost-effectiveness of 30 mcg
imIFNβ 1a ($123,854 vs. $148,749 per relapse avoided). Sensitivity analyses around
model input values showed the model was robust and cost-effectiveness results
were consistent. The model results are most sensitive to drug cost. Conclusions:
Cost-effectiveness assessment may facilitate the decision-making process in selecting MS treatments. Using the highest-quality clinical data (Level 1, head-to-head
study, EVIDENCE), the cost-effectiveness of 44 mcg scIFNβ 1a was shown to be favourable compared with 30 mcg imIFNβ 1a.
PND41
Cost-Effectiveness Evaluation of Data from the Evidence
(Evidence of Interferon Dose-Response: European North American
Comparative Efficacy) Study
Phillips A L 1, Edwards N C 2, Locklear J C 1
1EMD Serono, Inc., Rockland, MA, USA, 2Health Services Consulting Corporation, Boxborough,
MA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of 44 mcg subcutaneous interferon
beta-1a (scIFNβ1a) and intramuscular interferon beta-1a (imIFNβ1a) during the comparative and open-label extension phases of the EVIDENCE (EVidence of Interferon
Dose-response: European North American Comparative Efficacy) study. Methods:
A decision analytic model from a US health care payer perspective was populated
with 2-year data from the EVIDENCE study of imIFNβ 1a and 44 mcg scIFNβ 1a (comparative and open-label extension phases). EVIDENCE results showed that the annualized relapse rate of 44 mcg scIFNβ 1a patients was 0.46 during the comparative
phase and 0.34 during the open-label extension phase. The annualized relapse rate
of imIFNβ1a patients during the comparative phase was 0.64. imIFNβ1a patients who
switched to 44 mcg scIFNβ 1a for the open-label extension phase had an annualized
relapse rate of 0.32. These data were used to model the cost-effectiveness of 44 mcg
scIFNβ 1a and imIFNβ 1a patients during the comparative phase as well as for the
combined comparative and open-label extension phases (for patients remaining
on scIFNβ 1a throughout and for those switching from imIFNβ 1a in the comparative
phase to scIFNβ 1a in the open-label extension). Disease-modifying drug (DMD) cost
was based on 2014 wholesale average cost with consideration of patient copayment
in the base case. Results: The cost-effectiveness for 44 mcg scIFNβ 1a and imIFNβ1a
during the comparative phase was $123,854 and $148,749 per relapse avoided,
respectively. The cost-effectiveness of patients who remained on 44 mcg scIFNβ 1a
throughout the study was $99,398 per relapse avoided, while the cost-effectiveness
of imIFNβ 1a patients who switched to 44 mcg scIFNβ1a for the open-label extension
was $116,404 per relapse avoided. Sensitivity analyses showed that the model was
robust and was most sensitive to DMD cost. Conclusions: This decision analytic
model evaluation shows that remaining on 44 mcg scIFNβ 1a and switching from
imIFNβ 1a to 44 mcg scIFNβ 1a were cost-effective treatment strategies.
PND42
Economic Evaluation of Lacosamide in the Management of Epileptic
Partial Onset Seizures in Greece
Geitona M 1, Kousoulakou H 1, Carayianni V 2, Baltogiannis C 3, Garganis K 4, Gatzonis
S 5, Giannakodimos S 6, Kodounis A 7, Nasios G 8, Polychronopoulos P 9, Christou P 10,
Theodoratou D 11, Karachalios G 11, Palaistis S 11
1University of Peloponnese, Corinth, Greece, 2Technological Educational Institution of Athens,
Athens, Greece, 3IASO General Hospital, Athens, Greece, 4Agios Loukas Hospital, Thessaloniki,
Greece, 5National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, General Hospital of Athens, Athens,
Greece, 6General Hospital of Athens, Athens, Greece, 7251 Hellenic Air Force Hospital, Athens,
Greece, 8Technological Educational Institute of Epirus, Ioannina, Greece, 9University Hospital of
Patras, Patra, Greece, 10UCB Pharma, Athens, Greece, 11UCB AE, Athens, Greece
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess the cost-effectiveness of Lacosamide (LCM) in the management of epileptic partial onset seizures (POS) versus standard AED therapy in Greece,
as well as its impact on the health care budget. Methods: A cost-effectiveness
model was developed simulating the treatment pathway of a hypothetical cohort of
1000 patients over two years. A comprehensive literature search was conducted to
identify local resource use data for medical, pharmaceutical and hospital treatment.
Due to lack of relevant data, an expert panel with 8 neurologists was convened. The
perspective was that of the Social Insurance Fund, and unit costs were taken from
officially published sources (Ministry of Health and Social Insurance Fund). Primary
and secondary analyses were carried out, in which the treatment algorithm was
based on trial data and was adapted to the Greek setting, respectively. Deterministic
and probabilistic sensitivity analyses were conducted to test the model’ results. In
addition, a budget impact analysis (BIA) was carried out to estimate the annual
cost of treating uncontrolled epileptic patients in Greece. Results: Treatment with
LCM was shown to be dominant compared to standard therapy, as it is associated
with 38 additional QALYs and reduced cost by € 410,024 and € 754,684 in the primary
A398
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
and secondary analysis, respectively. Extensive sensitivity analyses indicated that
results were robust. The most influential parameters were the utility estimates,
probability of hospitalization per seizure and unit cost of hospitalization. The BIA
showed that the annual cost of treating uncontrolled epileptic patients with LCM
in Greece ranges between € 274.9 and € 271.5 million, in the primary and secondary
analyses, respectively, compared to the respective costs with standard AED (€ 277.3
and € 279.9 million). Conclusions: LCM appears to be both less costly and more
effective compared with standard AED treatment in Greece and results in cost savings ranging between € 2.4 and € 8.3 million. Study funded by UCB Pharma.
PND43
Cost-Effectiveness of Subcutaneous VersUS Intramuscular
Interferon Beta-1A In Portugal Based on the Findings of Cochrane
Collaboration Review of First-Line Treatments for RelapsingRemitting Multiple Sclerosis
Silverio N 1, Sequeira L 1, Meletiche D 2
1Merck SA, Alges, Portugal, 2EMD Serono, rockland, ME, USA
.
.
.
with 44 mcg scIFNβ 1a in patients with EDSS > 3.5–5.0 was 1.21 per patient over 2
years. The mean number of relapses avoided for the overall study population was
0.74 per patient over 2 years. The average cost-effectiveness of 44 mcg scIFNβ 1a
was estimated to be $107,861 per relapse avoided for the EDSS > 3.5–5.0 cohort. The
average cost-effectiveness for the overall study population was estimated to be
$181,208 per relapse avoided. Sensitivity analyses showed that results were robust
to changes in key input parameters such as DMD costs, the number of relapses in
untreated patients, the relative risk reduction in clinical relapse rates, the rate of
adherence, and the average cost of relapse. Conclusions: Based on model results,
the average cost-effectiveness of 44 mcg scIFNβ 1a was favorable for both the overall
study population and the EDSS > 3.5–5.0 cohort.
PND46
A Cost-Utility Analysis of Sacral Anterior Root Stimulation (SARS)
Compared to Medical Treatment in Complete Spinal Cord Injured
Patients with a Neurological Bladder
Bénard A 1, Morlière C 1, Verpillot E 2, Donon L 1, Salmi L R 1, Joseph P A 1, Vignes J R 1
Bordeaux, Bordeaux, France, 2Université de Bordeaux, Bordeaux, France
.
Objectives: To estimate the cost-effectiveness of Interferon beta-1a subcutaneous (SC) when compared with Interferon beta-1a intramuscular (IM) in Portugal,
based on the findings published by the Cochrane review of first-line treatments for
relapse-remitting multiple sclerosis. Methods: An Excel-based model estimated
the number of relapses and costs incurred by a cohort of 3,000 patients treated
with two types of interferon beta-1a. The model evaluated the consequences of
each treatment based on the findings of a Cochrane meta-analysis (Filippini 2013).
The analysis was performed from a Portuguese NHS perspective, including only
direct costs. Costs of relapse were obtained from a local publication (Mateus C,
2000) whereas costs of both drugs were obtained from local official databases (Cat@
logo). Although efficacy was kept constant as Cochrane did not report outcomes
based on EDSS, costs of relapse were available for patients with different EDSS
values, thus allowing estimation of cost-effectiveness for different types of population. Results: According to the model, over a 2 year period and in a population
with EDSS ≤ 3, treatment with IM interferon beta-1a will result in a total of 2,228
relapses, and a total cost of 69,572,717€ , whereas treatment with SC interferon beta1a will result in 1,709 relapses and a total cost of 70,480,835€ . For a population with
EDSS between 3.5 and 4.5 cost values for IM and SC are 72,141,975€ and 72,451,135€ ,
respectively. Cost-effectiveness ratios were 1,748€ per relapse avoided when EDSS ≤
3 and 595€ per relapse avoided when EDSS was between 3.5 and 4.5. Conclusions:
Considering that the cost of a relapse varies between 3,896€ (EDSS ≤ 3) and 5,139€
(EDSS between 3.5 and 4.5) the incremental cost-effectiveness ratios found for
interferon beta-1a SC seem to indicate that that SC interferon beta-1a is a costeffective alternative to the use of IM interferon beta-1a.
PND44
Treating VersUS Non-Treating Obsturictive Sleep Apnea in Italy and
France: A Markov Model-Based Cost-Effectiveness Analysis
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1CHU
Objectives: To estimate the cost-utility of sacral anterior root stimulation (SARS,
using the Finetech-Brindley device) compared to medical treatment (anticholinergics + catheterization) in complete spinal cord injured patients with a neurological
bladder. Methods: A probabilistic Markov model was elaborated with a 10-year
time-horizon, one-year cycles and a 2.5% discount rate. Three irreversible states
were defined: 1) treatment without urinary complication; 2) surgery for urinary complication (sphincterotomy, urinary derivation); 3) death. Reversible states (urinary
calculi; Finetech-Brindley device failures) were integrated in the two first irreversible
states. A systematic review and meta-analysis were performed to estimate transition probabilities and Quality Ajusted Life Years (QALYs). In the perspective of the
French Healthcare System, costs were estimated from a published comparative
cost-effectiveness research (Neurosurgery 2014; 73: 600), and through simulations
using the 2013 French prospective payment system (PMSI) classification. Results:
In the primary analysis, the cost-utility ratio was 10,647€ /QALY gained. At a 30,000€
ceiling ratio the probability of SARS being cost-effective compared to medical treatment was 63%. If the French Healthcare System reimbursed SARS for 200 patients/
year the two first years and 50 patients/year during 8 years (anticipated target
population) the expected incremental net health benefit would be 222 QALYs, and
the expected value of perfect information (EVPI) would be 4,570,000€ . The highest
partial EVPI is reached for transition probabilities toward urinary calculi (4,420,000€ ).
With discount rates of 1% and 6% the cost-utility ratios were 6,951 and 19,770€ /
QALY gained, and the probabilities of SARS being cost-effective were 66% and 58%,
respectively. Conclusions: Our model shows that SARS using Finetech-Brindley
device offers the most important benefit and should be considered cost-effective
at a 30,000€ ceiling ratio. Despite a high uncertainty, EVPI and partial EVPI may
indicate that further research would not be profitable to inform decision making.
Whitehouse J T 1, Da Deppo L 2, Lazzaro C 3, Pedretti R F E 4, La Rovere M T 5, Pepin J L 6,
Defaye P 6
1GfK Market Access, Melton Mowbray, UK, 2Boston Scientific, Milan, Italy, 3Studio di Economia
Sanitaria, Milan, Italy, 4IRCCS Fondazione Salvatore Maugeri Tradate, Tradate Milano, Italy,
5IRCCS Fondazione Salvatore Maugeri Montescano, Montescano, Italy, 6Université Grenoble Alpes,
Grenoble, France
PND47
Comparison of a Markov Cohort Model and a Discrete-Event
Simulation for Economic Analyses of Treatments for
Multiple Sclerosis
Objectives: To investigate the cost-effectiveness of treating vs. not treating
obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) in Italy and France Methods: A 5-year, 10-state
Markov model with disease states including; disease and event-free with OSA, diabetes, hypertension, myocardial infarction [MI], post-MI, stroke, post-stroke, atrial
fibrillation [AF], heart failure [HF], and death; was developed to compare costs, outcomes, and event-free life-years (LYS) of treating vs not treating OSA from the Italian
National Health Service (INHS) and French National Health System (FNSH) viewpoint. Health care resources included those related to diagnosis, treatment (CPAP
only) and follow-up of OSA; management of hypertension, diabetes, HT, AF, post MI,
and post-stroke (per year); MI, and stroke (per episode). Health care resources were
valued at Euro (€) 2012 using published sources. Results: After 5 years the number
of incremental event-free LYS per patient treated for OSA reaches 0.31 (Italy: 4.15
vs 3.84; France: 4.07 vs 3.76). Treating OSA incurs an incremental cost of €1011.01
and € 2998.45per patient for Italy and France, respectively. The ICER of treating OSA
is € 3212.39 for Italy and € 9777.09 for France, respectively. Conclusions: Treating
OSA can be considered highly cost-effective for both the INHS and the FNSH when
compared to the acceptability range for incremental cost effectiveness proposed
for Italy (€ 25,000-€ 40,000) and for Europe (€ 50,000).
Objectives: Multiple sclerosis (MS) is a disease with lifelong impact, making the
cost-effectiveness (CE) of its treatments particularly sensitive to assumptions
embedded in model designs. Traditional sensitivity analysis (SA) can test many
assumptions, but it is not designed to investigate sensitivity to structural assumptions. The aim of this study was to compare a Markov cohort model (MM) and a
discrete-event simulation (DES) model of MS that were based on common clinical
data but developed independently to understand the impact of their structural differences on model predictions. Methods: A similar population was simulated in
the MM and the DES model; aggregated cost and utility estimates were compared
over varying time horizons. The average expanded disability status scale (EDSS) and
the distribution of EDSS were also compared over time to study the dynamics of
disease progression and treatment effects. Results: The two modeling approaches
led to different natural history behavior over longer time horizons, even after shortterm behaviors were well-aligned, with the DES model predicting slightly fewer
life-years (25.9 vs. 26.2 in the MM) but more quality-adjusted life-years (9.6 vs. 8.1
in the MM). These differences reflect slower progression of EDSS in the DES model,
particularly to higher EDSS states. When disease history (including a baseline EDSS
term) was excluded from the DES model, the natural history simulations of the
two models agreed more closely. Conclusions: Structural SA can help quantify
the impact of key modeling decisions. In this study, a comparison of an MM and
a DES model showed that natural history predictions diverge over long time horizons, in part due to the consideration of disease history in the DES model. A better
understanding of the differences between the two model designs helps ensure
interpretation of the model results while taking into consideration the assumptions
embedded in those designs.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
PND45
Cost-Effectiveness of Subcutaneous Interferon Beta-1A in a SubPopulation of Multiple Sclerosis Patients (Kurtzke Expanded
Disability Status Scale [EDSS]: > 3.5–5.0)
Phillips A L 1, Edwards N C 2, Locklear J C 1
1EMD Serono, Inc., Rockland, MA, USA, 2Health Services Consulting Corporation, Boxborough,
MA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of 44 mcg subcutaneous interferon
beta-1a (scIFNβ 1a) in patients with multiple sclerosis (MS) with Kurtzke Expanded
Disability Status Scale (EDSS) score > 3.5–5.0. Methods: The analysis was performed from a US payer perspective. The time horizon of the analysis was 2 years.
The decision analytic model was populated with real-world inputs and related
assumptions, as well as pivotal placebo-controlled clinical trial data for 44 mcg
scIFNβ1a 3 times a week (PRISMS Study). Clinical inputs were obtained for the overall
study population as well as a subpopulation of patients with Kurtzke EDSS score
> 3.5–5.0. Disease-modifying drug (DMD) cost was based on 2014 wholesale average
cost with consideration of patient copayment in the base case. Sensitivity analyses
were conducted on key input variables to assess their impact on cost per relapse
avoided. Results: Model results showed that the mean number of relapses avoided
Kansal A 1, Tafazzoli A 1, Leipold R 1, Sarda S 2
Idec, Weston, MA, USA
.
.
.
.
1Evidera, Bethesda, MD, USA, 2Biogen
PND48
The Long-Term Value of Glatiramer Acetate for the Treatment of
Relapsing Remitting Multiple Sclerosis in the Netherlands
Wilson,L E 1,2, Prüfert A 2
.
.
.
1Quintiles, Reading, UK, 2Quintiles, Hoofddorp, The
Netherlands
Objectives: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of glatiramer acetate (Copaxone®)
as a disease-modifying treatment (DMT) for relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis (RRMS) compared to intravenous [natalizumab (Tysabri®), alemtuzumab
(Lemtrada®) ] or subcutaneous injectables [interferon-beta-1b (Betaferon®), interferon-beta-1a 44mcg, 22mcg, 30mcg (Rebif-44®, Rebif-22®, Avonex®) ] and oral DMTs
[fingolimod (Gilenya®), dimethyl fumarate (Tecfidera®), teriflunomide (Aubagio®)].
Methods: A Markov model followed patients over 50 years through 21 health
A399
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
states: Expanded Disability Status Scale (EDSS) 0-9 for patients with RRMS and
secondary progressive multiple sclerosis (SPMS), respectively, and death (EDSS10).
Total treatment costs, quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs) gained and incremental
cost-effectiveness ratios (ICERs) were calculated from the Dutch societal perspective. Baseline demographics; transition probabilities; treatment-specific relative
risks; and utility values were obtained from published literature. Health resource
use was based on the products’ SmPCs. Unit costs were based on national tariffs and published data. A base case analysis considered the direct and indirect
costs of treatment. To test the robustness of the results, univariate and probabilistic sensitivity analyses (PSA) were performed. Results: Total treatment costs
of glatiramer acetate were lower versus teriflunomide, interferon-beta-1a 44mcg,
30mcg, fingolimod, natalizumab, dimethyl fumarate and alemtuzumab; and higher
versus interferon-beta-1a 22mcg, interferon-beta-1b, and BSC. Glatiramer acetate
dominated interferon-beta-1a 44mcg and 30mcg, and was cost-effective versus
other comparators at a willingness-to-pay threshold of € 20,000/QALY. The PSA
indicated these results were robust. Univariate analysis showed that relative risks
of disease progression and drug costs were the most influential model parameters. Conclusions: In the Netherlands, glatiramer acetate is a cost-effective
treatment versus a number of other treatments indicated in multiple sclerosis,
and results proved robust.
Pnd49
Expected Value of Partial Perfect Information for the Disability
Progression Efficacy of Teriflunomide and Fingolimod in the
Treatment of Relapsing-Remitting Multiple Sclerosis
Maruszczak M 1, Kusel J 1, Adlard N 2
1Costello Medical Consulting Ltd., Cambridge, UK, 2Novartis Pharmaceuticals UK Limited,
Surrey, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: To calculate the expected value of partial perfect information (EVPPI)
of the disability progression efficacy for teriflunomide and fingolimod in relapsingremitting multiple sclerosis (RRMS) and investigate the potential differences between
these two disease modifying therapies (DMTs). Methods: A cohort Markov model
based on the ScHARR model structure was developed from the UK NHS perspective,
which allows the cost-effectiveness of the DMTs to be calculated and also has the
additional ability to calculate the EVPPIs for progression efficacies. The evaluated
intervention consists of beta-interferons followed by fingolimod. The comparator
treatment includes beta-interferon therapy followed by teriflunomide. The EVPPIs
for both drugs were calculated and compared. Results: The EVPPIs varied substantially depending on the evaluated drug and the specific willingness-to-pay (WTP).
Although both EVPPI curves had a similar shape, the curve for teriflunomide had an
EVPPI equal or larger compared to fingolimod’s curve for every WTP value. At a WTP
of £30,000 per QALY, the EVPPI per patient of teriflunomide and fingolimod were
£252 and £50, respectively. In the sensitivity analysis, where the uncertainty around
the estimate of teriflunomide progression efficacy was artificially lowered to that of
fingolimod, the divergence between the EVPPI curves was reduced substantially, confirming that the uncertainty around teriflunomide progression efficacy is driving its
higher EVPPI. Conclusions: Higher EVPPI estimates of teriflunomide indicate that
the precise knowledge of the disability progression efficacy of teriflunomide would
be considerably more valuable to the decision maker than that of fingolimod. One
of the main factors affecting larger EVPPI of teriflunomide’s progression efficacy is a
higher uncertainty concerning effects of teriflunomide. There are, however, many data
limitations and uncertainties within the DMT modelling. Additionally, the expected
value of sample information analysis (EVSI) would be required in order to evaluate
more precisely the cost-effectiveness of additional clinical trials.
PND50
Cost-Minimisation Analysis of Colistimethate Sodium in Serbia- off
Label Use Approach
Djordjevic J 1, Mitrovic M 1, Marinkovic V 1, Tasic L 2, Krajnovic D 2
Pharma doo Serbia, Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro, 2University of Belgrade – Faculty
of Pharmacy, Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Colistimethate sodium (Colistin) is an old, “forgotten” antibiotics
revived due to multidrug-resistant Gram-negative bacteria in nosocomial infections. In many countries, both – intravenous and inhalational administrations of
Colistin have marketing authorisation. In Serbia, Colistin is registered only for
intravenous administration. Therefore, inhalational administration of Colistin in
treatment for cystic fibrosis is considered as off label use. AIM: The purpose of
this study was to assess benefits of Colistin off label use, currently available in
Serbia, for treatment for cystic fibrosis. Methods: Data collected from a review
of the literature (Pubmed searching key word off label, Colistin, Tobramycine, cost
minimisation) and data from Health Insurance Fond of Republic Serbia (2014)
were used to perform a cost-minimisation analysis comparing DDD in inhalation
administration of Colistin with Tobramycin (official methodology in Serbia for drug
reimbursement Listing). Results: Both, Colistin and Tobramycine are effective
in cystic fibrosis treatment. The cost of treatment per patient per year in Serbia is
3 616,00 Euro for Colistin and 5 950,00 Euro for Tobramycin. Total savings per year
for 200 registered patients in Serbia could be 466 857,00 Euro. Conclusions:
Given cost-minimisation analysis justified the treatment with Colistin as cost
saving therapeutic alternative to Tobramycin for cystic fibrosis patients in Serbia.
The lack of guidelines and principles regarding off label medicine use in health
care policy and decision making in Serbia was evidently an obstacle for better
patients care.
PND51
Health Care Utilization and Costs of Medicaid Program Services
for Patients Diagnosed with Multiple Sclerosis
Li L 1, Shrestha S 1, Baser O 2, Wang L 1
Research, Plano, TX, USA, 2STATinMED Research and The University of Michigan,
Ann Arbor, MI, USA
.
.
.
.
PND52
Cost-Utility Analysis (cua) Of First-Line Disease-Modifying
Treatments (DMT) Versus Best Supportive Care (Bsc) In Finnish
Relapsing-Remitting Multiple Sclerosis (RRMS) Patients
Soini E 1, Asseburg C 1, Sumelahti M L 2
1ESiOR Oy, Kuopio, Finland, 2School of Medicine, University of Tampere, Finland
.
.
.
.
Objectives: CUA of teriflunomide and first-line DMTs (glatiramer acetate (GA),
interferon-β -1a (IFNβ -1a: intramuscular IM, or subcutaneous SC) or interferon-β -1b
(IFNβ -1b)), compared to BSC in Finnish RRMS-patients. Methods: Register study
and Markov cohort modelling. During the 50-year time horizon, patients could stay
or progress to another Expanded Disability Status Scale (EDSS) state, experience
relapse (with/without hospitalisation), adverse events (AEs) or death. EQ-5D utilities were derived from literature, and Finnish costs (health care 2013; official drug
costs 4/2014 without VAT) were associated with EDSS, relapses, and AEs. Indirect
treatment comparison informed treatment effects. EDSS-related standardised mortality ratios (SMR) and RRMS-progression were analysed from Finnish MS-register
(Tampere, Vaasa, Seinäjoki regions; 1359 patients). Other health risks were based
on literature. Cohort characteristics were estimated from a subgroup (713 patients,
clinically confirmed RRMS, age, gender and EDSS 0–6.5 at first DMT initiation).
Caregiver’s disutility, Finnish productivity losses, and informal care costs were
included in sensitivity analysis (societal perspective). Costs and quality-adjusted
life-years (QALYs) were discounted with 3%/year. Results: Expected lifetime health
care [societal] costs per patient were: teriflunomide: € 798,864 [€ 1,596,570], IFNβ -1aSC: € 805,069 [€ 1,618,344], IFNβ -1b: € 826,633 [€ 1,647,745], GA: € 823,438 [€ 1,649,961],
IFNβ -1a-IM: € 820,516 [€ 1,645,472], and BSC: € 788,932 [€ 1,626,554]. Respective QALYs
were 6.55 [5.44], 6.27 [5.13], 6.15 [4.99], 6.05 [4.88], 6.04 [4.87], and 5.79 [4.60]. From
the payer [societal] perspective, incremental cost per QALY gained of teriflunomide
was € 13,089 [dominant] relative to BSC, and teriflunomide dominated other firstline DMTs. Teriflunomide had 83% [per-patient expected value of perfect information, EVPI € 241], 98% [EVPI € 22], and 100% [EVPI € 0] cost-effectiveness probability
with € 0, € 10,000, and € 20,000 per additional QALY, respectively. Conclusions:
Cost-effectiveness analyses of first-line DMTs compared to BSC showed that teriflunomide provided lowest cost and highest number of QALYs and was therefore
dominant over IFNβ s and GA for Finnish RRMS patients.
.
1Alvogen
1STATinMED
Objectives: Health care resource utilization and costs were evaluated for patients
diagnosed with multiple sclerosis (MS) in the U. S. Medicaid program. Methods:
Patients diagnosed with MS (International Classification of Disease, 9thRevision,
Clinical Modification [ICD-9-CM] diagnosis code 340) were identified using Medicaid
data from 01JAN2008 through 31DEC2010. The initial diagnosis date was designated
as the index date. Patients of the same age, race, and gender but without an MS
diagnosis were identified and matched as the comparison cohort, with a randomly
chosen index date to minimize selection bias. Patients in both groups were required
to be at least age 18 years, and have continuous medical and pharmacy benefits
1 year before and 1 year post-index date. One-to-one propensity score matching
(PSM) was used to compare health care costs and utilizations during the follow-up
period, between the diseased and the comparison cohorts, and adjusted for baseline
demographic and clinical characteristics. Results: After risk adjustment by PSM, a
total of 14,179 patients in each cohort were matched. Significantly more MS patients
had inpatient admissions (23.75% vs. 10.87%, p<0.0001) and long-term care (22.64%
vs. 4.13%, p< 0.0001), other service (99.70% vs. 89.00%, p< 0.0001) and pharmacy visits
(73.08% vs. 67.71%, p< 0.0001) compared to those without an MS diagnosis. Higher
health care utilization by MS patients led to significantly higher inpatient ($1,688
vs. $725, p< 0.0001), long-term care ($14,189 vs. $2,778, p< 0.0001), other service visit
($22,981 vs. $9,977, p< 0.0001) and pharmacy costs ($5,284 vs. $1,785, p< 0.0001) compared to those without MS. Conclusions: Compared to patients in the comparator
cohort, MS patients in the Medicaid program incurred substantially higher health
care resource utilization and costs.
PND53
Cost-Effectiveness Model Results of Intrathecal Baclofen Therapy
Compared to Conventional Medical Management in Patients with
Non-Focal Disabling Spasticity Who are Resistant or Intolerant to
Oral Therapy at the Institut Guttmann
Slof J 1, Serrano D 2, Álvarez M 3, Álvarez López-Dóriga M 3, Marqués T 4, Benito J 4, Vidal J 4
1Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, Bellaterra, Spain, 2Autonomous Consultant, Barbera del
Valles, Spain, 3Medtronic Ibérica, S.A., Madrid, Spain, 4Institut Guttmann, Barcelona, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate the cost-effectiveness of intrathecal baclofen therapy (ITB) against conventional medical management (CMM) in non-focal
disabling spasticity (N-FDS) patients who are resistant or intolerant to oral therapy. Methods: A markov model was developed to estimate clinical and economic
outcomes for patients treated with ITB or CMM. Treatment effects, patients´ baseline characteristics, resource utilization and health utility values were taken from
the EPICE study. The model was built in accordance with the Institut Guttmann´s
clinical practice, a reference center in Spain. Unit costs were obtained from the
cited center. The analysis was conducted from the Institut Guttmann´s perspective over a lifetime horizon with direct medical costs (2013) and outcomes discounted at 3%. Uncertainty was assessed through univariate and multivariate
sensitivity analysis (SA). Results: When comparing ITB with CMM, the model
estimates ITB would increase remaining lifetime costs by € 35,605 and result in a
QALY gain of 1.06; thus showing an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of
€ 33,619 per QALY gained. SA reflecting the most current clinical practice at the
Institut Guttmann (where now a new catheter, associated with an 80% reduction
in adverse events, is used) showed an ICER of € 27,805 per QALY gained. ICER
results were also sensitive to changes in the post-operation hospitalization period,
baclofen dose titration management, pump battery life, and health utility values. Conclusions: The present evaluation results in an ICER of ITB against CMM,
in the treatment of N-FDS patients who are resistant or intolerant to oral therapy
at the Institut Guttmann, close to a willingness-to-pay threshold of € 30,000 per
A400
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
QALY gained. However, SA results indicate that the ICER drops below this threshold
when most current clinical practice at the cited center is considered. Moreover, SA
results suggest potential ways to optimize the current clinical pathway in order
to reduce procedure costs even further.
PND54
Long-Term Costs and Consequences of Patients with Familial
Chylomicronemia Syndrome – A Simulation Model Approach
Lin F , Thomas S , Calado F , Clegg J
Novartis, East Hanover, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
Background: Familial chylomicronemia syndrome (FCS) is a rare genetic disorder characterized by deficiency of lipoprotein lipase, causing accumulation of
chylomicrons. An estimated 0.1-0.2 per 100,000 people has FCS worldwide. FCS
patients present massively elevated triglyceride levels (typically > 2,000 mg/dL),
resulting in increased risk of recurring acute pancreatitis. Standard triglyceride
lowering medications are ineffective for FCS patients, who rely on restrictive
low fat diet to control their triglyceride. There is limited literature about longterm progression, the burden of illness or consequences of acute pancreatitis for
FCS. Objectives: To estimate long term disease progression, costs and consequences of FCS. Methods: An individual Monte Carlo simulation model was built
to track disease progression of a cohort of FCS patients with a mean age of 37.8
years, 60% male, and a mean triglyceride level of 2,741 mg/dL. The model projected
the number of acute pancreatitis events, mortality and medical costs. Benefits
of a hypothetical triglyceride reduction intervention were assessed. Results:
With standard diet control, the average life expectancy of the studied cohort was
estimated to be 16.45 years. These patients were expected to experience 10.16
episodes of acute pancreatitis during their lifetime, resulting in 80.7 inpatient days.
The discounted lifetime cost of acute pancreatitis was projected to be $154,126
per patient. The cumulative mortality due to acute pancreatitis was estimated to
be 54.3%. Should an intervention reduce triglyceride levels by 50% in FCS patients,
the life expectancy would be increased by 3.16 years and 7.72 fewer episodes of
acute pancreatitis would occur, preventing 61.21 inpatient days and saving
$118,594 in medical cost. Conclusions: FCS patients are at high risk of lifethreatening and costly acute pancreatitis. Reduction in triglyceride levels has a
significant impact of morbidity and mortality associated with acute pancreatitis.
An effective triglyceride lowering intervention could mitigate the consequences
of FCS significantly.
PND55
Working Ability and Monetarily Valued Productivity of Patients
with Multiple Sclerosis Treated with Natalizumab
Kreimendahl F 1, Rychlik R P T 1, Patel S 2, Gleissner E 2, Becker V 3
1Institute of Empirical Health Economics, Burscheid, Germany, 2Biogen Idec GmbH, Ismaning,
Germany, 3Neurologische Praxis Eppendorf, Hamburg, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Relapsing remitting multiple sclerosis (RRMS) is a chronic inflammatory disease that represents the most common chronic neurological disorder
in young adults. RRMS often leads to disability and is a major cause of reduced
working capacity due to neurological diseases. Aim of this study is to investigate
patients’ working productivity during treatment with natalizumab. Methods:
RRMS-Patients treated with natalizumab for a maximum of three months prior to
baseline were eligible for study participation. Patients completed the EQ-5D and
a questionnaire focused on occupational status, working ability, and days absent
from work at study start study, after 6 months and 12 months. Socio-demographic
and clinical data were collected. Primary endpoint was work productivity, which
is defined as hours worked. To estimate costs and cost offsets due to the therapy
with natalizumab, an average monetary value per working hour has been calculated to value productivity monetarily. Results: Preliminary results including 95
patients after 6 months of therapy show a significant increase in work productivity
of 84 hours (p= 0.014) for the whole study population compared to baseline. The
average reduction of days absent from work was 4.8 days compared to baseline.
The increase in working hours leads to an average change of monetarily valued
productivity per patient and half-year from 6,550.40€ at baseline to 7,600.35€ after
6 months for the entire study population. A subgroup analysis has been run on
the group of employed patients. The working hours increased significantly by
63h per half-year (p= 0.025). Conclusions: In this study, the preliminary results
show a significant increase in work productivity, which leads to a significant
increase in the monetary value of productivity, for RRMS-patients treated with
natalizumab. An increase in working hours as well as a decrease in days absent
from work led to an increase in monetarily valued productivity. Study was funded
by Biogen-Idec.
Neurological Disorders – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference
Studies
PND56
Using a Panel Survey to Identify Predictors of Disease-Modifying
Drug Adherence in Patients with Multiple Sclerosis
Phillips A L 1, Kozma C M 2, Locklear J C 1
Serono, Inc., Rockland, MA, USA, 2Independent Research Consultant, Saint Helena Island,
SC, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
1EMD
Objectives: Identify predictors of multiple sclerosis (MS) disease-modifying drug
(DMD) adherence. Methods: A random sample of adult MS patients from the US
National Health and Wellness Survey or Lightspeed Research panel completed an
internet survey in Nov/Dec2012. Clinical trial–naïve subjects with relapsing-remitting MS who were on their current DMD for ≥ 4months were included. Adherence
was measured using the 4-item Morisky Scale. Patients were assigned to ‘high’
(negative response to all 4 questions: forget to take, careless at times about taking, stop if better, stop if worse) or ‘intermediate/low’ (any positive response). The
survey contained demographic, disease characteristic and health care experience
variables, which were evaluated as potential predictors of DMD adherence using
logistic regression, controlling for age and gender. No adjustment was made for
multiplicity. Results: 969 patients completed the survey; 579 met analysis criteria. High vs. intermediate/low adherers represented 47.7% and 52.3%, respectively.
Average age for high adherers was 49.1 (SD: 10.9), 81.5% female; intermediate/
low adherers had an average age of 47.3 (SD: 11.4), 87.7% female. Of 149 variables,
the following were associated with greater odds of high adherence: detailed discussions with health care professional about “how long the treatment had been
available” (p= 0.02; OR: 1.47; high 56.8% vs. intermediate/low 47.1%) or “long-term
safety” (p= 0.01; OR: 1.54; high 54.8% vs. intermediate/low 44.2%); satisfaction with
DMD (p= 0.04; OR: 1.14; high 5.4 [SD: 1.4] vs. intermediate/low 5.2 [SD: 1.3] ); or
insurance covered entire cost of DMD (p= 0.01; OR: 1.71; high 23.1% vs. intermediate/low 15.2%). Results indicating lower odds of high adherence included longer
duration on current therapy (p< 0.01; OR: 0.99; high 63.2 [SD: 53.5] months vs. intermediate/low 75.9 [SD: 60.0] months) and cost made them “skip a dose” (p< 0.01;
OR: 0.37; high 5.3% vs. intermediate/low 13.4%) or “not fill or refill a prescription”
(p< 0.01; OR: 0.43; high 5.3% vs. intermediate/low 12.0%). Conclusions: Patient
and provider dialogue, patient satisfaction with treatment and health plan benefit
design aspects may affect DMD adherence.
PND57
Modelling the Persistence of Disease-Modifying Drug Treatment
(DMT) and its Independent Drivers in Finnish Multiple Sclerosis (MS)
Patients: Parametric Survival Modelling
Soini E 1, Holmberg M 2, Asseburg C 1, Sumelahti M L 2
1ESiOR Oy, Kuopio, Finland, 2School of Medicine, University of Tampere, Finland
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Explore how MS DMT-persistence can be modelled, compare model’s
performance and assess the independent drivers for DMT-persistence. Methods:
Analysis was based on 1638 DMT uses (1.1. 1991–31.12.2010, time at risk 4009 years)
in incident MS-patient register from Tampere, Vaasa and Seinäjoki regions, Finland.
DMT-persistence = DMT end-day - DMT initiation day. Cox, exponential, generalized gamma, Gompertz, log-logistic, log-normal, and Weibull regression survival
models were used to model DMT-persistence. Models were compared based on
goodness-of-fit statistics (Akaike and Bayesian information criteria). Results:
Mean follow-up from first MS-symptoms and age at first DMT-initiation were 13
and 36 years, respectively. 73% of patients were female. Based on the data exploration of all known covariates, three DMT-persistence approaches with different
interpretations, selected covariates and data needs were modelled: 1] sex, birth
year, time from symptoms to DMT, age, DMT line (1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5-7th), DMT
(interferon-β -1a and -1b, glatiramer acetate, other) at DMT initiation; 2] approach
1] + Expanded Disability Status Scale (EDSS) at DMT initiation; and 3] approach 2]
+ DMT-discontinuation reason (pregnancy plan, flu-like symptoms, injection-site
reactions, ineffectiveness, antibodies, other/unknown). There was no gold standard survival model for DMT-persistence, and some models accommodated higher
number of covariates and associated dependencies better. For approaches 1] and
2] Weibull and for 3] Gompertz model provided the best goodness-of-fit. Based on
all three models (one per approach 1] –3]) with best goodness-of-fit, higher EDSS
or higher age at DMT initiation, treatment line (3rd and later), and incidence of
intolerable adverse events (AE) or ineffectiveness were independently associated
with shorter DMT persistence. In the approach 3], flu-like symptom and injection
site AEs had the highest hazard ratio for shorter DMT-persistence. Conclusions:
AEs, EDSS, age, treatment line and ineffectiveness were strong predictors for DMTpersistence. Flu-like symptoms and injection site AEs showed the highest hazard
for DMT-discontinuation.
PND58
Persistence with Fingolimod Versus Dimethyl Fumarate in Patients
with Multiple Sclerosis: Retrospective Analysis of us Open-Source
Pharmacy Data
Bergvall N 1, Lahoz R 1, Nazareth T 2, Korn J R 3
1Novartis Pharma AG, Basel, Switzerland, 2Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation, East Hanover,
NJ, USA, 3IMS Health, Waltham, MA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To compare 6-month persistence rates among patients initiating the
oral multiple sclerosis (MS) disease-modifying therapies (DMTs) fingolimod and
dimethyl fumarate (DMF). Methods: Our retrospective analysis used mail-order
pharmacy claims from the US open-source LRx™ database (IMS). Patients with ≥ 1
fingolimod or DMF prescription (index DMT) between 01-April-2013 and 31-July2013 were included. Patients were ≥ 18 years old, naive to fingolimod and DMF, and
had not received multiple DMTs on the date of the first index DMT claim (index
date). Prescription records were collected from pharmacies supplying ≥ 1 index
DMT claim between the index date and the last month of follow-up. Persistence
was assessed as time from initiating index DMT until discontinuation (gap of ≥ 60
days), receipt of another DMT or the end of the 6-month follow-up period. The
risk of and time to index DMT discontinuation was assessed using a Cox proportional hazards model (controlling for age, gender and region) and Kaplan-Meier
analysis, respectively. Results: The study included 9546 patients (fingolimod:
n= 1390; DMF: n= 8156). The proportion of patients discontinuing index DMT was
significantly lower for patients receiving fingolimod (23.3%) versus DMF (36.6%;
p< 0.0001). The risk of discontinuation was 1.6-fold higher in the DMF cohort versus the fingolimod cohort (hazard ratio, 95% confidence intervals: 1.58, 1.41-1.77;
p< 0.0001). Time to discontinuation was significantly longer with fingolimod than
with DMF (p< 0.0001), resulting in a longer duration of therapy persistence for
fingolimod versus DMF (mean ± standard deviation: 152±53 days versus 135±62
days, respectively). Results were similar when discontinuation was defined as a
gap of ≥ 30 days (p< 0.0001 for all outcomes). Conclusions: This analysis provides
the first insight into short-term persistence rates with oral DMTs. In a real-world
setting, the risk of discontinuation over 6 months was lower for patients initiating
fingolimod versus DMF.
A401
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PND59
Persistence in Open and Closed Data Sources: A Study of Fingolimod
VersUS Interferons/Glatiramer Acetate in Patients with Multiple
Sclerosis
Lahoz R 1, Bergvall N 1, Nazareth T 2, Korn J R 3
1Novartis Pharma AG, Basel, Switzerland, 2Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation, East Hanover,
NJ, USA, 3IMS Health, Waltham, MA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To compare 6-month persistence rates among patients receiving the
multiple sclerosis (MS) disease-modifying therapies (DMTs) fingolimod or interferon/
glatiramer acetate (IFN/GA) (index DMT), using open- and closed-source data that
reflect unrestricted or continuous health care coverage, respectively. Methods:
Retrospective analyses used administrative claims and mail-order pharmacy databases (IMS PharMetrics Plus™ [closed]) and LRx™ [open], respectively). All patients
were ≥ 18 years old and naive to fingolimod and index DMT, had ≥ 1 prescription for
index DMT between 01-Oct-2010 and 31-Mar-2013 and had not received multiple
DMTs at index date. An additional PharMetrics cohort was selected using more
stringent criteria (continuous enrolment pre-/post-index; MS diagnosis code).
LRx prescriptions were collected from pharmacies supplying ≥ 1 claim for index
DMT between the index date and the last month of follow-up. Persistence was
defined as time from initiating index DMT until discontinuation (gap ≥ 60 days),
receipt of another DMT or end of the 6-month follow-up period. Risk of and time
to discontinuation were assessed by a Cox proportional hazards model (controlling for age, gender and region) and Kaplan-Meier analysis, respectively. Results:
Using identical criteria, 22,467 PharMetrics patients (fingolimod: n= 1968; IFN/GA:
n= 20,499) and 49,803 LRx patients (8325 and 41,478, respectively) were selected.
Proportions of patients discontinuing index DMT were significantly lower for fingolimod vs IFN/GA (PharMetrics: 23.1% vs 27.2%; LRx: 26.9% vs 33.4%; p<0.0001). Risk
of discontinuation was higher for IFN/GA vs fingolimod (PharMetrics: hazard ratio,
HR= 1.18; 95%CI: 1.07–1.30, p= 0.0008; LRx: HR= 1.23; 95%CI: 1.17–1.29, p< 0.0001). Time
to discontinuation was significantly longer for fingolimod vs IFN/GA (PharMetrics:
p= 0.0005; LRx: p< 0.0001). With more stringent criteria used in PharMetrics, risk
of discontinuation of IFN/GA vs fingolimod increased (HR= 1.47; 95%CI: 1.24–1.74,
p< 0.0001). Conclusions: Both data sources provided similar results, supporting
use of open-source LRx data, which allows access to up-to-date information that
can improve sample size and statistical power.
PND60
Comparison of the Valuation of Treatment Alternatives in
Parkinson’s Disease with Best-Worst Scaling, Time Trade-off and
Visual Analogue Scales
Weernink M G M 1, Groothuis-Oudshoorn C G M 1, IJzerman M J 2, van Til J A 1
1University of Twente, Enschede, The Netherlands, 2University of Twente and MIRA institute for
Biomedical Technology & Technical Medicine, Enschede, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Traditional valuation methods are insensitive to small improvements
in process and outcome of care. Best-Worst scaling (BWS) was proposed as a sensitive and efficient method to determine the relative value of different treatments
for the same disease, which would be desirable to estimate cost-effectiveness. The
study objective was to compare the ability of BWS to differentiate between different treatment alternatives to that of Time Trade Off (TTO) and Visual Analogue
Scales (VAS). Methods: An online survey was conducted to estimate individual
values for six different treatments reflecting the real-life options in the treatment
of Parkinson’s Disease with BWS2, BWS3, TTO and VAS (n= 592). Pearson correlation coefficient was used to examine the strength of linear dependence between
estimated utility scores. Results: Twenty-seven percent of respondents was not
willing to trade life years in TTO. Only two percent of the respondent does not
differentiate between the value of health states with VAS. When non-traders were
excluded from the analysis, the best case scenario was valued significantly higher
than the worst case scenario with all methods. Rank reversals among intermediate alternatives were common. The correlation between utility scores was very
strong (VAS-BWS2 1,0; VAS-BWS3 0.98; TTO-BWS2 0.99; TTO-BWS3 0.98, BWS2BWS3 0.96; P< 0.000, n= 434). Conclusions: The results demonstrate that BWS,
TTO and VAS can be used to elicit incremental utility gain of small improvements
in care. However, all methods have limitations. VAS does not result in utilities
and some respondents do not trade with TTO. While the use of BWS is attractive
because of its ability to estimate utilities for many different treatment alternatives, its applicability in CEA is limited because BWS utilities are not anchored on
a 0-1 utility scale. We propose to use TTO to estimate utility for extreme health
states, and to use BWS to value intermediate health states which differ on process
characteristics.
PND61
Health-Related Quality of Life in Migraine Without Aura Based on
Attack Frequency: A time Trade-Off Study
Rencz F 1, Brodszky V 1, Péntek M 1, Bereczki D 2, Gulacsi L 1
University of Budapest, Budapest, Hungary, 2Semmelweis University, Budapest,
Hungary
.
.
.
.
.
1Corvinus
Objectives: To evaluate health-related quality of life (HRQOL) in migraine based
on attack frequency by time trade-off method (TTO) in a mixed population sample consisting of migraneurs and non-migraneurs. Methods: A cross-sectional
questionnaire survey was designed to measure HRQOL in migraine without aura
by TTO. A convenience sample was recruited from university students and staff
regardless of having ever experienced migraine or not. Participants were asked to
elicit two hypothetical health states characterised by different migraine frequency
(‘m’: two migraines lasting 4 hours each month and ‘w’: each week) within two
hypothetical lifetime frames (20 years left to live/lives until the age of 80 years).
Utilities were calculated for the four tasks (U20m, U80m, U20w, U20w) and compared between subgroups. Results: Altogether 180 respondents were included
in the analysis. Mean age was 25.6 years (SD 6.4), 71% were female and 61% were
self-reported migraneurs. Proportion of non-traders varied between 14% and 43%
within the four questions. Respondents were willing to sacrifice median 5 and
8 years of their remaining lifespan until the age of 80 years for avoiding two
migraines per month and per week, respectively. Mean utilities for two migraines
each month were U20m= 0.84 (SD 0.26) and U80m= 0.89 (SD 0.14), and for each
week were U20w= 0.79 (SD 0.27) and U80w= 0.83 (SD 0.17), respectively. Self-reported
migraneurs elicited higher mean utilities compared to non-migraneurs for all
migraine health states but this difference was statistically significant only for
U80m (p= 0.039). Also, males attached lower mean utilities for all health states
than females but this was significant only for U80m (p= 0.018). Besides, older
respondents valued higher mean utilities for U20m compared to the younger ones
(p= 0.040). Conclusions: Our findings provide the first time trade-off utilities
on migraine associated HRQOL impairment. Disutility caused by migraine ranged
between 0.1 and 0.2 depending on attack frequency.
PND62
Humanistic Research Outcomes in Multiple Sclerosis: Review of the
Literature from Latin America
Einarson T R 1, Bereza B 1, Machado M 2
1University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada, 2Biogen Idec, São Paulo, Brazil
.
.
.
.
Objectives: This research reviews the research literature reporting humanistic
outcomes related to multiple sclerosis (MS) in Latin America. Methods: We conducted a systematic search of Medline, Embase, LILACS and Scielo from inception
through 2013 for articles reporting original research on quality of life (QoL), utility
scores for states of MS, patient preference, mental health, social and emotional
wellbeing in people with MS in Latin America. Adherence and related issues were
not included. Outcomes were categorized into: mental domain (cognitive function;
mental health), physical domain (mobility/independence; fatigue; restless legs syndrome), employment, QoL, caregiver burden, and patient preference. Results: A
total of 38 studies were selected for analysis. Among them, 23 addressed issues in
the mental domain (9 cognitive functions and 14 mental health), 41 in the physical
domain (24 mobility/physical function, 15 fatigue and 2 restless legs syndrome).
One addressed impact of MS on employment, 16 QoL, 2 caregiver burden and 1
patient preference. Researchers used 56 different instruments to collect their data
from 2286 patients. Compared with controls, MS patients had significantly (P< 0.05)
lower levels of functioning, cognition and increased presence of mental illness. All
of these factors were significantly associated with decreased QoL in patients (odds
ratios ranged from 4.2-10.1; P< 0.05). Similarly, fatigue and restless legs syndrome
correlated significantly with anxiety, depression and level of mobility/functioning as
well as QoL. Conclusions: As in other parts of the world, MS exerts a substantial
negative impact on the lives of people with MS in Latin America. It lowers their QoL
and interferes with their ability to move about, care for themselves and work. Their
social life is also negatively affected. The amount of literature on this subject is
quite limited. More research in Latin America is needed to understand humanistic
outcomes in these patients and management of their MS.
PND63
The Effect of Insomnia and Insomnia Treatment Side Effects on
Health Status, Work Productivity, and Health Care Resource Use
DiBonaventura M 1, Richard L 2, Kumar M 1, Forsythe A 3, Moline M 4, Flores N 1
1Kantar Health, New York, NY, USA, 2Eisai Europe Ltd, Hatfield, UK, 3Eisai, Inc., Woodcliff Lake,
NJ, USA, 4Eisai Inc, Woodcliff Lake, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The aims of this study were to quantify the burden of insomnia and
to quantify the association between side effects of insomnia medications and
health outcomes. Methods: Data from the 2013 US (N= 75,000) and 5EU (N= 62,000)
National Health and Wellness Survey (NHWS) were used. The NHWS is a patientreported survey administered to a demographically representative sample of adults
(with respect to age, sex, race/ethnicity, and region). Those who met DSM-V criteria
for insomnia and, separately, those treated with insomnia were compared with their
respective propensity score-matched control groups on health status (SF-36v2), work
productivity (WPAI-GH), and health care resource use using ANOVA tests. Among
those with treated insomnia, those with and without side effects were compared on
health outcomes using general linear models controlling for demographics, health
history, and comorbidities. Results: Compared with their respective matched control groups, patients with insomnia (n= 4147) and treated insomnia (n= 2860) in the
5EU reported significantly worse mean health utilities (0.60 vs. 0.74; 0.60 vs. 0.74,
respectively), greater overall work impairment (38.74% vs. 14.86%; 39.50% vs. 15.66%),
and more annual physician visits (9.10 vs. 4.08; 9.58 vs. 4.11). Similar findings were
observed in the US cohort. Among those treated for insomnia, 13.56% and 24.55%
in the US and 5EU, respectively, were non-adherent due to side effects. In the US,
this behavior was associated with significantly worse health utilities (0.60 vs. 0.64)
and greater overall work impairment (37.71% vs. 29.08%), among other variables
(all p< .05). These relationships were not significant in the 5EU. Conclusions: A
significant humanistic and economic burden of insomnia was observed in both the
US and 5EU, and the burden remains even after treatment. Non-adherence due to
side effects was common and, in the case of the US, associated with significantly
poorer health outcomes.
PND64
Quality of Life Among Patients with Multiple Sclerosis Treated
with Prolonged-Release Fampridine 10 Mg Tablets for Walking
Impairment
Liu Y 1, McNeill M 2, Lee A 1, Zhong J 1, Mehta L R 1
1Biogen Idec, Cambridge, MA, USA, 2Biogen Idec, Maidenhead, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate the effect of prolonged-release (PR) fampridine 10 mg
tablet on generic quality of life (QoL) as measured by the EQ-5D in patients with
multiple sclerosis (MS) with walking impairment. Methods: The study population included 132 patients who enrolled in a 24-week randomized, double-blind,
and placebo-controlled phase 2 trial (NCT01597297) of PR-fampridine 10 mg tablets or placebo twice daily in multiple sites in Europe and Canada. Patients were
A402
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
categorized into three groups: placebo, PR-fampridine responders (those with
a mean improvement from baseline in the 12-item MS walking scale [MSWS12] of ≥ 8 points over 24 weeks), and PR-fampridine nonresponders (those with
worsening, no change, or < 8 points improvement in MSWS-12). Changes from
baseline were calculated for the EQ-5D utility index and visual analogue scale
(VAS) by visit and over the 24 weeks. Within-group and pairwise comparisons
were assessed based on the least square (LS) means using analysis of covariance
(ANCOVA) models adjusting for baseline EQ-5D scores. Results: The placebo
patients (n= 64), responders (n= 33), and nonresponders (n= 35) were similar in
baseline age, race, weight, and number of relapses in the past 1 and 2 years.
The responders had higher mean baseline EQ-5D utility (0.56 vs. 0.51 and 0.52,
respectively) and VAS (62.9 vs. 59.1 and 60.5, respectively) scores than the placebo
patients and nonresponders. Over the 24 weeks, the EQ-5D utility score improved
in the responders (mean change: 0.06, 95% CI: [0.01, 0.12]) but worsened in the
placebo patients (mean change: -0.03,95% CI: [-0.07, 0.01]) and nonresponders
(mean change: -0.07,95% CI: [-0.12, -0.02] ). Similar trends were observed in the VAS
scores although the differences within groups were generally not statistically significant. Conclusions: PR-fampridine 10 mg tablets demonstrated significantly
greater improvement in QoL among responders, despite starting from higher baseline EQ-5D scores, than the placebo or nonresponder groups.
PND65
The Burden of Primary Generalized Tonic-Clonic Seizures in Europe
and the United States: An Analysis of The National Health and
Wellness Survey
Gupta S 1, Forsythe A 2, Pomerantz D 1, Tsong W 2
Health, Princeton, NJ, USA, 2Eisai Inc., Woodcliff Lake, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
1Kantar
Objectives: Many prescription medications are available to treat Primary
Generalized Tonic-Clonic (PGTC) seizures. The objective is to understand the
impact of PGTC on health outcomes. Methods: Data from the 2011-2013 U.S. and
2010 & 2013 5E.U. National Health and Wellness Survey (NHWS) were analyzed.
The NHWS is self-administered, internet-based survey of a nationwide sample of
adults (18+ years) stratified to represent the demographic composition of each
country. Patients self-reported a diagnosis of epilepsy with PGTC and were grouped
as ≥ 1 seizure per week, 1-3 seizures per month, 1-4 seizures per year, < 1 seizure
per year (reference). Patients provided information on health status (mental (MCS),
physical component summary (PCS), and SF-6D (health utility) from the SF-36v2),
resource utilization in the past six months and productivity loss (Work Productivity
and Activity Impairment Questionnaire). Costs were estimated from the literature.
Regression analyses were conducted controlling for covariates (e. g., age, gender,
marital status, comorbidities, years diagnosed with epilepsy). Results: There were
782 patients in the U.S. and 418 in the 5EU. In both geographies the proportion of
employed respondents decreased as frequency of seizures increased. Over 75% of
patients in both geographies were taking a prescription medication for epilepsy.
After adjustments, patients reporting < 1 seizure per year had greater PCS, health
utilities, lower activity impairment, fewer emergency room visits and lower total
direct costs compared to the other three seizure groups (p< 0.05 both geographies).
Among employed patients, patients reporting < 1 seizure per year had the lowest
overall work impairment (p< 0.05 both geographies). For all employable patients
(18-60 years) indirect costs were highest for the ≥ 1 seizure per week group (p< 0.05
both geographies). Conclusions: Results suggest a significantly higher economic
and humanistic burden in patients with more frequent seizures. PGTC patients are
very much in need of newer treatment options.
PND66
Factors Associated with Caregiver’s Burden in Relapsing-Remitting
Multiple Sclerosis and Satisfaction with Current Therapies.
MS-Feeling Study
Balaña M 1, Fabregas M 2, Meca-Lallana J 3, Mendibe M 4, Garcia E 1
Farmaceutica, Barcelona, Spain, 2TFS Develop S.A., Barcelona, Spain, 3Hospital Virgen
de la Arrixaca, Murcia, Spain, 4Hospital de Cruces, San Vicente de Barakaldo, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
1Novartis
Objectives: To describe the characteristics and burden of caregivers and patients
affected by relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis (RRMS), and to describe their satisfaction with treatment. Methods: Multicenter, observational, cross-sectional
study in RRMS patients≥ 18 years (y), treated for ≥ 1y. Burden was assessed with
the Zarit Burden Interview. Other measures were: Center for Epidemiologic Studies
Depression Scale, short form (CESD-7); and treatment satisfaction of caregivers (adhoc questionnaire) and patients (Treatment Satisfaction Questionnaire for Medication
(TSQM)). Results: We included 180 patients (mean (SD) age 41 (11) y, 66% female) and
caregivers (47 (12) y, 56% female, 67% economically active). Most caregivers were relatives (59% partner; 25% parent; 9% brother or sister) and lived with the patient (86%);
37% helped with the medication. Median (Q1, Q3) time since diagnosis was 7 (4,10) y
and between diagnosis and first treatment, 0.3 (0.2, 1.3) y. Most patients received
monotherapy with interferon beta (51%), glatiramer acetate (20%), natalizumab (14%)
or fingolimod (7%); 15.6% received ≥ 2 drugs. Median EDSS was 2.5 (1,4). According to
the Zarit Interview, 19% of caregivers had some degree of burden (median: 10 (7,15)).
Factors associated with burden were: EDSS (mean (SD) in caregivers with burden vs
without burden, respectively: 4.0 (2.1) vs 2.6 (1.9), p<0.0005), years of caregiving (mean:
4.0 (4.5) vs 2.7 (4.5) y, p= 0.005), daily hours dedicated to patient (10.8 (12.1) vs 5.8 (4.6)
hours, p=0.038), and >1 drug (39% of burden when patients take≥2 drugs vs 16% with
monotherapy, p=0.004). Other caregiver’s characteristics (age, gender, professional
activity, relationship with patient or cohabitation) were not significantly associated.
28.2% of caregivers had depression (CESD-7≥ 15). Both patients (90% satisfied or very
satisfied according to the TSQM) and caregivers (mean of 7.6 (2.3) on a scale from
0-10 [maximum satisfaction]) were quite satisfied with treatment. Conclusions:
In the RRMS population with moderate disability, around 2 in 10 caregivers have some
degree of burden, and 1 in 4 suffer depression. The burden increases proportionately
with disease severity and number of medications administered. Overall, patients and
caregivers are satisfied with treatment.
PND67
Impact of Caregiving for Patients with Alzheimer’s Disease and
Dementia on Psychiatric and Clinical Comorbidities in Brazil
Goren A 1, Novick D 2, Barros B R 3, Laks J 4, Dueñas H 5, Kahle-Wrobleski K 6
1Kantar Health, New York, NY, USA, 2Eli Lilly and Company, Windlesham, UK, 3Eli Lilly do Brasil
Ltda, São Paulo, Brazil, 4Federal University of Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 5Eli Lilly de
Mexico, Mexico City, Mexico, 6Eli Lilly and Company, Indianapolis, IN, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Patients with dementia due to Alzheimer’s disease (AD) are often cared
for by family members who experience physical, psychological, social, and financial
burdens associated with provision of care. This study quantifies the impact of caregiving in Brazil and helps identify characteristics associated with caregiving. Methods:
Data were analyzed from the 2012 National Health and Wellness Survey (NHWS)
in Brazil (n = 12,000), an Internet-based survey of adults (aged 18+), using stratified random sampling (by sex and age) to ensure demographic representation of the
Brazil adult population. Caregivers were compared with non-caregivers on select
comorbidities considered potential outcomes of caregiving, plus sociodemographic
characteristics, health characteristics and behaviors, and Charlson comorbidity index
(CCI) scores. Binary logistic regression models assessed comorbidities associated with
caregiving, adjusting for potential confounds (CCI, age, gender, education, income,
insurance, and marital status). Results: Among 10,853 respondents (caregivers
[n=209]; non-caregivers [n= 10,644]), caregivers were on average 42.1 years old, and
53% were female, 52% married/living with a partner, 87% insured, and 42% living with
1+ children in the household. Caregivers vs. non-caregivers were more frequently
obese, smokers, insured, employed, and with college education or above, and they
had higher CCI scores and higher income, all p <.05. Adjusting for covariates, caregiving was associated with significantly increased risk of depressive symptoms (odds
ratio [OR] =2.008), major depressive disorder (OR=1.483), anxiety (OR=1.714), insomnia
(OR= 1.644), hypertension (OR=1.584), pain (OR=1.704), and diabetes (OR= 2.103), all
p<.015. Conclusions: This is the first study on caregivers for persons with dementia in Brazil using a large dataset (NHWS). Being a caregiver (compared with noncaregiver) is a predictor of overall psychiatric and clinical disorders in this sample. The
online survey format provides certain sampling advantages but may under-represent
caregivers without access/comfort with online technology. Direct treatment and policies to help caregivers are needed in Brazil.
PND68
The Value of Diagnostic Tests for Alzheimer’s Disease: DiscreteChoice Experiment and Contingent-Valuation
Mühlbacher A C 1, Johnson F R 2, Yang J C 3, Happich M 4
of Applied Sciences Neubrandenburg, Neubrandenburg, Germany, 2Triangle Health
Preference Research, Chapel Hill,, NC, USA, 3RTI Health Solutions, Research Triangle Park, NC,
USA, 4Eli Lilly and Company, Bad Homburg, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: Despite the existence of standardized medical criteria, clinical diagnosis of Alzheimer’s disease remains difficult. Lack of diagnostic certainty or possible
distress related to positive results could limit application of new testing technologies. Independent of the therapeutic value of prevention or cure, however, diagnostic
information could have value in informing contingency planning or have intrinsic
value: the value of “just knowing”. This paper aims to quantify respondents’ preferences for obtaining AD diagnostic tests and to estimate the perceived value of AD
test information. Methods: Discrete-choice experiment (DCE) and contingentvaluation (CV) questions were administered to N= 1301 respondents aged 60 years
or older in Germany and the United Kingdom. 12 pairs of virtual AD diagnostic tests
were presented (defined by test type, test precision defined by false-positive or falsenegative test results, and test cost) and a no-test alternative. DCE questions were
based on a predetermined experimental design. A double-bounded, dichotomouschoice CV question was used to further elicit willingness to take an AD test and pay
for it. Choice data of respondents interested in taking a test were analyzed using
random-parameters logit. A probit model characterized respondents who were not
willing to take a test. Results: Most respondents in both countries had a positive value for AD diagnostic test information. Most respondents who indicated an
interest in testing in Germany (N= 631) and the UK (N= 670) preferred brain imaging
without radioactive marker, followed by brain imaging with radioactive marker
and then spinal tap. Diagnostic tests with better precision were preferred. German
respondents had relatively greater heterogeneous preferences and lower moneyequivalent values for test features compared to UK respondents. Conclusions:
Respondents preferred less invasive diagnostic procedures and tests with higher
accuracy. Diagnostic test accuracy was more important than test type. Respondents
expressed a willingness to pay up to € 700 to receive a less invasive test with the
highest accuracy.
PND69
The Humanistic and Economic Burden of Partial Onset Seizures in
the Europe Five and Brazil Using a Patient Survey
Gupta S 1, Forsythe A 2, Pomerantz D 1, Tsong W 2
Health, Princeton, NJ, USA, 2Eisai Inc., Woodcliff Lake, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
1Kantar
Objectives: The aim of this study was to understand the current impact of partial
onset seizures (POS) on health outcomes and costs. Methods: Patients were identified from the 2010 & 2013 5EU and 2011-2012 Brazil National Health and Wellness
Survey, a nationally represented, internet-based survey of adults (18+ years).
Patients self-reported a diagnosis of epilepsy with POS and were categorized into
≥ 1 seizure per week, 1-3 seizures per month, 1-4 seizures per year, < 1 seizure per
year (reference). Patients completed the SF-36v2 (mental (MCS), physical component
summary (PCS)), SF-6D (health utility), Work Productivity and Activity Impairment
Questionnaire and reported on resource utilization in the past six months. Costs
were estimated from the literature. Generalized linear regression analyses were
conducted controlling for covariates (e. g., age, gender, marital status, comorbidities,
years diagnosed with epilepsy). Results: There were 175 patients in the 5EU and
32 in Brazil, 11.1% reported ≥ 1 seizures/week, 7.7% reported 1-3 seizures/month,
26.1% 1-4 seizures/year, and 55.1% < 1seizures/year. MCS, PCS, utilities, productivity
A403
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
loss and resource were similar in Brazil and the 5EU (all p> 0.05). After adjustments
(combined 5EU and Brazil), as the number of seizures decreased, PCS (≥ 1 seizures/
week: 40.9; 1-3 seizures/month: 41.7; 1-4 seizures/year: 46.9; < 1seizures/year: 48.4)
and health utilities (≥ 1 seizures/week: 0.58; 1-3 seizures/month: 0.63; 1-4 seizures/
year: 0.63; < 1seizures/year: 0.69) increased. As the number of seizures decreased,
activity impairment (≥ 1 seizures/week: 58.6%; 1-3 seizures/month: 51.1%; 1-4 seizures/year: 35.7%; < 1seizures/year: 25.5%), emergency room visits and hospitalizations decreased. In Europe direct and indirect costs were highest for the ≥ 1 seizure/
week group. Conclusions: POS burden was similar in Europe and Brazil. As the
number of seizures increased, economic and humanistic burden increased. Even
with the large number of treatment options available, patients and the health care
system need additional choices to reduce the frequency of seizures.
PND70
Psychometric Analyses to Inform Item Reduction and Evaluate
Sensitivity of the Early Mobility Impairment Questionnaire for
Multiple Sclerosis
Phillips G A 1, Mathias A 2, Coon C D 2, Agarwal S S 1, Sen R 2, Shah R 3, Ziemssen T 4
Idec Inc., Cambridge, MA, USA, 2Adelphi Values, Boston, MA, USA, 3University of
Mississippi, University, MS, USA, 4University Clinic Carl Gustav Carus, Dresden, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Biogen
Objectives: Mobility impairments affect most multiple sclerosis (MS) patients
(93%), yet many patients (~40%) “rarely or never” discuss trouble walking with a
health care provider (HCP). To facilitate patient-HCP dialogue and early identification of mobility impairments, the Early Mobility Impairment Questionnaire (EMIQ)
was developed based on qualitative research with patients diagnosed with MS and
in collaboration with key opinion leaders. To minimize the burden associated with
administration of the EMIQ, psychometric analyses were applied to the initial draft
to produce a parsimonious yet robust instrument. Methods: The EMIQ’s psychometric performance was evaluated in a multi-center, prospective, observational
study in subjects with an Expanded Disability Status Scale (EDSS) score of 2.0 to
6.0. Iterative exploratory factor analysis (EFA) was used to guide item reduction;
subsequently, an item response theory (IRT) graded response model was applied to
confirm the robustness of the instrument. Logistic regression analyses (using EDSS
scores) were used to confirm discriminatory power. Results: In total, 124 subjects
with moderate MS (EDSS mean score = 4.2) were included in the study. Discriminant
validity, factor analysis, and IRT modeling identified six items for reduction. The
resulting 9-item scale had one strong underlying domain (first eigenvalue explained
60% of variance). The information curve showed sufficient sensitivity (I> 3.3 for
-2.6≤ θ ≤ 2.4) throughout the scale (mild to severe), with the most precise information provided at ½ SD above the mean (I= 12 at θ = 0.4). Logistic regression showed
that the EMIQ was able to discriminate between patients with and without walking impairment (p< 0.05). Conclusions: The psychometric analyses resulted in a
streamlined scale that is appropriate for the screening of subjects experiencing early
mobility impairments due to MS. In addition to a potential role in guiding clinical
assessment and intervention, the EMIQ may also prove useful in the longitudinal
assessment of mobility, as patients’ conditions decline.
PND71
Cognitive Impairment and Health Related Quality of Life in
Relapsing Remitting Multiple Sclerosis
Balaña M 1, Galera J 1, López-Góngora M 2, Escartín A 2, Izquierdo G 3, Borges M 3, Garcia E 1
1Novartis Farmaceutica, Barcelona, Spain, 2Hospital Santa Creu i Sant Pau, Barcelona, Spain,
3Hospital Universitario Virgen Macarena, Sevilla, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The impact of Cognitive Impairment (CI) on Health Related Quality
of Life (HRQoL) in patients with Relapsing Remitting Multiple Sclerosis (RRMS)
is becoming a field of study increasingly relevant due to its implications on the
effectiveness and quality research. Since the studies reviewed highlight contradictory results, the aim of this study was to determine the predictive value of CI
and other correlated factors on HRQoL in a sample of RRMS patients. Methods:
Observational, cross-sectional and multicenter study at 21 Neurology Departments
in Spain. Multiple linear regression analysis (stepwise) was carried out to
assess if HRQoL (EQ-5D scores) was predicted by CI (Brief Repeatable Battery of
Neuropsychological Tests, BRB-N), physical disability (Expanded Disability Status
Scale -EDSS), depression (Beck Depression Inventory-BDI-II) and disease duration
(years diagnosed). Bivariate, partial and semi-partial correlations and multicollinearity analysis were performed to control confounding factors. Results: We
included 291 RRMS patients (71.50% female), mean age 41.65 years (SD= 10.18). The
mild disability group (EDSS 0-3) included 152 (52.20%) patients and the moderate disability group (EDSS 3.5-5.5) included 139 patients (47.80%). All correlations
between EQ-5D scores and BRB-N, BDI-II, EDSS and disease duration variables were
statistically significant (p< 0.01), not multicollinearity detected. The results of the
regression analysis indicated that two predictors explained 56.9% of the HRQoL
variance (Adjusted R squared= 0.569, F= 187,251, p< 0.01). It was found that depression significantly predicted HRQoL (Beta= -0.587, p< 0.01), as did physical disability
(Beta= -0.315, p< 0.01). Conclusions: The results showed a weak predictive value
of CI (measured with the BRB-N battery) in HRQOL scores while depression and
psychical disability were important predictors. Future research is needed in order
to clarify the relationship between CI and HRQoL.
PND72
Evaluating Working Ability and Quality of Life of Patients with
Multiple Sclerosis
Kreimendahl F 1, Rychlik R P T 1, Patel S 2, Gleissner E 2, Becker V 3
1Institute of Empirical Health Economics, Burscheid, Germany, 2Biogen Idec GmbH, Ismaning,
Germany, 3Neurologische Praxis Eppendorf, Hamburg, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Relapsing remitting multiple sclerosis (RRMS) is a chronic inflammatory disease representing the most common chronic neurological disorder in
young adults. RRMS usually leads to permanent disability and as a result is a major
cause of reduced working capacity due to neurological diseases. This abstract pre-
sents methods to evaluate working ability and quality of life in natalizumab-treated
RRMS patients. Methods: A non-interventional study was performed in Germany.
Patients treated with natalizumab for a maximum of three months prior to baseline
were eligible for study participation. Demographic and occupational information
was collected; DSS and EQ-5D-questionnaires were used. Data were collected at
baseline, after 6 months and after 12 months. Main objective was to evaluate productivity per year, by using the formula: (working hours per day*5 days per week*46
working weeks a year) - (days absent from work*working hours per year). To assess
health economic cost savings, productivity has been valued monetarily by calculating a daily rate of working costs. Subgroup analysis divides the study population into employed, unemployed, patients with statutory sick pay and students.
Analyses of variance and subsequent post hoc tests will be performed to identify
subgroup differences. Results: Of 95 patients included by January 2014, 46.3%
were employed. Average hours worked/day were 5.3 hours (employed: 6.5 hours);
average number of days absent from work during the past half-year was 17.4 days
(employed: 16.5 days). Calculated productivity per 6 months results in 569.6 hours
(employed: 661.0), meaning 6,5540.40€ (employed: 7,634.55€ ) in monetarily valued
productivity. Conclusions: This non-interventional study aimed at providing new
insights in the therapy of RRMS patients treated with natalizumab. The study’s
intention was to show how an increase in working hours in employed patients as
well as a decrease in days absent from work can lead to an increase in productivity.
Study was funded by Biogen Idec.
PND73
Significant and Meaningful Improvement in Treatment Satisfaction
with Teriflunomide Versus Subcutaneous IFNB-1A in Patients with
Relapsing MS Results from Tenere
Mäurer M 1, Van Wijmeersch B 2, de Seze J 3, Meca-Lallana J 4, Bozzi S 5, Vermersch P 6
Krankenhaus Bad Mergentheim, Bad Mergentheim, Germany, 2Hasselt University,
Diepenbeek, Belgium, 3Strasbourg University, Strasbourg, France, 4Universidad Católica San
Antonio de Murcia, Murcia, Spain, 5Sanofi, Chilly-Mazarin, France, 6University of Lille Nord de
France, Lille, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Caritas
Objectives: Teriflunomide is a once-daily oral immunomodulator approved for
relapsing–remitting MS. The phase 3 TENERE (NCT00883337) study comparing
teriflunomide with subcutaneous interferon beta-1a (sc IFNβ -1a) did not meet its
primary endpoint (superiority of teriflunomide vs sc IFNβ -1a on time to treatment
failure) although there was no difference in annualized relapse rate between teriflunomide 14 mg and sc IFNβ -1a. The objective of the current analysis was to compare
patient treatment satisfaction of teriflunomide with that of sc IFNβ-1a. Methods:
Randomized patients (n= 324) received once-daily teriflunomide 14 mg or 7 mg or
sc IFNβ -1a three times per week; the study was completed 48 weeks after the last
patient was randomized. Patient satisfaction with treatment was assessed as a
secondary endpoint using the Treatment Satisfaction Questionnaire for Medication
(TSQM) version 1.4, a validated generic questionnaire with scores for effectiveness, side-effects, convenience, and global satisfaction. A mixed-effect model with
repeated measures was used to analyze TSQM scores at Week 48. Magnitude of
effects was assessed using effect size (ES), defined as the difference in treatment
effect divided by standard deviation. The ES differences were ranked as follows: <0.2,
negligible; ≥ 0.2–< 0.5, small; ≥ 0.5–≤ 0.8, moderate; > 0.8, high. Results: At Week 48,
TSQM values showed significantly better patient satisfaction in the teriflunomide
14-mg group vs the IFNβ -1a group in three domains (side-effects, P< 0.0001; convenience, P< 0.0001; global satisfaction, P= 0.02), with no perceived difference on
effectiveness (P= 0.28). High ES values favoring teriflunomide 14 mg vs IFNβ-1a were
seen with side-effects (1.09) and convenience (1.81), with a smaller ES for global
satisfaction (0.39). Conclusions: A significant and meaningful improvement in
treatment satisfaction for teriflunomide 14 mg vs IFNβ-1a was observed with regards
to side-effects, convenience, and global satisfaction, which may potentially improve
treatment adherence and outcomes in clinical practice.
Neurological Disorders – Health Care Use & Policy Studies
PND74
Antiepileptic Drug (AED) Treatment Sequencing in the Uk in Patients
with Epilepsy: Real-Life Practice Data Using CPRD
Borghs S 1, Logan J 2, Hong L S 3, Butt T 4
Pharma, Slough, UK, 2Stats4Pharma, Blarney, Ireland, 3Redsen Limited, Bournemouth, UK,
4UCB Pharma, Brussels, Belgium
.
.
.
.
.
1UCB
Objectives: Analyze real-life AED treatment sequencing in the UK using prescription data from the Clinical Practice Research Datalink (CPRD), and compare it to
the 2012 National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) clinical guidelines. Methods: Patients were included if they had an epilepsy diagnosis and an
AED prescription between January, 2009 and January, 2014. Patients who entered the
database untreated were followed from first AED prescription following an epilepsy
diagnosis, for up to five lines of treatment until being censored at the end of registration, death, or end of data coverage. Follow-up time could differ substantially
between patients. AED treatment changes were classified as add, switch, or stop.
The number of patients per treatment line was calculated for each individual AED
combination and each regimen, grouped as Monotherapy, Polytherapy, and “No
AED”. Results: Overall, 8931 patients went through 2469 unique AED treatment
sequences; 97.1% were started on Monotherapy. 30.8% of patients stayed on their
first Monotherapy until censored. 16.5% of initial Monotherapy patients switched
to a second Monotherapy; 27% went to “No AED”; 25.7% progressed to Polytherapy.
The first treatment line was consistent with NICE guidelines for 70.4% of patients.
Thereafter, 14.7% of patients were treated within guidelines in the first 2 lines.
The main divergence from guidelines involved prescribing Polytherapy or “No
AED” rather than a second monotherapy in line 2. Largely consistent with NICE,
the most frequent (87.1%) initial monotherapy AEDs were valproic acid (30.1%),
lamotrigine (22.8%), carbamazepine (17.5%), levetiracetam (10.3%), and phenytoin
A404
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
(6.4%). Conclusions: These data suggest that, after initial monotherapy, a majority of epilepsy treatment decisions do not follow 2012 NICE guidelines, with the
degree of divergence increasing through lines of therapy. These results call for more
detailed investigation into treatment patterns and the reasons for divergence from
clinical guidelines in epilepsy.
PND75
Patterns of Use of Tests to Monitor Disease Activity Among
Patients With Relapsing Remitting Multiple Sclerosis in the United
States and Europe
Narayanan S 1, O’Meara P 2, White J 3, Chan J 3, Gabriele S 3
1Ipsos Healthcare, Columbia, MD, USA, 2Ipsos Healthcare, New York, NY, USA, 3Ipsos Healthcare,
London, UK
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Progression of symptoms among Relapsing Remitting Multiple
Sclerosis (RRMS) patients may necessitate active disease management. The objective
of the study was to assess the patterns of use of tests to monitor disease activity/
progression in RRMS in EU and US, based on disease severity. Methods: A multicenter retrospective chart-review study of MS patients was conducted in EU (UK/
France/Germany/Italy/Spain) and US to collect de-identified data on diagnosis, clinical status, and disease management approaches. Health care providers (HCPs; 94%
neurologists) were screened for duration of practice (≥3yrs) and patient volume (≥15
MS patients/mo) and recruited from a large panel to be geographically representative
in each country. Medical charts of next 10 consecutive MS patients were abstracted
by each HCP. RRMS patient data was analyzed. Results: 2433 eligible RRMS patient
charts were abstracted by 365 HCPs (EU/US: N= 265/100; mean neurology practice
duration= 17/21yrs; mean number of patients seen per month= 66/62). In EU/US,
patient mean age: 37/41yrs, female: 67%/70%, currently treated: 85%/88%, currently
with mild: moderate: severe disease-60%: 34%: 5%/67%: 29%: 3%. Top-5 tests used
to monitor RRMS varied between the regions overall as well as by patient disease
severity (EU/US: %patients): Neurological exam: overall-83/88, mild-80/89, moderate-87/86, severe-91/90; Gadolinium MRI: overall-62/71, mild-57/71, moderate-69/71,
severe-77/70; T2 MRI: overall-62/73, mild-59/74, moderate-66/70, severe-64/75; T1
MRI: overall-53/62, mild-51/64, moderate-55/58, severe-59/70; Expanded Disability
Status Scale (EDSS): overall-86/29, mild-87/29, moderate-86/30, severe-80/35.
Percent with unknown Gd-enhanced lesions were (EU/US): overall-33/40, mild37/42, moderate-29/37, severe-17/25. Percent with unknown T2 lesions were (EU/
US): overall-33/35, mild-34/36, moderate-32/34, severe-17/20. UK HCPs reported
substantially more patients with unknown Gd-enhanced (70%) and T2 lesions
(66%). Conclusions: Besides neurological exam and EDSS, MRI testing is widely
used and its use increased with increasing disease severity (EU only); the percent
of patients with unknown lesions decreased correspondingly. Still, one-third of
patients had unknown lesions (with UK reporting two-thirds), warranting further
scrutiny on practice patterns and diagnostics to optimize available therapeutic
choices and alleviate disease burden.
PND76
Frequency of Outpatient Physiotherapy Services in Neurology
Diseases in Hungary
Molics B 1, Hanzel A 1, Járomi M 1, Csákvári T 2, Danku N 1, Sebestyén A 3, Boncz I 4
of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary, 2University of Pécs, Zalaegerszeg, Hungary, 3National Health
Insurance Fund Administration, Pécs, Hungary, 4Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Pécs,
Pécs, Hungary
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: The aim of our study is to assess amount and frequency of the physiotherapy services in the different neurology diseases within out-patient care in
Hungary. Methods: The data come from the nationwide, financial data base of
the National Health Insurance Fund Administration covering the official reports
of outpatient care institutes in 2009. The total numbers of different physiotherapy
services were determined by selecting the reported specific diagnoses codes and
counting the number treatments provided for that specific diagnosis code. The diseases of the nervous system are listed in the International Classification of Diseases
(ICD) with code of G00-G99. Results: The total number of the 151 different types
WHO-classified physiotherapy procedures was 32318413; and 1331675 (4.12%) of
them related to neurology care with the ICD code group G00-G99. The amount and
frequency of the physiotherapy services are in the different neurology diseases are
the following: Inflammatory diseases of the central nervous system 3584 (0.26%),
Systemic atrophies primarily affecting the central nervous system 7265 (0.52%),
Extrapyramidal and movement disorders 82923 (5.96%), Other degenerative diseases
of the nervous system 15717 (1.13%), Demyelinating diseases of the central nervous
system 30300 (2.18%), Episodic and paroxysmal disorders 191909 (13.80%), Nerve,
nerve root and plexus disorders 438780 (31.56%), Polyneuropathies and other disorders of the peripheral nervous system 96871 (6.97%), Diseases of myoneural junction
and muscle 21276 (1.53%), Cerebral palsy and other paralytic syndromes 434550
(31.26%), Other disorders of the nervous system 67024 (4.82%). Conclusions: The
diseases of the nervous system showed different utilization frequency in physiotherapy services and represent a significant burden for the health care system.
PND77
Analysis of the Recent HTA Decision Making Landscape for Multiple
Sclerosis Therapies – Trends and Future Opportunities
Mardiguian S , Walsh S C M
PAREXEL, London, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In recent years, a number of new DMTs for the treatment of MS
have been approved by the FDA and EMA, specifically fingolimod, dimethyl
fumarate, teriflunomide, and alemtuzumab. This study evaluated the HTA
appraisals for these DMTs to identify any trends or future opportunities in
MS. Methods: HTA appraisals for fingolimod, dimethyl fumarate, teriflunomide, and alemtuzumab from NICE (England), SMC (Scotland), CADTH (Canada),
PBAC (Australia), HAS (France), TLV (Sweden) and IQWiG (Germany) were identified. Recommendations, reasoning, and the supporting clinical and economic
evidence were extracted. Results: Our search identified 19 submissions, all of
which included a placebo-controlled trial, and all except dimethyl fumarate also
included a head-to-head trial against one of the beta-interferons but not any other
therapies. Indirect comparisons against old and newer DMTs were also included
in the submissions. Approximately 90% of appraisals received positive recommendations; reasons for positive recommendations included recognition that
there is a need for additional treatment options in MS, particularly for patients
who do not have an adequate response to beta-interferons, and that oral DMTs
represent an innovative step in the treatment of MS. However, submissions were
generally criticised for trial design, scarcity of head-to-head trials, use of EDSS
to measure disability, the uncertainty regarding long-term clinical and economic
outcomes, and the heterogeneity of trial populations included in indirect comparisons. Conclusions: Due to the changing treatment landscape and the population included in MS trials, it is clear that placebo-controlled trials and the inclusion
of beta-interferon trials in indirect comparisons are becoming less suitable for the
evaluation of new MS treatments. Future HTA submissions will need to take into
account the need to demonstrate superiority over comparators, and manufacturers and regulators will need to work together to develop new and reliable measures
that can evaluate MS symptoms and impairments in the context of DMTs.
PND78
Comparing Characteristics of Hungarian “Real Life” Patients With
Participants of RCTS: First-Line Disease Modifying Therapies in
Multiple Sclerosis
Foldesi C 1, Penzes M 2, Szabo M 2
1National Institute of Quality and Organizational Development in Healthcare and Medicines,
Budapest, Hungary,, 2National Health Insurance Fund, Budapest, Hungary
.
.
.
Objectives: Health technology assessment and decision making process lean
on evidences provided by RCTs. Our aim was to compare the characteristics of
Hungarian patients with multiple sclerosis to the participants enrolled in pivotal
trials of first-line DMTs. Methods: The database of the National Health Insurance
Fund was used for analyze the attributes of all MS patients starting first-line DMTs
between 2008 and 2013. We investigated the following characteristics: 1. age, 2.
gender ratio, 3. time since first MS symptoms, 4. time since first MS diagnosis,
5. number of relapses in 2 years prior to therapy. For the comparison we summarized
phase III RCTs of interferon beta-1a and 1b, glatiramer-acetate, teriflunomide and
dimethyl-fumarate. Results: A total of 3877 Hungarian MS patients were involved
and 1670 were selected for analysis after excluding the population of the year of
DMT inclusion. The mean age was 36.18±9.96 years which resembles to the participants of old immunomodulatory drugs (≈36 years) and slightly younger than
the patients of the trials with new therapies (≈38 years). There was no difference
in gender ratio (≈70% female). While in the RCTs the mean time since first symptoms was longer than the mean time since first diagnosis (≈7–8 vs ≈5.5 years), in
the Hungarian patients these two values did not differ significantly (3.30±3.80 vs
3.17±3.77 years). We suspect that the reason for this unexpected difference can be
explained by the imprecise use of ICD codes in Hungarian clinical practice. The
relapse rate per 2 years seemed to decline in trials of the last two decades from 3 to
2-2.5 which is equal to the Hungarian patients. Conclusions: The population of
RCTs represents the Hungarian MS patients in certain aspects but not completely.
Our analysis can help the adaptation of international models to local circumstances
in HTA of forthcoming MS therapies.
PND79
Characteristics of Patients with Relapsing Remitting Multiple
Sclerosis Taking Injectable and Oral Disease Modifying Treatments
in the United States
Narayanan S 1, O’Meara P 2, White J 3, Chan J 3, Gabriele S 3
1Ipsos Healthcare, Columbia, MD, USA, 2Ipsos Healthcare, New York, NY, USA, 3Ipsos Healthcare,
London, UK
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Disease Modifying Treatments (DMTs) to manage Relapsing Remitting
Multiple Sclerosis (RRMS) patients have traditionally been injectables. With the
introduction of new oral DMTs, a better understanding of the shift in treatment
patterns and their impact on patient disease burden is needed. The objective of
this study was to assess the characteristics of RRMS patients taking injectable
and oral DMTs in the United States (US). Methods: A multi-center retrospective
chart-review study of RRMS patients was conducted in the US in 4Q2013 to collect
de-identified data on diagnosis, clinical status, and treatment patterns. Physicians
were screened for duration of practice (≥ 3yrs) and patient volume (≥ 15 MS patients/
mo and recruited from a large panel to be geographically representative. Medical
charts of the next 10 consecutive MS patients were abstracted. RRMS patients taking
an injectable (INJ) or oral DMT were analyzed. Results: 561 eligible RRMS patients
were included in the analysis (INJ: 66%; Oral: 34%). Patient characteristics were (INJ/
Oral): age: 41/40yrs, female: 71%/70%, time since diagnosis: 62/53mo, time between
diagnosis and initiation of first DMT: 5/3mo, percent on first, second, and third line
DMT were (INJ/Oral): 78%/30%, 18%/45%, and 4%/25%; time on current DMT (INJ/
Oral): 47mo/6mo. Reasons for current DMT initiation included (INJ/Oral): efficacy
against relapses (32%/27%)/efficacy in slowing progression (24%/23%)/efficacy in
early MS (21%/4%)/patient decision (7%/17%)/oral administration (0%/17%). Patient
JCV status (INJ/Oral): positive-3%/23% & not tested-75%/46%; number of gadoliniumenhanced & T2 lesions: 0.8/1.3 & 7.7/10.3; percent with ≥ 1 relapse in past 12mo:
42%/66%; percent with Expanded Disability Status Scale score of ≥ 4.5: 15%/31%;
percent with moderate-to-severe disability per physician judgment: 22%/40%; percent with active or highly active disease per physician judgment: 37%/60%; percent
with moderate-to-severe disease per physician judgment: 22%/44%. Conclusions:
In this cohort of RRMS patients, physicians initiated oral DMTs predominantly as
second or third-line treatment, and these patients may have higher disease burden compared to those receiving injectable DMTs. Further research is needed to
evaluate the observed treatment patterns and treatment sequencing strategies to
alleviate patient burden.
A405
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PND80
Adoption of Oral Disease Modifying Treatments to Manage Patients
with Relapsing Remitting Multiple Sclerosis from 2011-2013 in the
United States
Narayanan S 1, O’Meara P 2, White J 3, Chan J 3, Gabriele S 3, Hautamaki E 1
Healthcare, Columbia, MD, USA, 2Ipsos Healthcare, New York, NY, USA, 3Ipsos Healthcare,
London, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Ipsos
Objectives: New oral Disease Modifying Treatments (DMTs) for Relapsing
Remitting Multiple Sclerosis (RRMS) were recently introduced in the US. The
objective of this study was to assess trends in adoption of oral DMTs among
RRMS patients in the US. Methods: A multi-center retrospective chart-review
study of RRMS patients was conducted in the US in 4Q2011, 4Q2012, 2Q2013, and
4Q2013 to collect de-identified data on diagnosis, clinical status, and treatment
patterns. Neurologists were screened for duration of practice (≥ 3yrs) and patient
volume (≥ 15 MS patients/mo) and recruited from a large panel to be geographically representative. Medical charts of next 10 consecutive MS patients were
abstracted by each neurologist. RRMS patients taking oral, injectable, or infusible
DMTs were analyzed. Results: 2362 eligible RRMS patient charts were evaluated
(4Q2011:23%, 4Q2012:25%, 2Q2013:25% & 4Q2013:26%). Use of oral DMTs increased
four-fold (4Q2011:7%, 4Q2012:9%, 2Q2013:21% & 4Q2013:31%); use of injectable
DMTs decreased (4Q2011:82%, 4Q2012:78%, 2Q2013:71% & 4Q2013:60%), as did
use of infusible DMTs (4Q2011:10%, 4Q2012:12%, 2Q2013:7% & 4Q2013:8%). Across
timeframes, 61%, 27% & 12% of patients were on 1st-line, 2nd-line, and 3rd-line or
subsequent treatment, respectively. Among 3rd-line or subsequent patients, oral
DMT use increased from 23% to 59%; use of injectable and infusible DMTs decreased
from 34% to 16% and 37% to 25%, respectively. Among 2nd-line patients, oral DMT
use increased from 10% to 46%; use of injectable and infusible DMTs decreased
from 66% to 37% and 21% to 15%, respectively. Among 1st-line patients, oral DMT
use increased from 3% to 16%; use of injectable DMTs decreased from 96% to 83%
and infusible DMT use remained at 1-2%. Conclusions: Oral DMT use increased
between 4Q2011-4Q2013, predominantly in 2nd or subsequent lines. The impact of
this observed pattern of reserving new treatment options for later lines warrants
scrutiny to optimize patient management and alleviate disease burden.
RESEARCH POSTER PRESENTATIONS – SESSION II
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Consumer Role in Health Care
PHP1
Awareness and Interest in the United States Health Insurance
Marketplace
Bias T K , Fitzgerald P M , Agarwal P, Vasile E
West Virginia University, Morgantown, WV, USA
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To examine the level of awareness and interest in the newly setup
Health Insurance Marketplace under Affordable Care Act in West Virginia state of
the United States of America. Methods: Primary survey data were collected in
July/August 2013 from a stratified sampling of West Virginians. A mail survey was
completed by respondents in a cross-sectional study. Key variables included general awareness of the Health Insurance Marketplace and the availability of subsidies, the individual mandate, interest in using the Marketplace, and perceptions
of respondents’ ability to qualify for financial assistance. Results: Six thousand
surveys were mailed with a nine-page questionnaire. A total of 1,198 completed
surveys were returned. Two months prior to launch, awareness of the Health
Insurance Marketplace was low in WV; yet interest in the Marketplace was higher
among those most likely to benefit—the insured and residents likely to qualify
for financial subsidies. West Virginians reported being familiar with the individual
mandate. Conclusions: Efforts should be increased at the federal, state, and local
levels among government and non-government organizations to heighten awareness of the Health Insurance Marketplace in WV and, particularly, the availability of
subsidies. Many, once made aware, expressed interest in learning more.
PHP2
Attitudes of Patients Toward Generic Substitution and
Implication for Practice in Slovakia: First Results From
Adopting The Law in 2012
Babela R , Sajdikova K
St. Elizabeth University, BRATISLAVA, Slovak Republic
.
among patients. Conclusions: Based on our research among patients we conclude that generic substitution is most likely effective drug policy tool, but since
there are also many negative experiences (own or shared) with generic drugs, GS is
still considered as alternative treatment.
.
Objectives: Slovakia has from December 2011 new law that defines list of molecules for mandatory generic substitution. It was one of the cost-containment
measures applied in the same time at the field of drug policy. We provided research
on statistically selected sample of patients in Slovakia to detect current attitude,
knowledge and believes toward generic substitution (GS). Methods: We created
special questionnaire for patients and distributed it in selected regions in Slovakia.
From 600 questionaires, we evaluated 432. Questionares were distributed among
patients visiting pharmacies in 2013/2014 and all patients were older than 20
years. Results: There were 57% of women in our sample and only 11% from all
patients had lower than college education. 71% of all patients were using prescription drugs regularly and 58% of all patients were familiar with term GS. Suprisingly,
only 16% from all patients selected co-payment as the key factor influencing their
decision toward GS. Recommendation of GS in pharmacy or by doctor was selected
as key factor that influenced patients in choosing GS or generic molecule (40%).
Second most influential factor was own experience with generic (27%). Only 8%
of patients believed that GS can decrease overall consumption of drugs. We also
found out that 36% of patients consider GS as “risky” because of extended number
of generics available from various unknown companies. There was also a strong
statistical relationship between gender and positives as well as negatives of GS
PHP3
The Simultaneous Effects of Pharmaceutical Policies from Payers’
and Patients’ Perspectives. Italy as a Case Study
Armeni P 1, Otto M H 2, Jommi C 1
University, Milano, Italy, 2CERGAS Bocconi University, Milano, Italy
.
.
.
.
1Cergas, Bocconi
Objectives: The research analyses (i) the individual and interactive effects of
three pharmaceutical policies (cost-sharing, prescription quotas, therapeutic reference pricing) on drugs public and private expenditure and volumes, using Italian
regional policies as a case-study; (ii) the extent to which the long-run effect of policies on expenditure is mediated by prescribers’/patients’ behaviours. Methods:
An enriched difference-in-differences model is used. Firstly, policies impact on
public and private expenditure and volume is separately estimated. Then, the
hypothesis that the effects of policies on public expenditure are mediated by behaviours (transmission mechanism) is tested. As robustness check, a possible reverse
causality and feedback mechanisms is tested, by switching the mediator and the
independent variable. Results: The analysis shows (i) that combined policies do
not necessarily produce a higher impact than policies alone; (ii) a larger impact
of policies in the short-run, whereas in the long-run the trend is often reversed,
but not enough to compensate the final impact, which is usually in the expected
direction; (iii) as for cost-sharing, that its negative impact on public expenditure is
mainly due to a decrease in volumes than to a shift from public to private expenditure. Conclusions: Despite its limitation, this study has shined a light on the
impact of policies which are implemented in different time and places, thus covering an information gap and supporting policy-makers. Some empirical findings
show also that pharmaceutical policies may have an unintended impact on health:
e.g. the volumes decrease due to cost-sharing may imply patients under-treatment.
PHP4
Patient, Insuree and Public Participation in Health Technology
Assessment: An International Comparison
Mühlbacher A C , Juhnke C
Hochschule Neubrandenburg, Neubrandenburg, Germany
.
.
.
Objectives: There is a general consensus on the need for a stronger patient-centeredness, even in HTA processes. In international comparison different ways of
public participation (citizens, insured and patients) in the decision-making process
are discussed and tested. The need was recognized, but not yet fully reflected in
practice. This study describes how preferences can be taken into account in different decision situations and shows how methods of preference measurement/
citizens’ councils are used in an international context to support decision-making
and understand the importance of various decision-criteria that influence these
decisions. Methods: A systematic literature review in PubMed/Medline revealed
95 articles and showed that methods of patients, citizens and policyholder participation are manifold. In order to structure the international approaches further,
international HTA-organizations worldwide were questioned via e-mail in the end of
2013 on patients and public participation in their countries. Results: 17 out of 126
contacted organizations answered to these questions. In general, the participation
efforts extend from qualitative survey of patients’ needs up to the science-based
documentaries of quantitative patient preferences. The review and the survey of
the HTA-agencies show that internationally three mechanisms are used to involve
the public in decision-making bodies: membership of at least one patient representative
(e.g., Australia, France, Germany), presentation of oral/written comments from patients
(e.g., Australia, The Netherlands, Great Britain) and the possibility to check the HTAreports and the corresponding draft recommendations before publication (e.g., France,
Germany, Great Britain, New Zealand, USA). Conclusions: The role of the
patients or citizens seems to be limited to an informal or ad-hoc basis and is mostly
restricted to consulting activities. In order to achieve a patient-centered health
technology assessment two ways to sharing information are relevant: the public
needs information on medical and health policy/economic issues and decisionmaker need information on the patient perspective.
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Diagnosis Related Group
PHP5
The Effect of Degressive Financing Method on the Hungarian Drg
Based Hospital Reimbursement Between 2011-2013
Endrei D 1, Zemplényi A 1, Ágoston I 1, Molics B 1, Csákvári T 2, Danku N 1, Vajda R 1, Boncz I 3
of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary, 2University of Pécs, Zalaegerszeg, Hungary, 3Faculty of Health
Sciences, University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: Diagnosis Related Groups (DRG) like financing method was introduced
in Hungary in 1993. In addition to DRG based reimbursement, an degressive upper
ceiling (financial cap) was introduced for hospital reimbursement. The aim of our
study was to investigate the financial effects of degressive financing method on
the Hungarian DRG-based hospital financing. Methods: The data in our analysis
were derived from the nationwide administrative dataset of the National Health
Insurance Fund Administration (OEP), the only health care financing agency. We
examined the period between 2011 and 2013. In 2011 and 2012 hospital activity
over financial cap was reimbursed up to 110% by 30% of DRG base rate, while in
2013 hospital activity over financial cap was reimbursed up to 104% by 25% of
DRG base rate. Results: In 2011 hospital activity exceeded the financial cap by
4.6% with a monthly variation of 1.5% - 6.6%. In 2012 hospital activity exceeded
the financial cap by 4.2% with a monthly variation of 1.1% - 6.5%. In 2013 hospital activity exceeded the financial cap by 1.9% with a monthly variation of
1.1% - 2.6%. Between 2011 and 2013 the DRG base rate remained the same (150000
A406
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Hungarian Forint / DRG costweight). Conclusions: Introduction of degressive
financing method – in addition to DRG reimbursement – managed to control the
activity of hospitals. The soft regulation in 2011 and 2012 resulted in a 4.2-4.6%
excess activity of hospitals, while the more rigorous regulation in 2013 managed to
decrease the excess hospital activity to 1.9%. Degressive regulation can serve as a
cost containment tool for health policy decision makers.
PHP6
Nub Status - A 2014 Situation Analysis for Drugs: Oncology As
Leading Therapeutic Area
Friedmann B 1, Keck E 2, Schalk E 3, Schmitz D 2
1Quintiles Commercial, Mannheim, Germany, 2Healthcare Manufaktur, Cologne, Germany,
3Quintiles, Mannheim, Germany
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In the German hospital landscape NuB’s (Neue Untersuchungs- und
Behandlungsmethoden) are essentially the precursor for cost-intensive drugs to
be reimbursed within the G-DRG system. Hospitals can only start SHI negotiations
for reimbursement once drugs have been given a NuB 1 status. The objective of
this research was to provide an overview on the proportion of drugs (vs. methods,
medicinal products) and their respective indications, which submitted NuB applications for 2014. Methods: The German DRG database issued by the InEK (Institute
for the Hospital Remuneration System) was used to analyse NuB subgroups sorted
according to key therapeutic indications. In parallel, the number of NuB 1 status
products that went through the AMNOG process was analysed. Results: Out of
618 NuB submissions, only 133 (22%) were classified as drugs. In total, 114 (18%)
of all NuB applications received a NuB 1 status, out of these 43 (38%) were drugs.
The leading therapeutic area of the NuB 1 status drugs was oncology with 28 drugs
(65%), followed by 5 ophthalmic products (12%). NuB 2 status was given to 465 (75%)
procedures out of which 82 (18%) were drugs. The analysis reveals that, the success rate to receive the essential NuB 1 status is relatively low. Chances to receive
a successfull NuB 1 status approval is one in three for drugs, however only one in
six for other procedures. Out of the 43 drugs that were given NuB 1 status, already
24 (55%) passed through the AMNOG process and were given equal proportions
from important additional benefit to no additional benefit. Conclusions: Drug
applications are more likely than procedures to be given NuB 1 status and thereby
initiate reimbursement negotiations with the SHI. The application quality and support by the scientific societies and treatment centres is essential to make a NuB
application successful.
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Disease Management
PHP8
Multicriteria Decision Analysis and Cost Analysis in Health Care
Decision Making: A Literature Review
Ivlev I , Landova M
Czech Technical University in Prague, Kladno, Czech Republic
.
.
Objectives: The purpose this literature review is to investigate the application of
multicriteria decision analysis and cost analysis methods within health care decision-making. Methods: A search of the literature was conducted using scintific
databases. A combination of the following key words and phrases were inputted
into these databases: Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP), Analytic Network Process
(ANP), ELimination and Choice Expressing REality (ELECTRE), Goal programming, Grey
relation analysis, Markov process, Technique for Order of Preference by Similarity
to Ideal Solution (TOPSIS), CBA, CEA, and related words. The located articles were
divided into the following twelve health care topics: evaluation of health information services; evaluation of the product development process; project and technology
selection; pharmaceutics; health care management; therapy/treatment; management
of medical waste; human resource planning in health care; organ transplantation;
evaluation of health care policy; diagnostics; and shared decision-making with the
patient. Results: Ninety research articles were retrieved and determined relevant.
The pertinent articles were published between 1981 and 2013. It was found that the
AHP is the most commonly used method in health care decision making (65 articles).
AHP is mainly exploited in project and technology selection (22). The ANP method
is utilized in the evaluation of health information services, project and technology
selection, pharmaceutics and therapy/treatment. For the evaluation of health care
policy AHP (11), CBA (1), CEA (1) and Grey relation analysis (1) were used. The TOPSIS,
VIKOR, Markov process methods were utilized once in human resource planning
in health care, health care management and therapy/treatment respectively. The
CBA (4) and CEA (2) methods were especially useful for solving therapy/treatment
tasks. Conclusions: Multicriteria decision analysis and cost analysis offers a scientifically sound evaluation framework for health care management, where stakeholder
interests are of crucial concern and complex criteria that cannot easily be reduced to
simple monetary expressions, can be assessed in resource limited settings.
PHP9
Trends in Physical and Occupational Therapy Utilziation in the Us
And Western Europe
Eichmann F 1, DiBonaventura M 2, Schoefer A 3
1Kantar Health, Munich, Germany, 2Kantar Health, New York, NY, USA, 3Private Practice,
Marquartstein, Germany
.
.
.
Objectives: Allied health care (AHC) disciplines, such as physical (PT) and occupational therapy (OT), are primarily performed by non-medical health care professionals. Although the budget impact of AHC is generally low, reimbursements are often
scrutinized for their financial impact and benefit/risk ratios. To better inform the
health care decision making regarding AHC, the aim of this study was to examine
trends and utilization of PT and OT. Methods: Data from the 2013 US (N= 75,000)
and 2013 5EU (France, Germany, Italy, Spain, and UK; N= 62,000) National Health and
Wellness Survey (NHWS). The NHWS is a patient-reported survey administered to
a demographically representative sample of adults (with respect to age, sex, and
region) in each country. Overall rates of OT/PT visits were reported. Patients who
reported an OT/PT visit in the past six months were compared with those who did
not with respect to demographics, health history, and comorbidity variables. Logistic
regression models were then conducted to predict OT/PT visits from these variables. Results: Rates of OT/PT visits did not change from 2010 to 2013 but significant
differences among countries was observed (p< .05). In 2013, France (0.54%) and the
US (4.51%) had the most infrequent visits while Spain (11.13%) and Germany (11.92%)
had the most frequent. Being in Germany (OR= 3.46), being in Spain (OR= 3.24), and
having an above the median income (OR= 1.14) were the strongest demographic
predictors of an OT/PT visit (all p<.05). Although most comorbidities were associated
with an increased probability of an OT/PT visit, pain (OR= 2.30), arthritis conditions
(OR= 1.73), and psychiatric conditions (OR= 1.73) were most strongly associated (all
p< .05). Conclusions: PT and OT utilization varies significantly across countries,
being highest in Germany and Spain where over 10% of adults reported a visit in the
past six months. Pain-related (pain, arthritis) and psychiatric comorbidities were
among the strongest predictors of PT/OT use.
PHP10
A Gender Medicine Post-Hoc Analysis: Background and Methods of
the Metagem Project
Simoni L 1, Colombo D 2, Bellia G 2, Vassellatti D 2, Zagni E 2, Rizzoli S 1, Sgarbi S 1
1Medidata srl, Modena, Italy, 2Novartis Farma Italy, Saronno (VA), Italy
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Gender is a social construct, which is defined by the way people
perceive themselves and how they expect others to behave. Gender medicine
is the field of medicine that studies the biological and physiological differences between the human sexes and how that affects differences in disease.
The progress of research has confirmed that men and women differ not only
sexually but also in relationship to factors such as liver enzymes, sex hormones and to variables determined by the environment, education, culture
and psychology of the individual [Soldin and Mattison, 2009; Regitz-Zagrosek
and Seeland 2012]. The Italian Drug Agency has recognized the importance of
gender-specific analysis when evaluating new drug efficacy. The gender-medicine METAGEM project aims to describe gender differences in clinical outcomes,
therapeutic approach and safety parameters in real world data. Methods:
Areas of interest were defined regarding Dermatology, Central nervous system,
Infectivology, Rheumatology, and Transplantation; data were considered which
were collected in ten observational studies conducted between 2002 and 2013
in Italy in routine clinical practice. A post-hoc subgroup analysis is performed
by study, during which males are compared with females by statistical tests.
A merge of different study data will be performed in order to evaluate safety.
As post-hoc analysis all p-values are exploratory. Results: The number of
enrolled patients range between 238 to 1746 considering Rheumatology
and Dermatology areas respectively, for a total of 3743 male and 3018 female
patients. Conclusions: The papers and congress communications which will
arise from METAGEM project will make the scientific community more aware of
the importance of a gender-dedicated approach in the care of patients.
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Drug/Device/Diagnostic Use & Policy
PHP11
Health-Economics in Czech Republic: Can Formal Health-Economic
Methodology Improve The Quality Of Submitted Analysis?
Hambalek J , Spurna M , Vocelka M , Ballokova A
State Institute for Drug Control, Prague, Czech Republic
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Health economic analysis (HEA) has been required since 2008 as a
part of drug reimbursement applications submitted to the State Institute for Drug
Control (SUKL). In 2013, SUKL introduced a formal health economic guideline, mostly
based on the Czech Pharmacoenomic Society´s guideline published in 2011. The
aim of this study was to assess the impact of guideline implementation on the
quality of submitted HEAs. Methods: We reviewed all (18) applications for new
innovative drugs with prescription limited to specialized centers, in which the
final decision was issued and came into force between 1/2013-6/2014. The HEAs
were described in terms of type of analysis and further confronted with a ‘HEA
checklist‘ to identify common deficiencies in submitted HEAs. All check-lists were
peer-reviewed to ensure objectivity. Our results were compared with previously
published research (assessing HEAs submitted in 2008-2009 before the guideline
release). Results: All investigated dossiers contained HEA. Nine of them (50%)
were cost-effectiveness analysis (outcome expressed mostly in LYGs) and nine (50%)
were cost-utility analyses (outcome in QALYs). In general, the quality of HEAs was
higher compared to the previous research, with ‘evidence completeness’ and ‘uncertainty’ being the most commonly marked as ‘unsatisfactory’ in the HEA checklist
(less than 50%). Our results showed that 1/3 HEAs fell into the ‘best’ category (80100% ‘satisfactory’ questions), while none of HEAs fell into this category in previous
research. Conclusions: The present analysis showed a trend in higher quality of
submitted analyses (1/2013-6/2014) compared with years 2008-2009.
PHP12
Price Comparison in the European Pharmaceutical Market
Ressl S , Walter E
Institute for Pharmaeconomic Research, Vienna, Austria
.
.
Objectives: Due to rising health care costs, stricter governmental cost containment measures like international price comparison and external reference pricing,
the European pharmaceutical markets will lead to future challenges in pricing.
Despite of these prices of pharmaceuticals vary across European countries. Thus,
the aim of the analysis was to draw a comprehensive picture of the pharmaceutical price levels and consumption (expenditure per capita) of pharmaceuticals in
Europe. Methods: The study analyzed drug prices of the outpatient setting (Rx
and OTC) of all countries of the European Union except Denmark plus Switzerland.
A407
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Based on ex-factory prices per Standard Unit SU (tablet, vial etc.), price indices were
calculated. Study results showed international pharmaceutical price levels (in Euro
and purchasing power parities) and expenditure per capita. Observation period was
the year 2012. Data were collected via international literature review and based on
IMS Health data on file. Results: The international comparison of prices indices
based on SU prices showed (European average price = 100), France (138) and UK (126)
had the highest price indices and in contrast to Netherlands (69) and Romania (69)
were at the lower end. In the international country sample, the Netherlands had the
highest health expenditure (11.91% of GDP) in 2011, closely following by France with
11.33% of GDP. Subsequently, Switzerland occupied a leading position based on the
determined price index per capita (187) per ex-factory price, followed by Sweden
(167). The rear was Romania (45). Conclusions: In case of converting drug prices
with purchasing power parities differences between drug prices and affordability
in different countries were found. Low income countries reported less affordability
of drugs, leaving room for potential problems with drug access, and consequently,
a negative impact on health.
PHP13
How is Current Pharmaceuticals Pricing Policy on Generics
Performing in Turkey Regarding Price Erosion?
Gürsoy K , Köselerli R , Dogru S T , Köksal I
Social Security Institution of Turkey, Ankara, Turkey
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Generics are commonly accepted to contribute significantly to treating
disease by improving the affordability of pharmaceuticals. Once the patent expires
for an originator brand, generics erode prices through creating fierce competition.
The objective of this study is to investigate on Turkish pharmaceutical policies over
generics through measuring how much they lower the prices, and then develop
alternative strategies to maintain higher level of price reduction and hence saving. Methods: Claims data from Turkish Social Security Institution for all ambulatory care drugs reimbursed were collected monthly in the period of January 2009 to
December 2013. First, the share of generic drugs both in terms of sales volume and
value were calculated. Then, selected 12 equivalent groups each relying on same
molecule were evaluated and saving impacts due to generic entry were computed.
Finally, the price erosion for 15 generics entering the reimbursement list in 2012 as
first generics was measured. Results: Only 48% of all units sold was prescribed as
generic drugs, whereas it was only 31% when it comes to value. For 12 equivalent
groups constituting nearly 7% of SSI drug spending, the price erosion was nearly
41% ranging from 8% to 74%. Interestingly, when a first generic having an originator brand whose any form were marketed before 1987 in any country entered the
market, new discounted public price was higher than the price with no generic.
Finally, in the first year of the first generic entry, on average the prices were only
shrunk by 39% with an increase of 41% in units sold. Conclusions: Turkey is not
maximizing its full potential with respect to generic medicines. Therefore, it is
of great importance that policies such as therapeutic equivalence, tendering, and
aggressive generic pricing policy to stimulate higher savings need to be introduced.
PHP14
Cost-Effectiveness of Targeted Pharmacotherapy – A Systematic
Review of the Literature
Amler N , Becker T , Bierbaum M , Schöffski O
Friedrich-Alexander-Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg, Nuremberg, Germany
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Targeted therapies (e.g. trastuzumab, cetuximab) are often said to
constitute a new era of medicine. The new agents promise to be more effective
and less toxic than standard care. The consequences on costs are still a matter of
debate. While proponents refer to the enormous cost saving potential due to the
avoidance of side effects or hospitalizations for example, opponents expect a massive increase in costs of care. However, the impact of targeted therapies on cost as
well as their benefits are not yet clear. This review assesses the cost-effectiveness of
targeted therapies. Methods: We searched Medline, the Cochrane Library, Scopus,
ISI Web of Knowledge and ScienceDirect for relevant articles published between 2001
and 2013. Internet search and scanning reference lists complemented our search.
Authors independently reviewed titles, assessed articles’ eligibility for inclusion,
determined methodological quality and extracted relevant data. Results: In total
487 studies were identified. 50 of them met the inclusion criteria. 39 studies target either trastuzumab, or one of the aromatase inhibitors anastrozole, letrozole
or exemestane. Quality of the studies was assessed using the checklist provided
by Drummond/Jefferson (1996). The majority of the studies scored 80% or higher.
With few exceptions studies are based on Markov models. Effectiveness as well as
cost data were mostly obtained from clinical trials or literature respectively. Stated
cost-effectiveness ratios ranged from 4.370€ /QALY to 220.658€ /QALY, whereas the
majority of studies report favorable incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (≤50.000€/
QALY). Models often did not incorporate the respective companion test adequately.
Almost all studies were funded by the pharmaceutical industry. Studies without
financial support report higher cost-effectiveness ratios. Conclusions: Results
of the review indicate that targeted therapies seem to be cost-effective compared
to standard care. As most of the studies have been funded by pharmaceutical companies, authors suggest that results must be interpreted with care.
PHP15
Impact Of Pharmacoeconomic Guidelines on the Reimbursement
Process of Medicines In Serbia In 2014
Baltezarevic D 1, Novakovic T 1, Parker M 2, Samardzic J 3
1Pharmacoeconomics Section of the Pharmaceutical Association of Serbia, Belgrade, Serbia and
Montenegro, 2University of Liverpool Management School, Liverpool, UK, 3University of Belgrade,
Medical Faculty, Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess the impact of new rules for pharmacoeconomic evaluations
in Serbia, after the publishing of a new rulebook covering the criteria, methods and
conditions for listing medicines for reimbursement. Methods: We investigated the
reimbursement submissions to the National Health Insurance Fund (NHIF) in Serbia,
in the period September 2013 to June 2014. Quality was assessed using the criteria
for pharmacoeconomic evaluations from the in the most recent ISPOR guidelines
and the Serbian pharmacoeconomic guidelines. The impact of the introduction of
the new rulebook was assessed by comparing the period following its introduction
with the number and quality of submissions in the preceding period. Results:
Between September 2013 and April 2014 there were 268 submissions to the NHIF and
none were accompanied by the necessary pharmacoeconomic analysis. The new
rulebook was published in April 2014, making budget impact analysis an obligatory
part of every submission, and cost-effectiveness analysis obligatory for all new
INNs. 127 new and renewal submissions were made between April and June 2014,
47 for new INNs, 31 original and 16 for innovative medicines. All 47 completed the
obligatory pharmacoeconomic analysis. There was a widespread failure to reach the
requirements laid out in either the Guidelines for Pharmacoeconomic Evaluations
for Serbia or ISPOR guidelines. Conclusions: The introduction of compulsory
pharmacoeconomic component to reimbursement submissions in Serbia has raised
the standard of submissions to the NHIF. This standard is still too low to fully facilitate transparent evidence based decision making, however the new rulebook is
expected to force both the NHIF and the pharmaceutical industry to increase their
skills in evidence based decision making. However, Serbia still suffers from a lack
of the information required to construct quality pharmacoeconomic analysis, with
limited local cost estimates available and limited supply of health economic skills
in the region.
PHP16
Are Prices of Patent-Protected Pharamceuticals in the Top 5 Eu
Countries Converging?
Reinaud F 1, Ando G 2
1IHS, Paris, France, 2IHS, London, UK
.
.
Objectives: The goal of this study is to assess whether prices of innovative drugs
in the top 5 EU markets converge over time. Methods: Price trends of a sample of
50 innovative drugs, approved by the European Medicines Agency (EMA) in 2009 or
earlier, that are still patent-protected and marketed in each of the top 5 EU markets
were analysed over the period 2009-2014. The focus was on ex-manufacturing prices,
which were extracted from IHS’s international pricing database POLI. Discounts and
rebates were excluded from the analysis, and current exchange rates into Euros
were used. Given the timeframe, none of the products included in the sample was
assessed under the AMNOG reform in Germany. Results: While the data indicates
that there are still price differences across countries in 2014, these differences have
declined over time. In 2009, the price difference between the highest priced country
(Germany) and the lowest one (United Kingdom) was 24%; this figure dropped down
to 15% in 2014. The average price of the 50 products declined in all countries and
the overall price mean (all countries) slightly decreased - by around 5% - over the
period studied: from € 303.3 in 2009 to € 289.0 in 2014. This demonstrates a global
trend leading innovative drug prices to decrease over time while they are still patent
protected. Conclusions: Our data shows that prices slightly decrease over time,
and also that prices have started to decline in Germany. German prices in the sample
are still comparatively higher than the other major European markets, but with
most prices in Italy and Spain remaining constant, and those in France converging
to the mean, there are clear trends of price corridors shrinking across Europe. The
divergence is commonly larger at launch, and converges over time.
PHP17
Letting The Data Speak: A Shift of the Pharmaceutical Spending to
Households in Greece
Kyriopoulos D 1, Ollandezos M 1, Papadopoulos K 1, Kyriopoulos I I 2, Pentafragas V 1
1Pan Hellenic Union of Pharmaceutical Industry, Athens, Greece, 2National School of Public Health,
Athens, Greece
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Since 2009, Greece has implemented a fiscal consolidation programme that includes several reforms and budget cuts in health sector. Indicatively,
health expenditure has been reduced by more than 20% between 2009 and 2012.
Pharmaceutical sector can be characterized as one of the main sources of these
cuts. The objective of this study is to draw some early conclusions regarding the
impact of the current pharmaceutical policy on the structure of expenditure and the
access to medicines. Methods: The data are obtained from the Hellenic Statistical
Authority, the national accounts and the household surveys for the period 20092012, in order to examine potential changes of the public/private mix of the pharmaceutical expenditure. Results: Public pharmaceutical expenditure fell from €5.1
bn in 2009 to € 3 bn in 2012 (-42.5%). Private pharmaceutical expenditure was € 1.3 bn
in 2009, while it was approximately € 1.5 bn in 2012 (+12.4%). The total expenditure
dropped by 31.2%. The share of private expenditure on pharmaceuticals has sharply
increased during the study period. Specifically, the private expenditure was 20.6%
of the total pharmaceutical expenditure in 2009, while it approximated 34% in 2012.
Conclusions: The aforementioned imply that there is a shift from public to private spending for pharmaceuticals between 2009 and 2012. Moreover, preliminary
estimates for 2013 suggest that this trend is increasing. Therefore, apart from the
existing financial and income constraints, households are in front of an additional
financial burden. This change is associated with potential catastrophic expenditures
and reduction in patient compliance. The study findings suggest that individuals’
degrees of freedom are constrained and that patients express their preferences by
increased out of pocket payments. In the light of the above, the pharmaceutical
policy implemented so far can be associated to a sharp “indirect increase” of copayment and coinsurance rates.
PHP18
Economic Burden of Intravenous Iron Products In Public Hospitals
of Paris and Impact of Their New Hospital-Restricted Status
Therasse C 1, Bocquet F 2, Fusier I 1, Cordonnier A L 1, Sinègre M 1
1General Agency of Equipment and Health Products (AGEPS), AP-HP, Paris, France, 2Dauphine
University, Paris, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
A408
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: To assess the global economic consequences for French hospitals of
the European Commission (EC) decision to strengthen administration conditions
of intravenous iron products (IIP) (iron sucrose (IS) and ferric carboxymaltose (FC))
due to safety concerns. Following this EC decision, in February 2014, French Health
Authorities decided to give a hospital-restricted status (HRS) to IIP. Methods: We
compared, in acute care (medicine, -surgery-obstetrics) hospitals, IIP consumption
and expenditure (extracted from SAP software) before (2012 vs. 2013) and before-after
(02/2013-04/2013 vs. 02/2014-04/2014) they had a HRS, and the number of diagnosisrelated group “sessions of chemotherapy for non-tumor disease” (DRG-CNTD) linked
to anemia (Technical Agency of Information on Hospitals data). Results: 20 hospitals
were included. Before they had a HRS, IIP global consumption in volume increased by
9.6% (i. e. €171,022 spent more) in a year. After IIP had a HRS, the increase was 16.7%
(i. e. €164,338 spent more) in 3 months (02/2013-04/2013 vs. 02/2014-04/2014). 23.7% of
the increase was attributable to day hospital admissions (DHA) and 4.4% to dialysis
units. FC consumption was 23.9% higher (i. e. €188,838 spent more) in 2014 compared
to 2013, whereas IS consumption was 16.4% lower (i. e. € 24,500 spent less). DHA in
DRG-CNTD linked to anemia increased by a factor of 1.8. Conclusions: DHA as
part of the DRG-CNTD is the only way to finance this additional hospital activity (no
additional funding for traditional hospital care). FC’s cost of daily treatment (€120
to €150) is about 20 times IS’s (€ 5.2 to € 7.8), while a single tariff is allocated for the
DRG-CNTD (drug case-mix: €62, whatever the drug). Costs of the FC increasing use
to manage anemia may be offset by administration of other drugs, or the DRG-tariff
should be adjusted. Another alternative would be to implement a tender between IIP,
taking into account the cost-effective ratio of each drug.
PHP19
The Impact of Cost Containment Reforms to the Pharmaceutical
Benefits Scheme (Pbs) On Prescribing Volumes And Expenditure In
Australia: 1992 To 2011
Lee K S , Hendrie D , Sunderland V B , Moorin R
Curtin University, Perth, Australia
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The increase in PBS expenditure over the past two decades led to
the Australian Government implementing several cost containment measures. The
objective of the present study was to investigate the impact of these reforms on PBS
prescribing volumes and expenditure. Methods: Data retrieved from Medicare
Australia’s PBS Statistics database provided monthly government expenditure (benefit) and prescription volume (service) data. Segmented linear regression models
were used to analyse the time series data starting from 1 January 1992 to 31 March
2012. In each segment, between implementing the cost containment measures, two
parameters, the level and trend were used to estimate the impact of the intervention. A lag of 12 months was applied to adjust for seasonality and forward stepwise
eliminations were applied to obtain a parsimonious model. Seven cost containment
measures were investigated: the economic evaluation requirement for drug listing
(1/01/1993), re-supply limits (1/11/1994), two co-payment increases (1/01/1997 &
1/01/2005), therapeutic group premium (TGP) policy (1/02/1998), safety net 20-day
rule (1/01/2006), and price reductions in multiple brand drugs in Formulary 2 (F2)
(1/08/2008). Results: All interventions except the re-supply limits policy were
found to have a significant impact on PBS services or benefits. Reductions in the
services and benefits trend were observed in two measures, the TGP policy and
safety net 20-day rule while a reduction in the services trend was observed for
the economic evaluation requirement measure. No significant trend changes were
observed in the post F2 price reductions while higher co-payments resulted in a
reduction in the level of services followed by an increase in the trend of services and
benefits. Conclusions: Many of the cost containment measures implemented
in Australia have been effective in containing cost. Among these measures, the
safety net 20-days rule was estimated to be the most effective in reducing drugs
utilisation and expenditure.
PHP20
The Effects of Reforms, Price Cuts and Global Budget
Implementation on Biotechnological Medicine Sales Which Have
Annual Average Highest Amount Of Sales Between 2008-2013 In
Turkey
Vural E H 1, Vural I M 1, Yigit O 2, Uman N 1, Tolun C 1, Babacan S 1, Dogan E 1, Akbulat A 1,
Kahveci R 3, Malhan S 4, Artiran G 1, Kerman S 1
1Turkish Medicines and Medical Devices Agency, Ankara, Turkey, 2Turkish Statistical Institute,
Ankara, Turkey, 3Ankara Numune Education and Research Hospital, Ankara, Turkey, 4Baskent
University, Ankara, Turkey
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In 2003 Health Transformation Program and in 2006 Social Security
Reform were launched in Turkey. At the end of the years 2009 and 2011 price cuts
were done by the Government and between the years 2010-2012, there was a global
budget implementation in Turkey. The top 100 medicines, annual average highest
amount of sales of between 2008-2013, had one to four of the total pharmaceutical
market value in 2013. We aimed to examine the status of biotech-medicines in the
first 100 medicine’s and evaluate the effects of policy interventions on these medicine sales. Methods: While pharmaceutical sales data were obtained from the IMS
Health-Turkey data base, prices and characteristics of medicines were obtained from
the Turkish Medicine and Medical Devices Agency data bases. Each group (biotech/
nonbiotech-medicines) was analyzed using TRAMO and SEATS method. Results:
19 medicines are biotechnological. In 2009 compared to 2008 while biotech-medicines amount increased by 43.8%, nonbiotech-medicines amount increased by
14.2%. In subsequent years, an increase over the previous year is observed at lower
rates for biotech-medicines. This total amount has decreased compared to previous
years for nonbiotech-medicines. 2014 and 2015 for the consumption of biotechnological medicines was estimated to be around 9 million boxes, expenditure for 2014
of 1360 million Turkish Liras (TL) and 2015 million TL for the year 2015. On the other
hand, non-biotechnological medicines consumption would be approximately 185
million boxes and for the year 2014 2225 million TL, for the year 2015 2280 million
TL are projected. Conclusions: Biotechnological medicines have high unit costs
and these costs are increasing compared to year to year. Policy interventions did not
effected biotechnological medicine sales negatively. While big differences between
the biotechnological and non-biotechnological medicine box sales will continue,
the gap between the biotechnological and non-biotechnological medicines total
amount will be closer.
PHP21
Trends In Clinical Drug Development Timeframes, 1981-2013 – An
Example From Virology
Ward D J 1, Hammond E 2, Linden-Phillips L 1, Stevens A 2
1NIHR Horizon Scanning Centre, Birmingham, UK, 2University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: There are concerns that the time taken to develop innovative new drugs
is increasing, delaying access to and increasing the costs of new medicines. Both the
clinical trial stage and regulatory approval stage for new drugs are important components of overall development time, and we sought to determine whether the length
of either of these stages is increasing, using new anti-viral drugs launched in the UK
as a case-study. Methods: New anti-viral drugs launched in the UK between 1981
and 2013 were identified from the British National Formulary. Initiation of clinical
development was determined from Pharmaprojects (Informa Healthcare) and Medline
searches; the Investigational New Drug Application or first report of phase I trials
was taken as the start of clinical development, whichever was earlier. Regulatory
submission and approval dates were obtained from the European Medicines Agency
and UK Medicines and Healthcare Regulatory Agency. Results: 43 new anti-viral
drugs were launched in the UK between 1981 and 2013, with a mean time from start
of clinical trials to approval of 6.4 years. This period increased from 4.8 years for drugs
launched 1981-93, to 6.0 years for those launched 1994-2003, and 7.9 years for those
launched 2004-2013; and a statistically significant positive linear trend was observed
(r= 0.47). The mean time from regulatory submission to approval was 1.1 years, but
no significant linear trend was seen for this time period (r= 0.20). New drugs for HIV
typically spent less time in clinical development than other anti-viral drugs (mean
5.7 vs 7.3 years, p=0.049). However clinical development times for HIV and other antiviral drugs increased at a similar rate. Conclusions: For anti-viral drugs launched
in the UK, the time spent in clinical development has increased markedly since the
1980s, and this increase is not related to increasing time taken for regulatory approval.
PHP22
Impact of Health Policy Changes on Trends of Pharmaceutical
Market in Turkey
Safak Yilmaz E 1, Kockaya G 2, Yenilmez F B 3, Saylan M 2, Tatar M 3, Hilal Vural E 1, Vural I M 1,
Akbulat A 1, Gursoz H 1, Artiran G 1, Kerman S 1
1Turkish Medicines and Medical Devices Agency, Ankara, Turkey, 2Health Economics and Policy
Association, Ankra, Turkey, 3Hacettepe University, Ankara, Turkey
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Turkish Ministry of Health (MoH) initiated Health Transformation
Program (HTP) in 2002. HTP impacted all clinical and economic outcomes of health
including pharmaceutical sales by improving access to health services. Total pharmaceutical market reached US $ 8 billion in last 10 years. HTP improved health
coverage and access to health services, additional policies are implemented by MoH
for controlling this increasing trend on pharmaceutical consumption. The aim of
this analysis is to understand the impact of selected 5 major policy changes to total
pharmaceutical consumption in between 2002-2012. Methods: 132 months sales
data with segmented regression analysis for interrupted time series were used.
International reference pricing of pharmaceuticals (RF), mandatory reimbursement
dossier submission for new molecules, new indications and line extensions with
medical and economic evaluations (MRDS), auditing for good manufacturing practice (GMP), family physician system (FP) and compulsory medical service for physicians (CMS) were selected as five major policies that may affect cost, demand and
supply of pharmaceuticals. We analyzed possible breaks in trends prior and after
the implementation of 5 selected policies of the HTP. The analysis was conducted for
cost (CS) and unit sales (US) for all pharmaceutical products. The Durbin-Watson d
statistics of SPSS version 20.0 was used as a test for serial correlation of error terms.
Shift in slope with p< 0.05 was considered as statistically significant. Results: All,
except for RF policy changes, had a negative impact on the trends for CS. RF policy
did not reverse the trends in CS and US however it slowed positive trend in CS significantly down. All policies hindering impact on the increasing trend in US. However,
only RF and CMS policies reached statistically significant level. Conclusions:
Policies within the HTP framework were successful to control pharmaceutical
expenditures while improving access to health care. International reference pricing has a limited impact on controlling growth of pharmaceutical market.
PHP23
Boosting Biosimilars Uptake in European Countries
Young K E 1, Rémuzat C 2, Urbinati D 3, Toumi M 4
1Creativ-Ceutical, Milan, Italy, 2Creativ-Ceutical, Paris, France, 3Creativ-Ceutical, Luxembourg,
Luxembourg, 4University Aix-Marseille, Marseille, France
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To provide an overview of biosimilars uptake in Europe and assess
policies and initiatives that might boost uptakes of biosimilars in European countries. Methods: A literature review was conducted from European and national
health authorities websites, Generics and Biosimilars Initiative (GaBi) website,
Medline® database, and available grey literature. Results: To date, 17 biosimilars were granted marketing authorization throughout the European Union and
the European Medicines Agency released 9 product-specific biosimilar guidelines.
Recent approval of the first monoclonal antibody biosimilar of infliximab demonstrates the evolution of the European regulatory framework over time allowing
approval of structurally complex molecules. Despite Europe has been a pioneer in
this regulatory path, biosimilars uptake still remains limited (about 30% to 50%
volume uptake) with modest price discounts from the originators (15% to 30%). If
Germany authorized substitution of biological products produced by a same manufacturer in 2011, none of the Members States had allowed substitution of biological
products from different manufacturers so far. With adoption of the 2014 social
A409
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
security funding law, France is becoming the first country to allow biosimilars substitution when initiating treatment course. To encourage biosimilars substitution,
the Norwegian Medicines Agency announced in 2013 the funding of clinical studies
with infliximab originator and biosimilars in which patients would be switched
from originator to biosimilars forth and back. Moreover, increased price discounts
of about 40% were applied for infliximab in Norway. By 2020, expected savings
for biosimilars are estimated around € 12-33 billion in big EU5, Poland, Romania,
Sweden. Conclusions: While patent cliff of major biologic drugs is expected on
the next 5 years, initiatives to reassure physicians to prescribe biosimilars and
implementation of substitution rules, even if still raising some reluctance, might
contribute to boost biosimilar uptake in Europe. Price competition will impose
manufacturers of branded biologics to adopt new pricing strategies.
PHP24
Effects of Reference Price System on Medicines Which Have Annual
Average Highest Amount Of Sales Of Between Years 2008-2013
Uman N 1, Tolun C 1, Babacan S 1, Dogan E 1, Vural I M 1, Vural E H 1, Dasdag M M 1, Safak
Yilmaz E 1, Malhan S 2, Kahveci R 3, Akbulat A 1, Artiran G 1, Kerman S 1
1Turkish Medicines and Medical Devices Agency, Ankara, Turkey, 2Baskent University, Ankara,
Turkey, 3Ankara Numune Education and Research Hospital, Ankara, Turkey
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In Turkey, a medicine reference pricing system has been in use since
2004. The price of pharmaceuticals is determined by the acceptance of the lowest
ex-factory price in the reference countries (Greece, France, Italy, Portugal, Spain). We
aimed to examine the first 100 medicine’s, having the annual maximum amount
on the average Turkish Lira (TL) based medicine sales between the years 2008-2013
which have 25.1% value in the total pharmaceutical market, reference price changes
in these period. Methods: While pharmaceutical sales data were obtained from
the IMS Health-Turkey data base, medicine prices were obtained from the Medicine
Price List published by Turkish Medicines and Medical Devices Agency. Results: In
2008, the top 100 medicines in determining the price of most of Italy were taken as
the reference country, followed by Spain and Greece. In 2013 while Greece is taken as
the reference country more common; France and Italy are to follow. In 2008, only one
medicine’s price increased, and only one medicine’s price decreased because of the
reference price. In 2009 and 2010 price increases did not seen. In 2009, 8 and in 2010,
30 medicines prices had decreased. In 2011, 2012 and 2013 totally 27 medicines reference prices had increased. 21 medicine’s price in 2011, 20 medicine’s price in 2012
and 24 medicine’s price in 2013 had decreased. While mostly France (13 medicines)
connected to the reference price increases, mostly Greece (58 medicines) has been
based reference price drop in the analyzed period. Conclusions: The application
of reference prices, medicine prices to be reduced to a large extent. Greece based
reference price decreases are observed to be mainly from the year 2010. The reason
for this is considered as the economic crisis in Greece and the agreement with the
IMF, EU and ECB, the Greek government at cost-containment.
PHP25
Implications Of External Price Referencing of Pharmaceuticals in
Middle East Countries
Kalo Z 1, Alabbadi I 2, Al Ahdab O G 3, Al-Badriyeh D 4, Alowayesh M 5, Al-Saggabi A H 6,
Elmahdawy M 7, Tanzi V L 8, Alsultan H 9, Akhras K 10, Kanavos P 11
1Eötvös Loránd University (ELTE), Budapest, Hungary, 2University of Jordan, Amman, Jordan,
3Ministry of Health, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates, 4College of Pharmacy, Qatar University,
Doha, Qatar, 5Kuwait University, Yarmook, Kuwait, 6Ministry of National Guard Health Affairs,
Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, 7Ministry of Health, Cairo, Egypt, 8American University of Beirut, Beirut,
Lebanon, 9Dasman Diabetes Institute, Yarmook, Kuwait, 10Novartis, Dubai, United Arab Emirates,
11London School of Economics and Political Science, London, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: External price referencing (EPR) is a method to control pharmaceutical
prices, wherein decision-makers specify a basket of countries, whose prices they
use to inform their national target price. EPR is practiced frequently worldwide,
though countries vary substantially in how they execute EPR. The objective of our
pioneer collaborative health policy research initiative was to analyse how EPR is
used in Middle East countries, and assess whether EPR results in narrower price corridor for innovative pharmaceuticals compared to non-pharmaceutical services not
subjected to EPR. Methods: In Q1 2014, we conducted a survey on EPR regulations,
and collected prices of 16 innovative pharmaceuticals and 10 non-pharmaceutical
services in six Middle East countries (Egypt, Jordan, Kuwait, Lebanon, Saudi Arabia,
UAE). Prices in local currency were converted to USD by using market exchange
rates. Maximum and minimum prices of each pharmaceutical and non-pharmaceutical technology were compared to mean prices in the study countries. Results:
EPR regulations are most stringent in Egypt and Saudi Arabia (largest study countries), mandating the lowest pharmaceutical price out of a basket comprising more
than 25 countries each. By contrast, Kuwait references the country of origin only. The
average price corridor is +/-38% for pharmaceuticals and +/-78% for outpatient and
hospital services compared to mean prices. Conclusions: EPR results in narrower
price corridor for innovative pharmaceuticals compared to other health care services. Prices of innovative pharmaceuticals are the lowest in Egypt and Saudi Arabia,
and the highest in Kuwait, indicating the importance of population size and EPR
implementation on drug price levels. However, EPR results in higher pharmaceutical
prices in lower income countries compared to non-pharmaceutical services, which
may limit timely access of patients to new medicines in these countries compared
to global markets. Stakeholders should understand the implications of EPR and
develop solutions to prevent its negative consequences.
PHP26
Quantification of Switching Trends in the Greek Pharmaceutical
Market During the Period Of Crisis
Ollandezos M 1, Charitonidis S 2, Papadopoulos K 1, Katsoulakis M 2, Kofinas K 2,
Kyriopoulos J 3
1Pan Hellenic Union of Pharmaceutical Industry, Athens, Greece, 2IMS Health Hellas, Athens,
Greece, 3National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In 2009, Greece entered into one of the most serious economic downturns in its modern history. In May 2010, the country was put under the supervision of Troika (EU, ECB and IMF). Retail pharmaceutical market with size c. a. € 6.5
bn in retail prices for 2009 (public pharmaceutical expenditure € 5.2 bn), was one
of the main targets for change through the implementation of new policies and
drastic spending cuts. The purpose of this study was to measure the impact that
these new policies for pharmaceutical spending had and how this was attributed
to the levers of price, market volume and product mix. Methods: An economic
model was used, based on IMS Hellas’ and Hellenic Statistical Authority data,
to measure the contribution that (a) price; (b) market volume; and (c) product
mix had on the reduction in the size of the retail market for pharmaceuticals in
the period 2009-2014. The detailed approach decomposes the market change, as
measured in values, into those attributed to (a) price (assuming market volume
and product mix are constant); (b) market volume (assuming prices and product
mix are unchanged); (c) product mix. Results: The analysis indicated that, the
major contributor in the reduction of the pharmaceutical market size was the
price of medicines. It has been estimated that 87% of the reduction (> € 1.2 bn) is
coming from price. Volume contributed an additional c. a. 38% (> € 0.5 bn) in the
reduction of the size but, at the same time, it was partially offset from substitution with pricier medicines. Conclusions: Price was the major driver for the
reduction in the size of the retail pharmaceutical market during the period of
crisis. Volume had an impact as well but it was partially offset by switch towards
more expensive medicines.
PHP27
Is the French Liste–En–Sus Still Supporting Access To Innovative
Medicines?
Ortiz I 1, Conti C 1, Furniss S J 2
.
.
.
.
1GfK, London, UK, 2GfK, Melton
Mowbray, UK
Objectives: The “liste-en-sus” was implemented within the framework
of the HPST [1] law. One of its objectives was to ensure access to highly-priced
innovative medicines in hospital settings without distorting the DiagnosticRelated Groups (DRG). The objective of this research is to analyse the degree of
innovation of the medicines included in the “liste-en-sus”. Methods: Starting
from the ATIH [2] database, an initial analysis consisted of identifying all the
Health Technology Assessments (HTAs) for each product included in the “listeen-sus” available on the HAS website [3] . Then, for each HTA, the following information was collected: assessment date, SMR [4] and ASMR [5] scores. Results:
The liste-en sus includes 123 medicines. 21% have no HTA available. Another 19%
were last evaluated before 2004. Among the medicines which had undergone an
HTA since 2004, 7% were granted an ASMR I, 27% an ASMR II, 22% an ASMR III,
8% an ASMR IV, 36% an ASMR V. In other terms, amongst the medicines which
have undergone an HTA in the last 10 years, about 45% of them were deemed
non-innovative (ASMR IV/V). Those medicines mainly consist in antihemorrhagics
(27%), antianaemics (18%), antineoplastics (15%) and immune sera and immunoglobulins (15%)[6] . Although they are not innovative, those medicines are only
used in a proportion of patients and are thus likely to distort DRG. To put these
results into perspective, since 2005, 92% of evaluated medicines were granted an
ASMR IV/V [7]. Conclusions: Looking at the list-en-sus’ objectives, the most
decisive criterion seems to be more stability of the DRG rather than access to
innovative medicines; however a higher proportion of the medicines in the listeen-sus are innovative.
PHP28
A Multi-Stakeholder (Physician, Payer, Patient, and Industry)
Qualitative Analysis of the Policies That Would Support A
Sustainable European Biosimilars Medicines Market Combined
With A Quantitative Analysis of the Multi-Stakeholder Benefits A
Sustainable Medicines Market Would Deliver
Whitehouse J T 1, Teale C W 1, Glover J C 1, Taylor C 1, Lino Mendonca V 2
1GfK Market Access, Melton Mowbray, UK, 2European Generic Medicines Association (EGA),
Brussels, Belgium
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To establish the key policy areas that will drive the establishment
of a sustainable biosimilar medicines market. To outline the benefits that these
will bring to Physicians, Payers, Patients, and Industry, with particular focus
on the benefits for European National Health systems. Methods: 71 qualitative in-depth interviews were conducted across 7 European markets: France,
Germany, Hungary, Italy, Poland, Spain and the UK, collecting insight from
experts and policy influencers at pan-European, National and Regional levels,
Physicians, Payers, Pharmacists, Patients, and Industry. Quantitative modelling
used a systems dynamics approach with in-depth analysis of 3 representative
biologic products: trastuzumab, bevacizumab, and adalimumab. Dynamics were
based on a delphi panel of expert opinions. The five forces of supplier power, buyer
power, impact of new entrants, impact of substitutes, and competitive rivalry
were addressed. A ranking of the attractiveness of policy combinations from a
sustainability and benefit perspective was made based on a biosimilar medicines
market “Sustainability Index” and the calculation of the magnitude of the benefits (cost savings, additional patients treated) that the policy combination was
likely to produce. Results: The qualitative analysis has shown that a European
biosimilars medicines market based on stakeholder and policy alignment in four
key areas (1. education and understanding, 2. experience and use, 3. sustainable
pricing, 4. rational decision making) will be sustainable and deliver benefits to
all stakeholders. The quantitative analysis demonstrated that the most efficient
policy combination, measured in terms of the sustainability index, was the same
for all 3 molecules and would deliver cumulative 10 year cost savings of between
24% and 26%. Conclusions: Greater stakeholder alignment and the combination of specific policies will increase the sustainability of the European biosimilar
medicines market. A sustainable biosimilar medicines market will deliver significant benefits to all stakeholders.
A410
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PHP29
Impact of Health Policy Changes on the Cost Sales of 5 Top Selling
ATC1 Phramaceutical Groups in Turkey
PHP32
Impact of Health Policy Changes on the Growth Locally
Manufactured and Imported Pharmaceutical Markets In Turkey
Yenilmez F B 1, Kockaya G 2, Saylan M 2, Safak Yilmaz E 3, Tatar M 1, Hilal Vural E 3, Vural I M 3,
Akbulat A 3, Gursoz H 3, Artiran G 3, Kerman S 3
1Hacettepe University, Ankara, Turkey, 2Health Economics and Policy Association, Ankra, Turkey,
3Turkish Medicines and Medical Devices Agency, Ankara, Turkey
Hilal Vural E 1, Kockaya G 2, Yenilmez F B 3, Saylan M 2, Safak Yilmaz E 1, Tatar M 3, Vural I M 1,
Akbulat A 1, Gursoz H 1, Artiran G 1, Kerman S 1
1Turkish Medicines and Medical Devices Agency, Ankara, Turkey, 2Health Economics and Policy
Association, Ankra, Turkey, 3Hacettepe University, Ankara, Turkey
Objectives: Turkish Ministry of Health (MoH) initiated Health Transformation
Program (HTP) in 2002. HTP impacted all clinical and economic outcomes of
health including pharmaceutical sales by improving access to health services.
Total pharmaceutical market reached US $ 8 billion in last 10 years. The objective
of this study is to understand the differences in the impact of selected 5 policies
on 5 top selling ATC1 groups in terms of cost sales (CS) in the respective periods. Methods: 132 months sales data with segmented regression analysis for
interrupted time series were used. International reference pricing of pharmaceuticals (RF), mandatory reimbursement dossier submission for new molecules, new
indications and line extensions with medical and economic evaluations (MRDS),
auditing for good manufacturing practice (GMP), family physician system (FP)
and compulsory medical service for physicians (CMS) were selected as five major
policies that may affect cost, demand and supply of pharmaceuticals. We analyzed
possible breaks in trends prior and after the implementation of 5 selected policies
of the HTP. The Durbin-Watson d statistics of SPSS version 20.0 was used as a test
for serial correlation of error terms. Shift in slope with p< 0.05 was considered
as statistically significant. Results: There was an increasing trend for all ATC1
groups prior the implementation of policies. The trends in systemic antienfectives (J0), alimentary and metabolism (A0) and Respiratory system (R0) Central
Nerveous System (N0) groups were negatively impacted from all policies except for
RF. All policies impacted negatively the trend in cardiovascular system (C0) group.
Implementation of RF had a significant positive impact on A0 and R0 group. Impact
of RF was positive on C0 however it did not reach signifcance level. Conclusions:
Policy changes were very successful to control growth of top selling pharmaceutical groups while improving access to health. RF and CMS policies were the least
effective cost containment measures
Objectives: Turkish Ministry of Health (MoH) initiated Health Transformation
Program (HTP) in 2002. HTP impacted all clinical and economic outcomes of health
including pharmaceutical sales by improving access to health services. The objective
of this analysis is to to understand the impact of selected 5 major policy changes
by MoH to sales of locally manufactured and imported pharmaceutical products in
the respective periods. Methods: 132 months sales data with segmented regression analysis for interrupted time series were used. International reference pricing
of pharmaceuticals (RF), mandatory reimbursement dossier submission for new
molecules, new indications and line extensions with medical and economic evaluations (MRDS), auditing for good manufacturing practice (GMP), family physician
system (FP) and compulsory medical service for physicians (CMS) were selected as
five major policies that may affect cost, demand and supply of pharmaceuticals.
The analysis was conducted for total imported pharmaceutical (IP) sales and total
locally manufactured pharmaceutical (LMP) sales. The Durbin-Watson d statistics
of SPSS version 20.0 was used as serial correlation. Shift in slope with p< 0.05 was
considered as statistically significant. Results: The negative effect of RF policy
change on CS trends was more prominent for IP than LMP sales. However, the shift
in CS due to other 4 policy changes was lower for IP when compared with LMP
sales. The differences reached statistical significance level except for CMS policy.
Although not significant, positive shift of US due to RF policy change was higher for
LMP than IP sales. There was a decreasing slope of LMP unit sales following MRDS
and GMP policies but an increasing slope of IP unit sales. Conclusions: Policy
changes may effect at differently direction and amount the unit and cost sales
of LMPs and IPs. Cost control mechnism such as RF has a more negative effect on
imported product as expected.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To compare the savings achieved by appraisal of the clinical and cost
effectiveness of individual drugs by NICE’S Technology Appraisals for England &
Wales with those due to price cuts under the Pharmaceutical Pricing Regulation
Scheme 2000-2014. Methods: Maximum and best estimates of savings attributable
to the 512 technologies appraised and published by NICE to end 2013 with published
reports of the PPRS. Published estimates of the cost of the Multiple Risk Sharing
Scheme, the Cancer Drugs Fund and the End-of-Life criteria. Results: Savings
attributable to NICE were relatively low. Few drugs were not recommended and of
these, special schemes, funds and exceptions required by the governments of the
day, reduced savings that might otherwise have resulted. The bulk of the savings
due to NICE resulted from price cuts under Patient Access Schemes from 2009.
Higher savings resulted from cross the board price cuts in the PPRS. Conclusions:
Health systems aiming to control pharmaceutical expenditure should consider both
individual level appraisal of drugs as overall budget control of the branded prescription drugs budget.
PHP31
The Effects of Reforms, Price Cuts And Global Budget
Implementation on Original/Generic Medicine Sales Which Have
Annual Average Highest Amount Of Sales Between 2008-2013 In
Turkey
Vural I M 1, Vural E H 1, Yigit O 2, Dogan E 1, Babacan S 1, Tolun C 1, Uman N 1, Akbulat A 1,
Malhan S 3, Kahveci R 4, Artiran G 1, Kerman S 1
1Turkish Medicines and Medical Devices Agency, Ankara, Turkey, 2Turkish Statistical Institute,
Ankara, Turkey, 3Baskent University, Ankara, Turkey, 4Ankara Numune Education and Research
Hospital, Ankara, Turkey
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Young K E 1, Rémuzat C 2, Urbinati D 3, Toumi M 4
1Creativ-Ceutical, Milan, Italy, 2Creativ-Ceutical, Paris, France, 3Creativ-Ceutical, Luxembourg,
Luxembourg, 4University Aix-Marseille, Marseille, France
Raftery J P
University of Southampton, Southampton, UK
.
.
.
PHP33
An Overview of the Biosimilar Market in the Us
PHP30
Saving Money in Health Care: Cost Effectiveness of Individual
Drugs (As By Nice) Or Budget Cuts (As Under Pprs)?
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In 2003 Health Transformation Program and in 2006 Social Security
Reform were launched in Turkey. At the end of the years 2009 and 2011 price cuts
were done by the Government and between the years 2010-2012, there was a global
budget implementation in Turkey. The top 100 medicines, annual average highest
amount of sales of between 2008-2013, had one to four of the total pharmaceutical market value in 2013. We aimed to examine the status of original and generic
medicines in the first 100 medicine’s and evaluate the effects of policy interventions on these medicine sales. Methods: While pharmaceutical sales data were
obtained from the IMS Health-Turkey data base, prices and characteristics of medicines were obtained from the Turkish Medicine and Medical Devices Agency data
bases. Each group (original/generic medicines) was analyzed using TRAMO and
SEATS method. Results: 78 medicines are original, 22 medicines are generic. In
2009 compared to the previous year both generic and original medicine spending
increased by respectively 16% and 20,9%. Between the years 2010-2012 compared
to the previous year both generic and original medicines spending decreased by
different ratios. In 2013 according to 2012, generic medicine spending decreased
by 8.3% but original medicine spending increased by 7.9%. In 2013 total original
medicine spending was 2888 million Turkish Liras (TL). This amount estimated to
be 3050 million TL in 2014 and 3145 million TL in 2015. Generic medicines total
spend was 501 million TL in 2013. This amount projected to be 510 million TL in
2014 and 515 million TL in 2015. Conclusions: Original medicines dominated the
top 100 medicines. The total effect of the intervention is more negatively in generic
medicines. At the end of 2013, it is understood that original medicines total amount
have a tendency to increase.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: This study intends to provide an overview of the US biosimilar policies and its impact on the development of the biosimilar market in this country. Methods: A literature review was conducted from the US Food and Drug
Administration (FDA) website, Generics and Biosimilars Initiative (GaBi) websites, Medline® database, and available grey literature. Results: The Biologics
Price Competition and Innovation Act (2009) established an abbreviated Biologic
License Application (aBLA) pathway/351 (k) for biosimilars in addition to the 1.
Non-abbreviated biologic license application (BLA) /351 (a); 2. New Drug Application
(NDA) /505 (b) (2); or 3. Abbreviated New Drug Application (ANDA). 10 follow-on
biologics under NDA/ANDA and one under BLA were previously approved. Product
identity and therapeutic equivalence of some biologics (i. e. Lovenox, Copaxone) led
to important debates for defining the application pathway. Currently, the FDA has no
351 (k) approvals. The lack of clear FDA guidance on data requirements for biosimilarity in aBLA was a limiting factor for manufacturers to go through aBLA pathway.
They preferably opted for a classical BLA pathway due to its longer exclusivity period
and nearly the same amount of data required (i. e. Neutroval). The impact of the
recently released FDA draft guidance on designing clinical studies for biosimilarity (5/13/14) is yet to be seen but should address issues on proving biosimilarity
in aBLA. Further debate is anticipated but an increase in applications is expected
and biosimilars savings are projected at $250 billion by 2024. Conclusions:
The biosimilars market is still lagging, specifically compared to the EU, with no
351 (k) approvals despite the US’ leading position in the biopharmaceuticals market.
However, the US’ high prices for innovative products and history of generic utilization can signify a positive market projection after a transition period, as was seen
in Germany and Sweden. Further, the new FDA guidance by addressing biosimilarity
issues may ease biosimilar market entry.
PHP34
Impact of Health Policy Changes on the Growth Locally
Manufactured and Imported Pharmaceutical Markets of Top
Selling Atc1 Phramaceutical Group (Alimentary and Metabolism (A0)
In Turkey
Kockaya G 1, Yenilmez F B 2, Saylan M 1, Safak Yilmaz E 3, Tatar M 2, Hilal Vural E 3, Vural I M 3,
Akbulat A 3, Gursoz H 3, Artiran G 3, Kerman S 3
1Health Economics and Policy Association, Ankra, Turkey, 2Hacettepe University, Ankara, Turkey,
3Turkish Medicines and Medical Devices Agency, Ankara, Turkey
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Turkish Ministry of Health (MoH) initiated Health Transformation
Program (HTP) in 2002. HTP impacted all clinical and economic outcomes of health
including pharmaceutical sales by improving access to health services. Total pharmaceutical market reached US $ 8 billion in last 10 years. The objective of this
analysis is to understand the impact of selected 5 major policy changes by MoH
on the growth locally manufactured and imported pharmaceutical markets of top
selling ATC1 phramaceutical group, which was Alimentary and Metabolism (A0)
with US $ 1.1 billion sales in 2012, in the respective periods in Turkey. Methods:
132 months sales data with segmented regression analysis for interrupted time
series were used. International reference pricing of pharmaceuticals (RF), mandatory reimbursement dossier submission for new molecules, new indications and
line extensions with medical and economic evaluations (MRDS), auditing for good
manufacturing practice (GMP), family physician system (FP) and compulsory medical service for physicians (CMS) were selected as five major policies that may affect
cost, demand and supply of pharmaceuticals. We analyzed possible breaks in trends
A411
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
prior and after the implementation of 5 selected policies of the HTP. The analysis
was conducted for total imported pharmaceutical (IP) sales and total locally manufactured pharmaceutical (LMP) sales in the A0. The Durbin-Watson d statistics of
SPSS version 20.0 was used as a test for serial correlation of error terms. Shift in
slope with p< 0.05 was considered as statistically significant. Results: All policies
effected the LMP sales more positively than IP sales except FP. However, the difference of impact was moderately positive for LMP sales, there was not any statistically significant change. Conclusions: Policy changes may effect at differently
direction and amount the cost sales of LMPs and IPs. Non significant effect of these
policy changes may partly explained by limited oberservation time and by other
market dynamics.
PHP35
Characteristics of The Medicines Which Have Annual Average
Highest Amount Of Sales Of Between Years 2008-2013
Akbulat A 1, Dogan E 1, Babacan S 1, Uman N 1, Tolun C 1, Vural I M 1, Vural E H 1, Safak Yilmaz
E 1, Dasdag M M 1, Kahveci R 2, Malhan S 3, Artiran G 1, Kerman S 1
1Turkish Medicines and Medical Devices Agency, Ankara, Turkey, 2Ankara Numune Education and
Research Hospital, Ankara, Turkey, 3Baskent University, Ankara, Turkey
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In 2003 Health Transformation Program and in 2006 Social Security
Reform were launched in Turkey. At the end of the years 2009 and 2011 price cuts
were done by the Government and between the years 2010-2012, there was a global
budget implementation in Turkey. Health implications of these developments in the
medicine market have not been analyzed in a comprehensive manner. The top 100
medicines, annual average highest amount of sales of between 2008-2013, had one
to four of the total pharmaceutical market value in 2013. In this study we aimed to
determine these first 100 medicine’s, which have higher total sales amount, defining
characteristics. Methods: While pharmaceutical sales data were obtained from
the IMS Health-Turkey data base, characteristics of medicines were obtained from
the Turkish Medicine And Medical Devices Agency and the Social Security Agency
data bases. Results: While 78 medicines are original, 22 medicines are generic.
60 medicines are imported medicines, 40 medicines are manufactured medicines.
19 medicines are biotechnological medicines and all of these biotechnological
medicines are original and imported. 96 medicines covered by Social Security payments. Equivalent of 65 medicines are available (each equivalent group from 1-30,
an average of 13 generics available). 19 medicines and 15 medicines are respectively
systemic anti-infectives and antineoplastics and immunomodulating agents. In
this study, the license holders of the medicines are 40 firms in total. 15 firms have a
market share of 75% and the medicines which, have 77,7% portion of total amount,
are created by multinational firms. Conclusions: In the years which were the
effects of reforms, price cuts and global budget implementation seen, the medicines
which have higher total sales amount were mostly original, imported, covered by
Social Security payments and created by multinational firms.
PHP37
Impact Of Health Policy Changes on Unit Sales of 5 Top Selling Atc1
Phramaceutical Groups In Turkey
Saylan M 1, Safak Yilmaz E 2, Yenilmez F B 3, Kockaya G 1, Tatar M 3, Hilal Vural E 2, Vural I M 2,
Akbulat A 2, Gursoz H 2, Artiran G 2, Kerman S 2
1Health Economics and Policy Association, Ankra, Turkey, 2Turkish Medicines and Medical Devices
Agency, Ankara, Turkey, 3Hacettepe University, Ankara, Turkey
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
PHP39
The Grass is Always Greener on the Other Side or Why There Is Little
Meaning in International Pharmaceutical Price Comparison
Bierbaum M 1, Düttmann S 2, Amler N 1, Döpfer S 2
Erlangen-Nürnberg, Nuremberg, Germany, 2FAU ErlangenNürnberg, Nuremberg, Germany
.
.
.
.
1Friedrich-Alexander-Universität
Objectives: In many countries there is an ongoing debate about pharmaceutical
pricing. Especially in Germany there is common belief that pharmaceuticals are
more expensive than in other countries. Payers are making use of this belief when
negotiating prices with pharmaceutical companies. We wanted to know if there
is scientific evidence for this conception. Methods: We conducted a systematic
literature review in order to identify price comparison studies comparing Germany
with at least three other countries. We searched Pudmed and six other databases
to identify relevant articles published between 1998 and today. Furthermore we
developed a quality rating tool based on the approaches from Andersson (1993) and
Danzon/Kim (1998). Results: Our review delivered 4.927 articles from which 28 met
our inclusion criteria. Study quality was quite heterogeneous, ranging from 3 to 13
points with an average score of 8.8 out of 15. Some studies use old data back from
1992 and no study considers the recent changes in German legislation (AMNOG).
In addition no study includes rebates and selection of compared pharmaceuticals
is often arbitrary. Reviewed studies report German pharmaceutical prices slightly
above international average. High quality studies (upper quartile, quality score:
> 9) find German prices below international average, whereas low quality studies
(lower quartile, quality score: < 7) find German prices above international average. Conclusions: Results of the review suggest that there is a misconception of
pharmaceutical pricing in Germany. Within a price comparison study any desired
result can be achieved by deliberately choosing different approaches. At the end of
the day payers and policy makers should stop comparing prices with other countries. Instead resources should better be spent on making value based reimbursment
decisions in the respective health care setting.
.
Objectives: Turkish Ministry of Health (MoH) initiated Health Transformation
Program (HTP) in 2002. HTP impacted all clinical and economic outcomes of health
including pharmaceutical sales by improving access to health services. The objective
of this study is to understand the differences in the impact of selected 5 policies
on 5 top selling ATC1 groups in terms of unit sales (US) in the respective periods. Methods: 132 months sales data with segmented regression analysis for
interrupted time series were used. International reference pricing of pharmaceuticals (RF), mandatory reimbursement dossier submission for new molecules, new
indications and line extensions with medical and economic evaluations (MRDS),
auditing for good manufacturing practice (GMP), family physician system (FP) and
compulsory medical service for physicians (CMS) were selected as five major policies
that may affect cost, demand and supply of pharmaceuticals. We analyzed possible
breaks in trends prior and after the implementation of 5 selected policies of the
HTP. The top 5 selling ATC1 groups were Systemic Antienfectives (J0), Cardiovascular
System (C0), Alimentary and Metabolism (A0), Respiratory (R0) and Central Nerveous
System (C0). The Durbin-Watson d statistics of SPSS version 20.0 was used as a test
for serial correlation of error terms. Shift in slope with p< 0.05 was considered as
statistically significant. Results: There was an increasing trend for all ATC1 groups
prior the implementation of policies. The trends in J0 were negatively impacted from
all policies except for RF. The C0 group was negatively impacted from all policies
except for RF and CMS. The A0 group was positively impacted from all policies. The
N0 was positively impacted from all policies except MRDS and FP. The R0 group was
positively impacted from all policies except GMP and FP. Conclusions: Policy
changes were not sufficient to control unit growth of top selling pharmaceutical
groups. The effect of other policies to control unit sales of these group should also
be evaluated.
PHP38
Applicability of Turkish Pricing Policy on Price Increases
Beykoz V , Saylan M
Novartis Pharma, Istanbul, Turkey
.
increase. We excluded “plasma-derived blood products” that has different pricing
schemes for the cases they get an exchange rate related increase and also excluded
the price corrections. Price increase reasons were grouped as defined in the current
decree. We calculated mean percentage of price increases in overall and in original
vs. generic, import vs. locally manufactured, products below and above 6.79 TL pack
price (local definition of cheap products) and ATC1 level subgroups. Results: 606
products and 274 molecules had price increase in 2013. The most frequent reasons
for price increase were related critical product status (110 increases), increase in
reference price (105 increases) and due to the rule of getting the highest reference
for delisted or non-reimbursed products (89 increases). The average rate of price
increases was 23.1%. 57% of the price increases were applied to imported products
compared with 43% locally manufactured ones. Average rate of price increase in
original and generic products were 24% and 21% respectively. Products with exfactory price above 6.79 TL had more price increase compared with cheap products. The highest rate of price increases were in ATC1 groups A and B (81 increases
each) Conclusions: With the pricing policy change in 2013, price increases were
possible in Turkey for products from different groups.
.
Objectives: Turkey is using international reference pricing for the pharmaceuticals. An update for Turkish pricing decree is published in April 2012 and price
increases became more applicable due to various reasons. We analyzed price lists
to identify pharmaceutical products that had any price increase in 2013 and defined
causes in the decree Methods: We reviewed weekly cumulative price lists published in Turkish Medicines and Medical Device Institution and compared each list
with the list published in the previous week to identify products that had price
PHP40
Transformation of Green Card Program for the Poor: One Step
Further to Universal Health Care Coverage in Turkey
Seyhun O , Erdol S , Can H , Erdogan E
Medtronic, Inc., Istanbul, Turkey
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Since January 2012, Turkish government started to implement a mandatory general health insurance law. The Social Security Institution (SSI) coverage
which has been 86% in 2012 was expected to be 100% after this reform instead has
declined to 82% in 2013. On the other hand, as Turkish Green Card Program - a state
social scheme to ensure the provision of health services for the poor - was abolished
and transferred from Ministry of Health to SSI, approximately 9 million people have
been subject to income audit in order to be classified as eligible to pay premiums
themselves and non-eligible ones for which the state will pay the premiums. In this
regard; this poster presents this transformation and gives its current status in terms
of contribution to Universal Health Coverage in Turkey. Methods: Publications of
SSI, World Bank Reports and online articles are utilized. Results: The recent available data shows that 82% of the population is under the coverage of SSI. %2 of the
population corresponds to the groups which are out of SSI coverage according to
Law 5510, Article 60. Remaining population corresponds to 12 million people subject
to income audit. Approximately 62% of those could not pass income audit and their
premiums are paid by the state. Conclusions: Since 2012 there are increasing
number of people taking income audit and have the capacity to pay premiums. It is
also noteworthy to state that there were 8,865,470 people under Green Card scheme
whereas after the transfer of Green Card to SSI; 11,357,306 people applied for the
income audit in 2012, this reached to 12,266,043 people at the beginning of 2014.
Findings show that as Green Card Scheme brought under SSI, coverage has been
made available to all eligible people in a systematic and just way thus contributed
the extent of coverage in Turkey.
PHP41
Generic Penetration Within Top-10 Genericized Molecules – Greece
Versus Major European Countries
Charitonidis S 1, Kofinas K 1, Katsoulakis M 1, Papadopoulos K 2, Ollandezos M 2,
Kyriopoulos J 3
1IMS Health Hellas, Athens, Greece, 2Pan Hellenic Union of Pharmaceutical Industry, Athens,
Greece, 3National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In early 2010, Greece was placed under International Supervision (EU,
ECB and IMF), as a result of a growing public deficit and its non-sustainable state
expenditure. At the time, the retail pharmaceutical market had a size of c. a. €6.5 bn
in retail prices (public pharmaceutical expenditure €5.2 bn). Within that framework,
A412
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
the reduction of pharmaceutical expenditure was one of the main targets for fiscal
adjustment. The purpose of this study was to assess the usage of generic medicines
in Greece, as a key driver for savings from the pharmaceutical market, and compare
it with that of other major European countries. Methods: IMS data from several
European countries was collected in terms of the overall retail pharmaceutical market and the consumption of generic medicines in each of them. Focus was placed
on the top-10 genericized molecules for Greece including alendronic acid, atorvastatin, carvedilol, clarithromycin, clopidogrel, donepezil, fluconazole, olanzapine,
omeprazole and simvastatin. To ensure an “apples-to-apples” comparison across
countries, the study focused on the retail market only (excluding hospitals) given
that, in Greece, there is no publicly-available data for pharmaceutical consumption within the hospital setting. Results: The analysis indicated that, in Greece,
the penetration of generic medicines within the top-10 genericized molecules was
65% in terms of volume, with off-patent medicines holding the remaining 35%.
According to IMS data, Greece had a lower penetration of 21 percentage points
(-24%) versus the weighted European average and -8.2 percentage points (-11%)
versus the cluster of Southern European countries plus Ireland for calendar year
2013. Conclusions: Generic penetration within the 10 largest genericized molecules, in Greek retail-pharmacy setting, is significantly lower versus the weighted
average of major European countries but also compared to that of countries in
similar economic situation with Greece.
PHP42
Promoting Quality Use of Generic Medicines: Knowledge, Attitudes
And Practices of Community Pharmacists in A Middle Eastern
Country
Awaisu A , Mohamed Ibrahim M I , Kheir N , ElHajj M
Qatar University, Doha, Qatar
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The practice of generic medicines prescribing, dispensing and
substitution in developing countries has been controversial among health care
professionals, particularly due to issues on quality, safety and efficacy. These controversies are as a result of inter-country differences in policies and laws as well
as individualized knowledge and attitudes of pharmacists pertaining to generic
medicines. This study primarily aims to assess the knowledge, attitudes, and practices of community pharmacists in Qatar towards generic medicines. Methods: A
cross-sectional study using a pretested paper-based survey was conducted among
a random sample of community pharmacists in Qatar. The data were analyzed
using IBM–SPSS® version 20. Both descriptive and inferential statistical analyses
were applied. Results: A total of 160 surveys were distributed to community pharmacists of which 118 were returned (response rate, 74%). The mean total score of
generic medicines knowledge among the pharmacists was 6.8 ± 1.6 (maximum
possible score was 10). Years of practice as well as place of obtaining academic
degree did not influence knowledge score. Approximately 72% of the pharmacists
supported generic substitution for brand name drugs in all cases where a generic
medicine is available and the majority (93%) agreed that pharmacists should be
given generic substitution right. Nearly 61% of the pharmacists considered lack
of proven bioequivalence to original brands as an important barrier for selecting
generic medicines and 55% rated “lack of policy for directing the practice of generic
medicine” as an important barrier. Conclusions: In order to enhance the quality
use of and to promote the practice of generic medicines in Qatar, an educational
program should be implemented. A national generic medicine policy and guidelines
are warranted in the State of Qatar.
PHP43
Evaluating Rates of Potential Generic Substitution for
Prescription Drugs: Can We Improve On Existing Incentive Schemes?
Walton S 1, Rash C 1, Lambert B L 2, Galanter W L 3
1University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, IL, USA, 2Northwestern, Chicago, IL, USA, 3University
of Illinois Hospital and Health Sciences System, Chicago, IL, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Encouraging generic drug use has reduced health care costs for payers
and consumers, but the rate of branded medications therapeutically interchangeable to generic is not equal across medications disease states. The extent to which
different systems of care are able to substitute towards generics is not well understood. This study defined and measured the maximum generic rate (MGR) of currently prescribed drugs and illustrated differences across drugs associated with
selected underlying diseases. Methods: Using information in prescription claims
data, drugs were classified into “potentially generic substitutable” or not based on
clinical consensus regarding the following algorithm: 1. They did not having have
a narrow therapeutic index (NTI) as defined by the Food and Drug Administration
(FDA); 2. Did not belong to one of six protected classes of drugs in Medicare D; 3. They
were substitutable with a generic medication of the same chemical entity; 4. They
were therapeutically interchangeable with a generic in the same class which was
thought clinically to have class effect benefits and minimal risk of harm in switching. A maximum generic rate (MGR) was defined as the percent of prescriptions
that could be generic. This rate was examined overall and across drugs known to
be associated with illustrative diseases including hypertension, diabetes mellitus,
and obstructive lung disease. Results: The MGR ranged from 100% for drugs used
in hypertension to 26.7% for drugs used in obstructive lung disease. The overall
maximum possible generic rate (MGR) was 83.6%. Conclusions: Payers wishing
to promote generic substitution should incorporate the potential for substitution
toward clinically appropriate generic medications as part of incentives for generic
utilization to avoid unintended consequences of using a fixed target rate. A practical
methodology for determining a MGR is offered here.
Objectives: Medicine shortages are a global phenomenon. A growing number of
reports indicate the problem is increasingly affecting the European pharmaceutical
market. The present study aims to investigate the characteristics, determinants,
legal aspects and management of medicine shortages in Belgium, France and from
the perspective of the European Union. Methods: A review of scientific and grey
literature was performed. The legal framework on European and national level
was reviewed. Primary qualitative data was collected through 22 semi-structured
interviews with key representatives of health care systems’ stakeholders on the
national and European level. Results: France reported three times more shortages
than Belgium. However, the main therapy area, the major cause and the dynamics
of medicine shortages were analogous between the two countries. Determinants
of medicine shortages were categorised in manufacturing problems, distribution
and supply issues, and economic-related challenges. Manufacturing problems
were most frequently reported as the primary cause of medicine shortages. Laws
and regulations related to medicine shortages are more extensive in France than
Belgium. Several preventive and responsive measures were identified to address
such shortages. Conclusions: Although medicine shortages are country-specific,
the underlying mechanisms of medicine shortages appear to be similar in Belgium
and France. Economic aspects seem to play a central role in the phenomenon of
medicine shortages, as it influences stakeholders’ business decisions. The impact
of the legal framework around medicines on the occurrence of medicine shortages
may be limited. Collaboration, communication and coordination are key to any
effective approach to address medicine shortages.
PHP45
Expedited Regulatory Review and Authorisation of Medicines and
Their Subsequent Appraisal By Hta Agencies in the European Union
McCarron C 1, Griebsch I 2
1Boehringer Ingelheim, Berkshire, UK, 2Boehringer Ingelheim GmbH, Ingelheim am Rhein,
Germany
.
.
Objectives: Firstly, to review whether medicines that have received expedited
regulatory approval in the European Union (EU) subsequently received positive
recommendations from selected Health Technology Assessment (HTA) agencies in the EU. A second objective was to understand the reasons for negative
appraisals of these medicines by EU HTA agencies. Methods: Medicines that
have received Conditional Marketing Authorisation (CMA) by the European
Medicines Agency (EMA) were identified from the EMA website. Websites of HTA
agencies in the United Kingdom (NICE, SMC); Ireland (NCPE), France (HAS) and
Germany (IQWiG) were searched to ascertain whether these medicines had been
appraised. Appraisal reports were reviewed. For medicines with at least one negative appraisal, reason (s) for the negative appraisal were identified. Results:
13 medicines have received CMA in the EU. 10 of these medicines have received
a negative appraisal by at least one HTA agency (either ‘not recommended’ or
deemed to offer ‘no additional benefit’ over existing treatment). Of the 10 medicines with at least one negative appraisal, 8 are oncology medicines. The most
common reason for a negative appraisal (relevant to 9 of the 10 medicines) was
insufficient or uncertain clinical effectiveness. Uncertain cost-effectiveness in
relation to the proposed treatment cost was mentioned as a source of uncertainty
for 5 of the 10 medicines. Conclusions: Despite receiving expedited regulatory
approval, patient access to innovative medicines in the EU may be delayed due
to negative appraisal of these medicines by HTA agencies (most often due to a
relative lack of data on clinical effectiveness). Such delays obviate the intention
of expedited regulatory review of medicines.
PHP47
Challenges: in Implementing HTA In The Reimbursement Decisions In
Algeria / A Compartive Analysis
Aissaoui A 1, Soualmi R 2, Kaddar M 3
1Paris dauphine University, Paris, France, 2Algiers University, Algiers, Algeria, 3Independant
Consultant, Oran, Algeria
.
.
.
Objectives: To provide a comprehensive description of the current Drug
Reimbursement Systems in Algeria and to compare it to two archetypes drug reimbursement systems in France and UK and to a system in a middle income country:
Turkey where the HTA has been recently implemented. Methods: We collected and
reviewed relevant information to describe the health care and drug reimbursement
systems in these countries; we reviewed the legal framework and procedure documents. For Algeria, in addition to the data and information collected, we conducted
informal interviews supplemented by a survey among key stakeholders. Results:
Compared to the UK, no similarities were found. This is probably due to the cultural
differences and the lack of expertise in the use of cost-effectiveness approaches.
Compared to the France, we didn’t find similarities, except the final decision which
is taken at the Ministry level. This is due to the administrative nature and the lack
of transparency of the assessment in Algeria especially where the methods as well
as the results of the assessment are not explicitly expressed. Compared to Turkey,
we found some similarities in terms of process, but not in terms of methods as this
country is now more familiar with the HTA approach. Conclusions: Our study
shows that the implementation of HTA differs according to cultural and financial
factors and to expertise capacity in data collection, analysis and use in the decision
making process. The use of HTA in the drug evaluation and reimbursement system
in Algeria is underestimated and underdeveloped. That’s why before adopting HTA
approaches in the pharmaceutical sector, the Algerian authorities should consider
these factors and improve the data quality and decision process transparency. This
is becoming vital as cost of drugs is increasing and the fiscal space will be more
constrained in the near future.
PHP44
Prevention and Management of Medicine Shortages in Belgium,
France and from The Perspective of the European Union
PHP49
An Analysis of the 2014 Moroccan Drug Price Cuts
Bogaert P , Prokop A , Bochenek T
Jagiellonian University Medical College, Krakow, Poland
Hollis M , Ando G , Izmirlieva M
IHS, London, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
A413
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: The Moroccan government announced new public and hospital
prices for 5308 drugs in April 2014. These price cuts came into force in June 2014.
The study examines the price changes and analyzed the potential impact of the
price cuts on pharmaceutical companies operating in the market. Methods:
Standard statistical methods were used to analyze government provided data in
order to identify general trends within the pricing notification. Secondary sources
were then examined to determine the general pricing rationale. Results: The
price notification included 5308 drugs (note duplication occurs where a brand
name has multiple formulations). Examining public prices: 390 of the drugs were
newly listed on the list for public purchase, a further 2968 saw no price increase
and two drugs saw modest price increases. Public price declines were seen for
1948 drugs with the level of decline covering a range of 1635 percentages between
0.006% and 78.6%. Average public price, excluding drugs with no decline, saw an
average decline of 13.6% and median decline of 6.5%. All the 5308 drugs already
had an existing hospital price, however 114 of these drugs saw no pricing change.
Of the 5194 drugs which did see a price decline this varied across a range of
2559 different percentages between 0.001% and 79.8%. The average hospital price
decline, excluding drugs which saw no decline, was 9.3% and the median was
5.8%. Conclusions: The large range of pricing declines suggests that the prices
were not indicative of a formulaic event such as currency fluctuation changes.
This also means that there is a differential impact on pharma companies, with
certain parts of their portfolio being more protected than others.
PHP51
Trends in Time To Market Access In Europe - Is It Getting Better?
Flostrand S J A 1, Lor S 1, Anon Y 2
1IMS Consulting Group, La Défense Cedex, France, 2IMS Health, La Défense Cedex, France
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Unequal access due to delays or non-availability of medicines denies
patients treatments they need and contributes to inequality across Europe. The
EFPIA previously monitored access delays via the “Patients Waiting to Access
Innovative Therapies (WAIT)” indicator, however; this has not been updated
since 2011. Following the 2012 EC Transparency Directive 89/105/EEC mandating
no more than 120 days of delay for national pricing and reimbursement decisions, an updated evaluation is needed. Methods: IMS MIDAS data was used to
identify the first sale for all EMA-approved non-generic, non-biosimilar products
since 2008 in 15 EU markets. The delay (from approval to first sale) was noted for
each product and market and compared to the EFPIA Patients WAIT indicator for
2008-2010. Annual average delays were calculated over the 2008-2013 period and
for available products, an analysis of minimum and maximum delay performed
for each market. Additional analyses were performed for trends within and across
markets, and to identify progress and variations. Results: Improvements across
the 2008-2012 period give cause for optimism in most European markets, as delays
have fallen sharply in almost all markets, from an average of 524 days in 2008 to
281 days in 2012, with only Greece showing no real improvement. However; absolute availability of new medicines has varied greatly by market, with same-year
availability of EMA-approved medicines declining to just 41% on average in 2013.
Notable declines were seen in Greece, Spain, Romania and Portugal, suggesting
that economic difficulties may lead some governments to refuse reimbursement,
rather than simply delay decisions. Conclusions: This updated access analysis
shows that while delays are shortening, absolute access for patients is not always
improving. Some new access rules such as “class C” drugs in Italy (access without
funding), may send misleading signals, and underscore the need for monitoring
of true access across Europe.
PHP54
Market Access for Medical Devices: Adapting to Change
Charter R 1, Bottegoni G 2, Stengel C 1, Pistacchio L 1, Lombardi L 3, Jommi C 4, Tarricone R 5
1SDA Bocconi (MIHMEP), Milano, Italy, 2D3-Computation, Italian Institute of Technology, Genova,
Italy, 3Bocconi University, Milano, Italy, 4Cergas, Bocconi University, Milano, Italy, 5Bocconi
University, Milan, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Market Access (MA) is key for medical devices given recent changes in
regulation from one side, and pressures on costs from the other side. Nevertheless,
there is scant evidence on how MA works in the medical device industry and
whether it works effectively. The aims of the present study are to illustrate current
gaps in MA for medical devices and to recommend future actions to make this
function more effective. Methods: We conducted a literature review aimed at
gathering a clear picture of current state of the art on MA for medical devices and
at highlighting major gaps vis-à-vis other industries (e.g. pharmaceuticals). Based
upon the review’s findings, we carried out an e-survey to small, medium, and large
device companies operating in the EU in order to understand: i) how MA is perceived
and actually organised, ii) which are the main perceived obstacles to MA, iii) how
companies invest in market access and at which stage of medical device development, and iv) what the main challenges are to a more efficient market access process. Results: The findings of the literature review and preliminary results of the
e-survey are presented. Conclusions: MA is an under-developed function in the
medical device industry and in certain cases its role is not fully exploited. Although
the pharmaceutical industry doesn’t represent a fully appropriate benchmark, MA
for medical devices is even less developed when compared to its full potential. A
different approach is needed to deal with new changes in the regulation and policy
arenas aimed at synergistically encompassing knowledge, expertise and operating
tools from public affairs, medical departments, pricing & reimbursement, health
economics and marketing.
PHP55
Qualitative Research on the Impact Of European Hospital
Procurement Practices on Market Access For Disposable
Medical Devices
Hertz D , DiPaolo A , Armstrong S
GfK Market Access, Wayland, MA, USA
.
.
.
Objectives: In European hospitals, budgetary pressure is driving centralized
purchasing and increasing the importance of procurement in market access.
Centralized purchasing is thought to lead to cost savings through stronger negotiating power, economies of scale and reduced inventory. The objective of this
study was to understand the procurement methods for disposable medical devices
employed by European hospitals and their impact on market access. Methods:
A review of hospital purchasing practices was conducted in France, Germany and
England, including published articles and government websites. Twelve 45-60 minute telephone interviews were conducted with hospital decision makers (purchasers, pharmacists and clinicians) in 2013. Results: Most disposable medical
devices are evaluated at the facility level by committees made up of clinicians,
procurement specialists, pharmacists and management. France and Germany
require listing on the facility formulary and typically procure via tendering and
group purchasing. England has a national procurement body but hospitals regularly purchase products directly from the manufacturer. All three countries report
that austerity measures are causing many facilities to limit the number of products
per category. Product trials and clinician preference are seen as the main drivers
of adoption however clinicians are under increasing pressure to justify costs.
Hospital purchase decisions are increasingly likely to be based on non-product
specific attributes such as total cost of purchasing including volume discounts,
broad portfolio of products, and administrative costs. Conclusions: In the current environment, market access for disposable medical devices will require a
strong economic argument in addition to evidence of superior quality. Although
clinicians still drive the adoption of consumable medical devices, in the absence
of a strong clinician preference, non-product specific attributes may determine
market access. Manufacturers can support their economic messaging along categories of inventory reduction and a broad portfolio of products that allows for
administrative efficiencies and reduced shipping costs.
PHP56
The Impact of the Information System of Medical Devices in
Portugal
Silva E , Inacio P , Figueira J
INFARMED_ National Authority for Medicines and health Products, Lisboa, Portugal
.
.
.
Objectives: The Portuguese National Health System (NHS) identified the
need to easily access information that allowed identification of all medical
devices (MDs) with their respective manufacturers, distributors, characteristics,
and purposes. The objective of the creation of an information system is to collect, store and analyze data of each MD and to provide NHS resources management, health technology assessment (HTA), as well as data about the Portuguese
market. Methods: A system consisting of a database that is a repository, and
an application system that stores the information was built. For the registry of
information all MDs should disclose their respective instructions of use, labels
and price. The concept of unique medical device and a process to assign a code to
each device was designed, and tested by collecting data from NHS acquisitions.
The prescription of medical devices is made by code, with all information online.
A model for communication between the health regulatory agency and market
operators was also devised, as well as rules and codes of procedure. Results: The
creation of this system in 2011 allowed for the coding of 20% of all registered MDs
(n= 838000) up to June 2014. This has allowed for the elimination or withdrawal of
16% (n= 136000) of references, thus keeping the registries up to date. The coding
permitted the comparison of devices and the management of total expenditure in
MDs by hospitals of the NHS. Conclusions: The system provides solid information about available MDs in the market, their respective manufacturer, distributor
and pricing to which they are sold to the NHS. The system is a support for decision
makers, payers, and HTA processes. It facilitates the management and traceability
of medical devices in hospitals and has impact on reimbursement, access and
pricing varies by market.
PHP57
Pricing of Medicines In Poland – Two-Year Overview Of How The New
Law Affected Costs Of Reimbursement
Szmurlo D , Wladysiuk M , Plisko R
HTA Consulting, Krakow, Poland
.
.
.
Objectives: Rapid increase of costs of reimbursement in Poland led to redesign of
the drug pricing mechanisms. As a result a new law which brought revolutionary
changes to the health care system was introduced in 2012. The aim of this work is
to summarize the two years of new drug policy in Poland and to present mechanisms that resulted in substantial savings in reimbursement costs. Methods:
Few savings-generating mechanisms were implemented in the new reimbursement law: negotiations of prices, new method of calculation of reimbursement
limit (resulting in higher co-payment) and also formal obstacles in obtaining prescriptions for reimbursed products (some reimbursed drugs, i. e. antibiotics, due
to formal issues are prescribed with 100% co-payment). The first and the third
reason result in lower overall costs of reimbursed medicines, while the second
reason influences the proportion of costs borne by the National Health Fund. We
have analyzed data on prices of reimbursed drugs before 2012 and after implementation of the new law (currently the prices may change every two months).
We have then compared the amount of sales of those drugs, costs of reimbursement and patients’ co-payment. For some reference groups (i. e. oral aromatase
inhibitors) we made in-depth analysis of pricing mechanisms. Results: In 2012
total public expenditures amounted to 2.3 billion EUR, 83% of the planned budget,
which gave 460 million EUR savings as compared to 2011. In 2013 the drug budget
was executed in 87%, resulting in 430 million EUR savings. Saving were driven by
price negotiations, but also by mechanisms of lowering the reimbursement limit,
i. e. in case of oral aromatase inhibitors the reimbursement limit was lowered by
half during 2012-2013. Conclusions: The new reimbursement law resulted in
substantial savings in costs of drugs. The success is however relative, as costs of
drugs were partially shifted towards patients.
A414
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PHP58
Therapeutic Positioning Report: New Collaborative Network of
Drug Assessment in Spain - The Start Of P&R Based On Relative
Effectiveness?
Paladio N , Cortés I , Gil A , Crespo C
Boehringer Ingelheim, Sant Cugat del Vallès (Barcelona), Spain
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Therapeutic Positioning Reports (TPRs) were introduced to the
Spanish P&R process in May 2013. TPRs evaluate comparative efficacy and safety
and introduce usage and monitoring criteria for new drugs and existing drugs seeking reimbursement. The procedure was set-up by the Spanish Medicines Agency
(AEMPS) and the Ministry of Health with the aim to accelerate the P&R process
and to generate a single, national relative effectiveness report avoiding additional
regional evaluations, contributing to reducing the long-delays in market access
timelines experienced in the last few years. The objective of this ongoing work
is to describe and analyze both the metrics of the process and the contents and
results of TPRs. Methods: Descriptive study based on public information available
from the European and Spanish Medicines Agencies (May 2013-ongoing). Results:
From June 2013 to May 2014 the Therapeutic Positioning Coordinating Group
(TPCG) has officially launched 60 TPR plus 7 use protocols (UP) at the request of
the Interministerial Price Council (IMPC). 75% of TPR involve new chemical entities (82% of those with a positive opinion from the CHMP between May 2013-April
2014) and assess a single entity (48% specialty care) indicated, mainly, for patients
with neoplastic (28%) and endocrine (18%) diseases. All UP affect targeted therapies
with approval between Jan2010-Dec2012. Since its establishment in May 2013, the
TPCG has released 26 TPR (57% of those expected according to the pre-established
procedure -3 months working time) with a median release time of 7,1 months. Only
1 has been published. The rest await for P&R decisions. Other 5 pilots have been
published in parallel. In total 5 TPR recommend to further restrict the European
label. Conclusions: TPR are not being released at the expected rate. Follow up is
necessary to predict its impact in P&R and market access in regions across Spain.
PHP59
Are There Any Commonalities In Payer Requirements and
Reimbursement Pathways for Medical Devices in the Dach (Germany,
Austria, Switzerland) Region?
Walzer S 1, Droeschel D 1, Hentschel D 2, Waaga F 3, Portegies W 3, Schwander B 4
Market Access & Pricing Strategy GmbH, Weil am Rhein, Germany, 2Johnson & Johnson,
Vienna, Austria, 3MedicalWriters. com GmbH, Zurich, Switzerland, 4AHEAD GmbH, Loerrach,
Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
1MArS
Objectives: Medical devices constitute a set of important health technologies for
the care of patients. While there are similarities between some reimbursement
systems, each market has its own unique characteristics. This article focuses on
the reimbursement procedures for medical devices in the DACH countries (Austria,
Germany, Switzerland), and aims at finding commonalities in payer requirements
and reimbursement pathways. Methods: Reimbursement application pathways
for inpatient and outpatient medical devices were evaluated for Austria, Germany
and Switzerland. The key items being analysed for similarities and differences in
each setting were transparency, clinical and health economic evidence requirements, submission timelines and the length of the whole reimbursement application process. Results: In the inpatient setting, the evidence requirements for
clinical data are different between the analysed countries: The lowest clinical evidence requirements are seen in Germany, while the highest are given in Switzerland
(in some scenarios). In terms of health economics the requirements are medium
to low. A medium rating was given for Austria and Switzerland (in some scenarios)
as a health economic analysis is required (e.g. cost comparison), and a low rating was applied to Germany as limited economic information (cost assessment/
comparison) needs to be submitted. The length of the application process is well
defined in Austria and Germany and vague in Switzerland. In the outpatient setting
the requirements for clinical and health economic data are significantly increasing. Clinical requirements are getting close to pharmaceutical methods whereas
health economic evidence is requested in all DACH countries. The length of the
reimbursement process is not clearly defined in all three countries. Conclusions:
Despite varying reimbursement processes within the DACH region, there are some
important similarities between the evidence requirements which may help manufacturers to guide market access and reimbursement strategy decisions in order
to drive successful submissions and applications of innovative medical devices.
PHP60
The Relevance of Health Services Research for the Pharmaceutical
Industry in Germany –Results of A Representative Online Survey
Anton V 1, Gehrke K 1, Hessel F P 2
1German Pharmaceutical Industry Association, Berlin, Germany, 2SRH University Berlin, Berlin,
Germany
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The necessity for manufacturer of pharmaceuticals and medical
devices seem to deal with health services research (HSR). Health care reform acts
and revisions of HTA method guidance documents in many European countries
continue to point out the importance of real-life consequences. The objective of the
study was to evaluate the self-reported importance and the own activities of pharmaceutical companies in Germany concerning health services research. Methods:
Between December 2013 and February 2014 an online survey among members of
the German Pharmaceutical Industry Association (BPI) was accomplished. Similar
surveys were conducted in 2009 and 2011. Results: 59% of 109 addressed companies took part in the survey. The participants were representative for Germany
concerning research-orientation, size and type of products. For 88% of the participating companies HSR is of importance. This high rate remained constant compared
to the last surveys. For most of the companies HRS yields valuable contributions
for the negotiations with payers (96%), in the AMNOG evaluation process (89%) and
for optimization of placement of marketed products (94%). 50% of the companies
conducted HSR studies over the last years, respectively are currently conducting HSR
studies or participate in joint projects, whereas 69% plan to conduct HSR studies in
the near future. All these numbers increased since the last surveys. Conclusions:
The results of the survey clearly pointed out the high and still increasing importance
of HSR and real-life studies also in the health care industry. Although a considerable
amount of uncertainty concerning the specific methodological requirements remain
it is widely accepted that the quality of data and analyses is crucial for acceptance
by payers. As HSR projects require considerable human and financial resources alliances and joint projects between industry, academia and payer are aspired.
PHP61
Integration of Cost–Effectiveness Assessment in the Market Access
Scheme of Drugs and Medical Devices In France
Rumeau-Pichon C , Harousseau J L
Health Economics and Public Health Department S, Health Economics and Public Health
Committee C
Haute Autorité de santé, Saint-Denis La Plaine, France
.
.
.
Objectives: In France, drugs and medical devices costs concern an important part
of health care expenditure. Several reforms have been put in place over the past
years in order to limit these expenditures, in particular price cutting policy. Costeffectiveness assessment was integrated in France in the market access scheme
of health products by the Social Security Financing Act for 2012 and is required
since October 3rd 2013. This new mission was assigned to the Health Economics
and Public Health Committee (CEESP) of the French National Authority for Health
(HAS) and is become compulsory for innovative health products and are likely to
have a significant impact on the health insurance expenditures. The objectives of
this work were to see how the cost-effectiveness assessment has been integrated in
France and to discuss the impact of this assessment on the health products market
access. Methods: The work consists in analyzing the process of the economic
evaluation achieved by the HAS since October 3rd 2013. Results: Economic evaluation is a new step in the market access scheme. In order to respect the legislated
timeframe of 90 days, it is simultaneously conducted with the medical assessment
by the Transparency Commission of the HAS. For each health products, an efficiency
opinion is delivered by the CEESP. It presents the methodological conformity according to HAS guidelines and a conclusion about the efficiency, on the basis of the
Incremental Cost-Effectiveness Ratio (ICER). Currently, 15 dossiers were eligible for
cost-effectiveness assessment. First assessments permit to confirm that the procedure is operational. The average processing time was 94,8 days. Conclusions:
In France without efficiency threshold value, the CEESP can’t conclude absolutely
on the efficiency of health product. We don’t know how the ICER will be considered
by the French Healthcare Products pricing Committee (CEPS) at the time of pricing
negotiation with the pharmaceutical industry.
PHP62
Analysis of Cost-Effectiveness Assessments In France By The French
National Authority For Health (Has)
Rumeau-Pichon C , Harousseau J L
Health Economics and Public Health Department S, Health Economics and Public Health
Committee C.
Haute Autorité de santé, Saint-Denis La Plaine, France
.
.
.
Objectives: In France, cost-effectiveness assessment is required since October 3rd
2013 for innovative health products and are likely to have a significant impact on
the health insurance expenditures. The objective of this work is to report first costeffectiveness assessments, achieved by the Health Economics and Public Health
Committee (CEESP) of the French National Authority for Health (HAS). Methods:
The investigation consists in analyzing medico-economic dossiers submitted at
the CEESP between October 2013 and October 2014. This analysis is based on the
opinion delivered by the CEESP, the methodology used in the model and the process of the assessment achieved by the HAS. Results: At the time of writing the
abstract, 15 dossiers were eligible for cost-effectiveness assessment. All dossiers
were based on cost-utility models. Two dossiers presented a negative opinion due
to the methodological conformity according to HAS guidelines. For dossiers with
a positive opinion, the Incremental Cost-Effectiveness Ratio (ICER) were between
5 866€ /QALY (for a subgroup analysis) and 194 531 € /QALY. Main methodological
reserves made by the CEESP concerned comparators, time horizon, robustness of
clinical data, utility measures. The average processing time was 94,8 days. For the
moment, no price has been published in the Official Journal. Conclusions: The
first assessments permit to confirm that the procedure is operational. In light of
these first assessments, an update of the HAS methodological guidelines should
be done. In France, without efficiency threshold value, the CEESP can’t conclude
absolutely on the efficiency of health products. Thus, we don’t know what will be
the place of the ICER in the pricing negotiation between the pharmaceutical industry
and the French Healthcare Products pricing Committee (CEPS).
PHP63
Accessing the Medical Device Market in the People’s Republic of
China--Policy Changes Since the Restructuring of the China Fda
Zhang S X , Kriza C , Kolominsky-Rabas P L
Centre for Health Technology Assessment (HTA) and Public Health (IZPH), Friedrich-AlexanderUniversity Erlangen-Nürnberg, Erlangen, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The objective of this research is to provide an overview of the regulatory process of medical devices in China. Potential challenges related to medical
device registration and major policy changes are highlighted especially since the
restructuring of the China FDA in March 2013. The results of this research are aimed
at informing regulatory bodies, health policy decision makers, national and international Health Technology Assessment networks, as well as medical devices manufacturers. Methods: A systematic review was conducted from 2009-2013 to identify
the challenges and opportunities in the Chinese medical device regulatory process
searching the PubMed, Science Direct, Scopus databases and Zhongguozhiwang.
The PRISMA guidelines were applied for the search. In addition, an analysis of
A415
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
previous and current policies and regulations in the grey literature was conducted
for this research. Results: 17 articles were included in the systematic review. The
three most crucial issues in the regulatory process have been analyzed in detail
and relate to products technical requirements, the type test report and the clinical
trials evaluation. Concerning the ‘products technical requirements’ and the ‘type
test report’, the main challenges are related to the lack of sufficient legal status
and openness for interpretation. A new Regulation governing the Supervision and
Administration of medical devices introduced in June 2014 now includes improvements regarding specification of requirements. In addition, if a medical device fulfills certain requirements, it should be exempted from clinical trials, which signifies
a major simplification for manufacturers. Conclusions: Getting a medical device
registration certificate in China is a complicated, time-consuming process. The new
regulatory policies in place focus more strongly on the clinical effectiveness and
safety of medical devices. However, some major structural problems remain, i. e.
the lack of technical standards for manufacturers, with major policy planning and
changes currently underway in order to address these problems.
PHP64
The Benefits and Challenges of Submitting to the Nice Medical
Technologies Evaluation Programme-Manufacturer Perceptions
And Experiences
Satherley A W 1, Entwistle J 1, Panciera D 2
Market Access, Melton Mowbray, UK, 2University of Nottingham, Nottingham, UK
.
.
.
.
1GfK
Objectives: The Medical Technologies Evaluation Programme (MTEP) was set up
by NICE in 2009 to identify new medical devices and diagnostics that could improve
patient experience and outcomes whilst driving health care efficiencies. Innovative
products are submitted by manufacturers for evaluation, requiring confidence in
the programme and its methods. The purpose of the study was to examine the
experiences of manufacturers whose products have been assessed by MTEP, to
review the challenges of the submission process, the resources required for the
submission, NICE support for further evidence generation, and the impact of NICE
recommendations on product uptake in the UK and elsewhere. Methods: A systematic review of published literature on MTEP and products/companies that have
been through this process was completed. Qualitative interviews were then undertaken with a representative sample of senior team members from manufacturers
whose products have undergone MTEP review to elicit insight on their perceptions
and experiences of the programme. Findings were collated and analysed thematically. Results: Manufacturers have identified the benefits of submitting to MTEP
in terms of value communication in the NHS, however key issues are: the significant time and resource burden of completing the submission, the lack of funding
for additional data generation where this is required, the challenges of adhering
to the stringent timescale, and the questionable benefits of submitting for larger
companies with extensive sales teams. There is also a recognised need for greater
efforts to influence practice and prescribing decisions in the NHS based on the MTEP
guidance. Conclusions: Manufacturer experience of the MTEP process is largely
positive, however as MTEP is dependent on manufacturers to initiate submissions,
key actions can be taken to incentivise future submissions. Priorities will be ensuring that MTEP recommendations have a tangible and proven impact on prescribing
decisions and that support is available for the submission development.
PHP65
Availability of Risk Sharing Agreements in the Turkish
Pharmaceutical Sector
E 1, Tatar
M 2, Ergin
G 1, Senturk A 1, Atikeler
.
.
.
PHP67
Economic Impact of Drugs De-Funding and Pharmaceutical
Co-Payment
Buigues-Pastor L 1, Sánchez-Chorro J L 2, Saurí-Ferrer M I 1, Muñoz-Fernández J I 2,
Uso-Talamantes R 1, Ortiz-Rodríguez O 2
1Conselleria de Sanidad. Generalitat de Valencia, Valencia, Spain, 2Servicio Extremeño de Salud,
Mérida (Badajoz), Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: to assess the consequences in terms of outpatient pharmaceutical
expenditure, that accounted for changes in state law on de-funding of medicines
and the introduction of pharmaceutical co-payment in 2012 in Spain. Methods:
Cross-sectional study during 2012. Two health regions of Spain (Comunitat Valenciana
with 5,129,266 inhabitants and Extremadura with 1,108,130. Total population:
6,237,396) where analysed to determine the evolution of outpatient pharmaceutical expenditure after a change in state law (July 1,2012). We compared the first over
the second half of 2012 by age and gender distinction. Results: The total spending
was reduced by 16.80% after the new law. By gender, the reduction was greater in
women (17.47% versus 15.25%). By age, the decrease was seen most sharply in the
stretch of paediatrics (0 to 14 years). In older people, the stretch mostly affected
was the one from 66 to 70 years old. The stretches with fewer changes in terms of
outpatient pharmaceutical expenditure were 21-25 years (reduced by 5.42%) and
46-50 years (reduced by 6.07%). Conclusions: After the de-funding of 400 drugs
and the increase of pharmaceutical co-payment (40% previously and now variable,
40%, 50% and 60% depending on income levels), a drastic drop in the amount of
pharmaceutical outpatient expenditure is observed. Further analysis is required
in order to assess whether that decline is sustained over time or, on the contrary, a
new phase of positive growth begins.
PHP68
When Gender Matters: Impact of Fda Safety Warning on Dispensed
Zolpidem Dose
Irwin D E 1, Palmer L A 2
1Truven Health Analytics, Durham, NC, USA, 2Truven Health Analytics, Bethesda, MD, USA
.
K2
Tuna
1Polar Polar Health Economics & Policy, Ankara, Turkey, 2Hacettepe University, Ankara, Turkey
.
Region to legislate on the matter, supporting the prescription of the biosimilar to the
naive patient. The aim of this study was to evaluate the impact of cost-containment
policies about biosimilars in Campania between 2009 and 2013. Methods: IMS
Health regional database was used to carry out this descriptive retrospective drugutilization for the years 2009 through 2013. Information was retrieved about different distribution channels (retail, direct distribution, hospital). Consumptions are
expressed in Counting Units (CU) and trends have been calculated using Compound
Average Grow Rate (CAGR). Results: In 2013, a total consumption of 930.859 CU of
biosimilar drugs was registered in Italy (CAGR 13/09 68,8%). The penetration rate of
biosimilar was 23,9% with regard to expenditure and 25,3% with regard to consumption. Analyzing the consumption of biosimilars by therapeutic category in Italy,
the consumption of erythropoietin and filgrastim has an index of annual growth
respectively equal to 153.4% and 174.7%. In Campania, the penetration rate of all
biosimilars was 31.4% of total expenditure and 35.9% of consumption. Analyzing
the trend in consumption for single therapeutic category, it can be seen that penetration is due to erythropoietin (297.5% CAGR); with regard to filgrastim, however,
the average annual growth rate is around 54%. Conclusions: The results suggest
that Campania Region records an index of market penetration of biosimilars higher
than the national. This trend could be attributable to the cost-containment policies
implemented in the region.
.
Objectives: Risk sharing agreements are among the new trends in pharmaceutical
sector as a tool for reducing the drug expenditures and increasing patient access
to innovative drugs. The objective of this study is to elaborate the availability of
risk sharing agreements in the Turkish pharmaceutical sector. Methods: A literature review was undertaken to identify the existing risk sharing schemes in the
European countries using “risk sharing agreements”, and risk sharing schemes” as
key words. Results: Risk sharing agreements are mainly classified as financial
based and performance based schemes. The vast majority of those agreements are
implemented in oncology area, others are mostly implemented in ophthalmology,
blood diseases and multiple sclerosis areas. Countries mostly prefer financial based
schemes as they are easier to implement and track. Performance based agreements
are relatively rare as they are more complicated due to the long length of follow up,
lack of reliability of data generation/registration, administrative burden for all stakeholders. Conclusions: Taking into account that original drugs to be reimbursed
in Turkey need to grant a compulsory statutory discount which is generally 41%,
it can be stated that Turkey is already implementing a financial based scheme. On
the other hand, when availability of performance based risk sharing agreements is
assessed, there is a lack of infrastructure to track drugs or non-responders and also
it seems to be difficult to make this kind of agreements in Turkey without making
any amendments in current regulations. In addition to these regulation issues,
transaction and administrative costs should also be taken into account. On the
other hand despite these difficulties, these schemes could provide budget control
and patient access to highly innovative and expensive treatments.
.
.
.
Objectives: The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) issued a safety announcement on January 10,2013 requiring manufacturers to lower the recommended dose
of zolpidem for women. Lower dose recommendations for elderly patients were
already labeled. This analysis describes the impact of the FDA safety announcement
on the initial dose dispensed to new zolpidem users. Methods: Patients > = 18
years old with an immediate- (IR) or extended-release (ER) zolpidem prescription
between July 2012 and July 2013 were evaluated using MarketScan Commercial
and Medicare Supplemental Databases. The first zolpidem prescription during the
pre-warning (July 1, 2012 – Jan. 9, 2013) and post-warning (Jan. 10, 2012 – July 31, 2013)
time periods was evaluated. Chi square tests were used to examine differences in
the proportion of new users dispensed low dose zolpidem during each of the time
periods. Results: Overall a significantly higher proportion of patients in all age
gender groups received low dose IR zolpidem during the post-warning compared
to the pre-warning period. Similar results were found for the ER formulation except
among males 65 years or older. Before and after the FDA safety warning, the highest proportion of patients receiving low dose zolpidem (any formulation) for their
first prescription was among elderly women (46% pre-warning; 53% post-warning).
Even after the FDA warning, a large proportion of women 18 to 64 years old (63% IR;
65% ER) and women 65 years or older (46% IR, 55% ER) received high dose zolpidem
for their first prescription. Conclusions: For all age and gender categories, the
proportion of patients receiving low dose zolpidem increased after the FDA safety
warning issued in 2013. The highest proportion of low dose zolpidem use was seen
in elderly females. However, the proportion of women and elderly who received low
dose zolpidem even after the FDA safety warning was still relatively low.
PHP69
Non-Steroidal Anti-Inflammatory Drugs in Household Drug
Supplies in Serbia
PHP66
Impact of Cost- Containment Policies on Biosimilars Market
1Federico
Putignano D 1, Fiorentino D 1, Guerriero F 1, Monetti V M 1, Orlando V 2, Menditto E 2
II University of Naples, Naples, Italy, 2CIRFF- Center of Pharmacoeconomics, Naples,
Italy
1Faculty
Objectives: The expiration of biotech drugs patents has led to the creation of
drugs copies of originator products, defined biosimilars. The automatic substitutability between the originator and the biosimilar is not allowed in Europe with the
exception of France. In Italy, in the absence of a national legislation, some Regions
have issued directives to the spread of the biosimilar use. Campania was the first
Objectives: Medications in households offer a variety of opportunities for irrational consumption and development of adverse drug reactions (ADR). One of the
medicines most commonly associated with ADR are non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), one of the most frequently used medications in Serbia.
Therefore, the aim of this study was to analyze the amount and structure of
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Kusturica M P 1, Tomas A 1, Horvat O 1, Bukumiric Z 2, Tomic Z 1, Sabo A 1
of Medicine, University of Novi Sad, Novi Sad, Serbia and Montenegro, 2Faculty of
Medicine, University of Belgrade, Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A416
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
NSAIDs present in household drug supplies, and address the issue of possible inadequate use. Methods: This was an observational, cross-sectional study of drug
storage and self-medication practice in households in the city of Novi Sad, Serbia
over the 8 months period. Study consisted of personal insight into the drug inventory, and drugs were classified according the Anatomical Therapeutic Chemical
(ATC) classification system. Results: Out of 383 surveyed households, 280/383
(73%) households held at least one box of NSAID in their home-pharmacy and a
total of 473 packages of NSAID have been inventored. Most commonly encountered NSAIDs were ibuprofen (52.64%), diclofenac (31.92%), nimesulide (8.03%) and
meloxicam (3.38%). Other NSAIDs accounted for less than 4% altogether. Over 70%
of all NSAIDs present have been bought without prescription. Majority of ibuprfoen
(91.3%) and diclofenac (65.74%) were obtained without a prescription even though
in Serbia all NSAIDs (except ibuprofen 200mg) are prescription only medication
(POM). According to European Medicine Agency, ibuprofen is classified as OTC,
but diclofenac is strictly POM. Large amount of diclofenac used without consulting a physician presents a serious issue. Nimesulide and meloxicam were almost
exclusively bought with prescription (> 80%). Conclusions: NSAIDs were present in most of Serbian home-pharmacies and were usually bought without prescription. This present a serious problem, especially for unsupervized diclofenac
use. Financial Sources: This work was supported by the Ministry of Science and
Technological Development, Republic of Serbia, project No. 41012.
PHP70
Pharmacoeconomic Analysis of Antifungal Drug Use in the
Intensive Care Unit
Selimzyanova L , Namazova-Baranova L , Vishneva E , Lazareva A , Katosova L ,
Kryzanovskaya O , Tepaev R
Federal State Budgetary Institution “Scientific Centre of Children Health” under the Russian
Academy of Medical Sciences, Moscov, Russia
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: to investigate changing of Candida species (C. spp) distribution and
expenditure for antimicrobial drugs in the intensive care unit (ICU). Methods:
from 1.01.11 to 30.07.13 there were 200 patients with Candida spp positive samples
in the ICU. We followed up antifungal drugs susceptibility of different C. spp. and
evaluated expenditure for antifungal drugs. Results: C spp was detected in 200
patients (12,2% of ICU microbiota). In 2011: 47 (19,3%); in 2012: 50 (9,3%); in 2013:
103 (12,1%) patients. The predominant species, detected during period of investigation was Candida albicans (C.a.), which was isolated in 21 (44,7%), 21 (42%)
and 52 (50,5%) patients in 2011,2012 and 2013 accordingly. Candida parapsilosis
(C.p.) was on second place and frequency of this fungus detecting increased: 1
(2,1%); 12 (24%); 31 (30,1%) patients. Candida tropicalis (C.t.) was detected: in 5
(10,6%); 6 (12%); 10 (9,7%) patients. Candida glabrata (C.g.): in 9 (19,1%); 3 (6%); 2
(1,9%). Candida krusei (C.k.): in 6 (12,8%); 1 (2%); 1 (1%). Candida lusitaniae (C.l.):
in 2 (4,3%); 2 (4%); 3 (2,9%). Fluconazole susceptibility was: for C.a.: 100%; 89%;
97%; C.t. 82%; 94%, 92%, C.g 18%; 46%; 0% in 2011, 2012 and 2013 accordingly;
for C.p.: in 2012; 29%: in 2013: 23%. Changing of C. spp species distribution led
to increasing of expenditure for antifungal drugs in ICU: 52% of expenditure for
antimicrobial drugs in 2011; 72% in 2012; 78% in 2013. Echinocandines determined
44%; 65% and 70% of ICU expenditure for antimicrobial drugs in 2011; 2012; 2013
accordingly. Conclusions: Our data coordinate with modern tendency in C. spp
changing in ICUs. Increasing of C. spp proportion, resistant to fluconazole requires
more frequent echinocandines use, that leads to rise of hospital expenditure.
PHP71
Impact of the Early Benefit Assessment on A Pharmaceutical’s Real
Consumption in Germany
Kotowa W 1, Häussler B 2, Reindl S 1, Höer A 2
1IGES Institut GmbH, Nuremberg, Germany, 2IGES Institut GmbH, Berlin, Germany
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The Act on the Reform of the Market for Medicinal Products (“AMNOG”)
introduced an early benefit assessment (EBA) of pharmaceuticals in Germany in
2011. Since the impact of the results of the EBA on a pharmaceutical’s consumption
is unclear, those effects were quantitatively analyzed. Methods: All pharmaceuticals which were assessed by an EBA in 2011 or 2012 and were still available in 2012
and 2013, and gliptins launched before 2011 with an EBA in 2013 were considered. A
pharmaceutical’s real consumption (measured by defined daily doses) in 2012 and
2013 was compared to the expected consumption (EC) based on the highest possible
number of patients defined by the Federal Joint Committee according to a pharmaceutical’s label. For the EC only subpopulations with an acknowledged additional
benefit (AB) were taken into account. Results are presented in terms of „shares“ (=
real consumption / EC). Results: Pharmaceuticals with a low share (< 10%) were
cabazitaxel (0.22% in 2012), saxagliptin, protease inhibitors against chronic hepatitis
C, eribulin, vandetanib and rilpivirin. Sitagliptin, ticagrelor, antineoplastic agents
and tafamidis achieved a midsize share (10-50%). Ivacaftor, abiraterone, emtricitabin/rilpivirin/tenofovir, apixaban, fingolimod and axitinib reached shares of > 50%
and up to 398%, respectively (fingolimod in 2013). There was no correlation between
the extent of AB and a pharmaceutical‘s share. For most pharmaceuticals consumption was higher in 2013 than 2012. Conclusions: The shares of pharmaceuticals
considered in this analysis vary between 0.22% and 398%. No correlation between
share and extent of AB could be identified. It is assumed that label restrictions
regarding the use of a pharmaceutical, competing alternatives in the same therapeutic indication, a pharmaceutical’s life-cycle or overestimation of the EC influence
a pharmaceutical’s share. Shares > 100% indicate that also subpopulations without
an acknowledged AB receive treatment with the respective pharmaceutical. Further
research is needed to confirm these assumptions.
PHP72
Using Data Envelopment Analysis (Dea) To Rank Gp’s According To
Their P4p Quality and Efficiency Scores
Perronnin M , Pichetti S , Sermet C
IRDES, Paris, France
.
.
.
Objectives: Payments for Performance (P4P) schemes are commonly used in
many OECD countries in order to incite physicians to improve both quality and
efficiency of prescribing. In France, a set of 29 indicators has been selected as the
P4P perimeter by National Public Health Insurance. Each indicator provides useful
information of GPs’ performance, but it is not that easy to combine them all at
the same time in order to provide a synthetic view of GPs’ performance. Instead,
some of these indicators can be grouped together according to a therapeutic rationale (diabetes indicators, high blood pressure indicators) or an efficiency rationale
(multiple-sourced drug prescribing). Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) can be used
to calculate an aggregated score for each GP and for each dimension (therapeutic or
efficiency). Methods: Database used in this study were taken from the IMS-Health
Disease Analyzer (DA) database. It contains information on pharmaceutical prescriptions administered by 693 French General Practitioners and related diagnoses.
Quality and efficiency indicators are calculated both inside and outside P4P perimeter. Indicators reflecting efficiency are considered separately from those reflecting
quality and the latter are grouped according to therapeutic rationale (diabetes, high
blood pressure). Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) is used to produce performance
scores while aggregating several efficiency or quality scores and neutralizing at the
same time each GP’s characteristics. Results: DEA scores are calculated on each
dimension (quality or efficiency) and for each GP. Comparing the scores on each
dimension enables to better understand if GPs’ are faced with a trade-off between
these two Objectives. Conclusions: Results from this analysis may have implications for public policy design. A better understanding of GPs’ strategies relatively
to P4P schemes could enable to adapt incentives in order to improve the system.
PHP73
Prescribing Pattern of Antibiotics In Neonates in a Tertiary Care
Hospital
Thakur S 1, Acharya L D 1, Lewis L E S 2, Kumar R 1, Kumar S 1
1Manipal College of Pharmaceutical Sciences Manipal University, Manipal, Karnataka,, India,
2Kasturba Medical College Manipal Univeristy, Manipal, Karnataka, India
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Neonates are among special population group who are more
susceptible to nosocomial infections due to underdeveloped immunity level at
their age (0-28 days of life) and it is a common practice of administering antibiotics, pending bacterial culture results, to sick neonates and to neonates who
are more prone to develop infectious diseases; which in turn is gradually progressing towards a global problem of multidrug antibiotic resistance in Neonatal
Intensive Care Units. Objective of the present study was to study prescribing patterns of antibiotics in hospitalized neonates, and to assess duration of therapy,
antibiotic regimen and outcome of therapy. Methods: All neonates prescribed
with antibiotics during 6 months period from November 2014 to April 2014 were
selected. A prospective observational study was carried on selected cases by
using sources of data such as patient treatment charts, progress sheet, laboratory investigation reports, and patient discharge summary; collected datas were
reported in case record forms. Data analysis was done with SPSS (18.0), Microsoft
Excel (2010). Results: Of the total of 404 admitted neonates, 30% (n = 122) were
prescribed with antibiotics; among which 76 (62.3%) males and 46 (37.7%) were
females. Among n= 122 cases, 71 (58.2%) empirically and 51 (41.8%) were prescribed in indication of infections. Most commonly prescribed antibiotic class were
Aminoglycoside (97.54%), broad spectrum penicillin (66.39%), extended spectrum
penicillin (28.68%), 2ndgeneration cephalosporin (17.21%). Empirical use of ampicillin and amikacin were most frequently encountered. Our study showed that
Dual antibiotic regimen produced a better outcome (50%) than single/triple/more
antibiotic regimen. Conclusions: The broader outcome of this study would be
the potential utility of this data in designing strategies both at level of physicians
and administrators for rational prescribing and policy decisions respectively; so
that a continuous surveillance for rational use of antibiotics and strategy of antibiotic cycling can provide some better answers for difficulties coming across in
management of neonatal infections.
PHP74
Do Quality or Efficiency Indicators Inside French P4p Perimeter
Influence Quality Or Efficiency Indicators Outside P4p?
Pichetti S, Perronnin M, Sermet C
IRDES, Paris, France
Objectives: Payments for Performance (P4P) schemes are commonly used
in many OECD countries in order to incite physicians to improve both quality
and efficiency of prescribing. In France, a set of 29 indicators has been selected
as the P4P perimeter by National Public Health Insurance. P4P schemes may
induce undesirable behaviors from GPs leading to a decrease both in quality and
efficiency outside the P4P perimeter (De Pouvourville, 2013). On the contrary,
other studies (Campbell et al., 2009) tend to show that respecting P4P targets
may imply a virtuous effect outside P4P. Methods: Database used in this study
were taken from the IMS-Health Disease Analyzer (DA) database. It contains
information on pharmaceutical prescriptions administered by 693 French General
Practitioners and related diagnoses. Quality and efficiency indicators are calculated both inside and outside P4P perimeter. In a first step, each category –quality
or efficiency- is considered separately. We calculate an aggregated score for each
category, by averaging indicators pertaining to it. In a second step, each indicator
outside the P4P perimeter is regressed on quality or efficiency aggregated scores,
controlling for other characteristics of the physician. Results: At first sight,
there is no obvious link between quality and efficiency scores inside and outside
P4P perimeter. As a matter of fact, descriptive statistics, correlation analysis and
Principal Component Analysis do not show any straightforward relation. All these
first results call for further analyses. Conclusions: Results from this analysis
may have implications for public policy design. If respecting P4P targets imply a
virtuous effect outside P4P, there is no need to extend the P4P perimeter. If not,
regulatory agency has to increase the number of indicators in order to improve
quality and efficiency.
A417
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Equity and Access
PHP75
Trend Comparison of the Colombian Multidimensional Poverty
Index, Inequities in Maternal Mortality, Neonatal Mortality and
Gini Coefficient, 1997-2011
Romero Moreno LF, Eslava Schmalbach JH, Sandoval Vargas G, Saboya Romero DM
Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Bogotá, Colombia
Objectives: To describe and to compare the Colombian multidimensional poverty
index (MPI) ’s trends against Gini coefficient (GC) and inequities in maternal mortality and neonatal mortality since 1997 to 2011. Methods: An ecological study
was performed. MPI and Gini coefficient were obtained from National Statistics
Department´s (DANE) databases. The Maternal Mortality Rate and Neonatal
Mortality Rate were estimated and standardized by age and sex respectively. The
Attributable Fraction (AF) was estimated as the inequity indicator for these two variables estimating the excess of risk by geographical exposure. We estimate the trend
and behavior among MPI’s Colombian version and health inequities and disparities
indicators over time from 1997 until 2011. Results: A substantial change was evident in the MPI 51% decrease (1997-2011) and 40%, (2003-2011) decreasing from 0.6
to 0.3 (2003-2011), whilst Maternal Mortality attributable Fraction (MMAF) showed
a 3% increase, rising from 83.4% to 86.2% (2000-2008), and a slight reduction for
Neonatal Mortality attributable fraction (NMAF) 1.6%, (2000-2008) decreasing from
88.9% to 88.4%. At the same time. GC evidenced a 1% decrease between 2000-2011
decreasing from 0.57 to 0.54. Conclusions: The established MPI for Colombia in
the last decade had a descending trend and did not resemble the stationary behavior
of the major inequity indicators calculated for the country in the same time span.
Consequently, there was an undervalued perception over the issues where affected
population were not target of requested interventions. It is therefore important to
question the validity of measures used to quantify the poverty (MPI’s Colombian
version) in order to reconsider the strategies of interventions where health inequity
is an important referent to create control and intervention measures.
PHP76
Nurses VERSUS Other Health Professionals Perceptions on Quality
and Safety Culture Elements in Greek Hospitals
Dreliozi A 1, Siskou O 2, Bouchoris P 3, Galanis P 4, Kaitelidou D 4, Prezerakos P 5
Regional Health Authority of Piraeus and Aegean islands, ATHENS, Greece, 2Center for
Health Services Management and Evaluation, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens,
Athens, Greece, 3IASO GROUP, ATHENS, Greece, 4National and Kapodistrian University of Athens,
Athens, Greece, 5University of Peloponnese, Sparta, Greece
.
.
.
.
.
.
12nd
Quality and risk management together, are prerequisites of patient safety which
forms the basis of health care quality management activity. Objectives: To explore
the prevailing organizational climate-in terms of clinical governance’ factors
“Climate of blame and Punishment” and “A planned and integrated QI program and
proactive risk management”, in Greek hospitals and to compare nurses’ perceptions
with those of the rest health professionals on the particular factors. Methods: It
is a cross-sectional study, including a representative sample of all specialties of
employees working in a public and a private Greek hospital. The validated Clinical
Governance Climate Questionnaire (CGCQ) was filled by Nn= 261 nurses and Noth
prof= 198 other professionals (response rate: 79%). A lower score signifies greater
satisfaction in a particular concept. Data mining took place from May to August
2012. Data analysis was performed with the SPSS 19.0 and included factor analysis,
t-test, X2test and regression analysis The two-tailed significance level was set ≤
0.05. Results: The results for the factors “Climate of blame and Punishment” and “A
planned and integrated QI program and proactive risk management”, demonstrated
a slightly positive trend (Means: 2.73 and 2.28 respectively) in the total population.
Nurses, appear to perceive more negatively the climate related to: i) protected time
for Quality Improvement initiatives (p< 0.05), ii) systematic assessment of clinical
risks (p< 0.001), iii) sharing of a common vision (p< 0.05), iv) dissemination of Risk
prevention policies (p< 0.001), v) proactive risk management (p<0.05), vi) systematic
evaluation of Human Resources development needs (p< 0.001), vii) equal employee’s
valuation regardless of professional background (p< 0.05). Conclusions: The views
of nurses are essential, as they are important and direct factors of care provision.
The assessment of climate produces conclusions which if exploited properly, can
mark the beginning and support the effort of continuous improvement of patient
safety.
PHP77
Pharmaceutical Market Access in Emerging Markets Through
Innovative Patient Access Schemes
Leibfried M J , Arsiwalla M Y , Richardson S K
GfK Market Access, New York, NY, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Emerging markets are a major priority for pharmaceutical manufacturers, and continue to grow as areas of interest for many firms. However, coverage
from 3rd party payers, whether public or private, is often limited, and as a result
the patient is the primary payer. Pharmaceutical companies must devise innovative
strategies in order to provide access to patients while driving sales. In this study, we
aimed to assess pharmaceutical company strategies to address patient affordability
in emerging markets. Methods: We undertook a secondary research horizon scan
utilizing public resources to examine a variety of strategies, including innovative
patient access schemes across emerging markets. We then filtered a total of n= 14
schemes in emerging markets into several categories in order to create archetypes
and to identify common themes and trends. Examples from a number of countries
and regions were considered, including Brazil, China, India, sub-Saharan Africa,
and others. Results: We categorized n= 14 patient access schemes into three main
categories/archetypes: Licensing and Technology Transfer, Differential Pricing and
Cost Offset Programs, and Value Added Services based on the primary objectives and
characteristics of each scheme. A majority of programs fell under the Differential
Pricing and Cost Offset programs (n= 8), with the other two categories splitting
up evenly at n= 3 each. Conclusions: Pharmaceutical manufacturers are using
innovative patient access schemes to gain access in emerging markets and are
doing so by finding ways to drive down overall patient spend. While we were able to
archetype innovative patient access schemes into three categories, it is important
to note that many schemes incorporate elements from across the categories identified. Finally, when designing a scheme, pharmaceutical companies must take into
account a host of factors including country level dynamics, company assets and
strategy, and particulars of scheme design.
PHP78
Patient Envolvement in Reimbursment of Drugs in Slovakia
Tomek D 1, Tomekova K 2
1Slovak Medical University, Bratislava, Slovak Republic, 2Slovak Society for Pharmacoeconomics,
Bratislava, Slovak Republic
.
.
Objectives: To define the possible ways of participation of patients in the decision-making processes in Slovakia. To analyze the current status of patients in
the reimbursement process in Slovakia and to define barriers to the participation. Methods: To identify the relevant literature, a survey was carried out using
a search engine to the literature in PubMed 2000-2013. The survey was carried out
using the following key words: “Patient participation”, “Patient choice”, in combination with the terms “Priority Setting”, “Innovation” or “Pharmaceutical Innovation”.
Materials with those keywords were found, as well as through a Web browser. We
performed analysis of the Slovak legislation, which regulates the status of patients
in the reimbursement process and the comparison of this with other legislative
standards, governing the status of citizens in public processes. There has also been
evaluated legislative consultation process, which took place during the years 2010
and 2011. Results: Actually the patients can (as the whole public) only view all
documents relevant to reimbursement, since they are not a “registered” participant of the process. They are 3 possibilities to comment the process according to
relevant legislation: send a writing comment to the MoH, draw up a petition, file a
complaint. In the period 2010 – 2011, before the legislation change, the MoH received
318 comments, from that 140 were from public. Conclusions: The whole process
is totally transparent and visible via internet site of MoH. The status of patients (e.g.
patient representatives) in the process declined since the last change of legislation
from 1.12.2011. Due to the introduction of WTP threshold for ICER/QALY is also the
introduction of innovative drugs more restrictive as before, what makes the possibilities of patient participation in reimbursement process even more important.
PHP79
Advantages of Extemporaneous Dosage Forms in Ukraine
Zalis’ka O , Maksymovych N , Kacheray J , Sichkoriz O
Danylo Halytsky Lviv National Medical University, Lviv, Ukraine
.
.
.
.
Objectives: We evaluated the data of license registry of Ukraine on 01.01.2014.
Extemporaneous medicines are presented in 426 pharmacies, about 3% of the total
number in Ukraine. The range of extemporaneous formulations in Ukraine is significant, it is complemented by modern specifications physicians. Methods: We
analyzed the 1570 prescriptions on extemporaneous dosage forms of various doctors in few Lviv pharmacies during 2013-2014. Results: We found that 53 names
of substances used active substances and excipients. That should be noted that
different formulations are made: medicine, tinctures, solutions, suspensions, drops,
ointments, pastes, suppositories, powders. Among the most commonly prescribed
by doctors’ prescriptions are liquid dosage forms, topical solution (solution furacillin
0.02% - 500.0; rivanol 0.05%, 0.1% - 500.0; hydrogen peroxide 3% - 500 0, a solution
of methylene blue 1% - 10.0), solutions for electrophoresis, nasal drops (solution
collargolum 3% - 10.0 and protargolum 2% - 10.0), thymi water, soothing medicine
quater, Pavlova, Ravkin. These pharmacies offer 26 solutions to supply hospitals.
Also popular are antiflu powder (antigrypin) and vitamins, care products for face
and body. Among soft medicines dominate ointment for wound healing (Lesyuk
ointment, kalanhoie ointment) and for the treatment of sinusitis, Unna paste (for
healing venous wounds), suppositories for hemorrhoid treatment (by prof. Maslyak)
and antifungals (solution Kastelyani and various ointment). Currently, there are
difficulties in ensuring substances, including missing: dibazol, diphenhydramine,
collodion 4% lithium chloride, paracetamol, pepsin, yellow mercury, sulfur purified,
diluted hydrochloric acid 8.4%, zinc sulfate, extract althey root, aminophylline, 1%
citral alcohol solution. Conclusions: Extemporaneous medicines are economically available, the average costs of solutions are 4-12 UAH (1 Euro= 16.0UAH), eye
drops- 6-18 UAH, ointments - 5 - 15 UAH, which is 40-85% less than the manufactory
drugs. That’s cost-effective therapy and provide individualized drug treatment for
children, elderly, and chronically patients in Ukraine.
PHP80
Towards Universal Health Care- A Review of the Basic Basket of
Care Associated With Universal Health Care Delivery Models
Burns R M 1, Dooley B 2, Armstrong J 3
1University of Oxford, Oxford, UK, 2AXIS Healthcare Consulting Ltd., Galway, Ireland, 3Erasmus
University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In 2014, the Irish Department of Health and Children (DoHC) published
a policy document outlining the introduction of Universal healthcare by 2019. The
impetus for adopting Universal healthcare is multi-faceted; the main driver being
the current two-tier, private/public delivery system limits access to care for subgroups of the population. Inequality in access to care and clinical outcomes has been
extensively published in Ireland; the implementation of Universal health care will
aid in reducing this inequality as well as stabilise variation in resource use across
socio-economic groups providing more efficient and equitable delivery of health
care. The aim of this review was to catalogue what basic care is offered at the population level across Universal delivery models in Europe and document disease-specific
resource use and health outcomes as well as organisation around reimbursement
structures for purposes of informing policy in Ireland. Methods: EU-27 countries
were classified by health care delivery systems according to data available from
A418
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
each country’s department of health. Countries were reviewed under a range of
headings including: current delivery models in place, institutions responsible for
delivery and organisation of reimbursement system, incentive structures in place,
basic bundle of health care covered, additional options for coverage, disease-specific
resource use and health outcomes, government contribution to cost of health care
and overall health care expenditure. Results: Generally, the basic bundle of health
care across countries with Universal entitlement ensures comprehensive medical care for everyone including GP services, access to tertiary care, post-natal care
and medications. Co-payments, excess payments and retention fees apply in some
countries dependent upon the Universal delivery model in place. Conclusions:
This review presents characteristics of Universal health care delivery systems across
Europe. Basic bundles of health care provision and organisation of reimbursement
across delivery models have been outlined, thus providing further clarity on the
characteristics of and variation across Universal health care models.
PHP81
National Rare Disease Strategies: The Current State for Orphan
Drug Market Access in European Union (Eu) Member States
Scholten J , Lie X, Kalbasko A , Maervoet J
Quintiles Consulting, Hoofddorp, The Netherlands
.
.
.
Objectives: By 2013 all European Union (EU) member states were recommended
to elaborate and adopt a national strategy for rare diseases. This study provides
insights into the national rare disease strategies, in particular about the status of the
programmes, recent developments, and the congruencies and differences between
the programmes regarding market access. Methods: A literature and Internet
search was performed to identify national strategies for rare diseases published by
EU member states. Both policies and recent orphan drug introductions have been
analysed to compare the rare disease strategies. Results: All member states had a
variety of approaches already in place before developing a national strategy. France
is the frontrunner in implementing rare disease policies as well as the member
state with the highest number of marketed orphan drugs. Over the past five years,
most member states finalised their national plans with a peak in publications late
2013. Plans include similar methods on increasing patient access such as off-label
use, compassionate drug use and utilising cross-border health care. Member states
with a decentralised market access model (e.g., Spain and Italy) commonly use
national funds and decision-making to provide equity in treatment levels across
the nation for rare diseases. There are few orphan drug specific pricing policies;
however special reimbursement criteria are common especially in countries with
cost-effectiveness criteria. Conclusions: Increasing patient access to orphan
drugs has been a focus point in the national plans for rare diseases. Congruencies
in methods will aid the EU’s ambition to align policies at European level. However
the implementation phase has only recently been initiated for most plans and actual
policies are yet to be developed. As member states such as France are introducing
cost-effectiveness criteria in their health technology assessments, one can expect
that tailored criteria need to be developed for orphan drug assessments.
PHP82
Measuring the Efficiency of Hungarian Hospitals by Data
Envelopment Analysis
Csákvári T 1, Turcsanyi K 1, Vajda R 2, Danku N 2, Ágoston I 2, Boncz I 3
of Pécs, Zalaegerszeg, Hungary, 2University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary, 3Faculty of Health
Sciences, University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary
.
.
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: Hospitals are important cost elements of the Hungarian health care
system. During the past decade, several health care reform affected the number
of hospital beds in Hungary. The aim of our research is to analyse the efficiency
of the Hungarian acute inpatient-care system. Methods: Data derived from
the Hungarian nationwide health insurance database. We analyzed the technical- (TE) and scale efficiency (SE) of the Hungarian acute inpatient-care system
(2003, 2006, 2010). The number of hospitals included into the study was 133 in
2003,125 in 2006 and 93 in 2010. We chose four inputs and two outputs: the number
of active hospital beds, the number of discharged patients, the number of oneday cases, completed days of nursing (inputs), average length of stay, DRG cost
weights (outputs). The method we used for our calculations was Data Envelopment
Analysis. Results: In 2003 both the technical and scale efficiency were high
(TE: 96.9%; SE: 92.9%). To 2006 the situation deteriorated by some degree (TE: 96.6%;
SE: 80.3%). By 2010 technical efficiency still did not show improvement (TE: 94.0%),
but scale efficiency increased (SE: 88.2%). Usually the hospitals with higher number
of beds are more efficient than the smaller units. Conclusions: The effects of the
performance volume limit did not improve the two values; however, the capacity
decrease of 2007 did improve the scale efficiency to some extent. The Hungarian
health care system needs to reduce the numbers of hospitals and rethink their
functions, but needs to improve the size of them.
PHP83
Experiences With Price Competition of Biosimilar Drugs in Hungary
Z 2, Tálos
Z 1, Ágoston I 2, Endrei
D 2, Csákvári T 3, Boncz I 4
Hornyák
1Csolnoky Ferenc Hospital, Veszprém, Hungary, 2University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary, 3University of
Pécs, Zalaegerszeg, Hungary, 4Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary
.
.
.
.
.
.
PHP84
Impact of Prior Authorization Restrictions on Resource Utilization
and Costs In US Health Plans: A Review Of Literature
Shah D , Tongbram V , Paly V
ICON Plc, Morristown, NJ, USA
.
.
.
Objectives: Prior authorization (PA) restrictions have been implemented by US
health plans in an effort to ensure safety, manage appropriate utilization and control
costs. A review of published peer-reviewed literature was conducted to evaluate
the impact of such PA restrictions on resource utilization and costs. Methods: A
targeted review of literature was conducted in Medline from 2009 onwards using
search terms including “prior authorization”, “resource”, “use”, “utilization”, “cost”,
“impact”, “economic”. Review articles, non-English language studies, non-US studies, kins, and studies evaluating the effectiveness of formulary policies of which PA
may be a component were excluded. Impact of PA policies on health care utilization
and costs was qualitatively assessed. Results: Fourteen studies were identified
which met our inclusion criteria. Majority (57%) of the studies were conducted on
Medicaid plans (Medicaid: 8, commercial: 4, Medicare: 1, not clear: 1). Majority (57%)
of studies evaluated the impact of mental health medications (anti-convulsants,
anti-depressants bipolar medications, antipsychotics), two studies were conducted
on anti-diabetics, one on a multiple sclerosis drug, one for a lipid-lowering drug,
one on an anti-hypertensive and one on a vaccine. Four studies were industrysponsored. 12 studies were retrospective data analyses and only 2 studies were
decision-analytic models. Overall, the trend showed that PA restrictions were effective in reducing pharmacy utilization and health care costs, but few studies also
raised concerns on patient safety and quality of care outcomes due to PA policies. Conclusions: Although PA restrictions may result in cost-savings, patient
safety and quality of life concerns must also be evaluated while imposing these
restrictions. Rigorously designed studies including assesment of PA administration
costs as well as indirect costs due to lost productivity should be conducted to better
assess the overall economic impact of such restrictions.
PHP86
Do Nice Decisions Affect Decisions in Other Countries?
Hernández-Villafuerte K , Garau M , Devlin N
Office of Health Economics, London, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: The objective is to test the hypothesis whether NICE recommendations
on the use of a new drug affect recommendations from other bodies in countries
outside England and Wales. To our knowledge, this is the first attempt to approach
this topic quantitatively. Therefore, a sub-objective is to determine the feasibility
of gathering a high quality database with sufficient number of observations to
test our hypothesis. Methods: A basket of 29 drug/indication pairs and a group
of 15 countries were included (Australia, Canada, Denmark, France, Italy, Korea,
The Netherlands, New Zealand, Poland, Portugal, Spain, Bosnia, Ecuador, Egypt and
Ghana). Information regarding NICE HTA recommendations was extracted from
NICE’s website and HTAinSite. com. Moreover, an online-survey of key opinion leaders was carried out to collect information regarding the HTA decision in 10 countries. For the remaining five countries, we used the information from their official
webpages. A descriptive analysis was conducted, including an examination of the
position of each decision of NICE in comparison with that of other HTA agencies in
the timeline of decision making about the 29 medicines. Results: There is a lack
of comparability between the publically available information. The findings suggest
that after the publication of a NICE appraisal there is a higher probability that an
HTA is undertaken for the same drug in other countries. Furthermore, when NICE
has published a negative decision, the tendency of not recommending the drug by
another HTA body is much larger after than before NICE’s decision. Conclusions:
Issues encountered in the collection of information made it difficult to quantify the
effect of NICE recommendations on HTA decisions in other countries. The results
suggest that the selected agencies are considering NICE decisions as a factor for
rejecting or restricting the use of drugs which in other case would be recommended
or reimbursed.
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Health Care Costs & Management
PHP87
Complications, costs And Resource Utilization in Real-World
Complex Abdominal Wall Reconstruction Patients
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Formulary Development
L 1, Nagy
erythropoietin treatment, while in the first 12 months after the bid 3647 patients,
resulting in a 12.5% decline. In the 12 months before biosimilar bid 13974 patients
received colony-stimulating factor treatment, while in the first 12 months after the
bid 13352 patients, resulting in a 4.5% decline. Conclusions: The analyses of the
Hungarian price competition bid of biosimilar products showed a minimal decline
in the number of patients under treatment by both colony-stimulating factor and
erythropoietin products while the health insurance reimbursement of these drugs
significantly decreased.
.
Objectives: The aim of our study is to analyse the biosimilar bids of the Hungarian
National Health Insurance Fund Administration in case of colony-stimulating factor
and erythropoietin products. Methods: Data derived from the nationwide pharmaceutical database of Hungarian National Health Insurance Fund Administration.
We analysed how the number of patients treated by colony-stimulating factor and erythropoietin products changed before (01.07.2011.-30.06.2012.) and
after (01.07.2012.-30.06.2013.) the first biosimilar bid performed in March 2012 in
Hungary. Results: In the 12 months before biosimilar bid 4167 patients received
Mencer M 1, Reaven N 2, Funk S 2, Franz M G 1, Macarios D 1, DeNoto I I I G 3
1LifeCell Corporation, Bridgewater, NJ, USA, 2Strategic Health Resources, La Canada, CA, USA,
3Hofstra North Shore-LIJ School of Medicine, Manhasset, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Little information is available on complication-related resource utilization and costs over time in patients with complex abdominal wall reconstruction.
Under pay-for-performance requirements financial decision-makers need better
information to allocate health care resources and budget dollars. This analysis
reports complication-related resource utilization and costs over time in a real-world
patient population undergoing complex abdominal wall reconstruction. Methods:
A cohort of patients with complex abdominal wall reconstructions during inpatient stays between1/1/08 and 6/30/11 (Index event) were followed for 12 months.
Related complications, returns for facility-based care and related costs were evaluated for 30-60-90-365 days after discharge. Insurance claims from the Truven Health
A419
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Analytics MarketScan® database, inpatient costs from the Healthcare Cost and
Utilization Project (HCUP) and costs reported for Ambulatory Patient Classifications
(APC) were used to estimate costs from the hospital perspective. Results: 13,463
patients were evaluated. Rates of patients experiencing any complication were
17.3% within 30 days, 11.0% within 31-60 days, 8.1% within 61-90 days, and 21.4%
within 91 days – 12 months. In total, 37.8% of patients experienced a complication
over 12 months. The most frequent complications over 12 months were infection
(16.6%), bowel obstruction/ other GI complication (12.6%), skin/connective tissuerelated complications (10.7%), and wound complications (8.1%). Complicationrelated cost over time followed a similar trend; average 12 month cost for patients
experiencing an infection was $20,679, $21,558 for bowel-related complications,
$14,950 for skin/ connective tissue related complications and $19,230 for wound
complications. The index event average length of stay for patients with no complications and patients with complications was 3.9 (sd 4.4) and 17.0 (sd 19.6), respectively;
p< 0.0001. Conclusions: Health care resource utilization, costs and complications
for complex abdominal wall reconstruction patients increase over time. Resource
utilization is exacerbated when complications occur. Further study may be required
to validate these findings.
PHP88
The Growing Financial and Quality-of-Life Burden Associated With
Atrial Fibrillation (Af), Diabetes, Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary
Disease (Copd) And Asthma in Ireland
Daacke I M
Boehringer Ingelheim UK, Bracknell, UK
.
.
Many people in Ireland suffer from chronic diseases including AF, diabetes, COPD
and asthma. With the prevalence of these conditions expected to rise, general
wellbeing and quality-of-life will be increasingly affected. Chronic conditions also
account for most of the health care resources used, and represent a significant
economic burden for Ireland in the future. Objectives: Estimate the number of
preventable disease associated events and costs associated with poor management
of patients with AF, diabetes, COPD and asthma. Methods: For each province,
calculate the number of patients diagnosed with AF, diabetes, COPD or asthma,
based on disease prevalence and 2011 Census data. Estimate the number of patients
not achieving target management of their condition and the associated number of
preventable events and total costs, using publically available information. Results:
Of the approximately 59,647 patients diagnosed with AF in Ireland, 23,561 patients
are not receiving appropriate anticoagulation treatment. This results in 531 patients
experiencing an avoidable stroke each year, costing the health care system around
€ 9.3m. Amongst the 238,589 patients diagnosed with type 2 diabetes, 77% will not
achieve a target HbA1c of 6.5% or less, resulting in an expense of € 886m and 12,493
avoidable deaths each year. In addition, 30% of diagnosed COPD patients, and as
many as 60% of asthma patients, are not managing their condition effectively,
costing the Irish health care system € 899m per year in hospital admission costs
alone. Conclusions: Much of the chronic disease burden is caused by preventable
risk factors. This is intended as a key policy lever, to elevate chronic diseases on the
health agenda of key policymakers, providing them with better evidence about risk
factor control, and persuading them of the need for health systems change. Unless
steps are taken now to effectively deal with chronic diseases, Ireland is headed for
serious financial and quality-of-life crises.
PHP89
What Is Working Well In Louisiana For Us Employers:
A Descriptive Analysis of Employers Actively Engaged
In Promoting Employee Health
Copher R 1, Tolbert C 2, Li X 1, Wang Z 3
Lake, NJ, USA, 2Louisiana Business Group on Health, Baton Rouge, LA, USA,
3Eisai Inc., Woodcliff Lake, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
1Eisai, Inc., Woodcliff
Objectives: As health care costs continue to rise, employers seek options to improve
the health and wellness of their employees. This study examined the practices of
employers that are actively engaged in promoting employee health. Methods:
A study of 18 employers who applied for the Working Well award provided by the
Louisiana Business Group on Health in 2013, recognizing employers who are exemplar in their employee health and wellness activities. Applicants completed a survey
detailing business policies and programs intended to promote wellness. De-identified
data derive from 2013 applications. Results: Over half of the companies had fewer
than 500 employees (55.6%), 4 had more than 2000. Health plan coverage was fully (8;
44.4%) or self (7; 38.9%) funded. Almost half implemented wellness programs within
the last 3 years (44.4%), whereas 4 (22.2%) had programs more than 10 years; all were
company funded. Annual spend on wellness was split across participating employers with 55.6% spending < $50,000 and the rest > $50,000 (8; 44.4%). Rationale most
cited for programs: improve employee wellbeing (18; 100%), contain health care costs
(17; 94.4%), increase productivity (13; 72.2%), and reduce absenteeism (12; 66.7%).
Most employers incentivized program participation (16; 88.9%) through premium
reductions (8; 44.4%), cash (8; 44.4%), or PTO (3; 16.7%). Information most reported
to help with wellness planning were health risk assessments (HRAs) (15; 83.3%),
health care claims and utilization (14; 77.8%), and worker’s compensation claims
(8; 44.4%). Conclusions: In the US, employers are responsible for a significant portion of health care spend. Though a small self-selected sample, this analysis reveals
that employers actively engaging their employees, using prevention and incentives
to promote wellness are a more recent occurrence. The trend suggests increasing
awareness that efforts to improve employee health and wellness can help attract
and retain staff, as well as potentially reducing health care costs.
PHP90
A Quantification of Expenditure on Hospital Stays In 5 European
Countries
Waterman J , Gavaghan M
GfK Market Access, Wayland, MA, USA
.
.
Objectives: Throughout Europe, economic conditions are forcing health care systems to reduce costs. One primary driver of health care costs is hospital length of
stay (LOS). This study sought to determine which European countries have been
most successful at reducing their average LOS for five inpatient admissions. This
research also sought to quantify the potential savings for countries that have
not been as successful in reducing their average LOS if they can align with their
peers. Methods: A review of hospital LOS and cost per day of hospital stay data
was conducted in five European countries (France, Germany, Italy, Spain and the
United Kingdom), utilizing data published by the World Health Organization (WHO).
Additionally, hospital payment systems were assessed in each country through
published research to understand systemic motivations of health care providers
with regards to LOS. Results: Substantial variability exists in average LOS for the
studied admissions. The greatest variability was in breast cancer, with average stays
ranging from 4.36 days in the UK to 11.01 days in Germany. The average LOS for three
admissions (single spontaneous delivery, cataracts, and pneumonia) are relatively
similar across countries. However, the average LOS in Germany for malignant neoplasm of the breast and acute myocardial infarction are significantly higher than
the other four countries. There is little variability, however, in average costs per
bed-day in the target countries. A review of payment mechanisms for inpatient
stays revealed that hospitals are financially incentivized to minimize LOS in all five
countries. Conclusions: Additional research is needed to understand the reason
for the discrepancy between German stays and the other four countries. While there
are many potential reasons for the differences, should Germany align their average
LOS for malignant neoplasm of the breast and acute myocardial infarction with the
other four countries, they could save € 744 million per year.
PHP91
R&D Investments, Intangible Capital and Profitability in the
Pharmaceutical Industry
Goncharov I 1, Mahlich J C 2, Yurtoglu B 1
Beisheim School of Management, Vallendar, Germany, 2Janssen-Pharmaceutical
companies of Johnson & Johnson, Neuss, Germany
.
.
.
.
1WHU-Otto
Objectives: The pharmaceutical industry is in the center of political debate due
to their high profitability. In this study, we argue that abnormal profitability in the
pharmaceutical industry is a kind of optical illusion created by accounting standards and their influence on reported accounting profit and book equity – the two
components of ROE. The internationally accepted accounting frameworks either
do not permit capitalizing R&D investments as U. S. GAAP or limit capitalizing R&D
investments as International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) applicable in
the E. U. and most countries. This treatment understates assets and equity, and
can overstate reported profit because relevant cost components (amortization of
R&D) are not deducted from revenues they generate. We empirically aim to estimate the magnitude of this accounting bias. Methods: Based on international
financial data of 413 pharmaceutical firms between 1972 and 2012, we assessed
the “true” profitability of pharmaceutical firms by capitalizing R&D and amortizing
it over the shelf-life of developed products. We use three amortization approaches
(linear amortization, declining-balance amortization and amortization based
on the empirical amortization rates). Results: Corrected profit and equity
figures lead to substantially lower long-term profitability of pharmaceutical
firms. Over the three proposed amortization approaches, the corrected ROE of
14.1% is comparable to profitability reported by U. S. firms from other industries (ROE = 11.1%). Non-U. S. pharmaceutical firms also have an adjusted ROE
that is comparable to firms from other industries (7.6% pharma vs. 9.6% nonpharma). Conclusions: The policy implication of our study is that price regulation or rate of return regulation in the pharmaceutical market should be reviewed
and applied with caution when it is solely motivated by the allegedly high profitability of the industry. This is especially true since such a policy also impedes
R&D investments and innovation in the long run because profits serve as a major
source of R&D investments.
PHP92
Do Specialty Drugs Offer Greater Value for Money Than Traditional
Drugs?
Chambers J D , Thorat T , Chenoweth M , Pyo J , Neumann P J
Tufts Medical Center, Boston, MA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Specialty drugs are often many times more expensive than traditional
drugs, raising questions of affordability, and whether their clinical benefits are
worth their added costs. The objective of this study was to consider new molecular
entities (NME) (i. e., drugs that had not previously been approved by the FDA or
marketed in the US) approved by the FDA from 1999 through 2011 to compare the
value of specialty and traditional drugs. Methods: We searched the FDA website
to identify all NMEs approved from 1999 through 2011. We identified published estimates of additional health gains (measured in quality adjusted life years (QALYs))
and costs (drug costs, hospitalization costs, etc) associated with specialty drugs
compared to existing standard of care at their time of approval, and compared
findings with traditional drugs. We compared incremental QALY gains, incremental costs, and the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio, for specialty vs. traditional
drugs using a Mann Whitney U test. Results: We identified relevant estimates
of additional health gains and costs for 101 (36%) of NMEs, including 59 specialty
drugs. We found specialty drugs offered greater QALY gains than traditional drugs
(0.19 vs. 0.01, p< 0.01), but were associated with greater additional costs ($10,460
vs. $906, p< 0.01). We found the cost-effectiveness of the different drug types to be
broadly similar (p= 0.58). Conclusions: This research suggests specialty drugs
may offer greater health benefits over existing care than traditional drugs, and
despite specialty drugs being associated with greater costs, specialty and traditional
drugs were comparable in terms of cost-effectiveness. As payers search for ways to
control health care costs it is important to recognize the relative benefits as well as
the costs of specialty drugs, and to mitigate inappropriate use and waste to ensure
that effective treatments are affordable to patients.
A420
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PHP93
Assessing Assessment: Does Health Technology Assessment Do Its
Job of Controlling Costs Without Compromising Quality?
Armstrong S 1, Garfield S 2
1GfK, Wayland, MA, USA, 2GfK Market Access, Wayland, MA, USA
.
.
Objectives: The pace of innovation in health care has facilitated gains in life
expectancy, but at a tremendous cost. Rational use of limited health care resources
remains one of the greatest challenges in health care worldwide. This analysis
sought to compare health care spending and health outcomes in countries with
and without formal health technology assessment programs. Methods: Data
was collected on health care spending from 1990-2012 in European countries with
and without HTA and compared to the United States, which eschews any formal
evaluation of comparative or cost effectiveness. Measures of health outcomes were
considered, including life expectancy and overall mortality. The impact of population age, tobacco use and obesity rates on health outcomes were considered. Lastly,
the number, content and methodology of HTA publications in countries with HTA
were assessed. Results: The majority of HTA evaluations have focused on pharmaceuticals. Countries with established HTA had lower spending on pharmaceuticals, but not always lower overall health care spending, while maintaining or
improving health outcomes relative to non-HTA countries. The United States had
the highest rate and annual increase in rate in pharmaceutical spending as well as
overall health care spending, with the worst health care outcomes in countries analyzed. Conclusions: The incorporation of formal health technology assessment as
part of overall health care decision making appears to assist in controlling the rise
in health care spending, particularly drug spending. While better health outcomes
in life expectancy and mortality were found in HTA versus non-HTA countries,
correlation versus causality can only be considered at this point. Systematic use of
HTA on both pharmaceutical and non-pharmaceutical interventions may help to
control overall health care spending.
PHP94
The Trend of the Prices Of New Marketed Drugs in Turkey
Yenilmez F B 1, Kockaya G 2
1Hacettepe University, Ankara, Turkey, 2Health Economics and Policy Manager, Ankara, Turkey
.
that setting arbitrary benchmarks based on empirical observation of comparative EU countries is incorrect due to wide inconsistencies over pharmaceutical
distribution.
.
PHP96
HTA Informed Price Negotiations: Cost Savings To The Health Payer
in Ireland
McCullagh L M 1, Tilson L 1, Adams R 1, Barry M 2
Centre for Pharmacoeconomics, Dublin, Ireland, 2HSE Medicines Management
Programme, Dublin, Ireland
.
.
.
.
.
1National
Objectives: In Ireland, the reimbursement decision process involves the Marketing
Authorisation Holder (MAH) submitting a Health Technology Assessment (HTA) dossier to the National Centre for Pharmacoeconomics (NCPE). The NCPE evaluates
this dossier and submits a reimbursement recommendation to the Health Service
Executive (HSE) (the decision maker). Along with Cost-Effectiveness and Budget
Impact analyses, the decision maker considers other criteria in determining the
health benefit of an intervention. Those interventions which are not deemed cost
effective at a threshold of € 45,000/QALY may proceed to HTA informed HSE-MAH
price negotiations. The aim of this study was to estimate the potential annual cost
savings (reduced potential budget impacts) to the HSE as a consequence of HTA
informed price negotiations. Methods: All NCPE assessments received over a 2
year period were reviewed. Interventions were included if initially they had not been
recommended for reimbursement, but had subsequently been reimbursed after
HTA informed price negotiations. The potential total annual cost saving to the HSE
(difference between the original Gross BI (submitted price) and the revised Gross
BI (negotiated price) was estimated. The respective MAH BI models were used for
these analyses. Results: Eight interventions fitted the inclusion criteria; all were
classified as either oncology drugs or drugs for orphan diseases. When all such
drugs are considered, it is estimated that the cost savings to the HSE, as a result of
HTA informed price negotiations is over € 19 million per annum. Conclusions:
In Ireland, HTA informed price negotiations lead to considerable cost savings to
the Health Payer.
.
Objectives: Health Transformation Program was started at year 2002 by Ministry of
Health (MoH) in Turkey. Today, Turkey has a well established health system mostly
dominated by government on health care provider and payer. The program allows
the patient access to all drugs. There was an increasing trend for the pharmaceutical consumption in years depending on the taken policies as other health care
services. The aim of this study is to review an analysis for the new drug release
prices for Turkey in the recent years. Methods: The data was obtained from the
last price list of each calender year published by MoH for the years between 20092014. The year 2014 year data limited with the first quarter (Q1). The data classified
in three groups which were; over 100 TL, over 1000 TL and over 10000 TL. All the
result were based on ex-factory prices. A descriptive analysis was conducted on
the price lists with the number of the products, maximum and average ex-factory
prices. Results: The numbers of new released products over 100 TL were; 1, 7, 58,
36 and 52 in the years 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012 and 2013, respectively. The numbers
of new released products over 1000 TL were; 0, 1, 10, 11 and 13 in the years 2009,
2010, 2011, 2012 and 2013, respectively. The highest ex-factory prices were 739 TL,
1117 TL, 4066, 72 TL, 5781, 05 TL, 22791, 55 TLand 36577, 33 in the years 2009, 2010,
2011, 2012 and 2013, respectively. The average ex-factory prices were 178, 98 TL, 329,
28 TL, 214, 36 TL, 312, 93, 497, 44 TL and 612, 85 TL in the years 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012,
2013 and 2014Q1 respectively. Conclusions: It was shown that the number of
high prices drugs, the highest price and the average price of the new drugs were
increased year by year. Increased patient access may encoruage pharmaceutical
companies to enter the Turkish market with their innovative drugs which have high
price tag compared to regular drugs.
PHP95
Setting Targets For Public Spending Under Eu-Imf Assistance To
Portugal - The Case Of Health Care and Pharmaceuticals
PHP97
Access To Non Communicable Disease Medicines in India: A
Comparative Analysis of State Level Public Procurement Data
Chokshi M 1, Farooqui H H 2
1Public Health Foundation of India, New Delhi, India, 2Public Health Foundation of India, Gurgaon,
India
.
.
.
Objectives: - To assess access to NCD medicine in India using public drug procurement data. Methods: - State procurement data was used to calculate, total and per
capita value of procurement towards purchase of essential medicines. ABC analysis
was performed to identify priority medicines that together account for 80% of total
expenditure (Category A items). The proportion of NCD medicines among category A
items was then estimated. Finally, the efficiency of the system was captured through
comparative price analysis of procurement price to International Reference Price
(IRP). Results: - Out of the 91 NCD medicines on WHO list of essential medicine,
states were procuring 40 to 87 NCD medicines. In addition, the share of NCD procurement value to total procurement value was in range of 1.32% to 37%. Similarly,
the annual per capita spending was in range of 0.1 to 103 Indian Rupees (INR).
The procurement prices across all the states were lower than the international
reference price. The retail market prices were between 45%-3600% higher than the
state procurement prices, and were higher on average by 6 times of international
reference price. The defined daily dose estimates were not uniform for all ATC. The
most neglected category among all ATC’s was mental health, in the range of 0.02056.688 DDD per 1000. Conclusions: - There is limited access to NCD medicines
in public health system in selected Indian states.
PHP98
Constructing A Comorbidity Index According To Iso-Resource
Consumption
Sicras-Mainar A 1, Navarro-Artieda R 2
Serveis Assistencials, Badalona. Barcelona, Spain, 2Hospital Universitari Germans
Trias i Pujol, Badalona, Spain
.
.
Rocha L , Fernandes C , Viana R
Novartis Farma-Produtos Farmacêuticos S.A., Portugal, Porto Salvo, Portugal
1Badalona
Objectives: The 2008 global financial crisis hit Portugal strongly culminating
in request financial assistance from European Union and International
Monetary Fund on 17th May of 2011. In addition, Portuguese economy had already
before 2008 a decreasing real growth rate of GDP, stagnant from early in the decade, and an increasing external deficit. Health care measures represented a key
area within the assistance program. Specific targets were set for public spending in pharmaceuticals in order to align with EU average at 1.25 and 1.0 percent
of GPD for 2012 and 2013, respectively. The aim of our study was to demonstrate
that GDP targets was a political decision not supported by evidence, technically inaccurate, created a hurdle and equity asymmetries for patients access to
medications, as well as jeopardized the future sustainability of Pharmaceutical
sector. Methods: We analyzed health, pharmaceuticals and medicines public
spending EU benchmark in real terms, GDP ratio and per capita. We also revise
the System of Health Accounts methodology and conceptual framework of
International Classification of Health Accounts. OECD definitions, sources and
methods were also studied. Results: Despite the efforts to improve the comparability across countries through common and better information framework
of greater relevance for policy concerns, we observed that such approach is not
recommended. For a more comprehensive understanding of health spending in
relation to GDP ratio, it should be considered together with health spending per
capita. Portugal comparisons are an OECD example for this rational. Importantly,
OECD measures of pharmaceutical spending exclude in-patient (hospital) spending. In addition, pharmaceuticals definition is broader than prescription medicines
only. Conclusions: Important political decisions were taken assuming pharmaceuticals and prescription medicines as the same concept. Here, we demonstrate
Objectives: To construct a comorbidity index according to iso-consumption of
health resources and their associated costs in routine clinical practice. Methods:
We made a multicentre study through review of computerized medical records.
The study population consisted of patients assigned to seven primary care centres,
two acute care hospitals and one social health centre, allmanaged by Badalona
ServeisAssistencials SA. The following variables were analysed: age (0-100 years),
sex, comorbidity (chronic diagnoses) and direct health care costs. We estimated
the resource use and gross health care costs attributed to all patients requiring
health care in 2013. Subsequently, an expert panel identified the most-prevalent
chronic diseases (ICD-9). Subgroups were established according to age and number
of chronic comorbidities. The main variables and comorbidities associated with
the costs were identified using a multivariate model. This allowed a total score to
be developed for each patient. Statistical analysis: Spearman’s correlation coefficient, multiple logistic models and linear regression were used. A value of p < 0.05
was identified as significant. Results: We recruited 103,764 patients (86.5% of the
total). Mean age was 43.1 (23.9) years and 52.4% were female. The mean unit cost
was € 836.9 (2032). The gross cost was associated with age (r = 44.8) and comorbidity (r = 0.512). The final score was obtained from the logistic model. The score
obtained showed a good correlation with age (r = 81.8), comorbidity (r = 0.939)
and the cost of health care (r = 0.696). The index obtained explained 44.7% of the
gross cost. The index was better adapted to the adjusted costs. We describe the
disaggregated results and the results according to levels of comorbidity (healthy,
low, medium, high). Conclusions: The comorbidity index obtained was shown
to be a simple potential predictor of the cost of care and may be applied in routine
clinical practice.
.
.
.
A421
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PHP100
Correlation Between Hospitalized Morbidity and Cost of
Treatment of Selected Chronic Diseases
Ofierska-Sujkowska G 1, Jagodzinska-Kalinowska K 2, Matusewicz W 2
1Agency for Health Technology Assessment in Poland, Warsaw, Poland, 2Agency for Health
Technology Assessment in Poland (AOTM), Warsaw, Poland
.
.
.
Objectives: In 2011 the budget of the public payer in Poland, National Health Fund
(NHF) amounted to 58.2 bln PLN. 47.3% of these funds was allocated to fund hospital
treatment which is based on diagnosis-related groups (DRGs) but also includes
innovative, expensive drugs (i. a. chemotherapy, orphan). The aim of the paper was
to identify the existing correlation between hospital morbidity and the average unit
cost of hospital treatment in various chronic diseases. Comparison of individual
hospital costs of treatment different chronic diseases with varying degrees of severity, different course and level of incidence (from common to ultrarare) open the
possibility of presenting the correlation between morbidity and unitary medical
costs incurred by the NHF for the treatment of various indications. Methods:
The analysis was prepared for 23 therapeutic areas, which were divided into 4
categories (diseases: common, infectious, pediatric and rare /ultrarare), diversified
both in terms of severity and morbidity. This choice gave a possibility of comparing
a wide range of chronic diseases, which have a significant impact on quality of life
and mortality. The analyzed material included hospital procedures and services
indicated by the NHF in 2011. Results: Using the Pearson’s linear Correlation test,
dependence between variables (the average cost of hospitalization and the number
of patients) for 23 therapeutic areas was assessed. The results showed that the lower
prevalence (fewer patients with the diagnosis) is connected with the higher average
unit cost of treatment. Conclusions: In Poland, among all studied diseases the
most expensive was the individual treatment of patients diagnosed with ultrarare
diseases (i. a. Lysosomal storage diseases). Chronic ischemic heart disease, hypertension and diabetes mellitus were associated with the largest number of annual
hospitalizations and globally were the most cost-intensive for NHF. At the same
time hypertension is associated with the lowest average unit cost of hospitalization
among all studied diseases.
PHP101
Patient Reported Outcomes and Their Relevance in Reimbursement
Decisions
Stoddart S 1, Lis Y 2, Malmenas M 3
1PAREXEL International, London, UK, 2PAREXEL International, Uxbridge, UK, 3PAREXEL
International, Stockholm, Sweden
.
.
.
Objectives: Payers all need evidence of clinical effectiveness, reasonable cost, and
safety. Although, patient-reported outcomes (PROs) are an important component of
this evidence it is not always clear which PROs to use and reliance on an incorrect
PRO can have negative consequences. The objective was to describe the factors
determining which PROs are most likely to meet payer evidence needs. Methods:
A structured discussion of factors influencing PRO choice was held between experts
in late phase studies, evidence review, and economic modelling. These were then
validated against a sample of published reimbursement decisions across multiple
disease areas. Results: Focus of most questions is on whether to use a generic,
disease-specific or novel measure. Disease specific PROs are very frequently of value
in demonstrating clinical effectiveness and may be the standard clinical outcome.
For example, migraine studies include pain assessment and headache frequency. To
facilitate Payers’ decision making generic PROs such as EQ-5D and SF-36 are commonly used for assessing quality of life (QoL). However these instruments may not
be reliable in disease areas characterised by focal impacts on patient wellbeing. For
example, pain is only a small component of the SF-36 consequently changes in pain
levels cannot be measured with great precision and the extreme effects of pain may
be missed when generating estimates of utility. Conclusions: When choosing a
PRO, it is important to consider the disease, treatment and payer reimbursement
decision context. Disease specific QoL measures may be more sensitive than a
generic tool but may also need mapping to a general QoL measure. Acceptance will
be contingent on the existence of robust evidence either from published literature
or additionally collected data. Reviews of previous HTA submissions and payer decisions help identify requirements / standard practices in key markets and identify
common criticisms or problems.
PHP102
Interventions and Policy Measures in Health Care And
Pharmaceutical Sector To Increase Effeciency And Recovery
of Greek Health Care System
Malovecká I 1, Minariková D 1, Foltan V 2
University, Bratislava, Slovak Republic, 2Faculty of Pharmacy, Comenius University,
Bratislava, Slovak Republic
.
.
.
1Comenius
Objectives: Greece is under a very tough and strict memorandum enforced by
the European Union that has designed and applied austerity measures in order
to save Greek economy and minimizes its public debt. Also the Greek Heath care
system should be improved, upgraded or redesigned from scratch in order to be
more flexible and more efficient. The legislative intervention made by the European
Union and the memorandum in Greek Heath Care system and the Pharmaceutical
market constituted legislative framework for the Greek Heath Care and the
Pharmaceutical sector. Methods: Data on total pharmaceutical expenditures
from 2009-2011, some of them until 2012 were obtained from Hellenic Association
of Pharmaceutical Companies. They were analyzed using basic statistical methods
of observing. Results: In nearly all observed parameters was recorded their lowering. Total pharmaceutical expenditures per capita Δ x2009-2011= -20%, x2011= 5.073
mil € , pharmaceutical expenditure as% of health expenditure Δ x2009-2011= -6,5%,
x2011= 24,1%, pharmaceutical expenditure as % of GDP Δ x2009-2011= -11,1%, x2011=
2,4%, private pharmaceutical expenditure Δ x2009-2011= -13%, x2011= 1.094 mil € , private pharmaceutical expenditure per capita Δ x2009-2011= -13,5%, x2011= 96 € , public
pharmaceutical expenditure Δ x2009-2012= -36,8%, x2012= 3.215 € , public pharmaceu-
tical expenditure per capita Δ x2009-2012= -37,6%, x2012= 282 € , rebate from pharmaceutical companies Δ x2009-2012= +364,1%, net public pharmaceutical expenditure
Δ x2009-2012= -42,3%, x2012= 2.88 mil € , net public pharmaceutical expenditure per
capita Δ x2009-2012= -43%, x2012 = 253 € , net public pharmaceutical expenditure as %
of GDP Δ x2009-2012= -36,3% and in 2012 they constituted 1,4% GDP. Price changes of
medicines Δ x2005-2011= -17,8%, Δ x2010-2011= -10,7%. Conclusions: Interventions
implemented in 2010 had according presented parameters a great impact on effectiveness of Health care and Pharmaceutical sector and this improvement will continue for a few years more. The betterment of Health care and Pharmaceutical sector
might help to lower the public debt and recover economic credibility of Greece.
PHP103
Determinants of Hospitals’ Attractiveness For Patients:
Application to Expensive Drugs
Siorat V 1, Degrassat-Théas A 1, Paubel P 2, Parent de Curzon O 1, Sinègre M 1
1General Agency of Equipment and Health Products (AGEPS), PUBLIC WELFARE HOSPITAL OF
PARIS (AP-HP), PARIS, France, 2Paris Descartes University, Paris, France
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Hopital’s attractiveness can impact the number of inpatients, and so
health care expenditures. The objective is to identify parameters related to patients
or drugs, wich influence the proportion of inpatients not residing in the hospital’s
region, in order to better understand expensive drug expenditures. Methods: A
database on expensive inpatient drugs listed on a national formulary was set up,
with information related to drugs -from National and European Health authorities- and patients -from our university hospital centre’s database (UHC) of the
Paris region. A censored regression model, Tobit model, was developed in which
the dependent variable was, for each drug, the ratio of the number of inpatients not
residing in the Paris region, on the total number of inpatients receiving this drug.
Explanatory variables were related to drugs and to patients. All statistical tests
were run in Stata/IC13®. Results: During 2012, 526 091 doses -of the 113 drugs
list- are administered to 30 499 UHC inpatients. 13% of inpatients come from off
the Paris region. According to the Tobit model, three variables positively impact the
ratio (innovative status, percentage of women and Diagnosis Related Group coded
as severe) and three negatively (orphan designation, percentage of patients over
65 years old, biological origin). Therapeutic classes and Major Diagnostic Categories
also impact significantly the ratio according to the statistic class. For instance,
innovative status, defined by a market authorization granted in the five last years
and a high level of improvement in actual benefit, improves the ratio of 8.6 points.
To benefit from the most innovative treatments, patients tend to be cared in UHC’s
hospitals. Conclusions: This study represents the first step of modelling significant determinants of hospital’s attractiveness for patients. It focuses, quite uniquely,
on patients and drugs factors, and could be extended to other variables.
PHP104
Economic Impact of Clinical Researches to the Research Centers
and Reimbursement Systems in Turkey
Kockaya G 1, Daylan Kockaya P 2, Demir M 3, Uresin A Y 3
Economics and Policy Association, Ankra, Turkey, 2Zirve University, Gaziantep, Turkey,
3Istanbul Medical Faculty, Istanbul, Turkey
.
.
.
.
.
1Health
Objectives: Clinical researches are an important tool for the improvement of
medicine and significant economic value. The aim of this study was to investigate
the economic impact of clinical researches to the research centers and reimbursement system in Turkey. Methods: Budget of clinical trials were calculated from
the raw data of the Report of Istanbul Medical Faculty Clinical Researches (ITFKAR)
between years 2006-2010. In addition, the possible cost of the drugs that were used
in the clinical researches for SGK was calculated for showing the cost of medicines
acquired with clinical researches. It has been accepted that predicted budgets of
reviewed files were spent for research. Similarly, it has been accepted that the number of patients was not changed during the studies. Thus, approved budgets could
be accepted as drug investment of the approval year. For the calculation of drug
costs, discounted reimbursement figures of Social Security Administration (SGK)
for licenced products were used. If not licenced and imported via Turkish Chamber
of Pharmacists, the prices of abroad drug list of SGK were used. Calculations were
performed with the drug prices for the year 2013. Results: The average of drug cost
savings per patient with participation to the clinical research and clinical research
investment per patient were calculated as US$ 21.649 and US$ 4.879. It could be said
that total budget of sponsored pharmaceutical researches was US$107 million and
the government had a saving close to US$ 311.096.130 due to not reimbursing the
cost of drugs of the patients who were included to the clinical researches in Turkey
depending on the analysis. Conclusions: However study is based on assumptions, the findings are unique for the literature. The health policy makers can take
account the study of the policy improvements about clinical trials in Turkey.
PHP105
Pharmaceutical Developpement: Africa an Emergent Market
Mahi L 1, Lemdasni M 2, Houari A 2
1Axelys Sante Affaires Medicales et Recherche Clinique, Paris, France, 2Stratance Health, Rabat,
France
.
.
.
Objectives: With population of more than 1 Billion, Africa is the world’s second
largest continent. The transition that African countries are undergoing is a real
challenge for health care authorities. 24% of the global disease burden is accounted
in Africa. The diseases that prevailed in the 60s and 70s have not completely disappeared, tuberculosis is still endemic as well as transmissible diseases like HIV/AIDS
and Hepatitis still remained as a major problem while some others, such as cancers,
cardiovascular and metabolic disorders are dramatically increasing, requiring the
implementation of effective health care programs and leading to an increasing
demand for drugs treatment. Methods: Inventory of the potential of Africa in
clinical research. Results: In 2012, African Pharmaceutical market revenue was
USD 18 Billion and expected to reach USD 30 Billion by 2016. Established countries in
both Sub-Saharan and North African countries (South Africa, Nigeria, Cote d’Ivoire,
A422
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Senegal, Egypt, Morocco, Algeria and Tunisia) are contributing # 80% of the pharma
market in Africa. Despite maintaining regional offices within Africa, many major
Pharma and device manufacturers frequently overlook the continent when sponsoring clinical studies. Cultural barriers, political upheaval and uneven infrastructure
are certainly causes for the lack of interest. But Africa offers tremendous expertise
and opportunity for drug and device companies looking for cost-effective study
sites and appropriate patient drug market populations. Currently more than 45%
of the whole continent’s clinical trials are being conducted in South Africa and
hence the need for the next generation clinical trial destination for a drug and
device manufacturers. These companies can also consider technology transfer by
partnering with local drug manufacturers and research centers to diversify their
business portfolio. Conclusions: Africa presents real opportunities that should
encourage many pharmaceutical companies to really engage in innovative clinical
research programs in a win-win approach.
the treatment of asthma were not accepted due to comments about population
and model input, lack of statistical calculations and size of the incremental effects.
Ranibizumab’s results for age-related macular degeneration were not accepted
because of a wrong comparator, lack of long term data, assumptions on risks and
mortality, and uncertainties around health care costs and ICER sensitivity. Finally,
ZiNL considered the appropriate use of alglucosidase alfa for Pompe’s disease
to be unsubstantiated because of the population choice for the ICER calculation
and the use of a higher dose than the registered dose which was not supported
by scientific data. The outcome results of alglucosidase alfa for cost-effectiveness
were accepted, however. Conclusions: Although at T= 0 ZiNL provided feedback
regarding the design of the outcome research study, most of ZiNL’s comments were
on the final methodology used. The outcome research studies were considered
to be of mixed quality and the results could often not substantiate the claim of
cost-effectiveness and appropriate use.
PHP106
Market Analysis in Regard to Biologically Active Supplements And
Medicines in Armenia
PHP109
Opportunity Costs of Implementing Nice Decisions in NHS Wales
Beglaryan M , Amirjanyan A
Yerevan State Medical University, YEREVAN, Armenia
.
.
Objectives: Although, whether biologically active supplements (BAS) are medicines or not is still debatable, BAS keep making their way to the customer basically
through pharmacies. A worldwide tendency toward “greener” choices when purchasing health status modifiers (HSM) is well documented. Current endeavor studies
the pharmaceutical market situation (PMS) in Armenia (2009 to 2013) in regard to
growth trends both in US dollars turnover (USDT) and number of packs sold (NPS) of
BAS versus medicines, stratified by five leading diseases (LD). Methods: Statistical
data on morbidity and mortality from the MOH RA were used to identify the leading
five disease groups in newly identified cases. Further, statistical data on pharmaceutical market from “Pharmexpert” Marketing Research Centre (analysis of wholesale
sales volumes to the retail drug stores) were investigated to identify growth rate
(GR) trends of interest. Results: A PMS analysis has shown 11.92% and 6.65% of
GR (medicines and BAS combined) in USDT and NPS respectively. For medicines
alone the results were: 11.56% and 6.23% GR in USDT and NPS respectively. As for
BAS, USDT and NPS, the figures were 21.48% and 15.36% of GR respectively. A further
stratification by five LM has shown the highest GR in medicines used for treatment
of Uro-Genital diseases (13.24% and 10.01% for USDT and NPS respectively), whereas
in BAS the highest GR was in the Cardio-Vascular group (63.84% and 92.82% for USDT
and NPS respectively). Conclusions: The results of the study go in line with the
worldwide trends in shifting whenever possible, from medicines to using HSM of
natural origin, of which BAS are a major part. The study does not claim to identify
the underlying compound factors influencing such a tendency. However, the reality
at had compels for studying the levels of BAS administration and use literacy among
both HSM prescribers and consumers.
Karlsberg Schaffer S 1, Sussex J 1, Hughes D 2, Devlin N 1
1Office of Health Economics, London, UK, 2Bangor University, Bangor, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In the UK, when a technology is recommended by the National
Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE), the NHS is mandated to provide
the funding to accommodate it within three months. Explicit in NICE’s approach
to health technology assessment (HTA) is the assumption that the approval of a
new, cost-increasing technology will result in the displacement of an existing, less
cost-effective health care programme from elsewhere in the NHS. The objective
of this study is to identify the actual opportunity costs of specific NICE decisions
by documenting how in practice local commissioners in Wales accommodated
financial shocks arising from technology appraisals (TAs). Methods: Interviews
were conducted with Finance and Medical Directors from all seven Local Health
Boards (LHBs) in NHS Wales. These interviews covered prioritisation processes, as
well as methods of financing NICE TAs and other financial “shocks” at each LHB.
We then undertook a systematic identification of themes and topics from the
information recorded. Results: The financial impact of NICE TAs is generally
planned for in advance and the majority of LHBs have contingency funds available for this purpose. Efficiency savings (defined as reductions in costs with no
assumed reductions in quality) were a major source of funds for all cost pressures.
Service displacements were not linkable to particular TAs and there appears to be
a general lack of explicit prioritisation activities. The Welsh Government has, on
occasion, acted as the funder of last resort. Conclusions: The assumption that
newly recommended technologies will displace existing NHS services does not
appear to hold true in practice. As the additional cost pressures represented by
new NICE TAs are likely to be accommodated by greater efficiency and increased
expenditure, the true opportunity cost of HTA decisions is extremely difficult to
quantify and may even lie outside the NHS.
PHP107
Impact of 2011 German Health Care Reform on Prices
PHP110
Funding Integrated Health Care Services
Ackermann A C 1, Reinaud F 2, Ando G 3, Izmirlieva M 3
1IHS, Zurich, Switzerland, 2IHS, Paris, France, 3IHS, London, UK
Belgaied W 1, Urbinati D 2, Toumi M 3
1Creativ-Ceutical, Tunis, Tunisia, 2Creativ-Ceutical, Luxembourg, Luxembourg, 3University
Aix-Marseille, Marseille, France
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: This study seeks to evaluate the incremental benefit scores granted
to new medicines under the 2011 AMNOG reform in Germany, and if there is a
correlation between that score and the extent of price reduction after negotiation
with the statutory health insurance fund. Methods: Resolutions issued by the
G-BA related to all drugs which achieved the early benefit assessment process
between January 2011 and June 2014 were reviewed to determine whether the
drugs were deemed to bring an added benefit. Under AMNOG, an added therapeutic benefit score is granted to medicines according to 6 categories (major, considerable, minor, non-quantifiable, no or less added benefit versus the comparator).
As part of the study, IHS created an overall quantitative innovation score for each
product, based on any and all qualitative ratings granted by the G-BA in each
patient subgroup. The score ranged from 0 (no added benefit proven) to 4 (major
added benefit) and was weighted against each patient population. An average price
reduction per innovation score range was then calculated. Results: Out of the 76
drugs assessed in the study, a total of 44 were deemed to bring an added benefit
over the appropriate comparator by the G-BA, of which 34 had achieved price negotiation as of end of May 2014. These ratings translated into an average innovation
score of 1.77, and were subject to price cuts averaging 21.7%. Conclusions: Our
analysis highlights that innovative medicines can be subject to significant price
cuts in Germany. No correlation between the innovation score and subsequent
price cuts could be derived, as many other factors, including the initial price difference between the new medicine and the comparator, enter into account as
part of the price negotiations.
PHP108
Real World Data (Rwd) At T= 4 in the Netherlands
Lie X , Nijhuis T
Quintiles Consulting, Hoofddorp, The Netherlands
.
.
Objectives: If the cost-effectiveness and appropriate use of a drug in the
Netherlands cannot yet be determined during the initial reimbursement assessment (T= 0), this will be done at the re-evaluation 4 years later (T= 4) using RWD.
Outcome research is an essential part of the re-evaluation of conditionally reimbursed drugs. The objective was to assess the reasons for accepting or rejecting
outcome research results to confirm cost-effectiveness and appropriate use of
a drug at T= 4. Methods: The website of Zorginstituut Nederland (ZiNL) was
searched for re-evaluations of drugs published between January 2006 and May
2014. ZiNL’s assessments of the outcome research were compared. Results: ZiNL
published the outcome research results for four drugs. The outcome research
results for agalsidase alfa & beta were accepted for demonstrating cost-effectiveness and appropriate use in Fabry’s disease. The T= 4 results for omalizumab for
.
.
.
Objectives: Western countries health care systems face growing challenges dealing with disability and death due to chronic diseases. Coordination of health care
services has become unavoidable. Our objective was to identify the Integrated
Health Services (IHS) in the major health care markets and understand the funding process. Methods: IHS provided in Europe, North America and Asia were
identified through a literature review. Future perspectives were based on country
policy and observed trends. Results: All studied countries developed IHS such
as disease management, case management and telemonitoring services, with the
United States (US) being the major market. However, levels of implementation,
funding processes and stakeholders involved vary highly between different countries. Funding processes such as fee for services and capitation are widely used in
all studied countries and Payment for performance (P4P), bundled payment and
diagnosis-related group (DRG) for outpatient are in progress, used mainly in the
US, and to a much lower extent in the United Kingdom (UK) and Germany. Multiple
IHS exists in France, though inappropriate incentives hinder their development. In
the US, under the Affordable Care Act, Accountable Care Organisations (ACOs) are
testing a range of payment models (capitation, one-sided/two-sided shared saving fee-for-service, bundled/episode payments and P4P). Conclusions: IHS have
become ubiquitous in all health organisations. All countries studied are expected to
develop more IHS based on P4P schemes. The P4P of ACOs represents the ultimate
gold mine for the development of paid health care services. Even if this concept is
still in progress it will be leading this market. This will also change dramatically the
way pharmaceutical companies will do business. Drugs will have to be integrated
in a more complex selling process driven by medium to long term outcome impact.
The management of confounding factors on outcomes is critical and represents
the challenge for ACOs.
PHP111
Acceptance Of Telemonitoring By Health Care Professionals in
Germany: A Question Of Financial Conditions
Leppert F , Dockweiler C , Eggers N , Webel K , Hornberg C , Greiner W
Bielefeld University, Bielefeld, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The comprehensive implementation of telemedical applications still
lags behind expectations in Germany. One of the main barriers to innovation is a
lack of both a willingness to adapt and user’s acceptance. Processes of adoption
and acceptance are characterized by a network of different factors which influence attitude and behavior which differ in severity depending on each user group.
One key factor for accepting and adopting an innovation is the economic framework. We therefore examined the influence of economic factors influencing the
A423
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
attitudes of physicians in Germany towards telemonitoring. Methods: In the first
step fundamental determinants of adoption and acceptance were identified using
a systematic literature review and transferred to a theoretical effect model. This
model was used to create a quantitative questionnaire which was then used to
interview online 201 outpatient and inpatient physicians from different fields of
medicine. The participants (84.3% male, mean age 53 years) were asked to assess the
empirically based economic attributes of telemonitoring regarding its implementation. Results: The results show a lack of information regarding the financial risks
of using telemedical technology, as only 14% of those interviewed said they felt
sufficiently informed about the subject. Barriers to using telemedicine technology
include missing arrangements for reimbursement, uncertain financial advantages
and missing business models. In addition, the cost of implementation are indistinct
for a broad majority of interviewees. On the other hand, in most queried dimension
the user see a potential financial benefit due to telemedicine. The positive effects
expected from telemonitoring were rated much better rated by those who already
used telemonitoring in their professional life. Conclusions: In addition to a more
precise legal framework, information security and quality-based guidelines, more
emphasis must be placed on economic issues. It is also imperative that physicians
be better informed about all aspects of telemedicine.
PHP112
External Reference Pricing Impact of the Integration of the Amnog
Discount In The List Price
Thivolet M 1, Cetinsoy L 1, Vataire A L 1, Rémuzat C 1, Brunet J 2, Kornfeld A 1, Toumi M 3
1Creativ-Ceutical, Paris, France, 2Assistance Publique des Hôpitaux de Marseille, Marseille, France,
3University Aix-Marseille, Marseille, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In Germany, the AMNOG law replaced free pricing by the early benefit assessment (EBA) since 2011. Manufacturers are free to set new drugs’ prices
for up to one year after which the price is negotiated between manufacturers
and insurers based on the EBA. The negotiated price, that is consistently lower
than the one set by the manufacturers, is considered as the official list price since
April 1st2014. The objective of this study is to evaluate the potential impact of this
new law on the external reference pricing (ERP) in Europe. Methods: A simulation model, developed for the European Commission, was used to simulate ERP’s
impact on Boceprevir and Telaprevir prices after five years, following the discount’s
inclusion on the official list price in Germany. ERP impact on price was evaluated
in Belgium, Czech Republic, France, Germany, Luxembourg, Norway, Slovakia,
Slovenia, Sweden, Switzerland, The Netherlands and UK for Boceprevir and in
Belgium, Finland, France, Germany, Luxembourg, Norway, Poland, Slovakia, Slovenia,
Sweden, Switzerland, The Netherlands and UK for Telaprevir. National policy inputs
were obtained from a literature review and consultation of international organisations’ representatives. Prices used at the start of the simulation were obtained from
IMS. Results: After five years, the relative price variation of Boceprevir between
the scenario with AMNOG discount integrated in the list price and with no discount integrated in the list price was null in Belgium, Luxembourg, Sweden and
UK, of -8.1% in the Netherlands, -9.2% in Norway, nearly -10% in Czech Republic,
France, Slovakia and Switzerland, and -14% in Slovenia. For Telaprevir, the price
variation was null in Belgium, Finland, Luxembourg, Slovenia and the UK, of -0.8%
in Slovakia, -2.5% in the Netherlands, -2.9% in Norway, -6.9% in France and -8.6% in
Switzerland. Conclusions: Integrating AMNOG discount in the list price impacts
significantly the price in European countries due to ERP.
PHP114
A Comparison of Cobb-Douglas, Translog and Additive Models of
the Production Functions of Inpatient Services In Public Hospitals
Reyes-Santias F 1, Antelo M 2, Rodriguez-Alvarez M X 1, Vivas-Consuelo D 3,
Cadarso-Suarez C 2, Caballer-Tarazona V 3
1Universidad de Vigo, Vigo, Spain, 2Universidad de Santiago de Compostela, Santiago de
Compostela, Spain, 3Universidad Politecnica de Valencia, Valencia, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
PHP115
Gender-Related Behaviors in Drug Consumption In Italy
Orlando V 1, Bruzzese D 2, Putignano D 1, Guerriero F 1, Tettamanti A 3, Menditto E 1
1CIRFF- Center of Pharmacoeconomics, Naples, Italy, 2University of Naples, Federico II, Napoli,
Italy, 3IMS Health, Milano, Italy
.
.
.
PHP116
Value of Life And Cost of Pre-Mature Deaths With The Perspective Of
Productivity As Net Tax Revenue: A Comparison In Usa, Canada, Japan
and Australia
Yenilmez F B 1, Tuna E 1, Atikeler K 1, Kockaya G 2, Tatar M 1
University, Ankara, Turkey, 2Health Economics and Policy Association, Ankra, Turkey
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Hacettepe
Objectives: The Human Capital Theory emphasizes investments to the health
care sector as an important element in achieving and sustaining economic development. Investments to health care sector improves macro and micro economic
outcomes for the whole society. The aim of this study is to calculate the possible
produced value for a life-time term (VLT) and cost of pre-mature deaths (CPD)
from the productivity for USA, Canada, Japan and Australia. Methods: Net present value (NPV) of the taxes and spending for each year were calculated. For
calculating NPV in the government perspectives, two modelling approaches were
combined, human capital modelling based on lives saved and lost productivity,
and generational accounting, which accounts for a range of other government
fiscal transfers to citizens. The possible produced value for a life-time term for
each country were assumed as calculating the total NPV for each country depending on the countries life expectancy. CPD for each countries were assumed as the
difference between NPV on the year of life expectancy and each decades as life
years 60, 50, 40, 30, 20, 10. The economic values for the model of each country
derived from World Bank, OECD, UNESCO or WHO. Results: Possible produced
value for a life-time term for each country were calculated as US $ 1.415.530, US$
774.663, US$ 238.236 and US$ 2.917.835 for USA, Canada, Japan and Australia,
respectively. CPD per person for USA were calculated as US$ -1.526.126, US$
-1.661.257, US$ -1.300.923, US$ -796.547, US$ - 351.827 and US$ -40.507 for the life
years 10, 20, 30, 40, 50 and 60 respectively. The trend was same for Canada, Japan
and Australia. Conclusions: However the study was based on a hypothetical
model that calculated the NPV with the taxes and spending in a life-time term,
the results of each country were parallel.
.
.
Objectives: To investigate the adequacy of the widely used Cobb-Douglas
and translog models of the production functions of hospital in-patient services. Methods: To investigate the adequacy of the widely used Cobb-Douglas
and translog models of the production functions of hospital in-patient services,
we fitted these and additive models (AMs) to 2002-2007 data for the gynaecology
and obstetrics, general and digestive surgery, internal medicine, and traumatology and orthopaedic surgery services of 10 public hospitals in Galicia (NW Spain).
Production, measured as admissions weighted in accordance with their diagnosisrelated groups (DRGs), was treated as a function of physician full-time equivalents
as surrogate labour factor and number of beds as surrogate capital factor. Results:
For the General Surgery specialty the findings for the CD model indicate a better
fit than those for the Translog and the AM, as it is shown by AIC value while R2
(CD= 96.32, Translog= 96.30, AM= 98.30) prefers the flexible AM. This is a good example of using AM as a tool for checking the behaviour of existing parametric models.
In this case we can be confident with Cobb-Douglas estimations. Findings for the
Internal Medicine specialty indicate responses for the CD (AIC= -17.789) seems to be
more “robust” than those based on the AM (AIC=-13.113) and Translog (AIC=-15.939)
models, R2 (CD= 95.88, Translog= 95.80, AM= 97.90) shows better fit for the AM regression model. Conclusions: Our results suggest that while the Cobb-Douglas and
translog models suffice to represent the production functions of services with low
average DRG weight, the greater flexibility of models such as AMs is required for
services with higher average DRG weight.
.
entire populations. The aim of this study was to describe difference in prevalence
of drugs use in the entire population in Italy between men and women. Methods:
We performed a cross-sectional study using 2012 data from the IMS LifeLink
Treatment DynamicsTM LRx Database, an italian-based administrative database
that includes all prescribed drugs that are reimbursed by the Italian National
Healthcare System. Pharmacological groups accounting for > 90% of the total
volume in Defined Daily Doses were considered. Crude and age adjusted differences in prevalence were calculated as risk ratios of women/men. Results: 31
therapeutic categories were analyzed and there are significant differences for 30
of them. The largest sex difference in prevalence was found for thyroid preparations that were more common in women (59.3/1000 women and 10.9/1000 men,
respectively). This was followed by antiinflammatory and antirheumatic products
(114.0/1000 women and 67.4/1000 men) and antidepressants (62.1/1000 women
and 26.8/1000 men). The pharmacological groups with the largest relative differences of dispensed drugs were drugs affecting bone structure and mineralization
(RR 12.4), calcium (RR 7.0) and thyroid therapy (RR 4.9), which were dispensed to
women to a higher degree. Antigout-agents (RR 0.4), vasodilators used in cardiac
diseases (RR 0.7) and ACE inhibitors (RR 0.7) were dispensed to men to a larger
proportion. Conclusions: This is the first Italian study that shows substantial
differences between men and women. Our findings are congruent with those
reported previously in the literature. Some of differences may be explained by
variations in disease prevalence and severity, pathophysiology, or by other biological differences. However, it is also evident that other differences lack a rational
medical explanation.
.
.
Objectives: Sex differences in drug use have been demonstrated in several therapeutic area. However, there is a lack of overviews on sex differences of drug use in
PHP117
Home Pharmacies: An Insight In Self-Medication Practice
Paut Kusturica M 1, Tomic Z 1, Bukumiric Z 2, Trivic B 1, Sabo A 1
1Faculty of Medicine, Novi Sad, Serbia and Montenegro, 2Faculty of Medicine, Belgrade, Serbia and
Montenegro
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Based on the content of drugs in households, it is possible to examine
the inclination of patients towards self-medication and groups of drugs that are
commonly used for this purpose. Taking into consideration the above, the present
study aimed to investigate the self-medication practice, with an emphasis on
self-medication with prescription only medications. Methods: The study was
performed in 8 months period and involved 383 randomly selected households.
The study consisted of a personal insight into the inventory of all drugs. The interviewer recorded the total number of drugs in households and asked respondents
for each the drug was obtained on prescription or bought in the pharmacy for
self-medication. After the data were collected, drugs were classified according the
Anatomical Therapeutic Chemical (ATC) Classification System. Drugs were also
classified according to ALIMS (Medicines and Medical Devices Agency of Serbia)
into two groups: prescription only medication (POM) and OTC (Over the Counter)
drugs and then analyzed. Results: The total number of drug items present in
the 383 households was 4384 with an average of 11.4±5.8 per household. More
than a half of drugs in households were prescription only medications (58,5%).
Approximately one third of these drugs were obtained without prescription. The
most common prescription only medications obtained without prescription
were anti-inflammatory and antirheumatic products (41,8%) and antibacterials
for systemic use (12,4%). Ibuprofen (61,0%), diclofenac (27,8%) and nimesulide
(8,2%) were the most common self-medicated drugs in the group of antiinflamatory drugs, while the most frequently self-medicated antibiotics were cefalexin
(25,7%), doxyciclin (18,6%), cotrimoxazole (17,7%). Conclusions: In conclusion,
our survey indicated that self-mediation with prescription drugs appeared to be
a rather common practice, which is far away from the concept of “responsible
self-medication”, especially regarding antibiotics. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT: This
work was supported by the Ministry of Science and Technological development,
Republic of Serbia, project No. 41012.
A424
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PHP118
Patterns and Predictors of Hospital Readmission in Taiwan
Cheng J S 1, Ku H P 1, Chang C J 2
Gung University, Tao-Yuan, Taiwan, 2Chang Gung University, Kwei Shan, Tao Yuan,
Taiwan
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Chang
Objectives: Hospital readmissions have been an important issue, as they reflect
suboptimal quality of medical care and incur high health care expenditures.
However, limited information is available on the patterns of hospital readmission
in the entire population to support a thorough planning to prevent hospital readmissions. Therefore, this study aimed to examine the patterns and economic burden
of hospital readmission in Taiwan, and identify predictors of hospital readmissions. Methods: This study used the National Health Insurance Research Database
of enrollees randomly selected from those enrolled in the National Health Insurance
program in 2005. Individuals who were admitted to acute hospitals in 2005 were
selected and their readmission patterns one-year after discharge were examined.
Cox proportional hazards regression model was adopted to identify predictors of
hospital readmission. Results: The 30-day, 6-month and one-year readmission
rates were 11%, 25%, and 34%, respectively. During the one-year follow-up, 52% of
total health care expenditures were due to hospital readmissions. Of those who
were readmitted to hospitals, 56% were readmitted once and took up 29% of the
cost of rehospitalization. However, those readmitted for more than three times (5%)
accounted for 30% of the cost. The major disease category of the highest 30-day and
one-year readmission rates was neoplasms. The disease of the highest 30-day and
one-year readmission rates were cancer of bronchus and lung (36%) and cancer of
liver and intrahepatic bile duct (74%), respectively, and the most frequent reason
for readmission was the disease itself. Age, gender, place of residence, previous
hospitalization history, comorbidities, and length of stay of the index hospitalization
were risk factors of hospital readmissions. Conclusions: This study identified
diseases of higher short-term and long-term readmission rates, causes of shortterm and long-term hospital readmissions, and predictors of hospital readmission.
The information is of importance for planning interventions to reduce hospital
readmission rate.
PHP119
Secure System for Iv Administrations: Health Economic Impact Of A
“Smart” Infusion Safety System
Schmidt A , Bénard S
st[è]ve consultants, Oullins, France
.
.
Objectives: More than half of medication errors are reported during administration. “Smart” Infusion Safety Systems (SISS) have been developed to avoid
administration errors and provide data for continuous quality improvement (CQI).
Few data produced by SISS have been analysed. Given the lack of clinical trials, a
model was developed in order to assess the economic benefits of SISS from the
perspective of a French public hospital. Methods: Comprehensive data from
6 intensive care units (ICU) were analysed. Two types of alerts were defined: hard
(absolute) and soft limits. An avoided error was defined as the detection of a
scheduled infusion over a hard limit or a scheduled infusion over a soft limit that
was later overridden by staff. The severity of consequences was estimated on
the HARM INDEX score, which is based on the pharmacologic risk, overdose
detectability, overdosing range and the type of hospital unit. According to this
score, errors were categorised as minor, significant, and serious. The economic
value was estimated based on the hypothetical resulting length of stay had the
error not been avoided, which increases according to error severity, and the
financial investment for SISS. Results: Overall, 207,025 infusions were analysed
from the database of 6 ICUs and 8,503 of them were associated with a safety
alert (4.1%), including 987 errors (0.48%). Applied to one public ICU equipped with
5 SISS, the model estimates that SISS would prevent 78 errors per year (54 minor,
12 significant, 12 serious) and avoid 173 days of hospitalisation per year. This
corresponds to an annual savings of € 139,491 for the hospital (39% and 61% from
significant and serious errors, respectively). Conclusions: This model demonstrates the high economic burden of medication errors for French public hospitals
and the need for CQI. To date, no equivalent evaluation has been conducted in
France.
PHP120
Value of Life and Cost of Pre-Mature Deaths With The Perspective of
Productivity As Net Tax Revenue: A Comparison in France, Germany,
Italy, Spain, United Kingdom
Tuna E 1, Yenilmez F B 1, Atikeler K 1, Kockaya G 2, Tatar M 1
University, Ankara, Turkey, 2Health Economics and Policy Association, Ankra, Turkey
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Hacettepe
Objectives: The Human Capital Theory emphasizes investments to the health
care sector as an important element in achieving and sustaining economic development. Investments to health care sector improves macro and micro economic
outcomes for the whole society. The aim of this study is to calculate the possible
produced value for a life-time term (VLT) and cost of pre-mature deaths (CPD)
from the productivity for France, Germany, Italy, Spain, UK (UK). Methods: Net
present value (NPV) of the taxes and spending for each year were calculated. For
calculating NPV in the government perspectives, two modelling approaches were
combined, human capital modelling based on lives saved and lost productivity,
and generational accounting, which accounts for a range of other government fiscal transfers to citizens. The possible produced value for a life-time term for each
country were assumed as calculating the total NPV for each country depending
on the countries life expectancy. CPD for each countries were assumed as the difference between NPV on the year of life expectancy and each decades as life years
60, 50, 40, 30, 20, 10. The economic values for the model of each country derived
from World Bank, OECD, UNESCO or WHO. Results: Possible produced VLT term
for each country were calculated as US$ 993.347, US$ 629.814, US$ 245.885, US$
48.818 and US$ 1.628.957 for France, Germany, Italy, Spain, UK, respectively. CPD per
person for France were calculated as US$ -1.060.571, US$ -1.148.852, US$ -887.348,
US$ -551.873, US$ - 224.070 and US$ -10.972 for the life years 10, 20, 30, 40, 50 and 60
respectively. Although numbers were different, the trend was same for Germany,
Italy, Spain, UK. Conclusions: However the study was based on a hypothetical
model that calculated the NPV with the taxes and spending in a life-time term,
the results of each country were parallel.
PHP121
Switching Patients With Primary Antibody Deficiencies to HomeBased Subcutaneous Immunoglobulin: Economic Evaluation of An
Interprofessional Drug Therapy Management Program
Perraudin C , Bourdin A , Berger J , Bugnon O
School of pharmaceutical sciences, University of Geneva, University of Lausanne, Lausanne,
Switzerland
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Lifelong immunoglobulin G (IgG) replacement is the standard therapy for patients with primary antibody deficiencies. It can be administered either
intravenously (IVIg) by health care providers in hospital or subcutaneously (SCIg)
by patients at home. However, self-administration requires patients’ education
and support over long term to ensure proper adherence and optimal efficacy and
safety. Every patient who switches to SCIg is proposed by the Policlinique Médicale
Universitaire (Lausanne, Switzerland) a drug therapy management program with a
nurse and a community pharmacist including training, coaching and follow-up.
The aim of the study was to evaluate if switching to SCIg at home including the
management program was cost-effective compared to IVIg at hospital. Methods:
Assuming that both therapies provide similar efficacy, a 3-years cost-minimization
analysis based on a simulation model was performed from a societal perspective.
Health care costs (IgG, time of professionals, infusion pumps and disposables) were
derived from administrative data. Transport and losses of productivity were estimated. One-way sensitivity analyses were performed. Results: Under base case
assumptions, SCIg at home was estimated at 34960 CHF per patient the first year
and 30 030 CHF in subsequent years against 34 170 CHF per year for IVIg. The total
savings for a switch to SCIg at home with the program was 7490 CHF per patient over
3 years. Results were relatively sensible to the assumptions. Conclusions: Homebased SCIg therapy including an interprofessional therapy management program
may be an effective and efficient alternative to hospital for patients with primary
antibody deficiencies. Additional costs from purchase of equipment and management program in the first year were offset by hospital costs avoided in short term.
Additional studies are ongoing to analyse the retention in the therapy in medium
term and the impact on quality of life.
PHP122
Gender Medicine in Germany: What is so Difficult about its
Implementation? - An Empirical Study in Germany –
Chase D P 1, Mitar I 2, Oertelt-Prigione S 3, Hess N 4, Amelung V E 5
for Applied Health Services Research, Berlin, Germany, 2Pfizer Pharma GmbH, Berlin,
Germany, 3Charité Berlin, Berlin, Germany, 4Cardiology Practice, Berlin, Germany, 5Hannover
Medical School, Hannover, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Institute
Objectives: Personalized medicine is currently a popular topic in health care
debates. Yet, the basic differentiation between females and males is hardly found
in care delivery/health management programs. This study aimed at elucidating
the opinion of German Statutory Health Insurance (SHI) managers and internal
specialists regarding gender-specific care in order to understand their perceptions on responsibilities and possible implementation opportunities. Methods:
Between April and June 2013, a questionnaire on the implementation of gender
medicine in the current health care landscape was developed. Based on literature
review and expert consultations, it included open- and closed-ended questions on
expectations/prioritization, need for action, and implementation of gender medicine. Forty-eight insurance managers of the largest German SHIs, covering over
95% of the market, and approximately 16,000 physicians of the German Society
for Internal Medicine (DGIM) were contacted to complete a web-based survey.
Descriptive analyses, Chi-square tests, and Pearson correlation coefficient were
used to investigate the research objective. Results: According to both, insurance
managers (76%) and physicians (60%), gender-specific care is not sufficiently incorporated into standard medical care. Respondents claim the responsibility lies with
the ministry of health, physicians and medical staff, as well as their associations.
Specifically, more evidence is needed to incorporate gender aspects in treatment
guidelines, an idea which is well-supported by insurances (65%) and physicians
(70%). A top-down approach for implementation is preferred by 65% of insurance
managers and 50% of physicians, whereas fewer participants encourage bottomup mechanisms. Conclusions: German SHIs expect a significant governmental
influence and/or support of self-governing bodies to achieve an incorporation of
gender medicine into daily practice. Primary responsibility for the integration of
gender-specific approaches is perceived to lie with physicians. As soon as critical
hurdles in the medical field will be removed, the positive perception of both participating parties can be integrated in the implementation process of gender-medicine.
PHP123
Value of Life And Cost of Pre-Mature Deaths With the Perspective of
Productivity As Net Tax Revenue for Turkey
Kockaya G 1, Tuna E 2, Yenilmez F B 2, Atikeler K 2, Tatar M 2
Economics and Policy Association, Ankra, Turkey, 2Hacettepe University, Ankara, Turkey
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Health
Objectives: The Human Capital Theory emphasizes investments to the health
care sector as an important element in achieving and sustaining economic
development. Investments to health care sector improves macro and micro economic outcomes for the whole society. The aim of this study is to calculate the
possible produced value for a life-time term (VLT) and cost of pre-mature deaths
(CPD) from the productivity for Turkey where the life expectancies was noted 75
years. Methods: Net present value (NPV) of the taxes and spending for each year
were calculated. For calculating NPV in the government perspectives, two modeling
approaches were combined, human capital modeling based on lives saved and lost
A425
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
productivity, and generational accounting, which accounts for a range of other government fiscal transfers to citizens. The possible produced value for a life-time term
was assumed as calculating the total NPV depending on the life expectancy. CPD
was assumed as the difference between NPV on the year of life expectancy and each
decades as life years 50, 40, 30, 20, 10 and new born. The economic values for the
model were derived from World Bank, OECD, UNESCO or WHO. Results: Possible
produced value for a life-time term for Turkey was calculated as US$ 483.298. Cost
of pre-mature death per person was calculated as US$ - 102.064, US$ - 271.716, US$
-441.679, US$ -583.726, US$ - 518.753,14 and US$ - 483.986 for the life years new born,
10, 20, 30, 40 and 50 respectively. Conclusions: However the study was based
on a hypothetical model that calculated the NPV with the taxes and spending in a
life-time term, cost of premature death was calculated as the highest in early ages
and was decreasing up to the retirement age. The results may be reference for the
decision makers. Health policy makers may improve the access to the treatments
in the early life years for the possible increased cost of premature deaths in Turkey.
PHP124
Exposure To Potential Drug-Drug Interactions in Teaching Hospital
Of South Punjab, Pakistan
Khan H M S 1, Butt H 1, Shah N H 2
1Islamia University Bahawalpur, The Islamia University of Bahawalpur, Pakistan, 2Bahauddin
Zakarya University, Multan, Pakistan
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Drug-drug interaction is a common error in poly-medication and contributes a major part in adverse drug reactions. The aim of the present study was to
evaluate the percentage of potential drug-drug interactions in the prescription in the
region of South Punjab Pakistan prescribed by the medical practitioner Methods: A
total of 100 prescriptions were included in this study. Institution based retrospective
study was performed in Nishter Hospital Multan, Pakistan, the 3rd oldest medical
institution of Pakistan, which has a capacity of 1800 beds and having a best facility to hold a large number of emergencies at a time. Prescriptions were collected
to see the Drug - Drug interactions and compared with the standard reference of
important DDI’s. The potential drug-drug interactions were categorized according
to their severity, effect and mechanism. Results: The study showed that among
100 prescriptions (543 medicines), 41% of prescriptions have potential DDI’s. Mostly
prescribed drugs were the antibiotics (38%), and the drugs belonging to class analgesic were found to contribute mostly in drug-drug interactions (26.50%). The survey
showed the total of 71 interactions and their severity level accounting as major
(20.10%), moderate (63.4%) and minor (15.90). The mechanism by which the drugs
interact with one another showed that there were pharmacokinetic (60.5%), pharmacodynamic (38.6%) and few of them interact by the mechanism which was not specified in the available literature (0.9%). Conclusions: Drug-drug interactions occur
in poly-medication and need to be evaluated and monitored for the positive impact
on the medication use system and improvement of quality of patient care. A clinical pharmacist with its accurate knowledge of drug, their effect on human organs
and their interaction with other can monitor and manage these drug interactions.
PHP125
Value of Life And Cost of Pre-Mature Deaths With The Perspective Of
Productivity As Net Tax Revenue: A Comparison In Argentina, Brazil
And Mexico
Atikeler K 1, Tuna E 1, Yenilmez F B 1, Tatar M 1, Kockaya G 2
1Hacettepe University, Ankara, Turkey, 2Health Economics and Policy Association, Ankra, Turkey
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The Human Capital Theory emphasizes investments to the health care
sector as an important element in achieving and sustaining economic development.
Investments to health care sector improves macro and micro economic outcomes
for the whole society. The aim of this study is to calculate the possible produced
value for a life-time term (VLT) and cost of pre-mature deaths (CPD) from the productivity for Argentina, Brazil and Mexico. Methods: Net present value (NPV) of
the taxes and spending for each year were calculated. For calculating NPV in the
government perspectives, two modelling approaches were combined, human capital
modelling based on lives saved and lost productivity, and generational accounting,
which accounts for a range of other government fiscal transfers to citizens. The
possible produced value for a life-time term for each country were assumed as calculating the total NPV for each country depending on the countries life expectancy.
CPD for each countries were assumed as the difference between NPV on the year
of life expectancy and each decades as life years 60, 50, 40, 30, 20, 10. The economic
values for the model of each country derived from World Bank, OECD, UNESCO or
WHO. Discount rate and inflation for wages were taken as 3% per year for all countries. Results: Possible produced VLT for each country were calculated as US $
716.945, US$ 663.129 and US$ 653.598 for Argentina, Brazil and Mexico, respectively.
CPD per person for Argentina were calculated as US$ -666.234, US$ -657.861, US$
-512.554, US$ -338.675, US$ - 164.722 and US$ -24.615 for the life years 10, 20, 30, 40,
50 and 60 respectively. The trend was same for Brazil and Mexico. Conclusions:
However the study was based on a hypothetical model that calculated the NPV with
the taxes and spending in a life-time term, the results of each country were parallel.
PHP126
Community Pharmacist Perceptions of Generic Medicines: A Survey
in Tehran
Mehralian G 1, Noee F 2, Yousefi N 1, Peiravian F 1
1Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, School of Pharmacy, Tehran, Iran, 2Azad
University, Tehran, Iran
.
.
.
.
Pharmaceutical expenditure as has been increasingly grown during the last decades
so that policy makers have paid more and more attention to develop strategies
to deal with this challenging issue. Pharmacists play an important role in health
continuum to implement such strategies through dispensing and delivering generic
medicines to consumers. So, the main objective of this study was to explore the perception of Iranian pharmacists regarding generic substitution, and also to explore
how Iranian pharmacists think about patients’ role, physicians’ role and government
role in generic substitution. A cross sectional descriptive study involving the entire
population of Tehran community pharmacies (n = 2000) was performed using a
self-administrated anonymous questionnaire. A total of 1205 questionnaires were
returned indicating a response rate of 60%. Regarding to the first section, 62% of
participants agreed that pharmacists should be given right to generic substitution, and 45% viewed that the generic medicine are bioequivalent with brand ones.
Majority of the respondents (73.6%) stated that, they do substitution once generic
medicine is available. However, they think that patients, physicians and government
have important role in generic substitution. More than half (75.5%) of pharmacists
believed physicians’ prescription behavior highly influenced by the marketing
and promotion activities of foreign companies. 93% of respondents pointed to full
coverage of generic medicines by providers as a strategy to generic substitution.
Summary, evidences indicated that Iranian pharmacists have good insights regarding implementation and promotion of generic substitution strategy.
PHP127
Building A “High-Alert/High Risk Medications Reminder System” To
Improve Patient Safety
Kao L C
Mackay Memorial Hospital, Taipei, Taiwan
.
.
Objectives: This paper was aimed to introduce how we developed a “high-alert/
high risk medications reminder system” operated in the computer system to
improve medication safety in our hospital. Methods: This reminder system was
designed in a 2,400-bed health institute with 2,000 nurses, consisting of 12 nursing
divisions and 75 units. The new module was added to the current BCMA system with
VB. net. The functions of this computer system include seven steps. Results: A
satisfaction and cognition survey on the application of the new, computerized “highalert/ high risk medications reminder system” was done to MICU nurses (N= 36). The
survey response rate was 100%. The results showed high rate of positive support
on the new system due to easy to access and easy to learn. The satisfactory rate
comparing the old paper form system and the new computer system was 62.8% vs.
96.1%. More importantly, the “high-alert/high risk medications reminder system”
appeared to reduce the administration error rate from 5 cases in 2011 to 0 cases
in 2012. Conclusions: Our early experience showed that an efficient and userfriendly “High-Alert/High Risk Medications Reminder System” could be helpful for
medical staffs to improve medication safety although a longer follow-up time to
evaluate the efficacy of the computerized system is still needed before a final conclusion can be established. In addition, we are also keen to investigate whether this
system could reduce the waste of time, expenditure, and manpower in a medical
center in our future study.
PHP128
Cost-Effectiveness of Telemedicine: Lessons To Learn From An
International Review
Bongiovanni-Delarozière I 1, Le Goff-Pronost M 2, Rapp T 3
1French National Authority of Health (HAS), Saint Denis La Plaine, France, 2Telecom Bretagne,
Brest, Brittany, France, 3University of Paris Descartes, Paris, France
.
.
.
Objectives: At the global level the large deployment of telemedicine raises needs
for cost-effectiveness evaluations. The objective of this literature review is to explore
to what extend telemedicine innovations that were implemented in many countries
were cost-effective. Specifically, we explore whether the model used to evaluate the
cost-effectiveness can be adapted to the evaluation of telemedicine technologies.
So, what answers can a review of the international literature relating to the medico-economic evaluation of telemedicine provide? Methods: Following analytical
reading of 286 articles published between 2000 and 2013, 74 studies that implemented economic evaluation of telemedicine are analysed. Three axis of analysis
are considered: the act concerned by the telemedicine intervention, the medical
speciality, the economic evaluation method implemented. Results: The descriptive analysis showed significant heterogeneity in studies characteristics: economic
analysis method, telemedicine applications, medical specialities, and organisational
practices. The qualitative analysis underlines that most studies face methodological
issues and provide reduced evidence of the economic impact of the telemedicine
interventions. The telemedicine technologies are too individualised (by the context
and the organisation) to be evaluated using the standards of cost-effectiveness
analysis. Conclusions: This literature review did not allow proposing a classification for telemedicine practices identified as efficient, depending on the strategies
compared, field of application or speciality, types of telemedicine or an organisation
of care model. Despite all this, one focus can be the management of chronic diseases
that remains a central topic at the international level. The increase in the number
of medical specialities or fields of application concerned with telemedicine and
the increased volume of activity necessitate the dissemination of methodological
recommendations to promote the coherent development of economic evaluations.
Our literature review shows that there is need to develop innovative methods to
assess the cost-effectiveness of telemedicine technologies.
PHP129
Assessment of Validity of An Indicator Module In Identification of
adverse Drug Events in Patients of Medicine Department
Mallayasamy S , Shravya J , Mehta A , Vilakkathala R
Manipal University, Manipal, India
.
.
.
.
Objectives: An indicator is a clue that helps a health care organization to identify adverse drug events and assess the overall harm that occurs from medical
care within that organization. The main aim of the study was to investigate use
of an indicator list for identification of adverse events in the health care setting
studied. Methods: The study was a prospective observational study in a tertiary
care teaching hospital. The study mainly involves the review of medical records of
patients in general medicine department who were admitted due to drug related
problems with the help of trigger tool. When the presence of indicator is identified,
those cases were thoroughly scrutinized to identify adverse drug events and confirm
A426
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
such events in the light of available evidence and discussion with the treating physicians. Results: A total of 275 patients were included in the study for case review
as per the study criteria. Out of 275 patients, 150 patients had at least one indicator
(55%) and detection of adverse events was about 19.2%. Ratio of actual adverse event
detected to the presence of indicators was calculated as true positives. The average
true positive value of indictors was 33%. Average number of indicators present per
patient was determined to be 3.82. The harm categorization was carried out for
the observed adverse events as per National Coordinating Council for Medication
Error Reporting and Prevention (NCC MERP). Conclusions: The present study
showed that indicator tool could be used to review the cases prospectively and
identify adverse events. The identified indicators showed the pattern and frequency
of adverse events. Findings of our study supported the idea of making the indicator
tool as a practical aid for identification of adverse events.
PHP130
Barriers of Pharmaceutical Care in Community Pharmacies:
Evidences From Emerging Counteries
invited; 22 [8HQ/14LAF] tentatively agreed to participate and 15 [7HQ/8LAF] were
finally interviewed. Compared to LAF, HQ perceive the GVD more useful (HQ: 100%;
LAF:63%) and capable of positively influencing the final outcome of submissions
(HQ:86%; LAF:50%). Compared to HQ, LAF consider the GVD is delivered too late
(LAF:88%; HQ:13%) and that LAF should be involved in GVD development (LAF:100%;
HQ:71% but only for review). HQ consider that LAF involvement should be restricted
to the GVD review while LAF think they should participate in building the value
story (63%) or the economic model (37%). LAF prefer a modular GVD with each
component delivered separately (LAF: 88%; HQ: 66%), request national data to be
included (LAF:63%; HQ:14%), and cannot see the utility of new technologies for the
GVD (LAF:75%; HQ:33%). HQ and LAF expect the GVD to be updated continuously
(HQ:6%; LAF:75%) and be supplemented with phase IIIb data for potential resubmissions (HQ:100%; LAF:88%). Conclusions: HQ and LAF expectations differ particularly on how soon the GVD should be made available, the involvement of affiliates
during its development and the applicability of the GVD contents to local submissions. How to address these discrepancies to ensure alignment will be discussed.
Mehralian G 1, Javadi arjmand A 2, Ranghchian M 1, Peiravian F 1
1Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, School of Pharmacy, Tehran, Iran, 2Azad
University, Tehran, Iran
PHP133
Management of Crises and Risks in German Hospitals - Factors
Influencing Medication Errors
The pharmaceutical care concept has been popular in the world during past decades, but it did not reach well to its maturity in some countries, so the investigation
on barriers to the implementation of the pharmaceutical care in these countries
would be great of interest. Objectives: The aim of the study was to identify and
prioritize barriers to the provision of pharmaceutical care in Iranian community
pharmacies based on Tehran community pharmacists’ perceptions. Setting The present study was conducted with participation of pharmacists working in community
pharmacies settled in Tehran, the capital city of Iran. Methods: A cross-sectional
descriptive study was performed using an anonymous questionnaire between
August and November 2013. 505 community pharmacists expressed their perceptions on items by a 5-point Likert-type scale. Besides descriptive analysis, data was
also analyzed through structural equation modeling. Main outcome measured was the
importance perceived by community pharmacists in the case of 5 area including
resources, attitude and vision, education and training, skills, regulatory and environmental issues. Results: Five major dimensions included in the survey instrument
were confirmed by confirmatory factor analysis. According to the model developed
based on pharmacists’ opinions, lack of pharmacists’ skills and lack of appropriate
regulation and environment are the two most important barriers of the provision of
pharmaceutical care, and the least important is lack of resources. Conclusions:
Findings of the present study showed that importance of various barriers vary from
country to country based on the pharmacists’ perceptions, and corrective actions
should be made accordingly.
Draheim M 1, Flessa S 2, Glasberg R 1, Hartmann M 1, Schermuly C 1, Stanchev V 1, Tamm G 1,
Hessel F P 1
1SRH University Berlin, Berlin, Germany, 2University Medicine Greifswald, Greifswald, Germany
.
.
.
.
PHP131
Costs and Effectiveness of the Mediguide Technology in the
Conditions of the Czech Republic
Jurickova I , Jarosova V
Czech Technical University in Prague, Kladno, Czech Republic
.
.
Objectives: MediGuide technology is designed to monitor the position of diagnostic and therapeutic catheters equipped with a sensor MediGuide and navigation in
vascular or cardiac intervention in the environment of electro-physiological laboratory. MediGuide compared to conventional technology, offers the 3D display on the
live fluoroscopy or recorded background, radiation burden reduction, fluoroscopy
time and total time performance. The aim of this thesis is to analyze the clinical and cost effectiveness of new technologies MediGuide in the Czech Republic.
Results of the analysis are being compared to the studies of the German Cardiac
where technology is positively evaluated. Methods: The evaluation method is
cost-effectiveness analysis, which compares technology system MediGuide to a
comparator angiography Siemens Artis Zee. Value of the effect was determined by
TOPSIS in which they were entered weight values obtained by Saaty method of pair
comparison by group of experts. The sum of direct costs includes costs associated
with the operation of both technologies. Calculated values of costs and effects were
achieved in incremental ICER assessment ratio, fixing the amount of costs per unit of
effect. Results: More appreciated criteria in Saaty method were: safety and effectiveness of the technology. The fundamental values of the following criteria in this
method were used: radiation burden, which in the Czech Republic reached values
using conventional technology 575±511μ Gy. m2 and in Germany 14,453±7,403μ Gy.
m2, fluoroscopy time values for Czech Republic 7.5±4.5min; Germany 34±9min and
total time performance of Czech Republic 148±91 min; Germany 157±51min. The
cost of power at the treatment of 100 patients was in the first year to CZK 181,711;
MediGuide under the same conditions CZK 276,765. Conclusions: Manufacturer
of MediGuide values technology as an effective, safe and value-added reduce the
radiation burden of the patient, fluoroscopy time and shorten the overall time performance.
PHP132
Can A Global Value Dossier Meet Headquarters and Affiliates’s
Expectations?
Kooreman P J 1, Casamayor M 2, Schuchardt M 1, Van Engen A 1
Consulting, Hoofddorp, The Netherlands, 2Quintiles Consulting, Barcelona, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In German hospitals there is a need for optimized crisis- and risk
management. About one third of all hospital-acquired patient damages are due to
medication errors. The aim of our interdisciplinary project “Risk Management in
Hospitals” is to analyze the behavior of the various key players in the fields of medical care, human resources, supply and IT-systems in the context of various simulated risk scenarios as well as to develop adequate risk management tools. In this
abstract, the first results on medication errors are presented. Methods: Through
a network of experts, systematic literature searches and expert workshops, the five
most relevant crises from different disciplines (medical, HR, supply and IT) were
identified and specified. In a standardized survey among German hospital managers
further data were collected on these crises, their management and influencing factors. The results on medication errors presented here are based on the survey data
using a linear regression model. Results: The analysis was based on fully completed questionnaires by 97 German hospitals. 70% of the hospitals reported that
crises due to medical errors occurred in the last 5 years, which could not be handled
with established risk management tools. Although the crisis-appearance was lower
in private hospitals (28%) compared to publicly funded (31%) and nonprofit (41%)
hospitals, this difference was not significant. We recognized that a high frequency
in the occurrence of medical errors was significantly associated with a lower evaluation of risk management issues (e.g. the presence of a staff member responsible
for risk management, scenario analysis and crises trainings). Conclusions: Our
study confirms that German hospitals have to expand their targeted risk management activities in order to prevent the occurrence of hospital crises especially
due to medical and medication errors. All survey results will be incorporated in a
decision-making and benchmarking-tool for hospital managers to improve crisis
management in German hospitals.
PHP134
Comparison of Expected Versus Actual Cost Consequence Of
Reimbursed Drugs in the Netherlands Between 2009 and 2013
Chatterjee A 1, Tempelaar S 1, Verheggen B 2
International, York, UK, 2Pharmerit International, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
.
.
.
1Pharmerit
Objectives: A Budget Impact Analysis (BIA) analyses the financial consequence
associated with the uptake of a new treatment option in the market; which can
impact planning and forecasting and influence changes to pharmaceutical and
health care budgets. Therefore, BIA forms a key consideration of the Dutch Health
Care Insurance Board (ZiNL) when making a reimbursement decision regarding a
new treatment intervention. The current analysis investigates consistent trends
observed between the predicted budget versus the actual budget spent on reimbursed drugs in the Netherlands. Methods: Forecasted data specific to new drugs
reimbursed under list 1B between 2009 and 2013 were extracted from drug reimbursement reports available from the ZiNL website. Actual data of the selected drugs
were extracted from the Drug and medical devices Information Project database
(GIP database). Per year and cumulative (between 1 and 5 years) data on total drug
cost, total number of users and total cost per patient were compared between the
forecasted values and the actual values. Results: In total 20 drugs were included in
the analysis, of which 12 presented data for 3 years or more. Compared to the actual
data, the expected total drug cost was overestimated for 14 drugs, total number of
users was overestimated for 12 drugs and for 10 drugs the total cost per patient was
overestimated. Total number of users was most accurately estimated, presenting a
pooled cumulative overestimation of 5 times the actual number of users. Total drug
cost was least accurately estimated (pooled cumulative overestimation of 13 times
the actual total cost), since the total drug cost includes the uncertainty reflected
in both the total number of users and total cost per patient. Conclusions: The
expected budget of 1B drugs in reimbursement submission reports generally overestimated the actual budget presented in the GIP database between 2009 and 2013.
1Quintiles
Objectives: Gaining reimbursement is a complex process that involves generating the right evidence and communicating it successfully to stakeholders. To
ensure alignment of the value story across countries and help affiliates in their
local submissions, headquarters (HQ) develop the global value dossier (GVD). We
have investigated whether the current GVD meets HQ and local affiliates (LAF)
expectations. Methods: Pharma HEOR and market access professionals from HQ
and LAF were invited to participate in telephone interviews to assess their views
on current use and utility of the GVD. Results were analyzed to identify differences
and alignments between HQ and LAF. Results: 43 [16HQ/27LAF] professionals were
PHP135
Predicted Versus Actual Budget Impact of High-Cost Drugs In
Ireland
Fogarty E 1, Barry M 2
1National Centre for Pharmacoeconomics, Dublin, Ireland, 2HSE Medicines Management
Programme, Dublin, Ireland
.
.
Objectives: Budget impact analyses are an essential component in the economic
evaluation of new drugs. These analyses allow the health care payer to assess the
likely impact of the drug on the payer’s budget, and to plan for short- and long- term
A427
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
resource allocation. The objective of this study is to compare the company-predicted
budget impact with the actual budget impact of high-cost drugs reimbursed in
Ireland. Methods: All drugs submitted to the health service executive (HSE, health
care payer in Ireland) for reimbursement under the high-tech drug scheme (a scheme
used to administer high cost drugs) from 2009 to 2012 were included in the review.
Company estimates of the likely budget impact of the drug in 2013 were extracted
from submissions and compared with actual expenditure in 2013 from the health service executive-primary care reimbursement service (HSE-PCRS). Only drugs for which
budget impact estimates were available and which were reimbursed by the HSE in
2013 were included in the analysis. Results: Ten drugs were included in the analysis,
including six cancer drugs, two immunomodulators for multiple sclerosis and rheumatoid arthritis, and two orphan drugs for cystic fibrosis and idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura. The cumulative expenditure on these drugs in 2013 was € 55.8 million
compared with a predicted gross budget impact of € 53.4 million, representing a € 2.4
million underestimate in company submissions. The most significant underestimate
related to the drug for multiple sclerosis (€3.4 million) while the biggest overestimate
related to the orphan drug for cystic fibrosis (€2.9 million). Conclusions: Company
submissions have been shown to both under- and over-estimate budget impact predictions. It is important that budget impact estimates are as realistic as possible
in order to effectively inform decisions on resource allocation or reimbursement.
PHP136
Redel Study: Differences in Reimbursement Delays in Cee Countries
Komáromi T , Bagi P , Salfer B
Healthware Consulting Ltd., Budapest, Hungary
.
.
.
Objectives: The dynamic of the reimbursement politics shows a very different pattern in different countries. The REDEL study examined the elapsed time
from marketing authorization to the starting date of reimbursement of the original medicines in Central and Eastern European Countries (Austria, Bulgaria, the
Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland, Romania, Slovakia and
Slovenia). Methods: The basis of comparison were 216 products and their ATC
codes selected from the database of the European Medicines Agency which were
granted a marketing authorization between 1st January 2007 and 1st July 2013. In
the case of these products the research studied the dates, when countries adopted
them into their reimbursement system. The adoption was the subject of the study
between 1st January 2010 and 1st July 2013. The following three different indicators
were calculated in the study: REDEL - the delay between marketing authorization
date and reimbursement date; INNREIMB - the number of reimbursed INNs according to a specific country or MAH; SR - Success Rate as the ratio of reimbursed
INNs to examined INNs. Results: While an average of 403 days elapsed between
the authorization and the starting date of reimbursement in Slovenia (mean of 76
products), the same period was 1295 days in Poland (mean of 21 adoptions). The
average is 632 days. The top three in the ranking of REDEL of active substances
(ATC 1st level – anatomical main group) were dermatologicals (D), respiratory system (R) and Muscolo-skeletal system (M). Conclusions: The results show that
even threefold differences exist among the studied countries with regards to the
reimbursement delay. An average of almost two years elapse until a producer can
have the given product adopted into the reimbursement system in a country (the
REDEL steadily increasing in the studied period, while the number of reimbursed
products decreasing).
PHP137
Black Box Amnog Rebates: What Is Driving the Price in the
Negotiation With The Gkv-Spitzenverband?
Freiberg M 1, Pruefert A 2, Hepp S 3, Schalber T 3
1Quintiles Consulting, Neu-Isenburg, Germany, 2Quintiles Consulting, Hoofddorp, The
Netherlands, 3Quintiles Commercial, Mannheim, Germany
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Price negotiations of a pharmaceutical company with the German
GKV-Spitzenverband (Association of Statutory Health Insurance) after early benefit assessments can be considered a black box. This analysis aims at providing
insights on the parameters that drive the final rebate to predict future pricing
decisions and to enhance the negotiation strategy and therefore secure optimal
pricing. Methods: Published benefit assessments from the G-BA (Federal Joint
Committee) website and the products’ prices as listed in the German pharmacy
selling system were used as a basis for research. The latter allows a comparison of
launch prices (manufacturer selling prices) and prices after the negotiation with
the GKV-Spitzenverband (reimbursement prices). The following parameters were
analyzed: Rebate size, rebate by added benefit rating, and rebate by therapeutic
area. Results: By June 2014, 36 products had been through price negotiation, with
the rebate of the launch price ranging from 5-71% (average: 25%). The rebate of products with considerable benefit rating ranged from 10-35% (average: 21%). Products
with minor added benefit reached rebates between 5-48% averaging at 23%. Products
with no quantifiable benefit yielded rebates ranging from 11-44% (average: 24%).
Products with no additional benefit had a rebate between 5-71% averaging at 27%.
Products in oncology yielded an average rebate of 27%., followed by endocrinology
(23%), central nervous system (22%), cardiovascular (21%), and infectious diseases
(16%). Conclusions: The better the added benefit rating of a product, the lower
is its negotiated rebate. However, only marginal average differences were observed.
The rebate per therapeutic area did not reveal obvious patterns: Assessments for
oncology products resulted in above average rebates, while rebates for products for
infectious diseases were far below the average.
PHP139
Comparison of Post-Authorisation Measures From Regulatory
Authorities With Additional Evidence Requirements From HTA
Bodies in Germany
Ruof J 1, Staab T R 1, Slawik L 2, Orben T 3, Bosch S 4
1Roche Pharma, Grenzach-Wyhlen, Germany, 2Bristol-Myers Squibb GmbH und Co. KGaA,
Munich, Germany, 3vfa, Berlin, Germany, 4Bayer Business Service GmbH, Leverkusen, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Regulatory authorities such as the European Medicines Agency
(EMA) can make marketing authorisation contingent upon post-authorisation
measures (PAMs) so as to fill in information gaps in efficacy and safety.
PAMs are generally formulated in agreement with manufacturers, and evaluate clinical hypotheses in an ethical and practical way. In Germany, novel
medicines must also undergo an early benefit assessment (EBA) by the Federal
Joint Committee (G-BA) following marketing authorisation. G-BA may demand
additional evidence in order to formulate an opinion on added therapeutic
value, which then leads to determination of reimbursement. We compared
selected PAMs with the corresponding G-BA demands to see if they were similar. Methods: Medicines that received a restricted EBA from G-BA before 15
June 2014 were evaluated and compared with their marketing authorisations by
EMA. PAMs from EMA, and EBA restrictions from G-BA, were assessed in terms
of their required additional evidence. Results: Twenty-eight percent of all 79
medicines assessed by G-BA received a restricted EBA. Only nine of those had
obligations for PAMs. Four of these were conditional approvals or approval under
exceptional circumstances, while five received unconditional marketing authorisation. G-BA justified restricted EBAs for the four conditional approvals based
upon agreement with the EMA opinion. For the five unconditional approvals,
G-BA required considerably more information than EMA. The additional evidence
requested by the two bodies rarely corresponded to one another. EBA restrictions were more influenced by transferability to the German health care context,
choice of subgroups and appropriate comparator, than were the corresponding
EMA PAMs. Conclusions: G-BA often demands more evidence than specified
in EMA PAMs from medicines granted unconditional approval. Although PAMs
are discussed and agreed between EMA and manufacturers, G-BA demands and
restrictions are not. The possibility for such discussions with G-BA would be an
improvement for the future.
PHP140
Standard Costs for Health Economic Evaluations:
An International Comparison
Mostardt S , Sandmann F G , Seidl A , Zhou M , Gerber-Grote A U
Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care (IQWiG), Cologne, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Country-specific lists of standard costs can reduce the variability of
results in health economic evaluations that are attributed to differences in employed
data sources and approaches for defining the resource use and unit prices. Moreover
they potentially speed up the conduct of health economic evaluations. We aim to
investigate which HTA agency officially recognizes and applies a standard cost list
and, where such list exists, explore pre-specified procedural and methodological
aspects. Methods: Reviewing all national pharmacoeconomic guidelines published
on the ISPOR Website http://www.ispor.org/PEguidelines/index.asp in English (i.e., 30
out of 37). Standard cost lists mentioned in the guidelines were, inter alia, compared on
the following aspects: i) objective, ii) authorship, iii) release interval, iv) data sources,
v) costing perspective, vi) cost categories, and vii) health-state costing. Results: Out
of the 30 pharmacoeconomic guidelines available in English, a standard cost list was
officially recognized and applied by 4 HTA agencies (Canada, England, Australia and
the Netherlands). All 4 lists aim to reduce heterogeneity between health economic
evaluations in order to increase the comparability. Compiling the standard cost lists
was commissioned to external scientific institutions in all 4 countries. Updates of the
lists have been published periodically, spanning from anually (e.g. England) to when
required for methodological reasons or to ensure currency (e.g. the Netherlands).
Data collection was primarily based on claims data and/or official statistics; in the
Netherlands, published research and expert opinions can be employed (for estimating
resource use). Costs were derived from a payer perspective. Both direct and indirect
costs were stated, except for Australia (only direct costs). No country presented costs
in relation to health states. Conclusions: Standard cost lists are mentioned in
13% of the pharmacoeconomic guidelines available in English. The 4 lists conicide
on many procedural and methodological aspects. Heterogeneity arises mainly from
country-specific costs.
PHP141
Regulatory Approval To Patient Access, An Evaluation of Eu5 And Us
National Timing Differences: An Update
Mycka J 1, Dellamano R 2, Lobb W 1, Dalal N 1, Pereira E 1, Dellamano L 2, Sagaydachnaya O 1
1Medical Marketing Economics, LLC, Montclair, NJ, USA, 2ValueVector, Milan, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Examine the time between regulatory approval and launch/pricing and
reimbursement (P&R) approval in the US and EU5 countries. Methods: Examined
new molecular entities, formulations and combinations with EMA approval between
Jan 2009 and May 2014. Additional analysis of products launched between April 2013
and May 2014. Time comparison for general medicines vs. orphan/oncology indications was made including shifts over time. Data gathered from: USA: FDA approval
date, wholesale; acquisition cost effective date; UK/Germany: Product availability/
introduction; France: P&R decision (Agrément collectivités/date published in Journal
Officiel); Italy: First Official Gazette P&R Decree publication; and Spain: Date of
commercialization. Results: Overall, for launches between Jan 2009 and May 2014,
the average time from FDA approval to US launch was 6 weeks (oncology 4 weeks;
orphan drugs 2 weeks). Across the EU5, Germany remains the fastest to market.
Analysis of new products launched between April 2013 and May 2014 shows time
to access in Spain has increased vs. the previous 5 years (75 vs. 54 weeks). Limited
numbers of orphan drugs have completed full Spanish P&R process with 106 weeks
to launch far exceeding all drugs (75 weeks). Italian average time to complete P&R is
69 weeks, while average time to be listed in class C-nn, without national reimbursement, is only 18 weeks. UK average time to oncology launch appears short (16 vs.
20 weeks), however HTA assessments often mean significant access delays. French
orphan drugs assessment is faster vs. all drugs (46 vs. 50 weeks). Conclusions:
The time to P&R post-regulatory approval increased ~3 weeks in Italy and ~21 weeks
in Spain for products launched in the latest year vs. all drugs with EMA approvals
between Jan 2009 and Dec 2013.
A428
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PHP142
Impact of Chronic Diseases on Health Care Expenditures:
A Multivariate Linear Model From Pharmaceutical
Reimbursement Data
Karakaya G , Van Tielen R , Vanrillaer V , Umbach I
MLOZ, Brussels, Belgium
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The aim of the study is to analyze the burden of chronic diseases
on public health care expenditures using pharmaceutical data regarding about 2
million individuals. Methods: Data come from the administrative database of
the third Belgian health insurance funds. Without explicit diagnoses of diseases
in the database, chronic diseases are mainly estimated using drugs prescription
(reimbursed medications only) for a treatment of at least 90 days/year. A multivariate linear model based on the OLS method is used to analyse the impact of
23 chronic diseases on health care expenditures, while controlling for age, sex,
marital and social status, share of hospital expenditures, residential areas and year
of death. Results: Monthly average health care costs for people with one or more
chronic conditions is 6 times greater than the ones without any chronic conditions
(€ 423 vs. € 71). All chronic diseases (except psoriasis) have a significant impact on
health care (at 1% level). The last months of life, developing or living with cancer,
chronic renal failure, rare disease and mental disorder are the factors having the
greatest impact on monthly reimbursed health care expenditures. All things being
equal, a person at the end of life costs more than € 2,236 per month to the health
insurance compared to a person not at the end of life. Respectively this amounts to
€ 3,557, € 3,008, € 2,042 and € 1,151 for people living with a rare disease, chronic renal
failure, mental disorder and cancer. Conclusions: Results found in this study
are similar to those observed in other countries. Our findings show in particular
that chronic diseases significantly drive health care expenditures. Using secondary
data allows to classify chronic diseases according to the financial weights while
controlling for characteristics of the analysed population. Results highlight the high
financial burden of chronic diseases for public health care expenditures and allow
decision-makers to take appropriate public health measures.
PHP143
The Effect of China’s Basic Medical Insurance Schemes on Health
Service Utilization
Lee C 1, Sun H 2, Guan Q 3, Wasserman M 3
1Double Helix Consulting, London, UK, 2Nanyang Technological University, Singapore, 3Double
Helix Consulting, Singapore
.
.
.
.
Objectives: China’s medical insurance coverage surpassed 95% nationwide by 2011
under three basic medical insurance schemes UEBMI, URBMI and NCMS, partly due
to the government’s heavy investment since 2009. It is still inconclusive whether
the increased coverage rate has improved access to care. Past studies using the
China Health and Nutrition Survey (CHNS) focused on data before 2009. This study
investigates effects of the three different insurance schemes on health services
utilization after the 2009 new health reform. Methods: An analysis was conducted
on 2009 and 2011 data from the CHNS (sampling totally 23202 people from 9 provinces). To control for confounding factors, propensity score matching models were
developed controlling for relevant factors such as age, gender, income, educational
level and health status. The level difference of health service utilization was compared between each insured and the uninsured group. Attempts were also made to
compare average treatment costs per episode; however the data set is incomplete
for statistical analysis. Results: In the matched samples, the UEBMI group on
average used 2.7% less outpatient services (p< 0.05) but 1.2% more inpatient services than the uninsured group (p< 0.05). By contrast, the URBMI group was more
likely to pay both outpatient and inpatient visits than the uninsured, although both
improvements were not statistically significant (p> 0.05). People in the NCMS group
were 5.6% less likely to use outpatient services (p< 0.05); they also tended to use
inpatient services less (p> 0.05). Conclusions: Access to care across the varying
schemes is not equal. Differences between the UE/URBMI and the uninsured may
be resulted from different health statuses, but also they could reflect the tendency
among the employed to delay care seeking. The relative underutilization of care by
the rural population points again to high co-payment requirement. More research
is necessary to understand the interplay of care infrastructure and individual care
utilization in China.
PHP144
Price Negotiation For Pharmaceuticals in Germany: High Influence
Of Eu Price Weighting Method
Neubauer A S , Voss P, Minartz C , Gmeiner A , Neubauer G
IfG Institute for Health Economics (www.ifg-muenchen.com), München, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To investigate quantitatively, which influence the chosen EU price
weighting method has in a theoretical framework model of pharmaceuticals price
negotiations. Methods: Three components theoretically determine the reimbursed price of a pharmaceutical under AMNOG conditions in Germany: 1) the
level and certainty of added benefit, 2) prices of comparable pharmaceuticals
in Germany and 3) the weighted EU price level (post rebates). In a theoretical
model the influence of various weighting methods of EU price levels on resulting reimbursement was investigated. Results: Several weighting models for EU
prices are theoretically feasible. When defining the 15 EU basket countries the
German arbitration board had considered a weighting based on volume, approximated by country population size and an adjustment by purchasing power parity.
Operationalisation of each of those factors showed a significant influence on
results in our simulation: in several example cases a population and PPP health
basket (Eurostat) was set as base case. Using a weighting based on GDP (in PPP)
instead, resulted in a ~10-15% increase and based on Eurostat general goods
basket (in PPP) in a ~20-25% increase in the calculated average EU price level.
Actual observed EU drug volumes appeared to rather support such cases than
the weighting based on the Eurostat PPP health basket. Which currency exchange
rate was used, e.g. yearly vs. daily, Eurostat vs. other sources, had only a minor
influence in most constellations. The launched country basket showed an overall
high impact, with a frequently high importance of the U. K. as an EU country being
launched relatively early. Conclusions: The chosen weighting method of EU
prices has a high impact on results of EU average price, which is an important
component of German price negotiations. No undisputed method exists at the
time of market entry.
PHP145
A Payers Perspective to Pharmaceutical Market Access:
Defining Market Access
Sendyona S
Creativ-Ceutical, London, UK
.
Objectives: The payer’s perspective is considered after a drug has been
granted market access and launched. This is often too late as payers may not
want to reimburse expensive drugs, especially if the current gold standard is
cost effective compared to alternatives. This is mostly encountered if the drug
was, during the clinical trials, compared to sub-standard comparators. This
research aims to establish whether there are interventions to consider during a
drug development cycle, and how, by using Key Intervention Points, a drug can
be successful in the market. The first in a series of questions aims to define what
exactly market access is. Methods: A literature review was conducted on Ovid
MEDLINE to establish a whether a clear and internationally validated definition
of market access has been proposed. Included were articles and/or reviews concerning market access of pharmaceuticals for human use published from January
1999 to present day. Results: Market access can be thought of as either gaining regulatory approval from bodies such as Food and Drug Administration or
European Medicines Agency to make a drug available to patients, or as developing a drug that achieves blockbuster status through successful reimbursement,
either through a high number of sales, or a higher-than-competitor premium
price. Regulatory approval and reimbursement are often thought of as being inherently different, yet both share the central principle of balancing the benefits and
harms in deciding availability of drugs. The main difference between regulatory
approval and reimbursement is the scope of benefits and harm, and the population they consider. Conclusions: Market access is difficult to define, with
different opinions and perspectives. There currently lacks a clear, internationally
validated method of defining exactly what it market access entails, and what it
means to have successfully achieved it. There is a need to definitively define this
important concept.
PHP146
Market Access Pathway for Medical Nutrition in Europe and The Us
Chevrou Séverac H 1, Droeschel D 2, Walzer S 2
1Takeda Pharmaceuticals International, Zurich, Switzerland, 2MArS Market Access & Pricing
Strategy GmbH, Weil am Rhein, Germany
.
.
.
Objectives: This analysis aims at presenting different market access pathways of Medical Nutrition (MN) products in the US, France, Germany and the
UK. Methods: Systematic review of submission processes for MN and food
for special medical purpose (FSMP), combined with experience of the authors
from previous research on health economics, Market Access and reimbursement. Results: When considering MN delivered in the ambulatory care setting,
only in France, innovative MN presenting with therapeutic value faces the medical device reimbursement process. In the UK, the process is handled by the ACBS
and focus mainly on clinical outcome and safety; additionally this process sets
a reimbursed price. In the US and Germany, there are reimbursed categories for
MN linked to composition of the product and dedicated to patients with inability
to have their nutritional needs covered by normal food intake (set by CMS in the
US and G-BA in Germany). Creating new reimbursed categories linked to new
MN either bringing innovative therapeutic value or targeting new disease area is
highly difficult in all countries. For MN delivered in hospital settings, products
delivered enterally or orally are mainly covered by hospital budget. The budget
can be either from the hospital’s kitchen for thickened and thickening products,
under the diagnosis-related group funding scheme related to each countries, by
the nutritionist budget (mainly UK and US) or by the hospital’s pharmacy budget
for specialties. For standard products, access is obtained based on tenders. In
long-term care and nursing home, coverage and funding are more heterogeneous: they vary from highly regulated reimbursed scheme based on composition of
the products and disease area to per diem fee per patient covering both food and
MN. Conclusions: The market access pathways for granting reimbursement
or coverage of the medical nutrition category are very heterogeneous between
the analyzed countries.
PHP147
The Reimbursement of Expensive Drugs In Hospitals in Western
European Countries
Falk K , Brown A , Murray G , Martensson M
Abacus International, Manchester, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Over the past decade increasing numbers of expensive drugs have
entered the market, placing a financial burden on hospitals in particular. Many
high-cost therapies require use or at least initiation in the hospital setting. Many
European countries reimburse hospitals via diagnosis-related group (DRG) systems.
However, DRG systems are often insufficient to cover the costs of expensive drugs.
Here we assess how expensive drugs are funded in hospitals across markets, what
the requirements are, and the process of additional funds being granted. Methods:
Publicly available documents, governmental guidelines and regulations were
assessed to understand the different processes and requirements expensive drugs
need to meet to receive additional funding. Countries included were the UK, France,
Germany, Italy, Spain, the Netherlands, Sweden, Denmark, Switzerland, Austria and
Portugal. Results: In all included countries, hospital treatments are reimbursed
via DRG systems, and most provide additional funding for expensive drugs. There
A429
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
is overlap in the criteria to qualify for funding. Many countries consider drugs for
additional funding when a drug can be used in more than one indication and cannot be grouped to a specific DRG. Other criteria identified relate to, for example,
drug prices and indications. Some countries grant additional reimbursement for
drugs prior to assessment by a national reimbursement process, while others only
grant additional reimbursement after the drug has been available for a certain
period of time and funding decisions are based on historical data. In most countries,
additional reimbursement is considered annually. Hospitals and expert groups can
suggest additional reimbursement for expensive drugs to the responsible authority. Conclusions: Many countries have adapted to the need for additional funding
for expensive drugs, and have established systems to grant this funding to hospitals.
There are differences in criteria to qualify for, and timelines for receiving, additional
funding after drugs are launched.
PHP148
Pay-For-Performance: Balancing Cost and Care
Ziskind M A 1, Pierce C A 2
1Johnson & Johnson Healthcare Systems Inc., Horsham, PA, USA, 2The Resource Group, Richfield,
OH, USA
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Initiatives aimed at improving both the quality and efficiency of United
States health care are commonly grouped under the broad category of “pay-forperformance” (P4P) programs. Typically these programs award bonuses to providers
that attain pre-determined quality and cost goals, but may also impose financial
penalties on those that fail to meet those goals. Fueled by the Affordable Care Act,
P4P programs have recently expanded significantly within the public sector and
are expected to grow. This project was designed to review Medicare P4P cost measures, discuss the implications for provider prescribing patterns, and recommend
possible alternatives. Methods: Two P4P programs, both well known under the
health reform law and having potential to impact a large portion of the Medicare
population, were evaluated: 1) Accountable Care Organizations (ACO), and 2) the
Physician Value Based Payment Modifier (VBPM). Each program’s cost measure
components and calculation methodologies were isolated, described and evaluated for the potential to influence prescribing patterns. Results: Cost measures
for the ACO and VBPM programs are based on payments made under Medicare Part
A (Hospital Insurance) and Medicare Part B (Supplemental Insurance) but do not
include Medicare Part D (Prescription Drug Benefit) costs. Whether performance
is measured against the provider’s historic costs, or compared to national benchmarks, only Medicare Parts A and B costs are included. Conclusions: Medicare
Part D costs are not included in the cost measure calculation, thereby eliminating
prescription drug expense from the performance rating. This methodology may
encourage providers to shift Part B drug costs to Part D, thus limiting patient access
to therapies that may only be covered under Medicare Part B.
PHP149
Review of Pricing And Reimbursement Systems in South-Eastern
Europe
Zibelnik N 1, Odeyemi I A 2
1Astellas Pharma South-East Europe, Ljubjana, Slovenia, 2Astellas Pharma Europe Ltd,
Chertsey, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: To provide an up-to-date description and comparative analysis of pricing and reimbursement policies in South-Eastern Europe (SEE), and to identify factors influencing reimbursement decisions. Methods: Payers and decision makers
in Slovenia, Croatia, Romania and Bulgaria were interviewed by questionnaire. An
additional literature survey covered country-specific legislation and publications
(PubMed 2009–2014), and relevant documents from web sources including national
hospital insurance funds, drug agencies, ministries of health, Eurostat, pharmacoeconomic and outcomes research conference proceedings, the Organisation for Economic
Co-operation and Development, and Business Monitor International. Results: The
four countries spent 5.1%–8.8% of gross domestic product on health in 2012. Price
controls are commonly used, applied via negotiation with marketing authorisation
holders or indirectly through the application of copayments. Key policies are based
on international and internal reference pricing. Bulgaria, Romania and Slovenia
base pricing on the lowest manufacturing or retail price, while Croatia uses average
pricing. Reimbursement requires demonstration of clinical and economical benefits
over current standard therapy. When the importance of benefits are recognised and
recommendations from reference health technology assessment authorities in
Europe are published, budget impact analyses focusing on key drivers such as target
population and price are applied. Cost containment mechanisms are also applied,
including net price negotiation, rationing, decision postponement, payback, clawback and risk sharing, with the aim of protecting overall budgets. Legislative changes
to pricing and reimbursement systems are very common. Out-of-pocket expenses
in Romania and Bulgaria are among the highest in Europe, while the reimbursed:
retail price difference is largely covered by supplementary insurance in Slovenia and
Croatia. Conclusions: The middle/lower income SEE countries use reference pricing, and have some of the lowest prices in the European Union. Reimbursement of
innovative drugs is restricted, there are downward trends in pricing, and risk-sharing
agreements based on outcomes are finance-driven.
PHP150
Pricing and Reimbursement Environment For A Biologic Obtaining A
Licence In A Second Indication in Key European Countries
Ling C S 1, Balp M M 2, Bjoerk B 2, Quijano M 2, Heyes A E 1
1RTI Health Solutions, Manchester, UK, 2Novartis Pharma AG, Basel, Switzerland
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To gain a better understanding of the pricing and reimbursement processes and evidence requirements at national, regional, and local levels with regards
to a biologic obtaining a license in a second indication in the UK, France, Italy, and
Spain. Methods: In countries with a largely national system (UK, France), five
telephone interviews were conducted; as Spain and Italy also have local and regional
systems, 17 and 18 interviews, respectively, were conducted. Stakeholders included
payer-advising clinicians, hospital administrators and pharmacists, regional payers, and local payers. Results: In the UK and France, pricing and reimbursement
is agreed at a national level, with few restrictions at regional and local levels. In the
UK, NHS England is likely to be responsible for funding of new biologics and relies
on guidance from NICE before adopting a product in a new indication; therefore,
demonstrating cost-effectiveness is key. In France, the ASMR issued by the transparency commission is important; funding usually is through the groupe homogéne
de séjour. In addition to demonstrating clinical benefits, pharmacoeconomic studies may be required for high-cost drugs. In contrast, in Italy, although AIFA needs
to approve a new product on a national level, subsequent requirements vary by
region and sometimes specific location. Similarly, in Spain, once approved nationally, regions develop their own recommendations, and local decisions are made by
hospital formularies. Evidence requirements in Italy and Spain vary at national,
regional, and local levels. Conclusions: A biologic obtaining a license in a new
indication must undergo the same procedure as a new product. The process and
restrictions for biologics may be stricter than for other medications due to the
perceived high cost. The level of national, regional, and local requirements and
restrictions varies; it is important that appropriate evidence is submitted to decision makers at each level.
PHP151
Cost and Quantity Characteristics of Medical Devices In Slovakia
Malovecká I 1, Minariková D 1, Lehocká L 1, Foltan V 2
University, Bratislava, Slovak Republic, 2Faculty of Pharmacy, Comenius University,
Bratislava, Slovak Republic
.
.
.
.
1Comenius
Objectives: Medical devices, together with pharmacotherapy are supportive treatment of many acute and chronic diseases. The place of their dispensing and direct
sale is the dispenser of medical devices. Many medical devices are reimbursed from
public health insurance funds entirely, for others, particularly advanced functional
types of medical devices, there must the patient participate on the price or he can
buy them according own decision. Methods: The target of the work was to analyse
the data from paid databases of Slovak authority National Center for Health
Information that collects the outputs of provided health care services. The most
recent data were from 1.1. - 30.9.2014. Results: Referring to the Center for Health
Information until 30.9.2013 there were 226 registered establishments that sell medical
devices. Their specialization were dispenser of medical devices (n= 163), dispenser of
orthopedic devices (n=48) and dispenser of audioprotetic devices (n=15). Expenditure
of reimbursed medical devices from public health insurance funds amounted
n-monthly packaging= 8,8mil and n-monthly value= 12,7 mil €. The highest shares had the
group medical devices for incontinence and urinary retention (n-packages= 7,7 mil,
n-packages%= 86.9, n-values= 3,9 mil € , n-value%= 30.9), the group plasters and bandaging materials (n-packages=0,5 mil, n-packages%=6.1, n-values=2,6mil €, n-value%=10.2) and
medical devices for ostomates (n-packages=0,4 mil, n-packages%=4.6, n-values=1,6 mil €,
n-value%=8.1). Direct sale of medical devices to the patients reached n-monthly packaging=
0, 9 mil and n-monthly value=1,1mil €. The highest shares had the group medical devices
for incontinence and urinary retention (n-packages=5,7 mil, n-packages%=50.3, n-values=
2, 6 mil €, n-value%=26.2), the group plasters and bandaging materials (n-packages=3,5
mil, n-packages%= 30.9, n-values= 2,0 mil € , n-value%= 20.4) and medical devices for
diabetics (n-packages= 0,5 mil, n-packages%= 4.5, n-values= 0,7 mil € , n-value%= 7.3).
Conclusions: Medical devices are reimbursed frompublic health insurance funds
or paid by patient and their proportion constitutes 7: 1 in packages and 11: 1 in Eur.
PHP152
The Greek Health Care Reform After Troika’s Involvement: The
Potential Impact on Global Pricing and Access Strategy
Anastasaki E 1, Bradshaw S 1, Shah S 2
Solutions LLC, London, UK, 2Market Access Solutions LLC, Raritan, NJ, USA
.
.
.
1Market Access
Objectives: Troika’s measures to support Greece’s financial recovery have targeted all sectors of economy including health care. Since 2012, policy reforms have
changed the way health care is funded, managed and delivered, and how pharmaceuticals are priced, accessed and reimbursed. This study examines the changes
to the Greek system and tries to understand the wider possible impact on global
pricing and access strategies. Methods: To better understand the recent reforms
we conducted a literature review of public domain sources, including the Greek
Government Gazette, PubMed and other websites. Searches were conducted in
English and Greek-language, and materials were translated into English. From our
findings a road map diagram was developed, and this was validated by interviews
with health policy experts. Results: Part of troika’s campaign to reduce public
spending has seen the Greek government focus on pharmaceutical markets and
introduce policies to contain costs. The drug budget for 2014 has been cut to 2
billion euros, a billion lower than 2013. Considerable price cuts have been agreed
on both novel and generic agents on top of clawbacks and rebates for high cost
drugs. Prescribing is controlled through electronic prescription and physician budget
caps. Introduction of price-volume agreements and risk sharing schemes are being
considered, however the infrastructure to support implementation is still under
development. Demonstrating value by health economics and outcomes research
can still help manufacturers to achieve premiums. Conclusions: With a small
population and an ever-decreasing expenditure on health care, it is tempting to
overlook Greece when developing a product launch strategy. However, with Greek
drug prices being referenced by several EU and non-EU countries, ignoring Greece
may no longer be an option, especially when considering the indirect effect on the
big EU5 prices. Understanding the reforms and assessing the impact on launch
sequencing will be key in developing optimal pricing strategies.
PHP153
Swisshta Recommendation as an Optimal approach for Pragmatic
HTA Evaluations? An International Comparison
Walzer S , Droeschel D
MArS Market Access & Pricing Strategy GmbH, Weil am Rhein, Germany
.
.
A430
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: Switzerland’s regulation of prices for reimbursed drugs is based on
referencing across countries and within the therapeutic class for products with
comparators. The SwissHTA initiative involving all key stakeholders in the health
care systems (sickness funds, industry, physicians, academia, Kantons) has published consensus papers for new benefit criteria and measurements. Methods:
A comparison was executed comparing the new proposed criteria against benefit
assessments in HTA systems in Germany and the UK. Results: In terms of clinical
benefit assessment the suggestion by SwissHTA follows accepted evidence-based
methods. In comparison to Germany the Swiss approach suggests a pragmatic
application by applying disease specific standards. This disease focus allows also
accepting different levels of evidence given the characteristics of the disease. This
pragmatic approach allows Swiss decision-makers accepting lower evidence levels
at the time of launch (e.g. in case of comparison with non-Swiss standard-of-care)
coupled with a post-reimbursement commitment. The Swiss method looks similar to the medical benefit application by NICE. In terms of health economic (HE)
evaluations SwissHTA suggests focusing on technical efficiency instead of QALY
comparisons across the whole system as in the UK. Such an approach avoids the
application of arbitrarily defined cost-effectiveness thresholds. In Germany the HE
focus is solely based on cost comparisons. In terms of decision-making in Germany
the focus is based on an assessment of the available evidence against a theoretical maximum standard of evidence. In the UK coverage decisions are based on
cost-effectiveness assessments allowing for context-specific adjustments. In the
SwissHTA recommendation a multi-criteria decision-making should be applied
with an equal focus on all key aspects (e.g. clinical benefit, public relevance, social
preferences, etc.). Conclusions: In comparison to HTA systems in Germany and
UK the SwissHTA recommendations seems to be more pragmatic and would follow
a broader multi-criteria decision making approach.
PHP154
Product Quality Aspect in Reimbursement of Medical Devices:
Comparison of Turkey VersUS Europe
Seyhun O 1, Erdogan E 1, Can H 1, Erdol S 1, Guler I 2, Bayazit A 2
1Medtronic, Inc., Istanbul, Turkey, 2Turkish association of social security experts, Ankara, Turkey
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: FDA has long recognized that dramatic increase in adverse event
reports due to medical devices and recalls may reflect quality flaws. While some
of this increase can be explicated by FDA’s greater outreach emphasizing reporting
requirements, failures in product design and manufacturing process cause more
than half of all product recalls. Therefore, FDA’s concern regarding low quality products remains. In the EU, medical device pre-market quality is assured by CE mark
authorization. This regulation is the prerequisite for market registration also for
Turkey. However, due to heterogeneity and complexity of devices, manufacturers,
imported devices and multiple use environments, there is strong need for postmarket quality assurance. Methods: This study investigates whether post-market
quality assurance (measured by less adverse events/better health outcomes) can be
applied through local reimbursement policies. First, it is investigated whether there
are reimbursement rules in Europe acting as post-market quality assurance. Then,
a comparison is made with Turkey’s existing reimbursement scheme. Results:
Our comparative analysis reveals only Belgium and France implement quality or
brand based reimbursement rules. In Turkey, there is no quality based reimbursement scheme; however current reimbursement application guideline requirements
may act as a gate keeper for lower quality products. Our Results show in addition
to pre-market regulations, post-market quality can be assured by local reimbursement authorities. Conclusions: There are several opportunities to improve
quality assurance and reduce risk across medical device industry; i.e. enhancing
visibility of comparative quality to harness market forces and increasing the collaboration between stakeholders. From health policy perspective, implementation
of new value based reimbursement models require providers to prove that they’re
meeting quality standards and benefitting patients while cutting costs. Therefore,
while value based payment contracts are still in their infancy in Europe and Turkey,
they will have a direct impact on the assurance of continued medical device quality.
PHP155
A Comparison of Factors Influencing Reimbursement and Coverage
Decisions in Scotland (Smc), The Netherlands (Nzi) and Germany
(G-Ba)
Charokopou M 1, Alleman C J M 1, Verleger K 2, Spoorendonk J A 1, Schmidt R 2,
Schoeman O 2, Heeg B 1
1Pharmerit International, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 2Pharmerit International, Berlin, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In Germany, Scotland and the Netherlands, the manufacturer’s
submission is assessed by the HTA bodies; G-BA, SMC and NZi. In Germany, the
submitted evidence is used to assess the drug’s additional benefit, followed by
price-rebate negotiations with the GKV-Spitzenverband. In Scotland and the
Netherlands, the submitted evidence is evaluated for reimbursement decision.
This study aims to compare factors that influence the reimbursement recommendation by SMC and NZi, the additional benefit by G-BA and the rebate by
GKV-Spitzenverband. Methods: Three databases were created consisting of
463 SMC applications, 262 NZi evaluations and 68 G-BA decisions. Logistic regression analyses were conducted to assess the impact of the submitted evidence
on the recommendation by SMC and NZi and the effect of variables on the additional therapeutic benefit by G-BA. The impact of variables on the rebate was
examined through linear regression analysis. Results: In Scotland, 57% of the
applications received positive recommendation and the NZi recommended 83% of
the submissions. In Germany, 60.3% of the products demonstrated an additional
benefit. In Scotland, the multivariate analyses showed that the performance of a
cost-minimization analysis and beneficial cost-effectiveness outcomes were the
strongest positive predictors of the recommendation. In the Netherlands, univariate analyses showed that the decision was significantly affected by whether the
product under assessment was a life-saving intervention and the inclusion of
(positive) economic evidence. In Germany, univariate analyses demonstrated that
the therapeutic indication and the overall survival benefit, along with improved
morbidity and adverse events meaningfully influenced the benefit assessment.
Analysis showed that the rebate was significantly reduced by 13% for products
that demonstrated additional benefit. Conclusions: Even though reimbursement submission requirements of Scotland and the Netherlands look similar,
SMC weights the cost-effectiveness outcomes more, while NZi focuses on the
variables related to additional clinical benefit; variables that also significantly
influence G-BA’s decision.
PHP156
A Comparison of Additional Benefit Scores in Germany (Gba) and
France (Has)
Soussi I 1, Thivolet M 2, Kornfeld A 2, Brunet J 3, Toumi M 4
1Creativ-Ceutical, Tunis, Tunisia, 2Creativ-Ceutical, Paris, France, 3Assistance Publique des
Hôpitaux de Marseille, Marseille, France, 4University Aix-Marseille, Marseille, France
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The Pharmaceutical Market Restructuring Act (AMNOG) has brought
a sustainable change to the reimbursement of new drugs in Germany. The G-BA
assesses the additional benefit of the drug, compared to an appropriate therapy.
AMNOG law is perceived to be one of the toughest drug evaluation process in Europe.
In France the high authority for health (HAS) assesses the level of improvement of
actual benefit (IAB). The objective of this study was to compare the additional benefit
score issued under AMNOG law to IAB scores granted by the HAS. Methods: All
G-BA’s additional benefit scores until June 1st 2014 and HAS IAB score were compared. Results: In Germany, a total of 76 completed early benefit assessments.
From the best available score perspective, the G-BA assessed the additional benefit
as considerable in 20% of drugs assessed (score 2), as minor in 30% of drugs assessed
(score 3), as unquantifiable in 8% of drugs assessed (Score 4) and as none in 38%
of drugs assessed (Score 5). No drug has been granted a major additional benefit
(score 1) and 4% of drugs were directly allocated to a reference price group. In France,
the transparency committee granted a major improvement in 0.2% of cases (IAB
I), an important improvement in 1.3% of cases (IAB II), a moderate improvement
2.5% of cases (IAB III), a minor improvement in 9,2% of cases (IAB 4) and no clinical improvement in 86.8% of cases (IAB V). Conclusions: This study shows that
the G-BA assigned an additional benefit (scores from 1 to 4) to more than half of
drugs whereas the HAS granted an additional benefice rating to less than 14% of
case. This study suggests that there is a more favourable benefit rating in Germany
than in France.
PHP157
Hta Status of Biosimlars Across the UK and Ireland
Mildred M , Davies K
Boehringer Ingelheim Ltd, Bracknell, UK
.
.
Objectives: Biosimilars have the potential to revolutionise the health care landscape by realising cost savings over originator biologics and thus increasing access
to innovative medicines. The biosimilars marketplace in the UK and Ireland is
relatively new, however the landscape is rapidly developing. The objective of this
analysis was to map the HTA status of biosimilars in the UK and Ireland to provide
insight for stakeholders involved in the assessment of new biosimilars. Methods:
The HTA status of all EMA authorised biosimilars was identified by searching the
websites of all four HTA agencies in the UK and Ireland, namely, NICE, the SMC, the
AWMSG, and the NCPE. All previously assessed medicines and on-going technology
appraisals were screened for the inclusion of biosimilars using the non-proprietary
(common name) and proprietary (brand) names. Results: Sixteen (84%) of the
nineteen biosimilars submitted to the EMA have been authorised, eleven of which
(69%) have been considered by HTA agencies. The SMC has approved 100% of the
biosimilars it has considered (n=7); the largest positive reimbursement rate amongst
all HTA agencies considered. The AWMSG has considered the largest number of
biosimilars (n= 11), of which five, (45%) received a positive reimbursement status.
Both NICE and the NCPE have approved one biosimilar, however three additional
biosimilars are currently being considered by NICE. Conclusions: The reimbursement status of biosimilars in the UK and Ireland is not consistent across HTA
agencies. The timing of HTA submissions to different HTA agencies may play an
important factor in the reimbursement status of biosimilars given that this landscape is relatively new and assessment processes vary. Marketing authorisation
holders for biosimilars may want to consider the strategic importance of submitting
evidence to each of the HTA agencies in the UK and Ireland, and the impact timing
may have on the uptake of their biosimilar.
PHP158
Does Not Reaching an Agreement on the Final Nice Scope Have Any
Impact on The Final Apraisal Outcome?
Casamayor M 1, Heemstra L 2, Van Engen A 2
1Quintiles Consulting, Barcelona, Spain, 2Quintiles Consulting, Hoofddorp, The Netherlands
.
.
.
Objectives: Identifying the right patient population, comparator and endpoints is
key to increase the likelihood of reimbursement. Manufacturers do not always agree
with payers’ views on these items. Disagreement may lead to funding rejection. We
assessed the rate of mismatches between manufacturers and NICE and their impact
on the final appraisal outcome. Methods: All manufacturer submissions (MS)
from January 2011 until June 2014 were reviewed. For these submissions, the initial
proposed scope, the manufacturer’s comments, and the final scope and appraisal
outcome were analysed. All changes to the initial scope suggested by the manufacturer were recorded and their impact on final outcome investigated. Results:
In the time period reviewed there were 101 MS of which 7 were suspended and
not included in our analysis, while comments were not available for another 18.
Manufacturer comments are published for 76 MS. The manufacturer disagreed on
≥ 1 section of initial scope in 93% (71/76) of MS. The areas where manufacturers and
NICE disagreed most commonly are the comparator(s) (43/71; 61%) and population
(40/71; 56%) to be assessed. The final scope implemented all and some of the manufacturer’s comments in 56% (40/71) and 28% (29/71) of submissions, respectively.
A431
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Rejection was more common for manufacturer’s comments on outcomes (6/8; 75%)
and comparators (8/13; 61.5%). Rate of final recommendation by NICE was higher
for those MS where all (29/40; 74%) or certain changes (14/20; 74%) requested by
the manufacturer were implemented in the final scope than for those where NICE
rejected all manufacturer requests (7/11; 64%), and similar to overall recommendation rate (66/91; 73%). Conclusions: These data highlight that the initial scope
frequently does not meet manufacturer’s expectations. However, manufacturer’s
suggestions are often incorporated in the final scope. NICE not implementing manufacturer’s suggestions to the final scope does not decrease the likelihood of being
granted funding.
PHP159
An Examination of the Regulatory and Reimbursement Processes
for Biobetters and Comparison With Biosimilars
de Silva S U , Dimova M , Bending M W
Mapi, London, UK
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Biosimilars and biobetters are subsequent versions of licensed innovator biotherapeutics. Whereas biosimilars are comparable to the originator product
in terms of quality, safety and efficacy, biobetters incorporate intentional modifications to the originator molecular profile with the aim of producing a superior
product. This distinction between biosimilars and biobetters has important implications from a regulatory perspective, with biosimilars following class-specific
guidance whereas biobetters are considered innovator drugs. This study sought
to examine and compare the regulatory and reimbursement approaches to the
appraisal of biobetters and biosimilars. Methods: Biobetters and biosimilars of
the same product class were identified, and qualitative analyses of the recommendations by indication, evidence considered, and key decision drivers were undertaken using available regulatory and HTA reimbursement decision documentation
from six European countries. Results: Findings for filgrastim are presented as
an example; 7 biosimilars, and the pegylated filgrastims (pegfilgrastim and lipegfilgrastim) considered biobetters, were identified. Biosimilar filgrastims were granted
European marketing authorisation based on demonstration of clinical comparability to the originator filgrastim in one indication and extrapolation of the results
to all 5 approved indications. Pegfilgrastim demonstrated clinical non-inferiority
to filgrastim in one indication and was approved solely for this indication; the
subsequently developed lipegfilgrastim was approved for the same indication but
used pegfilgrastim as the comparator. Similar to biosimilar filgrastims, economic
evidence in the form of cost-minimisation analyses was considered in HTA recommendations of both pegylated filgrastims. This differs from the approach for certain
other biobetters that have demonstrated clinical superiority and cost-effectiveness
versus their originator. Conclusions: Biosimilars and biobetters are subject to
distinct regulatory processes and the decision driving factors for reimbursement
also differ among currently licensed biobetters. With the development of these
products gaining momentum, it will be interesting to observe how the appraisal
processes evolve to address the scope and variety of emerging biobetters.
PHP160
Time Limits Restriction in Germany
Thivolet M 1, Soussi I 2, Kornfeld A 1, Toumi M 3
.
.
.
.
1Creativ-Ceutical, Paris, France, 2Creativ-Ceutical, Tunis, Tunisia, 3University Aix-Marseille,
Marseille, France
Objectives: In Germany, with the introduction of the Pharmaceutical Market
Restructuring Act (AMNOG) in January 1st2011, pricing and reimbursement decisions for new drugs have been driven by the early benefit assessment (EBA). G-BA
can decide to set or not a time limitation to the decision. The objectives of this
study were, first, to review the number of time-limited decisions over time and
second, to identify drivers of these decisions. Methods: G-BA’s decisions, from the
introduction of AMNOG Law to June 1st2014, were reviewed. Exempted and/or
cancelled procedures were excluded. Results: As of June 1st 2014, 76 EBAs were
concluded and time limits, from 1 to 5 years, were imposed on 28% (21/76) of these
decisions. Short-term restrictions (≤ 2 years) accounted for 52% (11/21) of the timelimited decisions and long-term (> 2 years) for 48% (10/21). Time-limited decisions
concerned largely oncology drugs (62%; 13/21), followed by endocrine/metabolic
drugs (19%; 4/21) and neurology drugs (10%; 2/21). The number of time limited decisions increased over the studied period, from none (0/2) of the decisions in 2011 to
16% (3/19) in H1 2012, 38% (3/8) in H2 2012, 20% (3/15) in H1 2013, 35% (7/20) in H2
2013 and reaching 42% (5/12) from January 1st to June 1st 2014 decisions. Time-limited
decisions were triggered by one or several factors, with safety concerns being the
major driver (38%; 8/21). Other drivers were uncertainties of outcomes (33%; 7/21),
ongoing studies (33%; 7/21), lack of data (24% (5/21), European Medicine Agency’s
(EMA) conditional approval (19%; 4/21), design uncertainty (10%; 2/21), inappropriate
comparator (10%; 2/21), quality of life concerns (10%; 2/21), and EMA requirements
for post-authorisation studies or risk management plan (10%; 2/21). Conclusions:
An increasing trend for time-limited decisions was observed. Time restricted decisions have become a major uncertainty management tool in Germany.
PHP161
Reimbursement Trends and Evidence Requirements for UltraOrphan Therapies Across Europe: Optimising Market Access in
Increasingly Challenging Markets
Morawski J 1, Paul A 2, Ransom J F 3, Spinner D S 4, Doyle J J 5, Faulkner E C 6
1Quintiles, Cambridge, MA, USA, 2Quintiles Consulting, Durham, NC, USA, 3Quintiles Global
Consulting, Hawthorne, NY, USA, 4Quintiles, Durham, NC, USA, 5Quintiles, Hawthorne, NY, USA,
6Institute for Pharmacogenomics and Individualized Therapy, Eshelman School of Pharmacy,
University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Ultra-orphan diseases are extremely rare conditions many of which
are severe, chronic, and progressive with high mortality rates. There is a growing
number of therapies for ultra-rare diseases currently on the market. Reimbursement
decisions for these therapies have been characterized by reduced evidence require-
ments with unmet need weighing heavily into health technology assessment (HTA)
and reimbursement decision-making; as well as a generally wide pricing latitude.
To gain insight into evolving market access requirements, we conducted a review
of pan-European ultra-orphan therapy HTA requirements and reimbursement decisions. Methods: Applying the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence
(NICE) definition for ultra-orphan diseases (prevalence of ≤ 1/50,000), full European
HTA reports on ultra-orphan therapies published through May 2014 were identified
and reviewed to compare evidence requirements and reimbursement decisions
across countries for health economic, clinical, and value based criteria. Results:
Over sixty published ultra-orphan HTAs were identified across nine markets. A
small portion of these submissions were rejected for reimbursement largely due
to lack of evidence on clinical benefit. For therapies recommended with access
restrictions, payers often requested additional follow-on studies or ongoing monitoring of patients by manufacturers. With respect to economic evidence evaluation,
reimbursement decisions predominately hinged on therapy cost per patient per
year, rather than cost-effectiveness. More recent assessments also evaluated quality of life evidence and input from patient groups. Conclusions: As health care
budgets become more strained, ultra-orphan therapies priced at a premium have
come under increased scrutiny from HTA agencies and payers to demonstrate value
for money. In order to achieve optimal market access, manufacturers must consider
continually evolving stakeholder evidence requirements and develop clinical and
health economic value plans that demonstrate how their ultra-orphan therapies
provide health gain instead of disease stabilization.
PHP162
Global HTA Assessments of Ultra-Orphan Products: A Case Study Of
Eculizumab (Soliris) and Iduronate-2-Sulfatase (Elaprase)
Paul A 1, Morawski J 2, Spinner D S 3, Doyle J J 4, Faulkner E C 5, Ransom J F 6
1Quintiles Consulting, Durham, NC, USA, 2Quintiles, Cambridge, MA, USA, 3Quintiles, Durham,
NC, USA, 4Quintiles, Hawthorne, NY, USA, 5Institute for Pharmacogenomics and Individualized
Therapy, Eshelman School of Pharmacy, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC, USA,
6Quintiles Global Consulting, Hawthorne, NY, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Ultra-orphan diseases affect a very small patient population, defined
by the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) as those diseases
with a prevalence of ≤ 1: 50,000. Medicines for these indications are difficult to
develop in part due to challenges associated with recruiting for clinical trials
from a small patient population. Within this context, global payer bodies have
assessed these therapies with modified evidence requirements and opportunity
for very high prices. We performed a health technology assessment (HTA) review
of two ultra-orphan products – eculizumab/Soliris and iduronate-2-sulfatase (IDS)/
Elaprase – to gain insight into the evolving HTA evidence requirements for ultraorphan medicines and comparatively evaluate key decision drivers across geographies. Methods: We scanned global HTAs published before end of May 2014 to
identify the two most widely assessed ultra-orphan therapies that have variable
reimbursement decision outcomes (eculizumab/Soliris and IDS/Elaprase). To evaluate pivotal decision drivers, we analyzed HTAs across several criteria, including
clinical efficacy, unmet need, strength of evidence, cost-effectiveness and burden
of illness. Results: We identified HTAs in seven countries. For both products,
reimbursement decisions varied across agencies. Key decision drivers included
cost-effectiveness, clinical efficacy, risk-sharing schemes, and lowered evidence
requirements/ special criteria for ultra-orphan medicines. Assessments rejecting
Soliris and Elaprase (e.g., Australia, Canada, UK) did so based on cost-effectiveness
and lack of long-term survival data. Notably, the NICE Highly Specialized Technology
Committee requested unprecedented justification of Soliris pricing. Some agencies
(e.g, Scottish Medicines Consortium [SMC]) preemptively rejected the products due
to manufacturer non-submission of required data. In Australia, Soliris gained recommendation alongside a risk-sharing scheme while Elaprase gained recommendation
under Life Saving Drugs Program criteria. Conclusions: Eculizumab and IDS are
among a select list of therapies commanding very high prices globally. This study
demonstrates variability in decision criteria and approaches across HTA agencies
for such high-priced ultra-orphan products.
PHP163
Evidence-Based Market Access Value Resource: Navigating The
Hurdles for A Biologic Obtaining A License In A Second Indication in
Key European Countries
Hogue S 1, Bjoerk B 2, Walker A 3, Balp M M 2, Fernandez M 4, Quijano M 2, Ling C S 5, Heyes A E 5
1RTI-Health Solutions, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA, 2Novartis Pharma AG, Basel,
Switzerland, 3University of Glasgow, Glasgow, UK, 4RTI Health Solutions, RTP, NC, USA, 5RTI
Health Solutions, Manchester, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Market access for an innovative technology, such as a biologic
obtaining a license in a second indication, can be complex and time consuming.
Reimbursement is critical to rapid adoption of and optimal patient access to a new
technology. This study aimed to determine the best approach for communicating
value and providing field-based staff with value resources to facilitate dialogue
with stakeholders in various scenarios. Methods: We conducted desktop research
of published literature, health technology assessment reports, clinical trials data,
and third-party websites to identify the critical path and data most valuable to
reimbursement decision making in order to prepare a communication resource.
We conducted a country-affiliate workshop and qualitative one-on-one interviews
with payer decision makers in several key markets to understand funding flow and
the most appropriate means of communicating value to external decision makers. Results: The process and restrictions for biologics may be stricter than for
other medications because of perceived high cost. There are multiple appropriate
access pathways for various settings of care, all with varying requirements and
value drivers. It is critical to understand the needs of external decision makers
and provide field-based staff with a consistent yet customizable means of communicating the value of new technologies. All evidence and insights were synthesized into an evidence-based market access value resource for key stakeholder
A432
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
engagement. Conclusions: The evidence-based market access value resource
approach provides a clear, concise, and globally integrated value story that will
assist in market access and form the basis of consistent communication regarding
value at the national, regional, and local level across external stakeholders (e.g.,
payer decision makers, physicians, patient advocates). Access for a biologics will be
complex; regardless of pathway, decisions regarding reimbursement and adoption
of a new technology are diverse and dispersed across and within countries, with
varying levels of required evidence.
PHP164
Medicare Provider Utilization and Payment Data: The Book to
Bill Gap
Casazza Liberatore C 1, Connelly N 2, Culp J L 2, Doyle J 3
1Quintiles Consulting, Hawthorne, NY, USA, 2Quintiles Consulting, Durham, NC, USA, 3Quintiles
Global Consulting, Hawthorne, NY, USA
.
.
.
.
.
The US significantly outspends all other top 10 developed nations, with no increase
in life expectancy. Increasing transparency in health care spending could help
address this cost to outcomes gap. CMS’ recent release of Medicare Part B Utilization
and Payment data, covering 880,000 providers and $77 billion in Medicare payments, is a significant step toward this goal. Objectives: Understand differences
in billed versus paid amounts for provider and procedure types reported in Medicare
data. Methods: Descriptive and inferential statistics were run on provider specialties representing greater than 2% of claims to describe the differences between
maximum allowed Medicare payment amount, amount billed by providers, and
the amount reimbursed. Geographical variation was also explored. Results:
Amount billed is at least double the amount paid and double the maximum allowable amount for all of the specialties explored; amount billed versus paid varies
significantly by specialty, with some specialties billing as much as six times what
they are paid. Largest discrepancies were in anesthesiology (on average billing $838,
versus $139 allowed and $110 paid). Other specialties with significant disparity
include cardiology, diagnostic radiology, emergency medicine, ophthalmology, and
orthopedic surgery; within certain specialties, specific procedures showed ranges
of billing and payment ratios; across all specialties, average amount paid was about
90% of maximum allowable; and each state is represented in line with census data
for the Medicare population; state differences in amount paid versus billed and
allowed is not significant. Conclusions: In analyzing payer and provider data to
increase transparency on health care spend, we recognize there is heterogeneity
between what is paid versus billed across specialty. There is an opportunity to focus
attention on narrowing this gap for high-value procedures through evidence and
education of patients, payers, and providers to ensure patients receive appropriate
treatment, and providers are appropriately reimbursed.
PHP165
Claims Reimbursement Analysis of the National Health Insurance
Scheme in Ghana
Nsiah-Boateng E
National Health Insurance Scheme, Accra, Ghana
.
Objectives: To assess the value and service quality of the National Health
Insurance Scheme (NHIS) benefits. Methods: A review method was employed
to analysis medical claims for the 2011 to 2013 period. The medical claims were
retrieved from the database of the Ashiedu Keteke District NHIS Office. The incurred
claims ratio, promptness of claims settlement, and claims rejection ratio indicators
of benefit value and service quality were analyzed. Results: A total of 421,574
medical claims with a cost of GHS7.3 million (USD2.6 million) were analyzed.
These claims came from thirteen accredited health care providers-three public
health facilities, four private clinics and six community pharmacies. The incurred
claims ratio increased significantly from 4.3 to 7.2 over the period, 2011-2013. The
proportion of claims settled beyond 90 days increased consistently from 26% to
90% over the same period. Although, the proportion of claims rejected increased
from 0.9% to 3.6% over the period under review, overall, it was low. The reasons for
rejection included provision of benefits to inactive subscribers and breach of sublimit on certain expense category. Conclusions: There is increased awareness
and utilization of health services; however, there are considerable delays in claims
settlements. It would be necessary for management of the NHIS to settle claims
in time to ensure that health care providers are financially resourced to render
service to subscribers.
PHP166
National Health Insurance Fund Drug Expenditure in Bulgaria,
2007-2012: Reference Based Pricing Alone or in Combination With
Other Approaches to Pricing
Djambazov S N 1, Vekov T Y 2, Petrov D 3
1Cancer clinics Doc Dr Valentina Tsekova, Sofia, Bulgaria, 2Medical University Pleven, Pleven,
Bulgaria, 3Bulgarian Medical Union, Sofia, Bulgaria
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Our team wanted to compare the economic effect of restricted market access and reference based pricing (RBP) vs. RBP alone in two consecutive
periods, 2007—2009 and 2010—2012. Methods: We used the officially published
cash flow statements and income statements from the financial reports of the
National Health Insurance Fund (NHIF) for each of the years from 2007 to 2012.
Then we compared the data about the expenditure for drugs, as well as the data
about the budget control. Results: While restricted market access and RBP has
been applied between 2007 and 2009, the NHIF drug expenditure increased with
15% (from EUR 144 mln to EUR 166 mln). For that period, the drug expenditure
was generally 100% within the budget. From 2010 to 2012, while only RBP has been
applied, the expenditure increased with 62% (from EUR 187 to EUR 303 mln). For
the period, the drug expenditure exceeded the NHIF budget with 5% in 2010, 34% in
2011, 20% in 2012. Conclusions: RBP alone cannot control the drug expenditure
in a long-term. Additional measures are needed together with RBP. Performancebased pricing, differential pricing, comparative pricing, profit control and price-
volume agreements may be considered as additional to RBP measures for pricing
and budget control.
PHP167
Evaluation of Social Welfare Part of Hungarian Drug Provision
System
Andriska P , Komáromi T , Gyáni G
Healthware Consulting Ltd., Budapest, Hungary
.
.
.
Objectives: The part of Hungarian drug provision system, which is available
on social welfare list, changed several times and in different extents in recent
years. The introduction of drug budget in 2006 and simultaneously the abolition
of social welfare drug list implied the most significant change. The chief aim of
our analysis to give a comprehensive overview about the main trends on this field
examining the range of available products on social welfare list based on different
aspects, also concerning the trends of demand, product structure, expenditures
and patient burdens. Methods: Changes of key points of relevant acts concerned
in drug provision, the aggregated (not patient level) public turnover data of the
Hungarian Health Fund and published number of patients involved in this reimbursement category were considered as the key sources and indicators of our
evaluation. Results: After regulation changes, demand (DOT) and number of
patients within social welfare list category significantly decreased after 2006 until
2009, but since then both of them stagnate. Significant growth of reimbursement
outflow within this segment can be observed until 2011, but after slight decrease.
Part share of higher level reimbursement categories within reimbursement outflow increased. Demand moved to more expensive products, while patients were
able to access to more innovative active ingredients in higher level reimbursement categories. Strong correlation can be observed between changes of acts and
breaks in turnover trends. Conclusions: Results of the analysis may support
objective judgement of the present social welfare provision system, as well as
may contain considerable consequences regarding to potential ways of future
structural changes, considering both interests of entitled patients (right to access
innovative therapies) and the Health Fund (increase savings, improve efficiency).
Further analysis based on real world (patient level) data may result more complex
investigation opportunities of this patient segment and reimbursement category.
PHP168
Analysis of New Model of Therapeutic Positioning Reports As A P&R
Decision-Making Tool in Spain
Rodrigues T , Izmirlieva M , Ando G
IHS, London, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: This study aims to determine if the recently proposed model for therapeutic positioning reports (IPTs) in Spain is actually being used as a supportive
tool for pharmaceutical pricing and reimbursement (P&R) decisions whilst delivering greater transparency and regional market access harmonisation. Methods:
Primary research was conducted with regional payers on the proposed model of
IPTs, which contain a comparative evaluation on effectiveness and safety, as well
as criteria of use, for newly authorized medicines and older medicines which have
a high potential health or economic impact. This was supplemented by secondary
research. Results: The publication of IPTs has brought quicker uptake and greater
homogenization to the market access of certain medicines. Notably, according to
primary research, protease inhibitors were made available in all autonomous communities (CCAAs) two months after the IPT publication. However, the deadline of 3
months for the publication of IPTs is generally not being met. As delineated in the
model and shown by primary research, IPTs are starting to be used as a basis for
P&R decision-making in Spain and play an important role in the identification of
the most suitable target patient population. IPTs are also delivering on promises
of generating consensus amongst the Spanish CCAAs. Conclusions: IPTs are
being used to support the Inter-ministerial Commission of Medicine Prices and
the Directorate General of Pharmacy and Basic Services role in P&R. If accepted
by the majority of the CCAAs, IPTs will also serve as a tool to evaluate and limit
discrepancies in innovative medicines access throughout Spain. However, there is
lack of consensus of whether an IPT should include an economic evaluation from
the start. Contrary to manufacturers, regional payers generally believe its inclusion
would help with the selection of more cost-effective medicines whilst aiding with
the adoption of IPTs in general.
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Health Care Research & Education
PHP169
Determination of Referral Utilization Rate: Linking Households To
Health Care System; Kenyan Rural Setting Experience
Mogere D M 1, Loum C S 1, Kaseje D 2
1Great Lakes University of Kisumu, KISUMU, Kenya, 2Great Lakes University of Kisumu, Kisumu,
Kenya
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Referral utilization is defined as the number of patients referred and
seen by physicians. The objective was to establish referral utilization rate among sick
persons identified at the households, counseled and referred to link hospitals by community health workers. Sick persons identified were issued with referral and counter
referral slips to take to the hospital. Methods: This was a quasi -experimental study
carried out in two sub- locations in rural Kenya. One hundred community health
workers were trained on community based referral and counter referral model and
issued with referral tools. Each was assigned 25 households, instructed to regularly
visit them in order to identify sick persons, counsel and refer them to link hospitals for
care. One hundred villages comprising 2209 households with a population of 11,000
people were covered and referral model implemented for 12 months. Results: A
total of 322 patients were identified, advised and referred, with a referral response
rate of 93% (298/322.) Seventy percent were five years and above. The study showed
that 82% (263/322) of the patients arrived in hospital with referral slip the same day
A433
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
they were referred, 5% (15/322) arrived the second day, 6% (20/322) third day and over
and 7% (24/322) did not arrive in the hospital. Conclusions: The study provides
evidence that community health workers if properly trained, equipped and supported
would identify sick persons in the households, counsel and refer them to hospitals for
specialized care. Patient referral arrival rate on same day is reasonably high because
households were regularly visited and sick persons encouraged to seek care. Similar
studies carried out in the US and Great Britain suggest that in a population of 1000
adults, 750 will experience an episode of illness, of these 250 will consult a physician
of whom 6 will require to be referred to the physician.
PHP170
Provincial Entry of New Drugs In China
Wan W Y H , Conti C
GfK NOP, London, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To improve health care provision whilst containing cost at the same
time, Chinese authorities allow the entry of new drugs at provincial level. Whilst
different provinces have different economic situation and needs, it is essential for
pharmaceutical companies to strategize provincial drug entry. The purpose of this
research is to explore province(s) that may provide the best chance for new drug
entry. Methods: To capture all the drugs that were newly included in the 2012
National Drug List (NDL) but not the 2009 NDL, multiple databases including the two
NDLs, Adis Insight and the Chinese database Yao-zhi Shu-ju were used. Provincial
reimbursement status of these drugs was identified using the Chinese database.
Provincial population and economic data (including gross domestic product (GDP),
health expenditure and consumer price index (CPI)) in 2011 were captured on the
National Statistical Database. The correlation between the numbers of provincially
reimbursed drugs (with/without restrictions) and GDP per capita, and between the
numbers of provincially reimbursed drugs (with/ without restrictions) and regional
health expenditure, were investigated. All databases were accessed in September
2013. Results: 245 new formulations were identified, among which 35 of them are
alternative formulations of 26 new drugs. Among the 23 provinces and 4 municipalities provinces, Anhui (48%) followed by Jiangsu (20%) approved most new drugs without restrictions. Guangxi (21%) was the autonomous region approved most new drugs
without restrictions. Among the provincially reimbursed drugs, Jilin (62%) was the
province approved most drugs associated with restrictions. The number of approved
drugs was not correlated to regional GDP per capita (p=0.18, r2=0.06) nor with regional
health expenditure (p=0.78, r2=0.003). Conclusions: There is a substantial variation
in the number of approved new drugs between provinces in China. The economic
status of the provinces is not likely to be the sole factor causing such differentiation.
PHP171
Using The Ispor 2013 European Congress as a Big Data Case Study
Furnback W , Wang B C M
Alliance Life Sciences, Somerset, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The availability of concentrated big data sets can help researchers
analyze current trends in an industry and drive future growth. Over 1,600 poster
presentations related to pharmacoeconomics and outcomes research were presented at the 2013 ISPOR European meeting. We analyzed the titles of the posters to
find trends in research. Methods: We analyzed the titles and associated sections
of all the poster presentations accepted for the ISPOR 2013 European meeting held
in Dublin, Ireland. The distribution by sector (research on methods, health care use
& policy studies, cancer, cardiovascular, etc) was calculated in addition to the type
of study (cost, PRO & patient preference, clinical outcomes, etc.). We also searched
the titles of posters for key words to divide studies into the following four categories:
cost-effectiveness, budget-impact, burden of illness and literature review. Results:
In total, 1,679 poster title were analyzed. For the sector distribution, the top three
studies were as follows: research on methods (238; 14.18%), health care use & policy
studies (217; 12.92%) and cancer (210; 12.51%). The most popular types of studies
were: cost studies (617; 36.75%), patient reported outcome & patient preference
studies (212; 12.63%), and clinical outcomes studies (200; 11.91%). Of all the posters,
cost-effectiveness studies made up 12.27%, while budget impact studies, literature
reviews and burden of illness studies made up 2.5%, 1.67% and. 6%, respectively. The
top three sectors for cost-effectiveness studies were cancer (31; 15.05%), cardiovascular disorders (29; 14.08%), and infections (28; 13.59%). Conclusions: Analyzing
trends at conferences may help researchers and key stakeholders understand the
current issues in the field. The most common type of study for the 2013 ISPOR
European were cost studies. The cost-effectiveness studies were concentrated in
cancer, cardiovascular disorders and infections.
PHP172
Common Illnesses Identified by Community Health Workers in the
Households and Referrred to Primary Health Facilities For Care
Mogere D M 1, Loum C S 1, Kaseje D 2
1Great Lakes University of Kisumu, KISUMU, Kenya, 2Great Lakes University of Kisumu, Kisumu,
Kenya
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To determine common illnesses identified and referred to the health
facility for care by community health workers during routine household visitations. Methods: Quasi-experimental study was carried out in two sub-locations
in rural Kenya where one hundred community health workers were trained on
community based referral and counter referral model and issued with referral
tools. Each was assigned 25 households, instructed to regularly visit them in order
to identify sick persons counsel and refer them to link hospitals. One hundred
villages comprising 2209 households with a population of 11,000 people were
covered where the counter referral model was implemented. Results: In total
the community health workers identified, counseled and referred 322 sick persons to health facilities for health care. Those identified for referrals were categorized as either below or above five years. Under fives referrals accounted for
30% (97/322) where the top five reasons for referrals included; general illnesses for
under fives, 5.2 (18%); postnatal care for infant, 30 (9.3%); immunization defaulters
(3.1%); malaria, 3 (. 9%) and diarrhea, 3 (. 9%). Top five reasons for above five referrals included; general illnesses for above fives, 89 (27.6%); ANC clinic 34, (12.7%);
health check up, 24 (7.5%); Chronic cough, 19 (5.9%) and PNC for mother 6 (1.9%.)
Conclusions: Community Health Workers were able to identify, counsel and
refer 322 persons with 38 various types of ailments. The study concludes that
if CHWs are trained well, supplied with referral tools and provided with regular support supervision, they have the capacity to identify common ailments at
household level and provide advice on the appropriate health action required to
be taken. It is the view of the authors that community health workers referral
model be scaled up.
PHP173
An Evaluation of Patient Satisfaction In Pafos, Cyprus With The
“Europep” Instrument
Panayides N 1, Latsou D 2, Geitona M 2
1Neapolis University, Pafos, Cyprus, 2University of Peloponnese, Corinth, Greece
.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate patients’ satisfaction with the general practice care provided at the Pafos General Hospital outpatient units. Methods: The EUROPEP questionnaire, standardized and validated into Greek, was distributed to outpatients,
with the method of random sampling and filled out with personal interviews, from
February to April 2014. EUROPEP includes 23 items and 5 dimensions regarding
doctor – patient relationship, medical care, information - support, organization of
care and accessibility. The sample size was based on 50% of annual outpatients’
visits. For the assessment of the questionnaire internal consistency, the coefficient
a Cronbach was used. Student’s t-test and analysis of variance have been performed
in order to determine the significant differences between the dimensions and sociodemographic characteristics. Results: In total 345 out of 383 outpatients filled
out the questionnaire (RR= 90%). The majority of the sample (61.2%) was female and
belonged to the 61-80 years old group. 43.5% of sample answered moderate health
condition and 43.8% bad. The Cronbach’s alpha of questionnaire met the criterion
of 0.858. The doctor – patient relationship, medical care, information – support
and organization of care scored 4.09±1, 3.56±0.8, 3.97±0.9 and 4.01±1.2 respectively,
which mean ‘satisfied’. However, the accessibility regarding the getting through to
the practice and waiting time was scored much lower (2.3 ±0.8), meaning ‘dissatisfied’. Statistically significant differences were found between gender and doctor –
patient relationship (p= 0.019), information - support (p≤ 0.001) and organization of
care (p= 0.003), while age group was related to information – support (p≤ 0.001) and
organization of care (p≤ 0.001). Patients’ health condition was found significant with
the doctor – patient relationship (p= 0.004), medical care (p= 0.007) and accessibility (p= 0.001). Conclusions: Patients were satisfied with the provision of general
practice and sociodemographic characteristics appear to be significant predictors of
satisfaction. Also, problems of accessibility can be solved through the forthcoming
reform of primary health care in Cyprus.
PHP174
Clinical Trial Activity in Greece From 2010 To 2012: Still Missing the
Opportunities?
Athanasakis K 1, Boubouchairopoulou N 1, Alexiou V 1, Baroutsou B 2, Kyriopoulos J 1
1National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece, 2Sanofi - aventis AEBE, Athens, Greece
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Clinical trials (CTs) lead to innovative medical treatments, and present positive externalities both for clinical practice and the economy. The study
aimed at portraying the CT activity in Greece for 2012, built upon a previous survey
conducted in 2010, and at highlighting any discrepancies. Methods: The survey
was conducted among the members of the Hellenic Association of Pharmaceutical
Companies (SFEE). Each company was requested to return a structured questionnaire for each interventional CT approved by the National Ethics Committee
(NEC) during 2012. Questionnaire items focused on the main characteristics of
each CT: duration, phase, budget, number of recruited patients, affiliation of
recruiting sites and therapeutic area of the investigational agent. Results: All
SFEE members participated returning completed questionnaires (response rate:
100%). Data on 70 interventional CTs were received. The majority was phase-III
trials (64.3%) as in 2010 (68.3%) with a mean duration of 36.3 months (regardless
of phase). Most CT sites were affiliated to a university or NHS hospital (45.7% and
42.3% respectively). A contractionary phase in the CT activity was observed compared to 2010, as demonstrated by the basic characteristics of approved CTs, i.e.
average number of patients/trial: 35 vs 98, average number of patient per participating center: 8.68 vs 32.5, average total budget/trial 218,556€ vs 296,598€ for 2012
vs 2010 respectively. Conclusions: In 2012, the health care sector in Greece
entered a recession phase due to the severe economic crisis and the subsequent
fiscal adjustment program. These measures, accompanied by non-efficient processes in the administrative setting for CT approvals in Greece, appear to have an
impact on the country’s CT activity. Given that CTs represent vital investments
for the human capital and the economy, joint action from all stakeholders is
of paramount importance in order to surpass existing hurdles and to promote
investment in research.
PHP175
Predictors of Working Motivation in Job Satisfaction Among Nurses
in Cyprus
Polyviou C 1, Latsou D 2, Geitona M 2
1Neapolis University, Pafos, Cyprus, 2University of Peloponnese, Corinth, Greece
.
.
.
Objectives: To investigate factors affecting nurses’ working motivation on job
satisfaction in public and private hospitals in Pafos. Methods: The study included
all hospitals in Pafos, with 410 nurses out of which a random sample was collected from February to March 2013. Two generic, self-administered, instruments
have been used. The first questionnaire refers to working motivation in terms of
recognition, responsibility, personal development, job interest, working relationships etc, developed by Everard κ α ι Morris (1999). The second instrument refers to
job satisfaction by Spector (1985). Both instruments score 1: “agree/satisfied very
A434
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
much” to 4 “disagree/dissatisfied very much”. Correlation analysis was performed
to identify the relationship between working motivation and job satisfaction. Also,
multivariate regression analysis with stepwise method was conducted between
overall job satisfaction and various working motivation dimensions. Results: 141
out of 150 nurses filled out the questionnaire (RR 94%). The majority of the sample
(68.8%) was female and belonged to the 21-30 years old group. Working motivation scoring was ranged from 2.54 to 2.04, meaning positive, except from working relationships (1.8 ±0.7). Also, the mean of overall job satisfaction was 2.3±0.6,
meaning satisfied. Positive correlation was found between working motivation and
job satisfaction (p≤ 0.01), with the exception of salary and working relationships.
Personal development (β = 0.227), job interest (β = 0.254), responsibility (β = 0.149) and
recognition (β= 0.154), were significant predictors of overall job satisfaction (p≤0.05).
Reporting high motivation from work was positively and significantly associated
with higher job satisfaction. Conclusions: Working motivation of health professionals contributes to the enhancement of their job satisfaction and consequently
to the improvement of health services provision.
PHP176
Factors Influencing Job Satisfaction Among Nurses of Pafos
General Hospital in Cyprus
M 1, Latsou
D 2, Geitona
M2
drugs were found using the online Drug Future Chinese Marketed Drugs Database
(accessed December 2013 to January 2014). Results: 260 drugs for neurological
diseases, 106 drugs for oncology and 76 drugs for respiratory diseases were identified; 92, 42 and 26 drugs respectively had the marketing years of both import brands
and local brands were available. 32 (~35%) neurological drugs, 13 (31%) oncology
drugs and 11 (42%) respiratory drugs had local ‘branded’/generic versions available
before the imported (originator) version. Most of these drugs in all three therapeutic
areas were marketed between 2002 and 2003, whilst their imported (originator)
versions were marketed 1-7 years later. Since 2009, no originator drug has been
found marketed later that their local ‘branded’/generic versions. Conclusions:
The low number of local ‘branded’/generic drugs marketed before the imported
drugs in recent years suggests that the IP issue in China might have improved since
the 2009 health reform. Current Results also suggest that respiratory medicine was
most popular for inappropriate local manufacturing. It is yet to find out whether this
observation was related to the costs of the originator drugs, the market demand, difficulties in copying new molecules due to their complexity, or high cost of manufacturing. These results may act as the basis to further explore future IP issues in China.
PHP179
The Ecology of Medical Care in Japan Revisited
Nikolaou
1Neapolis University, Pafos, Cyprus, 2University of Peloponnese, Corinth, Greece
Takahashi O , Ohde S
St. Luke’s Life Science Institute, Tokyo, Japan
Objectives: To assess the job satisfaction of the nursing staff of the Pafos General
Hospital in Cyprus. Methods: A cross-sectional survey was conducted in April
2014. All 150 nurses (RR= 100%) working at the General Hospital of Pafos filled out a
standardized, self-administered questionnaire with a 5-point Likert scale, regarding
the assessment of job satisfaction, working conditions and personal well being. The
questionnaire scoring from 1 represented “very dissatisfied” to 5 “very satisfied”. In
order to investigate the association among job satisfaction as dependent variable
and sociodemographic characteristics of the sample, satisfaction of working conditions and personal well being as independent variables, multiple linear regression
analysis was performed with backward method. Also, correlation analysis, using
Spearman rank coefficient, was conducted to quantify the strength of association
among job satisfaction and independent variables. Results: The majority of the
sample (64.7%) was female and permanent employees (60.7%). The mean age was
33.7 (S.D. 9.7) years. The personal well being score was 4.1 (S.D. 0.6), which means
satisfied. The working conditions and job satisfaction scores were 2.2 (S.D. 0.7) and
2.9 (S.D. 0.9), showing low and moderate satisfaction respectively. Age (β = -0.321,
95% C.I. -0.650, -0.008), permanency of job (β = 0.346, 95% C.I. -0.005, 0.697), satisfaction of working conditions (β = 0.532, 95% C.I. 0.331, 0.732) and personal well being
(β = 0.444, 95% C.I. 0.188, 0.700) were significant predictors of overall satisfaction
(p≤ 0.05). Positive correlation was found between job satisfaction and working conditions (rs = 0.349, p ≤ 0.001) and personal well being (rs = 0.185, p ≤ 0.024) respectively. Conclusions: The assessment of nurses’ working conditions appears to
contribute to the improvement of job satisfaction, the enhancement of productivity
and nursing care outcomes.
Objectives: Studies on the ecology of medical care have provided a framework for
health care systems, medical education, and clinical research. Ten years ago, Fukui
et al. reported the ecology of medical care in Japan. However, medicine and health
care organization has changed since then. In the current study, we conducted an
updated evaluation and compared it to results observed 10 years ago to understand
health care seeking behaviors of people in Japan. Methods: A population weighted
random sample from a nationally representative panel was used to estimate the
number of health-related symptoms, self-care, and health care utilization per 1,000
individuals based on a prospective health diary recorded for one month. Variations
in terms of age and gender were also examined. Results: Based on 4,548 persons
(3,787 adults and 797 children), on average per 1,000 persons, 794 (95% Confidence
Interval (CI): 782 - 805) had at least one symptom, 447 (95% CI: 433 - 462) used overthe-counter drugs (OTC), and 265 (95% CI: 252 – 278) visited a physician’s office, 206
(95% CI: 194 – 218) a primary care physician, 4 (95% CI: 2 - 5) a hospital emergency
department, and 117 (95% CI: 107 - 126) a professional provider of complementary
or alternative medical (CAM) care. Children had more physician visits, and adult
used more OTC and CAM. Females were more likely than males to have symptoms,
to visit their physician and to use OTC and CAM. Conclusions: Compared with
the data from 2003, health care seeking behaviors of people with symptoms in Japan
are remarkably similar, with the exception of an observed increase in the use of
CAM. Results of this study would be useful for further delineation of health care
seeking behaviors of people in the context of a health care system unique to Japan.
.
.
.
PHP177
Legal and Ethical Implications of Using Data From Social Media
Websites
Khankhel Z , Abogunrin S , Martin A
Evidera, London, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: Most social media (SM) sites have common terms and conditions dictating how data from the sites may be used, but how these relate to health care
research is usually unclear. We analyzed studies included in two separate systematic literature reviews to assess whether researchers have evaluated the legal and
ethical implications of using SM as a clinical tool or as a data source for health
care research. Methods: In the first review, MEDLINE and Embase were searched
(2008-2013) for articles evaluating the use of SM as a tool or application in health
care. In the second review, MEDLINE and Embase were searched for English language studies on the use of SM in the context of adult vaccination. We assessed
whether any of the individual studies considered the legal and ethical implications
of using SM sources. Results: The first review identified 3,232 unique abstracts; 36
reported on interactive, internet-delivered programs, Facebook, and mobile apps, for
improving health outcomes of patients with cancer, or inflammatory, mental health,
musculoskeletal, neurologic, ophthalmologic, or sexual health-related disorders. The
second review identified 1,264 publications, of which 32 used SM to communicate
with patients, analyze content, or recruit patients for studies related to perceptions
of adult vaccines. Among these 68 publications, no study reported whether the legal
or ethical implications of using SM content were considered prior to conducting
research. Conclusions: The evidence suggests that legal and ethical implications
of utilizing data from SM websites are not reported, and may not be considered, in
current SM research. It is unclear whether this reflects the lack of clarity about what
these restrictions mean for health care research, or whether researchers are not aware
that such restrictions may exist. An informed debate to raise awareness of these
issues and come to an understanding of the best way forward is urgently needed.
PHP178
Phenomenon of Inappropriate Drug Manufacturing in China - Past
and Present
Wan W Y H
GfK NOP, London, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: It was an unspoken fact that Chinese manufacturers copying patentprotected drugs inappropriately (e.g. aripiprazole (neurology), pemetrexed (oncology), tiotropium bromide (respiratory)). The purpose of this study is to explore this
phenomenon among the drugs currently included in the National Drug Lists (NDLs)
and trends in the recent years. Methods: Reimbursed drugs from three therapeutic areas (neurology, oncology and respiratory) were identified from the 2012 NDLs.
The marketing years of the import (originator) drugs and local ‘branded’/generic
.
.
PHP180
What Is The Proportion of Patients Who Return Counter Referral
Slips to the Original Referral Service For Confirmation of Arrival
to the Hospital?
Mogere D M 1, Loum C S 1, Kaseje D 2
1Great Lakes University of Kisumu, KISUMU, Kenya, 2Great Lakes University of Kisumu, Kisumu,
Kenya
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Counter referral success rate is defined as number of patients received
back at the original referring service with counter referral slips divided by the total
number of patients referred and received at the referral hospital. Study objective
was to determine the number of patients who returned counter referral slips to
the original referral service for confirmation of arrival to the hospital. Methods:
Quasi-experimental study was carried out in two sub-locations in Kenya where
hundred community health workers were trained on community based referral
and counter referral model and issued with referral tools. Each was assigned 25
households, instructed to regularly visit them in order to identify sick persons
counsel and refer them to link hospitals. One hundred villages comprising 2209
households with a population of 11,000 people were covered where the counter
referral model was implemented. Results: During the 12 months of implementation, a total of 322 patients were identified, counseled and referred to link hospitals
of whom 93% (298/322) arrived the hospitals with referral and counter referral slips.
The study showed that forty six percent (138/298) of counter referral slips had the
name, signature and date of referring health worker, only 12% (35/298) indicated
CHW’s telephone contact. Forty one percent (121/298) had the name and signature
of attending physician of which 96% (116/121) had hospital stamp. Further, forty
seven percent (140/298) of the patients returned counter referral slips to the original
referral service for confirmation of arrival at the referral hospital. Fifty one percent
(117/228) were satisfied with referral and counter referral process. Conclusions:
It is concluded that referral and counter referral model is both feasible and acceptable. However, referral protocols and other resources are necessary for the process
to be successful. Further, both ends should be willing and prepared to receive those
being referred there.
PHP181
What Is The Patients’ Median Delay From The Referring Community
Health Worker To Arrival in the Link Health Facility?
Mogere D M 1, Loum C S 1, Kaseje D 2
1Great Lakes University of Kisumu, KISUMU, Kenya, 2Great Lakes University of Kisumu, Kisumu,
Kenya
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Median delay could be defined as time taken in days from referring
health facility to arrival at receiving link health facility. The purpose of the study
was to determine the amount of time (in days) patients take to arrive at the link
health facility for health care after being referred from the household by community health workers. Methods: Quasi-experimental study was carried out in two
A435
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
sub- locations in Kenya where hundred community health workers were trained
on community based referral and counter referral model and issued with referral
tools. Each was assigned 25 households, instructed to regularly visit them in order
to identify sick persons counsel and refer them to link hospitals. One hundred villages comprising 2209 households with a population of 11,000 people were covered
where the counter referral model was implemented. Results: Three hundred and
twenty two sick persons were identified, counseled and referred to the two link
health facilities by one hundred community health workers who covered one hundred villages. It was further shown that 82% (263/322) arrived in the referral health
facilities with referral slips on the same day, 5% (15/322) second day, 6% (20/322)
third day and over while 7% (24/322) did not arrive in the hospitals. Conclusions:
It was observed that community health workers regularly visited households. This
observation is consistent with findings of previous similar studies. Only about less
than a third of all the referrals did not arrive the link referral hospital the first day.
It is therefore concluded that community health workers are a critical link between
the households and primary health care facilities. They are likely to identify common illnesses during routine household visitation, counsel and refer sick persons
to health facilities for care.
PHP182
Choosing Important Health Outcomes For Comparative
Effectiveness Research: A Systematic Review
Gargon E 1, Gurung B 1, Medley N 1, Altman D 2, Blazeby J 3, Clarke M 4, Williamson P 1
1University of Liverpool, Liverpool, UK, 2University of Oxford, Oxford, UK, 3University of Bristol,
Bristol, UK, 4Queen’s University, Belfast, Ireland
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: A core outcome set (COS) is a standardised set of outcomes which
should be measured and reported, as a minimum, in all effectiveness trials for a
specific health area. This will allow results to be compared, contrasted and combined as appropriate, as well as ensuring that all trials contribute usable information. The aim of this review was to identify studies which sought to determine
which outcomes or domains to measure in all clinical trials in a specific condition,
and to describe the methodological techniques used in these studies. Methods:
We developed a multi-faceted search strategy for electronic databases (MEDLINE,
SCOPUS, and Cochrane Methodology Register). We included studies which sought
to determine which outcomes/domains to measure in all clinical trials in a specific
condition. Results: 198 studies (250 reports) were included in the review. Studies
covered various areas of health, most commonly cancer, rheumatology, neurology,
heart and circulation, and dentistry and oral health. A variety of methods have been
used to develop COS, including semi-structured discussion, unstructured group
discussion, the Delphi Technique, Consensus Development Conference, surveys and
Nominal Group Technique. The most common groups involved were clinical experts
and non-clinical research experts. Thirty-one (16%) studies reported that the public
had been involved in the process. The geographic locations of participants were predominantly North America (n= 164; 83%) and Europe (n= 150; 76%). Conclusions:
This review has brought together the existing research in a single place. COS will
increase the efficiency and value of the research process and make it easier for
people to make well-informed decisions about health care. Design of new trials
will be simplified, risk of measuring inappropriate outcomes reduced, and selective reporting of outcomes less likely. We have highlighted future areas of research,
including the need for methodological guidance for COS development and better
reporting of COS studies.
PHP183
The Role of Patients in Clinical Research and Evidence Based
Decision Making as Reported Via A Survey of Patient Advocates
Holtorf A P 1, Palacios D 2, Brixner D 3
1Health Outcomes Strategies, Basel, Switzerland, 2Novartis Pharma AG, Basel, Switzerland,
3University of Utah, Salt Lake City, UT, USA
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Increasingly, patients are becoming more active contributors to
research. The purpose of this survey was to understand the experience and expectations of patient organizations (POs) with clinical research and patient reported
outcomes. Methods: An online survey was conducted in English language during
May 2014 among 40 participants of a global cross disease patient forum. The information was used to provide background regarding patients as active contributors in
clinical research. The participants represent a broad range of disease specific and
general patient organizations from various countries including USA, European countries, Asia, Latina America, Middle East and Australia. Results: The most important
deficiencies of current clinical research practice were described as a lack of patient
friendly reporting, incomplete reporting and a lack of patient involvement in the
study design. Over the half of respondents stated that clinical trials are conducted
in a way that does not yield information relevant to the patients. Active involvement
in clinical trials was specified through 79 different expectations which fell into 7
categories: (1) Accessibility of new medicines (2) More representative patient selection for studies (3) Transparent conduct of the study (4) Better information on safety
and risks to participants (5) Active versus passive role of patients (6) Contribution
to innovation (7) Improved result reporting; especially to patients. One third of the
respondents have already been actively involved in clinical research and felt that this
was a mostly positive experience. Globally, patients and patient organizations are
becoming increasingly involved in clinical research through multiple formal or informal routes of engagement. Conclusions: Patients should be better represented in
clinical research and consulted for patient relevant study aspects in order to provide
information of greater relevance to patients in their own therapeutic decisions.
PHP184
Drug Repurposing as An Efficient Strategy In Drug Development –
Example Of Cns Area
Toumi M 1, Murteira S 2, Caban A 3, Kornfeld A 4
1University Aix-Marseille, Marseille, France, 2Lundbeck Japan KK, Tokoyo, Japan, 3CreativeCeutical, Paris, France, 4Creativ-Ceutical, Paris, France
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Traditionally, drug repurposing has been considered as a cost-effective
and a reduced-risk strategy for developing new drugs. Currently little is known and
documented regarding efficiency of repositioning strategies in drug development.
The objective of this article is to assess the meaning of this process with focus on
CNS area. We aim to identify the repositioning strategies that conducted to the
discovery and development of new CNS products as well as identify the source and
target indication and development status. Methods: In order to identify repurposing cases that target CNS, an extensive research was performed. It included a
literature review as well as search of websites of organizations engaged in promoting and development of drug repurposing. Cases were extracted from the source
material. For each molecule, its initial and target indication as well as development
status was recorded. Each case was classified by type of repurposing strategy (repositioning, reformulation or both). Results: 109 source products were identified.
They were repositioned 183 times. About one third of the source products have
been repositioned more than one time. Half of new indications was approved. The
majority of cases were repositioned while only 10 were reformulated and 16 were
reformulated and repositioned at the same time. The highest number of repurposed
molecules was originating from CNS therapeutic area (67 molecules targeted 127
indications). Among new therapeutic indications alcohol / opioid / drug dependence
was targeted most often (20 repositions). Regarding repositions within CNS area,
Schizophrenia, Epilepsy and Depression were the richest sources of repositioned
drugs with 10 and more products each. Conclusions: Drug repurposing in CNS is
an efficient and currently very active drug development strategy, exemplified by the
considerable amount of new indications that have been found via this strategy, with
approximately half of the target indications being currently under development.
PHP185
Components of Sustainable Health Systems: What Is Known About
The Cost-Effectiveness of Clinical Care?
Tordrup D , Stephan L , Bertollini R
World Health Organization, Bruxelles, Belgium
.
.
.
Objectives: Evidence to ensure cost-effective purchasing of services are an
important pre-requisite for ensuring financial sustainability of health systems.
The Research Agenda for Health Economic Evaluation project aims to map out the
economic evidence available for the treatment of the 10 highest burden conditions
in the European Union and identify evidence gaps. Methods: The 10 highest
burden diseases are selected by Disability Adjusted Life Years (DALYs) based on
the Global Burden of Disease study for Europe (Ischemic Heart Disease, Low Back
Pain, Stroke, Major Depressive Disorder, Lung Cancer, Falls, COPD, Diabetes, Other
musculoskeletal, Neck pain). Clinical pathways are generated for these conditions by
merging published clinical guidelines from public and professional bodies. Economic
(cost-benefit and cost-effectiveness) evidence indexed by MEDLINE is stratified by
treatment pathways to identify evidence gaps. Existing reviews are analysed to
assess coverage of primary evidence. Results: Results are presented for diabetes:
1,208 articles were retrieved from MEDLINE, of which 315 mapped to the treatment
pathway. Most evidence was published after 2000. 74 reviews were identified, of
which 24 were published between 2009-13. Volume of economic studies for each
treatment ranged from 0 to 39 studies. The most intensively studied were diabetic
retinopathy (n= 39), foot ulcers (n= 34) and renal disease (n= 31). Areas with no economic evidence included non-pharmacological blood pressure and dyslipidemia
control. In some cases economic evidence was available, but no recent reviews of
the evidence were identified (eg. islet or pancreas transplantation, diabetic neuropathy, interventions for weight loss). Conclusions: Economic evidence was
available for the majority of treatment modalities for diabetes, however for several
treatments no studies were identified. Importantly, reviews were not identified
for several treatments where economic evidence was available. Lack of economic
evidence prevents cost-effective commissioning, and lack of reviews of evidence
may be a further barrier to translation.
PHP186
Health Care Reform in China And The United States: A Tale of Two
Nations Seeking To Improve Access To Affordable Coverage
Moore R
Decision Resources Group, Nashville, TN, USA
.
Objectives: China and the United States have approved massive health care
reforms seeking to increase access to affordable health care services. Both countries employed a composite of government programs and private enterprises
designed to improve efficiencies in their health care markets. This study compares the results of these health care reforms so far, explores the longer-term
prognoses and considers how lessons learnt can inform health care reform elsewhere. Methods: In the U.S., 80 MCOs and 240 physicians were surveyed about
their participation in reform programs. Quarterly data on the uninsured and health
care cost trend data were also assessed. In China, 670 patients were surveyed
regarding their access to a health care provider. Results: Early returns show
mixed results that stem from policy decisions inherent in the original programs
as well as from national political considerations. Overall, both the U.S. and China
health care reforms are enjoying success but have shortcomings. In the U.S, partisanship, technology issues, and implementation uncertainties have undermined
the reform legislation. However, the nation’s uninsured rate declined from 17.1%
in Q4 2013 to 13.4% in Q2 2014, and the health care cost trend has fallen. Moreover,
the predicted spike in emergency room utilization has not yet appeared. In China,
the percentage of citizens with coverage increased from 30% in 2003 to 95% in 2011,
while patients’ share of out-of-pocket costs fell. However, improvement is felt less
in rural regions and demand for services is increasing. Consequently, Chinese
citizens still have difficulty accessing health care providers, which, combined
with inadequate reimbursement rates, means health care in China remains suboptimal. Conclusions: Together with early coverage statistics, responses from
both the U. S. and China to challenges in their respective health care reform efforts
indicate that long-term success is achievable. Their experiences underscore the
A436
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
need for political unity, substantial financial investments, and adaptability when
faced with obstacles and suboptimal results.
PHP187
The Future of Education In HTA and Health Economics
Carroll C , Beecroft C , Miller L
The University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: An increasing range of online education is available to those working
in the field of pharmaco-economics and Health Technology Assessment (HTA). The
aim of this study was to explore the market for free online education in HTA and to
assess the practicalities of delivering a free, interactive short-course. Methods:
We delivered a 5-week online course at the end of 2013 following the principles of the Massive Open Online Course (MOOC) approach: the HTA MOOC. The
programme covered the basics of HTA: What it is; how new technologies are
identified; how they are evaluated; the principal means of assessing clinical and
cost-effectiveness; and how HTA is used within different health systems to inform
reimbursement decisions. The course was provided through the Coursesites, a free,
open-access, education platform. Materials were adapted from an existing online
MSc programme. Descriptive statistics of participants were recorded and a survey
conducted of participants’ experiences. Results: 2039 individuals registered for
the HTA MOOC, of which 1508 completed a voluntary survey giving basic sociodemographic data about themselves. Participants were from Europe (55%), Asia
(16%) and North America (13%) and accessed the MOOC to gain knowledge about
the subject (78%), and specifically for career development (56%). 531/2039 (26%)
of those registered in Week 1 completed the MOOC (i.e. submitted all required
weekly assessments by the end of Week 5), compared to an average of 5-6% for
MOOCs generally [THES 2013]. Students reported the principal strength of the
programme to be the quality and usefulness of the learning materials, and the
principal issue to be time required (workload was considered by some to exceed
the 4-5 hours/week intended). Conclusions: The MOOC approach offers scope
for delivering flexible, effective and accessible education to small or large international cohorts of professionals, patients and providers working within HTA and
pharmaco-economics.
PHP190
Pharmacoeconomic Education in Brazilian Schools of Pharmacy
Freitas G 1, Balbinotto G 2
.
.
1UFRGS, Porto Alegre, Brazil, 2Universidade
Federal Do Rio Grande Do Sul, PORTO ALEGRE, Brazil
Objectives: The objective of this study was to survey the pharmacy schools in
Brazil to determine the extent of education in pharmacoeconomics offered during
the school year 2012-2013. Methods: A questionnaire based on previous studies
was developed. This was emailed to 55 pharmacy schools in Brazil during October
and December 2013. The schools were selected from the Ministry of Education
website. Public and private University schools (only those that have high concepts
in the National Examination Performance of Students) were included. In addition,
a search was made in the database directories of research groups from National
Council for Scientific and Technological Development (CNPq). Results: Of the 55
questionnaires sent, 16 were returned (29%). Only two schools do not address the
education of pharmacoeconomics in any moment. Most of schools address some
concepts in different subjects (8 hours). Five schools have formal courses that
teach only pharmacoeconomics and health technology assessment (over 30 hours).
All agree that the education of pharmacoeconomics is important and ten schools
believe that very few hours are devoted to the teaching pharmacoeconomics at
his university. In search of directories of research groups 23 groups that develop
research in the area of pharmacoeconomics in Brazil were found. Conclusions:
There is a large deficit in the availability of courses pharmacoeconomics in Brazil
at both the undergraduate and graduate. There is a great opportunity for experienced individuals to fill this gap. Provide an education in pharmacoeconomics
for pharmacy students is especially important in the context of evidence-based
decisions and when health issues and allocation of scarce resources is a priority
for Brazil.
PHP191
Application of A ‘Nice Post-Hoc B/S Analysis’ To the Nice Appraisal
Process
Macaulay R
HERON Commercialization, London, UK
.
Objectives: Post-hoc subgroup analyses are still used in clinical trials of medical technologies to identify patient populations in whom greatest benefits can
be achieved, despite this being derided as an analytical approach. Indeed, using
such an approach, aspirin has been shown to be ineffective versus placebo in
acute myocardial infarction patients born under the star signs of Libra and Gemini
(ISIS-2, 1988, Lancet) and endarterectomy is only efficacious in treating symptomatic stenosis patients born on a Monday, Wednesday, or Friday (ECST group, 1998,
Lancet). This research aimed to determine what effect the name of a drug has
on the National Institute of Health and Care Excellence (NICE) appraisal process
by applying a post-hoc analysis that compares the rates of acceptance by the
first letter of the drug or technology name using a Chi-squared test. Methods:
All final appraisal determinations resulting from Single Technology Appraisal
(STA) or Multiple Technology Appraisal (MTA) processes were identified up
to April 2014 from which the first letter of the generic name and the decision
were extracted. Results: 481 appraisals were identified, 371 (77%) of which
were approved (defined as ‘recommended’ or ‘optimised’), spanning all letters
of the alphabet except J, K, W, X, and Y. The lowest approval rates by letter were
for B (64%, 14/22) and S (69%, 18/26). Drugs beginning with a B or S were significantly less likely to be approved than drugs beginning with any other letter
(p= 0.0072). Conclusions: Based on this ‘NICE post-hoc B/S analysis,’ manufacturers should consider lobbying the World Health Organization to give their new
pharmaceuticals International Nonproprietary Names beginning with ‘B’ or ‘S’
to optimise success rates in the NICE appraisal process. Alternatively, regulators
and HTA bodies should continue to view efficacy claims on the basis of post-hoc
sub-group analyses with great scepticism.
PHP192
Impact of Story Books on Promoting Knowledge and Behavior of
4th Stage Elementary Students About Rational Use of Medicines in
Kermanshah Provine of Iran 2008
Mohammadhosseini N
National Committee on Rational Drug use, Tehran, Iran
.
Objectives: Evaluation of the impact of children stories on promotion
of the knowledge and behavior of 4 th stage elementary students about
rational use of medicines in the Kermanshah elementary schools. Methods:
64 elementary schools were selected in Kermanshah province of Iran. The
schools were categorized into 3 groups (rich, medium and poor level) based on
their students’ economic level. Both boys and girls were involved. Two checklists
were designed in order to evaluate students’ knowledge and behavior before
and after the intervention. A story book which was published by National
Committee of Rational Drug Use (RUD) conveyed to the students as the intervention. Results: The correlation between pre and post intervention and the
schools economic levels and the gender of students were obtained. The knowledge change rates were 21.83%, 22.28% and 17.40% for rich, medium and poor
schools respectively. The change rate for girls was greater in comparison to
that of boys. Conclusions: It is concluded that children stories as an educational intervention causes valuable positive changes on students’ knowledge
and behavior regarding hygiene and medicine. Implementing such interventions among children, result in promoting rational use of medicines in future
of the society.
PHP193
Clinical Trials in France: An Underexploited Opportunity
Mahi L , Mahi I
Axelys Sante Affaires Medicales et Recherche Clinique, Paris, France
.
.
Objectives: Despite high-performance infrastructures and recognized
expertise, Clinical trials (CT) are declining in France. Health Professionals
deplore the burdens of the French administration that leads to a real concern
regarding the international scientific competition. In addition patients are reluctant to participate in CT especially after the benfluorex scandale. Methods: one
of the witnesses of the competitiveness of France in CT is the activities among
Clinical Investigation Centers (CIC). These are plateforms fully dedicated to clinical and scientific research acting as an interface between INSERM units (Public
National Institut of Scientific Research) and CHU (University Hospital). Results:
There are 54 CIC in France. They have been created between 1992 and 2009. CICs
are located in university hospitals (CHU) dessiminated in the most important
regions of the country. The specific needs of CHU and researchers have led to
implement several types of CICs: multi-topics (24 CIC-P), Clinical Epidemiology
(9 CIC-EC), integrated in biotherapy (11 CIC-BT) and technological innovations (8
CIC-IT). During the last quadrennium, CIC-P supervised about 1000 protocols, of
which 2/3 were therapeutic and 1/3 on physiopathology. 25% of protocols conducted in CIC-P were translational in collaboration with INSERM units, 20% were
for rare diseases, 35% were funded by industry and 36% by the PHRC (Academic
funding). The AP-HP (Academic Hospitals of Paris Area) is the major sponsor in
France and one of the first in Europe, with 500 clinical trials enrolling more than
17,000 patients in 2010. Despite this development, the number of CT submissions to ANSM (French Regulatory Agency) decreased from 1,000 in 2008 to 895 in
2012. ANSM approuved 705 protocols in 2012 versus 790 in 2008. Conclusions:
Despite appropriate structures and willingness to encourage scientific production, clinical trails remain underexploited due to different causes which need to
be deeply evaluated.
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Health Technology Assessment
Programs
PHP194
Will Value Based Assessment (VBA) Revolutionise The Nice
Assessment?
Heemstra L 1, Purchase J L 2, Van Engen A 1
1Quintiles Consulting, Hoofddorp, The Netherlands, 2Quintiles Consulting, Reading, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In March, the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE)
revealed their plans to implement Value Based Assessment (VBA) in their Technology
Appraisal process: VBA will replace NICE’s end-of-life criteria. Instead wider societal impact (WSI) and burden of illness (BOI) will be systematically included in the
assessment through absolute and proportional Quality Adjusted Life Year (QALY)
shortfall. However, it is unclear whether these elements will impact NICE’s recommendations. Methods: The BOI and WSI for the 26 examples provided by NICE
was compared with an average displaced treatment in the NHS. Assuming that both
elements were weighted equally, an average QALY shortfall rating was calculated.
This was then transformed into a hypothetical willingness to pay (WTP) threshold
ranging from £20,000 for the drug with the lowest rating to £50,000 per QALY for
the drug with the highest rating. The hypothetical WTP was compared with the
most plausible ICER and recommendation from NICE. Results: Multiple Sclerosis,
rheumatoid and psoriatic arthritis, as well as oncology indications were associated
with a high BOI/WSI. Six of the 26 examples had higher most plausible ICERs than
the estimated threshold. Two of these six were still recommended using end-oflife criteria (metastatic melanoma and mCRPC), whereas the remainder were not
recommended by NICE. Three of the 26 examples had ICERs below the estimated
WTP threshold but higher than £30,000, and were still recommended. All of these
recommendations mentioned additional value elements such as innovation, end-of-
A437
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
life criteria or even QoL impact on family. Conclusions: This analysis presented
a possible scenario for the implementation of VBA. None of the drugs with a negative recommendation would get a positive recommendation under this scenario.
The products at most risk are those currently accepted using end-of-life criteria.
However, how the new value elements will be weighted has yet to be determined.
PHP195
The Evolution of International Reference Pricing: An Analysis of
39 Countries
Lockwood C , Marinoni G , Ando G
IHS, London, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: To characterise country-level changes to international reference
pricing (IRP) policy frameworks across 39 markets, and understand how countries amend this tool. Methods: Qualitative interviews were conducted with 50
stakeholders across 39 markets, representing 37 payers or payer influencers and 13
industry stakeholders. These interviews focused on country-level IRP methodology,
both past and present. Extensive secondary research of government websites and
existing literature was also conducted. A qualitative and semi-quantitative analysis
of these findings was undertaken to identify key trends in how IRP has been modified as a policy tool since implementation. Results: Of the markets considered,
IRP has remained comparatively stable – in terms of both the countries comprising
the reference basket and the underlying formula for determining the reference price
remaining unchanged – in just under one-third of the 39 markets. In contrast, just
over one-third of these markets have modified their IRP baskets to include one or
more additional countries with the objective of lowering prices. A smaller number
have made substantive changes to the IRP formula itself, notably with four markets
transitioning from taking the average price of their basket as a reference to either
taking the average of the three lowest or taking the lowest. Conclusions: IRP
serves as a dynamic policy tool, changing to reflect individual country circumstances and broader policy reform over time. While a number of markets have
maintained a stable IRP regime since inception, a larger number have made some
changes, the most common being to add one or more markets to the reference
basket. Although changes to IRP are mostly concentrated in Eastern European markets, as well as Western European markets most impacted by the recent economic
crisis, the present study also suggests that there is considerable variation across
geographies and time in how countries adapt their use of IRP.
PHP196
Making Sense of Nice’s ‘New’ MTA and STA Process Guide: A Narrative
Synthesis
Urbich M , Mildred M
Boehringer Ingelheim Ltd, Bracknell, UK
.
.
Objectives: NICE’s guides to the process of Multiple Technology Appraisals (MTA)
and Single Technology Appraisals (STA) provide a valuable source of information
to enable stakeholders to engage in Health Technology Appraisals (HTAs). NICE
recently conducted a review of the process guides which has implications for all
stakeholders involved with MTAs and STAs. The objective of this analysis was to
identify the number and type of amendments within the guides in order to highlight the most important changes for consultees and commentators. Methods:
Narrative synthesis was used to systematically identify, classify and explore the
impact of the proposed amendments to the MTA and STA process guides. The
hypothesis was that the amalgamation of the MTA and STA guides would simplify
both TA processes whilst increasing rigour and transparency. Sources of reference
were the draft of the new process guide, the NICE Senior Management Team Board
Cover Paper, and the 2009 MTA and STA process guides. Results: Amendments
were classified as relating to the process itself (26%), data and confidential information (44%), terminology (7%), and others (22%). Of the 27 amendments to the
MTA and STA process guides, 4 (15%) were identified as major amendments which
warrant specific appreciation. Major amendments included: (1) the STA decision
problem meeting moving to after the Department of Health referral; (2) stricter rules
around the marking of confidential information; (3) full publication of MTAs; and
(4) MTAs now have the opportunity to go straight to Final Appraisal Determination
(FAD) following the first committee meeting. Conclusions: The draft process
guide suggests that the new MTA and STA processes will foster greater engagement between stakeholders early on, increase transparency, and enable patients
to have quicker access to innovative medicines which are able to go straight to FAD.
PHP197
Methodological Requirements Regarding Quality of Life
Measurement in the Early Assessment of Benefit In Germany
Blome C , Augustin M , Lohrberg D
University Medical Center Hamburg-Eppendorf, Hamburg, Germany
.
.
sis, and interpretation emerged. Dominant topics included: the appropriate level of
disease-specificity of QoL instruments; required evidence on an instrument’s validity and on the validity of a minimal important difference; appropriate duration of
QoL assessment; consequences of potential bias due to unblinded study design or
missing data; interpretation of results that differed between subscales of an instrument; non-acceptance of surrogate endpoints for QoL. Conclusions: Evidence
on QoL can have high impact on the additional benefit determined by the G-BA.
Therefore, QoL assessment and analysis in clinical studies that shall enter benefit
dossiers should confirm with a range of methodological requirements.
.
Objectives: In Germany, an early assessment of benefit (EAB) is required for new
medicines since January 2011. The pharmaceutical manufacturer submits a dossier
on additional benefit over comparative treatment which is subsequently evaluated
by the Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care (IQWiG). Stakeholders can
comment on the evaluation in a formal comments procedure. The final decision
on additional benefit is made by the Federal Joint Committee (G-BA); it provides the
basis for price negotiations between manufacturer and statutory health insurance
funds. Quality of life (QoL) is one of four criteria for benefit evaluation. This qualitative study aimed to determine methodological requirements for QoL measurement
in the German EAB. Methods: A qualitative content analysis according to Mayring
was conducted. Documents of all EABs completed until December 2013 (including
dossier, IQWiG evaluation, protocol of the oral hearing, and G-BA decision) were
searched for the term QoL or synonyms. Relevant passages were extracted and
reduced to key content by two researchers independently. On the basis of subsequent consensus building, recurring themes of the term’s usage in the EAB process
were identified. Results: In the 66 early assessments of benefit included in the
analysis, a range of methodological requirements regarding QoL assessment, analy-
PHP198
Exploring The Flaws in Cost-Effectiveness Models That Lead to
Rejection of Nice Submissions
Griffiths E A , Hendrich J
PAREXEL, London, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: New health technologies are required to demonstrate both clinical and
cost-effectiveness before recommendation by the National Institute for Health and
Care Excellence (NICE) for reimbursement in England; however, a large proportion
of submissions are rejected due to non-robust economic analysis. Published NICE
guidance includes a comprehensive critique of submitted economic evidence so, to
help inform future submissions, we assessed the flaws in cost-effectiveness models
leading to rejection by NICE. Methods: All NICE single technology appraisals from
January 2006 to May 2014 were included in the analysis. Multiple technology appraisals, resubmissions, vaccination programmes, requests for advice, and submissions
where an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) could not be determined were
excluded. Recommendations and reasoning across decisions were extracted, with
a focus on the critique of the economic evidence. Results: 121 NICE submissions
met the inclusion criteria, 28 (19.8%) of which were rejected. Non-robust economic
analysis was one of the listed reasons for rejection in 75.0% (21) of cases, and in all
cases where the submitted ICER was below the £30,000 cost-effectiveness threshold. Within these submissions, the key drivers behind rejection due to non-robust
cost-effectiveness modelling were: a high level of uncertainty in inputs (leading to a
sensitive or unreliable ICER) (in 90.5% of cases); mishandling of data (e.g., overstated
treatment effect or failure to account for adverse events) (85.7%); misalignment to
the reference case (e.g., inappropriate comparator or weak methodology) (38.1%);
and unrealistic assumptions (38.1%). Conclusions: Non-robust economic analysis
is one of the main reasons behind rejection of NICE submissions, largely due to high
uncertainty, or selective use of data to favor the health technology being appraised.
Early modelling may allow manufacturers to identify and address sources of uncertainty or weakness early in the clinical development process, in order to construct
a convincing and robust economic argument ahead of reimbursement submission.
PHP199
Is it Possible to Predict The Market Access of a New Pharmaceutical
in Germany? A Systematic Evaluation of Federal Joint Committee
Decisions on Early Benefit Assessments According to The German
Law For Reforming The Market of Pharmaceuticals
Schwander B 1, Banz K 2, Kaier K 3, Walzer S 4
GmbH, Loerrach, Germany, 2Outcomes International, Basel, Switzerland, 3University
of Freiburg, Freiburg, Germany, 4MArS Market Access & Pricing Strategy GmbH, Weil am Rhein,
Germany
.
.
.
.
1AHEAD
Objectives: As of 1st January 2011 the German drug market is regulated by the
act of the reorganization of the pharmaceutical market (AMNOG). Since then the
normal procedure for reimbursement of a new pharmaceutical is an early benefit
assessment by the joint federal committee (G-BA) which determines one of six
additional benefit levels. According to AMNOG any specification of the reimbursement price shall be based on the outcomes of the early benefit assessment. Hence
this assessment takes a key role for market access of a new drug in Germany which
poses the question whether it is possible to predict the level of additional benefit
that will be established by the G-BA. Methods: In order to evaluate a possible
predictor of G-BA decisions, the ‘evaluation of pharmaceutical innovations (EVITA)’
score was calculated and retrospectively compared with 40 published G-BA decisions. The EVITA algorithm evaluates a new compound for a given indication and in
relation to a relevant comparator on the basis of randomized controlled trial (RCT)
evidence. EVITA translates the RCT outcomes on the therapeutic benefit and risk
profile into rating points, which are expressed as a total EVITA score. Results:
Univariate ordinary least squares and ordered logit regression analyses show statistically significant correlations between EVITA scores and the G-BA additional
benefit levels. Moreover, for the prediction of an additional benefit level of at least
‘minor’, an EVITA score cutpoint of ≥ 3 is associated with a sensitivity of 100% and
a specificity of 80%. For the prediction of an additional benefit level of at least ‘considerable’, an EVITA score cutpoint of ≥ 7.5 is associated with a sensitivity of 100%
and a specificity of 93.1%. Conclusions: The present investigation indicates that
the EVITA score may have the potential for the prediction of G-BA decisions related
to AMNOG early benefit assessments.
PHP200
Selection of Topics For Nice Technology Appraisal 2005-2011: What
Matters Most?
Ward D J 1, Shiyka A 2, Fellows R 1
1NIHR Horizon Scanning Centre, Birmingham, UK, 2University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) undertakes appraisals of selected health technologies, and those judged to be costeffective must be funded for use on the National Health Service in England and
Wales. Obtaining a positive appraisal decision is therefore important to commercial developers seeking market access, who require consistent application of topic
selection criteria (which were amended in 2009). We sought to establish which
characteristics of drugs or their indications were most important in the decision
to undertake an appraisal. Methods: All marketing authorisations (MAs) granted
A438
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
2005-2011 for new drugs and new indications for existing drugs were identified
from the European Medicines Agency (EMA) website. The decision to undertake an
appraisal was obtained from the NICE website and NIHR Horizon Scanning Centre
records, and the associations between this and characteristics of the drug and
intended patient population were then determined. Results: For 2005-2011, we
identified 134 MAs granted by the EMA (116 new drugs and 18 new indications) of
which 72 (54%) were selected for appraisal. The decision to undertake an appraisal
was significantly associated with an MA granted 2009-2011 (OR= 2.3, p< 0.01), the
drug being a biological agent (OR= 3.9, p< 0.01), administered on a long-term basis
(OR= 1.8, p< 0.05), indicated for a patient population < 1 in 1,000 (OR= 2.1, p< 0.05), or
for malignant disease (OR= 5.1, p< 0.01). It was not associated with an indication for
more severe disease (OR= 2.0, p= 0.06), an MA issued for a new indication (OR= 1.4,
p= 0.50), or whether a drug was first-of-kind (OR= 1.8, p= 0.10). Conclusions: We
identified several characteristics associated with the decision to undertake an
appraisal relating to both the drug and intended patient population that do not
completely match published topic selection criteria (e.g. severity). Further analyses
are required to determine which are the most relevant factors in this decision.
recommendations, comparison of patient pathways and specific type of patient
input desired. Two reviewers extracted methodological details, study designs, and
outcomes into summary tables. Results: We identified 21 articles out of a total of
18,829 studies. Articles covered multiple subject areas. Process improvements were
most common (4 studies) followed by current perceptions (3 studies), comparison
of patient pathways (2 studies) and specific type of patient input desired (1 study).
Research methodologies and stakeholders varied widely including telephone, web
audit, interview /questionnaire and literature review. Stakeholders varied between
national & international HTA agencies, experts and patient groups. Three studies
involved patient groups and one involved patients. These studies informed the role,
process and nature of input but did not address the impact on HTA decision making. Conclusions: Compared to other HTA areas there is a lack of published material on PAG involvement. There have been many attempts to provide a framework
for patient involvement but so far none has been used in HTA decision-making.
Existing data does not help to quantify role of the patient in HTA decision making.
Additional research is needed to understand and quantify patient group input in
HTA decisions.
PHP201
Determination of Cost-Effectiveness Threshold For Malaysia
PHP204
Trends and Key Decision Drivers For Rejecting An Orphan Drug
Submission Across Five Different HTA Agencies
Lim Y W , Shafie A A , Chua G N , Hassali M A A
Universiti Sains Malaysia, Penang, Malaysia
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
PHP202
Systematic Review of Economic Evaluation of Health Technologies
Developed In Brazil From 1980-2013
Decimoni T C 1, Leandro R 1, Soarez P 1, Craig D 2
1Sao Paulo University, São Paulo, Brazil, 2University of York, York, Brazil
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The aim of this study is to review published economic evaluation of
health technologies conducted in Brazil. Methods: Systematic review of economic
evaluations studies published in MEDLINE, EMBASE, LILACS, SciELO, NHS EED, HTA
Database, Web of Science, SCOPUS, BVS ECOS and SISREBRATS from 1980 to 2013.
Full (Cost consequence analysis - CCA, cost minimization analysis - CMA, costeffectiveness analysis - CEA, cost-utility analysis - CUA, and cost-benefit analysis
- CBA) and partial (cost description - CD and cost analysis - CA) economic evaluation studies were eligible for inclusion if at least one of the authors was Brazilian
and was affiliated to a Brazilian institution. Two independent reviewers screened
articles for relevance and carried out data extraction. Disagreements were resolved
through discussion or through consultation with a third reviewer. We performed a
qualitative narrative synthesis. Results: We identified 11946 records and 557 met
inclusion criteria. One hundred and ninety (34.1%) were full (of these, 56.6% CEA,
20.3% CCA, 12.7% CUA, 5.6% CMA, and 4.7% CBA), and 367 were partial economic
evaluation (of these, 64.7% CD and 32.3% CA). The main health problem studied were
Infectious and Parasitic diseases (17.1%), Diseases of the Circulatory System (12.3%)
and Neoplams (10.3%). The majority (72.9%) was conducted by authors from the
southeast region, and south region (12.6%), mainly linked to academia (69.5%), and
54.2% were published in medical and 18.9% in public health journals. Seventy-two
(14.7%) studies reported to be funded by industry and 16% was considered to have
conflict of interest. Conclusions: There was a considerable growth in the conduct
and publication of economic evaluation studies in Brazil. A qualitative evaluation
of the methodology used in those studies is important to legitimize their use in the
process of local decision-making.
PHP203
A Literature Review of Patient Advocacy Group (Pag) Involvement
in HTA
Hicks N 1, Hawken N A 2, Arvin-berod C 1, Toumi M 3
1Commutateur, Paris, France, 2Creativ-Ceutical, Luxembourg, Luxembourg, 3University AixMarseille, Marseille, France
.
.
.
.
Mardiguian S , Stefanidou M , Sheppard F
PAREXEL, London, UK
.
Objectives: Decision on the cost-effectiveness (CE) of health care technologies
usually creates an argument especially when alternatives are more expensive but
more effective. In this situation, external criterion in the form of CE threshold or
willingness-to-pay for a quality-adjusted life-year (WTP/QALY) needs to be applied
to decide on its CE. Nevertheless, the lack of empirical and well-accepted CE threshold in Malaysia is recognized as one of the most important barriers in using health
technology assessment for decision making. This study was mainly done to determine the CE threshold value across Malaysian population, estimated in terms of
societal WTP for a QALY. Methods: A cross-sectional, contingent valuation study
was conducted using stratified multistage cluster random sampling technique in the
states of Penang, Kedah, Selangor and Kuala Lumpur Federal Territory. Respondents
were asked for the socioeconomic background, quality of life and their WTP for a
hypothetical EQ-5D health state scenario (treatment, extended life in terminal illness and life saving situations with three health severities – mild, moderate and
severe, and two QALY gained levels – 0.2 QALY and 0.4 QALY) using pre-designed
questionnaires. Interval model analysis was applied to determine the CE threshold. Results: One thousand thirteen respondents aged between 20–60 years old
who can understand either English or Malay language were interviewed face-toface. The mean value of CE threshold was determined at the range of MYR 19,929 to
MYR 28,469 (~ USD 6,200 to USD 8,900). Conclusions: By comparing our results to
Malaysian GDP per capita in the year 2013; ~ MYR 33,754 (~ USD 10,548), we noted
that the mean WTP/QALY is ranged between 0.59–0.84 times of GDP per capita.
.
Objectives: Patient input is an important part of the assessment process, yet sometimes seen as having a low evidence base. Previous work by the authors shows more
research is needed on identifying how the patient group contribution is impacting
decision making. Our objective was to review and critically appraise existing publications on PAG involvement in HTA. Methods: A search in Pubmed, Cochrane
and ISPOR databases since 2009 was undertaken to identify studies on patients
or PAG involvement in the HTA decision. Studies were evaluated for relevancy.
We extracted information on perceptions of patient input, process improvement
.
.
Objectives: Access to orphan drugs is often inconsistent, and is hindered by difficulties in demonstrating value in HTA appraisals due to the small patient populations and insufficient data. To inform future submissions, we examined the trends
and key decision drivers that resulted in a submission being rejected across five HTA
agencies. Methods: The Orphanet database was searched for orphan drugs with a
marketing authorisation between 2002 and 2014. To assume a certain level of competition, awareness and commercial potential, rare diseases for which two or more
orphan drugs were available were selected. Decisions from five HTA agencies were
considered: AWMSG (Wales), CADTH (Canada), NICE (England), PBAC (Australia),
and SMC (Scotland). Assessments that resulted in a rejection were examined for
key decision drivers, and for trends and variation by disease type. Results: A total
of 28 licensed orphan drugs were available for the treatment of eight rare diseases.
The number of orphan drugs assessed, and rejection rates, varied by HTA agency;
PBAC and SMC had the lowest rejection rates (4/18; 22% and 6/22; 27%, respectively),
while NICE had the highest rejection rate with 40% (4/10). Uncertainties regarding
clinical efficacy, and concerns over the robustness of economic evidence were the
key decision drivers that led to a rejection. Examination of data by disease type
indicated a trend towards higher rejection rates for diseases with a higher prevalence rate. Conclusions: The proportion of rejected submissions varied by HTA
agency, particularly within the HTA bodies in the UK, highlighting inconsistencies
in decision-making. An association between prevalence rate and the proportion of
rejected submissions was found, with lower rates of disease prevalence correlating
with higher acceptance rates. This is most likely due to the lower budget impact
incurred in smaller patient populations.
PHP205
Predictors of German Amnog Decisions and GKV Rebate
Negotiations: A Database Analysis
Verleger K 1, Schoeman O 1, Schmidt R 1, Wilke T 2, Heeg B 1
1Pharmerit International, Berlin, Germany, 2IPAM - Institute for Pharmacoeconomics and
Medication Logistics, Wismar, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: G-BA, IQWiG and GKV are the main governmental stakeholders in
the German AMNOG process. Based on manufacturer-submitted dossiers, the G-BA
assesses the drugs’ additional benefit per pre-defined subgroup. Subsequently, the
GKV negotiates rebates by drug. This research aims to describe factors influencing GB-A decisions and assess the association between additional benefit and
rebate. Methods: All G-BA decisions up to March 2014 were analyzed. Univariate
logistic regression was used to investigate the relationship of G-BA decisions
(dependent variable: additional benefit (y/n) per subgroup) with study characteristics. Study characteristics included were disease area (ATC-code), superiority/
non-inferiority study design, comparators used in the submitted trials (in/direct;
in/adequate comparator according to GBA [“ZVT”]), main area of claimed benefit
e.g. overall survival (OS). Linear regression was used to assess the impact of added
benefit (in at least one subgroup) on rebate. Results: Sixty-eight G-BA decisions,
with in total 137 G-BA subgroups, were included and analyzed. In total, 60.3% of
assessments resulted in an additional benefit. Most commonly, dossiers were submitted to the G-BA for ATC-codes L and A (39.7%; 19.1%). Out of 40 ATC-code L subgroups (27 drugs), 70.0% resulted in a positive assessment, with 50% demonstrating
a benefit in OS. Univariate logistic regression showed a significant relationship
between added benefit and: ATC-codes A/J/L; improvements in morbidity; adverse
events; direct comparators; and the ZVT (ORs: 0.1; 11.2; 6.0; 55.2; 24.3; 20.9; 15.2; all
p< 0.05). All drugs showing an OS advantage received a positive benefit assessment.
Added benefit reduced the rebate significantly by 13.1% (p< 0.05). Conclusions:
Key factors for a positive G-BA benefit assessment are improved OS, morbidity, and
adverse events, demonstrated through the use of direct “ZVT” comparators. ATCcodes J and L carry the highest chance of gaining a positive assessment. The rebate
negotiated with the GKV decreases significantly if an added benefit is determined.
PHP206
Nice Restrictiveness Compared To the Market Authorization
Jaksa A, Westbrook L , Rubinstein E , Daniel K , Ho Y S
Context Matters, Inc., New York, NY, USA
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To determine how often NICE recommendations are more restrictive
than the market authorizations. Methods: 161 NICE Technology Appraisal decisions from 2007-2013 were evaluated. These reviews included 80 unique drugs from
37 disease conditions. For each generic drug included in a review, the corresponding
A439
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
market authorization was retrieved from the EMA or MHRA. NICE positive decisions
were compared to the market authorizations. Any decision that included language
that restricted the population eligible for reimbursement for a given therapy was
categorized as “recommend with restrictions.” NICE positive decisions that were not
more restrictive than the market authorization were categorized as “recommend.”
Negative decisions were categorized as “do not recommend.” Restrictions were also
quantified and categorized. Results: NICE issued “do not recommend” decisions
in 32% of the reviews from 2007-2013. The overall rate at which NICE issued “do not
recommend” decisions increased after 2010, but this did not pass traditional levels of
statistical significance (p= .21). NICE issued positive decisions in 68% of reviews, but
the decision was more restrictive than the market authorization in 52% of the positive decisions. NICE’s restrictiveness has decreased since 2007, with the exception
of 2013 where 60% of NICE’s positive decisions were “recommend with restrictions.”
For the “recommend with restrictions” reviews, there are 1.7 restrictions on average
(range 1-4, s.d. 11) added to the market authorization. The most prevalent type of
restrictions were for contraindicated or intolerance.” Conclusions: In 2007-2013,
NICE issued “recommend with restrictions” decisions in 36% of reviews and issued
both “recommend” and “do not recommend” decisions in 32% of reviews. NICE was
more restrictive than the market authorization in 52% of the positive decisions,
though NICE’s restrictiveness seems to be declining over time. An independent
analysis of NICE decisions in 2007-2013 found a statistically significant different
distribution of decisions than reported in the NICE website (p= .01).
PHP207
Multicriteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) In HTA – Pilot Study in the
Czech Republic
Hajek P 1, Pecen L 2, Bulejova L 3, Cook M 4, Dolezal T 5, Dolezel J 6, Duba J 7, Dukova I 8, Fuksa
L 9, Heislerova M 10, Jaskova K 8, Karasek P 11, Klimes J 12, Kminek A 13, Kucera Z 14, Vesela Š 15,
Vothova P 1, Svihovec J 10
1Pfizer s.r.o., Prague, Czech Republic, 2CEEOR s.r.o., Prague, Czech Republic, 3InterMune,
Muttenz, Switzerland, 4BAYER s.r.o., Prague, Czech Republic, 5VALUE OUTCOMES, Prague,
Czech Republic, 6GlaxoSmithKline, s.r.o., Prague, Czech Republic, 7OAKS Consulting s.r.o., Prague
9, Czech Republic, 8Merck, Prague, Czech Republic, 9General Health Insurance Company of the
Czech Republic, Praha, Czech Republic, 10University Hospital in Motol, Prague, Czech Republic,
11Novartis s.r.o., Prague, Czech Republic, 12iHETA, Prague, Czech Republic, 13AstraZeneca, Prague,
Czech Republic, 14Sanofi-Aventis, Prague, Czech Republic, 15Janssen, Prague, Czech Republic
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Multicriteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) is an analytical quantitative
instrument focused on supporting the decision-making process between alternative
products based on multiple criteria. Methods: In the pilot study on MCDA application in HTA in the Czech Republic, the following criteria were chosen by the experts:
efficacy/effectiveness, safety, budget impact, disease severity, cost effectiveness
and unmet needs. The number of evaluators was 10. Each evaluator determined
weights within the range from 1 to 10 (from the least to the most important). The
resultant weights were displayed as an arithmetic mean of weights of the individual evaluators and as a trimmed mean with the minimum and maximum values
discarded. The weights were also calculated by discarding the last evaluator, i.e.
there were 4 sets of weights examined, each time normalized by 100%. Results:
Each evaluator rated 5 chosen medicines with weights 0, 1, 2, 3 within the chosen
categories. Afterwards, the mean scores and trimmed means with the lowest and
the highest values discarded were determined for each of the 5 medicinal products
chosen. All 8 estimates (4 weights times 2 mean scores) lead to the identical classification of medicinal products which proves the robustness of the approach. The
biggest divergences between the evaluators‘ assessment of the same medicinal
product was observed in case of its safety, whereas the slightest were considered
the budget impact and cost-effectiveness. On the other hand, the differences in
the cost-effectiveness assessment of the 5 medicinal products considered were
followed by the greatest discrepancies as regards the budget impact. The MCDA s
was compared with the classifications of the medicinal products based on the ICER
only which revealed significant differences (e.g., 2nd place according to the ICER
vs. 5th according to the MCDA). Conclusions: The MCDA brings new information
with respect to the each criterion‘s separate application.
PHP208
Out With The Old – In With The New: Would New Social Preference
Weights For Eq-5d Inevitably Require A Reappraisal of Previous CostEffectiveness Determinations?
Kind P , Meads D M
University of Leeds, Leeds, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: Social preferences are widely used in economic evaluation required by
regulatory agencies. In the UK, NICE requires the use of EQ-5D and its associated set
of TTO preference weights for computing QALYs. The weights in question date back
nearly two decades. It is reasonable to question whether they continue to represent
contemporary social preferences. Were a revised set of EQ-5D weights to be produced then would this necessitate the revision of all past appraisal decisions? This
paper presents the 1stphase of work designed to address that question. Methods:
The ICER is defined by the ratio of marginal cost (Δ C) /marginal benefit (Δ B). For a
given ΔC the ICER falls as ΔB increases. For a given threshold (λ ) and for a fixed incremental cost (Δ C), there is a minimum health benefit Δ Bmin (given by Δ C/λ ) which
must be achieved to produce an ICER that comes below that threshold limit. TTOweighted scores were computed for all 243 health states defined by the 3-level version of EQ-5D. A difference matrix was created in which D(i,j) contains the numeric
difference between the ith and jth state. The number of differences below a given
Δ Bmin was computed for each column (health state). Threshold values were varied
(£20,000-£50,000). Cost differences were varied (£500-£10,000). Results: Less than
10% of health state value differences failed to meet the minimum Δ Bmin of 0.0125
(Δ C = £500; λ = £20,000) indicating susceptability to changes in health state value,
however this proportion rose to 57% for higher incremental costs (e.g. Δ C = £3,000).
81/243 health states account for 50% of the differences that exceed Δ Bminat all
tested levels of Δ C and λ . Graphical representation of these Results can be used
to assess the need for reappraisal. Conclusions: For higher cost interventions,
relatively small differences in EQ-5D weights can generate ICERs with the propensity
to reverse previous cost-effectiveness decisions.
PHP209
Decision Drivers For Brazil: An Analysis of Conitec
Recommendations
Kreeftmeijer J 1, Skaltsa K 2, Palazzolo D 3
1Quintiles Consulting, Hoofddorp, The Netherlands, 2Quintiles Consulting, Barcelona, Spain,
3Quintiles Consulting, Reading, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: Since its establishment in December 2011, Brazil’s HTA body CONITEC
(National Commission on the Incorporation of Technologies), has published more
than 90 assessments. The objective of the present study was to perform an analysis
on CONITEC’s positive and negative decisions, in order to understand the main decision drivers. Methods: All assessments published by CONITEC between December
2001 and April 2014 were included in our analysis. The rationale for the decisions
was analyzed for both positive and negative recommendations. Reasons for recommending or rejecting a technology were summarized into categories. Results: In
total, 101 publications were identified: 67 of those assessed drugs, 12 a procedure or
intervention and 11 a medical device. The remaining 11 were clinical guidelines (not
included in the analysis). Overall, 46 recommendations were positive and 44 negative. The main reasons for rejection were concerns about the economic evidence
(23 reports) or lack to demonstrate significant additional clinical benefits (22). The
main reasons for positive recommendations were demonstrated clinical efficacy
benefit (21), low budget impact (19) and fulfillment of high unmet needs (15). In
the majority of cases, the decision was based on multiple factors. Conclusions:
Brazil has set the way for a more transparent process for technology assessment
following a formal process including pharmacoeconomic guidelines. However, insufficient clinical benefits and methodological concerns about the economic evaluation as major rejection drivers reveals that manufacturers are not yet addressing
CONITEC’s requirements. Full transparency on the evaluation of outcomes is still
missing, providing additional complexity for manufacturers towards a positive recommendation. Our results demonstrated a positive relation between acceptance
and demonstrated clinical efficacy, as well as a low budget impact. CONITEC seems
to follow a specific pathway in their decision that should be leveraged by manufacturers in order to increase their likelihood of receiving a positive recommendation.
PHP210
The Risky Business of Drug Development: The Final Say of National
Hta Agencies on A Pharmaceutical’s Benefit During The Last
Stretch of An Expensive, Long-Lasting And Arduous Development
Journey – As Illustrated By The Decisions Of Germany’s Gemeinsamer
Bundesausschuss (G-Ba)
Maetzel A 1, Staab T R 2, Ruof J 2
LLC, Chapel Hill, NC, USA, 2Roche Pharma, Grenzach-Wyhlen, Germany
.
.
.
.
1Berlikon
Objectives: Since 2011 Germany follows a formal process of evaluating new pharmaceuticals for their incremental benefit vs. an appropriate comparator to inform
price negotiations with Insurers. This study summarizes the rationale underlying
the German authorities’ (G-BA) final assessment of manufacturers’ submissions
following successful approval by regulators. Methods: G-BA decisions (1/2011 to
2/2014) were evaluated for their alignment (full, partial or none) between manufacturer’s development programs and expectations concerning: (1) target population; (2) comparator; (3) clinical endpoints, including indirect comparisons. Also
addressed was the role of safety and how the G-BA addressed the potential for
bias. Results: Of 69 completed submissions, 3 were resubmissions and 7 lacked
a dossier. 59 completed submissions were subjected to a detailed review. Ten (17%)
were for orphan disease indications. Major disagreement existed for 37 (63%), of
which 17 (46%) were considered fully inadequate, and 20 (54%) inadequate for significant subgroups. Main reasons for inadequacy were: wrong comparator (27 of 37
[73%], wrong endpoint 6 [16%] and use of historical controls (3 [11%]). For 34 (92%)
the major disagreement also led to a lower benefit judgment. All 19 indirect treatment comparisons were considered flawed. Safety was a differentiator for 24 of the
59 submissions, either primary (2) or in addition to efficacy (22). G-BA disagreed
with the manufacturer on safety for 12 (50%) of the 24 submissions. Conclusions:
This analysis of the first 3 years of G-BA’s early benefit appraisal illustrates that a
majority of the submissions fail to convince the German authorities despite having
obtained licensing approval. A wrong comparator was the main reason for full or
partial rejection. Indirect treatment comparisons were never accepted. Decisions
taken early in the development program have important repercussions on reimbursement negotiations with authorities in Germany.
PHP211
Hta Epidemiology Data in Different Geographical Regions:
Investigation of Requirements For Oncology Drugs
Chadda S , Chandler T
PHMR Associates, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK
.
.
Objectives: Harmonisation of health technology assessment (HTA) processes
between countries is a logical and efficient solution to complex data gathering
exercises required of pharmaceutical manufacturers when preparing submissions.
However, harmonisation is a slow process and potentially substantial differences
between countries exist. Further, some types of data will inevitably need to be
country-specific to meet local HTA requirements. Epidemiological data can be
considered one such source of information. Methods: We reviewed HTA requirements in Australia, England and Wales, Japan and Scotland for epidemiology data
requirements in their submission. Specific data types were identified and compared
across the geographical regions. Results: Clear requirements were available for
Australia (Pharmaceutical Benefits Advisory Committee [PBAC]), England and Wales
(National Institute for Health and Care Excellence [NICE]), and Scotland (Scottish
Medicines Consortium [SMC]). As of April 2014, there is an ongoing development
A440
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
of the HTA process in Japan, which is excluded from this analysis. NICE, PBAC and
the SMC all require the number of patients with the indicated disease and a clear
statement of patient numbers eligible for treatment per year for 5 years. Beyond
this, the requirements of the Australian PBC and the SMC were similar, specifying
prevalence, incidence and mortality data, whereas NICE requires a measure of disease burden (not clearly defined) and life expectancy among those with the disease.
The epidemiology requirements did not differ by disease area. Conclusions: HTA
bodies stipulate the inclusion of epidemiological data to estimate economic impact
of interventions. Some requirements are common to all agencies, but there are
also some important differences. Specific epidemiological data needs for individual
agencies must be considered by drug developers when planning and gathering
information for HTA submissions.
PHP212
Inclusion and Consideration of Patient Preferences in Amnog Early
Benefit Assessments
Obradovic M , Rauland M
GfK Market Access, Nuremberg, Germany
.
.
Objectives: To explore the inclusion and evaluation of patient preference data in
AMNOG early benefit dossiers. Methods: Patient perspective is becoming increasingly important in health care decision making. Health technology assessment (HTA)
agencies include patient views in their appraisals in different ways and to various
extents. Patient views and preferences can be captured either by engaging patient
organisations, patients themselves, or informal carers in the HTA process (as is
done for example in the UK or Canada). Such patient aspects can be also explored in
qualitative and quantitative studies which are considered as part of evidence documentation by the assessment committees. We have reviewed value dossiers and corresponding benefit assessments in Germany from 1st January 2011 to 31th March 2014.
Types of patient preference data included in the value dossiers and their consideration
in the assessments were collected and summarised. Results: A total of 68 dossiers
were analyzed. 18 dossiers (26%) included data on patient preferences. Those data
related to: a) relevance of different treatment endpoints from the patient’s perspective in oncology, hepatitis C, diabetes, or HIV infection; b) patient preference for a
specific drug administration route (e.g. oral vs. injections), administration system (e.g.
different inhalation systems), or administration frequency; c) patient preference for
therapy duration or type of therapy. In none of the assessment reports did the evaluating committee specifically address the evidence presented on patient preferences. A
comment on patient preference data was stated in one assessment report only (for
aclidiniumbromid). Conclusions: About a quarter of value dossiers referred to data
on patient preference. Surprisingly, it appears that the evidence on patient preference
has not been considered in the AMNOG benefit assessments despite the fact that
benefit to the patient is the central criterion of the AMNOG early benefit assessment.
PHP214
Rapid Relative Effectiveness Assessment of Pharmaceuticals:
Transferability and Completeness of Information Derived From
Global Value Dossiers To Complete A Eunethta Submission
Neeser K 1, Lister J 1, Stanisic S 2, Stengel C 1, Mueller E 1
1LASER ANALYTICA, Loerrach, Germany, 2LASER ANALYTICA, Milano, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: EUnetHTA is currently evaluating the applicability of the Core Model®
for Rapid Relative Effectiveness Assessment of Pharmaceuticals of selected drugs for
which a market authorization is intended between 2013 and 2015. A global value
dossier (GVD) represents an important tool for pharmaceutical manufacturer (PM)
to consolidate information on considered disease, its management and treatment, epidemiology, as well as health economic outcomes. The current study
is intended to quantify the information that may be transferable from a well
prepared, comprehensive GVD to EUnetHTA submission via gap analysis. The
EUnetHTA submission comprises of 4 modules: 1. Description of the health problem; 2. Technical characteristics of technology and appropriate comparator(s); 3.
Clinical effectiveness, and 4. Safety of the new drug. Methods: A GVD, developed
for a pharmaceutical product, was used as data source to evaluate the feasibility
to address all questions in the four EUnetHTA modules. Results: In modules 1
and 2 about 60% of data that are required to complete the EUnetHTA submission
are missing from the GVD. Most of this information (e.g. implementation of the
new drug, current use of the drug) may be easily obtained from other documents
held by PM. In modules 3 and 4 about 70% of queries cannot be answered without
additional assessments (e.g. complementary evidence synthesis, study quality
assessments), systematic searches (e.g. on-going unpublished studies) and additional sources. Conclusions: A GVD can be a useful pool of knowledge for a
new drug in a specific indication. Despite this large body of evidence, a considerable part of the information that is required for a EUnetHTA submission may be
missing from GVDs and needs to be derived from existing clinical study reports,
extensive systematic literature searches and additional evaluations. Applying of
validated and systematic methods during the GVD development process may
reduce additional work for assessment reports.
PHP215
Encepp-HTA Working Group Survey on Capacity To Conduct Research
in Support Of Health Technology Assessment
Toussi M 1, Lis Y 2, Qizilbash N 3, Blake K V 4, Ehrenstein V 5, Kurz X 4, Moore N 6, Sinclair M 7
Health, Paris La Défense, France, 2PAREXEL International, Uxbridge, UK, 3OXON
Epidemiology Limited and Department of Primary Care and Public Health, Imperial College,
London, UK, 4European Medicines Agency, London, UK, 5Aarhus University Hospital, Aarhus N,
Denmark, 6INSERM CIC-P 0005, Université de Bordeaux, CHU de Bordeaux, Bordeaux, France,
7University of Ulster, Newtownabbey, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1IMS
Objectives: In light of growing interest in Health Technology Assessment
(HTA) related outcomes being incorporated into post-authorisation studies (PAS)
of medicines, an HTA Working Group of the European Network of Centres for
Pharmacoepidemiology and Pharmacovigilance (ENCePP) has been established.
The Working Group’s current focus is on establishing baseline data to shape
the network’s activities in meeting emerging demands for evidence generation
in PAS. Therefore, an exploratory survey was undertaken to map current capabilities related to research that supports HTA and to identify relevant training
needs. Methods: An online survey was developed and piloted within the HTA
Working Group prior to distribution to over 200 researchers on the ENCePP mailing
list. The items in the survey were both qualitative and quantitative. Data will be
analysed using simple descriptive statistics and thematic analysis. Results: The
survey is ongoing and will close in July 2014. Preliminary results indicate that (50%)
of those sampled had conducted studies involving patient reported outcomes
(PROs) including quality of life data. The most frequently used data collection
tools were: paper (80%), handheld devices (50%), interactive voice (30%) and webbased (30%). Clinical outcomes were the most frequent primary study endpoints
(100%), although at least some data on PROs and cost outcomes were included in
86% and 71% of studies, respectively. The most common design was primary data
collection prospective cohort studies. ENCePP guidelines were the most frequently
referenced followed by ISPOR and ISPE methodological good practice guidelines.
Full data analyses will be available in September 2014. Conclusions: The findings of the ENCePP-HTA WG survey provide baseline data on ENCePP expertise
and resources in research supporting HTA that are of interest to regulatory and
HTA stakeholders across Europe.
PHP216
What The English Could Learn From The Irish: Making The Nice
Approval Process More Cost-Effective
Macaulay R
HERON Commercialization, London, UK
.
Objectives: The National Institute of Health and Care Excellence (NICE) is a body
that has gathered worldwide respect for its fully comprehensive clinical and economic
review of pharmaceutical agents. However, it has been criticized for taking too long
to conduct assessments and, as a consequence of this, only being able to appraise a
subset of all new agents coming to market. Other Health technology Asessment (HTA)
bodies achieve a much higher output of treatment appraisals with a much shorter
turnaround time (e.g. in 2013 NICE appraised 27 drugs compared to 57 by the National
Centre for Pharmacoeconomics (NCPE), Ireland). Methods: A thematic analysis of
the appraisal processes of the NCPE was conducted to determine if any key criteria
could be extrapolated that could potentially increase the speed and output of the NICE
appraisal process. Results: One particularly interesting aspect of the NCPE system
was revealed – a 2 to 4 week rapid preliminary review that all drugs must undergo to
determine the necessity of a full pharmaco-economic assessment (PEA). Full PEAs are
reserved for products with high cost, significant budget impact, and/or questionable
value for money. This enables products that are cheaper and at least as efficacious as
the relevant comparator to gain rapid market access. It also enables the NCPE to focus
their time and resources on the products that will have a substantial/questionable
clinical and/or economic impact. Conclusions: Adoption of such a systematic rapid
review procedure into the NICE appraisal process with reimbursement conditional on
NICE approval could similarly enable a better focussing of NICE resources to where
it is most impactful. This could also incentivise pharmaceutical companies to drop
their prices to gain rapid market access rather than going through the expensive and
time consuming procedure of a full NICE submission.
PHP217
Going Beyond The Qaly In Assessing The Benefits of Medical Devices
Wilkinson G 1, Drummond M 2
School of Economics and Political Science, London, UK, 2University of York, Heslington,
York, UK
..
.
1London
Objectives: Many medical devices offer improvements over current care that
may be difficult to assess using standard methods of benefit such as the qualityadjusted life-year (QALY). The objective of this research was to identify whether
these benefits could be measured and valued by alternative approaches, such as
contingent valuation (willingness-to-pay) or conjoint analysis (discrete choice experiments). Methods: We undertook a systematic review of the literature from 1996 to
2013 to identify empirical studies of the benefits of medical devices using the following methodologies: willingness-to-pay (WTP), discrete choice experiments (DCEs),
multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDAs) and subjective well-being (SWB). We recorded
the number and category of individuals surveyed, the attributes explored and the
key findings of each study. Results: The search resulted in 2772 hits, of which 2016
were considered not relevant and 76 were duplicates. On further examination, 47 of
the remaining 680 papers were found not to meet our inclusion criteria, 240 were
methodological papers and 363 involved non-device technologies. This left 30 relevant
empirical studies, of which 18 were WTP and 12 DCEs. The types of devices studied
included hearing aids, hip and knee implants and colostomy bags. Comfort, convenience or ease of use was the most common attribute explored other than effectiveness
and quality of the device. Where both were studied, patient preferences sometimes
differed from those of physicians. Conclusions: This research demonstrates that it
is feasible to measure and value the benefits of devices using alternative approaches
to QALYs, but that the literature is quite small as compared with that for non-device
technologies. This is surprising given the often-repeated claim that devices have
benefits that are difficult to assess using standard methods. Whilst the studies demonstrate the relative importance of each attribute, thought is required on how to
incorporate these estimates into comparative cost-effectiveness studies.
PHP218
Reality in Market Access In Germany and France – Comparative
Analysis of Added Benefit Decisions on Innovative Pharmaceutical
Therapies
Droeschel D 1, Chicoye A 2, Lepretre M 2
University - SRH FernHochschule Riedlingen, Riedlingen, Germany, 2ESSEC Executive
Education, Paris-La Défense, France
.
1Riedlingen
.
.
A441
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: The German market access system for drugs have been changed
significantly in the last years, by introducing a similar focus on benefit assessment
as in the French system. The research question remains whether they produce
consistent results in terms of additional benefit (AB) for pharmaceuticals which
have passed the assessment in both systems. Methods: The G-BA and IQWiG as
well as the Transparency Commission (TC) databases were searched systematically
to identify those products, which have been processed in both systems between
Jan 2011 and Dec 2013. For further comparison a data grid consisting of 26 items
for evaluation has been developed including study comparator, primary clinical
endpoints, health related quality of life inclusion. Results: Overall, 140 new
therapies have been assessed in France by TC, and 80 in Germany by the G-BA.
According to inclusion criteria, 44 products could be identified which have passed
through both systems including 7 orphan drugs. Thirteen products (30%) had no
AB granted by both Agencies, whereas 9 (20%) were in both cases granted with a
minor AB, (assuming that “minor” values are equivalent between the two systems),
amounting to 22/44 cases with a similar resolution. Five cases (11%) showed a
discrepancy in added benefit, all times TC = no and G-BA = yes. However, varying
magnitudes appeared to be the greatest difference (n = 17 (39%) remaining drugs),
conditioned by lacking concordance of both scale grade systems. Conclusions:
Decisions of the agencies in both countries show partial heterogeneity in driving
criteria like benefit levels (ASMR and AB). Although the evidence package for initial
assessment in both countries is largely similar, preliminary results suggest their
contextualization and scales are different. Further analysis based on results of
the grid is needed to better assess criteria leading to different benefit levels and
their reimbursement impact.
PHP219
Factors Influencing Dutch Drug Reimbursement Recommendations;
A Database Analysis
Alleman C J M , Spoorendonk J A , Charokopou M , Hensen M , Heeg B
Pharmerit International, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In the Netherlands, manufacturers need to apply for reimbursement
of outpatient drugs on either list 1A (no added benefit) or 1B (added benefit). For
expensive drugs, hospitals can receive additional reimbursement if the drug is
included on the expensive drug list (EDL). Pharmacoeconomic evidence is only
required for list 1B and EDL evaluations. The National Health Care Institute (NZi)
evaluates submissions and makes (provisional) reimbursement recommendations to the Dutch government. The aim of this study was to identify explanatory
variables for the recommendation by NZi. Methods: A database of published
evaluations from February-2006 to March-2014 was created, consisting of the
final reimbursement recommendation and a range of corresponding explanatory
variables such as the therapeutic indication, clinical and economic characteristics. Univariate analyses were performed to assess the impact of the individual
explanatory variables on the recommendation by means of odds ratios. Results:
In total 262 applications were included; the number of positive recommendations by NZi were 121/122 (99%) for 1A, 77/107 (72%) for 1B and 19/28 (68%) for
EDL. Pharmacoeconomic analysis was reported in 36/107 (34%) 1B evaluations,
of which 27 (75%) were recommended. For the EDL category, pharmacoeconomic
analysis was reported in 20/28 (71%) evaluations, out of which 17 (85%) received a
positive recommendation. Univariate analyses for the 1B subgroup showed that
NZi recommendations were significantly (α = 0.05) influenced by clinical trials with
life-saving primary endpoint (positive), non-inferior trial outcomes compared to
placebo (negative) and budget impact below € 2,500,000 (positive). Whereas, the
univariate analyses on EDL evaluations demonstrated that ATC-code L (antineoplastic and immunomodulating agents), clinical trials with life-saving primary
endpoint and reporting of economic analysis outcomes had a significant and positive impact on the final NZi recommendation. Conclusions: These univariate
analyses demonstrated that for 1B and EDL evaluations indication, clinical and
economic factors impact the NZi reimbursement recommendations.
PHP220
Measuring Extent of Access For Nice Health Technology Assessment
Decisions: Trends From 2008 to 2013
O’Neill P , Devlin N
Office of Health Economics, London, UK
.
.
Objectives: When assessing trends in NICE HTA decisions it would be useful
to ascertain their implications on access for groups of technologies. A specific
issue is to understand the degree of access associated with ‘optimised’ decisions,
where usage has been restricted to a subgroup of patients relative to the scope of
the appraisal. Using a previously developed method, we calculate the degree of
recommended access for medicines and assess trends between 2008 and 2013 by
therapeutic area and over time. Methods: In a previously published paper we
developed a measure, M, to assess access associated with NICE technology optimised appraisal decisions. This was defined as M=(p/P)x100, where M is a measure
of the level of patient access (0 equals no access, 100 full access), P is the set of
patients considered in the guidance as potential candidates for treatment (given
the scope of appraisal and license), and p is the number of patients for whom
NICE did recommend. Applying measure M to NICE HTA decisions for medicines
between January 2008 and December 2013 we assess trends by therapeutic area
and over time. In this paper, to understand trends, we extend the analysis to
include recommended and not recommended decisions. We assume a recommended decision scores 100 using measure M, a not recommended decision 0, and
optimised decisions, where not possible to determine M, a score of 50. Results:
For 201 decisions between 2008 and 2013, on average, M was equal to 52, ranging
from 37 in 2008 to 57 in 2011. At therapy level, M scored between 38 for cancer
medicines to 100 for Hepatitis C treatments. Conclusions: The results for this
period suggest around half of patients have been recommended by NICE to receive
treatment, relative to scope of appraisal and license. These considerations address
access not implementation issues.
PHP221
A Comparison of International Health Technology Assessment
Systems – Does The Perfect System Exist?
Kerr A 1, Todd C 1, Hebborn A 2, Ulyate K 1
1Roche Products Pty. Ltd., DEE WHY, Australia, 2F. Hoffmann-La Roche AG, Basel, Switzerland
.
.
.
.
Objectives: There are a number of common elements considered good practice
in Health Technology Assessment (HTA) that have been published by organizations
representing the field. These components include: clear processes and decisionmaking, including scope for pragmatic approaches and appeal; transparency in
methodology, value judgments and decisions; and a facility for stakeholder involvement. The objective of this study was to compare international HTA systems to
rank their performance against the ideal components of HTA. Information was
also collected on emerging topics such as combined regulatory-payer scientific
advice, coverage with evidence, evaluation of drug-diagnostic pairs and disinvestment. Methods: A survey was designed to collect information on the HTA systems in the United Kingdom (UK), France, Germany, Italy, The Netherlands, Sweden,
Central Eastern Europe, Canada, Australia, New Zealand (NZ), Korea and Taiwan.
Questions were grouped under the topics: process, methods, data, societal input
and transparency. The survey was completed by Roche affiliates with first-hand
experience working with the HTA system in their country. Results: The majority
of countries give consideration to rare diseases and low budget impact with leniency
in decision making and/or process. Transparency in decision-making is lacking in
many of the countries surveyed. Whilst consumer members sit on decision-making
committees in several countries, only the UK involves a group of citizens in setting
the decision making criteria applied by the committee. Combined regulatory-payer
scientific advice is only available in European countries. Australia is the only country
to evaluate drug-diagnostic pairings for both costs and outcomes. Only the UK and
NZ have routine disinvestment reviews. Conclusions: Each country is performing well in some elements of their HTA system, but none met all the requirements
of an ideal system. HTA systems can learn from the experiences in other countries
when considering improvements to processes and efficiency.
PHP223
Trends In Early Engagement Between Industry And HTA: Analysis of
Scientific Advice Service Provided By Nice Since 2009
Maignen F M 1, Osipenko L 1, Gajraj E 1, Chivers R 2
Institute for Health and Care Excellence, London, UK, 2National Institute for Health and
Clinical Excellence, Manchester, UK
.
.
.
.
.
1National
Objectives: Regulatory Scientific Advice (SA) provided by EMA, FDA, MHRA and other
agencies is highly demanded by manufacturers but health technology assessment
(HTA) scientific advice is still far from becoming a routine step in the product development cycle. NICE has been running an advisory service for 5.5 years. Methods: This
work presents analysis of requests to the programme: types of advice projects, number and type of requests per company, clinical indication, stage of clinical development when the advice is sought, reason for seeking advice and current development
and regulatory status of products. Results: Between 2009 and 2014 NICE conducted
109 advisory projects (107 medicinal products and two diagnostic tests). 23 of these
projects were done in parallel with regulatory agencies and/or other HTA bodies.
78% of all requests were in the following four therapeutic areas: oncology, neurology,
rheumatology and cardiology. Majority of products (61%) were in phase II of clinical
development when advice was sought. At the time of this analysis, 71 products (66%)
were still in development, 6 (5.5%) were subject of a review for a marketing authorisation (MA), 8 (7.5%) had received a MA, the authorisation was not granted to 2 products
(2%) and the clinical development was discontinued in 20 cases (19%). Most products
that received NICE scientific advice are yet to be referred to the technology appraisals
programme. Conclusions: Over the last few years, requests for scientific advice
diversified into personalised medicines, regenerative medicines and products for rare
and very rare diseases. Most HTA scientific advice requests continue to come from
top 20 Pharma companies, however we are starting to see an increasing number of
inquiries and project bookings from small-medium size companies.
PHP224
Exploring Uncertainty in Economic Evaluation Of Medicines: A
Review of The First Manufacturers’ Submissions To the French
National Authority For Health (Has)
Ghabri S 1, Hamers F F 1, Josselin J M 2, Harousseau J L 1
1Haute Autorité de Santé (HAS), Saint-Denis La Plaine, France, 2Université de Rennes 1, Rennes,
France
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Since October 2013, HAS is required to provide the inter-ministerial Economic Committee on Health Care Products (CEPS) with an economic
evaluation on innovative medicines likely to have a significant budget impact
on the national health insurance scheme. HAS economic evaluations are based
on critical appraisals of cost-effectiveness analyses (CEA) submitted by manufacturers. Exploration of uncertainty around incremental cost-effectiveness
ratio is critical to assess the robustness of CEA. Our objective was to assess how
uncertainty exploration has been undertaken by manufacturers, using HAS
guidelines on economic evaluation as an analytical framework. Methods:
Manufacturers’ submissions assessed by end of May 2014 (n= 13) were reviewed.
Three sources of uncertainty were considered: uncertainty around model input
parameters, uncertainty around model structure and methodological uncertainty.
Tools to explore uncertainty included deterministic sensitivity analysis (DSA), probabilistic sensitivity analysis (PSA), as well as overall compliance with HAS guidelines. Results: Model input parameters were the most frequently explored source
of uncertainty. Both DSA and PSA were systematically used. However, reporting of
DSA varied substantially across submissions, with frequent lack of justification of
parameters ranges. Regarding PSA, the choice of distribution was not systematically justified and lacked consistency across similar parameters. Most submissions
failed to consider parameters correlations. Exploration of uncertainty around model
structure was rarely presented. Where applicable, alternative methods for extrapo-
A442
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
lating health outcomes were reported in two-thirds of the submissions. However,
worst-case scenarios were hardly presented. Compliance with HAS guidelines for
exploring methodological uncertainty (e.g. perspective, discounting, time horizon)
was fair. However, the choice of the comparator(s)–an essential component of a
CEA–was considered problematic in nearly 40% of submissions. Conclusions:
Overall, reporting of DSA and PSA is complying with HAS guidelines. More work is
needed to explore uncertainty, in particular, to account for correlations between
model input parameters and to enhance the analysis of structural uncertainty.
PHP225
Conditional Resolutions in the Amnog Early Benefit Assessment
Assmann G , Schmidt U , Drechsler M , Pfannkuche M
Boehringer Ingelheim Pharma GmbH & Co. KG, Ingelheim, Germany
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Since 2011 the early benefit assessment (EBA) is mandatory to obtain
reimbursement for new drugs in Germany. By law EBA of the G-BA (Federal Joint
Committee) can be conditional for a certain period of time. This study explores
the number, duration and rationale of conditional G-BA resolutions. Furthermore
the provided, later given (during statement process), accepted and additionally
requested study data is analysed in this context. Methods: AMNOG dossiers and
resolutions of the G-BA including justifications until June 2014 were reviewed for relevant information and analysed with special regard to the submitted and accepted
study data. Drugs which were directly allocated to a fixed-reference price group
were excluded. Results: 22 new drugs with conditional resolutions were identified
(29.3% of all resolutions; 2012: 6, 2013: 10, 2014: 6). Duration varied between 1 and 5
years (1: 4, 2: 8, 3: 5, 4: 1, 5: 4). Conditional resolutions were most common in cancer
(n= 13; 59.1%) drugs. 91.0% had at least a benefit (none: 2, minor: 12, considerable:
6, not quantifiable: 2) in one subgroup. G-BA limited resolutions due to (a) no sufficient data to assess the benefit (n= 9), (b) conditional approval and/or further data
requests by EMA (European Medicines Agency) (n=6), (c) expected new study results
(n= 6), and (d) due to a formal incorrect dossier (n= 1). To date, only vemurafenib
was assessed again with same result as before. Conclusions: From 2011 on an
increased number of resolutions and especially cancer drugs were conditional. Only
in a few cases G-BA defined in the resolution which specific data has to be shown
in the re-assessment. In these cases the requirements concerning further evidence
were not part of the G-BA voting. As currently just one drug was re-assessed, no
conclusions can be drawn how re-assessment changes the extent or certainty of
additional benefit.
PHP226
Pricing Additional Benefit in Germany
Daniel K , Jaksa A , Ho Y S
Context Matters, Inc., New York, NY, USA
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Gemeinsame Bundesausschuss (G-BA) assesses the additional
benefit of newly-approved drugs compared to the G-BA-determined appropriate
comparator. As part of the submission, manufacturers provide annual drug cost
estimates. This research tests whether manufacturers submit higher annual costs
for drugs that provide greater additional benefit, that is, whether added benefit is
priced. Methods: The influence of G-BA’s additional benefit assessment on the
manufacturer’s estimated per patient annual drug cost was estimated via ordinary
least squares based on 73 reviews. The model also included controls for the (log)
size of the target population and the annual cost of the comparator. These variables were collected from the Federal Gazette publication or the “Beschluss” document. Results: Our model explains three-quarters of the variation in annual drug
cost (R2= .76). Conditional on the target population and the cost of its comparator,
a drug assessed as having unquantifiable or minor added benefit is estimated to
have a per patient annual cost about 2 times greater than one with no added benefit
(p= .02). A drug with the highest assessment, “Considerable additional benefit,” is
estimated to have an annual per patient cost that is 9 times greater (p< .01). There
is evidence of a “quantity discount”: doubling the size of the target population is
estimated to reduce the per-patient annual cost by 18% (p< .01). Conclusions:
If, as seems plausible, manufacturers’ assessments of their own drugs are aligned
with G-BA’s assessments, our results are consistent with manufacturers setting
higher prices for more beneficial drugs. The price a manufacturer uses to estimate
annual cost represents in effect a proposed allocation of its drug’s benefits between
itself and patients/payers. This research raises at least two important questions:
How do manufacturers propose to share the gains and what sharing emerges from
subsequent price negotiations?
PHP227
Risk of Bias in Trial-Based Economic Evaluations
Adarkwah C C , Evers S M , Hiligsmann M
Maastricht University, Maastricht, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The objective of our research is to give first an overview of the risks
of bias in trial-based economic evaluation, and second to identify how key sources
for bias can be revealed and overcome (bias-reducing strategies) in future trialbased economic evaluation in the fields of general practice and health psychology. Methods: A scoping review was performed using PubMed and the NHS
Economic Evaluation data base. It was complemented with experiences of the
authors. Sources of bias in trial-based economic evaluation as well as bias-reducing strategies are discussed. Results: The different forms of bias are presented,
and assigned to a particular trial phase. A distinction is made between pre-trial
biases, biases during the trial and biases that are relevant after the actual trial. All
potential forms of bias are discussed in detail and strategies are shown to detect
and overcome these biases. Conclusions: In order to avoid bias in trial-based
economic evaluations, one has to be aware of all of the possible forms of bias and
all stakeholders have to examine trial-based economic evaluations in a rigorous
and stringent manner. Our research findings can be helpful in this examination
as they provide an overview of the possible biases which researchers should take
into account.
PHP228
UK Value-Based Assessment: Will Scotland’s Smc Approach It In The
Same Way?
Hamilton M L
Access Partnership, London, UK
.
.
Objectives: In May 2010 the UK government set out its intentions to reform the
current method of pricing branded medicines and introduced a new system of
value-based pricing (VBP). This was to replace the Pharmaceutical Price Regulation
Scheme (PPRS) which expired at the end of 2013. With discussion still ongoing,
and the PPRS renewed up until end of 2018, it has been indicated that VBP will no
longer relate to medicines’ pricing, but instead will be a reshaping of the Health
Technology Assessment (HTA) model employed by the UK in its appraisal of new
medicines, and renamed Value Based Assessment (VBA). As medicine assessment
is devolved in the UK, performed by NICE in England and the SMC in Scotland,
we seek to understand whether the SMC will adopt the same approach to VBA as
NICE. Methods: The research was conducted through in-depth secondary research
and interviews with stakeholders, including payers and KOLs, in UK. Results: Both
NICE and the SMC have indicated they will continue to use QALY as a measurement
of clinical and cost effectiveness while also incorporating issues such as burden
of illness and wider societal impact in their assessment. However, their approach
to conducting such assessments may differ with the SMC suggesting using a new
system of patient and clinician engagement (PACE), currently in use for the appraisal
of medicines for end of life or rare conditions (orphans), as a wider process to
determine Scotland’s requirement for a value based approach to assess all new
medicines. Conclusions: Manufacturers would be encouraged to closely follow
the outcomes from the new PACE system, incorporated into the SMC assessment
for end of life and orphan therapies, to ensure readiness for the introduction of
VBA in Scotland.
PHP229
Discrepancy Between National Drug Recommendations And Local
Uptake in the Swedish Inpatient Sector
McGee M A 1, Izmirlieva M 2, Ando G 2
Life Sciences, London, UK, 2IHS, London, UK
.
.
.
.
1IHS
Objectives: The current study seeks to assess discrepancies between national
inpatient drug recommendations issued through the cost-effectiveness pilot project
(Klinikläkemedelsprojektet) in Sweden and local uptake reflected by Stockholm
Country Council´s (SLL) procurement activity. Methods: Secondary research
investigated the 15 inpatient drug recommendations issued by the national New
Pharmaceutical Therapies group (Nya Lakemedels Terapier, NLT) in 2013 and compared these against the SLL’s 2014 procurement list. Results: In 2013, the NLT
group issued a total of 15 recommendations for products in a variety of therapeutic areas (TA). Out of these, ten gained positive national decisions, 50% of which
were for oncology drugs. Of those recommended, cancer drug pertuzumab (Perjeta;
Roche, Switzerland) saw the highest incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER), at
SEK2,565,000 (USD383,730) per quality-adjusted life year (QALY) - greatly exceeding the informal cost-effectiveness threshold of SEK800,000 in Sweden. There was
a significant discrepancy in the number of nationally recommended drugs (ten)
in 2013, versus the SLL uptake (two) by 2014. The two recommended products
subsequently procured were Roche´s (Switzerland) ophthalmology drug ranibizumab (Lucentis) and Takeda´s (Japan) oncology therapy brentuximab vedotin
(Adcetris). Conclusions: The Swedish government is contemplating making the
Klinikläkemedelsprojektet permanent, and as such the alignment between national
and local level priorities is a critical component of its integrity. The results show
that eight nationally recommended products had not been procured, indicating
that there is still a discrepancy between those recommendations and uptake at
the local level, based on the current data. One explanation for the discrepancy
could be attributed to the funding system, where local payers are responsible for
funding inpatient drugs.
PHP230
HTA Approach in Italy. Structure, Methods, And Process Of Veneto
Region’s Evaluation Of Pharmaceutical Effectiveness Unit (Unità Di
Valutazione Dell’efficacia Del Farmaco, Uvef)
Young K E 1, Urbinati D 2, Toumi M 3
1Creativ-Ceutical, Milan, Italy, 2Creativ-Ceutical, Luxembourg, Luxembourg, 3University
Aix-Marseille, Marseille, France
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Veneto leads the nation in terms of better health status and pharmaceutical expenditures within budget. This study aimed to assess the region’s
Health Technology Assessment (HTA) approach (structure, methods, and process
of conducting HTA) by observing Evaluation of Pharmaceutical Effectiveness Unit’s
(UVEF) evaluations on drugs, the concomitant Regional Technical Commission
(CTR) decisions on formulary inclusion, and the evidences considered. Methods:
We reviewed all HTA reports in the UVEF website evaluating the HTA dimensions
assessed, if they were in line with the HTA scoping document by the Regional
Decrees (2008), and changes over time. Further, this research evaluated the presence
of explicit explanations behind each CTR decision. Results: 223 HTA listings were
retrieved in the UVEF website (2004-2011). 50.23% were published before the actual
establishment of UVEF (2008) and were probably labelled HTA retrospectively. Fewer
dimensions were assessed in the earlier documents and the most extensive changes
were seen in 2008. The most assessed dimensions were Efficacy, Safety, and Costs
and the least assessed were Budget Impact Analysis, Target Population, Place in
therapy, and Assessment of Innovation. The Regional Decrees (2008) were impactful
on the structure of the HTA reports, however these are still not fully compliant to
the scoping document. A total of 72 CTR decisions were found in the website from
2009 to 2011. On average, 92% of all CTR documents have a documented explanation behind each decision. Conclusions: The HTA approach in Veneto is evolving
towards the development of uniformity in the documents and a single transparent
approach. The upward trend of attaching CTR decisions with explicit explanations
A443
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
shows a positive development within the region’s HTA. The Regional Decrees were
impactful however the HTA reports are not fully compliant to the scoping document
and it is central to understand the reason behind the challenge.
PHP231
Quality Of Life – A Rarely Acknowledged Key Category Within The
Amnog Process in Germany
Eheberg D 1, Shlaen R 2, Batscheider A 2, Gohlke A 2
1IMS HEALTH, Munich, Germany, 2IMS Health, Munich, Germany
.
.
.
.
Increasingly, quality of life becomes a more important part of the HTA assessments
of new products. Assessing quality of life is trickier than changes in clinical parameters as changes of quality of life tend to occur slower and with a high level of
variance. Additionally, it is sometimes necessary to assess quality of life indirectly,
especially in cognitive disorders. However, the available data are often driven by the
requirements for marketing authorization and rarely fit to the requests of HTA agencies. Quality of life is, among mortality, morbidity and safety, one of the key patient
relevant outcomes categories in the AMNOG (Arzneimittelmarktneuordnungsgesetz;
Law on the Reorganization of the Pharmaceutical Market) process in Germany.
Objectives: Our focus was to review the impact of quality of life data presented
by manufacturers since the introduction of the AMNOG in 2011 on the level of
additional benefit claimed by the manufacturer and the evaluation by the Federal
Joint Committee (G-BA) and the Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Healthcare
(IQWiG). Methods: We screened the IMS HTA database and the assessments published on the G-BA website for assessments including additional benefit claims
based on quality of life. We compared these with the corresponding IQWiG reports
and the final decision of the G-BA (if available). Results: Data on quality of life
was part of 36 additional benefit claims. In most cases, IQWiG (n= 23) and G-BA
(n= 28) considered quality of life data as well. However, in 6 cases IQWiG and G-BA
assessed quality of life, even though the manufacturer didn’t include these data.
There are only few additional benefit claims acknowledged by G-BA based on quality of life. Conclusions: Even though quality of life is seen as highly relevant
factor for the HTA assessment of a new drug or technology, it is rarely taken into
consideration.
PHP232
Understanding The Role of Subgroup Analysis And Tests For
Homogeneity or Interaction in the Amnog Dossier
Hofmann-Xu L 1, Bonduelle D 2, Eheberg D 3
1IMS Health Germany, Munich, Germany, 2IMS HEALTH GmbH & Co. OHG, Munich, Germany,
3IMS HEALTH, Munich, Germany
.
.
PHP233
The Inverse Correlation Between Internal And External Risk
Under International Reference Pricing: An Analysis of Six European
Countries
.
.
PHP234
An Archetype For Classification and Comparison of Hta Activities
in Latin America
Skaltsa K 1, Allen N 2, Van Engen A 3, Blogg K 4
1Quintiles Consulting, Barcelona, Spain, 2Centre for Innovation in Regulatory Science, London, UK,
3Quintiles Consulting, Hoofddorp, The Netherlands, 4Quintiles Consulting, Reading, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: HTA processes are being implemented in Latin America in an effort
for a more efficient resource allocation. The objective of this study was to explore
the HTA environment and classify its diversity based on previously developed taxonomies. This enables the comparison within the region, as well as with other
regions in which similar maps have been developed, such as Europe. Methods:
Two taxonomic groupings were used as described in Allen et al 2013 Health Policy
113; 305– 312. The first one is based on the position of a national HTA agency in
relation to the position of the regulatory and the coverage body. The second set
focuses on the key tasks performed by the HTA agency. The following countries were
examined: Mexico, Cuba, Costa Rica, Colombia, Venezuela, Ecuador, Peru, Bolivia,
Brazil, Uruguay, Argentina and Chile. No information on HTA activity could be identified for the rest of the countries on official websites or publications. Results:
Seven different archetypes were identified by combining different values of the two
taxonomic sets in these twelve countries. There were two main groups identified:
one consisting of Brazil, Cuba and Chile where the HTA and coverage decisions are
performed by the same agency and regulatory is independent, and the other one
consisting of Costa Rica, Venezuela, Peru and Bolivia where no HTA process was
identified and external evaluations or decisions from reference countries are used
to inform decisions. Conclusions: Although the landscape is expected to change
in the coming years, this first high-level overview shows that currently, there is a
high degree of heterogeneity in HTA processes in Latin America despite the fact
that these countries tend to share expertise in various levels, with few countries
following similar processes and a number of countries with no HTA bodies in place
at any decision level.
.
Objectives: Although subgroup analysis in clinical trials is often criticized, it is still
considered an important part of the AMNOG Dossier when describing effect modification in different patient groups. An identification of effect modification in the
subgroups will either support or weaken the total additional benefit (Zusatznutzen)
of a drug. The purpose of this article is to give a detailed background with regard to
the statistical inference in subgroup analysis and a brief review of the effect of tests
for homogeneity/interactions on the final grading of the additional benefit, according to the decision from IQWiG. Methods: This article covers: Understanding tests
for homogeneity, individual versus pooled data and influence of subgroup analysis
on recent IQWiG benefit assessment. A research of the recently published AMNOG
Dossiers was performed. A description was given to the number of drugs that had
an additional benefit and the subgroups that were involved. Clustering analysis
was performed to investigate the hidden structrue in the subgroups. Regression
models were used to analyze the relationship of the subgroups and the additional
benefit. Results: Some subgroups such as age, gender and weight play a major role
in the AMNOG assessment. Other subgroubs are more specific for certain disease
areas e.g. BMI or hypertension for diabetis. In a worst case the benefit of a drug may
disappeare when a certain subgroup is taken into consideration. Conclusions:
Subgroups exert a profound influence upon the overall effect of a drug. Despite of
the weakness of the statistical inference, subgroup analysis plays an important role
in the AMNOG Dossier. Some subgroups are frequently related to the overall effect
of a drug and some might even change the whole story in the AMNOG Dossier. In
conclusion, subgroup analysis should be understood properly and the results should
be interpreted carefully.
Marinoni G , Lockwood C , Ando G
IHS, London, UK
ments in the internal risk index. Conclusions: The inversion seen between the
two risk indices reflects a key aspect of the current IRP landscape. Namely, mature
markets exert considerable influence on prices internationally, while their use of
IRP exerts limited downward pressure on their own prices. Conversely, while IRP
policy in emerging markets is more likely designed to secure the lowest possible
prices, these markets carry less influence on prices internationally.
.
Objectives: To index six countries on the basis of the risk they pose to pharmaceutical prices with regards to international reference pricing (IRP), from both an
internal (how IRP is used by the country) and external (how other countries use
this country for IRP) perspective. Methods: Details on IRP methodologies were
obtained from primary and secondary research. Achievable drug price levels in
Bulgaria, France, Germany, Portugal and Romania were derived from these markets’ IRP formula and the relative drug price levels in their reference markets
(based on existing literature). Furthermore, based on the IRP formulas and relative drug price levels of each of the markets referencing these five and the United
Kingdom, the markets most likely influenced by the six were identified. This number of markets, the fraction of them representing major pharmaceutical markets,
and the relative price levels in each of the six countries were assigned weightings
to rank them by external risk. Results: While Bulgaria, Portugal and Romania
represent the greatest internal risk for pharmaceutical prices (i.e. greatest risk of
obtaining a low price as a result of IRP), these markets fall into the low and moderate risk segments in the external risk index. Conversely, while France, Germany
and the UK pose the greatest external risk (i.e. as a function of the number of
significant markets referencing them), they fall into the low and moderate risk seg-
PHP235
Combining Headroom and Return on Investment Analysis To Rank
Potential Commercial Value of Six Medical Devices in Development
Markiewicz K 1, van Til J A 1, Steuten L M G 2, IJzerman M J 3
1University of Twente, MIRA Institute for Biomedical Technology & Technical Medicine, Enschede,
The Netherlands, 2University of Twente, Enschede, The Netherlands, 3MIRA Institute for
Biomedical Technology & Technical Medicine and University of Twente, Enschede, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The development process of medical devices strongly depends on
the financial resources available and the expected return on investment to manufacturers. The aim of this paper is to analyse the potential commercial viability of
two disruptive and four incremental medical devices in different stages of development. Methods: The headroom method combined with the return on investment
analysis was performed for one therapeutic and five diagnostic devices for different
clinical target areas. Information regarding maximum additional benefit that could
be obtained with new device, the estimated production price and expected sales
volume was gathered from literature and expert opinions. A willingness-to-pay
threshold for one additional QALY of € 30,000 was assumed for headroom analysis. Results: The devices were ranked according to their potential commercial
viability. The analysis showed that two disruptive and two incremental devices had
reasonably good balance between headroom and unit cost, and two incremental
devices had no good balance. The device with the highest potential commercial
viability was a disruptive therapeutic device for the cartilage repair treatment
in the first clinical trial stage, with estimated headroom for the cost of the new
treatment: € 74,600 and an expected production cost of the therapy: € 8,000 per unit.
The market volume size was calculated based on the incidence of cartilage defects:
65% in routine knee arthroscopies. The disruptive diagnostic device for home brain
monitoring of epilepsy patients in the prototype stage of development had the lowest potential commercial viability, with an estimated headroom of € 81,000 and an
expected production costs per unit: €120,000 that resulted in the unfavorable return
on investment. Conclusions: The headroom method combined with a return on
investment analysis, offers insight in the potential commercial viability of medical
devices under development. The research on the impact of that analysis on actual
R&D decision making will still be determined.
PHP236
Transferability of Economic Evaluations To Central and Eastern
Euroepan and Former Soviet Countries
Mandrik O 1, Knies S 2, Kaló Z 3, Severens J L 4
1Institute of Health Policy & Management, Erasmus University Rotterdam, Kiev, Ukraine,
2Institute of Health Policy & Management, Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The
Netherlands, 3Eötvös Loránd University (ELTE), Budapest, Hungary, 4Erasmus University
Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Data availability and decision makers methodology requirements are
two important factors influencing transferability of economic studies. Applying qualitative assessment of experts’ opinion and systematic review of published economic
studies, we aimed to analyze transferability of economic evaluations in Central and
Eastern European (CEE) and former Soviet countries. Methods: Firstly, eleven reimbursement experts from eight countries were interviewed on their background and
current practice of using economic evaluations, opinion regarding transferability
of economic evaluations and importance of individual Welte’s transferability factors. Secondly, we analyzed peer-reviewed English-language economic evaluations
A444
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
of sixteen countries from the region according to different criteria: characteristics,
quality (using Drummond’s checklist), use of local data, addressed inputs limitation and results transferability. Results: Economic evaluations are used in CEE
countries for informing decision making, while critically considering methodology,
quality and study’s reliability. Experts acknowledged limited generalizability of study
results both between and within geographic regions. Meanwhile, despite these constraints, facing limited health technology assessment (HTA) capacity experts were
still using foreign evidence. At the same time, the usefulness of studies published in
CEE and former Soviet countries to inform their decision making is limited because
of insufficient transparency in reporting, unaddressed uncertainty, limited insight on
inputs and transferability of results. Although local costs, baseline risk and resource
use data are required, experts accept evidence originating from health care settings
outside CEE and former Soviet countries regarding relative effect and utilities values. Conclusions: HTA priority setting and transferability assessment of economic
evidence are important issue in health care decision making in CEE and former Soviet
countries, since HTA research capacity is limited and local evidence is scarce. For this
purpose, quality, transparency, and transferability should be addressed explicitly in
published economic evaluations originating from CEE and former Soviet countries.
PHP237
Ten Years Of Development Studies In Health Technology Assessment
In Brazil: Profile Of Studies And Operational Indicators
Koury C D N 1, Elias F T S 2
1FIPE -Fundação de Ensino e Pesquisas Econômicas, Brasilia, Brazil, 2Ministry of Health of Brazil,
Brasilia, Brazil
.
.
.
.
.
.
Background: The Department of Science and Technology (DECIT) at the Ministry
of Health (MoH), since 2003, has financed studies to support demands from
the MoH technical areas regarding the decision making process about health
technologies. Objectives: To analyze DECIT performance in financed Health
Technology Assessment (HTA) studies to improve the capacity building of HTA in
Brazil. Methods: A retrospective descriptive study based on the analysis of documents and official records built in a single database in Excel containing the studies
promoted by DECIT from 2003 to November 27, 2013. The variables pre-classified
and collected from Brazilian Network for Health Technology Assessment’s database,
SISREBRATS, were revised by two reviewers and conferred or supplemented with data
from the Database of Health Research, Annual Reports Management by DECIT, and
Final Reports and Cooperation Agreements by co-financier partners. Results: 284
HTA projects were financed entirety for R$ 25 million (± R$ 1,69 million) between 2003
and 2013. The average value financed was R$ 346 thousand and the average bias was
± RS 61 thousand. Of these, 57% (162/284) are pharmacotherapy; and 35% (99/248) are
systematic reviews. The majority of the studies 58% (165/284) were financed by MoH
calls in years 2005 to 2010 and contributed to 110 masters and doctors conclusions in
HTA landfield. Conclusions: These numbers show despite the HTA culture in Brazil
having been in its initial stage, DECIT is increasing its capacity to respond to demands
with a variety of studies types, specily in pharmacotherapy. However, evaluation
demands do not always correspond to health needs of promotion and prevention.
PHP238
The Definition and Role of Quality of Life In Germany’s Early
Assessment of Drug Benefit
Lohrberg D , Augustin M , Blome C
University Medical Center Hamburg-Eppendorf, Hamburg, Germany
.
.
PHP241
Romanian Quick-HTA Development In 2013
Radu C P , Cernea R
Roche Romania, Bucharest, Romania
.
.
.
Objectives: The Objectives are to present the characteristics of the quick-HTA
started in June 2013 and to show the Results of the first quick-HTA process in
Romania. Methods: The health care context and the Romanian legislation covering HTA were studied by considering: the reasons behind HTA introduction, the
key stakeholders and the HTA process. A critical appraisal was done covering public
HTA reports and the decisions taken by the Ministry of Health (MofH). Results:
The introduction of quick-HTA began mid-June 2013 when MofH released the legislation and the HTA Unit started receiving dossiers for new drugs/indications. The
HTA model was based on a “score-card” system with 6 criteria: HAS (France) opinion,
NICE/SMC/AWMSG (UK) opinion, the number of EU countries with reimbursement,
relative efficacy, relative safety and relative patient-reported-outcomes (PRO), but no
role of budget impact. From June to December 2013, 167 HTA dossiers were evaluated
by the HTA Unit with an acceptance rate of about 80%. Most of the drugs accepted for
reimbursement were oncological (23%); other main therapeutic areas were diabetes
with 16 drugs/indications receiving positive evaluations, rheumatology (14), oncohaematology (8) and neurology (7). The HTA included also biosimilars, all 4 of them
receiving positive decisions. Unfortunately, early 2014, the new Government abrogated
this HTA legislation and the already-published HTA reports, claiming that the process
didn’t mentioned the criteria for de-listing reimbursed drugs nor the budget impact,
within HTA reports. Moreover, the HTA process was moved into the responsibility of
the National Agency for Drugs. Conclusions: The implementation of the quick-HTA
in Romania took a good start, using a mixture of information, from benefits and costeffectiveness in other countries, to relative effectiveness, safety and PRO. However,
the lack of consideration for the local context and the political disagreements led to
a temporary suspension of this quick-HTA process in Romania.
.
Objectives: Since January 2011, pharmaceutical manufacturers are obliged to submit dossiers presenting benefits over comparative treatment when launching new
products in the German pharmaceutical market. These dossiers are usually evaluated by the Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care (IQWiG). Based on the
dossier, the IQWiG’s evaluation and a subsequent hearing process, the Federal Joint
Committee (G-BA) decides on additional therapeutic benefit related to mortality,
morbidity, quality of life (QoL) and side effects. As QoL is among the more contested
of these criteria and remains comparably unspecified, this qualitative study’s aim
was to analyze definitions and the role of QoL in early assessments of benefit (EAB)
in Germany. Methods: As most of the documents are freely available on the G-BA’s
website, this study included all relevant documents of the first completed 66 assessments (11.2011-12.2013). We conducted a qualitative content analysis screening the
dossiers, IQWiG evaluations, G-BA decisions and the protocols of the oral hearing for
relevant links to QoL and synonyms. In a process of independent analysis and joint
consensus building by two researchers, relevant text passages were extracted and
reduced to key content on the term’s usage. During analysis, a system of codes was
developed accounting for a wide variety of recurring QoL-related definitions and
references to its importance. Results: Even though key players did not necessarily
share the same QoL-definition, the concept’s relative importance was highlighted in
numerous references. G-BA decisions criticize the lack of or the inadequate presentation of QoL data in the manufacturer’s dossiers. G-BA and IQWiG apply a narrow
understanding of QoL, while manufacturers failed to establish wider notions of QoL
linking factors such as patient satisfaction to the concept. Conclusions: QoL in a
particular sense is of pivotal importance in Germany’s early assessment of benefit.
The demand for reliable QoL data is growing.
PHP240
An Update on Clinical And Economic Evidence Requirements for
Advanced-Therapy Medicinal Products in Europe
Anastasaki E 1, Walker A 2, Bradshaw S 1
1Market Access Solutions LLC, London, UK, 2University of Glasgow, Glasgow, UK
.
models that Payers have come to expect at the launch of pharmaceuticals. Thus,
manufacturers face difficulties when negotiating the price for ATMPs and may not
be able to realize their full potential. This paper aims to use case studies of ATMPs
launched in EU5 to outline access pathways and review the clinical and economic
evidence requirements. Methods: Secondary research identified ATMP approvals since 2008 and a framework was created to develop hypotheses on clinical
and economic evidence requirements, considering alternative routes to market.
Hypotheses were then validated during in-depth interviews with key stakeholders
across EU5. Results: Payers are yet to be convinced about the full benefit of ATMPs
and are reluctant to pay premium prices if they are not sure about long-term efficacy and safety. Additionally, in their cost-benefit analyses, Payers tend to consider
only the direct costs associated with a condition, ignoring broader societal benefits
and savings in the long run. Therefore, price negotiations are sometimes lengthy.
Risk sharing and novel payment-by-result schemes are often agreed to mitigate
risks. Conclusions: Payers are not yet familiar with the potential value of ATMPs,
and, in most cases specific evaluation criteria don’t exist. Manufacturers need to
invest in educating Payers on the huge differences between ATMPs and traditional
therapies, particularly to show that manufacturing costs are substantial, and work
together to identify relevant measures for clinical and economic evaluations of
this new therapy class.
.
.
Objectives: Advanced-therapy medicinal products (ATMPs), such as gene therapy,
cell therapy and tissue engineering are a new class of medicines in the EU. ATMPs
offer prospects in prevention and treatment of fatal and/or chronic debilitating
diseases where no effective treatments exist. However, with complicated mechanisms of actions and benefits often being anticipated in the longer term, it is challenging to demonstrate hard clinical evidence and create robust cost-effectiveness
PHP242
Hta In The Brazilian Health Care System and Potential Lessons
Learned For Other Brics States
Stuwe L T 1, Bellanger M M 2, Picon PD 3
University, Paris, France, 2EHESP French School of Public Health, Rennes,
France, 3Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul, Porto Alegre - RS, Brazil
.
.
.
.
.
1Pierre-and-Marie-Curie
Objectives: The objective of the study was to provide an external assessment
of recent HTA institutionalization in Brazil, and identify a set of lessons learned
potentially applicable to BRICS States. Methods: This research is based on a quantitative and qualitative assessment. A literature survey between 2000 and 2014 was
conducted in English, Spanish and Portuguese in PubMed/Medline, Science Direct,
LILACS and SciELO. Epidemiological and socio-economic data was retrieved from
national health accounts as well as WHO/PAHO, OECD and World Bank. For the
Brazilian National Committee for Incorporation of Technologies (CONITEC), available reports on the incorporation of medicines into the National Unified System
(SUS) for the first two years of operation (2012 and 2013) were analyzed. A matrix
containing quantitative and qualitative criteria was elaborated to analyze reports
by the outcome of decision, therapeutic class, author (s) of the request and public
consultation. Results: A total of 92 available CONITEC reports for 2012 (n= 38, 33
for medicines) and 2013 (n= 54, 42 for medicines) were analyzed. 45% of reports on
medicines recommended incorporation into the SUS. Most of the positive recommendations were clearly related to public health priorities as identified by the government, translating a strong commitment for improved access to medicines within
the SUS i.e. anti-cancer drugs. Overall, the creation of the CONITEC represents a
substantial step toward the institutionalization of HTA, with more transparency
and accountability in decision-making processes, considering ethical, organizational, social, and legal aspects. Conclusions: Whereas lowest in Russia, India
and South Africa, and at a transitional stage in China, Brazil has a comparable
degree of institutionalization of HTA as countries with a long-lasting HTA experience. A best-practice assessment in the area of HTA within the BRICS has still to be
elaborated. Transferability of lessons learned might be a strong tool for improving
HTA development within the BRICS.
PHP243
Is G-Ba Strategically Discounting The Benefit Assessment of
Relatively High Cost Drugs?
Jaksa A , Daniel K , Bergemann R , Ho Y S
Context Matters, Inc., New York, NY, USA
.
.
.
.
.
A445
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: Gemeinsame Bundesausschuss (G-BA) states that it assesses additional benefit strictly on clinical grounds, but it also requires that manufacturers
submit drug and comparator costs. This raises the possibility that G-BA’s assessment
might be influenced by price, possibly to provide leverage during subsequent price
negotiations. This research tests the hypothesis that high cost drugs (relative to
the comparator) are more likely to receive poor benefit assessments. Methods:
The following variables were collected from the Federal Gazette publication or the
“Beschluss” document: additional benefit assessment, annual cost per patient of
drug and comparator, and estimated target population. The Scottish Medicines
Consortium (SMC) clinical rationale for the same drugs and indications were collected to control for clinical efficacy. After excluding orphan drugs, reviews using
best supportive care comparators, and reviews without SMC reviews, 58 reviews
remained for analysis. G-BA’s additional benefit assessments were ranked from
least benefit to most. The influence of drug cost relative to the comparator on the
G-BA assessment was estimated via an ordered logit model. The model also included
controls for the (log) size of the target population and clinical efficacy (SMC’s clinical
assessment). Results: An increase in the cost difference between the drug and the
comparator is estimated to result in a modest, statistically significant increase in the
odds of receiving an additional benefit assessment greater than a “no additional
benefit” assessment. Conclusions: Our results are inconsistent with the alternative hypothesis that G-BA is strategically discounting its assessment of relatively
high cost drugs. The positive estimated relationship is consistent with manufacturers’ setting higher prices for more beneficial drugs (The data available provide no
way to statistically account for this plausible source of endogeneity). Our results
provide no support for rejecting the null hypothesis that G-BA assesses added benefit independently of drug cost.
PHP244
Development of Hta in Turkey
Tuna E 1, Tatar M 2, Ergin G 1, Senturk A 1, Atikeler K 2
1Polar Polar Health Economics & Policy, Ankara, Turkey, 2Hacettepe University, Ankara, Turkey
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The aim of this study was to assess the development of HTA in
Turkey. Methods: In this regard, organization structures of the Ministry of Health
(MoH) and Social Security Institution (SSI) and presentations of first HTA meeting held in April 2014 have been analyzed. Results: There are three main HTA
agencies in Turkey. One is under the payer institution called SSI. The HTA committee of SSI assesses all the new health technologies to define whether they will
be reimbursed or not. In other words, this committee is the major decisive HTA
committee. Other two HTA committees are under the MoH. One of these is under
the General Directorate of Pharmaceuticals and Medical Devices. This committee
assesses certain drugs which are specifically asked to be evaluated by the SSI, MoH
or other Ministries. One of the projects completed by this committee is the evaluation of top 100 selling drugs according to the effect of price, regulation, market and
qualitative characteristics of drugs. The second committee of the MoH is under
the General Directorate of Health Research. This committee assesses more general
issues like obesity, KOAH etc., instead of certain health technologies and publishes
national reports. One of the reports published by this committee was the importance of obesity surgery in the treatment of obesity. In addition to all these three
committees, HTA studies also being carried out by a MoH hospital called Ankara
Numune Training and Research Hospital (ANHTA). They have been working on hospital based HTA. Conclusions: Despite valuable studies being conducted as stated
above, HTA is still in its infancy in Turkey and compared to other EU countries like
Germany, UK etc. there is not an autonomous HTA agency. There are more than one
committee, working on different aspects of health technology assessment under
the supervision of government.
PHP245
Disease Burden in Brazil and Health Technology Assessment: A
Retrospective of Ten Years of Supporting
Koury C D N 1, Elias F T S 2
1FIPE -Fundação de Ensino e Pesquisas Econômicas, Brasilia, Brazil, 2Ministry of Health of Brazil,
Brasilia, Brazil
.
.
.
.
.
PHP247
Correlation Between End-of-Life Status of A Treatment And
Likelihood of A Patient Access Scheme in The Setting of A Nice
Review in The UK
Izmirlieva M , Ando G
IHS, London, UK
.
.
Objectives: This study aims to assess the existence of a correlation between
the applicability of end-of-life treatment criteria and the likelihood of NICE
requiring a Patient Access Scheme (PAS) to recommend the treatment for
funding. Methods: A review of all patient access schemes in existence as
of March 2014 for NICE-recommended drugs was conducted to assess how
many of those were for medicines which met the end-of-life treatment criteria
and whether the supplementary criteria for end-of-life treatments had any
bearing on the final NICE recommendation. Results: In total 42 PAS were
identified. Of those, end-of-life treatment criteria were met and had bearing
on the final NICE guidance in 7 cases (16.7%). End-of-life treatment criteria
were considered but were not met in full in the case of 3 NICE reviews (in one
of the three NICE considered that end-of-life criteria were not met in another
review, even though the manufacturer had not applied for those criteria to
be considered in the present review). End-of-life treatment criteria were also
considered for one additional review where they were a focal point of the manufacturer appeal against the NICE guidance. In one additional case, end-of-life
criteria were applied for but had no bearing on the final NICE guidance as the
cost-effectiveness threshold was met without the application of special considerations. Conclusions: Given the high cost of drugs meeting end-of-life
criteria (most of which are for oncology indications), as expected, many of them
are subject to a PAS in the UK. However, the opposite correlation does not hold
true - i.e., the requirement for a PAS in the UK is not restricted to end-of-life
treatments.
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Patient Registries &
Post-Marketing Studies
.
Background: Defining health technology assessment priorities has been a challenge for the Department of Science and Technology who adopted a prioritization criteria strategy (epidemiologic relevance, services/policy relevance, state of
the art, operational feasibility and social demand) for demands from MoH technical areas. However, evaluation demands do not always correspond to health
needs. Objectives: To analyze the relationship between projects financed from 2003
to 2013 and disease burdens in Brazil. Methods: Systematization of the summaries
from financed projects through searches in the information from www.saude.gov.br/
rebrats and http://pesquisasaude.saude.gov.br/bdgdecit/ and categorization according
to the twenty sub-groups of diseases and injuries of disease burden (Dalys) research
in Brazil (SHARMM ET al, 1998). Results: 284 HTA projects financed between 2003
and 2013. Of these, 24% (68/284) apply to the twenty main causes of loss of life years
by premature death or incapacitation (Dalys, 1998). The first three largest are equal
to 15% – diabetes, coronary ischemia, acute myocardial infarction, angina, cerebral
infarction and stroke– corresponded to 13% of the (37/284) projects. Conclusions:
The percentage found allows for the questioning of the prioritization starting point
where the criteria are applied to subjects selected due to external influence and
pressure from the market and not necessarily based on the needs impacting the
population’s health. Uniting the two dimensions while also taking into account the
strategic innovations in order to prioritize and finance assessment will be important
for health systems sustainability.
PHP246
First Experiences With The New Testing Examination and Treatment:
Methods in Germany: Is This A New Amnog Clone?
Bonduelle D 1, Eheberg D 2, Plantoer S 1
1IMS HEALTH GmbH & Co. OHG, Munich, Germany, 2IMS HEALTH, Munich, Germany
.
Objectives: In a new regulation the Federal Joint Committee (G-BA) can pass
directives for testing examination and treatment methods with not yet sufficiently proven benefit, but which show potential as essential treatment alternatives (§137e SGB V). The objective of the present study was to compare the
requirements for a successful application with the existing AMNOG (Law on the
Reorganization of the Pharmaceutical Market) HTA requirements in Germany.
The applicants must submit valid data on the potential of the method in question, among other requirements. In one of the first applications in Germany,
done by the authors, we see a lot of parallels with the HTA process for drugs but
also a lot of uncertainties. Methods: We compared the requirements of the
IQWIG Methodology paper 4.2 and the G-BA rules of procedure for the early benefit assessment for medical drugs (§35a SGB V) with the new potential analysis
for examination and treatment methods. This analysis was made for different
criteria’s like study and endpoint design, certainty of results of the studies and
others. We used our business case as template to extract the key-learning’s
and identify the pitfalls in the new process. Results: The new legislation will
have a strong impact on the study design and evidence to show the potential
of new examination and treatment methods as essential treatment alternatives. A lot of evaluation criteria’s came from the drug assessments but are
hardly applicable to proof the potential of new examination and treatment
methods. Conclusions: The legislation uses parts of classic HTA assessment
on medical drugs to evaluate the potential of new examination and treatment
methods. In most cases this is not possible and will decrease the level of evidence of available clinical data for new examination and treatment methods
due to grey zones and loopholes in the legislation.
.
.
PHP248
The Costs and Effects of Post-Authorisation Safety Studies For
New Active Substances
Bouvy J C 1, De Bruin M L 1, Hoekman J 1, Stolk P 2
University, Utrecht, The Netherlands, 2University of Utrecht, Utrecht, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Utrecht
Objectives: At market entry, there usually is uncertainty regarding a new medicine’s benefit-risk profile. Therefore, regulatory authorities may request additional
pharmacovigilance (PhV) activities. Regulatory Authorities can request a PostAuthorisation Safety Study (PASS) such as a registry, database study, survey, or
clinical trial to reduce the uncertainty regarding certain safety risks. We aimed to
assess the costs and effects of PASS for centrally approved new active substances
(NAS) in Europe in 2007. Methods: We compared two scenarios for all NAS (n= 47):
(1) Full regulation: routine PhV activities (spontaneous adverse drug reaction (ADR)
reporting) with additional PASSs for some NAS; (2) Limited regulation: only routine
PhV activities. For a follow-up period of six years after marketing we assessed the
safety-related labeling changes for NAS and identified the source of these changes
(PASS, spontaneous ADR reporting or other). Data on labeling changes was extracted
from the European Medicines Agency’s website. A survey among pharmaceutical
companies was used to estimate the costs of all requested PASSs. Results: For
23 of the 47 NAS, at least one PASS (33 PASS in total) was requested in 2007. After
six years, on average 8.1 safety-related labeling changes were identified per NAS.
Requested PASS were the source of ~4% of all cases of new safety information identified. The total estimated costs of the 33 requested PASS were between € 50 and € 150
million. Conclusions: For the 2007 cohort of NAS approved in Europe, the total
costs of all requested PASS were substantial and yet these PASS contributed to the
identification of only 4% of all new safety information identified post-marketing
for NAS. However, PASS primarily aim to reduce uncertainty regarding safety risks
and the (societal) value of this uncertainty reduction might not fully be captured
by assessing health effects alone.
A446
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PHP249
Supporting Interoperable Eu Patient Registries: Survey of Registry
Holders’ Needs
Pristas I 1, Doupi P 2, Meglic M 3, Karanikas H 4, Zaletel M 5, Brkic M 1, Plese B 1,
Zuriaga Llorens O 6
1Croatian Institute of Public Health, Zagreb, Croatia, 2National Institute for Health and Welfare
(THL), Helsinki, Finland, 3National Institute of Public Health, Slovenia, Ljubljana, Slovenia,
4National & Kapodistrian University of Athens, Athens, Greece, 5Nacionalni Institut za javno
zdravje, Ljubljana, Slovenia, 6Conselleria de Sanitat. Generalitat C. Valenciana, Valencia, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Due to the diversity in EU Member States’ specific needs and legislation, the complexity of the health domain and the variable progress in
IT-implementation there is currently limited standardization across registries and
other eHealth tools. PARENT Joint Action (www. patientregistries. eu) aims at supporting the development of comparable and interoperable patient registries, thus
enabling secondary data usage for public health and research purposes in a crossborder setting. As part of mapping the EU patient registry landscape, we undertook
a survey of registry holders with the purpose of gathering information on current
practices, as well as future needs and expectations with regard to IT-supported
data exchange. Methods: A survey of EU registry holders (n= 177) was conducted
and data was collected via an online questionnaire. Gathered information defines
additionally patient registry metadata and is part of the development process of the
Registry of Registries (RoR) – an envisioned go-to source for up-to-date information
about patient registry metadata across Europe. Results: We found a high degree
of interest (82%) for participation in a single IT-enabled platform on the EU level,
indicating IT tools, quality control systems and networking opportunities as the
most potentially desirable services of such a system. The registries that indicated an
interest to link their data to other data sources were more likely to have previously
established standardized data exchange procedures and formats (Pearson χ2= 6.909,
df= 1, p= 0.009). There were no statistically significant differences in presence of
routine data exchange procedures among patient registries according to Registry
type (condition-based, product-based or service-based), Geographical coverage and/
or Holding institution type. Conclusions: Achieving patient registry interoperability requires a complex service-oriented approach taking into account the whole
registry context (political, legal, organizational, semantic and technical levels). Our
survey findings will serve more advanced in-depth assessments of registry quality
dimensions to be performed through the PARENT Framework.
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Population Health
PHP250
Determination of Major Chronic Diseases by Using Pharmaceutical
Reimbursement Data From A Large Belgian Health Insurer Claims
Database
Van Tielen R , Karakaya G , Vanrillaer V , Umbach I
MLOZ, Brussels, Belgium
.
.
.
PHP251
Use Of Factor Analysis To Obtain Independent Health Performance
Indicators
.
.
PHP252
Impact of Economic Crisis on the Greek Health Care System and on
the Population Health
Kaitelidou D 1, Kalogeropoulou M 2, Galanis P 1, Theodorou M 3, Charalambous G 4,
Liaropoulos L 1
1National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, Athens, Greece, 2Center for Health Services
Management and Evaluation, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, Athens, Greece,
3Open University of Cyprus, Latsia, Nicosia, Cyprus, 4Hippokratio Hospital of Athens, Athens,
Greece
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The aim of the paper is to map the impact of economic crisis on the
Greek health care system and on the population health. Methods: A systematic literature review was conducted in databases Pubmed, Embase and Scopus
for the years 1980-2013, focusing mainly to the impact of the economic crisis in
Latin America, Eastern Europe and Eastern Asia. In order to assess the impact
of crisis in Greece, Hellenic Statistical Authority (EL. STAT.), Hellenic Center for
Disease Control and Prevention (HCDCP), OECD, Eurostat and World Bank databases were used. Results: Greece entered a deep economic crisis in 2009 and in
only four years lost more than 25% of its GDP. Unemployment rate exceeded 27%
of the population in 2013, the number of uninsured population reached 2 million
according to the Ministry of Labour (2014) whereas the rate of population at risk of
poverty or social exclusion has increased from 27.6% in 2009 to 34.6% in 2012. Total
current health expenditure decreased by € 5.4 billion (23.7%) while public current
health expenditure fell by a greater proportion, 25.2% or € 4bn between 2009 and
2012. At the same time the use of public services (e.g. hospital admissions) and
waiting times increased. Regarding the health outcomes, an increase in the incidence rate of HIV/AIDS per million population by 10% was recorded. Incidence of
Hepatitis A was increased by 187.5% and meningitis by 87% between 2011-2013. Total
mortality rate was increased by 3.2% while expressed unmet health care needs
were increased by 55% between 2009-2011. Conclusions: The efforts to reform
the Greek National Health System have been focusing mainly on short-term effects
by reducing expenditure. However, health-promoting policies providing equitable
access, especially regarding the vulnerable groups, and infectious diseases prevention should be considered as a more cost-effective alternative.
.
Objectives: The objective of this exploratory study is to define the (chronic) health
status of about 2 million affiliates from the Independent Sickness funds (MLOZ,
Belgium). Methods: Data were extracted from the administrative database of
MLOZ. Information of specific reimbursed medications was used as proxy for diagnosis of 20 chronic diseases. We processed data of pharmaceutical consumption in
the ambulatory sector (minimum 90 DDDs/year) to characterize the health status
of patients. Results: The analysis included 1,962,526 affiliates. The prevalence
of chronic diseases is 23.3% in the population. This population is spending 64.3%
of the total health expenditures reimbursed for all affiliates. Hypertension is the
most common with 16.2% of the population, followed by depression (5.1%), diabetes
(3.8%) and a group called “cardiovascular event” with 2.1%. Patients suffering from
respiratory disease represent 3.8% (Asthma (1.7%) and COPD (2.0%)). Regarding the
average health care costs, the picture is totally different. Patients with a rare disease induce on average € 48,476 health care cost, followed by patients with renal
failure (€ 40,429) or cystic fibrosis (€ 20,700). Patients with hypertension “only” cost
€ 4,938. Conclusions: Claims databases from health insurers are attractive for
researchers because of their size and detailed computerized records of all reimbursed health care procedures on a recipient-specific basis. In terms of public
health, it seems interesting to concentrate (public) financial efforts towards chronic
pathologies concerning a large number of patients with important average health
care costs. Using secondary data of insurer claims databases allows (with some
caution) to characterize chronic health status of large populations. Results may
help decision-makers in defining priorities in resource allocation.
Van Wilder P , Bormans V , Leemans E
SMART&BI, Zaventem, Belgium
the variance. The 3 iHPIs loaded respectively on ‘mortality’, ‘prevention’ and ‘AIDS
incidence’. The 7 European regions differed significantly for 7 of the 8 initial HPIs
and for each of the 3 iHPIs (p always < 0.02). Cluster analyses based on the 3 iHPIs,
avoiding multi-collinearity, generated regions with different country composition.
Both Malta and Georgia became isolated; Finland and Portugal shifted from their
geographical region. Conclusions: HPIs are important to assess and compare the
impact of health care policies across regions and countries. After extracting 8 correlated HPIs linked to direct health care policies from a published set of HPIs, factor
analysis allowed us to convert these into 3 independent components, which were
subject to further multivariate analyses offering additional and different insights.
.
Objectives: Health Performance Indicators (HPIs) provide a quantitative tool to
assess the performance of health care policies. Available HPIs may be strongly correlated, limiting further inferential use. In this study we converted published HPIs into
a set of independent HPIs (iHPIs) using factor analysis. We subsequently used iHPIs
to perform regional health care performance comparisons. Methods: We used the
set of 27 HPIs on 43 European countries from 7 geographical regions of Mackenbach
(Mackenbach JP, McKee M. European Journal of Public Health 23 (2), 195-201, 2013).
We extracted only indicators related to direct health care services having limited
missing data (< 20%) and applied factor analysis to obtain iHPIs. The performance
of the 7 regions was analysed using iHPIs in cluster analysis and non-parametric
ANOVA (significance level at 0.05). Results: 8 correlated indicators met our analysis criteria: systolic blood pressure, cervical cancer screening, teenage pregnancy,
newborn and mother mortality, measles vaccination, mortality and AIDS incidence.
The factor analysis reduced the set to 3 components or iHPIs and explained 77% of
PHP253
Estimation of Stress Resistance of Medical Students in LVIV
Blavatska O 1, Lototska L 1, Blavatskyj I 2
Halytskyj Lviv National Medical University, Lviv, Ukraine, 2Lviv Politechnic National
University, Lviv, Ukraine
.
.
.
1Danylo
Objectives: High demands for speed and amount of students’ trainings in health
care education is one of the stress causes. Presence of stress can negatively affect
the state of progress and level of physical health of medical students. Methods:
Testing of 275 students III-IV years of studying at medical faculty (145 girls, 130 boys)
using methods of Friedman and Rosenman modifications «tendency to stress» and
«self- rating of stress resistance». Results: Test results revealed: 34% of girls & 29%
of boys showed below average level self-rating of stress resistance, including group
tendency to stressful situations. Average level was characterized for 39% of girls &
27% of boys. This indicates the sufficient resistance to stress and rejection as failure
stress. Higher than average level of stress resistance was observed for 15% of girls &
26% of boys. These students, despite the negative influence of different factors fight
stress and try to prevent it. High level of stress resistance was exposed only by 12%
of girls & 18% of boys. Conclusions: Gender differences in the aptitude to stress
of medical students were established. High aptitude was recorded for 11% of girls &
7% of boys. Relatively high frequency of getting into stress was inherent for 25% of
girls & 21% of boys. Presence of stress and attempts to avoid it were found for 29%
of girls & 40% of boys. For 22% of girls & 26% of boys was found the ability to resist
stress by communicative & harmony lifestyles. High level of self-regulation, the
ability to achieve goals as the result of low aptitude to stress was inherent for 10%
of girls & 7% of boys. Reducing adaptation to stress among medical students was
registered. Formation of skills for stress resistance by implementation of healthsaving technologies in student lifestyle is necessary.
PHP254
Breastfeeding and Its Effect On The Probability of Occurance of
the Probability of Occurance of the Disease And Related Costs
Lehocká L 1, Malovecká I 1, Minariková D 1, Foltan V 2
University, Bratislava, Slovak Republic, 2Faculty of Pharmacy, Comenius University,
Bratislava, Slovak Republic
.
.
.
.
1Comenius
Objectives: Breastfeeding and nutrition of a child by breast milk has distinct
influence on the child’s health during childhood as well as in their adult age.
Insufficient nutrition of infants and young children is one of the factors influencing morbidity in children and can cause increased susceptibility for certain chronic,
non-infectious (so called civilization) diseases in adulthood, for example allergic
diseases, obesity, diabetes mellitus that are closely associated with future costs
of health care. Methods: Analysis of medical records of randomly selected children between the age of 1 to 11 (n= 100) from four pediatrician offices. The following data was analyzed: age, weight, breastfeeding, duration of breastfeeding and
incidence of selected diseases (gastroenteritis, laryngitis, bronchitis, pneumonia,
A447
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
allergic rhinitis, cow’s milk allergy, eczema and obesity). Results: Of 100 studied children 64% were breastfed (BF), while 36% had artificial nutrition (AN), xBF≤
6months =48%, xBF> 6months=52%. Gastroenteritis: xBF =1,42 diseases/child/life (D/CH/L),
xAN = 1,64 D/CH/L, xBF≤ 6months = 1,84 D/CH/L, xBF> 6months= 1,23D/CH/L. Laryngitis:
xBF= 0,27D/CH/L, xAN = 0,64 D/CH/L, xBF≤ 6months = 0,74D/CH/L, xBF> 6months= 0,20D/
CH/L. Bronchitis: xBF= 3,73D/CH/L, xAN= 4,86 D/CH/L, xBF≤ 6months = 3,89D/CH/L,
xBF> 6months= 3,34D/CH/L. Pneumonia: xBF= 0,11D/CH/L, xAN = 0,31 D/CH/L, xBF≤
6months = 0,26D/CH/L, xBF> 6months= 0,03D/CH/L. Allergic rhinitis: xBF= 0,16D/CH/L, xAN
= 0,28 D/CH/L, xBF≤ 6months =0,21D/CH/L, xBF>6months=0,11D/CH/L. Cow’s milk allergy:
xBF= 0,11D/CH/L, xAN = 0,17 D/CH/L, xBF≤ 6months = 0,16D/CH/L, xBF> 6months= 0,03D/
CH/L. Eczema: xBF= 0,09D/CH/L, xAN = 0,42 D/CH/L, xBF≤ 6months = 0,21D/CH/L,
xBF> 6months= 0,03D/CH/L. Obesity: xBF= 0,03D/CH/L, xAN = 0,17 D/CH/L, xBF≤ 6months
= 0,05D/CH/L, xBF> 6months= 0,00D/CH/L. Conclusions: Results of the analysis indicated that breastfed children showed less frequent incidence of all of the studied
diseases compared to children who had artificial nutrition. Breastfeeding and even
more importantly the duration of breastfeeding has important positive impact on
child’s health, lower the occurrence of the diseases, frequency of medication use
and overall total expenditure on health care.
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Prescribing Behavior & Treatment
Guidelines
PHP255
Evaluation of Medicine Prescription Pattern Using World Health
Organization Prescribing Indicators in Iran: A Cross-Sectional
Study
Soleymani F 1, Taheri F 2
of Health, Tehran, Iran, 2Minitry of Health, tehran, Iran
.
.
1Ministry
Objectives: objective was to quantify the specialists’ prescription pattern in Iran
and to point out the prescribing behavioral differences among several specialties. Methods: A retrospective cross-sectional study was carried out on the claim
data. National prescription data were obtained on the basis of the claims that the
pharmacies submitted to the insurers during 1 year period of the study. More than
85 million prescriptions were analyzed using “Rx-Analyst” software that is designed
and applied by National Committee of Rational Use of Medicines in Iran. Specified
medical specialties were considered and the World Health Organization prescription indicators were used to evaluate the physicians’ prescribing behavior. Results:
Average items per prescription were ranged from 3.68 in cardiologists’ to 2.06 in
dermatologists’ prescriptions. The highest and the lowest mean price were belonged
to neurologists’ and ophthalmologists’ prescriptions, respectively. In addition, 45% of
patients received antibiotics, 41% of patients received injectable form of drugs, and
23% received corticosteroids. A high tendency toward prescribing corticosteroids and
antibiotic as well as an injectable form of medicines was observed among general
physicians. Conclusions: There is an inevitable need to improve prescription habits among different specialties, especially among general practitioners. This causes
the policymakers to put more emphasis on priorities such as continuous education.
and optimise the reporting of such evaluations. To our knowledge, there are no such
published guidelines in Spain. Methods: This guidance was designed with the
main aim of providing authors with recommendations, in the form of a checklist, to
optimise design and reporting of EE and BIA to be submitted to the Catalan Health
System (CatSalut) within its harmonization program for pharmaceutical innovation. Results: For a given evaluation, two separate guidelines with corresponding
checklists assess its methodology, quality, and reporting based on several dimensions. Conclusions: The steps outlined in this first guidance in Spain, although
not compulsory, will provide useful practical tips for how to go about designing and
reporting of an EE or a BIA for pharmaceuticals in Catalonia (Spain).
PHP258
Guidance for Risk Sharing Agreements / Pay Per: Results SCHEMES FOR
PHARMACEUTICALS IN CATALONIA (SPAIN)
Mora-Ripoll R 1, Gilabert-Perramon A 1, Espinosa-Tome C 1, Segú L 2, Gasol-Boncompte M 1
1CatSalut, Barcelona, Spain, 2Consorci Salut, Barcelona, Spain
.
Tsiantou V 1, Kyriopoulos J 1, Lionis C 2
School of Public Health, Athens, Greece, 2University of Crete, Faculty of Medicine, Clinic
of Social and Family Medicine, Heraklion, Greece
.
.
.
1National
Objectives: Monitoring and measuring prescribing patterns can provide valuable
information regarding the use of medicines and the overall prescribing behavior.
In Greece, until recently there was no organized system to monitor and record
prescribing patterns. The aim of this study is to describe prescribing patterns of
GPs in primary health care. Methods: A prospective cross-sectional study was
conducted (March–June 2011). Two geographical areas (rural and semirural) in Crete
and one urban in Athens were randomly selected and all GPs working in these
areas in public or private practices were invited to participate. Each GP answered a
structured questionnaire regarding his/her prescribing patterns and collect data on
100 patients within a specified period. Prescribed drugs and diagnoses were then
classified according to the ATC classification system and the ICPC-2 classification
system respectively. Results: 13 GPs (7 from Crete) participated in the study giving
data for 1202 patients. 84.5% of the patients received a prescription and the mean
items prescribed were 2.72. At the 12.4% of the total encounters the patient was
not present while at 9.9% of all encounters the reason was to ask a prescription
for medicines already bought from the pharmacy. GPs prescribed at the 96.7% and
97.5% of these cases respectively. Diseases of the circulatory (24.9%), endocrine
(23.5%) and musculoskeletal (10.4%) systems were the most commonly recorded
diagnoses. Overall, 62% of all prescribed medicines were from the cardiovascular
system, alimentary tract and metabolism and nervous system. 4.8% were antibiotics,
2.7% were injections, 19.9% were launched in the Greek market after 2001, 4% were
OTCs, 3.7% were narcotics, 10.8% were generics. Conclusions: This preliminary
descriptive analysis gives an overview of the prescribing patterns of GPs and highlights the areas that pharmaceutical policies should be focused. Further analysis is
needed to identify the factors that determine this behavior.
PHP257
Guidance For Economic Evaluation and Budget Impact Analysis For
Pharmaceuticals in Catalonia (Spain)
Mora-Ripoll R 1, Gilabert-Perramon A 1, Oliva-Moreno J 2, Puig-Junoy J 3
Castilla La Mancha, Toledo, Spain, 3Universitat Pompeu
Fabra, Barcelona, Spain
.
.
.
.
1CatSalut, Barcelona, Spain, 2Universidad
Objectives: Health economic evaluations (EE) and budget impact analysis (BIA) for
pharmaceuticals are increasingly being used for decision making. Guidelines can be
very useful to help authors with the use of proper methodology, assess the quality
.
.
.
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Quality of Care
PHP259
Type of Multimorbidity and Patient-Centered Care Among Elderly
Medicare Beneficiaries
Garg R 1, Shen C 2, Sambamoorthi N 3, Ajmera M 1, Sambamoorthi U 1
University, Morgantown, WV, USA, 2The University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer
Center, Houston, TX, USA, 3Northwestern University, Evanston, IL, USA
.
PHP256
Prescribing Patterns of General Practitioners (Gps) in Primary
Health Care: Evidence From Greece
.
Objectives: In recent years, spending on prescription drugs contributes substantially to the continuous growth in health expenditure which is influenced by both
a rise in the use of existing drugs and by the adoption of new and expensive drugs.
However, their effectiveness outside of clinical trial settings is often uncertain at the
time they gain market approval. This uncertainty may reflect a lack of real-world
outcomes data, as opposed to clinical trials data, for a typical patient population.
A risk-sharing agreement is a contract between a drug manufacturer and a health
care provider/payer to help manage uncertainties regarding the cost and effectiveness of those drugs and serves the interests of both. Guidelines can be very useful to identify these uncertainties and select the pharmaceuticals which are most
eligible for such an agreement to be implemented. To our knowledge, there are no
such published guidelines in Spain. Methods: This guidance was designed with
the main aim of identifying uncertainties, helping select the pharmaceuticals most
eligible, and defining best type of risk sharing agreement (RSA) / pay per Results
scheme (PRS) to be implemented between the Catalan Heath System (CatSalut)
and health care providers/pharmaceutical companies in Catalonia. Results: For
a given pharmaceutical, two questionnaires identify and score following four variables related to main uncertainties involved: (1) efficacy/effectiveness uncertainty;
(2) budget uncertainty; (3) budget impact; and (4) incremental cost-effectiveness
ratio (ICER) and willingness to pay. Final score guides the best type of agreement
to be implemented accordingly. Conclusions: The steps outlined in this first
guidance in Spain, although not compulsory, will provide useful practical tips for
how to go about setting up an RSA or PRS in Catalonia (Spain). This guide is not a
substitute for suitable regulatory or legal advice.
.
.
.
.
1West Virginia
Objectives: Patient-centered care (PCC) is a critical component of health care
management of elderly with multimorbidity, especially for those with co-existing chronic physical conditions with mental illnesses. However, little is known
about the association between type of multimorbidity and PCC. The objective of
this study was to analyze the association between type of multimorbidity and
PCC. Methods: A retrospective cross-sectional study design was used. Data were
derived from 2011 Access to Care module of the Medicare Current Beneficiary
Survey (MCBS). The study sample (N = 10,158) consisted of community-dwelling
elderly Medicare beneficiaries aged 65 years or older with at least one physical
chronic condition. Types of multimorbidity (MM) defined as: 1) single physical
condition (No MM); 2) two or more physical conditions without mental illnesses
(MM-PI); and 3) both mental and physical conditions (MM-MI&PI). PCC was defined
using patient-physician communication and patients’ confidence in physician.
Chi-square tests and logistic regressions were used to test the unadjusted and
adjusted associations. Results: A lower percentage of elderly Medicare beneficiaries with MM-MI&PI had optimal patient-physician communication (73.5%)
and high confidence in their physicians (86.1%) as compared to those with No MM
(79.1% and 90.2%). Without adjustments for health status, elderly with MM-MI&PI
were less likely to have optimal patient-physician communication (OR = 0.74, 95%
CI [0.61, 0.88]) and confidence in their physicians (OR = 0.67, 95% CI [0.53, 0.86]) as
compared to elderly with no MM. The relationship between multimorbidity and
PCC was not statistically significant after adjusting for general health and functional status. However, those with MM-MI&PI were as likely as those with MM-PI
to have optimal patient-physician communication and confidence in their physicians. Conclusions: Those with multiple conditions faced poor communication
and low confidence in doctor as compared to those with single physical condition.
However, type of multimorbidity was not associated with PCC.
PHP260
Impacts Of Bar-Code Medication Administration (Bcma) On Patients’
Safety in Taiwan
Lee M
Wan Fang Hospital, Taipei city, Taiwan
.
Objectives: A BCMA system was introduced to the hospital in June 2012. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the impact of the BCMA system on reducing medication errors and nurse and pharmacist satisfaction with the system. Methods:
The nurse satisfaction questionnaire and the pharmacist satisfaction questionnaire for the overall system were designed by 8 experts using content validity
index (CVI). Medication error rates before and after the implementation of the
A448
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
BCMA system was compared. We also collected the numbers of phone calls for
tracking stat drugs from Oct 2nd to Nov 15th in 2012. Results: After the implementation of the BCMA system, the medication error rate was significantly reduced
from 0.18% to 0.12% (p < 0.05). Pharmacists agreed that the BCMA system provides assistance in tracking prescriptions (90%), identifying medications (60%),
and reducing medication errors (53%). However, pharmacists also think that the
system has increased their routine workload (57%). Nurses agreed that the BCMA
system can improve patient identification (73%), administration of right medication (57%), medication administration time (47%), and access to correct prescription/medication information (42%). Both pharmacists and nurses were dissatisfied
with the stability of the system (53%, 69%) and poor barcode sensitivity (47%,
64%). From Oct 2nd to Nov 15th in 2012, we received 469 phone calls. The average
of tracing call for drugs is 1.67 times every hour. Conclusions: BCMA system
significantly decreases medication error rate in the hospital. It is recognized to be
able to improve medication safety by both pharmacists and nurses. Improving the
quality of associated computer equipment is the next important step.
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Regulation of Health Care Sector
PHP261
Pharmacoeconomic Evaluation For Reimbursement Purposes in
Bulgaria: Recent Updates
Stoimenova A 1, Savova A 1, Benisheva-Dimitrova T 2, Kamusheva M 1, Petrova G 3
University, Faculty of Pharmacy, Sofia, Bulgaria, 2NATIONAL COUNCIL ON PRICES AND
REIMBURSEMENT OF MEDICINAL PRODUCTS, Sofia, Bulgaria, 3Medical University Sofia, Faculty
of Pharmacy, Sofia, Bulgaria
.
.
.
.
.
1Medical
Objectives: Our study evaluates the preferred methods which the pharmacoeconomic evaluations submitted for reimbursement purposes in Bulgaria are
using. Methods: This is retrospective, descriptive study. We have examined
all applications submitted to National Council on Pricing and Reimbursement
in 2013 on which positive opinion was issued. Quantitatively and qualitatively
descriptive analyses towards the new molecules were carried out based on
the submitted pharmacoeconomic evaluations. Results: 22 new INNs were
submitted and approved for reimbursement during the studied period (average time
for approval: 194.55 days). Only 18.18% (n= 4) were orphan drugs. The most commonly used types of pharmacoeconomic evaluation were cost-effectiveness analysis
(n=10), followed by cost-minimization analysis (n=4). Only one cost-utility analysis
was provided. In all other cases only budget impact analyses (BIA) was submitted that
correspond with the national regulatory requirements. Only one analysis included
hospitalization costs calculation. The chosen perspective was the payer’s perspective
for all analyses. The time horizon varies between 10 days and 5 years. 68.18% (n= 15)
of the pharmacoeconomic evaluations were adjusted to 1 year calculations. 72.73% of
the INNs were approved for 100% reimbursement rate, 3 INNs – for 75% and two-for
50% reimbursement rate. 45.45% of the submitted evaluations contained local epidemiological data. Only one analysis did not include the relevant comparator and only
two haven’t discussed any additional benefits of the treatment. Pharmacoeconomic
evaluations of new medicinal products was often inadequately validated by incorrect type of pharmacoeconomic analysis chosen, lack of Bulgarian epidemiological
data, costs and effects were not correctly analyzed which led to prolongation of the
time need for approval. Conclusions: The need for more detailed guidelines is
obvious in the light of increasing importance of pharmacoeconomic evaluations for
reimbursement purposes.
PHP263
The Effect of Procurement Design on Entry and Success of Generic
Drug Firms
1Comenius
University, Bratislava, Slovak Republic, 2Faculty of Pharmacy, Comenius University,
Bratislava, Slovak Republic
Objectives: The economical crisis and the requirements for structural changes
in all aspects of public health brought a new era of reforms in the country as well
as the health care system itself. The Pharmaceutical Legislation, both European
and national, were implemented to protect public and state interests. Application
of new legislation influenced provider of health care services in different areas.
Therefore it is important to evaluate the impact and performance on costs and
revenues of health care services provider. Methods: Monitoring, calculation and
assessment of costs and revenues with the help of financial analysis indicators
for years 2003-2012, using financial statements was conducted, with respect to
profitability, debt, liquidity, working capital and efficiency ratios. These ratios constituted significant information of implementing new health care legislation and
price policies. Results: In case of profitability, parameter gross profit ranged from
x2003–2011= 16.1–22.8% (xaverage= 19.2%, Xmean= 19.8%, σ = 2.4), but in 2012 decreased on
14.3%. Net profit ranged x2003–2011= 12.8–18.3% (xaverage=14.6%, Xmean=16.6%, σ=4.9%),
while in 2012 reached only 2.3%. Debt parameters varied from x2003–2012= 2.33-4.8
(xaverage= 3.44, Xmean= 3.06, σ = 0.82), liquidity parameters current ratio x2003–2012= 1.11.7 (Xaverage= 1.43, Xmean= 1.45, σ = 0.15) and quick ratio x2003–2012= 0.7-1.3 (xaverage= 1.16, xmean= 1.09, σ = 0.15), working capital ratio x2003–2012= 2,7-12,9, (Xaverage= 9.6,
Xmean= 10.1, σ = 3.1) and efficiency ratios were measured either. Conclusions:
Implementation of new health care legislation and price policy that were intended
to apply restrictive measures to increase system efficiency and cost savings had a
significant impact on health care services providers by worsening profitability and
liquidity parameters as key indicators of provider stability. Despite the improvement
in debt ratio, working capital ratio and efficiency ratios, stability may be threatened
and may affect the amount of health care services providers.
PHP265
The Effect of Decentralised Public Health Care Provision on
Accessibility To Medicines in Bosnia And Herzegovina
Melck B , Ando G , Izmirlieva M
IHS, London, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: This study aims to assess the extent of the restriction on access to
medicines in Bosnia and Herzegovina in relation to the country’s decentralised
provision of health care, with three separate state entities and 10 cantons within
the federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina all having a role in the provision of public health care. Methods: A comparison was made between the contents of the
federal essential drug list and the drug lists of the various entities and cantons, in
order to ascertain which medicines were available, at what price, and with what
level of reimbursement. Results: The federal essential list contains the basic INNs
which must be provided by each canton, but there were some important differences
between the lists of the various entities and cantons. For example, the range of
patented and originator medicines available in the Republic of Srpska was greater
than in the cantons of the federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina in general. Also,
within the federation, there was some variation in the price of medicines between
cantons, and an even greater variation between the reimbursement levels paid for
them. For example, in the Tuzla canton, a package of generic losartan produced by
Krka was priced at 9.30 convertible marks and reimbursed at 20% by the canton’s
health insurance fund, while the same package at the same price was reimbursed
50% in the West Herzegovina canton. Conclusions: The lack of centralised control
over drug funding means that citizens face variability in access to medicines across
the spectrum, depending on which entity or canton they live in. Recent regulatory
changes aimed at bringing greater control into drug pricing have so far failed to
have any notable impact.
Laitenberger U 1, Hunold M 2
for European Economic Research, Mannheim, Germany, 2European Commission, SaintJosse-ten-Noode, Belgium
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Risk Sharing/Performance-Based
Agreements
Objectives: Competitive tendering of active ingredient-specific contracts for
generic drugs has emerged in Germany due to regulatory changes in 2009. The
central goal of these changes is to accomplish that small and medium sized firms
(SME) have better chances to succeed. Another goal is more participation of manufacturers, including outright market entry. We study how different designs of the
competitive tendering affect participation and the outcome of generic drug manufacturers. Methods: We use a newly collected data set on almost all of the around
4000 public competitive awardings of procurement contracts by purchase groups
in Germany from the first one in 2008 to the end of 2012. An important source of
cross-sectional variation is caused by the nine purchasing groups, which differ in
how they design their awarding procedures. Major differences include the lot size,
the number of possible contracting firms and whether a drugs of a specific active
pharmaceutical ingredient is auctioned in one or different lots. We use OLS regressions with fixed effects for unobserved active pharmaceutical ingredient (API) market characteristics, as well as count data and discrete choice models. Results: Our
econometric analysis reveals that there are more bidders in tenders where contracts
with more than one supplier are possible, when the drugs for one API are auctioned
in a single lot and when the lot size is smaller. Also small firms are more likely to
win when multiple winners are possible and the lot size is smaller. Conclusions:
We find that the design of awarding procedures influences participation in tenders
and, furthermore, the chance of new suppliers to win the contract. This is relevant
for both purchasing groups and policy makers as low bids and thus drug expenses
of the statutory health insurances can only be achieved with a competitive industry
structure.
PHP266
The Comparison of the Risk-Sharing Schemes Proposed in
Reimbursement Applications Received By Ahtapol In 2012 and 2013
.
.
1Centre
PHP264
10 Years Evaluation of Costs And Revenues Of Heath Care Services
Provider Under The New Health Care Legislation and Price Policy
Malovecká I 1, Minariková D 1, Foltan V 2
.
.
.
Zawodnik S 1, Iwanczuk T 1, Hermanowski T R 2, Matusewicz W 1
1Agency for Health Technology Assessment in Poland (AOTM), Warsaw, Poland, 2Medical
University of Warsaw, Warsaw, Poland
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To compare the Risk-Sharing Schemes (RSSs) proposed in reimbursement applications received by Agency for Health Technology Assessment in Poland
(AHTAPol) in 2012 and 2013. Methods: Comparative analysis of RSSs proposed in
reimbursement applications received by AHTAPol in 2012 and 2013 was conducted.
RSSs were quantitatively and qualitatively analyzed and classified on the basis of
both Carlson’s approach and the Polish Act on the reimbursement of medicinal
products. Results: In years 2012 and 2013, 56 reimbursement applications with 26
proposed RSSs and 80 reimbursement applications with 52 RSSs proposed received by
AHTAPol, respectively. They were classified into 5 categories according to the Act on
the reimbursement. The most common category in 2012 was making the official sales
price dependent on the applicant providing supplies at a reduced price (34.62%). On
the other hand, in 2013 the most common category was making the official sales price
dependent on a pay-back of a part of the reimbursement obtained to the entity which
is obliged to finance benefits with public funds (48.08%). Further categories were also
analyzed. Among all RSSs proposed in each year, only 17 of 52 in 2013 and 9 of 26
(1 proposition included more than one category) in 2012 could be classified according
to the Carlson’s approach. As a Results, most common categories were Price Volume
Agreements (4 in 2012 and 10 in 2013) and Manufacturer funded treatment initiation
(4 in 2012 and 6 in 2013). Both in 2012 and 2013, there were only one RSSs dependent
on the health effects achieved. Conclusions: Most of the propositions both in 2012
and 2013 are not considered to be RSS according to the Carlson’s approach. In 2013
compared to 2012 there were less price reduction schemes and more pay-back based
schemes. There is a strong need for further research.
A449
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PHP267
Coverage With Evidence Development Activities Around The World:
An Environment Scan
dialogue between health care authorities and the pharmaceutical industry to create
true risk-sharing agreements.
Li C M , Risebrough N A , Hux M
ICON plc (formerly Oxford Outcomes), Toronto, ON, Canada
PHP271
Risk-Sharing Schemes In Poland - Analysis And Classification of Rss
Proposed In Reimbursement Application Received by Ahtapol In 2013
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: A growing number of health technologies are coming to market
with limited, yet promising, clinical data. Coverage with evidence development
(CED), a conditional interim reimbursement scheme linked to research to reduce
uncertainty, has been increasingly explored by payers worldwide. The objective
was to summarize CED programs worldwide, and report final reimbursement decisions. Methods: A search was conducted using published literature, websites and
grey literature to identify CED programs worldwide from 1998 to 2012. Results:
Seventy-four CED schemes were identified in Canada (n= 23), Sweden (n=16), United
States (n=14), UK (n=11), Australia (n=4) and Europe (n=6). CED schemes were found
in oncology (n= 21), heart disease (n= 12), diabetes (n= 10), Neurological disorders
(n= 7), multiple sclerosis (n= 2), mental health (N= 3), rheumatoid arthritis (N= 1),
and other (N= 18). Drugs, imaging techniques, surgical procedures, and devices
were most commonly evaluated. Most CED programs aimed to address more than
one type of uncertainty. The most commonly encountered uncertainty was clinical benefit, followed by value for money, adoption and diffusion, and affordability.
Study designs included interventional, clinical, observational, and economic studies.
CED programs were generally managed by independent, government-funded nonprofit research organizations, university-based academic centers, or professional
societies. In only 39% (N= 28) of the identified CED schemes, study outcomes and
funding decisions were reported. In 74% (N= 17) of reported cases, the technology
evaluated was successfully funded. One technology (lung volume reduction surgery)
was only funded in a subgroup, and one technology was funded with price reduction. On many accounts CED has proven challenging to implement. Conclusions:
Although a large number of CED activities were identified, detailed information,
especially the study outcomes and final reimbursement decision, only limited information of final decisions was publically available. CED is a promising mechanism to
reduce uncertainty and aid timely patient access, but with emerging implementation challenges.
Iwanczuk T 1, Zawodnik S 1, Hermanowski T R 2, Matusewicz W 1
1Agency for Health Technology Assessment in Poland (AOTM), Warsaw, Poland, 2Medical
University of Warsaw, Warsaw, Poland
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To analyze and classify the Risk-Sharing Schemes (RSSs) proposed in
reimbursement applications received by Agency for Health Technology Assessment
in Poland (AHTAPol) in 2013. Methods: Risk-Sharing Schemes proposed in reimbursement applications received by AHTAPol in 2013 were quantitatively and
qualitatively analyzed. The classification of the RSSs was conducted based on both
Carlson’s approach and the Polish Act on the reimbursement of medicinal products. Results: In the studied period, 80 reimbursement applications for medicines,
special purpose dietary supplements or medical devices were received by AHTAPol.
Among them, there were 52 RSSs for 51, medical technologies. They were classified
into 5 categories according to the Act on the reimbursement. The most common
category was making the official sales price dependent on a pay-back of a part
of the reimbursement obtained to the entity which is obliged to finance benefits
with public funds (48.08%). Further categories were: making the official sales price
dependent on the applicant providing supplies at a reduced price as specified in the
negotiations on the price of the medicine (15.38%), making the official sales price
dependent on the level of turnover of the medicine (11.54%) and making the level
of the applicant’s revenues dependent on the health effects achieved (1.92%). Other,
nonclassified RSSs constituted 23.08% of all. Among 52 proposed RSSs only 17 of
them could be classified according to the Carlson’s approach. As a results, 10 Price
Volume Agreements, 6 Manufacturer funded treatment initiation and 1 Conditional
treatment continuation were identified. Conclusions: Most of the propositions
are not considered to be RSS according to the Carlson’s approach. The most common
propositions were related to pay-back of a part of the reimbursement obtained for
each reimbursed package and did not included any risk sharing. There is a strong
need for further research.
PHP268
Managed Entry Agreements in UK, Italy And Spain
Tolley C , Palazzolo D
Quintiles Consulting, Reading, UK
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Conceptual Papers
Objectives: To compare Managed Entry Agreements (MEAs) in the UK, Italy, and
Spain, and analyse the type of MEAs, number of agreements, and therapy areas in
which they exist. Finally, to determine MEA impact on market access delay in these
countries. Methods: HTA databases were searched for types and quantities of
MEAs (publicly available). The data were analysed by indication, and country specific knowledge applied, to quantify the average delay to market access. Results:
All types of MEA have been granted previously in the UK, the majority were nonoutcomes based (76%). In Italy, and Spain, all MEA’s were outcomes based, with
Italy focused purely on risk-sharing agreements. UK has 42 MEA’s since 2000, Italy
has 44 MEAs since 2006 and Spain has 9 MEAs since 2010. Of 95 MEAs, 56% were for
oncology drugs, 12% musculoskeletal, 10% ophthalmology, 7% CNS, 5% respiratory
and 10% other therapy areas. NICE average time to HTA decision is 21 months, and
is delayed up to 10 months depending on the type of MEA. AIFA average time to HTA
decision is 8 months; however MEAs are part of the pricing negotiation, so it may
be a way to gain market access faster. In Spain, the average time to HTA decision
is 8 months with decisions for drugs with double pricing arrangements taking on
average 14 months. For high cost hospital and orphan drugs, the delay can be up to
a year. Conclusions: Negative reimbursement decisions can have a significant
impact on achieving market access, and revenue generation. MEAs represent an
avenue for overcoming these negative decisions and market access for high cost
medicines. Companies aiming for MEAs in UK, Italy, and Spain, should be aware of
the potential market access delay and the precedence of MEAs that the payers in
these countries are amenable to.
PHP272
Whatever Happened To Nice Value-Based Pricing? Welcome, ValueBased Assessment
.
.
PHP270
The Possibility of Initiating True Risk-Sharing Agreements in the
Current Economic Situation
Germanenko A 1, Traulsen J M 2
of Copenhagen, Kobenhavn N, Denmark, 2University of Copenhagen, Kobenhavn,
Denmark
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: The aim of this project was to evaluate risk-sharing agreements that
are currently being negotiated in Europe between health care authorities and the
pharmaceutical industry. Methods: A literature review of the grey literature
(reports of the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development and WHO
Collaborating Centre for Pharmaceutical Pricing and Reimbursement Policies) as
well as peer-reviewed literature (PUBMED) was done to explore the background of
this topic. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with representatives of the
pharmaceutical industry, consultant agencies and health care authorities to get
their opinions about the current state of risk-sharing agreements. Results: The
study identified multiple problems in risk-sharing agreements such as insufficient
terminology and methodology, the absence of adequate infrastructure for implementation and a lack of trust and dialogue between the establishing parties: health
care authorities and pharmaceutical industry. These issues question the crucial concept of sharing the risks equally and disgrace the agreements, even though it would
be of great value to overcome current challenges. Such agreements could help the
health care authorities to keep within their budget while still providing innovative
pharmaceutical products/treatments to the patients. In addition, the pharmaceutical industry would have the opportunity to bring its products to the market and
patients would benefit from adequate pricing and reimbursement. Conclusions:
In spite of the current problems, the popularity of risk-sharing agreements in Europe
is growing fast and the future is bright. For this reason there is a strong need for
Langham S 1, Gemmell E 2, Kerrigan M 1, Wright A J 1, Chetty M 1
1PHMR Associates, London, UK, 2PHMR Associates, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
For several years, there has been much discussion about the central role the National
Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) would play in the move to valuebased pricing (VBP) of drugs in England and Wales as part of the new Pharmaceutical
Price Regulation Scheme (PPRS) scheduled to start in 2014. To date, there is no VBP
model, but NICE and the PPRS have been disentangled, and NICE is currently consulting on a proposal to include new terms of reference for value based assessment
(VBA) in its Technology Appraisal Methods Guide. This would change the way in
which it makes recommendations to the NHS and could become policy within a
short time frame. Therefore, manufacturers need to be aware the implication of the
VBA proposal on data requirements for NICE submissions. Currently, NICE reimbursement decisions are based on an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio threshold
of £20,000/QALY, with factors such as innovation and National Health Service objectives acting to increase the acceptable threshold up to £30,000/QALY, and end-of-life
benefits potentially increasing the acceptable threshold further to £50,000/QALY.
A key feature of the proposed VBA is the use of modifiers to numerically adjust
the ICER (up to a maximum of 2.5 times the base ICER of £20,000/QALY, i.e £50,000/
QALY). The burden of the illness for which the drug is approved as well as its societal
impact are two such modifiers. Precise guidance on applying burden of illness and
societal impact modifiers to ICERs is currently lacking, although information may
become available during summer 2014. However, there is some draft information
on quantifying these modifiers. We will review all available information, including
any post-consultation guidance, to provide an overview of data requirements and
possible changes to cost-effectiveness models that manufacturers may need to
consider for future VBAs.
PHP273
National Immunisation Technical Advisory Groups - A Framework
For Assessment and Insights From Research
Kleintjens J 1, King S 2, Hernández-Pastor L J 2, Abels M 1, Saka Ö 1, Bichon J 1
1Deloitte, Diegem, Belgium, 2GlaxoSmithKline, Wavre, Belgium
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: A National immunization Technical Advisory Groups (NITAG) is a body
of national experts that empowers and provides guidance to national health policy
makers to enable them to make evidence-based decisions on immunisation. The
aim of this study was 1) To develop a framework for the assessment of NITAGs that
will allow to understand how closely their operations are aligned with best practice;
2) to investigate whether differences with best practice are influenced by economic
or geographic differences between countries; and 3) to understand the impact of
NITAG alignment on the adoption of vaccines in the country’s national immunisation
programme. Methods: Building on previous initiatives mostly undertaken by the
World Health Organization, we conducted interviews and in-depth research on 35
NITAGs worldwide and built an assessment framework with 48 indicators to evaluate
NITAG Alignment with international guidance. Results: The assessment revealed
that there is a high variability in the degree of NITAG Alignment between countries
which could not be explained by differences in GDP per capita, health expenditure
per capita, or geographic location. Countries with a reasonably well-aligned NITAG
have a higher proportion of the WHO-recommended and additional vaccines in their
A450
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
national immunization programme. Some lower and middle income countries with
fairly strong alignment scores for recently established NITAGs have basic immunisation programmes. This study also found that NITAGs are usually developed following
a stepwise maturing process. Conclusions: Our detailed analysis of data from 35
countries suggests that, with the right support, all countries – regardless of their GDP/
capita, health expenditures and geographical location – have the potential to establish
highly performing NITAGs that are well-aligned with international recommendations.
Well-aligned NITAGs are generally instrumental for having strong immunisation programmes. Through awareness of its position in this maturation process, a NITAG can
focus on the appropriate next step for development and strengthening.
PHP274
Discontinuities Between Health Technology Assessment (HTA) and
Health Care Service Objectives of the NHS
Brazier P J 1, Durand A 1, Tierney R 1, Kelly S 2
Knowledge, London, UK, 2Pfizer Limited, Surrey, UK
.
.
.
.
.
1Matrix
Objective: Advances in early cancer diagnosis and treatment are enabling patients
to live longer with more fulfilling lives. The value assessment in such cases is
compelling. Many novel treatments for late-stage cancer also extend life, though
prognosis may still be poor. The valuation of such life-extending treatments can
be significantly reduced by health care costs associated with managing patients
for longer. This study highlights discontinuities between HTA for treatments that
extend patients’ lives and the NHS’s objective to improve cancer patients’ survival rates. Methods and Results: Economic comparison of two treatments
with an equivalent QALY gain, one that extends life while the other enhances the
quality of life, indicates that to achieve a common cost per QALY outcome the
life-extending treatment must be valued lower than the life-enhancing therapy.
This anomaly arises primarily because the value assessment for life-extending
treatments includes NHS costs of patient management during their extended life
in addition to the new treatment costs. For long-term chronic conditions these
additional costs may be easily offset; however, for severe, debilitating, or terminal
diseases the impact can be significant. Furthermore, for new treatments added in
combination to standard care, the greater the cost of existing care the lower the
value that may be placed on the new life-extending treatment, to the point that
new therapies may be deemed uneconomical even if available at no cost to the NHS.
These findings challenge the equitable use of ICERs for HTA including the accounting for health services costs during the extended lifetime of a patient achieved with
a new treatment. Conclusion: Value-based metrics used to appraise new treatments can inadvertently discriminate against life-extending therapies. Use of the
ICER in HTA can result in inconsistency with health service objectives e.g. the UK
Government’s goal to improve 1-year and 5-year survival rates for cancer patients.
PHP275
The Economic Value of Vaccination: Why Prevention Is Wealth
Remy V 1, Largeron N 1, Quilici S 1, Carroll S 2
1Sanofi Pasteur MSD, Lyon, France, 2Sanofi-Pasteur MSD, Maidenhead, UK
.
.
.
.
Context: Theoretical and empirical evidence has demonstrated that health care
is a major driver of economic growth. The European economic crisis has resulted in
health care budget cuts conferring consequences for health systems. Preventative
programmes, and particularly vaccination, are most vulnerable to short-term cuts
because their benefits are not always immediately identifiable. Although its huge
public health benefits are recognised, only a minor fraction of the health care budget
is allocated to vaccination. It has been suggested that cost-effectiveness analyses, as used in HTA as part of recommendations and reimbursement decisions,
may render a too narrow perspective of the overall economic benefits of vaccination. Objectives: The aim of this project is to demonstrate that, in addition to
contributing to health care system sustainability, vaccines have importance for
wider economic planning. A seven-chapter report was developed to highlight the
full economic value of vaccination from different perspectives: macro-economic,
health care system, society… Each chapter is illustrated with existing evidence
retrieved from peer-reviewed publications. The objective of this report is threefold:
1) to demonstrate the full economic value of vaccination with real life examples; 2)
to inform policy-makers on how immunisation contributes to health care systems
sustainability and efficiency; 3) to launch a call for action for the consideration of
the full economic value of vaccination. Discussion: Immunisation programmes
require adequate value recognition to ensure quick population access and wide
acceptability. Policy-makers should acknowledge that prevention through vaccination involves low levels of investment relative to the substantial incremental benefits it procures. As with other preventative interventions, it is difficult to evaluate
the true economic value of vaccines given a number of benefits are intangible and
thereby difficult to quantify in pure monetary terms. Taking into account the full
economic benefits of vaccination will allow understanding why prevention is the
one of the best ways to find efficiency gains.
PHP277
The Cost-Effectiveness Threshold For Orphan Designations in
Poland Based on Reimbursement Decisions
Grzywacz K , Pelczarska A , Witkowski M A , Ofierska-Sujkowska G , Zawada A
Agency for Health Technology Assessment in Poland, Warsaw, Poland
.
.
dations is cost-effectiveness information. Currently in Poland there is no specific
formal threshold for orphan designations, there is only a general cost-effectiveness
threshold that equals 3 x GDP per capita for ICUR/QALY (for CUA) or ICER/LYG (for
CEA), which in 2014 is approximately € 26 800. We extracted data on orphan drugs
from our database of medical technologies assessments from 2009 to March 2014.
Data on the cost-effectiveness (QALY / LYG) were put together with the decision of
reimbursement. On the basis of these data the threshold of cost effectiveness in
Poland for orphan designations was determined and summarized with the costeffectiveness thresholds current for a given time interval. Determination of the
threshold of cost effectiveness for orphan designations, that would be different
(higher) than the generally accepted cost-effectiveness threshold (due to high price
of orphan drugs to provide value for money is unlikely), is particularly important
from an ethical point of view, because of substantial therapeutic meaning of these
drugs and/or absence of other treatment options of proven benefit for the disease.
.
.
.
PHP278
Conflict Of Interest in HTA Recommendations and Case Law In
France
Frybourg S 1, Kornfeld A 1, Brunet J 2, Toumi M 3
1Creativ-Ceutical, Paris, France, 2Assistance Publique des Hôpitaux de Marseille, Marseille, France,
3University of Marseille, Marseille, France
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The slow reaction of French authorities to the “Mediator saga”
in France led to investigations that questioned the way conflicts of interest are
reported. This policy research reviewed the Loi Bertrand, known as French Sunshine
Act, and reported case law from the French Council of State (COS) related to conflict
of interest in HTA recommendations. Methods: Literature review and analysis of
recent laws and decrees were conducted to understand French policy in the field
of conflict of interest. A review of COS’ decisions related to conflicts of interest
among members of HAS commissions was performed. Results: France implemented the Loi Bertrand in May 2013 with the aim of specifying the scope of disclosure obligations. It affects most of the agreements concluded between health care
professionals and companies and covers a vast range of health products. Six cases
examined by the COS were analyzed, most of them related to removal of products
from refundable list. Four cases led to suspension or invalidation of decisions based
on HAS recommendations due to conflicts of interest. In the two other cases the
HAS provided the declarations of interest when required by the COS and the COS
considered the conflicts of interest as irrelevant for the decision. It appears that
the COS based its decisions on two main criteria: the acknowledgement of negative
conflict of interest (link with competitors) and the unavailability of declarations
of conflict of interest, which have to be provided by latest when required by legal
authorities. Conclusions: The strengthening of the regulation on declarations
of interest might lead to more transparency but also more cases ruled by the COS.
PHP279
Measuring and Observing Positive And Negative Externalities
Caused By Vaccines: Do We Have The Right Assessment Approach
Available?
Lefebvre C 1, Terlinden A 2, Standaert B 3
1Independent Researcher, Kiowa, CO, USA, 2Navigha, Tervuren, Belgium, 3GlaxoSmithKline
Vaccines, Wavre, Belgium
.
.
.
Objectives: Vaccination not only results in direct protection to those being vaccinated, it also has the potential of inducing indirect protection among unvaccinated
individuals (=herd protection or positive externality). However, negative unintended
consequences or externalities may also result from vaccination programmes (e.g.
rebound effects). It is our purpose to present how and when these positive and
negative externalities can be observed and measured. Methods: We first identify
under what conditions herd protection is most likely to occur. We then explore how
negative rebound effects can also be manifested. Detailed illustrations of both positive and negative effects are presented for different infections in relation to mass
vaccination programmes. Lastly, we discuss methods for observing and measuring
these externalities. Results: Optimal herd protection is likely to be observed when
the vaccine has a high quality-induced immunity, substantial effect on the force of
infection, and appropriate vaccine coverage and distribution. Example: HPV vaccination of 12-16 year old girls resulted in a 50% decrease of anogenital warts in
15-19 year aged adolescents in Denmark observed over a 4-year period. Rebound
effects may potentially occur due to vaccine-related age shifting, decreased natural
immunity, serotype replacement, low-medium coverage and non-homogeneous
vaccine distribution. Example: increased herpes zoster incidence in elderly postvaricella vaccine introduction. Those externalities can be captured through observational studies using real-life data, or may be estimated using dynamic transmission
modelling techniques. Conclusions: Limitations are inherent in those studies
and involve substantial ambiguity in the process of observing and quantifying the
indirect effects, making accurate evaluation troublesome. However the nature of
these outcomes could be critical for achieving good economic value when decision- makers are evaluating a novel vaccine for introduction into a particular region
or people group. More investigation is needed to identify and develop successful
assessment methodologies for precisely analysing these outcomes.
.
The aim of this study was to identify the cost-effectiveness threshold for an orphan
designations in Poland. According to criteria specified by the European Medicines
Agency (EMA) a medicine must meet a strict criteria to qualify for orphan designation, such as: treatment, prevention or diagnosis of a disease that is life-threatening
or chronically debilitating; disease prevalence level in the European Union (EU) of
no more than 5 cases in 10,000 patients is necessary; no satisfactory method of
disease diagnosis, prevention, treatment or if such method exists, the drug must
deliver significant benefits to patients. In Poland, orphan drugs undergo full pharmacoeconomic evaluations and coverage decision processes similar to any other
innovative medicines. One of the important element of reimbursement recommen-
PHP280
Market Access and Reimbursement: The Increasing Role of RealWorld Evidence
Pietri G , Masoura P
PAREXEL Consulting, London, UK
.
.
Randomised controlled trials (RCTs) have historically been considered the primary
source of evidence to support market access and reimbursement. However, real-world
data (RWD) are increasingly being considered by industry and payers. The objectives
of this research were to review the current perception of RWD across Europe and to
assess how RWD can support market access and reimbursement. A review of the
literature, guidelines from European health technology assessment (HTA) agencies
A451
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
and governmental authorities, case studies and the latest publications in value-based
assessment (VBA) was performed to summarise the current perception of RWD, and
to identify the advantages and challenges of using RWD to support market access and
reimbursement. Only 10 guidelines were found from 73 European HTA agencies or
governmental authorities which cited RWD as a source for evidence. NICE acknowledges the difficulties of generalising RCT results to clinical practice, and supports
the capture and analysis of observational data. In addition, recent developments in
VBA anticipate a greater scrutiny of attempts to model natural history in economic
evaluations, which may be addressed by using longitudinal observational data. Case
studies have shown economic evaluations based on RCT data may lack external
validity, and may consequently produce inaccurate estimates of economic endpoints.
There is a consensus that RWD are valuable in providing clinical practice evidence on
treatment pathways, resource use, long-term natural history and true effectiveness.
However, there are methodological challenges (such as lack of randomisation) to
be addressed before RWD are widely accepted as a complement to RCTs to support
decision-making. RWD are increasingly recognised as a valuable source of evidence
for market access and reimbursement, and as a complement to clinical trial evidence.
Nevertheless, there are challenges that need to be addressed to ensure real world data
provide valid evidence to the decision process.
PHP281
Reimbursement Hurdles For High-Cost Brand-On-Brand
Combinations and Impact on Patient Access
Leoni G , Papadopoulou K
ICON Plc, London, UK
.
.
Combinations of high-cost branded drugs are becoming a reality. The synergistic
value of combining two potent drugs is expected to considerably bolster the benefit
to the patient in terms of efficacy and, in some cases, even safety. However, the synergistic cost of using branded combinations increases exponentially due to longer
treatment durations, thus making the total treatment cost unaffordable to European
health systems. This poster aims to explore the pricing and reimbursement issues
that health systems will encounter during the evaluation of branded combination
therapies and potential solutions to make these combinations affordable by the
health care systems and ensure patient access to innovative drugs. To meet these
objectives, an in-depth review of published sources was conducted, including a
thorough analogue assessment. Moreover, targeted interviews with twenty payers
involved at different levels of pricing and market access decision-making in the
EU5 were also conducted to support analysis. Research revealed that synergistic
costs of already expensive monotherapies, further exacerbated by longer duration
of treatment, exceed payers’ cost thresholds. Therefore, on one hand payers will
struggle to award a value-based price for the individual drugs as well as for the
combination and will look to discount and/or restrict access. On the other hand, as
this approach will not reflect the combination’s synergistic value and could threaten
the life-cycle indications of each compound, manufacturers may not launch in some
markets, thus, limiting patient access. Consequently, it is important to find a balance
in setting a value-based price for individual indications and for the combinations
to ensure broad patient access. Aligning patient, payer and manufacturer needs is
paramount to find a win-win-win solution. In the context of brand-on-brand combinations, traditional pricing models are not the solution and alternative approaches
need to be adopted.
PHP282
The Case For Early Payer Engagement
Leigh C 1, Faulkner E 2, Horowicz-Mehler N 1
Global Consulting, New York, NY, USA, 2University of North Carolina, Durham, NC,
USA
.
.
.
1Quintiles
Background: Knowledge of payer evidence requirements is vital to manufacturers who are facing increasing development costs for uncertain market access
outcomes. Failure to engage payers early in asset development could result in delay
of approval and/or coverage. Objectives: Build the case for early payer engagement as a means of reconciling the needs of payers and manufacturers Methods:
A literature search was performed and primary research with key opinion leaders
in the US and EU was conducted to characterize 5 early engagement strategies
(informal consultation, formal consultation, outcomes-based risk sharing, financialbased risk sharing, and formal partnerships). 7 major markets (Canada, France,
Italy, Germany, Spain, UK, and US) were also assessed for their historic use of early
engagement models. Results: Payers want more manufacturer involvement in evidence development, including input into clinical trial design and RWE development
in phases II and III through formal and informal consultations. Articulation of an
asset’s value story in the peri-launch phase and negotiations with regional and local
payers through direct consultations allows manufacturers to position the asset for
optimal pricing and reimbursement. When agreement cannot be reached on price
or reimbursement terms, risk-sharing agreements allow broader access in exchange
for the manufacturer bearing incrementally greater financial risk. Manufacturers
have also built partnerships to uncover the real-world value of therapies and gain
insight into usage and adherence patterns. Each market has its own challenges
for promoting collaboration, requiring manufacturers to tailor their approach to
the various national and local payers Conclusion: Early planning is imperative
in value-focused health care. When early payer engagement succeeds, it provides
manufacturers time to design informed strategies to meet payer valuation needs.
Evidence development that is closely aligned with payer requirements results in
therapies that are more cost effective and gain quicker market access, benefitting
manufacturers, payers, and patients alike.
PHP283
Early Nice Decision Problem Meetings: Implications For CrossFunctional Industry Teams
Floyd D , Langham S , Chetty M
PHMR Associates, London, UK
.
.
.
The National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) in England and Wales
is currently piloting a process whereby decision problem meetings are held several months before starting a technology appraisal, rather than approximately 10
weeks after formal invitation for the manufacturer to submit evidence, per current
protocol. In general, the purpose and outcomes of the meeting, involving the NICE
team and representatives from the evidence research group (ERG), do not change
other than happening earlier. However, the meeting does allow manufacturers and
sponsors to signal potential regulatory developments during the appraisal, ahead
of the submission, to indicate potential inclusion and handling of patient access
scheme proposals. For the meeting, an outline is required to demonstrate how the
manufacturer/sponsor intends to approach the decision problem. This outline is
to include, but is not limited to: evidence sources to be used; evidence likely to
become available during the appraisal and how this might be managed; the planned
approach to disease and economic modelling; potential challenges in interpreting
the evidence; proposed approach to handling of uncertainty. If adopted, there are
several implications of this new process for manufacturers/sponsors: market access
strategy will need to be considered earlier than currently, with implications for data
availability and analyses, value story development, positioning and indications,
etc; cost-effectiveness models and their base cases will need earlier definition and
completion; intentions regarding patient access schemes must be made before submission; ERGs may be reviewing limited published evidence in fast-moving therapy
areas;, manufacturer market access groups will require more information from
clinical, regulatory, medical affairs, modellers, epidemiologists much sooner that
they currently do. Therefore, this seemingly simple change of meeting date relative to time of submission has important implications for manufacturers beyond
their market access teams that require careful consideration in terms of planning
and communication.
PHP284
The Irish Cost-Effectiveness Threshold: Does It Support Rational
Rationing or Might It Lead To Systematic Damage Of Ireland’s
Health System?
O’Mahony J 1, Coughlan D 2
College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland, 2Newcastle University, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK
.
.
1Trinity
Irish legislation recognises the need to consider the cost-effectiveness of health
services, both for new interventions and their opportunity cost. Ireland did not
have an explicit cost-effectiveness threshold until a 2012 agreement between the
pharmaceutical industry and government established a € 45,000/QALY threshold.
It was agreed as part of a deal that provided cost savings on existing medications
and only applies to pharmaceuticals: there is no official threshold for non-drug
interventions. Drugs with cost-effectiveness ratios within the threshold are guaranteed reimbursement, whereas those exceeding the threshold may be approved
following further negotiation. A number of drugs far exceeding the threshold have
been reimbursed in Ireland in recent years. There are four reasons for concern
regarding Ireland’s threshold. Firstly, as a price floor not a ceiling it offers only a
weak constraint on the introduction of cost-ineffective interventions, which leaves
little scope for positive net health benefit. Secondly, that the threshold only applies
to drugs creates potential for inconsistencies whereby relatively cost-effective
non-drug interventions may not necessarily be approved, leading to sub-optimal resource allocation. Thirdly, the current threshold has no apparent empirical basis. Finally, recent efforts to determine the appropriate cost-effectiveness
threshold in the UK have estimated a threshold of approximately £13,000/QALY.
Assuming Ireland’s threshold should be broadly comparable, the current Irish
threshold is most probably too high. Consequently, reimbursing new interventions at and above the € 45,000/QALY threshold is likely to result in net harm, as
new drugs produce less health than the interventions they displace. The failure
of Ireland’s threshold to be empirically determined by the cost-effectiveness of
services foregone means the requirements of current legislation are not being
met and reimbursement decisions cannot be considered fully evidenced-based.
It is likely the current threshold is excessive and will lead to systematic damage
of the health system.
PHP285
An Ethic System Overview: Brazilian Perspectives For Observational
Studies
Minowa E 1, Bueno C C 1, Piedade A 1, Clark L G O 1, Santinho C S 1, de Castro Monteiro D C 2,
Feijo L F 1, Ueda K 3, Matos G M 4, Hashimoto D A K 4
1Evidências Credibilidade Científica, São Paulo, Brazil, 2Roche Product New Zealand, Auckland,
New Zealand, 3Harvard Medical School, Tokyo, Japan, 4Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo,
Brazil
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Background: Observational studies have been one of the hallmarks for the development of public health and health economics fields. It includes epidemiologic studies, evaluation of patterns of care, use of resources, cost of illness, analysis of safety
and effectiveness of interventions from real world. However, there are different patterns of requirements for ethics reviews concerning observational studies, including
vastly available models of ethics systems among different countries. Therefore,
the objective of this study is to evaluate the ethics system, regulations and guidelines concerning observational studies in the selected countries. Methodology:
Guidelines and regulations from Brazil, Argentina, Japan, New Zealand, Australia,
USA and UK were reviewed to evaluate the ethics system and available guiding
principle for observational studies. Additionally, a literature review was performed
in the database Medline and SciELO mesh using the terms “ethics”, “observational
study” and “multicenter study” among other similar terms. Results: In Brazil,
same ethics regulation is applied for both interventional and observational projects,
plus there is unsatisfactory ethics review timelines and duplicity of ethics review
when considering multicenter studies. Specific pathways for multicenter studies
are available only in New Zealand, Australia, USA and UK. For the exception of Brazil,
other evaluated countries have specific guidelines, recommendations or regulations
for observational studies. Conclusions: Brazil and Argentina still have a lot of
A452
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
challenges to overcome regarding the overall ethics system. Applying same ethics
regulations or guidelines from interventional studies may not be the most adequate
choice for observational studies.
PHP289
Sustainable Health Care Systems: The Role of Therapeutic Value and
Value Based Pricing
Hulshof J A M
Simon-Kucher & Partners, Bonn, Germany
.
PHP286
State of the Art Research In Austria: Dexhelpp - Decision Support
For Health Policy and Planning: Methods, Models and Technologies
Based On Existing Health Care Data
Zauner G 1, Popper N 1, Breitenecker F 2
GmbH, Vienna, Austria, 2Vienna University of Technology, Vienna, Austria
.
.
.
1dwh
The Austrian health care system incurs costs of 30 billion/year, the bulk of the costs
(77%) are publicly financed. Health policy and decision planning based on research
evidence helps to tackle increasing costs. The urgent need for the evaluation of
new health technologies, services, infrastructure, as well as for the development
of improved technologies for the analysis, planning and control of health systems
is met by DEXHELPP. Methods: Today, decision support in health care is usually
based on evidence from studies of limited size, but not yet on the analysis of
large volumes of routinely collected health care data. DEXHELPP is dedicated to
filling the gap by combining academic excellence by research partners with professional implementation including knowledge of commercial partner institutions.
By doing so special methods for statistical analysis, simulation and visualisation
will be implemented as well as new methods for documentation and providing of k-anonymity for used individual data. For this task, existing cooperation
schemes provide a firm substantial and conceptual knowledge base. All relevant
fundamental technological competencies from academic and applied research
are provided by the consortium, coming from universities, competence centres,
and R&D SMEs. Results: Developed methods will help in (1) analysing the status
quo, (2) making reliable prognoses, and (3) evaluating the consequences of interventions. A scientific research server with routine data in order to test developed
methods will be run. The project covers all relevant areas within this complex process, from data management via analysis and modelling through to user friendly
presentation of results and quality assurance. Some of the most important actual
decision-makers in Austria complete the consortium with application-oriented
expertise. Conclusions: DEXHELPP focusses on the development on high innovative technological methods. Future focus will lay on building up a network
with more stakeholders to integrate those methods in national and international
processes.
.
.
It is a common perception that the cost of pharmaceutical care, driven by the price
of medicines, is a major contributor to increasing public health care expenditure,
the culprit of unsustainability of health care systems. This presentation shows how
the net effect of value-based pricing of new, innovative treatments and competitive pricing of older, often generic, products defeats that perception. The growth
of pharmaceutical expenditure is, in fact, leveling off in most European countries,
a trend that started even before the economic crisis of 2008. Value based pricing
is an approach by which the pricing strategy is determined by therapeutic value,
economic value and cost-effectiveness. Value based pricing requires a substantial body of sophisticated evidence, generated throughout product development.
Competitive pricing is an approach by which the pricing strategy of older products
is defined relative to the price of direct competitors in order to maximize market
share. Competitive pricing occurs in crowded markets with multiple equal or undifferentiated treatment options. In recent years, competitive pricing has brought the
price of many widely prescribed drugs significantly down. These two approaches
to strategic pricing take place against the backdrop of tightening public financing
rules that aim at ensuring financial sustainability of publicly financed health care
systems. Consequence thereof is a two-tiered market access decision-making routine: for high-value/high-priced innovative treatments centralized decision-making
based on value assessment with evidence, restricting them to a tightly characterized
severely ill patient sub-population with low volume and/or a sales ceiling; versus
local decision-making based on lowest (net) price for high-volume multisource
products or equivalent single-source products, leading to significantly lower (net)
prices than the originator at time of launch. Sustainable pharmaceutical care with
openness towards innovation is therefore within reach.
PHP290
Economic Evaluation In Portugal – Establishment of The National
Health Technology Assessment System (Sinats)
Cortegaça P , Silva F , Viana D , Ramos R , Martins J
INFARMED, I.P., Lisbon, Portugal
.
.
.
.
.
The rationale for patient and public involvement (PPI) in the Health Technology
Assessment (HTA) process has been widely documented. Engagement of patients or
public in the process facilitates a broadening of scope and delineates a role for the
patient as an ‘expert witness’ who has unique insight to living with an illness and
the potential benefits/disadvantages (including side effects) that medical technology may offer. Our objective was to explore the concept of practical and meaningful
public participation in the HTA process and present a research protocol to propose
a PPI framework applicable to the Irish context. A qualitative systematic literature
review and concept analysis was used to identify key attributes relating to patient
and public involvement. It is proposed that this knowledge will be supplemented
through semi-structured interviews of key informants and a review of a purposive
sample of HTA agency websites. Researchers, decision makers and policy makers
will contribute to development and refinement a framework through a process of
deliberation. Capturing the diverging perceptions of key informants will lead to the
enhancement of the proposed framework. The role of the publics will be clarified,
various levels and methods of PPI further defined. This research will explore the
concept of PPI and suggest a study protocol for the development of a framework for
PPI in the context of the Irish HTA process.
Economics is a social science that has a focus on allocating limited resources efficiently. In health care is essential to invest properly, assuring access to health technologies with the best cost-effective profile, ensuring the sustainability of National
Health Systems. In Portugal, the INFARMED – National Authority of Medicines and
Health Products I.P., has been making economic evaluations of medicines for 15
years, and is currently developing the National Health Technology Assessment
System – SiNATS, of the utmost importance to the National Health System.
Nowadays the assessment of the technologies (relative effectiveness assessment
and cost-effectiveness) is focused on medicines, within the reimbursement process
and the preliminary assessment to its acquisition by the National Health System’s
Hospitals. Consequently, it is always done before the reimbursement decision, as
a supporting tool to the decision itself. The purpose of this model is to guarantee
a global system, and at the same time, extending it to new technologies besides
medicines, e.g. medical devices. In these cases, the cost-effectiveness evaluation will
be done through the whole life-cycle of that technology, affecting its price and use
considering its real performance; instead of only its market entry. The INFARMED,
by developing SiNATS, intends to contribute to minimize expenditures in health and
the citizens’ life quality, in order to assure the National Health System’s sustainability and efficient usage of public resources in health. Moreover, this system also
aims to observe the technologies’ effectiveness and its usage, with the purpose of
reducing wastes as well as to promote and award innovation and equal access to
health technologies. This research intends to verify the applicability of the universal key principles of Health Technology Assessment Systems in SiNATS, in order
to guarantee that the model achieves its proposing objectives. The study will be
focused on the structure of system.
PHP288
Patient Access To Life-Saving Medication; Preventing Stock-Outs
Due To Parallel Trade
PHP291
Market Access and Reimbursement Options For Orphan Durg
Hospital Only Medicines In Europe – One Size Fits All?
Ratcliffe M 1, Mbanya Z 2, Gielen V 1, Sparrowhawk K 1
1PHMR Associates, London, UK, 2PHMR Associates, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK
Vosgerau S 1, Paulus G 1, Plantoer S 2
1IMS Health, Munich, Germany, 2IMS HEALTH GmbH & Co. OHG, Munich, Germany
Manufacturers and suppliers of potentially life-saving drugs must ensure adequate
supplies of in-date drug formulations for all markets across Europe. Failure to do
so risks patient lives, but stock-outs have occurred even when a manufacturer has
“over-supplied” a market with many times the amount of drug expected to meet
local demand. These stock-outs have occurred as a result of parallel trade. In these
cases, as little as a 10% variance on pack cost is enough to trigger parallel trade,
which can result from price variations at launch across the EU and currency fluctuations following launch. These situations form a useful series of case studies to
determine supply chain issues leading to stock-outs. Based on this case study analysis, a model is being developed to estimate the degree of exposure to risk of parallel
trade and its associated potential cost to the manufacturer/supplier, and to patient
access. The model identifies and quantifies trade flow patterns and key elements.
Consequently, supply planning is possible based on essential metrics identified in
the trade flow patterns. An allocation scheme to meet local needs is the key output
of the model. The allocation scheme is applied to limit stock to the country to be
in line with demand, plus a smaller variance (depending on local conditions) for
that market compared to that previously applied. The model is intended for use in
key EU markets (France, Germany, Italy, The Netherlands, Spain, Italy, UK) as well
as countries in Central and Eastern Europe. The model should help to optimise
supply chain planning and operations, thereby minimising the risk of stock-outs.
Consequently, all patients requiring specific, potentially life-saving drugs should
have access to these treatments.
Orphan drugs are medicines used to the treat life-threatening or chronic diseases
affecting very rare diseases. From April 2000 to October 2010, 720 drugs received
orphan drug designation from the European Medicines Agency (EMA). Hereof, 63
were granted marketing a marketing authorization. Since then - with an annual
orphan drug sales volume of more than $6 billion - there has been a steady increase
in applications for orphan designation with the Committee for Orphan Medicinal
Products (COMP), averaging ten positive recommendations per month. Although
central approval of orphan drugs covers 30 European countries, it does not necessarily provide for national availability as each national authority has to agree to
market access and reimbursement. Further, the hospital sector is known for its
high diversity in terms of national access mechanisms and degree of centralization,
exemplified by the Nordic Countries: In Denmark and Norway a highly centralized
hospital sector prevails with one main hospital procurement agency (AMGROS in
Denmark and LIS in Norway), while in Sweden and Finland several county councils
are authorized to make decisions independently from each other. The objective of
the present study is to identify and evaluate possible short cut routes to market
access and reimbursement for orphan drug hospital only medicines (OD-HOM) in EU
and further investigate country specific requirements for identified short cut routes
to market access and reimbursement for OD HOM in EU as strategic options. A literature review and further desk research was performed. The following countries are
included in the analysis: Nordic Countries, Germany, France, The Netherlands and
Spain. The results of the ongoing OD-HOM research will be displayed as a summary
PHP287
Proposed Framework for Patient And Public Involvement in the Hta
Process In Ireland
Walsh C
Trinity College Dublin, Montenotte, Ireland
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A453
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
of options and requirements by country. The evaluation of market access options for
OD-HOM can ease market access and reimbursement and influence international
launch sequences of innovative orphan drugs.
patient’s involvement and better health outcomes. Improving service development
and access to health advice with care experience are other adjuvant interventions.
So patient’s participation is a key better care plan.
PHP293
Cost and Duration Of Regulatory Process in an Observational
Study in Europe and USA
PHP297
Turkish Public Procurement System for Medical Devices:A Guide for
Reimbursement Policy?
Ori A , Fiori G G , Fernandez S , Longo D , Simoni L
MEDIDATA SRL, MODENA, Italy
Seyhun O , Can H , Erdol S , Erdogan Ciftci E
Medtronic, Inc., Istanbul, Turkey
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Despite the growing interest in observational studies, there is any
defined regulatory process unlike clinical trials, which have a defined one. Currently,
international observational studies have to deal with each county regulatory process
that means to face times and costs very heterogeneous and not regulated yet by
the EU. Here we report the experience of MediData in international observational
study conduct. Methods: The start-up process in 7 countries was analyzed as for
regulatory process in terms of time and costs. Results: In Europe the faster regulatory process takes 12 weeks (Turkey) and the slowest one takes almost twice as
long (Italy 24 weeks), while in the USA they spend almost 16 weeks to conclude the
whole process. Usually times and costs have an inverse relationship, but the observational studies analyzed shows that the second cheaper country is Turkey, that comes
after France where the process is free. Another example of this variety is the case of
Spain and France in the same duration of the process have a difference of spending
of 12000 € . Conclusions: These duration and spending really differentiated
have a huge impact on the observational study conduction. Especially at the international level, we might run into sponsored studies which could be conducted in
countries with cheaper or faster regulation processes, with the real risk of a selection
bias of the sites and, therefore, a very partial collection of data. Inevitably, the result
will be unrepresentative epidemiological data. It’s very important to have a pan-European regulation that allows the observational study conduction in an homogenous
and aligned way and also to have complete and representative epidemiological data.
PHP295
Access To Orphan Drugs in France: The Case Of Siklos For The
Treatment of Sickle Cell Syndrome Before The Council of State
.
.
.
In 2008, Public Procurement Law (PPL) was amended to implement and regulate
e-Procurement in Turkey. Non-private, public purchaser hospitals are obliged to
enter tender results of their medical device purchases into e-procurement system
(EPS) to be eligible for a reimbursement by the Social Security Institution (SSI) in
Turkey. Objectives of this research are to examine the impact of the EPS that is
currently being used for medical device purchases in Turkey since 2011; and to
investigate how the system is being used to define ceiling prices for reimbursement,
concurrently assessing the quality and quantity of data uploaded by hospitals. EPS
data is downloaded on a GMDN basis from Turkish National Database for Medical
Devices, (TITUBB) which is an e-catalogue system that was launched to provide barcode level product registration, search and the e-procurement results. In accordance
with the objectives, assessment is conducted on more than ten GMDNs and results
are utilized to see the effect of EPS on pricing, comparing the prices on officially
published SSI positive lists. Our study shows that a lowest price detected on EPS
could be set as the reimbursement price, as was the case for the product; aortic stent
graft, contralateral limb, where a defined SSI positive list price was reduced after
determination of a lower price on EPS, on account of a mispriced tender record.
An extrapolation while searching out the reimbursement prices is needed instead
of SSI’s calculations based on merely a retrospective and detection of lowest price
practice. Effectiveness of this policy depends on resolving the weaknesses of EPS
data in terms of quality and quantity; a misdated tender or a mispriced product
could be a ground for an erroneous price setting and tenders that are not recorded
at all or deferred might lead to incomplete EPS data to define reimbursement prices.
Murteira S 1, El Hammi E 2, Kornfeld A 3, Toumi M 4
1Lundbeck Japan KK, Tokoyo, Japan, 2Evidenz, Tunis, Tunisia, 3Creativ-Ceutical, Paris, France,
4University of Marseille, Marseille, France
Disease-Specific Studies
Background: Hydroxycarbamid is an antineoplastic molecule commercialized
since 1968 in France under the name Hydrea®. In the absence of an alternative
licensed drug for the treatment of Sickle Cell Syndrome (SCS), Hydrea® has been routinely used off-label for over 15 years in this indication. In 2007, Siklos® became the
first licensed orphan drug indicated in the symptomatic treatment of SCS. However,
during the pricing and reimbursement procedures, the French Transparency
Committee decided to compare Siklos® to Hydrea® and as such Siklos® was evaluated as bringing a weak additional benefit (ASMR IV) which had a major impact on
the price given by the French Economic Committee on Health Care Products (CEPS).
The manufacturer of Siklos® entered in litigation with the CEPS and after a long
legal procedure, the French Council of State issued two orders by way of interlocutory procedures suspending the decision of the drug price setting and determining
the minimal threshold under which Health Authorities could not set the price of
this drug. Discussion: The negative assessment of the French HTA could have set
a precedent for future evaluations of orphan or pediatric medicines issued from
drug repurposing. These decisions are unique in the history of the Council of State’s
jurisprudence on several aspects: it was an unprecedented case where a CEPS decision is overturned by the Council of State and the first time that a judicial decision
provides guidance on the price level for a pharmaceutical drug in France. This case
law has also the consequence to enlarge the criteria taken into account by the CEPS
in new drug price setting, especially for orphan drugs. Conclusion: Siklos® case
law provided a new legal ground that is in contradiction with available regulation
and practice and opens the way for future legal challenges to the CEPS decisions.
Mental Health – Clinical Outcomes Studies
.
.
.
.
PHP296
Patient’s Participation in Improvement of Health Related Outcomes:
The Better Care Plan
PMH1
The Risk of Metabolic Disorders in Patients Treated with Asenapine
or Olanzapine: A Real World Data Study Conducted in Italy
and Spain
Maina G 1, Ripellino C 2, Pegoraro V 2, Caresano C 3
1University of Turin, Turin, Italy, 2CSD Medical Research S.r.l., Milan, Italy, 3Lundbeck Italia
S.p.A., Milan, Italy
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Second-generation antipsychotic drugs, knows as Atypical
Antipsychotics, have a better tolerability than conventional antipsychotics but it
has reported that its usage lead to a substantial weight gain, an increase risk of
dyslipidemia and type 2 diabetes mellitus. In this article authors assessed the risk
of metabolic adverse events associated with Asenapine in comparison with those
associated with Olanzapine by studying real world data. Methods: The study was
a retrospective analysis based on data extracted from Italian and Spanish Cegedim
Stategic Data Longitudinal Patient Data databases. Patients were divided in two
cohorts (Asenapine and Olanzapine) according to the inclusion criteria and data
from these patients were analyzed starting from 2009 up to 2013. Diabetes and
dyslipidemia registrations have been searched in order to assess the risk of developing metabolic adverse events. Results: The retrospective analysis showed a lower
risk of developing type 2 diabetes and dyslipidemia associated with Asenapine
treatment in comparison with Olanzapine. Scenario analyses supported the robustness of the results. Conclusions: Asenapine is associated with a lower risk of
metabolic adverse events than Olanzapine, demonstrating a better safety profile
with regard to metabolic effects.
Singh A 1, Khera K 1, Rana R 2, Chauhan S 3
1Manipal College of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Manipal, India, 2R.M. Medical College & Hospital,
Chennai, India, 3KLE’s College of Pharmacy, Belgaum, India
PMH2
Efficacy of the Phosphorylated Tau P181 for the Alzheimer’s Disease
Dementia - a Systematic Review and Meta Analysis
Objective: Patient’s involvement in their health care is important to improve quality, efficacy and better patient care. It is a strategy to achieve improved health
outcomes and lower costs. A main objective of the discussion is focused on “how
to inform, encourage and educate the patient to participate in their health care
decisions?” The purpose of the discussion also centered on the various patients
focused interventions required to improve the health care outcomes by patient’s
participation. Background: All patients want the information about the disease
and complications they have, but not all want to involve in decision making. Most of
the patients preferred to leave the final decision on doctors/clinicians. Engagement
of patients in health care and decision making would improve the health outcomes
and lowering the cost of therapy or treatment. Discussion: Health care is a complicated system to patients; they struggle to understand their medical conditions
and services. All patients must have to know about basic health information and
treatment options. This would be possible by encouraging patient’s to play an active
role in their health care that could improve health outcomes, efficiency and quality.
Patient’s participation and engagement are based on patient activation which refers
to understanding, ability, health literacy and willingness of patient to manage his or
her health and care. Patients can participate at different levels as direct care or their
preference in treatment plan and/or in policy making for future recommendations.
Patient focused interventions are discussed as companion to patient’s participation
or engagement. Improvement in health literacy, patient safety, improvement in self
care and clinical decision making are four primary interventions which promote the
Mo J
National Evidence-based Health Care Collaborating Agency & Inha University, SEOUL,
South Korea
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The purpose of this study was to apply a systematic review of the
literature to evaluate the diagnostic effectiveness of the Phosphorylated tau p181
for the Alzheimer’s disease dementia. Methods: A systematic literature review
was used to evaluate the effectiveness of of the Phosphorylated tau p181 for the
Alzheimer’s disease dementia. The Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network
(SIGN) tool was used by two evaluators to independently evaluate the quality of the
ten studies. The literature review covered from October 27, 1946 to October 22, 2013,
and eight domestic databases including KoreaMed and foreign databases including Ovid-MEDLINE, EMBASE, and Cochrane Library were used. Results: A total of
9studies (9 diagnostic evaluation studies) were identified to evaluate Phosphorylated
tau. Theeffectiveness of this test was evaluated based on diagnostic accuracy. The
diagnostic accuracy for identifying AD of ELISA was high (pooled sensitivity, 0.843
(95% CI 0.818-0.867); pooled specificity, 0.799 (95% CI 0.768-0.828); summary receiver
operating characteristic area under the curve 0.9082±0.0236. Primary criteria for
inclusion were valid studies on (i) patients with mild cognitive impairment with
confirmed or suspected AD and non-AD dementia, and (ii) assessment of tau levels
using appropriate comparative tests. Conclusions: Evaluated CSF Phosphorylated
tau levels are of potential utility in the differential diagnosis of AD versus non-AD
dementias and healthy controls.
A454
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PMH3
Adaptive Video Games can Assess and Enhance Cognitive Health
Sparrowhawk K 1, Kumar R 1, Harrison J 2
1MyCognition, London, UK, 2Metis Cognition, London, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: MyCognition has already demonstrated that its adaptive video game
programmes are able to enhance cognitive health in healthy volunteers (FENS, July
2014). It is now using the same technology to assess and train cognitive health
in psychiatric and neurological patient populations that have cognitive impairment. Methods: In both the psychiatric and neurological patient population it is
planned that all with have their cognitive health assessed prior to commencement
of the study to provide a baseline score. This will be for the 5 key cognitive domains
(attention, psychomotor speed, episodic memory, working memory and executive
functioning). All will then be randomised to either active or control group. The
active group comprises adaptive video training of at least one hour per week over
a 12-week period on top of standard care. The control group receives standard care
alone. All the subjects will have their cognitive health assessed at 0, 4, 8 and 12
weeks. They will also have their condition assessed via a specific scale, e. g., PANS for
Schizophrenia, UPDRS for Parkinson’s. The results will be calculated as change from
baseline for both groups at 4, 8 and 12 weeks. Results: In previous tests in healthy
volunteers a significant improvement in cognitive health was seen after 4 weeks of
training. By 8 weeks it was possible to see a dose response to the duration of training,
with longer training showing a greater effect. Conclusions: Detrimental cognitive
health is seen in many neuropsychiatric conditions. To date, drug therapies have
had a poor impact on cognitive disorders. This adaptive video training programme
presents a potential therapeutic intervention that is safe and effective. The online
assessment can be used to profile at risk subjects and the training could be used to
prevent as well as treat cognitive decline.
PMH4
Selecting Patients with Severe Personality Disorders using
Concept Mapping
Goorden M
Institute for Medical Technology Assessment, Rotterdam, Zuid Holland, The Netherlands
.
Objectives: The costs of mental health care for patients with severe and complex personality disorders are high. It is likely that currently, these patients are
not treated effectively due to limited early recognition. The aim of this study is to
develop a set of criteria to match patients with severe and complex personality disorders to effective treatment in highly specialized treatment programs. Methods:
The subsequent steps consisted of conducting a literature search, applying concept
mapping, arranging an expert-meeting and validating the set of criteria. After the
literature search, concept mapping, using cluster analysis and multidimensional
scaling, was conducted. Goodness of fit and reliability were tested. A consensus
meeting was arranged to determine cut-off points and operationalize the clusters. In this way, the definite set of criteria for matching patients with severe and
complex personality disorder was developed. A pilot study on the checklist was
conducted, including 20 therapists evaluating 45 patients and subsequently a validation study at 8 mental health institutes was performed. Additionally, a methodology
to obtain sets of criteria for other psychiatric diagnoses was developed. Results:
After the literature search and concept mapping, 6 different categories of criteria
were defined. The concept mapping model provided a good fit (stress value= 0.30)
and reliability (ρ = 0.49) was reasonably high. The bridging values were on general
low, indicating homogeneity. The pilot study indicated that clinical judgment and
the outcome of the checklist correlated high (0.8). The validation study has been
accomplished at 8 mental health institutes in the Netherlands. The analysis concerning the validation study is now being conducted and the first results will be
available in August 2014. Conclusions: The method is systematic, structured and
repeatable and the results of the pilot study are promising. The protocol will provide
an instrument to develop sets of criteria for other disorders to increase matching of
patients in mental health care to (cost) effective interventions.
PMH5
Systematic Literature Review and Mixed Treatment Comparison of
Gxr Versus other Treatments in Children and Adolescents with
Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD)
Joseph A 1, Ayyagari R 2, Bischof M 3, Cai S 4, Xie M 2, Zhanabekova Z 2, Sikirica V 5
Group Inc., Boston, MA, USA, 3Shire, Eysins, Switzerland,
4Analysis Group Inc., New York, NY, USA, 5Shire Development, LLC, Wayne, PA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Shire, Zug, Switzerland, 2Analysis
Objectives: This study compared the clinical efficacy of ADHD treatments in children and adolescents. Methods: A systematic literature review was conducted,
according to National Institute for Health and Care Excellence guidelines, to identify
randomized controlled trials (RCTs) of guanfacine (GXR), atomoxetine (ATX), lisdexamfetamine (LDX), and methylphenidate (MPH) extended release (ER) and immediate
release (IR) in children and adolescents with ADHD. A Bayesian mixed treatment
comparison was conducted to compare baseline-to-endpoint change in ADHDRS-IV score, response (defined as a clinician global impressions – improvement
[CGI-I] score ≤ 2), with meta-regression adjustments permitted by data availability
(age and percent female). 95% credible intervals (CrIs) for treatment effects and
the posterior probability that GXR was more efficacious than each treatment were
estimated. Results: Of 5,619 records retrieved, 29 RCTs met the inclusion criteria.
Five trials included GXR, 4 included LDX, 16 included ATX, 7 included MPH-ER, and
5 included MPH-IR. Per-arm patient sample size ranged from 29 to 222. The mean
ADHD-RS-IV score change from baseline and 95% CrI (active minus placebo) were
-8.68 (-10.63, -6.72) for GXR, -14.98 (-17.14, -12.80) for LDX, -6.88 (-8.22, -5.49) for ATX,
and -9.33 (-11.63, -7.04) for MPH-ER. The relative risk and 95% CrI for CGI-I response
(drug vs placebo) were 2.13 (1.68, 2.59) for GXR, 2.93 (2.47, 3.40) for LDX, 2.30 (1.79,
2.81) for MPH-ER, 1.97 (1.43, 2.58) for ATX, and 1.66 (1.02, 2.32) for MPH-IR. Among
non-stimulants, GXR was more effective than ATX when comparing ADHD-RS-IV
change (with a posterior probability of 93.91%) and CGI-I response (posterior probability 71.01%). Conclusions: This review found that LDX had greater efficacy
compared with GXR, ATX, and MPH in the treatment of children and adolescents
with ADHD with no overlap in CrIs. Among non-stimulants, although GXR had a
higher probability of being more efficacious than ATX, their CrIs overlapped.
PMH6
An Evaluation of the Comparative Effectiveness of Clomethiazole
Against Diazepam in the Treatment of Alcohol Withdrawal
Syndrome in Routine Clinical Practice
Kamudoni P 1, Gründer G 2, Sychla H 2, Juha B 3
University, Cardiff, UK, 2RWTH Aachen University, Aachen, Germany, 3Cheplapharm
Arzneimittel GmbH, Greifswald - Insel Riems, Germany
.
.
.
.
1Cardiff
Objectives: The objective of this study was to assess the comparative effectiveness of clomethiazole against diazepam in the treatment of alcohol withdrawal
syndrome (AWS) in the real-world. Methods: Following a retrospective design,
this study is based on case report notes of patients consecutively treated for AWS
at a University Clinic in Germany (Aachen), from 2008 to 2013. The primary outcomes were: scores of German version of the revised clinical institute withdrawal
assessment for alcohol scale (CIWA-Ar) in the first four days of therapy; duration
of therapy; duration of hospital stay and rates of complications. Patients in the two
groups (diazepam and clomethiazole) were matched for demographic factors and
severity of withdrawal using propensity scores. Results: Seventy nine patients
(Diazepam = 42; Clomethiazole = 37) were included. Mean age of patients (M =
69%, F = 30.4%) was 45±15 years. Duration of excessive alcohol use was 16 ± 12
years. On admission mean systolic and diastolic blood pressure was 139±20 and
88±13, respectively. Pulse rate was 100 ±18 per minute. CIWA-Ar scores at the end
of each of the first four days of therapy were not statistically significantly different
(ANOVA, p < 0.5) for the two therapies. Average duration of therapy was 3.81±2.9
days vs. 5.8 ±3.2 days (ANOVA - F = 8.6, p = 0.004), for clomethiazole and diazepam
groups, respectively. Duration of hospital stay was 14.92±10.1 vs. 15±13 (ANOVA –
F, p > 0.2), respectively. There was no difference in complication rates, except for
seizures (higher in Diazepam group, Chi-square test, p = 0.023). Conclusions:
Clomethiazole and Diazepam seem to offer comparable effectiveness in resolving
symptoms of AWS. Otherwise the notably shorter therapy duration and lower rates
of complications for clomethiazole hints at some advantages such as faster recovery
and lower costs of treatment, although this would have to be confirmed in future.
PMH7
Predictors Pf Remission in the Treatment of Depression in the
Middle East: Real-World Evidence From A 6-Month Prospective
Observational Study
Novick D 1, Jihyung Hong J 1, Montgomery W 2, Dueñas H 3, Elfatarany G 4, Haro J M 5
1Eli Lilly Holdings Limited, Windlesham, UK, 2Eli Lilly Australia, Sydney, Australia, 3Eli Lilly de
Mexico, Mexico City, Mexico, 4Eli Lilly & Company, Saudi, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, 5Parc Sanitari
Sant Joan de Déu, CIBERSAM, Universitat de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To understand the potential predictors of remission among patients
treated for major depressive disorder (MDD) in a naturalistic clinical setting in
the Middle East. Methods: Data for this post-hoc analysis were taken from a
6-month prospective, non-interventional, observational study that involved 1,549
MDD patients without sexual dysfunction at baseline in twelve countries worldwide (n= 314 in the Middle East). Depression severity was measured using Clinical
Global Impression of Severity (CGI-S) and 16-item Quick Inventory of Depressive
Symptomatology Self-Report (QIDS-SR16). Depression-related pain was measured
using the pain-related-items of Somatic Symptom Inventory (SSI). Remission was
defined as a QIDS-SR16 score ≤ 5. Generalised estimating equation (GEE) regression model was used to examine baseline factors associated with remission at
each follow-up visit. The model included age, sex, region, CGI-S score, QIDS-SR 16
total score, SSI pain total score, and treatment (duloxetine vs. a selective serotonin
reuptake inhibitor [SSRI] ) at baseline. Other baseline factors were also included if
they appeared to be significant at p< 0.1 in simple GEE models. The model analysed
the patient observations up to the point where their initial medications were maintained. Results: Of the 240 patients analysed, 133 (55.4%) initiated duloxetine and
107 (44.6%) initiated an SSRI at baseline. Of these, 199 patients achieved remission
at any visit during follow-up (91.0% in the duloxetine group and 72.9% in the SSRI
group, p< 0.001). The GEE results showed that higher QIDS-SR16 scores at baseline
(odds ratio [OR]= 0.88, p= 0.002) and more MDD episodes in the past 24 months
(OR= 0.77, p< 0.001) were negatively associated with remission, whereas treatment
with duloxetine (vs. SSRIs) was positively associated with remission (OR= 2.78,
p< 0.001). Conclusions: Treatment with duloxetine (vs. SSRIs), a lower level of
depression severity and fewer previous MDD episodes appeared to be strong predictors of achieving remission in the treatment of MDD in the Middle East.
PMH8
A Network Meta-Analysis of the Relative Efficacy of
Pharmacological and Psychological Interventions
in Adults with Obsessive Compulsive Disorder
Bryden P A 1, Caldwell D M 1, Welton N 1, Churchill R 1, Baxter H 1, Lewis G 2, Skapinakis P 2
1University of Bristol, Bristol, UK, 2University College London, London, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD) is the fourth most common
mental disorder in the UK with a prevalence of 1.5%. Both pharmacological and
psychological interventions are used in the treatment with the treatment course
usually chronic. This study estimates the relative efficacy of pharmacological
and psychological treatments or combinations of both. Methods: A systematic
review was conducted to identify RCTs of clomipramine, SSRIs, venlafaxine, and
psychological interventions with a behavioural, cognitive or cognitive behavioural
component. A Bayesian random effects network meta-analyses (NMA) was used to
obtain coherent estimates of relative efficacy of every pair of the different interventions, even when direct evidence was not available. The primary endpoint was
mean change in Yale-Brown obsessive compulsive scale (YBOCS). We assumed that
treatment effects for the different SSRIs were similar in the sense that they came
A455
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
from a common Normal distribution of treatment effects with an overall SSRI class
effect mean, and between treatment within class heterogeneity. Results: There
were 55 eligible studies identified in the systematic review. The intervention with
the greatest decrease in YBOCS was behavioural therapy (“exposure and response
prevention”) showing a decrease of 13.86 (CrI 9.34 to 18.31). The second and third
greatest decrease was cognitive therapy (12.80 CrI 7.39 to 18.18) and behavioural
therapy plus clomipramine (12.47 CrI 5.80 to 19.08) respectively. The SSRI class effect
showed a relative decrease in mean YBOCS of 2.89 (CrI 1.05 to 4.71) compared to
pharmacological placebo. The results of the individual SSRIs ranged from a decrease
of 2.49 (sertraline) to 3.10 (fluvoxamine). Conclusions: This analysis showed a
combination of behavioural therapy plus clomipramine has the greatest decrease
in YBOCS. There is little evidence to show a difference between SSRIs.
PMH9
Systematic Review and Mixed Treatment Comparison of Lithium
or an Atypical Anti-Psychotic (AAP) used to Augment a Selective
Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitor (SSRI) in Treatment Resistant
Depression (TRD)
Edwards S J , Wakefield V , Nherera L , Trevor N
BMJ, London, UK
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate the clinical effectiveness of augmentation of SSRI antidepressant therapy with either lithium or an AAP in TRD, defined as failure to respond
to two or more antidepressants in the current episode of depression. Methods:
Systematic review of CENTRAL, EMBASE, MEDLINE, and PsycINFO was completed
in August 2011. Additional data were obtained from manufacturers. Studies were
assessed for quality using the Cochrane Risk of Bias Tool. Pairwise meta-analysis
and mixed treatment comparison (MTC) were undertaken based on intention-totreat analyses. Results: Of the 3,721 papers found in the literature search, 12
randomised controlled trials (RCTs) were identified; 10 (SSRI + AAP vs SSRI + placebo/no treatment); 1 (SSRI + AAP vs SSRI + lithium); 1 (SSRI + lithium vs SSRI +
placebo). The RCTs included in the primary analyses used fluoxetine as the SSRI and
olanzapine as the AAP. Results of the MTC showed a non-significant trend in favour
of lithium augmentation for response [lithium odds ratio (OR) 1.29; 95% credible
interval (95% CrI): 0.11 to 5.32], mean change in Montgomery-Åsberg Depression
Rating Scale (MADRS) score from baseline (mean difference -1.47; 95% CrI: -9.10 to
6.41) and all-cause withdrawals (OR 0.74; 95% CrI: 0.10 to 2.66). Conclusions: In
patients with TRD, there is a lack of direct evidence comparing the clinical effectiveness of augmenting an SSRI with an AAP compared with augmenting with lithium.
Augmentation of SSRIs with lithium or AAP is likely to be beneficial in people with
TRD. The limited evidence indicates no statistically significant difference between
the two augmentation strategies.
PMH10
Relationship of Insight with Medication Adherence and the Impact
on Outcomes in Patients with Schizophrenia and Bipolar Disorder:
Results From A 1-Year European Outpatient Observational Study
Novick D 1, Montgomery W 2, Treuer T 3, Aguado J 4, Kraemer S 5, Haro J M 6
1Eli Lilly Holdings Limited, Windlesham, UK, 2Eli Lilly Australia, Sydney, Australia, 3Eli Lilly &
Company, Budapest, Hungary, 4Parc Sanitari Sant Joan de Deu, CIBERSAM, Sant Boi de Llobregat,
Spain, 5Eli Lilly and Company Ltd, Bad Homburg, Germany, 6Parc Sanitari Sant Joan de Déu,
CIBERSAM, Universitat de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Many patients with schizophrenia and bipolar disorder have
impaired insight and low medication adherence. The aim of this post-hoc analysis is to explore the relationship between insight and medication adherence
and their impact on the outcomes of patients with schizophrenia or bipolar
disorder. Methods: We included 903 patients with schizophrenia or bipolar disorder who participated in an observational study conducted in Europe on the outcomes of patients treated with two oral formulations of olanzapine over a 1-year
period. Evaluations included Clinical Global Impression (CGI), Global Assessment
of Functioning (GAF), insight (Scale to Assess Unawareness of Mental Disorder,
SUMD), non-adherence (Medication Adherence Rating Scale, MARS), and therapeutic
alliance (Working Alliance Inventory, WAI). Correlations between variables were
assessed by Spearman Correlation Coefficient (SCC). A path analysis was used to
understand the relationship between insight, adherence, therapeutic alliance and
outcomes. Results: 67.8% of patients had schizophrenia. GAF score was higher
in bipolar vs schizophrenia patients (mean (SD) 58.4 (15.6) vs 51.9 (15.7), p< 0.001).
Medication adherence was also higher in bipolar patients (mean MARS score (SD) 6.5
(2.8) vs 5.8 (2.7); p< 0.001). Patients with schizophrenia had lower insight (i.e. SUMD
item 1, unawareness of mental disorder, mean (SD) of 2.5 (1.3) in schizophrenia vs
1.9 (1.2) in bipolar, p < 0.001). Better insight was associated with higher adherence
(SCC, ranging from 0.39 to 0.49 for the three SUMD general items, p< 0.0001 in all
cases) Higher insight was related to a stronger therapeutic alliance (SCC ranging
from 0.38 to 0.48, p< 0.0001). The path analysis revealed a positive impact of insight
on adherence and alliance and that stronger alliance was related to lower clinical
severity (lower CGI score). Conclusions: Insight and adherence were found to
be closely related. Insight impacts on the therapeutic alliance with mental health
professionals. These factors are associated to treatment outcomes.
PMH11
Social Contacts Reduce Negative Symptoms, Especially Emotional
Withdrawal in Patients with Schizophrenia
Millier A 1, Siegrist K 2, Amri I 3, Toumi M 4, Aballéa S 1
University Düsseldorf, Düsseldorf, Germany,
3Creativ-Ceutical, Tunis, Tunisia, 4University of Marseille, Marseille, France
.
.
.
.
.
1Creativ-Ceutical, Paris, France, 2Heinrich-Heine
Objectives: In schizophrenia, negative symptoms - especially emotional withdrawal (EW) - represent an important dimension, and are associated to a significant
burden. Social contacts are likely to reduce negative symptoms and ameliorate
quality of life (QoL) over time. Our objective was to test whether this hypothesis was
verified in a large cohort of European patients with schizophrenia. Methods: We
used data from the EuroSC study, a longitudinal cohort of 1208 patients with schizophrenia followed for 2 years. Every 6 months, the collected information included
QoL-Interview, from which the Global Satisfaction Score (GLS) and the frequency
of social contacts score were derived, and the Positive And Negative Symptoms
Scale (PANSS), from which EW score was derived. After bivariate and correlation
analyses, we tested whether few social contacts at baseline would predict greater
EW and lower GLS after 2 years when adjusted on baseline level. Finally, randomeffects regression analyses were performed to test the longitudinal effect of social
contact, adjusting on potential confounding factors. Results: Bivariate and correlation analyses established a link between frequency of social contact and both
EW score (-0.24, p< 0.001) and negative factor scale (-0.30, p< 0.0001) at each time
point. Few social contacts at baseline were associated with greater EW (p= 0.013)
and worse negative factor score (p= 0.009), when compared to baseline. A trend for
prediction of better QoL was also found, although not reaching significance. Random
effects regressions confirmed the significant impact of social contacts over time on
EW (p< 0.0001), negative factor score (p< 0.0001) and QoL (p< 0.001). Conclusions:
Given consistent effects of social contacts on reduction of negative symptoms and
improvement of QoL in schizophrenic patients, social contacts should be used as a
therapeutic tool. A higher frequency of social contacts could be obtained by regular
therapeutic groups offered to these patients.
PMH12
Outpatient Treatment of Adolescents in Japan with Drugs for
Attention Deficit Disorders
Inagaki A 1, Nishimura Y 2, Otsuka H 2, Hirakawa H 2, Hatou K 2, Kubota Y 3, Watanabe Y 3,
Miki K 3, Endoh Y 4
1Aoyama Gakuin University, Tokyo, Japan, 2Japanese Association of Mental Health Services,
Tokyo, Japan, 3Japanese Association of Neuro-Psychiatric Clinics, Tokyo, Japan, 4Institute of
Neuropsychiatry, Tokyo, Japan
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To examine prescription patterns of drugs for the treatment of attention
deficit disorders in Japanese children and adolescents. Methods: We conducted a
cross-sectional survey during October 2013 on outpatients aged 19 years or less in 34
private mental clinics. Patients who were prescribed at least one drug for the treatment of attention deficit disorders were analyzed in this report. Data were extracted
on gender, age, principal psychiatric diagnosis (based on ICD-10), and types and
doses of psychotropic drugs. Results: The samples consisted of 286 males and 51
females. The average age (standard deviation) was 11.6 years (3.1). The mean length
of psychiatric treatment was 21.3 months (24.0). The most frequent principal diagnostic category was “behavioral and emotional disorders with onset usually occurring
in childhood and adolescence” (F9; n= 237), followed by “disorders of psychological
development” (F8; n= 99), and “mental retardation” (F7; n= 1). Of 337 samples, 247
(73.2%) were prescribedOROS methylphenidate (OROS-MPH), a psycho-stimulant,
while 141 (41.8%) received atomoxetine (ATMX), a selective noradrenalin reuptake
inhibitor. OROS-MPH/ATMX combination therapy was administered to 51 (15.1%) of
337 patients. Antipsychotics were concurrently prescribed in 80 (23.7%) patients. Mood
stabilizers were co-prescribed in 20 (5.9%) cases. Antidepressants were co-prescribed
in 19 (5.6%) patients. Anxiolytics/hypnotics were concurrently prescribed in 13 (3.9%)
patients. Conclusions: In Japan, nearly one-sixth of the outpatients with attention
deficit disorders received OROS-MPH/ATMX combination therapy.
PMH13
The Quality of Prescribing for Psychiatric Patients
Soerensen A L 1, Nielsen L P 2, Poulsen B K 2, Lisby M 2, Mainz J 3
University, Aalborg, Denmark, 2Aarhus University Hospital, Aarhus, Denmark, 3Aalborg
Psychiatric University Hospital, Aalborg, Denmark
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Aalborg
Objectives: Prescribing for adult psychiatric patients is often highly complex
due to the nature of psychiatric conditions, but also due to somatic comorbidity. Therefore, the aim of this study was to identify prevalence and types of
potential inappropriate prescribing (PIP), asses the severity of potential clinical
consequences and identify possible predictive factors of PIP. Methods: The study
was designed as a prospective study of PIP using medication reviews.
Patients who were admitted during a 4 month period (August 2013 - November
2013) to a psychiatric university hospital were included (n= 219). The medication reviews, including an assessment of potential severity, were carried
out by clinical pharmacologists after admission and after the attending physician had seen the patient. Frequencies and categories of PIP were analyzed in
absolute numbers and as percentages. Severity of PIP was assessed using four
categories. Logistic regression analysis was used to identify possible predictive factors of PIP. Results: The proportion of patients with one or more PIPs
was 123/219 (56%). “Interaction between drugs” was the most common category
for potentially serious and potentially fatal PIPs with 49/123 (40%) and 32/45 (71%),
respectively. Of 32 identified potentially fatal drug-drug interactions, 15/32 (47%)
involved two or more antipsychotic drugs and 12/32 (37%) involved antipsychotic
drugs in combination with antidepressants. The remaining 5/32 (16%) potentially
fatal drug-drug interactions involved propranolol, erythromycin, simvastatin
and promethazine. After adjusting for age, gender, alcohol/substance abuse,
number of prescriptions, number of somatic diagnoses and level of kidney
function, only polypharmacy (> 5 prescriptions) increased the odds for a PIP
significantly; OR= 4,82 (95%CI: 2.33-9.98), p< 0.0001. Conclusions: PIP is
frequent and might have serious or fatal consequences. Special attention should be
given to drug-drug interactions involving antipsychotics and antidepressants but
also somatic medications and polypharmacy threatens medication safety. There
is a pressing need to improve the quality in prescribing for psychiatric patients.
PMH14
The Prevalence and Disease Burden of Treatment-Resistant
Depression - a Systematic Review of the Literature
Kubitz N 1, Vossen C 2, Papadimitropoulou K 2, Karabis A 2
1Janssen-Cilag GmbH, Neuss, Germany, 2Mapi, Houten, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
A456
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
1Creativ-Ceutical, Paris, France, 2ZRx
Objectives: Major depressive disorder affects approximately 10-15% of the population and is associated with significant morbidity and mortality. It is one of the
leading causes of disability in young adults. A large proportion of the burden can be
attributed to treatment-resistant depression (TRD). To understand the prevalence
and disease burden of TRD in Western European countries, the US and Canada, a
systematic literature search was performed. Methods: OVID, the Cochrane Library
and the CRD database were used to retrieve TRD publications in English language
from January 2003-October 2013. In total, 6306 abstracts were identified. Predefined
selection criteria regarding study design, patient population (age ≥ 12 years; US,
Canada, Germany, Italy, France, Spain or UK; TRD defined as one treatment failure
and high symptom severity e. g. MADRS ≥ 31, or an inadequate response to ≥ two
antidepressants) and outcomes of interest were applied. Results: Only seven studies included prevalence and/or disease burden data. Five studies provided prevalence estimates which adhered to the strict TRD definition used for this review.
Study design and definition of the patient population were critical in determining
the prevalence rates, with the lowest rates found in US employer claims databases
(11-15%), higher rates in commercial health insurance databases (29-31%) and the
highest rates in a European multicenter study (51-56%). The database studies mainly
included employed patients thereby likely underestimating the prevalence, whereas
the European study likely overestimated the prevalence due to a less stringent TRD
definition. Inconsistent data were reported regarding treatment outcomes, comorbidities, hospitalization and work productivity. There was no information on other
outcomes such as health-related quality of life or functioning. Conclusions: No
consistent data were found in the literature from January 2003-October 2013 regarding the epidemiology and disease burden of TRD. To determine the prevalence and
disease burden for TRD, further studies are needed.
Objectives: Buprenorphine/naloxone (BUP/NAL) combination is a well known
treatment for opioid dependence. As a chronic relapsing disorder, some patients
alternate between periods of on treatment and off treatment. The aim of this
study was to compare health care resource utilization and costs between these
patients and patients treated continuously. Methods: Statistical analyses were
conducted on a Medicaid insurance claims database (TruvenHealth MarketScan®
Medicaid) from January 2007 to June 2012. Patients with at least two treatment
episodes in the first year after the initial filled prescription were identified. The
end of a treatment episode was defined as a period of 60 days with no filled BUP/
NAL prescriptions following the theoretical end of the last filled prescription. An
ordered logistic regression model was used to analyze the impact of initial treatment episode duration on the number of new episodes in the year following the
end of the first episode. Health care resource utilization and related costs during
the first year after initiation were compared between the two groups. Results:
2,223 patients were included in the analysis. During the first year, 86% of patients
had only one treatment episode, 13% had two and 1% had three. Compared to
patients who remained in treatment continuously over 12 months, the multiple
treatment episode group had lower medication costs (-$2,877) but higher psychiatric inpatient costs (+$720), non-psychiatric inpatient costs (+$2001) and emergency room costs (+430) over 12 months. Total health care costs over 12 months
were higher among multiple treatment episode patients ($16,583 vs. $15.123,
p= 0.0004). Conclusions: Despite lower medication costs, total health care costs
over 12 months were higher among patients with multiple treatment episodes
compared to patients treated continuously.
PMH15
Prevalence of Metabolic Syndrome in Patients with Schizophrenia
According to the Presence or Absence of Negative Symptoms
PMH18
Treatment Cost Comparison: Paliperidone Palmitate Versus
Risperidone Long Acting in Brazil
Sicras-Mainar A 1, Ruiz-Beato E 2, Mauriño J 2, Navarro-Artieda R 3
1Badalona Serveis Assistencials, Badalona. Barcelona, Spain, 2Roche Farma, S.A, Madrid, Spain,
3Hospital Universitari Germans Trias i Pujol, Badalona, Spain
Pititto L , Guarniero F , Antonio M
Janssen Cilag, São Paulo, Brazil
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The aim of this study was to estimate the prevalence of metabolic syndrome (MS) in patients with schizophrenia according to the presence or absence of
negative symptoms. Methods: A retrospective, cohort study was conducted using
electronic medical records from the health provider BSA (Badalona, Spain). All adult
outpatients with a diagnosis of schizophrenia were followed for 12 months. Two study
groups were defined by the presence or absence of negative symptoms based on the
PANSS Marder Negative Symptoms Factor (N1-N4, N6, G7 and G16). MS prevalence was
estimated using the NCEP ATP III criteria. Descriptive statistics and logistic regression models were applied. Results: We studied 1,120 patients (mean age: 46.8 ±
13.8 years; male: 58.4%). One or more negative symptoms were present in 52.5% of
patients (95%CI: 49.6-55.4%). Dyslipidemia (48.7%), hypertension (38.2%), and diabetes
mellitus (19.3%) were the most frequent comorbid conditions. Quetiapine, risperidone
and olanzapine were the most common antipsychotic drugs administered. Patients
with negative symptoms showed a greater mean number of comorbid conditions than
patients without this symptomatology (8.5 and 7.0, respectively; p<0.001). Prevalence
of MS was 38.6% (CI: 35.7-41.5%), higher among patients with one or more negative
symptoms (43.9% vs. 34.9%, respectively; p= 0.002). MS was associated with the presence of negative symptoms, age, and comorbidity (OR= 1.6, 1.2, and 1.2, respectively;
p<0.05). Conclusions: Further studies are necessary to elucidate the association
between the presence of negative symptoms and MS among patients with schizophrenia as well as the underlying mechanisms involved.
PMH16
The Potential Benefits of Long-Acting Atypical Antipsycothic
Therapy in Preventing Relapse in Brazil
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Deloitte Access
Objectives: To quantify the economic burden of schizophrenia relapse in
Brazil, and to estimate the impact of atypical Long Acting Injectables (LAIs) on
relapse. Methods: Administrative health service data from a Brazilian public system
database (DATASUS) were used to estimate the number of relapse patients and related
resource utilisation. Corresponding data for private system patients were estimated
based on published literature and by extrapolating DATASUS data. A prevalence-based
costing with a mixed bottom-up and top-down approach was used to quantify direct
and indirect costs, disability adjusted life years (DALYS) and their associated monetary
value. A decision-analytic model was constructed to evaluate the cost effectiveness
of potentially transferring non-compliant patients from oral antipsychotics to atypical LAIs. All costs are presented in 2013 Brazilian real. Results: In 2011-12, 88,721
patients with schizophrenia in Brazil experienced 263,037 episodes of relapse that
resulted in hospital or outpatient care. The potential avoidable health care cost of
relapse was R$722.6 million. The estimated additional health care cost per DALY
avoided was R$5,049 if non-compliant patients could be transferred to atypical LAIs
to achieve 5% overall utilisation. Reducing relapses would give Brazil potential avoidance of 1,335 DALYs, which corresponds to a saving of R$482.8 million in the stock
of health capital. Conclusions: The economic burden of schizophrenia relapse in
Brazil is significant. Brazilian policymakers should provide greater access to LAIs.
PMH17
Analysis of ‘Revolving Door’ Patients in Opioid Dependent Patients:
the Impact of Treatment Discontinuation on Relapse Rates and
Health Care Costs in us Public Health Insurance Claims
Clay E 1, Zah V 2, Kharitonova E 1, Ruby J 3, Aballéa S 1, Khemiri A 4
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To compare the treatment cost of paliperidone palmitate (PP) versus
risperidone long acting (R-LA), both indicated for the treatment of schizophrenia in
Brazil. Methods: In Brazil, both (PP and R-LA) long acting 2nd generation antipsychotics are approved for the treatment of schizophrenia. Published literature shows
no difference in safety and efficacy between them; therefore, a cost-minimization
analysis was performed. Yearly treatment costs were calculated for an average dose
of 37,5 mg per patient in the case of R-LA and 75 mg in the case of PP. The two initial
treatment doses were considered: for PP, 150 mg on the 1st day and 100 mg on the
8th day, and for R-LA 21 days oral supplementation with 3 mg of risperidone, according to dosing intervals defined in the product label. Prices were gathered from the
official price list (CMED – Apr’14). Results: PP has the lowest cost of treatment,
at R$ 12,739 per patient in the 1st year – against R-LA R$ 18,165 – and R$ 11,359 in
the 2nd year (R-LA has R$ 17,971). Treatment with PP compared to R-LA may bring
important savings to the payers (HMOs or Government), with potential to reduce
the cost of treatment by 30% in the 1st year, and 37% in the 2nd year - allowing a
higher number of patients to be treated at the same budget level. Conclusions:
Although both molecules, PP and R-LA, have demonstrated similar efficacy, PP offers
a cost reduction from the perspective of the Brazilian private health care system
compared to R-LA. In addition, PP offers advantages that can have additional value
for public and private payers alike such as a monthly injection and no need for
cold chain. PP can therefore be considered a cost-saving therapeutic option for
schizophrenia compared to R-LA.
.
.
.
Kellar J 1, Mittmann N 2, von Heymann C 3, Zingaro J 3, Kuriakose B 4, Li A 4
1Centre for Addiction and Mental Health, Toronto, ON, Canada, 2Sunnybrook Health Sciences
Centre, Toronto, ON, Canada, 3Cubic Health Inc., Toronto, ON, Canada, 4Janssen Inc, Toronto,
ON, Canada
.
Tay-Teo K 1, Pezzullo L 1, Violin B 2, Dias T 2, Sardi P 2, Delatorre R 2, Pititto L 3, Guarniero F 3
Economics, MELBOURNE, Australia, 2Monitor Deloitte, Sao Paulo, Brazil, 3Janssen
Cilag, São Paulo, Brazil
.
.
PMH19
Costs of Employees with Treatment-Resistant Depression Based on a
Canadian Private Claims Database
Mental Health – Cost Studies
.
Outcomes Research Inc., Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro,
Benckiser Pharmaceuticals, Inc. /NA, Richmond, VA, USA, 4Creativ-Ceutical, Tunis, Tunisia
3Reckitt
.
.
.
.
.
Approximately 10-20% of individuals with Major Depressive Disorder (MDD) fail to
respond to antidepressant monotherapy. These individuals with treatment resistant depression (TRD) have been found to be frequent users of health care services,
thus incurring significantly greater costs than those without TRD. Objectives:
To investigate the cost of Treatment-Resistant Depression from a private payer
perspective in Canada. Methods: An employer-sponsored benefits plan database (2011/2012) was used to define a cohort of Non-TRD and TRD claimants. TRD
claimants are defined as those on their third antidepressant monotherapy; or
combination antidepressant therapy; or antidepressant augmented with lithium,
thyroid hormone or an antipsychotic medication. The cost of prescription medication utilization, short-term disability (STD), and long-term disability (LTD) benefits
for employees was calculated (2011 and 2012 $CAN) for both Non-TRD and TRD
groups. Descriptive statistics were used to characterize the cohort of claimants
and employees, as well as resources and costs for employees. Results: There
were 55,324 and 61,028 employee claimants in 2011 and 2012, respectively. 717
(1.3%) and 798 (1.3%) were TRD claimants; 4,744 (8.6%) and 5,137 (8.4%) were NonTRD claimants in 2011 and 2012, respectively. In 2011, the medication costs for
treating depression was $774 per TRD employee claimant compared to $303 per
Non-TRD claimant. STD costs were $6,263 for TRD (n= 79) and $5,855 for Non-TRD
(n= 276). LTD costs were $13,598 for TRD (n= 80) and $12,272 for Non-TRD (n= 119).
In 2012, the medication costs for treating depression per TRD employee claimant
was $794 compared to $293 for Non-TRD claimants. STD costs were $7,832 for TRD
(n= 86) and $4,001 for Non-TRD (n= 248). LTD costs were $13,927 for TRD (n= 89)
and $12,901 for Non-TRD (n= 121). Conclusions: Claimants identified with TRD
had higher medication, STD and LTD costs than those with Non-TRD. Limitations
include lack of diagnostic information for claimants and small sample sizes for
STD and LTD subgroups.
A457
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PMH20
The Societal Costs of Schizophrenia in Switzerland
Pletscher M 1, Mattli R 1, Reich O 2, Von Wyl A 3, Wieser S 1
Institute of Health Economics, Zurich University of Applied Sciences, Winterthur,
Switzerland, 2Helsana Insurance Group, Dübendorf, Switzerland, 3School of Applied Psychology,
Zurich University of Applied Sciences, Zürich, Switzerland
.
.
.
.
.
1Winterthur
Objectives: The objectives of this study are to estimate the prevalence of schizophrenia in Switzerland and to assess its burden on patients, caregivers and society
as a whole. Methods: A hospital registry was combined with a physician survey
and health insurance claims data to capture all patients living in the northern part
of the canton of Zurich. Total costs included direct medical and non-medical costs
and lost production. All costs were calculated for the year 2012 from a societal
perspective using a prevalence-based bottom-up approach. Intangible costs were
expressed as quality adjusted life years (QALY) lost and were calculated from Swiss
life tables, standardized mortality ratios and utility weights from the literature.
Uncertainty and its sources were addressed in univariate and probabilistic sensitivity analysis. Results: The point prevalence of schizophrenia in 2012 was estimated at 0.39% of the Swiss population. The average annual costs of schizophrenia
amounted to EUR 39,408 per patient and consisted of direct medical costs of EUR
9,507 (24%), the costs of care by relatives and in residential homes of EUR 4,793
(12%) and lost production of EUR 25,108 (64%). Inpatient hospital care accounted
for EUR 6,242 per year or 66% of direct medical costs. The estimated reduction in
life expectancy of 10.46 years and the utility decrement of 22.05 percentage points
lead to intangible costs of 19.02 QALY per incident chronic case. Conclusions:
The results of this study show the high burden of schizophrenia on patients, caregivers and society as a whole. The high costs of inpatient hospital care demonstrate
the benefits of an effective prevention of relapse associated with hospitalization.
Programs for the reintegration of schizophrenic patients into the labor market have
a high potential to reduce the costs of schizophrenia considering the high burden
of lost production and the early onset of the disease.
PMH21
A Model to Estimate the Health System Burden of Prescription
Opioid Abuse in Europe
Shei A 1, Hirst M 2, Kirson N Y 1, Enloe C J 1, Birnbaum H G 1, Dunlop W 2
1Analysis Group, Inc., Boston, MA, USA, 2Mundipharma International Limited, Cambridge, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Prescription opioid (“RxO”) abuse has not been regarded as a major
problem in Europe so far, but a lack of reliable data hinders the assessment of this
problem. This study aimed to derive estimates of the prevalence and excess costs
of RxO abuse in the five largest European countries (France, Germany, Italy, Spain,
and UK; “EU5”). Methods: Data from the European Monitoring Centre for Drugs
and Drug Addiction and the UN Office on Drugs and Crime, on the prevalence of
problem opioid abuse and the share of opioid abuse patients who report using
non-heroin opioids, were used to estimate the prevalence of RxO abuse in the EU5.
The costs of RxO abuse were calculated by applying published estimates of the
excess health care costs of RxO abuse to country-specific estimates on the costs
of chronic pain. Sensitivity analyses varied assumptions surrounding the prevalence of opioid abuse patients in the general population and the estimates of the
excess costs of RxO abuse in the EU5. Results: The prevalence of RxO abuse, in
the general population, varied between the EU5 countries, ranging from 0.7 per
10,000 to 13.7 per 10,000. In the base case scenario, the total annual health system
costs of RxO abuse across all EU5 countries were estimated to be €323 million; results
of sensitivity analyses ranged from € 98 million to € 730 million. These cost estimates
included health system costs only; indirect costs were not included. Conclusions:
RxO abuse imposes a burden on EU5 health systems. Future research should examine trends in the prevalence and total economic burden of RxO abuse in Europe
over time and assess the potential benefits of abuse-deterrent formulations, which
published research suggests have been associated with a significant relative reduction in rates of diagnosed opioid abuse.
PMH22
Productivity Loss and Resource Utilization in Individuals
Providing Care for Adults with Schizophrenia in the 5eu
Gupta S 1, Isherwood G 2, Jones K 3, Van Impe K 4
1Kantar Health, Princeton, NJ, USA, 2Kantar Health, Epsom, UK, 3European Federation of
Associations of Families of People with Mental Illness, B-3000 Leuven, Belgium, 4Janssen-Cilag
GmbH, Neuss, Germany
.
.
.
.
Objectives: This study aimed to understand the impact of providing care for
adults with schizophrenia on productivity, daily activities and resource utilization
in the 5EU. Methods: Data from the 2010-2011 and 2013 5EU (France, Germany
Italy, Spain, UK) National Health and Wellness Survey, an online questionnaire
of a nationwide sample of adults (18+ years) was analyzed. Schizophrenia
caregivers (n= 398) were matched to non-caregivers (n= 158,989) and other caregivers (n= 14,341) on baseline characteristics (sociodemographics, BMI, comorbid status) via propensity scores (1: 2). Outcome measures included health care
utilization (type/number of resources used within the past 6 months) and Work
Productivity and Activity Impairment questionnaire-based scores. Chi-square
tests and ANOVAs were used to determine significant differences between
schizophrenia caregivers vs. non-caregivers and other caregivers (e. g., cancer,
Alzheimer’s). Results: The average age of schizophrenia caregivers was 45.3
(SD= 15.8 years), 59.6% were female, and 52.5% were currently employed. After
matching, schizophrenia caregivers reported greater activity impairment (38.4%
vs. 26.1%), more health care provider visits (8.0 vs. 5.7), emergency room visits
(0.9 vs. 0.2) and hospitalizations (0.8 vs. 0.1) than non-caregivers, all p< 0.001.
Amongst employed respondents, schizophrenia caregivers reported greater
absenteeism (12.4% vs. 5.6%), presenteeism (29.9% vs. 17.5%), and overall work
impairment (35.0% vs. 20.7%) than non-caregivers, all p< 0.001. Comparing schizophrenia caregivers and other caregivers, schizophrenia caregivers reported more
activity impairment (38.4% vs. 32.3%) and health care provider visits (8.0 vs.
6.6), both p< 0.05. A greater proportion of schizophrenia caregivers reported at
least one emergency room visit (26.1% vs. 20.2%) and hospitalization (20.4% vs.
14.3%) than other caregivers, both p< 0.05. No significant difference was found
on work-related impairment, probably due to the small sample of employed
respondents. Conclusions: Schizophrenia caregivers reported greater activity
impairment and more resource use than non-caregivers and caregivers of adults
with other conditions. Better family and social support systems may help reduce
the burden for schizophrenia caregivers.
PMH23
Medication Usage Pattern, Health Resource Utilization and
Economic Burden for Patients with Mdd in Beijing, China
Zhang H 1, Yue L 1, Chen Y 1, Ding H 2, Zhao K 3, Montgomery W 4
1Lilly Suzhou Pharmaceutical Company, Ltd., Shanghai, China, 2Dalian Medical University,
Dalian, China, 3Beijing Brainpower Pharma Consulting Co. Ltd., Beijing, China, 4Eli Lilly Australia,
Sydney, Australia
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To investigate medication usage patterns, health care resource
utilization and direct medical costs of patients with Major Depressive Disorder
(MDD) in Beijing, China. Methods: Data were randomly extracted from Beijing
Urban Employee Basic Medical Insurance Database. Patients who were aged ≥ 18
years, with at least 1 primary diagnosis of MDD and 12-month continuous enrollment after their first observed MDD diagnosis between 2012 and 2013 were identified. Those with a diagnosis of schizophrenia, bipolar disorder or cancer within the
study period were excluded. Descriptive statistics were used to describe patient
profiles, medication usage, health care resource utilization and costs. Results:
A total of 8484 patients were included with mean (±SD) age of 57.15 (±15.34)
years, 63.02% female and 94.47% having co-morbidities. 71.35% of patients were
treated with antidepressant medications, including 60.53% of patients with SSRIs,
followed by NaSSA (8.96%) and SNRIs (8.26%). Concomitant medications were
prescribed for 76.78% of patients. Only 0.42% of patients experienced ≥ 1 MDDrelated hospitalizations during the 1-year follow up and the average annual number of hospitalization was 1.22 (±0.64) for those hospitalized patients. The length
of stay was 33.38 (±30.6) days per hospitalization and 36.61 (±40.04) days per
patient-year. All patients had ≥ 1 MDD-related outpatient visits. The mean annual
number of outpatient visits was 3.06 (±2.99). The mean annual direct medical
cost for all MDD patients was 1694.05 (±2513.71) RMB with 48.54% for antidepressant medications, and that for hospitalized patients was 21290.97 (±16121.61)
RMB with 15.03% for antidepressant medications and 66.45% for non-drug
medical costs. Conclusions: In Beijing China, most MDD patients also had comorbid conditions and were mainly treated in the outpatient setting. SSRIs were
the most commonly used antidepressants. The economic burden of MDD was
considerable.
PMH24
Atomoxetine for the Treatment of Newly Diagnosed Adults with
Adhd - a Cost Effectiveness Analysis in Spain
Tockhorn A 1, Televantou F 1, Dilla T 2
Lilly UK, Windlesham, Surrey, UK, 2Eli Lilly Spain, Madrid, Spain
.
.
.
1Eli
Objectives: Atomoxetine is the first medication to receive marketing authorization in Spain for the treatment of newly diagnosed adults with Attention-Deficit/
Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD). The aim of this analysis was to assess if treatment with atomoxetine in adults with ADHD was cost-effective vs. placebo from
the Spanish Healthcare System perspective. Methods: A Markov state transition model was developed for a theoretical cohort of newly diagnosed adult
patients with moderate-severe ADHD. Key input data (response and discontinuation) were derived from the atomoxetine trial program. Patients enter the
model at the age of 18 and receive atomoxetine (initiated at 40mg for a week and
then titrated to 80mg or 100mg) or placebo (in the absence of another authorized
medication for the treatment of newly diagnosed adults with ADHD). Treatment
success has been defined as response to treatment, showing improvements in
both symptoms and functioning as measured by the CAARS and CGI-S scales,
respectively. Treatment, non-specific health state utilities were populated with
estimates from a vignette study in adults conducted in the UK. Drug and direct
medical costs were obtained from local databases. In accordance with other
published ADHD models, a 1-year time horizon was used. To check the model
for robustness, probabilistic and deterministic sensitivity analyses were performed. Results: Atomoxetine was found to be cost-effective with an ICER of
€ 24,248/QALY despite patients in placebo arm only accumulating cost of physician
visits. In addition, a QALY gain of 0.023 was projected, due to greater proportion
of patients responding to treatment in the atomoxetine arm. Results from a
probabilistic sensitivity analysis indicated that atomoxetine has a 57% probability of being more cost-effective than placebo at a willingness to pay threshold
of € 30,000/QALY in the Spanish setting. Conclusions: Atomoxetine is a costeffective option versus no active medical treatment for newly diagnosed adults
with ADHD in Spain.
PMH25
Aripiprazole Once-Monthly is a Cost-Effective Therapeutic Option
in the Maintenance Treatment of Schizophrenia: Results from a
Markov Model
Sapin C 1, Tempest M J 2, Gaughran F 3, Beillat M 1, Robinson P 4, Treur M 5
SAS, Issy les Moulineaux, France, 2Pharmerit Ltd, York, UK, 3South London and
Maudsley NHS Foundation Trust, London, England, 4Otsuka Pharmaceutical Europe Ltd, Wexham,
UK, 5Pharmerit International, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Lundbeck
Objectives: Schizophrenia is a heterogeneous chronic disease with enormous
economic consequences for the society. This study aimed at building a conceptual
framework to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of Aripiprazole Once-Monthly (AOM)
versus other atypical long-acting injectable (LAI) antipsychotics: Risperidone LAI
(RLAI), Paliperidone Palmitate (PP) and Olanzapine Pamoate (OP) in the mainte-
A458
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
nance treatment of schizophrenia. Methods: The schizophrenia Markov model
developed by the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) was
adapted to the context of LAI antipsychotics. Effectiveness was measured through
Quality-Adjusted Life Years (QALYs) and number of relapses. The economic analysis was conducted over a ten-year time horizon, including cost of managing
stable schizophrenia, relapse and treatment-emergent adverse events (TEAEs).
Probabilities of relapse, discontinuation due to adverse events, and due to other
reasons came from a mixed treatment comparison of pivotal clinical trials; disutilities associated to TEAEs and other non-drug-specific inputs came from various
epidemiological sources. Results: AOM was associated with higher number of
QALYs (7.26 vs 7.17, 7.18 & 7.19 for PP, RLAI and OP respectively) over a 10-year time
horizon. Assuming a theoretical parity price between AOM and PP, the base case
analysis showed that AOM was the dominant strategy as compared to RLAI, PP and
OP. Deterministic sensitivity analyses confirmed these overall Conclusions, the
main drivers of cost-effectiveness being both probability and cost of relapse. In the
probabilistic sensitivity analysis, AOM demonstrated a higher probability of being
cost-effectiveness than RLAI, PP and OP at a willingness to pay threshold of £20,000
(52%, 89% and 90%, respectively). Conclusions: Although model outcome may
vary according to local data and settings, and assuming a theoretical parity price
with PP, AOM was found to provide clinical benefits at lower total costs compared
to other atypical LAI antipsychotics, showing its value in the maintenance treatment of schizophrenia.
PMH26
Prescribing Anti-Depressants by Baseline Severity: Evidence
Synthesis, Economic Model and Value of Information Analysis
Thom H 1, Welton N 1, Lewis G 2
1University of Bristol, Bristol, UK, 2University College London, London, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: Aim to determine the most cost-effective threshold of depression
severity above which to prescribe anti-depressants to patients, in England and
Wales, presenting with depression and under consideration for anti-depressants.
Also aim to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of a new trial of anti-depressants
in a population of wider range of depression severity than in previous trials. Methods: Meta-regression of existing study results to estimate a proportional treatment effect on depression severity, which is then extrapolated to a
wider range of severity than in included trials. An economic model which consists of a continuous outcome for the initial 12 weeks of treatment, followed by
a Markov model with states for depression category and treatment. Treatment
effects on Hamilton Depression Rating Scale (HAMD) were mapped to EQ5D.
Expected value of partial perfect information (EVPPI) was used to determine an
upper bound on the value of collecting ffurther evidence. Results: Patients on
anti-depressants had an additional 12% (CrI 3-21%) decrease in 6-week HAMD
versus placebo. Treating patients with a severity > 2 on HAMD had the highest
probability (> 65%) of being cost-effective at £20,000 willingness-to-pay threshold. However this assumes that the relationship with severity can be extrapolated beyond the range of HAMD included in the systematic review. A short-term
trial investigating the relation between treatment effect and severity and quality of life in depression patients had EVPPI= £67.7 million over a 10 year timehorizon. Conclusions: On the basis of available evidence, our model suggests
it may be cost-effective to treat patients with lower severity of symptoms than
have been included in the majority of existing RCTs. However, evidence of treatment efficacy in those with low HAMD is lacking, and there is likely to be value in
conducting a trial on this lower severity population.
PMH27
Economic Evaluation of Nalmefene for the Treatment of Alcohol
Dependence in Greece
Relakis J 1, Paparrigopoulos T 2, Kourlaba G 3, Maniadakis N 1
1National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece, 2Athens University Medical School, Athens,
Greece, 3Collaborative Center for Clinical Epidemiology and Outcomes Research (CLEO), Athens,
Greece
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess, from the perspective of national health insurance, the
cost-effectiveness of psychosocial support plus nalmefene versus psychosocial
support alone, for the treatment of adult patients with alcohol dependence who
have a high drinking risk level, without physical withdrawal symptoms, and who
do not require immediate detoxification. Methods: A cost-effectiveness Markov
model, originally developed for the Single Technology Appraisal by the National
Institute for Health and Care Excellence of Nalmefene, was adapted to the Greek
health care setting to evaluate the health effects and associated costs of compared
therapeutic options. The model consisted of a short-term phase (1 year: based on
clinical trials assessing nalmefene) and a long-term phase (2-5 years) evaluating patient progression and a second-line abstinence treatment option. Clinical
inputs were derived from ESENSE1 (NCT00811720), ESENSE2 (NCT00812461) and
SENSE (NCT00811941) clinical trials and epidemiological data from the national
statistical authority and published literature. All direct costs with respect to treatment of alcohol dependence and the management of alcohol-attributable harmful
events were considered reflecting the year 2014. Results: Over a 5-year horizon, the addition of nalmefene to psychosocial support led to the avoidance of
3,071 alcohol-attributable diseases/injuries and 851 deaths per 100,000 patients.
Nalmefene plus psychosocial support reduced the proportion of high-risk and
very high-risk drinkers (23% versus 37% with psychosocial support alone) and
increased the number of controlled drinkers (61% versus 45%). In the base-case,
the nalmefene plus psychosocial support arm cumulated a 5-year incremental
cost of € 160 and an incremental QALY of 0.024. The incremental cost-effectiveness
ratio of € 1,928 was considerably low with respect to the decision threshold of
€ 16,000 per QALY gained (equal to the GDP per capita of Greece). Conclusions:
Treatment with nalmefene is cost-effective in the Greek health care setting leading
to significant reductions of alcohol dependent patients and alcohol-attributable
harmful events.
PMH28
The Effect of Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder on
Functioning and Resource Utilization by Psychiatric Outpatients
in Europe
Televantou F 1, Sobanski E 2, Kan C C 3, Lebrec J 4, Kraemer S 5, Dieteren N A H M 6, Deberdt W 7
1Eli Lilly UK, Windlesham, Surrey, UK, 2Central Institute for Mental Health, Mannheim, Germany,
3Radboud University Nijmegen Medical Centre, Nijmegen, The Netherlands, 4Eli Lilly and
Company, Bad Homburg, Germany, 5Eli Lilly and Company Ltd, Bad Homburg, Germany, 6Lilly
Nederland BV, Houten, The Netherlands, 7S.A. Eli Lilly Benelux N.V., Brussels, Belgium
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) can have a significant
negative impact on health outcomes in adults. This study was designed, in part, to
determine the functional outcomes and health care utilization of adult psychiatric outpatients with ADHD in several European countries. Methods: This was a
multinational observational study. All eligible outpatients (excluding patients with
any psychotic disorder) from a variety of outpatient settings were invited to participate. ADHD diagnosis was established with the Diagnostic Interview for ADHD in
Adults (DIVA) based on the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders,
5thEdition. All patients were further evaluated with the Sheehan Disability Scale
(SDS) and the EuroQol-5 Dimensions (EQ-5D) questionnaire, which was also used
to assess anxiety/depression. Results: Of 5662 patients approached, 2284 (40.3%)
enrolled, of whom 1986 patients (87.0%) completed the study. Patients were 17 to
72 (median= 42) years of age, and the majority were women (58.8%). Based on the
DIVA, 17.4% (95% CI 15.7%-19.0%) of patients were diagnosed with ADHD. Patients
with ADHD had moderate to severe overall impairment (mean SDS total score 18.9
[SD= 6.6, n= 348] versus 11.6 [SD= 8.6, n= 1659] in patients without ADHD). On the
EQ-5D, a majority of patients with ADHD indicated having problems performing
their usual activities (66.2% versus 41.2%) and many reported being “extremely
anxious or depressed” (24.6% versus 16.0%). However, compared to patients without
ADHD (n= 1660), patients with ADHD (n= 349) were less often prescribed antidepressants (57% versus 71.9%). The proportions of patients who visited a primary
care physician, psychiatrist, or psychotherapist during the previous 6 months were
similar between the 2 groups. Conclusions: Adult psychiatric outpatients with
ADHD in our sample reported more overall functional impairment and psychiatric
comorbidities compared to outpatients without ADHD. The use of medical resources
was similar between the 2 groups.
PMH29
Paliperidone Versus Atypical Long-Acting Antipsychotics for
Relapsed Chronic Schizophrenia: an Economic Analysis
Einarson T R 1, Letchumanan M 2, Pudas H 3, Van Impe K 4
of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada, 2PIVINA Consulting Inc., Mississauga, ON, Canada,
3Janssen, Espoo, Finland, 4Janssen-Cilag GmbH, Neuss, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: To determine the cost-effectiveness of atypical long-acting injectable
(LAI) antipsychotics in treating relapsed chronic schizophrenia from the viewpoint
of the Finnish National Health Service. Methods: A 1-year decision tree was
adapted for use with patients in relapse, guided by an expert panel. Drugs included
available atypical long-acting antipsychotics: paliperidone (PP-LAI), risperidone
(RIS-LAI), olanzapine (OLZ-LAI) and aripiprazole (ARI-LAI). Rates of adherence,
success, relapse and hospitalization were taken from the literature. Prices were
obtained from standard lists and expressed in 2014 euros: drugs, psychiatrists/
physicians, psychiatric nurse, inpatient and outpatient hospital care. Outcomes
included expected cost/patient treated, QALYs, rates of re-hospitalization, emergency room (ER) visits and days in relapse. The primary analysis was the incremental cost per QALY. These preliminary results were tested with 1-way sensitivity
analyses on important inputs. Results: Over the 1-year time horizon, PP-LAI
had the lowest total cost of 34,446€ per patient, RIS-LAI cost 37,338€ , ARI-LAI cost
37,433€ and OLZ-LAI cost 41,384€ . PP-LAI had the highest number of QALYs (0.686),
followed by OLZ-LAI with 0.680, RIS-LAI with 0.674 and ARI-LAI with 0.671. PP-LAI
also had the lowest rates of all negative outcomes. Re-hospitalization rates were
10.1%, 12.5%, 12.4% and 12.2% for PP-LAI, RIS-LAI, ARI-LAI and OLZ-LAI, respectively, Respective ER visits were 20.6%, 23.2%, 25.4% and 21.7%. Patients receiving
PP-LAI experienced 224.0 relapse days, as opposed to 234.8 with RIS-LAI, 237.5
with ARI-LAI and 234.8 with OLZ-LAI. In 1-way sensitivity analyses, costs were
robust (required changes > 20%) against changes in drug price, primary rate of
success, rates of relapse, dropouts and adherence. The driver of the model for
all drugs was hospitalization, comprising from 70%-81% of the total cost; drug
costs constituted 12%-22% and medical care 8%-15%. Conclusions: PP-LAI was
shown to have the lowest cost and best clinical outcomes, and hence should be
the atypical LAI of choice.
PMH30
The Cost Effectiveness of Group Art Therapy for Patients with NonPsychotic Mental Health Disorders in England And Wales
Stevenson M , Rawdin A , Uttley L , Sutton A
University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Art therapy provides an alternative to standard forms of psychological
therapy. We estimated the cost-effectiveness of group art therapy for people with
non-psychotic mental disorders. Methods: A de novo area under the curve model
was constructed with the following assumptions that: the maximum treatment
effect would be associated with the time at which treatment ended; there would
be a linear increase in treatment effect, from zero at baseline to the time at which
treatment ended; there would be a residual effect of treatment with a linear decline
in benefit until there was zero benefit at 52 weeks; given the short assumed duration
of benefit, discounting was not necessary. Two RCTs identified in an accompanying
clinical review provided data from which EQ-5D values could be estimated via mapping allowing comparisons to be made of group art therapy with wait-list control
and with group verbal therapy. Scenario analyses altering the cost per patient and
the assumed residual benefit were conducted. Results: Art therapy compared
with wait-list control had a mean cost per quality adjusted life year (QALY) below
A459
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
£6000 for all scenarios and a 100% probability of being cost-effective at a willingness
to pay of £20,000 per QALY. Verbal therapy appeared more cost-effective than art
therapy with a cost per QALY below £1000 but there was considerable uncertainty
in the decision and a sizeable probability (20%) that art therapy was dominant.
In neither comparison was the art therapy intervention similar to that employed
in England and Wales, furthermore in the wait list comparison patients were not
explicitly diagnosed with non-psychotic mental disorders. As such, the generalisability of the results to practice in England and Wales is uncertain. Conclusions:
Art therapy appears cost effective versus wait-list but of uncertain value compared
with verbal therapy. Confirmatory studies are required to allow more definitive
statements to be made.
PMH31
Cost-Effectiveness of Lithium Versus an Atypical Anti-Psychotic
(AAP) used to Augment Treatment with a Selective Serotonin
Reuptake Inhibitor (SSRI) in Treatment Resistant Depression (TRD)
Edwards S J , Nherera L , Trevor N , Wakefield V
BMJ, London, UK
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate the cost-effectiveness of augmentation of SSRI antidepressant therapy with either lithium or an AAP in TRD, defined as failure to respond to
two or more antidepressants. Methods: CENTRAL, EMBASE, MEDLINE, PsycINFO
and NHS Economic Evaluation Database (NHS EED) were searched from inception
to August 2011. Additional data were obtained from manufacturers. Systematic
reviews of the economic and quality of life (QoL) literature were executed. Studies
were assessed, independently by two reviewers, for quality against predefined criteria. A de novo probabilistic economic model was developed to synthesise the
available data on costs and clinical effectiveness from UK NHS perspective; time
horizon 1-year (8 weeks of acute treatment and 10 months of maintenance treatment). Results: Four economic evaluations (none directly addressing the review
question) and 17 QoL studies were identified and summarised in narrative reviews.
Model results indicate that augmentation of an SSRI with lithium dominates augmentation with AAP (i.e. Results in cost savings of £905 per person per year and
generates more health benefits, estimated to be 0.03 quality-adjusted life-years).
However, sensitivity analyses showed that the model was highly sensitive to
changes in acute treatment efficacy (response and remission) or discontinuation.
The model was not sensitive to changes in other parameters. Conclusions: Costeffectiveness analyses suggest that augmentation with lithium is less expensive
and more effective than augmentation with AAP. However, the uncertainty in the
clinical estimates of discontinuation and treatment response is reflected in the
model results. An RCT comparing the two augmentation strategies, reporting relevant outcomes, including QoL, is needed.
PMH32
Computerised Cognitive Behaviour Therapy for Depression
Management: A Cost-Effectiveness Analysis
Duarte A 1, Walker S 2, Littlewood L 1, Gilbody S 1, Palmer S 1
1University of York, York, UK, 2University of York, Heslington, York, UK
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Computerised cognitive behaviour therapy (cCBT) forms a core component of stepped psychological care within primary care in the UK and other
countries. However, the existing clinical effectiveness evidence for cCBT comes
from developer-led trials and independent research is needed which evaluates the
clinical and cost-effectiveness of cCBT. Methods: A cost-effectiveness analysis
was undertaken comparing two cCBT software packages, free-to-use MoodGYM
and a commercial pay-to-use Beating the Blues (BtB), in addition to usual
general practitioner care (UGPC), with UGPC alone, for the treatment of depressed
adults. The analysis was based on data collected on the Randomised Evaluation of
the Effectiveness and Acceptability of Computerised Therapy (REEACT). REEACT
was a large (n= 691), pragmatic multicentre study, independently conducted in
a primary care setting. Outcomes were assessed using EQ-5D and used to estimate quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs). Resource use and costs were estimated from a NHS and Personal Social Services perspective. Scenario analyses
were performed to determine the impact on cost-effectiveness of alternative assumptions, and uncertainty was characterised using cost-effectiveness
acceptability curves. Results: BtB was both more expensive and generated lower
QALYs than UGPC alone (dominated) and MoodGYM yielded lower QALYs but at
lower cost, resulting in an ICER of £6,933 per additional QALY for UGPC alone
versus MoodGYM. UGPC alone was the most cost-effective intervention in the
majority of scenario analyses, and the intervention most likely to be cost-effective at a £20,000 per QALY threshold (probabilities ranging across scenarios from
0.545 to 0.619). Conclusions: Our findings indicate that commercially-produced
products were no more effective than free-to-use cCBT programmes. Importantly,
neither BtB or MoodGYM appeared cost-effective compared to UGPC alone. Practice
recommendations such as those offered by NICE and other countries supporting
the use of cCBT within stepped models of care for depression will need to be
reconsidered in light of these results.
PMH33
Cost-Utility Analysis of Long-Acting Paliperidone in Comparison
with Oral Risperidone, Oral Paliperidone and Long-Acting
Risperidone in the Maintenance Treatment of Schizophrenia in the
Czech Republic
Kolek M 1, Duba J 1, Vesela S 2, Pasztor B 1, Doleckova J 1
1OAKS Consulting s.r.o., Prague 9, Czech Republic, 2Janssen-Cilag s.r.o., Prague 5, Czech Republic
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The number of patients with schizofrenia in the Czech Republic
amounts annually to approximately 126,000. Schizophrenia causes significant increases in mortality, shortening life expectancy by 25 years compared to
the general population which implies high disease burden. The aim was to estimate the cost-effectiveness of long-acting paliperidone in the treatment with
schizofrenia compared to oral risperidone, oral paliperidone and long-acting ris-
peridone. Methods: Cost-utility analysis was performed using a Markov model.
The primary outcome was ICER/QALY. Oral risperidone, oral paliperidone and
long-acting risperidone were selected as comparators. The basic components of
the model include probabilities of relapse, individual hazard ratios for non-compliance by medication type and switch of treatment probabilities. Specific utilities for each health state were considered. Among relevant costs, reflecting payer’s
perspective, drug acquisition costs, monitoring costs, costs of relapses, follow-up
care and adverse events were considered. Results: Long-acting paliperidone
reached ICER of EUR 16,233/QALY compared to oral risperidone, EUR 15,058/QALY
to oral paliperidone and EUR 335/QALY to long-acting risperidone. The robustness
of the model was supported by one-way deterministic analysis and probabilistic
sensitivity analysis, which gave stable results. Long-acting paliperidone was cost
effective in 97% of the simulations compared to oral risperidone. Long-acting paliperidone treatment gained incremental 0.903 QALYs on average compared to oral
risperidone. Conclusions: The treatment of schizophrenia using long-acting
paliperidone is associated with increased QALYs. It reduces incidence of adverse
events, results in better prevention of relapses and can be considered a cost-effective
treatment in the Czech Republic.
PMH34
Cost-Utility of Vortioxetine in the Treatment of Major Depressive
Disorder: Comparison with Agomelatine, Bupropion, Sertraline and
Venlafaxine in the Finnish Setting
Soini E J 1, Hallinen T 1, Brignone M 2, Despiégel N 3, Aalto-Setälä M 4, Danchenko N 2,
Kolasa K 4
1ESiOR Oy, Kuopio, Finland, 2Lundbeck SAS, Issy-les-Moulineaux, France, 3Optum, Nanterre,
France, 4Oy H. Lundbeck Ab, Turku, Finland
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Switching to vortioxetine (a new antidepressant) after inadequate
response to selective serotonin re-uptake inhibitor/serotonin–norepinephrine
reuptake inhibitor (SSRI/SNRI) resulted in a significant and clinically relevant
improvement versus agomelatine (REVIVE head-to-head clinical study) and also
better efficacy over sertraline, venlafaxine and bupropion (indirect comparison).
The aim of this study is to assess the Finnish cost-utility of vortioxetine versus
these antidepressants in patients who switch due to inadequate response to
previous treatments. Methods: A one year cost-utility analysis was performed
using a decision tree model for the second line and a Markov model for subsequent lines of MDD treatment. Undiscounted payer and societal perspectives were
considered. Three health-states (depression, remission, recovery) and two treatment phases (2-month acute, 6-month maintenance) were defined. The relative
efficacy of antidepressants was derived from the REVIVE trial and indirect comparisons at 2 months. Efficacy in subsequent treatment steps was derived from the
STAR*D study. Adverse events and their consequences were included and derived
from REVIVE, indirect comparisons, literature and expert opinion. Utilities were
derived from REVIVE and the literature using Finnish preference weights. Finnish
costs in 2013/2014 value were considered. Sensitivity analyses were conducted to
assess the robustness of the findings. Results: Vortioxetine was dominant from
the payer’s and societal perspective versus all comparators. It was projected to
result to QALY gain of 0.013, 0.017, 0.025 and 0.028, and € 223 (€1074), €128 (€957), €110
(€ 720) and € 238 (€ 1390) direct (total) annual cost saving compared to agomelatine,
bupropion, venlafaxine and sertraline respectively. These results were confirmed to
be robust in several sensitivity analyses. Conclusions: Vortioxetine dominated
agomelatine, bupropion, venlafaxine and sertraline in Finland and appears to be a
relevant treatment option for MDD patients who need a therapy switch.
PMH35
Cost-Effectiveness of Paliperidone Palmitate Versus other
Antipsychotics for the Treatment of Schizophrenia in France
Doutriaux A 1, Cognet M 2, Druais S 2, Lançon C 3, Samalin L 4, Levy P 5, Godet A 6, Guillon P 7
1Amaris Consulting, London, UK, 2Amaris, London, UK, 3Hopital Sainte-Marguerite CHU,
Marseille, France, 4CHU Clermont-Ferrand, Clermont-Ferrand, France, 5University of Dauphine Paris, Paris, France, 6Janssen Cilag, Issy-les-Moulineaux, France, 7Janssen, Issy-les-Moulineaux,
France
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate the cost-effectiveness of paliperidone palmitate (PLAI),
a once-monthly long-acting injectable (LAI) atypical antipsychotic, compared
to the most common antipsychotic strategies in France. Methods: A Markov
model was developed to simulate the progression of a cohort of schizophrenic
patients through four health states (stable treated, stable non-treated, relapse
and death) and up to three lines of treatment. PLAI was compared to risperidone
LAI (RLAI), aripiprazole LAI (ALAI), olanzapine LAI (OLAI), haloperidol decanoate
(HLAI) and oral olanzapine (OO). Costs, quality-adjusted-life-years (QALYS) and
number of relapses were assessed over five years based on three-month cycles,
and discounted at 4%, from a health insurance perspective. Patients were supposed to be stabilised after a clinical decompensation and entered the model into
an initiation phase, followed by a relapse prevention phase in case of success.
In the prevention phase, relapse rates were derived from hospitalisation risks
based on French real-life data in order to capture the adherence effects. Safety
and utility data were derived from international publications. Costs came from
French health insurance databases and publications. Robustness of results was
assessed through deterministic and probabilistic sensitivity analyses. Results:
PLAI was the less costly LAI and associated with an incremental cost-effectiveness
ratio (ICER) of € 1,988/QALY gained and € 2,267/relapse avoided versus OO. RLAI
and PLAI were associated with the highest number of QALYs (ICER of € 2,421,386/
QALY gained between PLAI and RLAI). PLAI dominated all other LAIs in terms of
relapse but OLAI. Nevertheless, PLAI was highly cost-effective versus OLAI (ICER of
€ 1,575,217/relapse avoided). Conclusions: This analysis is the first to assess the
cost-effectiveness of antipsychotics based on French observational data. PLAI was
found to be the least expensive LAI antipsychotic from French payer perspective.
Oral therapies were less expensive but associated with lower levels of QALYs and
more relapses compared to all atypical LAIs.
A460
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PMH36
Economic Evaluation of Agomelatine for Major Depressive
Disorders Relative to other Antidepressants in the Italian
Setting
in terms of longer length of stay, more readmissions and higher consumption of
drugs. The average quality of the studies was moderate. Further research is needed
to establish the degree of burden of agitation and containment borne by hospitals
and the health care system.
Lanati E P , Lidonnici D
MA Provider, Milano, Italy
.
.
.
Objectives: The purpose of the present study is to conduct an economic evaluation
of Agomelatine vs the current alternatives in daily clinical practice for treating patients
with major depression disorders (MDD) in Italy (Venlafaxine, Fluoxetine, Sertraline,
Escitalopram and Duloxetine). Methods: Using a Markov model-based cost-effectiveness analysis, Agomelatine was compared with other therapies used for the treatment of MDD commonly prescribed (Venlafaxine, Fluoxetine, Sertraline, Escitalopram
and Duloxetine), chosen on the basis of market shares, and compared with placebo.
The population considered in the model consists of patients suffering from MDD
and with an average age of 45 years. The perspective of the third party payer (Italian
National Healthcare Service) and the societal perspective were considered. Results:
The study shows that Agomelatine administration is linked with higher direct and
indirect costs only when compared with Duloxetine (respectively € 4,365 vs. €4,253
and €5,553 vs. €5,484). Nevertheless, Agomelatine has the higher efficacy in terms
of QALY gained (1.477) in comparison to all comparators considered in the analysis.
According to the societal perspective, Agomelatine is dominant against Venlafaxine,
Escitalopram, Fluoxetine and Sertraline, since it is less expensive and more effective
and cost-effective compared to Duloxetine since the incremental cost per QALY gained
is €12,461. According to the perspective of the Italian NHS, Agomelatine is dominant
versus Venlafaxine, Fluoxetine and Sertraline and is cost-effective in comparison to
Duloxetine (ICER 6,101 € /QALY) and Escitalopram (3,336 € /QALY). Conclusions:
The present economic evaluation indicates that Agomelatine provides greater benefit and is less costly compared to generic Venlafaxine, generic Escitalopram, generic
Fluoxetine and generic Sertraline and that Agomelatine is cost-effective compared to
Duloxetine. In conclusion, according to its favorable tolerability profile and its proven
efficacy, Agomelatine represents a powerful tool for many patients suffering from
MDD, which may lead to both clinical and economic advantages.
PMH37
Retrospective Database Study on Health Care Resource Utilization
of Patients Initiating Long-Acting Olanzapine in Sweden
Tockhorn A 1, Johansson S 2, Borgeke H 3
1Eli Lilly UK, Windlesham, Surrey, UK, 2IMS Health Sweden, 113 46 Stockholm, Sweden, 3Eli Lilly
and Company, Stockholm, Sweden
.
.
.
Objectives: The Swedish national payer, TLV, was interested in understanding how
OLAI is used in routine clinical practice regarding dosing and its impact on psychiatric-related hospitalization. Methods: Three Swedish nationwide health registers:
the patient register, the drug register and the mortality register were linked. Patients
with ≥1 prescription of OLAI and one diagnosis of schizophrenia or schizoaffective
disorder prior to initiation of OLAI were included in this retrospective patient mirrorimage study. The minimum follow-up was six months. The study period was from
03/2010 until 12/2011. The average number and duration of hospitalizations were
compared before and after initiation with OLAI using a Student’s t-test. Results:
70 patients met the inclusion criteria. The proportion of patients being hospitalized
≥1 was 77% in the pre-index period and 67% in the post-index period. The number of
outpatient visits increased from 45% prior to OLAI to 77% post initiation. The results
showed a significant reduction in the mean length of stay per hospitalization (19.6
days vs 3.9 days [p<0.001] ), and in the mean total number of days spent in hospital
per patient (52.3 days vs. 16.2 days [p< 0.001] ). No significant difference was seen in
the number of hospital visits between the pre- and post-initiation periods, although
there was a numerical decrease observed within the post-index period. The average
dose of OLAI was 18.1 mg per day (95% CI: 16.6 mg; 19.7 mg) and the prescription
refill period was 19.6 days (95% CI: 17.7 days; 21.5 days). Conclusions: This study
provides evidence that initiation with OLAI significantly reduces the length of stay
per hospitalization and the total days spent in hospital.
PMH38
Use of Services and Cost of Agitation and Containment in
Psychiatric Hospitals: a Systematic Review
Rubio-Valera M 1, Luciano-Devís J V 1, Ortiz J M 1, Salvador-Carulla L 2, Haro J M 1, Gracia A 3,
Serrano-Blanco A 1
1Parc Sanitari Sant Joan de Déu, Sant Boi de Llobregat, Spain, 2Centre for Disability Research and
Policy, Lidcombe, Australia, 3Ferrer Internacional, Barcelona, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The aim of this study was to evaluate the use of services and costs
related to agitation and containment of adult patients admitted to a psychiatric
hospital. Methods: Systematic review through searches of Pubmed, CINHAL and
Web of Knowledge (using a wide variety of terms related to agitation; inpatient care
and use of services/costs); bibliographic references in retrieved studies and expert
consultation. Studies published since 1998 were selected in duplicate by reviewing abstracts and full-text papers. Results: After removing duplicates, 372 papers
were reviewed and 11 included in the review. Four studies were of high quality, 4
of moderate-high to moderate-low quality and three of low quality. Eight of the
studies evaluated the impact of agitation on the length of stay and 6 showed that
it was associated with longer stays. Four studies evaluated the impact of agitation
on readmission and showed a statistically significant increase in the probability of
readmission of agitated patients in comparison with non-agitated patients. Two
studies evaluated medication, one showed that the mean medication dose was
higher in agitated patients and the other found higher costs of treatment compared with non-agitated patients in the unadjusted analysis. Another estimated
the costs of conflict and containment related to acute inpatient psychiatric care
in UK. The total annual cost in England for all conflict was £72.55 million (£145,177
annual conflict cost per ward) and £106 million for containment (£212,316 annual
containment cost per ward). Conclusions: Studies on use of services and costs
of agitation are scarce. Overall, agitation has an effect on health care use and costs
Mental Health – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference Studies
PMH39
Which Adverse Effects Influence the Dropout Rate in Selective
Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitor (Ssri) Treatment?
Kostev K 1, Ehlken B 2, Rex J 1, Engelhard J 1, Altmann V 1, Heilmaier C 3
1IMS Health, Frankfurt am Main, Germany, 2IMS Health Germany, Munich, Germany, 3FOM
University of Applied Sciences, Essen, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Nowadays selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) are the most
frequently prescribed antidepressants due to their better clinical efficacy, effectiveness, tolerability, and safety, when compared to tricyclic antidepressants or
monoamino oxidase inhibitors. However, despite this, especially at the beginning
of treatment SSRIs are associated with side effects, which may lead to premature
discontinuation of therapy in some cases. Assessment of these factors was the aim
of the present study. Methods: This retrospective database analysis used data
from 50,824 patients first time treated with SSRIs for major depressive disorder
selected from a Electronic Medical Records (EMR) database (IMS Disease Analyzer)
in Germany, providing information on SSRI side effects and their influence on premature treatment discontinuation calculated by regression analysis. In addition to
that, presence of certain co-morbidities was registered. Results: Mean age was
54.5 ± 19 years with two-thirds of study population being female. Most frequently
mentioned adverse effects were “discomfort” of the digestive system (10%), sleep
disorders (8.6%), and heart rhythm disorders (4%); however, these were of tolerable
severity as they did not significantly influence dropout rate. Contrary to that, especially somnolence and younger age (≤ 50 years) increased the chance of premature
treatment discontinuation, while patients suffering from cardiovascular risk factors
or osteoporosis tended to adhere to therapy. Conclusions: Overall, the findings
indicate a good tolerability of SSRIs at the beginning of treatment, whereas occurrence of somnolence leads to incompliance.
PMH40
General Beliefs about Medicines Among Depressed Patients in Saudi
Arabia
Aljumah K 1, Hassali A A 2, Al Mutari A 1, Al Zaide N 1
Sains Malaysia, Penang, Malaysia
.
.
.
.
.
1MOH, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, 2Universiti
Objectives: The aim of this study to explore patients’ general and specific beliefs
about medicines among depressed patients and effect on adherence Methods:
a cross-sectional design used to measure patients’ general and specific beliefs
among depressed patients, using BMQ general and specific scale. Patients were
recruit from outpatient clinic at AL-Amal hospital in Riyadh (psychiatric hospital)
between 2013 and January 2014. Results: A total of 403 patients meet the inclusion criteria and were participated in this study. Two hundred three representing
50.37 % of the total study sample, were female, while the remaining 200 (49.6 %)
were male, with average 39 years. Half of the patients (52.9%) report low adherence
to antidepressant medication. Both low and high adherence group scored high in
the necessity beliefs (18.02 (SD 3.91) -18.32 (SD 3.9) respectively with no statistically
different. contrariwise patients with high adherence had significantly lower level of
concerns belief about antidepressants medication and less harmful belief also the
same finding with general overuse belief. Conclusions: General patients beliefs
either general overuse or general harm about medication influence patients taking
medication behavior and have negative correlation with adherence to medication
on another hand only specific concerns belief to antidepressant have a positive
correlation with adherence to antidepressant this finding will help psychiatric to
improve adherence and clinical outcome by addressing medications taking behavior
using a systematic approach based in this finding.
PMH41
Adherence to Psychotropic Medications by Outpatients in
Psychiatric Hospital, Uselu Benin City, Nigeria
Arute J E 1, Eniojukan J F 2, Eboigbe N P3
1Delta State University, Abraka, Nigeria, 2Niger Delta University, Wilberforce Island, Nigeria,
3Delta State University, Abraka, Nigeria, Abraka, Nigeria
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Patients adherence studies are essential for evaluating the quality of
care delivery of a health facility and patients’ role in improving their conditions.
The objective of this study is to determine the level of adherence of outpatients to
psychotropic drugs and evaluate the impacting factors. Methods: The study was
a cross-sectional study done at the psychiatric hospital, Uselu, Benin city, Nigeria
from April to September, 2013. Convenient sampling method was used in population size determination for data collection. The participants were adult patients (18
years and above) attending the outpatients psychiatric clinic of the hospital with
diagnosis of various psychiatric illnesses. A total of 250 patients participated in the
study and a well-structured self-report 10-item questionnaire using the medication adherence rating scale (MARS) was used. Additional information was patients’
socio-demographic profile and clinical variables that affect patients’ adherence to
medications. Adherence to medication data were analyzed with respect to gender
and level of adherence and factors that impact patients’ adherence. Results: The
level of patients’ adherence to psychotropic was 63.6% and factors found to significantly affect adherence include amount spent per clinic visit, perception of social
support, intake of alcohol, medication side effects, and existing denial of illness and
use of traditional medicine. Conclusions: The level of adherence to psychotropic
medications was fairly high and factors that were significantly related to adherent
status were amount spent per clinic visit, perception of social support, intake of
alcohol, medication side effects, existing denial of illness and use of traditional
A461
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
medicine. The study provides a baseline data for further studies on patients’ adherence to psychotropic medications.
PMH42
Treatment Continuation and Treatment Characteristics of 3
Long Acting Antipsychotic Medications (Paliperidone Palmitate,
Risperidone Microspheres and Haloperidol Decanoate) in Belgium
Sermon J 1, Geerts P 1, Decuypere F 2, Weglewski T 2, Rijntjes R 3, De Hert M 4
NV, Beerse, Belgium, 2IMS Health, Vilvoorde, Belgium, 3Janssen-Cilag BV, Tilburg,
The Netherlands, 4Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Kortenberg, Belgium
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Janssen-Cilag
Objectives: Treatment continuation of 3 long acting, injectable, antipsychotic
drugs: paliperidone palmitate, risperidone microspheres and haloperidol decanoate,
was evaluated in the Belgian outpatient setting using panel data from public pharmacies. Drug dosage, age distribution and frequency of co-prescribed antipsychotic
medications were investigated. Methods: IMS LifelinkTM Treatment Dynamics
database was used, applying appropriate selection criteria. Three patient cohorts
that started paliperidone palmitate, risperidone microspheres or haloperidol
decanoate treatment respectively, between 1 December 2011 and 31 August 2012,
were analyzed. All cohorts included at least 13 months of follow up. Treatment
continuation was investigated. Results: After 90 and 180 days, more patients
continued treatment with paliperidone palmitate (60,71% and 42,41% respectively)
than with risperidone microspheres (39, 07% and 26, 49%) or haloperidol decanoate
(34,23% and 17,57%). Within 3 months after discontinuation, more patients restarted
their treatment when using paliperidone palmitate (41%) compared to risperidone
microspheres (27%) or haloperidol decanoate (17%). For all therapies, dosing was
comparable between treatment initiation and discontinuation. Patients treated
with paliperidone palmitate were generally younger (patients ≤ 32 years: paliperidone palmitate, 26%; risperidone microspheres, 17%; or haloperidol decanoate, 5%).
Over 1 year, on average 62% of patients used paliperidone palmitate or risperidone
microspheres in monotherapy. In contrast, haloperidol decanoate in monotherapy
declined over time (from 49% to 28% in 1 year). Medication against extrapyramidal
symptoms was on average more used with haloperidol decanoate (37%) than with
paliperidone palmitate (16%) or risperidone microspheres (18%). Conclusions:
Results of the database research indicate that more patients treated with paliperidone palmitate continued their therapy, restarted therapy and were of younger
age than patients receiving risperidone microspheres or haloperidol decanoate.
Monotherapy was more frequently observed with paliperidone palmitate and risperidone microspheres while co-medication against extrapyramidal symptoms was
less frequently used compared to with haloperidol decanoate.
PMH43
Describing the Health Status of Schizophrenia Caregivers in
the 5E.U
Gupta S 1, Isherwood G 2, Jones K 3, Van Impe K 4
1Kantar Health, Princeton, NJ, USA, 2Kantar Health, Epsom, UK, 3European Federation of
Associations of Families of People with Mental Illness, B-3000 Leuven, Belgium, 4Janssen-Cilag
GmbH, Neuss, Germany
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Research indicates schizophrenia is a cause of burden for patients and
caregivers. This study examined health-related quality of life (HRQoL) and comorbidities experienced by schizophrenia caregivers compared to non-caregivers and
caregivers of other conditions. Methods: Data were obtained from the 2010-2011
and 2013 5E. U. (UK, Germany, France, Italy, Spain) National Health and Wellness
Survey, an online questionnaire that’s representative of the total adult (18+ years)
population. Respondents provided information on HRQoL (SF-36v2: mental and
physical component summary (MCS, PCS) and SF-6D (health utility) scores), and
comorbidities (sleep-difficulties, insomnia, pain, headaches, heartburn, anxiety,
depression) experienced in the past 12 months. Schizophrenia caregivers (n= 398)
were matched to non-caregivers (n= 158,989) and other caregivers (n= 14,341) on
baseline characteristics (age, gender, income, etc.) via propensity scores (1:2). Chisquare tests and ANOVAs were used to determine significant differences across the
groups. Results: The average age of schizophrenia caregivers was 45.3 (SD= 15.8
years), 59.6% were female, and 14.8% reported an income of € 50,000/£40,000+. After
matching, schizophrenia caregivers reported significantly lower MCS (40.3 vs. 45.9),
PCS (46.8 vs. 49.0) and health utilities (0.64 vs. 0.71), compared to non-caregivers (all
p< 0.001). Schizophrenia caregivers reported experiencing significantly more sleep
difficulties (42.7% vs. 28.5%), insomnia (32.4% vs. 18.5%), pain (39.7% vs. 30.4%),
headaches (48.0% vs. 42.0%), heartburn (31.7% vs. 22.9%), anxiety (37.9% vs. 23.6%),
and depression (29.4% vs. 19.4%) than non-caregivers. Comparing schizophrenia
caregivers and other caregivers, schizophrenia caregivers reported lower MCS (40.3
vs. 42.7, p< 0.001), and health utilities (0.64 vs. 0.67, p< 0.001). Schizophrenia caregivers reported significantly more sleep difficulties (42.7% vs. 36.8%), insomnia (32.4%
vs. 26.0%), pain (39.7% vs. 31.5%), and anxiety (37.9% vs. 29.8%) than other caregivers. Conclusions: Schizophrenia caregivers reported worse HRQoL and more
comorbidities than non-caregivers and caregivers of other conditions. Providing
caregivers with support services to better manage patients effectively may improve
caregiver’s health status.
PMH44
Does Giving Carers a Break Improve their Wellbeing? Results from
an Evaluation using the EQ-5D-5L
Gladwell D 1, Moule P 2, Moody E 3, Pollard K 2, Watson C 4, Hatswell A J 1
1BresMed, Sheffield, UK, 2University of the West of England, Bristol, UK, 3NHS Bristol Clinical
Commissioning Group, Bristol, UK, 4Bristol City Council, Bristol, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
caring. It provided direct payments and aid to allow carers to take a break from caring
(with or without the person cared for). Here we investigate the effects of the scheme
on carers’ HRQL. Methods: In order to conduct the evaluation, a quality of life survey
was conducted. Carers were asked to complete questionnaires at Week 0 and Week
12. One of the questionnaires selected for inclusion in both surveys was the EQ-5D
(5 level). Results: Of the 155 patients completing the Week 0 survey, 97 completed
at least some of the Week 12 survey. There was some evidence to suggest a small
improvement in HRQL via the EQ-5D-5L (0.62 to 0.66, n=86). Both pre- and post-intervention the estimated mean utility of the cohort was significantly lower than 0.81;
the value that would be predicted in the general population given the age and gender
characteristics of the cohort. Conclusions: Informal carers have significantly lower
HRQL than age-matched controls. While it is not possible to draw firm conclusions
around the benefit derived from the intervention, due to the lack of control arm, the
evaluation of a carer breaks service indicates a potentially modest benefit.
PMH45
The Impact on Work and Social Activities Among Carers of Children
with Adhd in Sweden Relative to Other Nordic Countries
Romero B 1, Gajria K 2, Dietrich C N 1, Flood E 1, Gustafsson P A 3, Ahnemark E 4, Sikirica V 2
Commercialisation and Outcomes, Bethesda, MD, USA, 2Shire, Wayne, PA, USA, 3Linköping
University, Linköping, Sweden, 4Shire, Danderyd, Sweden
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1ICON
Objectives: To understand social and work impacts of caring for children/
adolescents with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in Sweden
relative to a combined cohort of other Nordic countries (Denmark, Finland and
Norway). Methods: Carers in Sweden and other Nordic countries completed the
Caregiver Perspective of Pediatric ADHD (CAPPA) online survey capturing carer
impacts, including work, social activities and family relationships, due to their
child’s ADHD. Impacts were explored when the child was “on” and “off” medication (e. g. days medication not taken). Comparisons of “on” and “off” medication
were examined using the Wilcoxon Signed-Rank test. No statistical comparisons of
impacts were made between countries. Results: 219 Swedish and 249 other Nordic
carers of ADHD children aged 6–17 years completed the survey. 37% of Swedish
carers reported employment changes (e. g. resigned, changed shift, reduced hours)
due to their child’s ADHD; 52% of these changes occurred when the child was “on”
medication. In the past 4 weeks, 60% of Swedish carers reported missing work and
45% reported being late for work. After excluding outliers (n= 15), mean number
of hours missed was 4.32 (n= 91, SD 2.53) and mean number of times late was 2.91
(n= 69, SD 1.35). Swedish carers reported fewer “moderate” to “tremendous” impacts
on social life when their child was “on” versus “off” medication (partner relationship
strain: 37% vs 67%; relationship strain with other children: 29% vs 57%; social activity
interference: 40% vs 59%). Relative to other Nordic countries, more Swedish carers
reported being late for work (36% vs 45%) and more “moderate” to “tremendous”
interference with social activities while the child was medicated (29% vs 40%). All
other impacts described were similar between the two cohorts. Conclusions:
While medication helped, it did not completely alleviate child ADHD-related impacts
on work and social activities among carers from Sweden and other Nordic countries.
PMH46
Conceptual Comprehensiveness of Anxiety Instruments in Chronic
Obstructive Pulmonary Disease: Exploring the Potential for
Confounding Somatic Items
Willgoss T G 1, Humphrey L 1, Fatoye F 2, Yohannes A M 2
International, Manchester, UK, 2Manchester Metropolitan University, Manchester, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Abacus
Objectives: Clinically relevant anxiety is a highly prevalent co-morbidity in chronic
obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), affecting up to 74% of patients. However,
despite its prevalence, co-morbid anxiety remains under-recognised and undermanaged. Furthermore, its identification and measurement can be confounded by
the overlap of somatic symptoms between anxiety and COPD. This study sought to
evaluate the ability of existing patient-reported outcome (PRO) measures to assess
anxiety in COPD through conceptual mapping, with particular attention on the
coverage of non-somatic anxiety symptoms. Methods: To determine conceptual
comprehensiveness, the content of 12 extant anxiety PROs was mapped to a conceptual model of anxiety in COPD, developed through a qualitative literature review and
in-depth qualitative interviews (n= 15) of COPD patients with anxious symptomology. Results: The conceptual model contained 29 concepts within five domains
(somatic [15 concepts]; psychic tension [5 concepts]; apprehension [5 concepts];
panic [3 concepts]; behavioural [1 concept]). The most comprehensive conceptual
coverage was found in the Mind Over Mood Anxiety Inventory which assesses 18/29
(62%) concepts across all five domains. Concept mapping revealed the majority of
PROs are biased toward assessing somatic symptoms of anxiety, with no measure
providing comprehensive assessment of non-somatic concepts. Indeed, the two
most widely used anxiety PROs in COPD research and clinical practice (Beck Anxiety
Inventory [BAI] and Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale) provide sub-optimal coverage of anxiety concepts. In particular, the BAI is heavily weighted toward assessing
somatic concepts, with little focus on psychic, apprehensive, panic and behavioural
concepts of anxiety. Conclusions: In light of the sub-optimal content validity of
extant instruments, including those commonly used in research and practice, there
is a need for a comprehensive COPD-specific anxiety PRO. Such an instrument can
be utilised in clinical trials for evaluating new products and enhance the accuracy
of anxiety screening and measurement in clinical practice.
.
Objectives: Informal carers are widely acknowledged to be an important part of
health care provision, as well as a source of substantial cost savings to the health
care system. It has been observed, however, that carers have worse health-related
quality of life (HRQL) than the general population. As a result of this, the wellbeing
of carers has been set as a government priority. In Bristol, UK, the National Health
Service and council jointly funded a 12-week scheme to facilitate breaks from
PMH47
The Anxiety Inventory for Respiratory Disease (Air): an Exploration
of the Air’s Psychometric Properties Through Rasch Analysis
Willgoss T G 1, Humphrey L 1, Fatoye F 2, Yohannes A M 2
International, Manchester, UK, 2Manchester Metropolitan University, Manchester, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Abacus
Objectives: The Anxiety Inventory for Respiratory disease (AIR) is a novel, nonsomatic patient-reported outcome (PRO) measure of anxiety among patients with
chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). Traditional psychometric meth-
A462
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
ods have demonstrated promising properties of the tool. However, traditional
psychometrics may have clinically relevant limitations, including scale and sampling dependency. The objective of this study was to evaluate the AIR’s strengths
and weaknesses using more sophisticated Rasch Measurement Theory (RMT)
Methods. Methods: Previously collected data from an observational study of 56
patients with COPD (mean age 70 years, 52% female) were analysed using RMT
(conducted using RUMM2030 software) to evaluate scale-to-sample targeting, measurement adequacy and person reliability. Results: Person severity was well spread
(-5.47 to 2.01 logits) but there was evidence of sample-to-scale mis-targeting at the
lower end of the anxiety severity spectrum. Monotonic ordering of response categories for all 10 items suggest that the response options work as expected. No evidence
of misfit on any of the items was identified (fit residual range -0.85 to 2.28) and this
was supported by item characteristic curves, which demonstrated good fit to the
Rasch model. Correlations among item residuals identified 11 item pairs which
exceeded recommended values (-0.30 to 0.30) indicating local dependency (range
-0.48 to 0.31). The AIR had a good person separation index (0.90) indicating that
the sample were well separated by the instrument. Conclusions: RMT analysis
demonstrated that the AIR has promising measurement properties. Mis-targeting at
the lower end of the severity spectrum is of minimal concern given the mild severity
of anxiety symptoms in this sample. Any modifications to address this issue should
be carefully considered in light of the excellent screening properties previously
identified. Evidence of local dependency between some items can be explored by
reviewing qualitative data used in the development of the AIR.
PMH48
Quality of Life and the Predictors of Thai Depressive Disorders
Patients
Kongsuk T , Leejongpermpoon J , Primtra S
Ministry of public health, Ubonratchathani, Thailand
.
.
.
Objectives: To study the impact of patients with depressive disorder on quality of
life and factors predicting quality of life in depressive disorders patients. Methods:
This is a cross-sectional survey research. The sample consisted of depressive disorder patients, having depressive disorder diagnosed by psychiatrists using standard
criteria of DSM-IV during January - July 2012 and aged 18 years and above, approximately 400 participants were selected using quota sampling method. The instruments used in this study were questionnaires on SF-36 Health Survey. Comparative
analysis of average multiple regression analysis imported variables stepwise, partial correlation and colinearity statistics. Results: The number of patients with
major depressive disorder found that respondents were 397 people. Quality of life
of depressive disorder patients in 8 scales found that physical function (mean 67.9)
role limited by physical problems (mean 40.4) role limited by emotional problems
(mean 38.0) bodily pain (mean 66.6) vitality (mean 48.5), mental health (mean 53.7)
social-functioning (mean 65.6) general health (mean 47.8) and female who had experienced to be depressive disorder shown score in quality of life lower than male in
Physical Function (t=3.608, p<0.000). A multiple regression analysis, the independent
variables by stepwise analysis found the equation that predicts the optimal quality
of life consists of 6 independent variable were the severity of symptoms, age, marital
status, unemployed widower, primary school and female which is related to the
quality of life of patients with depression is high (R = 0.706) could explain the change
in quality of life was 49.8 percent. Conclusions: Quality of life in depressive disorder Thai patients is lower than that of general population. Increased unemployment
and marital divorce will negatively affect the quality of life of depressive disorder
patients. Therefore care depressive disorder patients in addition to medical treatment should pay attention to the social economy of the patient.
PMH49
Cultural Adaptation of the Alcohol Quality of Life Scale for Use
in Japan, China, and Korea
Whalley D 1, Crawford S R 1, Laramée P 2, Higuchi S 3, Hao W 4, Kim S G 5, Luquiens A 6,
Aubin H J 6
1RTI Health Solutions, Manchester, UK, 2Lundbeck S.A.S., Issy-les-Moulineaux cedex, France,
3National Hospital Organization Kurihama Medical and Addiction Center, Yokosuka, Japan,
4Second Xiangya Hospital of Central South University, Changsha, China, 5Pusan National
University, Yangsan, South Korea, 6Hôpital Paul Brousse, INSERM 669, Université Paris-Sud,
Villejuif, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The Alcohol Quality of Life Scale (AQoLS) is a new measure to assess
health-related quality of life (HRQL) in alcohol use disorder (AUD). The measure,
developed in the UK and France, has 34 items over 7 hypothesised domains: relationships, activities, looking after self, emotional impact, control, living conditions,
and sleep. The aim of this study was to adapt the measure for use in Japan, China
and South Korea. Methods: The cultural adaptation process included three stages:
initial translation of the UK-English AQoLS using forward-back translation; lay
assessment of the initial translations with members of the general population in
the target countries to ensure cultural appropriateness of the language register and
content; cognitive debriefing interviews with AUD patients in the target countries
to assess face and content validity. Results: Initial translations of the AQoLS into
the three target languages were produced. Lay assessments were conducted with
8 individuals in Japan, 5 in China, and 5 in Korea, and modifications made to each
new language version. Cognitive debriefing interviews were conducted with 8 AUD
patients in Japan (3 male, age 34-71 years), 10 in China (8 male, age 25-45 years), and
12 in Korea (9 male, age 44-65 years). Patients found the AQoLS easy to understand
and relevant to their experiences. Further modifications were made to maintain
consistency with the source version, clarify the intended meaning, or to improve
acceptability of individual word or phrases. Conclusions: The new adaptations
of the AQoLS are appropriate instruments to assess HRQL in AUD patients in Japan,
China, and Korea. The adaptation methodology was comprehensive, involving translation experts, members of the general public, and patients with AUD in each target
country. This ensured that the new language versions were conceptually equivalent
to the source instrument and appropriate to the target culture.
PMH50
The Patient Experience of Alcohol use Disorder
Whalley D 1, Luquiens A 2, Crawford S R 1, Laramée P 3, Doward L 1, Price M 4, Hawken N A 5,
Dorey J 6, Owens L 7, Llorca P M 8, Falissard B 2, Aubin H J 2
Health Solutions, Manchester, UK, 2Hôpital Paul Brousse, INSERM 669, Université Paris-Sud,
Villejuif, France, 3Lundbeck S.A.S., Issy-les-Moulineaux cedex, France, 4RTI Health Solutions,
Research Triangle Park, NC, USA, 5Creativ-Ceutical, Luxembourg, Luxembourg, 6Creativ-Ceutical
USA, Chicago, IL, USA, 7Institute of Translational Medicine, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, UK,
8Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Clermont-Ferrand, Clermont-Ferrand, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1RTI
Objectives: Alcohol consumption carries a risk of adverse personal, social,
and health effects. Alcohol use disorder (AUD) is a problematic pattern of alcohol use leading to clinically significant impairment or distress. The aim of this
study was to determine the patient-perceived impact of AUD. Methods: Focus
groups were conducted with a sample of patients with current or remitted AUD
in the UK and France to identify key areas of impact from the patient perspective.
The groups were audio-recorded and transcribed. Thematic analysis of the data
was undertaken. Results: Ten focus groups were conducted with a total of 38
patients (20 current AUD, 18 remitted AUD; 26 male, 12 female; age range 23-69
years). All patients met the diagnostic criteria (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual
of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition) for alcohol dependence. Patients characterised their relationship with alcohol as an ongoing battle for control. The cycle of
consumption and dependence permeated most areas of patients’ lives, with often
devastating consequences. Seven key areas of impact of AUD were identified:
social and personal relationships; household, family and social activities; selfcare and personal safeguarding; emotional well-being; control over life, self and
alcohol; financial and housing situation; and sleep disturbance. The impact
of AUD continued even after patients stopped drinking; remitted patients
described the ongoing battle to remain abstinent, and the lasting legacy of damaged relationships and feelings of low self-worth. Conclusions: AUD has considerable impact on many areas of patients’ lives, particularly relationships, and
feelings of control and self-worth, which can continue even after abstinence has
been achieved. From the patient perspective, drinking cessation or reduced consumption may not be the most relevant outcome to determine treatment benefit.
There is a clear need for measures that can quantify the humanistic outcomes
associated with AUD.
PMH51
Societal Costs and Qol of Children with Adhd and their Parents: a
Comparison to a Reference Group from the General Population
Van Der Kolk A 1, van Agthoven M 2, Bouwmans C 3, Buitelaar J K 4, Hakkaart L 3
1Janssen-Cilag BV the Netherlands, Tilburg, The Netherlands, 2Janssen-Cilag BV, Tilburg, The
Netherlands, 3Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 4Donders Institute for
Brain, Cognition and Behaviour, Nijmegen, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To compare Quality of Life (QOL) and societal costs in an ADHD population to a control group representing the general population. Methods: An online
cross-sectional retrospective study among parents of children with ADHD was
conducted via Balans, a Dutch ADHD organization. Because of large differences in
responder groups in the initial study, comparison with a control group was added
to understand the impact of ADHD compared to the general population in greater
detail. Therefore, a separate online research among parents of children without
ADHD or any other chronic disease was performed. The control group was selected
on the basis of pre-defined characteristics in order to match the ADHD group. QoL
(EQ-5D for children and parents and KIDSCREEN-10 for children) and societal costs
(TiC-P) were surveyed based on proxy reporting. In this study, monthly resource
use of patients and their parents was identified. Descriptive statistics, independent
samples t-test and Chi-square for p-values (sig. 2-tailed) were used for analysis on
significance in differences between samples. Results: The ADHD sample (n= 618)
was compared to the control group (n= 704). Both groups primarily contained boys
with a mean age of 11 years. QOL differed significantly between children with
ADHD and the control group, both for EQ-5D (ADHD 0.80 vs. controls 0.96; p< 0.000)
and KIDSCREEN-10 (ADHD 41.67 vs. controls 55.46; p< 0.000). The same is true for
their parents (ADHD 0.83 vs. controls 0.88; p< 0.000). Total monthly costs associated
with ADHD differed significantly as well, both for children (ADHD € 518 vs. controls
€ 91; p< 0.000) and parents (ADHD € 288 vs. controls € 49; p< 0.000). Conclusions:
Although this was not a direct comparative study, the magnitude of differences in
absolute results seem to justify the conclusion that ADHD accounts for significantly
higher costs and lower QoL for patients, parents and society compared to a control
group representing the general population.
PMH52
Alcohol Consumption: the Burden of Entourage
Touboul C 1, Hoertel N 2, Limosin F 2, Crochard A 3, Rouillon F 4
1Kantar Health, Montrouge, France, 2Hôpital Corentin-Celton, Issy-les-Moulineaux, France,
3Lundbeck S.A.S., Issy-Les-Moulineaux, France, 4Centre Hospitalier Sainte-Anne, Paris, France
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The purpose of this study, carried out on a general sample in France in
2013, was to measure the burden of alcohol consumption on the entourage (family
members and friends) of people with alcohol problems and to identify the consequences of excessive alcohol consumption on the caregivers. Methods: The
ENTOURAGE survey was conducted among individuals from KANTAR HEALTH’s
panel. A self-administered questionnaire was sent to a representative sample
of 10,000 adults (aged 18+) based on the quota method. The level of burden was
assessed using the Zarit Burden Scale (ZBI) and the level of alcohol consumption
using the AUDIT-C. Results: Of the 7,813 individuals who filled out their questionnaires, 13% (n= 1,018) stated that a member of their entourage has a problem with
alcohol. Of this 13%, the alcohol consumption level was ‘not at risk’ in 2% (n= 18),
‘excessive’ in 39% (n= 406) and 52% (n= 533) were ‘alcohol-dependent’ according
to AUDIT-C scores; 7% did not specify the quantity of alcohol consumed. 37.0%
of these 1,018 respondents rated burden as ‘minimal’, 40.7% as ‘mild’, 18.3% as
‘moderate’ and 3.9% considered it as ‘severe’. The average score of the ZBI was 28.5
A463
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
(SE= 16.0). Burden felt by the entourage was positively correlated with the physical and affective proximity between the interviewee and the drinker, particularly
when the interviewee lives with him, and with the presence of social, behavioral
and medical consequences of alcohol consumption (on average the number of
medical comorbidities was 2.1 for ‘severe’ burdens vs 1.4 for ‘minimal’ burdens,
p< 0.01). Conclusions: Excessive drinking has deleterious effects on drinkers and
his entourage. Our results demand greater recognition of caregivers’ burden in the
management of patients with alcohol dependence and further support the need for
improving alcohol dependence management and prevention of its development to
reduce the global burden of alcoholism.
PMH53
Quality of Life in Hospitalized Seniors with Psychiatric Disorders
Poliakova N , Grochalova M, Mastiliakova D , Gerlichova K , Bielik J
Trencin University, Trencin, Slovak Republic
.
.
.
.
PMH56
Work Productivity Loss with Depression, Diagnosed and
Undiagnosed, among Employed Respondents in an Internet-Based
Survey Conducted in Japan
Asami Y 1, Goren A 2, Okumura Y 3
1Pfizer Japan Inc., Tokyo, Japan, 2Kantar Health, New York, NY, USA, 3Institute for Health
Economics and Policy, Tokyo, Japan
.
.
.
Objectives: In Japan, estimated numbers of patients who received medical treatment with major depressive disorder have recently increased and are reported
almost 708,000 patients according to the results of the Patient Survey 2011. In
addition, the potential magnitude of disease burden associated with undiagnosed
depression is suggested by the low mental health service utilization in Japan, which
is even lower than many western countries. The aim of this study is to investigate
whether depression severity was associated with work impairments, regardless of
diagnosis. Methods: Employed respondents (n=17,820) of an internet-based crosssectional survey (the 2011 National Health and Wellness Survey fielded in Japan)
were categorized according to depression diagnosis (diagnosed or undiagnosed) and
severity (Patient Health Questionnaire-9 score= 10+ or < 10). Work Productivity and
Activity Impairment questionnaire-based measures were predicted by diagnosis,
severity, and their interaction, adjusting for covariates. Results: Among employed
respondents (n= 17,820) in the Japan NHWS, 3.8% were diagnosed with depression
within 12 months (n= 678). Among those with diagnosis, 51.0% (n = 346) had PHQ-9
scores of 10 and above, while among those without a diagnosis, 7.8% (n = 1,336) had
scores of 10+. In other words, 7.5% among all employed respondents (1,336/17,820)
self-reported that they were undiagnosed as depressed but had PHQ-9=10+. Among
the undiagnosed, high severity respondents had greater overall work impairment
(33.3% vs. 14.8%), absenteeism (5.9% vs. 2.2%), presenteeism (30.4% vs. 13.4%) than
low severity respondents. Significant interactions between diagnosis and severity indicated greater impairments among undiagnosed vs. diagnosed respondents
(except on absenteeism). Conclusions: Depression severity was associated with
work productivity loss, even among the undiagnosed, suggesting a need for early
detection, referral, and treatment of depression in the workplace.
Objectives: The number of seniors in Europe is increasing. The aim of our research
study was to determine quality of life in the long term hospitalized seniors with
psychiatric diseases and to determine to what extent the age and education affects
the quality of life. Methods: Two standardized questionnaires - WHOQOL-BREF
(World Health Organization Quality of Life Assessment-Brief) and WHOQOL-OLD
(World Health Organization Quality of Life Assessment-Old) were used in the study.
The research sample consisted of 100 patients hospitalized in geriatric psychiatric
department of a Woman’s Psychiatric Hospital in Kroměříž. Patients were from 65
to 95 years old. Duration of hospitalization was from 2 to 12 months. Data were
collected was in October 2012 - February 2013. Results: Average score WHO-QOL
BREF was lower than of the population norms. Satisfaction with health was lower
than the assessment of quality of life. Comparing the results to respondents 79 years
old and over 80 years old it has been found lower scores in all domains of quality of
life by younger patients. Worsening of physical health and quality of social relations
were patients with lower level of education. Other domains were worse evaluated by
patients with higher level of education. Assessment domains WHOQOL OLD values
were lower than of population norms. Very low score, regardless of age and education, appeared in ratings independence. Conclusions: Long-term hospitalization
is reflected in the perception of quality of life, particularly in the physical domain
and the feeling of dependence. Chronic health problems, social isolation, reduction
in the activity disturb seniors wellbeing and reduce subjective assessment of quality
of life. The effort to engage of hospitalized seniors in society and leisure activities
can increase the quality of their life. Early diagnosis and treatment reduce the price
of treatment and length of hospitalization.
PMH57
Description of Agitation and Crisis Interventions in a Psychiatric
Hospital in Spain: a Qualitative Study
PMH54
A Potential Gender Bias in the Quality of Life - an Exploratory
Standard Gamble Experiment Among Economics Students
Rubio-Valera M 1, Ortiz J M 1, Baladón L 1, Luciano-Devís J V 1, Salvador-Carulla L 2, Haro J M 1,
Gracia A 3, Serrano-Blanco A 1
1Parc Sanitari Sant Joan de Déu, Sant Boi de Llobregat, Spain, 2Centre for Disability Research and
Policy, Lidcombe, Australia, 3Ferrer, Barcelona, Spain
Mental Health – Health Care Use & Policy Studies
.
Mahlich J 1, Al Obaidi L 2
1University of Vienna, Vienna, Austria, 2University of Nottingham, Nottingham, UK
.
.
Objectives: To estimate determinants of quality of life of undergraduate
Economics students at the University of Vienna. Methods: Quality of life values
were elicited by means of the standard gamble approach. The impact of several
variables such as gender, side job, length of study and living arrangements on
the quality of life were identified using different types of regression techniques
(OLS, GLM, Betafit). Results: Significant evidence was found that female gender is associated with a higher quality of life in all specifications of our estimations. Conclusions: The observed gender differences in quality of life can be
attributed to a higher degree of risk aversion of women. A higher risk aversion
leads to a higher valuation of given health states and a potential gender bias in
health economic evaluations.
PMH55
Economic Evaluation of Dialectical Behavior Therapy (Dbt)
Amongst those with Borderline Personality Disorder (Bpd)
who Engage in Self-Harm in Ireland
Murphy A M , Bourke J
University College Cork, cork, Ireland
.
.
.
Objectives: This study examines the cost effectiveness of Dialectical behavior therapy (DBT) amongst those with borderline personality disorder (BPD) who
engage in self-harm compared to treatment as usual (TAU) in Ireland. DBT is a
comprehensive cognitive–behaviour treatment, which has been demonstrated
to be effective in reducing suicidal behaviour, hospitalisations, etc. The programme consists of group therapy and individual therapy, running for 24 weeks
in total. Methods: A decision analytical model is developed to conduct the economic evaluation. The perspective taken is that of the health care payer/provider
(HSE). Costs of the treatments were identified, measured and valued. This included
direct costs of DBT and TAU, as well as additional resources consumed (emergency
department, outpatient and inpatient attendances). Relevant health effects of
the treatments were measured using a variety of condition specific and generic
measures including the Beck Depression Inventory, Borderline Symptom Checklist
and EQ-5D. These measures were collected at baseline, six months and 18-month
intervals. To account for uncertainties a probabilistic sensitivity analysis, employing a Monte Carlo simulation, is performed. Results: Preliminary results indicate
there are additional costs associated with DBT compared to TAU. With regard to
effectiveness DBT was associated with lower presentations at emergency departments, output and inpatient stays; higher utilities and better scores on condition
specific measures. The reduction in health service utilisations represents cost savings to the health care provider and payer. Conclusions: This is first economic
evaluation of DBT in the Irish setting. A review by Brazier et al in 2006 suggested
further evidence was required to demonstrate the cost effectiveness of DBT. This
study contributes greatly to international literature. While DBT is an expensive
therapy, compared to TAU, this study finds that the cost savings owing to reduction
in utilisations of acute services is noteworthy.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The aim of the study was to define and characterize the agitation
states present in usual medical practice in the acute and emergency units of a
psychiatric hospital from the viewpoint of psychiatrists and nurses. We also aimed
to describe the typical care packages (crisis intervention) for each of the agitation states described. Methods: Two nominal groups, one with 7 nurses and the
other with 10 psychiatrists, from the Parc Sanitari Sant Joan de Déu emergency
and acute care psychiatric wards were established. Results: The nurses described
two main states forming the endpoints of a spectrum: from mild (pre-agitation) to
severe (agitation). A third state was outlined in which agitation was characterized
by disorganized behavior problems. Agitation subtypes were described according
to the characteristics and severity of the clinical situation. Various care packages
were described for each agitation state. The care packages were divided into first,
second and third line approaches. The first line approaches (i. e., verbal containment) were used on every (pre) agitated patient. If the first line approach was not
effective, the second and third line approaches were implemented, culminating
with physical restraint. Every episode was followed by behavioral observation. The
psychiatrists described 3 states: a mild initial state (anxiety and irritability), moderate (pre-agitation without aggressiveness) and a severe state of agitation with
aggressiveness and/or violence. Again, every state was associated with specific
treatment. Conclusions: In order to avoid progression to a severely agitated
state, both groups agreed on the importance of appropriate verbal containment
for all states. This would be followed by environmental measures, medication and
mechanical restrain depending on the severity of the state. Mechanical restrain is
stressful for the patient, requires considerable health care resources and should be
avoided whenever possible.
PMH58
Comparison of Health Care Resource use and Costs in Patients
with Opioid Prescription Drug Dependence (Opd) Treated with
Buprenorphine/Naloxone and Patients without Pharmacological
Treatment: Retrospective Analysis of us Public Insurance Claims
Khemiri A 1, Clay E 2, Kharitonova E 2, Aballéa S 2, Zah V 3, Ruby J 4
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Creativ-Ceutical, Tunis, Tunisia, 2Creativ-Ceutical, Paris, France, 3ZRx
Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro,
USA
4Reckitt
Outcomes Research Inc.,
Benckiser Pharmaceuticals, Inc./NA, Richmond, VA,
Objectives: The buprenorphine/naloxone (BUP/NAL) combination is used in the
treatment of prescription opioid dependence (OPD). The objective of this study was
to determine if there were health economic advantages related to treatment compared to no pharmacological treatment. Methods: A retrospective cohort analysis was performed using insurance claims extracted from the US Truven Health
MarketScan® Medicaid database from January 2007 to December 2012. Two groups
were considered: 1) patients with opioid prescription drug (OPD) dependence treated
with buprenorphine/naloxone and 2) patients with opioid prescription drug (OPD)
dependence and no pharmacological treatment. Final study groups were selected
with one-to-one matching on demographic characteristics, comorbidities at baseline and cost of outpatient and inpatient care over six months before index date.
A464
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Resource use (pharmacy claims, outpatient claims, emergency room admission
and hospital admission) and corresponding costs over twelve months after index
date were compared between groups. Results: Each group included 362 patients.
Patient characteristics at baseline, resource use, and health care costs before index
date were comparable between the two groups. At twelve months after the index
date, patients with no pharmacological treatment had higher resource utilization in
every category but medication. Total costs over 12 months were $14,983 and $15,692
in groups with and without pharmacological treatment, respectively (p = 0.67).
Patients with pharmacological treatment had a higher pharmacy cost, but this was
offset by the higher cost of outpatient visits in patients with no pharmacological
treatment. These visits were mostly related to mental disorders, nervous system,
skin and musculoskeletal disorders and injuries and poisonings. Conclusions:
While the treatment of opioid dependence with buprenorphine/naloxone is associated with higher medication acquisition cost, it is outweighed by cost savings
in other categories, especially outpatient care. Patients without pharmacological
treatment use more health care resources and have higher total costs.
age group of 21 -30 years. In study population 141 (61.3%) were married and majority of Housewives 57 (24.8%) followed by Govt. service 28 (12.2%). Amongs study
population 136 (59.1%) patients received the second generation antipsychotics
and 8 (3.5%) patients received first generation antipsychotics Resperidone was
the most commonly prescribed antipsychotic given to 36.5% of the patients followed by clozapine 26.5% and olanzapine. Monotherapy was received by 22.2%. 106
(46.08%) patients and 89 (38.69%) received dual drug regimen. Conclusions: The
utilization pattern of antipsychotics, revealed that atypical antipsychotics were
prescribed more commonly when compare to typical antipsychotics. Among the
atypical antipsychotics, Resperidone was commonly used during Schizophrenia
as compared to other atypical antipsychotic drugs.
PMH59
Drug Utilization Study of Antipsychotics used for the Hospital
Treatment Of Schizophrenia in Russia
1Market Access
PMH62
Comparison of Resource use and Health Care Costs in New
Initiators of Long-Acting Injectable (Lai) and Oral Second
Generation Antipsychotics
Seetasith A 1, Burudpakdee C 2
Solutions LLC., Raritan, NJ, USA, 2MKTXS, LLC, Raritan, NJ, USA
.
Vaskova L , Tyapkina M
1st Moscow State Medical University named after I.M. Sechenov, Moscow, Russia
.
.
Objectives: The goal was to examine utilization of typical (TA), atypical antipsychotic (AA) and depot antipsychotic s (DA), used for treatment of patients with
schizophrenia in Russian hospital during 1 year. Methods: A retrospective study,
carried out in Moscow hospital from January 2012 to December 2012. Patient data
on demography (age, sex), medicines used (dose, duration of treatment), length of
hospital stay and clinical outcome were recorded and analyzed. Drug consumption
was calculated using defined daily dose (DDD) methodology. Results: Total 227
patients were included in the study. Among study population 121 (53.3%) patients
were male and mean age was 33.2 (male) and 45.5 (female). Out of 227 patients 219
(96.5%) were improved and 1 (0.4%) person were recovery. Mean length of hospitalization was 75.3 days. Total 27 antipsychotic were used for the treatment schizophrenia among these patients. Among used antipsychotic consumption (DDD/100
bed days) was highest for AA clozapine oral (194.25) followed by TA haloperidol oral
(52.39), DA fluphenazine parenteral depot (20.04) and DA haloperidol parenteral
depot (19.59). However the cost of treatment for AA clozapine was higher, than for
TA haloperidol. The total consumption (DDD/100 bed days) in the antipsychotics
group was: 224.3 for AA, 73.38 for TA and 39.91 for DA. Conclusions: This study
provides estimate of consumptions different antipsychotics used for the hospital
treatment of schizophrenia. Atypical antipsychotic clozapine oral is highest consumed among 27 antipsychotics. Total drug utilization for AA was three times higher
than for TA and five times higher than DA, however the costs of treatment for AA
was substantially higher than for TA.
PMH60
Drug Utilization Pattern of Lisdexamfetamine Dimesylate in
Germany
.
Objectives: To measure health care utilization and costs among new initiators of
LAI and oral second generation antipsychotics with schizophrenia or bipolar disorder. Methods: A large database of a commercially insured US population was used
to index patients on their first treatment between 1/1/2011 and 12/31/2011. Patients
were required to have ≥ 12 months pre-index and ≥ 12 months post-index, were new
users of a second generation antipsychotic, and diagnosed with schizophrenia or
bipolar disorder during their pre-index period. LAI and oral patients were matched
1: 3 using propensity scores. Mean differences in annual resource use and costs
were compared across groups in an unadjusted difference-in-difference analysis: [
(LAI post - LAI pre) - (Oral post - Oral pre)]. Results: Initial selection identified 250
LAI and 8,356 oral treatment patients. Matching resulted in balanced cohorts of 204
LAI and 612 oral initiators. Annual hospitalizations and ER visits from pre-index
to post-index was significantly lower in LAI initiators compared to oral initiators.
Mean annual hospitalizations per LAI patient reduced from 1.09 to 0.51 (p < 0.0001)
while that of the oral cohort reduced from 0.53 to 0.39 (p = 0.0011). This resulted in
a net reduction of 0.45 annual hospitalizations per patient in the LAI cohort, using
the oral cohort as a reference (p < 0.0001). Mean annual ER visits reduced from
1.72 to 1.03 per LAI patient compared to no change in the oral cohort, resulting in
a net difference of 0.72 ER visits between the two groups (p < 0.0001). The unadjusted difference-in-difference analysis showed a relative reduction in total health
care costs of $4,997 in the LAI cohort compared to the oral cohort. Conclusions:
Initiating treatment with an LAI resulted in greater reductions in hospitalizations
and ER visits compared to oral second generation antipsychotic medications in
patients with schizophrenia or bipolar disease.
PMH63
Antidepressant use and Suicide Rate in England: the
Geographic Divide
Anderson R , Wilson T , Griffiths M
Costello Medical Consulting Ltd., Cambridge, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: - The objective of the study was to provide utilization data in Germany
for the ADHD stimulant medication lisdexamfetamine dimesylate (LDX) in the first
six months following its launch in June 2013. Methods: - This drug utilization
study (DUS) analysed a longitudinal electronic medical record database (IMS Disease
Analyzer - Germany), and was part of a larger DUS providing data for 8 European
countries for up to 5 years. The study included records of all patients who had been
prescribed LDX from June 2013 to December 2013 in the paediatrician panel (PP)
or neurologist/psychiatrist panel (NPP) of the German database. Results: - The
analysis included 123 patients (348 prescriptions) from the PP and 296 patients
(710 prescriptions) from the NPP. In both panels, 91% of patients had a documented
diagnosis of ADHD. When initiated on LDX treatment, most patients (PP, 98%; NPP,
91%) were between 6 and 18 years of age; up to 1% of patients in both panels were
below 6 years of age and 2% and 8% of patients in the PP and NPP, respectively, were
above 18 years of age. The majority of patients in both panels were male (PP, 77%;
NPP, 79%). The average prescribed daily dose of LDX was within the recommended
range (30–70 mg) for all patients in the NPP and for 98.4% in the PP, with a mean
daily dose across patients of 42 mg in both panels. Conclusions: - The findings of
this analysis of electronic medical records indicate that, during the first six months
after launch, LDX was mainly prescribed in Germany within the EMA-approved
Summary of Product Characteristics (SmPC) with regard to the indicated patients,
age group and dose regimen.
Objectives: Mental illness is widespread, with 1 in 3 people worldwide reporting
symptoms indicative of a psychiatric disorder at some point in their lives. The use
of antidepressants has risen globally and within Europe has been reported to be correlated with a reduced suicide rate. The aim of this research is to analyse the use of
antidepressants in England and identify any trends. Methods: Antidepressant prescribing data for National Health Service (NHS) England from 2003–2012 and from all
Primary Care Trusts (2010/11–2012/13) and Clinical Commissioning Groups (2013/14)
were obtained from the Health & Social Care Information Centre. Data were collated
for the four NHS regional area teams (North, Midlands & East, London, and South)
and analysed against population size and suicide rates. Results: Antidepressant
use in England has increased dramatically in recent years and coincides with a
year-on-year drop in ingredient costs, with 27.7 million prescriptions in 2003 and
a net ingredient cost of £395.2 million, to 50.2 million prescriptions in 2012 and a
net ingredient cost of £211.1 million. From 2010 to 2014, almost £1 billion has been
spent on antidepressants by NHS England, of which almost a third is accounted for
by the North region. Over 4 years, the average number of prescriptions per 1,000
population was 1,140.7, 987.4, 888.2 and 540.5 in the North, Midlands & East, South
and London, respectively. These figures were correlated with a suicide rate of 9.87
and 7.05 per 100,000 people in the North and London, respectively. Conclusions:
There is a clear divide within regions of England regarding antidepressant use and
suicide rate, and the correlation between these two measures was found to be
opposite to that reported for Europe generally. These findings highlight the importance of understanding mental illness and the underlying reasons for the wide
disparity in England.
PMH61
Utilization Patterns of Antipsychotics Usage in Tertiary Care
Hospital Patients with Schizophrenia
PMH64
Analysis of Prescribing Patterns of Atypical Antipsychotics in
Lhu Caserta
Pethekar A J 1, Nair S 1, Kunhikatta V 1, Sharma P S V N 2, Thunga G1
1Manipal College of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Manipal University, Manipal, India, 2Manipal
University, Manipal, India
Farina G 1, Menditto E 2, Manna S 1, Pagliaro C 1, Troncone C 1, Putignano D 2, Orlando V 2,
Linguiti C 1, Buffardi G F 1, Tari M G 1
1LHU Caserta, Caserta, Italy, 2CIRFF- Center of Pharmacoeconomics, Naples, Italy
Objectives: The main objective of the study was to find the utilization pattern
of antipsychotics in schizophrenia patients in a tertiary care teaching hospital
South India. Methods: A retrospective study has been carried on schizophrenic
patients admitted in a tertiary care teaching hospital for a period of one year. The
diagnosis of schizophrenia was based on ICD-10 (Tenth revision) criteria. Patients
of both sexes who diagnosed with schizophrenia were included in the study. Other
mental illness or drug induced psychosis patients were excluded from the study.
All demographical and clinical characteristic including treatment pattern were
collected and entered. Data were analyzed in SPSS 20.0. Results: Out of 230
patients, 144 (63%) were males and the majority of patients were 65 (28%) in the
Objectives: The Local Health Unit Caserta has made web-platform (SANIARP)
available to specialists and pharmacists to enter the diagnostic and therapeutic
information of the patient with each prescription. The advantage provided by this
platform is to make available the information on the analysis of the profiles of
prescriptive drugs in a large population sample. The aim of study was to evaluate
prescribing patterns of atypical antipsychotics in LHU Caserta for the years 20112013. Methods: This retrospective cohort study was carried out from the data of
pharmaceutical prescriptions and of plans therapeutic in Saniarp in the LHU Caserta
in the 2011-2013. Information about users of atypical antipsychotics were analyzed.
Information about the diagnosis and treatment plans were obtained through the
Cook M 1, von Bredow D 2, Rex J 3, Keja J 2, Maxwell T 1, Varughese S 1
1Shire, Wayne, PA, USA, 2IMS Health, Munich, Germany, 3IMS Health, Frankfurt am Main,
Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A465
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
linkage between the pharmaceutical database and the SANIARP database, using
anonymized patient code. Based on the date of the first prescription (index date)
the following prescribing patterns have been defined: continuers (subjects with
a gap < 30 days between two prescriptions on-going); intermittent (subjects with
a gap> 30 days but that receive another prescription at index date); switchers
(discontinuation of index drug and prescription of a new antipsychotic); add-on
(addition of a new antipsychotic); as-needed (addition of a new antipsychotic for
a limited period). Results: We identified 2,768 patients (44.5% females) with at
least one prescription of atypical antipsychotics and with a diagnosis coded in
the study period. Schizophrenia is the most frequent indication (31.1%) the most
prescribed drug is olanzapine (29.1%), followed by risperidone (17.7%), quetiapine
(13.4%), aripiprazole (12.5%), clozapine (10.3%) and asenapine (3.1%). About 70% of
schizophrenic patients is treated with the same drug, 7.9% switch and 23.6% is in
polytherapy. Conclusions: The use of SANIARP, web- platform able to allow the
systematic monitoring of prescribing patterns of drugs, is of primary importance
for better health planning.
PMH65
Maintenance Daily Dose of Venlafaxine and Duloxetine in the
Monotherapy of Patients with Major Depressive Disorder Resistant
to Selective-Serotonin-Reuptake-Inhibitors in Routine Clinical
Practice in Spain
Sicras Mainar A 1, Rejas Gutiérrez J 2, Blanca Tamayo M 1, Navarro Artieda R 3,
De Lossada Juste A 4
1Badalona Serveis Assistencials SA, Badalona (Barcelona), Spain, 2Pfizer S.L.U., Alcobendas/
Madrid, Spain, 3Hospital Germans Trias i Pujol, Badalona (Barcelona), Spain, 4Pfizer, S.L.U,
Alcobendas/Madrid, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Major Depressive Disorders (MDD) guidelines recommend using
antidepressants with dual mechanism-of-action (venlafaxine, duloxetine) when
resistant to a prior course of Selective-Serotonin-Reuptake-Inhibitors (SSRI). Dose
to use should be close to the DDD recommended by WHO. Routine clinical practice may be frequently far from guidelines. The aim was to ascertain the average
maintenance daily dose (DD) of venlafaxine and duloxetine in the monotherapy
of patients with MDD who showed resistance to a previous SSRI in routine medical practice in Spain. Methods: Retrospective analysis extracting consecutively
electronic medical records (EMR) of the BSA, a provider which health plan coverage
includes near 120,000 inhabitants in Badalona (Spain). EMR of male/female patients,
> 18 years, included in the chronic prescription follow up program, with a MDD
ICD-9-CM code (296.2x/296.3x), and who were resistant to a previous SSRI course,
were extracted for analysis. Resistant was defined as persistence of symptoms
(score >17 in the Hamilton-Depression scale and/or reduction lower than 30% of the
baseline score). Maintenance DD was considered the dose repeated (refills) at least
two time consecutively during the study period (years 2012-2013). Results: Threesixty-eight EMR [81% women, 60.3 (15.2) years] were extracted; 160 of duloxetine
and 208 of venlafaxine. Average maintenance DD were 65mg/day and 117 mg/day
for duloxetine and venlafaxine, respectively. Demographics, number of comorbidities or previous SSRI were not related with average dose. 86% of duloxetine EMR
were prescribed the WHO DDD for this drug (60mg), while only 42% of venlafaxine
received its WHO DDD (100mg), p< 0.001. Number of DDD per day were significantly
higher with venlafaxine; 1.17 (1.10-1.23) vs. 1.09 (1.05-1.12), p=0.049. Conclusions:
Routine medical practice average maintenance DD of venlafaxine and duloxetine in
SSRI resistant subjects with MDD are different in terms of both their recommended
doses in labelling or guidelines and in number of DDD per day.
PMH66
The Health Economic Impact of Resource use in Dementia:
the Erlanger Dementia Registry (EDR)
Schaller S U 1, Marinova-Schmidt V 1, Gobin J 1, Luttenberger K 2, Richter-Schmidinger T 3,
Gräßel E 2, Maler J M 3, Kornhuber J 3, Kolominsky-Rabas P L 1
1Centre for Health Technology Assessment (HTA) and Public Health (IZPH), Friedrich-AlexanderUniversity Erlangen-Nürnberg, Erlangen, Germany, 2Centre for Health Services Research in
Medicine, Psychiatric and Psychotherapeutic Clinic, University Hospital, Friedrich-AlexanderUniversity Erlangen-Nürnberg, Erlangen, Germany, 3Psychiatric and Psychotherapeutic Clinic,
University Hospital Erlangen, Friedrich-Alexander-University Erlangen-Nürnberg, Erlangen,
Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Dementia patients are in need of more extensive personal care compared to other long-term care users. This results in a high economic impact of dementia on patients, families and health care systems. Due to the increasing prevalence
of dementia worldwide, combined with limited health care expenditures, a better
understanding of resource use in dementia care is needed. Therefore the aim of our
study is the assessment of resource use in dementia in the most common setting:
home-based care (informal caregivers). Methods: The Erlanger Dementia Registry
structure was set up in 2013. Both dementia patients and informal caregivers are
interviewed separately with internationally approved valid instruments. Follow-up
takes place after 6, 12 months and afterwards annually. Resource use in dementia is
assessed via the ‘Resource Utilization in Dementia (RUD) instrument’. Results: A
total number of 50 informal caregivers (mean age=63, 61% female, 23% employed, 72%
live together with the patient) were interviewed after the initial dementia diagnosis
at baseline, and 22 study participants took part at the 1st follow-up. Informal caregivers were mainly spouses (72%) and children (22%). Main support was provided for
instrumental activities of daily living (t0:77%; t6:86%), followed by activities of daily
living (t0:37%; t6:52%) and supervision (t0:26%; t6:33%). Average hours for support
6 months after diagnosis were: IADL= 4.3h/day (min= 1.0, max=16.0), ADL= 5,2h/day
(min=2.0, max=16.0), and supervision=12.9h/day (min=1.0, max=24.0). The average
monthly costs for informal caregivers 6 months after diagnosis (medication; additional disease-related costs) are 76 €. Conclusions: Our results highlight the significant impact of informal costs (time provided for care) in dementia care, occurring
early in the disease course. For dementia patients cared for at home, informal costs
put an additional economic burden on families. For future health policy planning in
dementia, the perspective and inclusion of informal costs is essential. The research
is funded by the European Commission, ICT FP7, project ID 287509.
PMH67
Economic Burden of Major Depressive Disorder (Mdd) in Five
European Countries: Description of Resource use by Health State
Painchault C 1, Brignone M 2, Lamy F X 2, Diamand F 2, Saragoussi D 2
1Keyrus Biopharma, Levallois-Perret, France, 2Lundbeck SAS, Issy-les-Moulineaux, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Estimating resource use [RU] in real life is an important part of health
economic evaluations. RU data should reflect how patients are actually treated. In
MDD, RU data are mostly obtained from expert opinion. Variability in RU may lead to
uncertainty in health economic evaluations, but few published studies report these
data in the detail needed. The present analysis reports RU data by depression health
state from an observational study. Methods: PERFORM (Prospective Epidemiological
Research on Functioning Outcomes Related to Major depressive disorder) is a 2-year
prospective observational study conducted in 5 Western-European countries. Two- and
six-month RU were estimated by health state: remitters, non-remitters, patients in
relapse or not. RU included visits to different health care professionals, hospitalization
and sick leave. Results are reported for the whole study population and are also available by country (including the UK, for which EQ5-D-derived utilities are also available)
and for subgroups (e. g., patients who switched antidepressants at baseline). Results:
Of the 819 analysable patients at 2 months, 29% were in remission. Among patients
with at least one visit, the frequency of visits to general practitioners, psychiatrists
and psychotherapists was consistently lower for remitters versus non-remitters (1.8
vs. 2.4, 2.2 vs. 2.4 and 2.6 vs. 3.1 respectively). Fourteen patients had at least one hospitalisation. Sick leave was less frequent (14% vs. 27%) and shorter (34 vs. 41 days) for
remitters versus non-remitters respectively. At 6 months, 19.3% of patients relapsed.
RU were higher with more visits to psychiatrists, psychotherapists (4.0 vs. 2.7, 7.8
vs. 5.5) for relapsed versus non-relapsed patients. Conclusions: This first analysis
provides European RU data in MDD. More information is expected at completion of
the two-year follow-up and this study offers the possibility to describe RU by health
states, countries and subgroups and assess their transferability to other countries.
PMH69
The Impact of Economic Crisis on Suicide Rates in Greece
Skroumpelos A 1, Zavras D 1, Kyriopoulos I I 1, Nikolaidis G 2, Kyriopoulos J 1
School of Public Health, Athens, Greece, 2Institute of Child Health, Athens, Greece
.
.
.
.
.
.
1National
BACKGROUND AND Objectives: Economic crisis in Greece has several social implications, as unemployment and poverty have largely increased during the past years.
Since the onset of the economic crisis, suicides have marked a significant increase.
Therefore, aim of this study is to investigate the relationship between suicides and
the economic crisis and certain macroeconomic indices. Methods: Annual suicide
rates were obtained from the Hellenic Statistical Authority. Multiple linear regression analysis with Newey-West standard errors was carried out in order to examine
the relationship between gender and age specific suicide rates and unemployment,
GDP per capita and economic crisis (binary variable). Additionally, several statistical
tests were conducted in order to examine the properties and the robustness of the
model. Results: Unemployment appears as the major factor affecting suicides of
men and women above the age of 15. However, gender and age-related differences are
being observed. Unemployment is positively associated with the suicides of men aged
15-24, 35-44, 55-64 years. Female suicides are also affected by unemployment, excluding the age groups of 35-44 and 45-54 years old. Interestingly, suicides of women aged
between 45-54 and 55-64 were negatively associated with economic crisis. In the total
population, unemployment has impact on suicides for 15-24, 35-44, 55-64 age groups,
while economic crisis affects suicide rate in the age group of 25-34. In addition, GDP
per capita is negatively associated with suicide rates for young men (aged under 24).
The same effect is also observed for the young population in general. Conclusions:
The current economic turmoil in Greece affects suicides deaths. According to this
analysis, unemployment is the main factor that determines age-specific rates and
essentially point to the direction where measures should be taken in order to control
suicides’ incidence and lessen the effect of economic crisis on health.
PMH70
Population Health: Mental Health of us Veterans by Benefits
Enrollment Status
Richardson T 1, Claeys C 2, Sastry P 1
1KJT Group Inc., Honeyoe Falls, NY, USA, 2KJT Group Inc., Honeoye Falls, NY, USA
.
.
.
Objectives: Population-based approaches to improving health are critical to controlling rising health care costs. US Veterans represent an identifiable population of
significant interest due to their unique occupational exposures. The objectives of this
study is to characterize the mental health of a representative US sample specifically
comparing: non-Veterans, Veterans receiving VA benefits and Veterans not receiving
VA benefits. Methods: A representative (U.S. ) sample of 2,000 individuals completed
an online survey assessing their mental health (PHQ-2), Veteran status and receipt of
Veteran Administration health care benefits. We conducted bivariate analyses among
the entire population and multivariate logistic regression among 352 Veterans to
assess the relationship between ones mental health (PHQ-2 score > =3) and Veteran
benefit enrollment status controlling for ones self-reported physical health, history
of combat, awareness of Veteran Crisis Line and sociodemographic factors. Results:
Overall 28% of Veterans scored positive for depressive symptom based on a score
of 3 or greater on the PHQ-2 compared to 11% of non-Veterans. However, breaking
Veterans into those enrolled and those not enrolled revealed that 38% of enrolled
Veterans were positive compared to just 17% of non-enrolled Veterans. After removing
insignificant and/or collinear variables from the logistic regression model, the final
set of independent variables included Vets enrolled in VA benefits OR=3.91 (1.93- 8.44),
poor/fair physical health OR= 4.32 (1.98-9.68), age OR= 0.93 (0.91-0.95) and awareness
of Veteran crisis line 3.12 (1.69- 5.97). Conclusions: Younger veterans in poorer
physical health whom are receiving VA benefits and are aware of the Veteran Crisis
line are more likely to have depressive symptoms. Population based approaches to
A466
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
identifying Veterans at risk for poor mental health may be working to provide health
care benefit coverage but the persistence of symptoms, amongst those enrolled, may
suggest a need for improved treatment or surveillance.
PMH71
History of Antidepressant use Among Primary Care Depressed
Patients Switching Treatments in the United Kingdom
Lamy F X 1, Quelen C 1, Brignone M 1, Ferchichi S 2, Vataire A L 2, Rive B 1, Saragoussi D 1
1Lundbeck SAS, Issy-les-Moulineaux, France, 2Creativ-Ceutical, Paris, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Major depressive disorder is characterised by the presence of one
or more major depressive episodes. Up to one-third of patients do not adequately
respond to first-line therapies. In case of treatment failure, the most common strategy is to switch to another antidepressant drug (AD). However, patients may have
been exposed in prior episodes to one or more other ADs, which could impact
the efficacy of subsequent treatments. This study describes historical AD use in
depressed patients undergoing treatment switch. Methods: This retrospective longitudinal cohort study used a database of medical records from general practitioners located throughout the UK (CPRD). Adult patients with a depression diagnosis
undergoing an AD switch between 01/01/2012 and 30/06/2013 and with no diagnosis
of schizophrenia or bipolar disorder were included. Historical AD use was assessed
on all available prescriptions prior to switch and was grouped by treatment class
(SSRI, SNRI, TCA and others). Results: 11,611 patients were identified. Their mean
age was 44.5 years (SD= 16.18) and 66.7% were women. Prior to switch, patients used
2.65 different classes of ADs on average (SD= 1.89); at least two different classes of
ADs were prescribed for 64.8% of patients. Before the switch, SSRIs were the most
common (1.65/patient) followed by TCAs (0.51/patient), other ADs (0.31/patient)
and SNRIs (0.18/patient). Significant proportions of patients had previously been
prescribed several AD classes: 34.1% of patients received at least one SSRI and one
TCA, 24.0% at least one SNRI and one TCA, 15.0% at least one SSRI and one SNRI,
and 13.7% at least one TCA and one other AD prior to AD switch. Conclusions:
This analysis showed that for patients initiating an AD switch, historical use of ADs
was very common, and that a substantial proportion of patients had already been
prescribed several ADs, thereby reducing the treatment options for future switches.
PMH72
Treatment Patterns and Health Care Costs in Patients with
Depression Treated with Antidepressant only or Combined with
Benzodiazepine: Results From a Japanese Claims Database Analysis
Jamotte A 1, Clay E 1, Onishi Y 2, Aballéa S 1, Toumi M 3
K.K., Tokyo, Japan, 3University of Marseille,
Marseille, France
.
.
.
.
.
1Creativ-Ceutical, Paris, France, 2Sanofi
Objectives: To describe and compare treatment patterns and health care costs in
patients with depression initiating treatment with antidepressant (AD) (in monotherapy or in combination) and patients initiating AD treatment combined with
benzodiazepine (BZD) using claims database in Japan. Methods: Using data from
the Japan Medical Data Center (JMDC) database, a retrospective longitudinal cohort
study was conducted, including adults aged 18-65 years with a first prescription
of AD (index date) between January 2009 and September 2013, and diagnosed with
major depression around index date. Time to treatment discontinuation (gap of 90
days without AD treatment) and total costs at 6 and 12 months were estimated for
each group (AD vs. AD+BZD), and compared, with adjustment on potential confounders (gender, age, insurance status, index year and baseline costs) using Cox
proportional-hazards regression and log-linear regression models. Results: 7,723
patients were included (43.7% initiating treatment with AD+BZD and 56.3% initiating with AD). Mean age of the population was 36.5 years and 59.1% were males, with
no significant differences found between the groups (p= 0.14 and p= 0.39 respectively). The total health care costs at 6 months were significantly higher in AD+BZD
patients (¥176,946 vs. ¥151,992; p< 0.0001). After adjustment, AD+BZD treatment was
associated with higher costs at 6 months (+5.2%, IC95%: [+4.7 %; +5.8 %], p< 0.0001)
and at 12 months (+6.4%, IC95%: [+5.7%; +7.1%], p< 0.0001). Time to discontinuation
was longer for the AD+BZD group (HR= 0.758, p< 0.0001). Conclusions: A large
proportion of patients with depression were treated with AD+BZD at initiation, a
practice not recommended in Japanese guidelines. Patients treated with AD+BZD
tend to have higher costs than patients treated with AD. The combination with BZD
is associated with longer treatment duration and further analyses are recommended
to determine if this is related to improved persistence or longer time to remission.
PMH73
Level of Testing for Potential Medication-Related Co-Morbidities
for Patients Taking Antipsychotics
Rascati K L 1, Richards K M 2
1The University of Texas at Austin, College of Pharmacy, Austin, TX, USA, 2The University of
Texas at Austin, Austin, TX, USA
.
.
.
13 years (children) [22.7%], 13-17 years (adolescents) [17.3%], 18-40 years [30.0%], and
>40 years [30.0%]. The prevalence of HbA1c, FBS, and lipid panel testing significantly
differed among the groups overall, and increased with increasing age, for both FGAs
and SGAs. Conclusions: It is recommended that patients taking antipsychotics
be tested regularly for glucose and lipid changes. Only about one-third of patients
taking antipsychotic medications had a lipid panel test, and less than one-fifth had
an HbA1c or FBS test during the 12 months of analysis.
.
Objectives: Patients taking antipsychotics are at higher risk for other co-morbid
diseases, including metabolic-related conditions. The objective of this study was to
determine the level of testing for potential medication-related co-morbidities, looking
at rates of Hemoglobin A1c (HbA1c) and fasting blood sugar (FBS) tests for diabetes as
well as lipid panel tests for hyperlipidemia. Methods: Using Texas Medicaid claims
for 2012, a total of 135,757 patients filled at least one prescription for an antipsychotic
medication. Claims data on lab testing were extracted for these patients. Results:
Overall, 36.0% of patients taking antipsychotics received a lipid panel test, 18.7%
received an HbA1c test, and only 6.5% received a FBS test. Nine percent and 95.8% of
patients had claims for first- and second-generation antipsychotics (FGAs and SGAs),
respectively [some patients had both prescribed]. A total of 53.5% were male and 46.5%
were female. A larger proportion of patients taking FGAs had HbA1c, FBS, and lipid
panel tests compared to patients taking SGAs: 28.9% vs. 18.4% (HbA1c); 8.1% vs. 6.4%
(FBS); 49.8% vs. 35.6% (lipid panel). A larger proportion of females had HbA1c, FBS,
and lipid panel tests compared to males: 23.4% vs. 14.8% (HbA1c); 7.6% vs. 5.6% (FBS);
40.7% vs. 32.3% (lipid panel). In addition, patients were divided into four age groups: <
PMH74
Treatment Patterns and Health Care Costs in Patients with
Schizophrenia Initiating with First- or Second-Generation
Antipsychotic: Results from a Japanese Claims Database Analysis
Jamotte A 1, Clay E 1, Aballéa S 1, Onishi Y 2, Toumi M 3
K.K., Tokyo, Japan, 3University of Marseille,
Marseille, France
.
.
.
.
.
1Creativ-Ceutical, Paris, France, 2Sanofi
Objectives: To describe and compare treatment patterns and health care costs in
patients with schizophrenia initiating treatment with first-generation antipsychotic (s)
(FGA) and patients initiating treatment with second-generation antipsychotic (s)
(SGA) using claims database in Japan. Methods: Using data from the Japan Medical
Data Center (JMDC) database, a retrospective longitudinal cohort study was conducted, including adults aged 18-65 years with a first prescription of antipsychotic
(index date) between January 2009 and September 2013, and diagnosed with schizophrenia around index date. Time to treatment discontinuation (gap of 90 days
without antipsychotic treatment), time to switch, time to psychiatric hospitalisation
and total costs at 6 and 12 months were estimated for each group (FGA vs. SGA),
and compared, with adjustment on potential confounders (gender, age, insurance
status, index year and baseline costs) using Cox proportional-hazards regression
and log-linear regression models. Results: 2,615 patients were included (14% initiating treatment with FGA and 86% initiating with SGA). 55.0% were female, with
no significant difference between the groups (p= 0.22). FGA patients were older than
SGA patients (40.1 years vs. 34.1, p< 0.0001). The total health care costs at 6 months
were significantly higher in FGA patients (¥1,489,680 vs. ¥324,595; p< 0.0001). After
adjustment, FGA treatment was associated with higher costs at 6 months (+121%,
IC95%: [+93%; +152%], p< 0.0001), and at 12 months (+87%, IC95%: [+60%; +119%],
p< 0.0001). Time to discontinuation as well as time to hospitalisation were shorter
for the FGA group but did not reach significance (HR=1.146, p=0.09; HR=1.406, p=0.07
respectively). The probability of switching was higher in the FGA group (HR: 5.281,
p< 0.0001). Conclusions: A large proportion of patients with schizophrenia were
treated with SGA at initiation, consistently with previous studies conducted in
Japan. Patients treated with SGA tend to have longer treatment duration and lower
costs than patients treated with FGA.
Urinary/Kidney Disorders – Clinical Outcomes Studies
PUK1
Comparative Efficacy And Tolerability Of Solifenacin 5mg
Versus Oral Antimuscarinic Agents In Overactive Bladder
(Oab): A Systematic Literature Review (Slr) And Mixed Treatment
Comparison (Mtc)
Kelleher C 1, Aballea S 2, Maman K 3, Nazir J 4, Hakimi Z 5, Chambers C 4, Odeyemi I A 4
and St. Thomas’ NHS Foundation Trust, London, UK, 2Creativ-Ceutical, Paris, France,
Ceutical, Paris, France, 4Astellas Pharma Europe Ltd, Chertsey, UK, 5Astellas Pharma
Global Development, Leiden, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Guy’s
3Creativ
Objectives: To compare the efficacy and tolerability of oral first-line antimuscarinic agents recommended for the treatment of OAB. Methods: Literature
searches were undertaken to identify published randomised controlled trials
(2000–2012), which reported efficacy and/or tolerability in adults receiving pharmacological treatment for OAB. Bayesian MTC methodology was used to assess
changes from baseline in micturition frequency per 24h, urgency, incontinence,
and urge incontinence (UI). Safety outcomes included dry mouth, constipation, and
blurred vision. Results: Forty-one eligible trials involving 25,118 patients were
included in the MTC. Solifenacin 5mg was significantly more effective than darifenacin 7.5mg based on incontinence (mean difference [MD]= 0.531/day), fesoterodine
4mg based on micturition (MD= 0.374/day), and tolterodine 4mg based on micturition (MD= 0.387/day), urgency (MD= 0.434/day), incontinence (MD= 0.309/day), and
UI (MD= 0.416/day). However, the starting dose of solifenacin 5mg was significantly
less effective than solifenacin 10mg according to micturition (MD= –0.343/day), and
urgency (MD= –0.391/day). No other significant efficacy differences were reported.
Solifenacin 5mg had a significantly lower risk of dry mouth compared to oxybutynin
(intermediate-release) IR 9mg (odds ratio [OR]= 2.732) or 10mg (OR= 3.534), oxybutynin extended-release (ER) 10mg (OR= 1.714), tolterodine IR 4mg (OR= 1.763), and
solifenacin 10mg (OR= 2.470). Tolterodine ER 4mg (OR= 0.481) or IR 4mg (OR= 0.440),
oxybutynin IR 9mg (OR= 0.429) or ER 10mg (OR= 0.440), and fesoterodine 4mg
(OR= 0.463) were associated with a significantly lower risk of constipation than
solifenacin 5mg. Solifenacin 10mg was associated with a higher risk of constipation
(OR= 1.804) and blurred vision (OR= 1.730) than solifenacin 5mg. Conclusions:
This MTC suggests that the 5mg starting dose of solifenacin is more effective than
the 4mg starting dose of tolterodine in reducing symptoms of OAB; solifenacin 5mg
also has similar or better efficacy than the starting doses of other antimuscarinic
agents across the spectrum of symptoms analysed. The lower risk of dry mouth with
solifenacin 5mg may deliver improved treatment persistence.
PUK2
Comparative Effectiveness Of Automated Versus Continuous
Ambulatory Peritoneal Dialysis On Patients With End-Stage Renal
Disease In Taiwan
Tang C H , Sue Y M , Wu Y T , Huang S Y
Taipei Medical University, Taipei, Taiwan
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A467
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: Automated peritoneal dialysis (APD) has been increasingly used since
payment scheme was expanded to cover APD machine in addition to the continuous
ambulatory peritoneal dialysis (CAPD) in the benefit package of National Health
Insurance Program in May of 2008. This study aims to compare the health outcome
between patients who used APD and CAPD. Methods: The including criteria were
patients treated by APD or CAPD identified in National Health Insurance Research
Database (NHIRD) during 2001-2010. The excluding criteria were patients who were
treated by hemodialysis for more than 3 months before PD, or younger than 18
years old, or received kidney transplant before. The CAPD patients and APD patients
were identified and matched according to their propensity score predicted by age,
gender, comorbid conditions, Charlson Comorbid Index, medication history, and
premiums wages in the year of treatment initiation. There were 2,287 APD and
2,287 CAPD patients entered the final analysis. The Kaplan-Meier curve and the
Cox proportional hazard regression were performed to examine the differences
in mortality rate, technique failure rate and incident rate of peritonitis between
APD and CAPD. Results: There are significant differences in mortality rate (0.76%
vs. 0.65% per patient month, p= 0.02), in technique failure rate (1.07% vs. 0.87% per
patient month, p< 0.001), and in incidence rate of peritonitis (1.94% vs. 2.14% per
patient month, p< 0.01) between APD and CAPD cases. When compared with CAPD,
patients treated by APD posed higher risk in death and technique failure but no
difference in the incidence of the 1stperitonitis with hazard ratios of 1.18 (CIs: 1.031.34), 1.22 (CIs: 1.09-1.37) and 0.98 (CIs: 0.88-1.10), respectively. Conclusions: The
APD patients seemed to have higher mortality rate and technique failure rate than
CAPD patients, however, APD patients had lower incident rate of peritonitis than
CAPD patients in Taiwan.
PUK3
A Study To Assess Disease Progression To Esrd Within A Year In
Patients With Advanced Ckd
Kumar P , Nair M , Prabhu R , Bairy M
Manipal University, Manipal, India
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Aimed at determining the time period for the progression to ESRD and
also to find out the major risk factors for early progression to ESRD. Methods: A
retrospective cohort study was conducted in a tertiary care teaching hospital. The
data was collected from medical record dept. for the last two years (2012 and 2013)
in hospital. Demographic details and clinical parameters of ESRD patients with
major risk factors for early progression to ESRD were collected using the descriptive
statistics feature of SPSS v20.0. Results: A total of 240 patients were included in
the study. The mean age of the population was found to be 54.6±14.2 years. Majority
of the population were males (74.83%). Hypertension 67.1%, Diabetes 47.1% and
anemia 40.83% were the most prominent risk factors present in the study population. More than half of the population (72.5%) took more than a year to progress to
ESRD. Conclusions: The study revealed that males are at a higher risk of ESRD
with half of the study cohort consisted of elderly patients (above 50 years of age).
The study results concluded that hypertension is the most common risk factor for
ESRD followed by diabetes and anemia. Most of the CKD patients took more than
one year to progress to ESRD (72.5%). This information help physicians and patients
inform decisions regarding preparation for renal replacement therapy in patients
with advanced CKD.
PUK4
Be Cautious Of Triple Whammy!!!
.
.
PUK6
Analysis Of Budget Impact Of Anemia Correction In Russian Patients
With Chronic Kidney Disease
Ryazhenov V V , Gorokhova S G
I. M. Sechenov First Moscow State Medical University, Moscow, Russia
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To analyze budget impact of strategies of anemia correction with
different stimulators of erythropoiesis in patients with chronic kidney disease
(СКD). Methods: Pharmacoeconomic analysis included cost modelling for a new
strategy for patients with CKD and anemia that includes the use of continuous
erythropoietin receptor activator (CERA) compared with traditional darbepoetin alfa
(as described in ARCTOS study). The model included two stages: 1. Estimation of
costs in 18 week correction period (phase 1 study), and 2. estimation of costs and
effectiveness within 10 week period (phase 2 study). The costs were evaluated in
two groups of 100 people, the first with CERA and the second with darbepoetin alfa.
According to ARCTOS study, fewer patients treated with continuous erythropoietin
receptor activator (CERA) required transfusion procedures compared with darbepoetin
alfa (2.5% and 6.8%, respectively). The drugs in the study were to be administered
under medical supervision in a day hospital. The time horizon of the study was 28
weeks. Results: The costs of a phase 1 was 53 187.21 in CERA group and 104 528.88
RUB in darbepoetin alfa group. The costs were almost identical in the second phase.
The costs in darbepoetin alfa group were 2.7 times higher compared with CERA in
respect of blood transfusion and 2 times higher in respect of drug administration.
The cost of pharmacotherapy in CERA group was significantly lower than in group
of darbepoetin alfa. Total costs in CERA group were 1, 7 times lower than those for
darbepoetin alfa. Conclusions: The study demonstrates that administration of
CERA is the most economically effective strategy for the treatment of patients with
chronic kidney disease in Russia. It is associated with considerably lower costs compared to darbepoetin alfa.
PUK7
Budget Impact Evaluation Of Treatment With A Low Protein Diet
And Ketoanalogues Of Essential Aminoacids For Predialysis
Patients In Russian Federation
Serpik V G , Kulikov A
I.M. Sechenov First Moscow State Medical University, Moscow, Russia
.
Zulkifly H , Abdul Wahab M S , Shaharuddin S , Chiau Ming L , Mat Zaid H
Universiti Teknologi MARA, Selangor, Malaysia
.
to estimate associated direct health costs comparing the use of paracalcitol and
cinacalcet plus low dose vitamin D over a 5-years horizon and using the Italian
National Health System perspective. The model was developed using parameters
from literature and assumption discussed with clinicians. National tariffs and costs
from literature were used to value drug use, dialytic treatment, hospitalizations and
transplant. One-way sensitivity analyses for model inputs were conducted. Costs
and effects were discounted at 3% annum. Results: Considering 13.311 candidate
subjects for each treatment strategy, results from the model showed a decrease in
direct health care costs from 1.782.921.351 Euro to 1.622.357.209 Euro in favour of
paricalcitol over 5 years. Particularly, paricalcitol produced an overall saving in drug
costs for more than 51 millions Euro while the other direct health costs related to
dialysis, hospitalization and transplant were reduced by approximately 109 millions Euro. Conclusions: In light of the high economic burden of end stage renal
disease mainly associated with dialysis and transplant the use of paricalcitol for
the treatment of IPTS in these patients represents a valid alternative not only from
a clinical point of view but also from an economic point of view.
.
.
.
Objectives: This study was aimed to identify the occurrence of concomitant prescribing of NSAIDs, ACE Inhibitors (ACEI) and diuretics known as triple whammy
received by out-patients at a Malaysian teaching hospital. It also aimed to identify the
relationship between prescriptions of triple whammy with specific age. Methods:
A retrospective, observational study was performed in a general teaching hospital.
The patients’ prescriptions (January-March 2012) from the outpatient pharmacy
department that were prescribed with NSAIDs, ACE Inhibitors (ACEI) and diuretics
were reviewed and recorded. The association between the prescriptions with age was
investigated. Statistical analysis was done using SPSS with significance difference
determined by p value of < 0.05. Results: Four hundred and twenty four patients
(56.1% male) were included. Four hundred and twenty two patients were taking one or
more of NSAIDs, ACEI and diuretic and only 2 patients were taking all three. Majority
of our patients (40.1%) received the combination of ACEI and diuretics. Combination
of ACEI and diuretics were mainly (21.7%) prescribed to patients above 65 years old
(p=0.362). Conclusions: The occurrence of triple whammy at a teaching hospital
during the period of data collection is low. This is indeed a good predictor of safe prescribing of drugs among physicians as concomitant use of these three medications
may impair renal function especially in the elderly and dehydrated patients. Majority
of the patients that were prescribed with combination of diuretics and ACEI are above
65 years old, therefore proper monitoring of their renal function and the hydration
status should be performed to reduce the risk of renal insufficiency in the future.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate budget impact of low protein diet (LPD) and ketoanalogues supply of predialysis patients in Russian Federation from Pharmacoeconomic
perspective. Methods: Analytic decision-making model and budget impact
analyses (BIA) were performed. Direct costs (ketoanalogues, hemodialysis, peritoneal dialysis, etc.) were considered. Two patients groups were compared in the
model: ketoanalogues and LPD was administrated for the first arm in predialysis
stage, while second arm started in the model of dialysis patients. Results of retrospective efficacy analysis state, that administration of keto-analogues and LPD
delays start of dialysis at least for one year. The following prices were used: rates of
State medical insurance fund, Sechenov First Moscow State Medical University hospitals price lists, NHS medication prices. Exchange rate: 1EURO = 40 RUB. Results:
The first year annual costs were 23186 EURO per patient for the patients group on
dialysis and 8620 EURO for the group of ketoanalogues. The results of BIA have
shown that administration of ketoanalogues and LPD provides cost-saving of 14562
EURO per patient in the first year compared with dialysis group. Total cost-saving per
patient in the group of ketoanalogues and LPD over 5-year period was 12895 EURO
compared with the dialysis group. Conclusions: Budget impact assessment has
shown, that ketoanalogues and LPD in Russian Federation is a preferable technology
and provides cost-saving of 12895 EURO over five years per patient.
PUK8
An Economic Model To Investigate The Budget Impact In Spain Of
Onabotulinumtoxina To Manage Urinary Incontinence In Patients
With Idiopathic Overactive Bladder
Ruff L 1, Zeidman R 1, Aracil J 2, Loveman C 3
Group, London, UK, 2Allergan S.A.U., Madrid, Spain, 3Allergan Holdings Ltd.,
Marlow, UK
.
.
.
.
Urinary/Kidney Disorders – Cost Studies
1Medaxial
PUK5
A Budget Impact Analysis (Bia) Of The Use Of Paricalcitol For The
Treatment Of Secondary Hyperparathyroidism (Shpt) In End Stage
Renal Disease Patients
Objectives: Treatment options for patients for whom urinary incontinence (UI)
due to idiopathic overactive bladder (OAB) is inadequately managed by anticholinergic therapy are limited, and can be expensive, invasive and inefficacious. This
can lead to a significant economic burden to hospitals and health care systems.
OnabotulinumtoxinA may provide an effective and minimally-invasive treatment
option for OAB. An economic model was developed to investigate potential cost
savings associated with the use of OnabotulinumtoxinA – as an adjunct to bestsupportive care (BSC) – to manage OAB rather than other treatment options in
Spain. Methods: A prevalence-based, deterministic budget impact model with a
five-year time horizon was developed from the perspective of the Spanish health care
Lorenzoni V , Pierotti F , Turchetti G
Scuola Superiore Sant’Anna, Pisa, Italy
.
.
.
Objectives: Budget impact analysis (BIA) of the use of paricalcitol versus alternative treatment for the management of secondary hyperparathyroidism (SHPT) in
end stage renal disease patients. Methods: A Markov model was used to simulate
the evolution of end stage renal disease patients trough transplant and death and
A468
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
system. The model took into account the cost of drugs, disposables (e. g. incontinence
pads) and devices, procedures, monitoring costs, and the cost of managing adverse
events. Model input data were derived from the Spanish Ministry of Health, published
and unpublished clinical studies, clinical guidelines, and expert opinion. Results: In
the Spanish population, an estimated 96,360 individuals were eligible for treatment
with OnabotulinumtoxinA for OAB. Compared to a current treatment pattern in which
5% of patients received OnabotulinumtoxinA, increasing OnabotulinumtoxinA usage
annually from 10% in year 1 to 30% in year 5 resulted in an estimated cost saving of
€26.4 million over five years. This saving represented a 4.7% decrease in overall spending compared to the current treatment pattern. Increased drug acquisition costs were
entirely offset by savings due to decreased use of incontinence pads and anticholinergic therapy. Conclusions: Costs associated with inadequate management of UI due
to OAB are significant and avoidable. Our model estimated that managing patients
with OnabotulinumtoxinA may reduce the economic burden to the Spanish health
care system, with increased acquisition costs of OnabotulinumtoxinA completely
offset by savings due to decreased resource use.
PUK10
The Impact Of Cardiovascular Disease And Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus
On Social Cost In Chronic Kidney Disease Patients In Italy
Bellelli S , Turchetti G
Scuola Superiore Sant’Anna, Pisa, Italy
.
.
Objectives: Chronic kidney disease (CKD) is leading condition of several comorbidities with additional social economic burden. The study aims to estimate the economic
impact of cardiovascular disease (CVD) and type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) on the
social cost of a patient with CKD (stage IV and V pre-dialyses) in Italy. Methods: All
adult outpatients in charge of 14 main Hospitals Centers in Tuscany Region have been
enrolled during 7 week in the cross sectional study. Direct medical costs have been
estimated using tariff for laboratory test, diagnostic exams, visits and hospitalization
and price for drugs. Non medical costs included the cost of diet, patients and caregivers travel expenses, domestic help and informal care. The loss of productivity of
patients and caregivers have been estimated as indirect costs using the human capital
approach. The incremental effects of having comorbidities on social cost of CKD were
estimated by multivariate Generalized Linear Models (log link, Gamma family) adjusting for gender, age and stage of CKD. Costs are expressed in Euro 2012. Results:
Among 484 CKD patients enrolled, CVD and T2DM have been found respectively in
214 (44%) and 171 (35%) patients. The raw estimated mean annual social costs were
€11,375 (± €7,480) per patient with CKD-CVD and €11,627 (± €7,657) per patient with
CKD-T2DM. Direct non medical costs and indirect costs accounted respectively for
31% and 23% of social cost for CKD-CVD and 30% and 22% for CKD-T2DM. The incremental effects of having comorbidities on the overall social cost of CKD were € 2,928
(95% CI: € 1,680-€4,176, p=0.000) for CVD and € 2,640 (95% CI: € 1,301-€3,979, p=0.000)
for T2DM. Conclusions: CVD and T2DM significantly increase the social cost of
CKD due to the rise of the medical component. However the burden of the disease is
mainly sustained by patients, their families and the productivity system.
PUK11
The Economic Cost Of Urinary Tract Infections In The Community:
Results From Ireland
Callan A , O’Shea E , Galvin S , Duane S , Corry O , SIMPle Team T , Vellinga A
NUI Galway, Galway, Ireland
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Urinary tract infections (UTIs) are the second most common bacterial
infection in primary care and are often treated empirically with antibiotics. However,
outside of the United States, there has been a lack of systematic cost-of-illness studies to assess the economic cost of UTIs in the community. The objective of this study
was to estimate the economic cost of UTIs in Ireland from the perspective of the
health service. Methods: We conducted a secondary analysis of a dataset which
contained information on adult patients (excluding pregnant women) presenting to
their General Practitioner (GP) with a suspected UTI. Data was collected from 22 GP
practices in the West of Ireland over a 9 month period from September 2009 to May
2010. Results from microbiological analysis to determine a positive urine culture
were obtained from the University Hospital Galway laboratory. Health care costs were
estimated on the basis of GP consultation costs, antibiotic costs, laboratory costs and
secondary inpatient and outpatient costs. The latter was acquired from national clinical data on discharges in acute hospitals. Results: Of the 2,850 GP consultations,
almost 70% of the urine samples showed no laboratory evidence of a UTI. 57% of
the patients were prescribed an antibiotic and 11% of patients re-consulted within
one month. Total primary care costs (including antibiotics) to treat suspected UTIs
across the 22 practices was approximately €343,000 annually. Extrapolating results
to a national level, the annual estimated primary care costs are approximately
€ 19.2 million. The annual cost of UTIs in secondary care is low at approximately
€155,000. Conclusions: Suspected UTIs are a common reason to attend primary
care services in Ireland. From the health service perspective, the overall economic
cost of UTIs is mainly driven by primary care costs with comparatively low secondary care costs.
PUK12
A Review Of Cost Of Illness Studies In Patients With End Stage Renal
Disease
bases (MEDLINE, EMBASE, SCIENCE CITATION INDEX, NHSEED, HEED, CEA REGISTRY,
RePEc, HTA database) for manuscripts published between January 2003 and November
2013. Results were assessed for relevance by two reviewers. For eligible studies, data
extracted included objectives, costing methodology, sources of data, disaggregated
and aggregated costs, and conclusions. Results: Of 2094 de-duplicated references
identified from the combined search, 57 manuscripts remained after review of titles/
abstracts and 40 after full-text review. The majority (n=35) of studies used retrospective data; the most common study country was the US (n=16); most studies (n=36)
reported direct costs only. There were four national level costing studies. Societal costs
for ESRD in Canada totalled $CAN 1.857 billion (2000); cost of RRT in England was £780
million (2009–2010); total public budgetary impact of Spain’s RRT programme was
€1,829 million (including indirect costs) in 2010; health costs of ESRD patients with
diabetes was $3,611 million in the US and £184.5 million in the UK in 2001. Annual perpatient ESRD health care costs ranged from $US 36,917 (PPP, 2004) in Australia, to $US
96,014 (2002) in US patients with diabetes. Studies also reported national and patient
level costs for transplant and dialysis. Conclusions: A number of COI studies have
quantified the cost of ESRD and demonstrate the substantial economic burden associated with the management of these patients.
PUK13
Cost-Utility And Value Of Information (Voi) Analyses On The
Feasibility Of A Future Randomised Controlled Trial (Rct) Of
Invasive Urodynamic Testing Prior To Surgery For Stress Urinary
Incontinence In Women
Homer T 1, Vale L 1, Shen J 1, Hilton P 2
University, Newcastle, UK, 2Newcastle upon Tyne Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust,
Newcastle, UK
.
.
.
.
1Newcastle
Objectives: To assess the feasibility and VOI of conducting a definitive RCT to determine whether invasive urodynamic testing (IUT) is cost-effective compared with
clinical assessment in women prior to surgery for stress (SUI) or stress predominant
mixed urinary incontinence (MUI) and to rehearse the economic evaluation for a
definitive RCT. Methods: Cost-utility analysis was performed alongside a pilot RCT.
222 participants were randomised to receive IUT (‘IUT’ arm) or clinical assessment
(‘no IUT’ arm) before surgery. Health service resource use, costs, utility values (from
EQ-5D-3L and SF-12) and quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) were calculated. Expected
value of sampling information (EVSI) analysis was used to determine the expected
net gain (ENG) of additional information and the optimal sample size needed to
maximise ENG in a future trial. Results: At 6 months the average cost incurred in
the ‘IUT’ arm was £154 less than the ‘no IUT’ arm (95% bootstrapped CI -315 to 24)
and there was no evidence of a difference in effects (-0.019 QALYs, 95% bootstrapped
CI -0.0258 to 0.0133). ‘IUT’ generated an incremental cost per QALY of £8090. A stochastic analysis showed that at a zero-willingness to pay threshold the IUT was 96%
likely to be cost-effective. The VOI analysis suggested there would be added value
from additional research to confirm which treatment is more efficient. The ENG was
estimated to be £91m and to maximise ENG a sample size of 105 complete cases in
each treatment arm is required. Conclusions: There was no significant difference
in QALYs between study arms, the ‘no IUT’ arm incurred a higher average cost but
only short-term NHS costs were considered. Our results should be interpreted with
caution due to the limitations within our analysis. The EVSI analysis confirmed that
there is additional value to be gained from a definitive study in this area.
PUK14
Cic Users’ Preference For Catheters Reducing The Uti Frequency
Neovius K E , Lundqvist T
Wellspect HealthCare, Göteborg, Sweden
.
.
.
Objectives: To investigate the preference among individuals practicing clean intermittent catheterization (CIC) on a daily basis for urinary catheters that can reduce
the frequency of urinary tract infections (UTIs). Methods: A questionnaire was
sent by e-mail to 769 catheter users from Germany, Italy, Sweden, the UK and the
USA through a database held by Wellspect HealthCare. The participants were asked
to assume a situation in which they use their current catheter but have the choice
to switch to a similar catheter, which hypothetically would reduce the frequency
of UTIs including possible complications. Either every fourth or every second UTI
could be avoided. The participants’ willingness-to-pay for the new catheter was
collected by letting them choose to spend either one of eleven explicit monthly
amounts from € 0-€ 100 or any other amount in an open answer. The participants
also reported their UTI frequency. Only individuals stating that they were “certain”
or “very certain” regarding their answers were included in the analyses. Results:
429 (response rate 56%) individuals returned the questionnaire, of which 278 (65%)
were certain or very certain regarding their answers. The proportion of respondents
with ≤ 1 UTI/y and > 1 UTI/y were 47% and 53%, respectively. The respondents were
willing to spend on average € 16 each month to avoid every fourth UTI and € 22 each
month to avoid every second UTI. The willingness-to-pay was higher among the
users with > 1 UTI/y both to avoid every fourth and every second UTI (€ 21 vs € 11 and
€ 30 vs € 15, respectively). These differences in willingness-to-pay were statistically
significant (p< 0.05).Conclusions: The CIC users in this study, who practice intermittent catheterization on a daily basis, expressed a clear preference for catheters
that could help to decrease the frequency of urinary tract infections (UTI).
Paczkowski R 1, Norrbacka K 2, Van Brunt K 3, Kennedy-Martin T 4
1Eli Lilly and Company, Inc., Indianapolis, IN, USA, 2Eli Lilly Finland, Helsinki, Finland, 3Eli Lilly
and Company, UK, Windlesham, Surrey, UK, 4Kennedy Martin Health Outcomes, East Sussex, UK
PUK15
Cost Consequence Analysis Of Darbepoetin Alfa For The Treatment
Of Anemia Due To Chronic Kidney Disease (Ckd) In Greece
Objectives: End-stage renal disease (ESRD) is a debilitating medical condition of
chronic kidney failure. In ESRD, the kidneys are permanently impaired and patients
require renal replacement therapy (RRT). In order to understand the economic burden of ESRD, this scoping literature review was undertaken to identify published
cost of illness (COI) studies in ESRD. Methods: The search strategy identified studies quantifying the economic burden of ESRD in selected countries (USA, Canada,
Australia, Japan, UK, France, Germany, Spain, and Italy). We searched electronic data-
Kourlaba G 1, Boletis I 2, Goumenos D 3, Iatrou C 4, Papagiannopoulou V 5, Tritaki G 5,
Maniadakis N 6
1Collaborative Center for Clinical Epidemiology and Outcomes Research (CLEO), Athens, Greece,
2Medical School of Athens, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens School of Medicine,
Athens, Greece, 3Nephrology and Renal Transplantation Department, Patras University Hospital,
Patras, Greece, 4General Hospital of Nikaia, Athens, Greece, 5AMGEN Hellas, Marousi, Greece,
6National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A469
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: Conduct an economic evaluation of darbepoetin alfa for the treatment
of anaemia due to chronic kidney disease (CKD) compared to other erythropoiesis
stimulating agents (ESAs) in patients on haemodialysis (HD) or peritoneal dialysis
(PD) in Greece. Methods: A decision tree model was developed to compare overall
costs per patient in control of darbepoetin alfa to other ESAs under different haemoglobin (Hb) concentrations and CKD patients. It estimates the economic impact
of treating CKD patients on dialysis with darbepoetin alfa, originator and biosimilar short-acting ESAs and pegylated epoetin beta to different Hb target strategies,
10 (±1) g/dL and 11 (±1) g/dL, over 1 year. The effectiveness of “% patients under
anaemia control” was defined as the number of patients being alive, not hospitalized, nor transfused during the analysis period. Clinical inputs depend on Hb target
strategy and not on ESAs as extracted from published studies. Cost inputs are drug
acquisition, administration and clinical event costs, the last comprising hospitalisation and blood transfusion costs (2014). Analysis was conducted from public
third-party-payer perspective. Results: For both Hb target strategies in patients
on HD or PD, darbepoetin alfa demonstrated the lowest overall costs per patient in
control followed by short-acting originator ESAs, whereas pegylated epoetin beta
and short-acting biosimilar ESAs showed the highest overall costs per patient in
control. As clinical event costs are identical across all ESAs, the overall costs per
patient in control are mainly affected by drug acquisition costs and by ESAs doses.
Treatment with darbepoetin alfa at Hb target 11 (±1) g/dL is associated with the
lowest overall costs per patient in control at € 8,210 and € 6,689, for patients on HD
or PD, respectively. Conclusions: Darbepoetin alfa may be the most cost saving treatment compared to other ESAs for the management of anaemia (CKD) in
patients on HD or PD in Greece.
PUK16
Cost Effectiveness Of Solifenacin Compared With Oral
Antimuscarinic Agents For The Treatment Of Patients With
Overactive Bladder (Oab) In The Uk
Kelleher C 1, Aballea S 2, Maman K 3, Nazir J 4, Hakimi Z 5, Chambers C 4, Odeyemi I A 4
and St. Thomas’ NHS Foundation Trust, London, UK, 2Creativ-Ceutical, Paris, France,
3Creativ Ceutical, Paris, France, 4Astellas Pharma Europe Ltd, Chertsey, UK, 5Astellas Pharma
Global Development, Leiden, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Guy’s
Objectives: To evaluate the cost effectiveness of solifenacin 5mg compared with
other oral antimuscarinic agents in adults with OAB from a UK NHS payer perspective. Methods: A Markov model was developed to model major symptoms of OAB
and the efficacy and tolerability of antimuscarinics. A 5-year time-horizon with
monthly cycles was used in the base case. Five levels of symptom severity were
used for micturitions and incontinence (total: 25 health states). Treatment with at
least two antimuscarinic agents was assumed before patients received botulinum
toxin. For each antimuscarinic, there was a probability of continuing or discontinuing medication, or switching to an alternative antimuscarinic with or without
adverse events. Efficacy and tolerability inputs were based on a phase 3 study of
solifenacin (Chapple et al. BJU Int 2004; 93: 303–10) and a mixed treatment comparison (results reported separately). Other model inputs were determined from the
literature or expert opinion. All costs were based on GBP 2012/2013. Utilities were
based on EuroQol-5D. Incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICER) were expressed
as cost/quality-adjusted life year (QALY). Deterministic (DSA) and probabilistic
(PSA) sensitivity analyses were performed. Results: Solifenacin 5mg was dominant versus tolterodine extended-release 4mg, darifenacin 7.5mg, fesoterodine 4mg
and solifenacin 10mg, and cost-effective versus darifenacin 15mg (ICER= £982.89/
QALY), fesoterodine 8mg (ICER= £232.53/QALY), oxybutynin extended-release 10mg
(ICER=£1117.32/QALY) and trospium 60mg (ICER=£3674.25/QALY). Both DSA and PSA
showed that results were robust at a willingness-to-pay threshold of £20,000/QALY.
At a cost-effectiveness threshold of £20,000/QALY, the probabilities that solifenacin 5mg was cost-effective versus comparators were: 95.4% (tolterodine extendedrelease 4mg), 92.1% (solifenacin 10mg), 97.3% (fesoterodine 4mg), 99.6% (fesoterodine
8mg), 99.4% (oxybutynin extended-release 10mg), 99.4% (darifenacin 7.5mg), 99.2%
(darifenacin 15mg), and 97.3% (trospium 60mg). Conclusions: Solifenacin 5mg
appears to be a cost-effective strategy compared with other oral antimuscarinic
agents for the treatment of adults with OAB from a UK NHS perspective.
PUK17
Cost-Effectiveness Of Mirabegron 50mg Compared To Tolterodine
Er 4mg In The Treatment Of Patients With Overactive Bladder In
Canada
Herschorn S 1, Vicente C 2, Nazir J 3, Ramos B 4, Hakimi Z 5
1University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada, 2PIVINA Consulting Inc., Mississauga, ON, Canada,
3Astellas Pharma Europe Ltd, Chertsey, UK, 4Astellas Pharma Canada, Inc, Markham, ON,
Canada, 5Astellas Pharma Global Development, Leiden, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Mirabegron, a β 3-adrenoceptor agonist approved for the treatment of
overactive bladder (OAB), has been shown to reduce OAB symptoms and improve
HRQoL relative to placebo and to cause a lower incidence of dry mouth than tolterodine. We investigated the cost-effectiveness of mirabegron 50mg compared to
tolterodine ER 4mg. Methods: A Markov model was developed to simulate management, symptom changes (micturitions, incontinence), and adverse events in OAB
patients. The model predicted costs and QALYs over 1 year in a hypothetical cohort
of Canadian patients previously treated for OAB. The analysis compared treatment
with mirabegron 50mg to tolterodine ER 4mg, administered in a reference arm in
the pivotal study SCORPIO and one of the antimuscarinic options most widely prescribed and funded in Canada for the treatment of OAB, from both a payer (Ontario
Ministry of Health and Long-term Care [MOH]) and societal perspective. Clinical and
health state utility data for the model were based on the previously treated OAB
population of SCORPIO. Transition probabilities between symptom severities were
obtained using multinomial logistic regression models estimated from SCORPIO.
Probabilities of discontinuation and switching therapy were derived from the literature. Resource utilisation estimates were based on clinical trial data, the literature
and expert opinion. Unit costs were derived from official schedules for Ontario and
published Canadian literature. Deterministic and probabilistic sensitivity analyses
were performed. Results: Mirabegron 50mg dominated tolterodine ER 4mg: incremental cost savings were CA$118.91 (MOH perspective) and CA$140.48 (societal); and
0.005 QALYs (MoH and societal) were gained. ICERs were robust over a wide range
of sensitivity analyses, but were most sensitive to micturition symptom levels for
tolterodine and to costs of subsequent therapy. Conclusions: Treatment with
mirabegron 50mg is cost-effective compared with tolterodine ER 4mg in a population
previously treated for OAB from Canadian health care and societal perspectives.
PUK18
Economic Evaluation Of Percent Free Psa For Prostate Cancer
Detection In Taiwanese Men
LAI A Y H
ESSEC Business School Asia Pacific, Singapore
.
.
.
Objectives: The prevalence of prostate cancer in the Chinese population with
abnormal prostate-specific antigen (PSA) levels of 4.0-10.0 ng/ml is low. The diagnosis can only rely on transrectal ultrasound-guided prostate biopsies (TRUS-Bx)
which may cause major complications. We assess the cost-effectiveness of two
diagnostic strategies for prostate cancer detection in Chinese men with abnormal
PSA levels of 4.0-10.0 ng/ml and normal digital rectal examination of prostate
(DRE). Methods: Using a decision tree model, we performed a cost-effectiveness
analysis to compare the two strategies: 1) direct prostate biopsies (TRUS-Bx) and
2) percent free PSA testing prior to TRUS-Bx. A systematic review of 855 patients
with PSA levels of 4.0-10.0 ng/ml and normal DRE enrolled in a single medical
institute from Jan 2002 to December 2005 was conducted. The outcome measures
were the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio, and costs were calculated through
activity-accumulation costing based on National Insurance Scheme Bill Size. A
one-way sensitivity analysis was undertaken. The effectiveness was measured by
means of the number of detected cases and actual cases (detected cases minus
lost cases). A threshold analysis is used to illustrate the value of a given variable
of which the two strategies have equal outcomes or costs. Results: The strategy of percent free PSA with TRUS-Bx was dominant and found to be the most
cost-effective. The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio for free PSA + TRUS-Bx
compared with TRUS-Bx was USD 3,871.58. Strategy 2 (TRUS-Bx) would be more
cost-effective if the cost of percent free PSA increased to USD 36.78 or if prostate
cancer prevalence increased to 42%. Conclusions: The use of percent free PSA
prior to TRUS-Bx is the most cost-effective diagnostic strategy and will become
more cost-effective as prostate cancer prevalence increases in the ageing population and the free PSA test costs down.
PUK19
Cost Effectiveness Of Extracorporeal Shock Wave Lithotripsy
Against Ureteroscopic Laser Lithotripsy For Treatment Of Ureteral
Calculi
Caballer V 1, Vivas D 1, Reyes F 2, Budia A 3
Politecnica de Valencia, Valencia, Spain, 2Universidad de Vigo, Vigo, Spain, 3Hospital
La Fe Valencia, Valencia, Spain
.
.
.
.
1Universitat
Objectives: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of extracorporeal lithotripsy against
ureteroscopic laser in the treatment of ureteral stones in the La Fe Hospital in
Valencia. Methods: A decision tree was performed to evaluate the costs and
effectiveness of two treatment strategies (starting with ESWL and second line URS,
versus directly start with URS). It was considered as a parameter of effectiveness,
the ratio of patient with stone-free status or the presence of insignificant residual
fragments (< 3 mm) at 3 month of follow up. Subsequently, to consolidate the results
of the decision tree, a sensitivity analysis of Monte Carlo with 1000 iterations was
developed. Were available from a database of 162 patients treated for ureteral stones
at the Hospital La Fe de Valencia. Of these, 77 were treated in lithotripsy sessions
(27 % of whom had upper stones 1 cm), while 85 were referred directly to URS (the
percentage of these patients with upper stones centimeter was 32.4 %). The unit
cost of each treatment was calculated from data provided by the economic management Department of Hospital La Fe and were 286.06 for each session in the case of
ESWL and 1409.89 for URS. Results: The overall effectiveness after four sessions
of lithotripsy plus second line URS was 99,76%, while in the case of URS was 98.81%.
The average cost of ESWL plus URS alternative was 881.59 euros, while in the case
of the strategy of starting with URS was 1,496 euros. Therefore, the ESWL plus URS
showed dominant versus first line URS. For both group upper and less than 1 cm also
ESWL plus URS was dominant. Conclusions: Thus, the combination of first line
lithotripsy plus second line ureteroscopic laser is better than first line ureteroscopic
laser for treatment of ureteral calculi in terms of in terms of cost effectiveness.
PUK20
Cost-Effectiveness Of Mycophelonate Sodium On Patients With
Renal Transplant At The Public Mexican Health Care System
Ruiz Miranda C I , Ubiarco Lopez V
Novartis Mexico, Mexico, Mexico
.
.
.
Objectives: To perform a cost-effectiveness analysis of Mycophenolate Sodium
(MPS) vs Mycophenolate Mofetil (MMF) with empirical treatment of rejection, both
options available at IMSS*. Methods: A Decision Model was designed to analyze
effectiveness and treatment cost of MPS and MMF for renal transplant patients.
The outcome was renal graft survival related to gastrointestinal tolerance in the
first year. The model starts with a renal transplant performed, in a period of three
months the patient may experience gastric intolerance or tolerance. For the patients
showing gastric intolerance, there are two alternatives: switching to azathioprine
or reducing the dose of mycophenolates (MPS or MMF). Then, the patient moves to
the next state which may be rejection (humoral or cellular) or not. The absorbent
state is the graft losses which include the cost of the intervention of renal transplant plus the cost of replacement therapy: Ambulatory Peritoneal Dialysis (APD),
Intermittent Peritoneal Mechanical Dialysis (IPMED), Intermittent Peritoneal Manual
Dialysis (IPMAD) and Hemodialysis. A probabilistic sensitivity analysis (PSA) was
A470
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
performed using Monte Carlo technique. Results: Annual patient costs of MMF
were: $7,746.75, $7,993.03, $7,694.19 and $7,939.14 USD. For MPS were: $7,673.35,
$7,989.92, $7,605.80 and $7,920.64 USD with an incremental efficacy of 0.07 less graft
rejection in APD, IPMED, IPMAD and hemodialysis respectively in one year horizon.
PSA shows consistency on model results. Conclusions: MPS was a dominant
alternative having lower costs and more effectiveness than MMF. These results
show possibilities to achieve cost-savings and a potential clinical benefit in renal
transplants, from the perspective of the Mexican public health system, in specific
from IMSS. *IMSS (Mexican Institute of Social Security)
PUK21
A Cost-Effectiveness Analysis Of Onabotulinumtoxina VersUS
Best Supportive Care (bsc) For The Treatment Of Anticholinergic
Treatment-Refractory Neurogenic Detrusor Overactivity (ndo)
Hamid R 1, Loveman C 2, Millen J 2, Colayco D 3, Stanisic S 4, Gultyaev D5
1Department of NeuroUrology, Royal National Orthopaedic Hospital & University College Hospital,
London, UK, Stanmore, UK, 2Allergan Holdings Ltd., Marlow, UK, 3Allergan, Inc., Irvine, CA, USA,
4The LASER Group, Milano, Italy, 5The LASER Group, Loerrach, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Uncontrolled NDO may lead to medical sequelae, such as upper
urinary tract complications and renal failure. Treatment choices include BSC
(comprised of behavioural therapy and pads, alone or in combination with clean
intermittent catheterisation, and possibly with anticholinergics), onabotulinumtoxinA, and surgery. The study’s objective was to determine the cost-effectiveness
of onabotulinumtoxinA 200 U vs. BSC among patients inadequately managed with
anticholinergics in a UK setting. Methods: A Markov model was developed to
compare onabotulinumtoxinA + BSC to BSC alone, with surgery as a downstream
option. Efficacy and safety inputs were based on Phase 3 trials. Utility values were
derived from a UK preference elicitation study. Costs were obtained from various
NHS sources. Model uncertainty was examined through deterministic and probabilistic sensitivity analyses. Results: The base case incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) was £3,856, with an incremental cost of £1,692 and incremental
benefits of 0.4387 quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs) for onabotulinumtoxinA
+ BSC compared with BSC alone over 5 years. A lifetime horizon yielded an
ICER of £2,739 per QALY. Univariate sensitivity analyses indicated that the main
cost drivers are mean monthly use of catheters and treatment administration
costs. Probabilistic sensitivity analysis suggested there would be 100% probability
of the ICER being ≤ £10,000. Conclusions: Our analysis suggests that onabotulinumtoxinA + BSC is a cost-effective treatment option, compared with BSC alone
for patients with NDO who are inadequately managed with anticholinergics in
the UK.
PUK22
Cost-Effectiveness Comparison Of Botulinum Toxin Type A Plus
Best Supportive Care Versus Best Supportive Care Alone In The
Treatment Of Idiopathic Overactive Bladder With Urinary
Incontinence Among Patients Not Adequately Managed By
Anticholinergic Therapy In France
Ruffion A 1, Velard M 2, Loveman C 3, Khalaf K 4, Roze S 5, Pignata M 5, Stanisic S 6, Lister J 7
Hospitalier Lyon Sud, Pierre Bénite, France, 2Allergan France SAS, Courbevoie, France,
3Allergan Holdings Ltd., Marlow, UK, 4Allergan, Inc, Irvine, CA, USA, 5HEVA HEOR, Lyon, France,
6The LASER Group, Milano, Italy, 7Laser Analytica, Loerrach, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Centre
Objectives: To assess the cost-effectiveness of botulinum toxin type A (BTXA;
BOTOX®) 100 U in the treatment of idiopathic overactive bladder (OAB) with urinary
incontinence (UI) among patients inadequately managed by anticholinergic therapy
in France. Methods: A 10 year Markov model divided into 3-month cycles was
developed to predict the long-term costs and health outcomes of BTXA + best supportive care (BSC; comprising behavioural therapy, incontinence pads, continued
anticholinergic therapy for some patients and, occasionally, catheters) versus BSC
alone from a societal perspective (excluding productivity loss) in France. Health
states were determined by daily number of UI episodes. Patients discontinuing BTXA
and a proportion of patients receiving BSC alone were eligible to receive downstream
sacral nerve stimulation (SNS). Costs and health outcomes were discounted at 4%
annually. The modelled cohort comprised patients from two phase 3 clinical trials of
BTXA and a long-term extension study. Literature, published guidelines and expert
advice informed all other model assumptions. Incontinence Quality of Life (I-QOL)
data from the trials were mapped to 5-dimension EuroQol questionnaire (EQ-5D)
utility values using a published algorithm. Sensitivity analyses assessed the impact
of varying model parameters as well as providing a direct comparison between BTXA
+ BSC and SNS. Results: BTXA + BSC was economically dominant compared with
BSC alone in the base case (quality-adjusted life-year [QALY] gain: +0.198; cost difference: –€1937). BTXA + BSC was also economically dominant when compared directly
with SNS (QALY gain: +0.143; cost difference: –€ 8973). Probabilistic sensitivity analysis indicated that the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio has approximately a 90%
likelihood of being below €20 000 per QALY gained. Conclusions: In France, BTXA
+ BSC is economically dominant over BSC alone for patients with OAB, symptoms
of UI and an inadequate response to anticholinergic therapy.
PUK23
Early Versus Late Ketoanalogs Supplementation In Patients With
Chronic Kidney Disease In Taiwan – A Cost-Effectiveness Analysis
You J 1, Ming W 1, Lin W 2, Tarn Y H 2
1The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Shatin, Hong Kong, 2Taiwan Pharmacist Association,
Taipei, Taiwan
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In Taiwan, chronic kidney disease (CKD) patients with estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) < 15 mL/min/1.73m2 are suggested to be managed with
low-protein diet (LPD) (≤0.6 g/kg/day) plus ketoanalogs (KA) supplement. Recent clinical findings showed early KA initiation with LPD at eGFR 15-29 mL/min/1.73m2 would
significantly slow down eGFR decline. We compared cost-effectiveness of KA initiation
at eGFR 15-29 mL/min/1.73m2 versus eGFR <15 mL/min/1.73m2 in CKD patients on
LPD from Taiwan health care payer’s perspective. Methods: A Markov was designed
to simulate outcomes of two options in a hypothetical cohort of adult CKD patients
with eGFR 15-29 mL/min/1.73m2: (1) Initiation of LPD plus KA, and (2) watchful-waiting
on LPD and initiation of KA at eGFR < 15 mL/min/1.73m2. The Markov states included
CKD stage 4 and 5, hemodialysis, and death. Total direct medical cost and qualityadjusted life-years (QALYs) gained were calculated over a maximum period of 10
years. Model inputs were derived from literature. Sensitivity analyses evaluated the
impact of uncertainty in all model variables. Results: In base-case analysis, early KA
initiation group (3.926 QALYs and USD548,191) gained higher QALYs and cost less than
the watchful-waiting group (3.787 QALYs and USD887,608) (USD1=NTD30). Sensitivity
analysis indicated that early KA initiation at eGFR at 17-29 mL/min/1.73m2 would
be the preferred cost-effective option if reduction of eGFR decline associated with
LPD plus KA was 4% or above. When KA was initiated at eGFR 15-17 mL/min/1.73m2,
it would remain cost-effective if the reduction of eGFR decline associated with LPD
plus KA was 13.5% or above. 10,000 Monte Carlo simulations showed early KA initiation group to be less costly with higher QALY gained than watchful-waiting group by
USD333,655 (95% CI 332,174-335,137) and 0.160 (95% CI 0.140-0.180) QALYs, respectively. Conclusions: KA Initiation with LPD in CKD patients as early as eGFR 15-29
mL/min/1.73m2 seems to be cost-effective in Taiwan.
PUK24
COST- MINIMIZATION ANALYSIS OF THE DIRECT COSTS OF SEVELAMER
CARBONATE AND LANTHANUM CARBONATE IN THE TREATMENT OF CKD-ND
PATIENTS
Petrov M K 1, Dimitrova M 2, Petrova G I 3
Bulgaria, Sofia, Bulgaria, 2Medical University of Sofia, Faculty of Pharmacy, Sofia,
Bulgaria, 3Medical University, Faculty of Pharmacy, Sofia, Bulgaria
.
.
.
.
.
1Sanofi
Objectives: Hyperphoshatemia or elevated phosphorus in the blood is prevalent
in patients with chronic kidney disease - mineral and bone disorder (CKD-MBD)
and independently and significantly contributes to morbidity and mortality. The
objective of this study is to perform cost - minimization analysis of the newly
available medicines sevelamer carbonate (SC) and lanthanum carbonate (LC), for
the treatment of hyperphosphatemia in CKD patients not on dialysis (CKD-ND) in
Bulgaria. Methods: The results of the head-to-head clinical trial conducted by
Spraque (2009) demonstrated equivalent efficacy and safety profiles between the
two treatment options. To differentiate the cost in high dose and low dose therapeutic regimes was performed a cost-minimization analysis. Based on that was
forecasted the expected cost savings for four years period. Discounting rate of 3.5%
was applied. The robustness of the Results was tested through sensitivity analysis
(SA) using Tornado diagram. Results: The estimated treatment cost per patient/
per year with SC and LC was 1441,75€ and 1569,50€ respectively at the low dose
regimen (4000 mg of SC vs. 2000 mg of LC), while within the high dose regimen (6400
mg of SC vs. 3000mg of LC) it was 2306,80€ and 2354,25€ respectively. Expected cost
savings (discounted) for the four years period within the assumed market shares
was between 1 348 794€ and 2 696 431€ at the low dose regimen, while at the high
dose regimen the estimated cost savings was between 501 593€ and 1 001 532€
respectively. The results of SA (discounted) show that the major cost drivers in the
treatment of hyperphosphatemia were the unit costs of SC and LC. Conclusions:
The equal efficacy and lower cost of sevelamer carbonate than lanthanum carbonate when used for treatment of hyperphosphatemia in patients with CKD -ND in
Bulgaria should made the sevelamer carbonate a preference alternative.
PUK25
A Spanish Cost-Effectiveness Analysis Of Sevelamer Versus Calcium
Carbonate In Nondialysis-Dependent Chronic Kidney Disease
(Ckd) Patients
Subirà R 1, Rubio M 1, Rodríguez-Carmona A 2, Pons R 3, del Pino M D 4
1Sanofi, Barcelona, Spain, 2Hospital Juan Canalejo, A Coruña, Spain, 3Servicio del Hospital de
Castellón, Castellon de la Plana, Spain, 4Hospital Torrecardenas de Almería, Almería, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In a 36-month, open label RCT that involved 213 patients in stage 3-4
nondialysis-dependent CKD (NDD-CKD) (INDEPENDENT study), sevelamer showed
lower rates of all-cause mortality and dialysis inception vs. calcium carbonate. The
aim of this study was to assess the cost-effectiveness of sevelamer vs. calcium carbonate in NDD-CKD patients with hyperphosphatemia in Spain. Methods: A
Spanish National Health System perspective and lifetime horizon was chosen for
the analysis. A Markov model was developed considering health states of “alive with
NDD-CKD”, “alive with dialysis-dependent CKD”, and “dead”). All-cause mortality, dialysis inception, hospitalization (frequency and length of stay [LOS]), and drug
dosage data were taken from the INDEPENDENT study. All-cause mortality and dialysis
inception were extrapolated beyond 36 months using Weibull regression analysis. Local
costs (euros, 2014) were applied to pharmaceutical, hospitalization and dialysis utilization. Health utility data was taken from the published literature. Costs and effects were
discounted at a rate of 3%. Results: In the base case analysis sevelamer was associated with increased survival, delay in dialysis inception, fewer hospitalizations, shorter
LOS, 2,12 life years gained (LYG) and 1,61 quality-adjusted life years gained (QALYG) vs.
calcium carbonate. Increased survival translated into more treatment time and dialysis
sessions vs. calcium carbonate, resulting in an incremental cost of 33.687 €. The incremental cost per LYG for sevelamer vs. calcium carbonate was 15.897 € and the incremental costs per QALY gained was 20.883 €. Sensitivity analysis showed that sevelamer was
more effective and less costly (i.e., dominant) vs. calcium carbonate in time horizons
< 6 years. Conclusions: The Spanish analysis showed that sevelamer is a cost-effective strategy vs. calcium carbonate for the treatment of hyperphosphatemia in patients
with NDD-CKD, with cost-effectiveness ratios well below the accepted thresholds of
30.000-45.000 €/QALY gained.
PUK26
Burden On Secondary Care Of Overactive Bladder Patients Who Are
Inadequately Managed With Anticholinergics In England
Hamid R 1, Loveman C 2, Morton R 3, Millen J 2, Hassan Y 4
.
.
.
.
.
A471
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
1Department of NeuroUrology, Royal National Orthopaedic Hospital & University College Hospital,
London, UK, Stanmore, UK, 2Allergan Holdings Ltd., Marlow, UK, 3Allergan Holdings Ltd, Marlow,
UK, 4HealthIQ, London, UK
Objectives: Anticholinergics drugs (ACHD) are an established first-line pharmacological therapy for overactive bladder (OAB). Despite the fact that many patients cycle
through multiple ACHD, there is limited evidence on the relationship between the burden on secondary (hospital) care and these patients whose OAB is inadequately managed with ACHD. The objective of this study was to analyse the variation in health care
burden in secondary care of patients who cycle through multiple ACHD. Methods: A
retrospective observational study was conducted to examine the relationship between
health care burden and number of prior ACHD with each ACHD switch. Data was
extracted from the Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) database and 3,059 GP practices
for patients with a diagnosis for OAB, or any of the symptoms of OAB (frequency,
urgency, incontinence or nocturia) and with at least one prescription for an ACHD
between April 2007 and March 2013. Treatment activity and cost burden (including
burden associated with comorbid conditions) were analysed following initiation of
the second and the third ACHD and compared to the same cohort from the point at
which they had received the first ACHD. All costs were calculated by applying national
health service (NHS) tariff prices to treatment activity. Results: Overall, the number
of patients identified was 13,117. Our analysis showed that there were increases of
70%, 40% and 10% in inpatient, outpatient and emergency settings respectively from
the initial ACHD prescription to 3+ ACHD. This led to an increase in overall health
care costs of 30% from the first to 3+ ACHD or £197 (£642 to £839) per patient over the
investigation period. Conclusions: OAB patients who are inadequately managed
with ACHD place an increased burden on hospital resources. These findings emphasize the importance of identifying alternative ways to treat these patients to address
the cumulative burden they place on health care systems.
Urinary/Kidney Disorders – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference
Studies
PUK27
Accept® Questionnaire: Relation Between Acceptance And
Compliance In Liver- And Kidney-Transplanted Patients Converted
To Once-Daily Tacrolimus
Bourhis Y 1, Chretin S 1, Cantarovich D 2, Gilet H 1, Bugnard F 1, Arnould B 1
NANTES, Nantes Cedex 1, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Mapi, Lyon, France, 2CHU
Objectives: ACCEPT® is a 32-items self-administered questionnaire recently validated to measure patient acceptance to treatment. Acceptance was defined as the
balance between treatment advantages and disadvantages as rated by the patient and
may help predict adherence. The objective was to evaluate the relation between early
Acceptance and Compliance in liver- and kidney-transplanted patients converted
to once-daily tacrolimus (TAC-OD). Methods: 6-month observational, prospective,
longitudinal, multicenter study conducted by 23 hepatologists and 56 nephrologists
in France. 1106 adult patients with kidney and/or liver transplant, initiating TAC-OD
during post-transplant follow-up were included. Acceptance and compliance were
assessed 3 and 6 months after TAC-OD initiation using ACCEPT® and Compliance
Evaluation Test questionnaires. Results: Data from 271 liver-, 824 kidney- and 11
liver+kidney-transplanted patients were analyzed. Mean age was 52.4 (±13.2) years.
61.5% of patients were male. Mean time between graft and TAC-OD initiation was
5.0 (±4.9) years. Mean general acceptance score (range: 0-100) at month 3 was 75.4
(±26.5). At month 6, 25.5% of patients had good treatment compliance, 68.0% minor
non-compliance and 6.5% were non-compliant. Higher general acceptance score
at month 3 was significantly associated with better compliance at month 6 (good
compliance: 85.2±20.7, minor non-compliance: 74.5±26.7, non-compliant: 68.0±29.6,
p< 0.001). 3-month general acceptance score was particularly low in patients who
specified at month 6 having ‘omitted to take their treatment this morning’ (N=4,
mean: 41.7±44.1) or ‘ever forgotten to take their treatment because their memory was
failing’ (N=53, mean: 69.5±29.7). Although not significant, the 17 patients who discontinued TAC-OD before 6 months had lower 3-month mean general acceptance score
(64.6±36.5 vs. 75.7±25.9 in patients still treated with TAC-OD). Conclusions: This
study highlighted a strong association between early Acceptance and late Compliance
to TAC-OD. Further investigations are needed to explore how early detection of low
acceptance can help patient management and improve long-term outcomes.
PUK28
Persistence And Adherence With Mirabegron, A New Beta-3 Receptor
Agonist, Versus Antimuscarinics In Overactive Bladder: Early
Experience In Canada
Wagg A 1, Franks B 2, Ramos B 3, Berner T 2
of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada, 2Astellas Scientific and Medical Affairs, Inc.,
Northbrook, IL, USA, 3Astellas Pharma Canada, Inc, Markham, ON, Canada
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: To compare persistence and adherence with mirabegron versus antimuscarinic treatment for overactive bladder (OAB). Methods: This was an exploratory analysis of retrospective claims data from the largest Private Drug Plan database
in Canada. Patients aged ≥18y who had a first prescription claim for a target medication during a four-month index period in 2013 were identified. A six-month look-back
was used to categorize patients as ‘treatment-naïve’ (no claims for OAB medication)
or ‘treatment-experienced’ (≥ 1 prior medication) during this time. Time to end of
persistence (defined by a maximum gap in therapy of 30 days or switching to another
medication) and adherence (calculated by medication possession ratio) were analyzed
after six months. Hazard ratios (HR) with 95% confidence intervals (CI) were calculated
for mirabegron versus each antimuscarinic, using Cox proportional hazards modeling. Results: Data were analyzed for 13,391 patients (mirabegron, n=993). In the
treatment-experienced cohort, six-month persistence was highest with mirabegron
(51%), followed by solifenacin (39%) (HR 1.383; CI: 1.109−1.726; p=0.004), ranging to 18%
with oxybutynin IR (HR 2.488; CI: 1.961−3.157; p<0.001). In the treatment-naïve cohort,
persistence was also highest with mirabegron (40%), followed by fesoterodine (24%)
(HR 1.512; CI: 1.333−1.716; p< 0.001), ranging to 13% with oxybutynin IR (HR 2.315; CI:
2.093−2.561; p<0.001). Median number of days on therapy with mirabegron was 183
(treatment-experienced) and 129 (treatment-naïve), compared with 67−120 and 34−90
days with antimuscarinics, respectively. Mean adherence overall was 68% with mirabegron vs 39−55% with antimuscarinics (each p<0.05 vs mirabegron). Conclusions:
Patients treated with mirabegron had improved persistence and adherence over antimuscarinics. While differences in patient characteristics among the OAB drugs were
accounted for within the model, results should be viewed in the light of the likely
characteristics of patients started on any new medication to the market; hence this
sample may not be reflective of more mature usage.
PUK29
Treatment Discontinuation In Patients With Urinary Incontinence
Suffering From Glaucoma
Kostev K 1, Rex J 1, Engelhard J 1, Altmann V 1, Ehlken B 2, Rockel T 1, Kalder M 3
1IMS Health, Frankfurt am Main, Germany, 2IMS Health Germany, Munich, Germany, 3University
Hospital of Gießen and Marburg, Marburg, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The frequency of side effects in the treatment with anticholinergic
drugs are well described in a number of previous studies. However, little is known
about the impact of side effects on therapy discontinuation. The aim of the present study was to estimate the frequency of glaucoma in association with urinary
incontinence therapy begin and the impact of glaucoma diagnosis on the therapy
discontinuation based on real life data. Methods: Data from Disease Analyzer
database including 988 general, 95 urologist and 203 gynecologist practices were
used. 26,834 patients (17,125 female and 9,709 male) were identified to have received
a first-time anticholinergic prescription of UI, namely darifenacin, fesoterodine,
oxybutynin, propiverine, solifenacin, tolterodine or trospium. Co-variates studied
included demographic data, concomitant diagnoses and potential drug-induced
side-effects. Glaucoma (H40) was defined as strict indication for the use of anticholinergic drugs. A Cox proportional hazard regression model was used to estimate the
relationship between non-persistence and the diagnosis of glaucoma for up to 36
months. Results: The proportion of patients that were diagnosed with glaucoma
during the time of treatment was very similar in each of the study substances.
32 - 38 % of patients received a referral to an ophthalmologist and 0.3 - 1.2 % of
patients were first time diagnosed with glaucoma. Not surprisingly, there was a
highly increased risk for treatment discontinuation in patients having glaucoma
(HR: 1.46; p < 0.0001). Conclusions: Overall, the potential side effects including
the aggravation of diagnosed glaucoma that were registered in the database were
rarer than in clinical trials; most likely they were under-reported due to the nature
of the registry. However, there was a significant impact of glaucoma on therapy
discontinuation. This finding should be taken into account in clinical practice for
the use of anticholinergic drugs in patients suffering from glaucoma.
PUK30
Health-Related Quality Of Life (Hrqol) Of Asian Patients With EndStage Renal Disease (Esrd) In Singapore
Yang F 1, Griva K 2, Lau T 3, Vathsala A 3, Lee E 3, Ng H J 2, Mooppil N 4, Newman S P 5, Chia K S 1,
Luo N 1
1Saw Swee Hock School of Public Health, National University of Singapore, Singapore,
2Department of Psychology, Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences, National University of Singapore,
Singapore, 3Division of Nephrology, University Medicine Cluster, National University Health
System, Singapore, 4National Kidney Foundation, Singapore, 5City University London, London, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: This study aimed to assess the health-related quality of life (HRQOL)
of multiethnic Asian end-stage renal disease (ESRD) patients treated with dialysis and to identify factors associated with the HRQOL of those patients. The role
of dialysis modality was also explored. Methods: Data used in this study were
from two cross-sectional surveys of Singaporean ESRD patients on haemodialysis
[HD] or peritoneal dialysis [PD]. In both surveys, participants were assessed using
the Kidney Disease Quality of Life (KDQOL) instrument and questions assessing
socio-demographic characteristics. Clinical data including co-morbidities, albumin level, haemoglobin level, and dialysis-related variables (e. g. dialysis vintage
and dialysis adequacy) were retrieved from medical records. The 36-item KDQOL
(KDQOL-36) was used to generate three summary scores (physical component summary [PCS], mental component summary [MCS], kidney disease component summary [KDCS]) and two health utility scores (Short Form 6-Dimension [SF-6D] and
EuroQol 5-Dimension [EQ-5D]). Multivariate analysis was performed to examine the
association of demographic, social and clinical variables with each of the HRQOL
scores. Results: Five hundred and two patients were included in the study (HD:
236, PD: 266; mean age: 57.1 years; female: 47.6%). The mean (standard deviation
[SD]) were PCS 37.9 (9.7), MCS 46.4 (10.8) and KDCS 57.6 (18.1); the mean (SD) of the
health utility were 0.66 (0.12) for SF-6D and 0.60 (0.21) for EQ-5D. In multivariate
regression analysis, factors found to be significantly associated with better HRQOL
included: fewer co-morbidities, higher albumin level, and higher haemoglobin
level with PCS and EQ-5D; higher albumin level with SF-6D; longer dialysis vintage with MCS; and Malay ethnicity, PD modality, and longer dialysis vintage with
KDCS. Conclusions: Socio-demographic and clinical factors are both associated
with HRQOL in ESRD patients on dialysis in Singapore. Dialysis modality has no
impact on the health utility of those patients.
PUK31
Health-Related Quality Of Life And Subjective Happiness Of Patients
With Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia: First Results Of A CrossSectional Survey From Hungary
Rencz F 1, Kovács Á 1, Gulacsi L 1, Majoros A 2, Nyirády P 2, Tenke P 3, Németh Z 3, Nagy G J 4,
Nagy J 5, Buzogány I 6, Böszörményi-Nagy G 7, Brodszky V 1
1Corvinus University of Budapest, Budapest, Hungary, 2Semmelweis University, Budapest,
Hungary, 3Jahn Ferenc South-Pest Hospital and Clinic, Budapest, Hungary, 4Saint Borbala Hospital
of Tatabánya, Tatabánya, Hungary, 5Szentgotthárd Clinic, Szentgotthárd, Hungary, 6Péterfy
Sándor Hospital, Budapest, Hungary, 7Bajcsy-Zsilinszky Hospital, Budapest, Hungary
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A472
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: To assess health-related quality of life (HRQOL) and subjective happiness
of men with lower urinary tract symptoms associated with benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH/LUTS). Methods: In 2014 a multicenter cross-sectional questionnaire
survey was conducted in Hungary. Inclusion criteria were diagnosis of BPH/LUTS at
least 12 months before the study and patient had never been undergone any prostate
surgery. HRQOL was assessed indirectly by the EQ-5D and visual analogue scale (EQ
VAS) and directly by matching indifference time trade-off (TTO) where patients’ subjective life expectancy was applied as time frame. Subjective happiness was measured
on a 10-cm-long visual analogue scale. Results: In total 64 men completed the
questionnaire, mean age and disease duration were 70.8±8.8 years and 6.9±6.5 years,
respectively. At the time of the survey, 75% of the patients received alpha-blockers
(AB), 11% were treated by 5-alpha-reductase inhibitors (5ARI), and 11% by combination therapy (AB+5ARI). Median EQ-5D, EQ VAS, TTO and happiness scores were 0.85,
70, 0.73 and 6.5, respectively. Utilities assessed by EQ-5D were found significantly
higher compared to those elicited by TTO (p<0.001). Mean utilities decreased with
clinical severity measured with EQ-5D (mild: 0.90±0.1, moderate to severe: 0.79±0.2,
p= 0.046) whereas increased when assessed with TTO (mild: 0.46±0.3, moderate to
severe: 0.63±0.3, p=0.336). Patients with moderate to severe disease reported significantly lower happiness scores than those with mild disease (5.85±2.2 and 7.02±2.3,
p=0.044). Subjective happiness correlated moderately with EQ VAS (rs=0.64, p<0.001)
but only weakly with EQ-5D (rs=0.28, p=0.029). Conclusions: BPH/LUTS patients
experience notable reduction in their HRQOL and subjective happiness measured by
any of the applied outcome measures. Utilities for BPH/LUTS ranged from 0.46 to 0.90
depending on clinical severity and assessment method. Considerable discrepancy was
found between utilities elicited by EQ-5D and TTO that raises concerns about which
method is feasible to use for utility evaluation in BPH/LUTS.
PUK32
A Mixed Methods Approach (Mma) To Understanding Men’s Attitudes
Toward The Management Of Lower Urinary Tract Symptoms (Luts)
Associated With Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia (Bph)
Ikenwilo D 1, Watson V 1, Heidenreich S 1, Chambers C 2, Newman C 2, Nazir J 2, Ryan M 1
1Health Economics Research Unit, University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen, UK, 2Astellas Pharma Europe
Ltd, Chertsey, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To understand men’s attitudes, preferences and values for LUTS/BPH
management and its impact on quality of life (QoL) using a MMA. Methods: The
innovative MMA approach combined qualitative (online discussion groups [ODG])
and quantitative methods (discrete choice experiment [DCE]). ODGs and a selfadministered online DCE survey were conducted with men in the UK aged ≥ 45
years with an International Prostate Symptom Score (IPSS) ≥ 8. A series of five asynchronous ODGs (or bulletin boards) were live for 5 days (moderated by the research
team). The ODGs collected information about men’s experiences of LUTS/BPH and
its impact on their QoL; data were analysed using an inductive thematic analysis.
A literature review informed the ODG design, and both informed the DCE design.
The DCE survey elicited men’s preferences for LUTS/BPH medical management.
Please see a separate meeting abstract for more information on the DCE (Ikenwilo,
et al). Results: 48 men were invited to the ODGs; 22 participated and had a mean
age of 59.8 years and mean IPSS of 16.4 (standard deviation 7.1). The ODGs found that
LUTS/BPH affects how men organise their day at work and at home, and prevents
men from leading their preferred daily activities. Symptoms most adversely affecting QoL were urgency (especially urge incontinence) and day-time and night-time
urinary frequency. There appears to be a lack of awareness about LUTS amongst
the men: many had not discussed LUTS with their doctor, family or friends, and
were unaware that LUTS/BPH is treatable. The DCE informs that men are willing to
pay at least £23.95/month to improve urgency, and £29.70/month to avoid erectile
dysfunction. Conclusions: This is the first MMA to evaluate men’s preferences in
LUTS/BPH. The ODG and DCE results together expand our understanding of men’s
attitudes toward the management of LUTS/BPH.
PUK33
Prevalence Of Symptoms And Cluster Analysis In Dialysis Patients
Using Kdqol-36
Galain A I 1, Alvarez R 2, Dapueto J J 1, Varela A 1
1Facultad de Medicina, Universidad de la República, Uruguay, Montevideo, Uruguay, 2Facultad de
Ciencias Economicas, Universidad de la República, Uruguay, Montevideo, Uruguay
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: This study assessed the prevalence of symptoms, and symptom clusters
in a sample of dialysis patients in Uruguay. Methods: A longitudinal study aimed
to assess HRQL in hemo (HD) and peritoneal dialysis patients (PD) was conducted
in thirteen centers in Uruguay. Data of the first assessment was included here. The
12 items of the KDQOL-36 Symptom Subscale were analyzed for symptom prevalence. For cluster analyses the ICLUST procedure was followed, using an algorithm
to hierarchically cluster items to form composite scales. Alpha, the mean split half
correlation, and beta, the worst split half correlation, are estimates of the reliability and general factor saturation of the test. Clusters are combined if coefficients
increase in the new cluster. Results: Of a total of 751 patients, 486 accepted to
participate and completed the forms (64.7%), with mean age 60.5 years, SD: 15.5),
211 (43.4%) were women; 407 (83.7%) were HD, and 79 (16.3%) were PD patients.
Most prevalent symptoms were muscle sores (59.0%); cramps (57.5%); “washed out”
(50.9%), dry skin (48.5%), and itchy skin (43.8%). Five clusters of symptoms were
identified; “cutaneous” (itchy and dry skin, α .68), ”cardiac” (chest pain and shortness of breath, α .69), ”digestive” (nausea and lack of appetite, α .62), ”neurophatic”
(numbness and cramps, α .50), ”energy” (“washed out”, faintness, α .59). A second
block called “locomotive” included neuropathic plus muscle sores (α .64), and a third
of “neurological symptoms” included locomotive plus energy (α .70). Cutaneous
symptoms remained as a separated cluster. Cronbach alpha of the total Symptom
Scale was .93. Conclusions: Dialysis patients experience a high number of
symptoms. The study of clusters identified 5 groups of symptoms; cutaneous, cardiac,
neuropathic, digestive and lack of energy. More complex associations included neurological, digestive and cardiac complaints. The identification of symptom clusters
can help to understand common underlying pathways, and the use of drugs targeted
to associated symptoms.
PUK34
Men’s Preferences For The Treatment Of Lower Urinary Tract
Symptoms (Luts) Associated With Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia (Bph):
A Discrete Choice Experiment (Dce)
Ikenwilo D 1, Watson V 1, Ryan M 1, Heidenreich S 1, Newman C 2, Nazir J 2, Chambers C 2
1Health Economics Research Unit, University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen, UK, 2Astellas Pharma Europe
Ltd, Chertsey, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To quantify men’s preferences and willingness to pay for attributes
of medications to treat LUTS/BPH using a DCE. Methods: An online DCE was
conducted with men in the UK aged ≥ 45 years with a self-reported International
Prostate Symptom Score (IPSS) ≥ 8. Men were asked to consider different scenarios
associated with moderate-to-severe LUTS, and then choose between two medical
alternatives and a no-treatment option, according to seven attributes: day-time
urinary frequency, night-time urinary frequency, urgency, sexual and non-sexual
side effects, number of tablets/day and cost/month. These attributes were identified from a literature review and online discussion groups (ODGs). Men’s marginal
willingness to pay (MWTP) and 95% confidence intervals for improvements in each
attribute were calculated. Please see a separate meeting abstract for more information on the ODGs (Ikenwilo, et al). Results: The DCE survey was conducted 19–26
March 2014. 5212 individuals were invited to participate: 1097 opened the hyperlink,
586 were ineligible or excluded because the quota was full, and 247 completed the
final survey used for this analysis. The mean age was 62.3 years and the mean IPSS
was 15.7 (standard deviation 6.0). MWTP was £23.95/month and £25.42/month for
an improvement from urge incontinence to moderate urgency or mild urgency,
respectively; £5.80/month for one less night-time urination, and £1.30/month for
one less day-time urination. Sexual side effects reduced MWTP by £29.70/month
for erectile dysfunction, £18.37/month for “decreased sexual desire”, and £16.92/
month for “no fluid during ejaculation”. Non-sexual side effects reduced MWTP by
£17.25/month for dizziness and £16.75/month for headaches. Neither dry mouth nor
the number of tablets/day significantly affected MWTP.Conclusions: Improving
urgency is perceived as the most important benefit of medication to men with LUTS/
BPH; improving frequency is also valued. The perceived value of a medication is
reduced by sexual and non-sexual side effects.
Urinary/Kidney Disorders – Health Care Use & Policy Studies
PUK35
Incidence Of Unlicensed And Off-Label Prescription In Urologic
Cancers Therapy In Turkey: Assessment Of Legislative And
Regulatory Policy
Tanyeri M H 1, Kockaya G 2, Tanyeri P 3, Yenilmez F B 4, Buyukokuroglu M E 3, Vural I M 5,
Akbulat A 5, Artiran G 5, Kerman S 5
1Yenikent Governmet Hospital, Sakarya, Turkey, 2Health Economics and Policy Manager, Ankara,
Turkey, 3Sakarya University, Sakarya, Turkey, 4Hacettepe University, Ankara, Turkey, 5Turkish
Medicines and Medical Devices Agency, Ankara, Turkey
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: “Off-label” is defined by the Turkish Ministry of Health (MoH) as
the use of licensed pharmaceutical products in doses outside the scope of the
registered indication and the use of unlicensed medicinal products that are
imported for the purpose of individual treatment. Off-label use of medications is
extremely common especially in oncology. The aim of the study is to evaluate the
usage of off-label or unlicensed medicines in urologic cancers for understanding of Turkey’s perspective within this area of health care provisions. Methods:
This study involved patients (n= 105) with metastatic bladder CA who received
paklitaxel or other medicine application off-label, (n= 194) with metastatic renal
cell CA who received sorafenib, sunitinib or other medicine application off-label,
(n= 44) with metastatic testis cancer who received paklitaxel, gemsitabin or other
medicine application off-label in Turkey. A computer search was performed using
the TITCK’s (Turkish Drug and Medical Devices Institution) database. The patient
base was searched for off-label medicine applications between 1st May 2008 to
1st May 2011. Results: The data obtained from TITCK’s database showed that 86,
136, and 44 applications for off-label metastatic bladder CA medicine, metastatic
renal cell CA and metastatic testis CA medicine usage, respectively. Ninety five
(90.47%) of all off-label medicine usage applications for metastatic bladder CA, one
hundred twenty two (62.88%) for metastatic renal cell CA and thirty nine (88.63%)
for metastatic testis CA were approved. University hospitals were created the vast
majority of applications (79.89%) for metastatic bladder CA, (64.76%) for metastatic
bladder CA and (79.89%) for metastatic bladder CA. The most preferable off-label
drug medications for bladder CA, renal CA and testis CA were paklitaksel (84.04%),
sorafenib (68.42%) and paklitaksel (43.24%), respectively. Conclusions: Off-label
urology medicine use is rising in Turkey. If off-label use increasing parallel to the
off-label urology medicines, it is needed to define new pathways to evaluate the
applications.
Research Poster Presentations - Session Iii
Disease–Specific Studies
CARDIOVASCULAR DISORDERS – Clinical Outcomes Studies
PCV1
Readmittance To Hospital Within 6 Months After A Venous
Thromboembolism Event: Prefer In Vte Registry
Bauersachs R 1, Gitt A K 2, Mismetti P 3, Monreal M 4, Willich S N 5, Wolf W P 6, Agnelli G 7,
Cohen A T 8
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A473
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
1Max-Ratschow-Klinik für Angiologie, Gefäßzentrum Klinikum Darmstadt GmbH, Darmstadt,
Germany, 2Herzzentrum Ludwigshafen, Ludwigshafen, Germany, 3Centre Hospitalier
Universitaire Saint-Etienne, Hopital Nord, Saint Etienne, France, 4Hospital Universitari Germans
Trias I Pujol, Barcelona, Spain, 5Charité - Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Berlin, Germany, 6Daiichi
Sankyo Europe GmbH, Munich, Germany, 7University of Perugia, Santa Maria della Misericordia
Hospital, Perugia, Italy, 8King’s College, London, UK
Objectives: Data are limited on the course of patients after an acute venous thromboembolism (VTE) event under clinical practice conditions. Methods: We present
current data on the re-hospitalization of patients with deep venous thrombosis
(DVT) or pulmonary embolism (PE) from the PREFER in VTE registry in 7 Western
European countries (France, Italy, Spain, Germany, UK, Austria and Switzerland).
The current interim analysis includes data of 2863 patients. 1689 patients had DVT
alone and 1174 had PE (±DVT) as qualifying event for inclusion. Results: At baseline, 72.2% of the patients received heparin, 11.9% fondaparinux, 48.0% vitamin K
antagonists, 25.4% non-VKA oral anticoagulants, 7.0% acetylsalicylic acid, 2.1% other
antiplatelets and 1.6% thrombolysis agents. Within the first 6 months, 14.7% of VTE
patients were hospitalized for any reason (DVT: 12.9%, PE: 17.5%). Hospitalization
rates varied between countries (Spain 10.7%, Germany 10.8%, France 12.5%, Italy
19.3%, UK (at 3 months) 7.5%). The mean number of hospitalizations was 1.3 ±0.85
(1.1 to 1.5 in the various countries; median 1, range 1-6). The documented reasons for
hospitalization, among others, were VTE (15.3%), surgery/trauma (13.5%), bleeding
(7.4%), or stroke/TIA (3.7%). Mean duration of all combined hospital stays was 9.8
±12.61 days (4.0 days in Germany, 4.7 in France, 9.0 in Spain, 14.0 in Italy). The overall
median duration of hospitalization was 6 days (interquartile range 2-12), for DVT
cases it was 6 days (IQR 3-13), for PE cases it was 5 days (IQR 2-11). Conclusions:
Under real-life conditions, one in seven patients had to be readmitted to hospital
in the first 6 months after the DVT or PE event. However, the majority of hospitalizations were not due to the thromboembolic disease or bleeding. The duration of
hospital stays showed a wide range across Western European countries.
PCV2
Discontinuation And Hospitalisation Rates In Patients With Atrial
Fibrillation: Follow-Up Results Of The Prefer In Af Registry
Brüggenjürgen B 1, Schliephacke T 2, Darius H 3, De Caterina R 4, Le Heuzey J Y 5, Pittrow D 6,
Reimitz P E 2, Schilling R J 7, Zamorano J L 8, Kirchhof P 9
1Steinbeis University Berlin (SHB), Berlin, Germany, 2Daiichi Sankyo Europe GmbH, Munich,
Germany, 3Vivantes Hospital Neukölln, Berlin, Germany, 4G. d’Annunzio University, Chieti,
Italy, 5Hôpital Européen Georges Pompidou, Université René Descartes, Paris, France, 6Technical
University Carl Gustav Carus, Dresden, Germany, 7Barts and St Thomas Hospital, London,
UK, 8University Hospital Ramón y Cajal, Madrid, Spain, 9University of Birmingham Centre for
Cardiovascular Sciences and SWBH NHS Trust, Birmingham, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The great majority of patients with atrial fibrillation (AF) require lifelong antithrombotic therapy for prevention of stroke. For optimal treatment, it is
important to investigate treatment discontinuations, as those might be associated
with increased hospitalization rates. As potential indicator for unstable anticoagulation efforts we assessed hospitalization rates for non-vitamin K antagonist oral anticoagulants (NOAC) and for warfarin under real-life practice conditions. Methods:
PREFER in AF (The PREvention oF thromboembolic events – European Registry in
Atrial Fibrillation) is a prospective non-interventional disease registry of patients
with AF in 7 countries in Western Europe. Discontinuation rates were assessed looking at all patients (n= 6412), whereas hospitalization rates reported at Baseline (BL)
and 1 year Follow-Up (FU) focused on two groups: patients treated with warfarin
(BL= 1379, FU= 1571) and patients treated with NOAC (BL= 194, FU= 424). Descriptive
statistics were applied. Results: Out of 6412 patients, 9 to 18% of patients treated
with vitamin K antagonists (VKA) discontinued therapy (warfarin 10.3%, phenprocoumon 9%, acenocoumarol 10.4%, fluinidone 18%). The discontinuation rates for
patients on NOAC were 9.4% for rivaroxaban and 10.3% for dabigatran, respectively.
Reported hospitalization rates (irrespective of reason) were 19.8%/10.0% for NOAC,
and 24.1%/11.6% for warfarin at BL or FU, respectively. Mean duration of hospitalization was 1.3±4.0/ 0.9 ±5.1 days for NOAC, and 2.0±6.1/ 1.0 ±4.2 days for warfarin.
Conclusions: No major differences were observed in the discontinuation rates
between VKA and NOAC on the class level nor the various available NOAC drugs.
Hospitalization rates and corresponding number of days in hospital reported at BL
were substantially higher compared to FU. Patients on NOAC had lower hospitalization rates and less days in hospital compared to those on warfarin. Further analyses
are needed to explore the reasons for hospitalizations.
PCV3
The Additional Costs Of Clinical Complications In Patients
Undergoing Transcatheter Aortic Valve Replacement In The German
Health Care System
Kaier K 1, Gutmann A 2, Sorg S 2, Beyersdorf F 2, Vach W 1, Zehender M 2, Bode C 2, Reinöhl J 2
of Freiburg, Freiburg, Germany, 2Heart Center Freiburg University, Freiburg, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: Transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR) is a relatively new
alternative to surgical replacement of the aortic valve. Recent development of third
generation systems and new products have shown reductions in the frequency and
severity of complications associated with the procedure. The aim of this study was
to identify the cost impact of complications for patients undergoing TAVR in a German
hospital. Methods: Data was derived from a prospective observational study,
whereby a total of 163 consecutive patients were treated either with transfemoral
(TF-, n= 97) or transapical (TA-) TAVR (n= 66) between February 2009 and December
2012. Predefined clinical endpoints were analyzed, “in-hospital” costs determined
from the hospital perspective (2012=100) and results reported within the seven most
relevant cost categories. Results: TF-TAVR patients experienced more minor access
site bleeding (p= 0.017), major non-access site bleedings (p= 0.026), minor vascular
complications (p=0.002), stage 2 acute kidney injury (AKI, p=0.043) and permanent
pacemaker implantation (p< 0.001) compared with TA-TAVR. However, total in-hospital costs did not differ between groups (mean € 40,348; SD €15,851). Costs were proportioned in either categories (staff = 26%, materials = 62% and infrastructure = 12%)
or units (normal ward = 13%, ICU = 15%, catheter laboratory or operating room = 62%
and other = 10%). The average additional cost of any single complication was € 3,438
(p<0.01). Life-threatening non-access site bleeding was associated with the highest
additional costs (€47,494; p<0.05), followed by stage 3 AKI (€20,468; p<0.01), implantation of a second valve (€16,767; p<0.01) and other severe cardiac dysrhythmia (€10,611
p<0.05). Interestingly, censoring cases of in-hospital mortality is associated with a
substantial decrease in the additional costs. Conclusions: Bleeding complications,
severe kidney failure, and implantation of a second valve are the most important cost
drivers in TAVR patients, and strategies to reduce those complications may have the
potential to generate significant in-hospital cost reductions.
PCV4
Clotting Factor (Cf) Product Use And Same-Day Risk For Thrombotic
Adverse Events (Tes), As Recorded In Large Health Care Database
During 2008-2013 Study Period
Ekezue B F 1, Sridhar G 1, Izurieta H S 2, Forshee R A 2, Selvam N 1, Ovanesov M V 2, Jain N 2,
Mintz P D 2, Anderson S A 2, Menis M 2
1HealthCore Inc., Alexandria, VA, USA, 2U. S. Federal Drug Administration, Silver Spring, MD,
USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: There has been an increase in the number of clotting factor (CF) products available in the U. S. in recent years. Thrombotic events (TEs) are serious adverse
events that can occur following administration of CFs. The objective of this study
is to assess the same-day TE risk following exposure to CF products. Methods:
A retrospective cohort study of individuals exposed to CF products during January
2008 through June 2013 was conducted using HealthCore Integrated Research Database
(HIRDSM). CF products were identified by Health care Common Procedure Coding System
(HCPCS) codes, and TEs were ascertained via ICD-9-CM diagnosis codes. Crude sameday TE rates (per 1,000 persons exposed) were estimated overall, by congenital clotting
factor deficiency status and by specific CF products, age, and gender. Results: Of 3,801
individuals exposed to CFs, 117 (30.8 per 1,000 persons) had TEs recorded on the sameday as CF exposure. The crude same-day TE rate (per 1,000) was higher for CF users
without congenital CF deficiency, 70.2 (102 of 1,452), as compared to those with congenital CF deficiency, 6.4 (15 of 2,349), unadjusted rate ratio of 11.0 (95% CI 6.4-18.9). For
individuals without congenital CF deficiency, the crude TE rates (per 1,000) were 15.9 for
under 15 years of age, 16.1 for 15 to 44 years, 62.8 for 45 to 64 years, and 160.9 for 65 years
and older. The unadjusted same-day TE rates (per 1,000) ranged from 12.8 for Factor
VIII to 204.1 for Factor IX complex product(s). Multivariable analyses are underway to
control for potential confounders and identify recipient risk factors. Conclusions:
The study shows an increased risk of same-day TEs for CF users without congenital
CF deficiency and suggests a potentially substantial off-label use of CFs, which needs
further investigation. In addition, study findings suggest elevated same-day TE rates for
specific CF products with additional multivariable investigation ongoing.
PCV5
The Effect Of Atriala Fibrillation In Acute Myocardial Infarction
Patients In Taiwan
Li C Y 1, Chang C J 2, Chu P H 3, Fann C S J 4
Gung University, Taichung, Taiwan, 2Chang Gung University, Kwei Shan, Tao Yuan,
Taiwan, 3Chang Gung University, Taoyuan, Taiwan, 4Academia Sinica, Taipei, Taiwan
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Chang
Objectives: Acute myocardial infarction (AMI) is a major cause of mortality
and disability worldwide. AMI occurs when blood flows irregularly into heart and
thus heart muscle is injured due to insufficient constant oxygen received. It will
cause severe complications or co-morbidities if the condition is lasting. Hence,
we hypothesized the atrial fibrillation (AF) is an independent risk factor to the
major severe cardiovascular events (MACE) after AMI occurred. Methods: The
AMI patient is defined by the patient treated in the emergency room at the beginning of the illness. Frequencies and costs of AMI data were extracted from the
National Health Insurance Research Database for this observational retrospective
cohort study between 2007 and 2012 in Taiwan. ICD-9-CM 410 was used to extract
the AMI patients. Fisher’s exact test and categorical data analytic method were
utilized to assess the AF as a risk factor to MACE in the AMI patients. Results: We
mainly focused on the AMI adults without any prior MACE occurred. As a result,
there were 3,452 AMI who can be divided into 2 groups: 2,939 AF patients and 513
non-AF patients. The average medical cost was USD$ 3142.8 and the mean LoS
was 10.4 days with st. d. 29.0 days. There were 1,791 MACE identified among the AF
patients (60.9%), while there were 251 MACE among the non-AF patients (48.9%).
In consequence, the AMI with AF resulted more MACE than those in non-AF (RR =
1.63, C.I. = (1.35, 1.97), p < 0.0001). The difference of cost was not significant between
both groups. The mean LoS in AF was 16.6 days, which was significantly smaller
than that in non-AF (19.1 days). The difference was probably due to higher fatalities
in AF. Conclusions: This study has demonstrated that AF risk is associated with
MACE in patients after AMI occurred.
PCV6
Development Of A Collaborative European Pharmacoepidemiologic
Post-Authorization Safety Study (Pass) Programme Examining
Rivaroxaban Use In Routine Clinical Practice
Brobert G 1, García Rodríguez L A 2, Garbe E 3, Bezemer I D 4, Layton D 5, Friberg L 6, SuzartWoischnik K 1, Alderson J 7, Winchester C 7, Herings R M C 4, Jobski K 3, Schink T 3, Shakir S 5,
Soriano-Gabarró M 1, Wallander M A 8
1Bayer Pharma AG, Berlin, Germany, 2Ceife - Centro Español de Investigación
Farmacoepidemiológica, Madrid, Spain, 3Leibniz Institute for Prevention Research and
Epidemiology - BIPS, Bremen, Germany, 4Pharmo Institute for Drug Outcomes Research, Utrecht,
The Netherlands, 5Drug Safety Research Unit, Southampton, UK, 6Friberg Research AB, Stockholm,
Sweden, 7Oxford PharmaGenesis™ Ltd, Oxford, UK, 8Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Background: Proactive, post-authorization monitoring of drug safety and effectiveness is of increasing importance. Rivaroxaban is a Factor Xa inhibitor with
multiple indications, including: treatment of venous thromboembolism (VTE) and
prevention of recurrent VTE; stroke prevention in atrial fibrillation; and prevention
A474
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
of atherothrombotic events (when combined with antiplatelet therapy) following an
acute coronary syndrome. Use, safety and effectiveness of rivaroxaban in real-life
settings need to be monitored to understand its value and comply with regulatory
requirements. Objectives: To develop a pharmacoepidemiologic PASS programme
to characterize post-authorization rivaroxaban use and relevant outcomes related to
safety (intracranial, gastrointestinal, and urogenital haemorrhage) and effectiveness
(myocardial infarction, ischaemic stroke and thromboembolic events). Methods:
European sources of longitudinal observational health care data were identified
that contained population-based data on demographics, comorbidities and comedications. Additional studies were designed to capture drug utilization, safety
and effectiveness data in primary and secondary care via physician questionnaire
completed based on medical chart review. With an emphasis on the consistent
definition of endpoints, protocols were developed and tailored for each study for
submission to regulatory authorities and relevant ethics committees. Results:
A PASS programme of 7 studies was designed. Rivaroxaban drug utilization, and
safety and effectiveness, in comparison with standard of care, are being assessed
using The Health Improvement Network (UK), the PHARMO Database Network (The
Netherlands), the German Pharmacoepidemiological Research Database and the
National Swedish Registries. The programme also includes 2 Specialist Cohort Event
Monitoring studies to collect data on the initial treatment period in secondary care
settings, and a complementary Modified Prescription-Event Monitoring study that
evaluates long-term use in primary care. Conclusions: This pharmacoepidemiologic PASS programme, with its unique and complementary approach, will monitor
and characterize the real-life benefit–risk profile of rivaroxaban. A flexible design
allows the accommodation of any new indications for rivaroxaban approved during the study.
PCV7
Coronary And Cardiovascular Disease Risks In Migraine Patients:
Evidence From National Health And Nutrition Examination Survey
1999–2004
Yu J , Zhang W , Mezzio D , Vo T
Touro University California, Vallejo, CA, USA
.
.
.
.
Objectives: (1) To assess the prevalence of migraine using the National Health
and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES) conducted in the general United
States population; (2) To calculate the 10-year Framingham cardiovascular disease (CVD) and coronary heart disease (CHD) risks and compare the risks between
migraine patients (MP) and non-migraineurs (NM). Methods: MP were identified using the survey question: “During the past 3 months, did you have severe
headaches or migraines?” from the 1999-2000, 2001-2002, and 2003-2004 NHANES.
Independent chi-square tests and t-tests were used to compare differences in
CVD or CHD risk factors between MP and NM. Multivariant ordinal logistic regressions were used to examine the odds ratios of low, moderate, and high CHD and
CVD risks between MP and NM accounting for the complex sampling design
used by NHANES. Significance was defined as p≤ 0.05. Results: Amongst the
total of 14,204 study subjects (6,731 men and 7,473 women), 2,895 (20.38%) subjects reported having migraines or severe headaches in the past three months.
The average age of MP was 41.8 (±16.8) years, compared to 47.4 (±19.8) years in
the NM group. MP had a significantly higher percentage of females, with 1,962
(67.77%) females. Subjects in the migraine group were found to have an odds
ratio of 1.208 (95% CI, 1.033-1.412, p-value< 0.001) for moderate CHD risk, and
an odds ratio of 0.975 (95% CI, 0.732 – 1.412, p-value< 0.001) for high CHD risk.
Regarding CVD risk, migraine patients were found to have an odds ratio of 1.173 (95%
CI, 0.818 – 1.683, p-value<0.001) for moderate risk, and an odds ratio of 1.112 (95% CI,
0.909 – 1.582, p-value< 0.001) for high risk. Conclusions: Migraine appears to be
more prevalent among younger subjects with an overall mean age of 42 years old.
These findings also suggest a positive association between migraine and CHD risks.
PCV8
Effectiveness And Costs Of Different Strategies For The Diagnosis
Of Stable Coronary Artery Disease Results From The Evinci Study
Turchetti G 1, Lorenzoni V 1, Bellelli S 1, Pierotti F 1, Rovai D 2, Caselli C 2, Underwood R 3,
Knuuti J 4, Neglia D 2
1Scuola Superiore Sant’Anna, Pisa, Italy, 2National Research Council, Pisa, Italy, 3Imperial College
London, London, UK, 4University of Turku and Turku University Hospital, Turku, Finland
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The analysis of different non-invasive imaging strategies in a
European population of patients with stable angina could help the identification
of the best approach for the diagnosis of significant CAD. Methods: In 475 pts
(291 males, 60±9 yrs) with stable angina enrolled in the EVINCI multicenter study,
CT coronary angiography (CTCA) and stress imaging were performed before invasive coronary angiography (ICA). Significant CAD was defined as > 50% stenosis
in the left main or > 70% stenosis in a major coronary vessel or 30-70% stenosis
with fractional flow reserve ≤ 0.8. Nine non-invasive imaging strategies including
CTCA or stress imaging (ECHO, CMR, SPECT or PET) alone or in combination with
CTCA performed as first line examinations were evaluated. Combinations were
positive if both CTCA and the stress test were positive and their performance
was evaluated in terms of accuracy (AUC). Centres specific reimbursements were
collected for invasive and non-invasive examination and the costs associated
with different strategies were obtained at individual patient level by summing
up reimbursement of the examinations involved. Results: Significant CAD was
diagnosed at ICA in 140 patients (29%). CTCA had the highest diagnostic performance among strategies involving single imaging modalities [0.91 (0.88-0.94)] and
CTCA-PET among combinations [0.84 (0.74-0.93)]. Costs vary significantly among
the strategies involving single non invasive modalities with value ranging from
425 Euro for ECHO to 1245 Euro for PET as well as for those involving combinations of imaging modalities ranging from 508 Euro for CTCA-ECHO to 870 Euro for
CTCA-SPECT. Conclusions: The diagnostic workflow for CAD detection shows
variable effectiveness and costs according to the use of different single or combined non invasive imaging modalities. Data collected in the EVINCI study offer
the opportunity to evaluate several diagnostic workflow from a combined clinical
and economic perspective using a cost-effectiveness analysis.
PCV9
An Assessment Of The Current Literature On Apheresis Use In The
Treatment Of Familial Hypercholesterolemia
Wang A 1, Richhariya A 2, Gandra S R 2, Calimlim B 1, Kim L 1, Nordyke R 1
Segundo, CA, USA, 2Amgen, Inc., Thousand Oaks, CA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1ICON, El
Objectives: Although apheresis is an important treatment for reducing LDL-C in
familial hypercholesterolemia (FH) patients, little is known about its treatment patterns. We conducted a systematic review to assess the efficacy/effectiveness, practice patterns, cost, and clinical guidelines for apheresis in FH patients. Methods:
Electronic databases were searched for publications of apheresis in FH patients.
Inclusion criteria include: articles in English published 2000-2013, description of
practice patterns, efficacy/effectiveness, and costs. Data were stratified by country
and FH genotype where possible. Results: Thirty-seven studies met the inclusion
criteria: 8 open-label clinical trials, 11 observational studies, 16 reviews/guidelines,
and 2 health technology assessments. Of the 19 clinical and observational studies,
6 assessed only homozygous FH (HoFH) patients, 4 assessed only heterozygous FH
(HeFH) patients, 6 included HoFH and HeFH patients, and 3 did not specify type of
FH. The prevalence of FH is not well characterized by country and underdiagnosis
is a barrier to optimal FH treatment. Apheresis guidelines recommend weekly/biweekly treatments conducted at apheresis centers that may last ≥ 3 hours per session. Apheresis may be recommended as first-line treatment in HoFH patients and
after drug therapy failure in HeFH patients. Studies reported a range of LDL-C reduction after apheresis: HoFH: 57-75%; HeFH: 58-63%. Eight studies reported apheresis
costs. Cost (USD 2013) per apheresis session ranged from $2,200-$4,300 in the US,
$2,150-$2,600 in the UK, $1700-$1850 in Germany and France, and $2,350-$2,750
in Australia. Calculated annual costs may reach $88,400-$225,000 per patient for
weekly treatment. Conclusions: LDL-C apheresis treatment is necessary for FH
patients when drug therapy is inadequate. While apheresis reduces LDL-C, high
per-session costs and the frequency of guideline-recommended treatment result
in substantial annual costs. The costs and the inconvenience of apheresis sessions
are barriers in optimal treatment of FH.
PCV10
Estimated Added Benefit Of Catheter-Based Renal Denervation For
Moderate Treatment-Resistant Hypertension: Impact Of Age And
Cardiovascular Risk Factors
Pietzsch J B 1, Geisler B P 1, Esler M D 2
1Wing Tech Inc., Menlo Park, CA, USA, 2Baker IDI Heart and Diabetes Institute, Melbourne,
Australia
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Our objective was to estimate the impact of catheter-based renal
denervation plus standard of care (RDN) versus standard of care alone (SoC) on
European stage-1 hypertension patients with different cardiovascular risk factor
profiles. Methods: We simulated resistant hypertension cohorts with different
cardiovascular risk factor profiles (CVRPs) who had stage-1 hypertension despite
adequate treatment with SoC. Six different cohorts with permutations of starting
ages of 40, 55, or 70 years; and low and high CVRPs based on JNC7 guidelines were
modeled. Interventions were RDN plus SoC with three or more anti-hypertensives
including a diuretic at full doses or SoC alone. As observed in a recent prospective
uncontrolled pilot study, the impact of a 13 mmHg reduction in systolic blood pressure (SBP) – from a baseline SBP of 151 mmHg – was evaluated. Undiscounted life
year (LY) and quality-adjusted life year (QALY) gain was computed using a published
life-time Markov simulation model based on multivariate risk equations. Results:
Across the studied age groups and cardiovascular risk profiles, catheter-based renal
denervation was associated with gains in unadjusted (0.51-1.48 LYs) and qualityadjusted life expectancy (0.39-1.20 QALYs). Younger age and higher cardiovascular
risk profile led to numerically higher increments. The cohort-specific LY and QALY
gains were projected as follows: 1) 40 year old cohorts: low CV risk profile: 0.84 LYs/
0.78 QALYs; high CV risk profile: 1.48 LYs/ 1.20 QALYs; 2) 55 year old cohorts: low CV
risk profile: 0.69 LYs/ 0.60 QALYs; high CV risk profile: 1.29 LYs/ 0.95 QALYs; 3) 70 year
old cohorts: low CV risk profile: 0.51 LYs/ 0.39 QALYs; high CV risk profile: 0.99 LYs/
0.68 QALYs. Conclusions: RDN, when used to treat moderate treatment-resistant
hypertension, is associated with clinically significant increases in life expectancy.
These model-based findings need to be confirmed in clinical trials.
PCV11
The Use Of Minimally Invasive Surgery (Mis) And Intraoperative
Imaging Modalities In The Treatment Of Intracerebral Hemorrhage
(Ich): A Systematic Review Of The Literature
Karamalis M 1, Langer K 1, Demessinov A 2, Birinyi-Strachan L 3
Kazakhstan, Almaty, Kazakhstan, 3Medtronic
Australasia, Sydney, Australia
.
.
.
.
1Medtronic, Tolochenaz, Switzerland, 2Medtronic
Objectives: The objective of this review was to investigate the use of MIS and intraoperative imaging technologies in the treatment and management of persons with
ICH. Methods: A systematic search of the published literature was undertaken in
February 2014, using the Embase, PubMed and CRD York bibliographic databases. Key
society websites were also searched for relevant ICH practice guidelines. Studies and
guidelines reporting on MIS techniques in persons eligible for treatment for Primary
ICH were included. Results: 1042 citations were retrieved, of which 190 full-text
articles were reviewed. Six practice guidelines, 4 Systematic reviews, 10 RCTs and 3
Economic evaluations were included. All 4 systematic reviews of RCT data showed
consistent results in favour of MIS versus medical management (MM) or craniotomy
(CR) for both efficacy (mortality and/ or mortality and dependent living benefit) and
safety (lower rebleeding and higher hematoma volume reduction) vs. CR. A statistically significant reduction in the relative risk (RR) of death ranging from 34-71% for
patients treated with MIS as opposed to CR or MM was reported in all 4 reviews. Three
ICH guidelines (Europe, Japan and USA) recommended the use MIS in specific circum-
A475
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
stances. All 3 economic studies found MIS in the treatment of ICH was associated
with lower costs compared to MM or CR. In one study MIS resulted in a $USD44,329
saving in acute care costs compared to MM, primarily driven by lower hospital bed
days (70 vs. 98.9 days). Conclusions AND IMPLICATIONS OF KEY FINDINGS: MIS
in the treatment of ICH presents convincing evidence for improved efficacy over MM
and CR. The latest clinical practice guidelines for the treatment of ICH do not yet accurately reflect these latest findings and as such, current treatment practices may be
lagging behind what the highest level of evidence suggests should be standard of care.
PCV12
Pharmacoeconomic Grounding Of Using Polypill Amlodipine With
Atorvastatin Versus Monodrugs In Patients With Hypertension And
Dyslipidemia In Ukraine
Mishchenko O , Bezditko N , Adonkina V , Tkachova O
National University of Pharmacy, Kharkiv, Ukraine
.
.
.
.
Objectives: One reason of the low efficiency of cardiovascular diseases (CVD)
treatment in Ukraine is the low adherence of patients. Modern trends improving
the quality of treatment and increase patients compliance is use of polypills (PP).
The aim: pharmacoeconomic assesment the feasibility of PP amlodipine and atorvastatin versus monodrugs in patients with hypertension and dyslipidemia (DYS)
from the Ukrainian perspectives point of view. Methods: The results of clinical
studies AVALON (Granger C. B., McMurray J. J., Yusuf S. et al., 2003) were used. Cost
minimization analysis of three regimens of patients treatment with hypertension
and DYS during 8 weeks: PP amlodipine 5 mg + atorvastatin 10 mg; amlodipine 5 mg;
atorvastatin 10 mg. Results: The results of the clinical research AVALON found,
that the use of PP amlodipine+atorvastatin provides significant clinical benefit:
the largest number of patients reached target levels of blood pressure (BP) and
low-density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-C) (45.5%), versus amlodipine (8.3%), atorvastatin (28.6%), placebo (3.5%). The scheme using amlodipine is the most expensive
(cost for course of treatment (CCT) € 20.28), the regimen of atorvastatin 10 mg (CCT
€ 10.46) and the PP amlodipine+atorvastatin (CCT € 17.72) are less costly. This PP is
more cost effective versus amlodipine monotherapy (CER = € 38.95 versus € 244.34
per patient with target levels of BP and LDL-C) and less cost effective compared
atorvastatin monotherapy (CER = € 36.57 per patient with target levels of BP and
LDL-C). The cost of an additional unit of effectiveness (ICER) showed that the use of
PP amlodipine+atorvastatin instead amlodipine provides for the treatment of each
100 patients additional 37.2 patients achieved target levels of BP and LDL-C and
saving € 6.88 per patient. Conclusions: Pharmacotherapy of patients with hypertension and DYS based on PP amlodipine+atorvastatin provides significant clinical
benefit versus monodrugs and pharmacoeconomic advantages versus amlodipine.
PCV14
Lifetime Clinical Events Avoided And Resource Utilization With
Apixaban Compared To Low-Molecular-Weight Heparin Followed
By A Vitamin K Antagonist For The Treatment And Prevention Of
Venous Thromboembolism
Hamilton M 1, Phatak H 1, Lanitis T 2, Mardekian J 3, Rublee D A 3, Leipold R 4, Quon P 4,
Browne C 2, Cohen A T 5
1Bristol-Myers Squibb Company, Princeton, NJ, USA, 2Evidera, London, UK, 3Pfizer, Inc., New York,
NY, USA, 4Evidera, Bethesda, MD, USA, 5Guy’s and St Thomas’ NHS Foundation Trust, London, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
PCV15
The Effectiveness Of Carotid Artery Stenting Compared With
Endarterectomy In Symptomatic Patients With Carotid Stenosis In
Korean Multi-Center Setting
You J H 1, O h S H 1, Lee J Y 2, Park J J 1, Shin S 3
1National Evidence-based Healthcare Collaborating Agency, Seoul, South Korea, 2National
Evidence-based Healthcare Collaborating Agency (NECA), Seoul, South Korea, 3National Evidencebased healthcare Collaborating Agency, Seoul, South Korea
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
PCV16
Real-Time Assessment Of Medication Taking And Activities Of Daily
Living In Patients With Uncontrolled Hypertension
DiCarlo L , Kim Y A , Young J, Bezhadi Y
Proteus Digital Health, Redwood City, CA, USA
.
.
.
.
Objectives: For patients with uncontrolled hypertension, differentiation of pharmacological resistance from inadequate or improper medication use is key to clinical management. Proteus Digital Health has developed a unique digital feedback
system, which utilizes an Ingestible Sensor (IS) to determine medication-taking
patterns. A wearable sensor in the form of an adhesive patch collects timing and
taking of IS ingestions, and physiological and behavioral metrics such as heart
rate, and patterns of activity and rest, providing insights into the patient’s dayto-day lifestyle. This study evaluates the utility of the Proteus system in patients
with uncontrolled hypertension. Methods: Patients with a history of uncontrolled
hypertension (BP> 140/90) at 5 primary care centers in the United Kingdom were
prescribed the Proteus system for 14 days. Patients co-ingested the IS along with
their prescribed BP medications while simultaneously wearing the patch. BP was
measured on days 1 and 14 by a clinician, and all other parameters, such as adherence, activity and rest patterns, were collected via the Proteus system. Results:
Of the 190 patients, 21 patients had incomplete data. In the remaining 169 patients
(89%), mean medication adherence was 88%, and mean BP decrease was -7.6 mm
Hg systolic and -3.8 mm Hg diastolic. The system data provided diagnostic insight
differentiating non-response vs. non-adherence. One hundred forty-eight (78%)
patients had ≥ 70% adherence; 100 (53%) achieved blood pressure control on their
prescribed therapy, and 48 (25%) remained uncontrolled and required modification of their therapeutic regimen. The remaining 21 patients (11%) were identified as needing intervention to support medication adherence. Conclusions: In
patients with a history of uncontrolled hypertension, 53% achieved BP control within
2 weeks, and 25% received an informed therapeutic intervention using the Proteus
system. Thus, Proteus can identify specific individual needs for progressing through
the recommended treatment pathway and for advancing toward treatment goals.
.
.
Objectives: The AMPLIFY trial compared apixaban to low-molecular-weight
heparin (LMWH) followed by a vitamin K antagonist (VKA) for treatment and
prevention of recurrent venous thromboembolism (VTE). The AMPLIFY-EXT trial
compared extended treatment with apixaban to placebo in previously treated
patients. This analysis evaluated the potential lifetime implications of apixaban
treatment versus LMWH/VKA. Methods: A Markov model was developed to evaluate the lifetime impact of treatment and prevention of VTE with apixaban (5 mg
BID for 6 months, then 2.5 mg BID) versus LMWH/VKA. Clinical event rates were
taken from AMPLIFY, AMPLIFY-EXT, and indirect treatment comparison. Length
of stay for hospitalizations was taken from AMPLIFY for recurrent VTE (median
5 days for apixaban, 6 days for LMWH/VKA) and major bleeds (median 5 days for
apixaban, 7 days for LMWH/VKA). Sixty percent of patients with recurrent VTE
and all patients with major bleeding were assumed to be hospitalized. Outcomes
evaluated were events and hospital bed days avoided, number needed to treat to
avoid a recurrent VTE, number needed to treat to harm with an additional bleed,
and life years gained. Results: In a cohort of 1,000 patients, lifetime treatment
with apixaban versus LMWH/VKA resulted in 6 fewer recurrent VTE events, 191
fewer major bleeds, 707 fewer clinically relevant non-major bleeds, and 1,730 hospital bed days avoided. On average, a patient treated with apixaban gained about 3
months of life expectancy due to avoidance of VTE events and major bleeds. These
results translated to one recurrent VTE event avoided for each 157 patients treated
and one major bleed avoided for each 5 patients treated with apixaban versus
warfarin. Conclusions: Apixaban for treatment and prevention of VTE appears
to be a superior alternative to LMWH/VKA, leading to fewer recurrent VTEs, bleeding events, and hospital bed days resulting in a projected increase in life-expectancy.
.
compare the effectiveness with CAS and CEA in 677 patients with symptomatic
carotid artery stenosis in korean clinical practice. Methods: From January 1 2008
to December 31 2011, retrospective cohort study was conducted in 677 symptomatic
carotid stenosis patients with more than 50% stenosis) (CAS=346, CEA=331) in the
Korean hospitals (Asan medical center, Samsung medical center, Severance hospital,
Inha university hospital, Chonnam university hospital). The primary outcome was
stroke, myocardial infarction, or death during periprocedural (30-day) and postprocedural period. Results: For 677 patients over 2-year follow-up period, All death, major
stroke, minor stroke were higher in CAS group than CEA (1.45% vs. 0.30%, 4.05% vs.
1.81%, 3.47% vs. 3.02%, 0.58% vs. 0%). All outcomes were higher in CAS than in CEA
within 30-day after treatment and in subsequent years, except the incidence of 30
days-minor stroke. Conclusions: CEA was superior to CAS in symptomatic patients
with carotid stenosis. This study suggests that CEA can be considered the first-line
therapy for symptomatic carotid artery stenosis in South Korea.
.
Objectives: Carotid endarterectomy (CEA) has been recommended as the gold
standard for the management of carotid disease in many clinical guidelines. But,
in Korean clinical practice, carotid artery stening (CAS) was conducted more than
CEA (21.6%) based on the national claims-data. The purpose of this study was to
PCV17
Use Of Computer Simulation To Generate Evidence To Aid Health
Care Decision Making: An Example Using The Archimedes Model To
Compare Rosuvastatin With Atorvastatin
Colivicchi F 1, Sternhufvud C 2
San Filippo Neri, Rome, Italy, 2AstraZeneca, Mölndal, Sweden
.
.
1Ospedale
Objectives: Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) provide the most robust evidence source for making patient health care decisions. When RCT data are lacking,
however, complementary evidence sources may also be needed. As an example of
this, three clinical trials comparing rosuvastatin with atorvastatin were simulated
using the Archimedes model, a validated, individual-based simulation of human
pathophysiology and behaviours, treatment interventions and health care systems. Methods: Comparison A assessed clinical outcomes in patients receiving
available doses of the two drugs. Comparison B assessed the impact of initial treatment decisions, with individuals randomized to receive various doses of either
rosuvastatin or atorvastatin and eligible for treatment intensification for up to 5
years if target lipid levels were not met. Comparison C assessed the effect of switching patients’ treatment from rosuvastatin to atorvastatin. Results: In comparison
A, rosuvastatin was estimated to result in greater reductions than atorvastatin
in major adverse cardiac events (MACEs) at 5 and 20 years at all doses examined
(relative risk [RR]: 0.907,0. 892 and 0.931 at 20 years for rosuvastatin 20 mg versus
atorvastatin 40 mg, rosuvastatin 40 mg versus atorvastatin 80 mg, and rosuvastatin
20 mg versus atorvastatin 80 mg, respectively; P< 0.05 in all cases). In comparison
B, outcomes were significantly better in patients initially prescribed rosuvastatin
relative to atorvastatin (RR of MACE at 10 years: 0.919; P< 0.001). In comparison C,
risk of MACE was significantly greater in patients who switched from rosuvastatin to
atorvastatin, relative to those who remained on rosuvastatin (RR at 10 years: 1.115;
P< 0.001). Conclusions: In this example using the well-validated Archimedes
model, better outcomes were predicted in patients receiving rosuvastatin than
in those receiving atorvastatin in a variety of different settings. This provides an
example of the utility of robust modelling approaches to generating evidence that
is not available from clinical trials.
PCV18
Critical Appraisal Of Network Meta-Analyses Evaluating The
Efficacy And Safety Of New Oral Anticoagulants In Atrial
Fibrillation Stroke Prevention Trials
Cope S 1, Clemens A 2, Hammès F 3, Noack H 4, Jansen J 5
1Mapi, Inc., Toronto, ON, Canada, 2Boehringer Ingelheim Pharma GmbH & Co KG, Corporate
Devision Medicine, Ingelheim, Germany, 3Boehringer Ingelheim, Paris, France, 4Boehringer
Ingelheim Pharma GmbH & Co KG, Medical Data Services, Ingelheim, Germany, 5Tufts University
School of Medicine, Boston, MA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
A476
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: To critically appraise the published network meta-analyses (NMAs)
evaluating the efficacy or safety of the new oral anticogulants (NOACs) dabigatran,
rivaroxaban and apixaban for the prevention of stroke in patients with non-valvular
atrial fibrillation (AF). Methods: A systematic literature review was performed to
identify the relevant NMAs using MEDLINE®, EMBASE®, Cochrane Library, Database
of Abstracts of Reviews of Effects, and Health Technology Assessment. The synthesis
studies were evaluated using the ‘Questionnaire to assess the relevance and credibility of the NMA’. Results: Eleven NMAs evaluating NOACs among adults with
non-valvular AF were identified. Most NMAs included three large phase III RCTs,
comparing NOACs to adjusted-dose warfarin (RE-LY, ROCKET-AF, ARISTOTLE). The
main differences identified related to potential treatment effect modifiers regarding the mean time spent in therapeutic range (TTR) in the warfarin arm, the risk of
stroke or systemic embolism across the trials (mean CHADS2 score: Cardiac failure,
Hypertension, Age ≥ 75 years, Diabetes mellitus, Stroke, 2 two points for stroke) or
primary versus secondary prevention, and type of populations used in the analysis.
Kansal et al. appropriately adjusted the ROCKET-AF TTR to match the RE-LY population based on individual patient data. Meta-regressions are not expected to minimize confounding bias given limited data, whereas subgroup analyses had some
impact on the point estimates for the treatment comparisons. Conclusions:
Results of the synthesis studies were generally comparable and suggested the
NOACs had similar efficacy, although some differences were identified depending
on the outcome. The extent to which the differences in the distribution of TTR,
CHADS2 or primary versus secondary prevention biased the results remains unclear.
PCV19
Targeted Literature Review Of Unmet Need In The Hyperlipidaemia
Population With High Risk Of Cardiovascular Disease
Mitchell S E 1, Roso S 2, Samuel M 1, Woods M S 1, Pladevall-Vila M 3
1RTI Health Solutions, Manchester, UK, 2Pfizer Ltd, Surrey, UK, 3RTI Health Solutions, Barcelona,
Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To examine recommended target levels of low-density lipoprotein
cholesterol (LDL-C) for hyperlipidaemia patients at high risk (i.e., with two or more
risk factors or coronary heart disease or its risk equivalents) for cardiovascular disease (CVD); to determine the proportions of patients who do not achieve targeted
LDL-C levels in real-world setting studies. Methods: A targeted literature review
identified guidelines and real-world studies that analysed hyperlipidaemia patients
who were not at goal (as defined by study). MEDLINE, Embase, the Cochrane Library,
and BIOSIS databases were searched. Guideline publications were searched from
2008; observational studies were searched from January 2005 to December 2013.
There were no language or geographical restrictions. Results: 17 guidelines and
70 observational studies were included in the review. While country-specific guideline recommendations vary slightly, the commonly used European Atherosclerosis
Society and European Society of Cardiology (EAS/ESC) guidelines recommend a
LDL-C target of < 2.5 mmol/L for patients with high CVD risk. Most studies reported
that between 61.8% and 95.4% of high-risk patients did not reach this target. 3
studies from North America reported lower proportions, between 18.9% and 42.3%.
The EAS/ESC guidelines recommend a LDL-C target of < 1.8 mmol/L for patients
with very high CVD risk. Studies reported that 68.1% to 96.0% of patients do not
achieve this goal. Conclusions: Patients in higher cardiovascular-risk categories
tend to have more stringent LDL-C target levels, which may contribute to failure to
achieve target levels. This suggests several unmet needs: large numbers of patients
who fail to achieve LDL-C targets, reducing the patients’ risk for CVD, and consequently reduce the occurrence of cardiovascular events. Based on recently published
American College of Cardiology and American Heart Association guidelines, which
do not recommend a treatment target LDL-C level, further research is needed to
re-evaluate the unmet need in hyperlipidaemia patients.
PCV20
Study On Drug Utilization And Assessment Of Stroke Risk Using
Chads2 And Cha2ds2-Vasc Scoring In Elderly Patients With NonValvular Atrial Fibrillation
Raj T 1, Bonthu S 1, Mallayasamy S R 2
University, Manipal, India, 2Manipal College of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Manipal
University, Manipal, India
.
.
.
.
1Manipal
Objectives: Stroke Risk Stratification in AF patients of can be done using
CHADS2 (Congestive heart failure, Hypertension, Age ≥ 75, DM, prior Stroke/TIA
[2 points]); or CHA2DS2VASc2 (Congestive heart failure/left ventricular ejection
fraction ≤ 35%, Hypertension, Age ≥ 75 [2 points], DM, prior Stroke/TIA/thromboembolism [2 points], Vascular disease, Age 65–74, Sex- female). Treatment options
for Prevention of stroke includes Anti-coagulants (Vitamin K Antagonist-Warfarin,
Acenocoumarol; and Newer Oral Anticoagulant- Dabigatran) and anti-platelets
(Aspirin and Clopidogrel). The objective of this study was to assess better tool
for Stroke Risk Stratification; CHADS2 vs CHA2DS2VASc2 and to observe utilization pattern of antithrombotics with stroke as the outcome. Methods: Elderly
patients (Age> 65yrs) with Non-Valvular Atrial Fibrillation admitted in the hospital within span of 2yrs (2012-13) were selected excluding patients with comorbidities like Atrial flutter, DVT, PFO, Endocarditis and/or ARF (after approval of
ethical committee). Total of 160 patients were segregated based on stroke risk
and percentage of patients experiencing thromboembolic event in each group
was observed and CHADS2 and CHA2DS2-VASc were compared. The efficacy of
antithrombotics in prevention of thromboembolic event in patients with AF was
studied. Results: For stroke risk stratification, CHA2DS2-VASc was observed to
be a better tool than CHADS2 to predict ‘truly low risk’, ‘moderate risk’ and ‘high
risk’ patients. A shift of AF patients from ‘low-moderate risk’ by CHADS2 to ‘high
risk’ by CHA2DS2VASc was noticed, 95% of patients required anticoagulation (either
VKA or NOACs) as per CHA2DS2VASc, whereas, only 60% required OACs as per
CHADS2. Most patients who experienced CVA belonged to ‘No antithrombotics
prescribed’ group (25%). Dabigatran showed no incidence of CVA outcome, followed
by VKA-, (Warfarin-28% and Acenocoumarol-18%) and least efficacy was seen by
Antiplatelets-30%. Conclusions: CHA2DS2-VASc showed better prediction than
CHADS2 for stroke risk prediction. Dabigatran was observed to have better outcome followed by VKA and Anti-platelets.
PCV21
Management Of Chronic Thromboembolic Pulmonary Hypertension:
Clinical And Reported Outcomes From A Referral Hospital In Spain
Escribano P 1, Del Pozo R 1, Cuervo J 2, Rebollo P 2, Alvarez M P 3, Espinós B 3, Vieta A 3, LópezGude M J 1, Cortina J 1
1Hospital Universitario 12 de Octubre, Madrid, Spain, 2LASER ANALYTICA, Oviedo, Spain, 3Bayer
Hispania, Barcelona, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate the management of Chronic Thromboembolic Pulmonary
Hypertension (CTEPH) in a referral hospital by assessing clinical variables, patientreported outcomes and caregivers’ burden. Methods: An observational, retrospective study was conducted. All patients (aged > 18 years) attending the specialised
unit on CTEPH at the 12 de Octubre Hospital (Spain), between January 2010 and
November 2012, were offered to participate. Clinical variables were recorded at
the clinical session for treatment decision (Pulmonary endarterectomy –PEA- if
operability was confirmed or medication therapy –MT- if inoperable), and after
one year. Outcomes considered: The New York Heart Association Functional Class
(FC), 6-Minute Walking Distance, pulmonary arterial pressure, pulmonary vascular
resistance and pro-brain natriuretic peptide. Participants completed the EQ-5D and
caregivers’ fulfilled the Zarit Burden Interview. Differences between groups were
studied (Chi-squared, Mann-Whitney U and ANCOVA). Results: A total of 64 CTEPH
cases (57.8% males) were included. Mean (SD) age at diagnosis was 55.8 (14.9) and
67.2% had an III-IV FC at diagnosis. At the moment of treatment prescription, differences in clinical variables were not found (all p> 0.4) between PEA (n= 35-54.7%-)
and MT groups (n= 29-45.3%-). After 12 months, 8 patients died (2 in PEA group and
6 in MT). Among survivors, FC was significantly better in PEA group (93.9% improved
at least one level). Regarding EQ-5D, patients undergoing PEA showed significant
higher utilities (0.83-0.17- vs. 0.53-0.31-p= 0.007) and VAS values (80.22-14.24- vs.
49.47-20.68-p< 0.001). Furthermore, mean VAS values in PEA group were comparable
to general population (adjusted by sex and age). Finally, formal care was needed
by just 4.8% of patients in PEA versus 33.3% in MT. Reported caregivers’ burden
were relatively low in both groups (p= 0.87). Conclusions: The positive outcomes
obtained, especially in those patients undergoing PEA, suggest the experienced
management of CTEPH by this referral hospital and highlights the importance of
detecting candidates for PEA.
PCV22
The 3.5-Year Mortality Impact Of Drugs In Secondary Prevention
Of Myocardial Infarction In Real-Life (Interim Analysis Of The Eole
Cohort)
Droz C 1, Dureau C 2, Thomas D 3, Danchin N 4, Tricoire J 5, Benichou J 6, Paillard F 7, Hercberg
S 8, Sibon I 9, Rouanet F 9, Rambelomanana S 2, Maizi H 2, Bernard M A 2, Blin P 2, Moore N10
1INSERM CIC Bordeaux CIC 1401, Univ. Bordeaux, INSERM U657, Bordeaux, France, 2INSERM
CIC Bordeaux CIC1401, Univ. Bordeaux, Bordeaux, France, 3Hôpital Pitié Salpétrière, Paris, France,
4Hôpital Européen Georges Pompidou, Paris, France, 5Clinique Ambroise Paré, Toulouse, France,
6CHU de Rouen, INSERM U657, Rouen, France, 7CHU de Pontchaillou, Rennes, France, 8INSERM
U557, Bobigny, France, 9CHU de Bordeaux, Bordeaux, France, 10INSERM CIC Bordeaux CIC1401,
Univ. Bordeaux, INSERM U657, CHU Bordeaux, Bordeaux, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Few studies have assessed the real-life impact of secondary prevention
drugs on all-cause mortality post-myocardial infarction (MI), especially in countries
with low incidence of MI. The objective of this interim analysis after 3.5-year of followup was to assess the real-life all-cause mortality impact of drugs reimbursed for
MI secondary prevention in France: acetylsalicylic acid (ASA), anti-platelet agents
(APA), beta-blockers (ß-), angiotensin converting enzyme inhibitors (ACEI), statins, and
omega-3 supplementation (Om3). Methods: Cohort study of patients with recent
(≤3 months) acute MI included by hospital and non-hospital cardiologists, with 6-year
follow-up. Vital status was obtained from the National death registry, and failing that
by patient/relatives/physicians investigation. Drug exposure was defined using both
physician and patient reports at inclusion. Cox proportional hazard model was used
to estimate for each drug, mortality hazard ratio (HR) of exposed versus non exposed
patients, adjusted for gender, age, cardiovascular risk factors, other MI prevention
drugs, and propensity score to be exposed at inclusion. Results: Between May 2006
and June 2009, 596 physicians included 5538 patients: mean age 62.1 years, 77.6% male,
9.6% current smokers, 14.5% diabetic, 44.6% hypercholesterolemic, 43.6% hypertensive, 8.2% with LVEF < 40%. At inclusion, 97.5% were exposed to ASA, 91.0% to APA,
89.7% to ß-, 71.1% to ACEI, 92.0% to statins, and 15.7% to Om3. The 3.5-year mortality
was 7.8% (95%CI [7.1%-8.5%]) with an incidence rate of 23.2 per 1000 patient-years.
Adjusted HR were: 0.98 [0.60-1.61] for ASA, 0.86 [0.60-1.24] for APA, 0.84 [0.63-1.11]
for ß-, 0.80 [0.61-1.03] for ACEI, 0.67 [0.45-1.00] for statins, and 0.82 [0.58-1.16] for
Om3. Conclusions: The 3.5 year interim all-cause real-life death reduction point
estimates were close to those of large randomized controlled trials, except for ASA,
for which almost all patients were exposed. The study’s statistical power will be sufficient to confirm or not these trends at the final 6-year analysis.
PCV23
A Database Analysis Of Patients Eligible For Second-Line LipidLowering Treatment For Hypercholesterolaemia In England
Amber V 1, Jameson K 1, Das R 1, Baxter C 1, Watson L 2
1MSD Ltd., Hoddesdon, UK, 2Epi Pharmaco Ltd., Buxton, UK
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In 2012, the NHS Health and Social Care Information Centre (HSCIC),
with support from NICE, reported on the eligible population for ezetimibe as a
second-line lipid-lowering therapy (LLT) in England. Several populations were
omitted from this analysis, including some very high-risk Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus
(T2DM) patients with CVD. We re-evaluated the eligible population for ezetimibe
indicated for treatment intensification in a retrospective analysis. Methods:
Patients with ≥ 1 total cholesterol (TC) measure in each year of interest were iden-
A477
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
tified from the Clinical Practice Research Datalink (CPRD). From this cohort, three
groups of patients were identified and counted for 2010, 2011 & 2012: Group 1 –
very high-risk T2DM patients with CVD, TC ≥ 4.0 to < 5.0mmol/l and low-density
lipoprotein cholesterol ≥ 2.0mmol/l despite statin treatment; Group 2 – untreated
patients, with a TC ≥ 5.0mmol/l who were not prescribed any LLT after ceasing statin
therapy; Group 3 – patients prescribed atorvastatin, rosuvastatin and/or ezetimibe
with TC <5.0mmol/l who previously had TC ≥5.0mmol/l. Numbers were extrapolated
to the population in England. Results: Of the general population in England in
2012, 8, 200, 699 (15.4%) patients had a TC test recorded, with similar proportions
in 2010 & 2011 (15.4% and 15.3% respectively). Among the three groups defined in
this analysis, a total of 305, 261 patients eligible for ezetimibe were not included
in the 2012 estimates by HSCIC. This represents an 80.0% increase of the original
estimate of 381, 797 patients using the original HSCIC methodology, corresponding
to 33, 753, 141, 619, and 129, 889 patients in Groups 1, 2 and 3, respectively. Hence
a year-on-year increase in the estimated eligible population were observed compared to the original HSCIC estimate; 64.8% increase in 2010 and 75.7% increase in
2011. Conclusions: A significant and increasing number of high-risk patients
eligible for ezetimibe were missed in the HSCIC estimates during 2010-2012.
PCV24
More Than One In Two Instances Of Venous Thromboembolism (Vte)
Treated In French Hospitals Could Have Occurred During The
Hospital Stay
Allaert F A 1, Benzenine E 2, Quantin C 3
Biotech/CEN Nutriment, Dijon, France, 2university hospital, Dijon, France, 3University
hospital, dijon, France
.
.
.
.
1CEN
Objectives: describe the prevalence of venous thromboembolism (VTE), pulmonary embolism (PE) and deep vein thrombosis (DVT) without PE among all
hospitalized patients and the percentages of those occurring during the hospital
stays. Methods: Statistics are issued from the national PMSI MCO databases which
are encoded using the CIM10. The codes used for VTE are I801 to I809 for DVT and
codes I260, I269 for PE... Any stay with a the ICD-10 codes selected regardless of the
Principal Diagnosis of Medical Unit Summaries and whatever its position (Principal,
Related or Associated Diagnosis) was considered as a hospital-occurred thrombosis unless it was the Principal Diagnosis of the first Medical Unit Summary of the
stay. To eliminate outpatient consultations or in day care, stays of < 48 hours were
excluded. The term of hospital-occurred is preferred to hospital-acquired VTE suggesting a nosocomial origin which can be the case or not. Results: The results bear
on the 18 683 603 hospital stays in 2010-2011. Out of 100 hospital stays involving VTE,
for 40.3% VTE was the cause of hospitalization whereas 59.7% can be considered
to have occurred during hospital-stay. These distributions are of 25.6% and 74.4%
for DVT respectively 53.8% and 46.2% for PE. The age of patients varies little with
whether VTE, DVT, and PE were hospital-occurred or not and are similar in men
and women. The percentage of mortalities of these VTE is high and reaches 6.58%
and the mortality from VTE, DVT, and PE is multiplied by a factor of 3 to 4 (p< . 0001)
when hospital-occurred. Conclusions: The high proportion of hospital-occurred
VTE is an alarming situation that should question the quality of prevention and/or
its effectiveness. VTE prevention policies must be strengthened in hospitals for the
sake of patients and health care savings alike.
PCV25
Risk Factors Associated With Venous Thromboembolism Recurrence
In A European Population
Hamilton M 1, Gupta S 2, Goren A 3, Auziere S 4, Claflin A B 5, Reboul R 4, Phatak H 1
Squibb Company, Princeton, NJ, USA, 2Kantar Health, Princeton, NJ, USA, 3Kantar
Health, New York, NY, USA, 4Kantar Health, Montrouge, France, 5Pfizer, Inc., New York, NY, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Bristol-Myers
Objectives: This study estimated venous thromboembolism (VTE) recurrence
and associated risk factors in a European population, given limited data in this
region. Methods: This retrospective cohort study included data from physicians
(376 general practitioners and 307 specialists) in France, Spain, Italy, and Germany,
who completed case report forms (2,184 patient records) for the next 3-4 patients
seen in consultation for any reason who had an initial VTE event 3 to 24 months
prior (i.e., patients surviving 90 days since initial VTE). All Anderson & Spencer
individual risk factors (plus gender, bleeding, and initial VTE type, but excluding
previous VTE and bed rest > 3 days) were entered into a Cox proportional hazard
model accounting for censored data and predicting VTE recurrence. Backward stepwise regression was used to select a reduced final model. Results: Patients’ mean
age was 61.3 years (SD= 14.3) and 47.4% were female. Of 2,184 patients, 379 developed recurrent VTE over 1,298 person-years of follow-up. The final model included:
age=40+ (91.6%) vs. 18-39 years, varicose veins (26.4%), history of heart failure (5.9%),
congestive respiratory failure (1.3%), arthroscopic knee surgery (2.2%), central
venous line (0.9%), chemotherapy (6.1%), and orthopedic (3.1%) surgery. Significant,
independent predictors of recurrence were: varicose veins (hazard ratio [HR]: 1.4;
95% confidence interval [CI] 1.1-1.8), central venous line (HR: 3.2; CI 1.5-6.8), congestive respiratory failure (HR: 2.4; CI 1.2-4.6), and heart failure (HR: 1.5; CI 1.1-2.2).
Other factors, including age= 40+, knee surgery, chemotherapy, orthopedic surgery,
and type of VTE (e.g., deep vein thrombosis vs. pulmonary embolism) did not exhibit
significant associations with recurrence of VTE. Conclusions: VTE recurrence is
high in this European population and associated with several independent risk factors. Targeted anticoagulant treatment post-initial VTE plus longer term prevention
of recurrence are needed, including attention to risk factors that help differentiate
patients more likely to experience recurrence.
PCV26
Real World Incidences And Hospital Cost Of Venous And Pulmonary
Thromboembolic Events In France
Bouee S 1, Emery C 2, Samson A 3, Bailly C 4, Cotté F E 4
1Cemka, Bourg la Reine, France, 2Cemka, Bourg La Reine, France, 3Paris-Dauphine University,
Paris, France, 4Bristol-Myers Squibb, Rueil Malmaison, France
.
.
Objectives: To estimate the cumulative incidence and hospital cost for venous and
pulmonary thromboembolic events in a real world setting in France. Methods: We
conducted a retrospective analysis of the EGB database, a 1/97th random sample of
the whole National health insurance database records linked to hospitalizations.
All patients hospitalized in 2010 and 2011 with a diagnosis of deep vein thrombosis (DVT) or pulmonary embolism (PE) were included. Inpatients were identified
through principal diagnosis of hospitalization stay. Outpatients with a DVT were
identified by 1) an echo Doppler exam, 2) preceded or followed by a low molecular
weight heparin or fondaparinux delivery (+/-7 days), and 3) a subsequent Vitamin K
antagonists delivery (0 to 7 days). Incidences and annual hospital cost of DVT and PE
were estimated and extrapolated to the overall French population, and cumulative
proportions of recurrences were calculated. Results: For 2011, the estimated crude
incidences were 141/100,000 (91,650 patients) for DVT, and 79.4/100,000 for PE (51,610
patients in France). Mean age of patients was 67.0+/-17.2 years for PE and 64.1+/-17.7
years for DVT. A majority of patients were females (57% in both groups). After index
event (PE/DVT), the cumulative proportions of venous thromboembolic recurrences
were 2.6% at 1 month, 3.7% at 3 months, 5.1% at 6 months and 6.7% at 12 months.
The cumulative proportions of death after a PE and a DVT first event were 0.2% at 1
month, 1.1% at 3 months, 2.6% at 6 months and 6.2% at 12 months. Annual hospital
cost of venous and pulmonary thromboembolic events was estimated at 712 million
€ (362 million € for DVT and 350 million € for PE). Conclusions: In 2011, around
143,000 patients suffered from venous and pulmonary thromboembolic events in
France. Hospitalized events accounted for an important burden in France.
.
.
.
.
PCV27
Cognitive Function And Non-Adherence To Antihypertensive
Medications
Li S S , Brondolo E , Dalrymple N , Schupf N , Kronish I M
Columbia University, New York, NY, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Non-adherence to blood pressure medications is common, present
in 30-50% of patients, and known to be associated with an increased risk for major
cardiovascular events and increased health care costs. Prior research suggests
that impaired cognitive function is associated with medication non-adherence.
Our aim was to determine if easily administered measures of cognitive function
can be used to identify hypertensive patients at increased risk of medication nonadherence. Methods: A convenience sample of 101 primary care patients (n= 101)
with uncontrolled hypertension was enrolled from two hospital-based clinics in
ethnically diverse communities of New York City. Patients with overt dementia
as noted by their primary care doctors were ineligible. Subjects completed three
brief cognitive tests (≤ 5 minutes to complete each one): Trail Making Test-A, Trail
Making Test-B, and the Symbol Digit Modalities Test. The primary outcome was
adherence based on percentage of doses taken as prescribed, measured by a 4-compartment electronic pillbox (MedSignals). Multivariable logistic regression was used
to determine if impaired cognitive function was associated with poor adherence
after adjusting for age, gender, ethnicity, education, and total blood pressure medications. Results: Patients who were classified as impaired when screened by
Trail Making Test-B had a three-fold (OR= 2.91,95% CI, 1.02-8.35) increased likelihood of non-adherence compared with those who were not impaired, adjusting
for age, education, gender, ethnicity, and number of BP medications (p= . 05). Trail
Making Test-A and Symbol Digit Modalities Test were non-significant predictors of
adherence in both adjusted and unadjusted analyses. Conclusions: Trail Making
Test-B, a measure of executive function, may be a useful screening tool to identify
patients without overt dementia who are at risk for non-adherence to anti-hypertensive medications. The findings from this study may provide an opportunity to
identify a tailored approach to medication adherence interventions.
PCV28
Retrospective Analysis On Hospitalization And Health Care Costs,
According To Serum Uric Acid Levels In Patients From A Sample Of
Italian Local Health Units
Degli Esposti L 1, Saragoni S 1, Buda S 1, Desideri G 2, Borghi C 3
1CliCon Srl, Ravenna, Italy, 2L’Aquila University, L’Aquila, Italy, 3Policlinico S. Orsola, University of
Bologna, Bologna, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Hyperuricemia is an independent risk factor for gouty arthropathy,
renal disease, atherosclerosis and cardiovascular diseases (CVD). The objective of
this study was to explore the relationship between serum uric acid (SUA) levels and
hospitalization events and assess health care costs. Methods: A retrospective
analysis using a large administrative database and a clinical registry containing
laboratory results was performed. Subjects, aged ≥ 18, were assigned to one of
the 4 groups based upon the first SUA measurement between October 1, 2010 and
September 30, 2011: ≤ 6 mg/dl [good-control], > 6 mg/dl and ≤ 7 mg/dl [fair-control],
> 7 mg/dl and ≤ 8 mg/dl [poor-control], > 8 mg/dl [very-poor-control]. We calculated
incidence rates to estimate the risk of hyperuricemia-related and CVD hospitalizations occurred until December, 2012. A Poisson regression model was used to assess
the relationship between the number of CVD hospitalizations and SUA level. Total
annual costs included all the pharmacological treatments and the direct costs due
to hospitalizations and outpatient services. Results: Of 52,822 patients included,
SUA level was ≤ 6 mg/dl -good-control- for 33,638 (63.7%) patients and > 6 mg/dl
–suboptimal-control- for 19,184 patients (36,3%), of whom 60,7% with fair-control,
25,8% poor-control and 13,5% very-poor-control. Compared with good-control group,
suboptimal-control patients showed an increased risk of hyperuricemia-related hospitalizations (unadjusted rate was 1,02 vs 0,43 per 1000 person-years, p< 0.001) and
of CVD hospitalizations (unadjusted rate 5,09 vs 3,17 per 100 person-years, p< 0.001;
adjusted incidence rate ratio 1.22, p< 0.001). Over one year, the mean total cost was:
€ 2,077.43 in good-control patients; € 2,079.87 in fair-control patients; € 2,296.39 in
poor-control patients; € 3,295.41 in very-poor-control patients. Conclusions: The
36,3% of the patients in this study sample were at sub-optimal SUA control (>6mg/dl).
This analysis indicates that higher hyperuricemia-related and CVD hospitalizations as well as total health care costs resulted associated with higher SUA levels.
A478
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PCV29
The Association Between The Nature And Timing Of Dental Visits
And C-Reactive Protein Levels
PCV34
Statin Use And Risk Of Developing Diabetes In Cardiovascular
Disease: Systematic Literature Review And Meta-Analysis
Candrilli S D 1, Blackwood J 2
1RTI Health Solutions, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA, 2Danbury Hospital, Danbury, CT, USA
Thakker D , Nair S R , Shukla H, Shaikh J S
Capita India Pvt. Ltd., Mumbai, India
Objectives: Evidence suggests an association between dental disease and cardiovascular disease (CVD). C-reactive protein (CRP), an inflammatory marker, has
been implicated as a risk factor for CVD, and dental disease can affect CRP levels.
Our study examined the relationship between the timing and nature of dental
visits and CRP. Methods: Using data from the US-based 1999-2000, 2001-2002,
and 2003-2004 National Health and Nutrition Examination Surveys, we examined
the relationship between time since and reason for most recent dental visit and
CRP among adults ≥ 20 years old. Participants were excluded if they were pregnant
at the time of the survey, did not take part in the examination component of the
survey, or were missing covariates for a logistic regression model: age, sex, race,
BMI, HbA1c, WBC count, CRP measure, time since and reason for last dental visit,
smoking status, cholesterol-lowering medication use, and history of asthma, cancer,
rheumatoid arthritis, chronic bronchitis, or recent illness. A dichotomous elevated
CRP measure was used, defined as CRP > 0.30 mg/dL. Time since last dental visit
was categorized as < 6 months, 6 months to < 1 year, 1 year to < 2 years, and 2+
years ago; respondents who reported never visiting a dentist were placed in the
2+ years category. Results: A greater proportion of the normal (≤ 0.30 mg/dL) CRP
group last visited a dentist < 6 months ago (P= 0.0460), and last visited the dentist
for a “preventive” visit (P< 0.0001), while a greater proportion of the elevated CRP
group last visited the dentist for a “symptom-driven” visit (P< 0.0001). Regression
model results demonstrated that preventive visits are associated with a reduced
likelihood of elevated CRP (OR= 0.722; P= 0.0120), regardless of the time since last
visit. Conclusions: Given the apparent association between risk of elevated CRP
and reason for the last dental visit, medical and dental providers should consider
interventions specifically around appropriate dental care.
Objectives: Statins are widely used for the primary and secondary prevention
of cardiovascular diseases (CVDs). Studies have shown that statins may induce
diabetes in non-diabetic CVD patients, as class effect. This systematic literature
review aims to evaluate the risk of developing diabetes in CVD patients receiving
statins. Methods: Randomized controlled trials (RCTs), which used any statin as
an intervention for non-diabetic CVD patients, were identified from August 2010
to June 2014 in databases such as, Embase, PubMed, and Cochrane. The timeframe
of the searches was selected post the study conducted by Mills et al. in 2011. This
review will also include relevant studies from the Mills et al. study until August 2010.
Two researchers will independently review studies as per the Cochrane methodology for systematic reviews. The primary outcome is the incidence of diabetes.
Subgroup analyses will also be performed to assess whether statin type, age, ethnicity or patient groups contribute to the intensity of the risk of developing diabetes. Results: In total, 5238 potentially relevant studies were retrieved from the
databases and are being screened for inclusion in the review. The data extraction
and analyses (both qualitative and quantitative) are being performed and the full
results will be presented in the poster. Conclusions: This systematic literature
review is an update of the findings of a previous study and will hopefully throw
more light on the association between statin use and the risk of diabetes in CVD
patients, with special emphasis on subgroups.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
PCV35
A Retrospective Study Of Mortality In Risk Patients With High Dose
Statin Usage And No Statin Usage
Rockberg J 1, Jørgensen L 1, Taylor B 2, Kilpatrick R D 2, Sobocki P 1
Health, Stockholm, Sweden, 2Amgen Inc, Thousand Oaks, CA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Pygargus/IMS
PCV30
Traditional And Non-Traditional Risk Factors For Cardiovascular
Disease In Type 2 Diabetes: Systematic Review Of Longitudinal
Studies
Smith-Palmer J 1, Bae J P 2, Boye K S 2, Perez-Nieves M 2, Valentine W J 1
Health Economics and Communications, Basel, Switzerland, 2Eli Lilly and Company,
Indianapolis, IN, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Ossian
Objectives: A systematic literature review of longitudinal studies across a broad
range of both general and disease specific populations was performed to understand
characteristics of patients with type 2 diabetes (T2D) with risk factors for cardiovascular (CV) events and whether the magnitude of CV risk varies across different T2D
populations. Methods: MeSH term based literature searches were performed in
the PubMed, EMBASE and Cochrane Library databases. For inclusion, studies (in any
disease area) were required to have a minimum of 1,000 T2D patients and minimum
5 years follow up. After 2 rounds of review a total of 52 articles and 2 meta-analyses
were included. Results: Twenty nine articles were described as prospective studies;
13 articles were from Europe, 20 from Asia Pacific, 13 from North America, 2 from the
Middle East and 4 were multinational. Six articles were sourced from general or nondiabetes specific data and 46 articles were based on diabetes studies. Several publications were from large scale diabetes registries (e.g. Hong Kong Diabetes Registry [n=6]
and the Swedish National Diabetes Register [n=4]). The review also identified several
post-hoc analyses from clinical trials and large scale retrospective observational/
database analyses. Risk factors investigated included well characterized markers in
T2D patients (e.g. HbA1c, blood pressure, lipids, proteinuria [n= 20]), less well characterized factors including dietary components (n=7), biochemical measures (e.g.
serum uric acid, fibrinogen; n= 6), depression (n= 6) and poorly characterized risk
factors including oral health (n=1), erectile dysfunction (n=1) and presence of H. pylori
(n=1). Conclusions: Analysis of the literature showed that in addition to traditional
risk markers, factors such as depression, erectile dysfunction, poor oral health are also
independent risk factors for CV disease. These factors should be taken into account
when estimating the CV risk profile for patients with T2D.
PCV31
Relation Of The Time In Therapeutic Range (Ttr) Of Warfarin To
Bleeding Incidences In Patients With Atrial Fibrillation
Jasmi M A S 1, Mazlan M N 1, Shaharuddin S 1, Zulkifly H H 1, Long C M 1, Hashim R 2, Abdul
Wahab M S 1
1Universiti Teknologi MARA, Selangor, Malaysia, 2Cyberjaya University College of Medical
Sciences, Cyberjaya, Malaysia
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Warfarin use in atrial fibrillation has been established for preventing
occurrence of stroke in patients with atrial fibrillation. However, safety and clinical
monitoring of warfarin use is crucial due to its risk of bleeding complications. This
study aims to compare and establish relation of time in therapeutic range (TTR) of
warfarin in patients with atrial fibrillation in the first 6 months and 6 month thereafter of anticoagulation therapy. Methods: This is a retrospective study carried out at
a tertiary-care hospital with anticoagulation clinic in the state of Selangor, Malaysia.
Data collected included patients’ demographics, co-morbidities, and international
normalized ratio (INR). TTR were determined using Rosendaal method based on
records found in database (INR Desk 4.0 system) and patients’ hemorrhage events
were also recorded. Samples of the study were patient who started warfarin from
January 2009 until March 2013. Results: A total of 167 patients with atrial fibrillation were enrolled and only 6% (n= 10) achieved TTR of more than 75% for the first
6 months of warfarin use as compared to 16.8% (n= 28) of TTR more than 75% 6
months thereafter. As for bleeding incidences, 29% (n= 45) of patients in the group
of TTR less than 75% in the first 6 months had bleeding complications as compared
to 18.7% (n= 26) in patients of TTR less than 75% 6 months after. Conclusions:
A more regular follow up is necessary during the first 6 months of new warfarin
users as they tend to be out of the TTR and have a higher bleeding risk.
Objectives: The aim of this retrospective cohort study was to calculate hazard
rates of CV/non-CV related death in risk patients stratified by statin dose and to
generate data for health-economic analyses. Methods: Anonymous retrospective
electronic medical records were extracted from a 10% sample of the Swedish population > 18 years in primary care and merged with hospital records, prescribed drugs,
and death data by National Board of Health and Welfare. Cohorts were defined as
diabetic (DM), Clinically-evident CardioVascular Disease (CeCVD), Acute Coronary
Syndrome (ACS), Heart Failure (HF) and Ischemic Stroke (IS) patients. CV/non-CV
related death was investigated. The population was divided into high dose statin
users (> 40 mg simvastatin or equivalent) and non-statin users. Royston Parmar (RP)
spline analysis was used to calculate hazard rates of both outcomes in each cohort
to enable a smooth hazard function with good fit to data compared to ordinary Cox
regression. Initial AIC-based optimization demonstrated that modeling of the log
cumulative odds as a spline function of log time and three nodes gave the best fit.
Crude rates were calculated for each cohort and event, and hazard rates adjusted
for gender, diabetes, LDL (where applicable) and age were calculated. Results:
The total database consisted of 1.3 million patients; there were 55,778 DM, 47,581
CeCVD, 49,857 ACS, 82,835 HF and 38,949 IS patients. High dose statin users showed
after initial decrease a constant/marginally increasing hazard rate, whereas the no
statin group after initial decrease had a strong increase in hazard rate versus time.
The overall hazard rate was always higher for the no statin group. Independent of
statin status diabetics and males demonstrated an at least numeric elevated hazard
rate. Conclusions: RP splines could be used to generate hazard rate functions
for cost-effectiveness models. The death rate was lower in patients with high dose
statin usage.
Cardiovascular Disorders – Cost Studies
PCV36
Budgetary Impact Analysis Of Reimbursement Varenicline In The
Smoking Cessation Treatment Of Patients With Cardiovascular
Diseases, Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Or Type-2 Diabetes
Mellitus: A National Health System Perspective In Spain
Rejas Gutiérrez J 1, Sicras Mainar A 2, Navarro Artieda R 3, De Lossada Juste A 4
1Pfizer S. L. U., Alcobendas/Madrid, Spain, 2Badalona Serveis Assistencials SA, Badalona
(Barcelona), Spain, 3Hospital Germans Trias i Pujol, Badalona (Barcelona), Spain, 4Pfizer, S. L. U,
Alcobendas/Madrid, Spain
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Varenicline is indicated for smoking cessation. Around 60.000 people die every year in Spain because of tobacco related diseases, particularly cardiovascular diseases (CVD), chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) and
type-2 diabetes mellitus (t2DM). At present, varenicline is not reimbursed in the
Spanish National Health System (NHS). The objective was to estimate the budgetary
impact (BI) for the NHS of the reimbursement of varenicline in smoking cessation
in patients with CVD, COPD or t2DM. Methods: BI was estimated comparing the
actual not-reimbursed scenario versus a reimbursed scenario using the Spanish
NHS perspective. A hybrid BI model was designed using epidemiological data to
estimate size of populations and a Markov modelling simulating until four quitting attempts to estimate smoking cessation rates with varenicline during a 5-year
horizon. Costs of cessation attempts were considered in the reimbursement scenario only, and included varenicline, medical visits and counselling. Effectiveness
of varenicline was expressed as one year of abstinence rate following a 12-weeks
course of standard doses, and were derived from clinical trials. Cost savings due to
smoking cessation were extracted from local published cost-of-illness studies in
such populations. Results showed incremental cost-savings of reimbursed versus
not reimbursed scenario. Univariate sensitivity analysis was also applied. Results:
Five-years cumulated cessation attempts increased from 140,795 in the not-reimbursed to 354,631 in the reimbursed scenario, yielding to 52,127 extra subjects
A479
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
quitting smoking. Cost of 5-year reimbursement varenicline was estimated to
be € 63.0 millions, while smoking cessation avoided costs reached € 99.9 millions,
which compared with € 21.1 millions savings in the not-reimbursed scenario: a net
incremental cost-saving of € 15.9 millions. Savings were observed since 3rd year of
modelling. Conclusions: The BI of the reimbursement of varenicline in smoking
cessation is a cost-effective health policy in the Spanish NHS, and could produce
cost-savings since the 3rd year of implementation.
PCV37
Budget Impact Analysis Of Hypertensive Treatment With Indapamide
And Amlodipine Single-Pill Combination In The Polish Setting
Kawalec P 1, Stawowczyk E 2, Holko P 2, Borowiec L 3, Filipiak K J 4
University Medical College, Krakow, Poland, 2Centrum HTA Sp z o. o. Sp.
komandytowa, Kraków, Poland, 3Medical Department, Servier Poland Ltd, Warsaw, Poland, 41st
Chair and Department of Cardiology, Medical University of Warsaw, Warsaw, Poland
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Jagiellonian
Objectives: The aim of this study was to calculate and compare public payer and
patients’ costs of hypertensive treatment with indapamide 1.5 mg and amlodipine
5 mg or 10 mg single-pill combination (SPC) and free combination (FC), in the Polish
setting. Methods: The analysis compared two scenarios: existing and new. The
existing one assumed treatment with FC of indapamide 1.5 mg and amlodipine 5
mg or 10 mg. The new one also included treatment with SPC of indapamide 1.5 mg
+amlodipine 5/10 mg. Population and market shares were estimated on the basis of
published reimbursement data, experts’ opinion and validated with available epidemiological data. Cost data were analysed from the public payer perspective (National
Health Fund) and from patient perspective, in a three-year horizon. SPC cost is based
on average pharmacy price reported in April 2014 (18.13PLN and 19.75PLN respectively for 1.5+5mg and 1.5+10mg /30 tabs); 30% patient copayment was assumed.
The cost of FC was calculated as an average cost of reimbursed indapamide and
amlodipine products in corresponding doses. All costs present 2014 values, and are
expressed in Polish zloty (PLN). Average monthly exchange rate of May 2014 was
applied (1EUR=4.1790PLN). Difference in clinical effectiveness between SPC and FC
was also included, in the form of cardiovascular events risk. Results: Introduction
of indapamide/amlodipine SPC on the reimbursement list next to FC brought savings
from public payer perspective and from patient perspective amounting to: 509,255PLN
(121,860EUR) and 5,893,941PLN (1,410,371EUR) in first year, 689,239PLN (164,929EUR)
and 7,833,005PLN (1,874,373EUR) in second year, 725,965PLN (173,717EUR) and
8,328,480PLN (1,992,936EUR) in third year. Additionally it resulted in avoidance of
808 cardiovascular events in the three-year horizon. Conclusions: Treatment with
indapamide/amlodipine SPC in comparison to FC generates significant savings both
from the public payer perspective and from patient perspective in contemporary
Polish setting, and reduces cardiovascular events.
PCV38
Modeling The Impact Of A Digital Health Feedback System In
Uncontrolled Hypertensive Patients
Kim Y A , Virdhi N , Raja P , DiCarlo L
Proteus Digital Health, Redwood City, CA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Despite the availability of numerous therapeutic agents and management tools, half of all hypertensive patients do not have their blood pressure (BP)
at goal. A model was developed to estimate the incremental costs of uncontrolled
vs. controlled hypertension and the impact of shifting patients to controlled status via a unique digital health feedback system. This Proteus system utilizes an
Ingestible Sensor to determine medication-taking patterns, and a wearable 7-day
sensor in the form of an adhesive patch to collect physiological and behavioral
metrics such as heart rate, step count, and patterns of activity and rest, providing
a means of determining non-response vs. non-adherence to prescribed medications and recommendations for daily routine. Methods: The additional costs of
outpatient services, monitoring, and cardiovascular complications were calculated
for uncontrolled vs. controlled hypertensive patients from a US plan perspective for
a 1 year time horizon. The clinical and utilization assumptions were derived from
the literature and expert opinion, and costs were derived from the Medicare Fee
Schedule and AHRQ databases. The impact of the Proteus system on BP control was
based on a real-world study evaluating this technology in 164 patients with a history
of uncontrolled hypertension. Results: In a health plan of 1 million members, 7.9%
(78,656) were uncontrolled hypertensive patients receiving care who were eligible for
the Proteus system. The direct annual medical costs of uncontrolled hypertension
were estimated to be $60.9 million over the costs for controlled disease. The Proteus
system was estimated to result in $7.3-18.3 million in savings ($328-$717 per BP at
goal), and lead to a 3-9% reduction in the number of coronary artery disease and
stroke events in one year. Conclusions: Even in the short-term, a digital health
feedback system appears to provide an effective way to mitigate the substantial
costs of uncontrolled hypertension.
PCV39
Budget Impact Analysis Of Apixaban Versus Other Noacs For The
Prevention Of Stroke In Italian Non-Valvular Atrial Fibrillation
Patients
Pradelli L 1, Calandriello M 2, Di Virgilio R 3, Bellone M 1, Tubaro M 4
HE&OR, Turin, Italy, 2HE OR Unit - Bristol-Myers Squibb S. r. l., Rome, Italy, 3Pfizer
Pharmaceuticals, Rome, Italy, 4San Filippo Neri Hospital, Rome, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
1AdRes
Objectives: This study aims to perform a budget impact analysis of the use of three
available novel oral anticoagulant agents (NOACs) for preventing thromboembolic
events in Italian patients with non-valvular atrial fibrillation (NVAF). Methods:
Estimated Italian population of patients is run through a decision tree/Markov
model simulating their treatment with the available therapeutic options: dabigatran
at two dose levels (110 mg/bid for the over 80 years old, 150 mg/bid for younger NVAF
patients), rivaroxaban, and apixaban. Effectiveness estimates derive from an adjusted
indirect treatment comparison using warfarin as link. Epidemiological data and unit
costs are collected from Italian published sources. The budget impact analysis evalu-
ates the financial impact of apixaban introduction by comparing expected 1,2, and
3 years costs in hypothetical scenarios: with and without apixaban. Italian NVAF
patient population estimation is based on official apixaban reimbursement criteria,
applying the characteristics of the trial population to national epidemiologic data.
Sensitivity analysis is performed on an alternative non-experimental population of
NVAF patients. Results: Among available NOACs, apixaban is expected to be the
least expensive at 1,2, and 3 years in an estimated patient population of 364,000
Italian patients, allowing for savings of over 5 million € by the third year. Results of
the simulation run on an alternative non-experimental population of NVAF patients
yields comparable estimates. Exclusive use of apixaban for three years in the identified population would allow for savings of € 8,832,500, € 14,446,551 and € 27,282,998
when compared with dabigatran (110 mg), dabigatran (150 mg) and rivaroxaban,
respectively. Conclusions: The different safety and effectiveness profiles of the
available NOACs emerging from the adjusted indirect comparison indicate that the
introduction of apixaban could improve health care expenditure control while maintaining or increasing therapeutic appropriateness in the Italian NVAF population.
PCV40
The Budget Impact Of New Generation Ct Scanners For Difficult-ToImage, Low-Risk Patients With Suspected Cad
Shields G E , Chapman A M
BresMed, Sheffield, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The National Institute of Health and Care Excellence (NICE) issued
diagnostic guidance on new generation computed tomography (CT) scanners recommending them as an option for the first-line imaging of coronary arteries in
patients with suspected low-risk coronary artery disease (CAD) in whom imaging
with old generation scanners is difficult (e.g. obese patients). The capital investment
for a new generation scanner is considerably more than a standard scanner, which
could hamper implementation. Based on the NICE guidance, a model was designed
for use as a planning tool for rapid access chest pain clinics (RACPCs) looking to
replace their current scanner with a new generation scanner. Methods: An Excel®
model was developed to estimate up to a 10-year impact of acquiring a new generation scanner. It was assumed that under standard care low-risk, difficult-to-image
patients would be referred for a diagnostic invasive coronary angiography (ICA).
Under the new diagnostic pathway these patients can be scanned with a new generation scanner. Whenever possible the NICE guidance was used to guide assumptions
and populate default values. Results: The model estimates that for each difficultto-image patient a new generation scanner has the potential to save approximately
£946.62 in diagnostic costs. Considering the capital investment required, a RACPC
looking to replace their standard scanner and considering implementing a new
generation CT scanner only need 53 difficult-to-image patients per year to see a
positive return on investment over a 10-year period. Conclusions: The model is
likely to be conservative as it focuses on difficult-to-image patients only, yet the
scanner is available for all patients who will likely benefit from the better sensitivity
and specificity associated with the new scanners. However, it highlights that even
a low number of these difficult-to-image patients will result in a positive return on
investment over the expected life-time of the scanner.
PCV41
Simvastatin Plus Fenofibrate As A Fixed Dose Combination In The
Treatment Of Mixed Dyslipidemia In Greece: Budget Impact Analysis
Relakis J 1, Kourlaba G 2, Maniadakis N 1
School of Public Health, Athens, Greece, 2National and Kapodistrian University of
Athens School of Medicine, Athens, Greece
.
.
.
1National
Objectives: To evaluate the affordability of switching patients already treated with
the multi-pill therapy of simvastatin and fenofibrate to the first simvastatin and
fenofibrate fixed dosed combinations (FDC) product, for the management of mixed
dyslipidemia in the Greek health care setting. Methods: A budget impact model
was locally adapted. The analysis was conducted from a third-party payer perspective over a time horizon of 3 years. The population with mixed dyslipidemia in
Greece, the market shares of available treatments and the corresponding drug acquisition costs were combined to estimate the total budgetary impact that will result
from the penetration of FDC in the Greek market. Data on population with mixed
dyslipidemia were derived from the National Statistical Service and published literature. Estimates of the current and future market shares were obtained from Abbott
Hellas market research. Drug acquisition costs were calculated using the latest
price bulletin issued and the corresponding reimbursement prices. Reimbursement
prices were reduced by the patient’s relevant co-payment and relative rebates. Since
market prices for the FDC are not available yet in Greece, estimated retail prices
provided by Abbott Hellas were considered [FDC 20/145: € 13.70 (€ 12.22-16.27) and
FDC 40/145: € 16.71 (€ 15.22-19.23)]. Results: Savings in pharmaceutical reimbursement on year 1 were estimated at 146,974 (€181,084-€88,503) decreasing the relevant
cost by 5.87% (7.23%-3.53%). On year 2, savings of € 250,544 (€ 322,536-€ 136,474) were
attributed to the penetration of FDC, lowering the budget by 9.93% (12.78%-5.41%).
On the 3rdyear, savings were estimated at € 403,405 (€ 509,489-€ 221,565) reducing
spending by 15.82% (19.98%-8.69%). On average, over the 3-year time horizon of the
analysis, the addition of FDC was found to decrease reimbursement costs by 10.54%
(13.33%-5.88%) generating savings of € 266,974 (337,703€ -€ 148,147). Conclusions:
The introduction of FDC reimbursement will result in a predictable budget impact
which is expected to decrease the relevant pharmaceutical cost for national health
insurance.
PCV42
Budget Impact Analysis Of Botulinum Toxin A Therapy For Upper Limb
Spasticity In Germany
Zoellner Y F 1, Gerwe M 2, Richter M 2
1Hamburg University of Applied Sciences, Hamburg, Germany, 2Ipsen Pharma, Ettlingen, Germany
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Upper limb spasticity (ULS) secondary to stroke has a considerable
patient and caregiver burden, particularly with regards to pain, activities of daily
A480
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
living and mobility. Botulinum neurotoxin-A (BoNT-A) injections are effective in
treating ULS. We aimed to calculate annual BoNT-A treatment cost of ULS on a
per-patient basis, and the expected overall annual budget impact of BoNT-A treatment in Germany using static and dynamic market share scenarios. Methods:
A budget impact model for BoNT-A use, adopting a German health care system
perspective, was developed. Two market-share scenarios were modelled over 5 years.
While the static scenario assumed current market shares (abobotulinumtoxinA,
36%; onabotulinumtoxinA, 26%; incobotulinumtoxinA, 38%) to remain constant over
time, the dynamic scenario assumed market share of abobotulinumtoxinA to rise
up to 76% across 5 years. Epidemiologic data inputs were sourced from the most
recently published literature, unit costs for BoNT-As from the Lauertaxe (pharmacy
purchase price [PPP] level), and market share assumptions from IMS Health (Market
Sizing). Equivalence of the 3 BoNTAs in terms of efficacy and safety is assumed and
therefore no differential use of medical services or other goods. Results: Annual
BoNT-A drug costs per ULS patient were 3 463€ , 5 603€ , and 5 410€ , respectively,
with prescribing patterns following SmPC recommendations for abobotulinumtoxinA, onabotulinumtoxinA, and incobotulinumtoxinA. The total drug costs were
decreased by between 1 231 861€ (-4%) in year 2 and 5 133 684€ (-17%) in year 5 by
shifting the market share to abobotulinumtoxinA. Sensitivity analyses showed that
the number of patients treated with BoNT-As, time to re-injection, and dose per
injection were the most influential parameters on budget impact, impacting both
drug acquisition costs and physician visits. Conclusions: Increased use of abobotulinumtoxinA compared with incobotulinumtoxinA and onabotulinumtoxinA
for ULS in Germany could potentially reduce the total cost of treatment.
PCV43
Renal Denervation With The Symplicity Catheter System For
Treatment-Resistant Hypertension: A Budget Impact Analysis
Naclerio M 1, Corbo M 2, Beccagutti G 2
1Medtronic Italia S. p. a, Sesto San Giovanni (MI), Italy, 2Medtronic Italia, Sesto San Giovanni (MI),
Italy
.
.
.
Objectives: Renal denervation (RDN) is a new treatment option for patients with
uncontrolled resistant hypertension. Studies have shown RDN to have a potential
reduction in systolic blood pressure and therefore reduce risk for different cerebrocardiovascular disease (stroke, ischemic heart disease, heart failure, etc.). The aim is
to assess the economic impact of renal denervation in resistant hypertensive patients
based on the potential clinical benefit demonstrated in literature. Methods:
A budget impact model was developed to quantify RDN-related cost-savings accomplished through lower rate of cerebro-cardiovascular events compared with the
medical treatment cohort (with 3+ anti-hypertensive medications including a diuretic). The model was developed from the Italian National Healthcare Service (NHS)
perspective with a 10-year time horizon. The risk of events was calculated using
different multivariate equations. A literature review was carried out to collect the
treatment costs for both acute and chronic phase of hypertension-related events.
The cost of RDN procedure was approximated to the related DRG tariff. Results:
Renal denervation, considering the blood pressure reduction observed after procedure, substantially reduces cerebro-cardiovascular event probabilities by 30% if
compared to the medical treatment cohort. Assuming a yearly 2% RDN adoption
rate, approximately 2,000 events would be avoided in 10 years allowing total savings
up to 9 Million euro. The higher cost of new technology was offset from potential
saving associated to the avoided events. Compared to the total costs associated
to the medical treatment cohort in 10 years the overall expenditure for RDN was
greater than 0.8%. The annual incremental cost for patients treated with surgical
approach was estimated at 16 euro per patient. Conclusions: The economic
impact of hypertension-related complications is significant in the Italian setting.
Consequently the potential savings according to the NHS perspective derived from
the implementation of strategies aimed at improving the level of hypertension
should be considered.
PCV44
Dabigatran versUS Dicoumarins In Non-Valvular Atrial
Fibrillation. Budget Impact Study In The Extremadura Public Health
System
Gemio Zumalave P 1, Parejo Hernández E 1, Alvárez Fernández M 1, Montaño Pérez L M 1,
Sánchez Chorro J L 1, Hidalgo A 2
1Servicio Extremeño de Salud, Mérida, Spain,, 2Instituto Max Weber, Majadahonda, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
of the study is that the safety data were obtained from clinical trials rather than
actual clinical practice with these drugs.
PCV45
Estimating The Value Of Cangrelor From Eliminating Preloading In
Coronary Artery Bypass Graft (Cabg) Patients
Bay C , Cyr P L , Jensen I
ICON plc, Cambridge, MA, USA
.
.
.
.
Objectives: 2011 AHA and 2012 ESC guidelines recommend antiplatelet therapy
at presentation for suspected ACS patients. For CABG patients (approximately 10%
of ACS presentations) this strategy creates a dilemma: delay CABG to washout antiplatelet therapy or perform surgery and risk bleeding. Bridging strategies have been
proposed using GPIs. Cangrelor, a novel reversible, IV P2Y12 inhibitor with rapid
onset/offset, demonstrated in the CHAMPION PHOENIX trial a reduction in ischemic
events vs. clopidogrel in patients undergoing PCI. Adoption of cangrelor for angiography in ACS patients eliminates the need to washout an oral P2Y12inhibitor in case
of unanticipated CABG. The aim of our analysis was to quantify the annual value of
this pathway change to a US hospital. Methods: A decision analytic model based
on the current CABG patient pathway was developed to quantify the value of a
reduction in bridging by adopting cangrelor from a US hospital perspective. Premier
hospital database informed the timing of CABG after washout; demographics, drugmix, LOS, blood product utilization, and hospital ward costs. Ischemic event rates
and costs were informed by published sources. Drug costs were 2014 wholesale
acquisition costs. Cangrelor cost was set to $0. Results: For a hypothetical US
hospital treating 195 CABG patients/year (patient mix: 4% STE-ACS, 26% NSTE-ACS,
70% SA), shifting away from bridging with GPI by adopting cangrelor resulted in a
total annual cost reduction of $120,000. Total costs in the base-case are estimated
to be $2.95MM vs. the scenario case of $2.83MM. Cost savings were derived from
eliminating GPI utilization, lowering washout drug costs and reducing hospitalization days. Conclusions: Removal of the need to washout oral antiplatelet therapy
prior to CABG through adoption of cangrelor is estimated to deliver a clinical value
of ~$615/CABG patient with fewer total days spent hospitalized.
PCV46
Budget Impact Of The Introduction Of New Oral Anticoagulants
(Noac) For No Valve Atrial Fibrillation (Nvaf) In Extremadura
ParejoHernández E D P 1, Gemio Zumalave P 2, Alvárez Fernández M 1, Montaño Pérez L M 1,
Sánchez Chorro J L 2, Hidalgo A 3
1Servicio Extremeño de Salud, Mérida, Spain, 2Extremadura Health System, Mérida, Spain,
3Instituto Max Weber, Majadahonda, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To analyse the budgetary impact (BI) of the introduction of NOAC
in patients with NVAF compared to warfarin treatment scenario (DC) from the
perspective of the public health system of Extremadura (PHSE). Methods:
A budget impact study was performed during 2013. It was based on anticoagulant
therapy (AO) on patients with NVAF. The data came from the electronic clinical history called JARA®. Pharmaceutical costs associated to the control and monitoring
of patients with DC were included. Specifically those related to the incidence of
stroke (CVA), gastrointestinal haemorrhage (HG), intracranial haemorrhage (ICH)
and acute myocardial infarction (AMI) as the RE-LY, ROCKET and ARISTOTLE trials.
For DC, there were taken into account the best and worst scenario. The pharmaceutical cost considered was the sum of the official price and the VAT. To other public
health costs, official prices from the PHSE and the Spanish National Health Care
System were considered. Results: Treatment distribution among patients was
92.63% DC; 4.02% Dabigatran (DAB); 3.07% rivaroxaban (RIV) and 0.28% Apixaban
(APX). The total expenditure for the AO patients with VKA in the best scenario is
€ 3,036,604.28 (average cost per patient: € 342.11, CI 95%: 341.89 - 342.34) and the
worst would be € 3,727,169 (€ 419.92, CI 95%: 419.70 - 420.15). For NOAC the results
are € 572,515.39 (€ 810.93, CI 95%I: 786.71 - 835.16). NOAC represent the 71.44% of the
pharmaceutical expenditure (PE), the 23.47% of PE’s control and monitoring of DC
and the 15.86% of the total expenditure from AO patients with NVAF, in the best scenario. Conclusions: The market access of NOAC has been modest and similar to
the rest of Spain. AVK alternative has the lowest average cost per patient. Limitation:
safety data has been obtained from clinical trials instead of using clinical practice.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate the costs associated with the use of dabigatran (DB) vs.
dicoumarins (DC) in non-valvular atrial fibrillation (NVAF) from the perspective
of the Extremadura Public Health System (EPHS) in 2013. Methods: A budget
impact study of anticoagulant therapy (AT) with DB and DC in patients with NVAF
was carried out during 2013. The data were processed using the JARA® electronic
record application. Pharmaceutical costs and costs associated with patient followup and monitoring were included. Costs relating to incidence of stroke, gastrointestinal bleeding, intracranial haemorrhage and acute myocardial infarction were
also included based on RE-LY clinical trials. For pharmaceutical cost RRP + VAT of
the medicinal products was used, and other health care costs were based on the
public prices of the EPHS and the National Health System. Results: Three hundred eighty-five patients were treated with DB (4.01 %) and 8876 with DC (92.63%).
Mean age was 77 (95 % CI: 76.82-77.19). Total expenditure for AT with AVK for the
best case scenario would be € 3,036,604.28 (mean cost per patient: € 342.11; 95%
CI: 341.80-342.34) and the worst case € 3,727,169.83 (€ 419.92; 95% CI: 419.70-419.15)
and for DB € 318,077.15 (mean expenditure: € 826.27; 95% CI: 796.81-855.57). For a
DB market penetration of 50%, expenditure on anticoagulation of these patients
would be € 3,958,659.57 while for 75% it would be € 5,937,989.36. Conclusions:
Dabigatran is a more costly option than classic treatment with DC. In 2013 this drug’s
market penetration was limited and was closer to other estimates. Estimated mean
cost per patient for DCs is similar to the estimates of other communities (Basque
Country: € 300-700 and the Valencian Community: € 300) and are somewhat lower
for DB (Basque Country: € 1,197 and the Valencian Community: € 1,350). A limitation
PCV47
The Move Towards Full Implementation Of The Nice Guidelines For
Stroke Prevention In Atrial Fibrillation: The Potential Cost And
Clinical Impact
Shields G E , Chapman A M
BresMed, Sheffield, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Updated treatment guidelines for atrial fibrillation (AF) have been
released by the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) in the
United Kingdom and highlight a current shortfall in the prescribing of anticoagulants to patients with AF despite the importance of stroke prevention. A model
was designed for use as a planning tool for Clinical Commissioning Groups (CCGs)
looking to budget for the future move towards full implementation of the NICE
guidelines. Methods: An Excel model was developed to estimate the 5-year
impact of gradually treating all eligible AF patients who are currently not being
prescribed anticoagulants, both in terms of the effect on clinical outcomes (strokes,
major bleeds and mortality) and the financial impact associated with treating more
patients. Assumptions had to be made in order to simplify the model and populate
default values. Risks of clinical outcomes were taken from a literature search. Costs
were taken from published national sources. Results: In an average sized CCG
(population of 226,000) the model estimated that in order to gradually treat the full
eligible AF patient population, an additional budget of £103,899 will be required in
Year 1 to treat an additional 248 patients, rising to £791,076 in Year 5 to treat an
additional 1,889 patients. Cumulatively over the 5-year timeframe this could lead
to the prevention of 8 ischemic strokes and 3 deaths, as well as an increase of 2
haemorrhagic strokes and 8 bleeds. Conclusions: The clinical benefits of appro-
A481
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
priate anticoagulation are recognised, but full implementation can be difficult and
costly. Therefore the development of models such as this can support the planning
process allowing stakeholders to discuss how best they can reach the target of full
implementation. The model is flexible and can be adapted to suit different payers.
PCV48
Cost Effectiveness Analysis Of Mitraclip In Mitral Regurgitation
For High Risk Patients
Jamet N 1, Bourguignon S 1, Marque S 2
Santé, Evry, France, 2Capionis, Paris, France
.
.
.
1Stratégique
Objectives: Mitral Regurgitation (MR) is a cardiac disease resulting in backflow
of blood from the left ventricle to the left atrium which could increase the risk of
heart failure and mortality. Half of severe MR patients are not considered eligible to surgery (valve repair or replacement) and receive a medical treatment. MR
patient management could benefit from usage of Mitraclip, a transcatheter device,
which enables percutaneous edge-to-edge repair to treat MR. The cost-effectiveness
model presented here compares Mitraclip therapy versus medical standard care
treatment. Methods: A four-state Markov model (Death, MR grade 0, MR grade I
/II, MR grade III/ IV) has been developed. In each state patients could be hospitalized or not. A national payer’s perspective was chosen with a 5 year time horizon.
Primary and secondary endpoints were respectively the number of deaths and of
hospitalizations avoided. Data were obtained from the EVEREST II high-risk study
and from french cost analysis. Results: Within the time horizon analyzed, 276
further deaths could be avoided by using Mitraclip strategy out of 1000 patients
with MR, compared to medical treatment. The Incremental Cost Effectiveness Ratio
(ICER) is estimated at € 93,000 per death averted with cumulative cost on five years.
Sensitivity analysis shows that the cost of the initial surgery and the cost of the
device where the two most sensitive variables. Costs of managing MR are higher for
the Mitraclip option during the first year (€ 29,894 for Mitraclip compared to € 8,557
for medical treatment) option due to the cost of the device and surgery, whereas
this is inversed from the second year onwards (€ 8,557 for the medical option vs.
€ 3,122 for Mitraclip). Therefore, an average ICER (20 720€ per death averted) has also
been calculated. Conclusions: Mitraclip might represent a new economically
attractive treatment option for MR patients at high-risk which increases survival.
PCV49
Cost-Effectiveness And Budget Impact Analyses Of Risk
Stratification Of Patients With Moderate Risk Of Cardiovascular
Events Using Lp-Pla2 Testing
Rinde H 1, Genser B 2, Sonntag D 2, Kleber M E 2, Stojakovic T 3, Scharnagl H 3, Maerz W 4
1BioBridge Strategies, Binningen, Switzerland, 2Mannheim Institue of Public Health, Social
and Preventive Medicine, Mannheim, Germany, 3Medical University of Graz, Graz, Austria,
4Medizinische Fakultät Mannheim der Universität Heidelberg, Mannheim, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: 1) Analyze whether a testing strategy using the biomarker
Lp-PLA2would improve clinical and economic outcomes vs. ESC-SCORE alone in
Germany for 50-70 year-olds. 2) Evaluate the potential budget impact for payers.
Methods: To decide the treatment strategy for patients with moderate risk for
cardiovascular events is a challenge. They would usually not receive statin treatment in Germany. For further risk stratification there is a need to identify patients
with vulnerable plaques. When an arterial plaque becomes unstable Lp-PLA2is
released, which indicate that these patients could benefit from treatment to prevent future cardiovascular events. An integrated cost-effectiveness and budget
impact model was constructed. Lp-PLA2increased the adjusted risk for CVD events
in the moderate ESC-SCORE population by > 2 fold in the German LURIC Study
Cohort (HR 2.23,95% CI 1.15-4.32; P= 0.018). Efficacy of statin treatment relevant
costs were obtained from literature. A range of sensitivity analyses were performed. Results: The cost-effectiveness and the budget impact analyses used a
theoretical population of 1 million, of which 14% were 50-70 year olds with moderate cardiovascular risk. The total 10-year discounted and adherence adjusted
net cost savings from implementing the Lp-PLA2 testing strategy was € 19 million,
or € 156 per Lp-PLA2tested patient. The 10-year accumulated number of deaths
averted by the Lp-PLA2 testing strategy was 611, or 17 incremental discounted
life-days and 2.2 incremental discounted event-free life-months per Lp-PLA 2tested
patient. Projected to whole of Germany’s population aged 50-70 the potential
annual discounted savings from the Lp-PLA2testing strategy would be € 180 million.
The potential number of deaths averted per year would be 5,030. Conclusions:
Our results indicate that the Lp-LPA2 testing strategy is both cost saving and provide reduction in mortality and morbidity. The implementation of Lp-LPA2 testing
strategy should be considered in Germany.
PCV50
Comparing Actual Patient Level Hospital Costs To The Canadian
Cmg+ Costing Estimates For Acute Myocardial Infarction
Chu F 1, Ohinmaa A 1, Jacobs P 2, Zheng Y 2, Kaul P 1
of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada, 2Institute of Health Economics, Edmonton, AB,
Canada
.
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: This study compares differences in actual hospital costs and Case
Mixed Group (CMG+) costs (Canadian version of the Diagnosis Related Group), for
patients with acute myocardial infarction (AMI) in Edmonton, Alberta. Methods:
New AMI (ICD-10 code I21) patients (no AMI hospitalization within one year) hospitalized in Edmonton area hospitals between April 1,2006 and March 30,2009 were
segmented into CMG+ categories by the Canadian Institute for Health Information.
The differences between actual hospital cost and CMG+ cost were analyzed by comparing the mean and median differences between costs for each patient and trimming out 5% of high and low cost patients and excluding patients with longer than
90 days of hospitalization. 15 comorbidities were derived from secondary diagnostic
codes and regressed against CMG+ costs and actual costs independently. The coefficients between the two separate regressions are then tested for statistical equivalence using the Wald test. Results: The data included 4,734 new AMI patients,
and after excluding the outliers and longer than 90 days LOS, the data included
3,428 patients. The estimated mean difference using the average CMG+ estimate
for the whole hospital episode costs were about $500 higher than actual costs. The
median CMG+ cost were most accurate estimates for per diem costs, which was
about $20 higher than actual cost. 2 comorbidities were dropped from the regression
due to multicollinearity. Using average CMG+ estimate for whole hospital episode
costs, 10/13 comorbidity coefficients were found to be statistically equivalent to the
coefficients in a separate regression using actual cost. Conclusions: This study
shows that various derivations of costing proxies using the CMG+ methodology
produce relatively accurate cost estimates for AMI patients when actual cost are
not available. Based on the available patient data and the context of use of the cost
estimates, different methods will be optimal.
PCV51
Cost Estimation Of Home Blood Pressure Monitoring Versus
Combined Office And Ambulatory Measurements In Hypertension
Management
Boubouchairopoulou N 1, Karpettas N 2, Athanasakis K 1, Kollias A 2, Protogerou A D 3,
Achimastos A 2, Stergiou G S 2
1National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece, 2Sotiria Hospital, Athens, Greece, 3Laiko
Hospital, Athens, Greece
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Hypertension is a chronic condition, directly linked to cardiovascular
diseases. Therefore, the monitoring of blood pressure (BP) is of utmost importance in
order to avoid BP-related adverse clinical outcomes. This study aimed at comparing
the health resources consumed and the subsequent costs for hypertension management using home blood pressure monitoring alone (HBPM) vs combined office
measurements and ambulatory blood pressure monitoring (C/ABPM). Methods:
A total of 116 previously untreated, hypertensive subjects were randomized to use
either HBPM or C/ABPM for antihypertensive treatment initiation and titration. The
analysis involved all health resources (BP measurements/outpatient visits, laboratory and other tests, pharmaceutical therapy) utilized within 12-months follow up,
their respective costs, and efficacy (hypertension control). A 5-year projection was
applied assuming (a) continuation of stable treatment as in the end of first year (for
both arms), (b) single ABPM/year in C/ABPM group, (c) 2 visits/year in HBPM group
and 3 in ABPM. Results: The total cost of hypertension management regardless
of BP measurement method was calculated at 1,404.8€ /patient (laboratory tests:
50.4%, BP measurements+outpatient visits: 32.4%, pharmaceuticals: 17.1%). In HBPM
group, total cost was 1,336.0€/patient vs 1,473.5€/patient in C/ABPM group (p<0.001).
Findings suggested that the cost of treatment did not differ between the two groups
(233.1 vs 247.6€/patient respectively, p=NS), while BP measurements+outpatient visits were estimated at 393.9€/patient in HBPM arm and 516.9€/patient in C/ABPM arm
(p< 0.001). For subsequent years (>1), expenditures were estimated at 348.9€/patient
for HBPM vs 440.2€ /patient for C/ABPM group (p< 0.001), whereas for a 5-year projection, 2,731.4€ /patient and 3,234.3€ /patient respectively (p< 0.001). Conclusions:
C/ABPM strategy presented a higher first year cost compared to HBPM, while the
same trend was unveiled in 5-year projection. Effective hypertension management
through the appropriate strategies is of paramount importance considering its high
prevalence; ergo, even small differences in the cost of applying them could have
substantial impact on health expenditures.
PCV52
The Cost Comparison Of Drug-Eluting Stents (Des) And Bare-Metal
Stents (Bms) - A Retrospective Cohort Matched Study
Lang H C 1, Chen T C 1, Chen C H 2
University, Taipei, Taiwan, 2Taipei Veterans General Hospital, Taipei, Taiwan
.
.
.
.
.
.
1National Yang-Ming
Objectives: Literature has failed to demonstrate the clear superiority of Drug-Eluting
Stenting (DES) for stable coronary artery diseases on survival as compared to the baremetal stenting (BMS). This study aimed to compare the health care utilization and
the costs between drug-eluting stenting (DES) and bare-metal stenting (BMS). We also
examined factors that influenced cumulative costs of these two groups. Methods:
We conducted a retrospective cohort study based on the NHI program. Patients who
had coronary stenting between Jan. 2007 and Dec. 2008 were recruited and followed
through the end of 2010. Both groups were matched on 2: 1 by propensity score which
adjusted sex, age, stent number and Charlson comorbidity index (CCI). We estimated
cumulative medical cost for these two matched group by conducting the KaplanMeier Sample Average (KMSA) estimates. Regression analysis was used to explore the
predictors of cost. Results: The mean age in both groups was around 66 years. After
propensity score matching, we had a total of 966 patients; 644 in BMS group and 322
in DES group. KMSA estimates (discounted 3.5%) showed that DES group had a higher
3-year cumulative total outpatient cost at US$ 6,867 and heart related outpatient
cost at US$ 2,548 as compared to BMS group, which were US$7,668 and US$ 3,302
respectively (1US$= 30 NTD). The heart related inpatient cost was similar between two
groups. The significant predictors of heart-related outpatient costs were stent type,
premium and CCI. The predictors of heart-related inpatient costs were stent type,
stent number, CCI and procedure for acute coronary syndrome (ACS). Conclusions:
In Taiwan, NHI reimburses DES and BMS at the same price, and hospitals can balance
billing for the DES. We found that even after adding the extra national average outof-pocket payment to DES, DES still was a cost-effective procedure.
PCV53
Goal Directed Perfusion (Gdp): A Differential Cost Analysis In Uk
And Us
Povero M , Pradelli L
AdRes HE&OR, Turin, Italy
.
.
Objectives: High oxygen delivery (DO2) during cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB)
is associated with better renal outcome in cardiac surgery. Traditional perfusion
(TP) techniques, targeted on body surface area and CPB temperature, achieves high
DO2 in about 50% of the cases while a goal directed perfusion (GDP) approach can
lead to more than 90% of cases achieving high DO2 with a consequent reduction
A482
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
in Acute Kidney Injury (AKI) rate of about 40%. Aim of this study is to perform an
economic evaluation of GDP strategy with respect to TP in UK and US. Methods:
A Discrete Event Simulation model was developed to compare TP and GDP strategy
in patients undergoing CPB. The patient’s pathways from operation to discharging
from hospital was simulated: AKI incidence, in-hospital mortality, hospital length
of stay, transfusions were correlated to probability to achieve high DO2 target using
published correlations. National perspective was adopted to calculate costs associated to each event while GDP strategy was exploited considering card and data
management system (DMS) cost per patient. Results: GDP strategy saved more
than 3 days in hospital and 11% of AKI episodes. The cost-saving is 2,821 £ in UK
and 3,206 $ in US; the cost of card and DMS (79 £ in UK, 110 $ in US) is completely
offset by savings in hospital stay that result the main driver in cost (2,886 £ in UK,
3,222 $ in US). Deterministic sensitivity analysis shows that the total savings are
mainly influenced by hospital LOS, cost per day both in ICU and in ward, and nadir
haematocrit during CPB. Conclusions: GDP seems to improve significantly the
main outcomes related to CPB surgery, when compared to TP techniques. Additional
costs due to perform GDP strategy have no impact on the total cost since completely
offset by the savings in hospital cost.
PCV54
Can A Cvd Polypill Save Money In The ‘Real World’?
Laba T L 1, Hayes A 2, Jan S 1, Rodgers A 1, Patel A 1, Cass A 3, Reid C 4, Tonkin A 4, Usherwood
T 2, Webster R 1
1George Institute for Global Health, University of Sydney, Camperdown, Australia, 2University of
Sydney, Camperdown, Australia, 3Menzies School of Health Research, Darwin, Australia, 4Monash
University, Melbourne, Australia
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
model was a hospital in the United States (US). Clinical data was obtained from US
pivotal studies for the Medtronic stent system and the competing stent systems. The
competition arm (Competition) was created by pooling the pivotal study data for the
current stent systems manufactured by Gore, Endologix, and Cook. Cost data was
obtained from the Premier database (2011-2012) and augmented with the published
literature. All costs were adjusted to 2013 dollars. The model estimated the costs
associated with the following utilization outcomes: procedure time, transfusion rate,
intensive care unit (ICU) length of stay (LOS), and general ward LOS. The following
adverse events were considered: myocardial infarction, respiratory failure, acute
renal failure, stroke/TIA, and second endovascular procedure within 12 months of
the initial procedure. Sensitivity analysis was performed to assess the impact of
imputed data, and one-way sensitivity analysis was performed for each parameter.
Results: The expected costs for a hospital related to the above utilization and
adverse event were $8,463 for Medtronic’s stent graft system and $11,380 for the
Competition. Fifty-six percent of the $2,917 difference was attributable to improved
utilization associated with Medtronic’s stent graft compared to the Competition.
Adverse events and secondary endovascular procedures accounted for 25% and 19%
of the difference, respectively. These results were robust to alternative sensitivity
analyses. Conclusions: This analysis suggested that Medtronic’s current stent
graft is associated with cost savings compared to Competition for the above parameters. Future research is necessary to examine if these results are maintained based
upon a head-to-head clinical study of EVAR stent systems.
.
Objectives: The use of polypills in the prevention of cardiovascular disease is
mooted to reduce costs compared with current practice, yet there is very little
prospectively-collected data to support this claim. The present study compares
the ‘real-world’ costs of a polypill strategy against usual care among Australians
with established cardiovascular disease or at high estimated cardiovascular
risk. Methods: A ‘within trial’ cost analysis from the Australian health system
perspective of polypill-based care versus usual care with separate medications
was conducted using data from the pragmatic randomised controlled trial Kanyini
Guidelines Adherence to Polypill (Kanyini GAP) and linked health service and medication claims data. The primary outcome, estimated with generalised linear models,
was mean health service and pharmaceutical expenditure, per patient per year.
All costs during the trial, conducted from 2008-2012, were inflated to $AUD 2012
prices. Results: A statistically significantly lower mean pharmaceutical expenditure of $989 (95%CI 648 to 1331) per patient per year in the polypill arm compared
to usual care (P< 0.001, adjusted, excluding polypill cost). No significant differences
were observed in annual non-hospital health service expenditure ($40, 95%CI -202 to
281 per patient). Conclusions: This study provides evidence that a cardiovascular
disease polypill strategy has the potential to produce significant cost-savings to
health systems. At an estimated reimbursement cost of $1 per day for the polypill,
these savings would have amounted to over $600 per patient per year. Cost-savings
would accrue to patients also, given fewer prescription charges. Linking health
service and medication claims data with data from a pragmatic randomised controlled trial has provided an avenue to assess the real-world cost implications of
introducing this new technology into clinical practice.
PCV55
Study Of Costs Of The Cardiac And Diabetes Mellitus Patient In A
Cardiology Hospital Of High Complexity
Costa M G S D 1, Santos M S 2, Tura B R 2, Goulart M C 2, Cintra M A C T 2, Senna K M S 1
de Janeiro, Brazil, 2National Institute of Cardiology, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1INC, Rio
Objectives: There is a growing prevalence of diabetes mellitus (DM) among chronic
diseases in the world. Currently there are over 135 million people with diabetes
worldwide with estimates reaching 300 million in 2025. Developing countries concentrate two thirds of these patients and it is known that the economic burden of
chronic diseases generate high costs for the health system and social welfare as
a function of mortality and premature disability. The objective of the study was to
investigate the impact on hospital costs of treating a patient with ischemic heart
disease and DM, compared with cardiac patients without DM, in a cardiology hospital of high complexity Ministry of Health in Brazil. Methods: observational study
of historical cohort of 421 diabetic heart disease (CD) and non diabetic (CND), from
January 2009 to March 2010 in cardiology hospital of high complexity of the Unified
Health System (SUS) in Brazil. Were only covered the direct medical costs of hospitalizations. The costs of the study population (CD and CND) were grouped into
surgery, and clinical treatment obtained by two different approaches (top-down and
bottom-up estimates), and subsequently analyzed and compared using R software
version 3.0. Results: No differences between groups were observed. Cost of surgery: CND = U. S. $ 2937.55 and U. S. $ 3024.51 = CD (p = 0.319). Medical Treatment:
CND = U. S. $ 685.09 and U. S. $ 304.11 = CD (p = 0.218). Values are expressed as
medians. Conclusions: studies analyzing these conditions separately describe
high expenses resulting from the treatment of diabetes and cardiovascular disease.
We can infer from the results of this study that the diabetic patient cardiac does not
generate a significant financial impact for a cardiology hospital of high complexity.
PCV56
A Cost Comparison Analysis Of Medtronic’s Stent Graft System
To Competition For Endovascular Aneurysm Repair For Abdominal
Aortic Aneurysms
Mallow P J 1, Baniewicz J 2, Williams J M 2, Au-Yeung A 2
Clinical Trial and Consulting, Cincinnati, OH, USA, 2Medtronic, Inc, Mounds View, MN, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
1CTI
Objectives: To perform a cost comparison analysis of Medtronic’s current stent
graft system compared to currently competing stent graft systems for endovascular aneurysm repair (EVAR) of abdominal aortic aneurysms (AAA). Methods:
A simulation model was constructed using Microsoft Excel. The perspective of the
PCV57
Hospitalizations And Costs In Patients With Implantable
Cardioverter Defibrillators: Association Of Long VersUS Standard
Detection Intervals
Borghetti F 1, Proclemer A 2, Arenal A 3, Kloppe A 4, Lunati M 5, Ferrer J B M 6, Hersi A 7, Gulaj
M 8, Wijffels M C E F 9, Santi E 10, Manotta L 11, Beccagutti G 1, Campo C 11, Gasparini M 12
1Medtronic Italia, Sesto San Giovanni (MI), Italy, 2Azienda Ospedaliero Universitaria S. Maria
della Misericordia, Udine, Italy, 3Hospital General Universitario Gregorio Marañón, Madrid, Spain,
4Berufsgenossenschaftliches Universitätsklinikum Bergmannsheil, Bochum, Germany, 5Azienda
Ospedaliera Niguarda Ca’ Granda, Milano, Italy, 6Hospital de Txagorritxu, Vitoria (Álava), Spain,
7College of Medicine, King Saud University, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, 8MSWiA Hospital, Bialystok,
Poland, 9St. Antonius Ziekenhuis Hospital, Nieuwegein, The Netherlands, 10MEDTRONIC Clinical
Research Institute, Roma, Italy, 11MEDTRONIC Clinical Research Institute, Sesto S. Giovanni, Italy,
12Humanitas Research Hospital, IRCCS, Rozzano (MI), Italy
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: ADVANCEIII trial showed that a long detection programming reduces
all delivered therapies as well as inappropriate shocks in patients implanted with
implantable cardioverter defibrillator (ICD). The purpose of this Advance III secondary analysis was to assess the impact of long detection on hospitalizations (H),
length of stay (LOS) and associated costs for the health care system. Methods:
1902 patients enrolled in the ADVANCEIII Trial: 948 patients randomized to long
detection (NID 30/40) and 954 to short setting (NID 18/24). All hospitalizations
were reviewed and classified according to ICD9CM codes and, consequently, to the
corresponding Diagnosis-Related Groups (DRGs). Costs correspond to the specific
public tariffs for the DRGs applied. The prospective was of a single-payer agent
(Italian Ministry of Health). Results: Over a median period of 12 months, rates
of overall and cardiovascular hospitalizations (CV) were lower in the long detection group (43.8*100 pts/years (39.6-48.4) vs 52.3*100 pts/years (47.7-57.3), IRR: 0.84
(0.73-0.96) p= 0.005,32.7*100 pts/years (29.1-36.7) vs 40.3*100 pts/years (36.2-44.6),
IRR (95% CI): 0.81 (0.69-0.95) p= 0.004 respectively). Patients programmed with a
long detection had shorter LOS (overall H: 407days (394-421) vs 470 days (456-484),
IRR: 0.87 (0.83-0.91) p< 0.001; CV: 298 days (287-309) vs 368 days (356-381), IRR: 0.81
(0.77-0.85) p< 0.001) and lower mean hospital cost per patient-year compared with
patients with nominal programming (overall H: 1.311 € (1.309 € - 1.314 € ) versus
1.528€ (1.525€ - 1.530€ ) IRR: 0.86 (0.86-0.86) p< 0.001; CV: 1.100 € (1.098 € - 1.103 € )
versus 1.339 € (1.337 € - 1.342 € ) IRR: 0.86 (0.86-0.86) p< 0.001). Conclusions:
A long detection window was associated with a reduction in hospitalization rates,
total length of stay and cost per patients both for all-causes and cardiovascular
related events.
PCV58
Economics And Clinical Evaluation Of Endovascular And Surgical
Treatment Of Patients With Disability Of Superficial Femoral
Artery
Kamensky V , Ivlev I
Czech Technical University in Prague, Kladno, Czech Republic
.
.
Objectives: The rising cost of treatment of peripheral arterial disease and the
growing incidence of this disease led to economic analysis of arterial disease. With
the increasing price of modern instrumentation, it is appropriate to evaluate not
only clinical efficiency, but also intervention economics. This study aims to create a
recommendation for choosing the most effective treatment based on both economic
data and clinical outputs of the disabled superficial femoral artery. Methods: The
methods chosen were reviewed from clinical outputs for treatment effectiveness,
multiple-criteria decision-making for the synthesis of treatment effects, analysis of
costs at the selected interventions and cost-effectiveness analysis. Results: The
four clinical outputs used in the study as a criterion by the research of the clinical
studies were primary patency, technical success, patient survival and limb salvage at
the year of operation. The weights of each criterion, and the preferences of the interventions were counted. The sequence of interventions was set by the AHP method:
PTA (35.6%), PTA/S (33.9%) and bypass (30.6%) and method of weighted sum: PTA/S
(56%), bypass (55%) and PTA (42%). From the view of both health insurance payer and
health care provider, where the direct medical expenditures were included, the order
of intervention was the same: PTA, bypass and PTA/S. The cost-effectiveness was
calculated for both, and the PTA intervention achieved the best results. Incremental
expenditures by unit of effect was calculated for each effect: ICER or the domination
of one intervention over another was set. Ratio of the ICER was generally higher for
PTA/S compared to bypass. In the sensitive analysis was determined the influence of
A483
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
the direct medical expenditures on the final outputs. Conclusions: The treatment
of disabled superficial femoral artery was compared from chosen clinical outputs,
economic expenditures and cost-effectiveness. On this basis, the recommendation
was set for choosing the most effective treatment.
PCV59
Interest Of A Hospital Database To Analyze The Cost For Acute
Stroke: The Example Of Versailles Hospital
Bourguignon S 1, Milojevic K 2, Lemaire B 2, Le Lay K 3, Faille S 2, Parisse S 2, Pico F 2, Lambert
Y2
1Stratégique Santé, Evry, France, 2Centre Hospitalier de Versailles, Le Chesnay, France, 3Boehringer
Ingelheim France, Paris, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
greater LOS and 32.3% greater ICU LOS (both p< 0.001) than patients not receiving
blood. In patients who received blood, total cost of hospital stay was 22.7% greater
including blood product cost and 21.7% greater excluding blood product cost (both
p< 0.001). Conclusions: Preventing or rapidly controlling bleeding in patients
undergoing complex cardiac surgery would likely reduce patient risk and avoid
elevated costs of hospitalization.
PCV62
The Cost Burden Of Syncope At A Hospital Level In Spain
Egea M 1, Marti B 1, Álvarez M 2
Iberia, Madrid, Spain, 2Hospital Universitario del Henares, Coslada, Spain
.
.
.
1Medtronic
Objectives: Stroke generates an important socioeconomic burden and heavy
hospital expenses. The objective of this study was to evaluate the impact of delay
to manage stroke for patients transported by Mobile Intensive Care Units (MICU)
in outcomes and early hospital costs. Cost of management and NHISS (National
Institute of Health Stroke Score) score regression at patient discharge have been
described for three different stroke management time groups. Methods: A retrospective study was conducted from a database containing records of 427 patients
diagnosed with stroke. Patients were classified as “short delay” (stroke managed
within 45 minutes), “medium delay” (45 minutes to 2 hours) and “long delay” (above
2 hours). 3 homogenous groups of 100 patients were established, adjusted on age,
gender, stroke mechanism (ischemic or hemorrhagic), NIHSS score and comorbidity.
Hospital Database (PMSI - French National Hospital Information Systems Program)
recorded information between 2004 and 2013. ResultsThe number of deaths was
respectively 17 for « short delay », 25 for « medium delay » and 42 for « long delay ».
The average cost for one hospital stay for stroke was € 15,812 for the « short delay
» group, € 20,639 for « medium delay » and € 20,184 for « long delay ». “Short delay”
treated patients retrieve an average of 8.41 points compared to 1.87 for “long delay”
patients. Conclusions: These results show a correlation between the delay in
managing stroke and early hospital costs and improvement of NIHSS scores. These
results are part of a study performed through the PMSI database aiming at calculating the average cost of retrieving one-point NIHSS impairment. They underline the
importance of an early treatment of stroke.
Objectives: Syncope, defined as a transient loss of consciousness that leads to a
spontaneous recovery without consequences, is very prevalent. It is known that syncope related admissions (principal diagnosis) are associated with a high cost burden
for the Spanish National Health System, but little is known about the number of
hospitalisations due to injuries caused by the fall (secondary diagnosis). The objective of this study was to estimate the burden and cost of syncope from the Spanish
Health Care System perspective. Methods: Admissions with a primary diagnosis
of syncope and admissions for injuries and pacemaker/defibrillator implantations
where syncope was coded as a secondary diagnosis were analysed. The source of
data was the Spanish Basic Minimum Data Set and the period 2001-2010. Results:
The annual incidence of syncope-related admission was 4.22 cases/10,000 inhab.
The annual average number of admissions was 15,703, including 77.5% syncope as a
primary diagnosis. The total annual cost of syncope related admissions was € 46mill,
from which a 46.4% was associated to injuries where syncope was coded as a secondary diagnosis. The average cost of a patient admitted with syncope as a primary
and secondary diagnosis was € 2,062 (min €1,556 – max €28,772) and €5,996 (min €719
– max €26,940) respectively. The average length of stay for patients with syncope as a
primary and secondary diagnosis was 5.17 and 9.33 days respectively. Conclusions:
Syncope has an important cost burden resulted from the high number of hospitalisations and the length of stay associated. The cost of a patient admitted with syncope
as a secondary diagnosis was nearly 3 times higher than a patient with a primary
diagnosis of syncope. It is important to implement health strategies to diagnose
these patients in order to assure an efficient management of the available resources.
PCV60
Burden Of Cardiovascular Complications In Patients With Atrial
Fibrillation In France
PCV63
Clnical Management Of Non-Valvular Atrial Fibrillation In Hong
Kong
Fauchier L 1, Samson A 2, Chaize G 3, Gaudin A F 4, Vainchtock A 3, Bailly C 5, Cotté F E 5
1Service de Cardiologie B et Laboratoire d’Electrophysiologie Cardiaque, Pôle Cœur Thorax
Vasculaire, Centre Hospitalier Universitaire Trousseau, Chambray-les-Tours, France, 2ParisDauphine University, Paris, France, 3HEVA, Lyon, France, 4Bristol-Myers Squibb, Rueil-Malmaison,
France, 5Bristol-Myers Squibb, Rueil Malmaison, France
Lee V W 1, Chiu L Y 1, Chung S L 1, Lau C Y 1, Yousaf S 1, Wong H 1, Lam Y Y 2, Yan B P 2
1Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, Hong Kong, 2Chinese University of Hong Kong,
Shatin, Hong Kong, China
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Atrial fibrillation (AF) is associated with numerous cardiovascular (CV) complications. The objective of this study was to estimate the national
annual burden of CV complications in patients with AF in hospitals. Methods:
All patients hospitalized in 2012 with a diagnosis of AF were identified from the
French National public/private hospital database (PMSI). Comorbidities and medical
data were collected during a 5-year look-back period and used to calculate stroke
risk score (CHA2DS2-VASc). Reasons for CV-related hospitalization, emergency
admission, rehabilitation and death at discharge were described. Costs of acute
care were determined using Diagnosis Related Groups and corresponding tariffs
(2012 Euros). Results: In total, 533,044 AF patients were hospitalized for any reason. Mean age was 78.0(±11.4) years, 53% were males and mean CHA2DS2-VASc
score was 4.0(±1.8). CV-related hospitalizations occurred in 267,681 patients: 34%
for AF management care, 28% for heart failure, 8% for strokes, 7% for other ischemic
heart diseases, 5% for vascular diseases, 4% for transient ischemic attacks and
systemic embolisms, 2% for bleedings and 12% for other CV reasons. In CV-related
hospitalizations, 45% of patients required emergency admission, especially patients
hospitalized for strokes (75%) and for bleedings (67%). Death at hospital occurred in
6% of patients with a CV-related hospitalization: 17% in patients with strokes and
10% in patients with bleedings. Rehabilitation was needed for 34% patients with
non-fatal strokes with a mean length of 48 days. The annual total cost (acute care
and rehabilitation) for all hospitalized CV events during the year 2012 was €1.94 billion. Among this, heart failure represented € 518m, AF management € 306m, strokes
€ 291m and hemorrhages € 48m. Conclusions: A half-million AF patients were
hospitalized in 2012 in France. CV-related hospitalizations involved over a quartermillion AF patients for a global burden of almost € 2 billion.
PCV61
Cost Of Bleeding In Complex Cardiac Surgery
Magee G 1, Whyte J 2, Zbrozek A 2
1Premier Inc., Charlotte, NC, USA, 2CSL Behring, King of Prussia, NC, USA
.
.
.
Objectives: In complex cardiac surgery there is a high demand for blood/blood
products. Their administration can be costly. Our goal was to assess the cost of
care and outcomes for complex cardiac surgery patients based on bleeding status. Methods: Patients >18 years, discharged between January 2010 and December
2012, were identified in the Premier Hospital Database based on ICD9 codes and
categorized as having received blood/blood products or not. Patients who received
blood products prior to the day of surgery were excluded. Differences in treatment
costs and outcomes were assessed using univariate analysis and multivariate modeling. Results: A total of 463,734 patients (82,832 Bleeding; 380,902 Non-Bleeding)
were included. Patients who received blood were older (> 65 years: 62.3% vs. 49.8%),
sicker (Charlson Comorbidity Index > 3: 22.5% vs. 15.4%), with greater rates of cerebrovascular disease (10.2% vs. 4.3%), PVD (18.2% vs. 9.4%), CHF (33.0% vs. 18.6%),
renal dx (20.9% vs. 13.5%) and CPD (25.3% vs. 18.7%) than those who did not. Models
adjusting for patient factors showed that patients who received blood were 4.54
times as likely to be admitted to the ICU, 3.40 times as likely to die and 4.59 times as
likely to be readmitted for bleeding within 30 days (all p< 0.001). They also had 49.1%
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The present study aimed to investigate the cost of non-valvular atrial
fibrillation (NVAF) management in Hong Kong. Methods: We analyzed consecutive patients with documented NVAF enrolled in the Prince of Wales Hospital Atrial
Fibrillation Registry between February 2013 and February 2014.. Patient clinical characteristics, prescribed therapies and adverse clinical events were extracted from the
hospital electronic Clinical Management System. One-year direct health care costs
including costs of medications, accident and emergency admissions, hospitalizations,
clinical visits, coagulation tests and computed tomography of brain scans were estimated from a health care provider perspective. Results: Of 534 NVAG patients, 45.9%
were male with a mean age of 75.8±10.2 years. The average CHADS2, CHAsDSsVASc
and HASBLED scores were 2.44±1.39,4. 12±1.77 and 3.26±1.09, respectively. 66.7% of
patients were taking rate control medications only. Patients taking both rate and
rhythm control medications were associated with the highest rate of hospitalizations due to poor AF control (28.2%) when compared to using neither rate or rhythm
control drugs, rate control or rhythm control groups (p < 0.0005). The overall use of
anticoagulants including both warfarin and new oral anticoagulants was 66.9%. The
main reason for patients with CHADS2 score ≥ 2 not receiving anticoagulant was
patient refusal (20%) and physicians’ opinion (40%). The one-year median cost of
managing patients with stroke was higher than those without stroke (Euro$ 5521.2
versus Euro$ 1075.2) from the health care provider perspectives during the study
period. Conclusions: Majority of NVAF patients in Hong Kong were prescribed
rate control medications only. The clinical use of antithrombotic therapy for stroke
prevention was more conservative than guideline recommendations. It was more
costly (5 times more) to manage patients with stroke than patients without stroke.
PCV64
The Economic Impact Of Cardiovascular Events In Patients Post
Myocardial Infarction: Uk Health Care Perspective
Jain M 1, Sonathi V 1, Rathi H 1, Thomas S K 2, Mollon P 3
Healthcare Pvt. Ltd., Hyderabad, India, 2Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation, East
Hanover, NJ, USA, 3Novaris Pharma AG, Basel, Switzerland
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Novartis
Objectives: There is a high risk of recurring cardiovascular (CV) events in patients
post myocardial infarction (MI) despite the current standard of care (SoC). The aim
of this study was to estimate the current economic burden of CV events for patients
after having an MI event. Methods: A lifetime markov model was developed from
a UK health care perspective to capture progression post-MI. Recurrent MI, stroke
and CV deaths were the major CV events captured. A comparison of cost (2012 UK£)
and outcomes in terms of QALYs and life years (LYs) was made between the current scenario of patients receiving SOC and a hypothetical scenario where post-MI
patients had no subsequent CV events. All cost and outcomes were discounted at
3.5% per annum. Results: The current cumulative lifetime event rate of non-fatal
MI, non-fatal stroke and CV death post-MI was estimated to be 0.432,0. 06 and
0.42/patient respectively. The total lifetime cost was estimated to be £6,926/post-MI
patient without CV events, which was 31% lower than the current estimated cost
of £9,959/post-MI patient. At current rates of CV events there was an incremental
lifetime loss of 4.3 LYs/patient and 3.5 QALYs/patient when compared to the hypothetical scenario where patients had no CV events. Considering the prevalence of
MI to be 1.5 million, the economic burden posed by MI patients over lifetime if they
A484
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
had no recurrent CV events was estimated to be £10.4 billion versus £14.94 billion
with recurring CV events under current SOC. This translated into a 43.8% higher
economic burden on health care. Conclusions: The subsequent CV events in
post-MI patients pose an additional economic burden of 44% on UK health care
despite the current SoC. This indicates the need to design new interventions to
reduce the risk of further CV events in post-MI patients.
PCV65
The Costs Of Atherosclerotic And Haemorrhagic Events Associated
With Acute Coronary Syndrome (Acs) In Turkey
Parali E 1, Ozdemir O 2, Aykut Aka S 3, Afsar N 4, Degertekin M 5, Ergene O 6, Ongen Z 7,
Ozdemir M 8, Deger C 1, Asan Z S 1, Sumer F 1, Ozel M O 1
1Bayer Turk Kimya San. Ltd. Sti., Istanbul, Turkey, 2Yorum Consultancy, ISTANBUL, Turkey,
3Siyami Ersek Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery Training and Research Hospital, Istanbul,
Turkey, 4Medical Park Hospital, Istanbul, Turkey, 5Yeditepe University Hospital, Istanbul, Turkey,
69 Eylül Faculty of Medicine, Izmir, Turkey, 7Istanbul University Cerrahpasa Faculty of Medicine,
Istanbul, Turkey, 8Gazi University, Ankara, Turkey
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate the costs of atherosclerotic and haemorrhagic events
associated with Acute Coronary Syndrome (ACS) treated with ASA + Clopidogrel,
in Turkish settings. Methods: An expert panel was organized to reflect the solid
data regarding disease management patterns and options to Turkish payer for
reimbursement process. Due to the multidisciplinary nature of the ACS, physicians from the cardiology, neurology and cardiovascular surgery participated
to panel. Cost components of bleeding events, haemorrhagic stroke, ischemic
stroke, myocardial infarction and revascularization have been identified. Experts
have reviewed their daily clinical practices and local & global literature for the
related complications along with medical procedures. All cost components including medications, hospitalization, surgical treatments follow up procedures and
rehabilitation were considered. For the prices of medications, and diagnostic and
therapeutic procedures, March 2014 local prices have been taken into account.
For Turkish Lira: Euro conversion, Turkish Central Bank March 2013 currency rate
(was used TL/Euro = 3.06). Results: The cost of MI in the first year is 2.004€ and
376€ for the following years. (≈%70) of the cost comes from non-pharmacological
treatment. Costs of ischemic and hemorrhagic stroke for the acute period and following three months are 2.266 € and 3.010€ , respectively. Annual cost of ischemic
and haemorrhagic strokes are 2.951€ and 3.646€ for the first year. The main cost
drivers for stroke are also non-pharmacological treatments, mainly physiotherapy
for stroke. (≈%70-80 for the 1st year) Coronary revascularization costs 833€ for
percutaneous interventionand 2.354€ for coronary by-pass. Bleeding costs are
relatively low compared to other complications. Major and minor bleedings are
189€ /event and 17€ /event. Conclusions: Costs of the ACS related complications
are quite high. Especially acute phase of MI and stroke has significant burden of
the budget. More effective secondary prevention of the ACS might reduce the
burden of disease in the Turkish settings.
PCV66
Pharmacoeconomic Burden Of Statins In Patients With Ischemic
Heart Disease In The Health Care Of Belarus
Kozhanova I 1, Romanova I I 1, Gavrilenko L 1, Sachek M 2
1Belarusian State Medical University, Minsk, Belarus, 2The Belarusian Center for Medical
Technologies, Computer Systems, Administration and Management of Health, Minsk, Belarus
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The aim of this study has been determination of the burden of statins in
the treatment of acute coronary syndrome (ACS) and angina pectoris (AP). There is a
significant number of registered statins (brands and generics) in Belarus (lovastatin,
atorvastatin simvastatin and rosuvastatin). Pharmacoeconomic studies of statins are
topical because of the competition at the pharmaceutical market to ensure rational
use of public and private funds. Methods: Overview of available statins has been
conducted. Equivalent effective doses were established on the basis of the published
data. “Cost of illness” has been calculated with the help of national clinical guidelines
for treatment of ACS and AP. Comparison of the each statin burden by determining
the proportion of funds falling at each one in the overall cost of the patient´s care has
been made. Results: Cost of statins had no significant value in the overall “cost of
illness” for acute coronary pathology (ranged from 0.3% to 1.88%). The cost of statins
has a significant impact on the final “cost of illness” in the case of chronic cardiac
pathology and ranges from 18.54% to 39.9%. Burden of rosuvastatin (Mertenil) in
this analysis seems to be the most stable and predictable because of the changes
in a narrow range (23.9% - 26.48% in the first year and 28.48% - 29.49% - the second
and subsequent years) vs. atorvastatin (19.35% - 35.7% in the first year and 23.3% 39.9% in the second and subsequent years) and simvastatin (18.54% - 32.62% in the
first year and 22.13% - 35.89% in the second and subsequent years). Conclusions:
Pharmacoeconomic evaluation of statin choosing is important for prolonged use of
medicines but not for short-term use in acute coronary syndrome.
PCV67
A Systematic Review Of Cost-Of-Illness Studies In Chronic Heart
Failure
Lesyuk W , Kriza C , Kolominsky-Rabas P L
Centre for Health Technology Assessment (HTA) and Public Health (IZPH), Friedrich-AlexanderUniversity Erlangen-Nürnberg, Erlangen, Germany
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The aim of this study was to perform a systematic review of recently
published Cost of Illness (COI) studies related to Chronic Heart Failure (CHF) to highlight the increasing cost impact associated with the disease and identify the major
cost drivers. Methods: A systematic review was conducted from 2004-2014 to
identify COI studies related to CHF, searching the PubMed, Science Direct, Cochrane
Library, Scopus and York CRD databases. The PRISMA guidelines were applied for the
search. Results: 12 studies were included in this review and were grouped into a
prevalence- and an incidence-based approach. Most articles were considering only
the direct medical costs (hospitalization, medication, primary care) of CHF, while
some of them also assessed the economic impact of indirect care, i.e. informal care
provided by nonprofessionals. The costs of indirect care were reported to be considerably higher than the direct costs. Direct annual costs range from 1,869€ for Poland to
22,230$ for the US. The costs for inpatient care generate the main part of the direct
economic burden. In the majority of cases the economic impact is referred to the
severity of the CHF expressed by the New York Heart Association functional classification (NYHA) stage. The more severe NYHA stages III and IV are associated with
higher costs. Conclusions: Our review highlights the considerable and growing
economic burden of CHF on the health care systems of developed countries. The
COI studies included in this review show large variations in methodology used and
the cost results vary as a consequence. Further research is needed to highlight the
economic burden of indirect costs of CHF. High quality data from COI studies with a
robust methodology applied can inform policy makers about the major cost drivers
of CHF and can be used as the basis of further economic evaluations.
PCV68
The Cost Of Illness Of Atrial Fibrillation In Italy: A Cohort Of
Hospitalized Patients
Fornari C 1, Conti S 1, Ciampichini R 1, Chiodini V 1, Mantovani L G 2, Madotto F 1, Cesana G 1
of Milano - Bicocca, Monza, Italy, 2Federico II University of Naples, Naples, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: Atrial Fibrillation (AF) is the most common sustained cardiac arrhythmia. The increasing prevalence of AF and the advances in the management of the
disease in recent years highlight the importance of updating cost of illness studies
to understand both the financial burden and the related health care resource use.
The main purpose of this study was to perform a cost analysis of AF hospitalized
cases in a large general population of Italy from the perspective of the Health System
(HS). Methods: This is an observational retrospective cohort study conducted
using automatic health care administrative archives of the Italian publicly funded
HS. The study cohort included all subjects living in Lombardy, a region of Northern
Italy, with a hospital discharge for AF or flutter (index event) in the time period 1st
January 2003 - 31st December 2009. A pre-index period of eligibility shorter than 3
years was an exclusion criterion. Subjects were followed until 31stDecember 2010 or
death or emigration, collecting data related to hospitalizations, drug prescriptions
and outpatient visits and related direct costs. Results: The mean age of patients
admitted to hospital with a diagnosis of AF was 72 years (± 14.1 standard deviation).
Women were older than men and 50% of patients were male. Major comorbidities
at index event were: congestive heart failure, cerebrovascular diseases, chronic
pulmonary diseases and diabetes. The mean cost of index hospitalization was about
3,600 € (± 3,900 € ). Survival at one year from index event was 83%, 66% at four years
and 53% at seven years. The main driver of direct medical cost during follow-up
was inpatient care, followed by drug therapies. Conclusions: AF resulted in a
substantial medical cost, reflecting resource-intensive and long-term treatments.
These costs accompanied with increasing prevalence of AF, justify increased attention to the management of patients with AF.
PCV69
Cost Of Illness: Heart Failure In Ireland
Corry S E 1, McDonald K 2, Kennelly B 3
1Novartis Ltd, Dublin, Ireland, 2St Vincents University Hospital, Dublin, Ireland,, 3National
University of Ireland Galway, Galway, Ireland
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Map and cost the patient pathway for acute and chronic heart failure patients in Ireland. Obtain the key cost parameters using a top down approach,
whilst highlighting the economic and societal impact of this non communicable
disease. Methods: A prevalence based top down approach was applied to estimate
the cost of heart failure in Ireland for the year 2012, taking a societal perspective.
Data on primary and all case diagnoses were obtained from the National Hospital
In-Patient Enquiry Scheme (HIPE). Market research identified admissions in private
hospital. Patients hospitalised with heart failure have been taken as representative
of patients with Acute Decompensated Heart Failure (ADHF). All treatment pathways
associated with the direct cost of both prevalent and incident cases of heart failure
were confirmed and validated by health care professionals in primary and secondary
care settings. Indirect and economic costs consisted of informal care and Life Years
Lost (LYL), respectively. These were estimated using national surveys and registries,
such as the Central Statistics Office (CSO). LYL were monetised using Irish specific
life tables and the value of a statistical and/or the QALY threshold. Where data were
lacking or uncertain, treatment algorithms were confirmed and validated through
scientific engagement with key opinion leaders. Results: The total cost of heart
failure in Ireland for the year 2012 was estimated at € 662.3 million. Indirect and economic costs were identified as the largest cost component at €473.7m (76%), while the
direct cost represented 24% of the cost burden. Conclusions: Once HF has developed, the pathophysiology of the condition is characterised by high morbidity and
mortality, frequent hospitalisation, and a large reliance on informal care. This study
identified large regional variation in available heart failure services, hence impacting
the necessary follow up care. As a result, a substantial cost driver in the management
and care of heart failure patients is informal care. This cost has not been considered
in previous heart failure studies, making it an important area for future research.
PCV70
Cost Of Bleeding In Trauma Patients
Zbrozek A
CSL Behring, King of Prussia, PA, USA
.
Objectives: Trauma patients often experience significant hemorrhage and, therefore, may require more resources during hospitalization than patients who do not
hemorrhage. The cost of blood/blood products is poorly understood in trauma patients
and not well documented in the literature. Our objective was to evaluate the outcomes
and cost of care for trauma patients based on bleeding status. Methods: Patients
with costs and length of stay (LOS) greater than zero, discharged between January 1,
2010 and December 31, 2012, were identified in the Premier Hospital Database based
on select ICD9 codes. All costs were based on hospital reported costs. Patients who
received blood products prior to the day of surgery were excluded. Multivariate regres-
A485
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
sion models for costs and LOS used log transformation techniques. Results: A total
of 62,527 patients (8,800 Bleeding; 53,727 Non-Bleeding) were included. Patients who
received blood/blood products were significantly different in a number of baseline
characteristics including Charlson Comorbidity Index. Unadjusted outcomes demonstrated significant differences in mean total costs ($43,375 Bleeding; $18,411 NonBleeding; p<0.001) and LOS (13.62 Bleeding; 7.53 Non-Bleeding; p< 0.001) for patients
who received blood products compared with those who did not. Multivariate models
adjusting for patient characteristics demonstrated that patients who received blood/
blood products had 38.9% greater LOS and 34.3% greater ICU LOS. They also were
3.53 times as likely to be admitted to the ICU, 3.75 times as likely to be readmitted
for bleeding and 4.09 times as likely to die in hospital (all p<0.001). Furthermore,
they had 32.9% greater total cost of care including blood product cost and 31.8%
greater total cost of care excluding blood product cost (both p<0.001). Conclusions:
Preventing or rapidly controlling emergent bleeding in trauma patients would likely
reduce patient risk and avoid elevated costs of hospitalization.
Average costs of treating unstable angina were € 2,217 - 3,644 PA. Direct medical costs
of chronic HF patients were between € 3,150 - 4,792 per patient per year. Average treatment costs for hospitalized PAD in the acute phase were € 4,186 PA, € 2,138 during
month 1-6 after initial hospitalization, € 1,350 in month 7-12, and € 1,172 in month
13-18. For stroke, total direct medical costs in year one were € 11,408 per patient. Total
direct medical costs during the 1st year after an ischemic stroke event were € 15,573
- 18,517 per patient, € 5,280 in month 13-18, and € 5,479 per year in the subsequent 4
years. Conclusions: MI, unstable angina, HF, stroke and PAD have a high financial
impact on the German health care system. Treatment costs in the first year after event
were highest for MI with €11,672 – 12,713 per patient followed by stroke with € 11,408
per patient demonstrating need for improvement in preventing CVE.
PCV75
Annual Cost Of Conservative Treatment Of Supraventricular
Tachycardias In Poland
Farkowski M M 1, Golicki D 2, Czech M 3, Pytkowski M 1, Maciag A 1, Wood K A 4, Kowalik I 1,
Szwed H 1
1Institute of Cardiology, Warsaw, Poland, 2HealthQuest, Warsaw, Poland, 3Medical University of
Warsaw, Warsaw, Poland, 4Duke University School of Nursing, Durham, NC, USA
.
PCV71
The Economic Impact Of Hypertension In Health Care System Of
Pakistan
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
PCV72
Hospital Costs Of Ischemic Stroke And Transient Ischemic Attack In
The Netherlands
Objectives: Supraventricular tachycardias (SVT) are a group of arrhythmias which
result in significant impairment of health-related quality of life (HRQoL). While not
as common as atrial fibrillation, SVT are still a significant health care problem since
an average time from the onset of symptoms to successful ablation exceeds 10 years
both in highly and less developed countries. The aim of this study was to calculate
an annual cost of conservative treatment of SVT in Poland. Methods: This was
an economical part of The PPRA study (NCT01594814). PPRA was a single-center,
prospective, cohort study conducted in tertiary care cardiology center in Poland. All
data concerning health care resources utilization: outpatient and inpatient visits,
emergency room (ER) consultations, drugs etc. were derived from the study. Costs of
disease related groups (DRG), outpatient visits and reimbursed drugs were derived
from official price lists of Polish National Health Fund (NHF). Costs of ER visits were
calculated as a mean cost of visit derived from seven hospitals of different levels of
care. Costs of medical transport were calculated as a mean cost derived from four
different centers providing ambulance services. Cost of non-reimbursed drugs and
of outpatient visits and diagnostic tests in private sector were calculated as a mean
cost of those resources available on official websites of nation-wide providers. All
costs are presented in Euro (EUR) as median [interquartile range]. Results: During
1.5 years, 82 patients were enrolled and the data for this analysis was available for all
patients. The yearly median cost of conservative treatment of SVT was EUR 415 [237727] from the NHS perspective and EUR 468 [280-793] from the societal perspective.
Those costs were mainly driven by costs of hospitalizations and ER. Conclusions:
Annual cost of conservative treatment of SVT is substantial and driven mainly by
hospital services.
Buisman L R 1, Tan S S 1, Koudstaal P J 2, Nederkoorn P J 3, Redekop W K 1
1Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 2Erasmus MC, University Medical
Center Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 3Academic Medical Center, University of
Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
PCV76
Linking Health Care Administrative Databases And National
Registry Data In Order To Monitor Icd Therapy In Italy
Iqbal M S 1, Iqbal M W 2, Bahari M B B 1, Iqbal M Z 1
1Department of Clinical Pharmacy, Faculty of Pharmacy, AIMST University, Kedah, Malaysia,
2Faculty of Law, Universiti Malaya,, Kualalumpur, Malaysia
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Hypertension (HTN) is a severe public health issue across the globe
and a major risk factor for various cardiovascular diseases. This study was aimed
to examine the potential costs of prognostic utilities and direct and indirect
health care costs of the treatment of HTN in patients visiting public hospitals in
Pakistan. Methods: A cross-sectional, convenient-sampling oriented study was
conducted in patients attending public hospitals in Pakistan. The direct and indirect health care costs were assessed by different variables i.e. consultation fees,
cost of medicines, travelling costs, laboratory test expenses. All obtained data were
analyzed using descriptive and inferential statistics. Results: The mean annual
direct health care cost for a HTN patient was around PKRs. 19789.88 (US$ 201.21)
and indirect health care cost was PKRs. 11990.90 (US$ 121.92). It was also observed
that the mean indirect health care costs per patient were significantly varied
(p < 0.001) among different public hospitals. Conclusions: Type of the HTN, distance to the hospital and length of stay in the hospital were proportional to the
direct and indirect health care costs of the HTN patients. Better management of
HTN can favorably impact the disease burden as untreated HTN or its comorbidities increase the overall treatment costs which affect affordability of the patient.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Advances in the prevention and treatment of ischemic stroke and
transient ischemic attack (TIA) during the past two decades have resulted in changes
of medical practice. However, the existing cost estimates of ischemic stroke and
TIA are based on resource use and cost data of approximately 20 years ago. We
therefore determined hospital costs of ischemic stroke and TIA in the Netherlands
for 2012. Methods: A retrospective cost analysis was conducted using patient
and resource use data from the Diagnosis Treatment Combination (Diagnose
Behandeling Combinatie) casemix system. Four subgroups were analysed: inpatient ischemic stroke, inpatient TIA, outpatient ischemic stroke, and outpatient TIA.
Additionally, we estimated the costs for carotid endarterectomy. Unit costs were
based on 2012 reference prices of the Dutch Manual of Costing and tariffs provided
by the Dutch Healthcare Authority. Ordinary least squares regression analysis was
used to examine the association between hospital costs and various patient and
hospital characteristics. Results: A total of 35,903 ischemic stroke and 21,653 TIA
patients were included. Inpatient care costs for ischemic stroke were € 5,328 while
the costs for TIA were € 2,470. Outpatient costs were estimated at € 495 for ischemic
stroke and € 587 for TIA. Average hospital costs for carotid endarterectomy were
estimated at € 6,836. The number of inpatient days was the greatest contributor
to hospital costs for ischemic stroke and TIA patients. Age, type of hospital, and
region were strong predictors of hospital costs. Conclusions: This study is the
most recent and extensive cost analysis of inpatient and outpatient hospital costs
of ischemic stroke and TIA patients. Our results may be used as input for economic
evaluations and health economic models to support decision making about reimbursement, investment, and pricing of health care interventions.
PCV74
Costs Of Treating Cardiovascular Events In Germany: A Systematic
Literature Review
Schmid T 1, Xu W 2, Gandra S R 3, Michailov G 1
GmbH, München, Germany, 2Pharmerit International, Rotterdam, The Netherlands,
3Amgen, Inc., Thousand Oaks, CA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
1Amgen
Objectives: Cardiovascular events (CVE) are the number one cause of death (42%)
in Germany. This study evaluates available literature regarding direct medical costs
related to CVE in Germany. The CVE of interest were myocardial infarction (MI), unstable angina, heart failure (HF), stroke, and peripheral artery disease (PAD). Update of a
review conducted in 2012. Methods: A systematic literature search was performed
in the following databases- Medline, Embase, Centre for Reviews and Dissemination,
TIBORDER, and German dissertation database from 01/2003 to 10/2013. Observational
studies and randomized clinical trials were considered for the review. Results: The
search identified 400 publications; 13 were included in this review. For MI, average hospitalization costs during acute phase were between € 5,836 and € 7,522 per admission
(PA). In the first year after a MI, direct medical costs were € 11,672 - 12,713 per patient.
Madotto F 1, Fornari C 1, Chiodini V 1, Mantovani L G 2, Zecchin M 3, Proclemer A 4, Conti S 1,
Cesana G 1
1University of Milano - Bicocca, Monza, Italy, 2Federico II University of Naples, Naples, Italy,
3“Ospedali Riuniti” Hospital, Trieste, Italy, 4“S. Maria della Misericordia” Hospital, Udine, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The main purpose of study was to evaluate the utilization of implantable cardioverter defibrillator (ICD) with or without cardiac resynchronization pacing
(CRT-D) in Lombardy, the most populated Italian region with universal health care
coverage for about 10 million inhabitants, from 2000 to 2010. The second aim was
to assess health care resources utilization after a first ICD implantation, highlighting differences between implant indication (primary and secondary) or ICD type
(single-chamber, dual-chamber and CRT-D). Methods: Data were extracted from:
i) the data warehouse DENALI that organizes health care administrative databases
concerning all subjects covered by Lombardy Health System; ii) ICD National registry
data. Linking DENALI and registry data, we developed and validated (with Cohen’s
kappa coefficient) an algorithm to distinguish hospitalizations for ICD in first implant
and replacement in order to estimate the annual rates of first implant (per million
person-years) and replacement (per hundred person-years). We selected a cohort
of patients who underwent a first ICD implantation and we followed them until
12/31/2010, recording vital status and health care resources consumed: hospitalizations, drugs and outpatient claims. Results: We identified 25,358 hospitalizations
for ICD implantation: 17,864 for a first ICD and 8,034 for a replacement. 86% of hospitalizations found a match in the National registry and the Cohen’s kappa coefficient
showed values over 0.8 from 2005. The annual rates were 232.5 (95%CI: 228.5-236.4)
and 10.5 (95%CI: 10.3-10.7) for first ICD and replacement respectively. We selected a
cohort of 12,525 patients who underwent a first ICD: 55% were implanted in primary
prevention and the ICD types were: 35% single-chamber, 29% dual-chamber and 35%
CRT-D. Among these groups, we detected differences in survival, ICD duration and
health care resources utilization. Conclusions: The combined use of information
from national ICD registry and health care administrative databases could overcome
the limitation of both data sources and it could improve the monitoring of ICD therapy.
PCV77
Does A 12-Lead Ecg More Reliably Detect Atrial Fibrilation Than A
Rhythm Strip Only Ecg?
Vyas V , Duran J , Ansaripour A , Niedzielko M , Steel A , Bakhai A
Barnet & Chase Farm Hospitals NHS Trust, London, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The 12-lead electrocardiogram (ECG) is the current gold standard for
the diagnosis of atrial fibrillation (AF). However, undertaking a 12-lead ECG is cumbersome, expensive and time consuming compared to a rhythm strip alone. The AF
detection rate using a single lead ECG compared with a12-lead ECG amongst trainees
of varying degrees of experience has not yet been reviewed in depth. Methods:
Five doctors of different grades and specialties and one Cardiology Specialist Nurse
A486
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
were each asked to review a different batch of ECGs with differing proportions of AF
and Sinus Rhythm (SR). ECGs were presented to the reviewers on two separate occasions in two variations: full 12 lead and 10-second rhythm strip only. The diagnoses
(AF/SR or unsure) were compared to a Consultant Cardiologist reading the 12-lead
ECG. Results: Overall, compared to the Consultant Cardiologist, the AF detection
rate using a 12-lead ECG was 81% and 82% with a rhythm strip. There was a significant difference (chi squared test, p< 0.01) in AF detection rate when the reviewers
were divided into 2 groups according to level of cardiology experience. The AF detection rate for the 12-lead ECG amongst specialists vs. non-specialists was 93% vs.
70% (P< 0.001) and 92% vs. 73% (P= 0.003) for the rhythm strip. Conclusions: Our
findings indicate that a 10-second rhythm strip alone has a comparable AF detection
rate to a 12-lead ECG in the hands of doctors and nurses when measured against the
consultant’s diagnosis. With both the rhythm strip and a 12-lead ECG, the accuracy
of AF detection improved with experience. Mass screening using a single strip could
be acceptable and inexpensive particularly with mobile phone technology.
PCV78
Cost Consequence Comparison Of Hemostatic Matrix Agents
Beby A T 1, Faivre P 2, Zinck R 1, Kuntze C E 2
BV, Utrecht, The Netherlands, 2Baxter Healthcare SA, Opfikon-Glattpark, Switzerland
.
.
.
.
.
.
clinical response to treatment and the number of QALYs per patient accrued during
the study. Only direct medical costs (drug acquisition, administration and hospitalization costs) were incorporated in the model, as the analysis was conducted from a
third-party payer perspective. With respect to administration cost, two alternative
scenarios were considered in the base case analysis: administration in day-case unit
and administration in the hospital outpatient department. Probabilistic sensitivity
analysis was conducted. Primary outcomes were quality adjusted life years (QALYs)
and incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICER). Results: In the base case analysis,
QALYs of FCM treated patients were higher compared to no iron treated patients by
0.04 QALYs. The total 24-week cost of FCM was higher by € 969 and € 204, it the two
scenarios respectively. This difference was mainly attributed to the administration
cost and drug acquisition cost related to FMC. Incremental cost effectiveness analysis
showed that treatment with FCM was a cost-effective option resulting in an ICER
of € 25,506 and € 5,368 per QALY gained in the scenarios respectively. Probabilistic
sensitivity analysis revealed that FCM was likely to be cost-effective in over 80% and
99% in the two scenarios respectively, at a willingness-to-pay threshold of €34,000
per QALY gained. Conclusions: Ferric carboxymaltose may be a cost – effective
option in relation to no iron treatment for the management of iron deficiency of HF
patients in Greece.
1Baxter
Objectives: Hemostatic agents are used to stop intraoperative bleeding in the
presence of actively flowing blood when applied directly to the bleeding site. Recent
published literature on animal studies and real-world outcome data indicated that
the hemostatic matrix agent Floseal could stop bleedings and reduce complications
more effectively than Surgiflo with thrombin. The objective of this study is to quantify cost consequences in the Netherlands when using Floseal versus Surgiflo with
thrombin from a hospital perspective. Methods: A cost-consequence model was
built based on a large retrospective analysis of a Premier’s US Hospital database to
assess the value of using Floseal to achieve hemostasis in mixed cardiac surgery procedures relative to Surgiflo with thrombin. The model captures the cost implications
on the following parameters: (1) operating room time; (2) postoperative bleedingrelated complication rates; (3) the need for surgical revisions due to bleeding, and;
(4) the number of intraoperative and postoperative blood transfusions. Costs (€ )
were derived from published literature, the Dutch guideline for cost research and
2014 national list prices. The model assumed a surgical case load of 100 mixed
cardiac surgeries. Results: By reducing operating time, but moreover the number
of complications, surgical revisions and blood products transfusion, Floseal can
lead to a cost saving of € 2,933 per patient in comparison to the use of Surgiflo with
thrombin. Conclusions: Our preliminary analysis indicates that using Floseal to
stop intraoperative bleeding could lead to significant cost saving for the hospitals in
the Netherlands. Further studies are required to confirm these findings.
PCV79
Cost-Effectiveness Of Dabigatran Compared With Warfarin,
Apixaban, Rivaroxaban And Low Molecular Weight Heparins For The
Treatment And Secondary Prevention Of Venous Thromboembolism
In Colombia
Rosselli D 1, Rueda J D 2, Wolowacz S 3, Brockbank J 4, Abeysinghe S 4
1Pontificia Universidad Javeriana Medical School, Bogotá, Colombia, 2Pontificia Universidad
Javeriana, Bogotá, Colombia, 3RTI Health Solutions, Manchester, UK, 4RTI Health Solutions,
Didsbury, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
PCV81
Potential Cost-Effectiveness Of Therapeutic Drug Monitoring In
Patients With Resistant Hypertension
Chung O 1, Vongpatanasin W 2, Haverkamp W 1, Dorenkamp M 1
1Charite University Berlin, Campus Virchow-Klinikum, Berlin, Germany, 2University of Texas
Southwestern Medical Center Dallas, Dallas, TX, USA
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Non-adherence to drug therapy poses a significant problem in the treatment of patients with presumed resistant hypertension (RH). It has been shown that
therapeutic drug monitoring (TDM) is a useful tool for detecting non-adherence and
identifying barriers to treatment adherence, leading to effective blood pressure (BP)
control. However, the cost-effectiveness of TDM in the management of RH has not
been investigated. Methods: A Markov model was used to evaluate life-years, quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs), costs, and incremental cost-effectiveness ratios in RH
patients receiving either TDM optimized therapy or standard best medical therapy.
The model ran from the age of 30 to 100 years or death, using a cycle length of 1 year.
Efficacy of TDM was modeled by reducing risk of hypertension-related morbidity and
mortality. Cost analyses were performed from a payer’s perspective. Deterministic
and probabilistic sensitivity analyses were conducted. Results: In the age group
of 60-year olds, TDM gained 1.07 QALYs in men and 0.97 QALYs in women at additional costs of € 3,854 and €3,922, respectively. Given a willingness-to-pay threshold
of €35,000 per QALY gained, the probability of TDM being cost-effective was ≥ 95% in
all age groups from 30 to 90 years. Results were influenced mostly by the frequency
of TDM testing, the rate of non-responders to TDM, and the magnitude of effect of
TDM on BP. Conclusions: Therapeutic drug monitoring presents a potentialy highly
cost-effective health care intervention in patients diagnosed with RH. Importantly,
this finding is valid for a wide range of patients, independent of gender and age.
PCV82
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis Of Ivabradine In Heart Failure With
Reduced Left Ventricular Ejection Fraction In Spain
Fernandez de Bobadilla J , Gonzalez Fernandez O , Lopez de Sa E , Lopez-Sendon J L
Hospital La Paz, Madrid, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate cost-effectiveness of dabigatran and new oral anticoagulants (NOA) compared to currently reimbursed warfarin and low molecular
weight heparins (LMWH) for thromboembolic events prophylaxis from a payer’s
perspective in Colombia. Methods: Markov decision model based on efficacy,
utilities and safety inputs from clinical trials (CT) (RE-COVER I and II; EinsteinDVT; Einstein-PE; AMPLIFY; RE-SONATE; RE-MEDY and a meta-analysis of 18 CT
for LMWH. Cost of medication was obtained from SISMED, Vademecum Med®,
and government reference prices; costs of events were estimated from hospital
billing records, POS tariffs, SOAT Manual and local experts. Costs are reported in
euros (1 € = COP 2,655) and effectiveness in terms of deaths due to bleeding and
Quality Adjusted Life Years (QALYs). A 3% discount rate was used for costs and
QALYs. A cohort of 1,000 patients, with similar demographic characteristics to
those reported in the CT, was followed for a 5-year time horizon; with analysis for 6
months, 1 year and lifetime. A univariate and probabilistic sensitivity analysis was
performed. Results: Deaths due to bleeding were 5 with dabigatran, 7 with apixaban, 9 with LMWH, 7 with rivaroxaban and 15 with warfarin, per 10,000 patients.
Dabigatran is dominant compared with LMWH and apixaban. Compared with
rivaroxaban, dabigatran is safer with similar costs and QALYs gained. Considering
a base line scenario comparing all alternatives versus warfarin, dabigatrán demonstrates the lowest ICER (€ 32,121/QALY) compared with rivaroxaban (€ 36,388/
QALY), apixaban (€ 72,228/QALY) and LMWH (€ 604,515/QALY). Our findings were
consistent in the sensitivity analyses. Conclusions: Dabigatran is the alternative with the best value for money when all alternatives are compared with
warfarin, and is dominant compared with LMWH, which are reimbursed by the
current Colombian National Plan POS.
Objectives: SHIFT trial demonstrated that, by decreasing heart rate with
Ivabradine, the incidence of events is reduced in patients with HF due to left ventricular systolic disfunction (LVSD) and heart rate (HR) over 70 bpm. A cost-effectiveness analysis demonstrating that this treatment strategy is cost-effective in United
Kingdom has been published, but there are no publications with Spanish data. The
objetive of this analysis is to determine whether treatment with Ivabradine in HF
due to LVSD is a cost-effective strategy in Spain. Methods: A Markov model with
three health states was built (baseline, admission due to HF and death), based on a
simulated cohort of patients suffering HF due to LVSD and HR over 70 bpm, in order
to compare the treatment strategies of the SHIFT trial, Ivabradine vs placebo, on top
of standard treatment, was performed. A cost-efectiveness analysis with a life-time
horizon, under the perspective of the NHS. Spanish costs were used to feed the
model, and it was assumed that quality of life was worse during hospitalizations.
A probabilistic sensitivity analysis was performed. The model took into account
the incidence of complications related with HF (admission for HF, readmission for
HF and death) and was fed with transition probabilities taken from the SHIFT trial
and the SHIFT-hospitalization trial. Costs were obtained from cost data bases, the
National Statistics Institute of Spain, institutions and scientific journals. Results:
Cost per QALY of Ivabradine in comparison to placebo in heart failure due to left
ventricular systolic disfunction is € 17,488 € , well below the acceptability threshold
accepted in our enviroment (around 30,000 € ). Cost per LYG was € 13,044. Results
were robust in the performed sensitivity analyses. Conclusions: In conclusion,
treatment with Ivabradine in heart failure due to left ventricular systolic dysfunction is cost-effective in Spain.
PCV80
Economic Evaluation Of Ferric Carboxymaltose In Patients With
Chronic Heart Failure And Iron Deficiency: An Analysis For Greece
Based On Fair-Hf Trial
PCV83
Pharmacoeconomic Assessment Of Apixaban Versus Standard Of
Care For The Prevention Of Stroke In Italian Non-Valvular Atrial
Fibrillation Patients
Mylonas C 1, Kourlaba G 2, Berberian K 3, Maniadakis N 1
1National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece, 2Collaborative Center for Clinical Epidemiology
and Outcomes Research (CLEO), Athens, Greece, 3GENESIS Pharma SA, Athens, Greece
1AdRes
Objectives: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of iron repletion with ferric carboxymaltorse (FCM), in iron-deficient heart failure (HF) patients in Greece. Methods:
An international economic model was locally adapted to evaluate the use ferric carboxymaltorse to standard care over a time horizon of 24 weeks corresponding to the
duration of the FAIR-HF trial. The efficacy of therapy was evaluated based on the
Objectives: The objective of this study was to evaluate the cost-effectiveness
of apixaban in the prevention of thromboembolic events in patients with nonvalvular atrial fibrillation (NVAF) relatively to standard of care (warfarin or aspirin)
from the Italian National Health System (SSN) perspective. Methods: A previously published Markov model was adapted for Italian NVAF patients. Clinical
.
.
.
.
Pradelli L 1, Calandriello M 2, Di Virgilio R 3, Bellone M 1, Tubaro M4
HE&OR, Turin, Italy, 2HE OR Unit - Bristol-Myers Squibb S. r. l., Rome, Italy, 3Pfizer
Pharmaceuticals, Rome, Italy, 4San Filippo Neri Hospital, Rome, Italy
.
.
.
.
A487
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
effectiveness data were derived from head-to-head randomized trials (ARISTOTLE
and AVERROES); main events considered in the model were ischemic and hemorrhagic stroke, systemic thromboembolism, bleeds (both major and clinically relevant minor) and cardiovascular hospitalizations. Expected survival was projected
beyond trial duration using national mortality data adjusted for individual clinical
risks and adjusted by utility weights for health states derived from literature. Unit
costs were collected from published Italian sources. Costs (2013 € ) and health gains
accruing after the first year were discounted at an annual 3.5% rate. Deterministic
and probabilistic sensitivity analyses (PSA) were carried out to assess the effect of
input uncertainty. Results: Incremental LYs (0.31/0.19), QALYs (0.28/0.20), and costs
(1,932/1,104) are predicted with the use of apixaban relative to aspirin and warfarin,
respectively. The incremental cost effectiveness ratios (ICERs) of apixaban were €
6,794 and € 5,607 per QALY gained, respectively. In PSA, the probability of apixaban
being cost effective relative to aspirin and warfarin was 95% and 93%, respectively,
for a WTP threshold of € 20,000 per QALY gained. Univariate analyses indicate that
results were most sensitive to variations of the absolute risk reduction for cardiovascular events with apixaban. Conclusions: Apixaban is expected to increase life
expectancy and quality-adjusted life expectancy, but also costs dedicated to Italian
NVAF patients, as compared to standard of care. The resulting ICERs have high probabilities of being below the conventional thresholds of WTP for health benefits of
the SSN, indicating efficient allocation of health care resources.
PCV84
Assessing The Cost Effectiveness Of An Anticoagulation Clinic In
Comparison With The Usual Medical Clinic In Kuala Lumpur Hospital
Thanimalai S 1, Shafie A A 1, Ahmad Hassali M A 2, Sinnadurai J 3
1Universiti Sains Malaysia, Penang, Malaysia, 2Discipline of Social and Administrative Pharmacy,
School of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Universiti Sains Malaysia, Penang, Malaysia,, 3Hospital Kuala
Lumpur, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Systematic anticoagulation management clinic is now recommended to manage warfarinized atrial fibrillation (AF) patient. In Malaysia, the
service is recently introduced as pharmacist managed Warfarin Medication Therapy
Adherence Clinic (WMTAC). The objective of the present study was to assess the
cost effectiveness of anticoagulation clinic in comparison with usual medical
in Kuala Lumpur Hospital. Methods: A Markov model built using the provider
perspective and 20 year time horizon was used to assess the cost effectiveness.
The base case analysis assumed a cohort of patients with AF 57 years of age with
comorbid illnesses. Data sources include a 6 month retrospective cohort analysis
of the effectiveness of the clinics, the cost of drugs, cost of personnel and space
of the clinics, cost of monitoring and cost of adverse events were obtained from
the local source and publications. The transition probabilities of these clinics outcomes were obtained from a literature search. Future costs were discounted by
3% to convert to present values. All costs were in Ringgit Malaysia (RM) based on
year 2012. Results: The results of a 20-year period model showed that UMC was
dominated by the WMTAC in the same time period. The mean cost of the WMTAC
was RM 5864 whereas the UMC cost was RM 6550. The sensitivity analysis showed
that clinic treatment costs and effectiveness influenced the cost-effectiveness. If the
cost of WMTAC was increased by 50% of the current cost, the WMTAC would not be
a dominant intervention. WMTAC was also cost effective for a willingness to pay of
RM32000. Conclusions: The anticoagulation management service appears to cost
less and provide greater effectiveness than usual care. In conclusion, the Markov
model suggests that from the provider perspective the anticoagulation clinic is a
more cost effective option than the usual medical clinic in Kuala Lumpur Hospital.
PCV85
Cost-Effectiveness Of Ranolazine For The Treatment Of Angina
Pectoris In Russia
Gorokhova S G 1, Ryazhenov V V 1, Gorokhov V D 2, Maximkin S A 3
1I. M. Sechenov First Moscow State Medical University, Moscow, Russia, 2Scientific Clinical Center
of JSC Russian Railways, Moscow, Russia, 3Center for strategic research in healthcare, Moscow,
Russia
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess cost-effectiveness of ranolazine in Russian patients with
angina pectoris. Methods: A model was developed to compare a strategy of treatment of angina pectoris with ranolazine and a traditional therapy in patients with
at least 3 heart attacks per week. The analysis was based on the results of ERICA
(Efficacy of Ranolazine in Chronic Angina) study that included Russian patients and
reflected a routine Russian practice for the treatment of the disease. The analysis
included costs of drug therapy, emergency care and hospitalization. Effectiveness
rate was measured as a change of frequency of angina attacks compared to initial
level estimated by SAQ (Seattle Angina Questionnaire). Sensitivity analysis considered the change of parameters in different length of hospitalization. Results:
Total costs in ranolazine group were insignificanlty higher than in control group
(573.84 RUB per patient). At the same time, ranolazine changed the structure of
costs: expenditures on medications grew while costs of emergency care and hospitalization reduced. CER value was 1640.86 in ranolazine group, and 1964.63 (1.2
times less) in group of traditional therapy. The change of hospitalization length in
sensitivity analysis was also more favorable in case of ranolazine: 164 479.81 vs
197 300.02 RUB/unit, which confirms previous results. Conclusions: The use of
ranolazine in patients with > 3 heart attacks of angina pectoris per week is clinically
and economically substantiated.
PCV86
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis Of Ticagrelor In Treating Patients With
Acute Coronary Syndrome In Hong Kong
Wu D B C 1, Lee B S C 2, Lee K K C 1
University Malaysia, Selangor, Malaysia, 2Prince of Wales Hospital, Shatin, Hong Kong,
Hong Kong, Hong Kong
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Monash
Objectives: The multi-centered, double-blind, randomized PLATO trial on 18,624
patients from 43 countries has demonstrated that ticagrelor was superior in reduc-
ing cardiovascular mortality, myocardial infarction (MI), or stroke among patients
with acute coronary syndrome (ACS) compared to clopidogrel but without a significant increase in major bleedings. In Hong Kong, generic clopidogrel was introduced
in 2012. This study aimed to evaluate the long-term cost-effectiveness of ticagrelor
in ACS patients in Hong Kong (HK) from a public hospital’s perspective. Methods:
A two-phase Markov model was used to estimate the short- and long-term costeffectiveness measured as cost per quality-adjusted-life-year (QALY) and cost per
life-year-gained (LYG) over 1 year, 5 years and patients’ lifetime. Direct medical costs
were HK-specific and patients’ resource use, rate of cardiovascular events (i.e. MI
and stroke) and utility data were from published literature. All costs were presented
as 2014 figures, cost and effectiveness were both discounted at 3% per annum.
Sensitivity analyses were performed to test model robustness. Results: Despite
the great difference in the daily drug cost of ticagrelor and generic clopidogrel
(US2.8, vs US0.10,1US= 7.8HK), the overall cost of management between the 2 groups
remains similar. Our study shows that the incremental cost-effectiveness ratios
(ICER) of ticagrelor were reduced substantially from US16,071/LYG and US19,493/
QALY in the first year to US302/LYG and US357/QALY over a lifetime time horizon
due to improvements in health outcomes. The ICER values were all cost-effective
based on the WHO 3xGDP criteria (GDP 2013= US37,860). The results are sensitive
to cost of generic clopidogrel. Conclusions: Treating ACS patients with lifetime
use of ticagrelor can potentially reduce the cost of management and increase the
cost-effectiveness due to better health outcomes as compared to generic clopidogrel.
Ticagrelor therapy appears to be cost-effective both on short- and long-term assessment in the public health care sector of Hong Kong.
PCV87
The Cost Of Increasing Physical Activity And Decreasing Body Mass
Index For Mid-Life African Women
Johnson T J , Wilbur J , Fogg L , Schoeny M
Rush University, Chicago, IL, USA
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The purpose of this project was to evaluate the incremental costs of
increasing physical activity and improving body composition for a lifestyle walking
program targeting sedentary African American women. Methods: The Women’s
Lifestyle Physical Activity Program was a randomized behavioral trial that included
a group intervention with social support and culturally relevant, tailored content
about increasing physical activity and an automated telephone response system
to track physical activity for sedentary African American women ages 40-65. The
principal outcomes were change in minutes of walking and moderate and vigorous
physical activity per week, and body mass index (BMI) between baseline and 24
weeks. Incremental cost effectiveness ratios (ICER) were calculated for each outcome. The cost-effectiveness analysis included both program and participant costs
and was calculated in 2013 US dollars. Results: For the 260 participants in the
analysis, participant costs (e.g., group session attendance, logging physical activity
in the ATR system) were $152 ± 42, while program costs (e.g., group session facilitation, materials and supplies) were $164 ± 21, for a total cost of $316 ± 59. Walking
increased by 200 minutes per week at 24 week, with an ICER of $1.64 (95% CI, 1.63
– 1.66) per minute, moderate and vigorous physical activity increased by 117 minutes per week, with an ICER of $2.79 per minute, and BMI decreased by 0.09 points,
with an ICER of $3463 (95% CI, 500 – 9,540) per 1-point reduction. Conclusions:
The Women’s Lifestyle Physical Activity Program is a relatively low cost strategy for
increasing physical activity. The incremental cost of increasing walking minutes
is substantially lower than for moderate and vigorous physical activity. The participant costs related to time in the program were more than half of the total costs,
suggesting that practitioners and policymakers should consider the participant cost
when disseminating group programs into practice.
PCV88
Cost Effectiveness Analysis Of Apixaban Versus Other Noacs For The
Prevention Of Stroke In Italian Non-Valvular Atrial Fibrillation
Patients
Pradelli L 1, Calandriello M 2, Di Virgilio R 3, Bellone M 1, Tubaro M 4
HE&OR, Turin, Italy, 2HE OR Unit - Bristol-Myers Squibb S. r. l., Rome, Italy, 3Pfizer
Pharmaceuticals, Rome, Italy, 4San Filippo Neri Hospital, Rome, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
1AdRes
Objectives: The study assessed the lifetime cost-effectiveness of apixaban in preventing thromboembolic events in non-valvular atrial fibrillation (NVAF) patients,
as compared to other novel oral anticoagulant agents (NOACs), from the Italian
Health System (SSN) perspective. Methods: A previously published Markov
model was adapted. Baseline clinical risks were assigned based on the demographic and clinical features of the patients; effectiveness parameters derived
from adjusted indirect comparison using warfarin as link. Expected survival
was projected beyond trial duration using national mortality data adjusted for
clinical risks and weighted by published utilities. Unit costs were collected from
official and published Italian sources. Costs (2013-€ ) and health gains occurring
after the first year were discounted at an annual 3.5% rate. Deterministic and
probabilistic sensitivity analyses (DSA&PSA) were carried out. Results: In the
short to medium term, apixaban was associated with marginal LYs and QALYs
gains and slight savings. However, as apixaban extended expected survival versus dabigatran (110mg), dabigatran (150mg) and rivaroxaban (0.13,0. 08, and 0.06
LYs or 0.11,0. 07, and 0.05 QALYs), expected total lifetime costs exceeded those of
these comparators (319,282,16 € ). Corresponding ICERs were estimated in € 2,911,
€ 3,882 and € 327 per QALY gained. In PSA, the probabilities of apixaban being cost
effective with a WTP threshold of 20,000 € /QALY gained were 99%, 92% and 93%
for the same comparisons. The most influential parameter according to DSA was
daily cost of NOACs, but the corresponding ICERs remained well below commonly
accepted WTP values. Conclusions: Apixaban is expected to be more effective
than dabigatran and rivaroxaban in Italian NVAF patients, and marginally more
costly due to costs in added years of life. The ICERs have a high likelihood of being
below conventional thresholds of WTP for health benefits of the SSN and suggest
that apixaban is cost-effective compared with other NOACs.
A488
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PCV89
Novel Imaging Technology To Select Patients For Individualized
Therapies: Test Performance And Cost-Effectiveness
Buisman L R 1, Rijnsburger A J 1, Koudstaal P J 2, Redekop W K 1
1Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 2Erasmus MC, University Medical
Center Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Non-invasive molecular imaging tests are currently being developed
to improve individual stroke risk prediction in patients with a recent transient
ischemic attack (TIA) or minor ischemic stroke. We estimated the minimum performance (i.e., sensitivity and specificity) that a test must have in order to be more
cost-effective than current clinical practice. Methods: The aim of imaging tests is
to identify which patients should undergo surgery instead of receiving medicines.
Decision modelling was used to estimate the minimum performance of a confirmatory test that is performed based on the result of an initial duplex ultrasonography.
The comparators were patient management according to Dutch guidelines and three
observed clinical practice strategies. Scenario analyses were performed in which the
sensitivity and specificity were varied to estimate the minimum test performance
needed to be cost-effective versus the comparators. Results: A perfect confirmatory test (100% sensitivity and specificity) with a cost of € 390 for a 60-year-old man
is cost-effective versus all comparators. Assuming 100% sensitivity, a test must be at
least 71% specific to be cost-effective versus the Dutch guidelines using a threshold
of € 30,000/QALY. Similarly, assuming 100% specificity, a test must be at least 52%
sensitive to be cost-effective. In addition, assuming 90% sensitivity, a test must have
a specificity of at least 77% to be cost-effective. Moreover, the minimum values of
sensitivity and specificity needed for a test to be cost-effective are dependent on the
QALY threshold used. Conclusions: An imaging test that improves risk prediction
and therefore treatment decisions for patients with a recent TIA or minor ischemic
stroke has the potential to improve cost-effectiveness by reducing the risk of recurrent stroke. However, developers must consider if the minimum test performance
required to be cost-effective can be achieved; other concerns of payers (e.g. budget
impact) must also be considered.
PCV90
Cost-Effectiveness Of Apixaban Compared To Other Anticoagulants
For Lifetime Treatment And Prevention Of Recurrent Venous
Thromboembolism
Lanitis T 1, Hamilton M 2, Rublee D A 3, Leipold R 4, Quon P 4, Browne C 1, Cohen A T 5
1Evidera, London, UK, 2Bristol-Myers Squibb Company, Princeton, NJ, USA, 3Pfizer, Inc., New York,
NY, USA, 4Evidera, Bethesda, MD, USA, 5Guy’s and St Thomas’ NHS Foundation Trust, London, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Guidelines suggest only 3-6 months of anticoagulant treatment in
most venous thromboembolism (VTE) patients due to concerns that the bleeding
risk with vitamin K antagonists (VKAs) outweighs the reduced risk of VTE recurrence in extended treatment. However, non-VKA novel oral anticoagulants (NOACs)
have been studied recently for extended VTE treatment. Apixaban demonstrated
superiority to placebo in VTE reduction without increasing risk of major bleeding in
the AMPLIFY-EXT trial, justifying reassessment of the potential benefit of extending
treatment. This analysis reports cost effectiveness of lifetime treatment with apixaban versus rivaroxaban, dabigatran, and low-molecular-weight heparin (LMWH)/
KA from the perspective of the UK National Health Service (NHS). Methods:
A Markov model was developed that includes the following health states: recurrent
VTE, major bleed, clinically-relevant non-major bleed, chronic thromboembolic
pulmonary hypertension, and death. Transition rates among health states were
based upon AMPLIFY and AMPLIFY-EXT clinical trial data, network meta-analyses,
discontinuation due to clinical events, and UK life tables. Costs were from UK NHS
Healthcare Resource Group tables and utilities were from published literature. The
primary outcome of interest was incremental cost per quality adjusted life year
(QALY) gained. Results: Compared to other anticoagulants, lifetime treatment
with apixaban was projected to result in fewer bleeds and fewer recurrent VTEs.
The lower bleeding risk with apixaban led to fewer treatment discontinuations,
longer time on treatment, and fewer recurrent VTEs. The reduced number of clinical events led to increased QALYs at a nominal cost increase, due primarily to
longer treatment duration with apixaban. Incremental costs per QALY gained
were £2,781, £619, and £10,820 for apixaban versus dabigatran, rivaroxaban, and
LMWH/VKA, respectively. Sensitivity analyses indicated that results were robust
to a wide range of inputs. Conclusions: Apixaban for lifetime treatment of VTE
can offer substantial clinical benefits and is a cost-effective alternative to other
NOACs and LMWH/VKA.
PCV91
Cost-Effectiveness Of Extracorporeal Cardiopulmonary
Resuscitation In Patients With Refractory Cardiac Arrest
Buriskova K 1, Rogalewicz V 1, Ostadal P 2
University in Prague, Kladno, Czech Republic, 2Nemocnice Na Homolce, Praha 5,
Czech Republic
.
.
.
1Czech Technical
Objectives: Extracorporeal life support (ECLS) has been recently introduced as a
therapeutic option for refractory cardiac arrest (extracorporeal cardiopulmonary
resuscitation - ECPR). Despite growing evidence demonstrating improved survival rate with ECPR in refractory cardiac arrest, a number of questions remains
unanswered and data on cost-effectiveness of this approach are still insufficient. Methods: Retrospective cost-effectiveness analysis was performed from
the provider’s perspective. Sixteen patients undergoing ECPR were included into
the analysis (ECPR group) and the data were compared with 35 subjects with conventional CPR for refractory cardiac arrest (non-ECPR group). Results: In the
ECPR group seven out of sixteen patients were weaned from ECMO, four of them
with good neurological outcomes (CPC 1); three patients survived one year with
CPC 1, one patient survived one year with severe neurological dysfunction (CPC
3) and one patient with persisting coma (CPC 4). In comparison, in the non-ECPR
group all patients died within 24 hours. In the ECPR group, when using Levitronix
Centrimag blood pump (Thoratec, USA), the average annual costs per patient
reached CZK885,044 (~EUR32,260), with the Cardiohelp device (Maquet, Germany)
CZK788,432 (~EUR28,738). The cost utility analysis revealed 3,961,970 CZK/QALY
(~144,413 EUR/QALY) with Cardiohelp, and 4,447,457 CZK/QALY (~162,109 EUR/
QALY) when using Levitronix Centrimag. However, if only patients with CPC 1 were
included into the analysis, the cost-utility ratio decreased to 834,616 CZK/QALY
(~30,422 EUR/QALY) and 908,253 CZK/QALY (~33,106 EUR/QALY) for Cardiohelp and
Levitronix, respectively. Conclusions: Our data indicate that ECPR for refractory
cardiac arrest might be cost effective despite the high costs per individual patient
treated with this approach. Larger studies are, however, required to confirm these
observations.
PCV92
Cost Effectiveness Of Ivabradine In Chronic Heart Failure Patients
With Heart Rate Above Bpm In Taiwan
Chang C J 1, Chu P H 2, Fann C S J 3
Gung University, Kwei Shan, Tao Yuan, Taiwan, 2Chang Gung University, Taoyuan,
Taiwan, 3Academia Sinica, Taipei, Taiwan
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Chang
Objectives: Raised heart rate is a risk factor for cardiovascular events and
death. Heart rate reduction could be an important role in management of chronic
heart failure. Ivabradine is a new, pure and specific heart rate lower therapy. We
assessed the cost effectiveness of Ivabradine in CHF with heart rate 75 bpm
using the perspective of a middle-income country’s public health insurance system. Methods: Model-based analysis closely mirrored the SHIFT trial was performed. Micro-simulation method of CHF disease, mortality and hospitalization
were used to compare Ivabradine plus standard care with standard care only.
A two state Markov model has been employed to simulate the natural history of
disease. Costs were estimated from national health insurance research database
in Taiwan, a single-payer program that offers universal health care coverage. And
another estimated costs using a medical center in Taiwan with clinical examination value were performed to validate the accuracy of costs. Incremental cost per
quality adjusted life year (QALY) gained is used to express the value of Ivabradine
over a lifetime horizon and 29 months of trial period. Results: The incremental cost per additional QALY for Ivabradine plus standard care versus standard
care has been estimated as £14,832 for trial period and £7,634 for lifetime.
Ivabradine is cost-effective according to NICE threshold. And the result was
robust in sensitivity analysis. Conclusions: In a middle-income country like
Taiwan, the use of Ivabradine to treat the eligible CHF patients is likely to be cost
effectiveness.
PCV93
Economic Analysis Of Thrombo Incode, A Clinical-Genetic Function
For Assessing The Risk Of Venous Thromboembolism
Rubio-Terrés C 1, Soria J M 2, Morange P E 3, Suchon P 3, Souto J C 4, Mateo J 4, Saut N 5, RubioRodríguez D 1, Sala J 6, Gracia A 6, Pich S 7, Salas E 7
de Genòmica de Malalties Complexes Sant Pau, Barcelona,
Spain, 3Inserm UMR_S 1062, F-13385, and Aix-Marseille Université, Marseille, France, 4Unitat
d’Hemostasia i Trombosis IIB-Sant Pau, Barcelona, Spain, 5Inserm Unité Mixte de Recherche en
Santé (UMR_S) 937; ICAN Institute for Cardiometabolism and Nutrition, Université Pierre et
Marie Curie, Paris, France, 6Scientific Department Ferrer inCode, Barcelona, Spain, 7Scientific
Department Gendiag. exe, Barcelona, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Health Value, Madrid, Spain, 2Unitat
Objectives: To conduct an economic analysis of the risk assessment of venous
thromboembolism (VTE) from the perspective of the Spanish National Health
System with Thrombo inCode versus conventional/standard method used to date
(Factor V Leiden and Prothrombin G20210A). Methods: An economic model
was created from the National Health System perspective using a decision tree
in patients aged 45 with a life expectancy of 81 years. The predictive capacity of
VTE based on the identification of thrombophilia with Thrombo inCode and of the
standard method was obtained from two case-control studies (S. PAU and MARTHA)
conducted on two different populations (1,451 patients in all). Although this is not
always the case, in this analysis the least favourable situation was assumed for
Thrombo inCode, with patients identified as suffering from thrombophilia being
subject to preventive treatment of VTE with warfarin, leading to a reduction in
the number of VTE events and an increased risk of severe bleeding. The health
states utilities (quality-adjusted life years, QALY) and costs were obtained from
the literature and Spanish sources. Results: Based on a price of € 180 for Thrombo
inCode, this would be the dominant option (more effective and with lower costs than
the standard method) in both populations. The Monte Carlo probabilistic analyses
indicate that the dominance would occur in 100% of the simulations in both populations. The threshold price of Thrombo inCode needed to reach the incremental
cost-effective ratio (ICER) generally accepted in Spain (€ 30,000 per QALY gained)
would be between € 3,950 (MARTHA) and € 11,993 (S. PAU). Conclusions: Thrombo
inCode is a dominant option in assessing the risk of VTE compared to the standard
method currently used.
PCV94
A Cost-Effectiveness Analysis Of Interventions For Symptomatic
Varicose Veins
Marsden G 1, Perry M 2, Bradbury A 3, Hickey N 4, Kelley K 2, Trender H 5, Wonderling D 2,
Davies A H 6
1Office of Health Economics, London, UK, 2National Clinical Guideline Centre, London, UK,
3University of Birmingham, Solihul, UK, 4Worcestershire Royal Hospital, Worcester, UK, 5Sheffield
Teaching Hospital Foundation Trust, Sheffield, UK, 6Imperial College & Imperial College NHS
Trust, London, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Treatment of varicose veins (VV) has been shown to increase health
related quality of life. However, the cost-effectiveness of such treatments has been
uncertain. Indeed there is great regional variation across the UK in how, and if, VV
are treated. This economic analysis formed part of the NICE clinical guideline on VV,
with an objective to investigate whether such treatments should be recommended
across the UK. Methods: An economic analysis was conducted to compare the
A489
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
cost-effectiveness of surgery, endodermal ablation (ETA), ultrasound guided foam
sclerotherapy (UGFS) and compression stockings (CS). The analysis was based on a
Markov decision model, which was developed in consultation with members of the
NICE guideline development group (GDG). The model had a five year time horizon,
and took the perspective of the UK National Health Service. Clinical inputs were
based on a network meta-analysis (NMA), informed by a systematic review of the
clinical literature. Outcomes were expressed as costs and quality adjusted life years
(QALYs). Results: All interventional treatments were found to be cost-effective
compared to CS at a cost- effectiveness threshold of £20,000 per QALY gained. ETA
was found to be the most cost-effective strategy overall, with an incremental costeffectiveness ratio of £3,161 per QALY gained compared to UGFS. Surgery and CS
were dominated by ETA. Conclusions: Interventional treatment for VV is costeffective in the UK NHS. Specifically, based on current data, ETA is the most costeffective treatment in people for whom it is suitable. The results of this research
were used to inform recommendations within the NICE guideline on VV. Funding:
This work was undertaken by the National Clinical Guideline Centre, which received
funding from the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE). The
views expressed in this publication are those of the authors and not necessarily
of the institute.
PCV95
The Cost-Effectiveness Of Dabigatran Etexilate Compared With
Rivaroxaban In The Treatment Of Acute Venous Thromboembolism In
The Uk
Jugrin A V 1, Ustyugova A V 2, Urbich M 3, Lamotte M 1, Sunderland T J 4
1IMS Health HEOR, Vilvoorde, Belgium, 2Boehringer Ingelheim GmbH, Ingelheim am Rhein,
Germany, 3Boehringer Ingelheim Ltd, Bracknell, UK, 4Boehringer Ingelheim, Berkshire, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Venous thromboembolism (VTE) including deep vein thrombosis
(DVT) and pulmonary embolism (PE) is a common cardiovascular disorder. Acute
VTE has been traditionally managed with short course parenteral anticoagulation
followed by 3-6 months of a vitamin-K antagonist. Novel oral anticoagulants do
not require routine coagulation monitoring and dose adjustment, thus potentially
providing an alternative treatment option. The cost-effectiveness of dabigatran vs.
rivaroxaban over a 6 months treatment course in the UK health care setting was
evaluated in this research. Methods: A life-time Markov model was developed,
encompassing recurrent VTE events and VTE-related deaths, and the most common adverse events during anticoagulation therapy: major or clinically relevant
bleeds (MCRB). The model was populated with data from pooled RE-COVER and
RE-COVER II dabigatran trials and the 6 months treatment duration subgroup of
the rivaroxaban EINSTEIN-DVT and EINSTEIN-PE trials. Long-term consequences
of VTE were considered. Costs were analysed from the NHS and Public Social
Services perspectives. Health outcomes were assessed in quality-adjusted life
years (QALY). Utility values for modelled health states were EQ-5D data from
RE-COVER studies, and published data. Probabilistic sensitivity analyses (PSA)
were undertaken. Results: In patients with index PE, 6 months treatment with
dabigatran dominated treatment with rivaroxaban projecting less recurrent VTE
and less MCRB at lower costs. Dabigatran was likely to remain cost-effective in 70%
of cases at a threshold used in the UK of £30,000/QALY gained. Dabigatran continued to dominate treatment with rivaroxaban in patients with index DVT, projecting less non-fatal PE, less intra-cranial haemorrhages and less clinically relevant
bleeds, but more recurrent DVT, with 68% likelihood of remaining cost-effective.
In the pooled DVT/PE group, dabigatran dominated treatment with rivaroxaban
and was 62% likely to remain cost-effective. Conclusions: Dabigatran is less
costly and more effective than rivaroxaban when administered for 6 months after
index PE, index DVT or both.
PCV96
The Cost-Effectiveness Of Dabigatran Etexilate Compared With
Warfarin And Rivaroxaban In The Treatment Of Acute Pulmonary
Embolism In The Uk
Jugrin A V 1, Ustyugova A V 2, Urbich M 3, Lamotte M 1, Sunderland T J 4
1IMS Health HEOR, Vilvoorde, Belgium, 2Boehringer Ingelheim GmbH, Ingelheim am Rhein,
Germany, 3Boehringer Ingelheim Ltd, Bracknell, UK, 4Boehringer Ingelheim, Berkshire, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: This economic evaluation aimed to assess the cost-effectiveness
of dabigatran etexilate for six months of treatment for acute pulmonary embolism (PE) compared with warfarin and rivaroxaban in the UK health care setting. Methods: A Markov state-transition cohort model was used to project the
lifetime recurrence of PE and occurrence of deep vein thrombosis (DVT) in patients
with initial acute PE. The incidence of recurrent venous thromboembolism (rVTE)
was based on the relevant study endpoints of RE-COVER and RE-COVER II trials
comparing dabigatran with warfarin, and the EINSTEIN-PE study for rivaroxaban.
Intervention-specific probabilities of events within the composite efficacy endpoint and within the composite safety endpoint of major or clinically relevant
bleeding (MCRB) were sourced from the very same randomised trials. Beyond
the data from clinical studies, the probability of rVTE was sourced from the
published literature. Long-term consequences of VTE were considered, namely
chronic thromboembolic-induced pulmonary hypertension and post-thrombotic
syndrome. The perspective on costs was that of the NHS and Public Social Services.
Health outcomes were assessed in quality-adjusted life years (QALY). Utility values relevant to events and health staes were EQ-5D data from RE-COVER studies,
and published literature. Probabilistic sensitivity analyses (PSA) were undertaken. Results: Compared with warfarin, dabigatran projected similar number
of rVTE, but was associated with less MCRB. The expected lifetime incremental
cost-effectiveness ratios (ICERs) were £2,004/life years (LYs) and £1,285/QALYs. PSA
showed 84% likelihood for dabigatran to remain cost-effective given a willingnessto-pay of £30,000/QALY. When compared with rivaroxaban, treatment with dabigatran was projected dominant,. Dabigatran projected less rVTE, less intracranial
haemorrhages and clinical relevant non-major bleeds, but was associated with a
higher risk of major bleeds. PSA showed 66% likelihood for dabigatran to remain
cost-effective over rivaroxaban. Conclusions: In patients treated for acute pulmonary embolism, dabigatran is a cost-effective alternative compared with both
warfarin and rivaroxaban.
PCV97
Cost-Effectiveness Of Apixaban Compared To Warfarin And Aspirin
In Patients With Non-Valvular Atrial Fibrillation (Nvaf) In The
Russian Federation
Rudakova A V 1, Parfenov V A 2
1St. Petersburg Chemical Pharmaceutical Academy, Saint-Petersburg, Russia, 2I. M. Sechenov First
Moscow State Medical University, Moscow, Russia
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate cost-effectiveness of the novel oral anticoagulant apixaban compared to warfarin and aspirin in patients with NVAF from the Russian
Federation national health care system perspective. Methods: Cost-effectiveness
analysis was based on a Markov model that allowed estimation of the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) for apixaban compared to warfarin and aspirin
over lifetime horizon in vitamin K antagonists (VKA) suitable and VKA unsuitable
patients with NVAF, respectively. The model enclosed cardiovascular event rates
derived from the randomized clinical trials: ARISTOTLE and AVERROES. The following cardiovascular events were considered: ischemic and hemorrhagic stroke,
intracranial hemorrhage, systemic embolism, other major bleeds, clinically relevant non-major bleeds, myocardial infarction and cardiovascular hospitalizations.
Characteristics of the baseline patients’ cohort including quality of INR control
corresponded to the local population. Direct medical costs were determined based
on the rates of the compulsory national medical insurance system. The price of
the antithrombotic drugs was taken as a weighted average tender price in 2013.
Cost-effectiveness threshold was set at 1,4 million rubles per quality-adjusted
life year (QALY) gained and corresponded to the three times GDP per capita in
the Russian Federation in 2013. One-way sensitivity analyses were undertaken to
examine the effects of model drivers. Results: In the base case analysis it was
demonstrated that apixaban compared to warfarin and aspirin provided additional
0.187 and 0.214 QALYs, respectively. With that estimated ICER for apixaban compared to warfarin and aspirin was 603.92 and 473.02 thousands rubles per QALY
gained, respectively. Sensitivity analysis indicated that results were robust over
explored range of inputs. Conclusions: According to the results of the modeling
study apixaban may be considered as a cost-effective alternative to warfarin in
VKA suitable patients and as a cost-effective alternative to aspirin in VKA unsuitable patients for NVAF treatment from the Russian Federation national health care
system perspective.
PCV98
The Cost-Effectiveness Of Dabigatran Etexilate Compared With
Warfarin In The Treatment And Secondary Prevention Of Acute
Venous Thromboembolism In The Uk
Jugrin A V 1, Ustyugova A V 2, Urbich M 3, Lamotte M 1, Sunderland T J 4
1IMS Health HEOR, Vilvoorde, Belgium, 2Boehringer Ingelheim GmbH, Ingelheim am Rhein,
Germany, 3Boehringer Ingelheim Ltd, Bracknell, UK, 4Boehringer Ingelheim, Berkshire, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: This economic evaluation aimed to assess the cost-effectiveness of
dabigatran compared with warfarin, in the treatment and secondary prevention
of acute venous thromboembolism (VTE) comprising deep vein thrombosis (DVT)
and pulmonary embolism (PE), in the UK health care setting, based on safety
and efficacy data collected during pivotal phase III trials. Methods: A life-time
Markov state-transition cohort model was developed around the two primary
composite endpoints in the pivotal trials: recurrent VTE and VTE-related death
(rVTE), and major or clinically relevant bleeding (MCRB). Intervention-specific
probabilities of events within the composite endpoint rVTE (recurrent DVT; recurrent PE) and the composite endpoint MCRB (intracranial haemorrhage; other major
bleeds; non-major bleeds) were sourced from the pivotal trials. Beyond the trials
follow-up period, the probability of rVTE was sourced from the literature. Longterm consequences of VTE were considered, namely chronic thromboembolic pulmonary hypertension and post-thrombotic syndrome. The perspective on costs
was that of the NHS and Public Social Services. Health outcomes were assessed
in quality-adjusted life years (QALY). Utility values for health states and events
were EQ-5D data collected within the clinical trials, and the published literature.
Probabilistic sensitivity analyses (PSA) were undertaken. Results: In patients
with index DVT, the estimated incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of treatment with dabigatran compared with warfarin was £614 per QALY gained; in
patients with index PE, the ICER was £1,285/QALY; in the pooled DVT/PE group, the
ICER was £862/QALY. In the treatment followed by secondary prevention analysis,
ICER was £8,319/QALY. PSA suggested that the probability of dabigatran being
cost-effective at a threshold of £30,000/QALY was 90%, 81% and 94% in acute
treatment and 96% in secondary prevention respectively. Conclusions: In a
UK setting, dabigatran appears to be a cost-effective option for treatment and
secondary prevention of VTE in patients with acute DVT and acute PE compared
with warfarin.
PCV99
Economic Evaluation Of Valsartan Versus Olmesartan Addition
To Amlodipine And Hydrochlorothiaziade Single-Pill Triple
Antihypertensive Therapy
Stafylas P 1, Mavrodi A 2, Kourlaba G 3, Hatzikou M 4, Rombopoulos G 4, Maniadakis N5
1Medical Research & Innovation LP, Thessaloniki, Greece, 2University of Macedonia, Thessaloniki,
Greece, 3Collaborative Center for Clinical Epidemiology and Outcomes Research (CLEO), Athens,
Greece, 4Novartis Hellas, Metamorfosis, Greece, 5National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The aim of the study was to compare the cost-utility of the two singlepill triple combination antihypertensive therapies available in the Greek market
for patients with moderate to severe hypertension; the valsartan (V) against the
olmesartan (O) combination with amlodipine (A) and hydrochlorothiazide (H).
Methods: A Markov model with eight health states was constructed. The short-
A490
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
term effect of antihypertensive treatment on blood pressure was extracted from
relative clinical trials and these data were extrapolated through the Hellenic SCORE
and Framingham risk equations, estimating the long-term survival and qualityadjusted life-years (QALYs) gained. Costs and outcomes were evaluated over lifetime, divided into annual cycles and were discounted at 3.0% with 2014 as reference
year. The analysis was conducted from the Greek third-party-payer perspective
(EOPYY). Results: The total lifetime cost related to V/A/H combination was estimated to be lower (€ 10,970) compared to that of the O/A/H combination (€ 11,080),
despite the higher drug acquisition cost. Moreover, the estimated QALYs gained with
the V/A/H combination were 10.88 vs. 10.80 for O/A/H combination. Therefore, the
V/A/H combination was found to be a dominant alternative over O/A/H combination, as it was associated with lower cost and greater efficacy. In a scenario when
the ambulatory blood pressure measurements were taken into account, the ICER
was far lower than the Greek GDP per capita (€ 6,845/QALY) vs. O/A/H combination,
suggesting V/A/H combination to be a cost-effective choice. Extensive sensitivity analyses confirmed the robustness of the results. The probabilistic sensitivity
analysis also demonstrated that there was about 80% probability for the V/A/H
triple combination to be cost-effective at a willingness-to-pay threshold of €16,000/
QALY. Conclusions: This is the first study performed to compare the cost-utility
of the two single-pill triple antihypertensive therapies. The V/A/H combination was
proven dominant over the O/A/H combination for the treatment of moderate to
severe hypertension.
PCV100
Cost-Effectiveness Of High-Sensitive Troponin Assays For The Early
Rule-Out Or Diagnosis Of Acute Myocardial Infarction (Ami) In
People With Acute Chest Pain: A Nice Diagnostic Assessment
Ramaekers B L T 1, Armstrong N 2, Joore M A 3, Westwood M 4, Whiting P 2, Thokala P 5, Ross J 2,
Kleijnen J 2, Severens J 6, van Asselt A 7
University Medical Center,, Maastricht, The Netherlands, 2Kleijnen Systematic
Reviews Ltd., York, UK, 3Department of Clinical Epidemiology and Medical Technology
Assessment, Maastricht University Medical Centre, Maastricht, The Netherlands, 4Kleijnen
Systematic Reviews Ltd, York, UK, 5University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK, 6Erasmus University
Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 7University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
PCV102
Efficiency Of Rehabilitation Programs For Patients After Traumatic
Brain Injury And Acute Cerebrovascular Accident (Stroke) In Russia
Omelyanovsky V 1, Avksentieva M V 2, Derkach E V 3, Dombrovskiy V S 1, Fedyaev D 1
1The Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration, Moscow,
Russia, 2Research Center for Clinical and Economic Evaluation and Pharmacoeconomics, Moscow,
Russia, 3Russian State Medical University, Moscow, Russia
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The objective of the present study was to assess efficiency of rehabilitation programs for patients after traumatic brain injury and acute cerebrovascular
accident (stroke) in Russia. Methods: Short-term clinical and social outcomes
(health status and disability rates) of rehabilitation were analyzed in the database
of the Moscow Center of Speech Pathology and Neurological Rehabilitation. Changes
in the officially registered disability rates and clinical outcomes were assessed for 3
different strategies of rehabilitation: hospital, day care and home care. The decision
tree model was constructed to simulate disability rates, direct and indirect costs of
rehabilitation vs “no rehabilitation” scenario under conditions when officially registered disability corresponds to real health and functional status of patients. TreeAge
Pro 2009 and Microsoft Excel 2010 software were used for modeling. Results: Use
of officially registered disability as an endpoint does not reflect the actual effectiveness of rehabilitation programs. 90% of patients are able to live without assistance
after discharge but still are registered as 1stdegree disabled (most severe degree of
disability in Russia) in order to receive social benefits. According to preliminary
results of modeling total cost of rehabilitation may be less than cost of ”no rehabilitation” scenario if disability correlates with actual health and functional status
of individuals, for example annual total cost is € 25,923 for home care rehabilitation and € 28,124 for “no rehabilitation” scenario. Conclusions: It’s necessary to
improve approaches to official disability registration in Russia in order to make
rehabilitation programs efficient.
.
1Maastricht
Objectives: To assess cost-effectiveness of high sensitivity troponin (hs-cTn)
assays for the management of adults presenting with acute chest pain at the
emergency department. Methods: An economic model was constructed to estimate lifetime costs and QALYs of five hs-cTn strategies (differing according to
manufacturer, timing of the test, number of tests and cutoff point for a positive
test result) compared to standard troponin (sTn) testing at presentation and at
10-12 hours, which was considered the reference standard. In the base case, it
was assumed that sTn testing had perfect accuracy for diagnosing AMI and only
patients with a positive test for sTn were at increased risk for adverse events and
would benefit from immediate treatment. In a secondary analysis, a proportion
of patients with a positive hs-cTn test and a negative sTn test were at increased
risk for adverse events and would benefit from immediate treatment. Results:
Base case: Strategies considered cost-effective depending upon ICER thresholds
were Abbott ARCHITECT hs-cTnI 99th centile (thresholds < £6,597), Beckman
Coulter hs-cTnI 99th centile (thresholds £6,597 - £30,042), Abbott ARCHITECT hscTnI optimal strategy (thresholds £30,042 - £103,194), and the sTn test (thresholds
> £103,194). Secondary analysis: Strategies considered cost-effective were Abbott
ARCHITECT hs-cTnI 99th centile (< £12,217), Roche Elecsys hs-cTnT 99th centile
(£12,217 - £14,992) and Abbott ARCHITECT hs-cTnI optimal strategy (> £14,992).
STn was dominated. Sensitivity/subgroup analyses: Main drivers are: the difference in outcomes between treated and untreated patients, and treatment costs
for patients testing false-positive. Hs-cTn testing is more cost-effective in younger
age, pre-existing coronary artery disease, and symptom onset < 3hrs ago. No testing is only cost-effective when pre-test prevalence is 1%. Conclusions: There
is no strong evidence to prefer one hs-cTn testing strategy over another. Results
do indicate that hs-cTn testing in general may be cost-effective compared to sTn
testing, especially in the secondary analysis.
PCV101
Cost Effectiveness Of Renal Denervation Therapy For The Treatment
Of Resistant Hypertension In The Netherlands
Henry T 1, De Brouwer B F E 2, Van Keep M M L 3, Blankestijn P J 4, Bots M L 4, Koffijberg H 4
Health Solutions, Sheffield, UK, 2Medtronic Trading NL BV, Heerlen, The Netherlands,
3BresMed Health Solutions, Utrecht, The Netherlands, 4University Medical Center, Utrecht, The
Netherlands
PCV103
Impact Of A Pharmacological Cardioversion With Vernakalant On
The Management Cost Of Recent Atrial Fibrillation In Belgium
Lamotte M 1, Gerlier L 1, Caekelbergh K 1, Lalji K 2, Polifka J 2, Lee E 2
1IMS Health HEOR, Vilvoorde, Belgium, 2Cardiome Pharma Corp, Vancouver, BC, Canada
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: We aimed at estimating and comparing the total management costs of
patients admitted to the emergency department (ED) with recent (< 48 hours) atrial
fibrillation (AF) between three types of cardioversion: direct current cardioversion
(DCC), intravenous amiodarone or intravenous vernakalant. Methods: A decision
analytic model was developed to mimic the pathways of patients admitted via the
ED with recent AF and to calculate an average AF management cost per strategy.
The cardioversion success rates were based on published observational studies
(DCC 90%, amiodarone 68%, vernakalant 70%). In case of successful conversion
the patient was released directly from the ED to home (DCC 50%, amiodarone 25%,
vernakalant 100%) or admitted to the hospital for a median of 1 day (DCC) or 2
days (amiodarone) reflecting cardioversion-specific times to sinus rhythm. After
a failed pharmacological cardioversion, patients were assumed to receive a DCC;
failed DCC was followed by intravenous amiodarone. The associated inpatient costs
were retrieved from the IMS Hospital Disease Database (HDD2011). ED treatments
were costed using the national health care payer tariffs. Univariate and probabilistic
sensitivity analyses were performed. Results: The total AF management costs
from ED to discharge were estimated at € 952 (DCC), € 1,894 (amiodarone) and € 1.354
(vernakalant). Given the relative frequencies of amiodarone (55%) and DCC (45%) to
treat recent FA in Belgian ED, the weighted average management cost was €1.470
(+ € 116/treatment vs. vernakalant). The break-even situation is reached when 75%
of successfully treated vernakalant patients avoid the hospitalization (base case
100%). Based on a probabilistic sensitivity analysis, vernakalant was cost saving in
55% of the 1,000 simulations vs. current management. Conclusions: In patients
with recent AF, the rapid mode of action of vernakalant increases the chance of
obtaining sinus rhythm within 48 hours, and its use was cost saving compared to
the current average Belgian practice.
PCV104
Cost Model Analysis Of Gore® Propaten® Vascular Graft VersUS
Standard Eptfe Vascular Graft For Infrapopliteal Bypass In
Peripheral Arterial Disease (pad) Management: Spanish Scenario
1BresMed
Scarpa F
W. L. GORE & Associati S. r. l., Verona, Italy
Objectives: Recent studies have demonstrated the safety and efficacy of catheter-based renal denervation (RDN) for the treatment of resistant hypertension.
These studies have been used to estimate the cost effectiveness of this approach,
however, there is no such published estimation in the Dutch health care setting.
We aimed to determine the cost effectiveness of RDN from the perspective of
the health care payer in The Netherlands. Methods: A Markov state-transition
model previously constructed in TreeAge® was adapted to Microsoft Excel®. The
Excel-based model was updated with costs and quality-adjusted life years (QALYs)
relevant to the Dutch setting and the cost effectiveness of RDN was compared
with standard of care (SoC) for patients with resistant hypertension. The efficacy of RDN treatment was modelled as a reduction in the risk of cardiovascular
events associated with a lower systolic blood pressure (SBP). Results: Base case
deterministic results showed that treatment with RDN resulted in an increase in
QALYs of 0.89 at an incremental cost of € 1,315 per patient resulting in an ICER of
just € 1,474 Deterministic and probabilistic sensitivity analyses (PSA) indicated
treatment with RDN therapy was cost effective at conventional willingness-topay thresholds used in The Netherlands of € 10,000–80,000 per QALY. Furthermore,
9.5% of PSA iterations showed RDN to be a cost saving treatment compared to
SoC. Conclusions: RDN is a cost-effective intervention for patients with resistant hypertension in The Netherlands.
Objectives: Demonstrate the cost savings of using the GORE® PROPATEN® Vascular
Graft compared to standard ePTFE vascular grafts in the management of PAD
patients. Superior clinical outcomes in terms of primary / secondary patency and
limb salvage rates result in lower average per-patient treatment costs. Background:
Vascular bypass is used in patients with PAD (Peripheral Arterial Disease) to treat
ischemic rest pain, to improve walking distance in patients with severe life-limiting
claudication, and to save limbs that might otherwise require amputation. When
patients presenting for peripheral artery reconstruction have absent or inadequate
saphenous veins due to prior use, small size, or poor quality, vascular surgeons
may choose a prosthetic bypass graft. The GORE® PROPATEN® Vascular Graft features a proprietary end-point covalent linkage of heparin molecules to the luminal
surface of the graft that provides sustained resistance to thrombosis. Methods:
A cost model analysis was developed to represent hospital treatment costs. A typical
PAD patient’s treatment pathway in Spanish clinical practice was identified by a
survey involving Spanish vascular surgeons. A literature review was conducted to
determine patency and limb salvage rates. Spanish GRD AP27–2012-Ministerio de
Sanidad tariffs were used as hospital cost of treatment inputs. A three-year patient
management cycle was considered. Results: Better patency and limb salvage rates
obtained using the GORE® PROPATEN® Vascular Graft result in fewer reinterventions and amputations, corresponding to lower per-patient treatment costs. The
cost model demonstrates an overall cost saving for PAD patient management using
the GORE® PROPATEN® Vascular Graft for infrapopliteal bypass. The cumulative
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A491
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
cost savings at 3 years is estimated to be 11.671€ per patient. Conclusions: The
use of the GORE® PROPATEN® Vascular Graft for infrapopliteal bypass in the PAD
patient population represents a safe, clinically effective, and cost-saving alternative
to standard ePTFE vascular grafts.
PCV105
Pharmacoeconomic Analysis Of Rosuvastatin Use In Patients With
Hypercholesterolemia In The Health Care Of Belarus
Kozhanova I 1, Romanova I I 1, Gavrilenko L 1, Sachek M 2
State Medical University, Minsk, Belarus, 2The Belarusian Center for Medical
Technologies, Computer Systems, Administration and Management of Health, Minsk, Belarus
.
.
.
.
.
1Belarusian
Objectives: Pharmacoeconomic analysis of rosuvastatin use in patients with
hypercholesterolemia in the health care of Belarus has been performed to determine economic advisability of its applying in Belarus. As there is own production
of statins (generics of lovastatin, atorvastatin and simvastatin) in Belarus, the
insclusion of new statin (rosuvastatin) in the clinical protocols requires pharmacoeconomic study. Methods: Overview of statins available in Belarus has been
conducted. Equivalent effective dose to achieve target of low density lipoprotein
cholesterol (CH-LPLD) values were established on the basis of published data. Costminimization analysis has been used. Model “decision tree” to achieve the target
CH-LPLD values has been built on the basis of STELLAR trial. Statin doses required
to achieve the target CH-LPLD values have been calculated. The costs of achieving
the target CH-LPLD values have been evaluated. The cost of each statins treating
during the year has been calculated. Results: The highest cost has been obtained
for the equivalent dose of lovastatin ($ 0.35) compared with atorvastatin ($ 0.31) and
simvastatin ($ 0.28) manufactured in Belarus. Average price rosuvastatin (Merten
®) was comparable to the cost ($ 0.21) of Belarusian generics. The average cost of
achieving the target CH-LPLD level was the lowest in the case of rosuvastatin - $ 170
compared with atorvastatin ($ 200) and simvastatin ($ 286) considering available
statins of all manufacturers. Due to rosuvastatin’s lower effective dosage the costs
of the one-year treatment with rosuvastatin is lower (on average 94 $) than with
atorvastatin (all manufacturers - $ 100) and simvastatin (202 $). Conclusions:
The study has demonstrated pharmacoeconomic acceptability of rosuvastatin use
in the health care of Belarus.
PCV106
Cost-Utility Analysis Of Hypertensive Treatment With Indapamide
And Amlodipine Single-Pill Combination In The Polish Setting
Stawowczyk E 1, Holko P 1, Kawalec P 2, Borowiec L 3, Filipiak K J 4
HTA Sp z o. o. Sp. komandytowa, Kraków, Poland, 2Jagiellonian University Medical
College, Krakow, Poland, 3Medical Department, Servier Poland Ltd, Warsaw, Poland, 41st Chair
and Department of Cardiology, Medical University of Warsaw, Warsaw, Poland
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Centrum
Objectives: To assess cost-effectiveness of indapamide 1.5 mg +amlodipine 5/10
mg single-pill combination (SPC) compared with free combination (FC), in the
Polish setting. Methods: A Markov cohort simulation model was used. Results
of meta-analysis by Gupta et al show a difference in patients’ compliance between
SPC and FC. Better compliance results in lower systolic blood pressure, which
influences risk of cardiovascular events. Hence, compliance is associated with
life expectancy and quality of life. Cardiovascular disease risks were based on
the Framingham risk equations. Life-time horizon, Polish public payer perspective and patient perspective were applied. Indapamide/amlodipine SPC cost is
based on average pharmacy prices reported in April 2014 (18.13PLN and 19.75PLN
respectively for 1.5+5mg and 1.5+10mg /30 tabs); 30% patient copayment was
assumed. Cost of FC was calculated as an average cost of reimbursed indapamide
and amlodipine products in corresponding doses. All costs present 2014 values,
and are expressed in Polish zloty (PLN). Costs and effects were discounted with
5% and 3.5% rates. Results: Indapamide/amlodipine SPC compared with FC generates additional life years (LYs) and quality adjusted life years (QALYs), and is
highly cost-effective from public payer perspective and dominant from patient
perspective. Difference between SPC and FC in LYs and QALYs was: 0.007960 and
0.020809. Difference in total costs from public payer perspective and from patient
perspective was 113.14PLN (27.07EUR) and -211.31PLN (-50.56 EUR). ICUR from
public payer perspective was 5,437PLN/QALY (1,301EUR/QALY). At prices +199% vs
the base-case, SPC remains a cost-effective technology from public payer perspective according to the legally defined CE threshold (111,381PLN/QALY= 26,653EUR/
QALY). At prices -9.9% vs base-case, SPC is a dominant/cost saving technology vs
the FC comparator. Conclusions: From public payer perspective, indapamide/
amlodipine SPC compared with FC is a highly cost-effective treatment option for
hypertensive patients in contemporary Polish setting. From patient perspective,
SPC is a dominant technology.
PCV107
Cost-Effectiveness Of Ldl-P-Guided Statin Therapy
Folse H J 1, Rengarajan B 1, Goswami D 1, Budoff M 2, Kahn R 3
1Evidera, San Francisco, CA, USA, 2Los Angeles Biomedical Research Institute, Torrance, CA, USA,
3University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Numerous trials have shown that lowering LDL cholesterol (LDL-C)
reduces CVD events; however, at any LDL-C level, residual risk remains. LDL particle concentration (LDL-P) may be a better predictor of events, but no studies have
evaluated its cost-effectiveness. We used the Archimedes model to evaluate the
cost-effectiveness of using LDL-C or LDL-P in preventing cardiovascular disease
in dyslipidemic patients. Methods: Archimedes is a highly detailed, large-scale
simulation model of physiology, disease and health care systems. We created a
simulated population of 1,000,000 individuals age 20-84 reflective of real subjects
in the NHANES dataset. Because NHANES does not contain LDL-P values, they
were imputed maintaining covariance with other biomarkers. The study had three
arms: •Control: subjects evaluated for therapy for elevated LDL-C and treated
with statins to LDL-C goals outlined in ATP-III; •LDL-P Alone: subjects evaluated
and treated based solely on their LDL-P values; •Dual Arm: subjects evaluated
by LDL-C but treated to both LDL-C and LPL-P recommended goals. Results: In
the general population, the costs per quality-adjusted life year (QALY) associated
with the use of LDL-P alone were $76,052 at 5 years and $8,913 at 20 years and
with the use of both markers were $142,825 at 5 years and $25,505 at 20 years.
In high-risk subpopulations, the use of LDL-P alone was cost-saving at 5 years;
whereas the cost per QALY for the use of both markers was $14,250 at 5 years and
$859 at 20 years for high-risk dyslipidemics, $19,192 at 5 years and $649 at 20 years
for diabetics, and $9,030 at 5 years and $7,268 at 20 years for patients with prior
CHD. Conclusions: Utilizing LDL-P to guide statin therapy is cost-effective in
the long term for the general population, and cost-saving or cost-effective in the
short term for high-risk patients.
PCV108
Cost Effectiveness Analysis Of Ticagrelor Versus Generic
Clopidogrel In The Treatment Of Patients With Acute Coronary
Syndrome In Spain
Capel M 1, Lopez-Sendon J L 2, Heras M 3, Carrera F J 4, Brosa M 5
La Paz, Madrid, Spain, 3Clinic Hospital, Barcelona, Spain,
4Dr. Moliner Hospital, Valencia, Spain, 5Oblikue Consulting, Barcelona, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1AstraZeneca, Madrid, Spain, 2Hospital
Objectives: The aim of this study was to evaluate the long-term cost effectiveness
of ticagrelor + aspirin versus clopidogrel + aspirin in patients with acute coronary
syndrome (ACS) treated for 12 months in Spain. Methods: The cost effectiveness model consisted of a decision tree (1st year) based on the PLATO study and
a long-term Markov model (2nd year onwards). This allowed estimation of cardiovascular events (death, myocardial infarction and non-fatal stroke), survival, health
costs, and health related quality of life. A life time horizon was applied. The daily
drug cost was € 0.60 and € 2.96 for generic clopidogrel and ticagrelor, respectively.
Spanish unit costs and life tables were used; outcomes and costs were discounted
at 3%. A sensitivity analysis across subgroups was carried out, and probabilistic
sensitivity analysis was used to validate the robustness of the model. Results:
Ticagrelor compared to clopidogrel was associated with a gain of 0.1586 life years
and 0.1363 years of quality-adjusted life years (QALY), with an incremental cost of €
596. The incremental cost per life year and per QALY gained was € 3,760 and € 4,374,
respectively. The probabilistic sensitivity analysis showed that ticagrelor was costeffective versus clopidogrel in > 99 % of the simulations given a willingness-to-pay
threshold of € 15,000/QALY. The results were consistent across different subgroups
of ACS patients. Conclusions: Ticagrelor + aspirin for 12 months is a cost effective
treatment compared to generic clopidogrel + aspirin in patients with ACS treated
invasively or conservatively, based on the findings of the PLATO study and Spanish
health care costs.
PCV109
Cost-Utility Analysis Of Carotid Artery Stenting Versus
Endarterectomy For Symptomatic Carotid Stenosis Patients
Oh SH1, You J H 1, Lee J Y 2, Park J J 1, Shin S 3
Evidence-based Healthcare Collaborating Agency, Seoul, South Korea, 2National
Evidence-based Healthcare Collaborating Agency (NECA), Seoul, South Korea, 3National Evidencebased healthcare Collaborating Agency, Seoul, South Korea
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1National
Objectives: This study was conducted to determine the cost-effectiveness of
carotid Artery stenting (CAS) versus carotid endarterectomy (CEA) in patients with
symptomatic carotid stenosis (more than 50% stenosis) in Korean health care system perspective. Methods: We performed a cost-utility analysis. Costs were estimated from retrospective chart review (CAS=346, CEA=331), health insurance claims
data, and other national resources and expressed in 2013 KRW. Transition probabilities were estimated from retrospective chart and systematic review. Health utility
index was assessed for general population using Time Trade Off (TTO) with health
scenario. We used a Markov model to project 15-year costs and quality-adjusted
life years (QALYs) for the 2 treatment groups. Results: In the base case analysis,
CAS produced 6.49 QALYs, compared with 6.71 QALYs for CEA. The incremental
cost of stenting was 1,691,740 KRW. In the base case analysis, CEA for patients
with symptomatic stenosis had a greater benefit than CAS, with lower costs. In
subgroup for patients with stenosis more than 70% or patient with over 80 years
old, CAS was cost-effective. Sensitivity analyses showed that the major stroke or
mortality influenced the results. However the results were consistent with the base
analysis. Conclusions: Under the current circumstances in Korea, CEA was dominated by CEA in symptomatic steonsis. Therefore we concluded that CEA would be
cost-effective intervention for carotid stenosis. To be economically competitive, the
clinical effectiveness such as mortality and major stroke rates of CAS must be at
least equivalent if not less than those of CEA.
PCV110
Burden Of Hyperlipidemia Resulting From Productivity Loss Estimates From Population-Based Register Data In Sweden
Banefelt J 1, Hallberg S 1, Gandra S R 2, Mesterton J 1, Fox K M 3, Paoli C J 2, Johansson G 4, Levin
L Å 5, Sobocki P 6
1Quantify Research, Stockholm, Sweden, 2Amgen, Inc., Thousand Oaks, CA, USA, 3Strategic
Healthcare Solutions, LLC, Monkton, MD, USA, 4Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden, 5Linköping
University, Linköping, Sweden, 6IMS Health, Stockholm, Sweden
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate productivity loss and associated indirect costs in workingage patients treated for hyperlipidemia. Methods: A retrospective populationbased cohort study was conducted using Swedish electronic medical records
linked to national health registers and the Social Insurance Register. Patients were
included based on a prescription of lipid-lowering therapy between January 1,2006
and December 31,2011 and followed until December 31,2012 for estimation of productivity loss and cost outcomes. Patients were stratified into three cohorts based
on cardiovascular (CV) risk level. Results: Total mean days lost, measured as the
sum of net sick leave and net disability pension days, during the one-year period
following study inclusion was highest in the CV event history cohort (n= 6,881; 159
days), followed by the CV risk equivalent (RE) cohort (n= 3,226; 131 days) and the low/
A492
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
unknown risk cohort (n= 2,497; 86 days). The annual indirect cost related to work
productivity loss was estimated at 209,704 SEK for treated hyperlipidemia patients
with CV event history. Corresponding data for CV RE patients and patients at low/
unknown risk were 168,517 SEK and 108,429 SEK, respectively. The higher CV risk
levels were associated with greater productivity losses. Indirect costs varied within
cohorts depending on past diagnoses of the patients. In patients with CV event history, a previous diagnosis of myocardial infarction was associated with the lowest
annual indirect costs (189,114 SEK) while a past diagnosis of ischemic stroke was
associated with the highest indirect costs (281,985 SEK). Within the CV RE cohort, a
previous diagnosis of abdominal aortic aneurysm and transient ischemic attack was
associated with the highest (264,441 SEK) and lowest annual indirect costs (156,254
SEK), respectively. Conclusions: The high level of productivity losses illustrates
the high indirect cost burden in patients treated for hyperlipidemia. The type of
past CV event affected the level of indirect costs.
PCV111
Health Care Costs Associated With Cardiovascular Events In
Patients With Hyperlipidemia - Estimates From Population-Based
Register Data In Sweden
Hallberg S 1, Banefelt J 1, Mesterton J 1, Gandra S R 2, Fox K M 3, Johansson G 4, Levin L Å 5,
Sobocki P 6
1Quantify Research, Stockholm, Sweden, 2Amgen, Inc., Thousand Oaks, CA, USA, 3Strategic
Healthcare Solutions, LLC, Monkton, MD, USA, 4Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden, 5Linköping
University, Linköping, Sweden, 6IMS Health, Stockholm, Sweden
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate annual incremental health care costs of new cardiovascular (CV) events (myocardial infarction, unstable angina, revascularization, ischemic
stroke, transient ischemic attack or heart failure) in patients with hyperlipidemia
or prior CV events. Methods: A retrospective population-based cohort study was
conducted using Swedish electronic medical records and national registers. Patients
were included in the study based on a prescription of lipid-lowering treatment
between January 1, 2006 and December 31, 2006 or history of CV events (prior to
2006) and followed until December 31, 2012 for identification of new CV events and
estimation of cost. Patients were stratified into three cohorts based on CV risk level.
Propensity score matching was applied to compare patients with new events to
patients without new events and to estimate incremental costs. Results: A new
CV event resulted in increased costs during all follow-up years. Inpatient hospital
stays were the main driver of the increase. The majority of the costs occurred in
the first year following event when patients with CV event history (n= 6,881) had
an incremental cost of 74,758 SEK. This was similar to that of CV risk-equivalent
patients (n= 3,226; 75,415 SEK) and patients at low/unknown CV risk (n= 2,497; 72,635
SEK). Ischemic stroke resulted in the highest first year cost in all cohorts (88,739;
85,516; and 87,668 SEK) and transient ischemic attack the lowest (34,098; 36,042;
and 29,052 SEK). Incremental costs during subsequent years remained elevated for
all cohorts, with the CV event history cohort having the highest costs. Second year
incremental costs varied between 10,689 and 15,082 SEK and third year costs varied
between 8,828 and 11,558 SEK across cohorts. Conclusions: The direct costs of
new CV events were substantial and varied considerably by type of event. Costs were
increased during all follow-up years, regardless of CV risk level.
PCV112
Inpatient Case-Related Treatment Costs For Different
Cardiovascular Diseases In Germany
Schädlich P K 1, Rosenfeld S 2, Reindl S 3, Kotowa W 3
Institut GmbH, Berlin, Germany,, 2Sanofi-Aventis Deutschland GmbH, Berlin, Germany,,
3IGES Institut GmbH, Nuremberg, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
1IGES
Objectives: As part of a non-interventional study, hospitalizations due to the
following diagnoses of cardiovascular disease (CVD) were documented: atrial fibrillation (AF), stroke or TIA (SoT), acute coronary syndrome (ACS), arterial embolism (AE), decompensated heart failure (DHF), syncope (S), ventricular arrhythmia
(VA), and cardiac arrest (CA). The objective of this cost analysis was to quantify
inpatient treatment costs for each diagnosis in Germany from the perspective of
the statutory health insurance. Methods: The analysis was conducted for 2012
using the latest available “G-DRG V2013 Browser 2012 § 21 KHEntgG”. Invoiced
diagnosis-related groups (DRGs) including the ICD10-codes corresponding to the
considered diagnoses were collected. For available DRGs, the number of cases with
normal length of stay and the corresponding cost weights (CWs) were documented.
Then, the proportion of an individual DRG within a diagnosis (≥ 1 ICD10-code)
was calculated (number of cases for individual DRG / sum of all cases for every
DRG within a diagnosis = “DRG weight factor”). Next, the CWs of an individual
DRG were multiplied by the “DRG weight factor” to reflect the prevalence of a DRG
within an ICD10-code (“weighted CWs”). Finally, the “weighted CWs” were added
up to obtain an average CW for a diagnosis, which is based on all DRGs and CWs
coded for this single diagnosis. This sum of CWs was multiplied by the state-wide
base rate of 2,991.53€ . Results: The following inpatient treatment costs for the
respective diagnoses were derived: 2,800€ (AF); 5,000€ (SoT); 5,200€ (ACS); 6,200€
(AE); 3,800€ (DHF); 1,900€ (S); 8,200€ (VA); 15,900€ (CA) (rounded). Conclusions:
Inpatient treatment costs for the considered CVD diagnoses vary from 1,900€ to
15,900€ . Generally, hospitalizations due to CVD have a remarkable impact on the
budget of German sick funds. The results of this cost study can be used for further
health economic analyses in CVD.
PCV113
Clinical Pathway And Health Care Resources Utilization Of A
Patients Cohort At High Risk Of Cardiovascular Disease Of Local
Health Care Unit (Asln°1) Of Milan: A Results Of Intervention On
Secondary Prevention
Di Matteo S 1, Colombo G L 2, Malnis D 3, Bruno G M 1
e Valutazioni economiche, Milan, Italy, 2University of Pavia, Milan, Italy,
3Dipartimento Governance asl Milano1, Rho, Italy
.
1S. A. V. E. Studi Analisi
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The objective of the project is to evaluate the impact of health care
resources and the related health care costs in relation to outcomes occurred in 10
years on the cohort of 2002 and intervention on secondary prevention cohort 2010
with a follow-up to 3 years. Methods: In 2002, Local HealthCare Unit (ASLn°1)
of Milan identified a cohort of 33,977 patients with RCV (Cardiovascular risk).
Data analysis was done trough a retrospective claims data study from ASLn°1
of Milan; Physicians who participated were 494. Information has been collected
for inclusion in the study regarding some risk factors and treatment. At the end
of 2010, all recruited patients were started on a program of secondary prevention, by reducing the effects of smoking and BMI after ad hoc training events
for physicians. Results: 12,000 subjects were recruited and followed for 3 years
with reduction of spending on the NHS system and reduced incidence of events.
A resources utilization analysis has been developed using profiles of treatments
and dividing the population into groups with homogeneous treatment (smoking
and BMI control vs. standard care), verifying the occurrence of greater outcomes
and related health care costs. Data are analyzed with the definition of major cardiovascular events, all-cause mortality and cause-specific, occurrence of diabetes
and other chronic greater diseases, verifying the occurrence of greater outcomes
and related health care costs. Conclusions: Administrative databases offer
low-cost information (since they are already available) regarding more or less all
services provided in a health care environment. These sources and their integration are a powerful tool supporting conventional methods used in epidemiological
studies and as tools for plan Health care policy.
Cardiovascular Disorders – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference Studies
PCV114
Cardiovascular Risk, Gender And Medication Adherence In Rural
Area Of Vietnam
Nguyen T P L , CCM S V , Postma M J
University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To examine the relationship between medication compliance, cardiovascular risk and gender in hypertensive patients visiting primary health care centers. Methods: A prospective 1-year study was conducted in rural communes in
Vietnam on hypertension management in a population from 35 to 64 years. Data on
age, gender, blood pressure and blood test were collected at baseline. Cardiovascular
risk was based on the Cardiovascular Risk Prediction Model for populations in
Asia. Medication compliance was calculated as the number of days taking the drug
divided by the number of days since the first day of the prescription. A threshold of
80% was applied to differentiate between compliance or non-compliance. Taking
medication was based on patients’ self-report during each monthly visit. Results:
Of total 338 patients met the selection criteria for medication compliance study,
46% was female. Mean age was 53.5 (+/- 6.9) and 77.2 % of patients was < 10% of
CVD risk in 8 years. In primary health care settings, medication compliance was
49%. No significant difference in medication compliance in both CVD risk groups
(< 10% vs. > 10% risk) was found, also not after controlling for age and gender
(adjusted OR was 1.27; 95 % CI: 0.7 – 2.2; p value 0.39). The odds of medication compliance in females was however 0.6 times higher than in males (95% CI: 0.38 to 0.95,
p value 0.028). Each 1 year increase, results in patients being 1.04 times more likely
to be compliant (95% CI: 1.009 to 1.076, p value 0.01). Conclusions: Medication
compliance rate was low among hypertensive patients in Vietnam. CVD risk at the
baseline did not significantly differentiate complaint from non-compliant patients.
Yet, a major difference in compliance was found for gender. Rather than risk profile,
gender should be considered for guiding the choice on who to target for improving
medication compliance for hypertensive patients.
PCV115
Health Behavior And Medication Adherence
Han E 1, Sohn H S 2, Jang S 3
University, Incheon, South Korea, 2Sookmyung Women’s University, Seoul, South Korea,
3Inje University, Gimhae, South Korea
.
.
.
.
1Yonsei
Objectives: To explore the associations of selected health behaviors with medication adherence in elderly patients aged 65+ years with hypertension, diabetes, or
hyperlipidemia. Methods: The Korean National Health Insurance data between
January 2010 and June 2011 were used. The study included 662,170 hypertensive,
179,285 diabetic, and 244,702 hyperlipidemic patients. Poor medication adherence was defined as < 80% medication possession ratio from January to June 2011.
Health behavior data were from year 2010. Multivariate logistic regression was
used. Results: Patients with a waist circumference < 85 (for women) or 90 (for
men) centimeters were more likely to adhere to their medications. Current smokers and moderate or heavy drinkers showed poor medication adherence than their
counterparts. Mild physical activity was associated with better medication adherence. Conclusions: Public efforts need to focus on improving comprehensive
control of both health behaviors and medication adherence.
PCV116
Understanding Medication Adherence Using Stated-Preference Data
González J M 1, Poulos C 1, Mollon P 2
1RTI Health Solutions, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA, 2Novaris Pharma AG, Basel, Switzerland
.
.
.
.
Objectives: More than half of people who have experienced a myocardial infarction (MI) are not adherent to their medication regimen, which leads to poorer health
outcomes. We used a stated-preference (SP) study to examine factors that could
influence patient compliance to prophylactic cardiovascular treatments, and discuss
practical issues in using SP methods to explain medication adherence. Methods:
Preference data for treatments that lower the risk of cardiovascular events were
collected from 464 respondents in the United States with self-reported history of MI
using a discrete-choice experiment (DCE). All respondents answered 11 judgment
A493
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
questions that presented a pair of virtual patients who were prescribed different
treatments defined by: reduction in the risks of nonfatal MI and fatal MI, treatment-related risk of serious infection, mode and frequency of administration, and
monthly medication cost. Half of the choice questions asked respondents to select
the treatment to which they would most likely be nonadherent. The other half asked
respondents to state which of two virtual patients was better off after learning how
adherent each was to each medication. Limited dependent-variable models were
used to estimate weights indicating the impact of treatment and respondent characteristics on stated-adherence and quantifying the stated impact of nonadherence
on respondents’ well-being. Results: Results indicated that reductions in the risk
of a nonfatal MI had the largest effect on stated adherence, followed by medication
cost, the risk of serious infection, and lastly mode and frequency of administration.
Results also show that reductions in compliance had a significant impact on the
perceived overall benefits of prophylactic treatments. Conclusions: We find that
both clinical and nonclinical factors can impact treatment adherence, suggesting
that the flexibility to include a variety of factors with SP models can be useful in
understanding patient compliance.
PCV117
Patient Adherence Among Adolescents With Arterial Hypertension
Nowakowska E , Paczkowska A , Bryl W , Hoffmann K
Poznan University of Medical Sciences, Poznan, Poland
.
.
.
PCV118
Health State Utilities In Chronic Heart Failure In The Uk
Nafees B 1, Cowie M R 2, Patel C 1, Deschaseaux C 3, Brazier J 4, Lloyd A J 5
1ICON plc, Oxford, UK, 2Imperial College London, London, UK, 3Novartis Pharma AG, Basel,
Switzerland, 4University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK, 5Oxford Outcomes, An ICON plc Company,
Oxford, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Previous research has shown the impact of chronic heart failure (CHF)
on health-related quality of life (HRQL). Less is known regarding the impact of
reduced ejection fraction (HFrEF) on HRQL. The aim of this study was to elicit utility
values for CHF with HFrEF or preserved ejection fraction (HFpEF) by New York Heart
Association (NYHA) classification system in the UK. In addition, utility values for
events such as stroke, myocardial infarction (MI) and chronic kidney disease (CKD)
were estimated. Methods: Health states were developed from concept elicitation
interviews with CHF patients (N= 10) and cardiologists (N= 5). Draft health states
were validated in cognitive debrief interviews with different patients (N= 5) and
cardiologists (N= 4) and finalised with scientific input from experts. The resulting
health states (n = 10) were piloted with general public to check understanding.
General public participants (n=100) completed background questions and rated each
state using visual analogue scale and time trade-off (TTO) assessments (with lead
time method for states worse than dead). Results: The mean TTO utility for HF-rEF
ranged between 0.86 (SD= 0.19) (NYHA class II); 0.60 (SD= 0.23) (NYHA III) to 0.28
(SD= 0.41) (NYHA IV). Equivalent values for HF-pEF were 0.83 (SD=0.24) (NYHA II);
0.55 (SD= 0.28) (NYHA III) to 0.27 (SD= 0.35) (class IV) respectively. Other values
were post hospitalisation after stroke (mean= 0.30, SD= 0.43); post MI (mean= 0.45,
SD= 0.37) and CKD (mean= 0.78, SD= 0.21). Post-hospitalisation states captured a
period of upto three months after the event. Conclusions: This study shows the
effect that NYHA class has on HRQL for people with CHF in the UK. The findings
showed that HFrEF and HFpEF were very similar. Participants considered events such
as recovery from stroke to have significant impact on HRQL. These are important
data to consider in evaluating outcomes of treatments and should be reflected in
cost effectiveness models in CHF where relevant.
PCV119
Acute And Chronic Impact Of Cardiovascular Events On Health
State Utilities
Matza L S 1, Devine M K 1, Gandra S R 2, Delio P R 3, Fenster B E 4, Davies E 5, Jordan J1, Lothgren
M6, Feeny D H 7
1Evidera, Bethesda, MD, USA, 2Amgen, Inc., Thousand Oaks, CA, USA, 3Neurology Associates of
Santa Barbara, Santa Barbara, CA, USA, 4National Jewish Health, Denver, CO, USA, 5Evidera,
London, UK, 6Amgen (Europe) GmbH, Zug, Switzerland, 7University of Alberta, Portland, OR, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
PCV120
Health State In Patients With Atrial Fibrillation On New Oral
Anticoagulants As Assessed With The New Eq-5d-5l Questionnaire
At Baseline And 12-Month Follow-Up: Prefer In Af Registry
Brüggenjürgen B 1, Schliephacke T 2, Darius H 3, De Caterina R 4, Le Heuzey J Y 5, Reimitz P E 2,
Schilling R J 6, Schwertfeger M 2, Zamorano J L 7, Kirchhof P 8
1Steinbeis University Berlin (SHB), Berlin, Germany, 2Daiichi Sankyo Europe GmbH, Munich,
Germany, 3Vivantes Hospital Neukölln, Berlin, Germany, 4G. d’Annunzio University, Chieti, Italy,
5Hôpital Européen Georges Pompidou, Université René Descartes, Paris, France, 6Barts and St
Thomas Hospital, London, UK, 7University Hospital Ramón y Cajal, Madrid, Spain, 8University of
Birmingham Centre for Cardiovascular Sciences and SWBH NHS Trust, Birmingham, UK
.
Objectives: The aim of the study was to assessment of compliance by adolescents
in the field of pharmacological and non-pharmacological methods of hypertension treatment. Methods: The study included 62 patients (20 women, 42 men)
diagnosed with hypertension and treated in specialist health care facilities. As
a research tool was used questionnaire prepared on the basis of recent literature. Results: The vast majority of respondents (72,7%) declared that regularly taking
antihypertensive drugs. The proportion of patients regularly taking antihypertensive
drugs was higher in patients treated with monotherapy than polytherapy (48,5% vs
24,2%). Among the methods of non-pharmacological treatment of hypertension the
most accepted lifestyle change in the study population was smoking cessation (83,8%
of respondents) and reduction of salt consumption (64,5% of respondents), and the
least acceptable lifestyle change was to maintain proper body weight by eating a low
calorie diet (30,6% of respondents). Conclusions: Adolescents with hypertension
in varying degrees adhere to a medical recommendations related to the hypertension
treatment. From the available literature data indicate that the current effective way
to improve cooperation with the patient’s is education.
.
recovery; post-event health states represented chronic impact. UK general population respondents valued the health states in time trade-off tasks with time horizons
of one year for acute states and ten years for chronic states. Results: A total of 200
participants completed interviews (55% female; mean age = 46.6y). Among acute
health states, stroke had the lowest utility (0.33), followed by heart failure (0.60) and
ACS (0.67). Utility scores for chronic health states followed the same pattern: stroke
(0.52), heart failure (0.57), and ACS (0.82). For stroke and ACS, acute utilities were
significantly lower than utilities for chronic post-event (difference = 0.20 and 0.15,
respectively; both p < 0.0001). Conclusions: Results add to previously published
utilities for cardiovascular events by distinguishing between chronic post-event
health states and acute health states that include the event and its immediate
impact. Findings suggest that acute and chronic impact should be considered when
selecting scores for use in cost-utility models. Thus, the current utilities provide a
unique option that may be used to represent the acute and chronic impact of cardiovascular conditions in economic models comparing treatments that may delay
or prevent the onset of cardiovascular events.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Cost-utility models are frequently conducted to compare treatments
intended to prevent or delay cardiovascular events. Most published utilities represent post-event health states without incorporating the disutility of the event or
reporting the time between the event and utility assessment. Therefore, the objective of this study was to estimate health state utilities representing cardiovascular
conditions while distinguishing between acute impact including the cardiovascular
event and the chronic post-event impact. Methods: Health states were drafted
and refined based on literature review, clinician interviews, and a pilot study. Three
cardiovascular conditions were described: stroke, acute coronary syndrome (ACS),
and heart failure. One-year acute health states represented the event and gradual
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: We aimed to understand the short-term impact on quality of life
associated with Non VKA Oral AntiCoagulants (NOACs) use in patients with AF. We
obtained baseline (BL) and follow-up (FU) data on the health state of AF patients
under everyday practice conditions in the PREvention oF thromboembolic events
– European Registry in Atrial Fibrillation (PREFER in AF). Methods: PREFER in AF
documents AF patients in terms of clinical characteristics, management, quality of life and other outcome parameters. The EuroQol EQ-5D-5L descriptive system and visual analogue scale (VAS) were applied in PREFER in AF at BL and FU
to obtain patient-reported generic health-related quality of life information and
utility weights. Results: Of the 6390 AF patients at follow-up 1895 (29.7%) had
paroxysmal, 1533 (24.0%) persistent, 474 (7.4%) long-standing persistent, and 2488
(38.9%) permanent AF. Comorbidities were highly prevalent. 3344 AF patients (61.1%
males, mean age 71.7 ± 9.85 years) provided EQ-5D-5L data both at BL and 12-month
FU. On the VAS (range 0-100), the mean score at FU was 68.8 ±18.1 points, with
no major differences between patients on NOACs (68.3), VKAs (68.9), AP (70.1), or
VKA+AP (71.7), respectively. All scores improved from baseline from 0.36 in patients
on VKA to 1.77 for those on AP. The overall utility index at FU was 0.80 ±0.21. At FU
the 409 patients on NOACs had a utility score of 0.79 (change from BL, -0.01), the
1789 patients VKAs 0.80 (-0.01), the 237 patients on AP 0.81 (+0.01), the 151 patients
on VKA and AP 0.80 (-0.01) and the 749 patients receiving neither VKAs nor AP
0.80 (0.00). Conclusions: Patients with AF present with reduced self-reported
quality of life compared to the general population. Patients receiving NOACs had
similar quality of life both at baseline and after 12-month FU, when compared to
alternative medications.
PCV121
Health State In Patients With Venous Thromboembolism On
Conventional And Non-Vka Oral Anticoagulants As Assessed With
The Eq-5d-5l Questionnaire: Prefer In Vte Registry
Cohen A T 1, Bauersachs R 2, Gitt A K 3, Mismetti P 4, Monreal M 5, Willich S N 6, Wolf W P 7,
Agnelli G 8
1King’s College, London, UK, 2Max-Ratschow-Klinik für Angiologie, Gefäßzentrum Klinikum
Darmstadt GmbH, Darmstadt, Germany, 3Herzzentrum Ludwigshafen, Ludwigshafen, Germany,
4Centre Hospitalier Universitaire Saint-Etienne, Hopital Nord, Saint Etienne, France, 5Hospital
Universitari Germans Trias I Pujol, Barcelona, Spain, 6Charité - Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Berlin,
Germany, 7Daiichi Sankyo Europe GmbH, Munich, Germany, 8University of Perugia, Santa Maria
della Misericordia Hospital, Perugia, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Non-VKA oral anticoagulants (NOAC), which do not need routine
monitoring, have the potential to improve the quality of life (QoL) in patients on
long-term treatment for venous thromboembolism (VTE). We aimed to obtain
contemporary data on the health state of patients with VTE under daily practice
conditions. Methods: PREFER in VTE is a non-interventional study in 7 countries
(France, Germany, Austria, Switzerland, Italy, Spain, UK) that prospectively documents patients after an event of acute deep venous thrombosis (DVT) or pulmonary embolism (PE) in terms of clinical characteristics, management, quality of life
and other outcome parameters. The EuroQol EQ-5D-5L consists of the 5-dimension
descriptive system used to derive utility scores and the visual analogue scale (VAS),
measuring self-rated health (scale 0-100). Results: A total of 2790 patients with
acute VTE at baseline (BL: 1640 DVT, 1150 PE ±DVT) and 723 patients at an interim
analysis at 6 months (443 DVT and 280 PE ±DVT) completed the EQ-5D-5L. On the
EQ VAS for current health state, the mean score at 6 months was 73.8 points (change
from BL +10.9), with similar values in DVT patients (74.6, change from BL +9.8)
compared to PE patients (72.4, change from BL +12.4). Between BL and 6-month
follow-up, index values increased in all medication classes (heparin only: 0.66 to
0.75; heparin/VKA: 0.70 to 0.84; NOAC: 0.73 to 0.87). Overall the index value increased
from 0.69 to 0.83 (DVT: 0.71 to 0.85, PE: 0.67 to 0.81). Conclusions: Under clinical
practice conditions, patients on NOAC and heparin/VKA had larger increases in their
health state scores than those on heparin only. This generic QoL tool detected only
small differences between treatment options. Six months after the event, patients
with DVT had similar self-reported QoL on the VAS compared to patients with PE,
and patients with DVT had somewhat higher utility values.
A494
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PCV122
The Intermediate Burden Of Diabetes Mellitus In Patients With
Cardiovascular Disease (Cvd): A Quality Adjusted Life Year (Qaly)
-Analysis Based On Primary Longitudinal Data
Laxy M 1, Hunger M 2, Thorand B 1, Meisinger C 1, Kirchberger I 3, Holle R 1
Zentrum München - German Research Center for Environmental Health (GmbH),
Neuherberg, Germany, 2Helmholtz Zentrum München, Neuherberg, Germany, 3KORA Myocardial
Infarction Registry, Augsburg Hospital, Augsburg, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Helmholtz
Objectives: While the independent influence of metabolic and cardiovascular
diseases on either quality of life (QoL) or survival is well studied, the evidence on
the combined burden in terms of quality adjusted life years (QALYs) is rather weak.
Previous burden of disease studies mostly combined cross-sectional QoL data
with mortality statistics from other data sources. However, due to strong model
assumptions these studies might be limited in validity and accuracy. The goal of
this study was to analyze the intermediate burden of diabetes in patients with
previous myocardial infarction in terms of QALYs lost, by introducing a method
capable to exploit primary longitudinal data sources of population-based studies. Methods: Data for this analysis were taken from the KORA-Acute Myocardial
Infarction (AMI) Registry. QoL (Euro-Qol-5D-index, German tariff) of a subset of
patients known to be alive was assessed through postal surveys in 2006 (n= 1022)
and subsequently in 2011 (n= 716). Mortality was tracked by the routine surveillance system of the AMI Registry. QALYs gained were calculated assuming a
linear QoL change from baseline to follow-up. QoL trajectories of non-responders at follow-up and patients who died before follow-up were approximated by
multiple imputation methods using the baseline QoL and covariate structure.
Ordinary least square regression models were performed to quantify the QALYs
and life years (LYs) lost over the mean observation time. Results: Over a mean
observation time of 4 years, patients with diabetes lost 0.14 LYs (3.75 vs. 3.89,
p< 0.01) and 0.36 QALYs (2.96 vs. 3.33, p< 0.01) more than patients without diabetes. The QALY-gap was greatest for diabetic patients taking insulin (-0.66, p< 0.01).
Sensitivity analyses showed that models were robust concerning model assumptions. Conclusions: The intermediate burden of diabetes for patients with CVD
is substantial. Using individual-level data from population-based follow-up of
studies is a valuable methodological extension to accurately quantify the burden
of chronic conditions.
PCV123
Sensitivity Of The Safuca Questionnaire To Detect Differences
Between Atrial Fibrillation Patients Treated With Vitamin-K
Antagonist Against Those Treated With New Oral Anticoagulants
Ruiz M A 1, Anguita M 2, Bertomeu V 2, Cequier Á 2, Muñiz J 2
1Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Madrid, Spain, 2Sociedad Española de Cardiología, Madrid,
Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: A secondary analysis was carried out to test if differences existed in
reported treatment satisfaction between non-valvular atrial fibrillation patients
(NVAF) treated with vitamin K antagonist (VKA) anticoagulants and new oral anticoagulants (NOAC). Methods: A sample of 1318 patients was recruited at random
in the FANTASIIA study, between June 2013 and March 2014, from which 77% were
using VKA and 23% NOAC at least 6 months before inclusion. The specific treatment
satisfaction instrument SAFUCA was used to test differences between groups. The
SAFUCA questionnaire is composed by 7 dimensions and overall score, measured
in a 0 (least satisfied), 100 (most satisfied) scale. Guyatt’s d was used to estimate
effect size. Results: Mean age was 73.8 (SD= 9.4) years, and 42.5% were women.
Patients using NOACs attained statistically significant higher values in the overall
score and in all SAFUCA dimensions. Overall score effect size (NOAC vs VKA) was
medium-small (79.91 vs 73.22, d= 0.43, p< 0.001). Small to large effect sizes were
also found by dimension: Effectiveness (77.63 vs 72.70, d= 0.33, p< 0.01), Ease and
Convenience (80.99 vs 73.72, d= 0.49, p< 0.001), INR Controls (62.35 vs 57.66, d= 0.32,
p< 0.01), Impact on Daily Activities (90.08 vs 81.97, d= 0.55, p< 0.001), Medication
Undesired Effects (86.20 vs 79.21, d= 0.47, p< 0.001), Satisfaction with Medical Care
(80.30 vs 69.38, d= 0.74, p< 0.001), and Overall Satisfaction (80.30 vs 69.38, d= 0.74,
p< 0.001). Conclusions: SAFUCA questionnaire was able to detect satisfaction
differences between NVAF patients treated with NOAC and those treated with VKA,
presenting medium effect size in most dimensions. This new evidences offer additional support to the questionnaire validity.
PCV124
Unmet Needs And Solutions For Heart Failure Admission
Steel A , Ansaripour A , Collett S , Wick C, Wagih S , Bakhai A
Barnet & Chase Farm Hospitals NHS Trust, London, UK
.
.
.
.
aggressive therapies such as complex devices or ultrafiltration, as well as enabling
an enriched end of life experience for those beyond such therapies. Enabling end
stage patients to die in their location of choice would also release considerable
resources at the same time.
.
Objectives: Unplanned patient admissions to hospital with heart failure (HF) are
on the increase due to an ageing population and increasing survival post coronary
disease. Pre-discharge mortality is high, predictable and often occurs after many
days stay for many patients and often without palliative care involvement, not
aligned with guidance. Methods: We audited palliative care input to HF patients
admitted to our hospital as the predominant condition and subsequently passing
away, both before and after an awareness campaign, publishing barriers to end
of life dialogues between patient and clinicians, demonstrating the early use of
a Get With The Guidelines (GWTG) risk assessment tool to predict mortality and
introduction of a daily HF nursing team service. Results: In 2009, amongst 57 HF
patients the average time to death was 17.8 days, only 7% received any palliative
input before death. The time to death in these patients correlated positively with the
(GWTG) predictive score indicating that these deaths could have been anticipated
and appropriate palliative involvement triggered. Data from 2010 to 2013 following
these interventions (n= 99) showed a marked improvement with 44% of patients
having palliative input before death. The average time to death in this group was
comparable at 17.22 days. Conclusions: The care of HF patients and their families
can be greatly improved with early mortality prediction, sensitive dialogues, routine
involvement of HF teams both to enhance survival for patients who will benefit from
PCV125
Clinical Psychologists: Closing The Communication Gap Between
Physicians And Patients, Leading To Higher Patient Satisfaction And
Compliance
Djambazov S N 1, Vekov T Y 2, Petrov D 3, Lambeva V 4
clinics Doc Dr Valentina Tsekova, Sofia, Bulgaria, 2Medical University Pleven, Pleven,
Bulgaria, 3Bulgarian Medical Union, Sofia, Bulgaria, 4Telelink, Sofia, Bulgaria
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Cancer
Objectives: We wanted to compare the patient satisfaction and compliance
between a hospital with a trained clinical psychologist, acting as a mediator
between physicians and patients and a hospital without one. Methods: The
comparison was done between two identical cardiac hospitals, which belong
to the same network of cardiac facilities, for a period of six months. At each
hospital, 200 patients were included. The patient characteristics, numbers and
patient flow were comparable; the facilities were identical as level of comfort
and staff training. To measure the patient satisfaction we used a questionnaire.
The level of attendance of control visits after discharge we measured with the
hospital registry. How many of the 200 patients stick to the discharge therapy
after 3 and after 6 months after discharge, we measured with the out-patient centre registry and by telephone interviews. Results: In each hospital 200 patients
were included and followed-up. For the hospital without clinical psychologist,
patient satisfaction was 79% excellent marks (n= 158), control visits attendance
was 42% (n= 84), patient compliance was 72% (n= 144) on the 3rd and 65% (n= 130)
on the 6th month after discharge. For the hospital with a clinical psychologist,
patient satisfaction was 97% excellent marks (n= 194), control visits attendance
was 78% (n= 156), patient compliance was 96% (n= 192) on the 3rd and 89% (n= 178)
on the 6th month after discharge. With the help of a trained clinical psychologist,
we witnessed the following differences: 18% improvement in patient satisfaction, 36% better attendance to control visits, 24% more compliant patients for
both the 3rd and 6th month after discharge. Conclusions: Trained clinical
psychologists may play the role of a mediator and close the communication gap
between physicians and patients and lead to improved patient satisfaction and
compliance.
PCV126
Evaluating The Gap Between Physicians’ And Patients’
Understanding Of Patient Needs
Djambazov S N 1, Vekov T Y 2, Petrov D 3
clinics Doc Dr Valentina Tsekova, Sofia, Bulgaria, 2Medical University Pleven, Pleven,
Bulgaria, 3Bulgarian Medical Union, Sofia, Bulgaria
.
.
.
.
.
1Cancer
Objectives: We wanted to establish the gap between physicians’ and patients’
understanding of patient needs in a hospital setting. Methods: The study was
run in the four of the Bulgarian Cardiac Institute clinics. We used questionnaires
and within a period of two months, first we asked 30 physicians and 50 patients
about what patient needs are according to their understanding. Based on the
answers we defined 10 categories for each of the two groups. Then we asked 143
physicians and 500 patients to define which category is most and least important
for them by using the Maximum Difference Scaling technique. Results: Courtesy,
after discharge recommendations and information about the discharge drugs were
the top three most important patient needs according to the patients. Life-saving
activities, improvement of quality of life and improve the longevity were the top
three most important patient needs according to the physicians. Conclusions:
There is a tremendous gap between patients’ and physicians’ perceptions of
patient needs. It is very hard for the hospitals to increase patient satisfaction
relying on medical services only. Further research is needed to find ways to close
that gap.
PCV127
Beliefs About Medicines In An Urban Black Hypertension Population
Barr J 1, Callender S 2, Tung D 1, Fashote B 1, Lacroix L 3, Young A 2
1Northeastern University, Boston, MA, MA, USA, 2Mattapan Community Health Center, Boston,
MA, USA, 3Northeastern University, Boston, MA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Given ethnic variation in attitudes toward hypertension (Ford 2010;
Lewis 2010), study objectives are to determine 1) patient preferences concerning medication use as revealed by responses to Beliefs about Medicines Questionnaire (BMQ,
Horne 1999) in an urban black population with hypertension (HTN) and 2) if these
preferences were influenced by experiences with parents/friends HTN diagnoses.
Methods: After approval from Northeastern University’s Institutional Review
Board, coded clinic appointment schedules were used to identify patients scheduled for routine HTN follow-up appointment at a Boston inner-city community
health center. Researchers screened for eligibility (English speaking, black ethnicity, taking anti-hypertensive medication), described the study, and requested
informed consent. Patients agreeing to participate and completing background
questions and the hypertension-specific Beliefs about Medicines questionnaire
(BMQ: 18 items, 5 levels, strongly agree-strongly disagree) received a $10 CVSprovided gift card. Results: 189 patients were approached. 94 (49.7%) completed
the questionnaire, 11.6% declined, and 38.6% didn’t meet criteria, e.g., didn’t speak
English or had previously completed the BMQ. Patients averaged 55.6yo, 67%
female. Overall BMQ factor scores were: Specific Necessity (SN), 3.41 ±0.83; Specific
Concerns (SC), 2.82 ±0.8; General Overuse (GO), 2.98 ±0.74 and General Harm (GH),
2.54 ±0.72. Patients whose parent had a stroke had higher SN (p= 0.038) and lower
GH scores (p= 0.042) than patients without that prior experience. There was no difference in any factors as to whether parents or a friend did/didn’t have hypertension and whether a friend did/didn’t have a stroke. SC were lower in patients with
higher educational level (p= 0.002). No statistical associations occurred between
A495
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
self-reported adherence results and any of the 4 factor scores. Conclusions:
This study provides BMQ factor scores for urban black HTN patients and insight
into how experiences of patient’s parents can be used to target increased perception of anti-hypertensive medication necessity and reduce patient-specific
medication harm concerns.
PCV128
Place Of Residence And Employment Status After Stroke
Dewilde S 1, Peeters A 2, Thijs V 3, Annemans L 4, Belgian Stroke Council N P 5
1SHE, Brussels, Belgium, 2Cliniques universitaires Saint-Luc, Bruxelles, Belgium, 3KULeuven,
Leuven, Belgium, 4Ghent University & Brussels University, Ghent, Belgium, 5Virga Jesseziekenhuis,
Hasselt, Belgium
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To investigate the living and employment situation of patients after
stroke, and examine whether this differs by degree of disability. Methods: We
conducted an observational retrospective study among 569 post-stroke patients
and examined changes in employment and living situation. The investigational
period was divided into 3 intervals: < 3,3-6 and > 6 months after stroke. All patients
had their mRS (modified Rankin Score, ranging from 0 full health to 5 severely
dependent) measured at 3 months after stroke, plus an additional mRS assessment
if their stroke was more than 6 months ago. Patients were recruited in 10 regional
and university hospitals across Belgium using a convenience sample stratified by
mRS. Results: Before their stroke the majority of patients lived at home (99%)
despite the fact that 13% had a previous stroke. At 3 months after stroke an association was found between the time spent in an inpatient care facility (hospital, rehabilitation facility, nursing home) and the mRS (p< 0.0001 Weibull survival analysis,
average inpatients days were 9.2, 14.1, 27.7, 53.4, 67.0 and 73.4 for mRS 0-5 respectively). Between 3 and 6 months after stroke on average 7% of patients were staying
in a rehabilitation facility and 5% in a nursing home; these were mostly patients
with mRS > = 3. After six months all patients returned home, except patients with
mRS4 (36% home) and mRS5 (38% home). Before stroke 70% of patients were retired;
in those working before their stroke, 16-20% patients in mRS categories 0-2 were
working again compared to none in mRS category 3-5, of which 14% took early
retirement or leave of absence. Conclusions: Experiencing a mild stroke will
not affect the patient’s employment and living situation beyond the short term;
however suffering a severe stroke is likely to lead to significant changes in place of
residence and occupation.
PCV129
Uisess-B Oral Health Questionnaire Validity And Reliability In A
Mexican Diabetic, Systemic Hypertension And Obese Patients
Salcedo-Rocha A L 1, Flores-Larios E A 2, Balderas-Peña L M A 3, Preciado-Serrano M D L 2,
García de Alba-García J E 1
1Delegación Jalisco IMSS, Guadalajara, Jalisco, Mexico, 2Universidad de Guadalajara, Guadalajara,
Jalisco, Mexico, 3UMAE Hospital de Especialidades Centro Médico Nacional de Occidente IMSS,
Guadalajara, Jalisco, Mexico
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Evaluate validity and reliability of the UISESS-B oral health questionnaire in a Mexican diabetic, systemic hypertension and obese patients in the
primary health care level. Methods: Were studied 105 subjects with diabetes,
systemic hypertension and/or over-weigh-obesity in the context of a diabetic’s
control group in the Instituto Mexicano del Seguro Social. Was applied an oral
health questionnaire named UISESS-B previously validated. The instrument is
divided in three main areas: oral health care habits, oral health and nutrition
related habits, and oral health care related symptoms and signs. ResultsConstruct
validity was confirmed by the correct compilation of the items included in the
two main constructs: habits and perceptions each one including specific multiitem questionnaires (correlation coefficients ranged from 0.30 to 0.80, P>0.001);
the reliability was confirmed by the internal consistency (Cronbach alpha: 0.55
for the construct habits and 0.71 for the construct perceptions). Conclusions:
The UISESS-B questionnaire shows significant validity and reliability, suggesting
its use as an instrument useful to be used as a patient reported outcome in oral
health in patients with chronic diseases.
PCV130
The “Venous Age”: A New Tool To Sensitize Patients To Their Venous
Disease
Allaert F A 1, Crebassa V 2
Biotech/CEN Nutriment, Dijon, France, 2clinique du millénaire, Montpellier, France
.
.
.
1CEN
Objectives: Many years ago, cardiologists developed on the basis of the
Framingham study an “arterial age” which is very useful to sensitize patients to their
cardiovascular risk. The purpose of the study was to develop a “venous age” to make
people more aware of their venous disease and to better adhere to lifestyle improvement and venous disease treatments. Methods: The score calculation was based
on an international epidemiological study conducted in 24 countries in the daily
practice or general practitioners. The data base included patients with or without
venous disease, whatever the reason for which they were consulting and whatever
the level of their venous disease which was systematically described according the
elements of the international CEAP classification. Results: The study covers 124
235 patients aged of 52 among whom 69.4% were female. Among them 18.8% had no
sign of venous disease (C0), 22.9% had only functional symptoms (C0s), 40.6% had
Telangiectasies or reticular veins, 34.8% varicose, 24.9% edema, 14.0% skin changes,
7.3 Healed ulcers and 4.3% active ulcers. The statistical analysis has determined
the number of years which must be added to the real age to get the “venous age”
by comparison of the age of somebody who has no venous functional symptoms
or physical signs. The results provide that number for women and men according
the different venous symptoms and sign they present. Conclusions: This first
attempt of creating a “venous age” will be certainly improved in the next future,
using more complex analysis based on risk factors or other criteria, but it seems
already efficient to make people aware of their venous risk and to better adhere to
lifestyle improvement and venous disease treatments.
PCV131
Preferences Regarding The Attributes Of Oral Anticoagulants
In Patients With Atrial Fibrillation Results Of A Discrete Choice
Experiment
Boettger B 1, Thate-Waschke I M 2, Bauersachs R 3, Kohlmann T 4, Wilke T 5
1IPAM - Institut für Pharmakooekonomie und Arzneimittellogistik, Wismar, Germany, 2Bayer Vital
GmbH, Leverkusen, Germany, 3Max-Ratschow-Klinik für Angiologie, Gefäßzentrum Klinikum
Darmstadt GmbH, Darmstadt, Germany, 4University Medicine Greifswald, Greifswald, Germany,
5IPAM - Institute for Pharmacoeconomics and Medication Logistics, Wismar, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Since the introduction of non-vitamin-K-antagonist oral anticoagulants (OACs), an additional option for stroke prevention in patients with atrial fibrillation (AF) compared to vitamin-K-antagonists (VKAs) is available. The objective
of this study was to assess patients’ preferences regarding the attributes of these
different treatment options. Methods: We conducted a multicenter study among
randomly selected physicians who were asked to recruit AF patients. Patients’
preferences were assessed by computer-assisted telephone interviews. We used a
Discrete-Choice-Experiment (DCE) with four treatment dependent attributes (need
of bridging: yes/no, interactions with food/nutrition: yes/no, need of INR controls/
dose adjustment: yes/no, frequency of intake: once/twice daily) and one comparator attribute (distance to practitioner: < 1km/> 15km). Preferences measured in the
interviews were analyzed descriptively and based on a conditional logistic regression model. Results: A total of 140 AF patients (age: 74.0±8.5 years; 57.0% male;
mean CHA2DS2-VASc: 6.1±1.1; current medication: 27.1% rivaroxaban, 71.4% VKA,
1.4% other) could be interviewed. Regardless of type of medication, patients significantly preferred the attributes’ level (in order of patients’ importance) “once daily”
for “frequency of intake” (binary-coded: once = 1 vs. twice = 0; Coefficient = 0.954;
p< 0.001), “no” for “interaction with food/nutrition” (yes vs. no; -0.842; p< 0.001), “no”
for “bridging necessary” (yes vs. no; -0.656; p< 0.001) and “≤ 1 km” for “distance to
practitioner” (≤ 1 km vs. > 15 km; 0.644; p< 0.001). However, for the attribute “need of
INR controls/dose adjustment” (yes vs. no; 0.020; p=0.808) no significant preference
in favour of one of the options are shown. Conclusions: In our analyses, “once
daily frequency of intake” was the most important attribute for patients’ choice
followed by “no interactions with food/nutrition” and “no bridging necessary”. Thus,
patients with AF seem to prefer treatment options which are easier to administer.
PCV132
Health Related Quality Of Life At One Year Post Discharge In
Patients With Heart Failure
Escobar A 1, Trancho Z 1, Gonzale-Saenz de Tejada M 1, Quiros R 2, Garcia Perez L 3,
Navarro G 4, Bilbao A 5
1Basurto University Hospital (Osakidetza). Red de Investigación en Servicios Sanitarios y
Enfermedades Crónicas (REDISSEC)., Bilbao, Spain, 2Hospital Costa del Sol. Marbella, Marbella,
Spain, 3D. Servicio Canario de Salud. Red de Investigación en Servicios Sanitarios y Enfermedades
Crónicas (REDISSEC), Santa Cruz, Spain, 4Corporació Sanitària Parc Taulí, Sabadell, Spain,
5Basurto University Hospital (Osakidetza). Red de Investigación en Servicios Sanitarios y
Enfermedades Crónicas (REDISSEC), Bilbao, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: There are few studies in Spain about outcomes at 1-year in terms of
health-related quality of life (HRQoL) in patients hospitalized by heart failure (HF).
The main objective of the present study was to evaluate changes in HRQoL from
baseline to 1-year post discharge in patients with HF through two questionnaires,
SF-12 and Minnesota Living with Heart Failure questionnaire (MLHFQ). Methods:
This has been a prospective study with 502 patients admitted by HF in Basque
Country (Spain). Patients completed questionnaires during their hospitalization and
at 1-year. The MLHFQ is a specific instrument which has 21 items with an overall
scale, physical (8 items) and emotional (5 items) subscales. MLHFQ items are scoring
from 0 (best) to 5 (worst). Total score ranges from 0 to 105, physical domain from
0 to 40 and emotional from 0 to 25. SF-12 has two dimensions, Physical Summary
Score (PCS) and Mental Summary Score (MSC) which scores range from 0 (worst)
to 100 (best). We have used general linear model to study gains in each dimension
adjusted by baseline score, age, gender and hospital readmissions in the previous
6 months. Results: Mean age was 76.7 (SD= 10.4), there were a 56.1% of men and
20.3% of readmissions in the previous six months. Regarding both questionnaires
and dimensions, baseline status influence in gains, the worse the baseline the more
the gains. Likewise men have greater gains and patients readmitted lower in all
domains. Age has an influence in MLHFQ physical domain and PCS. Conclusions:
Adjusted by baseline score and readmissions, men have greater improvements in
all domains of MLHFQ and SF-12. On the other hand, the younger the patients the
higher the improvement is, in physical domains however age does not have any
influence in psychological domains.
PCV133
Literature Review Of Pro Measures Assessing Anticoagulant
Therapy
Barrett A M 1, Harris N I 2, DeMuro C 2, Kachroo S 3, Phatak H 3
Health Solutions, Manchester, UK, 2RTI Health Solutions, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA,
3Bristol-Myers Squibb Company, Princeton, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1RTI
Objectives: To identify and summarize the key characteristics, strengths, and
weaknesses of available patient-reported outcome (PRO) measures assessing treatment satisfaction and health-related quality of life (HRQOL) related to anticoagulation therapy in patients with atrial fibrillation, including evaluating how well the
measures meet current regulatory guidance requirements in Europe and the United
States. Methods: Publications describing the development, validation, or use of
PRO instruments in patients using anticoagulant therapy were identified through
a comprehensive literature review. Several sources (PubMed, Patient-Reported
Outcome and Quality of Life Instruments Database [PROQOLID], and ClinicalTrials.
org) were reviewed to identify instruments. The development process and measurement properties (internal consistency and test-retest reliability, convergent and
divergent construct validity, known-groups validity, and responsiveness) of the identified instruments were compared. Results: Five measures assessing anticoagu-
A496
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
lation-related PROs were identified: 1) Sawicki questionnaire (assesses treatment
satisfaction and HRQOL); 2) Perception of Anticoagulant Treatment Questionnaire
(PACT-Q); 3) Duke Anticoagulation Satisfaction Scale (DASS); 4) Anti-Clot Treatment
Scale (ACTS) (based on the DASS conceptual model); and 5) Deep Venous Thrombosis
Quality of Life (DVTQOL) (assesses HRQOL outcomes related to a primary event of
DVT and includes items assessing anticoagulation burden). All of the measures
except the Sawicki questionnaire involved anticoagulated patients in the process
of item generation and refinement. The ACTS and the DASS exhibited the strongest
measurement properties. To a limited degree, the ACTS, DASS, and Sawicki questionnaire have demonstrated responsiveness in clinical trial settings. Conclusions:
Although some of the identified measures have shown responsiveness in clinical
trials, this review concluded that no existing measure appears likely to support an
FDA or EMA PRO label claim in anticoagulation-related treatment satisfaction or
HRQOL. However, concepts related to anticoagulation treatment satisfaction and
HRQOL are important to patients and should be included in clinical trials, particularly as the burdens and benefits of anticoagulants evolve over time.
PCV134
Health Utility Of Acute Coronary Syndrome Patients From An Asian
Population
Azmi S 1, Anchah L 2, Goh A 1, Fong A 2
Burhani Consulting, Petaling Jaya, Malaysia, 2Sarawak General Hospital Heart Centre,
Kuching, Malaysia
.
.
.
.
1Azmi
Objectives: To compare the health utility of Acute Coronary Syndrome (ACS)
patients from an Asian population at baseline admission and 12 months post-ACS.
Secondary objectives were to investigate the factors that affect health utility and
the impact of using local versus UK tariffs in the analysis. Methods: Primary
data was obtained from ACS patients who were admitted to a tertiary-care, general
hospital in Malaysia and agreed to participate in the study. The quality of life (QOL)
of ACS patients was elicited using validated language versions of the EQ-5D (three
severity level) patient reported outcome instrument. QOL data was collected at
baseline during initial admission for ACS and at 12-months post-admission. Patient
demographic and clinical data were extracted from medical records. Health utility
scores were calculated using EQ-5D utility tariffs from Malaysia and the UK population tariff. Results: A total of 112 subjects were recruited into the study of which
104 were used in the primary analysis. Mean age of patients in the analysis dataset
was 56.1 years, 88% were male and duration of admission was 6.3 days. Calculated
by Malaysian tariff weights, health utility was 0.75 during initial admission, increasing to 0.82 after 12 months (p= 0.012). Among the statistically significant factors
associated with lower baseline utility were diagnosis of NSTEMI/unstable angina
compared to STEMI (p=0.045), and female sex (p=0.038). Utilities calculated using the
Malaysian tariff was consistently higher than those calculated using the UK tariff.
ACS utility at baseline was 0.75 and 0.62 (p< 0.001) while utility after 12 months was
0.82 and 0.72 (p< 0.001) respectively. Conclusions: This study investigates several
factors that may impact the QOL outcomes of Malaysian ACS patients. It also found
significant differences in utility values calculated by Malaysian and UK tariffs, which
indicate that the use of local tariffs is more appropriate.
PCV135
Health-Related Quality Of Life Impact Of Triple Combinations
Of Olmesartan Medoxomil, Amlodipine Besylate And
Hydrochlorothiazide In Subjects With Hypertension
Haag U 1, Guest J F 2, Soro M 3
GmbH, Schriesheim, Germany, 2Catalyst Health Economics Consultants Ltd.,
Northwood, Middlesex, UK, 3Daiichi Sankyo Europe, Munich, Germany
.
.
.
.
1HaaPACS
Objectives: A secondary objective of a phase-III study spanning 54 weeks was to
measure changes in the health-related quality of life (HRQoL) of 2,690 patients ≥ 18
years of age with moderate-to-severe hypertension who ended up receiving one of
six doses of olmesartan/amlodipine/hydrochlorothiazide (OLM/AML/HCTZ) using the
MINICHAL and EQ5D instruments. Methods: Descriptive statistics were used to
measure blood pressure and HRQoL scores over the study period. Analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) was used to identify those factors (i.e. age, sex etc.) that could possibly have influenced HRQoL. Linear regression was used to assess the relationship
between changes in blood pressure and HRQoL scores. Results: At the study start
90.8% of patients had Grade 2 or 3 hypertension, but at the study end 91.9% had normal/high-normal BP. Patients’ baseline MINICHAL mood and somatic domains scores
were 5.5 and 2.6. Over the study period HRQoL improved as both MINICHAL scores
decreased by 31-33%. Patients’ baseline EQ5D index and VAS score was 0.9 and 73.4
respectively, increasing by 6% and 12% over the study period. Patients’ QALY gain over
the 54 weeks study period was estimated to be 0.029 QALYs. Linear regression was
unable to detect any correlation between the changes in blood pressure and HRQoL
scores. The ANCOVA model showed that changes in patients’ HRQoL was likely to
have been influenced by patients’ grade of hypertension at baseline, the amount of
concomitant medication (“pill burden”) and patients’ antihypertensive treatment in
the last 26 weeks of the study. Conclusions: OLM/AML/HCTZ reduced blood pressure and significantly increased blood pressure control whilst improving patients’
HRQoL. Reducing patients’ pill burden is likely to increase adherence to treatment
and improve blood pressure control. Hence, when prescribing antihypertensive agents
physicians should consider the impact that pill burden has on adherence to treatment, achieving blood pressure control and patients’ HRQoL.
PCV136
Treatment Patterns And Quality Of Life Of Patients With NonValvular Atrial Fibrillation: An Experience Of A Tertiary Health
Care Centers (Treq-Af Study)
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: This study aimed to determine anti-coagulant treatment patterns and
stroke- and bleeding-related risk factors and to evaluate quality of life (QoL) in nonvalvular atrial fibrillation (NVAF) patients. Methods: This multicenter (12-centers),
observational study included ≥ 18 year-old patients (n= 213) diagnosed with NVAF.
CHADS2, CHA2DS2-VASc, HAS-BLED scores and EQ-5D scale were used to assess risk
factors and QoL and clinical features were recorded at baseline, and 6th and 12th
months. Results: The rate of adverse events was 64.7%, major bleeding was 10.8%,
stroke was 5.9%, and hospitalization was 25.5% in one-year follow-up. The patients’
treatment patterns were grouped as warfarin, new oral anti-coagulant (NOAC) (dabigatran, rivaroxaban), and antiplatelet agents (AA) (acetylsalicylic acid, clopidogrel).
Patient numbers for the groups at baseline, and 6th and 12th months, respectively,
were 92, 74, 41 for warfarin, 2, 13, 14 for NOAC, and 39, 29, 26 for AA. The distribution
of patients in the warfarin, NOAC, and AA groups regarding CHADS2≥ 2 was 53.8%
(n= 49), 50% (n=1), and 63.2% (n=24), respectively; regarding CHA2DS2-VASc≥2 was
86.8% (n=79), 50% (n=1), and 89.5% (n=34), respectively; and regarding HAS-BLED≥3
(high bleeding risk) was 23.1% (n= 21), 0% (n=0), and 18.4% (n=7), respectively. EQ-5D
scale scores were 0.85±0.12 and 0.76±0.13 at baseline and 0.67±0.29 and 0.62±0.37 at
12th month for the warfarin and AA groups, respectively; the decrease was significant
in the warfarin group (p=0.002) but not in the AA group (p=0.249). The mortality rates
of the patients in the warfarin, NOAC, and AA groups in one-year follow-up were 7.6%,
0.0%, and 10.3%, respectively. Conclusions: Our study has demonstrated that a
significant number of patients who should be on oral anticoagulants are still treated
with AA and the negative effects of warfarin on QoL of NVAF patients as compared
to AA. More data is needed with head-to-head comparison of warfarin and NOAC.
PCV137
Quality Of Life In Patients With Permanent Cardiac Pacemaker In
The Slovak Republic
Gerlichova K 1, Simkova E 1, Mastiliakova D 1, Matisakova I 2, Bielik J 1
1Trencin University, Trencin, Slovak Republic, 2Trencin University of Alexander Dubcek, Trencin,
Slovak Republic
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: 2579 permanent cardiac pacemakers (PCPM) were implanted in
Slovakia in the year 2012, 532 reimplantations were utilised in 475 resp. 98 per
1000000 inhabitants. Up to now in the Slovak Republic there was not realised the
study oriented on OoL in the patients with this treatment. Methods: 100 patients
with PCMK were studied, women 58, men 42. The average age was 66.47, duration of
illness – 6.93 y. 57 patients were married, 31 divorced or a widower, widow, single 12.39 patients had sick sinus syndrome (SSS). 22 - AV blockade II, 23 - AV blockade III,
16 - brady form of atrial fibrillation. QoL was evaluated by standardised instrument
and so Quality of Life Index Cardiac Version – IV). Four domains were examined:
health and functional state, mental and spiritual state, family relations. Finally, the
total QoL was discovered, too. Kruskall Wallis Anova Test and Mann-Whitney Tests
were used to verify the statistical significance. Results: None of rhythm disorders and the duration of illness had impact on QoL. The smallest QoL occurred in
health and functional state, the highest QoL occurred in family relations. In the last
one (family relations) there was significant difference in comparison to the other
domains (p ≤ 0,029), and specifically in the group of married patients. The age had
negative significant correlation on QoL (p ≤ 0,027). Women had significant lower
QoL in the social and economical fields. Conclusions: PCPM has a certain impact
on QoL. The knowledge about the differences in the field of family state and in age
gives the incentive to take more attention to older, divorced, widower/widows and
single patients and try to realise relevant psychological interventions.
PCV138
The Evaluation Of The Health Related Quality Of Life Among Adults
With Hypertension
Paczkowska A , Nowakowska E , Koligat D , Bryl W , Hoffmann K
Poznan University of Medical Sciences, Poznan, Poland
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The aim of the study was a subjective evaluation of the quality of life
among adults with diagnosed and treated hypertension. The paper also identifies
social and clinical factors significantly influencing the quality of life of respondents.
Methods: 112 people took part in the study (38 women and 78 men), aged between 19
and 65 years old – in all cases hypertension was diagnosed and treated in a particular
health care centre. As a main study tool a questionnaire WHOQOL-BREF in a Polish
version was applied. In addition, in order to evaluate the social and clinical factors that
influence the quality of life participants were asked to fill anonymous questionnaire
prepared specially for this study. Results: The results of the conducted studies indicated that people suffering from hypertension experience remarkably lower quality
of life comparing to healthy people. Considerable discrepancies in terms of the quality of life were visible in physical and psychological domains of the WHOQOL-BREF
questionnaire. It has been assumed that the quality of life of patients with hypertension is determined by both social (age, gender, education, economic status), and
clinical (level of blood pressure, weight, the type of hypertensive therapy, the presence
of coexisting diseases). Conclusions: Chronic diseases, including hypertension,
distinctively affect the quality of life of patients. The quality of life of patients with
hypertension is determined by numerous social and clinical factors. Thus, there is a
need to consider the problem of hypertension and its treatment among adult people
multidisciplinary – in order to improve their lives.
PCV139
Treatment Satisfaction In Patients With Venous Thromboembolism
As Measured With Pact-Q2: Prefer In Vte Registry
Ozin B 1, Aytemir K 2, Arslan O 3, Ozcan T 4, Kanadasi M 5, Demir M 5, Gokce M 6, Sucu M M 7,
Ozdemir M 8, Yigit Z 9, Yavuzkir M F 10, Oto A 2
1Baskent University, Ankara, Turkey, 2Hacettepe University, Ankara, Turkey, 3Dokuz Eylul
University, Izmir, Turkey, 4Mersin University, Mersin, Turkey, 5Cukurova University, Adana, Turkey,
.
6Karadeniz Technical University, Trabzon, Turkey, 7Gaziantep University, Gaziantep, Turkey, 8Gazi
University, Ankara, Turkey, 9Istanbul University, Istanbul, Turkey, 10Elazig University, Elazig,
Turkey
.
Willich S N 1, Bauersachs R 2, Gitt A K 3, Mismetti P 4, Monreal M 5, Wolf W P 6, Agnelli G 7,
Cohen A T 8
1Charité - Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Berlin, Germany, 2Max-Ratschow-Klinik für Angiologie,
Gefäßzentrum Klinikum Darmstadt GmbH, Darmstadt, Germany, 3Herzzentrum Ludwigshafen,
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A497
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Ludwigshafen, Germany, 4Centre Hospitalier Universitaire Saint-Etienne, Hopital Nord, Saint
Etienne, France, 5Hospital Universitari Germans Trias I Pujol, Barcelona, Spain, 6Daiichi Sankyo
Europe GmbH, Munich, Germany, 7University of Perugia, Santa Maria della Misericordia Hospital,
Perugia, Italy, 8King’s College, London, UK
Objectives: Following an acute deep vein thrombosis (DVT) or pulmonary
embolism (PE) event, physicians can choose among heparin, vitamin K antagonists (VKA), and Non-VKA oral anticoagulants (NOAC) for therapy. We assessed
patients’ satisfaction with their ongoing anticoagulation treatment. Methods:
PREFER in VTE (PREvention oF thromboembolic events – European Registry in
Venous Thromboembolism) is an ongoing non-interventional study in France,
Germany, Austria, Switzerland, Italy, Spain and UK. The Perception of Anti-Coagulant
Treatment Questionnaire (PACT-Q2) is a valid and reliable instrument that allows
the assessment of patients’ satisfaction regarding anticoagulant treatment, as well
as their opinion about convenience of use. Results: At baseline (BL), a total of
2311 patients with acute VTE (1366 DVT, 945 PE) met the eligibility criterion of current anticoagulation and completed the PACT-Q2 questionnaire. 665 patients were
eligible for an interim analysis at 6 months: 7.8% have received heparin only, 33.2%
initial heparin/VKA and 9.0% uninterrupted NOAC. In the “convenience” dimension, the score (0-100 range) at BL/6 months was 78.9 ±17.62/ 76.2 ±18.20 points for
heparin only, 81.0 ±16.36/ 80.5 ±16.34 for heparin/VKA, and 88.9 ±12.14/ 93.3 ±7.30 for
NOACs (all patients: 81.5 ±16.78/ 81.6 ±17.26). Compared to BL, the score improved
the most in the NOAC group. In the “anticoagulant treatment satisfaction” dimension, the score at BL/ 6- month was 64.2 ±14.02/64.3 ±16.68 points for heparin only,
65.8 ±14.92/68.7 ±14.46 for heparin/VKA and 68.2 ±16.65/72.9 ±16.70 for NOACs (all
patients 65.4 ±15.26/68.5 ±15.76). Conclusions: Overall, patients on current anticoagulation reached relatively high values on the convenience scale, but moderate
values on the satisfaction scale. Patients on NOACs rated their convenience and
treatment satisfaction substantially higher than patients on heparin/VKA.
PCV140
Treatment Satisfaction In Patients With Atrial Fibrillation On New
Oral Anticoagulants As Assessed With Pact-Q2 At Baseline And 12Month Follow-Up: Prefer In Af Registry
Brüggenjürgen B 1, Schliephacke T 2, Darius H 3, De Caterina R 4, Le Heuzey J Y 5, Reimitz P E 2,
Schilling R J 6, Schwertfeger M 2, Zamorano J L 7, Kirchhof P 8
University Berlin (SHB), Berlin, Germany, 2Daiichi Sankyo Europe GmbH, Munich,
Germany, 3Vivantes Hospital Neukölln, Berlin, Germany, 4G. d’Annunzio University, Chieti, Italy,
5Hôpital Européen Georges Pompidou, Université René Descartes, Paris, France, 6Barts and St
Thomas Hospital, London, UK, 7University Hospital Ramón y Cajal, Madrid, Spain, 8University of
Birmingham Centre for Cardiovascular Sciences and SWBH NHS Trust, Birmingham, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Steinbeis
Objectives: We aimed to understand treatment satisfaction over time under everyday practice conditions after introduction of NOACs (Non vitamin K antagonist
oral anticoagulants) in the The PREvention oF thromboembolic events – European
Registry in Atrial Fibrillation (PREFER in AF). Methods: PREFER in AF documents
clinical characteristics, management, quality of life and other outcome parameters
of AF patients. A total of 6412 consecutive patients with ECG-confirmed AF in the
previous 12 months were followed up prospectively. The ‘Perception of Anticoagulant
Treatment Questionnaire’ is a valid and reliable instrument to assess patients’
expectations (PACT-Q1) and satisfaction regarding anticoagulant treatment, as
well as patients’ opinion about treatment convenience of use (PACT-Q2). Results:
A total of 2985 patients were willing to fill out the PACT-Q2 questionnaire both at
baseline and FU. 1632 of these were on vitamin K antagonists (VKAs), 374 on NOACs,
203 on antiplatelets (AP), 142 on VKA+AP combinations and 634 on neither treatment. In the “convenience” dimension, the overall score (0-100 range) at FU was
84.3 ±16.5. The scores ranged from 81.9 in the no NOAC/VKA/AP group (± 18.43),
84.0 AP (± 16.7), 84.4 NOAC (± 15.9), 85.0 VKA (± 15.9) to 86.8 in the VKA +AP group
(± 14.13). In the “anticoagulant treatment satisfaction” dimension of the PACT-Q2,
the overall score was 65.1 ±15.7. The scores ranged from 64.5 in no NOAC/VKA/AP
(± 14.8), 63.2 in AP group (± 17), 66.0 in NOAC (± 15.05), 64.9 in VKA (± 15.9), to 69.5 in
VKA +AP group (± 15.8). Conclusions: Overall, patients on current anticoagulation
achieve relatively high values on the convenience scale, but moderate values on the
satisfaction scale. While differences in group size and patient characteristics need to
be taken into account, patients on NOACs compared to patients on VKAs rate their
convenience and treatment comparable to other treatment schemes.
Cardiovascular Disorders – Health Care Use & Policy Studies
PCV141
Primary Pacemaker Insertion: Gender Differences In Prior Er
Utilization
Roy D 1, Blanchette C M 2
1University of North Carolina, Charlotte, Charlotte, NC, USA, 2University of North Carolina at
Charlotte, Charlotte, NC, USA
.
.
.
Objectives: Men’s and Women’s health care experiences differ as they age. These
differences lead to disparate health and treatment outcomes between the genders,
especially in the area of cardiac health, which has significant disease burden in
the US. Women experience symptoms that ‘deviate’ from the ones found in a clinician’s guidebook. The emergency room (ER) also serves as a medical space for initial
diagnosis of heart conditions. Thus, looking at the gender based use of ER prior to
a cardiac event may help us understand the disparities from a systems perspective. Cardiac pacemakers are used to treat severe and/or symptomatic bradycardia,
heart block or a combination of both. This study explored gender differences in
characteristics and ER diagnoses associated with pacemaker implants in an inpatient setting. Methods: The study used data from the inpatient and emergency
room hospital discharge data from the Florida HealthCare Utilization Project for
years 2009 and 2010. Patients with a primary insertion of initial pacemaker and
with a diagnosis of bradycardia or heart block or both were included. A unique
patient identifier helped map patients across the inpatient and emergency set-
tings. Descriptive statistics were used to look at items of interest. Results: There
were 1403 discharges meeting the inclusion criterion. These were linked to 1402 ER
discharges previous to the surgery. There were no significant differences between
the genders in terms of characteristics like race, primary payer, age, etc. However,
more men had ER visits than women (52.43% vs 47.57%). The top diagnosis in the
ER consisted of conduction disorders (21.03%). Syncope occurred in 10.05% of discharges. Atrial fibrillation was the only ER diagnosis which women experienced
more than men. Conclusions: The findings of the study were inconclusive in
showing significant differences between the genders in terms of characteristics
and ER diagnosis among recipients of primary pacemaker.
PCV142
Ldl-C Goal Attainment In Patients With Hyperlipidemia - Estimates
From Population-Based Register Data In Sweden
Mesterton J 1, Hallberg S 1, Gandra S R 2, Banefelt J 1, Fox K M 3, Johansson G 4, Levin L Å 5,
Sobocki P 6
1Quantify Research, Stockholm, Sweden, 2Amgen, Inc., Thousand Oaks, CA, USA, 3Strategic
Healthcare Solutions, LLC, Monkton, MD, USA, 4Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden, 5Linköping
University, Linköping, Sweden, 6IMS Health, Stockholm, Sweden
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate low-density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-C) goal attainment
in patients with hyperlipidemia or prior cardiovascular (CV) events. Methods:
Retrospective population-based cohort study conducted using electronic medical
records linked to national registers. Patients were included in the study based on a
prescription of lipid-lowering treatment between January 1, 2006 and December 31,
2006 or history of CV events (prior to 2006) and followed until December 31, 2012 for
estimation of LDL-C goal attainment. Patients were stratified into cohorts based on
CV risk level. Propensity score matching was applied to compare patients with new
events (myocardial infarction, unstable angina, revascularization, ischemic stroke,
transient ischemic attack or heart failure) to patients without new events. Results:
Mean LDL-C at the time of the new CV event (index date) was 100.4 mg/dL for
patients with CV event history who had a new event (n= 1,101). The mean LDL-C
for patients without new events in the same cohort (n= 1,304) was 97.4 mg/dL. The
proportion of patients with CV event history and LDL-C < 70 mg/dL was 20.5% and
21.5% for patients with and without new events, respectively. The percentage who
attained the goal of 100 mg/dL was 54.1% and 58.1%, respectively. Mean LDL-C for
CV risk equivalent (RE) patients with new events (n= 803) was 100.3 mg/dL while
patients in the same cohort without new events (n=975) had a mean level of 97.4 mg/
dL. 22.0% of CV RE patients with new events had a LDL-C < 70 mg/dL and 53.8% had
a level < 100 mg/dL. The corresponding data for CV RE patients without new events
were 19.1% and 57.7%, respectively. Conclusions: The proportion of patients who
met LDL-C goals was low, suggesting that current treatment is suboptimal. The proportion of patients who attained the goals was similar in patients with and without
new events and across CV risk levels.
PCV143
The Clinical Impact Of Rivaroxaban To Chinese At Atrial Fibrillation
Patients Results From A Simple Communication Tool
Yang L1, Wu JJ2, Zhu G2, Evers T3
University, Beijing, China, 2Bayer Healthcare Company Ltd., Beijing, China, 3Bayer
Pharma AG, Wuppertal, Germany
1Peking
Objectives: To estimate the clinical impact over three years of switching atrial
fibrillation (AF) patients receiving no treatment or aspirin, or Vitamin K antagonist (VKA), to rivaroxaban in China. Methods: A prevalence-based, deterministic
budget impact model was developed. The number of AF patients was calculated
based on data from literatures. The baseline risk of events and the efficacy and
safety data for aspirin and VKA were from meta-analysis. While the efficacy and
safety data for rivaroxaban were from ROCKET-AF trial. The current treatment pattern was from a large registry study for Chinese AF patients. 9%, 61% and 30% of AF
patients received no treatment, aspirin and VKA, respectively. We just assumed that
5% of the patients who received aspirin currently switch to rivaroxaban per year.
Then the model estimates the number of ischemic stroke (IS), systemic embolisms
(SE), myocardial infarction (MI), intracranial bleeds (ICH) and major extracranial
bleeds (ECH) per year. Results: The number of NVAF patients is 4.5 million. For
those patients, there might be 127,469 major IS events, 34,001 SE events, 9,933 MI
events, 28,745 ICH events and 56,193 major ECH events under current treatment
per year. With 5% patients switching to rivaroxaban from aspirin in the first year,
the IS events reduced 4%, SE events reduced 6% and MI events reduced 2% with
increased 3% ICH and 1% ECH. To the third year, the IS events continue to reduce
11%, SE events reduced 17% and MI events reduced 6% with increased 10% ICH and
4% ECH compared with the current situation. Conclusions: Rivaroxaban may
decrease the clinical burden of AF in China by reducing the incidence of stroke and
fatal CV events. Decision-makers can find the exact value of rivaroxaban easily by
the simple tool in different situations.
PCV144
The Clinical Impact Of Rivaroxaban To Chinese At Deep Vein
Thrombosis Patients Results From A Simple Communication Tool
Yang L 1, Wu J J 2, Zhu G 2, Evers T 3
University, Beijing, China, 2Bayer Healthcare Company Ltd., Beijing, China, 3Bayer
Pharma AG, Wuppertal, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
1Peking
Objectives: To estimate the clinical impact over three years of switching deep
vein thrombosis (DVT) patients receiving low molecular weight heparin (LMWH)
and vitamin K antagonist (VKA) to rivaroxaban. Methods: A prevalence-based,
deterministic budget impact model was developed. The incidence of DVT patient
was from literatures. We assumed that 12%, 65% and 23% received treatment for
3months, 6months and 12months, separately. The efficacy and safety data for
LMWH+VKA were from meta-analysis. While the efficacy and safety data for rivaroxaban were from EINSTEIN-DVT trial. We just assumed that 20% of the patients
who received LMWH + VKA currently switch to rivaroxaban in the first year and
A498
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
following with 15% of the rest patients switching to rivaroxaban per year. Then the
model estimates the number of DVT, pulmonary embolism (PE), intracranial bleeds
(ICH) and major extracranial bleeds (ECH) per year. Results: The new DVT patients
are 287,813 per year. For those patients, with 20% patients switching to rivaroxaban from LMWH+VKA in the first year, the recurrent venous thrombus embolism
(VTE) events, including DVT and PE, reduced 4.6%, major bleeding events including
ECH and ICH reduced 7% with 1% minor bleeding increasing. To the third year, the
recurrent VTE events reduced 11.4%, major bleeding events reduced 17% with 2%
minor bleeding increasing compared with the current situation. Conclusions:
Rivaroxaban may decrease the clinical burden of DVT in China by reducing the
incidence of recurrent VTE and fatal bleeding events. Decision-makers can find the
exact value of rivaroxaban easily by the simple tool in different situations.
PCV145
Cost-Effectiveness Of Disease Management Programs For
Cardiovascular Risk And Copd In The Netherlands
Tsiachristas A , Burgers L T , Rutten-van Mölken M P M H
Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Disease management programs (DMPs) for cardiovascular risk (CVR)
and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) are increasingly implemented
in the Netherlands to improve quality of care and patient’s lifestyle. The aim of
the study was to provide evidence about the (cost-) effectiveness of Dutch DMPs
as implemented in daily practice. Methods: We compared the 2-year costs
and changes in physical activity, smoking behaviour, and utilities between the
most and the least comprehensive DMP in four disease categories: primary CVRprevention, secondary CVR-prevention, both types of CVR-prevention, and COPD
(total n: 1034). Propensity score matching increased comparability between DMPs.
A cost-utility analysis was performed from the health care and societal perspective.
Sensitivity analysis was performed to estimate the impact of DMP development and
implementation costs on the cost-effectiveness. Results: Patients in the most
comprehensive DMPs increased physical activity and had higher smoking cessation
probabilities after 2 years in most disease categories. From a health care perspective, the incremental costs were positive in primary CVR-prevention (96% certainty),
negative in secondary and both types of CVR prevention (93% and 98% certainty) and
indifferent in COPD. The incremental QALYs were positive in all categories (certainty
range: 64%-80%). The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio’s ranged from € -114,662
to € 8,849. The results from the societal perspective and the sensitivity analysis were
in the same line. Conclusions: The most comprehensive DMPs for CVR and COPD
were cost-effective compared to the least comprehensive DMPs. The challenge for
Dutch stakeholders is to find the optimal mixture of interventions.
PCV146
Comparing Quality Effects Of Patient Care In Integrated And
Regular Care For Patients With Hypertension
Waehlert L 1, Rex J 2, Engelhard J 2, Altmann V 2, Kostev K 2
1Fresenius University of applied sciences, Idstein, Germany, 2IMS Health, Frankfurt am Main,
Germany
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: This study examines the extent to which Integrated Care Programs
lead to an improvement in the quality of patient care. The aim of the study is
to carry out a quantitative analysis of differences in quality between patients
participating in Disease Management Programs (DMPs) and patients receiving
regular care, regardless of health insurance status, program, or region. Methods:
The study used data from the representative IMS Disease Analyzer database. It
included patients with a confirmed diagnosis of hypertension who started antihypertensive therapy in the period between January 2010 and December 2012.
The primary dependent variable of the study was the change in blood pressure
after at least six months of antihypertensive treatment. To assess this variable, we
determined the proportion of patients with a blood pressure of below 140/90 in the
period between day 183 and day 365 after initiation of treatment (index date). In
order to eliminate confounding factors, we performed one-to-one matching based
on a propensity score. Results: 1,317 patients participating in the integrated
care program (ICP) and 1,317 patients not participating in such a program were
available for further analyses following the propensity score matching. Patients
in both groups were very similar with respect to demographic variables and
antihypertensive therapy. The proportion of patients with blood pressure values
< 140/90 after one year of treatment was 33.6% in the group of ICP participants
and 22.7% in the group of non-ICP patients (p< 0.0001). The chance of reaching
the treatment goal was significantly higher in the group of patients participating
in an integrated health program (OR: 1.73; 95% CI: 1.45-2.05). Conclusions: It
is evident that DMP participants have a significantly better chance of achieving
the therapy goal. Thus, it can be established that integrated health care programs
have a positive effect on quality.
PCV147
Segmentation Is A Key Strategic Tool For Effective Prioritisation
And Targeting Of Payers In Highly Competitive Markets; A Client’s
Perspective
Areteou T
Double Helix Development, London, UK
.
Objectives: The research aimed to develop an attitudinal based, payer segmentation approach to explore payers’ attitudes and behaviours towards the managed entry of novel agents in the anticoagulation area in the health care systems
of countries within the EU. The segmentation exercise explored payers’ drivers,
motivations, barriers and limitations when assessing, endorsing or restricting new
agents. Methods: Qualitative in-depth telephone interviews were conducted
to explore payers’ views, along with perceived challenges relating to the entry of
novel class of anticoagulation agents. Followed by a quantitative data collection
and advanced statistical analysis methodology was employed with regional and
local payers in each of the researched markets to define the segmentation accord-
ing to attitudes and beliefs relevant to the therapy area. Results: Quantitative
segmentation identified key distinct segments of payers displaying unique attitudes and beliefs towards entry of the novel class of anticoagulation agents. The
segmentation approach identified key differentiating factors between segments,
allowing full profiling of each group. Payers’ underlying values were explored
with a view to gain insight to what is important to them as individuals as well as
decision makers, what motivates them and what restricts them. Conclusions:
Findings from this research were utilized to prioritise targeting of payer segments.
In addition, communication and messaging strategies were optimised for these
payer groups. Subsequently a post-project feedback workshop with the pharmaceutical client was conducted. The poster will discuss how the research was used
by the pharmaceutical client and the benefits of this strategic tool to the brand
team.
PCV148
Impact Laws And Decrees On Activities: The Ilda Study
Citarella A 1, De Liguoro F P 2, Di Martino P 3, Iarrobino A 2, Nava E 4, Ragone P 5, Vercellone
A 4, Cammarota S 1
1LinkHealth s. r. l., Naples, Italy, 2MediCoop VESEVO - GPs Association, Torre del Greco, Italy,
3IPPOCRATE - GPs Assosiation, Castellammare di Stabia, Italy, 4Department of Pharmacy,
Local health Napoli3 Sud, Castellammare di Stabia, Italy, 5IPPOCRATE - GPs Association,
Castellammare di Stabia, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess whether the prescribing pattern of statins changed after
reimbursement criteria revision and regional policies in a general practice in
southern Italy. Methods: Analysis has been performed on a database of 123
medical practitioners that have managed an average of 190.000 inhabitants in
the Campania Region (south of Italy). Prevalence of use and incidence of new
treatments were calculated from Jan 2012 to Jun 2013. Statin users were stratified
into three groups (Moderate Cardiovascular Risk, MR; High Cardiovascular Risk,
HR; Very High Cardiovascular Risk, VHR) according to new criteria for reimbursement for lipid lowering agents revised by the Italian Drug Agency (AIFA) (Nota 13).
Results: After the reimbursement criteria revision (November 2012), the prevalence of statin use slightly decreased reaching 6.6% in the second quarter of
2013 (-14% compared to second quarter of 2012). Stratified by level of CV risk, the
prevalence of statin use is reduced by 24.9% into MR, 13.1% into HR and 5.9% into
VHR, while incidence of new users of 22.4%, 34 5% and 45.8% respectively. In the
second quarter of 2013, atorvastatin (+45.3%) was prescribed in 57,5% of patients
in MR group (+45.3%), rosuvastatin 5.9% with (-60.1%) and 1.6% with simvastatin + ezetimide (-57.5%); in HR group, 40.7% (+20.8) atorvastatin, 5.3% (-57.0%)
rosuvastatin and 2.1% (- 42.3%) simvastatin + ezetimide; in VHR, 56.3% (+15.8)
atorvastatin, 12.5% (-37.5%) rosuvastatin and 2.1% (-27.1%) simvastatin + ezetimide. Conclusions: The revision of reimbursement criteria and the regional policies led to significant changes in general practice in southern Italy resulting in a
reduction in the statin use, especially in patients who could potentially benefit
from it most. The results of the study provide useful information for the general
practitioner about areas for improvement prescriptive.
PCV149
Assessment Of The Impact Of Legislation On The Utilization Of
Statins In Slovakia
Minariková D 1, Malovecká I 1, Foltan V 2, Lehocká L 1
University, Bratislava, Slovak Republic, 2Faculty of Pharmacy, Comenius University,
Bratislava, Slovak Republic
.
.
.
.
1Comenius
Objectives: Frequent legislative changes that have brought the Slovak health care
reform over the past decade, reflected also on drug policy and especially on the
prices of medicines and total consumption of medicines. Generic substitution was
introduced to save both health insurance and patient’s finances. Methods: Data
on prices and consumption of lipid-lowering agent medicines were collected from
Slovak Ministry of Health and Health insurance. Data processing, we used a uniform
methodology recommended by the WHO - ATC / DDD classification and basic statistical methods of observing. In case of national data, we reported consumption in units
of DDD per 1,000 inhabitants for one day (DID). Results: A class of lipid-lowering
agent medicines (C10A) poses in recent years on Slovak market expanding group. Its
number significantly increased in direct proportion with the introduction of generic
drugs, mainly after 2004, when generic substitution was enacted and later after
2011, when mandatory generic prescribing entry into the force. The proportion of
total medicines and generic drugs in the group C10A were x2008total-medicines/%genericdrugs= 55/74,6 types and x2014total-medicines/%generic-drugs= 203/94 types. The number of
generic drugs with atorvastatin ranged x2008-2014= 4-18, rosuvastatin x2008-2014= 3-11,
simvastatin x2008-2014= 7-7, fluvastatin x2008-2014= 1-1, lovastatin x2008-2014= 1-5. The
consumption of medicines with atorvastatin x2008-2014-packages= +Δ 47,7%, x2008-2014value= +Δ 20,1% € , rosuvastatin x2008-2014-packages= +Δ 18,8%, x2008-2014-value= -Δ 77,4 % € ,
simvastatin x2008-2014-packages= -Δ 48,6%, x2008-2014-value= -Δ 79,6 % € , fluvastatin x20082014-packages= -Δ 50,5%, x2008-2014-value= -Δ 90,4 % € , lovastatin x2008-2014-packages= -Δ 70,1%,
x2008-2014-value= -Δ 81,8 % € . In the years 2008-2013 consumption of C10A in Slovakia
increased by 77,5 per DDD/1000 inh. /day (DID). OECD statistics from 2011 indicate
consumption of lipid-lowering agents amounting to 130 DID, while at the end of
2013 according to our data analysis increased to 142.8 DID. Conclusions: Overall
changes in legislation of drug policy brought rising utilization of lipid-lowering agent
medicines and in 2011 Slovakia together with Great Britain was on the second place
with 130 DID consumption of lipid-lowering agents.
PCV150
The Impact Of Pharmaceutical Policies On Pharmaceutical Sales
Patterns In Sweden And Japan
Imai S 1, Andersson Sundell K 2, Fushimi K 3
Hospital Organization, Tokyo, Japan, 2Sahlgrenska Academy, University of Gothenburg,
Gothenburg, Japan, 3Tokyo Medical and Dental University Graduate School of Medicine,
bunkyo-ku, Tokyo, Japan
.
1National
.
.
A499
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: Pharmaceutical expenditure accounted for between 11% to 13% of total
health expenditure in European countries including Sweden in 2010 whereas this
was 20% in Japan for the same year. We expect that big changes in sales pattern will
happen as a result of patent expiry. Other changes have been seen when prescribers get negative/positive information on drugs. In this article we study the impact
of patent expiry and negative information relating to pharmaceutical policies on
pharmaceutical sales patterns of selected drugs in Sweden and Japan. Methods:
we selected angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors (ACEs) and Angiotensin
Ⅱantagonists (ARBs), since widely used in Sweden and Japan. Seasonal autoregressive integrated moving average (ARIMA) modeling with intervention analysis was
used to estimate the change of sales volume. Results: Losartan had a positive
change (0.77650, p= 0.0068) in October 2010, Candesartan had a negative change
(-0.50760, p= 0.0058) in July 2010. There were no significant differences in the sales
volume of Losartan, Telmisartan, except for Candesartan in Japan (0.04868, p=0.7995,
-0.38547, p= 0.0880, and -1.21215, p= 0.001, respectively). In this study, we used a
publication informed that Candesartan and Telmisartan had not reduced patients’
mortality by a journal July in 2009 as negative information. Conclusions: We
found that the sales pattern of selected drugs were changed by negative information
and not by the expiry of their patents in Sweden. Whereas in Japan the negative
situation for implementing generic substitution like the therapeutic substitution
of Trandolapril and the possibility of switching from Candesartan to a combination
drug was seen. Further assessment will be needed since factors associated with the
changing use of drugs will be infinite.
PCV151
The Impact of Modifications of the Formula for Generic Drug
Prescription Rate on the Switch To New Brand-Name Drugs With
Similar Therapeutic Uses
Shimizu S 1, Imai S 2, Ishikawa K B 3, Ikeda S 4, Fushimi K 5
1Institute for Health Economics and Policy, minato-ku, Japan, 2National Hospital Organization,
Tokyo, Japan, 3National Cancer Center, Tokyo, Japan, 4International University of Health and
Welfare, Ohtawara -City, Japan, 5Tokyo Medical and Dental University Graduate School of
Medicine, bunkyo-ku, Tokyo, Japan
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: From April 2013, the method of calculating the prescription rate
of generic drugs in Japan was changed and protected brand name drugs were
excluded from the denominator. In the case of Japan, which does not have a
reference pricing system, it is thought that this will lead to a change in prescriptions toward protected brand name drugs rather than drug substitution to generic
drugs. The objective of this study is to clarify the trends in relation to the prescription of generic drugs, through the use of administrative data on a nationwide
level. Methods: We used survey data from dispensing pharmacies from April
2012 to March 2014. As a comparison, we used the prescription data of 1139 acute
care hospitals in which incentive measures for drug substitution to generic drugs
had not taken place during the same period. The medical products in question
were drugs for diabetes and hypotensive drugs. For data analysis used SQL Server
2008 R2 and R. Results: As the dispensing pharmacy receives additional compensation based on the rate of generic drugs dispensed by that pharmacy in the most
recent 3 months, the dispensing rate of generic drugs will have a direct impact
on their business. The change in the method of calculating generic drugs has a
major impact on the dispensing pharmacies, and in this study we have shown
the possibility of dispensing pharmacies shifting more to protected brand name
drugs. The dispensing rate of generic drugs by acute care medical facilities has
always been low, and thus the impact of the change in calculation of the dispensing ratio is correspondingly low. Conclusions: The results of this study show
that when encouraging drug substitution to generic drugs as a policy to reduce
drug expenditure, it is necessary to consider measures in relation to the shift to
protected brand name drugs.
PCV152
Analysis of Cardiac Implants Recalls in the Last Decade: An
International Comparison
Zhang S X , Kriza C , Schaller S U , Kolominsky-Rabas P L
Centre for Health Technology Assessment (HTA) and Public Health (IZPH), Friedrich-AlexanderUniversity Erlangen-Nürnberg, Erlangen, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The objectives of this research are to provide an overview of the recalls
of cardiac implant medical devices in the last decade according to the different
categories of cardiac implant medical devices and analyze the recall reasons. On the
basis of this analysis, this research will provide recommendations on how to build
a high quality implant registry. Methods: A systematic search was performed
focusing on regulatory bodies’ homepages from a range of middle and high-income
countries with sufficient information on cardiac implant recalls and the related
reasons. Data was extracted for the years 2004-2014 with the following criteria
applied: cardiac implant medical device recalls and reasons for recall, i.e. harm
or risk to patients excluding labeling or legal problems. Results: 11 countries
have been included in the study: United States, Canada, Australia, New Zealand,
PR China, China Hong Kong, UK, Germany, Ireland, Switzerland and Saudi Arabia.
104 recall reports have been analyzed in total. The categories of cardiac implants
include the following: Implantable Cardioverter Defibrillator (ICD) 40.4%; pacemaker
14.4%; stent 14.4%; as well as Cardiac Resynchronization Therapy (CRT) 13.5%;
leads 9.6% and replacement materials 7.7%. Referring to the recall reasons, 32.7%
of the reports related to problems with the device battery; 30.7% of devices were
recalled due to incorrect therapy delivery; 15.4% devices had software problems;
15.4% devices had connection problems and 5.8% of devices did not deliver correct
output data. Conclusions: Due to the high-risk nature of cardiac implants medical devices and their high complication rates associated with considerable associated mortality, the traceability and transparency of safety hazards information are
crucial. By analyzing the recall information including recall reasons and cardiac
implants categories, important information is gained that can inform a high quality cardiac implant registry for monitoring the safety of cardiac implant patients.
PCV153
Dabigatran Users With Non-Valvular Atrial Fibrillation in the Us: A
Characterization of Dabigatran Initiators and Switchers
Shash D 1, Schnee J 2, Schneider G 3, Schoof N 1, Zint K 1, Clemens A 4, Bartels D B 1
Ingelheim GmbH, Ingelheim, Germany, 2Boehringer Ingelheim Pharmaceuticals, Inc,
Ridgefield, CT, USA, 3Evidera, Lexington, MA, USA, 4University Medical Center Mainz, Mainz,
Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Boehringer
Objectives: In routine clinical practice the selection of a particular anticoagulant
for treatment of a specific patient may be based on a variety of different factors. The
aim of this study was to explore if there were differences in the characteristics of
patients with non-valvular atrial fibrillation (NVAF) who started on dabigatran etexilate (DE) and who in the prior year had no oral anticoagulant treatment (initiators)
versus those who had previously been treated with warfarin (switchers). Methods:
Medco claims data were used to characterize 7,055 NVAF patients from the US with
a DE prescription between Feb 2011 and Apr 2012. The first prescription in this
period defined the index date. The treatment-groups were stratified by initiators
and switchers. Characteristics, comedications, and comorbidities in the 12-monthperiod prior to index date were assessed. All illustrated differences were statistically
significant (p < 0.05) (1). Results: Switchers (N = 2,585) had a mean age of 74.0
(±9.6) years, whereas initiators (N= 1,903) were younger (mean 70.0 (±9.6) years).
A higher proportion of switchers used comedications compared to initiators, e.g.
beta blockers (66% vs. 59%), and gastrointestinal drugs (34% vs. 28%). Switchers
were more likely to have congestive heart failure, hypertension, cerebrovascular
disease, renal disease and bleeding related hospitalizations when compared to the
initiators, and also had a higher mean CHA2DS2-VASc score (4.0 (±1.8) compared to
initiators (3.4 (±1.9)). Conclusions: This study shows differences between patients
who are initiating DE as first anticoagulant treatment and those who are switched
from warfarin to DE revealing that switchers might represent a distinct patient
population. Identifying, stratifying or accounting for such differences are necessary
in comparisons using real world data. (1) Schoof N et al., Characteristics of patients
with non-valvular atrial fibrillation using dabigatran or warfarin in the US. Curr
Med Res Opin. 2013 Dec 27.
PCV154
Impact of Drug Policy Regulations on the Consumption of
Antihypertensive Drugs in Slovakia
Psenkova M 1, Foltan V 2, Mackovicova S 1, Marcisova M 1, Minarikova D 3, Tomek D 4
Ltd, Bratislava, Slovak Republic, 2Faculty of Pharmacy, Comenius University,
Bratislava, Slovak Republic, 3Comenius University, Bratislava, Slovak Republic, 4Slovak Medical
University, Bratislava, Slovak Republic
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Pharm-In
Objectives: In 2011, various legislative measures were adopted in Slovakia regarding
drug policy. The aim of the submitted work is to evaluate links between the introduction of regulations and the consumption of antihypertensive drugs (AH), expenditures and patient co-payments. Methods: We evaluated data on drugs consumption
based on IMS Data. Patient co-payments data were taken from the National Health
Information database. When evaluating the average amount of co-payments, we
applied a weighted average, which takes into account the level of co-payment and
consumption. Results: The consumption of AH (in DOT) increased continually in
2006-2013 (+36%) and the turnover of AH dropped by 4% as a consequence of introducing new regulations. The impact of new regulations was expressed foremost in the
consumption of RAS inhibitors, where the decrease in turnover after introduction of
clusters in 2012 was 14%. In the evaluated period, the final price of AH was reduced
by 35% (from € 8.86 to € 5.78) and the reimbursement was reduced by 52% (from € 7.87
to € 3.76). At the same time, there was an increase in average co-payments by 105%
(from € 0.99 to € 2.03). In the evaluated period, the patient co-payment for a fixed
AH almost quadrupled (from € 1.05 to € 4.05). The patient paid an average of € 0.93
more for one pack of fixed AH than for a free combination. After the introduction of
regulations, the consumption of fixed combinations grew at a slower pace than in
the case of monocomponents. Conclusions: The legislative changes in drug policy
had a significant impact on the consumption of antihypertensive drugs and on the
expense of hypertension treatment. It is necessary to monitor long-term and analyse
the impacts of regulations on the prescription of AH and to evaluate factors that can
influence the success of hypertension treatment.
PCV155
Initiation of Oral Anticoagulant Drugs: Identification of Drivers
of Prescribing of New Agents Versus Warfarin
Spillane S 1, Bennett K 2, Barry M 1
1HSE Medicines Management Programme, Dublin, Ireland, 2Trinity College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland
.
.
.
Objectives: Oral anticoagulants (OACs), used for stroke prevention in atrial fibrillation, include warfarin and the newer drugs (NOACs) dabigatran, rivaroxaban and
apixaban. High direct drug costs of the NOACs to the health care payer prompt
monitoring of real-world NOAC uptake patterns. This study aimed to identify factors
associated with anticoagulation initiation with NOACs versus warfarin. Methods:
Analyses were performed using national pharmacy claims data from a means-tested
state medical services scheme. First-time initiators of an oral anticoagulant between
January 2009 and December 2013 with ≥ 1 year scheme eligibility and ≥ age 50
were identified. Patients whose claims amounted to < 90 days of oral anticoagulation were excluded. Patient characteristics, and number and type of concomitant
medications at the time of first oral anticoagulant were recorded and considered
as predictors of NOAC initiation using multivariate logistic models (odds ratios, OR
and 95% CIs). Results: 34,944 new initiators of oral anticoagulants were included.
In 2009, 7.6% of new initiators received a NOAC; this figure rose to 41.2% in 2013. The
following were positively associated with NOAC initiation in multivariate analyses:
female gender (OR: 1.14,95% CI 1.07-1.21), age < 80 (OR: 1.11, 95% CI 1.04-1.19) and
concomitant receipt of NSAID drugs (OR: 4.04, 95% CI 3.72-4.38). Receipt of multiple
concomitant medications was negatively associated with NOAC initiation; patients
receiving 15+ drug classes had a 42% decreased odds of NOAC receipt (versus ≤ 5
drug classes) (OR: 0.58, 95% CI 0.51-0.66). Specific concomitant drugs negatively
A500
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
associated with NOAC use included rate/rhythm control treatments (OR: 0.78, 95%
CI 0.73-0.83) and SSRI/SNRI antidepressants (OR: 0.87, 95% CI 0.79-0.96). Regional
variation in initiation of NOACs versus warfarin was also observed. Conclusions:
Multiple comorbidities may be associated with lower likelihood of NOAC initiation,
as recently observed in other jurisdictions. Such uptake patterns have implications
for real-world cost-effectiveness and outcomes studies.
PCV156
Investment Aspects of Generic Drug Policies in Countries With
Severe Resource Constraints
Kaló Z 1, Harsányi A 1, Vámossy I 2
Loránd University, Budapest, Hungary, 2Gedeon Richter Plc, Budapest, Hungary
.
.
.
1Eötvös
Objectives: The objective of generic drugs policies can be defined as reduction in
health care expenditure without compromising health outcomes. This definition
is based on the disinvestment aspect of drug policies. However, the objective of
generic drug policies can be also defined from an investment perspective, especially in those countries with volume limits for the use of original patented drugs
due to economic constraints: increase in population health gain by improved
patient access without need for additional health expenditure. Our objective was
to compare benefits of generic drugs policies in Germany vs Hungary. Methods:
We reviewed the grey literature and IMS database to identify pharmaceutical products with (1) patent expiry in recent years, (2) major therapeutic advancement to
previous standard therapies, (3) no direct therapeutic alternative at patent expiry,
(4) pharmacy distribution and consequently reliable IMS sales records in different countries. Then we compared aggregated annual volume sales in DOT and
ex-factory sales for the selected pharmaceuticals in +/- 3 years before and after
first generic entry. Results: In this analysis we present the case of clopidogrel. In
Germany the volume sales of clopidogrel products increased by 1.7% with 3 years
after first generic entry, in Hungary the increase was 120.5%. The ex-factory sales
were reduced after patent expiry in both countries, by 30.1% in Germany and by
59.5% in Hungary. Conclusions: In Germany off-patent clopidogrel generated
significant savings without volume increase. In Hungary generic products significantly improved the accessibility of patients to clopidogrel therapy, in addition
to reducing pharmaceutical expenditure. Incremental health gain of off-patent
medicines should not be underestimated in those countries, where accessibility
of patients to patented medicines in restricted.
PCV157
The Impact of Drug Policy on the Utilization of Medicines for
Treatment of Cardiovascular Diseases in Slovak Republic
Gatialova K 1, Foltan V 2, Majtas J 3
1Comenius Univeristy, Bratislava, Slovak Republic, 2Faculty of Pharmacy, Comenius University,
Bratislava, Slovak Republic, 3Comenius University, Bratislava, Slovak Republic
.
.
.
Objectives: From the total health care costs in Slovak Republic the costs of medicines for treatment of cardiovascular diseases represent about 25%. In the world
the proportion is at 8-10%. Accurate data on morbidity from cardiovascular disease
in Slovak Republic is not available. National Health Information Center is processing the data on prevalence and incidence of circulatory system diseases, but this
includes only those patients who are followed in cardiology in SR. Reportedly,
the prevalence of cardiovascular diseases in SR is about 250 000 patients (50.8/
1000 inhabitants). Methods: The utilization of medicines in period from 2008
to 2013 for treatment of cardiovascular diseases was analysed quantitatively by
inderect descriptiv method of evaluating supply of medicines in quantitative units
(number of packages), in the number of DDD and in financial indicators reflecting the full value of consumed package. Data were gained from National Health
Center and State Institute of Drug Control. Results: The decline of consumption
expressed in number of packages was observed in the group of cardiac therapy
and by peripheral vasodilatators. The groups of beta blocking agents, agents acting
on the renin-angiotensin system and lipid modifying agents showed increase in
consumption. In DDD units the consumption deacreased most significantly in the
group of peripheral vasodilatators. Rise in DDD units was observed in the group
of beta blocking agents, antihypertesives, beta blocking agents, agents acting on
the renin-angiotensin system and lipid modifying agents. Atorvastatin was active
agent with highest consumption in DDD. The highest average price per package was
calculated by lipid modifying agents. After access of generic drugs to the market
in 2008 the consumption in financial units declined while consumption in DDD
grew in followed period. Conclusions: By using the same amount of health care
expenditures there is the possibility to provide treatment to more patients with
cardiovascular disease.
PCV158
Local Variation in Primary Care Prescribing Behavior in England:
Ticagrelor
lor example suggests that a positive National level (NICE) recommendation does
not necessarily translate into common local prescribing behavior. Local variation
(the fifth hurdle of market access) should be considered by pharmaceutical companies when developing market access strategy.
PCV159
Drug Utilisation in Cardiovascular Diseases Management in
Slovakia: 8 Years Overview
Babela R 1, Szydlowski S 2, Rusnak R 1, Fasko M 3
1St. Elizabeth University, BRATISLAVA, Slovak Republic, 2University of Scranton, SCRANTON,
Slovak Republic, 3St. Elizabeth University, Bratislava, Slovak Republic
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Atherosclerotic cardiovascular diseases (CVD) remain the major cause
of premature death in Europe. CVD treatment and precribing behavior remains
a major challenge for the doctors, payers and regulatory bodies. Key aim of our
study was to collect and compare reliable and comparable data on drug utilization for CVD therapy in Slovakia during 8 years (2005-2012). Methods: We utilized review of available costs data sources connected to ATC classification and to
cardiovascular diseases (C01-C10). We also looked for Daily Defined Doses (DDD)
measurement units. We adopted time frame and data was consequently used for
analysis. Costs were used in EUR. Results: Total increase in EUR spent on cardiovascular drugs was more than 60 million EUR (2012 vs 2005). Key growth drivers
from selected ATC groups were Vasoprotectives and Calcium channel blockers with
78% and 88% growth respectively (2012 vs. 2005). Amount of drug costs allocated
for cardiovascular disease escalated in 2011 with almost 197 million EUR, average
price for package reached 5,38 EUR in same year and price per 1 DDD was 0,17 EUR
per 1 DDD (2012) compare to 0,16 EUR (2005). Overall unit sales results from 2005 to
2012 show slide growth tendency till 2010 with following slight declined. Growth
in units for all ATC group under our scope reached the level of 4,3% (2012 vs 2005).
Standardized death rate for CVD decresed from 637,3 in 2005 to 510,4 in 2012 (per
100.000). Conclusions: Increase spending for CVD management translated also
into decrease death rate (2012 vs 2005). It is important for regulatory bodies and
payers to continue in taking adequate measures that will ensure rational pharmacotherapy alongside with improving prescribing behavior. Combining different measures, such as electronic prescription monitoring and promoting available guidelines
for CVD management, could be an effective way.
PCV160
Implementation of an Automatic Laboratory Data Checking System
To Reduce Deduction of Statins Reimbursement in A Teaching
Hospital in Taiwan
Lu T H , Chang Y T , Lin Y M
Shuang Ho Hospital, Taipei Medical University, New Taipei City, Taiwan
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: According to National Cholesterol Education Program Adult Treatment
Panel IV, lipid-lowing agent is required if in patient with atherosclerotic risks. The
annual cost of statins consumption was the first five human medications in Taiwan.
Therefore, disallowed/deduction of reimbursement from Administration of National
Health Insurance (NHI) was relatively higher than other drugs. An “Automatic
Laboratory data Checking System” was established in order to enhance rational
use of statins and to reduce deduction rate of statins reimbursement. This study
aims to analyze the economic outcomes after implemented the system. Methods:
The major cause of deduction was the lipid profile fragmented in the medical record.
To ensure rational use of statins based on NHI regulation, an “Automatic Laboratory
data Checking System” in computerized physician order entry (CPOE) system was
implemented in a teaching hospital on February 2013. When processing a statin
prescription through CPOE system, the prescriber should choose the lipid profile
linked with laboratory system in our hospital, or filled in lipid profile performed at
outside source. The prescription would be blocked if the inspection date and laboratory data were not adherence to the NHI regulation. Results: After system implementation, the deduction of statins reimbursement was significantly decreased.
There were three indicators substantially improved in year 2013 than 2012: The
average quarterly deduction was 2.16 million NTD reduced, the average quarterly
deduction rate was 14% reduced (18.18% versus 3.95%), and the disallowed reimbursement account for 57.11% medication fee decreased to 7.17%. Conclusions:
The present study demonstrated that “Automatic Laboratory data Checking System”
lessen the economic burden of statins reimbursement based on NHI regulations.
The system was associated with rational use of statins and reducing disallowed
reimbursement as well.
PCV161
Clinical and Demographics Characteristics of Non-Valvular Atrial
Fibrillation Patients Switching From Warfarin To Novel Oral
Anticoagulants
Sear R D , Jenner H D
McKinsey & Co, London, UK
Kachroo S 1, Pan X 2, Liu L 3, Kawabata H 4, Phatak H 1
1Bristol-Myers Squibb Company, Princeton, NJ, USA, 2Bristol-Myers Squibb, New Haven, CT, USA,
3Pfizer, New York, NY, USA, 4Bristol-Myers Squibb, Hopewell, NJ, USA
Objectives: To understand the level of local variation in community-level
prescribing of ticagrelor in England, after national-level recommendation from
NICE. Methods: Monthly GP-Practice-level prescribing data was collected for
antiplatelet drugs (Chapter 2.9 of British National Formulary [BNF]) in England,
between August 2011 and February 2013. Data was obtained from the Health
and Social Care Information Centre (HSCIC) and analyzed in Statistical Analysis
Software (SAS). The percentage of total antiplatelet spend (net ingredient cost)
attributed to ticagrelor was calculated for each GP Practice and Clinical commissioning Group (CCG) cluster. Results: Despite national-level NICE guidance (December 2011) recommending the use of ticagrelor for Acute Coronary
Syndrome, uptake of ticagrelor at CCG level varied greatly between August 2011
and February 2013. The proportion of total antiplatelet spend on ticagrelor in
February 2013 ranged from 0% to 34∙91%, between CCGs. The highest relative use of
ticagrelor was clustered around the Yorkshire region. Conclusions: The ticagre-
Objectives: This real-world study evaluated the baseline characteristics of patients
with non-valvular atrial fibrillation (NVAF) who had switched from warfarin to novel
oral anticoagulants (NOACs). Methods: Retrospective cohort study was conducted
using the MarketScan® plus Earlyview data from 10/1/2009 to 12/31/2013. Adult
NVAF patients (ICD-9 code 427.31 or 472.32) with one year of baseline period and
a history of continuous warfarin use in the baseline period for at least 3 months
immediately before the index date (defined as the first NOAC claim) were included.
Patients with evidence of valvular heart disease, thyrotoxicosis, pericarditis, mitral
stenosis, VTE, cardiac surgery, and endocarditis during the baseline period were
excluded. Categorical variables were reported as percentages and frequencies,
and continuous variables as means±SD. Categorical variables were compared
using Pearson’s chi-squared test while continuous variables were compared using
wilcoxon signed-rank test. Results: Among 11,743 eligible patients, 427 (3.64%)
switched to apixaban, 8,989 (76.55%) to dabigatran and 2,327 (19.81%) to rivaroxaban.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A501
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Apixaban (74.82±11.39 years) patients were older versus those who switched to dabigatran (72.46±10.89 years, p< 0.0001) or rivaroxaban (73.50±11.27 years, p= 0.0193).
Apixaban users (45.4%) were more female compared to dabigatran (38.4%, p= 0.0037)
and rivaroxaban (40.4%, p=0.0499). The mean CHADS2 score was higher for apixaban
users (mean±SD 2.28±1.25) as compared to dabigatran (1.94±1.20, p< 0.0001) and
rivaroxaban (2.18±1.25, p= NS) users. Apixaban patients had significantly higher
baseline rates for congestive heart failure (p= 0.0111), hypertension (p= 0.0002), renal
disease (p= 0.0017) and ischemic stroke/ transient ischemic attack (p= 0.0004) as
compared to dabigatran users. Apixaban users (2.34±2.12) also had higher mean
charlson comorbidity index scores as compared to dabigatran users (1.98±1.96,
p= 0.0002). Conclusions: Patients who switch to apixaban are older and sicker
as compared to those switching to dabigatran or rivaroxaban. A detailed evaluation
of patient characteristics on the treatment outcomes in NVAF patients switching
from warfarin to NOAC is warranted in future.
PCV162
Treatment Patterns in Hyperlipidemia Patients With New
Cardiovascular Events - Estimates From Population-Based Register
Data in Sweden
Hallberg S 1, Banefelt J 1, Fox K M 2, Mesterton J 1, Johansson G 3, Levin L Å 4, Sobocki P 5,
Gandra S R 6
1Quantify Research, Stockholm, Sweden, 2Strategic Healthcare Solutions, LLC, Monkton, MD, USA,
3Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden, 4Linköping University, Linköping, Sweden, 5IMS Health,
Stockholm, Sweden, 6Amgen, Inc., Thousand Oaks, CA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess treatment patterns of lipid-lowering drugs in patients with
hyperlipidemia or prior cardiovascular (CV) events (myocardial infarction, unstable angina, revascularization, ischemic stroke, transient ischemic attack or heart
failure) who experience new CV events. Methods: A retrospective populationbased cohort study was conducted using Swedish electronic medical records and
national registers. Patients were included in the study based on a prescription of
lipid-lowering treatment between January 1, 2006 and December 31, 2006 or history
of CV events (prior to 2006) and followed until December 31,2012 for identification
of new CV events and assessment of treatment patterns. Patients were stratified
into three cohorts based on CV risk level. The index was the date of first new CV
event during follow-up. All outcomes were assessed during the year following index
date. Adherence was defined as medical possession ratio (MPR) > 0.80. Persistence
was defined as no gaps > 60 days in supply of drug used at index date. Results:
Of patients with CV event history (n= 6881), 49% were not on treatment at index.
Corresponding data for CV risk equivalent and low/unknown CV risk patients were
37% (n=3226) and 38% (n=2497), respectively. Mean MPR for patients on treatment at
index was similar across cohorts (0.74–0.75). The proportions of adherent patients
(60–63%) and persistent patients (56–57%) were also similar across cohorts. Dose
escalation from the dose at index was seen within all cohorts, most notably for
patients with low/unknown CV risk as 25% increased the dose after index. 2–3% of
patients switched to a different drug after index while 5–6% of patients augmented
treatment by adding another lipid-lowering drug. Conclusions: Almost 50% of
secondary prevention patients were not on any hyperlipidemia treatment, indicating a potential therapeutic gap. Medication adherence and persistence among
patients on hyperlipidemia treatment were suboptimal.
PCV163
Determinants of Health Care Utilization in Hypertensive Patients:
A Longitudinal Analysis
Pinheiro B 1, Fernandes M 2, Antunes M 3
de Investigação Sobre Economia Portuguesa, Lisbon, Portugal, 2Universidade de Lisboa,
Lisbon, Portugal, 3Faculdade de Ciências da Universidade de Lisboa, 1749-016, Portugal
.
.
.
1Centro
Objectives: DIMATCH-HTA is a cohort study conducted to identify determinants of blood pressure control among Portuguese-speaking African immigrants
and Portuguese natives. The aim of this analysis is to study the determinants of
health care utilization among hypertensive patients followed in Primary Health
Care. Methods: The sample comprises 1243 unbalanced observations from 513
patients. Data were collected through questionnaires administered face-to-face
at baseline, 6 and 12 months, and by telephone at 3 and 9 months after enrolment. The variable used to capture health care utilization was the number of visits
to the general practitioner related to hypertension, in the three months prior to
each interview. The covariates were chosen based on Grossman’s health capital
model of demand for health (1972) and Andersen conceptual model (1968). Amongst
socioeconomic covariates, gender, age, ethnicity, education, monthly equivalent
income, living alone and domestic work were considered. Health status was captured by the presence of diabetes, time since hypertension diagnosis and number
of medicines. Self-perception of hypertension and private health insurance were
also included. A GLMM model for count data, with a random effect on intercept
was estimated. Model adequacy was checked via residual analysis and comparison of observed and predicted values. The analysis was performed in R (version
3.0. 2) using lme4 package. Results: Results of estimated model indicated that
total number of medicines (beta= 0.05, p-value= 0.03) and diabetes (beta= 0.40,
p-value=0.01) have significant positive impact on health care consumption. Patients
whose occupation is domestic work have higher health care utilization (beta= 0.73,
p-value= 0.02). On the other hand, those who self-assess their hypertension as controlled (beta= -0.37, p-value= 0.02) and patients with higher income (in log scale,
beta= -0.26, p-value= 0.01) have less visits to general practitioner related to hypertension. Conclusions: Based on the analysis it seems that not only variables
related to health status, but also socioeconomic determinants impact health care
utilization in hypertension.
PCV164
The Determinants of Uptake and Diffusion of Innovative Health
Technologies. An Empirical Analysis
Callea G 1, Armeni P 2, Tarricone R 3, Cavazza M 4, Jommi C 5
.
.
.
.
.
1Centre for Research on Health and Social Care Management (CERGAS) and The European
Health Technology Institute for Socio-Economic Research (EHTI), Milan, Italy, 2Bocconi University,
Milano, Italy, 3Bocconi University, Milan, Italy, 4Centre for Research on Health and Social Care
Management (CERGAS), Milan, Italy, 5Università del Piemonte Orientale, Novara, Italy
Objectives: The aim of the research is to explore the main determinants driving
the diffusion of new medical technologies. Methods: We investigated the diffusion two medical technologies: cardiac ablation for atrial fibrillation (CA-AF) and
left atriage appendage closure (LAAC). Our sample consists of all Italian hospitals
that adopted the two focal technologies in the period 2009-2012. We classified
the hospitals according to ownership, type, teaching status and urban location.
In the first regression we investigate the diffusion, i.e. yearly number of procedures performed by each hospital, in the second one the average frequency of use,
measured as the average number of days between two subsequent procedures
in each hospital. Results: Different types of hospitals show different baseline
trends of diffusion. Public hospitals, both teaching and non-teaching, use less
CA-AF compared to private non-teaching ones. Among hospital-level variables,
the use of DRG-based reimbursement has a positive effect on CA-AT diffusion,
not significant for LAAC. The rank in adoption is an important factor only for
CA-AF. The impact of the number of other hospitals contemporaneously adopting
the technology is negative for both technologies, but significant only for CA-AF.
The average time between two subsequent uses is negatively correlated with the
diffusion for both technologies. Regional contextual variables, including type of
funding and socio-economic variables do not show significant impacts, with the
exception of per capita public health expenditure, that enhances the diffusion
of both technologies, and the ratio between public health expenditure and GDP
in the case of CA-AF. The average frequency of use decreases over time for both
technologies. Neither hospital-level variables nor regional-level ones do not show
significant effects. The only variable with a significant and negative impact on the
frequency of use of CA-AF is the number of competitors. Conclusions: These
results are consistent with previous literature.
PCV165
Challenges and Opportunities in The Management of Chronic
Diseases During The Economic Crisis In Greece: A Qualitative
Approach
Tsiantou V , Mylona K , Karampli E , Boubouchairopoulou N , Pavi E , Kyriopoulos J
National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: There is evidence that in Greece, economic crisis has substantially
affected chronic patients’ access to health care services. The aim of the study was
to depict the current situation and identify the challenges and opportunities regarding the management of chronic diseases, in times of economic crisis and austerity from the aspect of both providers and patients. Methods: Representatives of
chronic patients and medical associations were invited to participate in a focus
group session. Four diseases (Type 2 Diabetes, Hypertension, COPD, and Alzheimer)
were selected based on their epidemiology and socioeconomic impact on the Greek
health care system. Fifteen representatives participated and their statements were
recorded, analyzed and categorized into 4 categories. Results: Common issues in
the management of chronic diseases under study appear to be the low quality of
health services, fragmented primary care system and absence of specialized centers for the management of chronic diseases. These problems of the Greek health
system were found to be magnified because of the recession. Furthermore, the
increased numbers of unemployed, uninsured and patients at risk of poverty, puts
additional pressure to the health system and futher undermines the quality of
the health services. Economic and geographic barriers in access were reported,
strengthening of the primary health system, development of patient registries,
patient education regarding self-management and involvement of their associations
in decision making was considered critical to the improvement of disease management. Conclusions: The management of chronic diseases was challenging even
before the economic crisis in Greece, but the current economic framework poses
additional threats for the health care system jeopardizing patients’ health and its
sustainability due to an increased risk for future costs. Investment in patients and
physicians education regarding chronic diseases management was thought to be
the key for improving this situation.
PCV166
Catastrophic Health Expenditures and Chronic Condition Patients
in Greece
Skroumpelos A 1, Pavi E 1, Pasaloglou S 2, Kyriopoulos J 1
1National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece, 2Novartis Hellas, Metamorfosi, Greece
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Aim of the study was to investigate chronic patients’ out-of-pocket
expenditures and the percent of the households subjected to catastrophic health
expenditures (CHE) during the economic crisis. Methods: A cross-sectional study
was conducted among 1600 chronic patients suffering from diabetes, hypertension, COPD and Alzheimer. Patients were asked to indicate the amount they spent
for primary and secondary health care services and for pharmaceuticals. Current
household income and income decrease since 2010 were also measured. CHE was
defined as any amount spent for health which accounts for more than 20% of the
total household income. Results: 1594 patients responded to the survey (99.6%).
In 2013, 7.8% of all households with at least one chronic condition patient were subjected to CHE, compared to 3.6% in 2010. The analysis by disease showed that 11.4%
in 2013 vs 6.2% in 2010 of the Alzheimer patients faced CHE, while the respective
figures was 8.7% vs 2.9% for the COPD patients, 7.1% vs 3.4% for diabetic patients,
and 4.2 vs 1.7% for the hypertensive patients. Pharmaceutical expenditures alone
were deemed catastrophic for 4.6% of all the above patients in 2013 vs 1.6% before
the introduction of the austerity measures and the health care reforms. Of the
Alzheimer patients, 6.2% in 2013 vs 2.8% in 2010 faced CHE due to out-of-pocket
payments for drugs, while the respective figures were found to be 3.4% vs 1.8%
for the diabetic patients, 2.9% vs 0.9% for COPD patients and 1.7% vs 0.9% for the
hypertensive patients. Conclusions: After the introduction of austerity measures
A502
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
in Greece a substantial increase of the households with at least one chronic condition patient which are subjected to CHE is recorded. There is a need for counter
measures or/and an alternative policy context in order to reduce this catastrophic
effect of economic crisis.
PCV167
Snapshot of Prescribing Practice for Clopidogrel and Esomeprazole
Co-Prescription and Cost Evaluation of Guidelines Application
Vernaz N , Rollason V , Adlere L , Bonnabry P , Desmeules J
University of Geneva Hospitals, Geneva, Switzerland
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Through CYP2C19, the antiplatelet clopidogrel and the proton-pump
inhibitor esomeprazole demonstrate a pharmacokinetic interaction that could
translate into clinical inefficacy of clopidogrel. No medical consensus has been
reached to date and therefore different guidelines are available. We aimed to
evaluate the prescribing practices in the University Hospitals of Geneva (HUG) by
measuring if the co-prescription was staggered as suggested by experts. We also
measured the Omeprazole-CLopidogrel-Aspirin (OCLA) study impact on clopidogrel use in our hospital. Methods: Patient’s medical orders and nurse’s drug
administration planning’s were analysed from January 2013 to April 2014 and the
hospital pharmacy database from January 2000 to April 2014. To measure the “extra
costs” of the implementation of different guidelines we built scenarios assuming the clopidogrel or esomeprazole replacement with prasugrel or ticagrelor
and pantozole or ranitidine, respectively. Results: Fifty seven percent of patients
under clopidogrel had a co-prescription of esomeprazole during the study period.
Among them 15% (154/1’000) had a medical order staggering the co-prescription
(more than 10 hours apart), 16% a concomitant prescription and 64% no clear
information. Five percent had 40 mg esomeprazole twice daily, hindering the
possibility of staggering. Surprisingly we found a higher rate of patients having a nurse’s schedule of more than 10 hours (39%, 417/1’071). Switching drugs
would lead to increased costs for HUG of € 38’210 for prasugrel, € 34’800 for ticagrelor, € 9’590 for pantoprazole and € 5’205 for ranitidine. A statistical significant
decrease in trend of clopidogrel use was observed after the OCLA study publication. Conclusions: The medical order’s information time frame should be
mandatory in order to improve the transmission throughout the whole information system and allow a clear staggering of clopidogrel-esomperazole co-prescription avoiding drug-drug interactions when possible. Nurses take the initiative
to stagger the co-prescription when these are not clearly defined by medical
orders.
PCV168
Regional Variation in Hospital Mortality, Length of Stay and Cost
of Ischemic Stroke Patients in Alberta
Ohinmaa A 1, Zheng Y 2, Jeerakathil T 1, Thanh N X 2, Hakkinen U 3, Kaul P 1, Klarenbach S 1,
Friesen D 4, Ariste R 5, Ruseski J 6, Jacobs P 2
of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada, 2Institute of Health Economics, Edmonton,
AB, Canada, 3National Institute for Health and Welfare, Helsinki, Finland, 4Alberta Medical
Association, Edmonton, AB, Canada, 5Canadian Institute for Health Information, Ottawa, ON,
Canada, 6West Virginia University, Morgantown, WV, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: This study compares the outcome and health care performance
among five health zones in Alberta by evaluating 30 days in-hospital mortality
and length of stay (LOS) in patients with acute ischemic stroke, and total hospitalization costs over one year. Methods: Ischemic stroke (ICD-10 code I63) patients
(without previous stroke within one year, N= 1,445) hospitalized between April
1, 2007 and March 31, 2008 were followed for one year using hospital Discharge
Abstract Database. The severity of the stroke was obtained from the ambulatory
care database (NACRs). Median hospital costs by CMG+ group were obtained from
Alberta Health. Logistic regression was used to analyse in-hospital mortality; negative binomial regression assessed LOS, and generalized gamma model (log link)
for hospital costs. The risk-adjusted outputs were estimated adjusting for sex,
all disease-specific co-morbidities, and stroke severity. We calculated observed/
expected results for five zones; South, Calgary, Central, Edmonton, and North
Zones. Results: The risk-adjusted 30-days-mortality rates (95% CI) varied from
7.8% (3.4%-12.1%) to 13.5% (9.6%-17.4%) in South and Central zones, respectively.
The adjusted mean LOS varied from 16.3 (13.8-19.3) days in South Zone to 26.7
(24.2-29.5) and 29.3 (24.0-35.8) days in Edmonton and North zones, respectively. The
results show several statistically significant differences between the first episodes
LOS between zones reflecting partly differences in the post-acute care in each location for patients not discharged to home. The one-year-mean hospitalization costs
varied from $72,300 ($55,000-$95,100) in North Zone to $25,500 ($20,500-$31,800) in
South Zone. Conclusions: The study shows significant variation in outcomes
for ischemic stroke between the five health zones. Although the Provincial Stroke
Strategy has largely standardized the stroke care between regions, differences in
post-acute care arrangements have produced significant LOS and cost differences.
More detailed analysis of the reasons for regional variation is needed for improvement of the regional health care outcomes.
PCV170
The Association of Hosptial Type and Stroke Centre With
Mortality, Length of Stay and Hospital Cost of Ischemic Stroke
Patients in Alberta
Ohinmaa A 1, Zheng Y 2, Jeerakathil T 1, Thanh N X 2, Hakkinen U 3, Ruseski J 4, Kaul P 1,
Klarenbach S 1, Friesen D 5, Ariste R 6, Jacobs P 2
1University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada, 2Institute of Health Economics, Edmonton, AB,
Canada, 3National Institute for Health and Welfare, Helsinki, Finland, 4West Virginia University,
Morgantown, WV, USA, 5Alberta Medical Association, Edmonton, AB, Canada, 6Canadian
Institute for Health Information, Ottawa, ON, Canada
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: This study examines the association of 30 day in-hospital mortality,
length of stay (LOS) during the first hospital episode, and hospitalization costs
during one year after acute ischemic stroke by type of hospital and by stroke centre
status. Methods: New ischemic stroke (ICD-10 code I63) patients (no previous
stroke within one year) between April 1, 2006 and March 31, 2009 (N= 4,350) were
followed for one year using hospital Discharge Abstract Database. The severity of
the stroke was obtained from the ambulatory care database. Median hospital costs
by CMG+ group were obtained from Alberta Health. Hospitals were classified as
teaching, community large, community medium, and community small hospitals.
Hospitals were also classified as comprehensive stroke centre, urban and rural
primary stroke centres, and other urban and rural hospitals. The adjusted risk
factors in Bayesian Model included sex, age, all disease-specific co-morbidities,
and disease severity. The results for four hospital types and five stroke center categories were calculated using the observed/expected approach. Results: The 30
days mortality rates (95% CI) were lowest for teaching hospitals 10.1% (9.0%-11.2%)
and large community hospitals (10.0%; 8.3%-11.8%), and the small community
hospitals had the highest mortality rates (12.8%; 9.9%-15.8%). The mean LOS (95%
CI) varied from 21.7 (20.9-22.6) days in teaching hospitals to 34.2 (28.6-41.0) days
in community medium hospitals. The community medium hospitals had significantly higher costs ($62,400; $49,900-$78,000) than the community large hospitals
($32,900; $29,900-$36,200) and teaching hospitals ($37,000; $34,900-$39,200). Both
comprehensive stroke and urban stroke centers had lower 30 day mortality rates
(95% CI): 9.9% (8.8%-11.1%) and 9.7% (7.3%-12.0%); shorter LOS 21.6 (20.7-22.5)
and 25.0 (22.7-27.6) days; and medium levels of costs $39,300 ($36,100-$40,700),
compared to other hospitals. Conclusions: The study shows the hospital type
and stroke centre had limited effects on the mortality but significant impact on
LOS and costs.
PCV171
In-Patient Hospital Costs of Stroke: A Focused Literature Review
Kritikou P 1, Vemmos K 2, Payne K A 3
BioSource Corporation, London, UK, 2Acute Stroke Unit, Department of Clinical
Therapeutics, University of Athens, Athens, Greece,, 3United BioSource Corporation, Dorval, QC,
Canada
.
.
.
.
1United
Objectives: Stroke is the third leading cause of mortality worldwide, with significant associated acute care hospitalization costs. The objective of this literature
review was to delineate the costing methodologies employed for the estimation of
in-patient hospital costs of stroke. Methods: A PubMed search was performed
using the keywords: hospitalization, cost analysis, acute stroke, and cost-effectiveness; limited to publications in English from 2008 onwards. Inclusion criteria
were patient-level data collection and detailed description of costing methodology
applied. Cost-effectiveness and literature review studies were excluded. Results:
In total 22 articles were included in the analysis. Cohort studies comprised 45% of
the sample, followed by database analyses (32%), registered-based studies (9%),
retrospective chart review studies (9%), and clinical trials (5%). Cost categories
measured included direct medical costs (bed and staff, laboratory and imaging
investigations, medications, rehabilitation and supportive nursing care), as well
as indirect costs for the patients and their caregivers; in 2 studies the economic
analysis was performed from a societal perspective. The resource utilization
(excluding the database analyses) was identified in the medical records (80%), or
from interviews (20%). Unit costs were primarily derived from national listings or
hospital accounting files (36% each). The sample sizes (ranging from 100 to over
60,000 patients), as well as the total costs (ranging from US$500 to US$150,000 per
patient and from US$70 to US$13,000 per day) varied significantly, as a result of the
heterogeneous cost variables described. Conclusions: Methodologies differed
in approach, complexity and specific cost variables evaluated. Consequently, the
total costs varied significantly across studies which makes direct comparisons of
outcomes difficult. A trend towards more sophisticated economic analyses, such
as real costs measured versus hospital reimbursement rates, or hospitalization
costs before versus after stroke, was observed. A more standardized approach to
evaluating in-patient costs of stroke care is warranted.
PCV172
Optimizing Process Efficiency Through Implanting Reveal Linq
VersUS Reveal Xt/Dx From Three Spanish Hospital Perspective
Egea García M 1, Toquero Ramos J 2, García Alberola A 3, Arias Palomares M Á 4, Marti
Sánchez B 1
1Medtronic Iberia, Madrid, Spain, 2Hospital Puerta de Hierro, Majadahonda, Spain, 3Hospital
universitario Virgen de la Arrixaca, Murcia, Spain, 4Hospital Virgen de la Salud, Toledo, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Implantable loop recorders (ILR) are devices that continuously monitor heart rhythm in patients with suspicion of cardiac arrhythmias. Reveal LinQ™
is a new insertable holter, an 87% smaller than Reveal® XT/DX that records abnormal heart rhythm up to 3 years. The objective was to develop an economic tool
which allows hospitals to quantify their cost savings from the simplified procedure
of Reveal LinQ™. The tool was used to compare the costs of implanting Reveal®
XT/DX in the cath lab to the costs of inserting Reveal LinQ™ out of the cath lab in
three public hospitals of the Spanish National Health Care System. Methods: A
cost model was developed to assess the cost per procedure of Reveal LinQ™ and
Reveal® XT/DX. The model included data of the personnel needed in the procedure, the hospital setting, the hospitalization previous to the procedure, remote
monitoring and post-procedure controls. Results: The total process-related
savings of LinQ™ vs. Reveal® XT/DX in Virgen de la Salud, Puerta de Hierro and
Virgen de la Arrixaca Hospitals were € 335 (13.3%), € 365 (13.1%) and € 517 (19.2%),
respectively. Reveal LinQ™ was associated with a 66% reduction in cardiologist
and OR-assistant time in Virgen de la Salud Hospital, a reduction of 15 minutes
of cardiologist time in Puerta de Hierro Hospital and a reduction of 3 control visits due to remote monitoring in Virgen de la Arrixaca Hospital. Conclusions:
The economic tool showed that the insertion of Reveal LinQ™ is associated
with mean savings of € 406 from a hospital perspective compared to previous
devices; mainly derived from moving the procedure out of the catheter lab, a
reduction of the specialists’ time and in-hospital follow up visits due to remote
monitoring.
A503
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PCV173
Effect of Oral Nutritional Supplements On Hospital Outcomes in
Patients Aged 65+ With Congestive Heart Failure
Lakdawalla D 1, Thornton Snider J 2, Perlroth D 3, LaVallee C 2, Linthicum M T 2, Philipson T J 4,
Partridge J 5, Wischmeyer P 6
of Southern California, Los Angeles, CA, USA, 2Precision Health Economics, Los
Angeles, CA, USA, 3Stanford University, Stanford, CA, USA, 4University of Chicago, Chicago, IL,
USA, 5Abbott Nutrition, Columbus, OH, USA, 6University of Colorado School of Medicine, Aurora,
CO, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: Hospital admissions for congestive heart failure (CHF) are a major
driver of costs for health systems, and CHF is especially prevalent in patients
aged 65 and older. This study assessed whether provision of oral nutritional supplements (ONS) in the hospital can reduce these costs, by estimating the effect
of ONS use on 30-day readmission rates, length of stay (LOS), and hospitalization episode costs. Methods: Using the 2000-2010 Premier Research database,
a large US hospital episode database, we extracted a sample of episodes among
patients aged 65 and older with a primary diagnosis of CHF. We excluded episodes
involving tube feeding and those ending in death (due to censoring). Using propensity score matching, we created a 1: 1 matched sample of ONS and non-ONS
episodes. We applied ordinary least squares (OLS) and instrumental variables
(IV) regression analyses to investigate the outcomes of ONS use. The key outcomes studied were 30-day readmission rates, LOS, and episode costs (measured
in 2010 US$). Results: Propensity score matching produced a matched sample
of 38,418 CHF episodes. Naïve OLS analysis, which did not account for selection
bias, suggested that ONS increased costs, LOS, and probability of 30-day readmission. However, using IV regression analysis to control for selection bias revealed
that ONS use reduced the probability of readmission within 30 days by 10.1%,
from 0.387 to 0.360 (p< 0.01). LOS was reduced through ONS use by 1.28 days
(14.2%), from 9.03 to 7.75 (p< 0.01). Episode costs were significantly lower with
ONS use, reducing medical expenditures by $1,266 (7.8%), from $16,166 to $14,900
(p< 0.01). Conclusions: In elderly patients hospitalized with CHF, ONS improves
30-day readmission, LOS, and episode cost outcomes. ONS use could provide a
low-cost strategy for improving hospitalization outcomes for elderly patients with
CHF and reducing burden on health systems from CHF.
PCV174
Knowledge Transfer Gap Between Cardiologists and Patients
Undergoing Percutaneous Coronary Intervention Regarding Risks
Associated With Drug-Eluting Stents: An Asian & European Survey
Yan B P 1, Ip A 1, Lee V W 2
Chinese University of Hong Kong, Shatin, Hong Kong, China, 2The Chinese University of
Hong Kong, Hong Kong, Hong Kong
.
.
.
.
.
1The
Objectives: The choice of stent used in percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI)
is often at the discretion of the interventional cardiologist (IC) without informed
shared decision making. We aim to assess the impact of ICs’ awareness of the risk of
delayed arterial healing associated with drug-eluting stents (DES) on patient knowledge transfer. Methods: 132 ICs from 11 countries (3 Asian: Malaysia, Hong Kong,
Singapore and 8 European: Germany, Italy, UK, The Netherlands, Belgium, Denmark,
Russia and Serbia) were invited to complete an online survey using a 4-point scale
regarding their (i) familiarity with delayed arterial healing associated with DES; (ii)
how concerned they are about delayed arterial healing; (iii) frequency they discuss
this risk with their patients and (iv) frequency this risk influence the type of stent they
use. Responses from Asian cardiologists were compared with Europeans. Results:
43.2% ICs were Asians and 56.8% were Europeans. Majority of IC were extremely/
very familiar with the risk of delayed arterial healing after DES implantation (63.2%
Asian vs. 56.0% European, p=NS). IC who were extremely/very concerned about the
risk of delayed healing were more likely to discuss with their patients (Odds Ratio
(OR) 2.62, 95% confidence interval (CI) 1.17-5.85, p< 0.01) and influence their stent
choice (OR 5.56,95%CI 2.56-12.05, p< 0.01). Although twice as many Asian compared
to European ICs were extremely/very concerned about delayed arterial healing with
DES (59.6% vs. 32.4%, respectively, p<0.01), there were no significant differences in the
frequency this risk was discussed with patients (often/always: 24.6% Asian vs. 26.7%
European, P= NS) or influence the type of stent used (often/always: 47.4% vs. 35.7%,
P=NS). Conclusions: Many patients are not well informed of the risk associated
with DES despite high level of physician awareness and concern of this risk. This
knowledge transfer gap exists in both Asia and Europe.
PCV175
Acute Ischemic Stroke (Ais) Patient Management in French Stroke
Units and Impact Estimation of Thrombolysis On Care Pathways and
Associated Costs
Schmidt A 1, Bénard S 1, Heroum C 2, Caumette D 3, Delaitre O 3, Le Lay K 3
consultants, Oullins, France, 2CHRU Montpellier, Montpellier, France, 3Boehringer
Ingelheim France, Paris, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
were to home, 25% to rehabilitative care then home, 2% to rehabilitative care then a
nursing home, 7% to long-term care and 6% of stays ended with a patient death. Of
a total cost over 1 year of € 610 million (mean cost per patient of € 20,326), 70% concern the post-acute phase. By increasing the proportion of patients thrombolyzed,
costs are reduced primarily by a decrease in rehabilitative care, with savings per
additional treated patient of € 1,462. By adding improved timing, savings are more
than doubled (€ 3,183 per additional patient). Conclusions: By improving thrombolytic management in stroke units, patient journeys through care pathways can
be modified, with increased discharges home, a change in post-acute resource
consumption and net savings.
PCV176
Launching Novel Class Iii Implantable Cardiac Devices for
Cardiology in Europe First, Is This Common Commercial Practice
Improving Health Care Quality for Europeans
Garfield S 1, Armstrong S 2
Market Access, Wayland, MA, USA, 2GfK, Wayland, MA, USA
.
.
1GfK
Objectives: Regulatory hurdles for novel medical devices are lower in Europe
than in the US. The costs and evidence requirements to achieve CE marking for
class III devices are lower than to achieve FDA-approval via a PMA submission. As
such, many companies have chosen to enter European markets with innovative
cardiac devices before entering the US market. This study sought to understand
the frequency with which that has occurred in the last 10 years, and the correlation
between market access timing and cardiac outcomes. Methods: A review of CE
mark and FDA approvals for class III implantable cardiac devices was conducted for
the period of 2003-2013. Devices were identified and cross referenced to determine
which products achieved both CE mark and FDA approval. Those with both, were
then compared by the date of approval to determine market access variance in the
US versus Germany. Publically available coverage and reimbursement policies were
reviewed in each market in combination with relevant disease prevalence rates over
the study period. Results: Implantable cardiac devices were routinely available in
Germany before the US during the study period. Early use across Europe, in many
cases, created additional evidence that was leveraged during the FDA approval and
follow-on reimbursement assessment processes in the US. While HTAs for devices
was relatively rare in Germany, similar rates of reimbursement and access were
achieved in both markets. Rates of cardiovascular associated mortality have dropped
dramatically, across both markets though rates initiated their decline earlier in
Germany. Conclusions: Germans benefited from earlier access to many innovative implantable cardiac devices during the period of 2003 to 2013, as compared to
their American counterparts. The link between early access, clinical outcomes, and
cost needs to be further analyzed in future studies.
PCV177
Recruiting Cardiologists and Chronic Heart Patients From A
Managed Physician Panel To Support Clinical Studies Phase Iii/Iv Or
Health Outcome Studies
Eichmann F 1, Potthoff P 1, Brown C 2
Health Germany, Munich, Germany, 2All Global, London, UK
.
.
.
1Kantar
Objectives: To identify cardiologists willing to participate in Health outcome or
Clinical Studies Phase III/IV in internal medicine and to include patients for outcome assessment. Real life and Peri/Post-Approval Studies are becoming more and
more important to meet regulatory and market access needs. The objective of the
present contribution is to assess the benefits of a managed panel of cardiologists
for site and patient recruitment. Methods: In 2012, a representative survey among
members of a managed physician panel of cardiologists in US, UK, GER, FR, IT and
SP was conducted. 208 cardiologists reported on former experiences with clinical
studies phase III/IV and other post-approval studies, their willingness to participate
in future studies and their potential adherence to requirements of Good Clinical
Practice rules. Results: 87,6% of the cardiologists reported to have formerly participated in clinical studies phase III/IV, and 54,3% in post-approval studies. Over
58% of these cardiologists were willing to participate in future studies (58,2% in
clinical studies phase III/IV and 63,1% in other post-approval studies). More than
92,7% of this group was ready to be named as principal investigator to an ethical
committee, to report serious events to the sponsor (97,6%), or to participate in a
web-based training session (90,3%). Within one month cardiologists see in average
175 patients suffering from chronic heart disease in their practices (Minimum: 20;
Maximum more than 500). 93,5% of the cardiologists are willing to ask their patients
for informed consent for participation in studies, thereby providing a promising
source for recruiting patients. Conclusions: Cardiologists from a managed panel
are a time- and cost-effective option for recruiting sites and patients for observational post-approval outcome and safety studies in the big 5 EU countries and
the US. Patient incidence estimates are a reliable source for enrollment planning.
1st[è]ve
Objectives: This study aims to evaluate the current management and associated costs of acute ischemic stroke (AIS) for patients admitted in stroke units
in France and over a 1 year follow-up period as well as to assess the impact
of improved thrombolytic management in terms of increasing the proportion
of patients receiving thrombolysis and/or treated within 3hrs from symptom
onset on functional recovery and care pathways. Methods: A decision model
was developed, comprising two components: the first corresponding to the acute
hospital management phase of patients with AIS up until hospital discharge and
the second corresponding to the post-acute phase. Patient journeys and costs were
determined for both phases. Improved thrombolytic management was modeled
by increasing the proportion of patients receiving thrombolysis from the current
estimated level of 16.7 to 25% as well as subsequently increasing the proportion of
patients treated within 3 hours of the onset of symptoms post-stroke from 50 to
100%. The impact on care pathways was derived from clinical data. Results: In
2011, 29,999 stays took place in a stroke unit for AIS in France. 60% of discharges
PCV178
Health Care Stakeholders’ Evaluation of A User-Friendly Tool
Which Estimates Long-Term Health Gains Following the Reduction
of Ldl Levels
Laires P
Merck Sharp & Dohme, Oeiras, Portugal
.
Objectives: Demonstration of long-term value of preventive care in terms of health
gains and avoided costs associated with disease progression may be of great value
for those who need to prioritize health policies. This analysis aimed to evaluate
physicians’ and primary care payers’ opinions about a user-friendly tool which estimates long-term health gains following LDL-C reduction. Methods: A user-friendly
tool was developed based on a previously published Markov model employed to
evaluate health outcomes, including cardiovascular (CV) events and due costs. The
model incorporated Framingham risk equations, Portuguese population characteristics, national mortality rates and local costs. Software runs in iOS and the user may
simulate for 3, 5 and 10 years the expected CV events drop following a given LDL-C
A504
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
reduction. A predefined questionnaire was delivered to physicians’ and primary
care payers’ (namely members of the regional health authorities) to survey their
opinions about the value of this tool. Results: Overall opinion from 30 physicians
and 11 primary care deciders (geographically distributed) was positive, averaging
3.9 in a likert scale from 1 (strongly disagree) to 5 (strongly agree). Physicians averaged 4 while primary care payers’ was 3.7. 71% of respondents ranked 4 to 5 in
this overall assessment of the tool. Regarding more specific topics using the same
likert scale, global, physicians’ and primary care deciders’ responses averaged as
following, respectively: Utility of the tool: 3.6, 3.6 and 3.6; Relevance of the tool: 3.9,
3.9 and 3.9; Value of the tool to understand LDL-C treatment targets: 4.0, 4.2 and
3.6. Conclusions: This approach is useful to understand user’s opinions about a
tool which aims primarily to raise awareness on the importance of the LDL-C reduction. Available evidence demonstrates that health care stakeholders in Portugal still
need to understand the public health potential of LDL reduction. This tool might be
of great value to address this need.
PCV179
Treatment Patterns Among Heart Failure Patients Within 30 Days
Post Diagnosis: Results From A Us Claims Database Analysis
De Camargo Cancela M 1, Hudson E 1, Turner S J 2, Deschaseaux C 3
Ireland Ltd, Dublin, Ireland, 2Novartis Pharmaceuticals, East Hanover, NJ, USA,
3Novartis Pharma AG, Basel, Switzerland
.
.
.
.
.
1Novartis
Objectives: Clinical guidelines recommend ACEIs (angiotensin converting enzyme
inhibitors), ARBs (angiotensin receptor II blockers) for patients intolerant to ACEI, beta
blockers (BBs), aldosterone antagonists (AAs) and diuretics as the pharmacological
treatment for heart failure (HF). This study assesses the treatments prescribed within
30 days post diagnosis among HF patients in a real world setting based on an administrative claims database in the US. Methods: This was a retrospective cohort study
conducted using MarketScan database. Adult patients having ≥2 HF-related medical
claims or 1 hospitalisation with primary HF diagnosis between April 2009 and March
2012, and with a minimum of 12 months pre- and post-index continuous medical
and pharmacy eligibility were included. Index date was defined as the first HF-related
medical claim between April 2009 and March 2012. Patients with HF diagnosis in the
12 months pre-index period were excluded. Demographics, clinical characteristics
and index treatment (defined as a 30 days window period after HF diagnosis) were
analysed. Results: Among 121,904 patients included in the analysis, 48.3% were >75
years of age and 35.0% were 18-64 years of age. Diabetes (27.0%), CV related conditions (26%) and COPD (16.3%) were the most prevalent comorbidities. Overall, 37.6%
patients were not prescribed any treatment related to HF within the first 30 days
after HF diagnosis (no HF severity available). Among those prescribed treatment, the
following treatment breakdown was observed: ACEIs, 29.3% of patients; ARBs, 8.5%;
BBs, 46.6%; AAs, 7.4%; and diuretics, 45.7%. Prescription of fixed dose combination of
ACEIs with diuretics or ARBs with diuretics was very limited. Conclusions: Findings
suggest that a substantial proportion of patients do not receive HF specific medications following the month of diagnosis. Further research is necessary to explore the
reasons for lower than expected HF medication claims in these patients considering
their high risk for morbidity and mortality.
PCV180
Pattern of Benzodiazepines Utilization In Outpatients With
Hypertension in Serbia
Tomas A 1, Horvat O 1, Tomic Z 1, Ban M 1, Sabo A 2
1Faculty of Medicine, University of Novi Sad, Novi Sad, Serbia and Montenegro,, 2Faculty of
Medicine, University of Belgrade, Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Benzodiazepines (BZD) are often administered to patients with arterial
hypertension in addition to antihypertensive agents. The aim of this study was to
analyze patterns of BSD usage among hypertensive outpatients in Serbia according
to sex and age. Methods: Data on BZD issued on prescription for the International
classification of diseases (ICD) code I10 (essential arterial hypertension) were collected from all state-owned pharmacies in Novi Sad (population 350,000) from
September 2011 to February 2012. Consumption was calculated using the ATC/
DDD methodology. Results: BZD accounted for 2% of all drugs issued in treatment of hypertension. The total amount of BZD issued was 2.27 DDD/1000inh/day.
Bromazepam (51.38 %) and diazepam (37.56 %) were the most commonly used BSD
and accounted for almost 90% of all BSD utilized. Lorazepam accounted for 8.36%
of total consumption. Other agents (alprazolam, nitrazepam, midazolam, klonazepam) accounted for less than 3% altogether. The BZD consumption increased with
patient’s age – 91% being prescribed to the patients over the age of 50. Consumption
was highest in age group 70-80 years. BZD were more often prescribed to female
(68.63%) than to male outpatients (31.37%). Conclusions: This study confirmed
consumption of BZD among outpatients with hypertension. It is most common
in hypertensive female and elderly population. However, since the benefits of
BZD administration in hypertension control remain unclear, the adequacy of this
practice is questionable. This work was supported by the Ministry of Science and
Technological Development, Republic of Serbia, project No. 41012.
PCV181
Logistics of Monitoring of Vitamin K Antagonists in Western
European Countries: Prefer in Vte Registry
Monreal M 1, Bauersachs R 2, Gitt A K 3, Laeis P 4, Mismetti P 5, Willich S N 6, Cohen A T 7,
Agnelli G 8
1Hospital Universitari Germans Trias I Pujol, Barcelona, Spain, 2Max-Ratschow-Klinik für
Angiologie, Gefäßzentrum Klinikum Darmstadt GmbH, Darmstadt, Germany, 3Herzzentrum
Ludwigshafen, Ludwigshafen, Germany, 4Daiichi Sankyo Europe GmbH, Munich, Germany,
5Centre Hospitalier Universitaire Saint-Etienne, Hopital Nord, Saint Etienne, France, 6Charité Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Berlin, Germany, 7King’s College, London, UK, 8University of Perugia,
Santa Maria della Misericordia Hospital, Perugia, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In patients with acute deep venous thrombosis (DVT) or pulmonary
embolism (PE) there is a lack of comparative data on the logistics of international
normalized ratio (INR) monitoring in patients on vitamin K antagonists (VKA) on
maintenance anticoagulation. Methods: This interim analysis is based on data of
2863 patients enrolled in the PREFER in VTE registry in 7 Western European countries
(France, Germany, Italy, Spain, UK, Austria and Switzerland). 1689 had DVT (only)
and 1174 had PE (±DVT). Results: At 6-month follow-up, 51.5% of the patients were
treated with VKA. INR measurements at 6-month follow-up (UK: 3 month) were
performed in the hospital setting for 13.1% of these patients (most frequently in
Spain 42.9%, UK 32.7%,, Italy 18.0%), in the anticoagulation center in 23.6% (in Spain
40.0%, Italy 37.0%, UK 16.4%), in the physician’s office in 16.8% (Germany 90.7%, UK
41.8%), by the patient self-measured in 4.9% (Spain 8.6%), or at biology labs or other
institutions in 36.9% (France 92.4%). The patient’s mean travel distance to the INR
site was 5.8 ±9.16 km overall, the range was 0-90 km (mean varied across countries
from 2.4 to 7.7 km). Mean travel time was 14.3 ±18.4 min (across countries 5.7 to
18.2 min). Patients most frequently used their private car/motorbike (50.8 %) or
walked (16.4%). The mean number of INR measurements over the 6-month period
was 16.8, the number of INR measurements per month was 2.8 ±1.2 overall (across
countries 1.8 to 3.2). Conclusions: In the various countries, different institutions are responsible for routine INR measurements. While biology labs are almost
exclusively used in France, there is no equivalent for such institutions in other
countries. INR self-measurement plays a minor role. Patients usually have the INR
sites in their vicinity, and the average number of measurements shows little variation between countries.
PCV182
Treatment Patterns and Health Resource Utilization Among Atrial
Fibrillation Patients in United Arab Emirates and Saudi Arabia
Johnston K 1, Osenenko K M 1, Donato B M K 2, Qatami L 3, Alawi A A 4, Binbrek A S 5, Hersi A S 6,
Mould J F 7, Levy A R 1
1ICON Epidemiology, Vancouver, BC, Canada, 2Bristol-Myers Squibb Company, Wallingford, CT,
USA, 3Bristol-Myers Squibb Company, Dubai, United Arab Emirates, 4Sheikh Khalifa Medical City,
Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates, 5Rashid Hospital, Dubai, United Arab Emirates, 6King Saud
University Medical City, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, 7Pfizer, New York, NY, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Atrial fibrillation (AF) is the most common cardiac arrhythmia, and
accounts for one-third of hospitalizations for cardiac disturbances. The majority
of descriptive data on management of AF patients are from western countries,
with limited information available from the Middle East region. The objective of
this study was to characterize treatment patterns and health resource utilization
among AF patients in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA) and United Arab Emirates
(UAE). Methods: A retrospective chart review was undertaken at three hospitals
in UAE and three in KSA, to identify AF patients diagnosed between January 2005
and June 2010. Patient charts were sampled consecutively backwards by diagnosis
date, from June 2010 until the target sample was reached. AF was identified based
on ICD-9 code (427.31), from a sample of patients defined by any history of anticoagulant use. Data on demographic and disease-related characteristics, treatment
patterns, health resource utilization, and international normalized ratio (INR) control were abstracted from diagnosis until June 2012. Results: Among eligible AF
patients (UAE, n= 157, KSA, n= 152), the majority were diagnosed with chronic AF
(80.9% in UAE, 63.7% in KSA) as opposed to paroxysmal AF. Treatments prescribed to
AF patients differed between countries: warfarin monotherapy was widely used in
UAE (59.9%), while a variety of warfarin- and aspirin-based combination therapies
were used in KSA, with no single dominant regimen. Warfarin + bisoprolol (12.5%)
and aspirin + bisoprolol (10.5%) combination therapies were the most common
regimens in KSA. Patterns of health care utilization also varied, with hospitalization
and emergency room visits more common in KSA, and outpatient visits more common in UAE. Conclusions: Treatments and health resources used by AF patients
varied between KSA and UAE. While some differences may result from differences
in patient and disease characteristics, they likely also reflect variation in management strategies across the regions.
PCV183
Ldl-C Lowering Efficacy of Evolocumab (Amg 145) Could Reduce
Apheresis in Patients At High Risk for Cardiovascular Events in
Germany
Villa G 1, Schmid T 2, Lothgren M 1, Michailov G 2
(Europe) GmbH, Zug, Switzerland, 2Amgen GmbH, München, Germany
.
.
.
.
1Amgen
Objectives: Individuals at high risk for cardiovascular events who fail to achieve
treatment goal (LDL-C<100 mg/dL) despite being on maximal lipid lowering treatment qualify for apheresis, a procedure that costs approximately 40,000€ per patient
per year in Germany. The current model aims to assess the ability of evolocumab
(AMG 145), an investigational medication that is being evaluated in clinical trials,
to reduce the proportion of patients requiring apheresis in Germany. Methods:
Data on secondary prevention patients eligible for apheresis, excluding homozygous
familial hypercholesterolemia patients, were extracted from the German IMS Disease
Analyzer 2011-2013 database (n= 8,262) and included in the analysis. The calculated
mean LDL-C reductions observed in the DESCARTES and LAPLACE-2 evolocumab trials, ranging from 59.3% (95% CI [54.9%, 63.8%]) to 72.3% (95% CI [69.1%, 75.4%]), were
applied to baseline LDL-C levels of the identified patient-profiles, following a probabilistic approach. The goal for such patients was LDL-C< 100 mg/dL, as defined in the
German lipid association (DGFF) guideline. Results: The mean ± standard deviation
LDL-C levels of the sample decreased from 150.2 ± 32.9 mg/dL at baseline to 61.1 ±
13.8 mg/dL (DESCARTES) and to 41.7 ± 9.5 mg/dL (LAPLACE-2) after evolocumab treatment. From an initial proportion of 100% of patients eligible for apheresis at baseline,
evolocumab treatment led to a proportion of 1% (DESCARTES) and 0% (LAPLACE-2)
of patients requiring apheresis. Thus, in the analyzed population, apheresis-related
costs could be largely reduced. Conclusions: The use of evolocumab in the treatment algorithm of high-risk patients not at LDL-C goal could allow reducing the
invasive, time-consuming, burdensome and costly weekly apheresis treatments. As a
result, significant savings of apheresis-related costs could be achieved by the German
Health Care System.
A505
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
INDIVIDUAL’S HEALTH – Clinical Outcomes Studies
PIH1
Predictive Validity of Inappropriate Prescribing Criteria for
Adverse Drug Events, Hospitalizations, and Emergency Department
Visits: A Time-To-Event Comparison of the Beers and Stopp Criteria
Brown J , Li C , Painter J , Hutchison L C , Martin B
University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences, Little Rock, AR, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Adverse drug event (ADEs), hospitalizations, and emergency department
(ED) visits are important sequelae of inappropriate prescribing. Explicit measures are
useful methods to detect inappropriate prescribing in the elderly. This study compares the predictive validity of the 2002 Beers, 2012 Beers, and the STOPP criteria
for these outcomes. Methods: A retrospective cohort design was implemented
using commercial claims data between 2006 and 2009. Subjects included those 65
years and older continuously eligible for medical and pharmacy benefits for at least
6 months to assess baseline comorbidities and 3 months of follow-up. Time varying cox proportional hazard models were estimated using a monthly time interval
where indicators of inappropriate prescribing exposure in month (i-1) where related
to outcomes in month (i) to minimize temporal ambiguity between exposure and
outcome. Measures of model discrimination (c-index) and hazard ratios (HR) were
calculated to compare un-adjusted and adjusted models with the 2002 Beers, 2012
Beers, and STOPP exposures models. Results: The final cohort included 174,275
contributing 361,621 person years of follow up. The prevalence of inappropriate prescribing was 34.1%, 32.2%, and 27.6% for the 2012 Beers, 2002 Beers, and the STOPP
criteria and the rates of ADEs, ED, and hospital visits were 21.0, 140.3, 67.2 per 1000
person years. All inappropriate prescribing criteria modestly discriminated ADEs
in unadjusted analyses: STOPP (HR= 2.89 [2.68-3.12]; C-index= 60.7%), 2012 Beers
(HR=2.51 [2.33-2.70]; C-index=60.3%), 2002 Beers (HR=2.65 [2.46-2.85]; C-index=60.5%).
Similar results for model discrimination measures were observed for ED visits (STOPP
[C-index= 59.0%], 2012 Beers [C-index= 58.5%], 2002 Beers [C-index= 58.5%]) and
hospitalizations (STOPP [C-index=59.8%], 2012 Beers [C-index=59.0%], 2002 Beers
[C-index=58.8%]). Conclusions: All three of the criteria were modestly prognostic
for ADEs, EDs, and hospitalizations with the STOPP criteria slightly outperforming the
Beers criteria. Inappropriate prescribing is common in the elderly and significantly
increases the risk of subsequent hospitalizations, ED visits, and ADEs.
PIH2
Prevalence of Chronic Diseases Among Older Patients (> 65 Years)
in German General Practitioner Practices
Kostev K 1, Rex J 1, Engelhard J 1, Altmann V 1, Jockwig A 2
1IMS Health, Frankfurt am Main, Germany, 2Fresenius University of Applied Sciences, Idstein,
Germany
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In Germany, the share of persons aged >65 years is 21%. Germany therefore has the highest share of older inhabitants compared to other european countries. The aim of the present study was to evaluate the prevalence of defined chronic
diseases among older patients (> 65 years) in German general practitioner (GP) practices. Methods: Data from Disease Analyzer database including 1,100 GPs were used.
2,722,706 patients with at least one consultation in the time between April 2013 and
March 2014 were included and analyzed. Results: Overall, 774,361 (28.4%) of patients
by GPs were over 65 years. In patients aged >65 years 66% were diagnosed with hypertension, 41% with lipid metabolism, 33% with diabetes mellitus, 29% with coronary
heart disease, 20% with rheumatoid arthritis, 19% with cancer, 15% with chronic
obstructive pulmonary disease and 14% with heart insufficiency. Conclusions:
Patients older than 65 years make up 28% and therefore comprise the main client
group of GPs. The prevalence of chronic diseases is in this age very high. On account
of their multimorbidity, the care of these patients is challenging. It is therefore important to place particular emphasis on geriatric patient care as a part of the study of
medicine as well as in physicians assistant degree programs.
PIH3
Current Situation of Paediatric and Adult Patients With Fragile X
Syndrome: Preliminary Data From the Explain Fxs Registry
Haessler F 1, Gaese F 2, Pittrow D 3, Huss M 4, Peters H 4, Kretschmar C 5, Brinkman M 6,
Elstner S 7, Colla M 8
1Klinik für Psychiatrie, Neurologie, Psychosomatik und Psychotherapie im Kindes- und Jugendalter,
Universität Rostock, Rostock, Germany, 2Isar-Amper-Klinikumr gGmbH, Klinikum München-Ost,
Haar, Germany, 3Technical University Carl Gustav Carus, Dresden, Germany, 4RheinhessenFachklinik Mainz, Mainz, Germany, 5Städt. Krankenhaus Dresden-Neustadt, Dresden, Germany,
6Novartis Pharma GmbH, Nuremberg, Germany, 7Evangelisches Krankenhaus Königin Elisabeth
Herzberge gGmbH, Berlin, Germany, 8Charité/ ECRC, Berlin, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The Fragile X syndrome (FXS), caused by a CGG repeat expansion
in the FMR1 gene on the X chromosome, is the most common inherited form of
mental retardation and autism. Representative data on the characteristics and
management of FXS patients in Germany are lacking. Methods: EXPLAIN FXS
is an ongoing prospective longitudinal observational study which evaluates characteristics and management of patients with a genetically confirmed diagnosis of
FXS in ambulatory care. The registry uses a non-probability sampling approach to
collect data on the characteristics, therapeutic drug and non-drug interventions,
psychosocial parameters, quality of life, caregiver burden, and health economic
parameters such as hospitalisation days. Results: After an average 9-month
recruitment period in 10 centres, 33 patients have been included (86% males,
mean age 22 years, age range 2- 82 years). Only 1 and 4 patient attended regular
school, or regular school with integration measures, whereas the others were in
special schools for the mentally impaired. Siblings were affected by FXS in 59%
(10% unknown). On the 6-item FXS disease score by Giangreco (on 25 patients),
the mean value was 6.7 ±2.4 points (range 2.4 to 11.0). Autistic behaviour was
noted in 89%, hyperactivity in 50%, impaired intelligence in 96%. An FXS phenotype was often met, as 63% of patients were described to have a long, narrow
face, and 89% large or prominent ears. Comorbidities were frequent, in particular
anxiety disorders in 65%, ADHD in 61%, impaired social behaviour in 85%, depression in 23%, and seizures in 4%. Medical therapy for comorbidities was often
prescribed. Conclusions: The registry is expected to provide much-needed data
on the characteristics and management situation of FXS patients in Germany, to
allow comparisons with other countries, and to enable gap analyses based on
current guidelines for management of these patients. ClinTrials. gov identifier
is NCT01711606.
PIH4
Feasibility of A Network Meta-Analysis in Endometriosis
van Nooten F E 1, Novak A 2, Langham J 3
1Astellas, Leiden, The Netherlands, 2Anovak-Services, Apeldoorn, The Netherlands, 3PHMR
Associates, London, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To conduct a systematic review of randomised controlled trials
comparing effectiveness of GnRHa in the treatment of endometriosis in order to
assess the feasibility of conducting a meta-analysis and indirect treatment comparison. Methods: Inclusion criteria were all published randomized controlled
trials comparing GnRHa versus any other pharmacological treatment or placebo
in the treatment of laparoscopically confirmed moderate to severe endometriosis.
Electronic databases were searched up to February 2014 (Embase, Medline, Cochrane,
Clintrials. gov and clinical conferences). Search results were screened, eligible studies were assessed for risk of bias and data extracted. Studies were evaluated for
the feasibility of inclusion into a network meta-analysis. Results: A total of 1,670
titles and abstracts were screened. Sixty-nine papers relating to 62 studies were
identified as eligible for inclusion. Fourteen of the 62 were excluded due to high
risk of bias, a further 21 did not present sufficient data. The remaining 27 studies
showed clinical heterogeneity in the measurement of disease severity and efficacy
outcomes and quality of reporting. Efficacy outcomes were measured using various
methods and at different time points (3, 6 to 12 months). All but one measured pain,
12 using modified versions of the Biberoglu and Behrman (B&B), 7 using a similar
method and 4 used a visual analogue scale. Quality of life was measured in 7 studies,
most commonly by a generic HRQoL instrument, the SF-36. Adverse event recording
varied. Conclusions: A core set of studies were identified that could be incorporated into a quantitative analysis assessing effectiveness of GnRHa for treatment of
moderate to severe endometriosis over 6 months. A network meta-analysis would
potentially be feasible using more commonly reported pain outcomes, (modified)
B&B; HRQoL and reported adverse events.
PIH5
The Efficacy of Oximes in Acute Human Organophosphorus
Poisoning; An Updated Meta-Analysis
Abdollahi M 1, Nikfar S 1, Mirfazaelian H 2
University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran, 2Tehran University of Medical Sviences,
Tehran, Iran
.
.
.
1Tehran
Objectives: The present study iims to meta-analyze clinical trials evaluating the
efficacy of oximes on organophosphorus (OP) poisoning treatment. Methods:
PubMed, Scopus, Google Scholar, and clinicaltials. gov were searched for studies
investigating the effects of oximes in the treatment of OP poisoning. Mortality,
intermediate syndrome, intensive care unit (ICU) admission rate, hospital stay duration, and intubation rate were the key outcomes of interest. Data were searched in
the time period of 1966 through December 2013. Results: Thirteen studies (eleven
clinical trials and two historical cohorts) that met our criteria were included in
the analysis. Pooling of data showed that relative risk (RR) of need for intubation
in OP poisoning for eight included trials comparing oximes with placebo was 1.27
with 95% CI= 0.73 to 2.23 (P= 0.4). RR of only one observational study was 1.57 (95%
CI= 0.79 to 3.2, P> 0.05). The summary of RR for mortality rate in 9 studies was 0.38
(95% CI= 0.65 to 2.97, P= 0.41) and for one observational study was 1.33 (95% CI=
0.54 to 3.29, P> 0.05). The RR for ICU admission rate in OP poisoning for three trials
comparing oximes to placebo was2.12 with 95% CI= 0.89 to 5.03 (P= 0.09). For only
one observational study, RR was 0.81 (95% CI= 0.49 to 1.25, P> 0.05). For intermediate
syndrome, while the RR of only trial comparing oximes with placebo was 1.89 (95%
CI= 1.27 to 2.91, P< 0.05), for only one observational study, it was 1.43 (95% CI= 0.7
to 2.96, P> 0.05). For hospital stay duration, the RR of four studies was 0.75 with 95%
CI = -0.51 to 1.99. Conclusions: According to these data, oximes beneficence in
OP poisoning is unclear and there is possible increase in incidence of intermediate
syndrome.
PIH6
labour induction with prostaglandins: what works best? A
systematic review, network meta-analysis and cost-effectiveness
analysis
Keeney E 1, Alfirevic Z 2, Caldwell D M 1, Dowswell T 2, Dias S 1, Jones L 2, Navaratnam K 2,
Welton N J 1
1University of Bristol, Bristol, UK, 2University of Liverpool, Liverpool, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The number of women whose labours are induced is increasing with
average rates in England in excess of 20%. A broad range of methods for induction
are available, including pharmacological, mechanical and alternative interventions
with considerable variation in effectiveness, safety and cost. Of the pharmacological interventions, the most commonly used are prostaglandins. However, even
within this class, there are a variety of different prostaglandins with a variety of
modes of administration. The aim of this piece of work is to identify the most costeffective and safe prostaglandin for cervical ripening and labour induction in the
NHS setting. Methods: A systematic review and network meta-analysis (NMA) of
all relevant randomised trials comparing all prostaglandins for labour induction,
and a cost-effectiveness analysis represented in the form of a decision tree model
incorporating cost and maternal and neonatal health outcomes. Results: The NMA
of randomised controlled trials comparing 11 different types of prostaglandins for
labour induction demonstrated that the best treatment for achieving a vaginal birth
within 24 hours was vaginal misoprostol tablet ≥ 50μ g with a probability of being
A506
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
best of 53%. The safest treatment in terms of caesarean section risk was titrated
(low dose) oral misoprostol solution with a probability of being the best of 63%.
Giving equal weight to both outcomes, titrated low dose oral misoprostol solution
had the best overall outcomes (average rank of 1.5) followed by vaginal misoprostol
≥ 50μ g (average rank of 1.6). Cost and utility data are now being gathered to inform
the cost-effectiveness analysis. Conclusions: The NMA and cost-effectiveness
analysis will be of value to clinicians, pregnant women, guideline developers and
policy makers within the NHS. We will discuss how the model can be extended to
include other types of intervention for induction of labour.
PIH7
Examination of the Efficiency of Electrical Stimulation in Case of
Stress and Urge Incontinence
Oláh A 1, Turnerné Hilmer H 1, Müller Á 1, Knisz J 1, Fullér N 1, Boncz I 2, Pakai A 3,
Stromájer-Rácz T 1
1University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary, 2Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary,
3University of Pécs, Zalaegerszeg, Hungary
.
.
.
.
.
.
care (15.6%), others (12.3%), indigestion (2.9%), energy drinks (2.7%), constipation
(1.9%), antihistamine (0.4%), skin ointments for allergy (0.4%), and skin ointments
except for allergy (0.2%), respectively. Only 5 people (1%) reported side effects after
taking OTC drugs and dietary supplements. The most common reason for buying
OTC medicines and dietary supplements was to choose products they prefer (33.8%);
some participants had taken OTC drugs and dietary supplements for improving
overall health status (19.8%). Also, the use of OTC drugs and dietary supplements
was associated with chronic disease (p=0.034), education level (p<0.001), and household income (p< 0.001), Conclusions: The results demonstrate the prevalence of
OTC use in the elders for more than 3 months is unsubstantial and multivitamins
and dietary supplements are commonly taken by the elderly. In addition, the elders
with chronic diseases, higher income, and/or lower education level are inclined to
take OTC medicines.
.
.
Objectives: Electrical stimulation is one kind of conservative treatment in urinary incontinence. Electrical stimulation can trigger the contraction of pelvic floor
muscles, the functioning of these muscles can be improved, and the strength of
muscle contraction can be increased as well. The aim of this research is to examine
the efficiency of electrical stimulation treatment in case of stress and urge incontinence. Methods: In the course of the examination non-random, purposive sampling was applied. Self-made questionnaires were given to the participants before
and after treatment. Incontinence Impact Questionnaire (IIQ-7) and Urogenital
Distress Inventory (UDI-6) international valid questionnaires were applied to measure life quality. The target group was woman clients between the age of 30-65,
and above 65 years. The examination took place at Kaposi Mór Teaching Hospital,
Somogy County, from 15 February, 2013 to 15 February, 2014. The analysis of results
was performed with MS Excel 2007 program. Results: The research was conducted
with 100 participants. In the course of the examination 45% of the participants
reported improvement after treatment regarding stress incontinence while in case
of urge incontinence only 15% experienced positive change. Due to the treatment
the number of the regular liner users was decreased. The number of users was
75 (75%) before treatments, which reduced to 44 (44%) after treatment. Electrical
stimulation proved to be more efficient in case of stress incontinence than in urge
incontinence. Conclusions: Follow-up of the participants for several months
would give information about the long-term benefits of electrical stimulation. In
the future the improvement of the knowledge of patients on incontinence including
the methods of conservative treatment is important.
PIH11
Identifying Potentially Inappropriate Medication (Pim) and Major
Risk Factors for Hospitalization for Elderly Patients Admitting To
Teaching Hospital: Study From Indian Perspective
Shah C S
SJM college of pharmacy, chitradurga, India
.
.
Objectives: Inappropriate polypharmacy is a particular concern in older people and
is associated with negative health outcomes. Objective of this study was to identify
potentially inappropriate medication (PIM) and major risk factors for hospitalization
in elderly patients. Methods: It was an observational prospective study in semi
government teaching hospital situated in south India (Karnataka). This study was
performed for 3 month and data were collected from elderly patients having age above
60 year who were admitted to medical ward. Results: Current analysis involving
data of 150 (64 % male) elderly in patients with mean (SD) age of 67.9 (8.13) years.
Majority of patients (30 %) were diagnosed with asthma followed by cancer (16 %).
Mean (SD) hospital stay was 15 (5.23) days for cancer followed by 3 (0.77) days for
asthma patients. Total 24 prescriptions were found with PIM as per beer’s criteria
2012. Out of which 50 % of the inappropriate medication found exclusively in asthma
patients. Insulin was reported to be the single most PIM in 25 % of the prescriptions. Conclusions: Asthma was found to be the single most common disease
leads to hospitalization among elder patients. Cancer was found to be the single
common disease which increases hospital stay. Group of patients with asthma were
receiving highest numbers of inappropriate medication compare to other patients.
INDIVIDUAL’S HEALTH – Cost Studies
PIH8
Effects of A Multidisciplinary Home-Based Medication Review
Program On Hospital Admissions In Older Adult Singaporeans
PIH13
Potential Efficency and Cost Savings To the English Nhs By A
Laparoscopic Aproach To Total Abdominal Hysterectomy
Cheen H H M , Ong K Y , Lim S H , Chng S G J , Chen L L , Lim P S , Ng S M , Chang W T
Singapore General Hospital, Singapore
Farrugia M
East Kent University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Margate, England
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The study aimed to (i) evaluate the effectiveness of a multidisciplinary
home-based medication review (HBMR) program in reducing hospital admissions
and (ii) determine the prevalence of drug-related problems (DRP) in older adult
Singaporeans. Methods: A retrospective observational study was conducted at
an academic medical centre in Singapore. Patients referred to the HBMR program
between March 2011 and December 2012 were included. Home visits were conducted
by a team comprising a pharmacist and care coordinators. Frequency of hospital
admissions was determined 6 months before and after HBMR. DRP identified were
categorised and their outcomes (resolved/unresolved) recorded by the pharmacist.
Summary statistics were used to report patient characteristics and prevalence of
DRP. Incidence of hospital admissions was compared using Poisson regression, while
paired t-test was used to compare associated costs (in Singapore dollars) and length
of stay (LOS) before and after HBMR. Results: The analysis included 107 patients
with mean (SD) age of 75.6 (7.6) years. There were 52 (48.6%) males, and 89 (83.2%)
were Chinese. The implementation of the HBMR program resulted in a 41% reduction
in risk for hospital admissions (IRR: 0.59; 95% CI: 0.47 – 0.73, p< 0.001). Mean (SD)
costs of hospital admissions reduced from $16,957.77 ($16,118.35) before HBMR to
$7,488.76 ($12,773.40) after HBMR (p< 0.001). In a subgroup analysis of 62 patients
who had hospital admissions before and after HBMR, mean (SD) LOS decreased
from 26.5 (22.4) days to 17.6 (17.8) days (p= 0.010). The team identified 525 DRP
from 1,353 medications reviewed. Of these, 34 (6.7%) and 174 (34.1%) DRPs were
resolved with and without physician involvement respectively. The most common
DRP identified were failure to receive drug (n= 163, 31.0%) and untreated indication
(n= 140,26.7%). Conclusions: The multidisciplinary HBMR program was effective
in reducing hospital admissions in older adult Singaporeans with multiple DRP.
PIH10
Over the Counter Medication and Dietary Supplements Use Among
Older Adults
Lee H 1, Choi S E 1, Lim J 2, Kang D 1, Lim E A 1, Cheong C 3
1Korea University, Yeongi-gun, South Korea, 2Korea University, Sejong, South Korea, 3Seoul
National University, Seoul, South Korea
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The aim of this study was to examine the prevalence and patterns
of over-the-counter (OTC) medicine and dietary supplements use among older
adults in South Korea for more than 3 months period. Methods: The data were
drawn from the 2009 Korea Health Panel database by selecting 2,910 Koreans aged
65 years or older. Data on self-reported OTC drugs and dietary supplements use
longer than 3 months and demographic characteristics were collected from participants using a questionnaire and multiple logistic analysis was performed to
estimate the factors associated with OTC and dietary supplements use. Results:
424 of 2,910 (14.6%) older adults took at least one OTC medication or dietary supplement. Most frequently used categories of OTC drugs and dietary supplements
were vitamins and dietary supplements (46.9%) followed by analgesics (16.7%), gum
.
Objectives: Hysterectomy is the most common procedure in gynaecology and
carries a very high patient satisfaction rating by patients. As a result, a number of
economic benefits arise, including reduction in average length of stay (LOS), as well
as readmission and surgical site infection rates using a minimally invasive route.
The cost savings and efficiency gains accrued to the English NHS are presented in
the form of a budget impact model. Methods: A budget impact model (BIM) was
developed in order to compare the costs of two treatment strategies – total abdominal hysterectomy (TAH) and total laparoscopic hysterectomy (TLH). Micro-costing
data was obtained from EKHUFT for a subset of TAH and TLH procedures. The latter
was extrapolated at the National level using OPCS-level Hospital Episode Statistic
(HES) in order to calculate cost and efficiency savings vis-à-vis average LOS and
readmissions. This calculation relies on a conservative increase in laparoscopic
adoption from 22 to 30%. Results: In 2013, 25,548 TAH procedures were carried
out compared to 5,611 TLH. The LOS was 3.6 days for TAH compared to 1.3 days for
TLH. The readmission rates are significantly higher for TAH at 1.64/1000 procedures
compared to 0.18/1000 for TLH. The estimated savings on increasing the TLH rate
nationally by 8% will free 4000 patient days. On taking into account the lower readmission rate, lower LOS and potential income from additional procedures carried
out from additional bed availability, the micro-costing of the procedure shows an
overall financial benefit to the NHS. Conclusions: A increase in the laparoscopic
approach to hysterectomy by 8% will result is significant economic benefits for the
English health service. This study confirmed the reduced LOS, with a lower readmission rate following the laparoscopic approach. The budget impact of the calculated
increase in costs of TLH can be absorbed within tariff.
PIH14
Economic Assessment of Preeclampsia: Screening, Diagnosis,
Treatment Options, and Long Term Outcomes, A Systematic Review
Zakiyah N 1, van Asselt A 1, Baker P 2, Postma M J 1
1University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands, 2Gravida: National Centre for Growth and
Development, The University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To provide a comprehensive overview of the existing evidence on
the health economics of screening, diagnosis, and treatment options in preeclampsia. Methods: A systematic literature search was undertaken using three
electronic databases (MEDLINE, Embase, Cochrane) to identify all English language
full papers published between 1994 and 2014 containing economic evaluation or
budget impact analysis (BIA) studies concerning the screening, diagnosis, treatment
and prevention of preeclampsia. In addition, the included studies were appraised
by means of the Consolidated Health Economic Evaluation Reporting Standards
(CHEERS) statement and the guidelines on reporting format for budget impact
analysis (ISPOR Principles of Good practice for Budget Impact Analysis). Results:
From an initial total of 119 citations, six papers fulfilled the eligibility criteria, five
of which were economic evaluations and one was a BIA. All studies were published
A507
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
between 2001 and 2012. One study was on early screening using maternal markers,
and concluded that this may be cost-effective from a payer perspective. Three other
studies focused on treatment and management, and concluded that induction of
delivery is the most cost-effective option in term preeclampsia. Also, magnesium
sulphate was found to be a cost-effective treatment, but more so in low income
countries. One study was a comprehensive HTA report on combination strategies
of screening and prevention, which found that providing calcium to all pregnant
women without prior testing was the most cost-effective strategy. The BIA, on introducing a novel diagnostic test, concluded that the savings associated with this test
would offset its initial cost. Conclusions: Novel biomarkers in screening for and
diagnosing preeclampsia show promise as a cost-effective approach, from a payer
perspective. Moreover, magnesium sulphate seemed to be a cost-effective option
to manage seizures in preeclamptic women while delivery remains the ultimate
efficient treatment, especially for women with term preeclampsia.
PIH15
Price Variation in Obstetrical Services in A Rural State
Erten M Z , Phillips J , Jones C , Kappel S , Meyer M
University of Vermont - College of Medicine, Burlington, VT, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To determine and quantify the level of price variation in inpatient care
for obstetrical services across hospitals in the State of Vermont, USA. Methods:
We used data from Vermont Healthcare Claims Uniform Reporting and Evaluation
System (VHCURES) for the calendar year 2012. We generated single-line summaries
for all inpatient obstetrical services with an admission date in 2012. We excluded
records for Medicaid, secondary payments either to Medicare or another commercial insurance, denied claims, non-VT resident claims and adjustments to existing
claims. This produced a total of 4,019 records for the evaluated services from 13
Vermont hospitals. We calculated the allowed amount for each Diagnosis Related
Group (DRG) (total amount a hospital received from a payer, including any prepaid
amounts related to the service, plus the amount due from a patient through copayment, co-insurance and deductible). The outcome of interest is the average price
of a specific DRG at each hospital as a percent of group average price in Vermont
Hospitals. To reflect patient severity we adjusted prices by case-mix. Results were
generated for hospitals only when there were at least 10 discharges in a specific
hospital. Results: The average prices for a vaginal delivery with complicating diagnoses varied between 66% to 156% of the group average, vaginal delivery without
complicating diagnoses varied between 74% to 182%, neonate with other significant
problems varied between 60% to 206% and normal newborn varied between 77% to
180%. Conclusions: There is wide variation in payments for obstetrical services
across Vermont hospitals. Further analysis is necessary to understand the role of
various factors that contribute to this variation. During this transition period to a
single-payer system in the rural state of Vermont, policy makers will need evidencebased information to ensure undiminished access to care in obstetrical services.
PIH16
Malnutrition in Institutionalized and Community-Dwelling
Older Adults in Spain: Estimates of Its Costs To the National
Health System
Rodríguez-Mañas L 1, Abizanda P 2, Barcons N 3, Lizán L 4
1Getafe University Hospital, Madrid, Spain, 2Complejo Hospitalario Universitario de Albacete,
Albacete, Spain, 3Nestlé Health Science, Barcelona, Spain, 4Outcomes 10, Castellon, Spain
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate the economic impact of malnutrition on annual direct
cost in Spanish institutionalized or community-dwelling older adults. Methods:
A systematic review was carried out on the economic burden and use of medical resources associated with malnutrition in institutionalized or communitydwelling older adults. National and international databases until December 2013
were searched. Based on results from the literature review, an Excel-based tool
was developed to estimate the annual cost difference between malnourished and
well-nourished institutionalized and community-dwelling older adults in Spain.
Malnutrition prevalence, annual frequency of general practitioner (GP) visits and
hospitalizations were the main inputs considered in the model. Unit costs were
derived from health care cost databases available in Spain (Euros, 2014). One-way
sensitivity analysis (OWSA) was performed. Results: The results of the systematic
review showed that malnutrition implies higher medical costs in the study population, particularly due to the length of hospital stay, number of hospital admissions
and GP visits. Economic results showed that the annual cost associated with the
use of resources of a malnourished patient (€ 5,000.66) was 3.5 times higher than
that of a well-nourished (€ 1,433.78). OWSA showed that prevalence of malnutrition
was the variable with the greatest impact on results. Decreasing the prevalence
of malnutrition according to minimum values identified in the literature (from
15.6% and 4.4%, to 2% and 3% in institutionalized and community-dwelling patients
respectively), caused the annual cost per patient with malnutrition to drop from
€ 5,000.66 to € 2,511.83, while increasing it to the maximum values (62% and 23%,
respectively), implied a rise from € 5,000.66 to € 24,291.93 in the annual cost per
patient. Conclusions: Adopting measures to reduce the prevalence of malnutrition in institutionalized or community-dwelling older adults would reduce by
up to 50% the annual cost per patient associated to GP visits and hospitalizations.
PIH17
The Prevalence and Cost of Illness in Women With Endometriosis
in Ukraine
Piniazhko O 1, Zalis’ka O 1, Vernikovskyy I 2
Halytsky Lviv National Medical University, Lviv, Ukraine, 2Lviv Regional Perinatal Center,
Lviv, Ukraine
.
.
.
establishing now in Ukraine. Methods: We performed a retrospective analysis of the real data from 450 medical records of patients who were treated
in a Lviv Regional Perinatal Center in 2013. The results of our previous study of
treatment cost of endometriosis in Ukraine were used (Zalis’ka O., Piniazhko O.
et al. 2014). We used the prices from Ukrainian database of Morion company
(Kiev) on 01.06.2014 (1 EUR = 16,04 UAH). Results: According to the analysis
70% of women with endometriosis choose treatment hormones with the duration of six month usually and 30% of patients undergo surgical treatment.
Annual direct cost of endometriosis per patient varies from € 224 to € 487 depending
on the chosen scheme of pharmacotherapy, which differences 2 times. Accordingly,
costs correlated with clinical severity and patient’s financial position and ability to
pay. Based on the data of State Statistics Service of Ukraine, we estimated that the
number of women of reproductive age in Ukraine was 14,7 million in 2013. Therefore
when to extrapolate data the number of women with endometriosis could amount
approximately 1,47 million and 1,03 million women would take pharmacotherapy
instead of surgery. The annual cost of treatment hormones of endometriosis could
amount from €230,5 million to €501,6 million. Conclusions: The economic burden
of endometriosis in Ukraine demonstrates a significant need in the optimization of
the management of this disease within the introduction of health insurance system
and health technology assessment of the applicable hormones.
PIH18
Burden and Cost of Multiple Chronic Diseases in A Large Cohort of
Elderly in Italy
Rossi E , Cinconze E , De Rosa M
CINECA Interuniversity Consortium, Casalecchio di Reno, Italy
.
.
.
Objectives: Life expectancy in Italy is constantly increasing (+2,4 years for men and
+1,7 years for women from 2001 to 2011) with a consequent effect on health needs
and expenditure. Furthermore, on overall population, 21% has one chronic disease,
9,3% two and 8% more than three. The aim of this study is to evaluate the burden
of multiple chronic diseases and associated costs in a large community setting
of Italian elderly population, starting from Cineca ARNO Observatory. Methods:
ARNO Observatory is a comprehensive population-based database which integrates
since 1987 administrative data from Local Health Units to monitor health data
in the real world. On a population of 10,5 millions of inhabitants we selected a
cohort of 2.166.000 (21%) subjects over 65 years. Outpatient drug prescriptions, inpatient hospital discharges, diagnostic, lab tests prescriptions were analyzed during
2012 to evaluate chronic diseases, multiple chronic conditions and illness direct
costs. Results: From selected cohort, 82,5% has at least one chronic disease and
this proportion rises up to 89,6% in over 80s. Hypertension is the most common
disease (67%), followed by dyslipidemia (30%) and diabetes (18%). Over 50% of elderly
has multiple chronic diseases but the risk of developing concomitant chronic illnesses rises with ages (60% of people aged > = 85 have comorbidities). Integration
of administrative data led to the evaluation of cost of illness which varies from
2.528€ for hypertension to 13.613€ for Acute Coronary Syndrome; the average cost of
patients with 2 or more comorbidities is twice than patients with only one chronic
disease. In general, more than a half of cost is due to hospitalization (57%), 27% to
drugs and 16% to diagnostic exams (16%). Conclusions: Analyses of real world
data represent an effective tool for the evaluation of elderly population diseases
and can be a valid instrument to support clinical governance.
PIH19
Epidemiological and Financial Burden of Preterm Labor
Hospitalizations – An Analysis of German Claims Data
Wetzka S 1, Fleßa S 1, Lange A 2, Zygmunt M 3
1Department of Health Care Management, Faculty of Law and Economics, Ernst-Moritz-ArndtUniversity Greifswald, Greifswald, Germany, 2Department of Neonatology and Pediatric Intensive
Care, Hospital for Pediatrics, University of Greifswald, Greifswald, Germany, 3Department of
Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Greifswald, Greifswald, Germany
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Preterm Labor (PTL) in pregnant women is a common obstetrics inpatient diagnosis. It is important to differentiate between threatened PTL associated
with potentially avoidable hospitalization and PTL resulting in a preterm birth (PTB)
with respect to their burden to the health care system. The prevention and diagnostic-driven reduction of such hospital admissions for observational reasons are
supposed to reduce costs. The aim is to analyze the epidemiological and financial
impact of programs to prevent avoidable hospital admissions due to threatened
PTL. Methods: A cohort of singletons at the University hospital Greifswald with
PTL-related hospital admissions prior to birth was analyzed with respect to resource
use and obstetrics outcomes. This bottom-up analysis was conducted from the
perspective of the statutory health care system based on accounting information
claims from the hospital`s database for the period 2007 to 2012. ICD-10 codes were
used to identify the study population. All costs were inflated to 2012 using the
German GDP index. Results: Out of 4,408 singleton births, potentially avoidable
hospital admissions were found in 248 cases (5.6 %). In this subgroup, 17 infants
were delivered preterm (avg. 34.8 weeks), resulting in a PTB rate of 6.9 % compared
to a general rate of 8.7 % in Germany. These hospitalizations led to average costs of
about 1,600 EUR per case (min. 300 EUR; max. 5,600 EUR). Conclusions: Although
threatened PTL affects one singleton pregnancy in 20, the fraction of costs resulting from observational admissions associated with threatened PTL is less than 0.7
percent compared to the total department costs. This finding conflicts with the
cost-saving potential of prevention programs (e. g. pH self-assessment) suggested
in the literature.
1Danylo
Objectives: Endometriosis affects 10% of women of reproductive age and WERF
EndoCost study has recently shown that it imposes substantial economic burden
on society through the reduced economic and personal productivity. The aim of
the study was to estimate the prevalence of endometriosis and the cost of illness from the payer’s perspective in Ukraine as the model of health insurance is
PIH20
Incidence and Long-Term Cost of Oral Steroid-Related Adverse
Events in Chronic Diseases in Poland
Garbacka M 1, Zapalska A 1, Borowiack E 1, Tronczyñska D 2, Wepsiec K 2, Dziurda D 2,
Krzyzanowska A 2
1NUEVO HTA CLP, Cracow, Poland, 2GlaxoSmithKline, Warsaw, Poland
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A508
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: Although the relationship between use of glucocorticoids (GC) and
occurrence of adverse events (AE) is widely acknowledged, the estimation of risk
size of specific AE is still imprecise. The aim of study was to quantify the incidence
and economic cost of selected steroid-related AE in GC-users regardless of baseline
chronic disease. Methods: Review of the available data about the consequences
of long-term use of oral GC (depending on prednisone or its equivalent dose and
period of use) was conducted. From 162 full-text publications (10024 abstracts),
four with mixed population and > 5 years median follow–up were valuable. Hip
fracture (HFr), cataract (CAT) and diabetes mellitus (DM) were chosen as the common and most cost generating AE connected with oral GC treatment. A Markov
model with a lifetime horizon (30 years) was developed to forecast incidence
and health care cost of three regimen (non-GC, low dose GC < 2.5 mg, high dose
GC > 7.5 mg). Direct medical costs were included in the analysis. Results: For a
lifetime horizon the incidence of HFr, CAT and DM increased from 0.77% to 5.49%,
23.48% to 91.04% and 12.34% to 17.02% (7.1, 3.9, 1.4 fold increase) respectively for
comparison non-GC versus high dose GC. For selected cohort of 1,000 you need to
treat 34, 2, 22 patients respectively (low dose GC instead of high dose GC) to prevent
one additional case of HFr, CAT, DM. Shorter duration of steroid therapy (5 years)
provide two Quality-Adjusted Life Months gained (per one patient) and leads to
2,230, 35,460, 6,920 avoided cases of HFr, CAT, DM (per 100,000 cohort). The use
of low-dose or non-GC is cost-effective strategy (total cost per patient 2,958 PLN,
1,301 PLN, respectively) compared with high-dose GC (10,823 PLN). Conclusions:
Oral GC treatment can lead to dose-dependent increase in the risk of selected AE.
PIH21
Potentially Inappropriate Medication in the Elderly – Relevance
and Economics of the 30 Top-Selling Priscus Agents in Germany
Pohl-Dernick K 1, Meier F 1, Maas R 2, Schöffski O 1, Emmert M 1
1Friedrich-Alexander University Erlangen-Nürnberg, Nuremberg, Germany, 2Friedrich-Alexander
University Erlangen-Nürnberg, Erlangen, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Some drugs increase risk for adverse effects in elderly patients.
Accordingly, lists of potentially inappropriate medication (PIM) that should be
avoided in elderly patients have been proposed. In 2010 an expert panel published
a PIM list adapted to the German drug market (PRISCUS-list) which lists 83 inappropriate agents and their recommended surrogates. This study calculates the amount
of drug reimbursement of PIM and the potential saving using appropriate surrogates
recommended by the PRISCUS list from the perspective of statutory health insurance (SHI). Methods: Data was provided by AOK Research Institute (WIdO). Study
material consists of a register extraction of the top 30 drugs (by sales) on PRISCUSlist in 2009 for patients ≥ 65 years of the entire SHI-population. We calculated the
percentage of sales and defined daily doses (DDD) for patients ≥ 65 compared to
the total SHI-population. Costs for the recommended substitution were estimated
by different scenarios. Results: In 2009, the proportion of the top 30 drugs on
the PRISCUS-list that were prescribed to patients ≥ 65 was 58.2%. Sotalol was the
drug with the largest proportion of DDD prescribed to patients ≥ 65 (92.9%). Drug
reimbursement for the top 30 PIM medications prescribed to patients ≥ 65 were
€ 305.7 million (54.3% of total reimbursement). Reimbursement for Solifenacin was
highest with € 32.5 million. Prescription of the surrogates would lead to increasing
costs for the German health care system. Those were calculated to range between
€ 325.9 million and € 810.0 million. Conclusions: This is the first study assessing
the economic burden of PIM according to PRISCUS-list in Germany. The results show
that a more appropriate medication for the elderly comes along with additional
costs. For a final evaluation of relevance and economics of PIM, costs of adverse
drug events caused by PIM and clinical feasibility of substitution have to be taken
into consideration.
PIH22
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Use of Dydrogesterone in
Premenstrual Syndrome
Kolbin A , Vilum I , Kurylev A , Balykina Y , Proskurin M
Saint Petersburg State University, Saint Petersburg, Russia
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The primary objective of the study was the analysis of pharmacoeconomic expediency of administration of dydrogesterone (Duphaston®) for
premenstrual syndrome (PMS) treatment in comparison with micronized progesterone (Utrogestan®). Methods: The mathematical modeling with dydrogesterone or micronized progesterone was applied in the study. For the calculation
of the efficacy data of clinical trials were used. Costs were calculated on the basis
of Russian prices (grls. rosminzdrav. ru). The model was constructed as following: for each branch of the decision tree, cost and efficacy for a group of 100
patients (female aged 18 – 45 years) and per patient were analyzed. Modeling
duration was 3 months (therapy during three cycles). The cost-effectiveness ratio
(CER) and incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICERs) were calculated. Results
were evaluated to cost-effectiveness threshold. Efficiency was estimated on
the basis of clinical trials (effectiveness). Calculation of cost included: the cost
of drugs administration course; costs of consultative and diagnostic appointments of the gynecologist; the cost of inefficient therapy – costs of additional
diagnostic examination. The comprehensive sensitivity analysis was performed. Results: The cost of the total course of therapy with dydrogesterone
was more expensive in comparison with micronized progesterone – 84,1 EUR
against 82,6 EUR. Strategy of administration of dydrogesterone showed more
efficiency in comparison with micronized progesteron (8% increase of effectiveness). CER for dydrogesterone and micronized progesterone were 115.20 and
127.07 respectively. The ICER was 18.75 Eur per patient that is much lower than
a cost-effectiveness threshold in Russia (27922.8 EUR). The sensitivity analysis
confirmed conclusions of the main scenario. Conclusions: The strategy of administration of dydrogesterone in PMS is economically expedient
from the point of view of cost-effectiveness ratio. In addition, increase of effectiveness was noted for use of dydrogesterone. The study was conducted at Abbott
support.
PIH23
Cost-Benefit Model of Varying Nexplanon and Other Long-Acting
Reversible Contraceptive (Larc) Methods: Uptake Compared to the
Oral Contraceptive Pill: UK Perspective
Praet C , D’Oca K
Merck Sharp and Dohme Ltd, Hoddesdon, UK
.
.
Objectives: Cost is considered one of the major barriers to greater use of LARC
(Long-Acting Reversible Contraceptive) methods, especially cost of treatment initiation. However, when considering their contraceptive efficacy alongside cost of pregnancy, LARC methods are deemed by NICE to be more cost-effective than combined
oral contraceptive pills even at one year of use. (NICE LARC CG30 2005). Methods:
A 3 year time-horizon cost-benefit model was developed to assess budgetary impact
of increasing LARC uptake (implant, IUD, IUS and injectable) compared to the oral
contraceptive pill, in UK women aged 16-49 who currently use the following contraceptives of interest: non-LARC method (defined as contraceptive pill only) or
LARC methods (IUD, IUS, injectable, implant). A weighted-average price based on
current market shares was calculated, for all contraceptive pills currently available
in the UK. Increased uptake of any LARC method was offset against a reduction in
contraceptive pill usage. Unintended pregnancies, based on typical failure rate,
occurring with all treatments considered was taken into account. Results: Of
approximately 14,750,000 women aged 16-49 in the UK, official statistics confirm
37% use contraceptive methods of interest to our model. This proportion formed
our cohort of approximately 5,500,000 UK women aged 16-49, which was followed
over a 3 year time horizon. A 100% increase in uptake of each LARC method would
lead to a 49% decrease in oral contraceptive pill uptake. Over a three year period
this would save 374,794 unintended pregnancies, and elicit financial savings of
£630,831,022, on which £54,098,847 is attributable to treatment costs (ingredient,
consultations, removal/insertion costs) and £576,732,175 to the cost of unintended
pregnancies (live birth, miscarriage, abortion, ectopic pregnancy). Conclusions:
The model projects that increasing LARC uptake will result in a significant reduction in the number of unintended pregnancies, with consequent savings to the
NHS across the UK.
PIH24
Misoprostol Vaginal Insert Pharmacoeconomic Model for 5
European Countries
Walczak J 1, Bierut A 2, Dowgiallo J 2, Pacocha K 1, Pieniazek I 1, Stelmachowski J 1, Opala T 3,
Sobkowski M 3, Baev O 4
1Arcana Institute, Krakow, Poland, 2Ferring Pharmaceuticals Poland Sp. z o. o., Warsaw, Poland,
3Ginekologiczno-Polozniczy Szpital Kliniczny Uniwersytetu Medycznego im. K. Marcinkowskiego
w Poznaniu, Poznan, Poland, 4Federal State Budget Institution “Research Center for Obstetrics,
Gynecology and Perinatology” Ministry of Healthcare and Social Development of the Russian
Federation, Moscow, Russia
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Our aim was to assess the costs and consequences of labour induction
using misoprostol vaginal insert (MVI) compared with currently used technologies
using a specifically developed user-friendly decision model developed for Austria,
Poland, Romania, Russia and Slovakia. Methods: The model was developed in
Microsoft Office Excel and compares clinical and safety aspects like time to vaginal
delivery, time to active labour, occurrence of cesarean delivery and adverse events
of MVI with selected comparators. Efficacy and safety data were retrieved from targeted literature review, conducted in the main medical databases. Country-specific
information about costs and resource use was incorporated into the model. Local
data were collected for each country via a specifically developed questionnaire. The
model considered the hospital and public payer perspectives. The model generated results as an incremental difference between the total costs related to labour
induction with MVI or a comparator. The threshold price of MVI was also calculated. Results: Local Key Opinion Leaders recommended the following comparators: dinoprostone vaginal insert (DVI; Austria), dinoprostone vaginal tablets (Dtab;
Austria, Slovakia), dinoprostone cervical gel (Dgel; Poland, Russia, Slovakia) and
oxytocin (Austria, Poland, Romania, Russia). The hospital perspective was chosen
as default (additionally the public payer perspective was adopted for 2 countries).
The use of MVI in most scenarios is related to a reduction in time consumption of
hospital staff and in the length of patients’ stay in hospital wards. MVI was less
costly or marginally more expensive in 80% of cases. Conclusions: Induction of
labour with the use of MVI using a hospital perspective, brought savings in most
countries and scenarios in comparison to other prostaglandins (DVI, Dtab, Dgel).
PIH25
Cost Effectiveness Analysis of A Vaccination Programme for the
Prevention of Herpes Zoster and Post-Herpetic Neuralgia in Adults
Aged 65 and Over in Norway
Suseg P 1, Olsen D 2, Préaud E 3, Uhart M 3
1LINK Medical Research AS, Oslo, Norway, 2SPMSD, Drammen, Norway, 3Sanofi Pasteur MSD,
Lyon, France
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Herpes Zoster is a very painful and debilitating disease for which no
satisfactory treatment exist. A vaccine is licensed in Europe for the prevention of
Herpes Zoster (HZ) and postherpetic neuralgia (PHN) in adults aged ≥ 50 years and
is recommended in France and UK. The objective of this study was to assess the
cost-effectiveness of vaccination programs in people aged 65 years and over in
Norway. Methods: An existing European Markov cohort Model was adapted to
the Norwegian health care setting. Health states considered are healthy, HZ, PHN,
healthy post-HZ and death. HZ and PHN states are further split by pain severity
(mild, moderate or severe). A vaccine efficacy durability model based on the pivotal
trial data was included to simulate waning in the efficacy. The cost-effectiveness
outcomes were assessed from both the third party payer and the societal perspective. First, analysis comparing a HZ vaccination policy for adults aged ≥ 65 years with
a no vaccination policy was done. Then, analysis comparing vaccination policies
of 5-years age class cohorts (from 65 to 100 years old) to a no vaccination policy
were conducted. Input data were obtained from Norwegian sources whenever avail-
A509
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
able. Results: The strategy of vaccinating people over 65 yo showed incremental cost-effectiveness ratios of 41,467€ /QALY gained from a payer perspective and
40,733€ /QALY from a societal perspective. The analysis by age group showed that
the ICER is age-dependent, the lowest ICER (30,780€ /QALY in both perspectives)
having been found in the cohort 70-74 years old. In sensitivity analyses data on
the duration of PHN, utilities and vaccine efficacy duration showed a major impact
on the results. Conclusions: Our cost-effectiveness analysis shows that a HZ
vaccination policy for adults aged ≥ 65 years in Norway could be cost-effective and
provide substantial public health benefits in the Norwegian health care system.
PIH26
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Surgical Management of Stress
Urinary Incontinence With Single-Incision Mini-Sling Versus
Tension-Free Vaginal Obturator in Spain
Castañeda E 1, Sanz-Granda Á 2, Hidalgo A 2, Meza D F 1, Marqueta J M 1, Carreras M 1
de Palamós, Palamós, Girona, Spain, 2Weber, Economía y Salud, Majadahonda,
Madrid, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Hospital
Objectives: To analyze the cost effectiveness of surgical management of stress
urinary incontinence (SUI) in women with single-incision mini-sling (SIMS) compared with tension-free vaginal obturator (TVT-O) Methods: A cost-effectiveness
analysis based on the results of interventions performed with TVT-O (2005-2008)
and SIMS (2008-2011) in women with a diagnosis of SUI was performed. The clinical effectiveness was defined as an objective cure at 12 months (pad-test < 1 g/h).
A perspective of the hospital payer was adopted; therefore, only direct health care
costs (diagnostic and surgical procedures, medical devices, medications, hospital
stay times and staff) were included. CI95% of total cost was estimated by bootstrapping; later, different sensitivity analyses were conducted Results: Procedures
were carried out in 81 women (44 in the SIMS group and 37 in the TVT-O). A small
difference (6.7%) in clinical effectiveness was observed in favour of SIMS, however,
it was not statistically significant (SIMS: 93.2% and TVT-O: 86.5%). The total annual
cost per patient with SIS was lower (2,059€ ; CI95%: 1,914-2,285) than with TVT-O
(2,821€ ; CI95%: 2,661-2,997), showing a statistically significant cost saving of 762€
(CI95%: 516-987). In the base case, the probability of SIMS is less costly than TVT-O
was 100%. The sensitivity analysis showed that the cost determinant was the length
of the hospital stay, observing that an equivalent cost was only achieved if there
was no cause for any hospital stay with TVT-O. Conclusions: The use of singleincision mini-sling is associated with an comparable clinical effectiveness but with
a 762€ per patient reduction of the average annual cost, compared to tension-free
vaginal obturator. Therefore, the results suggest that, over a post-operative period
of twelve months, tension-free tape single-incision mini-sling is a dominant alternative to tension-free vaginal obturator because of a lower cost and a comparable
effectiveness.
PIH27
A Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Different Types of Labor for
Singleton Pregnancy – Real Life Data
Lakic D 1, Tadic I 1, Odalovic M 1, Petrovic B 2, Petrova G 3
1University of Belgrade Faculty of Pharmacy, Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro, 2University
Hospital for Gynecology and Obstetrics “Narodni Front”, Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro,
3Medical University Sofia, Faculty of Pharmacy, Sofia, Bulgaria
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess cost, clinical outcomes and cost-effectiveness of different
types of labor in singleton pregnancies. Methods: A decision model was used
to compare vaginal labor, induced labor and planned cesarean section. All data
were taken from the Book of Labor from the University Hospital for Gynecology
and Obstetrics “Narodni Front” in Serbia, for labors conducted during one month
period in 2011. Successful delivery, (i. e. labor that began up to 42 gestation weeks,
without maternal mortality and the newborn Apgar scores greater than or equal
to seven in the first and fifth minute of life) was considered as the outcome of the
cost effectiveness analysis. To test the robustness of this definition probabilistic
sensitivity analysis was performed. Results: From a total of 667 births, vaginal
labor was conducted in 98 cases, induced vaginal in 442, while planned caesarean
section was performed 127 times. Emergency caesarean section as a complication
was much higher in the vaginal labor cohort compared to the induced vaginal
cohort (OR = 17.374, 95% CI: 8.522 to 35.418, p < 0.001). The least costly type of labor
was induced vaginal labor: average cost 461 euro, with an effectiveness of 98.17%.
Both, vaginal and planned cesarean labor, were dominated by the induced labor.
The results were robust. Conclusions: Elective induction of labor was associated
with the lowest cost compared to other types of labor, with favorable maternal and
neonatal outcomes.
PIH28
Cost Effectiveness of Pentavalent Rotavirus Vaccine (Rv5)
in Slovenia
Gebremeskel B G 1, Pokorn M 2, Zakotnik B 2, O’Brien M A 3
1Merck & Co., Inc/Rutgers University, West Point, PA, USA, 2University Medical Centre Ljubljana,
Ljubljana, Slovenia, 3Merck & Co, Inc., West Point, PA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess the potential impact of universal vaccination with RV5 on
health care burden and costs associated with rotavirus gastroenteritis (RGE) among
a hypothetical birth cohort of 21,938 Slovenian children in their first five years of
life Methods: A Markov model was used to evaluate the cost per quality-adjustedlife-year (QALY) and public health impact of vaccination with RV5 from the health
care payer and societal perspectives. The base case assumes three dose coverage
rate of 94% at 2, 4 and 6 months among the vaccinated, the remaining receiving 1
or 2 doses. In the absence of universal vaccination 819 hospitalizations and 3,276
office visits were projected to occur in the first 5 years of life. RGE associated costs
include direct and indirect costs associated with parental work loss. The efficacy
of RV5 in reducing health care resource utilization is based on the results of the
Rotavirus Efficacy and Safety Trial (REST). Results: A universal RV5 vaccination
program is projected to reduce hospitalizations, office visits and parental work
loss by 94, 76 and 87% respectively. The cost per case avoided would be 165 Euros,
and cost per hospitalization avoided would be 1,639 Euros with implementation of
universal vaccination. The cost per QALY saved would be 29,452 Euros and 20,453
Euros from the health care and societal perspectives respectively. Conclusions:
RV5 is projected to avert substantial number of RGE hospitalizations and office visits in Slovenia and would be considered a cost effective intervention. KEYWORDS:
rotavirus vaccine, cost effectiveness, QALY.
PIH29
Health Economic Model On the Costs and Effects of Rotavirus
Vaccination in Romania
Preda A L 1, Moise M 1, Standaert B 2
1GlaxoSmithKline, Bucharest, Romania, 2GlaxoSmithKline Vaccines, Wavre, Belgium
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Rotavirus gastroenteritis (RVGE) is one of the most frequent diseases in
children less than 5 years old. Today, no recommendation for general rotavirus vaccination exists in Romania, which leads to a vaccination coverage rate of < 8%. We
model whether the strategy of “Universal Mass Vaccination” should be cost-effective
from the Social Health Insurance Fund (SHIF) perspective. Methods: We adapted
an already published simple model to estimate the cost-effectiveness of rotavirus
vaccination in Romania. It helps identifying the drivers of the economic analysis in
a birth cohort of 194,411 children (Romania 2012) followed over a period of 5 years.
In the model, vaccine efficacy results from international clinical trials are combined
with Romanian epidemiology and cost data from the SHIF perspective for 2012. The
model assumes a theoretical vaccination rate of 100% and uses discount rates of 3%
on costs and effects. Results are tested on their robustness using univariate sensitivity analysis. Results: The model predicts that a two-dose rotavirus vaccine could
avoid around 82,581 mild, 51,328 moderate and 3,075 severe RVGE cases. Moderate
and severe events are associated with physician visits and hospital stays respectively.
These also lead to a total cost saving of € 2.4 million for indirect cost estimates.
The main factors responsible for the savings are the reduction in hospital stays, in
productivity losses of parents and in medical visits. Sensitivity analysis indicates
the importance of good epidemiological data and cost numbers on productivity
loss. Conclusions: General vaccination against rotavirus could avoid many of the
severe diarrhea events in children less than 5 years old in Romania. Depending on the
price per course, the vaccination strategy will lead to societal cost gain.
PIH30
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Coffee Consumption for Prevention
of All-Cause Mortality in Germany
Drees L 1, Theidel U 1, Campbell C M 2, Popelar B V 2, O’Day K 2, Mittendorf T 1
GmbH, Hannover, Germany, 2Xcenda, LLC, Palm Harbor, FL, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Herescon
Objectives: Coffee contains over 1,000 distinct molecular compounds and is one
of the most widely consumed beverages worldwide. Epidemiologic studies have
shown an inverse relationship between coffee consumption and all-cause mortality. This analysis aims to assess the cost-effectiveness of coffee from a blended
German consumer and payer perspective. Methods: An existing decision-analytic
model was adapted with German data. A cohort life-table analysis was developed
to model life-years (LYs) of German coffee consumers vs. non-consumers over a
lifetime horizon. Age- and gender-specific mortality rates were used to model survival outcomes. Relative risks of death by average coffee intake (cups/day) were
obtained from a recent large, prospective cohort study. Cost were considered for
cost per cup (home prepared and from a national sample of low and high-cost
vendors) and for health care. Incremental analyses were conducted by cost, sex,
and level of daily coffee consumption. Deterministic and probabilistic sensitivity
analysis was performed. Results: Coffee increased undiscounted LYs in 1, 2-3,
4-5, and 6+ cup/day male (0.65, 1.10, 1.33 and 1.10) and female (0.45, 1.21, 1.51, 1.41)
consumers, respectively, versus non-consumers. ICERs per undiscounted LY gained
were € 3,938/ € 7,047/ € 16,271 for males and € 5,514/ € 5,066/ € 13,537 for females,
respectively, for 1, 2-3, and 4-5 cups/day consumption of home-prepared coffee;
≥ 6 cups/day was strictly dominated. Consumption of 4-5 cups per day purchased
from high-cost vendors was not cost-effective (male: € 168,780/ female: € 135,636).
Results were consistent throughout the sensitivity analyses, whereas coffee effectiveness in preventing death and coffee acquisition cost has the largest impact on
ICERs. Conclusions: In this analysis, coffee consumption was associated with
increased LYs and was shown to be potentially cost-effective, especially if homeprepared or purchased from low-cost vendors. Given the observational nature of the
study data, further research is warranted to validate these findings.
PIH31
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Screening Syphilis Among
Pregnant Women
Chuluunbaatar E
National Yang Ming University, Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia
.
Objectives: Maternal and congenital syphilis prevalence rates are currently rapidly
increasing in Mongolia. On-Site screening and same-day treatment for syphilis
in pregnancy prevents greater numbers of congenital syphilis and its complications. The Ministry of Health has been implementing on-site rapid screening test
(RT) intervention and same day treatment approach for maternal syphilis with
the contribution of the World Health Organization. Objective of the study was to
understand the cost- effectiveness (CE) of screening antenatal syphilis using the
RT strategy, to compare this intervention with RPR testing strategy. And in order to
estimate CE we found out maternal syphilis prevalence. Methods: Ingredientsbased cost data and epidemiological data were collected retrospectively from the
pregnancy medical records. Decision analysis was used to estimate the incremental
CE of on-site PT compared to the current practice, off-site PRP/TPHA. Descriptive
analysis has done for prevalence of syphilis, and economic analysis has done to
calculate costs. Stability of cost-effectiveness ratios were evaluated by the univariate
sensitivity analysis. Results: With antenatal syphilis prevalence of 3.0% (1.46%
in urban and 5.7% in sub-urban area), the cost effectiveness was US$ 14.60/DALY
A510
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
for RT intervention and US$ 17.88/DALY for RPR intervention. Cost-effectiveness
ratios (CERs) were more sensitive to the prevalence rate, sensitivity of tests, and
DALY discount rate. Conclusions: Using the on-site antenatal rapid testing, same
day treatment for positive results, and confirmed by RPR testing approach is costeffective in Mongolia.
PIH32
Cost Effectiveness of Calcium Supplement in Reducing
Preeclampsia-Related Maternal Mortality
Chicaiza-Becerra L A 1, Garcia-Molina M 1, Oviedo S 1, Urrego J 2, Rincon C J 3, Gomez P I 1,
Rubio-Romero J A 1
1Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Bogotá, Colombia, 2Facultad de Ciencias Económicas,
Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Bogotá, Colombia, 3Universidad Nacional de Colombia,
Bogota, Colombia
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate the cost-effectiveness of the supply of calcium of 1200mg
per day from the week 14 of pregnancy to all pregnant women compared to not
supplying it to reduce the incidence of preeclampsia. Methods: A decision tree
was built in TreeAge® with outcome measured in life years gained (LYG) associated
to the reduction in maternal deaths. The costs were included from the perspective
of the Health System in Colombia. Pharmaceutical costs were obtained from 2008
SISMED (1) and the value of the procedures was calculated by adjusting the values
of Tariff Manual ISS 2001 + 30% (2), these values were compared with information
of costs supplied by three EPS. All costs are expressed in Colombian pesos of 2010.
The discount rate was 0%. It was performed sensitivity univariate and probabilistic
analyzes for costs and effectiveness. Results: Compared to no intervention, calcium
supplement is a dominant alternative. If the incidence of preeclampsia is lower than
51.7 per 1000 pregnant women or the cost per tablet of calcium of 600 mg is greater
than $454, calcium supplement is no longer a cost-effective alternative in Colombia
for a threshold of 3 times the GDP per capita in Colombia of 2010 by LYG, equal to
$36,143,550. Conclusions: Supply of calcium to all pregnant women from week
14 of gestation is a dominant alternative compared to no intervention, which saves
200 LYG, while it decreases costs in the order of $5,304 million pesos per 100.000
pregnant women.
PIH33
Economic Evaluation of Ulipristal Acetate for the Treatment of
Patients With Moderate and Severe Symptoms of Uterine Fibroids
in Romania
Lorenzovici L 1, Székely A 1, Ágh T 2, Vámossy I 3, Kelemen L J 4, Finta H 5, Kaló Z 6
Research Romania Ltd, Tirgu Mures, Romania, 2Syreon Research Institute, Budapest,
Hungary, 3Gedeon Richter Plc, Budapest, Hungary, 4Gedeon Richter Romania SA, Corunca,
Romania, 5University of Medicine and Pharmacy of Tirgu Mures, Tirgu Mures, Romania, 6Eötvös
Loránd University, Budapest, Hungary
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
ing an additional unintended pregnancy with ulipristal acetate as compared to
levonorgestrel is estimated to be 418€ . Ulipristal acetate is most cost-effective in
the subgroup of intake within 24 hours, where it is more efficacious at a lower cost
compared to levonorgestrel. Conclusions: Ulipristal acetate is a cost-effective
alternative to levonorgestrel, given that the cost of avoiding an additional pregnancy
with ulipristal acetate is less than the average cost of said pregnancies. Therefore,
French minors should have free access to ulipristal acetate directly in a pharmacy.
Ulipristal acetate should be used rapidly after unprotected intercourse (within
24hours) to benefit from its cost-saving potential compared to levonorgestrel use.
.
1Syreon
Objectives: Ulipristal acetate is a selective progesterone receptor modulator
that has been demonstrated to be an effective 3-month pre-operative treatment
for moderate to severe symptoms of uterine fibroids in adult women of reproductive age. The aim of this analysis was to assess the cost-effectiveness of 5 mg
ulipristal acetate as an add-on therapy to standard pre-surgical observation and
treatment or immediate hysterectomy in Romania. Methods: A Markov model
was developed using a 10-year time horizon. Ulipristal acetate was compared with
pre-surgical observation and immediate hysterectomy. The model comprised the
following mutually exclusive health states: mild, moderate, severe, or persistent
severe excessive bleeding disorder; myomectomy; post-myomectomy with mildly to
moderately excessive bleeding disorder; post-myomectomy with severely excessive
bleeding disorder; hysterectomy; post-hysterectomy; post-menopause; and death.
Transition probabilities and utility values were obtained from clinical trials and the
scientific literature. Resource utilisation and unit costs were derived from the consensus panel of clinical experts and the Romanian National Insurance House tariffs.
Cost vectors in RON were converted to EUR by using 2013 Romanian National Bank
average exchange rate (1 EUR = 4.419 RON). Results: Adding a 3-month course of
ulipristal acetate to pre-operative observation was predicted to achieve an additional 0.021 quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) at an estimated incremental cost of
367 € , which would result in an incremental cost of 17,749 € /QALY. When 3 months
of ulipristal acetate therapy was compared with immediate hysterectomy, the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio was reduced to 2,300 € /QALY. The results were most
sensitive to the utility value of the post-hysterectomy health state but responsive
to changes in other model parameters. Conclusions: The results of this analysis
suggest that adding ulipristal acetate treatment to standard pre-surgical therapy
represents a good value for money in Romania. The inclusion of societal benefits
may considerably reduce the cost-effectiveness ratio.
PIH34
The Cost-Effectiveness of Emergency Hormonal Contraception
With Ulipristal Acetate Versus Levonorgestrel for Minors in
France
Schmid R
HRA Pharma, Paris, France
.
Objectives: To compare the cost and effectiveness of two emergency contraceptive methods in minors in France and to support the payer’s analysis if it is worth
to deliver ulipristal acetate for free to minors. Methods: Based on a decisionanalytical model, the cost-effectiveness of two emergency contraceptive methods is compared. Pregnancy rates, outcome of unintended pregnancy in minors
and resource utilization are derived from literature. Resources and their costs are
considered until termination or a few days after delivery. Costs are taken from a collective perspective. Sensitivity analyses are performed on the most sensitive input
parameters. Results: Using emergency contraception is superior to no method.
The cost of an unintended pregnancy in a French minor is estimated to be 1630€
(1330€ - 1803€ ). Almost 4 million€ (3.1-13.7million€ ) could have been saved by using
ulipristal acetate instead of levonorgestrel in 2010. The incremental cost of avoid-
PIH35
Cervical Assessment With Progesterone in the Prevention of
Preterm Birth: A Strategy Based On Cost-Effectiveness
Fonseca E B 1, Nishikawa A M 2, Paladini L 2, Clark O A C 2
1Universidade Federal da Paraíba, João Pessoa, Brazil, 2Evidencias, Campinas, Brazil
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
INTRODUCTION: Preterm birth (PTB) complications are estimated to be the second
most common cause of death in under-five children and responsible for 3.1million
neonatal deaths. According to a worldwide analysis, Brazil is one of the top ten
countries with the highest number of PTB. Considering its long-term costs, strategies that reduce incidence may be cost-effective. Treatment with progesterone is
one of the interventions recommended for PTB prevention due to the evidence
supporting its efficacy in women with short cervix and prior history of preterm
delivery. Objectives: Determine whether treatment with progesterone for pregnant women with a short cervical length < 25mm identified in routine measurement
of second-trimester transvaginal cervical length by ultrasound in low-risk singleton
pregnancies is a cost-effective strategy under the Brazilian Healthcare System perspective. Methods: A cohort model was developed according to the disease and
resources use. Epidemiology of pregnancies at risk of PTB eligible for progesterone
treatment were obtained from published data. To obtain national clinical data, births
were categorized by gestational week age at delivery specialist opinion. Progesterone
effectiveness data were obtained from systematic reviews, meta-analysis and specialist opinion. Costs included screening test, prenatal consultation, progesterone
and neonatal hospitalization. Exchange rate was 1USD= 2.30BRL. Results were presented in cost/PTB avoided. Results: Considering 278.100 PTB, the inclusion of
screening test to identify pregnant women with short cervix and its prophylaxis
with progesterone shows significant economic savings of USD74 million. Although
the expenditure on drug, screening test and prenatal consultation increment the
total costs, the reduced number of PTB (263,052 vs 278.100) and neonatal UTI hospitalization length (4,098,543 days vs 4,518,056 days) resulted in a total economic
saving. Conclusions: Prevention of PTB is dominant in women with short cervix
as compared to a no-prophylactic strategy scenario resulting in economic savings
to the Brazilian health care system.
PIH36
Cost-Effectiveness of Palivizumab Use in High Risk Children From
Brazilian Health System Perspective
Fernandes R R A
UERJ - IMS, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
.
.
.
Objectives: This study aimed to investigate the cost-effectiveness of palivizumab
to different combinations of risk groups, such as premature children born with gestational age (GA) ≤ 28 weeks, GA ≤ 32 weeks, children with congenital heart disease
and bronchopulmonary dysplasia. Methods: Literature review was performed to
search effectiveness data. One Markov model (base case), and one decision tree
(alternative scenario) were built with a cohort simulation along a 18 years-time
horizon for the base case and a 1 year time horizon for the decision tree. Base case
consider sequelae after infection, and alternative scenario not. The Health System
perspective was used, with a discount rate of 5%. A probabilistic sensitivity analysis
(Monte Carlo simulation) with probability distributions fitted to the variables, was
performed under the different structural assumptions, as well as a deterministic
analysis, using Tornado diagram, to verify the variable modifications able to alter
the responses of the model. A threshold analysis was used to estimate the price
that palivizumab would fit under an acceptability threshold proposed for the health
system. Results: The option of using the prophylaxis just in preterm children born
with GA ≤ 32 weeks dominated all others. The incremental effectiveness of base
case analysis compared with no prophylaxis (base line) was 0.19 QALY. However,
this strategy was not cost-effective, presenting an incremental cost-effectiveness
ratio (ICER) of R$ 81,627.31/QALY, value above of World Health Organization (WHO)
proposed threshold of three times GDP per capita (R$ 63,756.00/QALY). The ICER of
GA ≤ 32 weeks in alternative scenario was 2.023.045,72, showing the importance of
considering sequelae in analysis. Sensitivity analysis showed that some variables
when altered were able to change model final answers. Conclusions: Threshold
analyses demonstrated that palivizumab price must be reduced in at least 22% to
be incorporated to all populations use, based on WHO threshold.
PIH37
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of the New Biomarkers for Diagnosis of
Acute Kidney Injury in Children After Cardiac Surgery
Bogavac Stanojevic N 1, Petrovic S 1, Lakic D 2, Peco Antic A 3, Vulicevic I 4, Ivanisevic I 5,
Kotur Stevuljevic J 1, Jelic-Ivanovic Z 1
1University of Belgrade, Faculty of Pharmacy, Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro, 2University of
Belgrade Faculty of Pharmacy, Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro, 3School of Medicine, University
of Belgrade, Belgrade, Serbia, Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro, 4University Children’s
Hospital, Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro, 5University Children’s Hospital, Belgrade, Serbia and
Montenegro
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Children undergoing cardiac surgery for congenital heart disease are
more likely to experience development of acute kidney injury (AKI) in the immediate postoperative period. In current clinical practice, AKI diagnosis is based on a
rise in serum creatinine (sCr) levels, which occurs 2-3 days after the initiating renal
insult. Many new biomarkers offer promise for earlier AKI diagnosis. The objective
A511
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
was to assess the incremental cost effectiveness of using serum CysC (sCysC), urine
NGAL (uNGAL) and urine L-FABP (uL-FABP) for the diagnosis of AKI in children
after cardiac surgery compared with current diagnostic method (monitoring of sCr
level). Methods: We developed a decision analytical model to estimate qualityadjusted life years (QALY), lifetime costs and incremental cost-effectiveness of different biomarker-based diagnostic strategies which can be used in clinical practice
compared to current strategy. This model simulates detection of AKI, its progression
to chronic kidney disease (CKD) and CKD treatment in cohort of patients younger
than 18 years. Results: The cost-effectiveness ratios were between $1485/QALY for
sCr and $3579/QALY for uNGAL. uNGAL and sCys C strategies yielded higher costs
and lower effectiveness (ie. dominated) compared to uL-FABP strategy. uL-FABP
added 1.43 QALY compared to current diagnostic method at an additional cost of
$8521.87. ICER for uL-FABP compared to sCr was $5959.35/QALY. Probabilistic sensitivity analyses indicated that the uL-FABP strategy was cost-effective for all 10.000
patient simulations at specified $50000/QALY threshold. Conclusions: Our results
suggest that the use of uL-FABP is likely to represent an economically advantageous
strategy for early AKI diagnosis in children after cardiac surgery. However, we need
rapid screening uL-FABP test to ensure timely and efficient AKI treatment.
mize selection bias. Patients in both groups were required to be at least age 18 years,
with continuous medical and pharmacy benefits 1 year before, and 1 year after the
index date. One-to-one propensity score matching (PSM) was used to compare health
care costs and utilizations during the follow-up period between the menopausal and
the comparison groups, and were adjusted for baseline demographic and clinical
characteristics. Results: After risk adjustment by PSM, a total of 67,740 patients
in each cohort were matched. More menopausal patients had inpatient admissions
(15.18% vs. 11.89%, p< 0.0001) and other service (99.98% vs. 90.29%, p<0.0001) and
pharmacy visits (86.55% vs. 71.23%, p<0.0001) compared to those without menopause.
Menopausal patients also incurred significantly higher other service visit ($11,215 vs.
$8,812, p<0.0001) and pharmacy costs ($2,448 vs. $1,878, p< 0.0001) than comparison
patients. Conclusions: In the U.S. Medicaid program, menopausal patients had
higher health care utilization and incurred higher costs than those without menopause, highlighting the economic burden of the disease.
PIH38
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of the Therapy of Endometriosis
1Temas
Tuletova A , Dochshanova A , Skakova R
Medical University Astana, Astana, Kazakhstan
Objectives: Infantile Hemangioma (IH) is one of the most common childhood
benign tumours. Recent studies have demonstrated the success of propranolol for
involution of IH and the higher clinically effective and safe compared with corticosteroids. The purpose of this study is to estimate the cost-utility of propranolol,
a new medicinal product authorized for this specific paediatric indication (3.75 mg/
mL, oral solution) versus corticosteroids (5.00 mg, tablets), used in clinical practice
in absence of other authorised therapies of proliferating IH requiring systemic treatment. Methods: A life-time (30 years) mixed decision tree and Markov model
has been developed to describe the pathway of infants with IH and to assess costs
and outcomes (Quality-Adjusted Life Years – QALYs – gained) from the perspective of the Italian National Health Service (INHS). Clinical inputs derive from the
manufacturer’s pivotal trial and literature review, validated by key clinicians in Italy.
The economic evaluation considers direct medical costs associated with IH (drug
acquisition, hospital admissions and outpatient visits) derived from public sources.
The atopic dermatitis as a proxy for IH utilities, the Infants Dermatitis Quality of
Life Index and the Children’s Dermatology Life Quality Index were used to estimate
quality of life. Probabilistic sensitivity analyses (PSA) were performed to investigate
model parameter uncertainties. Costs and health benefits have been discounted at
an annual rate of 3.00%. Results: The cumulative costs are €2,399.32 and € 1,859.68
while cumulative QALYs are 19.11 and 18.95 for propranolol and for corticosteroids respectively, corresponding to an ICUR of € 3,372.75/QALY. PSA results suggest
that 94.60% of the 1000 iterations fall within a € 30,000 cost-effectiveness threshold
considered acceptable for a marginal unit of effectiveness. Conclusions: The
propranolol (3.75 mg/mL, oral solution for paediatric use) for the treatment of proliferating IH can be considered cost-effective compared to corstisteroids (5.00 mg,
tablets) in the INHS perspective.
PIH41
Cost-Utility Analysis Comparing Propranolol With Corticosteroids
in the Treatment of Proliferating Infantile Hemangioma in Italy
Paragò V 1, El Hachem M 2, Bonamonte D 3, Diociaiuti A 2, Teruzzi C 1
- A Quintiles Company, Cassina de’ Pecchi, Italy, 2Bambino Gesù Children’s Hospital,
Rome, Italy, 3University of Bari, Bari, Italy
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Endometriosis is a disease with social and economic impact. We analyses the clinical and pharmaco-economical efficacy of the treatment of genital
endometriosis. Methods: This open-label prospective comparative research was
performed in 2012-2013 on Center of Endometriosis of Astana. Results of treatment taken from 180 female patients with endometriosis aged 19-35 years old were
included into the study. All of them were divided on three groups depending on the
methods of therapy. 1st group have a endo-surgery treatment (60 patient), 2nd group
(60 patient) - only hormonal therapy (Dienogest 2 mg per day for 6 months) and 3rd
group - combined therapy (after endo-surgery taken the Dienogest 2 mg per day
for 6 months). For the calculation of cost/effectiveness index we included all of the
direct medical expenses. Results: In the first group efficacy index is 66,7%, in the
second group – 70,0% and in the third group – 91,7%. Index cost/effectiveness for
endo-surgery is 143 298 KT (1$= 182KT), cost/effectiveness for hormonal therapy
is 92 428 KT and cost/effectiveness for combined methods is 115 718 KT. Surgical
treatment has the low efficiency of the high costs compared with other therapies.
The indicator of cost/effectiveness of the combined therapy is higher than in the
hormonal treatment: higher efficiency cost in additional costs. For the objectification of this fact calculated Incremental Index per patient: 186 500 - 107 833 / 92.0
- 70.0 = 182 KT. So, the increase of one percent of effectiveness combined therapy
compare to hormonal therapy reflects additional cost, not more than 182 KT per
patient. Conclusions: Hormonal therapy resulted as the cost-saving therapy of
genital endometriosis in young women. The higher efficiency of treatment of endometriosis are needed additional expenses.
PIH39
Cost-Utility Analysis of Preventive Home Visits in Older Adults
Brettschneider C 1, Luck T 2, Fleischer S 3, Roling G 3, Beutner K 3, Sesselmann Y 3, Luppa M 4,
Behrens J 3, Riedel-Heller S 4, König H H 1
1University Medical Center Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany, 2University Leipzig, Leipzig, Germany,
3University Medical Center Halle (Saale), Halle (Saale), Germany, 4University of Leipzig, Leipzig,
Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Most elderly prefer to grow old in the community within a familiar environment, instead of moving to a nursing home. Preventive home visits
based on multidimensional geriatric assessment can be one strategy to support
this preference and might additionally reduce health care costs, due to the avoidance of costly nursing home admissions. The purpose of this study was to analyse the cost-effectiveness of preventive home visits from a societal perspective in
Germany. Methods: This study is part of a multi-centre, non-blinded, randomised
controlled trial. Participants were older than 80 years and living at home. Three
home visits were conducted to identify self-care deficits and risk factors, to present recommendations and to implement solutions. The control group received
usual care. A cost-utility analysis using QALY based on the EQ-5D was performed.
A cost-effectiveness acceptability curve controlled for confounding variables was
constructed. A sensitivity analysis to control for the influence of the mode of QALY
calculation was performed. Results: 278 individuals were included in the analysis. Mean total cost (+874 EUR) and number of QALY (+0.0014) were higher in the
usual care group, but differences were not significant. The probability for costeffectiveness of preventive home visits increased from 6% (Willingness-to-pay:
0 € / QALY) 30% (Willingness-to-pay: 250.000 € / QALY). The results were robust to
the mode of QALY calculation. The probability of cost-effectiveness did not exceed
30%. Conclusions: We found convincing evidence that the evaluated preventive
home visits programme is not cost-effective.
PIH40
Evaluation of the Economic Burden of Menopausal Women in the U.
S. Medicaid Program
Li L 1, Shrestha S 1, Baser O 2, Wang L 1
1STATinMED Research, Plano, TX, USA, 2STATinMED Research and The University of Michigan,
Ann Arbor, MI, USA
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate the economic burden of menopausal women enrolled in the
U.S. Medicaid program. Methods: Menopausal women (International Classification
of Disease, 9thRevision, Clinical Modification [ICD-9-CM] diagnosis code 627) were
identified using U.S. Medicaid data from 01JAN2008 through 31DEC2010. The initial
diagnosis date was designated as the index date. A separate group of patients without
a menopause diagnosis but of the same age, race, and gender was identified, matched
and designated as the comparison group. A random index date was chosen to mini-
.
.
.
.
PIH42
Cost Effectiveness Analysis of A Vaccine To Prevent Herpes Zoster
and Postherpetic Neuralgia in Italy
Coretti S , Ruggeri M , Codella P
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Rome, Italy
.
.
.
Objectives: The aim of this study was to assess the cost-effectiveness of HZ vaccination compared to no vaccination strategy which only involves the treatment of
patients affected by HZ, within the Italian context. Methods: The natural history
of HZ and PHN was mapped through a Markov model with lifetime horizon and
cycles lasting one month. Both third party payer (the Italian National Health Service)
and societal perspectives were adopted. Costs and Effectiveness data was derived
from literature and discounted by 3.5%. Model results are expressed in terms of
incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER). Both deterministic and probabilistic
sensitivity analyses were performed to appraise the effect of parameters’ variation
on model results. Results: A population of patients with HZ aged between 60 and
79 years was hypothesized. The ICER of the vaccination equaled € 12,155 per QALY
under the NHS perspective and € 11,118 per QALY under the societal perspective.
Moreover, under NHS perspective the cost per HZ-episode avoided and the cost per
PHN-episode avoided amounted to € 1,098 and € 8,742 respectively. Considering a
cost-effectiveness threshold of € 30,000/QALY, the probabilistic sensitivity analysis
showed that vaccination is cost-effective regardless of the perspective adopted, in
99% of simulations. Conclusions: Results showed that a vaccination program
against herpes zoster and post-herpetic neuralgia is cost-effective in Italian patients
aged between 60 and 79 years.
PIH43
Cost-Utility Analysis of A Medication Review With Follow-Up for
Older People With Polypharmacy in Community Pharmacies in Spain:
Consigue Program
Jódar-Sánchez F 1, Malet-Larrea A 2, Martín J 3, Garcia L 4, López del Amo M P 3, MartínezMartínez F 3, Gastelurrutia-Garralda M A 5, Garcia-Cárdenas M V 6, Sabater-Hernández D 6,
Benrimoj S I 6
1Virgen del Rocío University Hospital, Seville, Spain, 2University of the Basque Country, Vitoria,
Spain, 3University of Granada, Granada, Spain, 4Andalusia School of Public Health, Granada,
Spain, 5University of Granada, San Sebastián, Spain, 6University of Technology Sydney, Sydney,
Australia
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The objective of this study was to estimate the incremental costeffectiveness ratio (ICER) of a medication review with follow-up (MRF) service for
older people with polypharmacy in community pharmacies against the alternative
of receiving usual dispensing. Methods: The study was designed as a longitudinal cluster randomized trial carried out over six months of follow-up. The target
A512
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
population consisted of older people (≥ 65 years) with polypharmacy (≥ 5 drugs) and
the study was conducted in 178 community pharmacies in Spain. A total of 1,403
patients were enrolled, 688 in the intervention group (IG) and 715 in the control
group (CG). The analysis adopted the perspective of the National Health Service
(NHS). In order to analyze the uncertainty of ICER results, we performed a nonparametric bootstrapping with 5,000 replications. Results: Both groups reduced
the average number of prescribed medications, although this reduction was greater
in the IG (0.28 drugs; p< 0.001) than in the CG (0.07 drugs; p= 0.063). Patients in the
IG showed an improvement in their quality of life by 0.0528 in the utility score
(p< 0.001). By contrast, patients in the CG showed no differences in their quality of
life by 0.0022 in the utility score (p= 0.815). We obtained an ICER of € 8,542/QALY and
€ 6,777/QALY for the first and second scenario respectively, and a MRF as dominant
strategy for the third, fourth and fifth scenario. For a willingness to pay of € 30,000/
QALY, the probability of the MRF being cost-effective, compared to usual dispensing,
is in a range between 98.2% and 100% for the five scenarios. Conclusions: MRF is
an effective intervention for optimizing prescribed medication and improving the
quality of life of older people with polypharmacy in community pharmacies. The
results from the cost-utility analysis suggest that MRF is cost-effective.
PIH44
Retrospective Analysis of the Economic Burden of Long-Term
Care Facility Residents Diagnosed With Alzheimer’s Disease in
the United States
Huang A 1, Shrestha S 1, Baser O 2, Wang L 1
1STATinMED Research, Plano, TX, USA, 2STATinMED Research and The University of Michigan,
Ann Arbor, MI, USA
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate health care resource utilization and costs of patients
diagnosed with Alzheimer’s disease (AD) and residing in long-term care facilities. Methods: A retrospective database analysis was performed using the
Minimum Data set (MDS) linked to 5% Medicare data from 01JAN2008 through
31DEC2011. AD patients were identified using International Classification of Disease,
9thRevision, Clinical Modification (ICD-9-CM) diagnosis code 331.0. The first diagnosis date was designated as the index date. A comparison cohort was created for
patients without an AD diagnosis, using 1: 1 propensity score matching (PSM) to control for baseline characteristics (age, region, gender, index year, baseline Charlson
Comorbidity Index [CCI] score). For the comparison cohort, the index date was
randomly chosen to reduce selection bias. Patients in both cohorts were required
to be age ≥ 65 years, with at least two consecutive quarterly assessments in MDS
data in the 6 months pre-index date and 1-year continuous medical and pharmacy
benefits enrollment pre- and post-index date. Study outcomes (health care costs and
utilizations) were compared between the cohorts. Results: After 1: 1 matching, a
total of 2,158 patients were identified for the disease and comparison cohorts, and
baseline characteristics were balanced. The AD cohort had a higher percentage of
inpatient stays (33.73% vs. 24.93%, p< 0.0001), outpatient visits (92.22% vs. 89.99%,
p= 0.01) and skilled nursing facility (SNF) (32.53% vs. 28.41%, p< 0.01) and hospice
admissions (11.03% vs. 7.14%, p< 0.0001) than the comparison cohort. The AD cohort
also incurred higher inpatient ($5,442 vs. $4,001, p< 0.001), SNF ($5,679 vs. $4,523,
p< 0.01) and hospice stay costs ($3,164 vs. $2,047, p< 0.001) as well as carrier claim
($2,907 vs. $2,686, p= 0.03) and pharmacy costs ($5,043 vs. $4,722, p= 0.01), compared
to the comparison cohort. Conclusions: AD was associated with higher health
care resource utilization and a significantly higher economic burden.
INDIVIDUAL’S HEALTH – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient
Preference Studies
PIH45
Validation of the Adherence Barriers Questionnaire (Abq) – An
Instrument for Identifying Potential Risk Factors Associated
With Medication-Related Non-Adherence
Müller S , Wilke T
IPAM, University Wismar, Wismar, Germany
.
.
Objectives: Medication-related non-adherence is a major challenge in the reallife treatment of patients. To meet this challenge successfully, adherence interventions with a tailored approach towards patient-specific adherence barriers are
needed. Therefore, a reliable and practicable questionnaire for identification of those
adherence barriers in specific patients is needed. The aim of this investigation is
to develop and validate such a questionnaire. Methods: The “Adherence Barriers
Questionnaire (ABQ)” was developed and tested in 432 patients with atrial fibrillation in a multicenter observational cohort study. Evaluation of the questionnaire
included an assessment of internal consistency as well as factor analysis. Criterionrelated external validity was appraised by comparing the ABQ score with the score of
a self-report adherence measure and with a clinical parameter (time in therapeutic
range (TTR) regarding INR values in the VKA-based stroke prophylaxis treatment
of patients). Results: The final 14-item ABQ scale demonstrated high internal
consistency (Cronbach’s alpha= 0.820). Factor analysis identified a three-factor solution, representing intentional adherence barriers with 5 items (31.9% of the variance), medication- or health care system-related adherence barriers with 5 items
(13.3% of the variance) and unintentional adherence barriers with 4 items (7.7% of
the variance). The ABQ correlated significantly with self-reported non-adherence
(Spearman’s rho=0.438, P< 0.001) as well as TTR (Spearman’s rho=-0.161, P< 0.01).
Patients with above-average ABQ scores (increased number of existing adherence
barriers) were significantly (p< 0.005, Pearson Chi-Square) more likely to have a poor
anticoagulation quality (TTR<60%) than patients with a lower ABQ score (44.6%
versus 27.3%). Conclusions: The ABQ is a practicable, reliable and valid instrument
for identifying specific barriers to medication-related adherence. Future research is
required to examine the ability of the ABQ to identify patient perception/behavior
changes over time which may be important for the measurement of success of adherence interventions.
PIH46
Stress Load Factors in the Scope of Students
Szunomár S 1, Nagy J 1, Pakai A 2, Fullér N 1, Stromájer-Rácz T 1, Boncz I 3, Oláh A 1
of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary, 2University of Pécs, Zalaegerszeg, Hungary, 3Faculty of Health
Sciences, University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: The examination of the effects of stress in university students during the exam period, compared with demographic data. Methods: Prospective
research was made in the exam period. Altogether 181 university students participated in the study, in the course of which online questionnaire were applied.
In the first part of the questionnaire demographic questions were listed, while
Student Nursing Stress Index (SNSI) questionnaire was applied to measure stress
level. Emotions perceived in a given moment could be evaluated by the Brunel Mood
Scale. In the last part of the questionnaire Marlowe- Crowne Senior Short Form
Social Desirability Scale (MCSDS) was applied to evaluate behaviour desired by the
society. The analysis of results was performed with SPSS 20.00 and MO Excel 2007
programs. For data analysis descriptive statistics, χ 2-test, t-test, variance analysis and regression analysis besides the significance level p< 0,05. Results: The
division of genders was 28 (15,47%) male and 153 (84,53%) female participants in
the research (n= 181). The average age was 21,62±3,07 years. The measurement of
stress showed that sleeping time of students can be significantly affected by stress
(p< 0,001). Those whose parents are divorced reached higher points in the value of
stress (p=0,038). Stress load caused by the exams did not show significant difference
between specialities (p> 0,05). In the course of the research we found that senior
students experienced significantly more stress in the exam period than freshmen
(p= 0,013). Conclusions: As the result of the measurements it can be said that
stress is continuously present in students. Besides the requirements of the university students have to cope with several other problems.
PIH47
Failure To Obtain the First Prescribed Refill (Early Medication NonPersistence): A Meta-Analysis of Rates and Causes of Variation in
Rates By Chronic Disease Class and Analytic Methods
Atkinson M J 1, Trivedi B 1, McHorney C A 2
Market Access Services, Inc., San Diego, CA, USA, 2Covance Market Access Services, Inc.,
Gaithersburg, MD, USA
.
.
.
.
.
1Covance
Objectives: Medication non-adherence is often classified by the timing of nonadherence. Primary non-adherence is the failure to fill a newly-prescribed medication (Rx). Rx non-persistence is the failure to continue therapy after the initial fill. A
recent classification − early non-persistence (ENP) − is the failure to obtain the first
prescribed refill of a new Rx (single dispensation only). In this meta-analytic review,
we compare the rates of ENP across studies by four moderator dimensions: (1) chronic
disease class; (2) symptomatic vs. asymptomatic chronic condition; (3) length of the
baseline treatment-free interval; and (4) whether ENP estimates were adjusted for
Rx switches. Methods: Fifty-eight studies that contained data on ENP were identified using a PubMed literature search and searches of each article’s reference list.
ENP rates were recorded for 91 distinct samples. ENP was defined as the failure to
obtain the first prescribed refill within 30 days of the first-refill date. ENP rates were
weighted by sample size and combined to provide pooled fixed effect size estimates
for the moderator dimensions. Results: Across all samples, the overall weighted ENP
rate was 23.6%. Observed difference between ENP rates by disease class were largely
explained by whether the treatment focused on symptom control or not: symptomatic
ENP rate= 39.5% vs. asymptomatic ENP rate= 17.7%. ENP rates were affected by two
aspects of methodology: (1) length of baseline treatment-free interval (shorter, favoring treatment-experienced=17.1% vs. longer, favoring treatment-naïve=27.2%); and (2)
Rx switches accounted for in the ENP estimates (accounting for switch= 18.8% vs. not
accounting for switch=26.0%). Conclusions: ENP is as high, and can be higher than
primary non-adherence. Most extant studies simply document the rate of ENP. Given
that ~ 24% of patients are “one-and-done,” it is imperative to: (1) understand the drivers of ENP and (2) develop patient-centered interventions to stem the epidemic of ENP.
PIH48
Patients’ Acceptance of Their Medication: Results From a French
Multi-Diseases Study With Patient Online Community Using
the Acceptance By the Patients of Their Treatment (Accept©)
Questionnaire
Gilet H 1, Chekroun M 2, Arnould B 1
.
.
.
1Mapi, Lyon, France, 2carenity.com, Paris, France
Objectives: Lack of adherence and persistence can be major barriers to treatment
efficiency in real world, for many chronic diseases. Measuring patients’ acceptance
of their medication is thus gaining importance as it is likely to help better understand and predict patients’ behavior towards treatment. The generic ACCEptance
by the Patients of their Treatment (ACCEPT) questionnaire was developed to measure patients’ acceptance of their medication. The objective of this study was to
evaluate for a variety of diseases the level of acceptance in real life using a patient
online community. Methods: This study was observational, cross-sectional, conducted through the French Carenity platform. All patients connected were invited
to complete an online questionnaire including demographics, chronic disease and
treatment, and the 25 ACCEPT items. ACCEPT includes 6 multi-item acceptance
dimensions (Medication Inconvenience, Long-term Treatment, Regimen Constraints,
Side Effects, Effectiveness and General; range 0-100; higher score= greater acceptance) and one single-item acceptance dimension (Numerous Medications; range
1-3). Patients included in the analysis were suffering from any chronic diseases
with at least 50 respondents and currently receiving a treatment for this disease. Results: Responding patients had breast cancer (n= 57), type 1 diabetes
(n= 101), type 2 diabetes (n= 213), fibromyalgia (n= 135), rheumatoid arthritis (n= 98),
multiple sclerosis (n=260), ankylosing spondylitis (n=134) or bipolar disorder (n=65).
Most respondents were female (49% to 100%), with mean age 44 to 61. Mean (SD)
ACCEPT General score was: 36 (33) for breast cancer, 64 (31) for type 1 diabetes, 54
(32) for type 2 diabetes, 35 (31) for fibromyalgia, 39 (31) for rheumatoid arthritis, 50
A513
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
(31) for multiple sclerosis, 34 (33) for ankylosing spondylitis and 45 (33) for bipolar
disorder. Conclusions: This study enabled ACCEPT data to be collected in real
life for a variety of chronic diseases. These data can be of major interest to help
evaluating and interpreting level of acceptance in future studies.
PIH49
Attitude Change Among 18-19 Years Old Boys After School-Drug
Prevention Program
Danku N 1, Csákvári T 2, Vajda R 1, Boncz I 3
1University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary, 2University of Pécs, Zalaegerszeg, Hungary, 3Faculty of Health
Sciences, University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The aim of our study was to explore the efficiency of “FÜGE” school-drug
prevention program based on the students attitude change. Methods: The research
program was made at the Zipernowsky Károly Secondary Technical School with a
standard questioner. Pre-test was made 10 days before and post-test 10 days after the
school-drug prevention program. 94 people participated in the research. We processed
our data with the help of MS excel 2007 and we prepared a T-test with it. Results:
The results showed that the rate of those, who know everything about drugs have
grown from 52,1% to 59,6% and those, who did not know anything decreased from
3,2% to 2,1% (p= 0,181) before and after the drug-prevention program. The effect of
the “FÜGE” program also changed the student’s sense of danger regarding drugs significantly. There was a significant change (p= 0,008) in the trying of marihuana and
hashish. Based on the given answer’s T-tests there were also significant differences in
the test of hallucinogenic drugs (p= 0,012) and amphetamine, speed (p= 0,046). There
was an almost significant (p=0,071) correlation regarding the occasional usage of
amphetamine, speed. Furthermore, after the program was made, significantly more
students believes that trying (p= 0,001), using occasionally (p= 0,050) and using regularly (p=0,003) herbal drugs is dangerous. However, less than 7% percent of the students agreed the statements: “I have learned a lot from the occasions.” and “I received
answers for a lot of question that I was interested in earlier.” Conclusions: “FÜGE”
program is considered successful, because the participants’ knowledge increased,
their sense of danger changed, but only half of them had a positive opinion about the
program’s information-amount. We have to state that the changes in the knowledge
about drug usage not necessarily lead to changes in behavior.
PIH50
Patient Perspective: Pro Compliance and Effective Reminder
Strategies
Ross J , Holzbaur E , Wade M , Rothrock T
Almac Clinical Technologies, Souderton, PA, USA
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Survey data results providing patient perspectives on compliance and
reminder-use in studies including Patient Report Outcomes (PROs) is shared. This
presentation looks at patients’ preferred reminder modes, identifies what may impact
diary compliance, and evaluates reminder strategies. Methods: The survey was
conducted in 2013, including patients globally (N=405) who participated in at least one
clinical trial in the past two years with patient diaries. Patients were asked about their
most recent diary experience (including compliance), future trial participation (including preferences for receiving reminders-content/modality/timing), and personal technology behaviors. Results: Only 53.6% of patients reported always being compliant
with completing diary entries. Factors associated with non-compliance were age,
dissatisfaction, and hard to remember diaries. Reasons for non-compliance included:
“They Forgot” (51.4%), “Too Busy” (41.1%), “Access” (27.6%), and “Other” (2.7%). Patients
(77.2%) provided high attractiveness ratings for reminders in future trials. Preferred
reminder modes include: text messages (67.2%), hand-held alerts (34.3%), phone calls
(34.1%), calendar alerts (32.6%), and email (6.2%). The majority of patients want to
receive reminders for: diaries (97.3%), appointments (95.8%), and medication (95.0%).
Most patients indicated checking text messages and emails daily. Significantly more
patients check text messages immediately compared to email suggesting that text
messages may be more effective for reminding patients. Majority reported owning
some mode of technology; therefore, reminder strategies should be tailored to patient
mode availability. Conclusions: As self-reported by patients, forgetting is the top
reason for non-compliance which can be highly prevalent in trials. Results show
patients feel reminders are helpful. Patients would like to be reminded of various
events. Reminder strategies should account for patient preferences and mode availability to keep patient satisfaction high. Effective reminder strategies can positively
affect compliance, satisfaction and patient experiences in clinical trials. Reminder
practices can also be rolled out to benefit compliance in health care.
PIH51
Using the Analytic Hierarchy Process To Derive Health State
Utilities From Ordinal Preference Data
Reddy B 1, Kind P 2, Adams R C 1, Walsh C 3, Barry M 4
1National Centre for Pharmacoeconomics, Dublin, Ireland, 2University of Leeds, Leeds, UK, 3Trinity
College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland, 4HSE Medicines Management Programme, Dublin, Ireland
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: EQ-5D is a standardised instrument for use as a measure of health
outcome. There are well-documented problems regarding how best to measure
worse than dead states using the Time Trade Off (TTO) approach. We attempted to
generate utilities from ordinal relationships between health states (HSs) to overcome these issues, using the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) approach. AHP is a
multiple criteria decision analysis technique based upon pairwise comparisons, useful for structuring complex prioritisation problems. It has been widely used in health
settings. Methods: The technique outlined was applied to the Measurement and
Valuation of Health (MVH) study dataset. The number of occasions that each HS was
preferred to each of the others was measured and represented by a 45*45 matrix.
This was subsequently transformed into a scale indicating the significance of the
difference between each pair of HSs. We describe 5 approaches to structure pairwise
comparisons of HS preference (2 concave, 2 convex, 1 linear). A score for each HS was
derived from this matrix’s principal eigenvector, and the matrix’s consistency calculated. Results: All approaches predicted the rankings of HSs found in the MVH
report well. However, the utilities subsequently derived followed an unconventional,
bunched shape compared to the original study. By optimizing the parameters in
order to minimize the sum of squared errors between approaches, a more suitable
approach (“Beta rank fit”) was identified. Utilities could in principle therefore be
derived using this method alone, without recourse to TTO models. Conclusions:
This paper outlines an approach that may be suitable for converting ordinal preference data into cardinal utilities, and offering a number of advantages over previously
described approaches. Ranking exercises for participants are considerably easier to
carry out than full TTO studies, so the approach may be suitable for resource limited
settings or for underrepresented subpopulations.
PIH52
A Utility Algorithm forthe Pressure Ulcer Quality of Life – Utility
Instrument (Puqol-Ui)
Czoski Murray C J 1, Meads D M 1, McCabe C 2, Edlin R 3, Rutherford C 4, Hulme C T 1, Nixon J 1
of Leeds, Leeds, UK, 2University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada, 3University of
Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand, 4University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: Pressure Ulcers are an important health care problem, recognized as
‘Never Events’ by the US Government. To date, there is no instrument to capture
their health utility impact, or the value of treatments and prevention strategies. The
Pressure Ulcer Quality of Life Utility Instrument (PUQol-UI) is a condition specific
preference-based measure designed to capture the impact of having a pressure
ulcer (PU) on an individual’s health related quality of life and will allow calculation of QALYs necessary for cost-effectiveness analyses. PUQol-UI consists of 7
domains (Pain, Mobility, Activities of Daily Living, Energy, Depression, Burden and
Social Function). Each domain has three possible response levels: ‘No Bother’, ‘Little
Bother’, and ‘A lot of Bother’. Methods: A valuation exercise obtained Time TradeOff values for 51 PUQol-UI health states in 200 interviews with the UK General
Population. OLS, Random Effects and Fixed Effects linear regression models were
fitted and evaluated using tests of standard goodness of fit and estimation and validation sample predictive performance. Results: The Random Effects model was
superior in fit and predictive performance, with 83% of states predicted to within
0.1 of the observed mean. Preliminary analysis of the psychometric properties of
the PUQoL-UI indicates adequate levels of validity and may offer measurement
advantages over the generic EQ-5D measure. Conclusions: The PUQol-UI is a
useful addition to the portfolio of condition specific utility measures available to
researchers interested in economic evaluation of technologies for the management
of pressure ulcers, and health care decision makers responsible for funding such
technologies.
PIH53
Time-Trade-off Modelling of Health Utility Values for Menopausal
Symptoms and Their Treatment
Pisa G 1, Kurz P 2, Potthoff P 1, Eichmann F 1
1Kantar Health Germany, Munich, Germany, 2TNS-Infratest, Munich, Germany
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Impaired Health-Related Quality of Life (HRQoL) of women due to various symptoms of menopause impairments has been given increased importance
in the past years. The objective of the present study is to estimate utility values for
symptoms relevant for menopause-specific disturbances and to convert them into
women’s willingness to give away months of life (time-trade-off) for relief of those
symptoms. Methods: A time-trade-off (TTO) model was applied to estimate the
utilities of 7 symptoms caused by menopause impairments. A German version of
the QualiPause Inventory (QPI) was used for assessing the severity of the symptoms.
A quota sample of 478 women, aged 45 to 60 years, was interviewed. Health states
were presented to participating women on a mobile computer screen, and they
were asked to specify the willingness to give away months/years for the relief of
the symptoms, using time-scaled graphic slide controls visible on the computer
screen. A total of 45 health states were valued out of a potential of 2,187 defined
by the classification system. Logistic regression and Bayes methods were used to
estimate the utility values. Utility values were converted into trade-off willingness
for life months. Both methods led to almost identical results. Results: Willingness
to trade-off life months for relief of symptoms ranges between Zero and 132 months
of life with a median of 12 months. 25% of the women were willing to trade-off
more than 45 months, 5% more than 100 months and 1% even 132 months or more.
Among the more severely rated symptoms are dryness of the vagina, bleedings,
and anxiety. Conclusions: Time-Trade-Off techniques can be used to estimate
preference values for health states affected by menopausal symptoms and their
relief. These values can be used to estimate differential outcomes of hormone
replacement therapy.
PIH54
Geographical Variations of Health Perception in the Us, Using Brfss
Data 2012
Duccini F D M 1, Roïz J 2
.
.
.
.
1Ensai, BRUZ, France, 2Creativ-Ceutical, London, UK
Objectives: To determine whether and how the location influences the way people perceive their health in the US using BRFSS data 2012. The explained variable,
general health, has five modalities (excellent (1), very good (2), good (3), fair (4) and
poor (5)). Methods: Using BRFSS data 2012, a descriptive study and chi-square
test have been conducted crossing the general health variable with the location
variable. This variable has been combined in ten modalities (New England, MidAtlantic, East North Central, West North Central, South Atlantic, East South Central,
West South Central, Mountain, Pacific and Guam/Puerto Rico). It has been followed
by an ordered logit model to explain general health variable by the location using
stepwise selection. Results: The study has been carried on 474,124 weighted individuals from BFRSS data 2012. The chi-square value is 962,244 and the p-value was
lower than 0.001. Some regions such as Pacific, mid Atlantic, mountain and new
England were found in a higher proportion among the excellent and very good
health groups than in all the population (P: 11.7% and 10.6% vs 10.5%; MI: 11.9%,
A514
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
11.6% vs 11.2%; M: 9.1% and 8.8% vs 8.4%; NE: 5% and 4.7% vs 4.3%). When others
such as the East South Central and the West South central regions were found in a
higher proportion among the good, fair and poor health groups (ESC: 5.8%, 6.7% and
9.6% against 5.6% WSC: 13.6%, 13.4% and 15.6% vs 12.5%). The coefficients found
in the ordered logit model were all significant and have confirmed the descriptive
study. Conclusions: The location influences the way people perceive their health
in the US. Next step would be to look at other socio-demographics variables such
as people’s revenue, race or education.
PIH55
A Comparison of Value for Health States Worse Than Dead Between
Japan and Uk
Noto S 1, Shimozuma K 2, Saito S 3, Shiroiwa T 4, Fukuda T 4, Moriwaki K 5, Izumi R 1
University of Health and Welfare, Niigata, Japan, 2Ritsumeikan University, Kusatsu,
Japan, 3Okayama University, Okayama, Japan, 4National Institute of Public Health, Saitama,
Japan, 5Kobe Pharmaceutical University, Kobe, Japan
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Niigata
Objectives: To clarify the difference of value for health states worse than dead
(WTD) between Japan and UK. Methods: A web survey was conducted asking
respondents whether each health states is WTD before discrete choice experiment (DCE) tasks (DCE results not described). Health states were described using
the EQ-5D-3L descriptive system. The 48 health states were blocked into 24 sets
for DCE tasks. All respondents were asked 12 sets tasks randomly. We compared
value for WTD between Japan and UK, UK’s value referred the article (Bansback et
al., 2011). Results: A sample of 1242 members of the market research panel was
invited by email to participate in the survey. Of these, 1085 (87%) completed all
tasks. The mean age of participants were 49.5 years (SD= 16.6). High numbers of
value of WTD were confirmed. 50.5% of respondents judged health state 33333 to
be value of WTD, but 77.0% judged in UK. Similarly, 45.7% and 41.0% of them judged
to be value of WTD for health state 33332 and 33323, respectively (72.0% and 60.0%
in UK). Conclusions: Our findings suggest that Japanese value of worse health
states not to be low in comparison with UK’s. On the other hand, it was thought
that participants might not understand the tasks.
PIH56
Patient-Reported Fall Related Health Care Services in
Elderly Women
Tamulaityte-Morozoviene I , Tamulaitiene M , Stukas R , Surkiene G , Dadoniene J , Alekna V
Vilnius University, Vilnius, Lithuania
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Although the falls in elderly people lead to serious health consequences, the economic burden is underestimated. The aim of this study was
to examine the fall-related out-patient medical care in community-dwelling
elderly women. Methods: Women aged 65 years and older who visited National
Osteoporosis Center for diagnostic or treatment procedures, were interviewed by
phone recording the consequences and health care procedures related to every fall
sustained during the previous 12 months. Results: The study population consisted
of 310 women who reported one or more fall, one in three of them had fallen twice or
more. Of all women who fell, 280 (90.3%) reported their fall resulted in an injury, and
77 (15.3%) falls led to bone fractures. Fall related medical care was provided to 135
women: to 43.5% of those who fell and 48.2% of those who sustained injuries from
falling received medical attention. Among these, the highest percentage reported
using of out-patient medical services. The number of out-patient visits reported
(535 visits in total) ranged from 1 to 13, and in 70 cases (51.9%) – from 2 to 4 visits.
Different types of out-patient health care were used by 43.5% of women who fell.
The majority of specialists visited were orthopaedist, surgeon, and radiologist. An
ambulance was used by 11.9%, and family doctor was visited by 19.4% of fallers.
The mean number of health care procedures was higher in women who sustained
a fracture, as compared to those who did not: 4.9 (95% CI 4.4–5.4) and 0.67 (95% CI
0.29–0.76), respectively; p< 0.0001. Conclusions: From all self-reported falls registered in women over 65 years, 90.3% resulted in any injuries. The mean number
of out-patient visits per faller was 1.73 (95 % CI 1.36–2.1).
Objectives: The EuroQol-5D (EQ-5D) is a generic patient-reported outcome measure (PROM) allowing comparisons to be made across different diseases and conditions. The instrument has been used in the UK’s National Health Service (NHS) since
2009 to collect data from patients to assess the effectiveness of a number of surgical
interventions. The aim of this study was to investigate whether the EQ-5D domains
behave similarly across patient samples. Methods: The data were derived from
published Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) for April 2013 to March 2013. The EQ-5D
had been completed by patients undergoing four surgical procedures: groin hernia repair (N= 21831), hip (N= 37800) and knee replacement (N= 40429) and varicose
vein repair (N= 4681). The partial credit model (Masters, 1982) was applied to the
data. Uniform differential item functioning (DIF) and non-uniform DIF (criterion
difference > 0.5 logits) was assessed across the four interventions, gender, age
group and the interactions. Results: There was significant uniform DIF between
the 4 interventions with 50% of all possible contrasts demonstrating DIF. The only
domain not affected by DIF was Discomfort/Pain. There was DIF present in 2/3 of
the contrasts for Anxiety/Depression, Mobility and Self-care and in 50% of the Usual
Activities domain. DIF was also demonstrated across age groups for the Mobility and
Anxiety/Depression domains. No DIF was found for gender. Finally, non-uniform DIF
was demonstrated for age group by intervention. The Mobility domain showed the
greatest degree of non-uniform DIF (20/24, 83% of the contrasts). Conclusions:
The finding that the EQ-5D performs differentially depending on the patient group
is an important one and means that the instrument should be used cautiously
when comparisons across different surgical interventions are being made. This
has potentially major ramifications for the use of the instrument as a measure of
efficacy in the NHS.
PIH59
Antenatal Depression and Its Risk Factors Among Women in
Chengdu of China Results From A Hospital Based Survey
Zhao Z M 1, Pan X F 1, Qi X R 2, Li S Q 1, Zhao Y 1, Chang H 1, Xue Q P 1, Wen Y 1, Liu X 2, Yang C X 1
University, Chengdu, China, 2West China Women’s and Children’s Hospital, Sichuan
University, Chengdu, China
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Sichuan
Objectives: Mental health of pregnant women is essential for maternal and neonatal health. However, there is lack of statistics of antenatal depression in China.
The study aimed to investigate the prevalence of antenatal depression and explore
its risk factors among pregnant women in Chengdu of China. Methods: Women
at third trimester of pregnancy were screened for symptoms of depression at antenatal clinics of West China Second Hospital between 28 October 2013 to 28 February
2014 based on the Chinese version of the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale
(EPDS) and a psychosocial risk factors checklist. Results: A total of 2243 pregnant
women aged 30.0±4.0 years participated in the survey. The mean EPDS score was
8.43 (standard deviation: 3.97). With a threshold score of 13, 14.2% were screened as
having symptoms of depression. Age (P=0.007), education level (P<0.001), occupation
(P=0.001), number of children (including the fetus) (P=0.018), number of miscarriage/
abortion (P=0.048), and age of first pregnancy (P=0.001) were associated with antenatal depression in univariable analysis but not multivariable analysis (P> 0.05 for all).
Women who were dissatisfied with living conditions (OR= 1.81; 95% CI: 1.38-2.38),
had a poor relationship with mother-in-law relationship (OR= 2.20; 95% CI: 1.652.92), and had unplanned pregnancy (OR= 1.34, 95% CI: 1.02-1.76) were more likely to
show antenatal depression symptoms. Conclusions: Our study shows antenatal
depression might be prevalent among Chinese women in Chengdu. Early detection
and intervention for antenatal depression may be necessitated to improve maternal
and neonatal health after more systematic studies and reliable data are available.
PIH60
Disutility Associated With Erectile Dysfunction in the Middle-Aged
Or Older Males
Väätäinen S , Martikainen J A
University of Eastern Finland, Kuopio, Finland
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess the long-term grading of health-related quality of life
(HRQL) of care-needed elderly who had received the occupational therapy in
Japan. Methods: We carried out a 2-year follow-up study of multicenter trial.
The subjects were recruited from 26 nursing homes in Japan. The proxy of the
subjects completed a questionnaire of the Health Utilities Index Mark3 (HUI3). We
tested the long-term effect of occupational therapy and aged natural grading of
care-needed elderly. Results: 55 male and 85 female subjects remained at final
follow-up. The mean age of subjects was 76.9 years. The global score of HUI3 of
baseline was 0.377 (SD= 0.270). Their score was improved for three month (mean
score=0.418, SD=0.284), but had deteriorated to 0.328 (SD=0.324) 2-year later. Speech,
Ambulation, Emotion and Cognition had deteriorated significantly among 8 attributes of HUI3. In regression analysis, higher care level significantly increased risk of
deteriorating HRQL of care-needed elderly. Conclusions: Our findings suggest
that occupational therapy have short-term effect for care-needed elderly. However,
we cannot affirm that that occupational therapy has long-term effect. The aging
may deteriorate their HRQL of care-needed elderly naturally.
Objectives: Erectile dysfunction (ED) affects millions of males world-wide. While it
is obvious that ED affects individuals Quality of Life, the quantifiable data on disutility
associated with ED is still lacking. Moreover, the health utility – impact has not been
studied using multiple health utility instruments previously. Our aim was to quantify the disutility caused by different levels of ED using two preference-based health
utility indices simultaneously. Methods: A total of362 middle-aged or older (52-75
year old) males responded to the five-item International Index of Erectile Function
(IIEF-5) in the cross-sectional sample of Savitaipale Study in 2007-2008. The lower
score in IIEF-5 (range 1-25) corresponds to more severe ED. Health utility was assessed
with two separate validated preference-based instruments, 15D and SF-6D. Data were
adjusted for age, number of morbidities and marital status. Minimally important
differences (0.02-0.03 for 15D and 0.04 for SF-6D) were used to guide the clinical
interpration of the results. Results: Both 15D and SF-6D were significantly correlated
with IIEF-5 (p<0.001). When examining the ED categorically, the adjusted marginal
disutility (0.023 in 15D and 0.038 in SF-6D) was statistically significant (p< 0.05) and
clinically noticiable even at the mild ED (IIEF-5 score of 22-25). The marginal disutility
progressively increased with increasing level of dysfunction, and was highest among
the males who had not had sexual activity in past 6 months (0.060 in 15D and 0.093 in
SF-6D, p<0.001 on both). On average, a one point decrease in IIEF-5 corresponded to a
0.003 decrease in 15D (p<0.001) and 0.004 in SF-6D (p<0.001). Conclusions: Erectile
dysfunction can cause a substantial disutility on males. While this condition may
not be life treathening or is not considered a major public health problem societally,
the marginal disutility associated with severe ED is comparable or even greater than
disutility associated with many chronic morbidities.
PIH58
Differential Item Functioning and the Eq-5d: Evidence From the Uk
Hospital Episode Statistics
PIH61
Reference Eq-5d-3l and Eq-5d-5l Data From the Italian General
Population
Smith A B
University of York, York, UK
1University
PIH57
Long-Term Grading of Health-Related Quality of Life of CareNeeded Elderly: A 2-Yr Follow-Up Study
Noto S 1, Izumi R 1, Moriwaki K 2
University of Health and Welfare, Niigata, Japan, 2Kobe Pharmaceutical University, Kobe,
Japan
.
.
.
1Niigata
.
.
Scalone L 1, Cortesi P A 1, Mantovani L G 2, Ciampichini R 1, Cesana G 1
of Milano - Bicocca, Monza, Italy, 2Federico II University of Naples, Naples, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A515
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: No recent Italian norm EQ-5D data were available. Furthermore, norm
data from the new descriptive system with 5 levels were completely missing. The
main objective of the present study was to assess an Italian general population reference data using both the standard EQ-5D-3L version and the recently introduced
EQ-5D-5L. Methods: Large-scale telephone survey was conducted in November
2013 on 6,800 subjects from the general population of the Lombardy region, with
9.8 million residents. They were recruited to be representative of the Lombardy
general adult population as regards age (from 18 years), gender and geographical distribution. Each participant underwent a telephone interview including the
Italian version of the 5L and 3L descriptive system, then, to minimize memory
effects, between the two descriptive systems the participants were asked to report
their socio-demographic data, and finally they answered the question on the visual
analogue scale (VAS). The data collected with the 3L and 5L version descriptive
system were converted into utilities. Results: Participants were 48% male with a
mean (SE) age of 51.9 (0.21). Around half (51.3%) of the participants specified they
have a paid or unpaid work, 15.8% were housewives, 6.2% students were, 5.3% idles
and 26.5% retired. Overall no problems were reported by 86.5% (3L) and 84.2% (5L)
with mobility, by 96.1% (3L) and 94.2% (5L) with self-care, by 88.0% (3L) and 84.9%
(5L) with usual activities, by 58.4% (3L) and 52.8% (5L) with pain/discomfort, and by
66.5% (3L) and 61.7% (5L) with anxiety/depression. The mean (standard error) and
median VAS was 78.2 (0.2) and 80. Mean (SE) utility index obtained from both the
3L and the 5L versions was 0.915 (0.001). Conclusions: Reference EQ-5D-3L and
EQ-5D-5L data on the Italian general adult population are now available. Although
these data were collected in the Lombardy region we can consider our results a
good proxy of the full Country.
PIH62
Patient Preferences: Pro Mixed Modes – Epro Versus Paper
Ross J , Holzbaur E , Wade M , Rothrock T
Almac Clinical Technologies, Souderton, PA, USA
.
.
.
.
Objectives: This presentation expands on a previous ISPOR presentation on
patient acceptance of the use of Mixed Modes for collecting PROs in trials. The
ISPOR PRO Mixed Modes task force recommends when mixing modes to avoid mixing paper with ePRO. However, interest in using paper for PRO collection still exists.
This presentation will investigate survey data to examine if patients prefer ePRO
over paper. Methods: The research (conducted in 2013) includes patients globally (N= 405) who participated in at least one clinical trial requiring patient diaries
in the past two years. Patients were asked about previous diary experiences and
future trial participation. The previous presentation showed most patients are in
favor of mixed modes–mainly due to being able to choose their preferred mode.
This presentation focuses on patients with prior experiences with both paper and
ePRO (N=167). Results: Of paper/ePRO experienced patients, 77.3% preferred ePRO;
76.1% had high agreement that ePRO makes dairy participation easier; 73.1% had
high agreement that ePRO-use makes them more willing to participate in future
diaries. Of patients who prefer ePRO, those who used ePRO in their most recent trial
had significantly higher satisfaction ratings (87.0%) than those who used paper
(55.2%), p< 0.001. Low agreement ratings were associated with dissatisfaction and
longer times per diary entry. Conclusions: These findings show most patients
prefer ePRO and satisfaction rates are higher when patients use their preferred
ePRO mode. Sponsors should consider using ePRO due to patient preference, as
higher satisfaction is associated with optimal compliance and data quality when
implemented appropriately. As lower agreement was associated with dissatisfaction
and longer times per entry, this indicates there may have been issues with ePRO
implementation or instrument selection. Proper implementation planning should
include appropriate ePRO mode/instrument selection, ensuring ease of use while
keeping patient burden low and satisfaction high.
PIH63
Implementation of An Ambulatory Pharmacist-Managed
Anticoagulation Clinic In Qatar: Development of A New Service and
A Pilot On Patients’ Satisfaction and Quality of Life
Awaisu A , Kheir N , Mohamed Ibrahim M I , Al-Taweel H M , Elmubark A E
Qatar University, Doha, Qatar
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Pharmacist-managed anticoagulation clinics have been shown to
improve the quality of life (QoL) of patients receiving anti-clot treatment. The
first pharmacist-managed anticoagulation clinic in Qatar was established at
Al-Wakrah Hospital in March 2013. This study aims to report the development of
a new pharmacist-managed service and to determine the patients’ satisfaction
with the new service and their overall QoL using a validated instrument called
Duke Anticoagulation Satisfaction Scale (DASS). Methods: A new pharmacistmanaged anticoagulation clinic was successfully develop through agreements
with physicians on the scope of the service. A prospective cross-sectional study
using 25-item DASS QoL instrument was conducted at the Anticoagulation Clinic
of Al-Wakra Hospital. An Arabic-translated version of the tool that was conceptually equivalent to the original English version was developed through linguistic
validation and cultural adaptation processes. Each item was assessed using a
7-item Likert-type scale with lower values indicating a better QoL and greater
satisfaction. The primary outcome measures were QoL and satisfaction. Results:
Of the 50 patients attending the anticoagulation clinic, 25 consented to participate in the study. The mean total QoL score of the population was 66±24 (range
34-118), indicating modest QoL. Male patients reported a better QoL than female
patients (61.7 ± 19.5 vs. 73.3 ± 30.7; p= 0.255). Furthermore, participants who were
naïve to anticoagulation treatment showed better QoL compared to non-naïve
participants (61.3±22.3 vs. 80.3±26.0; p= 0.093). However, these differences did not
reach statistical significance. Conclusions: Patients receiving anticoagulation
service managed by pharmacists in Qatar have expressed satisfaction with the
service and a modest QoL that was comparable to what has been reported in the
literature. Additional studies with larger samples are required to further document
the value of the new service.
PIH64
Family Preferences in the Volume VerSUS Outcome Debate:
Implications for the Delivery of Complex Pediatric Care
O’Leary G 1, Lockhart A 1, Mullenger R 2, Warren A 2, Hancock Friesen C 2, Levy A 2,
Molinari M 2, O’Blenes S 2
1IWK Health Centre, Halifax, NS, Canada, 2Dalhousie University, Halifax, NS, Canada
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: A Relationship between volume and outcome for complex medical
procedures has been used as an argument for regionalization; however, this must
be balanced against preferences to have care delivered close to home. The objective
of our study was to determine how families trade-off variations in risk against the
ability to have complex pediatric care delivered locally. Methods: Twenty parents
of children without serious medical problems seen in an outpatient clinic participated in a probability trade-off experiment involving two scenarios in which they
were asked to imagine their child required a complex medical procedure (‘lowrisk’= 5% mortality, ‘high-risk’= 30% mortality) available locally or at an alternate
large center 2.5 hours away by air. Numeric and graphic representations of mortality
risk were reduced in a stepwise fashion for procedures performed at the alternate
center. Thresholds at which participants chose to travel were identified. Participant’s
decisions were then challenged by increasing the costs incurred by travelling to
the alternate center. Results: In the low-risk scenario, participants chose not to
travel until absolute risk was reduced by 2±0.2% (relative risk reduction of 39±3%).
In the high-risk scenario, a larger absolute risk reduction (5.1±0.8%, p= 0.0001) but
smaller relative risk reduction (17±3%, p= 0.0001) triggered a decision to travel. In
the low-risk scenario, only 2 of 8 participants with household income > $100,000/
yr changed their decision to travel when faced with additional costs; however 8 of
12 with lower income changed their decision (p= 0.07). In the high-risk scenario, 1
of 8 in the high income group changed their decision compared to 7 of 12 in the low
income group (p= 0.04). Conclusions: Many families would trade substantially
higher risk to have complex pediatric care delivered locally. These results have
implications for policy development related to delivery of complex care at smaller
children’s hospitals located far from large urban centers.
PIH65
Evaluating Prevalence of Self-Medication in Bahawalpur
Masood I 1, Ahmad M 1, Khan M S 2, Minhas M U 1
Islamia University of Bahawalpur, Bahawalpur, Pakistan, 2The Islamia University of
Bahawalpur, Punjab-Pakistan, Bahawalpur, Pakistan
.
.
.
.
.
.
1The
Objectives: Aim of this study was to determine the prevalence and pattern of selfmedication among different classes in Bahawalpur community Methods: It was a
cross-sectional descriptive study targeting residents of Bahawalpur including almost
every class and gender. Sample size was calculated and 10% was added to encounter
non response, respondents were selected through convenience sampling method.
The data was collected using a pre-tested self-administered questionnaire. The data
collection tool was tested and restructured after a pilot study on a small number
(10% of the calculated sample) of population was tested and re-structured. The data
was analyzed using SPSS version 15 and the results were tabulated Results: A total
420 of the participants responded including literate 280 (66%) illiterate 140 (33%).
Most of the respondents were motivated towards self-medication due to high cost of
prescription medicines (n=312; 74.3%), weak trust on physicians (n= 404; 96.2%) and
drug sellers (n= 217; 51.7%). Significantly high percentage of medical professionals
(n=111,77.6%; p=008) had opinion that self-medication gives desired results as compare to respondents with no-medical background (n= 180; 65%). Conclusions: It
was concluded that self-medication is common among the residents of Bahawalpur
and prevails more among literate and medical health care professionals as compare
to illiterate and those not with medical background.
PIH66
A Systematic Review To Identify the Use of Preference Elicitation
Methods in Health Care Decision Making
Janus S I M 1, Weernink M G M 1, van Til J A 1, Raisch D W 2, van Manen J G 1, IJzerman M J 3
1University of Twente, Enschede, The Netherlands, 2University of New Mexico College of Pharmacy,
Albuquerque, NM, USA, 3University of Twente and MIRA institute for Biomedical Technology &
Technical Medicine, Enschede, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Preference elicitation methods (PEMs) offer the potential to increase
patient-centered medical decision-making (MDM), by offering a measure of benefit
along with a measure of value. Preferences can be applied in decisions on: reimbursement, including health technology assessment (HTA); market access, including
benefit-risk assessment (BRA), and clinical care. The three decision contexts have
different requirements for use and elicitation of preferences. The aim of this systematic review was to identify studies that used PEMs to represent the patient view and
identify the types of health care decisions addressed by PEMs. Additionally, PEMs
were described by methodological and practical characteristics within the three contexts’ requirements. Methods: Search terms included those related to MDM and
patient preferences. Only articles with original data from quantitative PEMs were
included. Results: Articles (n=322) selected included 379 PEMs, comprising matching methods (MM) (n= 71, 18.7%), discrete choice experiments (DCE) (n= 96, 25.3%),
multi-criteria decision analysis (n= 12, 3.2%), and other methods (i. e. rating scales),
which provide estimates inconsistent with utility theory (n= 200, 52.8%). Most
publications of PEMs had an intended use for clinical decisions (n= 134, 40%), HTA
(n= 68, 20%), or BRA (n= 12, 4%). However, many did not specify an intended use
(n= 156, 41.1%). In clinical decisions, rating, ranking, visual analogue scales and
direct choice are used most often. In HTA, DCEs and MM are both used frequently,
and the elicitation of preferences in BRA was limited to DCEs. Conclusions:
Relatively simple preference methods are often adequate in clinical decisions,
because they are easy to administer, give fast results, place low cognitive burden
on the patient, and low analytical burden on the provider. MM and DCE fulfill the
requirements of HTA and BRA but are more complex for the respondents. There
were no PEMs that had low cognitive burden, and strong methodological underpinnings which could deliver adequate information to inform HTA and BRA decisions.
A516
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PIH67
Comparison of Equity Weights of Life Year Gains: A Discrete Choice
Experiment for Japanese and Korean General Public
Goto R 1, Mori T 2
1Kyoto University, Kyoto, Japan, 2Konan University, Kobe, Japan
.
.
Objectives: Setting priorities with limited public resources has gained heated
interests worldwide. Weighting health gains differently for different groups in the
population is another manner to consider equity in cost-effectiveness analysis.
However, there is only a few empirical analysis eliciting general public preference.
This research is to compare equity weights of Japanese and Korean. Methods: We
conducted a web-based survey in Mar 2013 including a discrete choice experiment
(DCE) to elicit general publics’ equity weight for life gains of those from different
groups. We selected attributes and designed this experiment following manners
used in Norman (2013). Thus, we analyzed weights according to the difference of
gender, smoking status, life style, caring status, income and age. Results: 1,280
Japanese and 580 Koreans completed questionnaires and were eligible for analysis.
Japanese put higher weight on male (p< 0.001), non-smokers (p< 0.001), those with
lower income (p< 0.001), carer (p< 0.001) and those with an expected age of death
less than 45 years (p< 0.001). Korean have the same patterns of preference according to income (p< 0.001), caring (p< 0.001) and smoking status (p= 0.026). However,
they equally consider groups from different gender (p= 0.331) and age groups. For
both countries, respondents tend to prefer groups with same characteristics as
them. Conclusions: People from two Asian developed countries with universal
health insurance shows different equity weights. These may reflect the variations
of cultural backgrounds and coverage of health care services.
PIH68
How Iranian People Think About Generic Substitution?
Mehralian G 1, nourmohammadI S 2, Yousefi N 1, Peiravian F 1
1Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, School of Pharmacy, Tehran, Iran, 2Azad
University, Tehran, Iran
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The growth of pharmaceutical expenditure and patients’ out of pocket
has motivated researchers to explore underlying factors affecting on generic substitution both in developed and developing countries. The purpose of this study is
therefore to explore how Iranian people think about generic medicines and what
underlying factors should be taken into account by policy makers to promote the
culture of generic substitution. Methods: A cross-sectional descriptive study inviting Iranian people was performed using a self-administrated anonymous questionnaire. Besides the demographic section, 34 items of developed questionnaire were
categorized to 7 main factors including: experience of patients, efficiency of medicines, cost of medicines, physician’s role, pharmacist’s role, negetive perception of
patients and government interventions. Results: After analyzing 1310 completed
questionnaires, results showed the among the aforementioned factors the government interventions has the first priority to encourage patients to use of generics
medicines instead of brand medicines and followed by physician’s role, pharmacist’s
role, efficiency of medicines, cost of medicines, experience of patients and negetive
perception of patients. Conclusions: In conclusion, the trust of Iranian’s society
to the government, physicians and pharmacists would be a worthy opportunity to
reduce health care expenditure as well as patients’ out of pocket by taking evidencebased decisions toward promotion of generic substitution.
PIH69
Assessment of Health States and Erectile Dysfunction-Associated
Quality of Life Among Adult Males and Females With Male Partners
in Germany, the United Kingdom and the United States
Menegatou E 1, Claeys C 2, Wasserman D 2, Tomaszewski K 2
1KJT Group, Inc., Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 2KJT Group, Inc., Honeoye Falls, NY, USA
.
.
.
.
Objectives: This study assessed the quality of life associated with various states
of erectile dysfunction (ED) among adults: both diagnosed ED sufferers and nonsufferers in Germany, the United Kingdom and the United States. Methods: A
multi-national, cross-sectional online survey was conducted among a representative sample of 2,000 adults (n= 500 Germany, n= 500 UK, n= 1,000 US) with an equal
number of men and women in a heterosexual relationship. Respondents rated
either their or their partner’s erectile function, and health state utilities were
measured using standard gamble (SG) and visual analog scale (VAS) in counterbalanced order. Utilities were estimated for one level from the Erection Hardness
Scale: penis gets hard but not hard enough for penetration. Differences were examined by measure, country and respondent demographics. Results: The SG and
VAS measures yield similar, but not identical mean estimates for the ED health
state. Significant variation exists by measure as well as by country. In comparing
the utility assessments between the countries using SG, German respondents
have significantly higher average utility (0.49) for ED than do respondents from
the UK (0.40), and US (0.41). When examining differences by gender, females have
greater utility for the ED health state when compared to males. Men with ED
report a lower utility for the ED health state when compared to men without ED.
By contrast, females whose partners have ED report a higher utility for the ED
health state when compared to females with partners without ED. Although utility is consistent across most ages, an increase in utility exists for adults aged 75
and over. Conclusions: Notable differences in ED utility emerged by country:
Germans have higher utility for ED when compared to UK and US respondents.
Significant differences in ED utility between males and females suggests there
is an important relationship disconnect between men with ED and their female
partners.
PIH70
Does Price Matter? The Impact of Cost Information On Patient
Decision Making
Chan J Y 1, Butt T 2
School of Economics, London, UK, 2University College London, London, UK
.
1London
.
.
Objectives: In publicly funded health systems such as the United Kingdom (UK)
National Health Service (NHS), patients do not normally face the full economic
cost of treatment decisions, nor are they aware of the potential cost to the system. We investigated whether patient awareness of treatment costs, either to the
system or to themselves, would affect treatment choices. Methods: 344 representative members of the UK public were recruited via an online survey panel.
Respondents were required to make treatment decisions in three different health
conditions (sore throat, psoriasis and sciatica). Respondents were presented with
condition-specific patient decision aids (Option Grids™), each supported by: 1) no
cost information, 2) cost to the NHS (drug/ procedure tariff), 3) cost to patient (drug/
procedure tariff), and 4) access cost to patient (flat cost for all options). Differences
in treatment choices were explored using ANOVA. Significant differences within
each health condition were subsequently explored using t-tests. Results: A significant number of respondents switched choice to the cheapest intervention when
tariff costs to either the system (p< 0.05) or themselves (p< 0.01) were considered
versus no cost information when choosing between treatments for psoriasis. For
all three health conditions, presenting flat access costs increased the likelihood
(p< 0.01) of respondents choosing the treatment option known to have the highest
tariff price. Conclusions: Cost information influences treatment decisions. We
observed that awareness of cost to the system or to oneself encouraged the choice
of lower priced treatment options, whereas flat access charges encouraged the
choice of treatment known to be more expensive. Provision of cost information may
therefore be important for informed decision making, and could also be a policy
tool to generate cost savings for the health system.
PIH71
Health Literacy and Self-Reported Health Status Using the Eq5d-5l: An Exploratory Analysis
Rey-Ares L 1, Augustovski F 2, Irazola V 3, Garay O U 4, Gianneo O 5, Fernández G 5, Morales M 5
for Clinical Effectiveness and Health Policy (IECS), CABA, Argentina, 2Economic
Evaluations & HTA Department; Institute for Clinical Effectiveness and Health Policy (IECS)
and Professor of Public Health, University of Buenos Aires, Buenos Aires, Argentina, 3Institute
for Clinical Effectiveness and Health Policy, Buenos Aires, Argentina, 4IECS Institute for
Clinical Effectiveness and Health Policy, Buenos Aires, Argentina, 5Fondo Nacional de Recursos,
Montevideo, Uruguay
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Institute
Objectives: To describe health literacy (HL) in Uruguayan general population
and its relation with self-reported health status. Methods: As part of an ongoing
Uruguayan EQ-5D-5L valuation study, we included the Short Assessment of Health
Literacy-Spanish questionnaire (SAHL-S), a previously validated instrument that
evaluates HL through 18 items combining word recognition and comprehension.
Low HL is defined by identifying ≤ 14 correct items. We included participants with
valid SALH-S responses, complete sociodemographic characteristics, self-reported
health status with the EQ-5D-5L, and report of previous experience with illness.
This preliminary analysis describes sociodemographic characteristics, HL and selfreported health status and explores the independent association between EQ visual
analogue scale (VAS) score and HL using standard linear regression. Results: Of
773 participants 60.2% were women (mean age 42.02 years; SD: 15.51). VAS mean was
79.34 (DS: 16.39). 52.9% participants had at least one limitation in any of the EQ-5D
domains, 75.9% had experience with illness and 51% in caring others. Educational
attainment (EA) distribution was 17.2% up to primary, 52.3% up to secondary and
30.5% up to tertiary or higher education. Low HL was present in 39.8% of the population. In bivariate analysis aging and low HL were associated with poorer VAS
scores (coef -0.276; p= 0.000; coef -3.028; p= 0.012). Higher VAS scores were observed
with higher EA (coef 2.832; p= 0.001). Multiple regression shows HL is related to VAS
independently of age, but this association loses its statistical significance -becoming borderline- after adjusting for EA and experience in caring others (coef -1.93;
p= 0.098). Conclusions: HL is a recently developed construct that combines formal education and acquired knowledge related to health. This is the first study that
describes HL in Uruguay, and shows that is associated with self-reported health.
Further studies are needed to explore the potential value added to standard educational level measurement.
PIH72
Assessing the Translatability of the Term “Frustrated”
McKown S 1, Angun C 2, Talbert M 3, Brandt B A 4, Gawlicki M C 4
1Corporate Translations, Inc., Chicago, IL, USA, 2Corporate Translations Inc., Odunpazarı,
Eskişehir, Turkey, 3Corporate Translations Inc., Chicago, IL, USA, 4Corporate Translations, Inc., East
Hartford, CT, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The objective of this study was to assess the translatability of “frustrated,” a term commonly used to describe a range of emotions in Clinical Outcomes
Assessments (COA). “Frustrated” includes many constructs, such as “discouragement,” “anger” and “upset.” Previous studies have shown that terms including multiple constructs in English, such as “bother,” are not sufficiently translatable across
all languages. Methods: Back-translations of questionnaires containing the word
“frustrated” were analyzed to assess the translatability of the term. The following
related constructs were also included in analysis: “discouraged,” “angered,” “disappointed” and “upset.” Data collection forms resulting from cognitive debriefing were
also analyzed to determine subjects’ interpretation of “frustrated” as translated in
other languages. Results: “Frustrated” proved to be very problematic for 13 out
of the 24 languages in this study, most notably for Eastern European, Indian and
Asian languages. For example, “frustrated” was translated as “indignant” in Greek,
“disillusioned” in Hungarian, “irritated” in Japanese and “discouraged” in Korean.
Out of 245 subjects, 13% took issue with “frustrated,” indicating that it was not
understood or not appropriate for their languages. Analyses of related constructs
showed that “discouraged” and “angered” were best suited for use, as these terms
were translated with no issues in all 12 languages available for analysis. “Upset”
was found to be equally problematic, and thus rejected as a recommended construct. Conclusions: “Frustrated” is not recommended for use in COAs intended
for international data pooling. Similar to the findings of previous studies, more spe-
A517
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
cific terms, such as “discouraged” and “angered,” translate with greater conceptual
equivalency. Therefore, when seeking to measure the various concepts associated
with the term “frustrated,” measuring more specific constructs independently using
separate questionnaire items is recommended.
PIH73
Mobile Phone Use in Patient Reported Outcomes– An Updated
Literature Search
O’Gorman H
Exco InTouch, Nottingham, UK
had “symptoms” as a primary endpoint; a drug for rheumatoid arthritis (RA) had
“functioning” as its lead secondary endpoint; the remaining six drugs (for pulmonary arterial hypertension (PAH), Crohn’s Disease, smoking cessation, Myasthenia
Gravis, asthma, and overactive bladder) had “HRQOL”, “symptoms, and “functioning”
as minor secondary endpoints. Three drugs -indicated for PAH, seizure, and RA- had
PRO claims in their labels. Conclusions: Although not yet prominent in Japan,
PROs are used in drug clinical trials and label claims. Symptoms, Quality of Life, and
Functioning are the most common PROs used.
.
Objectives: To demonstrate the increasing use of mobile phones to collect patient
reported outcomes in research as a valid method of data collection. Methods: A
literature search was conducted looking at articles published between 2009 and 2014
that referenced electronic diaries of some description. Articles were pulled out that
specifically referenced mobile or cellular phones. Results: 39 of out of 191 articles
found specifically referenced mobile. The studies referenced were carried out on
populations with an age range of 8 years up to 80 (mean 35.4; SD 16.6) and were split
into 15 therapy areas including metabolic and genetic disorders, pain, weight management, sexual activity, respiratory, multiple sclerosis and gastroesophageal reflux
disease. Population size ranged from 12 to 994 (mean 208.3; SD 269.2), and subjects
reported for a minimum of 7 days (up to 6 reports per day) to a maximum of 2 years
(mean 154.3 days; SD 170.6). Notably, 18 out of the 39 studies allowed the subjects
to use their own mobile phone for the reporting and 19 articles referenced smartphones specifically. Conclusions: All concluded that mobile phones were suited
to collect data from subjects. It was noted that the use of mobiles was acceptable
as they are used them in everyday life and found to be convenient; the technology
was also inexpensive to implement. The fact that 46.2% of the studies allowed the
subjects to use their own mobile phones for the reporting emphasises the practicality of using mobile phones in patient reported outcomes. Although the mean age of
all the studies was relatively low, the age range was very wide and researchers can
be confident that older populations could use mobile phones to collect these data.
The technical evolution of mobile technologies and ubiquitous nature show that
this technology is a valid means to collect patient reported outcomes.
PIH74
Regulatory Issues in Pro Advertising: A Review of the Ddmac/Opdp
Letters From 1998 To 2013 To Identify Pro Claims Violations and
Examine Their Evolution Over Time
Acquadro C 1, Regnault A 2, Arnould B 2
Research Trust, Lyon, France, 2Mapi, Lyon, France
.
.
.
PIH76
Comparing the Equivalence of Eq-5d-5l Across Different Modes of
Administration
O’Gorman H 1, Mulhern B 2, Brazier J 2, Rotherham N 1
InTouch, Nottingham, UK, 2University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK
.
.
.
.
1Exco
Objectives: Interest in delivering Patient Reported Outcome Measures (PROMs)
using mobile devices (e-PROMs) has increased in recent years. However there is
debate about the level of equivalence between the traditional pencil and paper
and electronic modes of administration. The aim of this study is to compare the
equivalence of delivering a widely used generic PROM (EQ-5D-5L) pencil and paper
and mobile phone administration modes. Methods: A mobile version of the
EQ-5D-5L was developed with guidance from the EuroQol Group. Two hundred
respondents from a research cohort of people in South Yorkshire were identified,
and randomly allocated to one of the administration modes based on stratifications
for age and gender (and across a range of self-reported health issues). The EQ-5D-5L
was completed either using a mobile device or the standard paper version which
were sent out to the respondent. Follow up usability questions were also included.
EQ-5D equivalence was compared at the dimension and utility and VAS score level
using ANOVA. Results: Response rates were comparable across the arms, with
the majority of respondents owning a smartphone. The mean EQ-5D-5L utility and
VAS scores and the frequency of respondents endorsing the individual EQ-5D-5L
categories across each of the dimensions does not differ across the administration
modes. The majority of the mobile phone completion sample agreed that the mobile
version of EQ-5D-5L was easy to complete, and that the phone was easy to use, and
that they would complete e-PROMs again. Conclusions: Completing e-PROMs
using mobile phones produces equivalent results and response rates to pencil and
paper methods, and respondents are positive towards completing questionnaires
using these methods. This provides evidence that e-PROMs are valid for use to
collect data in a range of settings including clinical trials, routine care, and as, for
example, health diaries.
1Mapi
Objectives: According to the Federal, Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act (FD&C Act),
prescription drug promotion must not be false or misleading, have fair balance, be
consistent with the approved product labeling, and only include claims substantiated by adequate and well-controlled clinical studies. The Office of Prescription
Drug Promotion (OPDP), formerly the Division of Drug Marketing, Advertising and
Communications (DDMAC), was set up to protect the public health by assuring prescription drug information is truthful, balanced and accurately communicated.
The objective of this study was to review the DDMAC/OPDP warning and notice of
violations letters to find out 1) how many violations were in relation to PRO and
HRQL claims and 2) how those evolved after the publication of the FDA PRO draft
guidance in 2006. Methods: DDMAC letters were identified on the “Enforcement
Activities by FDA” webpage. Letters from 1998 to 2013 were all reviewed manually
to identify violations in relation to PRO and HRQL claims during the periods before
and after the publication of the guidance (1998-2005 vs. 2006-2013). Results: 763
letters were reviewed. Each letter included information about one or more violations of the FD&C Act, such as “Omission of Risk Information”, “Overstatement of
Efficacy”, “Unsubstantiated Superiority Claims”, etc. The review showed a letter
volume on the decline (n= 524 for 1998-2005, n= 239 for 2006-2013), with an increase
in PRO violations: 19.50% of all letters (1998-2005) vs. 30.5% (2006-2013). HRQL violations were rarer after 2006 and were more often detected as implicit: 20 false
HRQL claims, of which two were considered implicit (1998-2005) vs. seven false
HRQL claims, of which four were considered implicit (2006-2013). Examples will be
presented. Conclusions: The FDA guidance on PRO measure seems to have had
an influence on HRQL information: less ads with explicit violations and a OPDP’s
tendency to argue over implicit claims.
PIH75
The Use of Patient Reported Outcomes (Pros) By the Pharmaceutical
Industry in Japan – A Brief Review of Pmda Data in Comparison With
Fda and Ema-Approved Label Claims
PIH77
Are Patient Reported Outcomes Relevant To Patients? Learnings
From A Patient Advocate Survey
Holtorf A P 1, Palacios D 2, Brixner D 3
1Health Outcomes Strategies, Basel, Switzerland, 2Novartis Pharma AG, Basel, Switzerland,
3University of Utah, Salt Lake City, UT, USA
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Increasingly, patients become active participants in making decisions
on their therapy. A survey was conducted to understand the experience and expectations of patient organizations (POs) with patient reported outcomes (PRO) as they
are measured today. Methods: An online survey was conducted in English language throughout May 2014 among 40 participants at a global cross disease patient
forum to prepare a discussion of the relevance and usefulness of patient reported
outcomes from the patient perspective. The participants represented a broad range
of disease specific and disease independent patient organizations from various
countries including USA, European countries, Asia, Latina America, Middle East
and Australia. Results: Current PROs were perceived as useful but not optimal
for informing patients in making their own therapy decisions. All of 9 typical PRO
domains were considered important (between 3.9 and 4.7 on a 5 point scale) with
the most important being symptoms (4.6±0.89), Physical Function (4.65±0.59) and
psychological well-being (4.7±0.47). The participants thought that PROs should be
part of all studies throughout the entire life cycle of products including evidence
for clinical research, reimbursement decisions, listing decisions, health technology
assessment (HTA) or comparative effectiveness (CER) studies (all between 4.25 and
4.6 on a 5-point scale). Increasingly, POs develop their own instruments to elicit
PROs from the patient perspective and as patient based evidence. Conclusions:
The concept of patient reported outcomes is good in principle but more is needed
for integrating additional aspects which are relevant for the patients themselves
to understand the full impact and consequences of the therapy. Patient reported
outcomes are a key endpoints from the patient perspective and should be elicited
throughout the entire development and marketing cycle of products.
Ledesma D A 1, Tanaka E 1, Adachi K 1, Rossi B 2
.
.
.
.
.
1Bayer Yakuhin, Ltd., Tokyo, Japan, 2Bayer Yakuhin, Ltd., Osaka, Japan
Objectives: The use of patient-reported outcomes (PROs) in label claims in the
US and Europe is regulated by the US FDA and the EMA, respectively. Japan’s
Pharmaceuticals and Medical Devices Agency (PMDA) does not have such regulations. This study was done to determine whether Japan-based pharmaceutical
companies utilize PRO endpoints at all and in what way, by investigating their
inclusion of PROs in pharmaceutical clinical trials and drug information materials. Methods: We searched the websites of ClinicalTrials. gov and the PMDA for
information on 14 drugs which had received PRO claim approvals from both the
US FDA and EMA from 2006-2010. Search terms were the generic and/or brand
names of the selected drugs (in English and Japanese, as appropriate). PROs were
classified as “symptoms”, “functioning”, and “HRQOL” based on the PRO scale used.
A table comparing PRO type, endpoint positioning, and US and Europe-approved
label claims versus the PRO information reported in Japan for the same drug was
created. Results: Of the above fourteen drugs, four are not yet available in Japan.
One drug with an FDA and EMA-approved “symptoms” claim did not have such in
its Japan clinical trial. Of the nine remaining drugs, the PRO endpoints were as follows: two drugs, indicated for epileptic seizure and for benign prostatic hyperplasia,
PIH78
The Endometriosis Health Profile (Ehp) – A Case Study of Successful
Epro Collaboration
Two R 1, Wilkins G 1, Cox A1, Jenkinson C 2, McEvoy K 3, Churchman D 4, Walzer A 5,
Wichmann K 5
Ltd, Banbury, UK, 2University of Oxford, Oxford, UK, 3CRF Health, London, UK, 4Isis
Outcomes, Oxford, UK, 5Bayer Pharma AG, Berlin, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1PharmaQuest
Objectives: To migrate the UK English Endometriosis Health Profile (EHP) from
paper to ePRO format for completion by respondents on a touchscreen tablet device.
Following migration, to produce translations of the UK English ePRO version in
25 languages. Methods: The draft ePRO version of the EHP was reviewed by the
questionnaire developer, the translation project manager and the sponsor. During
the initial review the questionnaire was assessed for linguistic equivalence with
the paper version and for usability in relation to the target patient group. A number
of factors were considered including layout, response input method and forced
completion. Decisions were made based on the recommendations of the developer,
translation vendor and ePRO vendor according to the specialism of each party, taking into consideration the capabilities of the software and the requirements of the
A518
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
patient group. Following the initial review the tablet-based ePRO version was pilot
tested with 10 endometriosis patients who were native speakers of UK English.
The translated versions of the EHP were adapted for ePRO administration and the
resulting screenshots proofread for accuracy. Results: Feedback from patients
indicated that some amendments to the formatting and ordering of instructions
would be beneficial. However, all respondents indicated that the ePRO version of
the EHP was easy to use and preferable to a paper-based questionnaire. The ePRO
format posed some difficulties for specific languages which required an adjustment
to the layout or wording structure. Conclusions: Cognitive debriefing and usability testing confirmed that the ePRO version of the questionnaire was an accurate
representation of the original paper version. This was achieved via cooperative
input at the initial review stage to ensure that all aspects were considered and close
collaboration throughout the project to find appropriate solutions to the challenges
posed by the ePRO administration of the EHP.
PIH79
Evaluating the Translatability of Physical Assessment Clinical
Outcomes Assessment (Coa) Items
McKown S 1, Talbert M 2, Brandt B A 3, Gawlicki M C 3
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Corporate Translations, Inc., Chicago, IL, USA, 2Corporate Translations
3Corporate Translations, Inc., East
Inc., Chicago, IL, USA,
Hartford, CT, USA
Objectives: The objective of this study is to determine which physical assessment Clinical Outcomes Assessment (COA) questionnaire items are most translatable. Methods: Eighteen (18) physical assessment items were analyzed, using
back-translations to determine conceptual equivalency with the source text.
Previous studies have regarded 80% source conceptual equivalency as a translatability benchmark. Translator feedback regarding cultural appropriateness also
influenced whether certain physical assessment items were optimal for use in questionnaires, as some items might be translatable, but not appropriate for the target
country. Results: Physical assessment items were grouped into three categories:
highly translatable, moderately translatable, and problematic. Highly translatable
examples, “running errands,” “getting around town” and “washing yourself” were
translated with conceptual equivalency 100% of the time, and were considered
culturally appropriate for all languages. Moderately translatable items, such as
“taking a trip” may be misconstrued, as the distance implied may differ across
languages. “Bathe yourself” was translated with 87% conceptual equivalency, and
may be misunderstood as “taking a bath,” when the intention is to clean oneself.
Problematic items, such as “going out,” translated with conceptual equivalency
only 76% of the time, requiring a destination or activity to be comprehensible in
other languages. “Walking a block,” although achieving 84% conceptual equivalency,
is not applicable nor understood in many languages. When measuring distance
walked, it is recommended to be specific, using examples such as 100 meters or
a kilometer. Conclusions: Specific concepts appear to be more translatable
and universal, such as “getting around town” and “walking 100 meters. ” Items
left open for interpretation, such as “bathing yourself” or “taking a trip” can cause
moderate translation difficulties. Additionally, many languages cannot coherently
translate less specific items, such as “going out,” or translate culturally specific
items. Although “walking a block” is translatable, such an example is unlikely to be
understood in many languages.
PIH80
Theoretical and Practical Possibilities of the Measurement of
Postoperative Pain in Obstetric Intensive Ward
Oláh A 1, Toldyné Beck M 1, Müller Á 1, Knisz J 1, Gelencsér E 2, Szunomár S 1, Boncz I 3,
Fullér N 1
1University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary, 2University of Pécs, Kaposvár, Hungary, 3Faculty of Health
Sciences, University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The measurement of the degree of pain and the exploration of influencing factors to compare data about the evaluation of postoperative pain given
patients and nurses on a numeric scale. The connection between BMI index, age
and verification of need for opiate associated with BMI was evaluated. Our aim
was to measure whether nurses underestimate the level of pain in patients as
well to show the advantages of multimodal analgesia and the additional opiate
needs. Methods: The survey was conducted between the 1st November and 15th
of December in 2013 among 40 patients who had surgery and 10 nurses dealing with
them afterwards. Data was collected at the sub intensive ward of the Department
of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, University of Pécs. The analysis of results was
performed with MO Excel 2007 program. For data analysis absolute and relative
frequency, Chi-square test, two-sample t-test, correlation and linear regression
analysis besides the significance level p< 0,05. Results were presented with main
confidence interval. Results: Nurses underestimated the patients’ pain value
(p= 0,011). Tight and continuous connection with the patient’s vital parameters had
not been proved (p>0,05). Connection was not found between the age and BMI index
of the patients (p= 0,134), however in case of the mostly overweight sample group
the need for opiate wasn’t increased (p= 0,62). It is shown by the survey that open
surgeries aren’t result in higher pain value which was not significant after adequate
analgesia (p> 0,05). The benefit of multimodal therapy in analgesia had been proved,
although it had not resulted in decreased need for opiate (p=0,807). Conclusions:
It is essential to conduct a survey on the knowledge of health care workers in the
future and to organize possible workshops and create protocols. Moreover, pain
should be monitored minimum three times a day (Shugarman LR., 2010, Canada).
PIH81
Health Related Quality of Life in Patients Receiving Home Enteral
Nutrition in Spain Assessed By A Specific Questionnaire: Nutriqol®
Apezetxea A 1, Cuerda C 2, Virgili N 3, Irles J A 4, Cuesta F 5, Casanueva F 6, Carrillo L 7, Layola
M 8, Lizán L 9
1Hospital Basurto, Bilbao, Spain, 2Hospital Universitario Gregorio Marañón, Madrid, Spain,
3Hospital Bellvitge, Barcelona, Spain, 4Hospital Universitario Nuestra Señora de Valme, Sevilla,
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Spain, 5Hospital San Carlos, Madrid, Spain, 6Hospital Universitario Santiago de Compostela,
Santiago de Compostela, Spain, 7Centro de Salud Victoria de Acentejo, Santa Cruz de Tenerife,
Spain, 8Nestle health science, Barcelona, Spain, 9Outcomes’10, Castellon, Spain
Objectives: To assess Health Related Quality of Life (HRQoL) in patients receiving
Home Enteral Nutrition (HEN) using NutriQoL® questionnaire in Spain. Methods:
NutriQoL®, a specific questionnaire, developed and validated in Spain, for the assessment of HRQoL of patients receiving HEN regardless of the underlying condition was
administered to a prospective cohort from 9 Spanish hospitals. It includes 17 pairs
of items of HEN-related HRQoL grouped in two dimensions: 1) physical functioning
and activities of daily living; 2) social life aspects, scoring from -51 (worst HRQoL) to
51 (best HRQoL). Cluster analysis using k-means identified groups of patients with
similar HRQoL. Results: A total of 140 subjects (61.4% men; mean (SD) age: 62.7
(15.41) participated. NutriQoL® mean total score was 14.98 (14.86). Dimension 1 and
2 scored 13.55 (11.71) and 1.40 (4.74). Cancer patients presented lower HRQoL compared to neurological and malabsorption patients (12.76 vs. 18.11 vs. 17.37; p= 0.098).
Patients receiving oral HEN as a supplement referred higher HRQoL than those
receiving HEN by gastrostomy or nasogastric tube (19.54 vs. 14.00 vs. 7.02; p< 0.001)
as their only nutrition route (19.33 vs. 8.18; p< 0.001). Up to 71.4% of patients referred
HRQoL improvements since the introduction of HEN. Cluster analysis resulted in
4 groups according to NutriQoL® score. Cluster 1 [32.23 (5.83)]: Neurologic patients
receiving oral HEN as a supplement. Cluster 2 [18.19 (3.94)]: oncologic disease receiving HEN by gastrostomy as a supplement. Cluster 3 and 4: [3.9 (4.67) and 12.21 (5.95)]:
oncologic patients receiving oral HEN as a supplement, with differences in terms of
severity (Charlson index 2.45 (2.65) vs. 3.14 (2.57). Conclusions: NutriQoL® results
demonstrated a sample with a fairly good HRQoL, where the introduction of HEN
had improved their HRQoL. In patients receiving HEN, physical functioning and
activities of daily living were better predictors than social life domain.
PIH82
Quality of Life in Pregnant Women Attending Anti-Natal Clinics in
Rural and Urban Areas of Delta State
Arute J E 1, Eniojukan J F 2, Odili V O 1
STATE UNIVERSITY, ABRAKA, Nigeria, 2Niger Delta University, Wilberforce
Island, Nigeria
.
.
.
.
.
.
1DELTA
Objectives: Preventing problems for mothers and babies depends on an operational continuum of care with accessible, high quality care before and during pregnancy, childbirth, and the postnatal period. The objective of this study is to evaluate
the quality of life of pregnant women attending antenatal clinics in rural and urban
areas of Delta State, Nigeria. Methods: A descriptive cross sectional study design
was used. Six hundred and ninety nine pregnant women attending antenatal clinics
in selected hospitals were interviewed using a 31 item pretested, structured questionnaire developed using the World Health Organization Quality of Life (WHOQOL)
on Pregnancy assessment brief template. Data assessed include socio-demographics
and questions relating to physical, psychological, social and environmental health
were used to assess the health related quality of life values in each of the study
participants. Data collected were analyzed using the Statistical Package for Social
Sciences (SPSS) software version 16.0. The level of statistical significance was set
at P< 0.0001. Results: The mean age of the respondent was 27±5.04. The HRQOL
mean scores were highest for the environmental domain (26.39±5.34) and lowest for the social relationship domain (11.43±1.81). The overall QOL mean scores
in the other two domains were: physical health (24.84±3.74), psychological health
(21.84±3.03). Significant differences were observed in all domains except social relationship. Conclusions: The health related of life (HRQOL) in pregnant women
was found to be lower in those living in the rural areas than their counterparts in
the urban areas in all domains except social relationships.
INDIVIDUAL’S HEALTH – Health Care Use & Policy Studies
PIH83
Hospital Drg Costing and Health Services Use of Very Pre-Term
Infants From the Proprems Neuro Study Across 10 Hospitals in
Australia and New Zealand
Sia K L 1, Gold L 1, Jacobs S 2, Cheong J 2, Opie G 3, Garland S 2, Donath S 4, Hickey L 2, Boland
R 4, Webster C 5
1Deakin Health Economics, Melbourne, Australia, 2Royal Women’s Hospital, Melbourne, Australia,
3Mercy Hospital for Women, Melbourne, Australia, 4Murdoch Children’s Research Institute,
Melbourne, Australia, 5Northern Hospital, Melbourne, Australia
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Mortality and morbidity of very preterm (born < 32 weeks’ gestation)
and very-low-birth-weight (VLBW, < 1500g) infants impose substantially on finite
health resources. This study estimated costs of hospital and non-hospital services
for a cohort enrolled in ProPrems Neuro, of very preterm/VLBW infants from birth
to 24 months’ age corrected for prematurity. We also tested the sensitivity of results
to the costing approach used. Methods: ProPrems Neuro study assesses the 2-year
outcomes of very preterm/VLBW infants from Australia and New Zealand from
2007-2011 in a prospective multicentre, double-blinded randomised controlled trial
of probiotic administration. Infants’ health resource use was collected from medical
assessment records at birth hospitals, parent report and, with parental consent,
from Medicare Australia (Government database) for resource use up to 24 months.
Hospital costs were calculated separately by the Victorian (State) Casemix funding
approach and the newly implemented national activity-based funding (ABF) algorithm. AR-DRG diagnostic/procedural codes were used to classify inpatient episodes
by prematurity/birth weight, complications, length of stay (LoS), hospital and patient
characteristics. Costs were measured in 2013 Australian dollars. Results: 1099
preterm infants across 10 hospitals were included. Average costs were highest for
infants with birth weight < 750g: $224,158 with mean LoS 105 days. Cost comparison between Casemix and ABF systems showed significantly lower costs using the
national algorithm. Mean cost difference for the largest participating hospital was
$9132 (95%CI 5998, 12267; p< 0.001). Final results of infant health service use to 2
A519
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
years corrected age will be presented in November 2014 with follow-up completion and data release from Government database by August 2014. Conclusions:
Preterm infants showed high services use including hospitalisation, with associated
high costs. Costs vary by patient characteristics and costing approach. This study’s
results should inform effective resource planning of neonatal health services and
development of future prevention interventions aimed at preterm birth.
PIH84
Daily Dose and Costs Associated With Maintenance Therapy of
Topical Testosterone Agents Among Hypogonadal Men
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Topical testosterone agents (TTAs) are commonly used to raise low
serum levels of testosterone in men. After initiating at a recommended starting dose
(RSD), patients may undergo dose titration to achieve an appropriate maintenance
dose. The objective of this study was to compare daily maintenance doses and
costs of treatment with TTAs from US payer perspective in adult men diagnosed
with Hypogonadism (HG). Methods: Adult men with a HG-associated diagnoses initiated at the RSD with Axiron® (Lilly USA, LLC; RSD 60mg per day; N= 209),
AndroGel® 1% (AbbVie Inc.; 50mg per day; N= 614), AndroGel® 1.62% (AbbVie Inc.;
40.5mg per day; N= 235), or Testim® (Auxilium Pharmaceuticals, Inc.; 50mg per day;
N= 558) between January 1, 2011 and March 31, 2012 were identified in a database
of commercially insured beneficiaries. Patients were required to have continuous
eligibility and no claims of the index therapy in 12 months prior to and at least 1
month of continuous eligibility following initiation. Baseline demographic characteristics, Charlson Comorbidity Index (CCI), comorbidities, and testosterone use
were compared using chi-squared test for categorical variables and Wilcoxon ranksum test for continuous variables. Mean dose was estimated per-person per-day
(PPPD). Risk-adjusted dose and payer costs PPPD were estimated with a generalized
linear model. Results: Maintenance dose was attained at month 4. Mean dose
PPPD in month 4 was 68.45mg, 56.68 mg, 51.18mg, and 59.24mg and risk-adjusted
dose PPPD was 113.3%, 113.5%, 126.3%, and 118.7% of RSD for Axiron, AndroGel
1% (non-significant vs. Axiron), AndroGel 1.62% (P< 0.001 vs. Axiron), and Testim
(P= 0.047 vs. Axiron), respectively. Risk-adjusted third-party payer costs PPPD were
$7.49, $9.49, $10.39, and $9.59 (all P< 0.001 vs. Axiron), respectively. Conclusions:
Maintenance dose as a proportion of RSD was the least among Axiron and AndroGel
1% patients, while third-party payer costs for the maintenance dose were lowest
among Axiron patients.
PIH85
The Efficiency Evaluation of the Rule From Drug Market Regulation
Chamber (Cmed) Proposed To Public Medicines Acquisitions in
Antitrust Market Conditions
SantAnna F A
ANVISA, brasilia, Brazil
.
.
Objectives: The aim of this work is measure the efficiency of public medicine
purchase considering competitive markets applied by the rule that establishes
PMVG. Methods: The competitive market was defined as more than 5 (five) pharmaceutical manufactories. Two lists were built, one with PMVG (PMVG databank),
established by CMED, and the other list contains the public prices acquisitions
before and after the enacted CAP legislation (Health Price Bank – BPS databank). The
lists were separated in two groups. The first contains the prices of PMVG databank
and BPS databank between 2004 and 2006 (group 1), and the second complains
the prices for the period between 2007 and 2012 (group 2). The comparison of two
groups, before CAP (group 1) and after CAP (group 2), was conducted by Student
t-test one-tailed of the mean medicine prices (significance level of 5%, assuming
unequal variances). Results: The list resulted in a selection of 29 medicines. Six
(6) medicines had an average BPS price before CAP less than or equal to the average BPS price after CAP, however, only 1 was statistically significant (α ≤ 0.05). In
contrast, 23 medicines had an average BPS price after CAP significantly lower or
equal to the average BPS price before CAP, but only 5 (five) no statistically significant
(α ≤ 0.05). Conclusions: For competitive market we have observed efficiency loss
by application of CMED legislation.
PIH86
The Efficiency Evaluation of the Rule From Drug Market Regulation
Chamber (Cmed) Proposed To Public Medicines Acquisitions
Araujo M A M
ANVISA, Brasilia, Brazil
.
.
PIH87
Implementation of A Collaborative Pharmacy Practice Model in
Nursing Homes of A Swiss Canton: Drug Cost Monitoring Between
2009 and 2012
Zeukeng M J 1, Niquille A 2, Locca J F 2, Perraudin C 3, Bugnon O 1
of pharmaceutical sciences, University of Geneva, Lausanne, Switzerland, 2University
of Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland, 3School of pharmaceutical sciences, University of Geneva,
University of Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland
.
Kaltenboeck A 1, Boytsov N 2, Hayes-Larson E 1, San Roman A 1, Ivanova J 1, Birnbaum H 3,
Foster S 2, Vazquez J 2, Muram D2, Swindle R 2
1Analysis Group, Inc., New York, NY, USA, 2Eli Lilly and Company, Indianapolis, IN, USA,
3Analysis Group, Inc., Boston, MA, USA
.
cally significant (α ≤ 0.05). In contrast, 47 medicines had an average BPS price
after CAP significantly lower or equal to the average BPS price before CAP (α ≤
0.05). Conclusions: It is concluded that this CMED legislation is economic and
social efficient.
.
Objectives: The aim of this work is measure the efficiency of this rule that established PMVG for public medicine purchase. Methods: Two lists were built, one
with PMVG (PMVG databank), established by CMED, and the other list contains
the public prices acquisitions before and after the enacted CAP legislation (Health
Price Bank – BPS databank). The lists were separated in two groups. The first contains the prices of PMVG databank and BPS databank between 2004 and 2006
(group 1), and the second complains the prices for the period between 2007 and
2012 (group 2). The comparison of two groups, before CAP (group 1) and after CAP
(group 2), was conducted by Student t-test one-tailed of the mean medicine prices
(significance level of 5%, assuming unequal variances). Results: CMED implemented The Price Adequacy Coefficient (CAP) by publishing the Resolution CMED
nº 04 on 18thof December of 2006. It is a mandatory minimum discount to be
applied by pharmaceutical companies and distributors in the Factory Price of
medicines (PF) authorized, resulting on a public price cap (PMVG). There is no
evidence of the efficiency, or the real need for this regulatory activity performed
by CMED geared to the drug public acquisitions. The list resulted in a selection of
68 medicines. Fourteen (14) medicines had an average BPS price before CAP less
than or equal to the average BPS price after CAP, however, only 4 were statisti-
.
.
.
.
.
.
1School
Objectives: The aging of the population and the increase of chronic disease
patients represent the current medical and socio-economic challenges. In 2008,
facing considerable increase of medicines cost in nursing homes (NH) in the
canton of Vaud (Switzerland), professionals around the resident were invited to
develop a collaborative pharmacy practice model derived from the successful
experimentation in the canton of Fribourg. The intervention called Quality Circle
in NH is an evidence-based program with a direct influence on the prescriber, that
promotes team based care and clinical guidelines. The model has showed sustainable evidence of the cost containment of medicines without affecting the quality of
care. The objective of this study was to assess the first results of economic impact
of the program in NH engaged between 2009 and 2012. Methods: Individual
data by NH resident was derived from community pharmacists’ invoice and from
resident admission data. The evolution of the daily mean drug cost per resident
was compared to the evolution of the daily mean drug cost of the population
over 65 years old in primary care from cantonal pharmacy invoice (Swiss Health
Observatory, OBSAN). Results: Between 2009 and 2012,13 NH were entered into
the program (601/6’492 beds, 9.3%), between 9 and 11 NH were monitored. In 2012,
the mean age of residents was 88 (SD 7.3) years old; 78% were women. From 2009
to 2012 the daily mean drug cost per resident of the program decreased to 10.3%
from 6.8 to 6.1 EUR, representing a clear reduction compared to cantonal invoice
that record an increase of 0.59%. Conclusions: The monitoring of the program
shows first positive results due to the reduction of drug costs. Nevertheless, this
model has an operating cost. The next step will be to determine the break even
point of the intervention.
PIH88
Fda Cdx Category Medication Use During Pregnancy in the
United States
Raval A , Pan X , Sambamoorthi U
West Virginia University, Morgantown, WV, USA
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess the patterns and factors associated with prescription
of FDA classified C, D and X category drugs (unsafe medications) during pregnancy. Methods: Cross-sectional analysis was conducted of pregnant women aged
20 and 49 years using data from the Medical Expenditure Panel Survey (MEPS) for the
years 2009 and 2011. Difference in the demographic variables, socioeconomic status,
access to health care, and chronic conditions were tested for the use of safe medications. All analyses accounted for the complex survey design of MEPS. Results:
The study sample consisted of 1603 pregnant women (whites [595 (58.8%)], married
[924 (66.3%)], employed [918 (64.5%)], no chronic illness [1103 (65%)]). A total of 413
(28.3%) women utilized medication of FDA category CDX. The use of the category
C medications was highest [337 (23.4%)] drugs followed by category D [101 (6.9 %)],
and category X [64 (4.4)]. Women with chronic illness [adjusted Odds Ratio (aOR) =
1.61; 95% CI = 1.03, 2.52, P < 0.001], having fair or poor perceived health status (aOR =
1.95; 95% CI= 1.15, 3.31, P < 0.05), doing regular physical activity (aOR = 1.50; 95% CI=
1.12, 2.01, P < 0.01) were more likely to receive unsafe medication, while pregnant
women with less than higher secondary education (OR = 0.30; 95% CI = 0.11,0. 81,
P < 0.05), with near poor (aOR: 0.53, 95% CI: 0.31, 0.91, P< 0.05) or middle income (aOR:
0.62, 95% CI: 0.40, 0.95, P < 0.05), were less likely to receive unsafe medications. There
were no differences rates of unsafe medications use by age, race, marital status,
employment status, mental health, and smoking status. Conclusions: Nearly
one-third of all pregnant women used FDA category CDX drugs. Interventions should
be carried out to reduce utilization of FDA CDX especially among the women with
chronic conditions and poor health status.
PIH89
Evaluation of Patient and Financial Outcomes Associated With
Advanced Infertility Treatment Options
Locklear J 1, Bozkaya D 2, Migliaccio K 2, Bramley T 3, Phillips A L 1, Mahony M 1
1EMD Serono, Inc., Rockland, MA, USA, 2Xcenda, L.L.C., Palm Harbor, FL, USA, 3Xcenda, Palm
Harbor, FL, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: A model was designed to evaluate infertility treatment protocols and
examines the medical and pharmacy budget impact from a patient and health
plan perspective. Methods: An Excel-based platform (Microsoft Excel 2010) was
designed to model the cost and expected number of pregnancies associated with
the following advanced infertility treatments: natural cycle intrauterine insemination (IUI), IUI with clomiphene citrate (IUI-C), IUI with gonadotropins (IUI-G), in vitro
fertilization (IVF) and IVF with intracytoplasmic injection (IVF+ICSI). The model is
designed to customize inputs within key parameters including population, treatment strategies and health plan coverage. Standard fertility treatment strategy can
choose to enter one of five standard first line treatment pathways including IUI,
IUI-C, IUI-G, IVF or IVF+ICSI. Fast track fertility treatment strategy does not include
the use of IUI-G. Health plan coverage allows end user to input drug coverage (yes/
no, copayment per cycle and patient coinsurance) and procedure coverage (yes/no,
number of cycles covered, copayment, number of covered doctor visits per cycle
and patient coinsurance). Results: Default model population of women initiating
fertility treatment is 1,555. The total cost to the health plan per year (health plan
A520
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
perspective) for the standard fertility treatment strategy is about 50M USD compared to the fast track fertility treatment strategy at about 41M USD for a net budget
impact of 9M USD. The average cost per patient per year (patient perspective) for
the standard fertility treatment strategy is approximately 4,800 USD compared to
the fast track fertility treatment strategy at an estimated 4,200 USD for a net budget
impact of approximately 600 USD. Results vary upon user inputs. Conclusions:
An Excel-based model was developed to assist managed care organizations and
employers with the development of an optimal fertility benefit design. The model
serves as an educational tool to evaluate various fertility benefit designs in terms
of patient and financial outcomes.
PIH90
Potentially Inappropriate Medicines and Potential Prescribing
Omissions in Older People and Their Association With Health Care
Utilization: A Retrospective Cohort Study
Moriarty F 1, Cahir C 2, Fahey T 1, Bennett K 3
College of Surgeons in Ireland, Dublin, Ireland, 2Trinity College Dublin, Dublin 8, Ireland,
3Trinity College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland
.
.
.
.
mary profile we used the data of frequency by age and gender for this specialised
profile obtaining this from the minimum joint data base of the hospital discharge.
The profile of the pharmaceutical expenditure by age and gender was obtained
from the pharmacy invoice, once the public contribution was deducted. The estimated population in 10 years was obtained from the National Statistic Institute.
(INE). Results: aging results in a cumulative annual rate for the period 2011-2021
for public health expenditure growth of 5.34%. The aging effect implies a cumulative annual rate in the period 2011-2021 of 6.43% and a decrease of -0.69% due to
the range effect (decrease in population). Of all the segments, the largest increase
is in the pharmaceutical costs with an accumulated increase of 8.81%, of which
5,65% is in primary attention and 4,78% in specialised attention. Conclusions:
According to our results, population growth or aging are determining aspects in
public health expenditure increase. Using data directly from each region will explain
the differences. In the case of Extremadura, the age factor is very important when
increasing the pressure of the public health cost, having a special influence in the
field of pharmaceutical expenditure and primary attention.
1Royal
Objectives: Older people are vulnerable to medicine-related adverse effects. In
response to these concerns, prescribing indicators have been developed addressing: Potentially Inappropriate Medicines (PIMs), medicines with unfavourable riskbenefit ratios and Potential Prescribing Omissions (PPOs), omission of indicated
medicines with a clear benefit. Little is known about the impact of PIMs and PPOs
on health care utilization. This study aims to determine the association between
PIMs and PPOs and health care utilization. Methods: This is a retrospective cohort
study of 2,051 community-dwelling participants in The Irish Longitudinal Study on
Ageing (TILDA) aged ≥ 65 years with linked medication dispensing history from a
national pharmacy claims database. PIM and PPO exposure in the 12 months prior
to participants’ TILDA interviews was determined using validated prescribing indicators: Screening Tool for Older Persons’ Prescriptions (STOPP), the Screening Tool
to Alert doctors to Right Treatment (START), Beers’ criteria and Assessing Care of
Vulnerable Elders (ACOVE) indicators. Outcome measures used were self-reported
number of hospital visits (emergency department or inpatient admissions) and
general practitioner (GP) visits in the previous year. Poisson regression models were
used to determine the associations between PIMs and PPOs and these outcomes,
adjusting for age, sex, education, number of medications, chronic conditions, and
health insurance status. Results: Overall PIM prevalence was 19.8-52.7% and PPO
prevalence was 43.6-44.8% depending on the screening tool applied. Independent
of screening tool used, PIMs and PPOs were significantly associated with hospital visits. For example, the adjusted Incident Rate Ratio (IRR) for each additional
STOPP PIM was 1.24 (95%CI= 1.15-1.35). With the exception of START PPOs, PIM and
PPO exposure were also significantly associated with GP visits (adjusted IRR= 1.10
(95%CI= 1.06-1.15) for each additional Beers’ PIM for example). Conclusions: PIM/
PPO exposure is independently associated with increased health care utilization,
supporting application of PIM/PPO indicators as robust measures of health care
quality and patient safety in relation to prescribed medications.
PIH91
Impact of Assisted Reproductive Therapy (Art) On Infant Health and
Health Care Cost Outcomes
Tabano D C , Schroeder A , Sullivan K , Vaidya N
University of Colorado School of Pharmacy, Aurora, CO, USA
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Assisted reproductive therapy (ART) has increased dramatically in
the US over the past several decades, nearly doubling from 1999 to 2008. Prior
research has evaluated multiple outcomes from ART including newborn survival
and birth weight as well as cost analyses measuring cost per live birth; despite
robust information on ART as a whole there is no Colorado-specific data on neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) outcomes following ART and its economic implications. Methods: Using data from the Colorado Department of Public Health
and Environment (CDPHE) - Colorado Birth Certificate Database from 2007-2012,
we use multivariable logistic regression to determine if ART births are associated with a higher risk of NICU admission compared to non-ART (no fertility
treatment) births. We compare the risk of NICU admission among the full birth
cohort and a singleton-only cohort controlling for plural births and birth order.
We use Colorado state Health Care Policy and Financing (HCPF) fiscal year 2007-08,
Colorado Centre for Reproductive Medicine costs and Colorado State Medicaid 2012
fee schedule data to estimate average NICU admission rates, total ART procedural
costs and average costs of delivery, respectively. Results: 190,795 live births in
2007-2012 were included into the birth cohort for analysis (12,666 ART births;
178,129 non-ART births). ART births resulted in a 52% increased risk of being
admitted to the NICU compared to non-ART births (OR 1.52 [95% CI 1.38,1. 69]);
singleton-only ART births had a 39% greater risk of being admitted to the NICU
compared with singleton non-ART births (OR 1.39 [95% CI 1.18,1. 65]). Average
NICU admission costs were estimated at $ 6,165.78 per ART birth and $ 331.85 per
non-ART birth. Conclusions: ART births in Colorado have a higher risk of NICU
admission compared to non-ART births. The economic impact of NICU admissions
is 18.6 times greater among ART births compared to non-ART births.
PIH92
Aging Impact Over the National Health Cost in Extremadura Public
Health Expenditure of Extremadura in the Period 2011-21
Hidalgo A 1, Alonsog S 2, Vizcaino S 2, Montaño L 2, Alvarez M2, Maiilo M A 2, Muñoz J I 2,
Sanchez-Chorro J L 2
1Instituto Max Weber, Majadahonda, Spain, 2Servicio Extremeño de Salud, Merida, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
PIH93
Kazakhstan VerSUS Uzbekistan: A Review of the Drug Provision
Systems
Rainova K , Izmirlieva M , Ando G
IHS, London, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: As is the case with many of the Commonwealth of Independent
Countries (CIS), since the collapse of the Soviet Union, both Kazakhstan and
Uzbekistan have been re-building health care provision, and improving access
to medications for their population. This study compares the two separate paths
the countries have taken, and aims to establish the outcomes achieved by the
two systems as well as the direction of future reforms. Methods: Secondary
research focused on analysing the systems in place in the two countries, focusing on drug provision. The study assessed the mechanisms in place, drawing
comparisons between the two systems, with a particular focus on the outcomes
achieved. Results: Uzbekistan provides medications free of cost for certain categories of patients, while in Kazakhstan, the government has approved a list of drugs
that are provided for free as part of the guaranteed volume of free medical care. In
both the cases these fall under an outpatient setting. Although the procurement of
drugs is carried out mostly via tenders, Kazakhstan’s system involves establishing
price ceilings. In Uzbekistan, retail and wholesale margins are controlled. Between
2002-2012, public health expenditure as a percentage of total health expenditure
rose from 54% to 58% in Kazakhstan and from 45% to 53% in Uzbekistan. Life expectancy however, increased from 65.9 to 69.6 years in Kazakhstan and from 67.1 to 68.1
years in Uzbekistan. Conclusions: With growing government health expenditure, reflecting the expansion of the health care systems, the countries are likely
to increasingly look into containing costs. Given that some pricing mechanism
is already in place in Kazakhstan, it may consider implementing tighter pricing
regulations, moving closer to those seen in Europe. In Uzbekistan, the government
may potentially consider expanding the beneficiary categories while ensuring competiveness within the tendering process.
PIH94
Psychometric Properties of the 16-Item Sort form Version of the
Menopause Cervantes Health-Related-Quality-of-Life Scale: the
Cervantes-Sf
Coronado P 1, Sánchez Borrego R 2, Ruiz Díaz M A 3, Rejas Gutiérrez J 4
Universitario San Carlos, Madrid, Spain, 2Clínica DIATROS, Barcelona, Spain, Spain,
3Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Madrid, Spain, 4Pfizer S.L.U., Alcobendas/Madrid, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
1Hospital
Objectives: The Cervantes scale is a specific health-related-quality-of-life (HRQoL)
questionnaire developed in Spanish women through and beyond menopause. The
original 31-item scale was reduced to a less time consuming 16-item sort form:
The Cervantes-SF. The aim of this work was to assess the psychometric properties
of the Cervantes-SF in a routine clinical sample of perimenopause and postmenopause women. Methods: Peri and postmenopause adult women were recruited in
twelve outpatient clinics of Gynecology. All of the patients completed both scales,
the 31-items form and the abridged version, however, order of administration was
balanced equally to avoid administration bias. A sub-sample of 31 women answered
the sort form within 1-2 weeks later (rete-test). Correlation between forms and testretest reliability were used to test measurement stability. Item analysis, internal
consistency reliability, item-total and item-domain correlations and item correlation with the generic Spanish version of the EQ-5D-3L questionnaire were also
studied. Results: A sample of 215 women [mean age 55 years old (SD= 5.3)] was
enrolled. Internal consistency was good (Cronbach’s a=0.829) but slightly lower than
that of the original scale (a= 0.895). Dimension reliabilities ranged between a= 0.636
(Health) and a= 0.923 (Vasomotor). Correlations between extended and reduced
subscales was high and significant in all cases (p< 0.001), ranging from r= 0.790 for
Health to r= 0.872 for Vasomotor. Correlation between total scores was also high
(r= 0.885) and no differences were found between mean scores (Effect size= 0.353).
Short-form total score correlation with EQ-5D utility score was negative and significant (r= -0.487) and also with EQ-5D Health VAS (r= -0.432). Test-retest correlation
was high (r= 0.886). Completion of Cervantes-SF required half of the time than the
original scale. Conclusions: The abridged 16-item Cervantes scale (Cervantes-SF)
maintained the original psychometric properties. This version extends 51% of the
original length, being faster to apply and making it specially suitable for routine
medical practice.
.
Objectives: To estimate the effect of demographic component in the evolution
of public health expenditure of Extremadura in the period 2011-21 Methods: we
estimated health expenditure profiles by age and gender in 2011. Then, we used
population projections to calculate future health spending. To obtain those profiles
we used data obtained from the information systems of Extremadura. For the pri-
PIH95
Predictions for Medical Subsidy Enrollment Among Young Children
From High-Risk Families in Taipei
Lussier E C 1, Ting T T 2, Lin C Y 3, Hung N 1, Chen C Y 1
University, Taipei, Taiwan, 2Academia Sinica, Taipei, Taiwan, 3Taipei Tzuchi
General Hospital, Taipei, Taiwan
.
.
.
1National Yang-Ming
.
.
.
.
.
.
A521
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: The current study looks to explore young children from high-risk families in the Taipei City setting. High-risk social welfare intervention was investigated.
First, differences between enrollees and non-enrollees for medical subsidy program
among high-risk family whose cases were started in 2009 or 2010 will be looked at.
Second, the study will try to determine the social welfare intervention’s effectiveness in increasing application for medical subsidy program and finding any predictors which may have helped or harmed application for enrollment. Methods: The
study sample included under 6 year old children high-risk families (n=199). Highrisk family database and medical subsidy database were linked. Differences between
high-risk subsidy enrollees (n= 87) and non-enrollees (n= 112) and effectiveness of a
social welfare intervention in increasing subsidy application were investigated in a
pre-post analysis of high-risk social welfare intervention. Individual level as well as
relative residential level characteristics were explored. Results: Medical subsidy
enrollment was correlated with younger age at time of a high-risk intervention and
relative district level variables. Pre-post comparison suggests high-risk interventions
significantly increased subsidy application by 7.4%. Logistic regression indicates
older age at time of intervention was associated with 40% less chance of application. Conclusions: The study provides empirical evidence for potential effects of a
high risk social welfare intervention on the accessibility to health care. Findings also
show where policy makers can improve intervention in order to address the needs
children at-risk, especially for different age groups.
PIH96
What Factors Are Associated With Vaccination Programme Success?
van Oorschot D A M
Radboud University, Nijmegen, The Netherlands
.
.
.
Objectives: When the WHO launched the Expanded Programme on Immunisation
(EPI) in 1974, < 5% of the world’s children were vaccinated against polio, measles,
diphtheria, tetanus, pertussis and tuberculosis. Nowadays coverage rates are
increasing and more vaccines have been added to the programme. This project
aims to identify factors associated with successful programmes based on EPI coverage. Methods: The relationship between multiple socio-demographic and economic factors and EPI coverage (primarily obtained from the WHO and World Bank)
was investigated using simple linear regression, Principal Component Analysis (PCA)
to identify explanatory variables, and finally multiple linear regression analysis. 132
countries with data on self-funded health care programmes were included in the
analysis. These were ranked according to Gross National Income (GNI) per capita and
lower (L), lower-middle (LM), upper-middle (UM) and upper (U) quartiles were identified. Results: Income (GNI/capita) was not significantly associated with achieving high EPI coverage rates. Within the income groups the factors trending with
improved EPI coverage included: 5-yr mortality and corruption index in L, sanitary
facilities in LM, 5-yr mortality, sanitary facilities, birth-rate and life-expectancy in
UM. In U all countries achieved > 90% coverage. Conclusions: Identifying simple
predictive variables of successful vaccination programmes is complex because of
multicollinearity. However, by exploring within homogeneous income groups, it was
possible to identify underlying factors related to vaccination programme success. As
the core EPI vaccines were introduced 40yrs ago one would expect introduction to
have been fully implemented thus reducing the likelihood of a relationship between
country income and coverage today, however it could have been expected some time
ago. To further explore the relationship between country income and vaccination
programme success, one could expand the analysis to include the newer vaccines
as soon as coverage information is available for a majority of the countries.
PIH97
Patient-Reported Outcomes (Pro) in Go/No-Go Decision Making in
Drug Development
Ingelgard A P 1, Nokela M 2, Cole J C 3, Berger A K 3
1Covance Market Access, Solna, Sweden, 2Covance Market Access Services, Solna, Sweden,
3Covance Market Access Services, Inc., San Diego, CA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Despite existing examples of the great impact successful integration
of PRO science and know-how may have on improving market access, PROs are typically not part of drug development decision making such as go/no-go decisions. The
objective of this study is to identify decision making instances in drug development
when important go/no-go decision making also could have included PROs but typically
weren’t. Additionally, search for any strategies and activities that might better enhance
the likelihood for senior decision makers also to integrate PRO science and knowhow
in drug development decision making. Methods: A literature search was carried
out including terms such as PRO, strategy, decision-making, go/no-go decisions, drug
development and phases I to IV. Results: Typical go/no-go decisions mentioned in the
literature include decisions to move a drug candidate from one development phase to
the next stage, i. e. from target-to hit to launch decisions. There were very few references
found where go/no-go decision-making in drug development also included PROs. Many
references also states the necessity to include the patient (e. g. listen to the patient) early
on in drug development. However, no concrete suggestions on how to carry out these
ambitions in practice were found. Conclusions: There is little research to be found in
the literature on go/no-go decision making in drug development where PRO science and
knowhow are taken into account. The lack of clear practical guidance and examples on
when and how to start inclusion of PROs science and knowhow in go/no-go
decision making may be one impediment to their successful inclusion. Perhaps, a best
practice rule could be as simple as including a PRO opportunity assessment in phase
I-II go/no-go decisions where the feasibility, pros and cons for potentially including
PRO in the clinical development program are summarized. At least, a first overview
of PROs potential is done.
PIH98
Estimation of Serum Calcium Level in Peri and Postmenopausal
Women: A Comparative Study
Paras P 1, Shobha Rani R 1, Shobha G 2
1Al-Ameen College of Pharmacy, Bangalore, India, 2St. philomena’s hospital, Bangalore, India
.
Objectives: To estimate the calcium levels in peri menopausal and postmenopausal women and to evaluate the need for calcium supplementation among
them. Methods: A prospective study was conducted at gynecology department of
a tertiary care hospital for the period of six months to estimate the serum calcium
levels among them. Study populations were divided in to perimenopausal and post
menopausal group. All the eligible patients were enrolled after obtaining informed
consent. Study subjects from both the group were estimated for serum calcium
levels to identify if they need calcium supplements. Unpaired T test was performed
to find out any significant difference between both groups and pearson’s correlation cofficient (r) was applied to assess the relation between age and calcium
levels. Results: During the study period, 53 of 100 patients enrolled were postmenopausal with the mean age of 60.8±10.47 years and 47 of 100 patients enrolled were
perimenopausal with mean age of 44.6±3.54 years. The mean calcium level of 47
perimenopausal women was found to be 9.32±0.55 (reference level: 8.0-11.0 mg/dl)
and 8.56±0.54 for 53 postmenopausal women. In post menopausal women there
was highly significant drop observed in serum calcium levels with increasing age,
compared to peri menopausal women. (CI: 95%, p< 0.0001, r: -0.81). Conclusions:
The serum concentrations of calcium in majority of our study population were
within the normal range. There was a good source of dietary intake of calcium in
most of the patients. The levels of calcium were lower in postmenopausal women
compared to perimenopausal women. Since there is an negative effect of calcium
on the bone mineral density in postmenopausal women, it can be recommended
that calcium supplementation can be given as prophylaxis to prevent the long
term bone loss and to decrease the risk of fracture and osteoporosis.
.
.
PIH99
Patient Characteristics and Medication Treatment Patterns Among
Men With Erectile Dysfunction (Ed), Lower Urinary Tract Symptoms
Secondary To Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia (Bph-Luts), Or CoOccurring Ed and Bph-Luts In the Uk Primary Care Setting
Ilo D 1, Raluy-Callado M 2, Graham-Clarke P 3, Donaldson R 2, Birt J 4, Sadasivan R 2, Zhu Y 4,
Neasham D 2
1Lilly UK, Hampshire, UK, 2Evidera, London, UK, 3Eli Lilly Australia Pty Ltd., NSW, Australia, 4Eli
Lilly and Company, Inc., Indianapolis, IN, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Describe patient characteristics and medication treatment
patterns among newly diagnosed cases of BPH-LUTS, ED, and co-occurring ED
and BPH-LUTS. Methods: Retrospective cohort study using UK CPRD data on
incident BPH-LUTS and incident ED patients indexed between June 2010 and
May 2011. Patient records were analysed from 12 months pre-index and up to
24 months post-index. Results: The cohort included 8912 men with BPH-LUTS-only,
2589 with an ED diagnosis followed by BPH-LUTS, 8093 with ED-only and 1641
with a BPH-LUTS diagnosis followed by ED, all aged ≥ 40 years. The majority of
BPH-LUTS patients (~90%) were diagnosed and managed within GP practices.
Men were diagnosed with BPH-LUTS alone at an older average age (68±11.9 years,
IQR= 59–77) compared to men in the ED/BPH-LUTS group (67±9.5 years, IQR= 61–74,
p= 0.002). Men were diagnosed with ED at an older average age (65±9.2 years,
IQR= 59–72) in the BPH-LUTS/ED group compared with ED-only patients (57±9.1
years, IQR= 50–64, p< 0.001). Time between diagnoses was longer for ED/BPH-LUTS
patients (6.8±4.76 years) versus BPH-LUTS/ED patients (5.8±5.10 years). BPH-LUTS
and ED treatment patterns were similar for patients with and without co-occurring
conditions. Most patients were initially prescribed alpha-blockers (62.9% BPHonly, 65.5% ED/BPH-LUTS) or anticholinergics (14.9% BPH-only, 14.0% ED/BPHLUTS). For ED, most patients were initially prescribed sildenafil (51.6% ED-only,
49.6% BPH-LUTS/ED) or tadalafil (24.3% ED-only, 26.0% BPH-LUTS/ED). At six
months post-diagnosis, ~47% incident BPH-LUTS patients and ~78% ED patients
were not on any BPH-LUTS or ED treatment, respectively. Conclusions: Study
data suggests > 80% of patients are managed as either BPH-LUTS- or ED-only.
Average age of BPH-LUTS/ED patients at ED diagnosis suggests patients may suffer from ED years before seeking medical attention (p= 0.002). Presence of the
co-occurring condition does not appear to impact treatment choice, however,
a lower proportion of ED patients initiate treatment after diagnosis, compared
with BPH-LUTS patients.
SYSTEMIC DISORDERS/CONDITIONS – Clinical Outcomes Studies
PSY1
Pain Incidence and Analgesic Consumption During Haemodialysis
Sessions: Impact on Health-Related Quality Of Life
Rebollo P 1, Arenas M D 2, Castejón N 1, Reichert García J 2, Delgado Conde P 2,
Gutierrez Rivas P 2, Gil González M T 2
1LASER ANALYTICA, Oviedo, Spain, 2Hospital Vithas Perpetuo Socorro, Alicante, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To analyse the incidence of pain and the need of analgesics during haemodialysis sessions, and its impact on Health-Related Quality of Life
(HRQoL). Methods: Data about the number of sessions in which 172 patients
showed pain and needed analgesics were collected in 2 haemodialysis units in Spain
during 3 months. Age, sex, comorbidities, (diabetes and cancer history), time on
haemodialysis, pain complaints during haemodialysis sessions, intake of analgesics,
opioids and antidepressant drugs, were collected. Generic HRQoL was assessed by
means of the computer adaptive test CAT-Health, previously validated, through an
iPAD. A negative score means that the HRQoL is worse than that of general population and a positive score, indicates that it is better. Results: Mean age (S. D) was
66.87 (13.32), being 44 patients (25.6%) aged over 75 years. 55.8% were male, 34.3%
diabetic and 11.6% had cancer history. The median time undergoing haemodialysis
was 51.50 months (27.75-84.50). 81 patients (47.4%) had pain during some session.
The mean number of haemodialysis sessions with pain was 4.78 (range between
1 and 21 sessions), which represents 12.7% of the total number of sessions. 67
patients (39%) were usually taking analgesics, 37 (21.5%) opioids and 29 (16.9%)
antidepressant drugs. Patients taking analgesics showed worse HRQoL: mean (S.
A522
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
D) CAT-Health scores of -1.2412 (1.6065) vs -0.0119 (1.3495) (p< 0.001). Patients taking opioids also showed worse scores: -1.1009 (1.9349) vs -0.3288 (1.4169) (p= 0.037).
Differences on HRQoL according to antidepressant drugs were not statistically significant. Episodes of pain during dialysis were concentrated in 24 patients who had
6 or more painful sessions. These patients were taking analgesics more frequently
(86.4% vs 36.9%; p< 0.001) and showed worse CAT-Health score: -1.5391 (1.6348) vs
-0.3243 (1.4981) (p= 0.005). Conclusions: Pain during haemodialysis sessions is
very common and requires the frequent use of analgesics, having a negative impact
on patients’ HRQoL.
PSY2
Clinical Utility of the Collect Scale To Assess Comorbidities In
Patients With Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia
De La Serna J 1, Carbonell F 2, Giraldo P 3, Lopez A 4, González I 5, García C 5, Orofino J 5,
Roset M 6, Perulero N 6, Rios E7
1Hospital Universitario 12 de Octubre, Madrid, Spain, 2Consorci Hospital General Universitari
Valencia, Valencia, Spain, 3Hospital Universitario Miguel Servet, Zaragoza, Spain, 4Hospital
Universitari Valle d’Hebron, Barcelona, Spain, 5Roche Pharma, Madrid, Spain, 6IMS Health,
Barcelona, Spain, 7Hospital Virgen de Valme, Sevilla, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: COLLECT scale assesses comorbidities in patients with Chronic
Lymphocytic Leukemia (CLL). Validation of COLLECT was a secondary objective
of the MABERYC non-interventional study. The aim is to assess the clinical utility and the validity of COLLECT to guide treatment regimen prescribed to CLL
patients. Methods: MABERYC study included patients with CLL, being or not previously treated, initiating treatment with Rituximab+chemotherapy. COLLECT was
administered at baseline and 12 months following treatment finalization. Treatment
response (TR) and safety was also assessed in the last visit. COLLECT categorizes
comorbidity in low (0-3), moderate (4-7) and high (> 7). Changes in COLLECT were
categorized in improvement (reduction≥ 2), without changes (variation< 2) and
worsening (increase≥ 2). Results: MABERYC included 218 patients, 179 completed
COLLECT at baseline. Patients had a mean age of 67.5 years, 73% were male, 53%
were naïve, 37% had moderate comorbidity and 27% high comorbidity. At baseline,
42% of patients initiated treatment with Rituximab-Fludarabine-Ciclofosfamide
(RFC), 30% with Rituximab-Bendamustine (RB), 18% with Rituximab-Clorambucile
(RC) and 10% other patterns. Mean COLLECT score was higher in older patient,
higher ECOG, previously treated (5.2 vs 4.2) and those receiving less aggressive treatments (5.8 RC, 5.4 RB, 3.6 RFC). Changes in COLLECT were analysed in 134 patients.
CR could be associated to improvement in comorbidity. Complete remission was
reached by 53% of patients with COLLECT improvement, 47% without changes, and
32% worsening. Number of adverse events (AEs) treatment related tend to be higher
in patient with lower comorbidity (1.6 vs 0.9), using more aggressive treatments.
Total number of AEs (related or not to treatment) tend to be higher in patients with
higher comorbidity (7.8 vs 5.8). Conclusions: COLLECT scale assess comorbidity which is related with patients’ profile, treatment regiment prescribed, CR and
AEs. COLLECT could assist decision-making on the intensity of the chemotherapy
regimen to prescribe.
PSY3
Impact of Biologics Use on Depression and Anxiety Frequency and
Health Care Resource Utilization In Psoriasis: An Analysis Using the
Quebec Provincial Drug Reimbursement Program Database
Lachaine J 1, Lambert-Obry V 1, Gaumond S 2, Desjardins O 3
1University of Montreal, Montreal, QC, Canada, 2AbbVie Canada, Saint-Laurent, QC, Canada,
3AbbVie Canada, St-Laurent, QC, Canada
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Psoriasis is a chronic inflammatory disease of the skin that cannot
be cured. For patients with active moderate to severe psoriasis, biologics use is
associated with an improvement in patients’ quality of life especially by reducing
prevalence of psychological disorders. The objective of this study was to assess
the impact of biologics use on depression and anxiety frequency and the number
of medical visits. Methods: A retrospective study of the Quebec provincial drug
reimbursement program (RAMQ) database was conducted using a randomly selected
group of patients who have received at least one diagnosis of psoriasis between
January 1st, 2007 and June 30th, 2012. To assess the impact of biologics use, time series
analyses were performed. Time series analyses evaluate changes in the slope of a
trend pre- and post-intervention, herein defined as biologics initiation. Trends in
depression and anxiety frequency and medical visits frequency were compared for
each year for a 5-year period before and after biologics initiation to assess the differences in slopes. Results: A total of 43,400 patients with psoriasis were included
in the study (mean age= 54.6 [SD= 21.9] years, 53.7% females), of which 1,108 (2.6%)
used a biologic agent. For patients who needed to be treated with biologics, the
rates of change in the depression and anxiety prevalence increased by 3.4% and by
4.2% per year prior to biologics initiation respectively. After biologics initiation, the
trends were still increasing, but at a statistically lower rate of 2.5% (p= 0.028) and of
2.4% (p=0.012) per year. Medical visits per patient increased during the 5-year period
before biologics initiation. Visits frequency has reduced during the 5-year period
after biologics initiation with a trend decreasing annually (p=0.002). Conclusions:
The present analysis illustrates that biologics use reduces the increase in depression
and anxiety frequency and decreases the number of medical visits.
PSY4
A Real-World Characterization of Patients With “Moderate-ToSevere” Systemic Lupus Erythematosus
Strand V 1, Johnson J 2, Vandeloo C 3, Galateanu C 3, Lobosco S 2
1Biopharmaceutical Consultant, Portola Valley, CA, USA, 2Adelphi Real World Ltd, Macclesfield,
UK, 3UCB Pharma, Brussels, Belgium
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To characterize the patient (pt) group classified by physicians as having “moderate-to-severe” systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) disease severity, and
assess disease burden. Methods: Data were extracted from the Adelphi 2013 Lupus
Disease-Specific Program, a multinational survey of clinical practice. Physicians com-
pleted Patient Record Forms (PRFs); pts self-reported data including EQ-5D and the
Work Productivity and Activity Impairment Index for SLE (WPAI-Lupus) in Patient
Self-Completion Records (PSCs). Pt eligibility was determined by physicians; disease
activity and severity were based on physician assessment. Data across countries
were pooled. Results: Data were collected from rheumatologists in the USA (n=97),
France (n= 37) and Germany (n= 35), including PRFs (550/200/207, respectively) and
PSCs (303/109/149, respectively). Physician assessment of disease severity was predominantly based on affected organs and symptoms (45% and 35% of rheumatologists, respectively); 15% based severity on test results/clinical assessments. No disease
activity index was widely used, 58% used their own assessment. Physician assessment
of severity was imperfectly correlated with control of disease activity (activity controlled in 56.1% of “moderate-to-severe” pts, uncontrolled in 6.1% of “mild” pts). Pts
with “moderate-to-severe” severity presented with greater severity and organ involvement, and a higher proportion experienced flares per 12-month period than “mild”
pts (78.4% vs 52.6%). “Moderate-to-severe” severity was associated with a greater
impact on HRQoL (EQ-5D: 0.72 vs 0.86; WPAI: 35.0 vs 16.3) than “mild” disease. Fewer
“moderate-to-severe” pts were employed (full-time employment: 35.8% vs 48.8%),
and a higher proportion required a care provider (6.6% vs 3.3%). Conclusions: SLE
severity is not consistently assessed or defined in clinical practice: measures used in
clinical trials are not routinely adopted in daily practice, whilst organ involvement
and symptoms are central to physician assessment of severity. Correlation between
severity and control of disease activity is imperfect. “Moderate-to-severe” severity is
associated with a greater burden than “mild” disease.
PSY5
Effectiveness of Heavy-Light Chain Quantitative Test:
A Systematic Review
Kim J H , Shin H W , Lee M
National evidence-based healthcare collaborating agency, Seoul, South Korea
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Heavy-light chain (HLC) quantitative test can identity and quantify the heavy and light chain of each immunoglobulin class. The purpose of this
study was to evaluate the effectiveness of HLC quantitative test. Methods: To
evaluate the effectiveness of HLC quantitative test, systemic literature review using
Ovid-MEDLINE, EMBASE, Cochrane library and eight domestic databases including
KoreaMED had performed until October 10th, 2013. We included five cohort studies
and one diagnostic evaluation study in the final evaluation. Two reviewers independently assessed the quality of included studies and extracted data on study.
The qualities of these studies were assessed according to Scottish Intercollegiate
Guidelines Network (SIGN) tool. Results: The correlation between HLC quantitative test with previous tests was evaluated in one study which patients with
increased monoclonal IgA were enrolled, and the correlation coefficient with comparator tests was reported as 0.94 in that study. Clinical significance of quantitative
HLC test for predicting prognosis was also reported in five cohort studies. Survival
rate in patients with higher HLC ratio was significantly lower, and the increased
IgA κ /λ ratio or IgM κ /λ ratio was significantly correlated with higher survival rate
in patients with monoclonal gammaglobulinemia. The body of evidence as a whole
suggests a Grade C for HLC quantitative test. Conclusions: HLC quantitative test
is safe and effective test that can quantitatively measure the identified immunoglobulin type and predict the prognosis of patients with monoclonal gammopathy.
PSY6
Disappearance of B-Symptoms In Comorbid Patients Receiving FirstLine Obinutuzumab (Ga101) -Chlorambucil (G-Clb) Or RituximabChlorambucil (R-Clb) for Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia (Cll)
Wenk Andres S 1, Becker U 2, Klawitter S 1, Wiesner C 3, Bernhardt A 2
Pharma AG, Grenzach-Wyhlen, Germany, 2F. Hoffmann-La Roche Ltd., Basel, Switzerland,
3Genentech Inc., South San Francisco, CA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
1Roche
Objectives: The CLL11 study (stage 2, NCT02053610; sponsored by F. Hoffmann-La
Roche, Basel, Switzerland), compared G-Clb with R-Clb in 663 patients with previously untreated CLL and comorbidities. We compared the presence, disappearance
and duration of absence of B-symptoms (fever, night sweats and weight loss) for
G-Clb with R-Clb in CLL11. Methods: Patients were randomised to receive six
28-day (D) cycles (C) of G-Clb (N= 333) or R-Clb (N= 330; G: 1000 mg D1, 8 and 15 C1,
D1C2–6; R: 375 mg/m2 D1C1, 500 mg/m2 D1C2–6; Clb: 0.5 mg/kg D1 and 15 each
cycle). B-symptoms were assessed by a physician at baseline, D1C1, D8C1, D1 of
each subsequent cycle, 28 days after last study drug and every 3–6 months during follow-up for progression-free survival. The data cut-off for this analysis was
9thMay 2013. Results: At baseline, 260 patients had B-symptoms (n= 126, G-Clb;
n= 134, R-Clb). During the treatment period, B-symptoms disappeared in 107 (85%)
and 124 (93%) patients who received G-Clb and R-Clb, respectively (relative risk
[RR]: 0.92, 95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.84–1.00; p= 0.0554). Median time to first
disappearance of all B-symptoms was 32.0 days for G-Clb and 35.0 days for R-Clb
(hazard ratio [HR]: 1.24,95% CI: 0.96–1.61; p= 0.103). At end of treatment, 96 (76%)
and 108 (81%) patients who received G-Clb and R-Clb, respectively, were B-symptom
free (RR: 0.95, 95% CI: 0.83–1.07; p= 0.3899). In patients whose B-symptoms disappeared, the 25% quartile for duration of absence of B-symptoms (median not
reached) was 16.4 months for G-Clb and 10.4 months for R-Clb (HR: 0.59, 95% CI:
0.36–0.97; p=0.0387). Conclusions: There was no clinically meaningful difference
in B-symptom freeness at end of treatment, however the absence of B-symptoms
was prolonged by 6 months for G-Clb versus R-Clb.
PSY7
Comparison of Disease Status and Outcomes of Patients With
Ankylosing Spondylitis (As) Receiving Adalimumab Or Etanercept
Monotherapy In Europe
Narayanan S 1, Lu Y 2, Hutchings R 2, Baynton E 2
1Ipsos Healthcare, Columbia, MD, USA, 2Ipsos Healthcare, London, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To compare the disease status and outcomes of patients with AS
receiving adalimumab and etanercept monotherapy in Europe. Methods: A multi-
A523
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
country multi-center medical chart-review study of AS patients was conducted
among rheumatologists in UK/France/Germany/Italy/Spain to collect de-identified
data on patients who were recently treated with a biologic as part of usual care.
Physicians were screened for duration of practice (3-30yrs) and patient volume (incl.
> 5AS biologic patients/month) and recruited from a large panel to be geographically representative in each country. Eligible patient charts (≥ 3) were randomly
selected from a sample of prospective patients visiting each center/practice during the screening period. Physicians abstracted patient diagnosis, treatment patterns/dynamics and patient symptomatology/disease status/outcomes. Patients
on adalimumab/etanercept monotherapy were analyzed. Results: 329 eligible
AS patient charts were abstracted; 141 on adalimumab (male: 89%, age: 41.9yrs,
average months on adalimumab: 29.5, 95% on first biologic) and 102 on etanercept
(male: 78%, age: 43.2yrs, average months on etanercept: 32.2, 98% on first biologic).
Top-3 comorbidites (adalimumab vs. etanercept) were dyslipidemia: 6% (range: 0%
(Germany) -11% (Italy)) vs. 8% (range: 0% (UK/Germany) -15% (Spain)), obesity: 4%
(range: 0% (Italy) -7% (Germany)) vs. 6% (range: 0% (UK) -11% (France)), and depression: 6% (range: 0% (Italy/Spain) -15% (UK)) vs. 5% (range: 0% (Germany/Spain) -7%
(Italy/France)). Among patients with available data, latest lab measures documented
were (adalimumab vs. etanercept): ESR: 15.1mm/h (range: 11.6 (Germany) - 23.6
(Italy)) vs. 13.6mm/h (range: 8.0 (Germany) -19.2 (Italy)), CRP: 6.7mg/dl (range: 2.6
(Spain) -8.9 (France)) vs. 7.3mg/dl (range: 1.9 (Germany) -10.0 (Italy)), rheumatoid
factor-positive: 6% (range: 0% (Spain) -10% (Germany/Italy)) vs. 10% (range: 0% (UK)
-19% (Italy)). Latest disease severity measures documented were (adalimumab vs.
etanercept): Swollen Joint Counts: 0.8 (range: 0.1 (Germany) -1.4 (UK)) vs. 0.5 (range:
0.3 (France) -0.9 (Italy)), Tender Joint Counts: 1.2 (range: 0.5 (Germany) -1.9 (Italy))
vs. 1.1 (range: 0.4 (France) -2.1 (Italy)), HAQ: 1.1 (range: 0.7 (Spain) -1.5 (UK)) vs. 1.3
(range: 1.0 (France) -3.0 (Germany)). Conclusions: Among AS patients receiving
adalimumab or etanercept monotherapy, disease severity differed within the EU5,
with patients on adalimumab, and patients in Italy, having marginally higher burden
and poorer outcomes. Factors influencing the observed patterns and the impact
of specific biologic treatments on these observations warrant further scrutiny to
optimize therapeutic interventions and improve outcomes.
PSY8
A Double-Blind Controlled Study of the Efficacy and Safety of
Long-Acting Amfepramone Treatment In Mexican Obese Patients
H 1, Pizarro
M 2, Rosado
J 3, Rizzoli
Cordoba A 2, Fernández
Soto Molina
Castellanos
Perez
del Valle C 4, Reyes García J G 4
1HS Estudios Farmacoeconómicos, Mexico City, Mexico, 2Hospital Infantil Federico Gomez,
Distrito Federal, Mexico, 3FES Zaragoza, Mexico City, Mexico, 4Instituto Politécnico Nacional,
Mexico city, Mexico
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
erase 45U/kg). Non significative differences implies overlapped confidence intervals
for the three therapies in all the efficacy endpoints. Conclusions: This analysis
suggests a comparable effect of the velaglucerase and taliglucerase on platelet count
increase, as well as a comparable effect of the three enzymes approved for Gaucher
disease on Hemoglobin concentration increase, Liver and Spleen volume reduction.
PSY10
The Oncology Pain Treatment Clinical Studies Quality Assessment
Giermaziak W 1, Faluta T 2, Bondaryk Z 1, Markowska A 1, Deszcz M 3
Medical Library, Warsaw, Poland, 2Military Institite of Medicine, Warsaw, Poland, 3Medical
University of Warsaw, Warsaw, Poland
.
.
.
.
.
1Main
Objectives: Opioids have been extensively used in the treatment of oncological
pain for many years. Due to various therapeutic doses and imprecise measurements of the reduction of pain, it is difficult to make meta-analysis. There are
only a few precise systematic reviews assessing efficacy of pain medicines (especially meta-analysis). The study goal was to assess the quality of published data
of oncological pain treatment and create a meta-analysis when it is possible. It
has been led in the context of a limited amount of meta-analysis for the opioid
preparations’ use. Methods: Opioids have been extensively used in the treatment of oncological pain for many years. Due to various therapeutic doses and
imprecise measurements of the reduction of pain, it is difficult to make metaanalysis. There are only a few precise systematic reviews assessing efficacy of pain
medicines (especially meta-analysis). The study goal was to assess the quality of
published data of oncological pain treatment and create a meta-analysis when
it is possible. It has been led in the context of a limited amount of meta-analysis
for the opioid preparations’ use. Results: The primary research provided data
of high quality. The average Jadad scale rating for all primary publications was
equal to 3.43. The individual studies presented the effectiveness of individual drugs.
However, their variation with respect to the scale assessing either pain intensity
or diversity of a population makes the presentation of meta-analysis impossible to
be presented. Conclusions: Oncology pain treatment has been assessed in high
number of published studies. However due to their heterogeneity the meta-analisis
methodology is limited to be used.
PSY11
A Pilot Study of the Effectiveness of Treatment Patients With
Hemophilia In Ukraine
Zalis’ka O 1, Mudrak Y 2, Mudrak I 2
1Danylo Halytsky Lviv National Medical University, Lviv, Ukraine, 2Vinnyca National Medical
University after M. Pyrogov, Vinnyca, Ukraine
.
.
.
Objectives: Amfepramone is an anorectic drug used for the short-term treatment of obesity; however, its efficacy and safety in the long-term has been scarcely
studied. To determine the efficacy and safety of long-acting amfepramone treatment in Mexican adult obese patients by a double blind, randomized and placebocontrolled clinical trial study. Methods: One hundred and fifty six volunteers
with a body mass index (BMI) greater than 30 kg/m2 and less than 45 kg/m2 were
randomized to receive a tablet of 75 mg amfepramone or placebo daily during 6
months. Primary outcomes were the absolute body weight loss and the percentage of patients who achieved at least 5% or 10% weight loss at 3 and 6 months,
whereas secondary outcomes were the improvement of anthropometric and metabolic parameters. Results: Amfepramone treatment showed a superior efficacy
to decrease the body weight than placebo at 3 (-4.9 ± 0.25 versus 0.7 ± 0.32 Kg) and
6 (7.7 ± 0.52 versus 1.1 ± 0.7 Kg) months. In addition, Sixty-four and thirty-four
patients achieved at least 5% or 10% weight loss, respectively, with amfepramone
at 6 months, compared with eight and zero patients of placebo. Amfepramone also
improved BMI and waist circumference, but not waist-hip index (WHI), glucose,
total cholesterol, low-density lipoproteins (LDL), high-density lipoproteins (HDL) and
triglycerides at 3 and 6 months. Amfepramone produced only mild adverse events
and they were presented in a greater number than placebo only at 3 months, being
the main adverse event dry mouth. Conclusions: Data suggest that amfepramone
is effective and well tolerated in the long-term treatment of Mexican obese patients.
Objectives: The incidence is 87% of hemophilia and often leads to disability (90%
of patients). WHO recommends annual demand of 1 patient of 30 000 IU of factor
VIII, but in Ukraine with a national program funded an average 5786 IU per year
(20% of the need). In Ukraine, began production of the domestic drug factor VIII
“BioKlot A” from 2012. The aim was to determine the effectiveness of substitution
treatment “BioKlot A” native medicine in the treatment of patients with hemophilia
A. Methods: In a pilot clinical study examined 168 patients diagnosed with hemophilia A severe form of male, aged 18-52 years, who were hospitalized. Experimental
group received “BioKlot A” control group – “Oktanat” in equal doses of 40 IU / kg /
day during the first day, 20 IU / kg / day - the next day. All patients were determined
by the intensity of joint pain, joint swelling index, joint circumference, blood count,
and others criteria. Results: Within 24 hours after “BioKlot A” (average dose rate
of 10 000 IU) joint pain significantly decreased after 48 hours - the pain disappeared
and the joint volume decreased by 14% in 72 hours - the amount of diminished
joint by 22% and increased range of motion by 28%. Time coagulation by Lee-White
24 hours decreased from 30 ± 0,2 minute to 19 ± 0,2 minute. In the control group,
the average dose rate amounted to 10750 IU “Oktanat” and dynamics of clinical
and hematological data were not significantly different from the experimental
group. Conclusions: The established similar effectiveness of factor VIII “BioKlot
A” (Ukraine) and “Oktanat” (Austria) with clinical and laboratory criteria. Production
of factor VIII preparation in Ukraine has significant socio-economic impact, providing improved quality of life of patients.
PSY9
Comparative Effectiveness Study of Enzymatic Replacement
Therapies In the Treatment of Gaucherxs Disease On Adults
PSY12
How To Improve Health Outcomes In the Treatment of Chronic
Myeloid Leukemia
Muciño-Ortega E 1, Mendoza C F 1, Rubio M E 2
1Pfizer S.A. de C.V., Ciudad de México, Mexico, 2Pfizer S.A. de C.V., Mexico City, Mexico
1Novartis, Porto
Objectives: This study aims to perform a comparative effectiveness study of
licensed Enzymatic Replacement Therapies (ERT´, taliglucerase, imiglucerase and
velaglucerase) on the treatment of Gaucher´s disease on adult patients. Methods:
A systematic review of published clinical trials was performed on three Medical
databases. Inclusion criteria were randomized, double-blind and phase III clinical
trials measuring the efficacy of ERT on adult patients. Using meta-analysis methodology, the difference in the clinical outputs due the use of a specific ERT in four endpoints was assessed: Hemoglobin concentration increase, platelet count increase,
Spleen and Liver volume reduction. Since no placebo group is reported in clinical
trials of orphan drugs, outcomes previous to ERT were considered as control. In this
study we report the p-value of test for subgroup differences to compare among the
three alternatives. Results: For the higher dose (60U/kg for the three enzymes), the
data reported allowed a taliglucerase, velaglucerase and Imiglucerase comparison in
efficacy measures (except the analysis of imiglucerase in platelet count endpoint).
Hemoglobin concentration increased a mean of 1.79 g/dL [95% CI 1.08, 2.51; p-value
for therapy differences= 0.82]. Spleen volume decreased a mean of -5.17 Multiples
of Normal (MN) [-10.09, -0.25; p-value for therapy differences= 0.90]. ERT showed a
trend favouring liver volume reduction, -0.28 MN [-0.57, 0.01; p-value for therapy
differences= 0.80] and increased platelet count, 33.11x109/L [-1.67, 67.89; p-value for
therapy differences= 0.74]. However, for data limitations, we were unable to perform
the comparison for the lower dose (taliglucerase and imiglucerase 30U/kg, velagluc-
Objectives: Imatinib and nilotinib are two tyrosine kinase inhibitors (TKI) used in
the treatment of chronic myeloid leukemia (CML). Recent data reveals that patients
who achieve deep molecular responses may be able to stop TKI, which has important clinical and economic implications. The efficacy of nilotinib was compared
to imatinib in newly diagnosed patients and the proportion of patients achieving
deep molecular response MR4.5, after 5 years, was 31% for imatinib and 54% for
nilotinib. The aim of this analysis was to estimate the number of patients remaining
in TFR with nilotinib compared with imatinib. Methods: According to STIM trial,
39% of patients remained in complete molecular response after discontinuation
of imatinib. In the Stop 2G-TKI study, 62.2% remained in undetectable molecular
residual disease after nilotinib discontinuation. Based on this data, we developed
an outcomes model to estimate the number of patients remaining in TFR long term
after consolidated treatment with nilotinib versus imatinib. It was assumed that
after 5 years of treatment with imatinib or nilotinib, patients with consistent MR4.5
are eligible to interrupt treatment. After 12 months, patients who maintain sustained undetectable BCR-ABL will remain in TFR. Results: Considering an annual
CML incidence of 1.33 per 100,000 patients, of which 8% are intolerant to treatment,
we estimated 128 de novo CML patients eligible for TKI treatment in Portugal per
year. For this cohort of patients, treatment with nilotinib would result in an additional 28 patients in TFR when compared with imatinib (43 versus 15). Given the
number of patients remaining in TFR, overall treatment costs with nilotinib, after
.
.
.
.
.
Viriato D 1, Marques A 1, Fonseca M 1, Almeida A 2
Salvo, Portugal, 2Instituto Português de Oncologia de Lisboa, Lisboa, Portugal
.
.
.
.
A524
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
6 years, would be 34% lower. Conclusions: Treatment with nilotinib is expected
to result in better health outcomes, with more patients achieving TFR. This initial
TKI investment should reflect itself in long term economic benefits.
PSY13
Pre-Symptomatic Genetic Testing In Familial Amyloid
Polyneuropathy: The Reproductive Options
Inês M1, Rodrigues F 2, Saraiva J 3, Costa J 4
1Instituto de Medicina Molecular, Lisboa, Portugal, 2Centro Hospitalar e Universitário de Coimbra,
Coimbra, Portugal, 3Centro Hospitalar e Universitário de Coimbra, Medical Genetics Unit, Hospital
Pediátrico, Coimbra, Portugal, 4Institute of Molecular Medicine, Lisbon, Portugal
.
.
.
Objectives: Familial Amyloid Polyneuropathy (FAP) is a rare, rapidly progressive,
debilitating and life-threatening neurodegenerative disease. Pre-symptomatic
genetic testing (PST) can contribute to reduce FAP prevalence, informing carriers
about risk of transmission to offspring’s and available reproductive options such as
Pre Natal Diagnosis (PND) or Pre Implantation Genetic Diagnosis (PGD). This study
aims to describe FAP carrier’s reproductive options after PST and to analyse its
socio-demographic determinants. Methods: Data from a cohort of 145 FAP carriers
that underwent PST at Medical Genetics Unit (HP/CHUC – Portugal, 2000-2012) was
used to analyse reproductive options of FAP carrier’s. An econometric logistic model
was specified to identify determinants for natural reproduction option. Results:
The subjects were mainly women (55%) with mean age of 35 years (SD= 15) at PST
entry. Most participants were in a relationship 92/145 (63%) and mean number years
of education was 9 years (SD= 14). 75/145 (52%) of subjects were already parents,
reporting a total of 144 children. 21/145 (14%) subjects decided not to have offspring
following their positive test result. No child adoption was reported. 27/145 (19%)
of subjects report offspring posteriori to PST: 19/27 (70%) subjects undergo natural
reproduction and 8/27 (30%) reproduction with PND or PGD support. A total of 9 offspring non-FAP carriers (with PND/PGD) and 24 offspring from natural reproduction
were observed until data collection. The logistic regression for decide on natural
reproduction confirms statistical significance (p-value<0.05) for only two variables:
being in relationship and having previous children. No statistical significance was
observed for gender, age at PST or number of education years. Conclusions:
There is evidence of a high proportion of carriers with offspring’s when initiate
PST and high proportion of natural reproduction within FAP carriers after PST. An
ethical physiological case-by-case approach is essential to learn more about the
determinants for preventing FAP offspring transmission.
PSY14
Trends In Prescription Opiate Use Among Patients With Commercial
Or Government Sponsored Health Insurance In the Us From 2010-2013
Bonafede M M 1, Palmer L A 2
Health Analytics, Cambridge, MA, USA, 2Truven Health Analytics, Bethesda, MD, USA
.
.
.
prostate cancer) (C60-63), 10.7% had malignant neoplasms of digestive organs (C1526) and 8,4% showed malignant neoplasms of ill-defined, secondary and unspecified
sites (C76-80). The outpatient diagnosis rate for CLL was 94.9%, inpatient rate 0.6%
and in-and outpatient rate 4.6%. Overall, 266 of 1,405 pts (18.9%) (175 men [65.8%], 91
women [34.2%]) received chemotherapy in 2012 (ATC Code L01* 74.1%, PZN 9999092
23.0%, OPS 854* 2.9%). Most patients received outpatient treatment (94.0%), with 5.3%
of patients received both out- and inpatient treatment and 0.7% inpatient treatment. The most commonly used treatments were rituximab (26.7%), bendamustine
(20.2%), chlorambucil (11.1%), cyclophosphamide (7.7%), fludarabine (6.2%) and other
treatments (28.1%). Conclusions: The majority of patients being diagnosed with
CLL did not require treatment within a time period of a year. Approximately 1/3
of patients had a second malignancy, predominantly skin cancer. Treatment was
primarily composed of chemotherapy or chemoimmunotherapy.
PSY16
Acute Myeloid Leukemia and Myelodisplasic Syndrome Treated
With Intensive Chemotherapy In France Based On National Hospital
Databases (Pmsi)
Thiebaut A 1, Lafuma A 2, Bureau I 2, Boyaval G 3, Bensoussan C 3, Godard C 3
1Department of Hematology, Grenoble University Hospital, La Tronche, France, 2Cemka-Eval,
Bourg la Reine, France, 3MSD France, COURBEVOIE, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate the annual number of patients in France with Acute
Myeloid Leukemia (AML) and MyeloDysplasic Syndrom (MDS) and treated with
intensive chemotherapy susceptible to induce neutropenia. Methods: French hospital databases named PMSI record medical information about all the hospitalizations performed annually in France. From 2006 to 2012, databases allow linking the
stays over time of a given patient with an anonymous number. In this study, PMSI
databases were used to identify patient, aged more than 15, with diagnosis of AML
or MDS and who were alive during the year 2012. Then, patients who underwent
hospital stays for chemotherapy during more than 5 days were identified and considered as neutropenic according to experts opinions. Results: Since 2006, 51,386
patients with at least one diagnosis of AML or MDS and aged more than 15 were
identified, from which only, 16,006 had at least one hospital stay in 2012 and 3,468
were hospitalized more than 5 days for chemotherapy. Among those patients, 55.2%
were male, mean age was 60.4 years, 30% died during a hospital stay and 19% (664)
were bone marrow grafted during the year 2012. These patients had 1.8 stays for
chemotherapy per year with average chemotherapy duration of 27 days. Two third
of these patients (34%) were diagnosed in 2012 and 23% in 2011. Conclusions:
Among the 16,006 patients diagnosed AML or SMD and hospitalized in France in
2012, 3, 468 (21%) received intensive chemotherapy inducing neutropenia, putting
them at high risk of invasive fungal infection.
.
1Truven
Objectives: To describe the prevalence of outpatient prescription opiate use
among patients with Commercial, Medicare Supplemental, or Medicaid insurance
in the US after 2010. Methods: Patients were identified using the Truven Health
Commercial and Medicare Supplemental databases from 2010-2013 and Medicaid
Multi-State databases from 2010-2012. We estimated the proportion of patients with
at least one outpatient opiate prescription for each calendar year among patients
with continuous medical and pharmacy enrollment for the entire calendar year,
stratified by insurance type and age (< 18, 18-64, 65+). Average opiate days supply
per calendar year was also described. Results: On average, a total of 32.9 million
(m) patients were included in each calendar year analysis with an average of 6.7m
Commercially-insured children, 20.2m Commercially-insured non-elderly adults,
2.5m Medicare Supplemental adults (age 65+), 2.6m Medicaid-insured children and
0.8m Medicaid-insured adults per year. Among commercially-insured non-elderly
adults, the prevalence of opiate prescriptions decreased from 25.1% to 23.4% from
2010 to 2013 (p< 0.001) with a similar decrease among Medicare Supplemental
patients (29.5% to 27.6%, p< 0.001). Among Medicaid adults, opiate prescription
prevalence was lower prevalence in 2012 (38.9%) than in 2010 (44.1%) or 2011 (45.2%).
Among children (age <18), opiate prescription prevalence use was slightly higher for
Medicaid than commercially-insured children (9.9% versus 7.4%, p<0.001); opiate
prescription prevalence dropped by 15.3% among commercially-insured patients
from 2010 to 2013 (p<0.001) and by 12.1% among Medicaid children from 2010 to 2012
(p< 0.001). Average annual days supply increased over time among Medicaid adults
(92.8 to 100.5 days), commercially-insured non-elderly adults (41.7 to 44.5 days) and
Medicare Supplemental adults (65.9 to 68.6 days); days supply per year was steady
among children (calendar year range: 7.5-9.1). Conclusions: There were modest
reductions in the prevalence of prescription opiate use from 2010-2013. Further and
more detailed monitoring is needed to parallel efforts to curtail inappropriate use.
PSY17
Allogeneic Stem Cell Transplant With Graft Versus Host Disease In
France In 2012 Based On National Hospital Databases (Pmsi)
Thiebaut A 1, Lafuma A 2, Bureau I 2, Boyaval G 3, Bensoussan C 3, Godard C 3
1Department of Hematology, Grenoble University Hospital, La Tronche, France, 2Cemka-Eval,
Bourg la Reine, France, 3MSD France, COURBEVOIE, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate the number of patients receiving Allogeneic Stem Cell
Transplant (ASCT) and presenting with graft versus host disease (GVHD) in 2012 in
France. Methods: French hospital databases named PMSI record medical information about all the hospitalizations performed annually in France. From 2006 to 2012,
databases allow linking the stays of a given patient over time with an anonymous
number. In this study, PMSI databases were used to identify patient, aged more
than 15, with allogeneic stem cell transplant through adequate Diagnosis Related
Group and who were alive, hospitalized during the year 2012. Patients with diagnosis of GVHD or typical diagnoses of GVHD symptoms (sclerodermia, diarrhea,
mucitis and keratitis) were identified. Results: Since 2006 to 2012, 9,855 patients
received allogeneic stem cell transplant in France of which 3,469 died during a
hospitalization over the period, with an annual death rate stable around 20%. In
2012, 3,842 ASCT patients aged more than 15 were hospitalized at least once, and
the proportion with GVHD was estimated to 40% (1,574). Acute GVHD diagnosis or
typical GVHD symptoms occurring less than 100 days after grafting appeared in
274 patients and chronic GVHD was diagnosed in 1300 patients. Mean age was 47.8,
61.4% were male and 22% of these patients died during a stay in 2012. Among the
ASCT patients hospitalized in 2012, only 5% were grafted in 2006 and this figure
regularly increased with the year of the procedure to reach 35% grafted in 2012, corresponding to a mean annual mortality rate of around 20%. Conclusions: Among
the 3,842 ASCT patients hospitalized in France in 2012, 1,574 (40%) presented GVHD,
putting them at higher risk of immunosuppression and invasive fungal infection,
but also at higher risk of death.
PSY15
Prevalence and Treatment of Chronic Lymphocytic Leukaemia (Cll)
In Germany: An Analysis of Sickness Funds
PSY18
The Presence of Anxiety Among Elementary Schools Obese Children
1Janssen-Cilag
Tomeczkowski J 1, Leisten M K 1, Metin H 1, Khuen C 1, Fleischmann J 2, Tapprich C 1
GmbH, Neuss, Germany, 2Janssen-Cilag Germany, Neuss, Germany
1University
Objectives: No national registries for chronic lymphocytic leukaemia (CLL) exist
in Germany. The objective of this analysis was to examine the number of patients
with CLL diagnosed (with or without other diagnoses of cancer) and to characterize the types of treatment being utilized and care settings using sickness funds
claim data. Methods: This analysis evaluates data from 1,771,225 beneficiaries
in 2012 from different statutory sickness funds. Patients with CLL were identified
by ICD-10 C91.1*, oncological co-diagnoses by ICD-10 C00-79; D37-48 and chemotherapy by Anatomical Therapeutic Chemical (ATC) Code L01*, pharmacy number
(PZN) 9999092 and/or operating and procedure code (OPS) 854*. Results: In total,
1,405 patients with a diagnosis C91.1* (CLL) were identified (prevalence 79/100,000)
with 60.2% were male and 39.8% female. Overall, 32.2% of patients with CLL had a
co-diagnosis with another cancer; 25.1% melanoma (C43-44), 21.3% had neoplasms
with unknown behaviour (D37-48), 11.8% had malignant male GU neoplasms (90%
Objectives: From among the consequences of the obesity very considerable the
emotional and distressful disturbances with which it grew fat children day, than
day they fight. Assessing a what kind of measure the sport influences it on was our
aim the nutritional and the mood life, furthermore, that the obesity influences the
learning and the mood life. Methods: We made a questionnaire survey in the
primary schools of Szekszárd, 13-14 year ones among students. Inclusion it was a
criterion that only 7-8. are class children may have taken a part in the examination,
furthermore without parents consent, and sufferers may not have taken a part in
the examination only in a serious illness. All element 149 heads. At the compilation of the questionnaire used Helena (Healthy Lifestile in Europe by Nutritrion in
Adolescence) name from a project for us essential questions, and we complemented
it their edited our questionnaire implied altogether 150 questions with questions,
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Germán Z 1, Botár A 2, Sziládiné Fusz K 1, Pakai A 3, Boncz I 4, Fullér N 1, Oláh A 1
of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary, 2Balassa János Hospital, Szekszárd, Hungary, 3University of
Pécs, Zalaegerszeg, Hungary, 4Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A525
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
so. Results: Our 1. hypothesis, that the children with normal weight move much,
than their obese companions, not proven true (p= 0,778). It was the next supposition
that less are truth with a subject for the students with normal weight they have
difficulties, than for the obese students. According to the examination, the normal
one and the obese child with a subject truth in the look of difficulty, we found a
significant difference (p= 0,015). The third hypothesis, that, in the obese group taller
the anxious children’s proportion, than the did not grow fat in a group, not proven
true. The overweight children (n= 46, medium= 109, 76) anxiety with a significantly
bigger degree was not showed based on the scale the normal one tápláltsági state
at students (n= 95, medium= 104, 56 dot, p= 0,515). Conclusions: The enrolled
students showed no significant difference between the observed parameters of the
overweight and sporting habits.
SYSTEMIC DISORDERS/CONDITIONS – Cost Studies
PSY20
Clinical and Cost-Effectiveness and Budget Impact of Routine Use
of Bispectral Index Monitors In Theatres
Vincent O 1, Sabatelli L 2, Craig J 1, Taylor M 1
1York Health Economics Consortium, York, UK, 2GLOB MOD, Barcelona, Spain
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Bispectral Index (BIS) monitoring systems monitor spontaneous electroencephalography, track sedative drug effects and help guide anaesthetic administration. Evidence shows such monitoring enables savings on anaesthesia and
reduces adverse events compared with monitoring clinical signs only. However, the
cost-effectiveness of monitors is uncertain. Methods: A cost-effectiveness model
and budget impact analysis were developed to compare the outcomes of monitoring the depth of anaesthesia with BIS monitors compared with standard clinical
monitoring. Over a five-year period, the model estimated the incremental cost per
quality-adjusted life year (QALY) and incremental number of adverse events avoided
in theatres with anaesthetists using BIS monitors compared with standard care.
Data values were obtained from peer-reviewed literature. Subgroup analysis was
conducted for an elderly patient group. Sensitivity analyses explored uncertainty
in the model. A budget impact model examined the financial impact of adopting
BIS monitors across the UK. Results: The modelled results showed that using BIS
monitors dominated clinical observation of signs and use of electrocardiograph
and other devices, being cost saving by £82 per operation in the adult population,
whilst improving QALYs by 0.016 per patient. The budget impact analysis showed
a cumulative saving of over £136 million if theatres in the UK adopted a phased
increase in monitor use such that 1.35 million surgical procedures were conducted
using these monitors in five years time. Conclusions: Adopting BIS monitors
is cost-effective and results in substantial cost savings compared with observing
clinical signs plus conventional devices only.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: to estimate the costs of drug supply for registered rare diseases (RD)
patients in Russia in 2013. Methods: The study included two steps: 1) the analysis
of the current situation with financing of drugs for RD patients in Russia in 2013
and 2) estimating the unmet needs - necessary weighted average costs (nWAC) for
a pathogenetic pharmacotherapy of registered patients with RD in the same year.
Number of registered patients with 24 RD listed in the Government Regulation of
Russian Federation № 403 from April 26, 2012 was estimated for the studied year.
Number of registered patients and actual financing has been received from the
database of regional public health services. The nWAC for expensive pathogenetic
pharmacotherapy of patients with 24 RD were calculated on the basis of standards of therapy and experts’ survey results. The current situation with financing
of RD drugs in Russia in 2013 was compared with unmet needs (nWAC). Results:
4.4 billion rubles ($125.7 million) were spent from regional budgets in Russia for
11,173 patients (0.008% from all population of Russia) with 24 RD in 2013. The largest patient group with 3,460 patients was a classic phenylketonuria group. The
prognostic annual nWAC for pharmacotherapy of the most expensive patient with
type VI mucopolysaccharidosis were 40.9 million rubles ($1.2 million) per child
and 71.5 million rubles ($2.0 million) per adult. The nWAC for pharmacotherapy
of registered patients with 24 RD in 2013 were 15.7 billion rubles ($448.6 million).
The annual nWAC for pharmacotherapy of the most expensive disease (idiopathic
thrombocytopenic purpura (Evans syndrome) was estimated as 2.9 billion rubles
($82.8 million) per group of 2,700 patients. Conclusions: The state financing of
pharmacotherapy for patients with 24 RD in Russia should be increased approximately in 3.5 times to fulfill the unmet needs.
PSY22
Budget Impact Analysis of Drugs for Ultra-Rare Non-Oncological
Diseases In Europe
Schlander M 1, Gandjour A 2
1University of Heidelberg, Wiesbaden, Germany, 2Frankfurt School of Finance & Management,
Frankfurt, Germany
.
Kanters T A , Steenhoek A , Hakkaart L
Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The relatively low budget impact of orphan drugs is often used as
an argument in reimbursement decisions. However, overall, the budget impact of
orphan drugs can still be substantial. In this study, we assess the uptake and budget
impact of orphan drugs in the Netherlands. Methods: We examined the number
of orphan drugs, the number of patients and budget impact of orphan drugs in the
Netherlands in the period 2006 to 2012, both for inpatient and outpatient orphan
drugs. Budget impact was provided in absolute numbers and relative to total pharmaceutical spending. Results: The number of orphan drugs and patients treated
increased substantially over the period studied. Overall, budget impact increased
substantially over a period of six years, both in absolute terms (426% increase) as
well as relative to total pharmaceutical spending (378% increase). Growth rates
decreased over time. In 2012, 17% of available drugs had an individual budget impact
of more than € 10 million per year. Conclusions: Individual budget impact of
orphan drugs is often limited, although exceptions exist. However, in total, the
budget impact of orphan drugs is considerable and has grown substantially over
the years. This could potentially influence reimbursement decisions for orphan
drugs in the future.
PSY25
Budget Impact Analysis of Introducing Biosimilar Infliximab for
the Treatment of Auto Immune Disorders In Five European Countries
.
Sura M 1, Gerasimova K 1, Omelyanovsky V V 1, Avxentyeva M 1, Tatarinov A 2, Fedyaev D 2
1The Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration, Moscow,
Russia, 2Financial Scientific Research Institute of the Ministry of Finance of Russia, Moscow,
Russia
.
PSY24
Budget Impact of Orphan Drugs In the Netherlands In The Period
2006-2012
Jha A 1, Upton A 2, Dunlop W 1
1Mundipharma International Limited, Cambridge, UK, 2Abacus International, Bicester, UK
PSY21
Estimating the Costs of Drug Supply for Rare Diseases Patients
In Russia
.
estimate was based on prevalence data for URDs for which patented drugs are currently available and for which drugs are in clinical development and hence may
be expected to be launched in the foreseeable future. A power function was used
to estimate the relation between (decreasing) prevalence and (increasing) cost per
patient. For drugs in development, we applied phase duration data and attrition
rates from the Tufts Center for the Study of Drug Development database. Results:
A total of 18 drugs under patent protection for non-oncological URDs were identified. Furthermore, 29 drugs for non-oncological URDs under development that have
the potential of reaching the market by 2021 were found. Total budget impact over 10
years was estimated to be € 14,112 and € 4,965 million for approved and pipeline URD
drugs, respectively (total: € 19,077 million). Relative to total pharmaceutical expenditures in Europe, spending on drugs for URDs is estimated to rise from 0.7% at present
to 1.6% in 2021. Univariate sensitivity analyses and extreme scenario analyses suggesting robustness of this projection will be presented. Conclusions: Our analysis
does not support concerns regarding an uncontrolled growth in expenditures for
drugs for URDs. Nevertheless, continuous monitoring of the budget impact as an
input to rational policy making is recommended.
.
Objectives: Ultra‐rare disorders (URDs) have been defined by a prevalence of less
than 1 per 50,000 persons. On a per patient basis, the annual acquisition costs of
drugs for URDs can be very high, and there have been concerns that expenditures
for these products might escalate in the future. The goal of this study was therefore
to provide a budget impact analysis (BIA) of drugs for ultra-rare non-oncological
diseases in Europe. Methods: The BIA had a time horizon of 10 years (from 2012
to 2021) and adopted the perspective of all European payers in combination. The
.
.
Objectives: Biosimilar infliximab has been approved by EMA for the management
of inflammatory autoimmune disorders including rheumatoid arthritis (RA), ankylosing spondylitis (AS), Crohn’s disease, ulcerative colitis (UC), psoriatic arthritis
(PsA), and psoriasis based on quality, safety and efficacy profiles comparable to infliximab. The aim of this study was to evaluate the five-year budget impact of introducing biosimilar infliximab in the management of RA, AS, Crohn’s disease, UC, PsA,
and psoriasis from the health care system perspective. Methods: An Excel-based
budget impact model was developed. The numbers of patients eligible for infliximab
were calculated based on disease prevalence rates in Germany, Italy, Belgium, the
Netherlands and the United Kingdom. The price of biosimilar infliximab is not yet
known; therefore three discount scenarios versus infliximab (10%, 20%, and 30%)
were applied. Market share was assumed to be 25% in the first year in all scenarios.
Annual market share growth was varied in each of the scenarios at 20%, 30% and
40%, respectively. Results: The combined net budget savings for Germany, Italy,
Belgium, the Netherlands and the United Kingdom in the first year were € 17.8, € 35.5
and € 53.3 million for the 10%, 20% and 30% price discount scenarios, respectively.
Over a 5 year period the net budget savings were € 132.8, € 322.8 and € 532.8 million
for the 10%, 20% and 30% price discount scenarios, respectively. Conclusions:
The introduction of biosimilar infliximab as a treatment option for patients with RA,
AS, Crohn’s disease, UC, PsA, and psoriasis could achieve substantial cost savings
for health care systems. In the price discount scenarios tested, the total combined
savings across Germany, Italy, Belgium, the Netherlands and the United Kingdom
over a 5 year period ranged from € 132.8 million to € 532.8 million. The net budget
impact was highly sensitive to market uptake rates and the price discount applied.
PSY26
Budget Impact Analysis of Belimumab In the Treatment of Patients
With Systemic Lupus Erythematosus In Russian Federation
Kulikov A , Komarov I , Pochuprina A
I.M. Sechenov First Moscow State Medical University, Moscow, Russia
.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate budget impact analysis (BIA) of belimumab plus standard of care (SoC) comparing the SoC alone in the treatment of patients suffering
from systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). Methods: BIA was conducted of the
belimumab treatment plus SoC vs SoC alone. Costs of treatments in both groups
contained following direct medical costs: costs of drugs and administration, costs
of diagnostic laboratory and instrumental procedure, costs of inpatient and outpatient visits, costs of SLE complications and also adverse event costs. A five-year time
horizon was used. All costs in both groups were estimated to their present value
using a 5 % discount rate. Results: Costs of the course of belimumab therapy were
2,118,449 RUB/ 45,581 EUR for 5 years but the difference in the required budget funds
between belimumab treatment groups and SoC alone treatment group amounted to
1,876,965 RUB/ 40,385 EUR for 5 years with a 5 % discount rate. The decrease of the
difference in the required budget funds between these two groups was due to a lower
A526
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
frequency of inpatient visits and pulmonary, cardiovascular, renal and skin complications of SLE in group treated with belimumab. Therefore the use of belimumab led
to a reduced difference in the required budget funds from 2,118,449 RUB/ 45,581 EUR
to 1,876,965 RUB/ 40,385 EUR and the reduction ran as high as 241,484 RUB/ 5,196
EUR for 5 years. Conclusions: The use of belimumab in the treatment of patients
with SLE resulted in budget spending. However, a good safety profile and efficacy of
belimumab help reduce the costs for 241,484 RUB/ 5,196 EUR for 5 years in belimumab
treatment group.
PSY27
Public Expenditure On Authorised Orphan Drugs In the Czech
Republic Between 2008 and 2013
Vocelka M 1, Spurna M 1, Fuksa L 2, Hambalek J 1
Institute for Drug Control, Prague, Czech Republic, 2Charles University, Faculty of
Pharmacy, Hradec Kralove, Czech Republic
.
.
.
.
1State
Objectives: The aim of the study was to determine public expenditure on medicines
for rare diseases from the public health sector in the Czech Republic (CZ). Methods:
We identified orphan medicinal products (OMPs) registered by the European
Medicines Agency (EMA) until December 2013 in the public database of EMA. In the
base-case scenario, medicinal products available in the CZ were considered OMPs
only within the interval of marketing authorisation date and December 2013 or OMP
designation withdrawal date or date of withdrawal of use. Reports on consumption
and real expenditures of these OMPs came from all health insurance companies in
the CZ. Exchange rate of 25.4 CZK = 1 EUR was used. Results: Overall, 86 OMPs were
authorised within the European Union (EU) between 2008 and 2013. Of these, 50 OMPs
(58.0%) were covered from the Czech public health insurance at some point within
this period. The number of registered OMPs increased from 54 in 2008 to 84 in 2013,
while the number of covered OMPs doubled from 24 to 41, respectively. The annual
public expenditure on OMPs rose simultaneously from 43 to 72 million EUR, while
the total expenditure on drugs increased from 1.7 to 2.0 billion EUR. The OMP share of
total pharmaceutical sales grew steadily from 2.5% in 2008, reaching 3.4% in 2011 and
plateaued at 3.6% in 2013. Twenty-one oncological OMPs (51.2%) generated up to 72.6%
of the overall orphan costs in 2013. Conclusions: Compared to other EU countries,
the Czech public expenditure on OMPs of 3.6% of all drugs seems to be relatively high.
The major part of OMP costs is in oncological diagnoses. One of the limitations is the
exclusion of designated OMPs not authorised by EMA since these OMPs still might
be present on the market and reimbursed. This aspect needs further investigation.
PSY28
Qutenza® Estimated Costs Per Patient In Primary Versus Secondary
Care. A Comparison Between Qutenza®, Pregabalin and Lidocaine
for the Treatment of Peripheral Neuropathic Pain
Darba J 1, Kaskens L 2, Villa G 2
1Universitat de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain, 2BCN Health Economics & Outcomes Research S.L.,
Barcelona, Spain
.
.
.
Objectives: The objective of this analysis was to estimate and compare the annual
cost per patient of the administration of capsaicin 8% patch, Qutenza®, in Primary
and Secondary Care for the treatment of adult patients with peripheral neuropathic
pain (PNP). The annual cost per patient treated with Qutenza® was also compared
with Pregabalin and Lidocaine in Primary Care. Methods: The costs per patient
for each treatment were estimated by analysing the health care resources associated with the use of pregabalin, lidocaine and Qutenza®for the treatment of PNP
from the perspective of the Spanish National Health System. Healthcare resources
associated with the three pharmacological treatments considered were administration time and health care personnel, complementary non-pharmacological
treatment, hospitalisation, adverse effects and concomitant medication, EUR 2013.
Total costs per patient were estimated and compared both including and excluding
concomitant medication to estimate the effect on the treatment costs. Results:
The annual treatment cost per patient when Qutenza® is administrated in the hospital was estimated at € 5,387.32 and € 5,259.19 when administered in Primary Care.
Qutenza® applied in Primary Care for the treatment of PNP showed annual savings
of € 128.14 per patient compared with the administration of Qutenza® in Secondary
Care. Overall, the annual treatment costs per patient with pregabalin or lidocaine
were estimated at € 14,074.14 and € 5,998.09, respectively, resulting in savings of
€ 8,814.95 and € 738.9 respectively when compared with the annual cost per patient
when treated with Qutenza® in Primary Care. Conclusions: The introduction
of Qutenza® into Primary Care for the treatment of PNP is expected to result
in annual savings due to lower administration costs associated with the use of
Qutenza® and savings in health care personnel in Primary Care. Qutenza® also
showed to be the less expensive option in comparison with pregabalin or lidocaine,
independent of the area of administration.
PSY29
Economic Impact Linked To the Reduction of Exacerbations When
A Treatment Regime With Inhaled Antibiotics Is Switched To
Aztreonam Lysine In Patients With Cystic Fibrosis and Chronic
Pulmonary Infection Caused By Pseudomonas Aeruginosa
Sole A 1, Poveda J L 1, Giron R M 2, Prados M C 3, De Gracia J 4, Casado M Á 5
Universitario La Fe, Valencia, Spain, 2Hospital La Princesa, Madrid, Spain, 3Hospital
Universitario La Paz, Madrid, Spain, 4Hospital Universitari Vall d’Hebron, Barcelona, Spain,
5Pharmacoeconomics & Outcomes Research Iberia, Madrid, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Hospital
Objectives: Estimate, from the Spanish National Healthcare System (SNS) perspective, the required reduction of exacerbation episodes in different patient profiles to
maintain constant the overall treatment cost if a chronic treatment with inhaled antibiotics is switched to aztreonam lysine in patients with cystic fibrosis (CF) and chronic
pulmonary infection by Pseudomonas aeruginosa (PA). Methods: A cost comparison
model was developed considering two criteria to define patient profiles: current drug
treatment (12 options linked to tobramycin and/or colistimethate sodium) and current
exacerbation episodes (1-6/year). For each patient profile the overall treatment cost
was calculated. Considering a switch to aztreonam lysine, the reduction of exacerbation was estimated in order to maintain the overall treatment cost. For the base case,
ex-factory prices were considered; for sensitivity analysis, discounts ranged from 15
to 50%. Results: Switching to aztreonam lysine would not increase overall treatment
costs in 8/12 options; even maintaining current exacerbation episodes could lead to
SNS savings. In the remaining options, the required reduction of exacerbations varies depending on the patient’s current situation, ranging from 110% (one episode/
year) to 18% (six episodes/year). In the sensitivity analysis, there are 3 options in
which switching to aztreonam lysine would not imply higher treatment costs. For the
remaining alternatives, the required reduction of exacerbations does not change
significantly from the base case: from 116% (one episode/year) to 19% (six episodes/
year). Conclusions: In CF patients with chronic pulmonary infection by PA, hospitalizations costs due to exacerbations have a greater economic impact than drug
treatment costs. Using aztreonam lysine, instead of other treatments, would not imply
a budget impact in a wide range of patient profiles if exacerbation episodes can be
reduced. As the number of current exacerbations increases, a lesser reduction of these
events is required by a switch to aztreonam lysine to avoid incremental treatment costs.
PSY30
Impact of Generic Substitution On the Prescribing of MeprobamateContaining Combination Analgesics In South Africa
Truter I
Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University, Port Elizabeth, South Africa
.
Objectives: Meprobamate is a constituent of various combination analgesics in
South Africa. Due to its abuse potential, the scheduling status of meprobamate is
currently under review with the possibility of introducing stricter controls on its
availability. The primary aim was to determine the impact of generic substitution on
meprobamate-containing combination analgesic prescribing. Methods: A retrospective, cross-sectional drug utilisation study was conducted on prescription data
of a medical insurance scheme administrator in South Africa for 2011. Results: A
total of 97 491 analgesics were dispensed to 31 854 patients during the year. Within
ATC category N02B, 62.10% of prescriptions were for analgesic combinations, of
which 20 326 prescriptions were for meprobamate-containing analgesics at a cost
of R282 930. A total of 10 404 patients received meprobamate-containing analgesics.
Overall, 20.85% of all analgesics contained meprobamate. Patients who received
meprobamate-containing analgesics were slightly older (39.52 years) compared
to patients who received analgesics in general (33.61 years). Mandatory generic
substitution exists in South Africa, unless otherwise indicated by the prescriber
or if the patient refuses. Twenty-two trade names of meprobamate-containing
analgesics were dispensed, of which 17 (the originator plus 16 branded generics)
contained exactly the same dosages of active ingredients (320 mg paracetamol,
8 mg codeine phosphate, 32 mg caffeine and 150 mg meprobamate). In previous
studies, the originator product was the most often prescribed, yet in this study
the originator product only constituted 3.72% of products prescribed (average cost:
R30.42) compared to 70.63% for the most popular branded generic (average cost:
R11.65). Conclusions: The price difference between generic equivalents and the
originator product, together with mandatory generic substitution, were responsible
for the change in prescribing patterns.
PSY31
The Economic Burden of Treating Thalassemia In Greece
Geitona M 1, Karagianni V 2, Kattamis A 3, Voskaridou E 4, Drosou M 5, Vini D 5,
Kalogeropoulou M 6
1University of Peloponnese, Corinth, Greece, 2Technological educational institute of Athens, Egaleo,
Greece, 3Ag. Sofia Children Hospital, Goudi, Greece, 4Laiko General Hospital of Athens, Ambelokipi,
Greece, 5Agios Panteleimon General Hospital, Nikaia, Greece, 6Center for Health Services
Management and Evaluation, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, Athens, Greece
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The objective was to estimate the economic burden of B-thalassemia
and to compare the cost of alternative iron chelation strategies in patients with
transfusion (TDT) and non-transfusion dependent thalassemias (NTDT) in
Greece. Methods: A multicenter, non interventional, retrospective, observational,
phase IV study was conducted in the 3 out of 8 thalassemia units in Attica. Patients’
data and resource use, including medication and related consumables, blood transfusions, lab tests, diagnostic examinations and hospital visits were recorded from
January 2009 to December 2011, and classified per diagnosis and iron chelation treatment strategies. Greek NHS perspective was considered. Results: 331 thalassemic
patients were recorded whereas the majority (87.6%) was diagnosed with Betathalassemia major, 31% were treated with deferasirox (DFX), 23% with deferoxamine
and deferiprone, (DFO+DFP), 9.7% with deferiprone (DFP) and 5.1% with DFO. Patient
mean annual cost per patient was € 32,064, including all treatment strategies, for
the period 2009-2011, ranging from € 30,997 in 2009 to € 32,564 in 2011. Medication
(45.9%), blood transfusions (38.1%) and consumables (14.9%) were the most important cost drivers. Mean cost per patient treated with DFX was estimated at € 35,928,
with DFO+DFP at € 34,035, with DFO at € 31,637 and with DFP at € 17,208 for the same
period. DFX significantly reduced (p< 0.001) the number of blood transfusions in
relation to DFO+DFP with 19 and 25 transfusions per year, respectively. Similarly,
DFX significantly reduced the volume of blood transfusions (p< 0.001) in relation
to DFO with 9,693ml and 10.312ml per year, respectively. Conclusions: Rational
health care decision making process should be based on the holistic perspective of
analytical resource use and disease management data rather than focusing on the
price per product per se. Especially in Greece, a country where Beta-thalassemia
incidence in general population is ~8 %, the consideration of all cost components
should be taken into account in health resource allocation.
PSY32
Economic Considerations On the Use of Mifamurtide In the
Treatment of Osteosarcoma In Spain
Brosa M 1, García del Muro X 2, Mora J 3, Villacampa A 1, Pozo T 4, Adán C 4, Grande M 4,
García E 4, Cubells L 4
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A527
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
1Oblikue
Consulting, Barcelona, Spain, 2Institut Català d’Oncologia, L’Hosp. de Llobregat, Spain,
Sant Joan de Déu, Esplugues de Llobregat, Spain, 4Medical Department. Takeda
Farmacéutica España, Madrid, Spain
3Hospital
Mepact® (mifamurtide) is the first drug approved for treatment of high-grade resectable non-metastatic osteosarcoma in patients aged 2-30 in the last 20 years. It
follows a randomised clinical trial showing a statistically-significant and clinicallyrelevant decrease in the risk of death without compromising safety. Objectives:
This study assessed the cost-effectiveness and budget impact of mifamurtide added
to the standard chemotherapy of cisplatin, doxorubicin and methotrexate with
this same standard therapy (ST) without mifamurtide. Methods: A Markov model
was built to combine trial-based outcomes with Spanish resource use and unit
cost of compared options. The analysis has been carried out from the perspective
of the Spanish National Health Service, with a time horizon of up to 60 years in
the base analysis. A probabilistic sensitivity analysis was carried out to assess the
influence of the uncertainty of the variables introduced into the model. All the
costs are expressed in euros for the year 2011 and, beyond the first year, both costs
and effects (quality-adjusted survival) have been discounted with an annual rate
of 3%, following local recommendations. Results: The observed greater efficacy
of mifamurtide in the trial translates into a gain of 3.03 (undiscounted) and 1.33
(discounted) QALYs and an additional cost of € 102,000. The estimated budgetary
impact of using mifamurtide in 10% to 100% of the potential population would cost
€ 671,000 and € 6.7 million respectively. Conclusions: The iCER of mifamurtide in
Spain is in the low band (< € 100,000) of the iCERs obtained by other orphan drugs
and would have a limited, predictable and affordable cost in Spain.
PSY33
Cost Analysis In the Treatment of Patients With Systemic Lupus
Erythematosus In Russian Federation
Kulikov A , Komarov I , Pochuprina A
I.M. Sechenov First Moscow State Medical University, Moscow, Russia
.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate and compare costs of belimumab treatment plus standard of care (SoC) vs SoC alone in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus
(SLE). Methods: The cost analysis was conducted of the belimumab treatment plus
SoC vs SoC alone for one year. Based on the results of clinical trials to assess safety
and efficacy of belimumab (BLISS-52 and BLISS-76) the cost structure of treatment was
determined. Results: The costs were evaluated in the following groups: drug costs,
costs of inpatient and outpatient visits, costs for correction of adverse events and
costs for treating of SLE complications. The costs of inpatient visits comprised 91,830
RUB/ 1,976 EUR for SoC alone and 52,991 RUB/ 1,140 EUR for patients treated with
belimumab plus SoC. The correction of adverse events came to 7,763 RUB/ 167 EUR for
SoC alone, while for belimumab plus SoC it was 7,846 RUB/ 169 EUR. The costs of treating SLE complications totaled 384,976 RUB/ 8,283 EUR and 370,229 RUB/ 7,966 EUR for
SoC alone and belimumab plus SoC groups of patients, respectively. Conclusions:
The costs of inpatient visits in belimumab treatment group were lower than those of
the SoC group resulting from a reduction in the frequency of SLE flare. The costs for
correction of adverse events were similar in both patients groups due to a good safety
profile of belimumab. The level of costs for treating SLE complications was lower in
belimumab as compared to that in SoC group as a consequence of lower frequency of
cardiovascular, pulmonary, renal, and skin complications in the belimumab treatment
group. A good safety profile and efficacy of belimumab, which had been demonstrated
in clinical trials, led to a decrease in costs of inpatient visits and treatment of SLE
complication in patients treated with belimumab.
PSY34
Opioid Prescribing and the Impact of Branded Generics
Truter I
Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University, Port Elizabeth, South Africa
.
Objectives: Opioids are the mainstay of therapy for patients with moderate to
severe pain. Mandatory generic substitution exists in South Africa, unless otherwise indicated by the prescriber or if the patient refuses. Few studies have been
conducted in South Africa analysing the prescribing patterns and cost of opioid
analgesics. Methods: A retrospective, cross-sectional drug utilisation study was
conducted on prescription data of a medical insurance scheme administrator
in South Africa for 2011. The database contained 2 298 312 records for medicine,
medical devices and procedures. Results: A total of 97 491 analgesics were dispensed to 31 854 patients during the year. Within ATC category N02, opioids (NO2A)
accounted for 26.55% of analgesic prescriptions at a cost of R1 071 230.14. A total of
9 793 patients were prescribed 25 888 opioid analgesics. The average age of patients
was 41.50 (SD= 16.61) years. Female patients were slightly younger (average age:
40.69 (SD= 17.05) years) than male patients (average age: 42.32 (SD= 16.09) years).
Nine different active ingredients and two combination products were prescribed.
Tramadol, an atypical opioid, was the most often prescribed (68.11%), followed by
pethidine (14.39%) and morphine (8.38%). The average cost per prescription was
R41.38 (SD=R69.29). Fentanyl had the highest average cost per prescription (R454.43),
and pethidine the lowest (R8.53). Overall, the average cost for an originator product
was R56.25 and for a generic product R28.95. Tramadol accounted for 68.11% of
prescriptions and 80.40% of cost. Tramadol had the most most branded generic
equivalents on the market (7), yet only had 42.89% generic prescribing. Most prescriptions were issued by private hospitals (62.89%), followed by pharmacies (24.41%)
and general medical practices (12.16%). Only 35.48% of the products were prescribed
on a chronic basis. Conclusions: Tramadol dominated opioid prescribing. The
study confirmed price differences for opioid analgesics between branded generics
and originator products.
PSY35
Pill Burden, Health Care Resource Utilization and Costs Among
Subpopulations of Immediate Release Hydrocodone Users
BenJoseph R 1, Yang S 2, Yang E 2, Holly P 1, Boulanger L 2
Pharma L.P., Stamford, CT, USA, 2Evidera, Lexington, MA, USA
.
1Purdue
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess pill burden, health care resource utilization (HRU), and costs
among patients with long-term immediate release (IR) hydrocodone use. Methods:
We performed a retrospective analysis of health care claims from 2011-2012 Truven
MarketScan® Commercial, Medicare supplemental, and Medicaid Multistate databases. Patients with IR hydrocodone prescription for ≥ 90 days during 6 month
baseline period (July 2011- December 2011) with continuous enrollment during
baseline and 12 month follow-up periods were selected. The final population was
sub-categorized by prescribed coverage days (PCD) of IR hydrocodone during baseline into 90-119, 120-179, and ≥180 days. Chi-square or ANOVA analyses were used to
test pill burden, HRU and costs (standardized to 2013 US dollars) during baseline and
follow-up periods across subpopulations. Results: A total of 36,174 commercial,
32,699 Medicaid, and 8,873 Medicare IR hydrocodone users were selected. In the
baseline period, subgroups with longer PCD had significantly more average hydrocodone pills per month yet fewer HRU and medical costs (all p< 0.05). However, during
the follow-up period, groups with longer PCD had greater increase in number of
inpatient hospitalizations and other types of HRU (length of stay, outpatient hospital
visits, office visits, and emergency room visits). The subgroup of patients with PCD
< 120 days had lower annual all-cause medical costs during follow-up compared
with baseline (decreasing $2,624, $2,955, $4,209 per patient per year in Medicaid,
Medicare and commercial patients, respectively), while patients with longer PCD
during baseline had increased costs (p< 0.05). For example, Medicaid patients with
120-179 PCD had an increase of $1,874 and those with ≥ 180 PCD had an increase of
$4,348. These trends were similar for all insurance types. Conclusions: Extended
length of PCD, particularly after 120 days, corresponds with higher patient burden
including elevated pill burden and rising HRU and costs in both commercial and
public insurance patients with long-term IR hydrocodone use.
PSY36
Prevalence-Based Measurement of the Economic Burden of Rare
Diseases: Case Review To Determine the Annual Cost of Acromegaly
In France
Ponet O 1, Tasdemir E 2, Magestro M 3, Griner B P 4, Cummins G 5, Van Engen A 6,
Kreeftmeijer J 6, Niemira J 4, Tao C 7
1Novartis France, Rueil Malmaison, France, 2Novartis Oncology, Origgio / VA, Italy, 3Novartis
Pharmaceuticals Corporation, East Hanover, NJ, USA, 4Quintiles, Cambridge, MA, USA, 5Quintiles,
Durham, NC, USA, 6Quintiles Consulting, Hoofddorp, The Netherlands, 7Quintiles Consulting,
Cambridge, MA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Although acromegaly is acknowledged as requiring resource-intensive
treatment, its ultimate economic burden is unclear. As an extension of work presented at ISPOR 2013 International Conference (New Orleans, US), the objective of
this research is to measure the annual economic burden of acromegaly in France
using a case-review methodology with a prevalence-based sample of patients diagnosed with acromegaly. Methods: A case-review method was used with a sample
of 22 endocrinologists reviewing 88 patient cases (4 cases per physician) diagnosed
with acromegaly. The patient case histories included: resource utilization including office visits and hospitalization, diagnostic procedures and labs, medications
prescribed, medical procedures preformed, and an estimate of lost productivity. A
micro-costing analysis was conducted to obtain costs in the prior 12 months for
each patient case reviewed using published literature, medical fee schedules, and
pharmaceutical cost databases to assign costs to treatments and medical procedures identified in the survey data. Annual costs were examined across a broad
range of patients of different ages, gender and time from diagnosis. Two biomarkers
were used to categorize acromegaly patients as Controlled vs. Uncontrolled: Insulin
Growth Factor-1 (IGF-1) and Growth Hormone (GH). Several patient characteristics
were used as control factors when comparing annual economic costs: age, sex,
and time from diagnosis. Statistical tests and confidence intervals were calculated to determine the significance of patient characteristic effects on economic
burden. Results: Three patient subgroups were used to classify uncontrolled
acromegaly patients: IGF-1, GH and both IGF-1 and GH. The annual per-patient
economic burden of disease costs ranges from € 29,000 to € 79,400 across these
groups. These cost ranges are benchmarked to other studies to provide context
and validity. Conclusions: The total economic burden of acromegaly in France
is significant. Understanding the factors impacting burden of illness will inform
future improvements in treatment practice.
PSY37
Rates of Diagnosed Opioid Abuse Or Dependence and Incremental
Direct Health Care Costs Among Patients With Long-Term Use of
Immediate Release Hydrocodone
BenJoseph R 1, Yang E 2, Huse S 2, Bhagnani T D 2, Holly P 1, Kansal A 3
Pharma L.P., Stamford, CT, USA, 2Evidera, Lexington, MA, USA, 3Evidera, Bethesda,
MD, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Purdue
Objectives: To estimate rates of diagnosed abuse and incremental health care
costs among long-term immediate release (IR) hydrocodone users. Methods: We
performed a retrospective analysis of health care claims from 2011-2012 Truven
MarketScan® Commercial and Medicaid Multistate databases. Patients with IR
hydrocodone prescription ≥ 90 days during 6 month baseline period (July 2011December 2011) with continuous enrollment during baseline and 12 month follow
up periods were selected. Opioid abuse was defined as a patient having at least
one medical claim indicating opioid abuse/dependency (ICD-9-CM diagnosis codes:
304.0x, 304.7x, 305.5x, 965.00,965.02 or 965.09) during the study period. Rates of
opioid abuse during baseline and follow up periods were estimated by plan type,
along with total health care costs, standardized to 2013 US dollars. Generalized
linear model regressions were used to estimate incremental costs in the post-index
period. Results: A total of 32,699 Medicaid and 36,174 commercial IR hydrocodone
users were selected in the study. Rates of abuse were 96 and 36 per 10,000 patients,
respectively. Abusers had higher unadjusted annual total health care costs than
non-abusers during both baseline and follow up period (p< 0.05). After controlling
for baseline characteristics of age, gender, Charlson Comorbidity Index, pill burden
A528
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
and costs (all p< 0.05), the adjusted annual incremental costs in abusers versus nonabusers were $28,882 (95% Confidence Interval [CI]: $28,455-$29,311) and $15,523
(95% CI: $15,389-$15,657) per patient among Medicaid and commercially insured
patients, respectively, during the post-index period. The main cost driver was inpatient hospitalization which comprised 88% of unadjusted incremental costs during
follow up in Medicaid insured population and 53% in commercial insured population. Conclusions: Diagnosed opioid abusers among long-term IR hydrocodone
users impose significantly higher financial burden in both Medicaid and commercially insured populations in terms of all-cause direct health care expenditures,
ranging from $28,882 to $15,523 per abuser per year.
PSY38
Prevalence-Based Measurement of the Economic Burden of Rare
Diseases: Case Review To Determine the Annual Cost of Acromegaly
In Italy
Premoli E 1, Tasdemir E 2, Magestro M 3, Griner B P 4, Cummins G 5, Van Engen A 6,
Kreeftmeijer J 6, Niemira J 4, Tao C 7
1Novartis Pharma - BU Oncology, Origgio, Italy, 2Novartis Oncology, Origgio / VA, Italy, 3Novartis
Pharmaceuticals Corporation, East Hanover, NJ, USA, 4Quintiles, Cambridge, MA, USA, 5Quintiles,
Durham, NC, USA, 6Quintiles Consulting, Hoofddorp, The Netherlands, 7Quintiles Consulting,
Cambridge, MA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Direct medical costs were estimated using tariffs for laboratory tests, diagnostic
exams, visits, and prices for drugs. Procedure and inpatient cost data were collected
at Center level. Non medical costs included costs for travel and accommodation,
domestic help and informal care. The loss of productivity of patients have been
estimated using the human capital approach. The incremental effects of having
comorbidities on social costs were estimated by multivariate Generalized Linear
Models (log link, Gamma family) adjusting for gender, age, BMI, type of intervention and complications. Costs are expressed in Euro 2013. Results: Among 301
patients enrolled, 108 (36%) had hypertension, 53 (18%) T2DM and 47 (16%) ADD. The
raw social cost of intervention were € 8,749 (± € 2,359), € 9,511 (± € 2,292) and € 8,999
(± € 2,275) for patients with hypertension, T2DM and ADD. A significant incremental effect of having T2DM was found on social cost of intervention (€ 751, 95%CI:
242-1,259, p= 0.004). 1 year after intervention reductions of 48%, 81% and 15% were
observed for hypertension, T2DM and ADD. The raw social annual costs estimated
were € 2,461 (± € 1,490) for hypertension, € 2,424 (± € 951) for T2DM and € 3,582 (±
€ 2,017) for ADD. Direct non medical costs and indirect costs represent the main
component of social cost in patients with hypertension and ADD. Conclusions:
Bariatric surgery led to reductions of obesity-related comorbidities. One year after,
the economic burden is mainly sustained by patients, their families and the productivity system.
Objectives: Although acromegaly is acknowledged as requiring resource-intensive
treatment, its ultimate economic burden is unclear. As an extension of work presented at ISPOR 2013 International Conference (New Orleans, US), the objective of
this research is to measure the annual economic burden of acromegaly in Italy using
a case-review methodology with a prevalence-based sample of patients diagnosed
with acromegaly. Methods: A case-review method was used with a sample of 22
endocrinologists reviewing 86 patient cases (4 cases per physician) diagnosed with
acromegaly. The patient case histories included: resource utilization including office
visits and hospitalization, diagnostic procedures and labs, medications prescribed,
medical procedures preformed, and an estimate of lost productivity. A micro-costing
analysis was conducted to obtain costs in the prior 12 months for each patient case
reviewed, using published literature, medical fee schedules, and pharmaceutical
cost databases to assign costs to treatments and medical procedures identified in
the survey data. Annual costs were examined across a broad range of patients of
different ages, gender and time from diagnosis. Two biomarkers were used to categorize acromegaly patients as Controlled vs. Uncontrolled: Insulin Growth Factor-1
(IGF-1) and Growth Hormone (GH). Several patient characteristics were used as
control factors when comparing annual economic impact: age, sex, and time from
diagnosis. Statistical tests and confidence intervals were calculated to determine the
significance of patient characteristic effects on economic burden. Results: Three
patient subgroups were used to classify uncontrolled acromegaly patients: IGF-1,
GH and both IGF-1 and GH. The annual per-patient economic burden of disease
costs ranges from € 18,600 to € 38,000 across these groups. These cost ranges are
benchmarked to other studies to provide context and validity. Conclusions: The
total economic burden acromegaly in Italy is significant. Understanding the factors
impacting burden of illness will inform future improvements in treatment practice.
PSY41
Cost of Illness Analysis of Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy In Italy
PSY39
Costs of Absenteeism In Psoriatic and Enteropathic Arthropathies
Based On Real-Life Data From Poland’s Social Insurance Institution
Database In 2012
PSY42
The Burden of Myelofibrosis In Greece
Kawalec P , Malinowski K
Jagiellonian University Medical College, Krakow, Poland
.
.
Objectives: The aim of this study was to assess the indirect costs caused by absenteeism associated with psoriatic and enteropathic arthropathies from the perspective of the Social Insurance Institution (ZUS) in Poland. Methods: The estimates
were based on data published by ZUS referring to year 2012 and concerning absence
from work due to the illness (sick leave), the amount of short term disability, the
sufferers of which claim rehabilitation benefit, and the amount of permanent (or
long term) disability, the sufferers of which claim disability pension. Costs were
calculated with Human Capital Approach methodology taking into account Gross
Domestic Product (GDP) per capita equaled 41 398 PLN; results were presented
in Polish zloty (PLN). Results: Total indirect costs of psoriatic and enteropathic
arthropathies in the year 2012 calculated using GDP per capita in Poland were 9
312 773 PLN. The highest component of indirect costs of psoriatic and enteropathic
arthropathies was sick leave (82%). Long and short term disability costs constitute 9% and 8% of total indirect costs of psoriatic and enteropathic arthropathies,
respectively. In 2012 Poland’s Social Insurance Institution database reported 1 900
patients on sick leave, 54 patients with short term disability and 3 patients with
long term disability. Indirect costs per patient associated with sick leave were 4
037 PLN calculated using GDP per capita. Indirect costs per patient associated with
short term disability were as high as 16 227 PLN and associated with long term
disability were as high as 255 288 PLN. Conclusions: Psoriatic and enteropathic
arthropathies in Poland generated high indirect costs. The main component was
sick leave; rehabilitation benefit and disability pension generated much lower costs
of lost productivity.
PSY40
Social Costs of Different Procedures In Bariatric Surgery In
Patients With Obesity-Related Comorbidities
Bellelli S 1, Armeni P 2, Tarricone R 3, Turchetti G 1
1Scuola Superiore Sant’Anna, Pisa, Italy, 2Bocconi University, Milano, Italy, 3Bocconi University,
Milan, Italy
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate the social cost of bariatric surgery techniques in obese
patients with hypertension, diabetes mellitus (T2DM) and anxiety-depression disorders (ADD). Methods: A longitudinal multicenter study was conducted by enrolling obese adult patients in charge to 6 Hospital in Italy at time of intervention of
gastric banding, gastric by-pass, and sleeve gastrectomy and following up to 1 year.
Fabriani V , Marcellusi A , Mennini F S , Giannantoni P
University of Rome “Tor Vergata”, Rome, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The objective of this study is to estimate the average annual direct
and indirect costs associated with Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) in Italy
considering both National Health System (NHS) societal perspective. Methods:
A probabilistic prevalence-based cost of illness model was used to estimate the
economic impact of a rare disease as DMD. All the costs were determined through
a survey that families registered with the Muscular Dystrophy Association “Parent
Project onlus” completed on-line. NHS and family prospective has been analyzed
dividing the patients into three age groups (< 8, 8 – 16 and > 16). Human capital
approach was used to determine loss of productivity due to absenteeism, while the
bottom up approach was used to calculate direct costs. Furthermore, a probabilistic
sensitivity analysis with 5,000 Monte Carlo simulations was performed, in order
to test the robustness of results and define the 95%CI. Results: Indirect costs
are those that weigh more on the total expenditure of the NHS with € 474.634.836
(95%CI: € 300.028.168 - € 698.965.090) per year, while the direct health care costs are €
7.475.596 (95%CI: € 5.124.369,29 - € 10.263.785) and nonmedical costs are € 12.944.879
(95% CI: € 7.925.699 - € 19.175.331). Patients with more than 16 years spend more
than those between 0 and 7 years old, and even more than those between 8 and 15.
For what concern the private expenditure, the model estimated € 2.910.506 (95%CI:
€ 345.231,83 - € 718.786) for the direct costs, and € 185.333.744 (95%CI: € 114.177.282
- € 273.446.219) for the nonmedical costs. Conclusions: Although DMD is a rare
disease, its economic impact on NHS is quite remarkable. Furthermore, the most
of the impact relies on families and society.
Kousoulakou H 1, Symeonidis A 2, Kyriakou D 3, Sotiropoulos D 4, Gigantes S 5, Delimbasi S 5,
Tsirigotis P 6, Hatzikou M 7, Geitona M 1
1University of Peloponnese, Corinth, Greece, 2University of Patras Medical School, Patras, Greece,
3University Hospital of Larissa, Larissa, Greece, 4G. Papanicolaou Hospital, Thessaloniki, Greece,
5Evangelismos Hospital, Athens, Greece, 6Attikon Hospital, Chaidari, Greece, 7Novartis Hellas,
Metamorfosis, Greece
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate the burden of myelofibrosis (MF) in Greece, focusing on
epidemiological data, quality of life (QoL), direct and indirect costs. Methods: A
17-page questionnaire was developed, validated, and completed with the Delphi
technique. It included questions on epidemiological, resource use, QoL and socioeconomic data. An expert panel with 9 KOL haematologists was convened consisting
of experts from the largest Haematology Units of Greece, covering geographically
six out of seven Regional Health Authorities. Unit costs in 2014 prices were taken
from officially published sources. The societal perspective was adopted. Results:
Prevalence and incidence rates of MF in Greece are approx. 2.5: 100,000 and 0.7:
100,000 people respectively, corresponding to approx. 270 patients (71.7% with primary and 28.3% with secondary) and 76 new cases every year; 92% of the patients
present with splenomegaly at diagnosis, 1/3 of which reduce their daily activities. Current treatment options in Greece are ruxolitinib and best supportive care
(BSC). 72.6% of the primary and 65% of the secondary MF patients treated with
ruxolitinib show improvement of splenomegaly vs. 23% and 7%, respectively for
patients treated with BSC. Ruxolitinib patients show QoL improvement and less
splenectomies (< 1%) compared with BSC patients (~3%). Work loss days associated
with ruxolitinib are estimated at 23 days per year (51 days for BSC), and 20% of them
return to work after treatment (5% for BSC). The annual direct cost of managing
all MF patients in Greece is estimated at € 1.65 million, including pharmaceutical, hospital, follow-up costs, blood transfusions, and management of infections.
Productivity losses are estimated at € 217,975 per year, resulting in a total annual
burden of approx. € 1.87 million. Conclusions: MF is associated with significant
burden to patients, their families, and to the society. Treatment with ruxolitinib
appears to improve patients’ QoL and reduce indirect costs, mainly through reduction of splenomegaly and splenectomies.
PSY43
The Indirect Costs of Multiple Sclerosis Associated With
Absenteeism In Poland
Mocko P 1, Kawalec P 2
University Medical College, Krakow, Poland, 2Jagiellonian University Medical
College, Krakow, Poland
.
1Jagiellonaian
.
A529
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: The aim of this study was to assess the indirect costs associated with
multiple sclerosis (MS) from the perspective of Social Insurance Institution (ZUS)
in Poland. Methods: The estimates were based on data from the Social Insurance
Institution (ZUS) referring to year 2012 and focused on absenteeism due to the
illness: costs of sick leave as well as the short-term disability due to rehabilitation
benefit and the burden of permanent (or long term) disability due to disability pension in Poland. Cost analysis was performed based on the Human Capital Approach
taking into account Gross Domestic Product (GDP) per capita equaled 41 398 PLN
and Gross Value Added (GVA) per worker equaled 99 697 PLN. Costs were presented
in polish zloty (PLN). Results: Total indirect costs of multiple sclerosis associated with absenteeism in the year 2012 in Poland were 39 870 385 PLN calculated
using GDP per capita and 96 018 323 PLN as a GVA per worker. The predominant
component of absenteeism of MS was sick leave, which accounted for 69%. Long
and short term disability costs constituted 21% and 9% of total indirect costs of
multiple sclerosis associated with absenteeism, respectively. One sick leave of
person with multiple sclerosis generated the cost of lost productivity equal 1 866
PLN and 4 490 PLN calculated using GDP per capita and GVA per worker, respectively. Indirect cost of short-term disability for one entitlement to the benefit of
rehabilitation were 17 077 PLN and 41 125 PLN, respectively. Cost of one long term
benefit were much higher than short term benefit and equaled 41 398 PLN and 99
697 PLN, respectively. Conclusions: Multiple sclerosis in Poland generated very
high indirect costs. The main component was sick leave; disability pension and
rehabilitation benefit generated lower costs of lost productivity.
PSY44
Costs of Absenteeism In Ankylosing Spondylitis Based On Real-Life
Data From Poland’s Social Insurance Institution Database In 2012
Malinowski K 1, Kawalec P 2
1Jagiellonian University Medical Collage, Krakow, Poland, 2Jagiellonian University Medical College,
Krakow, Poland
.
.
Objectives: The aim of this study was to assess the indirect costs caused by absenteeism associated with ankylosing spondylitis (AS) from the perspective of the Social
Insurance Institution (ZUS) in Poland. Methods: The estimates were based on data
provided by ZUS referring to year 2012 and concerning absence from work due to
the illness (sick leave), the amount of short term disability, the sufferers of which
claim rehabilitation benefit, and the amount of permanent (or long term) disability,
the sufferers of which claim disability pension. Costs were calculated with Human
Capital Approach methodology taking into account Gross Domestic Product (GDP)
per capita equaled 41 398PLN and Gross Value Added (GVA) per worker equaled 99
697PLN and were presented in 2012 prices in Polish zloty (PLN). Results: Total
indirect costs of AS in the year 2012 calculated using GDP per capita and GVA per
worker in Poland were 21 299 578PLN and 51 294 959PLN, respectively. The highest component of indirect costs of AS was sick leave (56%). Long and short term
disability costs constitute 6% and 39% of total indirect costs of AS, respectively. In
2012 Poland’s Social Insurance Institution database reported 3 500 patients on sick
leave, 72 patients with short term disability and 7 patients with long term disability.
Indirect costs per patient associated with sick leave were 3 400PLN and 8 188PLN
calculated using GDP per capita and GVA per worker, respectively. Indirect costs
per patient associated with short term disability were 16 602PLN and 39 983PLN
respectively and associated with long term disability were as high as 1 171 958PLN
and 2 822 381PLN, respectively. Conclusions: AS in Poland generated high indirect
costs. The main component was sick leave; rehabilitation benefit and disability
pension generated lower costs of lost productivity.
PSY45
The Economic Burden of Systemic Lupus Erythematosus:
A Structured Literature Review
Jugrin A V 1, Sun Y 2, Cox F 3
1IMS Health RWE Solutions and HEOR, Vilvoorde, Belgium, 2UCB Pharma, Brussels, Belgium,
3UCB Pharma, Smyrna, GA, USA
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess the direct and indirect costs of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), analysis of which is complex due to the heterogeneity of the disease,
accumulative organ damage and associated comorbidities. Methods: Direct and
indirect costs attributable to SLE were extracted from studies published January
2004–March 2013, identified using Medline, EMBASE, EconLit and NHS EED. Eligible
studies involved adults with active SLE. Results: The direct cost associated with
SLE management was € 3,691/yr in Europe.1 In the US, annual health care costs
were $10,984 higher for SLE patients vs non-SLE controls.2 Organ damage and
disease activity were key drivers of annual cost variations;1–4 in Europe, cardiovascular/respiratory (€ 596/yr) and renal involvement (€ 511/yr) appeared the most
costly organs.1 Estimated direct annual cost of treating any flare in the EU was
~€ 399, whilst for severe flares was ~€ 1,002.1 In the US, renal involvement was the
most costly organ: cost ratios were 3.1 (95% CI: 2.3–4.2) in newly diagnosed and 2.7
(95% CI: 2.4–3.0) in existing SLE patients.4 Annual costs for mild and severe flares
in the US were $129/flare and $11,716/flare, respectively.2 The indirect economic
burden is also substantial, as SLE typically occurs during the peak of working
years and in young women with child-bearing potential (around the age of 20 in
Black females and 30 in White females).5,6 Predictors of future work loss in SLE
included older age, shorter job tenure, thrombotic and musculoskeletal manifestations, greater number of manifestations and high disease.7,8 Conclusions:
The direct and indirect economic burden is prominent within SLE patients. Organ
damage is a substantial “hidden cost” and should be considered when assessing
the economic impact
References:
1. Doria A. Ann Rheum Dis 2014; 73 (1): 154-160, 2. Kan H. Biomed Res Int 2013;
808391, 3. hamashta M. Lupus 2014; 23 (3): 273-283, 4. Furst D. Lupus 2013; 22
(1): 99-105, 5. Baker K. Lupus 2009; 18 (14) 1281-1288, 6. Somers E. Arthritis
Rheum 2007; 57 (4): 612-618, 7. Yelin E. Arthritis Care Res 2013; 64 (2): 169-175,
8. Oglesby A. Arthritis Rheum 2012; 64 (10): S934
PSY46
The Cost of Active Systemic Lupus Erythematosus in Greece Results
From the Lycos Study
Athanasakis K 1, Karampli E 1, Psomali D 2, Perna A 3, Kyriopoulos J 1
School of Public Health, Athens, Greece, 2GlaxoSmithKline, Halandri, Greece,
3GlaxoSmithKline, Brentford, UK
.
.
.
.
.
1National
Objectives: Systemic Lupus Erythematosus (SLE) is an autoimmune disease, characterized by periods of remissions and flares, with significant clinical and economic
burden. The primary study objective was to estimate the 1-year direct medical cost
for adult patients with active, autoantibody-positive SLE in Greece. Methods: This
is a national, multi-centre, retrospective study. Data were abstracted from patient
records in 6 hospital centers specialized in SLE management. Starting with the
patient with the most recent visit, patients with consecutive visits (backwards in
time) were considered for inclusion, provided they met specific criteria. In order to
estimate costs per disease severity, a stratification criterion was applied. Patient
data were collected for a 1-year period starting from the inclusion date (January
-September 2011) and moving forward. Data included patient characteristics and
health care resource utilization. In addition, all SLE patients fulfilling the inclusion criteria and followed-up in the participating centers during a 3-month retrospective period were recorded. For cost calculation, official 2013 list prices were
used. Results: 215 patients (30% severe according to the stratification criterion)
were included in the study. Mean direct medical costs were estimated at € 1,225
for patients with non-severe and at € 3,741 for patients with severe active SLE.
Laboratory and imaging tests, medicines, physicians’ visits, and hospitalization
costs represented 10.5%, 51.7%, 1.2%, 36.5% of mean cost respectively. Costs were
statistically significantly higher for severe SLE patients. The total number of patients
visiting the participating clinical sites during a 3-month period was 318 (19% with
severe SLE). The weighted mean annual direct medical cost of SLE in Greece was estimated at € 1,703. Conclusions: Direct medical cost of SLE in Greece is significant,
especially for patients with severe disease. An estimation of indirect costs would
provide a comprehensive picture of the societal burden of the disease.
PSY47
Romiplostim Cost Per Response In Itp Treatment In the Brazilian
Health Care System
Pepe C 1, Teich V 1, Coutinho M B 2, Almeida S 3
- Grupo Resulta, São Paulo, Brazil, 2Amgen Brazil, Sao Paulo, Brazil, 3Amgen,
São Paulo, Brazil
.
.
.
.
.
1NewBD/Medinsight
Objectives: Immune thrombocytopenia (ITP) is characterized by isolated thrombocytopenia with no underlying cause. It manifests clinically as mucocutaneous bleeding caused by decreased platelets. Recently, two thrombopoietin receptor-agonists
have emerged as an important therapeutic options: romiplostim and eltrombopag.
Since these medications have different mode of administration, safety and efficacy profiles, the present study was carried out in an attempt to investigate which
drug would be more cost-effective in the Brazilian setting. The objective was to
perform an economic analysis evaluating the cost per response of romiplostim
versus eltrombopag in adult patients with chronic ITP and refractory to other treatments as corticosteroids and immunoglobulins in Brazil health care private system. Methods: Two economic analyses were performed in order to study the use
of romiplostim and eltrombopag for the treatment of adults with chronic refractory
ITP, based on annual treatment costs and cost per response. The average body weight
adopted was 74,6 kg. Efficacy data were obtained from the product inserts, as well
as from scientific publications. In cost per response, it was considered a 6-month
analysis, which corresponds to the overall platelet response in clinical trials. The
outcome of these trials was the global response to treatment. The cost of each drug
presentation were based on ex-factory price (VAT 18%) and obtained from the official
price list (CMED; April, 2014). Results: The cost of treatment with romiplostim
showed an annual saving of R$7,724 over eltrombopag within the payer perspective, which may be further improved if we assume that drug-food interactions of
eltrombopag in some patients lead to reduced medication adherence and loss of
response. The cost per response with romiplostim was 26% lower than with eltrombopag. Conclusions: Romiplostim was more cost-effective than eltrombopag for
the treatment of chronic refractory ITP in adult patients and may represent savings
to the Brazilian health system.
PSY48
Direct and Indirect Costs Associated With Increasing Body Mass
Index (Bmi) In the Eu5
Richard L 1, Gupta S 2, Pomerantz D 2, Forsythe A 2
1Eisai Europe Ltd, Hatfield, UK, 2Kantar Health, Princeton, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
Objectives: This study evaluated the impact of BMI category on health utilities,
health care resource-utilisation, productivity, activity impairment, and associated
costs. Methods: Results were from the 2013 EU5 National Health and Wellness
Survey (N= 62,000), a nationally representative, online survey of respondents
aged ≥ 18 years. This analysis focused on normal weight (BMI≥ 18.5 & < 25 kg/m2),
overweight (BMI≥ 25 & < 30 kg/m2), obese class (OC) I (BMI≥ 30 & < 35 kg/m2), OC II
(BMI≥ 35 & < 40 kg/m2), and OC III (BMI≥ 40 kg/m2) respondents. Patients provided
information on SF-6D (health utility) scores, productivity loss (Work Productivity and
Activity Impairment questionnaire) and resource-utilisation (type/number of visits)
in the past six months. Direct and indirect costs were estimated from the literature.
Generalised linear models predicted resource use and productivity as a function of
BMI category, adjusting for covariates (e. g., age, gender, comorbidities). Results:
Among 58,364 respondents, 46.9% were normal weight, 34.5% were overweight,
12.5% were OC I, 4.0% were OC II, and 2.1% were OC III. Metabolic comorbidities
increased as BMI increased. Adjusting for covariates, health utility (normal weight:
0.720; overweight: 0.718; OC I: 0.703; OC II: 0.683; OC III: 0.662) scores declined with
an increase in BMI (all p<0.05 vs. normal). Among employed patients (57.7%), overall
work impairment increased as BMI increased (normal weight: 17.9%; overweight:
18.4%; OC I: 19.0%; OC II: 21.4%; OC III: 26.7%, p< 0.05 all OCs vs. normal). Normal
A530
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
(vs. all OCs) had lower activity impairment and fewer provider visits, lower indirect
costs (normal weight: € 7,974; overweight: € 7,825; OC I: € 8,465; OC II: € 9,394; OC III:
€ 10,437), and lower total direct costs (normal weight: € 516; overweight: € 553; OC I:
€ 583; OC II: € 605; OC III: € 717), all p< 0.05. Conclusions: Increased BMI is associated with higher direct and indirect costs and worse health utilities. The findings
highlight the impact of obesity on health outcomes.
PSY49
Cross-Country Comparison of Medical Resource Utilisation In
Patients With Autosomal Dominant Polycystic Kidney Disease In
Europe
Blais J 1, Krasa H B 2, Szende A 3, Colman S 4, Schaefer C 5, Dale P 6, Robinson P 6, O’Reilly K 6
Pharmaceutical Development & Commercialization, Inc., Princeton, NJ, USA, 2Otsuka
Pharmaceutical Development & Commercialization, Inc., Rockville, MD, USA, 3Covance, Leeds,
UK, 4Covance Pty Ltd, North Ryde, Australia, 5Covance, Gaithersburg, MD, USA, 6Otsuka
Pharmaceutical Europe Ltd, Wexham, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Otsuka
Objectives: Autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease (ADPKD) is the most
common genetic kidney disease. Currently there is little published information on
medical resource utilisation (MRU) in European ADPKD patients. This study aimed
to estimate the health care resource use of ADPKD patients across six European
countries. Methods: A retrospective review of medical charts was conducted via
an online physician survey in France, Germany, Italy, Spain, Sweden and the United
Kingdom (UK). A total of 353 physicians were recruited to review MRU over the previous 24 month period from the records of 1,055 patients, with each clinician selecting
the last three patients representing three different chronic kidney disease stages.
Data collected included patient characteristics and MRU such as tests, visits, hospitalisations and medications. Results: The proportion of patients who had a kidney
ultrasound during the 24 months study period varied from 20.0% in Sweden to 68.0%
in Germany. In all countries, except Germany (66.0%), at least 90% of patients had
one or more contact with a specialist. Annualised specialist visits varied from 2.7
(SD 7.9) in Germany to 6.0 (SD 10.7) in Sweden. Germany had the largest proportion
of patients with hospitalisations related to ADPKD (25.7%) whereas Sweden had
the lowest (13.3%). Hospital length of stay was longest in Spain (mean, 8.5 days (SD
6.2)) and shortest in the UK (mean, 4.7 days (SD 3.8)). In terms of medication use,
32.7% of German patients were prescribed loop diuretics whereas this proportion
was 9.0% in the UK. The UK had the highest rate of opioid use for renal pain overall
(8.7%) and among patients on dialysis (27.3%). Conclusions: This is the first study
to provide comparative evidence on MRU in European patients with ADPKD. Results
highlight some country-specific differences in treatment patterns, including rates
of hospitalisation, frequency of specialist visits and medication use.
PSY50
An Evaluation of Medical Resource Utilisation In Patients With
Autosomal Dominant Polycystic Kidney Disease In Europe
Blais J 1, Krasa H B 2, Szende A 3, Colman S 4, Schaefer C 5, Dale P 6, Robinson P 6, O’Reilly K 6
Pharmaceutical Development & Commercialization, Inc., Princeton, NJ, USA, 2Otsuka
Pharmaceutical Development & Commercialization, Inc., Rockville, MD, USA, 3Covance, Leeds,
UK, 4Covance Pty Ltd, North Ryde, Australia, 5Covance, Gaithersburg, MD, USA, 6Otsuka
Pharmaceutical Europe Ltd, Wexham, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Otsuka
Objectives: Autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease (ADPKD) is the most
common type of polycystic kidney disease (PKD) and the fourth leading cause of endstage renal disease. Currently, there is no published information on medical resource
utilisation (MRU) in patients with ADPKD in Europe. This study aimed to better
understand MRU associated with ADPKD by disease stage in six European countries
(Germany, France, the United Kingdom, Italy, Spain and Sweden). Methods: This
study was a retrospective review of medical charts collected via an online physician
survey. Participating physicians abstracted data for the last three eligible ADPKD
patients treated in their practice, each within a different Chronic Kidney Disease
(CKD) stage. Data collected over the past 2 years included socio-demographics,
clinical characteristics and MRU, such as diagnostic tests, specialist visits, dialysis,
emergency department visits, inpatient admissions and medications. Results:
A total of 1,055 ADPKD patients were enrolled. The mean (SD) age of the sample
was 50.4 (14.4) years, 53.6% were male, with 39.4% employed full time. Only 40% of
patients had a known PKD genotype, of which 83% had PKD-1 and 17% had PKD2. Almost all patients (99.1%) experienced at least 1 ADPKD-related complication,
most commonly hypertension (75.4%). On average (SD), patients had 4.4 (9.3) annual
specialist visits. Approximately 19.7% of patients experienced at least 1 hospitalisation over the 2 year study period with a mean (SD) length of stay of 7.0 (8.5) days.
Patients in more advanced disease stages reported higher mean (SD) annual specialist visits and more disease-related hospitalisations, 1.5 (1.1) and 9.2% in CKD
Stage 1 compared to 10.0 (17.2) and 32.4% in Dialysis, respectively. Conclusions:
This is the first study to provide evidence on MRU among patients with ADPKD in
Europe. Results demonstrate that ADPKD patients require substantial MRU, which
accumulate with disease progression.
PSY51
Cost-Consequences Analysis of the Long-Term Prophylaxis In A Type
1 Von Willebrand Disease Patient With Recurrent Bleedings In Italy
Cipolla A 1, Cultrera D 1, Teruzzi C 2, Mantuano M 3
1Dept. of Hematology, Haemophilia Regional Reference Centre, University of Catania, Catania,
Italy, 2Temas - A Quintiles Company, Cassina de’ Pecchi, Italy, 3Temas. A Quintiles Company,
Milan, Italy
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Von Willebrand Disease (VWD) is the most common inherited bleeding
disorder, caused by a deficiency or abnormality of the Von Willebrand factor (VWF).
Long-term prophylaxis (LTP) with Factor VIII-containing VWF product (FVIII/VWF) is
used for patients with severe VWD. However, FVIII/VWF is not enough effective in
some cases. Furthermore repeated infusions of FVIII/VWF may increase the risk of
thromboembolic events. The objective of the analysis was to assess the economic
impact of VWF concentrate almost devoid of FVIII as an alternative to FVIII/VWF for
a patient on LTP with recurrent bleedings. Methods: A cost-consequences analysis
was adopted to assess the economic impact from the NHS and Society perspectives.
The cost analysis was based on one patient case (type 1 VWD, recurrent gum bleedings), treated with FVIII/VWF and then with VWF concentrate almost devoid of FVIII.
The costs included direct costs (drug acquisition, hospital admissions, outpatient
visits, red blood cells units) and indirect costs (working days lost). Data were gathered
from a questionnaire (Hemophilia Reference Center of Catania). The health care costs
were calculated by DRG analysis that assessed DRG refund value for day hospital
and standard hospitalization. The indirect costs were calculated on the basis of the
annual income average. Results: The analysis showed a reduction of the number
of bleedings when treating with VWF concentrate almost devoid of FVIII (30 vs 0),
minimizing the cost per bleeding episodes (€87,957 vs €0), hospitalizations (€3,252 vs
0), monitoring visits (€331 vs €165) and the number of working days lost (26 vs 2). The
annual health care costs and indirect costs avoided were € 49,684 and €3,734 respectively. Conclusions: The replacement therapy with VWF concentrate almost devoid
of FVIII decreased the consumption of hospital resources and reduced the number
of working days lost per bleedings together with the discomfort related to bleedings.
PSY52
Cost Per Response Analysis for Thrombopoietin Receptor
Agonists (Tpo-Ras), In the Treatment of Adult Chronic Immune
Thrombocytopenia (Itp) In Mexico
Alva M E 1, Rivera R 1, Arocho R 2, Campos I 3, Campioni M 4
City, Mexico, 2Amgen, Inc., Barcelona, Spain, 3Amgen, Zug, Switzerland, 4Amgen
(Europe) GmbH, Zug, Switzerland
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Amgen, Mexico
Objectives: TPO-RAs, represent an evidence-based treatment option in the public setting for adult patients with chronic ITP in Mexico. TPO-RAs have not been
directly compared in head-to-head randomized controlled trials (RCTs); however
an indirect comparison was undertaken using Bayesian metaregression: the overall
platelet response was significantly higher in patients receiving Romiplostim than
in those receiving Eltrombopag, estimating an Odds ratio (OR) of eltrombopag vs
romiplostim as 0.15 (95% CI: 0.02, 0.84). The objective of this study is to compare
the cost per response of TPO-RAs in chronic adult ITP in Mexico. Methods: A cost
per response analysis was developed. Dose was derived from RCTs and Summary
of Product Characteristics. Median dose for romiplostim was 2.5 mcg/kg/week and
average dose for eltrombopag was 55 mg/day (21.5% of patients received 25mg;
41% 75mg; and remaining 37.5% 50mg). Costs for romiplostim were based on vials
used, considering a representative Mexican patient (65kg); for eltrombopag, it was
based on milligrams needed. Cost assessment included cost of medication, cost of
administration and in case of eltrombopag, cost of liver monitoring, expressed in
Mexican pesos. Crude Overall Response Rate (ORR) for romiplostim was 83%. Placebo
adjusted ORR for eltrombopag was 42% calculated by applying the OR estimated
from the Bayesian indirect comparison performed by the NICE Evidence Review
Group. Results: Romiplostim generates a cost per overall platelet response of
$219,690.80, while eltrombopag yields $374,137.72. Conclusions: Within the TPORAs, romiplostim generates a lower cost per response than eltrombopag, in adult
patients with chronic ITP in Mexico.
PSY53
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Belimumab In the Treatment of
Adult Systemic Lupus Erythematosus (Sle) Patients With Positive
Biomarkers In Spain
Vallejo-Aparicio L A 1, Díaz-Cerezo S 1, Parrondo J 1, García-Aparicio A M 2
España, Tres Cantos, Spain, 2Hospital VIrgen de la Salud, Toledo, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
1GSK
Objectives: Belimumab is a novel biological treatment specifically developed for
the treatment of active, autoantibody positive SLE patients. The purpose of this study
is to estimate the cost-effectiveness of belimumab for SLE patients from the Spanish
societal perspective. Methods: A UK cost-effectiveness microsimulation model
was adapted to the Spanish setting. The analysis compared standard of care (SoC)
vs. belimumab plus SoC with 2 years maximum treatment duration and a life-time
horizon. Disease activity reduction seen with belimumab in the BLISS-52 and BLISS76 trials, was extrapolated using data from the US Johns Hopkins Lupus Cohort to
predict impact on long-term organ damage and mortality.. Utility values and unit
direct costs (treatment, administration, patient´s follow-up and organ damage costs)
were obtained from UK and Spain published data, respectively. Indirect costs were
calculated using the Human Capital Approach method. A discount rate of 3% was
applied to costs and outcomes. Results were expressed as € 2014. Deterministic and
probabilistic sensitivity analyses (PSA) were conducted to determine the robustness of the results. An additional analysis was conducted to compare societal and
Spanish National Health System (NHS) perspectives. Results: The cost per life year
gained (ICER) and cost per QALY (ICUR) for Belimumab were € 16,647 and € 23,158
respectively. In 68% of scenarios plotted in the PSA, belimumab was a cost-effective
alternative considering a € 30,000/QALY threshold. From NHS perspective (indirect
costs excluded), ICER and ICUR were € 25.619 and €35.640. Conclusions: Base-case
results show that belimumab is cost-effective from the Spanish societal perspective.
From the NHS perspective, the model provides results that fall within an acceptable
threshold considering the prevalence and the severity of the disease. These results
highlight the importance of adopting a societal perspective, especially in pathologies
such as SLE which affect young people of working age.
PSY54
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Maintenance Treatment With
Rituximab In Patients With Follicular Lymphoma Responding To
First Line Induction Therapy In Portugal
Pereira C 1, Rubio Terres C 2, Rubio Rodríguez D 2
Farmacêutica Química, Lda., Amadora, Portugal, 2Health Value, Madrid, Spain
.
.
.
1Roche
Objectives: Evaluate the efficiency of rituximab in maintenance treatment of
patients with follicular lymphoma (FL) who respond to first line induction with
rituximab versus observation in Portugal. Methods: Cost-effectiveness (Life
A531
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Years Gained - LYG) and cost-utility analysis (Quality- Adjusted Life years – QALYs)
were performed for a time horizon of 10 years according to a Markov economic
model with four health states - “progression free survival (PFS) in first and second
lines”, “progression” and “death” - and monthly cycles. Health states transition
probabilities were obtained from two randomized controlled clinical trials: PRIMA
(Salles G. et al 2010) and EORTC 20981 (van Oers M. et al 2010). Health state utilities were obtained from literature (Pettengell R. et al 2008). Resource consumption
was estimated by a Portuguese expert’s panel. Costs were calculated considering
the Portuguese Health System perspective through official data (unit costs: € in
2014). Costs and consequences were discounted at 5% per annum. Deterministic
and probabilistic (Monte Carlo simulation) sensitivity analyses were performed for
several assumptions namely time horizon, PFS supportive care and progression
costs; adverse events costs; health states utilities values and costs and benefits
annual discount. Results: For a 10 years’ time horizon, the cost per LYG and QALYs
gained was € 10,630 and € 10,674 respectively. Sensitivity analyses confirmed the
base case results for time horizons of 20 and 30 years, ranging between € 7,430 and
€ 7,155 per QALY gained, respectively. Probabilistic sensitivity analysis confirmed
the robustness of the model with a cost per QALY gained of € 10,657. The incremental cost-effectiveness acceptability curve shows that rituximab maintenance
therapy would be cost effective from a willingness to pay of € 12,000 per QALY
gained. Conclusions: According to the present model rituximab maintenance
treatment of FL patients who respond to first line induction therapy compared with
observation is a cost-effective strategy in Portugal.
PSY55
The Cost-Effectiveness of Expanding the Nhs Newborn Bloodspot
Screening Programme To Include Homocystinuria (Hcu), Maple
Syrup Urine Disease (Msud), Glutaric Aciduria Type 1 (Ga1), Isovaleric
Acidaemia (Iva), and Long-Chain Hydroxyacyl-Coa Dehydrogenase
Deficiency (Lchadd)
Bessey A 1, Chilcott J 2, Pandor A 1, Paisley S 1
University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK, 2University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK
.
.
.
.
1The
Objectives: The NHS newborn bloodspot screening programme currently screens
all babies in England for five rare conditions. The objective of this study was to
assess the cost-effectiveness of expanding the screening programme to include five
new rare conditions all inborn errors of the metabolism; HCU, MSUD, GA1, IVA, and
LCHADD. Methods: A decision tree model was built to estimate the cost-effectiveness of the expanded newborn screening programme. Estimates of the prevalence
of the five conditions and the test characteristics of screening were taken from
the literature. Survival and morbidity estimates for the screened and unscreened
populations were estimated from published case series. Quality adjusted life years
(QALYS) were estimated from the extended EQ-5D+ (C) which includes a cognitive
dimension in order to capture the impact of neurological impairment and developmental delay which are known sequelae of the five conditions. Costs related to
the marginal cost of the expanded screening programme, management costs of the
conditions, and costs associated with the sequelae of the conditions were estimated
from the pilot study of the expanded screening, case reports from the pilot, expert
elicitation, published guidelines and estimates from the literature. Costs and QALYs
were multiplied by survival and morbidity estimates to give lifetime estimates for
the screened and unscreened populations. A probabilistic sensitivity analysis (PSA)
was conducted. Results: The results from the deterministic analysis and PSA suggests that screening for all five conditions is cost-saving with screening associated
with lower total costs and higher total QALYs compared to no screening. The incremental net benefit for all five conditions, at a threshold of £25,000 per QALY, was
between £0.46 for IVA and £5.94 for GA1. Conclusions: Screening for MSUD, HCU,
IVA, GA1 and LCHADD are each estimated to be potentially cost saving and result
in increased quality of life compared to no screening.
PSY56
Cost-Effectiveness of Capsaicin 8% Patch (Qutenzatm) Compared
With Pregabalin for the Treatment of Patients With Peripheral
Neuropathic Pain (Pnp) In Scotland
Patel S 1, Trueman D 2, Bentley A 2, Poole C 1, Chambers C 1
Pharma Europe Ltd, Chertsey, UK, 2Abacus International, Bicester, UK
.
.
.
.
.
1Astellas
Objectives: PNP is a high-burden disease exacerbated by poor tolerability of conventional oral therapies. Capsaicin 8% patch is a well-tolerated cutaneous treatment for PNP in non-diabetic adults either alone or in combination with other
therapies. We evaluated the cost-effectiveness of capsaicin 8% patch versus pregabalin in patients with PNP from the perspective of NHS Scotland. Methods: A
decision tree model was developed considering patients with PNP who had neither
achieved pain relief nor tolerated conventional first-/second-line treatments. After
8 weeks’ treatment with capsaicin 8% patch or pregabalin, patients remained on
therapy or discontinued due to intolerable adverse events. Patients continuing on
therapy were classified as either responders (≥ 30% decrease in pain from baseline)
or non-responders. Last-line therapy was given to non-responders and those who
discontinued treatment. The base-case time horizon was 2 years. Effectiveness,
discontinuations and quality of life utilities were estimated from a recent head-tohead study (ELEVATE; NCT01713426). Other inputs were obtained from published
sources or clinical expert opinion. All costs were based on GBP 2013/14. The results
were presented as incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICERs), i. e. cost per qualityadjusted life-year (QALY) gained. Model assumptions were tested with scenario
analyses. Parameter uncertainty was tested using one-way and probabilistic sensitivity analyses. Results: Compared with pregabalin, capsaicin 8% patch was
dominant versus pregabalin (total cost difference, –£11 and total QALY gains, +0.049).
Using a 1-year time horizon, the ICER increased to £1,242/QALY. The model was most
sensitive to variations in time to capsaicin 8% patch retreatment (worse case ICER,
£7,951/QALY). Capsaicin 8% patch was dominant in six/seven scenario analyses.
At a willingness-to-pay threshold of £20,000/QALY gained, the probability of costeffectiveness for capsaicin 8% patch versus pregabalin was 97%. Conclusions:
Capsaicin 8% patch is cost-effective compared to pregabalin for patients who have
failed one or more previous systemic treatments for PNP.
PSY57
Cost Effectiveness Analysis Evaluating Factor Viii As Primary
Prophylaxis Treatment for Patients With Severe Haemophilia A
In the Netherlands
Kip M 1, van den Bosch M 2, Fischer K 3, Tamminga R 4, Lepage-Nefkens I 1
Netherlands, 2Bayer, Mijdrecht, The Netherlands, 3Van Creveldkliniek
& Julius Center for Health Sciences and Primary Care, University Medical Center Utrecht, Utrecht,
The Netherlands, 4Beatrix Childrens Hospital, University Medical Center Groningen, Groningen,
The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
1PANAXEA, Enschede, The
Objectives: Multiple regimens are used in the treatment of severe haemophilia A
in the Netherlands. Most patients receive clotting factors intravenously 2-3 times
weekly to prevent bleedings: intermediate dose prophylaxis. Given the high utilization of prophylaxis treatment, budget restraints might hinder the availability of
prophylaxis for patients in the nearby future. Other treatment regimens are ondemand (OD) treatment, administering clotting factors in case of bleedings, and
prophylaxis treatment with a switch to OD at 18 years. This analysis estimates
the cost-effectiveness of Dutch prophylaxis treatment for severe haemophilia A
patients compared to other treatment regimens. Methods: A Markov model is
developed with the health stages ‘Alive’, ‘Severe joint damage’ and ‘Death’. Bleeding
rates of individual patients are simulated over lifetime, including a probability of
inhibitor development. A higher joint bleed rate is accompanied by increased joint
damage, increasing the chance of joint surgery. Disease progression, within the
Alive health state, is modeled with the Pettersson Score (PS). The PS indicates the
radiographic arthropathy. Increased joint damage is associated with physical limitations and decreased QoL. Because the chosen treatment regimen affects both the
joint bleed rate and inhibitor development, it also affects the HRQoL. The analysis
was performed from a societal perspective. Results: Prophylaxis treatment was
associated with the greatest QoL. The cost-effectiveness acceptability curve shows
a probability of 90% for prophylaxis treatment to be cost-effective at a threshold of
€ 0, - compared to OD treatment. Compared to prophylaxis with a switch to OD at
18 years, prophylaxis treatment has a 50% probability of being cost-effective at a
€ 80.000, - threshold. The model outcome is sensitive for variations in bleeding rate,
prophylaxis dosage, inhibitor development and utilities. Conclusions: Based on
our model, treatment of severe haemophilia A patients with lifetime prophylaxis
is cost-effective compared to OD treatment.
PSY58
Cost-Effectiveness of the Lidocaine 5% Medicated Plaster VERSUS
Pregabalin and Amitriptyline for the Treatment of Post-Herpetic
Neuralgia In the Netherlands
Obradovic M 1, Vanden Baviere H 2, Liedgens H 3
1GfK Market Access, Nuremberg, Germany, 2Grünenthal, St Stevens Woluwe, Belgium,
3Grünenthal GmbH, Aachen, Germany
.
.
.
Objectives: The objective of the analysis was to evaluate costs and outcomes
of treating post-herpetic neuralgia (PHN), a chronic disease with severe burden
for patients, in the Netherlands with lidocaine 5% medicated plaster compared to
pregabalin and amitriptyline. Methods: A Markov model was used to extrapolate
outcomes beyond the time horizon of the available trial data and to allow for the
fact that patients may discontinue treatment at any point during treatment. Costs
and effects, expressed in terms of the quality-adjusted life-year (QALY) gained,
were calculated for each treatment strategy over a period of 6 months. The study
included direct costs related to PHN. Indirect costs were not included as most
patients with PHN are older and retired. Transition probabilities were based on
the comparative and long-term clinical trials. Utilites were identified through a
literature review. Resource utilization was obtained from a two-step Delphi study
with pain specialists, cost data were obtained from the official price tariffs/lists.
Extensive sensitivity and scenario analyses were performed to explore robustness of
the results. Results: In 6-month time horizon, treatment with the lidocaine plaster
yielded 0.4283 QALYs. For pregabalin and amitriptyline the total effect was 0.3390
QALYs. The mean costs per patient treated with lidocaine plaster (1.71 plasters/day)
were 1,082 € . For pregabalin (488 mg/day) and amitriptyline (25 mg/day) the mean
costs were 912 € and 346 € , respectively. Therefore, the lidocaine plaster compared
to pregabalin and amitriptyline had an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio of 1,907
€ /QALY and 8,246 € /QALY, respectively. Probability of the lidocaine plaster being
cost-effective versus pregabalin and amitriptyline exceeded 90% when considering
a threshold of 30,000 € per QALY gained. Extensive scenario and one-way sensitivity
analyses confirmed robustness of the results. Conclusions: The lidocaine 5%
plaster is a highly cost-effective treatment for PHN in the Netherlands.
PSY59
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Amfepramone (Diethylpropion) for
the Obesity Treatment In Mexico
Soto Molina H 1, Díaz Martínez J P 1, Escobar Juárez Y 1, Fernández del Valle C 2
Estudios Farmacoeconómicos, Mexico City, Mexico, 2Instituto Politécnico Nacional, Mexico city,
Mexico
.
.
.
.
.
1HS
Objectives: The main objective was to perform a pharmacoeconomic analysis
to find out the cost effectiveness of diethylpropion (DEP) with diet and exercise.
(DEP+DaE), compared against Diet and Exercise (DaE) in the treatment for obesity
from the institutional point of view in Mexico. Methods: Effectiveness data from
a mexican clinical trial (Morin, 2007) was used to populate a decision tree model
to estimate the cost-effectiveness of DEP+DaE and its comparator DaE. The target
population were men and women over 18 years with BMI > 30 kg/m2. Principal
outcome was the reduction of the Body Mass Index (BMI); benefit was expressed as
the percentage of patients who reduced more than 10% of their initial weight. Only
direct medical costs were used, such as medications and adverse events; these were
obtained from the portal shop by IMSS and also from their unitary costs. To prove the
A532
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
strength of the analysis, deterministic and probabilistic sensitivity tests were performed; all the quantities are expresed in Mexican pesos (MXP) at 2013. Results:
Both groups lose weight and reduce their BMI. However, these changes were earlier
and more pronounced in the (DEP+DaE) group. DeP+DaE presented a significant
higher percentage of patients reducing 10% of their intial weight (37% vs 17%,
p-value< .05). Incremental cost was $1,455.09 MXP and incremental effectiveness
was 20% in reducing the initial weight. The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio of
(DEP+DaE) relative to DaE was calculated to be $7,374.07 MXP per additional percentage of reduction suggesting that DEP+DaE is cost-effective compared with DaE as
a treatment for obesity in Mexico. Conclusions: The combination of DEP+DaE
provides a cost effective improvement to the treatment of patients with a risk profile
for obesity in Mexico.
PSY60
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Oxycodone Lp An Opioid Analgesic
for Patients With Moderate To Severe Pain Secondary To Cancer
In Mexico
Soto Molina H 1, Sanchez K 1, Escobar Juárez Y 1, Constanzo A 1, Fernandez Z 2, Melendez C 2
Estudios Farmacoeconómicos, Mexico City, Mexico, 2Psicofarma S.A. de C.V., Mexico City,
Mexico
.
.
.
.
.
.
1HS
Objectives: To perform a complete economic evaluation type using oxycodone
(Endocodil XR ®) versus morphine, buprenorphine (transdermal patches) and fentanyl (transdermal patches) on moderate to severe pain secondary to cancer type
in Mexico, from the point of view of public health. Methods: A cost-effectiveness
analysis was made, a decision tree model was developed to simulate the costs and
benefits of health outcomes of each opioid analgesic, the probabilities were obtained
through a systematic review of the literature. The model has 13 cycles of 28 days
under a time horizon of 364 days, the main measure of effectiveness was determined as days without severe adverse events and pain controlled, only measured
direct medical costs and the ratio was obtained incremental cost-effectiveness,
further a deterministic sensitivity analysis, probabilistic sensitivity analysis and
budget impact was performed. Results: The results demonstrate that oxycodone
(Endocodil XR ®) is a dominant option respect to Buprenorphine (PT), fentanyl (PT),
the results showed 309 days without severe adverse events and controlled pain
compared to 219 and 255 respectively Oxycodone had a cost of $ 57,702.34 under $
58,254.43 and 129,906.49 costing of their comparators respectively, compared to morphine oxycodone is more effective but more expensive, it had an ICER of $ 202.05,
sensitivity analysis and budget impact showed that oxycodone remains an option
cost-saving. Conclusions: The results demonstrate that oxycodone (Endocodil XR
®) is a cost-effective option for the treatment of patients with pain of moderate to
severe secondary to cancer in Mexico, it is an option that effectively combines price
and fails to meet the necessary standards for palliative care and pain management.
PSY61
Comparative Pharmacoeconomic Analysis of the Application of
Posaconazole, Fluconazole and Itraconazole With the Purpose
of Primary Prevention of Invasive Fungal Infection In Patients
With Neutropenia During Chemotherapy for Acute Myelogenous
Leukemia Or Myelodysplastic Syndrome
Krysanov I 1, Krysanova V 2
1Postgraduate Medical Institute, Moscow National University of Food Production, Moscow, Russia,
2I.M. Sechenov First Moscow State Medical University, Moscow, Russia
.
.
Objectives: to perform ñomparative pharmacoeconomic analysis of alternative
schemes for prevention of invasive mycosis with fluconazole, itraconazole and
posaconazole in patients with neutropenia, after chemotherapy for acute myelogenous leukemia or myelodysplastic syndrome. Methods: were reviewed research
on the clinical effectiveness and safety of use of Posaconazole. Assess of the quality of research and level of evidence obtained in these results was performed. The
model is constructed on the basis of the results of a multicenter randomized trial
Cornely O. A. et al., 2007. The model calculated the differences in direct medical
costs for the use of drugs, as well as the cost of medical treatment cases invasive mycosis the ineffectiveness of primary prevention. The duration of preventive
treatment, the probability of various outcomes correspond to the data of specified clinical study. Results: analysis of the evidence has shown that on patients
with neutropenia antifungal prophylaxis with posaconazole is more effective than
fluconazole/itraconazole, and significantly reduces the risk of developing invasive
mycosis, and associated mortality. Total costs for the use of posaconazole was 13169
USD, that by 24.6 % higher than the use of fluconazole (total costs 9932 USD) and
24.3 % higher than itraconazole (total costs 9965 USD). Also use of posaconazole has
increased the total number of LYG by 6%. The ICER was $ 21339 USD and 21117 USD
compared to fluconazole and itraconazole, and lower than the estimated threshold
of willingness to pay in the Russian Federation equal 38390 USD. One-way sensitivity analysis showed that in case of changes in the cost of posaconazole from
75% to 125 %, the ICER for a one LYG do not exceed the threshold of willingness
to pay. Conclusions: use of Posaconazole for prevention of invasive mycosis in
patients with neutropenia is economically justified.
PSY62
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Eltrombopag As Support Treatment
In Chronic Hcv Infected Patients With Thrombocytopenia To Enable
Interferon-Based Regimens
Parrondo J 1, Rincón Rodríguez D 2, Romero Gómez M 3, Sola Lamoglia R 4, Roldán C 1
1GSK Spain, Tres Cantos, Spain, 2Hospital General Universitario Gregorio Marañón, Madrid,
Spain, 3Hospital Universitario de Valme. Universidad de Sevilla, Sevilla, Spain, 4Hospital del Mar
IMIM - Universitat Autonoma de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Thrombocytopenia limits the use of interferon (INF) based regimens
in chronic hepatitis C virus (HCV) patients. Eltrombopag, a thrombopoietin-receptor
agonist, effectively elevates platelet count allowing optimal INF-treatment. The
objective of the present study was to assess the cost-effectiveness as support treat-
ment in chronic HCV infected patients with thrombocytopenia to enable INF-based
treatment regimens from the Spanish Health System perspective. Methods: A
two-phase individual-level model was developed to evaluate the cost-effectiveness
of eltrombopag treatment in thrombocytopenic HCV-patients over a lifetime horizon. Individual-level models are more flexible and provide more accurate estimations than Markov approaches. One million patients were simulated using data from
trials ENABLE 1 and 2 and local studies. In the first phase, a discrete event simulation
was used to recreate patient events during INF-treatment. When eltrombopag was
considered, patients underwent an initial pre-INF treatment with eltrombopag.
Those that failed to reach INF-label platelet count did not receive INF-based regimens. In the second phase, a microsimulation was used to emulate each patient
from treatment discontinuation to death. Health states included fibrosis (F0, F1/2,
F3, F4), liver decompensation, hepatocelullar carcinoma, liver transplant and death.
Transition probabilities for each 1-month cycle, utilities and direct health care costs
(€ 2014) were obtained from literature and national databases. A 3% annual discount
was applied to costs and health outcomes. Sensitivity analysis with 0% and 5%
discount rates were performed. Results: Eltrombopag was associated with an
average increment of 0.58 quality-adjusted life years (QALY) and an additional cost
of € 17,084.47/patient. The average incremental cost effectiveness ratio (ICER) was
29,808.26 € /QALY. Considering a € 30,000 threshold, eltrombopag was cost-effective
in 59.12% of cases. This proportion remained similar with 5% (56.7%) and 0% (63.25%)
discount rates. Conclusions: With the premises considered in this study, eltrombopag in HCV patients could be considered cost-effective from the Spanish Health
System perspective.
PSY63
Cost-Effectiveness of Romiplostim for the Treatment of Chronic
Immune Thrombocytopenia In Portugal
Augusto M 1, Gouveia M 2, Borges M 3, Campioni M 4
Care Research and Consulting, Lda, Lisboa, Portugal, 2Católica Lisbon School
of Business and Economics, Lisbon, Portugal, 3University of Lisbon, Lisbon, Portugal, 4Amgen
(Europe) GmbH, Zug, Switzerland
.
.
.
.
1Evigrade, Health
Objectives: To assess the cost-effectiveness of romiplostim in the treatment of
Adult Immune Thrombocytopenia (ITP) in Portugal, versus eltrombopag and current
medical standard of care (SoC). Methods: A lifetime treatment-sequence cost-utility
Markov model with an embedded decision tree was developed from the Portuguese
Healthcare Payer perspective to compare romiplostim with eltrombopag and SoC in
splenectomized patients, non-splenectomized patients and a combined population.
Treatment sequences and health care utilization were validated by a Portuguese
expert in ITP. Outcomes included incremental cost-utility ratio (ICUR). Costs (€, 2014)
included drug acquisition costs and costs associated with monitoring patients and
managing complications. Results: In the combined population, romiplostim versus
eltrombopag had incremental costs (IC) of 13.848€ and a quality-adjusted life-years
(QALY) gain of 0,566, yielding an ICUR of 24.451€ . Compared with SoC, romiplostim
had IC of 18.622€ and a QALY gain of 0,938, yielding an ICUR of 19.848€ . In splenectomized patients, the most prevalent sub-population in Portugal (65% of adult chronic
ITP patients), romiplostim had an ICUR of 6.304€ versus eltrombopag and an ICUR
of 3.179€ versus SoC. One-way sensitivity analysis showed that the model was most
sensitive to variations in the drug doses/ percentage of utilization and costs (romiplostim, eltrombopag and intravenous immunoglobulin) and to the utility of patients
responding to ITP treatments. In the combined population the probabilistic sensitivity analysis showed that romiplostim is likely to be cost-effective in 66% and 84% of
samples versus eltrombopag and versus SoC at a willingness-to-pay threshold of
30.000€/QALY, respectively. Conclusions: Use of romiplostim in the ITP treatment
pathway, compared with eltrombopag or SoC, is likely to be cost-effective in Portugal.
PSY64
Belimumab for the Treatment of Systemic Lupus Erythematosus (Sle)
In Greece: A Cost-Effectiveness and Cost-Utility Analysis
Athanasakis K 1, Karampli E 1, Ollandezos M 1, Igoumenidis M 1, Karabela P 2, Psomali D 2,
Kyriopoulos J 1
1National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece, 2GlaxoSmithKline, Halandri, Greece
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Systemic Lupus Erythematosus (SLE) is a chronic autoimmune inflammatory disease, associated with significant health and socioeconomic burden.
Current treatment of SLE involves glucocorticoids, antimalarials, non-steroid antiinflammatory drugs, and immunosuppressive agents. Belimumab, a human IgG
monoclonal antibody specific for soluble human B lymphocyte stimulator protein,
is a novel pharmaceutical treatment approved as an add-on therapy in adult SLE
patients with highly active disease (autoantibody-positive and low complement
levels) despite treatment. The study objective was to estimate the incremental
cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) and incremental cost-utility ratio (ICUR) of adding
belimumab to the Standard-of-Care (SoC) treatment of SLE patients with high disease activity in the Greek health care setting. Methods: The analysis is based on
the local adaptation of a micro-simulation model. The model follows individual
patients over a lifelong period. Data on short-term outcomes were sourced from two
randomized controlled trials (BLISS 72/7614). Long-term outcomes were estimated
via natural history models developed on the basis of data from the John Hopkins
cohort of SLE patients. Direct costs consisted of short-term disease activity related
costs, organ damage costs, SoC treatment and belimumab administration costs.
Short-term costs and costs of treatment were calculated on the basis of resource
utilisation elicited from a panel of experts and using list prices (2013 prices). Organ
damage costs were identified through a literature review. Results were discounted at
3.5% for both costs and effects. The study was performed from the perspective of the
health care payer. Results: Treatment with belimumab+SoC resulted in 0.81 added
life years and 0.377 QALYs (Quality-Adjusted Life Years). This resulted in 18,350€ /
LYG (Life-Year-Gained) and 27,254€ /QALY. Conclusions: Cost-effectiveness and
cost-utility ratios of belimumab compared to SoC treatment are below internationally applied thresholds. Belimumab can be considered as an add-on therapy to SoC
for the treatment of SLE patients with highly active disease in Greece.
A533
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PSY65
Cost-Utility Analysis of Bosutinib for Previously Treated Chronic
Myeloid Leukemia (Cml) In Portugal
Paquete A T 1, Inês M 2, Duarte I 3, Almeida A 4, Esteves S 5, Miguel L S 1
- ISEG/UL, Lisboa, Portugal, 2Instituto de Medicina Molecular, Lisboa, Portugal, 3Pfizer
Oncology, Porto Salvo, PA, Portugal, 4Instituto Português de Oncologia de Lisboa, Lisboa, Portugal,
5IPOLFG, Lisboa, Portugal
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1CISEP
Objectives: To assess the incremental cost-utility ratio (ICUR) of bosutinib for CML
as a third-line (3L) treatment for chronic phase (CP) Philadelphia chromosomepositive (Ph+) patients in Portugal compared to hydroxycarbamide, in the societal
perspective. Methods: A survival analysis model was adapted to the Portuguese
setting. Bosutinib overall survival was based on Study 200, an open-label phase I/
II single-arm study of Ph+ CML patients. Overall survival with hydroxycarbamide
and time spent in the accelerated and blastic phases, that are assumed to be independent of treatment, were estimated by an expert panel of five Portuguese haematologists. Resource consumption was elicited by this expert panel, being unit
costs based on Portuguese official sources. Utility values were adapted from the IRIS
study. A 5% discount rate was applied to both costs and consequences on a 50-year
time horizon. Results: The use of bosutinib allows an increase of 4.1 life years
(LY) and 3.5 quality adjusted life years (QALY), being associated to an additional
cost of 88,319€ . Consequently, cost per LY is 21,465€ and cost per QALY is 25,252€ .
Sensitivity analysis shows that results are mainly driven by survival time gained
with bosutinib. Conclusions: Bosutinib for CML 3L treatment for CP patients
in Portugal represents a substantial added benefit relative to hydroxycarbamide
although with added costs per LY and per QALY. These ratios are generally accepted
in Portugal, both below 30,000€ willingness to pay threshold.
PSY66
Cost Effectiveness of Romiplostim for the Treatment of Immune
Thrombocytopenia (Itp) Patients In the Czech Republic
Brezina T 1, Klimes J 2, Dolezal T 2, Maskova H 1, Campioni M 3, Kutikova L 3
1Amgen s.r.o., Praha 1, Czech Republic, 2VALUE OUTCOMES, Prague, Czech Republic, 3Amgen
(Europe) GmbH, Zug, Switzerland
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess the cost-effectiveness of romiplostim in the treatment
of adult patients with ITP in the Czech Republic, in comparison with the medical standard of care (SoC) and eltrombopag. Methods: A lifetime treatment
sequence cost-utility Markov model was developed from the health care payer
perspective. The model was based on the treatment sequences that reflect current practice for ITP management and was driven by platelet response (platelet
count ≥ 50x109/L), which determined effectiveness and progression along the treatment pathway, need for rescue therapy and risk of bleeding. Costs were derived
from reimbursement lists available in January 2013. Four scenarios were conducted where romiplostim was compared with SoC with rituximab, SoC without
rituximab, SoC without both rituximab and mycophenolate mofetil (MMF), and
eltrombopag. Patients were evaluated by splenectomy status and for the combined
population (CP). Results: Compared to SoC with rituximab, romiplostim was
dominant in splenectomised patients and CP, with cost savings of 2,203,982CZK
and 1,078,899CZK and gains of 1.58 and 1.81 quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs),
respectively, and was cost-effective in non-splenectomised patients with an ICER
of 44,107 CZK/QALY. Compared to eltrombopag, romiplostim was dominant in
splenectomised patients and CP, with cost savings of 1,626,409CZK and 741,613CZK
and gains of 1.12 and 1.21 QALYs, respectively, and was cost-effective in nonsplenectomised patients with an ICER of 74,266 CZK/QALY. Similar results were
shown in the other two scenarios: romiplostim was dominant in splenectomised
patients and CP compared to SoC without rituximab and SoC without both rituximab and MMF, and was cost-effective in non-splenectomised patients with ICERs
of 51,011CZK/QALY (SoC without rituximab) and 41,192CZK/QALY (SoC without
rituximab and MMF). Conclusions: Romiplostim was less costly with higher
QALY gain compared to SoC and eltrombopag in splenectomised patients and CP.
Romiplostim was cost-effective with ICERs between 41,000 and 74,000CZK/QALY
in all non-splenectomised populations in all four scenarios.
PSY67
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Celecoxib In the Treatment of
Patients With Chronic Pain In Japan
Kawaguchi I 1, Kamae I 2, Soen S 3, Sakamoto C 4
Japan Inc, Tokyo, Japan, 2The University of Tokyo, Graduate School of Public Policy, Tokyo,
Japan, 3Nara Hospital, Kinki University School of Medicine, Nara, Japan, 4Nippon Medical School,
Graduate School of Medicine, Tokyo, Japan
.
.
.
.
1Pfizer
Objectives: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of celecoxib compared with loxoprofen for the treatment of patients with chronic pain caused by osteoarthritis,
rheumatoid arthritis and low back pain in Japan. Methods: Using the Markov
model, long-term simulations were conducted with a 3-month Markov cycle for
each regimen of celecoxib vs. loxoprofen in the perspective of Japanese health
care payers. The direct medical costs and quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) were
estimated as outcome measures throughout the lifetime of patients. The base
case population was aged 57 years which was the weighted mean age from the
cited literature. All the costs were expressed as of March 2014, and annual discount rates of 2% were applied for both costs and health benefits. Results: The
incremental effectiveness of celecoxib compared with loxoprofen was 0.024 QALY
while the incremental cost was JPY 73,785 (USD 716, USD 1 = JPY 103), indicating
the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) was JPY 3,131,480 (USD 30,403) per
QALY gained. Sensitivity analyses identified two factors substantially sensitive to
ICER: 1) decrease in efficacy of celecoxib in the recurrence of symptomatic ulcer,
and 2) increase in utility of the primary disease that causes chronic pain while the
administration of the drug halts. The literature review, however, supported that
both of those sensitive cases are not so much likely to happen. Conclusions:
Celecoxib was considered cost-effective compared with loxoprofen in patients
with chronic pain in Japan.
PSY68
Population-Based Cost-Efficiency Simulation of Partial Versus
Complete Thromboprophylaxis In Hospitalized Patients In Saudi
Arabia: Application of A British Model
Alomi Y 1, Alharbi E 2, Alshayban D 3, Khoshaim M 1, Alhowasi M 1, Zamakhshary M 1,
Alhumaidi A 1, Alesseimi M 1, Abraham I 3
1Ministry of Health, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, 2King Saud Medical City, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia,
3University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Venous thromboembolism (VTE) is a frequent but preventable complication in hospitalized patients. The objective of this population-based simulation
was to estimate, for Saudi Arabia and using a British (NICE) model, the cost-efficiency of partial versus complete thromboprophylaxis of hospitalized adult patients
at medium-to-very-high (M2VH) -VTE risk. Methods: Simulation including all 2012
Saudi adult medical (n= 2,129,866) and surgical (n= 964,033) hospital admissions,
expressed in Saudi riyals (SAR), using three scenarios based on published realworld thromboprophylaxis studies: (1) international study and (2) Saudi subsample
thereof (Cohen et al, Lancet 2008), and (3) Middle-Eastern study (Mokhtari et al, J
Thromb Haemost 2011). Variables included rates for: high bleeding risk (mechanical
versus pharmacoprophylaxis); major bleeding episode (MBE) secondary to pharmacoprophylaxis; deep vein thrombosis (DVT; pulmonary embolism (PE); and 12-month
DVT/PE readmission following such discharge diagnosis. Costs considered were:
thromboprophylaxis; management of MBE, DVT, PE; and 12-month DVT/PE readmission. Results: Scenario (1): total costs for partial and complete prophylaxis
were SAR631,462,830 and SAR508,957,517 for a complete-over-partial cost-avoidance
by 24.1% of SAR122,505,313/year (SAR92.14 per patient and SAR167.83 per patient
at VTE risk). Scenario (2): total costs for partial and complete prophylaxis were
SAR712,441,824 and SAR600,483,584 for a complete-over-partial cost-avoidance
by 18.6% of SAR111,958,239/year (SAR77.35 per patient and SAR127.58 per patient
at VTE risk). Scenario (3): total costs for partial and complete prophylaxis were
SAR749,939,936 and SAR647,300,590 for a complete-over-partial cost-avoidance by
15.9% of SAR102,639,346/year (SAR62.77 per patient and SAR97.84 per patient at VTE
risk). Conclusions: In this population-based cost-efficiency simulation for Saudi
Arabia, thromboprophylaxis of all admitted M2VH-VTE risk versus partial methods
is associated with significant cost savings per year. Considering the associated
reductions in DVT, PE, and readmissions, even under increased pharmacoprophylaxis-related MBE risk and costs, complete thromboprophylaxis of (M2VH) -VTE risk
patients achieves the Institute for Healthcare Improvement Triple Aim of better care,
better patient outcomes, and reduced costs.
PSY69
Cost Minimization Analysis of Activated Prothrombin Complex
Concentrate (Apcc) Compared To Recombinant Factor Viia (Rfviia) for
Hemophilia Patients With Inhibitors
Mlcoch T 1, Klimes J 2, Dolezal T 2
1VALUE OUTCOMES, s.r.o., Prague, Czech Republic, 2VALUE OUTCOMES, Prague, Czech Republic
.
.
.
Objectives: Approximately 15-35% of patients with hemophilia A develop inhibitory antibodies to factor VIII. There are currently two bypassing agents to treat
inhibitor patients in the case of bleeding episodes (BE) and preemptively before
and during major surgeries. Both APCC and rFVIIa demonstrated similar efficacy
and safety results. Our aim was to compare the costs of bypass strategy based on
APCC or rFVIIa while we included only drug acquisition costs, and from them we
derived costs of bleeding episodes and surgery costs in Hungary, Slovakia, Slovenia
and Serbia. Methods: For the purpose of cost comparison, we developed a model
using cost-minimization approach which included only the costs of APCC or rFVIIa.
We assessed the cost differences for two basic scenarios - patients with bleeding
episodes and patients undergoing major surgeries. The doses used in model were:
i) BE APCC 62.5 U/kg, ii) surgery APCC 85 U/kg, iii) BE and surgery rFVIIa 90 μ g/kg.
The doses are based on the SmPCs (middle of given dose intervals) and published
literature (in the case of APCC used in surgery which is administered in higher doses
in clinical practice compared to declaration in SmPC). Results: In the scenario
of bleeding episodes, the use of APCC instead of rFVIIa brings the potential savings € 4,596-8,704; € 5,135-9,347; € 5,738-10,807; € 4,369-8,527 respectively in Hungary,
Slovakia, Slovenia and Serbia (depending on the dosing scheme). While using APCC
during major surgeries, the savings are equal to € 157,159 (if compared to rFVIIa
therapy) and € 15,616 (if compared to the combination therapy of APCC and rFVIIa)
in Hungary; € 180,653 and € 16,558 in Slovakia; € 196,965 and € 19,362 in Slovenia;
and € 145,979 and € 15,422 in Serbia. Conclusions: The potential savings by using
APCC instead of rFVIIa are significant for health care systems, APCC thus indirectly
enables more treated patients for the same health care costs consumption.
PSY70
Cost-Minimization Analysis of Methadona Opioid Analgesic for
Mexican Patients With Acute and Chronic Secondary Cancer As
Rotation Option In Severe Pain
Soto Molina H 1, Sanchez K 1, Constanzo A 1, Escobar Juárez Y 1, Fernandez Z 2, Melendez C 2
Estudios Farmacoeconómicos, Mexico City, Mexico, 2Psicofarma S.A. de C.V., Mexico City,
Mexico
.
.
.
.
.
.
1HS
Objectives: Perform a full economic evaluation of cost minimization of the use
of Methadone versus oxycodone (extended release), buprenorphine (transdermal
patches), fentanyl (transdermal patches) and hydromorphone in opioid rotation
for patients with acute severe pain secondary to cancer and chronic type as rotation option in Mexico, from the point of view of public health. Methods: A systematic literature review was conducted to identify articles and extract data of
safety and efficacy and compare the available alternatives: methadone, oxycodone,
buprenorphine (PT), fentanyl (PT) and hydromorphone. Based on the results of this
systematic review was identified that 5 alternatives presented safety and efficacy
profiles without significant differences. Economic evaluation corresponded to a
cost minimization, the analysis was performed with three subgroups with rotation
of opioids, each subgroup received a certain amount of morphine (80mg, 160mg,
A534
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
480 mg respectively) before rotation the number of milligrams of each opioid was
calculated based on equianalgesic tables using only direct medical costs, further
a deterministic sensitivity analysis was performed. Results: The results demonstrate that methadone (Amidone ®) generates average savings per patient of
$ 84.37 to $ 5,817.00 compared to oxycodone, buprenorphine (PT), fentanyl (PT) and
hydromorphone in the three subgroups analyzed, the sensitivity analysis shows
that methadone remains a cost-saving option. Conclusions: Using Methadone
(Amidone ®) is a cost-saving option for patients with acute and chronic severe pain
secondary to cancer in Mexico, from the institutional point of view.
PSY71
Real-World Cost-Utility Evaluation of Multiple Myeloma
Treatments In Stem Cell Transplanted Patients
Gilabert Sotoca M , Schoenenberger Arnaiz J A , Pons Llobet N , Martinez Sogues M ,
Mangues Bafalluy I , Martinez Castro B
Hospital Universitari Arnau de Vilanova, Lleida, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Multiple myeloma (MM) is an incurable disease with an incidence
of 4-7 new cases by 100.000 people. In the setting of the study, 28% of the yearly
25 news cases of MM are candidates to autologous stem cell transplant (ASCT).
Because of the lack of real-world economic studies, authors sought to describe
the cost per quality-adjusted-life-year (QALY) of the MM treatment in a group of
transplanted patients. Methods: An observational retrospective study was performed and included detailed clinical data from a transplanted cohort of patients
with MM. All patients received bortezomib based treatments. Costs were evaluated
from the payer’s perspective and included total drug costs and hospital admission
costs. QALYs values were obtained from the CEA Registry of Tufts University. Four
health states were considered: complete response (CR), partial response, stability
and progressive disease. Time between state transitions was used to calculate QALYs
for each patient. Results: The study included 17 patients with a mean age of 61,2
years; 12 of them (Group 1) were followed during 2,77±0,24 years and 5 (Group 2) during 1,6±0,19 years. Global complete response rate one year after ASCT was 8/17 (47%)
and dropped to 5/12 (41,6%) at two years. For the whole cohort the median of QALY’s
cost was 56.198€ (IQ range 36.391-70.339). For patients with CR one year after ASCT,
the median of QALY’s cost was 46.358€ (IQ range 36.299-67.537). For all other patients
the median of QALY’s cost was 56.676€ (IQ range 39.114-73.613). For Group 1 patients,
the median of QALY’s cost was 51.278€ (IQ range 36.345-73.613). Conclusions:
These results reveal that the actual costs of MM treatment using protocols that
include bortezomib are above the 30.000-50.000€ threshold generally admitted in
cost-effectiveness studies.
PSY72
Orphan Drug Pricing In France: Influence of Main Factors
GRAND H 1, Samson A L 2, Aulois-Griot M 1
Bordeaux, Bordeaux, France, 2Université Paris Dauphine, Paris, France
.
.
.
.
1Université
Objectives: Orphan drugs (OD) require considerable expenditures, which causes
difficulties in their market access. For several years, the price of these new therapies
has often been criticized and considered as too high. However few studies about
OD pricing mechanisms are available. The aim of the paper is to highlight the main
factors that influence OD pricing in France. Methods: We collected public prices
of 37 products designated as OD and approved by the European Medicines Agency
until January 2014. Given that an OD can have several indications, our database
contains 49 observations. For each observation, we calculated the ex-factory price
without tax (defined per daily dose) defined by summary products characteristics.
We also collected different characteristics of these products: improvement in actual
clinical benefit (IACB), actual clinical benefit (ACB), number of OD indications,
number of comparators drugs, number of competing orphan drugs, therapeutic
use, target population, inclusion on the list of medicines reimbursed by National
Health Insurance. Ordinary least squares are used to analyse the determinants of
OD prices. Results: The distribution of OD prices is very heterogeneous, with a
minimum of 2.34 euros and a maximum of 2882.08 euros. The average (SD) price
is 380.675 euros (687.414). Our main results are that OD prices are significantly
lower for OD that do not improve actual clinical benefit (-136%, p= 0.024), for OD
with only one orphan indication (-80%, p= 0.047), and for OD with a high target
population (-251%, p= 0.000). Conclusions: There is a need to understand OD
pricing mechanisms. Our study shows that innovation and research efforts are
encouraged by pricing policy.
PSY73
Evaluation of Use of Belimumab In Clinical Practice Settings
(Observe Study) In Spain: Health Resource Utilization and Labour
Absenteeism
Cortés J 1, Andreu J L 2, Calvo J 3, García-Aparicio A M 4, Coronell C G 5, Díaz-Cerezo S 5
1Hospital Vall d´Hebrón, Barcelona, Spain, 2Hospital Puerta de Hierro, Majadahonda (Madrid),
Spain, 3Hospital de Sierrallana, Torrelavega, Spain, 4Hospital VIrgen de la Salud, Toledo, Spain,
5GSK España, Tres Cantos, Spain
.
.
patients presented an overall clinical improvement of ≥ 20%, ≥ 50% and ≥ 80%. These
improvements were associated with a reduction of steroid use (75% of patients
on steroids at belimumab-initiation decreased mean dose from 14.8 to 6.8mg/day;
p< 0.001) and HRU between the pre/post index periods: emergency-room visits 1.65
to 0.41; p= 0.001; unscheduled visits to treating-physician 1.02 to 0.03; p< 0.001,
visits to other specialists (1.64 to 1.06; p= 0.017) and antibody tests (7.78 to 7.53;
p= 0.47). An increase in HRU was observed for hematological and renal tests (3.14 to
3.52; p= 0.045) and (5.95 to 6.59; p= 0.024), respectively. Working patients (39%) also
showed a reduction in the LA days between the pre/post index periods (25.6 to 5.7
days; p= 0.025). Conclusions: Belimumab treatment yielded improved clinical
outcomes and a reduction in HRU directly related with SLE management, as corticoid use. Mean number of LA days also showed a substantial reduction, especially
important in SLE, mostly affecting young patients.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To analyze the health resource utilization (HRU) and labour absenteeism (LA) in Systemic Lupus Erythematosus (SLE) patients treated with belimumab
in the Spanish clinical setting. Methods: OBSERVE is a multicenter retrospective
medical chart-review study. Twenty-five rheumatologists from Spanish hospitals
with > 10 SLE patients annually and >5-years of practice experience identified adult
SLE patients who had received 6-months of belimumab treatment. In the 6-months
pre- and 6-months post-index periods physicians assessed: demographics, comorbidities, SLE disease characteristics, treatment clinical outcomes, HRU and LA data.
Index-date is the date of the first infusion. OBSERVE primary endpoint was overall
clinical response per physician judgment. Statistical analyses included appropriate tests for paired-samples (parametric/ non-parametric). Two-way P-values 0.05
were considered statistically significant. Results: A total of 64 patients were eligible for analysis: mean age 42.7±12 years; female 89%; hypocomplementemia 70%
and high anti-dsDNA 69%. After receiving 6-months therapy, 72%, 52% & 27% of
SYSTEMIC DISORDERS/CONDITIONS – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient
Preference Studies
PSY74
Impact of Patient Programs On Adherence In Inflammation and
Immunology: A Global Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of
Published Evidence
Burudpakdee C 1, Khan Z M 2, Gala S 1, Nanavaty M 1, Kaura S 2
1MKTXS, Raritan, NJ, USA, 2Celgene Corporation, Summit, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Patient adherence is important for successful treatment in chronic
conditions, including inflammation and immunology (I&I) diseases, to improve
patient outcomes. Programs and interventions that aim at improving medication adherence play an essential role in optimizing care. This review and metaanalysis assessed the effectiveness of different types of adherence programs in
I&I. Methods: A global systematic literature search was conducted and studies
were identified from PubMed, conference proceedings, and grey literature. Selection
criteria included studies of patient programs in I&I diseases published in English
language between January 2008 and September 2013 that reported % of adherent
patients. A meta-analysis was performed using a random effects model. Weights,
odds ratios, 95% CI, and forest plots were developed for behavioral, informational,
and combination interventions. Results: Of 29 studies screened, a total of 13 studies were eligible for inclusion in the meta-analysis. Seven studies were in patients
with osteoporosis, 4 in ulcerative colitis, 1 in childhood-onset systemic lupus erythematosus, and 1 in rheumatoid arthritis / psoriasis. Overall, patient programs
increased adherence (OR = 2.48, 95% CI = 1.68 - 3.64, P < 0.00001) as compared
to standard of care or no intervention. Combination interventions that used both
informational and behavioral strategies were superior in increasing adherence (OR
= 3.68, 95% CI = 2.20 - 6.16, P < 0.00001) compared to interventions using solely a
behavioral strategy (OR = 1.85, 95% CI = 1.00 - 3.45, P = 0.05) or only an informational
strategy (OR = 2.16, 95% CI = 1.36 - 3.44, P = 0.001). Conclusions: Patient programs
and interventions can significantly improve adherence in I&I diseases as compared
to standard of care or no intervention. Programs employing a multimodal approach
are more effective in improving adherence than either informational or behavioral
strategies alone. This in turn may improve patient outcomes.
PSY75
Adherence To Anticoagulant Therapy In Children Hospitalized for
Pulmonary Embolism and Deep Vein Thrombosis
Singh R R 1, Gupte K P 1, Wilson J P 1, Moffett B S 2
University of Texas at Austin, Austin, TX, USA, 2Baylor College of Medicine/Texas Children’s
Hospital, Houston, TX, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1The
Objectives: The American College of Chest Physicians Guideline recommends anticoagulant therapy for at least three months in children with venous thromboembolism. The objectives of the study were to evaluate the medication utilization patterns,
and the predictors of adherence to anticoagulant therapy in the pediatric population. Methods: Texas Medicaid medical and prescription claims from June 01,
2007 to September 31, 2012 were extracted for children (< 18 years) hospitalized
for Pulmonary Embolism (PE) or Deep Vein Thrombosis (DVT). The index date was
defined as the date of the first prescription of an anticoagulant warfarin (oral)
and/or enoxaparin (injectable) given within 14 days after discharge from hospitalization. Patients hospitalized for atrial fibrillation, air/fat embolism, bleeding/
coagulation disorder within 90 days of discharge were excluded. Proportion of
days covered (PDC≥ 80% vs. < 80%) was used to assess adherence to anticoagulants
while controlling for demographics, cause of hospitalization, history of NSAID use,
anticoagulant use, malignancy, drug type, and Charlson comorbidity index (CCI). A
multivariate logistic regression analysis was used. Results: The patients (n= 57)
had a mean (±SD) age of 14.1 (±4.9) years, were primarily female (54.4%), African
American (61.4%), enoxaparin users (54.4%), and had a mean (±SD) CCI of 19.7 (±39.4).
The mean (±SD) adherence rates for warfarin and enoxaparin were 85.6% (±22.3%)
and 78.2% (±22.7%), respectively. 66.7% were adherent (PDC≥ 80%) to anticoagulant
therapy. The median (Mean±SD) persistence with anticoagulant therapy was 84.6
(71.9±33.3) days. Logistic regression showed that increasing age was significantly
associated with adherence to anticoagulant therapy (Odds Ratio= 1.3, p= 0.0158),
after controlling for covariates. Conclusions: Nearly one third of the pediatric
patients on anticoagulant therapy after discharge from hospitalization with PE or
DVT were non-adherent. Further research is needed to underline the factors responsible for non-adherence in pediatric patients.
PSY76
New Observer-Reported Outcomes To Measure Treatment
Satisfaction, Compliance, Palatability, and Gi Symptoms for
Patients Needing Iron-Chelation Therapy
Lasch K 1, Horodniceanu E G 2, Carter J A 2, Dhatt H 2, Bal V 3, Côté I 3, Constantinovici N 4,
Herranz R M 4, Malet I 4
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A535
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
1Pharmerit
International, Cambridge, MA, USA, 2Pharmerit International, Bethesda, MD, USA,
Pharmaceuticals Corporation, East Hanover, NJ, USA, 4Novartis Pharma AG, Basel,
Switzerland
outcomes and greater indirect costs. The distribution of BMI is similar to the 5 E.U.
Finding suggest the need for additional weight-loss options.
Objectives: Adherence to iron chelation therapy (ICT) is essential for patients with
transfusion-dependent anemia (TDA) (e. g., sickle cell disease [SCD] and thalassemia) to increase survival and minimize disease-related sequellae. Adherence has
been noted as especially problematic for children and adolescents. In order to measure compliance and treatment satisfaction in young children, the Satisfaction with
Iron Chelation Therapy (SICT) instrument (initially developed for use by adults and
adolescents) was modified to be an observer-reported outcome (ObsRO) measure to
be administered electronically to caregivers. In addition, three other ObsROs were
developed measuring compliance, palatability, and gastrointestinal (GI) symptoms
related to treatment benefit of a new ICT formulation. Methods: Subjects included
10 caregivers of children with TDA. Informed consent was obtained. Two sets of
face-to-face cognitive interviews were conducted iteratively with modification to
items and further debriefing of modifications. Interviews began with an open-ended
question to elicit caregivers’ and their reports of their child’s experiences with
ICT. Interviews were audio recorded and transcribed. Data were analyzed using
ATLAS. ti software. Results: Three interviewers conducted 10 caregiver interviews in 6 US cities. Caregivers were 90% female aged 35-65 (mean= 48). Children
of caregivers included those with SCD (80%) and thalassemia (20%) and were 60%
female, aged 2-17 (mean= 9). Responses to the open-ended question confirmed
several concepts in the modified SICT and the need for new items. The resultant questionnaires included the modified SICT (17 items), Compliance (2 items),
Palatability (4 items), and GI Symptom Diary (6 items). Changes were made to each
to ensure comprehension, relevance, lack of redundancy, and appropriate response
options. Conclusions: Evidence supports the content validity of the modified
SICT, Compliance, Palatability, and GI Symptom Diary questionnaires. Use in clinical
research awaits tests of validity, reliability, and responsiveness.
PSY79
The Multicentric Castleman’s Disease (Mcd) -Symptom Scale
(Mcd-Ss): Development and Validation of A Patient-Reported
Outcome (Pro) Measure for An Ultra-Orphan Disease
3Novartis
PSY77
Impact of Pulmonary Exacerbations On Eq-5d Measures In Patients
With Cystic Fibrosis
Solem C T 1, Vera-Llonch M 2, Liu S 1, Botteman M 1, Lin F J 1, Castiglione B 2
International, Bethesda, MD, USA, 2Vertex Pharmaceuticals, Boston, MA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Pharmerit
Objectives: Pulmonary exacerbations (PEs) in patients with cystic fibrosis (CF)
have been reported to impact health-related quality of life. This analysis examined the impact of PEs on EQ-5D measures in patients with CF using trial-based
data. Methods: In a 48-week randomized, placebo-controlled study of ivacaftor
in patients ≥ 12 years with CF and a G551D-CFTRmutation, the EQ-5D questionnaire,
including visual analog scale (EQ VAS), was administered at baseline, 15 days, 8
weeks, and every 8 weeks thereafter. UK preference weights were employed to
derive the EQ-5D index. PE was defined as a change in antibiotic therapy for ≥ 4 of
12 signs or predefined symptoms. EQ-5D measures collected in the 8-week pre- and
post- exacerbation periods were examined after pooling observations across study
treatments and visits. Results: A total of 146 PEs were experienced by 72 (44.7% of
total 161) patients, including 52 (35.6%) PEs that required hospitalization. Mean (±SD)
duration was 30.0±22.2 days for PEs requiring hospitalization (n= 48) and 20.6±11.6
days for those not requiring hospitalization (n= 89) (9 PEs had missing end dates).
For PEs requiring hospitalization, mean (±SD) EQ-5D index/VAS scores within 1-8
weeks before PE start were 0.91 (±0.13)/75.5 (±14.2), respectively. The lowest average EQ-5D index/VAS scores were reached within 1 week of PE start; mean scores
within 1 week were 0.76±0.33 (p= 0.044 vs. 1-8 weeks prior to PE) /63.7±24.1 (p= 0.039).
Corresponding values for PEs not requiring hospitalization were 0.89±0.16/73.4±16.1
within 1-8 weeks before PE start, and 0.90±0.13 (p= 0.777) /68.4±17.4 (p= 0.124) within
1 week of PE start. Conclusions: In a clinical study of patients with CF (≥ 12 years
of age and a G551D-CFTR mutation), the PEs were associated with lower EQ-5D and
VAS scores, primarily among those requiring hospitalization. Reducing PEs requiring hospitalization is likely to improve health-related quality of life among these
patients.
PSY78
Is Obesity A Problem In Brazil?
Richard L 1, Gupta S 2, Pomerantz D 2, Forsythe A 3
1Eisai Europe Ltd, Hatfield, UK, 2Kantar Health, Princeton, NJ, USA, 3Eisai Inc., Woodcliff Lake,
NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
Objectives: This study investigated the effect of BMI on quality of life, productivity, activity impairment, health care resource-utilisation, and associated
costs. Methods: Results were from the 2011-2012 Brazil National Health and
Wellness Survey (N= 24,000), a nationally representative, online survey of respondents aged≥ 18 years. Analysis focused on normal weight (BMI≥ 18.5 & < 25 kg/m2),
overweight (BMI≥ 25 & < 30 kg/m2), obese class (OC) I (BMI≥ 30 & < 35 kg/m2), OC II
(BMI≥ 35 & < 40 kg/m2), and OC III (BMI≥ 40 kg/m2) respondents. Outcomes included
quality of life (SF-36v2), health utilities (SF-6D), productivity loss (Work Productivity
and Activity Impairment questionnaire) and resource utilisation (type/number of
visits) in the past six months. Direct and indirect costs were estimated from public
sources. Generalised linear models predicted outcomes as a function of BMI category, adjusting for covariates (e. g., age, gender, comorbidities). Results: Among
22,871 respondents, 46.4% were normal weight, 34.9% were overweight, 12.9% were
OC I, 3.7% were OC II, and 2.0% were OC III. Adjusting for covariates, mental, physical component summary (normal weight: 51.8; overweight: 51.4; OC I: 50.3; OC II:
48.5; OC III: 46.0), and health utilities (normal weight: 0.73; overweight: 0.72; OC I:
0.71; OC II: 0.70; OC III: 0.67) decreased as BMI increased (OCs vs. normal, p< 0.05).
Amongst the employed (66.1%), impairment while working (normal weight: 15.5%;
overweight: 15.6%; OC I: 16.9%; OC II: 18.2%; OC III: 22.4%, OCs vs. normal, p< 0.05)
increased as BMI increased. Normal weight (vs. OCs, p≤ 0.05) had lower activity
impairment, fewer provider visits, and lower indirect costs (normal weight: R$333;
overweight: R$338; OC I: R$385; OC II: R$395; OC III: R$458). Conclusions: Over
50% of Brazilians are overweight or obese. Increase in BMI is associated with poorer
Casper C 1, Van Agthoven M 2, Rothman M 3, Fleming S 4, Ho K F 4, Qi M 4, Vermeulen J 5,
Cavet J 6
1Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center, Seattle, WA, USA, 2Janssen-Cilag BV, Tilburg, The The
Netherlands, 3Janssen Global Services, LLC, Spring House, PA, USA, 4Janssen R&D, US, Spring
House, PA, USA, 5Janssen, Leiden, The Netherlands, 6Christie Hospital, Manchester, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: MCD, an ultra-orphan lymphoproliferative disorder with heterogeneous symptomology, including fatigue, malaise, sweats, and nodal/extranodal
masses, is driven by dysregulated interleukin-6 signaling. Siltuximab, an antiinterleukin-6 antibody, is approved in the US and EU for treatment of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) - and human herpes virus-8 (HHV-8) -negative adult MCD
patients. This study aimed to fill an unmet need for a validated PRO tool to quantify
MCD symptoms and responses to therapy. Methods: Using FDA guidance, an MCD
symptom scale (MCD-SS) was developed by collecting and evaluating symptoms
in 12 patients from 2 US centers, with further validation using additional patients
from 1 US center. Item performance, scale structure and scoring, reliability, validity,
responsiveness, and clinically meaningful change were evaluated in a randomized,
placebo-controlled, double-blind study of siltuximab (N=79) in HIV-, HHV-8-negative
MCD patients (Wong Blood 2013:122 (21)). Results: Patient-reported MCD symptoms were: cough, dizziness, drowsiness, dry mouth, fever, headaches, hot flashes,
itching, skin lesions, loss of appetite, nausea, numbness/tingling, pain, rash, shortness of breath, sweating, swollen lymph nodes, swelling/edema, tiredness/fatigue,
vomiting, weakness, weight gain, and weight loss. Following exploratory factor
analysis, 3 domains were created: fatigue, rash/itching, and sweats (total score also
calculated). The final MCD-SS comprised 16 questions with 6 response options: “did
not experience,” “very mild,” “mild,” “moderate,” “severe,” and “very severe” (score,
0-5). Subjects reported a mean (SD) and median (range) of 9.2 (3.76) and 9.5 (1-16)
symptoms, respectively. Test-retest reliability was acceptable (r> 0.70) for fatigue,
sweats, and the total score but lower for rash/itching (r= 0.65). Internal consistency
exceeded 0.70 for all. Lower ECOG scores were associated with lower MCD-SS scores.
MCD-SS total scores were moderately correlated (r= 0.48) with baseline clinicianreported signs and symptoms. Conclusions: This is the first known attempt to
develop a PRO instrument for MCD. These data support further use of the MCD-SS
in the target population.
PSY80
“I Don’t Know How It Happened Or When Everything Changed.
It’s Like I Blinked and All of A Sudden, I Didn’t Recognise My Own
Body”: Using Qualitative Insights To Develop A Conceptual Model
To Understand the Lived Experience of Patients With Systemic
Sclerosis
Willgoss T G 1, Humphrey L 1, Blankenburg M 2
1Abacus International, Manchester, UK, 2Bayer HealthCare Pharmaceuticals, Berlin, Germany
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Systemic sclerosis (SSc) is a rare, multisystem chronic disease characterised by fibrotic changes affecting all or some bodily organs. SSc is associated
with high morbidity and a significant effect on patients’ health-related quality
of life. Qualitative insights can provide rich context to the patients’ experience
of a disease. Conceptual models based on qualitative data are a valuable way to
“explain, with graphically or narrative form, the main things to be studied - the key
factors, concepts and variables – and the presumed relationships between them”.
Despite the existence of SSc-specific measures, no conceptual model of SSc exists.
This research aimed to develop a qualitatively-derived, patient-centred, conceptual
model of SSc. Methods: To identify patient-reported SSc symptoms and impacts,
we reviewed qualitative literature (published since 2000 to limit the search) in
which experiences of living/coping with SSc are described. We also reviewed social
media blogs/forums to identify additional concepts and provide supporting quotes.
Concepts were identified by independent researchers who collaboratively developed
the model. Results: Twelve qualitative studies and 150 social media posts were
reviewed. The review identified 56 symptom concepts, which were categorised into
13 domains (peripheral, cognitive, pain, neurological, cardiorespiratory, ophthalmological, gastrointestinal, fatigue, nasopharyngeal, weight, oesophageal, dizziness,
nausea) and 48 impact concepts, which were categorised into 8 domains (daily living,
diet, social, clothing, work, physical and psychological functioning). Of note, nausea
and dizziness were identified only through the social media review. Conclusions:
A conceptual model for SSc was developed based on qualitative insights. The model
depicts the diverse range of symptoms and impacts experienced by patients. By
incorporating a social media review, relevant symptoms, which would not have
otherwise been identified, were found and included in the model. This research is
an important first step in identifying the most relevant and conceptually comprehensive clinical outcomes assessments for clinical research/practice.
PSY81
Prevalence of Neuropathic Pain and Its Disease Burden In Korea
Patients With Lumbar Spine Surgery
Cho Y E 1, Moon S H 2, Whang C J 3, Kim H J 4
1Gangnam Severance Spine Hospital, Yonsei University College of Medicine, Seoul, South
Korea, 2Department of Orthopedics, College of Medicine, Yonsei University, Seoul, South Korea,
3Asan Medical Center, College of Medicine, University of Ulsan, Seoul, South Korea, 4Pfizer
Pharmaceuticals Korea Limited, Seoul, South Korea
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The objectives of this study were to investigate the prevalence of
Neuropathic Pain (NP) and newly occurred (de novo) NP postoperatively. This study
also aimed to identify the disease burden (pain severity and quality of life (QoL))
of NP. Methods: This study was a nationwide, multi-centered, prospective, and
A536
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
observational study. It was conducted from September 2011 to December 2012 and
included a total of 1,109 patients who were scheduled for lumbar spinal surgery
from 44 spinal centers (both orthopaedic surgery and neurosurgeons). Patients were
diagnosed of having NP if the Leeds Assessment of Neuropathic Symptoms and
Signs (LANSS) pain scale criteria were ≥ 12 points. The patients were investigated
to assess their pain severity using pain numeric rating scale (NRS) and quality
of life using EuroQol (EQ)-5D at baseline, after 1 week and 3 months of the surgery. Results: Among 1,109 patents, at baseline, NP was identified in 404 (36%)
patients. After 1 week and 3 months of the surgery, NP was found in 8.6% and
4.0% patients respectively. Among the 705 patients without NP preoperatively, the
prevalence of de novo NP occurred in the 1 week and 3 months of post-surgery was
3.1% and 2.3% respectively. At baseline, NP patients showed lower QoL compared
with non-NP patients (0.49 vs 0.53 p< .001). However, NP patients improved more
their QoL compared to non-NP patients after 3 months (0.86 vs 0.84 p=.029). Among
the de novo NP patients at 3 months after surgery (n= 16), the pain severity was not
improved after 1 week and 3 months of the surgery. Conclusions: In Korea, NP
patients were suffered from severe pain and lower QoL than non-NP patients. De
novo NP caused severe pain which may not easily be handled. Those study findings
highlight that timely diagnosis and management of NP are required in patients
with lumbar spine surgery.
PSY82
The Pain Assessment for Lower Back Symptoms (Pal-S): Refinement of
A New Pro Instrument Through A Mixed Methods Approach
McCarrier K P 1, Bushnell D M 1, Ramasamy A 2, Liedgens H 3, Blum S I 4, Cano S 5, Martin M L 1,
Patrick D L 6
1Health Research Associates, Inc., Seattle, WA, USA, 2Forest Research Institute, Jersey City,
NJ, USA, 3Grünenthal GmbH, Aachen, Germany, 4GlaxoSmithKline, Collegeville, PA, USA,
5ScaleReport, Stotfold, UK, 6University of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The Pain Assessment for Lower Back Symptoms (PAL-S) is a Patient
Reported Outcome (PRO) instrument being developed to assess the key symptoms
of chronic low back pain (cLBP). Qualitative development included both concept
elicitation and cognitive interviews. As part of the ongoing development of the
instrument, we further evaluated and refined the PAL-S using a mixed methods
approach. Methods: Adults self-reporting a clinical diagnosis of cLBP were
recruited from an existing US-based commercial survey panel to participate in
a pilot quantitative study. Qualifying participants completed a web-based survey
consisting of the 14-item PAL-S and items assessing clinical, treatment, and demographic characteristics. Study data was analyzed to assess item- and scale-level
performance of the PAL-S using Rasch Measurement Theory analyses. Following
analysis and modification, two waves of cognitive interviews were conducted to
evaluate respondent understanding of the revised PAL-S. Results: The dataset
included 598 respondents (mean age: 55.5±12.6; 67.9% female; 88.0% white; and
54.0% married) who had cLBP for mean of 15.2±11.5 years. The Rasch analyses item
threshold maps showed only two items having ordered thresholds, suggesting that
respondents experienced increased difficulty distinguishing between options at
the lower levels of the 0-10 scale. Simulations collapsing the responses to a bestfit 4-point response scale resulted in improved ordering of thresholds, suggesting
a more optimal response option structure. Based on these findings, the numeric
response scale of the PAL-S items was replaced with a 4-point verbal rating scale
incorporating response choices such as not at all, slight, moderate, and severe. Findings
from eight cognitive interviews confirmed patient comprehension and relevance
of the revised instrument. Conclusions: The mixed-methods approach proved
valuable to the ongoing development of the PAL-S, as Rasch analyses identified
a need for refinement of the response scale. The measurement properties of the
revised PAL-S will be evaluated in additional web-based and clinic-based quantitative studies.
PSY83
Impacts of Lower Back Pain: Refinement of the Pain Assessment for
Lower Back-Impacts Questionnaire (Pal-I) Using a Mixed Methods
Approach
Bushnell D M 1, McCarrier K P 1, Ramasamy A 2, Liedgens H 3, Blum S I 4, Cano S 5, Martin M L 1,
Patrick D L 6
1Health Research Associates, Inc., Seattle, WA, USA, 2Forest Research Institute, Jersey City,
NJ, USA, 3Grünenthal GmbH, Aachen, Germany, 4GlaxoSmithKline, Collegeville, PA, USA,
5ScaleReport, Stotfold, UK, 6University of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The Pain Assessment for Lower Back-Impacts (PAL-I) is a patientreported outcome (PRO) instrument being developed to assess key impacts, e.
g. walking, sitting, standing, etc. associated with chronic low back pain (cLBP).
Following a mixed methods approach, the PAL-I development included qualitative
work (both concept elicitation and cognitive interviews) and now a quantitative
“pilot study” evaluation for further content validity. Methods: Adults self-reporting a clinical diagnosis of cLBP were recruited from a US-based commercial survey
panel. Qualifying participants completed a web-based survey consisting of the
13-item PAL-I and items assessing clinical, treatment, and demographic characteristics. Study data was analyzed to assess item- and scale-level performance of the
PAL-I using Rasch Measurement Theory analyses. Following analysis and modification, cognitive interviews were conducted to evaluate patient understanding of the
revised PAL-I. Results: The 598 subjects in the pilot study reported having cLBP
(mean of 6.1 on 11-point numerical rating scale, 0= no pain). Subjects experienced
cLBP for 0.3 to 66 years (mean 15.2, SD 11.5), were 55.5 years old (SD 12.6), 67.9%
female, 88.0% white and 54.0% married. The Rasch item threshold map showed
only 2 items having an ordered threshold identifying problems with the response
categories. Category probability curves indicated subjects had “difficulty” endorsing
items specifically in relation to the extreme options. Based on these findings, four
items were removed and the response options were modified for the remaining
items (from 6-point scale 4-point: Not at all limited, Limited a little, Limited a lot, Did
not do). Comprehension of the revised instrument was evaluated and confirmed
during eight individual cognitive interviews. Conclusions: The mixed-methods
approach provides valuable support in the development of a fit-for-purpose instrument assessing impacts of cLBP. Upon testing this revised PAL-I in a second pilot
quantitative study, the final measure will undergo formal validation including sensitivity to change.
PSY84
Pro Claims In Orphan Medicines Approved By the European Medicines
Agency (Ema) for the Treatment of Lymphoproliferative Disorders
Acquadro C 1, Perret C 2, Arnould B 3
Research Trust, Lyon, France, 2MAPI Research Trust, Lyon, France, 3Mapi, Lyon, France
.
.
.
1Mapi
Objectives: 1) To identify orphan medicines indicated for lymphoproliferative disorders approved by the European Medicines Agency (EMA); (2) To identify medicines
for which a PRO evaluation was performed; (3) To list those with a PRO labeling claim,
and (4) To identify reasons for not granting a PRO claim. Methods: The search
was performed on the EMA website (06/21/2014). The products were browsed by
type (i. e., orphan medicines). Products refused and withdrawn were excluded. The
PROLabels database was searched for each product retrieved to identify any PRO
claim in the label. Summary of Product characteristics (SMPc) and CHMP Assessment
Reports (AR) were retrieved for each product and analyzed to find out about PRO
evaluation reported in the AR and not reported in the label. Results: Thirteen
orphan medicines indicated in lymphoproliferative disorders were identified, representing three main indications: lymphomas (Hodgkin, systemic anaplastic large
cell, T-cell lymphoblastic, mantle-cell), leukemias (chronic lymphocytic, hairy cell,
acute lymphoblastic) and multiple myeloma. Only one product had a PRO claim:
ofatumumab (resolution of constitutional symptoms). The label of another product
(brentuximab vedotin) indicated “resolution of B symptoms.” However, there was
no mention in the AR on how the symptoms were collected (patient or clinician).
For one product (pomalidomide), a HRQL evaluation was mentioned in the AR, but
not reported in the label. However, there was no information about this evaluation
in the AR and the reader is left to wonder about the HRQL results and the reasons
for not including them in the label. Conclusions: The percentage of PRO claims
in orphan medicines (7.7%) is inferior to the percentage of PRO claims in all EMA
products (26%). This is remarkably low considering the profound effect of lymphoproliferative disorders on patients’ life. Efforts should be made to improve the
reporting of PRO data in the CHMP Assessment Reports.
PSY85
Psychometric Validation of the Newly Developed Phenylketonuria–
Quality of Life (Pku-Qol) Questionnaires Assessing the Impact of
Phenylketonuria and Its Treatment On Patients’ Quality of Life
Bosch A M 1, Burlina A 2, Cunningham A 3, Bettiol E O 4, Moreau-Stucker F 5, Benmedjahed
K 6, Regnault A 6
1University Hospital of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 2University Hospital of Padova,
Padova, Italy, 3Tulane University School of Medicine, New Orleans, LA, USA, 4University of Geneva
Hospitals and Faculty of Medicine, Geneva, Switzerland, 5EMD Serono Inc, Billerica, MA, USA,
6Mapi, Lyon, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Phenylketonuria (PKU) is a rare genetic disorder impacting phenylalanine (Phe) metabolism. Treatment involves a lifelong Phe restricted diet that
is strict and socially demanding. Even when treated early and well, mild cognitive abnormalities have been seen. PKU can affect quality of life in individuals
and their families. The phenylketonuria–quality of life (PKU-QOL) questionnaires
are the first PKU-specific QOL questionnaires ever developed. The study aimed to
perform the psychometric validation of these questionnaires. Methods: An observational study was conducted in France, Germany, Italy, The Netherlands, Spain,
Turkey and the UK to finalize and validate PKU-QoL questionnaires in individuals
with treated PKU aged 9–11, 12–17 and ≥ 18 years, and in parents of individuals < 18
years. Questionnaires were assessed for reliability (internal consistency, test–retest),
concurrent validity (using three generic questionnaires adapted to the respondent:
PedsQOL, SF-36 for adults and CHQ-PF28) and clinical validity (using PKU severity
and overall assessment of patient health status). Results: In total, 559 participants
(306 individuals, ages 9–45 years; 253 parents, ages 24–66 years) were included in the
analysis. Return rate and quality of completion of the questionnaires were good,
indicating good acceptability. Scores were defined to assess all relevant aspects of
experiences: PKU symptoms, impact of PKU, dietary protein restriction and supplementation. Reliability and validity were satisfactory overall for the adolescent,
adult and parent PKU-QoL questionnaires, and slightly weaker but acceptable for
the child version. Conclusions: The four PKU-QOL questionnaires are valid and
reliable instruments for assessing the specific quality of life aspects that are affected
in individuals with PKU of different age groups (children, adolescents and adults)
and their parents, and are available in seven languages. They are very promising
tools for focused evaluation of PKU impact on individuals and parents in different
countries, and for monitoring the efficacy of therapeutic strategies.
PSY86
Evaluating Relationship Between White Blood Cells and Platelets
During Recovery Phase In Dengue Hemorrhagic Fever Cases In Punjab,
Pakistan: A Retrospective Study
Rasool F 1, Ahmad M 2, Masood I 2, Khan H M S 3
of Punjab, Lahore, Pakistan, 2The Islamia University of Bahawalpur, Bahawalpur,
Pakistan, 3Islamia University Bahawalpur, The Islamia University of Bahawalpur, Pakistan
.
.
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: Dengue infection is a major cause of disease in tropical areas with
an estimated 50 million infections occurring each year and more than 2.5 billion
people being at risk of infections. The main objective of this study was to investigate
relation between white blood cells and platelets during recovery phase in dengue
hemorrhagic fever. Methods: A retrospective multi-center study was conducted
on 1000 seropositive cases of dengue fever. Results: More prevalence has been
observed in male 880 (88%) as compared to female 120 (12%). A rapid fall in white
blood cells count (WBC) was observed in initial CBC reports at start of disease then
A537
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
in platelet count. During recovery phase WBC count increased first followed by platelets count production after 3-4 days. Among 1000 confirmed dengue fever patients
812 were considered dengue hemorrhagic fever cases on the basis of clinical finding.
In most of these cases (n= 783; 96.47%), directly proportional relation was observed
between WBC and platelets count. Conclusions: It is wrongly perceived in community that dengue virus infection is still progressing when platelets count is below
normal even the white blood cells counts is getting better during recovery phase.
White blood cells production during recovery phase is a good indicator about recovery of disease rather than focused on platelets counts production.
PSY87
Physicians’ and Patients’ Preferences Over the Attributes of
Biological Agents Used In the Treatment of Rheumatic Diseases In
Spain: A Conjoint Analysis
Martin E 1, Rodriguez M 2, Ibero I 3, Raya E 4, Nolla J M 5, Nocea G 6, Aragon B 6, Lizán L 7, Paz S 7
La Paz, Madrid, Spain, 2Complejo Hospitalario de Ourense, Ourense, Spain, 3Hospital
General de Alicante, Alicante, Spain, 4Hospital Universitario San Cecilio, Granada, Spain, 5Hospital
Universitario de Bellvitge, Barcelona, Spain, 6MSD, Madrid, Spain, 7Outcomes’10, Castellon, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Hospital
Objectives: To define the importance values assigned to the attributes of biological agents (BA) by Spanish rheumatologists and patients with rheumatic diseases: rheumatoid arthritis (RA), ankylosing spondylitis (AS) and psoriatic arthritis
(PA). Methods: Observational, cross-sectional design based on conjoint analysis. RA, AS and PA patients diagnosed at least 2 years prior and currently or previously (≤ 1 year ago) receiving BA for a minimum of 1 year were consecutively
recruited. Rheumatologists with at least 3 year experience on BAs participated. A
literature review and 4 focus groups were undertaken to identify attributes and
levels. Scenarios were selected using orthogonal design. Participants ranked 8
scenarios from 1 (most preferred) to 8 (least preferred). Relative importance (RI)
of attributes was calculated. Multivariate regression analysis was performed for
each attribute. Results: 488 patients [male= 50.9%; mean (SD) age= 50.6 (12.06)
years; RA= 33.8%, AS= 32.4%, PA= 33.8%; mean time from diagnosis= 12.6 (8.2) years]
and 136 rheumatologists [male= 50.4%; mean age= 46.4 (9.1) years; mean time of
practice= 16.7 (8.8) years] took part. Most important attributes selected by patients
and physicians, respectively, were: ‘Pain relief and improvement of the functional
capacity’ (RI= 49.1% and 48.9%); ‘Risk of adverse events’ (RI= 31.8% and 31.5%),
‘Administration method’ (RI= 10.2% and 11.4%) and ‘Time to perceive the need for
a new dose’ (RI= 9.0% and 8.2%). The ideal BA, for patients and physicians, should
allow pain relief and an improvement of the functional capacity, with a low risk
of adverse events, a long time prior to perceiving the need for a new dose and
self-administration at home, when possible. Conclusions: Although efficacy and
safety are key for patients with rheumatic diseases and rheumatologists to make a
choice over a BA, the need for a low frequency of administration and the administration method also play an important role as preference attributes for BAs in Spain.
PSY88
Preferences of Spanish Patients Over the Attributes of Biological
Agents for the Treatment of Rheumatic Diseases Depending On the
Administration Route
Rodriguez M 1, Ibero I 2, Martin E 3, Nolla J M 4, Raya E 5, Aragon B 6, Nocea G 6, Lizán L 7,
Aceituno S 7
1Complejo Hospitalario de Ourense, Ourense, Spain, 2Hospital General de Alicante, Alicante, Spain,
3Hospital La Paz, Madrid, Spain, 4Hospital Universitario de Bellvitge, Barcelona, Spain, 5Hospital
Universitario San Cecilio, Granada, Spain, 6MSD, Madrid, Spain, 7Outcomes’10, Castellon, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Biological agents (BA) to treat rheumatic diseases are commonly
administered by either the subcutaneous or the intravenous route. The objective
of this study was to assess rheumatoid arthritis (RA), ankylosing spondylitis (AS)
and psoriatic arthritis (PA) Spanish patients’ preferences over BA considering the
administration route. Methods: Observational, cross-sectional design. Participants
were RA, AS and PA patients (diagnosed ≥ 2 years prior to study entry; currently
or previously (≤ 1 year ago) receiving BA for a minimum of 1 year. Conjoint analysis was performed to define preferences over 8 scenarios combining 4 attributes
[‘Administration method’ (ADMINISTRATION), ‘Pain relief and improvement of the
functional capacity’ (RELIEF), ‘Risk of adverse events’ (AE) and ‘Time until perceiving the need for a new dose’ related to the frequency of administration (TIME)].
Relative importance (RI) was calculated for patients on subcutaneous or intravenous
administration, respectively. Results: A total of 488 patients [male= 50.9%; mean
(SD) age= 50.6 (12.06) years; RA= 33.8%, AS= 32.4%, PA= 33.8%; mean time from diagnosis= 12.6 (8.2) years; receiving currently BA= 98.2%] were included. The patients
currently receiving subcutaneous (n= 305) or intravenous (n= 174) administration
with BA gave highest importance to ‘RELIEF’ (45.4% and 46.7%) and ‘AE’ (28.2% and
31.8%), followed by ‘ADMINISTRATION’ (19.7% and 10.2%) and ‘TIME’ (6.7% and 11.3%,
respectively). Both groups of patients preferred to stay on the same route of administration, either subcutaneous or intravenous, they had been on. Moreover all patients
considered most crucial a longer time until perceiving the need for a new dose (8
over 4 over 2 over 1 week). Conclusions: Spanish patients with rheumatic diseases placed high importance on pain relief and risk of AEs as preference attributes
for BAs. The frequency of administration (time until perceiving the need for a new
dose) also plays a crucial role as all patients indicated their preference for lower vs.
higher frequencies of BA administration.
PSY89
Preference for Rituximab Subcutaneous (Sc) and Intravenous
(Iv) Among Patients With Cd20+ Non-Hodgkin’s Lymphoma (Nhl)
Completing the Rasq Measure In Randomized Phase Iii Studies
Prefmab and Mabcute
Rule S 1, Briones J 2, Smith R 3, Theodore Oklota C 4, Ngoh C A 3, Osborne S 3, Capochiani E 5,
Rummel M 6
1Derriford Hospital, Plymouth, UK, 2Santa Creu i Sant Pau Hospital, Barcelona, Spain,
3F. Hoffmann-La Roche Ltd, Basel, Switzerland, 4Genentech, South San Francisco, CA, USA,
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
5Centro Aziendale di Ematologia, Livorno, Italy, 6University Hospital Giessen and Marburg,
Giessen, Germany
Objectives: Rituximab SC reduces administration times (~5 minutes) compared with the IV route (~4 hours). We examined the extent of patient preference for rituximab SC versus IV in the PrefMab and MabCute studies using the
Rituximab Administration Satisfaction Questionnaire (RASQ). Methods: In
PrefMab (NCT01724021) patients with untreated CD20+ DLBCL/FL received 1 cycle
of IV rituximab (375mg/m2) followed by either SC rituximab (1400mg, x3) then IV
rituximab (x4), or IV rituximab (x3) then SC rituximab (x4), with chemotherapy.
In MabCute (NCT01461928) patients with relapsed/refractory CD20+ indolent NHL
received induction rituximab IV (375mg/m2; 1 cycle) then rituximab SC (1400mg;
cycles 2–8) plus 6–8 chemotherapy cycles. RASQ evaluated preference by assessing
patients’ perceptions of the impact of administration route and treatment satisfaction. Conceptual validation of RASQ has been conducted and psychometric data
will be reported. Results: Median RASQ scores for PrefMab were: convenience IV
(n= 211) 58.3 (interquartile range: 41.7–75.0) and SC (n= 207) 83.3 (75.0–91.7); satisfaction: IV (n= 211) 75.0 (62.5–87.5), SC (n= 208) 87.5 (75.0–100.0); impact on daily life:
IV (n= 145) 50.0 (41.7–83.3), SC (n= 163) 83.3 (83.3–100.0); physical impact IV (n= 211)
83.3 (66.7–100.0), SC (n= 208) 83.3 (75.0–100.0); psychological impact IV (n= 211) 80.0
(65.0–90.0), SC (n= 208) 88.8 (75.0–95.0). SC administration was preferred by 80.3%
and 85.9% of patients with IV or SC as most recent dose, respectively. Results were
similar irrespective of treatment sequence. Median RASQ scores for MabCute
(n= 92) were: convenience: IV 58.3 (33.3–66.7), SC 83.3 (66.7–83.3); satisfaction: IV
62.5 (50.0–87.5), SC 87.5 (75.0–100.0); impact on daily life: IV 58.3 (41.7–66.7), SC 83.3
(66.7–83.3); physical impact IV 75.0 (66.7–91.7), SC 83.3 (66.7–91.7); psychological
impact IV 70.0 (60.0–85.0), SC 85.0 (75.0–95.0). Conclusions: Consistent patient
satisfaction and preference for SC versus IV rituximab was demonstrated in the
PrefMab and MabCute studies. RASQ is a reliable and valid measure of patient treatment preference.
PSY90
A Systematic Literature Review of the Humanistic Burden of
Multiple Myeloma
Rizzo M 1, Xu Y 2, Panjabi S 3, Iheanacho I 1
.
.
.
.
1Evidera, London, England, 2Evidera, Lexington, MA, USA, 3Onyx
Pharmaceuticals, Inc., an Amgen
subsidiary, South San Francisco, CA, USA
Objectives: We conducted a systematic literature review to identify published
evidence from observational studies on the humanistic burden of multiple myeloma
(MM). Methods: We searched MEDLINE, Embase, EconLit, and the Cochrane Library
for English-language articles and analysed these qualitatively. Results: The review
identified 20 publications based on 18 observational studies; these were mainly
cross-sectional in design (n= 14). Most studies (n= 15) examined populations with
MM in general, typically without stating the proportion with relapsed (R) or relapsed
and refractory (RR) MM. Fewer studies examined patients with newly-diagnosed
MM (n= 2) or RMM/RRMM (n= 1). Health-related quality of life (HRQoL) was typically
assessed using validated cancer-specific instruments (e. g., the EORTC-QLQ-C30:
n= 9; and the MM-specific EORTC-QLQ-MY20: n= 4). On average, patients with MM
had poorer HRQoL compared to the general population (n= 6), and compared to
patients with certain other hematologic cancers (n= 2). MM patients whose disease
duration ranged from diagnosis to 11 years had greater physical function impairment (p< 0.001) than other hematologic cancer patients. Other complaints included
fatigue, bone pain, tingling, and non-specific pain. Patients on active treatment had
worse side effects than those in a first treatment-free interval (p< 0.001); the latter
had better scores on HRQoL dimensions including role and social function, future
perspectives, and body image (all p< 0.05). Between baseline and one year, patients
experienced worsening on the EORTC-QLQ-C30 global health scale (p< 0.001) and
in fatigue, nausea/vomiting, and pain scores (all p< 0.05). Symptomatic patients
had lower physical functioning scores (p< 0.05) than asymptomatic patients; those
with severe symptoms had lower EORTC-QLQ-C30 global health scores (p< 0.05;
mild/moderate symptoms: p= NS). Fatigue, bone pain, and anaemia were associated
with lower. Conclusions: HRQoL in patients with MM deteriorates with disease
duration, symptom severity, disease progression, or development of complications.
This evidence suggests substantial unmet needs in MM patients.
PSY91
Patient-Reported Outcomes In Moderate To Severe Hemophilia
Patients: Finding From A Cross-Sectionalstudy In Korea
Lee K S 1, Cha J H 2
1Kyungpook National University School of Medicine, Daegu, South Korea, 2Pfizer Pharmaceuticals
Korea Ltd., Seoul, South Korea
.
.
.
.
Objectives: There are approximately 2,000 hemophilia patients in Korea, but
patient-reported outcome (PRO) studies involving a large number of hemophilia
patients have been rarely studied. The aim of this study was to assess PROs in
moderate to severe hemophilia patients in Korea. Methods: It was a crosssectional, multi-centered and observational study. Moderate to severe, male
hemophilia patients aged 8 to 65 were recruited at 2 of Korea Hemophilia
Foundations and 3 other pediatrics from November 2012 to September 2013.
All patients completed self-reported questionnaires to measure patients’ characteristics and PROs including health-related quality of life (HRQoL) and productivity loss. HRQoL was examined using EQ-5D, ranged 0-1, which higher
values indicate better HRQoL and Heamo-QoL, ranged 0-100, where higher values imply lower HRQoL. Productivity loss was estimated with absenteeism and
presentism in terms of lost productivity time (LPT). Results: For a total of 605
patients (mean age, 29.3 years; 88.6% with severe hemophilia) enrolled in this
study, the mean scores of heamo-QoL and EQ-5D were 32.28 and 0.68 respectively. The mean scores of EQ-5D in this study are comparable to 0.68 in rheumatoid arthritis patients from Korea Observational Study Network for Arthritis.
Significantly lower EQ-5D was found in patients with the following clinical factors
compared to those with reverse conditions; joint bleedings (0.68 vs. 0.73, p= .001),
A538
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
hemophilic joint health (0.67vs. 0.73, p< .001) or disability (0.65 vs. 0.70, p< .001) as
similar as in the results of Haemo-QoL. With patients who were either on a job or
students (n= 467, 77.2%), LPT was estimated at 127.81 hours per month on average.
Of 467, patients with inhibitor or disability showed higher LPT compared to those
without inhibitor (130.61 vs. 126.61 hours per month, p= 0.486) or disability. (132.27
vs. 124.95 hours per month p=.087). Conclusions: The study findings suggest that
patients’ clinical characteristics should take into account for the management of
hemophilia given patient-reported outcomes differed by clinical manifestations.
PSY92
Burden of Lupus Nephritis (Ln) Among Patients Managed In Routine
Clinical Practices In Europe (Eu)
Narayanan S 1, Hutchings R 2, Lu Y 2
1Ipsos Healthcare, Columbia, MD, USA, 2Ipsos Healthcare, London, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess the burden of LN in comparison to SLE patients without
Nephritis (Non-LN) in routine clinical practices in EU. Methods: A multi-center
medical chart-review of adult (16-89yrs) SLE patients was conducted among rheumatologists and internal medicine physicians in UK/France/Germany/Italy/Spain
(5EU). Physicians were recruited from a geographically representative sample in
each country. Approx. 5 consecutive eligible persistent active or relapse remitting
SLE patients currently managed as part of usual care were identified. Physicians
abstracted de-identified patient data on disease characteristics, lab values and
treatment patterns. LN and Non-LN cohorts were compared using descriptive
statistics. Results: 168 LN patients and 569 non-LN patients with SLE were analyzed. Patient characteristics included (LN/Non-LN): age (yrs): 40.2/42.7; % Female:
82.7/79.4; % Caucasian: 82.7%/88.8%; % full-time employment: 32.1/36.0; % part-time
employment: 19.0%/22.0%. Among LN/Non-LN cohorts, frequency of clinic visits was:
9.5wks/10.6wks, % currently receiving care in in-patient setting was: 14.9/8.8, % hospitalized >=1 in the past-year was: 49.4/29.7; mean # of organ manifestations was:
3.9/3.0. Top-5 organ manifestations were (% LN/Non-LN): musculoskeletal: 85.1/90.8,
mucocutaneous: 85.1/84.8, haematologic: 51.8/52.2, renal: 100.0/5.9, pulmonary:
16.7/16.2; % experiencing a flare was (LN/Non-LN): 23.2/16.6. Renal biopsy was performed in 87.5% (LN) and 4.0% (Non-LN) of patients. Steroids were used by 82.1%
(LN) and 69.4% (Non-LN). % patients with low C3 and C4 was LN: 66.3/48.1/Non-LN:
60.2/50.0; mean ESR scores were 40.2 (LN) and 36.8 (Non-LN). Among patients with
available data, SELENA-SLEDAI scores were 11.5 (LN) and 8.5 (Non-LN). Humanistic
burden (reported via physician ratings, on a scale of 0 (most impact) to 7 (least impact))
was (LN/Non-LN, mean scores): ability to perform every-day tasks: 5.0/5.3, ability to
interact fully with family and friends: 5.4/5.6, and ability to work/keep employment:
4.5/5.0. Conclusions: LN cohorts had higher clinical and humanistic burden in 5EU
in comparison to their non-LN SLE counterparts. Factors influencing the observed
burden, including the therapeutic strategies used in these geographies warrant further investigation to manage SLE, and LN in particular, optimally.
PSY93
Quality of Life (Qol) With Psoriasis: Ethnography Study Evaluating
the Impact of Psoriasis On Moderate To Severe Patients In Europe
(Eu), From A Patient’s Perspective
Narayanan S 1, Franceschetti A 2
Healthcare, Columbia, MD, USA, 2Ipsos Healthcare, London, UK
.
.
1Ipsos
Objectives: To qualitatively assess the impact of Psoriasis on patient
QoL. Methods: An ethnographic study with moderate/severe Psoriasis patients
was conducted in 4EU (UK/France/Spain/Italy) and the US to explore patients’ views
on treatment options and Psoriasis impact on QoL. Anthropologists and ethnographers spent several-hours with consented patients and filmed their behaviours
inside and outside their homes in everyday situations. 175 hours of recordings/notes
were analysed to identify QoL-related themes: self-image, psychological effects of
psoriasis (e. g., anxiety/depression), life-style changes due to Psoriasis, relationship
with family, friends and colleagues. Results: Study included 35 adult patients (4EU:
20, US: 15; mean age: 39 yrs; female: 65%). Patients described their appearance with
a sense of disgust and self-loathing. Feelings of frustration were often expressed due
to a perceived lack of control of their lives. Prior to biologic initiation, daily rituals
absorbed good part of their day, including waking up earlier to apply creams, going
to work earlier to check their appearance and cover patches of dead skin. Due to
lack of cultural discourse and patient’s difficulty in articulating Psoriasis’ impact,
partners and family did not know how to react nor did they realize the full extent
of the problem. Difficulty in getting appropriate psychological support needed left
them with a feeling of resignation. As a result, majority dealt with their issues in
isolation. Most patients experienced social discriminations due to Psoriasis which
led some to lie about their disease, keeping it a secret. Biologic experienced patients
noticed a significant improvement physically, but psychological scarring remained.
Despite their regained confidence owing to the effectiveness of biologics, they still
did not discuss their condition with family and friends. Conclusions: Patients
with Psoriasis experienced significantly lower quality of life and high psychological
scarring. Ethnographic study design vividly depicted the unarticulated and emotional impact of Psoriasis on patients’ everyday lives.
PSY94
Health Related Quality of Life of Patients and Their Caregivers In
Rare Diseases Results of the Burqol-Rd Project In Hungary
Péntek M 1, Baji P 1, Pogány G 2, Brodszky V 1, Boncz I 3, Gulácsi L 1
University of Budapest, Budapest, Hungary, 2Hungarian Federation of People with Rare
and Congenital Diseases, Budapest, Hungary, 3Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Pécs, Pécs,
Hungary
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Corvinus
Objectives: The Social Economic Burden and Health-Related Quality of Life in
Patients with Rare Diseases in Europe (BURQOL-RD, http://www.burqol-rd.com/)
project aimed to investigate disease burden and self-percieved health outcomes of
patients and their caregivers in rare diseases in eight EU countries (Bulgaria, France,
Germany, Hungary, Italy, Sweden, Spain, UK). Methods: An online questionnaire
survey was developed for patients (adults/children) and caregivers. Patients were
recruited by patient organisations in cystic fibrosis (CF), Prader–Willi syndrome
(PWS), haemophilia (HEMO), Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD), epidermolysis
bullosa (EB), fragile X syndrome (FXS), scleroderma (SCL), mucopolysaccharidosis
(MPS), juvenile idiopathic arthritis (JIA) and histiocytosis (HIS). Demography amd
main characteristics were recorded. Patients’ and caregivers’ health state was
assessed by the EQ-5D-5L, disability and caregivers’ burden by the Barthel Index
and Zarit Burden Interview questionnaires. Results: In Hungary, 296 Hungarian
patients (children: 161, 54%) participated in the study (CF 110, PWS 5, HEMO 58,
DMD 57, EB 6, FXS 12, SCL 38 and MPS 10 patients), no data were obtained in JIA and
HIS. Mean age among adults/children was 37.0 (SD 16.1) / 9.6 (SD= 4.5) years, and
disease duration was 18.5 (SD= 14.4) / 7.1 (SD= 4.5) years, respectively. The lowest
average EQ-5D-5L score was found in MPS (0.134 / 0.070) and DMD (0.310 / 0.198)
just alike with the Barthel Index (MPS: 35.6; DMD 58.0). Caregivers’ (N=95) mean
age was 39.2 (SD= 8.0) years and their EQ-5D-5L score (0.797, SD= 0.251) was not significantly different from the general populations’ average. Satisfaction with health
care (1-10 Likert scale) was the lowest in MPS, DMD and EB (mean 4.1, 5.2 and
4.3). Conclusions: Rare diseases induce substantial deterioration of patients’
quality of life and impose burden on caregivers. Taking an integrated approach our
results can serve for international comparisons and facilitate further investigations
in other orphan diseases.
PSY95
Is the Disease-Specific Lupusqol Sensitive To Changes of Disease
Activity In Systemic Lupus Erythematosus Patients After Treatment
of A Flare?
McElhone K 1, Burnell J 2, Sutton C 2, Abbott J 3, Lanyon P 4, Rahman A 5, Yee C S 6, Akil M 7,
Ahmad Y 8, Bruce I N 9, Gordon C 10, Teh L S 1
Blackburn Hospital, Blackburn, UK, 2UCLAN, Preston, UK, 3University of Central
Lancashire, Preston, UK, 4Queen’s Medical Centre, Nottingham, UK, 5University College London,
London, UK, 6Doncaster Royal Infirmary, Doncaster, UK, 7Royal Hallamshire Hospital, Sheffield,
UK, 8Betsi Cadwaldr University Health Board, Llandudno, UK, 9University of Manchester,
Manchester, UK, 10University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Royal
Objectives: The aim of the UK multi-centre LupusQoL Sensitivity Study is to
assess whether the LupusQoL, a systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) specific,
health-related quality of life measure is sensitive to change when disease activity improves or deteriorates. Methods: Patients with SLE experiencing a flare
(baseline) & requiring an increase in treatment were recruited. Assessments were
undertaken at baseline & monthly for 9 months & included BILAG-2004 disease
activity index & the LupusQoL with 8 domains and scores ranging from 0 (worst)
to 100 (best HRQoL). LupusQoL domain scores when disease activity improved or
deteriorated between consecutive time-points are reported as mean changes, with
95% CI constructed using robust standard errors to account for repeated patient
assessments. Results: Mean (SD) age was 40.9 (12.8) & duration since diagnosis was 9.3 (8.1) years for the 101 patients recruited; 94% females, 62.6% white
Caucasians. At baseline all mean LupusQoL domain scores were < 52. Scores for
LupusQoL physical health (+4.0, 95%CI 1.9 to 6.1), pain (+7.7, 95%CI 4.8 to 10.5) &
fatigue (+4.1, 95%CI 1.7 to 6.5) increased when BILAG improved. Scores for physical health (-4.9, 95% -9.4 to -0.4) and pain (-6.9, 95%CI -12.9 to -0.8) decreased with
a major BILAG deterioration but changes with a minor deterioration were small
and non-significant. The effects of improvements & deterioration in BILAG on
the other LupusQoL domain scores were smaller. Conclusions: Improvement
and deterioration of LupusQoL domain scores for physical health, pain & fatigue
domain scores was seen in patients with significant changes in disease activity
over 1 month. Sensitivity to change of other LupusQoL domains in relation to
changes in disease activity may need to be evaluated over a longer interval as the
more emotive type of response to the disease & its consequences may be latent
and therefore not evident at monthly intervals.
PSY96
The Quality of Life of Patients Treated With Robotic Versus
Traditional Surgery Results From An Italian Observational
Multicenter Study
Turchetti G , Pierotti F , Palla I , Manetti S , Cuschieri A
Scuola Superiore Sant’Anna, Pisa, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess the Quality of Life (QoL), focusing on level of pain, of patients
submitted to surgical interventions with robotic technique in comparison with
traditional approach in the Italian setting. Methods: The prospective multicentre study analysed the QoL of 699 patients submitted to surgical interventions,
enrolled in 8 Italian Hospitals for the period February 2011-May 2014. The specialties
were general, thoracic, gynecological surgery performed with open, manual laparoscopic or robotic technique. Patients completed two questionnaires: one related
to pain intensity during the hospitalization and one fulfilled at home related to
pain intensity and its impact on daily activities, mood, relationship, sleep. Pain was
measured using the scale of facial expressions corresponding to the Visual Analog
Scale. For each intervention and specialty, linear regression for repeated measure,
corrected by length of stay and use of analgesics, were performed to explain level
of pain during hospitalization and at home, respectively. Results: Level of pain
during hospitalization is significantly (p= 0.05) lower in general and gynecological
robotic surgery versus the open technique, but not versus laparoscopic, while robotic
thoracic surgery presents significant differences with laparoscopic but not with
open surgery (p= 0.059). Level of pain at home is significantly different for robotic
interventions versus open both in general and gynecological surgery; moreover,
with respect to laparoscopic interventions, the differences are significant both in
gynecological and in thoracic but not in general surgery. Conclusions: The study
gives us insightful knowledge about QoL, focusing on pain, of patients submitted to
surgical interventions with robotic technique vs traditional surgery. Further analysis
are in progress to combine results on QoL, not only referred to level of pain, with
clinical severity and other indicators of clinical efficacy as length of stay, operating
A539
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
time, medical/surgical complications to refine a robust measure of effectiveness
useful to perform cost effectiveness analysis.
PSY97
Characteristics of Patients With Systemic Lupus Erythematosus
(Sle) Currently On Remission, With Active Disease But Not
Experiencing Flare, and Those Experiencing Flares In Clinical
Practices In Europe
Narayanan S 1, Hutchings R 2, Lu Y 2
1Ipsos Healthcare, Columbia, MD, USA, 2Ipsos Healthcare, London, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess the characteristics of SLE patients currently on Remission
(Group-1), currently with active disease but not experiencing a flare (Group-2) and
those who are experiencing flares (Group-3) in Europe (EU). Methods: A multicenter medical chart review of adult (16-89 yrs) SLE patients was conducted in
1Q2014 among rheumatologists/internal medicine physicians in UK/France/
Germany/Italy/Spain (5EU). Physicians were recruited from a geographically representative sample in each country. Approx. 5 consecutive eligible persistent active or
relapse remitting SLE patients currently managed as part of usual care were identified. Physicians abstracted de-identified patient data on disease characteristics, lab
values and treatment patterns. Patient disease status and humanistic burden was
assessed by physician per clinical judgment & patient interaction. Results: 747 SLE
patient charts were abstracted in 5EU (UK: 156/France: 149/Germany: 148/Italy: 146/
Spain: 148); Group-1: 25.7% (range: 19.9% (Italy) –29.7% (Germany)), Group-2: 56.2%
(range: 42.3% (UK) –66.4% (Italy)), Group-3: 18.1% (range: 13.5 (Germany) –28.8 (UK)).
Patient characteristics included (Group-1/Group-2/Group-3): age (yrs): 41.4/43/40.6; %
female: 81.8/80.2/77.8; % full-time employment: 38.0/34.5/32.6; % part-time employment: 25.5/20.5/17.8; % on sick leave: 3.6/7.6/17.0; % currently receiving treatment
in in-patient setting: 3.1/7.6/28.1; % hospitalized > = 1 in past-year: 23.4/32.1/55.6.
Top-5 organ manifestations were (% Group-1/Group-2/Group-3): musculoskeletal:
90.6/89.5/88.1, mucocutaneous: 86.5/84.0/85.2, haematologic: 45.8/53.8/55.6, renal:
23.4/26.7/33.3, pulmonary: 15.1/13.6/26.7. In Group-1/Group-2/Group-3, % patients
with low C3 and C4 were 33.3/53.9/73.4 and 31.6/53.2/77.5 and % anti-ds-DNA positive were 54.7/71.0/78.5. Humanistic burden (reported via physician ratings, on a
scale of 0 (most impact) to 7 (least impact)) was (Group-1/Group-2/Group-3, mean
scores): patient ability to perform every-day tasks: 6.11/5.17/4.37, patient ability to
interact fully with family and friends: 6.20/5.45/4.90, and patient ability to work/
keep employment: 5.76/4.80/3.87. Conclusions: Over half of the SLE patients had
an active disease while one-in-five were experiencing a flare in this study cohort,
with significant variations observed within 5EU. Clinical and humanistic burden
varied based on patient disease status, with highest burden observed among those
experiencing flares.
of 16 criteria. Methods: 85 experts were interviewed to estimate the importance
of each criterion in the decision-making on financing MT for rare diseases. We
used 10-point scale, where 10 points mean major importance to the priority indicator, and 1point means minor importance. Mean estimates were calculated using
descriptive statistics, then means were normalized. Results: Respondents were
41 years on average (ranging from 23 to 64 years), and included 20 public servants,
16 health administrators, 32 practitioners, and 14 researchers. 44 respondents had
a scientific degree. The most important criteria were characteristics of treatment “Effect of treatment on quality of life” and “Effect of treatment on life expectancy”
with 1 points each. The least important criteria were both characteristics of the
disease - “Cognitive disorders as manifestations of the disease and “Additional burden on the daily lives of care-givers” with 0.28 and 0.1 respectively. Conclusions:
Characteristics of treatment turned out to be more important for respondents than
characteristics of disease, therefore characteristics of treatment should be given
consideration when evaluating rare diseases to determine priority financing.
PSY100
Patterns and Trends In Opioid Use In Iran From 2007 To 2011
Taheri F
Minitry of Health, tehran, Iran
.
Objectives: Opioid analgesics are proven to be safe and effective in malignant or
nonmalignant pains. The consumption trend of six opioids (Morphine, Codeine,
Oxycodone, Fentanyl, Pethidine, and Methadone) in Islamic Republic of Iran
assumed as an indicator for prescription pattern and is evaluated during five year
period (2007-2011) as the aim of this study. Methods: The data of opioid analgesic
consumption were collected from FDO (Food and Drug Organization) of Iran. The
collected data were converted to DDD (Define Daily Dose) for each of six selected
opioids in order to be compared accurately. Results: Overall consumption of opioids was grown during the period of investigation. Putting six selected opioids into
two groups – synthetic and non-synthetic -, the growth rate of synthetic ones are
obviously higher than those of non-synthetics. Opioid analgesics consumption in
2011 was shown to be 4 times more than the opioid consumption in 2007. The CAGR
(Compound Average Growth Rate) between 2007-2011 were reported 111.27%, 33.11%,
16.48%, 3.91%, 3.76%, and -41.63% for Oxycodone, Methadone, Fentanyl, Morphine,
Pethidine and Codeine respectively. The growth rate of mentioned above opioids
for the last year of investigation was reported 41.12%, 16.54%, 29.99%, -0.38%, 7.66%,
23.67% respectively. Conclusions: Like other low consuming countries, consumption of opioid analgesics in Iran is limited by means of different kinds of barriers.
There are also parameters which set a specific orientation in opioid consumption.
Analyzing this trend, results in defining the barriers and other parameters clearly.
PSY101
Orphan Drug Approvals In Europe: Historical Review and Trends
SYSTEMIC DISORDERS/CONDITIONS – Health Care Use & Policy Studies
Rodrigues J 1, Korchagina D 1, Rémuzat C 1, Brunet J 2, Tavella F 3
Publique des Hôpitaux de Marseille, Marseille, France,
3Creativ-Ceutical, London, UK
.
.
.
.
.
1Creativ-Ceutical, Paris, France, 2Assistance
PSY98
Orphan Drug Policy: Approaches To Market Access In Multiple
Countries
Shih D Y , Jarrett J
MAPI, London, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: Despite increasing policy guidance to encourage the development
of and access to orphan drugs, the policy landscape indicates a lack of transparency and consistency across countries. The objective of this study is to compare
the orphan drug policies of Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan to the policies in the
EU. Methods: A targeted literature review was conducted to identify papers pertaining to orphan drugs in Japan, South Korea and Taiwan, with a focus on quantitative analysis for policy-making related to pricing and reimbursement from the payer
perspective. No limits were placed on language. Country specific policy websites
were hand-searched. Results: A total of 3465 abstracts were identified for screening. Of those, 104 were eligible for full-text screening. The definition of prevalence
with regard to rare diseases in Japan, South Korea and Taiwan was stricter than in
the EU. All of them had introduced regulations, guidelines and incentives to the
development of orphan-designated drugs. Strict HTA requirements were waived
for rare diseases, although cost-effectiveness data are referenced in South Korea.
In Japan and Taiwan, prices were reduced for existing drugs with new orphandesignated indications. Within the existing benefits of national health insurance
schemes or under the coverage of rare disease regulations, full reimbursement
was given, which is different from the partial reimbursements observed in certain European countries. In some cases, the application of drug treatment can be
approved prior to or without market authorisation. The availability of orphan drugs
to patients was not inferior to that of the EU. Conclusions: While access in Japan,
South Korea and Taiwan is seemingly no different to the EU, there are no consistent
or transparent policies in place in these countries. Policy makers should prepare
innovative schemes that offer warranties to both payers and patients and establish
a systematic evaluation procedure for manufacturers.
PSY99
Mcda Approach To Ranking Rare Diseases In Russia: Preliminary
Results
Fedyaeva V K 1, Omelyanovsky V V 1, Rebrova O 2, Khan N 1, Petrovskaya E V 3
1The Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration, Moscow,
Russia, 2Pirogov Russian National Research Medical University, Moscow, Russia, 3Samara State
Medical University, Samara, Russia
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The ranking and prioritization of rare diseases are crucial in order to
define for which of them state support measures are justifiable. For this purpose the
set of 16 criteria to assess rare diseases (8 related to the characteristics of disease,
and 8 to the characteristics of treatment) was proposed by experts, so multi-criteria
decision (MCDA) analysis approach could be useful. The aim of the study was to
assess the reliability of the criteria set and to determine the relative importance
Objectives: In Europe, orphan designation has been granted by European
Medicines Agency since 2000. Molecules with orphan designation can benefit from
a number of incentives to guarantee return on investment for manufacturers. Since
introduction of orphan legislation, the number of Orphan Drugs (OD) has significantly increased. In 2012, total OD sales reached 13% of the whole pharmaceutical
market. This study aims to analyse current situation and trends in OD approvals. Methods: All ODs approved gaining marketing authorization was identified
through EMA website. Extensions to a new disease were considered as an independent approval, while extensions of indication for the same condition were not considered. Information on drug status, indications, therapeutic area, and authorisation
date was extracted. Results: 77 orphan molecules were identified of which two
have been withdrawn, and one orphan designation has expired. Yearly approvals
continuously grow (from 2 ODs approved in 2002 to 12 and 8 drugs in 2012 and 2013
respectively). By mid-2014, already 6 were approved. There is a high imbalance
within therapeutic area with 36% for oncology, 27% for endocrine, nutritional and
metabolic disorders whereas the remaining 37% cover 11 therapeutic classes. No
product has been approved for 7 therapeutic areas despite existence of rare disorders. Moreover, oncology is associated with the highest growth. Conclusions:
Orphan drug market is rapidly growing but targeting selective therapeutic areas
with high potential return on investment. The incentive policies happen to well
function but discriminate among diseases. A review of orphan drug policies might
be warranted to ensure patient equity in development of new OD.
PSY102
Comparative Analysis of Hta Decisions, Price and Reimbursement
Level of Orphan Drugs In France and Italy
Korchagina D 1, Tavella F 2, Rémuzat C 1, Kornfeld A 3, Toumi M 4
1Creativ-Ceutical, Paris, France, 2Creativ-Ceutical, London, UK, 3Creativ Ceutical, Paris, France,
4University of Marseille, Marseille, France
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: While there exist a number of incentives to stimulate research and
development of orphan drugs (OD), the Health Technology Assessment (HTA) agencies do not offer specific path for OD in most countries where it is left to payer value
judgement. This leads to a high inequity in patient access to OD. The study aims
at comparing the HTA decisions, price and reimbursement level of OD in France
and Italy. Methods: All OD assessed since 2000 were analysed. Prices, reimbursement rates and decision details were extracted for each drug using Farmadati Italia
database for Italy and Transparency committee reports, AMELI’s national health
insurance and Thériaque databases for France. Results: Among 74 OD approved in
Europe 66 are available in Italy compared to 53 in France. All ODs available in France
are officially available in Italy. The average delay between the market authorization
and the price and reimbursement decision was about 16 and 17 months in France
and Italy, respectively. In France all available drugs are 100% reimbursed through
hospital, 36 molecules are available in retail pharmacy with reimbursement from
A540
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
15% to 100%. In Italy only 9 molecules are reimbursed in retail pharmacy and other
10 are not reimbursed at all. In 63% cases ex-factory prices in Italy are higher than
in France. The average price difference in price is 12 % with 50% of products sharing
almost same price (less than 5% difference). No information is available in France on
managed entry agreement, while it is publicly available in Italy. This prevents fair
price comparison. Conclusions: OD are more available in Italy, but reimbursement is poorer than in France. Prices are slightly higher in Italy but France displays
multiple confidential rebates making it impossible to compare net prices. In Italy
the actual accessibility depends a lot on regional level unlike France.
Orphan Drugs, only the Eculizumabe for the treatment of PNH has no approved
registration by the National Health Surveillance Agency (ANVISA). Conclusions:
Considering its high cost, high judicial demand and limited availability of scientific
evidence, orphan drugs represent a challenge for researchers and decision makers.
Clinical benefit, disease severity, availability of therapeutic alternatives, ethical,
political and social aspects should be considered. It is necessary to start a multidisciplinary reflection on the development of HTA models and policies regarding
rare diseases and innovative treatments in the SUS, as well as fostering the primary
researches in this field.
PSY103
Health Technology Assessment, Price and Reimbursement Review
for Orphan Drugs In Italy
PSY106
To What Extent Do Disease and Treatment Characteristics
Influence Hta-Based Recommendations for A Sample of Orphan
Drugs In Three Countries, and Could These Indicate Whether Orphan
Drugs Have A “Special Status”?
Tavella F 1, Korchagina D 2, Rodrigues J 2, Rémuzat C 2
.
.
.
.
1Creativ-Ceutical, London, UK, 2Creativ-Ceutical, Paris, France
Objectives: In Italy drug Health Technology Assessment (HTA) is conducted by the
Scientific Technical Commission of Italian Medicines Agency (AIFA) with further
negotiation between the manufacturers and the AIFA’s Pricing & Reimbursement
Committee on price and reimbursement. After the decision is taken it is published
in the official journal (Gazetta officale), the assessed drug is formally available
for Italian patients next day. There does not exist a specific procedure for orphan
drugs (OD), they are evaluated under the same conditions as drugs for common
diseases. Pharmaco-economic studies are recommended for innovative drugs. The
objective of the study is to review HTA decisions, prices and reimbursement of OD
in Italy. Methods: All OD assessed in Italy since 2000 were identified. Prices, reimbursement rates and decision details were extracted for each drug using Farmadati
Italia database. Results: Among 74 OD approved in Europe 66 molecules are officially available in Italy. It took 5-10 months from granting market authorization to
final decision on pricing and reimbursement and publication in ‘Gazetta officale’.
The mean time was about 17 months shorter than for common drugs. Only 9 of
available molecules are fully reimbursed in Italy, reimbursement of 30 drugs is
restricted to hospital use, 10 are not reimbursed and 5 are in a special class waiting
a decision on reimbursement rate. For other drugs information is not available. Postmarketing surveillance studies were requested for a half of indications, AIFA registries were reported in 25% of cases. Annual treatment ex-factory price of OD varies
from € 2 500 to almost € 1 000 000. Conclusions: Almost 90% of approved OD are
available in Italy. However, the actual situation often differs a lot from the official
data as some drugs are unavailable from retail or hospital pharmacies. In addition,
regional authorities contribute to inequity in access especially for “expensive drugs”.
PSY104
Health Technology Assessment, Price and Reimbursement Review
for Orphan Drugs In France
Korchagina D 1, Rémuzat C 1, Rodrigues J 1, Kornfeld A 2, Toumi M 3
1Creativ-Ceutical, Paris, France, 2Creativ Ceutical, Paris, France, 3University of Marseille,
Marseille, France
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In France Orphan Drugs (OD) undergo the same Health Technology
Assessment (HTA) procedure as other drugs. The evaluation is performed by the
Transparency Committee (TC). Two scores are assigned and further used for pricing & reimbursement decision: drug’s medical benefit (SMR) and improvement in
medical benefit (ASMR). OD can be eligible to an accelerated procedure established
for innovative products. The study aim is to analyse HTA decisions, prices and reimbursement of OD in France. Methods: Exhaustive prices, reimbursement and HTA
opinions were extracted using Transparency Committee Website, AMELI’s national
health insurance and Thériaque databases. Results: Among 74 OD approved
in Europe, 21 drugs are not available in France. 6 were recently assessed by TC
but are not yet reimbursed, 14 were not assessed and one got a negative opinion.
Reimbursement process took between 2 and 5 months after TC opinion. 88% of
drugs were considered as bringing a substantial medical benefit. At the same time,
more than a half of medicines were graded as providing a major (9%), significant
(27%) or moderate (20%) improvement in actual benefit leading to opportunity for
premium prices, 30% were rated minor improvement, and about 14% no improvement according to TC opinion. Annual treatment prices of OD varie from € 1,500 to
almost € 1,000,000. Conclusions: About a third of approved ODs are not available
in France. Most of them were authorized recently and are might become available
after the HTA and pricing process. In comparison to non OD, the ASMR scoring is
outstanding. Lack of alternative treatment and severity of the condition appear to
be the drivers of high SMR-ASMR score.
PSY105
Hta Studies On Orphan Drugs By Rebratsxmembers
Souza K M 1, Gonçalves L 2
1Brazilian Ministry of Health, Brasília, Brazil, 2Brazilian Ministry of Health, Brasília-DF, Brazil
.
.
.
Objectives: In Brazil, the studies produced by members of the Brazilian Network
for Health Technology Assessment (REBRATS) have contributed in a significant way
in the process of management and incorporation of technologies in the Brazilian
Public Health system (SUS). However, there is still a lack of a Pharmaceutical
Assistance and HTA Policy for rare diseases and the evidence for orphan drugs are
limited and lower. The coverage for these drugs, is frequently done through judicial
orders, political and social pressure, with no support of evidence-based medicine.
The objectives is to evaluate the production of HTA studies for orphan drugs made
by REBRATS members. Methods: Query to the REBRATS database and the internal
production of the HTA coordination, prioritizing 6 major diseases: Gaucher disease, Fabry disease, Mucopolysaccharidosis Type I (MPS I); Mucopolysaccharidosis
Type II (MPS II); Mucopolysaccharidosis Type VI (MPS VI); Paroxysmal Nocturnal
Haemoglobinuria (PNH). Results: Five HTA studies were found, which are: a
Rapid Response for Gaucher disease; a study on Health Technology Management
for Fabry disease; an Economic Evaluation for MPS I, II and VI; a Systematic Review
for Mucopolysaccharidosis Type II; and one Rapid Review for PNH. For the evaluated
Nicod E
London School of Economics and Political Science, London, UK
.
Routine HTA methods may not adequately capture all the important considerations
of a treatment’s value and the impact of the condition on the patient given that
evidence is often incomplete. This study aims to explore the influence of broader considerations of scientific and social value judgments on reimbursement decisions for
a sample of orphan drugs.Objectives: To identify and compare the extent to which
these broader considerations not captured by the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio
(ICER) influenced HTA decision-making process in three countries; and, on this basis,
explore whether orphan drugs have a “special status”. Methods: Countries included
were England, Scotland and Sweden. Ten drug-indication pairs with EMA orphan designation and all appraised by NICE were selected. Publicly available HTA reports were
coded using thematic analysis to systematically identify and compare these broader
considerations across countries using an existing analytical framework. Results:
108 different other considerations were identified and grouped into 15 clusters based
on the information provided. The most common related to the nature of the disease,
and considerations based on rarity or unmet need. 52% were one of the main reasons
for the decision, and in some cases, were also a pivotal factor in accepting high and
uncertain ICERs. Categorising these as social or scientific value judgments was done
to identify areas where further elicitation of societal preferences, and where more
consistency and transparency in their use are needed, respectively. Each of these was
then compared to determine whether they pertained specifically to orphan drug or
rare disease characteristics. Conclusions: Considerable variation was seen in the
application of these broader considerations. Identifying these is a way forward to
highlight areas where more research, or consistency and transparency are needed.
Some of these other considerations may also favour orphan drugs, furthering the
debate around whether orphan drugs deserve special status.
PSY107
Why Are There Differences In Hta Recommendations Across
Countries? A Systematic Comparison of Hta Decision Processes for A
Sample of Orphan Drugs In Four Countries
Nicod E
London School of Economics and Political Science, London, UK
.
HTA reimbursement recommendations often result in different outcomes across
countries despite the same evidence being appraised for a same technology. There
is a need to understand the reasons for these differences. Objectives: To systematically compare HTA processes for a sample of orphan drugs across four countries
(England, Scotland, Sweden, France): to identify the use and interpretation of the evidence appraised, and highlight differences across countries. Methods: Ten orphan
drug-indication pairs were selected and systematically compared using a previously
validated framework. An exploratory sequential mixed methods design divided the
research into two stages: (1) qualitative in-depth analysis of the decision-making
processes; and (2) quantitative identification of agency-specific risk preferences
and agreement levels across countries. Results: Differences at each step of the
decision-making process were identified. The same pivotal trials were appraised
but with varying levels of detail in reporting the clinical outcomes, explaining some
of the reasons for differing HTA recommendations. Agency-specific risk preferences were identified through correspondence analysis as drivers of these decisions, further explaining some of these differences. Poor to moderate agreement in
the interpretation of the evidence was measured using Cohen’s kappa scores. This
reflected situations where the countries interpreted the same evidence differently
and situations where differences in the handling of the same uncertainties were
seen, including differences in the extent to which stakeholder input influenced a
decision. Conclusions: This research systematically compared HTA processes
in different countries, facilitating the understanding of these complex processes
including how different HTA bodies conduct value assessments. It enabled to raise
awareness around the reasons for differences across countries, and highlight
areas for potential methodological improvements in HTA. Further application of
this framework to other disease areas and countries is a way forward to improving the drivers of coverage decisions while better understanding the settings and
limitations of HTA.
PSY108
Top 20 Orphan Drugs Availability, Pricing and Reimbursement In
Slovakia: 2005-2012 Review
Babela R 1, Uraz V 2, Babelova O 2, Slezakova Z 1
University, BRATISLAVA, Slovak Republic, 2St. Elizabeth University, Bratislava,
Slovak Republic
.
.
.
.
1St. Elizabeth
Objectives: Orphan drugs are highly priced and top 20 orphan drugs create almost
2,5% of total drug expenditure in Slovakia. We conducted 8 years review of government and literature sources to provide insight into pricing, reimbursement and
availability situation surrounding top 20 orphan drugs in Slovakia from the health
care payer perspective. Methods: We provide analysis of official prices, reim-
A541
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
bursement status and availability of top 20 orphan drugs in Slovakia from 2005
till 2012. Data were obtained from government sources. Results: We considered
orphan drugs list (Cote and Keating, 2012) that exceeded 1 billion $ sales in 2008
(globally) and compared molecules’ availability in Slovakia. Same molecules are
among best selling 20 orphan drugs in Slovakia, with highest sale of 95 million EUR
(Bevacizumab, 2005-2012) compared to lowest sale of 19 million EUR (Tacrolimus,
2005-2012). It took from 1 (Imatinib) to 19 years (Glatiramer acetate) to be launched
in Slovakia after orphan designation. Top 20 orphan drugs had average DOT 472
EUR compared to total pharma market DOT average 0,43 EUR. From selected orphan
drugs 60% had full (100%) reimbursement status and 40% were fully covered by
hospital budgets. Only 4 of them were launched in Slovakia since 2005 (included), 16
of them were launched from 1990 till 2004. Prices ranged from 330 EUR to 5800 EUR
(ex-factory, one package, 2012). Conclusions: There are highly valuable incentives
for industry to invest in to development of orphan drugs in EU. Current context of
economic constraints in EU however justifies the need to pay close attention to the
rationale of maintaining such incentives in the context of potential return on investments of companies offering high priced drugs. Top 20 orphan drugs in Slovakia
have prices high above average and also full reimbursement status. We expect more
restrictive drug policy measures in this field.
PSY109
Effect of Excluding Non-Patient Benefits As An Element On Acmg
Newborn Screening (Nbs) Recommendations
Mahida S , Algarni M , Rittenhouse B
MCPHS University, Boston, MA, USA
.
.
.
Objectives: In 2006 the American College of Medical Genetics (ACMG) developed
a stakeholder survey to make recommendations for 84 rare conditions to be considered for mandatory newborn screening (NBS). Scores of 19 different surveyed
attributes for each condition were totaled. These scores determined an entry point
to an algorithm (EPA) that determined final recommendations (Core conditions,
Secondary Targets or Not Recommended). Among these attributes was a controversial one - non-patient benefits (NPB). Such attributes have historically not been
considered in mandatory screening recommendations. This analysis examines
how the exclusion of this attribute would affect recommendations. Methods:
The ACMG report provided scores for individual attribute survey responses. We
deleted the attribute score for NPB (0 to 100 points) and rescored the totals for
each condition. We then assessed whether score changes were sufficient to alter
the EPA and whether a different EPA would result in changes to the recommendations. Results: Six conditions had missing data. Of the 78 remaining, there were
15 conditions (19%) whose initial total scores were capable of changing by enough
in this exercise (maximum 100 point reduction) to change the EPA. Of those, 10 (67%)
did change EPA and, of those, 3 (30%) changed final category (in all cases from Core
to ST). Of the initial 29 recommended Core conditions, there would be a 10 percent
reduction to 26 and an increase in Secondary Targets from 25 to 28. Conclusions:
Including screening benefits to non-patients (family or society) is controversial
and has not been standard in the past. We have shown that in the ACMG recommendations, had no changes been made to the algorithm consequent to dropping
non-patient benefits from consideration, 3 conditions would have changed from a
Core recommendation for screening to only a Secondary Target.
PSY110
Access To Orphan Drugs In Greece During Economic Crisis
Tsiantou V 1, Mylona K 1, Karampli E 1, Boubouchairopoulou N 1, Kyriopoulos I I 1,
Athanasakis K 1, Gabriel E 2, Makridaki D 3, Kyriopoulos J 1
1National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece, 2Institute of Pharmaceutical Research and
Technology, Pallini, Greece, 3Panhellenic Association of Hospital Pharmacists, Marousi, Greece
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Orphan Drugs (ODs) are medicinal products intended for diagnosis,
prevention or treatment of rare diseases. Access to ODs is crucial for patients’ health
and quality of life. The aim of this study was to identify current problems and future
challenges of patients’ access to ODs in Greece. Methods: A qualitative study took
place between December 2013 and January 2014. Data were retrieved through semistructured interviews with six representatives of key stakeholders in Greece and
policy documents identified through web searches using keywords “orphan drugs”
and “rare diseases” in Greek. Web-based documents and transcribed interviews were
content analyzed. Results: Delays in pricing and reimbursement of ODs in the
Greek pharmaceutical market, budget cuts in hospitals and absence of patient registries constitute according to the analysis the greatest barriers in patients’ access
to ODs. There are two main channels through which the patient can have access
to an OD and it depends whether it is licensed in Greece or not. In the first case
the patient can take the drug through the hospital or the pharmacy of EOPYY if it
is not available at the hospital pharmacy and in the second case through a public
sector organization (IFET). All cases are characterized by extensive bureaucracy and
involvement of up to three organizations in order to receive the approval, a procedure creating delays in patients’ access and risking their health. Also, the absence of
a well-described procedure and lack of cooperation between the organizations and
committees create further delays. Conclusions: Ensuring patients’ access to ODs
in Greece is challenging especially during the economic crisis. Financial constraints
and continuous legislative changes in the health system and the pharmaceutical
market constitute important barriers to patients’ access. There is a need to describe,
organize and communicate the pathway of patients’ access to ODs.
PSY111
Self Reported Health Care Resource Use and Indirect Economic
Burden of Opioid Induced Constipation (Oic)
Alemayehu
B 1, Coyne
1AstraZeneca
.
K S 2, King
.
.
F3
.
Pharmaceuticals LP, Wilmington, DE, USA, 2Evidera, Bethesda, MD, USA,
3AstraZeneca, Gaithersberg, MD, USA
Objectives: To describe the health care resource utilization associated with the
diagnosis, treatment, and general management of opioid-induced constipation (OIC)
and events attributed to OIC including the negative impact on job-related activities. Methods: A prospective longitudinal study conducted in the United States
(US), Canada (CN), UK (UK), and Germany (GE) of patients with OIC who have been
on opioid therapy for at least four weeks was conducted. OIC related medical history
and health care resource use was collected from participants self report. The number of hours missed from work and the extent to which the work productivity and
regular daily activities were affected was collected using the WPAI-SHP. Results:
A total of 489 eligible participants (US: 238; CN: 38;, GE: 115; UK: 98). Back pain
(77%) and joint pain (52%) were the most common pain diagnosis with an average
duration of chronic pain and opioid medication use of 10 and 6 years respectively.
27% of participants were currently employed. 18% of participants used at least
one prescription laxative; 70% reported using at least one over-the-counter (OTC)
laxative with the most common being stimulant laxatives (20%), osmotic laxatives
(15%) and stool softeners (7%). 63% of participants reported discussing OIC with a
health care provider, 3.0% reported a visit to the emergency room and 2.0% reported
being admitted to a hospital because of their OIC during a 6-month time period.
9% of employed participants reported missing an average of 4.6 hours per week
because of problems associated with constipation and 32% reported impairment
while working due to constipation. Conclusions: The cumulative impact of OTC
use, physician office visits and the negative impact on work-related activities for
OIC may be substantial.
PSY112
Health Care Utilisation and Selected Expenditures Associated With
Neuroblastoma In England
George S 1, Buckle J 2
.
.
1Milliman, Tampa, FL, USA, 2Milliman, London, UK
Objectives: Neuroblastoma (NB) is a rare cancer of childhood, with nearly 90% of
cases diagnosed by age 5 (ACS 2013). Our objective was to report the utilisation and
cost of hospital services related to patients who have a diagnosis of NB and High
Risk NB (HRNB) reported in an England dataset from a Clinical Commissioning
Group (CCG) perspective. Methods: We used an England dataset covering hospital events (April 2010 - September 2013). Patients were included if they were under
age 18 and had a hospital event with a primary or secondary diagnosis coded as
International Classification of Disease 10thEdition (ICD10) C749. Newly diagnosed
patients were identified if they had no hospital events in the first 4 months of
the study period. From this newly diagnosed cohort we identified a HRNB cohort
(bone marrow transplant) that included patients who had a high risk procedure
that did not occur in the last 12 months of the study period. Cost and utilisation is
reported from hospital admissions, emergency department visits, and outpatient
attendances. Results: We observed 336 patients as newly diagnosed and an additional 33 patients were identified as HRNB. Newly diagnosed population inpatient
admits were 12 per patient, compared with 22 per patient for the HRNB population.
Total costs associated with the 336 newly diagnosed patients were £24.3m. Total
costs associated with the 33 HRNB patients were £4.3m. Costs per HRNB patient
(£130,303) were almost double the costs per newly diagnosed patient (£72,321).
The average length of stay was 6 days for both sets of patients. Conclusions:
To our knowledge this is the first retrospective analysis of NB cost and utilisation
using encounter data from England. While it does not capture the entire costs to
the England health care system, it indicates the level of resource intensity and
cost at the CCG level.
PSY113
Database Analysis On Patients Using Immunobiological Drugs In A
Brazilian Private Health Care Plan: A Real World Data Analysis
Reis H P L C 1, Viana A D J R 1, Magalhães D D P 1, Alcantara A C D C 1, Sartori D P 1, Vieira J B 1,
Ferreira J 2, Rodrigues E X 1, Filho N G 1
1Unimed Fortaleza, Fortaleza, Brazil, 2UFC, Fortaleza, Brazil
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Patients’ profile undergoing intravenous immunobiological treatment
is very limited. This study aimed to describe this information from the perspective of
a Brazilian health plan, located in Fortaleza. Methods: This was a cross sectional
study with data obtained from the HMO database as presented by Reis H et al at
ISPOR 18th Annual Meeting. Eligible criteria for data analysis were patients being
treated for rheumatoid arthritis (RA), ankylosing spondylitis (AS), psoriatic arthritis
(PsA) or Crohn’s disease (CD) who have received at least one dose of immunobiological drug between March/2012 and October/2013. Data was stratified by indication
(RA, AS, PsA and CD), patient weight and treatment profile (naïve versus non-naïve
patients). Results: A total of 118 patients had been analyzed, with an average
age of 51 years, and 66.9% (n = 79) of them being women. RA (n = 53,44,9%) and AS
(n = 49,41,5%) were the most prevalent diseases being treated, followed by PsA
(n = 13,11%) and CD (n = 3,2, 5%). The average weight of patients varied according
to the disease being treated: 67 kg for RA and CD, and 70 kg for AS and PsA. It was
observed that 65.5% patients were naïve to immunobiological drug, of which 73%
initiated treatment with an anti-TNFa, being infliximab the most commonly prescribed one (85.2%). As for patients who had already been previously treated, golimumab and abatacept were the most commonly prescribed drugs (23%), whereas
48.7% out of total were receiving the third immunobiogical drug and 35.9% were
receiving the second one. Conclusions: The knowledge of patients profile and
treatment information is the basis for any planning strategy in an HMO. Associated
with costs, this data is crucial in supporting HMO board decisions on best treatment
alternatives and so optimize the provided care.
PSY114
Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis for Reimbursing Orphan Drugs: A
Dutch Demonstration Study Using the Analytic Hierarchy Process
Method
Trip A M 1, Tsiachristas A 1, Koenders J M 2, Kanters T A 1
1Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 2Novartis Pharma B.V., Arnhem,
The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A542
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: Reimbursement decisions are often unsystematic and lack transparency, especially for orphan drugs. The objective of this study was to demonstrate
whether multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA) can support rational and explicit
reimbursement decision process for orphan drugs in the Netherlands. Methods:
An Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) framework was used in which Health Economics
students were asked to weigh criteria used in drug reimbursement decisions through
a web-based survey. Criteria were identified by a systematic literature review. Three
different orphan drugs (alglucosidase alfa in infantile Pompe disease, canakinumab in
cryopyrin-associated periodic syndromes and investigational product in rare disease)
were also assessed by the students on their performance on these criteria. Criteria
weights and performance scores were aggregated to an overall score for each orphan
drug. Rank-ordering on overall scores prioritized the reimbursement of the three
drugs. The students were also asked to assess the AHP survey on feasibility. Results:
Nine criteria were identified and categorized in four domains; disease (burden of illness without treatment, life-threatening nature of the disease), drug (availability of
other treatments, effectiveness of the drug, side effects and safety of the drug), financial aspects (annual costs of the drug per patient, budget impact, cost-effectiveness)
and quality of evidence. The criterion ‘life-threatening nature of the disease’ was
given the highest importance weight and budget impact the least. Alglucosidase alfa
for treatment of infantile Pompe disease ranked highest of the three orphan drugs
examined, particularly due to its performance in the disease and drug domains. The
AHP survey was perceived as difficult by the respondents, which was confirmed by
poor values for consistency ratios. Conclusions: Performing MCDA can enable
explicit, transparent and auditable reimbursement decision-making for orphan drugs.
However, its feasibility and applicability needs further investigation.
PSY115
Orphan and Rare Diseases - the Payer Perspective
Spoors J , Rietveld A
RJW & Partners, Royston, UK
.
.
Objectives: To look at the affordability of orphan medications across Europe and
whether payer attitudes to high-price medications are changing in the face of rising
health care expenditure and tighter budgets. Methods: We conducted an online
semi-quantitative survey of 10 European markets and the USA to understand how
payers views and attitudes are changing in response to new treatments coming to
market for rare and ultra-rare conditions. The payers selected for the survey hold
or have held senior positions within their respective market institutions. The USA
was included to provide international context to the European results. Results:
82% of payers surveyed believe that the current approach to orphan drug pricing is
unsustainable in the future and all respondents predict a tougher approach from
payers going forward. 73% of payers do not believe that patent expiry alone will free
up the necessary space for innovative orphan and ultra-orphan products. 82% of the
payers surveyed believed that less than half of all orphan and ultra-orphan drugs
coming to market are supported by an adequate evidence base for reimbursement.
Although payers view rare diseases as a relatively high priority to fund, they are still
behind therapy areas such as oncology and cardiovascular disease. Conclusions:
As the financial performance of European countries begins to diverge, so do attitudes towards the funding of orphan medicines. The increasing number of rare
diseases is forcing payers to view orphan drugs in a new light and they are becoming increasingly sceptical about the prices charged in relation to the clinical benefit
offered. There is space for innovation; and patent expiry is freeing up funds, but rare
diseases are competing with other therapy areas for limited budget. The bottom-line
is that as rare disease spending becomes a higher proportion of pharmaceutical
budgets, payers will take action to curb this trend.
PSY117
Sources of Information and Pharmacists’ Knowledge Regarding
Rare Diseases and Orphan Drugs: Cross-Sectional Study In Serbia
Arsic J 1, Krajnovic D 2, Tasic L 2, Marinkovic V 2, Djordjevic J 3
1Pharmacy Vranje, Vranje, Serbia and Montenegro, 2University of Belgrade – Faculty of Pharmacy,
Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro, 3Alvogen Pharma d. o. o, Serbia, Belgrade, Serbia and
Montenegro
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The lack of information and scientific knowledge of rare diseases (RDs)
and orphan drug (ODs) could affect the quality of health care delivered to patients suffering from rare diseases. The aim of this study was evaluation of the level of the general
epidemiological knowledge among pharmacists regarding RDs and ODs as well as how
that knowledge is influenced by information sources, education level and years of experience. Methods: The research design was based on a descriptive cross-sectional study.
A questionnaire previously used in a pilot KAP study in Serbiain2012 was applied. The
respondents were 182 pharmacists from public pharmacies in seven of 29 districts in
Serbia. Individual level of knowledge was assessed by total number of correct answers
from a maximum of 9, and overall knowledge was an average of the individual level of
knowledge. Results: In total, 155 pharmacists were included in the full analysis set
(response rate was 86.3%). Overall, the mean age was 43.4 years, and 94% were women.
The average number of information sources regarding RD was 1.7%, and mostly one
source out of five was used (56.1%). Pharmacists who were engaged in post-graduate
programmes or completed such programmes tended to use more sources of information
(69.2%) than those who were not involved in any such programme (41.9%). The mean
value of correct answers about pharmacists’ knowledge regarding RD and OD was 4 ±
1.77. Most pharmacists (n = 30, 19.35%) replied correctly to 6 questions. Conclusions:
The results indicate that years of experience and age among pharmacists do not have
influence to the overall knowledge about RD. The positive impact of education was evidently, and for the better pharmaceutical care of RD patients the training of pharmacists
to proper use of professional sources of information should be usefully.
PSY118
Behavior Therapy for Obesity Treatment Considering Approved Drug
Therapy – An Update
Kossmann B 1, Wasem J 2, Buchberger B 1
.
.
.
1-Universität
Duisburg-Essen, Lehrstuhl für Medizinmanagement, Essen, Germany, 2University of
Duisburg-Essen, Essen, Germany
Objectives: Many obesity-associated diseases require intensive medical treatment and are cause of a large proportion of health-related expenditures in
Germany. Treatment of obesity includes nutritional, exercise and behavior therapy, usually in combination. The goal of behavior therapy for obesity is to bring
about a long-term alteration in eating and exercise habits of overweight and obese
individuals. Depending of the severity of obesity, drug treatment may be indicated. To evaluate the clinical and economic effectiveness of behaviour therapy
for obesity considering approved drugs reducing weight, a Health Technology
Assessment was carried out in the year 2008. This HTA was updated with publications up to 12/2013, along with new developments in behavior therapies and
drugs. Methods: A systematic review was carried out using relevant electronic
literature databases Publications chosen according to predefined criteria were
evaluated by approved methodological standards of evidence-based medicine and
health economics systematically and qualitatively. Results: Nine randomized
controlled trials showed moderate but statistically significant reduction of weight
in the intervention groups compared to control groups between 1.1 kg (at month 4)
and 6.6 kg (at month 9). Studies with several examination time points resulted in
statistically significant differences in the first evaluation time point (month 6) but
not in the subsequent time points (month 12, 18, 24). The most frequent approach
used for behavior therapy, was per phone or Email, two studies offered behavior
therapy face-to-face. New behavior therapy approaches applied were techniques
such as “Motivational Interviewing” and “Transtheoretical model”. No study was
identified examining behavior therapy in combination with approved drug therapy.
Two identified studies evaluating cost-effectiveness of behavior therapy per Email
or phone showed cost-effectiveness for this kind of intervention but the results are
biased due to a high rate of drop-outs. Conclusions: Behavior therapy considering new approaches is an effective method to reduce weight.
PSY119
Comparison of Treatment Patterns and Disease Severity Among
Patients With Psoriatic Arthritis (Psa) Receiving Their First Biologic,
Treated By Rheumatologists and Dermatologists In Europe (Eu)
Narayanan S 1, Hautamaki E 1, Lu Y 2, Franceschetti A 2
Healthcare, Columbia, MD, USA, 2Ipsos Healthcare, London, UK
.
.
.
.
1Ipsos
Objectives: To compare rheumatologists and dermatologists in terms of treatment patterns and disease severity among PsA patients receiving their first biologic in 5EU (UK/Germany/France/Italy/Spain). Methods: A medical chart-review
study of psoriasis and PsA patients was conducted among rheumatologists and
dermatologists in hospitals and private practices to collect de-identified data on
disease and treatment characteristics. Physicians were screened for duration of
practice (3-30yrs) and patient volume (≥ 2 Psoriasis/PsA biologic patients/month)
and recruited from a large panel to be geographically representative in each country.
Physicians abstracted charts of the next 5 consecutive Psoriasis/PsA patients in
their respective sites. Treatment patterns and disease severity among PsA patients
on their first line of biologic therapy treated by rheumatologists and dermatologists respectively were compared using descriptive statistics. Results: In Q42012,
337 rheumatologists abstracted 527 PsA patient-charts (mean-age: 47.4yrs, male:
51.4%) and 225 dermatologists abstracted charts of 109 psoriasis patients with PsA
(mean-age: 49.0yrs, male: 56.0%; 55.1% were managed in conjunction with a rheumatologist; 67% were referred by GP/another dermatologist). Time to first biologic
since diagnosis was 41.0mo/20.8mo for the rheumatologist/dermatologist-treated
cohorts; disease severity at biologic initiation per physician judgment was (mild/
moderate/severe): rheumatologist-treated-cohort: 2.7%/60.2%/37.2%, dermatologisttreated-cohort: 1.96%/46.08%/ 51.96%. In rheumatologist-treated-cohort: treatment
naïve-12.9%, non-biological DMARDS-experienced: 74.0%; in dermatologist-treated
cohort: treatment nainve-6.5%, 1-or-2 systemic-treatment-experienced prior to their
first biologic-initiation: 69.5%. 38.7%/61.3% and 27.5%/72.5% had moderate-severe/
remission-mild disease-status among rheumatologist- and dermatologist-treated
cohort respectively. Average current PASI score was higher among rheumatologisttreated-cohort (18.7 vs. 10.3). Conclusions: Across the EU5, PsA treatment patterns and disease severity varied based on physician specialty (rheumatologist vs.
dermatologist); at biologic initiation dermatologists reported a significantly higher
proportion of moderate/severe PsA patients than rheumatologists, but once first
biologic treatment was well established dermatologists reported a lower disease
burden then rheumatologists. Factors influencing these observed variations, including optimal therapeutic approaches and care coordination between specialties to
alleviate patient burden may warrant further scrutiny.
PSY120
Variations In Treatment Patterns and Disease Severity Among
Patients With Psoriasis Receiving Their First Biologic Therapy In
Europe (Eu)
Narayanan S 1, Franceschetti A 2
Healthcare, Columbia, MD, USA, 2Ipsos Healthcare, London, UK
.
.
1Ipsos
Objectives: To assess treatment patterns and disease severity of psoriasis patients
receiving their first biologic-therapy in EU. Methods: A medical chart-review study
of psoriasis patients was conducted in 4Q2013 in EU5 (UK/Germany/France/Italy/
Spain) among dermatologists to collect de-identified data on disease/treatment
characteristics. Physicians were screened for duration-of-practice (3-30yrs) and
patient-volume (≥ 2psoriasis biologic patients/month) and recruited from a large
panel to be geographically representative in each country. Physicians abstracted the
charts of next 5 consecutive psoriasis patients in their center/practice. Results from
patients on their first biologic treatment were analyzed and comparisons made to
EU5-averages. Results: 877 patient-charts were abstracted; 702 (80.0%) were on
their first biologic (mean age: 47.3yrs, male: 64.1%). Prior to initiating biologic therapy, immunomodulators/phototherapy were more widely used in UK than in other
countries (90.3%/43.1% vs. 76.6%/30.4% overall, respectively); in Germany, fumarates/
A543
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
corticosteroids were more widely used (46.5%/26.8% vs. 12.3%/11.0%) and retinoids
were less commonly used (5.1% vs. 18.0%). UK physicians were less likely to prescribe a biologic-treatment before trying >=1 other systemic-treatment (1.8% vs. 8.5%),
and to wait longer after diagnosis to initiate biologic-therapy (25.8movs. 20.1mo);
in Germany, patients were more likely to have tried 3-5 other systemic-treatments
before initiating biologic-treatment (28.0% vs. 14.2%); patients in France were the most
likely to initiate a biologic without trying another systemic-treatment first (11.2% vs.
8.5%). Patients in Germany were started on biologics later on average (25.8mo after
diagnosis vs. 14.0mo). The average flares in past-year was highest in Germany (1.4
vs. 0.9). Average current PASI-score (26.4 vs. 16.0) and BSA-score (22.8 vs. 19.5) were
highest in Germany. In France, 41.2% of patients had not had a PASI score done past
year (vs. 23.3%). In Germany, 56.0% of patients had severe/terminal disease severity
at biologic-therapy-initiation (vs. 47.8%). Conclusions: Among psoriasis patients
receiving their first biologic-therapy, treatment patterns and disease severity varied
across the EU5. Factors influencing the observed variations in treatment patterns and
outcomes warrant further scrutiny to decrease patient disease burden.
PSY121
Apoptosis and Oxidative Stress Induced By Exposure of Microwave
Radiation In Rat Thymus: Modulatory Effect of Melatonin
Sokolovic D 1, Sokolovic D M 2
of Nis, Faculty of Medicine, Nis, Serbia and Montenegro, 2Institute for Blood
Transfusion in Nis, Nis, Serbia and Montenegro
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: Exposition to microwave radiation (MW), from mobile phones, satellite
communications, radio relays, radars and microwave devices in medicine induce
disturbances in thymus. The pineal secretory product, melatonin (Mel), exerts a
veriety of effects on the immune system. The aim of the present study was to
evaluate the effect of melatonin on apoptosis and oxidative stress parametars in
thymus tissue of rats after 40 days long exposure to MWs. Methods: Wister rats
were divided in 4 experimental groups: I (control), II (Mel group) - rats treated with
Mel every day (2 mg/kg b.w., i.p), III (MW group) - rats exposed to MW (4 h/day), IV
(MW+Mel) - rats treated with Mel every day (2 mg/kg b.w., i.p) and exposed to MW
radiation (4 h/day). Ten animals from 4 group were successively sacrificed after 40
days of the experiment. MW was produced by a mobile test phone (SAR = 0.0430.135 W/kg). Results: The current study results demonstrate that MW significantly
increased thymocyte apoptosis, detected using the Annexin V-FITC/PI detection kit
(p< 0.001). DNA fragmentation in thymocytes injury of MW is probably triggered by
the increase activation of alkaline-DNase I (caspase 3-activated) and acid-DNase II
(p< 0.05). A significant increase in the thymus malondialdehyde (MDA) and carbonyl
group concentration (p< 0.001), and decreased activity of catalase (p< 0.001) was
registered during exposure. Melatonin was found to be effective on rat thymocyte:
(1) decreased apoptotic rate of thymocytes (p< 0.001), (2) effect on terminal apoptotic reaction, because of the decrease DNase I and DNase II activity (p< 0.01), (3)
decreased MDA and carbonyl group levels (p< 0.01), (4) increase activity of catalase
(p<0.05), comparated with MW group. Conclusions: Having in the mind obtained
results we can conclude that melatonine exerts protective effects on rat thymocyte
by preventing apoptosis and oxidative stress disturbances in rats’ thymus under
exposure of MW.
RESEARCH POSTER PRESENTATIONS - SESSION IV
RESEARCH ON Methods STUDIES
RESEARCH ON METHODS – Clinical Outcomes Methods
PRM1
Symtomatic Factors in Patients With Major Depressive Disorder
(MDD): Results from an Observational Study
Novick D 1, Montgomery W 2, Aguado J 3, Dueñas H 4, Haro J M 5
Lilly Holdings Limited, Windlesham, UK, 2Eli Lilly Australia, Sydney, Australia, 3Parc Sanitari
Sant Joan de Deu, CIBERSAM, Sant Boi de Llobregat, Spain, 4Eli Lilly de Mexico, Mexico City,
Mexico, 5Parc Sanitari Sant Joan de Déu, CIBERSAM, Universitat de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Eli
Objectives: To explore the existence and clinical implications of symptomatic
factors in patients with major depressive episodes. Methods: Data are from a
6-month prospective, non-interventional, observational study that included 1,549
MDD patients without sexual dysfunction in twelve countries. Depression severity
was measured using the Clinical Global Impression (CGI) and the 16-item Quick
Inventory of Depressive Symptomatology Self-Report (QIDS-SR16). Pain and quality of life were measured using the pain related items of the Somatic Symptom
Inventory (SSI) and the EuroQoL-5D, respectively. The QIDS-SR16and the SSI items
were jointly included in a factor analysis. Exploratory factor analysis (EFA) was
conducted in a randomly selected half of the sample and confirmatory factor
analysis (CFA) in the remaining half. Results: The EFA showed that a four factor
model explained the data apropriately (RMSEA 0.041, 90%CI 0.034- 0.048; CFI 0.979).
The four factors were mood (feeling sad, concentration/decision making, self criticism, suicidal thoughts, interest in people or activities, energy/fatigability, psychomotor retardation and agitation); sleep (initial, middle insomnia, early awakening
and sleeping too much); appetite and weight, and pain (muscle soreness, cramps in
abdomen, pain in lower back, pain in heart or chest, pain in joints, neck pain, headache). The CFA showed good fit indexes for this four-factor model (RMSA 0.054, 90%
CI 0.049-0.059; CFI 0.954). There was a highly statistical significant correlation (Spearman) between each of the four factors and CGI severity score and
quality of life at each of the visits, with higher scores in the factors (higher
severity) associated with higher CGI and lower quality of life (p< 0.001, all comparisons). Conclusions: Considering the results presented, the data reasonably support that pain symptoms be included in the evaluation of patients with
major depression. More severe pain symptoms are associated to higher severity
of depression and lower quality of life.
PRM2
Predictors of Functional Disability in Patients With Chronic
Lumbosacral Radicular Pain
Kanukula R 1, Bansal D 2, Ghai B 3
Institute of Pharmaceuitical Education and Research, Punjab, India, 2National Institute
of Pharmaceuitical Education and Research, Mohali, India, 3Postgraduate Institute of Medical
Education and Research, Chandigarh, India
.
.
.
1National
Objectives: Chronic lumbosacral radicular pain has significant morbidity and burden
to the society. The objective of this study was to assess the functional disability and
factors affecting it in patients with chronic lumbosacral radicular pain. Methods: We
performed an observational cross sectional study in a public tertiary care hospital in
north India. Adult patients (18 and 75 years), with >12 weeks of low back pain, without
any co-morbidities were included in this study. Data regarding socio-demographics,
duration of low back pain, prescribing pattern and depression collected at baseline.
Pain assessed using visual analogue scale (VAS), functional disability using modified
oswesrty disability questionnaire (MODQ). Patients also asked for health care utilization at the end of study. Predictors of high disability were analysed using multivariate
regression analysis. Results: A total of 246 patients (51% males and 49% females) with
mean age of 44.9 (12.25) years were included for final analysis. Mean VAS and MODQ
scores at baseline are 72.3+12.5 and 48.3+11.2 respectively. Based on disability scores,
62% of patients found to be crippled whereas 62% and 24% of patients fall in severe
and moderate disability category respectively. VAS and MODQ scores were positively
correlated (r=0.84, p<0.05). Multi factorial analysis reveals that severe pain (higher
VAS scores), high duration of pain, older age, over-weight, patients from urban region
and depression were significantly associated with high disability. Conclusions:
Our study results suggest that chronic lumbosacral radicular pain patients suffer with
sever disability. Severity of pain was significantly correlated with levels of disability.
PRM3
Hierarchical Network Meta-Analysis Incorporating Ordering
Constraints on Increasing Doses of Interventions - Application to
Overactive Bladder Syndrome
Owen R K , Tincello D G , Bujkiewicz S , Abrams K
University of Leicester, Leicester, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
Background: For the conservative treatment of Overactive Bladder (OAB)
symptoms, the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) in the
UK currently recommends a course of supervised pelvic floor muscle training,
behavioural therapy, anticholinergic medication, sacral nerve stimulation, and
more recently, botulinum toxin type A (BoNTA) and Mirabegron. Given the large
number of interventions and relatively few primary trials, network meta-analyses (NMAs) produce considerable uncertainty in the estimated treatment effects
and consequently, there is little evidence of the most clinically effective intervention. Objectives: To evaluate the use of hierarchical NMAs incorporating
ordering constraints on increasing doses in order to identify the most effective
intervention for the treatment of OAB symptoms. Methods: Using Bayesian
Markov Chain Monte Carlo methods, we apply a 3-level hierarchical NMA that
accounts for both the correlation between treatments within the same class, as
well as the residual between-study heterogeneity. We further extend this model
to incorporate ordering constraints on increasing doses of the same intervention. We apply the methods to a dataset obtained from a systematic literature
review of randomised controlled trials evaluating interventions for OAB syndrome.
The primary outcomes of interest were mean change from baseline for voiding, urgency, and incontinence episodes. Results: The dataset includes 78 trials
comparing 39 interventions that can be further categorised into 10 classes of
interventions, including placebo. For voiding, and urgency episodes, BoNTA 200u
was the most effective intervention with estimated mean reduction of -2.24 (95%
CrI: -2.95, -1.48), and -2.6 (95% CrI: -3.46, -1.7) episodes relative to placebo, respectively. BoNTA 300u was the most effective intervention for reducing incontinence
episodes with an estimated mean reduction of -1.81 (95% CrI: -2.39, -1.33) episodes relative to placebo. Conclusions: Use of hierarchical NMAs, incorporating
ordering constraints, increases the precision in the effect estimates but maintains
the interpretability of individual interventions. BoNTA was found to be the most
effective intervention for reducing symptoms of OAB.
PRM4
Treatment Effect Heterogeneity in Clinical Trials: An Evaluation
of 13 Large Clinical Trials Using Individual Patient Data
Kent D M 1, Nelson J 1, Altman D G 2, Hayward R A 3
Medical Center/Tufts University School of Medicine, Boston, MA, USA, 2University of
Oxford, Oxford OX2 6UD, UK, 3University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Tufts
Objectives: Using randomized clinical trials (RCTs) for clinical decision-making
necessitates making decisions for individuals based on average treatment effects.
While many assume important patient variation in treatment effects, identifying
patients most likely to benefit is problematic. Stratifying patients by their risk
of the primary outcome was proposed as a method to identify high versus low
benefit patients. Methods: From publically available sources, we identified 13
large RCTs with greater than ~1000 enrollees and overall statistically significant
results. We derived Cox or logistic regression models using established risk factors blinded to treatment assignment and stratified the patient population into
quartiles of risk for the outcome. Treatment effect within each risk quartile was
estimated on relative and absolute scales. Heterogeneity of treatment effect (HTE)
was evaluated statistically by testing for an interaction between treatment and
the linear predictor of risk, and by comparing hazard (or odds) ratios and absolute risk reduction in the extreme risk quartiles. Results: Among 19 unique
treatment comparisons analyzed, there was no apparent relationship between
baseline risk and the hazard (or odds) ratios across trials; only 1 of 19 analyses
had a significant interaction between treatment and baseline risk on the proportional scale. The difference in the log hazard ratio between the extreme risk
quartiles ranged from -0.89 to 0.60 (median= 0.03; inter-quartile range (IQR) = -0.4-
A544
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
0.2). However, absolute risk reduction was generally higher in high risk strata,
ranging from -1.4 to 18.3% (median= 4.6%; IQR= 0.8-6.1%) in quartile one and from
0.8 to 35.0% (median= 11.5%; IQR= 3.3-19.8%) in quartile four. The difference in
the absolute risk reduction between the extreme risk quartile ranged from -3.2 to
28.3% (median= 7.7%; IQR= 0.3-11.3). Conclusions: Clinically significant HTE is
common even in phase 3 “efficacy” trials on the absolute scale. A multivariate risk
stratified approach to subgroup analysis is feasible and often clinically informative
when assessing treatment efficacy.
PRM5
Non-Treatment Specific Parameter Value Estimates: Relationship
Between BMI and Utility
Halfpenny N J A 1, Quigley J M 1, Donatti C 2, Hawkins N S 1
Health Economics, Oxford, UK, 2Janssen-Cilag UK, High Wycombe, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1ICON
Objectives: Cost-effectiveness models are an important component of health
economic evaluation. In addition to estimates of treatment effects (typically
estimated for RCTs), cost-effectiveness estimates may be sensitive to estimates of
non-treatment specific parameters that describe the relationship between model
variables. These may be estimated from epidemiological studies that themselves
include covariable adjustment in order to account for potential confounding. We use
the example of the estimated relationship between BMI and utility as to illustrate
methods for the review meta-analysis of parameter estimates arising from multiple studies and issues around the selection of appropriate estimates. Methods:
A targeted search was carried out in MEDLINE and EMBASE for studies with utility
data on BMI. The outcome was utility change per unit increase in BMI. Study characteristics recorded included the utility instrument used, study location, diabetes status and number of covariates. Fixed and random effects models as well as graphical
methods were used to investigate the influence of study characteristics. Results:
Several utility scales were used throughout with some using multiple utility scales
within the study to assess quality of life. EQ5-D and SF-6D were the most commonly used utility scales. Using a random effects model we observed a change
in utility per unit increase in BMI of -0.0054 [-0.0077; -0.0031]. However there was
significant heterogeneity between studies. The number of covariates ranged greatly
between the studies and appeared predictive of the magnitude of effect of BMI on
utility. Conclusions: We illustrate methods for meta-analysing multiple parameter estimates and discuss the selection of appropriate parameter estimates for the
inclusion in cost-effectiveness models. In particular we illustrate the relationship
between the selection of appropriate parameter estimates in terms of which covariables were included in the originating studies and the cost-effectiveness model
structure in terms of which independent causal effects are modelled.
PRM6
Comparison Of Iqwig and G-BA Benefit Ratings in Oncology
Schuchardt M 1, Khoury C 2, Friedmann B 3, Haigh J 4
1Quintiles Consulting, Hoofddorp, The Netherlands, 2Quintiles Consulting, Neu-Isenburg,
Germany, 3Quintiles Commercial, Mannheim, Germany, 4Quintiles Consulting, Reading, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: This research was conducted to understand key reasons why the G-BA
came to a different benefit rating than IQWiG during oncology HTAs. Methods:
Searching the G-BA and IQWiG homepages, oncology HTAs between 1st of January
2011 and 31st of December 2013 have been identified. Assessments for which the
G-BA attested a benefit rating divergent from the one proposed by IQWiG have been
analyzed to reveal the key reasons for difference. Results: In the observed time
frame, 18 HTAs of oncology products have been conducted by IQWiG and G-BA in
Germany. IQWiG and G-BA were aligned in their benefit ratings in 14 reports (78%).
During four assessments (22%) the G-BA came to a different conclusion than IQWiG.
These are the assessments of crizotinib, eribulin, pertuzumab and the resubmission
for vandentanib. One reason for different ratings observed in three assessments
is that the G-BA looked at time-adjusted analyses to correct for different lengths
of treatment in the trial arms. The extend of benefit that is extracted from the
same data also potentially differs. This is exemplified by the case of vandentanib,
where the G-BA was more convinced by the data on “time to worsening of pain”
than IQWiG and attested a “minor benefit” (as compared to “no added benefit”).
In the case of eribulin, G-BA and IQWiG agreed on benefit based on survival data.
Due to the potential side effects however, G-BA demoted to “minor”, while IQWiG
initially demoted to “no added benefit”. Conclusions: The translation of clinical
evidence into a benefit rating and weighing of positive versus negative effects is
highly complex. We see that G-BA and IQWiG can come to different conclusions. In
all cases it is important that the manufacturer shows evidence against the specified comparator. The benefit rating plays an important role in the reimbursement
amount negotiations.
PRM7
Survival Status in (Pharmaco) Epidemiological Studies can be
Successfully Investigated Using Administrative Residential
Registries
Potthoff P , Eichmann F , Klamert A
Kantar Health Germany, Munich, Germany
.
.
.
Objectives: Study subject survival is a key outcome and endpoint in pharmacoepidemiological studies. When participants in long-term studies drop out, administrative residential registries can be a useful source to investigate subjects’ vital status.
The present contribution reports procedures and results of vital status inquiries
in German administrative residential databases. A pharmacoepidemiological and
an environmental exposure study are used as case studies. Methods: For both
case studies, residential addresses of study participants were submitted to the
responsible official residential register with the purpose of collecting information
about vital status or – in case of address changes – the new address was collected.
For persons with multiple address changes up to 7 inquiry loops were necessary
until vital status could be ascertained. Results: In the environmental case study
assessing effects of an urban chemical accident, 20.170 addresses of German citizens
(5.574 exposed and 14.596 not-exposed) were submitted to residential registries.
The vital status of 96,6% of the study subjects could be confirmed by information
of the registries. 80,7% were still alive 15 years after the accident (81% exposed, 80%
not-exposed). 24,6% had died from cancer, 40,9% from cardiovascular diseases and
31,8% from other causes of death. No effects of the exposure on the vital status
could be determined (Cox-Regression). In the pharmacoepidemiological case study
evaluating long term safety of hormone replacement therapy, the survival status of
2.485 participants was investigated in country-wide residential databases. The vital
status of 90,8% these participants could be confirmed using the registry information.
2.250 were still alive after 4-5 years of inclusion into the study, only 6 deaths were
identified and for only 9% the status could not be determined. Conclusions:
Official residential registries can be a valuable source for investigating the survival
status and the causes of death of study subjects in pharmaco- and general epidemiological studies.
PRM8
Recruiting Myelofibrosis Patients for Clinical and Health Outcome
Studies Using Managed Physician Panels in 5 EU Countries
Eichmann F 1, Potthoff P 1, Brown C 2, Cholmakow-Bodechtel C 1
Health Germany, Munich, Germany, 2All Global, London, UK
.
.
.
.
1Kantar
Objectives: Myelofibrosis (MF) is a chronic blood cancer with an estimated prevalence in the US population of 4-5 patients per 100.000 inhabitants. Among the
sources to recruit MF patients for post-approval studies in a real life environment,
oncological or cardiological sites are of primary importance. The objective of the
present contribution is to assess the number of MF patients in these specialties
and the willingness of the physicians to enroll MF patients for clinical and health
outcomes studies. Methods: In 2011, a feasibility survey assessing the incidence
of MF patients in the sites of 94 oncologists, 72 hematologists and 65 cardiologists in
5 EU countries (UK, GER, FR, IT, ES) was run, using the All Global managed physician
panel. The willingness of these specialist groups to participate in clinical and health
outcomes studies and to recruit patients for these studies was estimated among
335 oncologists/hematologists and 208 cardiologists. Results: 88% of the oncologists and 99% of the hematologists treat Myelofibrosis patients (88% oncologists;
99% hematologists). Cardiologists are involved in MF treatment to a smaller degree
(75%). In 25% of all practices, less than 10 patients are treated per year, in 36%, 11
to 50 patients, and in 38%, more than 50. Approximately 90% of the oncologists/
hematologists and 88% of the cardiologists are experienced in clinical and health
outcomes studies; 80% of the oncologists/hematologists and 60% of the cardiologists are willing to participate in future studies and 92% resp. 94% in this group
are willing to enroll patients for clinical and health outcome studies, including
management of informed consent and ethics procedures as required for the study
type. Conclusions: Myelofibrosis patients can be successfully recruited for clinical and health outcomes studies using managed panels. Oncologists/hematologists
and cardiologists are experienced in these study types and willing to participate
in future studies.
PRM9
Can Gastric Cancer Patients be Successfully Recruited for Clinical
Phase III/IV and Health Outcome Studies Using Managed Physician
Panels?
Eichmann F 1, Potthoff P 2, Brown C 3
Health, Munich, Germany, 2Kantar Health Germany, Munich, Germany, 3All Global,
London, UK
.
.
.
1Kantar
Objectives: Gastric cancer (GC) is a cancer arising from parts of the stomach. To
recruit GC patients for post-approval studies in a real world environment, oncological, hematological, and internist sites might be of primary importance. The present
contribution assesses the number of GC patients in these sites and the willingness
of physicians to enroll GC patients for health outcome or clinical phase III/IV studies.
Methods: In 2011 a feasibility study about the number of GC patients was run
in the sites of 63 oncologists, 23 hemato-oncologists and 26 internists in UK (16),
GER (19), FR (11), IT (27), ES (27), and US (12). Physicians reported about the number
of “new patients with unresectable, locally advanced or metastatic gastric or gastroesophageal junction (GEJ) adenocarcinoma”. The willingness of these specialist
groups to participate in clinical phase III/IV or health outcome studies was also
estimated in a different survey. Results: In total these 112 specialists have seen
approximately 3,200 new gastric cancer patients in the last 6 months. In average
(median values) oncologists have seen 30 new gastric cancer patients in 6 months,
hematologists 20 patients and internists 6 patients. Most of the patients (2,600) have
been treated with chemotherapy. Approximately 90% of the oncologists/hematologists and 88% of the cardiologists are experienced in clinical phase III/IV or health
outcome studies; 80% of the oncologists/hematologists and 60% of the cardiologists
are willing to participate in future studies and 92% resp. 94% in this group are willing
to enroll patients for clinical phase III/IV or health outcome studies and ask them for
written informed consent. Conclusions: Patients suffering from Gastric Cancer
can be successfully recruited for clinical phase III/IV or health outcome studies
using managed panels. Oncologists/hematologists and cardiologists are usually
experienced in these studies.
PRM10
Assessing the Relationship Between Treatment Effect and Baseline
Risk in Network Meta-Analsysis of Moderate to Severe CHRONIC
Plaque Psoriasis Trials
Smiechowski B 1, Cope S 2
1Mapi, Boston, MA, USA, 2Mapi, Toronto, ON, Canada
.
.
Objectives: To investigate differences across randomized controlled trials (RCTs)
evaluating biological therapies for the treatment of moderate to severe chronic
plaque psoriasis in terms of baseline risk in psoriasis area severity index score (PASI)
and the association with treatment effects by means of network meta-analysis
(NMA). Methods: 25 RCTs reporting the proportion of patients experiencing a
A545
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
75% improvement from baseline in PASI (PASI 75) at the end of the trial were identified from two recently published NMAs focused on the efficacy of biologics in the
treatment of moderate to severe psoriasis based on a systematic literature review.
Differences in baseline risk of PASI 75 were explored graphically. The association
between the treatment effect of 19 different biologics and baseline risk of PASI
75 with placebo was assessed by conducting a Bayesian NMA with baseline risk
covariate adjustment using a model assuming a constant treatment by covariate
interaction, and a normal distribution for baseline risk. The model also allowed for
the baseline risk adjustment of RCTs that did not include a placebo arm. Results:
Across the RCTs, PASI 75 at the end of the trial period for patients in the placebo arm
ranged from 2% to 19%. The coefficient for baseline risk was a median of -0.33 (95%
credible intervals: -0.79, 0.21) which suggested baseline risk was not significantly
associated with the proportion achieving PASI 75 across the RCTs. Conclusions:
Based on a NMA of RCTs regarding the efficacy of biologics in terms of PASI 75, it
is unclear if baseline risk of PASI 75 acts as a treatment effect modifier. Further
analyses are required to assess whether baseline risk may explain differences in
the classes of biological therapies used to treatment moderate to severe psoriasis.
PRM11
Riding the E-Publication Wave
Quigley J M , Thompson J C , Halfpenny N , Scott D A , Hawkins N S
ICON Health Economics, Oxford, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Submissions to Health Technology Assessment (HTA) bodies must
include the most up-to-date information on comparator technologies. This enables HTA bodies to make fully informed decisions. In order to ensure up-to-date
information is obtained, all relevant data sources should be searched. At present
HTA method guidelines generally specify that a core set of databases comprising
EMBASE, MEDLINE, MEDLINE-in-process and the Cochrane Library are searched.
However, in an attempt to manage the increasing quantity of research, journals
are publishing more articles ahead of print as online e-publications. E-publications
ahead of print are identifiable in PubMed but are not indexed in EMBASE, MEDLINE
or Cochrane. Methods: We selected a NICE guideline published in June 2014 for
ablation techniques in atrial fibrillation which searched for randomised clinical trials (RCT) in the common databases. We updated the searches in EMBASE,
MEDLINE, MEDLINE-in-process and the Cochrane Library from the date of the last
search, to identify any studies published since the guideline was published. We
concurrently searched PubMed using a filter to identify studies only available as
e-publications ahead of print. Results: We identified one RCT meeting the inclusion criteria that was retrieved by the search in PubMed but was not identified by
searching in EMBASE, MEDLINE or Cochrane (all searches being run on the same
date). Conclusions: If studies are missed from systematic reviews there can be
important implications on clinical efficacy comparisons. To produce the most upto-date systematic review, with all available full papers it is necessary to search
for e-publications ahead of print in PubMed as well as for all other publications in
EMBASE, MEDLINE and Cochrane.
PRM12
Individualised Growth Response Optimisation (IGRO): A MultiLanguage Software Medical Device to Predict Growth Response in
Children Treated With Growth Hormone (GH)
Loftus J 1, Lindberg A 2, Aydin F 2, Rawlings F 3, Ranke M 4, Camacho-Hubner C 5
1Pfizer Ltd, Tadworth, UK, 2Pfizer, Sollentuna, Sweden, 3Pfizer Inc, Collegeville, PA, USA,
4University Children’s Hospital, Tuebingen, Germany, 5Pfizer Inc, New York, NY, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To produce a modern, accessible, quick and intuitive growth prediction
tool in which growth prediction models (GPMs) were clinically validated. Methods:
GPMs support physicians to optimise and monitor GH treatment and response. They
are validated, providing accurate predictions of growth response following GH treatment in children with idiopathic growth hormone deficiency (IGHD), Turner syndrome (TS) and short children born small for gestational age (SGA). By using GPMs,
realistic expectations of treatment outcomes are conveyed to patients and parents
(important as children respond differently to treatment). A modern platform, a
website, will host iGRO; the software should ensure web browser compatibility in
European endocrine clinics. An internal paediatric endocrinologist robustly tested
the GPMs. User acceptance testing (UAT) for acceptability and usability was conducted with external paediatric endocrinologists. These outputs contribute to the
Class I medical device Technical File; a requirement for iGRO. Results: The clinical
validation performed under simulated conditions using the final medical device
software passed, consistent with regulatory expectations. GPMs for IGHD, SGA, TS
were tested for prediction accuracy. Validation acceptance criteria and test results
were included in the test script records. UAT was designed and executed following
a rigorous software development lifecycle methodology to ensure completeness
of the tool and the specified business and user requirements. UAT was certified
through role based testing scenarios (requirements and processes for daily use). The
tool, accessed via a secure password protected website, was easily navigated and
provided a clear interface requiring little training. Data entry was quick and growth
outcomes (i.e. graphical comparisons between patient’s actual growth response and
one-year predictions) were easily viewed. Conclusions: iGRO, an accessible webbased software medical device, provides accurate growth prediction which enable
physicians to monitor patients’ response to GH treatment. It may potentially be
used to detect discrepancies early.
PRM13
Strengthening Evidence Base for Traditional Medicine in Asean,
Quality of Reporting of Randomised Controlled Trials of Herbal
Interventions in Asean Plus Six Countries: A Systematic Review
Pratoomsoot C 1, Sruamsiri R 2, Dilokthornsakul P 2, Chaiyakunapruk N 3
1Discipline of Applied Thai Traditional Medicine, Faculty of Public Health, Naresuan University,
Phitsanulok, Thailand, 2Department of Pharmacy Practice, Faculty of Pharmaceutical Sciences,
Naresuan University, Phitsanulok, Thailand, 3Monash University Malaysia, Selangor, Malaysia
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Traditional Medicine and the use of herbal interventions are regarded
as an integral part of health care among countries of Association of Southeast Asian
Nations (ASEAN). To date numerous randomised controlled trials (RCTs) of herbal
interventions have been conducted within ASEAN. It is recognised that good quality reporting of RCTs is crucial to the assessment of clinical significance. ASEAN
has placed strong emphasis on the facilitation of research in Traditional Medicine,
especially in the strengthening of evidence base for herbal medicines. The objective
of this study was to systematically review the quality of reporting of RCTs of herbal
interventions conducted in ASEAN Plus Six Countries. Methods: Searches were
performed using PubMed, EMBASE and MEDLINE, The Cochrane Library, and Allied
and Complementary Medicine (AMED), from inception through October 2013. The
following limits were applied: Human; RCTs. Herbal species search terms were
based on those listed in the National List of Essential Medicines [NLEM (Thailand,
2011)]. Studies conducted in ASEAN Plus Six Countries, published in English were
included. Quality of reporting was assessed according to the 22-item Elaborated
CONSORT statement for reporting RCTs of herbal interventions. Results: Seventyone articles were identified, of which thirty RCTs (42.25%) were conducted in ASEAN
Countries, whereas 41 RCTs (57.75%) were from the Plus Six Group. Adherence to
the recommended CONSORT checklist items for reporting of RCTs of herbal interventions among ASEAN Plus Six Countries ranged from 0% to 97.18%. Less than
half of the RCTs reported methods used to generate random sequence allocation
(item 8,47.89%), and implement random allocation sequence (item 9 allocation concealment, 29.58%). Less than a quarter of RCTs (18.31%) reported information on
standardisation of herbal products. Conclusions: The present study highlighted
the need to improve reporting quality of RCTs of herbal interventions across ASEAN
Plus Six Communities.
PRM14
Endpoints in Pain: the Suitability for Health Economic Evaluation
of Endpoint Designs in Chronic Pain Studies
Rycroft C 1, Hirst M 2, Dunlop W 2, Pirk O 3, Mullins C D 4, Akehurst R 5
International Limited, Cambridge, UK, 3Olaf Pirk
Consult, Nürnberg, Germany, 4University of Maryland School of Pharmacy, Baltimore, MD, USA,
5University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1BresMed, Sheffield, UK, 2Mundipharma
Objectives: A wide range of instruments are used to measure outcomes in clinical
studies of chronic pain. However, the suitability of study outcomes for economic
evaluations in chronic pain is limited by variability in the instruments used and
the failure of those that are in common use to adequately capture the dimensions
of a patient’s experience of pain, including function, quality of life and tolerability.
The current study aims to identify the pain instruments and study endpoints most
commonly used in the clinical trial setting. Methods: A structured, comprehensive
literature review of ongoing registered trials (trial registries) and published clinical studies (PubMed) in the areas of chronic pain (cancer, non-cancer and neuropathic), pain in elderly patients, and breakthrough pain was conducted. Inclusion
criteria were: interventional study, pain population of interest and pain measured
within primary endpoint. Data were extracted from identified publications focusing on primary and secondary endpoints reported, and primary pain instrument
used. Results: Of 1,256 citations retrieved, 132 were included as they reported
large clinical studies in pain populations. The majority of primary endpoints were
pure pain measures (112), most commonly: numerical rating scale (NRS) (44), visual
analogue scale (VAS) (34), and brief pain inventory (BPI) (18). Other outcome domains
were typically limited to secondary endpoints and were not consistently applied
across the studies. These include measures of function (47), quality of life (36),
safety/tolerability (33), emotional wellbeing (26) and sleep (20). Conclusions:
The majority of studies still use simple pain measures as their primary outcomes.
Useful economic outcomes such as quality of life and function are relegated to
secondary endpoints and are inconsistently used. Types of pain instruments currently used in registered, ongoing trials will also be reported. Further research is
needed to consider which existing endpoint designs constitute best practise and
if new designs are required.
PRM15
Comparative Real World Effectiveness of Novel Agents Versus
Conventional Therapies in Multiple Myeloma Patients in Sweden
Thilakarathne P 1, Diels J 2, van Sanden S 3, Liwing J 4, Van Agthoven M 5, Chirita O 6, Nahi H 7
1Janssen Pharmaceutica N. V., Beerse, Belgium, 2Janssen Research & Development, Beerse,
Belgium, 3EMEA HEMAR Analytics, Janssen EMEA, Beerse, Belgium, 4Janssen-Cilag AB,
Sollentuna, Sweden, 5Janssen-Cilag BV, Tilburg, The Netherlands, 6Janssen, High Wycombe, UK,
7Karolinska University Hospital, Solna, Sweden
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Comparing outcomes between different treatments based on real
world evidence can be challenging, first because of confounding due to lack of randomization at treatment initiation, and secondly due to selection bias induced by
selective treatment switching. To account for both sources of bias, we explored the
Inverse probability of censoring weights analysis (IPCW) to account for this bias on
a retrospective dataset of multiple myeloma patients in Sweden. Methods: IPCWapproach was used to additionally adjust for bias induced by selective treatment
switching in 2 steps. First, time-varying weights were estimated using multivariate
logistic regression, including age, gender, stage, M-protein type, creatinine-clearance
as baseline covariates and M-protein as time-varying covariate. Secondly, these
time-dependent weights were incorporated in a proportional hazards model, including treatment and baseline characteristics, with patients censored at initiation of
subsequent therapy. ITT-estimates were generated based on multivariate proportional hazards model, including the same baseline covariates. Results: In the total
MM population (n= 1638), the non-transplant population was 1125, of which 31%
(n= 349) received novel therapies (bortezomib, lenalidomide and thalidomide based)
while 69% had conventional therapies in frontline. Mean age was 71/75 respectively.
The mean baseline serum m-protein level was 30.9 g/L for both groups. The ITT HR in
frontline was 0.56 [0.45, 0.70] and IPCW-adjusted HR is 0.31 [0.22, 0.42]. ITT vs IPCWbased HR for 2nd and 3rd line of therapy were 0.71 [0.58, 0.87] vs 0.667 [0.487, 0.914]
A546
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
and 0.87 [0.68, 1.11] vs 0.655 [0.455, 0.944], respectively. Conclusions: This analysis
shows the improved survival of patients who received novel therapies as compared
to conventional therapies, across the different therapy lines. Additionally, results
illustrate the impact of selection bias induced by selective treatment switching, and
the need to apply novel approaches as IPCW to make additional adjustments, for
which traditional statistical techniques cannot be used for.
PRM16
Comparing the Use of Patient-Level Data to An Average Patient
Profile Within a Type 2 Diabetes Simulation Model
McEwan P 1, Bennett H 2, Ward T 2, Bergenheim K 3
Economics and Outcomes Research Ltd, Cardiff, UK, 2Health Economics and Outcomes
Research Ltd, Monmouth, UK, 3AstraZeneca, Mölndal, Sweden
.
.
.
.
1Health
Objectives: Despite significant patient heterogeneity and complex treatment
pathways, averages are commonly relied upon when defining patient populations
and treatment effects within type 2 diabetes modeling. As a result, clinicians may
struggle to relate results to the clinical setting. This study compares outcomes
when using patient-level and average cohort inputs within a published simulation
model, based on the UKPDS68 outcomes equations. Methods: UK patient data
(2,251 patients initiating dual therapy) were obtained from The Health Improvement
Network (THIN). Simulations, performed over a medium-term horizon of 20 years,
utilised either patient-level data, collating outputs over all replications, or average
cohort data. The outputs (total costs, benefits and complication rates) were then
compared. Results: Average baseline characteristics were: age: 63.36 (±11.14) years;
HbA1c: 8.39% (±1.23); total cholesterol: 4.18 (±0.92) mmol/L; systolic blood pressure:
135.07 (±14.76) mmHg; weight: 89.85 (±19.01) kg. The mean treatment effect was
a reduction in HbA1c of 1.01 (±1.23) %. Over 20 years, fewer macrovascular and
microvascular events (-82/1,000 patients) and higher all-cause mortality (+17/1,000
patients) were predicted when using patient-level data compared to the average profile. Differences in the frequency and timing of deaths were driven primarily by variation in age and led to fewer estimated life-years (-0.66), quality-adjusted life-years
(QALYs; -0.59) and costs (-£551) per patient. Patients estimated to have lower costs
and higher QALYs than those associated with the average profile were younger, with
higher HbA1c and cholesterol but lower blood pressure at baseline. Conclusions:
Modelling results differ depending on the use of patient-level or average cohort
model inputs. Patient-level data may provide insight into the type of patients in
whom therapy is likely to be most beneficial. Furthermore, it enables the accurate
simulation of correlation between patient characteristics and treatment effect,
which are rarely accounted for as part of a standard probabilistic sensitivity analysis.
PRM17
Quantifying Nonlinear Effects in Stochastic Markov Simulation
Using UKPDS 68 and Ukpds 82 Equations in Type 2 Diabetes Modeling
Analysis With the IMS Core Diabetes Model (CDM)
McEwan P 1, Grant D 2, Lamotte M 3, Foos V 4
1Health Economics and Outcomes Research Ltd, Cardiff, UK, 2IMS Health, London, UK, 3IMS
Health Consulting, Brussels, Belgium, 4IMS Health, Basel, Switzerland
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Previous studies have demonstrated incorporating parameter sampling (PS) is crucial to capture nonlinear effects (NE) in cost effectiveness modeling.
NE are, among other causes, driven by the degree through which the symmetric
sampling of a risk factor is translated into non-symmetrically distributed probabilities generated by the applied risk equations (RE). This study sought to assess
degree by which the incorporation of NE through PS alters event rate predictions
from the UKPDS 82 (UK82) and UKPDS 68 (UK68) RE in a set of selected validation
studies conducted with the CDM. Methods: A total of 50 validation simulations
were performed to data from ACCORD, ADVANCE, VADT, ASPEN, DCCT and UKPDS.
Simulations mirroring cohort baseline characteristics of each of the trials were
conducted with and without PS using UK68 and UK82 REs. Predicted versus observed
macrovascular (MAC) and microvascular (MIC) complications and all cause mortality (ACM) were assessed using the coefficient of determination (R2) goodness of fit
measure. Results: When the CDM was run without PS, validation studies produced
an R2 statistic of 0.898 using UK68 and 0.853 using UK82 RE. This compared to R2
statistics of 0.876 and 0.791 in analysis with PS for UK68 and UK 82 REs, respectively.
Overall, PS caused end point predictions for MAC, MIC and ACM to increase. Internal
validations against UKPDS 80 demonstrated that PS increased event rate predictions for myocardial infarction (MI), stroke, MIC and ACM by 4.4%, 21.5%, 19% and
16.4% when UK68 RE were applied and 26.3%, 64.7%, 14.9% and 34.8% with UK82 RE,
respectively. Conclusions: The findings from this study have shown that external
validity declined with PS in simulations using UK68 RE and UK82 RE. The degree
by which PS increased end point predictions was considerable stronger in UK82 RE
predictions for MAC and ACM but lower for MIC.
PRM18
Inverse Probability of Censoring Weighted Analysis to Adjust the
Treatment Effect on Overall Survival for Subsequent Therapy:
A Case Study in a Clinical Trial in Multiple Myeloma
Thilakarathne P 1, Palumbo A 2, Diels J 1, Delforge M 3, van Sanden S 4, Mateos M V 5, Chirita O 6,
Dimopoulos M A 7, van de Velde H 8, San Miguel J F 9
1Janssen Pharmaceutica N. V., Beerse, Belgium, 2University of Torino, Torino, Italy, 3University
Hospital Leuven, Leuven, Belgium, 4EMEA HEMAR Analytics, Janssen EMEA, Beerse, Belgium,
5Hospital Universitario de Salamanca, Salamanca, Spain, 6Janssen, High Wycombe, UK,
7Alexandra Hospital, Athens, Greece, 8Johnson & Johnson ORD, Beerse, Belgium, 9Hospital
Universitario Salamanca, Salamanca, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: ITT-analyses of oncology trials tend to underestimate the treatment
effect on overall survival, due to the impact of subsequent therapy. Inverse probability
of censoring weighted analysis (IPCW) was explored to estimate an adjusted treatment effect on OS in VISTA, a phase III randomized clinical trial comparing melphalan
and prednisone with or without bortezomib (VMP vs MP) in previously untreated multiple myeloma patients ineligible for stem cell transplantation. Methods: The IPCW
consisted of 2 steps. First, time-varying weights were estimated using multivariate
logistic regression, including age, gender, stage, M-protein type, creatinine-clearance
as baseline covariates and M-protein as time-varying covariate. In a second step,
these time-dependent weights were incorporated in a proportional hazards model,
including the same baseline characteristics, with patients censored at initiation of
subsequent therapy. Results: 338/344 patients received up to nine 6-week cycles of
VMP or MP respectively, with median follow-up of 44.2 months. 68% of MP-patients
received subsequently therapy, compared to 58% in the VMP-arm. Age< 75, creatinine-clearance 30-60ml/min, stage III, and increasing M-protein measures over time
were additional drivers for treatment-switching. The IPCW-approach generated an
adjusted hazard ratio of 0.584 [0.406, 0.839], compared to the ITT-estimate of 0.704
[0.576, 0.860]. Conclusions: In oncology, particularly in early line treatment, it is
common that patients receive subsequent treatment lines. This typically happens
more frequently and earlier in the comparator arm, which may bias the estimate for
the treatment effect on OS. The IPCW-approach was explored to adjust for this bias,
which resulted in an increased estimate of the treatment-effect on OS of VMP vs
MP, compared to the original ITT-analysis. With overall survival being a key input in
economic evaluation, estimating the accurate effect on OS is key. Employing this type
of approaches may result in more accurate cost effectiveness results and thus more
consistent/appropriate Health Technology Assessment recommendations.
PRM19
Sharing of Information Across Studies to Inform Choice of
Functional Form When Conducting Parametric Survival Analysis
Parker C 1, Hawkins N S 2
1ICON Clinical Research, Oxford, UK, 2London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London,
UK
.
.
.
Objectives: To explore the sharing of information across multiple studies in order to
inform the choice of functional form when conducting parametric survival analysis.
Methods: A set of four clinical trials in advanced soft tissue sarcoma were identified from a published systematic review. Individual patient data for overall survival
were estimated from digitised Kaplan-Meier curves using a published algorithm.
A range of parametric survival models (exponential, Weibull, Gompertz, log-normal, log-logistic, Gamma and Generalised Gamma) were fitted. Two approaches
were explored for identifying the preferred parametric model: (i) selecting models
independently for each study (ii) selecting a common model across all the studies.
Models were selected using the Bayesian Information Criterion (BIC). For approach
(ii) a single BIC statistic was calculated by summing the components of the BIC (n,
k and ln (L)) across studies. Estimates of mean survival were derived for each model
and a bootstrap analysis was conducted to estimate both the uncertainty in model
selection and the variance in mean survival estimates. Results: Independent
selection led to different functional forms being selected for each study with considerable uncertainty regarding the choice of model (the bootstrap estimation for
the probability that the optimum model had been selected varied between 16 to 84%
across studies). The choice of model influenced mean survival predictions. Selecting
a common model across studies was found to reduce the uncertainty in model
selection and variance of the estimated mean survival (by up to 65%) compared to
selecting models independently. Conclusions: Use of multiple studies to inform
choice of functional form can improve the efficiency of survival estimates and hence
reduce uncertainty of cost-effectiveness estimates. Given the considerable uncertainty in selecting survival models within individual studies, it may be reasonable
to treat information on functional form as exchangeable between studies and to
‘borrow’ strength across studies.
PRM20
Predictive Modeling to Assess Predictors of Treatment Success and
Failure Among Combination Statin Therapy Patients
Nyandege A 1, Burudpakdee C 1, Philip S 2
1MKTXS, Raritan, NJ, USA, 2Amarin Pharma Inc., Bedminster, NJ, USA
.
.
.
Objectives: Combination statin therapy may help to further lower low-density
lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-C) better than monotherapy alone. The objective of this
study was to apply predictive modeling methodology to determine the predictors of
success and failure in achieving LDL-C goals after combination statin-fibrate therapy
in patients diagnosed with hypertriglyceridemia (HTG). Methods: A large claims
database was used to identify patients initiating a fibrate between January 2011 and
December 2011 (index date). Diagnosis of HTG and the use of statins were confirmed
within 6 months before the index date. A total of 622 patients were selected for the
current analysis. Patients were categorized into very high risk, high risk, moderate
risk, and low risk groups. Logistic regression and two-group discriminant analysis
models based on 17 potential predictors for treatment success or failure were constructed. Results: At index, the median triglyceride (TG) level among all patients
was 95.5 mg/dL, LDL-C level was 92 mg/dL, and high-density lipoprotein (HDL) was
40 mg/dL. The mean age was 54 years. Two predictors were associated with combination statin-fibrate treatment success or failure and accounted for 5.3% of variance
between groups. Low HDL (defined as < 40 mg/dL) (OR= 0.35; 95% CI, 0.20-0.59) and
peripheral arterial disease (OR=0.10; 95% CI, 0.02-0.38) were significantly associated
with treatment failure. Low HDL variable was the key discriminator. Conclusions:
Analytic insights enabled by predictive models may help researchers gain information on discriminating factors about certain target treatment groups and drug
classes. A set of key predictors may suggest opportunities to understand and predict
treatment success and failure of targeted groups and/or drug classes. These predictors may be useful in developing treatment strategies that will optimize outcomes.
PRM21
Predictive Modelling for Optimal Target Population and RealWorld Study Design: An Example In Mother-To-Child Transmission
of HIV
Amzal B
LASER Analytica, London, UK
.
A547
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: This research will present the Bayesian decision analytic framework
for late phase study simulation and calculation of chance of study success applied
to optimal target population and study design. A real-world example in motherto-child transmission of HIV conducted in Thailand will be used to illustrate the
concepts throughout. Methods: Predictive models describing virtual cohorts over
time under various care strategies can be informed via Bayesian inference using all
relevant data available on associations between population characteristics, relative
drug efficacy, drug uses and design parameters. In the proposed example, historical
transmission data from 3,876 Thai women were modeled via mixed-effect logistic
regression adjusted for viral load, gestational age, CD4 count at delivery and infant
treatment duration. Viral load was described as an exponential function of prophylaxis duration. Monte Carlo simulations were used to predict intrapartum transmission
rates with and without single dose nevirapine (sdNVP) added to the standard of care
(antenatal prophylaxis), and predict chance of success of a naturalistic Phase IIIb
study in Thailand under various assumptions on target population and adaptive study
design. Results: In women with short prophylaxis durations (<8-weeks) estimate of
intrapartum transmission rate was 2.6% (95%-Credibility Interval=0.5%-9.2%) with the
standard of care and 0.8% (95%-CI=0.1%-2.9%) with sdNVP added to standard care,
corresponding to a risk ratio of RR=3.9 (95%-PI=2.1-9.7). Study simulations showed
that a single-arm study with stopping rules at N= 58, 118, 275, and 410 has 78% (resp.
68%) probability of evidencing RR>1.3 (resp. RR>2). Conclusions: When the association between outcomes, design parameters and the main effectiveness drivers can
be informed by historical data, Bayesian predictive models can be powerful decision
support tools for optimal target population and late-phase or pragmatic study design.
Retrospective database studies of PAH using US payer claims data have limitations
due to lack of specific ICD-9 codes for PAH and ability to identify patient severity.
Previous studies used an algorithm which includes patients with non-specific PH
codes, along with a claim for an advanced PAH drug therapy. This study attempts
to validate the algorithm and identify patient disease severity through linkage to
data abstracted from medical charts. Objectives: To evaluate validity of a retrospective review of payer database along with chart abstraction for confirmation of
PAH diagnosis and identification of World Health Organization Functional Class
(FC). Methods: Medicare patients who received an (1) endothelin-receptor antagonist, phosphodiesterase type 5 inhibitor, or prostacyclin AND (2) had a diagnosis of
pulmonary hypertension, other chronic pulmonary hypertension or chronic pulmonary heart disease OR (3) medical claim indicating right heart catheterization (RHC)
were identified from pharmacy and medical claims data. A random sub-sample of
110 patients was chosen and the providers contacted to provide medical charts.
Charts were reviewed to abstract data indicating PAH diagnosis, FC, and/or symptoms, diagnostic tests, and treatments to enable classification. Results: Of 110
charts requested, 41 were received and abstracted. Twenty-one charts (51%) came
from a specialist. All 41 charts documented a confirmed diagnosis of PAH. Of those,
18 (44%) explicitly identified PAH class. Physical symptoms were reported, with dyspnea (66%) being most frequent, while walk test results, documentation of RHC and
pulmonary diagnostic tests were reported in less than 20% of cases. Conclusions:
The identification algorithm successfully identified diagnosed, confirmed cases
of PAH. Refinements to provider selection algorithm could result in an increase in
provider response rate, charts with documented FC and overall chart data quality.
PRM22
The statistical analysis of delayed effects in survival outcomes
for immunotherapies. Estimation of time-delay and application of
weighted log rank
PRM25
Quality Assessment of Controlled Trials Evaluating Chinese
Herbal Medicine in Patients With Rheumatoid Arthritis:
A Systematic Review
Luaces P , Sánchez L , Viada C , Frias A , Alvarez M , Rodríguez P C
Center of Molecular Immunology, Havana, Cuba
Pan X 1, Lopez-Olivo M A 2, Nayak P 2, Suarez-Almazor M E 2
Hospital, Shanghai University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Shanghai, China, 2The
University of Texas, MD Anderson Cancer Center, Houston, TX, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The aim of the study was to assess the delayed-time effect on survival
of the immunotherapy with a cancer vaccine by comparing the conventional logrank
test vs a weighted logrank in presence of non-proportional hazards. Methods:
Data from a multicenter, open-label and randomized phase III clinical trial with
an EGF-based cancer vaccine in advanced NSCLC. The diagnosis of the delayedtime effect was done and the time-delay was estimated. The non-proportional
hazards were also confirmed and tested delayed effect on survival of the treatment. Weighted logrank tests was applied and the results were compared with
those obtained using the conventional logrank test. The R software was used in
the analysis. Results: The time-delay was estimated in 28 months and a significant effect after this time was verified. The proportional hazard assumption was
not satisfied. The median survival for the vaccinated arm was 10.37 months vs.
8.93 months for non-vaccinated arm. The difference was statistically significant by
weighted logrank (p=0.04) and the conventional logrank test does not detect this difference. Conclusions: Weighted logrank is substantially more efficient than the
conventional logrank statistic in those situations in which non-proportional hazards
are foreseen. This analysis is recommended for immunotherapies where the appearance of a late biological effect is displayed several months after randomization.
PRM23
Impact of Single Risk Factor Changes on Long Term Outcomes and
Cost in a Type 2 Diabetes Modeling Study Contrasting Projections
With UKPDS 68 Versus UKPDS 82 Risk Equations
Foos V 1, McEwan P 2, Grant D 3
1IMS Health, Basel, Switzerland, 2Health Economics and Outcomes Research Ltd, Cardiff, UK, 3IMS
Health, London, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: The degree to which predefined risk factor (RF) changes alter long-term
clinical and cost outcomes in the IMS-CORE-Diabetes-Model (CDM) was reported
in earlier publications. Since this time the CDM has undergone a series of updates
including the inclusion of recently published UKPDS-82 risk equations (UK-82-RE). The
objective of this study was to project the lifetime benefits and total lifetime costs (TLC)
associated with a range of selected RF changes opposing results from CDM projections
utilizing UKPDS-68 risk equations (UK-68-RE) vs. UK-82-RE. Methods: The CDM was
applied to project the lifetime benefits (life years (LYs), quality adjusted life years
(QALYs)) and TLC (£GBP) associated with baseline RF changes for HbA1c, body-massindex (BMI), systolic blood pressure (SBP), high-density-lipoprotein (HDL) and low-density-lipoprotein (LDL). A intermediate risk type-2 diabetes cohort (age 52 years, HbA1c
8%, SBP 140 mm-Hg, BMI 30 Kg/m2, HDL 50 mg/dl and LDL 150 mg/dl) was projected
over lifetime to explore the sensitivity of undiscounted LYs, QALYs and TLC for selected
RF ranges (A1c+/-2%, SBP+/-20 mmHg, BMI+/-2 Kg/m2, HDL+/-10 mg/dl, LDL+/-20 mg/
dl). Linear regression models were fitted to assess the degree of end point sensitivity
per unit RF change. Results: When UK-68-RE were applied, projected changes in
benefits were 0.264, 0.094, 0.050, -0.611 and 0.162 LYs and 0.288, 0.111, 0.123, -0.358, and
0.113 QALYs associated with unit RF reductions of 1% point (A1c), 10 mm-HG (SBP),
1 KG/m2 (BMI), 10 mg/dl (HDL) and 10 mg/dl (LDL), respectively. This compared
to changes of 0.161, 0.079, 0.053, -0.262, 0.311 (LYs) and 0.215, 0.099,0. 116, -0.178,
0.208 (QALYs) utilizing UK-82-RE. TLC decreased by £1’105, £298, £115, £680 and £38
utilizing UK-68-RE and £1’073, £309, -£71, -£221, -£7 with UK-82-RE. Conclusions:
The degree to which RF changes are translated into benefits and costs may change
considerably dependent on the choice of selected risk equations.
PRM24
A Chart Abstraction Based Method to Classify Real World Patients
With Pulmonary Arterial Hypertension Based on Who Functional
Classification
Stemkowski S 1, Pruett J 2, Dufour R 1, Lane D C 1, Raspa S 2, Drake W 2
Health Insights, Humana, Louisville, KY, USA, 2Actelion Pharmaceuticals US Inc.,
San Francisco, CA, USA
.
1Comprehensive
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Shuguang
.
Objectives: We conducted a systematic review to appraise the methodological
quality of controlled clinical trials evaluating the efficacy and safety of Chinese
herbal medicine (CHM) patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA). Methods: We
searched electronic databases (Medline, EMBASE, The Cochrane Library, and Web
of Science) from inception until May 2014. Study selection was performed by 2
independent reviewers. The methodological quality of the trials was assessed using
the Cochrane risk of bias tool for randomized trials and Newcastle Ottawa Scale
for controlled non-randomized studies. Results: 54 studies were included (51
randomized trials; 3 non-randomized studies) evaluating 7,792 patients. Only one
study was conducted in the US, the remaining in China. There were 3,446 patients
receiving CHM. In the control groups 2,283 patients received a disease modifying
anti-rheumatic drug (DMARD), 182 non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs),
and 164 inert placebo. For the randomized studies, when evaluating selection bias
54% of the studies were judged to have an adequate random sequence generation,
but 77% had inadequate allocation concealment. 79% had a high risk of performance
bias (not blinding participants and/or personnel) and detection bias was unclear
in 56% of the studies; 62% of the studies reported how missing data was handled,
therefore attrition bias was judged to be low. In 87% no disclosure of interest or
source of founding was reported. For non-randomized studies, all the studies were
representative of RA patients, had an adequate ascertainment of intervention with
comparable groups, but only one demonstrated that the outcome of interest was not
present at start of study or provided the rate of lost to follow-up. Conclusions:
Studies evaluating CHM often fail to meet expected methodological criteria, and
high quality evidence is lacking. Future studies of CHM should be methodologically
robust and adhere to reporting guidelines such as the CONSORT statement for TCM.
RESEARCH ON METHODS – Cost Methods
PRM26
Validation of The Hospital Episode Statistics Outpatient Dataset in
England
Thorn J C 1, Turner E 1, Hounsome L 2, Walsh E 1, Down L 1, Donovan J 1, Verne J 2, Neal D 3,
Hamdy F 4, Martin R M 1, Noble S 1
1University of Bristol, Bristol, UK, 2Public Health England, Bristol, UK, 3University of Cambridge,
Cambridge, UK, 4University of Oxford, Oxford, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Health economists are being encouraged to use routine datasets for
resource-use measurement and costing purposes in economic evaluations alongside
clinical trials to reduce research burden. The Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) dataset, which records all NHS hospital-based activity in England, is one such dataset.
However, its validity for research purposes has not been established. This study
aims to assess the validity of the HES outpatient dataset. Methods: Men who
died of, or with, prostate cancer were selected from a prostate-cancer screening
trial (CAP, Cluster randomised triAl of testing for Prostate cancer). Details of visits
that took place after 1/4/2003 to hospital outpatient departments for conditions
related to prostate cancer were extracted from medical records (MR). Data from the
HES outpatient dataset were obtained for the same men. Appointments for visits
extracted from MR were sought in the HES dataset. The matching procedure was
repeated for periods before and after 1/4/2008 (when the dataset was accredited as
a national statistic). Results: 4922 outpatient appointments were extracted from
MR for 370 men between 2003 and 2012. 4086 appointments recorded in MR were
identified in the HES dataset (83.0%; 95%CI 81.9–84.1). Allowing a +/-2 day tolerance
for the appointment date resulted in a slight improvement to 4171 (84.7%; 95%CI
83.7–85.7) matches (p= 0.5). For appointments occurring when the dataset was considered experimental (prior to 1/4/2008), 2194/2754 (79.7%; 95%CI 78.1–81.2) matches
were observed, while 1892/2168 (87.3%; 95%CI 85.8–88.6) appointments occurring
after 1/4/2008 were identified (p= 0.03). Conclusions: The HES outpatient data-
A548
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
set appears reasonably valid for research, particularly following accreditation. The
dataset may be a suitable alternative to collecting MR data manually within a trial,
although caution should be exercised with earlier data. Further work is ongoing to
establish the nature of the missing data and the implications for cost differences.
PRM27
Can Using a Resource Use Log in an Economic Evaluation Alongside
a Randomised Controlled Trial Reduce the Amount of Recall Bias?
Noble S , Tudge I , Wylde V , Lenguerrand E , Marques E M
University of Bristol, Bristol, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To determine whether giving patients a resource use log (RUL) at
hospital discharge reduces recall bias in a follow-up resource use questionnaire
(RUQ). Methods: Within the APEX randomised controlled trials (RCTs), 86 patients
undergoing joint replacement were randomised to receive or not receive an RUL at
hospital discharge (The RUL trial). A postal RUQ was then administered to all participants at 3-months after surgery. Resource use data (visits to GPs, GP home visits
and telephone calls; GP practice nurse visits and telephone calls; and prescribed
medication) in relation to the patient’s joint replacement were extracted from GP
records from hospital discharge until completion of the 3-month RUQ by a blinded
researcher. Data from both sources were coded into use of resource and number
of contacts. For each resource use category, descriptive statistics were calculated
by data source and RUL trial arm. Kappa statistics and Concordance Correlation
Coefficients (CCC) were calculated as appropriate. Results: GPs were contacted
for 67/86 patients originally randomised to receive or not receive an RUL (one had
surgery delayed, 3 died, 5 withdrew, 6 had GP practices outside of area, 4 did not
complete the 3-month RUQ). Information was then extracted for 66/67 patients.
There was evidence of improved recall in favour of the RUL arm in relation to visiting
a GP (Kappa= 0.5312 vs. -0.0161). There was some slight evidence in favour of the
non-RUL arm with regards to having a GP home visit (Kappa= 0.335 vs. -0.0937). The
RUL arm showed more agreement than the non-RUL arm between data sources
in terms of number of: visits to GPs (CCC= 0.581 vs. -0.013); GP telephone calls
(CCC= 0.564 vs. 0.173) and prescriptions (CCC= 0.418 vs. -0.13). Conclusions:
Although based on small numbers, our study found some evidence that provision
of an RUL reduces recall bias in relation to visits to GPs.
PRM28
Systematic Review and Critique of Health Economic Models on
Relapsing-Remitting Multiple Sclerosis in the UK
Kusel J 1, Maruszczak M 1, Montgomery S 1, Allen F 2, Adlard N 2
1Costello Medical Consulting Ltd., Cambridge, UK, 2Novartis Pharmaceuticals UK Limited, Surrey,
UK
.
.
.
.
PRM29
Should Changes in Drug Price Over Time be Considered in CostEffectiveness Analyses?
Millier A 1, Briquet B 1, Aballea S 1, Toumi M 2
of Marseille, Marseille, France
.
.
PRM30
Estimating Costs in A Cost-Effectiveness Analysis: Adherence to HTA
Guidance
Mauskopf J A 1, Mitchell S E 2, Samuel M 2
Health Solutions, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA, 2RTI Health Solutions, Manchester, UK
.
.
.
.
.
1RTI
Objectives: Since the results of a cost-effectiveness analysis (CEA) are generally
sensitive to the input cost parameter values selected for difference disease-related
outcomes a systematic approach should be used to derive these estimates as suggested in HTA guidance. To determine the extent to which a systematic approach
was used to select disease-related cost estimates for inclusion in CEAs for new
hepatitis C treatments. Methods: A systematic literature review of primary costing studies and of the cost data used in published CEAs was performed for different stages of liver disease for those with chronic hepatitis C infection. The process
described in the cost-effectiveness analyses by which they selected the input
base-case cost values as well as the ranges used in the sensitivity analyses was
reviewed to determine whether or not a systematic approach was used to identify
primary cost studies and whether or not the a rationale was supplied for the values selected. Results: The hepatitis C systematic review focused on US costs and
cost-effectiveness analyses. In most of the hepatitis C cost-effectiveness analyses,
the cost estimates used were either taken directly or derived from recent primary
cost studies. However, a systematic review was not generally used to identify the
recent primary cost studies. In addition, the method used to adapt the data from
the selected studies for use in the CEA was either not explained and/or appeared to
be incorrect in some of the CEAs. In most of the CEAs, sensitivity analyses assumed
arbitrary ranges for the cost estimates (for example, plus or minus 50%) rather than
using ranges from alternative cost studies. Conclusions: Very little detail is provided in published CEAs about the methods used to identify primary disease-related
cost studies and a rationale for selection of the costs is generally not provided.
.
Objectives: Several new disease modifying therapies have recently received marketing authorisations for the treatment of relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis
(RRMS). Given the recent appraisal by NICE of these therapies, the objective of this
study was to systematically review and critically evaluate the techniques used in
modelling relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis in the UK. Methods: Embase,
Medline, Cochrane Library and the NICE website were searched systematically on
03.03.14 to identify articles relating to cost-utility models in RRMS with a UK perspective. Data sources, techniques and assumptions of the included models were
extracted, compared and critically evaluated. Results: Of 385 search results, 25 full
texts were evaluated and 17 articles (relating to 12 different models) were included.
Early models varied considerably in method and structure but convergence was
apparent over time towards a Markov model with states based on disability score,
a 1-year cycle length and a lifetime time horizon. More recent models also allowed
for disability improvement within the natural history of the condition. Considerable
variety remains, however, with an increasing number of comparators over time, the
need for treatment sequencing and different assumptions around efficacy waning
and treatment withdrawal. Additionally, modelling techniques were sometimes
implemented inappropriately. Confidential data sources were frequently used, especially within the models submitted to NICE. Conclusions: Despite a convergence
over recent years to a similar Markov structure, there are still significant discrepancies between the models simulating the course of RRMS in the UK. Differing
methods, assumptions and data sources make the comparison of models, and their
results, problematic. The Markov structure commonly used also leads to problems
such as an incapability to deal with heterogeneous populations and multiplying
complexity with treatment sequences; these would best be solved by using alternative model types such as discrete event simulations.
.
dynamic incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER), at the time of market entry
and by year thereafter. While experts were not aware of any existing guidelines,
the predominant view was that although using the brand price for the studied drug
would be a conservative approach, it is reasonable to account for price reductions
after patent expiration for all drugs considered. Conclusions: Drug price variations may introduce a source of uncertainty in CEA, as both timing of entry and
level of generic drug pricing are unknown. There is currently no consensus on how
this should be considered. Failure to incorporate generic drug entry in CEA is likely
to yield overestimates of ICER for treatments used over long-term.
.
PRM31
Identifying the Broader Value of Vaccines in Low and Middle Income
Countries
Van der Putten I M 1, Hiligsmann M 1, Paulus A T G 1, Hutubessy R 2, Evers S M 1
University, Maastricht, The Netherlands, 2World Health Organization, Geneva,
Switzerland
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Maastricht
Objectives: Current economic evaluations of vaccine immunization strategies
mainly concentrate on immediate health gains (measured in metrics such as
QALYs or DALYs) and household cost savings. Vaccine immunization strategies,
however, often take place within a broader societal context. In order to financially sustain these strategies, economic evaluations should not only encompass
immediate health gains and household costs but also the ‘broader value of vaccines’. This study aims to identify the relevance of information with regard to
the broader value of vaccines for decision makers in low and middle income
countries. Methods: Several methods were used to identify the broader value
of vaccines including a literature review, a survey, interviews and consultations
with experts. The long-term effects of those who were vaccinated and the effects
experienced by society as a whole, including non-vaccinated community members, were included in a framework. Results: In total, twenty broader values
in five different domains were identified. The first domain included long-term
productivity gains. These gains refer to the individual long-term productivity due
to better physical and mental health as well as to the economic consequences of
decisions made by households due to improved child survival. The second domain
consists of ecological values which are related to the decline of prevalence and
incidence of vaccine related diseases. The third domain encompasses different
types of equity considerations. The fourth domain includes the impact of vaccine
strategies on other health interventions. Finally, the fifth domain includes macroeconomic effects, such as the impact of vaccine immunization strategies on GDP
tax revenues and overall government savings. Conclusions: Several broader
economic values outside the health care sector were identified. These results
provide the input for the incorporation of these values in economic evaluations.
Further research is needed to identify the most important broader values for
national decision makers.
1Creativ-Ceutical, Paris, France, 2University
Objectives: Cost-effectiveness analyses (CEA) are used to support funding decisions for new drugs by estimating their clinical and economic value. While prices
of drugs may fall over time due to market competition, entrance of generic drugs,
or negotiated price cuts, this is rarely accounted for in CEA. The objective is to
review pharmacoeconomic guidelines and current practice around drug price evaluation in CEA. Methods: Pharmacoeconomic guidelines were reviewed to identify
countries in which a drug price modification over the time horizon is allowed or
recommended in CEA. Then methodological articles and published CEA using price
modifications were identified. Finally, several health economics experts were interviewed. Results: Only 3 pharmacoeconomic guidelines report recommendations
around price adjustment in CEA (Norway, New-Zealand): modellers should take
into account changes in drug price over time. In France, it is possible to include a
generic price in sensitivity analysis. In other countries, this was not mentioned in
the guidelines. Methodological articles mentioned the possibility to use an estimated 4% decrease over time in UK. In most of published CEA incorporating price
modifications, this was performed as secondary analyses. Other CEA reported
PRM32
Proposal for a Comprehensive Definition of Budget Impact Analysis
Bierbaum M
Friedrich-Alexander-Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg, Nuremberg, Germany
.
Objectives: To our knowledge in most articles BIA is only defined as what it does.
Some authors have tried to define it by comparing it to cost effectiveness analysis. But
still there is no common stand-alone definition of the term Budget Impact Analysis
available. Our aim is to provide such a definition. Methods: In the course of a PhD
thesis we conducted a systematic literature review in order to identify methodological articles regarding budget impact analyses. We searched pudmed and seven
other databases to identify relevant articles. From the eligible articles the different
understandings and definitions of BIA were extracted and synthesized into a comprehensive definition. Results: Our search delivered 223 articles from which 28 met our
inclusion criteria. 15 different approaches to describe BIAs were identified. Over the
years (2001 to today) there was a constant improvement and increase of complexity
in the descriptions. Nevertheless most of the late definitions are based on the work of
A549
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Mauskopf et al. in 2005 and 2007. Conclusions: Based on the results we suggest the
following definition for BIA: “A budget impact analysis is a form of health economic
evaluation. Its purpose is to predict the financial consequences of the introduction
or removal of an intervention from the current health care setting. Therefore BIA
is a framework to synthesize the best available evidence. Rather than calculating
a precise impact number it provides a valid model to the decision maker, enabling
him to understand the relative effects of his decisions. The analysis is undertaken by
modeling two scenarios where the reference scenario is the status quo and the second
scenario a simulation of the decision to be made. The model parameters are chosen
according to the framework requirement of the decision maker.”
PRM33
Episodes of Care and their Costs Based on ICPC-2 Classification:
Three Month Follow-Up Study in Finland
Heinonen J 1, Soini E 2, Ryynänen O P 3, Koskela T 1
1Department of General Practice, University of Tampere, Tampere, Finland, 2ESiOR Oy, Kuopio,
Finland, 3Department of Public Health and Clinical Nutrition, University of Eastern Finland, and
General Practice Unit, Kuopio University Hospital, Kuopio, Finland
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To explore patient characteristics, resource use and costs related to
different episodes of care (EOC) in Finnish health care. EOC is a health problem
needing testing, diagnosis, care or follow-up from its first presentation by the
patient to health care until the completion of the last health care contact for
it. Literature around costs of episodes (COE) is scarce. Methods: Primary and
secondary care data was collected during the three months prospective, nonrandomized follow-up study (Effective Health Centre) using questionnaires and
electronic health record. Setting included three primary health care practices in
Pirkanmaa, Finland. 622 (41% of potential) patients were recruited during one
week period. Patients that had doctor/nurse appointment on the recruiting day
and agreed to participate were included. Patients visiting specialized health guidance clinic for pregnant women, children and mothers were excluded. The main
outcome measures were patient characteristics, resource use and costs classified
based on the International Classification of Primary Care (ICPC-2) episode title
codes. Resource use was valued with health care providers’ 2012 unit costs. Social
Insurance Institution costs (e.g. outpatient drugs) were excluded. Results: On
average, patient had 1.22 EOCs during the three months. Patient characteristics
and resource use differed between the EOC-classes. Class L ‘Musculoskeletal’ had
the highest number of episodes (17%). The most common (8%) single EOC was
‘upper respiratory infection’. The mean COE was € 390 (SE € 61) and the median COE
was € 165 (IQR € 118-289) during the three month follow-up. The most expensive
class was K ‘Circulatory’, with a mean COE of € 910. The most expensive single COE
(€ 32,546) was in the group K. The most expensive one percent of COEs summed up
covered 36% of total COEs. Conclusions: Patient characteristics, resource use
and costs differed between the ICPC-2 classes, which could be taken into account
in evaluations, planning and pricing.
PRM34
Do the Us Panel Recommendations Hold for Europe? Investigating
the Relation Between Quality of Life Versus Work-Status,
Absenteeism and Presenteeism
Knies S 1, Boonen A 2, Severens J L 3
Health Care Institute, Diemen, The Netherlands, 2Maastricht University Medical Center,
Maastricht, The Netherlands, 3Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
1National
Objectives: In the last twenty years there has been an intense debate on how to
value lost productivity in economic evaluations. According to the Washington panel,
lost productivity influences health-related quality of life (HRQoL) and should thus
be considered a health effect instead of a cost to avoid double counting. Until now
empirical evidence on the inclusion of income loss when valuing health states is
not decisive. We examine the relationship between three aspects of lost productivity (work-status, absenteeism and presenteeism) and patient or social valuation of
health-related quality of life. Methods: Cross-sectional survey data from a total of
830 respondents with a rheumatic disorder from four Western-European countries.
Health-related quality of life was expressed in either the European societal utility
using EQ-5D-3L or the patient valuation using EQ-VAS. Linear regression analyses
were performed to examine the impact of work-status (four categories), absenteeism (absent from paid work during the past three months), and presenteeism
(QQ method) on EQ-5D utilities and VAS scores taking demographic characteristics and disease severity (duration, pain and restriction) into account. Results:
The relationship between work-status, absenteeism or presenteeism and HRQoL
is stronger for patient valuation than societal valuation. Compared to work-status
and presenteeism is the relationship between absenteeism and HRQoL even less
explicit. However, results for all measures of work are only marginal significant
and negligible compared to the influence of restriction due to disease we studied.
Conclusions: In four European countries, analyses among patients with a rheumatic disorder do not fully support the claim of the Washington panel that lost
productivity has a significant relationship with HRQoL, and this is even more apparent for absenteeism than for work-status and presenteeism. Therefore absenteeism
should continue to be included in the costs and not in the QALY. Findings need to
be confirmed in other disease areas.
PRM35
Cost of Previously Treated Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia (CLL) and
Indolent Non-Hodgkin’s Lymphoma (INHL) in the United Kingdom (UK)
Cognet M 1, Druais S 1, Gervais F 1, Gauthier A 1, Abrams K R 2
of Leicester, Leicester, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Amaris, London, UK, 2University
Objectives: Accurate cost data are required to inform cost-effectiveness assessments of novel treatments in the UK for NICE appraisals. Up to now, levels of
resource use to manage CLL and iNHL have mainly been based on clinical expert
opinion. However, recently, two key primary care databases in the UK (THIN and
CPRD) were linked with Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) at the patient level,
thereby providing additional information on secondary care in England. This
study aimed to generate more accurate resource use for the management of CLL
and iNHL by using the THIN-HES database. Methods: First, a MEDLINE and UK
Health Technology Appraisals (HTAs) reviews were undertaken to identify studies documenting the cost of previously-treated iNHL and CLL in the UK. Then, to
collect patients health care resource use, THIN database linked to the HES dataset
was analysed. Results: Three HTAs were identified as relevant, and cost estimates relied on assumptions from clinical experts. Assumptions varied as TA193
related to relapsed CLL assumed that health care visits were three times more
frequent post-progression (3 consultations/month: £86) than pre-progression (1
consultation/month: £28.67) while another, TA202, assumed a rather constant
number of visits across the two health states (1 clinic visit per month: £121.11).
Therefore, analyses of the THIN database linked to HES were undertaken, including more than 1 000 patients. OPCS4 codes and READ codes in the HES and THIN
databases respectively, were used to identify treatments prescribed and procedures undertaken. Costs were estimated by applying unit costs from national
references. Conclusions: To our knowledge, this analysis is the first retrospective observational study to assess the cost of managing previously-treated CLL
and iNHL in the UK. This study will serve as an important resource in the health
economic evaluation of emerging therapies. This method suggests a greater standardization of disease management costs across HTAs.
PRM36
A Systematic Review of Methods to Assess the Economic Impact of
Air Pollution
Conti S , Fornari C , Madotto F , Cesana G
University of Milano - Bicocca, Monza, Italy
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Despite the fact that short and long-term effects of the exposure to
air pollution on health have been extensively analyzed, estimates of the health
care economic impact of such effects are still limited. We therefore carried out a
systematic review of the literature, with the aim of identifying the current major
research focuses in the field and the topics that will need to be addressed in the
future. Methods: We searched the electronic databases MEDLINE and EMBASE,
in which we applied respectively the following algorithms: 1) “((“cost of illness”
[MeSH Terms] OR “health care costs” [MeSH Terms] OR “health expenditures” [MeSH
Terms]) AND “environmental pollution” [MeSH Terms]) OR (Pollution [Title/Abstract]
AND (Expenditure [Title/Abstract] OR Expenditures [Title/Abstract] OR cost [Title/
Abstract] OR costs [Title/Abstract]) AND (health [Title/Abstract] OR health care [Title/
Abstract]))“; 2) “‘health care cost’/exp AND ‘pollution’/exp”. Searches were limited
to article written in English and Italian, without any date restriction. Results:
The initial selections identified 775 records in MEDLINE and 466 in EMBASE, 149
of which were classified as relevant. They focused on a wide range of pollutants,
including volatile organic compounds, nitrogen dioxide, pesticides, ozone, particulate matter and tobacco smoke. Most of the studies assessed the health impact of
environmental pollutants using direct and indirect cost estimates acquired from
literature, mainly relying on cost of illness methods; 27 papers used an individual
direct health care costs approach, but they usually didn’t involve indirect costs in
the final computations. Finally, only a few studies distinguished between short-term
and long-term effect of air pollution. Conclusions: The results of our review identified two main topics that deserve further research: future health impact assessments should integrate indirect costs estimates with information from the direct
modeling of real-life health care costs; the short- and long-term economic impacts
should be clearly separated.
PRM37
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Ipilimumab in Previously Untreated
Patients With Unresectable Malignant Melanoma in Scotland
Lee D 1, Porter J 1, Hatswell A J 1, Hertel N 2, Walker A 3
Myers Squibb, Uxbridge, UK, 3University of Glasgow, glasgow,
UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
1BresMed, Sheffield, UK, 2Bristol
Objectives: This analysis assessed the cost effectiveness of ipilimumab 3mg/
kg as first-line treatment for metastatic melanoma. As ipilimumab has an existing second-line recommendation, the decision problem is ipilimumab first-line
followed by best supportive care (BSC), compared with Scottish clinical practice
- dacarbazine or vemurafenib first-line followed by ipilimumab. Methods: In line
with SMC requirements, an area under the curve model was built comparing firstline ipilimumab, dacarbazine and vemurafenib. The model utilised progression,
survival and utility data from CA184-024 for ipilimumab/dacarbazine and dacarbazine, survival data from MDX010-20 for ipilimumab second-line, and survival
and progression data from BRIM-3 for vemurafenib. MDX010-20 and observational
data, using the approved regimen, were tested within scenario analyses assessing
the performance of ipilimumab 3mg/kg at first-line. 2013 costs were taken from
Scottish or UK official sources. Results: Economic analysis, including patient
access schemes for ipilimumab and vemurafenib, shows that ipilimumab firstline followed by BSC is cost-effective versus dacarbazine first-line followed by
ipilimumab (incremental costs: £10,502, incremental quality-adjusted life-years
[QALYs]: 0.33, incremental cost-effectiveness ratio [ICER]: £31,481). Compared with
ipilimumab first-line followed by BSC, the sequence vemurafenib first-line followed by ipilimumab is associated with incremental QALYs (0.26) but also incremental costs (£33,306), resulting in a not cost-effective cost/QALY trade-off (ICER
= £126,482), i.e. ipilimumab first-line should be the preferred option. A scenario
analysis that compared ipilimumab first-line with vemurafenib first-line alone
resulted in ipilimumab being the dominant treatment option. Comprehensive
sensitivity analyses identified survival parameters as having the largest impact
on model results. Ipilimumab remained cost-effective at a threshold of £50,000
per QALY gained against both comparators. Conclusions: First-line ipilimumab
treatment for melanoma is cost-effective, and as a first-line option it would
expand clinician choice, enabling selection of the most appropriate therapy for
patients depending on their disease characteristics and BRAF mutation status.
A550
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PRM38
Clusters of Health-States Valuations
Garcia-Molina M 1, Chicaiza-Becerra L A 1, Rincon C J 2, Romano G 2
1Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Bogotá, Colombia, 2Universidad Nacional de Colombia,
Bogota, Colombia
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To identify groups of countries with similar health preferences. Methods: Cluster analyses were performed for the 242 states of the general population EQ-5D valuations for 13 published studies based on Time Trade
Off; and for 10 studies based on the Visual Analogue Scale. The perfect health state
was not included. Cluster and their optimal number were identified by means of
the Ward algorithm with the Euclidean measure and the hierarchical clustering
technique. The identified clusters in each case are compared in order to find out
whether they coincide. Results: 3 clusters were identified for TTO: 1) Germany,
Argentina, Poland, The Netherlands, Denmark; 2) Japan, South Korea, USA, Hispanic
USA, Zimbabwe; 3) Spain, Chile, UK. 4 clusters were identified for VAS: 1) Belgium,
New Zealand, Germany; 2) Europe, UK, Spain; 3) Denmark, Slovenia; 4) Finland,
Argentina. Countries are not in the same clusters for the two methodologies. Only
the UK and Spain belong in the same groups in both cases. Conclusions: Healthstate valuations tend to be clustered in a few groups of countries but the groups
differ according to the methodology. This suggests that Visual Analogue Scale results
may not be a good approximation to Time Trade Off.
PRM39
IMTA Productivity Cost Questionnaire (IPCQ)
.
.
.
.
PRM42
A Methodology for Estimating the Population of Advanced or
Metastatic EGFR M+ Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer Patients in the UK
and Ireland
Mildred M
Boehringer Ingelheim Ltd, Bracknell, UK
.
Bouwmans C 1, Krol M 2, Brouwer W 2, Severens J L 1, Koopmanschap M A 2, Hakkaart L 1
1Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 2Erasmus University, Rotterdam,
The Netherlands
.
parameters that can be combined to produce suitable measures of cost (c) and clinical
benefits (e) associated with an intervention. Within the Bayesian framework (which is
the natural environment for BCEA), this amounts to estimating a posterior distribution for the pair (e, c). Health economic evaluations then proceed by computing some
relevant summaries of the resulting decision process: is the innovative intervention t1
more “cost-effective” than the standard intervention t0?. Methods: BCEA provides a
set of functions that can be used to produce a standardised analysis, by synthesising
the decision process given the current evidence and uncertainty, as well as producing
several indicators that can be used to perform Probabilistic Sensitivity Analysis (PSA)
to parameter and model structure uncertainty. These include the Cost-Effectiveness
Acceptability Curve and the analysis of the Expected Value of Information, which can
be used to prioritize research. Results: BCEA uses as inputs vectors of simulations
from the distributions of the average costs and benefits. This naturally fits the Bayesian
framework, but a frequentist analysis can also be carried out by using tools such as
the bootstrap. There is scope for linking R and programs such as Excel to facilitate a
comprehensive health economic analysis, including extensive PSA. Conclusions:
In this talk, I will present the main feature of BCEA and its applicability to the wider
context of health economic evaluation and cost-effectiveness analysis.
.
.
.
Objectives: Productivity costs often reflect a large part of the total cost in economic evaluations adopting a societal perspective. Currently, no consensus exists
on how productivity losses are best measured. We aimed to develop a standardized
instrument for measuring productivity losses to enhance the comparability and generalizability of the outcomes of economic evaluations. Methods: A focus group
of well-experienced researchers in the field of measuring and valuing productivity
losses for use in economic evaluations assessed the instruments’ main quality criteria
including: building on pre-knowledge and evidence on items’ reliability and validity, inclusion of all relevant domains of productivity losses, allowing for quantifying
productivity losses suitable for self-report. A feasibility study was performed to check
on consistency and intelligibility of the questionnaire and applicability for different
valuation methods. Results: The focus group identified three separate aspects of
productivity losses leading to three modules in the iPCQ. Questions for measuring
absenteeism and presenteeism are evidence- based originating from the Short-Form
Health & Labour Questionnaire and PRODISQ. As evidence regarding measurement of
losses of unpaid work is lacking, the questions of this module were developed during
brainstorm sessions, based on similar questions on paid work. To enhance the instruments’ feasibility and responsiveness the draft version was translated into language
level 1 by an agency specialized in language and clear writing. The feasibility study
included 195 respondents aged > 18 years. Five percent identified problems while
filling in the iPCQ, including the questionnaire’s instructions and routing (n=8) and
wording (n=2). Conclusions: The iPCQ is based on previously available instruments
and satisfies the current scientific state of play in productivity cost measurement
and valuation. The instrument is understandable for the vast majority of the general
public including low-educated people. To enhance the applicability of the iPCQ for
national and international studies a translation in English is performed.
Objectives: Budget impact models (BIMs) which demonstrate the economic impact
of introducing or increasing the use of specific treatments are routinely used to assist
the NHS with financial planning. A core component of any BIM is the estimation
of the eligible patient population. The objective of this study was to identify an
appropriate methodology for estimating the size of the stage IIIb/IV EGFR M+ nonsmall cell lung cancer (NSCLC) patient population eligible for first-line treatment
with a tyrosine kinase inhibitor such as afatinib (GIOTRIF®). Methods: A review
of the approach taken by NICE in the costing statements of all treatment options
for patients with advanced (stage IIIb) or metastatic (stage IV) EGFR M+ NSCLC was
conducted. The costing statements of tyrosine kinase inhibitors afatinib, erlotinib
and gefitinib were reviewed, as was the costing statement for the chemotherapy
agent pemetrexed. Results: Based on the reviewed approaches, the calculation can
be broken down into six discrete steps from the estimation of the general population to the target population: (1) Incidence of lung cancer; (2) Proportion of NSCLC;
(3) Proportion with stage IIIb/IV NSCLC; (4) Proportion who receive first-line chemotherapy; (5) Proportion with EGFR mutation status; and (6) Proportion who are EGFR
M+. A detailed breakdown of the methods used to calculate the patient population
eligible for treatment with afatinib was not available in the respective NICE costing
statement; however the eligible population estimated by NICE validates that this
approach is reasonable. Conclusions: The methodology employed by NICE to
estimate the proportion of stage IIIb/IV EGFR M+ NSCLC patients was broadly consistent across all costing statements considered. Is it reasonable to assume that this
approach, used to estimate the population of stage IIIb/IV EGFR M+ NSCLC patients
in England and Wales is also applicable in Scotland and Ireland.
PRM43
Are Care-Seekers Good Candidates for Subgroups Cost-Effectiveness
Analyses?
Rapp T 1, Sirven N 2
of Paris Descartes, Paris, France, 2Université Paris Descartes, Paris, France
.
PRM40
Feasibility of the Headroom Analysis in Early Economic Evaluation
of Innovative Diagnostic Technologies With no Immediate
Treatment Implications
Van Nimwegen K J
Radboud university medical center, Nijmegen, The Netherlands
.
.
Objectives: There is a growing need for early evaluation of innovative technologies
to prevent ineffective and expensive technologies to be widely diffused in health
care. The headroom method was introduced for early determination of the potential
value of new technologies. In this study we explore the feasibility and usefulness of
the headroom method in the early assessment of diagnostic technologies with no
immediate treatment implications. Methods: We applied the headroom method
to the implementation of whole exome sequencing (WES) into the current diagnostic
trajectory of complex pediatric neurology. We determined the room for improvement
regarding health-related quality of life (HRQoL), diagnostic yield and the duration of
the current diagnostic trajectory. Results: The headroom in a certain diagnostic
trajectory can be calculated after the so-called effectiveness gap is established and
monetised. The preferred measure for the effectiveness gap is HRQoL expressed in
quality-adjusted life years (QALYs). Since the direct product of diagnostics is information, and not improved health, no impact on HRQoL is expected. Other measures, such
as diagnostic yield, can also be used to calculate the effectiveness gap. Unlike QALYs,
these appeared difficult to monetise, however. Despite this difficulty, effectiveness gap
calculation using these effect measures is very informative on the room for improvement in current clinical practice. In combination with foreseeable downstream costs
and savings due to a new technology it gives an idea of the potential societal value of
this technology. Conclusions: Despite some methodological challenges, the headroom method proved to be potentially useful in early health economic evaluation of
diagnostic technologies with no immediate treatment implications.
PRM41
BCEA: A R Package to Perform Bayesian Cost-Effectiveness Analysis
Baio G
University College London, London, UK
.
Objectives: BCEA is a R library specifically designed to post-process the result of a
health economic model. Typically, this consists in the estimation of a set of relevant
.
1University
Objectives: There is a growing need to consider heterogeneity in cost-effectiveness
analyses (CEA). To capture heterogeneity, subgroups analyses have been performed
using various socio-demographic and clinical variables. However, the results of these
subgroups CEA can be considered inequitable. Consequently, there is need to find new
subgroups that can be used for decision-making. Methods: We explore whether
subgroups defined by care-seeking behaviors are good candidates for CEA subgroup
analysis. Care-seekers are defined as patients who received both an early diagnosis
and an early treatment. We use data from the PLASA study, a French randomized
controlled trial designed to reduce the rate of functional decline in Alzheimer’s
disease: 1,131 patients were randomized in an intervention group and in a control
group and were followed during a 2-year period. We use a sample selection model to
explore whether the unobserved heterogeneity associated with the early diagnosis
decision is correlated with the unobserved heterogeneity associated with the early
treatment decision. We use a fixed-effect model to explore whether the rate of functional decline was lower within the care-seekers subgroup. Results: Our theoretically grounded selection model shows that the care-seeking behavior is associated
with unobserved preferences, motivating the need to run subgroup analyses within
a subgroup of care-seekers. Our fixed-effect model results show that on average,
the clinical intervention was not effective. However, the intervention was effective
within the subgroup of care-seekers. Care-seekers who received the intervention did
not face a significant decline in their functional status over the 2-year study period.
On the contrary, care-seekers in the control group lost on average 9 points of ADCSADL per year (p< 0.01). Conclusions: Stratifying CEAs by care-seekers subgroups
seems relevant. Our analyses can be easily implemented by adding three questions
in the clinical protocol.
PRM44
A Review of The Utility Values Used in Published Cost-Effectiveness
Analyses of Angiotensin-Converting Enzyme Inhibitor or
Angiotensin Receptor Blocker Therapy in Patients With Diabetic
Nephropathy
Paczkowski R 1, Kennedy-Martin T 2, Rayner S 2
Lilly and Company, Inc., Indianapolis, IN, USA, 2Kennedy Martin Health Outcomes, East
Sussex, UK
.
1Eli
.
.
A551
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: Diabetic nephropathy (DN) is a progressive kidney disease that occurs
in around 40% of patients with diabetes, and the recommended treatment is an
angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitor (ACEi) or angiotensin receptor blocker
(ARB). Individuals’ health-related quality of life (HRQoL) can be summarised by
utility values, which reflect preferences for different health states, and are used in
cost-utility analyses (CUAs). This literature review identified the utilities used in
CUAs of ACEi/ARB treatment in patients with DN. Methods: A combined protocol
was developed to identify CUAs of ACEi/ARB treatment in DN as well as studies
that estimated utilities in DN (for a separate review). We searched electronic databases (MEDLINE, EMBASE, NHS EED, HEED, CEA Registry, EconLit, RePEc, HTA) from
1 January 2000 to 31 July 2013. Search results were assessed for relevance by two
reviewers. For eligible CUAs, data extracted included health states with assigned
utilities. Results: Of 5236 references identified from the combined search, 28 CUAs
remained after review of titles/abstracts, and eight after full text review. The CUAs
assessed treatment (ACEi n= 3; ARB n= 4; both n= 1) in patients with type 1 diabetes (n= 2), type 2 diabetes (n= 4) or unspecified diabetes (n= 2). Seven CUAs used a
Markov model and one a decision-analysis tree. Health states in the models included
microalbuminuria, proteinuria, nephropathy, end-stage renal disease (ESRD), nonESRD, dialysis and transplant. ESRD was the most frequent, with utilities ranging
0.53-0.69 (n= 6). Utility data used in the models were sourced from a number of
different studies. Conclusions: For CUAs of ACEi/ARB therapy in patients with
DN, few health states were included, and there was variation in values for the same
health state due to a range of different reference sources being used. It is important
for future economic models of DN therapies that robust utility values are available
for included health states.
PRM45
Modelling Dependence Between Disability Status and Health
Service Costs of People With Rheumatoid Arthritis in Hungary
Rakonczai P 1, Nagy B 1, Rojkovich B 2, Gáti T 2
Consulting Ltd., Budapest, Hungary, 2Buda Hospital of Hospitaller Brothers of
St. John, Budapest, Hungary
.
.
.
.
1Healthware
Objectives: The main objective of this study is to estimate the impact of the level
of functional status and disability on health service costs related to rheumatoid
arthritis (RA) disease in Hungary. It is straightforward to think that higher disability
implies higher costs, where the nature of the relationship is unclear. In order to
explore the dependence structure a novel approach is proposed. Instead of fitting
trend lines for the cost by regression methods the entire bivariate distribution was
modelled. Methods: Health Assessment Questionnaire’s disability index data
were collected for 497 RA patients (with 2594 observations) treated in the Arthritis
Center (AC) Buda Hospital of Hospitaller Brothers of St. John from 1st January 2005
to 31st July 2013. The same patients were also found in the database of National
Health Insurance Fund Administration (NHIFA) and further parameters as e.g.
relevant treatments and health service costs (in- and outpatient) were collected.
After merging AC and NHIFA database the 2 dimensional patterns of the HAQindex measurements versus costs (sum of relevant costs in the following quarter
year) become available for bivariate modelling. The ingredients were the empirical distribution of HAQ-index and quarter year cost, and some parametric copula
families (elliptical or Archimedean) capturing the (possibly non-linear) dependence
structure. The performance of the different model assumptions were compared by
goodness-of-fit procedures. Results: The fitted bivariate distribution based on
the best-performing dependence model are shown in the original “HAQ-index vs.
cost” scale. The differences of average costs for low/medium/high HAQ-index values
are summarized and the conditional distribution functions of costs are presented,
respectively. Conclusions: It has been proved that there is a significant positive dependence between the disability status of RA and health service costs. The
dependence cannot be considered as linear but this non-linearity can be tackled
easily by using copula methods.
PRM46
Pharmacy Cost Calculator for Hepatitis C Virus Patients in Turkey
Baser E 1, Baser O 2, Altinbas A 3, Kariburyo M F 4
1STATinMED Research and Gazi University, Ankara, Turkey, 2STATinMED Research and The
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA, 3Diskapi Yildirim Beyazit Education and Research
Hospital, Gastroenterology Clinic, Ankara, Turkey, 4STATinMED Research, Ann Arbor, MI, USA
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To design a user-friendly cost calculator to estimate and project
health care costs of patients diagnosed with hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection in
Turkey. Methods: We used Visual Basic in a Microsoft Excel to program complicated models within an easy-to-use framework for providers and payers to calculate
pharmacy costs for HCV patients in Turkey. The calculator, first, uses the starting
year to the end year as an input. The user then enters prevalent and incident patient
numbers. Medication types, medication names, prescription numbers per year and
prescription costs per medication are also entered. The calculator allows combination therapies. Depending on response rates, rates of incident and prevalent patients
and medications type, prescription rates from 2014 and forward (until 2020) can
then be calculated and projected. The calculator can be used for any country as
long as the inputs are available through literature from real-world or simulation
studies. Results: We used a hypothetical example to project pharmacy costs in
Turkey in 2014 and 2015. We assumed 10,000 patients in 2014 (20% were assumed to
be treatment naïve) and expected 2,000 new patients in 2015. We assumed ribavirin
and telaprevir combination therapy for 2014 treatment naïve patients, and peginterferon alfa-2a and ribavirin for prevalent patients. The response and treatment rates
were assumed at 80% for patients who were eligible for treatment. The recurrence
rate was assumed to be approximately 10% after treatment. Pharmacy costs for HCV
were calculated at € 7 million in 2014 and approximately € 2 million in 2015, using
these rates. Conclusions: The economic burden of HCV in Turkey is significant.
A simple-to-use calculator that uses real-world data and econometric models to
estimate health care costs of patients with HCV can help payers and providers to
make improved evidence-based health care decisions.
PRM47
A De-Novo Economic Model to Assess Clinical and Economic
Consequences of Bronchiectasis
Bhattacharyya S B 1, Calado F 2, Priedane E 3, Shirore R M 4, Haworth C S 5, Flume P A 6, Sonathi
V 1, Thomas S K 7
1Novartis Healthcare Pvt. Ltd., Hyderabad, India, 2Novartis, East Hanover, NJ, USA, 3Evidera,
London, UK, 4ConvergeHEALTH, Bangalore, India, 5Cambridge Centre for Lung Infection,
Cambridge, UK, 6Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, SC, USA, 7Novartis
Pharmaceuticals Corporation, East Hanover, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Bronchiectasis (BE) is characterised by permanent dilation of bronchi
with destruction of elastic and muscular components of their walls. Prophylactic
antibiotic treatment with acute management of exacerbation episodes is an important component of treatment. Currently there are no approved therapies for BE
and inhaled antibiotics and nebulized solutions are used off-label. The objective
of this study was to predict clinical and economic consequences associated with
BE in adult patients over their lifetime. Methods: We developed a Markov cohort
model with a cycle length of 4 weeks from UK health care perspective. The model
included 4 Markov states: one stable disease state defined as confirmed non - cystic
fibrosis bronchiectasis and without exacerbations in the previous 4 weeks and three
exacerbation states defined on the basis of severity of exacerbation and associated
health care resource utilization. Disease state specific costs included costs of drugs,
consultations/visits, diagnostic test/procedures, physiotherapy, emergency room
visits and hospitalizations. Patient baseline characteristics, exacerbation rates and
utilities were estimated from literature. Results: The model suggests that ability to
reduce hospitalizations and limit impact on quality of life are the major value drivers. The model is also sensitive to baseline risk of exacerbations. A treatment for BE
that results in 35% reduction in exacerbation rates and related hospitalizations may
result in a reduction of 15.53 exacerbations and 3.23 hospitalizations per patient
over lifetime. Reduction in number of hospitalization will result in fewer long-term
complications, leading to reduction of 1 death per 600 patients over a period of 10
years. The treatment could result in reduction of medical cost by £10,777 and 0.11
QALY gain per patient over lifetime. Conclusions: Any health care intervention
that could reduce the number of exacerbations and related hospitalizations in the
BE patients can have significant beneficial impact on clinical outcomes, costs and
quality of life.
PRM48
Different Strategies for Latent TB Assessment in Patients
Undergoing Anti-TNF Treatment: an Economic Model
Pierotti F , Trieste L , Turchetti G
Scuola Superiore Sant’Anna, Pisa, Italy
.
.
.
Objectives: Since treatment with biologics may reactivate latent TB, testing and
prophylaxes before initiating therapy are mandatory. However, there is not a unique
solution for the number and type of tests to be used for detecting the presence of TB,
and for the definition of when prophylaxis should be prescribed. Which alternative
should be preferred depends on the effectiveness of treatment and also on the cost
associated. This methodological study aims to define a general economic model to
assess different protocols for latent TB detection in patients undergoing anti-TNF
treatment. Methods: A decision tree approach has been designed for comparing
alternative protocols in terms of (a) expected costs of different strategies for latent
TB assessment in patients undergoing anti-TNF treatment; b) the economic convenience of the prophylaxis therapy in presence of a negative chest X-ray. Uncertainty is
expressed by the probability of being positive and negative to the tests. In the NHS
perspective the model considers: costs of tests; costs of TB onsets for rheumatologic patients who undergo biologics; costs of extending anti TB prophylaxis also
to false negative patients; costs related to 1-month biologic therapy delay because
of prophylaxis; costs for adverse events therapy and/or test related. Indirect costs
are also considered in the broader societal perspective. Results: Costs assessed
are useful to choose the less costly alternatives. The comparison also considers
the reduction of false negatives to the tests which do not follow prophylaxis while
being affected by latent TB. Conclusions: The model, that can represent a useful
tool both for clinical and health policy decision making, is a general one; it can be
applied to any country by inserting the country specific epidemiological, clinical,
and economical data, and to any anti-TNF drug, by using the specific biologic drugrelated risk factor.
PRM50
An Efficient Design for Cost-Effectiveness Studies of Personalized
Medicine Strategies
Leunis A 1, Redekop W K 2, Lowenberg B 3, Uyl-De Groot C A 4
1Institute for Medical Techonology Assessment (iMTA), Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 2Erasmus
University, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 3Erasmus Medical Center, Rotterdam, The Netherlands,
4Institute for Medical Technology Assessment (iMTA), Erasmus University, Rotterdam, The
Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The aim of this study is to assess how cost-effectiveness analyses of
personalized medicine approaches (PMA) can be efficiently designed by using a
case study in the field of acute myeloid leukemia. Methods: The cost-effectiveness analysis of the PMA was performed in two steps. As a PMA often only causes a
treatment change in a specified subgroup of the patients, the cost-effectiveness of
the identified treatment change was estimated as a first step (restricted analyses).
Subsequently, a full cost-effectiveness analysis was performed which included
all patients and the costs of identifying the specified subgroup. The relationship between the full and restricted analyses was evaluated by varying different
input parameters. Results: It was found that the full cost-effectiveness of a
PMA approach could be described as a function of the (cost-) effectiveness of the
treatment change in the specified subgroup, the costs of identifying the subgroup
and the size of the subgroup. If no additional costs are associated with the identification of the subgroup, the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of the
full analysis is identical to the ICER of the restricted analysis. Otherwise, the ICER
A552
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
increases with higher test costs, smaller subgroup and smaller incremental effects
due to the treatment change. Conclusions: The data collection of costs, survival
and quality of life of PMAs should be restricted to the subgroup for whom treatment changes. Therefore, cost-effectiveness analyses of PMAs should start with
identifying that subgroup. Once the size of the subgroup, the cost-effectiveness
of the treatment change and the test costs are known, the full cost-effectiveness
can be easily calculated. The described function can also be used to assess the
potential cost-effectiveness of future PMAs. If a PMA causes a treatment change
in a small subgroup, the PMA can only be cost-effective with low test costs or
large incremental effects.
PRM51
Methods for Health Economic Evaluations of Vaccines – Results
from an International Expert-Workshop
Ultsch B 1, Damm O 2, Beutels P 3, Bilcke J 3, Brüggenjürgen B 4, Gerber-Grote A U 5, Greiner W 2,
Hanquet G 6, Harder T 7, Hutubessy R 8, Jit M 9, Knol M 10, Kuhlmann A 11, von Kries R 12,
Levy-Bruhl D 13, Perleth M 14, Postma M J 15, Salo H 16, Siebert U 17, Wasem J 18,
Weidemann F 19, Wichmann O 7
1Robert Koch Institute / Charité University Medical Center, Berlin, Germany, 2School of Public
Health, Bielefeld University, Bielefeld, Germany, 3University of Antwerp, Antwerp, Belgium,
4Steinbeis University Berlin (SHB), Berlin, Germany, 5Institute for Quality and Efficiency in
Health Care (IQWiG), Cologne, Germany, 6Belgian Health Care Knowledge Centre (KCE),
Brussels, Belgium, 7Robert Koch Institute, Berlin, Germany, 8World Health Organization, Geneva,
Switzerland, 9London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine / Public Health England (PHE),
London, UK, 10RIVM - Centre for Infectious Disease Control, Bilthoven, The Netherlands, 11Leibniz
Universität Hannover, Hannover, Germany, 12Ludwig-Maximilians-University Munich (LMU),
Munich, Germany, 13Institut de Veille Sanitaire, Saint-Maurice Cedex, France, 14Gemeinsamer
Bundesausschuss (G-BA), Berlin, Germany, 15University of Groningen, Groningen, The
Netherlands, 16National Institute for Health and Welfare, Helsinki, Finland, 17Medical Informatics
and Technology, and Director of the Division for Health Technology Assessment and Bioinformatics,
ONCOTYROL, Hall i. T, Austria, 18University of Duisburg-Essen, Essen, Germany, 19Robert Koch
Institute / Charité Berlin, Berlin, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Health economic evaluations (HEEs) of vaccines are commonly considered during immunization introduction decision-making processes in most
industrialized countries. Despite the availability of guidelines advocating more
standardization for such HEEs, there are still several infection/immunization-specific particularities that are debated in the scientific community. An international
expert-workshop was convened to identify good practices for (i) how to conduct
HEEs of vaccines and (ii) how to consider results of HEE in vaccine introduction
decision-making. Methods: A systematic literature search was conducted to
identify prevailing opinions and remaining issues of HEE in vaccination. Twentytwo experts in the field of health economics and immunization decision-making
were invited to a workshop and were asked to answer a survey-questionnaire
based on the systematic literature search beforehand to inform the preparation of group work sessions (GWS). In GWS, issues focusing on ‘mathematical
modeling’, ‘health economics’, and ‘decision-making’ were discussed and summarized. Results: The GWS (based on systematic literature search) included
topics such as cost-components, quality of life (QoL), discounting, and perspectives leading to suggestions such as including caregiver QoL impact and applying
decreasing time-related discount rates. Since vaccination often causes indirect
effects, the use of dynamic models is required and exceptions should be justified. In order to facilitate transparent decision-making, the results of HEE should
present parameter and methodological uncertainty as well as cumulative and
time-specific figures. The majority of countries in Europe use results from HEEs
in an informal judgment-process without willingness to pay (WTP) threshold. The
expert-group emphasized that transparency should be maximized in decisionmaking process. Conclusions: The deliberations led to suggestions on several
HEE issues. However, vaccines not always need to be considered differently in HEE
since other interventions might share similar characteristics. Transparency in the
conduct and presentation of HEE, and subsequent decision-making is essential,
especially in the absence of explicit WTP thresholds.
across every stage, all of which are fully transparent, provides a unique combination
of broadness, resilience and inclusiveness making it an ideal decision making tool.
PRM53
Comparison of Generic, Condition-Specific and Mapped Health State
Utility Values for Pediatric Asthma
Gialetti S 1, Trieste L 2, Pierotti F 2, Turchetti G 2, Silvestri M 1, Della Casa Alberighi O 1
1Institute Giannina Gaslini, Genova, Italy, 2Scuola Superiore Sant’Anna, Pisa, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Many aspects of QALY measurement in children are not yet fully
developed. This study is aimed at contextualizing the mapping methodology
in a field not yet covered: paediatric asthma. The objective is to derive utility
values from non-preference-based questionnaires, the estimated utility values
will be useful for QALY assessment by means of: i) evaluation of a linear mapping between the generic preference-based EQ-5D-3L (self- and proxy-versions)
and the condition-specific non-preference-based Paediatric Asthma Quality of
Life Questionnaire (PAQLQ) and Paediatric Asthma Caregiver’s Quality of Life
Questionnaire (PACQLQ), respectively; ii) assessment of the capability of mapping to discriminate for disease severity. Methods: Either PAQLQ or PACQLQ and
EQ-5D-3L will be administrated to 170 asthma children (7-17 years of age) during
a 24-month multicenter randomized placebo-controlled trial of allergen specific
sublingual immunotherapy coded EudraCT No. 2012-005678-76/FARM94793N at
baseline, month 12, and month 24 visits. Level of severity will be assessed using
the Asthma Control Test (ACT) and the Childhood-ACT (C-ACT) questionnaires.
The possibility of a linear mapping will be evaluated through a Tobit model, where
either PAQLQ/PACQLQ will be tested as predictors of EQ-5D-3L answers. Capability
of mapping to be sensible in changes of disease severity will be measured
through a Pearson’s correlation between changes in estimated EQ-5D-3L scores
and changes in ACT and C-ACT answers. Results: Linear mapping, if feasible,
applies the statistical relationship between either PAQLQ or PACQLQ and EQ-5D-3L,
being PAQLQ/PACQLQ answers predictors of EQ-5D-3L score. EQ-5D-3L and PAQLQ/
PACQLQ, as well as EQ-5D-3L built on PAQLQ/PACQLQ answers by applying the
linear mapping is expected to discriminate for both patients’ level and changes
in disease severity. Conclusions: This study seeks to inform policy makers in
their choice of the source of utility values and their discrimination across severity
groups and responsiveness in asthma children.
PRM54
Estimating Means from Medians: A Case Study With Treatments for
Metastatic Colorectal Cancer (MCRC)
Ozer-Stillman I 1, Whalen J D 2, Mendivil J 3, Villegas-Sánchez J 3, Chang J 4
1Evidera, Lexington, MA, USA, 2Evidera, Inc., London, UK, 3Bayer Hispania, Barcelona, Spain,
4Bayer HealthCare, Whippany, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
PRM52
Applying Multiple Criteria Decision Analysis in the Context of
Health Technology Assessement: an Empirical Case Study
Objectives: Guidelines for economic evaluation from ISPOR and NICE recommend the use of mean values rather than medians, but do not offer guidance for
situations when mean values are not available. This study evaluated the impact
of different methods of estimating means from medians, within the context of
estimating treatment duration for drugs used to treat mCRC. Methods: Clinical
trials and prescribing information for drugs used to treat mCRC were reviewed
for information on the mean, median, and range of treatment cycles. Various
approaches were used to estimate mean values, including direct use of the median,
a published equation considering the median and range, confidence intervals and
interquartile range, and the use of distributions commonly used in survival analysis. Where possible, the estimated means were compared with reported means
from clinical trials. Results: Very few studies reported both median and mean
treatment duration; direct use of the median under-predicted the mean by 23-39%
and the published equation over-predicted the mean by 19-28%. Simple assumptions about the distribution of treatment durations performed best, predicting the
reported mean within ±12%. The use of progression-free survival as a proxy for
treatment duration over-predicted treatment duration by 5-38%, although estimates were improved by accounting for early discontinuation. Conclusions:
By only considering the 50th percentile, the median may not provide an accurate
representation of the outcomes in a population. It is important that researchers
and budget-holders are aware of the limitations in the use of medians, and that
they consider multiple estimation methods to estimate mean values for economic
analyses.
Angelis A , Kanavos P
London School of Economics and Political Science, London, UK, Past research has indicated
that Multiple Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) approaches could be used as an alternative
methodology for assessing the value of medical technologies from a Health Technology Assessment
(HTA) perspective.
PRM55
Adopting an Evidence Synthesis Approach for Assessing CostEffectiveness of Screening Strategies for Prostate Cancer in
Ireland
.
.
Objectives: To apply in practise an MCDA framework for the value assessment of
a set of therapeutic options in regards to an oncology indication through an HTA
simulation exercise. Methods: Using MCDA principles, past research outcomes
and the clinical and economic literature, a disease specific value tree was constructed incorporating the values concerned as criteria. The alternative options
were scored against the criteria through the development of value functions,
weights were assigned to the criteria using a swing method, scores and weights
were aggregated using a linear additive model, and sensitivity analysis of the results
was conducted. All the stages were informed by extensive stakeholder engagement through their participation at a decision conference workshop. Results:
Value parameters considered included burden of illness, therapeutic, safety, innovation and socioeconomic criteria. Overall value scores were produced reflecting
the performance of the options against the criteria while considering their relative
importance. Hypothetical payer’s resource allocation decisions on the coverage of
the options were made on “value for money” grounds through the use of “cost-perunit of value” that was derived by incorporating purchasing costs. Conclusions:
MCDA possesses the prerequisites of a value based assessment methodological
framework. The multiplicity of criteria that can be incorporated to assess value,
the weights that can be applied to the criteria, and the stakeholders’ involvement
Burns R M 1, Leal J 1, Wolstenhome J 1, O’Neill C 2, Sullivan F J 3, Drummond F J 4, Sharp L 4
1University of Oxford, Oxford, UK, 2National University of Ireland Galway, Galway City, Ireland,
3Prostate Cancer Institutue, Galway, Ireland, 4National Cancer Registry Ireland, Cork, Ireland
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Prostate cancer (PCa) incidence has been steadily increasing over the
last twenty years, resulting in Ireland having the highest incidence rate in Europe
in 2008. The main driver of this is wide-spread use of prostate specific antigen
(PSA) testing in primary care as an ad-hoc detection mechanism. The objective of
this research was to undertake a cost-effectiveness analysis of organised screening
using PSA testing in Ireland. Methods: Using a Bayesian Multi-Parameter Evidence
Synthesis (MPES) framework, non-cost parameters were synthesised, informed by
incidence, mortality and clinical data from the National Cancer Registry Ireland
for men diagnosed with PCa in 2009. The MPES framework estimates unobserved
parameters using available evidence and so facilitates analysis of interventions
where observational data is limited. Average costs were estimated using projectspecific survey costs, Irish hospital costs (HSE Casemix) and costs published in the
literature. Effectiveness of PSA testing was sourced from the literature. Utility scores
were collected from 2,500 PCa survivors. The cost-effectiveness analysis employed
a cohort, semi-Markov model following men from age 30 to death. A range of PSA
screening strategies were compared with no PSA testing and an extensive series of
A553
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
scenario analysis was employed. PSA cut-off levels were varied between > 3ng/ml
and > 4ng/ml reflecting European guidance and practice variation in Ireland. Costs
and benefits were discounted at 5% per annum. Results: Extensive probabilistic
sensitivity analyses highlighted wide variation in incremental cost-effectiveness
ratios (ICERs). PSA testing may be cost effective using a once-off test at age 50 or age
55 depending on the ceiling ratio incorporated. Results for the ≥3ng/ml PSA cut-off
consistently dominated those for the ≥ 4ng/ml PSA cut-off. Conclusions: This
analysis illustrates the value MPES methods for economic modelling of interventions. The results contribute to the ongoing accumulation of evidence on the costs
and benefits of PSA testing internationally.
RESEARCH ON METHODS – Databases & Management Methods
PRM56
Preliminary Steps in the Development of an Algorithm for
Identifying Relapsed CLL Patients in Secondary Data
Foley K A 1, Princic N 1, Bizier R 1, Hansen L G 2, Huse D M 1
Health Analytics, Cambridge, MA, USA, 2Truven Health Analytics, Northwood, NH, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
clarifying and updating ClinRO information. Methods: PROQOLID was searched on
April 9, 2014 to retrieve current information about ClinROs using an advanced search
engine. Results: The ClinRO information was found under the category “mode of
administration” in the subcategory “clinician-rated.” Out of the 801 questionnaires
in the database, fifty-two (6.5%) were identified as ClinROs. Out of these 52 questionnaires, nine were generic. Eight different therapeutic areas were identified (i.e.,
digestive system diseases, musculoskeletal diseases, neoplasms, nervous system
diseases, respiratory tract diseases, psychiatric disorders, pathological conditions
signs and symptoms, and skin and connective tissue diseases), representing 17 different indications, and 33.33% of the therapeutic areas included in PROQOLID (n=24).
The most represented therapeutic area was psychiatry (n= 23) followed by nervous
diseases (n= 7). Only two questionnaires were specific to children: the Pediatric
Evaluation of Disabilty Inventory and the WeeFIM®. To better individualize ClinRO
information in PROQOLID, it is proposed to create a new meta-category, i.e., type of
COA (PRO, ClinRO, ObsRO and PerfRO). It is also recommended to expand PROQOLID
to all COAs. Conclusions: This review has shown that PROQOLID already includes
ClinRO information. Recommendations are given on how to modify the organization
and content of the database to present information on all COAs.
1Truven
Objectives: Despite advances in chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL) treatment,
roughly 25% of first and 50% of second line patients experience relapse. Relapse,
however, is not well coded in claims data and is not well documented in EMR data
due to under reporting of patient status, variability in terminology used to report
patient status, and change in disease progression over time. The goal of this analysis
was to develop an algorithm to identify relapsed patients when patient status is
not clearly documented. Methods: CLL patients in the MarketScan® Oncology
EMR Database with recorded patient status were identified. Relapse was explored
using two methods: 1) recorded patient status of relapse; 2) changes in laboratory
data. For the first phase of algorithm development, both indications of relapse were
compared to the date of treatment initiation. Laboratory data included lymphocytes,
platelets, and hemoglobin. Results: Of 18,334 patients with CLL, 7,865 (43%) had
any patient status reported. 528 had any mention of either relapse or remission
and 73 (1%) patients had a record for relapse on the same date as a CLL diagnosis
and no evidence of any other cancer types. For these 73 patients, the date of new
treatment initiation had no relationship with the date of the first recorded relapse.
Among these same patients, declines in hemoglobin and platelets, and increases in
lymphocytes preceded treatment initiation by several days. Conclusions: Patient
status does not appear to be updated regularly and documented status may not
indicate decision to treat. This preliminary work suggests that lab data provide a
viable source for algorithm development as they are regularly reported in the EMR
and for CLL are likely linked to decision to treat. Next steps include determining
the specific rule for identifying the change in lab values that triggers treatment
initiation or resumption.
PRM57
Occurrence, Survival And Annual Cost of Colorectal-, Breast-,
Prostate- and Lung Cancer in Hungary
Inotai A 1, Abonyi-Tóth Z 2, Rokszin G 2, Voko Z 1
Research Institute, Budapest, Hungary,, 2RxTarget, Szolnok, Hungary
.
.
.
.
1Syreon
Objectives: Evaluating effectiveness of oncological treatments and their costs
becomes more and more important with respect to the high burden of malignant
diseases. The aim of this research was to estimate the occurrence, survival and
health care cost of colorectal-, breast-, prostate- and lung cancer patients based on
the National Health Insurance Fund (NHIF) database. Methods: Survival and cost
analyses were performed on the NHIF database. Inclusion criteria: at least two consecutive ICD codes between 2000 and 2012, with a minimum of 30 days difference;
or those with one ICD code, followed by death within 60 days. The following ICDs
were considered: C18-C20 (colorectal), C33-C34 (lung), C50 (breast), C61 (prostate).
428 860 social security numbers met our inclusion criteria. The following indicators
were estimated: number of new cases, mortality, time from diagnosis to treatment,
survival and annual costs related and not related to the disease. Results: In 2011,
the numbers of new cases were the following: colorectal cancer: 7299 breast cancer:
5842, prostate cancer: 3162, and lung cancer: 5499. The probability of 5-year overall survival from first diagnosis were 41.3%, 75.2%, 62.1% and 17.1%, respectively.
Median time from first diagnosis to treatment initiation was less than 1 month
in colorectal-, breast- and prostate cancer and less than 2 months in lung cancer.
Annual cost of patient was 3166 EUR (colorectal cancer), 2585 EUR (breast cancer),
2833 EUR (prostate cancer) and 4158 EUR (lung cancer), respectively (2011 average
exchange rate: 279.21 HUF/EUR). These figures indicate that annual cost of care of
these malignant patients are less than half of the annual cost of kidney transplanted
and haemophilia patients estimated with similar methodology. Conclusions:
Data suggest that payer’s database is suitable for estimating epidemiologic and
economic indicators of malignant disorders. Payer’s database analysis can support
evidence-based policy-making.
PRM58
Update of the Patient-Reported Outcome and Quality of Life
Instruments Database (PROQOLID): Integration of The New COA
Taxonomy - The Clinro Example
Perrier L L , Conway K , Acquadro C
Mapi Research Trust, Lyon, France
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In 2002, PROQOLID was launched to provide an overview of existing
PRO instruments. In October 2011, the term Clinical Outcome Assessments (COAs)
was introduced to better reflect the importance of the source of information in
measurements: patients (PROs), clinicians (ClinROs), and observers (ObsROs). In May
2013, a new category was added: Performance outcome assessments (PerfOs). With
this evolving taxonomy, including information about all COAs might become a crucial step in developing PROQOLID. The objective of this study was: (1) To review how
ClinROs are currently reported in PROQOLID; and (2) To propose (if needed) ways of
PRM59
ECOA Licensing: Lessons Learned from the Copyright of COA
Translations and Specificities of ECOAS
Anfray C 1, Conway K 2, Acquadro C 2
1Mapi, Lyon, France, 2Mapi Research Trust, Lyon, France
.
.
.
Objectives: Electronic Clinical Outcome Assessments (eCOAs) are increasingly
being used in clinical trials and their use is encouraged by regulatory authorities.
Licensing is a key issue for their appropriate utilization. The objective of this abstract
is to make recommendations about eCOA licensing using lessons learned from the
COA translation licensing. Methods: Publications about licensing of COA translations were searched and a review of the eCOAs specificities was performed using
information available from e-vendors. Results: Very few publications exist about
the licensing of COA translations. The ISOQOL TCA SIG has developed a draft reflection paper which considers that translations are derivative work of original questionnaires. As such, they recommend that the copyright of a COA and its translations
should be owned by a unique entity, generally the original developer to harmonize
and facilitate conditions of access and use. They state that distribution should be
centralized to facilitate access to questionnaires, maintain reliable information
about them, and control their use. Review of the e-vendors information shows that
eCOAs are often customized, with proprietary devices and softwares, and cannot be
shared across users. As a consequence, there is a multiplication of e-versions for a
same content. Equivalence between paper and e-versions and between e-versions
is then a major concern. The review also shows that migration from paper to the
electronic platform/device implies changes to the content and format of the paper
version. Therefore the eCOAs can be considered as derivative works of an original
COA and lessons learned from copyright of translations may apply. Examples will
be provided. Conclusions: Centralized copyright ownership by the owner of the
original COA and centralized licensing process for eCOAs should be discussed with
all stakeholders to help controlling use and users and to protect the integrity of
the instrument across e-versions by providing clear rules of e-implementation.
PRM60
Mapping European Database Usage: An Analysis of Published Data
Types
Langham S 1, Pooley N 2, Weir S 1
1PHMR Associates, London, UK, 2PHMR Associates, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: To determine how European databases are used to support pharmacoepidemiological research. Randomised, controlled trials remain the gold standard
for evaluation of drug efficacy and safety. However, the only way of identifying treatment pathways and improving understanding of real world costs and outcomes at
different stages of care is via longitudinal observational studies. Observational data
from electronic health records (EHRs) are essential to this pharmaco-epidemiological research. Different European databases have different strengths in terms of data
types and availability. Identifying these strengths will help to select the right database for a particular study. In this context, one approach to increasing our understanding is to analyse types of published data to determine how databases have
historically been used to support research. Methods: We identified peer-reviewed
publications over the last 10 years from one popular longitudinal general practice
patient database with some secondary care links. The publications were assigned
to disease areas and study types (e.g. prevalence, resource utilisation, treatment
patterns, outcomes etc). Results: Based on this mapping exercise, we identified
the types of studies and the disease areas that this European database commonly
supports. We also highlight gaps in disease area coverage and types of real world
evidence studies and discuss potential reasons for this underuse. Conclusions:
European observational data from EHRs provide increasingly important information
for stakeholders of new treatment, however there are still a number of gaps in terms
of disease areas and study types that these databases can support.
PRM61
Using an Innovative Approach to Build a Prospective Diabetes
Cohort Registry of Patients With Type 2 Diabetes in Germany: DIAREG
Garcia Alvarez L 1, Rathmann W 2, Bode-Greuel K 3, Engelhard J 3, Bush S 4, SchröderBernhardi D 3, Hiller J 1
1IMS Health, London, UK, 2German Diabetes Center, Duesseldorf, Germany, 3IMS Health, Frankfurt
am Main, Germany, 4AstraZeneca, Hamburg Area, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The lack of accessible, comprehensive sources of medical and quality
of life data in Germany has partially hindered the ability to research diabetes clinical
practice. The aim of this study was to build a prospective, national, multi-centre Type
2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) registry using an innovative data collection methodology to better understand the disease specific epidemiology, treatment patterns and
A554
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
patient reported outcomes (PRO). Methods: From the physician universe of the
IMS®Disease Analyzer (1,500 diabetologists and 57,500 general practitioners), a subset of 101 physicians have agreed to participate. Pre-programmed inclusion criteria
(i.e. ≥ 18 years old with T2DM diagnosis) triggers consecutive patient selection for
further data collection. A custom software-based electronic case report form (eCRF)
is completed once per quarter by the physician to capture further diabetes information. Patients complete a validated set of PROs at physician office every 6 months.
Anonymised data from the electronic medical record (EMR), eCRF and PRO are linked
through a unique process to ensure patient confidentiality. Results: A total of 1,029
T2DM patients are contributing to the registry (at June 2014). Preliminary analysis
of the DIAREG cohort has shown comparable representativeness to IMS®Disease
Analyzer for several patient characteristics: age, gender, distribution of T2DM treatment and physician type. The DIAREG improves research use of the EMR data by
filling in missing information for weight, blood pressure and HbA1C (e.g. completeness of HbA1C records improved from 42.3% to 83.3% of patients). The DIAREG
enhances breadth of information by collecting data that is not normally captured
in EMR sources, such as physician rationale related to treatment choice or switch,
target HbA1C, hypoglycaemic events, occurrence of micro or macrovascular events,
and patient reported information (e.g. quality of life, treatment satisfaction and
depression). Conclusions: DIAREG enables unique capability to research T2DM
in Germany through multiple linked longitudinal data sources.
PRM62
Insight In Health Care Databases in Asian Pacific Region
Velthuis E J M
PPD, Bennekom, The Netherlands
.
.
.
Objectives: Health care utilization databases or electronic medical records can be
very useful to study the use and outcomes of pharmacological and therapeutical
measures. There is little information on the availability and accessibility of these
types of databases for health and disease management in the Asian Pacific Region.
This study is performed to gain more insight in the availability and accessibility
of health care utilization databases in AsiaPac. Methods: Searches were done
using Google Scholar, PubMed, ISPOR’s International Digest of Databases and references in publications. Different types of databases were included in the overview,
including health insurance databases, claims databases and electronic medical
records from primary care of hospitals. Information extracted was: type of database,
short description, population covered, start of data collection, variables included,
accessibility, URL and English language yes/no. Countries included were Australia,
China, Japan, South Korea, Malaysia, Singapore and Thailand. Results: Most of the
databases originate in Japan and Australia. Taiwan and South Korea have a large
health insurance databases covering ~98% of the population. Limited number of
databases is available in the other countries investigated. Accessibility could only be
derived from the websites that provide an English translation. From these websites
it appears that accessibility to these databases is often limited for health policy
makers and researchers due to privacy protection issues. Conclusions: Several
valuable health care utilization databases exist in the Asian Pacific region. These
databases could be very valuable in drug utilization and health outcomes research
if easily available to all researchers.
PRM63
Evaluation of Dissemination of Brazilian Network for Health
Technology Assessment (REBRATS)
L 1, Souza
KM2
Gonçalves
1Brazilian Ministry of Health, Brasília-DF, Brazil, 2Brazilian Ministry of Health, Brasília, Brazil
.
.
.
has been believed that EMR system improved efficacy of the hospital. But a pure
hospital management/financial meaning of EMR is still not clear. It is said that the
total costs for maintaining EMR are 2-5% of medical revenue and they are continuously needed. In Japan, in order to increase the efficiency of a clinical trial/research,
government is planning to set up one big virtual hospital using EMR and IT technology. In this study, we analyze the change in financial condition and the price of
EMR system. Methods: From the hospital website and financial statement, we
checked when and whether EMR was introduced. Then we analyzed the change
in financial condition of the hospital that introduced EMR with the hospital that
did not introduce EMR using the financial statements of 143 hospitals in National
Hospital Organization (NHO). The information of the EMR price was obtained from
the government website. Results: In 2011, there were 44 hospitals that had introduced EMR. Comparing the financial condition between the hospital with EMR and
the hospital without EMR, there was 1% or more of difference in medical revenue.
The average price of EMR for 1 year per 1 bed was US$328.8. Conclusions: The
result demonstrated that the price of all EMR system did not improve hospital
finance and efficiency. Because of the high cost EMR system, making one big virtual
hospital using IT technology is still difficult. Therefore, we need more cost effective
and easy EMR system.
PRM65
A Dutch Administrative Database in Support of Economic
Evaluations: A Feasibility Study
Tan S S , Bouwmans C , Hakkaart L
Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To support tariff setting of Diagnosis Related Groups in the
Netherlands, the hospital services of each patient are systematically collected in
a national database. This database may also serve as an important data source
for economic evaluations. Our study assessed the feasibility of the database to
support economic evaluations. Methods: Treatment costs for acute myocardial
infarction (AMI) and breast cancer were determined for 2012 from the hospital
perspective, with the national database as the primary data source. Results:
Using the national database as a primary data source for economic evaluations
has several limitations. Firstly, the database does not contain unit costs of hospital services. Thus, we had to rely on alternative data sources such as reference
prices. Secondly, the establishment of relevant patient-subgroups is not always
possible because only few clinical parameters are recorded. Although we were
able to identify relevant patient subgroups for AMI (ST segment vs non-ST segment elevated patients and PCI vs conventional treatment), this was not possible
for breast cancer where different stages of disease could not be distinguished.
Lastly, some resource quantities, such as medications and medical devices, are
not routinely collected. Conclusions: Using the national database as the input
of resource quantities in economic evaluations may result in valid cost estimates,
especially when relevant subgroups can be identified. The cost assessment of AMI
has proven that the database enables the collection of resource quantities for
individual patients from a single data source and thus increases the comparability
of health economic outcomes.
PRM66
Impact of Influenza B in France
Lamure M 1, Cohen J M 2, Pribil C 3, Garassus P 4, Auray J 5, Fleming D 6, Pujol P3
1University Claude Bernard Lyon 1, Paris, France, 2Regional Group for the Surveillance of Influenza
- GROG, Open Rome, Paris, France, 3GSK, Marly Le Roi, France, 4BAQIMEHP, Paris, France, 5Cyklad
Group, Rilleux la Pape, France, 6University Of Surrey, GUILDFORD, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The Brazilian Network for Health Technology Assessment (REBRATS)
spreads the HTA culture in health services and academic institutions, and also
supports policy makers and managers in the decision-making process. It works
through six working groups that prioritizes HTA settings and themes; develops
methodological guidelines; trains professionals; and manage and disseminates
information. This study aims to demonstrate REBRATS´s advances based on the
productivity of the network members. Methods: Analysis of the network performance through the number of publications available on the REBRATS database; number of accesses to the REBRATS webpage obtained through the access
tool and data extraction by Google Analytics, monitoring the participation on the
REBRATS social networking and computing new network members. Results:
Since REBRATS´ implementation in 2008, it was made available on its website 62
publications including Guidelines, HTA Bulletins and others, and 364 studies in
its database. In 2014, 64 institutions are already member of the network, representing an increase of over 45% compared to 2008. Additionally, the site began
to be tracked in mid-2012, when the average number of accesses was 36,659 and
approximately 2037 per monthly in more than 85 countries. Since March 2012,
when REBRATS social network on Facebook was created, there have been more
than 300 published news with approximately 43,891 views and an average of 143
visualizations per issue reported by the network. Conclusions: The strategies
for advertising the network and disseminate the HTA products produced by its
members have contributed significantly to the advance of HTA in Brazil, beyond
the reach of people interested in this research field. Efforts should be directed
towards advertising the production internationally.
Objectives: To evaluate the burden of influenza B in terms of hospitalizations
and deaths in France. Methods: The analysis of the impact of influenza B used 3
French databases 1) hospitalization for respiratory diseases, 2) deaths resulting from
cardiorespiratory disease, and 3) information on circulating strains. The analysis
covered the period 2003 through to 2011. The study is based on an indirect approach
of modeling where hospitalization, mortality and virology time series data will be
extracted as monthly or weekly aggregated information. The numbers of hospitalizations and deaths attributable to influenza B were determined from positive
virological analysis through a regression model (considering all influenza circulating strains classified by type and subtype) firstly over the total French population,
and then by age category (0-4 years, 5-12, 15-64, 65 and above). A second method to
estimate the excess of hospitalizations and deaths during influenza epidemic periods vs. non-epidemic periods was also used. Results: Over the period 2003-2011,
nearly 28,000 hospitalizations and 12,000 deaths on average were associated with
influenza each year. The percentages of hospitalizations and deaths attributable
to influenza B were 33% (9,200) and 34% (4,000) respectively, amongst the overall
population. These were observed predominantly in the elderly (> 65 years): 66% of
hospitalizations and 94% of deaths. The two methods used show similar results,
with a difference globally of less than 5%. Conclusions: On average each year
around 9,200 hospitalizations and 4,000 cardiorespiratory deaths are associated
with epidemics of influenza B in France.
PRM64
Analysis of the Expenses for the Introduction of Electric Medical
Record System in the National Hospital Organization
Zulkifly H 1, Dingle K 2, Clavarino A 3
1Universiti Teknologi Mara, Selangor, Malaysia, 2Queensland University of Technology, Kelvin
Grove, Queensland, Australia, 3Univesity of Queensland, Woolloongabba, QLD, Australia
Nakagawa Y 1, Tomita N 2, Irisa K 1, Ito M 1, Nakagawa Y 1
Hospital Organization Shikoku Medical Center for Children and Adults, Zentuji city,
Japan, 2National Institute of Public Health, Saitama, Japan
Objectives: To identify the long term effects of common symptoms of pregnancy
and whether these increase the risk of cardiovascular disease or symptoms associated with it in women at 21 years after pregnancy. Methods: Data used were
from the Mater University Study of Pregnancy (MUSP), a community- based prospective birth cohort study begun in Brisbane, Australia, in 1983. Chi square test
and logistic regression analyses were conducted. Results: Data were available for
3692 women. In cross tabulations, morning sickness, heartburn and backache show
.
.
.
.
.
1National
Objectives: Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare (MHLW) of Japan announced
the rule about electronic preservation of a medical record in 1999. Then, introduction of Electric Medical Record (EMR) into a hospital was started. Government set
a target of diffusion rate of EMR to 60% in 2006, but the result was only 20-30%. It
PRM67
Common Pregnancy Symptoms Increase the Risk Of Cardiovascular
Disease
.
.
.
A555
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
positive association (p< 0.05) with different cardiovascular outcomes. However, in
the multivariate models, only those experiencing heartburn (adjusted OR 1.3, 95%
CI 1.0-1.7) during pregnancy were at greater risk of having hypertension 21 years
post partum. Women experiencing morning sickness (adjusted OR 1.2, 95% CI 0.82.0) and backache (adjusted OR 1.1, 95% CI 0.6-1.7) were not considered to be at
risk for future heart disease. Conclusions: As a whole, our study suggests that
most common symptoms of pregnancy are not associated with an increased risk
of cardiovascular disease or with hypertension in the long term.
PRM68
Increased Accuracy of Distribution Based Missing Value Imputation:
An Alternative to Mean Inputation in Real World Environment
Survey Research
Wasser T , Eisenberg D
HealthCore, Inc., Wilmington, DE, USA
.
.
Objectives: Missing values within variables can impede accurate data analysis
on many levels including both univariate and multivariate analysis. This research
presents distribution-based imputation (DBI), where the distribution of non-missing
values is simulated to create a set of values that are then randomly inserted into to
the missing values in the actual data and compares this against mean based imputation (MBI). Methods: DBI was compared to MBI in 12 different simulation conditions based on three sample sizes (50, 100, 150 and 200) and three different missing
value percentages for each of the sample sizes (10%, 20% and 30%). Each simulation
created 1,000 test datasets within each condition for a total of 12,000 simulated
datasets. The statistical package, R was used for the sumilation. Results: MBI
was biased by simulating smaller Standard Deviations, and less accurate in mean
estimation than DBI in all 12 simulation combinations. DBI was more accurate in
matching the number of rejected hypotheses as compared to the gold standard.
Comparing the calculated p-values for bias where an unbiased estimator would
demonstrate a 50/50 split being greater than and less than the gold standard, DBI
was closer to the gold standard with at 48.7/51.3 split, as compared to the 25.8/74.2
split of MBI. Conclusions: DBI was found to be more accurate and unbiased as
compared to MBI methods. As a result, when studies are small and do not contain a
large number of variables, or in situations where more elaborate imputation methods cannot be done, DBI is an accurate and unbiased method.
PRM69
INDIRECT COMPARISON OF THE EFFECTS OF ANTI-TNF BIOLOGICAL AGENTS
IN PATIENTS WITH ANKYLOSING SPONDYLITIS BY MEANS OF A MIXED
TREATMENT COMPARISON PERFORMED ON EFFICACY DATA FROM PUBLISHED
RANDOMISED, CONTROLLED TRIALS
Migliore A , Bizzi E , Massafra U
S. Pietro Fatebenefratelli Hospital, Rome, Italy
.
.
.
Objectives: To compare ASAS (Assessment in Ankylosing Spondylitis Response
Criteria) 20 response patterns between anti-TNF biological agents in patients with
ankylosing spondylitis by means of a mixed treatment comparison of different randomised, controlled trials (RCTs) on the efficacy of biological therapies. Methods:
A systematic review of literature was performed to identify a number of similarly
designed double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled trials investigating the efficacy of the TNF-alfa inhibitors etanercept, infliximab, golimumab, certolizumab
pegol and adalimumab in the treatment of ankylosing spondylitis patients, conducted over an 18-years period. The endpoint of interest was ASAS20 response
criteria at 12 weeks. Results were analyzed simultaneously using Bayesian mixed
treatment comparison techniques. Results were expressed as odds ratio (OR) of
ASAS20 response and associated 95% credible intervals (CrIs). The probability of
being the best treatment was also reported. Results: 6 RCTs were selected for data
extraction and further analysis. By mean of MTC, all anti-TNF agents demonstrated
to be more efficacious in inducing a ASAS20 response than placebo. Infliximab
shows a 67,6% of probability of being the best treatment of all. Adalimumab, golimumab and etanercept show probabilities of 17,7%, 10,6% and 4%, respectively,
while certolizumab pegol showed a probability of being the best treatment of 0,1%.
No differences were observed when comparing directly an anti-TNFalfa agent
against another. Conclusions: Even if the mixed treatment comparisons between
infliximab, golimumab, certolizumab pegol, adalimumab and etanercept did not
show a statistically significant difference, this analysis suggests that infliximab,
compared to placebo, is expected to provide the highest rate of ASAS20 response
in SA patients naive to biologic treatments.
PRM70
A Tutorial on Dimensionality Reduction in Large Claims Data Sets
Juneau P
Truven Health Analytics, Boyds, MD, USA
.
Objectives: The objective of this presentation will be to introduce the audience
to various data dimension reduction techniques that may be applied in the setting
of a large commercial claims data set to facilitate the task of identifying important
factors or key features for use in subsequent analysis. Methods: The author will
provide a brief survey of the data dimension reduction literature from areas as
diverse as image analysis, neural networks, gene expression microarrays, and high
through-put chemistry to demonstrate that despite that many of these techniques
have been used in other settings or areas of research, their application to the analysis of health care claims data is relevant and potentially quite useful. Results:
One, all-purpose, optimal data dimension technique does not exist for application
in the analysis of health care claims data. The analyst needs to weigh the features
of the large data set under consideration, the objectives of the downstream or subsequent analysis, and the availability of tools for ease of use and interpretation
of results. Conclusions: The number of data dimension reduction techniques
available to claims data set researchers is large and diverse; however, keys features
of these various approaches can help the analyst make an informed decision that
is effective with some simple setting and objectives diagnosis.
PRM71
Reimbursement Decisions in Oncology Drugs: An International
Analysis
Aissaoui A
Paris dauphine University, Paris, France
Objectives: The aim is to compare the drug reimbursement decisions of innovative anti-cancer drugs in five countries (UK, France, Italy, Spain & Australia). Our
approach was to identify both convergence and divergence in these reimbursement
decisions and to assess the agreement level between the policy makers. Methods:
For our analysis we have used 39 oncology drugs authorized by the EMA between
January 2004 and December 2012 covering a total of 65 indications, and we have
compared the reimbursement decisions in theses 5 countries. We reviewed the
technology appraisal performed by their respective national HTA agencies and their
reimbursement decisions. We have also analyzed the level of agreement for reimbursement decisions between pairs of each country with kappa scores. Results:
Out of these 39 drugs, only 16 drugs were reimbursed in Australia, 15 in England,
38 in France, followed by Italy and Spain, which respectively reimbursed 29 and 28
drugs. When we have analyzed the common reimbursement decision taken, we
have observed that between France and Italy 72% of common positive reimbursement decision were taken, and between France and England only 33 % of positive
reimbursement decisions are common. In contrast we have found 49 % of common
negative reimbursement decision between England and Australia. Then we have
measured the consistency between decision makers with KAPPA scores and it came
out that France, Italy and Spain are often in agreement in their reimbursement decisions, and that conversely France and England decisions are significantly in disagreement. Conclusions: This study demonstrates that the discordance between
countries reimbursement decisions, in most cases may reflect the differences in
the decision making process (Eg. France Vs England). But this analysis cannot be
conclusive. This is why we have carried out further researches using larger datasets
allowing us to highlight some elements yielding to these reimbursement decision
differences between countries.
PRM72
Easy Come, Hardly Go: Epidemiological Methods to Evaluate the
Effect of Ispor Board of Directors Membership on Publication
Activity
Merész G 1, Gyurcsán G C 2, Salfer B 3
1Syreon Research Institute, Budapest, Hungary, 2Self-employed, Budapest, Hungary, 3Healthware
Consulting Ltd., Budapest, Hungary
.
.
.
.
Objectives: ISPOR is approaching its 10th anniversary, which offers a suitable occasion to assess the impact of the organization. As the number of members increased,
the influence of the Board of Directors on scientific discussions also emerged. The
aim of this research is to present what effect being elected an ISPOR Director has
on a researcher’s publication activity by using epidemiological methods and data
mining techniques. Methods: Data on number of publications by year, co-authors,
titles, abstracts of former ISPOR Directors between 1995 and 2012 were obtained
from public sources (ISPOR website and PubMed) and analysed by an algorithm
developed by the authors in R. A case-only study design was applied by matching the
duration spent as a member of the Board of Directors with the same period prior to
and after finishing the directorate term. Incidence rate ratios (IRR) were estimated
by fitting separate Poisson regression models to correct for the baseline increase
in publication activity. The average number of co-authors and probability of the
director being the first author was also analysed. Results: The IRR of the period
preceding to directorate versus the directorate period was 1.59 (CI 95%: 1.34-1.91),
yielding statistically significant association. The IRR of directorate period versus the
period succeeding the directorate period was 1.01 (CI 95%: 0.88-1.13). The average
number of co-authors was the highest after the directorate term (5.94); the probability of the director appearing as the first author was the highest prior to directorate
term (22.91%). Conclusions: As a result of our study, it has been statistically
proven that being an ISPOR Director does not only provide leadership in a scientific
organization, but can enhance the members’ career as a researcher. ISPOR Directors
are more likely to co-author publications even after finishing their directorate term.
RESEARCH ON METHODS – Modeling Methods
PRM73
Creating Patient Profile in Individual Simulations: A Comparison of
Approaches
Stern S , Pan F
Evidera, Bethesda, MD, USA
.
Objectives: Individual simulation is increasingly used in economic models, partly
because of its capability of predicting event risks based on individual patient characteristics. However, due to lack of individual patient level data, models often use
means and standard deviations to create patient profiles. The objective of this study
is to evaluate different simulation approaches of creating patient profile at baseline
and their impact on model outcomes. Methods: Patient level data (N= 8,857) from
National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES) was used to evaluate three approaches of creating baseline patient profiles for simulation models.
10 samples of 1000 patients each were created through 1) random sampling from
patient level data; 2) using means and standard deviations of the profile variables
without correlating the characteristics; 3) using means and variance-covariance
matrix among the continuous variable characteristics with cholesky decomposition approach. 10-year cardiovascular diseases (CVDs) rates are estimated using the
created patient profiles from these 3 different approaches. Results: The predicted
CVD rates based on random sampling are 18.2% for males and 9.7% for females using
the random sampling approach, 14.5% for males and 7.9% for females using the
mean and standard deviation approach and 16.0% for males and 9.2% for females
using the cholesky decomposition approach. The CVD rates using the NHANES entire
A556
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
population are 18.5% for males and 9.8% for females. Conclusions: Random sampling from patient level data provided the best approximation of actual NHANES
population predicted CVD rates. The cholesky decomposition approach was slightly
limited since only continuous variables could be utilized which could explain the
deviation from the population predicted CVD rates. Independent sampling underestimated the mean risk by ~20%, an interesting finding as many individual simulation models created patients with this approach. Researchers should be cautious
in their use of summary statistics when populating individual simulation models.
half-cycle correction method provided more accurate results than calculations without any kind of half-cycle correction with the exception of one set of input parameters. Conclusions: Based on our model the most accurate method for half-cycle
correction is Simpson’s method as in most cases it was the closest to real data. It is
important to note that with a few exceptions even the standard method’s results were
more accurate than in cases where no half-cycle correction was applied.
PRM74
Validation of the SPHR Diabetes Prevention Model
PRM77
Application of A Model Of Decision Based on Fuzzy Logic to
Pharmacoeconomics: Treatment of CROHN’S Disease With Antitnf in
Out of Label Use
Thomas C , Watson P , Squires H , Chilcott J , Brennan A
University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK
1HOSPITAL
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: We have developed a model to evaluate type-2 diabetes prevention
interventions. We aimed to validate this model against external data to test the accuracy of model predictions. MethodsAn individual patient simulation was developed
to predict longitudinal trajectories of HbA1c, 2-hr glucose, FPG, BMI, systolic blood
pressure, total cholesterol and HDL cholesterol based on statistical analyses of the
Whitehall II longitudinal cohort. Criteria for diabetes diagnosis were flexibly specified. Cardiovascular events were estimated from the QRISK2 algorithm. Microvascular
complications of diabetes were estimated from the UKPDS outcomes model. Several
validations were performed to compare model outcomes with reported data from
external sources. We assessed the predicted diabetes incidence using data from the
EPIC Norfolk cohort. Data from the Health Survey for England (HSE) 2003 cohort was
simulated for eight years to compare predicted disease incidence and metabolic
distributions with HSE 2011 data. We compared microvascular, cardiovascular and
mortality outcomes in a diabetic population with those observed in the UKPDS. We
assessed the performance of the model in predicting the results of the ADDITION trial
for diabetes screening. Results: We found that the model overestimated three-year
incidence of diabetes, particularly in high risk (HbA1c>6.0) individuals, but underestimated diabetes incidence in medium risk individuals (HbA1c 5.5-5.9) compared with
the EPIC-Norfolk data. Predictions from HSE 2003 were fairly accurate. Predictions
for microvascular events were similar to the UKPDS, but cardiovascular disease and
mortality were slightly under-predicted. The model replicated the non-significant
difference seen between control and intervention arms of the ADDITION trial, but
overestimated total mortality and cardiovascular disease. Conclusions: The SPHR
Diabetes model appears to be fairly accurate at predicting external data, but has
a tendency to overestimate mortality rates in a newly diagnosed diabetic cohort,
and underestimate cardiovascular disease and mortality compared with the UKPDS.
PRM75
Use Of Model Averaging Techniques in Cost-Effectiveness Analysis
in Oncology
Le H H , Ozer-Stillman I
Evidera, Boston, MA, USA
.
.
.
Objectives: Often in cost-effectiveness analysis (CEA) of oncologic drugs, survival
data from a randomized controlled trial are extrapolated to a lifetime horizon using
parametric regression techniques. To capture parameter uncertainty in the analysis,
regression parameters along with other model parameters are varied in probabilistic
sensitivity analysis. However, structural uncertainty in the choice of regression
model is rarely investigated. This study discusses the use of model averaging and
provides an example to address structural uncertainty in CEA. Methods: Using a
cohort partition model, the numbers of patients in “progression-free”, “progressed”,
and “dead” health states were calculated directly from progression-free survival
(PFS) and overall survival (OS) curves. Weibull, exponential, lognormal, log-logistic,
generalized gamma, and Gompertz parametric models were used to extrapolated
these curves to a lifetime horizon. Total costs, life year (LY), and quality adjusted
life year (QALY) for each regression model were estimated. Weighted results across
all models were calculated, based on weights that were derived from Akaike’s or
Bayesian Information Criterion (AIC or BIC) parameters. Results: Evaluating
solely on BIC values, the lognormal distribution was identified as the best model
for both survival curves. This resulted in the lowest observed ICERs. When model
selection was based on considerations involving the log-cumulative hazard plots,
clinical plausibility, and AIC/ BIC for each distribution, the Weibull distribution was
selected for both curves, resulting in a 29% and 27% increase in the ICER for QALY
and LY, respectively. Similar increases were observed when model averaging was
applied using BIC-derived weights. In this case, model averaging produced results
that were similar to those where model selection was based on multiple criteria.
Conclusions: Choice of parametric models often has the biggest impact on the
outcomes in CEAs in oncology. Model averaging takes into account the structural
uncertainty surrounding the choice of parametric models.
PRM76
Comparing Three Different Methods of Half-Cycle Correction
Nemeth B , Szeker V
National Institute of Quality- and Organizational Development in Healthcare and Medicines,
Budapest, Hungary
.
.
Objectives: To compare three different half-cycle correction methods and their
effect on the final results of Markov models. Methods: To assess the relative performance of the alternatives to the standard half-cycle correction we constructed a
5-state Markov model where the courses of the number of patients in health states
follow different shapes to represent the most likely cases in modelling practise. We
applied three different correction methods (standard half-cycle correction, Simpson’s
method and using the mid-cycle values) and we also looked at the results without any
correction and with different numbers of Markov cycles. We conducted a sensitivity
analysis by changing the input parameters of our model. In total we examined 80
cases. Results: In our Markov model Simpson’s method provided the most accurate
results where the difference from real data was less than 0.1% in 67 of the 80 cases.
The second most accurate method was using the mid-cycle values. The standard
Alonso Herreros J M 1, González-Cuello A 2
LOS ARCOS MAR MENOR, SAN JAVIER (MURCIA), Spain, 2Murcia University,
MURCIA, Spain
.
.
.
Objectives: We present a model decision based on fuzzy logic, and apply to off
label use of antiTNF in Crohn’s disease (CD) (Infliximab (IFB) 10 mg/kg/8 weeks,
adalimumab (ADA) 80mg/2 weeks,. Certolizumab (CZB) 200mg/2weeks). The term
“fuzzy logic” (FL) was introduced in 1965 by LAZadeh. Compared to traditional logic,
FL variables may have a truth value in degree. FL has been applied to many fields, from
economic analysis, to artificial intelligence. However it has not been applied so far to
pharmacoeconomics. Methods: According to a decision analysis model based on FL
four fuzzy variables that affect the choice of treatment are defined: treatment success
(expressed as a probability), cost of success, cost of failure (expressed as inverses),
and other conditions about the cost (negotiation, handling of drugs...). Based on the
value of these fuzzy variables, three linguistic variables (High, Medium, Low) are
defined to expressing convenience of choice. The combination of the three possible
values for each of the variables gives us 81 possible decision rules, so that the (HHHH)
would be the most favorable option and (LLLL) the more unfavorable. So a new fuzzy
variable called “ranking” is established for classifying these options with 7 possible
values (Very-unfavorable, unfavorable, slightly-unfavorable, neutral, slightly-favorable,
favorable, very-favorable). The value of the fuzzy variables for antiTNF at 52 weeks
of treatment, were established based recent meta-analysis and reviews. Results:
The matrices obtained and corresponding decision rules were: for IFB (0.65, 6.3 10-5,
-1.17 10-4, 0.075) / (MMML); For ADA (0.41, 9.21 10-5, 6.4 10-5, 0.075) / (MMML); for CZB
(0.52, 1.30 10-4 1.5 10-4 0.075) / (MHHB). Thus the CZB would be the “slightly-favorable”
option, versus IFB and ADA (unfavorables). Conclusions: It possible to apply methods of “FL” to pharmacoeconomic studies According to the model, Certolizumab would
be a most favorable choice in off-label use for CD.
PRM78
Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA): Testing a Proposed Mcda
Model for Orphan Drugs
Schey C 1, Connolly M 2
of PharmacoEpidemiology & PharmacoEconomics, Groningen, The Netherlands,, 2University
of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands
.
.
1Unit
Objectives: Since the introduction of the orphan drugs in Europe, it has been suggested that the general method of appraising drugs for reimbursement is not necessarily suitable for orphan drugs. The National Institute for Health and Clinical
Excellence indicated that several criteria other than cost and efficacy could be
considered in reimbursement decisions for orphan drugs. The aim of this study
was to apply a MCDA framework that was proposed by Hughes-Wilson et al (2012)
to a range of orphan drugs in different diseases to test the correlation between
drug price and aggregated MCDA scores for each product. Methods: A MCDA
framework was developed using the nine criteria suggested by Hughes-Wilson
et al. A supplementary literature review was conducted to identify other attributes described in the application of MCDA in rare diseases. A numerical scoring
system on a scale of one to three was developed for each criterion. Correlations
between the average annual cost of the drugs and aggregate MCDA scores were
tested and plotted graphically. Different weightings for each of the attributes were
also tested. A further analysis was conducted to test the impact of including the
drug cost as an attribute in the aggregate index scores. Results: The literature
review identified further commonly cited criteria: ‘convenience of administration’, ‘age of the target population’, ‘quality of life’, and ‘drug innovation’ that
were added to the aggregate index scores. In the drugs studied, the R 2was 0.808
and 0.704 when costs were included and not included, respectively. The standard
error of the slope varied from 7711.9 to 11413.3 when costs were included and not
included, respectively. Conclusions: This quantitative study provided insight
into using MCDA and its relationship to annual costs. Further work should explore
the potential for therapy-specific MCDAs and how to inform value-based pricing
assessment.
PRM79
Advishe: a New Tool to Report Validation of Health-Economic
Decision Models
Vemer P 1, Corro Ramos I 2, Van Voorn G 3, Al M J 2, Feenstra T L 4
Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands, 2Erasmus University, Rotterdam, The Netherlands,
3Wageningen University & Research, Wageningen, The Netherlands, 4University of Groningen,
University Medical Center Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1UMC
Background: Modelers and reimbursement decision makers could both profit
from a more systematic reporting of the efforts to validate health-economic (HE)
models. Objectives: Development of a tool to systematically report validation
efforts of HE decision models and their outcomes. Methods: A gross list of model
validation techniques was collected using a literature review, including sources
outside the HE field. A panel then selected the most important items. Based on
the Delphi method, the panel members could score items in three e-mail rounds.
Participants were HE modelling experts, covering various nationalities and work
environments. They could comment on relevance, feasibility and formulation of
the items and received feedback on comments from others. This resulted in a draft
tool of selected items, which was tested and improved in two further rounds. In
A557
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
addition, the Dutch National Health Care Institute commented on usefulness for
decision makers, while a separate group of 50 HE experts could comment during a
workshop at ISPOR Montreal 2014. Results: 35 Validation techniques were identified and grouped into four categories: conceptual model validation, computerized
model validation, data validation and operational validation. Around 30 HE experts
commented in each of the first three Delphi rounds, resulting in a 15 item draft
tool. The Dutch health care advisory institute suggested to add one more item.
Participants from the ISPOR workshop delivered 19 filled-in questionnaires. A fourth
round resulted in 17 responses. This led to a refined version containing 16 items,
which is currently sent out for a final, fifth round. Conclusions: When filled
out by the modellers, AdVISHE (Assessment of the ValIdation Status of HealthEconomic decision models) supports model users in assessing the validation status
of a model It will be useful as part of reimbursement dossiers, by providing systematic and transparent insight into the validation efforts performed and their results.
PRM80
Modelling Survival in the Presence of Different Mechanisms of
Action: Ipilimumab and Vemurafenib in Advanced Melanoma
Lee D 1, Porter J 1, Hertel N 2, Hatswell A J 1
1BresMed, Sheffield, UK, 2Bristol Myers Squibb, Uxbridge, UK
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Traditional indirect treatment comparison methods assume the
underlying survival profiles of treatments are similar (i.e. proportional hazards). This
assumption is unlikely to hold for the comparison of ipilimumab and vemurafenib:
Whereas vemurafenib exhibits improved short-term survival compared with ipilimumab, pooled study data for ipilimumab consistently show that patients achieve
durable long-term survival. We present a method to compare across trials with differing survival profiles by accounting for follow-on treatments and different patient
baseline characteristics. Methods: Comparative survival estimates for ipilimumab
and vemurafenib were produced using patient-level data from trial CA184-024 for
ipilimumab and published survival curve fits from BRIM-3 (along with registry data)
for vemurafenib. The BRIM-3 vemurafenib overall survival curve was adjusted to
account for (a) the effect of second-line ipilimumab (via a tunnel-state methodology) and (b) differences in patient baseline characteristics between BRIM-3 and
CA184-024, by means of a model (Korn model), constructed to predict the outcomes
for dacarbazine-treated patients. The resulting survival estimates were compared
with naïve unadjusted survival curve fits, and estimates produced using a hazard
ratio (from an indirect comparison) to the ipilimumab data. Results: Estimated
survival for ipilimumab was 3.3 years (mean). Predicted survival for vemurafenib,
using a naïve comparison, was 3.0 years (mean). Adjusting for second-line ipilimumab and different baseline characteristics resulted in an estimate of 2.8 years
for vemurafenib. When a hazard ratio was applied to the ipilimumab data, which
underlies the here strong assumption that the vemurafenib overall survival profile
is similar to that of ipilimumab, predicted survival for vemurafenib increased to 4.2
years.Conclusions: Depending on the methodology used, the mean predicted
survival for vemurafenib varied from 2.8 to 4.2 years. Alternative methods that
incorporate the long-term survival profile of ipilimumab (naïve comparison or more
sophisticated adjustment methodology) demonstrate a higher number of life years
with ipilimumab versus vemurafenib.
PRM81
Health Economic Models in Alzheimer’s Disease: A Critical
Assessment
Walzer S 1, Droeschel D 1, Kaier K 2
Market Access & Pricing Strategy GmbH, Weil am Rhein, Germany, 2University of Freiburg,
Freiburg, Germany
.
.
.
1MArS
Objectives: Alzheimer’s Disease destroys brain cells, causing problems with memory, thinking, and behavior severe enough to affect work, family and social relationships, and, eventually, the most basic activities of daily living. Different treatment
options have been introduced and evaluated from a health economic perspective.
However, given the specific characteristics of the disease an evaluation of existing
models is needed. Methods: The following databases were searched systematically: PubMed, Health Technology Assessment Database, NHS Economic Evaluation
Database, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, Cochrane Database of
Systematic Reviews, DAHTA-database, PSYNDEX and PsycINFO. For the abstracts
that met the pre-defined inclusion criteria, full text articles were obtained and
evaluated for inclusion in the assessment. Results: After eliminating duplicates
the search indicated yielded 1’219 articles of which another 940 were excluded based
on the title selection. Finally 59 articles have been reviewed in full text after abstract
review. Out of those articles 39 were deemed to be relevant based on the research
question. The majority of models (48%) have been Markov models, other methods
being used were various statistical analysis applications, micro-simulation, and
discrete-event simulations. Limitations of existing models include the following:
Focus on cognitive function as disease progression only; lack of inclusion of correlation between disease progression and other factors (e.g. residential status); lack of
complete structure of diagnosis and treatment of disease (e.g. including non-drug
treatments). Based on the Drummond checklist for health economic models the
quality of models proved generally to be high but the majority of those lack presenting a comprehensive pathway of the natural history of the disease. Conclusions:
Current models do not allow decision makers optimally characterizing the disease,
to better assess the costs and benefits of a wide range of potential interventions.
Potential new models need to take the disease characteristics and specifics more
appropriate into account.
PRM82
Approaches Used to Model the Relationship Between ProgressionFree Survival (PFS) / Time-To-Progression (TTP) And Overall Survival
(OS) Within Health Economic Models of Cancer Therapies
Rafia R , Ward S E
University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: Within health economic models of metastatic cancer therapies assumptions on the relationship between progression-free survival (PFS) / time-to-progression (TTP) and overall survival (OS) are typically required; notably when OS data are
immature or unavailable. A review was undertaken to identify the methods that have
been used within health economic models regarding this relationship and to identify
the rationale given for the approach taken, specifically in those situations where OS
data were not available or immature. Methods: All NICE technology appraisals in
the advanced and/or metastatic cancer setting completed by December 2013 were
reviewed. The review included all relevant appraisal documents publicly available on
the NICE website containing information on the methods used and/or rationale for
the approach taken to model the relationship between OS and PFS/TPP within the
health economic model. This included the sponsor submission and updated analyses,
the independent Assessment Report, and other reports/analyses in relation to the
appraisal process. Results: In those instances where OS data were immature or not
available, PFS/TTP was typically assumed to be a valid surrogate of OS. Justification
for this assumption was inconsistently reported. In some health economic models
a quantification of the assumed relationship was informed by published evidence
and/or expert judgement. In some cases attempts were made to explore the potential
impact of this relationship in sensitivity analysis. Conclusions: The methods and/
or rationale given for the approach used to model the relationship between OS and
PFS/TTP in health economic models has been inconsistently reported and justified.
Whilst some health economic models attempted to quantify this relationship, further
transparency is required. A consensus needs to emerge on the most appropriate
approaches to be used within health economic models to quantify this relationship,
specifically when OS data are not available or immature and to identify the circumstances when particular approaches may be most relevant.
PRM83
Comparison of Methods to Estimate Health State Utilities in
Metastatic Breast Cancer (MBC)
Hudgens S 1, Briggs A 2, Tremblay G 3, Forsythe A 3, Lloyd A 4
Outcomes Solutions, Tucson, AZ, USA, 2University of Glasgow, Glasgow, UK, 3Eisai Inc,
Woodcliff Lake, NJ, USA, 4ICON Plc, Oxford, UK
.
.
.
.
.
1Clinical
Objectives: Patient-level utility values for different stages of MBC and toxicities
commonly associated with chemotherapy regimens are useful for health economic
assessments. Three methods to estimate utilities exist when direct utility data are
not available: utility ‘mapping’ from existing disease-specific scales, vignette studies
that describe the health states; or derivation of preference-based measures from
an existing condition-specific scale. This study compares utility estimates in MBC
utilizing the above methods. Methods: Based on data from a phase 3 clinical
trial in MBC (N= 1102) utility mapping was conducted using a published regression
algorithm to convert the EORTC QLQ-C30 questionnaire to the EQ-5D utility. Mean
utility values were estimated for relevant health states: stable disease (SD), tumor
response (TR), disease progression (DP) and common toxicities. Results were compared to previously published values obtained for a vignette study conducted in
one hundred members of the general public. Results: Observed MBC utilities were
similar in mapping vs. vignette studies for SD: 0.697 vs. 0.715, and TR: 0.782 vs. 0.790.
General public respondents in the vignette study assigned much lower utility to
symptomatic DP (0.443) vs. imaging-based DP in mapping study (0.679); and disutility for toxicities: vomiting: 0.103 vs. 0.050; fatigue 0.115 vs. 0.029; febrile neutropenia
0.150 vs. 0.012 (vignette vs. mapping respectively). Hand-foot syndrome, stomatitis
and hair loss were not associated with disutility in the mapping study (potentially
due to small sample size) while disutility of 0.116; 0.151; and 0.114 were reported
by the vignette study. Conclusions: Utilization of different methods to estimate
utilities in MBC may lead to a wide range of estimated values with potentially significant implications for health economic evaluation. Caution must be exercised
when comparing utility values derived using different methods. It is preferable to
collect such data from patients directly and use vignettes as a last resort.
PRM84
Cost-Effectiveness Models for Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary
Disease (COPD): Cross-Model Comparison of Hypothetical Treatment
Scenarios
Hoogendoorn M 1, Feenstra T 2, Asukai Y 3, Borg S 4, Hansen R N 5, Jansson S A 6, Samyshkin
Y 3, Wacker M 7, Briggs A 8, Lloyd A 3, Sullivan S D 9, Rutten-van Mölken MP1
1Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 2RIVM /UMCG, Bilthoven, The
Netherlands, 3IMS Health, Economics and Outcomes Research, London, UK, 4The Swedish Institute
for Health Economics, Lund, Sweden, 5School of Pharmacy, University of Washington, Seattle, WA,
USA, 6The OLIN Studies, Luleå, Sweden, 7Helmholtz Zentrum Munchen, Neuherberg, Germany,
8University of Glasgow, Glasgow, UK, 9University of Washington, Pharmaceutical Outcomes
Research and Policy Program, Seattle, WA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To compare different COPD cost-effectiveness models with respect
to structure and input parameters and to cross validate the models by running
the same hypothetical treatment scenarios. Methods: COPD modeling groups
simulated four hypothetical interventions with their model and compared the
results with a reference scenario of no intervention. The four interventions modeled assumed: 1) 20% reduction in decline in lung function, 2) 25% reduction in
exacerbation frequency, 3) 10% reduction in all-cause mortality and 4) all these
effects combined. The interventions were simulated for a five-year and lifetime
horizon with standardization, if possible, for sex, age, COPD severity, smoking status,
exacerbation frequencies, mortality due to other causes, utilities, costs and discount rates. Furthermore, uncertainty around the outcomes of intervention four was
compared. Results: Seven out of nine contacted COPD modeling groups agreed to
participate. Differences in 5-year QALY gains ranged from 0.00020 to 0.039 for intervention one, 0.0089 to 0.075 for intervention two and 0.017 to 0.048 for intervention
three. The difference in costs ranged from € 561 to € 912 for intervention one, € 739
to € 1350 for intervention two and € 1140 to € 1618 for intervention three. The 5-year
cost-effectiveness ratios (ICERs) for the most comprehensive intervention, intervention four, was € 17,000/QALY for two models, € 25,000-€ 28,000/QALY for three models
A558
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
and € 47,000/QALY for the remaining two models. Differences in the outcomes could
mainly be explained by differences in input values for disease progression, exacerbation-related mortality and all-cause mortality with high input values resulting
in low ICERs and vice versa. Lifetime results were mainly influenced by the input
values for mortality. The probability of intervention four to be cost-effective at a
willingness-to-pay of € 50,000/QALY was 90-100% for five models and about 70% and
50% for the other two models. Conclusions: Mortality was the most important
factor determining the differences in cost-effectiveness outcomes between models.
PRM85
A DE-NOVO Model to Predict Outcomes of a New Hypothetical
Intervention to Reduce CV Risk in Post Mi Patients
Jain M 1, Sonathi V 1, Rathi H 1, Bakuli A 1, Thomas S K 2, Mollon P 3
1Novartis Healthcare Pvt. Ltd., Hyderabad, India, 2Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation, East
Hanover, NJ, USA, 3Novaris Pharma AG, Basel, Switzerland
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The risk of cardiovascular (CV) events in post myocardial infarction
(MI) patients poses a significant burden on the UK health care system despite the
current standard of care (SoC). The objective of this analysis was to develop a model
to quantify the relationship between efficacy and outcomes of a new hypothetical
drug given in addition to current SoC to reduce the risk of CV events in post-MI
patients when compared to SoC. Methods: A 6-state lifetime Markov model with
a 1-year cycle length was developed from a UK health care perspective. Recurrent
MI, stroke and CV death were modeled. The hypothetical drug was assigned efficacy
values for its ability to reduce the incidence of CV events. The outcomes were measured in terms of QALYs and LYs. A linear regression model was fitted to estimate
the expected outcome/patient based on relative risk reduction (RRR) in the incidence of CV events. All outcomes were discounted at 3.5% annually. Results: The
model structure addressed some of the limitations of previous economic models,
namely increased risk due to stroke in MI patients and increased risk of subsequent events in the first year. For identical cohorts, the outcomes from the model
compared well with other published studies. For a cohort of patients aged 40-years,
the model predicted on an average, LYs of 17.6 and QALYs of 13.64. A hypothetical
drug achieving a 5% RRR in CV events resulted in an incremental LYs of 0.28 and
QALYs of 0.23. The increase in incremental QALYs and LYs per percentage point
reduction in relative risk as compared to SoC was estimated to be 0.043 and 0.054
respectively. Conclusions: A de-novo economic model quantifies the relationship
between the efficacy and outcomes of a hypothetical drug when compared to the
SoC to reduce the risk of CV events in post-MI patients.
PRM86
Estimating the Lifetime Health Outcomes of Type 2 Diabetes
Mellitus (T2dm) Patients Inadequately Controlled on Metformin
Plus Sulphonylurea Receiving Either Canagliflozin or Sitagliptin
Using the UKPDS Outcomes Model V1.3
Nuhoho S 1, Worbes-Cerezo M2
1Janssen-Cilag A/S, Birkerød, Denmark, 2Janssen-Cilag UK, High Wycombe, UK
.
Objectives: The goals of type 2 diabetes management are to control glycaemia and
other micro- and macrovascular risk factors such as weight, blood pressure and lipids
in order to prevent death and other complications due to the disease. The natural
history of the disease makes it challenging to estimate the effects of treatments on
these long term complications and mortality from standard clinical trials. Modelling
is therefore a key bridging tool for predicting long term health outcomes from intermediate endpoints. The objective of this analysis was to estimate the relative effects
of canagliflozin 300mg and sitagliptin 100mg on mortality, micro- and macrovascular
complications in T2DM patients in triple line as add on to metformin plus sulphonylurea using the UKPDS Outcomes Model v1.3. Methods: A probabilistic patient
generator was developed which generated 10,000 patients with applied treatment
effects based on data from head to head randomised clinical trials. Upon loss of
glycaemic control (HbA1c ≥7%), patients were assumed to switch to insulin. 1% point
reduction in HbA1c was applied on rescue. For model stability, patients were looped
1,000 times (creating 10 million patients in each arm) with 100 bootstrap simulations.
Outcomes were discounted 3.5% annually. Results: At the end of the 40 years simulation, patients initiating canagliflozin 300mg had 49 more survivors and 16,918 fewer
diabetes-related deaths. Micro- and macrovascular complications were estimated
in fewer patients on canagliflozin 300mg than on sitagliptin 100mg (between 5,948
fewer renal failures and 41,157 fewer myocardial infarctions). There were discernible
relative risk reductions in all complications and diabetes-related death ranging from
1.40% (heart failure) to 2.96% (amputation). Conclusions: Results of the analysis
using the UKPDS Outcomes Model v1.3 suggest that canagliflozin 300mg compared
with sitagliptin 100mg as add on to metformin plus sulphonylurea reduces long-term
diabetes-related mortality and complications.
PRM87
All-Cause Mortality Validation of the Core Diabetes Model Against
Predictions of the Charlson Comorbidity Index
Foos V 1, McEwan P 2, Lamotte M 3, Grant D 4
1IMS Health, Basel, Switzerland, 2Health Economics and Outcomes Research Ltd, Cardiff, UK, 3IMS
Health Consulting, Brussels, Belgium, 4IMS Health, London, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: All cause mortality (ACM) validations with the IMS CORE Diabetes
Model (CDM) have demonstrated below average fit when compared to overall validation scores from 96 validation end points (EP) with a R2-statistic of 0.651 (vs.
0.93 All-EP). Lack of fit was associated with a model overestimation of ACM when
compared to contemporary outcome studies (ACCORD, ADVANCE, VADT). The objective of this investigation was to put these findings into perspective by comparing the model to mortality risk predictions from the Charlson-Comorbidity-Index
(CCI). Methods: The CCI was applied to predict the 10 year mortality risk for diabetes patients with age of 50,60,70 and 80 years and four different co-morbidity levels:
no complications (NC), myocardial infarction (MI), MI and stroke (MI+S), MI+S and
heart failure (MI+S+HF) and MI+S+HF and renal failure (MI+S+HF+RF). CCI mortality
scores were compared to corresponding 10 year ACM predictions from the CDM.
Base case (BC) analyses applied UKPDS-68 risk equations (UK68-RE) for CV risk and
mortality. Two sets of sensitivity analyses were conducted using UK68-RE for CV risk
but mortality tracked individually per complication event (non combined mortality
approach) (SA1) and UKPDS-82 risk equations (UK82-RE) applied for CV risk and
mortality (SA2). Results: Across all age and co-morbidity states, CDM simulations
demonstrated the closest match to CCI-scores in SA1 with an R2-statistic of 0.877.
This compared to R2-statistics of 0.757, and 0.851 for BC and SA2, respectively. BC
and SA2 analyses noteworthy underestimated ACM risk in analyses with increased
co-morbitity level by 68% (BC) and 49% (SA2) vs. 17% (SA1) in (MI+S+HF) and 44%
(BC) and 36% (SA2) vs. 3% (SA1) in (MI+S+HF+RF). Conclusions: The CDM demonstrated a closer match to CCI mortality scores (vs. outcome studies) with a trend
to underestimate ACM. This trend increased with baseline age and (only BC and
SA2) co-morbidity level.
PRM88
Deterministic Versus Stochastic Prediction of Risk for
Cardiovascular Events
Villa G 1, Lothgren M 1, Gandra S R 2, Lindgren P 3, van Hout B 4
(Europe) GmbH, Zug, Switzerland, 2Amgen, Inc., Thousand Oaks, CA, USA, 3IVBAR,
Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, Sweden, 4University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Amgen
Objectives: Multivariate functions can be used to predict individual risk for cardiovascular (CVD) events and also to estimate baseline risk in economic models.
We present a comparison of deterministic versus stochastic risk predictions using
Framingham’s [D’Agostino 2008] and REACH’s [Wilson 2012] functions. Stochastic
risk prediction accounts for patient-level heterogeneity, but involves a number of
issues including increased complexity, data requirements, need for assumptions
and computational burden. To our knowledge, this topic has not been studied in the
CVD setting. Methods: D’Agostino 2008 and Wilson 2012 modeled primary (PE) and
recurrent event (RE) risks, respectively. Both studies considered fatal and non-fatal
aggregate CVD events and estimated a Cox Proportional Hazards (CPH) multivariate
risk function. In the deterministic prediction, the means of the risk factors were
used to predict the population’s risk directly from the functions. In the stochastic
prediction, individual patient profiles (n= 10,000) were generated using Monte Carlo
simulation. Individual risks were then estimated from the functions and averaged
to compute the population’s risk. Multinomomial distributions were assumed for
discrete variables (e.g. diabetes, number of vascular beds) and normal or log-normal
distributions were assumed for continuous variables depending on skewness (e.g.
age, total cholesterol). Probability distributions were parameterized based on the risk
factors descriptives reported in the original references. Simulations were performed
with and without considering dependence of risk factors. Results: Due to the nonlinearity of the CPH function, the stochastic prediction yielded 23% (PE) and 17%
(RE) higher risks than the deterministic approach (14% and 10%, respectively, if age
was kept constant). Differences between prediction approaches are even higher if
the estimated correlation structure of risk factors is accounted for. Conclusions:
When compared to the stochastic prediction, the deterministic approach leads to
lower estimates of CVD risks. Therefore, economic models using this approach
might underestimate treatment effect.
PRM89
Are Cycles Needed in Markov Models? – The Continuous Model as a
Simpler Approach
Tichy E
Evidera, Budapest, Hungary
.
Objectives: To present an alternative implementation for the conventional Markov
models with area under the curve (AUC) approach: the continuous model (CM).
To present how the CM avoids the need of determining cycles in theory and to
compare the traditional and the CM approach in terms of results and complexity in an oncology model example. Methods: The AUC model assumes that the
survival function is known at any timepoint not only at the beginning and end of
model cycle. The CM calculates the model outcomes for the whole timehorizon by
using the values of the survival function in every timepoint, instead of the discrete
timepoints defined by cycle length. The CM approach overcomes the issue of the
artificial characterization of time using cycles, that is often criticized in Markov
models. Using CM can also lead to more precise estimates. A simple oncology AUC
model with three health states (progression free survival, progression and death)
and four-weekly cycles was built and converted to a CM model in Excel®, using
user defined Visual Basic functions. Results, generalizability and user friendliness
were compared. Results: The results of the two models were similar: for health
outcomes differences were around 1%, for costs and incremental cost-effectiveness
ratios around 0.5%. Calculations were done in a single cell/outcome instead of a
column of 100-200 cells depending on cycle length and time horizon, giving less
scope for bugs and facilitating easier debugging. As a result the implementation of
the CM model was faster and technical validation easier. Conclusions: The CM
approach requires more technical background from the developer; custom functions have to be built even for point estimates. However, results of a CM, requires
smaller spreadsheet space, and provides more transparency and easier debugging,
while providing similar or potentially more precise estimates compared to the AUC
model results.
PRM90
A Comparison of Modelling Techniques: Patient Simulation VERSUS
Markov Modelling in Ophthalmology
Claxton L 1, Malcolm W A 2, Hodgson R 1
1York Health Economics Consortium, York, UK, 2Novartis UK, Frimley, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Markov models are a currently popular means of estimating the costeffectiveness of interventions; however they are associated with certain limitations
which may make them ill-suited to inform some health care decisions. Patient simulation models offer an alternative methodology which may overcome some of these
A559
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
limitations potentially providing more accurate estimates of the cost-effectiveness.
This study aims to explore the strengths and limitations associated with simulation modelling, and the appropriateness of this methodology in ophthalmology.
Methods: An ophthalmology model that was previously developed using a Markov
structure was adapted to a patient simulation model using the same cost and quality of life inputs, and clinical inputs adapted to the appropriate format. The deterministic and probabilistic results of each model were then compared to each other,
with the costs being broken down by health state to identify key areas of differences.
Each model’s results were verified against real-world observational data. Results:
Results suggest that cost and quality of life outcomes are similar when unilateral
disease is considered, with differences in quality of life and costs being seen when
bilateral disease is incorporated. The key area of differences in costs is those relating
to blindness, as this is a function of both eyes which is not captured well in a Markov
model. One-off costs when a patient becomes blind are also not well captured in a
Markov model. Conclusions: Our results suggest that the ability of simulation
models to more accurately represent the real-world patient pathway allows a number of aspects of disease progression to be modelled, which cannot be easily done
using a Markov structure. In particular, the benefits of a simulation approach can
be demonstrated in the modelling of quality of life as a function of visual acuity in
both eyes, and capturing the costs relating to blindness, resulting in differences in
estimated cost effectiveness.
PRM91
The Oncotyrol Prostate Cancer Outcome and Policy Model - How
Latent Prevalence Affects the Benefit-Harm Balance of Screening
Mühlberger N 1, Heijnsdijk E A M 2, Kurzthaler C 1, Iskandar R 1, Krahn M D 3, Bremner K 4,
Oberaigner W 5, Klocker H 6, Horninger W 6, Conrads-Frank A 7, Sroczynski G 8, Siebert U9
1UMIT - University for Health Sciences, Medical Informatics and Technology / Oncotyrol - Center
for Personalized Cancer Medicine, Hall i. T. / Innsbruck, Austria, 2Department of Public Health,
Erasmus Medical Center, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 3Toronto Health Economics and Technology
Assessment (THETA) Collaborative, Toronto, ON, Canada, 4University Health Network, Toronto,
ON, Canada, 5Cancer Registry of Tyrol, TILAK GmbH, Innsbruck, Austria, 6Department of Urology,
Innsbruck Medical University, Innsbruck, Austria, 7UMIT - University for Health Sciences, Medical
Informatics and Technology, Hall i. T., Austria, 8UMIT - University for Health Sciences, Medical
Informatics and Technology/ ONCOTYROL - Center for Personalized Cancer Medicine, Hall in
Tyrol/ Innsbruck, Austria, 9Medical Informatics and Technology, and Director of the Division for
Health Technology Assessment and Bioinformatics, ONCOTYROL, Hall i. T, Austria
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The ONCOTYROL Prostate Cancer Outcome and Policy (PCOP) Model
is a state-transition micro-simulation model designed to evaluate prostate cancer
(PCa) screening. We used the model to investigate how the benefits-harm balance
of PCa screening is affected by the size of the latent prevalence pool. For this purpose, we recalibrated the natural history and detection component of the original
PCOP model adopted from an earlier version of the Erasmus MISCAN model to
match the higher prevalence observed by autopsy studies. The benefits and harms
of screening predicted by the recalibrated model were then compared with predictions from the original model. Methods: For recalibration, we reprogrammed the
natural history and detection component of the PCOP model as a deterministic
state-transition model with stage- and grade-specific cancer states in the statistical software package R. All parameters were implemented as functions or variables
and calibrated simultaneously in a single run using the ‘nlminb’ optimization
algorithm available in R to minimize the deviation of model predictions from
observed data. Calibration targets were observed data from autopsy studies, cancer
registries and the European trial (ERSPC). Both the recalibrated and original models
were identical except for calibrated parameters. Results: In total, we calibrated
46 parameters. Observed data could not be sufficiently fitted using the original
set of parameters. Additional parameters, allowing for an interruption of disease
progression in the stage- and grade-specific health states, and an effect modifier
allowing for lower screening sensitivities in older men had to be implemented.
Recalibration to higher prevalence demonstrated a considerable increase of overdiagnosis and decline of screening sensitivity, which significantly worsened the
benefit-harm balance of screening regarding QALYs. Conclusions: Benefit-harm
predictions of models, which use calibration to simulate PCa progression in the
unobservable latent phase, can be significantly affected by the assumptions on
latent cancer prevalence.
PRM92
A Systematic Search and Methodological Review of Economic
Models of Analgesics for Chronic Pain
Sullivan W 1, Gladwell D 2, Fagnani F 3, LopezBastida J 4, Phillips C 5, Hirst M 6, Dunlop W 6
1Bresmed, Sheffield, UK, 2BresMed, Sheffield, UK, 3Cemka Eval, Bourg La Reine, France, 4University
Castilla-La Mancha, Ciudad Real, Spain, 5Swansea University, Swansea, UK, 6Mundipharma
International Limited, Cambridge, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Economic modelling of analgesics for chronic pain (including the
chronic pain sub-populations of musculoskeletal, neuropathic and malignant pain)
is well established but characterised by methodological heterogeneity. The methods
used to model pain vary substantially between and within the sub-populations
and this variability inhibits comparability across the evidence base. This research
aims to facilitate increased consensus for future development of pain models, by
summarising existing published economic models and identifying key model characteristics. Methods: A systematic search and methodological review of published
economic models of therapies in chronic pain was performed. MEDLINE, EMBASE,
Health Technology Assessment, NHS Economic Evaluation Database and EconLit
were accessed in April 2014 and, from studies that met the inclusion criteria, key
methodological data were extracted and analysed. Results: Thirty-four studies
were included in the final review. From these, eighteen original model structures
were identified. Outcomes considered alongside analgesic effect varied substantially
across studies. Assumptions were used to model multiple treatment lines in eleven
model structures. Only three models used a time horizon greater than one year.
The inclusion of the costs of adverse events was common (eleven models) but less
prevalent in neuropathic pain models than for other chronic pain states. Finally the
majority of models (eleven) used a Markov structure but four of ten neuropathic
pain models used decision trees. Conclusions: Some methodological similarities
can be identified when considering economic modelling within sub-populations in
particular neuropathic pain. However, there is scope for further consensus in the key
design attributes of pain models, in particular the choice of secondary outcomes.
Further research is required to identify the strengths, weaknesses and complexities
of the key modelling choices. FUNDING STATEMENT: This research was funded by
Mundipharma International Limited.
PRM93
Validation of A Global Economic Model to Evaluate The CostEffectiveness Of Targeted Treatments Using Companion Diagnostics
In Advanced/Metastatic Cancer Treatment Using Kras Testing For
Cetuximab Therapy In Metastatic Colorectal Cancer
Mathurin K , Beauchemin C , Lachaine J
University of Montreal, Montreal, QC, Canada
.
.
.
Objectives: A global economic model to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of targeted
treatment using companion diagnostics in advanced/metastatic cancer treatment
has been recently developed. Targeted treatment with cetuximab guided with KRAS
testing in metastatic colorectal cancer (mCRC) is well implanted and has been subject of different economic evaluations. The objective of this study was to use data on
cetuximab guided with KRAS testing in mCRC to validate the global economic model
in advanced/metastatic cancer. Methods: Survival data and incidence of adverse
events (infections, rash, and pain) were obtained from the CO. 17 study, which is
a pivotal trial on the efficacy of cetuximab used according to the KRAS status vs.
best supportive care (BSC). Prevalence of KRAS mutation, specificity/sensitivity and
cost of KRAS testing, and the cost of cetuximab were obtained from the literature.
Other parameters for the cost-effectiveness analysis were intrinsic components of
the global model. Analyses were conducted from a Ministry of Health (MoH) and a
societal perspective. Results: The incremental cost-utility ratio (ICUR) of cetuximab treatment guided with KRAS testing compared to no testing and BSC to all
patients from a MoH perspective was estimated at $192,814/QALY and at $297,198/
QALY from a societal perspective. According to the deterministic analysis results,
the ICUR of cetuximab with KRAS testing compared to no testing and BSC varied
between $149,845/QALY and $387,971/QALY from a MoH perspective and between
$232,417/QALY and $492,354/QALY from a societal perspective. Parameters that
have the greatest impact on base-case ICURs were the cost of cetuximab and the
specificity of KRAS testing. Conclusions: Validation using cetuximab with KRAS
testing suggests that the global economic model is robust, as results obtained were
in the range than those reported in the literature. Although further validations will
be performed, the global model appears to produce quick, but accurate estimates.
PRM94
Systematic Overview On Value-Of Information Analyses In Cancer
Research
Rochau U 1, Schnell-Inderst P 2, Burger E A 3, Baldauf M 4, Kühne F 4, Jahn B 4, Siebert U 5
- University for Health Sciences, Medical Informatics and Technology/ ONCOTYROL Center for Personalized Cancer Medicine, Hall in Tyrol/ Innsbruck, Austria, 2UMIT - University for
Health Sciences, Medical Informatics and Technology, Hall i. T.; Innsbruck, Austria, 3University of
Oslo, Oslo, Norway, 4UMIT - University for Health Sciences, Medical Informatics and Technology,
Hall in Tyrol, Austria, 5Medical Informatics and Technology, and Director of the Division for Health
Technology Assessment and Bioinformatics, ONCOTYROL, Hall i. T, Austria
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1UMIT
Objectives: Value of information (VoI) analysis helps to set priorities for future
research by quantifying the value of collecting additional information. Determining
whether further evidence is required is especially important in oncology, where
novel, but expensive therapies with substantial uncertainty are emerging every
day. We aim to provide an overview of published VoI studies within cancer medicine
and summarize their methodological characteristics. Methods: We performed a
systematic literature review using Pubmed to identify VoI analyses applied within
cancer research. Studies exploring topics merely related to methodology were
excluded. The search terms were refined following the recent publication by Tuffaha
et al. 2014. Screening of articles was performed by two independent reviewers.
We extracted characteristics, such as health care context, disease, and type of VoI
analyses. Results: We identified a total of 96 references. Overall, 35 articles were
included for analysis. Nearly one-half (16) of the studies were conducted in the
health care context of UK, eight in the US, five in Finland, three in the Netherlands,
and one in Canada, France and Denmark. Disease areas included breast cancer
(26%), non-small-cell lung cancer (14%), colorectal cancer (14%), esophageal cancer
(9%) non-Hodgkin lymphoma (6%) and prostate cancer (6%). Nearly all of the studies
conducted expected value of perfect information (EVPI) analysis and about onehalf expected value of partial information (EVPPI). One study reported on expected
value of individualized care, and only three studies did sample size and trial cost
estimations. Conclusions: VoI analyses are becoming a more commonly applied
method, following standard calculations of cost-effectiveness, to assess the value of
further research. Simpler techniques, such as EVPI and EVPPI were reported more
frequently compared to the computationally more demanding calculations of EVSI
and ENBS, which often require complex statistical methods and estimates of a
study’s costs need to be derived.
PRM95
Clinical Trial Simulation Considering Quality Of Life Outcomes
Mohseninejad L , Heeg B , Majer I M
Pharmerit International, RotterdamThe Netherlands
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Prior to the actual implementation, trial simulations are often performed to optimize registration study design and hence to maximize the probability
of marketing approval. Almost exclusively, trials focus on clinical outcomes however reimbursement submissions require health economic evidence, in particular,
information on patients’ quality of life (QoL) and estimates of quality-adjusted life
A560
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
years (QALYs). Thus, considerations on QoL outcomes in the clinical trial design
phase may lead to better optimized reimbursement submissions. The objective
of this study was to develop a trial simulation model that is capable of addressing
complex research questions, provides flexibility to test various assumptions, and
predicts expected QALY outcomes. Methods: A patient-level simulation model
was developed using hypothetical data in oncology. The model considered two treatments reflecting the common design of a pivotal trial. Individual survival times
and time to progression data were simulated. Hazard ratios were used to include
treatment effects. Using the simulated individual level data, a multistate life table
model was constructed with three health states: pre-progression (with and without
adverse events), post-progression, and dead. Utility and disutility values derived
from literature were attached to the number of patients in each health state at a
given point in time. Differences between the treatment arms were derived in terms
of survival, QALYs, and the uncertainty around those (e.g. probability distribution,
P-value). Results: The trial simulation model assessed various patient number
scenarios to obtain the smallest sample size that provided a statistically significant minimum clinically meaningful QALY difference between the treatments.
Simulations were performed (e.g. testing the effect of different survival profile scenarios, utility values) to assess the robustness of the results. Conclusions: The
presented trial simulation model provided a flexible tool to inform clinical trial
design considering QoL outcomes. The model can be also useful for manufacturers
for pricing or investment decisions.
PRM96
Systematic Review Of Mathematical Models Predicting Relative
Effectiveness
Hummel N , Panayidou K , Gsteiger S , Egger M , Kilcher G
University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To identify and assess mathematical models predicting the relative
effectiveness of drug treatments in “real world” populations, based on data from
randomized control trials and other sources of evidence. Methods: Systematic
review of mathematical modelling studies addressing the step from relative efficacy to relative effectiveness. We identified eligible studies through electronic and
manual searches of MEDLINE and EMBASE databases, selected websites and reference lists of relevant papers. Two reviewers screened the articles independently
and extracted study characteristics such as model type, disease area, validation
and software used via an extraction form. Results: Eight papers met the inclusion
criteria covering four broad modelling approaches: multi-state models, simulationbased approaches, mechanistic models, and classical regression based models. The
multi-state models were the predominant class of models. These models are defined
as time-dependent stochastic processes with discrete event space. Most examples
belonged to the special case of Markov multi-state models. Multi-state models
were applied at the level of population groups or at the individual patient level.
The other approaches we identified were less frequent. Discrete event simulation
was used in one paper. This approach is entirely based on simulations. One article
described a mechanistic model based on ordinary differential equations, which
are typically derived from biological knowledge and first principles. Finally, more
classical regression techniques from survival analysis were used in two papers. Six
articles included models built for cardiovascular indications, the remaining ones
covered oncology and neurosciences. Internal or external model validation was
presented in six papers, while two papers considered only sensitivity analysis to
evaluate the model performance. Conclusions: This review shows the range of
models currently used for predicting the relative effectiveness of drug interventions
in real world patient populations. They complement the available tools for evidence
synthesis in comparative effectiveness research.
PRM97
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis Of An Antimicrobial Transparent
Dressing For Protecting Central Vascular Accesses In Critically
Ill Patients Versus Standard Transparent Dressings In France: A
Comparison Of Two Modeling Approaches: Decision-Tree Versus NonHomogeneous Markov Model
M 1, Motrunich A 2, Maunoury
F2
Palka-Santini
13M Germany, Neuss, Germany, 2Statésia, Le Mans, France
.
.
.
Objectives: To perform cost-effectiveness analysis (CEA) for routine use of a transparent dressing integrating a chlorhexidine gluconate (CHG) -containing gel pad
versus standard transparent dressings, with a classical decision tree model and
a Non-Homogeneous Markov Model (NHMM) previously developed. Methods:
Clinical efficacy data was extracted from a multicentre randomized controlled trial
(RCT) with 1,879 patients and economical data obtained from micro and macrocosting published studies. The baseline method is a NHMM previously developed in
Microsoft Excel® with VBA using the same data sources. The decision tree was built
with the TreeAge Pro® software 2013. One-way deterministic (DSA) and probabilistic
sensitivity (PSA) analyses were conducted on key clinical and economic parameters. Results: Based on the decision-tree model, the CHG-dressing is a dominant
strategy compared to standard dressings. The intervention prevents 13.5 infections
per 1,000 patients and saves € 157 per patient. These results are robust across a
range of values for several parameters in DSA. The PSA with the NHMM resulted in
11.8 infections avoided per 1,000 patients (95%CI: [3.85; 19.64)]) and a mean extra
cost of € 141 per patient (95%CI: [€ -975; € 1,258]) when using antimicrobial dressing. Effectiveness as calculated by both models is similar while cost estimations
diverge. Conclusions: Decision-tree and the NHMM are structurally different and
even though their outcomes cannot be directly compared, they were coherent. The
decision-tree model indicates that CHG-dressings are cost-saving and a dominant
preventative strategy for CRBSIs. The Markov model supports cost-effectiveness
compared to standard dressing. The main disadvantages of the decision-tree are the
inability to integrate changes among health states during the ICU stay and to simulate possible observable trajectories in the patient history. The structure of the nonhomogeneous Markov model does not allow DSA for the incidence of the disease.
PRM98
HEALTH ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF DIAGNOSTIC AND PROGNOSTIC
PREDICTION MODELS. A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW
Van Giessen A1, Wilcher B 2, Peters J 2, Hyde C 2, Moons K G 1, de Wit G A 3, Koffijberg H 1
Medical Center Utrecht, Utrecht, The Netherlands,, 2Exeter University, Exeter, UK,
Institute for Public Health and the Environment, Bilthoven, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1University
3National
Objectives: The aim of this study is to provide an overview of the quality of health
economic evaluations (HEEs) of prediction models, the evidence used, and the challenges. Methods: The databases Medline, Embase, Econlit, and the NHS Economic
Evaluations Database were systematically searched for HEEs of diagnostic and prognostic risk prediction models. The included HEEs were evaluated on their methodological quality using the Drummond checklist. Furthermore, an item list was
developed incorporating descriptive items on the HEE, specific items on the HEE of
prediction models, and statistical characteristics of the prediction model that could
be incorporated into the evaluation. Results: The database search resulted in 791
unique papers, from which 653 were excluded based on abstract. After assessing
full texts, 17 HEEs (all cost-utility studies) were included. A prediction model was
compared to current practice in 11 HEEs and to an extended prediction model in 6
HEEs. On a 35-point scale the quality score ranged from 17 to 32 (median 25). In 7
papers there was no overlap between authors of the initial prediction model paper
and those of the corresponding HEE. In 5 papers individuals were classified based
on a single (set of) threshold(s); based on guidelines in 4 papers and once on expert
opinion. In 8 papers the classification threshold was optimized in the CEA itself.
A probabilistic sensitivity analysis was not included in 7 papers and uncertainty
around predicted risks was only taken into account once. Conclusions: In most
papers limited (prediction model) details were available. Potentially due to this lack
of evidence and a lack of specific guidelines on HEE of prediction models, a large
variety in the quality and methodology was observed. This variation may complicate
the validation and interpretation of HEE results and thereby the decision making
on implementation of prediction models in practice.
PRM99
MIGRATION OF HEALTH ECONOMICS MODELS TO WEB AND MOBILE
ENVIRONMENTS. WHY SHOULD MODELS GO WEB?
Topachevskyi O 1, Volovyk A 2
Health Outcomes, Brussels, Belgium, 2Hashtago, Kiev, Ukraine
.
.
1Digital
Objectives: To understand the key functional differences between conventional
cost-effectiveness Excel and web based model types. Methods: An online survey
consisting 18 end users and 5 model owners (n= 23) was conducted. Respondents
were asked to rate key criteria of both model types on a scale from 0 to 10. Model
types were compared with the following 13 criterias: model execution speed and
size, general functionality support, accessibility, usability, model management and
versioning, ease of localization, ease of model core modification, sharing, review
process, usage analytics, integration with other content. No weighting to the scoring across criteria was applied. Results: Results of the survey indicate that web
based models outperform standalone models in 10 of the 13 criteria assessed. Model
review process, ease of model core modification and execution speed was rated
higher for conventional standalone Excel models. 80% of model owners and 78% of
model users assigned higher overall score for web based models compared to Excel
models. Conclusions: Web based models offer advantages primarily related to
model usage and lifecycle management. These models can be viewed on any hardware device or browser, thus overcoming the limitations of Excel models. The use of
latest web technologies such as JavaScript, HTML5 and CSS3 improve user experience in model adaptation and presentation to end audience. Usage analytics, smart
versioning, web sharing and automatic updates are the functional advantages that
can not be achieved with conventional Excel models due to technical limitations.
PRM100
Validating A Model To Predict Disease Progression Outcomes In
Patients With COPD
Risebrough N A 1, Briggs A 2, Baker T M 3, Exuzides A 4, Colby C 4, Rutten van-Molken M 5,
Gonzalez McQuire S 6, Lomas D 7, Muellerova H 6, Tal-Singer R 8, Ismaila A 9
1ICON plc (formerly Oxford Outcomes), Toronto, ON, Canada, 2University of Glasgow, Glasgow,
UK, 3ICON plc (formerly Oxford Outcomes), Morristown, NJ, USA, 4ICON plc, San Francisco, CA,
USA, 5Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 6GlaxoSmithKline R&D,
Uxbridge, UK, 7University College London, London, UK, 8GlaxoSmithKline R&D, King of Prussia,
PA, USA, 9GlaxoSmithKline, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To validate a model for quantifying the COPD disease progression
against both the data used to generate the model (internal validation) and clinical
trial data not used in the model’s development (external validation). Methods:
A model representing causal relationships between central disease attributes
(lung function, exacerbations, symptoms and exercise capacity) and final outcomes (survival, quality of life, cost) was developed based on the Evaluation of
COPD Longitudinally to Identify Predictive Surrogate Endpoints (ECLIPSE) study
dataset. Model predicted annual outcomes were compared to the corresponding
annual observed data from ECLIPSE (n= 2,164) and TOwards a Revolution in COPD
Health (TORCH) (n= 6,108) trials based on fitting the model baseline parameters to
reflect each specific study population. Results: The model accurately predicted
the ECLIPSE outcomes in at least two of the three annual time points within the
95% confidence interval (CI) of the observed data for survival, FEV1% predicted,
and annual exacerbations (per patient per year [PPPY]. The model predicted 9.0
metres annual decline in Six Minute Walk Distance compared to ECLIPSE observed
data of 5.7 metres decline. The model accurately predicted the TORCH placebo
outcomes in at least two of the three annual time points within the 95%CI of the
observed data for FEV decline and annual exacerbations PPPY. The model over
predicted survival by 8% (absolute) compared to TORCH observed data at year
3. Conclusions: As expected, the model more accurately predicted the ECLIPSE
observed outcomes in the internal validation exercise, than TORCH outcomes in
the external validation.
A561
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PRM101
Application Of A Model Of Decision Based On Fuzzy Logic To
Pharmacoeconomics: Ranibizumab VERSUS Aflibercert In AMD
Alonso Herreros J M 1, González-Cuello A 2
LOS ARCOS MAR MENOR, SAN JAVIER (MURCIA), Spain, 2Murcia University,
MURCIA, Spain
.
.
.
1HOSPITAL
Objectives: The term “fuzzy logic” was introduced in 1965 by LAZadeh. Compared
to traditional logic, fuzzy logic variables may have a truth value in degree. Fuzzy
logic has been applied to many fields, from economic analysis, to artificial intelligence. However it has not been applied so far to pharmacoeconomics. We present a
model of pharmacoeconomic decision based on fuzzy logic (Fuzzy Economic Review
2001; 6 (2): 51-73) and applied to the selection of ranibizumab-aflibercept in treating
AMD. Methods: According to a decision analysis model based on fuzzy logic four
fuzzy variables that affect the choice of treatment are defined: treatment success
(expressed as a probability), cost of success, cost of failure (expressed as inverses),
and other conditions about the cost (negotiation, handling of drugs...). Based on
the value of these fuzzy variables, three linguistic variables (High, Medium, Low)
are defined to expressing convenience of choice. The combination of the three possible values for each of the variables gives us 81 possible decision rules, so that the
(HHHH) would be the most favorable option and (LLLL) the more unfavorable. So
a new fuzzy variable called “ranking” is established for classifying these options
with 7 possible values (Very-unfavorable, unfavorable, slightly-unfavorable, neutral,
slightly-favorable, favorable, very-favorable). The value of the fuzzy variables for
ranibizumab and aflibercept were established based on pivotal clinical trials at 52
weeks cited by the EMEA. Results: The matrices obtained for ranibizumab was
(0.29,3. 55 10-4, -1.36 10-4 0.7), and aflibercept (0.269,7. 4 10-4 -2.59 10-4 0.3). These
matrices correspond to decision rules (HLLM) and (HMML) and correspond to a
ranking of “neutral” and “slightly-favorable”. Conclusions: It possible to apply
methods of “fuzzy logic” to pharmacoeconomic studies to select the most favorable
treatment. According to model, AMD treatment, with aflibercept would be a slightly
more favorable option than ranibizumab.
PRM102
Development Of An Influenza Outbreak Forecasting Model Using
Time Series Analysis Methods
Smolen H J
Medical Decision Modeling Inc., Indianapolis, IN, USA
.
.
Objectives: To use historical influenza incidence time series data to develop a
predictive model using time series analysis methods to forecast expected number of reported influenza cases. BACKGROUND: Influenza is a common disease
associated with high mortality. Low vaccination rates motivate health officials to
predict outbreaks and intervene accordingly. A predictive model would facilitate in
deciding whether an apparent excess of cases represents an outbreak or a random
variation. Methods: Google Flu Trend project data from 2003 to 2014 was used to
construct this predictive model. The influenza time series data clearly had a seasonal variation to it so a seasonally fit model using seasonal indicators, a seasonally
fit model using trigonometric functions, and a multiplicative seasonal autoregressive integrated moving average (SARIMA) model were considered. Fifty-two weeks
of data from the time series were withheld from the model fitting process so as
to evaluate the predictive capability of the selected model using mean absolute
percentage error (MAPE). The Akaike’s Information Criterion (AIC) goodness of fit
measure was used to select the model that fit the data the best (lower the better). Results: The SARIMA model provided the best fit for the data with an AIC of
6361.7. The seasonally fit model using seasonal indicators had an AIC of 8473.9 and
the seasonally fit model using trigonometric functions had an AIC of 8438.2. The
SARIMA model MAPE for the predicted 52 weeks was 87.5%. The forecasted values
were within the 95% confidence band of the actual ending 52 week data, though at
the high end of the band. Conclusions: The SARIMA model was an appropriate
predictor for flu cases in 2013-4. The data used to construct the model included flu
epidemics so removing these time periods would result in a model more appropriate for non-epidemic periods.
PRM103
Development Of A Global Economic Model To Evaluate The CostEffectiveness Of Targeted Treatments Using Companion Diagnostics
In Advanced/Metastatic Cancer Treatment
Mathurin K , Beauchemin C , Lachaine J
University of Montreal, Montreal, QC, Canada
.
.
.
Objectives: With the development of high priced new targeted treatment for cancer, there is a need to know as soon as possible if these treatments are likely to
be cost-effective. The objective of this study was to develop a model with global
parameters to estimate the cost-effectiveness of targeted treatments using companion diagnostics in advanced/metastatic cancer treatment. Methods: The model
was developed to take into account parameters usually considered in conventional
economic models in cancer (treatment costs, costs of cancer care, target population
characteristics, survival data, utilities, disutilities and costs associated with adverse
events (AEs), etc.), and also parameters specific to the companion diagnostic itself
(mutation prevalence, test specificity and sensitivity, and cost). The model had to
allow performing cost-utility analyses from both a Health Ministry and a societal
perspective and for most common cancers (lung, breast, colorectal, prostate, cervical/endometrial, bladder, and non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma). Results: The global
model comprises a decision tree and a lifetime Markov model. The decision tree
takes into account the sensitivity and specificity and cost of the companion diagnosis, and the prevalence of the biomarker/mutation in the eligible population.
The Markov model with monthly cycles includes the following 3 health states:
progression-free, progressive disease and death. Intrisic parameters of the model
comprise the mean characteristics of the target population, utilities associated
with health states, disutilities and costs associated with AEs, and costs associated
with drug administration, cancer care, end-of-life care, follow-up visits, productivity
losses, and informal care. Specific parameters to be entered by users are the prevalence of the mutation, treatment costs, specificity/sensitivity and cost of the test,
survival data and the incidence of AEs. Conclusions: The proposed global model
for the economic evaluation of targeted treatments using companion diagnostics in
advanced/metastatic cancer treatment can, with minimal input, quickly generate
cost-effectiveness analyses of targeted cancer treatment.
PRM104
A Web Based Optimisation Model For A Portfolio Of Preventative
Interventions Utilizing Multi Criteria Decision Analyses (Mcda)
Framework
Topachevskyi O 1, Volovyk A 2
1Digital Health Outcomes, Brussels, Belgium, 2Hashtago, Kiev, Ukraine
.
.
Objectives: To inform decision makers who seek extension of Universal Mass
Vaccination (UMV) about the most optimal allocation of funds across multiple preventative interventions or vaccines. To account for decision makers preferences using
MCDA. Methods: A multi cohort markov model was developed to assess clinical and
economic consequences of vaccine preventable diseases in Japan. Disease incidence
rates, direct medical costs and QoL data were obtained from local sources. Payer
perspective only was considered. Optimization module utilizing linear programming
was developed to maximize outcome of interest which serve as an objective function
subject to budget and intervention coverage constraints. A working version of the
model can be found at http: //www. digitalho. com/models/a/portfolio/index. html.
The model was initially developed in Excel and then automatically transformed into
a JavaScript application to allow for an online access. One way sensitivity analyses
was conducted to parametric unceranity. Results: Model results indicate that the
optimal mix of interventions depends primarily on the objective function. Various
single objective functions or a combination of multiple weighted objectives lead to
different mix of interventions. When prevention of death is as an objective function
then pneumococcal and rotavirus vaccines are chosen. Conclusions: The proposed
web based model is a complementary addition to the conventional cost-effectiveness
assessment for preventative interventions. This model helps to understand sequence
of introduction of prevantative interventions and expected health and economic
outcomes over time. The use of MCDA framework helps users to define specfic health
objectives to be used in optimisation module. The web based modeling solution provides a widespread access to an easy to use tool that can by used by authorities,
academia and non-modeling professionals.
PRM105
Calibration And Statistical Modeling To Inform A Micro-Simulation
Model For Early HTA
Bongers M L 1, De Ruysscher D 2, Oberije C 3, Lambin P 2, Uyl-de Groot C A 4, Coupe V M 1
University Medical Center, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 2University Hospitals Leuven/KU
Leuven, Leuven, Belgium, 3MAASTRO Clinic, Maastricht, The Netherlands, 4Erasmus University
Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1VU
Objectives: For the evaluation of the potential cost-effectiveness of an early
experimental therapy, we calibrated an existing micro-simulation model for radiotherapy planning in lung cancer using pilot data. Methods: We used an externally validated micro-simulation model, build using Real World Evidence data.
The model contained four clinical states from alive to death, with intermediate
states ‘local recurrence’ and ‘metastasis’, with 5 transitions. Based on individual
and time-dependent hazard rates, patients move through the model according to
their combination of patient characteristics and random variation. For the experimental dosis-escalation therapy we had limited pilot study data, which included
overall survival and a number of baseline characteristics. The distribution of patient
features in the cohort of the micro-simulation model was adjusted so that the simulated patients had the same baseline characteristics as the patients that received
experimental therapy. Alternative radiotherapy strategies affected 5 transitions in
the model, quantified by 5 hazard ratios (HRs). Subsequently, HRs for experimental
radiotherapy compared to current radiotherapy were calibrated until they were
able to satisfactorily reproduce the survival curve of the pilot data. The best fitting
sets of HRs were selected based on the least Sum of Squared Errors (SSE) of the
model predictions and the survival curve of the experimental therapy on three
time points. Results: The best fitting set HRs resulted in a SSE of 0,005 based on
prediction errors at 1,2 and 3-year survival. Although 33 out of 1000 sets produced
predictions with less than 5% prediction error, hazard ratios varied strongly within
and over the different sets. Conclusions: By using calibration, we obtained a
micro-simulation model that is suitable for the evaluation of new treatments in
the absence of empirical data. The model will be used for cost-effectiveness analyses, where the variation in hazard ratios within sets will be evaluated in scenario
analyses.
PRM106
How Does Uncertainty Around Costs And Effects Relate To
Uncertainty Around Cost-Effectiveness?
Jain M 1, Bhattacharyya S 1, Gupta S 1, Sonathi V 1, Mahon R 2, Malakar H 1, Vudumala U 1,
Gunda P 1, Kumar P 1, Partha G 1, Thomas S K 3
Healthcare Pvt. Ltd., Hyderabad, India, 2Novartis Ireland Limited, Dublin, Ireland,
3Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation, East Hanover, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Novartis
Objectives: HTAs require information on costs and outcomes as well as the
uncertainty around them for making reimbursement decisions. Uncertainty
around costs and effects (outcome uncertainty) can be substantial and increasingly so at more distal time points. However, the uncertainty surrounding the
decision to adopt or reject a technology based on cost-effectiveness (decision
uncertainty) evolves over time in a different manner. In this analysis, we intend
to illustrate that increased outcome uncertainty need not result in increased
decision uncertainty and that both may evolve over time differently. Methods:
A previously published lifetime Markov model, built from UK health care perspective, was used in the analysis. The model compared the cost-effectiveness (CE) of
A562
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Zidovudine + Lamivudine combination therapy vs Zidovudine monotherapy, to
treat HIV infection. Based on probabilistic simulations, cumulative incremental
net monetary benefits (CINMB) at a CE threshold of £20,000/QALY and probabilities of being cost-effective at various time-horizons (1-20 years) were estimated.
Further, for each time-horizon, a CINMB frequency distribution was plotted and
summary statistics were estimated. Results: For the combination therapy, while
the outcome uncertainty increased over time, the decision uncertainty decreased.
95% confidence interval for expected CINMB was narrowest at year 1 (-1,771£ to
-1,755£) and widest at year 7 (2,101£ to 2,209£); simultaneously the probability of
being cost effective increased from 5% to 80% during this time. Outcome uncertainty, measured as the standard deviation of CINMB values stabilized after 5
years while probability of the combination therapy being cost effective continued
to increase, indicating that decision uncertainty does not vary in tandem with
outcome uncertainty. Conclusions: The above analysis shows that higher outcome uncertainty does not necessarily lead to higher decision uncertainty. CINMB
could be a useful tool to observe the relationships between outcome uncertainty,
decision uncertainty and time.
PRM107
Development Of A Model To Assess The Cost-Effectiveness Of
Therapies For Patients With Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus (T2DM)
Following A Reference Model Framework
Aguiar-Ibáñez R 1, Palencia R 2, Kandaswamy P 3, Flavin J 4, Gauthier A 5, Davies M J 6
1Amaris Consulting UK, London, UK, 2Boehringer Ingelheim GmbH, Ingelheim am Rhein, Germany,
3Boehringer Ingelheim UK, Bracknell, UK, 4Boehringer Ingelheim Canada Ltd, Burlingon, ON,
Canada, 5Amaris, London, UK, 6University of Leicester, Leicester, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To describe the practical approach implemented to construct a
global cost-effectiveness model for T2DM therapies following a framework proposed for the development of reference models to inform public funding decisions. Methods: 1) A systematic review of published models was conducted to
conceptualise the model in terms of natural history and relevant effects to include.
2) Clinical and health economic experts were selected to provide feedback during
the model conceptualisation (to identify the appropriate modelling technique), the
model implementation and the assessment of the results. 3) The model was built
and populated based on the systematic identification of best available data, a network meta-analyses, a review of previous T2DM submissions to health authorities
and other published information. The model incorporated several structures for
uncertain areas, such as: treatment patterns; type and timing of adverse events;
their impact in the occurrence of long-term complications; and the impact of weight
changes on relevant endpoints. 4) The model was then validated based on outputs’ accuracy, feedback from country affiliates and consistency with the CORE
model results. 5) The critical feedback received by HTA bodies has also been used
to refine the model and improve its credibility accordingly. Results: Experts’ input
proved invaluable at each developmental stage. One challenge related to the comparability with other published T2DM models, which were not fully transparent
regarding assumptions. This framework resulted in a flexible model, accurate and
stable, and easily adaptable to different health care systems. Country adaptations
have contributed to the identification of aspects that require relevant structural
changes and their rationale. Conclusions: The followed framework enhanced
the transparency of the model and the accuracy of the results. Using a reference
model across different countries, with adaptations made in consistency with this
model, should help ensure consistent and comparable evaluations of the model
across different countries.
PRM108
Assessing The Relationship Between Individual Attributes
Identified In Review Of Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA)
Of Rare Diseases And Annual Treatment Costs In Rare Endocrine
Disorders
Schey C 1, Irwin J 2, Teneishvili M 2, Krabbe P F M 3, Connolly M 4
of Groningen, St Prex, Switzerland, 2Shire Pharmaceuticals, Maidenhead, UK,
3University of Groningen, University Medical Center Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands,
4University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: Payers have a perception that orphan products are extremely
expensive. The current health technology assessment (HTA) systems might be
too restrictive for orphan drugs, therefore potentially denying patients access to
life-saving medicines. While price is important, it should be considered in relation
to a broader range of product attributes, such as unmet need and disease severity
that are not considered in cost-effectiveness analysis used by many HTA agencies.
To overcome these challenges multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA) has been
proposed as an alternative to evaluate technologies. The aim of this study was to
identify criteria reported in the literature, and to assess their impact on the total
“score” for each product in relation to price. Methods: A systematic literature
review was conducted to identify the most frequently cited attributes in MCDA.
From the leading attributes identified, we reviewed and plotted the relationship
between single attributes and the average annual treatment costs for several drugs
used in the treatment of endocrine-related rare diseases. Annual treatment cost
was based on UK prices for the average daily dose per patient. Results: The
three most frequently mentioned attributes were ‘disease severity’, ‘treatment
impact on condition’, and ‘level of research undertaken to support use of the product’. Disease severity was not shown to influence product price. Similarly, orphan
drugs are not necessarily more expensive than products without orphan drug
status. There is little discernible relationship between treatment ‘convenience’
and average annual treatment cost. A trend was observed between the market size
and the average annual treatment cost. Conclusions: If society is concerned
about equity and equal access to medicines for all patients, MCDA may offer a
viable alternative to inform in reimbursement decisions for orphan drugs. The
analysis can be used to inform investigations on the application of MCDAs in
rare diseases.
PRM109
Visualizing Methods For Discrete-Event-Simulations Using The
Example Of A Breast Cancer Decision-Analytic Model
Jahn B 1, Rochau U 2, Shterjovska J 1, Kurzthaler C 3, Kluibenschädl M 1, Urach C 4, Einzinger P 4,
Piringer H 5, Popper N 4, Siebert U 6
1UMIT - University for Health Sciences, Medical Informatics and Technology, Hall in Tyrol, Austria,
2UMIT - University for Health Sciences, Medical Informatics and Technology/ ONCOTYROL Center for Personalized Cancer Medicine, Hall in Tyrol/ Innsbruck, Austria, 3UMIT - University
for Health Sciences, Medical Informatics and Technology / Oncotyrol - Center for Personalized
Cancer Medicine, Hall i. T. / Innsbruck, Austria, 4Vienna University of Technology, dwh Simulation
Services, Wien, Austria, 5VRVis Zentrum für Virtual Reality und Visualisierung Forschungs-GmbH,
Vienna, Austria, 6Medical Informatics and Technology, and Director of the Division for Health
Technology Assessment and Bioinformatics, ONCOTYROL, Hall i. T, Austria
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Discrete-Event-Simulation (DES) is a commonly used modeling
tool to analyze the comparative effectiveness of alternative health technologies
and to optimize resource allocation in health care settings. DES models are often
rather complex and visualization is very important to improve transparency and
acceptability. This study aims to illustrate and contrast alternative visualization
techniques on a decision-analytic model for breast cancer. Methods: DES visualization methods and their applications in health care, engineering, and operations research were sought from a wide variety of sources, including literature
databases (e.g., PubMed) and webpages of simulation conference (e.g., Winter
Simulation Conference), academic societies etc. Based on this review, alternative
visualization techniques for the conceptual model were selected, applied on a real
world modeling example and compared. Results: In health care, the recently
published ISPOR-SMDM Modeling Good Research Practice guidelines recommend
flow diagrams or state charts to represent the key elements of a model, including
the possible pathways, and the presence of queues and decision points. For flow
charts, we found an international standard (ISO 5807). The application of standards
like this could support harmonization of process-oriented models. In general, flow
charts may lack the information of health states and transitions between health
states that are relevant for clinicians to review the model. The semantic for state
charts invented by Harel provides a further development of the bubble diagrams
of State-Transition (Markov) Models (e.g. one state containing other states, one
state detects changes in another). In state charts, health states could explicitly
be named but treatment processes and resources use are less explicit. For DES
software implementation, state charts seem to be less intuitive. For both methods,
the application of visualization standards and guidelines was not always straight
forward for our breast cancer model. Conclusions: In the case example there
was no superior visualization technique.
PRM110
Microsimulation Model For The Assessment Of Personalized Cancer
Care: The Mapcca Model Framework
Van der Meijde E 1, van den Eertwegh A J 1, Fijneman R J 1, Meijer G A 1, Linn S C 2, Coupe V M 1
University Medical Center, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 2Netherlands Cancer Institute,
Amsterdam, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1VU
Objectives: Most cancer care models are based on observed clinical events such
as recurrence-free and overall survival. Times at which events are recorded depend
not only on effectiveness of treatment, but also on timing of examinations and
types of tests performed. Should these change, observation times would change
as well. Construct a microsimulation model that describes the cancer disease
process using a description of underlying tumor growth as well as its interaction
with diagnostics, treatments and surveillance. The aim is to arrive at a framework that allows for exploration of the impact of simultaneously altering two
or more aspects of the care process. Methods: The framework consists of two
components; the disease model and the clinical management module. The disease
model consists of atumor level, describing the growth and metastasis of the tumor,
and a patient level, describing clinical observed states, such as recurrence and
death, either from the disease or other causes. The clinical management module
consists of the care patients receive, i.e. the diagnostic process, treatment and
surveillance. This module interacts with the disease process, influencing the rate
of transitioning between tumor growth states at the tumor level, and the rate of
detecting a recurrence at the patient level. Results: A simulation study was
performed to examine the feasibility of applying the framework to melanoma
progression. Results demonstrated stage specific recurrence rates similar to those
found in literature. Conclusions: The proposed microsimulation model framework allows for generating individual patient histories by simulating underlying
tumor growth in interaction with clinical management. Our modeling approach
allows for the exploration of the potential of drugs intervening in different parts
of the tumor growth pathway. In addition, the approach allows for the evaluation
of changing diagnostic patterns.
PRM111
Methodological Evaluation Of The Impact Of Survival Costs In
Oncology Modelling
Taylor M 1, Filby A 1, Proudfoot C 2
1York Health Economics Consortium, York, UK, 2Sanofi, Guildford, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: Economic evaluations typically include all costs relevant to a disease,
not only drug-related costs. This is particularly relevant to oncology modelling, as
costs are assigned to each health state in the model, and, therefore, extending survival also increases costs. Because patients often incur higher health care costs in
the post-progressed state of disease where costs of disease management are high,
extending survival and increasing a patient’s time in the post-progressed stage
can be particularly costly. Empirical analyses of the implications of such methods
have not yet been extensively investigated by assessing different scenarios such as
baseline severity and prognosis. The objective of this research was to investigate
the methodology used in oncology modelling, and to determine the effect that this
has on predicted cost-effectiveness. Methods: We developed a flexible three-state
A563
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
economic model with ten key parameters to calculate the ICERs associated with
various combinations of inputs. Published HTAs were reviewed to determine the
model inputs. Extensive scenario and multiway sensitivity analyses were carried
out to document informative patterns and relationships between parameters that
affected the results. Results: Results showed that cancer sub-types with higher
post-progression costs reduced a treatments likelihood of being cost-effective. The
results also highlighted specific thresholds at which various cancer-specific case
studies or combinations of inputs, including drug price, resulted in the drug being
deemed not cost-effective using a threshold of £20,000 per QALY. Conclusions:
The impact of post-progression costs can vary dependent on how these costs are
modelled and also dependent on several factors, namely the ratios between health
state utilities, ‘background’ costs, drug costs and the relative time spent in the
stable and progressed disease states. It is demonstrated that, for many oncology
treatments whose primary aim is to extend survival, this impact can be prohibitive
to an intervention’s probability of being cost-effective.
PRM112
Dose-Response Network Meta-Analysis To Address Dose
Heterogeneity In A Cost-Effectiveness Analysis In Acute Migraine
Reason T 1, Dias S 2, Welton N 2
Health, London, UK, 2University of Bristol, Bristol, UK
.
.
.
1IMS
Objectives: Network Meta Analyses (NMAs) are often used to parameterise efficacy
in decision models for economic evaluation. A common source of heterogeneity
in NMA arises from the fact that treatments may be given at different doses. This
variation may manifest as unexplained heterogeneity in standard NMA models and
propagates through to the decision analysis. We aim to explore how dose-response
NMA can be used to inform cost-effectiveness analysis using a cost-utility analysis
of treatments for acute migraine. Methods: We conducted four NMAs with different assumptions around dose-response to inform an economic evaluation in acute
migraine. Separate 1-level NMAs were conducted where interventions were ‘lumped’
at the ‘dose’, ‘treatment’ and ‘class’ levels and a multi-level NMA was conducted,
assuming monotonic dose-response. All NMAs were used to inform effect sizes in
an economic model; the model structure, costing methods and utility inputs from
the NICE Headaches guideline were adopted. The NMA models were compared
in terms of heterogeneity and Deviance Information Criteria (DIC). We report the
results of the economic analyses using cost-effectiveness acceptability frontiers
(CEAFs). Results: Dose-response parameterisation lead to NMA models with lower
heterogeneity and better fit. Different dose-response parameterisations substantially changed the resource allocation decision, particularly at lower willingness
to pay thresholds. For the more complex NMA model, it is unclear from a decision
making perspective which effect size estimates should be selected as inputs to
the decision model and we show that careful consideration should be given to the
relevance of individual doses and confounding bias. Conclusions: Dose-response
NMA provides a useful and arguably more appropriate method for conducting NMA
for decision analysis. Careful consideration should be given to how to treat doses of
the same intervention in NMA since different parameterisations may lead to biased
effect sizes and sub-optimal conclusions around cost-effectiveness.
PRM113
Impact Of International And Therapeutic Referencing On Prices And
Launch Optimization
Hakim P 1, Weiss J 1, Degun R 1, Chalmers M 1, Kjeldgaard-Pedersen J 2, Sleeper M 3
Consulting, Inc, London, UK, 2Data2Impact, Copenhagen, Denmark, 3Asera Consulting,
Surrey, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Navigant
Objectives: Majority of established pharmaceutical markets use pricing rules that
reference products both across (international reference pricing; IRP) and within
(therapeutic reference pricing; TRP) country-lines. Some markets, such as the UK,
use no such rules and freely price therapies. IRP and TRP are used as effective
measures to control price of pharmaceutical products. However, understanding the
impact on a global level is considered highly complex, due to each market using
different legislations and mechanisms. There is a growing need to better understand
the impact of IRP and TRP on the decay of pharmaceutical drug prices and their
effects on launch prices and sequencing across multiple markets. Methods: We
utilized a model to simulate the impact of IRP and TRP, as well as parallel trade, to
quantitatively assess impact on drug prices across 40 markets (EU28, Switzerland,
Russia, Iceland, Norway, Turkey, Israel, Brazil, Japan, South Korea, Australia, Canada
and USA). The model uses simulating annealing parameters to also yield optimized
launch sequences in all markets. Results: Outputs of the model include impact to
volume, price and revenue as well as parallel trade. Using a dynamic launch map,
the model provides optimized price and launch sequence of a given pharmaceutical
product. Within a set window, the launch and reimbursement dates were optimized
based on a divergent set of rules and country baskets, often differing from manufacturers expected launch prices and sequences. While manufacturers are often
able to secure higher price for therapies in free-price markets, the model clearly
demonstrates the spill-over impact of referencing (both formally and informally)
across countries and within therapeutic groups. Conclusions: Previously, launch
sequences were optimized based on the implications on major markets. However, an
expansive model looking at large number of markets that employ varying IRP and
TRP rules will assist manufacturers in identifying an optimized price and launch
sequence strategy.
PRM114
Modeling Disease Progression In Alzheimer’s Dementia To Inform
HTA (CEA)
Green C , Zhang S
Exeter University, Exeter, UK
.
.
Objectives: Alzheimer’s dementia (AD) poses a significant challenge to health care
systems around the world. Whilst treatment options are currently limited, with no
effective disease modifying treatment, new advances in diagnosis and manage-
ment of AD and promising advances in health technologies have the potential to
significantly impact on the burden of the disease. However, alongside treatment
advances it is important to improve the evaluation framework if we are to capture
the potential benefits to people with AD. Methods to model disease progression
over time, for use in comparative and cost-effectiveness analyses (CEA), is a priority area for further research. The objective in this research is to develop a new
framework for modeling AD progression over time using the three main symptom
domains of cognitive function, behaviour and mood, and functioning. Methods:
Development of a descriptive system, comprising a set of health states for AD, using
the three symptom domains. Statistical modeling of disease progression through
states over time, using US data from the National Alzheimer’s Coordinating Center
(NACC) (n= 3009). The model is tested in a decision-analytic context, using time to
progression and a cost-per-QALY framework. Results: A 20-state disease progression pathway has been developed using multi-variate health states described using
the three symptom domains. Transition probabilities and hazard rates have been
estimated to model progression over time through the multi-variate descriptive
system. In a baseline model over a 5-year timeframe, using mild-to-moderate AD
starting states, 78% of people progressed to health states considered severe on at
least one of the symptoms (46% severe for cognition). In a HTA context simulating a
treatment with a modest effect the modeling framework predicted significant QALY
differences between control and treatment over 5-years. Conclusions: This new
modeling framework shows promise and presents a broader opportunity to capture
the impacts of treatment over time using a range of symptom domains.
PRM115
Use Of External Data To Guide Long-Term Survival Extrapolations
Of Trial Data For Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia
Hawe E 1, Pearson I 1, Wolowacz S 1, Haiderali A 2
1RTI Health Solutions, Manchester, UK, 2GlaxoSmithKline, Collegeville, PA, USA
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The National Institute for Health and Care Excellence recommends
utilising external data to evaluate the validity of extrapolation beyond trial followup. The objective was to demonstrate the use of external data to guide long-term
survival predictions where only short-term trial data are available. Methods:
Four-year patient-level data for chlorambucil and ofatumumab+chlorambucil from
the COMPLEMENT-1 trial were available; the survival rate was over 70% at four
years. Published 18-year Kaplan-Meier data for chlorambucil from the C9011 study,
which compared fludarabine and chlorambucil, were used to simulate a patientlevel dataset. These data were not used directly as outcomes have improved substantially since patients were enrolled (1990-1994) and the chlorambucil dosing
regimens differed. However the curve was used to guide the extrapolation of the
COMPLEMENT-1 data using a three-stage approach: 1) Survival functions were fitted
for the COMPLEMENT-1 and C9011 chlorambucil arms with an indicator for study.
2) The average treatment effect (chlorambucil versus ofatumumab+chlorambucil)
was estimated from survival analysis for both arms of COMPLEMENT-1 and
the C9011 chlorambucil arm, with indicators for treatment and study. 3) For
ofatumumab+chlorambucil, long-term survival was estimated by applying the
treatment effect from stage 2 to the function for chlorambucil from stage 1.
Exponential, gamma, Weibull, log-normal, log-logistic and Gompertz functions were
fitted. Results: Weibull, Gompertz, and gamma functions provided reasonable fits
during trial follow-up and plausible extrapolations (assessed by Akaike information
criterion, Bayesian information criterion, graphical diagnostics, and expert clinical
opinion). Survival predictions were markedly lower than conventional functions
fitted to COMPLEMENT-1 data only (e.g. Weibull predictions for chlorambucil at 20
years were 8% vs 26%, respectively). Conclusions: Using long-term external data
to guide the extrapolation provided plausible predictions for chlorambucil upon
which alternative scenarios for the continuation of treatment effect observed in
COMPLEMENT-1 could be explored.
PRM116
Modelling Evolving Cancer Risk During Epidemiological Transition
Using Economic Data
Hughes M , Seesaghur A , De Silva D
Decision Resources, Burlington, MA, USA
.
.
.
Objectives: Epidemiological projections sizing patient populations are fundamental to budget impact analyses and market forecasting. When disease risk evolves
over time, as in the case of epidemiological transition, using historical estimates in
epidemiological projection becomes unjustified. Incorporation of additional variables that model evolving risk may allow for more reliable forecasts. The hypothesis
that gross domestic product per capita (GDP) is correlated with disease risk was
tested for a variety of cancers using global epidemiological and economic datasets. Methods: Age-standardized incidence for 18 cancer sites across 188 countries
was retrieved from the International Agency for Research against Cancer for the
years 1993-1997. Corresponding country-specific GDP data was collected from the
World Bank. For each site, correlation between GDP and incidence was measured
using R2and linear co-efficient values. Results: Risk is strongly correlated with
GDP for all of the sites studied, with the exception of the stomach (R 2= 0; p> 0.05).
Correlation was strongest for those sites associated with diet/lifestyle factors
prevalent in higher-income countries, namely: colorectal (R2= 0.61; p< 0.001), breast
(R2= 0.61; p< 0.001) and lung (R2= 0.42; p< 0.001). Strong association was also seen for
prostate (R2=0.47; p<0.001), although this may be explained by better case-detection
in higher-income countries. Conversely, those cancer sites associated with infection showed a negative correlation, namely: cervix (R2= 0.33; p< 0.01), liver (R2= 0.09;
p< 0.001) and oesophagus (R2= 0.06; p< 0.01). Conclusions: GDP is strongly associated with cancer risk and varies by organ site in a manner concordant with the
evolving exposures to known pathogens that characterize epidemiological transition. On the assumption that such correlation is a marker for various causal relationships, and that robust economic methods underlie GDP forecasts, it is reasonable to
conclude that these correlations could be used to make epidemiological projections
more accurate than projections assuming constant disease risk.
A564
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PRM117
Cost-Effectiveness Modeling Of Antimicrobial Dressings For
Preventing Catheter-Related Bloodstream Infection: Homogeneous
VERSUS Non-Homogeneous Markov Approaches
Maunoury F 1, Motrunich A 1, Palka-Santini M 2
1Statésia, Le Mans, France, 23M Germany, Neuss, Germany
.
.
.
Objectives: To compare homogeneous (HMM) versus non-homogeneous Markov
models (NHMM) for cost-effectiveness analysis (CEA) of routine use of transparent
dressings containing a chlorhexidine gluconate gel pad versus standard transparent dressings. The antimicrobial dressing protects central vascular accesses
reducing the risk of catheter-related bloodstream infections (CRBSIs) in intensive
care units (ICU). The impact of the modeling approach on the decision of adopting antimicrobial dressings for critically-ill patients is discussed. Methods:
Comparative clinical efficacy data from a multicentre randomized controlled trial
(RCT) enrolling 1,879 patients and economical data from micro and macro-costing
published studies were combined. The HMM and NHMM models were built separately using the same sources. The statistical unit was the ICU patient and the ICU
perspective was chosen. Probabilistic sensitivity analyses (PSA) were conducted
for both models for comparing the robustness of the CEA results. Results: The
difference in clinical outcomes between each dressing strategies was statistically significant with both models while cost differences were not. The PSA with
the NHMM resulted in 11.8 infections avoided per 1,000 patients (95%CI: [3.85;
19.64]) and a mean extra cost of € 141 per patient (95%CI: [€ -975; € 1,258]) when
using antimicrobial dressing. The PSA with the HMM resulted in 6.45 infections
avoided per 1,000 patients (95%CI: [0.15; 12.75]) and the mean extra cost of € 252
per patient (95%CI: [€ -924; € 1,428]). Conclusions: The antimicrobial dressings
are consistently more efficacious in preventing CRBSIs whatever the model used.
The HMM is less sensitive to simulate the real life of the ICU patients. Regardless
the model approach chosen the antimicrobial strategy is more efficacious than
the comparator, but its probability of being cost-effective is comparatively reduced
with the HMM. Time dependent approach (NHMM) seems to be better adapted to
model rare events as CRBSIs.
PRM118
Development Of A Model To Predict Disease Progression In
Autosomal Dominant Polycystic Kidney Disease (ADPKD)
McEwan P 1, Bennett Wilton H 2, Robinson P 3, Hadimeri H 4, Ong A 5, Ørskov B 6, Peces R 7,
Sandford R 8, Scolari F 9, Walz G 10, Woon C 11, O’Reilly K 3
1Swansea Centre for Health Economics, Swansea, UK, 2Health Economics and Outcomes
Research Ltd, Cardiff, UK, 3Otsuka Pharmaceutical Europe Ltd, Wexham, UK, 4Department
of Nephrology, Kärnsjukhuset, Skövde, Sweden, 5Academic Nephrology Unit, Department of
Infection and Immunity, The University of Sheffield Medical School, UK, 6Department of Medicine,
Renal Division, Copenhagen University Hospital, Roskilde, Denmark, 7Hospital Universitario
La Paz, Madrid, Spain, 8Academic Laboratory of Medical Genetics, Addenbrooke’s Treatment
Centre, Cambridge, UK, 9Department of Nephrology, University of Brescia, Italy, 10Department of
Nephrology, University Medical Centre Freiburg, Zentrale Klinische Forschung, Freiburg, Germany,
11McCann Complete Medical, Macclesfield, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease (ADPKD) is a major
cause of end-stage renal disease (ESRD) affecting approximately 4 per 10,000 people
in Europe. There is a paucity of research regarding the natural history of ADPKD
progression. This study aimed to utilise the results of a systematic literature review
characterising predictors of ADPKD progression to construct a natural history disease model for ADPKD. Methods: An individual patient-level lifetime simulation
was developed in Microsoft Excel, driven by baseline and time-dependent age, estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) and total kidney volume (TKV). Rates of
progression were informed by a large naturalistic study. Dialysis modality, transplant
status and disease-specific mortality were also modelled. Relevant ADPKD complications were stratified by chronic kidney disease stages. Modification of disease
progression rate was investigated in order to assess the potential of the model
for evaluating treatment interventions. Results: On visual inspection, modelled
and published eGFR trajectories for the general ADPKD patient were consistent
(median age at ESRD of approximately 55 years). When patients are stratified by
baseline TKV the model predicts variable rates of progression to ESRD, aligning with
the assertion that the baseline TKV is the most important prognostic indicator for
ADPKD progression. Modification of the risk equations to incorporate the impact of
an intervention has shown promise to estimate important outcomes such as delay
to ESRD. Conclusions: The model has demonstrated both face and predictive
validity and is capable of predicting outcomes consistent with those reported in the
ADPKD literature. It represents the first model capable of informing on important
clinical outcomes relevant to both clinicians and patients, such as time to ESRD,
with the potential to evaluate the long-term impact of treatment interventions on
ADPKD progression.
PRM119
Forecasting Cancer Incidence Using Gross Domestic Product
Ayodele O A 1, Isherwood A 2, Hughes M 2
1Decision Resources Group, Burlington, MA, USA, 2Decision Resources Group, London, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To validate the use of change in Gross Domestic Product per capita
(GDP) as a proxy for forecasting change in cancer risk. Methods: Using data from
the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) and GDP data from the
World Bank, the correlation between the incidence of five cancers (breast, prostate,
lung, liver, and colorectal) in 147 countries for 1993-1997 (midyear 1995), and the
corresponding GDP was calculated. We used this correlation to retrospectively
forecast the 2005 incidence for five cancers in four cities (Cali, Colombia; Delhi,
India; Shanghai, China; St. Petersburg, Russia). The GDP-based forecasts were compared to a control assuming no change in incidence from the IARC incidence data
for 1998-2002 (midyear 2000). The two forecast estimates with the actual reported
IARC 2003-2007 incidence data were compared. Results: Overall, the GDP-based
method correctly forecasts the directional change in incidence in 75% (95% confi-
dence interval 67-83%) of instances compared with the control method (25%, 95%CI
17-33%), and among 83% (95%CI 76-91%) of positively-GDP-associated cancers
compared with 17% (95%CI 9-24%) for the control method. There was no significant
difference between the two methods for negatively-GDP-associated cancers. In
terms of the relative magnitude of change compared to the actual incidences, there
was no significant difference between the GDP-based forecast incidences and the
control (mean magnitude difference 3.8%, 95% CI -3.5% - 11.0%). Conclusions:
During epidemiological transition, cancer incidence is unlikely to remain static
and so developing a proxy variable to evaluate risk over time is important. Using
GDP as a proxy variable is preferable to the alternative of projecting historical
values forward unchanged in terms of directional effect. However our study found
no significant difference in terms of relative magnitude of the change over time.
This latter result may be due to a small sample size of registries, indicating a need
for further research.
PRM120
Estimating Crossover Bias In A Randomized Clinical Trial Of
Ovarian Cancer Treatment
Kuehne F 1, Rochau U 2, Paracha N 3, Sabate E 3, Siebert U 4
of Public Health and Health Technology Assessment, UMIT - University for
Health Sciences, Hall, Austria, 2UMIT - University for Health Sciences, Medical Informatics and
Technology/ ONCOTYROL - Center for Personalized Cancer Medicine, Hall in Tyrol/ Innsbruck,
Austria, 3F. Hoffman-La Roche, Basel, Switzerland, 4Medical Informatics and Technology, and
Director of the Division for Health Technology Assessment and Bioinformatics, ONCOTYROL, Hall
i. T, Austria
.
.
.
.
.
1Department
Objectives: Bevacizumab (BEV) has proven to be efficacious to delay ovarian cancer progression and in controlling ascites. Significant overall survival (OS) benefits
were reported in GOG218 patients with ascites at baseline, however, not in the ITT
population. This raises questions about the potential role of “progression-driven
cross-over” in confounding OS trial results. The objective of this study was to use
decision-analytic modeling to estimate the potential impact of this “cross-over bias”
in a RCT. Methods: A decision-analytic Markov model with 6 mutually exclusive health states was built simulating OS as reported in GOG218. In the base case
analysis, a 49 month time horizon was used (trial length). Input parameters were
based on trial data and published literature. The model was calibrated to estimate
the amount of patients developing ascites and switching. The model was then used
estimating the unbiased treatment effect as it would have been observed without
switching. Results: The model provided similar survival curves as reported. When
switching treatment was disabled, the relative risk reduction for OS due to BEV
compared to placebo changed from 11% to 32% over the 49 month time horizon. The
results were sensitive to changes in the input parameter of switching, developing
severe ascites and mortality after progression. Conclusions: Decision-analytic
methods are suitable for describing causal relations and the impact of a potential
bias. We estimated that about two thirds of the true treatment effect could not be
captured in the biased data analysis. However, a formal adjustment of the original
RCT data was not feasible due to lack of clinical trial data describing switching
patterns. As crossover bias cannot always be avoided by trial design due to ethical
reasons, we recommend collecting sufficient confounding variables determining
cross-over so that specific statistical methods for causal-inference can be applied
to control the cross-over bias.
PRM121
The Impact Of The New Drug Co-Payment Scheme On Economic
Evaluations In Spain
Martin Saborido C , Zuluaga Sanchez S
RTI-HS, Manchester, UK
.
.
Objectives: To examine the new co-payment scheme for prescribed medications
introduced in Spain in 2012 and to explore differences in patient and National
Health Service (NHS) drug cost co-payments between the old and the new schemes,
using an example in a modelled patient population with coronary heart disease
(CHD). Methods: The new legislation was researched and the new co-payment
scheme was summarised in a flowchart. A published economic evaluation of drugeluting versus bare metal stents for high-risk patients with CHD was used to calculate co-payments for the total cost of a prescribed drug (clopidogrel) from patients
and from the NHS. The patient contribution was estimated from the income and
expected work status of the model’s population. Results: In the new co-payment
scheme, pharmacy-dispensed drugs are divided into three categories, using the
Anatomical, Therapeutic, and Chemical classification system: 1) reimbursed with
reduced contribution (4.26 € per prescription in 2014), 2) reimbursed without reduced
contribution (ranging from 40% to 60%, depending on declared incomes for active
workers, and from 10% to 60% for retired people) and 3) not reimbursed. Monthly
limits for retired people (in 2014) range from 8.26 € to 62 € , with a monthly limit
of 0.426 € for long-term, chronic conditions. The current, monthly, over-the-counter price of clopidogrel is 22.92 € . Under the old co-payment scheme, the model
estimated that the average NHS payment was 19.62 € per patient (86% of the cost).
Under the new scheme, this amount was estimated at 16.55 € (72%). The NHS contribution decreased by 14%. Conclusions: The new scheme results in a significant reduction to drug-related NHS co-payment contributions. This reduction could
lead to significant changes in incremental cost-effectiveness ratio estimates. It is
recommended that this adjustment be made in economic evaluations developed
or adapted for Spain.
PRM123
Stratified Cost-Effectiveness Analysis To Guide Genetic Screening
For Cancer Risk
Folse H J , Dinh T
Evidera, San Francisco, CA, USA
.
.
.
Objectives: Genetic screening identifies candidates for intensified cancer
screening and prevention. Due to the high cost of genetic testing, it is impor-
A565
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
tant to identify patients who are most likely to benefit. Doing so using clinical trials is prohibitively expensive; thus a mathematical modeling approach is
required. Methods: We developed a framework for stratified cost-effectiveness
analysis using individual-based discrete-event simulations, consisting of a natural history component that captures mutation distribution, correlations between
mutation and other risk factors (e.g. family history), and cancer incidence, progression and mortality, and a health care process component that captures interactions between the patients and the health care system, through genetic testing,
screening, diagnosis and treatment, and their costs. The genetic screening strategy consists of 3 steps: a benefit- risk assessment step, in which patients are
assessed for risk of carrying mutations and potential benefits from genetic testing,
a genetic testing step, in which qualified patients within an optimal risk bracket
are given the appropriate tests and an intervention step, in which patients are
given care based on the results from the genetic tests. Results: We use the following approach to explore and identify optimal strategies for 3 genetic screening
applications: Dinh et al. demonstrated that primary screening for Lynch syndrome
in patients at least 25 years old and with a risk of at least 5% was cost effective.
Folse et al. showed that single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) screening for breast
cancer risk for recommending patients to MRI screening was most cost-effective
in women age 40 with a lifetime risk of 16 to 28%. Green et al showed that the
same genetic test for recommending patients to chemoprevention was most costeffective for women age 50-59 with a 5-year risk of 1.2-1.66%. Conclusions: As
more genetic tests becomes available, this method can be used to identify screening strategies that maximize cost-effectiveness.
PRM124
Discrete Event Simulation For The Cost-Effectiveness Evaluation
Of Pet-Ct Scans In The Diagnosis Of Conn’s Disease In Hypertensive
Patients
Maruszczak M 1, Stewart G 1, Kusel J 1, Brown M J 2
1Costello Medical Consulting Ltd., Cambridge, UK, 2University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To develop a flexible and computationally efficient discrete event
simulation (DES) model which could be employed in a cost-effectiveness analysis
comparing the use of PET-CT scans versus current diagnostic procedures for Conn’s
disease in hypertensive patients. Methods: Visual Basic was used for the model
simulation with Microsoft Excel constituting the front-end software. In order to
ensure a high level of flexibility, individual patients could be assigned a number
of personal traits and the clinical, cost and utility inputs were easily adjustable.
Individual diagnostic procedures were programmed in separate modules with the
aim of simplifying potential modifications to the diagnostic pathway. Results:
A DES was constructed to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of new treatments based
on the experience of patients assigned to intervention and comparator arms.
Patients were considered individually in each arm, using the same background
mortality. Time, gender and event dependent risk equations enabled efficient modelling of endogenous heterogeneity of the population. Continuous time accounting
allowed for the modelling of competing adverse events and provided a realistic
representation of patients’ experience. Preliminary results indicate that the
use of PET-CT scans for the screening of Conn’s syndrome could be cost-effective. Conclusions: The newly developed model is the first formal attempt to
evaluate the cost-effectiveness of this alternative screening technique for hypertensive patients who are suspected of suffering from Conn’s disease. The model will
be further developed to include probabilistic sensitivity analysis and bootstrapping
in order to evaluate the robustness of the potential results. Evolutionary algorithms
will be incorporated to define the most optimal solution from the continuous spectrum of potential screening strategies. As the model will utilise actual patient level
data, it could be used by the decision maker to determine the most cost-effective
diagnostic strategy.
PRM125
Modelling Long-Term Changes In Opioid Induced Constipation (OIC)
Altincatal A 1, Lawson R 2, King F 3, Marsh K 4
.
.
.
.
1Evidera, Lexington, MA, USA, 2AstraZeneca, R&D
| Global Medicines Development|Payer and Real
Pricing and Reimbursement, Gaithersburg,
3AstraZeneca, Global
World Evidence, Cheshire, UK,
MD, USA, 4Evidera, London, UK
Objectives: Patients’ experience of OIC may be unstable, with periods of constipation and non-constipation, an observation supported by physician reports.
There is, however, a lack of quantitative evidence of this experience. Such evidence
would be valuable to inform development of economic models for OIC treatments.
The objective of this abstract is to fill this gap utilizing data from two pivotal
Naloxegol studies, KODIAC 4 and 5, which demonstrated significant improvements
in SBM frequency response compared to placebo over 12 weeks. Methods: 892
non-cancer pain patients with OIC were randomized to Naloxegol 25 mg or placebo in two pivotal studies. A 4-week rolling determination of OIC and non-OIC
status at weeks 4 through 12 was used in time-to-event analyses. Patients were
considered OIC if they reported < 3 SBMs for > = 2 out of the 4 weeks and non-OIC
if reported > = 3 SBMs for > = 3 out of 4 weeks. Those with non-OIC status at week
4 were selected as the baseline and first observed OIC status was considered an
event. Parametric analyses with Exponential, Weibull, Gompertz, Log-normal, Loglogistic, and Generalized Gamma distributions were conducted. Results: Based
on the parametric time-to-event analysis results, the Log-normal distribution was
selected as the best fit and provided plausible long term projections. Naloxegol had
a noticeable separation for extending the time to first OIC event when compared
to placebo over the projected long-term follow-up. Conclusions: This research
demonstrates that the natural fluctuation between OIC and non-OIC is substantial
and requires integration into an economic model. Even in the absence of treatment, a substantial proportion of patients become non-OIC, and a significant
proportion of these remain in non-OIC subsequently. Nevertheless, a treatment
effect for Naloxegol was observed over and above this ‘background’ placebo variation in the experience of OIC.
PRM126
Companion Diagnostics-Targeted Therapies Pairings Model-Based
Economic Evaluation: Reflection On A General Modeling Framework
And Key Methodological Points
Marty R 1, Roze S 1, Tisseau A 2, Borget I 3, Chouaid C 4
1HEVA HEOR, Lyon, France, 2Merck Serono, on belhalf of the LEEM Biomarker Working group,
Lyon, Paris, France, 3Institut Gustave Roussy, Villejuif, France, 4Santé publique au cabinet, Creteil,
France
.
.
.
.
.
BACKGROUND: Companion diagnostics (CD) testing aims to stratify the patient
population. It conditions the choice of best available therapeutic options, limiting
targeted therapy (TT) to subgroups most likely to benefit and triggers potential cost
savings. Objectives: To provide a general framework and a list of key methodological points to be addressed while conducting a model-based economic evaluation
of CD-TT pairings, especially in oncology. Methods: Based on a health economic
literature review and a clinical expert panel with examples drawn from cases of CD
testing selection biomarker predictive of the response level towards an anti-cancer
TT. Results: As CD and TT have embedded values, it is important to assess them
concomittantly within a shared modeling framework. We propose a decision tree to
model the patient population stratification and to incorporate impacts of analytical
and clinical validity. The former refers here to the inability of the CD to accurately
and reliably inform the biomarker resulting in true (false) positive/negative cases,
whereas the latter relates to the penetrance, i.e. the strength of association between
the biomarker and clinical phenotypes (treatment effect). Such parameters are crucial
especially in cases multiple distinct lab-tests (commercial vs. home-brew, technics,
amount of informations provided regarding the biomarker). Each patient sub-group
outcomes are required to be modeled (costs and health effects). A Markov state-transition model either based on treatment pathway and/or disease staging represents
both adequate approaches to simulate the clinical outcomes, incorporating specific
efficacy parameters per sub group depending on their biomarker expression levels.
In instances, time spent until the CD result delivery exceeds a clinical significant
threshold, testing delay shall be modelled such as all parameters driving loss of opporunity. Conclusions: Beyond reasonable simple binary-type of selection biomarker,
more complex types of biomarkers and CD technologies (full sequences) has risen
additional complexity and poses new methodological challenges.
PRM127
Patient Preferences And Hiv Drugs: What About Uncertainty?
Broekhuizen H 1, IJzerman M J 2, Hauber A B 3, Groothuis-Oudshoorn C G M 1
1University of Twente, Enschede, The Netherlands, 2University of Twente and MIRA institute for
Biomedical Technology & Technical Medicine, Enschede, The Netherlands, 3RTI Health Solutions,
Research Triangle Park, NC, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Quantitative patient preferences are increasingly considered for health
care policy decisions. The objective of this study is to develop a methodology to
combine patient preferences with clinical evidence in a multi-criteria framework
that takes into account uncertainty in both preferences and clinical evidence. The
methodology will be illustrated with a case on antiretroviral treatments. Methods:
Treatments under consideration are eight highly active antiretroviral therapies
(HAART) recommended for treatment-naïve patients by the National Institute of
Health. The treatments are compared on the probabilities of virologic failure, hypersensitivity reaction, bone damage, and kidney damage; and on the treatability of
bone/kidney damage. Preferences from 147 patients were elicited with a discrete
choice method in an earlier study. Preferences were assumed to be distributed with
a multivariate normal distribution. Treatment performances as identified from clinical trials were assumed to be distributed with beta distributions. The probability
distributions around preferences and clinical performances were combined with a
Monte Carlo simulation method to estimate the joint probability distribution around
each treatment’s patient-weighted utility. Results: The three treatments with the
highest mean patient-weighted utility were dolutegravir+abacavir/lamivudine (-0.4,
95% CI: -1.3 to 0.5), raltegravir+tenofovir/emtricitabine (-0.5, 95% CI: -1.6 to 0.7) and
darunavir/ritonavir+tenofovir/emtricitabine (-0.6, 95% CI: -2.0 to 0.8). There was considerable overlap between the probability distributions of patient-weighed utilities
(probability of first rank reversal: 49%; probability of any rank reversal: > 99%). When
ignoring uncertainty around patient preferences, the probability of a first rank reversal dropped to 12%, and that of any rank reversal dropped to 88%. Conclusions:
A probabilistic multi-criteria methodology was developed that explicitly combines
patient preferences and clinical evidence. The individual or joint impact of uncertainty in these on the treatments’ patient-weighted utilities is assessed. Although
limited by the small number of attributes, the illustrative case suggests the choice
of HAART is highly sensitive to patient preferences.
PRM128
MODELLING HEALTH-RELATED QUALITY OF LIFE (HRQOL) LONGITUDINALLY.
A BAYESIAN MIXED BETA REGRESSION APPROACH
Gheorghe M , Brouwer W , van Baal P
Erasmus University, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
.
.
.
Objectives: Cross-sectional studies showed that, for modelling health-related
quality of life (HRQoL), beta regression is superior in terms of fit and predictive accuracy to other commonly used methods based on normality distribution assumption.
Although, longitudinal HRQoL measurements are widely used in clinical trials, not
much is known about beta regression suitability in this context. This is mainly due
to software unavailability with classical estimation methods. This study proposes
to model the longitudinal HRQoL outcome using a mixed beta regression estimated
by Bayesian Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) methods implemented in WinBUGS.
Compared to the classical approach, not only the Bayesian estimation is considerably easier to implement but has other advantages; for example, the possibility of
including informative priors, enabling analysts to incorporate multiple sources of
evidence in a single model. Methods: We used a 16-year longitudinal follow-up
for modelling the relationship between SF-6D HRQoL and variables age, gender and
mortality risk by means of a mixed beta regression. Besides modelling the mean
A566
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
parameter, we also modeled the precision parameter using a regression structure.
Regression coefficients and predictive accuracy from this model estimated using
the Bayesian approach with vague priors were compared to those from a linear
mixed effects model estimated classically. Results: Our results indicated that beta
distribution fitted the SF-6D outcome better than normal distribution. Furthermore,
compared to the linear mixed effects model, the mixed beta regression model was
superior in terms of predictive model accuracy. We found that mortality risk had a
significant effect on both mean and precision parameters: we observed lower mean
HRQoL for higher mortality risk and higher variation of health utilities for higher
mortality risk. Conclusions: Mixed beta regression offers a superior approach
for modelling the HRQoL outcome longitudinally. Furthermore, such a model can
be easily implemented using freely available Bayesian software.
PRM129
Effect Of Sample Size And Data Maturity On Parametric Survival
Modeling Projections In Advanced Cancer
Graham C N , Davis K L , Goyal R K
RTI Health Solutions, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Parametric survival modeling (PSM) is often used in cost-effectiveness
analyses of oncology treatments to aid in lifetime projections due to right censoring of data. We sought to better understand the effect of sample sizes and data
maturity (follow-up time) on PSM projections to aid in the design of clinical trials and the interpretation of cost-effectiveness models. Methods: We modeled
overall survival (OS) for advanced colorectal cancer patients treated with first-line
chemotherapy and/or a biologic using SEER-Medicare data (2004-2010). Survival
was estimated using Kaplan-Meier (KM) and PSM methods. From the full cohort, we
randomly drew patients to match typical sample sizes from Phase II and III clinical
trials (n= 50, 100, 200, and 400). Additionally, arbitrary data cutoffs were created
to proxy clinical trial follow-up times (t= 3, 6, 9, 12, 24, and 36 months). Using PSM
methods mean survival from the full cohort was compared with survival from the
combinations of sample sizes and follow-up times. Results: Using the KM method,
6% of patients were alive at the end of the follow-up period (6.5 years). Mean OS
from the full cohort was estimated to be 21.9 months using the PSM method (best
fit Weibull curve). OS estimates for the sample size and follow-up time combinations ranged from 5.9-28.0 months. Minimum and maximum survival projections
represented a 73% underestimation and 28% overestimation of survival compared
with the full cohort projection, respectively. Projection accuracy was improved when
t≥ 6 months and n≥ 200. Conclusions: Both sample size and data maturity have
a profound effect on survival projections. Care should be taken when interpreting
projections in cost-effectiveness models, especially when sample size is low and
follow-up time short. In addition to power calculations, clinical trial design should
account for these issues. Additional analyses in other cancer types may provide
further guidance for optimum trial design.
PRM130
Understanding Real Life Treatment Patterns Among Patients With
Hypertension: A Markov Model
Letierce A 1, Jouaville S L 1, Boutmy E 2
strategic Data, Boulogne-Billancourt, France, 2Cegedim Strategic Data, BoulogneBillancourt, France
.
.
.
.
1Cegedim
Objectives: Approximately 65% of patients diagnosed with hypertension are
not well controlled and two third of patients need to be treated by two or more
drugs for achieving target blood pressure. The aim of this study was to describe
antihypertensive treatment patterns in real life settings by using Markov chain
model. Methods: Data concerning prescriptions of patients with diagnosed hypertension were obtained from a large primary care survey conducted in 2012 using
CSD Longitudinal Patient Database. Patients selected were treated with sartans,
prescribed alone or in combination with amlodipine and/or hydrochlorothiazide
(HCT), either in free associations or in fixed combinations. A Markov chain model
M1 with 4-states (A: single sartan, B: sartan+ amlodipine, C: sartan + HCT, D: sartan + amlodipine + HCT) was proposed to model transitions from one treatment
to another over time. A second chain, M2, with 6 states was also studied, in which
dual-therapies were divided into two states depending on whether the combination
was free or fixed. Age and sex were included as covariates. R packages and MSM
DIAGRAM were used. Results: 11,976 patients were selected, 49% were men, aged
69 years on average (SD = 11), suffering from hypertension for 7 years on average,
35% had diabetes, 5% renal failure and 31% a previous cardiovascular event. At the
time of selection, the distribution between the states was as follows: A: N = 5187
(43.3%), B: N = 1060 (8.9%), C: N = 5120 (42.8%), D: N = 609 (5%). At the end of one
year, > 93% of patients had remained in the same state of M1. The M2 model showed
substantial transitions from free to fixed associations. Age and sex did not change
the coefficients. Conclusions: The Markov chains used to visually describe the
evolution of treatment regimens are useful for analyzing large longitudinal databases of prescriptions.
PRM131
The Proportional Odds Model Is More Efficient Than The
Multinomial Logistic Model For Network Meta-Analyses Of Ordered
Outcomes
Bouwmeester W 1, van Beurden-Tan C 1, Bennison C 2, Heeg B 1
1Pharmerit International, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 2Pharmerit Ltd, York, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Network meta-analysis (NMA) techniques have been developed to
study relative treatment effects for several outcome types (e.g. time-to-event outcomes). No literature exists comparing models of NMA for ordered categorical data,
though models are available with different characteristics. This study compared
the proportional odds (PO) and multinomial logistic (ML) model for NMA in ordered
categorical datasets based on model fit and qualitative characteristics. Methods:
To contrast model performance, two extreme datasets were simulated, one which
exactly satisfied the PO assumption (POA dataset), and one which did not (nPOA
dataset). The models were also tested in a clinical dataset including ordered
response categories for four different treatments in psoriasis patients. Both fixed
and random effects models were studied. Results: In the POA dataset, the PO
fixed effects model had the lowest residual deviance (54.8 versus 58.9 for the ML
model) and uncertainty of treatment effects (49% lower standard error (SE)). In the
nPOA dataset, the predictions of the PO model were biased, and the ML model had
the lowest residual deviance (52.7 versus 271.0 for the PO model). Visual inspection
indicated a partial violation of the PO assumption in the psoriasis data. Analyses of
the psoriasis data, showed that the PO fixed effects model had the lowest residual
deviance (18.1 versus 20.9) and uncertainty (62% lower SE). However, PO model
predictions were biased for treatment responses which violated the PO assumption. Conclusions: Statistical selection of NMA models for ordered outcomes
should be based on the PO assumption and deviance measures. If data satisfies the
PO assumption, the PO model differentiated treatment effects better as a result of
lower uncertainty. In terms of flexibility, the PO model can handle data from studies
that use different cut-offs for response categories and the ML model can be applied
to datasets violating the PO assumption.
PRM132
Evaluating The Effect Of Immunotherapy In Advanced Non-SmallCell Lung Cancer Patients Using Two Components Mixture Model
Sánchez L 1, Muchene L 2, Luaces P 1, Viada C 1, Rodríguez P C 1, Frias A 1, Shkedy Z 2, Lage A 1
of Molecular Immunology, Havana, Cuba, 2Hasselt University, Diepenbeek, Belgium
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Center
Objectives: The aim of the study was to assess the effect of an immunotherapy
for the treatment of advanced non–small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC). Methods:
Data from a phase III, multicenter, randomized, open-label trial evaluating the
efficacy of one EGF-based cancer vaccine (CIMAvaxEGF) as switch maintenance in
patients with advanced NSCLC, were used. Survival analysis using Kaplan Meier
estimates was performed. Weighted log-rank was conducted to assess the later
effect of the immunotherapy. Additionally, a finite mixture model to the primary
endpoint (Overall Survival, OS) was fitted. Weibull distribution was assumed for
the overall survival and a mixture model consists of one, two or three components
was fitted.. All analysis was conducted using the NLMIXED procedure in SAS.
The Akaike Information Criterion (AIC) was used for model selection. Results:
Intention-to-treat (ITT) analysis showed 1.44 months of OS benefit for vaccinated
patients with confirmed delayed-separation phenomena (OS: Vaccine arm, 10.37
months vs. Control arm, 8.93 months; p= 0.043). The mixture model with the best
goodness to fit to the data consists of two components (AIC= 3097.7). The two
mixture components represent short-term and long-term survival subpopulations. The proportions of the subpopulations are estimated to be equal to 0.89
and 0.11 respectively. The median OS was estimated to be equal to 9.59 and 60.32
for short- and long- term survival populations, respectively. 23.26% and 76.74%
from the patients who were classified into long-term survival subpopulation were
from the control and vaccinated group, respectively. From them, 7 (70%) patients
in the control group and 25 (75%) patients in the treated group were still alive at
the end of the study. Conclusions: The results confirm that the vaccination
with CIMAvaxEGF prolongs the survival of the advanced NSCLC patients. Mixture
models allow assessing the efficacy/effectiveness of vaccines and biological products in the presence of heterogeneous populations.
PRM133
Predictive Modelling: Predicting Hospitalisation And Estimating
The Cost And Risk To The Third Party Funder
Celliers R E
Agility Global Health Solutions/University of Pretoria, Centurion, South Africa
PREDICTIVE MODELLING: PREDICTING HOSPITALISATION AND ESTIMATING THE COST
AND RISK TO THE THIRD PARTY FUNDER R CELLIERS (MsC. (Mathematical Statistics)
University of Pretoria)
.
.
Objectives: In the third party funder environment most analyses focus on retrospective claims analyses; the aim of predictive modelling is to estimate future
claims or current risk, based on the probability of a hospital event using historical
data. Methods: A logistic regression approach is followed where the likelihood of
a hospitalisation event is established and mapped to a cost estimate. The modelling
process involved establishing a development and validation sample, identifying the
predictor variables, building and lastly validating the sample. During the model
building process the development and validation population consisted of 149 416
and 47623 beneficiaries respectively; where the data was obtained from a third
party funder consisting of 3 years of data. During the building process the dependant variable (Y= Logg (odds)) takes on the value 1 or 0 depending on whether or not a
hospital event occurred. To calculate the cost per beneficiary a weighted probability
was multiplied by the average cost of a hospital authorisation. Beneficiaries were
classified as high risk if log (odds) > = 0.7. Results: The final model is: Log (odds)
= -0.11X1+0.00576X2+0.409X3+0.179X4+0.614X5 where X1-X5 denotes the predictor
variables. X1 denotes an indicator variable for gender, X2 the predictor variable for
age, X3 the HIV indicator variable, X4 the diabetes indicator variable and X5 the
chronic indicator variable. The strongest predictors were the chronic indicator variable and age. The validation process resulted in 79% of the beneficiaries being correctly classified and the cost estimation resulted in totals within 3-5% of the actual
values. Conclusions: The proposed model predicts hospitalisation efficiently at
a beneficiary level and can be implemented to monitor risk and the associated cost
(hospital or total) for individuals, employer group or the third party funder. Third
party risk management and cost estimation are other applications of the model.
PRM134
Joint Modelling Of The Change In Tumor Size And Overall Survival; A
Parametric Model Considering Patient Heterogeneity Not Observed
At Baseline
Majer I M , Heeg B
Pharmerit International, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
.
.
.
A567
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: In economic evaluations in oncology, survival data is typically extrapolated without taking into account prognostic factors. If individual level trial data
are available, patient and disease characteristics observed at baseline are considered. However, survival models typically disregard information that are not known
at baseline, e.g. response to treatment, but that may be valuable for the prognosis
of patients and hence for decision making. In this study we present a parametric
survival model that included response to treatment over time. Methods: Data
from 99 patients with late-stage soft tissue sarcoma from a clinical trial was used.
Survival information and the percentage change in the sum of the longest diameters of target lesions (i.e. the basis for response evaluation) measured repeatedly
during follow-up were utilized. A joint model was estimated linking a random
effects sub-model for the change of tumor size with a Weibull sub-model for the
survival outcome. The association between change of tumor size over time and
overall survival was assessed. Several different functional forms were explored
to model the tumor size data and the best fitting model was selected. Results:
The median follow-up time in the trial was 1.6 years; 63 patients died. On average, 4.8 measurements on tumor size were available per patient. A flexible cubic
B-spline sub-model provided the repeatedly measured tumor size change data the
best model fit. The association between tumor growth and overall survival was
marginally statistically significant with a P value of less than 0.10. Conclusions:
The presented joint model demonstrated that response to treatment over time
may be important to consider when building survival models for health economic
evaluations in oncology. The model explicitly incorporated the heterogeneity of
patients not observed at baseline providing a clinically relevant survival model.
Individual survival predictions can be prepared using patient-specific history of
tumor growth.
RESEARCH ON Methods – Patient-Reported Outcomes Studies
PRM135
Assessment Of The Huntington Quality Of Life Instrument (H-QOL-I)
Cross-Cultural Validity
Clay E 1, Belhadj A 2, Squitieri F 3, Dorey J 4, Auquier P 5, Zielonka D 6, Trigo P 7, Toumi M 8
Ceutical, Les Berges du Lac, Tunisia, 3Neurogenetics and
Rare Disease Centre, IRCCS Neuromed, POZZILLI, Italy, 4Creativ-Ceutical USA, Chicago, IL, USA,
5Université de la Méditerranée, Marseille, France, 6Poznan University of Medical Sciences, Poznan,
Poland, 7Hospital Ramón y Cajal, Madrid, Spain, 8University of Marseille, Marseille, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Creativ-Ceutical, Paris, France, 2Creativ
Objectives: The Huntington Quality of Life Instrument (H-QoL-I) is the first selfreported specific instrument developed to assess the health-related QoL (HRQoL)
of patients with Huntington’s disease (HD). It includes three subscales: motor
(4 Likert-type items), psychology (4 Likert-type items) and socializing (3 Likerttype items). The aim of the study was to assess whether patients from different
countries respond differently to the H-QoL-I instrument. Methods: Data were
from the European study of HD burden (EURO-HDB) survey and included data
across 6 countries: France, Germany, Italy, Spain, Poland and the USA. The Differential
Item Functioning (DIF) method was adopted to examine whether patients from different countries with the same characteristics had different probability of giving
a certain response on H-QoL-I. An item was considered as displaying a DIF if the
p-value associated with the two-degree-of-freedom Chi-squared test comparing the
two ordinal logistic regressions (with/without country effect and an interaction term
between the total rest score and country) was lower than 0.01 and the Zumbo-Thomas
effect size was higher than 0.130. Zumbo-Thomas effect size measure and associated
p-value were calculated for each item and for all pairs of countries (i.e. 15 combinations). Results: The study included 633 patients (176 French, 124 Italian, 44 German,
60 Polish, 59 Spanish and 170 American). No DIF was detected across all combinations
of countries for all items. Sixteen pairwise Zumbo-Thomas effect size measures referring to 7 items were found significant but were lower than 0.130. Conclusions: This
study did not detect any variation across the studied countries in the assessment of
HRQoL of HD patients using the H-QoL-I instrument. These results support the crosscultural validity of the H-QoL-I.
PRM136
Assessment Of The Huntington Clinical Self-Reported Instrument
(H-CSRI) Cross-Cultural Validity
Dorey J 1, Belhadj A 2, Squitieri F 3, Clay E 4, Auquier P 5, Zielonka D 6, Trigo P 7, Toumi M 8
USA, Chicago, IL, USA, 2Creativ Ceutical, Les Berges du Lac, Tunisia,
3Neurogenetics and Rare Disease Centre, IRCCS Neuromed, POZZILLI, Italy, 4Creativ-Ceutical,
5
Paris, France, Université de la Méditerranée, Marseille, France, 6Poznan University of Medical
Sciences, Poznan, Poland, 7Hospital Ramón y Cajal, Madrid, Spain, 8University of Marseille,
Marseille, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Creativ-Ceutical
Objectives: The H-CSRI is the first clinimetric self-reported instrument for patients
with Huntington’s disease (HD). It includes three subscales: motor (13 Likert-type
items in 4 dimensions), functional (7 Yes/No questions) and behavioural (13 Likerttype items in 4 dimensions). The aim of the study was to assess whether patients
from different countries respond differently to H-CSRI. Methods: Data were from
the European study of HD burden (EURO-HDB) survey and included data across 6
countries: France, Germany, Italy, Spain, Poland and the USA. The Differential Item
Functioning (DIF) method was adopted to examine whether patients from different
countries with the same characteristics had different probability of giving a certain
response on H-CSRI. An item was considered as displaying a DIF if the p-value
associated with the two-degree-of-freedom Chi-squared test comparing the two
ordinal logistic regressions (with/without country effect and an interaction term
between the total rest score and country) was lower than 0.01 and the ZumboThomas effect size was higher than 0.130. Zumbo-Thomas effect size measure and
associated p-value were calculated for each item and for all pairs of countries (i.e.
15 combinations). Results: The study included 633 patients (176 French, 124
Italian, 44 German, 60 Polish, 59 Spanish and 170 American). Almost all the
items (24 of 26) didn’t show any cross/cultural difference. The two items show-
ing DIF were related to the dimension “precise movement” and were detected in
the Spain-Italy comparison (Δ R2 [left hand] = 0.2165, Δ R2 [right hand] = 0.1618)
and in the Spain-France comparison (Δ R2 [left hand] = 0.1571, Δ R2 [right hand]
= 0.1578). Conclusions: Globally, these data support the H-CSRI cross-cultural
validity. Further analyses should be conducted to confirm if those particular items
need to be revised in the Spanish version.
PRM137
Severity And Functional Disability Of Patients With Occupational
Contact Dermatitis: Validation Of The German Version Of The
Occupational Contact Dermatitis Disease Severity Index (ODDI)
Apfelbacher C 1, Popielnicki A 2, Bauer A 3, Diepgen T L 4, Elsner P 5, Dawsey R 6, Mahler V 7,
Molin S 8, Schmitt J 9, Weisshaar E 10, Ofenloch R F 10
- University of Regensburg, Regensburg, Germany, 2TransPerfect, Boston, MA, USA,
3University Hospital Carl Gustav Carus, Technical University Dresden, Dresden, Germany,
4University Heidelberg, Heidelberg, Germany, 5University Hospital Jena, Jena, Germany,
6TransPerfect, Atlanta, GA, USA, 7University Hospital of Erlangen, Friedrich-Alexander-University
Erlangen-Nuremberg, Erlangen, Germany, 8Ludwig-Maximilians-University Munich, München,
Germany, 9Medical Faculty Carl Gustav Carus, Technical University Dresden, Dresden, Germany,
10University Hospital Heidelberg, Heidelberg, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1UR
Objectives: The Occupational Contact Dermatitis Disease Severity Index (ODDI)
was designed in Australia to measure severity and functional disability in patients
with occupational contact dermatitis (OCD) of the hands. The psychometric properties of the German version of the ODDI are unclear. Our objective was to investigate the validity and reliability of the German ODDI version. Methods: The ODDI
was translated and linguistically validated into German for Germany, following
industry standard procedures of concept definition, dual forward translation, back
translation and reconciliation, and clinician review. Once the German version was
available, data was drawn from the baseline assessment (T0) and first follow-up
(T1) of the German chronic hand eczema (CHE) registry (carpe). Spearman correlations of the ODDI with reference measures were computed to assess validity. Cronbach’s alpha was calculated as a measure of internal consistency and the
intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) to assess retest-reliability. Smallest real difference (SRD) and minimal clinical important difference (MCID) were calculated
to assess sensitivity to change. Physician Global Assessment (PGA) was used as an
anchor for the MCID. Results: 422 patients (54.5% female, mean age: 45.1 years)
were included for analysis. Cronbach’s α was found to be 0.73. The ICC was 0.79.
Correlations of the ODDI total and the Dermatology Life Quality Index (rho= 0.36)
as well as the PGA (rho= 0.48) and patient-assessed disease severity (rho= 0.40)
were of moderate strength. The MCID (1.29) was found to be smaller than the SRD
(1.87). Conclusions: The German ODDI version is reliable and valid to measure
functional impairment and disease severity in patients suffering from OCD. The
MCID falls within the range of measurement error and should not be used.
PRM138
Mapping Fact-P To EQ-5D In Metastatic Castration-Resistant
Prostate Cancer (MCRPC): Performance Of A Previously Developed
Algorithm When Applied On A Sample With A Different Disease Stage
Ivanescu C 1, Longworth L 2, Skaltsa K 3, Holmstrom S 4
Consulting, Hoofddorp, The Netherlands, 2Brunel University, Uxbridge, UK, 3Quintiles
Consulting, Barcelona, Spain, 4HEOR, Astellas Pharma Global Development, Leiden, The
Netherlands
.
.
.
.
1Quintiles
Objectives: To evaluate the predictive performance of a previously published
mapping algorithm for converting the prostate cancer specific instrument FACT-P
(Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy–Prostate) to EQ-5D utility values (UK tariff)
on a sample with a different disease stage than the one on which the model was
generated [Skaltsa et. al. ViH 2014]. Methods: We applied a previously developed
algorithm to the data obtained from a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled
phase 3 trial in asymptomatic/mildly symptomatic chemo-naïve mCRPC patients.
The trial collected EQ-5D and FACT-P data at baseline and until treatment discontinuation. The mapping model was developed on mCRPC patients in a post-chemo
setting, included the FACT-P subscale scores and baseline variables and used separate algorithms for patients with good and poor health defined as a FACT-P score
exceeding or not 76. Model performance was assessed by mean absolute error (MAE)
and root mean squared error (RMSE). Results: The testing dataset contained 1,669
patients with baseline and ≥ 1 post-baseline scores. The average baseline EQ-5D
utility and FACT-P total score were 0.844 and 119.5 respectively. Percentage of perfect health was 37% across all visits (ceiling effect). The average (across all visits)
observed and predicted EQ-5D utility index value was 0.823 and 0.842, respectively.
The model yields accurate predictions (MAE= 0.107; RMSE= 0.150) comparable to
the ones obtained on the development sample (MAE= 0.117; RMSE= 0.162). The
model predicts well for milder health states, but overpredicts for the more severe
ones (EQ-5D utility≤ 0.5: MAE= 0.436, RMSE= 0.258; EQ-5D utility > 0.5: MAE= 0.096,
RMSE= 0.125). Conclusions: Although external validation is recommended using
similar samples, our findings show that the algorithm developed in the post-chemo
setting performed well in a pre-chemo setting in mCRPC patients, although overpredicts for severe states. This model seems suitable for predicting utility values for
economic evaluation when a preference-based measure is absent in chemo-naïve
mCRPC populations.
PRM139
How Do Individuals Complete The Choice Tasks In A Discrete Choice
Experiment?
Veldwijk J 1, Determann D 2, Lambooij M S 1, van Til J A 3, Korfage I J 4, de Bekker-Grob E 5, de
Wit G A 1
Institute for Public Health and the Environment, Bilthoven, The Netherlands, 2National
institute for public health and the environment, Bilthoven, The Netherlands, 3University of Twente,
Enschede, The Netherlands, 4University Medical Center Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands,
5Erasmus medical center, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
.
.
.
1National
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A568
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: To explore how participants evaluate and complete the choice tasks
in Discrete Choice Experiments (DCE), with special attention to the impact of educational level and health literacy. Methods: Two existing DCE questionnaires on
rotavirus vaccination and prostate cancer screening served as a case for the current
study. In total, 70 participants were sampled based on educational level (35 per case
study). During structured interviews, participants completed five choice tasks aloud.
Interviewers monitored how participants read the choice tasks, how they interpreted
the included risk attributes and what decision strategy they used to make their decision and if the monotonicity and continuity axioms hold. Results: The majority of
the participants read all the attributes within each choice task. Nearly all participants
chose the scenario with the optimal attribute levels (monotonicity axiom). In accordance with the continuity axiom, most participants mentioned three or more attributes
when motivating their decisions. Overall, higher educated and literate participants
more often included three or more attributes when motivating their decision and used
trading between attributes more often as a decision strategy. Conclusions: The
majority of the participants complete a DCE as presumed by its underlying methodology. However, the assumptions did not hold for a subset of lower educated and less
literate participants. Based on participants’ age, educational level and health literacy
additional measures should be undertaken to enhance participants’ understanding
of the attributes, the attribute levels and the choice tasks in a DCE.
PRM140
The Measurement Of Utilities In Asthma Patients: A Preliminary
Study
Yong Y V , Shafie A A
Universiti Sains Malaysia, Penang, Malaysia
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess the feasibility of a computer-based Standard Gamble (SG)
visual prop whilst measuring utilities of different asthma health states at the same
time. Methods: Twenty adult asthma patients literate in either Malay or English
language were conveniently sampled from a public hospital in Penang, Malaysia.
They were interviewed by two trained interviewers using a bilingual script. Each
patient was requested to value the given health states using Visual Analogue Scale
(VAS) prior to SG exercise. There were three chronic health states (C1-C3) for 10 years,
three temporary states (T1-T3) for 3 months, and two anchor states (healthy and
dead). During the SG exercise, the visual prop was fully operated by the interviewers.
The probability of being in a worse state was changed in a ‘ping-pong’ fashion until
the indifference point was reached. Results: All patients understood the SG exercise and rated SG easier than VAS. Around 85% (n= 17) completed SG within 30 minutes. There was 90% (n=18) who ranked T3 as the worst temporary health state during
VAS. Two patients provided logical inconsistency data in SG. The preferences by SG
were higher than VAS. Preferences were also higher in temporary states measured
by chained SG than other states by conventional SG. The mean utilities for C1= 0.56
(SD 0.38), C2= 0.47 (SD 0.33), C3= 0.53 (SD 0.38), T1= 0.65 (SD 0.31), T2= 0.53 (SD 0.35),
and T3= 0.38 (SD 0.38). Conclusions: The SG methods including the props are
feasible for utilities measurement in asthma, based on the agreements achieved
with other studies on the pattern of utilities measured in this preliminary study.
PRM141
DISCRETE-CHOICE EXPERIMENT VERSUS RATING SCALE EXERCISE TO
EVALUATE THE RELATIVE IMPORTANCE OF ATTRIBUTES: A STUDY OF THE
MAASTRICHT ISPOR STUDENT CHAPTER
Wijnen B F M 1, van der Putten I M 1, Groothuis S 1, de Kinderen R J A 1, Noben C Y G 1, Paulus
A T G 1, Ramaekers B L T 2, Vogel G C W M 2, Hiligsmann M 1
1Maastricht University, Maastricht, The Netherlands, 2Maastricht University Medical Center,
Maastricht, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Eliciting preferences has become increasingly important in health
care. Several methods are available to evaluate the relative importance of different
aspects of health and health care. In this study, we aim to examine the difference
between a discrete-choice experiment (DCE) and a rating scale exercise (RSE) to
determine the most important attributes of undergraduate students when selecting a study specialization. Methods: First-year health sciences students were
asked to complete a questionnaire that included a DCE and a RSE. Six attributes
were identified in focus groups: “possible acquainted masters”, “job opportunity”,
“scope of specialization”, “quality of education”, “hours self-study” and “personal
interest”. Fourteen unlabeled choice tasks were constructed using a statistically
efficient design and a mixed multinomial logistic regression analysis was used for
data analysis. In the RSE, attributes were rated on perceived importance using a
7-point Likert scale. Two versions of the questionnaire were distributed in which the
RSE was put before and after the DCE. Results: A total of 254 students filled out
the questionnaire. In the DCE, three attributes were statistically significant of which
“personal interest” was the most important attribute followed by “job opportunity”
and “quality of education”. In the RSE, all attributes except “hours of self-study” were
rated 4 or higher. The RSE scores of the attributes with a relatively low importance in
the DCE were significantly lower in the questionnaire version that started with DCE
than in the other version. Results of the DCE did not significantly differ between the
two questionnaire versions. Conclusions: The DCE had a differentiating effect
on the relative importance of attributes whereas in the RSE attributes were rated
more equally and were, except for one, all considered important. Forcing respondents to make first trade-offs between attributes (using a DCE) leads to lower RSE
scores for less important attributes afterwards.
PRM142
THE DEVELOPMENT AND PRELIMINARY VALIDATION OF THE MANCHESTER
SLEEP SYMPTOMS INDEX (MSSI) FOR PEOPLE WITH CHRONIC OBSTRUCTIVE
PULMONARY DISEASE (COPD)
Garrow A P 1, Yorke J 1, Khan N 2, Tyson S 1, Singh D 3, Vestbo J 4
1University of Manchester, Manchester, UK, 2The Medicines Evaluation Unit, Manchester, UK,
3University of Manchester, Medicines Evaluation Unit, Manchester, UK, 4The University of
Manchester, Manchester, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In COPD, disturbed sleep is related to exacerbation frequency, poor
quality of life and early mortality. We developed the Manchester Sleep Symptoms
Index (MSSI) to assess night-time symptoms and disturbed sleep in COPD. Methods:
Identification of potential items was guided by interviews and focus groups involving
COPD patients and age-matched controls. Hierarchical methods and Rasch analysis
informed item deletion and development of a unidimensional scale. Internal consistency and test-retest reliability were assessed. Concurrent validity was examined
using Pearson’s correlation with the St George’s Respiratory Questionnaire (SGRQ),
modified MRC Dyspnoea Scale, FACIT fatigue scale, MOS Sleep Scale, HADS Anxiety
and Depression scores. Results: Qualitative data from 36 patients with COPD and
10 age-matched controls informed an initial list of 22 items. The cross-sectional study
included 203 COPD patients (GOLD: I: 14% II: 41% III: 25% IV: 7%; male: 63%, mean
age: 64.7; SD: 7.5 years) and 50 non-COPD controls. 12 items were removed during
hierarchical methods and a further two following Rasch analysis. The final MSSI
contains 8 sleep-related items that are specific to COPD patients: breathlessness,
chest tightness, cough and sputum production. The index has good internal consistency (Cronbach’s alpha 0.87), test-retest repeatability (intra-class coefficient 0.77)
and validity. Total MSSI scores significantly correlated with the SGRQ (r= 0.64); MRC
Dyspnoea scale (r=0.46), FACIT-F (r=-0.61); MOS problems index 2: (r=0.62); MOS Sleep
adequacy (r=0.40); MOS Sleep disturbance (r=0.53) HADS anxiety (r=0.54) and depression (0.48). There was good overall fit to the Rasch model (Chi-squared: 29.2 df: 16
p=003.) and distribution of item scores. Conclusions: The MSSI is a reliable, valid,
uni-dimensional self-reported outcome measure of sleep and night-time symptoms
for people with COPD. It is simple and quick to use making it suitable for research
and practice. Further work is needed to determine the minimal clinical important
difference and cross cultural validity.
PRM143
Psychometric Evaluation Of The Patient’s Knee Implant
Performance (PKIP) Questionnaire For The Assessment Of Primary
Total Knee Arthroplasty
Coles T M 1, Dwyer K A 2, Mordin M 3, Williams V 1, Clatworthy M 4, Yates P 5, Hamilton W 6
1RTI Health Solutions, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA, 2DePuy Orthopaedics, Inc, Warsaw,
IN, USA, 3RTI Health Solutions, Ann Arbor, MI, USA, 4Ascot Hospital, Auckland, New Zealand,
5Murdoch Orthopaedic Clinic, Murdoch, New Zealand, 6Anderson Orthopaedic Research Institute,
Alexandria, VA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The objective of this study was to evaluate the psychometric properties
of a new patient-reported measure of knee implant functional performance associated with physical activities prior to and following primary total knee arthroplasty
(TKA). The Patient’s Knee Implant Performance questionnaire (PKIP) was developed
to assess factors that lead to patient dissatisfaction and describe unmet needs
in knee functional performance. Methods: The psychometric analysis sample
(n=764) was based on a multicenter, prospective, noncomparative longitudinal study
of patients with osteoarthritis undergoing TKA at 22 international sites. The PKIP
and additional patient-reported outcomes and clinical measures were collected
preoperatively, postoperatively at less than 1 year, at a minimum of 1 year, and at 2
years. The PKIP structure and its reliability, construct validity, discriminating ability, and responsiveness were assessed. Results: Based on inter-item correlations,
factor analyses, and results of previous qualitative research, the PKIP was scored as
four subscales (Stability, Confidence, Satisfaction, and Activity Modification) and
an Overall PKIP score. The Overall PKIP score met reliability standards (internal
consistency: alpha = 0.78 at minimum 1 year; test-retest: intraclass correlation coefficient = 0.77). Correlations between the PKIP and other available measures provided
evidence of construct validity. For example, the PKIP correlated 0.19 and 0.50 with
the American Knee Society Score preoperatively and at less than 1 year, respectively,
and correlated 0.69 and 0.77, with the Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score
Quality of Life subscale. The PKIP was capable of discriminating between groups
of patients with better or worse knee functioning as defined by clinician-rated
measures; hypothesis tests were in the predicted direction and mostly statistically
significant. The effect size for the Overall PKIP score was 2.38, indicating that the
PKIP was highly responsive. Conclusions: The reliability, validity, and responsiveness of the PKIP support its use among patients undergoing primary TKA.
PRM144
Validity And Responsiveness Of The Bristol Rheumatoid Arthritis
Fatigue Multidimensional Questionnaire (BRAF-MDQ) In A
Randomized Controlled Clinical Trial
Kirwan J 1, Coteur G 2, Dures E 1, Nicklin J 1, Bryson J 3, Hewlett S 1
Royal Infirmary, Bristol, UK, 2UCB Pharma, Brussels, Belgium, 3UCB Pharma, Raleigh,
NC, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Bristol
Objectives: To evaluate the validity of the BRAF-MDQ in a new group of patients
in a clinical trial setting, to confirm its internal factor (domain) structure and to
document its sensitivity to change. Methods: Pooled data from a randomized
controlled trial (NCT01242488) in patients with moderate to severe RA were collected at baseline (BL), Wk10 and Wk12. Spearman’s correlation coefficients,
Bland-Altman plots and confirmatory factor analysis tested construct validity,
reproducibility and internal factor structure of the BRAF-MDQ. Responsiveness
was assessed amongst clinical responders at Wk12 by effect sizes of changes from
BL in BRAF-MDQ. Results: There were 219 patients (mean age: 55.5 years; disease
duration: 12.6 years; BL DAS28: 5.77). The proportion of missing item answers was
very low (0–3%). BRAF-MDQ scores correlated with patient global, pain and HAQ at
BL (r= 0.49, 0.46 and 0.58) and at Wk12 (r= 0.63, 0.65 and 0.64). Changes in the Physical
and Living domains were more closely related to changes in patient and physician
global scores and DAS scores than did changes in Cognition and Emotional domains.
Reproducibility was high (r> 0.87 for all total and domain scores; narrow BlandAltman limits of agreement), as was internal consistency (Cronbach’sa: 0.97 for total
scores; > 0.82 for each domain at BL). The Butler comparative fit index (CFI; 0.92)
indicated that the established structure within the BRAF-MDQ accounts well for data
variation. Effect sizes for BRAF-MDQ in clinical responders at Wk12 were very high
A569
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
(> 0.7) for the Physical domain, high (> 0.5) for the Total score and the Living domain
and moderate (>0.3) for the Cognition and Emotional domains. Conclusions: The
BRAF-MDQ was completed well by participants, related to appropriate measures
of disease severity, retained its factor structure, gave reproducible results and was
responsive to clinical change, confirming its validity as a measure of RA fatigue.
PRM145
Cdad-Daysyms™: A New Patient-Reported Outcome Tool For
Clostridium Difficile-Associated Diarrhoea
Kleinman L 1, Talbot G H 2, Schüler R 3, Broderick K 4, Revicki D 5, Nord C E 6
LLC, Anna Maria, FL, USA, 3Actelion
Pharmaceuticals Ltd, Allschwil, Switzerland, 4Cubist Pharmaceuticals, Lexington, MA, USA,
5Evidera, Bethesda, MD, USA, 6Karolinska Institutet, Karolinska University Hospital, Stockholm,
Sweden
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Evidera, Seattle, WA, USA, 2Talbot Advisors
Objectives: Patient-reported outcome (PRO) measures provide relevant information
on how patients function and feel about their health. Such data are useful in clinical
practice and registrational trials. Despite the importance of symptom assessment in
CDAD, there is no validated PRO for Clostridium difficile-associated diarrhoea (CDAD).
A qualitative research study was conducted to develop a CDAD PRO according to US
FDA PRO guidelines. Methods: Content development comprised 2 study phases,
with input from an advisory group of 6 CDAD experts in Europe and North America.
Phase I elicited patients’ experiences of CDAD symptoms in open-ended discussions
during telephone interviews. Supplementary interviews obtained nurses’ observations. A draft PRO was developed following demonstration of concept saturation.
Readability and translatability were assessed. Phase II involved 2 rounds of patient
interviews, with revision of the draft PRO after each round. All patients were ≥ 18
years old, with confirmed CDAD. IRB approval and participant informed consent
were obtained. Results: Phase I interviews included 18 patients and 6 nurses in
the United States; 16 additional patients were interviewed in Phase II. Patients were
representative of the general CDAD population, and diverse in age, gender, and disease
severity. Concept saturation was reached in Phase I for spontaneously reported CDAD
symptoms. Items were organised in a draft conceptual framework with 5 hypothesised domains: diarrhoea, abdominal discomfort, tiredness, lightheadedness, and
other symptoms. Phase II demonstrated initial content validity of the 13-item draft
daily diary (CDAD-DaySyms™). Participants reported the questions were clear, relevant, and comprehensive; were able to use the instructions to complete the diary
correctly; and considered the 24-hour recall period appropriate. Conclusions:
The CDAD-DaySyms™ captures symptoms relevant to CDAD patients, demonstrating initial content validity. To allow its use in clinical practice and CDAD clinical
studies, final content and psychometric validity are being evaluated in 2 ongoing
international clinical trials.
PRM146
Development And Content Validity Testing Of A Treatment
Acceptance Measure For Use In Hypercholesterolemia Patients
Receiving Treatment Via Subcutaneous Injection
Tatlock S 1, Grant L 1, Arbuckle R 1, Khan I 2, Manvelian G 3, Sanchez R 3
1Adelphi Values Ltd, Bollington, UK, 2Sanofi, Bridgewater, NJ, USA, 3Regeneron Pharmaceuticals,
Tarrytown, NY, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In phase II studies, alirocumab, a PCSK9 inhibitor administered via subcutaneous injection, demonstrated significant reduction in LDL-C levels. The objective
of this study was to conduct qualitative research to explore the concept of treatment
acceptance in patients receiving a subcutaneous injection to support the development and testing of a patient-reported outcome measure, the Injection-Treatment
Acceptance Questionnaire (I-TAQ). Methods: A literature review led to the targeting
of ‘treatment acceptance’ as the measurement concept in preference to treatment
satisfaction. Concepts generated from the literature and instrument review informed
the drafting of 17 items in the I-TAQ; item wording was adapted from three validated
instruments. Qualitative interviews were conducted among 29 US-English speaking
patients participating in alirocumab’s phase III program who self-administered the
treatment via autoinjector (n=19) or pre-filled syringe (n=10). First, concept elicitation
(CE) questioning was used to elicit concepts relating to patients’ treatment experiences and acceptance. The I-TAQ was then cognitively debriefed using “think-aloud”
methods. Verbatim transcripts were analyzed using thematic analysis and Atlas. ti.
Revisions were considered after each round of interviews. Results: Qualitative
analysis of CE data indicated treatment acceptance to be high, with the following
concepts identified as relevant: perceived efficacy, side effects, self-efficacy, convenience and overall acceptance. Ten (34%) patients reported an initial fear of needles,
which subsided with no impact on discontinuation. Pain was not considered relevant by patients, suggesting no pain associated with the injection. Five items were
added following round 1 interviews, three were retained after round 2 testing and two
were added at finalization, forming the conceptually comprehensive 22-item I-TAQ.
Patients demonstrated good understanding of item wording, instructions, response
scales and recall period. Conclusions: Successive rounds of interviews resulted in a
treatment acceptance measure with strong content validity. Next steps are to psychometrically validate the I-TAQ in a population with experience of taking alirocumab.
PRM147
The Influence Of Gene Expression Profiling (GEP) On Decisional
Conflict In Chemotherapy Treatment Decision-Making For EarlyStage Breast Cancer (BRCA)
Marshall D 1, MacDonald K 1, Deal K 2, Trudeau M 3, Leighl N 4, Bombard Y 5
of Calgary, Calgary, AB, Canada, 2McMaster University, Hamilton, ON, Canada,
3Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre, Toronto, ON, Canada, 4Ontario Cancer Institute, Toronto, ON,
5
Canada, Li Ka Shing Knowledge Institute, St. Michael’s Hospital, Toronto, ON, Canada
.
.
.
.
.
chemotherapy treatment decision-making. Methods: We embedded the validated
Decisional Conflict Scale (DCS) into our discrete choice experiment survey examining preferences for chemotherapy treatment in early BrCa. Of the 1004 general
population participants, 200 completed the DCS before (DCS-1; no GEP test score
in scenario) and after (DCS-2; GEP test score added to scenario) the discrete choice
experiment. The 16-item DCS was scored from 0-100 with five subscores. Mean
total and subscores, standard deviations and change in scores were calculated, with
significance based on matched pairs t-tests (p< 0.05). We anticipated GEP would
decrease decisional conflict in individuals unsure of their chemotherapy treatment decision. Results: As anticipated, total score and all subscores (uncertainty,
informed, values clarity, support, and effective decision) decreased significantly (all
p< 0.05) in the group of respondents (n= 33) who indicated uncertainty about taking chemotherapy in DCS-1 but changed to no chemotherapy after receiving a GEP
test score in DCS-2. In the group of respondents (n= 25) who indicated they would
undergo chemotherapy in DCS-1 but changed to unsure in DCS-2, their effective
decision subscore increase significantly (24.5 to 34.5, p< 0.05). In the overall sample
(n= 200), total decisional conflict decreased from DCS-1 to DCS-2 by 0.5 (p= 0.3) and
all subscores had non-significant decreases with the exception of effective decision, which had a non-significant increase. Conclusions: GEP influences chemotherapy treatment decisional conflict in individuals who are initially unsure in their
treatment decision-making. However, we do not observe this effect in individuals
who do not change their chemotherapy treatment decisions.
PRM148
Patient Reported Utilities In First-Line Advanced Or Metastatic
Melanoma: Analysis Of Trial CA184-024
Porter J 1, Lee D 1, Hertel N 2, Hatswell A J 1
1BresMed, Sheffield, UK, 2Bristol Myers Squibb, Uxbridge, UK
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In oncology, the impact of interventions on health-related quality of life
(HRQL) is traditionally modelled based on disease progression status. The aim of this
analysis was to assess if more meaningful patterns exist in HRQL data, based on other
clinically important events that should be considered in modelling utility. Methods:
HRQL data from the CA184-024 trial of ipilimumab plus dacarbazine in previously
untreated patients with unresectable malignant melanoma were analysed. European
Organisation for Research and Treatment of Cancer Quality of Life Questionnaire
Core-30 (EORTC QLQ-C30) responses were mapped to a generic, preference-based
measure (EORTC-8D) by means of a published and validated mapping algorithm.
The utility observations available for each patient were used to examine the relationships between HRQL and a number of disease- and time-based variables, including
treatment effect, progression status and time to death, via a mixed effects regression
model. Results: Progression status was found not to be significantly predictive of
utility (p=0.29). Of the variables considered, the strongest relationship was with time
to death, the mixed effects model for which was significantly predictive of utility
(p≤0.001). HRQL dropped as patients approached death; patients treated with ipilimumab had a utility of 0.86 if time to death was more than 1 year, which reduced to
0.61 during the final month of life. The ipilimumab treatment variable was associated
with a small negative coefficient (-0.02), accounting for the adverse event profile of the
drug when added to dacarbazine (p=0.06). Conclusions: Analysis of the CA184-024
HRQL data showed that time to death rather than progression status was significantly
predictive of utility. Hence, modellers should carefully examine primary data to determine if a time to event approach or a progression based approach is appropriate to
model utility best reflecting the pathology of the disease.
PRM149
RASCH FIRST? FACTOR FIRST?
Chen W H , McLeod L D , Coles T M
RTI Health Solutions, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Rasch modelling theory and its extensions have become popular tools
in assessing psychometric properties of patient-reportedoutcome (PRO) instruments. Since the Rasch model assumes a unidimensional structure, it is important
to assert that this assumption has not been violated. However, there has been much
debate about using factor analysis as the first step to assess dimensionality or using
the Rasch model directly to identify items not fitting the unidimensional model.
This study uses simulated data to compare the two techniques to examine the unidimensional assumptions. Methods: Simulated data that represent a typical PRO
instrument are generated based on the following variables: sample size (200 or 400),
number of factors (1,2, or 3), and correlation among factors (0.4 or 0.7). Each simulated PRO assessment contains 15 items with 5 response categories. Exploratory
factor analysis is conducted, and the number of factors proposed by the results
are noted. A Rasch model theory analysis is also conducted, and the number of
mis-fit items is noted. The unidimensional test associated with Rasch model is also
conducted. Results: Preliminary results suggest that when there is one dominant
factor, the Rasch results identify the simulated factor and it becomes the underlying
trait. Items not belonging to the dominant factor are flagged as mis-fit items or as
forming secondary factors based on the unidimensional test. In situations where
there is no dominant factor, factor analysis is able to identify separate factors,
whereas the results are inconsistent using Rasch model. Conclusions: Rasch first
or factor first? The preliminary findings suggest that, when there is prior knowledge
of a dominant factor, Rasch modelling can be conducted first and will result in a
unidimensional measure. When there is no prior knowledge of a dominant factor, then factor analysis should be conducted first to examine the dimensionality.
.
1University
Objectives: Individuals with BrCa have high decisional conflict with respect to
treatment decisions. GEP of tumours informs risk prediction, potentially affecting
decisions about adjuvant chemotherapy in early BrCa, where only 15% will experience recurrence. We aimed to examine whether GEP reduces decisional conflict in
PRM150
Predicting Suicidal Behavior In Veterans And Active Military
Personnel: Possibilities For Electronic Deployment To Discover A
Predictive Assessment
Sage C C 1, Platko J V 1, Nokela M 2
Market Access Services, San Diego, CA, USA, 2Covance Market Access Services, Solna,
Sweden
.
.
1Covance
.
.
.
A570
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: Currently no measure can identify, with a high degree of positive predictive power, suicidal behavior. Because suicide occurs at a low base-rate, studies
of instruments designed to predict this outcome often lack an adequate sample
size to prove the tool’s predictive ability. Our aim is to identify an assessment with
the most promise of predicting suicidal behavior in veteran or military patients and
present options to overcome previous research hurdles. Methods: Two systematic
reviews, one performed for the US Department of Veterans [1], and the other as
part of NICE guidance development [2] provided the background for our analysis. These summaries were reviewed to identify the most predictive assessments
yet developed. Sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive power were
tabulated for all reported instruments. Study limitations were recorded along with
these results. Results: One instrument showed promise of meeting the objective. The Affective States Questionnaire (ASQ) was able to predict suicide within 3
months with a sensitivity of 60%, specificity of 74% and positive predictive power
of 32% [3]. The study that produced those results was performed on an inpatient
and outpatient veteran population. However, the sample was small with only 283
patients and the risk of bias was unclear. A larger study may provide the needed
evidence to make the Affective States Questionnaire a useful screening tool. We
propose the Affective States Questionnaire be transferred to electronic administration and provided as part of routine admissions at VA facilities. Deploying the tool
electronically could provide the large sample sizes required to detect effects on this
low base-rate outcome. Conclusions: The Affective States Questionnaire shows
promise of becoming an appropriate screening tool for suicide in a military population. Electronic capture may allow for large scale deployment, therefore gaining
sufficient sample to determine applicability as a screening tool.
PRM151
Re-Validation of the Self-Injection Assessment Questionnaire©
(Siaqv2.0©) in Rheumatoid Arthritis Patients on Certolizumab Pegol
Treatment
Coteur G
UCB Pharma, Brussels, Belgium
.
Objectives: To evaluate psychometric properties of the revised Self-Injection
Assessment Questionnaire in rheumatoid arthritis patients (pts) receiving certolizumab pegol. Methods: In the study (NCT00674362), pts with low to moderate
rheumatoid arthritis (RA) received certolizumab pegol (CZP; 400mg at Weeks [Wks]
0, 2, 4, then 200mg every other wk). In the open-label extension (OLE; NCT00843778),
pts could self-administer CZP using a pre-filled syringe. Pts in OLE completed the
revised Self-Injection Assessment Questionnaire (SIAQv2.0©) at Wks 0, 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 12.
Domain scores were calculated per authors’ recommendations, and internal consistency was assessed using the Cronbach’s alpha statistics. Floor and ceiling effects
were reported as % pts with the worst/best domain score. Construct validity was
assessed by confirmatory factor analysis fitting the current conceptual framework
of the questionnaire and by calculating the Bentler’s Comparative Fit Index (CFI)
and the root mean square error of approximation (RMSEA). Results: 86 pts (mean
age: 50.8 years; disease duration: 4.6 years) entered the OLE and completed the SIAQ
at least once. At first self-injection visit, DAS28 (ESR) was 4.0 and HAQ-DI 0.9. The
internal consistency of all domains was >0.8 at any visit. Floor effect was <5% at any
visit; ceiling effect was ≤ 13% for Self-Confidence, Ease of Use (EU) and Satisfaction
domains, but reached 40% for Feeling and Injection-Site Reactions domains. The
ceiling effect of the EU domain was lower (10%) than the original validation (22%).
The conceptual framework structure was supported by the confirmatory factor
analysis with CFI values of 0.75–0.86 and RMSEA values of 0.10–0.13, which, given
the limited sample size, would indicate reasonable goodness of fit. Conclusions:
Modifications brought to the SIAQv2.0© appeared to remediate the acquiescence
bias issue that was noted during the validation of SIAQv1. The appropriateness
of the internal consistency reliability and construct validity of the SIAQ v2.0© were
confirmed.
PRM152
Physicians’ Preferences for Bone Metastases Treatments in Turkey
González J M 1, Gatta F 2, Arellano J 3, Qian Y 3, Ertugrul G 4, Hauber A B 1, Posner J 1,
Oksuzoglu B 5
1RTI Health Solutions, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA, 2Amgen (Europe) GmbH, Zug,
Switzerland, 3Amgen Inc., Thousand Oaks, CA, USA, 4Amgen Turkey, Istanbul, Turkey, 5Ankara
Oncology Training and Research Hospital, Ankara, Turkey
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate Turkish physicians’ preferences when selecting
between the different bone-targeted agents (BTAs) available for preventing skeletal-related events (SREs) in patients with bone metastases from advanced solid
tumors. Methods: Physicians from several centres, currently treating patients with
bone metastases from solid tumours were recruited by phone or personal invitation
and then engaged in a face-to-face interview where they completed a web-enabled discrete-choice experiment survey. Each survey included 10 choices between
pairs of hypothetical treatment profiles for the two putative patient profiles. The
hypothetical treatment profiles included five attributes within a pre-defined range
(based on prescribing information): time until first SRE (10, 18 and 28 months); time
until worsening of pain (3, 6 and 10 months); annual risk of osteonecrosis of the
jaw (ONJ; 0, 1 and 5%); annual risk of renal impairment (0,4 and 10%); and mode
of administration (oral tablet, subcutaneous injection, 15-minute or 120-minute
intravenous infusion). Choice questions were based on an experimental design
with known statistical properties. A main-effects random parameters logit model
was estimated. Results: A total of 105 physicians agreed to participate in the
face-to-face interview and accessed the online survey. Of these, 104 physicians
were eligible and consented to participate and 99 were included in the analysis.
Estimated preference weights for all applicable attributes were consistent with the
natural ordering of the categories. Risk of renal impairment and months until first
SRE were the most important attributes influencing physicians’ decisions, with
better clinical outcomes preferred to worse outcomes. Preventing pain progression was the third most important attribute followed by mode of administration.
Annual risk of ONJ was the least important attribute. Conclusions: When making
treatment decisions regarding choice of BTA for patients with bone metastases, the
main treatment goals for Turkish physicians are reducing risk of renal impairment
and delaying first SRE.
PRM153
Validity of the Eq-5d-5l in Stroke Patients
Golicki D 1, Niewada M 1, Buczek J 2, Karlinska A 2, Kobayashi A 2, Janssen M F 3, Pickard A S 4
1Department of Experimental and Clinical Pharmacology, Medical University of Warsaw, Warsaw,
Poland, 22nd Department of Neurology, Institute of Psychiatry and Neurology, Warsaw, Poland,
3Department of Medical Psychology and Psychotherapy, Erasmus MC, Erasmus University,
Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 4Department of Pharmacy Systems, Outcomes, and Policy, College of
Pharmacy, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, IL, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess EQ-5D-5L validity in patients with acute stroke, in comparison to EQ-5D-3L, EQ VAS, modified Rankin Scale (mRS) and Barthel Index
(BI). Methods: Cross-sectional study of 408 patients (51.5% males; mean age 69
years), after median 8 days from stroke onset. We assessed: construct validity in
terms of known-groups validity, convergent validity of EQ-5D-5L dimensions with
other stroke outcome measures, and criterion-related validity in terms of concurrent validity, with mRS as a gold standard. Results: A total of 2.9% EQ-5D-5L and
3.7% EQ-5D-3L questionnaires had at least one missing answer, indicating good
feasibility of both instruments in patients with stroke. The proportion of patients
reporting ‘no problems’ was 38.2% for BI, 6.1% for EQ-5D-3L, 5.6% for EQ-5D-5L,
5.0% for mRS and 2.5% for EQ VAS. Results of the known-groups validity tests confirmed prior hypotheses: health state utilities were lower in females, patients with
high mRS score, low BI or VAS score, patients with subarachnoid hemorrhage or
intracerebral hemorrhage, and when proxy respondent was used. Convergence of
EQ-5D-5L dimensions with mRS, BI and EQ VAS was improved or at least the same
as EQ-5D-3L dimensions. For predicting outcome in patients with stroke, the sum
of mRS related EQ-5D-5L dimensions (Mobility, Self-care, Usual activities), gave 1%
of false positive and 0% of false negative results. Conclusions: Results support
the validity of the EQ-5D-5L descriptive system as a generic measure assessed by
self-report and proxy in patients with acute stroke, demonstrating some psychometric advantages in comparison to EQ-5D-3L and substantially lower ceiling effect
in comparison to Barthel Index.
PRM154
An Evaluation of the Performance of Eq-5d: A Review of Reviews of
Psychometric Properties
Longworth L 1, Singh J 1, Brazier J 2
1Brunel University, Uxbridge, UK, 2University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: EQ-5D has been widely used to measure health status in a variety of
conditions and the amount of evidence of its performance has increased over recent
years. The aim of this study was to consolidate this evidence by reviewing papers
reporting systematic reviews of the psychometric properties (validity and reliability)
and/or responsiveness of EQ-5D. Methods: Medline and Embase were searched
for systematic reviews of the performance of EQ-5D. Supplementary searches were
carried out in Cochrane Library, Web of Science, reference lists of included studies,
the EuroQol database and hand searching of EuroQol Scientific Plenary Proceedings.
In addition the website of the Oxford Patient Reported Outcome Measures (PROMs)
Group was searched for reports. Data were extracted using a template designed
specifically for the study. Results: 25 reviews were identified in this study and a
further 18 were identified from the Oxford PROMs group website. The majority of
studies focussed on adults. Overall there was evidence of good to fair performance
of EQ-5D in depression, diabetes (type 2), rheumatoid arthritis, skin conditions, cancer, cardiovascular disease, asthma, personality disorder and urinary incontinence.
Evidence was mixed in COPD, dementia, schizophrenia and vision disorders, and
poor for hearing disorders. The was little evidence for liver transplantation, venous
leg ulcers, haemophilia, bipolar disorder and low back pain; although limited, the
evidence showed positive results for liver transplantation, haemophilia and leg
ulcers. No evidence was identified for, among others, skin cancer and systemic lupus
erythematous. Conclusions: This study has provided a comprehensive overview
of the evidence of the performance of EQ-5D. Most evidence suggests good psychometric properties of EQ-5D; however there are particular concerns about its ability
to capture the impact of dementia, schizophrenia, visual impairment and hearing
disorders. Further research is encouraged in conditions where data or reviews of
psychometric properties of EQ-5D are lacking.
PRM155
Health-Related Quality of Life in Italian Patients With Moderate
and Severe Crohn’s Disease: Interim Results from the Sole Study
Lazzaro C 1, Cappello M 2, Cortelezzi C 3, Costantino G 4, Fiorino G 5, Mastronardi M 6,
Giannotta M 7, Galletti B 8, Cicala M 9, Vadalà di Prampero S 10, Gualberti G 11, Caprioli F 12,
Gasbarrini A 13, Meregaglia M 14
1Studio di Economia Sanitaria, Milan, Italy, 2Università di Palermo, Palermo, Italy, 3AOU di
Circolo - Fondazione Macchi, Varese, Italy, 4Università di Messina, Messina, Italy, 5Istituto Clinico
Humanitas, Rozzano (MI), Italy, 6IRCCS S. De Bellis, Castellana Grotte, Italy, 7Azienda Ospedaliero
Universitaria di Careggi, Firenze, Italy, 8Ospedale S. Salvatore, L’Aquila, Italy, 9Università Campus
Bio Medico, Roma, Italy, 10Azienda Ospedaliero-Universitaria S. Maria della Misericordia di
Udine, Udine, Italy, 11AbbVie, Campoverde di Aprilia (LT), Italy, 12Università degli Studi di Milano,
Milano, Italy, 13Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Rome, Italy, 14Bocconi University, Milan, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: to investigate health-related quality of life (HRQoL) in Italian
patients with moderate and severe Crohn’s disease (CD) (Harvey Bradshaw
Index> 8). Methods: EuroQoL 5-dimension 3-level (EQ-5D-3L) questionnaire
and visual analogue scale (VAS) were administered to 540 consecutive patients
with moderate and severe CD who referred to a convenience sample of 38 Italian
inflammatory bowel disease centres (21 teaching-hospitals; 4 research hospitals;
8 self-governing hospitals; 3 Local Health Authority hospitals; 2 private hospitals) participating in the ongoing Survey on Quality Of Life in Crohn’s Patients (SOLE)
A571
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
during 2012. As Italian EQ-5D-3L tariffs were not available at the time of the research,
UK ones were used according to other comparable studies. Results concerning the
first out of the 4 visits planned in SOLE study were reported as mean, standard
deviation (SD), median and range. Correlation between EQ-5D-3L questionnaire and
VAS scores was investigated via Kendall’s tau-b (Ktau-b). Results: 531 patients
(mean age: 41.3; SD: 13.8; median: 41; range: 18—84) responded to EQ-5D-3L questionnaire (98.3%) and 536 to VAS (99.6%). The most frequently marked levels for
EQ-5D-3L questionnaire were: 1 for mobility (66.2%) and self-care (85.2%); 2 for
usual activities (51.8%), pain/discomfort (70.7%), and anxiety/depression (53.4%).
Overall scores for EQ-5D-3L questionnaire and VAS were 0.7 (SD: 0.3; median: 0.8;
range: -0.2—1) and 54.3 (SD: 20.8; median: 55; range: 0—100), respectively. Six out of
531 EQ-5D-3L questionnaire responders (1.1%) valued their health state potentially
worse than death (utility< 0). VAS scores of 10 or multiple of 10 were marked by 298
out of 536 patients (55.6%). Ktau-b between EQ-5D-3L questionnaire and VAS scores
reached 0.45 (p< 0.001). No significant differences were detected when EQ-5D-3L
questionnaire and VAS scores were stratified according to hospital institutional
features. Conclusions: Italian patients with moderate and severe CD report a
remarkable reduction in HRQoL.
PRM156
Current Sample Size Practices in the Psychometric Evaluation of
Patient-Reported Outcomes for Use in Clinical Trials
Coles T M , Chen W H , Nelson L M , Williams V , McLeod L D
RTI Health Solutions, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Sample size (N) affects the robustness of psychometric results, but for
evaluations of patient-reported outcome (PRO) measures, N is often a compromise
between timelines and resources. Currently, there are no psychometric N guidelines or requirements for the development of PROs for use in clinical trials. The
objective of this study is to review current N practices by conducting a systematic
literature review of the psychometric methods and N choices made in the evaluation
of PRO measures (for use in clinical trials) over the past 10 years. Methods: This
systematic literature review included abstracts that described the psychometric
evaluation of PRO measures that were likely developed for use in clinical trials. The
review included English-language journal abstracts published in the past 10 years
and identified in PubMed. Characteristics of each study were tabulated including
the number of items and dimensions in each PRO of interest, the psychometric
methods employed (e.g., internal consistency, test-retest reliability, factor analysis, responsiveness), and N. Results: The literature search yielded 252 abstracts
describing studies conducted mostly in Europe, Canada, and the United States.
Preliminary results indicate that Ns ranged from approximately 40 to 4,000. The
most frequently reported psychometric method was Cronbach’s alpha to quantify
internal consistency. Approximately thirty percent of studies employed methods
that demand the largest Ns such as item response theory (IRT) and factor analysis
(FA). Ns for studies using IRT or FA analysis ranged from approximately 100 to 4,000
participants. Conclusions: A wide range of Ns were employed for the psychometric evaluation of PROs developed for use in clinical trials. Ideally, researchers should
consider the complexity of the PRO measure, its intended use, and the purpose of
the evaluation when deciding on a study N. Additional studies should work toward
developing best practices for PRO N guidelines in clinical trials.
PRM157
Re Introduction of the Ranking Task in Eq-5d Valuation. Improved
Data Quality and Reduced Level of Inconsistencies?
Ramos-Goñi J M 1, Rand-Hendriksen K 2, Igarashi A 3, Ikeda S 4, Pinto-Prades J L 5
1The EuroQol Group Foundation, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 2Faculty of Medicine, University
of Oslo, Oslo, Norway, 3University of Tokyo, Graduate School of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Tokyo,
Japan, 4International University of Health and Welfare, Otawara City, Tochigi, Japan, 5Glasgow
Caledonian University, Newton Mearns, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The EuroQol group observed problems related to the quality of valuation data collected using the 5L protocol. The objective of this study was to test if
reintroducing a ranking task prior to TTO could help to improve the quality of the
data. Methods: Respondents were assigned to three different study branches in
Spain, while just two branches were used in Japan. The control group (Arm 1, both
countries) was the 5L protocol. The second branch (Arm 2, just Spain) was the EQ-VT
preceded by a ranking task, in which the respondents were asked to rank the target
health states using physical cards. The last branch (Arm 3, both countries) was
with ranking prior to the EQ-VT, but unlike the second branch, the ranked states
remained visible through the Composite TTO (C-TTO) tasks, and the C-TTO states
order were determined by the rank order. A sample of respondents was randomly
selected from Canary Islands and Tokyo population. All interviews were performed
face to face. We compared the number of C-TTO-based inconsistencies. Results:
The final sample size was 932 respondents (141 and 191 for branches 1 and 3 respectively in Japan and 196,205 and 199 for branches 1, 2 and 3 respectively in Spain).
The percentages of inconsistencies on C-TTO responses (state 55555 not valued as
the worst state) were 13.27%, 10.73% and 13.57% for branches 1, 2, 3 respectively in
Spain, and 20.6% and 10.5% for branches 1 and 3 in Japan. Grouping the data, the
inconsistencies were 16.3%; 10.7% and 12.1%. However, none of the observed differences were statistically significant. Conclusions: Differences in proportions
observed in the Spanish data are smaller than in Japanese data. Given that Japanese
team did all control arm interviews prior to ranking task interviews could play in
favor of ranking arm (learning effects).
PRM158
Are “Lively” and “Full of Pep” Similar Or Different Concepts?
Challenges in Translating These Terms in Seven Languages
Gil-Campos I 1, Anfray C 1, Acquadro C 2
1Mapi, Lyon, France, 2Mapi Research Trust, Lyon, France
.
.
.
Objectives: Feeling “lively” or “full of pep” are common items used in PRO measures. The Profile of Mood States (POMS) identifies and assesses six fluctuating
mood or affective states: 1) Tension-Anxiety, 2) Vigour-Activity, 3) DepressionDejection, 4) Fatigue-Inertia, 5) Anger-Hostility, and 6) Confusion-Bewilderment.
“Lively” (item 7) and “full of pep” (item 56) belong to the Vigor-Activity domain.
The objectives of this study were to evaluate the difference in concept
(if any) between these items and to translate them in 7 languages (Bulgarian,
Estonian, French, German, Latvian, Portuguese and Slovakian). Methods: The
POMS was translated following the Mapi methodology in compliance with the
ISPOR guidelines. The process consisted of: 1) definition of each concept behind
each item, 2) two forward translations by native translators, reconciliation of the
translations, 3) one back-translation by an English-speaker fluent in the target language, 4) final reconciliation, and 5) cognitive interviews with 35 native-speaking
healthy subjects (n= 5 per country). Results: The first step of the translation
process, i.e., definition of concepts, helped to clarify the conceptual differences
between “lively” and “full of pep”. “Lively” had to be considered more as an action
or behavior-based descriptor and “full of pep” as descriptive of the internal state.
“Lively” was considered as the manifestation of feeling “full of pep”: With this
definition in mind, each local team could find appropriate equivalents in each
language. “Lively” was translated with literal wording in all languages. As for “full
of pep”, translations varied from “enthusiastic” (Bulgarian, Portuguese) to “full of
vitality” (Estonian, Slovakian) or “peppy” (German), “full of spirit” in French and
“full of energy “in Latvian. The translations were well understood. Conclusions:
“Lively” and “full of pep” are two different concepts which could be easily translated with the help of the developers who provided clear definitions of the intent
of each item.
PRM159
A Reliability Generalisation of the Eortc Qlq-Br23
Smith A B 1, Taylor M 2, Cocks K 1, Parry D 3
1University of York, York, UK, 2York Health Economics Consortium, York, UK, 3AstraZeneca UK,
Macclesfield, UK
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The collection of patient-reported outcome (PRO) data is becoming
more routine in oncology clinical trials and in clinical practice. The European
Organisation for Research and Treatment of Cancer (EORTC) has developed and
validated a number of PRO instruments, including the QLQ-BR23, a breast cancer
specific measure. The objective of this study was to evaluate the internal reliability of the EORTC QLQ-BR23 through reliability generalisation, a meta-analytic
technique for pooling Cronbach’s alpha coefficients. Methods: A systematic literature review was undertaken of articles reporting the internal reliability of the
EORTC QLQ-BR23 to identify potential studies for inclusion. Internal reliability was
assessed for each of the five domains of the EORTC QLQ-BR23: Body (BI), Sexual
Functioning (SF), Arm Symptoms (AS), Breast Symptoms (BS) and Systemic Therapy
Side Effects (ST). Reliability generalisation was undertaken using fixed and random
effects models for each domain. A value for Cronbach’s alpha coefficient above
0.70 was considered to indicate reliability. Results: A total of 15 studies were
found resulting in 18 datasets. Of the 3102 patients who had been recruited into
studies 2888 had completed the BR-23 (93%). Almost half the studies had used
European language versions of the instrument (7/15,47%). The unweighted average
(fixed effects) Cronbach’s alpha coefficient ranged from 0.69 (breast symptoms) to
0.86 (sexual functioning). There was statistically significant heterogeneity present
across the 5 domains under the fixed effects model justifying the use of random
effects. All Cronbach’s alpha > 0.7 under the random effects model, e.g. BI: 0.84
(95%CI: 0.80-0.87), SF: 0.87 (95%CI: 0.84-0.89), AS: 0.71 (95%CI: 0.66-0.76), BS: 0.70
(95%CI: 0.65-0.74) and ST: 0.71 (95%CI: 0.66-0.75). Conclusions: The results suggest that the 5 domains of the EORTC QLQ-B23 are reliable and may be used in
clinical trials and practice to capture PRO data to help inform trial, as well as
individual clinical decision-making processes.
PRM160
Improving Performance in Diabetes Care: Benefits of Information
Technology Enabled Diabetes Management
Saric T 1, Lazic G 2, Poljicanin T 3, Prenda Trupec T 4
savjetovanje, Zagreb, Croatia, 2Private practice family medicine Karlovac, Karlovac,
Croatia, 3Croatian National Institute Of Public Health, Zagreb, Croatia, 4Croatian Health
Insurance Fund, Zagreb, Croatia
.
.
.
.
1Promeritus
Objectives: Empirical data suggest that compliance with diabetes clinical practice recommendations is inadequate in primary care and that a large proportion of
patients with diabetes remain at high risk. Changing physician practice patterns
with use of electronic integrated system would provide a suite of technologies to
support a full range of diabetes management activities. The objectives of this study
are to determine the financial and clinical benefits of implementing information
technology enabled diabetes management systems. Methods: The simulations
were performed using the CORE model – widely validated and broadly used to
enable a reliable estimation of costs and clinical effects associated with diabetes.
Several estimates of care process improvements were derived, representing different percentage of patients covered by designed management activities and
reaching target HbA1c. The primary outcome was medical cost savings and secondary measures include reduction of cardiovascular, cerebrovascular, neuropathy,
nephropathy, and retinopathy clinical outcomes. Results: Gradual, sustained,
and statistically significant improvements in a lifelong perspective performance
measures were observed. According to simulation, as percentage of patients covered by information technology enabled diabetes management is growing, health
care expenditures are reduced. With 10% of patients covered 6% of total patient
costs were saved in comparison to 23% of total patient costs saved with 100%
of patients covered. Conclusions: Implementation of information technology
enabled diabetes management has demonstrated significant potential for improving processes of care, preventing the development of diabetic complications, and
generating cost savings. Moreover, this improves the synthesis of information,
the delivery of knowledge, and the efficiency of communication, allowing for
coordination of care across delivery teams.
A572
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PRM161
Assessing the Methodological Value of Digital Real-Time
Collection of Qualitative Content in Supporting In-Depth
Qualitative Interviews Exploring the Symptoms and Impacts of
Gout on Health-Related Quality of Life
Rudell K 1, Tatlock S 2, Panter C 2, Arbuckle R 2, Symonds T 1
Ltd, Tadworth, UK, 2Adelphi Values Ltd, Bollington, UK
.
.
.
.
.
1Pfizer
Objectives: Gout is the most common arthritic condition, but research of Gout
patient experiences is limited. Qualitative interviews are a valid and well-accepted
means of gaining in-depth insight into the patient experience, but are typically
conducted in artificial environments relying on patient recall. Novel digital methods
of collecting qualitative data through real-time data capture (RTDC) have recently
emerged and have stronger ecological validity. The objective of this research was to
assess the added methodological value of analyzing audio/visual data recorded and
submitted by gout patients through a mobile phone application while experiencing
flares, in addition to traditional patient interviews. Methods: Concept elicitation interviews were conducted with 20 American gout patients using open-ended
exploratory questions to facilitate spontaneous elicitation of content. Following
interviews, 50% of the sample took part in a RTDC exercise by submitting selfrecorded videos and images in response to six tasks issued on a mobile phone
application over seven days. All data were subject to thematic analysis using Atlas.
ti. Interviews and RTDC data were compared in terms of conceptual coverage and
insights. Results: Qualitative analysis demonstrated both forms of data collection led to the identification of the same symptoms and impacts with no additional
concepts identified in either form of data. Symptoms and impacts of the disease
during flares were high. RTDC data provided additional insight into the severity of
symptoms and level of impact burden, specifically with regards to images of the
level of swelling experienced during a flare and sleep disturbances through videos
recorded by patients at the time of disturbance. Conclusions: Whilst traditional
patient interviews remain the gold standard in exploring the symptoms and impacts
of a condition, RTDC was found to provide additional valuable insights in this sample of gout patients, which can inform future measurement strategies and enhance
the field of patient-centered research.
PRM162
What Is the Appropriate Comparator Health State To Use in Time
Trade-off Studies?
Shah K
Office of Health Economics, London, UK
.
Objectives: Studies to produce utility values for the EQ-5D-5L instrument are
ongoing internationally. These include the valuation of 10 EQ-5D-5L health states
using the time trade-off (TTO) method. In some of the studies carried out to date,
relatively low mean TTO values for mild health states have been observed. It is
hypothesised that this is because the health states under evaluation are being compared to “full health”, whereas in previous studies they were compared to 11111 (the
“best” health state in the descriptive system). The objective is to assess differences in
TTO valuations using two different comparators (full health and 11111). Methods:
Preferences for EQ-5D-5L health states were elicited from a broadly representative
sample of the UK general public. TTO data were collected using computer-assisted
personal interviews, carried out in respondents’ homes. Respondents were randomly allocated to one of two arms: in arm 1 the comparator health state was full
health; in arm 2 the comparator health state was 11111. After completing 10 TTO
valuations, respondents were asked follow-up questions which sought to examine
their interpretations of the term “full health”. Results: 450 interviews were completed in mid-2014. Health state 11111 was almost always given a value of 1; yet
the majority of respondents who self-reported as being in 11111 did not consider
themselves to be in “best imaginable health”. Preliminary analyses suggest that
the use of 11111 (rather than full health) as the comparator does not increase the
average values elicited for mild health states. A sizeable minority of respondents
did not agree that 11111 and full health are equivalent. Vision and spirituality were
mentioned by respondents as examples of important aspects of health not covered
by 11111. Conclusions: The low observed values for mild EQ-5D-5L health states
cannot be explained by the choice of comparator health state alone.
the Total SGRQ score (r= 0.73) and Symptoms (r= 0.62); Activity (r= 0.55), Impact
(r= 0.72) subscales; the modified MRC Dyspnoea scale (r=0.54), FACIT-F (r= -0.66);
HADS Anxiety (r=0.53) and Depression (r= 0.54). The MEMSI also demonstrated good
overall fit to the Rasch model (Chi-squared 26.6; df 20; p=0.26) and distribution of item
scores. Conclusions: The final MEMSI contains 10-item and is a reliable, valid, unidimensional self-reported outcome measure of early morning symptoms for people
with COPD. It is quick and simple making it suitable for use in research and practice.
Further work is underway to determine the minimal clinical important difference.
PRM164
An Electronic Version of the Pdq-39: Acceptability To Respondents
and Assessment of Alternative Response formats
Morley D , Dummett S , Kelly L , Dawson J , Jenkinson C
University of Oxford, Headington, UK
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Firstly, to migrate the paper-based version of the PDQ-39 to a computer
based platform and assess its usability and acceptability to respondents. Secondly,
to investigate the impact of implementing non-response options on response rates
and data completeness. Methods: Six people with Parkinson’s (PwP) participated
in cognitive interviews in order to assess the usability and acceptability of the
electronic version of the PDQ-39, the ePDQ. This was followed by an online survey
of 129 PwP, randomly assigned to one of two groups; one required to provide a
response to every item and one with the option to skip any item they did not wish to
answer. Results: Cognitive interviews indicated that the ePDQ is acceptable to PwP,
with positive feedback regarding layout, features and functionality. 125 PwP fully
completed the ePDQ. Following randomization 60 participants completed the forced
response ePDQ and 65 completed the non-forced version. Response rates of 98.4%
were achieved for the forced response ePDQ and 95.6% for the non-forced. Missing
value analyses calculated levels of missing data at below 5% in the non-forced
sample. Conclusions: The ePDQ is user-friendly and acceptable to respondents.
Additionally, there appears little difference when implementing non-response
options on response rates and data completeness.
PRM165
Efficacy of Virtual Reality Exposure Therapy in the Management of
Symptoms Associated With Post Traumatic Stress Disorder
Jiandani N , Nair S R , Shukla H
Capita India Pvt. Ltd., Mumbai, India
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Management of symptoms and illness for post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) requires effective and prolonged psychiatric support. Re-experiencing
traumatic memories and events via virtual reality exposure therapy (VRET) can
lead to reduction of illness and symptoms associated with PTSD. This systematic
literature review aims to demonstrate the value of VRET in the management of
illness and symptoms associated with PTSD. Methods: Studies published in the
English language for PTSD and VRET were retrieved from Embase, PubMed, and
Cochrane databases using relevant search strategies. Two researchers are independently reviewing studies as per the Cochrane methodology for systematic literature
reviews. We considered VRET as a tool to deliver therapy programs via a virtual
platform to patients suffering from PTSD. The main outcome will be improvement in
symptoms such as anxiety, various phobias and depression developed as a result of
PTSD. Outcomes will be measured as change in baseline characteristics in patients
using VRET, by using questionnaires specific to the symptoms being measured
such as Beck’s Anxiety Inventory, Beck’s Depression inventory-II (BDI-II), ClinicianAdministered PTSD Scale (CAPS), and patient reported outcomes. Results: In total,
2574 potentially relevant studies were retrieved from the databases and are being
screened for inclusion in the review. The detailed results from the systematic review
will be presented in the poster. Conclusions: The evidence from this systematic
literature review will hopefully suggest the role of VRET as a promising new tool for
managing PTSD from a psychotherapeutic perspective.
PRM166
Quality of Life Elements in Schizophrenia for Patients and Carers
offer Challenges To and Opportunities for Intervention
Floyd D 1, Gemmell E 2, Brown J 1
.
.
.
1PHMR Associates, London, UK, 2PHMR Associates, Newcastle
PRM163
The Development and Preliminary Validation of the Manchester
Early Morning Symptoms Index (Memsi) for People With Chronic
Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (Copd)
Garrow A P 1, Yorke J 1, Khan N 2, Tyson S 1, Singh D 3, Vestbo J 4
1University of Manchester, Manchester, UK, 2The Medicines Evaluation Unit, Manchester, UK,
3University of Manchester, Medicines Evaluation Unit, Manchester, UK, 4The University of
Manchester, Manchester, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Early morning symptoms (EMS) of COPD are associated with poor
health, impaired daily activities and increased exacerbation risk. We describe the
development and preliminary validation of the Manchester Early Morning Symptom
Index (MEMSI) to quantify EMS in COPD. Methods: Potential items were identified
from interviews and focus groups with COPD and non-COPD participants. Cognitive
de-briefing elucidated the relevance and understanding of the potential items followed by a cross-sectional study to finalise the items for inclusion. The draft scale
was completed twice, one week apart to assess test-retest reliability. The St George’s
Respiratory Questionnaire (SGRQ), modified MRC Dyspnoea Scale, FACIT fatigue scale
and Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS) evaluated convergent validity.
Hierarchical methods and Rasch analysis informed item reduction and assessed
uni-dimensionality. Results: 36 patients with COPD initially identified 22 items.
The cross sectional study included 203 COPD patients (GOLD: I: 14% II: 41% III: 25%
IV: 7%, male: 63%, mean age 64.7, SD: 7.5 years) and 50 age and gender matched
non-COPD controls. 12 items were removed during hierarchical methods. The MEMSI
demonstrated excellent internal consistency (Cronbach’s alpha 0.9) and good testretest repeatability (r=0.82). The scale also showed moderate-good correlation with
upon Tyne, UK
Objectives: Schizophrenia is responsible for high levels of individual morbidity:
acute schizophrenia had the highest disability score of any condition in the 2010
Global Burden of Disease study. Consequently, quality of life (QoL) overall and related
to health is a major issue for patients, as well as their families/carers. Methods:
We undertook a pragmatic literature search of publications relating to QoL and
schizophrenia over the past 7 years to identify main themes and trends. Results:
Patients: Patient-reported QoL is often over-estimated compared to objective QoL as
measured by health care professions, particularly during psychotic episodes. Factors
that appear to be adversely associated with QoL include symptoms, treatment side
effects, physical mobility, lack of relationships, daily activity, housing, social stigma
and self-stigma. In some cases, there is a complex cause and effect relationship.
Families/carers: Those looking after patients with schizophrenia suffer impaired
QoL and this can have an impact on the whole household and its social milieu.
Poor carer QoL can ultimately impair levels of care and increase risk of mistreatment, which in turn risks a relapse of symptoms and ultimately hospitalisation.
On the other hand, the experience of caring for a patient with schizophrenia may
lead to personal emotional/psychological growth. Disease insight and education
for some schizophrenia sufferers can lead to diminished QoL and an increased risk
of suicide. On the other hand, disease understanding can help improve treatment
adherence. Conclusions: QoL in schizophrenia is complicated and must be fully
understood to help develop effective programmes to improve QoL for sufferers and
their families/carers. Programmes that do not reflect this complexity may increase
risk of symptom recurrence and even suicide. Thus, when devising interventional
programmes to supplement drug treatment for management of schizophrenia, a
range of patient- and carer-related factors must considered.
A573
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PRM167
Comparability of Interview and Self-Administration of the
Functional Assessment of Chronic Illness Therapy-Tuberculosis
(Facit-Tb) Instrument in Iraqi Pulmonary Tuberculosis Patients
Dujaili J A 1, Syed Sulaiman S A 1, Hassali M A 2, Blebil A Q 3, Awaisu A 4, Bredle J M 5
Sains Malaysia, Minden, Malaysia, 2Universiti Sains Malaysia, Penang, Malaysia,
3UCSI University, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, 4Qatar University, Doha, Qatar, 5FACITtrans,
Elmhurst, IL, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Universiti
Objectives: To investigate the extent to which two different modes of administration (interview by a trained interviewer versus self-administration) yielded a
comparable estimate of health-related quality of life (HRQL) in pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB) patients. Methods: The study was conducted between September
1st 2012 and July 31st 2013, among consecutive PTB patients treated at Thoracic and
Respiratory Disease Specialist Centre in Baghdad, Iraq. The mode of administration
of the Functional Assessment of Chronic Illness Therapy-Tuberculosis (FACIT-TB);
a new tuberculosis (TB) -specific instrument, at baseline was registered in 305 subjects. Results: Although the FACIT-TB was designed for self-administration, most
patients in our sample (N = 193,63.278%) requested some help from the interviewer
to fill out the questionnaire. Mann Whitney U test showed that those patients capable of self-administration were younger (38.16 ± 12.93 versus 43.58 ± 16.41 years, P
= 0.005) and required less time to complete the questionnaire compared to those
who interviewed by a trained interviewer (14.64 ± 3.24 versus 17.22 ± 2.61 minutes,
P < 0.001), while Chi-Square statistics showed that this group of patients had a
higher education level (P < 0.001). No differences in gender were observed. HRQL
score across all domains for those who interviewed by a trained investigator was
slightly lower than those who answered the questionnaire by self-administration.
However, the results did not reach statistical significance (P> 0.05). Conclusions:
Technical equivalence has been demonstrated in the sample of PTB patients in Iraq.
FACIT-TB instrument is flexible and it is able to accommodate the needs of patients
with diverse social, educational, and functional skills. Technical equivalence across
different modes of administration of questionnaire permits unbiased assessment
of the impact of the disease and its treatments on patients’ HRQL.
PRM168
Health Related Quality of Life in Cancer Patients: Evaluation With
A Self-Administered Ipad Application
Yuce D , Hayran M , Kilickap S , Erman M , Celik I
Hacettepe University, Ankara, Turkey
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Cancer has the second highest mortality rates after cardiovascular diseases in the world. Advances in treatment options caused significant enhancements
in survival of cancer patients. However, the major parameter affecting treatment
success and treatment adherence in these patients is the quality of life (QoL). We
aimed to develop a self-administered iPad application for evaluation of QoL in a
short questionnaire. Methods: As part of routine practice in Preventive Oncology
Department EORTC QLQ-C30 was administered to 1549 cancer patients treated in
Hacettepe University Oncology Hospital. We determined 10 questions that explains
most of the variation in QoL using factor analysis, and designed a new application
for iPad, where patients can record responses themselves. Results: The 10 factors
that described by the factor analysis had the power of 74,2% explaining QoL variances. The reliability analysis of these factors showed a Cronbach alpha coefficient
of 0,75. The new self-administered iPad application was tested in a pilot study that
conducted in 127 patients taking chemotherapy regimens in the outpatient setting.
The validity and reliability analyses revealed that the new application can be effectively used in Turkish cancer patients. Conclusions: Our results revealed that our
software application will be useful and efficient for monitoring of the changes in
QoL during their treatment course. Furthermore, this kind of mobile applications
may be practical for health professionals in daily routine clinical assessments of
patients. Also, the audio and visual enhancements in electronic applications provide
increased accessibility for the cancer patients.
PRM169
The Selection of Appropriate Health State Utility Values (Hsuvs) for
Health Technology Assessment (Hta): Lessons To Be Learnt
Patel A , King D , Greenall G , Mitchell S A , Purushotham S , Hudson P M
Abacus International, Bicester, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Incorporation of health-related quality of life (HRQoL) evidence into
economic models is a requirement of many countries for the purposes of Health
Technology Assessment (HTA), and therefore appropriate health state utility values
(HSUVs) are often sought. The objective of this review was to: (i) identify and summarise the principal limitations of HSUVs used in recent submissions appraised
by the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) and (ii) produce
a categorical checklist that can be used by manufacturers to reduce uncertainty
when selecting HSUVs for HTA. Methods: Evidence appraisal documents for the
50 most recently published technologies assessed by NICE were retrieved in June
2014. Economic models were assessed and utility inputs reviewed. Critiques of the
utilities reported by the evidence review group or final appraisal committee were
extracted, reviewed and categorised. Results: Of the appraisals reviewed (43 single
technology appraisals (TAs) and 7 multiple TAs), utility inputs were either sourced
from the literature (n= 27), published mapping algorithms (n= 11), de novo mapping
algorithms (n= 2), or derived from clinical trials (n= 10). The concerns expressed by
review groups can be categorised into four categories: (i) generalisability – relevance
of HSUVs to UK clinical practice, deviation from NICE scope, and the use of other
countries’ valuations for health states; (ii) HSUV selection – inadequate justification
of HSUVs, and lack of consideration for covariates and disutilities; (iii) mapping algorithms – use of non-validated or non-peer-reviewed publications, incomplete reporting of key model information, and ambiguity regarding selection and justification
of mapping function; (iv) risk of bias – sample size, instrument response rates, and
general study quality identified as factors affecting HSUV validity. Conclusions:
The selection of appropriate HSUVs is critical to reduce uncertainty in economic
models. A checklist based on critiques of recent HTAs will be a useful tool for manufacturers when selecting relevant HRQoL parameters.
PRM170
Translation and Linguistic Validation of the Electronic Colombia
Suicide Severity Rating Scale in Asia-Pac
Anderson H 1, Gordon-Stables R 1, Wild D 1, Riale K 2
1ICON plc, Oxford, UK, 2ERT, Pittsburgh, PA, USA
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The Columbia Suicide Severity Rating Scale (C-SSRS) has been developed into an electronic self-rated version (the e-CSSRS) in order to facilitate compliance with regulatory requirements for prospective monitoring of suicidal ideation
and behaviours. The e-CSSRS v2.0 for IVRS has been translated and linguistically
validated for use in over 60 countries. Whilst translating and linguistically validating
the scale it was noted that particularly in the Asia-Pacific region there were some
challenging issues around the concept of suicide from a linguistic and cultural
perspective. This study aimed to determine what these issues were and highlight
how they were resolved. Methods: Eighteen reports were reviewed from the AsiaPacific region. The languages were: China-Mandarin, India-English, India-Gujarati,
India-Hindi, India-Kannada, India-Malayalam, India-Marathi, India-Tamil, IndiaTelugu, Korea-Korean, Malaysia-English, Malaysia-Malay, Malaysia-Mandarin,
Philippines-English, Philippines-Tagalog, Singapore-English, Singapore-Malay, and
Singapore-Mandarin. Each report was reviewed for challenges relating to translation
and cultural adaptation. Results: Across all reports specific homonymic confusions were encountered within two target languages: in Indian Hindi the same
word is used for “pill” and “bullet”; in Singapore Malay the words for “end” and
“saving” sound similar, occasioning confusion in prompts about attempts to end
life. Translations were adapted to avoid these confusions. In two cases the use of
a gun in suicide attempts was found to be rare or unknown: in Singapore English
the relevant prompt was clarified to minimise confusion; for Malayalam for Kerala,
where shooting is rare and hanging is common, “getting a gun” was changed to
“getting a rope” wherever it appeared and for similar reasons “collecting pills” was
changed to “collecting a poison.” Conclusions: The e-CSSRS v2.0 IVRS is now
available in for use in over 60 countries. Some issues were identified relating to
translation and the methods of suicide in a small number of languages but these
were resolved throughout the linguistic validation process.
PRM171
From Clinically Relevant Outcome Measures To Quality of Life
in Epilepsy
de Kinderen R J A 1, Wijnen B F M 1, Postulart D 2, Majoie M H 2, Aldenkamp A P 2, Evers S M 1
University, Maastricht, The Netherlands, 2Epilepsy Center Kempenhaeghe, Heeze, The
Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Maastricht
Objectives: Utilities can be easily derived using generic quality of life (QoL) instruments. However, problems in collecting utility scores may occur because clinical
evaluations still favor disease specific instruments over generic quality of life instruments for reasons of sensitivity and reliability. Especially in case of the fluctuating
nature of seizures in epilepsy, generic QoL-instruments are often find to be unsuitable for outcome research. A proposed method to bridge the gap between clinically
relevant outcome measures and QoL is to derive utility scores for epilepsy health
states. The aim of this study is to develop a scoring algorithm to transform epilepsy
health states into utility scores. Methods: The proposed scoring algorithm was
based on valuations of health states generated by the Time Trade-Off (TTO) method.
The TTO was based on clinically important attributes (seizure frequency, seizure
severity and treatment related side-effects). A full factorial design was used which
resulted in 78 scenario’s. Besides standard demographics, every participant was
asked to value 10 or 11 different health states. A multilevel regression analysis was
performed to account for the nested structure of the data. The TTO was conducted
using online survey software. Results: In total 531 subjects of the general population, with an average age of 42 years, have participated in the TTO study. Preliminary
results show that the best health state (no seizures and no side-effects) is estimated
at 0.89 utility and the worst state (seizures twice a day, many side-effects, type 5
seizure) is estimated at 0.16. Conclusions: This study provides a scoring algorithm for transforming clinically relevant outcome measures of epilepsy into utility
estimates which can be incorporated into economic evaluations. Although seizure
frequency is the most commonly reported primary outcome measure in epilepsy
research, this study suggest that the impact of seizure severity alone should not
be underestimated.
PRM172
An Analysis of the Health Technology Assessment Recommendation
and Guidance on Use of Eq-5d-5l in Cost-Effectiveness Modeling
Ovcinnikova O 1, Firth Z A 2, Dimova M 2
.
.
.
.
1MAPI, London, UK, 2Mapi, London, UK
Objectives: Several national health technology assessment (HTA) bodies including
the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) for England and Wales
recommend EQ-5D as the preferred health-related quality of life (HRQL) measure for
use in cost-effectiveness analyses. This study aims to evaluate the recommendation
and impact of using EQ-5D-5L versus EQ-5D-3L for cost-effectiveness modeling in
HTA submission guidelines and subsequent reimbursement decisions. Methods:
A targeted review of national HTA submission modeling guidelines since the introduction of the EQ-5D-5L measure was carried out for the UK and France. The costeffectiveness modeling guidelines were assessed for the requirements for EQ-5D at
either level. The impact of guideline requirements on submissions were analysed
by examining the presence of EQ-5D-5L in the 20 most recent technical appraisal
manufacturer submissions for each HTA body. Results: While all HTA bodies recommended the use of EQ-5D as a generic measure of HRQL, only NICE specifically
recommended EQ-5D-5L. However, it was not a requirement. Of the latest published
guidance only NICE and the Scottish Medicines Consortium had one EQ-5D-5L submission each. Despite evidence suggesting increased sensitivity and reduced ceiling
A574
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
effects associated with EQ-5D-5L, this measure is still not a key requirement for costeffectiveness modeling in selected HTA submissions. Conclusions: EQ-5D-3L has
the potential to distort the true cost-effectiveness in conditions that are insensitive to the measure. Awareness and requirements for the use of EQ-5D-5L should
increase amongst manufacturers and HTA bodies to ensure submissions present
accurate cost-effectiveness models. Further research into the evaluation of costeffectiveness results between these two measures following the introduction of
validated independent value sets for EQ-5D-5L is encouraged.
PRM173
Modification of Patient Reported Outcomes Measures of
Compliance, Gastrointestinal Symptoms, Palatability and
Treatment Satisfaction for Patients Needing Iron
Chelation therapy
Lasch K 1, Côté I 2, Roma T 2, Srivastava B 2, Horodniceanu E G 3, Dhatt H 3, Carter J A 3, Bal V 2
International, Cambridge, NJ, USA, 2Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation, East
Hanover, NJ, USA, 3Pharmerit International, Bethesda, MD, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Pharmerit
Objectives: In patients requiring frequent blood transfusions due to transfusion
dependent anemia (TDA) (e.g., sickle cell disease [SCD]) and myelodysplastic syndrome (MDS), life expectancy is directly related to the quality of chelation therapy,
and poor adherence to treatment increases the risk of complications and shortens
survival1. Improved palatability ratings and gastrointestinal (GI) tolerability could
have positive impacts on adherence with iron chelation therapy (ICT) 2. Therefore,
patient-reported outcomes (PROs) measuring compliance, GI symptoms, and palatability were developed and the Satisfaction with Iron Chelation Therapy (SICT)
questionnaire was modified, as electronic PROs (ePROs) specific to a new formulation of ICT. Methods: Eleven patients with TDA or MDS provided informed consent and were included in this qualitative study. Two sets of face-to-face cognitive
interviews were conducted iteratively; modifications to items were debriefed in the
second set. Interviews began open-endedly to elicit patients’ spontaneous experiences with ICT. Interviews were audio recorded and transcribed. An item tracking
matrix documented the changes made for each item. Data analysis used ATLAS. ti
software. This study was conducted according to best practices for development3
and modification4 of PROs in an ePRO format. Results: Patients were 73% (n= 8)
male and 27% (n= 3) female with a mean age of 43 (range 14-81 years); 45% (n= 5) had
SCD, and 27% (n= 3) had MDS. Patient spontaneous reports and cognitive debriefing
responses confirmed concepts in the draft PROs and helped eliminate irrelevant
items. Changes made after cognitive debriefing ensured the comprehensibility, lack
of redundancy, and appropriate instructions and response options. The resultant
PROs included the Compliance (2 items), GI Symptom Diary (6 items), Palatability (4
items), and modified SICT (13 items). Conclusions: Results support the content
validity of PRO measures of compliance, GI symptoms, palatability, and satisfaction
with ICT. These measures require psychometric validation of validity, reliability, and
responsiveness before recommending their use in future clinical research.
PRM174
The Importance of Migration Assessments: Ecoa Translations and
Linguistic Validation
Sweeney E , Kelley T
TransPerfect, New York, NY, USA
.
.
Objectives: As the use of clinical outcomes assessments (COAs) in global studies
continues to increase, early collaboration between eCOA and linguistic validation
providers becomes critical to the success of global initiatives. Early involvement
of a linguistic validation partner in the eCOA migration process offers insight into
migration issues that may not be present in the English version of the instrument,
but if not identified, can lead to study delays as well as increased costs for the sponsor. Methods: An examination was conducted of previous linguistic validation
projects that included either newly developed eCOA instruments or pen/paper to
eCOA migration. A comparison of various eCOA platforms, the corresponding issues,
and details relating to migration solutions were assessed. Results: Frequently, a
line of text that is present in an eCOA platform (proprietary software, Excel, etc.)
is coded such that it populates into the eCOA device in multiple locations. These
segments are sometimes referred to as “computed text” and are commonly used
for response options that repeat for multiple items of a questionnaire. While this
may work adequately in English, many languages require a variance in the translation used based on the context of the item and/or response choice. While a pen/
paper version may allow for these variances, the initial eCOA programming may
not. The variance is only determined further into the linguistic validation process
and presents challenges if the device requires re-programming. Conclusions: A
migration assessment, separate from equivalency testing, allows for the eCOA and
linguistic validation providers to assess the initial setup of the eCOA software. This
assessment can determine whether system modifications are necessary to allow
for the translations to properly be mapped and displayed. This additional step will
also prevent study delays as well as quality issues as it allows issues to be addressed
early and avoid later difficulties.
feedback on a 4 point scale for applicability, comprehensibility and appropriateness
of the response options of each item. They were also encouraged to leave free-text
feedback. Results: A total of 218 subjects provided feedback, 61.47% female. Mean
age was 55.78 years, with patients from 18-80 years, 40.37% between 55-65 years.
The most represented conditions were Parkinson’s (27), Fibromyalgia (23), Multiple
Sclerosis (20) and Rheumatoid Arthritis (19). The mean number of quantitative
assessments per item was 55.74, while the mean number of comments was 11.64.
Considering a cut-off of 2 points in the 0-3 scale, 18 items had low applicability,
just one item had low comprehensibility and all items had appropriate response
options. Conclusions: An impressive amount of feedback was obtained in just
a week using the Open Research Exchange platform. The lowest scores were in
applicability. However, as the items are destined to an adaptive test, some of them
are very extreme (destined to severe cases). Therefore applicability was considered
a secondary concern. With this caveat, quantitative feedback was very positive, and
added to the great amount and detail of qualitative feedback suggest some changes
that we think will greatly improve the instrument.
PRM176
Quality of Life in Patients Undergoing Hemodialysis: A Vision of the
Influence of Time
Maia R C F 1, Monteiro W M S 1, Silva M G C 2, Almeida R F C 1
1Secretaria de Saúde do Estado do Ceará, FORTALEZA, Brazil, 2UECE, Fortaleza, Brazil
.
.
.
Castejón N 1, Harrington M 2, Campillo-Álvarez Á 1, Rebollo P 1
1LASER ANALYTICA, Oviedo, Spain, 2PatientsLikeMe, Cambridge, MA, USA
.
.
.
.
Objectives: CAT-Health is a generic health related quality of life computer adaptive
test developed and validated in Spain. Based on its 96 item pool, a new instrument
is being developed in English. The objective of the present study was to obtain
substantial feedback from patients on the items, through Open Research Exchange
platform, that centralizes PROM research and is integrated with PatientsLikeMe,
an online community. Methods: The item pool was split in four sets of 24 items
each. 750 patients with various conditions received an e-mail that included link
to a survey open for 7 days. They were asked to answer one of the sets and give
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To measure and compare the quality of life in patients undergoing
hemodialysis with respect to time. Methods: An observational, prospective study
conducted in 2012/2013 consisting of 50 patients with Terminal Chronic Kidney
Disease, undergoing HD in a public clinical care within the metropolitan area of
Fortaleza. We used the KDQOL instrument early in therapy and one year after its
beginning in order to observe changes in quality of life over time. Statistical analysis included frequency distribution and measures of central tendency. Results:
The general dimensions of this instrument indicate that the dimensions “physical
function”, “social function” and “emotional function” had the lowest scores early
in therapy. It is observed that these same dimensions showed significant improvements in patients after one year of HD. Only “general health” was not significant.
At baseline, specific dimensions of the instrument as “professional role”, “sexual
function” and “disease overload” have the lowest scores and remain the same after
one year of the begin of therapy, showing that the time difference has no statistical
significance. Conclusions: The quality of life of patients undergoing hemodialysis
after a year of therapy is superior to the quality of life showed at the beginning of
treatment although this difference is not statistically significant. It is important
to search for alternatives that can positively influence the quality of life of these
patients.
PRM177
Methods Used To Measure Patient Preferences In Psoriasis
Treatments – An Overview With Regards To The German Iqwig
And G-Ba
Gutknecht M , Herrlein O , Augustin M
University Medical Center Hamburg-Eppendorf, Hamburg, Germany
.
.
.
Objectives: According to the methodology of the German Institute for Quality
and Efficiency in Healthcare (IQWiG), the benefit assessment of a new treatment
intervention refers to patient-reported outcomes exclusively. Given the existence of
different patient-relevant outcomes the Federal Joint Committee (G-BA) can engage
the IQWiG to aggregate these to one comprehensive benefit measurement. So far,
the IQWiG uses no standardized method for this. In its current method paper, among
the benefit QALY, the IQWiG refers to methods of multi-criteria decision making
or preference evaluation like analytic hierarchy process and conjoint analysis. For
psoriasis, one of the most frequent chronic skin diseases worldwide, a variety of
treatment interventions is available. In the light of recent discussions, the objective
was to give an overview of methods which have been used to date to prioritize and
weight patient-relevant outcomes in psoriasis treatment. Methods: The present
review is based on a systematic literature research until 31 December 2013 in the
databases PubMed, Embase, Ovid Medliner, Cochrane Library, EconLit and CINAHL
using the keywords “psoriasis” and “preferences”. Results: The search resulted in
288 hits without duplicates. 16 articles met the predefined inclusion criteria. In addition to methods to calculate QALY like time-trade off and standard gamble, conjoint
analysis, willingness-to-pay and other preference methods were used. In view of the
method paper of IQWiG, no study exists in the field of psoriasis where the analytic
hierarchy process was used. Conclusions: The results of the presented review
show, that the analytic hierarchy process was not used in psoriasis studies, so far.
The use of this method in future studies might provide new essential knowledge
in the evaluation of patient preferences in psoriasis treatment.
PRM178
Impact of Osteoporotic Fractures on Quality of Life – Design of A
Mapping Study of Qualiost To Eq-5d
Hansen L 1, Vestergaard P 1, Petersen K D 2
University, Aalborg East, Denmark, 2Aalborg University, Aalborg, Denmark
.
PRM175
Patient Driven Questionnaire Development, Item Feedback from
Users of A Patient Network
.
.
.
.
1Aalborg
Objectives: The QUALIOST (quality in life questionnaire in osteoporosis) is one of
the most commonly used osteoporosis-specific health-related quality of life (HRQoL)
questionnaires and it is often used in clinical studies to document the longitudinal
impact of osteoporosis and related fractures. It is unknown whether the QUALIOST is
better at estimating HRQoL for osteoporotic fracture patients compared to the commonly used EQ-5D questionnaire. Preference scores have not yet been developed for
the QUALIOST and, thus, cost-utility analyses are difficult to perform. The purpose of
the present paper is to describe the first steps of a future study on mapping from the
QUALIOST to the EQ-5D questionnaire. Methods: A questionnaire, containing both
EQ-5D-5L and QUALIOST, is distributed to patients in an orthopaedic outpatient clinic
in Denmark and the aim is to include 150 patients. Patients above 50 years of age and
with a recent fracture (less than 2 weeks old) are invited to participate in the study.
A575
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
The patients are asked to complete the questionnaire at initial contact with the outpatient clinic and at four follow-up time points; one week, and one, three, and twelve
months post-fracture). The last inclusion date will be December 31st2014. Results:
The hypothesis is that the QUALIOST will provide a better estimate of the impact
of osteoporosis-related fractures on HRQoL as it contains disease-relevant aspects,
which may not be sufficiently covered in the generic EQ-5D-5L questionnaire. We will
develop a mapping algorithm to predict EQ-5D derived utilities for Danish fracture
patients from the QUALIOST, which can be used in future studies, where utilities then
may be estimated from QUALIOST results. Conclusions: Mapping from QUALIOST
scores to EQ-5D-5L derived utilities will enable estimation of preference-based HRQoL
utilities for patients with osteoporotic fractures.
PRM179
Review of Patient-Reported Outcomes in Diabetic Macular Edema
Ishii K , Narimatsu A , Adachi K
Bayer Yakuhin, Ltd., Tokyo, Japan
.
.
.
Objectives: Diabetic macular edema (DME) is a serious condition occurring in
patients with diabetic retinopathy (DR) which is a common complication of diabetes.
Understanding not only objective measurements such as visual acuity, but also the
patients’ perspective is important in gaining a comprehensive understanding of
the impact of DME and its treatment on their functioning and well-being. The aim
of this study is to understand possible measurements to investigate the impact of
DME on health-related quality of life (HRQoL), by identifying currently available
measurements, their ability to differentiate between DR and DME, and possible
reasons for difficulties in measuring HRQoL specifically for DME. Methods: We
performed a literature review on articles describing instruments of patient-reported
outcomes (PRO) for DME. We summarized the current evidence on the usefulness of
the instruments and whether they differentiate between DR and DME. In addition,
we investigated possible hurdles in measuring HRQoL for DME, given the clinical
understandings of the systemic aspects of DME. Results: We identified seven condition-specific or vision-specific measurements and seven general measurements
including generic HRQoL and utilities for possible instruments for DME. However,
realistic use for DME appears questionable even for vision-related measurements.
The possible reasons could be that: 1) DME is not the primary disease, 2) many of
DME patients have comorbidities such as DR, cataracts, and DR-induced glaucoma,
and 3) those comorbidities itself may lead to decreased visual acuity with decreased
HRQoL. Conclusions: Evidence is limited when measuring the impacts of DME
on diabetic patients largely due to the lack of an effective PRO instrument for DME.
The major difficulties in developing such instruments is that DME patients have
complex health statuses, which provides for multiple reasons in decrease of QoL
which may not be directly due to their DME.
PRM180
Development of the Behavior Rating Inventory of Executive
Function - Preschool Version (Brief-P) in 10 Languages
Vasarri S 1, Isquith P K 2
.
.
.
1Mapi, Lyon, France, 2Dartmouth
University, Norwich, VT, USA
Objectives: The Behavior Rating Inventory of Executive Function Preschool Version
(BRIEF-P) was designed to provide a better understanding of preschool children’s selfcontrol and problem-solving skills. It is composed of 63 items organized in five clinical
scales which measure five aspects of executive functioning (Inhibit, Shift, Emotional
Control, Working Memory, Plan/Organize). It is used to evaluate children aged 2-5 years
old with a wide spectrum of developmental and acquired neurological conditions, such
as learning disabilities, Tourette’s disorder, traumatic brain injury, attention-deficit/
hyperactivity disorder or pervasive developmental disorders/autism. The objective of
this study was to develop the BRIEF-P in 10 languages (Afrikaans, Bulgarian, Estonian,
Greek, Japanese, Lithuanian, Romanian, Serbian, Slovak, Ukrainian). Methods: The
following methodology was used: (1) Clarification of concepts with the developers; (2)
Forward and backward translation steps in each target country. Results: The translation process did not reveal any cultural issues since most of the concepts assessed
were cross-culturally relevant. The main difficulties consisted in finding conceptual
equivalents of the original items with strong idiomatic content or containing words
pertaining to the same semantic field. For instance, the most problematic items were
items 10, 23 and 50. Item 23 (Is fidgety, restless, or squirmy) raised difficulties since it was
not always possible to find direct equivalents for all adjectives in all languages. As
for item 50 [Acts overwhelmed or overstimulated in crowded, busy situations (such as lots of
noise, activity, or people)], discussions focused on how to convey the differences between
“overwhelmed” and “overstimulated”, as well as between “busy” and “crowded.”
In all cases, issues were solved with repeated discussions with the developers. Conclusions: The cross-cultural adaptation of the BRIEF-P into 10 languages
required an international collaboration. The involvement of the developers during
the whole process enabled the production of conceptually equivalent and culturally
appropriate measures.
PRM181
Challenges In Recruiting Patients For The Linguistic Validation Of
Pro Instruments Developed For Rare Diseases: A Case Study With
Alagille Syndrome
Kennedy C 1, Abetz-Webb L 2, Lambe J 3
1Lumena, San Diego, CA, USA, 2Patient-Centred Outcomes Assessments LTD, Macclesfield,
Cheshire, UK, 3Mapi, Lyon, France
.
.
.
Objectives: Observer and Patient Itch-reported Outcome Instruments (ItchRO)
are electronic morning and evening diaries developed in US English to assess itchrelated symptom severity (rubbing, scratching, skin damage, sleep disturbances or
irritability) in pediatric patients suffering from rare cholestatic liver diseases such
as Alagille Syndrome (ALGS). Itching is a key symptom in ALGS and significantly
impacts on a child’s daily life. This research presents the recruitment challenges
faced during the linguistic validation of the ItchRO into French, German, Polish and
Spanish in ALGS patients. Methods: Native translators performed two forward and
two back translations of the English ItchRO. Cognitive interviews with five children
with ALGS (patient report) and five parents (observer report) were to be performed.
Key inclusion criteria were: children aged 5-9 years with cholestatic liver disease
(ALGS) or progressive familial intrahepatic cholestasis (PFIC), who were also experiencing itching. Results: Recruitment was challenging and threatened to delay
the clinical trial programme. Thus, recruitment was extended to include children
who were 3-17 years of age, and in Spain and Germany, patients with alternative
pathologies that manifested primarily with generalized pruritus were included. The
final sample included: 15 with ALGS (France n= 5; Poland n= 5; Germany n= 3; Spain
n= 2), 2 with PFIC (Spain), 2 with atopic dermatitis (Germany) and 1 with contact
dermatitis (Spain). The ItchRO translations were well understood; there were no
apparent differences in translation interpretations by disease state. Conclusions:
Recruitment in linguistic validation projects in rare diseases can be a hurdle, yet
patient understanding, rather than those of ‘lay people, ’ is preferable in paediatrics
to ensure adequate interpretation, which can vary substantially across children. As a
result patients with similar symptom and impact characteristics could be recruited
if recruiting the primary population is likely to delay clinical trial research in rare
diseases, where there is an urgent need for treatment.
PRM182
Responsiveness and Minimal Clinically Important Difference of A
Specific Health Related Quality of Life (Hrqol) Questionnaire for
Home Enteral Nutrition (Hen) Patients: Nutriqol® Questionnaire
Cuerda C 1, Virgili N 2, Irles J A 3, Cuesta F 4, Apezetxea A 5, Casanueva F 6, Carrillo L 7,
Layola M 8, Lizán L 9
1Hospital Universitario Gregorio Marañón, Madrid, Spain, 2Hospital Bellvitge, Barcelona, Spain,
3Hospital Universitario Nuestra Señora de Valme, Sevilla, Spain, 4Hospital San Carlos, Madrid,
Spain, 5Hospital Basurto, Bilbao, Spain, 6Hospital Universitario Santiago de Compostela, Santiago
de Compostela, Spain, 7Centro de Salud Victoria de Acentejo, Santa Cruz de Tenerife, Spain,
8Nestle health science, Barcelona, Spain, 9Outcomes’10, Castellon, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To determine NutriQoL® responsiveness and minimal clinically important difference (MCID) in patients receiving HEN. Methods: NutriQoL®, a specific
questionnaire, developed and validated in Spain, for the assessment of HRQoL in
patients receiving HEN regardless of the underlying condition was administered
to a prospective cohort from 4 Spanish hospitals. It includes 17 pairs of items of
HEN-related HRQoL, scoring from -51 (worst HRQoL) to 51 (best HRQoL). NutriQoL®
was completed three times within 1-month (±15 days) intervals (visit 1/visit 2/visit
3). Responsiveness was assessed by estimating the effect size and the standardized response mean between visits 1 and 3. For MCID calculation an anchor-based
approach was performed. Interquartile range of the change in NutriQoL® from
patients, who reported changes in their health-status (worse or better) between
visits 2 and 3, was used. Results: A total of 86 subjects who presented clinical
changes between visits [63% male; mean (SD) age 61 (13)] participated. Cancer was
the main diagnosis leading to HEN prescription (66.3%). NutriQoL® scores were 16.98
(14.57), 16.63 (14.86) and 18.92 (15.25) for visit 1, 2 and 3, respectively. Up to 78.79% of
patients reported improvements in their HRQoL since the introduction of HEN. The
estimated effect size and the standardized mean response between visit 1 and 3
were 0.23 and 0.24. Regarding MCID, NutriQoL® total scores difference between visit
2 and 3 in those patients that perceived changes in their health status was between
-3.75 and 4.25 (interquartile range). Conclusions: NutriQoL® responsiveness is
moderate. This may be due to the limited temporal period between visits since most
of patients referred improvements in their condition. A difference of ±4 points on
NutriQoL® total score regarding a previous administration demonstrates a clinical
change that affects patients HRQoL.
PRM183
Measuring Change in Quality of Life: Can We Distinguish Recall Bias
and Scale Recalibration?
Blome C , Augustin M
University Medical Center Hamburg-Eppendorf, Hamburg, Germany
.
.
Objectives: Treatment effects on health-related quality of life (QoL) often differ
depending on whether they are measured prospectively (before and after treatment)
or retrospectively (after treatment only). It is not clear which of either evaluations is
more valid: Prospective evaluations may be biased by scale recalibration (a changed
understanding of the response scale), and retrospective evaluations may be biased
by recall bias (a wrong assessment of former QoL). Methods: Based on an analysis of literature, we present an overview on (a) possible biases in prospective and
retrospective measurement of QoL, (b) how these biases are named and defined in
literature, and (c) current approaches to distinguish scale recalibration and recall
bias. Results: The definitions of different biases are inconsistent. Many authors
do not clearly distinguish measurement bias from true change. Furthermore, some
consider only scale recalibration or only recall bias. There are different approaches
for distinguishing scale recalibration and recall bias. We argue that these make too
extensive assumptions to be valid. Conclusions: Much of the current discussion
on the validity of prospective and retrospective QoL measurement suffers from
unclear definitions, especially of “response shift” and “recall bias”, or from neglecting one of the possible biases. We suggest more elaborate definitions for different
types of bias, and recommend taking both kinds of bias into consideration when
measuring change in QoL. Due to a lack of valid methods, there is not enough evidence on the extent of these biases yet; therefore the best approach for outcomes
studies might be to include both prospective and retrospective assessments. In the
long run, valid methods need to be developed to determine the most valid method
of QoL assessment.
PRM184
Methods To Elicit Patient Preferences: A Case Study In Metastatic
Breast Cancer
Copher R 1, DiBonaventura M 2, Basurto E 2, Faria C 1, Lorenzo R 2
1Eisai, Inc., Woodcliff Lake, NJ, USA, 2Kantar Health, New York, NY, USA
.
.
.
.
.
A576
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: Patient preferences have implications for treatment decision making, treatment adherence and follow-up care. This study aimed to highlight, using
metastatic breast cancer (mBC) as an example, a method to elicit preferences and, of
particular novelty, examine individual differences of those preferences. Methods:
Using mixed methods, a qualitative study (n= 10) of patients with mBC informed
the development of the preference survey (a cross-sectional Internet survey administered to women with mBC). Survey participants (N= 181) completed a conjoint
exercise that included a series of choice questions. Each choice question included a
pair of hypothetical treatments that were presented in terms of eight safety attributes, single attributes for effectiveness, dosing regimen, and quality of life. Survey
choice data were analyzed using hierarchical Bayesian logistic regression models.
Predicted values from this model were then analyzed to understand individual
differences in patient preference. Results: Qualitative interviews identified the
most relevant side effects to include in the choice task (e.g., alopecia, nausea/vomiting, etc.) and reinforced the importance of quality of life when making treatment
decisions. In the survey data, treatment effectiveness was most strongly associated
with treatment preference, followed by alopecia, fatigue, neutropenia, and quality
of life. Predicted values from the choice model enabled preference comparisons
across treatment experience subgroups (e.g., 6+ rounds of chemotherapy vs. less).
Preference strength for individual attributes, e.g., side effects was correlated with
various demographic and health history variables, though only modest associations
were detected (Pearson rs< 0.25). Conclusions: Understanding patient preferences provides opportunities for improved care and outcomes. Combining qualitative and quantitative methods in this study allowed for specificity of preferences
and generalizability (albeit limited). Patient preferences derived across the sample
informed predicted values from the choice models that can also be used for comparing preferences across subsamples and identifying factors that may be associated
with certain preferences.
RESEARCH on Methods – Statistical Methods
PRM186
Real-World VersUS Randomised Controlled Trial Data: A Case
Study On The Cost-Effectiveness Of Laparoscopic Surgery For
Chronic Reflux
Faria R , Liu S , Epstein D , Manca A
University of York, York, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Real-world (observational) data has the potential to address the limitations of randomised controlled trials (RCTs) but presents its own challenges given
the increased risk of bias. We compared the costs and quality-adjusted life years
(QALYs) of patients following random vs preference-based allocation and assessed
the performance of different methods to address these challenges. Methods: The
REFLUX study was a pragmatic trial in patients with chronic reflux comparing laparoscopic fundoplication (surgery) with medical management (MM) over 5 years of
follow-up. The trial included randomised and non-randomised preference-based
allocation. We compared the cost-effectiveness of surgery in the RCT vs preference
cohorts as unadjusted raw differences, applying methods to handle biases from
selection and confounding (regression adjustment, propensity score matching and
instrument variable analysis) and explored the impact of receiving the preferred
treatment on the results. Results: The preference surgery group accrued greater
costs and QALYs than the randomised surgery group (£3,524 vs £2,852; 3.723 vs
3.612 QALYs). The preference MM group had lower costs but slightly better QALYs
than the randomised MM group (£861 vs £1,415; 3.541 vs 3.411 QALYs). The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) for the preference cohorts was similar to
that obtained in the RCT using the different methods at around £8,000 per QALY
gained (vs £7,149 in the RCT and £14,632 unadjusted raw differences). Receiving the
preferred treatment was significantly associated with lower costs and better QALYs
after adjusting for prognostic variables. Conclusions: Real-word data can be used
in cost-effectiveness analysis to complement RCT evidence. However, more research
is needed on how to choose the most appropriate method to adjust for selection
bias and how to account for patient preferences when making recommendations
on value for money.
PRM187
Integrating Health Psychometrics With Health Economics: Can the
‘Mapping’ Toolbox Be Extended Using Ordinal Structural Equation
Models?
Patton T , Manca A
University of York, York, UK
.
.
Objectives: Mapping enables the prediction of health-state utility values via health
outcome measures in trial data using algorithms linking those measures available
to preference-based measures (PBMs). However, the unusual distributional features
of PBMs mean that there is no consensus around the most appropriate statistical
methodology for obtaining mapping algorithms. Existing studies have shown that
structural equation modelling (SEM) developments open up a range of opportunities
for effectively analysing PBMs. This study draws upon some of the methodological
advances around SEMs from other fields in a case study. Progress towards developing a mapping algorithm for prediction of EQ-5D scores using a disease-specific
measure, the Seattle Angina Questionnaire (SAQ), is discussed. Methods: EQ-5D
and SAQ data were obtained from a completed RCT, the RITA-3 trial. Several psychometric analysis approaches were considered to decide which subscales and items of
the SAQ were likely to be relevant to the model. Several SEMs were specified and the
first looked at the EQ-5D index values and SAQ subscales as continuous responses in
a linear regression model. External information about the reliability of the diseasespecific measure was incorporated into this model. The subsequent models looked
at the specification of outcomes at the item level with an ordinal logistic approach.
Models were compared in terms of their ability to fit the observed data and their
predictive performance. Results: Only three of the five subscales of the SAQ were
selected for the development of mapping algorithms. The linear regression model
had best model fit. However, the SEM that incorporated item level data for ordinal
responses to each instrument showed better predictive performance, especially at
the lower end of the EQ-5D distribution. Conclusions: This study demonstrates
the flexibility of SEMs for the development of mapping algorithms. The models
developed showed comparable predictive performance to existing models in the
published literature.
PRM188
Evaluation of Methods for the Inclusion of Real World Evidence in
Network Meta-Analysis – A Case Study in Multiple Sclerosis
Jenkins D 1, Czachorowski M 2, Bujkiewicz S 1, Dequen P 1, Jonsson P 2, Abrams K R 1
1University of Leicester, Leicester, UK, 2National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE),
Manchester, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Network Meta-Analysis (NMA) is becoming a key component of submissions to reimbursement agencies world-wide, especially when there is limited
head-to-head evidence for multiple technologies. However, almost all NMAs only
consider Randomised Controlled Trials (RCTs) even though there may be considerable Real World Evidence (RWE) available – for example observational studies
or registry-based studies. Evaluation of methods to enable the inclusion of RWE,
especially in the light of the changing nature of RCTs from both a regulatory and
reimbursement perspective, is considered here. Methods: RCTs and RWE studies were searched for using standard filters and databases up to, and including,
the regulatory approval of Fingolimod by the European Medicines Agency (EMA) in
2011 for Multiple Sclerosis (MS). A number of NMAs were then conducted and which
included; only RCTs, both RCTs and RWE (accepted at face-value), both RCTs and
RWE but including an additional level in the NMA hierarchical model to represent
the different study designs, and finally both RCTs and RWE but adjusting the RWE
for potential biases. Results: Identification of RWE in addition to RCTs in this
MS example significantly increased the number of studies (and comparisons) that
were potentially included in the NMA. Whilst the inclusion of the additional RWE
led to a reduction in the level of uncertainty surrounding most effect estimates,
this depended on the method of inclusion adopted for the RWE, and the extent to
which biases were adjusted for. Conclusions: This initial evaluation of methods
for the inclusion of RWE in NMAs indicates that methods of adjustment for the
potential biases in RWE can have a significant impact on the level of uncertainty.
Consequently further work investigating both empirical evidence for such biases
and methods of elicitation from experts on the extent of biases associated with
individual RWE studies is warranted.
PRM189
Frequentist Approach for Detecting Heterogeneity in MetaAnalysis Pair-Wise Comparisons: Enhanced Q-Test Use By Using I2
and H2 Statistics
Laliman V 1, Roïz J 2
1Ensai, Bruz, France, 2Creativ-Ceutical, London, UK
.
.
Objectives: In meta-analysis, model selection is an important criterion which
needs to be tested and validated by strong statistical evidence. The Cohran’s Q-test
allows in theory to decide between random-effect and fixed-effect models. Due
to the highly conservative nature of this test, three statistics have been built to
estimate the heterogeneity between studies to lead the model decision: the I2, the
H2 and the R2. We conducted a review of the Q-test utility in diverse scenarios with
a comparison of three different methods to estimate the heterogeneity between
studies. Methods: Based on the global formulation of the Cochran’s Q-test, we
proposed to analyse jointly the first error species and the second error species in
different scenarios based on the number of studies included in each meta-analysis.
The goal was to determine the reliability of the Q-test in extreme situations but also
to give some benchmark for the reliability of this test. We use simulation methods
to analyse the three different methods for calculating the between-study variance
compared to the real value of heterogeneity. We also compared different arbitrary
levels for model selection using these statistics in different scenarios. Results: The
Cochran’s Q-test is too conservative with a large number of studies and concludes to
the presence of heterogeneity whatever the situation is when the number of studies
is higher than 18. In comparison, the different statistics have an average value conversely linked with the number of studies in case of non-heterogeneity: the higher
the number of studies, the lower the statistics’ average values. Conclusions: The
I2 and H2statistics can eventually enhance the use of Cochran’s Q-test by solving
conservative issue associated with this test. The model selection can, eventually, be
led by benchmark of these statistics jointly with the Cochran’s Q-test.
PRM190
The Use and Acceptance of Novel Statistical Analyses To Support
Technology Submissions To Hta Authorities
Batson S , Mitchell S A , King D
Abacus International, Bicester, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Indirect comparisons are increasingly accepted to model the clinical- and cost-effectiveness of treatments. The purpose of this study was to (i)
assess the literature reporting on the use of novel statistical methods [simulated
treatment comparison (STC), and matching-adjusted indirect comparison (MAIC)];
and (ii) assess technology appraisals (TAs) submitted to the National Institute of
Health and Carel Excellence (NICE) to determine whether these techniques have
been accepted by reimbursement authorities. Methods: Embase, Medline and
the Cochrane Library were interrogated to identify publications reporting on the
use of MAIC or STC. NICE TAs published from 2011-2014 which reported MAIC or
STC analyses were identified and the critique by the appraisal group was summarised. Results: Six publications reported on the use of MAIC in six indications.
Results from these analyses concluded that MAIC offered several advantages over
conventional meta-analysis methods that rely on aggregate data. Findings from the
review of NICE TAs indicated that these novel statistical techniques have not been
A577
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
widely used in manufacturers’ submissions to date. Of the most recent 60 NICE
TAs, analyses employing MAIC methodology have been presented in two submissions and a STC analysis in a single HTA, all in the oncology setting. In all cases
the review group identified limitations with the statistical methodology presented,
although their use as exploratory analyses supporting results from conventional
meta-analyses was highlighted in one submission. In particular the use of nonrandomised data from single treatment arms was highlighted as a potential weakness of STC. Conclusions: In spite of the increasing published evidence base
reporting on MAIC in a range of indications, both MAIC and STC have not been
widely used in manufacturer’s submission to NICE. Assessment bodies critiquing
the technology submissions remain to be convinced of the appropriateness of these
novel techniques for the robust assessment of relative efficacy.
PRM191
Meta-Analysis in Open Bugs: How To Assess the Convergence of
Mcmc Chain?
Laliman V 1, Roïz J 2
1Ensai, Bruz, France, 2Creativ-Ceutical, London, UK
.
.
Objectives: Meta-analysis is often conducted in OpenBUGS. This software, like
all BUGS projects, is based on MCMC simulations by using Gibbs sampling. One
of the main issues in the use of Markov chains in a continuous space is the chain
convergence. If the chain does not converge, transient states will be accounted for
in our posterior distributions. Since these states are not bound to the empirical data
but only with the chain’s starting point, the estimated parameters of the posterior
distribution will be biased. To help assessing the convergence of MCMC chain, several methods exist. Methods: Based on the literature, we run several simulation
scenarios in order to test built-in OpenBUGS graphical methods and to assess the
power of the “thin” approach, a fixed-step jumping-data method, for convergence.
Then, we focus on the existing diagnoses, their supplementary assumptions and
their associated computation costs. To help perform these diagnoses directly on
BUGS objects, we present the R-package coda. Results: The use of jumping-data
method leads to loss of power and a poorer estimation of posterior distribution
even in case of high autocorrelation. Consequently, the use of the thin method is
not recommended to obtain a quicker convergence and better posterior distribution
estimation. We have also seen that although autocorrelogram and trace can be useful to assess convergence, they can lead to misinterpretation in case of extremely
low number of studies and conclude to convergence. Alternatively, using the Geweke
diagnosis seems, in terms of computation cost and assumptions, recommended for
two main advantages: it gives a measure of trust of being in a stationary process and
very low computation cost. Conclusions: We presented methods to assess convergence of MCMC chains and argued on their pros and cons. The Geweke diagnose
was found to provide best trade-off between computational cost and interpretability.
PRM192
Adjusting for Treatment Crossover in A Trametinib Metastatic
Melanoma Rct: Identifying the Appropriate Method
Bell H 1, Latimer N 1, Amonkar M 2, Casey M 2
of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK, 2GlaxoSmithKline, Collegeville, PA, USA
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: Treatment crossover refers to the situation in randomised controlled
trials (RCTs) where patients randomised to the control group switch onto the experimental treatment. This leads to biased estimates of treatment effects if not appropriately controlled for. Several crossover adjustment methods are available, but
previous research has shown that the optimal adjustment method depends upon
the characteristics of the trial. This study applies crossover adjustment methods
to an RCT comparing trametinib to chemotherapy in patients with BRAF V600E/K
mutation-positive advanced or metastatic melanoma (NCT01245062), and investigates which adjustment method best fits this case study. Methods: The crossover
adjustment methods applied include the Rank Preserving Structural Failure Time
Model (RPSFTM), Iterative Parameter Estimation (IPE) algorithm, Inverse Probability
of Censoring Weights (IPCW) and a two-stage accelerated failure time model estimation procedure. Suitability of each method is compared by assessing the plausibility of the underlying assumptions of the models in this case study and analysing
output and performance indicators associated with each method. Results: In the
primary efficacy population (patients without history of brain metastases) 67.4% of
chemotherapy patients switched onto trametinib. The intention to treat (ITT) hazard
ratio (HR) for overall survival (OS) was 0.72 (95% CI 0.52-1.01). Point-estimates of
the adjusted HRs produced by the most plausible applications of the RPSFTM, IPE,
IPCW and two-stage methods ranged between 0.43 and 0.49, consistently favouring
trametinib. Results were sensitive to the technique used to apply each method. Key
issues included recensoring, the active nature of the comparator, and the choice of
covariates included in the analyses. Conclusions: Each of the crossover adjustment methods result in a lower HR than the ITT analysis. However, results are
uncertain and sensitive to key assumptions. It is important to carefully analyse trial
characteristics and model output when identifying which applications of adjustment methods are most plausible.
PRM193
Assessing Balance in Baseline Characteristics Using Different
Propensity Adjusted Methods for Bipolar I Mixed Disorder Patients
Initiating Asenapine Versus Other Oral Atypical Antipsychotics
Rouleau A 1, Guiraud-Diawara A 2, Landsman-Blumberg P 3, Lokhandwala T 3, StafkeyMailey D 3, Verpillat P 1
1Lundbeck SAS, Global Epidemiology, Issy-les-Moulineaux, France, 2Lundbeck SAS, Global
Analytics, Issy les Moulineaux, France, 3Xcenda, Palm Harbor, FL, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Asenapine (ASE), an oral Atypical Antipsychotic (AA), was initially used
for more severe bipolar I mixed disorder. Different propensity score (PS) methods
were investigated to achieve balanced baseline characteristics between ASE and
four oral AA cohorts for eventual outcomes analyses. Methods: Adults with ≥ 1
asenapine, aripiprazole, olanzapine, quetiapine, or risperidone prescription fill (Aug
2009 to Dec 2010) and diagnosis of bipolar I mixed disorder (ICD-9-CM: 296.6x) from
MarketScan® claims databases, yielded 230 ASE, 2726 aripiprazole, 984 olanzapine, 3056 quetiapine, and 1623 risperidone patients. PS were derived using logistic
regression models for ASE and each AA with baseline demographic and clinical
characteristics as covariates. PS, inverse probability treatment weight (IPTW: 1/
PS ASE; 1/ (1-PS) AA), and standard mortality ratio weight (SMR: 1 ASE; PS/ (1-PS)
AA) distributions were evaluated. ASE-AA un-weighted, IPTW, and SMR baseline
characteristics were compared using standardized differences, chi-squares, and
t-tests. Results: Un-weighted asenapine patients had pre-index greater bipolar
I episodes rates, psychiatric drug use, dyslipidemia and obesity (all comparators).
PS distributions for asenapine-olanzapine overlapped to some degree while PS of
asenapine and the other comparators overlapped little to not at all. Comparing IPTW
baseline characteristics, asenapine more resembled the AA cohorts. Demographic
imbalance increased between asenapine and each AA. IPTW improved clinical characteristic balance for asenapine versus olanzapine and risperidone, but only slightly
improved imbalance versus aripiprazole and quetiapine. However some clinical
characteristics not previously balanced in the un-weighted analyses for asenapine
versus each AA were now imbalanced. Applying SMR, AA cohorts more resembled
the asenapine cohort and all baseline demographic and clinical characteristics
were finally balanced. Conclusions: SMR, a less common PS method, resulted
in balanced baseline characteristics. SMR should be considered when IPTW leaves
imbalance and the cohort of primary interest differs significantly from the broader
underlying population to which it’s being compared.
PRM194
Task-Based Versus Case-Based Analysis of Time Outcomes in
Multi-Country Time and Motion (T&M) Studies: Methodological
Considerations and Application
De Cock E 1, Kritikou P 2, Tao S 3, Ngoh C A 4
1United BioSource Corporation, Barcelona, Spain, 2United BioSource Corporation, London, UK,
3UBC: An Express Scripts Company, Dorval, QC, Canada, 4F. Hoffmann-La Roche Ltd, Basel,
Switzerland
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: A challenge in multi-centre Time and Motion (T&M) studies is performing inferential statistics, in light of hierarchical data. Our objective was to investigate
two approaches to analyze the data. Methods: Task-based approach analysed
tasks independently, mean times were summed, and 95% confidence intervals
(CIs) were computed based on Variance Sum Law I (assuming time is independent among all tasks). Case-based approach involved imputation for missing time;
all tasks per observation were summed, and a single time variable was analysed.
Both approaches were applied to three countries participating in a multi-country
T&M study comparing intravenous [IV] and subcutaneous [SC] administration
processes. Absolute and relative differences in country means (case-based minus
task-based) and the difference in CI range were computed using a random intercept
model, to account for centre clustering. Results: Mean times were similar for both
approaches. For IV process, absolute (relative) differences in time were -0.03min
(-0.1%) in France, -0.77min (-2.3%) in Italy, and -0.07min (-0.3%) in Russia. For SC
process, results were 0.30min (2.1%) in France, 0.90min (4.5%) in Italy, and 0.01min
(0.1%) in Russia. The differences in CI range between both approaches were noticeable: 0.51min (5%) in France, 25.04min (57%) in Italy, and 10.06min (46%) in Russia for
IV and 4.38min (40%) in France, 0.88min (5%) in Italy, and 8.19min (56%) in Russia for
SC. Conclusions: The choice of task-based or case-based approach did not impact
mean process time; however, since task-based approach assumed independence of
task times, it resulted in much narrower CI range. On the other hand, case-based
approach eliminates the underestimation of variations, thus may therefore be a
more optimal choice to analyse time outcomes for complex processes. With only a
single time variable being analysed, it also allows pooling of data across countries,
therefore providing more power to generate reliable CIs.
PRM195
Graphical Interactive Meta-Analysis Module for Facilitating
Evidence-Based Decision Making in Health Care
Spata E 1, Bujkiewicz S 2
1Leicester University, Leicester, UK, 2University of Leicester, Leicester, UK
.
.
Objectives: In health technology assessment (HTA) decisions about reimbursement of new health technologies are largely based on effectiveness estimates
obtained from pre-prepared meta-analysis of evidence from randomised controlled trials. However, there is not always a consensus amongst the decisionmakers about the inclusion criteria of studies into the meta-analysis. Therefore an
approach that allows stakeholders to manipulate the content of the meta-analysis,
thus facilitating a critical sensitivity analysis in real time during the decisionmaking process, would be valuable from the point of view of the transparency of
the HTA submissions. A Graphical-User-Interface (GUI) was designed to facilitate
such a transparent decision-making process. Methods: The GUI was designed
using freely available software packages which included WinBUGS for development of meta-analysis and meta-regression models and R which was used to
design GUI, to link data with statistical models in WinBUGS and to extract the
results. R was also used to develop graphical tools for presentation of results (forest and bubble plots) and for visual assessment of publication bias (funnel plots).
Software was designed for an illustrative example in rheumatoid arthritis where
effectiveness of TNF-alpha inhibitors was measured on different scales (DAS28, HAQ, ACR, and EULAR). Results: R-based Transparent Interactive Decision
Interrogator (R-TIDI) was developed, which is a user-friendly tool with “point and
click” options that allows users to choose an outcome measure and run randomeffects or fixed-effects meta-analysis and meta-regression models. Users are not
required to have knowledge of statistical software or programming skills since
the use of WinBUGS and R is entirely “behind the scenes”. R-TIDI enables users to
interactively include/exclude studies from the meta-analysis allowing for conducting sensitivity analyses in real time. Conclusions: R-TIDI is a useful tool for
non-statistical decision-makers. It allows users to run sensitivity meta-analyses
A578
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
in a user-friendly environment during a decision-making setting avoiding disadvantages of pre-prepared analyses.
PRM196
An Evaluation and Comparison of Methods Used in Survival
Analysis To Fit Distributional Curves To Kaplan-Meier Data
Haines P
Curo, Marlow, UK
and we show for different scenarios how close the estimates come. For selected
treatment comparisons we present effect-sizes with confidence intervals. We apply
also the Bayesian extension and discuss its advantages. Conclusions: Based on
our research we give recommendations of when the Lumley-method should be best
applied, and discuss limitations.1 Lumley T: Network meta-analysis for indirect
treatment comparisons. Stat. Med. 2002; 21: 2313-2324.
.
Objectives: HTA bodies increasingly require accurate survival estimates in order to
provide reliable recommendations. It is argued that access to individual patient data
(IPD) can improve their accuracy. This paper aims to assess to what degree extracting IPD from published Kaplan-Meier curves helps improve extrapolated survival
estimates. Some methods currently used for HTA submissions fit a survival curve
directly to a published Kaplan-Meier curve, but does this lack accuracy? Methods:
Two methods used to extract the IPD from Kaplan-Meier curves reviewed in this
paper are by Guyot et al (Guyot, Ades, Ouwens, & Welton, 2012) and Hoyle and
Henley (Hoyle & Henley, 2011) which were compared against the outcomes of the
standard ‘least squares’ method. Comparisons were made for two situations: 1)
when numbers at risk are available at different time points throughout the KaplanMeier curve and 2) when numbers at risk are only available at the start. Results:
The three methods resulted in the long-normal distribution showing the best fit,
with all containing the true mean and median within their confidence intervals.
However, the Hoyle and Henley method estimates a mean marginally closer to the
true mean than the other methods in both situations. When many numbers at risk
are provided, the Hoyle and Henley method gives narrower confidence intervals.
Both extraction methods slightly outperformed the least squares method. The three
methods give median estimates and resulting confidence intervals which are statistically equivalent to that of the IPD, except for the Guyot method when numbers at
risk are not available. Conclusions: In conclusion, extraction methods can give
marginally better results than the Least Squares method. However, these results
may not be applicable to other examples. In addition, the extra time taken to run
extraction methods could be too large to account for the small improvement in
accuracy of results.
PRM197
Multi-Level Network Meta-Analysis To Account for Dose-Response
and Class Effects
Reason T 1, Dias S 2, Welton N 2
Health, London, UK, 2University of Bristol, Bristol, UK
.
.
Iakovlieva L , Kyrychenko O , Gerasymovà O , Kuznetsov I
National University of Pharmacy, Kharkiv, Ukraine
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Evaluation and comparison of oral antidiabetic drugs (OAD) consumption at state level are an important element at control of 2ndtype DM patients treatment quality. The objective of the study is to determine the volumes and structure
of OAD consumption in Ukraine and to compare it with consumption in the other
countries. Methods: ATC/DDD-methodology with application of DDD/1000/day
(DID). The evaluation is based on consumption volume, provided by “PharmXplorer/
Pharmstandard” analytical system of market research. Results: In year 2008, OAD
consumption in Ukraine was 5.78 DID and increased to 11.13 DID in year 2013. In
year 2011, OAD consumption was 54.28 DID in France, 44.58 - in Germany (S. Pichetti,
C. Sermet, S. van der Erf, 2013), 33.25 - in Estonia, 29.87 - in Latvia (Baltic Statistics
on Medicines 2010–2012), showing that OAD consumption in Ukraine was very low.
Structure of OAD consumption in Ukraine shows that 98.95% of the total consumption volume is distributed to 2 groups: sulfonylureas (73.84%) and biguanides (25%)
and only 1,05% to gliptines, glitazones, glucosidases and glinides. The total share
of preparations of sulfonylureas and biguanides group in the total consumption
structure in France and Germany was 71.8% and 80.1% respectively of the total
consumption OAD. In year 2013, OAD of the II generation - gliclazide (3.01 DID) and
glibenclamide (2,09 DID) had the highest consumption level in sulfonylureas group,
preparations of III generation - glimepiride (2,09 DID) had lesser consumption rate.
Out of 61 OAD trade names (TN), presented in the pharmaceutical market of Ukraine,
8 TNs took 89.78% of the total consumption volume. Conclusions: Very low rate
of OAD consumption in Ukraine shows the necessity of its increase. Analysis of OAD
consumption structure evidences the application of relatively cheap and long-used
medical preparations for treatment of 2nd type DM, which is largely due to financial
capacities of payers.
.
1IMS
Objectives: A frequent challenge in Network Meta-Analysis (NMA) arises from the
fact that several interventions may belong to the same class and be given at multiple
doses. Models have been proposed for NMA accounting for dose-response, but these
models do not also consider class effects at the same time, which are important
from a decision making perspective. We aim to develop a framework that extends
dose-response NMA methods to account for dose and class effects simultaneously,
and explore the ability of these models to explain heterogeneity, improve model fit
and increase precision of the estimated treatment effects. Methods: Using clinical trial data of treatments for acute migraine obtained from Cochrane reviews, we
developed multi-level NMA models to simultaneously account for dose-response
and class-effects, in particular defining a ‘dose’, ‘treatment’ and ‘class’ hierarchy
within the NMA models. We explored a non-parametric “random walk” model constrained to be monotonically increasing with dose. Multi-level NMA models were
compared to 1-level (standard) NMA models where interventions were ‘lumped’ at
each level separately. Results: The model that explicitly included monotonic doseresponse and class effects showed the best fit and least heterogeneity, and produced
more precise measures of treatment effect than all 1-level models. NMA models that
made less plausible assumptions around dose-response had poorer fit than models
with monotonic dose-response. Conclusions: We have developed a framework
for simultaneously estimating treatment effects at the ‘dose’, ‘treatment’ and class
level within the same NMA model. The framework can help decision makers identify the most appropriate class, drug, and dose, however, results of dose-response
models are not straightforward to interpret or implement from a decision making
perspective. Careful consideration should be given to dose-response and similarity
of interventions when conducting NMA.
PRM198
The Lumley-Method, A Recommended Network Meta-Analysis for
Indirect Comparisons, Summarized for Practitioners
Petto H 1, Kadziola Z 1, Belger M A 2
1Eli Lilly Regional Operations GmbH, Vienna, Austria, 2Eli Lilly and Company, Windlesham, UK
.
PRM199
Analysis of Volume and Structure of Oral Antidiabetic Drugs
Consumption in Ukraine
.
.
.
Objectives: In recent years we have seen a growth in the use of network metaanalysis as part of the evidence base for Health Technology Assessments, with the
Lumley method, published in 20021being a key reference when considering both
indirect and direct comparisons. Unfortunately the program-code included in the
manuscript cannot easily be run, and the given examples cannot be replicated,
even with corrected code. To give practitioners helpful insight into the method,
we start from individual patient data of head to head trials and show how from
subsequent data-aggregation the Lumley-model (a random-effects model) can be
derived. Methods: We give more details than in the article of how the proposed
variance function aggregates study-heterogeneities and of how effect-sizes and
confidence intervals can be derived from the parameter- and variance-estimates.
We discuss why dependencies coming from the network-structure should be incorporated into confidence-interval calculations and of how the model can be extended
with an in the article suggested Bayesian approach for modeling the random-effects
parameters. Results: We include an example of how the Lumley-method can be
applied in practice. We present based on the program-example in the article a corrected R-version and a translation into SAS. For both we show how aggregated
study-data should be structured and dummy-coded before running the program.
The Lumley-method was applied to simulated data with known model-parameters
PRM200
Development of A Web-Based Tool To Elicit the Opinion of Regionally
Dispersed Health Care Professionals Responsible for Medical Device
Vigilance
Pibouleau L 1, Galtier T 1, Sailly A C 2, Maison P 2, Katsahian S 3
1INSERM, CRC, Paris, France, 2Agence Nationale de Sécurité des Médicaments, Saint-Denis,
France, 3Hôpital Européen Georges Pompidou, Paris, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In the context of uncertainty due to the lack of sound data, expert
opinion is considered as a legitimate source of information for decision-makers.
The use of experts’ opinion requires to quantifying their uncertainty about a specific
event by eliciting a probability distribution of the event. The objectives of this study
were to develop a web-based tool enabling users to remotely elicit the opinion of a
group of geographically dispersed experts and to evaluate the measurement properties of this tool. Methods: The web-based tool allowed first to elicit univariate
probability distributions separately from each expert and secondly to calculate an
aggregated distribution. The elicitation method was the four-interval method that
was judged to be more appropriate for non-statistician experts due to its clarity
of use. As recommended to limit biases, the elicitation questionnaire included a
training exercise and a graphical feedback so that the experts could validate their
distributions. A pilot survey was conducted among all the French regional medical
device vigilance correspondents (n= 24) about the risk of failure (%) of an implantable
medical device. Results: Twenty-two correspondents (92%) completed the survey.
An aggregated distribution was calculated from the elicited individual distributions
and a beta distribution was fitted reflecting the group uncertainty about the risk of
failure. Feasibility was judged in view of the users’ feedback and time to completion.
Validity and reliability were assessed using data on comprehensiveness, internal
coherence and test-retest reliability. Conclusions: The proposed web-based tool
was feasible, valid and reliable. It should be useful in making expert elicitation
easier and more practical.
PRM201
Knowledge on Medication Taking Behaviour, Balanced Diet and
Physical Activity - A Survey Among the Adolescents
sandeep Chowdary K , Nallani V R R
Chalapathi Institute of Pharmaceutical Science, Guntur, India
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The main objective of the study is to promote awareness and assess
the knowledge of adolescents on medication use, importance of balanced diet and
physical activity. Methods: The study was conducted among the adolescents
aged from16-18 years in Regions of Guntur. The volunteers are allowed to fill their
informed consent to be a part of the study. The questionnaire was distributed to all
the volunteers included in the study, which includes questions on their medication taking behaviour, dietary habits and physical activity. The response was then
analyzed to assess the knowledge on medication use, balanced diet and physical
activity. Results: Among the 165 individuals on assessment of their medication
taking behavior78% of them do not follow their prescription, 61% of the individuals
do not have any idea on their medication use and a majority of 74% are not aware
of the unwanted effects caused by the medication. On assessment of their dietary
habits and physical activity, 62% of the individuals include meal rich in fat, 42%
of the individuals skip their breakfast every day and 41% of them will not include
leafy vegetables as part of their regular meal. 65% of individuals do not perform a
regular physical activity Conclusions: It is the responsibility of the pharmacist
A579
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
to promote awareness on the medications, balanced diet and physical activity to
improve the quality of life of an individual.
or to refine the decision formulation if uncertainty is high, potentially leading to
improved decision-making.
PRM202
Simulating Individual Patient Level Data To Address Treatment
Switching When Only Summary Data Are Available
PRM205
Systematic Review and Critical Appraisal of the Statistical
Methods Used in Published Studies To Indirectly Compare Novel
Anticoagulants (Noacs) With Warfarin for the Prevention of
Stroke in Patients With Atrial Fibrillation (Af)
Boucher R , Abrams K , Lambert P C
University of Leicester, Leicester, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Treatment switching commonly occurs in the pivotal HTA evidence
for advanced or metastatic cancer treatments submitted to reimbursement agencies. Simple approaches, such as Intention-to-treat (ITT) analysis, have typically
been used to analyse data with treatment switching, despite simulation studies
showing these to drastically underestimate the underlying treatment effect. With
more manufacturers conducting indirect comparisons (ICs) to compare treatments,
summary data are being used more in analysis. The method outlined addresses
treatment switching when only summary data are available to ensure appropriate estimates for the treatment effect are achieved when the data is then used
in an IC. Methods: Using digitised survival curves, multiple datasets that are
representative of the original individual patient data (IPD) are simulated. Treatment
switching information is estimated from reported information on progression-free
survival, and then established methods which adjust appropriately for treatment
switching used to analyse the simulated data. This approach is applied to an example from a technology appraisal (TA) submitted to National Institute for Health and
Care Excellence (NICE), and the ITT hazard ratio and median survival obtained and
compared with those reported, before analysis using a Rank Preserving Structural
Failure Time Model (RPSFTM). Results: Averaging over 2000 datasets, the replicated
summary statistics were similar to those reported. Both median survival times were
within 1 month of those stated in the TA and the hazard ratio less than 0.05 different. Subsequent analysis using an RPSFTM shows the new treatment to be more
effective, and inappropriately adjusting for crossover to have underestimated the
treatment effect. Conclusions: Adjusting summary data is important as otherwise, subsequent analysis conducted will give inappropriate results. The simulated
data approach well represents the original IPD, giving on average similar results to
those reported. Hence, the further analysis to address treatment switching issues
gives more appropriate treatment effect estimates.
PRM203
Modeling the Effect of Combining Alogliptin With Dual therapy in
Type 2 Diabetes
Johnson K I 1, Palin H J 1, Sibbring G C 1, Selby R 2
Clarity, Macclesfield, UK, 2Takeda UK, High Wycombe, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Complete
Objectives: To estimate the impact of combining the dipeptidyl peptidase-4 (DPP4) inhibitor, alogliptin, with metformin and sulfonylurea (alogliptin triple therapy)
to achieve glycemic control in patients with type 2 diabetes. Methods: Since no
clinical trial of alogliptin triple therapy has been conducted, the effect of adding
alogliptin to dual therapy (metformin+sulfonylurea) was modeled using novel additive effect methodology, utilizing data from a previous mixed treatment comparison
(MTC). The following assumptions were made: the efficacy of triple therapy can be
estimated as a function of its constituent parts, and the efficacies of the constituent
parts are equivalent. Pooled data for the absolute change from baseline in glycosylated hemoglobin (HbA1c) from trials of sitagliptin, linagliptin, and vildagliptin
triple therapy, and for their constituent parts, informed the model. A weighting factor, β coefficient, derived from DPP-4 mono, dual, and triple therapy trials, was used
to estimate the effect size for triple therapy using the sum of the constituent parts.
The estimated mean β value was validated against the observed effect size of alog
liptin+pioglitazone+metformin, using the pooled effect from the MTC. Results:
An estimated mean β coefficient value of 0.83 represented the DPP-4 inhibitor class.
Validation of the approach resulted in a similar β coefficient for pioglitazone triple
therapy (0.82). Absolute change in HbA1c from baseline for alogliptin triple therapy
was estimated as -0.77% (95% CI -1.16, -0.39). Similar values were observed in the
MTC for sitagliptin -0.94% (95% CI -7.34,5. 40), linagliptin -0.65 (95% CI -6.87,5. 60),
and vildagliptin -0.80% (95% CI -7.00,5. 43). Conclusions: The wide confidence
interval is consistent with expectations in the literature and is a limitation of the
method employed, in that it requires the variance of the individual studies to be
summated. Nevertheless, the method demonstrates the value of modeling when
clinical trial evidence is not available.
PRM204
Uncertainty and Probabilistic Methods in Multi-Criteria Decision
Analysis
O Meachair S , Walsh C
Trinity College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland
.
.
Objectives: Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) is a collection of techniques
for choosing optimal decisions when two or more criteria need to be taken into
account in the decision process. Most MCDA techniques require the specification
of a number of parameters; criteria weights, utility functions or indifference thresholds. We wish to account for the uncertainty in these parameters which may arise
due to the fuzzy nature of the Decision Maker’s preferences, conflicting opinions
between a group of decision makers or population group, or the abstract nature of
the parameters. Methods: We implement some MCDA models from a Bayesian
perspective where parameters come from posterior probability distributions representing the combination of available knowledge on the parameters. Such knowledge
can come from empirical data, expert elicitation, survey data, decision-making committees, or some combination of these. Results: Depending on the method used,
the end result is either a benefit function which quantifies the uncertainty in the
benefit score for each action, or a rankogram which depicts the uncertainty in the
ranking of actions. Conclusions: Knowledge about this uncertainty allows decision makers to make more informed decisions. A decision action may be clear when
uncertainty is sufficiently low, or it may be necessary to request more information
Daacke I M
Boehringer Ingelheim UK, Bracknell, UK
.
.
Introduction: The three main novel anticoagulants (NOACs) currently licensed
in Europe, apixaban, dabigatran and rivaroxaban, have all been directly compared
against warfarin in randomised controlled trials. However, none of the three drugs
have been directly compared against each other. Thus, there has been an increase
in the number of meta-analyses and indirect comparisons published comparing
the relative efficacy and safety of these novel anticoagulants against each other
via warfarin as a common comparator. Objectives: Systematically review all
meta-analyses and indirect comparisons evaluating the NOACs against warfarin
for the prevention of stroke in patients with AF and critically appraise the statistical
methods used to do so. Methods: Systematic searches of EMBASE, MedLine, EBM
Reviews, EconLIT as well as manual searches of ClincalTrials. gov, the Cochrane
Library, CADTH, NICE, NHSEED and HTA were conducted. Data was abstracted from
any citation applying statistical methods to compare the efficacy and safety of
NOACs for the prevention of AF-related stroke. Information regarding the statistical
approach; model assumptions; data presentation; interpretation of the evidence;
and discussions of internal and external validity was used to quality rate each
study. Results: Bucher’s method of adjusted indirect comparison was most widely
used. There were generally three main model assumptions required: the similarity,
homogeneity and consistency assumptions, each being investigated with varying
scrutiny in the studies reviewed. According to the quality assessment, the indirect
comparison conducted by Wells and colleagues (2012) is of the highest relative quality. Conclusions: The limited number of RCTs available comparing the NOACs to
standard therapy, creates considerable uncertainty surrounding the comparative
efficacy and safety of these anticoagulants. In order to establish which individual
NOAC is most likely to benefit a given patient population, indirect comparisons and
meta-analyses are increasingly used. However, the quality of indirect comparison
studies are variable and results should be interpreted with care.
PRM206
Methodological Assessment of Matching-Adjusted Indirect
Comparisons: Case Study Application To Attention Deficit/
Hyperactivity Disorder (Adhd)
Shafrin J 1, Sikirica V 2, Shrestha A 1, Henkhaus L E 3, Erder M H 2, Chandra A 4
Health Economics, Los Angeles, CA, USA, 2Shire Development, LLC, Wayne, PA, USA,
3University of Southern California, Los Angeles, CA, USA, 4Harvard University, Cambridge, MA,
USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Precision
Objectives: Matching-adjusted indirect comparison (MAIC) is a novel comparative
effectiveness approach to address biases that can appear in traditional indirect
comparison (IC) methods when patient characteristics differ across trials. We examined three unanswered MAIC methodological questions and applied the proposed
solutions to a comparison of ADHD treatments. Methods: Using individual patient
data from two randomized controlled trials (RCTs) comparing guanfacine (GXR)
vs placebo and published summary statistics from four RCTs comparing atomoxetine (ATX) vs placebo, MAIC was used to reweight the GXR data so that observable
GXR patient characteristics matched those of ATX patients. Change in ADHD-RS-IV
scores was the primary endpoint. Comparative efficacy results were evaluated for
their sensitivity to changes in the following three MAIC specifications: variable
selection using regression-based methods, statistical moments matched (i.e., mean
vs mean and variance), and matching on placebo-arm outcomes. Results: Both
treatments decreased ADHD-RS-IV scores relative to placebo (-17.9 GXR vs -10.7
placebo; -14.6 ATX vs -5.8 placebo). In the baseline MAIC specification adjusting for
patient baseline characteristics and placebo arm outcomes, GXR produced larger
decreases in ADHD-RS-IV scores than ATX (Δ: -3.9, p< 0.004). The results were insensitive to adding variables to the matching algorithm (Δ : -3.8, p< 0.023), or matching only covariate means rather than both means and variances (Δ : -3.6, p< 0.006).
Applying MAIC without matching placebo arm outcomes indicated a slightly greater
decrease in ADHD-RS-IV scores for ATX, but there was no statistically significant
difference between GXR and ATX (Δ : 0.6, p< 0.649). Conclusions: In this study,
MAIC results were insensitive to variable selection via regression and the statistical
moments matched, but matching the placebo arms altered the results. Matching
placebo arm outcomes is valid when unobserved trial-specific factors have a differential impact on a trial’s treatment and control arm outcomes; this was likely
the case in this GXR-ATX study.
PRM207
Proposed Checklist for Non-Statisticians To Assess the Quality of A
Network Meta-Analysis in the Context of A Nice Submission
Pacou M 1, Gauthier A 2, Taieb V 2, Bec M 2, Belhadi D 2, Guillemot J 2
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Amaris, Paris, France, 2Amaris, London, UK
Objectives: To develop a checklist to assess the quality of a network meta-analysis
(NMA) in the context of a submission to NICE. This checklist is intended to be comprehensible and easy-to-use by non-statisticians to assess whether an NMA is suitable for a submission to NICE and/or to populate cost-effectiveness models within
the context of the NICE requirements. Methods: An ad-hoc search of the literature
was conducted to identify existing checklists. Items from these checklists were
extracted and critically reviewed. Recommendations from NICE as well as existing
NICE submissions and corresponding comments from the evidence review groups
(ERG) were used to develop the checklist. Our checklist was validated by health
economists and pharmacists not trained in NMA on the basis of a NICE submission
A580
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
in type 2 diabetes mellitus. Comprehension of the checklist was assessed based
on qualitative interviews of each analyst. A measure of the inter-analysts agreement was estimated to ensure the reliability of the checklist. Results: Checklists
identified from the literature included the checklist developed by the NICE Decision
Support Unit and the one developed by the ISPOR task force. These two checklists
were developed for analysts who conduct NMAs as well as analysts who critically
review NMAs. However, they seem to lack clarity for non-statisticians. We developed
a new checklist, which included the following items: definition of the study question
(list of comparators, study population), methods (study selection, data extraction,
statistical model, selection of fixed versus random effects model, assumptions for
the base case, heterogeneity and inconsistency assessment and sensitivity analyses), reporting of results (network and source data, median or mean and 95% credibility interval) and interpretation of results. Conclusions: Our checklist can be
used by analysts not trained in statistics to prepare or review NMAs to be submitted
to NICE and/or to populate cost-effectiveness models.
PRM208
Methodology For Selecting Expert Groups For The Purpose Of
Decision-Making Tasks
Ivlev I 1, Bartak M 2, Kneppo P 1
University in Prague, Kladno, Czech Republic, 2Jan Evangelista Purkyne
University, Usti nad Labem, Czech Republic
.
.
.
1Czech Technical
Objectives: This work aims to develop a methodology for determining the qualitative composition of an expert group for the purpose of participation in decisionmaking in health care technology. Its goal is also to evaluate the methodology
based on an example of the selection of large medical equipment. Methods: The
complex weighting factor is a comprehensive evaluation of an expert. It is based
on the expert’s overall work experience, experience in solving tasks, level of education and scientific record, interest in solving the particular task, current position,
and awareness of how to solve the task. Also taken into account are the relevance
of the expert’s knowledge and the overall self-evaluation concerning his or her
total competence in solving the task. For the purpose of validating the methodology, 96 potential experts were interviewed. These subjects included managers
from relevant departments in hospitals and hospital staff members who were from
72 health facilities in the Czech Republic. Results: Unlike the other models, the
calculation model that was selected is able to eliminate errors in estimating the
proportionality of extreme values and to reduce the impact of uncertainty in the
experts’ overall self-evaluations concerning their total competence to the combined
ratio. Based on this model, a methodology for selecting experts was developed. A
statistically significant correlation was found between the complex weighting factor
and the following characteristics: the expert’s experience in dealing with similar
tasks (r= 0.512, p< 0.001), the expert’s theoretical background (awareness) and the
relevance of the expert’s knowledge (r= 0.44, p< 0.001), the expert´s current position
(r= 0.319, p= 0.002), and the level of his or her education and scientific record (r=0.28,
p= 0.007). Conclusions: This methodology will be especially useful in scientific
and technological forecasting, medical and managerial decision-making, quality
assessment, and operational research.
PRM210
Modelling Longitudinal Trajectories of Patient-Reported Outcomes
To Evaluate Treatment Effect
Jen M H
Eli Lilly and Company, Surrey, UK
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate treatment effect on longitudinal patient-reported outcomes using appropriate analytical strategy. Methods: This was an ad-hoc analysis of longitudinal patient-reported outcomes using a two stages simulated data
in which the true model is known, to explore and to evaluate the capability of the
group-based trajectory method to identify the distinctive features of a highly irregular but still continuous population distribution of trajectories. Firstly, we created
six different types of underlying trajectory in which the true model is known and
added in level-one between occasion random noises. Then we added a level-two,
between- patients variation (of the random intercept form) with differing variability to each of the six distinctive trends. This simulation allows us to examine how
the software implementation identifies different group trajectories as well as their
level-one and -two variances. It was recognized that a priori assignment of distinct
longitudinal trajectories may not be appropriate and that no ability to calibrate
the precision of individual classifications exists if ex-ante rules are used. Thus,
latent group-based trajectory model, a method to map the developmental course of
symptoms and assess heterogeneity in response to clinical interventions, was used
to identify patient groups with varied response. Results: The fitted trajectories
closely approximate the true shapes and there is also a close correspondence for the
percentage of places attributed to each group. Even the size of the level 1 random
term is correctly estimated. The semi-parametric group-based trajectory method
has demonstrated unequivocally its capability to capture the unobserved subgroups
in the presence of considerable level-1 random variation. Conclusions: Patients
in many disease areas experience changes in QoL in different ways. Identification
of those groups is essential for appropriate evaluation of therapy treatment effects
and identification of factors contributing to those groupings.
PRM211
The Randomized Blind Start Trial: Evaluation of A New Study
Design for Assessing Clinical Outcomes in Rare and Heterogeneous
Patient Populations
Signorovitch J 1, Ayyagari R 2, Kakkis E 3
1Analysis Group, Inc., Boston, MA, USA, 2Analysis Group Inc., Boston, MA, USA, 3Ultragenyx
Pharmaceutical Inc., Novato, CA, USA
.
.
.
Objectives: Clinical development of therapies for rare diseases can benefit from
improvements to conventional trial designs. This study evaluated a new trial design,
the randomized Blind Start. Methods: The Blind Start design randomizes patients
to ≥ 3 groups which initiate double-blind active therapy at different times from
baseline, preceded by 0,1, 2 or more intervals of placebo. Analytical and simulationbased investigations were conducted to compare the statistical power, required
assumptions, practical considerations and economic features of the Blind Start to
conventional single-arm and randomized designs. Results: Given the same number of patients, the randomized Blind Start provides equivalent statistical power for
detecting changes pre- vs. post-treatment compared to a conventional single-arm
design. However, by concealing treatment initiation times, the Blind Start enables
more objective assessments of outcomes that are effort-based, patient-reported
or subjectively assessed by investigators. In addition, compared to a conventional
2-arm randomized trial, analysis of parallel treatment and placebo groups embedded within a Blind Start design provides greater power to detect treatment effects
over any fixed time interval. For example, with N= 16 and a treatment effect equal
to 1 standard deviation of the outcome measure, a 4-arm Blind Start design provides
85% power in a pre-post analysis and 79% power in an analysis of embedded parallel groups. In contrast, a conventional 2-arm randomized trial provides 52% power
in this scenario. Benefits of the Blind Start design come at the expense of 1) more
patient-time in the trial and 2) lack of stringent control over patient status upon
active treatment initiation. Conclusions: The randomized Blind Start design can
improve precision for treatment effect estimation vs. parallel-group designs and
reduce risk of bias vs. single-arm designs. Endpoint choice and statistical analysis
strategies for the Blind Start design can maximize the assessment of treatment
effects on multiple outcomes.
RESEARCH on Methods – Study Design
PRM212
The Quality of Search Methodology and Search Reporting in
Published Systematic Reviews of Economic Evaluations:
Search Sources
Wood H , Arber M , Glanville J
York Health Economics Consortium, York, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: The economic evaluation of health care interventions is now an
accepted element of health care decision-making and priority-setting. As the number of published economic evaluations has grown, so has the number of systematic
reviews of economic evaluations. However, the quality of search methodology used in
recent reviews has not been widely investigated. This study sought to identify which
search resources are being used to identify studies in recent, published systematic
reviews of economic evaluations, and to investigate whether choice of resources
reflects current recommendations for the conduct of such reviews. Methods:
A search to identify systematic reviews of economic evaluations published since
January 2013 was undertaken in MEDLINE. Two reviewers extracted the following
information from reviews which met the inclusion criteria: general medical literature databases searched, specialist economic databases searched, health technology
assessment sources searched, supplementary search techniques used. Results were
compared against the search resources recommended by NICE when searching for
economic evidence for single technology appraisals, and the summary of current
best evidence provided in Sure Info (http://vortal.htai.org/?q= node/336). Results:
Sixty-five systematic reviews met the inclusion criteria; 23 of these could not be
accessed in full text, data was extracted from 42 reviews. Five reviews (12%) met
or exceeded the search resources recommended by NICE (MEDLINE, Embase, NHS
EED, EconLit). Nine reviews (21%) searched at least four of the six types of resource
recommended by Sure Info (specialist economic databases, general databases, HTA
databases, webpages of HTA agencies, grey literature, collections of utility studies).
None of the reviews searched all six. Although all reviews explicitly described the
resources searched, reporting frequently contained errors or lack of clarity in the
names of databases and interfaces. Conclusions: The information resources used
to identify evidence for the majority of recently published systematic reviews of
economic evaluations do not conform to current recommendations.
PRM214
Identifying Psoriasis and Psoriatic Arthritis Patients in
Retrospective Databases When Diagnosis Code Is Not Available:
A Validation Study Comparing Medication/Prescriber Visit Based
Algorithms To Diagnosis Codes
Dobson-Belaire W 1, Borrelli R 1, Goodfield J 1, Liu F F 2, Khan Z M 3
1IMS Brogan, Mississauga, ON, Canada, 2Celgene Inc., Mississauga, ON, Canada, 3Celgene
Corporation, Summit, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Retrospective database studies rely on the ability to accurately identify patient cohorts of interest within health care databases. Diagnosis code-based
algorithms are the primary method of identifying patient cohorts; however, many
databases lack reliable diagnosis code information. Our aim was to develop precise
algorithms based on medication claims/prescriber visit (MC/PV) to identify psoriasis
(PsO) patients or psoriatic patients with arthritic conditions (PsO-AC), a proxy for
psoriatic arthritis, in databases lacking diagnosis codes. Methods: Algorithms
were developed using medications with narrow indication profiles in combination with prescriber specialty to define PsO and PsO-AC. For the study period of
July 1, 2009 to June 30, 2013, algorithms were validated using the PharMetrics Plus™
(PharMetrics) database, which contains both adjudicated medication claims and
diagnosis codes. Positive predictive value (PPV), negative predictive value (NPV), sensitivity and specificity of algorithms developed for PsO and PsO-AC were assessed
using diagnosis code as the reference standard. Results: In the PharMetrics database, 183,328 patients were identified by diagnosis code or medication claim for validation. The highest PPVs for PsO (85%) and PsO-AC (65%) occurred when a predictive
algorithm of ≥ 2 MC/PVs was compared to the reference standard of ≥ 1 diagnosis
code. The majority of PsO-AC false positives had a diagnosis of PsO and pain or joint
symptoms. NPV and specificity were also high (99 – 100%), while sensitivity was low
(≤ 30%). Reducing the number of MC/PVs or increasing diagnosis claims decreased
A581
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
the algorithms’ PPV. Conclusions: We have demonstrated that MC/PV algorithms
can be used to identify PsO patients with a high degree of accuracy, while PsO-AC
accuracy requires further investigation. Such methods allow researchers to conduct
retrospective studies in databases where diagnosis codes are absent.
getting a positive final test result (i.e. wrongly continued). The developed software
(i.e. R-codes) can easily be applied to other cases.
PRM215
Assessing the Effectiveness of Counter Matching for Improving
the Efficiency of the Nested Case-Control Design in Observational
Studies
Jaksa A , Westbrook L , Daniel K , Ho Y S
Context Matters, Inc., New York, NY, USA
Kiri V 1, MacKenzie G 2
& JK Consulting Ltd, Guildford, UK, 2University of Limerick, Limerick, Ireland
.
.
1FV
Objectives: The nested case-control (NCC) design offers a simple method for
avoiding unreasonable assumptions in the evaluation of time-dependent treatment effect. Its results are easy to interpret. Its strength rests largely on the appropriateness of the controls which are matched to the cases- suggesting a matching
strategy that ensures maximum number of discordant case-control pairs may be
more efficient since effect estimation is based entirely on the off-diagonal data of
the resulting 2x2 tables in the conditional logistic regression. In theory, the more
off-diagonal pairs that are generated by the random sampling scheme, the more
improvement we can expect on efficiency. The objective of this study is to assess the
efficiency of counter-matching on treatment compared with the classical matching
approach in the NCC design based on results from the cohort design using simulated
data. Methods: In each simulation of 1000 patients at 100 replications per run, we
assumed an underlying event hazard of Weibull distribution using inputted values
for the scale and shape parameters, treatment, age and sex as the factors. Each
run involved distinct treatment prevalence of between 10%-50% with event rate
varying from common to very rare. We compared the proportion of matched pairs
(at 1 control per case) used in the analyses of the resulting data between the classical and counter matching strategies. Results: The counter-matched strategy was
more efficient than the classical approach. The proportion of matched pairs used
was on average over ten times more and it also gave mean effect estimates which
were more consistent with the full cohort values, particularly for low treatment
exposure and rare events. Conclusions: Our results suggest counter matching is
more efficient and more accurate estimates than classical matching in nested casecontrol design. These benefits may be particularly important for studies involving
rare events or low treatment exposure.
PRM216
Assessment of the Methodological Quality of Randomized
Controlled Trials Published in “Russian Allergology Journal” in
2009-2013
Rakina E 1, Dombrovskiy V S 2, Rebrova O 3
1Autonomous Non-profit Organization “National Centre for Health Technology Assessment”,
Moscow, Russia, 2The Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public
Administration, Moscow, Russia, 3Pirogov Russian National Research Medical University, Moscow,
Russia
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess the methodological quality of randomized controlled trials
(RCTs) published in “Russian Allergology Journal” (RAJ) in 2009-2013. Methods:
Retrospective analysis of 96 original publications was carried out. For 8 RCT the
risks of biases were assessed using the methodology of the Cochrane Collaboration.
Accuracy of statistical analysis was assessed in accordance with established in
2009 journal’s requirements, made in accordance with best international practice. Results: 96 articles were analysed, 8 (8%) of them were identified as RCTs. All
the RCTs have a high risk of the biases and major mistakes in the statistical analysis. Conclusions: The methodological quality of RCTs is insufficient and needs
to be improved. We consider that the most important role should play improvement
of trials’ planning. Collaboration with the experts in clinical trials’ methodology
is strongly recommended. The analysis empowers researchers to consider existing experience and to improve methodological quality of RCTs, their relevance to
international standards.
PRM217
Simulation of An Additional Go/No-Go Efficacy Interim Analysis in A
Head-To-Head Rct
Van Montfort K
Nyenrode Business University, Breukelen, The Netherlands
.
Objectives: A head-to-head randomized clinical trial (RCT) to evaluate a new
drug is financially risky, because a positive outcome is uncertain. We simulate
and evaluate a head-to-head RCT design incorporating an additional go/no-go
efficacy interim analysis to show the consequences of this additional interim analysis. Methods: We simulate the endpoint event-free-survival (EFS) of patients
in a head-to-head RCT. The decision rule of the additional interim efficacy analysis (i.e. stop or continue) depends on the number of patients (i.e. 300,400 or 500
patients) and the significance level (i.e. α = 0.05, α = 0.10 or α = 0.20) of the interim
analysis. The RCT without an interim-analysis has significance level α = 0.05,
power= 0.86 and sample size 800. Results: Each combination of sample size
and significance level, which is called a scenario, is investigated by simulating
2,000 trials of 800 patients. Per simulated scenario we report, among others, the
“Probability of positive final analysis test result GIVEN negative interim analysis
test result” (= wrongly stopped) and the “Probability of negative final analysis
test result GIVEN positive interim analysis test result” (= wrongly continued).
The results of the first scenario, i.e. an interim analysis at 300 included patients
and significance level α = 0.05, are as follows. If the actual improvement of the EFS
hazard rate is 0%, the abovementioned probabilities are 3.65% and 7.85%. An actual
improvement effect of 5% changes the probability values to 20.25% and 12.80,
while an actual improvement effect of 10% causes the probability values 28.50%
and 5.55%. Conclusions: The simulated probabilities were mainly influenced
by the actual EFS improvement. The smaller the actual outcome improvement, the
greater the probability of continuing the trial up to 800 included patients without
PRM218
Negative Reimbursement Consequences From Trial Design Choices
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Health Technology Assessments (HTA) use clinical trial data to determine comparative efficacy and cost-effectiveness; thus study design plays a roll
in market access. The objective is to determine how often reimbursement decisions cite trial design defects. Methods: We analyzed 1,702 HTAs from CADTH,
G-BA, HAS, NICE, PBAC, and SMC. We examined the clinical assessment rationale
for the decision and the reimbursement decisions. An explicit trial design defect
was defined as a clinical assessment of “inappropriate comparator” or “inappropriate patient population.” Clinical assessments of lower, uncertain, or unknown
efficacy or a clinical determination of insufficient or lack of evidence were defined
as potential trial design defects. Results: Reviews that cited trial defects resulted
in significantly more negative reimbursement decisions (6.6%) than positive reimbursement decisions (0.4%; p< .001). This pattern held true for each individual
agency examined. G-BA was the agency most likely to cite an explicit trial deficit
(39%), while HAS was the least likely (0.6%). In addition, significantly more reviews
that cited a potential trial defect resulted in negative reimbursement decisions (44%)
than positive reimbursement decisions (5.5%; p< .001). This also held true for each
agency. Again, G-BA was most likely to note a potential trial defect in reviews (46%)
while SMC was least likely (6.4%). Among disease conditions with more than 10
reviews, explicitly cited trial defects were mostly frequently seen in Cystic Fibrosis
and Parkinson’s Disease (15% and 13%, respectively). Potential trial defects were
most frequently cited in Atrial Fibrillation and Depression reviews (42% and 39%
respectively). Conclusions: Explicit and potential trial design issues have negative consequences for reimbursement outcomes. Negative decisions are more likely
than positive decisions to cite trial design issues. G-BA is more inclined than other
agencies to cite these trial design issues when issuing their reimbursement decisions. Manufacturers should consider market-access outcomes when designing
clinical trials.
PRM219
Evidence Resulting From Chart Review Methodology Applied
To Named Patient Programme Participation And Compassionate
Medication Use: Peri-Approval Approximation Of Post-Market
Practice Patterns And Costs
Stein D 1, Jean-Mary J 2, Goldwin A E 2, Lau M R 3, Manson S 3
Express Scripts Company, Dorval, QC, Canada, 2United BioSource Corporation, London,
UK, 3GlaxoSmithKline Oncology, Uxbridge, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1UBC: An
Objectives: Compassionate use programmes provide peri-approval drug access
based on unsolicited physician requests for patients with unmet need. Practice
pattern evaluations in this context, using chart review methodology, permits the
collection of pre-approval data outside of clinical trial settings that can approximate real-world post-market use. Data can be used to inform important economic
evaluations, value dossiers, and drug safety assessments. Methods: Study design
and operational considerations related to chart review studies of compassionate
use populations have been summarized by evaluating three multi-national case
studies. Results: The source populations of patients were drawn from compassionate use programmes providing oral anti-cancer therapies. These were initiated pre-approval following positive clinical trial findings. Countries included
Australia, Belgium, Greece, Ireland, Israel, Italy, The Netherlands, New Zealand,
Spain, Switzerland and the United Kingdom. Data including patient characteristics, patterns of care and drug dosing, duration of treatment and reasons for
treatment discontinuation, overall survival, clinical benefit, progression free survival and adverse and serious adverse events are being collected to inform health
economic and other burden of illness assessments. Site and patient selection was
performed using compassionate use enrollment data, facilitating an efficient study
start-up. Data were cleaned at point of data entry and via an electronic query process in real-time resulting in tailored international datasets. Patients provided consent for their medical data to be used prior to initiating compassionate use therapy,
and additional ethical approval for the chart review was sought on a local and/
or national level. Chart review study design requires a balance between scientific
and operational rigor and practicality and feasibility. Conclusions: Peri-approval
chart review studies of patients in compassionate use programmes offer an important opportunity to characterize patterns of use and associated treatment costs as
well as the clinical impact of investigational medications in non-trial settings to
inform clinical, health economic and market access decisions.
PRM220
Immature Survival Data From Early Trial Termination – Theory and
Hta Practice
Pruefert A 1, Skaltsa K 2, Maervoet J 1, Van Engen A 1
1Quintiles Consulting, Hoofddorp, The Netherlands, 2Quintiles Consulting, Barcelona, Spain
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Scientific research suggests that randomized controlled trials terminated early for benefit considerations systematically overestimate treatment
effects of the primary outcome. This study assessed whether Health Technology
Assessment (HTA) agencies accept the increased uncertainty around overall survival
(OS) estimates in oncology trials arising from early termination. Methods: Public
scientific databases were searched to identify scientific articles and pivotal trials
involving early trial termination. A selection of related HTA appraisals, published
between January 2011 and February 2014, were analysed. Current scientific evidence
on the impact of early stopping on outcome estimates was compared to the conclusions made by 11 HTA agencies. Results: Twelve scientific articles, 12 pivotal trials,
and 31 related HTA appraisals were selected for in-depth analysis. The scientific
literature suggests that more stringent significance levels in the repeated interim
A582
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
analyses reduce the probability of finding significant results due to chance while
large numbers of outcome events reduce the overestimation of treatment effects.
Our analysis finds that a statistically significant gain in OS is an important decision driver for even the most critical HTA agencies, although the treatment effect
may still be questioned when the trial is unblinded early. HTA agencies appreciate
to receive the latest available information (UK, Australia and Germany) and may
reject the use of oncology drugs when there is too much uncertainty around OS
estimates to justify the proposed price. It is generally useful to continue data collection and follow-up patients should HTA agencies still request more reliable OS
estimates for modeling purposes (UK and Australia) or long-term risk-benefit evaluation (France). Conclusions: Payers are aware of the overestimation of effect size
due to early trial termination and may reject drugs for high uncertainty around OS
estimates. For adequate responses to requests for more reliable data, it is advised
to continue data collection and follow-up patients.
PRM221
The Management of Irritable Bowel Syndrome (Ibs) in England: A
Real World Study in Primary Care Clinical Practice
Caldwell I 1, Collins J 2, Rance M 3, Dew R M 4
1Swan Lane Medical Centre, Bolton, UK, 2NIHR Clinical Research Network: Greater Manchester,
Manchester, UK, 3Almirall, Uxbridge, UK, 4pH Associates Ltd, Marlow, UK
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: IBS is often a diagnosis of exclusion, with poor diagnosis coding in
primary care and identification of eligible research participants challenging. We
present the methodology of an on-going multi-centre, observational, retrospective research study, designed to overcome the challenges of IBS patient identification. Methods: FARSITE, a software tool for identification of research participants
developed by the Greater Manchester Comprehensive Local Research Network and
North West eHealth, was used to screen anonymised primary care records for
potentially eligible patients. Ethical approval reference 13/LO/0692. Search criteria:
patients aged 18-60; combination READ code symptoms indicative of IBS and prescription of IBS medications 01/01/2009–31/12/2011. GPs at 8 participating practices
in Salford & Greater Manchester reviewed clinical records of the FARSITE-generated
list of patients to apply full eligibility criteria for final patient selection. Inclusion
criteria: medical diagnosis of IBS or meeting ROME III criteria; provision of consent.
Exclusion Criteria: diagnosis excluding IBS; IBS symptoms secondary to other condition; IBS medications only for non-GI symptoms. Results: FARSITE identified
1089 (1.3%) patients, of which 297 (27.3%) were eligible. 97 patients consented to
participation (79% female). Main reasons for non-eligibility were not meeting ROME
III criteria or IBS excluded by medical opinion. Patients were most commonly coded
as irritable colon (37%), difficulty defecating (21%), abdominal pain (18%), diarrhoea
symptoms (14%). Four (4%) patients had a READ code specific for IBS. The median
(IQR) time from 1st presentation with abdominal symptoms to study eligibility was
3.98 (0.00-9.04) years. Conclusions: Identification of patients with IBS using READ
codes is sub-optimal in primary care. A combination search of READ codes with
symptom and prescription data via FARSITE has enabled potential participants to
be identified with a reasonable screening failure rate. FARSITE is a valuable research
tool aiding study feasibility by reducing the need for manual patient identification.
PRM222
The Effect of A Likely Overemphasis on Ficiency-Related Test
Attributes on Acmg Recommendations and Access To Newborn
Screening (Nbs)
Rittenhouse B
MCPHS University, Boston, MA, USA
.
Objectives: Patient access to NBS has been greatly influenced by the 2006
American College of Medical Genetics (ACMG) recommended expansion of NBS.
ACMG relied largely on a stakeholder survey on 19 attributes of 84 rare conditions.
The percentage of respondents agreeing to an attribute’s presence for a condition,
along with its weight, determined attribute score. Sums of scores determined the
entry point to an algorithm for final recommendations. This research examines 6
attributes that appear to be associated with the same concept and asks whether
these are really one (over-weighted) concept. Methods: The ACMG report provided attribute scores. Six questions addressed test efficiency (simplicity, high
throughput, cost < $1/condition, multiple analytes/test run, other conditions
identified/analyte, multiple conditions detected/test). We examined correlations
between the 6 answers for a given condition across conditions and associations
with recommendations. Results: After eliminating conditions with missing data,
78 remained. Pairwise correlations between the 6 answers were high (mean= .85;
range, .72-.96). Of those conditions (37) scoring at least 75% of the possible points
on one question (“high throughput”), 79% were recommended as Core conditions
to be screened and only 8% were Not Recommended. The mean total scores for the
6 similar questions was 339 (500 possible). Of those (19) scoring 25% or fewer of the
possible points for that one question, only 3% were Core, 72% Not Recommended
(mean score:89). Conclusions: The high correlations support the idea that the
6 similar questions were answered as if they were the same concept, weighting the
common general attribute very highly. A more systematic approach, say MCDA,
would likely have eliminated some of these questions with significant consequences
for ACMG recommendations.
PRM223
Workflow Mapping for Paediatric Vaccination Process in the United
Kingdom (Uk): A Precursor of A Time and Motion (T&M) Study
Mokiou S 1, De Cock E 2, Standaert B 3
1UBC: An Express Scripts Company, London, UK, 2United BioSource Corporation, Barcelona, Spain,
3GlaxoSmithKline Vaccines, Wavre, Belgium
.
.
.
Objectives: Time and Motion (T&M) methodology allows quantifying timerelated outcomes for a health care delivery process by disaggregating the process
in its constituent parts to measure task durations. The design of a T&M study
requires early process mapping to define the time outcomes to be measured.
The mapping of paediatric vaccination process in the United Kingdom (UK), as a
precursor of a real-world study, is described. Methods: A targeted review of publicly available information was conducted to gain comprehensive understanding
of the paediatric vaccination process in the UK. A survey was designed eliciting
the chronology of vaccination process prior to and on vaccination day, including
estimates of active health care professional involvement. Face-to-face interviews
with a nurse were conducted at three general practitioner surgeries routinely
performing vaccinations. A subsequent follow-up call with each nurse was also
arranged. Descriptive statistics were generated and preliminary cost calculations
made. Results: Paediatric vaccination process can be broken down in 6 and 8
clearly discernible steps prior to and on vaccination day, respectively. Activities
prior to vaccination day include, among others, inventory, ordering, cold-chain
management and are typically for multiple subjects. Mean time for those activities,
recalculated per single vaccination visit, was 6.7 minutes, of which 61% dedicated
to administrative duties. Activities on vaccination day include, among others, room
preparation, consultation, vaccine administration. Estimated time per single visit
totaled 25.4 minutes. Estimated total cost per single vaccine administration, with
nurse salary cost from PSSRU, was £10.4. Costs may vary substantially depending
on the level of “on-costs” to nurse’s gross salary. Conclusions: The detailed
mapping of paediatric vaccination process in the UK identified clearly discernible
tasks, time estimates, factors impacting variability of time outcomes, and early
cost estimates. This forms the basis of a real-world T&M study aiming to generate
robust time and cost outcomes.
PRM224
Comparative Effectiveness Research of Medical Devices – New
Methods Needed?
Hunger T 1, Schnell-Inderst P 2, Arvandi M 1, Conrads-Frank A 1, Siebert U 1
- University for Health Sciences, Medical Informatics and Technology, Hall i. T., Austria,
2UMIT - University for Health Sciences, Medical Informatics and Technology, Hall i. T.; Innsbruck,
Austria
.
.
.
.
.
1UMIT
Objectives: Guidelines for Health Technology Assessment (HTA) and Comparative
Effectiveness Research (CER) largely focus on pharmaceuticals and only few explicitly consider other health care technologies. CER of medical devices (MD) faces some
challenges that raise questions about how adequate current CER methods account
for the specific features of MD and how well MD fit in the paradigm of drug HTA. Our
aim was to identify challenges and gaps in methodology related to specific issues
of MD. Our comprehensive framework for the evaluation of clinical effectiveness of
MD includes recommendations for generation of primary data and analyzing and
synthesizing data in systematic reviews of CER of MD. Methods: We performed a
targeted literature review for CER methods and specific features of MD. An electronic
database search was combined with systematic screening of tables of content of
selected journals in the fields of epidemiology, HTA, statistics, and evidence-based
medicine, which have a strong focus on methods. Additionally, we screened the
reference lists of the most relevant papers. Results: More than 200 publications
about the general evaluation of MD and about specific CER methods were included.
The MD’s physical mechanism of action, the dynamic development and regulatory
evidence requirements are the driving features that suggest the increased use of
certain methods for the evidence generation, finding of information for HTA, data
analysis and synthesis, and interpretation of results. Rather than following the paradigms of drug evaluation, MD resemble more the notion of complex interventions.
Our methodological framework is compatible with the EUnetHTA core model and
integrates existing recommendations for other complex interventions. The consideration of observational data, operator characteristics, active control trials, and
decision-analytic modeling are of special importance, as well as the application of
Bayesian methods. Conclusions: The assessment of the clinical effectiveness of
MD does require specific, although not necessarily new methods.
PRM225
(Cost-) Effectiveness of A Multi-Component Intervention for Adults
With Epilepsy: Study Protocol of A Dutch Randomized Controlled
Trial
Wijnen B 1, Leenen L A M 2, de Kinderen R J A 1, Majoie M H 2, van Heugten C M 3, Evers S M 1
1Maastricht University, Maastricht, The Netherlands, 2Epilepsy Center Kempenhaeghe, Heeze, The
Netherlands, 3MHENS, School for Mental Health and Neuroscience, Maastricht, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Poor adherence to anti-epileptic drugs has been shown to be the
most important cause of poorly controlled epilepsy. Furthermore, it is emphasized
that an increase in quality of life among patients with epilepsy could be reached
by counseling and treatments aimed at increasing their self-efficacy and thus
stimulate self-management. However, there is a need for evidence on the effectiveness of such programs, especially within epilepsy care. Therefore, we have
developed a multi-component intervention (MCI) which combines a self-management/education program with e-Health interventions. Hence the overall objective of this study is to assess the (cost-) effectiveness of a MCI aiming to improve
self-efficacy in people with epilepsy compared to care as usual. Methods: A
randomized controlled trial in 2 parallel groups will be conducted to compare
the MCI intervention with a waiting list control condition in epilepsy patients.
One hundred eligible epilepsy patients will be recruited from the Kempenhaeghe
epilepsy center and allocated to intervention or control group. Patients in the
intervention group will receive an education program of six meetings including
e-Health intervention and will be followed for 12 months. Patients in the control
group will be followed for 6 months after which they will be offered to participate
in the MCI. The study will consist of three parts: 1) a clinical effectiveness study,
2) a cost-effectiveness study, and 3) a process evaluation. The primary outcome
will be self-efficacy. Outcome assessments will be done using questionnaires at
baseline and after 3, 6, 9, and 12 months. Results: N/A. Conclusions: This
study will determine the (cost-) effectiveness of an MCI intervention to improve
the self-efficacy of epilepsy in adult patients. The MCI is designed to stimulate
self-management skills and awareness of epilepsy patients in combination with
A583
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
the use of e-health interventions.*Both B. F. M. Wijnen and L. A. M. Leenen contributed equally to this work.
PRM226
Implementation of International Chart Review Studies: An
Assessment of Ethics and Regulatory Considerations
Jean-Mary J 1, Stein D 2, Yeomans K 2, Payne K A 3
BioSource Corporation, London, UK, 2UBC: An Express Scripts Company, Dorval, QC,
Canada, 3United BioSource Corporation, Dorval, QC, Canada
.
.
.
.
.
1United
Objectives: In the absence of secondary sources of health care data, chart review
studies can result in patient level data repositories including patient characteristics, care patterns, treatment effectiveness and clinical and safety outcomes. Data
can be used to populate economic evaluations, and value dossiers, and inform
drug safety assessments. For successful implementation, however, knowledge of
country-specific ethics and regulatory approval processes is paramount. Methods:
Operational, ethics and regulatory issues and considerations as well as strategies for
study success have been summarized in the context of eleven recent multi-national
chart review case studies. Results: Two of 11 studies also collected data prospectively; two studies were categorized as post authorization safety studies and three
studies were conducted in peri-approval compassionate use program populations.
The majority of studies (9) were oncology focused, with two studies focused on
infectious diseases and opioid-induced constipation. Sample sizes varied from 20
to 500 patients, the number of countries from 1 to 8, and the number of sites from 4
to 61. All studies included at least one European country. Across studies, key operational considerations that impacted the ethical/regulatory approval process were
ambiguous/amorphous multinational regulatory requirements/guidelines; commercial availability or non-availability of the sponsor product at the time of chart
abstraction; data collection method(s) (i.e., retrospective vs. hybrid chart review plus
prospective data collection); country variation in informed consent requirements
and definitions of personal data; and multinational contractual requirements with
the participating sites. Conclusions: International chart review studies are an
effective methodology to resolve data gaps not solved by existing secondary health
care data sources resulting in tailored, patient-level datasets. Current knowledge of
the highly variable and evolving global regulatory requirements, as well as the development of a risk management plan informed by methodological and operational
lessons learned at study-outset will facilitate risk mitigation and allow researchers
to overcome key challenges.
PRM227
Cost Per Patient in Non Interventional Studies and Added Value of
Direct To Patient Contact Service
Fournie X
Mapi, Lyon, France
.
Objectives: In addition to study outcome concerns arising from patients lost to
follow-up (LFU) in pharmacoepidemiology and pharmacovigilance studies, the
financial impact of LFU can be significant. Our objectives were to estimate cost
per patient in Non-interventional studies, to identify variables that may affect this
patient cost, to estimate cost of patient lost to follow-up (LFU), and financial benefits
that can be expected from LFU minimization through Direct to Patient Contact service (DPC). Methods: Analysis of 2013 proposals and budgets submitted to study
sponsors. Selection criteria: non interventional, prospective, longitudinal patient follow-up, full CRO services. Analysis were performed according to patient sample size,
study duration, disease category, and different hypothesis for LFU rates. Results:
1) 20 studies (Domestic, Regional or Global) met all inclusion criteria; 2) Annual
cost per patient -ranging from € 1,068 to € 4,370- decreases as the study duration
increases (set-up cost is more diluted in the patient annual cost). But the longer the
study is the more expensive the overall cost per patient; 3) Mean annual patient cost
significantly differs according to rarity of disease/population; rarity is an important
criterion that greatly impacts overall and annual patient cost, especially for study
lasting more than 1 year. Below 1 year, the cost per patient remains quite similar
between types of diseases/populations; 4) Cost are more significant in rare diseases
studies, therefore DPC can provide the best overall cost savings in these populations;
and 50 The cost savings are depended on the expected rate of patient LFU-with/
without DPC service and the planned patient sample size. Conclusions: Return
On Investment plays an important role for Sponsors to determine if DPC is valuable in a study. The financial investment may be beneficial regardless of the cost to
insure completion of the patients, thus meeting the scientific study objectives. But
it could generate cost savings as well.
PRM228
Retrospective Chart Review Studies: Strategies To Ensure Robust
Data Quality
Stein D 1, Bassel M 1, Payne K A 2
Express Scripts Company, Dorval, QC, Canada, 2United BioSource Corporation, Dorval,
QC, Canada
.
.
.
.
1UBC: An
Objectives: Retrospective chart review studies can result in robust naturalistic
data to inform evaluations of treatment patterns, resource utilization, costs of care,
clinical outcomes and safety. Data quality control is challenging both as a result of
poor quality documentation in the usual care medical chart, or as a result of data
abstraction and data entry processes. Methods: Ten chart review case studies conducted in the United States, Canada and Europe were evaluated to provide recommendations for improving chart review data quality control mechanisms. Results:
All 10 studies used electronic data capture (EDC) systems. Common lessons learned
across the studies were that the case report forms (CRFs) should only include necessary data points required to fulfill the analysis. Direct chart-to-EDC data entry and
remote real-time data quality control is recommended to reduce additional transcription errors that may occur if using paper CRFs. It is important to ensure the EDC
system includes a cohort-control platform that enables selection of patient cohorts
(i.e., random selection) and tracking of eligibility screening to reduce selection bias
risk. Automated edit checks of primary data endpoints should be programmed into
the EDC system prompting data abstractors to revise erroneous data and/or confirm
data outside of expected ranges at entry. To confirm abstracted data reflect source
documents (patient medical charts), a second abstractor at the site can re-abstract
pre-defined critical study variables from patient medical charts for cross-referencing
for data discrepancies. Site training must be effective to ensure compliance with
chart abstraction and data quality requirements. Conclusions: Given the frequent incomplete or poor quality medical chart information and the potential for
human error in data abstraction and entry processes, data quality control methods
are paramount. Approaches to protocol, CRF and study training materials design
can positively impact data quality.
RESEARCH on Methods – Conceptual Papers
PRM229
Research Prioritization In An Mcda Context: Existing Methods New Results
Janssen M P 1, Koffijberg H2
1University Medical Center Utrecht, Utrecht, The Netherlands, 2University Medical Center, Utrecht,
The Netherlands
.
.
Objectives: Health technology assessment typically involves consideration of multiple conflicting criteria. Therefore, trade-offs are required between different objectives such as maximizing health, restricting budget impact, increasing health equity
and maximizing safety. Methods such as multiple decision criteria analysis (MCDA)
are therefore increasingly being used to reflect such trade-offs in a transparent
and consistent manner. Although MCDA can be combined with cost-effectiveness
analysis it may, however, invalidate results from Value of Information (VOI) analysis
when it also includes other health-related or cost-related objectives. Methods: In
two case studies we first applied VOI methods directly and only to cost-effectiveness
estimates, and then also applied these methods separately to all relevant decision criteria. In a simulation study on two drugs we calculated the expected value
of perfect information (EVPI) with drug selection concerning a trade-off between
cost-effectiveness and drug safety. In a clinical study on the primary prevention of
cardiovascular disease using improved versus standard risk prediction we calculated
the EVPI with selection of the best risk prediction strategy concerning a trade-off
between cost-effectiveness and budget impact. Results: In our simulation study
we found EVPI estimates per patient based only on cost-effectiveness were up to
€ -586 lower and € +459 higher compared to EVPI estimates also acknowledging
the safety criterion, depending on its weight. In our clinical study, the EVPI estimates based only on cost-effectiveness were consistently lower, up to € -540 per
patient, compared to EVPI estimates also acknowledging the budget impact criterion. Conclusions: When decisions are based not only on cost-effectiveness
but on other criteria as well, some of which also relate to costs or health effects,
standard VOI estimates are no longer valid. However, separate application of VOI
methods to each of the relevant decision criteria is straightforward and can facilitate
transparent research prioritization in a complex MCDA context.
PRM230
A Statistical Modeling Framework To Characterize the Impact of
Progression on Survival in Oncology
Ishak K J
Evidera, St-Laurent, QC, Canada
.
.
The benefits and value of new cancer treatments often focus on the overall survival
(OS) gains that patients may derive. Trials are typically not long enough to allow
detailed understanding of OS, and potential benefits must be inferred from benefits
on progression-free-survival (PFS). This raises questions such as whether early or later
progression impacts survival, whether the increase in mortality following progression
is sustained or gradually diffused, and whether a benefit observed on PFS implies a
benefit in OS. Answering these questions requires an analytical framework in which
progression and survival can be analyzed together and parameterized to address key
questions. We propose a statistical modeling framework based on Cox regression and
time-dependent predictors and effects. A simple formulation of this model would
include a time-dependent indicator for progression, whose coefficient would measure the increase in risk of death following the event. This is very limiting, however;
it assumes that the timing of progression does not matter and that the increase in
risk of death is sustained indefinitely. A more flexible formulation can be built using
two descriptors of event: the timing of progression (TP) and time since progression
(TSP). These can be continuous measures or categorized (e.g., early vs. late TP), as
appropriate. The coefficient for TP reveals whether later progression is associated
with higher/lower subsequent mortality, while the coefficient of TSP reflects whether
and for how long the increase/decrease in mortality is sustained and whether it ever
returns to the level of patients who had not progressed. The impact of treatment can
be captured on each of these parameters separately. The proposed framework will
be illustrated with an example, and extension of the approach to other applications
(e.g., measuring the impact of a stroke on survival) will be discussed.
PRM231
Towards Integration of Research Evidence on Patient Preferences
in Coverage Decisions and Clinical Practice Guidelines: A Proposal
for A Taxonomy of Preference-Related Terms
Utens C M 1, Joore M A 1, van der Weijden T 2, Dirksen C D 2
of Clinical Epidemiology and Medical Technology Assessment, Maastricht University
Medical Centre, Maastricht, The Netherlands, 2Department of Family Medicine, CAPHRI School
for Public Health and Primary Care’, Maastricht University, the Netherlands, Maastricht, The
Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Department
Despite the availability of a large body of research evidence on patient preferences
for health outcomes and/or health care services, its use in health care policy decisions is limited. This contrasts with the current increasing attention for patient-cen-
A584
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
tred care and integration of the patient perspective in health care policy decisions.
A major challenge for the integration of evidence on patient preference is that
research on patient preferences is performed by various disciplines (e.g. psychology
and economics) that do not share a common language. It has been recommended to
perform conceptual and taxonomic work on the definition and conceptualisation
of ‘preference’ and related terms. The aim of this study was to develop a taxonomy
of preference-related terms. The taxonomy was developed in three steps: 1) the
identification of preference-related terms; 2) providing all identified terms with
a definition from the dictionary; and 3) the identification of dominant theories
or models from (health) economics and psychology that deal with the referencerelated terms. The proposed taxonomy consists of several building blocks that hold
all identified preference-related terms and demonstrate the relation between terms.
The building blocks are centred around a factual event. Ex ante to this factual event
lies building block 1, “decision making” holding terms like “choice” and “decision”.
Ex post lie building block 2 “evaluation process” and building block 3 “outcome of
evaluation process”. Building block 3 holds terms like “utility”, “quality of life” and
“satisfaction”. Building blocks 1-3 are influenced by building block 4 “the value
system”. This value system is divided in cognition, affect and conation and holds
terms like “beliefs”, “expectation”, “attitudes”, “desires” and “intention”. In this taxonomy, preferences can be considered as a part of the value system. The proposed
taxonomy is a first step towards conceptual clarity to facilitate the integration of
research evidence in health care policy decisions.
PRM232
When It May Not Be Necessary To Model Overall Survival for
Economic Evaluations of Anti-Cancer Drugs
Hoyle M 1, Hamilton W 1, Rudin C 2
of Exeter, Exeter, UK, 2Royal Devon & Exeter Hospital, Exeter, UK
.
.
.
1University
Overall survival (OS) is traditionally modelled in economic evaluations of anti-cancer
drugs. However, OS is commonly associated with problems such as immaturity of the
data, or confounding due to treatment switching or use of inappropriate treatments
after progression. Fortunately, analysis of historical trials reveals that there is good
evidence across a range of cancers that the mean time in post-progression survival
(PPS) is equal between treatment arms, i.e. Δ PPS = 0. Therefore, we recommend that
the default position is to assume equal mean times post-progression. If there is no
a priori biological reason to suppose that the PPS times are likely to differ between
treatments (e.g. due to differences in cross-resistance or long term toxicities between
treatments), our recommendation is that it should be assumed that the mean time in
progressive disease is equal between treatment arms if any of the following apply: OS
is very immature; treatments post-progression are substantially imbalanced between
treatment arms; in particular, treatment switching has occurred at progression; treatments post-progression are different to those routinely given in clinical practice; only
single arm trials are available. If none of the above apply, or if there are a priorireasons
to suggest that ΔPPS differs from 0, then the recommendation is to model OS and PFS
in the traditional way. For chronic cancers, it is recommended that analyses should
either assume equal times post initial treatment or equal time post progression. The
assumption that Δ PPS = 0 substantially simplifies the economic analysis because
cost-effectiveness becomes insensitive to OS. The methodology has been endorsed
twice by NICE appraisal committees in assessments of drugs for chronic myeloid
leukaemia. The cost-effectiveness of several drugs recently assessed by NICE are
re-calculated using the methods proposed. Next, we give simplified formulae for the
maximum drug price acceptable for reimbursement under the methodology.
PRM234
Feasibility of Conducting Retrospective Studies Using Hashtags
and Social Media Data From Facebook and Twitter
Volovyk A 1, Topachevskyi O 2
.
Cost-effectiveness models often require the consideration of a sequence of treatments. This enables the downstream implications of a treatment to be captured, and
alternative sequences to be compared. However, when many treatments are available,
the number of feasible sequences can be large. Also, if the objective is to maximise net
benefit for a given ICER threshold, then a comparative analysis to identify the optimal
sequence may not be possible. This is further compounded when using individual
patient simulation (IPS), because of the increased computational burden compared
with cohort approaches. The aim of this study was to undertake a systematic review
of optimisation methods that are applicable to a treatment sequencing IPS model.
28 key papers were identified across a range of academic subjects. Metaheuristics
including simulated annealing, tabu search and genetic algorithms have been
applied to simulation-optimisation problems and a bespoke review framework was
applied to determine their appropriateness. Based on the review, a framework for
the economic evaluation of treatment sequences was developed. The framework
considers the requirements of a cost-effectiveness model to efficiently evaluate
sequences, the application of the reviewed metaheuristics to determine the optimal
sequence, and the consideration of these results within a decision-making context.
This will be applied to a case study in rheumatoid arthritis. Alternative metaheuristic algorithms will be applied in an attempt to estimate a (near) optimal treatment
sequence. Preliminary results of these experiments will be available in time for the
November 2014 ISPOR conference. If these methods prove successful and feasible,
then the framework may have potential applicability to sequencing models in many
diseases. Whether there is the capability for it to be applicable within the current
process for decision-making organisations such as NICE remains an open question,
however, identifying an optimal sequence in a decision problem is of interest to
decision makers.
.
1Hashtago, Kiev, Ukraine, 2Digital
PRM236
Novel Indirect Comparison Methodology for Estimating
Time-Dependent Response To Antimuscarinics for the
Treatment of Oab
Snedecor S J , Sudharshan L
Pharmerit International, Bethesda, MD, USA
.
.
.
Background: Common indirect treatment comparison (ITC) methodology in overactive bladder involves combining absolute reduction in urge urinary incontinence
(UUI) episodes at study endpoint (e.g., week 12) to estimate the overall treatment
effect. Trials with differing endpoints must assume equivalence to be included in
the network. Further, analyses of endpoint data are not sufficient to predict efficacy
at intermediate time points (e.g. 4 or 6 weeks). We developed and tested an alternate
methodology to utilize available intermediate time points into an ITC of published
studies of fesoterodine and tolterodine. Methodology: Study-level mean UUI
reduction over time can be represented as the percent reduction from baseline,
which can be modeled as a monotonically-increasing function with a theoretical
maximum of 100%. This function is expressed with two parameters: %red = bi*time/
(ci + time), where bi is the maximum possible reduction for treatment i, and ci is the
time required to reach half the maximum reduction. The inverse %red is a linear
function of 1/time that can be used within a Bayesian ITC framework to generate
a placebo-adjusted indirect comparison of efficacy. Conclusions: The endpoint
results obtained from the alternate methodology were comparable to those obtained
from an endpoint ITC. This novel methodology has the additional advantage of
utilizing all available time point data within a single analysis, which can then be
used to generate efficacy estimates at intermediate time points, which may be
utilized within economic models. Limitations include unavailability of uncertainty
estimates of the %red variable and difficulty of estimating combinations of parameters within functional constraints. Finally, our alternate methodology may be used
for any longitudinal data exhibiting a monotonic increase or decrease and may be
expanded to include a network with multiple treatments.
Health Outcomes, Brussels, Belgium
Various online services such as Socialbakers, Keyhole, Gnip offer tools to analyze,
fetch and collect data from social media. This data is often presented in a form
of interactive web based dashboards, displaying various trends: number of posts,
mentions, shares, likes over time. Facebook and Twitter have an API to access data
on social media profiles of real people. Users profiles usually have data on age,
sex, employment and relationships status, specific group membership, etc. We
conducted a simple feasibility study using Facebook API in diabetes area using
profiles of people posting hashtags as a primary source of data. We then expanded
the sample by adding people who liked, shared and reposted messages containing
diabetes relaed hashtags #Diabetes, #dedoc, #ourD. We applied exclusion criteria
to derive a sample consisting of patients only, hence targeting specific group of
people. Our assumption was that people who interact with posts containing specific hashtag have diabetes. We used descriptive statistics to characterize obtained
sample (n= 17296) by calculating mean age, age distribution histogram, proportion
of males and females and other descriptive metrics. We also calculated conditional
probabilities of being in multiple disease area Facebook groups such as obesity
groups or groups of people with increased risk of cardiovascular disease. Future
area of research will be concentrated on aspects of in-degree centrality in network of diabetic people, hypothesis testing between two different groups, analyses
of changes in positive/negative posting trends following drug launch, locating
agents and influencers in the network and conducting prospective studies in
social media using hashtags. Social Media data can be a valuable addition to a
real life post launch data. Evidence on changes in positive/negative postings can
be used as an additional piece of information in Phase IV studies or risk-sharing
agreements.
PRM237
Bayesian Models for Cost-Effectiveness Analysis in the Presence of
Structural Zero Costs
PRM235
A Framework for the Economic Evaluation of Sequential Therapies
for Chronic Conditions
Moran P , Harrington P , Ryan M
Health Information and Quality Authority, Dublin, Ireland
Tosh J , Stevenson M , Strong M , Akehurst R
University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK
.
.
.
.
Baio G
University College London, London, UK
.
Bayesian modelling for cost-effectiveness data has received much attention in
both the health economics and the statistical literature, in recent years. Costeffectiveness data are characterised by a relatively complex structure of relationships linking a suitable measure of clinical benefit (\eg QALYs) and the associated
costs. Simplifying assumptions, such as (bivariate) normality of the underlying distributions are usually not granted, particularly for the cost variable, which is characterised by markedly skewed distributions. In addition, individual-level datasets are
often characterised by the presence of structural zeros in the cost variable. Hurdle
models can be used to account for the presence of excess zeros in a distribution and
have been applied in the context of cost data. We extend their application to costeffectiveness data, defining a full Bayesian specification which consists of a pattern
model for the individual probability of null costs, a marginal model for the costs
and a conditional model for the measure of effectiveness (given the observed costs).
The model is presented using a working example to describe its main features. In
addition, we present a R package (BCEs0) that directly implements this framework
and can be used to run a full Bayesian cost-effectiveness analysis of individual data
in the presence of structural zero costs for some subjects.
PRM238
Effective Prioritisation of National Health Technology
Assessments
.
.
.
Prioritisation of assessment topics is an essential activity within HTA. Failure to
successfully identify technologies that are likely to have the greatest impact on
the health system carries an opportunity cost that is measured in poorer decision
A585
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
making, reduced patient benefits and less efficient use of public resources. Within
individual agencies, prioritisation is also a business function that must balance the
need to plan for and manage the allocation of resources with the need to provide
expeditious advice to decision makers and adapt quickly to changing circumstances.
This research describes a transparent and responsive framework for selecting health
technologies to assess, minimising the potential for important technologies to be
missed and providing a useful resource for HTA agencies facing similar issues.
Topics are identified through a mix of routine horizon scanning, a formally convened
advisory group consisting of the major decision makers from within the publicly
funded health system and informal business intelligence gathering. Screening is
carried out to eliminate technologies that are clearly unsuitable and provisionally grade all remaining candidates according to three principal criteria; 1) clinical
impact (patient population, potential incremental effect and availability of alternatives); 2) economic impact (incremental costs and potential disruptive effect on how
services are currently organised) and 3) policy impact (link to decision-making and
factors that make it likely to feature on the national health care agenda). The screening process feeds into an in-depth expert group discussion, which also considers
operational issues such as the extent of the advice required to inform the decision,
data availability and costs associated with the assessment. We also describe a software visualisation tool developed to facilitate the prioritisation process, as well as
measures for quality assurance and ongoing performance evaluation.
PRM239
Goal Attainment Scaling – A Useful Individualized Clinical
Outcome Measure
Jones M , Kharawala S , Langham J , Gandhi P
Bridge Medical, London, UK
.
.
.
.
Goal Attainment Scales (GAS) capture outcomes relevant to individual patients and
provide “real-world” outcome measurement. This abstract will describe the background to their use, their operationalization, strengths and limitations. Traditional
outcome measures assess a standardised set of questions regardless of their relevance
to each patient. GAS overcomes these weaknesses because it is an individualised
assessment based on achievement of goals which are personal to each patient.
Despite its widely cited use in academic literature and good psychometric properties it is rarely used in drug intervention studies. Operationalisation of GAS varies
but follows these basic steps: 1) The patient’s specific problem areas are assessed and
goals for each defined; 2) A GAS for each goal is created and an “expected outcome” for
each agreed; 3) Goal attainment levels are defined for each point on, typically, a 5-point
scale (expected outcomes are usually scored 0; baseline is often -2, but may be -1 or
0 depending on potential for deterioration). Each level must be carefully described
in a way that is relevant, observable, measurable and consistent with study design.
Published standardised goals are available; and 4) A standardized statistical formula
provides overall goal attainment. Benefits include: ease of use; relevant goals; no
redundant items; assessment of multiple domains; provides quantifiable and applicable outcomes across different conditions and severities; potentially more sensitive
measure than traditional scales. Limitations include: potential bias; appropriate goal
selection and outcome prediction; observable changes may differ from pre-defined
outcomes; time consuming; may require independent GAS assessors for blinded trials; may require “control” goals not affected by treatment; statistical issues around
single overall score. In capturing those outcomes relevant to each individual patient,
GAS has potential use in supporting product labeling claims and value assessment
of a medicine by HTA and payers.
PRM240
Avoiding and Identifying Errors and Other Threats To the
Credibility of Health Economic Models
Tappenden P , Chilcott J
University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK
.
.
Health economic models have become the primary vehicle for undertaking economic evaluation and are used in various health care jurisdictions across the world
to inform decisions about the use of new and existing health technologies. Models
are required because a single source of evidence, such as a randomised controlled
trial, is rarely sufficient to provide all relevant information about the expected costs
and health consequences of all competing decision alternatives. Whilst models are
used to synthesise all relevant evidence, they also contain assumptions, abstractions
and simplifications. By their very nature, all models are therefore “wrong.” Whilst
the presence of imperfect evidence provides the impetus for developing models, it is
also the reason why we can never fully validate them. As such, the interpretation of
estimates of the cost-effectiveness of health technologies requires careful judgements
about the degree of confidence that can be placed in the models from which they
are drawn. The presence of a single error or inappropriate judgement within a model
may lead to inappropriate decisions, an inefficient allocation of health care resources
and ultimately suboptimal outcomes for patients. This study sets out a taxonomy
of threats to the credibility of health economic models. The taxonomy segregates
threats to model credibility into three broad categories (1) unequivocal errors, (2)
violations and (3) matters of judgement, and maps these across the main elements of
the model development process. These three categories of threats to model credibility
are defined according to the existence of criteria for judging correctness, the degree
of force with which such criteria can be applied, and the means by which potential
threats can be handled. A range of suggested processes and techniques for avoiding and identifying these threats is put forward with the intention of prospectively
increasing the credibility of any given model.
PRM241
Assessing Heterogeneity of Treatment Effect Using Real World
Data
Murray J F 1, Kadziola Z 2, Zagar A 1
1Eli Lilly and Company, Indianapolis, IN, USA, 2Eli Lilly Regional Operations GmbH, Vienna,
Austria
.
.
.
.
There is increasing scrutiny of pharmaceuticals on their value proposition as well as
a growing demand for evidence on real world effectiveness once they are commercially available. There are many challenges in producing valid and reliable estimates
of real world effectiveness. A major challenge is assessing a product’s effectiveness
relative to why patients may respond differently to a treatment (i.e., identifying
groups of patients exhibiting “Heterogeneity of Treatment Effect” (HTE) using subgroup identification methods). Assessing HTE is critical to understanding differences that may exist between the efficacy observed in randomized clinical trials
and a product’s real world effectiveness. Understanding causes for HTE is required
for correct attribution of any observed difference between efficacy and effectiveness
to the product versus other sources (e.g., patient behavior); Not recognizing and
accounting for HTE will confound assessment of a product’s performance, which
ultimately affects its acceptance and use by payers, physicians, and patients. Failure
to define and incorporate subgroups is a frequent criticism of systematic evidence
reviews and comparative effectiveness research reports. However, the analytical
methods for finding factors that define subgroups that explain HTE are challenging
due to many known statistical issues (e.g., limited statistical power, multiplicity
adjustments) Real world data exacerbates the analytical challenges due in part to
biases (e.g., selection bias) and issues (e.g., data quality) inherent in the data. We
will describe the data and bias challenges that create these analytical complexities for detecting the cause and magnitude of HTE when using real world data. We
will present results from a simulation experiment that compared and validated
several subgroup methods developed to address these data and analytical issues.
We simulated 22 permutations of subgroups with known identification criteria and
treatment effects to determine the performance of the methods.
PRM242
Impacts of Epro Data Collection Mode Selection on Patient
Inclusion
Holzbaur E , Ross J , Wade M , Rothrock T
Almac Clinical Technologies, Souderton, PA, USA
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The Electronic Patient Reported Outcome (ePRO) data collection
mode selected for trials is often based on efforts to minimize timelines, budgets, and patient burden. However, are sponsors inadvertently introducing bias
into trial results in this selection process? This conceptual paper reviews common ePRO modes and explores patient groups that may be excluded. Methods:
Common modes for ePRO data collection are reviewed. An assessment of potential
patient groups that may be excluded is performed based on ePRO mode. Results:
Common ePRO modes include telephone, web, and handheld device. As sponsors
look to reduce costs, improve data quality, and reduce patient burden, industry has
continued its shift towards patients using their own telephone, computer, tablet,
or smartphone and away from sponsors provisioning these devices to patients.
Choice of patient-provisioned device: Patients from certain geographic areas may
be excluded where internet connections and cellular/mobile telephone reception
is limited. Requiring patients to use their personal web/mobile device may exclude
patient groups with certain economic, cultural, or demographic characteristics
who live in rural or underdeveloped areas. Choice of sponsor-provisioned device:
Logistics issues, i.e. shipment of devices including customs considerations, reliability of data transmission, storage and replacement of devices and cords, training, etc. Conclusions: The objective of clinical trials is to establish treatment
effectiveness, generalizable to the overall patient population. ePRO mode selection
may impact inclusion of individuals from certain economic, cultural, demographic,
and geographic areas. Exclusion of these groups could impact results; therefore, it is
important to understand the potential bias that can be introduced when selecting
an ePRO mode. Proper planning should include assessment of patient population
and inclusion of regions that would render generalizability. ePRO mode selection
should be based on which method works best for the required regions to optimize
inclusion, as well as the patient population’s characteristics to minimize burden.
PRM243
Clinical Outcome Assessment (Coa) Instrument Scoring: the
Validity and Precision of Unweighted Summary Scores VersUS Irt
Weighted Scores, and the Added Value of Irt Standard Errors
Coon C D 1, Lenderking W R 2
1Adelphi Values, Boston, MA, USA, 2Evidera, Lexington, MA, USA
.
.
.
.
COA development experts in recent years have given thought to the psychometric evaluation of instruments and their ability to detect meaningful differences
between patient groups. The scoring of the instruments, however, has received less
attention, with various approaches sometimes suggested without a clear preference or justification. The score is ultimately used for evaluating patient outcomes
and treatment efficacy and is what requires validation, so this seems like a significant omission. We examine the traditionally accepted unweighted summary score
approach and compare it to the more complex IRT weighted scoring to evaluate if
the gain in precision justifies the increased scoring complexity. Precision may differ
depending on whether the score is close to the mean of the population or closer to
the extreme ends of the distribution. Simulated data are used for this comparison to
evaluate if the precision of the scores differs depending on the location of the score
and if the instrument is used for group comparisons versus individual diagnosis.
Additionally, we recognize that the reliability of a scale is likely to be variable across
the range of its scores. With that in mind, we consider an approach to comparing
mean scores between groups that incorporates the standard error of each individual
IRT score into the model. By using the IRT standard errors, we can adjust for the
different levels of uncertainty associated with ranges of scores along the scale,
ultimately providing us greater confidence in the group comparison results.
PRM244
Evaluation of Estimators of Treatment Effect in Observational
Studies
Faries D E 1, Lipkovich I 2, Kadziola Z 3
.
.
.
.
A586
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
1Eli Lilly and Company, Indianapolis, IN, USA, 2Quintiles Innovation, Morrisville, NC, USA, 3Eli
Lilly Regional Operations GmbH, Vienna, Austria
Many methods are currently available to estimate treatment effects with observational data. We conducted simulations evaluating some well-established methods
(regression, propensity weighting, stratification or matching on propensity) as
well as some newer ideas (tree based methods, local control, entropy balancing,
prognostic scoring) under several different scenarios including homogeneous and
heterogeneous treatment effects. Mean square error, bias, coverage probability for
the overall treatment effect, and prediction accuracy of personalized treatment
contrast (for scenarios with heterogeneous treatment effect) were assessed. We
will present some guidelines for estimating treatment effects with observational
data and strategies that are appropriate with respect to (i) tree-structured treatment models (ii) polynomial outcome model with interactions (iii) presence of
noise covariates.
PRM245
Health Technology Assessment and Environmental Costs: Time for
Health Care To Catch Up?
Marsh K 1, Ganz M 2, Hsu J 3, Strandberg-Larsen M 4, Palomino Gonzalez R 4, Lund N4
1Evidera, London, UK, 2Evidera, Lexington, MA, USA, 3Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA,
4Novo Nordisk A/S, Bagsværd, Denmark
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The United Nations recently published its most definitive report,
calling for greater action on climate change. Historically, however, health technology assessment (HTA) has had a more narrow focus with emphasis on the
health of patients and health inequalities. Recently some health care decision
makers have extended the focus to include the environment, e.g. the Swedish
Government is considering a Green Premium for generic drugs, and the UK NHS
has CO2 emissions targets. We consider the case for incorporating environmental
impacts into HTA, and the associated methodological challenges. Methods: We
reviewed health care decisions where environmental impacts were considered
- a summary will be provided in the paper. We then convened a workshop with
key opinion leaders. Results: There are two lines of reasoning for incorporating
environmental impacts into HTA: 1) Direct impact: changes in the environment
could affect the health of individuals; and 2) Health decision makers’ objectives are
broader and are informed by other policy goals, such as the CO2 targets adopted
by the NHS in the UK. We also identified two types of methodological challenges
for implementation. First, the nascent evidence base is insufficient to support
the accurate comparison of the environmental impact of technologies. Second,
uncertainty about how best to incorporate evidence into HTA. The cost-utility
analysis approach favoured by many HTA agencies could capture some of the value
of environmental impacts – in particular, those that generate health impacts. Both
cost-benefit analysis and multi-criteria decision analysis have potential, having
both previously been applied to evaluate both health and environmental interventions, though are less familiar to health care decision makers. Conclusion:
Further work is needed to track decision makers’ demand for evidence on environmental impacts. Robust methods also are needed for capturing and incorporating
environmental data as part of HTA as more decision makers begin incorporating
environmental impacts.
PRM246
Multiple Decision Criteria for Assessing An Incremental CostEffectiveness Ratio of Expensive Health Technologies
Kamae I , Yamabe K , Sugimoto T
The University of Tokyo, Graduate School of Public Policy, Tokyo, Japan
.
.
Objectives: To develop a new method that naturally extends the UK NICE way
of single-threshold for incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER). It aims to provide multiple decision criteria for assessing an ICER of expensive health technologies such as molecular-targeted cancer drugs and regenerative medicine
products. Methods: We took a theoretical approach, provided that the cost (C)
-effectiveness (E) function, C = f (E), is known regarding the treatment alternatives
for a disease area, given two points Pb and Ps plotted with a pair of C and E on the C-E
plane, where Pb represents the best comparator, and Ps as the second best for a new
technology X located at the point. Px (ex (effectiveness; known), cx (cost; assumed)).
At first, given a single threshold of ICER, the “expensiveness” in the C-E function
was defined using a tangent/derivative method (poster presentation PRM119 by
Kamae I, et. al. in ISPOR Montreal 2014). Second, we estimated three benchmarks
based on the C-E function: 1) the ICER of Pb to Ps, 2) the tangent at Pb, 3) the tangent
at the point on the C-E curve which intersects with the vertical line at the point:
(E, C) = (ex, 0). Then the magnitude relationship was examined between the three
benchmarks and the ICER of the technology X defined by the slope of the line connecting Px with Pb. Results: Multiple decision criteria at six levels were identified
and formulated as for acceptance of the “expensive” cost-effectiveness of a new
health technology: 1) unconditional acceptance (simple dominance), 2) preferred
(extended dominance), 3) less preferred, 4) minimally preferred, 5) not preferred,
but negotiable, and 6) cannot accept. Example calculations clarified how the theory
works in practical setting. Conclusions: Our approach offers multiple decision
criteria to assess expensive health technologies as a natural extension beyond the
NICE way of single-threshold assessment.
PRM247
Efficacy, Effectiveness and the “Efficacy-To-Effectiveness Gap”:
Review of the Current State of Play and Perspectives. First Results
From the Imi Getreal Consortium
Nordon C 1, Karcher H 2, Pichler F 3, Rossignol M 4, Abbe A 5, Abenhaim L 6
Lilly and Company,
Windlesham, Surrey, UK, 4McGill University, Montreal, QC, Canada, 5SANOFI, Chilly-Mazarin,
France, 6London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
1LASER Analytica, Paris, France, 2LASER Analytica, London, UK, 3Eli
Background: The concept of “efficacy-effectiveness gap” (EEG) has gained awareness in the scientific community and started to erode the confidence in decisions
taken on drugs: authorization, appraisal, and medical choice between alternatives.
The Innovative Medication Initiative was launched the GetReal project to tackle
this issue. It gathers representatives of more than 14 pharmaceutical companies,
public institutions such as EMA, HAS, ZIN, NICE and Academic research teams and
aims at (1) better understanding how evidence of efficacy and effectiveness should
be considered and reconciled and (2) proposing operational solutions. Objective
and method: We conducted a focused literature review to gain clarity and perspective on the concept of EEG: on which historical background it emerged, how it
is understood and which solutions have been suggested to narrow it. Results: A
disconnect between outcomes from clinical trials and information needed for clinical practice has been identified in the process of standardization of drugs assessment (Schwartz, 1967), evidence-based medicine (Feinstein, 1997), and knowledge
dissemination (Lehman, 1995), and called the EEG. Several factors have been identified to explain it, including characteristics of real-life health care settings (physician and patient behaviours) and the weak generalizability of clinical trials due to
their design. The need for a more systematic assessment of effectiveness is now
widely acknowledged. Adaptive licencing was recently proposed to account of the
sequential evidence generation on drugs outcome (Eichler, 2011). The EEG can be
conceptualized as the interaction of drug effect and “real-life” contextual factors
(Unutzer, 1999). Conclusions: Although the literature on the EEG is extensive,
the contextual factors that actually impact drug’s outcome in real-life are still to
be identified. Innovative and integrative study methods and designs are required
to enable the EEG to be addressed adequately early on in the drug development
process: this is the next step in the GetReal project.
PRM248
Health Technology Assessments for Personalised Medicines:
Are Current Methodologies Suitable for the Assessment of
Personalised Therapies?
Lauks S 1, Gee A 1, Wilson L E 2
Consulting, Reading, UK, 2Quintiles, Reading, UK
.
.
.
.
1Quintiles
Objective: An increased drive towards personalised healthcare and medicine by
policy-makers, alongside technological advances in medicines and diagnostics,
is leading to more personalised medicines coming to market. Given that personalised medicines differ from traditional medicines in their development, use and
cost, previously published articles have stated that current health technology
assessments (HTA) methodologies are not designed to appropriately evaluate
these technologies. This research was conducted to provide insights on methods
for evaluating personalised medicines and what modifications to current HTA
processes would be needed to ensure robust and timely assessment. Methods:
Qualitative interviews were conducted with five experts in personalised medicine and market access across the UK, US and Germany to discuss the movement towards and benefits of personalised medicines as well as the key metrics
on which they should be evaluated. These insights, supported with secondary
research, were used to provide suggestions on the structure and methodology of
personalised medicine assessments and how current assessment processes would
need to be altered to accommodate these unique technologies. Results: The key
areas where personalised medicines would need special consideration in HTAs
identified were: - Study design: population size, geography, ethnicity - Companion
diagnostics: cost, logistics - Unmet need: individualised view of perceived benefit
- Cost effectiveness: costs and outcomes of therapy and companion diagnostic,
reduction in overall health care costs Conculsion: The key areas identified are
discussed in further detail, specifically, as to how they could be incorporated into
current HTA models to effectively assess personalised medicines and how they
would influence the decision-making process.
PRM249
Challenges In Meeting Evidence Needs Of Payer, Physician, Patient
And Industry Stakeholders For Novel Therapeutics
Pauer L
Santen, Inc., Emeryville, CA, USA
.
Objectives: Evidence development programs for novel therapeutics must simultaneously demonstrate safety, efficacy, clinical significance, economic value and
effectiveness to meet diverse stakeholder requirements. This is further complicated by variable evidence needs across global markets and resource limitations.
Understanding how to address all stakeholder perspectives for treatments in ophthalmology was accomplished through primary research. Methods: Conducting
primary research through in-depth phone interviews and advisory board meetings with patient, payer and clinical stakeholders in three ophthalmic conditions:
chronic, non-infectious posterior uveitis, wet age-related macular degeneration
and glaucoma provided important insights. Patient research questions focused on
identifying patient burden and unmet needs. Further research with physicians and
payers was accomplished through evaluating diverse criteria applied to assessing
clinical and economic evidence plans. Results: When therapeutic areas lack
universally accepted clinical guidelines that can be relied upon to guide treatment decisions, payers rely heavily on clinicians to understand current standard
of care and accepted endpoints. Clinician leaders, interestingly, were not in universal agreement. Moreover, physicians and payers differed on use of economic
endpoints and appropriate therapeutic comparators. Physicians differed on the
endpoints that would be most relevant for demonstrating treatment response
and how to address the patient burden. Overall, clinicians were more willing to
consider clinical trial endpoints that differed from those endpoints found in published data. Payers preferred to have consistent endpoints to facilitate indirect
comparisons between treatments. Conclusions: The differing needs of payer
and clinician stakeholders create additional barriers for development planning
for novel therapeutics, particularly when published treatment guidelines are not
available. Manufacturers must consider multi-stakeholder insights across global
markets in clinical trial design development. 1Santen Pharmaceuticals, Emeryville,
CA, USA. 2GfK Market Access, Wayland, MA, USA.
A587
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PRM250
Pathways of Implementation of Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis
Into Orphan Drug Approval Procedure for Drug Supply Programs in
Russian Federation
Serpik V G 1, Yagudina R I 2
Research Institute of Public Health, Moscow, Russia, 2First Moscow State Medical
University named after I. M. Sechenov, Moscow, Russia
.
.
.
.
1National
Background: While the orphan drug supply program is in progress, development
of decision-making rules for approving orphan drug for supply program of Russian
Federation becomes very actual. Real world data provides evidence, that routine
approaches for approving such kind of drugs, e.i. pharmacoeconomic conclusions,
are not applicable. Than the need in more appropriate approaches is existed.
Multi-criteria decision analysis is one such approaches (MCDA). Objective: To
evaluate prospective of implementation of MCDA in health care system of Russian
Federation and to develop road map of MCDA in Russia. Methods: Literature
review, cluster analysis, interviewing experts. Results: The first step (qualitive)
to implement MCDA is to test various MCDA methods to find out optimal one for
Russian Federation: it is expected to select the most relevant criteria from the wide
range of them. First of all, MCDA is considered to be the instrument to improve the
quality of discussion and its transparency, to underline different point of view and
unmet needs. On the second stage it may be possible to use quantity MCDA assessment as a rule to approve orphan drugs for drug supply programs. Local recommendations for MCDA in Russian Federation has been published. Conclusion:
Implementation of MCDA as assisting instrument for orphan drug approving for
drug supply programs is likely to be a valuable approach, that may improve the
quality, transparency of decision-making process and to provide social equity for
accepting decisions.
PRM251
Propensity Score Matching and Subclassification With Multi-Level
Treatments
Kadziola Z 1, Yang S 2, Imbens G W 3, Cui Z 4, Faries D E 4
1Eli Lilly Regional Operations GmbH, Vienna, Austria, 2Harvard School of Public Health, Boston,
MA, USA, 3Graduate School of Business, Stanford University, and NBER, Stanford, CA, USA,, 4Eli
Lilly and Company, Indianapolis, IN, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
There is extensive literature on methods, such as propensity scoring, for estimating the causal effects for two treatments using real world data. Much less
work has been done for the more general setting with three or more treatments.
Whereas the literature has suggested that these propensity-based methods do
not naturally extend to the multi-level treatment case, we show, using the concept of weak unconfoundedness, that adjusting for or matching on a scalar function of the covariates removes biases associated with observed covariates. We
focused on subclassification and matching approaches as these have found to
be effective for two treatments and are among the most popular methods in
that setting. We apply the proposed methods to an analysis of the effectiveness
of treatments for fibromyalgia from a prospective observational study. We also
carried out a simulation study to assess the performance of those new methods
relative to such approaches like: pairwise propensity score matching; matching
on the Mahalanobis distance of all covariates; matching on the set of propensity
scores (with the number of scores equal to the number of distinct treatment levels minus one (Rassen, 2013)); weighting on the inverse of the binary treatment
propensity scores (McCaffrey, 2013). The simulations suggest that the proposed
methods are simple and viable options for comparing the effectiveness of three
or more treatments. RASSEN et al.: Matching by propensity score in cohort studies
with three treatment groups. Epidemiology 24, 401–9. MCCAFFREY et al.: A tutorial
on propensity score estimation for multiple treatments using generalized boosted
models. Stat. Med. 32,3388–414.
PRM252
Getting To Reimbursement Faster: Combining Randomised,
Pragmatic, and Observational Clinical Trial Data
Alsop J
Numerus Ltd, Wokingham, UK
.
Reimbursement authorities often require pharmaceutical companies to provide
them with more than just placebo-controlled data from RCTs. Instead, they typically seek data from a wider “real-world” setting, where the focus is on generating
evidence of comparative effectiveness. The natural temptation for many pharmaceutical companies is to provide this evidence from separate, post-market
approval studies. However, this approach can be expensive and undoubtedly leads
to delays in reimbursement. We propose that both the additional costs of evidence
gathering and the delays between regulatory and reimbursement approvals could
be reduced by combining the main design elements of randomised, pragmatic,
and prospective observational studies into a single, integrated Phase 3/4 study.
This single study approach would typically begin with a standard RCT phase
where, for example, an initial cohort of patients would be randomised to receive
either the investigational therapy or placebo. Either in parallel with or following this phase, a second patient cohort would be randomised under pragmatic
clinical trial conditions with the aim of comparing the investigational therapy
with placebo and a limited number of active comparator treatments. Lastly, a
third (observational) cohort would be enrolled and allocated to a wider range
of therapies, as per clinical practice. Data from the RCT cohort would be used
to obtain limited regulatory approval. Following this, data from the pragmatic
cohort, once available, would then be formally combined using standard statistical
techniques with data from the RCT cohort in order to obtain a wider regulatory
approval and possibly some form of conditional reimbursement. The pragmatic
and observational cohorts would then provide the comparative effectiveness
data to allow for reimbursement across different patient groups. We outline the
strengths and weaknesses of this approach, and discuss its operational considerations.
PRM253
An Epidemiologic Modeling Application To Pharmacoeconomics for
Improved Health Care Planning
Cid Ruzafa J , Cox A , Merinopoulou E , Baggaley R , Leighton P , Desai K
Evidera, London, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
Epidemiologic and pharmacoeconomic models differ in terms of populations considered, mathematical techniques used, and questions addressed. A typical pharmacoeconomic model assesses chronic or acute conditions, uses Markov techniques,
and considers a closed patient group receiving a defined therapy to assess incremental costs needed to achieve gains in quality adjusted life years. A typical epidemiologic model assesses vaccination or public health interventions for infectious
disease using differential equations and considers open populations representing
communities to estimate prevalence or numbers of disease cases averted. The manner of conducting sensitivity analyses also differs. In oncology, in which multiple
lines of treatment are available, the epidemiologic approach has application to estimate the patient point prevalence or the number of patients who can start on a line
of therapy over a certain time period, when this cannot be determined from clinical
trials or registers (which usually focus on single lines of therapy or limited types of
patients that are not representative of the overall patient population). The approach
consists of conceptualizing an open population that incorporates incidence of the
condition and the transition of patients through various lines of treatment until
death, and uses systems of difference/differential equations. Parameterization is
challenging if there are several prognostic factors to describe the patient population,
multiple or complex treatment pathways, and a wide range of variability. Parameters
are obtained from the published literature, analyses of database information, and/
or surveys to experts in the field. Steady state solutions of the model equations
estimate point and period prevalence. This approach is applicable to gastrointestinal stromal tumours and multiple myeloma. Resulting estimates are important for
budget impact analysis and health care services planning by reducing uncertainty
associated with identifying the patient numbers eligible for a given treatment.
Epidemiologic modelling permits a framework to estimate disease prevalence that
is little used in pharmacoeconomics.
PRM254
Non-Interventional Research Ethical Requirements in England and
France: Shared Experience From A Binational Research Project
Guillemot J , Boval M C , Gauthier A
Amaris, London, UK
.
.
.
.
Background: Ethical review for non-interventional research is progressively becoming part of research standards. This evolution ensures that participants in research
are respectfully considered. In practice, information on ethical requirements for noninterventional research seems insufficient. Increasing and legitimate expectations
from peer-reviewed journals regarding reviews by ethics committees sometimes
challenge researchers. In this presentation, we share our experience of investigating
ethical requirements for conducting a questionnaire-based research on physicians in
France and England. Methods: This investigation consisted of a documentary analysis, including official guidance documents on ethical requirements, communications
with institutions and publications reviews. Documents were identified using an ad
hoc search on official websites. Publications were identified on PubMed. Findings:
In England, the service of the National Research Ethics Service (NRES) serves as the
ethics reviewer. It offers an informal preliminary review of the study protocol and estimates ethical risks associated with non-interventional research projects. Depending
of the target population, the methods and the risk level associated with the research
project, the NRES states whether a formal ethics application is necessary or not. In
case of low risk projects the NRES supplies an email which can be used as a justification for peer-reviewed journals. In France, structures to support ethical reviews for
non-interventional research are the result of an on-going reform. Comités de Protection
de la Personne, or CPPs, fulfil the role of ethics reviewers although they were initially
designed to collaborate for hospital-based research. Gaining ethical review in France
was more complex due to the infrequent character of such request from the industry. Conclusion: This experience showed the increasing role of ethical requirements in non-interventional research. It is a domain in constant movement which
calls for innovative approaches to compile and disseminate information regarding
ethical requirements for non-interventional research across Europe and the world,
especially regarding cross-national research projects.
PRM255
Real World Studies, Challenges, Needs and Trends from the
Industry
Batrouni M , Comet D , Meunier J P
Axonal, Paris, France
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To understand key challenges, needs and trends for conducting real
world studies (RWS). Methods: An online survey conducted in September 2013
within key players in the pharmaceutical and medical device industry in EU and US.
456 persons have been solicited through emails and phone calls, 107 have responded
to the questionnaire. Respondents were mostly occupying senior positions in medical affairs, health economics and outcome research. Results: 27% RWS conducted
are requested by Health Authorities, 73% on the industry initiative. 75% of those
studies are subcontracted to a CRO. The main criteria of choice are the experience
in RWS, particularly in the regulation process, the capacity to deliver on time and a
flexible and adaptable structure. The RWS activity is expected to increase by 25 % in
the next two years. Most of those studies have safety and effectiveness objectives
and to a lesser extent drug utilization and health economics and the most common
therapeutic areas are: oncology, cardiovascular and metabolic disorders. In addition,
pharmaceutical companies are conducting more and more epidemiological studies
to prepare dossiers for market access (disease understanding, unmet needs, population targeting). Conclusion: The pharmaceutical market is becoming global and
is expanding into new countries and therapeutic areas. The result is an increase
in the need for RWS where the regulatory agencies are asking for additional data
A588
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
concerning the long term safety and effectiveness of the drugs when used on larger
populations. Pharmaceutical companies face big challenges for the coming years
especially in EU and there is an increase need for local regulatory knowledge. There’s
still need to increase awareness for the importance of real world studies and the
impact it has on the patient’s life.
PRM256
Publication Manual of Budget Impact Analysis (Bia) by the
Department of Science and Technology of the Ministry of Health
(Decit)
Koury C D N 1, Elias F T S 2
1FIPE -Fundação de Ensino e Pesquisas Econômicas, Brasilia, Brazil, 2Ministry of Health of Brazil,
Brasilia, Brazil
.
.
.
.
.
.
The epidemiological and economic methods applied to health technologies evaluations had a significant development in the last two decades. The need to balance
the incorporation of new technologies in health care and limited financial resources
promoted the construction and application of instruments supporting the decision
making of health technology. The requirement Budget Impact Analysis formally
stated in Law 12.401/2011 establishing the incorporation process technologies in
SUS. In this context, in 2010/2011, the National Agency of Sanitary Surveillance
(ANVISA) and DECIT, in partnership Institute for Health Technology Assessment
(IATS) for drawing up of this guideline. In the first stage of development were
used international recommendations of Canada, Australia, the UK and Poland,
the recommendations of the International Society for PharmacoEconomics and
Outcomes Research (ISPOR) and the methods used in studies of budgetary impact
that had already been published. Afterwards, drafted a preliminary version of the
Guideline and a standard tool - Excel worksheets - to estimate the uptake of monetary resources required for adoption of new technologies. Revisions were carried
out by technicians DECIT and health agencies, and the proposal was submitted to
the Working Group on Development of Methodology REBRATS, composed of experts
and academic researchers from several Brazilian states. Were also carried out workshops for the application of spreadsheets. In 2012, the first edition of the Guidelines
was published two thousand copies in Portuguese in order to provide best practice
recommendations for studies of budget impact.
DISEASE - SPECIFIC STUDIES
RESPIRATORY-RELATED DISORDERS – Clinical Outcomes Studies
PRS1
Prospective Study on Cost-Effectiveness of Nurse Interviw
Introducing Retesting With in Vitro Diagnostics (IVD) To Parents of
Children With Suspected Food Allergy in Finland
Hermansson L L 1, Korhonen K 2, Silvan M 2, Rantanen S 2, Isoaho R 3, Savolainen J 3
1Thermo Fisher Scientific, Uppsala, Sweden, 2Härkätie Primary Care Center, Lieto, Finland,
3University of Turku, Turku, Finland
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Accordance to Finnish Allergy Program 2008-2018, to decrease food
avoidance diets by 50%. Focus in algorithm with patient history +IVD in school
children with suspected food allergy and reason for declining re-diagnosis. NICE
clinical guideline (Food Allergy Diagnoses, 2011) suggested further work made
on effect of diagnosing allergies in realistic population and cost effectiveness of
retesting. Methods: Prospective trial with patients from Finnish primary care
database (2885 school children). School kitchen had allergy restricted diets for 179
children. In the pilot phase, 179 families were contacted by letter. Of the 24 who
were included in pilot, 17 were not allergic (70%). In this study families were interviewed by telephone. Of 156 families 107 agreed to participate in this study and
47 children will be diagnosed by component resolved diagnostics (CRD) and 60
with sIgE and CRD. Results: Prevalence of food avoidance diets: 6,2%. Reasons for
declining re-testing: 23 were not allergic, 9 were busy, 9 have own physician, 3 did
not believe allergy tests, 8 scared of needles, 7 already tested, 4 tested often due to
health problems, 2 in pilot study and 7 did not recognize a benefit. Conclusions:
Telephone consultation by nurse decreased special diets for 23 children (13%) and 39
(22%) had non-medical reason to decline retesting. Nurse consultation to introduce
retesting with IVD can be considered as cost effective approach in decreasing food
avoidance diets in children.
PRS2
Effectiveness of Montelukast on Asthma Control in Infants:
A Claims Data Study
Belhassen M 1, Ginoux M 1, Laigle V 2, chanut-Vogel C 2, Lamezec L 2, de Blic J 3, Fauroux B 3,
de Pouvourville G 4, Laforest L 1, Van Ganse E 1
1University of Lyon, Lyon, France, 2Laboratoires MSD France, Courbevoie, France, 3Pediatric
Medicine Necker University, Paris, France, 4ESSEC Business School, Cergy, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Montelukast 4mg (MTL-4) is an add-on therapy for asthmatic infants.
Given the quality and exhaustivity of the data, French claims data (SNIIR-AM) is a
relevant tool to investigate MTL-4 effectiveness in infants. The objective was to compare the effectiveness of MTL-4, associated or not with ICS, vs. ICS without MTL-4, on
health outcomes of infants with mild to moderate uncontrolled asthma. Methods:
Infants (6-24 months) receiving ≥ 2 consecutive dispensing of respiratory drugs from
2010 to 2011, and presenting an initial exacerbation within 6 months of the first
dispensing were preselected. Asthma-related outcomes included hospitalizations,
dispensing of oral corticosteroids, addition of short-acting beta agonists to existing respiratory therapy, switch to a higher ICS dosage, or nebulized CS. The studied
groups were infants receiving MTL-4 +/- ICS (MTL-4 group) and infants receiving
ICS without MTL-4 (ICS group). The two groups were matched, e. g. on initial therapy
before initial exacerbation and past asthma related hospitalization. The two groups
were compared, as to the occurrence of a new exacerbation and the total num-
ber of exacerbations during the 6 month follow-up following initial exacerbation.
We also compared health care utilization between both groups. Results: Among
115,489 infants (mean age: 13.9 months; 62.9% boys), 4,477 infants of the MTL-4
group were matched with 13,386 infants of the ICS group. In multivariate analysis,
the risk of a new exacerbation was lower in infants of MTL-4 group compared to
infants in ICS group (HR= 0.91, IC95% [0.87; 0.95]). The total number of exacerbations
did not differ between the 2 groups during the 6-month follow-up (p= 0,8617), neither the cost of asthma management (344€ for MTL-4 group vs. 308€ for ICS group,
p= 0.1410). Conclusions: MTL-4 and ICS appear to be comparable therapeutic
strategies, with similar effects on exacerbation and equivalent costs. The SNIIR-AM
allows conducting comparative effectiveness research.
PRS3
Clinical Trial-Based Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Indacaterol
(ONBREZ® 150 MCG) Versus Tiotropium (SPIRIVA®) in the Treatment of
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) IN TURKEY
Saylan M , Beykoz V , Keskinaslan A
Novartis Pharma, Istanbul, Turkey
.
.
.
Objectives: COPD is a disease that is characterized by chronic and progressive
restriction of the airflow. The cost of COPD medications can be reduced significantly by implementing a treatment algorithm that is consistent with the GOLD
guidelines. Indacaterol and tiotrpium administered by inhalation are indicated for
maintenance treatment of COPD in Turkey. We aimed to compare, from the perspective of the Turkish social security institution, the cost-effectiveness of indacaterol
150 mcg once daily and long-acting tiotropium 18 mcg once daily at months 3 and
6 in patients with moderate to severe COPD aged 30 years and above. Methods:
From payer perspective, a cost-effectiveness analysis based on two separate clinical
trials (INTENSITY-once daily indacaterol and tiotropium vs. placebo and INHANCEindacaterol vs tiotropium) was performed. The primary endpoints of the clinical
trials (Trough FEV1, Transition Dyspnea Index [TDI] and Saint Georges Respiratory
Questionnaire [SGRQ]) were included in the cost-effectiveness analysis. Incremental
cost effectiveness ratio (ICER) of indacaterol vs. tiotropium for different treatment
success criteria (week 12 FEV1 > 0.12L increase, ≥ 1 improvement in TDI score, ≥ 4
decrease in SGRQ score) were compared. Incremental cost effectiveness ratios were
calculated over incremental differences versus placebo. Probabilistic sensitivity
analysis was performed using the Bootstrap method. Results: FEV1success rates
at month 3 for indacaterol and ipratropium were 26.5% and 24.3%, respectively. At
month 3, ICERs of indacaterol versus ipratropium were -1002TL for FEV1, -434TL for
TDI and -878TL for SGRQ. At month 6, FEV1 success rates were 54.8 and 47.4%, TDI
success rates were 58.7% and 54.4% and SGRQ success rates were 81.8% and 77.1%,
respectively. ICERs of indacaterol versus ipratropium at month 6 were -616TL for
FEV1, -1049TL for TDI and -1014TL for SGRQ Conclusions: Based on this clinical
trial-based analysis, indacaterol was cost effective treatment and cost reducing
choice vs. tiotroprium in COPD treatment.
PRS4
A Network Meta-Analysis Comparing the Efficacy And Safety
of Ceftobiprole and Selected Comparators in the Treatment of
Hospital-Acquired Pneumonia
Pooley N 1, Chadda S 1, Madrigal A M 2, Kuessner D 3, Posthumus J 4
1PHMR Associates, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK, 2PHMR Associates, London, UK, 3Basilea
Pharmaceutica Ltd, Basel, Switzerland, 4Basilea Pharmaceutica International Ltd., Basel,
Switzerland
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Hospital-acquired pneumonia (HAP) is a severe respiratory tract infection which develops more than 48h after hospital admission. Ceftobiprole, the active
moiety of its prodrug ceftobiprole medocaril, is a new cephalosporin with bactericidal
activity against a broad spectrum of pathogens including resistant bacteria such as
methicillin-resistant S. aureus (MRSA), penicillin-resistant pneumococci andP. aeruginosa. Ceftobiprole was shown safe and effective for the treatment of HAP (excluding
ventilator-associated pneumonia), when compared with linezolid plus ceftazidime
in a large-scale phase-III clinical trial (NCT00210964). Methods: MEDLINE, EMBASE,
Medline-In-Process and the Cochrane Library were searched for randomised controlled trials that included ceftobiprole and/or comparators ceftazidime, meropenem,
imipenem/cilastatin, piperacillin/tazobactam, ciprofloxacin, levofloxacin, moxifloxacin and gentamicin as intervention in the treatment of HAP. The efficacy of ceftobiprole was compared to comparators using a random effects model implemented
within a fully Bayesian framework. Primary outcome was clinical response after end
of treatment in the clinically evaluable (CE) population. Results: Eleven studies
(2413 patients) with HAP were included in the analysis, 1618 patients were eligible
for analysis of clinical response in the CE population. The comparative efficacies
(odds ratio, 95% credible intervals) of ceftobiprole to each comparator were 0.92,0.
092-8.8 (ceftazidime), 1.1, 0.054-19 (piperacillin/tazobactam), 1.9, 0.12-30 (meropenem),
0.83, 0.019-32 (levofloxacin), 0.96, 0.047-16 (imipenem/cilastatin), and 0.87, 0.025-22
(ciprofloxacin). No comparison was possible to gentamicin or moxifloxacin due to
a lack of comparative studies against other comparators. No significant difference
was seen between ceftobiprole and any comparator in clinical response or in any of
the secondary outcomes, including mortality and adverse events Conclusions:
The results of this multi-treatment comparison support the comparable efficacy and
safety of ceftobiprole to relevant comparators in the treatment of HAP. This analysis
was limited by the small number of available studies, and by the fact that among the
drugs compared, only ceftobiprole provides coverage of MRSA.
PRS5
Comparative Efficacy of Umeclidinium Bromide Versus Other LongActing Anticholinergic Monotherapies as Treatments for Copd
Patients
Ismaila A 1, Huisman E 2, Punekar Y S 3
Park, NC, USA, 2Mapi - HEOR & Strategic Market Access,
Houten, The Netherlands, 3GlaxoSmithKline, Uxbridge, UK
.
.
1GlaxoSmithKline, Research Triangle
.
.
A589
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: To assess the relative efficacy of umeclidinium bromide 62.5 mcg OD
(UMEC) versus tiotropium bromide 18 mcg OD (TIO), aclidinium bromide 400 mcg
BID (AB) and glycopyrronium bromide 50 mcg OD (GLYCO). Methods: A systematic
literature review was performed to identify RCTs ≥ 12 weeks duration comparing
TIO, AB, GLYCO or UMEC to placebo in adult patients with COPD. Random effects
meta-analyses were performed by pooling results of each treatment vs. placebo
on change from baseline at 12 and 24 weeks in trough FEV1, SGRQ total score, TDI
focal score and rescue medication use. The results were synthesized by using an
indirect treatment comparison (ITC) within a frequentist framework based on the
Bucher method. Scenario analyses were performed to evaluate the robustness of
the results to variations in the included studies and assumptions. Results: At 12
weeks, ITC results show that treatment with UMEC resulted in a comparable but
numerically higher change from baseline in trough FEV1 compared to TIO [18.06mL
(95%CI: -19.11, 55.23, p=0.341)], AB [35.77mL (95%CI: -7.84, 79.38, p=0.108)] and GLYCO
[27.86mL (95%CI: -8.74, 64.45, p= 0.136)]. At 24 weeks, UMEC resulted in comparable
trough FEV1 values vs. TIO (p= 0.854), AB (p= 0.663) and GLYCO (p= 0.777). UMEC also
resulted in comparable TDI focal scores and rescue medication use at both time
points compared with TIO, AB and GLYCO. UMEC resulted in numerically lower
(better) change from baseline at 12 weeks in SGRQ total score compared with TIO
[-2.65 (95%CI: -7.09, 1.79, p= 0.242)], AB [-2.68 (95%CI: -7.12, 1.75, p= 0.235)] and GLYCO
[-2.15 (95%CI: -6.60, 2. 31, p= 0.345)]. At 24 weeks there was no statistically significant
difference in change from baseline in SGRQ total score between UMEC, TIO, AB and
GLYCO. Conclusions: UMEC showed comparable efficacy to TIO, AB and GLYCO
on trough FEV1, SGRQ, TDI and rescue medication use at 12 and 24 weeks.
PRS6
Systematic Review of Observational Studies and Rcts of
Omalizumab in Severe Persistent Allergic Asthma and MetaAnalysis Feasibility Assessment
Bergrath E 1, Hwa Ong S 2, Bousquet J 3, Balwin M 4, Manga V 2, Rao S 2, Cope S 5
Pharma AG, Basel, Switzerland, 3University of
Montpellier, Montpellier, France, 4Novartis Pharma AG (Employed by Novartis at time of
systematic literature review), Basel, Switzerland, 5Mapi, Toronto, ON, Canada
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Mapi, Inc., Boston, MA, USA, 2Novartis
Objectives: To compare the effectiveness of omalizumab versus standard of care
(SOC) based on randomized controlled trials (RCTs) compared with ‘real-world’,
single cohort, observational studies that assess patients ‘before and after’ the use of
omalizumab. Methods: A systematic literature review was conducted to identify
RCTs and observational studies that assessed omalizumab in patients with severe
persistent allergic asthma. Study and patient characteristics, outcome definitions,
and differences in baseline risk and observed study effects were compared in terms
of exacerbations and hospitalizations across the RCTs and observational studies. Results: 11 RCTs and 24 observational studies were identified. A wide range
of clinically significant exacerbation rates was observed across RCTs in terms of
baseline risk (SOC: 0.40–2.86) and the treatment effect (rate ratio [RR]: 0.39–0.75). This
differed from observational studies in terms of baseline risk (before omalizumab:
3.48–6.00) and the treatment effect (RRs: 0.12–0.46). A limited range of severe exacerbation rates was observed in RCTs regarding baseline risk (SOC: 0.42–0.48) and the
treatment effect (RR: 0.50–0.56). However, considerable differences were identified
in observational studies in terms of baseline risk (before omalizumab: 2.20–4.50)
and the treatment effect (RR: 0.05–0.39). In terms of hospitalization rates, a limited
range was observed for RCTs with respect to baseline risk (SOC: 0.12–0.17) and the
treatment effect (RR: 0.12–0.54). Again, a wider range was observed across the observational studies in terms of baseline risk (before omalizumab: 0.32–4.45) and the
treatment effect (RR: 0.09–0.71). Conclusions: ‘Real-world’ evidence reinforces
the efficacy of omalizumab in patients with severe allergic asthma derived from
RCTs, although differences in potential treatment effect modifiers were identified.
Patients in observational studies may represent a more severe population compared
with those in RCTs.
PRS7
Impact of Omalizumab on Poor Asthma Control Events and
Medication Utilisation in Patients With Moderate or Severe
Persistent Asthma
Yu T C 1, Nazareth T 1, Turner S J 2, Raimundo K 3, Zhou H 4, Ortiz B 1, Li L 5
1Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation, East Hanover, NJ, USA, 2Novartis Pharmaceuticals, East
Hanover, NJ, USA, 3Genentech Inc., South San Francisco, CA, USA, 4KMK Consulting Inc., Florham
Park, NJ, USA, 5Career International Inc., Shanghai, China
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Poor asthma control is associated with increased health care cost
in patients with moderate or severe asthma. Here we evaluate the impact of
omalizumab on poor asthma control events (PACE) and medication utilisation
(MU) in a case-crossover study of US patients with moderate or severe persistent
asthma. Methods: Truven MarketScan database was used to compare PACE
(hospitalisation, ER visit, corticosteroid [CS] burst or ≥ 7 short-acting beta-agonist
[SABA] fills) and MU for 1 year pre/post omalizumab exposure, during the period
1-January-2007 to 30-September-2012. Included in the analysis were patients aged
≥ 12 years who had 1 inpatient or 2 outpatient Asthma claims (ICD-9= 493. XX) and
used omalizumab continuously for 1 year, with 2 years continuous coverage (1 year
pre/post omalizumab index date). Patients were categorized as Moderate or Severe
based on their most recent 8 weeks of continuous, NHLBI-guideline-recommended,
therapy preceding omalizumab. Results: In total, 429 patients (mean age, 46.6
years; female, 59.0%; Moderate= 340, Severe= 89) were included in the analysis.
Omalizumab was associated with reductions in proportions of All, Moderate, and
Severe asthma patients with PACE (41.3%, 48.3%, 17.2%, respectively; all p< 0.05).
Specifically, reductions in patients with ≥ 1 asthma-related hospitalisation, ≥ 1
asthma-related ER visit, ≥ 2 CS bursts, and ≥ 7 SABA fills in the Moderate group
(Moderate: 55.9%, 77.8%, 53.8%, and 40.6%, respectively; all p≤ 0.0196) drove reductions in All patients (all p≤ 0.0159). Reductions in patients with ≥ 1 OCS fill and ≥ 1
SABA fill were observed in All and Moderate patients (20.3%–26.1%; all p< 0.0001);
reductions in mean OCS fills and mean SABA fills were observed in All and Moderate
patients (26.0%-42.5% p< 0.0001), while reductions in mean SABA fills were also
observed in Severe patients (20.1%; p= 0.0328). Conclusions: Omalizumab initiation was associated with significant reduction in PACE and MU in patients with
moderate or severe persistent asthma.
PRS8
Indirect Comparison of Exacerbation Frequency Between
Aclidinium and Tiotropium in Patients With Chronic Obstructive
Pulmonary Disease
Lee H , Choi S E , Bae E , Lim E A , Kim J , Park H
Korea University, Yeongi-gun, South Korea
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The purpose of this study is to compare the frequency of exacerbations between aclidinium and tiotropium in patients with chronic obstructive
pulmonary disease (COPD). Methods: Through a systematic literature search in
Medline (PubMed), we included randomized controlled trials that evaluated the
exacerbation frequency of aclidinium 200µg and 400µg twice a day and tiotropium
18µg once a day regimens compared to placebo. Inclusion criteria were at least
12 weeks of treatment from January 1990 to January 2014, an age over 40, current
or former smokers, and diagnosis with moderate to very severe COPD. The main
outcome is the frequency of exacerbation. Indirect comparison analysis was performed to estimate the odds ratio of exacerbation between aclidinium and tiotropium. Results: After screening 278 full-text articles, we identified 19 clinical trials
that total 19,741 COPD patients were participated: 3 trials of aclidinium 200µg and
400µg BID and 16 trials of tiotropium 18µg QD. tiotropium 18µg was associated with
a significant reduction in exacerbation compared with placebo (OR 0.90; 95% CI 0.84
to 0.96). Other two anticholinergic agents showed comparable effects in reducing
exacerbation compared with placebo: aclidinium 200µg (OR 0.73; 95% CI 0.53 to 1.01)
and aclidinium 400µg (OR 0.72; 95% CI 0.52 to 1.00). Aclidinium 200µg (OR 0.84; 95%
CI 0.603-1.167) and aclidinium 400µg (OR 0.83; 95% CI 0.592 -1.156) BID showed the
similar frequency of exacerbation to tiotropium 18µg QD. Conclusions: Our study
substantiates that tiotropium 18µg provides superior effects on lowering the risk of
exacerbation compared with placebo but there was no significant difference in the
frequency of exacerbations between aclidinium and tiotropium.
PRS9
Treatment Plan Comparison: An Observational Study of the Marche
Region
Sciattella P 1, Marcellusi A 2, Mennini F S 3
1University of Rome “Tor Vergata” Italy, Rome, Italy, 2University of Rome, Rome, Italy, 3University
of Rome “Tor Vergata”, Italy, Rome, Italy
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate the number of users of Theophylline (ATC: R03DA04)
and Doxofylline (ATC: R03DA11) for the treatment of chronic asthma in adults,
in the Marche Region. Moreover, we wanted to estimate the cost of the two treatments, taking into account the prescriptions of other drugs associated with
them. Methods: The drug prescriptions were extracted from the Information
System of the Pharmaceutical Prescriptions of the Marche Region (PHARM), containing all the recipes sent by pharmacies within the region and reimbursed by the
National Health System. The number of prescriptions per year has been obtained
by selecting all the recipes for each ATC code in the years 2008-2012, while the
number of users has been estimated by identifying the subjects who received at
least one prescription of the ATC codes of interest. The number of concomitant
prescriptions was estimated by selecting all the recipes for potentially associated
ATC, dispenced between 5 days before and 5 days following the prescription of ATC
codes. The price of prescriptions has been calculated using the information “price”
contained in the PHARM record. Results: For both drugs, the users are approximately 5,000 per year in the study period. Theophylline had a mean base price lower
than Doxofylline (4.81€ vs 6.37€ per prescription); however, Theophylline was more
associated than Doxofylline (34.4% vs 23.7%) with other drugs for the treatment of
Asthma. Consequently, the total treatment cost for Theophylline was equal to 33.65€
vs a total cost for Doxofylline equal to 22.49€ (+ 49.6%). Conclusions: The PHARM
allows the estimate of drugs’ utilization, taking into account the overall patient’s
treatment plan. In our study, the prescription of the first ATC code is more associated with prescriptions of other drugs, and this implies an increasing in the cost of
the treatment plan despite a lower average initial price.
PRS10
A Database Study to Investigate the Incidence of Anaphylaxis and
the Prescription Rate of Self-Injection Epinephrine in Japan
Shima D 1, Ii Y 1, Yamamoto Y 2, Nagayasu S 2, Fujimoto Y 1
1Pfizer Japan Inc, Tokyo, Japan, 2MinaCare co. ltd, Tokyo, Japan
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: A database research was conducted to investigate the incidence of
anaphylaxis/shock using a Japanese health-claims database (HDB). In addition,
the prescription rate of self-injection epinephrine was investigated among those
patients with anaphylaxis for the management of future reactions. Methods:
A Japanese HDB which contains approximately 1.8 million subjects covered by
employment-based health insurance (MinaCare Co. Ltd) was used for this retrospective study. In order to identify actual anaphylaxis/shock precisely, diagnosis recorded
in the claims based on ICD-10 code (T78.0, T78.2 and T88.6) was combined with claim
records of medical practice and prescriptions. Specifically, prescription for epinephrine/adrenaline or oxygen inhalation therapy was required for “anaphylactic shock”
and the use of an infusion therapy or venous catheter was required for detecting “anaphylaxis (except for anaphylactic shock)”. For this study, the data associated with events occurring in fiscal years 2010 to 2013 (2010/4/1 to 2013/3/31) were
included. Results: Of approximately 2.9 million person-years of observations, 13.3
anaphylactic shock events per 100,000 person-years (crude rate) were identified. The
rate was 42.9 per 100,000 person-years when non-shock anaphylaxis events were
considered. The age-specific anaphylactic shock event rates (per 100,000 personyears) were: 27.6 (0-6 years), 12.8 (7-12 years), 11.0 (13-18 years), and 11.9 (> 18 years).
Among the 389 anaphylactic shock events, etiologies of anaphylaxis were food 113
A590
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
(29.0%), venom 31 (8.0%), drug 28 (7.2%), other/unknown 217 (55.8%). The prescription rate of self-injection epinephrine immediately after the anaphylaxis was 10.9%
(after the insurance started to cover the service in 2011/9). Conclusions: This
is the first report on the incidence of anaphylaxis in general population in Japan;
the rates were consistent with those reported in the West. The prescription rate of
self-injection epinephrine was notably low even among those who experienced
anaphylaxis, indicating the importance of increasing the awareness of the availability of life-saving anaphylaxis management.
PRS11
Epidemiology and Severity of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary
Disease (COPD) in the United Kingdom (UK)
Raluy-Callado M1, Lambrelli D1, MacLachlan S1, Merinopoulou E1, Hagan MA2, Khalid JM3
1Evidera, London, UK, 2Takeda Pharmaceuticals International, Inc., Deerfield, IL, USA, 3Takeda
Development Centre Europe, Ltd., London, UK
Objectives: In 2013, the Global Initiative for Chronic Obstructive Lung Disease
(GOLD) recommendations on COPD management and prevention were updated
to include additional therapeutic options for patients based on severity using a
combined assessment of symptoms, degree of airflow limitation and number of
exacerbations. The objective of the present study was to quantify the prevalence and
incidence of COPD in the UK and estimate disease severity by 2013 GOLD categories
A/B (low risk) and C/D (high risk). Methods: Patients with a diagnosis of COPD
aged ≥ 40 years were identified in the population-based Clinical Practice Research
Datalink. Point prevalence was calculated on December 31, 2013. Incidence was
estimated using newly diagnosed patients between 2009-2013. Rates were standardised using 2011 UK population age and gender. % predicted FEV1, modified British
Medical Research Council grade and exacerbations defined by Read codes and prescriptions were used to classify patients by GOLD categories. Patient characteristics
were reported. Results: 49,286 prevalent patients were diagnosed with COPD with
mean age of 70 years; 51% were male. Median time since diagnosis was 5 years.
Overall prevalence was 33.0 per 1,000 people (95% CI: 32.7-33.4). Of these, 66.4% were
classified as GOLD A/B and 33.6% as GOLD C/D. 27,224 newly diagnosed patients were
identified with mean age of 67 years at first diagnosis; 53% were male. Incidence
was 2.2 per 1000 person-years (95% CI: 2.1-2.2). Conclusions: A third of COPD
patients in the UK are considered high-risk according to the 2013 GOLD categories.
Classification of patients is key to identifying appropriate treatment options to
reduce symptoms and the frequency of COPD exacerbations.
PRS12
Incidence and Prevalence of COPD By Gold 2013 Classification in the
Netherlands
Van den Berg E J 1, Overbeek J A 1, Penning-van Beest F J A 1, Khalid J M 2, Dekhuijzen P N R 3,
Herings R 1
1PHARMO Institute for Drug Outcomes Research, Utrecht, The Netherlands, 2Takeda Development
Centre Europe, Ltd., London, UK, 3Radboud University Nijmegen Medical Centre, Nijmegen, The
Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To quantify the five-year incidence (2008-2012) and 2012 prevalence
of COPD in The Netherlands by the Global initiative for chronic Obstructive Lung
Disease (GOLD) 2013 combined assessment categories. Methods: Using the
General Practitioners Database of the PHARMO Database Network, the five-year
incidence (2008-2012) and prevalence at July 1, 2012 of COPD (ICPC code R95) by
GOLD 2013 combined assessment categories among individuals ≥ 40 years of age
was assessed. Based on degree of airflow limitation (using post-bronchodilator
FEV1) and risk of exacerbations (based on medication or as recorded by the GP)
patients were classified as low-risk COPD (FEV1 ≥ 50% and/or ≤ 1 exacerbations) or
high-risk COPD (FEV1 < 50% and/or ≥ 2 exacerbations). Results: Using a source
population of 813,800 individuals ≥ 40 years of age the five-year (2008-2012) incidence (95% CI) of COPD among patients ≥ 40 years of age was 0.50 (0.49-0.50) per
100 person years; this was 0.54 (0.53-0.55) among males and 0.45 (0.44-0.46) among
females. The 2012 prevalence of COPD in a source population of 805,112 individuals ≥ 40 years of age was 3.7 (3.6-3.7) per 100 persons; this was 4.0 (3.9-4.1) among
males and 3.4 (3.3-3.4) among females. Mean (± sd) age of incident and prevalent
COPD patients was 65 ± 12 and 67 ± 12 years, respectively. The distribution of lowrisk COPD and high-risk COPD was 90% versus 10%. For patients treated by their
GP this distribution of low-risk and high-risk COPD was similar, while patients
treated by a specialist had a distribution of 82% versus 18%. Conclusions: This
study describes the epidemiology of COPD in the Netherlands. Results on the
distribution of low-risk and high-risk COPD depend on the population studied and
the definitions used. Additional information on symptoms would allow a more
detailed classification of patients.
PRS13
Estimating Smoking Cessation Rates and Smoking Prevalences Using
Public Data and a Published Dynamic Model
Kumar R , Govindan B
Vantage Research, Chennai, India
.
.
al1
Objectives: Mendez et
developed a dynamic forecasting model to predict
the prevalence of smoking. They use initiation and prevalence rates (data from
1965-1993) and estimate cessation rates for that period. Further, they assume the
persistence of the cessation rates and predict future prevalence of smoking. We
re-created the Mendez et al model in order to estimate smoking cessation rates (n)
and updated cessation rates for 2000-2012 using newly available data on smoking
prevalence (R). Further, smoking prevalences for the decade 2012-2024 were predicted based on a couple of alternate hypotheses of smoking initiation Methods:
We re-created the Mendez model in Excel, including the mathematical manipulations for estimates of mean rates of cessation from the years 1970-1994 and
used the re-created Mendez model set-up and newly available data on smoking prevalence (R), initiation etc. to estimate cessation rates between 2001 and
2012. Further, we predicted smoking prevalences for 2012-2024 and explored a
couple of different scenarios of smoking initiation. Birth and death rates of the
general population are assumed to be the average of the previous decade. Relative
Risk of mortality is assumed to be the same. Results: Smoking prevalence in
2024 is estimated to be 18.5%, even with alternate hypotheses around smoking
initiation in the 2012-2022 decade. Conclusions: Aging of smoker population
will continue to contribute to reducing prevalence of smokers. Existing dynamic
forecasting models were re-created and used to estimate smoker prevalence using
recent data.
References
1. Mendez D , Warner K E , Courant P N , Has smoking cessation ceased? Expected
trends in the prevalence of smoking in the United States. Am J Epidemiol.
1998 Aug 1;148(3):249–258.
PRS14
Patients With COPD who Initiate Roflumilast in Sweden
Khalid J M 1, Mushnikov V 2, Vattulainen P 2, Johansson G 3, Korhonen P 2, Hoti F 2
1Takeda Development Centre Europe, Ltd., London, UK, 2EPID Research, Espoo, Finland, 3Uppsala
University, Uppsala, Sweden
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In Sweden, reimbursement for roflumilast is limited to eligible patients
with severe to very severe chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) who are
intolerant to inhaled corticosteroid therapy. Therefore, patients being treated
with roflumilast in Sweden may differ by their characteristics to patients in other
countries. Our aim was to describe demographic and disease characteristics of
patients with COPD prescribed roflumilast in Sweden, at time of first prescription. Methods: Patients with diagnoses of COPD or chronic bronchitis (CB) who
initiated use of roflumilast at age ≥ 40 during 2011 were identified from the Swedish
Hospital Discharge Register and Swedish Prescribed Drug Register. Summary statistics were calculated for demographic and disease characteristics at time of first
prescription. The Charlson comorbidity index (CCI) was used to score the presence of comorbidities. Results: 1,161 patients (42.8% male) with COPD/CB initiated roflumilast. Mean age at time of first prescription was 70.8 (SD±8.3) years.
Mean time since first COPD diagnosis was 6.1 (SD±3.8) years. 640 (55.1%) patients
were hospitalized at least once in the year prior; 99 (8.5%) had ≥ 5 hospitalisations
in this period. 21.7% of patients had congestive heart failure, 13.5% myocardial
infarction, 17.1% diabetes, and 9.1% a mood disorder indicated in their medical
records. 37.2% of patients had a CCI score ≥ 3 at time of first roflumilast prescription. Conclusions: Patients who are prescribed roflumilast carry a very severe
disease burden. Appropriate methodology should be used when making comparisons between patients who are exposed to roflumilast to those who are not, using
real world data in Sweden.
PRS15
The Prevalence of Tobacco Smoking in Patients With Diabetes in
Hospital Pulau Pinang, Malaysia
Albaroodi K A I 1, Syed Sulaiman S A 2, Shafie A A 3, Awaisu A 4, Lajis R 1
1University Sains Malaysia, Pulau Penang, Malaysia, 2Universiti Sains Malaysia, Minden,
Malaysia, 3Universiti Sains Malaysia, Penang, Malaysia, 4Qatar University, Doha, Qatar
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Widespread evidence has demonstrated the negative effects of tobacco smoking
in patients with diabetes. Although many studies have explored the prevalence of
tobacco smoking in the general population, data are lacking regarding its prevalence in a specific population with a chronic disease such as diabetes.Objectives:
This study aims to determine the prevalence of tobacco smoking among patients
with diabetes in Hospital Pulau Pinang, Malaysia. Methods: A cross-sectional
survey was conducted to study diabetic patients who attended the endocrine
clinic at Hospital Pulau Pinang in Malaysia from March to August 2012. All the
diabetic patients who attended the endocrine clinic during that period were
asked about their smoking status, and their medical records were reviewed. A
total of 1,118 patients with diabetes were reviewed to determine the prevalence
of tobacco smoking in diabetic patients at the endocrine clinic of Hospital Pulau
Pinang. Results: The majority of the study population was male, with Malay
and Chinese patients in almost equal proportions and a smaller proportion of
Indian patients. Most of these patients had started smoking before they were diagnosed with diabetes. Among the 1,118 diabetic patients, only 108 patients smoked;
therefore, the prevalence of tobacco smoking in our patients with diabetes was
9.66%. Conclusions: A low prevalence of tobacco smoking was estimated in
this study. This prevalence is close to the corresponding value in the general
population in Malaysia.
PRS16
Current Annual Cost Calculation is the Best Predictor of
Mortality at Three Years in COPD
Dal negro RW
Nationa center for Respiratory Pharmacoeconomics & Pharmacoepidemiology, Verona, Italy
Objectives: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) is a progressive condition which is characterized by a dramatic socio-economic impact. Sensitivity of
clinical signs and lung function in predicting death is variable in different COPD
phenotypes. Aim: To assess the predictive value of COPD annual cost on mortality. Methods: Gender; age; smoking habit, clinical data, and complete lung funtion were assessed in 275 consecutive COPD patients aged > 40y together with the
annual cost calculated over the last twelve months. Statistics: t test for comparing means ± sd; linear regression for checking any relationship between each
variable and mortality (p< 0.05 was accepted). Results: The whole mortality was
40.4% over three years (n= 12; 47, and 52 subjects, respectively). Subjects still survived after three years (n= 164) proved originally different from those (n= 111) who
died in terms of mean age; FEV1 (in l); RV; TLCO/VA; 6’ walking test; BODE index, and
Charlson index (all p<0.001), but not of FEV1% pred. and FEV1/FVC (p=ns). Mean total
A591
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
COPD cost was 3,290.7 [95%CI: 2539.9; 4051.2], but € 1161.0 [95% CI: 968.4; 1,353.6]
in survivors and 6,158.9 [95% CI: 5,508.0; 6,809.8] in those who died, respectively
(p< 0.001). The hospitalization cost impacted for 78.2% of the total annual cost in
subjects who died, the absolute value being sixfold higher than in survivors. All
economic components of cost were discriminant at three years, independently of
gender. Conclusions: 1) several clinical and lung function variables contribute to
predict mortality in COPD; 2) identification of COPD phenotypes is crucial, but multiple indices are required; 3) total annual cost proved the most sensitive predictor
of mortality at three years; 4) annual cost is much easier and cheaper to obtain over
twelve months; 5) data are supporting the high predicting value and the convenience of COPD “economic phenotyping”.
RESPIRATORY-RELATED DISORDERS – Cost Studies
PRS17
Budgetary Implications of Introducing Fluticasone Furoate/
Vilanterol for COPD in the UK
Doyle S , Armstrong S , Bowditch S
GSK, Uxbridge, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: Fluticasone furoate/vilanterol (FF/VI) 92/22 mcg is a once-daily, fixeddose combination inhaled corticosteroid + bronchodilator licensed for the treatment
of COPD in the UK. A budget impact model (BIM) was designed to explore the cost
implications of prescribing FF/VI 92/22 in adult patients who continue to exacerbate
or are currently receiving an off-license therapy versus alternative ICS/LABA therapies, in line with clinical guidelines. Methods: a one-year BIM was constructed to
explore the financial outcomes of prescribing FF/VI 92/22 as an alternative treatment
option to currently prescribed therapies based on market shares. The BIM is based
on UK prescription analysis, epidemiological and resource data. The model explores
three routes for progressing patients: 1) exacerbating patients currently on LAMA or
LABA monotherapy progressing onto ICS/LABA combination therapy; 2) exacerbating patients currently on ICS/LABA combination therapy progressing onto triple
therapy; 3) patients currently on off-license therapies moved onto licensed COPD
products. The model does not explore differences in patient outcomes, efficacy or
safety; it explores drug acquisition cost alone. Results: The BIM estimates that
the average health economy (e. g. clinical commissioning group; local health board)
in the UK has 3066 COPD patients of whom 2138 continue to exacerbate or are
prescribed off licence therapies. In year 1, progressing exacerbating patients onto
alternative ICS/LABA combinations or triple therapy (50% implementation rate), or
patients on off-license therapies onto licensed therapies (100% implementation rate)
results in a budget impact of £156,498 compared with a budget impact of -£51,907
if these patients are moved onto FF/VI 92/22. Conclusions: The introduction of
FF/VI 92/22 in COPD has the potential to reduce the budget impact and total spend
on combination ICS/LABA therapies by £208,405 in the average UK health economy
compared to current patterns of prescribing.
PRS18
Budgetary Implications of Introducing Fluticasone Furoate/
Vilanterol for Asthma in the UK
Doyle S , Armstrong S , Bowditch S
GSK, Uxbridge, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: Fluticasone furoate/vilanterol (FF/VI) is a once-daily, fixed-dose combination inhaled corticosteroid + bronchodilator licensed for the treatment of asthma
in the UK. A budget impact model (BIM) was designed to explore the cost implications of initiating FF/VI in patients ≥ 12 years not adequately controlled on ICS
monotherapy (and as needed SABA) versus alternative ICS/LABA therapies, in line
with BTS-SIGN guidelines. Methods: A one-year BIM was constructed to explore
the financial outcomes of prescribing FF/VI as a treatment option in these dynamic
patients. The BIM is based on UK epidemiological and resource data. It compares a
scenario in which all eligible patients are treated with currently available ICS/LABA
products based on market shares with a scenario in which FF/VI is introduced for
uncontrolled patients eligible for step up onto an ICS/LABA combination therapy
in line with clinical guidelines. The model does not explore differences in patient
outcomes, efficacy or safety; it explores drug acquisition cost alone. Results: The
BIM estimates that the average health economy (e. g. clinical commissioning group;
local health board) in the UK has 7326 patient on ICS monotherapy of whom 3736
are inadequately controlled and appropriate for step-up to an ICS/LABA combination therapy. In year 1, presuming a 50% implementation rate, stepping up these
patients onto alternative ICS/LABA combinations at current usage rates results in
a budget impact of £342,413 compared with a budget impact of £313,167 if these
patients initiate FF/VI therapy. Conclusions: The introduction of FF/VI in asthma
has the potential to reduce the budget impact and total spend on combination ICS/
LABA therapies by £29,246 in the average UK health economy compared to current
patterns of prescribing.
PRS19
The Budget Impact of Duoresp® Spiromax® (Budesonide + Formoterol
Fumarate Dihydrate) Compared With Symbicort® Turbohaler® for
the Management of Asthma and Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary
Disease in the United Kingdom: Impact on Health Care Costs and
Inhalation Technique
Lewis A 1, Blackney M 1, Torvinen S 2, Holmes J 3, Osborne M 3, Dale J 3, Chandler S 3, Plich A 2
Inc., London, UK, 2Teva Pharmaceuticals Europe B. V, Amsterdam, The Netherlands,
3Teva UK Limited, Essex, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Covance
Objectives: DuoResp® Spiromax® (budesonide + formoterol fumarate dihydrate)
is a fixed-dose combination (FDC) of inhaled corticosteroid (ICS) + long-acting
beta agonist (LABA) in a novel dry powder inhaler (DPI). An economic model was
developed to assess the budget impact of using DuoResp ® Spiromax® instead
of Symbicort® Turbohaler® – a DPI delivering the same FDC – to manage adult
patients with persistent asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
(COPD) in the United Kingdom (UK). The potential cost benefit of improved inhalation technique, due to the innovative characteristics of the Spiromax® inhaler,
was also investigated. Methods: The eligible adult patient population was
based on current confirmed UK asthma and COPD diagnosis rates, with the proportion of patients receiving FDCs based on market research data. The costs of
Symbicort® Turbohaler® and scheduled and unscheduled health care events were
taken from publically available UK sources. Frequency of poor inhalation technique with Symbicort® Turbohaler® and the associated increased risk of unscheduled health care events were taken from a large (n= 1,664) cross-sectional, Italian
observational study. The estimated reduction in the proportion of patients with
poor inhalation technique with DuoResp® Spiromax® compared with Symbicort®
Turbohaler® was based on a conservative assumption. Results: An estimated
409,445 adult patients used Symbicort® Turbohaler® annually in the UK and
were therefore eligible for treatment with DuoResp® Spiromax®, with 178,108 of
these exhibiting poor inhalation technique. Assuming a hypothetical uptake of
DuoResp® Spiromax® reaching 25% in year 4 and 5 and its anticipated price,
the model predicted drug cost savings totalling £36.09 million. Furthermore,
39,266 unscheduled health care events could be avoided due to the predicted
improvement in inhalation technique with DuoResp® Spiromax® compared with Symbicort® Turbohaler®, resulting in further savings of £3.50 million. Conclusions: DuoResp® Spiromax® is likely to offer budgetary savings
compared with Symbicort® Turbohaler®, with further cost savings potentially
resulting from improved inhalation technique.
PRS20
The Economic Impact of Therapy Optimization in Chronic
Obstructive Pulmonary Disease in Portugal
Andrade A 1, Viriato D 1, Viana R 2, Luciano T 3
Salvo, Portugal,, 2Novartis Farma-Produtos Farmacêuticos S.A., Portugal, Porto
Salvo, Portugal,, 3ACES Amadora, Lisboa, Portugal
.
.
.
.
1Novartis, Porto
Objectives: Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) is an obstructive
lung disease characterized by persistent airflow limitation. COPD has a significant humanistic burden, representing the 5th leading cause of death in Portugal.
The prevalence of Portuguese population with more than 40 years is 14.2%. COPD
symptoms are similar to other respiratory diseases, making harder its diagnosis.
Furthermore, it may result in inappropriate use of medication which is associated
with an economic burden. This analysis aimed to estimate the economic impact
of inappropriate use of inhaled corticosteroid/long-acting beta-agonist (ICS/LABA)
fixed-dosed combination in COPD patients. Methods: GOLD 2013 treatment algorithm establish that ICS therapy should only be considered in high risk population
(patients classified within GOLD groups C and D), presenting FEV1 < 50% (forced
expiratory volume at 1 second) and/or 2 or more exacerbations per year. Based on
a Delphi panel there are 1% of patients in group C and 29% in group D. According
to ECLIPSE study, only 31% of patients in group C and 37% in group D are illegible
for ICS therapy. Based on these assumptions, we estimated the overtreatment of
ICS/LABA in Portugal according with local COPD prevalence and number of ICS/
LABA fixed-dosed combinations prescribed. It was also calculated the economic
impact associated with therapy switch of over treated patients from ICS/LABA to
glycopyrronium or indacaterol, according to GOLD 2013. Results: The treatment
with ICS/LABA was estimated to be approximately 1.6 times greater than expected.
Considering the number of patients over treated with ICS/LABA, the therapy switch
for indacaterol or glycopyrronium would result in a potential saving of 4,314,390€
or 8,694,008€ , respectively. Conclusions: Optimization of COPD therapy in compliance with GOLD guidelines would result in a better treatment for patients and
potential savings, in a Portuguese National Health Service perspective.
PRS21
Estimation of Increased Costs in Switching from Tiotropium
to Other Lama Therapy During Maintenance Treatment of COPD
in the UK
Ternouth A , Schoenherr N , Edwards S C
Boehringer Ingelheim, Bracknell, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) is a prevalent disease
with a significant economic burden to the UK National Health Service (NHS). NICE
recommends maintenance treatment including inhaled bronchodilator medications such as long-acting muscarinic antagonists (LAMAs); tiotropium is the
most widely used LAMA in the UK. The objective of this model was to quantify
the budget impact to the NHS of switching patients from tiotropium to another
LAMA, compared to remaining on tiotropium. Methods: Two matched patient
groups were considered: patients who switched from tiotropium to another LAMA
and patients who remained on tiotropium. The budget impact model was conducted over a 3 month time horizon, with sensitivity analyses conducted over a
12 month time horizon. Costs included were costs of medication; costs of patient
identification and new inhaler training; and primary care resource use in the
3 months following inhaler switch, priced according to PSSRU estimates. The
number and duration of GP visits was estimated from the CPRD; a representative
primary care patient database. Clinical efficacy endpoints were not included in
the model. Results: Across the 3 month time horizon, patients who switched
therapy incurred an increased incremental cost to the NHS of £77.10 per patient
compared to patients who remained on tiotropium. Switching from tiotropium
to other LAMA therapy also increased the NHS economic burden in the 12 month
sensitivity analyses. Increased costs were driven by higher resource utilisation in
terms of GP visits amongst switchers. Conclusions: Switching patients with
COPD from tiotropium maintenance to another LAMA incurs an increased cost
to the NHS. This is primarily due to a higher primary care resource use in the 3
months following switch. This finding has implications for prescribing practice
including GP workload and patient willingness to switch, hence patients remaining
on tiotropium are cost-saving for the UK NHS
A592
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PRS22
Economic Burden of Hospitalized Pneumonia from a Private Health
Care System Perspective in Brazil
Manfrin D F 1, Ferreira C N 1, Santana C F S D 2, Paloni E D M P 2, Campi F D S 2, Gea Y 1,
Rufino C S 1
1Pfizer, Inc., São Paulo, Brazil,, 2ORIZON - Companhia Brasileira de Gestão de Serviços, Sao Paulo,
Brazil
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: This study aimed to evaluate the economic burden of hospitalized pneumonia and its associated costs in the Brazilian Private Health
System. Methods: An administrative claims database containing over 18 million
lives was used to identify hospitalized pneumonia episodes, in all ages, between
Oct/2010 and Dec/2013. Pneumonia episodes were identified using ICD-10 codes
of A40.3, B95.3, G00.1, J13, J15, J15.0, J15.3, J15.4, J15.8, J15.9, J18, J18.0, J18.9, J20.2,
P23.3. Pneumonia costs included were taxes and exchange, medicines, materials,
medicinal gases, food, medical fees, exams, procedures and personal hygiene. The
costs represent a total in the evaluated period for all causes and considering the
total patients identified, average cost was calculated. Results: A total of 16,227
pneumonia patients were identified with a total of 17,781 hospitalizations, representing an average of 1.1 hospitalizations per pneumonia patient in all ages. The
aggregate costs for all inpatient treatment were BRL202,687,872.71 representing
a total of 130,406 hospital days across the pneumonia patients. The average days
for hospitalization per patient is 7.5 days. The average expenditure for the health
insurance provider represents BRL12,490.78 per patient or BRL11,399.13, when
evaluating per hospitalization. This translates to an average daily expenditure of
BRL1,704.06 per patient or BRL1,555.13 per hospitalization. Conclusions: Costs
related to pneumonia hospitalization are high and represents a large impact to
the total budget spends in the private health care system. Given the significant
economic burden associated with pneumonia, there is a need to better implement
prevention strategies such as flu and pneumococcal vaccinations and smoking
cessation.
PRS23
Cost-Minimization and Budget-Impact Analysis of Fixed-Dose ICS/
LABA Combination Inhalers in the Treatment of Asthma in Slovenia
Hren R 1, Trkman M 1, Stynes G 2
d.o.o., družba za promet s farmacevtskimi izdelki, Ljubljana, Slovenia,
2GlaxoSmithKline, Uxbridge, UK
.
.
.
1GlaxoSmithKline
Objectives: To compare the expected costs and outcomes associated with the
novel once-daily fixed-dose combination (FDC) of inhaled corticosteroid (ICS) and
long-acting beta agonist (LABA) fluticasone furoate/vilanterol (FF/VI) against those
expected with currently available FDC options, fluticasone propionate/salmeterol
(FP/S), budesonide/formoterol (BUD/F) and beclometasone dipropionate/formoterol
(BD/F), for asthma treatment in Slovenia. Methods: We developed a Markov model
based on the results of seminal study GOAL (Gaining Optimal Asthma Control) that
takes into account the complexity of asthma treatment and particularly accompanying dose titration. Using available clinical evidence, we assumed that the clinical efficacy and incidence of adverse events associated with a all four FDCs were
similar. We compared FF/VI with other FDCs of ICS/LABA from the Slovenian payers’
perspective at the price levels determined by international reference pricing as of
April 2014. We followed a cohort of 12,300 asthma patients over the time horizon of
3 years with costs and outcoumes discounted at 3.5% per annum. Results: Model
analysis showed that the expected three-year costs of FF/VI were lower than those
of FP/S, BUD/F and BD/F by 13%, 40%, and 32%, respectively. The costs of treatment
with FF/VI were lower than all other FDCs of ICS/LABA for patients who were previously treated with low/medium doses of ICSs (≤ 500 mg equivalent dose of BD) or
high-doses of ICSs (> 500 mg and ≤ 1000 mg equivalent dose of BD). Budget impact
analysis that was based on the current ICS/LABA market and projected market
shares of FF/VI, FP/S, and BUD/F revealed that introduction of FF/VI could save
the national Sick Fund € 863,000 over the first three years of use. Conclusions:
Results of our model indicate that the introduction of the new once-daily FDC ICS/
LABA FF/VI could reduce the costs of asthma treatment in Slovenia over the first
three years after introduction.
PRS24
Cost-Minimization and Budget-Impact Analysis of Fixed-Dose
Combination Inhalers in Treatment of Copd in Slovenia
Hren R 1, Stynes G 2
1GlaxoSmithKline d.o.o., družba za promet s farmacevtskimi izdelki, Ljubljana, Slovenia,
2GlaxoSmithKline, Uxbridge, UK
.
.
Objectives: To compare expected costs and health outcomes of the novel fixeddose combination (FDC) of inhaled corticosteroid (ICS) and long-acting beta agonist
(LABA) fluticasone furoate/vilanterol (FF/VI) with currently available FDC options,
fluticasone propionate/salmeterol (FP/S) and budesonide/formoterol (BUD/F), for
chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) treatment in Slovenia. Methods:
We developed a population-level Markov model based on the results of seminal
TORCH (Towards a Revolution in COPD Health) study that accounts for disease
progression of COPD and particularly the effects of changes in lung function and
exacerbations. Using available clinical evidence, we assumed that all FDCs of ICS/
LABA were clinically equivalent. We compared FF/VI with two other FDCs of ICS/
LABA from the payers’ perspective at the Slovenian price levels determined by
international reference pricing as of April 2014. We followed a cohort of 8,100
Slovenian COPD patients for 20 years, with costs and outcomes discounted at 3.5%
per annum. Results: The life expectancy predicted by the model was 8.74 years
with 2.76 years spent in moderate COPD, 2.55 years in severe COPD, and 3.43 in
very severe COPD. Model analysis showed that the expected three-year survival
of the cohort was 91% and that the expected corresponding costs of FF/VI (€ 1.021
per patient) were lower than those of FP/S (€ 1.535 per patient; +33% vs. FF/VI) and
BUD/F (€1.260 per patient; +19% vs. FF/VI). Expected costs of maintenance, moderate
exacerbations, severe exacerbations, and pneumonia were, for all treatment choices,
€ 617, € 65, € 1.707 and € 145 per patient, respectively. Budget impact analysis based on
projected market shares of FF/VI, FP/S, and BUD/F revealed that introduction of FF/VI
could save the national Sick Fund € 711,000 in the first three years. Conclusions:
This model predicts that the introduction of FF/VI, a once daily FDC ICS/LABA, would
reduce the overall costs of COPD treatment in Slovenia.
PRS25
Benefit of Positive Airway Pressure (PAP) Therapy in Sleep Apnoea
(SA) Patients With Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) in
Germany: A Retrospective Comparative Cohort Analysis Based on a
Statutory Health Insurance Database
Doess A 1, Zucca F 2, Woehrle H 3, Brueggenjuergen B 4
1ResMed Germany Inc., Martinsried, Germany, 2HGC GesundheitsConsult, Duesseldorf, Germany,
3ResMed Science Center, Martinsried, Germany, 4Institut für Sozialmedizin, Epidemiologie und
Gesundheitsökonomie, Charité - Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Berlin, Germany
.
.
.
.
Objectives: It is estimated that the prevalence of moderate-to-severe SA (apnoeahypopnoea index > 15/h) is 10%. Approximately 11% of SA patients have comorbid
COPD, which worsens sleep quality and desaturations. This study investigated the
effects of PAP therapy on all-cause mortality and cost of illness (COI) in patients
with SA and COPD in Germany. A statutory health insurance (SHI) perspective was
taken. Methods: A total of > 4 million individuals covered by the SHI database
were analysed (≈5% of the German SHI population). PAP therapy was initiated in
4,068 patients with SA (PAP group). Propensity score matching was used to define a
control group (CG) of 4,068 SA patients matched for age, sex, risk factors/aetiology,
region and medication who received usual care (no PAP). Of these, 1,300 patients
in the PAP group and 1,192 patients in the CG had comorbid COPD. This subgroup
of patients was followed for 3 years after initiation of PAP therapy. Results: Total
COI was higher in the PAP group versus CG in the first year of follow-up (€ 8,697
vs € 6,999, p< 0.0001). However, during the second and third year the difference
in COI between the PAP and CG was smaller (year 2: € 7,340 vs € 7,316, p< 0.0048;
year 3: € 6,847 vs € 6,714, p< 0.001). PAP recipients had a significantly lower 3-year
mortality rate compared with CG (8.2% vs 11.7%, p< 0.001; relative risk reduction
30.1%). Conclusions: SA patients with COPD treated with PAP showed significantly reduced mortality and morbidity. Total COI was higher in PAP recipients
versus CG over the first 3 years of follow-up, but the difference between groups
decreased over time. A follow-up period of ≥ 5 years may be required to show beneficial economic outcomes in SA patients receiving PAP therapy.
PRS26
An Analysis of Us Medicare Beneficiaries: Burden of Direct Medical
Costs in Patients With Idiopathic Pulmonary Fibrosis
Chen S Y 1, Collard H R 2, Yeh W S 1, Li Q 3, Lee Y C 3, Wang A 3, Raghu G 4
Idec, Cambridge, MA, USA, 2University of California San Francisco, San Francisco, CA,
USA, 3Evidera, Lexington, MA, USA, 4University of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Biogen
Objectives: In the US, more than half of patients with idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (IPF) are covered by Medicare; yet published data on the economic burden that IPF
imposes to this largest US payer are limited. The objective of this study was to compare health care resource utilization (HRU) and costs between Medicare beneficiaries
with IPF and matched non-IPF controls. Methods: Administrative claims from a
5% random sample of Medicare beneficiaries (aged 65+) from years 2000 to 2011
were analyzed. Incident IPF patients were identified based on ICD9-CM diagnosis
codes, with at least one year enrollment before (pre-index) and after (post-index)
the first diagnosis (index date). Up to 5 beneficiaries without IPF were matched to
each IPF patient, based on age, gender, race, and region. Annual HRU and medical
costs (excluding outpatient drug costs) during the pre-index and post-index periods were compared between IPF patients and the matched controls and univariate
descriptive analyses were performed to compare the differences. Results: A total
of 7,855 IPF patients were matched to 38,856 controls. During pre-index period, IPF
patients had 2-3 folds higher risk of COPD, asthma and lung infections, 80% higher
risk of hospitalization (28.8% vs. 15.8%), and higher total medical costs ($10,124 vs.
$5,888) than matched controls (all p< 0.05). During post-index period, IPF patients
had a higher risk of hospitalization (48.7% vs. 20.8%) and all other types of HRU
with the total medical costs $11,955 higher than controls ($20,887 vs. $8,932) (all
p< 0.05). Inpatient care accounted for 50% of total medical costs of IPF patients in
both pre-index and post-index periods. Conclusions: In the US, IPF patients aged
65 or older had a greater burden of comorbidity and incurred more HRU and medical
costs than matched controls. Multidisciplinary team based approach and effective
therapies are needed given the high unmet needs.
PRS27
Examination of the Burden of Illness of U. S. Medicare Patients
Diagnosed with Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease
Xie L 1, Kariburyo M F 1, Du J 1, Baser O 2
1STATinMED Research, Ann Arbor, MI, USA, 2STATinMED Research and The University of
Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To examine the economic burden and health care utilizations of
patients diagnosed with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) within the
U. S. Medicare population. Methods: Patients diagnosed with COPD (International
Classification of Disease 9th Revision Clinical Modification [ICD-9-CM] codes: 491,
492, 496) were identified using the U. S. national Medicare claims dataset from
01JAN2009 to 31DEC2011. The first diagnosis date was defined as the index date. A
comparator group was created by identifying patients without a COPD diagnosis
but of similar age, region, gender, index year and baseline Charlson Comorbidity
Index scores. The index date for the comparator group was randomly chosen to
reduce selection bias. One-year pre- and post-index continuous health plan enrollment was required for both groups. A 1: 1 propensity score matching was used
to compare follow-up health care costs and utilizations between the COPD and
comparison cohorts, adjusted for baseline demographic and clinical characteristics. Results: A total of 422,024 patients were identified for the COPD and compari-
A593
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
son cohorts. After applying a 1: 1 matching, a total of 123,356 patients were matched
from each cohort, with well-balanced baseline characteristics. COPD patients had
higher health care utilization, including Medicare carrier (98.1% vs. 70.1%), Durable
Medical Equipment (DME, 37.4% vs. 15.8%) and Home Health Agency (HHA, 17.2%
vs. 4.6%) claims, outpatient visits (73.9% vs. 41.7%) and inpatient (32.5% vs. 6.8%),
skilled nursing facility (SNF, 10.0% vs. 2.2%) and hospice admissions (1.2% vs. 0.6%)
and prescription drug claims (53.4% vs. 49.8%), resulting in higher health care costs
for Medicare carrier ($3,391 vs. $1,313), DME ($413 vs. $97), HHA ($923 vs. $228),
outpatient ($10,110 vs. $3,514), inpatient ($5,983 vs. 1,045), SNF ($1,982 vs. $368),
hospice ($304 vs. $143), pharmacy ($1,180 vs. $692) and total costs ($24,288 vs. $7,399)
(p< 0.0001). Conclusions: COPD patients are associated with high economic burden and health care utilization.
for moderate-risk RR2378 ($75) for all ages. Average reimbursement rate was RR2,000
($63) per outpatient episode. The average cost of hospitalization was RR20,870 ($655/
n= 500), RR20,925 ($657/n= 125) for low-risk, RR20,947 ($657/n= 364) for moderaterisk, and RR17,684 ($554/n= 11) for high-risk patients; with 60%-80% of patients
with CAP hospitalized and the estimated number of CAP patients of age 50 and
older in Tver 3,249, the annual cost of CAP to payer is RR53,448,423 (~$1.7million);
the national estimates of cost of CAP in senior adults was $124million. Employed
patients comprise 12.8% and 18.3% among the inpatient and outpatient cases,
respectively, and days lost from work per employed patient was 8.0 (inpatient) and
7.0 (outpatient). Conclusions: CAP in adults is a significant cause of resource use
and health care cost in Russia, inpatient care constitutes the majority of cost. Cost
of treatment was similar across all age and risk groups.
PRS28
Estimation of the Cost of Childhood Asthma in Turkey
PRS31
The Medical Costs of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease in
South Korea
Sekerel B 1, Malhan S 2
1Hacettepe University, Ankara, Turkey, 2Baskent University, Ankara, Turkey
.
.
Objectives: Asthma is the most common chronic disease in childhood, reduces
the quality of life of children and their families, and produces high social and
health care costs. The aim of this study was to estimate the direct cost of pediatric asthma in Turkey and to examine its variability depending on asthma control
level. Methods: The clinical pathway for childhood asthma was designed by and
based on the data from the available Turkish literature. Unavailable data was collected by the expert’s clinical view. To calculate direct costs, the medical management of childhood asthma estimated using ‘cost-of-illness’ methodology for one
year per child. All costs were calculated from the health care payer perspective. The
costs were covered hospitalizations, physician visits, diagnostic tests, medications
and co morbid diseases. Results: According to the recent studies, the controlled
patient was 60%, partial controlled patient was 25%, and uncontrolled patient was
15% in Turkey. The cost of asthma calculation was based on weight of control. The
mean annual cost per patient with controlled asthma is 542.97€ , partial controlled
asthma 714.52€ and uncontrolled asthma 1047.86€. Hospitalizations, physician visits, diagnostic tests, co morbid diseases costs and medication costs estimated 4 %,
21%, 7%, 27%, 40% of total costs for controlled patient, 27%, 16%, 5%, 21%, 31% of
total costs for partial controlled patient and 50%, 11%, 4%, 14%, 21% for uncontrolled
patient respectively. Conclusions: The direct cost of pediatric asthma in Turkey
increases depending on disease control level along with different spectrum of item
distributions. To increase the utility and effectiveness of health care system, the
findings of this evaluation may guide to construct future policies.
Yang D W 1, Kim Y 1, Jang S 1, Hong J M 1, Yi J 1, Kim I S 1, Yang B M 1, Lee S W 2, Kim C 3, Rhee C K 4
1Seoul National University, Seoul, South Korea, 2Asan Medical Center, University of Ulsan, Seoul,
South Korea, 3National Health Insurance System Ilsan Hospital, Goyang, South Korea, 4Seoul St.
Mary’s Hospital, The Catholic University of Korea, Seoul, South Korea
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The aim of this study is to investigate the medical costs of COPD
patients in South Korea. Methods: We enrolled 300 COPD patients who had been
treated and followed up for more than one year in the three hospitals from 2012
to 2013. The hospital electronic database was used to obtain medical costs and the
medical records were reviewed by physicians (respiratory specialists) to assess clinical characteristics. We calculated annual maintenance costs per-patient according
to disease severity, except the costs which were related to COPD exacerbation. The
costs of COPD exacerbation per-case was calculated and divided into severe-exacerbation (hospitalization and emergency visit) costs and non-severe-exacerbation
(outpatient visit) costs. Results: The annual maintenance costs per-patient was
KRW 351,599, KRW 401,068, KRW 573,010 and KRW 999,506 for mild, moderate,
severe and very-severe according to GOLD criterion, respectively. In case of the
COPD exacerbation, the costs per-case for each non-severe exacerbation and severeexacerbation was KRW 163,495 and KRW 2,765,086. Conclusions: The severity of
disease and exacerbation of COPD have a substantial impact on the medical costs of
COPD patients. Improvement of lung function and reduction of occurrence of COPD
exacerbation will be beneficial for the reduction of the health care expenditures.
PRS32
The Direct Cost of Asthma in Turkey
PRS29
Cost of a Pulmonary Arterial Hypertension-Related
Hospitalization in Belgium
Turktas H 1, Bavbek S 2, Malhan S 3
University, Ankara, Turkey, 2Ankara University, Ankara, Turkey, 3Baskent University,
Ankara, Turkey
Chevalier P 1, De Beule J 2, Lamotte M 1, Hunsche E 3, Régulier E 3
1IMS Health HEOR, Vilvoorde, Belgium, 2Actelion Pharmaceuticals Belgium NV, Mechelen,
Belgium, 3Actelion Pharmaceuticals Ltd., Allschwil, Switzerland
Objectives: Asthma is one of the mostly seen chronic illnesses in Turkey, yet there
are limited studies on cost of asthma in our country. In addition they were based on
a central database and weight of disease. The aim of this study was estimating the
nationwide cost of managing asthma and examining its variability depending on
asthma control level. Methods: The clinical pathway for asthma was determined
from the literature. Part of the data was collected from the expert’s clinical view. To
calculate the direct costs, the medical management of adult asthma was estimated
using ‘cost-of-illness’ methodology for one year per patient. All costs were calculated according to payer perspective. The costs covered were pyhsician visits, hospitalizations, diagnostic tests, medicine and comorbid disease. Results: According
to recent studies, the percentage of controlled, partially controlled and uncontrolled
patients were 22%, 50%, and %28 respectively in Turkey. The cost of asthma calculation was based on weighted percentage of control. The mean annual cost per patient
with controlled asthma was € 558,41, partially controlled asthma was € 594,86 and
uncontrolled asthma was € 1040,63. Hospitalizations, physician visits, diagnostic
tests, comorbidity and medication costs were estimated to be 4%, 11%, 11%, 28%,
46% for controlled patient, 10%, 11%, 10%, 43%, 26% for partially controlled patient
and 48%, 6%, 6%, 25%, 15% for uncontrolled patient respectively. Conclusions:
The cost of adult asthma in Turkey is very high and it significantly depends on
disease control level. As expected, uncontrolled patient’s cost is higher than that
of controlled patient. Nationwide health policies such as education of patients and
physicians, selecting the right treatment and smoking cessation strategies that
target the effective control of asthma will play an important role in the reduction
of the economic burden of disease.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Pulmonary arterial hypertension (PAH) is a rare disease, for which only
scarce health care cost data is available in Europe. The progressive nature of the
disease often requires hospitalization, the costs of which are currently unknown
in Belgium, mainly due to the low number of patients affected. The objective of
this research was to assess the cost and length of stay (LOS) of a PAH-related hospitalization likely related to disease worsening in Belgium. Methods: A retrospective database analysis was performed using the IMS hospital disease database
from 2009 to 2011, covering 20% (2010/2011) to 34% (2009) of the hospital beds in
Belgium. Data on adult patients, who were either hospitalized with a primary
diagnosis of primary pulmonary hypertension (PH) (ICD-9-CM code 416.0) OR were
receiving ≥ 1 medication indicated for PAH, was extracted. To ensure hospitalizations were likely related to disease worsening and not to planned procedures or
routine visits, only unscheduled hospitalizations of at least 2 days were included
in the analysis. Hospitalizations were excluded if primary co-diagnoses were suggestive of a non-PAH-related reason for the admission. Total hospitalization costs,
including hotel, drugs, procedure costs (extrapolated to 2013), and length of stay
(LOS) were analyzed with descriptive statistics. Results: 35 hospitalizations were
included into the study. Patients experiencing these admissions were mainly female
(71.4%), which is in line with the known female-male ratio (2-1) for this rare disease. Mean (SD) hospitalization cost was € 20,229 (9,399), including € 4,396 (9,502)
drug, € 8,499 (8,999) hotel, and € 7,334 (12,386) procedure costs. Average LOS was
17.7±16.8 days. Conclusions: Long durations and high incurred costs for PAHrelated hospitalizations reveal the severe morbidity, health care, and patient burden
of PAH in Belgium.
.
.
.
1Gazi
PRS33
Economic Burden in Direct Costs of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary
Disease (COPD) in Russia
PRS30
The Cost Burden of Community-Acquired Pneumonia in Russia in
Adults of 50 and Older: A Regional Study and National Estimates
Krysanova V 1, Krysanov I 2
1I.M. Sechenov First Moscow State Medical University, Moscow, Russia, 2Postgraduate Medical
Institute, Moscow National University of Food Production, Moscow, Russia
Samyshkin Y 1, Roberts C S 2, Koroleva N 3, Rodionov A 4
Health, London, UK, 2Pfizer Inc., New York, NY, USA, 3Sechenov Moscow Medical University,
Moscow, Russia, 4Tver State Medical Academy, Tver, Russia
Objectives: COPD is one of the leading causes of morbidity and mortality worldwide and has a major burden on Russian’s health care system. It’s lead to frequent
use of health care resources. The main aim of this study was to describe the direct
costs for management of COPD patients with differing degrees of disease severity. Methods: The methodology for cost of illness analysis was based on a previous Russian study (Avksenteva M. V. et al., 2010). One-year costs were identified by
applying cost data to medical information obtained by medical statistical records
from 2007. In this study were performed 2 variants of COPD costs. In 1st variant were
used epidemiological data from 2007 and medical resources costs from 2014. In 2nd
variant were used extrapolated epidemiological data and medical resources costs
from 2014. Due to lack of actual data in this study was modeled situation – from 2007
to 2012 the overall incidence of adult increased by 12.5%. Medical resources included
hospital stays, outpatient visits and ambulance service. Results: The mean annual
overall direct health care cost for 1st variant was estimated to be 54.6 billion rubles
($1.6 billion), for 2nd variant was estimated to be 61.6 billion rubles ($1.8 billion). The
.
.
.
.
.
1IMS
Objectives: Community-acquired pneumonia (CAP) represents a considerable burden in Russia. We assessed cost of CAP in Russia to characterize disease burden in
Russian adults of age 50 and older. Methods: We conducted a retrospective chart
review in a central Russian region of Tver for samples of 900 patients treated in inpatient and outpatient settings, and extrapolated data nationally. All patients were 50
years of age and represented new cases of CAP. Data were collected on demographics, comorbidities, and employment. The cost was estimated from the public payer
perspective, with a productivity loss in patients below retirement age. Results:
Cost of treatment was similar across age-and-risk groups in hospital and in outpatient settings. The cost of an outpatient episode was estimated far all risk groups at
RR2176 ($69), ranging from RR1,939 ($61) to RR2537 (~$80) for age groups 50-64 and
75-84 respectively; the cost of episode for low-risk patients was RR1737 ($55), and
.
.
A594
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
structure of direct costs in Russia was as follows – 77% for hospital stays, 21% for outpatient visits, 2% for ambulance service. COPD exacerbations contributed the major
portion of cost and also correlated with disease severity. Conclusions: COPD
associated with significant economic burden on Russian’s health care system. There
is a striking direct relationship between the cost of care and severity of the disease
with hospitalization leading to disease exacerbation being a major portion of cost.
PRS34
The Costs of Illness of Atopic Dermatitis in South Korea
Kim C M 1, Yim H W 1, Jo S J 1, Ahn S H 1, Seo S J 2, Choi W S 1
1Catholic University College of Medicine, Seoul, South Korea,, 2Chung-Ang University, Seoul, South
Korea
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Atopic dermatitis is a global public health concern considering its
growing prevalence and mounting socioeconomic burden. However, Few studies
has assessed the economic impact of atopic dermatitis in Korea. To conduct a cost
analysis of atopic dermatitis and evaluate the economic impact of the disease on
individual annual disease burden, quality of life, and change in medical expenses
in regards to change in health related quality of life. Methods: This prospective
cost analysis of atopic dermatitis by reviewing the housekeeping account books
of 32 patients was conducted and evaluated the economic impact of the disease
by analyzing the completed questionnaires. To handle the potential uncertainties,
we compared the results with the data released by the Health Insurance Review &
Assessment Board on medical costs claimed by the health care facilities. Results:
In regards to the cost of illness, direct cost of atopic dermatitis per patient during
the 3 month study period was 541,280 KRW and expenditure on other atopic dermatitis related products was 120,313 KRW. Extrapolated annual direct cost (including
expenditures on other atopic dermatitis related product) per patient was 2,646,372
KRW. Estimated annual indirect cost was 1,507,068 KRW. Annual cost of illness of
atopic dermatitis, computed by adding up direct and indirect costs, was estimated
to be 4,153,440 KRW. Conclusions: The annual total social cost on a national level
was estimated at 5.8000 trillion KRW.
PRS35
The Cost Study of Health Services in Mongolia
Damdinbazar O
Mongolian national university of Medical Science, Ulaanbatar, Mongolia
.
Objectives: There are three main funding sources of health system In Mongolia
which are state budget, health insurance and out of pocket payment. Health insurance funded health care service based on 115 DRG and total financing to health care
organizations were 87.1 billion MNT in 2011. Health insurance rates 240000 MNT
secondary and thirtary level of hospital by the same tariff. Aim of the study is to
calculate 10 DRG costs which were spent 25 percent of the health insurance fund
in 2012. Methods: We used both top down and bottom-up cost allocation method.
Secondary data were used. Results: Respiratory diseases finance is 9 percent
higher than the real cost. Other 9 diagnostic groups finance were less than actual
cost by 8-62%. That the total funding based on the number of cases nationwide,
12,032,906,381 MNT funding was insufficient. Conclusions: Health insurance
base tariff have to change based on the study while base rates should be different
at secondary and thirtary level of health care organization.
PRS36
A Pharmacoeconomic Care Analysis of Tuberculosis Control in
Pakistan
Iqbal M S 1, Iqbal M W 2, Bahari M B 3, Khalid S H 4, Iqbal M Z 1
of Clinical Pharmacy, Faculty of Pharmacy, AIMST University, Kedah, Malaysia,
2Faculty of Law, Universiti Malaya,, Kualalumpur, Malaysia, 3Faculty of Law, Universiti Malaya,
Kualalumpur, Malaysia, 4Department of Pharmaceutical Technology, School of Pharmaceutical
Sciences, Universiti Sains Malaysia, Pulau Pinang, Malaysia
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Department
Objectives: To assess the direct and indirect medical costs incurred in
the treatment of tuberculosis (TB) in patients attending public hospitals in
Pakistan. Methods: A descriptive cross-sectional study was conducted in patients
attending Accident and Emergency and TB wards of the hospitals in Pakistan by convenient-sampling technique. The direct and indirect medical costs were determined
by various parameters like consultation fees, cost of medicines, travelling costs
and laboratory test expenses etc. All obtained data were analyzed using descriptive and inferential statistics. Results: The mean annual direct medical cost for
a TB patient was around Rs. 17317.56 (US$ 176.26) and indirect medical cost was
Rs. 12918.50 (US$ 131.48). It was also observed that ccomparatively higher direct
and indirect medical costs per patient (p < 0.001) were associated with large and
urban hospitals. Besides, association of indirect medical costs with gender and age
were the persuasive predictors of the study. Conclusions: Severity of the disease,
distance to the hospital and length of stay in the hospital were proportional to the
direct and indirect medical costs. In Pakistan, a significant proportion of the direct
medical cost for TB treatment is subsidized for the public.
culated. Methods: The costs including lab investigation charges, unit costs of
treatment per bed, medication charges, food costs, transportation costs and loss of
productivity were calculated per asthma episode. Data was analysed by Statistical
Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS) version 18.0 using various descriptive and
inferential statistical tests. Results: A median medical cost of acute exacerbation
of asthma under Ministry of Health’s (MOH) perspective was USD 105.00 (RM338.47)
per episode. Medication cost comprised the majority (52.38%) of the total medical
costs. A median medical cost of acute exacerbation of asthma under patient’s perspective was USD 1.55 (RM4.99) per episode. Conclusions: Asthma exacerbation
and length of stay in the hospital were proportional to the direct medical costs. In
Malaysia, a substantial proportion of the direct medical cost of asthma treatment
is heavily subsidised for the locals.
PRS38
Pharmacoeconomic Evaluation and Burden of Illness of Acute
Exacerbation of Copd in Patients in Malaysia
Iqbal M S 1, Iqbal M Z 1, Barua A 2, Veettil S K 3, Wei L Y 3, Kit L W 3, Khan A H 4, Hussain Z 4,
Iqbal M W 5
1Department of Clinical Pharmacy, Faculty of Pharmacy, AIMST University, Kedah, Malaysia,
2Division of Community Medicine, School of Medicine, IMU, Bukit Jalil, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia,
3Department of Pharmacy Practice, School of Pharmacy, IMU, Bukit Jalil, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia,
4Department of Clinical Pharmacy, School of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Universiti Sains Malaysia,
Pulau Pinang, Malaysia, 5Faculty of Law, Universiti Malaya, Kualalumpur, Malaysia
.
.
.
.
M S 1, Iqbal
M Z 1, Barua A 2, Veettil
S K 3, Ling T K 3, Yong
N B 3, Khan A H 4, Hussain
Z 4,
Iqbal
Iqbal M W 5
1Department of Clinical Pharmacy, Faculty of Pharmacy, AIMST University, Kedah, Malaysia,
2Division of Community Medicine, School of Medicine, IMU, Bukit Jalil, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia,
3Department of Pharmacy Practice, School of Pharmacy, IMU, Bukit Jalil, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia,
4Department of Clinical Pharmacy, School of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Universiti Sains Malaysia,
Pulau Pinang, Malaysia, 5Faculty of Law, Universiti Malaya, Kualalumpur, Malaysia
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The cost of acute exacerbations of asthma had not been well studied in literature. The aim of this study was to identify and quantify the (average)
cost of moderate and severe exacerbations of asthma in patients attending tertiary-care setup in Malaysia. The related burden of exacerbations was also cal-
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Acute exacerbation of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
(AECOPD) appears to be the main reason of hospitalization in COPD patients. Since
substantial economic burden of COPD have not been previously studied in Malaysia,
this study aimed at estimating and identifying different costs and related burden
of illness in patients receiving treatment of AECOPD in a tertiary care hospital in
Malaysia. Methods: A prospective follow-up study was performed in Department
of Accident and Emergency and Respiratory Medicine of the hospital. Data were
derived on the basis of per exacerbation episode. Relationship between direct medical costs and disease severity was analyzed using various descriptive and inferential
statistical approaches. Results: Median actual direct medical costs and out-ofpocket costs were RM 457.68 (US$ 141.97) and RM 28.25 (US$ 8.76) per exacerbation
respectively. Drug cost (41%) was the leading cost driver, followed by unit cost of
treatment per bed (33.6%) and lab investigation cost (25.4%). However, food cost
(44.2%) represented the largest proportion in out-of-pocket costs. More than 90% of
actual direct medical costs were supported by the Government of Malaysia in the
patients studied. Conclusions: Impacts of AECOPD in health care resources are
worthy of attention. Cost information from pharmacoeconomic studies is important in decision making for health care professionals and policy makers in order to
improve health care outcome and minimize costs.
PRS39
Prospective Study on the Average Cost of Therapy for Bronchial
Asthma Patients in an Indian Tertiary Care Teaching Hospital
Nair S V , Abdulsalim S , Yedavalli N S , Shukla R , Mohan M K
Manipal University, Manipal, India
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To conduct a study to determine the average cost of therapy for bronchial asthma patients in a tertiary care center. Methods: A prospective observational study was carried out on a 100 bronchial asthma patients after ethical
clearance was obtained from an Independent Ethical Review (IEC) board. The patients
selected for the study were in-patients admitted to the Medicine and Pulmonary
wards for bronchial asthma related complaints with and without co-morbidities.
The study assessed the average cost of therapy which was obtained from patient
records. Statistical analysis was performed using SPSS version 20. Results: The
mean age of the study population (N=100) was 53.30±14.59. Females constituted 61%
of the study population. The job profiles of the majority of study population were
house wives (53%) and agriculturist (15%). The average cost of therapy among 100
patients was found to range from $1.81 to $598. The impact on the length of stay on
cost of therapy per day was classified into ≤ 5, 6-10, 11-21 days and cost was found to
be $9.21 ± 5.57, $12.12 ±9.65 and $15.56±10.36 respectively. Impact of co-morbidities
(35%) and without co-morbidities on cost of therapy per day was found to be $13.03
± 10.63 and $8.54 ± 6.77 respectively. Conclusions: Asthma creates a substantial
financial burden on the society and results in compromise on diagnosis and treatment mainly in a developing country like India. There was a substantial increase in
the cost of therapy as the duration of hospital stay increased and also in the case
of patients with co-morbidities. Pharmacoeconomic analysis is needed to develop
strategies to reduce the cost of therapy and thereby achieve greater medication
adherence and improved quality of life in asthma patients.
PRS40
Resource Use and Health Care Costs of Chronic Obstructive
Pulmonary Disease in Slovakia
Ondrusova M , Psenkova M , Mackovicova S
Pharm-In Ltd, Bratislava, Slovak Republic
.
PRS37
Pharmacoeconomic Evaluation of Acute Exacerbation of Asthma in
Patients in Malaysia
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The objective of this cost study was to measure the resource utilisation and the direct costs associated with health care management of patients
with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) in Slovakia and to provide a
basis for cost-effectiveness evaluations. Methods: The cross-sectional survey was
performed to obtain the information on the management of patients with COPD
and to estimate the direct costs of the disease management. The survey included
4 experts experienced in COPD treatment. The studied population were cohorts of
COPD patients evaluated separately according to the stage of the disease (mild, moderate, severe and very severe). The patients were treated with standard therapy, the
cost were set for one average patient per 3 months of treatment. The cost data were
assessed and actualized due the 1st July 2014. All types of health care used in COPD
management were evaluated (hospitalization, outpatient visits, diagnostics, laboratory tests and the management of symptoms, use of bronchodilators). Moderate
A595
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
and severe exacerbations were also evaluated and the costs were set for one single
event. Results: The total cost of mild COPD was € 26.22, moderate COPD € 30.26,
severe COPD € 92.04 and for the very severe COPD € 267.64 for 1 patient/3 months.
Expenses for bronchodilators also vary between different stages of COPD, for mild
COPD it represented € 17.44, moderate COPD € 109.54, severe COPD € 219.58 and for
very severe COPD € 206.15. Cost of treating exacerbations were set for one event - for
moderate exacerbation € 67 and for severe exacerbation € 1060.27. Conclusions:
In the management of COPD the most expensive are the costs of hospitalization,
outpatient care and symptomatic treatment. The most costly is the management
of the very severe COPD and severe exacerbation. This survey can be used as the
source for cost inputs in pharmacoeconomic studies.
PRS41
Cost-Effectiveness of Conjugate Pneumococcal Vaccination in
Romania
Preda A L 1, Moise M 1, Delgleize E 2, Leeuwenkamp O R 3
.
.
.
.
.
.
1GlaxoSmithKline, Bucharest, Romania,, 2GlaxoSmithKline Vaccines, Wavre, Belgium,, 3Eclipse,
Tervuren, Belgium
Objectives: The objective was to analyze the cost-effectiveness of a national immunization program with pneumococcal conjugate vaccine (PCV): 10-valent pneumococcal non-typeable Haemophilus influenzae protein D conjugate vaccine (PHiD-CV)
and 13-valent pneumococcal conjugate vaccine (PCV-13) in Romania. Methods: A
published age stratified, deterministic, and static cohort model is used. This model
highlights changes in cost and quality adjusted life years (QALYs) over time. Serotype
specific disease incidence, age stratified disease incidence, mortality in the population, vaccine costs and resource utilization costs were obtained from a General
Practitioner reports database and epidemiological sources. The model compared
identical immunization programs involving PHiD-CV and PCV-13 vaccines taking the
payer perspective. A cohort of 201,104 Romanian infants was followed for four years.
Same net indirect protection for invasive pneumococcal disease (IPD) was assumed
for both vaccines. Results: With 80% vaccine uptake and 2+1 vaccination schedule,
PHiD-CV dominated PCV-13 assuming price parity. Vaccination with PHiD-CV versus
PCV-13 resulted in an offset for the health care budget of £22,948 (the main driver
of this difference is the decrease in Acute Otitis Media (AOM) related costs – with a
total of 4,663 cases prevented) and a total of 23 QALYs gained. Sensitivity analyses
revealed robustness of the model results, confirmed the dominance of PHiD-CV
over PCV-13 and substantiated model outcome driven by incremental efficacy of
PHiD-CV in conjunction with high incidence AOM. Conclusions: According to the
model, implementation of PHiD-CV vaccination program for infants in Romania will
offer substantial benefits in terms of cost savings and improved health compared
to an identical vaccination program involving PCV-13. PHiD-CV’s potential to better
prevent AOM translates into incremental benefits and dominance of PHiD-CV over
PCV-13 given that their impact on IPD is similar.
PRS42
Cost-Effectiveness of a COPD Disease Management Program in
Primary Care: The Recode Cluster Randomized Trial
Boland M R S 1, Kruis A 2, Tsiachristas A 1, Assendelft W 2, Gussekloo J 2, Blom C 3, Chavannes
N 2, Rutten van-Molken M 1
1Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 2Leiden University, Leiden, The
Netherlands, 3Stichting Zorgdraad foundation, Oosterbeek, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Disease management programs for chronic obstructive pulmonary
disease (herein, COPD-DM) are currently implemented on a broad scale in the
Netherlands. However, the evidence about their cost-effectiveness is still inconclusive.
We aimed to conduct a cost-effectiveness analysis of a COPD-DM program in primary
care in the Netherlands, called RECODE. In RECODE, a multidisciplinary primary care
team was trained in motivational interviewing to improve life style, setting-up individual care plans, early recognizing and managing of exacerbations, and implementing clinical guidelines. In addition, clinical decision making was supported by audit
and feedback reports provided by an ICT program and reimbursement of physical
reactivation by a physiotherapist was provided. Methods: In a two-year cluster-randomized controlled trial (1086 COPD patients, 40 clusters), the COPD-DM program was
compared to usual care. As part of this trial we conducted a cost-effectiveness analysis
to relate the effect of the COPD-DM on intermediate and final health outcomes to the
costs from a health care and a societal perspective. Detailed self-reported health care
utilization data were collected during the trial-period. Results: The 2-year intervention costs of the training for professionals, the ICT, and the audit and feedback
reports were estimated to be €324 per patient. Excluding these costs, the intervention
group had €584 (95% CI €86 to €1,046) higher health care costs and €645 (95% CI €28 to
€1,190) higher costs from the societal perspective compared to the usual care group.
Health outcomes were similar in both groups, except for 0.04 (95% CI -0.07 to -0.01)
less quality-adjusted life-years in the intervention group. Conclusions: RECODE
was not cost-effective during the 2-year follow-up period. This is most likely due to
the fact that the interventions targeted professionals instead of patients and were
suboptimally implemented, the relatively mild COPD population, and the national
reforms in COPD care that affected the usual care group.
PRS43
Cost Effectiveness of Bedaquiline for the Treatment of MultidrugResistant Tuberculosis
Wolfson L 1, Walker A 2, Hettle R 3, Lu X 1, Kambili C 4, Murungi A 5, Knerer G 6
Pharmaceutica, Beerse, Belgium, 2Heron Evidence Development, Ltd., Luton, UK,
3PAREXEL Consulting, London, UK, 4Jansen Global Services, Raritan, NJ, USA, 5Janssen-Cilag UK,
High Wycombe, UK, 6University of Southampton, Southampton, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
over a 10-year horizon. A National Health Service (NHS) and personal social services perspective was considered. The effectiveness of treatment was evaluated
in terms of Quality Adjusted Life Years (QALYs) and Disability Adjusted Life Years
(DALYs). Data were sourced from a phase II, placebo controlled trial of bedaquiline,
NHS reference costs, and the literature. Costs and effectiveness were discounted
at a rate of 3.5% per annum. Probabilistic and deterministic sensitivity analysis
was conducted. Results: The total discounted cost per patient on B+BR was
£107,123, compared with £116,616 for BR. The total discounted QALYs per patient
were 4.85 for B+BR and 3.81 for BR. The addition of bedaquiline to BR resulted
in cost-savings of £9,493 and an additional 1.04 QALYs pp over a 10-year period,
and is therefore considered to be the dominant (less costly and more effective)
strategy over BR. B+BR remained dominant versus BR in the majority of sensitivity
analyses, with a 74% probability of being dominant versus BR in the probabilistic
analysis. Conclusions: In the UK, bedaquiline is likely to be cost-effective and
cost-saving, compared to the current standard of care for MDR-TB under a range
of scenarios. Cost-savings over a 10 year period were realized from reductions in
lengths of hospital stay, which offset bedaquiline drug costs. Bedaquiline remained
cost-saving in several sensitivity analyses, highlighting the certainty surrounding
the results of the model. These results also indicate that the B+BR regimen can
provide significant social economic benefits versus the BR only regimen.
PRS44
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Umeclidinium Bromide Compared to
Tiotropium Bromide for Symptomatic Patients with COPD in the UK
Ismaila A 1, Roberts G 2, Punekar Y S 3, O’Leary M 2
1GlaxoSmithKline, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA, 2Double Helix, London, UK, 3GlaxoSmithKline,
Uxbridge, UK
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate the long-term cost-effectiveness of umeclidinium bromide
62.5 mcg OD (UMEC) compared to tiotropium bromide 18 mcg OD (TIO) for the
maintenance treatment of COPD from the UK National Health Service perspective Methods: We utilized a recently developed, internally and externally validated
linked equations COPD Cohort disease progression model. The treatment effect,
expressed as change from baseline in forced expiratory volume in one second (FEV1)
at 12 and 24 weeks estimated from a Bucher method indirect treatment comparison
(ITC) analysis following a systematic review. UMEC price was set at parity price of
£33.5/month to TIO. Model outcomes included exacerbations, life years, quality
adjusted life years (QALYs) and costs/QALY. The time horizons investigated ranged
from one to 20 years (lifetime) on a sliding one-year increment. Costs, survival, and
QALYs after the first year were discounted at a rate of 3.5%. Health care costs were
obtained from NHS reference costs (2011-12). Sensitivity analyses were performed
to evaluate the robustness of the model to variations in the underlying input parameters and assumptions. Results: The ITC estimated change from baseline in trough
FEV1 of 18.06mL (95%CI: -19.11, 55.23, p= 0.341) at 12 weeks and 3.97mL (95%CI:
-38.30, 46.25, p= 0.854) at 24 weeks for UMEC compared with TIO. At price parity,
UMEC dominated TIO with incremental QALY of 0.0009, incremental life years of
0.0001 and cost reduction of £4.54. The sensitivity analyses suggested that variation
in main parameters will not alter the behavior of the comparison between the two
treatments. Conclusions: At price parity to TIO, UMEC may be considered as a
cost-effective treatment alternative for maintenance bronchodilator treatment to
relieve symptoms in patients with COPD in the UK.
PRS45
Cost Effectiveness of Umeclidinium/Vilanterol (UMEC/VI)
Combination Therapy Among Symptomatic COPD Patients
Punekar Y S 1, Roberts G 2, Ismaila A 3, O’Leary M 2
1GlaxoSmithKline, Uxbridge, UK, 2Double Helix, London, UK, 3GlaxoSmithKline, Research Triangle
Park, NC, USA
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: UMEC/VI is a long acting muscarinic agent (LAMA) and long acting beta
agonist (LABA) combination therapy. This study evaluated the cost-effectiveness of
UMEC/VI compared to tiotropium (18µg) from the UK National Health Service perspective. Methods: A linked equations cohort model developed using the patient
level data from ECLIPSE study and validated using patient level data from TORCH
study was used. The baseline patient characteristics were derived from UMEC/VI
phase IIIa clinical programme and included symptomatic COPD patients. The treatment effect expressed as change from baseline in forced expiratory volume in one
second (FEV1) at 24 weeks was estimated using 3 tiotropium comparator phase
IIIa trials and was assumed to last for at least 52 weeks following treatment initiation. Model outcomes included exacerbations, life years, quality adjusted life years
(QALYs) and costs/QALY. The timeframe for the analysis was patient lifetime and the
discount rate for costs and outcomes was 3.5%. The price of UMEC/VI was varied to
estimate the points at which it would be cost effective compared with the current
standard of care tiotropium. Health care costs were obtained from NHS reference
costs (2011-12). Results: The random effects meta-analysis estimated treatment
benefit of 92.17ml (95% CI: 61.52, 122.82; p<0.001) in FEV1for UMEC/VI compared with
tiotropium. A lifetime model resulted in 0.009 fewer moderate-severe exacerbations
per year on UMEC/VI. At parity price (£33.5/month), UMEC/VI dominated tiotropium with a probability of 0.81 for being cost effective at £30,000/QALY threshold.
The incremental cost effectiveness ratios were £11,080 and £22,178 at 5% and 10%
price premium to tiotropium, respectively. Conclusions: At an appropriate price,
UMEC/VI may be considered as a cost-effective treatment alternative for symptomatic patients with COPD.
1Janssen
Objectives: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of adding bedaquiline to the intensive phase of background regimens (BR) of drugs for multidrug-resistant tuberculosis
(MDR-TB) in the United Kingdom (UK). Methods: A cohort-based Markov model
was developed to estimate the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio of bedaquiline plus BR (B+BR) versus BR alone (BR) in the treatment of MDR-TB in the UK,
PRS46
Cost Effective Analysis of Dry Powdered Inhalers Versus Metered
Dose Inhalers of Salbutamol for Asthma in Rural Secondary Care
Hospital of South India
Vigneshwaran E , Maddirevula M R , Dharmareddy L , Thamineni R , Kadapala P R , Golla M ,
Yiragamreddy P R
raghavendra institute of pharmaceutical education and research, Anantapur, India
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A596
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: Asthma is a chronic disorder requires continuous and long term management. Thus it makes the patient economically week and produces more burden
on patient. Short acting β 2agonists in pressurized metered dose inhalers and dry
powdered inhalers are the most commonly prescribed formulations in south Indian
clinical settings. The present study aims to investigate and to select appropriate
cost effective formulation of metered dose inhalers (MDR) or dry powdered inhalers
(DPI) for salbutamol. Methods: It is a prospective comparative study conducted
among subjects those who were newly diagnosed with asthma. The patients were
divided into two groups based on the type of inhaler used such as MDI or DPI group.
All the patients were counseled about the usage of inhalers during their treatment device allotment. Quality of life and FEV 1 were measured at the baseline
visit. In addition to that data related to direct cost such as medical, laboratory and
re- hospitalization costs were also measured at baseline. Follow up was done for
both the groups. Similar to baseline visit quality of life, FEV1 and direct medical costs
were measured during follow up. Results: The present study results shows that
there is no significant difference between two groups with regards to demographic
characteristics. We observed a significant difference in QOL (p < 0.05) and the mean
score for two treatment devices groups was found to be 55.63 &43.72 respectively.
There is no significant difference in FEV 1 (p > 0.05) and symptom free days between
two treatment devices. Average cost effectiveness ratio was calculated and average
cost effectiveness ratio for MDI were found to be less compared to DPI but statistically not significant. Conclusions: Overall it was found that efficacy was higher
in MDI than DPI and cost was equal for both the groups to treat newly diagnosed
asthma patients with salbutamol.
PRS47
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Community-Acquired Pneumonia
Treatment
Zaytsev A 1, Makarevich A 2, Kondratyeva T 3
Main Military Clinical Burdenko Hospital, Moscow, Russia, 2The 301 Military Clinical
Hospital, Khabarovsk, Russia, 3The 1586 Military Clinical Hospital, Podolsk, Russia
.
.
.
1The
Objectives: To evaluate clinical efficacy, safety and cost-effectiveness of treatment options for mild to moderate community-acquired pneumonia in patients
with risk factors of poor efficacy (prior administration of antibiotics, comorbidities), comparing generic levofloxacin (Glevo, Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Ltd.)
versus original levofloxacin (Tavanic®, Sanofi-Winthrop Ind.) and conventional
treatment (b-lactam±macrolide). Methods: Patients were randomized to 3 treatment arms. Mean age was 24.3±11.5years. Treatment arm 1 included 61 patient
administered GLEVO in the dose of 500 mg/day, whereas in the treatment arm
2 (n= 41) patients were treated with original levofloxacin (Tavanic) in the dose
of 500mg/day, and 45 patients in the treatment arm 3 received conventional
therapy. Clinical efficacy and safety were evaluated based on clinical, laboratory
and radiological data analysis. Cost-effectiveness analysis included calculation of direct medical expenses and cost-effectiveness ratios (CER). Results:
Clinical efficacy rate in the treatment arm 1 (Glevo) was98.4%, in the treatment
arm 2 (Tavanic)–97.6%, whereas conventional therapy efficacy rate was84.4%.
Adverse event incidence in the treatment arm 1 was 21.3%, in treatment arms 2
and 3 –14.6% and35.5% respectively. Treatment duration in the Glevo treatment
arm was8.2±1.4days, in the treatment arm2 –8±1.2, in the conventional therapy
arm–7.2±2,1 days. Time to radiological resolution of pneumonia was comparable. Mean cost of antibiotic administration cycle and the cost-effectiveness
ratio in patients administered Glevo was 7.65€ (CERGLEVO = 7.8), in the treatment
arm 2 – 22.4€ (CERTAV= 22.9), in the conventional therapy arm–10.8€ (CERSTAND=
12.8). Conclusions: Administration of levofloxacin for mild to moderate community-acquired pneumonia in patients with risk factors is superior in clinical
efficacy compared to conventional treatment modalities. Administration of Glevo
is characterized by favorable cost-effectiveness parameters.
PRS48
Economic Evaluation of the Fixed Dose Combination of Indacaterol/
Glycopyrromium, as a Maintenance Bronchodilator Treatment in
Adult Mexican Patients With COPD
Reyes Lopez A 1, Lemus Carmona E A 2, Ruiz Miranda C I 2, Fernandez Plata M D R 3,
Martínez Briseño D 3
1Center for Economic and Social Studies in Health, Mexican Children Hospital, Mexico, Mexico,
2Novartis Mexico, Mexico, Mexico, 3National Institute of Respiratory Disease, Mexico, Mexico
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To perform a cost-effectiveness analysis of Indacaterol/
Glycopyrronium (IG) against tiotropium monotherapy (TM), salmeterol/fluticasone (SF) and indacaterol/tiotropium (IT) for COPD patients from the perspective
of the Mexican Public Healthcare System. Methods: A patient-simulation model
structured in MS Excel, developed and validated by Asukai et al (2013), allowed us
to compare IG against tiotropium monotherapy (TM), salmeterol/fluticasone (SF)
and indacaterol/tiotropium (IT). The effectiveness measures analyzed were life
years gained and exacerbations avoided based on efficacy data extracted from a
comprehensive large phase III trial program comprising 11 studies (ILLUMINATE,
SHINE, BRIGHT, ENLIGHTEN, SPARK, BLAZE, ARISE, BEACON, RADIATE, LANTERN,
FLAME) with more than 10,000 patients across 52 countries. COPD drug cost, maintenance cost and exacerbation cost were estimated for six months duration of
model cycle, using local prices for public health care institutions and evaluating
the resources utilization data extracted from a sample of medical records. Lifetime
horizon was used and a discount rate of 5%. Deterministic and probabilistic sensitivity analysis was performed. Results: Total expected costs per patient were
US$30,421 and US$31,577 for the comparison IG vs TM respectively; US$28,817 and
US$28,852 for IG vs SF respectively; US$28,900 and US$34,557 for IG vs IT respectively. IG delivers slightly more life years than comparators, but avoid significantly
more exacerbations than the other options (1 to 4) which in turn have favorable
economic impacts. Sensitivity analysis showed that base-case results are robust to
variations of key model parameters. Conclusions: Indacaterol/ Glycopyrronium
resulted more effective and less costly than comparators. These results showed
that is possible to achieve cost-savings and a potential clinical benefit with the
fixed dose of IG for Mexican patients with COPD.
PRS49
Cost- Effectiveness of Real Life Asthma Pharmacotherapy
Grekova D 1, Dimitrova M 2, Andreevska K 1, Petkova V 3, Madzharov V 1, Gueorguiev S 1,
Petrova G 4
1Medical university of Plovdiv, Plovdiv, Bulgaria, 2Medical University of Sofia, Faculty of
Pharmacy, Sofia, Bulgaria, 3Medical University, Faculty of Pharmacy, Sofia, Bulgaria, 4Medical
University Sofia, Faculty of Pharmacy, Sofia, Bulgaria
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To analyze ambulatory prescribing practice and to assess the costeffectiveness of asthma pharmacotherapy in country settings. Methods: It is a
prospective prescribing practice and cost-effectiveness analysis. During 2008-2011
were observed 238 patients in Plovdiv region and collected information about their
ambulatory asthma pharmacotherapy. Prescribed medicines were systematized in
INN groups of mono and fixed dose combination products. The FEO1 and percentage
of patients without exacerbation were used as measure of the therapeutic results.
Incremental cost-effectiveness ratio was calculated and with Tornado diagram was
explored the sensitivity of the results. Results: Pharmacotherapy with fixed dose
combination was performed mainly with Beclomethazone/formoterol; Budesonide/
formoterol; and Salmeterol/fluticasone. The monthly cost of pharmacotherapy is
varying among 35 and 50 Euro. Incremental cost effectiveness ratio is favoring the
combination Beclomethazone/ formoterol 100/6 mcg with ICER of 324 Euro for additional increase in FEO1, and 50 Euro ICER for additional patient without exacerbation, although all alternatives are cost-effective because all ICERs fall below the GDP
per capita. The monotherapy was performed with Beclomethazone, Fluticasone,
Budesonide, Ciclesonide, and Montelukast. Its monthly cost was among 19 and 40
Euro. Incremental cost effectiveness ratio is favoring ciclesonide that is a dominant
alternative as monotherapy for both studies outcomes. Results are sensitive to the
changes in therapeutic outcomes. Conclusions: The real life therapy follows the
international guidelines but less fixed dose combinations were prescribed in comparison with international recommendations. Beclomethazone/ formoterol fixed
dose combination and ciclesonide as monotherapy are cost-effective alternatives
for the observed health care settings.
PRS50
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of High-Dose Levofloxacin Therapy of
Patients With Community-Acquired Pneumonia
Zaytsev A 1, Makarevich A 2
1The Main Military Clinical Burdenko Hospital, Moscow, Russia, 2The 301 Military Clinical
Hospital, Khabarovsk, Russia
.
.
Objectives: Study of clinical efficacy, tolerance and economic indicators of treatment of non-severe CAP by (5-day) course of levofloxacin 750 mg/day vs. the standard administration of levofloxacin 500 mg/day. Methods: The research included 64
patients having non-severe CAP with risk factors (administration of antibiotics during
the preceding 3 months, concomitant diseases), all of them being males. The patients
were randomized into 2 groups; the 1st group received high-dose therapy of levofloxacin, 750 mg/day within 5 days (Remedia, Simpex-Pharma, India). 2nd group recieved
levofloxacin 500 mg/day for 7-10 days (Tavanic®, Sanofi-Winthrop Ind.). Efficacy and
safety were assessed in terms of comprehensive analysis of clinical, laboratory and
radiological data. For economic analysis, direct medical costs and “costs-efficacy”
ratios (CER) were calculated. Results: First group included 32 patients with average age 22.7±1.8 years. Second group consisted of 32 patients with average 21.8±6
years. Clinical efficacy of high-dose levofloxacin therapy amounted to 96.9%. Average
duration of antibiotic treatment was 5.2±0.9 days.. Standard regime by levofloxacin
was efficient in 100% of cases. Radiological resolution was identical in both groups.
Transient increase of hepatic transaminase activity was present in 3 patients (9.4%).
In standard group, this adverse event was present in 4 patients (12.5%). Average treatment cost by levofloxacin 750 mg/day amounted to 13.3±6.2 euros (CERLEVO-750=13.7);
cost of the standard therapy was 27.2±4.9 euros (CERLEVO-750=27.2). Conclusions
: Therefore, in terms of clinical efficacy and safety, the high-dose therapy (750 mg/
day) by levofloxacin, in brief course of treatment of patients having non-severe CAP,
is comparable with the standard regime of treatment (levofloxacin 500 mg/day for 7
to 10 days); and, is more efficient in economic terms.
PRS51
Cost-Effectiveness of Asthma Management in a Hospital-Based
Adult Asthma Clinic in Spain
Perez de Llano L A 1, Villoro R 2, Hidalgo A 3, Merino M 2
Universitario Lucus Augusti, Lugo, Spain, 2Instituto Max Weber, Madrid, Spain,
3University of Castilla La Mancha, Toledo, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
1Hospital
Objectives: Optimal asthma control has been associated with significant reductions in mortality, morbidity, and quality of life gains for the patients. Hospital
Asthma Clinics (ACs) are hospital-based units run by an experienced team composed of a pneumologist and a specialized nurse. Their aim is to provide effective
treatment and optimal control to asthma patients. However, their impact on disease control and their cost-effectiveness are unknown. The objective of this study
is to assess the cost-effectiveness of managing asthma patients in an AC versus
traditional management. Methods: We designed a case-crossover study using the
medical records of all patients submitted to one AC in Spain during 2012. We defined
the case period as 365 days after the first visit to the AC, and the control period as 365
days before the index date. We calculated changes in relevant disease control indicators and estimated the Incremental Cost Effectiveness Ratio (ICER) for one additional
controlled patient. Results: The percentage of controlled patients increased from
41% to 86% (n= 83, mean age was 49 ± 15.2; 66% female). Asthma control test score
increased from 18.7 ± 4.6 to 22.6 ± 2.3 (p< 0.005), exacerbations decreased by 75%
(p< 0.005) and FEV1 increased from 81.4% ± 17.5 to 84.4% ± 16.6 (p< 0.05). The use of
ICS/LABA combinations decreased from 79.5% to 41%. On the contrary, the use of
other drugs increased: anticholinergics from 3.6% to 16.9%, inhaled corticosteroids
A597
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
alone from 3.6% to 45.8%, and omalizumab from 0% to 6%. Annual hospitalizations
rates and emergency visits decreased by 78% and 75% respectively. The ICER was
1800€ per controlled patient per year. Conclusions: Managing asthma patients
in a specialized AC is cost-effective and has significant impact on patient control,
indicating better survival and quality of life for the patient according to published
literature evidence.
PRS52
Impact of Allergen Immunotherapy on Symptom-Free Days and
Health Care Costs in Patients With Grass Pollen-Induced Allergic
Rhinitis in Germany
Najib M 1, Westerhout K Y 2, Verheggen B 2, Schreder C H 3
1Stallergenes, Antony, France, 2Pharmerit International, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 3Stallergenes
GmbH, Kamp-Lintfort, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: A health economic assessment was conducted to determine the
relative impact of treatment with Oralair® or Grazax® on clinical effects and
health care costs in patients with grass pollen-induced allergic rhinitis (AR) in
Germany. Methods: The effects of three years of drug treatment on symptomfree days (SFDs) and associated costs were assessed using a health economic
Markov model with a nine-year time horizon. The relative efficacy on SFDs was
assessed through a network meta-analysis (i. e. indirect comparison) of 4-year,
placebo-controlled, clinical trial data. Costs associated with drug treatment and
other health care resources, including Statutory Health Insurance payments and
patient co-payments, were calculated. The incremental costs and SFDs gained for
Oralair® relative to Grazax® were generated accordingly. The uncertainty around
the model outcomes was determined by means of sensitivity analyses. Results:
The base case analysis over 9 years predicts a total of 206.6 discounted SFDs for
Oralair®relative to 205.1 for Grazax®, thus resulting in 1.5 (95%CI: -25.0; 29.3) additional SFDs gained with Oralair®. Total discounted costs are estimated at € 1,696 and
€ 2,968 for Oralair® and Grazax®, respectively, with incremental costs predicted at
-€ 1,272 (95%CI: -€ 1,530; -€ 999). Hence, Oralair® may be classified as the dominant
strategy, as additional effects are combined with considerable cost savings. The
sensitivity analyses suggest that results were mostly driven by drug-specific clinical effects on SFD, inputs for immunotherapy discontinuation, and length of the
pollen season. The predicted cost savings were driven by the difference in treatment costs. Conclusions: Oralair® is cost-effective relative to Grazax®in patients
with grass pollen-induced AR in Germany. Findings are confirmed by extensive
sensitivity analyses.
PRS53
Economic Evaluation of the Use of an Infant Formula Based on
Partially Hydrolyzed Serum Protein as Compared With a Standard
Whole Cow’s Milk Formula for Prevention of Atopic Dermatitis in
Children Under 3 Years Old
Derkach E V 1, Avxentyeva M 1, Fedyaeva V K 1, Rebrova O 2
1The Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration, Moscow,
Russia, 2Pirogov Russian National Research Medical University, Moscow, Russia
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate the potential economic impact of the 100% whey-based
partially hydrolyzed infant formula (PHF-W) in comparison with a cow’s milk standard formula (SF) in the prevention of atopic dermatitis (AD) in at-risk children at
the age periods 0–12 and 0–36 months in Russia. Methods: The Excel model was
constructed to estimate costs of artificial feeding with PHF-W vs SF and expected
AD cases treatment. The model was based on the results of meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials (RCTs), literature data and the results of the expert survey.
The costs of artificial feeding and AD treatment were calculated from the positions
of different payers: health care system, family, and society as a whole. The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) per averted AD case was calculated for PHF-W
vs SF. Results: From health care system point of view the use of PHF-W uniquely
lead to cost savings. If we consider all costs from the societal perspective PHF-W
vs SF requires additional costs in the first year of baby’s life, but in leads to cost
savings in a 3-year horizon. From the perspective of the at-risk child’s family artificial feeding costs will increase from 266 to 408 Euro for PHF-W vs SF. However the
likelihood of AD development in a child will decrease from 15 to 8% in the first year
and from 27 to 19% over three years and accordingly this will prevent AD treatment
costs. Conclusions: Using PHF-W for the AD preventionin high-risk children have
benefits for both the health system and for individual family.
PRS54
A Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Treatment for Mild to Moderate
Obstructive Sleep Apnea-Hypopnea Syndrome (OSAHS) in France
Poullié A I 1, Gauthier A 2, Cognet M 2, Clementz M 2, Späth H M 3, Perrier L 4, Scemama O 1,
Rumeau Pichon C 1, Harousseau J L 1
1Haute Autorité de santé, Saint-Denis La Plaine, France, 2Amaris, London, UK, 3ISPB - Faculté de
Pharmacie - Université Lyon 1, Lyon, France, 4Cancer Centre Léon Bérard, Lyon, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In France, continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) is recommended as first-line treatment for patients with severe OSAHS or mild-to-moderate OSAHS with high cardiovascular risk. Dental devices are recommended
as second-line treatment for these patients and can be suggested as first-line
treatment for mild-to-moderate OSAHS patients without high cardiovascular
risk. Lifestyle advice is recommended for overweight patients. This study aims to
assess the cost-effectiveness of these treatments for mild-to-moderate OSAHS
patients. Methods: This study was commissioned by the French National
Authority for Health (HAS) and followed their recommendations. A Markov model
was developed to simulate the lifetime progression of a cohort of mild-to-moderate adult OSAHS patients. CPAP was compared with dental devices, lifestyle
advice and no treatment. Daytime sleepiness, cardiovascular disease and road
traffic accidents were taken into account. Clinical parameters were taken from
international publications. Costs were retrieved from the French national health
insurance databases: Assurance Maladie and Technical Agency of Information on
Hospitals (ATIH). Costs and outcomes were discounted at 4% through 30 years and
2% thereafter. Robustness of results was assessed using sensitivity analyses. The
assessed outcomes were the incremental cost per quality-adjusted life-year (QALY)
gained and total life-years gained (LYG). Results: This study will inform public
decision making about reimbursement of mild-to-moderate OSAHS treatments.
CPAP was associated with higher costs and QALYs compared with dental devices,
lifestyle advice and no treatment. Several sensitivity analyses were undertaken
and it was found that the most sensitive parameters were related to sleepiness and
cardiovascular inputs. Further investigation (clinical trial/observational study) of
treatment effects on these parameters is needed. Conclusions: This analysis is
the first to assess the cost-effectiveness of treatments in mild-to-moderate OSAHS
patients in France. The technical report of this research will be available on the
HAS website at the time of the congress (November 2014).
PRS55
Cost-Effectiveness of Subcutaneous Immunothereapy in Allergic
Rhinitis Using One or More Allergens - An Analysis Long Overdue
Kiel M A 1, Röder E 2, Gerth van Wijk R 2, Rutten- Van Mölken M P M H 1
University, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 2Erasmus Medical Center, Rotterdam, The
Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Erasmus
Objectives: Allergic rhinitis – hay fever and mite hypersensitivity - is a prevalent
and increasingly common condition, causing considerable morbidity and economic burden to society. A minority of patients have an indication for subcutaneous immunotherapy (SCIT). SCIT using extracts of tree pollen, grass pollen and/or
house dust mite is common practice in The Netherlands, Europe and beyond. SCIT
is widely reimbursed, but very few prospective cost-effectiveness studies have been
done. Methods: An open-label, 2-year, multicenter, randomized controlled trial
with two parallel treatment arms was performed, comparing SCIT + usual care (UC)
with UC alone, using online resource use and labor productivity questionnaires, and
electronic versions of EQ-5D®, SF-36® and a global subjective assessment of symptoms (GA). Primary endpoints were the costs per QALY, costs per successfully treated
patient and the cost per additional symptom-free day. A Generalized Estimation
Equation (GEE) model was estimated with mean two-week health care/societal costs
as dependent variable, followed by a 1000-iteration bootstrap procedure. Results:
A total of 183 adult patients aged 18 to 45 years with persistent moderate to severe
allergic rhinitis due to one (43%) or more (57%) allergies (93 SCIT+UC, 90 UC) were
included. There were no significant differences at baseline. The percentage of
patients that reported to be treated successfully was 36% in SCIT and 20% in UC
after two years. Other health outcomes did not differ between SCIT and Usual Care.
Two-year costs of SCIT were 2946 Euro per patient. There was no difference in other
costs. Cost per additional successfully treated patient were about 15,000 Euro. For
the other outcomes, SCIT was dominated by UC. Conclusions: This study could
not support the cost-effectiveness of SCIT. A restriction in the indication of SCIT
to patients with severe persistent rhinitis, not sufficiently responsive to maximum
symptomatic therapy may improve cost-effectiveness.
PRS56
Impact of Allergen Immunotherapy on Quality of Life and Health
Care Costs in Adults and Children With Grass Pollen-Induced
Allergic Rhinitis in Germany
Najib M 1, Westerhout K Y 2, Verheggen B 2, Schreder C H 3
1Stallergenes, Antony, France, 2Pharmerit International, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 3Stallergenes
GmbH, Kamp-Lintfort, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To determine the relative impact of treatment with Oralair®, Grazax®,
Alutard® or symptomatic drug treatment (SDT) on clinical effects and health care
costs in subgroups of adults and children with grass pollen-induced allergic rhinitis
(AR) in Germany. The cost-effectiveness of Oralair® has been demonstrated in a
mixed population in previous research. Methods: The effects of three years of drug
treatment on quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) and associated costs were assessed
using a Markov model with a nine-year time horizon. Symptom score data were
extracted, and the relative efficacy on QALYs was assessed through a network metaanalysis (i. e. indirect comparison) of placebo-controlled, clinical trial data in adults
and children. Patient symptom scores were translated into the impact on quality of
life by means of published sources. Costs associated with drug treatment and other
health care resources, including Statutory Health Insurance payments and patient
co-payments, were estimated. The incremental costs and QALYs were generated
accordingly. The uncertainty around the model outcomes was determined by means
of sensitivity analyses. Results: In adults, the analysis predicted more QALYs for
Oralair® relative to Grazax®, 0.008 (95%CI: -0.043; 0.062) and Alutard®, 0.028 (95%CI:
-0.029; 0.093), combined with incremental costs of -€ 1,272 (95%CI: -€ 1,530; -€ 999)
and -€ 129 (95%CI: -€ 389; € 160) per patient, respectively. Hence, Oralair is dominant
relative to Grazax® and Alutard® in adults. The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio
was estimated at € 15,503 per QALY relative to SDT. Similar results were observed
in children, with the exception of Alutard® (lack of data). The sensitivity analyses
suggest that results were mostly driven by drug-specific clinical effects on symptom
score, drug costs, inputs for immunotherapy discontinuation, and length of the pollen season. Conclusions: Oralair® is cost-effective relative to Grazax®, Alutard®
and SDT in grass pollen-induced AR in Germany. Findings were confirmed again
and supported by extensive sensitivity analyses.
PRS57
Economic Evaluation of Omalizumab Compared With Standard
Therapy in the Treatment of Severe Allergic Asthma in Adult
Patients in Greece: a Cost Effectiveness Analysis Based on Clinical
Trial and Real-World Data
Sonathi V 1, Hatzikou M 2, Baldwin M 3, Panitti E 2, Tzortzaki E 4
Healthcare Pvt. Ltd., Hyderabad, India, 2Novartis Hellas, Metamorfosis, Greece,
3Novartis Employee by the time of the study, Horsham, UK, 4Medical School University of Crete,
Heraklion, Greece
.
1Novartis
.
.
.
.
A598
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: Severe asthma is a major cause of morbidity and mortality around
the world, associated with a heavy societal burden. The aim of this study was to
evaluate the economic value of omalizumab in the treatment of adult patients
with severe allergic asthma in Greece, from a societal perspective, based on data
collected from a clinical trial (INNOVATE) and real-world evidence (RWE) from a
prospective observational study conducted in Greece. Methods: A Markov cohort
model was developed in Microsoft Excel to compare the costs and outcomes of
omalizumab plus standard therapy (ST, primarily comprised ICS, LABA and SABA)
versus ST alone. The time horizon was that of a lifetime. Both direct and indirect
costs were incorporated. Health outcomes considered were Quality Adjusted Life
Years (QALYs). Costs and QALYs were discounted annually at 3.5%. Unit costs
were taken from publically available sources. Productivity losses were calculated
based on published data, while utility values were taken from the INNOVATE
study. Deterministic and probabilistic sensitivity analyses were undertaken to
test the robustness of the model results. Results: The addition of omalizumab
to ST led to an incremental cost per QALY gained of € 27,888 based on INNOVATE
trial and € 27,255 based on the RWE. The model appeared to be most sensitive to
changes in the time horizon and the age of retirement. Results of the probabilistic
sensitivity analysis showed that the probability of omalizumab being cost effective was 58% and 84%, at a willingness to pay threshold of € 30,000 and € 40,000,
respectively. Conclusions: Omalizumab appears to be a cost-effective treatment
option for adult patients with severe allergic asthma compared with ST in Greece,
confirmed by both trial and real-world data.
PRS58
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Indacaterol/Glycopirronium (QVA149)
as a Maintenance Bronchodilator Treatment in Adult Patients
With Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease in Spain
Granell M 1, Giovanna M 2, Paz S 3, Betoret I 1
Farmaceutica, Barcelona, Spain, 2Outcomes 10, Castellon, Spain, 3Outcomes’10,
Castellon, Spain
.
.
.
.
1Novartis
Objectives: To assess the cost-effectiveness (CE) of indacaterol/glycopyrronium
(QVA149; 85µg/43µg) as a maintenance bronchodilator treatment of adult patients
with Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) versus salmeterol/fluticasone (SFC; 50µg/500µg). Methods: A CE model of micro-simulation over a 3-, 5-,
10-year and lifetime horizon was developed from the perspective of the Spanish
National Healthcare System. Patients progress through subsequent COPD stages
based on their baseline characteristics and considering the natural decline of
Forced Expiratory Volume in 1 second (FEV1) and exacerbation rate. In the model
this is counteracted by treatment-associated FEV1 improvement from baseline and
exacerbation rate reduction associated to each treatment vs. placebo, which were
obtained by direct and indirect comparison of primary data from TORCH (SFC vs.
placebo), SHINE (QVA149 vs. placebo) and ILLUMINATE (QVA149 vs SFC) clinical
trials. The considered outcomes were life years (LY) gained and quality-adjusted
life years (QALYs). Cost estimates (Euros 2014) include drugs, disease management
and mild/severe exacerbation expenditures from Spanish health care cost databases and publications with a discount rate of 3% for costs and effects. Results:
QVA149 has shown to be less costly and more effective than the fixed combination
of SFC with respect to both LY and QALYs gained. The cost per patient treated with
QVA149 over a 3-, 5-, 10-year and lifetime period was estimated to be € 108, € 182,
€ 305, and € 467 lower than with SFC, which resulted from avoiding exacerbation
costs and decreasing maintenance cost in relation to slowing COPD progression.
Therefore, QVA149 was estimated to be dominant over SFC with respect to both
cost-effectiveness and cost-utility. Conclusions: Due to its higher effectiveness
in improving FEV1 and reducing COPD exacerbations, QVA149 has shown to be
more cost-effective than SFC.
PRS59
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Allergen Immunotherapy in Patients
With Grass Pollen-Induced Allergic Rhinitis in Spain
Valero A 1, Westerhout K Y 2, van de Wetering G 2, Pérez-Alcántara F 3, Azpeitia A 4, Najib M 5
Clinic Universitari de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain, 2Pharmerit International, Rotterdam,
The Netherlands, 3Oblikue Consulting, Barcelona, Spain, 4Stallergenes Ibérica S.A, Barcelona,
Spain, 5Stallergenes, Antony, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Hospital
Objectives: To determine the relative impact of treatment with Oralair®, Grazax®,
Pangramin®, Pollinex Quattro®, and symptomatic drug treatment (SDT) on clinical
effects and health care costs in patients with grass pollen-induced allergic rhinitis
(AR) in Spain. Methods: The effects of three years of drug treatment on qualityadjusted life years (QALYs) and costs were assessed using a Markov model with
a nine-year time horizon. Symptom score data were extracted, and the relative
efficacy on QALYs was assessed through a network meta-analysis (i. e. indirect
comparison) of 3-year, placebo-controlled, clinical trial data. Patient symptom scores
were translated into the impact on quality of life by means of published sources.
Costs associated with drug treatment and other health care resources were calculated. The incremental costs and QALYs gained were generated accordingly. The
uncertainty around the model outcomes was determined by means of sensitivity analyses. Results: The base case analysis over 9 years estimated incremental
QALYs of 0.005 (95%CI: -0.024; 0.038), 0.016 (95%CI: -0.034; 0.063), 0.059 (95%CI: 0.024;
0.107), and 0.143 (95%CI: 0.102; 0.195) when Oralair® was compared to Grazax®,
Pangramin®, Pollinex Quattro® and SDT, respectively. Corresponding incremental
costs were -€1,063 (95%CI: -€1,306; -€779), €109 (95%CI: €206; €428), €572 (95%CI: €321;
€ 864), and € 1,360 (95%CI: € 1,110; € 1,649). Hence, Oralair® was predicted as dominant relative to Grazax®, while ICERs of € 6,931/QALY, € 9,703/QALY, and € 9,517/QALY
were estimated relative to Pangramin®, Pollinex Quattro®, and SDT, respectively.
Apart from drug costs, the sensitivity analyses suggest that results were mostly
driven by drug-specific symptom score values, duration of the pollen season, and
inputs for immunotherapy discontinuation. At a willingness-to-pay threshold of
€ 20,000, the probability of Oralair® being the most cost-effective treatment option
is 65%. Conclusions: Oralair® is cost-effective relative to Grazax®, Pangramin®,
Pollinex Quattro® and SDT in grass pollen-induced AR in Spain. Findings are confirmed by extensive sensitivity analyses.
PRS60
Cost-Effectiveness of Endobronchial Valve Therapy for Severe
Emphysema: A Model-Based Projection Based on the Vent Study
Pietzsch J B 1, Garner A M 1, Herth F J 2
Inc., Menlo Park, CA, USA, 2University of Heidelberg, Heidelberg, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Wing Tech
Objectives: Endobronchial valve therapy (EBV) is an innovative treatment that
has been shown to be safe and effective in selected subgroups of patients with
severe emphysema. The objective of our study was to assess the cost-effectiveness
of valve treatment in the German health care system when compared to medical
management. Methods: Clinical data from a subset of the Endobronchial Valve
for Emphysema Palliation Trial (VENT) provided information about clinical events,
health-related quality of life, and disease staging through 12 months. This information was subsequently used as input to a previously published Markov model to
project longer-term disease progression, mortality, and health resource utilization.
From this combined analysis, we computed the 5-year and 10-year incremental
cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) in euros per quality-adjusted life year (QALY). Costs
and effects were discounted at 3% per year. Results: EBV therapy led to clinically meaningful disease restaging at 12 months (37.8% of cohort improved staging,
compared to 0% in control). Over 5 years, EBV was projected to increase survival
from 66.4% to 70.7%, and to add 0.22 QALYs. Costs were estimated to increase by €
10,299, resulting in an ICER of € 46,322/QALY. Over 10 years, 0.41 QALYs were gained
at additional cost of € 10,425, yielding an ICER of € 25,142/QALY. Conclusions: Our
model-based analysis suggests that EBV leads to clinically meaningful changes in
disease staging and progression when compared to medical management, with
resulting gains in unadjusted and quality-adjusted life expectancy. Relative to the
acknowledged willingness-to-pay threshold of € 50,000/QALY, our results indicate
EBV is a cost-effective therapy in the German health care system.
PRS61
Can Improved Treatment of Allergic Rhinitis Improve Workplace
Productivity? The Role of Intranasal Formulation of Azelastine
Hydrochloride and Fluticasone Propionate (Dymista)
Harrow B 1, Hofmeister J 1, Gever L N 1, Karafilidis J 1, Lacey M J 2, Scheibling C M 2,
Schneider J E 2
1Meda Pharmaceuticals, Inc., Somerset, NJ, USA, 2Avalon Health Economics, Morristown, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Allergic rhinitis (AR) affects 10-20% of the US population, with treatment costs exceeding $6 billion annually and has been shown to have a substantial
impact on productivity. In the U. S. AR is estimated to result in 3.5 million lost work
days and 2 million lost school days annually. AZ/FP is an intranasal formulation
of azelastine hydrochloride and fluticasone propionate in an advanced delivery
system indicated for the relief of symptoms of seasonal AR (SAR). Patients treated
with AZ/FP experience significantly greater and faster symptom relief in comparison to first-line therapy in trials, and thus have the potential to positively impact
workplace productivity. We use an economic model to calculate the economic effects
on workplace productivity associated with moving AZ/FP from third-tier to secondtier pricing and reimbursement. Methods: Population is SAR sufferers seeking
treatment. AZ/FP is assumed to gain market share annually with second-tier pricing. Time horizon is one year and five years. Four step approach: (1) estimate total
number of AR-related symptomatic days; (2) calculate total number of AR-related
episodes per year multiplied by number of days per episode; (3) estimate number of
these days that occur during a standard 5-day work week; & (4) Estimate proportion
of AR symptomatic days resulting in absenteeism or presenteeism. Results: For
a typical health plan, the estimate of expected number of absenteeism and presenteeism days per AZ/FP patient associated with moving AZ/FP from Tier 3 to Tier
2 resulted in a reduction of 4,729 AR-symptomatic days annually. Total workplace
cost savings ranged from $168,838 (Year 1) to $190,937 (Year 5), with the proportional
effects on absenteeism and presenteeism being roughly equal. Conclusions: AZ/
FP offers an appropriate means of adhering to AR practice guidelines and improving outcomes. This workplace productivity model shows that the added benefits to
employers could be substantial.
PRS62
The Potential Societal Cost Benefits of Improved Inhalation
Technique With Duoresp® Spiromax® (Budesonide + Formoterol
Fumarate Dihydrate) Compared With Symbicort® Turbuhaler® for
the Management of Asthma and Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary
Disease in Sweden
Lewis A 1, Blackney M 1, Torvinen S 2, Lindqvist F 3, Safioti G 3, Grundström J 4, Polyzoi M 4,
Plich A 2
1Covance Inc., London, UK, 2Teva Pharmaceuticals Europe B.V, Amsterdam, The Netherlands,
3Teva Pharmaceuticals AB, Helsingborg, Sweden, 4Parexel International, Stockholm, Sweden
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: DuoResp® Spiromax® (budesonide + formoterol fumarate dihydrate)
is a fixed-dose combination (FDC) of inhaled corticosteroid (ICS) + long-acting beta
agonist (LABA) in a novel dry powder inhaler (DPI). An economic model was developed to assess the potential societal cost benefits of improved inhalation technique
with DuoResp® Spiromax® compared with Symbicort® Turbuhaler®– a DPI delivering
the same FDC – in the management of adult patients with persistent asthma and
chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) in Sweden. Methods: The eligible
adult patient population was based on statistics from the National Board of Health
and Welfare in Sweden. Societal costs (lost productivity) were based on the annual
number of work-days lost for asthma and COPD patients in Sweden and the United
Kingdom (UK), respectively, and the average daily cost of sick leave in Sweden.
Frequency of poor inhalation technique with Symbicort® Turbuhaler® and the subsequent increased risk of unscheduled health care events were taken from a large
(n=1,664) cross-sectional, Italian observational study. The estimated reduction in the
proportion of patients with poor inhalation technique with DuoResp® Spiromax®
A599
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
compared with Symbicort® Turbuhaler®was based on a conservative assumption. Results: An estimated 167,666 adult patients used Symbicort® Turbuhaler®
annually in Sweden and were therefore eligible for treatment with DuoResp®
Spiromax®, with 72,935 of these exhibiting poor inhalation technique. Based on
the predicted improvement in inhalation technique with DuoResp® Spiromax®
compared with Symbicort® Turbuhaler® – and assuming a hypothetical uptake of
DuoResp® Spiromax®reaching 25% in years 4 and 5 – estimated societal cost savings,
through the avoidance of 147,158 lost productive days, totalled SEK285.4 million
(€ 31.2 million). Conclusions: DuoResp® Spiromax® has the potential to improve
inhalation technique compared with Symbicort® Turbuhaler®, which would likely
result in substantial societal cost savings.
PRS63
Impact of Omalizumab On All-Cause and Asthma-Related Health
Care Resource Utilisation in Patients With Moderate or Severe
Persistent Asthma
Turner S J 1, Nazareth T 2, Raimundo K 3, Zhou H 4, Ortiz B 2, Yu T C 2, Li L 5
1Novartis Pharmaceuticals, East Hanover, NJ, USA, 2Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation, East
Hanover, NJ, USA, 3Genentech Inc., South San Francisco, CA, USA, 4KMK Consulting Inc., Florham
Park, NJ, USA, 5Career International Inc., Shanghai, China
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Increased health care resource utilisation (HCRU) is associated with
inadequately controlled asthma. Here, we evaluate the impact of omalizumab
on HCRU in patients with moderate or severe persistent asthma. Methods: A
retrospective case-crossover study was conducted using the Truven MarketScan
database. Data between 1-January-2007 to 30-September-2012 was collected for
analysis. Patients included in the analysis had to have a diagnosis of moderate or
severe persistent asthma, be ≥ 12 years of age during the analysis period, have had
2 years of continuous enrolment (1 year pre/post omalizumab index date), and have
had exposure to omalizumab continuously for ≥ 12 months. All-cause and asthmarelated HCRU during the years, pre and post omalizumab initiation, were compared
using McNemar tests and 2-sided paired Student’s t test. Data were stratified by
asthma severity based on NHLBI criteria. Results: A total of 429 patients (mean
age, 46.6 years; female, 59.0%; Moderate= 340 [79.3%], Severe= 89 [20.7%]) from the
database were included in the analysis. The use of omalizumab was associated with
49.3% (p= 0.0003), 54.0% (p= 0.001), and 35.3% (p= 0.1466) reductions in the mean
number of asthma-related ER visits and 69.2% (p= 0.0005), 65.5% (p= 0.0045), and
80.0% (p= 0.0449) reduction in the mean number of asthma-related hospitalisations
among All, Moderate, and Severe asthma patients, respectively. The mean length of
stay for asthma-related hospitalisations was also reduced to 71.2% (p=0.0002), 64.5%
(p= 0.0016), and 90.6% (p= 0.0442) in All, Moderate, and Severe patients respectively.
All-cause ER visits were reduced by 30.8% (p= 0.0014), 32.5% (p= 0.0045), and 25.0%
(p= 0.1348), and hospitalisation reduced by 48.9%, 45.2%, and 64.7% (all p≤0.0155) in
All, Moderate, and Severe asthma patients respectively. Cohort analysis of severe
asthmatics was limited by sample size. Conclusions: In patients with moderate
persistent asthma, omalizumab use was associated with significant reductions in
all-cause and asthma-related HCRU.
PRS64
Device Handling Errors and the Impact on Quality of Life and
Health Care Resource Use in Asthmatic Patients
Jha A 1, Heron L 2, Marshall J 1, Dunlop W 1
1Mundipharma International Ltd., Cambridge, UK, 2Adelphi Values, Bollington, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Correct device technique has a significant influence on the delivery
of inhaled therapies and can thus impact the control and management of asthma.
The objective of this literature review was to examine the impact of device handling
errors on QOL and health care resources to understand the potential value of a
novel inhaler device for health care systems and patients. Methods: A literature
search of articles published 2009–2013 was undertaken using MeSH terms and key
words in MEDLINE®, supplemented by a grey literature review and searching of
reference lists. Article selection and relevant data extraction were based on key
words relating to handling error, QOL, and health care resource use. Results: Of
575 potentially relevant publications, 22 were selected for in-depth review. Papers
reported 25–73% of patients make critical handling errors that lead to no-dose or
reduced-dose delivery on first use of devices. Incorrect inhaler use was four times
more frequently reported in patients with uncontrolled asthma than in patients
with controlled asthma. Poor asthma control also impacts resource use: poorlycontrolled patients made twice as many ER visits, and spent 2–3 times more time
consulting with physicians than controlled patients (either physician visits or
time speaking to physicians). Asthma control also impacts QOL: poorly-controlled
patients reported health-state utility (EQ-5D) values of 0.52–0.69, compared to 0.88–
0.93 for well-controlled patients. Conclusions: Handling errors with devices can
lead to poorly-controlled patients, resulting in reduced QOL and increased health
care resource use. New inhaler devices represent an opportunity to reduce errors
and improve asthma control, therefore improving QOL and reducing resource use.
Further research is required to model the relationship between a reduction in handling error and improved asthma control status, and the subsequent impact on
resource use and QOL.
PRS65
Medium Term Avoided Costs: High-Dose Hypoallergenic House
Dust Mite Preparation Immunotherapy VERSUS Conventional
Symptomatic Treatment
Hidalgo A 1, Rodríguez-Marco A 2, Arias-Muñoz M 2
1University of Castilla La Mancha, Toledo, Spain, 2MERCK S.L, Madrid, Spain
.
.
.
Objectives: Quantifying cost difference between conventional symptomatic treatment of mite allergy and subcutaneous specific immunotherapy (SCIT) with high
doses of hypoallergenic dust-mite preparation. Methods: Observational, retrospective and multicenter study carried out in Spain in 2013.419 patients diagnosed
with rhinitis and / or bronchial asthma for mite allergy were retrieved. Mean age
24.9 years (SD 14.4). Comparing the use of symptomatic medication (rescue and
daily), diagnostic-tests, unscheduled medical care (allergist and emergency visits) and sick-leave days number associated with SCIT treatment versus no SCIT
treatment. SCIT treatment vs no SCIT treatment costs ratio was performed: Used
resources (Symptomatic medication, unscheduled medical care, diagnostic-tests,
and 3 years SCIT treatment and sick-leave days) were quantified in € . Efficacy
(decreased resource usage) of first year treatment was assumed during the remaining two years and during a three years follow-up period. Results: After a single
year of SCIT all quantified resources (emergency and allergist visits, diagnostic tests,
rescue medication and work absence days) diminished significantly (p< 0.05) from
baseline. Reductions in resources’ cost: Hospital resources (100% in Hospitalizations;
82% in additional visits to the allergist; 79% in ER visits). In medication: (56% in
rescue medication; 63% in daily medication). In diagnostic tests: (75% in spirometry
testing broncho-dilation; 72% in O2 saturation measuring; 90% in FeNO measuring
and 81% in chest radiographs. In leave sick days 94%. Ratio of comparative calculation described as SCIT treatment versus non SCIT treatment (or conventional
symptomatic treatment) is 0.8. Conclusions: Considering 3 years of SCIT, and 3
follow up years of sustained efficacy after completing treatment, cost per patient
SCIT treated is estimated at 20% below to the cost non SCIT treated patient. Direct
costs are reduced by 64% and indirect costs by 94%. SCIT of hypoallergenic preparation of dust-mite allows cost savings vs conventional treatment.
RESPIRATORY-RELATED DISORDERS – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient
Preference Studies
PRS66
Establishing the Relationship of Inhaler Satisfaction, Adherence,
Smoking History and Allergic Rhinitis With Patient Outcomes: Real
World Observations in US Adult Asthma Patients
Harrow B 1, Price D 2, Pike J 3, Higgins V 3, Small M 3, Piercy J 3
Pharmaceuticals, Inc., Somerset, NJ, USA, 2University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen, UK, 3Adelphi
Real World, Macclesfield, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Meda
Objectives: Improving asthma control has more recently focused on potentially
modifiable clinical and behavioural characteristics including correct inhaler technique, treatment of concomitant allergic rhinitis (AR), adherence and smoking.
This research aimed to establish the relationship of these factors with measures
of asthma control and overall health status to add to the growing body of evidence helping to optimize asthma management interventions. Methods: Data
were drawn from the USA 2013 Respiratory Disease Specific Programme, a crosssectional survey of adult asthma patients consulting for routine care. Partial Least
Squares Path Modelling was used to quantify the inner model relationships between
latent variables of patient-reported satisfaction of drug delivery, device functionality,
device feedback (based on groupings of 12 inhaler device attributes), concomitant
AR, adherence (Morisky Medication Adherence Scale), smoking history (smoking status, years smoked, number smoked per day), patient reported outcomes
(Asthma Control Test, Jenkins Sleep Questionnaire, EuroQol-5D-3L) and physicianreported number of asthma exacerbations in the last 12 months. Patients not receiving inhaled maintenance therapy were excluded. Results: 243 patients met the
inclusion criteria. All manifest variable loadings were positive, and a minimum
Cronbach’s Alpha of 0.713 for the latent variables indicated unidimensionality of
the manifest variables for each of the latent variables. Cross-loadings were also
supportive of the hypothesised outer model. Better patient outcomes were significantly associated with patient satisfaction with drug delivery (p= 0.002), adherence (p= 0.049), negative smoking history (p< 0.001) and absence of concomitant
AR (p= 0.005). The R2 value for outcomes was 13.3%, and the pseudo goodness of
fit, which measures the overall prediction performance of the path model, was
19.5%. Conclusions: Improving patient satisfaction with inhaler drug delivery
represents one potentially modifiable aspect of asthma management alongside
appropriate treatment of AR, smoking cessation and improving adherence, which
are likely to have a positive impact on asthma patient outcomes.
PRS67
Tecepoc II Study. How to Improve the Inhalation Techniques in
Patient with Copd. The Influence of Preferences
Barnestein-Fonseca P 1, Vazquez-Alarcon R 1, Leiva-Fernandez F 1, Aguiar-Leiva V 1,
Lobnig-Becerra M 1, Leiva-Fernandez J 2
1Distrito Sanitario Málaga (SAS), Málaga, Spain, 2Area Sanitaria Málaga Este-Axarquia,
Málaga, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: to test the efficacy of two educational interventions to improve the
inhalation techniques in patients with Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease and
the influence of patient´ preference. Methods: Design: Multicenter patients´ preference trial or comprehensive cohort design ISRCTN15106246. Patients: 465 COPD
patients (to detect a difference between groups of 25%, 80% statistical power, 95%
confidence level, 40% expected losses), with inhaled treatment, written consent.
Non-probabilistic consecutive sampling. Allocation: Patients without strong preferences for a treatment were randomised: RCT group (block randomization), and
those with strong preferences were given their choice: PPS group. Variables: Primary
outcomes: Performance of correct inhalation technique. Secondary outcomes: Pick flow,
Baseline dyspnea index (BDI), Functional status (forced spirometry). Interventions:
Intervention-A: Written information. A leaflet with the correct inhalation technique
for the main inhaler devices used in our area. Intervention-B: Intervention-A + individual training (by instructors). Follow-up: 12 month, visits: baseline, 1 month, 3rd
month, 6th month, 12th month. Statiscal analysis: Mean, frequency, 95% confidence
interval at baseline. Number Needed to Treat for a benefit (NNT) was calculated.
Intention to treat analysis. Results: Predominance of males (91.4%), mean age
69.8 years (CI95%, 69.00-70.59); FEV1 (mean)= 55.91% (IC95%, 53.62-58.2), mixed respiratory pattern (65.9%). Severity stage: 15.7% mild, 44.1% Moderate, 40.3% Severe.
Pharmacological treatment: inhaled-beta2-adrenergic (88.8%); inhaled-corticoster-
A600
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
oids (76.7%); inhaled-anticholinergic (70.7%); mucolitycs (19.4%); xanthine (7.3%);
oral-corticosteroids (1.3%). BDI: grade 2. Primary outcome: RCT cohorts: there was
no difference between control and intervention A and there were statistically
significative differences between intervention B versus control (p<0.0001), NNT=3.22
(IC95%, 2.27-5.88) and versus intervention A, NNT= 4.16 (IC95%, 2.63-10). In the PPS
cohorts: there was a difference (p< 0.0001) between intervention B versus intervention A, NNT= 3.22 (IC95%, 2.32-5.55). The preferences enhanced a 6.7% the correct
inhalation technique. Conclusions: The performance of a correct inhalation
Technique improves with monitor training. The patients´ preferences enhance the
efficacy of intervention.
PRS68
Inhalation Technique Evolution After Training in Copd. The Role of
the Device
Barnestein-Fonseca P 1, Vazquez-Alarcon R 1, Leiva-Fernandez F 1, Aguiar-Leiva V 1,
Lobnig-Becerra M 1, Leiva-Fernandez J 2
1Distrito Sanitario Málaga (SAS), Málaga, Spain, 2Area Sanitaria Málaga Este-Axarquia,
Málaga, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: to test the efficacy of two educational interventions to improve the
inhalation techniques per device in patients with COPD and the influence of patient´
preference. Methods: Design: Multicenter patients´ preference trial or comprehensive cohort design ISRCTN15106246. Patients: 465 COPD patients (to detect a
difference between groups of 25%, 80% statistical power, 95% confidence level, 40%
expected losses), with inhaled treatment, written consent. Non-probabilistic consecutive sampling. Allocation: Patients without strong preferences for a treatment
are randomised: RCT group (block randomization), and those with strong preferences are given their choice: PPS group. Variables: Primary outcomes: Performance of
correct inhalation technique. Independent variables: sex, age, Baseline dyspnea index
(BDI), Functional status (forced spirometry). Interventions: Interv-A: Written information. A leaflet with correct inhalation technique. Interv-B: Interv-A + individual
training (by instructors). Follow-up: 3 month, visits: baseline (V0), 1 month (V1),
3 month (V2). Statiscal analysis: Mean, frequency, 95% confidence interval. Intention
to treat analysis. Results: Males (91.4%), mean age 69.8 years (CI95%, 69.00-70.59);
FEV1 (mean)= 55.91% (IC95%, 53.62-58.2), mixed respiratory pattern (65.9%). Severity
stage: 15.7% mild, 44.1% Moderate, 40.3% Severe. BDI: grade 2. Devices use: 67.3%
Handihaler (Hd), 54.8% Turbuhaler (Th), 31.8% Accuhaler (Acc), 26.9% pMDI. Correct
Inhalation technique: Hd: RCT-control: 11.7% V0,10% (V2); RCT-intervA: 10.9%, 17.5%;
RCT-IntervB: 7.4%, 62.3% p< 0.0001. Th: RCT-control: 22% V0, 16.7% (V2); RCT-intervA:
8.7%, 24.4%; RCT-IntervB: 7.5 %, 57.5% p< 0.0001. Acc: RCT-control: 16.1% V0, 25% (V2);
RCT-intervA: 17.9%, 23.1%; RCT-IntervB: 11.5%, 74.1% p< 0.0001. pMDI: RCT-control:
6.9% V0, 3.6% (V2); RCT-intervA: 12.5%, 19%; RCT-IntervB: 8.3%, 34.6% p= 0.025.
There were statistically differences for all devices only in the intervention B arms
(p< 0.0001). The preferences enhanced 1% for Handihaler, 12.7% for Accuhaler, 4.6%
for Turbuhaler, 15.4% for pMDI the correct inhalation technique. Conclusions:
The performance of a correct inhalation technique improves with monitor training
for all devices. The patients´ preferences enhance the efficacy.
PRS69
Identification of Dry Powder Inhaler Attributes, and their Relative
Importance to Asthma and Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease
Patients, to Inform a Discrete Choice Experiment
Hawken N A 1, Aballéa S 2, Torvinen S 3, Plich A 3
.
.
.
.
.
1Creativ-Ceutical, Luxembourg, Luxembourg, 2Creativ-Ceutical, Paris, France, 3Teva
Pharmaceuticals Europe B.V, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
Objectives: To identify characteristics of dry powder inhalers (DPIs) considered
important by asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) patients,
in order to select attributes and attribute-levels for a discrete choice experiment. Methods: Qualitative data was collected from a literature review performed
to determine which inhaler attributes impact inhaler satisfaction and adherence
among asthma and COPD patients using DPIs. Focus groups with asthma and COPD
patients were conducted in France, with patients asked to cite and rate important
features of their inhaler. Qualitative analysis of the transcripts was performed
following International Society For Pharmacoeconomics and Outcomes Research
(ISPOR) guidelines. Results: Results of the literature review revealed no overall
consensus on the importance of different inhaler attributes in relation to inhaler
satisfaction and adherence across studies. The most frequently reported attributes
were: overall ease-of-use, low inspiratory flow requirements, presence of a dosing
feedback mechanism, ergonomics of the inhaler mouthpiece, ease with which the
device can be kept hygienic and the ease with which the medicinal dose can be prepared. Four discussion groups were held, with thirty patients participating. Overall,
the degree to which the inhaler can optimise treatment convenience appeared
to be the most important attribute to patients. In agreement with results of the
literature review, patients also rated the following inhaler attributes as being important: size of the dose counter, ability to keep the mouthpiece hygienic, ergonomics
of the inhaler mouthpiece, presence of a dosing feedback mechanism, ease with
which a dose can be prepared, low inspiratory flow requirements. Conclusions:
Results of this study provide an insight inhaler attributes most valued by asthma
and COPD patients. Patients described their ideal inhaler to be small, with an ergonomic mouthpiece and an easy to use dose preparation mechanism, and providing
enough medicine for at least a month of treatment.
PRS70
Symptom Burden and Health Related Quality of Life in Patients
With Idiopathic Pulmonary Fibrosis in Clinical Practice: Insights-Ipf
Registry
Pittrow D 1, Klotsche J 2, Kreuter M 3, Hoeper M M 4, Wirtz H 5, Koschel D 6, Claussen M 7,
Andreas S 8, Grohé C 9, Geier S 10, Koppe U 10, Behr J 11
1Technical University Carl Gustav Carus, Dresden, Germany, 2Deutsches RheumaForschungsinstitut, Berlin, Germany, 3Thoraxklinik am Universitätsklinikum Heidelberg,
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Member of the DZL, Heidelberg, Germany, 4Hanover Medical School, Member of DZL, Hanover,
Germany, 5Universitätsklinikum Leipzig AöR, Leipzig, Germany, 6Fachkrankenhaus Coswig,
Coswig, Germany, 7LungenClinic Grosshansdorf, akademisches Lehrkrankenhaus Universität
Schleswig-Holstein; Mitglied des Deutschen Zentrums für Lungenforschung, Grosshansdorf,
Germany, 8Lungenfachklinik Immenhausen, pneumologische Lehrklinik Universität Göttingen,
Immenhausen, Germany, 9Evangelische Lungenklink, Berlin-Buch, Germany, 10Boehringer
Ingelheim, Ingelheim, Germany, 11Ludwig Maximilian University, and Asklepios Clinics Gauting,
Member of the DZL, Munich, Germany
Objectives: We aimed to assess the symptom burden and health related quality of
life in patients with idiopathic lung fibrosis. Methods: Patients have been consecutively enrolled in an ongoing prospective non-interventional registry in Germany,
investigating clinical characteristics, clinical management practices and quality of
life. IPF diagnoses were in agreement with the international IPF guideline published
in 2011. Clinical parameters and treatment practice were recorded by the physician. Patients filled out the EQ-5D-5L, St George’s Respiratory Questionnaire (SGRQ),
WHO-5 and the UCSD shortness of breath (SOB) scale. The time trade off (TTO) score
was calculated for the EQ-5D. Results: To date (04 June 2014), 421 patients with IPF
have been enrolled in the registry (mean age 68.6±9.5; 77% male). The mean six-minute walk distance was 271±200, mean % of predicted forced vital capacity was 72±20
and the mean % predicted DLCO was 35±16. Patients were treated with oral steroids
(22.1%, as monotherapy in 7.1%); N-acetylcysteine (34.8%), pirfenidone (47.2%), and
long-term O2 therapy (34.4%). The physician rated the disease in 35.6% as stable,
in 31.1% as slowly progressing and in 11.9% as rapidly progressing. One in four
patients described their current state of health as at least good, and every fifth as
poor. The mean EQ-5D TTO score was 0.8±0.2. 45% of the patients showed depressive
symptoms based on the WHO-5. The mean SGRQ sum score was 47.7±20.1 describing
difficulties with breathing in the previous 3 months. Higher EQ-5D TTO scores were
significantly associated with a lower number of comorbid diseases (r= -0.31), higher
6-minute walk distance (r=0.20), higher FVC % pred (r=0.27), less depression (r=0.66)
and lower SGRQ scores (r= -0.72). Conclusions: The IPF patients in this large registry had a more severe disease, a higher symptom burden and more compromised
quality of life compared to recent randomised controlled trials.
PRS71
Translation and Linguistic Validation of Two COPD Symptom
Diaries (Nicsi And Emsci) for Use in 14 Countries
Eremenco S 1, Albuquerque P 2, Arnold B J 3, Trundell D 4, Hareendran A 5
1Evidera, Inc., Bethesda, MD, USA, 2Almirall, S.A., Barcelona, Spain, 3FACITtrans, Elmhurst, IL,
USA, 4Evidera, Inc., London, UK, 5Evidera, London, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The Nighttime Symptoms of COPD Instrument (NiSCI) and Early
Morning Symptoms of COPD Instrument (EMSCI) were developed to support treatment benefit endpoints in global clinical trials. Translations that were conceptually
equivalent to the English source version and easily understood by the target country
populations were required. The purpose of this study was to translate and assess
conceptual equivalence of the NiSCI and EMSCI for use in 14 countries: Austria,
Bulgaria, Canada, Czech Republic, France, Germany, Hungary, Italy, Lithuania, The
Netherlands, Poland, South Africa, Spain, and United Kingdom. Methods: The
NiSCI and EMSCI were translated following ISPOR guidelines for linguistic validation of PRO measures (Wild et al., 2005) using the universal approach discussed in
the second Task Force Report (Wild et al., 2009). The universal English, Spanish and
French versions were previously translated (Eremenco et al., 2012). For the remaining languages, two forward translations by native translators, reconciliation of the
forwards, one back-translation by an English-speaker fluent in the target language,
and final reconciliation by a native speaking language coordinator were conducted
for both measures. Harmonization was performed to ensure conceptual equivalence across languages. Interviews were conducted with five native-speaking COPD
patients for each language/country combination. Interview data were analyzed to
assess linguistic and cultural validity in each language and confirm conceptual
equivalence. Results: Mean age of the sample (N= 80) was 60 years (range 41-83)
and 54% were male. The translations were well understood and considered relevant,
with patients raising only minor issues during interviews. Changes were made to the
universal French (chest congestion), Hungarian (wheezing, chest congestion), Italian
(chest congestion, moderately), and Lithuanian (instructions, wheezing, shortness
of breath, experienced) following the patient interviews. Conclusions: All translated versions of the NiSCI and EMSCI in this study were found to be conceptually
equivalent and acceptable for use in the 14 countries evaluated.
PRS72
Testing E-PRO Device Usability During the Translation Process:
A Case Study of the Exact in 7 Countries
Eremenco S , Murray L
Evidera, Inc., Bethesda, MD, USA
.
.
Objectives: Usability testing of electronic Patient-Reported Outcomes (ePRO)
instruments is typically conducted during instrument development, in the language/country of origin. It has been suggested that usability testing also be performed during the translation process. It is unclear whether this additional step
is necessary. In this study, usability testing was conducted as part of the linguistic validation process in Simplified Chinese (China), German (Germany), French
(France), Russian (Russia), and Spanish (Universal, tested in Chile, Spain, and US)
for the Exacerbations of Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease Tool (EXACT), an
e-PRO developed and tested in English (US). Methods: The translation process
followed ISPOR guidelines (Wild et al., 2005). Cognitive interviews were conducted
with 2-3 native-speaking COPD respondents per language/country combination
in 2008. Subjects completed the EXACT in paper-pen screenshot format and were
interviewed for translation validation. Subsequently they were instructed to use a
PDA (Tungsten E2; CRF, Inc.) to complete the first 5 EXACT items and were interviewed regarding device usability. Interviewers rated subjects’ ability to use the
device. Results: Subjects (N=20) were 45-84 years, 60% male, and 60% with secondary education or less. Most (n=18) had not used a PDA previously; all (n=20) reported
A601
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
it was easy to use, the screens were easy to read, and that they could sign on and
move through the questions with no difficulty. Subjects from the Spanish-speaking
countries had the lowest reported difficulty turning the device on, with higher
levels of difficulty observed by the interviewers in China, who reported “somewhat”
for two of the three respondents. Interviewers observed that the majority (n= 15)
could “easily” or “very easily” use the device. Conclusions: Given the consistent
ease-of-use findings in these diverse, device naïve subjects across 7 countries and
the emphasis on subject training in clinical trials, it was determined that usability
testing with future translations was unnecessary.
PRS73
A Comparison of The Reliability and Validity of the Four-Item and
Six-Item NISCI Symptom Summary Scores
Mocarski M 1, Trundell D 2, Zaiser E 2, Garcia Gil E 3, Lamarca R 3, Hareendran A 2
1Forest Research Institute, Jersey City, NJ, USA, 2Evidera, Inc., London, UK, 3Almirall S.A.,
Barcelona, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The Nighttime Symptoms of COPD Instrument (NiSCI), developed
through qualitative research with patients, includes six symptom items: coughing, wheezing, shortness of breath, difficulty bringing up phlegm, chest congestion, and tightness in the chest. A symptom severity score is computed based on
these items. In situations where patient burden is a major consideration, a smaller
set of items may be preferable. Clinicians identified coughing, wheezing, shortness of breath, and difficulty bringing up phlegm as the most relevant for COPD
patients. Exploratory psychometric analyses were conducted for the symptom summary score based on these four items compared with all six items. Methods:
Psychometric properties of the four-item versus six-item symptom summary scores
were examined using phase 3 clinical trial data from a random split-half sample.
Symptom summary scores were tested for: internal consistency using Cronbach’s
Alpha; test-retest reliability using Intraclass Correlation Coefficients (ICC) and
Concordance Correlation Coefficients (CCC); convergent validity using Spearman
Rank Order Correlation Coefficients; and known-groups validity using ANOVA and
Scheffe’s test for pair-wise comparisons. Results: Patients (n=832) were aged 40–93
years (mean 63.78 ±-9.07 [SD]) and 51% were male. Both scores were internally
consistent and valid. Cronbach’s alpha was slightly higher for the six-item symptom summary (0.85) versus the four-item symptom summary (0.78). ICC and CCC
scores were 0.85 for the six-item and 0.84 for the four-item symptom summary
scores. Likewise, construct validity and known-groups validity were similar for both
scores (p> 0.05). Conclusions: The NiSCI symptom summary score based on four
items has similar psychometric properties to the six-item symptom summary score.
Both scores have measurement properties suitable for use in clinical trials. Further
work will test the psychometric properties of the instrument administered with
four items.
PRS74
Health-Related Quality of Life (HRQOL) in Patients With Idiopathic
Pulmonary Fibrosis
Yount S 1, Beaumont J 1, Kaiser K 1, Wortman K 1, Chen S Y 2, Van Brunt D 2, Cella D 1
1Northwestern University, Chicago, IL, USA, 2Biogen Idec, Cambridge, MA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (IPF) is a progressive disease characterized by declining lung function, leading to debilitating limitations on activity
which may negatively impact HRQOL. However, HRQOL data in this population
are limited. The primary objective was to evaluate HRQOL in IPF using measures
from the Patient Reported Outcomes Measurement Information System (PROMIS).
The secondary objective was to examine the association between key symptoms
and HRQOL. Methods: Individuals with IPF were recruited via patient advocacy
organizations to complete an online survey consisting of PROMIS-29 health profile, PROMIS-Dyspnea, dyspnea measured by Modified Medical Research Council
Dyspnea Scale (MMRC), self-reported cough, and cough subscale of the ATAQ
(A Tool to Assess Quality of life)-IPF. PROMIS-29 scores have mean= 50, SD= 10 in the
US general population; PROMIS-Dyspnea scores are referenced to a chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) sample. Results: The 275 survey participants
showed worse mean PROMIS-29 scores than the general population in all measured domains (mean value: anxiety=63.9; depression=61.9; fatigue=60.1; pain=62.6;
sleep disturbance= 55.8; physical function= 36.2; social role= 42.2). Dyspnea severity
was associated with worse mean PROMIS-29 scores (all p< 0.05). PROMIS-Dyspnea
(mean= 58.7) and Functional Limitations Due to Dyspnea (mean= 58.4) scores were
worse than the COPD reference population. Cough severity was associated with
worse HRQOL measured by ATAQ-IPF. Reliability of PROMIS-29 scores exceeded 0.65
and were moderately correlated with measures of similar constructs. A limitation
of the study is that data drawn from a sample from advocacy organizations might
not be generalizable to the entire IPF population. Conclusions: Patients with IPF
report substantial deficits in HRQOL, particularly with respect to physical function,
anxiety, pain, depression and fatigue. Patients suffering from dyspnea and cough
had poorer HRQOL. These deficits should be monitored in clinical practice and
evaluated in investigational trials aiming to improve the HRQOL of IPF patients.
PRS75
Asthma and Copd In Spain: Quality of Life and Health RESOURCES
CONSUMPTION
Collar JM
Mundipharma Pharmaceuticals, Madrid, Spain
Objectives: To analyze the impact that asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) have on patients Health Related Quality of Life (HRQOL) and
on health resources consumed by the Spanish Health System. Methods: Data
obtained from the last Spanish National Health Survey (SNSHS) 2011-12, on adult
population (> 15y), identifying patients with a diagnostic of asthma or COPD.
Descriptive statistic analysis was carried out, specially focused on self-reported
HRQOL (EQ-5D-5L) and health resources utilization. The EQ-5D results were translated into QALYs, with the social tariffs validated in Spain. Other demographic
factors, potentially related with the mentioned respiratory diseases prevalence,
as age, sex, smoking habits were analyzed. Four groups were compared: 1) asthma
patients, 2) COPD patients, 3) patients with other chronic conditions, and 4) global
Spanish population. Results: Data from 21,007 adults was recorded. Prevalence
of asthma was slightly above COPD (5.4% vs 4.7%), and 47.2% were suffering from
chronic diseases. Asthma patients were younger than those with COPD (51y vs
61y, as an average, respectively). Concerning EQ-5D results, the dimensions mainly
affected either in COPD or asthma were, respectively, pain/discomfort (53.7% /
38.7%), mobility (42% / 27.4%), usual activities (34.4% / 21.8%), and depression/anxiety (32.4% / 25.4%). Based on the EQ-5D questionnaire, the QALYs calculation were
0.75 for COPD and 0.90 for asthma patients, the latter results were similar to the
other chronic conditions and to the global population. Health resources in COPD
patients were significantly higher than in the other 3 groups analyzed, considering
office visits (GPs/Specialists), hospitalization and emergency unit visits during the
last year. Conclusions: Patients diagnosed with asthma have a similar HRQOL
compared to the rest of the population, but COPD patients have it worse. COPD
is also associated with a higher health resources consumption, which implies a
relevant impact on the Spanish National Health System.
PRS76
Health Related Quality of Life Among Young Smokers
Muragundi P M 1, Dharmagadda S 2, Ligade V S 3, Udupa N 3, Naik A N 4
College of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Manipal, India, 2Manipal College of Pharmceutical
Sciences, Manipal, India, India, 3Manipal University, Manipal, India, 4Manipal College of
Pharmaceutical Sciences, Manipal University, Manipal, India
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Manipal
Objectives: As young students are more prone to smoking and associated dangers it affects their health related quality of life (HRQoL). This study was done to
assess the HRQoL and other associated factors affecting HRQoL among smokers
and non-smokers who are students. Methods: In this exploratory study a pilot
tested questionnaire was used to collect information regarding young students,
demographics, BMI, food habits, alcohol consumption, family history of smoking
as well as family history of diseases. For health related quality of life measurement
both descriptive and visual analogue score (VAS) of EQ 5D 5L questionnaire ware
used. The data collected was analyzed using SPSS 16.0.0. The test of significance
was done by using Chi Square test for checking the associated habits and Mann
Whitney U test is done to check the significance of association between HRQoL
and smoking and other associated habits. Results: Total 126 students were
included in the study. The age was 22.9±2.17 (Mean±SD) and BMI was 22.03±4.27
(Mean±SD) and all of them were residing in an University town. 63 % of the students were non-vegetarians and 44.8% were consuming alcohol at least once
in a month. The mean EQ 5D visual analogue score of the studied population
was found to be 83.3±11.5 (Mean±SD). The Chi square test showed the association between smoking with family history of smoking, alcohol consumption and
soft drinks consumption (p< 0.001, 0.001 and 0.05 respectively). Mann Whitney
U test showed as significant difference in the VAS scores among smokers and
non-smokers (p< 0.05). Conclusions: Health Related Quality of Life is severely
compromised by smoking, hence there is an urgent need to create awareness
among young students.
PRS77
Health Related Quality of Life And Health Care Utilization in
Primary Care Patients With Moderate/Persistent Severity Asthma
Garcia Ruiz A 1, Garcia-Agua Soler N 1, Quintano J 2
1University of Malaga, Malaga, Spain, 2Respiratory group of SEMERGEN, Córdoba, Spain
.
.
.
Objectives: The aim of this study is to evaluate the health related quality of life
(HRQoL) and health care utilization in primary care (PC) patients with asthma
treated with beclomethasone/formoterol. Methods: This study analyzed the
HRQoL and health care utilization from a cohort of 65 patients over 6 months.
Inclusion criteria were patients aged 18 years and older with moderate/severe persistent asthma (GINA criteria) treated with beclomethasone/formoterol at least 1-3
months before the inclusion in the study. Sociodemographic variables such as age,
sex, duration of disease, severity of asthma, concomitant pathology were evaluated. The evaluation of the HRQoL were measured with the Asthma Quality of Life
Questionnaire (AQLQ), and two generic questionnaires, EuroQol-5D and SF-36. The
evaluation of the health care utilization included visits to PC, visits of care nursing
and visits to accident and emergency (A&E) department and admissions. Statistical
analysis: average ± standard deviation (SD); frequency and proportions. Inferential
statistics in terms of average HRQoL and health care utilization were calculated
using T-Student, Chi-square and ANOVA. Results: Average patients were female
(60%), aged 49 years old (SD 2.16) with disease duration of 92 months (SD 18.34).
The average health care utilization was: 3.43 (SD 0.35) visits to PC and 1.42 (SD
0.29) visits to nursing; analytical: 0.63 (SD 0.09); chest x-ray: 0.38 (± 0.08); ECG 0.32
(SD 0.08). The average of exacerbations without hospital admission was 1.09 (SD
0.19) and the A&E department visits of PC related with asthma was 0.43 (SD 0.11).
Statistically significant differences (p < 0.05) and clinically significant between the
beginning and end of the study on all forms of quality of life measured in these
patients were found measured with AQLQ, EuroQol-5D and SF36. Conclusions:
Beclomethasone/formoterol improved HRQOL in patients with asthma representing
a good cost/utility relationship.
PRS78
Health-Related Quality of Life Among Tuberculosis Patients in
Pakistan: A Cross Sectional Study Using WHOQOL-BREF
Iqbal M S 1, Iqbal M W 2, Bahari M B 1, Iqbal M Z 1
of Clinical Pharmacy, Faculty of Pharmacy, AIMST University, Kedah, Malaysia,
2Faculty of Law, Universiti Malaya, Kualalumpur, Malaysia
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Department
Objectives: The aim of this study was to assess impairment in health-related
quality of life (HRQoL) of pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB) patients in Pakistan. This
study also evaluated utility of various socio-demographic and clinical factors that
A602
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
are directly and indirectly linked with HRQoL of TB patients. Methods: A prospective cross-sectional study was conducted at a tertiary care hospital in a province
of Pakistan, the Punjab. Data was collected by using WHOQOL-BREF questionnaire (Urdu version, pretested for reliability and validity) by means of face-to-face
interviews and where possible by gender-based focus group sessions. In addition,
facilitators also used few open-ended questions in order to get patients’ demographic and socioeconomic data. Participants were also asked to share their personal experiences of being diagnosed and treated with TB and what impact it had
on their life style. All obtained data were analyzed using descriptive and inferential statistics. Results: The overall Cronbach’s alpha coefficient of the revalidated
WHOQOL-BREF questionnaire was 0.785. The confirmatory factor analysis also provided an acceptable fit to a four-factor model in the studied sample. The scores for
negative feelings, blue mood, depression, living place, personal relationships and
sex life were significantly different in the psychological health and social relations
domains. Age, gender and physical exercise were also significantly associated with
the HRQoL of the patients. Conclusions: The WHOQOL-BREF was reliable and
valid in the assessment of the HRQoL of TB patients in Pakistan. Despite the ability
to cure TB, there was a significant impact on HRQoL of the TB patients. Till today,
much attention is spent on curative and preventative mechanisms whereas the
impact of TB on HRQoL is often neglected.
patients recruited through an agency, Twitter and Asthma UK’s website. Participants
had experienced a NCS and a SS <3 years previously. Medication history and Asthma
Control Test (ACT) scores were collected. Interviews were audio-recorded, and thematically analysed. Results: The sample was 69% Caucasian, with six males and
seven females, and a mean age= 47. Most were working full time or retired, and had
many years since asthma diagnosis (mean= 22 years). NCS were related to reliever
(n= 7), preventer (n= 4) or both (n= 2) medications with the most common NCS from
one brand to another (n= 4). Participants reported negative feelings, difficulty using
the medication and ineffective symptom control. Most participants used the NCS
medication < 6 months (range < 24 hours–2 years). The SS for most was a return to
their original pre-NCS medication (n= 11). Although most found getting their SS
straightforward, this required at least two HCP visits for half the sample, and took
up to two months to obtain. Most expected symptoms to improve following the SS
but nine participants still had sub-optimal ACT scores. Lasting impacts included
damaged relationships with HCPs, strong views about NCS and concern about NCS
reoccurrence. Conclusions: Failure to inform and involve patients in medication
changes can have lasting impacts. It is important to note that NCS can incur costs
associated with rejection of medicines and additional consultations, thus negating
any attempt at cost saving.
PRS79
Systematic Literature Review Assessing Data on the Burden of
Allergic Rhinitis from a Cost and Quality of Life Perspective
RESPIRATORY-RELATED DISORDERS – Health Care Use & Policy Studies
Hahn-Pedersen J 1, Boxall N 2, Maier W 2, Linneberg A 3, Serup-Hansen N 1
1ALK, Hørsholm, Denmark, 2Mapi, London, UK, 3Glostrup University Hospital, Glostrup, Denmark
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess published data on perennial allergic rhinitis/house dust
mite allergic (PAR) patients and seasonal allergic rhinitis/grass pollen allergic (SAR)
patients in order to establish the burden of allergic rhinitis (AR) and allergic asthma
from both a quality of life (QoL) and cost perspective. Methods: A systematic literature review was conducted using Medline and Embase in eight pre-specified countries for the time period of January 2000 to January 2014. Search terms were related
to QoL and/or cost. A total of 2963 abstracts and titles were identified. 50 abstracts
met predefined criteria and provided data for calculations and collation. Results:
Based on the RQLQ, the overall QoL of PAR patients was significantly worse than that
of SAR patients (2.73 ± 0.12 cf. 2.04 ± 0.18, p≤ 0.001). In general, practical problems
(mean: 3.80 ± SE: 0.08) and activities (mean: 3.70 ± SE: 0.11) were the most affected
domains. Measured by the physical component score from the SF-36 questionnaire,
the overall QoL of PAR patients was worse (p= 0.002) than that of SAR patients (49.06
± 1.26 cf. 64.19 ± 7.89). For both PAR and SAR patients, domains measured by the
SF-36 showed that vitality (mean: 59.95 ± SE: 3.24) was the most affected domain.
Based on RQLQ, allergy immunotherapy improves eye symptoms, nasal symptoms,
activities and practical problems the most in grass allergic patients. Direct comparison of total direct and indirect costs was complicated by differences in individual
costs assessed among studies, however, the primary burden of costs is indirect
and caused by high absenteeism and presenteeism. Conclusions: The QoL and
economic burden of AR was substantial in the countries included in this review.
However, limitations regarding the number of studies per country, heterogeneity
between studies, and the lack of presented data have restricted the conclusions
that could be drawn.
PRS80
Prospective Study on Quality of Life (QOL) of Bronchial Asthma
Patients in a Tertiary Care Teaching Hospital
Yedavalli N 1, Shukla R 2, Nair S V 2, A S 2, Mohan M K 2
College of Pharmaceutical Sciences, manipal, India, 2Manipal University, Manipal, India
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Manipal
Objectives: To determine the Quality of Life (QoL) of bronchial asthma patients in
a tertiary care teaching hospital at baseline and at follow up. Methods: The study
was conducted for a period of 6 months among 100 bronchial asthma patients, with
and without co-morbidities, admitted to the pulmonary and medicine wards in
the university hospital after obtaining the ethical clearance. The quality of life was
assessed using Asthma Quality Of life Questionnaire (AQLQ). Patients were followed
up after 4weeks from the date of discharge. Statistical analysis was performed using
SPSS version 20. Results: The mean age of the study population was 53.30±14.59
having 61% of the patients as females. Data was analyzed by Wilcoxon signed rank
test. The total score of Qol at follow up (5.94 ±0.76) showed an improvement with
a P value < 0.0001 (wilcoxon signed rank t test) when compared with baseline (3.92
± 1.04). A significant improvement in symptoms was seen at follow up (6.05 ± 0.82)
from baseline (3.93 ± 1.14). The activity limitation improved with a P value < 0.0001
(Wilcoxon signed rank t test) from baseline (4.00 ± 1.08) to follow up (5.92 ± 0.83). At
follow up (5.97 ± 0.82) the emotional function showed an enhancement on comparing with baseline (3.92 ± 1.14). The environmental stimuli showed no significant
changes at baseline (3.66 ± 1.29) and follow up (3.84 ± 1.34). Conclusions: The
results of the study suggests that clinical pharmacists have a major role in improving patient knowledge and thereby significantly improve the quality of life of the
patient.
PRS81
Impact of Non-Consented Switch and Subsequent Switch in Asthma
Medication: Qualitative Study of Patient Perspective in the UK
Ballinger R 1, Friedemann C 1, Golics C J 1, Lloyd A 2, Doyle S 3
1ICON PLC, Oxford, UK, 2ICON Plc, Oxford, UK, 3GlaxoSmithKline, Uxbridge, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Patient satisfaction with asthma treatment is associated with better adherence and achievement of treatment goals. While medication changes are
sometimes instigated for clinical or financial reasons, changes without patients’
knowledge or involvement (‘non-consented switch’ [NCS]) can impact symptom
control and patient-health care provider (HCP) relationships. This study explored
experiences of patients who had a NCS and subsequently requested and received a
second switch (SS). Methods: Interviews were conducted with 13 UK adult asthma
PRS82
Evaluation of Selected Ken-Drgs in Greek Public Hospitals: The
Degree to Which they Reflect Actual Expenditure and Average
Length of Stay
Siskou O 1, Galanis P 2, Kaitelidou D 2, Kalogeropoulou M 1, Kouli E 2, Thireos E 3, Vafeiadis J 4,
Theodorou M 5, Prezerakos P 6, Lemonidou C 2, Liaropoulos L 2
for Health Services Management and Evaluation, National and Kapodistrian University of
Athens, Athens, Greece, 2National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, Athens, Greece, 3Athens
Medical Society, Athens, Greece, 4National Organization for Health Care Services Provision
-EOPYY, Marousi, Greece, 5Open University of Cyprus, Latsia, Nicosia, Cyprus, 6University of
Peloponnese, Sparta, Greece
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Center
Objectives: To evaluate the degree to which the officially pre-determined cost
and average length of stay (ALoS) per selected KEN-DRG reflect actual resource
use and to investigate other factors (e. g. size, type and location of hospital) correlated with charges and ALoS. Methods: Data were from the Health Regions data
base and included discharges, ALoS, and charges in NHS Hospitals for the selected
KEN-DRGs. Predetermined ALoS and cost per KEN-DRG were derived from Gazette
946/27/03/2012. Continuous variables did not follow normal distribution, so non
parametric methods (Spearman’s correlation coefficient, Kruskal-Wallis test and
Mann-Whitney test) were used. A two sided p-value ≤ 0.05 was considered statistically significant. Results: Higher length of stay compared with the officially
pre-determined was found for Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD)
with complications (10.8 vs 9 days), Bronchitis & Asthma with complications (5.8
vs 4 days), Bronchitis & Asthma without complications (2.7 vs 2 days) and Breast
Cancer with complications (7.9 vs 5 days). Consequently, officially pre-determined
cost for Breast Cancer with complications (€ 965), Bronchitis & Asthma with complications (€ 792) and COPD with complications (€ 1,446) represents less than 90%
of total hospital charges (total actual average charge: € 1,186; € 929; € 1,634 respectively). However, for the rest of the DRGs, under study, there were none or limited
additional hospital charges. For all KEN-DRGs, size and population density was
positively correlated with total charges (rs= 0.12, p= 0.018; median for Athens = 863
& semi-urban=752 p=0.09 respectively). Moreover, for Bronchitis & Asthma with and
without complications, population density was found to be positively correlated
with ALoS (median for urban areas= 5.1 and semi-urban= 4.7; p= 0.09 and median
for urban areas= 3 and semi-urban= 2.5; p= 0.03 respectively). Conclusions: The
introduction of KEN-DRGs was a useful first step to modernize the hospital reimbursement system. However, further revisions are required in order for KEN-DRGs
to become more useful.
PRS83
Patterns of Asthma Treatment Utilization in Newly Diagnosed
Elderly Patients are Inconsistent With Asthma Management
Guidelines
Ali A K
Eli Lilly and Company, Indianapolis, IN, USA
.
.
Objectives: Asthma is under-diagnosed and under-treated in elderly, and utilization of asthma medications in this population is not well characterized. This
study describes utilization patterns of asthma medications in newly diagnosed
≥ 50 patients. Methods: Medicare enrollees are followed for 12 months after first
asthma diagnosis between Q1 2004- Q3 2012 (ICD-9-CM code: 493*). Treatment pattern analysis was applied to initiators of asthma medications. Patients with > 1
prescription of second-line therapy following exposure to first-line therapy are considered therapy switchers or augmenters. Patients with history of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease are excluded (ICD-9-CM codes: 490, 491*, 492*, 494*, 495*
& 496). Results: Among 126,176 elderlies with asthma, 24,021 initiated asthma
therapy within 12 months of asthma diagnosis (70% women, median age 70 years).
319 (1.3%) continued therapy with one drug class (first-line therapy); 13,940 (58%)
discontinued first-line therapy; 3,469 (14.4%) switched to another drug class (second-line therapy); and 6,293 (26.2%) added second-line therapy (augmented). About
34% of patients initiated therapy with inhaled short-acting beta-agonists (SABA);
majority of them either discontinued SABA or added a controller medication. 19%
of elderly patients started with oral corticosteroids after asthma diagnosis, 77%
discontinued them and 12% switched to another asthma controller. Among controller medications, inhaled corticosteroids (ICS) /long-acting beta-agonists (LABA)
combination therapy, ICS monotherapy, and leukotriene antagonists respectively
accounted for 19%, 12%, and 11% of treatment initiators. The majority of these anti-
A603
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
inflammatory formulations were discontinued during 12 months after asthma diagnosis. Conclusions: Asthma treatment utilization patterns reflect poor asthma
control among newly diagnosed elderly patients, and initiation of anti-inflammatory
treatment after asthma diagnosis appears to be inconsistent with asthma management guidelines.
PRS84
Doctors’ Failure in Observance of the COPD Management Guidelines:
Case of the CZECH Republic
Tichopad A 1, Koblizek V 2, Kolek V 3, Pecen L 1
s.r.o., Prague, Czech Republic, 2Charles University Faculty of Medicine and University
Hospital, Hradec Králové, Czech Republic, 3Olomouc University Hospital, Olomouc, Czech Republic
.
.
.
.
1CEEOR
Objectives: The primary objective of this study was to examine the accuracy of
the GOLD 2011 strategy implementation among the Czech respiratory specialists,
esp. with respect to the patients’ classification. The secondary objective was to
explore what effect a misclassification has on inadequate use of inhaled corticosteroids (ICS). Methods: Multicentre cross-sectional study was conducted among
COPD specialists, consisting of general questionnaire and patient-specific forms. A
subjective classification into the GOLD 2011 groups as practiced by the health care
professionals was examined and then compared with the objective classification
achieved by rigorous software-computed classification. Adequacy of the ICS prescription was evaluated with regard to the subjective classification. Results: GOLD
2011 were claimed to be the leading guidelines for 143 out of 144 specialists involved,
often accompanied by CPPS guidelines (83.3%) and the ACP/ACCP/ATS/ERS standards
(50.7%). Based on 1355 patient forms, a discrepancy between the subjective and
objective classification was found in 32.8% of cases. The most common reason for
incorrect classification was erroneous symptoms assessment resulting in either
under-estimation in 23.9% of cases and over-estimation in 8.9% of the examined
patients’ records. Specialists seeing more than 120 patients per month were most
likely to misclassify their condition, i. e. in 36.7% of all seen patients. In general,
whilst examining the subjectively-driven ICS prescription, it was found that 19.5%
of patients received ICS incorrectly, while in 12.2% of cases the ICS was erroneously
omitted. Furthermore, with consideration to the objectively computed classification, it was discovered that 15.4% received ICS unnecessarily, whereas in 15.8% of
cases the ICS was not prescribed though, in fact, it would be adequate seeing the
patient’s condition. Women failed in correct prescription more frequently than men,
predominantly by overprescribing ICS. Conclusions: Despite high awareness of
the GOLD 2011 guidelines, its implementation is insufficient. Czech specialists tend
to either under-classify or overuse the ICS.
PRS85
Social Media Meets Population Health: A Sentiment And
Demographic Analysis of Tobacco and E-Cigarette Use Across The
“Twittersphere”
Clark E M 1, Jones C 2, Gaalema D 1, White T J 1, Redner R 1, Everett R 1, Dodds P S 1, Couch M 2,
Danforth C 1
1University of Vermont, Burlington, VT, USA, 2University of Vermont - College of Medicine,
Burlington, VT, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Twitter, a popular social media outlet, has become a useful tool for
the study of social behavior through user interactions called tweets. The location
time, and message content of tweets provide invaluable social and demographic
information for an applied comparison of social behaviors across the world. Our
goal is to determine the density and sentiment surrounding tobacco and e-cigarette
tweets and link prevalence of word choices to tobacco and e-cigarette use at various
localities. Methods: All tweets with geo-spatial coordinates are salvaged from the
twitter-feed, representing approximately 1% of the entire twitter-sphere. Pattern
matching by tobacco and e-cigarette related keywords yield approximately 20,000
affiliated tweets per month from North America. The emotionally charged words
that contribute to the positivity of various subsets of regional tweets are quantitatively measured using hedonometrics. We examined the density of these behavioral
tweet indicators by region and tested the relationship between tweeted smoking
sentiments and time-space-type coordinates over a 4-month span. Results: For
states with ≥ 600 tobacco related tweets (N= 30), we find a strong positive correlation (Pearson’s r= 0.54, p< 0.01) between the relative tweet density per state and
the average positivity of tobacco related tweets. However, state-to-state sentiment
comparisons suggest the attitude toward tobacco use can vary. We also explore
the relationship between the ratio of tobacco tweets per state-to-state smoking
rate estimates. Our results illustrate significant variation in smoking sentiments
by state and at varying regional scopes. Conclusions: It is anticipated that realtime analysis of nicotine and tobacco products using tweets will allow for more
targeted forms of health policy planning and intervention. Regional density of
nicotine and tobacco use related tweets yield insight to the prevalence of tobacco
usage per capita. Sentiment analysis across the twitter-sphere can help illuminate
hazardous health behavioral trends, which may lead to better targeting of health
behavior interventions.
PRS86
Sustainable Policy: Higher Medication Use & Adherence During
Reimbursement of Pharmacologic Smoking Cessation Treatments
Van Boven J F , Vemer P
University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands
.
.
analysis was performed on real-world observational data from the years 2010-2013
in The Netherlands. Data on use and adherence was collected, in patients who were
dispensed bupropion or varenicline in community pharmacies for the first time.
Adherence was defined a using minimal 80% of the in guidelines recommended
duration and intensity of use. Results: The study cohort consisted of 4,412 users of
pSCT. The number of prescriptions was stable at 0.5 prescriptions per 1,000 inhabitants (dispensing prevalence, dp) during 2010. The prevalence was on average 0.8
dp, with peaks in the the 1st and 4th quarters of 2011. In 2012, the prevalence was
stable at 0.4 dp. In 2013 was on average 0.5 dp, with a small peak in the 1st quarter.
Adherence was 18% in 2010 and 2012 (non-reimbursement period), and 21% in 2011
and 2013 (reimbursement period). Conclusions: Not only the likelihood of starting smoking cessation, but also the extent of adherence to pharmacologic smoking
cessation is higher during reimbursement. Increasing the awareness of health care
providers on adherence issues is warranted.
PRS87
Monte-Carlo Simulation to Estimate the Health Care Costs Avoided
With Fluticasone Furoate/Vilanterol Due to Exacerbation Rate
Reduction in Spanish COPD Patients
Mayoralas S 1, Huerta A 2, Parrondo J 2, Rubio-Terrés C 3, Rubio-Rodríguez D 3
1Hospital Ramón y Cajal, Madrid, Spain, 2GlaxoSmithKline, Madrid, Spain, 3Health Value, Madrid,
Spain
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Exacerbations are considered one of the main drivers of costs of
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD). In moderate to severe COPD
patients with a history of exacerbations, the addition of an inhaled corticosteroid
(ICS) to a long acting β 2 agonist (LABA) has been associated with a decreased rate of
exacerbations versus treatment with LABA alone. This study aims to estimate the
health care costs that the addition of the ICS Fluticasone Furoate (FF) to the LABA
vilanterol (VI) could avoid versus LABA monotherapy in Spanish patients due to
the reduction of the rate of exacerbations. Methods: The number of moderate
to severe COPD patients > 40 years old with a history of exacerbation potentially
treated with FF+VI was estimated from Spanish prevalence data. 1-year Monte-Carlo
simulations (one simulation per patient) were developed to simulate the number of
moderate and severe exacerbations and the health care costs avoided with FF+VI
versus VI from the National Health System (NHS) perspective. Monte-Carlo simulation was chosen as it allows simulating the effect of changes in different parameters obtained from clinical studies to describe real-life distributions. Parameters
used in the simulations were the yearly rate of moderate-severe exacerbations
with FF+VI and VI obtained from pooled-analysis of two head-to-head clinical trials
(NCT01009463 and NCT01017952) and the costs of moderate and severe exacerbations obtained from an observational study in real-life Spanish setting. Results:
18,098 patients were included. FF+VI could avoid 7,424 moderate and severe exacerbations (95% confidence interval 7,411; 7,438) vs VI. The reduction in the number
of exacerbations could lead to average health care costs avoided to the NHS of 3,278,
382€ (3,066, 703€ ; 3,336, 392€ ) in a year. Conclusions: Treatment with FF+VI could
decrease the economic burden associated with COPD reducing the health care costs
for the Spanish NHS due to the decreased rate of exacerbations compared with
LABA (VI) monotherapy.
PRS88
Determination of Availability of Antimicrobial Preparations for
Treatment of Community-Acquired Pneumonia in Ukraine
Iakovlieva L , Vasilieva A , Rybka A , Yurchenko O
National University of Pharmacy, Kharkiv, Ukraine
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Data of british specialists show, that 5-11 out of 1000 adults have community-acquired pneumonia (CAP) every year, which is 5-12% of all cases of lower
respiratory tract infections. The rate of CAP took over 3% in the structure of total
respiratory organs disease rate in Ukraine within years 2007-2011. Methods: The
data of use of antimicrobial preparations (AP): cephalosporins (ceftriaxone), penicillins (amoxicillin and enzyme inhibitor), macrolides (azithromycin) and fluoroquinolones (ciprofloxacin, levofloxacin) for CAP treatment in Kharkiv hospital were
used. Analysis of affordability as of index of payment capacity (Ca. s.) of trade names
(TNs) provided in pharmaceutical market of Ukraine on indicated INN has been
carried out to determine the availability of such preparations for wider population
of Ukraine. Results: Results of the AP affordability analysis made in five groups of
INN, showed, that the ratio of therapy of high, middle and low availability for each
AP group is different, but in all pharmacological groups except for ceftriaxone group,
highly available therapy prevails. Percentage of highly available preparations in the
studied groups of INN is: azitromycin (92.2%) > ciprofloxacin (74.3%) > amoxicillin
and enzyme inhibitor (67.5%) > ceftriaxone (49.02%) > levofloxacin (46.94 %). As of
preparations of middle availability, costing 5% - 15% of average monthly salary, ceftriaxone preparations are most (49.02%), azitromycin preparations are least (6.49%).
There are no low availability preparations in ciprofloxacin fluoroquinolone group.
Cephalosporins and macrolides group preparations have one AP of low availability.
Pharmacotherapy with application of preparations-analogous to levofloxacin, is
costly, as 32.7% of preparations of this group are preparations of low availability
(16 AP). Conclusions: Antibacterial preparations needed for treatment of CAP
are present in the pharmaceutical market of Ukraine in wide range of preparations
and cost. It makes them available to various social groups.
.
Background: The discussion on the reimbursement of Smoking Cessation
Treatment (SCT) has known many stages in The Netherlands. From January 2011,
SCTs were reimbursed, until January 2012 when the reimbursement of nicotine
replacement therapies (NRTs) and pharmacotherapeutic SCT (pSCT) was discontinued. As of 2013, NRTs and pSCTs were again reimbursed for a maximum of one
attempt per calendar year, provided they are accompanied by behavioural counselling. Objectives: To assess the impact of changes in reimbursement policy
of pSCT on use and adherence. Methods: A retrospective dispensing database
PRS89
How Much the Appropriate Tobacco Price Would Be?: A Discrete
Choice Experiment of General Public in Japan
Igarashi A 1, Goto R 2
of Tokyo, Graduate School of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Tokyo, Japan,, 2Kyoto University,
Kyoto, Japan
.
.
1University
Objectives: Though tobacco price increases are effective in reducing tobacco consumption and prevalence of smoking, tobacco-tax in Japan is still lower than those in
other developed countries. General public, particularly non-smokers, may think that
A604
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
tobacco tax is important as a source of revenue. The objectives of this research is to
quantitatively assess about how general public value several aims of tobacco policy
and the amount of tax revenue and to estimate “ideal” tobacco price where the price
elasticity of tobacco consumption is given. Methods: We conducted a web-based
survey from 9-15, Aug 2012 including a discrete choice experiment (DCE) to elicit
general public’s preference for targeted smoking rate, tax revenue, tobacco policy for
the younger generation and the usage of tax. Then, we numerically forecast general
publics’ support rate of a tobacco policy as a function of tobacco price where price
elasticity is given. Results: 1,077 completed questionnaires and were eligible for
analysis. They statistically prefer the tobacco policy which results in lower prevalence
of smokers, higher tax revenue, targeted for young people and tax revenue is used for
general purposes. Given the price elasticity of 0.3, 0.4 and 0.5, highest tobacco price,
which acquire the highest support from general public, was around JPY871 (EUR6.2),
JPY555 (EUR4.0) and JPY454 (EUR3.2), respectively. Conclusions: The present price
of cigarette per one pack is around JPY460 (EUR 3.3). When smokers are highly responsive to price elevation and are successfully quit after the elevation, present price of
cigarette is suitable when we consider public’s preference for tax revenue as well as
normal policy measures. Rooms for further price elevations depends on the price
elasticity of cigarette consumption.
Sensory Systems Disorders – Clinical Outcomes Studies
PSS1
Efficacy of Treatments for Macular Oedema Secondary to Branch
Retinal Vein Occlusion: A Network Meta-Analysis
Regnier S , Bezlyak V
Novartis Pharma AG, Basel, Switzerland
.
.
Objectives: To indirectly compare the efficacy of approved treatments for
macular oedema secondary to branch retinal vein occlusion (BRVO). Methods:
Randomized, controlled trials (RCTs) evaluating the efficacy at month 6 (or month
12) of at least two of ranibizumab 0.5mg pro re nata (after 6 monthly doses), aflibercept 2.0mg monthly, dexamethasone implant (retreatment interval ≥ 6 months),
laser photocoagulation or sham were identified from a published systematic
review, congress abstracts, clinicaltrials. gov and Novartis data on file. Outcomes of
interest were the mean change in best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA, measured as
Early Treatment Diabetic Retinopathy Study letters), and the percentage of patients
gaining ≥ 15 letters. For two studies, the standard deviation around mean BCVA
gain was estimated. A Bayesian network meta-analysis with random treatment
effects was used to compare mean BCVA gains and odds ratios (ORs) for gaining
≥ 15 letters. Results: The analysis included seven RCTs. Patient-level data for
three ranibizumab trials were re-analysed to match key inclusion criteria (BCVA
and duration of disease at baseline) from aflibercept studies. Statistically significant (p< 0.05) BCVA letter gains were found for ranibizumab monotherapy (+11.6),
ranibizumab plus laser combination therapy (+10.1) and aflibercept (+10.1) versus
laser, and for ranibizumab monotherapy versus dexamethasone (+8.0). ORs versus
laser for gaining ≥ 15 letters were 3.24 (95% credible interval, 1.03–12.56; p< 0.05)
and 3.07 (0.63–14.8) for ranibizumab monotherapy and aflibercept, respectively.
Mean BCVA letter gains were numerically higher with ranibizumab monotherapy
compared with aflibercept (+1.5 letters [-5.3–8.8]; OR for gaining ≥ 15 letters, 1.06
[0.16–8.94]). The probability of being the most efficacious treatment based on letters gained was 57% for ranibizumab, 15% for ranibizumab plus laser and 28% for
aflibercept. Conclusions: The analysis confirms the superiority of ranibizumab
over dexamethasone implant and laser therapy, and shows that ranibizumab has
the highest likelihood of being the most efficacious treatment for BRVO.
PSS2
Comparative Effectiveness of An Acellular Synthetic Matrix As An
Adjunct to Standard Care In The Treatment of Venous And Mixed
Leg Ulcers: Modeling of Clinical Data And Routine Data
Augustin M 1, Gutknecht M 1, Anastasiadou Z 1, Heyer K 1, Harding K 2, Shannon R J 3,
Heinrichs E L 4
1University Medical Center Hamburg-Eppendorf, Hamburg, Germany, 2Cardiff University, Cardiff,
UK, 3Global Health Economic Projects LLC, Clifton Park, NY, USA, 4Daresbury Innovation Centre,
Daresbury, Cheshire, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Recently, advanced treatments such as topical growth factors, biological dressings, and tissue engineered products have been developed in order
to promote healing as well as decrease the time to healing of chronic leg ulcers.
Nevertheless, if standard care fails, there is no widely accepted, easy to use secondline treatment primarily because most of these advanced treatments are expensive
and need further evidence of effectiveness in everyday clinical practice. The purpose
of our study was to assess the effectiveness of a new acellular synthetic matrix
(ASM) as an adjunct to standard care, using healing time as endpoint, in venous and
mixed leg ulcers in German everyday clinical practice. Methods: Prospective data
on venous and mixed leg ulcers from a safety and effectiveness study on an acellular
synthetic matrix was compared retrospectively to matched data from a German
Registry of Chronic Wounds (DRCW) database containing German patients with
equivalent leg ulcer disease, patient age and gender, baseline wound area, wound
duration, same outcome measures, and comparable follow-up periods. The outcome
of interest was healing time over 12-weeks of treatment. Results: Analysis using
Kaplan Meier survival curves showed a mean of 73.1 days (95% CI: 66.4 - 79.9 days)
to healing for acellular synthetic matrix treated ulcers, in comparison to 92.2 days
(95% CI: 87.1 – 97.2 days) for equivalent ulcers treated in everyday clinical practice
in Germany (Log rank test χ 2 11.46, p= 0.001). Conclusions: Results from this
study predict a highly significant effect of a new acellular synthetic matrix as an
adjunct to standard care in the repair of venous and mixed leg ulcers. The predictive model may be useful in determining expected effectiveness of the acellular
synthetic matrix in the treatment of venous and mixed leg ulcer patients treated
in everyday clinical practice in Germany.
PSS3
Cost-Effectiveness of Omalizumab in Chronic Idiopathic Urticaria
Refractory to H1-Antihistamines in Turkey
Tatar M 1, Sezen S 2, Senturk A 3, Balp M M 4, Saylan M 2, Keskinaslan A 2
University, Ankara, Turkey, 2Novartis Pharma, Istanbul, Turkey, 3Polar Polar Health
Economics & Policy, Ankara, Turkey, 4Novartis Pharma AG, Basel, Switzerland
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Hacettepe
Objectives: Omalizumab is a humanised anti-IgE recombinant monoclonal antibody approved in Turkey for treatment of chronic idiopathic (or spontaneous) urticaria (CIU) in patients resistant to standard treatment. We aimed to assess the
cost-effectiveness of omalizumab compared with the standard care in the treatment
of CIU patients in Turkey. Methods: A Markov model of 10 years horizon was developed to estimate costs and outcomes associated with omalizumab 300mg/every 4
weeks and standard of care for 24 weeks (SoC= licensed dose H1 antihistamines)
using data from two phase III studies (ASTERIA I&II includes patients with CIU
refractory to licensed dose of H1-antihistamines). The study was undertaken from
a Turkish health care payer perspective. At the end of this period, omalizumab was
stopped and background medication continued. Patients who have responded were
retreated by the same strategy upon relapse (UAS7 ≥ 16 or ≥ 28). We used Urticaria
Activity Score 7 (UAS7) to measure the outcome of the treatment and we used
symptom free days (UAS7 ≤ 6) as the outcome measure in this cost effectiveness
analysis. Resource utilization data were obtained via a Delphi panel. Unit costs
were taken from the Social Security Institution’s official list. Costs and outcomes
were evaluated over a lifetime and discounted at 3%. Results were presented as
incremental cost/symptom free days. Results: The incremental symptom free
days with omalizumab versus SoC was 27,965 days and the incremental cost was
1,610,349 Turkish Liras for 100 patients over 10 years. The incremental cost per
symptom free day was 57.59 Turkish Liras. One-way sensitivity analyses confirmed
the robustness of the model results. Conclusions: CIU affects the quality of life
of patients and is associated with direct and indirect costs to payers and society.
We believe that omalizumab 300mg Q4wks is a cost-effective treatment option for
patients with refractory CIU in Turkish setting.
PSS4
Outcomes of Patients With Neovascular Age-Related Macular
Degeneration (Namd) In Greece Under Ranibizumab
Yfantopoulos J 1, Rouvas A 2, Chatzaras A 1, Xanthopoulou P 2, Theodosiadis P 2
1National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, Athens, Greece, 2Attikon University Hospital of
Athens, Chaidari, Greece
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate the efficacy of treatment with ranibizumab in a sample of
Greek patients with nAMD. Methods: In this observational, non-interventional,
retrospective study, 194 cases with nAMD were enrolled from the Ophthalmology
Department of “Attikon” hospital. Patients treated with ranibizumab for at least one
year in one eye under routine clinical practice, and had at least one follow-up visit,
were considered eligible. Patients participating in another study and/or were receiving pharmaceutical product containing VEGF inhibitors were excluded. Primary endpoints were the mean change in Best Corrected Visual Acuity (BCVA), and in Central
retinal thickness (CRT), assessed by Optical Coherence Tomography. Results:
The average BCVA score per eye at baseline was 0.284 in decimal points (Snellen
equivalent≈ 20/84; ETDRS letters≈ 57.7), which improved at final visit (≈14 months
after baseline) reaching 0.336 (Snellen equivalent≈ 20/60; ETDRS letters≈ 61.3), i.e.
6,33% or approximately 3.7 ETDRS letters improvement (p< 0.001, r= 0.317) with 4.9
ranibizumab injections overall (4.3 injections/year). CRT similarly improved, as it
decreased by 28.4%, from 290.31 to 207.77 μ m (p< 0.001, r= 0.683). An extra ranibizumab injection per eye per year, increased the odds of an at least 0.1 increase in
BCVA from baseline to last visit by 20.8% (95%CI 1.068-1.366), and an at least 0.2
increase by 15.7% (95%CI 1.013-1.322). Conclusions: Ranibizumab provides significant benefit in patients with nAMD under routine clinical practice by improving
BCVA and reducing CRT, benefit which may be more important in a more frequent
dosing regimen.
PSS5
Results of A Decubitus Prevention and Wound Care Project
Dozsa C 1, Borcsek B 2
of Miskolc, Miskolc, Hungary, 2Med-Econ Ltd., Veroce, Hungary
.
.
1University
Objectives: Background: The project focused on the preventive use, effectiveness
and the better knowledge about the potential effects and mechanisms of dressings. Aims: To improve the effectiveness of wound care, to prevent effectively the
appearance of pressure ulcers during hospitalization. Methods: During 2 months
of the project 80 patients of 3 active and 2 chronic care departments were involved,
treatment of 84 pressure ulcers of 46 patients occurred. After the health check the
attachment of dressings and the wound management were carried out according
to the protocols and were documented on special datasheets. Subsequently, the
checking and processing of questionnaires – continuing the monitoring of patient
pathways – were done. Results: Pressure ulcers did not develop in case of 79% of
the patients after prevention, effectiveness of targeted prevention reached 95.5%.
The incidence of decubitus fell by 1.6-1.7 % in the project (formation rate was 58.890.9 % lower in average). In the background of successful prevention min. 3-day use
was observed, but even use of 1-1 preventive dressing was effective. The average
length of wound care was14 days, frequency was 8.2 times/patient. The healed or
recovering wounds were more frequently treated, but rather for more days, however, their treatment cost less than the average and those wounds which were not
healing. Conclusions: Wound care starts with prevention. The quality of wound
care should not decrease after the patient’s discharge, the home follow-up would
be essential, nevertheless its “best practices” has not spread widely in Hungary yet.
In the short term Decubitus Team doctors should be involved in patients’ discharge
planning, however in the long term creation of a so-called Wound Care Centre could
offer a sustainable solution. Hereinafter controlled trials of higher number of cases
could prove the cost-effectiveness of intelligent dressings in wider aspects of the
health care system.
A605
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PSS6
Clinical Effectiveness of Fumaric Acid Esters (Fumaderm) in
Psoriasis: A Systematic Review of Literature
PSS9
The Epidemiology of Medical Treatment for Glaucoma and Ocular
Hypertension in Germany
Ceglowska U , Wlodarczyk A , Slomka M
Agency for Health Technology Assessment In Poland (AHTAPol), Warsaw, Poland
Ernst F
Santen GmbH, Munich, Germany
Objectives: To review the literature evaluating the clinical efficacy of Fumaderm
(FAE) in patients suffering from psoriasis and psoriatic arthritis. Methods:
Systematic literature search in electronic databases (MEDLINE, Cochrane and
Embase) was performed (from inception to March 14,2014). Results were presented
by narrative synthesis including a quality assessment using Jadad scale. Results:
Three randomized controlled trials were included (Fallah Arani 2011, Altmeyer 1994,
Peeters 1992). Quality of studies ranged from 3 to 4 points. Observation period
was 16 weeks for all studies. One open-label study comparing FAE with methotrexate (MTX) in moderate to severe chronic plaque psoriasis was identified. The
primary efficacy endpoint was the difference in mean change from baseline in
Psoriasis Area and Severity Index (PASI). After 12 weeks of treatment the mean
PASI (± SD) decreased to 10.5 ± 6.7 compared with starting value of 18.1 ± 7.0 in
patients treated with FAE and to 6.7 ± 4.5 compared to starting value of 14.5 ±
3.0 in patients treated with MTX. The absolute difference between groups (FAE
vs. MTX) in the mean values was 1.4 (95%CI: 2.0; 4.7) and wasn’t statistically significant (p = 0.417). In the remaining two double-blind studies the efficacy and
safety of Fumaderm was assessed against the placebo. One study shows that in
psoriasis vulgaris population the mean PASI in FAE group decreased from 21.53 at
baseline to 10.77, whereas in placebo group mean PASI has not changed (p< 0.0001)
after 16 weeks of treatment. Moreover, the results of study in psoriatic arthritis
population revealed that FAE significantly (p< 0.04) decrease joint pain compared
to placebo. Conclusions: The results revealed that FAE and MTX have similar
clinical efficacy in the treatment of patients with moderate to severe psoriasis.
Moreover, FAE is more effective than placebo in the treatment of psoriasis vulgaris
and psoriatic arthritis.
Objectives: The purpose of this study is to review the epidemiology and the treatment paradigm of German glaucoma population and to assess the frequency of
switches from monotherapy to second- or third line combination therapy in primary
open angle glaucoma (POAG) patients. Glaucoma is the second leading cause of
blindness globally. The newly published EGS guidelines state that if the first choice
monotherapy is well tolerated and has effective intra ocular pressure (IOP) lowering
but has not succeeded in reaching the target pressure, the addition of a second drug
should be considered. Methods: German patient databases were searched in the
following areas: glaucoma prevalence and incidence studies in German population as well as treatment paradigm in glaucoma patients. Results: Our analysis
underlines the high number of glaucoma patients in Germany and the relevance of
this disease for the German health care system. The study also demonstrates that
a considerable number of glaucoma patients do not reach IOP target under monotherapy and have to be treated with a combination therapy. In general, treatment
with a combination of agents of different classes is associated with superior IOP
lowering efficacy. With an increasing number of available fixed dose combination
products, more options become available for combination therapy of glaucoma
patients. Conclusions: Glaucoma care needs to be given high priority in public
health programs. Especially treatment options for glaucoma patients in need for a
combination therapy should be in the focus of health care system decision makers
as well as further research in glaucoma clinical trials and clinical care.
.
.
.
PSS7
Knowledge and Perception of Medical and Pharmacy Students
Toward The Usage of Sunblock
Hadi H , Elkalmi R , Awadh A , Jamshed S , Al-Shami A
International Islamic University Malaysia, Kuantan, Malaysia
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate the knowledge and perception of medical and pharmacy students toward the usage of sunblock as skin protection against ultraviolet
(UV). Methods: This cross-sectional study was conducted among the undergraduate final year medical and pharmacy students at the International Islamic University
Malaysia (IIUM). Validated questionnaire were used to collect the data. The questionnaires were distributed to 134 students from medicine and 100 pharmacy students.
Descriptive and inferential statistics are used whenever appropriate. Results:
Overall, 161 participants out of a total of 234 completed the questionnaire with
101 medical students (75.4%) and 60 pharmacy students (60.0%). Majority of the
respondents were female 64 (63.4%) and 37 (36.6%) were male. The median of knowledge scores of the final year medical students was significantly lower than the
final year pharmacy students (p< 0.01). There is no significant differnce between
the knowledge of the female and male students (Mann Whitney U Test value =
0.27, p< 0.01). This study reported that 24 (39.3 %) of pharmacy students were influenced by the media to use sunblock whereas 35 (34.7%) of medical students had the
highest influence from friends to use sunblock. However, this study showed there
was no significant difference in the perception of pharmacy and medical studnets
p= 0.020. Conclusions: In conclusion, the knowledge of pharmacy students is
significantly higher than the knowledge of medical students had on the usage of
sunblock. Both medical and pharmacy students have the same level of perception
towards the usage of sunblock.
PSS8
Pharmacoepidemiology of Cellular/Tissue Derived Products for the
Treatment of Venous Leg Ulcers in Outpatient Care Settings
Gilligan A M , Waycaster C
Smith & Nephew Biotherapeutics, Fort Worth, TX, USA
.
.
.
Objectives: Venous leg ulcers (VLUs) are a debilitating condition for patients with
venous insufficiency. Compression therapy is the standard care for treatment of
VLU; however the success rate is approximately 50% at 6 months. Clinical trials
with cellular/tissue derived products (CTPs) have shown promising efficacy for
the treatment of VLU. The objective was to identify patient and clinical characteristics in the VLU population and examine patterns of CTP utilization. Methods:
Retrospective, de-identified electronic medical records from 2007-2013 were
extracted from the Intellicure Limited Data Set (I-LDS). The I-LDS extracts records
from 96 hospital-based outpatient wound centers. Patient, wound and encounter
level characteristics were examined. CTPs of interest included extracellular matrix
(ECM), human skin equivalent (HSE), and living skin equivalent (LSE). Results:
A total of 9,091 patients, 25,734 wounds, and 222,666 encounters for VLU were
identified. The majority of patients was male (50.5%), Caucasian (74.1%), and
reported Medicare as their primary insurance (53.4%). The average age was 68.9
(SD= 14.6) and the average number of physician visits was 17.7 (SD= 22.5). The mean
wound surface area was 20.1cm2 (SD= 83.4). The overall average wound duration
was 5.8 months (SD= 26.7). Of the 25,734 wounds, approximately 7.1% received
ECM (3.4%), HSE (3.5%), or LSE (0.2%). The average number of applications for ECM
was 2.7 (SD= 2.8), 0.6 (SD= 1.3) for HSE, and 3.1 (SD= 3.3) for LSE. Wounds treated
with CTPs were, on average, several months older: 12.5, 13.7, and 11.1 months for
ECM, HSE, and LSE, respectively. Overall average wound treatment time was 2.9
months (SD= 4.8). However, treatment time was substantially longer with CTP
utilization with an average time of 9.6, 9.7, and 7.5 months for ECM, HSE, and LSE,
respectively. Conclusions: CTP utilization was relatively low within outpatient
wound centers. Results from this analysis indicate that health care providers are
using CTPs on older, more difficult-to-heal VLUs.
.
Sensory Systems Disorders – Cost Studies
PSS10
A Us Hospital Economic Impact Model for Oritavancin In Absssi
Patients With Risk of Mrsa Infections
Wu C 1, Fortier K J 1, LaPensee K 2, Fan W 2, Mitchell M 2, Cyr P L 1, Jensen I S 1
1ICON plc, Cambridge, MA, USA, 2The Medicines Company, Parsippany, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: It is estimated that acute bacterial skin and skin structure infections
(ABSSSI) account for about 10% of hospital admissions in the US. Analyses of hospital claims indicate 74% of ABSSSI admissions involve empiric treatment with
methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) active antibiotics. Hospitalization
costs could be reduced if moderate-severe ABSSSI patients were treated to a greater
extent in the observational unit followed by discharge to outpatient parenteral
antibiotic therapy (OPAT). Oritavancin is a novel single-dose regimen, intravenous lipoglycopeptide antibiotic for ABSSSIs caused by gram-positive bacteria,
including MRSA. The aim of our analysis was to quantify the economic value of
using oritavancin for ABSSSI patients at risk of MRSA from a US hospital perspective. Methods: A decision analytic model based on current clinical practice was
developed to estimate the economic value of decreased hospital resources by using
oritavancin. Utilization of antibiotics was informed by analysis of the Premier hospital database. Demographic and clinical data were derived from a targeted literature review. ER, observation, laboratory, administration costs were from Medicare
National Limitation amounts. Drug costs were 2014 wholesale acquisition costs. To
estimate the economic impact of reducing resources using oritavancin we set its
price to $0. Results: For a hypothetical US hospital treating 1,000 ABSSSI patients
eligible for IV MRSA antibiotics/year, the administration of oritavancin in 25.75% of
patients facilitates shifting patients to the OPAT setting (441 to 561 patients) with
a total annual economic impact of $2,752K. Inpatient and outpatient costs were
reduced by $2,543K and $209K, respectively. Inpatient cost savings were derived from
a reduction in hospitalizations and lower administration burden drove decreased
OPAT costs. Conclusions: Using oritavancin in moderate-severe ABSSSI patients,
including those at risk of MRSA, is estimated to deliver an estimated cost reduction of $2,752/patient by shifting patient care to the OPAT setting, and decreasing
resource utilization.
PSS12
Economic Impact of Visual Impairment: A Pilot Study in Singapore
Wang X 1, Luo N 2, Lamoureux E 3, Ang M 4
1National University of Singapore, Singapore, 2Saw Swee Hock School of Public Health, National
University of Singapore, Singapore, 3University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Australia,, 4Singapore
National Eye Center, Singapore
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To examine the economic impact and independent determinants of
visual impairment (VI) in Singapore. Methods: 100 patients with VI associated
with the most common eye diseases were recruited from the Singapore National Eye
Centre. VI was classified as mild and moderate/severe VI based on the presenting
visual acuity (VA) in the better-seeing eye. Medical costs (MC) and loss of productivity (LP) in the patients and their families were estimated based on the center’s billing
data and self-reported data, respectively. LP was calculated for working patients
based on absenteeism due to VI. Linear regression models were used to assess the
association between costs and VI, generic (EQ-5D), and vision-specific quality of
life (VF-14). Results: The median (range) age of participants was 73.0 years old
(47.0-92.0). The proportion of male was 48.0% and the median (range) presenting
VA was 0.54 (0.30-2.00). The yearly median (range) MC and LP were S$1.53K (S$0.13S$83.59K) and S$0 (S$0-S$7.62K) per person, respectively. The yearly MC for those
with mild VI (S$3.50K) was significantly lower than those with moderate/severe VI
(S$5.21K) (P< 0.0001). The yearly MC in participants reporting full health or better
vision function were lower than those not in full health or better vision function
(e. g. MC for participants in full health= S$2.96K; MC for participants not in full
health= S$5.19K; P< 0.0001). After adjusting for socio-demographic characteristics,
the association between MC and VI, EQ-5D and VF-14 remained the same. LP had a
similar association with EQ-5D and VF-14 with or without adjustment; however, LP
A606
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
decreased with VI severity (the adjusted difference in LP between participants with
mild and moderate/severe VI= S$0.22K, P= 0.3846). Conclusions: Visual impairment poses substantial economic burden on individuals and families in Singapore.
The economic burden of VI is mainly medical costs. Self-reported health problems
seem to be better predictors of costs of VI than clinical measures.
PSS13
Costs of Burn Care: A Systematic Review
Hop M J 1, Polinder S 2, Middelkoop E 3, van Baar M E 1
of Dutch Burn Centres, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 2Erasmus MC, Rotterdam, The
Netherlands, 3Association of Dutch Burn Centres, Beverwijk, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Association
Objectives: Burn care is traditionally considered expensive care. However, detailed
information about the costs of burn care is scarce, despite the increased need for this
information and the enhanced focus on health care cost control. In this study, economic literature on burn care was systematically reviewed to examine the problem
of burn-related costs. Methods: Cost or economic evaluation studies on burn care
that had been published in international peer-reviewed journals from 1950-2012
were identified. The methodology of these articles was critically appraised by two
reviewers, and cost results were extracted. Results: A total of 156 studies met the
inclusion criteria. Nearly all of the studies were cost studies (n= 153) with a health
care perspective (n=139) from high income countries (n=127). Hospital charges were
often used as a proxy for costs (n= 44). Three studies were cost-effectiveness analyses. The mean total health care cost per burn patient in high-income countries was
$88,218 (range $704- $717,306, median $44,024). Conclusions: A wide variety of
methodological approaches and cost prices was found. We recommend that cost
studies and economic evaluations employ a standard approach to improve the
quality and harmonization of economic evaluation studies, optimize comparability
and improve insight into burn care costs and efficiency.
PSS14
Costs of Psoriasis in Europe. A Systematic Review of the Literature
Obradors M 1, Figueras M 1, Paz S 2, Comellas M 3, Lizán L 3
Farmaceutica S. A., Barcelona, Spain, 2Outcomes’10, Castellon, Spain, 3Outcomes 10,
Castellon, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
1Novartis
Objectives: To appraise the literature referred to direct and indirect costs of psoriasis in Europe. Methods: A systematic review of the literature was performed.
Electronic databases [MedLine/PubMed, Scopus, Cochrane Library, ISI Wok, MEDES,
IBECS, CSIC] and Google Scholar were searched to identify publications referred
to direct and indirect costs of psoriasis in Europe. Bibliographic references were
hand searched. European studies published in English or Spanish until October
2013 were selected. Economic evaluations of specific drugs and of preventive or
diagnostic interventions were excluded. Costs were updated to € , 2013. Results:
12 studies were reviewed (4 German, 2 Swedish, 2 Italian, 1 Dutch, 1
French, 1 English and 1 Spanish). From the social perspective, the mean
annual cost of psoriasis in Europe was heterogeneous and varied between
€ 1,340.25 (Spain) and € 8,253.74 (Italy), mainly due to differences of study
sample characteristics, methodology used and national health system
features. The highest proportion (68%-82.5%) of total costs was attributable to direct costs (hospitalizations, medications and laboratory tests).
The annual total cost of severe psoriasis was, at least, 2.5 fold superior to the costs
of mild disease, mostly because of a more frequent use of hospital resources and
loss of productivity. Out-of-pocket expenditure ranged from € 480.67 to € 797.00,
being mostly explained by the use of dermatological products (OTC) (29%-59.7%)
and alternative therapies (balnerotherapies) (24%-49%). The initiation of biologic
therapies implied reductions of up to 76% on the length of hospital stay and up to
98% hospital admissions, contributing to a decline of inpatient cost [€ 2,357.30 (SD:
722.29) vs. € 564.19 (SD: 257.62); p= 0.005; UK]. Conclusions: Costs results vary
across European countries. Severe psoriasis is a costly disease. The use of biologic
agents may contribute to a more efficient management of severe psoriasis due to
a more steady control of symptoms that improve clinical outcomes and decrease
the needs for hospital care and inpatient cost.
PSS15
Economic Burden of Eye Disease in Diabetic Patients: Literature
Review
Riera M 1, Granell M 2, Sarycheva A 2, Roura M 2
Consultant, Molina de Segura, Spain, 2Novartis Farmaceutica, Barcelona, Spain
.
.
.
.
1Independent
Objectives: To provide a literature overview on the costs of diabetic complications
focused on the economic burden of Diabetic Macular Edema (DME) and associated
vision loss and blindness. Methods: Literature searches in PubMed (including
Medline) and Embase were conducted to identify economic data related to diabetic
retinopathy, macular edema, blindness and low vision. Posterior filters included
year of publication (from 2000 to May 2014), country (Canada, USA or Europe) and
English language. Relevant full text articles were reviewed and major findings summarized. Results: A total of 468 citations from 5 different searches were retrieved
and 16 studies fulfilled the criteria to be summarized in this review. Microvascular
diabetic complications were found to be frequent and led to a 70% increase in
direct costs compared to patients with no complications. When microvascular and
macrovascular complications were given together, management costs increased
by up to 250%. Eye disease was associated with a 2,5 ratio of extra cost compared
to diabetic patients without complications, with DME incurring in twice to 3 times
higher costs related to Diabetic Retinopathy. Direct costs of DME accounted for
65-80% of total costs, with 73% of those being associated to hospital expenditure.
Data on the economic burden of visual impairment and blindness were limited:
vision loss had an annual per capita financial cost of $19.370 in Canada (2007);
including the value of lost wellbeing, the annual cost of vision loss was $33.704
per patient. Conclusions: DME appears to be a costly complication of diabetes.
Progression to visual impairment and blindness can lead to high economic and
social burden.
PSS16
Cost-Analysis of Chronic Idiopathic Urticaria Disease
Tatar M 1, Senturk A 2, Ergin G 2, Tuna E 2, Mat C 3, Bulbul Baskan E 4, Artuz F 5, Gurer M A 6,
Atakan N 7, Inaloz S 8, Sezen S 9, Keskinaslan A 9, Saylan M 9
1Hacettepe University, Ankara, Turkey, 2Polar Polar Health Economics & Policy, Ankara, Turkey,
3Cerrahpasa Medical Faculty, Istanbul, Turkey, 4Uludag Medical Faculty, Bursa, Turkey, 5Ankara
Numune research and Training Hosptial, Ankara, Turkey, 6Gazi University Medical Faculty,
Ankara, Turkey, 7Hacettepe University Faculty of Medicine, Ankara, Turkey, 8Gaziantep University
Medical Faculty, Gaziantep, Turkey, 9Novartis Pharma, Istanbul, Turkey
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Chronic idiopathic (or spontaneous) urticaria (CIU) is estimated to
occur in 0.3% of the general population in Turkey. Although the burden of the disease is substantial for the payer, there has been no cost-analysis performed in our
country. The purposes of this study are to determine the resources and costs related
to the diagnosis and treatment of patients with CIU, and to estimate the annual economic burden to the Social Security Institution (SGK). Methods: Delphi technique
was applied to determine the type and the amount of resources used in different
stages of CIU defined as mild or moderate to severe based on physicians clinical
assessment. The Delphi method solicits the opinion of an expert panel through a
carefully designed questionnaire which in this case included questions on: epidemiology, diagnosis, treatment of symptoms and angioedema, adverse events,
follow-up visits, hospital and emergency service admissions. The responses were
analysed and discussed in a face to face meeting followed by consensus building
steps. Unit of resources used for different CIU severity levels were determined from
expert opinion. Unit costs of resources used in outpatient clinics were obtained
from SGK’s Reimbursement Guideline-List of Procedure Fees Per Service. Results:
Hospitalizations, emergency admissions, outpatient visits and treatments, are the
key cost drivers in the management of CIU The annual cost per patient is calculated to be 725.36 Turkish Liras (TL) for mild CIU, 1.322,61 TL for moderate CIU and
2,478.75 TL for severe CIU. The total annual cost of CIU to SGK is estimated to be 262
million TL in 2014. Conclusions: This is the first study that aims to estimate the
resource utilisation and cost burden of CIU in Turkey by using the Delphi technique.
Cost effective treatment of CIU is an unmet need given the heavy burden to SGK
identified by the Delphi Panel.
PSS17
The Direct and Indirect Costs of Wet Age-Related Macular
Degeneration (Wamd) and Diabetic Macular Edema (Dme) in Greece
Geitona M 1, Karagiannis D 2, Pantelopoulou G 3, Hatzikou M 3, Kousoulakou H 1
of Peloponnese, Corinth, Greece, 2Eye Hospital of Athens, Athens, Greece, 3Novartis
Hellas, Metamorfosis, Greece
.
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: Treatment delays in patients with wAMD and DME are very important since they are associated with disease progression. This is the first study in
Greece to highlight patient’s access delays’ to treatment and to estimate the burden
of diseases in Greece. Methods: An expert panel with 11 ophthalmologists was
convened. The experts came from six out of seven Regional Health Authorities,
covering geographically the largest part of the country. A 13-page questionnaire
was developed and validated. The Delphi technique was used to collect data on
resource use and disease management, patient access delays, and indirect costs.
Unit costs were retrieved from NHS sources and the analysis was conducted from
the societal perspective, including direct costs incurred by patients, their families
and the health care system, and indirect costs, of productivity losses. Results:
Total cost of managing wAMD during the first year of treatment was estimated at
€ 20,660,32.8% of which consisted of direct costs (drug acquisition and administration, follow-up, lab and imaging tests), and 67.2% of which included non-medical
and indirect costs (caregivers). Direct medical cost per DME patient for the first year
of treatment was estimated at €6,066, while the non-medical and indirect costs were
estimated at € 12,271, resulting in a total cost of € 18,337 per patient per year. 91% of
the experts agreed that there are significant delays in patient access to specific treatments (average 20 days); all agreed (100%) that these delays lead to faster disease
progression, and a strong majority (>80%) supported that they lead to deterioration
of patients’ QoL. Conclusions: There are significant costs associated with the
management of wAMD and DME in Greece, 70% of which is incurred by patients and
their families. Administrative procedures leading to patient access delays should be
minimized in order to avoid disease progression and associated costs.
PSS18
Economic Burden of Burn Injuries in the Netherlands
Hop J M 1, Wijnen B F M 2, Nieuwenhuis M 3, Dokter J 1, Middelkoop E 4, Polinder S 5, van Baar
ME1
of Dutch Burn Centres, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 2Maastricht University,
Maastricht, The Netherlands, 3Association of Dutch Burn Centres, Groningen, The Netherlands,
4Association of Dutch Burn Centres, Beverwijk, The Netherlands, 5Erasmus MC, Rotterdam, The
Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Association
Objectives: Burn care has rapidly improved in the past decades. However, health
care innovations can be expensive, demanding careful choices on their implementation. Obtaining knowledge on the extent of the costs of burn injuries is an essential
first step for economic evaluations within burn care. The objective of this study was
to determine the economic burden of patients with burns admitted to a burn center
and to identify important cost categories until three months post-burn. Methods:
A prospective cohort study was conducted in the burn center of Maasstad Hospital
Rotterdam, the Netherlands, including all patients with acute burn related injuries
from August 2012 until July 2013. Total costs were calculated from a societal perspective, until three months post injury. Subgroup analyses were performed to examine
whether the mean total costs per patient differed by age, etiology or percentage
total body surface area (TBSA) burned. Results: In our population, with a mean
burn size of 8%, mean total costs were € 24,246 per patient varying from € 11,498 to
€ 71,756. Most important cost categories were burn center days, surgical interventions and work absence. Flame burns were significantly more costly than other types
of burns, adult patients were significantly more costly than children and adolescents
A607
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
and a higher percentage TBSA burned also corresponded to significantly higher
costs. Conclusions: Mean total costs of burn care in the first three months post
injury were estimated at € 24,246 and depended on age, etiology and TBSA. Mean
total costs in our population probably apply for other high-income countries as well,
although we should realize that patients with burn injuries are diverse and represent a broad range of total costs. To reduce costs of burn care, future intervention
studies should focus on reducing length of stay and enabling an early return to work.
PSS19
The Cost of Blindness in the Republic of Ireland 2010-2020
Green D 1, O Neill C 2, Ducorroy G 1, Skelly A 1, Keegan D 3, Kenny D 4, Naughton A 3,
Keegan D 3
1Novartis Ireland, Dublin 4, Ireland, 2National University of Ireland, Galway, Galway, Ireland,
3Mater Misericordiae Ubiversity Hospital, Dublin, Ireland, 4National Council for the Blind Ireland,
Dublin, Ireland
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Aims The aim of this study is to estimate the prevalence of blindness in the Republic of Ireland and estimate the financial and economic cost of
blindness between 2010 and 2020. Methods: The prevalence of blindness was
based on the National Council for the Blind of Ireland blind register and adjusted
for under registration found in previous literature. The financial cost of blindness was based on the sum of total direct and indirect health care costs (direct
health care costs due to blindness, cost of depression due to blindness, cost of
injurious falls due to blindness) and non-health care costs (productivity losses,
informal care and deadweight welfare loss). Where possible, methods adopted
reflect those used elsewhere in the literature. Results: The total financial cost
of blindness in the ROI is estimated to have been € 276. million in 2010. This is
projected to increase by 32.6% to € 367 million in 2020 if current trends in disease
burden continue. The total economic cost of blindness in the ROI is estimated to
be € 809 million in 2010 and is predicted to increase to over € 1.1 billion in 2020
based on current trends. Conclusions: A significant proportion of blindness
can be avoided through the implementation of existing technologies by the
health service. However a significant portion (98.04%) of the burden of illness
falls beyond the health service (primarily to the Department of Social Protection
and the Department of Finance) and may serve to reducethe priority of policies
aimed at avoiding blindness that might otherwise be received.
PSS20
Cost-of-Illness Study of Senile Cataract in the Czech Republic
Kruntoradova I 1, Kruntorádová K 2, Rogalewicz V 2, Barták M 3
1Charles University, Kladno, Czech Republic, 2Czech Technical University in Prague, Kladno, Czech
Republic, 3University of J.E.Purkyn? in Ústí nad Labem, Ústí nad Labem, Czech Republic
.
.
.
.
Cost-of-illness study of senile cataract in the Czech RepublicIlona Kruntorádová,
Klára Kruntorádová, Vladimír Rogalewicz, Miroslav Barták. Objectives: In the
Czech Republic, 7% of patients with senile cataract are indicated for surgery each
year, which means ten thousand of interventions annually. The aim of this study
is to quantify direct costs in relation to the implanted intraocular lens type from
both the public health insurance perspective and the patient’s perspective. The
senile cataract surgery with monofocal IOL is covered by public health insurance. Methods: Direct costs were calculated through a panel of experts that provided expert opinions, taking into account consumption of paid medical services
provided to patients. The panel consisted of 6 experts (4 physicians from eye clinics,
2 physicians from outpatient departments). Patient´s costs were obtained through
a patient questionnaire asking the direct (out-of-pocket) expenses associated with
the cataract. The study covered a cohort of 200 patients with senile cataract in
non-productive age (65+). Data were collected from 4 clinics performing cataract
surgery. Results: The structure of direct costs associated with senile cataract,
its surgery, and treatment of possible complications has been specified. Direct
costs of senile cataract surgery from the perspective of public health insurance
are CZK24900 (»EUR907) per person. Patient´s direct costs are lower for monofocal
lenses than for multifocal ones. Patients’ costs for an IOL and the related treatment
reach up to CZK35000 (»EUR1275), out of pocket expenses after treatment average
out at CZK4450 (»EUR162). Conclusions: Due to absence of laws governing medical care premium services and the age of patients, monofocal IOLs are implanted
predominantly. As a consequence, up to CZK 30 million (»EUR 1 1 million) are saved
on the public health insurance budget annually. Patients´ expenses for implanting
multifocal lenses are offset by savings due to unrealized spending for eyeglasses
and related medical care in the course of time.
PSS21
Costs of Dental Outpatient Care – Resource Use Differentials
Across Clinical Dentistry Branches
Rancic J 1, Rancic N 2, Majstorovic N 3, Biocanin V 4, Milosavljevic M 4, Jakovljevic M 4
Dentistry Clinic Dr D. Lopicic, Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro, 2Military Medical
Academy University of Defence Belgrade, Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro, 3The Faculty of
Dentistry University of Belgrade, Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro, 4The Faculty of Medical
Sciences University of Kragujevac, Kragujevac, Serbia and Montenegro
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Specialist
Objectives: Dental medical care bears particular financial burden for Eastern
European transitional economies due to its lack of insurance coverage in most
countries of the region and almost complete out-of-pocket payments by citizens.
This study estimates real costs of these services in the field and describe resource
use patterns and differentials across clinical dentistry branches, ICD-10 diagnostic
groups, and across particular medical services. Methods: In a case-series design
prospective cost-comparison study has been conducted from the perspective of
the patient. Sample size was 752 complete episodes of treatment, selected randomly in 2012/2013 throughout an array of several specialist state-owned (university
associated) and private-owned dental clinics in upper-middle income Serbia. All
direct medical costs of dental care were taken into account. Costs were expressed
in national currency Republican Serbian Dinar (RSD). Results: Mean total direct
medical costs of dental care were 5,018.96±17,109.61RSD per single dentist visit
while total costs incurred by this population sample were 3,774,256RSD. Highest
unit utilization of services belongs to conservative dentistry (31.9%), oral surgery
(19.5%) and radiology (17.4%), while highest value based turnover belongs to implantology 90,765.33±43,012.31RSD, orthodontics 77,361.82±73,123.92RSD and prosthetics 60873.89±26788.87RSD. Most frequently treated diagnosis was tooth decay
(33.8% unit services provided), pulpitis (11.2%) and impacted teeth (8.5%), while
most expensive to treat were anomalies of tooth position (70,998.33±73122.73RSD),
abnormalities of size and form of teeth (55,662.50±77,304.45RSD) and loss of teeth
due to accident, extraction or local periodontal disease (36,835.35±37,128.28RSD).
Conclusions: Although range of dental medical costs currently falls behind EU
average, Serbia’s emerging economy is likely to expand in the long run while market
demand for dental services will grow. Due to threatened financial sustainability of
current health insurance patterns in Eastern Europe, getting acquainted with true
size and structure of dental care costs might essentially support informed decision
making in future.
PSS22
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Ustekinumab Compared With
Etanercept for the Treatment of Moderate to Severe Psoriasis in
Costa Rica
Obando C A , Desanvicente-Celis Z , Herrera J A , Moreira M , De Castro J
Janssen, Panama, Panama
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess the cost-effectiveness of Ustekinumab (UST) compared with Etanercept (ETN) in Costa Rica, in patients with Moderate to Severe
Psoriasis. Methods: A cohort simulation Markov Model was developed based on
response rates for UST and ETN [Psoriasis Area Severity Index (PASI) ]. The time
frame was 10 years. The perspective was that of the Public System of Health of
Costa Rica. The health outcome of interest was Quality Adjusted Life Years (QALYs).
Efficacy data was taken from the ACCEPT clinical trial; this phase III clinical trial
directly compares UST and ETN, what strongly supports the efficacy data that is
used in the model. Utilities for health states were taken from published studies.
The base year was 2013. All costs are presented in Costa Rican currency (Colones –
CRC). Costs and outcomes were discounted at 3.5%. Probabilistic sensitivity analysis
(PSA) was conducted to assess uncertainty around the parameters. Results: UST
resulted in 3.85 QALYs and ETN in 3.58, per patient, respectively. Mean total costs
per patient were: CRC 8.441.031 for UST and CRC 5.401.222 for ETN. UST resulted
both more costly and more effective than ETN. The Incremental Cost Effectiveness
Ratio comparing UST and ETN was 11.142.470 per QALY Gained. According to the
classification of the World Health Organization (WHO), the acceptable threshold for
QALY Gained for Costa Rica is CRC 14.140.792 (3 times the Gross Domestic Product
per capita). The results of the probabilistic sensitivity analysis showed that, at the
threshold suggested by the WHO, the probability of UST of being cost effective,
compared with ETN is around 70%. Conclusions: UST can be considered cost
effective when compared to ETN, according to the threshold suggested by the WHO,
in patients with moderate to severe Psoriasis, from the perspective of the Public
System of Health of Costa Rica.
PSS23
Cost-Effectiveness of Ranibizumab on Patients With Diffuse
Diabetic Macular Edema Within the Public Mexican Health Care
System
Ruiz Miranda C I , Ubiarco Lopez V
Novartis Mexico, Mexico, Mexico
.
.
.
Objectives: To perform a cost-effectiveness analysis of Ranibizumab plus laser
photocoagulation vs monotherapy with laser photocoagulation in patients with
diffuse Diabetic Macular Edema (DME). Methods: A Markov model was designed
to analyze laser Photocoagulation vs laser Photocoagulation plus Ranibizumab.
Transition probabilities were obtained from RESTORE. The base patient was a diabetic with 53 years presenting DME, according to Mexican context. General mortality
rates were elicited locally from CONAPO*. A panel Delphi was performed to get use
of resources locally. The time horizon was 5, 7, and 10 (lifetime) years according
to life expectancy from ENSANUT** 2013, discount rate 5%. The outcome was life
years without visual impairment. The cost values were from Guidelines for the
Exchange of Services in the Health Sector. Probabilistic sensitivity analysis (PSA) was
performed using Monte Carlo technique. Results: Incremental Cost Effectiveness
Ratios of the combination versus the monotherapy were: $5,019.57, $2,375.62 and
$622.67 USD per life year without visual impairment in a time horizon of 5, 7 years
and lifetime. Cost effectiveness curve showed Ranibizumab be a cost effective
option at 98.7% vs monotherapy before reaching the GDP per capita. Conclusions:
Ranibizumab demonstrated to be a more cost-effectiveness alternative than monotherapy with laser photocoagulation. These results show the possibility of achieving potential clinical benefit with Ranibizumab in patients suffering from loss of
vision. *CONAPO National Council of Population **ENSANUT National Health and
Nutrition Survey
PSS24
Modeled Outcomes and Overall Costs of the 13-Valent
Pneumococcal Conjugate Vaccine in the Tunisian National
Vaccination Program
Zigmond J 1, Pecen L 1, Tichopad A 1, Roberts C S 2, Jomaa I 3
1CEEOR s. r. o., Prague, Czech Republic, 2Pfizer Inc., New York, NY, USA, 3Pfizer Pharmaceuticals
Tunisia, Tunis, Tunisia
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Like other North African countries, Tunisia has a substantial burden of
pneumococcal disease, with high resistance to antibiotics. The Tunisian population
remains largely unprotected in the absence of a national immunization program
(NIP). Methods: A decision-analytic model was developed to evaluate the potential
outcomes and costs of the PCV13-based NIP compared to no vaccination. The model
estimates bacteremia and meningitis (jointly IPD), all-cause community acquired
pneumonia (CAP), and all-cause otitis media (OM). The demographics and disease
A608
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
characteristics were obtained from WHO estimates or local sources, adjusted to
local conditions. PCV13 direct and indirect effectiveness was extrapolated from
PCV7 trials and surveillance records, adjusted to local serotype distribution. Cost
of vaccine was USD 16.34. A discount rate for cost and life-years was 3%. The payer
and societal perspectives were considered. Results: The budget impact in a single year with PCV13-based NIP in place would amount to USD 1.82 million, or USD
7.93 million without indirect vaccine protection considered. From this investment,
141 971 illnesses (1071 IPDs, 12477 CAPs and 128423 OMs) and 347 deaths could be
avoided annually. Without indirect vaccine protection, 58 524 illnesses (601 IPD, 4721
CAP, 53202 OM) and 184 deaths could be avoided. The cost-effectiveness analysis
produced ICER of USD 340/LYG or USD 367/QALY from the payer’s perspective. From
the societal perspective, the NIP is dominant. Not considering indirect protection,
the ICER would be USD 140/LYG or USD 152/QALY from a societal perspective and
USD 1157/LYG or USD 1254/QALY from a payer perspective. Conclusions: PCV13based NIP delivers benefits and cost savings that greatly offset the investment into
vaccine. WHO strongly encourages investment in interventions that deliver an additional year of life in full quality for less than one GDP per capita (USD 4237); hence,
a PCV13-based NIP with the above ICER presents an attractive option.
PSS25
Ranibizumab for the Treatment of Visual Impairment Due to
Myopic Choroidal Neovascularization: Cost-Effectiveness Versus
Aflibercept
Leteneux C 1, Haig J 2, Xue W 3, Bhattacharyya S 4
1Novartis Pharma AG, Basel, Switzerland, 2Optum, Burlington, ON, Canada, 3Optum, Uxbridge,
UK, 4Novartis Healthcare Pvt. Ltd., Hyderabad, India
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Ranibizumab has demonstrated efficacy in patients with myopic
choroidal neovascularization (mCNV) and is the first anti-VEGF licensed in this
indication. Aflibercept is being evaluated for use in mCNV. An existing model demonstrating the cost-effectiveness of ranibizumab versus verteporfin photodynamic
therapy was adapted to provide an initial evaluation of ranibizumab versus aflibercept. Methods: A Markov model in mCNV with a lifetime horizon and visual acuity
health states was adapted to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of ranibizumab and
aflibercept from a UK health care perspective. Baseline characteristics, injection
frequency and ranibizumab efficacy were based on the disease activity treatment
arm from the RADIANCE study (n= 116, Caucasian, Indian and East Asian patients).
Data for aflibercept were derived from initial results for the aflibercept treatment
arm from the MYRROR study (n= 90, East Asian patients only). Relative efficacy
was assessed by indirect comparison. An evaluation using the East Asian subgroup
of the ranibizumab disease activity treatment arm in RADIANCE (n= 35) was also
conducted. Results: Ranibizumab dominated aflibercept in both evaluations.
Based on the disease activity arm from RADIANCE, ranibizumab was associated
with a lower lifetime cost (incremental cost -£1770) and higher lifetime qualityadjusted life-years (QALYs) (incremental gain 0.02) than aflibercept. Results were
similar for the evaluation based on the East Asian subgroup. Ranibizumab was
associated with a lower lifetime cost (incremental cost -£2856) and higher lifetime
QALYs (incremental gain 0.06) than aflibercept. These results were driven by the
greater number of injections, higher treatment and recurrence costs, and smaller
proportion of patients gaining ≥ 20 letters visual acuity for aflibercept compared
with ranibizumab. Conclusions: This initial analysis suggests that ranibizumab
is less costly and is associated with a gain in QALYs relative to aflibercept based on
the disease activity arm and the East Asian subgroup from RADIANCE, as well as
initial data from MYRROR.
PSS26
Cost-Effectiveness of Aflibercept in the Treatment of Macular
Oedema Secondary to Central Retinal Vein Occlusion In Sweden
Eriksson M 1, Castelo-Branco A 2, Nilsson J 2
1Bayer AB, Solna, Sweden, 2OptumInsight, Stockholm, Sweden
.
.
.
Objectives: Central retinal vein occlusion (CRVO) is caused by a blood clot in the
central retinal vein, which slows or stops blood from leaving the retina. As a result,
blood and fluids can accumulate, causing retinal injury and vision loss. Thus, a
major complication in eyes with CRVO is macular oedema (ME) and is the primary
factor for poor visual acuity and visual fields in non-ischemic CRVO. A global costeffectiveness model was developed and adopted to estimate effects and associated costs, in Sweden, for treatment of ME secondary to CRVO with aflibercept
compared to ranibizumab. Methods: A Markov model was developed, including
health states that reflect the clinical treatment and disease progression/regression
of the ME. The simulated patient population consisted of adults treated for ME
secondary to CRVO with an average starting-age of 64 years. Patients were treated
and monitored for two years and followed for 15 years in the base case. Treatment
regimens were taken from clinical trials with aflibercept (GALILEO & COPERNICUS)
and ranibizumab (CRUISE & HORIZON), with 8.2 vs. 8.8 injections the first year and
2.9 vs. 3.5 injections the second year, respectively. Results: Aflibercept can be
regarded as a cost-effective, i. e. dominating, treatment-alternative compared to
ranibizumab as aflibercept is both less costly (total incremental cost of more than
-35,000 SEK) and more effective (total incremental QALYs of 0.061) than ranibizumab. Due to the more treatments, ranibizumab had higher drug (incremental
cost: -8,537 SEK) and administration (incremental cost: -5,793 SEK) costs compared
to aflibercept. Probabilistic sensitivity analysis showed that aflibercept was dominating over ranibizumab in 70% of the simulations. Conclusions: Aflibercept
is more cost-effective than ranibizumab for the treatment of ME secondary to
CRVO in Sweden.
PSS27
Cost-Effectiveness of Laser Doppler Imaging in Burn Care in The
Netherlands; A Randomised Controlled Trial
Hop M J 1, Stekelenburg C 2, Hiddingh J 3, Kuipers H 3, Goei H 1, Middelkoop E 4, Nieuwenhuis
M 3, Polinder S 5, van Baar M E 1
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Association of Dutch Burn Centres, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 2Association of Dutch Burn
Centres, Beverwijk, The Netherlands, 3Association of Dutch Burn Centres, Groningen, The
Netherlands, 4VU University Medical Centre, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 5Erasmus MC,
Rotterdam, The Netherlands
Objectives: In patients with burns an early accurate diagnosis of burn depth is
essential to determine optimal treatment. The combination of Laser Doppler imaging
(LDI) and clinical assessment leads to an accurate estimate of burn depth. However,
the actual effects of the introduction of LDI on therapeutic decisions, clinical outcomes and costs are unknown. The aim of our study was to analyse the effectiveness
and cost-effectiveness of LDI in burn care. The effects of LDI on decision-making,
clinical outcomes, costs, and cost-effectiveness were assessed. Methods: A randomised controlled trial was conducted in all three Dutch burn centres, including subsequent patients with burns of indeterminate depth. In the standard care
(SC) group, burn depth and treatment choices were based on clinical assessment
only, in the other group (LDI) clinical assessment and LDI results were combined.
Primary outcome was the effect of the introduction of LDI on wound healing time.
The economic evaluation was performed from a societal perspective with a bottom
up approach, following the micro-costing method. Results: Mean time to wound
healing from randomisation was 14.3 days in the LDI group and 15.5 days in the SC
group (p= 0.258). In the subgroup of clinical patients requiring surgery earlier decision for surgery and a shorter wound healing time were observed in the LDI group
(16.0 versus 19.9 days, p= 0.029). Mean total costs per patient were € 18 549 versus
€ 18 896 (p= 0.837). Conclusions: LDI proved to provide guidance for therapeutic
decisions with a significantly shorter wound healing time in the subgroup of clinical
patients requiring surgery. When time to surgery can be reduced by 2.4 days, similar
to the time to decision for surgery in our study, cost savings of € 794 per scanned
patient can be achieved.
PSS28
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Ingenolo Mebutato VersUS miquimod
in the Treatment of Actinic Keratoses in the Perspective of the
Italian Health System
Di Matteo S 1, Colombo G L 2, Pellacani G 3, Bruno G M 1
e Valutazioni economiche, Milan, Italy, 2University of Pavia, Milan, Italy,
3Università degli Studi di Modena e Reggio Emilia, Modena, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
.
1S. A. V. E. Studi Analisi
Objectives: Actinic Keratosis (AK) is the most common neoplastic lesion of the
skin, its prevalence in Italy is 1.4% in the adult population, over the age of 45
years. The objective of this study is to evaluate through the development of a
decision-tree model, the impact in terms of cost-effectiveness of treatment of
patients with actinic keratosis (on the face), of ingenolo mebutato gel vs. imiquimod cream. Methods: The effectiveness was expressed in terms of utility; the
ratio of cost effectiveness was expressed in terms of cost per Quality Adjusted Life
Years (QALYs). The time horizon of the simulation was 12 months. For ingenolo
mebutato was considered the price to the public starting from the ex-factory price
currently lower in Europe (Spain price), while for imiquimod has been adopted
the reference price, because of the drug generication. It was also considered the
adherence rate of patients to the two treatment alternatives, due to the different
duration of treatment (2-3 days Vs. 4-8 weeks) and adverse events, which in the
case of imiquimod may persist for all the therapy lenght. Results: Based on
these assumptions, ingenolo mebutato therapy is found to be less expensive and
more effective, and so dominant, compared to imiquimod. The cost-effectiveness
analysis has been tested with univariate sensitivity analysis, which confirmed
the validity of the base case. Conclusions: Based on these statement, it seems
clear that ingenolo mebutato, due to its way of administration combined with its
expected cost, represents a rational investment for the treatment of AK in the
landscape of our national health system.
PSS29
Cost-Effectiveness of 13-Valent Versus 10-Valent Pneumococcal
Conjugate Vaccine Use in Croatia National Vaccination Program
Tichopad A 1, Pecen L 1, Roberts C S 2, Uglesic L 3, Tesovic G 4, Rogier K 5
s. r. o., Prague, Czech Republic, 2Pfizer Inc., New York, NY, USA, 3Pfizer Croatia d. o. o.,
Zagreb, Croatia, 4University of Zagreb Medical School, Zagreb, Croatia, 5Pfizer bv, Capelle a/d
IJssel, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1CEEOR
Objectives: The national immunization program (NIP) on a voluntary basis
started in 2010 in Croatia, including the 10-valent PCV10 and the 13-valent PCV13.
We compare the cost-effectiveness of PCV10 and PCV13 use in the NIP. Methods:
A Markov model was developed to examine cost-effectiveness of PCV13 versus
PCV10 from the payer’s perspective in 10 years. The simulated diseases were invasive pneumococcal disease (bacteremia and meningitis), all-cause community
acquired pneumonia (CAP), and all-cause acute otitis media (AOM). Direct effectiveness was extrapolated from PCV7 clinical trials, adjusted by local serotype.
Indirect effect (IE) was extrapolated from the US surveillance data following universal PCV7 use. Vaccine prices per dose for PCV10 and PCV13 were € 45.16 and
€ 47.71, respectively. The epidemiology inputs were based on national sources or
adopted from neighboring Slovenia. Costs were obtained from local reimbursement lists and the DRG system. The IE for PCV10 was separately taken at 0%,
50% and 100% level. Results: Compared to PCV10 with presumed no IE, PCV13
could avoid additional 985 IPD cases, 15583 cases of inpatient and 26481 cases of
outpatient CAP, and 53555 AOM cases, whereas for modeled 50% IE of PCV10 only
679,10568,17 641 and 35026 cases would be avoided, and for modeled 100% IE of
PCV10 372,5552,8798,16498 cases would be avoided, respectively. There would be
2778 or 1958 or, 1137 deaths avoided, respectively. PCV13 compared to PCV10 with
assumed no IE leads to € 3.060 million more spent on vaccination and € 28.585 million saved, giving thus overall saving € 25.524 million in 10 years. Conclusions:
The cost-effectiveness analysis showed PCV10 to be dominated by PCV13 by its
overall lower costs and higher number of QALY as well as LYG gained, regardless of the IE level. The results were most sensitive to the cost and incidence of
hospitalized pneumonia.
A609
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PSS30
Cost-Effectiveness of Ranibizumab Versus Photodynamic
Therapy for the Treatment of Neovascluar Age-Related Macular
Degeneration Based in China Cost Setting
Feng S 1, Ying X 1, Qi F 1, Chang J 2
1Fudan University, China, Shanghai, China, 2Beijing Novartis Pharma Co., Ltd, Beijing, China
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To compare ranibizumab with photodynamic therapy (PDT) for
the treatment of predominantly classic chorodial neovascularization associated
with age-related macular degeneration (AMD) by means of cost-utility analysis in
China. Methods: This study compared cost-effectiveness between Ranibizumab
group (each delivering 0.5 mg of ranibizuamb monthly) and PDT group for the first
year (short-term) using decision tree model, from third-payer perspective. During
a 10-year time horizon (long-term), a Markov model was constructed to extrapolate
effects of treatment beyond clinical trials from a societal perspective (discounted at
5%). Visual acuity data from the Anti-Vascular Endothelial Growth Factor Antibody
for the Treatment of Predominantly Classic Choroidal Neovascularization in AMD
(ANCHOR) trial were applied. Direct-vision-related medical costs were based on
Clinical Pathway of AMD in China and experts consultation. We performed a literature review and meta-analysis to estimate the costs related to comorbid states,
including fall and depression resulting from low vision after suffer from AMD, which
were rarely inclusive in most previous studies. Informal care costs and utilities data
were derived from published studies. All costs were adjusted according to 2012 price
index in China. Probabilistic sensitivity analyses (PSA) were performed to test the
robustness in structural assumptions and parameter inputs. Cost-effective acceptability curves were performed after a 1000-sample Monte Carlo simulation. Results:
In short-term model, the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) was $81,029/
QALY for ranibizumab compared with PDT. The ICER was reduced to $13,206/QALY
for a 10-year time frame, when follow-up costs were included. From a societal perspective, PSA revealed a 97.75% probability of ranibizuamb being more cost-effective
than PDT at a threshold of $18,278 per QALY gained (3 times Chinese GDP per capita
in 2012) in China. Conclusions: Ranibizumab can be a long-term cost-effective
option for the treatment of AMD compared with PDT from a societal perspective.
PSS31
Cost-Utility Analysis of Recommended Ranibizumab Regimen for AgeRelated Macular Degeneration in China
Ying X 1, Feng S 1, Wu W 1, Chang J 2
1Fudan University, China, Shanghai, China, 2Beijing Novartis Pharma Co., Ltd, Beijing, China
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To conduct the cost-utility analysis (CUA) of treatment strategy with
ranibizumab recommended by the Chinese Clinical Pathway of age-related macular degeneration (AMD) in China. Methods: Visual acuity data for the as-needed
dosing regimen with ranibizumab (RBZ-PRN, administrated every month for three
doses, additional reinjections were determined by physicians’ need) were derived
from pivotal trials, based on ranibizumab dose of 0.5 mg. Decision tree model and
Markov model were developed to estimate RBZ-PRN compared with best supportive
care (BSC) for short and long term. The first year decision tree model from a thirdpayer perspective was performed to estimate CUA in short-term. Then a 10-year
Markov model from a societal perspective were constructed (discounted at 5%) in
long-term CUA estimation. Resource utilization was obtained from official recommendations in China. The costs of low-vision related disease were extrapolated from
meta-analysis. Informal care costs and utility values were estimated by published
studies. The uncertainty was identified in a one-way sensitivity analysis and probabilistic sensitivity analysis (PSA). Cost-effective acceptability curves were obtained
by a Monte Carlo approach with 1000 repetitions. Results: For RBZ-PRN compared
with BSC, the incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICER) ranged from $90,546/QALY
for the 1-year time frame to $9,787/QALY for the 10-year time horizon. As indicated
in the PSA, RBZ-PRN was the optimal strategy in 100% of cases below the willingness
to pay threshold of $18,278 per QALY gained (3 times Chinese GDP per capita in 2012)
for the 10-year model. Conclusions: When administered as needed, ranibizumab
is cost-effective compared with BSC from a societal perspective. In China’s current
clinical practice, this can be a useful tip for decision-makers who should consider
cost-effective issues for the treatment of wet-AMD.
PSS32
Non-Proliferative Diabetic Retinopathy: is It Cost-Effective to Treat
Early?
Mistry H 1, Auguste P 1, Lois N 2, Waugh N 1
of Warwick, Coventry, UK, 2Queen’s University Belfast, Belfast, UK
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: Diabetic retinopathy (DR) is a leading cause of sight loss in people
of working age. There have been recent developments in laser photocoagulation
techniques, along with anti-vascular endothelial growth factor drugs for the
treatment of severe non-proliferative and proliferative DR. The aim of the study
was to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of panretinal photocoagulation administered at the severe non-proliferative diabetic retinopathy (NPDR) stage (early
treatment), compared with waiting until high-risk proliferative (HR-PDR) characteristics (deferred treatment) developed. Methods: A Markov model with a
30-year time horizon was developed, with clinical pathway options for patients
presenting with moderate NPDR through to irreversible-severe vision loss and
blindness (and to death). Once patients entered a post-treatment health state
they can progress to more severe health states, regress back to earlier stages of the
disease, persist where they are, or die. NHS and personal social services perspective was adopted. Transition probabilities were based mainly on data derived from
the Early Treatment Diabetic Retinopathy Study. Health state utilities, costs and
complications were based on information from the literature, supplemented by
expert opinion. Costs and outcomes were discounted at 3.5%. Both deterministic
and probabilistic sensitivity analyses were conducted. Results: Administering
panretinal photocoagulation at the severe NPDR stage was more effective and
less costly than waiting until HR-PDR developed. Sensitivity analyses gave similar
results, with early treatment continuing to dominate deferred treatment. The
probabilistic sensitivity analysis suggests that at willingness-to-pay threshold of
£20-£30,000 per quality-adjusted life year, the probability of early treatment being
cost-effective is 60%. Conclusions: Panretinal photocoagulation administered
at the severe NPDR stage is likely to be cost-effective. However, given the limitations of the evidence on current treatments, these results to be interpreted with
caution. A trial of early versus deferred laser therapy is needed to provide better
data based on modern treatments.
PSS33
Cost-Utility Analysis (Cua) of First-Line Actinic Keratosis (Ak)
Treatments in Finland
Soini E 1, Hallinen T 1, Sokka A L 2, Saarinen K 3
1ESiOR Oy, Kuopio, Finland, 2LEO Pharma Oy, Vantaa, Finland, 3PlusTerveys Oy, Nastola, Finland
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: CUA of cryosurgery, topical treatments (diclofenac 3% 12 weeks,
imiquimod 3.75% 6 weeks or 5% 4/8 weeks, ingenol mebutate gel (IMG) 0.015%/
head 3 days or 0.05%/body 2 days), and methyl aminolevulinate + photodynamic
therapy (MAL+PDT) in the treatment of 25cm2 AK-plague affecting any body
part. Methods: A sequential probabilistic decision-tree with 2-year time-horizon
was used to assess the cost-utility (incremental cost-effectiveness ratio, ICER) of
AK-treatments, and to determine the cost-effectiveness acceptability frontier (CEAF)
and expected value of perfect information per patient (EVPI) from health care payer
perspective. In the model, the first-line AK-treatment resulted in complete clearance
(CC) with or without adverse events (AE), non-CC or AK-recurrence. Non-CC AK was
retreated with PDT and AK-recurrence was retreated with the previous treatment.
Incident AK-patients (year 2009, n= 3409, organ transplant patients excluded) were
identified from the Finnish hospital discharge register to assess AK-related 2-year
secondary health care costs for patients initiating different treatment regimens.
Other costs included general practitioner, AE-management, and outpatient drugs
(5/2014 without VAT; other costs in 2013 value). Quality-adjusted life-years (QALY)
were based on EQ-5D. Results were discounted with 3% annually. Results: The
mean per patient 2-year QALYs (costs) were 1.519 (€727) for IMG 0.015%, 1.518 (€ 887)
for MAL+PDT, 1.516 (€ 802) for IMG 0.05%, 1.514 (€ 995) for diclofenac, 1.512 (€ 815) for
imiquimod 3.75%, 1.511 (€ 707) for imiquimod 5%, and 1.507 (€ 1010) for cryosurgery.
IMG 0.015% had € 2806/QALY gained ICER against imiquimod 5%, and dominated
other AK-treatments. IMG 0.05% dominated diclofenac, imiquimod 3.75% and
cryosurgery, and had € 21,550/QALY gained ICER against imiquimod 5%. MAL+PDT
had € 32,848/QALY gained ICER against IMG 0.05%. Based on the CEAF, IMG 0.015%
was the optimal treatment when willingness-to-pay/QALY gained exceeded € 2806.
The EVPI was € 25/€ 81/€ 211 with the willingness-to-pay of € 0/€ 15,000/€ 30,000 per
QALY gained. Conclusions: IMG 0.015% was the most cost-effective first-line
AK-treatment.
PSS34
Cost-Effectiveness of Ranibizumab VersUS Aflibercept in Treatment
of Treatment of Visual Impairment Due to Diabetic Macular Oedema
(Dmo)
Haig J 1, Regnier S A 2, Malcom W 3, Xue W 4
.
.
.
.
.
1Optum, Burlington, ON, Canada, 2Novartis AG, Basel, Switzerland, 3Novartis
UK LTD, Frimley/
Camberley, Surrey, UK, 4Optum, Uxbridge, UK
Objectives: To estimate the cost-effectiveness of ranibizumab 0.5mg pro re nata
(PRN) compared with aflibercept 2mg bi-monthly in the treatment of visual impairment (VI) due to diabetic macular oedema (DMO) taking a UK health care perspective. Methods: A Markov model previously reviewed by the National Institute for
Health and Care Excellence (NICE) was used to simulate the long-term outcomes
and costs (at 2012 price level) of treating DMO. The health states were defined by
increments of 10 letters in best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA) with a 3-month
cycle length. Patients could gain (or lose), at most, 2 health states between two
cycles. A lifetime time horizon was implemented. Future costs and health outcomes were discounted at 3.5% per annum. Baseline characteristics, ranibizumab
effectiveness and adverse events were estimated with data from the RESTORE trial
(36 months). A published network meta-analysis was used to assess the relative
effectiveness of ranibizumab to aflibercept. Aflibercept injection frequency was
calculated with VIVID/VISTA phase III trials. Different utilities were used if the
treated eye was the better or the worse-seeing eye. Results: Ranibizumab monotherapy leads to an incremental gain of 0.05 quality-adjusted life-years (QALY)
(0.04 from the better-seeing eye and 0.01 from the worse-seeing eye) with a cost
savings of ₤5,841 relative to aflibercept. Therefore, ranibizumab provides greater
health gains with lower overall costs than aflibercept. Probabilistic sensitivity
analysis shows that ranibizumab has a 58% probability of being dominant and
79% probability of being cost effective compared with aflibercept at a willingnessto-pay threshold of £20 000/QALY. Conclusions: Ranibizumab is dominant over
aflibercept in the treatment of VI due to DMO.
PSS35
The Future Health Economic Potential of Next Generation
Artificial Vision Devices for Treating Blindness in Germany: an
Early Cost-Utility Assessment
Schwander B
AHEAD GmbH, Loerrach, Germany
.
Objectives: The next generation of artificial vision devices (AVDs), which is currently tested in clinical trials, has the potential to improve the vision of blind
patients with retinitis pigmentosa (RP) in a manner that they will be categorized
as visual impaired but no longer as blind. This unprecedented vision improvement
will result in a mentionable quality of life gain which poses the question at which
costs the next generation AVDs are to be regarded as cost-effective. Methods:
In order to answer this research question a Markov model, with the health states
blind, visual impaired and death, was developed to simulate and to compare
the costs and effects of next generation AVDs versus best supportive care (BSC)
over a lifetime horizon. Health care costs and health utilities for the Markov health
A610
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
states were determined on the basis of published literature. For next generation
AVDs, which are currently tested in clinical trials, various possible effect and
pricing scenarios have been simulated. Results: Applying the base case settings
resulted in incremental costs of € 107,925, in 2.03 incremental quality-adjusted
life years (QALYs) and in a cost-effectiveness ratio of € 53,165 per QALY gained.
Probabilistic and deterministic sensitivity analyses as well as scenario analyses
for the effect size and the AVD costs were performed in order to investigate the
robustness of results. In these analyses a strong variation of the cost-effectiveness
results was obtained ranging from € 23,512 (best case) to € 176,958 (worst case)
per QALY gained. Conclusions: The innovative nature, the high unmet medical need and the expected unprecedented efficacy of next generation AVDs will
highly likely lead to the case that even relatively high incremental cost effectiveness ratios, that have been obtained when simulating various effect and pricing scenarios, will be regarded as acceptable from a German health care payer
perspective.
PSS36
Implications for Time Savings Using New Intraoperative Measuring
Technology
Tavardkiladze G 1, Bakhshinyan V 1, Deger M 2, Irwin C 2, Rose S 2
Research Centre for Audiology and Hearing Rehabilitation, Moscow, Russia, 2Cochlear
AG, Basel, Switzerland
.
.
.
.
.
1National
Objectives: Intraoperative threshold measurement is a part of the cochlear
implantation procedure and in the current setting conducted by the clinicians
with a standard set-up. The newly released CR220 Intraoperative Remote Assistant
is a handheld device and can also be used by someone already in the operating
theatre (OT). The aim of this study was to compare measurement time with the
new CR220 and standard set-up and to investigate from the clinic’s perspective any
cost-savings created as a result of time-savings with the new device. Methods:
Stages of the measurement process are identified and the time is measured
for each stage during 113 patients’ implantation procedure. A literature review
was conducted to identify the reimbursement level of this process in order to
translate any time-savings to cost savings. Results: When the clinician travels to the OT, the mean time spent per procedure with CR220 is 8.4% less than
the computer set-up (163.7 minutes vs 149.9 minutes). If the measurement is
conducted by someone already in the OR, the measurement time is reduced by
95.5% with the CR220 (163.7 minutes vs 7.3 min). Literature review revealed that
the fee for measurement as $18.99-22.57 per 15 minutes in the US setting and
in most of the other settings this procedure is not reimbursed separately but
covered under cochlear implantation. Conclusions: The analysis showed that
considerable time is spent for the clinician to travel to OT and waiting in the OT.
This “unproductive” time is not only wasteful, but also means the clinician is not
available in the clinic seeing patients where their expert skills are of most value.
Moreover the clinic is either underpaid or is not paid at all for this expertise and
time demanding process. The new CR220 gives clinics the opportunity to allocate
their limited resources efficiently.
Sensory Systems Disorders – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient
Preference Studies
PSS37
Drug Survival Rates And Cost of Biological Agents for the
Treatment of Moderate to Severe Psoriasis in the Balearic Islands
(Spain)
Ventayol P
Hospital Son Espases, Palma de Mallorca, Spain
.
Objectives: There are few studies combining dose regimen in routine clinical
practice, drug survival rates and costs of biological agents for the treatment of
naïve patients with moderate-to-severe psoriasis in the clinical practice. To assess
the dose regimen in routine clinical practice, drug survival rate (persistence rate)
and efficiency (cost per persistence) for etanercept (ETN), adalimumab (ADA) and
ustekinumab (UST) in a real practice clinical setting. Methods: A retrospective
study on psoriasis patients aged ≥ 18 years, naïve to a biological agent and a minimum of 6 months of treatment was performed in 5 public health system hospitals
in the Balearic Islands (Spain) for the period from January 1st 2010 to December 31st
2013. The recorded variables were: sex, weight, age, indication (psoriasis or psoriatic
arthritis), discontinuation reason and pharmacy dispensation records. Costs were
based on the average wholesale price, estimating annual cost according to the first
treatment received. Persistence rates were reckoned taking into account the current total days of therapy comparing posology with pharmacy supplied dose, and
were estimated using the method of Kaplan-Meier. Results: During the study
period a cohort of 112 psoriatic patients (57% men) were evaluated: 37 patients
with ADA (81 kg, 51 years, 27; mean weight, mean age, and prevalence of psoriatic
arthritis respectively), 34 with ETN (82 kg, 52 years, 25%) and 41 with UST (76 kg, 43
years, 19%). The persistence rate at 2 years was, 48%, 62% and 81% and the cost per
persistence at 2 years was 52.961 € , 40.160 € , and 30.657 € (for ADA, ETN and UST
respectively). Conclusions: UST showed better overall drug survival compared
to ETN and ADA. UST has been the most efficient alternative for the treatment of
naïve patients and has shown the least budget-impact per persistent-patient at 2
years analysis.
PSS38
Medication Adherence and Discontinuation Predicted by Disease
Duration in Glaucoma Patients: Findings From A Cross-Sectional
Study in Korea
Park K H 1, Cha J H 2
1Seoul National University College of Medicine, Seoul, South Korea, 2Pfizer Pharmaceuticals Korea
Ltd., Seoul, South Korea
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Although several studies reported patients with chronic disease were
found to have lower medication adherence and higher discontinuation rates as
disease duration increased, it is still not evident in glaucoma patients. With this
perspective, this study was designed to assess the association of disease duration with medication adherence and discontinuation in glaucoma patients in
Korea. Methods: It was a cross-sectional, multi-centered and observational study
where glaucoma outpatients with less than two years of drug use were recruited at
15 eye clinics from March to November 2013. All patients completed a self-administered questionnaire asking about their daily use of glaucoma medications to estimate adherence and discontinuation. Medication adherence and discontinuation
were defined as patients administering the drug for ≥ 80% of prescribed days and if
patients stopped taking medication for 7 consecutive days respectively. Results:
A total of 1,050 glaucoma patients were enrolled in the study. Of the total, 14.4%
showed to be non-adherent to their glaucoma therapy and 7.5% had the experience of medication discontinuation. All patients were categorized into 3 groups
according to disease duration: group A ≤ 1 year (n= 600,57.1%), B > 1 year and ≤ 2
years (n= 415,39.5%), and C > 2 years (n= 35,3. 3%). The patients of group A with
the disease duration ≤ 1 year were likely to be non-adherent to glaucoma therapy
compared to those with longer disease duration. (A: 84.9% vs. B: 86% vs. C: 100%,
p=. 045) Highest discontinuation rate was found in group B with the disease duration
bewteen 1 and 2 years. (A: 6.7% vs. B: 8.9% vs. C: 5.7%, P= . 380) Conclusions: The
study results highlight more attention should be paid to the patients who newly
started glaucoma therapy because in the patients with less than 2 years of disease
duration the adherence was low and the discontinuation rate was high.
PSS39
Health State Utilities for Pressure Ulcers – A Comparison of
Condition-Specific and Generic Measures and Time-Trade-Off (Tto)
Meads D M 1, Czoski-Murray C 1, Rutherford C 2, Dealey C 3, McGinnis E 4, Stubbs N 5, Wilson
L 1, Nixon J 1, Hulme C T 1, McCabe C 6
1University of Leeds, Leeds, UK, 2University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia, 3Birmingham Hospitals
NHS Trust and University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK, 4Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust,
Leeds, UK, 5Leeds Community Healthcare NHS Trust, Leeds, UK, 6University of Alberta, Edmonton,
AB, Canada
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To compare a newly developed condition-specific utility index (CSUI),
the Pressure Ulcer Quality of Life Utility Index (PUQoL-UI) with generic and directly
elicited TTO values. Methods: The PUQoL-UI was completed by a group of patients
(n= 100) in England with pressure ulcers (PUs) along with the EQ-5D and own health
TTO. The discriminatory power of the utility measures was assessed across PU
grade and health and PU severity ratings. Multivariate regression was conducted
to explore determinants of utility values. Results: The mean sample age was 77.2
years (range 22.7-101.7), 49% were female and 50% wheelchair users. Mean (SDs)
utility for superficial PUs (grades 1-2) were 0.72 (0.17), 0.70 (0.35) and 0.24 (0.16) and
for severe PUs (grades 3-4) 0.67 (0.17), 0.65 (0.35) and 0.15 (0.38) for the PUQoL-UI, TTO
and EQ-5D, respectively. Mean (SDs) utility by self-reported PU severity was: [Mild]
0.78 (0.16), 0.66 (0.35), 0.29 (0.36); [Moderate] 0.72 (0.17), 0.63 (0.38), 0.25 (0.34); [Severe]
0.58 (0.17), 0.70 (0.33), 0.04 (0.40) for the PUQoL-UI, TTO and EQ-5D, respectively.
Regression analyses indicated both EQ-5D and PUQoL-UI values were explained by
perceived severity and general health ratings but not demographics or PU grade.
Duration and body part affected were additional significant explanatory factors of
the EQ-5D while wheelchair use approached significance. Conclusions: Values
were much lower for the EQ-5D than the other assessments which may be partly
explained by the range in EQ-5D and partly due to background mobility issues being
captured. The PUQoL-UI appears to have good discriminatory power and is recommended for use in trials of PU interventions. The utilities presented here will be useful for decision-analytic models that incorporate PU impact. Probabilistic sensitivity
analyses including the PUQoL-UI will likely generate lower levels of uncertainty than
the EQ-5D due to the smaller SDs for health states.
PSS40
Estimating Utility Data for Patient Symptom Severity in Chronic
Spontaneous Urticaria
Hawe E 1, Stull D E 1, McBride D 1, Balp M M 2
1RTI Health Solutions, Manchester, UK, 2Novartis Pharma AG, Basel, Switzerland
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To obtain utility estimates suitable for use in economic models for
chronic spontaneous (idiopathic) urticaria (CSU). Methods: Patient-level data from
three randomised clinical trials: ASTERIA I, ASTERIA II, and GLACIAL were analysed.
Health states were derived from Urticaria Activity Score (UAS7), a patient-completed
diary of signs and symptoms which calculates an average daily score over 7 days.
Higher score means more severe symptoms. UAS7 scores for the health states were:
Urticaria-free: 0; Well-controlled urticaria: 1-6; Mild urticaria: 7-15; Moderate urticaria: 16-27; Severe urticaria: 28-42. Mean EQ-5D utilities were calculated for each
health state. Individual trial analyses showed inconsistent utilities across the UAS7
health states due to small subsample sizes. A mixed model was used to predict
EQ-5D according to UAS7 health states in a pooled dataset containing all treatment
arms and time-points from the three trials. The predictor variable was UAS7 health
state and the dependent variable was EQ-5D utility. Fixed/random effects for trial
and patient were included and the following covariates: UAS7 health state at baseline (Moderate or Severe), presence of angioedema at baseline and during follow-up,
duration of CSU, number of previous CSU medications, and gender of the patient.
A parsimonious model was selected using the approach of backwards elimination;
UAS7 health state was forced into the model. The validity of pooling trials was considered through visual comparisons and interaction terms. Results: There was a
consistent improvement in EQ-5D utilities as severity of urticaria improved. Mean
utilities at Week 12 ranged from 0.712 in patients with severe urticaria to 0.897 in
patients who were urticaria-free. Sensitivity analysis confirmed the robustness of
results. Conclusions: The results suggest that EQ-5D utility score increased with
decreasing severity of urticaria. EQ-5D utility scores allow the comparison of HRQoL
across diseases by calculating QALYs in economic models.
A611
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PSS41
Health Related Quality of Life in Patients With Actinic Keratosis
- Results From Patients Treated in Dermatology Specialist Care In
Denmark
Ragnarson Tennvall G 1, Norlin J M 2, Malmberg I 3, Erlendsson A 4, Hædersdal M 4
Swedish Institute for Health Economics, Lund, Sweden, 2LEO Pharma A/S, Ballerup,
Denmark, 3LEO Pharma AB, Malmö, Sweden, 4Bispebjerg Hospital, Copenhagen, Denmark
.
.
.
.
.
.
1IHE, The
Objectives: Actinic keratosis (AK) is a common skin condition associated with
cumulative sun exposure that may progress to non-melanoma skin cancer. The
disease can potentially influence Health Related Quality of Life (HRQoL), but studies of HRQoL in patients with AK are limited. The objective was to analyze HRQoL
in patients with AK using generic and disease-specific HRQoL instruments and to
analyze the relationship between instruments. Methods: AK patients who visited dermatological clinics in Denmark were included in an observational, crosssectional, study in a multi-center setting. Dermatologists assessed AK severity
and patients completed: Actinic Keratosis Quality of Life Questionnaire (AKQoL),
Dermatology Life Quality Index (DLQI), EQ-5D (5L), and EuroQoL Visual Analogue
Scale (EQ-VAS). Results: A total of 312 patients from 10 clinics were included in
the analyses. In general, patients with AK reported impaired HRQoL. The mean
values (possible range) were: AKQoL 6.7 (0-27), DLQI 2 (0-30), EQ-5D-5L 0.88 (0-1),
and EQ-VAS 79 (0-100). HRQoL was least affected in patients with mild actinic disease, whereas patients with severe actinic damage suffered from further impaired
HRQoL (mean AKQoL 10.1 and DLQI 4.6). The correlation between DLQI and AKQoL
was moderate (0.52), whereas the correlations between DLQI and EQ-5D (-0.36) and
between AKQoL and EQ-5D (-0.10) were weak. Conclusions: All patients with AK
had impaired HRQoL. Patients with severe actinic damage were considerably more
affected than those with mild disease. Correlations between instruments demonstrate that they are complementary as they measure different aspects of HRQoL
and are used for different purposes. EQ-5D is essential for economic evaluations,
the DLQI is responsive to changes in relation to treatment and AKQoL captures
important aspects related to sun damaged skin.
PSS42
Categorical Health States In Chronic Spontaneous Urticaria
(Csu) Based On The Weekly Urticaria Activity Score (Uas7): Are They
Distinct, Discriminative, And Reproducible?
Stull D E 1, McBride D 1, Gimenez-Arnau A 2, Grattan C 3, Khalil S 4, Balp M M 4
Health Solutions, Manchester, UK, 2Hospital del Mar and Universitat Autònoma, Barcelona,
Spain, 3Norfolk and Norwich University Hospital, Norfolk, UK, 4Novartis Pharma AG, Basel,
Switzerland
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1RTI
Objectives: Specific ranges of scores reflecting patient severity or changes in
severity have not been established for average daily urticaria activity summed
over 7 days (UAS7; range= 0-42), a common measure for assessing CSU disease
activity. This study evaluates whether five non-overlapping health states derived
from the continuous UAS7 score can discriminate between patients with different
severities of urticaria and are reproducible across multiple studies. Methods:
Data come from three randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled Phase III
clinical trials evaluating the effect of omalizumab on symptoms of patients with
refractory CSU. Five CSU health states were defined: Urticaria-Free (UAS7= 0); WellControlled Urticaria (UAS7= 1-6); Mild Urticaria (UAS7= 7-15); Moderate Urticaria
(UAS7= 16-27); Severe Urticaria (UAS7= 28-42). Comparison variables included the
Dermatology Life Quality Index (DLQI), a 10-item dermatologic QoL instrument
(range= 0-30; higher scores= greater QoL impairment); patient diary questions asking about sleep and activity interference; presence of angioedema; and number
of diphenhydramine 25mg pills taken in previous 24 hours. Analyses established
whether different UAS7 health states showed different values on comparison
variables. Analyses were replicated across the trials at baseline and weeks 12,24,
and 40 (ASTERIA I and GLACIAL) and baseline and weeks 12 and 28 (ASTERIA II).
Results: Mean values for comparison variables were lowest (zero or very
close to zero) for patients who were Urticaria-Free and highest for those with
Severe Urticaria. For Well-Controlled and Mild Urticaria comparison variable
values increased. Larger increases in values occurred for Moderate and Severe
Urticaria. Changes in categorical health state severity were highly related to categorical changes in DLQI (p< 0.001 for all trials and time points). Conclusions:
Categorical UAS7 health states show meaningful differences in mean values on
comparison variables and are highly related to established levels of effect on
dermatological QoL. Categorical UAS7 health states could be informative about
subgroups for economic models and useful for clinical practice.
PSS43
The Burden Of Primary Hyperhidrosis On The Patient: Eq-5d-5l
Utilities, Willingness To Pay And Daily Time Spent In Managing The
Condition
Kamudoni P 1, Salek M S 1, Mueller B 2
1Cardiff University, Cardiff, UK, 2Riemser Pharma GmbH, Greifswald - Insel Riems, Germany
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The objective of this study was to estimate the burden associated
with primary hyperhidrosis by assessing patient’s health utilities, willingness
to pay (WTP) for a complete cure and daily time spent in managing the condition. Methods: The data used in this study were collected under a longitudinal
multi-stage research undertaken to develop and validate a new HRQoL instrument
from patients with hyperhidrosis recruited through online social networking communities (Hyperhidrosis support group UK and International hyperhidrosis society)
from January to August 2013. Only the baseline assessment is used in this analysis. Disease severity was measured using the Hyperhidrosis Disease Severity Scale
(2 = for tolerable sweating, 3 = …barely tolerable sweating, 4 = intolerable sweating).
The EuroQoL 5D-5L was used for assessing health utility index. Results: EQ-5D
health utility index was lower in patients with more severe hyperhidrosis [mean
utility value = . 85± 0.13 for HDSS = 2,0. 8±. 15 for HDSS = 3, and 0.69±. 2 for HDSS
= 4, chi-square = 25.86, df = 2, p < 0.001]. Further, the health utility index was.
64 ±. 22 for WTP £0,0. 81±0.16 for £ 1 to 49,. 81±15 for £ 50 to 99,. 76±. 16 for £100 to
199,. 79± for £ 200 to 299,. 71±. 19 for £300 or more. Patients spent a mean of 50±134
minutes (HDSS = 2), 65±119 minutes (HDSS = 3) and 161±293 minutes (HDSS = 4) for
daily management of hyperhidrosis. WTP showed the lowest correlation to disease
severity. Conclusions: The current study underscores the multidimensionality
of the burden of hyperhidrosis, with all aspects showing greater impairment with
greater disease severity. Health utility and daily time spent in managing the condition offered significant discrimination of patients.
PSS44
Subjective Expectations Regarding Life Expectancy And HealthRelated Quality Of Life In Moderate To Severe Psoriasis Patients
Rencz F 1, Gulacsi L 1, Remenyik É 2, Szegedi A 2, Holló P 3, Kárpáti S 3, Péntek M 1, Brodszky V 1
University of Budapest, Budapest, Hungary, 2University of Debrecen, Debrecen,
Hungary, 3Semmelweis University, Budapest, Hungary
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Corvinus
Objectives: To assess psoriasis patients’ subjective expectations regarding their
future health-related quality of life (HRQOL) and life-expectancy, and to explore
variables associated with under- or overestimating behaviour. Methods: A crosssectional questionnaire survey of adult moderate to severe psoriasis patients was
carried out. Patients were asked to indicate the age they expect themselves to live.
HRQOL expectations were measured by the EQ-5D descriptive system for 6 months
ahead and for future ages of 60,70,80 and 90, respectively. Current health state was
evaluated with EQ-5D and visual analogue scale (EQ VAS), Dermatology Life Quality
Index (DLQI) and Psoriasis Area and Severity Index (PASI). Results: Overall 167
patients (71% males) were included in the analysis with mean age of 50.38±12.35
years, mean EQ-5D, EQ VAS, DLQI and PASI scores were 0.71±0.30,65.3±21.08,5. 89±7.10
and 7.82±10.13, respectively. Currently 56% of the patients were on biological therapy.
Patients expected 0.1±0.23 mean improvement in EQ-5D scores within 6 months
(p< 0.001); inverse or palmoplantar psoriasis, and using only topical treatment or
initiation of the first biological at the time of the survey were likely associated with
higher expectations. Males overestimated their life-expectancy by 2.94±11.86 years
whereas females underestimated by 5.23±9.34 years (p< 0.001) compared to the gender- and age-matched statistical life-expectancy. Expected mean EQ-5D scores for
ages from 60 to 90 were: 0.56±0.48,0. 38±0.50,0. 15±0.55, and -0.17±0.54 (p< 0.001),
respectively that are lower than the general population norms in Hungary. Both for
6 months ahead and older ages, expected EQ-5D correlated moderately with current
EQ-5D and EQ VAS and only weakly with DLQI and PASI (p< 0.05). Conclusions:
Patients expected considerable improvement in their HRQOL for the near future and
large-scale deterioration for older ages. Exploring unrealistic expectations might help
to prevent dissatisfaction with treatment benefits and to improve compliance.
PSS45
The Decision Making Process In Receiving Bone Conduction Implants
(Bci) For Single Sided Deafness
Kosaner M , Urban M
VIBRANT MED-EL Hearing Technology GmbH, Innsbruck, Austria
.
.
Objectives: The main objective of this study was to evaluate the process in which
patients with single sided deafness proceed to receive bone conduction implants.
Factors contributing to decisions for or against implantation were also compiled. Methods: Using a comprehensive search strategy, several online databases
were searched to identify studies published since 2002. Research involving adults
and children with single sided deafness (SSD); and reporting on patient preference
for receiving BCIs were included. Screening of titles, and data extraction and quality
assessment of full papers were undertaken by one reviewer with any uncertainties
resolved by consultation with a second reviewer. Results: 16 studies were identified covering a total of 914 individuals diagnosed with SSD. All patients who trialled
a CROS device preferred to receive a BCI. Acceptance of new generation CROS devices
is suggested to be better but still low. Following a BCI Headband trial 19% to 77% of
patients across studies (mean 51%) proceeded to receive a BCI. When reported, the
most common reason for rejecting implantation was insufficient benefit with the
Headband in speech in noise or insufficient/no relief from tinnitus. Studies assessing factors in decision making found that age, gender, aetiology, duration of hearing
loss or the presence of contralateral hearing loss did not differ between individuals who decide for or against implantation. One study so far suggests the role of
transcranial attenuation at 2 kHz and tinnitus loudness to play a role in decision
making. Conclusions: When given the option to trial traditional treatments and
BCI simulators/Headbands many patients with SSD reject BCIs. This research highlights the importance of providing such trials before implantation. It is still unknown
which aspects play a role in decision making and identifying better candidates.
PSS46
The Burden Of Chronic Urticaria In Europe: A Systematic Literature
Review
Betoret I 1, Lambert C 1, Paravisini A 1, Tribaldos M 2, Paz S 3, Lizán L 2
Farmaceutica, Barcelona, Spain, 2Outcomes 10, Castellon, Spain, 3Outcomes’10,
Castellon, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Novartis
Objectives: To synthesize and analyze the available information on the burden of
chronic urticaria (CU) [Patients’ Reported Outcomes (PROs): Health related quality
of life (HRQoL), adherence, satisfaction, preferences, use of medical resources and
costs] in Europe. Methods: A systematic review on PROs and costs of CU was
performed. International (Pub Med, WOK, Scopus, Cochrane Library) and national
(CSIC-IME, IBECS, MEDES) databases were consulted. Original articles, narrative/systematic reviews of studies developed in Europe, until December 2013 were retrieved.
Editorials, letters/commentaries, and efficacy or economic evaluations of specific
drugs were excluded. Costs were updated to € , 2013. Results: 9 studies assessed
HRQoL (3, Germany; 1, France, Greece, Italy, Spain, UK, Germany/France, respectively)
and 1 satisfaction with treatments (Germany/France). No studies on adherence or
preferences for treatments were identified. The CU-Q2oL instrument, (0-100, higher
value, worse HRQoL), was the most frequently used (n= 4). Scores ranged from 18.4
A612
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
(Greece) to 42.8 (Germany) revealing an acceptable perception of HRQoL. Sleep, itching/embarrassment and mental health were the HRQoL dimensions most impaired.
Patients taking prescription drugs were more satisfied than those taking over the
counter (p< 0.01). Severely ill patients were willing to change therapies if new, more
effective alternatives became available (p< 0.05). Only 1 study assessed the costs of
CU in Europe while another one described the use of medical resources. CU total
cost in France was € 2,139.48 per patient/year. Patients lost 2.2 working days/month,
being productivity losses 92% of total costs. CU patients were mostly cared for a
dermatologist according to findings in Germany. A mean of 11.7 (SD: 11.5) visits/
month to the dermatology clinic were reported. Conclusions: PROs and costs
in CU are infrequently addressed in the literature. Findings show patients reduced
HRQoL and their willingness for more effective therapies. Frequent medical visits
and loss of productivity make CU a burdensome disease in European countries.
PSS47
A Review Of Patient Reported Outcomes (Pros) In Psoriasis According
To The Food And Drug Administration (Fda) Pro Guidance Criteria
Cheng R
Covance Market Access Services, Inc., San Diego, CA, USA
.
Objectives: Psoriasis is a chronic inflammatory skin condition that affects an
estimated 4.5 to 7.5 million people in the United States. Numerous clinical trials
have been conducted in psoriasis, many of which have included general dermatologic or psoriasis-specific PROs as study outcome measures. Commonly used
PROs in these trials include the Dermatology Life Quality Index (DLQI), Psoriasis
Disability Index (PDI), Psoriasis Life Stress Inventory (PLSI), Psoriasis Quality of Life
Questionnaire (PQOL-12), and Skindex. This study assessed how well the development and validation process of psoriasis-specific PROs align with the FDA PRO
guidance. Methods: We reviewed the development and validation studies of the
five PROs to assess if they align with the FDA PRO guidance criteria with regard to:
(1) content validity, including patient input in concept elicitation, item generation,
and cognitive debriefing; and (2) psychometric testing, including construct validity,
internal-consistency and test-retest reliability, and responsiveness. Results: The
PDI was developed without patient input in terms of concept elicitation, item generation, or cognitive debriefing. Variability and oftentimes inadequately documented
evidence of patient input for concept elicitation, item generation, and cognitive
debriefing were observed for the other four PROs. Test-retest reliability was not
evaluated in the PLSI. Evidence of responsiveness was not available for three of the
PROs. Conclusions: Based on this review, additional qualitative and quantitative
research is needed to eliminate the identified gaps before these PROs could fulfill
the FDA guidance for inclusion as a measure for a PRO label claim.
40.4±17.5 years with 76% males, respectively. Amongst the Hungarian patients 18%
used none or only topical therapy in the last 12 months, 31% systemic non-biological treatment and 52% biologicals whereas in Iran 48% of the patients applied
only topicals and 39% treated with non-biological systematic therapy. Mean EQ-5D,
DLQI and PASI of the Hungarian and the Iranian sample were 0.69±0.3, 6.29±7.3,
8.01±10, and 0.62±0.4, 10±6.5, 13±8.3, respectively. In both countries psoriasis of the
neck and/or décolletage was associated with the greatest HRQOL reduction using
either instrument (p< 0.05). Regarding clinical types, in Hungary the palmoplantar involvement while in Iran nail psoriasis patients reported the worst general
HRQOL (mean EQ-5D scores: 0.36±0.3 and 0.47±0.4). Correlation between EQ-5D
and DLQI was found very similar across the two countries (rs= -0.43- and -0.44,
p< 0.001), but EQ-5D showed significant correlation with PASI only in Hungary
(rs= -0.43, p< 0.001). Strong positive correlation was identified between DLQI and
PASI in both countries but only in those patients who received systemic therapy:
Iran (rs= 0.72, p< 0.001) and Hungary (systemic non-biological: rs= 0.65, p< 0.001,
biological: rs= 0.76, p< 0.001). Conclusions: Our results suggest that disease
severity, treatments, and country-specific differences might lead to variations in
the relationship between the outcome measures used in psoriasis.
PSS50
How Can the Quality of Life in Hand Eczema Questionnaire (qolheq)
be Interpreted? A Banding Study
Ofenloch R F 1, Weisshaar E 1, Dumke A -K 2, Molin S 3, Diepgen T L 1, Apfelbacher C 4
Hospital Heidelberg, Heidelberg, Germany, 2University Hospital Jena, Jena, Germany,
3University Hospital Munich, Munich, Germany, 4UR - University of Regensburg, Regensburg,
Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1University
PSS48
Current Management and Barriers to Treatment for Wet AgeRelated Macular Degeneration (Wamd): Perspectives From Patients
and Caregivers
Objectives: The Quality of Life in Hand Eczema Questionnaire (QOLHEQ) is a diseasespecific instrument to assess health-related Quality of Life (HRQOL) in hand eczema
(HE) patients. The QOLHEQ assesses four domains of HRQOL: (a) symptoms, (b) emotions, (c) functioning and (d) treatment/prevention. The QOLHEQ total-score ranges
from 0-127 points. The aim of this study was to assign bands of the QOLHQ-score
to an anchor question (AQ) on HE severity to aid the interpretation of the QOLHEQscore. Methods: Data was drawn from the German validation study of the QOLHEQ.
We calculated median, mean and mode of the AQ for 30 categories of the QOLHEQscore to devise separate sets of bands. Weighted kappa was calculated in order to
identify the set of bands with the best agreement between QOLHEQ and AQ. Results:
Overall n=316 HE patients were included in the study. Their mean age was 46.7 years
(SD=12.9) and 54.1% of the sample were female. With a weighted kappa of 0.54 the
best agreement was found for the following band: QOLHEQ<9 = minimal impairment;
QOLHEQ 9-25 = slight impairment; QOLHEQ 25-58 = moderate impairment; QOLHEQ
59-79 = severe impairment; QOLHEQ>79 = very severe impairment. Conclusions:
This is the first study which uses an anchor-based approach in order to devise a
banding for the QOLHEQ-score. This banding represents a standardized means of
interpreting the QOLHEQ total score. Further studies are needed to explore which
banding may be adequate for different language version of the QOLHEQ.
Varano M 1, Eter N 2, Winyard S 3, Wittrup-Jensen K U 4, Heraghty J5
1Fondazione G. B. Bietti-IRCCS, Rome, Italy, 2University of Muenster, Muenster, Germany, 3Royal
National Institute of Blind People, London, UK, 4Bayer Pharma AG, Berlin, Germany, 5Macular
Disease Foundation Australia, Sydney, Australia
PSS51
Factors Conditioning Health Related Quality Of Life In Patients
With Psoriasis In Europe: A Systematic Review Of The Literature
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The aim of this global survey was to evaluate the management of
wet age-related macular degeneration (wAMD) from a patient/caregiver perspective. Methods: Patients with a wAMD diagnosis and current or prior use of intravitreal injections and caregivers from nine countries (Australia, Brazil, Canada, France,
Germany, Italy, Japan, Spain, and the UK) completed a questionnaire. Results: 910
patients and 890 caregivers were surveyed. 55% of patients had wAMD in 1 eye and
64% had been receiving intravitreal injections for > 1 year. Many caregivers were a
child/grandchild of the patient (47%), or partner (23%); only 7% were a professional
caregiver. Most (73%) patients visited a health care professional (HCP) within 1
month of first noticing a change in vision; 41% of patients who delayed visiting
a HCP thought the symptoms would resolve. Following diagnosis, 54% of patients
began treatment immediately, and a further 37% scheduled an appointment within
1–3 weeks. 52% of patients reported a temporary improvement or stabilization in
vision as a result of current treatment, and 22% reported a return to pre-diagnosis
vision or that their vision was still improving. Most patients and caregivers reported
a number of obstacles in managing wAMD, including the treatment itself (35% and
39%, respectively), treatment costs (28% and 29%), and finding the right treatment
options (27% and 31%). Additionally, 27% of caregivers found the patient’s treatment extremely inconvenient with 57% of employed (non-professional) caregivers
having to take time off work or miss personal obligations. 16% of patients missed
a HCP appointment because their caregiver was unable to take them (26%), fear of
injections (21%), illness (19%), forgetfulness (15%), inconvenience (10%), costs (6%),
and discomfort of injections (3%). Conclusions: Many patients and caregivers
identified a number of obstacles in managing wAMD. These included the treatment
itself (patients and caregivers) and loss of productivity (non-professional caregivers).
PSS49
A Comaprative Cross-Sectional Study On Health-Related Quality Of
Life In Psoriasis From Hungary And Iran
Moradi M , Rencz F
Corvinus University of Budapest, Budapest, Hungary
.
.
Objectives: To compare health-related quality of life (HRQOL) of Hungarian and
Iranian psoriasis patients and to analyze possible differences in the relationship
between EuroQol 5 dimensions (EQ-5D), Dermatology Life Quality Index (DLQI)
and Psoriasis Area and Severity Index (PASI). Methods: Same cross-sectional
questionnaire survey was carried out in two countries. Altogether 200 adult psoriasis patients enrolled from two Hungarian university clinics and 62 from an
Iranian clinic. Besides HRQOL assessment, data on demographics, applied treatments, affected body sites and clinical types were collected. Results: Mean age
of the Hungarian and Iranian patients were 51.2 ±12.9 years with 69% males, and
Obradors M 1, Figueras M 1, Paz S 2, Comellas M 3, Lizán L 3
Farmaceutica S. A., Barcelona, Spain, 2Outcomes’10, Castellon, Spain, 3Outcomes 10,
Castellon, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
1Novartis
Objectives: To identify conditioning factors of Health Related Quality of Life
(HRQoL) of patients with psoriasis as reported in the literature in the last 5 years
in Europe. Methods: Electronic databases [PubMed, ISI-WOK, Cochrane Library,
MEDES, CSIC-IME, IBECS] and grey literature [Google Scholar], were searched to
identify studies written in English or Spanish on HRQoL in patients with psoriasis,
published in Europe between January 1, 2009 and December 31, 2013. Bibliographic
references were hand searched. Editorials, letters, commentaries, opinion papers
and studies related to specific treatments were excluded. Results: 27 studies accomplished the inclusion criteria. Most of the publications (66.7%, n=18)
were cross-sectional studies; 25.9% (n= 7) had a prospective design while 7.4%
(n= 2) were retrospective. 12 studies analyzed the relation between HRQOL and
demographic characteristics, determining in 75% and 50% of them, there was a
relation between sex (women) and age (younger patients) with poorer HRQoL.
3 publications demonstrated the HRQoL impairment associated with visibility of skin
lesions. 4 studies appraised the relationship between disease activity and HRQoL
determining a more compromised HRQOL in those patients with active psoriasis.
Disease Severity was the most frequent assessed factor, being studied in 13 publications, describing in 92% of them that patients with higher PASI had worse HRQoL. 2
articles indicated that disease symptoms as skin discomfort and pruritus were elements that negatively influenced the HRQoL of these patients. Emotional disturbances
were identified as predictors of poorer HRQOL in 5 studies. 3 publications determined
that the use of biologic therapy contributed to improve HRQoL. Conclusions:
HRQoL has been broadly addressed in patients with psoriasis in Europe. Several
disease- and patient-related factors contributed to its deterioration. Therapeutic
measures with proved effectiveness in controlling disease symptoms and reducing
PASI should be considered in patients with severe disease who have a relation with
poorer HRQoL.
Sensory Systems Disorders – Health Care Use & Policy Studies
PSS52
Cost-Effectiveness and Value of Information Analyses of
Nutritional Support in Preventing Pressure Ulcers in High Risk
Hospitalised Patients
Tuffaha H W 1, Shelley R 2, Chaboyer W 2, Gordon L G 1, Scuffham P A 1
University, Meadowbrook, Australia, 2Griffith University, Gold Coast, Australia
.
1Griffith
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A613
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: To assess the cost-effectiveness of nutritional support (high protein
supplementary diet) versus standard care (regular hospital diet) in preventing pressure ulcers in hospitalised patients at high risk of pressure ulcers and malnutrition. Further, to evaluate the need and value of additional research using value of
information analysis. Methods: Analyses were undertaken from the perspective
of the State health department in Queensland, Australia, using a Markov decision
model. Evidence for the relative risk (RR) was estimated from a meta-analysis of
randomised controlled trials; other parameters were systematically identified from
the literature to populate the model. The incremental net monetary benefit (INB)
was calculated and a probabilistic sensitivity analysis using Monte Carlo simulation
was conducted. The expected value of perfect information (EVPI), expected value
of perfect parameter information (EVPPI), expected value of sample information
(EVSI), expected total cost of additional research, expected net benefit of sampling
(ENBS), and the return on investment (ROI) were calculated for an estimated population of 125,000 over ten years. Results: At a willingness-to-pay of AU$ 50,000 per
quality-adjusted life year, the INB was AU$ 530, with a probability of 84% for nutritional support to be the preferred intervention. The population EVPI was AU$ 4.75
million, the highest EVPPI was for RR at AU$ 2.25 million. For a future randomised
study investigating the RR of the two interventions, the ENBS would be maximised
at AU$ 380,000 with 1,200 patients in each arm; from an EVSI of AU$1.6 million and
total study cost of AU$ 1.2 million. The expected ROI would be 32%. Conclusions:
Nutritional support is cost-effective in preventing pressure ulcers in high risk hospitalised patients; however, there is uncertainty surrounding the decision and the
value of this uncertainty is high. A future clinical trial to resolve this uncertainty
is worthwhile.
PSS53
The Impact of the German Drg-System on Policy Decision Making in
Ent
Fichtenbauer M , Kosaner M , Urban M
Vibrant Med-El Hearing Technology Gmbh, Innsbruck, Austria
.
.
.
Objectives: The German diagnosis-related groups (G-DRG) have been introduced
as a reimbursement system for in-patient care. The aim of this study was to report
on clinic-based data available from the G-DRG browser regarding the impact of
middle ear implantation as a basis for future health care decision making in
ear, nose and throat medicine (ENT). Methods: Using a clinical algorithm, the
unevaluated D23Z database from 2012 was analyzed to determine epidemiological characteristics of patients with different types of hearing losses and receiving
middle ear implants (MEI). All ICD-10 Codes used for the diagnosis of conductive (CHL), mixed (MHL) or sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL) were extracted. The
number of MEI cases reported in the D23Z was analyzed regarding Patient Clinical
Complexity Level (PCCL), age, sex and duration of stay. The incidence of MEI
candidates to the total number of ICD-10 codes and per indication were calculated. Results: According to the D23Z, approximately 30`000 individuals admitted
to ENT clinics were diagnosed with a hearing loss. About 38% suffered from CHL,
8% suffered from MHL and 48% suffered from SNHL. The proportion of patients
who received a MEI per indication were respectively 0.8% for SNHL, 8% for MHL
and 1% for CHL. Overall, about 466 (1%) patients received a MEI. 49.8% of them
were men and 50.2% were women. Children aged as young as 1-2 years could
also receive treatment. All patients had normal-term stay in hospitals with no
comorbidities or complications (PCCL < 4 in 99.2% of cases) The incidence of MEI
to the ENT patient base and the German population were respectively 15.5/1,000
and 0.6/100,000. Conclusions: The overall number of middle ear implantations
compared to standard treatments is quite low. Analyzing data on MEI available
from highly-developed DRG systems can be used by other countries for policy
decision making in ENT.
PSS54
Understanding Trends In Ophthalmologist Patient Selection And
Care Based On Patterns Of Billing
Culp J L 1, Connelly N 1, Kristopik J 1, Doyle J J 2
Consulting, Durham, NC, USA, 2Quintiles, Hawthorne, NY, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Quintiles
The recent U. S. release of Medicare Part B billing data provides unprecedented
insight into a health care system that reimbursed $77 billion in 2012. Of the 100
physicians receiving the greatest payments, nearly half were ophthalmologists.
Objectives: Examine ophthalmologist trends in patient selection and care,
and implications on system value delivery, based on Medicare and other
data. Methods: We examined aggregate and line-item data, comparing the
100 highest billing ophthalmologists to each other, and to the remaining 16,971,
identifying patterns in services billed, beneficiaries served, service location, and
dollars billed, allowed and paid. We also compared volume and cost of a key officebased code (J2778: Ranibizumab injection) to a key facility-based code (67042:
vitrectomy for macular hole), and incorporated epidemiology data to understand
provider incentives and drivers of care. Results: Ophthalmologists represented
2% of all practitioners billing Part B, but received 7% of reimbursement; the Top
100 billing ophthalmologists accounted for 0.6% of ophthalmologists billing, but
received 8.8% of payments; disparities between Top 100 billers and non-Top 100
include: variety of patients treated, percent of charges reimbursed, and practice
location; high volume J2778 performers were much more likely to be Top 100 billers than were high performers of 67042; and based on prevalence among those
65 and older, a significantly greater percentage of beneficiaries with wet AMD
received treatment than did beneficiaries with macular hole. Conclusions:
A large portion of payments were received by relatively few ophthalmologists,
whose practices demonstrate disparities in variety and volume of procedures
over non-top billers; incentives—some financial—may be factors that contribute
to greater treatment of wet AMD than of macular hole; and a focus on conducting
high-reimbursement services may drive disproportionate system costs. Greater
transparency may drive changes in practitioner behavior, and reduce unnecessary
health care system costs.
PSS55
Fabrication Of Voriconazole Solid Lipid Nanoparticles For Effective
Ocular Delivery
Kumar R , Sinha V R
UIPS, Panjab University, Chandigarh, India
.
.
.
Objectives: Preparation of Voriconazole (VCZ) solid lipid nanoparticles (SLNs) for
effective ocular delivery for the treatment of fungal keratitis. Methods: SLNs were
prepared by solvent emulsification technique using Compritol (lipid), Pluronic F-68
(surfactant) and sodium taurocholate (co-surfactant). Characterization of SLNs was
performed by size measurement, in-vitro release, ex-vivo corneal permeation studies and in-vitro antifungal activity. Results: Particle sizes were found in the range
of 150-300 depending upon lipid/Smix ratio with good zeta potential. Entrapment
efficiency of SLNs was found between 40-60% with sustained in vitro drug release
(> 70% in 12h). The ex-vivo corneal permeation studies exhibited good ocular permeation of VCZ from SLNs. Ex-vivo study also supports good ocular permeation of
VCZ from SLNs when compared with drug suspension. Further, in-vitro antifungal
activity exhibited the potential of VCZ SLNs. Conclusions: The sustained release
property with good corneal permeation of VCZ from SLNs encourages its application for in-vivo studies and hence could be proposed as an effective carrier for
ophthalmic administration.
PSS56
The Analysis of Dental Care in Ukraine at the Regional Level
Zaliskyy O , Shcherba P , Zalis’ka O
Danylo Halytsky Lviv National Medical University, Lviv, Ukraine
.
.
.
Objectives: The structure of the overall incidence diseases the mouth and teeth
morbidity occupy the third place in Ukraine. Thus 99% of the patients served in
outpatient clinics institutions. The structure of diseases requiring hospitalization
(approximately 1% of patients), the top spot is occupied odontogenic inflammatory
diseases and injuries of the maxillofacial face. Methods: In Ukraine, the availability of dentists is 4.0 per 10 000 population and 4.5 per 10 000 children. We have
analyzed the statistical data of the Lviv Regional Department of Health. We found
that 98% of the population have dental problems. Prevalence of dental caries, temporary occlusion in 6-years children reached 87.9%, a 12-year-olds - 72.3%. Prevalence
of chronic catarrhal gingivitis among adolescents aged 12-15 years ranged 70-98%
and teeth abnormalities in children 7-18 years more than 80%. In Ukraine everyone requires a prosthetics after 50 years. Results: Main social burden have the
dental institutions of the state and municipal property. By 2013 there were about
1.5 million causes to the dental care. We determined that in Lviv region on the
basis of licenses to practice medicine in dentistry are 248 dentists, who working
in cities and towns, and only about 10% - in rural areas. From 196th private dental surgeries 89 are situated in the regional center. Danylo Halytsky Lviv National
Medical University opened and acting university Dental Center from 2012, where
dentists had treated about 400 000 people, including more than 172 000 children
each year. Such preventive examinations make it possible to carry out monitoring
as indicators of dental public health field, to identify the most important risk factors for dental diseases. Conclusions: The management and pharmacoeconomic
studies of dental care, identifying optimal funding for state and municipal health
care institutions for cost-effectiveness use of state funds.
PSS57
Dental Care Use And Associated Factors Among People With
Rheumatoid Arthritis: A Nationwide, Population-Based, Propensity
Score-Matched Follow-Up Study
Chen Y T
Yang-Ming University, Taiwan, Taiwan
.
.
Objectives: Patients with RA suffer from a higher risk of periodontal attachment
loss and increased oral inflammation. There were few studies to access the utilization of dental care among RA in the Taiwan. The purpose is identify realize analyze
and discuss the dental use of diabetic patients, and the association between the risk
of rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and a history of periodontitis. Methods: retrospective
cohort studybased on the nationwide, population-based, NHIB used administrative data, case group consisted of 5,506 (age ≥ 18 years) patients with rheumatoid
arthritis (RA group) as the study group and 22,024 patients without RA attending
the Outpatient wing of Department of General Medicine formed the control group
(NRA group). Matched for Age, gender and RUB, Both groups were matched on 1:4.
Results: More advanced forms of periodontitis were found in RA patients compared with controls. The results showed that RA patients (66.9% of RA) had 5-years
utilization rate of dental care than non-RA patients (13.9% of non-RA). However,
people have RA or not, the characteristics of dental use were similar. Only has the
gender aspects to differ from, when the male suffered from RA, the utilization of
dental care were not different with the female. Conclusions: we propose that the
consulting rheumatologists inform the patients that they have a higher risk of periodontal. this study demonstrates an association between periodontitis and incident
RA. And the study is limited to lack of BMI, smoking, alcohol status.
PSS58
Macular Oedema Due to Retinal Vein Occlusion Methods for the
Identification of Treatment Guidelines and Areas of Unmet Clinical
Needs by Means of Systematic Review
Patel A S
Abacus International, Bicester, UK
.
.
Objectives: Retinal vein occlusion (RVO) causes macular oedema (MO), which
can lead to vision loss. The present study sought to identify treatment guidelines
internationally by conducting a systematic review and extensive hand searches.
The aims were to i) develop a systematic methodology for the identification of
such guidelines ii) review the guidelines and treatment pathways identified in
order to propose optimal positioning for an hypothetical intervention for the treatment of MO in RVO, and iii) to identify areas of unmet clinical needs. Methods:
A614
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Systematic searches in the electronic databases MEDLINE, EMBASE and The
Cochrane library were conducted and 53 online databases (including HTA agency
websites, international ministries of health, and clinical trials. gov) were hand
searched for clinical guidelines in the treatment of MO caused by RVO. Results:
Fifteen documents on treatment pathways or guidance used internationally were
identified from the hand searches. No papers or abstracts were found from the
electronic database searches. There were considerable between-jurisdiction differences in the guidance for the management of MO caused by RVO. These differences were consolidated to produce two amalgamated treatment pathways. In
total, eight treatment positions for interventions in the treatment of RVO subtypes
were identified. For one of the identified positions – treatment of ischaemic branch
RVO – no licensed treatment currently exists. Conclusions: The described systematic methodology for the construction of treatment pathways may be used
by manufacturers in early drug development decisions to identify unmet clinical needs, understand which treatment positioning may provide the most value,
and identify future treatment comparators in the same indication. Guidelines
to inform such commercial strategies may not be identifiable from electronic
database searches alone with extensive hand searches being a necessity. Between
jurisdiction guideline nuances also need to be taken into account when considering the target market for an intervention in development.
PSS59
Ophthalmology: Therapy Trends in Europe Based on Clinical Trial
Registry Data
Gupta A , Mukherjee B , Mahal S S , Mathews A
Novartis Healthcare Pvt Ltd, Hyderabad, India
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Ophthalmology pharmaceutical market is growing worldwide due
to rising aging population, new delivery technologies and changing lifestyle.
However, challenges like patent expiry of major brands and lack of awareness
still persists. Therefore, it is important to be aware of the upcoming treatment
options, changing patients’ needs and requirement of cost effective therapies.
This analysis provides an overview of the recent trends and future scenario in
Ophthalmology market. Methods: Pharmaceutical companies sponsored clinical
trials initiated from January 2011 to April 2014 in Glaucoma, Age-related Macular
Degeneration (AMD), Diabetic Retinopathy (DR) / Diabetic Macular Edema (DME),
Dry eye syndrome (DES) and Retinal vein occlusion (RVO) have been considered.
Only Phase I - III trials listed on public registries have been considered. Results:
The data showed that > 30% of the trials are being conducted on Glaucoma in
USA, Europe, Asia and Australia. This is followed by AMD (24%), DR/DME (21%),
DES (17%) and RVO (7%). Also, > 50% ophthalmological trials are being conducted
in USA; followed by Europe (~25%) and Asia (~20%). In Europe, 71 trials have been
conducted on 48 molecules, of which 69% are chemical entities, 19% are biologicals
and > 10% are entities like RNAi (oligonucleotide, aptamers), DARPin. Eye drops
(46%) and intravitreal injections (37%) are the key topical and parenteral formulations, respectively. 10% of the trials have been conducted on oral formulations. In
Europe, EU5 countries comprise of 43% of the trials and Germany has maximum 37
trials. Novartis has conducted trials in maximum 30 countries, followed by Santen
(19), Pfizer (15) and Allergan (13) in Europe. Conclusions: Based on the analysis,
currently, Glaucoma, AMD and DR/DME are the major focus of the companies in
ophthalmology. Though, biologicals and RNAi are being tested routinely, chemical
entities are foremost modalities. Similarly, eye drops remain as preferred method
of delivery with respect to other newer delivery techniques.
Research Poster Presentations - Session V
Disease-Specific Studies
CANCER – Clinical Outcomes Studies
PCN1
Treatment Patterns and Health Outcomes Among Patients with
Radioiodine-Refractory Differentiated Thyroid Cancer in the
United States and Western Europe
Gianoukakis A G 1, Flores N M 2, Pelletier C L 3, DiBonaventura M 2, Forsythe A 3, Wolfe G 2,
Rege J 3, Taylor M H 4
1University of California, Los Angeles, Torrance, CA, USA, 2Kantar Health, New York, NY, USA,
3Eisai Inc, Woodcliff Lake, NJ, USA, 4Oregon Health & Science University, Division of Hematology
& Medical Oncology, Portland, OR, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Most patients with differentiated thyroid cancer (DTC) have an
excellent prognosis after receiving standard treatment, consisting of surgery and
often adjuvant radioactive iodine (RAI). However, a subgroup of patients prove to
have progressive DTC which is refractory to RAI (RRDTC). Treatment options for
RRDTC are limited. This study investigated the treatment patterns and health care
resource utilization of patients with RRDTC. Methods: Data were collected by
performing a retrospective chart review study in the US and 5EU (France, Germany,
Italy, Spain, UK) with physicians recruited from an online panel. Physicians provided clinical information on 1 to 4 of their RRDTC patients in an online survey.
Demographics, disease history, treatment information, and health care resource
were included and reported descriptively. Health care resource use was compared
across treatment classes using general linear models. Results: 231 physicians
participated and provided a total of 700 patient charts (44.1% of charts were from
the US and 11-12% from each 5EU country). 45.0% of patients were male with a
mean age at diagnosis of 55.1 years [SD= 12.4]. 52.0% of patients were treated
with systemic treatment (e.g., 16.9% tyrosine kinase inhibitors [TKIs] only; 13.3%
chemotherapy only). The remaining 48.0% were either in a watch and wait (“WW”)
period (20.1%) or were managed with non-systemic palliative therapies (27.9%; eg,
external beam radiation). Overall, patients averaged 15.87 days hospitalized per
year (due to disease related complications or side effects). Although not statisti-
cally significant (p> .05), a trend toward more days hospitalized from disease-associated complications was observed for patients managed with WW (Mean= 9.21,
respectively) and non-systemic treatment (Mean= 8.27) than patients treated
with chemotherapy (Mean= 7.25) or TKIs (Mean= 8.22). Conclusions: Among
patients diagnosed with RRDTC, watch and wait and non-systemic treatment
options remain common. A large direct cost burden may be observed given the
frequent and long hospital stays.
PCN2
Approving Drugs Based on Early Stage Data - How Phase II Trial Data
Correlates with Phase III Outcomes. Case Study: NSCLC
Macaulay R , Tan H
HERON Commercialization, London, UK
.
.
Objectives: There is increasing pressure on regulators from patients, physicians
and industry for earlier access to pharmaceuticals for serious diseases. In reaction,
in March 2014 the European Medicines Agency (EMA) announced it was piloting
adaptive licensing, and the Medicines and Health care products Regulatory Agency
(MHRA) unveiled their Early Access to Medicines Scheme. Nevertheless, there are
questions over how, and if, Phase II trial benefits can be predictive of clinical advantages in Phase III studies, which this research aims to address. Methods: Phase
III data of any Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer (NSCLC) oncologic appraised by the
EMA, or that had failed Phase III clinical trials, since 2002 was extracted along with
its corresponding Phase II data. Statistical tests were conducted using Pearson’s
coefficient correlation. Results: 12 oncologics were identified with both Phase
II and III readouts, 6 of which met their Phase III trial primary endpoint. Overall
Response Rates (ORRs) reported in Phase II trials varied from 0%-61% (mean 24%).
4/4 (100%) drugs with Phase II ORRs > 30% met their primary endpoint vs. only
2/8 (25%) with ORRs ≤ 30%. Phase II ORRs were strongly correlated with Phase III
Progression-Free Survival (PFS) (r2= 0.864, p< 0.0005) and Overall Survival (OS) outcomes (r2= 0.858, p< 0.001). Nevertheless, 5/6 drugs that failed their Phase III primary
endpoints had comparative Phase II data indicating benefits versus these same
comparators, most notably onartuzumab, whose Phase III trial was terminated early
due to lack of efficacy, despite demonstrating significant OS benefits of 8.8 months
in Phase II. Conclusions: In NSCLC, Phase II ORRs can be strongly predictive of
the magnitude of PFS and OS readouts in Phase III trials. However, comparative
advantages in Phase II trials seem to be poorly predictive of OS benefits in Phase
III studies, raising questions over the appropriateness of approving drugs on early
stage comparative data.
PCN4
Cervical Human Papilloma Virus (HPV) DNA Primary Screening Test
Results of the Experience of a Regional Laboratory in Central Italy
Passamonti B U 1, Bulletti S 1, Gustinucci D 1, Martinelli N 1, D’Amico M R 1, Spita N 1,
Malaspina M 1, Carlani A 1, DI Dato E 1, Galeazzi P 1, Tintori B 1, D’angelo V 1, Calvi C 2
1Centro Unico di Screening Regione Umbria, PERUGIA, Italy, 2ROCHE DIAGNOSTICS, MONZA,
Italy
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To investigate feasibility and effectiveness of a cervical screening
program with DNA tests as preliminary assay versus usual cytology protocols in
Umbria Region. Methods: A large cohort of 35-64 aged women afferent to the
unique regional laboratory was considered. The usual algorithm with cervical cytology as primary test was followed in January 2008–June 2010, whereas in August
2010–October 2011 high-risk human papillomavirus (HR-HPV) DNA test was used
as primary screening. The cohorts were compared in terms of acceptance rate of
invitation, cytological results, molecular results including HPV genotype, detection
rate of histological lesions. Results: A total of 31,228 women were invited: 21,249
were suggested to undergo classical cervical cytology screening, 9,979 HR-HPV DNA
test as primary screening. A similar rate of adhesion (56.6% vs. 56.5%) was observed.
Age-related differences were evidenced, with younger women (35-49) more prone to
accept the invitation to HR-HPV DNA testing rather than usual cytology screening
(61.6% vs. 55.5%; p< 0.0001); analogously, uninvited younger women spontaneously
requesting cervical screening were more prone to specifically request molecular
than classical cytological testing (24.8% vs. 10.8%; p< 0.0001). Among the 6,272
HR-HPV DNA testing women, 396 (6.4%) were positive, and, among them, 141 (36%)
featured an altered cytology. All patients with altered cytology were suggested to
undergo colposcopy and 106 out of 141 (75.1%) answered to the invitation. Among
them, 89 (84%) featured abnormal histology with 48 (45.3%) CIN1 and 41 (38.7%)
CIN2. If comparing the CIN2 detection rate within the two studied periods, it was
almost doubled using the HR-HPV DNA than pap test as primary assay (0.64% vs.
0.37%; p= 0.005). Finally, the implementation of the DNA test screening program did
not increase total costs. Conclusions: although with some limits, the introduction of HR-HPV DNA primary testing resulted feasible and effective, significantly
increasing detection of severe lesions.
PCN5
Comparative Effectiveness of Treatments for Relapsed or
Refractory Mantle Cell Lymphoma (R/R MCL), Using Matching
Adjusted Indirect Comparison
Tongbram V 1, Sengupta N 2, Gaudig M 3, Sidhu M 1, Exuzides A 4, Colby C 4, Sanden S V 5,
McGovern A 1
1ICON Plc, Morristown, NJ, USA, 2Janssen Pharmaceuticals, Inc, Raritan, NJ, USA, 3Janssen
Pharmaceuticals, Inc, Neuss, Germany, 4ICON plc, San Francisco, CA, USA, 5Janssen
Pharmaceuticals, Inc., Beerse, Belgium
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Prognosis for relapsed or refractory (R/R) MCL patients with existing
treatments is poor; most patients progress within ~4 months. Ibrutinib, an oral once
daily Bruton’s tyrosine kinase inhibitor showed durable single agent activity with
good response rate in 111 R/R MCL patients and a median progression free survival
(PFS) of 13.9 months. Ibrutinib received breakthrough designation and United States
Food and Drugs Administration approval for use in MCL patients who received at
least one prior therapy (R/R MCL). This indirect analysis aims to compare the efficacy
A615
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
of ibrutinib to available treatments for R/R MCL patients. Methods: A systematic
literature review was conducted to identify clinical trials containing treatments of
R/R MCL. Matching adjusted indirect comparison (MAIC), described by Signorovitch
et al 2012, was utilized to obtain indirect relative treatment effect for ibrutinib
compared to other treatments. Using individual patient level data (IPD), baseline
characteristics of the ibrutinib trial patients were matched with the patients in the
published studies to obtain overall response (ORR) and complete response (CR) rates
based on balanced population between the ibrutinib and published studies. Kaplan
Meir curves for overall survival and PFS of comparators were plotted alongside those
of the matched ibrutinib patients. Results: Nineteen studies evaluating various
treatments were identified. Five trials evaluating bortezomib, BR (bendamustine,
rituximab), FCM (fludarabine, cyclophosphamide, mitoxantrone), FCM-R (fludarabine, cyclophosphamide, mitoxantrone, rituximab), and rituximab-hyper-CVAD
were considered for matching. Complete matching of the IPD was possible for the
bortezomib, FCM and FCM-R studies. Ibrutinib showed statistically significant better odds of achieving ORR compared to bortezomib (OR 3.62; 95% CI 1.18-11.14) and
FCM (OR 3.22; 95% CI 1.01-10.26). Conclusions: The indirect analysis suggests a
potential for improved ORR compared to a few relevant treatments in patients with
R/R MCL. Phase III comparative confirmatory data with ibrutinib are anticipated
in late 2014.
PCN6
Overall Survival in Patients with HER2+ Early Stage Breast Cancer
Patients Treated with Trastuzumab in the US Department of
Defense Practice Setting
Gallagher C M 1, More K 2, Masaquel A S 3, Kamath T 3, Guerin A 4, Ionescu-Ittu R 4, GauthierLoiselle M 4, Nitulescu R 4, Sicignano N 5, Barnett B 3, Wu EQ6
1Walter Reed National Military Medical Center, Bethesda, MD, USA, 2Naval Medical Center
Portsmouth, Portsmouth, VA, USA, 3Genentech, South San Francisco, CA, USA, 4Analysis Group,
Inc., Montréal, QC, Canada, 5Health ResearchTx, Trevose, VA, USA, 6Analysis Group, Inc., Boston,
MA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The NSABP/NCCTG trial (Romond et al. NEJM 2005; 353: 1673-1684)
established the efficacy of trastuzumab in the adjuvant treatment of HER2+ early
stage breast cancer (HER2+BC). Yet, little is known about the patterns of use and
outcomes of adjuvant trastuzumab in clinical practice. The study aimed to estimate the overall survival (OS) and relapse-free survival (RFS) of HER2+BC patients
treated with adjuvant trastuzumab in the US Department of Defense (DOD) practice setting. Methods: Adult women initiating adjuvant trastuzumab within 1
year of BC surgery were identified in the DOD health claims database (01/200312/2012). An algorithm based on secondary neoplasm ICD9 codes and treatment
gaps and initiations was used to identify relapses. OS and RFS unadjusted rates
at 3 and 4 years after the initiation of the adjuvant trastuzumab treatment were
estimated from Kaplan-Meier plots. Results: The study sample included 3,188
women (median age 63 years), followed for a median of 3.3 years after the initiation of trastuzumab and treated continuously with trastuzumab for a median of
12 months. Of these 3,188 women, 13.8% received neo-adjuvant therapy prior to
the surgery, 17.7% relapsed, and 7.9% died during the follow-up. The OS rates at 3
and 4 years were 93.2% (95% CI 92.1%-94.2%) and 90.0% (88.6%-91.2%), respectively.
The corresponding RFS rates were 78.8% (77.1%-80.3%) and 75.8% (74.0%-77.5%),
respectively. Conclusions: The findings suggest that most HER2+BC patients in
the DOD practice setting received per-label trastuzumab treatment (for 52 weeks)
and had OS rates that are similar to the OS rates that were previously observed
in the NSABP/NCCTG clinical trial (90.0% vs. 93% at four years). The lower RFS
rates observed in this study versus the NSABP/NCCTG trial (75.8% vs. 85.7% at
4 years), may be partially explained by differences in the characteristics of the
patients, including age.
PCN7
The Relative Efficacy of Treatments in First-Line Management
of Newly Diagnosed Chronic Myeloid Leukaemia: Systematic
Literature Review and Indirect Comparison
Kroes M 1, Zagorska A 2, Osei-Assibey G 1, Paine A 3
1Abacus International, Bicester, Oxfordshire, UK, 2Bristol-Myers Squibb, Rueil-Malmaison, France,
3Zedediah Consulting, Wokingham, Berkshire, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess the relative efficacy of first-line treatments in chronic myeloid leukaemia (CML), an updated systematic literature review (SLR) and indirect
comparison (IC) were conducted with follow-up period up to 48 months. Methods:
We updated a SLR initially conducted in 2011. Medical databases were interrogated
systematically in January 2014 to identify trials comparing first-line treatments for
CML. Using a fixed-effect Bayesian model implemented in WinBUGS, ICs were made
to calculate relative efficacy (cumulative complete cytogenetic response (CCyR) and
major molecular response (MMR)) for dasatinib, nilotinib and imatinib. Results:
Nineteen randomised controlled trials (RCTs) were included in the SLR, 10 were
eligible for inclusion in the IC. Compared with imatinib 400mg by 12 months, odds
of cumulative CCyR were significantly greater for dasatinib 100mg [odds ratio (OR)
2.25,95% credible interval (CrI) 1.55-3.15], nilotinib 600mg [OR 2.23 (95% CrI 1.503.21)] and 800mg [OR 1.94 (95% CrI 1.31-2.78)]. By 24 months compared with imatinib
400mg, the odds remained significantly higher with nilotinib 600mg [OR 2.03 (95%
CrI 1.28-3.10)] and 800mg [OR 1.70 (95% CrI 1.08-2.55)] and higher, but not significant with dasatinib 100mg [OR 1.41 (95% CrI 0.85-2.22)]. By 12,24,36 and 48 months
respectively, compared with imatinib 400mg, the odds of a MMR were: dasatinib
100mg [OR 2.22 (95% CrI 1.52-3.15) / 2.09 (1.45-2.93) / 1.76 (1.22-2.48) / 1.90 (1.27-2.74)]
nilotinib 600mg [OR 2.86 (95% CrI 1.95-4.08) / 3.24 (2.26-4.54) / 2.45 (1.70-3.43) / 2.54
(1.75-3.59)] and 800mg [OR 2.76 (95% CrI 1.88-3.94) / 2.60 (1.82-3.62) / 2.12 (1.48-2.95)/
2.18 (1.51-3.06)]. For both outcomes at all time points, there was no significant difference between dasatinib and nilotinib. Conclusions: Analysis including all available RCTs suggests that second-generation tyrosine kinase inhibitors dasatinib and
nilotinib are more efficacious than imatinib 400mg and should be treatments of
choice in newly diagnosed CML.
PCN8
Treatments for EGFR Mutation-Positive (M+) NSCLC Patients – A
Network Meta-Analysis (NMA) by Mutation Type
Popat S 1, Yang J C H 2, Lungershausen J 3, Griebsch I 3, Marten A 4, Wu Y L 5
1Royal Marsden Hospital, London, UK, 2National Taiwan University, Taipei, Taiwan, 3Boehringer
Ingelheim GmbH, Ingelheim am Rhein, Germany, 4Boehringer Ingelheim Pharma GmbH & Co. KG,
Ingelheim, Germany, 5Guangdong Lung Cancer Institute, Guangzhou, China
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Lung cancer is one of the most common causes of cancer-related
deaths world-wide. Afatinib is an irreversible ErbB family blocker showing superior
efficacy in EGFRm+ NSCLC as 1st-line treatment compared to standard-of-care
chemotherapy. To date, no head-to-head trial results exist to compare afatinib, gefitinib or erlotinib. Previous NMAs have compared the three treatments on an ITT
level, but not by mutation type. This analysis attempts to fill this gap. Methods:
Based on the EGFRm+ study network requested by NICE a Bayesian approach NMA
was conducted to estimate relative treatment effects of afatinib versus erlotinib and
gefitinib for progression free survival (PFS) and overall survival (OS) per mutation
type (common mutations: Del19 and L858R). Results: 9 studies were included,
8 reported PFS and 5 OS by mutation type, respectively. Results from fixed effects
models are reported. Afatinib significantly improved PFS in common mutations
versus gefitinib (HR 0.43: CrI 0.24; 0.75) and erlotinib (HR 0.60; CrI 0.39; 0.91). Results
also favored afatinib for both EGFR mutation subgroups Del19 and L858R, but did
not reach statistical significance. Afatinib showed a high probability (> 80%) of being
the best treatment both for common mutations and per mutation type. For OS, a
trend favoring afatinib was shown in particular for Del19. The probability of afatinib
being best for Del19 was > 70%. For L858R no difference in OS was detected between
the TKIs. Conclusions: In line with findings from previous NMAs, this analysis
by mutation type confirms both for PFS and OS a consistent trend towards superiority of afatinib versus reversible TKIs. Afatinib appears to be the best treatment
option for patients with common mutations, in particular Del19 mutations. A direct
trial-based comparison of the efficacy of these agents is warranted to clarify their
relative benefits.
PCN9
Health Care Costs in Patients Treated with Ipilimumab for
Advanced Melanoma Results of a Retrospective Chart Review
Tarhini A 1, Rao A S 2, Corman S 3, Botteman M 4, Ji X 4, Mehta S 3, Margolin K 5
1University of Pittsburgh Cancer Institute, Pittsburgh, PA, USA, 2Bristol-Myers Squibb, Plainsboro,
NJ, USA, 3Pharmerit International, Bethesda, MD, USA, 4Pharmerit US Bethesda, Bethesda, MD,
USA, 5Seattle Cancer Care Alliance, Seattle, WA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: This analysis described health care costs over time—excluding ipilimumab drug costs—stratified by survival duration and baseline ECOG status, in
patients receiving ipilimumab for advanced melanoma in the US community setting. Methods: We analyzed data from a retrospective chart review of patients
with unresectable stage III/IV melanoma treated with ipilimumab as first-line
monotherapy between 04/2011 and 09/2012. Hospitalizations, emergency department visits, subsequent chemotherapy, radiation, surgeries, nursing home, and
hospice visits costs were estimated using published sources and tariffs. Total costs,
excluding ipilimumab drug costs, were calculated for 3 periods: treatment regimen
(between first and last ipilimumab doses); post-regimen; and pre-death (within 90
days of death). Monthly costs were compared for the total population and stratified
by baseline ECOG status (0 vs. ≥ 1, when available) and survival (< 1 year vs. ≥ 1 year)
using Wilcoxon rank sum tests. Results: Data were abstracted from 273 patient
charts at 34 sites. Excluding ipilimumab drug costs, total monthly costs during the
treatment regimen, post-regimen, and pre-death periods were $690, $2151, and
$5123, respectively. Total monthly costs across all study periods were higher for
patients with ECOG ≥ 1 (n= 135) vs. ECOG= 0 (n= 104) (p= 0.0294), particularly in the
pre-death period ($5987 vs. $3460, respectively; p= 0.0143). A similar pattern was
observed for patients surviving < 1 year (n= 109) vs. ≥ 1 year (n= 122) (p< 0.0001), with
a difference of $9524 vs. $2955 (p< 0.0001) during the pre-death period (42 patients
still alive after < 1 year follow-up were excluded from this analysis). Key cost drivers
were hospitalizations (32.4% of total costs), followed by non-ipilimumab chemotherapy (23.1%), hospice care (19.1%), and nursing home stays (12.5%). Conclusions:
In this population, monthly costs were significantly lower during the treatment
regimen period than in subsequent periods. Survival ≥ 1 year and baseline ECOG= 0
were associated with significantly lower total monthly costs, particularly in the
pre-death period.
PCN10
Systematic Review of Relapsed or Refractory Mantle Cell
Lymphoma (MCL) Clinical Trials: Implications for Decision Modeling
Sorensen S 1, Dorman E 1, Xu Y 2, Sallum R 2, Pan F 1, Szatkowski A 2, Gaudig M 3, Sengupta N 4
Pharmaceuticals, Inc,
Neuss, Germany, 4Janssen Pharmaceuticals, Inc, Raritan, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Evidera, Bethesda, MD, USA, 2Evidera, Lexington, MA, USA, 3Janssen
Objectives: No standard of care exists for patients with relapsed or refractory
mantle cell lymphoma (MCL) and treatment options are limited. This study sought
to synthesize the clinical evidence of current treatments for relapsed or refractory
MCL, its limitations, and discuss the implications for decision making. Methods:
A systematic literature review was conducted in MEDLINE of phase II, III, or IV
clinical trials published in English between January 1, 2001 and May 2, 2013.
Supplemental searches included EHA, AACR, ASCO, and ASH 2011–2013 conference proceedings. Results: Results of the review indicate a paucity of evidence
relevant for decision making. Of 808 records reviewed, 17 trials in the R/R MCL
population were identified, only three of which were randomized controlled trials;
all others were single-arm trials. For most treatments, only one trial was available.
These factors made it infeasible to conduct a meta-analysis or indirect comparison.
Furthermore, there was a large amount of heterogeneity in the patient populations, trial designs, and reported outcomes, making it difficult to compare outcomes
across trials. Finally, of the 17 trials identified, five reported progression-free survival (PFS) Kaplan–Meier (K-M) graphs and only three reported overall survival (OS)
A616
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
K-M graphs. Conclusions: Due to very limited availability of trials with robust
endpoints and long-term follow-up, alternative options for establishing comparative efficacy must be used for decision making in relapsed or refractory MCL. These
alternatives include implementing comparisons of single-arm trial data without
adjustment (i.e., via naïve comparison) or methods such as match-adjusted indirect comparison (MAIC) to derive comparative estimates. MAIC is a relatively novel
method and may be difficult to implement given the heterogeneity in trial designs
and patient-level characteristics in MCL trials. The scarcity of K-M data to inform
PFS and OS of certain comparators further limits the comparisons that can be made
through modeling.
PCN11
The Efficacy of Current Treatment Options for Metastatic Cervical
Cancer
Palin H J 1, McCormick A L 1, Sabaté E 2
Clarity, Macclesfield, UK, 2F. Hoffmann - La Roche, Basel, Switzerland
.
.
.
.
.
1Complete
Objectives: The prognosis of patients with metastatic cervical cancer (CC) remains
poor, and treatment options are limited, with no single agent or combination of
agents recognised as standard of care; cisplatin/paclitaxel is the therapy most cited
by guidelines. This study aimed to assess the efficacy of reported treatment options
for patients with metastatic CC. Methods: Searches of PubMed were conducted,
with no date restrictions, to identify published randomised controlled Phase II/III
clinical trials (RCTs) of chemotherapies recommended by treatment guidelines,
and radiotherapy and/or surgery, that reported overall survival (OS) in patients with
metastatic (systemic recurrent, persistent or de novo-metastatic) CC. Treatment
guidelines and the Cochrane Library were also explored to identify additional citations. Results: Of 65 articles identified, 10 articles published between 1987 and
2014 proceeded to data extraction. Evidence supporting the use of chemotherapy
was limited to cisplatin-monotherapy or platinum-based combination therapy.
Overall the OS benefit of these agents ranged from 0.9 to 2.9 months and 0.79 to
1.32 for hazard ratio (HR). The latest innovation, bevacizumab plus chemotherapy,
demonstrated the greatest significant gain in OS versus chemotherapy (OS gain
3.7 months; HR 0.71; p= 0.004). The study did not identify any RCTs that supported
the use of surgery and/or radiotherapy in this setting; the evidence was limited to
seven retrospective hospital based studies. Conclusions: This study highlighted
an unmet need for additional treatment options for metastatic CC. Use of cisplatin-monotherapy or platinum-based combination therapy has provided limited
survival benefits for many decades. The novel combination of bevacizumab plus
chemotherapy has demonstrated an increase in survival in these patients. However,
since there is no RCT evidence supporting the use of surgery and/or radiotherapy,
a health technology appraisal of these alternative interventions is not currently
feasible. Additional clinical research is urgently needed to assess the comparative
clinical value of these therapies.
PCN12
Comparison of Mean Overall Survival (OS) and Radiographic
Progression Free Survival (RPFS) Based on Matching Adjusted
Indirect Comparison of Abiraterone Acetate and Enzalutamide
for the Treatment of Castration-Resistant Prostate Cancer in
Chemotherapy Naïve Patients
Dearden L 1, Majer I 2, Heeg B 2, Liwing J 3, Sandstrom K 3, Diels J 4
1Janssen, High Wycombe, UK, 2Pharmerit International, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 3JanssenCilag AB, Sollentuna, Sweden, 4Janssen Research & Development, Beerse, Belgium
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Abiraterone acetate plus predniso(lo)ne (AA) and enzalutamide (E)
are novel therapies for the treatment of metastatic castration-resistant prostate
cancer in chemotherapy naïve patients. Pivotal trials have been conducted evaluating the efficacy of the drugs using different comparators. In the COU-AA-302
trial, patients were randomised between AA and active comparator predniso(lo)
ne whereas in the PREVAIL trial, E was compared against placebo. For health
economic purposes, the mean overall survival (OS) and radiographic progressionfree survival (rPFS) of both novel agents need to be compared in the absence
of head-to-head trial data. Methods: Due to the difference in the comparator
arms, only survival data from AA and E were used for the comparison. Observed
individual level survival data with baseline patient characteristics were available
for AA. Individual survival data were simulated for E to replicate the rPFS and OS
curves published for the pivotal trial. rPFS and OS were modeled and extrapolated
by fitting parametric survival functions. The Weibull, exponential, and lognormal models were evaluated based on statistical and clinical considerations, i.e.
assessing the model fit and the implied hazard profiles, respectively. To control
for differences in baseline patient characteristics (PSA, ECOG, Gleason score, BPI,
LDH, metastasis, age, race) rPFS and OS estimates for AA were adjusted using a
matching algorithm. Results: The Weibull models were selected for extrapolation of both OS and rPFS. The mean rPFS was estimated to be 23.9 (95% CI:
21.5-26.3) and 19.5 (95% CI: 16.0-23.9) months for AA and E respectively. Mean OS
was estimated to be 38.7 (95% CI: 36.4-40.7) and 34.6 (95% CI: 31.8-37.8) months
respectively. Conclusions: Based on currently available data and the presented
modeling approach, these findings suggest that AA is associated with longer mean
rPFS and OS than E.
PCN13
Clinical Effectiveness of Robotic Image-Guided Stereotactic
Radiosurgery (CyberKnife) in Selected Primary and Secondary Soft
Tissue Neoplasms: A Systematic Review
Wlodarczyk A , Ceglowska U , Slomka M , Luchowska K
Agency for Health Technology Assessment In Poland (AHTAPol), Warsaw, Poland
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Effectiveness of radiosurgery for head and spinal neoplasms is
established. The aim of this study was to systematically review the clinical literature of CyberKnife for people with selected primary and secondary soft tissue
lesions. Methods: A systematic search was conducted for best available clini-
cal data for lung metastasis, primary and secondary liver cancer, locally advanced
pancreatic cancer population treated with CyberKnife radiation. Searching using
Medline, EMBASE, Cochrane Library took place in September 2013. Results: Only
one relevant comparative clinical study (matched-pair analysis) met the inclusion
criteria, assessing effectiveness and safety of stereotactic radiosurgery and radiofrequency ablation for colorectal liver metastasis. For other neoplasms single-arm
studies were found. Compared to RFA CyberKnife for liver metastasis was significantly better in median local disease free survival, which was 34.4 months vs. 6.0
months, (p< 0.001). 1 and 2-year local control rates also favored CK (85.0% vs. 65.0%
and 80.0% vs. 61.0%, respectively) but the difference wasn’t significant. However,
trend for better OS was found with RFA (34.4 vs. 52.3 months). For lung metastasis,
treatment with CK resulted in 24.0-62.0% complete or partial response, 38.0-76.0%
patients stabilized. In primary liver tumors OR (CR + PR) was observed in 63.0-86.0%
patients, 0.0-29.0% stabilized, median PFS reached 10.0-15.8 months. Inconsistent
results were seen in locally advanced pancreatic cancer population. In one study
92.0% responded or stabilized but in other only 1 patient of 77 had PR. Median OS
was 6.4-10.3 months. All studies reported mostly mild adverse events after CK.
Serious AE were rare. Conclusions: There is limited quality evidence on the
effectiveness and safety of robotic image-guided stereotactic radiosurgery in
patients with soft tissue neoplasms. Available studies are highly heterogenic in
methods, patients characteristics and outcomes but suggest that CyberKnife may
be beneficial in local tumor control. There is a need of well-designed comparative
studies.
PCN14
Analysis of Treatment Options for Relapsed or Refractory Chronic
Lymphocytic Leukemia (CLL)
Sallum R 1, Dorman E 2, Xu Y 1, Tran-Kerr K 1, O’Donnell M 1, Sorensen S 2, Szatkowski A 1,
Sengupta N 3, Gaudig M 4
1Evidera, Lexington, MA, USA, 2Evidera, Bethesda, MD, USA, 3Janssen Pharmaceuticals, Inc,
Raritan, NJ, USA, 4Janssen Pharmaceuticals, Inc, Neuss, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: For patients with relapsed or refractory (R/R) chronic lymphocytic
leukemia (CLL), treatment outcomes are poor and treatment options are limited.
Ibrutinib is an oral, once-a-day, first-in-class covalent inhibitor of Bruton’s tyrosine
kinase approved by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for R/R CLL. In a recent
phase III trial (PCYC-1112), ibrutinib was associated with improved progression-free
survival (PFS, hazard ratio [HR] = 0.215) and overall survival (OS, HR= 0.387) versus
ofatumumab. The aim of this study is to provide a summary and analysis of results
observed with current therapies in high-risk patients with R/R CLL. Methods:
A systematic literature review and targeted literature search of clinical trials and
international treatment guidelines in PubMed/MEDLINE (January 1,2001–April
28,2013) and ASCO/ASH/EHA conference proceedings (2011–2013) were conducted
to identify and evaluate current treatment options for R/R CLL, including alemtuzumab, rituximab, bendamustine, chlorambucil, and ofatumumab. Results:
Study results highlight poor outcomes with existing treatment options and
continuously high unmet need in patients. Sixteen trials were identified; the
majorities were single-arm with small sample sizes, making comparative effectiveness difficult to establish. Time-to-treatment failure was 5.8 months with
alemtuzumab, while median PFS was 5.5 months with rituximab, 5.5–5.7 months
with ofatumumab, 8 months with chlorambucil-ritiximab, and 15.2 months in
previously-treated patients and 6.8 months in previously-treated patients with
del (17p) with bendamustine-rituximab. Ofatumumab has demonstrated activity in patients with difficult-to-treat, high-risk CLL and is the only recognized
and approved treatment by health authorities globally in this treatment setting
and recommended in treatment guidelines. Conclusions: The lack of standard
of care creates challenges for defining comparators in clinical trials and health
technology assessments. In R/R CLL with high-risk features, ofatumumab is an
appropriate comparator. Interim results from the phase III RESONATE trial showed
that ibrutinib achieved significantly improved efficacy versus ofatumumab, even
in high-risk disease patients.
PCN15
An Indirect Treatment Comparison of Cabozantinib Verse
Vandetanib in Progressive Medullary Thyroid Cancer (MTC)
Rinciog C 1, Myrén K J 2, Aldén M 2, Diamantopoulos A 1, LeReun C 3
Limited, Borehamwood, UK, 2Sobi, Solna, Sweden, 3Independent Biostatistician,
Carrigaline county, Ireland
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Symmetron
Objectives: MTC is a rare form of thyroid cancer with prevalence of less than 7 per
100,000. A majority of MTC patients have RET mutations, and RET M918T mutations
are associated with especially poor prognosis. In 2012, EMA approved the first tyrosine kinase inhibitor (TKI) CAPRELSA® (vandetanib, VDB) for the treatment of MTC.
In March 2014, the EMA approved another TKI -COMETRIQ® (cabozantinib, CBZ) for
the treatment of adult patients with progressive, unresectable locally advanced or
metastatic MTC, with orphan drug status. The objective of this study was to assess the
relative efficacy in PFS and OS of CBZ vs VDB. Methods: Since there are no clinical
trials directly comparing the two treatments, an adjusted indirect comparison (Bucher
et al. method) was used. Evidence on PFS for the two treatments was collected from
the pivotal clinical trials in MTC. The analysis considered all patients and a subgroup
of RET M918T mutation positive (RET+) patients. Our analysis focused on PFS due
to lack of evidence for the VDB OS in the RET M918T mutation subgroup. In the all
patients analysis three different scenarios were explored: a logrank model to ensure
comparability with the VDB data; a Cox model stratified on age at randomization and
prior TKI status; and a Cox model without stratifications. Results: In the subgroup
analysis (logrank model) PFS was estimated to increase by 65% with CBZ comparing
to VDB (HR 0.35; 95% CI 0.14-0.87). In the all-patients analysis the estimates were less
conclusive: logrank model (HR 0.72; 0.40-1.28), Cox model with stratifications (HR 0.61;
0.35-1.04), Cox model without stratifications (HR 0.66; 0.39-1.13). Conclusions: The
results showed a positive trend in favour of CBZ in PFS. Given the limited evidence a
direct head-to-head comparison is necessary to validate the study findings.
A617
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PCN16
A Systematic Literature Review to Identify Trials in First-Line Ras
Wild-Type (WT) Metastatic Colorectal Cancer (MCRC) Patients
Jarrett J 1, Weijers L 2, Hnoosh A 3, Harty G 3, von Hohnhorst P 4
- HEOR & Strategic Market Access, Houten, The Netherlands, 3Merck
Serono Ltd., UK, UK, 4Merck Serono, Darmstadt, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
1MAPI, London, UK, 2Mapi
Objectives: The aim was at assembling published evidence on treatments for RAS
wild-type (wt) (KRAS and NRAS exon 2,3,4) metastatic colorectal cancer (mCRC)
to evaluate the efficacy and safety of cetuximab in combination with FOLFOX or
FOLFIRI chemotherapy as first line treatment of these patients. The outcomes of
interest were progression free survival (PFS), overall survival (OS), overall response
(ORR), and adverse event data. Methods: A systematic literature search was performed on the 24th March 2014 in Medline, Embase, and The Cochrane Library to
identify all randomized controlled trials (RCTs) as well as single arm trials concerning the efficacy and safety of first line interventions of interest in patients with
RAS wt mCRC. Abstract and article selection was performed by two independent
researchers, with a third person resolving disagreements, according to predefined
standards, which were based on criteria for patient, intervention, comparator,
outcomes and study design (PICOS). Results: 596 citations were identified after
removing duplicates. 520 citations were excluded for reasons including: patient
population (231), study design (174), intervention (74), outcomes (23) and duplicates
(18). A total of 76 abstracts were included and the full-text version of these publications were retrieved and screened resulting in excluding 69 further publications due
to the study design (20), patient population (43), outcomes (5), and one (1) duplicate,
not being in line with the review selection criteria. Ten citations on five different
RCTs were identified that met the inclusion criteria. Conclusions: This systematic review provided the latest studies on RAS wild-type (wt) metastatic colorectal
cancer (mCRC) treatments. Despite the small number of studies available for a
relatively new biomarker-specific mCRC, anti- EGFR treatments such as cetuximab
in combination with FOLFOX and FOLFIRI have demonstrated a significant benefit
in progression free survival (PFS), overall survival (OS) and overall response rate
(ORR) versus chemotherapy alone in mCRC RAS wt patients.
PCN20
Characteristics of Patients with Pleural Mesothelioma in the
Russian Federation
Gorbounova V A 1, Bychkov M B 1, Vladimirova L Y 2, Levchenko E V 3, Karpenko T D 1,
Mamontov O Y 3, Burmistrov V 4, Novick D 5, Rajan N 6, Sholokhova E 4, Solovyenko Y 4,
Tjulandin S A 1
1N.N. Blokhin Russian Cancer Research Center, Moscow, Russia, 2Rostov Scientific Research
Oncological Institute, Rostov-on-Don, Russia, 3N.N. Petrov Research Oncology Institute, SaintPetersburg, Russia, 4Eli Lilly Vostok S.A., Moscow, Russia, 5Eli Lilly Holdings Limited, Windlesham,
UK, 6Eli Lilly Australia Pty Ltd, West Ryde, NSW, Australia
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Malignant pleural mesothelioma (MPM) is a rare tumour with a poor
survival and prognosis. In Russia, the epidemiology of this disease has not been well
studied. We conducted an epidemiological study to understand the characteristics of
patients with MPM in Russia. Methods: Retrospective study of the characteristics
of patients with MPM. Patients treated for 1st and 2ndline therapy were included
in ten centers of the Russian Federation. The data were generated from hospital
records, electronic databases, and other sources of information between June and
December in 2013. Results: One hundred and twelve patients were enrolled. The
average age was 60.0±10.87 years and 42% were women. Harmful work environment was indicated in 21/112 (18.8%) of the patients. The exposure to asbestos was
reported in 10/112 (8.9%) patients, and contact with erionite in 8/112 (7.1%) patients.
Fifty percent (56/112) of the patients were smokers or are current smokers; smoking
period was 25.3±13.25 years. The disease stage at diagnosis was I-II in 31 (27.6%),
III-IV in 81 (72.4 %) patients. The ECOG performance status was 0 in 16 (14.3%),
1 in 46 (41.1%), 2 in 30 (26.8%), 3 in 15 (13.4%) and 4 in 1 (0.9%) patients, in 4 patients
- unknown. 50/112 (44.6%) patients had immunohistochemical verification of the
diagnosis. Antineoplastic drugs were used to treat 85/112 (75.9%) patients. The main
drugs used were cisplatin (n= 75), gemcitabine (32), doxorubicin (34), pemetrexed
(29) and carboplatin (21). Conclusions: In Russia, the majority of MPM patients
were diagnosed at advanced stages of disease. In 80% of the cases, a harmful work
environment was not identified. Given the low prevalence and the frequent use
of off-label medicines, it can be considered an orphan disease. Limitations: Only
limited number of centres was included.
PCN21
First-Line Therapy for Patients With Multiple Myeloma: Direct and
Indirect Comparison of Treatment Regimens on the Existing Market
Kuhr K 1, Wirth D 2, Srivastava K 3, Lehmacher W 1, Hellmich M 1
1University of Cologne, Cologne, Germany, 2Janssen-Cilag, Neuss, Germany, 3Heron India,
Chandigarh, India
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Motivated by the discussion whether the german AMNOG is applied
to currently marketed drugs we compared first-line therapies for patients with
multiple myeloma (MM). Methods: A systematic literature search for randomized
controlled trials (RCTs) was conducted and VMP (bortezomib (Velcade), melphalan
and prednisone), MPT (melphalan, prednisone and thalidomide) and MP (melphalan and prednisone) were identified as therapies of interest. We extracted information on overall survival (OS), progression-free survival (PFS), response criteria
(CR, VGPR, PR), and grade 3-4 AEs (any, hematological, non-hematological, DVT,
PNP). Random-effects meta-analysis was used for direct and the Bucher method
for adjusted indirect treatment comparison. Results: Seven RCTs with a total of
2,367 patients were included in our analyses, one RCT (n= 682) comparing VMP vs.
MP and six RCTs (n= 1,685) comparing MPT vs. MP. Direct head-to-head comparison
of VMP vs. MPT was lacking. For MPT vs. MP, data were extracted from a recently
published meta-analysis of individual patient data if available. VMP was superior to
MP regarding OS. Both VMP and MPT were superior to MP regarding PFS and response
criteria, but had a higher risk of developing AEs. The indirect comparison of VMP
vs. MPT via MP showed a statistically not significant advantage for VMP regarding
survival outcomes. Significant benefits were observed for CR and development of
any grade 3-4 AEs favouring VMP. Conclusions: Analysis of both aggregated and
individual patient data essentially lead to the same conclusions, i.e. VMP and MPT
seem more effective than MP, VMP seems ahead of MPT regarding response criteria
and adverse events. We found significant between-trials heterogeneity, however
no consistent relationship of effect and study-level covariates (e.g. maintenance
dosing) was apparent. Thus, we relied on the random effects approach to metaanalysis to cope with the unexplained trial-to-trial variability. Our results may best
be confirmed by a head-to-head trial of VMP vs. MPT.
PCN22
What is the Clinical Effectiveness and Cost- Effectiveness
of Erythropoietin-Stimulating Agents for the Treatment of
Patients with Cancer-Treatment Induced Anaemia? Insights from
Cumulative Meta-Analyses (CMA) and Lessons for Cost-Effectiveness
Analyses
Huxley N , Haasova M , Crathorne L , Hyde C
University of Exeter, Exeter, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: A health technology assessment (HTA) informing the recent NICE
guidance regarding the use of erythropoiesis-stimulating agents (ESA) in cancertreatment induced anaemia (CIA) identified uncertainty around the overall survival
hazard ratio (OSHR). We investigated how the understanding of OS in CIA patients
treated with ESAs has shaped over time and the effects of accumulating OS evidence
on cost-effectiveness. In addition, the effects of narrowing inclusion criteria, by comparing the HTA results to a recent Cochrane review, were investigated. Methods:
CMA was applied to both HTA review and Cochrane review OS data to identify patterns in results; study results were accumulated by the year of publication. Annual
OSHR results from the CMA were applied to an economic model developed in the
HTA to calculate the cost-effectiveness of ESAs. Results: Precision of the OSHR
estimate appeared to improve with additional evidence, but the true location of the
estimate remained uncertain and the best estimate varied over time. Using the HTA
CMA, results from 2001 and 2002 suggested survival benefits to using ESAs (0.77, 95%
CI 0.60–0.98 and 0.78, 95% CI 0.65–0.93 respectively), with ESAs being cost-effective
at a willingness to pay threshold of £30,000 per QALY for all values of the OSHR 95%
CI. HTA CMA for all other years and all Cochrane CMA results did not suggest any
significant effects of ESAs on OS. Cost-effectiveness results were therefore uncertain. Conclusions: Current evidence suggests we cannot reject the possibility
of no difference in OS between patients receiving or not receiving ESAs, regardless
of study inclusion criteria. However, there is also insufficient evidence to support
such conclusions, particularly as earlier results from narrower inclusion criteria suggested some survival benefits. This analysis highlights the additional uncertainty of
the current evidence base on cost-effectiveness analyses, which cannot be captured
in standard sensitivity analyses.
PCN23
Bortezomib Re-treatment in Patients with Multiple Myeloma (MM).
A Real World Medical Practice Experience from a Swedish National
Registry
Thilakarathne P 1, Diels J 2, van Sanden S 3, Liwing J 4, Chirita O 5, Van Agthoven M 6, Nahi H 7
1Janssen Pharmaceutica N.V., Beerse, Belgium, 2Janssen Research & Development, Beerse, Belgium,
3EMEA HEMAR Analytics, Janssen EMEA, Beerse, Belgium, 4Janssen-Cilag AB, Sollentuna,
Sweden, 5Janssen, High Wycombe, UK, 6Janssen-Cilag BV, Tilburg, The Netherlands, 7Karolinska
University Hospital, Solna, Sweden
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The question of sequencing multiple myeloma (MM) treatments is a
key one, as is the retreatment in patients where the same treatment was effective
in earlier lines. We investigated bortezomib retreatment in a Swedish MM national
registry. Methods: Patients diagnosed with MM since January 2000 until June 2011
from 7 university clinics, 5 regional centers and 3 local hospitals in Sweden were
included. Time to response and overall survival (OS) were analyzed using stratified
Kaplan-Meier analysis. Results: Of the 541 patients treated with bortezomib (out
of a total population of n= 1638), 93 were retreated with bortezomib. Median followup from start of retreatment was 10.2 mos. Median age was 63.5 (range 38–83), 57.3%
were male, 34.2%/15.9%/20.7% had stage I/II/III disease (ISS); median number of
prior therapies at initial bortezomib and retreatment was 1 and 3. 26.8%/32.9% of
pts initiated retreatment as 3rd/4th line therapy. 37.8%/22.0% initiated bortezomib
retreatment in combination with dexamethasone, 7.3% in monotherapy, compared
to 40.3%, 21.8% and 8.5%, at initial bortezomib. ≥PR/VGPR-rates at re-treatment were
59.1%/12.7%, compared to 82.0%/39.9% at initial bortezomib. Median time to ≥ PR/
VGPR was 2.4/1.3 months at retreatment versus 1.9/2.1 at initial bortezomib. The
≥ PR rate at retreatment was numerically longer in patients with < = 2 (75.1%) vs > = 3
(20%) therapies prior to retreatment. Median PFS/OS from start of re-treatment was
5.5 [95%CI: 3.7, 10.0]/17.4 [10.3, 26] months, compared to 8.1 [6.9, 9.7]/25.9 months
[21.0, 31.6] for initial bortezomib. Number of prior therapies at retreatment did not
affect PFS; however, OS was longer in pts with fewer prior therapies (p= 0.0112).
There was a trend towards longer PFS (p= 0.087) in retreated patients who achieved
> = PR compared to non-responders. Conclusions: These data suggest that, in
everyday medical practice, bortezomib retreatment is effective in relapsed/refractory MM, with more than half of pts who responded to initial bortezomib achieving
≥ PR at retreatment.
PCN24
Treatment Sequencing Survival Model for Patients with Multiple
Myeloma Ineligible for Stem Cell Transplantation (SCT)
Heeg B 1, Van Agthoven M 2, van Beurden-Tan C 3, Liwing J 4, Mellqvist U H 5, Plesner T 6,
Logman F 7, Aschan J 4, Einsele H 8, Treur M 1, Barendse M 4, Richardson P G 9, Palumbo A 10,
Nahi H 11, Sonneveld P3
1Pharmerit International, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 2Janssen-Cilag BV, Tilburg, The
Netherlands, 3Erasmus University Medical Center, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 4Janssen-Cilag
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A618
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
AB, Sollentuna, Sweden, 5Department of Hematology, Gothenburg, Sweden, 6Vejle Hospital, Vejle,
Denmark, 7Eastbridge Pharma BV, Utrecht, The Netherlands, 8Medizinische Klinik II, Würzburg,
Germany, 9Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, Boston, MA, USA, 10University of Torino, Torino, Italy,
11Karolinska University Hospital, Solna, Sweden
Objectives: Treatment of multiple myeloma (MM) consists of a consecutive application of various treatment modalities. The optimal sequence of different treatment combinations is unclear. There is a need for the establishment of an analytic
framework comparing overall survival (OS) of different treatment sequences in MM.
This analysis contains the first attempt to create such a framework. Methods:
We performed a systematic literature review (SLR) on treatments compared in
randomized controlled trials in newly diagnosed and relapsed MM patients. The
following treatment/combinations were considered; melphalan/prednisone (MP),
dexamethasone (D), thalidomide (T), bortezomib (V) and lenalidomide (R). Response,
time to next treatment (TTNT) and OS data were extracted. Response rates were
derived and pooled for each treatment and treatment line using ordered logistic
network meta-analysis. The pooled estimates were combined in a Markov model
framework with treatment switch and mortality transition probabilities to predict
OS. Seventeen sequences were tested, one starting with MPR and four for each
starting with MP, MPT, MPV and MPVT. Results: Estimations on the basis of the
Markov model showed that median OS varied between 40-43,42-45,43,44-47 and
46-49 months for sequences starting with MP, MPT, MPR, MPV and MPVT, respectively. Conclusions: This study shows a first attempt to build an analytic framework comparing OS of treatment sequences in MM. The absolute results should be
interpreted with caution, as MM is a heterogeneous disease and the model does
not yet capture all subtleties related to sequential treatment in clinical practice.
However, face validity of these first results seem promising and warrant further
development of this analytic framework.
PCN25
Burden of Disease in Stage IV Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer:
Comparing ALK Positive and ALK Negative Mutation Status in Egypt,
Russia and the United Arab Emirates
Fisher M 1, De Renteria J 2, Kuehl M 3, Suponcic S 4, Dharamshi K 1
Health, Munich, Germany, 3Kantar Health, Epsom, UK, 4Kantar
Health, New York, NY, USA
.
.
.
.
.
1FIECON, London, UK, 2Kantar
Objectives: The effect of having a positive anaplastic lymphoma receptor tyrosine
kinase (ALK) mutation on the burden of disease in Stage IV non-small cell lung
cancer (NSCLC) is unknown. This study compared the burden of disease in ALK
positive Stage IV NSCLC with ALK negative Stage IV NSCLC. Methods: Burden
of disease by ALK mutation status was evaluated in Egypt, Russia, and the United
Arab Emirates (UAE) using disability adjusted life years (DALYs). A burden of disease
model was developed in line with World Health Organisation (WHO) guidelines.
Epidemiological data were collected by a survey disseminated during interviews in
at least three centres per country. Disability weights were obtained from a Dutch
study. Discounting, age-weighting and life expectancies were based on the WHO
reference case. Sensitivity analyses were conducted to test the level of uncertainty
in the model results. Results: Total DALYs across the countries were lower in ALK
positive disease compared to ALK negative disease (833 vs. 2611). On a per country
basis, total DALYs were higher in ALK positive disease compared to ALK negative
disease for Egypt (22 vs. 11) and UAE (229 vs. 219) but lower for Russia (582 vs.
2381). DALYs per incident case of the disease were consistently higher across the
countries in ALK positive disease compared to ALK negative disease (Egypt: 11.24
vs. 10.85; Russia: 9.38 vs. 4.97; UAE: 15.29 vs. 7.82). Results were sensitive to changes
in discounting, age-weighting, deaths, and incidences. Conclusions: The study
would suggest that the greatest burden of disease lies in the population with ALK
negative Stage IV NSCLC compared to ALK positive Stage IV NSCLC, although this
finding varied between countries. However, it was consistently found that a single
patient with Stage IV NSCLC will have a greater burden of disease if their ALK
mutation test is positive.
PCN26
Real-World Data on the Epidemiology and Treatment of HR +, HER2Advanced Breast Cancer in Postmenopausal Patients in Different
Regions of Russia for Forming Markov Models of Managment of
Patients
Krasnova L , Vorobiev P , Holownia M
Russian Society for Pharmacoeconomics and Outcomes Research, Moscow, Russia
.
.
.
Objectives: In Russia, breast cancer (BC) took first place in the structure of cancer
incidence and mortality in the female population. Modern therapeutic approaches
advanced breast cancer (ABC) can achieve clinically significant regression of symptoms, prolong life and improve its quality. Aim of this study was to conduct clinical
and epidemiological analysis of reference postmenopausal patients with hormone(HR+), HER2-ABC in Russia. Methods: Survey of experts from different regions
of Russia. The questionnaire included the following questions: the proportion of
patients with different types of breast cancer; drugs and modes of their appointment as the first, second and third-line treatment of patients postmenopausal
HR+, HER2-ABC; hospitalization rate per year; laboratory and instrumental methods
of research, consulting, adverse events with the use of drugs in the treatment of
patients and their drug regimes correction. Results: From 13 regions of Russia 7
experts refused to provide information on the questionnaire, which may indicate
a reluctance to disclose information on the epidemiology and the tactics of the
disease. Data were obtained from the regions - Moscow, Saint Petersburg, Republic
of Khakassia, Omsk region, Primorsky Krai, Krasnoyarsk Krai. Share of the growth
of new breast cancer patients is 10,5-29,6% (median 13.4%) per year. Number of
patients with ABC from patients with breast cancer is 9,2-53% (median-30%). On
average, 70% of patients with ABC are in menopause. Number of patients with HR+,
ER2-ABC at the end of 2013 amounted to Moscow-1772, St. Petersburg-492, Republic
of Khakassia-188, Omsk region-344, Primorsky Krai-358, Krasnoyarsk Krai-3471. The
average frequency of hospitalizations in these patients is 6 times a year. Proportion
of these patients receiving 3-line therapy differed significantly in Moscow and St.
Petersburg, as compared with other regions. Conclusions: Obtained clinical and
epidemiological data made it possible to fill in the model of management of patients
with breast cancer in particular regions of Russia.
PCN27
Projecting Health Gains: The Population Impact of New Treatments
to Metastatic Breast Cancer
Lucas R 1, Andrade S 2, Barros H 1
1Medical School, University of Porto, Porto, Portugal, 2Roche Farmaceutica Quimica, Amadora,
Portugal
.
.
.
Objectives: Breast cancer is a leading cause of oncological death among Portuguese
women but a decline in age-standardized mortality rates is well documented and
due to an increasing frequency of early diagnosis (more than 85% of the women
aged 45-69 years, underwent a screening mammography according to the most
recent national health survey) and access to more efficient treatments, including
adjuvant and neoadjuvant chemotherapy. However, certain tumor characteristics,
such as Human epidermal growth factor receptor 2 (HER2) -positive breast cancer,
are associated with poor prognosis for patients with both early and metastatic
breast cancer. Methods: Previous studies showed that trastuzumab was expected
to prevent metastases in about 700 women during 10 years if used in early breast
cancer, in Portugal. T-DM1 significantly prolonged progression-free (3 m) and overall survival (6 m) compared to lapatinib plus capecitabine in patients with HER2positive advanced breast cancer previously treated with trastuzumab and a taxane.
Also, the combination of pertuzumab, trastuzumab, docetaxel, as compared with
placebo, trastuzumab, docetaxel, when used as first-line treatment for HER2-positive
metastatic breast cancer, significantly prolonged progression-free survival. These
trials data and population epidemiological information is used to fit predictive
models adjusting for available confounders. Results: Although high quality data
on patients with HER2-positive metastatic disease regarding age and other potential
health differences is lacking, particularly in Portugal, we modeled population measures of frequency and applied data describing the clinical epidemiology of metastatic breast cancer to anticipate the potential impact of these treatment options on
the quality and the quantity of life of affected individuals, taking into consideration
the period 2014-24. Additionally, by contrasting the available alternatives, we will
present an estimation of the averted expenses regarding treatment options for the
same period. Conclusions: The study provides information on health gains and
evidence for decision making.
PCN28
Long-Term Trends in Breast Cancer Epidemiology in the Slovak
Republic
Ondrusova M , Psenkova M
Pharm-In Ltd, Bratislava, Slovak Republic
.
.
Objectives: The latest available published oncology national data from the Slovak
Republic (SR) are for year 2008. The objective of this analysis was to evaluate longterm national trends of breast cancer (BC) incidence, mortality, clinical stages and
prevalence to obtain more actual data for the purpose of cost-of-illness studies
and budget impact analysis in the SR. Methods: Time-trends of national data
on incidence, mortality, clinical stages and prevalence of BC in 1978-2008 were
analyzed by using joint-point regression (Version 4.0.4. - May 2013). The data were
predicted to the current year 2014. The trends are presented with a corresponding 95% Confidence Intervals (CI) and p-value with null hypothesis being constant
with time. Results: In 2008, BC age-standardized incidence in the SR represented
59.8/100,000 females (n= 2.639 cases, mean age of women= 61.9 y.), in 1978-2008 the
incidence was increasing continuously with annual percentage change (APC) of 2.2%
(95% CI= 2.1-2.3, p< 0.0001), estimation for 2014 is 63.8/100,000 (n= 3.081). Mortality
in 2008 represented 15.2/100,000 (n= 751) with four join-points and decreasing trend
from 2001 by APC -3.6% (95% CI= -7.2-0.1, p< 0.04), estimation for 2014 is 14.0/100,000
(n=820). National prevalence in 1978-2008 represents 22.118 cases, for 2014 estimate
is 29.012. According to the national data, in 2014 we estimate 32.6% of patients
diagnosed in the 1st clinical stage, 36.2% in the 2nd, 16.4% in the 3rd, 7.0% in the
4th and 7.8% in the undefined clinical stage. The number of cases diagnosed in the
1st clinical stage is increasing during the time. Despite the observed increase in the
values of BC incidence, the decrease in mortality has manifested itself in recent
years. Conclusions: Actual data on incidence, mortality, prevalence and clinical
stages of BC in the SR can be used as the source for setting the size of population
in cost-of-illness studies and budget impact analysis.
PCN29
The Importance of Long-Term Surveillance of Stage IB Melanomas:
Unexpectedly Low Survival Subsequent to Recurrence
Leeneman B 1, Franken M G 1, Blommestein H M 1, van Gils C W M 2, van der Meijde E 3,
Wouters M W J M 4, Plaisier P W 5, Kruit W H J 6, van Ruth S 7, ten Tije A J 8, Hendriks M P 9,
Coupe V M H 3, Uyl- de Groot CA1
1Erasmus University, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 2GlaxoSmithKline, Zeist, The Netherlands, 3VU
University Medical Center, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 4Netherlands Cancer Institute–Antoni
van Leeuwenhoek, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 5Albert Schweitzer Hospital, Dordrecht, The
Netherlands, 6Erasmus Medical Center, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 7Tergooi Hospital, Hilversum,
The Netherlands, 8Amphia Hospital, Breda, The Netherlands, 9Medical Center Alkmaar, Alkmaar,
The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Stage IB cutaneous melanomas are characterized by a low risk for
recurrence and a high survival. However, empirical evidence on recurrence patterns
and survival subsequent to recurrence is limited. We investigated overall survival
(OS) and recurrence patterns, and assessed whether the time-to-recurrence was
associated with prognostic factors. Methods: The Dutch Comprehensive Cancer
Centers registry was used to identify patients diagnosed with stage IB melanoma
between January 2003 and December 2011 in six Dutch hospitals including two
academic and four general hospitals (n= 971). Data were retrospectively collected
A619
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
using electronic hospital records. Survival was assessed using the Kaplan-Meier
estimator. Recurrence patterns were investigated by type of first recurrence and
time-to-recurrence. A multivariate cox regression was used to analyze whether
time-to-recurrence was associated with gender, age and tumor thickness. Emigrated
patients (n= 10) and patients with an unknown recurrence status (n= 144) were
excluded. Results: Of all 817 patients, 111 patients (13.6%) experienced disease
progression (median follow-up: 5.5 years). Patients who developed a recurrence had
a lower survival compared to patients who did not developed a recurrence (median
OS: 9.4 years versus median has not yet been reached; 5-year survival rate: 69.9%
versus 96.6%; p< 0.001). The most frequent type of first recurrence was lymphatic
(36.9%), followed by distant (22.5%), local (21.6%) and intralymphatic (9.9%), respectively. The median time-to-recurrence has not yet been reached; however, in case of
a recurrence, the median time-to-recurrence was 2.5 years (minimum: 0.01 years;
maximum: 9.8 years). The time-to-recurrence was not statistically significantly associated with gender (HR= 0.81; p= 0.29), age (HR= 1.01; p= 0.38) and tumor thickness
(HR= 1.03; p= 0.76). Conclusions: Long-term surveillance of stage IB melanomas
is of utmost importance, because survival subsequent to recurrence is much lower
than expected. The risk of developing a recurrence was substantial; however, the
time-to-recurrence was not associated with gender, age and tumor thickness.
PCN30
Epidemiology of Patients with Metastatic Castrate Resistant
Prostate Cancer in Europe and Australia
Marteau F 1, Gimonet G 1, Gabriel S 2, Dinet J 1, Flinois A 3, LE Cleac’h J Y 3
Pharma, Boulogne-Billancourt, France, 2IPSEN Pharma, Boulogne Billancourt, France,
3Kantar Health, Paris, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1IPSEN
Objectives: The objective of this study was to evaluate both the incidence
of metastatic Castrate Resistant Prostate Cancer (mCRPC) and the number of
mCRPC patients who receive specific mCRPC treatments (mCRPCTT): chemotherapy and second generation Hormone Therapies (ADT manipulations were
not included). Methods: This study was conducted in 8 European countries and
Australia The incidence of mCRPC patients was assessed using several sources:
national cancer registries, a literature review and an ad-hoc chart review where
292 oncologists, 76 onco-radiotherapists and 357 urologists reported information
about 4171 prostate cancer patients. Of these, 2401 had metastatic castrate resistant
disease. Patient characteristics and treatments received were assessed and reported
separately by country. Results: Across all 9 countries, 76 200 new patients were
diagnosed mCRPC over the past year. Of these patients, 35% (26 400 patients) went
to supportive care without receiving any mCRPC TT while 65% (49 800 patients)
received a 1L mCRPCTT. Prior to receiving any 1L mCRPCTT, 43% of patients had ADT
manipulations during a short transitional period (median duration = 1 month). Of
the 49 800 patients who received a 1L mCRPCTT, 59% (29 250) went to a 2L mCRPCTT,
15% deceased during or just after the 1L TT and 26% went on to receive supportive
care only. Of the 29 250 patients who received a 2L mCRPCTT, 46% (13 500) went to
a 3L mCRPCTT. Conclusions: Our methodology enabled us to assess incidence
figures and the volume of mCRPC patients who receive specific mCRPCTT: over
one-third of mCRPC patients did not receive any mCRPCTT. Among the 65% who
received a 1L TT, 59% receive a 2L mCRPCTT.
PCN31
Comparison of Epidemiology and Drug Treatment in HER2 Negative
Metastatic Breast Cancer (MBC) in EU5
Nersesyan K 1, Robinson D 1, Pomerantz D 2
Health, St Louis, MO, USA, 2Kantar Health, New York, NY, USA
.
.
.
1Kantar
Objectives: Explore differences/similarities in epidemiology and drug treatment
of metastatic breast cancer (MBC) in EU5. Methods: All data was derived from the
Kantar Health CancerMPact database, sources for which include country specific
cancer registries, published scientific studies and proprietary physician surveys
comprising 85 doctors seeing 9,255 patients per month. Age and gender specific
incidence rates, annual stage specific progression rates and annual stage specific
survival rates are used to calculate total number of surviving patients at a specific
stage up to 10 years after diagnosis. Results: Prevalence of BC ranged between
41-73 per 100K population across EU-5. Among BC patients, prevalence of MBC was
similar: 8% (UK, Italy) to 10% (Germany, France, Spain). Overall 62% of MBC patients
were diagnosed with HER2-negative disease (56% Germany-70% France). Among
these patients 35-40% had active disease and were treated with chemotherapy.
Patients with triple negative disease had had fewer lines of treatment than did
not triple negative. Patients who are HER2-negative generally receive between two
and three lines of chemo therapy on average. Second line chemotherapy regimens
varied. Capecitabine was the most common therapy (mono and combination) in
all countries ranging from 36% (UK) to 40% (Germany). 2nd and 3rdmost common
therapies were vinorelbine (23%-26%) and paclitaxel (20%-23%) in Germany, Italy
and Spain vs. docetaxel (18%-34%) and paclitaxel (11%-19%) in UK and France.
In third line, the most commonly used agents were capecitabine (16%-44%) and
vinorelbine (18%-26%). Eribulin was used in second line (3%-6%) and third line (11%19%) in all countries except for Spain. Conclusions: Capecitabine is the most
utilized chemotherapeutic agent in the second and third lines chemotherapy in
Western Europe for HER2-negative patients. A variety of other regimens, primarily
monotherapies, may also be used in later lines, including vinorelbine, gemcitabine,
eribulin, and docetaxel.
PCN32
Association of Diabetes and Cancer Diagnosis in Primary Care
Practices in France
Grandfils N , Ricarte C , Solomiac A
IMS Health, PARIS LA DEFENSE, France
.
.
.
Objectives: Several studies suggest that diabetes carries an increased risk for
a number of different cancer types. The aim of this study was to investigate the
incidence of 14 different cancer types in the diabetic and non-diabetic popula-
tion. Methods: IMS Disease Analyzer™ (DA) database was used, focusing on
patients with or without diabetes in general practice in France. The analysis was
performed retrospectively from 2001 to 2013. The Hazard Ratios (HR; Cox regression) for the risk of cancer in diabetic versus non-diabetic patients were adjusted
for demographic and clinical variables. IMS Oncology Analyzer™ (OA) database was
also used to describe the cancer patient profile in 2013. Results: Overall 3.1% of
patients in DA are diabetic. 75,104 patients were diagnosed with type-2 Diabetes
Mellitus (T2DM). This population was matched to a control group in terms of age
(60±15 years) and gender (male: 52%). The overall risk of cancer was lower in T2DM
patients than in patients without diabetes (HR: 0.81; CI: 0.76 to 0.85). Those patients
were less likely to develop breast, prostate, lung cancer or non-hodgkin lymphoma.
Nevertheless, their risk was significantly higher regarding liver cancer (HR: 1.99; CI:
1.46 to 2.72), pancreatic cancer (HR: 2.13; CI: 1.51 to 3.00) and endometrial cancer
(HR: 1.25; CI: 1.01 to 1.55). No significant increase in risk was observed in colorectal,
stomach, kidney, thyroid, urinary bladder, gall bladder and oesophageal cancer.
OA showed a higher proportion of diabetic patients among the cancer population
(14.6%, n= 10,621). Consistently, this rate was even higher in patients diagnosed
with pancreatic (28.7%, n= 362), liver (27.0%, n= 256) and endometrial cancer (21.7%,
n=161). Conclusions: This retrospective analysis showed that T2DM may increase
the risk of certain cancer types but seems to prevent from some others. Further
research is required to evaluate the factors involving the diabetes-cancer correlations, such as the anti-diabetic drugs.
PCN33
Patient Count Projections for Advanced Melanoma by Line of
Therapy and Other Clinical Characteristics in EU Countries:
Results from The UK, Germany, France, Italy and Spain (EU-5)
Gueron B 1, Kish J K 2, O’Day K 2, Martel M J 2, Manley Daumont M 1
1Bristol-Myers Squibb, Rueil Malmasion, France, 2Xcenda, LLC, Palm Harbor, FL, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To forecast the number of advanced melanoma (AM) patients (Stage
III unresectable and Stage IV) newly initiating treatment over 5 years (2014-2018)
by line of therapy and clinical/tumor characteristics including BRAF/PD-L1 mutations status and rate of brain metastases. Methods: A patient count model was
developed to forecast the AM population using historical rate data (1991-2012) and
other population parameters including incidence rate annual percent change, stage
at diagnosis, rates of disease progression and survival obtained through a comprehensive literature review and hand-search of cancer registry websites. Analysis of a
cross-sectional sample (Ipsos Global Oncology Monitor) of 1,297 patients in the EU-5
was used to address any clinical data gaps. The model was validated by comparing projected 5-year prevalence rates to GLOBOCAN 2012 estimates. Results: The
model-projected number (rounded to nearest 100) of incident melanoma cases for
2014 was: Germany= 23,100; UK= 18,900; France= 12,400; Italy= 12,000; Spain= 5,800.
Of incident cases, 11.3%-13.0% were treatment eligible AM. Incidence rates increases
of 1.7-7.8% per year were applied based on historical trends. Analysis of IPSOS data
and review of the literature showed BRAF and PD-L1 prevalence rates of 45.4%-56.2%
and 15.9%-16.7%, in AM patients, respectively. Literature-derived, brain metastasis
prevalence ranged from 15.9-36.0% in Stage IV patients. Considering case progression, resection and adjuvant treatment rates, the forecasted number of AM patients
eligible for 1stand 2nd line treatment in 2018 is, respectively: Germany= 3,700 and
1,700; UK= 3,100 and 1,400 France= 1,900 and 500; Italy= 1,800 and 1,000; Spain= 1,100
and 400, representing approximately 10.8-12.0% of incident cases. Conclusions:
While melanoma incidence is projected to increase over the next 5 years the
majority of incident cases will be diagnosed in earlier disease stages. Under these
assumptions, the largest proportion of the incident melanoma population that is
AM patients initiating treatment is expected to be 12% in 2018, a slight decline
from 13% in 2014.
PCN34
A Validated Prediction Model and Nomogram for Risk of Recurrence
in Early Breast Cancer Patients
Witteveen A 1, Vliegen I M H 2, Siesling S 3, IJzerman M J 4
1University of Twente, MIRA Institute for Biomedical Technology & Technical Medicine, Enschede,
The Netherlands, 2University of Twente, Centre for Healthcare Operations Improvement and
Research (CHOIR), Enschede, The Netherlands, 3Comprehensive Cancer Centre the Netherlands
(IKNL), Utrecht, The Netherlands, 4MIRA Institute for Biomedical Technology & Technical Medicine
and University of Twente, Enschede, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The objective of this study is to develop and validate a conditional
logistic regression model for the prediction of locoregional recurrence (LRR) of
breast cancer. To make a translation to clinical practice a web based nomogram
was made. Methods: Women first diagnosed with early breast cancer (without
distant metastasis or ingrowth in the chest wall or skin) between 2003-2006 were
selected from the Netherlands Cancer Registry (n= 39,929). Risk factors for LRRs
within five year of the primary treatment were determined using logistic regression. Risks were determined per year, conditional on not being diagnosed with
recurrence in the previous year. The presence of interaction and collinearity in
the nomogram was assessed, as well as the discrimination by means of the area
under the ROC curve and calibration by the Hosmer-Lemeshow goodness-of-fit test
in deciles. Data on primary tumours diagnosed between 2007-2008 from a selection of Dutch hospitals was used for external validation of the performance of
the nomogram (n= 13,792). Results: The final model included the variables grade,
size, multifocality, and nodal involvement of the primary tumour, type of surgery,
and whether patients were treated with radio-, chemo- or hormone therapy. The
modelling group showed an area under the ROC curve of 0.82,0. 74,0. 67,0. 70 and
0.60 respectively per subsequent year after primary treatment. The calibration was
sufficient. All effects in the validation group were in the same direction, and the
estimates in the validation group did not differ significantly from the modelling
group. Conclusions: This validated nomogram can be used as an instrument to
aid clinical decision-making and to identify patients with a high risk of breast cancer
recurrence who might benefit from a more intensive follow-up after breast cancer.
A620
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PCN35
Survival After Locoregional Recurrence or Second Primary Breast
Cancer: Impact of the Disease-Free Interval
Witteveen A 1, Kwast A B G 2, Sonke G 3, IJzerman M J 4, Siesling S 2
1University of Twente, MIRA Institute for Biomedical Technology & Technical Medicine,
Enschede, The Netherlands, 2Comprehensive Cancer Centre the Netherlands (IKNL), Utrecht, The
Netherlands, 3Netherlands Cancer Institute (NKI), Antoni van Leeuwenhoek Hospital, Amsterdam,
The Netherlands, 4MIRA Institute for Biomedical Technology & Technical Medicine and University
of Twente, Enschede, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The association between the disease-free interval (DFI) and survival
after a locoregional recurrence (LRR) or second primary (SP) breast cancer remains
uncertain. The objective of this study is to clarify this association to obtain more
information on expected prognosis. Methods: Women first diagnosed with early
breast cancer between 2003-2006 were selected from the Netherlands Cancer
Registry. LRRs and SP tumours within five years of first diagnosis were examined.
The five-year period was subsequently divided into three equal intervals. Prognostic
significance of the DFI on survival after a LRR or SP tumour was determined using
Kaplan-Meier estimates and multivariable Cox regression analysis. Follow-up was
complete until January 1,2013. Results: A total of 36,255 women was included in
the analysis. LRRs or SP tumours were diagnosed in 1,646 (4.5%) patients: 55% developed a LRR and 45% SP breast cancer. Longer DFI was strongly and independently
related to an improved survival after a LRR (long versus short: HR 0.63, 95% CI 0.460.86; medium versus short HR 0.80, 95% CI 0.64-1.00; P for trend 0.01). Other factors
related to improved survival after LRR were younger age (< 70 years) and surgical
removal of the recurrence. No significant association was found between DFI and
survival after SP tumours. Conclusions: This is the first study to explore the association between the DFI and survival after recurrence in a nationwide populationbased cancer registry. The DFI before a LRR is an independent prognostic factor for
survival, with a longer DFI predicting better prognosis.
PCN36
Long Term Survival of Patients with Various Lung Cancer Histology
in Seer Between 2004-2011
Schmaus K1, Benedict A2
Francisco, CA, USA, 2Evidera, Budapest, Hungary
1Evidera, San
Objectives: Overall survival (OS) data from clinical trials in oncology are often
incomplete, thus modelling over the lifetime horizon requires long term extrapolation and it is a critical input to cost-effectiveness studies. Data from the Surveillance,
Epidemiology, and End Results (SEER) program may provide good validation on the
long term OS. The objective was to examine the parametric functions that best
fit data in lung cancer (LC) of various histologies in SEER. Methods: SEER data
(2004-2011) were analyzed for patients diagnosed with stage IV small cell, large cell,
squamous cell carcinoma and adenocarcinoma of the lung with complete followup. Mean age was 68.03 (sd 11.67) and 55.5% were males, with varying baseline age
and gender distribution by histology. Treatment status could not be established.
Parametric models for OS were fitted using exponential, Gompertz, loglogistic, lognormal, and Weibull distributions. Models were fitted with and without covariates.
Fits were inspected and compared graphically using survival and quantile-quantile
plots, and statistically using the Akaike Information Criterion (AIC). Modelled mean
life expectancy results were compared to the restricted mean life expectancy of
the Kaplan-Meier estimator. Results: The lognormal distribution was found to
have the best fit within the SEER population, both with and without covariates
indicating that a small proportion of patients survive for a long time despite the
poor general prognosis of any type of LC. Loglogistic and gamma distributions were
2nd and 3rd best, followed by Weibull, Gompertz and exponential, for all histologies. The last three fitted the data poorly, and underestimated mean life expectancy. Conclusions: Only small proportions of LC patients are alive at 5-8 years,
nevertheless the mean OS estimates are impacted by the choice of survival function.
The lognormal distribution fit best across all histologies indicating a higher propotion of patients alive than estimated with Weibull models.
PCN37
Impact of Hospital Volume on Breast Cancer Outcome: A Population
Based Study in the Netherlands
Siesling S 1, Tjan-Heijnen V 2, de Roos M 3, Snel Y 4, van Dalen T 5, Wouters M 6, Struikmans
H 7, van der Hoeven K 7, Maduro J 8, Visser O 9
1Comprehensive Cancer Centre the Netherlands (IKNL), Utrecht, The Netherlands, 2Maastricht
University Medical Center, Maastricht, The Netherlands, 3Rivierenland Hospital, Tiel, The
Netherlands, 4Association of General Hospitals, Utrecht, The Netherlands, 5Diakonessen Hospital,
Utrecht, The Netherlands, 6Netherlands Cancer Institute, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 7Leiden
University Medical Centre, Leiden, The Netherlands, 8University Medical Centre Groningen,
Groningen, The Netherlands, 9Comprehensive Cancer Centre the Netherlands, Utrecht, The
Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: For low-volume tumours, high surgical hospital volume is associated
with better survival. For high volume tumours like breast cancer this association
is unclear. The aim of this study is to determine to what extent the yearly surgical hospital breast cancer volume is associated with overall survival. Methods:
All patients, diagnosed with primary invasive non-metastatic breast cancer in the
period 2001-2005, were selected from the Netherlands Cancer Registry. Hospitals
were grouped by their annual volume of surgery for invasive breast cancer. Cox
proportional hazard models were used including patient and tumour characteristics as covariates. Follow-up was completed until the 1thof February 2013. Primary
endpoint was 10-year overall survival rate. Results: In total 58,982 patients with
invasive non-metastatic breast cancer were diagnosed during the period 2001-2005.
Hospitals were grouped by their (mean) annually surgical volume: < 75 (n= 19), 75-99
(n=30), 100-149 (n= 29), 150-199 (n= 9) and ≥200 (n=14). The 10-year observed survival
rates were 77%, 81%, 80%, 82% and 82%, respectively. After case-mix adjustment
patients in low volume hospitals had a HR of 1.08 (< 75 vs ≥ 200; 95%CI 1.02-1.14).
Age at diagnosis (continuous, HR 1.05, 95%CI 1.05-1.05), socioeconomic status
(lowest vs highest; HR 1.12, 95%CI 1.07-1.16), grade (high vs low, HR 1.72, 95%CI
1.63-1.82), tumour size (2-5 cm vs 1-2 cm; HR 1.46, 95%CI 1.40-1.51), and a higher
number of positive lymph nodes (1-3 vs 0; HR 1.40, 95%CI 1.34-1.46 and >10 vs 0; HR
3.19, 95%CI 3.00-3.39) influenced death, all to a larger extent than surgical volume
did. Conclusions: In the Netherlands, surgical hospital volume influences 10-year
overall survival only marginally, and far less than patient and tumour characteristics. No difference in survival was revealed for invasive non-metastatic breast cancer
patients in hospitals with 75-99 operations per year compared with hospitals with
over 200 operations per year.
PCN38
Simulation Model of Ibrutinib in Treatment of Relapsed or
Refractory Mantle Cell Lymphoma (MCL)
Peng S 1, Sorensen S 1, Pan F 1, Dorman E 1, Sun S 2, Van Sanden S 3, Sengupta N 4, Gaudig M 5
Companies of Johnson and Johnson,
Raritan, NJ, USA, 3University Hospital Leuven, Leuven, Belgium, 4Janssen Pharmaceuticals, Inc,
Raritan, NJ, USA, 5Janssen Pharmaceuticals, Inc, Neuss, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Evidera, Bethesda, MD, USA, 2Janssen, Pharmaceutical
Objectives: For patients with relapsed or refractory (R/R) mantle cell lymphoma
(MCL), prognosis is poor, with a median survival of one to two years, and treatment options are very limited. In a recent phase II trial (PCYCY-1104), Ibrutinib
(Imbruvica™), a first-in-class oral once a day covalent Bruton’s tyrosine kinase
inhibitor, was associated with a median progression-free survival (PFS) of 13.9
months. After a median follow-up of 15.3 months, 63% of patients were alive.
The aim of the current study was to evaluate the projected life years (LYs) and
quality-adjusted LYs (QALYs) associated with ibrutinib and other treatments for
R/R MCL. Methods: Patients with R/R MCL were simulated to receive treatment
in a health state, survival partition model. Patients received ibrutinib, bendamustine and rituximab (BR), fludarabine, mitoxantrone, and cyclophosphamide (FMC),
temsirolimus, or other comparators until death or until progression of disease,
at which point they were modeled to receive a subsequent line of treatment or
best supportive care. Clinical inputs for ibrutinib were informed by PCYC-1104
trial data; OS was extrapolated to estimate survival outcomes. Clinical inputs for
comparators were informed by published sources identified through a systematic
literature review. Utility values were informed by published studies. Outcomes
were discounted by 3.5%. Results: Treatment with ibrutinib resulted in better
health outcomes, incrementally increasing overall LYs by 0.92, 0.86, and 0.92 and
PFS LYs by 0.87, 0.87, and 0.87 compared to BR, FMC, and temsirolimus, respectively. Ibrutinib was associated with 0.71, 0.70, and 0.72 overall incremental QALYs
compared to BR, FMC, and temsirolimus, respectively. Conclusions: Compared
with other therapies, Ibrutinib yielded an average incremental benefit of 0.90 LYs
for R/R MCL patients, largely driven by the significant incremental improvement
in duration of PFS. Currently a phase III trial is ongoing, the data from which will
be used to validate the model.
PCN39
The Benefit of Her-2 Targeted Therapies on Overall Survival of
Patients With Metastatic Breast Cancer – A Systematic Review
Alves C 1, Mendes D 1, Andrade S 2, Batel Marques F 3
1AIBILI, Coimbra, Portugal, 2Roche Farmaceutica Quimica, Amadora, Portugal, 3University of
Coimbra, Coimbra, Portugal
.
.
.
.
Objectives: This study was aimed at evaluating the overall survival (OS) gains
associated with HER-2 directed therapies in patients with metastatic breast
cancer. Methods: A bibliographic search was conducted in the MEDLINE (PubMed)
and in the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials databases, from their
inception through March, 2014. Only phase III clinical trials (RCTs) including
HER2-positive metastatic breast cancer patients have been included in this review,
irrespective of the treatment administered (i.e., chemotherapy and/or hormone
therapy, chemotherapy and/or hormone therapy plus HER2-targeted therapy). OS
was defined as time from randomisation until the occurrence of death from any
cause. Studies have been grouped according to the line of treatment, i.e. first-line
or second-line or beyond. Results: Seventeen RCTs were eligible for inclusion, of
which 12 assessed therapies targeting metastatic breast cancer HER2+ in the first
line setting. OS improved from 20.3 months in the first RCT (standard chemotherapy;
Slamon et al, 2001) evaluating HER-2 targeting therapies to 48 months (estimated
median OS) in the study of Swain and colleagues (2013), with triple combination
of pertuzumab, trastuzumab and docetaxel. Four studies evaluated OS of HER-2
targeting therapies in second-line setting of metastatic breast cancer. The OS in
second-line setting improved from 15.3 months (capecitabine; Cameron et al, 2008)
to 30.7 months (trastuzumab emtancine; Verma et al, 2012). In the third-line setting,
the association of lapatinib + trastuzumab has demonstrated to improve OS in 4.5
months compared with lapatinib alone (14 months vs 9.5 months; Blackwell et al,
2012). Conclusions: The HER-2 directed therapies had an undeniable benefic
impact in the overall survival of patients with HER-2 positive metastatic breast
cancer. Triple combination of docetaxel, pertuzumab and trastuzumab is associated
with a survival extent of more than 3.5 years, compared with a life expectancy of
1,5 years achieved 13 years ago.
PCN40
Simulation Model of Ibrutinib for Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia
(CLL) With Prior Treatment
Pan F 1, Peng S 1, Sorensen S 1, Dorman E 1, Sun S 2, Gaudig M 3, Sengupta N 4
Companies of Johnson and Johnson,
Raritan, NJ, USA, 3Janssen Pharmaceuticals, Inc, Neuss, Germany, 4Janssen Pharmaceuticals, Inc,
Raritan, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Evidera, Bethesda, MD, USA, 2Janssen, Pharmaceutical
Objectives: Treatment options for chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL) who
received prior therapy are limited; no standard of care exists. In a recent phase
III clinical trial (PCYC-1112), ibrutinib, an oral, once-a-day, first-in-class covalent
Bruton’s tyrosine kinase inhibitor, was associated with improved progression-free
survival (PFS, HR= 0.215) and overall survival (OS, HR= 0.387) compared with ofa-
A621
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
tumumab. The current study aimed to evaluate the projected life years (LYs) and
quality-adjusted LYs (QALYs) associated with ibrutinib, ofatumumab, and other
therapies for treatment of CLL with prior therapy. Methods: A health state model
simulated treatment of a cohort of CLL patients who had received prior therapy.
Patients were simulated to receive either ibrutinib or ofatumumab until death or
disease progression, at which point they received subsequent treatment or best
supportive care. Clinical inputs for ibrutinib and ofatumumab were informed by
PCYC-1112 trial data (N=391). Long-term follow-up data from PCYC-1102 and PCYC1103 trials (combined N=101) was used in sensitivity analysis. Long-term OS and PFS
were extrapolated from clinical trials to estimate survival outcomes. Utility were
informed by published studies. Evaluation of ibrutinib versus other existing agent
and emerging agents including idelalisib and ABT-199 was included in a sensitivity
analysis. Long-term health outcomes were discounted by 3.5%. Results: Treatment
with ibrutinib resulted in better health outcomes, incrementally increasing LYs
by 0.63 and progression-free LY by 0.87 over a 5-year time horizon compared to
ofatumumab, which lead to 0.47 incremental QALYs. In a 10 year time horizon
analysis, ibrutinib increased LYs by 0.79. Ibrutinib was also associated with increased
LYs and QALYs compared to other existing and emerging treatments. The model
results are most sensitive to the approaches used to extrapolate OS. Conclusions:
Ibrutinib was demonstrated to yield better health outcomes for CLL patients with
prior therapy compared to ofatumumab, largely driven by significant improvements
in PFS and OS.
CANCER – Cost Studies
PCN41
Budget Impact Analysis of Aflibercept in yhe Treatment of
Metastatic Colorectal Cancer (MCRC) in Poland
Kaczor M P 1, Pawlik D 1, Wójcik R 1, Glasek M 2, Pieczonka A 2, Kraska A 2, Zelazowski K 2
s. c., Kraków, Poland, 2Sanofi, Warsaw, Poland
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
PCN43
Forecasting Outpatient Pharmaceutical Expenditure for Cancer
Treatment in Germany
Schoch G G 1, Blank S 1, Tamminga M 1, Steimle T 1, Stargardt T 2
1Techniker Krankenkasse, Hamburg, Germany, 2University of Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To allow budgeting of pharmaceutical expenditure for cancer drugs
in Germany, we forecasted future outpatient pharmaceutical expenditure for
cancer treatment from the perspective of the statutory health insurance (SHI) for
2016. Methods: Based on data of the Techniker Krankenkasse (TK), a large German
sickness fund with more than 8.2 million insured, we forecasted pharmaceutical
expenditure for 12 cancer indications in 2016 (according to ICD-10: C16, C18-21,
C22, C26.9/C49.9, C34, C43, C50, C56, C61, C73, C90, C91.1). To extrapolate results
to whole SHI, we adjusted for differences in demographics of insured between
TK and SHI using publicly available data, i.e. KM6 statistics. We also incorporated
trends in membership to SHI. To assess the impact of new drugs, we obtained expert
opinion by IMS Health on (a) the timing of drug launches in the German cancer
market, (b) the expected prices of new drugs and (c) the extent to that new drugs will
replace existing pharmaceuticals. For calculations, we assumed that newly launched
drugs will reach on average a diffusion of 20% of their market potential until
2016. Results: According to our model, SHI outpatient pharmaceutical expenditure for these 12 cancer indications was million € 2,780 in 2012, i.e., 9.5% of total
outpatient pharmaceutical expenditure. In 2016, we expect annual pharmaceutical
expenditure for these indications to increase by 17.2% to million € 3,258. Of the 26
new drugs identified to be launched until 2016,10 will at least partly replace existing
pharmaceutical treatments. Thus, million € 526 of our budget estimate will be due to
new drugs, €2,650 million will be due to pharmaceuticals that were already launched
in 2012 while € 82 million will be due to demographic change. Conclusions: The
expected increase in costs for cancer drugs are a financial challenge for German
SHI. Whether benefit of new drugs and expected costs can be considered fair value
needs to be investigated elsewhere.
1Aestimo
Objectives: To estimate the budget impact resulting from the introduction of
aflibercept for the treatment of metastatic colorectal cancer (mCRC) within drug
program in Poland. Methods: Analysis was performed in 3-year time horizon
(2014-2016) from the public payer (NHF) perspective. Target population is defined as
adult patients with mCRC that is resistant to or has progressed after an oxaliplatincontaining regimen (including patients who experienced distant relapse within
6 months of completion of oxaliplatin-based adjuvant therapy). Eligible patient
population was estimated by compilation of following data: epidemiological studies,
local market study, IMS data, survey among Polish oncologists. Market shares of different regimens (aflibercept 4 mg/kg +FOLFIRI, bevacizumab 10 mg/kg +FOLFOX-4,
FOLFIRI) were projected based on the NHF data and experts’ opinion. Following cost
categories were included: drug acquisition and administration (anti-VEGF, chemotherapy), diagnostics, monitoring and adverse events (grade 3-4). Results: With the
introduction of aflibercept, estimated annual number of patients starting aflibercept
treatment will be 90, 209 and 224 in year 2014, 2015 and 2016, respectively. Total
annual expenditures in year 2014, 2015 and 2016 were calculated to be 39.3, 40.3 and
41.2 million PLN in scenario without aflibercept, compared with 37.4, 34.9 and 35.0
million PLN, respectively, with the introduction of aflibercept. In case of aflibercept
reimbursement, the NHF would save 1.9 million PLN in year 2014, 5.3 million PLN
in year 2015 and 6.1 million PLN in year 2016. Conclusions: The introduction of
aflibercept would result in savings for the NHF in Poland, mainly as a consequence
of reduced pharmacological costs compared to bevacizumab.
PCN42
Estimating the Economic Impact of Sorafenib in Treatment of
Locally Recurrent or Metastatic, Progressive, Differentiated
Thyroid Carcinoma (DTC) That is Refractory to Radioactive Iodine
(RAI) Treatment
Sussman M 1, Munsell M 1, Valderrama A 2, Seal B S 2, Wen L 2
1Boston Health Economics, Inc., Waltham, MA, USA, 2Bayer HealthCare Pharmaceuticals Inc.,
Whippany, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Sorafenib, a multikinase inhibitor, received Food and Drug
Administration (FDA) -approval in 2013 for treatment of patients with locally
recurrent or metastatic, progressive, radioactive iodine-refractory (RAI-r) differentiated thyroid carcinoma (DTC). A budget impact model (BIM) was developed from a United States (US) payer perspective to estimate the costs of adding
sorafenib to the set of available treatments in a hypothetical health plan in the
RAI-r DTC population. Methods: An Excel-based BIM evaluated costs of RAI-r
DTC with other FDA-approved and compendia-recommended treatments using
baseline and projected market shares. Clinical inputs included the prevalence of
RAI-r, average monthly dosage, and average duration of sorafenib and other FDAapproved and compendia-recommended treatments. Economic inputs for each
treatment included the wholesale acquisition cost (WAC) per dose and hospital
administration costs per month. A net per-month cost to the payer for sorafenib
was $6,872. Laboratory testing costs were derived from product-specific package
inserts and the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) Physician Fee
Schedule. Sorafenib market share was assumed to increase from 35% at baseline
to 54% at 1 year, with shift from other treatments coming mostly (12%) from
clinical trial/no treatment. The duration of sorafenib treatment was 11 months
based the DECISION trial. Results: An estimated 25 patients with RAI-r DTC
were eligible for treatment with sorafenib. Costs increased 25% ($282,467) or $0.02
per member per month (PMPM) from baseline to 1 year post baseline. Sensitivity
analyses, varying default inputs for duration of treatment (±2 months) and estimated market share for sorafenib (±10%), showed greatest sensitivity to sorafenib
market share (incremental total costs: $180,812–$384,122). Conclusions: Our
findings indicate that adding sorafenib to a hypothetical health plan’s formulary
has a manageable budget impact of $282,467, or a PMPM increase of $0.02, given
the small RAI-r DTC population.
PCN44
Budget Impact Analysis of Everolimus for the Treatment of
Hormone Receptor Positive, Human Epidermal Growth Factor
Receptor-2 Negative (HER2-) Advanced Breast Cancer in Kazakhstan
Lewis L 1, Taylor M 1, Suriya Y 2, Kuanysh N 2, Kaldygul S 2, Ramil A 2
1York Health Economics Consortium, York, UK, 2Kazakh Research Institute of Oncology and
Radiology, Almaty, Kazakhstan
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To determine the budget impact of everolimus (in combination with
letrozole/anastrozole) as a second-line treatment for ER+ HER2-negative advanced
and metastatic breast cancer in postmenopausal women in Kazakhstan. Methods:
A cumulative cohort model was developed to estimate the five-year costs associated
with introducing everolimus to the Kazakh health care system, with two scenarios:
“with everolimus” and “without everolimus”. Treatment-specific PFS and OS data
were extrapolated from trial data using a Weibull function. It was assumed that
data from the BOLERO-2 trial (everolimus+exemestane vs exemestane alone) were
representative of everolimus+letrozole/anastrozole and letrozole/anastrozole used
in the model. Per-patient drug, health state, adverse event costs were calculated.
The per-patient costs were multiplied by the number of patients expected to receive
each treatment according to predicted market share, which was split between
everolimus+letrozole/anastrozole, letrozole/anastrozole alone, chemotherapy and
tamoxifen. Results: The within-trial data from BOLERO-2 reported 17 month OS
of 74.7% and 67.6% for everolimus+exemestane and exemestane alone, respectively.
The utilities reported in BOLERO-2 (data available up to week 78) were 0.67 and
0.70 for everolimus+exemestane and exemestane alone, respectively. The five year
results demonstrate that the introduction of everolimus leads to a 12% increase in
drug costs, a 2% reduction in pre-progression health state costs, a 1% increase in
post-progression health state costs and a 2% reduction in adverse event costs. The
net result is a 2% increase in total costs, from T16.97 billion to T17.389 billion over a
period of five years. Conclusions: The analysis estimated that, if everolimus were
to be introduced to the Kazakh health care market for the treatment of ER+ HER2advanced breast cancer, there would be a small impact upon overall health care
expenditure. An increase in drug acquisitions costs was largely offset by a reduction
in other health care costs due to improved disease management.
PCN45
Budget Impact Analysis of CYP2C19 Genotyping to Target
Voriconazole Prophylaxis During Induction-Consolidation Therapy
in Acute Myeloid Leukemia (AML) in The United States
Mason N T , Bell G C , McLeod H L
H. Lee Moffitt Cancer Center, Tampa, FL, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess the impact of genotyping acute myeloid leukemia (AML)
patients for CYP2C19*17 gene variant status prior to induction-consolidation therapy
from the perspective of a United States (U. S.) payer. Methods: Developed to aid
U. S. payers regarding the budgetary impact of DNA genotyping, this model examines the predicted economic outcomes of a hypothetical cohort of 100 neutropenic
AML patients under two alternatives: (1) standard voriconazole prophylaxis and (2)
genotyping patients for targeted prophylaxis. Published allelic frequencies estimate
27% of the general population may have at least one *17 allele. The presence of the
CYP2C19*17 allele results in more rapid metabolism and clearance of voriconazole,
which can lead to underdosing and ineffective prophylaxis on the standard regimen. The incidence of invasive fungal infection is 15% without effective prophylaxis
and is reduced to 6.6% upon adequate prophylaxis. Targeted prophylaxis based on
genotyping prescribes an alternative drug or higher voriconazole dose in patients
with the *17 allele. Further model parameters were taken from published literature and 2014 CMS Laboratory Fee Schedule. Results: The average total cost of
care for AML patients receiving standard versus targeted voriconazole prophylaxis
was $46,795 and $46,385 per patient, respectively. In addition to the $410 saved
per patient, the number of invasive fungal infections was reduced from 6.6 to 4.3
A622
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
by targeting prophylaxis based on patient genotype. The deterministic sensitivity
analysis showed that the savings is most dependent on the incidence of invasive
fungal infection, cost of treating an invasive fungal infection, and frequency of *17
in the population. Conclusions: Genotyping AML patients for CYP2C19*17 prior to
induction-consolidation is expected to be cost-neutral or potentially cost-saving by
reducing the incidence of invasive fungal infections compared to standard prophylaxis. These results may mitigate potential budgetary concerns, thereby reducing
barriers to a test that can be clinically beneficial to AML patients.
PCN46
Budget Impact Analysis of the Introduction of New Therapeutic
Agents for the Treatment of Metastatic Castration Resistant
Prostate Cancer (MCRPC) Patients After Docetaxel Failure in the
Brazilian Private Health System
Asano E , Vitale V
Janssen-Cilag Farmaceutica, São Paulo, Brazil
.
identified at IMSS and 631 at ISSSTE, 2,570 and 536 of them with NSCLC. A 4.2% ALK+
rate was assumed. Direct medical costs of standard treatment for LC were obtained
from a published source. Cost for crizotinib was given by the manufacturer. All costs
are expressed in 2014 USD ($1USD= $13MXN). Two scenarios are presented: 1) world
without crizotinib, where all patients with LC are treated with standard treatment; 2)
world with crizotinib, where patients with ALK+ advanced NSCLC are treated with
crizotinib and all other LC patients are treated with standard treatment. Results: 81
and 17 ALK+ advanced NSCLC patients were identified in IMSS and ISSTE, respectively.
Total costs in a world “without” and “with” crizotinib using a one-year time horizon is
$50.3 and $52.9 million, respectively, for IMSS. For ISSSTE, total costs were $10.5 versus
$11.1 million. The combined incremental budget impact across both public health care
institutions is 5.2%. Conclusions: Crizotinib, the only drug approved for the treatment of ALK+ advanced NSCLC patients has a minimal incremental budget impact on
the overall expenditure within the two main Mexican public health care institutions.
.
Objectives: In the latest years several drugs demonstrated to increase survival
in mCRPC patients post chemotherapy failure. However, issues remain related to
the treatment sequencing of these drugs. The aim of this study is to estimate the
budget impact of the introduction of enzalutamide in the Brazilian Private Health
System. Methods: A deterministic state transition budget impact model (BIM)
was developed to estimate treatment costs of mCRPC patients after chemotherapy
failure over a 3-year time horizon. Budget impact was estimated comparing a baseline scenario including mandatory coverage drugs (abiraterone, cabazitaxel) with
an alternative scenario including all treatment options (abiraterone, cabazitaxel
and enzalutamide). Target population, dosing, duration of therapy and sequencing was based on scientific literature. Pharmaceutical direct costs were based on
factory price, assuming parity price of enzalutamide and abiraterone. Univariate
Deterministic sensitivity analysis was conducted to determine the impact of parameters on results. Results: The BIM estimates that a total of 5,789 patients will be
treated in the next three years, with annual cost estimates in the baseline scenario
of R$83,944,041 in year 1, reaching R$198,507,065 in year 3 of the simulation. The
introduction of enzalutamide would incur a total increase in costs of R$16,649,325
after 3 years. In deterministic sensitivity analysis, enzalutamide price, proportion of
patients receiving additional treatment line and duration of therapy were the most
important variables that impacted results, with the alternative scenario remaining
more costly than the baseline scenario in all simulations, incurring additional costs
ranging from R$6,634,955 to R$38,818,233. Conclusions: Considering current
available evidence regarding treatment sequencing, the introduction of enzalutamide is expected to increase costs to the Brazilian Private Health System.
PCN47
Budget Impact Model of Ceplene® As Maintenance Therapy in Adult
Patients with Acute Myeloid Leukemia in First Remission
Kaskens L 1, Gehenio D 2, Munzel U 2, Darba J 3
Health Economics & Outcomes Research S.L., Barcelona, Spain, 2Meda Pharma GmbH & Co
KG, Bad Homburg vor der Höhe, Germany, 3Universitat de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain
.
.
.
.
1BCN
Objectives: To assess the economic impact of Ceplene® with low-dose Interleukin-2 (IL-2)
for the treatment of adult patients with Acute Myeloid Leukemia (AML) in first complete
remission (CR-1) which previously received intensive chemotherapy in Spain. Methods:
A budget impact model was developed using the perspective of the Spanish
National Health System with a 4-year time horizon. Ceplene®/IL-2 was compared
with no treatment and an unrelated allogenic hematopoietic stem cell transplant
(allo-HSCT). For both treatment options and no treatment, health care costs (EUR
2013) including medical visits, hospitalisations, laboratory and diagnostic tests,
prophylactic measures, treatment of complications and infections were considered. Average treatment costs per patient up to a maximum of three years were
estimated for both treatment options and no treatment depending on the probability of overall survival without or with a relapse, and death without relapse, as
well as the duration until relapse or death without relapse during this period. Total
annual health care costs were estimated based on the annual per patient cost, the
target population, and the market shares associated with each option, before and
after the introduction of Ceplene®/IL-2. Results: Patients eligible for Ceplene®/
IL-2 were estimated at 1,502 in 2013 with a small increase up to 1,509 in 2016.
The overall budget impact with the introduction of Ceplene®/IL-2, is estimated to
decrease with € 674,149 and € 728,945 in 2014 and 2016, and an increase of € 202,322
in 2015. Overall budget impact savings over the period 2014-2016 are estimated at
€ 1,130,894. Conclusions: The introduction of Ceplene®/IL-2 as maintenance therapy
supposes savings in the budget impact for the treatment of AML patients in CR-1 in Spain.
Ceplene®/IL-2 is expected to fulfil a direct medical need for patients not eligible or having
an unfavourable profile for an unrelated allo-HSCT receiving no treatment, and those who
received an unrelated allo-HSCT with unfavourable prognostics.
PCN48
Budget Impact Analysis of the Use of Crizotinib for Non-Small Cell
Lung Cancer and ALK+ Mutation in the Two Main Public Health Care
Institutions in Mexico
Guirant-Corpi L , Muciño-Ortega E
Pfizer S.A. de C.V., Ciudad de México, Mexico
.
.
Objectives: Standard treatment for lung cancer (LC) in Mexico is chemotherapy.
Crizotinib is the only therapy approved for patients with ALK+ advanced non-small
cell lung cancer (NSCLC), a low prevalence condition. This analysis aims to estimate
the economic impact of using crizotinib for patients with ALK+ advanced NSCLC
in the Mexican setting from public health care institution perspective. Methods:
A budget impact analysis with a one-year time horizon was developed to compare
expected costs that the Mexican Social Security Institute (IMSS) and the Safety and
Social Services for State Workers Institute (ISSSTE) public health care institutions
would incur if they were to include crizotinib on their formularies. Using epidemiology data from published sources, a total of 3,023 potential patients with LC were
PCN49
Budget Impact Analysis of Everolimus Plus Exemestane Versus
Gemcitabine Plus Paclitaxel and Capecitabine Plus Docetaxel in
Metastatic Breast Cancer Patients in Egypt
Elsisi G 1, Saeed E 2, Elmahdawy M 3
of Health, Faculty of Pharmacy Helwan University, Cairo, Egypt, 2Central Administration
for Pharmaceutical Affairs, Cairo, Egypt, 3Ministry of Health, Cairo, Egypt
.
.
.
1Ministry
Objectives: To estimate the budget impact of everolimus-exemestane versus the
most commonly used regimens in the Egyptian practice; gemcitabine-paclitaxel
and capecitabine-docetaxel for a health care plan that introduces everolimus
for post-menopausal hormone receptor positive, human epidermal growth factor receptor-2 negative metastatic breast cancer (HR+, HER2-MBC) patients over
three years. Methods: Drug and medical budget impacts (2013 EGP) were estimated over the first three years of the three drug regimens use from the health
insurance perspective. Epidemiology data were used to estimate target population size. The treatment data for MBC patients were obtained from published and
nonpublished sources. The model considered 2 scenarios—without (pre) and with
(post) everolimus-exemestane. Monthly medical costs were calculated for
the pre- and post-progression phase. Results were considered on a per member
per month (PMPM) basis to examine the relative impact on the plan. Deterministic
sensitivity analyses were conducted. Results: In a real-world 6,055,902 targeted
patients, 288,261 of them were found to be candidates for everolimus-exemestane
regimen. For patients taking gemcitabine-paclitaxel and capecitabine-docetaxel
regimens, the estimated incremental cost PMPM was LE3.00 and LE2.94 respectively for each after three years. The estimated incremental cost PMPM for the
gemcitabine-paclitaxel population was LE0.62, LE2.60 and LE5.77 for year 1, 2 and
3 respectively while for the capecitabine-docetaxel population was LE0.59, LE2.54
and LE5.70 for year 1, 2 and 3 respectively. The capecitabine-docetaxel results
were most sensitive to the cost of everolimus while gemcitabine-paclitaxel results
were most sensitive to the number of eligible patients. Conclusions: Increased
acquisition costs of everolimus-exemestane for HR+, HER2-MBC treatment
are expected to be obviously offset by both the reduced number of progressed patients
and the relatively small medical costs due to avoided adverse events of each of gemcitabine-paclitaxel and capecitabine-docetaxel regimens. The expected budget impact
of covering everolimus for this group of patients was relatively small.
PCN50
Buget Impact Analysis of Rituximab for Chronic Lymphocytic
Leukemic: The Case of Brazilian Public Health
Koury C D N 1, Nunes A A 2, Nita M 1
-Fundação de Ensino e Pesquisas Econômicas, Brasilia, Brazil, 2University of São Paulo USP, Ribeirão Preto, Brazil
.
.
.
.
.
.
1FIPE
Background: Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia (CLL) is a malignant disease incurable of the lymphoid system, that affects predominantly elderly, especially in
Western countries. Your treatment when necessary is based on the administration
of chemotherapy, with association of fludarabine plus cyclophosphamide (FC), the
most widely used schema. Recently the addition of rituximabe, a monoclonal antibody has been associated with this scheme, known as FCR. Objectives: To elaborate a budget impact analysis (BIA) of rituximab for chronic lymphocytic leukemic
for help the decision making. Methods: A BIA of association of fludarabine plus
cyclophosphamide in SUS compared to rituximab with this scheme was performed.
The analysis’ time horizon was 5 years, using a CLL prevalence of 4.4% and 25% of
CLL refractory between them (1.634), considering an annual growth rate of 0.8143%
and a market share of 25% and 75% according the classification of diagnosis and
stage of Rai & Keating. The mean total rituximab dose considered was 375/mg/
m2, with an average personal weight and size of 70kg and 1,70m, which means
681,75mg per cicle. All cost purchase prices and remission rate of rituximab (22%)
and stand chemiterapy (9%) were obtained at one year trial in the onco-hematology high complexity Clinical Hospital of the Faculty of Medicine of Ribeirão Preto
HCFMRP / USP hospital measured in real 2012. Results: The budget impact of FC
per year would be 38.7m reais ($17.5m) in the 1st year, considering 25% of target
population, reaching approximately 135.3m reais ($60.9m) in 75% of patients. For
RFC, the budget impact would be 97 million reais ($43.6m) in the 1st year, reaching
340 million reais ($153m) in 75% of patients. Conclusions: Treatment costs still
impressive, considering that rituximab ’ values reach 2.5 times the clicle unit values
of standart chemioperapy, fact that did not happen in other countries where they
are already covered.
PCN51
Real-World Costs of Laboratory Tests for Non-Small Cell Lung
Cancer
van der Linden N 1, Smit E F 2, Uyl-De Groot C A 1
for Medical Technology Assessment (iMTA), Erasmus University, Rotterdam, The
Netherlands, 2VU University Medical Centre, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
.
1Institute
.
.
.
.
A623
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: Cancer patients undergo a wide range of laboratory procedures, from
simple blood tests to complex molecular diagnostics. In cost-effectiveness analyses,
costs of laboratory testing are often ignored or estimated inappropriately. We present
real-world costs of laboratory procedures for non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC)
patients, per category of laboratory testing. Methods: In a Dutch academic hospital, all laboratory tests performed for NSCLC patients between 2009 and 2011, were
recorded and categorized in clinical chemistry; pathology; microbiology; serology,
hematology, transfusion; pharmacology; and other or unknown. Number of tests per
type were multiplied with unit costs per test obtained from The Dutch Healthcare
Authority. Results: 1,015 patients were included, with a total of 171,632 laboratory
procedures. 392 different types of tests were performed. Mean cost for laboratory
testing is EUR1,175 (95%CI 1,066-1,283) per patient. For cost allocation and modeling
purposes, cost per month with laboratory testing (EUR265,95%CI 247-282) and cost
per day with laboratory testing (EUR96, 95%CI 91-100) are presented. Costs are mainly
driven by (molecular) pathology (26%), other (25%, mainly order processing fees) and
clinical chemistry (24%, due to high test volumes). Conclusions: Costs of laboratory
procedures for NSCLC patients are substantial. Relatively simple blood tests contribute significantly to these costs due to high test volumes. Main cost driver however
is molecular testing by the pathologist, for the use of targeted therapies. In pharmacoeconomic evaluations, taking laboratory costs into account significantly impacts
results, especially when testing practices differ between treatment alternatives.
recombinant human granulocyte colony stimulating factor (pegfilgrastim) to reduce
the risk of FN, the incidence rate of FN was 39.5% in the control group, while it
was 3.04% in the pegfilgrastim group. Pegteograstim (Neulageg®) was shown to
be non-inferior compared to pegfilgrastimin the phase three clinical trial, so the
result was directly applied. The number of patients to whom the result applies was
estimated as 1,440 patients, which is 8% of the annual average number of breast
cancer patients in South Korea. The hospitalization costs for FN was estimated by
an average costs of 18 patients admitted to a Catholic University hospital in 2013,
which was 15,396,014 (±18,847,475) KRW. Costs for isolated ward, 3rd generation
antibiotics and G-CSF were included on the hospitalization costs for FN. Weighted
average costs given by Health Insurance Review & Assessment Service were used for
micro-costing. Results: When assuming an average incidence rate of 20% for FN,
FN will occur in 1.72% (25 patients), which is a 8.6% decrease with pegfilgrastim as
well as with pegteograstim. Therefore, when estimating at the sum of the costs of
pegfilgrastim, pegteograstim and the average cost of hospitalization, the total cost is
5,572,986,587 KRW for pegfilgrastim while it is 3,499,386,587 KRW for pegteograstim.
On the other hand, when pegfilgrastim or pegteograstim are not used, the incidence
rate of FN is 20% (288 patients), and the average cost of hospitalization after FN
occurs is 4,434,052,032 KRW. Conclusions: When pegteograstim is reimbursed to
reduce the incidence of FN during chemotherapies for breast cancer with moderate
risk of FN, about 1 billion KRW saving is expected from a payer perspective.
PCN52
Positron Emission Tomography/Computed Tomography Imaging for
Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer: A Budget Impact Analysis
PCN55
Costs of Pneumonia in Patients With Cancer Diagnosis from the
Private Health System Perspective in Brazil
Wichmann R M 1, Freitas M G 2, Silva M T 3
1Brazilian Ministry of Health, Brasilia, Brazil, 2Brazilian Ministry of Health, Brasília, Brazil,
3Universidade Federal de Manaus, Manaus, Brazil
Manfrin D F 1, Ferreira C N 1, Santana C F S D 2, Paloni E D M P 2, Campi F D S 2, Gea Y 1,
Rufino C S 1
1Pfizer, Inc., São Paulo, Brazil, 2ORIZON - Companhia Brasileira de Gestão de Serviços, Sao Paulo,
Brazil
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate the budgetary impact of the introduction of PET-CT for
staging non-small-cell lung carcinoma (NSCLC) in Brazilian Public Healthcare
System (SUS). Methods: For estimation of the budgetary impact the work considered patients diagnosed with NSCLC that would be submitted to the PET-CT for
tumor staging. It was considered the time horizon of 2013, 2014 and 2015. The number of procedures in those years was calculated from an estimate of the years 20082012, obtained from SUS. It was assumed that by 2013 the demand for PET grows due
to its incorporation and, from then on, there would be a tendency to annual decrease
of 7.5%, the same as in previous years. Cost estimates were obtained from recent
cost-effectiveness literature. Results: The average cost of the PET-CT procedure
calculated in 2012 is $1,229.92, the value used for 2013 approximately. The 2014 and
2015 values were adjusted for inflation at rate of 5% per year, resulting $1,291.40
and $1,355.97, respectively. The total budget impact for each year was calculated
by multiplying the number of procedures to be performed by its base value minus
the savings achieved. The values of $2,072,300.84, $2,030,645.11 and $1,988,842.77,
for the years 2013, 2014 and 2015, were found respectively. Conclusions: The
introduction of PET-CT in the staging of NSCLC affects the budget of the Ministry
of Health in 21.8%, 19.6% and 17.5% in the years 2013, 2014 and 2015, respectively.
PCN53
Budget Impact and Incremental Survival Benefit of Eribulin
Mesylate as a Treatment for Metastatic Breast Cancer in Brazil
Majethia U 1, Tremblay G 2, Borges L 3, Jones T 1, Forsythe A 2, Pomerantz D 4, Clark O A C 5
Lake, NJ, USA, 2Eisai Inc, Woodcliff Lake, NJ, USA, 3Evidências, Campinas, Brazil,
4Kantar Health, Princeton, NJ, USA, 5Evidencias, Campinas, Brazil
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The objective of this study was to estimate the incremental Budget
Impact (BI) and survival benefit of utilizing eribulin for treatment of Metastatic
Breast Cancer (MBC) in patients with 2-5 prior chemotherapy regimens including anthracycline and taxane. Methods: Epidemiology was derived from 2013
CancerMPact report and National databases (FOSP and INCA). Treatment of
Physician’s Choice (TPC) arm included capecitabine, gemcitabine, vinorelbine,
docetaxel and paclitaxel. TPC market shares, efficacy and Adverse Events (AE) data
were taken from Phase III clinical trial. Total costs comprised of drug costs, administration costs, direct medical and AE costs. A micro-costing analysis of resource
utilization for AE treatments and disease management pre and post progressions
was performed. Local Brazil tariffs for each costs unit were applied to an Excel-based
model to compare total costs and survival rates with and without eribulin for MBC
patients across a 5-year horizon from private payers perspective (assumed to cover
25% of Brazil population). Results: Applying an MBC prevalence rate, proportion
of patients with active disease and treated with 3rdline chemotherapies the model
estimates up to 801 patients treated with eribulin out of 3864 eligible patients over
5 years. Assuming eribulin market share of 2%, 5%, 9%, 14% and 20% in years 1, 2, 3,
4 and 5, the BI is R$294K, R$741K, R$1345K, R$2111K and R$3043K (net increase of
0.12% - 1.21%). The main cost offsets include the displacement of more widely-used
TPC therapies. Eribulin MBC treatment in Brazil is estimated to yield an incremental
245 progression free patient years and 408 life years in population covered by private
insurance. Conclusions: Given the limited number of effective treatment options
available to patients receiving third line chemotherapy, eribulin represents a much
needed therapy option for this population. With additional survival benefits eribulin
represents an effective innovative approach to MBC management.
PCN54
Budget Impact on the Use of Pegfilgrastim to Reduce the Febrile
Neutropenia During Chemotherapy for Breast Cancer with
Moderate Risk Compared to a Standard Therapy
Choi W S , Lee Y J , Ju S Y , Heo S B , Kim C M
Catholic University College of Medicine, Seoul, South Korea
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Cancer patients are susceptible to infections, including pneumonia, due to immunosuppressive therapies associated with cancer treatment. This
study aimed to evaluate the budget impact of pneumonia in patients with previous diagnosed cancer in the Brazilian Private Health System. Methods: Orizon
database (N= 18 million lives) was used to identify patients with any type of cancer
followed by a pneumonia hospitalization between October 2010 and December 2013.
Pneumonia was identified using code of A40.3, B95.3, G00.1, J13, J15, J15.0, J15.3, J15.4,
J15.8, J15.9, J18, J18.0, J18.9, J20.2, P23.3. Inpatient and related outpatient costs were
included. Results: A total of 68,717 patients with a pneumonia hospitalization
were identified. Of those, 2,769 were diagnosed with cancer (WCa) before the pneumonia hospitalization for a total of 3,605 hospitalizations. This translated to a mean
of 1.30 hospitalization per WCa patient. The group without cancer diagnosis (WoCa),
65,948 pneumonia patients had a total of 81,583 hospitalizations for a mean of 1.24
hospitalizations. The average costs per patient are BRL2,863.08 for the WoCa group
and BRL9,288.07 for the WCa group. When considered the costs per hospitalizations
the values are BRL2,314.60 and BRL7,134.16 respectively. Conclusions: Although
the number of pneumonia hospitalization per patient was slightly higher in WCa
compared with WoCA patients, the cost per patient and cost per hospitalization
was at least 3 times higher in the WCa compared with WoCA patients. This suggests
pneumonia has a substantial financial impact in patients with cancer who are in
the Brazilian Private Health System.
.
1Eisai, Woodcliff
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To conduct a budget impact analysis on the use of Pegteograstim
(Neulageg®) to reduce the risk of febrile neutropenia (FN) during chemotherapies
for breast cancer with moderate risk compared to a standard treatment with antibiotics and G-CSF after occurrence of FN. Methods: The efficacy of pegylated
PCN56
Economic Impact of a Genomic Companion Diagnostic Test for
Breast Cancer Patients in French Private Hospitals
Vataire A L 1, Aballéa S 1, Katz G 2
1Creativ-Ceutical, Paris, France, 2ESSEC Business School, Paris-Singapore, Cergy, France
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Several multigene prognostic and predictive tests have recently been
launched. The 21-gene assay (OncotypeDX®), a validated gene expression profiling test that predicts the likelihood of adjuvant chemotherapy benefit in patients
with early stage breast cancer, was found to be cost-effective and recommended
in several guidelines. Its use in clinical practice in France is limited because of
the absence of reimbursement. This study aims to determine if the utilisation of
the 21-gene assay in private hospitals would provide good value for money from
a collective perspective in France and whether hospitals can afford using the test
under the current payment system. Methods: A multicenter retrospective study
was conducted to estimate the cost of adjuvant chemotherapy from societal and
national insurance perspectives. The resulting estimate was used as an input of
a Markov model to assess the cost-effectiveness of the 21-gene assay from the
French collective perspective and the economic impact of the test on the revenue
in private hospital organizations. Results: The cost of adjuvant chemotherapy in
private hospitals was estimated at € 8,218 per patient from the national insurance
perspective (€ 10,305 from the societal perspective). The 21-gene assay was found
cost-effective compared to standard practice and cost-saving with inclusion of productivity costs. The absence of reimbursement involves a deficit for private hospitals
of € 3,200 per patient tested. Conclusions: Providing the 21-gene assay in French
private hospitals would be cost-effective in the French collective perspective. In the
absence of reimbursement from primary payers, some private hospitals may cover
the costs of companion diagnostics to improve their attractiveness, but the test
will be underused, thus depriving patients from a technology that could improve
their quality of life and using resources that could be freed up for other patients.
PCN58
Cost-Effectiveness and Budget-Impact Analysis of Braf Inhibitors in
Patients With Metastatic Malignant Melanoma (MMM) in Slovenia
Hren R
GlaxoSmithKline d.o.o., družba za promet s farmacevtskimi izdelki, Ljubljana, Slovenia
.
Objectives: To analyze cost-effectiveness and assses budget impact of novel BRAF
inhibitors – vemurafenib and dabrafenib – in patients with MMM. Methods: In the
absence of head to head data we derived a decision model from indirect comparison
A624
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
of progression-free survival (PFS) curves for dabrafenib and vemurafenib, from their
respective clinical trials with dacarbazine as a common comparator. The model
was applied to the conditions of locally-specific population data and treatment
costs, including adverse events, of patients with MMM. In the model, individuals
moved from progression-free state to post-progression state or death and were
followed for 45 weeks. We compared vemurafenib and dabrafenib from the payers’
perspective at the price level determined by international reference pricing as of
December 2013 in terms of costs and progression-free life years (PFLYs). Based on
the cost-effectiveness model, we carried out budget impact analysis for a scenario
with vemurafenib only and a scenario with vemurafenib and dabrafenib using their
projected market shares. Results: Our model has shown that more than 99% of
total treatment costs of MMM patients in Slovenia were due to drug costs of BRAF
inhibitors in spite of the fact that treatment of associated adverse events were 5
times higher in vemurafenib than in dabrafenib, primarily due to higher incidence
of cutaneous squamous cell carcinoma and keratocanthoma. Treatment with dabrafenib vs. vemurafenib allowed to save € 13,009 and gain 0.022 PFLY at a discount
rate of 3.5%; the sensitivity analysis showed robustness of findings and retained
dominance of dabrafenib over vemurafenib. Budget impact analysis for a 3-year
period revealed that introduction of dabrafenib would save the national Sick Fund
€ 402,000 (€ 5,318,000 in the scenario without dabrafenib vs. € 4,916,000 in the scenario with dabrafenib). Conclusions: Study results suggest that introduction of
dabrafenib in Slovenia could reduce costs and improve outcomes in MMM.
PCN59
Budget Impact Analysis of a Return-To-Work Intervention for
Cancer Patients Shows Hospitals Bear the Costs, for Society to
Enjoy the Benefits
Mewes J C 1, Steuten L M G 1, de Boer A 2, Frings-Dresen M 2, IJzerman M J 3, van Harten W 4
of Twente, Enschede, The Netherlands, 2Academic Medical Centre, Amsterdam, The
Netherlands, 3University of Twente and MIRA institute for Biomedical Technology & Technical
Medicine, Enschede, The Netherlands, 4Netherlands Cancer Institute, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: Multidisciplinary return-to-work (RTW) interventions effectively support cancer survivors to resume work and potentially increase quality of life, but
are not or only partly reimbursed by health insurers. To ensure optimal support for
cancer patients in resuming work, it is essential that hospitals can offer RTW in a
financially viable way. We analysed the budget impact of a RTW intervention (counselling by occupational physicians + physical exercise) and explored how financing
of a return-to-work intervention can be arranged. Methods: The budget impact
analysis compared costs of RTW support for all patients able and willing to resume
work versus no standardised support, for a large cancer centre serving a population of 1 million inhabitants. Costs and financial benefits relevant from a societal
perspective were considered, including intervention costs, productivity losses, and
patients´ costs. We identified which stakeholders, including hospitals, employers,
health insurances, social security, and patients accrue what costs; and which enjoy
the financial benefits under different financing arrangements. Results: RTW costs
are ≈ € 2,000 per patient. For a large cancer centre, the annual budget impact is €817k
in 2014, rising to €14.7m in 2017. Ccosts for patients with a multidisciplinary rehabilitation need are typically covered by health insurance, leaving € 735k to be financed
by the cancer centre. Small improvements in return-to-work and quality of life led
to substantial reductions in productivity loss and future health care costs. These
savings outweigh the costs of the intervention, rendering RTW cost-saving from a
societal perspective. Conclusions: From a societal perspective return-to-work is
expected to be cost-saving. Hospitals bear the largest share of the cost, while most
financial benefits fall upon other stakeholders. Re-distributing costs and financial
benefits among stakeholders would result in feasible financing of the intervention.
PCN60
Cost of Treating Acute Promyelocytic Leukemia (APL) Patients in
Italy
Kruse M M 1, Wildner R 1, Barnes G 2, Martin M 3, Mueller U 4, Lo Coco F 5, Leyman S 6,
Pathak A 2
1Optum, Waltham, MA, USA, 2Teva Pharmaceutical, 19355, PA, USA, 3OptumInsight, Uxbridge,
Middlesex, UK, 4Teva Pharmaceutical, Ehrenkirchen, Germany, 5University Tor Vergata, Rome, PA,
USA, 6TEVA Pharmaceuticals Europe, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate the total costs of arsenic trioxide and all-trans retinoic
acid (ATO+ATRA) versus ATRA and idarubicin (AIDA) regimens in Italy when used
in 1st-line APL treatment. ATO+ATRA is approved in 2st-line treatment, but commonly used globally in 1st-line. Methods: A Markov model was developed with
three health states: non-progressive disease, progressive disease and death. Each
month, patients could move from non-progressive to progressive disease or die
from either state. After progression, patients discontinued treatment and switched
to the other regimen. Treatment regimens, efficacy and adverse events were derived
from published sources and expert opinion, while each arm’s unit costs (induction and consolidation for both; maintenance for AIDA only) were collected from
standard Italian sources. Per-patient costs were reported, and extensive one-way
sensitivity analyses were conducted. Results: Expected 2-year pharmacy costs
for ATO+ATRA were € 46,600 versus € 5,300 for AIDA. However, direct medical (DM)
costs (e.g., monitoring, hospitalizations, etc.) for ATO+ATRA were € 11,300 versus
€28,500 for AIDA. The higher costs stemmed from AIDA consolidation taking place in
a hospital setting and 2-year maintenance monitoring costs. The treatment failure
likelihood for patients on AIDA was 14% versus 3% on ATO+ATRA. As these patients
switched to 2nd-line treatment, relapse costs for AIDA were € 1,500 compared to € 400
for ATO+ATRA. AIDA patients incurred higher costs from adverse events (AEs) than
ATO+ATRA (€ 600 vs. € 300, respectively). Results were most sensitive to consolidation cost changes: ATO+ATRA pharmacy costs and AIDA DM costs. Conclusions:
The results suggest potential cost savings due to DM, progression and AE costs
for ATO+ATRA, although AIDA pharmacy costs are lower. Additionally, ATO+ATRA
patients have lower clinical AE risks and shorter treatment duration (8 months
versus 28 months for AIDA), which could lead to patients’ improved quality of life
and cost savings. Further research is needed to determine the cost-effectiveness
of ATO+ATRA.
PCN61
Economic Impact of Centralized Histological Reviews in Patients
with Sarcoma, Gist, and Desmoid Tumors
Perrier L 1, Kembou Nzale S 1, Rascle P 1, Bui B 2, Morelle M 1, Ranchère Vince D 1, Terrier P 3,
Neuville A 2, Decouvelaere A V 1, Le Cesne A 3, Gomez F 1, de la Fouchardière C 1, Meeus P 1,
Trédan O 1, Pérol M 1, Fayette J 1, Neidhardt E M 1, Biron P 1, Boyle H J 1, Marec Bérard P 4, Farsi
F 5, Ducimetière F 1, Blay J Y 1, Ray Coquard I 1, Coindre J M 2
1Cancer Centre Léon Bérard, Lyon, France, 2Institut Bergonié, Bordeaux, France, 3Insitut Gustave
Roussy, Villejuif, France, 4IHOP, Lyon, France, 5Regional oncology network Réseau Espace Santé
Cancer, Lyon, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The aim of this study was to compare the costs of disease management
based on revised diagnoses after centralized histological reviews for sarcoma, GIST,
and desmoid tumors with the costs based on diagnoses before reviews. Methods:
A decision tree was constructed. For both options, the initial pathway was the World
Health Organization (WHO) Classification of soft tissue and bone tumors. Diagnoses
were considered concordant only when the final diagnosis was categorized in the
same manner as the initial finding, as defined by the WHO classification. The decision tree was evaluated over a time horizon of 12 months. Disease management and
the probabilities were based on a cohort of patients who had a histological review
performed within the RRePS (Réseau de Référence en Pathologie des Sarcomes)
network in 2010. The characteristics of the patient and disease, as well as any relevant guidelines, were used. All of the disease managements were defined by the
authors of this study. The costs were considered from the French National Health
Insurance (NHI) perspective and the costs of the histological review were extracted
from the literature. The costs were assessed for each pathway and expressed in
Euros 2013. The expected costs were calculated. One-way and probabilistic sensitivity analyses were performed. Results: A total of 2,425 patients underwent a histological review. Of these, 341 patients were found to have a discordant diagnosis. Ten
patients were excluded due to missing data. The costs reached € 8,420 (histological
review included) when disease management was based on revised diagnoses and
€ 8,610 when not. Conclusions: In addition to the positive impact of centralized
histological reviews on the quality of diagnosis for sarcoma, GIST, and desmoid
tumors, our model demonstrated that histological reviews lower the cost of disease
management for the French NHI.
PCN62
A Cost-Analysis of Complex Radiotherapy in Patients with Head and
Neck Cancer Results from the Art-Orl Study
Perrier L 1, Morelle M 1, Pommier P 2, Boisselier P 3, Lartigau E 4, Gallocher O 5, Alfonsi M 6,
Bardet E 7, Rives M 8, Calugaru V 9, Chajon E 10, Noel G 11, Mecellem H 12, Pérol D 1, Dussart S 1,
Giraud P 13
1Cancer Centre Léon Bérard, Lyon, France, 2Leon Berard Cancer Centre, Lyon, France, 3Institut
Régional de Cancérologie de Montpellier, Montpellier, France, 4Centre Oscar Lambret, Lille, France,
5Groupe OncoRad Garonne, Toulouse, France, 6Institut Sainte Catherine, Avignon, France, 7Centre
René Gauducheau, Saint Herblain, France, 8Institut Claudius Regaud, Toulouse, France, 9Institut
Curie, Paris, France, 10Centre Eugène Marquis, Rennes, France, 11Centre Paul Strauss, Strasbourg,
France, 12Institut de Cancérologie de Lorraine, Vandœuvre-lès-Nancy, France, 13Hôpital Européen
Georges Pompidou, Paris, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: A cost analysis investigating TomoTherapy ® (Accuray), Elekta
Volumetric-modulated Arc Therapy (VMAT®) and Varian RapidArc®was conducted
in patients with head and neck cancer. Methods: The cost-analysis, funded by
the National Institute of Cancer (INCa), was performed prospectively based on
a multicenter study. Cost calculations were strictly based on a micro costing
approach according to the hospitals’ point of view. Only resources which are likely
to vary between the strategies being compared were considered. Data on consumption of resources were collected from the treatment planning until the end of the
last irradiation session. Productivity losses of radiotherapy involved personnel
related to organisational constraints or absenteeism, costs of administrative personnel, costs of logistics and general management were not taken into account.
All costs were given in 2013 euros. Numbers of irradiation sessions were compared
using Kruskal-Wallis test. Uncertainty was captured by one-way and probabilistic sensitivity analyses using a non-parametric bootstrap method. Results: 174
patients were enrolled in 16 French centers from February 2010 to February 2012.
173 economic questionnaires were exploitable. The mean numbers of sessions
were 34.33 (SD: 2.90) for TomoTherapy® (n= 73) and 34.53 (SD: 2.57) for Varian
RapidArc® (n= 92, p= 0.603). Eight patients were treated with Elekta Volumetricmodulated Arc Therapy (VMAT®). For irradiation (all sessions included), the over
cost of TomoTherapy® (n= 73) reached € 1,109 per patient compared to Varian
RapidArc® (n= 92). Sensitivity analyses showed that the annual operating time of
the accelerators played a major role in irradiation costs. Conclusions: This is
to our knowledge the first study highlighting costs incurred by different IntensityModulated ArcTherapy (IMAT) modalities in this setting. Costs of TomoTherapy®
appeared more expensive than RapidArc®. The study should be now completed
by a cost-effectiveness analysis in order to shed further light on which modality
to focus on.
PCN63
Costed Treatment Pathways of Diffuse Large B Cell Lymphoma in a
UK Population-Based Cohort: A Patient Level Simulation Model
Wang H I 1, Smith A 1, Roman E 1, Crouch S 1, Jack A 2, Patmore R 3
1University of York, York, UK, 2St James’s University Hospital, Leeds, UK, 3Castle Hill Hospital,
Hull, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Diffuse large B-cell lymphoma (DLBCL) is the most common type of
non-Hodgkin lymphoma and treatment is usually given with curative intent. Using
restricted datasets derived from clinical trials, previous studies examining the cost
of treating this cancer have generally focussed on first-line therapy alone; meaning
A625
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
that their findings can neither be extrapolated to the general patient population
nor to other points along the pathway. Based on empirical data from a representative population-based patient cohort, the objective of this study was to develop
a simulation model that could predict costs at an individual level and estimate
the real medical costs of treating DLBCL. Methods: All patients newly diagnosed
with DLBCL in the UK’s population-based Haematological Malignancy Research
Network (www.hmrn.org) in 2007 were followed until 2013 (n= 271). The mapped
treatment pathways, alongside cost information derived from the National Tariff
2013/14, were incorporated into a patient level simulation model in order to reflect
the heterogeneities of patient characteristics and treatment options. Results:
The expected total medical costs were £23,184 for those treated curatively with
chemotherapy and £2,125 for those with a palliative approach over a period of five
years. The predicted medical cost of the first line was £15,243, and £16,325 and
£7,145 for the second line and the third line treatments respectively. The predicted
costs captured 94% of the actual costs and the proportion of patients simulated in
each health state was identical to the empirical data, supporting the validity of the
model. Conclusions: This is the first cost modelling study to use empirical data
to provide ‘real world’ evidence to estimate medical costs of entire DLBCL treatment
pathways. Future application of the model developed here could be used to evaluate
new technologies/treatments and support health care decision makers, especially
in the era of personalised medicine.
PCN64
Cost-Consequence Analysis of an Aprepitant Regimen Versus
a Standard Antiemetic Regimen for the Prevention of Highly
Emetogenic Chemotherapy-Induced Nausea and Vomiting in Italy
Rosti G 1, Ravasio R 2
9 Treviso (Italy), Treviso, Italy, 2Health Publishing & Services, Milano, Italy
.
.
1ULSS
Objectives: Prevention of chemotherapy-induced nausea and vomiting (CINV)
remains an important goal for patients receiving cytotoxic treatment. The objective of this study was to assess, from the Italian National Health Service payer
perspective, the costs of an antiemetic regimen using aprepitant, a selective neurokinin-1 receptor antagonist, for patients receiving highly emetogenic chemotherapy. Methods: A decision-analytic model was developed to compare an
aprepitant regimen (aprepitant, ondansetron, and dexamethasone) with a standard
antiemetic regimen (ondansetron and dexamethasone) for expected costs after
highly emetogenic chemotherapy. The model was populated with clinical results
from patients with high-dose cisplatin treatment in a randomized trial of CINV
preventative therapy. Only direct medical costs (pharmacological treatment and
emesis) – Euro 2014 – were considered. Sensitivity and Threshold analyses on key
clinical and economic parameters were performed. Results: Aprepitant regimen
showed the lower expected treatment cost (aprepitant regimen: € 109.88; standard
antiemetic regimen € 115.57). The drug acquisition cost of the aprepitant regimen
(aprepitant regimen: € 86.16; standard antiemetic regimen € 79.37) was offset by
reduced health care resource utilization costs for CINV (aprepitant regimen: € 23.72;
standard antiemetic regimen: € 36.20). Sensitivity and Threshold analysis confirmed
the base case results. Conclusions: The results of this cost-consequence analysis
suggest that, from the Italian National Health Service payer perspective, aprepitant regimen is a cost-saving strategy compared with antiemetic regimen without
aprepitant in the prevention of highly emetogenic chemotherapy-induced nausea
and vomiting.
PCN65
Cost of Non Small Cell Lung Cancer by Vietnamese and European
Treatment Standards in Vietnam
Dinh H T 1, Nguyen T T T 2
of Medicine and Pharmacy in HCMC, HCMC, Vietnam, 2University of Medicine and
Pharmacy in HCMC, Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam
.
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: Evaluate and compare the cost of non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC)
treatment by different standards of treatment in Vietnam. Methods: A tree-decision model has been developed to estimate the cost of NSCLC. The analysis has
been conducted based on the perspective of health insurance companies, therefore only medical direct costs, including cost for drugs and medical services has
been evaluated. The list of medical services and drugs was derived from NCCN
Clinical Practice Guidelines in Oncology (NCCN therapy) and Lung Cancer Therapy
of Vietnam National Cancer Hospital (Vietnam therapy). The transition rates in the
model were derived from clinical researches and consultation with experts. The
cost of drugs and medical services has been averaged from the relevant medical
services of some major hospitals in Vietnam. Results: The total treatment costs
increase following the severity of stage whether treatment was implemented by
Vietnamese or European standards. Moreover, in all stages of disease, the total
treatment costs of NSCLC by Vietnamese guideline are less than that by NCCN
standard (74,425,114 vs 79,729,000 in phase I; 139,031,940 vs 210,585,139 in phase II,
172,333,617 vs 339,542,672 VND in phase III, and 160,690,121 VND vs 266,197,825 VND
in phase IV, respectively). This can be explained by the lack of some expensive drugs
and medical services in Vietnam due to the socio-economic conditions of Vietnam.
In the structure of costs, cost for drugs take the dominant part with approximately
76.61% by NCCN standard and 74.92% by Vietnamese standard, which is almost 3
times higher than that of medical services. Conclusions: The high cost of NCSLC
should be considered to conduct the relevant health care policies, especially with
high-cost drugs in late stages of disease. The cost of NSCLC treatment by NCCN
therapy is higher than the cost of NSCLC treatment by Vietnam therapy.
PCN66
Hospital Cost of Thromboembolic Events in Breast or Prostate
Cancer Patients
Scotte F 1, Martelli N 1, Vainchtock A 2, Borget I 3
1Hopital Européen Georges Européen, Paris, France, 2HEVA, Lyon, France, 3Institut Gustave Roussy,
Villejuif, France
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Venous thromboembolism (VTE) is a common complication for cancer patients, leading to hospitalizations that increase the cost of management of
these patients. The objective of the present study was to evaluate the number and
the cost of VTE-related hospitalizations for patients with breast or prostate cancer
during the two first years of their oncologic treatment. Methods: Patients with
breast cancer (BC) or prostate cancer (PC) diagnosed in 2010 who had at least one
VTE-related hospitalization during the following two years were selected from the
French national hospital database (PMSI), using the disease-specific ICD-10 codes.
Hospital costs were estimated from the third-party payer perspective using the
official diagnosis related group (DRG) tariffs for each year considered. Results: In
2010,62,365 patients newly diagnosed with BC and 45,551 with PC were admitted
in French hospitals. Among them, 1,271 in the BC cohort (2.0%) and 997 in the PC
cohort (2.2%) were hospitalized for VTE at least once during the two-year followup, leading to 1,604 stays for BC patients and 1,210 stays for PC patients. During a
2-years follow-up, 15.9% of BC patients and 14.4% of PC patients were re-hospitalized
for VTE recurrence. The mean cost per stay was 3,261€ and 3,584€ for BC and PC
respectively. Mean cost per patient was estimated at 3,302€ and 3,611€ for BC and
PC patients hospitalized once for VTE-related events, and it increased to 5,545€ and
5,692€ for BC and PC patients who presented recurrences. Over a 2-year period, total
hospital cost induced by VTE-related events reached 1.98 million and 1.43 million €
for BC and PC, respectively. Conclusions: VTE-related hospitalizations in breast
or prostate cancer patients lead to a significant economic burden that could be
reduced by decreasing VTE recurrence.
PCN67
Assessing the Economic Burden and Health Care Utilization of U. S.
Medicare Patients Diagnosed with Melanoma
Xie L 1, Kariburyo M F 1, Du J 1, Baser O 2
1STATinMED Research, Ann Arbor, MI, USA, 2STATinMED Research and The University of
Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To examine the economic burden and health care utilization of
melanoma patients in the U. S. Medicare population. Methods: A retrospective database analysis was performed using U. S. national Medicare claims from
01JAN2008 to 31DEC2012. Melanoma patients were identified using International
Classification of Disease 9thRevision Clinical Modification (ICD-9-CM) diagnosis
code 172. xx. The first diagnosis date was designated as the index date. A comparator group was created, consisting of patients with the same age, region, gender,
index year, and matched baseline Charlson Comorbidity Index scores but without a melanoma diagnosis. A random index date was chosen for the comparator
cohort to reduce selection bias. Patients were required to have continuous medical
and pharmacy benefits 1 year pre- and post-index date. One-to-one propensity
score matching (PSM) was performed to compare follow-up health care costs and
utilizations between the cohorts, adjusting for demographic and clinical characteristics. Results: Eligible patients (N= 12,762) were identified for the melanoma
and comparison cohorts. After 1: 1 PSM, a total of 8,015 patients were matched
from each cohort and baseline characteristics were well-balanced. More melanoma
patients had health care utilizations, including Medicare carrier (99.6% vs. 64.3%),
Durable Medical Equipment (DME; 19.8% vs. 14.4%) and Home Health Agency
(HHA; 6.7% vs. 4.1%) claims, outpatient visits (68.4% vs. 35.4%), inpatient (10.9%
vs. 6.6%) and skilled nursing facility (SNF) stays (2.4% vs. 1.7%), but fewer melanoma patients had prescription clams (43.6% vs. 49.8%). Patients diagnosed with
melanoma incurred higher expenditures, including carrier ($3,527 vs. $1,324), DME
($153 vs. $101), HHA ($325 vs. $203), outpatient ($8,816 vs. $3,151), inpatient ($1,725
vs. $1,154) and total health care costs ($15,692 vs. $6,990) (p< 0.0001). Similar SNF,
hospice and pharmacy claim costs were observed in both cohorts. Conclusions:
Patients diagnosed with melanoma had a higher burden of illness compared to
the comparison cohort of non-melanoma patients.
PCN68
Resource Use and Health Care Costs of Cervical Lesions and
Cervical Cancer in Slovakia
Ondrusova M 1, Psenkova M 1, Mlyncek M 2, Masak L 3, Hlavinkova L 4, Trnovec P 4
Ltd, Bratislava, Slovak Republic, 2Faculty Hospital and Constantine the Philosopher
University, Nitra, Slovak Republic, 3Cancer Institute St. Elizabeth, Bratislava, Slovak Republic,
4GlaxoSmithKline Slovakia, Bratislava, Slovak Republic
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Pharm-In
Objectives: The objective of this cost study was to measure the resource utilisation and direct costs associated with health care management of cervical abnormal
cytology and cervical cancer in Slovakia and to provide a basis for cost-effectiveness evaluations. Methods: The cross-sectional survey was performed to obtain
the information on the management of patients with cervical lesions (Low Grade
Squamous Intraepithelial Lesion (LSIL), High Grade Squamous Intraepithelial Lesion
(HSIL), Atypical Squamous Cells of Undetermined Significance (ASCUS), Cervical
Intraepithelial Neoplasia (CIN) I-III) and cervical cancer (clinical stages IA1 to IVB)
and to estimate the direct costs of the disease management. All types of health care
used in the management of cervical lesions/cancer were evaluated (diagnostics,
treatment and follow-up). Average costs per patient were assessed on a yearly basis
and correspond to the prices in 2013. Results: Concerning the cervical lesions, the
highest mean annual costs were identified in the CIN III (36.45%; € 1406.62), followed
by CIN II (27.0%; € 1041.97), the most costly part of health care management being
the treatment of lesions. The costs of health care management of cervical cancer
depended on the clinical stage and the frequency of examinations during the year.
The highest total costs (follow-up included) were identified in the stage III (19.33%;
€ 4633.35) and IVB (14.24%; € 3413.22). However, the highest mean annual costs of
diagnostics were determined in stage IB (15.39%; € 542.12), IIA (15.46%; € 544.33),
IVA and IVB (14.89%; € 524.33). The most expensive treatment (including surgery,
radiotherapy, concomitant chemoradiotherapy and palliative chemotherapy) was
identified in the stage IIB (20.89%; € 3616.38) and III (21.01%; € 3637.79). In the most
advanced stages IVA and IVB, the treatment expenses were lower. Follow-up management was the most expensive in the stage IVB (15%; € 531.66). Conclusions:
A626
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
In the management of cervical lesions/cervical cancer, the most expensive are the
costs of treatment.
PCN69
Economic Burden of Melanoma in Three European Countries:
A Retrospective Observational Study
Kontoudis I 1, Harries M 2, Mohr P 3, Grange F 4, Ehness R 5, Benjamin L 6, Siakpere O 7, Barth
J 5, Stapelkamp C 8, Pfersch S 6, McLeod L 9, Kaye J A 10, Wolowacz S 11
1GlaxoSmithKline Vaccines, Rixensart, Belgium, 2NHS, London, UK, 3Dermatologic Center
Buxtehude, Buxtehude, Germany, 4Reims University Hospital, Reims, France, 5GlaxoSmithKline
GmbH & Co KG, Munich, Germany, 6GlaxoSmithKline France, Marly le Roi Cedex, France,
7GlaxoSmithKline UK, Middlesex, UK, 8GlaxoSmithKline, Uxbridge, UK, 9RTI Health Solutions,
Research Triangle Park, NC, USA, 10RTI Health Solutions, Waltham, MA, USA, 11RTI Health
Solutions, Manchester, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate cost-of-illness data associated with treatment of patients
with stage IIIB/IIIC melanoma with macroscopic lymph node involvement in France,
Germany and the United Kingdom (UK), whose primary melanoma and regional
lymph node metastases had been completely resected. Methods: This retrospective observational study enrolled patients aged ≥18 years, first diagnosed between 1
January 2009 and 31 December 2011. Data were extracted from medical records and
via patient survey. Costs were calculated in Euros (€ ) (France, Germany) or pound
sterling (£) (UK) by collecting resource use and multiplying by country-specific unit
costs. Costs were estimated from the health care provider perspective. National
annual costs were estimated from study results and national disease prevalence
estimates based on European cancer registry and other data. Results: 49 centres
provided data on 558 patients (55.7% male, 58.2% aged < 65 years at diagnosis, 53.6%
stage IIIB disease). Mean follow-up was 27 months in France, 26 months in Germany
and 22 months in the UK. Most patients received no adjuvant treatment in France
(93.0%) and the UK (97.4%). Use of interferon in Germany was limited (high-dose
11.0%; intermediate-dose 4.9%; low-dose 15.2%; pegylated 1.8%). Mean total direct
cost per patient during follow-up was € 23,582 in France, € 32,058 in Germany and
£31,123 (€ 37,348) in the UK. The largest cost drivers were melanoma treatment
(mean € 14,004 France, € 21,269 Germany and £24,385 UK) and hospitalisation/emergency treatment (mean € 6,634 France, € 6,950 Germany and £2,827 UK). Total mean
indirect costs per patient were € 129 in France, € 4,441 in Germany and £1,427 (€ 1,712)
in the UK. Preliminary estimates for annual national direct cost were €13.1 million in
France, €30.2 million in Germany and £22.8 (€27.6) million in the UK. Conclusions:
The economic burden of stage IIIB/IIIC melanoma with macroscopic lymph node
involvement was substantial in all three countries. Indirect costs varied by country.
PCN70
Cost and Burden of Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer’s in Portugal
Borges M 1, Gouveia M 2, Alarcão J 1, Sousa R 1, Teixeira E 3, Barata F 4, Laranjeira E 1, Lopes F 1,
Parente B 5, Pinheiro L 1, Vaz-Carneiro A 1, Costa J 1
1Center for Evidence Based Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, University of Lisbon, Lisbon, Portugal,
2Católica Lisbon School of Business and Economics, Lisbon, Portugal, 3Centro Hospitalar Lisboa
Norte, Lisboa, Portugal, Lisbon, Portugal, 4Centro Hospitalar Universitário de Coimbra, Coimbra,
Portugal, 5Hospital CUF Porto, Porto, Portugal
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: This study estimates the impact of Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer
(NSCLC) on population health levels and its economic impact in Portugal in 2012.
Methods: Data from a cohort of 581 patients with NSCLC completed with an expert
panel was used to develop a model of cumulated prevalence with a 6 months cycle
period and a time horizon of 5 years. The impact on health status was measured
using the Disability Adjusted Life Years (DALYs). The economic impact analysis
includes two components. The first estimates the direct costs generated by NSCLC
including consumption of inpatient care and outpatient care (consultations, medication, diagnostic exams, transportation, etc). The second estimates indirect costs
related to loss of productivity due to NSCLC. Results: A total of 3,180 deaths in
Portugal in 2012 were caused by NSCLC, which corresponds to 2.0% of the total
deaths in Portugal. The DALYs resulting from premature deaths caused by NSCLC
in 2012 totaled 25,071 representing 4.5% of years lost generated by all deaths in
the country. For 2012 it is estimated that 3,236 life years were lost due to disability.
The total disease burden attributable to NSCLC is thus estimated at 28,307 DALY.
The estimated direct cost generated by NSCLC was € 89 million and that total can
be broken down into € 32 million for inpatient care and € 57 million for outpatient
care. The indirect costs must also be taken into account and they added up to €
54 million. The economic burden of NSCLC is substantial, totaling € 143 million,
about 0.09% of Portuguese GDP and 0.92% of all Portuguese health spending in
2012. Conclusions: NSCLC is an important cause of disease burden and costs in
Portugal and should receive adequate attention from policy makers.
PCN71
Metastatic Prostate Cancer and Skeletal Related Events, a Cost of
Illness Study
Geenen J W 1, Heine ter R 2, Frederix G W 1, Hövels A 3, Vulpen, van M 4, Kooistra A 2, Klerk de
J M H 2, Bloemendal H J 2
1Utrecht University, Utrecht, The Netherlands, 2Meander Medical Center, Amersfoort, The
Netherlands, 3Utrecht Institute for Pharmaceutical Sciences, Division Pharmacoepidemiology &
Clinical Pharmacology, Utrecht University, Utrecht, The Netherlands, 4University Medical Centre
Utrecht, Utrecht, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess the intramural resource use and associated costs of treating
patients with prostate cancer, metastatic to the bone, focusing on Skeletal Related
Events (SREs). Secondary, to quantify the impact of SREs and different treatment
strategies on total costs. Methods: A retrospective bottom-up cost of illness study
performed at a large regional teaching hospital in the Netherlands. Results: A total
of 136 patients were included, follow-up started at diagnosis of bone metastases and
stopped at death. The mean total costs were EUR 17.931 per patient (median EUR
14.039), inpatient days were the most costly category at a mean of EUR 5955 (median
EUR 3995). SREs that required hospitalization (n= 53) were, at median costs of EUR
2039 to EUR 9346, depending on care required, more costly than SREs without hospitalization (n= 165). These SREs had median costs of EUR 200 to EUR 1912, depending
on care required. Conclusions: The impact of SREs on total costs could justify
policy aimed at actively preventing SREs, e.g. with radionuclide therapy, possibly
resulting in better quality of life and cost-reduction. Treatment of prostate cancer
with bone metastases is not very costly compared to lung-and breast cancer with
similar metastases. However, novel therapeutic options may dramatically increase
treatment costs in the near future and proper head-to-head cost-effectiveness studies of all treatment modalities are therefore necessary.
PCN72
Economic Impact Model of Breast Cancer Treatment at Early Stages
in the Mexican Public Health Care Sector
Guirant-Corpi L 1, Hernandez-Reyes F C 1, Kelly J 2, Muciño-Ortega E 1
S.A. de C.V., Ciudad de México, Mexico, 2Centro Médico Nacional Siglo XXI, Mexico City,
Mexico
.
.
.
.
.
1Pfizer
Objectives: Nowadays breast cancer represents a great economic burden to public
health care sector in Mexico. This economic burden is due by a lack of prevention
campaigns and late diagnosis. The analysis aims to estimate the economic impact
of standard treatment in Mexico for an optimistic scenario of 80% of all breast cancer population at early stages compared to the actual distribution (55%) of patients
along the stages in Mexican setting. Methods: A hypothetical patient cohort of 8765
was evaluated; this estimation was obtained from breast cancer 2011 prevalence in
Mexican population. The analysis was developed in order to estimate average cost
from the optimistic (base-case) versus actual scenario through public health care
perspective. Distribution of population in the actual case scenario was 16%, 39%,
30% and 14% at each stage, I-IV respectively. Direct medical costs were extracted
from a published source where through a micro-costing technique the cost at each
stage was obtained. Costs are expressed in 2014 USD ($1USD=$13MXN). It is assumed
that the economical difference between both scenarios will be used for prevention
campaigns. Results: The total cost of treatment for all patients on the actual scenario was $124,261,716 compared to $103,549,361 that was the cost calculated at the
base-case scenario. Economic impact of optimistic scenario is 17% less than total cost
of treatment at the current scenario. This difference, which represents $20,712,355,
could be reallocated to diagnose 32,689 more patients at early stages. A sensitivity
analysis with a best-case scenario was developed considering 100% of the patients
diagnosed during the first two stages where economic benefits were 314% higher than
base-case scenario. Conclusions: This analysis suggests that if more public policies
focused on breast cancer prevention were implemented, then it may lead to a more
optimal reallocation of resources since direct medical costs increase at late stages.
PCN73
Burden of Prostate Cancer and Future Need for Health Care
Services
Purmonen T 1, Tyrväinen V 2, Kataja V 3
1Medfiles Ltd, Kuopio, Finland, 2Proper Ltd, Joensuu, Finland, 3Central Finland Health Care
District, Jyväskylä, Finland
.
.
.
Objectives: Prostate cancer is the most common cancer with a current incidence
of 0,18% among the 2,6million Finnish men. Demand on health care resource use
is dependent on number of patients needing the service. Patient volumes are
increasing throughout Europe due to ageing of the population. Despite the stabile or decreasing age-adjusted incidence rates, the absolute number of patients is
growing. The population characteristics vary within geographical areas, and thus,
using average parameters for the whole country would lead to biased estimates.
In this study, burden of prostate cancer cases is estimated on municipality level
throughout Finland. Methods: Number of new cancer cases in different hospital
districts (N= 20) was extracted from the Finnish cancer registry. Official population
statistics and forecast were used to identify the current and predicted age and sex
distribution in all of the individual municipalities (N= 320). The data were combined
with Tableau (8.0) software, where a map-based interface was constructed. This
was also utilized to visualize the population changes and patient forecasts. Similar
methodology has been previously utilized in different cancer types. Results: The
number of new prostate cancer cases each year is estimated to be 1,5-fold by 2040.
As a case example, a Finnish municipality with 135,000 inhabitants was chosen.
There were 78 new prostate cancer cases among the 64,332 men in 2011, representing an incidence of 0,12%. According to our analysis, this university city with
relatively young population would reach the current country average (0,18%) as
late as 2040. Conclusions: The disease burden and population demographics are
unevenly distributed across the country, and thus municipality level estimates are
needed to inform local decision making and planning. Estimates on the absolute
number of patients across relevant disease areas are required in order to prepare
to the challenges health care systems are facing in the future.
PCN74
The Burden of Non-Small Cells Lung Cancer (NSCLC) in First Line (1L)
Treatment: Patterns of Care and Cost of Illness
Piedade A , Goes L , Castro A P , Alves A F , Minowa E
Evidências Credibilidade Científica, São Paulo, Brazil
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Several treatment options are available for 1L NSCLC. In Brazil, patients
with NSCLC have not been systematically evaluated and different management
strategies may be associated to different economical outcomes. Therefore, we aimed
to evaluate the patterns of care and cost of illness of 1L NSCLC treatment according
to Brazilian supplementary health system. Methods: Metastatic NSCLC patients
receiving 1L treatment during year 2013 were eligible and selected from the private
market administrative claims database (Evidencias database). Treatments, demographics, supportive drugs and exams were evaluated. Name and any other personal
identification were not available at the database. The most reported treatments
according to generic name in 1L therapy were defined as patterns of care. The cost
of illness was calculated by a bottom-up approach. Exams and associated drugs
A627
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
reported were also considered for costing and values were derived from Tables
Simpro and CBHPM. Exchange rate used was 1.00USD = 2.20BRL. Results: A total
of 233 patients with lung cancer were identified at the database from which 101 were
eligible to the study. Fifteen different chemotherapy regimens were reported. The
most common regimen was carboplatin with pemetrexed (29,7%), 20,8% received
bevacizumab containing regimen and only 6% were in use of oral chemotherapy.
About 87% of the patients received a total of 3 cycles of treatment. Costs per cycle of
the schemes observed ranged from US$ 11.890,36 to US$ 1.712,95. Considering the
number of cycles administered reported in the database, the average cost of management for one patient with metastatic NSCLC in 1L is US$19.001,79. Conclusions:
Treatment of 1L metastatic NSCLC represents a significant burden to the Brazilian
private payers. The preferences of chemotherapy regimens may change in the following years due to the incorporation of oral chemotherapy in the list of mandatory
coverage treatments and procedures.
PCN75
Real World Management and Costs in Unresectable Metastatic
Melanoma (UMM) Patients Treated at the Antwerp University
Hospital (UZA)
Strens D 1, Specenier P 2, Peeters M 2
1Realidad, GRIMBERGEN, Belgium, 2University Hospital Antwerp, Edegem, Belgium
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess the management and associated lifetime costs in
uMM patients as from the diagnosis of unresectable metastatic disease until
death. Methods: We performed a retrospective patient chart review to obtain
data on medical consumption related to the management of uMM. A complete
registry of all patients diagnosed with melanoma at UZA between 2007 and May
2014 was compiled. Eligible for this retrospective chart review were patients with
uMM with sufficient data available and who deceased before May 2014. Data on
demographics, disease characteristics and management of uMM were collected.
Direct costs were calculated by multiplying each item of resource use with its
unit cost (2013, € ) using the Belgian public health care payer’s perspective (PHCP)
and patient’s perspective. Average (bootstrap 95%CI) overall costs per patient
were calculated. Results: 396 patients were registered. 44 eligible patients were
included. 81.8% (n= 36) of patients were treated by systemic treatment (s) of which
13.6% (n= 6) received up to 4 different treatment lines. 14 patients received “new
drugs” (ipilimumab: 13; vemurafenib: 4) 48/145 (40%) hospitalizations were for
treatment administration. Mean overall cost/patient was € 45,297 (bootstrap 95%
CI: 33,905- 57,550), of which € 44,346 (95%CI: 33,098-56,584) was reimbursed. The
PHCP cost was driven by systemic treatments costs (51% of cost). Mean PHCP cost
was € 93,537 (95 % CI: 81,710-105,346) for patients treated with “new drugs”, € 26,564
(95 % CI: 20,688-32,999) for patients treated with chemotherapy but no “new drugs”
and € 7,394 (95 % CI: 5,490-9,472) for patients on best supportive care (BSC) only.
Median overall survival was 6.1 months (9 months, 5.2 months, and 1 month for
patients treated with “new drugs”, with chemotherapy only, and with BSC only,
respectively). Conclusions: Management of uMM results in considerable costs
for the PHCP, mainly driven by systemic treatment costs.
PCN76
Burden of Disease of the MASTOCARCINOMA IN AUSTRIA
Bauer M
The Institute for Pharmaeconomic research, Vienna, Austria
identify the direct costs, including costs for drugs and medical services, and indirect costs, including loss productivity, loss of work, cost for accommodation and
transportation due to treatment and other costs of patient and caregivers. Results:
Annual total cost per patient with asthma accounts for 6,618,682 VND, from which
direct costs are 2.5 times more than indirect cost (4,738,682 vs 1,880,000 VND). The
total cost of asthma has increased following the asthma severity with 4,960,278;
8,098,156; 10,759,234; 13,196,280 VND in mild, intermittent, moderate and severe
asthma rate. In the structure of total cost, following the asthma severity, the percentage of direct costs increases and indirect costs decreases especially in the mild
rate. Total economic burden of asthma was 23,165 billion VND, from which 71.5%
(16,585 billion VND) are for direct costs and 29.5% (6,580 billion VND) for indirect
cost. Conclusions: The economic impact of asthma (23,165 billion VND) on asthmatic patients, families and society is significant. According to the study, putting
more public health efforts to better control asthma is the first necessary step to
reduce the costs of asthma.
PCN78
Economic Burden of Disease in France In 2012: A Top-Down
Allocation of Health Care Expenditure by Disease Based on the
French Health insurance Database (SNIIRAM)
Gastaldi-Menager C 1, Pestel L 1, Drouin J 1, Fagot-Campagna A 1, Gissot C 2, Polton D 2
1CNAMTS (National Health Insurance), Paris Cedex 20, France, 2CNAMTS (National Health
Insurance), paris cedex 20, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The aim of this study is to assess health care expenditure by disease
in order to provide detailed analyses of resource allocations for 2012, based on
the French health care system database. Methods: Using information about
60 millions of individuals from the general scheme insurance database (85% of
the French population), we identified all people who received care for each of 56
groups of diseases or medical events or treatments, which are frequent, severe
and/or costly. Algorithms have been applied to each patient, using ICD-10 diagnoses for long-term chronic diseases or hospital stays, specific drugs or medical
procedures. Costs of all reimbursed expenditures (outpatient/inpatient care, disability/sickness benefits) were extracted per individual for a top-down method
allocated expenditure to each of the 56 diseases based on the average expenditure by disease calculated for individuals with only one disease. All expenditures were thereafter extrapolated to the whole population to fit national health
account aggregates. Results: Among the 146 billion euros of expenditures (all
insurance schemes), 22.1 billion (15%) were related to psychiatric disorders and
treatments, 14 (10%) to cancer, 14.6 (10%) to cardiovascular diseases, 7.5 (5%) to
diabetes, 6.6 (5%) to vascular-risk treatments, 6.1 (4%) to neurologic disorders, 3.5
(2%) to chronic respiratory diseases, 4.7 (3%) to inflammatory/rare diseases/HIV,
3.5 (2%) to treated chronic renal insufficiency, 1.4 (1%) to liver/pancreas diseases,
1.5 (1%) to chronic pain killer users and 4 (3%) to other long-term chronic diseases.
Isolated hospitalizations represented 32.8 billion € (23%), basic care 14.6 (10%) and
maternity 9.1 (6%). This analysis also provides detailed patterns of expenditures by
diseases. Conclusions: Our study provides helpful information to policy makers by monitoring the performance of the health care system at a disease-based
level. This tool will be used to forecast the impact of ageing and epidemiologic
patterns on health expenditures.
.
Objectives: Breast cancer or rather called mastocarcinoma, is a malignant growth of
the mammary gland. With an incidence rate of 5.105 people in 2010, breast cancer is
the most frequent cancer disease in Austria. Annually about 1.500 cases of death are
registered, therefore breast cancer is the leading cause for death among women. As a
result, enormous costs arise for the health care system. Hence, the aim of the analysis
was to evaluate the cost and disease burden of breast cancer. Methods: A burden of
disease study, which evaluates all kinds of disease burden, like costs, quality adjusted
life years (QALYs) and disability adjusted life years (DALYs) lost, was conducted. This
analysis had an incidence based approach and projects costs over a time horizon of
one year. Data were collected via literature review, published list prices and hospital
records. Costs from published sources were used from the societal perspective. The
direct costs include hospital, treatment and physician consultation costs. Indirect
costs cover patient care giver costs as well as work absenteeism. Results: Each
breast cancer patient causes direct costs of 6,423.91 EUR and indirect costs of 37,511.87
EUR. Due to the fact that not only costs are important for the health care systems,
the mortality rate, QALYs and DALYs were identified. The mortality rate of breast
cancer conducts 7.7 percent of all cancer deaths in Austria. Compared to the healthy
population, a breast cancer patient has average utility decrements of 0.11. With
regard to an incidence rate of 5.105 people in 2010, a breast cancer patient will lose
0.03 DALYs within one year. Conclusions: The analysis showed that the treatment
of new diagnosed breast cancer patients causes about 225.5 million EUR. Moreover
patients had a lower QALY of 561,55 and a loss of 153,15 DALYs within one year.
PCN77
Economic Burden of Asthma in Vietnam: An Analysis from Patients’
Perspective
Nguyen T T T 1, Nguyen N B T 2
of Medicine and Pharmacy in HCMC, Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam, 2University of
Medicine and Pharmacy in HCMC, HCMC, Vietnam
.
.
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: Nowadays, health care costs of asthma are under pressure in all countries due to high prevalence, incidence and the chronic nature of disease. Estimating
the economic burden of asthma from patients’ perspective is necessary not only to
understand the value and structure, but also the economic influence of asthma to
whole society to propose and implement the relevant medical. This is also the aim
of this study. Methods: A tree-decision model has been developed to estimate the
value and structure of the economic burden of asthma in Vietnam. The economic
burden of asthma has been evaluated based on cost of asthma, including direct
and indirect costs. A cohort of 227 asthma patients was selected to be surveyed to
PCN79
The Burden of Health Care Costs Associated with Prostate Cancer
in Ireland
Burns R M 1, Leal J 1, Wolstenhome J 1, O’Neill C 2, Sullivan F J 3, Drummond F J 4, Sharp L 4
1University of Oxford, Oxford, UK, 2NUI Galway, Galway, Ireland, 3Prostate Cancer Institutue,
Galway, Ireland, 4National Cancer Registry Ireland, Cork, Ireland
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In 2010,3, 230 men were diagnosed with prostate cancer (PCa) in
Ireland, yielding one of the highest incidence rates across Europe. The focus of this
paper was to derive average costs for PCa diagnosis, treatment and follow-up, and
to estimate the overall health care expenditure for PCa in 2010 in Ireland using
a quasi, incidence-based, bottom-up approach. Methods: PCa (ICD10 C61) incidence and treatment data during 2007-2010 was obtained from the National Cancer
Registry Ireland. Estimates of resource use for items not recorded by the NCRI were
sourced from the literature and expert opinion. Costs associated with detection,
diagnosis, treatment, treatment complications, follow-up until year 4 post-diagnosis
and terminal care were estimated using various sources including study-specific
survey data, Irish hospital costs (HSE Casemix) and costs published in the literature.
A payer’s perspective using direct costs was adopted and costs were reported in
2010€ . Results: The overall expenditure associated with prostate specific antigen
(PSA) testing for those diagnosed with PCa in 2010 was € 360,016 (average per patient
cost (APPC) € 56 (confidence interval (CI): € 45, € 67)). Diagnosis including biopsies
and staging was estimated at € 2,872,333 (APPC € 804 (CI: € 573, € 1,114)). Treatment
costs (for the first year) varied considerably with active surveillance estimated at
€ 423,106 (APPC € 655 (CI: € 520, € 814)), external beam radiation therapy (in particular
intensity-modulated radiation therapy) estimated at € 8,872,037 (APPC € 6,867 (CI:
€ 5,429, € 8,235) and radical prostatectomy estimated at € 3,549,864 (APPC € 7,327 (CI:
€ 5,797, € 8,787). The total burden of health care expenditure associated with PCa in
2010 was approximately € 46.9 million (CI: € 37.4m, € 56.6m). Conclusions: PCa
expenditure is substantial and represents a sizeable proportion of the Irish health
care budget (€ 11bn). PCa incidence has steadily increased since 1998 due to increasing PSA testing; should trends continue expenditure will increase and this will have
implications for resource allocation in Ireland.
PCN80
Health Care Costs and Utilization of U. S. Veteran Patients
Diagnosed with Pancreatic Cancer
Xie L 1, Kariburyo M F 1, Wang Y 1, Baser O 2
1STATinMED Research, Ann Arbor, MI, USA, 2STATinMED Research and The University of
Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA
.
.
.
.
.
A628
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: To examine the economic burden and health care utilizations
of patients diagnosed with pancreatic cancer in the U. S. veteran population. Methods: A retrospective database analysis was performed using Veterans
Health Administration Medical SAS data from 01OCT2007 through 30SEP2012.
Patients diagnosed with pancreatic cancer were identified using International
Classification of Disease 9thRevision Clinical Modification (ICD-9-CM) code 157.
The first diagnosis date was defined as the index date. A group of patients with
similar age, region, gender and index year but without a pancreatic cancer diagnosis were identified as the comparison group and matched by baseline Charlson
Comorbidity Index scores. One year of continuous health plan enrollment was
required before and after the index date for both groups. Study outcomes, including health care costs and utilizations, were compared between pancreatic cancer
and comparator groups using 1: 1 propensity score matching (PSM). Results: A
total of 10,894 patients were identified for the pancreatic cancer and comparison
cohorts. After applying a 1: 1 PSM, 3,671 patients were matched from each cohort,
and the baseline characteristics were proportionate. Pancreatic cancer patients
were more likely to have higher health care resource utilizations, including inpatient admissions (38.03% vs. 2.18%, p< 0.0001), emergency room (ER) (30.67% vs.
5.48%, p< 0.0001), physician office visits (98.39% vs. 57.91%, p< 0.0001) and prescription fills (83.55% vs. 62.82%, p< 0.0001). Risk-adjusted health care costs were
also higher for pancreatic cancer patients, including inpatient ($18,079 vs. $442,
p< 0.0001), ER ($330 vs. $46, p< 0.0001), physician office ($5,600 vs. $1,106, p< 0.0001)
and pharmacy costs ($2,244 vs. $321, p< 0.0001), resulting in higher total costs
($26,503 vs. $1,977, p< 0.0001) relative to the comparator cohort. Conclusions:
During a period of 12 months, VHA patients diagnosed with pancreatic cancer
reported higher health care resource utilization and costs than their matched
controls.
PCN81
A Systematic Literature Review of the Economic Burden in Multiple
Myeloma
Rizzo M 1, Xu Y 2, Panjabi S 3, Iheanacho I 1
.
.
.
.
1Evidera, London, England, 2Evidera, Lexington, MA, USA, 3Onyx
Pharmaceuticals, Inc., an Amgen
subsidiary, South San Francisco, CA, USA
Objectives: To explore the resource use and costs for multiple myeloma (MM)
in a systematic literature review. Methods: We searched MEDLINE, Embase, the
Cochrane Library, and EconLit for English-language studies published from January 1,
2003 to May 16, 2013 that evaluated resource use and costs related to MM, including relapsed or relapsed and refractory MM (R/RRMM). These studies underwent
data abstraction and qualitative synthesis. Results: Thirteen primary studies in
the US (n= 5), UK (n= 1), US and UK (n= 1), The Netherlands (n= 2), France (n= 1), Italy
(n= 1), Sweden (n= 1), and Switzerland (n= 1) met the inclusion criteria. Three studies
were in newly-diagnosed MM patients, one in newly-diagnosed and previouslytreated patients, and nine in R/RRMM. The key cost drivers in R/RMM (as percentages
of total costs) were medications (32% to 66%), hospitalisations (15% to 35%), and
adverse events/complications/comorbidities (6% to 42%). Among treatment-related
adverse events in MM, neutropenia was the main cost driver, accounting for at
least two-thirds of total costs for managing such events, followed by thrombocytopenia, anaemia, and infections. In addition, metastatic bone disease significantly
increased direct treatment costs (+$57,720 per patient; 2004 USD) and accounted
for 17% (€ 6,937 per patient; 2002 € ) of total MM treatment costs. Also, patients with
progressive disease incurred costs over three times those in patients without disease
progression after initial treatment ($837 vs. $237 PPPM [2010 USD]). Conclusions:
The primary drivers of MM management costs are medication, hospitalisations, and
adverse events. Neutropenia, skeletal complications and progressive disease are also
especially costly in MM. This evidence highlights the need for effective therapies
with improved tolerability profiles that delay progression across a broad range of
patients with and without comorbidities.
PCN82
Exploring the Usefulness of Social Media and Patient Forums in
Identifying indirect Costs of a Disease
Chalkiadaki C , Martin A
Evidera, London, UK
.
PCN83
Trends in Secondary Care Costs for Treatment of Head and Neck
Cancer in England
Keeping S T 1, Naylor N R 1, Tempest M J 2, Stephens S 2, Carroll S M 1
Pasteur MSD, Maidenhead, UK, 2Pharmerit Ltd, York, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Sanofi
Objectives: Encompassing a group of cancers originating from the upper aerodigestive tract, head and neck cancers are ranked in the top ten for both incidence and mortality among all malignancies globally. This study aimed to estimate
trends in total secondary care costs associated with the treatment of head and
neck cancers in England from 2006/2007 to 2010/2011. Methods: Data on inpatient and outpatient activity associated with oropharyngeal, oral cavity and laryngeal cancer was extracted from the Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) database.
After grouping inpatient episodes into spells, a single Healthcare Resource Group
(HRG) was derived for each and then cross-referenced with the National Tariff
2010/11 to estimate the associated cost. For specific types of therapy, including
chemotherapy and radiotherapy, HRG definitions were cross-referenced with the
National Reference Costs for the latest available year and inflated using the PCI
index. Outpatient costs were estimated by grouping consultations by treatment
speciality. Results: The total cost of treatment for all cancers over the entire
period was estimated to be around £309 million, at 2011 prices. Inpatient care
covered by bundled HRGs accounted for over 90% of this cost, at £280 million. Total
costs due to oropharyngeal cancer were slightly higher than those estimated for
laryngeal and oral cancer, costing £115 million (37.06%), £96 million (31.15%) and
£98 million (31.79%) respectively. There was, generally, an increasing trend in the
secondary care burden of all three cancers. Annual costs and patient numbers
increased the most for oropharyngeal cancer, with annual inpatient costs increasing from £16,576,046 in 2006/07 to £28,467,016 in 2010/11. Conclusions: This
study indicates that there is a significant, and increasing, health and economic
burden associated with head and neck cancers in England, highlighting the need
for preventative programmes.
PCN84
Economic Burden of Chemotherapy Related Toxicities in Third Line
Metastatic Breast Cancer Patients
Majethia U 1, Tremblay G 1, He Y P 1, Faria C 1, Mccutcheon S 2, Kopenhafer L 3, Forsythe A 1
Lake, NJ, USA, 2Eisai Europe, Hatfield, UK, 3Curo Consulting, Marlow, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Eisai, Woodcliff
Objectives: During chemotherapy, a majority of patients experience treatmentrelated adverse-events (TEAEs). However, the number of patients requiring treatment and/or hospitalization (T&H) for managing TEAEs is significantly lower. The
objective of this study was to evaluate economic burden of TEAEs in third line
Metastatic Breast Cancer (MBC) patients. Methods: A post-hoc analysis was conducted on Phase 3 clinical trial of eribulin vs. Treatment of Physician’s Choice (TPC)
in MBC patients with two prior chemotherapy regimens including anthracycline and
taxane. TPC included capecitabine, gemcitabine, vinorelbine, docetaxel and paclitaxel. Grade 3&4 TEAEs which were observed in ≥ 5% of patients were considered.
Patients who required T&H for managing TEAEs were further studied. Duration and
costs associated with T&H were obtained from a micro-costing study where UK-NHS
tariffs for each cost unit were applied. TEAE clinical trial frequency data for each
treatment were annualized prior to cost evaluation, based on treatment duration
(113 days for eribulin and 68 days for TPC patients). Results: Only a small proportion of patients who experienced TEAEs required T&H. The frequencies of TEAEs
experienced vs. TEAEs that required T&H for most commonly observed TEAEs were
as follows: neutropenia (Eribulin: 45.2% vs. 14.5%; TPC: 21.1% vs. 5.3%), leukopenia
(Eribulin: 13.9% vs 4.2%; TPC: 5.7% vs. 1.6%), peripheral-neuropathy (Eribulin: 8.2%
vs. 3.8%; TPC: 2.0% vs. 0.4%) and asthenia/fatigue (Eribulin: 8.8% vs. 1.6%; TPC: 10.1%
vs. 2.0%). Monthly TEAEs requiring T&H rates were Eribulin: 19.83%, TPC: 23.67%.
Average annual costs for management of TEAEs were £2,621 for eribulin vs. £2,740
for TPC patients. Conclusions: Economic burden of toxicities in MBC patients
may be lower than expected as very few TEAEs require T&H. This study may have
led to omission of rare but costly AEs because of the patient selection criteria used.
Using individual treatments as comparators instead of TPC may have brought additional clarity to the results. Further research is warranted to validate the findings.
.
Objectives: The objective of this study was to assess the breadth and usefulness of
information available in social media and patient-specific forums on indirect costs
of a disease. Methods: Internet searches of general social media and patient-specific forums were performed to identify sources of information on the indirect costs
of breast cancer and schizophrenia. Results: Searches of general social media sites
mainly resulted in posts related to available treatments, health awareness campaigns, non-patient opinions and news articles, as well as irrelevant, often malicious
posts, such as direct insults to schizophrenic patients. Fewer, but lengthier, posts
were identified on patient forums, which could be an effective way of identifying
indirect costs of the diseases. Such costs include time spent off work by the patient
and their caregivers, delays in restoring independence such as being able to drive,
and non-medical items used by women on chemotherapy. Breast cancer appears to
be better represented than schizophrenia, possibly because patients with mental
health problems face social stigma and thus don’t communicate their struggle as
openly. Topics of conversation across forums include adverse treatment events and
their associated costs, as well as other costs incurred by the patients due to their
deteriorating health and quality of life. Conclusions: This study looked at available information on the economic burden of breast cancer and schizophrenia on its
patients and found that general social media appear to be less useful than patient
forums. Depending on the disease being researched, different kinds of information
become available and prove to be useful in drawing conclusions about the indirect
costs of an illness. The breast cancer community appears to be better represented
and more vocal about resource use associated with the disease or treatment than
the schizophrenia community. The perspective of caregivers is less represented in
breast cancer than schizophrenia.
PCN85
The Cost of NSCLC Treatment in Three Countries: France, Germany
and UK
Mcguire A 1, Martin M 2, Lenz C 3, Sollano J 4
1London School of Economics, London, UK, 2OptumInsight, Uxbridge, Middlesex, UK, 3Pfizer, Berlin,
Germany, 4Pfizer, New York, NY, USA
.
.
.
.
Introduction: Lung cancer is a highly prevalent condition with non-small
cell lung cancer (NSCLC) representing ~80%. Given its high prevalence and poor
survival rates, it is important to understand costs associated with NSCLC treatment. Objectives: To carry out a study similar to the study by Ramsey (2008) in
three European countries: France, Germany and UK. Methods: Three similar
administrative databases were accessed: Hospital Episode Statistics (England),
Gesundheitsforen Leipzig (Germany), French Hospital Discharge system (France),
using ICD-9/10 codes and treatment/surgery algorithms to identify NSCLC patients.
An incidence population of NSCLC patients was obtained using an index year (ranging from 2007-2008), ensuring the absence of prior lung cancer (12-months). Data
were extracted on treatment information, patient characteristics and disease staging. Average NSCLC treatments were estimated by age and severity. For England
20,081 patients were identified, for France, 15,061, for Germany, 1,038. Results:
In-patient length of stay was 8.9, 8.7 and 10.1 days for France, England, Germany
respectively for the first year. Hospital in-patient costs in the first year amounted
to € 11,667, € 11,363, € 5,985 for France, Germany and England respectively. In year
two these were € 5,916 (France), €6,568 (Germany) and € 1,156 (England). Hospital outpatient costs were in year 1 and 2: € 2,313 - € 676 (France); € 1,925 - € 1,766 (Germany);
€ 1,209 - € 834 (England). Medicine costs in year 1 and 2 amounted to: € 3,542 - € 321
(France); € 4,488 - € 3,805 (Germany); € 8,593 yr1 only (England). Other costs reported
A629
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
for France and Germany in year 1 and 2, were € 502 - € 126 for France; € 1,429 - € 1,156
for Germany. Total costs reached € 18,024 (yr1), € 7,039 (yr2) France; € 19,025 (yr1),
€ 13,295 (yr2) Germany; € 15,785 (yr1), € 1,990 (yr2) England. Two-year costs totalled
€ 25,063 (France); € 32,500 (Germany); € 17,777 (England). Subgroup analyses showed
higher costs for elderly patients, those with non-metastatic disease and smokers.
Conclusions: Considerable differences in average treatment costs were observed.
In-patient costs dominate in the first year of treatment in all countries. The study
highlights the costly nature of NSCLC.
PCN86
Cost of Best Supportive Care for Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer
Patients – A German Perspective
Schmidt U 1, Lipp R 2, Drechsler M 1
Ingelheim Pharma GmbH & Co. KG, Ingelheim, Germany, 2GermanOncology,
Hamburg, Germany
.
.
.
1Boehringer
Objectives: Best supportive care (BSC) is in general individually provided to
patients. Thus, the scope of BSC and its costs can vary widely. Only limited
information on BSC costs for patients with non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC)
exists. Aim of this research was to estimate annual BSC costs for NSCLC patients
in Germany. Methods: To estimate BSC costs at first a literature search in
PubMed with the key words “best supportive care”, “cost”, “non-small cell lung
cancer” and “economic analysis” individual and combined search terms was
performed. International publications of economic evaluations including data
on single cost items which could be applied to the German health care system
were included. Additionally, data on BSC from a NSCLC patient registry (n= 193)
and prescription data derived from a randomised controlled trial (RCT) were used
as further references. Cost- items were extracted from each reference and finally
applied to the German inpatient and outpatient reimbursement system. Results:
The literature research yielded 317 records of which 3 met the inclusion criteria (2= UK; 1= North America). An extrapolation of these evaluation results to the
German health care system showed that BSC costs based on UK data ranged
from 16,940€ to 45,426€ (North America: 31,352€ ). According to health economic
data from an RCT annual cost for BSC amounted to 17,531€ , while data from a
NSCLC patient registry added up to 28,070€ . The average annual costs for BSC
were estimated at 27,864€ . Conclusions: Since BSC is individually delivered
to patients, it leads to a high variance of annual BSC costs for NSCLC patients in
Germany. Furthermore, international economic evaluations were extrapolated
to the German health care system. Hence, results should be interpreted with
caution as international treatment guidelines and reimbursement schemes are
not fully applicable to Germany. Future analyses should be based on a German
population only.
PCN87
Mastectomy Due to Breast Cancer in Brazil: Geographic
Distribution and Costs from the Public Health Care Perspective
Valle P M 1, Mosegui G B G 2, Vianna C 1, Araujo R L 1
Estadual do Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 2Universidade Federal Fluminense,
Niterói, Brazil
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Universidade
Objectives: Treatment for breast cancer is usually based on chemotherapy
and radiotherapy, but in unsuccessful cases, mastectomy is required. In Brazil,
mastectomies are performed as simple or radical, with lymphadenectomy. This
study aims to relate geographic distribution, temporal trends and economic profile
of this procedure in Brazil. Methods: Assessments about hospital admissions
were performed to analyze costs and geographic distribution among mastectomies
related with breast cancer realized in Brazil, from January 2008 to December 2012.
The data used were extracted by Brazilian Hospital Information System (SIH/SUS)
database, according to ICD-0416120032 (simple mastectomy) and ICD-0416120024
(radical with lymphadenectomy). Costs were estimated in 2014 Brazilian Real (BRL)
and represents federal reimbursement values for hospitalizations (exams, drugs,
medical procedures and fees). Results: In Brazil, the number of mastectomies
related with breast cancer ranged from 8,687 in 2008 to 9,703 in 2012. In Southeast
region were performed 22,977 procedures, which was the largest number per
region, compared with 1,814 in North; 8,443 in South; 2,280 in Midwest and 10,538
in Northwest. In São Paulo; 10,111 procedures occurred in this period, while 8 were
performed in Amapá. Total costs with mastectomies due to breast cancer in Brazil
during this period were 44,219,235.66 BRL. The value per patient increased about
12,5% over the years with mean costs from 2008 to 2012 of 799.75BRL, 842.62BRL,
845.28BRL, 878.20BRL and 870.25BRL, respectively. In 2010, the mean mortality rate
among simple and radical mastectomies was 0,22% and increased until 0,54% in
2012. Conclusions: Geographic distribution of mastectomy due to breast cancer
in Brazil is concentrated in Southeast region, in comparison to other regions and
from 2008 to 2012 there was no change in this pattern. Although costs elevated,
mortality also increased in this period.
PCN88
Estimation of Economic Losses Resulting from Diseases Associated
with Smoking in Mexican Insured and Uninsured Population
Muciño-Ortega E 1, Hernandez-Reyes F C 1, Reynales-Shigematsu L 2
S.A. de C.V., Ciudad de México, Mexico, 2Instituto Nacional de Salud Pública, Cuernavaca,
Mexico
.
.
.
.
1Pfizer
Objectives: Few data has been published in Mexico related to direct smoking
costs from the consumer perspective. To estimate lost income and pocket costs
related to smoking diseases from the perspective of Mexican families. Methods:
The analysis incorporated patients with public, private and no-health insurance
from 18-65 years. Through Mexican literature review, medical costs and prevalence
of 3 major diseases associated with tobacco consumption were identified: acute
myocardial infarction (AMI), chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) and lung
cancer (LC) as well as absenteeism associated to each disease. Average income was
extracted from 2012 national income survey. Scenarios evaluated were: 1) Publicly
health-insured patients: from the 4th day of disability, the Instituto Mexicano del
Seguro Social covers 60% of wages, 2) Private health-insured: economical loss of
private beneficiaries is a 20% co-pay plus daily average income lost. 3) No-healthinsurance: Medical costs and absenteeism represent the economical loss. Costs are
expressed in 2014 USD (1USD= 13MXN). Morbidity cases were extracted from published data by National Institute of Public Health and used to calculate a weighted
average of economical losses for each scenario. Results: The distribution of
people with smoking-related disease (AMI, COPD and LC) was 25.0%, 65.4% and
9.6%, respectively. Patients in scenario 1) 2) and 3) spend/lose an average of $446.6,
$8,448.2 and $37,384.95 per year, respectively (medical costs are the drivers of the
economic resources lost by not-insured population). Average illness expense derived
from tobacco consumption regarding the proportion of people in each scenario
was $13,917 yearly (local per capita GDP is $9,749). Regardless of health-insurance
status, LC is the most expensive disease ($39,564.26), followed by AMI and COPD
($14,337.06 and $10,109.32, respectively). Conclusions: The study showed that in
the long run smokers incur significant economic losses even if they have medical
insurance. Costs increases to people that do not have any insurance.
PCN89
Cost Comparison Among First Line Monoclonal Antibodies-Based
Oncology Treatment Protocols
Jakovljevic M 1, Gutzwiller F S 2, Schwenkglenks M 2, Milovanovic O 3, Rancic N 4, Varjacic M 3,
Stojadinovic D 5, Dagovic A 6, Matter-Walstra K 2
1The Faculty of Medical Sciences University of Kragujevac, Kragujevac, Serbia and Montenegro,
2University of Basel, Basel, Switzerland, 3Faculty of Medical Sciences, University of Kragujevac,
Kragujevac, Serbia and Montenegro, 4Military Medical Academy University of Defence Belgrade,
Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro, 5Urology Clinic, University Clinical Center Kragujevac,
Kragujevac, Serbia and Montenegro, 6Oncology and Radiation Therapy Center, Clinical Center
Kragujevac, Kragujevac, Serbia and Montenegro
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess and compare the costs of first-line monoclonal antibodies
(mABs) treatment protocols in breast cancer, non-Hodgkin lymphoma and colorectal carcinoma in South-Εastern Europe. Methods: A retrospective, bottom-up
case series study design was implemented with one-year time horizon and payer’s
perspective. The study sample size was 265 patients (breast cancer, N= 137, colorectal cancer, N= 44, and non-Hodgkin lymphoma, N= 84) while treatment protocols
included adjuvant mAbs: trastuzumab (N= 137), bevacizumab (N= 28), cetuximab
(N= 16) and rituximab (N= 84). ICD-10 related, direct medical and lost productivity
costs (€ ) across treatment groups during 2010-2013. Results: The average length
of observation was 128±97 days per patient. Total mean direct and indirect costs
of care were: trastuzumab breast cancer group € 17,740; bevacizumab colorectal
carcinoma group € 8,775; cetuximab colorectal carcinoma group € 27,181 and rituximab non-Hodgkin lymphoma group € 19,431. An average mAbs-treated patient
incurred € 17,897 costs of medical care. The total combined budget of these 265
patients was € 4,742,775. Conclusions: The use of mAbs strongly correlated with
high costs in first-line cancer medical care and dominated other cost domains.
Cetuximab-based treatment protocol in colorectal carcinoma patients was substantially more expensive compared to trastuzumab (C50); bevacizumab (C20)
and rituximab (C80) alternatives. Extremely high costs of mAbs are the key-issue
for Eastern European policy makers by crossing the upper limits of affordability
in middle-income economies.
PCN90
Use Patterns and Costs of Isolated Limb Perfusion and Infusion in
the Treatment of Regionally Metastatic Melanoma: A Retrospective
Database Analysis
Ma Q , Zhao Z , Barber B , Shilkrut M
Amgen Inc, Thousand Oaks, CA, USA
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Isolated limb perfusion and infusion (ILP/ILI) are therapies for regionally metastatic melanoma where high doses of anticancer drugs are delivered
directly into the circulation of an affected limb, while minimizing systemic drug
exposure. This procedure can lead to high response rates but without proven benefits to overall survival. It is recommended by ESMO and NCCN guidelines as a treatment option for patients with stage III unresectable metastatic melanoma. However,
limited information is available on its use pattern and costs in the literature. This
study was to examine patterns of ILP/ILI use and associated costs in patients with
melanoma in the US. Methods: This is a retrospective, observational study using
large administrative claims from the MarketScan® databases. Patients who underwent ILP/ILI (CPT-4: 36823) with diagnosis of melanoma (ICD-9-CM: 172. xx, V10.82)
between 1/1/2002 and 3/31/2013 were included. Patient characteristics, use patterns,
hospital length of stay, and costs (2013 US $) of ILP/ILI were assessed. Results:
A total of 113 patients met the study criteria and were included in the analysis. The
mean age was 62.1 years (standard deviation [SD] 14.1); 39.8% were male. The mean
baseline Charlson’s comorbidity index was 0.24 and 36.4% of patients were Medicare
beneficiaries. Overall, 86.4% of patients had melanoma in the lower limb, 12.7% in
the upper limb, and 0.9% in both upper and lower limbs; 59.3% had lymph node
metastasis and 56.8% had skin metastasis. Four patients (3.5%) underwent multiple
ILP/ILI procedures. The mean (±SD) hospital length of stay was 5.6 (± 3.5) days and
the mean (±SD) cost was $35,898 (± $26,492) per ILP/ILI procedure. Conclusions:
The use of isolated limb perfusion and infusion was associated with relatively long
hospital stay and high cost. The results of this study may provide source data for
economic evaluations of treatment options for regionally metastatic melanoma.
PCN91
A Guideline-Based Estimate of Health Care Resource Use and Cost of
Metastatic Unresectable Osteosarcoma
Cornelio N 1, Burudpakdee C 2
of North Carolina at Charlotte, Charlotte, NC, USA, 2MKTXS, Raritan, NJ, USA
.
.
1University
Objectives: To estimate the resource use and costs a health plan can anticipate
during the diagnosis, treatment, and surveillance of a patient with metastatic unre-
A630
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
sectable osteosarcoma using national guideline recommendations. Methods:
An economic disease model was developed based on recommendations from the
2013 NCCN Clinical Practice Guidelines in Oncology for bone cancer. The model
quantified resource use for diagnosis, 12 months of treatment, and 12 months
of surveillance of a metastatic unresectable osteosarcoma patient. Costs in 2014
dollar value were derived from publically available sources for reimbursement of
CPT codes, HCPCS codes, and generic WAC prices for medications. Chemotherapy
dosing was based on NCCN recommended treatment regimens. Results: The
diagnostic cost was estimated to be $1,706 per patient. Treatment costs, consisting of stereotactic radiosurgery and chemotherapy with drug monitoring, varied
widely across the four NCCN recommended regimens due to differences in the
price of pharmacotherapy. The chemotherapy regimens were estimated to be the
major cost components associated with this disease. Doxorubicin, cisplatin, and
high-dose methotrexate cost $103,051 per patient; doxorubicin and cisplatin cost
$17,549 per patient; doxorubicin, cisplatin, high-dose methotrexate, and ifosfamide
cost $38,404 per patient; and cisplatin, ifosfamide, and epirubicin cost $38,936 per
patient. Additionally, stereotactic radiosurgery was estimated at $2,755 per patient,
and the cost of drug monitoring during the one year of chemotherapy averaged to
$5,899 per patient. Additionally, one year of disease surveillance cost $4,264 per
patient. Conclusions: A guideline-based disease model can assist health plans
to better understand and anticipate the expected diagnosis, treatment, and surveillance resources and costs for unresectable metastatic osteosarcoma patients.
PCN92
Resource Use and Health Care Costs of Metastatic Malignant
Melanoma in Slovakia
Ondrusova M 1, Psenkova M 1, Hlavata Z 2, Visnovska M 3, Urbancek S 4
Ltd, Bratislava, Slovak Republic, 2National Cancer Institute, Bratislava, Slovak
Republic, 3East Slovak Cancer Institute, Kosice, Slovak Republic, 4F.D. Roosvelt University Hospital,
Banska Bystrica, Slovak Republic
.
.
.
.
.
1Pharm-In
Objectives: The objective of this cost study was to measure the resource utilisation and the direct costs associated with health care management of metastatic
malignant melanoma (mMM) in Slovakia and provide a basis for cost-effectiveness
evaluations. Methods: The cross-sectional survey was performed and included 3
oncologists experienced in mMM management. The survey was performed to obtain
the information on the management of patients with mMM and to estimate the
direct costs of the disease. The studied population were 3 cohorts of mMM patients
which are usually identified as the health states in the cost-effectiveness models:
“Before progression“, “Disease progression“ and “Terminal care“. Costs of drugs
were assesed separately from health states and rated particularly according to BRAF
positivity. The cost data were assessed for the year 2013. All types of health care used
in mMM management were evaluated (outpatient and inpatient visits, diagnostics,
prescription drugs and medical examinations). Costs of adverse events (AEs) were
set for one single event. Results: The most frequent treatment regimens used in
the first treatment line of BRAF mutant and BRAF negative patients were identical
- dacarbazin (94.9% of treated patients), fotemustin (4.5%) and ipilimumab (0.6%).
Monthly costs of mMM management in addition to the active treatment in the
state “Before progression“ count for 6.64% (€ 188.51/patient), during the “Disease
progression“ it was 45.56% (€ 1 294.31/patient) and during the “Terminal state of
patient“ 47.80% (€ 1 358.02/patient). Adverse event (AE) costs were evaluated for
grade 3 and 4. The most costly AEs were neutropenia (€ 1 014.66), fever (€ 364.87) and
rash (€ 230.35). Conclusions: In the management of mMM (excluding the active
drug cost), the most expensive are the costs of hospitalization and symptomatic
treatment. The most costly period is the “Terminal state“.
PCN93
Cost-Benefit Assessment of the Electronic Health Records for
Clinical Research (EHR4CR) European Project
Beresniak A 1, Schmidt A 2, Proeve J 3, Bolanos E 4, Patel N 5, Ammour N 6, Sundgren M 7,
Ericson M 8, De Moor G 9, Kalra D 10, Dupont D 1
Mining International, Geneva, Switzerland, 2F Hoffmann-La Roche Ltd, Basel, Switzerland,
3Bayer Healthcare, Leverkusen, Germany, 4Eli Lilly and Company, Alcobendas, Spain, 5Eli Lilly and
Company (until December 2013), Windlesham, Surrey, UK, 6Sanofi-Aventis R&D, Chilly-Mazarin,
France, 7AstraZeneca, Mölndal, Sweden, 8Amgen, Neuilly-sur-Seine, France, 9University of Ghent,
Ghent, Belgium, 10The European Institute for Health Records (EuroRec), London, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Data
Objectives: The EHR4CR 4-year research partnership between the European Union
and the European Federation of Pharmaceutical Industries and Associations (EFPIA)
has developed a platform for the trustworthy reuse of hospital electronic health
records’ data for clinical research. A cost-benefit assessment (CBA) was conducted
from the pharmaceutical industry perspective to assess the value of the first two
EHR4CR clinical research scenarios (S): Protocol feasibility assessment (S1), and
Patient identification and recruitment (S2), either used individually or sequentially
within a clinical trial workflow, versus current practices. Methods: The EFPIA
partners have conducted a resource utilization assessment to calculate the actual
person-time and cost of performing S1 and S2 for one oncology clinical study (Phase
II or Phase III) as reference case. Assuming that an estimated 50% reduction in actual
person-time and cost under EHR4CR conditions would directly translate in accelerated time to market (TTM), potential benefits to global pharmaceutical industry were
derived using global market values (2012) of oncology products1. Absolute cost-benefit analyses were conducted using Monte-Carlo simulations. Results: Compared
to current practices, individual EHR4CR scenarios S1 and S2 have yielded efficiency
gains of 134 days and 37 days respectively, and of 171 days when used sequentially.
Should these efficiency gains from study design optimisation translate in faster
TTM, corresponding estimated benefits for the global pharmaceutical oncology
franchise could reach 160,45, and 205 Million € , respectively. Conclusions: This
CBA is the first to assess the value of EHR4CR scenarios for oncology clinical trials.
The results confirm that the EHR4CR platform could generate substantial added
value for pharmaceutical industry should its efficiency gains translate in faster
TTM. Further benefits are expected from the EHR4CR platform in other therapeutic
areas. Disclosure: The EHR4CR project is mandated by the Innovative Medicines
Initiative (co-funded by the European Commission and EFPIA).
1. Evaluate Pharma September 2013
PCN94
Cost-Effectiveness of Colonic Stents for the Management of
Malignant Large Bowel Obstruction
Goodall S 1, Church J 2
of Technology, Sydney, Sydney, Australia, 2University of Technology Sydney, Sydney,
Australia
.
.
1University
Objectives: The aim was to determine the cost-effectiveness of colonic stent insertion for the management of malignant bowel obstructions. Colonic stents are a
minimally invasive alternative to open surgery for patients medically unfit for single
stage surgery. Methods: Two economic models were developed. The first compared
patients who received palliative or definitive stents and were not medically fit for
re-anastomosis. The second compared patients who received stents as a bridge-tosurgery and were medically fit for a second stage of two-stage surgery, this included
colostomy or Hartmann’s procedure. ResultsFor patients requiring palliation, the
cost of colonic stent insertion was estimated to be $17,809 compared to $20,516 for
palliative colostomy (a saving of $2,707). The benefits associated with both procedures were 0.099 QALYs and 0.089 QALYs gained, respectively, an incremental benefit
of 0.01 QALYs per patient. For patients requiring a bridge-to-surgery, the cost of
colonic stent insertion was estimated to be $29,729, compared to $30,169 for patients
that received multi-stage surgery (either a colostomy or a Hartmann’s procedure).
This represented a cost savings of $440. The estimated average patient would gain
0.510 QALYs compared to 0.458 QALYs in the multi-stage surgery group. This yields
an incremental benefit of 0.052 QALYs per patient. The main drivers of both models
were the technical and clinical success of the stent insertion, and length of hospital
stay following the procedures. The probability of a resection with primary anastomosis after insertion of a stent and the cost of stenting were also drivers in the
bridge-to-surgery model. Conclusions: In terms of cost-effectiveness, colonic
stent insertion for malignant bowel obstruction in patients requiring palliation or
a bridge-to-surgery dominated the current alternative surgical procedures.
PCN95
A Multi-State Model of Metatstatic Colorectal Cancer
van Rooijen E M 1, Coupé V M H 2, Koopman M 3, Punt C J A 4, Uyl-De Groot C A 5
for Medical Technology Assessment, Erasmus University, Rotterdam, The Netherlands,
2VU University Medical Centre, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 3University medical centre Utrecht,
Utrecht, The Netherlands, 4Academic Medical Centre Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands,
5Institute for Medical Technology Assessment (iMTA), Erasmus University, Rotterdam, The
Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Institute
Objectives: The aim of this study is to develop and validate a decision-analytic
model describing the current course of disease, including treatment, in metastatic
colorectal cancer. This baseline model will serve as the comparator in analyses of the
(cost-) effectiveness of new treatment strategies. Methods: An individual-based
micro-simulation model was constructed based on the disease states a patient
may experience after a diagnosis of metastatic colorectal cancer. The states include
first-line second-line and third-line treatment, as well as states of progression of
disease after first-, second- or third-line, finally a death state is included. Time spent
in each disease state was predicted using log-logistic, log-normal or weibull survival
models, each dependent on a number of patient characteristics. All survival models
and patient characteristics were based on patient-level data, provided by the CAIRO
trial (NCT00312000). Two oncologists evaluated the model for face validity, the model
was further validated by comparing various model outcomes with the original data,
the national cancer registry and a population based study. Results: There were no
significant differences in patient and treatment characteristics, nor intermediate
and overall survival estimates between the simulated and original patient-level
data. External validation with national cancer registry data showed few differences
in survival with the simulated data. Additionally the simulated survival did not
significantly differ from the survival as recorded in a pilot oxaliplatin study of 119
patients who were observed in the same timeframe as the RCT. Conclusions: The
micro-simulation decision model described in this article underwent an internal
and external validation and can be used to evaluate new possibilities for research
and treatment in metastatic colorectal cancer.
PCN96
Economic Consequences of the Adaption of the 21 Gene Reverse
Transcriptase-Polymerase Chain Reaction RT-PCR Assay from The
Greek Third Payer Perspective
Kikilias N 1, Siskou O 2, Kaitelidou D 3, Galanis P 3, Tsoulos N 4, Vafeiadis J 1, Liaropoulos L 3
Organization for Health Care Services Provision -EOPYY, Marousi, Greece, 2Center for
Health Services Management and Evaluation, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens,
Athens, Greece, 3National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, Athens, Greece, 4GENEKOR,
Gerakas, Greece
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1National
Objectives: The evaluation of the economic consequences of 21-gene RT-PCR assay
OncotypeDX introduction to the reimbursement scheme of National Organization
for Health Provision-EOPYY. Methods: A decision tree was developed concerning
two treatment scenarios for the year 2013: a) chemotherapy admission according the
common treatment practice without the application of the test vs b) chemotherapy
admission depending on the results of the test. The sub-group of breast cancer
patients appropriate for applying the test was determined according international
guidelines and included early stage breast cancer women with hormone receptor
positive and lumph node negative age ≤65 years. Cancer incidence was derived from
ELSTAT and OECD base, while some assumptions were made concerning the age
structure and disease stage of the population. The percentages of women assessed
as high risk (score> 31) for recurrence were obtained from EOPYY data for 2013. The
estimated cost for OncotypeDX test was set according the EOPYY reimbursement
price (€ 2,848 for 2013). Cost of chemotherapy and other cost items (eg laboratory
A631
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
tests) were based on official reimbursed prices. Results: Out of 4,934 newly diagnosed breast cancer women, 27.5% (1,357) were appropriate for the test application.
Only 35% of the women undertaken the oncotype test (N= 1,357) were found as high
risk for recurrence (N= 475). The average total cost of chemotherapy treatment was
estimated to € 8,271 from which more than 80% refer to pharmaceuticals. The total
treatment cost for women who didn’t undertake the test reached to € 10.9 mil.,
while the relevant cost for women who undertook the test was estimated to € 8 mil.
Conclusions: The introduction of Oncotype DX® to the Greek health care system
had as a result annual cost savings of almost € 3 million and avoidance of unnecessary chemotherapy treatment (and associated complications) to more than 880
women.
PCN97
Cost Consequence Model Investigating the Impact of Bowel
Cleansing on Prevention of Colorectal Cancer in a German
Screening Population
Fischbach W 1, Pohl J 2, Scola A M 3, Conway P 4
1Klinikum Aschaffenburg, Aschaffenburg, Germany, 2Horst Schmidt Klinik, Wiesbaden, Germany,
3McCann Complete Medical, Macclesfield, UK, 4Norgine Ltd, Harefield, UK
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The degree of benefit from colonoscopy in the prevention of colorectal
cancer (CRC) is highly dependent on the quality of bowel cleansing. In a randomized study of patients undergoing screening colonoscopy in Germany (MODEC),
2L polyethylene glycol with electrolytes + ascorbate components (PEG+ASC) resulted
in numerically higher overall polyp/adenoma detection rates (PDR/ADR) and significantly higher right-sided PDR/ADR than sodium picosulfate/magnesium citrate
(NaPic/MgCit), together with better bowel cleansing. The objective of the model
was to examine the socioeconomic impact of bowel cleansing quality on the effectiveness of CRC screening in the eligible German population. Methods: A costconsequence model was constructed to compare the total cost of colonoscopy and
treatment of subsequent CRC over a 10-year period in a cohort of 10,000 patients
aged ≥ 55 years receiving 2L PEG+ASC or NaPic/MgCit prior to colonoscopy. The
rates of successful bowel cleansing, completed colonoscopies, and PDR/ADR were
obtained from the MODEC study. Published rates of surveillance colonoscopy, associated costs and health care resource utilization in Germany were used, with costs
inflated to 2013 prices. Results: The model predicts that the use of 2L PEG+ASC
versus NaPic/MgCit increases the average per patient cost associated with colonoscopy by € 67. However, better bowel cleansing and numerically higher overall PDR/
ADR achieved using 2L PEG+ASC rather than NaPic/MgCit avoids progression to CRC
in 166 patients, due to early detection, equating to an average per patient saving in
CRC treatment costs of € 488. The model shows that the use of 2L PEG+ASC versus
NaPic/MgCit at screening/surveillance colonoscopy leads to an average overall cost
saving of € 420 per patient over 10 years. Conclusions: Modeling of long-term
outcomes shows that using an effective bowel cleansing preparation in CRC screening may reduce the number of patients developing CRC, and may lead to reduced
CRC treatment costs.
PCN98
A Cost-Consequence Analysis of Human Papillomavirus Vaccination
in Romania
Preda A L 1, Moise M 1, Van Kriekinge G 2
.
.
.
.
1GlaxoSmithKline, Bucharest, Romania, 2GlaxoSmithKline Vaccines, Wavre, Belgium
Objectives: The objective of the study was to estimate the potential cost and epidemiological impact of a Human Papillomavirus (HPV) mass vaccination in Romania
for the two available vaccines in the Romania: AS04 adjuvanted HPV16/18 vaccine (AS04V) and the HPV6/11/16/18 vaccine (QV). Methods: We applied, to the
Romanian settings, a population steady state model previously published with a
one year time horizon estimating the effect (cases and costs) of a vaccination programme. The number of cases and costs (in RON – Romanian National Currency)
were collected from the hospitalization Diagnosis Related Group database for the
year 2012. cervical cancer (CC) and genital warts (GW) were considered. Vaccine
effectiveness was approximated by weighting vaccine-type and non-vaccine-type
efficacy with HPV distribution reported for GW (literature) and CC (HPV Centre) for
each vaccine. One way sensitivity analysis was conducted on key input parameters. Results: HPV vaccination would save17,706,490 RON with AS04V and
16,432,592 RON with QV. An additional 820 CC-related hospitalisations amounting
to a cost difference of 1,273,898 RON was estimated in favour of the AS04V. A total
of 205 cases of GW prevented and 153,395 RON associated costs were estimated in
favour of the QV. The total cost difference amounted to 1,120,503 RON. Robustness of
the results was confirmed by sensitivity analyses”. Conclusions: Implementing
the AS04V would result in > 1 million RON saved versus the QV mainly due to a difference of extra 820 CC cases prevented that completely offsets the benefit associated with the prevention of GW. The observed difference is mainly due to higher
protection associated with non-vaccine types for AS04V.
PCN99
Association of Health Care Cost with Quality of Life for Various
Types of Cancers
Hayran M , Yuce D , Huseyin B , Esin E , Kilickap S , Erman M , Celik I
Hacettepe University, Ankara, Turkey
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The new cancer treatment modalities are improving survival rates
today and one of the main outcomes is the improved health related quality of
life (QoL). Prolonged survival also increases the financial burden of cancer care on
health care systems. In this study we aimed to analyze the associations between
QoL and direct health care costs in different types of cancers. Methods: We evaluated QoL (EORTC QLQ-C30) and direct medical costs (DMC) in 350 patients with lung
(Lng), breast (Br), hematological (Hem), head and neck (H&N), colorectal (CR), gastric
(Gas), gynecological (Gy), and prostate (Pr) cancers. The DMC data of each patient in
the following 3-month period after QoL assessment was obtained from the hospital finance department database. DMC per QoL point was calculated by DMC/QoL
score. Results: Mean DMC per QoL was lowest in Pr, and highest in Hem cancers
(ranged 60.1-195.1 TL/global QoL score) (Pr< Gy< CR≈Gas≈Br≈Lng≈H&N< Hem). QoL
was lowest in Gy and highest in CR (ranged 53,1-65,2) (Gy< Lng< Pr< Br≈Hem≈H&NC).
Total DMC ranged from 3124-13557 TL (Pr≈GY< Br< Gas≈CR< Lng≈H&N< Hem).
Depending on the type of the cancer the association between DMC and QoL could
be in different directions (the correlation between DMC and role functioning was
positive in Gas, while it was negative in H&N cancer). Conclusions: For a fixed
period of time the total DMC associated with the management of different types of
cancers vary substantially. As expected the total cost does not however purchase
equal amount of QoL for each type of cancer. For those cancers with higher DMC
per QoL, we should consider implementing wider psychosocial support measures.
Depending on the type of cancer DMC may reflect disease progression leading to
decreased QoL, or it may reflect presence of an effective and aggressive management leading to increased QoL.
PCN100
Cost-Effectiveness Model of Pertuzumab in Combination with
Trastuzumab and Docetaxel Compared with Trastuzumab in
Combination with Docetaxel for the 1st Line Treatment of HER2+
Metastatic Breast Cancer in Colombia
Saenz Ariza S A
Productos Roche, Bogota, Colombia
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate the cost effectiveness of Pertuzumab plus Trastuzumab
and docetaxel (PTD) vs. Trastuzumab and docetaxel (TD) for the first-line treatment in patients with HER2+ metastatic breast cancer in Colombia. Methods: For
the evaluation of the cost-effectiveness a health economic area under the curve
model was developed. The model considers three health states: progression-free
survival, disease progression and death. The proportion of patients in each health
state were derived using patient level data from the CLEOPATRA trial like efficacy
and safety results, with the exception where overall survival (OS) utilized data from
longer term clinical registries. The primary model outcome is the ICER cost per QALY
gained in the first-line PTD vs. TD. The following main model input data assumptions were applied for the base case analysis: Time horizon: 15 years; model cycle
length: weekly; 3) reference prices for drugs in Colombia, except for Pertuzumab
which was supplied by the manufacturer; 4) treatment duration: actual treatment
duration from the CLEOPATRA study extrapolated using an exponential function;
and 5) discount rates: annual rate of 3.0% for both, future costs and health benefits. Results: The outcomes over a time horizon show an increase in mean OS
time for patients assigned to the PTD group as compared to those in the TD of 0.72
years. Mean QALYs are also higher in the PTD group than in the TD group 0.58 QALYs.
The addition of Pertuzumab leads to higher total average treatment costs of $143.529
dollars per patient compared to the TD group. These findings result in an ICER of
$200.509 per life year gained and of $249.582 per QALY gained. Conclusions:
When compared to commonly accepted cost-effectiveness thresholds, these results
exceed commonly applied willingness-to-pay thresholds, but Pertuzumab becomes
a therapeutic alternative that offers a better health outcome.
PCN101
Cost-Effectiveness of Ipilimumab for Previously Untreated Patients
with Advanced Metastatic Melanoma in Spain
Aceituno S 1, Canal C 2, Paz S 3, Gonzalez P 2, Marquez-Rodas I 4
10, Castellón, Spain, 2BMS Spain, Madrid, Spain, 3Outcomes’10, Castellon, Spain,
4Instituto de Investigación Sanitaria Gregorio Marañón, Madrid, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
1Outcomes
Objectives: To assess the cost-effectiveness of ipilimumab compared to dacarbazine as first-line treatment in patients with advanced metastatic melanoma. Methods: A three-state Markov (progression-free, progression and death)
with three-week cycles model using the Spanish Healthcare System perspective was
developed over a lifetime horizon. The clinical profile of ipilimumab (3 mg/kg) was
obtained from a pooled dataset of chemotherapy naive patients from four phase
II and phase III studies, and from the CA184-024 trial for dacarbazine. Parametric
extrapolation methods were used to project survival over lifetime. Costs included
were: drug acquisition (ex-factory price -7,5% mandatory rebate) and administration, medical/terminal care, and adverse events management. Unit costs were
derived from Spanish health care cost databases (Euros, 2013). For drugs with a
double-pricing system (like ipilimumab), costs were based upon the official notified prices in Spain. Costs and benefits were discounted at 3%. Utility values were
taken from the CA184-024 trial. Univariate and probabilistic sensitivity analyses
(PSA) were performed. Results: The life years (LYs) and quality-adjusted life years
(QALYs) gained with ipilimumab as first-line treatment over dacarbazine were 2.01
and 1.68, respectively. The incremental cost of using ipilimumab versus dacarbazine
was 69,598 € . The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) and the incremental
cost-utility ratio (ICUR) were 34,566€ /LY gained and 41,459€ /QALY, respectively. PSA
showed that ipilimumab is up to 100% and 90% likely to be cost-effective at the
threshold established by the NICE for oncology drugs that meet ‘End-of-Life’ criteria (50,000-62,000€ ) for ICER and ICUR, respectively. Additionally, at the threshold
acceptable in Spain (30,000-45,000€ ) the likelihood of ipilimumab being cost-effective is up to 94% and 66% for ICER and ICUR, respectively. Conclusions: Results
suggest that ipilimumab is a cost-effective alternative for previously untreated
patients with advanced metastatic melanomain Spain.
PCN102
The Potential of (TARGETED) MR Colonography as a Screening Tool
for Colorectal Cancer: A Cost-Effectiveness Analysis
Greuter M J 1, Demirel E 1, Berkhof J 1, Fijneman R J 1, Stoker J 2, Meijer G A 1, Coupé V M 1
University Medical Center, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 2Academic Medical Center,
Amsterdam, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1VU
Objectives: MR colonography may have potential as a colorectal cancer (CRC)
screening tool since it has comparable test characteristics as colonoscopy but
is less invasive. Furthermore, innovators in the field of MR technology are striv-
A632
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
ing to develop a targeted contrast agent that specifically detects adenomas at
increased risk of progressing to CRC. This might even further raise the potential
of MR colonography. We explored the potential of conventional and targeted MR
colonography in terms of (cost-) effectiveness using the ASCCA model. Methods:
Thirteen screening strategies were evaluated, differing in primary screening
instrument and number of screening rounds. The strategies under consideration
were conventional and targeted MR colonography, colonoscopy and CT colonography with two, three and four screening rounds at a ten year screening interval.
Furthermore, eleven rounds of biennial faecal immunochemical test (FIT) screening were considered. Each strategy was evaluated assuming realistic and perfect
participation rates. Incremental costs and effects were estimated from a societal
perspective. Results: All screening strategies were cost-effective compared to
no screening. For conventional MR colonography, the ICER ranged between € 1,271/
LYG to € 3,003/LYG for two to four screening rounds at 34% participation per round.
For 62% and 100% participation, the ICER ranged from respectively € 1,576/LYG to
€ 3,777/LYG and € 1,971/LYG to € 4,577/LYG. However, conventional MR colonography
screening was more expensive than other screening strategies at comparable
LYG, for all participation rates. Targeted MR colonography was only slightly more
effective than conventional MR colonography but considerably more costly, even
under the most favourable assumptions regarding test characteristics and costs
per test. Conclusions: This is the first study to evaluate the cost-effectiveness
of MR colonography screening for CRC. Although conventional and targeted MR
colonography are cost-effective compared to no screening, at present they cannot
compete with more established screening tests because of the high costs per test.
PCN103
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Abiraterone Acetate Treatment
Compared with Cabacitaxel in the Republic of Panama, in Patients
with Metastatic Castration-Resistant Prostate Cancer that Have
Failed to Chemotherapy with Docetaxel
Obando C A 1, Desanvicente-Celis Z 1, Gonzalez L 2, Muschett D 1, Gonzalez F 1, Goldberg P 1
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Janssen, Panama, Panama, 2Janssen, Raritan, NJ, USA
Objectives: To assess the cost-effectiveness of Abiraterone Acetate plus
Prednisone (A-P) compared with Cabazitaxel plus Prednisone (C-P) in Panama,
in patients with Metastatic Castration-Resistant Prostate Cancer (mCRPC) that
have failed to chemotherapy with Docetaxel. Methods: A three-health state
cohort simulation Markov Model (progression-free, post-progression and death)
was developed based on overall and progression free survival data. The time frame
was 10 years. The perspective was that of the Public System of Health of Panama.
The health outcomes of interest were Quality Adjusted Life Years (QALYs) and Life
Years (LYs). Efficacy data was taken from clinical trials (COU-AA-301 for A-P and
TROPIC for C-P). Utilities for health states and negative utilities for adverse events
were estimated based on quality of life endpoints of the COU-AA-301 trial. The
base year was 2012. All costs are presented in United States Dollars (USD). Costs
and outcomes were discounted at 5%. Probabilistic sensitivity (PSA) analysis was
performed to evaluate uncertainty surrounding the parameters. Results: A-P
resulted in 0.79 QALYs and 1.35 LYs, per patient, respectively. C-P resulted in 0.71
QALYs and 1.28 LYs, per patient, respectively. Mean total costs per patient were:
USD 76.179 for A-P and USD 86.286 for C-P. The results of the probabilistic sensitivity analysis showed that, when compared with C-Z, A-P was found dominant (associated with reduced costs and increased QALYs) in the majority of the iterations.
A-P had a 73% probability of being cost effective, independent of the willingness
to pay, when compared to C-P. When the willingness to pay increases, A-P is more
likely to become cost effective. Conclusions: A-P can be considered dominant
(cost-saving), when compared with C-P, in patients with Metastatic CastrationResistant Prostate Cancer that have failed to chemotherapy with Docetaxel, from
the perspective of the Public System of Health of Panama.
PCN104
Everolimus Plus Exemestane Compared to Exemestane and
Fulvestrant for the Treatment of ER+ HER2- Metastastic Breast
Cancer in the United Kingdom – A Societal Perspective
Polanyi Z 1, Dale P 2, Taylor M 3, Lewis L 3, Glanville J 3, Vieira J 1, Chandiwana D 1
1Novartis Pharmaceuticals UK Limited, Camberley, UK, 2HEOR Solutions, London, UK, 3York
Health Economics Consortium, York, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: This study evaluated the cost-effectiveness of everolimus plus exemestane (EVE+EXE) versus exemestane (EXE) and fulvestrant (FUL) in the treatment of
postmenopausal women with ER+ HER2- metastatic breast cancer in the United
Kingdom (UK) from a societal perspective. Methods: A partitioned survival model
was developed to compare treatment with EVE+EXE versus EXE and FUL over a
10-year time horizon. Progression-free survival and overall survival for EVE+EXE
and EXE were estimated from the BOLERO-2 trial. Log-logistics functions were used
to extrapolate trial data beyond the follow-up period. In the absence of head-tohead evidence vs. FUL an indirect treatment comparison was conducted using a
Bayesian fixed effect model. Background health state and terminal care resource
use were derived from NICE Clinical Guideline 81. Drug costs were taken from the
British National Formulary. Productivity loss, defined as working days lost due to
disease, was included in the analysis. Utilities from published sources were combined with trial data to calculate quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) for the model
health state. Results: EVE+EXE led to an incremental gain in life years of 0.20 vs.
EXE and 0.19 vs. FUL. The incremental QALY gain was 0.31 vs. EXE and 0.27 vs. FUL.
The cost of lost productivity was £66,163 in the EVE+EXE compared to £75,067 in the
EXE arm and £73,434 in the FUL arm. The incremental cost per QALY was £27,644
vs. EXE and £14,030 vs. FUL. Probabilistic sensitivity analysis demonstrated that, at
a threshold of £30,000 per QALY gained, EVE+EXE had a 51.6% likelihood of being
cost-effective vs. EXE and 59.0% vs. FUL. Conclusions: Patients receiving EVE+EXE
experienced an improvement in survival which translated into health gains in terms
of both LYs and QALYs. EVE+EXE was associated with savings in productivity costs
compared to both EXE and FUL.
PCN105
Economic Evaluation of NAB-Paclitaxel Plus Gemcitabine Versus
Gemcitabine Alone for The Management of Metastatic Pancreatic
Cancer in Greece
Fragoulakis V 1, Papakostas P 2, Pentheroudakis G 3, Dervenis C 4, Maniadakis N 1
1National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece, 2Hippokration Hospital, Athens, Greece,
3Medical School, University of Ioannina, Ioannina, Greece, 4Konstantopoulio hospital, Athens,
Greece
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate the cost-effectiveness of nab-paclitaxel+gemcitabine (Npg)
versus gemcitabine (Gem) alone for the first-line treatment of metastatic pancreatic
cancer in Greece from a National Health System perspective Methods: A Markov
model was developed, included several stages such as: “pre-progression on firstline treatment”, “pre-progression off first-line treatment”, “post progression”, “four
weeks to death” and “death”. Data from the MPACT trial were used to estimate overall
survival (Life-Years- (LYs)) and adverse events. The prices of drugs used in the model
are publicly available for all hospitals in Greece. Cost assigned in each health state
reflected: drugs, adverse events, monitoring, administration and palliative care. Utility
values were obtained from the international literature to estimate Quality-AdjustedLife-Years (QALYs). Costs and health gains were discounted at 3.5% per annum. A
probabilistic sensitivity analysis was also conducted to construct confidence intervals (CI). Results: The mean number of QALYs was 0.71 (95%CI: 0.66–0.78) and 0.56
(95%CI: 0.52–0.60) for Npg and Gem, respectively, giving an incremental gain of 0.15
(95%CI: 0.08-0.25) QALYs in favour of Npg. The mean cost of therapy per patient was
estimated at €15,628 (95%CI: €14,377- €17,027) and €8,284 (95%CI: €7,455-€9,112) for
Npg and Gem, respectively. The incremental cost per LY gained with Npg was estimated at €37,007 and the incremental cost per QALY gained at €47,120. The probability
for Npg to be cost-effective at a threshold three times the per capita income (€ 60,000
per QALY) was 82%. Conclusions: The severity of pancreatic cancer, in combination
with the limited number of effective treatments, results in a high level of unmet need.
If the societal willingness-to-pay threshold for an additional QALY is relatively higher
for patients with short life expectancy or for diseases with a relatively higher burden,
the combination of nab-paclitaxel+gemcitabine could be considered a cost-effective
choice compared with gemcitabine alone in Greece.
PCN106
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Panitumumab Plus Mfolfox6 Versus
Bevacizumab Plus Mfolfox6 for First-Line Treatment of Patients
with Wild-Type Ras Metastatic Colorectal Cancer
Graham C N 1, Hechmati G 2, Hjelmgren J 2, De Liège F 3, Lanier J 3, Knoof A 3, Knox H 1, Barber
B 4, de Pouvourville G 5
1RTI Health Solutions, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA, 2Amgen (Europe) GmbH, Zug,
Switzerland, 3Amgen France SAS, Neuilly-sur-Seine, France, 4Amgen, Inc., Thousand Oaks, CA,
USA, 5ESSEC Business School, Cergy-Pontoise, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To compare the cost-effectiveness of panitumumab plus mFOLFOX6
(oxaliplatin, 5-fluorouracil and leucovorin) versus bevacizumab plus mFOLFOX6
as first-line treatment for patients with wild-type RASmetastatic colorectal cancer
(mCRC). Methods: Using a French health collective perspective, a lifetime Markov
model was constructed, with health states related to first-line therapy (progressionfree), disease progression with/without subsequent active treatment, resection of
metastases, disease-free after successful resection, and death. Transitions to disease
progression and death were estimated using parametric survival analyses of patientlevel progression-free (PFS) and overall (OS) survival from the only head-to-head clinical trial of panitumumab versus bevacizumab in mCRC (PEAK). Additional data from
PEAK informed the amount of each drug consumed, duration of therapy, subsequent
therapy use, and toxicities related to mCRC treatment. Literature and French public
data sources were used to estimate unit costs associated with treatment, duration
of subsequent active therapies, and survival post-resection. Patient-level data from
panitumumab trials in the first-, second-, and third-line settings were used to determine utility weights. One-way and probabilistic sensitivity analyses were performed.
Scenario analyses examined modelling of PFS and OS using observational survival
data and PEAK hazard ratios. Results: Based on the better efficacy outcomes for
patients with wild-type RASmCRC who received panitumumab plus mFOLFOX6 versus bevacizumab plus mFOLFOX6 in PEAK, the incremental cost per life-year gained
was estimated to be €26,918, and the incremental cost per quality-adjusted life year
(QALY) gained was estimated to be €36,577. Sensitivity and scenario analyses indicate the model is robust to alternative parameters and assumptions. Conclusions:
Panitumumab plus mFOLFOX6 can be considered cost-effective in first-line treatment
of patients with wild-type RAS mCRC.
PCN107
Cost-Utility Analysis of Pazopanib VersUS Sunitinib as First-Line
Treatment of Metastatic Renal Cell Carcinoma (MRCC) iN Spain
Espinosa J 1, González-Larriba J,L 2, Maroto P 3, Méndez-Vidal M J 4, Díaz-Cerezo S 5
General Universitario de Ciudad Real, Ciudad Real, Spain, 2Hospital Clínico San Carlos,
Madrid, Spain, 3Hospital Sant Pau, Barcelona, Spain, 4Hospital Reina Sofía, Córdoba, Spain, 5GSK
España, Tres Cantos, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Hospital
Objectives: To assess the cost-utility of pazopanib vs. sunitinib as first-line treatment of mRCC from the Spanish National Healthcare perspective. Methods: A
published partitioned-survival analysis model was used to estimate the incremental
cost-utility ratio (ICUR) of pazopanib vs. sunitinib. Progression free survival (PFS) and
overall survival (OS) data from COMPARZ (NCT00720941), a non-inferiority head to
head phase III-trial of sunitinib vs. pazopanib, were used to generate survival functions up to overall time horizon. Patients can be in one of three mutually exclusive
health states over time: alive and no progression, alive with progression and dead.
Utilities values were obtained from PISCES trial (NCT01064310) and adjusted taking into account the different treatment schedules (sunitinib-cycles: 4 weeks-on
plus2 weeks-off; pazopanib 800 mg/day). Health resource utilization was collected
using individual patient data from COMPARZ trial and their corresponding unit
costs were retrieved from published Spanish tariffs. Base-case analysis considered:
A633
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
5-year time horizon, PFS data assessed by independent review, drug doses adjusted
by relative dose intensity reported in COMPARZ trial and a discount rate of 3% for
costs and outcomes. Results were expressed as € 2014. Deterministic (10-year time
horizon, discount rates 0 and 5%, PFS assessed by investigator, and plenty-doses)
and probabilistic sensitivity analyses were conducted to determine the robustness
of the results. Results: In the base case analysis, pazopanib showed as a dominant
alternative, yielding more quality of life adjusted years (0.081) and less total costs
(€ 6,671) vs. sunitinib. Base-case results were robust in the alternative scenarios
examined via deterministic sensitivity analyses. In the probabilistic sensitivity
analysis (PSA), a 67% of the simulations were plotted in the dominant quadrant of
the cost-effectiveness plane. Conclusions: In the light of the present analysis,
pazopanib should be considered as a dominant alternative vs. sunitinib in the firstline mRCC treatment from the Spanish National Healthcare perspective.
PCN108
Economic Evaluation of the Use of Gefitinib for the Treatment of
Locally Advanced or Metastatic NSCLC
Polanco A C 1, Salazar A 1, Pizarro M 2, Carpio E 1, González L A 3
1AstraZeneca, Tlalpan, Mexico, 2Hospital Infantil de Mexico Federico Gomez, Mexico City, Mexico,
3Health Solutions Consulting, D. F., Mexico
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC) is the most common type of cancer representing 18.2% of all cancer deaths around the world and in Mexico the estimated
mortality rate is 13.4 by 100,000 patients. Objectives: Evaluate gefitinib as first
and second line treatment of locally advanced or metastatic NSCLC compared to
available treatment alternatives in Mexico. Methods: A two-way analysis was performed: (1) For the first-line treatment in patients with Epidermal Growth Factor
Receptor Inhibition in Mutation-Positive Non–Small-Cell Lung Cancer (EGFR M+
NSCLC) a cost-minimization analysis was used comparing gefitinib versus erlotinib
(Kim ST, 2012), also a Markov model was developed to perform a cost-effectiveness
analysis evaluating gefitinib versus carboplatin+paclitaxel (Mok TS, 2009), with
efficacy measure Progression-free survival (PFS); and (2) For patients in a secondline NSCLC treatment, regardless of EGFR mutation, a cost-minimization analysis was conducted comparing gefitinib versus docetaxel and pemetrexed (Hanna
N, 2004) (Kim ES, 2008). The costs were obtained from institutional sources. An
exchange rate of $13.12 MXN per USD was used. Sensitivity analyses were performed in order to test the robustness of the model. Results: For first-line treatment, gefitinib was a cost-saving alternative respect to erlotinib, obtaining a cost
differential of $9,710 USD in favor of gefitinib. To the same patients gefitinib compared to carboplatin plus paclitaxel generated an additional cost of $2,361 USD
per patient, with additional PFS of 0.37 years and an ICER of $7,023. For secondline treatment gefitinib had a lower cost compared to pemetrexed and docetaxel,
generating a saving per patient of $927 USD and $21,346 USD respectively. Robustness
of results was confirmed by additional deterministic and probabilistic sensitivity
analysis. Conclusions: The use of gefitinib for the treatment of locally advanced or
metastatic NSCLC is a cost-saving alternative compared to erlotinib, pemetrexed and
docetaxel, and also cost-effective compared to carboplatin plus paclitaxel.
PCN109
Cost-Effectiveness of Ofatumumab Plus Chlorambucil in First Line
Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia in Canada
Herring W 1, Pearson I 2, Purser M 1, Nakhaipour H R 3, Haiderali A 4, Wolowacz S 2,
Jayasundara K 3
1RTI Health Solutions, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA, 2RTI Health Solutions, Manchester, UK,
3GlaxoSmithKline, Mississauga, ON, Canada, 4GlaxoSmithKline, Collegeville, PA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: This study aimed to estimate the cost-effectiveness of Ofatumumab
plus Chlorambucil (OChl) compared with Chlorambucil (Chl) for patients with
Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia for whom fludarabine-based therapies are considered inappropriate, from the perspective of the publicly funded health care system
in Canada. Methods: A semi-Markov based decision model was developed with a
lifetime time horizon. The model comprised two distinct phases. The preprogression
phase was based on the overall response rates (ORR), progression free survival (PFS)
and overall survival (OS) observed in the COMPLEMENT-1 trial. The postprogression
phase was based on Canadian treatment practices, treatment patterns identified
in clinical guidelines and published literature. The incremental cost per qualityadjusted life year (QALY) gained was computed using model-estimated first- and
subsequent-line treatment costs, general disease management costs, and QALYs
based on health-state preference utility weights. Results: The discounted, lifetime
health and economic outcomes estimated by the model showed that first-line treatment with OChl in comparison with Chl in the target population led to an increase in
QALYs (0.41) and an increase in total costs (CAD $27,850), resulting in an incremental
cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of CAD $68,672/QALY gained. Various scenario analyses
indicated that the cost-effectiveness results were sensitive to the time horizon, the
method used to assess response, and the extrapolation of OS treatment effect beyond
the trial period. One way and probabilistic sensitivity analyses aligned with the results
of the base-case analysis. Conclusions: The base-case results indicate that the
improved ORR, PFS, and OS for OChl in comparison with Chl translate to improved
long-term health outcomes. The analysis found that the ICER for OChl versus Chl in
the target population was CAD $68,672/QALY gained. A variety of sensitivity and scenario analyses confirmed that the model’s cost-effectiveness estimates were robust.
PCN110
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Panitumumab+Mfolfox over
Bevacizumab+Mfolfox as a First-Line Treatment for Metastatic
Colorectal Cancer Patients with Wild-Type Ras in Greece
Kourlaba G 1, Boukovinas I 2, Saridaki Z 3, Papagiannopoulou V 4, Tritaki G 4, Maniadakis N 5
and Kapodistrian University of Athens School of Medicine, Athens, Greece, 2Bioclinic
Thessaloniki – Oncology Unit, Thesaloniki, Greece, 3Laboratory of Tumor Cell Biology School
of Medicine-University of Crete, Herakleion, Crete, Greece, 4AMGEN Hellas, Marousi, Greece,
5National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece
.
1National
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To conduct a cost-effectiveness analysis of panitumumab plus mFOLFOX6 versus bevacizumab plus mFOLFOX6 as first-line treatment (FLT) of metastatic
colorectal cancer (mCRC) patients with wild-type RASin the Greek health care setting. Methods: An existing Markov model consisting of seven health states was
adapted from the public third-party-payer perspective. Both efficacy and safety data
considered in the model were extracted from the PEAK trial and other published
studies. Utility values were also extracted from the literature. Direct medical costs
consisting of drug-acquisition costs for FLT, administration costs, subsequent therapy costs and other medical costs were incorporated into the model and reflect the
year 2014. Primary outcomes were patient survival (life-years), quality-adjusted life
years (QALYs) and the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) per QALY gained.
Probabilistic sensitivity analysis (PSA) was conducted to account for uncertainty
and variation in the parameters of the model. Results: The analysis showed that
panitumumab plus mFOLFOX6 produced greater discounted survival and quality
adjusted survival by 0.87 LYs and 0.65 QALY benefit in relation to bevacizumab plus
mFOLFOX6. The total lifetime cost was € 75,200 and € 52,736 for panitumumab and
bevacizumab plus mFOLFOX6, respectively. This difference was mainly attributed
to the higher acquisition cost of panitumumab compared to bevacizumab during
the pre-progression health state (€ 32,223 and € 14,730 respectively). Incremental
analysis showed that panitumumab plus mFOLFOX6 was more effective and more
costly than bevacizumab plus mFOLFOX6 resulting in an ICER equal to € 34,644
per QALY gained. PSA revealed that the probability of panitumumab plus mFOLFOX6 being cost-effective over bevacizumab plus mFOLFOX6 was 81.5% at the predetermined threshold of € 51,000 per QALY gained (3 times the GDP per capita of
Greece). Conclusions: The results suggest that panitumumab plus mFOLFOX6
may be a cost-effective alternative relative to bevacizumab plus mFOLFOX6 as FLT
of mCRC patients with wild-type RASin Greece.
PCN111
Cost-Effectiveness and Cost-Utility of Granulocyte ColonyStimulating Factors in the Primary Prophylaxis of Chemotherapy
Induced Febrile Neutropenia (FN) in Breast Cancer Patients in Greece:
A Comparative Analysis
Kourlaba G 1, Palaka E 2, Papagiannopoulou V 2, Maniadakis N 3
1National and Kapodistrian University of Athens School of Medicine, Athens, Greece, 2AMGEN
Hellas, Marousi, Greece, 3National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To conduct an economic evaluation comparing pegfilgrastim with
filgrastim or lenograstim used either in an 11-day regimen or in a 6-day regimen for
the prophylaxis of febrile neutropenia (FN) in breast cancer patients, in the Greek
health care setting. Methods: A cost-effectiveness model was locally adapted from
the public third-party-payer perspective. Efficacy and utility values extracted from
published studies were considered in the model. The analysis was conducted for a
6-cycle horizon, to reflect the common clinical practice in Greece. Drug acquisition
costs, administration costs and FN management reimbursed costs were considered
(in € 2014). The outcomes of the model were the incremental cost per additional FN
event avoided and per QALY gained (ICER) of pegfilgrastim to its comparators. The
ICERs were evaluated at the predetermined willingness-to-pay threshold of € 34,000/
QALY gained. Results: The incremental cost per additional FN event avoided with
pegfilgrastim ranged between € 11,015 and € 27,079 compared to 11-day regimens of
originator and a biosimilar filgrastim respectively, while pegfilgrastim was found
to be dominant compared to the 11-day regimen of lenograstim. Comparing pegfilgrastim with the 6-day regimen of filgrastim and lenograstim, it was found that
the ICER per additional FN event avoided ranged between € 9,538 and € 15,207 in case
of lenograstim and biosimilar filgrastim respectively. Similarly, cost-utility analysis
revealed that pegfilgrastim was cost-effective over 11-day and 6-day regimens of
originator filgrastim with ICERs of € 11,065 and € 19,942/QALY gained, respectively.
Compared to lenograstim, pegfilgrastim was found to be dominant over the 11-day
regimen and cost-effective over the 6-day regimen (ICER: € 15,546). Conclusions:
Our findings suggests that pegfilgrastim for the prophylaxis of chemotherapyinduced FN in breast cancer patients is associated with greater health benefit and
lower cost over 11-day use of lenograstim, while it is a cost-effective option over
either the 6-day or the 11-day regimen of biosimilar filgrastim, in Greece.
PCN112
Cost-Effectiveness of Vismodegib VersUS Standard of Care Therapy
in the Treatment of Locally-Advanced or Symptomatic Metastatic
Basal Cell Carcinoma in Hungary – A Global Cost-Effectiveness
Model Adaptation
Mikudina B 1, Péter T 1, Nagy B1, Horváth K2
1Healthware Consulting Ltd., Budapest, Hungary, 2Roche Hungary, Budaörs, Hungary
.
.
Objectives: Hungarian adaptation of global cost-effectiveness models of vismodegib vs. standard of care (SOC) in the treatment of locally advanced or symptomatic
metastatic basal cell carcinoma (laBCC and mBCC). Methods: Global Markovmodels were developed to compare the cost-effectiveness of vismodegib vs. SOC
in patients with laBCC or mBCC. The model inputs were based on the pivotal phase
II clinical study (ERIVANCE). Health state utility values were based on a time trade
off study. To support the reimbursement dossier submission, the adaptation of the
global cost-effectiveness models was conducted. The costs and resource use were
recalculated based on a questionnaire survey with Hungarian health care professionals. In the model there were two treatment arms, vismodegib and SOC. The
model had three states, progression-free, progressed and death. For progression-free
survival (PFS) and overall survival (OS) the results of the phase II clinical trial were
used in the vismodegib arm of the model. Originally on the SOC arm the model
calculated with mortality data of the general population, due to lack of relevant data
on the PFS and OS of patients with advanced BCC. Therefore, a research (Delphipanel survey) was conducted to estimate the OS of patients with laBCC and mBCC,
treated with SOC. Results: According to the Delphi-panel survey the median OS for
patients with laBCC and mBCC was 48 months and 24 months, respectively, on the
SOC arm. The average time spent in progression-free health state is longer with vis-
A634
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
modegib therapy than with SOC for both, laBCC and mBCC patients. Conclusions:
Vismodegib could provide an effective treatment for this therapeutic area with high
rate of unmet need. During the adaptation process Delphi-panel surveys seemed
to be an appropriate method to earn consensus statement to ensure estimation
and help interpretation.
PCN113
Potential Monetary Value of Human Papillomavirus Vaccination on
Human Papillomavirus-Related Cancers and Genital Warts in the
United Kingdom
sitivity analysis (PSA) was run with thousand repetitions and a one-way sensitivity analysis was calculated showing its results in a tornado chart. Results: The
model showed that everolimus + exemestane results in 0.74 progression free years
gained with an incremental cost of $18.6 million (MM) resulting in an incremental
cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of $26 MM. The PSA showed that the ICER is within
the range recommended by WHO (1-3 GDPs per capita) in 71% of cases (Currently
the GDP per capita in Chile is $10 MM). Conclusions: This analysis showed
that using everolimus plus exemestane in patients with ER +, HER2- advanced
breast cancer who have failed on NSAIs is a cost-effective option according to
WHO recommendations.
Van Kriekinge G 1, Starkie-Camejo H 2, Li X 1, Demarteau N 1
.
.
.
.
1GlaxoSmithKline Vaccines, Wavre, Belgium, 2GlaxoSmithKline, Uxbridge, UK
Objectives: The United Kingdom (UK) runs a successful human papillomavirus
(HPV) girls vaccination programme. Debate is ongoing on the value of including
boys in the programme. This study aims at quantifying the potential value associated with genital warts (GW) and HPV-related cancer prevention in UK males and
females based on a willingness-to-pay threshold of £20,000 per quality-adjusted
life-years (QALY) gained, representing the potential value a government places
on the prevention of these diseases. Methods: A static vaccine steady-state
(VSS) population model, stratified by age, with a 1-year time horizon, replicated
the incidence of GW and HPV-related cancers in females (cervical (CC), anal (AC),
vulvar (VuC), vaginal (VaC), oropharyngeal (OP)) and males (penile (PC), AC and
OP) pre-vaccination and at VSS. Data were retrieved from UK cancer registries,
sexually transmitted diseases reports and HPVCentre. Costs and utilities were
identified from the literature. The VSS vaccine effectiveness for GW and HPVrelated cancers was estimated combining efficacies (AS04-adjuvanted HPV-16/18
vaccine for cancers; HPV-6/11/16/18 vaccine for GW) weighted by vaccine-types
(HPV-6/11/16/18) and non-vaccine types (HPV-31/33/35/39/45/51/52/56/58/59) HPV
distribution. Costs and QALYs were discounted at 1.5%. Per-course vaccine costeffective price (vCE-p) was determined by increasing vaccine course price until
£20,000 per incremental QALY gained at VSS was reached. Sensitivity analyses
on key variables were performed. Results: The vCE-p in women (men) was: CC
£790, OP £20 (£57), AC £123 (£77), VaC £37, VuC £58, (PC £40), GW £26 (£27). Total
value of cancer prevention in women (men) was £1,027 (£173), a proportion of 6:
1. The value of CC alone is 4.5 times larger than the total value of cancer prevention in men. Sensitivity analyses showed results were robust while influenced by
potential herd protection. Conclusions: The vCE-p was estimated to be up to
6 times higher in women than in men due to the higher burden and frequency of
HPV-related cancers in women.
PCN114
Cost-Effectiveness of Aprepitant in Egyptian Patients Receiving
Highly Emetogenic Therapy from the Third Party Payer Perspective
PCN116
Cost-Effectiveness of 2-DOSE AS04-Adjuvanted Human
Papillomavirus 16/18 Vaccination Schedule in Slovakia
Hlavinkova L 1, Li X 2, Van Kriekinge G 2, Trnovec P 1
1GlaxoSmithKline Slovakia, Bratislava, Slovak Republic, 2GlaxoSmithKline Vaccines, Wavre,
Belgium
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Slovakia is a country with high incidence and mortality of cervical
cancer (CC). Despite the improvements in screening (22.9% coverage rate), the CC
incidence has increased over the past 30 years in Slovakia. Human Papillomavirus
(HPV) vaccination could help to reduce this CC burden. The objective of this analysis was to assess the cost-effectiveness of adding the AS04-adjuvanted HPV-16/18
vaccine (AS04V), using a 2-dose administration schedule, to the current CC screening programme in Slovakia. Methods: A previously published Markov cohort
model, reproducing the natural history of HPV infection, the impact of screening
and vaccination, was adapted to the Slovakian settings. Local data on health care
costs of pre-cancer lesions and CC, obtained from the expert panel, were used.
Transition probabilities and utilities were estimated from published data. Costs
were from a health care payer perspective. The incremental CC cases avoided, cost,
quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs) and resulting cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER)
of AS04V added to the current CC screening programme versus the current CC
screening in Slovakia was estimated. The base case assumes a 100% vaccination
coverage among 12-year-old girls (N= 24,859). A discount rate of 5% was used.
Univariate sensitivity analyses were carried out on key parameters. Results:
Compared to screening alone, adding AS04V to the current screening programme
was estimated to reduce the lifetime CC cases by 328 at an ICER of 11,621 € /
QALY gained. Compared to the official cut-off of 19,320€ /QALY gained, it can be
considered as cost-effective. Undiscounted analysis shows that AS04V generates
more QALYs with similar cost versus screening alone (ICER= 5€ /QALY gained).
Parameters most driving the results were discount rate, vaccine efficacy and duration of protection. Conclusions: AS04V vaccination of 12-year-old girls in a
2-dose schedule was estimated to be a cost-effective CC prevention strategy in
Slovakia.
Helal M 1, Elsisi G 2
.
.
1CAPA, Cairo, Egypt, 2Central Administration
for Pharmaceutical Affairs, Cairo, Egypt
Objectives: to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of aprepitant as add-on therapy to the standard Egyptian regimen in patients receiving highly emetogenic
therapy. Methods: A decision tree model was developed based on the Egyptian
clinical practice, and was derived from published sources. This decision analytical model was constructed to assess the costs and consequences associated with
aprepitant containing regimen compared with standard therapy for ChemotherapyInduced Nausea and Vomiting. The clinical parameters were derived from a randomized trial previously published. The utility of the health states was derived
using the available published data. Direct medical costs were obtained from the
third party payer tariff in Egypt. Deterministic sensitivity analyses were conducted.
All costs (in 2014 EGP) and outcomes were discounted at 3.5% annually. Results:
The total quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs) of adding aprepitant to the standard
regimen was estimated to be 0.0082, whereas that of the standard regimen was
estimated to be 0.0072 (with a net difference of 0.001QALYs). The total costs for
aprepitant plus standard regimen and standard regimen alone were EGP 414.25
and EGP 346.62 respectively (with a net difference of EGP 67.63). Thus the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) for aprepitant was EGP 66,004/QALY gained.
The probability of complete protection and incomplete response of both arms
were found to have the greatest effect on the results. Conclusions: The present
study concludes that adding aprepitant to the standard regimen is cost effective
based on the threshold stated by world health organization (3xGDP/capita) for
patients with severe vomiting after chemotherapy.
PCN115
Cost Effectiveness Analysis of Everolimus + Exemestane for
Patients with Advanced Breast Cancer with Positive Estrogen
Receptor (ER +), HER2-, Refractory to Non-Steroidal Aromatase
Inhibitors (NSAIS) in Chile
Ratto B 1, Torres Ulloa R 2, Cerda Veneros H 2, Anaya P 3
1Novartis Pharmaceuticals, Buenos Aires, Argentina, 2INSTITUTO NACIONAL DEL CÁNCER,
Santiago, Chile, 3Novartis Pharmaceuticals, Mexico City, Mexico
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of everolimus plus exemestane in patients with ER+, HER2- advanced breast cancer, who have failed on
NSAIs. Methods: A Markov model was developed with monthly cycles and a
time horizon of five years. The model compares progression free survival (PFS) of
exemestane + everolimus (EVE+EXE) to exemestane monotherapy (EXE). Transition
probabilities for PFS of EVE+EXE and EXE were based on BOLERO-2 study and calculated using a fitted Weibull distribution. The R-squared values for the Weibull fits
were 0.998 and 0.990 for EVE+EXE and EXE alone respectively. The Weibull parameters used in the model were: 0.067 and 1.118 for EVE+EXE and 0.191 and 1.006 for
EXE. Costs considered included drugs and cost of treating neutropenia (other AEs
are not covered by the National Formulary). The analysis was designed from the
perspective of the Chilean Public Healthcare. Results are shown in 2014 Chilean
pesos. A 5% discount rate for costs and efficacies was applied. A probabilistic sen-
PCN117
A Cost Effectiveness Analysis of Everolimus Plus Exemestane
Compared to Chemotherapy Agents for the Treatment of
ER+ HER2- Metastastic Breast Cancer in the United Kingdom
Polanyi Z 1, Dale P 2, Taylor M 3, Lewis L 3, Glanville J 3, Vieira J 1, Chandiwana D 1
1Novartis Pharmaceuticals UK Limited, Camberley, UK, 2HEOR Solutions, London, UK, 3York
Health Economics Consortium, York, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of everolimus plus exemestane
(EVE+EXE) versus chemotherapy agents [docetaxel (DOC), vinorelbine (VIN), doxorubicin (DOX) and capecitabine (CAPE)] for the treatment of hormone receptor
positive (HR+) HER2 negative (HER2-) advanced or metastatic breast cancer in the
United Kingdom (UK). Methods: A partitioned survival model was developed to
compare treatment with EVE+EXE versus DOC, VIN, DOX and CAPE in patients with
ER+ HER2- metastatic breast cancer over a 10-year time horizon from a UK NHS
perspective. Progression-free survival and overall survival for EVE+EXE were taken
from the BOLERO-2 trial. Log-logistic functions were used to extrapolate trial data
beyond the follow-up period. In the absence of head-to-head evidence comparing
EVE+EXE versus chemotherapy a naïve chained comparison was conducted with
the link between EVE+EXE established via tamoxifen using the Bucher method.
A class effect was assumed for the four chemotherapy agents. Background health
state and terminal care resource use were derived from NICE Clinical Guideline 81.
Drug costs were taken from the British National Formulary. Utilities for stable and
progressive states were obtained from the literature (Lloyd et al. 2006). Results:
Over a ten year time horizon, EVE+EXE led to a life expectancy of 3.55 years, compared to 1.88 for chemotherapy agents (DOC, VIN, DOX and CAPE). EVE+EXE resulted
in 2.06 QALYs, compared to 0.95 for chemotherapy agents. Total costs were £48,085
for EVE+EXE compared to £31,835 vs. DOC, £25,021 vs. VIN, £23,743 vs. DOX and
£21,851 vs. CAPE. The incremental costs per QALY were £14,550 vs. DOC, £20,653 vs.
VIN, £21,797 vs. DOX and £23,491 vs. CAPE. Results were most sensitive to changes
in PFS for chemotherapy and disease related costs. Conclusions: Everolimus in
combination with exemestane is a cost effective option compared with commonly
used chemotherapeutic agents (docetaxel, vinorelbine, doxorubicin and capecitabine) in UK clinical practice.
PCN118
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Bevacizumab- PaclitaxelCarboplatin (PC) Versus PC in First-Line Therapy of Advanced NonSmall Cell Lung Cancer from Patients’ Perspective in Vietnam
Tran T T H , Nguyen T T T
University of Medicine and Pharmacy in HCMC, Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Bevacizumab in combination with carboplatin/paclitaxel (BCP) was
approved to be the first-line therapy of advanced NSCLC due to its high clinical efficacy. However, economic effectiveness of BCP has been controversial. This
study aimed to estimate the cost-effectiveness of BCP versus PC in treatment of
advanced NSCLC patients from patients’ perspective in Vietnam. Methods: A
A635
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Markov model was developed to estimate the health outcome (QALY) and total
treatment costs with Markov cycle of 21 days and lifetime horizon. The effectiveness data was retrieved from the randomized clinical trial ECOG 4599. Direct
costs, including cost of drugs, administration, medical services, hospital bed day
and adverse drug reaction management were estimated based on treatment
guideline of NCCN for NSCLC. Indirect costs, including loss of earnings, cost for
meal, transportation, accomodation of patients and their caregivers due to treatment, were estimated based on survey of a cohort of 87 patients with NSCLC
in HCMC Oncology Hospital. Both cost and effectiveness were discounted 3%
annually. Results: Adding bevacizumab to PC regimen in first-line therapy of
advanced NSCLC patients resulted in incremental QALY gained of 2.26 month
compared with PC regimen (7.88 versus 5.62). The total treatment cost with BCP
was 3 times higher than PC (2,499 millions vs 761.7 millions VND, respectively).
ICER of BCP versus PC was 768,732,924 VND, which is 3.35 times higher than the
Willingness-To-Pay of Vietnam in 2013 (229,242,416 VND). A probability sensitivity
analysis demonstrated the patient’s weight and bevacizumab’s price as the most
affecting factors to the ICER of BCP vs PC. Conclusions: Conducted analysis
showed that combination of bevacizumab and PC regimen in first-line therapy
of NSCLC was not cost-effective compared with PC regimen. Support from the
manufactures, suppliers and insurance organizations are neccessary to raise its
economic effectiveness in treatment of advanced NSCLC.
PCN119
Cost-Effectiveness Simulation of Colonography Versus
Colonoscopy in Germany: Is Laxative-Free Colonography CostEffective?
Kriza C 1, Jahn B 2, Hassan C 3, Kolominsky-Rabas P L 1
1Centre for Health Technology Assessment (HTA) and Public Health (IZPH), Friedrich-AlexanderUniversity Erlangen-Nürnberg, Erlangen, Germany, 2UMIT - University for Health Sciences,
Medical Informatics and Technology, Hall in Tyrol, Austria, 3Nuovo Regina Margherita Hospital,
Rome, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Colorectal cancer (CRC) screening using computerised tomographic
colonography (CTC), also referred to as virtual colonography, has attracted considerable attention due to its positive impact on high screening uptake rates, especially
with a laxative-free preparation before screening. A decision analysis model was
constructed in order to evaluate the clinical and economic consequences of performing three different screening tests versus a no screening scenario in a population at average risk of colorectal cancer in Germany: colonoscopy, conventional
CT-colonography and laxative-free CT colonography. Methods: A state-transition
microsimulation was developed for the evaluation of the different screening strategies using TreeAge Pro Healthcare 2014. A hypothetic population of 100,000 German
asymptomatic adults aged between 50 and 100 years was used for the basis of the
model. The simulation of the screening strategies was undertaken by assessing the
number of screening patients diagnosed with CRC on the basis of the sensitivity
and specificity of each strategy and the related uptake of each screening method.
Sensitivity analysis will be applied to test the impact of parameter uncertainty on
model outcomes and recommendations. Results: Initial results of the simulation show that laxative-free colonography was found to be the most costly screening option, with a total cost of EUR 4,115 per screening patient in the simulation
model. Colonoscopy was found to be the least costly screening method, with total
equivalent costs of EUR 2,132. The most effective screening was modeled for laxative-free colonography. The ICER of laxative-free colonography compared to colonoscopy was simulated at 5,221 EUR per life year saved. Conclusions: Our simulation
has shown that using data from new research indicating the possibility of less costly
use of CTC than previously used for modeling, laxative-free CTC screening has the
potential to become a cost-effective alternative screening method for CRC due to
its advantage related to improvements in screening uptake.
PCN120
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Abiraterone Acetate Treatment
Compared With Cabacitaxel in Costa Rica, in Patients with
Metastatic Castration-Resistant Prostate Cancer That Have Failed
to Chemotherapy with Docetaxel
Obando C A 1, Desanvicente-Celis Z 1, Gonzalez L 2, Muschett D 1, Gonzalez F 1, Goldberg P 1
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Janssen, Panama, Panama, 2Janssen, Raritan, NJ, USA
Objectives: To assess the cost-effectiveness of Abiraterone Acetate plus Prednisone
(A-P) compared with Cabazitaxel plus Prednisone (C-P) in Costa Rica, in patients
with Metastatic Castration-Resistant Prostate Cancer (mCRPC) that have failed to
chemotherapy with Docetaxel. Methods: A three-health state cohort simulation Markov Model (progression-free, post-progression and death) was developed
based on overall and progression free survival data. The time frame was 10 years.
The perspective was that of the Public System of Health of Costa Rica. The health
outcomes of interest were Quality Adjusted Life Years (QALYs) and Life Years (LYs).
Efficacy data was taken from clinical trials (COU-AA-301 for A-P and TROPIC for C-P).
Utilities for health states and negative utilities for adverse events were estimated
based on quality of life endpoints of the COU-AA-301 trial. The base year was 2012.
All costs are presented in Costa Rican currency (Colones - CRC). Costs and outcomes
were discounted at 5%. Probabilistic sensitivity (PSA) analysis was performed to
evaluate uncertainty surrounding the parameters. Results: A-P resulted in 0.79
QALYs and 1.35 LYs, per patient, respectively. C-P resulted in 0.71 QALYs and 1.28
LYs, per patient, respectively. Mean total costs per patient were: CRC 33.881.184 for
A-P and CRC 41.981.207 for C-P. The results of the probabilistic sensitivity analysis
showed that, when compared with C-Z, A-P was found dominant (associated with
reduced costs and increased QALYs) in the majority of the iterations. A-P had an
89% probability of being cost effective, independent of the willingness to pay, when
compared to C-P. Conclusions: A-P can be considered dominant (cost-saving),
when compared with C-P, in patients with Metastatic Castration-Resistant Prostate
Cancer that have failed to chemotherapy with Docetaxel, from the perspective of
the Public System of Health of Costa Rica.
PCN121
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Abiraterone Acetate Treatment
Compared with Cabacitaxel in Dominican Republic, in Patients With
Metastatic Castration-Resistant Prostate Cancer that Have Failed
to Chemotherapy with Docetaxel
Obando C A 1, Desanvicente-Celis Z 1, Gonzalez L 2, Muschett D 1, Gonzalez F 1, Goldberg P 1
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Janssen, Panama, Panama, 2Janssen, Raritan, NJ, USA
Objectives: To assess the cost-effectiveness of Abiraterone Acetate plus Prednisone
(A-P) compared with Cabazitaxel plus Prednisone (C-P) in Dominican Republic, in
patients with Metastatic Castration-Resistant Prostate Cancer (mCRPC) that have
failed to chemotherapy with Docetaxel. Methods: A three-health state cohort simulation Markov Model (progression-free, post-progression and death) was developed
based on overall and progression free survival data. The time frame was 10 years.
The perspective was that of the Public System of Health of Dominican Republic. The
health outcomes of interest were Quality Adjusted Life Years (QALYs) and Life Years
(LYs). Efficacy data was taken from clinical trials (COU-AA-301 for A-P and TROPIC
for C-P). Utilities for health states and negative utilities for adverse events were
estimated based on quality of life endpoints of the COU-AA-301 trial. The base year
was 2012. All costs are presented in Dominican currency (Dominican Pesos - RD$).
Costs and outcomes were discounted at 5%. Probabilistic sensitivity (PSA) analysis
was performed to evaluate uncertainty surrounding the parameters. Results:
A-P resulted in 0.79 QALYs and 1.35 LYs, per patient, respectively. C-P resulted in 0.71
QALYs and 1.28 LYs, per patient, respectively. Mean total costs per patient were: RD$
2.204.289 for A-P and RD$ 2.732.365 for C-P. The results of the probabilistic sensitivity
analysis showed that, when compared with C-Z, A-P was found dominant (associated with reduced costs and increased QALYs) in the majority of the iterations. A-P
had a 75% probability of being cost effective, independent of the willingness to pay,
when compared to C-P. Conclusions: A-P can be considered cost-saving (dominant), when compared with C-P, in patients with Metastatic Castration-Resistant
Prostate Cancer that have failed to chemotherapy with Docetaxel, from the perspective of the Public System of Health of Dominican Republic.
PCN122
Clinical and Economic Analysis of Effectiveness of Everolimus in
the Treatment Of HR+, HER2- Advanced Breast Cancer in Russia
Krasnova L , Vorobiev P , Holownia M
Russian Society for Pharmacoeconomics and Outcomes Research, Moscow, Russia
.
.
.
Objectives: Modern therapeutic approaches in treatment of advanced breast
cancer can achieve clinically significant regression of symptoms, prolong life and
improve its quality. Aim of this study was to conduct clinical and economic analysis
of application of everolimus in the treatment of hormone-receptor-positive (HR+),
human epidermal growth factor receptor-2-negative (HER2-) advanced breast cancer in postmenopausal women. Methods: An epidemiological and pharmacoeconomic evaluation of HR+, HER2- advanced breast cancer in postmenopausal
women with using a survey of experts from different regions of Russia and modeling method. Calculating the cost of drugs and medical services was conducted
according to experts and standard of medical care. Filling of a Markov model was
conducted without using and with using of everolimus in the treatment of the
patients within 5 years. Calculated indicators were: the impact of the disease on
budget, the cost of one additional year of life. Results: From 13 regions of Russia
8 experts refused to provide information on the questionnaire, which may indicate
the unwillingness to disclose information on epidemiology and tactics of treatment
of disease. The burden of breast cancer for 5 years without the use of everolimus
in the treatment regimens of patients with postmenopausal HR+, HER2- advanced
breast cancer and with using it were: in Moscow 118.668.419€ and 137.596.651€ ;
St. Petersburg-36.730.318€ and 38.133.492€ ; Republic of Khakassia-18.854.270€ and
19.812.467€ ; Omsk region-32.428.540€ and 33.603.456€ ; Primorsky Krai-39.176.077€
and 40.877.880€ . The use of of everolimus with exemestane in the treatment of
advanced breast cancer increases by 1.5-2 times life expectancy and its “cost-effectiveness” indicator is 2 times lower comparing to exemestane monotherapy and
chemotherapy. Sensitivity analysis using the results from 5 regions of Russia showed
unidirectional comparison. Conclusions: The use of everolimus with exemestane
is the dominant technology of treatment HR+, HER2- advanced breast cancer in
postmenopausal patients compared with traditional technology of application of
chemotherapy drugs or exemestane alone.
PCN123
A Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of EGFR-TK Mutation Status-Guided
1st- and 2nd-Line Treatment of Stage III/IV Non-Small Cell Lung
Cancer in the UK
Patel K , Montouchet C , Cheynel J , Ruff L
Covance Inc., London, UK
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Lung cancers are the most common malignant tumours, accounting for 1.38 million annual deaths worldwide. Non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC),
the predominant tumour subtype, is associated with significant deteriorations in
both survival and quality of life. Epidermal growth factor receptor tyrosine kinase
(EGFR-TK) has emerged as a drug therapy target. The National Institute for Health
and Care Excellence (NICE) recommends erlotinib – an EGFR-TK inhibitor – for
first-line treatment of NSCLC in EGFR-TK mutation-positive patients, and secondline treatment in all patients irrespective of EGFR-TK mutations. We developed
a model to assess the cost-effectiveness of an EGFR-TK mutation status-guided
treatment strategy for stage III/IV NSCLC, compared with a strategy not dependent on mutational status. Methods: A Markov model was developed from the
perspective of the UK National Health Service (NHS) over a lifetime horizon. This
compared a current scenario (in which a cohort of NSCLC patients received doublet chemotherapy at first-line therapy, followed either by erlotinib or docetaxel at
second-line) to a revised scenario (in which all EGFR-TK mutation-positive patients
received erlotinib at first-line followed by second-line docetaxel, and all mutationnegative patients received doublet chemotherapy followed by either docetaxel or
A636
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
erlotinib). Efficacy data were based on the TORCH and TAX317 randomised controlled trials. Cost data were obtained from NHS Reference Costs, British National
Formulary list prices and other publically-available sources. Results: In the basecase analysis, the estimated incremental cost-effectiveness ratio exceeded the
NICE willingness-to-pay threshold of £20,000 per quality-adjusted life year gained.
Univariate and probabilistic sensitivity analyses suggested the results were robust
to parameter changes, showing greatest sensitivity to variation in overall survival
parameters. Conclusions: Our model suggests that, from the perspective of the
UK NHS, an EGFR-TK mutation status-guided treatment strategy across first- and
second-line treatment of NSCLC is not cost-effective compared with a strategy not
dependent on mutational status.
PCN124
Comparative Cost-Effectiveness Study of Modern Radiation
Therapies in Hungary for Localized Prostate Cancer
Zemplényi A 1, Kalo Z 2, Mangel L 1, Endrei D 1, Boncz I 3
1University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary, 2Eötvös Loránd University (ELTE), Budapest, Hungary, 3Faculty
of Health Sciences, University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The introduction of innovative medical devices with high investment
and operational costs is often delayed in countries with severe resource constraints.
Cost-effectiveness analysis can help decision-makers to understand the economic
value of such technologies. The purpose of our study was to compare the cost-effectiveness of two modern radiation therapy techniques, the stereotactic body radiation
therapy (SBRT) and intensity-modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) compared to the
3-dimensional conventional radiation therapy (3DCRT) for treatment of low- to
intermediate-risk prostate cancer in Hungary. Methods: A Markov model was
constructed with the following disease states of a 65-year-old patient with organ
confined prostate cancer: no evidence of disease after radiation therapy, hormone
therapy, chemotherapy, death. Transition probabilities were calculated based on
the international literature for SBRT, IMRT and 3DCRT. Utility values for each health
state were obtained from publically available secondary sources. Costs in the model
were calculated based on the Hungarian Health Insurance Fund rates, and were
converted to EUR by applying actual exchange rates (1 EUR = 305 HUF). Analysis
was conducted from payer perspective for 65-year-old patients over 10 years time
horizon. Results: Based on preliminary calculations the expected mean cost of
patients undergoing SBRT, IMRT and 3DCRT were 2,201 EUR, 5,704 EUR and 11.549
EUR respectively. Expected QALYs were 6.00 for SBRT, 5.8 for IMRT and 3.9 for 3DCRT.
Compared to 3DCRT, both IMRT and SBRT were less costly and resulted in more
health gain. Conclusions: The modern SBRT and IMRT are not only cost-effective
compared to the conventional 3DCRT but also provide a great cost saving potential
for the Hungarian health care system and may improve access to radiation and quality of life for patients. Appropriate financial incentives in the DRG system should
support the uptake of cost-effective hospital technologies in Hungary.
PCN125
Systematic Critical Review of Economic Evaluations of Rituximab,
Added to Conventional Chemotherapy Regimen in the Treatment of
Patients with Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemic Refractory
Koury C D N 1, Nunes A A 2, Nita M 1
-Fundação de Ensino e Pesquisas Econômicas, Brasilia, Brazil, 2University of São Paulo USP, Ribeirão Preto, Brazil
.
.
.
.
.
.
1FIPE
Objectives: To review the cost-effectiveness studies of chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL) treatment, in combination and in comparison with fludarabine and
cyclophosphamide chemotherapy (R-FC) in refractory patients or patients who had
been previously treated. Methods: Search and analysis of scientific evidence:
the basics of The Cochrane Library, Centre for Reviews and Dissemination (CRD),
Embase, Lilacs, Database of the Brazilian Network for Technology Assessment
(SISREBRATS), and MEDLINE via PubMed were searched. Aiming to meet economic
evaluations (AVE), or evaluations of health technologies (ATS), comparing schemas
cyclophosphamide and fludarabine (CF) and the same plus Rituximab (R-FC). Studies
were only selected in second-line treatment for CLL. Results: Two economic evaluations studied the treatment of patients with refractory or relapsing disease (R-FC
vs FC). In the study, 24% had improvement in progression-free survival outcome (p
< 0.05) in the R-FC, with more patients achieving partial or complete response in
this group (61% vs 49%, p < 0.05). There was no statistically significant difference in
overall survival. The Rituximab caused more adverse effects, but values of statistical
tests for these outcomes are not presented. In a technology assessment conducted
by NICE, even with reservations, the drug was recommended in view of the British
health care system. Conclusions: There is significant uncertainty in the relevant
outcomes for stages of refractory or relapsing disease. Few clinical trials evaluating
the effectiveness of Rituximab in patients with CLL, which demonstrate no impact
on overall survival, were found. In addition to the significant increase in costs for
managing the disease.
PCN126
What is the Most Cost-Effective Strategy for Treating Chronic
Myeloid Leukemia After Imatinib Loses Patent Exclusivity in Europe?
Padula W V 1, Conti R 2, Larson R 1
of Chicago, Chicago, IL, USA, 2University of Chicago, Chicago, GA, USA
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: To analyze the cost-effectiveness of treating all chronic-phase chronic
myeloid leukemia (CML) with imatinib initially compared to physician-choice
between imatinib or the second-generation tyrosine kinase inhibitors (TKIs) dasatinib or nilotinib. Imatinib will lose patent exclusivity between 2015-2016 and its
price is expected to drop 60-90% within one year throughout Europe. Methods:
A Markov model simulating “step-therapy” compared to “physician-choice” in
treating CML in 2015 through 5 years. The model assumes a European societal perspective. In both approaches, if initial treatment fails, patients are switched to a
second-generation TKI. Patients are assumed to switch if they fail to meet efficacy
endpoints: complete cytogenetic response (CCyR) or major molecular response
(MMR). The model assumes stabilized prices of second-generation TKIs, but discounts the price of imatinib: 100% for first 6-months; 60-80% for second 6-months;
and 10-30% thereafter. For each drug, tolerance, efficacy and the probabilities of
treatment choice, switching and failure were drawn from published clinical trials. Quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) were based on U. K. preference weights
(Szabo et al. 2010). According to Hoyle et al. (2011), direct medical costs per patient
were: £20,244 for imatinib; and ~£30,000 for dasatinib and nilotinib. Additional
costs included patient monitoring and allogeneic transplantation. Costs and QALYs
were discounted at 3% (British Pounds Sterling (£); 2013). Sensitivity analyses tested
parameters for impact on results at a willingness-to-pay of £50,000/QALY. Results:
Step-therapy costs less and offers clinically-equivalent utility (£62,388; 2.864 QALYs)
compared to physician-choice (£71,268; 2.879 QALYs), at an ICER of £592,000/QALY.
The results are robust to changes based on univariate analyses of each parameter.
Multivariate probabilistic sensitivity analyses found step-therapy cost-effective
in 99.9% of 10,000 Monte Carlo simulations. Conclusions: When imatinib loses
patient protection between 2015-2016 throughout Europe, it will be the cost-effective
initial treatment strategy for CML compared to second-generation TKIs.
PCN127
Literature Review of Decision-Analytical Models Used in the
Economic Evaluation of Empirical/Targeted Antifungal Treatments
for Invasive Fungal Infections
Buyukkaramikli N C 1, Gaultney J 2, Leunis A 1, Severens J L 1
for Medical Techonology Assessment (iMTA), Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 2Mapi Group,
Houten, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Institute
Background: Invasive fungal infections (IFIs) are an important cause of morbidity
and mortality in immunocompromised patients. Based on the pathogen identification status, either empirical (without diagnosis) or targeted (with diagnosis) antifungal therapy is administered to symptomatic patients (e.g. with fever). Several
antifungal agents are available and their cost-effectiveness is often evaluated
using decision analytic models (DAMs). Objectives: The objective was to review
all published DAMs used in economic evaluations of empirical/targeted antifungal
treatments for IFIs. This approach is novel as previous reviews were either pathogen or agent-specific. Methods: A review was conducted in MEDLINE/EMBASE
to identify all economic evaluations that included DAMs published until 1-1-2014.
Previous reviews were checked for additional studies. Non-English and studies of
prophylactic treatment were excluded. Data extracted included: population, indication, comparators, model structure, time horizon, outcomes, events, year, country,
and sponsorship. Results: Overall, 24 published economic evaluations including
a DAM were identified. 54% (n= 13) were for targeted treatments and the remaining
(n= 11) for empirical treatments. 62% of the DAMs on targeted treatments (n= 8)
focused on invasive pulmonary aspergillosis and the remaining 38% (n= 5) on invasive candiasis/candidemia. The majority (73%, n= 8) of DAMs evaluating empirical
treatments focused on patients with persistent fever/febrile neutropenia. Lipid formulation amphotericin-B was a comparator in 46% (n= 11) of the studies, followed by
caspofungin in 42% (n= 10) and voriconazole in 42% (n= 10). 92% of the DAMs (n= 22)
included only a decision tree, whereas the remaining 8% (n= 2) embedded a lifetime Markov model. The majority (54%, n= 13) had a hospital perspective and time
horizon of less than 12 weeks (54%, n= 14). Only one study utilized real-world data.
Conclusions: There are major differences in the modeling approach, time horizon,
comparator (s), treatment sequences and outcomes of published economic evaluations in IFI. A list of minimal, consensus-based methodological and structural
requirements for DAMs on antifungal treatments of IFIs, elicited from key experts
is needed.
PCN128
Expansion of the Norwegian HPV Vaccination Program
Sæterdal I , Juvet L , Jimenez E , Couto E , Klemp M , Torkilseng E B
Norwegian Knowledge Centre for the Health Services, Oslo, Norway
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of expanding the Norwegian HPV
vaccination program to catch-up females and 12 years old boys. Methods: We
systematically searched the literature for randomized clinical trials (RCTs) that examined the effect of HPV vaccines on cancer mortality and incidence, precancerous
stages and serious adverse events. We assessed selected publications for potential
risk of bias, and the overall quality of the evidence for each outcome using GRADE.
We adapted a published economic model to the Norwegian setting with respect to
incidence of HPV-related outcomes, costs and quality adjusted life years (QALYs)
lost from HPV-related diseases. The cost utility analysis reported results in Euros/
QALY gained in both a public health budget and a societal perspective. Results: We
included 46 publications reporting on 13 RCTs for young women, and 3 on 2 RCT for
boys (maximum follow-up period: three-four years). We found a borderline protective
effect of HPV catch-up vaccination on all CIN2+, with a pooled risk ratio (RR) of 0.80
(95% CI: 0.62-1.02) for a follow-up period of 4 years. HPV catch-up vaccination was
associated with a reduction in VIN2+ and VaIN2+ lesions, and genital warts. No difference in risk of serious adverse events was seen in vaccinated participants versus
unvaccinated women (pooled RR of 0.99 (0.91-1.08)). We are currently reviewing the
studies on boys. From a public health budget perspective, catch-up vaccination led
to higher costs and health gains and an ICER= 70371€ . From a societal perspective,
the incremental costs were lower, resulting in an ICER= 67365€. Conclusions: This
systematic review indicates that a HPV catch-up vaccination could be beneficial and
cost-effective for young women. The long-term effect of such a vaccination, and its
effect on cancer incidence and mortality is still unclear.
PCN129
Cost-Effectiveness of Radical Prostatectomy, Radiation Therapy
and Active Surveillance for the Treatment of Localized Prostate
Cancer – A Claims Data Analysis
Brandes A 1, Koerber F 1, Schwarzkopf L 1, Hunger M 1, Waidelich R 2, Rogowski W 1
1Helmholtz Zentrum München, Neuherberg, Germany, 2University of Munich, Munich, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
A637
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: Standard treatment for localized prostate cancer is radical prostatectomy (PE) or radiation therapy (RT) which frequently cause erectile dysfunction
(ED) and incontinence (IC). As tumor progression often is slow, active surveillance (AS) has been proposed as an alternative treatment strategy. This study
compares the cost-effectiveness of the three treatment strategies in a German
context. Methods: Based on claims data of a German sickness fund we analyzed men diagnosed with prostate cancer (ICD-10 code C61) in 2008. Life years
gained and complication rates of ED and IC as well as costs of inpatient and
outpatient treatment, pharmaceuticals, physical therapy, medical aids and copayments were tracked for 2.5 years after the initial treatment. An excess-cost
analysis was applied. Strategies were compared in an age-matched and comorbidity-adjusted approach. Results: The baseline study sample included 25,376
individuals. Exclusion of metastases, other cancer diagnoses and treatment strategies resulted in 910 men with PE, 292 with RT and 124 with AS. After matching
107 men remained in the AS group and 214 each in the PE and RT groups with
a mean age of 70 years. Risk of long-term ED (PE: 0.112, RT: 0.009, AS: 0.056)
and IC (PE: 0.313, RT: 0.009, AS: 0.084) was highest in the PE group. Compared to
RT and AS, PE was associated with more life years gained during the cause of the
study. Due to high inpatient costs of the initial surgery PE had ca. € 11,000 higher
total per capita costs than RT and AS. Conclusions: The analysis indicates that
PE is associated with better prognosis and higher overall costs compared to RT
and AS. 2.5 years follow-up might, however, not be enough to detect prostate
cancer-specific deaths.
PCN130
Critical Review of Cost-Effectiveness Analyses (CEA) of Prevention
Strategies Against Diseases Associated with Human Papillomavirus
(HPV) Infection
Gervais F 1, Jiang Y 1, Largeron N 2, Nikoglou T 2
1Amaris, London, UK, 2Sanofi Pasteur MSD, Lyon, France
.
.
.
.
Objectives: It is estimated that almost all cervical cancers are associated with
HPV infection. In most industrialised countries, cervical screening and vaccination with a bivalent or quadrivalent vaccine are recommended to prevent the
disease. The current study aimed to critically review the results of CEAs that have
assessed the trade-off between screening and vaccination. Methods: A systematic literature review was conducted in order to explore the cost-effectiveness
of HPV vaccination strategies with or without different screening strategies
within the geographical context of Western Europe, North America and Australia.
Modelling approach, disease considered, vaccination/screening settings and
costs were compared. Results: A total of 1,188 citations were identified and
20 studies were included in the review. Heterogeneity was seen across studies
in terms of modelling approach, disease and prevention strategies considered.
Inclusion of more HPV-related diseases significantly improves cost-effectiveness.
The strategies combining screening and vaccination were found to be cost-effective when compared to vaccination or screening alone. In terms of screening
strategy, HPV DNA testing with cytological triage showed a trend to be the optimal strategy in vaccinated girls. However the gain in benefits reduced as the
interval between screenings is reduced. Delaying the starting age of screening
could be cost saving, with a limited increase in risk of cancer. An increasing vaccine valence seemed to counterbalance the detrimental effect of delayed/less
frequent screening while the total costs of cervical disease prevention/treatment
may be maintained or decreased. Lastly, vaccine price seemed to affect the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio proportionally. Conclusions: Despite heterogeneity in methodology across studies, similar trend of cost-effectiveness of
competing prevention strategies was witnessed. In light of the trial results of the
new nonavalent HPV vaccine, which provides protection against five additional
types of the virus, the optimal prevention strategy needs to be reassessed within
local context.
PCN131
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Fulvestrant in the Treatment of
Metastatic Breast Cancer in Second-Line Chemotherapy
Krysanov I 1, Krysanova V 2
1Postgraduate Medical Institute, Moscow National University of Food Production, Moscow, Russia,
2I. M. Sechenov First Moscow State Medical University, Moscow, Russia
.
.
Objectives: To conduct a pharmacoeconomic evaluation of the application of fulvestrant compared with docetaxel and paclitaxel in the treatment of metastatic
breast cancer in second-line chemotherapy. Methods: Literature review of clinical
effectiveness and safety of use of fulvestrant was conducted. Assess of the quality
of research and level of evidence obtained in these results was performed. Direct
medical costs consisted of the cost of the drug, the cost of patient management and
correction of side effects. Duration of therapy, its effectiveness and side effects were
obtained from relevant studies on clinical effectiveness (CONFIRM 2013, S. Jones et
al. 2005). The cost of certain hematologic side effects have been taken from the study
Belousov DU et al, 2012. To estimate the duration of hospital stay in the development
of not hematological side effects, conducted a survey of experts. After calculating
the total medical costs on compared regimens was conducted cost - effectiveness
analysis with the calculation of CER. ResultsAccording to studies CONFIRM, 2013
and S. Jones et al. 2005., in patients taking fulvestrant PFS and OS were to 6.5 and
26.4 months, docetaxel - 5,7 and 15.4 months, paclitaxel - 3,6 and 12.7 months. The
total cost of treatment were maximal for the docetaxel - 17685 USD, significantly
lower for fulvestrant - 11803 USD and the minimal for paclitaxel - 7205 USD Costeffectiveness analysis showed that in spite of the average cost of treatment, taking
into account its effectiveness in PFS and OS, the best CER was shown for fulvestrant, followed by paclitaxel and docetaxel. The sensitivity analysis showed that
the simulation results are resistant to increase of the prices for fulvestrant i up to
12%. Conclusions: The use of fulvestrant for the treatment of metastatic breast
cancer in second-line chemotherapy is more cost effective than the appointment
of docetaxel and paclitaxel.
PCN132
Cost-Effectiveness Evaluation of Brentuximab Vedotin for
Refractory/Relapsed Hodgkin Lymphoma: A Comparative Analysis of
the Results of Mexico and Venezuela
Meza-Torres B 1, Gay J G 1, Jakouloff D E 2
1Ti Salud, Mexico City, Mexico, 2Takeda Pharmaceuticals, Zurich, Switzerland
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Brentuximab vedotin is an orphan drug currently indicated for treatment of patients with refractory/relapsed hodgkin lymphoma CD30+ following
prior Auto Stem Cell Transplant (ASCT) or following two prior chemotherapy regimens. This is a group of patients with a reported median survival of 12 months,
with no defined standard of care and for whom clinical trials are single armed
due to lack of appropriate comparators and scarcity of patients. Hence, an indirect
comparison was performed to determine the cost-effectiveness of brentuximab
vedotin in different countries. Methods: A three state Markov model was developed. Effectiveness of brentuximab vedotin was obtained from the clinical trial of
Gopal 2012. Effectiveness for the control group was obtained from 3 clinical trials
evaluating survival of post-ASCT patients where data was disaggregated based on
the patients´ response to prior ASCT/chemotherapy. The assumption was that only
patients with ASCT/chemotherapy failure would serve as controls. The treatments
received by the control group were based on the review of Martinez 2013, where
64% received chemotherapy, 29% AlloSCT and 8% AutoSCT. Simulations were run for
the Mexican and Venezuelan contexts. Direct medical costs were obtained from the
local public sectors and WHO-CHOICE. Results: For the base case scenario of both
countries the ICERs (USD/LYG) were respectively $38,614.34 (Mex) and $57,854.07
(Ven), which compares favorably against accepted ICERs in the orphan drugs field.
In the univariate sensitivity analysis the model was mainly sensitive to the costs
of brentuximab, AutoSCT and AlloSCT. Conclusions: Brentuximab vedotin is a
cost-effective alternative for both countries, especially in the space of orphan drugs.
The low costs of AutoSCT and AlloSCT in Venezuela relative to its GDP were what
mainly accounted for higher ICERs. Differences in chemotherapy usage and costs
did not alter the model. As a limitation, local epidemiology was not accounted for
due to lack of data.
PCN133
Economic Evaluetion of Fulvestrant 500 MG (F500) Versus Original
Nonsteroidal Aromatase Inhibitors in Patient with Advanced
Breast Canser in Russia (2 LINE THERAPY)
Krysanov I 1, Tyapkina M 2
Medical Institute, Moscow National University of Food Production, Moscow, Russia,
21st Moscow State Medical University named after I.M. Sechenov, Moscow, Russia
.
.
1Postgraduate
Objectives: to perform cost-effectiveness analysis fulvestrant 500mg (F500)
for the treatment of first progression or recurrence of advanced breast cancer
in postmenopausal patients compared with anastrozole 1mg (ANAS1), letrozole
2.5mg (LET2,5), exemestane 25mg (EXE25) and exemestane 25mg+everolimus
10mg (EXE25+EVE10). Methods: the data on efficacy and safety of 2-line hormonal therapy of breast cancer were derived from a network meta-analysis and
clinical data publication for overall survival (OS), progression free survival (PFS)
and serious adverse events (SAE). We considered the direct costs on second and
third line hormonal therapy and resource utilization. Data on resource usage,
were based on expert opinion and open sources. 1-way sensitivity analyses were
conducted. Results: in terms of OS F500 (mean 23.33 month) was as effective as
ANAS1 (22.12) and more effective than LET2.5 (17.44) and EXE25 (18.31). The highest incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) estimated for F500 versus ANAS1
was 84,592 USD per year with incremental effectiveness 1.21 month. The lowest
ICER estimated for F500 versus LET2.5 was 22,873 USD per year with incremental effectiveness 5.90 month. The ICER for F500 versus EXE25 was 25,890 USD
per year. In terms of PFS EXE25+EVE10 was more effective and costly, than F500.
The CER for F500 was 1,714 USD per year versus 4,215 USD for EXE25+EVE10.
A series of one-way sensitivity analyses showed this result is robust to variations
in costs of drugs, physician examination, and variation in costs associated with
SAE. Conclusions: the use of F500 is more effective than LET2.5 and EXE25, and
at least as efficacious as ANAS1 in terms of OS among postmenopausal women
with advanced breast cancer after failure on 1-line endocrine therapy. In terms of
PFS F500 less efficacious than EXE25+EVE10, however substantially cheaper. From
perspective of federal health care system, the cost of LYG for F500 is less than the
willingness to pay threshold.
PCN134
Will Governments be Able to Afford a Cancer Cure Under Current
Health Economic Evaluation Methods?
Jamali E 1, Focsa S 2
1PAREXEL, Sommerville, NJ, USA, 2PAREXEL, London, UK
.
.
Objectives: Cancer accounts for around 1.3 million deaths and € 50 billion in
health care expenditure in the European Union. Balancing increasing treatment
costs and prevalence will be increasingly difficult for governments to manage.
Advances in immunotherapies provide hope for a cancer cure; however its cost
might be out of reach for governments under current health economic evaluation methods which will be the aim of this research. Methods: The years of
life lost (YLL) in the UK due to cancer were obtained from the Institute of Health
Metrics and Evaluation (IHME) database and multiplied by the NICE cost effectiveness threshold of £20,000 per Quality Added life Year (QALY), this gave a first
estimate of the potential cost of a cancer cure that would be within an
acceptable cost effectiveness threshold. This cost was then modified to take into
account the quality of life (QoL) of the general population, QALY discounting,
cancer onset age, and other demographics. YLL due to disability in cancer were
not included in the calculation. Results: It is estimated that 32.4% of the total
YLL per year in the UK (5,615,310) are a consequence of cancer. The cost of saving these YYL at £20,000 per QALY was estimated to be around £12 billion for all
cancers per year, meaning an extra £425 in taxes would have to be generated
A638
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
from each taxpayer. Conclusions: A cancer cure evaluated under current health
economic evaluation methods would cause a budget impact that would be
unaffordable for governments due to the high prices that could be achieved
while remaining cost effective. Although these types of technologies therapies
are not currently available, payers might want to explore new methods of evaluation, as exploring the possibility of calculating costs based on quality adjusted
lifetimes rather than years or increasing discount rates on QALYs for immunotherapies.
PCN135
Economic Impact of the Inclusion of Pertuzumab for the Treatment
of Metastatic Breast Cancer HER2 +
Nazco G 1, Gutierrez F 1, Bullejos M 1, Viña M 2, Gonzalez I 1, Valcarcel C 3
1University Hospital of Canary Islands, La Laguna, Spain, 2University Hospital of Nuestra Señora
de la Candelaria, Santa Cruz de Tenerife, Spain, 3Canary Islands Foundation for Health and
Research, Santa Cruz de Tenerife, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To analyze the economic impact of the incorporation of pertuzumab
for the treatment of metastatic breast cancer HER2+ in a University Hospital according to real data of our patients. Methods: Cross-sectional study where the patients
with breast cancer were analyzed in our hospital during one year (April 2013 to
April 2014). The demographic data of the patients (age and weight) and antineoplastic treatments used were obtained from the computer program Hospiwin®.
The dose and efficacy data have been obtained from the phase III CLEOPATRA trial.
This clinical trial compares docetaxel + trastuzumab vs docetaxel + trastuzumab +
pertuzumab with progression-free survival (PFS) 12.4 (CI 10.4-13.5) vs. 18.5 (CI 16.621.6) months respectively. Costs of the drugs were included in the economic model
developed in Excel® data base. The time horizon was one year and the perspective
of medical leadership of the hospital was used. Results: During the study period
371 patients were treated for breast cancer and 75 patients (20.2 %) were HER2+. The
mean weight of 71.5 kg (SD = 17.1) and men BMI of 29.3 were obtained. The annual
cost of docetaxel + trastuzumab + pertuzumab was 69,245.32 € vs 29,837.4 € (CI (in
the docetaxel + trastuzumab treatment group. The cost per PFS per year was 44,964
€ (CI 38,469-50,177 € ) in the docetaxel + trastuzumab + pertuzumab group vs 29,837
(CI 26,640-35,948 € ) in the docetaxel + trastuzumab treatment group. The incremental cost effectiveness ratio (ICER) was 15.127 € /PFS per year. Conclusions: The
addition of pertuzumab to treatment with docetaxel / trastuzumab for metastatic
breast cancer has shown an increase in SLP. However, the economic impact of this
new drug, requires careful selection of patients who could benefit. Health authorities will have to consider whether pertuzumab is cost-effective in terms of their
willgness to pay.
PCN136
Cost Effectiveness of Sunitinib as First-Line Targeted Therapy for
Metastatic Renal Cell Carcinoma in China
Shi Q 1, Yin H 2, Xuan J 3, Wu Y 4, Cheng G 5
1Pfizer China, Shanghai, China, 2Philadelphia College of Osteopathic Medicine-Georgia Campus,
Suwanee, GA, USA, 3Fudan University, School of Public Health, Shanghai, China, 4Foshan food
and drug inspection testing center, Foshan City, China, 5Jinan University, Guangzhou, China
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Multitargeted receptor tyrosine kinase inhibitors are more effective alternatives to interferon-α and monoclonal antibodies in patients with
metastatic renal cell carcinoma (mRCC). However, studies on the economic and
humanistic outcomes associated with these treatments are sparse in the Chinese
setting. This study evaluated the clinical and economic consequences of sunitinib
compared with sorafenib and interferon-α from the third-party payer’s perspective
in China. Methods: A Markov model was developed to simulate disease progression and determine cost and outcomes over patient’s lifetime. The time horizon
of analysis was patients’ lifetime with a maximum of five years in cycles of six
weeks. The model was used to conduct a cost-utility analysis on sunitinib compared
to interferon-α and sorafinib. Costs of physician, anti-cancer medications, hospitalization, laboratory, and palliative care were estimated. Outcomes were measured in progression-free life years (PFLYs), life years (LYs) and quality-adjusted life
years (QALYs). A 3.5% discount rate was applied to both costs and QALYs gained.
Results: In the base case, the total cost of the sunitinib arm was RMB217,038.50,
the progression-free life year was 1.57, life year was 2.55, and QALY was 1.70. The
incremental cost per PFLY between sunitnib and IFN-α was –RMB78,562.10 and
RMB 22,501.03 between sunitinib and sorafenib. The incremental cost per life year
between sunitnib and IFN-α was –RMB168,633.00 and RMB 21,022.38 between sunitinib and sorafenib. The incremental cost per QALY between sunitnib and IFN-α was –
RMB184,825.00 and RMB 29,493.42 between sunitinib and sorafenib. Conclusions:
This economic study used the final clinical results of the pivotal sunitinib trial that
provides more accurate modeling results than previous studies based on extrapolation. It was found that sunitinib was dominant compared to IFN-α . Sunitinib was
cost effective compared to sorafenib based on the threshold recommended by the
World Health Organization.
PCN137
An Evidence-Based Model Design to Inform the Cost-Effectiveness
Evaluation of Primary Endocrine Therapy And Surgery for Older
Women with Primary Breast Cancer
Mousa R 1, Chen L C 1, Cheung K L 2
of Nottingham, Nottingham, UK, 2University of Nottingham, Derby, UK
.
.
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: Despite the lack of evidence-based information on their clinical and
cost-effectiveness, surgery and primary endocrine therapy (PET) are the most
commonly used initial treatment strategies for older women with primary breast
cancer in the United Kingdom (UK). To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of PET and
surgery, a decision analytical modelling is necessary. This systematic review aimed
to summarise the modelling methodologies from the literature to inform the
model design in older women. Methods: An electronic database search was
conducted using NHS Economic Evaluation Database, Cochrane Library, Ovid
Medline, PubMed, and EMBASE to identify full economic evaluations that compared different treatment strategies in postmenopausal women with primary
breast cancer. Quality and modelling methodologies of included studies were
assessed and summarised. Results: All the 31 included studies assessed surgery
and none assessed PET as the initial treatment. Most included economic studies used a Markov model with life-time horizon and 1-year cycle length. Nine
studies which included sub-group analysis for older women (over 65 years old)
used similar economic models and transition states with younger women (50
to 65 years old). The key disease-related health states were disease-free, recurrence, and death. Recurrence was mostly separated into loco-regional and distant
recurrence. Conclusions: This systematic review can inform the design of an
economic model comparing PET with surgery as initial treatment in older women
based on the following assumptions: (1) health states are applicable across age
groups; (2) transition states for modelling surgery in the literature are transferable
to model the same treatment for older women; (3) metastasis transition states
including progression, progression-free, and death can be used to model the PET
pathway. Future study will validate this model by using a longitudinal dataset of
older women with primary breast cancer, and synthesize data from different data
sources to populate this economic model.
PCN138
Cost Effectiveness of Cetuximab in 1st-Line Treatment of RAS WildType Metastatic Colorectal Cancer in Scotland: A Summary of the
Submission to the Scottish Medicines Consortium
Jarrett J 1, Ovcinnikova O 1, Hnoosh A 2, Harty G 2, Byrne B 3, von Hohnhorst P 4
Serono Ltd., UK, UK, 3Merck Serono Ltd., FELTHAM, UK, 4Merck
Serono, Darmstadt, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
1MAPI, London, UK, 2Merck
Objectives: Colorectal cancer is the third most common cancer in Scotland, with
nearly 4,000 cases reported in 2011 and 5.2% increase in incidence in the previous
10 years. Recent studies have shown that a subgroup of metastatic colorectal cancer
(mCRC) patients with wild-type (wt) RAS (KRAS and NRAS exons 2,3, 4) expressing
tumours are likely to have enhanced response to anti-EGFR treatment compared
to patients with mutant RAS exons (2,3, 4). RAS biomarkers aid identification of the
patient group that is likely to benefit the most from anti-EGFR treatment such as
cetuximab and therefore allow more efficient use of NHS Scotland resources. A New
Product Assessment Form was submitted to the Scottish Medicines Consortium with
the aim of demonstrating the latest improved outcomes in RAS wt mCRC patients
(versus KRAS wt) treated with cetuximab in combination with chemotherapy and
its cost effectiveness compared to currently available treatments. Methods:
A state-transition Markov cohort model was developed to simulate patient outcomes
and costs for first and subsequent lines of treatment including the long-term survival after a successful curative resection of liver metastases. Results: The model
estimated an incremental 0.28 life-years gained (LYG) with cetuximab + FOLFIRI
compared to FOLFIRI alone and an incremental 0.32 LYG with cetuximab + FOLFOX
compared to FOLFOX alone. The model was most sensitive to length of treatment
with cetuximab. Conclusions: The incremental cost effectiveness ratios imputed
in the model are close to the traditional willingness to pay threshold adopted by
the SMC. This analysis demonstrates that cetuximab in combination with FOLFIRI
or FOLFOX in mCRC RAS wt patients is a cost-effective treatment compared with
chemotherapy alone, specifically when taking into consideration that cetuximab
qualifies as an end of life medicine (following SMC criteria) which raises the value
of such intervention.
PCN140
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Bevacizumab, Fotemustine
and Extended-Dose Temozolomide in Patients with Recurrent
Glioblastoma in Spain
Garcia Lopez J L 1, Rodriguez Barrios J M 2, Puig-Junoy J 2, Carrato Mena A 1
Cajal University Hospital, Alcala University, Madrid, Spain, 2Pompeu Fabra University,
Barcelona, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Ramon Y
The treatment of glioblastoma after first-line treatment progression is not clearly
established in Spain. Most accepted alternatives are nitrosoureas (fotemustine, F),
extended-dose temozolomide (eT) or bevacizumab (B). Without clear standards of
care, increased clinical and health policy uncertainty among decision makers should
be clarified. So, economic evaluation might reduce those uncertainties. Objectives:
To analyze the cost-effectiveness of bevacizumab, extended-dose temozolomide
and fotemustine in patients with either recurrent or progressive glioblastoma after
standard therapy, compared to standard clinical practice (SCP). Methods: A costeffectiveness markov model was conducted from a payer perspective (time horizon
1 year, 3%, discount rate, 2012, € ). Our model got three health states: alive without
progression, alive with toxicity and progression as absorbing state. We subsequently
performed a deterministic and probabilistic analysis of sensitivity. Main efficacy
outcome was progression-free survival at six months (6m PFS). Toxicity data was
based on relevant phase II studies. Health state utility values were estimated based
on published values from an HTA report by Garside et al, 2007. Costs were obtained
from a Spanish University Hospital. Results: Cost/effectiveness ratios were: SCP
(based on carmustine) 2,368.45 € /year to obtain 6m PFS with stable health state
utility value, F 4,112.97 € /year, B 15,122.49 € /year and eT 5,470.05 € /year. Incremental
cost-effectiveness ratios were: F 7,404.12 €/year € /year to obtain 6m PFS with stable
health state utility value, B 40,371.8 €/year and eT 45,853.51 €/year. Tornado diagram
and CEAC showed our results robustness. Conclusions: ICER analysis shows fotemustine to be the dominant option in the treatment of patients with recurrent or
progressive glioblastoma.
PCN141
Pharmacoeconomic Analysis of Axitinib as Second-Line Treatment
for Metastatic Renal Cell Carcinoma
Kulikov A , Komarov I
First Moscow State Medical University named after I. M. Sechenov, Moscow, Russia,
.
.
A639
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: To identify the dominant scheme of mRCC second-line target treatment (compare two alternatives – Axitinib and Everolimus). Methods: Based on
the Markov model, the cost-effectiveness analysis was realized. Overall survival,
annual survival rate, time to progression of disease and direct cost of mRCC treatment was evaluated. Costs analysis included: costs of two target therapy lines
(Sunitinib as a first-line in combination with Axitinib or Everolimus treatment); cost
of 3 and 4 grade side effects compensation; cost of diagnosis and inpatient care; cost
of disease progression; cost of palliative and best supportive care. Results: During
the pharmacoeconomic analysis of Axitinib use as a second-line therapy for mRCC,
it was found that this target therapy regimen would significantly increase the time
to progression and the overall survival which amounted to 22,75 months, with an
annual survival rate of 68%, 38% and 17% of patients following the first, second and
third year of treatment, respectively. Despite the high cost of this treatment regimen,
reaching 51.327 EUR at the horizon of ten year study, the treatment regimen including Axitinib will be characterized by the lowest values of the cost-effectiveness
ratio, reflecting the costs incurred by the health care system for patient’s life saving, and incremental cost-effectiveness ratio, which was less than willingness to
pay threshold in Russia. Conclusions: It is shown, Axitinib use as second-line
of target therapy in patients with mRCC is the most preferable treatment regimen
then Everolimus from the pharmacoeconomic point of view.
PCN142
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Hydralazine and Magnesium
Valproate LP Associated With Treatment for Adult Patients with
Metastatic Recurrent or Persistent Cervical Cancer in Mexico
Soto H 1, Sanchez K 2, Escobar Juárez Y 2, Constanzo A 2, Fernandez Z 3, Melendez C 3
1Iteliness Consulting, Mexico City, Mexico, 2HS Estudios Farmacoeconómicos, Mexico City, Mexico,
3Psicofarma S.A. de C.V., Mexico City, Mexico
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Demonstrate through an economic evaluation of cost-effectiveness
that using Hydralazine LP magnesium valproate (Transkrip ®) associated with
first-line chemotherapy in the treatment of persistent or recurrent metastatic
stage IVB cervical cancer, type not candidates for surgery or radiotherapy is more
effective than the alternatives available in Mexican health institutions: cisplatin
with topotecan (CT), cisplatin with paclitaxel (CP), cisplatin with vinorelbine (CV),
carboplatin with paclitaxel (CaP), paclitaxel (P), cisplatin and cisplatin with gemcitabine © (CG). Methods: A cost-effectiveness analysis was developed, using
a Markov model with a time horizon of 2 years divided into 24 monthly cycles,
the measure of effectiveness was determined as the years gained free survival
(PFS), being an advanced cancer is significant, only were measured direct medical costs, an analysis of incremental cost-effectiveness was performed. To test
the robustness of the model a deterministic and probabilistic sensitivity analysis
was performed. Results: The cost per patient using therapy with hydralazine LP
magnesium valproate (Transkrip ®) is $ 142,109.93, gaining 0.8846 years in
Progression free survival this treatment was more effective but more expensive,
paclitaxel had a cost of $ 26,988.64 with 0.3631 years in PFS, this therapy is less
expensive but more effective than all comparators. The ICER of (Transkrip ®) was
$ 220.757 pesos per year in PFS versus paclitaxel. Conclusions: The economic
results of treatment of patients with metastatic cervical cancer, through an epigenetic therapy with hydralazine LP magnesium valproate (Transkrip ®) over a time
horizon of two years showed that hydralazine LP magnesium valproate (Transkrip
®) is a cost effective alternative respect to comparators showed a greater response
in years of progression-free survival and ICER below of 2 GDP.
PCN143
Prioritization of Future Outcomes Research Studies in Chronic
Myeloid Leukemia: Value of Information Analysis
Rochau U 1, Kühne F 2, Jahn B 2, Kurzthaler C 2, Corro Ramos I 3, Chhatwal J 4, Stollenwerk B 5,
Goldhaber-Fiebert J D 6, Siebert U 7
1UMIT - University for Health Sciences, Medical Informatics and Technology/ ONCOTYROL Center for Personalized Cancer Medicine, Hall in Tyrol/ Innsbruck, Austria, 2UMIT - University
for Health Sciences, Medical Informatics and Technology, Hall in Tyrol, Austria, 3Erasmus
University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 4MD Anderson Cancer Center, Houston,
TX, USA, 5Helmholtz Center Munich, Neuherberg, Germany, 6Western University, London, WA,
USA, 7Medical Informatics and Technology, and Director of the Division for Health Technology
Assessment and Bioinformatics, ONCOTYROL, Hall i. T, Austria
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Value-of-Information analysis can help to guide decision about future
research priorities: If and what further research is needed? Our aim was to guide
decision regarding future outcomes research on parameters related to different
regimens for chronic myeloid leukemia (CML). Methods: We updated a previously
developed state-transition Markov model of CML, which evaluates seven treatment
regimens including tyrosine kinase inhibitors, chemotherapy and stem cell transplantation (SCT). We derived model parameters from published trials data, Austrian
clinical, epidemiological, and economic data. We performed a cohort simulation over
a lifetime horizon, adopted a societal perspective, and discounted costs and benefits
at 3% annually. We calculated the expected value of perfect information (EVPI),
partial perfect information (EVPPI), and the population EVPI (PEVPI). Additionally,
we examined the expected value of sample information (EVSI) for different trial
sizes. Results: Three strategies are on the efficiency frontier: imatinibàchemotherapy/SCT, nilotinibàchemotherapy/SCT (140,000 € /QALY) and nilotinibàdasatinibàchemotherapy/SCT (176,000 € /QALY). The EVPI for eliminating all uncertainty
resulted in a curve with two peaks. One peak is around a WTP threshold of 150,000
€/QALY (EVPI 4,600 € ) and another peak is at 180,000 € /QALY (EVPI 7,700 € ). The PEVPI
for Austria assuming a 10-year technology horizon was 2.5 million € (WTP 150,000
€ /QALY) and 4.5 million € (WTP 180,000 € /QALY). EVPPI identified four parameters
most responsible for decision uncertainty: duration of first-line therapy, probability
of progressing from chronic phase to accelerated phase, probability of receiving a
SCT, and the health-utility after SCT. The EVSI commented on the optimal study
size for these parameters given the cost of obtaining information. Conclusions:
Acquiring additional evidence could prove valuable for determining optimal treat-
ment regimens for chronic myeloid leukemia. If further research were funded, studies should examine a combination of natural history, treatment, and quality of life
parameters, especially the effectiveness of first-line TKI treatment.
PCN144
Decision Analysis on the Cost-Effectiveness of Sequential
Treatment Strategies for Patients with Chronic Myeloid Leukemia
in the United States
Rochau U 1, Kluibenschaedl M 1, Stenehjem D 2, Kuo K L 2, Oderda G 2, Brixner D 3, Siebert U 4
- University for Health Sciences, Medical Informatics and Technology/ ONCOTYROL
- Center for Personalized Cancer Medicine, Hall in Tyrol/ Innsbruck, Austria, 2University of
Utah, Salt Lake City, UT, USA, 3UMIT - University for Health Sciences, Medical Informatics and
Technology/ ONCOTYROL - Center for Personalized Cancer Medicine/ University of Utah, Hall
in Tyrol/ Salt Lake City, UT, Austria, 4Medical Informatics and Technology, and Director of the
Division for Health Technology Assessment and Bioinformatics, ONCOTYROL, Hall i. T, Austria
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1UMIT
Objectives: The first goal was to adapt an existing Austrian decision-analytic
model for chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) treatment to the US-American health
care context. Secondly, we updated the model with new data and further treatment strategies to identify the most effective and most cost-effective strategy for
the treatment of CML patients with different sequential tyrosine kinase inhibitors (TKIs). Methods: We evaluated 18 different treatment strategies within the
US-American setting in terms of survival, quality-adjusted survival and costs. For
model parameters, data from literature, a US-American expert survey, the Utah
Cancer Registry, and economic data from a US-American database were used.
Evaluated treatment strategies included imatinib, dasatinib, nilotinib, bosutinib,
ponatinib, stem-cell transplantation and chemotherapy. The Markov state-transition model was analyzed as a cohort simulation over a lifelong time horizon,
a third-party payer perspective was adopted and a discount rate of 3% was used.
Additionally, several deterministic and probabilistic sensitivity analyses were conducted. Results: Imatinib without second-line TKI resulted in an incremental
cost-utility ratio (ICUR) of $148,700/QALY gained (incremental cost-effectiveness
ratio (ICER) of $128,800/Lys) compared to baseline strategy ‘chemotherapy’. Imatinib
with second-line nilotinib yielded an ICUR of $217,100/QALY gained (ICER $242,200/
LY) compared to imatinib without second-line TKI. Imatinib followed by secondline bosutinib had an ICUR of $331,300/QALY gained (ICER $265,100/LY) compared
to imatinib followed by second-line nilotinib. Imatinib with second-line dasatinib
produced an ICUR of $343,200/QALY gained (ICER $279,600/LY) compared to imatinib
with second-line bosutinib. All remaining strategies were excluded due to dominance. ICURs and ICERs obtained from the probabilistic sensitivity analysis deviated
up to 6.5% (2.5%) compared to base-case ICURs (ICERs). Conclusions: Based on
our analysis and current treatment guidelines, we recommend imatinib followed
by second-line nilotinib as the most cost-effective treatment strategy. Our model
results may support clinicians and patients in CML treatment decision making.
PCN145
The Cost-Effectiveness of Brentuximab Vedotin in Hodgkin
Lymphoma in Sweden
Engstrom A
Takeda Pharma Sweden, Solna, Sweden
.
Objectives: To assess the cost-effectiveness of using brentuximab vedotin (BV) in
treating relapsed or refractory Hodgkin Lymphoma compared to standard chemotherapy and allogeneic stem cell transplant in the Swedish health care setting.
Brentuximab vedotin is a novel antibody drug conjugate targeting CD-30 and is
indicated for treating relapsed/refractory Hodgkin Lymphoma. Methods: A Markov
model with a lifetime horizon was constructed to compare BV to chemotherapy or
allogeneic stemcell transplant (alloSCT). The analysis had a societal perspective
and included lost productivity using a human capital approach. The model uses
comparators relevant to Sweden and all epidemiological and cost parameters were
based on Swedish sources. Both costs and effects were discounted at 3% according
to Swedish guidelines. Clinical effectiveness for BV was based on pivotal clinical
trial results and published data from the literature for the comparators relevant to
the reimbursement authorities and to enable long term modelling. Outcomes were
measured in QALYs. Uncertainty was addressed both through probabilistic sensitivity analysis and one-way analyses of central variables. Results: Brentuximab
vedotin dominated alloSCT (i. e a lower treatment cost and a better health outcome)
and the ICER when compared to chemotherapy was SEK 419 000 (€ 47 000). One-way
sensitivity analyses showed that the results were stable when central variables
were varied. The probabilistic analysis also showed that brentuximab vedotin had
a high probability of being the most cost-effective treatment at the accepted threshold values for all scenarios. Conclusions: The ICERs calculated were all below
commonly accepted willingness to pay for a QALY in Sweden for both comparator
scenarios. Brentuximab vedotin is a cost effective treatment option for relapsed/
refractory Hodgkin Lymphoma in the Swedish health care setting.
PCN146
Economic Evaluation of Axitinib for Second Line Treatment in Adult
Patients with Advanced Renal Cell Carcinoma – the Portuguese
Case
Miguel L S 1, Luz R 2
- ISEG/UL, Lisboa, Portugal, 2Centro Hospitalar Lisboa Central, Lisboa, Portugal
.
.
.
1CISEP
Objectives: This study estimated the cost-utility of axitinib after sunitinib failure
in adult patients with renal cell carcinoma. Total costs and quality adjusted life
years accrued with axitinib was compared to everolimus, the only drug for second
line treatment financed by the Portuguese National Health Service. Methods:
A 4-week cycle Markov model with three health states (progression free, post
progression, and death) was adapted to the Portuguese setting. In the absence of
head-to-head clinical trials and the unfeasibility of a standard indirect comparison,
relative efficacy was based on a previous simulated treatment comparison. Axitinib
trial data on quality of life (utility) was used for the progression free stage and
A640
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
assumed equal for everolimus, while utilities for the post progression stages were
obtained from the literature. Resource use was determined by a panel of five experienced experts to reflect Portuguese clinical practice. Official unit costs were used,
following the Portuguese National Health Service perspective. The model adopted
a lifetime frame (15 years) with a 5%discount rate. Results: Axitinib allowed an
increment of 0.20 years of progression free survival, 0.53 years of overall survival,
and 0.32 quality adjusted life years compared to everolimus. Despite having a similar
daily cost, the use of axitinib implied an incremental cost of 9,100€ , mainly due to
the increase in progression free survival, that matches second line treatment duration. Consequently the cost per quality adjusted life year was 28,598€ . Sensitivity
analyses showed that results were robust to model parameters specification,
with the main uncertainty source being clinical efficacy. Conclusions: Axitinib
increased progression free and overall survival, which allowed patients to benefit
from more quality adjusted life years at a cost increase. Overall, it was possible to
advocate that axitinib is cost-effective, as the cost per QALY is below commonly
accepted thresholds.
PCN147
Economic Evaluation of Paclitaxel Albumin, Paclitaxel, and
Docetaxel as a Second Line Treatment for Metastatic Breast
Cancer
Gharaibeh M , Malone D C
University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ, USA
.
.
.
Objectives: Clinical studies have shown that docetaxel to be superior to paclitaxel
in overall survival (OS) and progression free survival (PFS) (median OS: 1.28 vs 1.06
year; median PFS: 0.47 vs 0.30 year) for the treatment of patients with metastatic
breast cancer progressing after an anthracycline-based regimen. Other studies
have shown paclitaxel-albumin extended OS by 9.7 weeks, and TTP by 4 weeks. An
economic evaluation based on these two clinical trials was performed to compare
paclitaxel albumin, paclitaxel, and docetaxel as a second line treatment for metastatic breast cancer. Methods: A Markov model was conducted using three health
states: PFS, progressed, and death to estimate overall survival, cost, life year gain
(LYG) and quality adjusted life year (QALY). Efficacy data for the treatments were
obtained from the published literature. In the absence of head-to-head trials, comparative efficacy and safety of taxanes were estimated using indirect comparisons.
A 3% discount rate for cost and outcomes was used. Cost of chemotherapy, administering, monitoring the disease, loss of productivity, and adverse drug reactions for
patients on treatment were included from the US societal perspective. Results:
Compared to docetaxel, paclitaxel albumin was found to be less expensive ($36,241
vs $73,510) and more effective in term of QALYs (0.782 vs 0.710). The incremental cost
effectiveness ratio (ICER) for paclitaxel albumin compared to paclitaxel was $77,670/
QALY. The probabilistic sensitivity analysis showed that paclitaxel albumin has 70%
probability of being cost effective at $100,000/QALY threshold value. Conclusions:
Paclitaxel-albumin is an attractive treatment option for the treatment of metastatic
breast cancer in patients who have failed 1st-line treatment for metastatic disease.
The primary analysis comparing paclitaxel albumin to docetaxel demonstrated
that paclitaxel albumin dominated docetaxel because it was less costly and more
effective.
PCN148
Cost Effectiveness Analysis of Targeted Intraoperative
Radiotherapy Alone (TARGIT-A) in Early Breast Cancer Patients
Vaidya A 1, Vaidya P 2, Both B 3, Brew-Graves C 4, Vaidya J 4
University, Maastricht, The Netherlands, 2O-Zone HEOR Consultancy, Maastricht, The
Netherlands, 3Carl-Zeiss Meditec AG, Oberkochen, Germany, 4University College London, London,
UK
.
.
.
.
.
1Maastricht
Objectives: Whole-breast external beam radiotherapy (EBRT) is normally given
over 3-6 weeks after lumpectomy in early breast cancer patients to reduce recurrence and mortality. An individualised risk-adapted approach to adjuvant radiotherapy has been tested in the randomised TARGIT-A trial which tested the efficacy of
one dose of radiation to tumour bed during lumpectomy. The objective of the present
study was to assess the cost effectiveness of TARGIT-A in these patients. Methods:
A model based economic evaluation compared single dose TARGIT-A with current
practice of EBRT in UK. A state transition Markov model approach was used to
simulate the treatment outcomes in a time horizon of 20 years post-surgery. The
primary outcome of interest was quality adjusted life years gained (QALY) and
analysis was conducted from the health care payer’s perspective. To address decision uncertainty, probabilistic sensitivity analysis was performed. A discount rate
of 3.5% was applied to future costs and effects. Results: In the Base Case Analysis
TARGIT-A was a dominant strategy yielding higher QALYs at a lower cost than EBRT.
Discounted EBRT and IORT costs for the time horizon of 20 years were £ 20,926 and £
14,461 respectively. Discounted incremental QALY gained by use of IORT was 0.0069.
Model results were robust to parameter uncertainty and probabilistic results were
similar to the deterministic results. Application of the net monetary benefit (NMB)
framework revealed higher NMB for TARGIT-A in all Monte Carlo simulations. Cost
effectiveness acceptability curves show that TARGIT-A is cost effective at various
willingness to pay thresholds. Conclusions: TARGIT-A is a cost effective strategy to treat early breast cancer patients in the UK. Implementation of this one-off
radiation treatment within a risk-adapted approach could improve quality of life
by sparing them from the protracted course of EBRT, improve compliance, prevent
unnecessary mastectomies and save valuable NHS resources.
PCN149
Early Cost-Effectiveness Modeling for Tumor Infiltrating
Lymphocytes (TIL) -Treatment Versus Ipilimumab in Metastatic
Melanoma Patients
Retèl V P 1, Steuten L M G 2, Mewes J C 2, van Harten W H 2
Cancer Institute, Amsterdam, The Netherlands,, 2University of Twente, Enschede,
The Netherlands
.
.
1Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Metastatic melanoma has a poor prognosis with 10 year survival
being < 5%. Standard therapy is the effective but costly Ipilimumab. An emerging
1st line treatment is Tumor Infiltrating Lymphocytes (TIL), with response rates
> 50% and expected survival rates of 25%-42% versus 45% (1yr) and 23,5% (2yr) for
Ipilimumab. TIL is highly personalized, however complex and requests substantial
upfront investments from the hospital in expensive lab-equipment, staff expertise
and training, as well as extremely tight hospital logistics. Therefore, an early health
economic modelling study, supporting a Coverage with Evidence Development (CED)
program, was performed. Methods: We used a Markov decision model to estimate
the expected costs and outcomes (quality adjusted life years; QALYs) for TIL versus Ipilimumab in metastatic melanoma patients from a societal perspective over
a life long time horizon. Three mutually exclusive health states (stable disease,
progressive disease and death) were modelled, divided in first and second line
treatment. Technical failures and non-compliance were incorporated to reflect the
dynamic nature of the technology. To inform further research prioritization, Value
of Information (VOI) analysis was performed. Results: TIL is expected to yield
more QALYs compared to Ipilimumab (0.99 vs 0.52 respectively) at lower total costs
(€ 83,588 vs € 87,834 respectively). Based on current information TIL has a probability
of 88% for being cost effective at a cost/QALY threshold of €30,000. Expected Value of
Perfect Information (EVPI) amounted to € 1,2 million. Partial EVPI (EVPPI) was highest
for survival data (€ 550,000). Expected Value of Sample information was estimated
€ 355,000 for an optimal sample size of n= 50. Conclusions: TIL is expected to
improve QALYs compared to Ipilimumab at lower incremental cost and has the
highest probability of being cost-effective. To reduce decision uncertainty, a future
clinical trial to investigate survival seems most valuable, and should preferably be
undertaken as part of a CED program.
PCN150
A Cost Effectivness Analysis of Everolimus Compared with Axitinib
in the Treatment of Metastatic Renal Cell Carcinoma in the United
Kingdom
Chandiwana D 1, Perrin A 2, Sherman S 2
1Novartis Pharmaceuticals UK Limited, Camberley, UK, 2Analytica LA-SER International, Inc, New
York, NY 10018, NY, USA
.
.
.
Objectives: This study assessed the cost-effectiveness of everolimus versus axitinib for the treatment of advanced metastatic renal cell carcinoma (mRCC) in the
United Kingdom (UK). Methods: A Markov model was developed with three health
states: stable disease, disease progression and death. The model time horizon was
12 years and a UK NHS perspective was considered. There are no head to head studies comparing everolimus with axitinib, thus evidence from a weighted adjusted
indirect analysis based on the RECORD-1 and AXIS trials was used to compare
progression-free survival (PFS) for everolimus versus axitinib. Survival distributions
for PFS were fitted to the post-matched population and fit statistics were generated.
As overall survival (OS) data were not available from the AXIS trial at the time of
the indirect analysis, the model assumed that the OS for axitinib was equivalent
to that of everolimus, based on OS from the RECORD-1 trial. The Weibull survival
distribution was used for both PFS and OS. Quality of life data were derived from
the Swinburn et al. study and drug costs were obtained from the British National
Formulary. Results: Everolimus resulted in a progression-free life expectancy
of 0.60 years compared to 0.57 with axitinib. Everolimus resulted in 0.65 QALYs
compared to 0.63 QALYs for axitinib. Active drug costs were £8,105 for everolimus
and £25,723 for axitinib. Total costs were higher for axitinib (£42,533) compared
to everolimus (£24,387). The cost difference reflects the higher treatment costs
per month and longer treatment duration for axitinib compared to everolimus.
Therefore, the incremental cost of axitinib compared with axitinib was -£18,146,
highlighting that everolimus is less expensive. The incremental cost per QALY
gained was -£1,048,954. Conclusions: This cost-effectiveness analysis demonstrates that everolimus likely dominates axitinib, i.e. it is more effective and less
expensive compared with axitinib in the treatment of mRCC.
PCN151
Cost-Minimization Analysis of Trastuzumab Intravenous Versus
Trastuzumab Subcutaneous for the Treatment of Patients With
HER2+ Early Breast Cancer And Metastatic Breast Cancer in Greece
Mylonas C 1, Kourlaba G 2, Fountzilas G 3, Skroumpelos A 4, Maniadakis N 1
School of Public Health, Athens, Greece, 2Collaborative Center for Clinical Epidemiology
and Outcomes Research (CLEO), Athens, Greece, 3Aristotle University of Thessaloniki School of
Medicine, Thessaloniki, Greece, 4Roche (Hellas) S.A., Athens, Greece
.
.
.
.
.
1National
Objectives: To conduct an economic evaluation comparing Herceptin subcutaneous formulation (Herceptin-SC) with -Herceptin intravenous formulation
(Herceptin-IV), in the treatment of patients with human epidermal growth factor
receptor 2-positive (HER2+) early and metastatic breast cancer (EBC-MBC), in the
Greek health care setting. Methods: A cost-minimization model was developed
to compare the total cost of care, from the hospital perspective, for new and existing
patients, over 18 cycles therapy course. Total cost of therapy reflects drug acquisition
cost, consumables dispensed, hospital overheads, physician and other staff time.
Costing data were obtained from official Government sources (in 2014) and resource
utilization data from a local validation of an international time and motion study.
Due to the short time horizon of the study, costs were not discounted. Results:
The mean total cost of therapy per patient on Herceptin-IV was estimated at
€ 24,163 compared to € 23,042 per patient receiving Herceptin-SC. Drug acquisition
costs accounted for € 22,630 and € 22,579 of total therapy costs for Herceptin-IV and
Herceptin-SC, respectively. Following drug acquisition costs, the administration cost
was € 518 and € 161 for Herceptin-IV and Herceptin-SC, respectively. Moreover, the
central venous access device cost was € 290 and € 0 of the total costs of Herceptin
IV and Herceptin SC, respectively. Finally, overhead costs made up approximately
€ 725 of the total cost for Herceptin-IV and € 302 for Herceptin-SC. Sensitivity analysis showed that the results of the model were sensitive to drug acquisition costs
and patient weight. Conclusions: The cost of treatment with Herceptin-SC is
A641
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
lower than that with Herceptin-IV in the management of patients with HER2+ EBC
and MBC. Hence, the substitution of Herceptin-IV with Herceptin-SC can produce
valuable savings for the Greek health care system, especially in the current economic environment where hospitals’ pharmaceutical budget has significantly been
reduced.
PCN152
Cost-Minimization Analysis of Bevacizumab VersUS Cetuximab in
First-Line Treatment for Metastatic Colorectal Cancer in Kras
Wild-Type Patients in the Supplementary Health Care System in
Brazil
Tsuchiya C T , Kim H S J , Maximo M F M , Ramos L A
Roche Brazil, São Paulo, Brazil
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Due to increasing costs in cancer management, there is a crescent
need to rationally allocate resources in health care systems. Recently, a head-tohead phase III study (CALGB80405) showed no significant difference in OS and PFS
for first line (1L) mCRC in KRAS wild-type (wt) patients amongst bevacizumab (Bev)
and cetuximab (Cet) – the most commonly used biologics in this setting. Since
benefit of both drugs is comparable, the aim of the study was comparing treatment
costs of Bev vs. Cet in 1L KRAS wt mCRC. Methods: A cost-minimization analysis
was conducted under payer perspective in Brazilian Supplementary Healthcare
System. Backbone chemotherapy regimens (mFOLFOX6 and FOLFIRI) were based
on CALGB80405 trial. Direct medical costs regarding drug acquisition, material and
procedures/service fees were included. Adverse events management costs were
excluded. The resource usage data was taken from the literature and drug labels.
Costs were taken from CMED price list and UNIMED reimbursement lists. A univariate sensitivity analysis was conducted varying parameters from ±20% range.
Results were reported in Brazilian Reais (BRL). Results: The average monthly
cost per patient was lower with Bev: BRL23’945 (Bev+mFOLFOX6) vs. BRL30’017
(Cet+mFOLFOX6) – reduction of 20.2% - and BRL23’008 (Bev+FOLFIRI) vs. BRL29’075
(Cet+FOLFIRI) – reduction of 20.9%. Average monthly cost per patient according to
mFOLFOX6/FOLFIRI usage proportion reported on CALGB80405 was BRL23’699 (Bev)
and BRL29’766 (Cet); considering PFS data presented in the trial, the average total
treatment cost was estimated as BRL256’899 (Bev) and BRL311’060 (Cet). The sensitivity analysis showed that model was more influenced by Cet price, Bev price and
patient height. Conclusions: Bev is a cost-saving choice for 1L KRAS wt mCRC
in combination with chemotherapy, potentially achieving around 20% of reduction
in monthly direct treatment costs compared to Cet, mainly because of Cet higher
total acquisition costs and weekly administration schedule, resulting in additional
resource consumption.
PCN153
Economic Impact of Using Subcutaneous Trastuzumab
Gutierrez F 1, Nazco G 1, Viña M 2, Bullejos M 1, Gonzalez I 1, Valcarcel C 3
1University Hospital of Canary Islands, La Laguna, Spain, 2University Hospital of Nuestra Señora
de la Candelaria, Santa Cruz de Tenerife, Spain, 3Canary Islands Foundation for Health and
Research, Santa Cruz de Tenerife, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To analyze the economic impact of the incorporation of trastuzumab subcutaneous (TSC) in a University Hospital according to real data of our
patients. Methods: Retrospective cost minimization study that included patients
diagnosed with breast cancer treated with trastuzumab intravenous (TIV) from
april 2013 to april 2014. The demographic data of the patients (age and weight)
and antineoplastic treatments used were obtained from the computer program
Hospiwin®. An economic model was developed in Excel® data base, based on the
dose used in previous clinical trials: IV loading dose of 8mg/kg and after 6mg/kg/3
weeks and SC fixed dose of 600 mg/3 weeks. The time horizon was one year and
the perspective of medical leadership of the hospital was used. The Spain cost of
TSC is not aproved yet. Two posibilities was analyzed: The cost of filing 600mg of
TSC equal to the cost of a 68kg patient with TIV (situation A) and the cost of a 63kg
patient with TIV (situation B). A sensitivity analisys included the cost of using an
oncology chair (168€ /treatment) was performed. Results: During the study period
371 patients were treated for breast cancer. Of these 75 were treated with TIV (20.2%),
with an average weight of 71.5 kg (SD= 17.1) and a cost of 990,996.88€ /per year. If
all patients had been treated with TSC: Situation A the total spending would be
829,965.4€ ; situation B the total spending would be 768,938.5€ . So the savings would
be 161,031.4€ (19.4%) and 222,058.3€ (28.8%) respectively. If the cost of oncology
chair (not necessary for the TSC) it´s included, the savings would be 253,549.4€ and
314,576.3 respectively. Conclusions: In this study we wanted to show how TSC
saved costs in all of the situations analyzed. The TSC is a therapeutic innovation
that helps promote the systems health´s sustainability.
PCN154
Pharmacoeconomic Analysis of Oral Capecitabine and Tegafur for
Colorectal Cancer Treatment in Russia
Gerasimova K 1, Avxentyeva M 1, Rebrova O 2
Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration, Moscow,
Russia, 2Pirogov Russian National Research Medical University, Moscow, Russia
.
.
.
1The
Objectives: To conduct a pharmacoeconomic analysis of oral drugs, tegafur vs
capecitabine, for advanced colorectal cancer (CRC) in adult patients. Methods:
Indirect comparison and network meta-analysis of clinical efficacy and safety of
tegafur vs capecitabine and tegafur + calcium folinate vs capecitabine were performed. Cost-minimization analysis (CMA) with calculation of cost minimization
difference was used for economic evaluation of studied drugs. Results: There
was no statistically significant difference in the full and partial objective tumor
response between oral tegafur (both in monotherapy or in combination with calcium
folinate) and capecitabine for advanced CRC treatment in an indirect comparison
and network meta-analysis. Capecitabine vs tegafur + calcium folinate has less
3-4th grade stomatitis but there was no difference in the incidence of diarrhea and
3-4th grade nausea/vomiting. There was no difference in safety between tegafur
and capecitabine monotherapy in terms of incidence of diarrhea, vomiting, stomatitis/mucositis. The hand-foot syndrome occurrred in less than 5% in case of
tegafur. Tegafur (in monotherapy or in combination with calcium folinate) is less
costly than capecitabine. The difference in costs in favor of tegafur monotherapy
amounted to € 1,956.97 per 1 patient per 6 months or € 3,778.53 per year; of tegafur +
calcium folinate - € 2,168.12 and € 4,220.06 per 1 patient per 6 and 12 months, respectively. Conclusions: Tegafur is a cost-saving option compared with capecitabine
with similar efficacy and safety.
PCN155
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Bendamustin-Rituximab Compared
to Chop-Rituximab in the Treatment of Indolent Follicular NonHodgkin Lymhoma in the Czech Republic
Mlcoch T 1, Klimes J 2, Kruntoradova K 2, Mandelikova M 1, Dolezal T 2
OUTCOMES, s.r.o., Prague, Czech Republic, 2VALUE OUTCOMES, Prague, Czech Republic
.
.
.
.
.
1VALUE
Objectives: There is new RCT phase 3 clinical evidence that bendamustinrituximab (B-R) is more effective in terms of progression free survival compared
to the standard of care CHOP-rituximab (CHOP-R) in indolent non-Hodgkin lymphoma (iNHL). Based on this RCT, we performed a cost-utility analysis of B-R compared to CHOP-R in the treatment of follicular iNHL (stage III and IV) in the Czech
Republic. Methods: We developed a life-time Markov cohort model with 28-day
cycle length and 5 health states, i.e. on treatment, rituximab maintenance (R-M),
stable disease, progression and death. Additionally, we modeled adverse effects
of treatment and four sub-states during progression (observation, imunochemotherapy, R-M, post R-M). Transition probabilities and utilities were derived from
published literature. Resource use (costs) was calculated from health care payer’s
perspective in cooperation with major Czech hemato-oncologic experts. Costs and
outcomes were discounted by 3.5%. Probabilistic sensitivity analysis (PSA) with
1000 iterations using a willingness to pay (WTP) threshold equal to 3 times GDP per
capita (40 100 EUR) in the Czech Republic was performed. Results: Over a life-time
horizon, B-R compared to CHOP-R brings additional 1.21 QALY (7.47 vs. 6.26) and 1.31
LYG (9.74 vs. 8.43). The incremental total costs were 1,368 EUR (total life time costs
for B-R and CHOP-R were 43,080 EUR and 41,712 EUR, respectively). ICERs thus equal
to 1,133 EUR/QALY and 1,044 EUR/LYG. The results of the PSA show that B-R is costeffective in 100% iterations under the WTP threshold; and simultaneously in 99.3%
iterations is cost-effective while using threshold equal to 7,300 EUR. Conclusions:
B-R proved that it is a highly cost-effective therapy in patients with follicular iNHL.
The higher costs of initial bendamustin treatment are in the long-term horizon
offset by substantial savings of progression costs. There is 100% probability of B-R
being cost-effective at the selected WTP threshold.
PCN156
‘DE NOVO’ Quantification of Genotype-Directed Therapy with
Afatinib in Metastatic Lung Cancer
Zaim R 1, Tran L 2, Groen H J M 3, Uyl-de Groot C A 1
University, Institute for Medical Technology Assessment, Rotterdam, The Netherlands,
2Boehringer Ingelheim BV, Alkmaar, The Netherlands, 3University Medical Center Groningen,
Groningen, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Erasmus
Objectives: The inhibition of epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) signaling
pathway by innovative therapeutics presents promising upshots in oncology. Our
study aims to quantify first-line treatment with afatinib, an irreversible tyrosine
kinase inhibitor, compared to pemetrexed+cisplatin (pem+cis), for patients with metastatic lung adenocarcinoma harboring common EGFR mutations (DEL19 or L858R) in
the Netherlands. Methods: An area under the curve partitioned survival model, constructed to quantify lifetime consequences of therapy with afatinib versus pem+cis,
was amended to the Netherlands. The updated (2014) LUX-Lung 3 trial results and
data from public sources were used to populate the model. Study outcomes were
expressed in quality-adjusted life years (QALY), incremental cost-utility ratios (ICUR)
and net monetary benefits (NMB). The analyses were conducted from health care and
societal perspectives. Uncertainty assessment was performed using one-way and
probabilistic sensitivity analyses (PSA). Results: Metastatic lung adenocarcinoma
patients with common EGFR mutations (89%) had higher overall survival when treated
with afatinib compared to pem+cis (HR: 0.78, p=0.10). The corresponding base-case
ICUR was <€20,000/QALY gained. For the subgroup of patients harboring DEL19 mutations (49%), treatment with afatinib resulted in cost-savings. Although NMB calculations were favorable for the genotype-directed therapy, inclusion of the entire patient
population (all EGFR mutations) resulted in higher incremental costs. PSA results of
lung adenocarcinoma patients with common EGFR mutations showed that afatinib
is >95% cost-effective compared to pem+cis at a €80,000 threshold. Conclusions:
This study shows that genotype-directed therapy with afatinib improved survival in
metastatic lung adenocarcinoma and translated itself as value-for-money, particularly for the DEL19 subgroup, in the Netherlands. Further research is encouraged to
compare afatinib with reversible EGFR inhibitors in this setting.
PCN157
Model-Based Cost–Utility Analysis of Erythropoiesis-Stimulating
Agents for the Treatment of Cancer-Treatment Induced Anaemia in
the UK NHS
Snowsill T 1, Huxley N 1, Hoyle M 1, Crathorne L 1, Haasova M 1, Briscoe S 1, Coelho H 1,
Medina-Lara A 1, Mujica Mota R 1, Napier M 2, Hyde C 1
1University of Exeter, Exeter, UK, 2Royal Devon & Exeter NHS FT, Exeter, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess the cost–utility of erythropoiesis-stimulating agents (ESAs)
in conjunction with red blood cell transfusions (RBCTs) in patients with cancertreatment induced anaemia (CIA). Methods: A cost–utility analysis from an NHS
and personal social services perspective was conducted by developing an ad hoc
economic model. A lifetime time horizon was used and outcomes were discounted
at 3.5% per annum. All ESAs were assumed to have the same clinical effectiveness. Haemoglobin (Hb) levels were assumed to drive health-related quality of life
(HRQoL), with haemoglobin linearly mapped to utility. This was used to calculate
A642
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
incremental quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) while ESAs were administered
and during a Hb “normalisation period” following cancer treatment. Incremental
long-term QALYs were accrued solely through extrapolated overall survival. Shortterm mortality and HRQoL associated with adverse events and RBCTs were not
modelled. Costs included: ESA acquisition (list prices, British National Formulary)
and administration, RBCT, additional blood tests with ESA therapy, and adverse
event costs. Results: All ESAs except epoetin beta and darbepoetin alfa were
cost-effective versus using RBCT only at an upper cost-effectiveness threshold of
£30,000/QALY. Incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICERs) ranged from £19,400/
QALY (biosimilar epoetin alfa) to £35,000/QALY (epoetin beta). Probabilistic sensitivity analysis showed that biosimilar epoetin alfa was cost-effective at the lower
cost-effectiveness threshold of £20,000/QALY in 50.9% of simulations. In 19.5% of
simulations it was clinically effective but not cost-effective and in 31.4% of simulations it was dominated by RBCT only. Additional sensitivity analyses demonstrated
that overall survival was one of the most influential and uncertain parameters.
When the survival advantage of ESAs (not statistically significant) was removed, the
ICERs for all ESAs were over £100,000/QALY. Conclusions: There is substantial
uncertainty regarding the impact of ESA therapy on overall survival, which leads to
significant uncertainty about the cost-effectiveness of ESAs in CIA.
PCN158
Qaly Weightings Based on the Burden of Illness Applied to a Uk
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Nab-Paclitaxel + Gemcitabine Versus
Gemcitabine Alone for the Treatment of Metastatic Pancreatic
Cancer
(comparison cohort) who were the same age, race, and gender were identified and
matched. A random index date was chosen to minimize selection bias. Patients in
both cohorts were required to be at least age 18 years, with continuous medical and
pharmacy benefits 1-year pre- and 1-year post-index date. One-to-one propensity
score matching (PSM) was used to compare health care costs and utilizations during
the follow-up period, between the diseased and comparison cohorts, and adjusted
for baseline demographic and clinical characteristics. Results: After risk adjustment by PSM, a total of 19,079 patients in each cohort were matched. Significantly
more breast cancer patients had inpatient admissions (23.77% vs. 12.56%, p< 0.0001)
and long-term care (7.77% vs. 6.60%, p< 0.0001), other service (99.88% vs. 87.86%,
p< 0.0001) and pharmacy visits (77.80% vs. 68.85%, p< 0.0001), compared to those
without breast cancer. Breast cancer patients also incurred significantly higher
inpatient ($2,141 vs. $1,537, p< 0.0001), long-term care ($7,471 vs. $5,335, p< 0.0001),
other service visit ($23,592 vs. $14,780, p< 0.0001) and pharmacy costs ($3,379 vs.
$2,787, p< 0.0001) compared to those in the comparison cohort. Conclusions:
Breast cancer patients in the Medicaid program incurred substantially higher health
care resource utilization and costs compared to those without the disease.
PCN161
Nab-Paclitaxel or Docetaxel as Alternatives to Solvent-Based
Paclitaxel in Metastatic Breast Cancer (Mbc): A Cost Utility
Analysis from a Chinese Health Care Perspective
Dranitsaris G 1, Yu B 2, Qing Z 2, King J 3, Zhang A 3, Kaura S 3
Pharma Consulting, Toronto, ON, Canada, 2Fudan University Shanghai Cancer
Center, Shanghai, China, 3Celgene Corporation, Summit, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Augmentium
Objectives: To demonstrate the impact of QALY weightings based on the burden-ofillness (BoI) of pancreatic cancer on the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of
nab-paclitaxel plus gemcitabine (NPG) versus gemcitabine (G). Methods: A markov
model using data from the MPACT trial plus resource use data and costs from NHS
Scotland have been submitted to the Scottish Medicines Consortium. The base case
ICER was £52,885/QALY based on a cost of £8,232 and a QALY gain of 0.156 (SMC DAD).
QALY weightings up to a maximum of 2.5 distributed across six modifier factors,
including BoI, have been proposed (NICE consultation on Value Based Assessment),
with BoI measured according to proportional QALY shortfall associated with the condition. The estimated 98% loss of healthy life (proportional QALY shortfall) in pancreatic cancer (Hutchings 2014) represents an almost complete loss of life, and thus
a very high BoI. A BoI weighting of 2.5 (maximum weighting allocated entirely to BoI,
or BoI FULL) and an alternative BoI weighting of 1.417 (maximum weighting shared
equally between six modifiers, so 1/6thof 2.5, or BoI PARTIAL) were therefore applied to
the QALY gain of NPG versus G. Results: The BoI FULL weighting gives an adjusted
QALY gain for NPG versus G of 0.39 and a corresponding ICER of £21,108/QALY. The
BoI PARTIAL weighting gives an adjusted QALY gain for NPG versus G of 0.221 and
a corresponding ICER of £37,249/QALY. Conclusions: Various ways of accounting
for disease severity can be considered and made workable by HTAs, including QALY
weightings according to proportional QALY shortfall. The adjusted QALY gain and
corresponding ICERs of NPG versus G in pancreatic cancer show that the value of
medicines for life-threatening ‘end-of-life’ conditions with a high relative shortfall
can be reflected by an appropriate system of QALY weightings.
Objectives: Paclitaxel and docetaxel are used for the treatment of MBC in China.
However, one important drawback, particularly with docetaxel, is the potential for
dose-limiting toxicity. To improve the side effect profile and efficacy of paclitaxel,
an albumin-bound formulation (nab-paclitaxel) is currently available in China
(Abraxane®). Clinical trials have demonstrated that nab-paclitaxel is safer and more
effective than both docetaxel and paclitaxel. To provide economic data for China,
a cost utility analysis comparing nab-paclitaxel to docetaxel, both as alternatives
to paclitaxel was conducted. Methods: Clinical data was obtained from a meta
analysis of randomized trials comparing either nab-paclitaxel (260 mg/m2 q3wk)
or branded docetaxel (100 mg/m2 q3wk) to solvent-based branded paclitaxel (175
mg/m2 q3wk). Health care resource use for the delivery of chemotherapy and the
management of grade 3/4 toxicity was collected from a time and motion study
in three Chinese cancer centers and from a survey of clinicians. Using the Time
Trade-off technique, treatment preferences and utility estimates were obtained
from interviewing 28 cancer patients from two centres in China. All costs were
reported in 2014 $U. S. Results: Nab-paclitaxel had the most favourable safety
profile characterized with the lowest incidence of grade 3/4 neutropenia, febrile
neutropenia, anemia and stomatitis. This translated into lower costs for managing
the grade 3/4 side effects of nab-paclitaxel relative to both docetaxel and paclitaxel
($21 vs. $166 vs. $81). In the preference assessment, 22 of 28 (78.6%) patients selected
nab-paclitaxel as their preferred agent. As an alternative to paclitaxel, the cost per
quality adjusted life year (QALY) gained was more favourable with nab-paclitaxel
than docetaxel ($57,900 vs. $130,600 respectively). Conclusions: Nab-paclitaxel is
an economically attractive alternative to paclitaxel and docetaxel in MBC, providing
a substantially lower cost per QALY. Additionally in the patient preference survey,
78.6% of patients selected nab-paclitaxel as their preferred agent.
PCN159
Economic Evaluation of Lapatinib in Her-2-Positive Metastatic
Breast Cancer Patients in Egypt
PCN162
The Cost-Effectiveness of Second-Line Crizotinib in Eml4-Alk
Rearranged Advanced Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer
Elsisi G 1, Mady E 1, Abo Taleb A A 2
for Pharmaceutical Affairs, Cairo, Egypt, 2WHO, Cairo, Egypt
Djalalov S 1, Graham D M 2, Beca J 1, Hoch J S 3, Tsao M S 4, Leighl N 4
Hospital, Toronto, ON, Canada, 2Princess Margaret Hospital, Toronto, ON, Canada,
3Canadian Centre for Applied Research in Cancer Control (ARCC), Toronto, ON, Canada, 4Ontario
Cancer Institute, Toronto, ON, Canada
Cowell W 1, Gladwell D 2, Parnaby A 3
1Celgene UK, Uxbridge, UK, 2BresMed Health Solutions LTD, Sheffield, UK, 3Celgene International
Sarl, Boudry, Switzerland
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Central Administration
Objectives: The objective of the current analysis was to assess the cost-effectiveness of lapatinib plus capecitabine versus capecitabine alone in human epidermal
growth factor receptor-2-positive metastatic breast cancer patients from the third
party payer perspective over a time horizon of ten years. Methods: A half cycle
corrected Markov chain model comprising 3 health states (stable, progression and
death) was developed to estimate the projected clinical and economic implications
of Lapatinib. Transition probabilities were estimated based on the results from the
EGF100151 clinical trial of Lapatinib. Health state utilities and major adverse events
were obtained from published sources. Direct medical costs were obtained from the
third party payer list. Costs (in 2013 EGP) and effects were discounted at 3.5% annually. One way sensitivity analyses were conducted. Results: The economic evaluation of lapatinib plus capecitabine as combination therapy resulted in additional
cost of 1,597,796 EGP, with an incremental positive effect of 5.7 quality adjusted life
years (QALY) or an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of 277,169 EGP/QALY
gained. The overall survival of the two arms was found to have the greatest impact
on the results. Conclusions: Compared with our willingness-to-pay threshold
stated by world health organization for middle and lower income countries, the
addition of lapatinib to capecitabine is not clearly cost-effective; and most likely to
result in an ICER higher than the threshold limit.
PCN160
Health Care Utilization and Costs of Breast Cancer in the Medicaid
Program
Li L 1, Shrestha S 1, Baser O 2, Wang L 1
Research, Plano, TX, USA, 2STATinMED Research and The University of Michigan,
Ann Arbor, MI, USA
.
.
.
.
1STATinMED
Objectives: To evaluate health care resource utilization and costs among patients
diagnosed with breast cancer in the Medicaid program. Methods: Patients diagnosed with breast cancer (International Classification of Disease, 9thRevision,
Clinical Modification [ICD-9-CM] diagnosis code 174, 233.0, 238.3, 239.3) were identified using Medicaid data from January 1, 2008 through December 31, 2010. The initial
diagnosis date was designated as the index date. Patients without breast cancer
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1St. Michael’s
Objectives: Targeted therapy with ALK inhibitor crizotinib offers significant
improvement in clinical outcome for treatment of EML4–ALK fusion positive nonsmall cell lung cancer (NSCLC) patients. We estimated the cost-effectiveness of
companion EML4-ALK genetic testing in combination with crizotinib treatment in
the second-line setting for advanced NSCLC in Ontario. Methods: We performed
a cost-effectiveness analysis using a Markov model from a Ministry of Health perspective and a lifetime horizon. Transition probabilities and mortality rates were
calculated based on the data of a recent second-line randomized trial of crizotinib
versus chemotherapy (Shaw et al. New Engl J Med 2013). Costs were obtained from
OCCI database, public labs and Princess Margaret Hospital. All parameters were
varied separately in one-way and selected two-way sensitivity analyses. Various
scenarios to assess the impact of model assumptions about testing and treatment
were conducted. Results: The use of pemetrexed and docetaxel in ALK-rearranged
NSCLC, based on our preliminary model, could yield as much as 0.539 QALY and
0.429 QALY respectively, assuming no crossover from chemotherapy to crizotinib.
Average costs per patient based on the preliminary model are estimated at CAD
$19,388 for pemetrexed and $$33,226for docetaxel, with incremental cost-effectiveness ratios of $333,595/QALY and $125,812/QALY gained respectively. The results of
the one-way sensitivity analysis indicated that the primary drivers of the ICER were
the utilities and cost of crizotinib treatment. The model was least sensitive to IHC
and FISH genetic test costs, re-biopsy cost, probability of progression while on pemetrexed treatment and probability of re-biopsy. Conclusions: EML4–ALK genetic
testing in combination with crizotinib treatment for all NSCLC patients eligible for
chemotherapy is not economically attractive in the current setting. Lower drug costs
would be required to make this strategy economically feasible.
PCN163
Cost-Effectiveness of Ipilimumab in Previously Untreated Patients
for Advanced Melanoma in Sweden
Barzey V 1, Asukai Y 1, Gueron B 2, Holmberg C 3, Kotapati S 4
.
.
.
.
.
A643
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
1IMS
Health, London, UK, 2Bristol-Myers Squibb, Rueil Malmasion, France, 3Bristol-Myers Squibb,
Bromma, Sweden, 4Bristol-Myers Squibb Pharmaceuticals, Wallingford, CT, USA
Objectives: Ipilimumab was the first compound to substantially prolong survival
in advanced melanoma. Evaluate the cost-effectiveness of ipilimumab in untreated
advanced melanoma compared to dacarbazine and vemurafenib from a Swedish
national payer perspective (TLV/NLT). Methods: A three-state Markov model with
stable disease, progression and death was developed, estimating costs and benefits over a lifetime horizon. Given a lack of head-to-head data and a connected
evidence network to allow for a robust NMA, the comparison used two sources of
data unadjusted for study characteristics. Ipilimumab survival data were based
on a pooled sample of treatment-naïve patients from clinical trials (n= 78) and
real-world settings (n= 181), the clinical data package used for EMA submission.
Parametric extrapolation methods were applied to dacarbazine data from CA184024. Mixture modelling was used to extrapolate vemurafenib data from BRIM-III.
Resource use was taken from a survey of Swedish oncologists (n= 5). EORTC-8D
utility data from an untreated population were used because they match the population of interest. Costs were obtained from official Swedish price lists. Survival and
utility assumptions were varied in scenario analyses. Results: Ipilimumab was
associated with a 0.93 QALY gain and an ICER of SEK782,000 (€ 84,000) versus dacarbazine. Ipilimumab dominated vemurafenib with a 0.76 QALY gain and a SEK109,000
(€15,000) cost-saving. The unadjusted comparison was the most conservative among
alternative methods of clinical comparisons explored. The ICER versus dacarbazine
was SEK521,000 (€ 56,000) using a published survival algorithm (7) and SEK532,000
(€ 57,000) using a covariate-adjusted survival regression based on the 78-patient
dataset. A real-world scenario using the patient shares of dacarbazine and vemurafenib was also deemed cost-effective. Conclusions: As in the previously treated
setting, ipilimumab produces large (> 0.5 year) survival and quality-adjusted survival gains relative to current treatments. TLV/ NLT considered ipilimumab a costeffective treatment for advanced melanoma based on these results.
PCN164
Cost-Utility Analysis of Trastuzumab in Treatment Of Metastatic
Her2-Positive Breast Cancer in Vietnam
Nguyen T T C , Nguyen T T T
University of Medicine and Pharmacy in HCMC, Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Trastuzumab, a targeted therapy, has been widely used in treatment
of HER2-positive breast cancer because of its proved effectiveness and safety by
many studies but its economic impact with low-income countries like Viet Nam has
not been assessed yet. The aim of this study is to evaluate the cost-effectiveness
of trastuzumab in combination of standard therapy versus standard therapy in
treatment of metastatic HER2-positive breast cancer. Methods: A Markov model
was developed with 3 states (stable disease, progressive disease and death) to simulate a hypothetical cohort of 1,000 metastatic HER2-positive breast cancer women
of an average age of 53 year old with the same entry criteria as in the M77001
study group. Chemotherapy with ACD regimen (Doxorubicin, Cyclophosphamide,
Docetaxel) was compared with ACD regimen plus trastuzumab. The cycle length of
model was 1 month and time horizon was lifetime. Both cost and Quality-adjusted
life-years (QALYs) were discounted annually with 3% discount rate. Probabilistic
sensitivity analysis was also conducted. Results: Combination of trastuzumab
and standard therapy compared with standard therapy in treatment of metastatic
HER2-positive breast cancer resulted in addition of 170.9 million VND (658,8 vs 487,9
million VND) and 0.81 QALY (1.77 vs 0.96). The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio
resulted in VND 208,736,442.49/QALY, which was less than willing to Pay (WTP) of
VietNam in 2013 (VND 253,503,360.00). Therefore, using trastuzumab in treatment
of metastatic HER2-positive breast cancer women has been considered to be costeffective. Sensitivity analyisis showed that the most affecting factors on the costutility of trastuzumab are trastuzumab’s price and patient’s weight. Conclusions:
Trastuzumab in combination of standard therapy is cost-effective in treatment of
metastatic HER2-positive breast cancer women in Vietnam. Trastuzumab’s price
and patient’s weight are the most affecting factors on the cost-effectiveness of
trastuzumab.
PCN165
What’s the optimal visual inspection screening intervals for
cervical cancer screening in real practice of rural china? A costutility modeling study
Li X 1, Goggins W 1, Zhao F H 2, Qiao Y L 3
1The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong SAR, China, 2Cancer Institute and Hospital,
Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences, Beijing, China, 3Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences &
Peking Union Medical College, Beijing, China
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Chinese government initiated a nation-wide cervical screening program, covering 10 million rural women in 221 counties all over the country. The
objectives of the present study were to compare costs, health outcomes, and costeffectiveness of visual inspection with acetic acid (VIA) screening strategies in rural
China, and to identify optimal screening intervals for policy makers. Methods:
Markov simulation model was developed to synthesize the evidence of screening
and treatment practices in rural China, and applied to predict the long-term costs
and effectiveness for hypothetical cohorts over 20 years of screening. Model was
validated by calibrating prediction with observation data on age-specific cervical
cancer mortality and incidence in China. Costs were considered from a societal
perspective while health effects were mainly expressed as quality-adjusted life
years (QALY). Both cost and utility were collected on-site and discounted at 5%
per year. Results: All completing alternatives showed certain benefits due to
the decreased number of women developing cervical cancer. A trend for shorter
screening intervals to have greater benefit was found. Under different screening
intervals, mortality and incidence were expected to be reduced by 6.67-31.74% and
5.12-23.60%, respectively. Comparing to no screening (status quo), ten-year VIA
screening was identified as the most cost-effective option, followed by VIA screening every five-, three- and one year, with corresponding incremental cost-utility
ratio (ICUR) ranged from 11,921 to 17,215 CNY (1889 to 2728 US dollars, 2012) per
QALY saved. All of the ICURs were much less than China’s GDP per capita (6247 US
dollars, 2012). Conclusions: VIA screening at different intervals were all very costeffective options for 35-59 years old women in rural China. It is also noted that the
cost-effective manner of aselected strategy largely depends on the local economic
status and the performance of such organized program.
PCN166
Economic Evaluation of Home Parenteral Nutriton in Cancer
Patients; The French Context
Hashim M S , Povero M , Aliano A , Pradelli L
AdRes HE&OR, Turin, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: This study aims to estimate incremental cost and utility of Home
Parenteral Nutrition (HPN) in a heterogeneous group of cancer patients from the
French public purchaser perspective, as compared with the same patients receiving
no HPN. Methods: Two economic models, from public French perspective, were
defined: a 28 day cost-utility model and a lifetime state transition model; both
models were based on ecological data from an extensive literature search. Four
health states were used in the second model: Home, two hospitalization states
and death. Transition to death state was based on survival analysis obtained from
published summary statistics from two different studies. Functional Assessment
Cancer Therapy-general (FACT-g) scores, reported in a recently published French
observational study, were used to compute utility weights in the intervention group
by applying relevant published algorithms. In the control groups, they were computed by decrementing the baseline utility weight of the intervention group. All
costs: nutrition costs, resources consumption costs, complication costs and hospitalization costs were adapted from published French studies. Both Deterministic
and Probabilistic Sensitivity Analyses were performed to test uncertainty. Results:
The cost-utility ratio of HPN is estimated in 508,059 and 182,584 Euro per QALY gain,
in the 28 day cost-utility model and the lifetime state transition model, respectively.
DSA showed that survival in the control group and cost of the nutrition were the
most influential parameters on the cost-utility ratio in both models. The probability
for cost-effectiveness, considering a willingness to pay (WTP) 87,000 Euro (3XGDP
per capita in France) for a QALY, was below 1% in both models. Conclusions:
Final judgment on HPN cost-effectiveness is difficult, even if it seems to be not costeffective according to standard WTP. The high cost-utility ratio, which declines with
increasing survival benefits, should urge clinicians and policy makers to control the
sources of ineffectiveness.
PCN167
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Ugt1a1 Genotyping Before
Colorectal Cancer Treatment with Irinotecan
Butzke B 1, Oduncu F 2, Heinemann V 2, Pfeufer A 1, Giessen C 2, Stollenwerk B 1,
Rogowski W 3
1Helmholtz Center Munich, Neuherberg, Germany, 2Ludwig-Maximilians University, Munich,
Germany, 3Helmholtz Zentrum München, Neuherberg, Germany
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Irinotecan is an anti-cancer agent that is used for the treatment of
metastatic colorectal cancer. Although it prolongs survival, it can cause severe toxicity (e.g. diarrhea and neutropenia) in patients who carry the UGT1A1*28 allele. This
study evaluates the cost-effectiveness of UGT1A1 genotyping prior to irinotecanbased chemotherapy from the perspective of the German statutory health insurance. Methods: We develop a decision-analytic Markov model to analyze costs
and QALYs during a time horizon of six months (two-week cycles). No testing was
compared to (1) change of chemotherapy to an irinotecan-free regimen, (2) dose
reduction of irinotecan-based chemotherapy and (3) administration of a prophylactic G-CSF growth factor for patients with a UGT1A1*28 variant. Probability, utility
and cost parameters used in this study were extracted from published literature.
Uncertainty was assessed by deterministic and probabilistic sensitivity analyses. Results: Strategy (2) was the cheapest strategy associated with costs of about
€ 12,600 and effects of approx. 0.32 QALYs. All other three strategies were absolutely
dominated. Compared to no testing, strategy (2) resulted in only marginal increases
of QALYs (0.0003) but reduced costs by about € 1,500 per patient. Strategy (1) resulted
in smaller health gains (0.0002 QALYs) and smaller cost savings (about € 60). Strategy
(3) yielded approximately the same QALY gains as strategy (2) but at higher costs. In
the probabilistic analysis, strategy (2) was the optimal strategy in 52% of simulations
at a threshold of € 50,000 per QALY. Uncertainty for this strategy originated primarily
from the utility weights and the costs of chemotherapy. Conclusions: Our analysis suggests that UGT1A1 genotyping and subsequent reduction of irinotecan-based
chemotherapy has a substantial cost-saving potential. Due to the promising results,
further research, for example in the form of a managed entry agreement would be
desirable to validate these findings.
PCN168
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Testing for Brca Mutations in
Women Diagnosed with Ovarian Cancer and their Female FirstDegree Relatives: A Uk Health Service Perspective
Dyer M 1, Vereecken W 1, Worrall J 1, George A 2, Rahman N 2
1AstraZeneca UK Ltd., Luton, UK, 2Institute of Cancer Research, London, UK
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Mutations in BRCA1 and BRCA2 are associated with an increased risk
of breast and ovarian cancer. If a mutation is detected in women with ovarian
cancer their unaffected relatives can potentially undergo gene testing and cancer
risk-reducing surgery. Current UK practice is for any such relative to have access
to testing. Guidelines also recommend that gene testing should be offered to individuals with BRCA mutation carrier probability of ≥ 10%, although this is not routinely implemented. In particular, many eligible women with ovarian cancer are not
offered BRCA testing. Our aim is to evaluate the long-term cost-effectiveness in the
UK of providing BRCA testing to women with ovarian cancer and to the unaffected
female first-degree relatives of those with BRCA mutations. Methods: A Markov
model with a lifetime horizon was developed to reflect the clinical and economic
A644
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
outcomes following BRCA testing in women with ovarian cancer and their female
first-degree relatives. Two strategies are being compared: no testing versus BRCA
testing. Estimates of cancer incidence and mortality, uptake and impact of riskreducing surgery and costs of BRCA testing, cancer treatment and palliative care
were based on literature review. Outcomes are expressed as quality-adjusted life
years (QALYs). One-way sensitivity analyses are conducted for key model parameters. Results: We first evaluated the cost-effectiveness of gene testing in relatives
of ovarian cancer patients with BRCA mutations. Results showed this was associated with an ICER below the UK cost-effectiveness threshold of £20,000 per QALY
gained compared with no testing. Sensitivity analyses showed the results were
robust. Conclusions: We demonstrate that gene testing in unaffected female
first-degree relatives of women with ovarian cancer due to BRCA mutations is cost
effective. The final results will consider the cost effectiveness of offering BRCA
testing to all eligible ovarian cancer cases and their unaffected female first-degree
relatives.
PCN169
Burden of Renal Impairment: Relative Health Care Resource use in
Prostate Cancer Patients with Bone Metastases
between March and April 2014 and retrieved from an extra boost of ONCOVIEW
database. ONCOVIEW is a continuous syndicated study on cancer treatment in
the hospital setting, based on the collection of patient questionnaires. Patients
inclusion criteria were the presence of an mCRC diagnosis, 3rd or later actual
therapy line and no participation in a phase II or III clinical study. Information collected included patient demographic characteristics, mCRC characteristics (TNM
Classification, Karnofsky performance status scale and mutation analyses) and
treatments (actual and previous schedules, dosages and durations). Furthermore,
an evaluation of the “Rechallenge” occurrence, in other words the use in 3rd or
later line of treatment of drugs previously used, has been performed. Results:
261 patients diaries have been collected: 218 out of 261 patients were in third
line of treatment, while 43 patients were in 4th or later treatment line. The
most administered schema among third line patients was Capecitabine alone
(63 patients), while the most used schema in fourth line was a combination of
Fluorouracil and Folinic Acid (7 patients). About 40% of molecules administered
in 3rd line and 67% of molecules administered in 4th line were used in previous lines. Conclusions: Results from the present study underline the unmet
medical need in 3rd or later line of treatment of mCRC patients and the need for
additional evidence-based treatment options.
1Amgen
Qian Y 1, Arellano J 1, Gatta F 2, Burke T P 3, Holbrook T 3
Inc., Thousand Oaks, CA, USA, 2Amgen (Europe) GmbH, Zug, Switzerland, 3Adelphi Real
World, Bollington, UK
PCN172
Burden of Drug Waste in Oncology: Optimization of Resource Use
Objectives: Existing evidence suggests that around 49% of patients with bone
metastases from solid tumors show evidence of renal impairment (eGFR< 60ml/
min/1.73m2) following diagnosis of bone metastases with approximately 80% of
them developing chronic kidney disease. The objective of this analysis is to assess
the economic and clinical burden of renal impairment in prostate cancer patients
with bone metastases. Methods: Patients with a diagnosis of prostate cancer and
bone metastases from the Adelphi Real World Disease Specific Programme USA
2012 were included in the analyses. Propensity Score Matching was used; patients
with evidence of renal impairment were matched with those without on a 1:1 basis,
controlling for: age, BMI, smoking status, employment status, and relevant comorbidities. Outcomes included number of hospitalizations and length of stay in the
past 12 months prior to the point of data collection. A Wilcoxon sign-rank test
was used to quantify the impact of renal impairment. Results: 109 patients per
group were included in the analyses (total 218). The renal impairment group was
estimated to have an increased risk of inpatient visits of 63% (p= 0.036) compared
to the control group (0.78 vs 0.48 inpatient visits per patient per year). Additionally,
the renal impairment group had a mean of 2.43 (p= 0.027) more inpatient days per
year than the control group (5.00 vs 2.56 inpatient days per patient per year). It was
also observed that the patients in the renal impairment group were less likely to
have received chemotherapy (37% vs 47% received chemotherapy). Conclusions:
Findings suggest an increase in health care utilization in the hospital setting in
prostate cancer patients with bone metastases and renal impairment. In addition,
compromised renal function in those patients may potentially have restricted the
use of nephrotoxic chemotherapy agents.
Castro A P , Alves A F , Piedade A , Clark L G O, Bueno C C , Minowa E
Evidências Credibilidade Científica, São Paulo, Brazil
.
.
.
.
.
.
PCN170
Estimating the Voi of Pivotal Studies Towards Predictive
Biomarkers of High Dose Alkylating Chemotherapy in Triple
Negative Breast Cancer
Miquel Cases A 1, Retèl V P 1, van Harten W H 2, Steuten L M G 2
1Netherlands Cancer Institute, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 2University of Twente, Enschede,
The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To estimate the expected benefits from a pivotal randomised controlled trial of predictive biomarkers for high dose alkylating chemotherapy (HDAC)
in triple negative breast cancer (TNBC) and to inform decisions about the design
and priority of further studies. Methods: A markov decision model compared
treating 40- years old TNBC women with HDAC based on four predictive biomarker
strategies: 1) BRCA1-like by MLPA testing; 2) BRCA1-like by aCGH testing, 3) strategy
1 followed by XIST and 53BP1 testing; and 4) strategy 2 followed by XIST and 53BP1
testing, versus treating all patients with standard chemotherapy. A Dutch societal
perspective and a 20-year time horizon were used. Input data came from literature
and expert opinions. We assessed four primary outcomes: the expected value of
(partial) perfect information (EV(P) PI), the expected value of sample information
(EVSI) and the expected net benefit of sampling (ENBS) for the ongoing pivotal
TNM trial (NCT01057069) and/or potential future studies. Results: The population
EVPI was € 663 million (M). The EVPPI suggests prioritizing further research towards
effectiveness parameters, specifically prevalence and positive predictive value of
the biomarkers; response rates in biomarker negative patients and TNBC unclassified patients, which are estimated to collectively have a value of information of
circa € 630M. The value of further research on transition probabilities is estimated
at € 41M, followed by utilities at € 34M and costs at € 34M. Further information on
transition probabilities could be gathered from the TNM trial and that of effectiveness parameters and costs from accompanying studies to this trial, altogether
estimated to have an ENBS of € 657 M. Conclusions: Further research on predictive biomarkers for HDAC should focus on gathering transition probability data
from the current TNM trial, and on accompanying studies to derive data on other
effectiveness parameters and costs.
PCN171
Real World Data in Oncology: Third- and Fourth-Line Treatments
Administered in Metastatic Colon-Rectal Cancer (MCRC)
Heiman F , Ripellino C , Visentin E
CSD Medical Research S.r.l., Milan, Italy
.
.
.
Objectives: The objective of this study was to assess the oncologists’ real clinical practice in the management of mCRC patients, with a focus on the 3rd, 4th
and later lines of therapy in Italy. Methods: Data presented in this study were
collected from medical records obtained by Italian oncologists on mCRC patients
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Minimizing waste of the use of drugs allows optimization of available
resources in a scarce environment. Grouping patients may be an alternative to
reduce drug waste in oncology. The aim of this study is to evaluate the economic
impact of streamlined form of dispensation and percentage of drug wastage of
the total drug expenditure in supplementary health system. Methods: Patients
receiving antineoplasic treatment for stomach, colon, rectosigmoid, rectum, lung
and breast cancer were eligible and selected retrospectively from the private market administrative claims database (Evidencias database). Name and any other
personal identification were not available at the database. Prescription and date
of administration were collected from 3 selected private institutions considering large to small size in terms of patients. Waste of drug was calculated and it
was defined as unavoidable or inappropriate clearance of partially drug use. All
analyses were performed according to regimen and disease. Saving costs were
calculated assuming minimization of waste by optimizing fully drug among group
patients. Costs were derived from Simpro table. Exchange rate used was 1.00USD
= 2.20BRL. Results: Seventeen drugs were identified among reported chemotherapy regimens in which 11 were analyzed due to potential of saving costs. From
these, only 6 drugs could be rationalized. The optimization of drug dispensing
would lead to a year savings of US$ 83.587,88, US$ 17.592,22 and US$ 8.225,24 to
a large, medium and small clinic, respectively. Calculated drug wastage represented from 2% to 8% of the total drug expenditure, regarding on the antineoplastic
used. Five of the 11 drugs did not cause savings due to small number of patients
receiving those treatments. Conclusions: Grouping patients for drug wastage
minimization is an effective way to reduce costs. Furthermore, savings can be
increased by gathering patients of different diseases.
PCN173
Resources Utilization for the Investigation of Pulmonary Nodules
in a University Hospital Center in Quebec, Canada
Gouault-Laliberté A 1, Bergeron C 2, Lachaine J 1
of Montreal, Montreal, QC, Canada, 2CHUM Hotel-Dieu, Montreall, QC, Canada
.
.
.
1University
Objectives: Lung cancer is the leading cause of death among cancer patients;
therefore, the detection of a pulmonary nodule cannot be ignored. With the
increasing prevalence of lung nodule detection, the investigation requires a large
number of health care resources. The objective of this study was to measure the
health care resources used for the investigation of pulmonary nodules. Methods:
A retrospective medical chart review was conducted at the CHUM-Hotel-Dieu in
Montreal, Canada. Eligible patients were selected consecutively using the electronic appointment book of the pulmonary clinic, from January 1 st 2011 to May
23rd 2012. Inclusion criteria were: 40 year-old and over, presenting a pulmonary
nodule ranging from 0.8 to 3.0 cm with no prior history of cancer in the last
5 years and no history of lung cancer. Patient’s demographics, nodule characteristics, medical information and resources utilization were extracted for
each eligible patient. Results: A total of 47 patients (23 women and 24 men,
mean age = 64) were included in the analysis. The mean nodule size was 1.8
cm. Thirteen patients (28%) had a benign nodule and 34 (72%) had a malignant
nodule. The most frequent non-invasive procedures were Thorax CT-Scan, PETScan and Chest X-ray performed at least once in respectively 96%, 85% and 77%
of patients. The minimally invasive procedures (bronchoscopy and transthoracic
needle biopsy) and the invasive procedures (thoracoscopy and thoracotomy)
were mostly performed in patients who were eventually diagnosed with a lung
cancer. On average, patients with a benign nodule underwent 0.77 minimally
invasive or invasive procedures vs. 1.94 for patients with a malignant nodule
(p= 0.028). Conclusions: A significant amount of health care resources are
deployed for the investigation of pulmonary nodules. This study tends to demonstrate that minimally invasive and invasive procedures are mostly deployed for
the diagnosis of malignant nodules.
PCN174
Impact on Hospitalization Derived from the Use of Denosumab for
the Prevention of Skeletal-Related Events in Patients with Bone
Metastases Secondary to Breast Cancer in Germany
Diel I 1, Ikenberg R 2, Cristino J 3, Gatta F 3, Qian Y 4, Arellano J 4
1Praxisklinik am Rosengarten, Mannheim, Germany, 2Amgen GmbH, Munich, Germany, 3Amgen
(Europe) GmbH, Zug, Switzerland, 4Amgen Inc., Thousand Oaks, CA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
A645
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: Skeletal-related events (SREs) defined as pathologic fracture, radiation
to bone, surgery to bone and spinal cord compression, are common consequences
of bone metastasis. Prior studies have shown that SREs increase the utilization of
health care resources, including hospitalizations. We estimated the decrease in hospitalizations when a novel superior therapy is used (denosumab), in substitution
of zoledronic acid (zol), to treat patients with bone metastases secondary to breast
cancer in Germany. Methods: An analysis was run for predicting the number of SREs
avoided and the reduction in number of hospitalizations attributable to treatment
with denosumab. The number of breast cancer patients was collected from a German
registry using the International Classification of Disease codes. Epidemiological data
were then utilized to derive the number of hospitalizations due to bone metastases. The number of patients treated for SREs prevention was obtained from market
research and applied to either treatment. The total number of SREs observed was
based in the SREs rates seen in a phase 3 clinical trial. German data from a multinational retrospective chart review was used to quantify the inpatient hospitalization
rates and length of stay associated with each type of SRE. Results: Approximately
9,500 patients per year with breast cancer and bone metastases were estimated to
be treated with denosumab or zol in Germany. The resulting 2,100 SREs prevented
per year led to a reduction of approximately 700 hospitalizations per year. The total
number of days per inpatient stay avoided by using denosumab instead of zol was
approximately 5,000 per year. Conclusions: The superior efficacy of denosumab
compared to zol reduces the disease burden by decreasing the number of SREs and
consequently the number of hospitalizations and inpatient days.
PCN175
Clinical Implementation of Genomic Sequencing in Pediatric
Oncology: Identification and Valuation of Resources and Costs
Associated with Next-Generation Sequencing
Oberg J A , Sireci A N , Mansukhani M M , Nagy P L , Glade Bender J L, Kung A L
Columbia University, New York, NY, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Beyond understanding the pure cost of genomic sequencing, the
real costs associated with implementing next-generation sequencing (NGS) into
clinical practice are currently unknown. To elucidate the real costs and to provide a potential benchmark for reimbursement, a pilot study was conducted to
identify and valuate the resources related to conducting clinical cancer wholeexome (cWES), transcriptome, and targeted panel sequencing in a cohort of
pediatric cancer patients. Methods: A cost model was calculated using 25 pediatric cancer patients who underwent clinical genomic sequencing at Columbia
University Medical Center. Our institutional workflow developed by the Precision
in Pediatric Sequencing (PIPseq) Program in the Division of Pediatric Oncology and
the Personalized Genomics Medicine Laboratory in the Department of Pathology
guided the identification of resources and costs associated with NGS. Results:
17 pediatric patients received cWES testing and 11 patients received transcriptome testing using Illumina HiSeq 2500 technology. 7 patients received targeted
cancer panel testing using Illumina MiSeq technology. The total cost per case per
test [cWES (tumor/normal), $4,459; transcriptome (tumor), $1,764; targeted panel
(tumor), $383) was calculated from summing the total variable cost (reagent cost,
pathologist time) with the fixed cost per case (annual machine cost, annual maintenance, tech labor cost, informatics cost, space for NGS hardware, server time,
NGS analysis lease, and data storage). Clinical utility was demonstrated by identifying a potentially actionable mutation in 24% of participants. Conclusions:
Since the reimbursement landscape for clinical genomic sequencing is currently
unknown, a comprehensive cost calculation reflecting resource utilization across
the whole sequencing workflow including costs associated with directed therapy
based on molecular profiling results is necessary. These data serve as a starting
point toward identifying and valuating resources associated with NGS and serve
as a first step toward demystifying reimbursement for clinical genomic sequencing in Pediatric Oncology.
PCN176
Amnog Benefit Assessment for Oncologic and Orphan Drugs in
Germany – Implications for Price Discounts
Theidel U , Wahlers K , Mittendorf T
Herescon GmbH, Hannover, Germany
.
.
.
Objectives: With the start of AMNOG in 2011, industry is demanded to submit
and defend evidence as well as negotiate discounts for new drugs with an additional patient benefit in Germany. The National Association of Statutory Health
Insurances (SpiBu) negotiates with a discount on the ex-factory price on top of
a mandatory discount. Evaluating final prices, questions arise regarding factors
might influence discounts and impact the German market especially for oncologic
and orphan drugs. Methods: A database containing detailed information for
all past assessments was used to explore potential impact factors for discounts.
Starting with an analysis of background information (discount, areas etc.) descriptive statistics were employed. Furthermore, we analyzed past assessments with
respect to: number and size of target population, results of the benefit assessment,
change in ex-factory price, magnitude of discount, incorporation of quality of life
evidence, and acceptance of comparator therapy among others. Results: Until
June 2014 24 price negotiations were completed for oncologic and/or orphan drugs
(neoplasm: 16, orphan drugs [w/o oncologics]: 8). It is inconclusive, if the scale of
benefit influences the price discount. An additional benefit was granted by the
G-BA in 21 of 24 cases. The magnitude of the discount tends to be higher in groups
with smaller target populations and quality of life evidence has no influence on
the negotiated discount. Discount rates might be smaller if the companies do
not deviate from recommendations given by the G-BA. In addition to discounts,
some companies needed to lower their ex-factory price. Conclusions: Whereas
binding and strict rules are in place for the benefit assessment itself, there is
no algorithm for prediction of levels of price discounts. To decrease uncertainty
for scenario planning a set algorithm or procedure would be preferable. Further
research is needed to evaluate those criteria.
Cancer – Patient-Reported Outcomes & Patient Preference Studies
PCN177
Targeted Literature Review of Medication Event Monitoring
Systems to Evaluate Adherence in Observational Real-World
Studies
Hanson K A , Payne K A
United BioSource Corporation, Dorval, QC, Canada
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To identify and review methods employed to evaluate medication
adherence in studies of oral antineoplastic agents, with particular interest in the
opportunities and challenges associated with medication event monitoring systems
(MEMS) implemented in observational studies. Methods: A targeted literature
review was conducted to identify studies that have measured adherence with antineoplastic agents. Our review included studies that were published between January
1990 and May 2014. Key data abstracted from each study included patient characteristics, study design and duration, cancer type, treatment, and adherence methodology and results. Based on preliminary results, a second targeted review was
conducted to evaluate the literature on the risk of the Hawthorne effect in observational studies utilizing MEMS in any therapeutic area. Results: We identified 69
studies that evaluated adherence to oral chemotherapy; 6 studies were interventional and excluded from further review. Of the remaining 63 studies, 28 (44%) were
prospective, 25 (40%) were retrospective, and 10 (16%) were cross-sectional. A total
of 15 studies used MEMS to evaluate medication adherence. Among observational
studies that utilized MEMS and evaluated the Hawthorne effect (n= 3), mixed results
were observed. In two studies, patients reported their behavior was affected by their
awareness of being evaluated. This was demonstrated by a significant decrease in
adherence between months 1-3 in one study but not measured in the second. The
third study showed no change in adherence scores over time and concluded there
was no Hawthorne effect. Potential ways to minimize the Hawthorne effect include:
study duration > 3 months, blinding patients and physicians to results of MEMS
downloads, and use of a patient-completed ‘debriefing form’ to assess behavior
modifications. Conclusions: MEMS have been utilized in observational studies
evaluating oral antineoplastic agents. The Hawthorne effect may be present with
MEMS caps, but can be minimized and is not prohibitive to study conduct.
PCN178
A Systematic Review of Health State Utility Values for Advanced
Ovarian Cancer
Al-Dakkak I 1, Borrill J 2, Murphy E 1, Posnett J 1, Zhang Y 1
International, London, UK, 2AstraZeneca, Macclesfield, UK
.
.
.
.
.
1PAREXEL
Objectives: Identifying appropriate utility values to inform cost-effectiveness
analysis is a common problem. The aim of this study was to review health-state
utility values (HSUVs) for patients with advanced ovarian cancer and make recommendations about their use in the economic evaluation of a targeted maintenance
therapy for platinum-sensitive recurrent (PSR) ovarian cancer. Methods: A systematic search of Embase®, MEDLINE®, and MEDLINE®in Process was conducted
in June 2013 for studies reporting direct (standard gamble (SG) or time trade off
(TTO)) or indirect (EQ-5D, SF-6D, or HUI-3) utility values for patients with advanced
ovarian cancer. HTA agency websites were also searched. Study design, country,
HSUV elicitation method, health state (HS) description, and who valued the HS were
extracted. Mean (SD) utility scores, or medians (ranges), if means were unavailable,
were recorded for each HS. Results: A total of 10 publications were found, representing five primary sources of utility values. Two were derived from trial-based
patient-reported EQ-5D profiles; one derived profiles from patients with ovarian
cancer and utility values from a sample of the general population using a SG; two
derived HSUVs from a sample of women without cancer using a TTO. These studies
reported utilities for 18 different health states. Where comparisons were possible,
utility values differed widely: clinical remission 0.83-0.977; progression-free after
recurrence 0.50-0.715; progressive disease 0.40-0.725. None of the studies reported
values for patients receiving maintenance therapy. Conclusions: There is limited
health-state utility data for advanced ovarian cancer and wide variations in sample size, methods of elicitation, populations used to provide utility values, and in
health state descriptions. Further research is required to provide robust estimates
to populate an economic model for a targeted maintenance therapy for PSR ovarian
cancer. Given the limitations of the current evidence base additional methods, such
as mapping algorithms should be considered.
PCN179
Health-State Utility Values in Breast And Prostate Cancer
Measured using the EQ-5D: A Systematic Review of the Literature
Hughes R , Mitchell C R , Bishop R S , Fotheringham I
Oxford PharmaGenesis Ltd, Tubney, Oxford, UK
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: In cost–effectiveness analyses (CEA), a paucity of health-related quality of life (HRQoL) data often necessitates use of utility values from populations
which may be ill-matched with the disease modelled. Use of the most pertinent data
increases model precision and the accuracy of CEA. This systematic literature review
aimed to identify utility values derived from the EQ-5D in patients with breast
cancer (BC) or prostate cancer (PC). Methods: A systematic search was conducted
using Medline, Embase and Cochrane databases. Eligible studies for inclusion comprised those reporting EQ-5D utility values in patients with BC or PC at any stage,
undergoing or not receiving treatment. Results: 31 studies reported relevant data
(BC, 17; PC, 14). Utility values for metastatic BC (6 studies) ranged from 0.55–0.75
and were lower for patients receiving palliative chemotherapy (CT) or terminal care
(0.51–60), while for stage 0–III disease (9 studies), values ranged from 0.74–0.88. In
early-stage BC there was little change during follow-up; for stage II/III BC, rapid
and sustained recovery was observed following high-dose (HD) CT and was maintained long-term post-HDCT and following adjuvant CT. Values for metastatic PC (9
studies) ranged from 0.63–0.85 and were lower for patients with bone metastases,
worse performance status or undergoing palliative care. For localised PC (2 studies),
A646
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
values ranged from 0.81–0.90. Pain, severity of disease, urinary and bowel function
and performance status affected utility values in patients with PC. Conclusions:
For BC and PC, disease progression, exposure to CT and worsening performance
status were associated with decreases in utility values. For corresponding disease
stages, utility values tended to be lower for BC than PC, although heterogeneity of
data across study populations makes comparisons challenging. No studies reported
utility values according to response to treatment. Further research is warranted to
improve the evidence available for CEA.
PCN180
Health State Utility Valuation in Radio-Iodine Refractory
Differentiated Thyroid Cancer (RR-DTC)
Kerr C 1, Fordham B 1, de Freitas H M 1, Pelletier C L 2, Lloyd A 1
1ICON Plc, Oxford, UK, 2Eisai Inc, Woodcliff Lake, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The study is designed to capture health related quality of life (HRQL)
weights for radioiodine refractory differentiated thyroid cancer (RR-DTC) health
states. Current treatment options for RR-DTC are limited, with generally poor prognosis. As new treatments emerge for RR-DTC, associated cost-effectiveness evaluations require appropriate preference-weighted HRQL values. Methods: Vignette
descriptions for RR-DTC treatment response and adverse event (AE) health states
were informed by qualitative work conducted with RR-DTC patients in the US and
interviews with 6 clinicians and nurses in the UK and US with RR-DTC treatment
experience. Health states included: stable disease, treatment response, progressive
disease, stable + grade III diarrhea, stable + grade III fatigue, stable + grade III hand
foot syndrome (HFS), stable + grade I-II alopecia. The vignettes were reviewed by
the UK and US clinical experts and piloted with UK general public participants
in cognitive debrief interviews (n= 5). All vignettes were valued by a UK general
public sample (n= 100) using a visual analogue scale (VAS) rating and time trade
off (TTO) interview. Data were analysed using descriptive and regression methods. Results: The mean TTO health utilities for RR-DTC states ranged from treatment response (0.86; 95% confidence intervals (CI) 0.83,0. 89); through stable disease
(0.80; CI 0.77, 0.84); to progressive disease (0.50; CI 0.45, 0.56). AEs had a significant
effect also (stable + grade I-II alopecia (0.75; CI 0.71, 0.79), + grade III fatigue (0.72;
CI 0.67, 0.77), + grade III HFS (0.52; CI 0.46, 0.58), and + grade III diarrhea (0.42; CI
0.36-0.48). Conclusions: TTO utilities from this vignette study show clear differentiation between RR-DTC states. The order and magnitude of HRQL impact
demonstrated by the utility values reflected clinical opinion and elicited VAS scores.
The values reported in this study are suitable for use in cost-effectiveness evaluations for new treatments in RR-DTC.
PCN181
French Utility Elicitation in Previously Treated European Patients
with Indolent Non-Hodgkin Lymphoma (INHL)
Bec M 1, Cognet M 1, Taieb V 1, Pacou M 2, Gauthier A 1
.
.
.
.
.
1Amaris, London, UK, 2Amaris, Paris, France
Objectives: Since October 2013, the Haute Autorité de Santé (HAS) requires costeffectiveness evidence to assess innovative health technologies. For cost-utility
assessments, the HAS strongly recommends using French utility values. To date,
the EQ-5D-3L and the HUI3 are the only instruments with a set of preferences
values obtained from a representative sample of the French population. In order
to inform a cost-utility model assessing pharmaceutical treatments of previouslytreated iNHL, this study aimed to review available utility values in France and
to collect such estimates if necessary. Methods: First, a reproducible MEDLINE
search was undertaken to identify studies documenting utility values of previously
treated iNHL and CLL in France. Then, a web-survey including socio-demographic
and clinical questions as well as the EQ-5D-3L was conducted. Given the difficulty
to recruit patients from the target population, the questionnaire was conducted
in France, the United Kingdom, Germany, Italy and Spain. In line with the HAS
guidelines, French tariffs from Chevalier et al. were applied to the collected EQ-5D
data. Mean utility values were generated by health state: progression free and
progressive disease. Results: Only one French cost-utility model conducted by
Deconinck E. et al was identified as relevant, but the study used English utility
inputs previously published by Wild et al. Results from the EQ-5D-3L questionnaire
conducted, illustrated that quality of life was substantially higher in patients with
stable disease versus patients with progression disease. Utilities were calculated
with the following scoring function, U (E) = 1–u1-u2-u3-u4-u5–N3. Values between
u1 to u5 depending of the 3 levels of the 5 dimensions: u1= 0; 0.15; 0.37, u2= 0; 0.21;.
32; u3= 0; 0.16; 0.19; u4= 0; 0.11;. 026; u5= 0; 0.09; 0.20 and N3= 0.17. Conclusions:
EQ-5D is a standardised and validated generic instrument which can be used to
elicit utility in iNHL patients. To our knowledge, these French utilities of previously-treated iNHL patients are the first to be published.
PCN182
Generating Health State Utility Values from Fact-Ovarian Data
Collected in a Phase Ii Maintenance Study in Platinum Sensitive
Recurrent Ovarian Cancer (Study 19): A Comparison of Mapping
Algorithms
Hettle R 1, Borrill J 2, Suri G 1, Wulff J 1
Consulting, London, UK, 2AstraZeneca, Macclesfield, UK
.
.
.
.
1PAREXEL
Objectives: Where direct or indirect estimates of health state utility values
(HSUVs) are not available, mapping algorithms can be used to generate HSUVs
from health related quality of life data. In a phase II randomised study of olaparib maintenance therapy in platinum-sensitive recurrent ovarian cancer, the
Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy Ovarian (FACT-O) questionnaire was
used. Although no FACT-O mapping algorithms are currently available, several
algorithms using FACT-General (G) domains of FACT-O have been published. In
this analysis, we applied FACT-G mapping algorithms to the FACT-O data collected
in the olaparib study and compared the HSUVs generated. Methods: FACT-O
data were collected at scheduled visits, and on treatment discontinuation. Three
algorithms mapping FACT-G to EuroQol (EQ-5D) [(Cheung, 2009), Ordinary Least
Squares (OLS) and Tobit (Longworth, 2014)] and one from FACT-G to Time-TradeOff (Dobrez, 2007) were applied to data from the phase II study. The agreement
between HSUVs was assessed using concordance correlation coefficients (CCCs),
and paired t-tests for mean HSUVs. Results: HSUVs were generated for 93% of
patients in the study. Mean predicted HSUVs using OLS and Tobit were statistically consistent (p-value= 0.947), whilst Cheung and Dobrez HSUVs were different
from other algorithms (p-values < 0.05). The CCCs comparing OLS to Tobit and
OLS to Cheung were 0.915 and 0.851, respectively. The CCCs comparing Dobrez
to the EQ-5D algorithms were 0.629 (OLS), 0.619 (Tobit) and 0.783 (Cheung). The
lowest and highest mean predicted HSUVs were estimated using OLS and Dobrez,
respectively. Conclusions: HSUVs can be estimated from FACT-O using FACT-G
mapping algorithms. Comparable HSUVs were generated using OLS and Tobit algorithms, whilst Cheung and Dobrez generated distinct HSUVs profiles. Without trial
data directly comparing EQ-5D to FACT-O, it is difficult to identify the optimal
mapping algorithm. Instead, a range of plausible mean HSUVs can be derived for
use in cost-utility analyses.
PCN183
Obtaining Indirect Utilities with the Sf-6d and the Porpus-U in
Prostate Cancer Patients
Avila M M 1, Pardo Y 1, Castells M 2, Ferrer F 3, Boladeras A 3, Pera J 3, Prada P 4, Guix B 5,
de Paula B 6, Hernandez H 7, Pont A 1, Alonso J 1, Garin O 1, Ferrer M 1
1IMIM (Hospital del Mar Medical Research Institute), Barcelona, Spain, 2Hospital Universitari de
Bellvitge, L’Hospitalet de Llobregat, Spain, 3Institut Català d’Oncologia, L’Hospitalet de Llobregat,
Spain, 4Hospital Universitario Central de Asturias, Oviedo, Spain, 5Fundación IMOR, Barcelona,
Spain, 6Instituto Oncológico de Guipúzcoa, Gipuzkoa, Spain, 7Hospital Meixoeiro- Complejo
CHUVI, Vigo, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To compare indirect utilities for prostate cancer patients obtained
with a generic (SF-6D) and a disease-specific instrument (Patient Oriented Prostate
Utility Scale, PORPUS-U). Methods: This was a cross-sectional study of 480 prostate cancer patients enrolled in two similar prospective cohorts. The first one
included men diagnosed in 2003-2005 with localized prostate cancer (stage T1
or T2) treated with radical prostatectomy, external radiotherapy, or interstitial
radiotherapy at 10 hospitals. The second cohort included patients with stage T2
or T3, treated with external radiotherapy alone or combined with brachytherapy,
recruited in 2003–2006 at 6 hospitals. Annual computer-assisted telephone interviews carried out in both cohorts included several questionnaires: the SF-36v2
(from which is derived the SF-6D), the PORPUS-U, and the Expanded Prostate
Cancer Index Composite (EPIC), measuring urinary, bowel, sexual, and hormonal
domains. ANOVA tests were performed to compare the means of utilities among
severity groups of severity defined by EPIC items (severe, small or no relevant
problem). Effect sizes between extreme groups were calculated to estimate the
magnitude of differences. Results: Mean age was 66.8 years (SD= 6.4) at prostate cancer diagnosis, 20.4% were treated with radical prostatectomy, 33.3% with
brachytherapy, 26.7% with external radiotherapy, and 19.6% with combined radiotherapy. The utilities indirectly obtained ranged 0.83-0.99 with PORPUS-U and
0.61-0.84 with SF-6D. Both instruments showed significant differences according
to problem severity of all domains measured with EPIC (p< 0.001). Utilities for
patients without problems were higher than patients with severe problems. The
effect sizes between the extreme groups with PORPUS-U and SF-6D were: 1.23 and
1.24 for urinary; 1.03 and 0.75 for bowel; 0.98 and 0.96 for sexual; and 0.94 and 2.17
for hormonal domains. Conclusions: Our results suggest that both the generic
index SF-6D and the disease-specific index PORPUS-U discriminated adequately
the problems related to prostate cancer and their treatments.
PCN184
Patient Satisfaction Regarding their Treatment and Disease
Decisions in Infra-Centimetric Breast Cancer
Dalenc F 1, Pau D 2, Chauvet M P 3, Belkacemi Y 4
1Institut Claudius Regaud, TOULOUSE, France, 2Roche, Boulogne Billancourt, France, 3CLCC Oscar
Lambret, LILLE, France, 4Hôpital Henri Mondor, CRETEIL, France
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The primary objective of this French prospective multicenter non
interventional ODISSEE study was to describe daily practice management of
infra-centimetric Breast Cancer (BC). One secondary objective was to describe
circumstances of diagnosis and disease announcement. Patients had to answer
at inclusion a questionnaire regarding satisfaction of the management of their
disease and upcoming treatment. Methods: From May 2009 to March 2010, 616
women with infiltrating, unifocal pT1ab, pN0 BC who underwent surgery were
recruited by 116 centers. Follow-up period is 10 years. Clinical data, treatments
and outcome were collected in routine visits. Regarding patient’s questionnaire
at inclusion, seven topics (disease, treatment planned/organization/duration/
side effects, complementary exams needed and disease evolution) were to be
discussed with their physician at disease discovery and patient’s satisfaction was
evaluated. Results: 546 (89%) patients answered the questionnaire. All 7 topics
were discussed with 52% of patients and none of them for 1% of patients. Disease
and treatment planned was discussed for 98% of patients, for whom 67% were
fully satisfied and 2% were not satisfied. While 60% of patients aged more than
50 years old felt fully involved in their treatment choice, only 44% of patients
aged less than 50 years old felt involved. Overall 12% of patients have considered
that they have not been involved in their treatment choice. When time between
disease discovery/physician visit/surgery is short (< 10 days), patient satisfaction is high (> 85%) and when time is greater than 1 month, patient satisfaction
falls below 40%. Physican specialty (surgeon/oncologist/gyneco-obstetrician) or
location of disease management (public/private) does not show significant difference in patient’s satisfaction. Conclusions: 57% of patients felt involved in
the choice of their treatment, and 65% of patients were globally satisfied of their
disease management. The shorter is the management of infra-centimetric breast
cancer, the better is the satisfaction.
A647
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PCN185
Public Preferences for Genetic Screening for Colorectal Cancer: A
Discrete Choice Experiment
Veldwijk J 1, Lambooij M S 1, Bredenoord A 2, van Kranen H 3, Dekker E 4, Kallenberg F 4,
Smit H A 2, de Wit G A 1
1National Institute for Public Health and the Environment, Bilthoven, The Netherlands, 2University
Medical Center Utrecht, Utrecht, The Netherlands, 3National Institute of Public Health and
the Environment, Bilthoven, The Netherlands, 4Academic Medical Center, Amsterdam, The
Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To explore individual’s preferences concerning genetic screening for
colorectal cancer (CRC) within a population-based CRC screening program and to
calculate the initial uptake of genetic screening for different scenarios based on
the three major categories of genetic CRC; familial adenomatous polyposis (FAP),
hereditary non-polyposis colorectal cancer or Lynch syndrome and other familial non-polyposis colorectal cancer (FCC). Methods: By means of ongoing data
collection, a Discrete Choice Experiment (DCE) questionnaire was sent to a representative sample of the Dutch population aged 55-65years. The DCE included
nine D-efficient designed choice tasks. Panel-mixed-logit models were used to
estimate the relative importance of the four included genetic screening attributes; risk of being genetically predisposed, risk of developing CRC, frequency of
follow-up colonoscopies, survival rate. The potential uptake was calculated for the
three screening scenarios. Results: When the chance of being genetically predisposed increased, respondents were more likely to participate in genetic screening.
Respondents preferred biannual and annual colonoscopies over having a follow-up
colonoscopy every 5 years. Increasing predicted CRC survival rates were associated with increased willingness to participate in screening. The risk of developing
CRC as a result of being genetically predisposed did not impact the willingness of
respondents to participate in screening. The frequency of follow-up colonoscopies
was relatively most important for respondents when deciding about participation
in genetic screening. The calculated potential uptake rates were high with respectively 91.3% for the FCC, 91.9% for the Lynch and 91.0% for the FAP screening scenario. Conclusions: Individuals are willing to participate in genetic screening for
CRC. This decision is mostly driven by the frequency of follow-up colonoscopies, CRC
survival rate and the chance of being genetically predisposed. This interest of the
general public in genetic screening should be taken into account when discussing
about the possibility of introducing genetic screening in population-based cancer
screening programs.
PCN186
Brio: A European Prospective Observational Study to Assess the
Burden of Disease and Treatment in Metastatic Breast Cancer (Mbc)
Patients Treated with Oral Vinorelbine (Nvboral) or Intravenous
Vinorelbine (Ivvino)
Barni S 1, Mouysset J L 2, Sediva M 3, Zamagni C 4, Garau I 5
Italiana di Oncologia Medica, Treviglio, BG, Italy,
2Clinique Provençale, Aix en Provence, France, 3Bulovka University Hospital, Prague, Czech
4
Republic, Oncologia Medica Addarii Policlinico S. Orsola Malpighi, Bologna, Italy, 5Son Llatzer,
Palma de Mallorca, Spain
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Ospedale Treviglio-Caravaggio; Associazione
Objectives: MBC is an incurable disease for which NVBOral is a standard treatment available in 45 countries. The burden of disease, treatment patterns and
motivation to choose across treatments and their consequences are seldom
described in the real world. Methods: A prospective observational study was
conducted to assess the global burden of disease and treatment with NVBOral or
ivVino in Czech Republic, France, Germany, Italy, Poland and Spain. Patients and
disease characteristics at inclusion, events, tolerability, hospitalisations observed
during one cycle of treatment, and reasons to choose either route of administration are described. Eligible patients received NVBOral either alone or combined
with capecitabine, or ivVino either alone or combined with capecitabine or trastuzumab. Results: 184 patients were registered in 6 European countries: 128
with NVBOral and 56 with ivVino. Patients’ characteristics differed significantly
only in term of age (64 years for NVBOral and 58 years for ivVino, p= .001) and
time between diagnosis and inclusion (104 and 71 months respectively, p= .002).
NVBOral was mainly given to patients with HER2-negative (90%), estrogen-positive (80%) and progesterone-positive (62%) disease (ivVino: 66%, 66% and 51%
respectively). Patients in the two cohorts had similar performance status and
were similarly distributed across chemotherapy lines. NVBOral was mainly chosen
for patients’ convenience (93%) and upon patients’ request (21%) (ivVino: 30%
and 12% respectively). The two treatments were similarly safe, with grade 3/4
neutropenia in 2% with NVBOral and 6% with ivVino, nausea and vomiting in 2%
and none respectively. NVBOral was given without interruption, delay, or dose
adjustment in 85% of patients (ivVino: 78%). Hospitalisation was required during
the cycle observed for 14% and 26% of patients respectively. Conclusions: In
this European prospective observational study, NVBOral appeared a safe, patientconvenient and easy to manage treatment for MBC patients. NVBOral is used
particularly after hormonal therapy.
PCN187
Health Related Quality of Life and Patient Satisfaction in Prostate
Cancer Patients Treated Through Radical Prostatectomy
Solano-Moreno H 1, Ramirez-Muñoz O R 1, Balderas-Peña L M A 2, Flores-Larios E A 3,
Ramírez-Conchas R E 2, Sat-Muñoz D 4, Salcedo-Rocha A L 5, García de Alba-García J E 5
1UMAE HE Centro Medico Nacional de Occidente Instituto Mexicano del Seguro Social,
Guadalajara, Mexico, 2UMAE Hospital de Especialidades Centro Médico Nacional de Occidente
IMSS, Guadalajara, Jalisco, Mexico, 3Universidad de Guadalajara, Guadalajara, Jalisco, Mexico,
4UMAE Hospital de Gineco-Obstetricia Centro Médico Nacional de Occidente IMSS, Guadalajara,
Jalisco, Mexico, 5Delegación Jalisco IMSS, Guadalajara, Jalisco, Mexico
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To determine HRQoL and patient satisfaction scores in prostate cancer
patients treated through radical prostatectomy with a curative intent. Methods:
Were selected prostate cancer patients treated through radical prostatectomy. One
month after of the surgery we applied EORTC questionnaires QLQ-C30, PR25, and
IN-PATSAT32. The scores for each questionnaire were calculated according formulas
and instruction in the EORTC Scoring Manual. We calculated mean and standard
deviation for each score. Results: Global Health Status/QoL has a mean score 74.80
(±20.74); the functional scales: physical 87.4 (±18.08); emotional 80.3 (±17.23); role
87.6 (±24.44), social 89.4 (±20.09). Symptoms scales: fatigue 15.6 (±15.48); insomnia,
27.3 (±30.00), pain 12 (±17.27), constipation 18.4 (±27.63), financial difficulties 17
(±29.38) the others symptom scales showed mean scores under 10. For scales in PR25
questionnaire, the scores were: sexual activity 72.7 (±20.68), sexual function 59.0
(±31.45); urinary symptoms 32.5 (±21.57), symptoms related with hormonal therapy
17.5 (±14.13), incontinence support 29.2 (±38.24). About scores for IN-PATSAT32, for
doctors: Interpersonal skills 88.30 (±16.72); technical skills 87.23 (±19.95); capacity
to bring information 89.01 (±17.29); availability 88.56 (±16.85); for nurse: interpersonal skills 87.41 (±16.74) technical skills 86.52 (±18.51); capacity to bring information 84.40 (±19.00); availability 79.26 (±20.89); other personnel kindness 80.85
(±20.47), access 76.86 (±23.16), waiting time 82.18 (±21.45), exchange of information 77.66 (±22.86), comfort/cleanness 80.85 (±21.62) and general satisfaction 84.57
(±18.46). Conclusions: The functional scales for QLQ-C30 showed a good quality
of life, however symptom scales related to sexual function showed a diminished
QoL, satisfaction with doctors and nurses is good, but not for other personnel.
PCN188
Health Related Quality of Life (Hrqol) in Multiple Myeloma Patients
Treated in a Tertiary Referral Hospital
Miranda-Ruvalcaba C 1, Rubio-Jurado B 1, Balderas-Peña L M A 2, Albores-Arguijo R C 1,
Garces-Ruiz O M 1, Borjas-Gutierrez C 1, Aguilar-Lopez L B 1, Vega-Ruiz A 1,
Alcantara-Cadillo R R 2
1UMAE HE Centro Medico Nacional de Occidente, INSTITUTO MEXICANO DEL SEGURO SOCIAL,
Guadalajara, Mexico, 2UMAE Hospital de Especialidades Centro Médico Nacional de Occidente
IMSS, Guadalajara, Jalisco, Mexico
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To determine the HRQoL scores in multiple myeloma patients who
are receiving treatment in a tertiary referral hospital. Methods: Outpatients
attended consecutively at the hematology department were enrolled, at any
stage of treatment. We interviewed through EORTC questionnaires: QLQ30, MY20
and INPATSAT32. The medians and percentiles were calculated. Questionnaire
scores were calculated according to formulas and instructions of the EORTC scoring manual. Results: 23 patients were analyzed; the median of age was 62.21
years (interquartile interval 59.02-69.88). 69.56% were men. Global health status/
QoL showed a median score of 66.67 (P25= 62.5, P75= 83.33), emotional functioning 83.33 (P25= 58.33, P75= 91.66), pain scale 33.33 (P25= 16.66, P75= 50.00), insomnia 33.33 (P25= 0, P75= 33.33), fatigue 33.33 (P25= 16.66, P75= 44.44). The median for
the body image scale was 100.00 (P25= 50.00, P75= 100.00) and future perspective
was 77.78 (P25= 55.55, P75= 97.22), the other medians: symptoms 27.78 (P25= 13.88,
P75= 38.88), treatment-related side effects 20.00 (P25= 8.33, P75= 36.66). In the satisfaction questionnaire, the scores for the doctor showed: technical skills 75.00
(P25= 54.16, P75= 97.91), information provided 41.67 (P25= 25.00, P75= 58.33) for nursing: technical skills 75.00 (P25= 58.33, P75= 89.58) and information provided 75.00
(P25= 50.00, P75= 91.66), waiting times 62.50 (P25= 50.00, P75= 96.87) and in overall
satisfaction average was 75.00 (P25= 50.00, P75= 93.75). Conclusions: Multiple
myeloma patients treated in this hospital show favorable results on scores of quality of life in terms of symptoms of the disease and treatment-related side effects,
especially in the fatigue. These results can be compared satisfactory accordingly
with other reports from the international literature.
PCN189
Health Related Quality of Life and Patient Satisfaction in
Colorectal Cancer Patients Treated Through Radical Surgery in
Curative Intent in a Colo-Proctology Clinical Department
Balderas-Peña L M A 1, Sat-Muñoz D 2, Palomares-Chacon U R 3, Flores-Larios E A 4,
Ramírez-Conchas R E 1, Salcedo-Rocha A L 5, García de Alba-García JE5
1UMAE Hospital de Especialidades Centro Médico Nacional de Occidente IMSS, Guadalajara,
Jalisco, Mexico, 2UMAE Hospital de Gineco-Obstetricia Centro Médico Nacional de Occidente IMSS,
Guadalajara, Jalisco, Mexico, 3UMAE HE Centro Medico Nacional de Occidente Instituto Mexicano
del Seguro Social, Guadalajara, Mexico, 4Universidad de Guadalajara, Guadalajara, Jalisco,
Mexico, 5Delegación Jalisco IMSS, Guadalajara, Jalisco, Mexico
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To determine HRQoL and patient satisfaction scores in colorectal cancer patients treated through radical surgery with a curative intent. Methods: Were
selected colorectal cancer patients treated through radical surgery. One month after
of the surgery we applied EORTC questionnaires QLQ-C30, CR29, and IN-PATSAT32.
The scores for each questionnaire were calculated according formulas and instruction in the EORTC Scoring Manual. We calculated median and percentilar values
25 and 75 for each score. Results: Were studies 83 colorectal cancer patients:
34 women and 49 men, the results for EORTC questionnaires are: Global Health
Status/QoL has a median score 83.33 (70.83-100); the functional scales: physical 93.33
(83.33-100); emotional 83.33 (75-91.67); role 100 (83.33-100), social 100 (83.33-100).
Symptoms scales: fatigue 11.11 (0.00-33.33); insomnia, 0.00 (0.00-0.00), pain 0.00
(0.00-16.67), constipation 0.00 (0.00-33.33), financial difficulties 0.00 (0.00-33.33). For
scales in CR29 questionnaire, the scores were: body image 100 (83.3-100), anxiety
66.67 (66.67-100); sexual interest in women 0.00 (0.00-33.33), sexual interest male
33.33 (0.00-33.33), urinary frequency 16.67 (0.00-33.33), blood stool 0.00 (0.00-16.67),
stool frequency 0.00 (0.00-16.66), urinary incontinence 0.00 (0.00-0.00). About scores
for IN-PATSAT32, for doctors: Interpersonal skills 100 (91.66-100); technical skills
100 (95.83-100); capacity to bring information 100 (91.66-100); availability 100 (100100); for nurse: interpersonal skills 100 (91.66-100) technical skills 100 (83.33-100);
capacity to bring information 91.67 (70.83-100); availability 87.50 (75.00-100); other
personnel kindness 91.67 (83.33-100), access 87.50 (62.5-100), waiting time 87.50
(62.5-100), exchange of information 100 (75-100), comfort/cleanness 75.00 (75.00-100)
and general satisfaction 75.00 (75.00-100). Conclusions: The functional scales for
QLQ-C30 showed a good quality of life, however symptom scales related to sexual
A648
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
function showed a diminished QoL, satisfaction with doctors and nurses is good,
but not for other hospital and doctors office conditions.
PCN190
Investigating the Framing-Effects of Risk Attributes in Discrete
Choice Experiments: A Pilot Study
Vass C M , Rigby D , Campbell S , Payne K
University of Manchester, Manchester, UK
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To understand how the communication of risk in a discrete choice
experiment (DCE) affects respondents’ choices. Methods: An online pilot DCE was
designed to understand the preferences of female members of the public (recruited
via an internet panel provider) for a breast screening programme described by three
attributes (probability of detecting a cancer, risk of unnecessary treatment, and outof-pocket cost) each with four levels. Two versions were used that presented the
risk attributes (probability of detecting a cancer and risk of unnecessary treatment
per 100 women screened) as: (A) a percentage or (B) a percentage and risk image
(icon array). The DCE was blocked into four surveys, each containing 10 choice sets.
The design, generated using Ngene, included an internal validity test through the
inclusion of a dominant choice set. The DCE data were analysed using conditional
logit models. Results: 62 women completed the DCE (31 for each version A and
B); all were currently eligible for screening under the current NHS programme. All
coefficients, but no interactions, were significant and had the expected signs. Of
the respondents who received the percentages only version, almost 20% failed the
validity test (compared to only 3% of those who received the risk image). Probability
of detecting a cancer was the most important attribute. Willingness-to-pay (WTP)
for an additional cancer detected was £175 for respondents presented with the risk
image, compared to only £152 in the percentages only group. Similarly, WTP to avoid
an unnecessary treatment was £59 for respondents presented with the risk image
compared to only £19 in the percentages only group. Conclusions: This pilot
study highlights the impact attribute framing can have on respondents’ choices in
a DCE. The use of risk images also resulted in fewer “irrational” responses implying
respondents had a greater understanding of the task.
PCN191
Results and implications of using a new eq-5d value set for costutility analyses in sweden. An application using enzalutamide
(xtandi®) versUS best supportive care for treatment of metastatic
castration resistant prostate cancer (MCRPC)
receive information about it (p < 0,001). 95.74% of women to arouse the attention on
breast cancer prevention advertisements. Conclusions: Results show that higher
graduates are less appear on screening contrary to lower. Rate of self-examination is
higher if family history of breast cancer known. Based on results, it is important to
reach women who have not yet participated in preventive performances. The reduced
activity of people living in cities should be improved, used of advantages of city.
Important to organize a training program, especially for the correct application of the
method and breast self-examination with usage of questionnaire.
PCN193
Knowledge of Human Papillomavirus among University Students in
Hungary
Vajda R 1, Kálmán D 1, Pakai A 2, Boncz I 3, Ágoston I 1, Molics B 1, Csákvári T 2, Danku N 1,
Horváthné Kívés Z 1
1University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary, 2University of Pécs, Zalaegerszeg, Hungary, 3Faculty of Health
Sciences, University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The main objective of our study was to assess the knowledge of
HPV among the female university students in Hungary and also learn their attitudes about the vaccine. Methods: The quantitative cross-sectional questionnaire survey was carried out among female students attending the University of
Pécs Faculty of Health Sciences. 180 questionnaires were distributed, of which 165
proved to be evaluable. χ 2-test and t-tests were performed as a statistical method
besides 95% probability (p< 0.05). The data analysis was performed with SPSS 20.0
programs. Results: 92% of the women knew the meaning of acronym HPV. 57 %
of respondent women knew the cause of infection. 79.5% of the women knew about
the virus causing lip and oral cavity cancer. 37.8% of the participants in the sample said that “only women”, and 62.2% of them said that “both men and women”
were affected by the infection. It was known by more women who elderly (χ 2=5,034,
p=0,024) and living in marriage or in partnership (χ 2=7,415, p=0,006). To sum up the
analysis on the issues of HPV, those respondents were considered to be informed
who responded well for 5 questions of 6 ones. This rate was 21.4% that is 32 participants of 149 women. 97,3% of respondent women had heard about the vaccination
against HPV. 15 women of the respondents had HPV vaccination, among them there
were significantly more single, divorced and widow persons. Conclusions: Overall
the awareness of human papillomavirus of the students responding is low (21,4%). The
against HPV vaccination does not happen because of the deficiencies in knowledge
therefore this program is the most important task.
Ghatnekar O 1, Nørgaard K 1, Skaltsa K 2
Pharma a/s, Kastrup, Denmark, 2Quintiles Consulting, Barcelona, Spain
PCN194
Patients’ Preferences for Bone Metastases Treatments in Turkey
Objectives: The guideline on economic evaluations from the Swedish price and
reimbursement authority (TLV) states that experience-based valuation of QALY
weights are preferred before a hypothetical valuation. The UK hypothetical EQ-5D
valuation set [Dolan 1997] has been used so far, but since 2013 an experiencebased “tariff” exists for the general population in Sweden [Burström 2013]. This
study explores the implications on ICERs by applying the two different value
sets. Methods: FACT-P mapped EQ-5D responses from patients with mCRPC in
the AFFIRM trial [Skaltsa 2013; Scher 2012] were converted into utility weights using
both the hypothetical and experience-based value sets. A Markov cohort cost-utility
model (with stable, progressed and dead health states) analyzing enzalutamide
(Xtandi®) vs. best supportive care (BSC) was used for studying the implications
of applying the different utility weights. Results: As the experience-based value
set had a more compressed event space, and was therefore less sensitive to QoL
changes, the “on treatment” utility for Xtandi was 0.03 vs. 0.06 (hypothetical). The
stable and progressed health states attained utility weights of: 0.688 and 0.603,
respectively (hypothetical); 0.826 and 0.784, respectively (experienced). The survival gain with Xtandi vs. BSC in combination with the lower hypothetical health
state utility weights resulted in a QALY gain of 0.66 vs. 0.75 with the experienced
weights. With an incremental cost of € 51,100 (€ 1= 9SEK) the resulting ICER was
€77,600 and €68,200 using the hypothetical and experience-based value sets, respectively. Conclusions: The Swedish experience-based EQ-5D value set generates a
greater absolute utility but with a more compressed event space compared to the
UK hypothetical value set. In terms of ICERs, this tends to favour technologies that
extend survival compared to QoL improving technologies, although Xtandi provides
both. These implications exert great challenge on Swedish decision makers on how
the Swedish value set should be implemented.
Gatta F 1, Qian Y 2, Ertugrul G 3, Hauber A B 4, Gonzalez J M 4, Posner J 4, Oksuzoglu B 5,
Arellano J 2
1Amgen (Europe) GmbH, Zug, Switzerland, 2Amgen Inc., Thousand Oaks, CA, USA, 3Amgen
Turkey, Istanbul, Turkey, 4RTI Health Solutions, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA, 5Ankara
Oncology Training and Research Hospital, Ankara, Turkey
.
.
.
1Astellas
PCN192
Possibilities of Breast Cancer Prevention
Karácsony I 1, Giczinger D 2, Ferenczy M 1, Oláh A 3, Boncz I 4, Germán Z 3, Pakai A 5
1University of Pécs, Szombathely, Hungary, 2Health Visiting Services, Nyőgér, Hungary, 3University
of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary, 4Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary, 5University
of Pécs, Zalaegerszeg, Hungary
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To assess patient preference for the currently available bone-targeted
agents (BTAs) used to prevent skeletal-related events (SREs; commonly defined as
pathologic fracture, radiation to bone, surgery to bone and spinal cord compression) in Turkey. Methods: Adult patients with a self-reported physician diagnosis
of bone metastases secondary to a solid tumor were recruited in several hospitals to complete a pencil and paper discrete-choice experiment survey consisting
of a series of 10 choices between pairs of hypothetical medication profiles. Each
profile was defined using five attributes with several levels (based on prescribing
information): time until first SRE (10,18 and 28 months); time until worsening of
pain (3, 6 and 10 months); annual risk of osteonecrosis of the jaw (ONJ; 0, 1 and 5%);
annual risk of renal impairment (0, 4 and 10%); and mode of administration (daily
oral tablet, or subcutaneous injection, 15-minutes or 120-minute intravenous infusion every 4 weeks). Twelve versions of the 10-questions were sequentially administrated across participants. A main-effects random parameters logit model was
estimated. Results: A total of 91 patients were included in the analysis and provided demographic information. Among the attributes included in the survey, annual
risk of renal impairment, time until worsening of pain and delaying SREs were the
three most important attributes, with better levels of outcomes preferred to worse
levels. Daily oral administration was the preferred mode of administration and there
was no statistically significant difference between injection and infusion of different durations. Annual risk of ONJ was judged by patients to be the least important
attribute. Conclusions: When considering treatment choices, patients in Turkey
focused mainly on the risk of renal impairment, the delay of pain worsening and
delaying SREs.
.
Objectives: Aims to gain knowledge about the rate of breast screening among
Hungarian women. In addition are they familiar with the concept of self-examination, with procedure and if so, whether it is used and how often. Also would like to
develop an educational program based on results, which would target risk groups
and self-examination and process would receive priority in prevention activities of
breast cancer. Methods: A descriptive, cross-sectional, prospective and quantitative
study made with women living in and around Sárvár, Hungary. Inclusion criteria was
considered the group of women over 45 years. A non-random, convenience sampling
was applied with 100 women, between January and June, 2013. Data collected with a
questionnaire of 31 questions. Descriptive statistics with frequency range, Chi2-test
was performed with Microsoft Excel 2007. Results: There is a significant difference
between the appearance of screening and the distance from medical centre (p < 0.05).
A higher proportion of women with higher education recognized therapeutic options
for breast cancer than those with lower education (p < 0.05). For women where breast
cancer was diagnosed in family history, 80% of them regularly attend screening. The
women participate in less complex programs for the prevention, because they did not
PCN195
What Matters to Patients and their Caregivers: Using Social Media
and Patient Forums to Obtain Valuable Information from a Patient
and Carer Perspective
Chalkiadaki C , Martin A
Evidera, London, UK
.
.
Objectives: The aim of this study was to assess whether social media and diseasespecific patient forums can be valuable sources of information on what matters to
patients and caregivers about their disease and its management. Methods: We
investigated the accessibility of such information in breast cancer and schizophrenia.
General social media websites and forums dedicated to sufferers of the two diseases
were examined. Results: Breast cancer was more frequently mentioned in general
social media websites than schizophrenia, with more charities, large organisations
and fundraising events dedicated to breast cancer. Searches for breast cancer and
schizophrenia on general social media sites result in hundreds of results, but these are
mainly posted by advertisers or pharmaceutical companies, or contain non-patient
opinions or news articles. Patients tend not to discuss their condition openly on
general social media sites, whereas disease-specific forums contain daily entries on
the patient experience. While searches within forums lead to fewer results, these are
A649
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
much more accessible and informative, and require less filtering through irrelevant
posts. For example, posts from breast cancer patients typically discuss side effects of
investigations and treatments and how to manage them, as well as offering emotional
support. The limitations of using this type of information include the lack of a mechanism to confirm that contributors really do have the relevant disease, although the
number of “factitious” patients is likely to be small and outweighed by “true” patients
and caregivers. Conclusions: This study showed that more valuable information
can be found in patient-to-patient correspondence in forum threads than in general
social media. Breast cancer patients appear to be more vocal in patient forums than
schizophrenia patients, possibly due to the stigma attached to mental health problems. Little was found on what matters to breast cancer caregivers, since patients
tend to present their own personal experience.
PCN196
Patient and Disease Characteristics are Important Determinants
of Health-Related Quality of Life of Patients with Metastatic
Renal Cell Carcinoma Results from a Population-Based Registry
de Groot 1, Redekop W1, Oosterwijk E2, Kiemeney L2, Uyl-de Groot C 1
1Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 2Radboud University Medical
Centre, Nijmegen, The Netherlands
.
Objectives: Limited data are available on the health-related quality of life (HRQOL)
of patients with metastatic renal cell carcinoma (mRCC) in daily practice. The aim
of this study was to estimate HRQOL of patients with mRCC in daily practice, and to
assess the influence of patient- and disease characteristics, such as comorbidities
and adverse events on HRQOL. Methods: Patients with mRCC were selected from
a Dutch population-based registry (PERCEPTION). In this RCC registry, data were collected on patient- and disease characteristics, treatments and adverse events. To
measure HRQOL, a generic questionnaire (EQ-5D) was used. Multiple linear regression was used to determine which patient- and disease characteristics were associated with HRQOL. Results: In this study, 100/465 (21.5%) patients presented with
or progressed to mRCC. Average age at diagnosis was 62.9 years (range: 40-82) and
77% was male. Patients with mRCC reported an average EQ-5D utility score of 0.73
(95%CI: 0.64-0.82) at diagnosis. Two to six months after diagnosis, the average EQ-5D
utility score was 0.75 (95%CI: 0.66-0.84) (P= 0.319). Multiple linear regression showed
that presence of comorbidities (> 1), number of metastatic sites (> 1), radiotherapy
and presence of grade 3 or grade 4 toxicity were significantly associated with a lower
EQ-5D utility score. Although presence of bone metastases significantly lowered
the EQ-5D utility score, this factor was not significant after adjustment for other
factors. Conclusions: This is one of the first studies that provides insights into
the HRQOL of patients with mRCC in daily practice. In contrast to previous studies,
this study also identified patient- and disease characteristics that influence HRQOL.
Presence of comorbidities, number of metastatic sites, radiotherapy and presence of
severe toxicity related to targeted therapies were significantly associated with HRQOL.
This information is helpful in correcting EQ-5D utility scores for these characteristics,
and will be useful in future cost-effectiveness analyses.
PCN197
Development of a Conceptual Model for Pediatric Oncology
Results from a Review of Qualitative Research Literature and
Clinician Interviews
Wells T1, Abetz-Webb L2, Evans C1, Theodore-Oklota C3
Outcomes, Boston, MA, USA, 2Patient-Centred Outcomes Assessments LTD,
Macclesfield, Cheshire, UK, 3Genentech, South San Francisco, CA, USA
1Endpoint
Objectives: Childhood cancer’s profound effects should be assessed appropriately
within clinical trials: however, a conceptual model is required to help design appropriate
measurement strategies. The aim of this study was to develop an initial pediatric oncology conceptual model. Methods: Key databases were searched for articles focused on
qualitative research with children (ages 0-18) with cancer and/or their caregivers. Four
patient/parent internet forums were reviewed. Telephone interviews with five pediatric
oncology clinicians were performed. Data were analyzed using grounded theory methods. Results: 112 qualitative studies were reviewed. Few studies presented data by
specific cancer type/stage or child age; blogs/clinician interviews provided insights into
these areas. Across cancer types, but especially for hematological cancers, pain, fatigue,
and “feeling unwell”/fever were emphasized, as well as impacts on daily functioning. For brain tumors, headaches, sudden lack of coordination/balance, blurred vision,
seizures, vomiting, dizziness and cognition-related impacts on mood and language
were highlighted. For solid tumors, tumor-location pain often led to related mobility
and/or functioning problems; clinicians emphasized lymphadenopathy and weight
loss. Adolescents appeared to be most impacted by cancer, due to their grasp of the
cancer’s gravity, self-image issues, loss of autonomy, school absences and social life
limitations. Though patients/parents/clinicians found it difficult to distinguish between
treatment- and cancer-related symptoms, treatments caused several problems, such
as neutropenia, changes in appearance, irritability, nausea/vomiting, fatigue and pain.
Not emphasized by clinicians but reported frequently in literature/blogs, mucositis and
changes in tastes concerned parents/children. Clinicians strongly emphasized shortterm/long-term/working memory loss and that anxiety contributed to the occurrence/
severity of other side-effects/impacts. Conclusions: Cancer’s impact on children is
multifaceted and complicated. Issues identified in this review that must be considered
when designing outcomes strategies are: the child’s age, cancer type and stage, delineating disease and treatment symptoms/impacts, and short/long term side effects impacts
on nutrition and development.
PCN198
Misuse, Abuse, and Diversion of instanyl® (Fentanyl Nasal Spray)
in France
Blin P 1, Dureau C 1, Lamarque S 1, Bernard M A 1, Robinson P 1, Lassalle R 1, Grolleau A 1,
Droz C 1, Moore N 2
1INSERM CIC Bordeaux CIC1401, Univ. Bordeaux, Bordeaux, France, 2INSERM CIC Bordeaux
CIC1401, Univ. Bordeaux, INSERM U657, CHU Bordeaux, Bordeaux, France
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Instanyl® (fentanyl nasal spray) received European market authorisation in July 2009 for the management of breakthrough pain in adults already receiving maintenance opioid therapy for chronic cancer pain, with precise instructions
on indications for use and dosage. The study objectives were to evaluate patientreported misuse, abuse, and diversion of Instanyl® in real-life in France. Methods:
Cross-sectional observational study of patients with an Instanyl® dispensation from
a non-hospital pharmacy. An anonymous self-administered questionnaire was distributed to patients at the time of drug dispensation between 27 July 2011 and 12
November 2012. The questionnaire collected data on indication, contraindications,
Instanyl® use, and previous completion of the questionnaire. Results: Among the
272 eligible questionnaires (at least one item completed in addition to age, gender,
time since first prescription, and absence of previous completion of the questionnaire), all patients were adult and 95% declared misuse. Among the 160 patients
who declared having cancer, 94% declared misuse: 76% declared at least one indication/contraindication misuse and 86% at least one posology misuse. Widening the
definition of use for breakthrough pain to use for both breakthrough and chronic
pain in cancer patients, reduced the indication/contraindication misuse (63%), but
when posology misuse was also considered this did not markedly change overall
misuse (93%). Abuse of Instanyl® (using the drug for emotional reasons, relaxation,
or sleep disorders) concerned 21 patients (15 with cancer, and 6 without); diversion
(passing the drug to another person) concerned 2 patients (1 with cancer and 1
without). Conclusions: Misuse of Instanyl® was widespread. Nearly half reported
not to have cancer, and among those who did, only a few used this drug correctly.
There seems to be a communication deficit as to the proper prescribing of this drug,
and its proper use when prescribed.
PCN199
Development of a Patient-Led End of Study Questionnaire to
Evaluate the Experience of Clinical Trial Participation
Brohan E 1, Bonner N 1, Turnbull A 1, Khan S 2, Dewit O 3, Thomas G 2, Manson S 2
1Adelphi Values Ltd, Bollington, UK, 2GlaxoSmithKline, Uxbridge, Middlesex, UK,
3GlaxoSmithKline, Cambridge, UK
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Obtaining feedback from participants in clinical trials using a structured method is a valuable opportunity to identify strengths and weaknesses of
trial design and conduct, highlight improvement opportunities and provide patient
insight to help future recruitment. This study aimed to develop a questionnaire
to provide a structured approach to evaluate patients’ experience of clinical trial
participation. Methods: A draft questionnaire assessing patients’ experiences
before, during and after the trial was developed in collaboration with oncology
patient-advocates before being qualitatively reviewed by individuals who have
participated in a clinical trial or who have provided support to trial participants.
A literature review informed these draft concepts. Three interviewer-led focus
groups involving clinical trial participants (on-going or completed within the last
12 months) (n≤ 9/group) were conducted to evaluate the concepts, and elicit further concepts for questionnaire inclusion. An updated questionnaire was developed based on combined insights from the focus groups and literature review.
Content validity of the revised measure was considered using cognitive debriefing interviews (n= 12). This testing aimed to identify the relevance and clarity
of the instrument. Results: A literature review confirmed the relevance of the
concepts assessed by the draft questionnaire. Aspects of the draft questionnaire
included the trial enrolment and consent process, logistics of study participation and dissemination of results. The focus group participants provided further
evidence on the relevance of the concepts included in the draft instrument and
the importance of capturing the clinical trial experience from the patient perspective. Cognitive debriefing results are also presented. Conclusions: The results
provide evidence to support the content validity of the post-trial questionnaire.
Assessing the clinical trial experience from the patient perspective using a robust
questionnaire may offer potential to improve trial design and ensure subjects stay
engaged throughout the trial process.
PCN200
Patient-Reported Outcomes Assessed Using the Breast-Q Instrument
in Women Undergoing Breast Reconstruction Post-Mastectomy: A
Systematic Literature Review
Lee L J , Milburn C , Macarios D
LifeCell Corporation, Bridgewater, NJ, USA
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Assessing the effects of breast reconstruction (BR) on patient-reported
outcomes (PRO) is important as BR becomes increasingly common after mastectomy.
A systematic literature review was conducted to assess the clinical use of a wellvalidated PRO instrument, the BREAST-Q (BQ) in women undergoing BR. Methods:
Searches using PubMed, ScienceDirect, Cochrane Library, and references in plastic
surgery journals were conducted from when BQ was developed in 2008 to May 2014
using the term, ‘breast-q OR breastq’. Non-English, reviews, letters, protocols and
single-patient case reports were excluded. BQ modules unrelated to reconstruction
(e.g., Augmentation or Reduction) were also excluded. Each BQ scale score ranged
from 0-100 with a higher score representing better PRO. Results: After applying
exclusion criteria, 35 studies were retrieved. Majority of studies were conducted in
North America (54%, 19/35) or Europe (29%, 10/35). Study sample size ranged from
N= 14 to 7,110 with mean age ranging 46-55 years. When compared to mastectomy
alone, BR was associated with higher PROs (p< 0.05) however, adjuvant radiotherapy
was associated with significantly lower PROs than without radiotherapy (p< 0.05).
Among PRO scales, sexual well-being was consistently low (range: 30-84) and the
scores of physical well-being and satisfaction with surgeons were consistently high
(ranges: 68-89 and ≥ 70, respectively). Majority of the studies administered BQ as
a single administration post-BR. Only 4 studies reported the change from pre- to
post-BR (Range of change score = -19 to 36). From 3 of 4 studies, the scale with
the largest Cohen’s d effect size (ES) was psychosocial well-being (ES range: 1.523.83). Conclusions: Our findings suggest that while BQ is widely used, study
type and method of administration are disparate. Further assessment of the BQ
A650
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
especially in comparative and longitudinal studies is recommended in order to
enhance use of BQ in clinical decision making around BR modalities.
PCN201
Patients’ Priorities in the Treatment of Neuroendocrine Tumors: An
Analytic Hierarchy Process
Mühlbacher A C , Juhnke C , Kaczynski A
Hochschule Neubrandenburg, Neubrandenburg, Germany
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Neuroendocrine tumors (NET) are relatively rare, usually slow-growing
malignant tumors. So far there is no data on the patient preferences/priorities
regarding the therapy of NET. This empirical study aimed at the elicitation of patient
priorities in the drug treatment of NET. Methods: Qualitative patient interviews
(N= 9) were conducted. To elicit patient’s perspective regarding various treatment
aspects of NET a self-administered questionnaire using Analytic Hierarchy Process
(AHP) was developed. The data collection was carried out using paper questionnaires supported by an item response system in a group discussion. To evaluate
the patient-relevant outcomes, the eigenvector method was applied. Results:
N= 24 patients, experts and relatives participated in the AHP survey. In the AHP all
respondents had clear priorities for all considered attributes. The attribute “overall
survival” was the most significant feature of a drug therapy for all respondents. As
in the qualitative interviews, “efficacy attributes” dominated the side effects in the
AHP as well. The evaluation of all participants thus showed the attributes “overall
survival” (Wglobal: 0.418), “progression free survival” (Wglobal: 0.172) and “response
to treatment” (Wglobal: 0.161) to be most relevant. “Occurrence of abdominal pain”
(Wglobal: 0.051) was ranked last, with “tiredness/fatigue” and “risk of a hypoglycemia” (Wglobal: 0.034) on a shared seventh place. Conclusions: The results thus
provide evidence about how much influence a treatment capacity has on therapeutic decision. Using the AHP major aspects of drug therapy from the perspective of
those affected were captured, and positive and negative therapeutic properties could
be related against each other. Based on the assessment of the patient’s perspective
further investigation must elicit patient preferences for NET drug therapy. In the
context of a discrete choice experiment or another choice -based method of preference measurement, the results obtained here can be validated and the therapeutic
features weighted according to their preferability.
PCN202
What Relapsed/Refractory Cll/Mcl Treatment Outcomes Do German
Patients And Physicians Find Most Important? Results from
Qualitative Interviews
Gaudig M 1, Ireland S 2, Musingarimi P 2, Jackson C 3, Tweats E 3, Eriksson J A 4, Landfeldt E 4
1Janssen, Neuss, Germany, 2Janssen, High Wycombe, UK, 3Adelphi Research UK, Bollington, UK,
4OptumInsight, Stockholm, Sweden
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Despite the availability of a wide number of treatments for relapsed/
refractory (r/r) chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL) and r/r mantle cell lymphoma
(MCL), no standard of care has emerged. There are no studies evaluating preferences
for treatment outcomes for r/r CLL and r/r MCL. This study was designed to elicit
preferences for r/r MCL and r/r CLL treatment outcomes among patients, the general
public and physicians experienced in treating CLL/MCL in Germany. Methods:
Interviews (90 minutes) in German of 6 CLL/6 MCL hematologists, 6 r/r CLL and 5 r/r
MCL patients were conducted (total 23 interviews). Participants were asked to state
their most important treatment outcomes. Transcripts were translated to English
and analyzed by counting the number of times each outcome was mentioned.
We present here results of patient and physician preferences. Results: r/r CLL
patients mention overall survival (OS; 5 counts), mode of treatment administration
(4), quality of life (QOL) aspects (4) and progression free survival (PFS) disease control
(4). A tolerable side effect (SE) profile/controlling disease symptoms was mentioned
by 3 patients. Other treatment outcomes were infections, nausea (2 each), fatigue,
weight loss, pain, fever, polyneuropathy and long treatment intervals (1 each). CLL
physicians mentioned OS (4), QOL (4) and PFS (4). r/r MCL patients mentioned efficacy benefits such as cure (4) and OS (2), PFS (1); various QOL aspects (5) and a
tolerable SE profile/controlling disease (3). Other treatment outcomes were longterm organ damage (2), hair loss, nausea and night sweat (1 each). MCL physicians
mentioned OS (6), QOL (5) and a tolerable SE profile (4). Conclusions: Extending
life, disease control, maintaining QOL and avoiding SE are important r/r MCL/CLL
treatment outcomes to German patients and physicians.
PCN203
Patients’ Preferences in Late Stage Treatment of Non-Small-Cell
Lung Cancer: A Discrete-Choice Experiment
Mühlbacher A C 1, Bethge S 2
1University of Applied Sciences Neubrandenburg, Neubrandenburg, Germany,, 2Hochschule
Neubrandenburg, Neubrandenburg, Germany
.
.
.
Objectives: Lung cancer is a major cause of cancer-related deaths and thus represents a global health problem. To date, decisions on which treatment to use are
often driven by health care professionals’ opinions. The perspective of patients
with metastatic non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) on the importance of different
treatment criteria and the ranking of these decision criteria are rarely taken into
consideration. Aim of the study is the evaluation of patients’ preferences for different treatment characteristics of NSCLC patients. Methods: The literature review
and 10 qualitative interviews revealed seven patient-relevant treatment attributes. A
Discrete-Choice Experiment (DCE) was used to rank the patient-relevant treatment
characteristics. The DCE was conducted using a fractional factorial design (Ngene)
and the statistical data analysis used random effect logit and GLLAMM latent
class models for subgroup identification. Results: In total N= 211 patients with
metastatic NSCLC participated in the computer-assisted personal interviews. The
estimation revealed a clear dominance for “progression-free survival” (coef.: 1.087)
and “tumor-associated symptoms (cough, shortness of breath and pain)” (coef.:
1.090), followed by the side effects: “nausea and vomiting” (coef.: 0.605), “rash” (coef.:
0.432), “diarrhea” (coef.: 0.427) and “tiredness and fatigue” (coef.: 0.423). The “mode
of administration” was less important for participants (coef.: 0.141). Conclusions:
“Progression-free survival” and “tumor-associated symptoms” were identified as key
patient-relevant characteristics in this study. The sole consideration of the “progression-free survival” as foundation for decisions is not sufficient from the patients’
perspective and multiple criteria are important. Subgroup analysis revealed that the
importance of “progression-free survival” increases with increased therapy experience. Basically, the results give insight into how much a deciding factor affects the
treatment decision from the perspective of patients. In addition, the results of this
survey can provide a basis for patient-oriented evaluation of treatment options
in NSCLC.
PCN204
Carer Perceived Burden as a Predictor of Health-Related Quality of
Life: The Case of Colorectal Cancer
Hanly P 1, Maguire R 1, Hyland P 1, Sharp L 2
College of Ireland, Dublin, Ireland, 2National Cancer Registry Ireland, Cork, Ireland
.
.
.
.
1National
Objectives: This study aimed to (i) investigate the impact of subjective and objective
factors on colorectal cancer carer physical and mental health, and (ii) identify key
subjective burden predictors of these two domains. Methods: 228 colorectal cancer survivors diagnosed October 2007–September 2009 nominated an informal carer.
Carers were posted a questionnaire which included questions on socio-demographic
characteristics, relationship with the care recipient, the caregiver reaction assessment (CRA) scale and the SF-12v2. Multivariate linear regression was used to assess
whether five CRA domains (family support, finances, schedule and health, esteem)
predicted carer mental or physical health, controlling for age and other confounders. Results: 153 carers (82% female) completed the questionnaire (response rate =
68%). Carers’ mean physical component score (PCS) was 48.56 (SD= 10.38) and mean
mental component score (MCS) was 49.22 (SD= 9.7). The most negatively affected
CRA domain was disrupted schedule (mean= 3.0), followed by financial problems
(mean= 2.4), health problems (mean= 2.3) and lack of family support (mean= 2.0).
Multiple regression analysis showed health burden was the strongest predictor (β =
-.54, p <.001) of carer PCS, followed by having a comorbid condition (β = -.34, p <.001),
age (β = -.33, p <.001) and schedule burden (β =.25, p =.008). MCS was significantly
predicated by financial problems (β = -.20, p =.02), age (β = -.16, p =.05) and esteem (β
= -.16, p =.05). Conclusions: Our results demonstrate the need to recognise the different aspects of the impact of caring on caregivers (i.e. physical and mental), and that
different domains of subjective caregiver burden impact differently on each of these.
PCN205
Impact of Brain Metastases on Quality of Life and Estimated Life
Expectancy in Patients with Advanced Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer
Roughley A 1, Damonte E 2, Taylor-Stokes G 1, Rider A 1, Munk V C 2
Real World, Macclesfield, UK, 2Roche, Basel, Switzerland
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Adelphi
The majority of patients with Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer (NSCLC) are diagnosed
with advanced disease (Stage IV). The site of the metastasis as well as the underlying disease influences the outcome and the patient’s quality of life. Objectives:
To evaluate the impact of brain metastases compared with other metastatic sites
on health-related quality of life (EQ-5D) and physician-perceived life expectancy
in stage IV NSCLC patients. Methods: Data were drawn from the Adelphi NSCLC
Disease-Specific Programme (DSP®), a cross-sectional survey of 120 pulmonologists
and oncologists and their NSCLC patients conducted between July and September
2010 in France and Germany. Each physician completed detailed record forms on
10 advanced patients being actively treated for NSCLC. Patients were invited to
complete an equivalent patient self-completion questionnaire (PSC) which included
the EQ-5D. Analysis was conducted on patients with only one metastatic site, either
brain, contralateral lung, adrenal gland, bone or liver. Mann-Whitney tests were
used to assess the differences between metastatic sites. Results: 498 patients
with one metastatic site were identified of whom 325 (65%) completed a PSC. The
higher the EQ-5D score the better the health state, EQ-5D was significantly lower
for patients with brain metastases (mean 0.52, n= 29) compared with contralateral
lung metastases (0.69, n= 111, p= 0.0196); adrenal glands (0.83, n= 43, p= 0.0001) and
liver (0.71, n= 46, p= 0.0191). No significant difference was observed between brain
and bone metastases (0.53, n= 92, p= 0.8219). Estimated life expectancy was significantly shorter for brain metastases (25.3 weeks) compared with contralateral lung
(50.5 weeks), bone (49.4 weeks), adrenal glands (48.7 weeks) and liver (44.9 weeks)
(all p< 0.01). Conclusions: The development of brain metastases in patients with
advanced NSCLC is associated with a significant reduction in quality of life and
estimated life expectancy compared with other metastatic sites.
PCN206
Skeletal-Related Events (SRES) Impact Significantly the HealthRelated Quality of Life (HRQOL) of Chemo-Naive Men With Metastatic
Castration Resistant Prostate Cancer (MCRPC)
Ivanescu C 1, Phung D 2, Loriot Y 3, Saad F 4, Mansbach H 5, Beer T M 6, Tombal B 7,
Holmstrom S 8
1Quintiles Consulting, Hoofddorp, The Netherlands, 2Astellas Pharma Global Development, Leiden,
The Netherlands, 3Institut Gustave Roussy, University of Paris Sud, Villejuif, France, 4CHUM,
Montreal, QC, Canada, 5Medivation, Inc, San Francisco, CA, USA, 6Oregon Health & Science
University, Portland, OR, USA, 7Cliniques Universitaires Saint-Luc, Brussel, Belgium, 8HEOR,
Astellas Pharma Global Development, Leiden, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Men with mCRPC are at risk of experiencing SREs, defined as pathologic bone fracture (“fracture”), spinal cord compression (“compression”), and the
need for radiotherapy or surgery to bone (“radiotherapy/surgery”). We examined the
patient and clinical relevance of SREs for HRQoL in men with mCRPC. Methods:
We analysed data from patients experiencing any type of SRE (n= 587; irrespective of
treatment) in PREVAIL - a phase 3 trial of enzalutamide (n= 872) vs. placebo (n= 845)
in asymptomatic/mildly symptomatic chemo-naïve mCRPC patients. For patients
with multiple SREs, only the first event was included. HRQoL was assessed using
the FACT-P and EQ-5D tools. Impact of first SRE on HRQoL was evaluated as follows:
A651
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
1) estimate each patient’s longitudinal HRQoL trajectory before the first SRE using
repeated measures analysis; 2) calculate how SREs affect HRQoL changes. Results:
We found statistically significant declines in utility scores after all three types of
SREs with an adjusted mean change of -0.06 (95% CI [-0.10, -0.02]) for “radiotherapy/
surgery” (N= 107), -0.20 (95% CI [-0.36, -0.04]) for “fractures” (N= 31) and -0.24 (95%
CI [-0.39, -0.08]) for “compression” (N= 23). “Fractures” and “compression” affected
a number of FACT-P domains and total score to a clinically meaningful and statistically significant extent. Compression had the broadest impact, affecting 7 out of 9
FACT-P domains and induced a mean decrease in the FACT-P total score of -16.96
(95% CI [-26.47, -7.44]). Radiotherapy/surgery was associated with a statistically
significant decline in physical (-1.28, 95% CI [-2.06, -0.50]) and functional well being
(-1.51, 95% CI [-2.37, -0.64]), and improvement in social well being (1.26, 95% CI [0.60,
1.91]). Full results will be presented. Conclusions: The presence of SREs was
significantly associated with poorer HRQoL in this patient population. Any therapy
reducing or delaying the occurrence of SREs may slow down the observed HRQoL
decline in mCRPC patients.
PCN207
Sustainable Measurement of Response Shift in Prostate Cancer
Patients: Adjusting Health Related Quality of Life with the
Then-Test
ten Ham R M 1, Wilson L S 2, Broering J M 2, Cooperberg M R 3, Carroll P 3
University, Utrecht, The Netherlands, 2University of California San Francisco, San
Francisco, CA, USA, 3University of California, San Francisco, San Francisco, CA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1Utrecht
Objectives: Patients diagnosed with prostate cancer (PCa) have similar survival
rates across treatments, making treatments choices based on health related quality
of life (HRQoL) more important. Objective was to increase HRQoL usage, sustainability and reliability measurement over time for use in cost–effectiveness analyses
by investigating the occurrence of response shift (RS) in PCa patients. Never before
has RS been measured over this long a time in PCa patients, not limited by few
available treatment options. Methods: A prospective cross sectional cohort study
was started in January of 2012 with 1,720 CAPSURE patients using the SF-36 and
UCLA-Prostate Cancer Index (PCI). In January of 2012 patient were asked to fill out
questionnaires asking about their perceived HRQoL at time of diagnosis (then score)
and current HRQoL (post-score). These scores were matched to previous collected
scores at baseline (pre-score), ranging from 3 months to 20 years. RS (then-pre score),
True Change (TC= post-then score) and Felt Change (FC= post-then) were calculated
and compared with t-tests in different questionnaire domains. Linear regression
was used to explore relations between scores and patient characteristics. Results:
RS and FC are found to be negative overall for SF-36 (RS:-3.6/-14.5 TC:-8.1/1.8
FC:-3.0/-22.7) and PCI (RS:-4.0/-30.2 TC:-20.2/0.07 FC:-3.6/-49.8), showing significant
difference (P< 0.05). Significant difference was also seen over the whole time range
between post-scores and RS-adjusted-post-scores for SF-36 and PCI. A difference
was found between recurrence and non-recurrence in both questionnaires (ranging
0/-4.0), although not significant. RS over time did not show change. Conclusions:
Mean negative RS scores were found in this population using SF-36 and PCI, indicating over reporting in retrospective collected data. It is recommended physicians
and researchers adjust found HRQoL scores with RS values found in this study,
to increase usage, sustainability and reliability of retrospective collected HRQoLscores. Further research is needed to investigate RS dependency on other variables
or characteristics.
of life (QoL) and the ability to work (WA) too. Till now in the Slovak Republic there
was not realised the study oriented on the both mentioned categories. Methods:
102 patients with LC were studied. The average of age was 50.3 y., weight – 78.3 kg,
height – 175.1, duration of illness – 2.4 y., symptoms of illness before diagnosis – 1.2
y. Metastases were present in 72 patients. 4 patients were mentioned as strong pessimists, 10 predominant pessimists, 9 neither pessimists nor optimists, 61 predominant optimists, and 18 strong optimists. QoL and the ability to work was evaluated
by means of the numeric scale from 0 to 10 (0-the worst, 10- the best) by patients
themselves. Results: The QoL was evaluated in these domains: in the time of good
health – 8-21, in the time of diagnosis – 2.82, in the current time – 3.71. The WA had
these results: in time of good health – 8.89, in the time of diagnosis – 5.08, and in
the current time – 2.17. The impact of treatment on the QoL was 2.49 and on the
patients families QoL it was 2.75. The willingness to pay for perfect cure was 92.35 €
per month (the average salary in Slovakia in 2013 was 824 € ). Conclusions: LC has
a great impact on QoL and on the WA too. There was a strong correlation between
QoL and WA, although the WA has the later onset as QoL. Our research confirmed
the importance of early diagnosis and high effective treatment of this disease.
PCN210
Validation of the Proposed Reduced Quality of Life Questionnaire
to the Eortc QLQ-C30 in Cubans Patients with Cancer
Viada C
Center of Molecular Immunology, Havana, Cuba
.
Objectives: To validate the short version of the QLQ-C30 obtained for patients with
non-small-cell lung cancer in patients with head and neck, prostate, breast or cervix
cancer. Methods: We analysed data of 636 patients distributed: 237 diagnosed
with head and neck cancer, 146 diagnosed with breast cancer, 140 diagnosed with
cervix cancer and 113 diagnosed with prostate cancer. The analysis followed a 4-step
approach. First, we conducted a Mokken nonparametric item response analysis
to ascertain the QLQ-C30 dimensionality and separate several scale if appropriate. Second, we conducted a parametric Samejima’s graded response model (GRM)
to assess the item characteristics and information for each scale. Third, we did
a confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) to test the scales unidimensionality and to
obtain standardised factor loadings to suggest a reduced version of the QLQ. Finally,
we assessed the discriminative validity of the reduced version by using receiveroperator curve (ROC) analysis. Results: Mokken analysis of the QLQ-C30 resulted
in a unidimensional scale, with an overall scalability defined a medium scale. The
unconstrained GRM showed that most items presented appropriate difficulty and
discrimination parameters. The CFA supported an underlying unidimensional
latent structure for the whole QLQ-C30 (CFI = 0.98; RMSEA = 0.05) with modification indexes pointing to important redundancy of information. The selection of
items with standardized factor loadings > 0.70 lead to a 6-item QLQ that showed
good discriminative validity against independent criteria of quality of life (ROC
area = 0.76; 95% CI = 0.72 to 0.80) as compared with the values for the whole scale
(ROC area = 0.70; 95% CI = 0.66 to 0.74). Conclusions: The EORTC reduced scale
was validated in this study; it presents good psychometric properties and includes
a unidimensional structure of patient-perceived quality of life.
PCN211
Shared Decision-Making in Women with Early Stage Breast Cancer
and Implications for Long-Term Health-Related Quality of Life
Scott A M 1, Jhanwar S M 1, Pusic A 2, McCarthy C M 1
Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, New York, NY, USA, 2Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer
Center, New York, NY, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
PCN208
Quality of Life in Patients with Multiple Myeloma in Slovakia
1Memorial
Misinova M 1, Gajdosikova E 1, Gerlichova K 1, Matisakova I 2, Bielik J 1
1Trencin University, Trencin, Slovak Republic, 2Trencin University of Alexander Dubcek, Trencin,
Slovak Republic
Objectives: Surgery for breast cancer has a substantial impact on a woman’s
health-related quality of life (HR-QOL). The NIH and EORTC advocate treatment
with breast conserving therapy (BCT) for women with early stage breast cancer. The
aim of this study was to understand the shared surgical decision-making process
from the patients’ perspective by implementing qualitative methods. Methods:
All participants were recruited and consented from a single center. Inclusion criteria
included women who selected BCT over mastectomy. Utilizing an interview guide,
women were asked to share their experience with all aspects of decision-making
related to breast cancer treatment. Interviews were audio-taped, transcribed, and
coded with NVIVO8. Qualitative data were further analyzed to identify factors
influencing decision-making regarding BCT. A comparative matrix analysis was
conducted to further evaluate women’s appraisal of their surgical decision-making process and how this impacted their long-term HR-QOL. Results: Nineteen
patients were included in the analysis. The mean age was 58.3 (+ 12.2) years, 52.9%
were married, 84.2% were Caucasian, 68.4% were currently employed and 31.6%
had a family history of breast cancer, 10.4% diagnosed with Stage 0, 52.6% stage
I and 36.8% stage II breast cancer. Factors contributing to decision-making were
dichotomized into satisfied (n= 11) or dissatisfied (n= 8). Satisfied patients were
further categorized as either (i) positive outlook n= 2; (ii) acceptance of choice n= 9;
Dissatisfied patients were further categorized as (i) experiencing regret n= 4; (ii) fear
of recurrence n= 4. Conclusions: As decision-making needs vary by individual
women, a personalized decision-making approach is an essential factor to improve
HR-QOL among women with early stage breast cancer. Additional prospective quantitative studies of the preoperative decision-making and post-operative HR-QOL are
necessary, as these findings may compliment existing outcomes research.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Multiple myeloma is common in older adults and its incidence increases
after the age of 60 (under the age of 40, it occurs rarely, < 2%). In SK approx. 400 new
cases have been diagnosed and in the treatment there is in average 1500 patients.
Research aim was to find out the impact of the disease on particular items of Quality
of patients´ lives. Methods: Sample: research consisted of pacienti diagnosed with
the disease of multiple myeloma. We distributed 120 questionnaires and compiled 82
questionnaires (68,33%). There were 36 men (43,90%) and 46 women (56,10%). Their age
was between 40 and more. We utilised standardised questionnaire of quality of life,
Quality of Life-BREF (WHOQOL-BREF). Its first part included 24 items in four domains
(physical health, psychological health, social relationships, and environment) and two
items of overall evaluation. Numerical scales were signed in the answers in the following way: the least auspicious answer had the smallest value and the most auspicious
answer had the biggest numerical value (range 1 – 5). The results of respondents were
compared to population norms of the WHOQOL-BREF domains. Results: In majority
of items, the answers of the respondents do not differ very much in comparison with
the average score of WHOQOL-BREF. Two items mostly differ from the average score
most: domain of physical health – pain, where the average of 2.5 lowered in comparison to population norm of 4.03. The domain psychological health – negative emotions: where the average of 2.00 was lower in comparison to the population norm of
3.47. Conclusions: Prompt diagnostics of multiple myeloma significantly increases
the possibility of the treatment to be successful. It also prolongs and improves quality
of patient life. Research finding points out the reality that MM does not have the same
impact on all domains of quality of life.
PCN209
Quality of Life in Patients With Lung Cancer in the Slovak Republic
CANCER – Health Care Use & Policy Studies
1Trencin
Bielik J 1, Matisakova I 2, Kucerkova P 2, Mastiliakova D 1, Melus V 2
University, Trencin, Slovak Republic, 2Trencin University of Alexander Dubcek, Trencin,
Slovak Republic
PCN212
Evidence-Based Medicine as a Driver of Improving Colorectal
Cancer Screening in Ukraine
Objectives: The current incidence and mortality of lung cancer (LC) in adult
patients in Slovakia ranges from about 57.3 resp. 50.3 in men and 10.6 resp. 7.6
in women per 100000 inhabitants. The lung cancer has a great impact on quality
1State
.
.
.
.
.
Rubtsova I 1, Melnyk Y 2
Expert Center of the Ministry of Health of Ukraine, Kyiv, Ukraine, 2The State Expert Center
of the Ministry of Health of Ukraine, Kyiv, Ukraine
.
.
A652
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: Colorectal cancer (CRR) is an important public health problem. The
human and financial costs of this disease have prompted considerable research
efforts to evaluate the ability of screening tests to detect the colorectal cancer at
an early curable stage. It is now established that screening by faecal occult blood
test (FOBT) in average-risk populations can detect asymptomatic colorectal cancers
and precancerous lesions (high-risk adenomas). Methods: We have reviewed the
evidence about the quality, accessibility, and cost of screening using the FOBT to
reduce colorectal cancer mortality. Such databases as Medline, PubMed, EMBASE
were used. Results: Faecal occult blood test screening benefits include reduction in CRR mortality, possible reduction in cancer incidence through detection
and removal of colorectal adenomas and potentially, treatment of early colorectal
cancers may involve less invasive surgery. Thus, implementation of biennial faecal
occult blood test screening is an efficient use of health resources. Conclusions:
The main objective for the improvement of cancer patients’ care is the introduction
of national colorectal cancer screening programs based on evidence and available to
people across the country. Introduction of clinical and cost-effectiveness screening
methods in Ukraine and coordination of Ukrainian and world practices will provide
timely and effective medical care for patients with CRR. In order to integrate these
approaches into clinical practice based on evidence the clinical protocols are being
developed.
PCN213
A Comprehensive Assessment of Early Trial Evidence in Primary
Breast Cancer: How Decisions Change Over Time
Dequen P , Cooper N J , Abrams K R
University of Leicester, Leicester, UK
.
.
.
.
.
Background: There is ongoing debate over the extension of accelerated
approval and conditional market authorisation initiatives, particularly for
new cancer drugs in the US and Europe. This raises concerns for the benefitrisk assessments of both regulators and payers when relying on early trial
evidence. Methodological issues relating to immature clinical data and
short-term follow-up, as well as the potential use of surrogate endpoints,
may undermine these assessments and the resulting decisions made under
conditions of uncertainty. In the context of health technology assessments
(HTA) in the UK, we considered the impact on the probabilities of being the
most effective and cost-effective treatment when reviewing available evidence along the drug development and assessment processes. Objectives:
To conduct a retrospective analysis of four NICE technology appraisals in primary breast cancer for HER-2 positive women alongside a simulation study to
evaluate the relative effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of selected drugs over
time. Methods: We extracted data from TA107, TA108, TA109 and TA112 to analyse ‘snapshots’ of evidence at different time-points. Based on this example, we
simulated individual patient characteristics and progression-free survival (PFS)
times according to a predefined recruitment timeline. For both applied and simulated datasets, we combined a network-meta-analysis and three-stage Markov
economic model in WinBUGS to predict the joint impact of growing evidence networks on HTA results. The model allowed for different assumptions regarding the
extrapolation of and the correlation between PFS and overall survival. Results:
The magnitudes of credible intervals depended heavily upon the level of restriction
used for follow-up. In addition, the performance of PFS as a surrogate endpoint
strongly relied on the assumptions made on the correlation between the two
endpoints. Conclusions: Our analysis highlighted the inherent limitations and
risks of early assessments with a substantial increase in the uncertainty of treatment acceptability at thresholds of £20K and £30K.
PCN214
Expert Elicitation Used for Early Technology Assessment to Inform
on Cost-Effectiveness of Next Generation Sequencing
Retèl V P 1, Joosten S E 1, van Harten W H 2
1Netherlands Cancer Institute, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 2University of Twente, Enschede, The
Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Next Generation Sequencing (NGS) promises to find mutations
(targets) in individual cancer patients, to subsequently assign targeted therapy.
Currently, the technology itself is still in development and the effects on disease
development, prognosis, or choice of therapy are still unclear. Besides information for the current patient, additional (secondary) information for future patients
can also become available. To accelerate the reimbursement process and have a
NGS-panel available for patients in the earliest possible stage, early Technology
Assessment (TA) is ongoing. In this project, we report on expert elicitation by
means of scenario drafting, to provide qualitative and quantitative data to fill
the evidence gaps in early cost-effectiveness modeling. Methods: The following steps in a multi-parameter framework can be distinguished: 1) Identifying
(dynamic) aspects having impact on adoption; 2) Brainstorm on possible scenarios (informal interviews with NGS experts); 3) Scenario construction; 4)
Validation of scenarios (semi-structured questionnaires to European NGS-experts);
5) Quantification into parameters for cost-effectiveness modeling. Results:
Based on the interviews and questionnaires (n= 29), the most likely scenarios as
patients interest in NGS (likelihood 66,5% ±28,1); organizational readiness (84,4
±18,5); advantage of including RNA, and the demand from the clinic (needs of
medical staff) were identified as drivers for NGS development. Possible barrier
scenarios were: number of actionable targets (55,2 ±23,7); demonstrating clinical
utility (50,4 ±31,4); current evidence generation (65,5 ±27,9); consensus on panel
for reimbursement (40,3% ±24,1); and competition within the field (64,2 ±21,9).
Clustering into parameters for cost-effectiveness modeling resulted in: “failures”,
“compliance”, “uptake”, and “future information”. Conclusions: Although there
are many issues to overcome to adopt NGS, the likelihood of NGS incorporation in
clinical practice is very high. The “additional future information” is the most interesting but complex variable to identify and to incorporate in cost-effectiveness
modeling.
PCN215
Next Generation Sequencing Technology: Health Technology
Assessment, Market Access Trends and Potential Impacts on The
Future of Companion Diagnostic Testing
Faulkner E C 1, Spinner D S 2, Ransom J F 3, Paul A 4, Chawla A S 5, Doyle J J 6, Shaw W H 2,
Fitzgerald J T 2
1Institute for Pharmacogenomics and Individualized Therapy, Eshelman School of Pharmacy,
University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC, USA, 2Quintiles, Durham, NC, USA, 3Quintiles
Global Consulting, Hawthorne, NY, USA, 4Quintiles Global Consulting, Durham, NC, USA,
5Quintiles Consulting, Durham, NC, USA, 6Quintiles, Hawthorne, NY, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Next Generation Sequencing (NGS) offers a potentially powerful platform for extremely sensitive, high-throughput, multiplex, quantitative detection of
nucleic acid biomarkers. While NGS currently represents a small portion of global
clinical molecular diagnostic testing, new funding and reimbursement initiatives
promise to accelerate its clinical utilization. Given increasing numbers of predictive/ prognostic biomarkers but limited tissue and need for less invasive sample
acuisition, NGS has the potential to transform personalized medicine (PM) and
companion diagnostics. The current study characterized global NGS availability and
reimbursement trends. Health technology assessments (HTAs) for NGS and other
relevant multiplex/ gene panel tests were also studied for evolving evidence requirements. Methods: Key health care provision, HTA agency, and payer websites in the
EU, US, Australia and Canada were reviewed to identify NGS funding and reimbursement initiatives, and relevant HTAs. In addition, a limited number of stakeholder
interviews were conducted to help further characterize the evolving global NGS
landscape. Results: A number of NGS funding and reimbursement initiatives
were identified, especially France, Germany, UK, US and Australia. Initiatives have
been mainly centered on funding of pilot clinical utility demonstrations through
research and clinical use. In Germany and US, specific initiatives are underway to
develop specific NGS reimbursement codes and payment rates. A number of HTAs
for NGS and other multiplex/ gene panel test platforms were identified, primarily for
oncology, cardiovascular, infectious disease, inherited disease, and neuropsychiatry
applications. Key HTA concerns include test clinical utility, cost-effectiveness, realworld reproducibility and equity of access given potential cost. Conclusions:
Payers and providers increasingly recognize NGS as enabling expanded adoption
of PM approaches. As PM expands with increasing numbers of clinically actionable
biomarkers, ensuring that test evidence development is aligned with expectations,
and expectations with reality are key steps. Further, developing reimbursement/
funding mechanisms to support testing uptake will be critical in all markets.
PCN216
How is Research and Development Innovation Evolving? Focus on
Oncology and Cardiovascular Disease
Coulton K , Savi L
HERON Commercialisation, London, UK
.
.
By 2030, 50% of all deaths are expected to be caused by oncology, or cardiovascular
diseases. Research and development therefore continues to evolve in these areas to
provide a better answer to complex medical needs. As a consequence, the definition
of innovation is evolving, going from therapeutic drugs with a new mode of action
to novel biotechnologies, biological therapeutics, and vaccination. Objectives:
We aim to investigate how therapies for oncology and cardiovascular diseases are
expected to evolve in future into technologies that transform the concept of innovation. Methods: Data were extracted from Citeline to assess the scale of therapies
in development including: vaccines, stem cells, antibodies, reformulation of combination therapy, gene therapy and RNAi. Results: In oncology, across the selected
novel therapies, there are over 670 trials in preclinical to phase 3 of development.
Vaccines have a higher rate of development with over 200 products in preclinical
development to phase 3. Other areas of development include antibodies, and gene
therapy, with over 30 therapies in phase 2 trials alone. Meanwhile, cardiovascular
disease has fewer ongoing ‘novel therapy’ trials compared to oncology (around 75%
fewer trials). The main areas of development include reformulation of fixed dose
combinations, and stem cell research (a total of 60 trials, and 53 trials in preclinical
to phase 3 respectively). The trend in innovation for cardiovascular disease instead
tends to be focussed on integrated technology and medical devices. Conclusions:
While we are fairly acquainted with the current evaluation methods and relevance
of clinical and economic evidence of traditional therapies, the emergence of new
technologies creates uncertainties around how they will be assessed by payers. For
example, demonstrating the value of vaccines (which avoid illness) is difficult to
express. Industry must now consider factors outside of the current remit to prepare
for successful market access.
PCN217
5-Year Survival is not an Appropriate Indicator for Cancer Control
in the Population: Revisiting the Issue Based on UK Data
Wen Y 1, Li S Q 1, Pan X F 1, Wang Y Y 2, Luo H J 3, Zhao Z M 1, Zhao Y 1, Chang H 1, Xue Q P 1, Yang
CX1
1Sichuan University, Chengdu, China, 2epartment of Epidemiology and Statistics, Institute of Basic
Medical Sciences Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences, Beijing, China, 3China CDC, Beijing, China
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: It is controversial to use 5-year survival estimates to assess the progress in cancer prevention and control. The study aimed to analyze associations
between 5-year survival, and two standard measures of cancer burden, incidence
and mortality, based on publicly available population cancer statistics in England
and Wales. Methods: Sex-specific mortality and incidence of 14 types of common cancer between 1976 to 1995 were obtained from a national database on
the UK Office for National Statistics website. Sex-specific 5-year survival data
retrieved from the Cancer Research UK website databases. The relationships
between 5-year survival, and incidence and mortality were estimated based on
both Pearson and Spearman correlation coefficients. Results: From 1976 to 1995,
all male and female cancer types showed increased 5-year survival, ranged from
0.2% (pancreas and lung cancers) to 16.6% (prostate cancer) for males, and from
A653
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
0.2% (pancreas cancer) to 16.6% leukemia for females. Inconsistent changes were
noticed for either incidence or mortality of different cancers. There were no statistically significant correlations between change in 5-year survival, and change
in incidence and mortality for either male or female cancers during this period.
When other time periods were considered for analysis, statistically significant
correlations were noticed between change in 5-year survival and incidence of
male cancers from 1981 to 1995 (Pearson r= 0.68; P= 0.03) and from 1986 to 1995
(Pearson r= 0.78; P= 0.007). However, when the two mostly overdiagnosed cancers
(prostate and breast) were excluded, there were no correlations between change
in 5-year survival, and change in incidence and mortality for the three time periods. Conclusions: Our study shows no reliable relationships between changes
in 5-year survival and incidence or mortality. The increase in 5-year survival might
not represent progress in cancer control, but instead indicate improved diagnosis
and treatment in clinical practice.
PCN218
Assessment of Lung Cancer Treatment by Disease Phase Using
National Cancer Registry Data Linked with Treatment Pathway
cost Data in Austria
Zauner G 1, Popper N 1, Breitenecker F 2
GmbH, Vienna, Austria, 2Vienna University of Technology, Vienna, Austria
.
.
.
1dwh
Objectives: Pilot study for evaluation of record linking and potential analysis of
combination of epidemiologic cancer registry data and personalized pathway of
care identified by billing data using lung cancer as test illness for Austrian datasets in the years 2006 till 2011. Methods: Data sets are linked by anonymized
distinct social insurance numbers of approximately 85 percent of all detected
incident lung cancer patients in Austria in the years 2006 till 2011 with billing
data on single person level. The calculated dataset deals as starting point for the
analysis of the remaining lifetime distribution depending on age and TNM – state.
Analysis of care classified by eight main categories given in hospitals coded by the
MEL-system in combination with treatment using defined drugs is analysed and
reported for further interpretation by the experts. An exploratory data analysis on
the socio-economic standard and regional differences in Austrian federal states
complete the pilot study. Results: Data for the whole Austrian health insured
population, including incident cases for lung cancer over a time span of two years
were analysed for the following chronic diseases detected by predefined rules
on hospital diagnoses and drug prescription in the one year preceding patient
history: COPD, diabetes and psychiatric illnesses. For the detected 6616 patients
the probability of surviving is calculated and visualized by Kaplan-Meier-Curves.
Exemplarily the one year survival is given: 75,44% and the 3-years life expectancy:
~1% Further results combining different influence factors on survival including
data from the cancer registry information table are performed. Conclusions:
Combining data collected by the national epidemiological cancer registry system
and personalized pathways of patient treatment in intramural and extramural care
provides a broad basis for analysis concerning real world pathway comparison
of cancer patients. This work can unlock potential in respect of defining clinical
national cancer registries.
PCN219
An Italian Oncology Research to Evaluate Adherence to Clinical
Guidelines for Cancer Treatment: The Right Program
Sgarbi S 1, Simoni L 1, Ori A 1, Fiori G G 2, Maiello E 3, Barni S 4
1Medidata srl, Modena, Italy, 2MEDIDATA SRL, MODENA, Italy, 3IRCCS Casa Sollievo della
Sofferenza; Associazione Italiana di Oncologia Medica, Foggia, Italy, 4Ospedale TreviglioCaravaggio; Associazione Italiana di Oncologia Medica, Treviglio, BG, Italy
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Clinical oncology societies develop and regularly update evidencebased guidelines in order to achieve more reliable and updated tools for patient
management. In 2004 AIOM (Italian Association of Medical Oncology) created the
RIGHT program: Research for the Identification of the most effective and hIGHly
accepted clinical guidelines for cancer Treatment. It aims to evaluate the concordance between AIOM breast (BC), colorectal (CRC) and lung (LC) cancer guidelines
and clinical practice in Italian cancer centers. Methods: the RIGHT program is
composed by three retrospective observational studies, one for each guideline,
conducted in a sample of 35 (BC) +37 (CRC) +53 (LC) Italian centers for cancer
care representative of 230 AIOM centers. Site sampling from AIOM database was
stratified by geographic distribution (North, Center, South). Indicators were identified to verify the concordance between AIOM guidelines and clinical practice
about staging and treatment. Patients were included if they had their first visit
at the site after guideline emission. Patients were then followed-up for at least
6 months. Results: Patients enrolled for the breast, colorectal and lung cancer
guideline evaluation were 324, 326, and 708, respectively. Adherence was on average 69% for BC, 76% for CRC and 69% for LC. For CRC adherence was 78% for colon,
69% for rectal cancer and 83% for advanced disease. For BC, the lowest degree
of compliance (0%) was observed for the follow-up indicator in asymptomatic
patients. For LC, on average 67%, 46% and 81% of stage I-II-IIIA, IIIB and IV patients
respectively received recommended care according to defined lung cancer indicators Conclusions: The RIGHT program showed that guidelines adherence
is generally high, with very few cases of low adhererence. Guidelines adherence
monitoring and update represent crucial activity to get more useful instrument
to plan health care interventions.
PCN220
Which is More Important for Doctors in a Low-Middle Income
Country: a National Guideline or the Medical Literature? A
Guideline Adherence Survey of Trastuzumab use for Breast Cancer
in iran
Ansaripour A 1, Uyl-de Groot C 1, Foroozanfar M 2, Rahimi Moghadam S 3, Redekop W 1
1Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 2Gilan University of Medical
Sciences, Lahijan, Iran, 3Iran Social Security Organization, Tehran, Iran
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Most national standard therapeutic guidelines recommend a 52-week
trastuzumab regimen for breast cancer treatment. In contrast, the Iranian national
guideline (published by the Ministry of Health) recommends a nine-week regimen. We
assessed the differences between current routine practice amongst Iranian specialists
and the guidelines for trastuzumab treatment and HER2 receptor testing in breast
cancer. Methods: 128 Iranian hematology oncologists and radiotherapy oncologists
were asked to complete an online anonymous questionnaire. Concurrently, a 3-year
retrospective claims database analysis was conducted using data from the Social
Security Organization, a health insurer which covers approximately 50% of the Iranian
population, to enable comparisons with the questionnaire results. Results: With
a 41% (52/128) response rate, doctors reported a relatively high absolute adherence
(86%) to the guideline for HER2 receptor testing but a low rate of absolute adherence
(6%) to the guideline for duration of trastuzumab treatment. Doctors indicated that
the planned duration was 9 weeks in only 32% of patients; in most cases, the plan
was 52-week treatment. Patients with a 9-week treatment plan received trastuzumab
for 8.6 weeks on average while patients with 52-week plans received treatment for
29.2 weeks. The general trends found in the survey were confirmed in the claims
database analysis of 830 HER2 positive patients. Conclusions: When it comes to
trastuzumab use, Iranian doctors appear to rely more on the medical literature than
on national guidelines developed by the Ministry of Health. Policymakers, doctors
and the general public should try to reach some consensus about the optimal way to
treat eligible patients. This is particularly necessary in low-middle income countries,
whose limited budget cannot easily accommodate all of the innovative technologies
to come. Inventive reimbursement policies may form part of the solution as long as
the experiences from other countries are examined.
PCN221
Time Savings With Transtuzumab Subcutaneous (SC) Injection
VersUS Trastuzumab Intravenous (IV) Infusion: A Time and Motion
Study in 3 Russian Centers
De Cock E 1, Pan Y I 2, Tao S 2, Baidin P 3
1United BioSource Corporation, Barcelona, Spain, 2UBC: An Express Scripts Company, Dorval, QC,
Canada, 3F. Hoffmann-La Roche Ltd., Moscow, Russia
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Trastuzumab (TRA) subcutaneous (SC) injection is an alternative to
intravenous (IV) administration for the treatment of HER2+ early breast cancer (EBC).
The objective was to quantify health care professional (HCP) time and patient chair
time related to TRA treatment to estimate potential time and cost savings with a
transition from IV to SC. Methods: A multi-centre, prospective time-and-motion
study was run in three Russian centres participating in the SafeHer clinical trial
(MO28048). Case report forms listing pre-specified tasks for IV, SC, and pharmacy
management in chronological order and tailored to site practices were used for data
collection. Trained observers recorded patient chair time and durations that HCPs
were actively completing the tasks. A random effects regression model was run for
each task to generate mean and 95% confidence intervals. IV vs. SC process time was
calculated as the sum of the mean task times. HCP and chair time were translated to
cost using Russian salary data, and 354 roubles (p) per infusion chair hour. Results:
Mean reduction in HCP time per patient session was 18.6min (-48%) (IV: 38.7min vs.
SC: 20.1min; centre range: 8.6-31.1min), of which 61% of time reduced was achieved
in the treatment room. Per treatment session (total 18 sessions), the estimated time
saving was 5.6 hours (range across centres: 2.6-9.3hours). Reduction in mean chair
time was 59.5min (-89%) (IV: 67.1min vs. SC: 7.6min; centre range: 29.8-97.3min).
The monetary value of HCP and patient chair time saved was 1,175p and 6,314p,
respectively, for 18 treatment sessions. Conclusions: Transition from IV to SC TRA
leads to substantial reductions in administration chair time, active HCP time and
associated costs. This allows more time to be used for other patient care activities,
increasing the number of patients who could be treated and thus increasing the
overall efficiency of treatment centers.
PCN222
Process Mapping to Capture Breast Cancer Patients’ Journey in
Greek Public Oncological Hospitals
Kaitelidou D 1, Kalogeropoulou M 2, Katostaras T 2, Minogiannis P 2, Skitsou A 3, Siskou O 2,
Liaropoulos L 1
1National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, Athens, Greece, 2Center for Health Services
Management and Evaluation, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, Athens, Greece,
3Frederick University, Nicosia, Cyprus
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The present study aimed to examine how breast cancer patients
proceed through the public Greek health care system by using process mapping to
identify constraints and bottlenecks and unnecessary process steps. Methods:
The sample of the study were 86 patients diagnosed with breast cancer at two
large public oncological hospitals. A process mapping study, by applying PERT
(Program Evaluation Review Technique) analysis, was conducted. Results: The
total time spent for obtaining the treatment (per os or chemotherapy) is higher up
to 7 times compared with the time spent in activities contributing directly towards
the patient’s outcome. The average time needed to complete the procedure (e.g.
physician consultation, waiting times, prescribing, obtaining pharmaceuticals)
in Hospital A was 78.65 minutes (SD= 37.43) while waiting time was 51 minutes
(64.9%). In Hospital B the respective time was 101 min (SD= 50.54) and 83.1% of that
time was the waiting time. Similarly, the average time required for chemotherapy
at Hospital A was 4 hours and 27 minutes (SD= 106.61) while the waiting time was
2 hours and 15 minutes (50.8%). In Hospital B, the average time for chemotherapy
was 3 hours 35 minutes (SD= 69.49) and 52.2% of that time was the waiting time.
Among the main reasons for the delays were the lack of electronic records and
poor function of the Central Information Prescribing System. Conclusions:
Waiting time represented the higher percentage of the total time needed to complete the process for obtaining the treatment. As it represents one of the major
causes for patient dissatisfaction, applying process mapping is a critical step for
health care organizations to improve the beneficial time and the overall quality
of the services offered.
A654
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
PCN223
A Comparison of Market Access Evaluations for new Oncology
Therapies in France, Germany and the UK: An Analysis Using the
Prismaccess Database
currently used agents, strategies such as cost-sharing to encourage payers to think
beyond the price tag, and promoting familiarity with novel agents among regional
and local payers will help optimize the market access opportunity.
Droeschel D 1, de Paz B 2, Houzelot D 2, Walzer S 3
1Riedlingen University - SRH FernHochschule Riedlingen, Riedlingen, Germany, 2PRIORITIS Market
Access, Paris, France, 3MArS Market Access & Pricing Strategy GmbH, Weil am Rhein, Germany
PCN226
Pricing and Reimbursement Analysis of Bacillus Calmette-Guérin
(BCG) Immunotherapy for Bladder Cancer
Objectives: In recent years (2011-2014) various new oncology therapies were
launched and evaluated by the different market access authorities. The international Prismaccess database includes all evaluations and decisions by the respective authorities in France, Germany and the UK. Methods: All decisions for new
oncology therapies which were evaluated by the authorities in France, Germany
and UK were systematically searched for. A comparison was executed with a
focus on reimbursement decision, basis of decision, acceptance of submitted
clinical endpoints, study designs, comparator, quality of life and indirect treatment comparison (ITC). Results: In total there were 23 new oncology therapies
being evaluated in the three countries. In France 10 decisions were positive (ASMR
I-III), further 6 of minor improvement (ASMR IV), 20 were positive in Germany
(n= 3 ‘significant’; n= 6 ‘considerable’; n= 9 ‘minor’; n= 2 ‘non-quantifiable’ added
benefit) and 4 were positive in England and 5 in Scotland. In 2 cases, respectively
the assessment was positive (different magnitude) or negative in all countries.
26% (n= 6) it was similar in at least three countries. (n= 5 positive decisions; n= 1
negative decision). In case overall survival was the primary endpoint the likelihood was higher in all countries for a positive decision. Key differences in terms
of decisions were given in acceptance of ITCs, comparator as standard of care and
ratings for cost-effectiveness. Conclusions: Using the Prismaccess database the
analysis shows that there might be key differences in terms of evaluation criteria
between the three countries analysed. In Germany a key focus is given on the
appropriate comparator(s) and patient-relevant endpoints. In the UK and Scotland
cost-effectiveness might trump a positive benefit assessment. In France the key
drivers are not only the severity of the pathology (for tumours, 25% of SMR are not
substantial), but also efficacy/adverse events ratio, Effective amount, Comparator
choice and Therapeutic strategy.
Bekcic S 1, Mitrovic I 2, Baltezarevic D 3, Radojevic V 4, Samardzic J 5, Milenkovic V6
of Virology, Vaccines and Sera, Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro, 2Institute of Virology,
Vaccines and Sera “Torlak”, Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro, 3Pharmacoeconomics Section of
the Pharmaceutical Association of Serbia, Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro, 4Clinical Centre,
Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro, 5University of Belgrade, Medical Faculty, Belgrade, Serbia and
Montenegro, 6University of Belgrade, Faculty of Pharmacy, Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro
.
.
.
.
PCN224
Current Status of Reimbursement Decisions for Orphan Drugs or
Cancer Drugs and Implementation for Access Schemes in Korea
Kim Y , Na Y , Yim E , Kim J , You M Y
Health Insurance Review & Assessment Service, Seoul, South Korea
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Korean government has been making efforts to improve the access
of orphan drugs or cancer drugs to patients since it is difficult for these drugs
to be reimbursed due to its high price or lack of clinical evidence. We aim to
investigate the current status of reimbursement and reviewed related schemes
in Korea. Methods: Appraisal results for orphan or cancer drugs during 7 years
(2007~2013) were included and recommendation rate, final listing rate and order of
entry among 8 countries were analyzed. Results: Total 331 were recommended to
be reimbursed in overall 467 appraisal results (71%), whereas 74 was recommended
to be reimbursed among 121 results for orphan or cancer drugs (61%), indicating
that it was less likely to be recommended for those drugs. Fifty eight orphan or
cancer drugs (48%) were finally listed through NHIC negotiation process. For cancer
drugs, recommendation and listing rate seem to increase from 47% to 64% and 32%
to 48% (2008~2010 vs 2011~2013), respectively. Those drugs have been reimbursed
in the 4.86th place among 8 countries including Korea on the average. Besides, 15
drugs considered as rule of rescue in those drugs have been listed for reimbursement. Conclusions: We identified that orphan or cancer drugs has been more
accessible to patients as time goes. As the benefit enhancement plan for four major
diseases (2013) and the Risk Sharing scheme (2013) have been implemented, it is
expected for the coverage for those drugs in Korean National Health Insurance to
be widened through these schemes.
PCN225
Market Access Levers and Barriers for Key Oncology Agents in the
EU5: Surveyed Oncologist and Interviewed Payer Insights
Cox J , Nawaz K
Decision Resources Group, London, UK
.
.
Objectives: Health technology assessment (HTA), pricing and reimbursement
(P&R) processes, and cost-containment strategies in France, Germany, Italy, Spain,
and the UK, are increasingly stringent. This study explored the resulting impact on
high-cost oncology brands, and carved out specific market access levers and barriers. Methods: Across the EU5, 500 medical or hematological oncologists were surveyed regarding their current and expected prescribing patterns, and 30 payers who
influence reimbursement at national or regional level were interviewed. Results:
Some 68-83% of surveyed oncologists in France, Italy, Spain, and the UK, and 44%
in Germany report that the average time taken by their health care authority to
review newly approved cancer treatments and settle reimbursement terms delays
availability for prescribing by ≥ 6 months. Thereafter, country-specific prescribing
restrictions impede uptake; e.g., 18% of German hematologists surveyed report
that their indicative prescribing budget prevents use of ponatinib in > 20% of their
chronic myeloid leukemia patients, while 30% of Italian medical oncologists say the
national oncology drugs register monitoring use of costly agents severely restricts
prescribing of erlotinib and gefitinib for non-small-cell lung cancer. Interviewed
payers stress, however, that well-designed pivotal trials considering increasing focus
on added benefit over direct comparators will help optimize HTA and P&R terms,
with those in Italy and the UK, especially, advocating cost-sharing schemes to secure
market entry. Furthermore, demonstrable downstream cost savings, locally targeted
marketing campaigns, and manufacturer estimates of patient population size to aid
regional/local budget planning are specified as uptake levers. Conclusions: HTA
and P&R demands and tightening budgets negatively impact prescribing of costly
oncology brands in the EU5. However, clear demonstration of robust benefits over
.
.
.
.
.
1Institute
Objectives: The objective of the analysis was to assess the pricing and reimbursement possibilities, as well as the budget impact, of a new medicine for bladder
cancer immunotherapy. Methods: We investigated the number of medicines
for bladder cancer immunotherapy that were registered and listed in the period
between March 2011 and March 2014, in Serbia. We also made pharmacoeconomics analysis that would be a part of the Health Insurance Fund submission
file. Results: According to the European Association of Urology (EAU) Guidelines
for non-muscle invasive bladder cancer (NMIBC) there are several bladder preservation strategies available: intravesical immunotherapy, intravesical chemotherapy, device-assisted therapy and combination therapy. In Serbia, there are three
medicines listed for chemotherapy (doxorubicin, epirubicin and mitomycin) and
one for intravesical immunotherapy (BCG). BCG has become the standard of care
for high-grade NMIBC and carcinoma in-situ (CIS) and is superior to intravesical
chemotherapy in reducing recurrences, in preventing or delaying progression of the
disease. Radical cystectomy should be considered after BCG treatment failure, when
BCG is contraindicated or not available. BCG is reimbursed in Serbia (wholesale
price: 79,18€ ) but due to continuous shortages of registered BCG from May 2012,
non-registered BCG was also listed (price: not defined). Still there was no import,
due to worldwide shortages. The absence of the treatment encouraged the Serbian
Institute of Virology, Vaccines and Sera “Torlak” to develop BCG for immunotherapy.
As the price proposal for new medicine would be 55,43€ , expenses per patient per
year would be 498,87€ and total costs for 520 patients would be 259.412,40€ , it is
projected that total savings would be 111.150,00€ per year. Market share of domestic
BCG would be 0,29% of total B list (hospital medicines) budget. Conclusions: The
future aim is to develop, register and list domestic BCG that would provide lower
costs per patient, high quality, availability and the continuous immunotherapy.
PCN227
The Expanding Value Footprint of Oncology Treatments
Rejon-Parrilla J C 1, Hernández-Villafuerte K 1, Shah K 1, Mestre-Ferrandiz J 1, Garrison L 2,
Towse A 1
1Office of Health Economics, London, UK, 2University of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To provide a better understanding of: how changes in the use of an
oncology medicine can affect its aggregate value; how different HTA systems have
assessed these value expansions; and whether there is a link between value expansions and use. Methods: We examine all oncology medicines approved by the
EMA between 2003 and 2005 – giving a sample of 10 medicines. Our framework sets
out seven possible value expansions beyond an initial approved indication: different cancer type; different disease stage; different treatment line/stage; different
treatment regimen; orphan designation; patient sub-population; and new route of
administration. We then assessed how HAS (France), NICE (England and Wales), and
Aetna (US) have recognised these value expansions. Finally, we analysed IMS data
(2004-2013) on prices, volumes and sales for the five of the medicines. Results:
Seven of the 10 medicines in the sample have additional value expansions following
initial indication. Many are now used for indications that are very different from
their original indication. Most of the HAS assessments resulted in the drug being
reimbursed but the rewards to the manufacturers were in many cases relatively low
because few of the recommended drugs were given low “improvement in medical
service” (ASMR) levels. The majority of NICE appraisals (63%) resulted in the drug/
indication not being recommended for use in the NHS. Generally, the UK had lower
prices, volumes and sales than France and the US (with some exceptions). The
comparisons between France and the US were a little more equivocal. There is a
mixed picture in terms of the correlation between NICE/HAS recommendations and
sales in the UK/France. We observe a link between expansions in licensed indications and changes in sales. Conclusions: Health systems and policy makers need
to recognise how product life-cycle considerations affect the value of medicines,
and in particular, oncology medicines.
PCN228
Impact of Introducing Costs/Qaly Threshold on Access to Oncology
Medicines in Slovakia
Psenkova M 1, Mackovicova S 1, Tomek D 2
1Pharm-In Ltd, Bratislava, Slovak Republic, 2Slovak Medical University, Bratislava, Slovak
Republic
.
.
.
Objectives: In December 2011, a threshold value of costs/QALY was introduced
to Slovak legislation. The aim of this work is to assess its impact on inclusion of
oncology drugs to the reimbursement system and their availability in clinical
practice. Methods: We evaluated the inclusion of oncology drugs to the reimbursement system based on data from the website of the Ministry of Health SR.
We analysed the consumption of drugs based on the National Health Information
Centre database. We acquired information about registered oncology drugs on the
EMA website. We determined the level of availability of oncology drugs in clinical practice via a qualitative survey among oncologists. Results: The success
rate of including new oncology drugs in Slovakia was high in 2000-2011. From the
62 oncology drugs registered in this period by the EMA, 48 were included to the
Reimbursement List. Innovative oncology drugs were included relatively quickly
A655
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
to reimbursements, causing a significant growth in costs. Expenses for oncology in
2003-2011 increased by 718% (from € 15.4 million to € 125.7 million). In December
2011, a cost/QALY threshold was introduced to legislation, creating a barrier to
the inclusion of oncology drugs to the Reimbursement list. Following adoption of
this legislation, of the 12 drugs registered by the EMA, only 3 oncology drugs were
included to the List during 2012-2014. Uncategorized drugs are available only for a
limited number of patients by way of individual exceptions, or by participation in
clinical trials. Conclusions: In Slovakia, the willingness to pay for an additional
unit of health was anchored in legislation, which greatly limited the availability of
innovative oncological treatment. The health system in Slovakia needs to introduce efficient and transparent mechanisms that enable the treatment of oncology
patients in line with the latest medical findings, while keeping expenses for treatment within economic possibilities.
PCN229
Innovation May Drive Streamlined Access to New
Biopharmaceuticals Across Some Emea Markets
Gardiner R B , White R
Access Partnership, London, UK
.
.
.
Objectives: Across geographies, approval, pricing and reimbursement of pharmaceuticals take place under varying timelines with different outcomes. There
are some countries that may obtain access to new pharmaceuticals through early
access schemes. Breakthrough and innovative products that are thought to have a
profound impact on current standard of care are often eligible for quicker routes to
access. This research sought to investigate how these schemes worked, where they
were prevalent, and the outcomes of such schemes. Methods: The research was
conducted through in-depth interviews with payers and clinicians across 10 EMEA
markets. Results: Of the 10 markets studied, 5 countries were identified to have
either easier or quicker routes to access for new biopharmaceuticals (e.g., ATU in
France and Algeria, law 648/96 in Italy, non-formulary access in Saudi Arabia, and
the “white list” in Norway). Most often, these routes were reserved for products with
orphan indications or products that were believed to significantly impact current
standard of care. If pharmaceutical companies opt for the streamlined route, there
are often significant restrictions imposed on the product, as well as a reduction
in volume. If companies elect for the standard route to approval and reimbursement, the review process is often more rigorous, however, the decision is likely
more permanent and the volume of product is larger. Frequently, if products opt
for the faster route to access, this will serve as additional evidence for getting the
product reimbursed at a later date for use in a wider population. Conclusions:
New pharmaceutical products that are likely to dramatically change the treatment
landscape or are active in orphan diseases should take advantage of these schemes.
Physicians grasp at the opportunity to use efficacious products as early as possible
and companies need to leverage the opportunity for streamlined access to products.
PCN230
Health Economic Impact of Volume Doubling Time as Biomarker in
Lung Cancer Diagnosis
Brinkhof S 1, Groen H J M 2, Siesling S 3, IJzerman M J 4
1University of Twente, MIRA Institute for Biomedical Technology & Technical Medicine,
Enschede, The Netherlands, 2University Medical Center Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands,
3Comprehensive Cancer Centre the Netherlands (IKNL), Utrecht, The Netherlands, 4MIRA
Institute for Biomedical Technology & Technical Medicine and University of Twente, Enschede, The
Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Lung cancer has a continuously bad prognosis in terms of survival
and quality of life, usually because of late detection of malignancies. Given an
expected increase in the incidence, overall mortality will increase. Early detection and efficient diagnostic planning may offer additional gain in survival. The
diagnostic pathway for patients with suspected lung cancer is characterized by a
cascade of different imaging and diagnostic modalities. The main objective of this
study is to estimate the health economic impact of diagnostic procedures and the
expected gain by volume-doubling time on low-dose CT as biomarker in suspected
lung cancer (NELSON protocol). Methods: A state-transition model is created to
simulate the pathway of lung cancer diagnostic procedures, including x-ray, diagnostic CT, PET-CT, bronchoscopy, mediastinoscopy and more. Hospital registries
and data from the National Cancer Registry were used to estimate the amount of
diagnostic procedures in a cohort of lung cancer patients. Systematic literature
search was performed to estimate the diagnostic performance of different modalities. Patient cohort is defined and the pre-test probability for malignancy is estimated through the Swensen criteria. Probabilistic sensitivity analysis is performed
using Monte Carlo Simulations. Results: Diagnostic procedures for patients with
suspected lung cancer can count up to almost € 3000 per patient. Pathway was
modeled in a microsimulated cohort through Swensen criteria, leading to a mean
chance of malignancy of 40%. Costly steps in the pathway include cervical mediastinoscopy and mutation analysis. Inclusion of NELSON protocol can lead to a
reduction in costs. Decision making per patient can reduce overuse of diagnostic
modalities. Conclusions: The diagnostic procedure for suspected lung cancer
patients is a costly pathway and can be improved with use of the NELSON screening
protocol or personalized selection of diagnostic procedures.
PCN231
How Successful Have Pediatric Investigation Plans Been In
Stimulating Research For Pediatric Cancers?
Miller K L
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, NC, USA
.
.
Objectives: The European Pediatric Medicine Regulation was created in 2007 to
encourage further drug development for pediatric diseases, by requiring pharmaceutical companies to submit pediatric investigation plans (PIPs) when submitting
the marketing application for a new drug. The objective of this study was to determine how successful this legislation had been in stimulating research in pediat-
ric cancers. Methods: Current oncology PIPs were manually extracted from the
EMA website for the study period 2007-2014. Primary variables included: indication,
applicant, decision, decision date, and date of expected completion. Indications for
approved PIPs were classified into five categories: brain tumors, diagnostics, leukemias/lymphomas, side effects, and solid tumors. Results: A total of 105 PIPs were
found; 36 of which were waivers, and 69 of which were approved. The study found
that 39% (27) of approved PIPs were indicated for solid tumors, including melanomas
and malignant tumors; 30% (21) of approved PIPs were indicated for leukemias or
lymphomas; 17% (12) of approved PIPs were indicated for chemotherapy-induced
side effects, such as anti-nausea and neuotropenia medications; 12% (8) of approved
PIPs were indicated for brain tumors; and one oncology diagnostic PIP was also
approved. The ramp-up of the PIP program was significant. PIPs approved in 2013
and the first half of 2014 accounted for 54% (37) of all PIPs approved during the study
period. Conclusions: Approved PIPs covered a wide range of pediatric cancers,
and the number of approved PIPs increased significantly over time. While the rampup of the PIP program indicated that it was successful in promoting research in
this area, serious concerns remained regarding the feasibility of the program. For
example, there were currently four trials planned for completion between 20152020 for extremely rare high grade gliomas. This limitation may compromise the
integrity of the PIP program.
PCN232
Treatment Patterns And Outcomes Of Patients Diagnosed With
Ovarian Cancer In The Netherlands: A Registry Study
Houben E 1, van Haalen H G M 2, Sparreboom W 2, Overbeek J A 1, Ezendam N 3, Pijnenborg H 4,
van Herk-Sukel M P P 1
1PHARMO Institute for Drug Outcomes Research, Utrecht, The Netherlands, 2AstraZeneca,
Zoetermeer, The Netherlands, 3Comprehensive Cancer Centre the Netherlands, Eindhoven, The
Netherlands, 4Tweesteden Ziekenhuis, Tilburg, The Netherlands
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: Little information is available on the patterns of chemotherapy regimens administered for the treatment of ovarian cancer (OC) in the Netherlands.
The objective for this study was to describe current chemotherapy patterns for OC
in the Netherlands and to evaluate survival outcomes following subsequent lines
of chemotherapy. Methods: Data from the Eindhoven Cancer Registry, including
data on all newly diagnosed cancer patients, was linked to the PHARMO Database
Network including, among other things, information on in- and outpatient drug use.
Patients diagnosed with primary OC between January 2000 and December 2010 were
selected. First and subsequent chemotherapy regimens were defined as the start of
a different (combination of) chemotherapeutic agent (s) or a gap > 42 days (or > 91
or > 183 days in sensitivity analysis) between two treatment cycles. Results: Of
the included OC patients, 70% received chemotherapy as initial treatment. Detailed
chemotherapy data were available for 261 patients, who had a mean age of 63 (SD
12) years. Pathological tumor stage was known for 77% of patients, of whom 11%,
55% and 17% of patients had disease stage II, III, and IV, respectively. In first line
chemotherapy, 76% of patients received platinum/taxane doublet chemotherapy.
Of the 161 patients receiving second line chemotherapy, platinum-containing
chemotherapy was received by 63% of patients (101 of whom 13 received platinum
monotherapy). In third line chemotherapy this was 51% (53 patients). At least eight
lines of chemotherapy were identified in 12 cases. Median survival as from diagnosis was 46 months. After second line chemotherapy, median survival remained
14 months. Conclusions: This study provides detailed information on the type
of chemotherapy regimens administered to OC patients at initial diagnosis and
during follow-up and the survival following the various chemotherapy regimens.
PCN233
The FDA Black Box Warning Does Reduce the Use of Erythropoietin
Stimulating Agents and Increases Blood Transfusions in Insured,
Low Income Cancer Patients
Noxon V 1, Bennett C 2, Wu J 3
1South Carolina College of Pharmacy – USC Campus, Columbia, SC, USA, 2University of South
Carolina College of Pharmacy, Columbia, SC, USA, 3University of South Carolina, Greenville, SC,
USA
.
.
.
Objectives: Erythropoietin stimulating agents (ESAs) are useful drugs for treating
chemotherapy related anemia to reduce the number of blood transfusions. However,
there were unrecognized toxicities of ESAs. These toxicities were finally recognized
in 2007 when the FDA issued a black box warning for ESAs. The objective of this
study is to determine the effect of the FDA black box warning on ESA use patterns and associated outcomes in insured, low-income cancer patients in South
Carolina. Methods: The merged South Carolina Central Cancer Registry-Medicaid
dataset was used to determine the trend of ESA use from 2001-2010. Female Breast,
Colorectal and Non-Small Cell Lung cancer patients were identified from the registry. Of those, their chemotherapy status was identified along with ESA use from
Medicaid medical claims. The major outcome measures were claims for use of ESAs
after chemotherapy and the blood transfusion rate. Logistic regression was used as
a quantitative method to determine if the likelihood of receiving ESA treatment was
reduced after FDA black box warning. Results: Among 1,645 patients treated with
chemotherapy from 2002-2010, the proportion of chemotherapy patients receiving
ESAs decreased from 56.47 % before the black box warning to 23.16% after black box
warning (p < 0.001). The blood transfusion rate per year during 2002-2007 remained
around 10-15% and increased to 31% in 2009. The likelihood of ESA use was reduced
by 63% after black box warning issued by FDA after adjusting for demographic and
clinical variables. Conclusions: The black box warning may have been effective
in reducing overall ESA utilization in cancer patients taking chemotherapy.
PCN234
Treatment Patterns and Costs Of Neoadjuvant Systemic Therapies
(NAT) For Early Breast Cancer (EBC): A Retrospective Claims Analysis
Chen Y J 1, Santos E 2, Schabert V 1, Antao V P 2, De A P 1, Portera C C 2, Wang Y 1, Kamath T 2
Health, Alexandria, VA, USA, 2Genentech, Inc., South San Francisco, CA, USA
.
1IMS
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A656
VA L U E I N H E A LT H 1 7 ( 2 0 1 4 ) A 3 2 3 – A 6 8 6
Objectives: NAT for eBC have potential benefits in reducing tumor size, permitting breast conservation, identifying effective adjuvant regimens, and providing
prognostic information. This study investigated the characteristics of eBC patients,
real-world utilization patterns of NAT, and health care costs from diagnosis to
primary surgery (neoadjuvant phase) using a US claims database. Methods: A
cohort from the IMS PharMetrics Plus database included female patients, aged
18+, with the first (index) breast cancer (BC) diagnosis (ICD-9-CM 174. x, 233.0)
between July 2006 and September 2012, primary surgery (mastectomy or lumpectomy) after index, continuous enrollment from 180 days before index (pre-index)
to 90 days after surgery, no pre-index diagnosis for BC or other primary cancer,
and no secondary malignancy from pre-index to surgery. Systemic therapies used
by this cohort in neoadjuvant phase were assumed as NAT. Patients with eBC
trastuzumab use were presumed HER2+. Results: Of 57,032 eligible eBC patients
(median age= 56), 2,011 (3.5%) received NAT. Patients who received NAT had primary surgery in a median of 166 days after index diagnosis vs. 21 days for patients
who did not receive NAT. Among patients receiving NAT, 485 (24.1%) had trastuzumab, with TCH (docetaxel, carboplatin, trastuzumab) and ACTH (doxorubicin,
cyclophosphamide, a taxane, trastuzumab) most frequently used (49.5% and
26.2%, respectively). FEC regimen (5-flurouracil, epirubicin, cyclophosphamide)
was used by only 5.6% trastuzumab users. From 2007 to 2011, there was a 46%
increase in proportion of trastuzumab use in NAT users (19.6% to 28.6%). Among
eBC patients receiving NAT, trastuzumab users had a higher monthly health care
cost in neoadjuvant phase ($17,425 vs. $11,422) than those without trastuzumab
use; however, the out-of-pocket spending by patients ($389 vs. $370) was similar. Conclusions: Based on these real-world data, neoadjuvant use of systemic
therapies was infrequent. Among the patients with HER2+ eBC, TCH and ACTH
were the most frequently used neoadjuvant regimens, consistent with their use
in the adjuvant setting.
PCN235
Off-Label Use of Anticancer Drugs In South Korea
Na Y , Choi Y J , Bae S, C H O MR, KIM A R , Kang I H , Chung I W , Yun M S , Lim S H , Kang K S
The Health Insurance Review and Assessment Service, Seoul, South Korea
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: The use of off-label medication is restricted by government in some
countries, because using off-label anticancer drugs has some concerns about its
efficacy and toxicity. HIRA (Health Insurance Review & Assessment Service) has the
process for the assessment and control for the off-label use of anticancer drugs in
South Korea. We would introduce the controlling for the off-label use of anticancer
drugs and evaluate the trend of off-label use in anticancer drugs. Methods: Since
Dec. 2006, HIRA has permitted off-label uses for which there is adequate evidence
for the efficacy, toxicity, and cost effectiveness. We collected the patient’s medical record data (briefly recorded response rate, major adverse effects. etc) which
updated every year from hospital. We defined 37 cancers (36 cancers, other cancer)
and preparative regimens of Hematopoietic stem cell transplantation. We calculated
the number of approved off-label regimens by year and cancer type, and the regimen
of the most widely used. Results: From Dec. 2006 to 2013, total 203 off-label regimens were approved their use in 63 hospitals (number of cumulative cases: 16,596).
From 2006 to 2012, the number of approved off-label regimen was increased (1, 3,
3, 14, 39.37, 67, respectively). In 2013, only 38 regimens were approved. Compared
with the other cancer, non-Hodgkin lymphoma (30 regimens, 15%), ovarian cancer
(10 regimens, 5%), and CLL (10 regimens, 5%) have many off-label regimens. The
regimens: “< 3 weekly> S-1 + cisplatin for gastric cancer” was the most widely used
regimens (59 hospitals, number of cumulative cases: 2,283). Conclusions: The use
of off-label anticancer drugs has been increased in South Korea since 2006. These
results suggest that the development of new drugs and the more clinical trials
should be needed in cancer disease.
PCN236
Using Innovative Modeling Analytics with Real World Data
to Develop a National Breast Cancer Screening Program in the
Kingdom of Saudi Arabia
Zamakhshary M F 1, Hassanain M 1, Farhat G N 1, Higashi M 2, Kruzikas D 2, Basulaiman M 1,
Saeedi M Y 1, Tahan F 1
1Saudi Ministry of Health, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia,, 2GE Healthcare, Barrington, IL, USA
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Objectives: To develop a national breast cancer (BC) screening program through
phased regional expansion using an advanced investment decision support
simulation model informed by real world data in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia
(KSA). Methods: An agent-based modeling simulation (ABMS) tool will represent
the KSA female population, BC burden and existing health system and project
impact of infrastructure investment options. Data are drawn from existing sources
including census, registries and health surveys; phased studies will generate real
world data on the outcomes of new clinical interventions. In Phase 1, a mobile BC
screening program was deployed in Riyadh with three mobile clinics equipped
with appropriate technology and medical staffing with the goal to screen at least
10,000 women during 2012-2014 and establish a care pathway for accurate diagnosis. The modeling and phased studies will guide the national program development by evaluating the impact of investments on BC screening rates, outcomes
and economic value. Results: The Phase 1 Riyadh program screened 12,877
females and established a care pathway model leading to 83 confirmed BC diagnoses (rate: 6.4 per 1000). Data visualization plotting breast cancer disease prevalence
and mammogram installed base identified areas of high need and low resources in
the regions of Riyadh, Hafr Al-Baten, Eastern, Al-Ahsa and Al-Jouf. The ABMS model
to be developed will evaluate the impact of investment scenarios encompassing
expansion of existing facilities and manpower, development of new radiology
centers, and implementation of additional mobile programs. Conclusions:
The Riyadh program revealed higher rate of breast cancer in the region than previously reported, emphasizing the need to ensure access for accurate diagnosis
and create a national program. Data visualization readily identified regions for
prioritized expansion. Real world data will continue to inform the ABMS model
to identify investments required to establish a national breast cancer program
across KSA.
PCN237
Differential Pharmaceutical Pricing: Are Prices Co-Related With
GDP?
Iacobucci W1, Mehta P2, Marinoni G2, Ando G2, Dall T1
1IHS, Washington, DC, USA, 2IHS, London, UK
Objectives: To assess co-relation of GDP per capita (purchasing power parity) on
pharmaceutical pricing. Methods: Based on empirical research, 18 drugs were
selected and grouped into seven therapeutic categories: (1) Blood Based Disorders; (2)
Cardiovascular Disorders; (3) Inflammatory Disorders; (4) Oncology; (5) Respiratory
Disorders (only fluticasone); (6) Diabetes; and (7) Viral Diseases Price per unit (mg, IU,
and U; at ex-factory level) data was collected from IHS PharmOnline International
(POLI) Database across 41 countries (Australia, Austria, Belgium, Brazil, Bulgaria,
Canada, China, Croatia, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France,
Germany, Greece, Hungary, India, Ireland, Italy, Japan, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg,
Morocco, The Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Russia,
Slovakia, Slovenia, South Africa, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Turkey, UK, and United
States) from 2007 to 2012. Prices were converted into Euros on a yearly exchange
rate basis and adjusted for inflation. Additionally, GDP data was collected from
World Bank for the same period. We fit the regression equation for the log price per
unit (dependent variable), log GDP per capita, generic status, strength, percentage
of population aged 65 and above, an indicator for the US market, and year (independent variables) as follows: Y (Price per Unit) = α + ∑ β i * Xi + ε . Results: eltrombopag (-0.977+.131, n= 160), filgrastim (-4.08+. 347, n= 1420), etanercept (-.253+. 227,
n= 870), adalimumab (2.52+. 128, n= 306), cetuximab (-.325+.166, n= 203), pazopanib
(-3.78+.164, n= 111), fluticasone (.559+.559, n= 108), sitagliptin (-4.00+.215, n= 413),
Stocrin (-12.75+.803, n= 556) and Truvada (-5.08+.157, n= 168) had statistically significant GDP (PPP) coefficients at the 0.01 level, whereas Tasigna, bevacizumab,
dabigatran, rivaroxaban, exenatide, liraglutide, saxagliptin, and interferon alpha
were not significant at 0.01 level. Conclusions: Our model finds varying degrees
of co-relation between GDP per capita (PPP) and price per unit. Nonetheless, sitagliptin, cetuximab, filgrastim, Stocrin, Truvada, and adalimumab exhibited highest
co-relation; they are thus most differentially priced.
PCN238
Health Care Resource Utilization (HCRU) In Hospitalized Febrile
Neutropenia (FN) Patients Treated With Chemotherapy For Solid
Tumors (ST) And Hematological Malignancies (HM) In Bulgaria
Gercheva L 1, Goranov S 2, Raynov J 3, Mihaylova Z 4, Mihaylov G 5, Karanikolov S 6, Petrova R 7
1Multiprofile Hospital for Active Treatment “Sveta Marina” EAD Varna, Varna, Bulgaria,
2University Multiprofile Hospital for Active Treatment “Sveti Georgi” EAD, Plovdiv, Bulgaria,
3Military Medical Academy-Multiprofile Hopsital for Active Treatment, Sofia, Sofia, Bulgaria,
4Military Medical Academy Multiprofile Hospital for Active Treatment Sofia, Sofia, Bulgaria,
5Specialized Hospital for Active Trea