Volume 13 • Number 7 • 2010
VA L U E I N H E A LT H
ISPOR 13th Annual European Congress
Research Abstracts
PODIUM SESSION I: HTA IN CANCER STUDIES AND METHODS
CN1
EFFICACY OF THE COMBINATION BEVACIZUMAB PLUS
CHEMOTHERAPY (BEV-CT) COMPARED TO CT ALONE IN PREVIOUSLY
UNTREATED LOCALLY ADVANCED OR METASTATIC NON-SMALL
CELL LUNG CANCER (NSCLC): SYSTEMATIC REVIEW (SR) AND
META-ANALYSIS (MA)
Botrel TEA, Clark O, Clark LGO, Paladini L, Faleiros E, Pegoretti B
MedInsight-Evidências, Campinas, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: To perform SR with MA of all randomized controlled trials (RCT)
comparing the efficacy of BEV-CT versus CT alone in previously untreated locally
advanced or metastatic NSCLC. METHODS: We searched MEDLINE, EMBASE,
LILACS, and CENTRAL among others. Primary end points were overall survival (OS)
and progression-free survival (PFS). Adverse events (AE) were analyzed. Extracted
data were combined using hazard ratio (HR) or risk ratio (RR) with 95% confidence
intervals (CI 95%). RESULTS: 544 references were identified and screened, three trials
comprising 2020 patients were included. Overall response rate (RR = 0.53; CI 95%
= 0.44 to 0.64; P < 0.00001) and PFS were higher in BEV-CT (HR = 0.71, CI 95%
= 0.63 to 0.80; P < 0.00001), however with significant heterogeneity (χ2 = 4.9, df =
2 [P = 0.09]; I2 = 59%) and (χ2 = 4.33, df = 2 [P = 0.11]; I2 = 54%), respectively.
Random-efffects model analysis favored BEV-CT. OS was higher in BEV-CT but with
significant heterogeneity (χ2 = 5.92, df = 3 [P = 0.12]; I2 = 49%) and random-effects
model analysis was not statistically significant (HR = 0.86, CI 95% = 0.71 to 1.05; P
= 0.15). Neutropenia (RR = 0.77; CI 95% = 0.65 to 0.91; P = 0.002) and febrile
neutropenia (RR = 0.42; CI 95% = 0.22 to 0.81; P = 0.009) were higher on BEV-CT.
Rates of anemia (RR = 1.41; CI 95% = 0.93 to 2.13; P = 0.1) and thrombocytopenia
(RR = 0.91; CI 95% = 0.69 to 1.20; P = 0.50) were similar. Non-hematologic toxicities
were higher on BEV-CT: hemoptysis (RR = 0.28; CI 95% = 0.09 to 0.90; P = 0.03),
hypertension (RR = 0.15; CI 95% = 0.07 to 0.30; P < 0.00001), proteinuria (RR =
0.05; CI 95% = 0.01 to 0.41; P = 0.005), venous thromboembolic events (RR = 0.87;
CI 95% = 0.51 to 1.47; P = 0.6), vomiting (RR = 0.41; CI 95% = 0.22 to 0.77; P =
0.005), rash (RR = 0.19; CI 95% = 0.04 to 0.88; P = 0.03), epistaxis (RR = 0.32; CI
95% = 0.03 to 3.10; P = 0.33) and bleeding events (RR = 0.27; CI 95% = 0.13 to
0.56; P = 0.0004). CONCLUSIONS: The combination BEV-CT increased the response
rate and PFS in patients with NSCLC. Benefits in overall survival remain uncertain,
and toxicity rates were higher in the combination group.
CN2
REAL-WORLD COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF OXALIPLATIN IN STAGE III
COLON CANCER: A SYNTHESIS OF TRIAL DATA WITH DATA FROM
DAILY CLINICAL PRACTICE
van Gils C, de Groot S, Redekop W, Uyl-de Groot C
Erasmus University, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: Previous cost-effectiveness analyses of oxaliplatin have been based on
randomized trial settings which may not reflect actual daily practice. The objective of
this study was to examine the real-world cost-effectiveness of oxaliplatin plus fluoropyrimidines versus fluoropyrimidines only, as adjuvant treatment of colon cancer.
METHODS: A Markov model was developed to estimate lifetime costs and qualityadjusted life-years (QALYs) from a hospital perspective. Dutch real-world (RW)
population-based data on use, costs, and disease-free survival after oxaliplatin use
were combined with published efficacy data from the pivotal clinical registration trial
(MOSAIC trial). Eighty-two percent of the patients in the RW study fulfilled the
MOSAIC trial eligibility criteria (“eligibles”); the other 18% (“ineligibles”) had a
poorer prognosis. The efficacy of the comparator was modelled using MOSAIC trial
results. Cost-effectiveness analyses (CEAs) were performed for four different scenarios:
1) CEA based on MOSAIC trial patients; 2) CEA using eligible RW patients; 3) CEA
using both eligibles and ineligibles, assuming that oxaliplatin had an equal effect in
both groups; and 4) CEA using eligibles and ineligibles, assuming oxaliplatin had no
effect among ineligibles. RESULTS: MOSAIC and eligible RW patients had similar
2-year disease-free survivals (79% vs. 78%). Oxaliplatin showed an incremental
QALY gain of 0.86, 0.73, 0.81, and 0.60, and incremental costs of c13,105, c13,278,
c13,225, and c13,456 in scenarios 1 to 4, respectively. The corresponding incremental
cost-effectiveness ratios (ICERs) were c15,185, c18,115, c16,254, and c22,387 in
scenarios 1 to 4, respectively. Sensitivity analyses of input parameters and model
assumptions produced only minimal differences in the estimated ICERs showing the
robustness of the model results. CONCLUSIONS: The real-world cost-effectiveness
of oxaliplatin plus fluoropyrimidine versus fluoropyrimidine for the treatment of colon
cancer can be estimated using different scenarios. We found that the various estimates
were very similar, and all suggest that oxaliplatin is cost-effective.
CN3
COST OF ABSENTEEISM DUE TO CANCER IN POLAND
1
1
2
Macioch T , Hermanowski T , Adamowicz O
1
Department of Pharmacoeconomics, Medical University of Warsaw, Warsaw, Poland;
2
HealthQuest sp.z o.o., Warsaw, Poland
OBJECTIVES: Cancer is a leading cause of death worldwide and major health
problem. It’s also a huge problem to worldwide economy due to high both direct and
indirect costs. The aim of this study was to evaluate absenteeism costs of cancer in
Poland in 2007. METHODS: Sickness absence data and data on disability were
derived by ZUS (Social Insurance Institution). Costs of lost productivity due to premature death were estimated based on regional register data on cancer mortality
(KRN—National Cancer Registry). Absenteeism costs were estimated based on gross
value added per employee derived by Central Statistical Office (GUS). The analyses
of indirect costs due to sickness absence were based on an assumption that number
of missed days includes only working days (226 days per year). Human capital
approach was used to estimate the absenteeism costs. Values are presented in Euro
(exchange rate: 1 EUR = 4.10 PLN). RESULTS: Costs of lost productivity due to
illness and disability were estimated to amount of c1081 million (c451 and c630
million, respectively). Costs of lost productivity due to premature death were estimated
to amount of c4692 million and were twice as high in male population compare to
female population (c3200 and c1492 million, respectively). The highest costs of lost
productivity due to premature death were related to lung cancer (c1331 million) followed by brain (c356 million), stomach (c314 million), and breast cancer (c259
million). Lung cancer was the leading cost of lost productivity due to premature death
in male population (c917 million), while breast cancer dominated in female population
(c255 million). CONCLUSIONS: Indirect costs of lost productivity due to cancerrelated illness, disability, and premature death are substantial to polish economy and
may account for near 0.6% of PKB loss in 2007 year.
CN4
HPV-BASED PRIMARY CERVICAL CANCER SCREENING IN GERMANY.
COST-EFFECTIVENESS RESULTS FROM A DECISION-ANALYTIC
MODELING STUDY
Sroczynski G1, Schnell-Inderst P1, Muehlberger N1, Lang K2, Aidelsburger P2, Wasem J3,
Mittendorf T4, Engel J5, Hillemanns P6, Petry K-U6, Kraemer A7, Siebert U1
1
Department of Public Health, Information Systems and HTA, UMIT—University for Health
Sciences, Medical Informatics and Technology, Hall i.T., Austria; 2CAREM GmbH, Sauerlach,
Germany; 3Institute for Healthcare Management, University of Duisburg-Essen, Essen,
Germany; 4Institute for Health Economics, University of Hanover, Hanover, Germany;
5
Munich Cancer Registry of the Munich Cancer Centre, Clinic Grosshadern, LudwigMaximilians-University, Munich, Germany; 6Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology,
Hanover Medical School, Hanover, Germany; 7School of Public Health, University of
Bielefeld, Bielefeld, Germany
OBJECTIVES: The objective of this HTA commissioned by the German Agency for
Health Technology Assessment (DAHTA@DIMDI) and the Federal Ministry of Health
was to systematically evaluate the long-term effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of
HPV-based primary cervical cancer screening for the German health care context using
a decision analytic approach. METHODS: A Markov model simulating the natural
history of cervical cancer was developed and validated for the German health care
context. Different screening strategies were evaluated, including cytology alone, HPV
testing alone or combined with cytology or with cytological triage for HPV-positive
women, and different screening intervals. German clinical, epidemiological and economic data were used. Test accuracy data were retrieved from international metaanalyses. Predicted outcomes were reduction in cervical cancer cases and deaths, life
expectancy, and discounted incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICER). a perspective
of the health care system and 3% annual discount rate were adopted. Extensive
sensitivity analyses were performed to evaluate robustness of results. RESULTS: HPVbased screening was more effective than cytology alone, with 71%–97% (depending
on screening intervals) relative reduction in cervical cancer compared to 53%–80%
for cytology. The ICER ranged between c2,600/LYG (cytology, 5-yr-interval) and
c155,500/LYG (annual HPV-testing age 30 yrs, cytology 20–29 yrs). Annual cytology, the current recommended screening strategy in Germany, was dominated by other
strategies. Increasing screening start-age to 25 yrs had no relevant loss in effectiveness
but resulted in lower costs. CONCLUSIONS: Based on our analyses, HPV-based cervical cancer screening is more effective than cytology and could be cost-effective, when
performed at intervals of 2 years or longer. For the German screening context, an
optimal screening strategy could be biennial HPV testing starting at age 30 yrs and
biennial cytology at the age 25–29 yrs. An extension to a 3-yearly screening interval
may be considered for low-risk women with good screening adherence or in populations with low HPV incidence.
© 2010, International Society for Pharmacoeconomics and Outcomes Research (ISPOR)
1098-3015/10/A239 A239–A480
A239
A240
PODIUM SESSION I: DEVELOPMENTS IN QUESTIONNAIRES
EQ-5D AND SF-6D
EQ1
PSYCHOMETRIC COMPARISON OF EQ-5D AND EQ-5D-5L IN STUDENT
POPULATION
Golicki D1, Zawodnik S1, Janssen MF2, Kiljan A1, Hermanowski T1
1
Department of Pharmacoeconomics, Medical University of Warsaw, Warsaw, Poland;
2
EuroQol Group, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: The new five-level version of the EQ-5D is now officially available. a
pilot five-level version of EQ-5D questionnaire was successfully tested in patients with
cancer. Other studies, using the official EQ-5D-5L, in moderately or severely disabled
populations of patients with stroke, diabetes, injury, or psychiatric conditions are
under way. Nothing is known about how EQ-5D-5L performs in relatively young and
healthy populations. Aim of the study was to compare a polish version of the threelevel EQ-5D questionnaire (3L) with the five-level version (5L) in a student population.
METHODS: In March 2010, all students from the Faculty of Pharmacy, Medical
University of Warsaw were surveyed with a set of HRQoL questionnaires (5L,
EQ-VAS, SF-36, and 3L). We examined percentage of reported problems, proportion
and size of logical inconsistencies, ceiling effect, redistribution properties, convergent
validity with SF-36 domains, and discriminatory power using Shannon’s indices.
RESULTS: Four hundred eighty-five students were approached and 443 responded to
all questionnaires (5L, SF-36, and 3L). The domains with the highest and the lowest
proportion of reported problems by 5L were Anxiety/Depression (57.1%) and SelfCare (0.2%), respectively. 3L and 5L responses were highly correlated in Pain/Discomfort (Pearsons’s Rho = 0.71), Usual Activities (0.64), and Anxiety/Depression
domains (0.64). Mean rate of logical inconsistencies was 3.02%, with 93% of them
being level 1 (according to Janssen et al., 2008). The ceiling effect was indentified in
47% of 3L questionnaires and 34% of 5L questionnaires. Absolute informativity was
higher for 5L, with similar relative informativity for both instruments. CONCLUSIONS: Results obtained in students support introduction of new 5-level version of
EQ-5D in young and healthy populations. EQ-5D-5L appears to be more favorable
in terms of ceiling effect and absolute informativity.
EQ2
TESTING THE PERFORMANCE OF THE NEWLY DEVELOPED VERSION
OF THE EQ-5D WITH 5 LEVELS OF SEVERITY: APPLICATION ON A
COHORT OF PATIENTS WITH CHRONIC HEPATIC DISEASES
Scalone L1, Ciampichini R2, Fagiuoli S3, Gardini I4, Del Prete A3, Gaeta L3, Fusco F2,
Mantovani LG5
1
University of Milano—Bicocca, Monza, Monza e Brianza, Italy; 2Charta Foundation, Milan,
Italy; 3Ospedali Riuniti Bergamo, Bergamo, Italy; 4EPAC—Hepatic Patient Association,
Vimercate, Milan, Italy; 5Federico II University of Naples, Naples, Italy
OBJECTIVES: To assess the performance of the EQ-5D-5L in a naturalistic context
targeted to patients with hepatic diseases. Preliminary investigations suggest that the
new version of EQ-5D, with five levels (5L) of severity per domain, is promising to
assess individuals’ QoL more appropriately than the standard version with three levels.
However, further research is encouraged to investigate the EQ-5D-5L properties in
different subpopulations and contexts. METHODS: This study was conducted within
a project aimed to estimate costs and QoL related to hepatic diseases. The participants
self-completed a questionnaire including the 5L descriptive system, the 3L standard
descriptive system, and the VAS. The following properties were tested: feasibility
(amount of missing answers); amount of inconsistent and consistent responses between
3L and 5L versions; convergent validity with the 3L version and VAS (Spearman’s
rank correlation coefficient); discriminatory power (informativity). RESULTS: Data
from 426 patients were analyzed: 69% male, 19 to 84 (median = 57) years old. They
were affected with: chronic hepatitis C (25.4%), chronic hepatitis B (22.5%), chronic
hepatitis B and C (1.2%), cirrhosis (20.9%), liver transplantation (19.0%), hepatic
carcinoma (4.5%), nonalcoholic steatohepatitis (1.9%), and other less frequent
hepatic diseases. With the standard version (3L), patients reported some or severe
problems with mobility (24.2%), self-care (10.4%), usual activities (29.0%), pain/
discomfort (35.5%), and anxiety/depression (37.4%). Median VAS was 70 (15–100).
Missing answers were more frequent with the 3L version (6.6% vs. 4.0% of patients).
In total, 97.5% of responses were consistent. Convergent validity of 5L-VAS (from
−0.35 to −0.57) was similar to the one of 3L-VAS (from −0.41 to −0.56). 3L-5L correlation coefficient ranged from 0.83 to 0.91. Informativity was similar between the
two versions. CONCLUSIONS: The EQ-5D-5L version holds promise as a valid
extension of the standard 3L version for the assessment of QoL of individuals with
hepatic diseases.
EQ3
ESTIMATING THE SF-6D VALUE SET FOR A POPULATION BASED
SAMPLE OF BRAZILIANS
Cruz LN1, Camey SA1, Hoffmann JF1, Brazier J2, Rowen D2, Fleck MP1, Polanczyk CA1
1
Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul (UFRGS), Porto Alegre, Brazil; 2University of
Sheffield, Sheffield, UK
OBJECTIVES: The SF-6D is a preference-based measure of health developed to estimate utility values from the SF-36. The aim of this study was to estimate preference
weights for SF-6D health states representing the preferences of a sample of Southern
Brazilian general population. METHODS: A sample of 248 health states defined by
the SF-6D has been valued by a sample of Southern Brazilian population using the
13th Euro Abstracts
standard gamble (SG) method. SG responses were used to estimate regression models
at the individual and mean levels to predict preference values for all SF-6D health
states. The models were compared with those described in the UK study. RESULTS:
Five hundred twenty-eight participants were interviewed, but 146 (28%) were
excluded due to inconsistent SG responses. Data from 382 subjects were used to
estimate the models, rendering 2224 health states valuations. All Brazilian models have
a large number of significant coefficients and a mean absolute difference between
observed and predicted values below 0.07. Inconsistent coefficients have been merged
to produce the final recommended model. Compared to UK data, Brazilian health state
values were lower, leading to a lower constant term in the models. The best model
fitted to Brazilian data was a random effects model using only the main effects variables, different from the preferred British SF-6D mean model, highlighting the importance to adopt a country-specific algorithm in predicting SF-6D health states values.
CONCLUSIONS: The results provide the first population-based value set for health
states in Brazil, making it possible to generate QALYs for cost-utility studies using
regional data. Utility scores based on Brazilian preferences values can be derived from
existing SF-36 data sets.
EQ4
DESCRIBING AND COMPARING HEALTH-RELATED QUALITY OF LIFE
DERIVED FROM EQ-5D AND SF-6D IN A SWEDISH GENERAL
POPULATION
Andersson D, Brodtkorb TH, Tinghög G
Linköping University, Linköping, Östergötland, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: Measurement of health-related quality of life (HRQoL) is a crucial
aspect of cost-effectiveness analysis. Two of the most widely used instruments for
assessing HRQoL are EQ-5D and SF-6D. Previous studies have shown that the sensitivity of these instruments differ depending on the severity of the disease. However,
few studies have systematically compared EQ-5D and SF-6D scores in a representative
sample of the general population. The objective of this study is to describe and
compare HRQoL derived from EQ-5D and SF-6D in a Swedish general population
for age, gender, and seven disease groups (respiratory, tumor, endocrine, cardiovascular, orthopedic, mental, and rheumatic diseases). METHODS: The EQ-5D and
SF-6D were included in a cross-sectional postal health survey in Östergötland County
to a representative sample (n = 6628, age: 18–84). RESULTS: When comparing
EQ-5D and SF-6D with regard to age, the mean HRQoL with EQ-5D across all ages
was 0.81, ranging from 0.86 (18–29 years) to 0.71 (80–84 years). For SF-6D, mean
HRQoL for the same population was 0.74, ranging from 0.75 (18–29 years) to 0.66
(80–84 years). With regard to gender, HRQoL was higher overall for men compared
to women. Men had an EQ-5D score of 0.83 and a SF-6D score of 0.79; in contrast,
women had an EQ-5D score of 0.79 and a SF-6D score of 0.73. Across disease groups,
the mean EQ-5D scores ranged from 0.60 (rheumatic) to 0.75 (endocrine), mean
SF-6D index values ranged from 0.64 (rheumatic) to 0.71 (endocrine). CONCLUSION: Although EQ-5D and SF-6D appear to measure similar constructs, our results
show that HRQoL varies greatly among the general population depending on chosen
instrument. However, when comparing our results across disease groups, differences
between the instruments appear less substantial. Our findings could have serious
implications for the transparency of cost-effectiveness analysis, if different studies use
HRQoL measurements that are not equivalent.
PODIUM SESSION I: DEVELOPMENTS IN MODELING METHODOLOGY
MO1
STRUCTURAL UNCERTAINTY IN COST-EFFECTIVENESS MODELS OF
TREATMENT FOR ALZHEIMER’S DISEASE
Peters JL, Hoyle M, Anderson R
Peninsula Medical School, Exeter, Devon, UK
OBJECTIVES: To discuss and explore important sources of structural uncertainty in
a decision model for drug treatment in Alzheimer’s disease. Progression in Alzheimer’s
disease can be modeled on various domains (e.g., cognition, function, behavior), each
of which can be measured by various scales. Defining disease progression and incorporating a treatment effect can therefore be difficult, requiring many assumptions
based on little or inconsistent evidence, resulting in a great deal of structural uncertainty. METHODS: We explored the impact of structural assumptions in a published
three-state Markov model of treatment for Alzheimer’s disease. This ultimately led to
the development of a novel model. Elements of structural uncertainty included 1)
defining the model states; 2) predicting occupancy of the states over time; and 3)
allowance for disease progression within a state. RESULTS: Assessment of the stepby-step structural changes to the published model indicated a number of assumptions
having a relatively large impact on the cost-effectiveness results, generally resulting in
lower costs per quality-adjusted life-year (QALY) associated with the treatments. The
cumulative impact of these assumptions was also considerable. However, there is little
evidence to inform which assumptions are the most realistic. CONCLUSIONS: Investigation into sources of structural uncertainty has helped to identify which assumptions had the largest impact on the estimated costs per QALY. However, this does
not help to reduce the uncertainty in the decision model, but does make the structural
uncertainty explicit. Decision-makers are therefore forced to address this type of
uncertainty as well as parameter uncertainty. Exploring structural uncertainty also
helps to identify gaps in the current evidence base to help understand which assumptions may be the most credible.
A241
13th Euro Abstracts
MO2
HERD IMMUNITY AS A RESULT IN DYNAMIC AGENT-BASED EPIDEMIC
MODELS
Miksch F1, Popper N2, Zauner G2, Endel G3, Schiller-Frühwirth I3, Breitenecker F1
1
Vienna University of Technology, Vienna, Austria; 2Dwh Simulation Services, Vienna, Austria;
3
Main Association of Austrian Social Security Institutions, Vienna, Austria
OBJECTIVES: Herd immunity describes a phenomenon in the area of communicable
diseases. Pathogens are spread by infected persons. Protecting a part of the population—for example via vaccination—lowers the overall appearance of pathogens as
these people cannot spread pathogens any more. Not protected people profit by fewer
contacts with pathogens, and further, a lower number of infections for them can be
expected. Classic Markov model cannot provide herd immunity as a result. In this
work, we propose calculations of herd immunity, create a model that is able to simulate epidemics, and show herd immunity dynamically in different states of the model.
Appearance of herd immunity is very disputed because it 1) cannot be measured
directly in real life and 2) depends on several factors. METHODS: Classic Markov
models require herd immunity as a static input parameter that cannot be provided.
The developed agent-based model includes single persons with different infection
states and a single pathogen. Every agent is part of a social contact model. It is possible
to simulate scenarios without vaccinations and with different vaccination strategies.
Herd immunity as a result of the dynamic model is calculated as the reduction of the
carrier rate of nonvaccinated persons for a certain vaccination strategy compared with
the scenario without vaccinations. RESULTS: Results show herd immunity as simulation result depending not only on vaccination strategies but also on other system
parameters. Further work extends the social contact structure with places like households, schools, or workplaces that are expected to have an impact on herd immunity
as well. CONCLUSIONS: Results can be implemented in systems for calculating new
strategies for vaccination programs. Current work considers two or more concurrent
serotypes where herd immunity and serotype replacement affects each other. In this
case, different definitions of herd immunity are possible.
MO3
THE DEVELOPMENT AND VALIDATION OF A DECISION MODEL
REPRESENTING THE FULL DISEASE COURSE OF ACUTE MYELOID
LEUKEMIA
Leunis A1, van Beers EH2, Löwenberg B3, Redekop WK1, Uyl-De Groot CA1
1
Institute for Medical Techonology Assessment (iMTA), Rotterdam, The Netherlands;
2
Skyline Diagnostics BV, Rotterdam, The Netherlands; 3Erasmus University Medical Center,
Rotterdam, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: Acute myeloid leukemia (AML) is a heterogeneous disease, consisting
of several subtypes with a variety in prognosis. a new genomics technology, the AML
profiler, has been developed that identifies new genetic subtypes. Since no decision
model exists that describes the full disease course of AML, the potential cost-effectiveness of this test cannot yet be determined. The aim of this study is to fill this gap
and develop and validate a disease progression model for AML. METHODS: The
structure of the model and the identification of relevant parameters were based on the
literature and expert opinion. All input parameters were estimated from clinical trial
data (HOVON data) for patients aged 18 to 60 years. The internal and external
validity of the model was evaluated by comparing model-based survival results with
the results from HOVON trials and the literature. RESULTS: Important prognostic
factors for AML were derived from the literature and expert opinion a microsimulation model (i.e., individual patient sampling) was designed to incorporate all important
prognostic factors in the model. The prognostic factors were included as covariates in
parametric survival functions for two events: relapse and death. The model combined
those survival functions with individual patient data to calculate life-years per patient.
The average 5-year survival of the simulated patient cohort was 40%, which is similar
to the survival found in HOVON trials and the literature. DISCUSSION: The content
validity of the model was achieved by involving clinical experts in the construction of
the model. The survival estimated using the model corresponds with those seen elsewhere, suggesting an acceptable level of internal and external validity. Therefore, the
model can be used to assess the cost-effectiveness of AML genomics technologies such
as the AML profiler. Moreover, the model can be used for other cost-effectiveness
analyses in the field of AML.
MO4
USING AHP WEIGHTS TO FILL MISSING GAPS IN MARKOV DECISION
MODELS
Steuten L, Hummel M, Wetering G, Groothuis-Oudshoorn K, Doggen C, Ijzerman M
University of Twente, Enschede, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: We propose to combine the versatility of the analytic hierarchy process
(AHP) with the decision-analytic sophistication of health-economic modeling in a new
methodology for early technology assessment. As an illustration, we apply this methodology to a new technology to diagnose breast cancer. METHODS: The AHP is a
technique for multicriteria analysis, relatively new in the field of technology assessment. It can integrate both quantitative and qualitative criteria in the assessment of
alternative technologies. We applied the AHP to prioritize a more versatile set of
outcome measures than most Markov models do. These outcome measures include
clinical effectiveness and costs, but also weighted estimates of patient comfort and
safety. Furthermore, as no clinical data are available for this technology yet, the AHP
is applied to predict the performance of the new technology with regard to all these
outcome measures. Results of the AHP are subsequently integrated in a Markov model
to make an early assessment of the expected incremental cost-effectiveness of alternative technologies. RESULTS: We systematically estimated priors on the clinical effectiveness and wider impacts of the new technology using AHP. In our illustration, AHP
estimates for sensitivity and specificity of the new diagnostic technology were used as
probability parameters in the Markov model. Moreover, the prioritized outcome
measures including clinical effectiveness (weight = 0.61), patient comfort (weight =
0.09), and safety (weight = 0.30) were integrated into one outcome measure in the
Markov model. CONCLUSIONS: Combining AHP and Markov modelling is particularly valuable in early technology assessment when evidence about the effectiveness
of health care technology is still limited or missing. Moreover, combining these
methods is valuable when decision makers are interested in other patient relevant
outcomes measures besides the technology’s clinical effectiveness, and that may not
(adequately or explicitly) be captured in mainstream utility measures.
PODIUM SESSION I: RISK-SHARING SCHEMES
RS1
A RISK FORECASTING MODEL TO HELP IN THE DESIGNING OF
RISK-SHARING SCHEMES
Ethgen O
University of Liège, Liège, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: To develop a financial risk forecasting model that could be used to
negotiate risk-sharing schemes (RSS) conditions. RSS are increasingly being established
as a market access strategy and have direct financial implications for both payer and
manufacturer. However, underlying methodologies remain poorly researched. Additionally, HTA agencies may need analytical frameworks to evaluate the value of RSS.
METHODS: We designed a financial-based agreement for a hypothetical technology.
The financial risk to be shared is defined as N × p × r where N is the size of the target
patients population, p is the price/dose of the technology, r is the proportion of
patients for whom di > D, di being the number of doses/year given to an individual
patient i and D being the maximum number of doses/year agreed in the schemes (the
cap). a logistic growth curve is used to simulate the risk evolution as time progresses
and patients progressively accrue in the RSS. Multiple risk evolution and “sharing”
scenarios with their resulting financial implications for both parties are simulated.
Finally, a Bayesian framework is introduced to allow both parties to make revisions
as real-life information becomes available upon implementation of the RSS. RESULTS:
For N = 1000 over a period of 3 years, D = 12 and a prior distribution for di centred
on 12 doses but with 20% of patients receiving more than 12 doses, the model predicts
that 23,092 doses will be delivered and that 542 doses (2.40%) will fall above the
cap. These doses in excess determine the cost to be shared: total refund, partial refund,
or price discount. CONCLUSIONS: Financial modelling and technological forecasting
techniques can be combined to simulate different risk-sharing scenarios and their
financial implications for payers and manufacturers. This provides both parties with
an analytical framework to design win-win schemes and to make potential revisions
as real-life information becomes available.
RS2
PAYER ROADBLOCKS TO RISK-SHARING AGREEMENTS AROUND THE
WORLD: WHERE, WHEN AND HOW?
Ando G, Kowal S, Reinaud F
IHS, London, UK
OBJECTIVES: The increasing use of risk-sharing in reimbursement decisions across
major markets necessitates that key stakeholders understand the role of this concept
in shaping drug development and regulatory decision-making. The objective of this
research was to examine global trends in risk-sharing agreements since 1990 to
provide a comprehensive understanding of the current and future impact of this fastevolving concept. METHODS: Primary research was conducted through 50 in-depth
45-minute telephone interviews in native languages. Subjects were carefully selected
and represented payers, government agencies, and HTA organizations in nine markets
(Europe 5, Australia, New Zealand, United States, and Canada) to understand their
assessment of the role which risk-sharing agreements have—or have not—played in
their respective markets, and whether they will do so in the future. This was complemented with secondary research of reimbursement decisions around the world based
on a newly created database of risk-sharing agreements around the world. RESULTS:
In some countries such as the United Kingdom and Italy, for certain therapeutic areas
such as oncology, these agreements almost act as a substitute for the normal reimbursement process, but primary research indicates that this practice faces significant resistance at many layers. Still, many other countries are seeking to understand the
potential applicability of risk-shares to their own market. Also, risk-share agreements
are being examined for their potential in several other therapeutic areas. While
population- and patient-level agreements remain the most popular, we conclude that
health outcomes-based arrangements are significantly on the rise, with 27 having been
identified through the study in the markets that were studied, the majority of which
were signed since 2007. Just over half were signed for oncology therapeutics. CONCLUSIONS: Outcomes-based agreements are becoming an increasingly important
consideration to include in pricing models across the traditional development pathway
for new molecules.
A242
RS3
THE BAYESIAN APPROACH FOR PERFORMANCE-BASED PRICING: A
CASE STUDY IN JAPAN
Kamae I1, Araki D2, Kamae MS3
1
Keio University Graduate School of Health Management, Fujisawa, Kanagawa, Japan; 2Meiji
University of Integrative Medicine, Nantan, Kyoto, Japan; 3Tufts Medical Center, Boston, MA,
USA
OBJECTIVES: To present a case study of Bayesian approach to performance-based
pricing in Japan, and to discuss advantages and limitations of the proposed method.
METHODS: The official price of any new drug listed on the National Reimbursement
List in Japan is initially determined by Ministry of Health, Labor, and Welfare in
political manners with some equations historically developed without considering the
science of pharmacoeconomics. The initial price determined when approved is biennially re-priced downward regarding the average market price (AMP) in reality. At
first, we reviewed the pricing and re-pricing methods of the government, then identified
which portion of the current rules for pricing and re-pricing could be reworded with
the quantitative methods of biostatistics and pharmacoeconomics, and finally tried to
develop a Bayesian method for making the current re-pricing rule better quantified
incorporating performance and value of a drug. RESULTS: We identified three portions such as premium rule in pricing, an adjustment in re-pricing, and the market
extension premium in re-pricing could be objectively described by scientific methods.
We developed in theory: 1) a pharmacoeconomic method associating the premium in
pricing with ICER (incremental cost-effectiveness ratio); 2) a Bayesian method quantifying an adjustment in the current re-pricing rule with respect to estimating the AMP
according to the degree of Bayesian belief; and 3) a mixture method of Bayes and
ICER quantifying the market extension in re-pricing to incorporate the performancebased concept. CONCLUSIONS: The Japanese pricing and re-pricing rules, which
employs the performance-based concept in a subjective manner, could be improved in
terms of pharmacoeconomics and Bayesian statistics. Although the validation of the
theory including data availability is left for further investigation, our approach would
be thought-provoking for any country which considers a statistical approach to policymaking for performance-based pricing or reimbursement.
RS4
THE INFLUENCE OF UK RISK-SHARING MODELS (PATIENT ACCESS
SCHEMES) ON PAYERS IN GERMANY AND THE NETHERLANDS. A
QUALITATIVE RESEARCH APPROACH
Guhl N1, Kolominsky-Rabas P2, Toumi M1
1
University Claude Bernard Lyon 1, Lyon, France; 2Centre for Health Technology
Assessment (HTA) and Public Health (IZPH), University of Erlangen-Nurnberg, Erlangen,
Germany
OBJECTIVES: The number of risk-sharing schemes in the UK increased significantly
since the introduction of the new Pharma Pricing and Regulation Scheme (PPRS) in
early 2009. Other health-care systems seem to follow. The objective is to investigate
via qualitative research if payers in Germany and The Netherlands are influenced by
UK decisions, if there are any preferred schemes, e.g., finance-based versus valuebased, and if the outcome for payers and manufacturers are comparable among the
countries concerned. METHODS: A comprehensive questionnaire was designed, validated, and translated into German and Dutch. Decision-makers at various levels
involved in the implementation of risk-sharing models in Germany and The Netherlands were interviewed face to face. The interviews lasted approximately 60 minutes
and were held in their mother language. All interviews were recorded and a total of
n = 10 interviews were conducted. RESULTS: German payers especially sick funds
seem to be more open to adopt risk-sharing models than their colleagues in The
Netherlands. There is a clear tendency in both countries that UK risk-sharing schemes
have an influence on the decision-making process; however, most payers responded
that there must be some adaptations to local needs. CONCLUSIONS: Risk-sharing
models will become increasingly popular in the near future especially in Germany.
Companies have to be prepared especially in therapeutic areas like oncology to follow
this route as a way of market access. Although risk-sharing models have been introduced in other European countries before 2009, the UK models seem to represent a
benchmark among payers especially with regard to their transparency.
PODIUM SESSION II: ADHERENCE AND COMPLIANCE STUDIES
AD1
SHORT MESSAGE SERVICE (SMS)-BASED STRATEGY TO IMPROVE
ANTIPSYCHOTIC ADHERENCE AMONG PATIENTS WITH
SCHIZOPHRENIA
Maurino J1, Tesoro A2, Diez T3, Gomez-Beneyto M4
1
AstraZeneca, Madrid, Spain; 2Hospital Universitario Virgen Macarena, Sevilla, Spain;
3
AstraZeneca, Zaventem, Brussels, Belgium; 4University of Valencia, Valencia, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Schizophrenia is a major psychotic disorder that has devastating effects
on the lives of patients and their caregivers. Poor adherence to antipsychotic treatment
is a well-recognized challenge among patients with schizophrenia and is associated
with increased morbidity and consumption of health-care resources. Implementation
of innovative strategies to enhance adherence is needed. To evaluate the effect of daily
short message service (SMS) reminders on patients’ adherence to antipsychotic treat-
13th Euro Abstracts
ment in schizophrenia. METHODS: A multicenter, randomized, open-label, controlled trial. The study included clinically stabilized schizophrenic outpatients with
adherence problems (at least one affirmative answer of Morisky–Green questionnaire—MAQ). Participants were randomized to receive a daily SMS reminder on their
cell phone to take their medication in the following 3 months or current standard of
care. The SMS reminder was sent daily at 10 am or 2 pm according to participants’
preferences. The primary end point was the absolute difference in mean adherence
rate between the two groups after 3 months using MAQ. RESULTS: A total of 254
patients were analyzed, 66.5% men. Mean age: 39.7 years (SD = 11.03). Baseline
sociodemographic and clinical characteristics were similar between the two groups.
No significant differences in baseline mean MAQ score were observed between groups
(2.23, SD = 0.94 and 2.23, SD = 0.85, respectively). At month 3, mean MAQ score
in the intervention group was 1.2 and 1.53 in the control group. The absolute difference in mean adherence rate between groups was −0.33 (95% CI −0.62, −0.03; P =
0.03). Largest change from baseline was observed in question 4 of the questionnaire
“When you feel better, do you sometimes stop taking your medicine?” (percentage of
affirmative answers in the SMS group vs. control was 45% and 59%, respectively, P
= 0.02). CONCLUSIONS: SMS reminders may help many patients become sufficiently
adherent to their antipsychotic medication in addition to standard interventions for
schizophrenia control.
AD2
THE SOCIETAL BURDEN OF POOR PERSISTENCE TO TREATMENT OF
OSTEOPOROSIS IN SWEDEN
Landfeldt E1, Lundkvist J2, Strom O1
1
i3 Innovus, Stockholm, Sweden; 2Amgen, Stockholm, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: Poor persistence to prescribed treatment regimens is a well-documented
health problem. The issue is of particular importance in treatment of chronic diseases,
such as osteoporosis. The objective of this study was to estimate the annual societal
burden of real-world persistence to treatment of osteoporosis in Sweden. a second aim
was to estimate the monetary net benefit of improved persistence. METHODS: The
annual societal burden was evaluated in relation to perfect persistence to a 5-year
treatment duration and performed using a published Markov model by Ström and
colleagues. The target population was extracted from the Swedish Prescription Register and based on all treatment-naïve patients who started therapy of primary osteoporosis in Sweden during 2009. Five hypothetical interventions were investigated, with
improvements in the persistent proportion of between 10% and 50%. RESULTS:
Annually, a total of 1018 fractures were estimated to be caused by nonpersistence to
treatment of osteoporosis in Sweden. These fractures resulted in a substantial waste
of health-care resources related to morbidity (c26 million annually) and a loss, in total,
of 771 QALYs. Using a societal willingness-to-pay for a QALY of c60,000, the total
annual societal burden, incorporating both monetary consequences and health effects,
was estimated at c62.76 million. Given current Swedish cost-effectiveness guidelines,
between approximately c225 and c1130 could be spent per patient to increase persistence, depending on the level of improvement (between 10% and 50%). CONCLUSIONS: The total annual societal burden of current, real-world persistence was
estimated at c63 million. The estimated additional fracture-related costs associated
with poor persistence were larger than the current total annual expenditure on all
osteoporosis medications in Sweden. Poor persistence to treatment of osteoporosis
should consequently be acknowledged as an important and costly health problem, and
be taken into account when evaluating osteoporosis interventions.
AD3
A CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK THAT CAPTURES THE
MULTIDIMENSIONAL ASPECT OF ADHERENCE IN A HEALTHECONOMIC MODEL: AN APPLICATION IN CHRONIC NONMALIGNANT
PAIN MANAGEMENT
Treur M1, Houwing NS1, Heeg B1, Kristanto P2, Botteman M3, Vo P4, Marx S4,
Lockhart E4, Van Hout B5
1
Pharmerit International, Rotterdam, The Netherlands; 2AARDEX Group Ltd., BE-4600,
Belgium; 3Pharmerit North America, LLC, Bethesda, MD, USA; 4Abbott, Abbott Park, IL,
USA; 5Pharmerit Ltd., York, UK
Incorporating adherence in a health-economic evaluation is challenging. a novel conceptual framework was developed that captures the multidimensional aspect of adherence in a health-economic model, by considering the case of pain medication in chronic
nonmalignant pain management. a 1-year microsimulation model was built. Realistic
dosing profiles (combining dose-taking and dose-timing information) were obtained
from electronically compiled dosing histories gathered in the Aardex/Pharmionic database. Probability and timing of dosing depended on time of intake during the day,
day of the week, whether or not a previous dosage was taken, and number of days
on treatment. The effect of dosages taken on pain was modeled via a pharmacokinetic–pharmacodynamic (PK-PD) model. The PK model translated dosages taken into
drug concentration levels. Drug concentration levels influenced the amount of pain a
patient experienced, quantified by the PD model. Quality of life (QoL) values were
obtained by assigning a utility value to the pain intensity a patient experienced.
Dosages taken by the patient contributed to medication costs. Work productivity
losses due to pain exacerbations, based on a pain survey, were included. The model
simulated 1000 unique patients to generate stable results, comparing realistic dosing
profiles with an optimal dosing profile for a four times daily (QID) regimen. The
realistic QID regimen had 14% lower average drug concentration levels and more
than 3.5-fold higher standard deviation in concentration levels than the optimal
regimen. Due to lower average concentration levels and higher fluctuation, this trans-
13th Euro Abstracts
lated into patients experiencing 37% higher average pain intensity, an 8% decrease
in QoL, and total additional costs of ~$1277 annually. This study provided a conceptual framework to model the health-economic impact of dosing variations based on
actual dosing information in a realistic and intuitive way. This novel concept can also
be applied to other disease areas to assess pharmaco-economic outcomes.
AD4
THE IMPACT OF PHARMACIST INTERVENTION ON PATIENTS’
ADHERENCE TO ANTIDEPRESSANT MEDICATION AND PATIENTREPORTED OUTCOMES
Aljumah K, Donyai P
University of Reading, Reading, UK
OBJECTIVES: Medications, regardless of effectiveness, do not work in patients who
do not take them. Poor adherence to prescribed medication regimens has been a wellrecognized problem in all of medicine and patients with chronic conditions, such as
depression, are less likely to follow prescription orders than those with acute conditions. In depression, several studies have reported a medication adherence rate of
about 72% within the first month of treatment which drops sharply to about 43%
after 6 months of treatment. Pharmacists may be able to help improve adherence rates,
yet no single review has examined the impact of pharmacist interventions on adherence
to antidepressants. The aim of this study was to summarize the literature and determine whether pharmacist intervention will 1) improve adherence in depression; and
2) improve patient-reported outcomes (PRO). METHODS: A systematic review of the
literature was conducted using the PubMed database to retrieve studies examining the
impact of pharmacist interventions on adherence to antidepressants and on patientreported outcomes, from 1990 to 2010. The following MESH terms were used:
pharmacist intervention, medication intervention, depression, medication adherence,
health-related quality of life, patient reported outcomes, and antidepressants. a total
of 25 papers were retrieved with 11 excluded on the basis of abstract or full-text
review resulting in 14 studies suitable for inclusion. RESULTS: The most common
intervention strategy that pharmacists utilized was a combination of drug monitoring
(baseline assessment and treatment follow-up), drug counseling by telephone and
personal interviews, and patient education (about medication side effects).The results
of these interventions were positive, improvement varying from 15% to 19%, and
also, HRQL improved to varying degrees. CONCLUSIONS: The studies support the
roles of pharmacists in providing interventions to improve medication adherence in
depression. The results can provide a basis for future studies examining the costeffectiveness of pharmacist interventions in depression.
PODIUM SESSION II: BIOLOGIC AGENT STUDIES AND METHODS
BL1
COST-EFFECTIVENESS, VALUE OF INFORMATION, AND BUDGET
IMPACT OF CERTOLIZUMAB PEGOL COMPARED TO SUBCUTANEOUS
TUMOR NECROSIS FACTOR (TNF) INHIBITORS AND METHOTREXATE
IN THE TREATMENT OF MODERATE-TO-SEVERE RHEUMATOID
ARTHRITIS IN FINLAND
Soini EJ1, Hallinen T1, Taiha M2, Honkanen V2
1
ESiOR Ltd, Kuopio, Finland; 2UCB Pharma Oy Finland, Espoo, Finland
OBJECTIVES: To analyze the cost-effectiveness, multinomial expected value of perfect
information (mEVPI), and budget impact of certolizumab pegol (CZP) compared to
the used first-line subcutaneously administered tumor necrosis factor (TNF) − inhibitors + methotrexate (MTX) and MTX alone in the treatment of moderate-to-severe
rheumatoid arthritis (RA) in the Finnish setting. METHODS: An Excel-based, probabilistic lifetime Markov cohort model was developed to assess the cost-effectiveness
and mEVPI. Treatment efficacy was measured using the ACR-responses (no ACR20,
ACR20, ACR50, or ACR70) at 3 months. ACR estimated response rates were based
on adjusted indirect comparison (MTX as the common comparator) of published
clinical trials. The health state utilities were estimated from the CZP-trials using
regression models. The inpatient days were linked to patients’ HAQ-scores according
to published literature. Cost estimates from Finnish sources were used and assessed
from payer perspective. Cost and health outcomes were discounted with annual 3%
discount rate. Undiscounted budget impact of CZP was estimated for years 2010–
2013 using Excel model. Equal inpatient costs and treatment efficacies were assumed
for all TNF inhibitors. RESULTS: The lifetime costs for CZP + MTX, etanercept +
MTX, and MTX alone were c179,986, c201,781, and c186,986, respectively. The
corresponding QALYs (life-years) were 7.041 (15.697), 6.838 (15.646), and 6.336
(15.547). According to the cost-effectiveness acceptability frontier, CZP + MTX was
the optimal treatment option with 58% to 73% probability of being cost-effective at
willingness-to-pay values of c0–30,000 per QALY gained. The respective mEVPI was
c5058–3701 per patient. Based on clinical responses, CZP + MTX dominated also
adalimumab + MTX with 100–85% probability of cost-effectiveness (c0–30,000 per
QALY gained; EVPI c0–218 per patient). The introduction of CZP produced annual
budgetary net savings of c0.17–0.80 million during 2010–2013 in budget impact
analysis. CONCLUSIONS: This analysis shows that, on average, CZP + MTX dominated the other subcutaneously injected TNF inhibitors considered or MTX alone in
the Finish setting. The use of CZP resulted in budgetary net savings.
A243
BL2
PATIENT PREFERENCES FOR BIOLOGIC AGENTS IN RHEUMATOID
ARTHRITIS: A DISCRETE CHOICE EXPERIMENT
Augustovski F1, Beratarrechea A2, Irazola V1, Rubinstein F1, Tesolin P3, Gonzalez JM4,
Lencina V5, Scolnik M3, Wainmann C5, Navarta D3, Citera G5, Soriano E3
1
Institute for Clinical Effectiveness and Health Policy, Buenos Aires, Argentina; 2IECS &
Hospital Italiano de Buenos Aires, Buenos Aires, Argentina; 3Hospital Italiano de Buenos
Aires, Buenos Aires, Argentina; 4RTI Health Solutions, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA;
5
Instituto de Rehabilitación Psicofísica (I.R.E.P.), Buenos Aires, Argentina
OBJECTIVES: To conduct a Discrete Choice Experiment (DCE) to elicit rheumatoid
arthritis (RA) patients’ preferences regarding treatment with BIOLOGIC AGENTS
(BA). METHODS: We designed a DCE with RA patients and seven treatment attributes: effectiveness, route of administration, frequency of administration, local and
systemic adverse effects, severe infections, and out-of-pocket costs. RA patients who
had never received BA from one private and one public hospital in Buenos Aires were
included. a multinomial probit regression model (MNP) was used. RESULTS: A total
of 240 RA participated (mean age 56.2 [SD 13.5], 87% women, median disease duration 9 years), all receiving conventional DMARDs (84.5% Metotrexate); median
Clinical Disease Activity Index 7.5, and median HAQ 0.5. All the attributes showed
to be significant factors affecting choice of treatment. Most attributes levels showed
coefficients with the expected signs and were statistically significant. Attributes importance ranking was in the following order: cost, systemic adverse events, frequency of
administration, efficacy, route of administration, local adverse events, and serious
infection (table). Patients had relatively high monthly WTP for treatments that significantly reduced the risk of systemic adverse events: mean 331 (95% CI: 212–499) US
dollars ($) for a reduction from 30% to 10%; of decreasing dose frequency: mean
$302 (95% CI: 183–461) for going from weekly to monthly administration; increasing
treatment efficacy: mean: $386 (95% CI: 285–532) for 40 versus 20 mm reduction in
patient global assessment VAS), and also for switching from an intravenous to an oral
therapy: mean $262 (95% CI: 262–555). CONCLUSIONS: Different treatment attributes had a significant and different influence in RA patients’ choice of BA. The results
of the DCE indicated that most respondents would be willing to pay for treatments
that importantly reduced the risk of systemic adverse effects, dose frequency, with
increased treatment efficacy, and with an oral route of administration.
BL3
A CONCEPTUAL MODEL FOR POMPE DISEASE: THE BACKBONE FOR
AN ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF AN ORPHAN DRUG
Kanters TA1, Redekop WK1, Hagemans MLC2, Van der Ploeg AT2, Hakkaart L1
1
Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands; 2Erasmus University Medical
Center, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: Studies of orphan drugs are, by nature, confronted with small patient
populations, meaning that randomized controlled trials (RCTs) will have limited
statistical power. Enzyme replacement therapy (ERT) is an orphan drug for Pompe
disease, a metabolic orphan disease, with a prevalence in the The Netherlands of 1
per 40,000 births. In order to estimate the (cost-)effectiveness of ERT, we developed
a disease model founded on all available clinical knowledge. METHODS: We developed a disease model with a strong clinical basis which linked disease-related factors
with quality-adjusted life-years. The structure of the Wilson-Cleary health outcomes
model was used as a blueprint. Based on literature and expert opinion, clinically
relevant aspects of Pompe disease were applied to the distinct entities of the WilsonCleary model. Data from a Dutch cohort study (n = 94, mean follow-up = 2.7 years)
were used to quantify the relationships between the different entities by means of
regression analyses. RESULTS: A conceptual model for Pompe disease was developed
by establishing a clinically plausible pathway from enzyme activity (“biological variables” in Wilson-Cleary model) via muscle strength and respiratory function
(“symptom status”), and MCS and PCS from the SF-36 (“functional status”) to the
final entity of health utility (“quality of life” using EQ-5D and SF-6D). The strengths
of the relationships between these entities were based on the results of the regression
analyses. Patient characteristics such as age, gender, and disease duration affected all
entities in the model. Therapy was assumed to affect only enzyme activity in the model;
all other health outcomes could only be affected via an impact on enzyme activity.
CONCLUSION: We have developed a clinically based model to assess the long-term
cost-effectiveness of ERT in Pompe disease. The approach used here is expected to be
applicable in the assessment of other orphan drugs.
BL4
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF TREATMENT STRATEGIES FOR
ANKYLOSING SPONDYLITIS: FIRST RESULTS OF A DISCRETE EVENT
SIMULATION MODEL
Tran Duy A1, Boonen A2, Arsenijevic J1, Severens JL3
1
Maastricht University, Maastricht, Limburg, The Netherlands; 2Maastricht University Hospital,
Maastricht, Limburg, The Netherlands; 3Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, South
Holland, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: Owing to rapid, persistent efficacy in reducing pain and preventing
structural damage, tumor necrosis factor-alpha inhibitors (anti-TNFs) has revolutionized the treatment of ankylosing spondylitis (AS). However, the high price of antiTNFs has limited their use. Recent studies suggest that increased medication costs by
adopting anti-TNFs may be offset by decreased values of other cost categories. In most
cost-effectiveness studies on AS treatments, costs were estimated as a whole. Our
A244
objectives were to 1) develop a simulation model which can simulate QoL and different cost categories from a societal perspective as affected by AS treatments with
sequential drugs using the ASAS recommendations at group level; 2) parameterize the
model using Dutch data; and 3) analyze simulated cost-effectiveness of treatment
strategies with and without anti-TNFs. METHODS: Discrete-event paradigm was
selected for model development. Pathways in AS treatments were simulated in conjunction with changes in AS-specific measures. Parameterization was realized using original
data from an observational cohort of AS patients and literature where necessary.
Frequencies of visits to rheumatologists and hospitals, and having paramedical treatments, informal/formal care, sick leave, and work disability were estimated using logit
and Poisson regression models. Health utility was estimated using a proportional-odds
model. Demographic variables were also considered in model selections. Two compared strategies in the simulation were 1) three Cox-1 plus two Cox-2 selective
nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, and 2) same as strategy 1 plus Etanercept and
Infliximab. The simulation was run for 1000 patients until death. RESULTS: Simulated values of QALYs and different cost categories were in reasonable ranges. Productivity and hospital costs constituted largest shares of the total costs, and were
significantly lower in strategy 2 (P < 0.05). The incremental cost per QALY gained of
strategy 2 against strategy 1 was c25,165. CONCLUSIONS: The model is flexible and
promising for assessing actual costs-effectiveness of different treatment strategies for
different societies.
PODIUM SESSION II: IRT AND RACH MODELING IN QUALITY OF
LIFE MEASUREMENT
IR1
METHODS FOR PSYCHOMETRIC AND CLINICAL EVALUATIONS OF
CAT-BASED MEASURES OF DISEASE IMPACT IN CHRONIC KIDNEY
DISEASE (CKD)
Lin P1, Ware JE1, Meyer K2, Richardson M3, Bjorner JB4
1
John Ware Research Group, Inc., Worcester, MA, USA; 2Tufts University School of
Medicine, Boston, MA, USA; 3Tufts Medical Center, Boston, MA, USA; 4National Institute for
the Working Environment, Copenhagen, Denmark
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate a new standardized disease-specific PRO impact item bank,
the Kidney Disease Impact Scale (KDIS), among adults with chronic kidney disease
(CKD). METHODS: A 34-item bank of items measuring disease impact, with standardized content (differing only in disease attribution) and standardized IRT-based
parameters from previous studies across therapeutic areas, was administered to 516
CKD patients, along with CKD-specific legacy (KDQOL Effects and Burden scales)
and a generic (SF-12v2) health survey. All measures were administered in a clinic
setting at three time points (baseline, 1 week, and 3 months) to evaluate: 1) reliability
(internal consistency and 1-week test–retest); 2) validity in discriminating among CKD
groups differing in clinically defined disease severity (nondialysis stages 3–5, dialysis
patients, and transplant patients); and 3) responsiveness (better, same, or worse after
3 months). Real-data CAT simulations were performed, using only the responses to
items that would have been selected and asked during a real CAT, to estimate KDIS
scores based on the full bank, and 5-, 10-, and 15-item CATs. RESULTS: As hypothesized, CAT-based score distributions were less skewed and estimates were more
efficient (covered a wider range and were as reliable with fewer items), in comparison
with legacy measures. All KDIS forms (full bank, various lengths of CATs) discriminated among clinically defined groups as well or better than legacy CKD-specific
measures and correlated substantially with generic HRQOL measures. Relative validity (RV) coefficients for discriminant validity and responsiveness tests for 1-minute
(5-item) CAT-based administrations compared favorably with scores based on the
entire bank (RV = 0.84), KDQOL scores (RV = 0.79 for Burden and 0.50 for Effects),
and generic measures (RV = 0.00 to 0.59, median = 0.13). CONCLUSIONS: Diseasespecific PROs can be improved to be more practical and more valid, in comparison
with legacy CKD-specific and generic PROs. CKD impact measures that perform better
psychometrically tend to perform better in empirical tests of clinical validity.
IR2
SCALING PROPERTIES OF TWO COMMONLY USED OUTCOME
MEASURES IN DERMATOLOGY—THE DERMATOLOGY LIFE QUALITY
INDEX (DLQI) AND THE PSORIASIS QUALITY OF LIFE SCALE
(PSORIQOL)
Twiss J, Mckenna S, Crawford S, Doward L
Galen Research Limited, Manchester, UK
OBJECTIVES: The DLQI is a 10-item generic dermatological HRQoL measure used
widely with psoriasis patients. The PSORIQoL is a 25-item psoriasis-specific measure
that employs the needs-based model of quality of life (QoL). Both measures have been
shown to have good psychometric properties using Classical Test Theory. However,
their scaling properties have not been fully assessed using Item Response Theory (IRT).
This is the purpose of the study. METHODS: Psoriasis patients, recruited from an
out-patients clinic, completed the DLQI and PSORIQoL. IRT (Rasch analysis) was
used to determine each measure’s overall fit to the Rasch model, individual item fit,
targeting of scales to severity of respondents, functioning of response categories, and
the presence of Differential Item Functioning (DIF) by age or gender. RESULTS: 146
psoriasis patients were included in the study (male 50%, mean age = 44.2, range =
17–83 years). DLQI: There was overall misfit to the Rasch model (χ2 = 39.85, df =
20, P = 0.005). One item misfit the Rasch model and another showed borderline misfit.
13th Euro Abstracts
Four of the 10 items had disordered response thresholds indicating that they did not
work in a logical way. Too few DLQI items covered milder levels of HRQoL (meaning
that the measure is not sensitive to change in patients with mild disease). DIF by age
was found in one item and DIF by gender in another. PSORIQoL: Overall, the measure
fit the Rasch model (χ2 = 56.45, df = 50, P = 0.247), although one item had a high
fit residual suggesting misfit. The response options worked logically and items were
well distributed across the QoL measurement range. No DIF by age or gender was
found. CONCLUSIONS: Application of Rasch analysis indicated that there were
several problems with the scaling properties of the DLQI. In contrast, the PSORIQoL
fit the Rasch model and exhibited good measurement properties.
IR3
THE USE OF IRT MODELING TO ACCOUNT FOR DIFFERENTIAL ITEM
FUNCTIONING IN THE PROQOL-HIV QUESTIONNAIRE
Lalanne C, Duracinsky M, Armstrong AR, Chassany O
Assistance Publique-Hopitaux de Paris, Paris, France
OBJECTIVES: This study aims to provide sample-free estimates of uniform DIF on a
newly developed HRQL questionnaire, PROQOL-HIV, based on IRT. Patient characteristics considered here were gender, country of residence, and ethnicity, given the
high prevalence of HIV in migrant populations. METHODS: We use a two-step
ordinal logistic regression to test for the significance of person covariates, on two
constructs extracted from factor analysis: Physical Health and Symptoms (PHS, 14
items), and Emotional distress and Health Concerns (EDHC, 10 items). a subset of N
= 505 patients (71% males, median age 43 years) from five countries (Australia, United
States, France, Brazil, and Thailand) was used. Person parameters were estimated
using a Graded Response Model. Missing responses (<1%) were imputed using halfrule. RESULTS: The EDHC dimension was more prone to exhibit item biases compared to PHS items, especially when referring to ethnicity. Country-related effects were
equally distributed on the two scales. In both cases, however, no DIF effects were
found for gender. We reached similar conclusions when comparing the results to those
obtained when using sum or rest scores as conditioning ability levels. Correlations
between raw scores computed with or without flagged items were above 0.5. Restricting analyses to Western countries, however, yielded smaller hits. Altogether, these
results suggest that DIF effects should be of limited impact when reporting scores for
these two HRQL dimensions of the PROQOL-HIV questionnaire. Results are discussed in light of other latent variable models proposed to assess DIF, the MIMIC,
and logistic mixed effects model. CONCLUSIONS: Using IRT instead of summated
scale scores allows the incorporation of person covariates and the study of DIF effects
in a probabilistic framework. The presence of DIF effects on biopsychological constructs raises important cross-cultural validity considerations for multi-country multiethnic studies, although assessment of DIF impact needs further investigations.
IR4
HUNTINGTON QUALITY OF LIFE INTERVIEW (HQOLI): A NEW
HUNTINGTON’S DISEASE-SPECIFIC QUALITY OF LIFE INSTRUMENT
Clay E1, Guelfucci F1, Dorey J1, Tedroff J2, Verny C3, Toumi M4, Aballea S1
1
Creativ Ceutical, Paris, France; 2NEUROSEARCH, Ballerup, Denmark; 3Neurology Unit
CHU, Angers, France; 4University Claude Bernard Lyon 1, Lyon, France
OBJECTIVES: No specific health-related quality of life (HRQOL) instrument tool is
available for Huntington’s disease (HD). In the context of a large European study on
HD burden (Euro-HDB), a specific HRQoL tool (HQOLI) was created for patients in
early and intermediate stages of HD. We describe the development and psychometric
validation of HQOLI. METHODS: After semistructured interviews with patients,
caregivers, and HD specialists, we ran a patient focus group. a self-reported questionnaire was then devised in French language. The questionnaire consists of 42 items,
relating to 11 dimensions: Mobility, Motor Ability, Autonomy 1 and 2, Finance,
Occupational Activities, Psychology, Feelings of Guilt, Vitality, Socializing, and Body
Image. Face validity and internal and external validity were examined. RESULTS:
Among 178 participating patients, 15 did not complete HQOLI. Item response rates
range from 0.81 to 0.98, excluding the occupational activities domain. As expected,
there is a ceiling effect on several items, suggesting low sensitivity at advanced HD
stage. Cronbach’s alphas are greater than 0.76. HQOLI total score is highly correlated
with generic HR-QOL (SF36 and EQ5D) as well as with the specific caregiver HRQoL
instrument (HDQoL-C). Correlations were −0.73 (P < 0.01) with EQ5D utility, −0.76
(P < 0.01) with “Physical Functioning,” and −0.74 (P < 0.01) with “Mental Health.”
Voluntary movement, fall/balance, and dystonia symptoms contribute significantly to
HQOLI (P = 0.01), but chorea does not (P = 0.21). CONCLUSIONS: These data
support the validity of the HQOLI in patients with HD. The ceiling effect limits the
use of HQOLI in late stages but appears necessary to achieve good discrimination at
early and intermediate stages. Correlations with other instruments suggest good external validity. High correlations of several items within dimensions suggest item number
can be reduced. a new, shorter version of the questionnaire is in development. Assessments of responsiveness to change, test–retest reliability, and cross-cultural validation
will be performed/are underway.
13th Euro Abstracts
PODIUM SESSION II: MIXED TREATMENT COMPARISON
METHODOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
MT1
DOES MODEL CHOICE IN MIXED TREATMENT COMPARISONS AFFECT
THE OUTCOME FOR DECISION-MAKERS?
Adams RC1, Schmitz S2, Fitzgerald O3, Walsh C2, Barry M1
1
National Centre for Pharmacoeconomics, Dublin, Ireland; 2Trinity College Dublin, Dublin,
Ireland; 3St. Vincents University Hospital, Dublin Academic Healthcare, Dublin, Ireland
BACKGROUND: An incremental cost-effectiveness ratio is calculated by dividing the
difference in cost of an intervention by the difference in effect. In the absence of head
to head trials, it is often necessary to combine evidence from placebo-controlled trials
of different treatments and thereby derive an estimate of effect of one treatment against
another. There are formal methods to do this and various models can be used. We
present four different models and examine whether using different models can change
the conclusion of the economic evaluation in rheumatoid arthritis (RA). METHODS:
A literature review was carried out and the relevant data were extracted according to
defined inclusion criteria. The outcome measures chosen were American College of
rheumatology (ACR) 20 and 50 at 6 months. The MTC was carried out in WinBUGS
and the method used was that by Nixon et al.[1]. This model allows inclusion of
methotrexate as a parameter. We then used the four different estimates from each of
the models in an RA model. RESULTS: The four different models differed in whether
random or fixed effect was applied to the treatment or to methotrexate. Pairwise risk
ratios (RR) are presented. The RR differ slightly for the same drug using the different
models. Both the positioning of the ICERs on the CE plane and the probability of
cost-effectiveness change from model to model. CONCLUSIONS: We see a difference
in the results of using different models for MTC. However, the relative positioning of
the estimates remains the same. Therefore, in deciding which method to choose in the
case of biological agents, it is unlikely that the choice of model will impact greatly on
the overall decision.
MT2
CONDUCTING A MIXED TREATMENT COMPARISON (MTC) IN A
SPECIFIC POPULATION: POSTMENOPAUSAL WOMEN WITH
METASTATIC HORMONE RECEPTOR POSITIVE BREAST CANCER
WHICH OVEREXPRESSES HER2
Pacou M1, Gauthier A1, Abrams K2, Moore L3, Jiang Y1, McNamara S3
1
Amaris Consulting UK, London, UK; 2University of Leicester, Leicester, UK; 3Roche Products
Limited, Welwyn Garden City, UK
OBJECTIVES: To estimate the relative treatment effects on progression free survival
(PFS) and overall survival (OS) of trastuzumab plus an aromatase inhibitor (AI), lapatinib plus an AI, and AI monotherapy (anastrozole, letrozole, or exemestane) in
postmenopausal women with untreated metastatic hormone receptor positive breast
cancer which overexpresses HER2. METHODS: A systematic literature review was
conducted in MEDLINE, MEDLINE-IN-PROCESS, EMBASE, Cochrane CENTRAL,
Web of Science Proceedings, and BIOSIS to retrieve relevant randomized clinical trials.
Heterogeneity and inconsistency were discussed with clinical experts and assessed
statistically. An MTC was developed within the Bayesian framework using noninformative priors. It was decided a priori to investigate whether AIs could be considered
as a class, through the evaluation of hazard ratios between single agents. As few trials
focused on the exact target population, extensive sensitivity analyses were planned.
RESULTS: The base-case analysis indicated no significant difference between AIs on
PFS. Combined therapies were significantly more effective than AIs: the hazard ratios
were estimated at 0.55 (95% CrI: [0.41; 0.74]) for trastuzumab + AI and 0.71 (95%
CrI: [0.53; 0.96]) for lapatinib + AI. Although the probability of being best varied in
the sensitivity analyses, trastuzumab + AI was always associated with the highest
probability of best efficacy. The effect on OS was similar across AIs. No significant
difference was found between the two combination therapies, which were associated
with high probabilities of best efficacy (48% for trastuzumab + AI and 50% for lapatinib + AI). The sensitivity analyses indicated that adjustment for cross-over had an
important impact on the OS results. CONCLUSIONS: Our study confirmed that
anastrozole, letrozole, and exemestane had similar efficacy with respect to PFS and
OS and that combined therapies were associated with significantly improved PFS
compared to AIs. Conducting an MTC in this specific population was addressed
through clinical and statistical assessments of heterogeneity and inconsistency, and
extensive sensitivity analyses.
MT3
COMPARATIVE EFFECTIVENESS OF ANTIDEPRESSANTS (AD) IN THE
TREATMENT OF THE ELDERLY WITH MAJOR DEPRESSIVE DISORDER
(MDD): A MIXED TREATMENT COMPARISON AND META-REGRESSION
ANALYSIS
Benedict A1, Naci H2, Fahrbach K3, Bozkaya D3, Happich M4, Deberdt W5, Raskin J6
1
United BioSource Corporation, Budapest, Hungary; 2United BioSource Corporation,
London, UK; 3United BioSource Corporation, Lexington, MA, USA; 4Eli Lilly & Company,
Bad Homburg, Hessia, Germany; 5S.A. Eli Lilly Benelux N.V., Bruxelles, Belgium; 6Eli Lilly &
Company, Toronto, ON, Canada
OBJECTIVES: To estimate the probability of clinical response, remission, and treatment withdrawal of antidepressants including TCAs, SSRIs, mirtazapine, buproprion,
and SNRIs in elderly patients with MDD using indirect comparison (MTC) and metaregression (MR) methods. METHODS: Published systematic reviews of AD in elderly
patients with MDD were used to extract data from RCTs of comparator treatments
A245
reporting response or remission or treatment withdrawal. Studies with less than 6
weeks duration, open label extension studies, and studies in patients with significant
dementia were excluded. Bayesian MTC and MR analyses, enabling indirect comparisons of interventions while respecting randomization, were performed using OpenBugs
3.0.2, adjusting for placebo control, baseline disease severity, treatment duration, age,
patients with late onset depression as study, or arm level covariates as appropriate.
Assuming similar class efficacy TCAs and SSRIs were grouped. RESULTS: The final
data set included 40 studies, with 87 comparator arms. Placebo control was associated
with a reduction in the log odds ratio (LOR) of response versus placebo for all treatments. Severity and publication year was marginally correlated with response. Posterior median predicted response and remission rates in non-placebo-controlled studies
ranged between 71.9% (buproprione) and 77.1% (duloxetine), and remission between
29.4% (SSRIs), 42.7% (duloxetine), and 58.1% (TCAs). Predicted withdrawal rates
for non-placebo-controlled studies vary between 25.7% (duloxetine) and 40% (venlafaxine). Remission results were sensitive to how the mean placebo incidence across
studies was modeled. CONCLUSIONS: In the absence of head-to-head clinical trials,
this analysis provides comparative estimates of relative treatment effect of AD among
elderly with MDD while statistically taking into account heterogeneity. Although
statistically not different, results suggest that among the elderly, duloxetine and TCAs
produce the largest clinical response and remission rates, with relatively favorable
withdrawal rates for duloxetine.
MT4
MIXED TREATMENT COMPARISON (MTC) OF ANTIFUNGAL DRUGS
FOR PROPHYLAXIS TREATMENT AGAINST INVASIVE FUNGAL
INFECTIONS (IFIS) IN PATIENTS RECEIVING CHEMOTHERAPY FOR
HEMATOLOGICAL MALIGNANCIES OR ALLOGENEIC HEMATOPOIETIC
STEM CELLS TRANSPLANTATION
Pechlivanoglou P, Le HH, De Vries R, Postma MJ
University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: Neutropenic patients treated with chemotherapy for hematological
malignancies and recipients of allogeneic hematopoietic stem cells transplantation
(HSCT) are at high risk of acquiring invasive fungal infections (IFIs). Prognoses for
IFIs are poor in terms of mortality and morbidity. An important factor in improving
outcome is early treatment with antifungal agents. Early treatment, however, is complicated by a number of factors, including poor diagnostic measures. As a consequence, antifungal prophylaxis may be an effective strategy. Use of antifungal
prophylaxis remains a matter of controversy, without a clear consensus on the choice
of drug treatment. In this study, we used mixed treatment comparison (MTC) methodologies to compare the effectiveness of different antifungal drugs used in prophylaxis treatments against IFIs in high-risk patients. METHODS: Through systematic
and transparent methodologies, MTC techniques allow for the combination of evidences from different sources and as a result may provide information where none
exists or where direct comparisons are incomplete. For the estimation of effectiveness,
we collected evidence on proven or probable IFIs from 13 different randomized clinical
trials (RCTs). Comparisons of interest included placebo, fluconazole, itraconazole,
voriconazole, and micafungin. The MTC analyses were carried out through the application of Bayesian hierarchical models. RESULTS: Significant evidence was found on
the superiority of all study drugs versus placebo for preventing IFIs. Furthermore,
MTC analyses indicated that the probability of acquiring an IFI after voriconzole
prophylaxis is significantly lower than after fluconazole prophylaxis (dOR = 0,17 95%
CI = [0.03, 0.94]). Comparisons between all other antifungals yielded no significant
differences in incidence of IFIs. CONCLUSIONS: After the application of MTC
methodologies on RCT evidence, the authors found evidence suggesting that prophylaxis with antifungals is superior to placebo and prophylaxis with voriconazole is
superior to fluconazole regarding reduction in incidence of IFIs.
PODIUM SESSION II: DEVELOPMENTS IN HTA AGENCIES LIKE NICE
NI1
RETROSPECTIVE ANALYSIS OF TECHNOLOGY APPRAISALS
CONDUCTED BY UK’S NATIONAL INSTITUTE FOR HEALTH AND
CLINICAL EXCELLENCE (NICE) IN SEVERAL CANCER INDICATIONS:
HIGHER EVIDENCE BARRIERS FOR TARGETED THERAPIES?
Banerji L, Das S
J&D Associates, London, London, UK
OBJECTIVES: We undertook a retrospective analysis of NICE technology appraisals
in NSCLC, hematological malignancies, gastric and breast cancer, and compared
submission evidence with final NICE recommendation. METHODS: The analysis was
based on a review of published appraisals on the NICE website from 2007 to 2010.
RESULTS: Over the past 3 years, NICE completed 15 appraisals in the indications of
NSCLC, hematological malignancies, and gastric and breast cancer. Ten of these
appraisals were of targeted therapies. A total of five out of 15 appraisals were not
recommended mainly because of weak clinical evidence surrounding efficacy. One of
these technologies, Lapatinib, was not recommended for breast cancer despite the
manufacturer offering a patient-access scheme. Focusing on the 10 appraisals that
received positive recommendation, four appraisals received unconditional reimbursement. Rituximab is the only targeted therapy to receive unconditional reimbursement
because it was cost-effective (<£30, 000 per QALY) due to the strong clinical evidence
that demonstrated PFS >10 months compared to chemotherapy in CLL. The remaining
A246
six assessments that resulted in conditional reimbursement were targeted therapies.
Typically, with these targeted therapies, PFS or OS ranged from ~3 months to 9
months with the cost-per-QALY > £45.000. Five of the six manufactures participated
in a patient-access scheme which consisted of fixed-price discounts such as Cetuximab
(CRC) and Gefitinib (NSCLC) or performance schemes like sunitinib (GIST), Bortezomib (myeloma), and Lenalidome (myeloma). CONCLUSIONS: Based on the retrospective analysis, it is clear that the biggest challenge for targeted-cancer therapies is
affordability with only one of the targeted therapies receiving unconditional reimbursement. However, nearly all the other targeted therapies evaluated that offered >3
months OS or PFS were recommended by NICE with a proviso to bring down the
cost of treatment. Therefore, when companies develop their market access strategy,
they should include a patient-access scheme in order to enter the UK market.
NI2
PATIENT ACCESS SCHEMES IN UK ARE DRIVEN BY HEALTH
TECHNOLOGY ASSESMENT
Toumi M1, Jaroslawski S2
1
University of Lyon, Lyon, France; 2Creativ Ceutical, Paris, Ile de France, France
OBJECTIVES: Achieving market access for new products has become complex for
pharmaceutical companies. Faced with growing expenditure, health-care authorities
accept or propose various schemes (risk sharing/payment for performance/commercial): UK’s Department of Health coined a term Patient Access Scheme (PAS) and
published specific guidance for the industry. We performed an in-depth analysis of
design of PASs in UK to revisit their typology and rationale. METHODS: We reviewed
official and grey literature on the Web sites of UK’s HTA Agency—NICE, the Department of Health (DoH), the industry, and in the Internet. We searched for documents
containing all synonimes of PAS and different scheme types. We selected PASs
launched after 2006. RESULTS: We identified 13 PASs, all of which were designed/
implemented in consultation with NICE. Drug’s comparative effectiveness was central
to the rationale behind the design of PASs. If effectiveness was acknowledged in the
HTA, PAS was based on cost-containment (rituximab, erlotinib). If it was not recognized, this was for one of the two reasons: (1) the uncertainity about the long-term
effect of the drug, or (2) the value of ICER was questioned in the HTA. In case of
(1), the PAS consisted in free provision of the drug by manufacturer after a predefined
period (lenalidomide, ranibizumab). In the case of (2), the PAS aimed at lowering the
ICER either through cost containment (sunitinib, cetuximab, pemetrexed), through
linking payment to outcomes (bortezomib, omalizumab), or by a mix of the two
(certolizumab, ustekinumab). CONCLUSIONS: Formalized Health Technology
Assessment is both a prerequisite and reason for implementing Patient Access Schemes
in the UK. If the comparative effectiveness of a drug is acknowledged, the agreement
is based on cost containment. On the other hand, if it is questioned, the PAS may
have a form of a risk-sharing scheme and may be linking the payment to health
outcomes (performance-based scheme).
NI3
NICE’S COST-EFFECTIVENESS THRESHOLD REVISITED: NEW
EVIDENCE ON THE INFLUENCE OF COST-EFFECTIVENESS AND OTHER
FACTORS ON NICE DECISIONS
Devlin N1, Dakin H2, Rice N3, Parkin D4, O’Neill P1
1
Office of Health Economics, London, UK; 2University of Oxford, Oxford, UK; 3University of
York, York, UK; 4NHS South East Coast, Horley, Surrey, UK
OBJECTIVES: Since its establishment, NICE has become increasingly explicit about
the way it uses evidence on cost-effectiveness in decision-making—and, more recently,
about the other factors it considers. This, together with other ways in which decisionmaking has evolved, suggests a number of testable hypotheses. We propose and
empirically test alternative ways that NICE decision-making might be modeled, building on and extending Devlin and Parkin (2004) and Dakin et al. (2006). The large
number of NICE decisions now observable facilitates the use of more sophisticated
modeling techniques. METHODS: NICE’s decisions are characterized as binary
choices: yes or no to a technology in a specifically defined patient group or indication.
NICE Guidance often contains multiple such decisions. The probability of NICE
recommending a technology is modeled as depending on evidence on effectiveness and
cost-effectiveness; characteristics of the patients, disease, or treatment; and contextual
factors. Data were obtained from HTAinSite (http://www.htainsite.com) on November
2009. RESULTS: Initial results, drawing on data for 262 decisions, suggest costeffectiveness alone explains the vast majority of NICE’s decisions, correctly classifying
85%, with high sensitivity and specificity. The estimated threshold, around £40k, is
higher than NICE’s stated threshold (20k–£30k) but similar to that estimated by
Devlin and Parkin (2004). Results across alternative model specifications showed that
almost none of the other variables exert a statistically significant effect on decisions,
with two exceptions. First, technologies for the treatment of cancer have a significantly
higher probability of being accepted, ceteris paribus, implying a willingness to pay an
additional >£10k per QALY gained by cancer patients. Second, analysis of the subset
of decisions made after NICE’s second “social value judgement” document suggest an
increased probability of rejection. CONCLUSIONS: This is work in progress; further
results will be available to report from additional data extraction and modeling.
13th Euro Abstracts
NI4
DO PATIENT ACCESS SCHEMES RESULT IN AN ACCEPTABLE
ADMINISTRATIVE BURDEN?
Haynes S, Costello S, Kusel J, Hamer N, Brooks-Rooney C
Costello Medical Consulting Ltd., Cambridge, UK
OBJECTIVES: In the UK, Patient Access Schemes (PAS) have become more common
in submissions to the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE).
The increase in PAS is a result of the essential role such schemes play in enhancing
the availability of high-cost treatments to payers. In published appraisals, minimal
emphasis has been placed upon the administrative burden of PAS, which is typically
described as “acceptable.” The aim of this study was to assess the impact of administering PAS in the UK, using both primary research and existing literature to identify
key administrative challenges. METHODS: A literature search was conducted using
PubMed and Google Scholar. Freedom of information requests were sent to NICE for
data on PAS administration. a pilot questionnaire was distributed to all 19 contacts
listed on the directory of NHS Chief Pharmacists in Wales, to assess the real-life
burden of PAS administration. RESULTS: Limited literature is available on the administration of PAS. However, the literature search uncovered evidence that the administrative impact of PAS is being recognized. The creation of the Patient Access Scheme
Liaison Unit (PASLU) in October 2009 and the publication of the Pharmaceutical
Price Regulation Scheme (PPRS) are two such developments, both of which are steps
toward a system that more accurately reflects the needs of NHS administrators. The
return rate for the questionnaire was low; however, responders showed dissatisfaction
with multiple aspects of PAS management. Responders emphasized the need to address
NHS requirements (both financial and temporal) in order to facilitate accurate PAS
administration. CONCLUSIONS: Encouraging steps have been taken to recognize the
burden of PAS on the NHS; however, further research is required to assess whether
these recent developments are meaningful in everyday practice. Additional support for
appropriate PAS implementation must also be provided if these important schemes are
to continue effectively.
PODIUM SESSION III: BIASES, METHODOLOGICAL CHALLENGES, AND
SOLUTIONS
BI1
ANALYZING OVERALL SURVIVAL IN RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED
TRIALS WITH CROSS-OVER
Jonsson L1, Sandin R2, Ekman M1, Ramsberg J1, Charbonneau C3, Huang X4, Jonsson B5,
Weinstein MC6, Drummond M7
1
i3 Innovus, Stockholm, Sweden; 2Pfizer Oncology, Sollentuna, Stockholm, Sweden; 3Pfizer,
Inc, New York, NY, USA; 4Pfizer Oncology, La Jolla, CA, USA; 5Stockholm School of
Economics, Stockholm, Sweden; 6Harvard School of Public Health, Boston, MA, USA;
7
University of York, York, UK
BACKGROUND: Offering patients in oncology trials the opportunity to cross over
to active treatment at disease progression is a commonly used strategy to address
ethical issues associated with the use of placebo controls, but could lead to statistical
challenges for the analysis of key end points such as overall survival. While an advantage from the perspective of the treated patient enrolled in the trial, cross-over leads
to loss of information and dilution of the comparative clinical efficacy and costeffectiveness results. OBJECTIVES: The purpose of the study is to compare alternative
methods for analyzing overall survival data in the presence of cross-over, thus illustrating differences between methods, and providing guidance on choice of methodology.
METHODS: Two promising methods for dealing with cross-over are inverse probability of censoring weighting and the rank-preserving structural failure time model. The
methods are compared with naïve censoring of data at cross-over and intention-totreat analysis ignoring cross-over using two recent examples of trials in oncology: the
receptor tyrosine kinase inhibitor sunitinib in renal cell carcinoma (RCC) and in
gastrointestinal stromal tumor (GIST). RESULTS: The analyses showed that for a trial
with a low proportion of cross-over from placebo to active treatment (RCC), the
choice of statistical method did not affect the results to a great extent; the range of
relative mortality risk for active treatment versus control was narrow. With a high
proportion of cross-over (GIST), the range of relative mortality risks was broader.
CONCLUSIONS: Naïve censoring at cross-over can lead to bias and should be
avoided. If cross-over occurs frequently, the inverse probability of censoring weighting
method or the rank-preserving structural failure time model are recommended depending on the characteristics of cross over in the trial, trial size, and available data.
BI2
MULTIPLE COHORT MODELING OF LONG-DURATION
INTERVENTIONS: QUESTIONING TIME HORIZONS AND
AGGREGATION ACROSS COHORTS
O’Mahony J
Erasmus University Medical Center, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
BACKGROUND: Models are widely used in the cost-effectiveness analysis of healthcare interventions. Most models only simulate one patient cohort, but some use
multiple cohorts. Advocates of multicohort modeling contend it better represents
actual health-care implementation, especially where interventions are applied over
specific age ranges, as in cancer screening. When such an intervention is introduced,
cohorts already older than the starting age only receive a partial intervention, possibly
A247
13th Euro Abstracts
resulting in cost-effectiveness different to that of younger cohorts that receive the
complete intervention: multi-cohort models can include both these “complete” and
“partial” cohorts. Some multi-cohort models described as population models impose
finite time horizons at which the intervention is assumed to cease, although health
effects are typically assessed until death. ANALYSIS: If cost-effectiveness differs
between partial and complete cohorts, then the overall cost-effectiveness estimate from
a multi-cohort model will depend on the relative numbers of partial and complete
cohorts. The total number of complete cohorts depends on how long the intervention
is used, which is uncertain. Therefore, the overall estimate may depend, in part, on
the number of future cohorts assumed. The appropriateness of time horizons depends
on whether a cross-sectional or a longitudinal cohort approach is used. Assuming an
intervention ceases at a time horizon is unrepresentative of actual implementation and
may result in biased cost-effectiveness estimates for curtailed cohorts. CONCLUSION:
Multi-cohort modeling is advocated as being more representative of actual implementation. However, a single cost-effectiveness estimate for multiple cohorts necessarily
implies an aggregation of estimates. Such aggregation leaves estimates sensitive to
assumptions of the number of cohorts included, can hide useful information, and lead
to nonoptimal policy choices. We suggest cost-effectiveness estimates for the complete
and incomplete cohorts should not be aggregated, but reported separately. Implementation time horizons should not be used in longitudinal cohort-based modeling in
cost-effectiveness analysis.
BI3
COMMON AND AVOIDABLE ERRORS IN ECONOMIC MODELING: A
REVIEW OF THE FREQUENCY AND IMPACT OF MODELING MISTAKES
Taylor M, Kenworthy J, Lewis L
York Health Economics Consortium, York, North Yorkshire, UK
BACKGROUND: Cost-effectiveness models are often used to predict the costs and
health outcomes that are likely to be associated with various different interventions.
Models are a useful tool for representing the detailed and complex “real world” in a
more simple and understandable structure. While models do not claim to necessarily
create an exact replica of the real world, they can be useful in demonstrating the
relationships and interactions between various different factors. However, developers
of models often consciously, and unconsciously, make assumptions that are avoidable
and may bias the results of a model. METHODS: A review was undertaken on a
random selection of published models in different disease areas to aim to identify the
frequency of typical “errors” in economic models. In addition, a simple model was
developed and used to explore the relative impact of different types of errors in models.
Each type of error was examined for its likely impact on the model’s overall findings
and conclusions. This helped to gain a greater understanding of both the frequency
of different errors and their magnitude of effect. RESULTS: Mistakes are commonly
observed in economic models. These were often due to limitations in scope of the
model, but all were found to be avoidable given unlimited time and data availability.
As well as identifying “major” errors in models, the review also identified many
common errors, such as excluding “half cycle correction,” that often have very little
impact on a model’s results, relative to other common errors. CONCLUSIONS: While
many errors in economic models are frequent, many errors often go unnoticed and
have significant impact upon a model’s results. This analysis has highlighted the relative importance of each type of error and has provided suggestions as to how these
might be avoided.
BI4
ARE SECOND OPINIONS OBJECTIVE? BIASES IN SECOND-OPINION
CONSULTATIONS
Vashitz G1, Pliskin JS2, Parmet Y2, Kosashvili Y3, Ifergane G4, Wientroub S5,
Davidovitch N2
1
Technion Institute of Technology, Haifa, Israel; 2Ben Gurion University of the Negev,
Beer-Sheva, Israel; 3Assaf Harofeh Medical Center, Zerrifin, Israel; 4Soroka University Medical
Center, Beer-Sheva, Israel; 5Dana Children’s Hospital, Tel-Aviv Sourasky Medical Center,
Sackler Faculty of Medicine, Tel-Aviv University, Tel-Aviv, Israel
OBJECTIVES: Discrepancies in diagnosis, treatment, or prognosis may emerge among
physicians. a known decision-making bias is the tendency to shift personal opinion
either toward or away from a previous opinion. We sought to evaluate such biases in
the context of second-opinion medical consultations. METHODS: We distributed a
survey questionnaire to a nationwide sample of orthopedic surgeons and neurologists.
The questionnaires presented eight scenarios, each with conventional treatment
options with no clear-cut preference. In four scenarios, the physicians were told that
a previous opinion had already been given by another physician, or that a second
opinion will be given, and the other four scenarios were used as controls. The physicians’ responses were coded according to the level of intervention (conservative to
interventional). RESULTS: 172 orthopedic surgeons and 160 neurologists filled out
the questionnaires, which represent about 50% of these specialties in Israel. In the
orthopedic questionnaire, when a first opinion had already been given, there was a
shift toward a more interventionist treatment (P < 0.05). This was especially prominent
when the first opinion was known to the second physician. When the patient intended
to seek a second opinion, there was a shift toward a more conservative treatment. No
such effect was found among neurologists. CONCLUSIONS: Physicians’ judgment
may be affected by another physician’s opinion (compared to their choices without a
first opinion). This bias mainly tends toward a more interventionist treatment. Due
to the immense impact of any decision on patient health and resource use, further
research should address such biases and develop tools to address them.
PODIUM SESSION III: HTA POLICY APPROACHES
HT1
REAL-WORLD DATA—IMPROVING APPROACHES FOR
DEMONSTRATING BENEFITS AND RISKS OF NEW DRUGS
Lucas F1, Arenson SM2
1
Pope Woodhead and Associates, St. Ives, UK; 2Cambridge University, Cambridge, UK
OBJECTIVES: Regulators and payers view randomized controlled trials (RCT) as the
gold standard for establishing the benefit/risk of new drugs. However, they are increasingly interested in real-world data (RWD) due to their external validity. This survey
explored stakeholders’ perceptions and emerging trends in the area of RWD.
METHODS: We identified relevant literature since 2006 via Google Scholar and
manual search, and reviewed it based on several topics: types of RWD, pros and cons
of different approaches, and impact of new statistical techniques and technology on
availability and quality of RWD. We then conducted 45–60 min in-depth, semistructured discussions with 17 experts from Academia, HTA bodies, health insurance,
research organizations, and pharmaceutical industry—from the UK, France, Germany,
the The Netherlands, and the United States. Their views about value and future directions of RWD approaches were elicited. RESULTS: Experts unanimously thought that
RCTs would remain a mandatory approach for the foreseeable future due to the limitations of RWD, mainly potential for confounding. New study designs (e.g., randomized database studies) and statistical techniques (e.g., high-dimensional propensity
scoring) remove confounding only partially and need to gain credibility. There was a
strong view that, while registries have been the reference source of observational data,
there is an opportunity for (claims) database and electronic medical records to form
an efficient platform for automatic, real-time analysis of naturalistic data. Despite a
few good examples, it will, however, require time to resolve technical difficulty of
linking databases and, crucially, the challenges of data ownership and privacy issues.
Several experts predict the short-term rise of at-home monitors, “smart pills,” and
“smart phones” that automatically feed into databases, and the increased use of data
from Google Health and Microsoft HealthVault. CONCLUSIONS: RWD may eventually become the new gold standard in drug development, but this will occur only
through incremental progress.
HT2
INFLUENCE OF HTA AND HOSPITAL FUNDING SYSTEMS ON PATIENT
ACCESS TO INNOVATIVE MEDICINES: EXAMPLE OF ADVANCED
RENAL CELL CANCER IN WESTERN EUROPE
Toumi M1, Misset J2, Jaroslawski S3, Aballea S3, Baynton E4, Lamure M1
1
University Claude Bernard Lyon 1, Lyon cedex 08, Rhone Alpes, France; 2Hôpital
Saint-Louis, Paris, Ile de France, France; 3Creativ Ceutical, Paris, Ile de France, France;
4
European Oncology Monitor Synovate Healthcare, London, London, UK
OBJECTIVES: Prices of recently launched targeted therapies are relatively high and
patient access differs between European countries. Advanced renal cell cancer (aRCC)
is a rare malignancy with poor prognosis for which four such drugs are available:
sunitinib, sorafenib, bevacizumab, and temsirolimus. We investigated relations
between funding decisions of national health authorities and patient access to these
treatments. METHODS: We reviewed Web sites of health authorities in France,
Germany, Italy, and UK. Data on drug utilization from June 2006 to July 2009 were
extracted from the Synovate Oncology Monitor, an ongoing prescription database
based on doctors’ diaries. Total sample size varied between countries, from 7766 to
9463 patients within the year ending 2009 Q2. RESULTS: Sunitinib was granted
restricted recommendation by NICE (UK) in March 2009, but other treatments were
not assessed during study period. All drugs were financed through payment-for-performance schemes (P4PS) with a registry in Italy. In France, bevacizumab and temsirolimus were reimbursed on top of DRGs and in Germany only bevacizumab.
Sunitinib was the first line treatment in 62%, 50%, 47%, and 31% of drug-treated
patients in France 2006Q3–2009Q2), Germany, Italy, and UK, respectively, followed
by temsirolimus in France and Germany but sorafenib in Italy. Sorafenib was the most
widely used second line treatment in Germany and Italy. In France, temsirolimus was
used off-label in first line and bevacizumab before funding decision in aRCC was
granted. In UK, many patients remained untreated. CONCLUSIONS: Funding on top
of DRGs in France contributed to early uptake and off-label usage. P4PS were associated with enhanced drug uptake in Italy. In UK, the lack of assessment by NICE
prevented patient access, which raises concern about the current financing system. The
large differences in patient access to recently approved cancer treatments raise the
issue of equity and health outcomes associated with innovative drugs.
HT4
EVIDENCE EXPECTATIONS FROM PAYERS ACROSS THE EU: DOES THE
DISEASE BURDEN ON HEALTH-CARE BUDGETS HAVE AN EFFECT?
Kirpekar S, Mukku SR
Double Helix Consulting Group, London, UK
OBJECTIVES: Payer expectations for reimbursement from novel drugs are constantly
increasing. Understanding these is crucial during evidence generation. Expectations in
terms of clinical outcomes vary across EU countries. This study compared payer
awareness and expectations in two disease areas with contrasting prevalence and
subsequent impact on health-care budgets, and thus their impact on reimbursement.
METHODS: The study was conducted in EU5 markets. Opinions of 36 stakeholders
were collected via telephone interviews. Value drivers for new drugs were tested
including unmet need, clinical data—safety and efficacy, cost-effectiveness, budget
A248
impact, price, price against comparator, and innovation. The results in the two disease
areas were separately analyzed and then compared with each other qualitatively on
the basis depth of the responses. RESULTS: Awareness about the evidence expectations were seen to vary substantially between the disease areas. Payers were seen to
be far more conscious in the high-burden disease area. Of the 12 stakeholders interviewed for the high-burden disease area (cardiovascular disease used as an example),
all of them could provide an in-depth understanding of the value drivers for a new
drug. On the other hand, of the stakeholders interviewed from a low-burden disease
area within urology, a very small part of the sample (n = 2) was able to provide details
about necessary expectations for the indication. CONCLUSIONS: The variation in
awareness among payers in disease areas tends to affect the clinical outcomes that are
presented by the drug manufacturer for a novel drug for the indication. The low
awareness regarding evidence expectations in disease areas with low budgetary impact
may lead to lower quality of evidence being accepted for reimbursement. This needs
to be further investigated.
PHP22
THE USE OF ECONOMIC EVALUATIONS IN DECISION-MAKING AT
MACRO LEVEL: A LITERATURE REVIEW
Silva ML1, Späth HM2, Moumjid NF1
1
Research Group in Health Economics, University Lyon 1; University Lyon 2, Lyon, France;
2
University Lyon 1, Lyon, France
OBJECTIVES: The number of economic-evaluations (EE) increases but their role in
decision-making remains unclear. Our literature review of the use of EE in decisionmaking at macro-level aimed to analyze the methods presented in the articles and to
investigate differences within and between countries regarding the use of EE, its facilitators and barriers. METHODS: We searched major databases (PubMed, Web-ofScience, Euronheed, EconLit) in seven languages, without time limit, using keywords
related to economics, health care policy decision-making, and outcomes research.
Abstracts were screened according to four criteria reflecting the objectives of our
review. Selected articles were analyzed and compared using a checklist of items related
to study context (period, location, domain . . .), methods (population, design . . .),
and outcomes (use of EE, facilitators, barriers . . .). RESULTS: Twenty-nine articles
were selected. Most reported single-country- (24), mainly developed-country-studies
(20). Five multi-country-studies compared countries of Europe, the USA and LatinAmerica. The studies’ population generally included public or private health authorities and used questionnaires (10), interviews (6), focus-groups (1), observations (4) or
a combination of interviews and other methods (8). The main facilitator to using EE
in decision-making was governmental/institutional incentives (UK and Australia).
Although the use of EE has increased since the late 1990s, barriers remain, without
apparent variation, overtime and between countries. Most relate to the accessibility
and acceptability of EE. CONCLUSIONS: Decision-makers are increasingly aware of
the importance of using EE in their practice. Despite large differences in the level of
EE use between countries, barriers are very similar. Studying these barriers could
narrow gaps between researchers and decision-makers and encourage governmental
incentives to using EE. Consequently, we decided to develop a methodology for assessing the use of EE in radiotherapy decision-making, a domain where many EE have
been undertaken, without actually investigating their use. This study will be conducted
in France, and in European or developing-countries.
PODIUM SESSION III: MAPPING SCORE FROM ONE QOL
MEASUREMENT INTO ANOTHER
MA1
HOW TO HANDLE THE MAPPING PROBLEM IN COST-UTILITY
ANALYSES?
Siani C1, de Peretti C1, Castelli C2, Phung T3, Duru G4, Daurès JP2
1
University Claude Bernard Lyon 1, Lyon, France; 2Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de
Nimes, Nimes, France; 3Institut Universitaire de Recherche Clinique, Montpellier, France;
4
Cyklad Group, Rilleux la Pape, France
OBJECTIVES: In cost-utility analyses (CUA), utility values are rarely available for the
entire patients sample and they are generally predicted using a “mapping” interpolation from a functional status questionnaire, known for the entire sample. This
mapping method is not accounted for in pharmaceutical industry and in literature
studies, when building confidence regions around the utility and the incremental costutility ratio, leading to a wrong confidence region and consequently, to a wrong
decision-making. The purpose of this paper is to build a confidence interval (CI)
around the mean utility, accounting for the uncertainty coming from the “mapping”
interpolation. METHODS: Analytical and bootstrap methods are developed to handle
the fact that values are interpolated. Linear, multilinear, and nonlinear mapping are
considered. Monte Carlo experiments are carried out to compare the performance of
these methods. These methodologies are applied on data issued from an observational
study dealing with prostate cancer treatment. Utility is assessed with Standard Gamble
method and some of these values are interpolated from the questionnaires: EORTC
QLQC-30; IPSS and IIEF-5; SF-36 and Visual Analogic Scales. RESULTS: Monte
Carlo experiments show that the analytic and bootstrap 95% CI display coverage
between 94% and 96% for various sample sizes. If mapping is not accounted for
(“naive method”), the coverage is between 20% and 40%. The cross validation shows
similar results. From prostatectomy data, the utility is explained by SF-36, role functioning, diarrhea, and age. For instance, mean utility equals 0.94. The analytic and
13th Euro Abstracts
bootstrap CIs equal [0.59, 1.51] and [0.51, 1.63] respectively. The naive interval
equals [0.95, 1.15]. CONCLUSIONS: In CUA, decision-making based on utility
values interpolated from mapping is not reliable: a naive interval would lead to a
serious mistake. The uncertainty due to mapping has to be accounted for. Our analytic
and bootstrap procedures, integrating the mapping, provide very accurate results.
MA2
ESTIMATING THE ASSOCIATION BETWEEN SF-12 RESPONSES TO
EQ-5D UTILITY VALUES USING A RESPONSE MAPPING AND A
PARAMETER UNCERTAINTY APPROACH
Rivero-Arias O1, Gray A1, Ramos-Goñi JM2
1
University of Oxford, Oxford, Oxfordshire, UK; 2Servicio de Evaluación del Servicio Canario
de Salud, Santa Cruz de Tenerife, Tenerife, Spain
BACKGROUND: Two types of mapping exercises have been suggested to translate
data from the short-form health instrument SF-12 into measurements for the EQ-5D
instrument. One of the trends associates SF-12 data directly to the EQ-5D index,
whereas a second approach suggests a response mapping method where SF-12 data
have been mapped to the five domains of the EQ-5D questionnaire. OBJECTIVES:
To improve the current response mapping approach and provide a comparison
between the direct and the response mapping approaches to the EQ-5D. METHODS:
Five multinomial logit regressions were implemented to estimate the association
between SF-12 variables and each of the EQ-5D domains. Predicted EQ-5D responses
were estimated using a Monte Carlo method. a parameter uncertainty approach was
introduced to calculate confidence intervals for the predicted EQ-5D index. The direct
mapping approach for the comparison was also conducted. Several large data sets
were used for internal and external validation. Actual versus predicted EQ-5D index
were compared using mean square error (MSE), mean absolute error (MAE), and
confidence intervals. RESULTS: In the internal validation data set, both the response
and direct mapping predicted a similar mean EQ-5D index, but the response mapping
yielded a smaller MSE of 0.018 compared to 0.020 in the direct mapping, and a
smaller MAE of 0.091 in the response mapping compared with 0.105 in the direct
mapping method. Using the external validation data set, the MSE and MAE were one
decimal point less in the response compared to the direct mapping. CONCLUSIONS:
The revised response approach provided marginally better results than the direct
mapping method. The response method can be implemented to country-specific
EQ-5D data with available value sets. To facilitate the implementation of the revised
response mapping algorithm, a Stata command has been programmed.
MA3
GLAUCOMA DISEASE PROGRESSION STATES: ESTABLISHING A
DIRECT, QUANTITATIVE LINK BETWEEN VISUAL FIELD DEFECTS AND
UTILITY LOSS
Gerlier L1, Lamotte M1, Verboven Y2
1
IMS Health Consulting, Brussels, Belgium; 2ALCON Couvreur NV, Puurs, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: Treatments of ocular hypertension (OHT) and glaucoma aim mainly
at maintaining the patient’s visual function and related quality of life (QoL). However,
it is not known to what extent the disease progression impacts the health-related QoL.
Using recent publications, the objectives were to 1) derive a range of EQ-5D utility
scores in OHT/glaucoma patients; (2) establish a direct, quantitative link between the
mean defect in perimetry (MD) measured in decibels (db) and the utility loss; and (3)
estimate the utility level of patients reaching a glaucoma stage. METHODS: The
glaucoma stages were characterized using MD thresholds of 0 db (OHT), 0–6 db
(early glaucoma), 6–12 db (moderate), 12–22 db (advanced), and >22 db (legal blindness), as per the Hodapp classification. An algorithm allowing to derive EQ-5D utility
scores from the eight mean subscale scores to the SF-36 (Ara and Brazier 2008) was
applied to the range of SF-36 scores published in a systematic review of QoL in
glaucoma (Mills 2009). Besides, the same algorithm was used to estimate the utility
loss corresponding to a MD of 1 db, based on a regression model assessing the correlation between visual function and QoL in glaucoma patients (Lin and Yang 2010).
RESULTS: Over eight studies in OHT/glaucoma patients, utility scores ranged from
0.65 to 0.89. Based on a significant regression coefficient for the SF-36 Role Physical
subscale, a utility loss of 0.0295/db was calculated. Applying this utility loss/db to the
predefined thresholds, the ranges of unadjusted utility scores expected per glaucoma
stage equal: 0.72–0.90 (early), 0.55–72 (moderate), 0.25–0.55 (advanced), and <0.25
(blindness), assuming a baseline utility of 0.90 for OHT. CONCLUSIONS: These
utility scores per disease stage are consistent with published direct measures of HUI3.
The estimated utility loss per db is sizeable and could be implemented in cost-utility
models where disease progression is tracked.
MA4
ANCHOR-BASED DETERMINATION OF THE MINIMAL IMPORTANT
DIFFERENCE OF A PRO SCALE—A CRITICAL LOOK ON A WIDELY
USED METHOD BY MEANS OF A SIMULATION STUDY
Kemmler G, Giesinger J, Holzner B
Innsbruck Medical University, Innsbruck, Tyrol, Austria
OBJECTIVES: Anchor-based methods are frequently used for determining the
minimal important difference (MID) of scales employed to measure patient-reported
outcomes (PRO). The anchor may, e.g., consist of a global rating by the patient or
the doctor or of a clinical measure closely related to the issue to be measured. The
role of the psychometrical properties of the anchor has been rarely studied in this
context. Aim of this contribution is to shed more light on the relationship between
A249
13th Euro Abstracts
the reliability of the anchor and the estimated MID. METHODS: We performed a
simulation study in which the reliability of the anchor used for MID estimation was
varied systematically. Features of real-life data (e.g., skewed distribution, discreteness
of PRO scale) and anchors were used to generate simulated PRO scales and anchors.
MIDs were then estimated on the basis of the simulated data. RESULTS: Compared
to the MID value obtained with an anchor with perfect reliability (r = 1), a marked
attenuation of the MID was observed when reducing the reliability of the anchor.
Thus, an anchor with reliability 0.7 gave rise to a 24% to 35% decrease of the MID
estimate and an anchor with reliability 0.5 led to a 45% to 55% reduction. Based on
the findings and on theoretical considerations, we suggest a method for bias correction.
CONCLUSIONS: When determining the MID of a PRO scale by an anchor-based
method, the reliability of the anchor plays a crucial role. Anchors with poor to moderate reliability may lead to considerable underestimation of the MID. Bias correction
is possible provided the reliability of the anchor is known.
PODIUM SESSION III: PRICING AND MARKET ACCESS
PR1
THE APPLICATION OF PHARMACOECONOMIC MODELING TO
ESTIMATE A VALUE-BASED PRICE FOR NEW CANCER DRUGS IN A
PUBLICLY FUNDED HEALTH-CARE SYSTEM
Dranitsaris G1, Truter I1, Lubbe M2, Spirovski B3, Cottrell W4, Edwards J5
1
Nelson Mandela University, Port Elizabeth, Eastern Cape, South Africa; 2North-West
University, Potchefstroom, North-West Provi, South Africa; 3Humber River Regional Cancer
Centre, Weston, ON, Canada; 4Princess Margaret Hospital, Toronto, ON, Canada; 5Dr. H.
Bliss Murphy Cancer Center, St Johns’s, NF, Canada
OBJECTIVES: Value-based pricing has recently been discussed by international organizations as a means to estimate a drug price that is linked to the benefits it offers
patients and society. However, one of the challenges with value-based pricing is
determining the optimal threshold for health policy decision-making. The World
Health Organization (WHO) has recommended using multiples of a country’s per
capita GDP as the value threshold. In this study, pharmacoeconomic modeling was
used to estimate a value-based monthly price for a hypothetical new cancer drug that
provides a 3-month survival to patients with metastatic colorectal cancer (mCRC).
METHODS: A decision model was developed to simulate progression free and overall
survival in mCRC patients receiving standard chemotherapy ± the new drug. Outcomes for cancer control and side effects were abstracted from randomized trials in
mCRC. Costs for chemotherapy were obtained from Canadian cancer centers. Utility
estimates measured as quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs) were determined by interviewing 24 oncology nurses and pharmacists using the Time Trade-Off technique. The
monthly price of the new drug was then modeled using a threshold of $117,000 per
QALY gained, which is three times the Canadian per capita GDP, as recommended
by the WHO. RESULTS: The analysis suggested that a monthly price of $2180 would
be considered cost-effective from the Canadian public health perspective. If the drug
were able to improve patient quality of life or survival from 3 to 6 months, the monthly
price could increase to $4100 and $3430 and offer the same value. CONCLUSIONS:
The use of the WHO criteria for estimating a value-based price is feasible. However,
one of the challenges would be to identify an appropriate threshold that would provide
a balance between what governments can afford to pay and the commercial viability
of the product in the reference country.
PR2
DECIDING ON VALUE FOR MONEY: A COMPARISON OF THE DUTCH,
BELGIAN, SWEDISH, AND FRENCH DRUG REIMBURSEMENT SYSTEMS
Franken M1, le Polain M2, Senn A2, Koopmanschap M1, Cleemput I2
1
Erasmus University, Rotterdam, The Netherlands; 2Belgian Health Care Knowledge Centre,
Brussel, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: Many countries are adapting their pharmaceutical reimbursement
system, increasingly emphasizing the role of pharmacoeconomics in decision-making.
The aim of our study is to analyze European regulatory systems to obtain insight into
best practice systems that deliver value for money. METHODS: The analytical Hutton
Framework was used for comparing and assessing “fourth hurdle” drug reimbursement systems in the The Netherlands, Belgium, Sweden, and France. We investigated
policy documents, explored literature, and conducted interviews with policymakers
and representatives of the pharmaceutical industry. RESULTS: All systems have a
centralized decision body, even though the financial responsibility may be regional
(Sweden). Only in Sweden, the minister has no role at the individual reimbursement
decision level. None of the systems has a fully independent evaluation process and the
impact of the systems is mainly assessed on drug expenditure. All countries make
efforts to increase transparency. However, in Sweden manufacturers may withdraw
their application before the final reimbursement decision, guaranteeing confidentiality
at the cost of less transparency. Policies to deal with uncertainty vary per country:
financial risk-sharing agreements by price/volume contracts—France—versus outcomes-based agreements for expensive inpatient drugs—the The Netherlands. The
actual value of a drug and disease severity is reflected in the level of reimbursement
in France and Belgium, whereas in the The Netherlands and Sweden, enlisted drugs
are fully reimbursed. All countries attempt to increase the importance of pharmacoeconomics in decision-making. However, no country expresses the relative importance
of cost-effectiveness compared to other criteria nor applies a strictly defined threshold.
CONCLUSIONS: This study reveals that while there is a convergence in scientific
evaluation processes, important differences remain between the Dutch, Belgian,
Swedish, and French regulatory frameworks. All countries recognize that pharmacoeconomics has a place in decision-making on value for money, but for the time being,
pharmacoeconomics seems to play a rather undefined role.
PR3
THE IMPACT OF FINNISH PHARMACEUTICAL PRICING SCHEME IN
COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSES
Hallinen T, Soini EJ
ESiOR Ltd, Kuopio, Finland
OBJECTIVES: Finnish retail prices for drugs are determined with a pricing scheme
(PS). The PS is of the form “multiplier × wholesale price + fixed sum.” The multiplier
ranges from 1.125 to 1.5 (being smaller for higher wholesale prices), whereas the fixed
sum ranges from 0.5 to 47.68 euros (being larger for higher wholesale prices).
Although PS is regressive, it nevertheless provides higher absolute pharmacy margins
for drugs with higher wholesale prices. At the lower end of wholesale prices, PS results
in retail prices that do not cover dispensing costs. Despite this, the retail prices (excluding VAT 8%) are used to represent all drug and drug delivery costs in economic evaluations. This study assesses the impact of this Finnish system-derived “distortion” in
cost-effectiveness analyses. METHODS: The cost utilities of new hypothetical treatments were assessed in a setting where the new and old treatments produce different
amounts of quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs) and the only cost difference comes
from the pharmaceutical prices. The treatments are assumed not to differ regarding
the real costs of drug delivery and patient survival. The PS-induced computational
cost difference was deducted from the retail price differences of new and old treatments
to estimate the impact of PS on the incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICER).
RESULTS: The computational cost differences due to PS ranged from 7.3 to 1 951
euros and the QALYs gained ranged from 0.004 to 0.070 in estimated scenarios. The
respective ICERs increased by 104 to 487 840 euros/QALY due to the PS. CONCLUSIONS: The PS significantly worsens the ICERs obtained for more expensive and often
innovative pharmaceuticals. The Finnish PS is problematic when the aim is to provide
optimal, cost-effective treatments to Finnish patients. In the current form, the PS
discourages innovation and may prevent reimbursement of otherwise cost-effective
treatments.
PR4
GLOBAL MARKET ACCESS STRATEGY: AN INTEGRATED APPROACH
1
2
Pang F , Mukku S
1
Shire Human Genetic Therapies, Inc, Basingstoke, UK, 2Double Helix Consulting Group,
London, UK
OBJECTIVES: To develop a framework for integrating pricing and reimbursement
with health economics and outcomes research and health policy to achieve commercially desirable prices and levels of access in 2010 and beyond. METHODS: A review
of recent pricing policy and regulatory changes of countries, especially those in the
financially troubled Eurozone, was conducted. This was supplemented by a review of
P&R decisions for a selection of drug launches between 2005 and 2009 and categorized according to the level of therapeutic innovation and disease type (conventional,
rare diseases, oncology). a search was performed on the OHE and NHS EED databases
and HTA reports to establish the level of published value evidence in support of these
launches, and finally, the components of most importance to a market access strategy
were identified and validated through interviews across different stakeholder types.
RESULTS: The review identified since January 2010, there have been 11 pricing policy
and regulatory changes. From the review of recent P&R decisions and stakeholder
interviews, the main components identified were: competitive and environmental
analysis (market assessment, reimbursement, revenue forecasts, policy trends); analysis
of payer’s decision drivers (payer, physician, and other stakeholder qualitative
research); value demonstration (value hypotheses, economic modeling, patientreported outcomes, scientific advice); pricing strategy (price targets, cross-market
revenue optimization modeling, country launch sequencing, scenario planning); and
local market access tactics (HTA, risk sharing, contracting negotiations with payers).
The review of the P&R decisions also demonstrated an increasing trend toward
deployment of risk-sharing schemes since 2008. CONCLUSIONS: Development of a
successful market access strategy requires an understanding of pricing, health economics and outcomes research, health technology assessment (HTA), and health policy,
and continually keeping vigilant and adapting to rapid changes in the policy environment. This research gives direction to health economics, P&R, and government affairs
professionals for the development of an integrated framework for the design and
implementation of a global market access strategy.
PODIUM SESSION III: HTA IN VACCINE AND EPIDEMICS
VA1
ARE THE BENEFITS OF FLU VACCINATION IN THE ELDERLY
CORRECTLY SIMULATED IN ECONOMIC ASSESSMENT MODELS?
Chen YC1, Van Bellinghen LA2, Van Vlaenderen I2, Standaert B1
1
GlaxoSmithKline Biologicals, Wavre, Belgium; 2Deloitte, Diegem, Belgium
BACKGROUND: In literature, economic models of flu vaccination in elderly (65+)
most often consider the target population as one homogeneous age group evaluated
during a 1-year time period (= 1-year 65+ group cohort model). Because the mortality
A250
rates in elderly steeply increase with age and the transition probabilities for specific
health states are age specific, this population should be evaluated as non-homogeneous
and over a lifetime with annual vaccinations. This study compares the cost results of
flu vaccination between these two different modeling approaches. METHODS: Two
models were developed to estimate the direct costs of annual flu vaccination compared
with no vaccination: 1) a 1-year 65+ group cohort model; and 2) a lifetime multi-age
cohort model with target population and clinical pathways stratified in five age cohorts
(65–69 years; 70–74 years; 75–79 years; 80–84 years; 85+ years) eligible for annual
vaccination. Both models were populated with US specific data. Vaccination coverage
and disease management were identical in both models. The decision tree included the
following states: natural deaths, infected, and symptomatic states followed by GP
visits, hospitalizations (pneumonia, influenza, stroke, myocardial infarction, and congestive heart failure), disease-specific death rates, and recovery in nursing homes.
Undiscounted costs per individual per year are compared for vaccinated and unvaccinated groups, using both approaches. RESULTS: The cost per individual per year
is higher in the 1-year 65+ group cohort model versus the lifetime multi-age cohort
model (no vaccination: $205 vs. $139; vaccination: $185 vs. $113) as expected:
considering additional age cohorts with decreasing life expectancies in the multi-age
cohort lowers the average cost per individual per year. Meanwhile, the selection of
model type impacts the estimated incremental cost of vaccinated versus unvaccinated
groups ($−20 vs. $−26). CONCLUSIONS: In economic assessments, a 1-year 65+
group cohort approach undervalues the impact of heterogeneity in elderly on the
benefit of flu vaccination, and therefore, a lifetime multi-age cohort is preferred.
VA2
GATHERING INFORMATION BY COMPARISON OF DIFFERENT
DYNAMIC MODELING APPROACHES FOR EPIDEMIC MODELS
Zauner G1, Popper N1, Miksch F2, Urach C2, Einzinger P2, Endel G3, Schiller-Frühwirth I3,
Breitenecker F2
1
Dwh Simulation Services, Vienna, Austria; 2Vienna University of Technology, Vienna, Austria,
3
Main Association of Austrian Social Security Institutions, Vienna, Austria
OBJECTIVES: Several dynamic approaches can simulate epidemics and vaccination
strategies. Generally, the models can be divided into top-down approaches like
Markov models and differential equations and bottom-up approaches like cellular
automata and agent-based models. Top-down approaches are characterized by cumulative values that are representing groups of people. Bottom-up approaches, in contrast, consider individuals. Both approaches have advantages and disadvantages.
Top-down approaches can be analyzed very well with mathematical methods, while
bottom-up approaches require comparison of the outcome of simulation runs with
different parameter sets. To improve validity of model structures, a method that
compares different approaches for epidemic models is introduced. METHODS: Statistical calculations and Markov models are static, while other approaches like differential equations or individual-based models are dynamic. In this context, dynamic
does not only stand for simulation over time but also for models where the calculation
of the next time step or period depends on the current state of the model. Since the
transition matrices in Markov models are calculated before execution time, it is not
considered to be dynamic. The advantage of dynamic models is that they can produce
highly nonlinear behavior that cannot be reached with static calculations. To validate
the structure of such nonlinear models, different model types are implemented and
compared. Results are compared; sensitivity analysis is done separately. RESULTS:
Outcome of vaccination against streptococcus pneumoniae was tested. a differential
equations model and an agent-based model could reproduce results of published
Markov models. As soon as we consider population dynamics, herd immunity, and
serotype replacement, the Markov model was not able to fulfill the structural requirements anymore, while dynamic approaches still work. CONCLUSIONS: Dynamic
models offer more information and opportunities for epidemic simulation. Usage of
different approaches provides at least comparable reliability.
PIN61
INFLUENZA RISK AND VACCINATION RATES IN EUROPE: A
NATIONWIDE SURVEY OF ADULTS
DiBonaventura M1, Goren A1, Gupta S2, Wagner JS1, Freedman D2
1
Kantar Health, New York, NY, USA; 2Kantar Health, Princeton, NJ, USA
OBJECTIVES: The aim of the current study was to determine influenza vaccination
rates among high- and non-high-risk adults across Europe (UK, France, Germany,
Italy, and Spain). METHODS: Data from the 2008 EU National Health and Wellness
Survey (NHWS) were used. Demographics, comorbidities, and vaccination behavior
in the past year were assessed for all respondents. Health-related quality of life (SF12v2) and resource use (number of emergency room visits, hospitalizations, and physician visits) in the past 6 months were also measured. RESULTS: Only 23.7% of
respondents received an influenza vaccine in the past year (UK: 25.3%, Germany:
25.2%, France: 20.2%, Italy: 24.8%, Spain: 24.1%). a total of 28,158 respondents
(52.6%) were at high risk for influenza complications (i.e., over age 50, had chronic
conditions such as asthma, diabetes, COPD, cardiovascular conditions, or HIV/AIDS).
Those at high risk reported significantly lower levels of both physical quality of life
(mean = 45.88 vs. mean = 52.10) and health utilities (mean = 0.72 vs. mean = 0.73),
and significantly higher levels of emergency room visits (mean = 0.21 vs. mean = 0.17),
hospitalizations (mean = 0.22 vs. mean = 0.12), and provider visits (mean = 5.96 vs.
mean = 4.14) in the past 6 months relative to those not at high risk, all P < 0.0001.
Despite the significantly worse health profile, only 35.9% of high-risk respondents
received the vaccine. High-risk status was the strongest driver of vaccination in the
13th Euro Abstracts
UK (high risk: 42.2% vaccinated vs. non-high risk: 5.4% vaccinated, Φ = 0.42) and
the weakest in Germany (high risk: 31.8% vaccinated vs. non-high risk: 16.2% vaccinated, Φ = 0.18). The most common reason for nonvaccination was a belief that the
vaccine was unimportant (35.9%). CONCLUSIONS: Despite influenza vaccine recommendation guidelines, only a modest percentage of respondents in Europe were
vaccinated. Even those at high risk for influenza complications, who reported significantly worse health outcomes than non-high-risk respondents, were vaccinated at less
than a 40% rate.
VA4
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF UNIVERSAL HEPATITIS B IMMUNIZATION IN
VIETNAM: APPLICATION OF COST-EFFECTIVENESS AFFORDABILITY
CURVES IN HEALTH DECISION-MAKING
Tu HAT, de Vries R, Woerdenbag HJ, van Hulst M, Postma MJ
University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: To perform a cost-effectiveness analysis of newborn universal vaccination against hepatitis B virus (HBV) and to identify the cost-effective affordability
levels of the vaccination program in Vietnam. METHODS: We simulated a birth
cohort using 1,693,000 newborns in 2002. Incremental cost-effective ratios (ICERs)
per quality-adjusted-life-year (QALY) gained with universal newborn vaccination
against HBV was calculated using a Markov model. Two types of analyses (including
and excluding expenditure on the treatment of chronic hepatitis B and its complications) were performed. We used 5000 Monte Carlo simulations to examine the costeffectiveness acceptability and affordability of the vaccination program from the
payer’s perspective and to derive a cost-effective affordability curve to assess the
program’s cost and health effects. All costs were expressed in 2002 US dollars.
RESULTS: In the base-case scenario, newborn universal vaccination against HBV
reduced the carrier rate by 58% at a cost of US$42 per carrier averted. From the
payer’s perspective, marginal cost per life-year and per QALY gained were US$4.76,
much lower than GDP per capita of ~US$440 in 2002. The vaccination could be
potentially affordable starting at a relatively low budget of US$1.7 million. Newborn
universal vaccination would save US$ 1 billion from the treatment cost of complications due to chronic HBV infections. The probability of vaccination being both costeffective and affordable is 27% at an annual budget of US$4.1 million at the
cost-effectiveness threshold of US$3.9 per QALY. CONCLUSIONS: Universal
newborn vaccination against HBV is highly cost-effective in Vietnam. In low-income,
high-endemic countries, where funds are limited and economic results of vaccination
are uncertain, our findings on the cost-effectiveness affordability options would assist
decision-makers in making proper health investments in vaccination strategies against
HBV.
POSTER SESSION I
CANCER – Clinical Outcomes Studies
PCN1
TOLERABILITY OF FIRST-LINE TREATMENTS OF LOCALLY ADVANCED
OR METASTATIC NON-SMALL-CELL LUNG CANCER (NSCLC): A
SYSTEMATIC REVIEW AND ADJUSTED INDIRECT COMPARISON
Edwards SJ1, Welton N2, Borrill J1
1
AstraZeneca UK Ltd, Luton, Bedfordshire, UK; 2University of Bristol, Bristol, UK
OBJECTIVES: Platinum-based chemotherapy is a common first-line treatment of
NSCLC; tolerability impacts on choice of regimen. This research compared the tolerability of gefitinib and doublet chemotherapy in this setting in patients with activating
epidermal growth factor receptor tyrosine kinase (EGFR-TK) mutations (M+).
METHODS: Systematic searching of CENTRAL, EMBASE, and MEDLINE for randomized controlled trials (RCTs) comparing ≥2 doublet chemotherapies (carboplatin
or cisplatin in combination with either docetaxel, gemcitabine, paclitaxel, pemetrexed,
or vinorelbine) for the first-line treatment of advanced NSCLC was completed in May
2009. Data were extracted on the following grades 3/4/5 adverse events (AEs) most
commonly reported with doublet chemotherapy or EGFR-TK inhibitors: anemia,
diarrhea, fatigue, febrile neutropenia, nausea/vomiting, neutropenia, and rash. We
performed a meta-analysis of the available gefitinib versus paclitaxel/carboplatin RCTs
in EGFR-TK M+ patients. We then carried out a mixed treatment comparison (MTC)
of doublet chemotherapies in unselected advanced NSCLC patients using paclitaxel/
carboplatin as a baseline. Treatment effect for the risk of AE occurrence was estimated
as an odds ratio (OR > 1.0 favors paclitaxel/carboplatin). RESULTS: Three RCTs were
identified for gefitinib, of which two were comparisons with paclitaxel/carboplatin. Metaanalysis of these two trials gave the following statistically significant results: anemia—OR
0.12, 95% confidence interval: 0.03–0.47; diarrhea—OR 5.78, 95% CI: 1.01–33.11;
neutropenia—OR 0.01, 95% CI: 0.00–0.03. Twenty-nine trials were appropriate for
inclusion in the MTC. The alternative doublet chemotherapy regimens did not demonstrate a statistically significant reduction in risk of any of the AEs assessed versus paclitaxel/
carboplatin, with the exception of gemcitabine/cisplatin, which had a lower risk of febrile
neutropenia (OR 0.39, 95% credible interval: 0.12–0.96). CONCLUSIONS: In the
absence of RCTs comparing all doublet chemotherapies with gefitinib in EGFR-TK
M+ patients with advanced NSCLC, this adjusted indirect comparison suggests that
gefitinib may have important tolerability advantages over other first-line treatments
in this targeted population.
13th Euro Abstracts
PCN2
PALONOSETRON VERSUS OTHER 5-HT3-RECEPTOR ANTAGONISTS IN
PREVENTING CHEMOTHERAPY-INDUCED NAUSEA AND VOMITING IN
PATIENTS WITH CANCER TREATED IN A HOSPITAL OUTPATIENT
SETTING
Craver C1, Gayle J1, Balu S2, Buchner D2
1
Premier, Inc, Charlotte, NC, USA; 2Eisai, Inc., Woodcliff Lake, NJ, USA
OBJECTIVES: To explore the risk of uncontrolled chemotherapy-induced nausea and
vomiting (CINV) associated with palonosetron (a 5-hydroxy tryptamine3-receptor
antagonist [5-HT3-RA]) initiation versus other 5-HT3-RAs among patients with cancer
on chemotherapy (CT) treatment in a hospital outpatient setting. METHODS: Patients
with a cancer diagnosis initiating CT and anti-emetic prophylaxis with palonosetron
(Group 1) and other 5-HT3-RAs (Group 2) for the first time (index date) between
April 1, 2007 and March 31, 2009 were identified from the Premier Perspective (TM)
Database. Inclusion criteria were patients aged ≥18 years, no evidence of nausea and
vomiting or a hospital charge for a CT or anti-emetic medication in the 6-month
pre-index date period, and 36 consecutive months of hospital data submission.
Patients were followed through eight CT cycles or 6 months post-index date, whichever occurred first. a negative binomial distribution-generalized linear multivariate
regression model estimating the number of CINV events on CT-matched groups in
the follow-up period was developed after adjusting for several demographic and clinical variables. RESULTS: Of 9144 identified patients, 1775 initiated palonosetron
(Group 1; 19.4%). Group 1 patients were significantly younger (61.2 [SD: 13.0] vs.
62.8 [13.1] years; P < 0.0001), comprised more females (52.5% vs. 41.1%; P <
0.0001), less Blacks (8.6% vs. 13.2%; P < 0.0001), more highly emetogenic CT
(43.3% vs. 28.5%; P < 0.0001), and more lung (26.1% vs. 22.4%; P < 0.0001) and
breast cancer patients (19.3% vs. 15.3%; P < 0.0001). In the follow-up period, the
number of unadjusted CINV events was statistically lower for Group 1 (8336 vs. 9400;
P = 0.0007) patients. The regression model predicted a 13.7% decrease in the total
CINV events per patient per cycle for Group 1 patients versus Group 2 patients; P =
0.0006. CONCLUSIONS: In this retrospective hospital outpatient study, patients with
cancer initiated on palonosetron were more likely to experience a significantly lower
rate of CINV events versus those initiating other 5-HT3-RAs.
PCN3
CHEMOTHERAPY-INDUCED NAUSEA AND VOMITING EVENTS BY
CHEMOTHERAPY EMETOGENICITY IN PATIENTS WITH CANCER
TREATED IN A HOSPITAL OUTPATIENT SETTING
Craver C1, Gayle J1, Balu S2, Buchner D2
1
Premier, Inc, Charlotte, NC, USA; 2Eisai, Inc., Woodcliff Lake, NJ, USA
OBJECTIVES: To characterize the changes in chemotherapy-induced nausea and
vomiting (CINV) events by chemotherapy (CT) emetogenicity among patients with
cancer initiating CT treatment in a hospital outpatient setting. METHODS: Patients
with cancer initiating CT for the first time (index date) between April 1, 2007 and
March 31, 2009 were extracted from the Premier Perspective comparative database.
Patients aged ≥18 years, no evidence of nausea and vomiting or a hospital charge for
a CT agent or antiemetic medication in the 6-month pre-index period, and 36 consecutive months of hospital data submission were included. Patients were followed through
eight CT cycles or 6 months post-index date, whichever occurred first. CT was categorized as highly emetogenic (HEC), moderately emetogenic (MEC), low emetogenic
(LEC), or minimal emetogenic (MinEC) per National Comprehensive Cancer Network
guidelines. a descriptive analysis of changes in CINV events (either a diagnosis of
nausea and/or vomiting or evidence of CINV-related medications) per CT cycle per
CT emetogenicity was performed in the follow-up period. RESULTS: The overall
study population (N = 11,495) had an average age of 63.3 years (SD 13.4), was 50.7%
female, and 86% white. Most common tumor types were lung (19.8%), breast
(15.9%), and urinary tract (13.8%). Use of HEC (cycle 1: 26.0% vs. study end: 9.8%;
P = < 0.0001) decreased over the follow-up period. Change in CINV events from cycle
1 to study end was statistically significant for HEC (32.1% vs. 29.9%; P < 0.0001),
MEC (38.4% vs. 39.9%; P < 0.0001), LEC (26.4% vs. 27.8%; P < 0.0001), and
MinEC (3.2% vs. 2.4%; P < 0.0001). The % point change from cycle 1 to study end
was also statistically significant between groups (HEC [−2.2%] vs. MEC [+1.5%] vs.
LEC [+1.4%] vs. MinEC [−0.8%]; P < 0.0001). CONCLUSIONS: In this retrospective
hospital outpatient study, patients with cancer initiated on MEC and LEC experienced
significantly higher CINV events over time versus HEC-initiated patients.
PCN4
LIKELIHOOD OF A SUBSEQUENT CHEMOTHERAPY-INDUCED NAUSEA
AND VOMITING (CINV) EVENT IN PATIENTS RECEIVING MODERATELY
OR HIGHLY EMETOGENIC CHEMOTHERAPY (MEC/HEC)
Feinberg B1, Gilmore J1, Haislip S1, Jackson J2, Jain G2, Balu S3, Buchner D3
1
Georgia Cancer Specialists, Atlanta, GA, USA; 2Xcenda, LLC., Palm Harbor, FL, USA; 3Eisai,
Inc., Woodcliff Lake, NJ, USA
OBJECTIVES: CINV with MEC and HEC therapy is well studied, but the association
of prior history of CINV with the future risk of CINV is not well quantified. This
study assessed the increased likelihood of a subsequent CINV following a first administration CINV in patients on single-day MEC/HEC therapy. METHODS: A retrospective analysis was conducted utilizing Georgia Cancer Specialists electronic medical
records database (October 2006–August 2009). Patients who received >1 single-day
MEC/HEC administration with no chemotherapy 3 months prior were included.
Patients who received multiday chemotherapy, started with low emetogenic chemotherapy, or had no dosing information were excluded. Two cohorts, a first administra-
A251
tion CINV (Group 1) and no first administration CINV (Group 2), were created and
followed for 6 months. a multivariate logistic regression assessed the likelihood of
subsequent CINV during the 6-month follow-up, controlling for age, gender, Charlson
comorbidity index, cancer type, gap between administrations, and chemotherapy
emetogenicity. Sub-analyses were performed for patients initiated on MEC and HEC.
RESULTS: A total of 3721 patients met inclusion criteria; 423 (11.37%) experienced
a first administration CINV. These patients were younger (56.6 vs. 59.4; P < 0.0001),
had lower comorbidity index (2.1 vs. 2.2; P = 0.0154), and had more gaps between
administrations (18.5 vs. 17.4; P = 0.0204). Unadjusted subsequent CINV rate was
higher in the Group 1 cohort (52.3% vs. 24.2%; P < 0.0001). After controlling for
covariates, Group 1 patients were 3.5 times more likely to have a subsequent CINV
compared to Group 2 patients (odds ratio [OR]: 3.48 [95% CI: 2.81–4.30]; P <
0.0001). Sub-analyses by MEC/HEC supported overall analysis (HEC OR: 2.9 [95%
CI: 2.1–3.9; P < 0.0001]) and (MEC OR: 4.1 [95% CI: 3.1–5.5; P < 0.0001]). CONCLUSIONS: In this retrospective analysis, patients receiving single-day MEC/HEC
who had a prior CINV were at increased risk of subsequent CINV. Further research
on the clinical and economic impact of early and appropriate anti-emetic prophylaxis
is required.
PCN5
EFFICACY OF PALONOSETRON (PAL) COMPARED TO OTHER
SEROTONIN INHIBITORS (5-HT3R) IN PREVENTING CHEMOTHERAPYINDUCED NAUSEA AND VOMITING (CINV) IN PATIENTS RECEIVING
MODERATELY OR HIGHLY EMETOGENIC (MOHE) TREATMENT: AN
UPDATE OF THE PREVIOUSLY PUBLISHED SYSTEMATIC REVIEW AND
META-ANALYSIS
Botrel TEA, Clark O, Clark LGO, Paladini L, Faleiros E, Pegoretti B
MedInsight-Evidências, Campinas, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: To perform an update of the previously published systematic review
and meta-analysis (Engel T. et al. ISPOR 2009) of all randomized controlled trials
comparing a single intravenous dose of PAL 0.25 mg with other 5-HT3R in patients
receiving MoHE chemotherapy. METHODS: Several databases were searched, including
MEDLINE, EMBASE, LILACS, and CENTRAL. The primary end points were the incidence of acute and delayed nausea and vomiting. The adverse events of each treatment
were analyzed. a subgroup analysis was performed to evaluate the impact of the use of
concomitant corticosteroids. The results are expressed as risk ratio (RR) and the correspondent 95% confidence interval (CI). RESULTS: Six studies were included, comprising 2201 patients. PAL was compared to Ondansetron, Granisetron, and Dolasetron.
Patients in PAL group had less nausea, both acute (RR = 0.86; CI 95% = 0.76 to 0.96;
P = 0.007) and delayed (RR = 0.82; CI 95% = 0.75 to 0.89; P < 0.00001). They also
had less acute vomiting (RR = 0.77; CI 95% = 0.67 to 0.88; P = 0.0001) and delayed
vomiting (RR = 0.78; CI 95% = 0.70 to 0.86; P < 0.00001). There were no statistical
differences in adverse events like headache (RR = 0.84; CI 95% = 0.61 to 1.17; P =
0.30), dizziness (RR = 0.40; CI 95% = 0.13 to 1.27; P = 0.12), constipation (RR =
1.29; CI 95% = 0.77 to 2.17; P = 0.33), or diarrhea (RR = 0.67; CI 95% = 0.24 to
1.85; P = 0.44). Patients receiving PAL presented less nausea and vomiting regardless
of the use of corticosteroids. CONCLUSIONS: PAL was more effective than the other
5-HT3R in preventing acute and delayed CINV in patients receiving MoHE treatments,
regardless of the use of concomitant corticosteroids.
PCN6
PRESERVED ANTITUMOR ACTIVITY AND REDUCED CARDIOTOXICITY
OF FIRST-LINE PEGYLATED LIPOSOMAL DOXORUBICIN COMPARED
WITH CONVENTIONAL DOXORUBICIN IN PATIENTS WITH
METASTATIC BREAST CANCER
Mann K, Rana C, Wadhwa A
Heron Health Private Ltd., Chandigarh, India
OBJECTIVES: Doxorubicin is an anthracycline used in the treatment of breast cancer,
but its use is limited by cumulative dose-dependent cardiotoxicity. Pegylated liposomal
doxorubicin is a novel drug delivery system that alters biodistribution of doxorubicin
resulting in reduced cardiotoxicity. Our aim is to compare the efficacy and cardiotoxicity of pegylated liposomal doxorubicin and conventional doxorubicin in first-line
treatment of metastatic breast cancer (MBC). METHODS: The literature databases
(Cochrane Library, EMBASE, and PUBMED) were searched from inception to May
2010. Randomized controlled trials assessing the efficacy and cardiotoxicity of
pegylated liposomal doxorubicin compared to conventional doxorubicin in first-line
treatment of MBC were included. Two reviewers independently selected trials, assessed
quality, and extracted data, and a third reviewer resolved discrepancies. The fixed
effects meta-analysis was performed in STATA 9.0 using a standard meta-analysis
approach. RESULTS: Two studies assessing pegylated liposomal doxorubicin with
conventional doxorubicin for first-line treatment of MBC met the study criteria.
Overall survival (HR = 0.869 [95% CI; 0.720, 1.049]) and overall response rate (RR
= 0.908 [95% CI; 0.725, 1.139]) were comparable between the two arms. Treatment
with pegylated liposomal doxorubicin resulted in significant reduction in cardiotoxicity as compared to conventional doxorubicin (RR = 0.312 [95% CI; 0.198, 0.490]).
The results of random effect analysis were similar (data not shown). CONCLUSIONS:
Pegylated liposomal doxorubicin provides comparable antitumor activity in terms of
efficacy and is better tolerated as compared to conventional doxorubicin in the treatment of MBC. Thus, the liposomal drug delivery system can play a significant role in
the use of doxorubicin in MBC treatment which is otherwise limited by its cardiotoxicity and supports its use in first-line treatment of MBC.
A252
PCN7
ASSESSING INTERFERON-ALPHA MONOTHERAPY IN PATIENTS WITH
ADVANCE OR METASTATIC RENAL CELL CARCINOMA
Rai MK1, Nair SR1, McEwan P2
1
CRC, Capita India Pvt. Ltd, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India; 2CRC, Cardiff, UK
OBJECTIVES: The objective was to evaluate the clinical efficacy and safety of interferon-α 2a (IFN) in the treatment of advanced/metastatic renal cell carcinoma in
treatment-naïve patients. METHODS: Studies were retrieved from Embase, Pubmed,
Cochrane, and DARE databases using relevant search strategies. Randomized controlled trials, which compared IFN with other pharmacological interventions/best
supportive care (BSC), were included according to prespecified inclusion/exclusion
criteria. The outcomes of interest were overall survival (OS), progression free survival
(PFS), response rate (RR), and adverse events (AEs). Two reviewers independently
extracted data from the included studies. Data were analyzed using RevMan (5).
RESULTS: Of the 736 studies identified, seven studies met the inclusion criteria. In
total, 1147 patients were randomized to IFN, and 1150 were randomized to comparator interventions. Two studies reported comparison with interleukin-2 (IL-2), two with
BSC and one each with sorafenib, sunitinib, and temsirolimus. Median OS ranged
from 9 to 21.8 months with IFN. Progression-free survival ranged from 1.9 to 5.6
months and overall RR ranged from 4.83% to 12.27% with IFN. Sunitinib had significantly better overall RR (P < 0.001), PFS (P < 0.001), and OS (P < 0.01) compared
to IFN. Sorafenib and temsirolimus had better overall RR than IFN (P < 0.01). Results
of meta- analysis demonstrate that IFN has better overall RR than BSC (OR: 2.51
[95% CI: 0.87, 7.27], P = 0.089) and similar RR as IL-2 (OR: 1.09 [95% CI: 0.48,
2.45], P = 0.836). The AE profile (gastrointestinal, vascular, infectious, and blood
disorders) was similar with IFN and comparators. CONCLUSIONS: Survival benefit
with IFN-α was lower than the newer therapeutic agents. Anti-angiogenic agents
targeting through multiple receptor kinases, such as sunitinib and sorafenib have
significantly improved response rates and survival. These agents would be preferred
for treatment naïve patients with advanced/metastatic renal cancer.
PCN8
CLINICAL AND ECONOMIC BURDEN OF TOXICITIES ASSOCIATED
WITH MONOCLONAL ANTIBODIES FOR METASTATIC COLORECTAL
CANCER (MCRC)
Burudpakdee C1, Zhao Z2, Trochlil K1, Gao SK3, Munakata J4, Barber B3
1
IMS Consulting, Falls Church, VA, USA; 2Amgen, Newbury Park, CA, USA; 3Amgen Inc.,
Thousand Oaks, CA, USA; 4IMS Health, Redwood City, CA, USA
OBJECTIVES: As overall survival improves with newer therapies for mCRC, treatmentlimiting toxicities and related costs will be important when evaluating treatment decisions. Little is known about toxicity-related cost of currently available monoclonal
antibody treatments. This study was designed to identify cetuximab-, bevacizumab-, and
panitumumab-related toxicities and estimate direct costs of treating these toxicities.
METHODS: A comprehensive literature search was performed to identify English
language phase II/III studies of monoclonal antibodies for mCRC. The search utilized
PubMed, conference abstracts, treatment guidelines, and product labels. Commonly
reported grade 3 and 4 toxicities were identified, and outpatient and inpatient costs
were estimated for all toxicities. Outpatient costs were estimated by applying 2010
Medicare reimbursement rates to resource use assumptions (assessed based on indepth clinical interviews). Inpatient costs were estimated using ICD-9 codes and 2007
Medicare payments from the HCUP database; then were converted to 2010 values
using the Consumer Price Index for medical care services. RESULTS: Clinically significant toxicities associated with bevacizumab include hypertension, arterial thrombosis, hemorrhage, gastrointestinal (GI) perforation, fistula, and wound healing
complication; while treatment-related toxicities associated with cetuximab and panitumumab include skin rash, hypomagnesemia, and infusion reactions, although the
incidence of these toxicities differ between the two drugs. Cost of toxicities treated in
outpatient setting ranged from $185 (hypertension and skin rash) to $585 (woundhealing complications). Inpatient cost per event for GI perforation is the highest at
$32,443, followed by fistula $29,062, arterial thrombosis $20,346, wound healing
complication $13,240, hemorrhage $12,956, infusion reaction $10,326, and hypertension $8453, while inpatient cost per event for skin rash and hypomagnesemia is among
the lowest at $4424 and $6174, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Monoclonal antibodies have different toxicity profiles and the costs associated with managing these toxicities vary greatly.
PCN9
OBSERVATIONAL STUDY OF PATIENTS WITH NON SMALL CELL
LUNG CANCER (NSCLC) TREATED BY ERLOTINIB: CLINICAL
PRACTICES AND MAIN OUTCOMES IN FRANCE
Vergnenegre A1, Monnet I2, Chouaid C3, Hureaux J4, Mazières J5, Quéré G6,
Lombard JN7, Cumin I8, Abdiche S9, Nocent Ejnaini C10, Decroisette C11
1
Hôpital du Cluzeau, Limoges, France; 2CHI Créteil, Créteil, France; 3Hôpital St Antoine,
Paris, France; 4CHU Angers, Angers, France; 5CHU Toulouse, Toulouse, France; 6CHU
Morvan, Brest, France; 7Cabinet de Pneumologie, Dijon, France; 8CH Bretagne Sud Site
Lorient, Lorient, France; 9Hôpital Robert Boulin, Libourne, France; 10CHI Côte Basque,
Bayonne, France; 11Centre Hospitalier de la Région d’Annecy, Pringy, France
OBJECTIVES: Few data are available about the use of erlotinib in real-life in France
for patients with non small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) in a selected population.
METHODS: An epidemiological multicenter observational study was built in 35
french centers. The study was retrospective (2006 to 2008) and a cohort was created
13th Euro Abstracts
with a follow-up period of 1 year. The main objective was to describe practices, use
of erlotinib, response, and adverse events. RESULTS: A total of 533 patients (333
males, 200 females) have been included. The histological types were as follows: 330
(62.5%) adenocarcinoma, 107 (20.2%) squamous cell carcinoma, 60 (11.3%) large
cell carcinoma, 36 (3.8%) undifferentiated carcinoma. In terms of practice, 502
patients had a first line chemotherapy (81% a doublet, 11% three drugs, 8.2% one
drug). Among them, 61.2% received a second line of treatment (83.4% one drug,
15.7% two drugs and 0.9% three drugs), 17.6% received a third line (91% one drug).
Erlotinib was prescribed a first line treatment (n = 30; 5.6%), second line treatment
(n = 190; 35.6%), third line (255; 47.8%), fourth line, and more (n = 50; 9.3%) and
as a maintenance therapy (n = 9; 1.7%); the stage at treatment initiation were stage
I–II (1.2%), IIIA (3.8%), IIIB (5.3%), and IV (89.7%). For the first line, the median
duration of erlotinib treatment was 123 days (d) in second line 98 d, in third line
77 d, in maintenance 127 d. Global response rate was 20% with a maximum of 32%
in first line and 33% in maintenance. Grade III adverse events occurred in 11.5% of
patients and grade IV in 3.4%. CONCLUSIONS: Erlotinib was widely used in France
in 2d and 3d line treatment with a good response rate and tolerance. Adenocarcinoma
is the main indication.
PCN10
EXPLORATIVE ANALYSIS ABOUT THE POTENTIAL OF A LARGE GPS
LONGITUDINAL DATABASE ON SEARCHING CAUSAL ASSOCIATIONS
AMONG PATHOLOGIES
Katz PM, Heiman F
BKL Consulting SRL, Milan, Italy
OBJECTIVES: The main objective of this study was to analyze different approaches
and methods to explore potential causal associations among prevalent pathologies.
We have focused on diabetes mellitus (DM) and its well-known association with
incident neoplasia. METHODS: For this retrospective cohort study, data were
obtained from CSD LPD, a General Practitioner’s longitudinal database. We have
evaluated the risk of neoplasia incidence among people with diabetes mellitus compared with those without this pathology, in patients who had no reported history of
benign or malign neoplasia at the start of the follow-up on January 2006. For the DM
group, patients with at least one diagnosis of DM from January 2005 to December
2005 have been selected, while for the DM-free group, patients without a diagnosis
of DM and a date of registration in the GPs office before January 2006 have been
selected. Both groups have been followed up for 48 months. RESULTS: During the
selection period, 45.121 (3.4%) patients with a diagnosis of DM (females: 22.330,
males: 22.791) and 1.290.597 (96, 6%) patients without a diagnosis of DM (females:
690.462, males: 600.135) have been selected. During the follow-up 6.648 and 80.880
incident cases of neoplasms have been documented from the DM and DM free groups
respectively. The mean follow-up duration was 43 and 45 months for the DM and
the DM-free groups respectively. CONCLUSIONS: The selected cohort has shown to
match quite well with general population in terms of gender and age. The estimated
prevalence of diabetes also matches with the one of the general population. Statistical
analysis has shown an adjusted (for age and sex) hazard ratio of 1,88 (95% Cl
1,83–1,93) suggesting an association between DM and incident neoplasms, evidencing
that GPs longitudinal databases could be a valid instrument for evaluating causal
association among prevalent pathologies.
PCN11
GEFITINIB COMPARED WITH DOUBLET CHEMOTHERAPY FOR
FIRST-LINE TREATMENT OF NON-SMALL-CELL LUNG CANCER
(NSCLC): A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW AND ADJUSTED INDIRECT
COMPARISON
Edwards SJ1, Welton N2, Borrill J1
1
AstraZeneca UK Ltd, Luton, Bedfordshire, UK; 2University of Bristol, Bristol, UK
OBJECTIVES: Objective response rate (ORR) is an early indicator of successful treatment in patients with NSCLC. This research compared gefitinib with platinum-based
doublet chemotherapies for first-line treatment of advanced NSCLC in patients harboring activating epidermal growth factor receptor tyrosine kinase (EGFR-TK) mutations
(M+). METHODS: Systematic searching of CENTRAL, EMBASE, and MEDLINE for
randomized controlled trials (RCTs) comparing ≥2 doublet chemotherapies (carboplatin or cisplatin in combination with either docetaxel, gemcitabine, paclitaxel, pemetrexed, or vinorelbine) for the first-line treatment of advanced NSCLC was completed
in May 2009. a meta-analysis was performed on ORR using data from published
RCTs of gefitinib versus paclitaxel/carboplatin in EGFR-TK M+ patients. a mixed
treatment comparison (MTC) was carried out with doublet chemotherapies in
unselected advanced NSCLC patients using paclitaxel/carboplatin as a baseline. Treatment effect was calculated as an odds ratio (OR) with 95% credible interval (95%
CrI). a sensitivity analysis was conducted on the inclusion of the gefitinib trials within
the MTC. For this analysis, it was assumed that the efficacy of doublet chemotherapy
is consistently affected by EGFR-TK mutation status. RESULTS: Three RCTs were
identified for gefitinib, of which two were comparisons with paclitaxel/carboplatin.
Meta-analysis of these two trials gave an estimated ORR favoring gefitinib: OR 4.04,
95% confidence interval: 2.73–5.98. Twenty-nine trials were appropriate for inclusion
in the MTC, of which 25 reported ORR. The MTC found no significant difference in
ORR among other doublet chemotherapies versus paclitaxel/carboplatin, with the
exception of pemetrexed/cisplatin, in patients with predominantly non-squamous
tumor cell histology, which was associated with a significantly higher ORR (OR 1.64,
95% CrI: 1.15–2.27). In the sensitivity analysis, ORR was significantly higher with
13th Euro Abstracts
gefitinib versus all doublet chemotherapies (gefitinib vs. pemetrexed/cisplatin OR 3.05,
95% CrI: 1.58–5.51). CONCLUSIONS: This adjusted indirect comparison suggests
that gefitinib may have important ORR advantages over other first-line treatments in
EGFR-TK M+ patients.
PCN12
EFFICACY OF SECOND LINE TREATMENTS IN PATIENTS WITH
METASTATIC HORMONE REFRACTORY PROSTATE CANCER (MHRPC)
IS NOT DEMONSTRATED BY PUBLISHED EVIDENCE FROM NONRANDOMIZED TRIALS
Freemantle N1, Mason M2, Jasso Mosqueda JG3, Nixon F4, Budhia S4
1
University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK; 2Cardiff Medical School, Cardiff, UK;
3
Sanofi-Aventis, Massy, France; 4Heron Evidence Development Ltd, Luton, UK
OBJECTIVES: Standard first-line treatment for patients with mHRPC is Docetaxel(D)based chemotherapy. Published results from randomized clinical trials of second-line
treatments after D failed to provide definitive conclusions about clinical efficacy largely
due to paucity of data. This study sought to identify nonrandomized trials of secondline chemotherapy in mHRPC patients pretreated with D and present related survival
and clinical benefits. METHODS: Pubmed and Embase were used to perform a systematic literature review (SLR) (2000–2010). Both comparative and noncomparative
nonrandomized evidence were extracted from prospective and retrospective studies.
Targeted population was patients with mHRPC failing previous D-based regimens.
End points included overall-survival (OS), progression-free-survival (PFS), and PSAresponse rate. RESULTS: Among the 825 records screened, 30 studies met the inclusion criteria, two of which were comparative. Of these, 10 addressed rechallenge with
D and seven addressed mitoxantrone (MTX); the remaining 18 studies considered
various other regimens. Treatment was with either single-agent or combination regimens. Ninety-three percent of studies included <50 patients. PFS and PSA response
definitions varied between trials. For studies evaluating rechallenge with D, the median
OS and PFS varied from 41 to 76 weeks and from 15 to 39 weeks respectively. For
MTX, the median OS and PFS varied from 39 to 48 weeks and 13 to 16 weeks,
respectively. For other chemotherapy regimens, the median OS and PFS varied from
51 to 104 weeks and 9 to 17 weeks, respectively. PSA response rates varied from 24%
to 70% to D rechallenge, from 4% to 33% to MTX-based regimens and from 0% to
60% to other regimens. CONCLUSIONS: The SLR showed a lack of available nonrandomized evidence, and among the selected studies, evidence was not strong enough
due to small sample sizes, noncomparative nature and variable PFS and PSA response
definitions. This literature review demonstrates that it is difficult to infer the clinical
efficacy of mHRPC 2nd line chemotherapy.
PCN13
EFFECT OF ZOLEDRONIC ACID AND PAMIDRONATE ON SKELETALRELATED EVENTS AND MORTALITY IN WOMEN WITH BONE
METASTASES FROM BREAST CANCER IN A MANAGED CARE PLAN: A
RETROSPECTIVE DATABASE ANALYSIS
Henk HJ1, Kaura S2
1
i3 Innovus, Eden Prairie, MN, USA; 2Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation, Florham Park,
NJ, USA
OBJECTIVES: Patients with breast cancer (BC) and bone metastases are at risk for
skeletal-related events (SREs) that are associated with significant morbidity, mortality,
and reduced quality of life. The intravenous bisphosphonates (IVBPs) zoledronic acid
(ZOL) and pamidronate (PAM) are approved for treating patients with bone metastases from BC. We compared incidence of SREs and mortality in women with BC who
received ZOL or PAM, and assessed the long-term benefit of ZOL in a real-world
setting. METHODS: A claims-based analysis of commercial and Medicare Advantage
data from >45 US managed care plans was used to evaluate SRE rates and mortality
in patients treated with ZOL or PAM. Inclusion criteria were age >18 years, BC with
bone metastasis diagnosis between 01/01/01 and 12/31/06, continuous enrollment in
the health plan, no evidence of bone metastasis or IVBP for 6 months before an index
date of first receipt of ZOL or PAM. Patients were followed until disenrollment
(including mortality) or study completion (12/31/07). Persistency was defined as the
absence of a >45-day gap between treatments. SREs were defined as evidence of
pathologic fracture, spinal cord compression, and radiotherapy or surgery to bone.
RESULTS: Among 8757 patients (mean age, 58.1 ± 12.4 years) approximately 30%
received ZOL, 15% received PAM, and 55% received no IVBP. Longer persistency
with ZOL was associated with lower risk of fracture and of all SREs versus shorter
persistency (trend test, P = 0.0026 and P = 0.0216, respectively). ZOL-treated patients
had a moderately lower SRE incidence (36.2 vs. 40.0 per 100 person-years; P =
0.0707) and significantly fewer deaths (6.2 vs. 8.9 per 100 person-years; P = 0.0130)
versus PAM-treated patients. CONCLUSIONS: In a real-world assessment of women
with bone metastases from BC, ZOL reduced SRE incidence and significantly
improved survival versus PAM. Longer ZOL persistency was associated with lower
SRE risk, reinforcing the importance of regular monthly ZOL dosing.
A253
PCN14
CLINICAL CONSEQUENCES OF PRIMARY PROPHYLAXIS WITH
PEGFILGRASTIM VERSUS FILGRASTIM FOR THE PREVENTION OF
FEBRILE NEUTROPENIA IN NON-HODGKIN LYMPHOMA AND STAGE II
BREAST CANCER PATIENTS IN GERMANY
Ozer-Deniz S1, Taylor DC1, Hill G1, Skornicki M1, Danel A2, Kunz E3
1
i3 Innovus, Medford, MA, USA; 2Amgen Inc., Zug, Switzerland; 3Amgen (Europe) GmbH,
München, Germany
OBJECTIVES: To assess the clinical consequences of primary prophylaxis (PP) with
pegfilgrastim versus 6- or 11-day filgrastim (F6, F11) in the prevention of febrile
neutropenia (FN) in non-Hodgkin lymphoma (NHL) patients receiving CHOP-14
chemotherapy and in breast cancer (BC) patients receiving TAC chemotherapy in
Germany. METHODS: A lifetime Markov model was developed, consisting of two
phases: 1) on-chemotherapy phase (OCP), where model cycle length equals chemotherapy cycle length (CHOP-14:14 days, TAC: 21 days), and 2) post-chemotherapy
phase (PCP) with annual model cycles. PP is defined as prophylaxis initiated with the
first chemotherapy cycle. Cycle 1 FN risk with no prophylaxis (NP) was estimated to
be 21% for NHL CHOP-14 and 14% for BC TAC. All cycle relative risk of FN using
PP with pegfilgrastim versus no PP, F6, and F11 was 0.25, 0.87, and 0.61. FN case
fatality was estimated (NHL: 8.9%; BC: 3.6%). In PCP, all-cause mortality was
estimated from German life-tables; NHL and BC mortality from US data; patients
experiencing FN were assumed to have higher mortality due to reduced chemotherapy
dose intensity. All inputs were estimated from clinical trials and published literature.
The model estimates life-years, number of FNs, and number needed to treat (NNT)
to prevent an FN. RESULTS: NNT to prevent an FN were 1.3, 6.2, 2.2 in NHL; 2.3,
11.1, 4.0 in BC for Pegfilgrastim, F6, and F11 compare to NP. Overall, FN episodes
per patient were 0.15, 0.76, and 0.47 in NHL; 0.09, 0.43, and 0.27 in BC. Per-patient
life-months gained using PP with Pegfilgrastim were 3.4 and 1.8 versus F6 and F11,
respectively in NHL, and 2.2 and 1.2 in BC. CONCLUSIONS: Primary prophylaxis
with pegfilgrastim results in a lower NNT, fewer FN events, and more life-years than
with 6-day filgrastim or 11-day filgrastim in both NHL and BC.
PCN15
SYSTEMATIC REVIEW OF LAPATINIB PLUS LETROZOLE WITH OTHER
FIRST LINE TREATMENTS FOR HORMONE POSITIVE (HR+) HER2+
ADVANCED OR METASTATIC BREAST CANCER (MBC)
Riemsma R1, Forbes CA1, Amonkar M2, Lykopoulos K3, Diaz JR4, Kleijnen J1, Rea DW5
1
Kleijnen Systematic Reviews Ltd., York, North Yorkshire, UK; 2GlaxoSmithKline, Philadelphia,
PA, USA; 3GlaxoSmithKline, London, UK; 4GlaxoSmithKline, Uxbridge, Middlesex, UK;
5
Institute for Cancer Studies, Birmingham, UK
OBJECTIVES: To undertake a systematic review of lapatinib plus letrozole (LAP +
LET) with other first-line treatments for HR+ HER2+ advanced or MBC in postmenopausal women who have not received prior therapy for advanced or metastatic disease.
METHODS: Seven databases were searched through January 2009 for randomized
controlled trials. Relevant interventions were lapatinib (alone/in combination), aromatase inhibitors (letrozole (LET), anastrozole (ANA), exemestane (EXE)), tamoxifen
(TAM), and trastuzumab (TRAS) (alone/in combination). Outcomes included overall
survival (OS), progression-free survival (PFS), time to progression (TTP), and objective
response rate (ORR). From the available evidence, it was possible to directly compare
LAP + LET with LET. Using a network meta-analysis, LAP + LET could be indirectly
compared with the four other interventions. RESULTS: Eighteen studies (62 papers)
met the inclusion criteria. LAP + LET was significantly superior to LET based on a
direct head-to-head study in terms of PFS/TTP and ORR. In the indirect comparison
with LAP + LET, TAM (hazard ratio [HR] = 0.45 [95% CI: 0.32, 0.65]), EXE (HR
= 0.52 [0.34, 0.79]), and ANA (HR = 0.53 [0.36, 0.80]) scored significantly worse in
terms of PFS/TTP and ORR (TAM: odds ratio [OR] = 0.25 [0.12, 0.53], ANA: OR
= 0.27 [0.12, 0.58], EXE: OR = 0.47 [0.20, 1.09]). LAP + LET also seemed better,
although not significantly, in terms of OS versus TAM: HR = 0.74 (0.49, 1.12), EXE:
HR = 0.65 (0.39, 1.11), and ANA: HR = 0.71 (0.45, 1.14). LAP + LET when indirectly
compared with TRAS + ANA, seemed to be better in terms of OS (HR = 0.85 [0.47,
1.54]), PFS/TTP (HR = 0.89 [0.54, 1.47]) and ORR (OR = 0.92 [0.24, 3.48]),
although, none of these results were significant. CONCLUSIONS: Using indirect
methods, LAP + LET appeared to be the best treatment in this HR+ HER2+ patient
population. However, the results are based on a network analysis for which the basic
assumptions of homogeneity, similarity, and consistency were not fulfilled. Therefore,
despite the fact that these are the best available data, the results need to be interpreted
with caution.
PCN16
MIXED TREATMENT COMPARISON OF BEVACIZUMAB-BASED
THERAPIES RELATIVE TO DOUBLET-CHEMOTHERAPY COMBINATIONS
TO ESTIMATE THE RELATIVE EFFICACY IN PROGRESSION-FREE
SURVIVAL FOR TREATMENT OF FIRST-LINE ADVANCED OR
METASTATIC NON-SMALL CELL LUNG CANCER (NSCLC)
Yi Y1, Chouaid C2, Vergnenegre A3, Bischoff HG4, Bergman G5, Walzer S6, Philips Z1
1
Mapi Values, Bollington, UK; 2Hôpital Saint-Antoine, Paris, France; 3SIME, Limoges, France,
4
Thoraxklinik Heidelberg GmbH, Hedelberg, Germany; 5Mapi Values, Houten, The
Netherlands; 6F. Hoffmann-La Roche Pharmaceuticals AG, Basel, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: To compare the efficacy in progression-free survival (PFS) of bevacizumab plus cisplatin and gemcitabine (BCG) and bevacizumab plus carboplatin and
paclitaxel (BCP), relative to doublet-chemotherapy combinations for the treatment of
A254
first-line advanced or metastatic NSCLC. METHODS: A systematic literature review
identified randomized controlled trials (RCTs) reporting PFS for bevacizumab-based
and doublet-chemotherapy combinations. Studies were evaluated for comparability of
design and patient population. Reported PFS hazard ratios (HR) were analyzed simultaneously with a Bayesian mixed treatment comparison. The base-case analysis compared BCG and BCP with grouped platinum-based doublets (PLD) and grouped
nonplatinum-based doublets (NPLD). Scenario analyses explored BCP and BCG
versus different combinations of doublet treatments. RESULTS: Eight identified RCTs,
considered comparable in design and patient characteristics, allowed for a comparison
between bevacizumab-based therapies and grouped doublet-chemotherapy combinations. The expected PFS HRs relative to PLD, for BCP, BCG, and NPLD were 0.66
(95% interval: 0.57; 0.77), 0.80 (0.71; 0.89), and 1.05 (0.92; 1.19), respectively. BCP
and BCG were ranked as the top two most efficacious treatments in terms of PFS
across all included regimens. Scenario analyses confirmed the top ranking for BCP and
BCG. When BCP and BCG were compared to individual doublet chemotherapies, BCP
showed the greatest benefit (HR of 0.63 [0.45; 0.88]), followed by BCG 7.5 mg/kg
(0.75 [0.64; 0.87]) and BCG 15 mg/kg (0.85 [0.73; 0.99]). Further analyses confirmed
the robustness of the findings. CONCLUSIONS: Compared to all available doubletchemotherapy combinations, bevacizumab-based therapy is expected to be more efficacious in terms of PFS, and could therefore be considered as the first treatment option
in advanced or metastatic NSCLC.
PCN17
NO CONCLUSIVE EVIDENCE FROM RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED
TRIALS (RCTS) FOR IMPROVED SURVIVAL WITH SECOND-LINE
TREATMENT OPTIONS, IN PATIENTS WITH METASTATIC HORMONEREFRACTORY PROSTATE CANCER (MHRPC) PREVIOUSLY TREATED
WITH DOCETAXEL
Mason M1, Freemantle N2, Parnaby A3, Högberg D4
1
Cardiff Medical School, Cardiff, UK; 2University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK;
3
Sanofi-Aventis, Vitry-sur-Seine, France; 4i3 Innovus, Stockholm, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: A docetaxel (D)-based regimen is recommended first-line treatment for
mHRPC patients. Currently, there are no recommended second-line treatments for D
pretreated patients. This study sought to identify phase II and III RCTs of second-line
treatments for mHRPC in D pretreated patients to provide information regarding
survival. METHODS: PubMed and Embase were used to perform a systematic literature review (2000–2009). Primary and secondary efficacy end points were extracted.
Safety outcomes were reviewed according to grade. RESULTS: Among 52 records
screened, three trials were included and 47 were excluded (35 not clinical trials; four
not second line to D; eight not comparative or randomized). Primary end points
included overall survival (OS), progression-free-survival (PFS), PSA response rate, and
objective tumor response (OTR). a phase III study comparing satraplatin plus prednisone (SP) to prednisone (P) alone (n = 950, 51% post-D) was identified. Two phase
II trials compared ixabepilone (ixa) with mitoxantrone plus prednisone (MP) (n = 82),
and custirsen in combination with prednisone plus D (DPC) versus curtisen plus MP
(MPC) (n = 42). SP demonstrated significant improvements compared to P in PSA
response (25% vs. 12%, P < 0.001), OTR (7% vs. 1%, P < 0.002), and pain response
(24% vs. 14%, P < 0.005). Median PFS (11 weeks vs. 9.7 weeks), but median OS
(66.1 weeks vs. 62.9 weeks) were similar. In the second trial (Ixa vs. MP), there was
no significant improvement in either PSA response (17% vs. 20%) or OS. In the third
trial, PSA response was better for DPC than MPC (40% vs. 27%); no OS data
reported. Grade 3 or 4 neutropenia occurred in 54% and 63% with Ixa and MP
respectively. CONCLUSIONS: This review found a limited number of published phase
II and III RCTs second-line treatments for mHRPC in D pretreated patients. None
demonstrated a survival benefit. Results should be interpreted with caution in terms
of clinical benefits.
PCN18
RETROSPECTIVE DATABASE ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECT OF
ZOLEDRONIC ACID ON SKELETAL-RELATED EVENTS IN MEN WITH
PROSTATE CANCER AND BONE METASTASES
Henk HJ1, Kaura S2
1
i3 Innovus, Eden Prairie, MN, USA; 2Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation, Florham Park,
NJ, USA
OBJECTIVES: Patients with bone metastases from prostate cancer (PC) are at risk for
skeletal-related events (SREs) including pathologic fracture, spinal cord compression,
the need for radiotherapy or surgery to bone, and hypercalcemia of malignancy.
Zoledronic acid (ZOL), an intravenous bisphosphonate (IVBP), has proven efficacy
for reducing the incidence and delaying the onset of SREs in multiple tumor types.
This retrospective study was designed to assess the fracture risk in patients receiving
ZOL or no treatment, and to examine the benefit of long-term ZOL use in a real-world
setting among men with PC and bone metastases. METHODS: Commercial and
Medicare Advantage databases were used to evaluate fracture rates and medication
persistency. Patients included in this analysis were ≥18 years old, had PC and bone
metastasis diagnosed between January 1, 2001 and December 31, 2006, were continuously enrolled in the health plan, and had no evidence of bone metastasis or IVBP for
6 months before first infusion of ZOL. Patients were followed until discontinuation
(including mortality) or study completion. Fractures were categorized as vertebral,
hip, or other nonvertebral fractures. Persistency was defined as the absence of a
>45-day gap between ZOL treatments. RESULTS: Among 4976 men (mean age, 70.9
± 9.7 years), approximately 26% received ZOL and 74% received no IVBP. Regardless
13th Euro Abstracts
of fracture site, ZOL reduced the fracture rate compared with no IVBP (5.9 vs. 8.5
per 100 person-years; P = 0.0003). Longer persistency with ZOL was associated with
a reduced fracture rate (trend test, P = 0.0179). The mortality rate was also significantly lower in ZOL patients versus patients receiving no IVBP (6.2 vs. 9.4 per 100
person-years; P = 0.0018). CONCLUSIONS: In men with bone metastases from PC,
ZOL was associated with a significantly lower fracture rate and mortality compared
with no IVBP. Furthermore, longer persistency with ZOL was associated with a lower
fracture rate.
PCN19
SYSTEMATIC REVIEW OF ENDOSCOPIC SUBMUCOSAL DISSECTION
VERSUS ENDOSCOPIC MUCOSAL RESECTION FOR EARLY GASTRIC
CANCER
Park YM1, Cho E2, Kang HY2, Kim JM1, Kim SY3
1
Health Insurance Review & Assessment Agency, Seoul, South Korea; 2Yonsei University,
Seoul, South Korea; 3Korea University, Seoul, South Korea
OBJECTIVES: Endoscopic submucosal dissection (ESD) allows en bloc resection of
the entire lesion which permits higher curative resection rate, lower local recurrence,
and consequently, increases quality of life by minimizing the resection size compared
to endoscopic mucosal resection (EMR). While ESD has been implemented in most
university hospitals in Korea currently, potential complications of ESD like hemorrhage and perforation waver over the therapeutic decision on the ESD for early gastric
cancer patients as well as the reimbursement decision-making. The study aims to
address both effectiveness and safety outcomes of ESD versus EMR in early gastric
cancer by systematic review. METHODS: MEDLINE, EMBASE, Cochrane Central
Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL), and Koreamed were searched using
primary key words: “stomach neoplasm” and “endoscopic submucosal dissection”
and “endoscopic mucosal resection.” To assess the quality of selected studies, the
methodological approach of Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network were used.
Five effectiveness-relevant and three safety-relevant outcome measures were extracted.
Bibliography management and meta-analysis for each outcome were conducted using
Review Manager 5.0. RESULTS: Three nonconcurrent cohort studies and nine retrospective cohort studies were identified. Meta-analyses showed significantly greater
effectiveness of ESD as compared to EMR for en bloc resection (OR = 8.43, 95% CI:
5.20–13.67), complete resection (OR = 8.54, 95% CI: 4.44–16.45), curative resection
(OR = 2.56, 95% CI: 1.68–3.91), local recurrence (RR = 0.13, 95% CI: 0.04–0.40),
and all-cause mortality (RR = 0.65, 95% CI: 0.08–5.38). While intraoperative bleeding (RR = 2.16, 95% CI: 1.14–4.09) and perforation risk (RR = 3.58, 95% CI:
1.95–6.55) were significantly greater for ESD, overall bleeding risk (RR = 1.22, 95%
CI: 0.76–1.98) and longer resection time (RR = 1.55, 95% CI: 0.74–2.37) were not
significantly different between ESD and EMR. CONCLUSIONS: Considering bleeding
risk was not significantly different between ESD and EMR, and the perforation risk
usually does not lead to life-threatening disease, the effectiveness benefit of ESD can
overweigh the overall harm compared to EMR on condition that ESD was performed
by surgeons with certain experiences.
PCN20
MAINTENANCE ERLOTINIB VERSUS PEMETREXED FOR THE
TREATMENT OF NON-SMALL CELL LUNG CANCER: INDIRECT
COMPARISON APPLYING REAL-LIFE OUTCOMES
Casciano R1, Bischoff H2, Nuijten M3, Malangone E1, Ray J4
1
Analytica International Inc., New York, NY, USA; 2Thoraxklinik Heidelberg GmbH,
Heidelberg, Germany; 3Ars Accessus Medica, Rotterdam, The Netherlands; 4F. Hoffmann-La
Roche Ltd., Basel, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: Recent clinical trials have established superior efficacy of both erlotinib
and pemetrexed as first-line maintenance therapies for metastatic non-small cell lung
cancer (mNSCLC) over placebo. Results indicated that erlotinib improved survival for
all histology types and pemetrexed improved survival in nonsquamous patients. To
date, there have been no head-to-head trials directly comparing the two agents. An
indirect comparison analysis was performed to examine the relative efficacy of these
two treatment regimens as maintenance treatment options following platinum-based
first-line therapy. METHODS: An adjusted-matched indirect analysis approach was
used to compare overall survival (OS) estimates in mNSCLC patients treated with
erlotinib from SATURN versus pemetrexed patients from JMEN. Patient distributions
of key characteristics between the two studies were unbalanced; JMEN trial patients
had a better prognosis at baseline. Patient distributions observed in the pemetrexed
study for race and smoking status were used to match erlotinib-treated patients using
patient-level data from the SATURN trial, employing an adjusted matching approach
to make the populations more comparable. a distribution of survival outcomes was
derived from each of 1000 repeated random matching samples of the SATURN data,
with 95% confidence intervals (CI) around the mean of the aggregate of all observed
median OS survival estimates generated by ordering the outcome measures and identifying the 2.5 percentile observations. To indirectly compare treatments, the median
ratio (MR) for OS was calculated to approximate the hazard ratio. RESULTS: The
estimated median OS after adjusted-matching was 13.9 months (95% CI 10.9–16.8)
for erlotinib, compared with the published median OS reported for pemetrexed of
13.4 months (95% CI: 11.9–15.9). Erlotinib patients had similar median OS compared
to pemetrexed patients with an MR of 0.96 (0.95, 1.09). CONCLUSIONS: Erlotinib
and pemetrexed are similarly efficacious in first-line maintenance NSCLC differing in
other parameters than efficacy such as tolerability, administration, and patient
convenience.
13th Euro Abstracts
PCN21
FIRST-LINE BEVACIZUMAB-BASED THERAPY VERSUS PEMETREXED +
CISPLATIN FOR THE TREATMENT OF ADVANCED ADENOCARCINOMA
NONSQUAMOUS NON-SMALL CELL LUNG CANCER: INDIRECT
COMPARISON APPLYING REAL-LIFE OUTCOMES
Berenson K1, Chouaid C2, Vergnenegre A3, Sherman S1, Walzer S4
1
Analytica International Inc., New York, NY, USA; 2Hôpital St Antoine, Paris, France; 3SIME,
Limoges, France; 4F. Hoffmann-La Roche Pharmaceuticals, Basel, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: In the absence of head-to-head clinical trial data, an indirect comparison of bevacizumab (BEV) versus pemetrexed (PMX) was conducted to compare
survival outcomes among adenocarcinoma nonsquamous metastatic Non-Small Cell
Lung Cancer (mNSCLC) patients. METHODS: An adjusted matched indirect analysis
was conducted to estimate overall survival (OS) in adenocarcinoma mNSCLC patients
treated with BEV + cisplatin doublet therapy using patient-level data from SAiL
(ECCO/ESMO 2009). These estimates were indirectly compared to previously published survival outcomes for PMX + cisplatin-treated patients (Oncologist
2009;14:253–263) by calculating the median ratio (MR) for OS. a subset of the SAiL
population was selected to more closely approximate the PMX population by excluding patients who did not have cisplatin doublet as their baseline treatment, those with
a baseline Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group (ECOG) performance status (PS) of
> = 2, and those with non-adenocarcinoma histology. This sample of BEV patients
was matched to the adenocarcinoma subgroup from the PMX trial on stage of disease
and ECOG PS. One thousand repeated random matched samples of the SAiL data
were produced to generate a distribution of survival outcomes and infer a 95% confidence interval (CI) around the mean of all sampled median survival estimates.
RESULTS: After adjusted matching, the estimated median OS benefit for BEV patients
was 15.6 months (95% CI: 15.0, 16.5) compared to the published median OS of 12.6
months (95% CI: 10.7, 13.6) for PMX patients. BEV patients had longer median OS
with an MR of 0.81 (95% CI: 0.71, 0.82). CONCLUSIONS: Results from this indirect
comparison show that BEV-based therapy provides superior overall survival outcomes
when compared to PMX in adenocarcinoma mNSCLC patients.
PCN22
EFFICACY AND CARDIAC SAFETY OF TRASTUZUMAB (T) IN THE
ADJUVANT TREATMENT OF HER2-POSITIVE EARLY-STAGE BREAST
CANCER: A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW (SR) AND META-ANALYSIS (MA)
Botrel TEA, Clark O, Clark LGO, Paladini L, Faleiros E, Pegoretti B
MedInsight-Evidências, Campinas, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: Trastuzumab (T) is now part of the standard adjuvant treatment for
HER2 positive, breast cancer patients. However, the results of the studies are not
uniform and there are still doubts about the ideal indication and schedule for its use.
Our objective was to perform a systematic review (SR) and meta-analysis (MA) of all
randomized controlled trials (RCT) comparing efficacy of Chemotherapy (CHEM)
plus T versus CHEM plus observation in the adjuvant treatment of HER2-positive
early-stage breast cancer. METHODS: Several databases were searched, including
MEDLINE, EMBASE, LILACS, and CENTRAL. The primary end points were progression-free survival (PFS) and overall survival (OS). a subgroup analysis was performed to evaluate the influence of the use of T concurrent or sequential to CHEM.
RESULTS: Overall, 730 references were identified and screened. The final analysis
included six trials comprising 13,940 patients. The PFS was higher in the group of
patients treated with CHEM plus T (fixed effect: HR = 0.61, CI 95% = 0.56 to 0.66;
P < 0.00001) with significant heterogeneity (χ2 = 13,33 df = 5 (P = 0.02); I2 = 62%).
This result remained favorable to the use of T after the random-effects model analysis
was performed (HR = 0.63, CI 95% = 0.54 to 0.73; P < 0.00001). OS was better for
patients who received T (fixed effect: HR = 0.71, CI 95% = 0.62 to 0.81; P < 0.00001
and random-effects: HR = 0.71, CI 95% = 0.60 to 0.84; P < 0.0001) with moderatelevel heterogeneity (χ2 = 7,12 df = 5 (P = 0.21); I2 = 30%). There was a significant
interaction between the concurrent and sequential use of T and CHEM, suggesting
that the concurrent use may be more effective. CONCLUSIONS: Trastuzumab
increased progression-free survival and overall survival of patients especially when
administered concomitantly to chemotherapy.
PCN23
SIMULATION AND COMPARISON OF PROGRESSION-FREE-SURVIVAL
OUTCOMES OF SEQUENTIAL TARGETED THERAPY IN METASTATIC
RENAL-CELL CARCINOMA
Mickisch GH1, Schwander B2, Cassinello JG3, Carles J4, Walzer S5, Nuijten M6
1
Center of Operative Urology Bremen, Bremen, Germany; 2AiM GmbH—Assessment in
Medicine, Research and Consulting, Lörrach, Germany; 3University Hospital Guadalajara,
Guadalajara, Spain; 4Vall d’Hebron University Hospital, Barcelona, Spain; 5F. Hoffmann-La
Roche Pharmaceuticals AG, Basel, Switzerland; 6Ars Accessus Medica, Jisp, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: The novel targeted agents bevacizumab (BEV), sorafenib (SOR), sunitinib (SUN), everolimus (EVR), and pazopanib (PAZ) have each demonstrated activity
in metastatic renal-cell carcinoma patients. One of the remaining key questions is
which therapy sequence provides the most valuable outcome in terms of progressionfree-survival (PFS). METHODS: A Markov disease model was developed using pivotal
trial evidence. All patients were assumed to be treatment-naïve, with a good or intermediate prognosis, and to enter the model in “PFS,” receiving first-line treatment with
either BEV + interferon-alpha-2a (IFN), SUN, PAZ, or IFN alone, taking into account
current EMA licenses (e.g., BEV + IFN indicated only for first-line therapy). After
initial treatment, patients were assumed to either die, progress to a subsequent line of
A255
therapy, or remain in PFS. Hence, in case of p. RESULTS: The most valuable therapy
sequence in terms of total PFS was BEV + IFN → PAZ → SUN → SOR → EVR
resulting in a mean PFS time of 33.2 months (95% confidence interval [CI]: 31.3–
35.2). The sequence BEV + IFN → PAZ → SOR → SUN → EVR obtained comparable
results (mean PFS 33.2; 95% CI: 31.3–35.1). The first-line PAZ sequences PAZ →
SUN → SOR → EVR (mean PFS 28.6; 95% CI 26.6–31.2) and PAZ → SOR → SUN
→ EVR (mean PFS 28.6; 95%CI 26.6–31.2) were the second-best alternatives, followed by the most valuable IFN first-line sequence (IFN → PAZ → SUN → SOR →
EVR; mean PFS 28.5; 95% CI 26.8–30.4) and the most valuable SUN first-line
sequence (SUN → PAZ → SOR → EVR; mean PFS 26.7; 95% CI 24.4–29.1). The
incremental PFS difference between the best therapy sequences (first-line BEV + IFN;
mean PFS 33.2 months) and the second-best therapy sequences (PAZ first-line; mean
PFS 28.6 months) of 4.6 months reached statistical significance (P < 0.004 for each
possible comparison). Additional overall survival simulations have confirmed these
findings. CONCLUSIONS: Modeling simulation indicates that patients’ PFS outcomes
could be improved significantly, if therapy started with first-line BEV + IFN compared
to other first-line agents (PAZ, SUN, or IFN alone).
PCN24
EFFICACY OF ADJUVANT CHEMOTHERAPY WITH GEMCITABINE
(GEM) COMPARED TO SURGERY-ONLY IN PATIENTS WITH RESECTED
PANCREATIC CANCER: SYSTEMATIC REVIEW (SR) AND METAANALYSIS (MA)
Botrel TEA, Clark O, Clark LGO, Paladini L, Faleiros E, Pegoretti B
MedInsight-Evidências, Campinas, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: We aimed to perform a systematic review (SR) with meta-analysis
(MA) of all randomized controlled trials (RCT) comparing the efficacy of adjuvant
chemotherapy with gemcitabine (GEM) versus observation in patients with resected
pancreatic cancer. METHODS: Several databases were searched, including MEDLINE,
EMBASE, LILACS, and CENTRAL. The primary end points were progression-free
survival (PFS) and overall survival (OS). The data extracted from the studies were
combined by using hazard ratio (HR) with their corresponding confidence intervals
of 95% (CI 95%). RESULTS: Overall, 233 references were identified and screened.
The final analysis included two trials comprising 472 patients evaluated. The proportion of patients that underwent surgery with curative intent (R0 or R1 resection) was
similar between the studies as well as their ages and nodal status. The progression-free
survival was higher in the group of patients who were treated with adjuvant chemotherapy including GEM (fixed effect: HR = 0.59, CI 95% = 0.50 to 0.70; P < 0.00001)
and no heterogeneity was found (χ2 = 0.01, df = 1 (P = 0.94); I2 = 0%). Overall survival
was also higher in patients treated with GEM (fixed effect: HR = 0.81, CI 95% = 0.67
to 0.98; P = 0.03) yet again no heterogeneity was detected (χ2 = 0.07, df = 1 [P =
0.79]; I2 = 0%). CONCLUSIONS: Adjuvant chemotherapy with gemcitabine increased
progression-free survival and overall survival of patients with resected pancreatic
cancer.
PCN25
DID THE UPTAKE OF NEW TREATMENT OPTIONS CHANGE THE
TREATMENT STRATEGY IN PATIENTS WITH COLORECTAL CANCER
AND PRIMARY NONRESECTABLE METASTASES? THE RESULTS OF
LARGE POPULATION-BASED SURVEY IN GERMANY 2006–2007
Kellermann L1, Arnold D2
1
Oncology InformationService, Freiburg, Germany; 2Hematology & Oncology, Martin Luther
University Halle-Wittenberg, Halle/Saale, Germany
OBJECTIVES: The survey was initiated to gain insights into the changes of treatment
patterns in treatment of metastatic colorectal cancer and the implementation of the
results of clinical trials in daily practice. METHODS: A representative sample of
centers (82) was selected with regard to the distribution of treated prevalence in
colorectal cancer in institutions (university hospitals, community hospitals, officebased oncologists) and regional population density. The physicians reported all pts.
with a treatment decision in colorectal cancer in the respective reporting period May
2006 to April 2007. The database contains 3254 pts. with a retrospective record of
their entire treatment history. The treatment patterns were analyzed in the whole
patient group and in subgroups according to resectability of metastases, the treatment
objectives (especially secondary resectability of metastases), used systemic treatment
regimen, age, concomitant diseases, and performing institution type. The statistics
were performed in SPSS by bivariate analyses with two-sided chi-square test. In the
next step, the decisive parameters for treatment choice were defined by logistic regression in multivariate analysis. RESULTS: The clinical trial data were taken up very
soon in clinical reality. The correlation of drug efficacy and resectability of metastases
was transferred into the disease management of colorectal cancer. The patient share
with treatment objective “secondary resection of metastases” increased significantly
(18% 2004 vs. 27% 2006–2007, P = 0.000%). In this subgroup, the patient share
treated with targeted therapy was significantly higher than in patients with other
treatment objectives (34% vs. 19%, P = 0.000%). CONCLUSIONS: The method used
for creation of the database and for the statistic analyses has been proven as appropriate for the objectives of this survey. The resectability of metastases is recognized as
an important treatment objective. Therefore, targeted therapy was implemented more
frequently in treatment regiments for patients deemed secondary resectable, compared
to other treatment aims.
A256
PCN26
ESTIMATION OF THE EPIDEMIOLOGICAL EFFECT OF RITUXIMAB FOR
THE TREATMENT OF AGGRESSIVE NON-HODGKIN LYMPHOMA
Barreto WG1, Oliveira JSR1, Borges LG2, Santos E2
1
Hospital Santa Marcelina, São Paulo, SP, Brazil; 2Roche Brazil, São Paulo, SP, Brazil
BACKGROUND: Non-Hodgkin lymphoma (NHL) are a heterogeneous group of
malignancies of the lymphoid system and represents approximately 80% of all lymphomas. Mortality associated with NHL in Brazil has increased in the last few years,
from 2772 cases in 2000 to 3194 in 2004. Aggressive NHL accounts for approximately 60% of all cases and cure can be achieved in more than 70% of cases with
rates ranging 50% to 90% when under immunochemotherapy depending on the clinical stage and international prognostic index (IPI). Currently, only CHOP therapy is
available to patients presenting with aggressive NHL in Brazilian Public Healthcare
System. OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the epidemiological impact of adding rituximabe
(R) to CHOP first-line therapy (cyclophosphamide, doxorubicin, vincristine, and
prednisone) on the annual number of patients experiencing recurrence and deaths
between 2010 and 2020 in Brazil. METHODS: Annual aggressive NHL incidence for
2010 to 2020 was estimated by applying published age-specific NHL incidence to
Brazilian population projections for the mentioned period. Projections were made for
aggressive NHL and population above 20-year-olds only. Therapy effect for R-CHOP
and CHOP was derived from Gao (2009) and 2-year overall survival and disease
control data were adjusted for a 1-year rate. Considering the subgroups analysis,
annual overall survival rate were 54.5% and 45.7% and disease control rate were
43.7% and 31.1% for R-CHOP and CHOP, respectively. RESULTS: Between 2010
and 2020, it is estimated that 8886 more patients would be saved if R-CHOP was
given (54,917 vs. 46,031 for CHOP). Regarding disease progression, R-CHOP has
the potential to control the disease in 12,703 more patients than CHOP (44,048 vs.
31,345). CONCLUSIONS: Findings suggest that R-CHOP has the potential to save
about 16% more lives annually when compared to CHOP in the management of
aggressive NHL, particularly in Brazilian patients who have late diagnosis which
implies a worse prognosis.
PCN27
ESTIMATION OF THE EPIDEMIOLOGICAL EFFECT OF TRASTUZUMAB
OVER THE 200–2015 PERIOD IN PORTUGAL
Calado F1, Monteiro I1, McNiven PM2, Weisgerber-Kriegl UM3
1
Roche Farmacêutica Química, Amadora, Portugal; 2Strategyst Consulting, Austin, TX, USA;
3
F. Hoffmann-La Roche Ltd., Basel, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: Trastuzumab was approved for the treatment of HER2-positive early
breast cancer (EBC) in 2006 in several European countries, Portugal included. The
model assesses the impact of trastuzumab treatment in EBC on the annual number of
patients entering the metastatic setting between 2005 and 2015 in Portugal.
METHODS: Annual EBC incidence for 2005 to 2015 was projected by applying
stage-specific proportions for stages I–III to female breast cancer incidence rates estimated for 2008 (GLOBOCAN 2010), using a conjoint estimate based on English
cancer registries, where overall breast cancer survival is comparable to that seen in
Portugal. Age-specific rates were applied to UN population projections for 2000 to
2025. The annual number of patients with HER2-positive metastatic breast cancer
(MBC) includes de novo and recurrent MBC patients. The baseline 10-year recurrence
rate was estimated as 37%, based on 4-year follow-up in the control arm of a combined trial analysis in patients with HER2-positive breast cancer and the long-term
timing of recurrence in all patients with breast cancer. To model recurrence in trastuzumab-treated EBC patients, the hazard ratio (HR) from the HERA trial (0.49; 95%
CI: 0.38, 0.63) was applied. RESULTS: In 2004, prior to approval of trastuzumab in
EBC, the pool of de novo and relapsed MBC patients was estimated to be 650.
Between 2005 and 2015, the model predicts that the use of trastuzumab will result in
an average annual decline in recurrence of MBC of 5.2% (95% CI: 3.0, 6.7). Cumulative recurrence prevented by trastuzumab treatment between 2005 and 2014 (projected through full 10-year window for recurrence) is projected to be 884 (95% CI:
537; 1075). CONCLUSIONS: Trastuzumab treatment of HER2-positive EBC over a
10-year period is expected to prevent nearly 900 women from developing metastases
in Portugal, which may result in a similar number of breast cancer deaths being
avoided.
PCN28
UTILIZATION OF ANTIEMETIC PROPHYLAXIS ALONGSIDE
CHEMOTHERAPY IN FOUR EUROPEAN COUNTRIES
Cristeau O1, Toumi M2
1
Creativ Ceutical, Paris, France; 2University Claude Bernard Lyon 1, Lyon, France
OBJECTIVES: To investigate prescription patterns for setron antiemetics used alongside chemotherapy in France, Germany, Italy, and the UK. METHODS: Prescription
data from June 2008 to July 2009 were extracted from the Synovate Oncology
Monitor, an ongoing database tracking prescriptions of anticancer therapies and
concomitant medications. Patients receiving setron prophylaxis (dolasetron, granisetron, ondansetron, palonosetron, or tropisetron) with Moderately emetic chemotherapy (MEC) or highly emetic chemotherapy (HEC) were selected. RESULTS: The
sample included 1715, 1658, 1830, and 1651 patients with MEC regimens in France,
Germany, Italy, and UK, respectively, and 557, 761, 903, and 627 patients with HEC
regimens. Ondansetron was used in 85.1%, 45.8%, 52.1%, and 83.3% of patients
with MEC regimens in France, Germany, Italy, and UK respectively, and 92.5%,
46.0%, 43.8%, and 62.2% of patients with HEC regimens. The shares of different
setrons were relatively similar between MEC and HEC regimens in Gemany. a stronger
13th Euro Abstracts
association between setron and regimen category was found in other countries, with
different trends according to country. Doses of setrons were slightly higher for HEC
regimens than for MEC regimens in Italy, but substantially higher in other countries.
The average daily dose was found to increase with treatment duration in all countries.
Neurokinin 1 antagonists (NK1) were used alongside setron in up to 46% of patients
in Germany, depending on setron, but were very rarely used in Italy. CONCLUSIONS:
Utilization of setrons and concomitant medications (NK1, antipsychotics) varied
widely between European countries. It appears that German prescribers adapted the
dose of setron rather than the drug according to regimen category, contrary to Italian
prescribers. Such international comparisons may provide useful insight for improving
practice in different countries.
PCN29
EPIDEMIOLOGY AND HEALTH-CARE UTILIZATION FOR RESECTED
SQUAMOUS CELL CARCINOMA OF HEAD AND NECK (SCCHN) IN
SOUTH KOREA
Kim K1, Amonkar M2, Lykopoulos K3, Kasteng F1, Högberg D1
1
i3 Innovus, Stockholm, Sweden; 2GlaxoSmithKline, Philadelphia, PA, USA; 3GlaxoSmithKline,
London, UK
OBJECTIVES: In South Korea, 2617 new cases of head and neck cancer (HNC) were
diagnosed and 1473 deaths were reported in 2005. In Western countries, SCCHN
represents more than 90% of HNCs and surgery is the primary treatment modality
for SCCHN. Chemotherapy is often an important treatment component combined
with radiotherapy for patients diagnosed with locally advanced disease. This study
aimed to estimate the number of resected SCCHN patients and describe their treatment
and health-care utilization in South Korea. METHODS: The study included the following cancer sites: oral cavity, pharynx, and larynx. The main source of data for the
probabilities of having different types of SCCHN treatments was results from retrospective analyses found through literature review using MEDLINE, EMBASE,
Cochrane, and the Korean Medical Database. Cancer incidence was based on data
from the National Cancer Registry. In addition, expert opinion of a HNC surgeon in
South Korea complemented the literature review. RESULTS: We estimated that
SCCHN constituted 91% of HNC cases; 69% of the SCCHN cases were surgically
resected. The number of new cases of resected SCCHN in South Korea was 1642 (oral
cavity, 501; pharynx, 397; and larynx, 744). Fifity-two percent of resected SCCHN
patients had neck dissections (45% of them were radical neck dissections) and 6% of
resected SCCHN patients had total laryngectomy. Ten percent of patients had secondary surgery and 75% had reconstructive surgery. Sixty-four percent of patients
received radiotherapy, whereas 33% received chemotherapy combined with surgery
or as concomitant therapy with radiotherapy. CONCLUSIONS: In South Korea,
resected SCCHN is estimated to constitute 1% of all cancers. However, 29% of
patients with resected SCCHN had major surgeries (radical neck dissection or total
laryngectomy), causing a significant negative impact on the quality of life of patients
and contributing to a high economic burden to the patients and society.
PCN31
THE PREDICTIVE AND PROGNOSTIC ROLE OF ERCC1 IN ADVANCED
NON-SMALL CELL LUNG CANCER: A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW AND
META-ANALYSIS
Roth J, Carlson JJ
University of Washington, Pharmaceutical Outcomes Research and Policy Program, Seattle,
WA, USA
OBJECTIVES: ERCC1 mRNA expression has the potential to be a useful tool in the
clinical treatment of advanced NSCLC; however, considerable uncertainty remains as
to the biomarker’s magnitude of effect on tumor response and survival. The objective
of this study was to evaluate the association between ERCC1 mRNA expression level
and treatment outcomes in advanced NSCLC patients treated with platinum-based
chemotherapy using a systematic review and meta-analytic techniques. METHODS:
A systematic search of the literature was conducted using MEDLINE and EMBASE
databases from June 1995 to May 2010. Additionally, a search of ASCO Annual
Meeting abstracts was conducted. Eligible studies were evaluated for clinical, methodological, and statistical heterogeneity. Pooled RESULTS: The pooled analysis demonstrated a statistically significant higher probability of response (according to the
RECIST criteria) to platinum-based chemotherapy for patients with low ERCC1
mRNA expression levels relative to patients with high ERCC1 mRNA expression
levels (OR: 0.64, 95% CI 0.42–0.95). Low ERCC1 mRNA expression level was also
associated with significantly improved overall survival relative to high mRNA expression levels (HR: 0.44, 95% CI 0.31–0.62). CONCLUSIONS: In conclusion, ERCC1
mRNA expression level may provide useful clinical information in terms of the likelihood of platinum-based chemotherapy response and overall survival prognosis.
Ongoing analyses are focused on evaluating the predictive role of ERCC1 in overall
survival. The findings of this analysis also reveal a need for standardization in characterizing “high” and “low” ERCC1 mRNA expression, as the studies evaluated
herein varied considerably in their methods.
13th Euro Abstracts
CANCER – Cost Studies
PCN32
COMPARING FORECASTED WITH ACTUAL BUDGET IMPACT:
REIMBURSED CANCER DRUGS IN THE NETHERLANDS
Thuresson PO1, Heeg B1, Botteman M2
1
Pharmerit, Rotterdam, The Netherlands; 2Pharmerit North America, LLC, Bethesda, MD,
USA
OBJECTIVES: In the The Netherlands, a new drug is priced to the level of an existing
drug cluster, if these are considered similar. However, when a drug is not considered
similar to a cluster, a separate price can be requested. Before this separate price is
approved, sufficient cost-effectiveness and budget impact (BI) data have to be provided
to the Dutch Health Care Insurance Board (CVZ). The present analysis investigated
how close the submitted BI-forecasts were to the actual BIs for cancer treatments in
the The Netherlands. METHODS: The publicly available evaluations by the CVZ
were assessed for cancer agents. From these, forecasted number of users, drug costs,
treatment lengths, and the BIs were derived. The predicted BIs were compared with
actual BIs from the GIP database (Dutch Drug Information System). The predicted BI
was standardized with respect to time to ensure that actual and forecasted BIs shared
the same starting point. Broadening of the indication was taken into account and
substitution was considered. To further explain any difference in forecasted and actual
BI, various variables such as drug cost, number of users, market share (when applicable), and treatment lengths were investigated. RESULTS: The search provided five
relevant cases. The forecasted budgets were lower than the actual ones in four out of
the five cases. The forecasted and actual BI differed up to 250%. Data on drug substitution was insufficient and therefore not considered. The differences between predicted and observed BIs were explained primarily by an underestimation of the number
of patients eventually receiving the evaluated treatments. The published BI forecasts
contained no/very limited sensitivity analyses. CONCLUSIONS: Most BI forecasts
underestimated the actual BI for new cancer drugs. One explanation was that the
growth of the patient population was often underestimated. Improvements in predicting total market size and penetration should be considered, as well as more elaborate
sensitivity analysis.
PCN33
IMPACT BUDGETING IN CROATIA: FULVESTRANT EXAMPLE
1
1
2
2
3
4
Culig J , Leppee M , Reic I , Serdar S , Boskovic J , Colak N
1
Andrija Stampar Institute of Public Health, Zagreb, Croatia; 2AstraZeneca d.o.o, Zagreb,
Croatia; 3University of Zagreb, Zagreb, Croatia; 4Colpharm d.o.o, Siroki Brijeg, Bosnia
OBJECTIVES: Chemotherapy is standard choice as third-line treatment in patients
with hormone-dependent metastatic breast cancer. The field research has shown that
there is a need for additional hormonal drug in order to delay expensive and harmful
chemotherapy. The aim is to analyze the impact on the budget Croatian Health Insurance Institute (CHII) budget including the drug fulvestrant 250 mg on the basic drug
list as a third-line treatment in patients with hormone-dependent metastatic breast
cancer. METHODS: Markov model was used to develop a new treatment scenario.
Program to calculate the financial impact on the budget was developed in Microsoft
Excel. RESULTS: The scenario with fulvestrant given as a third line of treatment in
a period of 4 months, followed by 4 months of paclitaxel, 3 months kapecitabine,
and, finally, 4 months with only supportive care was designed. This would delay the
application of chemotherapy for an average of 4 months. Therefore, significantly fewer
patients will be treated with chemotherapy. Additionally to that, a small part of
patients would receive chemotherapy over a shorter period. The quality of life of
metastatic breast cancer patients during their life expectancy would be significantly
better, with the same expected survival rate and potentially lower cost of treatment.
The impact budget analysis has shown reduce of therapy cost (4,202,922 Croatian
Kuna or c579,713). CONCLUSIONS: A need for additional line of hormonal drug
as a third-line treatment that can delay the implementation of poorly tolerated and
expensive chemotherapy was established. The effectiveness of fulvestrant qualified it
as a good candidate after the failure of the current endocrine therapy. The economic
evaluation using Markov models and analysis of the budget impact in Croatia has
been proven that adding fulvestrant in sequential treatment of metastatic breast cancer
HR+ patients is cost-effective as third-line hormonal therapy in advanced breast
cancer.
PCN34
BUDGET IMPACT ANALYSIS OF CAPECITABINE IN ADJUVANT
TREATMENT OF PATIENTS WITH RESECTED DUKES’ C COLON
CANCER (CC) FROM POLISH PUBLIC PAYER’S AND PATIENT’S
PERSPECTIVES
Oleszko R1, Kawalec P2, Drobniak A3, Stec R4, Streb J5, Russel-Szymczyk M6,
Szkultecka-Debek M6
1
Centrum HTA, Kraków, Poland; 2Jagiellonian University, Kraków, Poland; 3Holycross Cancer
Center, Kielce, Poland; 4Military Institute of Medicine, Warsaw, Poland; 5The University
Hospital in Krakow, Krakow, Poland; 6Roche Polska Sp. z o.o., Warsaw, Poland
OBJECTIVES: The aim of the analysis is to determine budget impact of reimbursement
of capecitabine monotherapy used in the adjuvant therapy of patients after resection
of stage III CC (Dukes’ C). METHODS: Cost data were collected from Polish public
payer’s (National Health Fund) and patient’s perspectives and calculated for a 3-year
time horizon. The population was estimated based on the Polish National Cancer
Register. The following direct medical costs were included: cost of drugs used in
A257
adjuvant, I and II line chemotherapy, drug administration costs, adverse events, and
monitoring costs. In “scenario A,” capecitabine was not reimbursed by the public
payer, while the “scenario B” was developed under assumption of 100% capecitabine
reimbursement. The proportion of patients treated with capecitabine and other drugs
used in CC treatment was assessed based on the results of a questionnaire study
conducted among Polish clinical experts. a cohort Markov model was used for simulation of long-term health outcomes and costs. a range of variables was tested in oneand multi-way sensitivity analyses. RESULTS: “Scenario B” introduction led to
savings equal to 24,730,000 PLN in the first year, 25,379,000 PLN in the second year,
and 26,712,000 PLN in the third year from public payer’s perspective (1 EURO = 4.1
PLN). Similarly, savings were observed when patient’s perspective was assumed.
Results of sensitivity analysis confirmed conclusions from base-case analysis. CONCLUSIONS: One hundred percent reimbursement of capecitabine used in adjuvant
therapy of patients after the resection for Dukes’ C CC leads to savings from both a
public payer’s and patient’s perspectives in Poland.
PCN35
CLINICAL AND ECONOMIC IMPLICATIONS OF SCREENING FOR KRAS
MUTATIONS IN METASTATIC COLORECTAL CANCER PATIENTS IN
SPAIN: A COST-EFFECTIVENESS AND BUDGET IMPACT MODEL
Saz-Parkinson Z, Amate JM
Instituto de Salud Carlos III, Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Colorectal cancer is the second most common cancer in Spain (25,600
incident cases and over 13,500 deaths yearly). Mutations in the KRAS oncogene are
associated with a poor response to epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) inhibitor
therapy in metastatic colorectal cancer (mCRC). In addition to avoiding unnecessary
toxicity, implementing routine KRAS screening and limiting the use of EGFR inhibitors to patients with wild-type KRAS may lead to cost savings. The objective is to
estimate health and economic outcomes derived from carrying out KRAS determination in mCRC patients requiring an aggressive treatment in Spain. METHODS:
Cost-effectiveness and budget impact analyses from national, regional, and hospital
perspectives were developed in an interactive mode. Information was obtained from
literature review of clinical trials (treatment response rates and prevalence of KRAS
mutations), official statistics (epidemiological data), and local databases (therapy and
KRAS test costs). Multivariate sensitivity analysis can be performed by changing the
technology for KRAS testing (PCR, real-time PCR), the chemotherapy regime
(FOLFIRI, FOLFOX-4), and the proportion of wild-type patients to be treated with
each therapy (bevacizumab, cetuximab). RESULTS: About 7000 mCRC patients will
require an aggressive treatment in Spain in 2010. a strategy based on treating wild-type
patients with cetuximab would raise first-line response rate from 44.80% to 53.84%
(20.18%, 633 patients more) when combined with FOLFIRI (19.05%, 620 patients
with FOLFOX-4) with an additional cost estimate of c22,117 per response (c17,201
with FOLFOX-4). Budget impact of this approach amounts to a 9.06% (5.01% with
FOLFOX-4) increase in resources devoted to mCRC treatment. Univariate and multivariate sensitivity analyses yield ratios between c19,101 and c27,531 and budget
impact estimates of 0.16–9.16%. CONCLUSIONS: Treating wild-type KRAS mCRC
patients with cetuximab would lead to over 600 additional patients (19–20%) with
first-line response every year in Spain, with an associated budget impact of 9–11% of
therapy cost.
PCN36
COST IMPLICATIONS OF RESTRICTING PALONOSETRON UTILIZATION
FOR THE TREATMENT OF CINV: RESULTS FROM AN ANALYTIC
MODEL FROM A PAYER PERSPECTIVE
Powers A1, Sarnes E2, Knoth RL1, Balu S1, Buchner D1
1
Eisai, Inc., Woodcliff Lake, NJ, USA; 2Xcenda, Palm Harbor, FL, USA
OBJECTIVES: Palonosetron is a 5-HT3 receptor antagonist (5-HT3-RA) indicated for
the prevention and treatment of chemotherapy induced nausea and vomiting (CINV).
Using an analytic model, this study explored the consequences of the restricted use of
palonosetron for the treatment of CINV from a payer perspective. METHODS: The
analytic model utilized rates of uncontrolled CINV among patients with cancer and
initiated on palonosetron or another 5-HT3-RA for antiemetic prophylaxis. Other inputs
included direct medical cost of a CINV event defined by inpatient and outpatient visits,
fixed Medicare reimbursement fees for medications (average sale price + 6%), national
prescription utilization data, and the costs associated with executing a prior authorization. Total costs associated with restricting palonosetron usage by 10% with a corresponding 10% increase in generic 5-HT3-RA utilization were modeled for six cycles of
moderately (MEC) and highly emetogenic chemotherapy (HEC). RESULTS: In a 1
million member health plan, 15,000 patients (1.5%) were estimated to require chemotherapy treatment annually. Of these, 10,800 patients (72%) were estimated to
receive 5-HT3-RA prophylaxis on the first day of chemotherapy, with 7587 (51%) on
either a MEC or HEC regimen. Result of the model demonstrated that a 10% reduction in palonosetron led to an overall savings in antiemetic costs equivalent to
$762,616. However, total direct medical costs to the health plan (including the cost
to treat uncontrolled CINV and the cost of the prior authorization program) increased
by an estimated $865,457. Total cost of care, therefore, increased by an estimated
$0.02 PMPM. CONCLUSIONS: Results from an analytic model showed that restricting palonosetron utilization by 10% through a prior authorization, while decreasing
medication costs, produced an overall increase in total direct costs to the MCO. These
results suggest that further studies on the clinical and economic impact of appropriate
utilization of antiemetic prophylaxis for CINV are warranted.
A258
PCN37
BI OF IRESSA IN NSCLC IN THE NETHERLANDS: A HOSPITAL
PERSPECTIVE
Langenfeld M, Scheer F
AstraZeneca BV, Zoetermeer, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: To gain insight in the total Costs of first-line treatment of NSCLC
phase III/IV in the Dutch hospital setting. To calculate the budget impact of adding
Iressa (gefitinib), including EGFR mutation testing, to the treatment sequence. To
identify costs of EGFR mutation testing. METHODS: A budget impact model was
constructed by Medaxial and adapted by AstraZeneca the The Netherlands to better
reflect the Dutch situation. The model calculates the budget impact of EGFR testing
and the resulting therapy change for NSCLC patients in Dutch hospitals. The model
covers the first-line treatment of NSCLC fase IIIb/IV patients and calculates total costs
in a hospital setting and budget impact, taken into account the following costs—Medication—EGFR mutation testing—Administration and monitoring—Treating grade III/
IV adverse events. The model also calculates—Costs of delivery of oral therapies
(outside hospital costs). RESULTS: Before introduction of Iressa, total costs of firstline NSCLC treatment in Dutch hospitals was c41,982.936. After introduction of
Iressa, total costs in hospital setting slightly decreased to c41.939,604 (year 1). Cost
of EGFR mutation testing is c198,432, but medication costs of the hospital will
decrease with c248,193. CONCLUSIONS: Adding extra diagnosis will introduce new
costs to the NSCLC treatment. However, for an individual hospital, the extra costs
are limited. And the total costs of first-line NSCLC treatment even decrease, since the
reimbursement of Iressa is outside of the hospital budget. As a result, the hospital has
less costs if patients are tested and the appropriate patients then treated with Iressa.
At the moment, for some hospitals, EGFR mutation testing is still seen as a hurdle.
Apart from the ethical point of view (making sure patients will receive the medication
they will benefit most from), also from costs perspective, it is worth to test.
PCN38
INFLUENCE OF ME-TOOS TO POSSIBLE SAVINGS DUE TO
BIOSIMILARS
Fuezi J, Reichardt B
Sickness Fund Burgenland, Eisenstadt, Burgenland, Austria
OBJECTIVES: To avoid the waste of market shares, me-toos of established top-selling
biopharmaceuticals enter the market before their patent expiry. After switching the
sales to the me-too, called “step-innovation” by the provider, the possible savings of
biosimilars diminish as the sales are parked at the me-toos. The objective of the study
is to analyze this hypothesis for the two2 substance classes erythropoiesis-stimulating
agents (ESA) and granulocyte colony-stimulating factors (G-CSF). METHODS: By
analyzing the account data of regional Austrian sickness funds, the share of prescriptions of filgrastim in GCSF (filgrastim plus lenograstim plus pegfilgrastim) and of
epoetin in ESA (epoetin plus darbepoetin) are correlated to the costs per package.
These data are shown for several periods, 6 months before the availability of Biosimilars, 6 montha after their availability, and 2 further half-years for ESA. To take
regional influence into consideration, the data are shown for all nine regional sickness
funds of Austria. RESULTS: The shares of prescription for epoetin in ESA show a
huge regional dispersion from 42% to 88% and those of filgrastim in GCSF from
23% to 66%. The average costs per package have an inverse relation to their market
share. These data are reconfirmed through data of the other periods. The average costs
per package have been declined with increased market share of the biosimilars. The
influence of the market share of the me-toos is though overwhelming. CONCLUSIONS: For pharmaceutical companies, it is a profit-maximizing strategy to substitute
their products in time before patent expiry. The less the substitution by patent-protected alternatives succeeds, the higher the achievable cost saving potential for the
sickness funds is.
PCN39
COST UTILITY OF HUMAN PAPILOMA VIRUS VACCINE IN SPAIN
Callejo D, Lopez-Polin A, Blasco JA
Agencia Lain Entralgo, Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: It is well known that a persistent infection by human papillomavirus
(HPV) is an essential cause of cervical cancer. Prophylactic HPV vaccines aimed at
preventing precancerous cervical lesions and cervical cancer are currently available
and may be used for primary prevention of cervical cancer. To define the efficiency
of using HPV vaccine within a cervical cancer screening program with cytology compared with the strategy of only screening with cytology. METHODS: A comprehensive
search of studies was developed in the main electronic databases including primary
studies assessing HPV vaccine efficacy and/or safety or HPV. Meta-analysis was
conducted when the studies were homogeneous. a decision analysis was performed
using a Markov model based on the results of the systematic review and information
about the natural history of the disease (HPV infection, cervical cancer). The model
allowed to estimate cancer incidence and associated mortality, life expectancy, and
associated costs, with the objective of performing an economic evaluation. RESULTS:
A total of 11 studies were included to assess HPV vaccines: seven for efficacy and 11
for safety assessment. The efficacy of vaccine in preventing CIN2+ was 96% (95%
CI: 91% to 98%). Modified intention-to-treat and intention-to-treat analyses were
also undertaken and the results supported this trend, although efficacy was lower. The
economic evaluation showed that the vaccination strategy would imply a cost-effectiveness ratio of around c10,000 per quality-life adjusted-years (QALY). CONCLUSIONS: There is evidence from RCTs that the HPV vaccines are safe and effective in
13th Euro Abstracts
the prevention of cervical cancer precursor lesions. On top of this, this efficacy is
reached with a reasonable cost-effectiveness ratio and within the accepable limits of
the Spanish National Health System.
PCN40
COST ANALYSIS OF MANAGING ADVERSE EVENTS IN THE
TREATMENT OF METASTATIC RENAL CELL CARCINOMA IN
PORTUGAL: A COMPARISON OF BEVACIZUMAB IN COMBINATION
WITH INTERFERON ALFA-2A AND SUNITINIB
Silva CI1, Monteiro I2, Schwander B3
1
Eurotrials Scientific Consultants, Lisbon, Portugal; 2Roche Farmacêutica Química, Amadora,
Portugal; 3AiM GmbH—Assessment in Medicine, Research and Consulting, Lörrach,
Germany
OBJECTIVES: The burden of metastatic renal cell carcinoma (mRCC) is substantial
for patients and society. Bevacizumab (BEV) combination with interferon alfa-2a
(IFN) has demonstrated to prolong mRCC patients’ progression-free survival and to
have comparable efficacy to sunitinib (SUN). However, tolerability differs between
these treatment alternatives and it is therefore of importance to evaluate the economic
impact of adverse events (AEs) management, for each alternative, in the daily clinical
practice in Portugal. METHODS: A linear decision analytical model was applied
considering direct medical costs only in the Portuguese Health System perspective. AEs
incidences associated with each of the two alternatives were extracted from published
literature. Health resource consumption was estimated based on an expert panel of
Portuguese oncologists and urologists. Corresponding unitary costs were obtained
through national official sources. The considered time horizon was 1 year. The basecase analysis includes all grades AEs and a normal dose (nine MUI, three times weekly)
of IFN scenario. Deterministic univariate sensitivity analyses were performed to test
the robustness of the model including grade 3–4 AEs analysis only and IFN low-dose
(six MUI or three MUI, three times weekly) scenarios. RESULTS: The associated costs
of managing AEs were considerably lower with BEV + IFN than with SUN in Portugal.
The average treatment costs for all grade AEs per patient was c1472 for SUN and
c1093 for BEV + IFN resulting in a difference of −379 c (a cost saving of 26% for
BEV + IFN vs. SUN). Sensitivity analyses showed that BEV + IFN remains the less
costly option when alternative scenarios are considered and that a low-dose IFN would
lead even to further cost savings. CONCLUSIONS: BEV + IFN is a more tolerable
and hence cost-saving alternative for the Portuguese Health System considering the
AE management costs of mRCC treatment when compared to SUN. These results are
consistent with previous evidence for other countries.
PCN41
ECONOMIC OUTCOMES AMONG 2ND LINE NON-SMALL CELL LUNG
CANCER PATIENTS IN THE OUTPATIENT COMMUNITY SETTING
Gruschkus S1, Reyes C2, Forsyth M1, Ravelo A2, Nadler E1
1
US Oncology, The Woodlands, TX, USA; 2Genentech, Inc., South San Francisco, CA, USA
OBJECTIVES: Second-line monotherapy options for advanced NSCLC include erlotinib (E), docetaxel (D), or pemetrexed (P). The purpose of this retrospective study
was to compare economic outcomes among patients (pts) receiving 2nd line monotherapy in the outpatient community setting. METHODS: Using US Oncology’s
iKnowMed EMR data, we identified advanced NSCLC patients who received 2nd line
monotherapy from July 1, 2006 to June 30, 2008. Economic outcomes were derived
using outpatient claims and pharmacy data and included total outpatient, chemotherapy, supportive care costs, and frequency of outpatient physician visits, lab procedures, and acute care (ER/inpatient) visits. All economic outcomes were calculated
as per-patient month (PPM) metrics over a 12-month follow-up period. Multiple
regression analyses were used to estimate the independent association between treatment (E, D, or P) on outcomes after controlling for age, gender, stage at diagnosis,
baseline hemoglobin, and performance status. RESULTS: We identified 610 pts—73
received E, 87 received D, and 450 received P. Total cost, chemotherapy costs, and
supportive care costs differed significantly by treatment, as did frequency of outpatient
visits and lab procedures. Relative to P, total adjusted costs PPM is $1579 lower for
D and $1584 lower for E (P < 0.05). Majority of the cost savings are due to decreased
chemo-related costs. Outpatient visits, lab procedures, and acute care visits are also
less frequent with E relative to P (−2.6 PPM, P < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: In US
outpatient setting, pts receiving E and D have statistically significant lower costs and
resource use relative to pts receiving P.
PCN42
COSTS OF MANAGING ADVERSE EVENTS OF FIRST-LINE THERAPY
FOR METASTATIC RENAL CELL CARCINOMA IN MEXICO:
BEVACIZUMAB IN COMBINATION WITH INTERFERON-ALPHA-2A
COMPARED WITH SUNITINIB
Carlos F, Ramirez J, Aguirre A
R a C Salud Consultores S.A. de C.V., México, D.F., Mexico
OBJECTIVES: Bevacizumab plus interferon-α2a (BEV+IFN) prolongs progressionfree survival (PFS) to >10 months, providing comparable efficacy to sunitinib in
patients with metastatic renal cell carcinoma (mRCC). However, the type and frequency of adverse events (AE) differ between these two regimens. We aimed to assess
the costs of managing AE of grade 3/4 of these regimens from the perspective of public
health-care system in Mexico. METHODS: A linear decision analytic model was
developed to compare the direct medical costs of managing AE of grade 3/4 of BEV
+ IFN and sunitinib in patients with mRCC. AE of grade 1/2 are assumed to entail
13th Euro Abstracts
very low costs or even no medical attention, and therefore were not taken into account.
Data sources included the published incidence rates for the 25 most frequent AE in
controlled clinical trials with BEV + IFN or sunitinib. a panel integrated by 10 local
experts from different specialties was constituted to estimate medical and nonmedical
resource use for diagnosis and treatment of each AE grade 3/4. Cost of medications
involved in treating AE were taken from public bids and unit cost of medical services
(outpatient medical consultations, laboratory and image tests, hospitalization at
general ward and at intensive care unit, surgical and nonsurgical procedures, etc.) was
gathered from official tariff lists. All costs are expressed in 2009 Mexican pesos
(MXN). RESULTS: The average cost per patient for the management of grade 3/4 AE
were 76.5% higher for sunitinib ($17,577) than those for BEV + IFN ($9959). The
main cost drivers for sunitinib were hypertension, heart failure, and non-febrile neutropenia; for BEV + IFN, main cost drivers included proteinuria and arterial and
venous thromboembolic events. CONCLUSIONS: BEV + IFN has a more tolerable
AE profile when compared to sunitinib, which is also reflected in the nearly double
cost for managing AE with sunitinib in patients with mRCC.
PCN43
COST COMPARISON OF ERLOTINIB VERSUS PEMETREXED FOR THE
FIRST-LINE MAINTENANCE TREATMENT OF PATIENTS WITH
LOCALLY ADVANCED OR METASTATIC NON-SMALL CELL LUNG
CANCER IN ITALY
Ravera S1, Walzer S2, Ray J2
1
Roche S.p.A., Milano, Italy; 2F. Hoffmann-La Roche Pharmaceuticals AG, Basel, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: First-line chemotherapy for locally advanced or metastatic non-small
cell lung cancer (mNSCLC) is usually limited to four to six cycles, as prolonged
exposure leads to cumulative toxicity without additional survival benefit. Maintenance
therapy represents a new treatment option which can delay disease progression and
extend survival in patients with mNSCLC. Erlotinib and pemetrexed are currently the
only treatments specifically approved for this indication by the European Medicines
Agency and US Food and Drug Administration; therefore, it is important to compare
the monthly treatment costs of using erlotinib or pemetrexed for the maintenance
therapy of patients with mNSCLC. METHODS: Italian monthly treatment costs were
calculated as the sum of the ex-factory costs for the average dose (erlotinib = 150 mg/
day, pemetrexed = 500 mg/m2) over a 30-day treatment duration plus administration
costs. Monthly administration costs were derived from regional tariffs for oncology
drugs. RESULTS: Monthly drug costs for erlotinib maintenance therapy are lower
than for pemetrexed (c1517 vs. c2770, respectively). In addition, as an intravenous
treatment, pemetrexed is associated with additional costs related to administration
(estimated at c140 per month), whereas orally administered erlotinib is not associated
with any administration costs. Pemetrexed total monthly treatment costs are therefore
c2910, c1393 higher than erlotinib total monthly treatment costs. The cost saving
associated with erlotinib would allow approximately 92% more patients to be treated
with erlotinib maintenance therapy, based on a fixed health-care budget. Furthermore,
it is anticipated that the management of pemetrexed-related adverse events (e.g.,
neutropenia, anaemia) would be more costly than those related to erlotinib use (e.g.,
rash, pruritus). Therefore, the cost saving when using erlotinib versus pemetrexed for
first-line maintenance therapy may be greater in a real-world setting. CONCLUSIONS: Based on Italian costs, erlotinib is a cost-saving treatment option compared
with pemetrexed, for the first-line maintenance therapy of patients with locally
advanced or mNSCLC.
PCN44
COST COMPARISON OF ERLOTINIB VERSUS PEMETREXED FOR THE
FIRST-LINE MAINTENANCE TREATMENT OF PATIENTS WITH
LOCALLY ADVANCED OR METASTATIC NON-SMALL CELL LUNG
CANCER IN SPAIN
Castro de Carpeño J1, Castro-Gómez AJ2, Walzer S3, Ray J3
1
La Paz University Hospital, Madrid, Spain; 2Roche Farma, Madrid, Spain; 3F. Hoffmann-La
Roche Pharmaceuticals AG, Basel, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: First-line chemotherapy for locally advanced or metastatic non-small
cell lung cancer (mNSCLC) is usually limited to four to six cycles, as prolonged
exposure leads to cumulative toxicity without additional survival benefit. Maintenance
therapy represents a new treatment option which can delay disease progression and
extend survival in patients with mNSCLC. Erlotinib and pemetrexed are currently the
only treatments specifically approved for this indication by the European Medicines
Agency and US Food and Drug Administration; therefore, it is important to compare
the monthly treatment costs of using erlotinib or pemetrexed for the maintenance
therapy of patients with mNSCLC. METHODS: Spanish monthly treatment costs
were calculated as the sum of the ex-factory costs for the average dose (erlotinib =
150 mg/day, pemetrexed = 500 mg/m2) over a 30-day treatment duration plus administration costs. Monthly administration costs were obtained from regional tariffs
(Galician Health Service). RESULTS: Monthly drug costs for erlotinib maintenance
therapy are lower than for pemetrexed (c2045 vs. c2914, respectively). In addition,
as an intravenous treatment, pemetrexed is associated with additional costs related to
administration (estimated at c235 per month), whereas orally administered erlotinib
is not associated with any administration costs. Pemetrexed total monthly treatment
costs are therefore c3149, c1104 higher than erlotinib total monthly treatment costs.
The cost saving associated with erlotinib would allow approximately 54% more
patients to be treated with erlotinib maintenance therapy, based on a fixed health-care
budget. Furthermore, it is anticipated that the management of pemetrexed-related
adverse events (e.g., neutropenia, anaemia) would be more costly than those related
A259
to erlotinib use (e.g., rash, pruritus). Therefore, the cost saving when using erlotinib
versus pemetrexed for first-line maintenance therapy may be greater in a real-world
setting. CONCLUSIONS: Based on Spanish costs, erlotinib is a cost-saving treatment
option compared with pemetrexed, for the first-line maintenance therapy of patients
with locally advanced or mNSCLC.
PCN45
DIFFERENCES IN HEALTH-CARE COSTS FOR PATIENTS WITH
CASTRATION-RESISTANT PROSTATE CANCER (CRPC) TREATED BY
ONCOLOGISTS OR UROLOGISTS
Engel-Nitz NM1, Alemayehu B2, Nathan F2, Parry D3, Kulakodlu M1
1
i3 Innovus, Eden Prairie, MN, USA; 2AstraZeneca, Wilmington, DE, USA; 3AstraZeneca,
Macclesfield, Cheshire, UK
OBJECTIVES: Patients with CRPC may be treated by urologists or oncologists. This
study examined differences in total health-care costs and prostate cancer-specific costs
in patients treated by oncologists or urologists. METHODS: A retrospective study
design used medical and pharmacy claims (2001–2007) to identify patients with CRPC
from a large US-managed care health plan. Patients were stratified based on the specialist providing treatment following castration; an oncologist (with/without a urologist, ONC), and a urologist without an oncologist (URO). A 6-month baseline period
was used to assess patient characteristics and initial clinical status; a variable follow-up
period (until disenrollment or December 31, 2008) was used to assess total health-care
costs. Lin’s regression was used to assess costs adjusting for the variable follow-up
and patient and treatment characteristics. RESULTS: A total of 995 URO and 1590
ONC patients with CRPC were identified. Mean age was higher in URO patients than
in ONC patients (75.5 vs. 71.1 years, P < 0.001). The URO cohort had a lower average
Charlson comorbidity score (3.7 vs. 4.9, P < 0.001), fewer comorbid illnesses (10.1 vs.
11.1, P < 0.001), and were less likely to have other cancers (17.7% vs. 27.4%, P <
0.001) or to have had hormones, chemotherapy, and radiation treatment during the
baseline period. After multivariate adjustment, mean total health-care costs during the
first year were $31,792 (URO), $54,306 (ONC with chemotherapy, P < 0.05), and
$30,894 (ONC without chemotherapy); during 6 years of follow-up, cumulative costs
rose to $86,706 (URO), $168,794 (ONC with chemotherapy), and $114,180 (ONC
without chemotherapy), P < 0.05 for all. a similar pattern was observed for prostate
cancer-specific cumulative costs. CONCLUSIONS: CRPC patients treated by oncologists, particularly patients with chemotherapy, had higher total and prostate cancerrelated health-care costs than patients treated by urologists.
PCN46
ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF ONCOTYPE DX® TO TARGET
CHEMOTHERAPY USE IN LYMPH-NODE–NEGATIVE, OESTROGENRECEPTOR–POSITIVE, EARLY-STAGE BREAST CANCER IN IRELAND
Lacey L1, Hornberger J2
1
Lacey Solutions Ltd., Skerries, Ireland; 2Stanford University & Cedar Associates, Menlo Park,
CA, USA
OBJECTIVES: Oncotype DX® is a clinically validated assay used to guide chemotherapy decision-making for patients with early-stage breast cancer. Patients classified
as low risk by Oncotype DX® have low likelihood of benefitting from chemotherapy.
By foregoing chemotherapy, patients avoid the risk of chemotherapy-related toxicities.
For those patients reclassified by Oncotype DX® as high risk, the assay identifies
patients who are likely to gain a large benefit from chemotherapy. The study objective
was to estimate the health-care costs of using Oncotype DX® testing in early-stage,
lymph node-negative breast cancer in Ireland. METHODS: A cost-analysis estimated
the health-care costs (chemotherapy, administration, adverse events [AEs], and G-CSF
costs) in patients whose treatment decisions are informed by Oncotype DX® testing.
The perspective was that of the Irish health-care system. The chemotherapy regimen
was docetaxel and cyclophosphamide (4 × 21-day cycles), costing approximately
c9200. Univariate sensitivity analysis was performed, together with a probabilistic
sensitivity analysis (PSA) of the net reduction in chemotherapy usage from Oncotype
DX® testing. In a meta-analysis of seven published studies, there was an estimated
30% (95% CI −40%, −21%; P = 0.0003) absolute reduction in chemotherapy usage
after Oncotype DX® testing (ratio 0.49 [95% CI 0.41, 0.58]; P < 0.00001). RESULTS:
Adoption of Oncotype DX® testing resulted in approximate cost-neutrality (0.4%
increase in cost) to the Irish health-care system, under the above conditions. The main
cost drivers were: net reduction in chemotherapy usage from Oncotype DX® testing
and the rate of G-CSF usage. From the PSA, the probability of Oncotype DX® being
cost-saving is approximately 47%. CONCLUSIONS: Using Oncotype DX® to inform
chemotherapy decisions in early-stage breast cancer has the potential to reduce the
incidence of chemotherapy-induced AEs, while being approximately cost-neutral to
the Irish health-care system. a cost-effectiveness analysis would be expected to result
in a low incremental cost-effectiveness ratio.
PCN47
CHANGE OF ANTIFUNGAL TREATMENT PATTERNS AND ASSOCIATED
COSTS IN PATIENTS WITH ACUTE MYELOGENOUS LEUKEMIA (AML)
AFTER CHEMOTHERAPY IN A GERMAN HOSPITAL FROM 2004 TO 2006
Boehme A1, Atta J1, Mousset S1, Steffen B1, Serve H1, Hoelzer D1, Shlaen R2, Ehlken B2,
Bug G1
1
Med. Clinic II, J.W. Goethe-University, Frankfurt, Germany; 2IMS Health, Munich, Germany
OBJECTIVES: To describe changes in outcomes, treatment patterns and costs of the
management of hospitalized patients with acute AML after chemotherapy in Germany
A260
over a 3-year time horizon, with a special focus on prophylaxis and treatment of
invasive fungal infections (IFI). METHODS: This was a retrospective, single-center
study on AML patients hospitalized for chemotherapy, neutropenia, and infections
after myelosuppressive chemotherapy from January 2004 to December 2006. Data on
occurrence of IFI, treatment patterns, and resource utilization were collected by chart
review. Direct medical costs were calculated from hospital provider perspective.
RESULTS: In total, 471 hospitalization episodes in 212 patients were eligible for
analysis. Occurrence of IFI decreased from 5.9% in 2004 to 1.9% in 2006. Mean
hospital stay decreased from 28.7 ± 17.9 days (2004) to 22.4 ± 11.8 days (2006) (P
< 0.05). From 2004 to 2006, use of a single antifungal drug increased from 30.4%
to 46.9% of episodes, whereas use of multiple antifungal drugs decreased from 24.4%
to 13.1%. Single antifungal drug use was dominated by azoles and increased from
23.7% (2004) to 43.4% of episodes (2006). Posaconzole monotherapy was applied
in 26.7% of episodes. Use of liposomal amphotericin B declined from 21.4% to 3.8%,
caspofungin from 19.3% to 8.1%, fluconazole from 25.2% to 11.9%, and voriconazole from 31.9% to 15.0%. Total costs per episode declined from c19,051 ± 19,024
(2004) to c13,531 ± 9,260 (2006) (P < 0.05); main reduction was observed for antimycotics, blood products, and hospital stay. CONCLUSIONS: These real-life data
from a university hospital in Germany indicate that the antifungal management of
AML patient hospitalized for chemotherapy, neutropenia, and infections after chemotherapy changed between 2004/5 and 2006. This change was accompanied by a
decline in treatment costs. Results suggest that the introduction of posaconazole
prophylaxis in 2006 has not only reduced the use of antifungal therapies but also the
need for treatment with multiple antifungal drugs.
PCN48
COST-EFFECTIVENESS COMPARISON OF APPROACHES FOR LOW-RISK
PROSTATE CANCER CARE: THE NEED TO BALANCE COST AND
UTILITY
Olaye A1, New M2, Abenhaim L3
1
London School of Economics, London, UK; 2LA-SER Europe Ltd., London, UK; 3London
School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London, UK
Prostate cancer is the most common form of cancer in UK men and incidence is on
the rise, primarily driven by increased screening. Low-risk prostate cancer has diseasespecific survival consistently over 95%. Consequently, the UK has deemed radical
treatments (RTs) comprising radical prostatectomy, radiotherapy, and brachytherapy
as unnecessary for low-risk prostate cancer and recommends active surveillance (AS).
AS does not address the disutility for patients living with cancer and in real-life over
50% of patients proceed to RT. Alternative “focal therapies” for this patient population are therefore generating interest. OBJECTIVES: Determine the cost-effectiveness
of AS in the UK as practiced and contrast with focal therapy. METHODS: A Markov
model was used to evaluate the cost-utility of treatments for low-risk prostate cancer.
Input parameters for progression rates, efficacy, and side effects were derived from
the literature. Biochemical and histological progression to RT plus patient choice were
modeled. Hormonal treatment was included as salvage therapy. Age-related mortality
rates were applied throughout the model. For focal therapy, all low-risk patients
received treatment. Failure of treatment led to patients commencing AS, while biochemical progression at any time led to RT. Costs were taken from the UK NHS
perspective. RESULTS: Over 25 years, AS delivered 13.3 QALYs (3.5% discount rate
applied). The QALY value was heavily weighted by the utility of 0.84 associated with
AS. Focal therapy delivered improved QALYs (14.6) over the same period and could
be delivered for cost parity with AS. Cost-effectiveness is discussed. CONCLUSIONS:
UK guidelines recommend AS for low-risk prostate cancer but do not meet the needs
of patients, evinced by low QoL and by many patients choosing RT. Hence, AS has
“hidden costs” in the UK system and there is a place for alternative treatment
approaches such as focal therapies.
PCN49
PREDICTORS OF THE DIRECT COSTS OF BREAST CANCER IN THE
UNITED STATES ELDERLY POPULATION
Davis KL1, Iyer S2, Candrilli S1
1
RTI Health Solutions, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA; 2Pfizer, Inc., New York, NY, USA
OBJECTIVES: To assess cancer-related costs and related predictors among elderly
breast cancer patients in the United States. METHODS: A retrospective study was
conducted in subjects aged ≥65 years and diagnosed with breast cancer between
January 1, 2000 and December 31, 2005. Patients were identified from the SEERMedicare linked database that combines clinical information on cancer cases with
longitudinal (1991–2006) Medicare claims. An index date was defined as the date of
the first observed breast cancer diagnosis. Costs (2009 US$) were aggregated from
subjects’ index date until death, Medicare disenrollment, or database end (December
31, 2006) and included breast cancer-related surgery, radiotherapy, chemotherapy,
and other medical encounters carrying a breast cancer diagnosis. Generalized linear
models with a log link function and gamma distribution were used to assess predictors
of costs. Age, race, stage at diagnosis, hormone receptor status (ER/PR), nodal status,
Charlson comorbidity score, and chemotherapy use were key explanatory variables.
RESULTS: The majority of the 66,217 breast cancer subjects selected were aged 70
to 79 years (47%), Caucasian (88%), and in localized stage (67%) at diagnosis.
Median follow-up was 50 onths. Approximately 5% of cases were diagnosed in the
metastatic stage with a median follow-up of 26 months. Approximately 73% of
subjects with metastatic disease died during follow-up compared to 21% of localized
cases. Cancer-related adjusted costs per patient were $55,120 (median $25,991) for
13th Euro Abstracts
all cases and $153,421, $82,789, and $38,099, for metastatic, regional, and local stage
cases, respectively. Regional and metastatic stage at diagnosis, increased age, increased
number of cancer-positive lymph nodes, negative estrogen/progesterone receptor
status, and chemotherapy use were found to be significant (P < 0.001) predictors of
higher costs. CONCLUSIONS: Clinical characteristics indicating poorer prognosis are
associated with significantly higher breast cancer costs. Patients with metastatic disease
carry the highest cost of care despite having shorter follow-up and poorer survival.
PCN50
BURDEN OF HOSPITALIZATIONS FOR HEPATOCELLULAR
CARCINOMA PATIENTS IN A US POPULATION
Tsong W1, Singer ME2, Ray S1
1
Abbott Laboratories, Abbott Park, IL, USA; 2Case Western Reserve University School of
Medicine, Cleveland, OH, USA
OBJECTIVES: Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is a rapidly progressing, fatal disease.
However, little is known regarding the hospitalization burden for these patients. This
study compares the burden of hospitalizations due to HCC and hepatobiliary conditions relative to other nonhepatobiliary comorbid conditions. METHODS: Insurance
claims (Janaury 1, 2000—December 31, 2008) from a geographically diverse, commercially insured US population were used to identify a cohort of patients with > = 1
HCC claim (index = 1st claim), age > = 18, and no other cancer diagnoses in the year
prior to index. Hospitalizations were grouped by primary diagnosis (ICD-9) codes
into the following categories: 1) HCC and hepatobiliary, and 2) nonhepatobiliary.
Hospitalization burden was compared between these categories based on: number of
hospitalizations, time to occurrence since HCC diagnosis, length of stay, and cost
(2009 USD). The number of hospitalizations was compared using a sign test for
patient-level differences. The remaining parameters were compared using general
estimating equations to adjust for patients with multiple hospitalizations. RESULTS:
This study identified 2927 HCC patients (mean age 50.4 years, 57% male) and 2192
hospitalizations. The subset of patients with > = 1 hospitalization (n = 1083, 37%)
had an average of 2.02 admissions per patient with a median of 11.8 follow-up
months. Compared to the nonhepatobiliary hospitalizations, the HCC and hepatobiliary hospitalizations had: a higher number of admissions (0.40 vs. 0.35 per patient; P
< 0.001), a shorter time to occurrence (112 vs. 330 days; P < 0.001), a longer length
of stay (6.4 vs. 5.4 days; P < 0.007), and a higher average cost per admission ($48,539
vs. 23,221; P < 0.001). The total cost of HCC and hepatobiliary hospitalizations was
2.3 times higher than nonhepatobiliary hospitalizations ($56,451,173 vs. $23,894,444).
CONCLUSIONS: HCC and hepatobiliary conditions accounted for the majority of
the hospitalization burden in liver cancer patients. Future HCC therapies demonstrating reduced symptom progression may reduce the prevalence, duration, and cost of
HCC and hepatobiliary-related hospitalizations.
PCN51
HOSPITALIZATION COSTS FOR HPV-RELATED CANCERS IN MALES
AND FEMALES IN FRANCE
Borget I1, Mathevet P2, Abramowitz L3, Largeron N4
1
Institut Gustave Roussy, Villejuif, France; 2Hopital Edouard Herriot, Lyon, France; 3Hopital
Bichat Claude Bernard, Paris, France; 4Sanofi Pasteur MSD, Lyon, France
OBJECTIVES: Human papillomavirus (HPV) infection is a necessary cause of cervical
cancer and is associated with a subset of other anogenital (anal, vulvar, vaginal, penile)
and head/neck cancers (oral cavity, oropharynx/pharynx, larynx). The overall HPVrelated disease burden is considerable in Europe. This study aimed to assess the
hospital costs of HPV-related cancers for both genders in France. METHODS: Hospitalization costs were collected from a recent publication for cervical cancer and from
the French national hospital database (PMSI) for other cancers. Costs included hospital stays, radiotherapy, and chemotherapy sessions. Annual costs for each cancer
were estimated from the health-care payers’ perspective. RESULTS: In 2006, the
annual costs of cervical cancer were estimated at c43.9 million. In addition, vulvar
and vaginal cancers were associated with c9.7 million annually. For anal cancer, the
annual costs were c20.3 million (male: c6.3 million; female: c14 million). Penile cancer
hospitalizations represented c2.6 million annually. The estimated annual costs for
head/neck cancers in 2007 for males and females, respectively, were c54.4 and c17.1
million for oral cavity, c128.2 and c21.7 million for oropharynx/pharynx, and c47.8
and c5.5 million for larynx. Considering the assumed proportion of cancers attributable to HPV (cervical: 100%; vulvar: 34.7%; vaginal 76.8%; anal: 84.2%; penile:
46.7%; oral cavity: 16.0%; oropharynx: 28.2%; larynx: 21.3%, in Europe), the
overall hospitalization costs due to HPV-related cancers were estimated at c61.6
million in males and c70.8 million in females. CONCLUSIONS: The hospital burden
of HPV-associated cancers in males is almost similar as in females, in France. This
burden is probably underestimated since outpatient and indirect costs were not
included.
PCN53
ANALYSIS OF SOCIOECONOMIC BUREDN OF HEPATOCELLULAR
CARCINOMA IN RUSSIA
Omelyanovsky VV, Avksentieva MV, Krysanov I, Ivakhnenko O
Research Center for Clinical and Economic Evaluation and Pharmacoeconomics, Moscow,
Russia
OBJECTIVES: In our study, we estimated social and economic burden of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) in Russian Federation resulting from HCC from the position
of public health-care system. METHODS: All types of costs were calculated—direct
13th Euro Abstracts
and indirect (the “cost of illness” analysis), connected with patient treatment at different stage of disease treatment. Epidemiology of ÍÑÑ in Russia was investigated:
prevalence, incidence, structure of disease depending on age, disease progression, and
death rate indicators. The expert opinion of real practice of HCC treatment was collected. All these methods allowed to estimate the direct and indirect costs of HCC.
RESULTS: HCC incidence rate was 2.4 patients per 100,000 population (85% in the
structure of primary liver cancer). HCC incidence rate index was 8658 patients as of
2008. In the HCC, structure intermediate stage prevails—61%, the terminal and local
stages—30% and 9% correspondingly. HCC treatment costs were 2370 bln RUB
(c67.7 mln) (2008). Direct medical costs were 2208 bln RUB (c63.1 mln) including
inpatient care (90%), outpatient care (6.6%), and diagnostics (3.4%). Indirect costs
were 0.161 bln RUB (c4.6 mln) including GDP loses (26%) and payment related with
temporary disability (74%) The current HCC treatment standards do not correspond
to international approaches. Very few patients with primary liver cancer get target
pharmacotherapy. The analysis of actual practice of managing patients with HCC
shows prevalence of drugs with no indications for usage from the point of view of the
existing standards and recommendations (form 33% according to regional reimbursement to 58% according to Federal reimbursement). CONCLUSIONS: Developing of
new standards of HCC treatment including target therapy can reduce the cost of illness
by reducing off-label use and optimizing the treatment strategy.
PCN54
HOSPITAL UNDERTAKING OF PATIENTS WITH A RESECTION OF
LUNG TUMOR IN FRANCE
Cancalon C, Schmidt A, Bénard S
St[è]Ve Consultants, Lyon, France
OBJECTIVES: With 30,651 new cases diagnosed in 2005, lung cancer is the fourth
most frequent cancer in France and the first in terms of mortality, with 26,624 deaths
per year. The survival rate at 5 years is less than 15%. The purpose of this study was
to describe the 2 years hospital undertaking of patients with a resection of lung tumor
and to estimate associated hospital costs. METHODS: The 2006 to 2008 PMSI French
hospital databases were used. Patients with a resection linked to a lung cancer (ICD10
diagnoses: C33* and C34*) in 2006 were identified and followed up during 2 years.
Hospital stays, chemotherapy, and radiotherapy sessions were extracted and associated costs (excluding expensive drugs) were assessed using DRG. Kaplan Meier
method was applied to estimate associated costs over time, by taking into account
survival probabilities. RESULTS: In 2006, 8798 patients were hospitalized for a resection of lung tumor of which 75.8% were men. Mean age at inclusion was 62.4 years;
2343 patients (26.6%) died in hospital during follow-up. The mean number of hospitalizations for repeated surgery was 0.11 per patient, 2.00 for radiotherapy sessions,
2.99 for chemotherapy sessions, and 2.57 for other hospitalizations. Total mean
hospital cost per patient was estimated at c16,169.89 for the 2 years follow-up. First
surgery account for 48%, repeated surgeries for 6%, radiotherapy session for 2%,
chemotherapy sessions for 8%, and other hospitalizations for 37%. First month of
first year supported half of the total cost, and first year bore 86% of it. CONCLUSIONS: In France, lung resections for cancer represent a heavy charge for hospitals.
During the follow-up period, major burden is dedicated to hospital stays especially
for the first months. These results could be relevant to estimate the impact of coming
drugs which will be associated to resection of lung tumor.
PCN55
COST OF TREATMENT OF BREAST CANCER IN RUSSIA
Yagudina R, Kulikov AU, Nguyen TTT
Moscow Medical Academy named after I.M.Sechenov, Moscow, Russia
OBJECTIVES: Estimating the amount and the structure of annual expenses for treatment of breast cancer (BC) at different stages in Russia. METHODS: Indentifying the
annual direct costs of treatment BC based on the Russian standard of treatment
confirmed by Minister of Health of Russian Federation. Direct costs of BC include
cost of medical services (MS) (hospitalizations, physician services, diagnosis, surgery,
and other supporting services), and cost of pharmacotherapy (PT) (cytostatics, hormones and antihormones, accompanying drugs, and other drugs). RESULTS: Annual
direct costs of treatment BC totaled 138,680, 1,379,980, and 1,923,050 roubles at
stages I–II, III, IV accordingly. With increase in weight of disease, the relative share
of expenses for MS decreases and for PT increases. Analyzing the structure of costs
at different stages showed that the cost of PT is substantial, especially at metastatic
stage. The presence and relative share of components vary at different stages in structure of expenses for MS, in which expenses for radiotherapy share about 60% and
68% at stage III and IV, accordingly. In structure of expenses for PT, the expenses
for cytostatics are substantial and take 85% at both stages III and IV. Analyzing the
gain of expenses for separate groups of drugs from stage III to IV showed that expenses
for cytostatics and accompanying drugs have grown by 43% and 128% accordingly,
while expenses for other groups have almost not changed. CONCLUSIONS: Expenses
for treatment BC at different stages vary in size and structure, and rises with increase
in weight of disease. With the amount of 51,865 patients with BC in 2007 (62.3%,
26.3%, 10.5% at stages I–II, III, IV accordingly), we received total expenses for treatment of 33,777.217.655 roubles ($1.125.907.255), in which expenses for treatment
of stage I–II, III, IV are 4.481.031.599 roubles ($149,367,120), 18,823,610,290
roubles ($627,453,676), and 10,472,593,166 roubles ($349,860,459), accordingly.
A261
PCN56
CLINICO-ECONOMIC ANALYSIS OF TREATMENT OF CHILDREN WITH
RHABDOMYOSARCOMAS ON PROTOCOLS CWS
Teplykh E1, Zhukovskay E2
1
Children’s Oncohematology Center, Chelyabinsk, Russia; 2State Medical Academy of
Chelyabinsk, Chelyabinsk, Russia
OBJECTIVES: To carry out clinico-economic analysis of treatment of children with
rhabdomyosarcomas on protocols CWS in Chelyabinsk Region, to estimate medical,
social, and economic efficiency of technology. METHODS: We reviewed 21 patients
<16 years old with rhabdomyosarcomas. All patients received therapy on protocols
CWS. We used following methods of clinico-economic analysis: cost of illness, costeffectiveness analysis, and analysis of the kept years of a life. RESULTS: The sum of
direct medical expenses for one patient has made US$16,904 dollars, and the total
sum of direct medical expenses for treatment of 21 patients included in research, has
made US$354,984. The overall survival rate was 52% that testifies to high medical
efficiency of applied technology. For all groups of patients, the treatment keeps 694.4
years of a life that makes 33 years of a life on one patient.The parity of a cost/efficiency
for one patient has made US$512 dollars for 1 year of the kept life. Considering that
in 2008 gross national product has made US$9.5 thousand per capita, an expense for
1 year of the kept life in 18.5 times there is less than parameter of gross national
product, means that expenses are justified. Before achievement of a pension age, the
survived patients will work 422 years and will make gross national product for the
sum US$4009 thousand. The survived patients provide the state with the income 11.2
times the society for their treatment. CONCLUSIONS: The clinico-economic analysis
has shown high medical, economic, and social efficiency of technology of treatment
of children with rhabdomyosarcomas on protocols CWS.
PCN57
EXAMINING PATIENT-BASED COSTS FOR IRINOTECAN
CHEMOTHERAPY: UK PRACTICE-BASED MICROCOSTING STUDY
Shabaruddin FH1, Elliott RA2, Payne K1
1
Health Sciences—Economics, The University of Manchester, Manchester, UK; 2University of
Nottingham, Nottingham, UK
OBJECTIVES: To conduct a robust economic evaluation, it is necessary to describe
current practice and associated costs. Available data on clinical pathways and cost of
chemotherapy are clinical trial-based, which may not reflect UK National Health
Service (NHS) practice. Practice-relevant costs of drug administration, patient monitoring and management of adverse events, required for a practice-relevant economic
model, are not available. This study aimed to inform an economic evaluation by
describing patient-based cost of NHS patients with advanced colorectal cancer (CRC)
undergoing irinotecan-based chemotherapy. METHODS: Resource use data were
collected from the medical records of 48 patients prescribed irinotecan-based (IrMdG)
chemotherapy at a UK tertiary care center. Using the hospital perspective, data were
collected from starting chemotherapy until treatment ended. Unit costs were assigned,
based primarily on NHS Reference Costs 2008/09. Data were analyzed using descriptive statistics and variations around the costs were obtained. Predictors of cost were
identified from a stepwise multiple regression analysis (ordinary least squares).
RESULTS: Total cost for 48 patients was £598,765.54 (UK £ 2008/09). Mean cost
per patient was £12,474.28 (95% CI: £11,233.24–£13,715.32, median £13,307.82,
range £3,024.48–£21,276.18). Cost components comprised: chemotherapy drugs
(36.9%), chemotherapy delivery (21.4%), pharmacy cost (15.0%), oncology appointments (9.5%), central line insertion (5.0%), management of complications and comorbidities (5.1%), management of adverse events (4.9%), and imaging (2.2%). Significant
predictors of increased cost (P < 0.05) identified from the stepwise regression were:
number of chemotherapy cycles received (adjusted R2 0.81), neutropaenia (adjusted
R2 0.83), no prior chemotherapy (adjusted R2 0.85), and full-dose chemotherapy
(adjusted R2 0.86). CONCLUSIONS: This study provides the first data describing
patient-based costs associated with current NHS practice in this patient group, derived
from a pragmatic observational study with no trial protocol dictating practice. These
data should be used in ensuing economic evaluations to ensure relevance to current
clinical practice.
PCN58
SURVEY AND ANALYSIS OF THE COSTS OF METASTATIC
COLORECTAL CANCER TREATMENT IN BULGARIA
Rutkowski J1, Haldas M1, Jedynasty K2
1
HTA Consulting, Krakow, Poland; 2Amgen GmbH, Headquarters Office for CEE, Vienna,
Austria
OBJECTIVES: To describe chemotherapy regimens used in the first, second, third,
and fourth line of treatment in patients with metastatic colorectal cancer. Costs of
chemotherapy regimens used as well as supportive care and medical procedures in
Bulgaria will be estimated (as part of a multinational central European study).
METHODS: This opinion-based study collected required data by online questionnaire. All information concerning treatment of colorectal cancer was based on experts
opinion from four oncology centers in Bulgaria. Oncologists had access to medical
records of approximately 1220 patients treated in year 2008. RESULTS: The leading
first line regimen (60% of patients) was FOLFOX 4 (oxaliplatin, calcium folinate, and
fluorouracil). The most commonly prescribed second-line regimen (50%) was
FOLFIRI (irinotecan, calcium folinate, and fluorouracil). Capecitabine was the most
popular in both the third- (26%) and fourth-line (4%) settings. The percentage of
patients receiving supportive care increased with disease stage, from 1% in the first,
A262
21% in the second, 53% in the third, and 94% in the fourth line. The most common
treatment algorithm (18%) was FOLFOX, FOLFIRI and supportive care in the first-,
second-, and third-lines, respectively. Mean regimen costs per patient were estimated
from a public payer perspective. The most expensive first, second, third and fourth-line
regimens were FOLFOX 4 (c14,200), FOLFIRI + bevacizumab (c7912c), cetuximab
+ irinotecan (c7237) and capecitabine (c2609), respectively. CONCLUSIONS: The
most common regimen in the first line was also the most expensive one. New chemotherapeutic agents are associated with improvements in survival time but also with
substantial costs. Factors influencing the selection of chemotherapy included: previous
therapies, course of the disease, the patient’s performance status, adverse events after
previous chemotherapies, and concomitant diseases. However, open-ended coverage
policies for new chemotherapeutic agents may prove difficult to sustain as costs
continue to rise.
PCN59
COST OF MANAGEMENT OF BREAST CANCER WITH BRAIN
METASTASES USING FRENCH HOSPITAL PATIENT CHAINING SYSTEM
Benjamin L1, Cotté FE1, Vainchtock A2, Mercier F3, Vidal-Trécan G4, Durand-Zaleski I5
1
GlaxoSmithKline, Health Outcome Studies, Marly le Roi, France; 2HEVA, Lyon, France;
3
StatProcess, Port-Mort, France; 4Hôpital Cochin, Unité de Santé publique, Paris, France;
5
Hôpital Henri Mondor, Service de Santé publique, Créteil, France
OBJECTIVES: Breast cancer (BC) is the second neoplasm which disseminates brain
metastases (BM). We estimated the incidence of patients with BCBM, those overexpressing HER2 (HER2+), and the costs related to their management using the new
chaining system of the French hospital information program (PMSI). This was to
identify predictors of costs. METHODS: A retrospective analysis using the PMSI
database (2006–2008) was conducted to estimate the number of public and private
stays related to the diagnosis of BCBM. Stays were extracted and chained to patients’
identification number to calculate the number of patients concerned by BCBM. The
administration of trastuzumab was used as a surrogate for the HER2 status. Costs
were estimated from the health insurance perspective including health-related group
tariff, supplements for intensive care, number and length of stays, and expensive-drugs
status. Spearman’s rank correlation coefficient and nonparametric test (Kruskal–
Wallis) were used for univariate analyses. RESULTS: In 2008, 3610 women were
hospitalized for BCBM (vs. 3273 and 3523 in 2006 and 2007, respectively) of whom
average age was 56.1 years (SD: 13.3). Patients had an average of 4.8 hospitalizations
(SD: 6.4) mostly for palliative care (42%), chemotherapy (39%), and radiotherapy
(14%). Twenty-one percent of patients suffered from BM only and 79% had multiple
metastases; 16% were identified as HER2+. Annual mean cost of care was c8049 per
patient with BCBM compared with c19,412 specifically for HER2+ patients (respectively, 11% and 59% were dedicated to expensive drugs). Age (P < 0.001), patients
with newly diagnosed BCBM (P < 0.001), and the number of metastases (P < 0.001)
were associated with the cost of BCBM. CONCLUSIONS: Incidence of BCBM seemed
to increase during 2006–2008. BCBM management appeared resource-consuming
especially for HER2+ patients. The development of chaining system in PMSI database
is an opportunity to estimate economic data accurately as well as to generate epidemiological data from an exhaustive database.
PCN60
CLINICAL AND ECONOMIC OUTCOMES ASSOCIATED WITH
ADJUVANT CHEMOTHERAPY IN ELDERLY PATIENTS WITH EARLY
STAGE OPERABLE BREAST CANCER
Sail K, Franzini L, Du XL, Lairson D
University of Texas School of Public Health, Houston, TX, USA
OBJECTIVES: Chemotherapy is a major factor contributing to the economic burden
associated with breast cancer in the elderly. However, there are no clear recommendations for adjuvant chemotherapy use in elderly women aged 70 and above due to lack
of efficacy data in that age group. The study objective was to examine the clinical and
economic outcomes associated with adjuvant chemotherapy in elderly patients aged
65 and above with early stage operable breast cancer. METHODS: We studied a
cohort of 23,110 node positive and 31,572 node negative women aged 65 and over
diagnosed with incident American Joint Committee on Cancer (AJCC) stage I, II, or
IIIa breast cancer between January 1, 1991 and December 31, 2002 using SEERMedicare data. Total treatment and chemotherapy costs were estimated from the
Medicare payments using the phase of care approach. Cox proportional hazard ratio
of mortality was used to determine the effectiveness of adjuvant chemotherapy after
adjusting for selected patient and tumor characteristics. a propensity score analysis
was also employed to minimize the bias associated with the receipt of adjuvant chemotherapy. RESULTS: The difference in the total unadjusted costs for patients who
received chemotherapy in contrast with patients not receiving any chemotherapy was
$16,795 in node positive patients and $11,882 in node negative patients. Regression
adjusted cost estimates for all node positive patients receiving chemotherapy was
approximately $6500 and was significantly higher (P < 0.05) than for patients not
receiving chemotherapy. Mortality was significantly reduced in node positive women
aged 65–69 who received adjuvant chemotherapy compared to those who did not
receive chemotherapy (HR, 0.66; CI, 0.58–0.74) and in patients aged 70–74 (HR,0.66;
CI, 0.59–0.74), after adjustment for factors that may affect survival. CONCLUSIONS:
Decision makers can use cost and effectiveness estimates from this study to assess relative value of chemotherapy in different age groups.
13th Euro Abstracts
PCN61
COST IMPACT OF ORAL CAPECITABINE COMPARED TO
5-FLUOROURACIL FOR TREATMENT OF PATIENTS WITH METASTATIC
COLORECTAL CANCER
Citarella A, Cammarota S, Riegler S, Putignano D, Menditto E
CIRFF, Federico II University, Naples, Italy
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the cost of biweekly oxaliplatin plus oral capecitabine
(OXXEL) versus oxaliplatin combined with leucovorin-modulated 5-fluorouracil
(5-FU) given as i.v. bolus every 2 weeks (OXAFAFU) in patients with metastatic
colorectal cancer (MCRC) in Italy. METHODS: We conducted a multicenter, retrospective longitudinal treatment-cost analysis. Direct medical costs attributable to
MCRC were quantified using 2008 prices and tariffs. The analysis was applied to a
time horizon of 6 months. The study was conducted from the perspective of the
National Healthcare Service (NHS). RESULTS: A total of 322 patients (59.9% males;
mean age 65.2 ± 9.4 years) were analyzed. Mean total cost per patient over follow-up
period was estimated at c5242.18 ± 2542.06 and c6732.80 ± 3423.72 in the
Capecitabine and 5-FU arms respectively (P < 0.0001). CONCLUSIONS: The study
estimated that oral capecitabine administration would produce a saving of c1490.62
to the NHS. The differences in cost between the two arms are determined by the
administration route (i.v. vs. oral administration). Therefore, the important economic
and practical advantage of capecitabine oral home-based therapy is the reduced
number of hospital visit and the relative costs. Avoiding the hospital access fees
reduces the impact of higher acquisition cost of capecitabine. Moreover, capecitabine
in comparison to the 5-FU regimen was associated with lower complication. Therefore, oral capecitabine may represent a valid alternative in the management of metastatic colorectal cancer.
PCN62
SURVEY AND ANALYSIS OF THE COSTS OF METASTATIC
COLORECTAL CANCER TREATMENT IN SLOVAKIA
Rutkowski J1, Haldas M1, Salek T2, Jedynasty K3
1
HTA Consulting, Krakow, Poland; 2National Cancer Institute, Bratislava, Slovak Republic;
3
Amgen GmbH, Headquarters Office for CEE, Vienna, Austria
OBJECTIVES: To describe chemotherapy regimens used in the first-, second-, and
third-line treatment of patients with metastatic colorectal cancer and to estimate costs
of regimens, supportive care, and medical procedures in Slovakia (part of a multinational study in central Europe). METHODS: In this opinion-based study, data were
collected by online questionnaire. All information concerning treatment of colorectal
cancer was based on expert opinion at three oncology centers in Slovakia. Oncologists
had access to medical records of approximately 1600 patients treated in year 2008.
RESULTS: The most commonly used first-line regimen (27% of patients) was IFL
(irinotecan, 5-FU, leucovorin) + bevacizumab. The most commonly prescribed secondline regimen (27%) was cetuximab + irinotecan and capecitabine was the most
common third-line regimen (15%). None of patients received supportive care in the
first line. The percentages of patients receiving supportive care in the second and third
lines were 27% and 45%, respectively. The most common treatment strategy (8%)
was first-line capecitabine and supportive care in the second line. Mean regimen costs
per patient were estimated from a public payer perspective. The most expensive firstline regimen was IFL + bevacizumab (c36,369). In the second and third lines, modified
FOLFOX 4 (oxaliplatin, 5-FU, leucovorin) was the most expensive regimen at c31,318
and c31,572, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: More than 50% of patients received an
active treatment until the second line. The most common regimen in the first line was
also the most expensive one. New chemotherapeutic agents are associated with
improvements in survival time but also with substantial costs. Factors influencing the
selection of chemotherapy included: previous therapies, course of the disease, the
patient’s performance status, adverse events after previous chemotherapies and concomitant diseases. However, open-ended coverage policies for new chemotherapeutic
agents may prove difficult to sustain as costs continue to rise.
PCN63
SURVEY AND ANALYSIS OF THE COSTS OF METASTATIC
COLORECTAL CANCER TREATMENT IN SERBIA
Rutkowski J1, Haldas M1, Jedynasty K2
1
HTA Consulting, Krakow, Poland; 2Amgen GmbH, Headquarters Office for CEE, Vienna,
Austria
OBJECTIVES: To describe chemotherapy regimens used and to estimate costs of
chemotherapy regimens, supportive care, and medical procedures in the first-, second-,
third-, and fourth-line treatment of patients with metastatic colorectal cancer in Serbia
(part of a multinational study in central Europe). METHODS: An online questionnaire
was used to collect necessary information in this opinion-based study. All information
concerning treatment of colorectal cancer was based on experts opinion from four
oncology centers in Serbia. Oncologists had access to medical records of approximately 1760 patients treated in year 2008. RESULTS: The leading first-line regimen
(38% of patients) was Mayo (Folinic acid, 5-FU). The most commonly prescribed
second-line regimen (46%%) was FOLFOX 4. Modified FOLFIRI (irinotecan, folinic
acid, 5-FU) was the most popular regimen in the third line (35%), while FOLFIRI/
cetuximab (35%) was the most commonly used fourth-line regimen. The percentage
of patients receiving supportive care was 7%, 5%, 10%, and 56% in the first, second,
third, and fourth lines, respectively. The most common treatment path (8%) was
FOLFOX 4 B in the first line, FOLFIRI B in the second, and Mitomicin mono in the
third. Mean regimen costs per patient were estimated from a public payer perspective.
The most expensive regimen in the first line was bevacizumab + capecitabine + oxali-
13th Euro Abstracts
platin (c21,126), the same regimen was also the most expensive in the second line
(c13,366), irinotecan/cetuximab in the third line (c25,633), and FOLFIRI/cetuximab
in the fourth line (c6479). CONCLUSIONS: New chemotherapeutic agents are associated with improvements in survival time but also with substantial costs. Factors
influencing the selection of chemotherapy included: previous therapies, course of the
disease, the patient’s performance status, adverse events after previous chemotherapies, and concomitant diseases. However, open-ended coverage policies for new chemotherapeutic agents may prove difficult to sustain as costs continue to rise.
PCN64
SURVEY AND ANALYSIS OF THE COST OF METASTATIC COLORECTAL
CANCER TREATMENT IN SLOVENIA
Rutkowski J1, Haldas M1, Jedynasty K2, Ocvirk J3
1
HTA Consulting, Krakow, Poland; 2Amgen GmbH, Headquarters Office for CEE, Vienna,
Austria; 3Onkoloski Institut Ljubljana, Ljubljana, Slovenia
OBJECTIVES: To describe chemotherapy regimens used in the first-, second-, third-,
and fourth-line treatment of patients with metastatic colorectal cancer and to estimate
costs of chemotherapy regimens, supportive care, and medical procedures in Slovenia
(part of a multinational study in central Europe). METHODS: In this opinion-based
study, necessary data were collected by online questionnaire. All information concerning treatment of colorectal cancer was based on experts opinion from an oncology
center in Slovenia. Oncologist had access to medical records of approximately 800
patients treated in year 2008. RESULTS: The most commonly used regimen in the
first line (30% of patients) was XELIRI (capecitabine, irinotecan) + bevacizumab. The
most commonly prescribed regimen in the second (28%) and third lines (12%) was
XELOX (capecitabine, oxaliplatin) + bevacizumab. XELIRI + bevacizumab was most
commonly used in the fourth line (6%). Supportive care was not used in the first line
with 9%, 55%, and 76% receiving it in the second, third, and fourth lines, respectively. The most common treatment algorithm (21% of patients) was first-line XELIRI
+ bevacizumab and second-line XELOX + bevacizumab. Mean regimen costs per
patient were estimated from a public payer perspective. FOLFOX + cetuximab was
the most expensive regimen in all lines. Costs of this regimen were c35,896 in the first
line and c36,179 in the second, third, and fourth lines. CONCLUSIONS: More than
50% of patients received an active treatment until the second line. Costs of treatment
vary between lines. New chemotherapeutic agents are associated with improvements
in survival time but also with substantial costs. Factors influencing the selection of
chemotherapy included: previous therapies, course of the disease, the patient’s performance status, adverse events after previous chemotherapies, and concomitant diseases.
However, open-ended coverage policies for new chemotherapeutic agents may prove
difficult to sustain as costs continue to rise.
PCN65
COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS OF A FOBT-BASED COLORECTAL
CANCER SCREENING PROGRAMME
Pizzo E1, Bracci E2, Vagnoni E2, Wilschut J3, van Ballegooijen M3
1
Imperial College London, London, UK; 2University of Ferrara, Ferrara, Italy; 3Erasmus
University Medical Center, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: Colorectal cancer (CRC) is one of the most common forms of cancer
in western countries and represents the second leading cause of cancer mortality in
Europe (AIRTUM 2009). Early detection and removal of cancerous lesions can reduce
CRC and mortality and improve patients’ quality of life (Taupin et al. 2006). The
main literature on this topic refers to the United States and few studies have been
conducted in Italy to date (Zappa et al. 1997; Tappenden 2007). Aim of the paper is
to shed some light on the effectiveness and costs of screening programs in the Italian
health-care system, presenting the results of a cost-effectiveness analysis of a CRC
screening program in Italy. METHODS: We use as case study a Regional CRC screening program to determine the full costs and the effectiveness of the adopted techniques,
FOBT combined with colonoscopy.The costs involved in each phase of the program
are evaluated using a microcosting analysis. Effectiveness is valued in terms of early
detected lesions and years of life gained. Cost and effectiveness data are used to
estimate the costs for year of life gained, using a MISCAN-COLON Model© to simulate and compare two alternative scenarios, with or without the screening program.
RESULTS: The preliminary results show that the screening will prevent almost 2.0
deaths (11.2%) per 1000 screened individuals, corresponding to 19.4 years of life
gained in 30 years with an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio of c2.400 for life-year
gained. CONCLUSIONS: The results outpace those of previous studies (Sonnenberg
2000), signaling an increasing effectiveness of CRC screening program. Besides, the
paper highlights the importance of implementing a screening not only for the effects
that prevention can have in clinical terms, but also for the economic impact of such
a policy in relation to the long-term sustainability of health-care systems.
PCN66
ECONOMIC ANALYSIS OF CAPECITABINE PLUS OXALIPLATIN
(XELOX) VERSUS FLUOROURACIL/LEUCOVORIN PLUS OXALIPLATIN
(FOLFOX) IN THE TREATMENT OF ADVANCED COLON-RECTUM
CANCER IN CHINA
Chen W
Fudan University, Shanghai, China
OBJECTIVES: The objective of the study was to examine the direct medical cost of
XELOX (capecitabine plus oxaliplatin) compared to FOLFOX (fluorouracil/leucovorin plus oxaliplatin) for the treatment of advanced colon-rectum cancer in China.
A263
METHODS: Since the equal efficacy was already demonstrated by the published literature and local clinical guideline, cost minimization analysis was performed to
compare the direct medical costs of XELOX and FOLFOX for the treatment of
advanced colon-rectum cancer. The direct medical costs were associated with the drug
costs, drug administration costs, hospitalization costs, and adverse events management
costs. The costs were calculated based on a questionnaire survey from an expert panel
of 23 pharmacists and 10 gastrointestinal surgeons and medical oncologists.
RESULTS: According to the recommendation of expert panel, the standard treatment
duration of XELOX and FOLFOX was eight cycles and 12 cycles, respectively. The
drug cost of XELOX regimen was CNY 47,306 (US$6926), higher than FOLFOX by
CNY 22,118 (US$3238). However, the cost increment of XELOX regimen was offset
by the higher drug administration cost (deviation CNY 6,820), hospitalization cost
(deviation CNY 10,200), and adverse events management cost (deviation CNY 7,710)
of FOLFOX regimen. As a result, XELOX showed a significant overall cost savings
of CNY 2612 (US$382) compared with FOLFOX. CONCLUSIONS: According to
the study, XELOX is cost saving in comparison with FOLFOX for the treatment of
advanced colon-rectum cancer in China, especially in the chemotherapy administration and hospitalization utilization.
PCN67
MANAGEMENT OF MALIGNANT ASCITES IN GERMANY—TREATMENT
PATTERNS, RESOURCE CONSUMPTION, AND COSTS
Ehlken B1, Berger K1, Shlaen R1, Gonschior AK2, Lordick F3
1
IMS Health, Munich, Germany; 2Fresenius Biotech GmbH, Munich, Germany; 3Medizinische
Klinik III, Klinikum Braunschweig, Braunschweig, Germany
OBJECTIVES: To describe treatment patterns, resource use, and associated costs for
cancer patients with malignant ascites (MA) receiving paracentesis in Germany.
METHODS: The study was conducted as an observational, multicenter, prevalencebased cohort study. Inclusion criteria were: age ≥18 years, diagnosis of ovarian or
gastrointestinal carcinoma (CA) with MA, paracentesis as treatment option for MA
at the time of enrolment. Resource consumption data were collected by chart review
and patient questionnaire covering the time period from the first paracentesis documented in the study until ascites diagnosis retrospectively and subsequent paracenteses
prospectively. Direct medical costs were analyzed from third-party payers’ (TPP) and
patients’ perspective. RESULTS: A total of 29 patients (38% male) with a mean age
of 65 ± 9 years were enrolled at 11 centers (six hospitals, five office-based practices)
between July 2008 and August 2009. Seven patients had ovarian CA (24%), 5 gastric
CA (17%), and 17 other gastrointestinal CAs (59%). a total of 101 paracenteses were
documented for all patients. From ascites diagnosis to death patients received on
average 4.6 paracenteses. Mean time between two paracenteses was 11.9 ± 12.3 days.
Data from 42 paracenteses were eligible for resource and cost analysis. Diuretics were
applied in 57% of paracentesis units and human albumin in 29%. Intraperitoneal
chemotherapy was applied rarely (5%). From TPPs’ perspective, mean total costs per
paracentesis unit amounted to c1064 ± 1453, from patients’ perspective c17 ± 46.
Direct medical costs per paracentesis unit varied from c671 ± 1070 at office-based
practices to c2.742 ± 1.535 at hospitals (inpatient treatment). CONCLUSIONS: This
is the first comprehensive study evaluating the burden of MA in cancer patients
undergoing paracentesis in Germany. Our findings indicate that the costs for paracentesis range around c670 to c2700 depending on health-care setting. Our results might
serve as a basis for further research on the economic implication of malignant ascites.
PCN68
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF PRIMARY PROPHYLAXIS WITH
PEGFILGRASTIM VERSUS FILGRASTIM FOR THE PREVENTION OF
FEBRILE NEUTROPENIA IN NON-HODGKIN LYMPHOMA AND STAGE II
BREAST CANCER PATIENTS IN GERMANY
Taylor DC1, Ozer-Deniz S1, Hill G1, Skornicki M1, Danel A2, Kunz E3
1
i3 Innovus, Medford, MA, USA; 2Amgen (Europe) GmbH, Zug, Switzerland; 3Amgen
(Europe) GmbH, München, Germany
OBJECTIVES: To assess the cost-effectiveness in Germany of primary prophylaxis
(PP) with pegfilgrastim versus 6- or 11-day filgrastim (F6, F11) in the prevention of
febrile neutropenia (FN) in non-Hodgkin lymphoma (NHL) patients receiving
CHOP-14 chemotherapy and in breast cancer (BC) patients receiving TAC chemotherapy. METHODS: A payer perspective Markov model of febrile neutropenia prophylaxis in chemotherapy patients was developed. PP was defined as initiating
prophylaxis with the first chemotherapy cycle. Model cycle length matches chemotherapy cycle length (CHOP-14:14 days, TAC: 21 days); model time horizon is the
duration of chemotherapy (6 cycles). Cycle 1 FN risk with no prophylaxis was estimated to be 21% for NHL CHOP-14 and 14% for BC TAC; all cycle relative risks
of FN versus no prophylaxis for PP using Pegfilgrastim, F6, and F11 were 0.25, 0.87
and 0.61, respectively, based on published literature and meta-analyses. Pegfilgrastim
cost was estimated as c1686 per chemotherapy cycle; corresponding costs for F6 and
F11 were c1347 and c2469 based on German national pricing. Incremental costeffectiveness ratios (ICERs) were calculated per FN events avoided. Costs and outcomes were discounted (3%/year). Sensitivity analyses were performed. RESULTS:
For NHL FN events per patient were 0.15, 0.76, and 0.47 for Pegfilgrastim, F6, and
F11, respectively. ICER for Pegfilgrastim versus F6 was c1386 per FN avoided. For
BC, corresponding FN events per patient were 0.09, 0.43, and 0.27. The ICER for
Pegfilgrastim versus F6 was c6651 per FN avoided. Pegfilgrastim was dominant (less
costly, more effective) compared with F11 in both populations. Results were most
sensitive to baseline risk of FN, cost of prophylaxis and cost of FN events. CONCLUSIONS: Primary prophylaxis with pegfilgrastim costs <c1400 per additional FN
A264
avoided compared with 6-day filgrastim for NHL patients treated with CHOP-14, and
<c7000 for BC patients treated with TAC. Pegfilgrastim dominated 11-day
filgrastim.
PCN69
COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS OF DASATINIB 100 MG VS. IMATINIB
800 MG IN PATIENTS WITH IMATINIB-RESISTANT CHRONIC MYELOID
LEUKEMIA IN SPAIN
Ramirez de Arellano A1, Sbarigia U2, Taylor MJ3, Martin P1, Restovic G4
1
Bristol-Myers Squibb Iberia, Madrid, Spain; 2Bristol-Myers Squibb, Braine-l’Alleud, Belgium;
3
University of York, York, UK; 4BCN Health, Barcelona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: To asses the cost-effectiveness relationship of dasatinib in comparison
to high dose of imatinib in the treatment of CML in patients with imatinib-resistant
chronic myeloid leukemia in Spain. METHODS: A Markov model was developed to
estimate, in the long term, the costs and clinical outcomes (life-years gained and
quality-adjusted life-years gained) of dasatinib compared to imatinib in imatinibresistant patients. Four health states were considered in the analysis: Chronic phase;
Accelerated phase; Blast phase; and Death. Cycle length is on a monthly basis and
health effects and costs were counted until all patients reached the “death” health
state. The efficacy outcomes are estimated from a direct comparison derived from the
clinical trial BMS 017. The health-care resource use has been set up by a Spanish
clinical expert and direct costs are in euros (2009). The perspective used is the Spanish
Health System. Both costs and effects were discounted annually at 3.5%. The robustness of the results was tested in deterministic sensitivity analyses. RESULTS: In the
base-case scenario, treatment with dasatinib proves to be a dominant option with a
lower total cost and a higher level of effectiveness (potential cost saving of c56,995
and 0.19 QALY gained). The sensitivity analysis indicates that dasatinib remains as
a dominant alternative in front of changes in the most relevant variables: costs, utility
values, age at the start of the treatment, time horizon, and discount rate. CONCLUSIONS: Compared to imatinib, dasatinib shows a slower disease progression with
relatively lower direct medical costs. Dasatinib can be regarded as a dominant treatment option in patients with imatinib-resistant CML in the Spanish Health System.
PCN70
COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS OF RITUXIMAB THERAPY IN
PATIENTS WITH PREVIOUSLY UNTREATED CHRONIC LYMPHOCYTIC
LEUKEMIA (CLL) IN BRAZIL
Chiattone CS1, Borges LG2, Santos E2
1
Faculdade de Ciências Médicas da Santa Casa de São Paulo, São Paulo, SP, Brazil; 2Roche
Brazil, São Paulo, SP, Brazil
BACKGROUND: Chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL) is the most common of adult
leukemias, comprising about 30–40% of all cases (Watson 2008). Incidence of CLL
varies worldwide, being 4.3/100,000 in Caucasian men and increases with age, with
median age at diagnosis of 64–70 years (Yamamoto 2005). In a phase III trial (CLL-8),
the combined immunochemotherapy R-FC (rituximab plus fludarabine and cyclophosphamide) showed longer progression-free and overall survival, higher complete
response rate, and longer duration of response than FC alone in previously untreated
CLL patients. OBJECTIVES: To assess the incremental cost-utility ratio for R-FC
versus FC alone in untreated CLL patients under the public payer perspective in Brazil.
METHODS: The cost-effectiveness analysis was based on the pivotal study ML17102
(CLL-8). a Markov model was developed consisting of three health states: “Progression-Free Survival” (PFS), “Progression,” and “Death”. The model cycle length is
monthly and the time horizon of the analysis is 15 years. Costing was based on public
sources. Only direct costs were considered in the calculation, including costs for treating severe adverse events and further treatment patterns. Costs were reported in 2010
(US$1.00~$Brz1.8) Brazilian Reais and discounted at a 5% rate according to local
guidelines for economic evaluation (Vianna 2007). RESULTS: R-FC combined
therapy resulted in a gain of 1.031 life-years (Lys) (5.611 vs. 4.579) at an incremental
cost of $Brz44,780. The ICER of R-FC versus FC is, therefore, estimated to be
$Brz43,414 per LY gained. The probability of R-FC being cost-effective is 98.84%,
considering a willingness-to-pay of R$100,000. CONCLUSIONS: In untreated CLL
patients, R-FC therapy improves overall survival and progression-free survival compared with FC alone. Results suggest that F-CR combined therapy is a cost-effective
intervention for the Brazilian Public Healthcare System.
PCN71
A COMPARISON OF THE COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF ZOLEDRONIC ACID
FOR PREVENTING SKELETAL-RELATED EVENTS IN PATIENTS WITH
BONE METASTASES FROM PROSTATE CANCER IN 4 EUROPEAN
COUNTRIES
Botteman M1, Carter J1, Kaura S2
1
Pharmerit North America, LLC, Bethesda, MD, USA; 2Novartis Pharmaceuticals
Corporation, Florham Park, NJ, USA
OBJECTIVES: Zoledronic acid (ZOL) is the only bisphosphonate indicated for preventing skeletal-related events (SREs) in patients with bone metastases from prostate cancer
(PC). We estimated and compared the cost-effectiveness of ZOL versus placebo for this
indication in France, Germany, Portugal, and the The Netherlands. METHODS: Incremental costs and quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs) associated with ZOL and placebo
were estimated using a literature-based decision analytic model using data from a
15-month randomized trial comparing ZOL (4 mg monthly; n = 214) with placebo (n
= 208). The model included assumptions about SREs, mortality, drug and administration
13th Euro Abstracts
costs, SRE costs, quality of life, and therapy duration. SRE costs were estimated using
Diagnosis Related Group tariff information (supplemented with published literature) in
France and Germany, and published retrospective medical record review cost analyses
in Portugal and the The Netherlands. RESULTS: Over 15 months, the cumulative
projected SREs were 0.83 for ZOL and 1.66 for placebo. ZOL reduced SRE costs by
c2659 to c4005, depending on the country. SRE cost savings were greatest in the The
Netherlands, followed by Portugal, Germany, and France. ZOL reduced total costs
(including drug costs) by c62 in Portugal and c301 in the The Netherlands, but increased
costs by c562 in Germany and c1022 in France versus placebo. ZOL increased qualityadjusted survival by 0.03566 QALY per patient, with an incremental cost per QALY
gained versus placebo of c15,770 in Germany and c28,648 in France. In all countries,
the cost-effectiveness ratio for ZOL was favorable and substantially below the internationally accepted c50,000/QALY threshold. Costs and QALYs were saved with ZOL
in Portugal and the The Netherlands. CONCLUSIONS: In patients with bone metastasis
from PC, ZOL is economically attractive. The cost-effectiveness ratio for ZOL is below
standard cost-effectiveness thresholds used by most health-care systems. In Portugal and
the The Netherlands, ZOL is cost-saving versus placebo.
PCN72
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF LETROZOLE AND OF ANASTROZOLE
VERSUS TAMOXIFEN AS ADJUVANT THERAPY IN POSTMENOPAUSAL
WOMEN WITH EARLY BREAST CANCER USING UPDATED SURVIVAL
DATA FROM THE BIG 1–98 AND ATAC TRIALS: A UK PERSPECTIVE
Karnon J1, Kaura S2
1
University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK; 2Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation, Florham Park,
NJ, USA
OBJECTIVES: The 74-month follow-up of the BIG 1–98 trial reported improved
overall survival (OS) for 5 years letrozole (LET) versus tamoxifen (TAM; hazard ratio
0.83; 95% CI 0.71, 0.97; P < 0.05). The 100-month follow-up of the ATAC trial did
not show a significant difference in OS for anastrozole (ANA) versus TAM. Using
reported differences in OS, we estimated the incremental cost per quality-adjusted
life-year (QALY) gained for 5 years LET or ANA versus 5 years TAM in postmenopausal women with endocrine-responsive breast cancer (ERBC), from a UK NHS
perspective. METHODS: Annual survival probabilities postoperatively were extracted
from BIG 1–98 and ATAC results. Survival was extrapolated to 20 years using data
reported by the EBCTG for women receiving 5 years TAM. Conservatively, equivalent
annual survival probabilities were assumed for TAM, LET, and ANA groups after
follow-up. Published adverse event (AE) costs and 5-year costs for locoregional recurrence (LR) and metastases were applied. Published utility weights for disease-free
survival with AEs, LR, and metastases were used. All costs and health benefits were
discounted at 3.5% annually. RESULTS: Over a 20-year period, the discounted
additional treatment costs are £3618 for LET and £3736 for ANA. When accounting
for AEs and reduced BC recurrence, the total cost difference between LET and TAM
is £2964, and between ANA and TAM is £2929. The model estimated a difference in
discounted QALYs of 0.297 for LET versus TAM, with an incremental cost per QALY
gained of £9999. The incremental cost per QALY gained for ANA versus TAM is
£46,829. CONCLUSIONS: Using updated OS data, economic analysis of 5 years LET
or ANA versus 5 years TAM in postmenopausal women with ERBC suggests that LET
is substantially more cost-effective than ANA. The current analysis is consistent with
earlier extrapolations based on differences in time to recurrence.
PCN73
COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS OF SUPERIOR HYPOGASTRIC
PLEXUS INHIBITION IN CANCER PATIENTS WITH VISCERAL PAIN IN
LOWER ABDOMEN
Contreras-Bello R, González-Buendía NI, Guajardo-Rosas J, Cerezo O,
Plancarte-Sánchez R
Oncology National Institute, Mexico City, D.F., Mexico
OBJECTIVES: The aim of a neurolytic sympathetic blockade is to reduce consumption
or the side effects of opioids, to improve and enhance the analgesic response, and get
efficiency of costs related to treatment. We assessed the cost-effectiveness (CEA) of
superior hypogastric plexus inhibition (SHPI) in patients with cancer and visceral pain
in the lower abdomen. METHODS: We conducted a CEA within a retrospective
follow-up clinical study at the National Cancer Institute in Mexico City in patients
>18 years with cancer and visceral pain. We assessed patients that underwent SHPI
between March 2005 and June 2009. We evaluated the visual analog pain scale (VAS),
drugs resource consumption, and medical direct costs. The measures were evaluated
before and after (1 day, 1 week, 1, 2, 3, and 6 months) the procedure. Incremental
cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) was calculated. RESULTS: Twenty-six patients underwent SHPI. They were matched with 26 patients with cancer and visceral pain
managed with standard treatment (WHO analgesic ladder steps). The average cost per
patient was not significantly different between treatment groups ($7372 vs. $6768
MXP, P = 0.54); however, the effectiveness (treatment success: 50% decrease in drug
consumption within 30 days) was much higher for SHPI (65% vs. 19%, P < 0.001).
The ICER was $1308 (IC 95% 1104–1485) MXP per patient. CONCLUSIONS: SHPI
was effective for treating visceral pain in cancer patients. The ICER ($1313 MXP)
shows that SHPI is a cost-effectiveness alternative in Mexico (threshold of 1 GDP per
capita).
13th Euro Abstracts
PCN74
ADDING ZOLEDRONIC ACID TO ENDOCRINE THERAPY IN
PREMENOPAUSAL WOMEN WITH HORMONE-RESPONSIVE EARLY
BREAST CANCER CAN BE COST-EFFECTIVE FROM ITALIAN, SPANISH,
AND PORTUGUESE HEALTH-CARE PERSPECTIVES, BASED ON THE
ABCSG-12 TRIAL
Taneja C1, Delea TE2, Kaura S3, Sternini P4, Gerzeli S5, Gnant M6
1
PAI, Brookline, MA, USA; 2Policy Analysis Inc., Brookline, MA, USA; 3Novartis
Pharmaceuticals Corporation, Florham Park, NJ, USA; 4Novartis Oncology, Origgio, Italy;
5
University of Pavia, Pavia, Italy; 6Medical University of Vienna, Vienna, Austria
OBJECTIVES: To retrospectively estimate the cost-effectiveness of adding zoledronic
acid (ZOL; 4 mg intravenously q6m) to adjuvant endocrine therapy (ET; goserelin
plus tamoxifen or anastrozole) in premenopausal women with endocrine-responsive
early breast cancer (ERBC) from Italian, Spanish, and Portuguese health-care perspectives. METHODS: A Markov model projected lifetime outcomes and costs of care for
ERBC patients receiving 3 years’ adjuvant ET or adjuvant ET plus ZOL. Cost-effectiveness was measured as the incremental cost per quality-adjusted life-year (QALY)
gained. Probabilities of BC recurrence were from the ABCSG-12 trial. Other probabilities and country-specific costs were from published literature. Results were generated
under two scenarios: 1) benefits of ZOL persist to the 7-year maximum follow-up
(trial benefit); 2) benefits persist until recurrence or death (lifetime benefit). RESULTS:
Expected ZOL costs (medication and administration) were c1500 (Italy), c2100
(Spain), and c2300 (Portugal). Under the trial benefit scenario, resulting savings from
reduced BC recurrence partially offset costs by c900 (both Spain and Italy) and c200
(Portugal). Therefore, projected total ZOL costs were c600 (Italy), c1300 (Spain), and
c2100 (Portugal). Projected QALY gains with ZOL were 0.46 (Italy), 0.47 (Spain),
and 0.33 (Portugal). Costs per QALY gained were c1304 (Italy), c2766 (Spain), and
c6364 (Portugal) (all favorable). Under the lifetime benefit scenario, savings from
reduced BC recurrences completely offset ZOL costs and yielded net savings of c2900
(Italy) and c2100 (Spain). Incremental total costs were c1400 for Portugal. Projected
QALY gains with ZOL were 1.57 (Italy), 1.59 (Spain), and 0.96 (Portugal). The cost
per QALY gained for Portugal was highly favorable (c1458). CONCLUSIONS:
Adding ZOL to ET in premenopausal women with ERBC can be highly cost-effective
(<c50,000 per QALY gained) in Italy, Spain, and Portugal. Additionally, ZOL would
be considered cost saving to patients in Italy and Spain if these benefits persist >7
years.
PCN75
COMPARISON OF ADVANCED NONINVASIVE TECHNIQUES TO
SCREEN COLORECTAL CANCER: FECAL IMMUNOCHEMICAL TEST VS.
FECAL DNA; A COS-EFFECTIVENESS STUDY
Bhattacharya R, Shah J, Sansgiry S
University of Houston, Houston, TX, USA
OBJECTIVES: This study aims to compare the guaiac-based fecal immunochemical
test (FIT), the primary colorectal cancer (CRC) detection technique, with the fecal
DNA (F-DNA) test which has been recommended as an alternative to FIT as the
standard of care. METHODS: A hybrid decision tree-Markov model was created to
estimate the CRC screening cost per quality-adjusted life-year (QALYs) of using the
FIT annually, or the F-DNA every 3, or the F-DNA every 5 years in individuals at
average CRC risk from a third-party payer’s perspective. a hypothetical cohort of
10,000, 50-year-old individuals transitioning between the health states: healthy,
polyps <10 mm, polyps >10 mm, local cancer, regional cancer, advanced cancer, and
dead, were followed until they were 75 years. Colonoscopy followed every positive
test result. Sensitivity, specificity, transition probabilities, and costs (in 2010 US
Dollars) were obtained from clinical trials and published peer-reviewed articles. The
costs and QALYs were discounted at 3% and sensitivity analyses were conducted.
RESULTS: Using FIT annually would result in an average cost of $56,716.94/QALY
for each individual with an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of $76,181/
QALY when compared to F-DNA used every 5 years. In the ICER plane of 1000
Monte Carlo simulations, FIT was more costly but more effective technique compared
to F-DNA used every 5 years, in 77% of the samples. FIT was the most cost-effective
screening strategy at willingness to pay (WTP) of $100,000/QALY. However, at a
lower WTP of $50,000/QALY, F-DNA every 5 years was cost-effective until a threshold of $71,000/QALY. F-DNA conducted every 3 years was completely dominated
by FIT. CONCLUSIONS: Further research is needed, and third-party payers may need
to assess variables such as compliance and patient characteristics, before considering
the F-DNA as a standard of care for screening CRC.
PCN76
A SIMULATION MODELLING APPROACH TO QUANTIFY THE
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF EXTRA-CORPOREAL PHOTOPHERESIS IN
CHRONIC GRAFT VERSUS HOST DISEASE (CGVHD) IN SPAIN
Perez-Simon J1, Sierra J2, Crespo C3, Rodríguez J4 Brosa M3
1
University Hospital of Salamanca Cancer Research Center (CIC/CSIC) of Salamanca and
Center of Regenerative Medicine and Cellular, Salamanca, Spain; 2Hospital de la Santa Creu i
Sant Pau, Barcelona, Spain; 3Oblikue Consulting, Barcelona, Spain; 4Johnson & Johnson,
Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Chronic graft-versus-host disease (cGVHD) is a major complication
after allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) that impairs quality
of life, functional status, and long-term survival. There is no standard therapy for
patients whose cGVHD does not resolve with immunosuppressors and corticosteroid
A265
treatment. The aim of this study was to compare the cost-effectiveness of extra-corporeal photopheresis (ECP) with Rituximab (Rmb) or Imantinib (IMT) or pooled
comparators (pooled) in addition to the usual care of cGvHD after standard treatment
failure in Spain. METHODS: The model assessed the incremental cost-effectiveness
ratio (ICER) of ECP versus Rmb or IMT or pooled comparator. The incremental cost
and quality-adjusted life-year (QALY) gained were estimated using a short-term decision analysis and a long-term Markov cohort modeling approach. Model probabilities
were obtained from literature, while treatment pathways and adverse event where
derived from expert opinion. Local data on health resources use and costs were used
and validated by clinical experts. The time horizon of the study was 5 years and only
direct local medical costs (euros 2010) were considered. a probabilistic sensitivity
analysis was performed. RESULTS: Preliminary results show that the higher efficacy
of ECP leads to a gain of 0.19–0.20 QALY at first year and 0.15–0.19 at year 5 when
compared to Rmb or IMT or pooled. The short-term cost of ECP is higher than Rmb
(c2.900), IMT (c800) and pooled (c1.800). The ICER results for ECP for the first year
were c15,340 versus RMB, c3.663 verus IMT and c8.977 versus pooled. At 3 years,
ECP was dominant versus IMT and pooled, and showed ICER less than c3.000 vs.
Rmb. The results of the evaluation were sensitive to limited data available. CONCLUSIONS: Preliminary results of this study indicate ECP is a cost-effective, below the
Spanish threshold, or dominant option with respect altenatives.
PCN77
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF OCTREOTIDE LAR IN PATIENTS WITH
METASTATIC NEUROENDOCRINE MIDGUT TUMORS FROM THE
PRIVATE PAYER PERSPECTIVE IN BRAZIL
Takemoto ML1, Fernandes RA1, Chinen R2, Alves MR2
1
ANOVA—Knowledge Translation, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil; 2Novartis Pharmaceuticals, São
Paulo, SP, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: Octreotide LAR has shown antiproliferative activity in advanced
midgut neuroendocrine tumors (NET) increasing time to tumor progression (TTP)
compared to placebo. This study aims to assess the costs and consequences of OCT-LA
versus best supportive care (BSC) in patients with metastatic midgut NET from the
private payer perspective. METHODS: A three health state (progression-free survival,
progression, and death) Markov model with a 10-year time horizon was developed
with data from the phase III PROMID trial. Within the trial, subjects remained on
treatment until progression. Resource use was estimated through published data and
input from clinical experts to reflect clinical practice in the Brazilian private setting.
Unit costs were obtained from Brazilian official sources. Costs and outcomes were
discounted 5% per annum. RESULTS: The model estimated 14 months PFS with
OCT-LA versus 6 months with BSC. Estimated PFS gain was 0.60 years (1.07 vs.
0.46). Total cost of treatment was 275,497 BRL for BSC and 303,111 BRL for
OCT-LA. The incremental cost per progression-free year gained was 28,706 BRL in
the OCT-LA arm versus BSC due to treatment until progression. The mean cost of
supportive care for progressive disease represented 87.3% (239,883 BRL) and 76.9%
(224,388 BRL) of the final cost of treatment for BSC and OCT-LA, respectively.
Results remained consistent when univariate sensitivity analyses were run. CONCLUSIONS: OCT-LA is a clinically effective option to control tumor growth in patients
with metastatic midgut NET. OCT-LA provides longer TTP compared to BSC for
those patients. Although there is ecological evidence to suggest improvement in OS
after introduction of OCT LA, the ICER for an additional life-year gained is not currently calculable as the PROMID trial was not designed to evaluate OS. Further areas
of research to elucidate the association between PFS and OS in NET are needed.
PCN78
OST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS OF ADJUVANT THERAPY WITH
IMATINIB MESYLATE IN PATIENTS AFTER RESECTION OF LOCALIZED
PRIMARY GASTROINTESTINAL STROMAL TUMOR
Krysanov I, Zorin N, Pyadushkina E, Koval DA
Institute of Clinico-Economic Expertise and Pharmacoeconomics, RSMU, Moscow, Russia
OBJECTIVES: Imatinib is a low molecular tyrosine kinase inhibitor that blocks the
kinase activity KIT and PDGFRα, and a first-line drug in the treatment of unresectable
and metastatic gastrointestinal stromal tumor (GIST). The standard treatment of
patients with localized primary GIST is a complete surgical resection of the tumor.
Several studies have shown that target therapy improves survival of patients after GIST
resection. The purpose of this study was to estimate the costs and effectiveness of
adjuvant imatinib therapy versus no treatment in patients who have undergone GIST
resection. METHODS: A Markov model was used to estimate costs and effectiveness
of adjuvant imatinib therapy in the long-term follow-up period. Data on overall and
recurrence-free survival were taken from the phase III clinical trial ACOSOG Z9001
and were used to assess efficacy. Measures of effectiveness include such indicators as
life-years saved and quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs) gained for adjuvant imatinib
following surgical resection and surgical resection only. Data on the common practice
of GIST treatment in the Russian oncology centers were used in the model. Costs,
life-years, and QALYs gained were calculated over the 50-year time horizon and
discounted at an annual rate of 5%. RESULTS: The number of life-years saved was
10.01 for imatinib treatment against 8.67 for no treatment. The number of QALYs
was 7.97 and 6.82, respectively. The costs of 1-year patient management with adjuvant imatinib therapy were c44,348 per person; a patient who had not received
imatinib in adjuvant mode required c32,102 per person. CONCLUSIONS: The analysis showed that adjuvant imatinib therapy is more costly compared with no treatment.
However, it is more effective and can increase the life expectancy of patients. In this
A266
case, the costs of therapy are partly offset by reducing the frequency of relapses and
the progression of the disease.
PCN79
ECONOMIC MODELING FOR TREATMENT FAILURE PATIENTS USING
MULTIPLE ROUNDS OF THERAPY AS COMPARATOR
Aggarwal S1, Stevens CA2
1
PAREXEL Consulting, Bethesda, MD, USA; 2PAREXEL Consulting, Waltham, MA, USA
OBJECTIVES: Treatment failure patients in various disease areas are often treated by
multiple rounds of therapy. However, new treatment options are emerging that have
potential to replace that treatment with single-agent or single round of combination
treatment. It is challenging to demonstrate cost-effectiveness of these new agents,
especially when comparator is not one single regimen but sequential treatment. We
present here our results from a study where we developed a model that can incorporate
multiple rounds of treatment or relapses to estimate cost-effectiveness of new emerging
therapies. METHODS: Intervention was chosen as an emerging T-cell lymphoma drug
candidate. Comparator was chosen as sequential treatment with 1–5 chemo regimens
(called DHAP, ESHAP, ICE, HyperCVAD, and EPOCH). All comparator chemo regimens are generics and their prices were obtained from Medispan’s PriceRx. Intervention’s price was assumed as median price of branded chemotherapy agents. Cost,
efficacy, adverse events, and utilities were sourced and estimated from published
studies for T and B-cell lymphoma. Relapses and number of chemo regimens for
comparators were varied from 1–5. Sensitivity analyses were performed for all base
calculations. RESULTS: Model results show that a new agent that can replace multiple
rounds of treatment is relatively more cost-effective than another agent that replaces
relatively fewer rounds of treatments. Our base-case incremental cost-effectiveness
with one chemo regimen as comparator was $262,908. However, if there are 2,3,4,
or 5 sequential rounds, the ICER values change to $223,078, $183,249, $143,420,
and $103,591, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: For newer agents that are indicated for
treatment failure patients, the use of sequential treatments as comparator can significantly improve their cost-effectiveness. The model approach described here can be
used for arthritis, hepatitis C, and diabetes and oncology TF patients.
PCN80
COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS OF OXLIPLATIN IN ADJUVANT
THERAPY FOR STAGE 3 COLON CANCER PATIENTS IN JAPAN
Fukuda T1, Shiroiwa T2, Takeuchi T1, Shimozuma K2, Ohashi Y1
1
Tokyo University, Tokyo, Japan; 2Ritsumeikan University, Kusatsu, Shiga, Japan
OBJECTIVES: FOLFOX (folic acid [l-LV], 5-FU, and oxaliplatin) is a standard
therapy for metastatic colorectal cancer. FOLFOX in adjuvant therapy was approved
in 2009. However, cost-effectiveness of FOLFOX, which can prolong DFS (diseasefree survival), is not known. METHODS: We performed cost-effectiveness analysis of
FOLFOX in adjuvant therapy for stage3 colon cancer compared with FU/LV as a
standard regimen. Our analysis is based on the patient-level data of MOSAIC (the
Multicenter International Study of Oxaliplatin/5-Fluorouracil/Leucovorin in the Adjuvant Treatment of Colon Cancer) trial. Survival curve of DFS and OS (overall survival)
was extrapolated by cure model, which uses parametric regression considering some
patients can cure without recurrence. Death of any other causes was treated as competing risk. Expected value of mean survival year was gained by calculating area under
the estimated survival curve during 15 years. QALY (quality-adjusted life-year) was
calculated weighting survival time by utility scores. Since our analysis is from the
perspective of health-care payer, only direct medical costs were included. Three percent
annual discount rate was used for both costs and outcome. RESULTS: Adjuvant
FOLFOX therapy for stage 3 colon cancer patients can gain more QALY than standard FU/LV therapy. The difference of both therapies is about 0.5 QALY. ICER
(incremental cost-effectiveness ratio) of FOLFOX compared with FU/LV estimated to
be less than JPY 2.5 million (US$28,000, US$ 1 = JPY 90) per QALY. This value is
thought to be a little conservative because time horizon of our analysis is 15 years,
not lifetime to avoid uncertainty of long-term future. CONCLUSIONS: FOLFOX
therapy in adjuvant of stage 3 colon cancer is cost-effective. The ICER compared with
FU/LV is acceptable from the Japanese health-care payer.
PCN81
COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS OF THREE STRATEGIES OF
ERLOTINIB TREATMENT IN NON0-SMALL-CELL LUNG CANCER: A
PROSPECTIVE MULTICENTRIC FRENCH STUDY (ERMETIC)
Borget I1, Cadranel J2, Mauguen A1, Coudert B3, Dansin E4, Friard S5, Daniel C6, Quoix E7,
Madelaine J8, Madroszyk A9, Morin F10, Pignon JP1, Chouaid C11
1
Institut Gustave Roussy, Villejuif, France; 2Hospital Tenon, PARIS, France; 3CLCC Dijon,
Dijon, France; 4CHU Lille, Lille, France; 5Hospital Foch, Suresnes, France; 6Institut Curie, Paris,
France; 7CHU Strasbourg, Strasbourg, France; 8CHU Caen, Caen, FRANCE, France; 9CLCC
Marseille, Marseille, France; 10IFCT, Paris, France; 11Hôpital St Antoine, Paris, France
OBJECTIVES: Although several clinical and biological parameters are prognostic
factors of NSCLC patients outcome, their medico-economic impact in the prescription
of erlotinib has never been evaluated. a French NCI prospective study aimed to
compare cost and effectiveness of three strategies of erlotinib initiation in second line
or more treatment of advanced NSCLC patients: initiation in all patients, patients
selected on clinical-guided strategy, and patients selected on biological-guided strategy.
METHODS: A Markov model compared the outcomes and costs (limited to direct
medical costs from the third-party payer perspective) of a prospective multicentric
cohort of consecutive advanced NSCLC patients newly treated by erlotinib, to a cohort
13th Euro Abstracts
of clinical-selected patients (non/ex-smoking women with adenocarcinoma histology)
and a cohort of biomarker-selected patients (EGFR mutation). Utility data were
extracted from literature. Sensitivity analyses were performed. RESULTS: A total of
522 patients were enrolled between March 2007 and March 2008. Median age was
63 years; 32% were females; 65% had adenocarcinoma; and 8% had EGFR mutation.
The strategy which consists to treat all patients was dominated, as it was both the less
effective and the most expensive strategy (0.495 QALY/c22,396). The clinical-guided
strategy was slightly more effective than the biological-guided strategy (respectively
0.568 and 0.563 QALY), but it was also more expensive (respectively c16,299 and
c15,187). The dominant strategy was then the biological-guided strategy (c26,975/
QALY). The model was robust to variations of biological exam costs, palliative costs,
and utility data. Biological-guided strategy appears the most effective and the less
expensive strategy when the prevalence of EGFR mutation exceeds 10%. CONCLUSIONS: Biological-guided strategy appears the dominant strategy if the prevalence of
EGFR mutation was >10%. This suggests determining EGFR mutation status in priority to non/former smokers, females with adenocarcinoma.
PCN82
RESEARCH PRIORITIZATION FOR PROSPECTIVE COMPARATIVE
EFFECTIVENESS RESEARCH (CER) IN CANCER GENOMICS
Veenstra D1, Thariani R1, Carlson JJ1, Garrison L2, Mohr P3, Deverka P4, Tunis SR3,
Hoban C5, Baker LH5, Ramsey S6
1
University of Washington, Pharmaceutical Outcomes Research and Policy Program, Seattle,
WA, USA; 2University of Washington, Department of Pharmacy, Seattle, WA, USA; 3Center
for Medical Technology Policy, Baltimore, MD, USA; 4University of North Carolina, Chapel
Hill, Phoenix, AZ, USA; 5University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA; 6Fred Hutchinson
Cancer Research Center, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA
OBJECTIVES: The Center for Comparative Effectiveness Research in Cancer Genomics (CANCERGEN) is a multidisciplinary, national consortium established to conduct
CER in Genomics and Personalized Medicine (GPM). The objective was the evaluation
and prioritization of GPM applications for study in a prospective, randomized CER
trial. METHODS: Candidate GPMs were identified through a landscape analysis of
recent literature. Initial candidates were examined by cancer genomics experts and
study investigators to identify 5–7 GPMs for evaluation by a diverse group of external
stakeholders, including representatives from patients groups, payers, test developers,
state-funded public HTA programs, and practicing oncologists. We developed Topic
Briefs and Test Target Profiles assessing the following domains: population impact,
current standard of care, clinical validity, potential benefits, potential harms, economic
impact, evidence of need, trial feasibility, and current payer status. RESULTS: We
identified 43 studies from 183 GPMs based on our landscape analysis, which were
narrowed to four GPMs through feedback from cancer genomics experts; two additional GPMs were identified by investigators from our clinical trials consortium
(SWOG). The six GPMs included: ERCC1 testing for platinum chemotherapy in
NSCLC, EGFR mutation testing for TKIs in NSCLC maintenance, tumor markers for
breast cancer recurrence, EGFR FISH testing for first-line cetuximab in NSCLC, BRAF
testing in colorectal cancer, and gene expression profiling in multiple myeloma. External stakeholders preliminarily identified the first three of these as most likely providing
the greatest value of research. CONCLUSIONS: A rapid process for research prioritization involving literature evaluation, expert input, and stakeholder feedback is
feasible with adequate resources and processes. Elements include an organization
facilitating collaboration between investigators with CER/clinical trials experience,
and utilizing systematic and timely evidence-assessment accessible to stakeholders.
Final selection of a GPM for study in a prospective CER trial will be based on quantitative value-of-information analyses, implementation feasibility, and funding mechanisms, including coverage with evidence development.
PCN83
A COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS (CEA) FOR DENOSUMAB, A FULLY
HUMAN MONOCLONAL ANTIBODY FOR CANCER TREATMENTINDUCED BONE LOSS (CTIBL) IN NON-METASTATIC PROSTATE
CANCER (PRCA): A SWEDISH PERSPECTIVE
Shroff S1, Martin M1, Kearney M2, Lothgren M2, Bracco A2
1
i3 Innovus, Uxbridge, Middlesex, UK; 2Amgen (Europe) GmbH, Zug, Switzerland
BACKGROUND: Androgen deprivation therapy (ADT) decreases bone mineral
density (BMD), increasing risk of fragility fractures and decreasing quality of life over
time. Until recently, there were no licensed treatments despite high unmet medical
need. In a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial, denosumab increased
BMD and reduced the incidence of vertebral fractures in nonmetastatic PrCa patients
receiving ADT. OBJECTIVES: To assess the cost-effectiveness (CE) of denosumab
versus no treatment in nonmetastatic PrCa CTIBL patients in Sweden. METHODS:
A Markov model was adapted from previously developed models in osteoporosis. This
includes six fracture states: hip, vertebral, wrist, other, post-hip, and post-vertebral
fracture. Model inputs were based on a literature review conducted in PUBMED. The
target population reflected patient characteristics of the trial. The model horizon was
5 years, reflecting progression to metastatic disease. General population fracture risks
from Swedish males were adjusted by the relative risk of fracture due to ADT. Only
the efficacy of denosumab on vertebral fractures was included in the base case. a
societal perspective was used. Published trial data were used to validate the model in
terms of fractures. RESULTS: The cost per QALY (ICER) for denosumab versus no
treatment ranged from c46,683 to c58,282. Multiple deterministic sensitivity analyses
(SA) were performed. The main driver of CE was the efficacy of denosumab; when it
13th Euro Abstracts
provides benefits at other fracture sites as shown in the postmenopausal pivotal trial
FREEDOM, the ICER reduces to c19,726. a probabilistic SA showed that denosumab
was a cost-effective option for a willingness to pay >c60,000. CONCLUSIONS:
Denosumab prevents vertebral fractures in patients with PrCa receiving ADT and is
cost-effective versus no treatment. Vertebral fractures significantly reduce quality of
life and since there is no other licensed treatment in Sweden, denosumab represents
an important option in PrCa at commonly accepted CE thresholds in Sweden.
PCN84
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF ERLOTINIB IN FIRST-LINE TREATMENT OF
ADVANCED NON-SMALL CELL LUNG CANCER (NSCLC) IN FIT
ELDERLY PATIENTS: AN ECONOMICAL ANALYSIS OF A PROSPECTIVE
PHASE 2 STUDY (GFPC 0504)
Chouaid C1, Le caer H2, Crequit J3, Monnet I4, Chouabe S5, Locher C6, Paillotin D7,
Auliac JB8, Thomas P9, Vergnenegre A10
1
Hôpital St Antoine, Paris, France; 2Hôpital de draguignan, Draguignan, France; 3Centre
Hospitalier de Beauvais, Beauvais, France; 4Centre Intercommunal de Creteil, Creteil, France;
5
Centre hospitalier de Charleville Meziere, Charleville Mézières, France; 6Hôpital Saint Faron,
Meaux, France; 7CHU de Rouen, Rouen, France; 8Service De Pneumologie, mantes la jolie,
France; 9Centre Hospitalier, GAP, France; 10Hôpital du Cluzeau Service de Pathologie
Respiratoire, Limoges, France
OBJECTIVES: Median age of newly diagnosed non-small cell lung cance (NSCLC) is
70 years (with 1/3 older than 75 years) and elderly are more vulnerable to chemotherapy. In this population, weekly gemcitabine and docetaxel or erlotinib are both
active in advanced NSCLC treatment. The GFPC0504 randomized prospective phase
2 study assess in fit elderly patients with advanced NSCLC, efficacy of weekly chemotherapy followed by erlotinib if progression (Arm A) versus erlotinib followed by
chemotherapy if progression (arm B). The main objective of this study was time before
second progression, secondary objective was overall survival. The objective of this
study is to assess the cost-effectiveness of erlotinib in first-line treatment of NSCLC
in fit elderly patients. METHODS: Outcomes (PFS and overall survival) and direct
medical costs until second progression (from the third-party payer perspective) were
prospectively collected. Costs after second progression and health utilities (based on
disease states and grade 3–4 toxicities) were derived from the literature. RESULTS:
For respectively 48 and 51 patients randomized respectively in arm a and B, PFS were
6.4 and 5.2 months, overall survival were 9.2 and 7.9 months; mean Qualy and mean
direct costs (euros value 2010) were respectively c0.434 ± c0.394 and c26,297 ±
c25,297 and c0.471 ± c0.451 and c25,948 ± c18,206. Acceptability curve will be
presented at the meeting. CONCLUSIONS: In this population of fit ederly patients,
erlotinb in first line, followed by chemotherapy if progression appears as dominant
compare to chemotherapy followed by erlotinib if progression.
PCN85
SORAFENIB AND SUNITINIB IN METASTATIC RENAL CELL
CARCINOMA: COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS IN REIMBURSEMENT
PROCEEDINGS VS. DATA FROM CLINICAL PRACTICE
Ondrackova B1, Demlova R2
1
Masaryk University, Faculty of Medicine, Brno, Czech Republic; 2Masaryk Memorial Cancer
Institute, Brno, Czech Republic
OBJECTIVES: Sorafenib and sunitinib are approved for patients with advanced or
metastatic renal cell carcinoma after INF-a or IL-2 therapy failure or intolerance, with
PS 0-1 and without CNS metastasis in defined cancer centers in the Czech Republic;
sunitinib is reimbursed for first-line therapy in mRCC patients of good or intermediate
risk. METHODS: We assessed the cost of sunitinib and sorafenib in patients treated
in comprehensive cancer center and prepared cost-effectiveness analysis (CEA) to
compare our data to CEA submitted by manufacturers to Czech authority (SUKL =
State Institute for Drug Control) in reimbursement proceedings between 2008 and
2010. (1c = 26CZK). RESULTS: CEA of sunitinib submitted to SUKL was based on
cost of pharmacotherapy and clinical data of Motzer et al. study (NEJM 2007; time
to PD: sunitinib 11 months, INF-a 5 months; duration of PD to death 6 months). Cost
per progression-free year (PFY) was 324144CZK/12467c in manufacturer’s analysis,
CZK867,946CZK/c33,383 in SUKL analysis (after INF-a cost reduction and costs
after PD removal) and CZK2,304,914/c88,651 in our analysis (cost and effects of
sunitinib based on our results; INF-a data were assumed identically). CEA of sorafenib
was performed for patients after cytokine intolerance or failure (Escudier et al.; NEJM
2007) in comparison with sunitinib (70% pts) or BSC (30% pts). The cost per PFY
was CZK965,726/c37,143 in manufacturer’s analysis. Although sorafenib was
cheaper alternative according to our results, time to progression was shortened by 18
days (ICER CZK516,820/c1,9878 per PFY). CONCLUSIONS: The cost per PFY in
sunitinib was seven times lower in manufacturer’s analysis than in CEA based on real
data from cancer center. We assume that this was mainly caused by shorter time of
pharmacotherapy in original study (6 vs. 11 months in our data). CEA of sorafenib
demonstrated lower costs and effects in our analysis, because the significance of
comparator (70% pts sunitinib) was underestimated in manufacturer’s analysis.
A267
PCN86
COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS OF SPLANCHNIC NERVE BLOCKADE
IN PATIENTS WITH CANCER AND VISCERAL PAIN IN THE UPPER
ABDOMEN
Domínguez-Ocadio G, Cerezo O, González-Buendía NI, Guajardo-Rosas J,
Plancarte-Sánchez R
Oncology National Institute, Mexico City, D.F., Mexico
OBJECTIVES: The aim of a sympathetic blockade is to improve the analgesic
response, diminish the opioid consumption, reduce the adverse effects from opioides,
and get efficiency of costs related to treatment. We analyzed the cost-effectiveness of
Splanchnic Nerves Blockade (SNB) versus drug therapy in patients with cancer and
visceral pain at the upper abdomen. METHODS: A cost-effectiveness analysis was
conducted within a retrospective, follow-up study in patients >18 years with cancer
and visceral pain. Using medical records, we assessed patients that underwent a SNB
between March 2005 and December 2009. We evaluated the visual analog pain scale
(VAS), Karnofsky performance scale (KPS), and medical direct costs. The measures
were evaluated before and after (1, 2, 3, 6, 9, and 12 months) the procedure. Cost
methodology was calculated trough cost of illness and microcosting technique, to get
the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER). RESULTS: Sixty-five patients were
treated with SNB and 19 with drug treatment-WHO analgesic ladder steps (mean age
52.7 ± 12.9 and 54 ± 12.9, respectively). Basal characteristics were not different
between them. VAS scores diminished in both arms, but at repeated measures ANOVA
patients on SNB had better pain control (P < 0.05) and higher KPS (P < 0.05). The
mean cost per patient in 1-year follow-up for the drug treatment group was $7512
MXP (CI 95% $1587–$13,436 MXP) and $5433 (CI 95% $5114–$5752) for SNB.
The effectiveness measure was 80% for SNB versus 20% for the drug treatment group,
respectively. The ICER obtained was negative (−$3526 MXP, IC 95% −5860 to
−1191), favoring the SNB as a cost-saving alternative. CONCLUSIONS: SNB showed
to be less costly and more effective than drug treatment alone. However, when a sensitive analysis (bootstrap methodology) was conducted, the sample size was not powerful enough for a precise CE estimate.
PCN87
PHARMACOECONOMIC ANALYSIS OF DIRECT MEDICAL COSTS OF
METASTATIC COLORECTAL CANCER THERAPY WITH XELOX OR
FOLFOX4 WITH OR WITHOUT BEVACIZUMAB AS THE FIRST-LINE
TREATMENT
Tikhomirova A1, Kulikov A2, Yagudina R2
1
FGU NCESMP Roszdravnadzora, Moscow, Russia; 2Moscow Medical Academy, Moscow,
Russia
OBJECTIVES: Pharmacoeconomic analysis of direct medical costs of mCRC therapy
using XELOX/FOLFOX4, XELOX + BV/FOLFOX4 + BV. METHODS: Costs of
diagnosis, medical services, and hospitalization were based on the price list for diagnostic and therapeutic procedures of Cancer Research Center n.a. N.N.Blokhin
RAMS. The medical services patient should receive during the treatment and the
frequency of their appointments were taken from the standards of medical care for
patients with colon and rectum cancer. Cost analysis of anticancer drugs (16 courses
of XELOX/XELOX + BV, 24 courses of FOLFOX4/FOLFOX4 + BV) and related
drugs were based on the information about maximum selling import prices, registered,
and entered into the State Register of prices of vitally essential drugs. The cost of other
drugs was based on a database of retail prices for drugs in pharmacies, which was
subsequently reduced by trade discount. RESULTS: In was calculated that the cost of
diagnosis was 16,757 rubles and the medical services—379,815 rubles. The mCRC
therapy as a first line by XELOX was 1,172,731 rubles and by XELOX +
BV—2,526,110 rubles; by FOLFOX4—1,487,627 rubles and by FOLFOX4 +
BV—2,843,558 rubles. The cost saving in applying the regime XELOX compared to
FOLFOX4 regime amounted to 314,896 rubles. In applying the regime of XELOX in
combination with BV in comparison with the regime of FOLFOX4 in combination
with BV amounted to 317,448 rubles. Sensitivity analysis showed that the decrease
and increase of the cost of capecitabine and bevacizumab in 20% for XELOX/XELOX
+ BV does not exceed the cost of regimes FOLFOX/FOLFOX4 + BV. CONCLUSIONS: From the pharmacoeconomic point of view, the most optimal is the use of
XELOX and XELOX + BV regimes because of lower costs for neutropenia treatment,
associated with an increased risk of infectious complications, as well as with a large
number of hospitalization days.
PCN88
COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS OF CANCER TREATMENTS IN
SOUTH OF IRAN
Ahmad Kiadaliri A1, Bastani P2, Hatam N3, Ahmadloo N3
1
Lund University, Malmo, Sweden; 2Iran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran; 3Shiraz
University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, Iran
OBJECTIVES: To calculate the incremental cost-effectiveness of docetaxel-adriamicine-cyclophosphamide (TAC) against adriamicine- cyclophosphamide-5 flourouracil
(FAC) in treatment of breast cancer in south of Iran. METHODS: A double blind
study was applied on a cohort of 100 patients suffering from breast cancer with nodepositive in the radiotherapy center of Namazi Hospital, Shiraz, Iran. The European
organization for research and treatment of cancer questionnaire (EORTC QLQ-C30)
was used for the measuring of quality of life at the first and last session of chemotherapy cycle. Third-party payer perspective was applied for costing side of evaluation.
At last, two-way sensitivity analysis was used for ensuring the robustness of the results.
A268
RESULTS: In spite of the same quality of life score at the first session of chemotherapy
(74.5 out of 100), after finishing the chemotherapy cycle, patients in TAC arm had
the lower score of QOL (64 in TAC vs. 68 in FAC) and higher range of toxicity and
their medical costs were higher as well (the average costs in TAC was 391,176,968.2
Rials vs. 2,427,775.2 in FAC). ICER was negative that showed the dominant result
for FAC comparing with TAC. CONCLUSIONS: It seems that because of the short
horizon of the study, TAC regimen had the worse impact on the patient’s quality of
life during the chemotherapy cycle because of more side effects than FAC. It is believed
that there is need for other studies with longer time horizons and specific attention to
the effects of these treatments on survival and quality of life.
PCN89
PROJECTING THE POTENTIAL COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF A BREAST
CANCER VACCINE IN COMPARISON TO OTHER STANDARD
TREATMENTS: A DECISION ANALYTIC MODEL
Patel TB, Zaveri VB, Gohil NS, McGhan WF
University of the Sciences in Philadelphia, Philadelphia, PA, USA
OBJECTIVES: Breast cancer is known to be one of the leading causes of death among
the female population. Preventive measures may provide an economic and outcome
advantage by reducing treatment costs and increasing survival. The objective of this
study was to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of a breast cancer vaccine versus current
standard treatments. METHODS: TreeAge software was used to calculate the costeffectiveness. a decision tree was constructed for different probabilities of success and
failure for the vaccine versus standard treatment. Costs and outcomes (life-years saved)
ranges were obtained from published clinical trials. The vaccine effectiveness was
projected from animal studies, with human clinical trials expected within a year. The
range of effectiveness of the vaccine was considered between 30% and 90% with a
baseline at 80%. The costs included for standard treatments ranged from $20,000 to
$45,000 and the cost of the vaccine was assumed at $450 for three doses; therefore,
the cost for vaccine ranged from $300 to $2000 depending on the number of doses.
The incremental cost-effectiveness ratios were calculated from the range of costs and
outcomes. Sensitivity analyses were performed to determine the robustness of the
findings. RESULTS: Vaccination was found to be a potentially cost-effectiveness
option with an ICER of 2384.146 relative to standard treatment. The incremental
effectiveness was 8.2 life-years saved. The highest cost-effectiveness of the vaccine was
at 90% success and a cost of not more than $1000 per individual. Sensitivity analyses
indicated that the vaccine remained cost-effective over the range of model parameters.
CONCLUSIONS: The breast cancer vaccine was projected to be the most costeffective treatment option in this analysis. It is expected that better screening for breast
cancer vaccine patient candidates will be available in the future.
PCN90
COMPARATIVE RETROSPECTIVE NON-RANDOMIZED
PHARMACOECONOMIC TRIAL OF EFFICIENCY AND SAFETY OF USE
OF PACLITAXELS (PACLITAXEL-LENS OR TAXOL) IN A MONOMODE
FOR 2ND LINE OF TREATMENT OF METASTATIC BREAST CANCER
PATIENTS
Pavlysh A1, Kolbin A2, Livshits R2, Koroleva O2, Manikhas A1, Tkachenko E1,
Atrashevskaya N1, Demicheva N1
1
Saint Petersburg City Clinical Oncology Dispensary, Saint Petersburg, Russi; 2Saint
Petersburg State University, Saint Petersburg, Russia
OBJECTIVES: For the first time in a modern Russian economic conditions, it has been
made pharmacoeconomics trial (PE) uses Russian generic of paclitaxel (Paclitaxel-Lens
[PL]) in comparison with original drug (Taxol (T)) at chemotherapy (ChT) in a
monomode for 2nd line of metastatic breast cancer (MBC) in real clinical practice.
METHODS: It has been provided retrospective comparative nonrandomized clinical
trial which have been included 70 patients for 35 patients of each group (PL or T)
after analysis of 148 case records. RESULTS: At the analysis of effectively treatment
MBC in group of the patients who have received T, the partial remission (PR, 28.5%
against 10%) statistically significantly has been more often reached. At the analysis
of safety, it has been shown that in group of the patients who have received PL,
statistically significantly has been more often fixed hepatotoxicity (23.3% against
3.8%) and an anemia (19.2% against 3.5%). In group of the patients who have
received T, statistically significantly has been more often fixed arthralgia/ myalgia
(29.8% against 0%). Total direct costs (DC) in group of patients with T also there
were above, than in group of PL, namely $10,727 and $9765 accordingly. Calculation
of efficiency of expenses has shown that treatment of MBC by T more expensive and
more effective, than treatment by PL. CONCLUSIONS: Thus, as a result of research,
it has been established that: 1) Applying of T was more (from 7% to 11%) expensive,
than PL, but gave the PR is much more often; 2) The alternative scenario and the
sensitivity analysis shown to choose conditions when application of compared drugs
will be economically more expedient; and 3) Thus, it is necessary to take into consideration, what application of PL was more often accompanied by hepatotoxicity and
anemia, like arthralgia/ myalgia after using of T.
13th Euro Abstracts
PCN91
BEVACIZUMAB + PACLITAXEL + CARBOPLATIN (BEV + PAC + CAR) VS.
PEMETREXED + CISPLATIN (PEM + CIS) IN ADENOCARCINOMA
NON-SQUAMOUS NON-SMALL CELL LUNG CANCER (NSCLC): A
COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS FROM A POLISH PUBLIC PAYER’S
PERSPECTIVE
Kawalec P1, Badurak P2, Denisso T2, Jastrzebski D3, Marek M4, Pluzanski A2, Szczesna A5,
Szkultecka-Debek M6, Russel-Szymczyk M6
1
Jagiellonian University, Kraków, Poland; 2Maria Sklodowska-Curie Memorial Cancer Center
and Institute, Warsaw, Poland; 3Medical University of Silesia, Zabrze, Poland; 4Leszczynski
Memorial Hospital, Katowice, Poland; 5Mazovian Center of Lung Diseases and Tuberculosis,
Otwock, Poland; 6Roche Polska Sp. z o.o., Warsaw, Poland
OBJECTIVES: To determine and compare the cost-effectiveness of Bev + Pac + Car
versus Pem + Cis regimens in the treatment of patients with adenocarcinoma nonsquamous NSCLC from a Polish Public Payer’s perspective. METHODS: Efficacy and
safety of 15 mg of bevacizumab + 200 mg/m2 of paclitaxel + 6 mg/mL/min of carboplatin versus 500 mg/m2 of pemetrexed and 75 mg/m2 of cisplatin was assessed based
on a systematic review performed for both therapies according to evidence-based
medicine principles. A cost-effectiveness analysis was performed with a lifetime (5
years) horizon and the National Health Fund perspective. a three state (progressionfree, progression, death) Markov model was developed. Costs of 1st and 2nd line
therapy, administration and monitoring, adverse events treatment, and palliative care
were included. Sensitivity analyses testing the influence of length of time horizon,
probability of progression, utilities, discounting rates, cisplatin dose, and the length
and costs of 2nd line therapy were performed. RESULTS: Bev + Pac + Car results in
0.21 life-years gained per patient when compared to Pem + Cis in the treatment of
patients with adenocarcinoma non-squamous NSCLC. The additional cost per patient
was 18,840 pln (1 EURO = 4.1PLN) over patient’s lifetime when Bev + Pac + Car
was used instead of Pem + Cis regimen. The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER)
was at an acceptable 91,216 pln. The sensitivity analyses demonstrated that the duration of 2nd line treatment (assumption of 2nd line treatment continuation for more
than six cycles) considerably influenced the ICER (1,198 pln). Other sensitivity analyses confirmed the base-case results, proving conclusions’ robustness. CONCLUSIONS:
Based on this modeling analysis, 1st line Bev + Pac + Car therapy is a clinically superior
and cost-effective treatment for patients with adenocarcinoma non-squamous NSCLC
when compared to chemotherapies such as Pem + Cis.
PCN92
PHARMACOEPIDEMIOLOGICAL AND PHARMACOECONOMIC
EVALUATION OF OXALIPLATIN IN PALLIATIVE CHEMOTHERAPY OF
METASTATIC COLORECTAL CANCER (MCCR)
Kolbin A1, Orlova R2, Pavlysh A3, Llivshits M1
1
Saint Petersburg State University, Saint Petersburg, Russia; 2Saint Petersburg Medical
Academy of Postgraduate Education, Saint Petersburg, Russia; 3Saint Petersburg City Clinical
Oncology Dispensary, Saint Petersburg, Russia
The problem of original drugs substitution on generics presents in the Russian clinical
practice due to rational expenditures allocation. Pharmaceutical bioequivalence of
generic should be confirmed by therapeutic one. Only after such kind of confirmation,
the mentioned substitution could be made in different segments of doctors’ practice
especially in anticancer chemotherapy. OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the clinical-economic interchangeability of the original oxaliplatin Eloxatine (EL) and local generic
Exorum (EX) in the chemotherapy of mCCR. METHODS: The retrospective clinicaleconomic analysis of FOLFOX scheme for chemotherapy of mCCR with EL and EX
in the real practice has been performed. Fifty case histories (23 with using of EL,
27—EX, was used nomogram of Altman’s) were studied. The calculation of direct
cost and cost-effectiveness ratio (CER) based on “partial regress + stabilization”
parameter no less than 80% has been performed. RESULTS: For achievement of equal
efficacy EL had less number of chemotherapy cycles and total dosage compared with
EX (5,0 and 7,3; 670 mg and 900 mg, respectively). Adverse effects were more frequent in EX versus EL (59 and 38, respectively) and caused additional costs and
prolonged hospitalization (9 days/patient compared to EL group). The utilitarian EX
program cost per patient was less compared to EL by 7,7%. In the same time, CER
calculated with total costs due to side effects treatment was practically equal (difference is 1,6% only). Cost prognosis for equal efficacy results with EL using is less by
28,6% versus EX. The alternative scenario has confirmed the cinical-economic added
value of EL. CONCLUSIONS: The change of original EL for generic EX in FOLFOX
scheme for mCCR has no economic advantages. EL substitution leads to increased
number of chemotherapy cycles, higher dose of oxaliplatin, higher rate of adverse
effects, and higher costs.
PCN93
COST-MINIMIZATION ANALYSIS OF XELOX (CAPECITABINE +
OXALIPLATIN) VERSUS FOLFOX-4 (5-FU/LV + OXALIPLATIN) AS
ADJUVANT TREATMENT IN STAGE III COLON CANCER UNDER THE
BRAZILIAN PRIVATE PAYER PERSPECTIVE
Prolla G1, Borges LG2, Santos E2
1
Hospital Mãe de Deus, Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil; 2Roche Brazil, São Paulo, SP, Brazil
BACKGROUND: Colorectal cancer is the third leading cancer worldwide (INCA)
with nearly 1.2 million cases and about 630,000 deaths expected in 2007 (ACS 2007).
In Brazil, it is estimated 28,110 new cases in 2010 (INCA 2010). For patients with
stage III colon cancer, the benefits from fluorouracil (5-FU)-based adjuvant chemo-
13th Euro Abstracts
therapy are well established and the combination regimens including a fluoropyrimidine + oxaliplatin are the current standard of care. OBJECTIVES: To compare costs
of XELOX with FOLFOX-4 as adjuvant treatment for stage III colon cancer under
Brazilian private payer perspective. METHODS: Both regimens demonstrated to significantly improve disease-free survival when compared to 5-FU/LV for adjuvant
treatment of stage III colon cancer (MOSAIC and XELOXA trials). In the absence of
head-to-head trials comparing both regimens, an indirect comparison using Butcher
approach (Butcher 1997) was conducted. No difference was found regarding efficacy
of regimens (XELOX vs. FOLFOX-4 in disease-free survival: HR 1.03, 95% CI 0.81,
1.29); therefore, a cost-minimization analysis was used. a modified Delphi panel
identified local practices to manage severe adverse events (SAEs) of each scheme. Only
direct costs were considered for a patient with 1.7 m2. Drug prices were obtained from
official public sources (Kairos Magazine, April 2010) and administration costs from
medical society physicians fee list (CBHPM2008, v.5). Time horizon was 6 months
according to clinical recommendations: eight cycles for XELOX and 12 for FOLFOX4. Discounting was not applied. RESULTS: XELOX is less costly than FOLFOX-4
($Brz49,862 vs. $Brz57,846). XELOX has higher acquisition costs which is offset by
savings in medical resource utilization. Mean acquisition costs for XELOX were
R$4185 higher than with FOLFOX-4, but costs to treat SAEs and administration costs
were $Brz12,169 higher for FOLFOX-4. One-way sensitivity analysis confirmed the
robustness of results. CONCLUSIONS: Findings suggest XELOX as a cost-saving
therapy for the adjuvant setting under the private payer perspective in Brazil when
compared to FOLFOX-4.
PCN94
CAPECITABINE + OXALIPLATIN (XELOX) VS. 5-FU/LV + OXALIPLATIN
(FOLFOX4) IN THE ADJUVANT TREATMENT OF PATIENTS WITH
COLON CANCER (ACC): COMPARISON OF DIRECT MEDICAL AND
SOCIETAL (INDIRECT) COSTS
Winterhalder R1, Delmore G2, van Lier M3, Urspruch A4, Hieke K5
1
Luzerner Kantonsspital, Luzern, Switzerland; 2Kantonsspital Thurgau, Frauenfeld, Switzerland;
3
Roche Pharma (Schweiz), Reinach, Switzerland; 4F. Hoffmann-La Roche Ltd., Basel,
Switzerland; 5NEOS Health AG, Binningen, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: FOLFOX4 has been the chemotherapy of choice for patients with stage
III colon cancer. Recently, the international NO16968 study reported results confirming the efficacy of XELOX in this setting, and evidence suggests that both regimens
have at least equivalent efficacy. Therefore, medical and societal resource utilization
are important factors for providers, patients, and payers. The objective of this analysis
was to compare total costs required to treat an average aCC patient with either
XELOX or FOLFOX4 in Switzerland. METHODS: In the absence of a direct comparison, detailed medical resource utilization (MRU) data collected for XELOX from
study NO16,968 (aCC) and for FOLFOX4 from study NO16,966 (metastatic colorectal cancer) were analyzed. The FOLFOX4 regimens are identical in both indications;
therefore, MRU data from NO16,966 were considered valid proxies. In addition to
direct MRU (chemotherapy, hospitalizations due to adverse events [AEs], ambulatory
encounters, AE medication, and central venous access [CVA] placements), patient time
and travel costs for hospitalizations, ambulatory encounters, and drug administration
were estimated. Unit costs were derived from official tariffs (Spezialitätenliste, Tarmed
2010 for drug costs and physician services), official statistics (hospital cost, mean
hourly salary) and tax guidelines (travel costs). Total costs while on treatment (24
weeks) for an average patient with aCC were compared. RESULTS: On average,
XELOX saved CHF 11,471 per patient versus FOLFOX4. CHF 8883 resulted from
savings in direct costs, mainly driven by savings in drug administration (CHF 9312)
and CVA placements (CHF 1730). Savings in patient time and travel costs amounted
to CHF 2588. CONCLUSIONS: XELOX appears to be cost-saving versus FOLFOX4
in aCC from both a Swiss health-care system and the societal perspective, assuming
equivalent efficacy for the two regimens. Considering the high incidence of colon
cancer in Switzerland, substantial overall savings may be realized by routine use of
XELOX in this indication.
PCN95
A MARKOV MODEL TO ESTIMATE THE COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF
OMACETAXINE IN CHRONIC MYELOID LEUKEMIA
Brereton NJ1, Batty AJ1, Foy CF2, McCormick AL2
1
BresMed Health Solutions, Sheffield, UK; 2Complete Market Access, Macclesfield, UK
OBJECTIVES: In patients with chronic myeloid leukemia (CML), first-line treatment
with imatinib therapy is beneficial. In cases of imatinib failure, second-generation
tyrosine kinase inhibitors (TKIs) are recommended. Omacetaxine has a novel mode
of action and acts independently of TKIs; thus, it may have therapeutic advantages
for patients who have developed resistance to TKI therapy and have no available
treatment options. The objective was to develop a health economic model to estimate
the cost-effectiveness of omacetaxine in the treatment of CML. METHODS: A costutility Markov model was developed to capture the progression of CML and treatment
effects. The model was developed from the perspective of the French health-care
system. Patients entered the model treated either with omacetaxine or standard care,
in one of three phases: chronic, accelerated, or blast phase, having failed on imatinib
therapy (through resistance or intolerance). Patients then moved to states of response,
no response, or death. Survival estimates for nonresponding and responding patients
were taken from studies 202 and 203. These were extrapolated using parametric curve
fits to estimate survival beyond the end of the trial. Resource use was based on the
trial and from the expert opinion of a panel of French clinicians. Unit costs and utilities
A269
were elicited from the literature. One-way and probabilistic sensitivity analyses (PSA)
were performed. RESULTS: The deterministic results demonstrated that treatment
with omacetaxine is cost-effective at a threshold of c30,000. Sensitivity analysis
showed that results were most sensitive to cost of omacetaxine, utility score, and
survival benefit. PSA results showed that the model was sufficiently robust to parameter uncertainty. CONCLUSIONS: The analysis demonstrated that omacetaxine is
cost-effective in the treatment of CML patients who are resistant to TKI therapy and
have no available treatment options.
PCN96
A UK COST-UTILITY ANALYSIS OF PACLITAXEL ALBUMIN COMPARED
TO SOLVENT-BASED PACLITAXEL MONOTHERAPY AND DOCETAXEL
MONOTHERAPY FOR PRETREATED METASTATIC BREAST CANCER
(MBC)
McLeod EJ1, Lloyd A1, Samyshkin Y1, Prunièras F2, Canney P3
1
IMS Health, London, UK; 2ABRAXIS BIOSCIENCE, Paris, France; 3Beatson West of Scotland
Cancer Centre, Glasgow, UK
OBJECTIVES: Paclitaxel albumin (P-A, Abraxane®) is nanoparticle albumin-bound
paclitaxel formulated without use of irritant solvents that are responsible for many of
the hypersensitivity and dose-limiting adverse events (AEs). Previous research has
compared its cost-effectiveness to solvent-based paclitaxel (S-P) and docetaxel (DOC)
in a cohort of patients with mixed treatment history. This study examined P-A’s costeffectiveness for pretreated MBC, the population specified in the European license.
METHODS: A Markov model with progression-free, progressed, and mortality states
was developed to estimate costs and outcomes over 5 years from a UK NHS perspective. Included from published sources were the costs at 2009 prices of drugs, administration, AEs, and supportive care. Published utility weights were applied to health
states to estimate the impact of response, disease progression, and AEs on qualityadjusted life-years (QALYs). Clinical data for pretreated patients receiving P-A
260 mg/m2 3-weekly (q3w) and S-P 175 mg/m2 q3w were from Gradishar (2005).
Using Bucher’s methods, an indirect comparison with Jones (2005) provided estimates
of clinical parameters for DOC 100 mg/m2 q3w. Weibull extrapolations of survival
data generated transition probabilities. RESULTS: Compared to S-P, P-A achieved an
extra 0.164 QALYs, 0.263 life-years, and incurred additional costs of £4,137 per
patient treated. This translated to an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio of £25,209/
QALY. P-A saved £697 when compared to DOC, with a marginal QALY gain of
0.0037 and no life-expectancy divergence. Probabilistic sensitivity analysis versus
DOC indicated a 61% likelihood of P-A satisfying a willingness-to-pay threshold of
£30,000/QALY. Both comparisons were sensitive to drug costs and survival estimates.
Accounting for potential drug wastage did not influence interpretation of results from
either comparison. CONCLUSIONS: The model found that P-A gave better outcomes
than S-P or DOC and was cost-effective compared to both interventions. This
depended upon greater efficacy than S-P and a more favorable safety profile than
DOC.
PCN97
A COST-UTILITY ANALYSIS ON THE USE OF TRASTUZUMAB +
ANASTROZOLE COMPARED TO LAPATINIB + LETROZOLE, LETROZOLE
MONOTHERAPY OR ANASTROZOLE MONOTHERAPY IN THE
TREATMENT OF HER2+/HORMONE RECEPTOR POSITIVE (HR+)
METASTATIC BREAST CANCER (MBC) FROM THE PERSPECTIVE OF
THE UK NATIONAL HEALTH SERVICE (NHS)
McNamara S1, Moore L1, Ray J2
1
Roche Products Limited, Welwyn Garden City, Hertfordshire, UK; 2F. Hoffmann-La Roche
Ltd., Basel, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: To assess the cost-effectiveness of trastuzumab/anastrozole compared
to lapatinib/letrozole, anastrazole, and letrozole for the treatment of HER2+/HR+
mBC patients in whom treatment with an aromatase inhibitor is suitable from a UK
NHS perspective. METHODS: An area under the curve model based on the TAnDEM
(trastuzumab/anastrozole vs. anastrozole) and EGF30008 (lapatinib/letrozole vs. letrozole) RCTs and the findings of a mixed treatment comparison (MTC) conducted on
endocrine treatments in HR+ mBC was developed in Excel. a rank preserving structural
failure time (RPSFT) model was utilized to account for the 70% crossover in TAnDEM.
In the base-case, no attempt to account for the sizeable additional imbalance in 2nd line
chemotherapy was made. The anastrozole PFS and RPSFT-adjusted OS curves from
TAnDEM were utilized as a baseline from which to implement the required indirect
comparisons under the assumption of an AI “class effect” (as suggested by expert clinical
opinion and confirmed by the MTC). The present value of all costs and health outcomes
attributable to each treatment option were calculated and the efficiency frontier defined.
Extensive deterministic and probabilistic sensitivity analyses were conducted. RESULTS:
Anastrozole is dominated by letrozole. Lapatinib/letrozole is extendedly dominated by
a combination of letrozole monotherapy and trastuzumab/anastrozole. Trastuzumab/
anastrozole produced the most QALYs of all regimens. Trastuzumab/anastrozole and
letrozole define the efficiency frontier with a base-case ICER of £54,336/QALY. The
use of the utility values derived from EGF30008 caused this ICER to fall to £44,497/
QALY. CONCLUSIONS: Lapatinib/letrozole is not a cost-effective use of finite NHS
resources at any cost-effectiveness threshold. As no attempt was made to account for
the imbalance of 2nd line chemotherapy in TAnDEM (31% in anastrozole vs. 8% for
trastuzumab/anastrozole) and relatively conservative utility values were used within
the model the base-case ICER of trastuzumab/anastrozole vs. letrozole (£54,336/
QALY) should be regarded as conservative and the true ICER likely lies below
£50,000/QALY gained.
A270
PCN98
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF A EUROPEAN COMMUNITY-BASED
INTERVENTION: “10,000 STEPS GHENT”
De Smedt D1, De Cocker K1, Cardon G1, De Bourdeaudhuij I1, Annemans L2
1
Ghent University, Gent, Belgium; 2Ghent University—Brussels University, Ghent, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: Physical inactivity is linked with inverse health effects and chronic
disease. The aim of this study was to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of the European
community-based project “10,000 Steps Ghent.” a published comparative controlled
trial showed that the intervention resulted in a significant decrease in sedentary time
and a significant increase in step counts (896 steps/day) and self-reported walking time
(66 minutes/week). METHODS: A Markov model, with a time horizon of 20 years
and a cycle length of 1 year was designed in Excel to estimate the development of
diabetes, cardiovascular events, and colorectal cancer. All individuals start in a healthstate free of events. The model transitions were age dependent and based on epidemiological data. The effect of the intervention was based on published relative risk
reductions (RRR) related to increased walking time. Costs (from a public payer perspective) and utility decrements related to events were obtained from published literature. To assess the impact of the uncertainty of the parameters on incremental costs
and QALYs one-way sensitivity analyses and a Monte Carlo analysis were performed.
RESULTS: Implementing the community-based program increased average QALYs
with 0.14 to 12.50 QALY and decreased the total costs with approximately c490 to
c2749. Hence, the intervention program was dominant. One-way sensitivity analyses
indicated that relative risk reductions had the most pronounced effect on the incremental QALYs and costs, however without changing the conclusion of dominance.
The results of the Monte Carlo analysis were favorable as well and the intervention,
based on 5000 simulations, remained dominant. CONCLUSIONS: The communitybased “10,000 Steps Ghent” campaign is a dominant intervention. Sensitivity analyses
have proved the robustness of the results; hence, implementing this intervention on a
population-based level could lead to improved health outcomes and reduced costs.
PCN99
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF IMATINIB AS ADJUVANT TREATMENT FOR
RESECTED GASTROINTESTINAL STROMAL TUMORS (GIST) VERSUS
BEST SUPPORTIVE CARE: CANADIAN PERSPECTIVE
El Ouagari K1, Pawar V2, Coombs J3, Rubin J2
1
Novartis Pharmaceuticals Canada, Dorval, QC, Canada; 2i3 Innovus, Medford, MA, USA;
3
Novartis, Florham Park, NJ, USA
OBJECTIVES: Clinical studies have highlighted the high risk of recurrence following
complete resection of primary GIST. Published data from the phase III (ACOSOG
Z9001) trial have demonstrated significant clinical benefit with adjuvant imatinib
versus placebo with respect to recurrence-free survival (RFS 98% vs. 83% at 1 year).
We conducted a health economic evaluation for imatinib as adjuvant therapy for GIST
that can be used to support this indication. METHODS: A Markov model was used
to project lifetime outcomes and costs for patients who undergo complete gross resection of primary GIST. Cost-effectiveness was measured in terms of the incremental
cost per quality-adjusted life-year (QALY) gained with the addition of imatinib. Probabilities of disease recurrence, resource use, utilities, and costs were derived from
ACOSOG Z9001 trial and other secondary sources. Results were generated under
three scenarios regarding the treatment duration with imatinib: 1-year, 3-year, and
continuous treatment with imatinib. RESULTS: Adding imatinib was projected to
result in a gain of 0.745, 1.538, and 5.180 QALYs assuming 1-year, 3-year, and
continuous treatment scenarios, respectively. These clinical benefits of imatinib are
obtained at an additional expected per-patient lifetime cost of $30,042, $81,125, and
$345,360 assuming 1-year, 3-year, and continuous treatment scenarios, respectively.
The incremental cost per QALY gained with imatinib was therefore $40,328, $52,760,
and $66,669 assuming 1-year, 3-year, and continuous treatment scenarios, respectively. Deterministic sensitivity analyses showed the results to be robust with respect
to variations in assumptions and estimates. The probability that imatinib is costeffective given a threshold value of $100,000 per QALY was over 98% in all scenarios.
CONCLUSIONS: Results of this evaluation suggest that, from a Canadian health-care
system perspective, imatinib is cost-effective and represents good value for the money
according to currently accepted standards of cost-effectiveness.
PCN100
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF GEFITINIB VERSUS DOUBLET
CHEMOTHERAPY IN FIRST-LINE TREATMENT OF NON-SMALL CELL
LUNG CANCER (NSCLC) IN SWEDEN
Jacob J, Henriksson M, Brattström D
AstraZeneca Nordic MC, Södertälje, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: The IPASS study (NCT00322452) showed that in patients with EGFR
mutation-positive tumors (EGFRm+), gefitinib significantly increased progression-free
survival (PFS) compared with doublet chemotherapy, reducing the risk of progression
by 52% (HR 0.48, 95% CI 0.36 to 0.64, P < 0.001) and increasing median PFS by
3.2 months (9.5 months vs. 6.3 months) for the first-line treatment of advanced nonsmall cell lung cancer (NSCLC). The aim of the study reported here was to evaluate
the cost-effectiveness of a clinically relevant treatment strategy with gefitinib based on
data from IPASS. The strategy with gefitinib involves EGFR mutation testing prior to
treatment, followed by selective gefitinib treatment of EGFRm+ patients and doublet
chemotherapy for EGFRm- patients and patients with unknown mutation status, and
is compared to treating all patients with doublet chemotherapy without mutation
testing. METHODS: A Markov model was developed to integrate IPASS study data
13th Euro Abstracts
with external data on costs and quality of life. The model estimated costs and QALYs
from a lifetime horizon for each treatment strategy. The key clinical data inputs were
event rates of PFS and overall survival data. Other important parameters, e.g., prevalence of EGFRm+, cost of EGFR-diagnostics, resource utilization, and utility estimates
were retrieved from the literature. RESULTS: The test and treat strategy, including
gefitinib, was associated with a QALY gain of 0.0116 at an incremental cost of c300
yielding a cost per QALY gained of c25,900. CONCLUSIONS: This cost-effectiveness
analysis of the IPASS study demonstrates that testing patients for EGFR status, followed by gefitinib treatment for EGFR m+ patients is a cost-effective option compared
to treating all patients with doublet chemotherapy in a Swedish setting.
PCN101
COST-UTILITY ANALYSIS OF DASATINIB AS A SECOND-LINE
TREATMENT IN THE CHRONIC PHASE OF CHRONIC MYELOID
LEUKAEMIA IN RUSSIA
Kuznetzov S1, Mungapen LJ2, Samyshkin Y2, Jakouloff DE3, Sbarigia U4, van Baardewijk M4
1
Haematology Research Centre, Moscow, Russia; 2IMS Health, London, UK; 3BMS, Moscow,
Russia; 4BMS, Braine l’Alleud, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of dasatinib 100 mg once daily in
second-line therapy for chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) patients in the chronic phase
(CP) resistant to imatinib 400 mg compared with imatinib 800 mg and nilotinib
800 mg in Russia. METHODS: A Markov cost-utility model was developed to estimate lifetime outcomes and resource use reflecting treatment practice for CML patients
in Russia. Treatment efficacy, disease progression, and rates of adverse events in the
model were based on published multicenter randomized controlled trials. RESULTS:
Dasatinib appeared to be dominant over imatinib and nilotinib in CP-CML in the
Russian setting. Incremental life expectancies were 0.17 years and 0.26 years when
comparing dasatinib with imatinib and nilotinib, respectively; quality-adjusted lifeyears (QALYs) gains were of 0.18 and 0.22 QALY versus imatinib and nilotinib,
respectively. The life-years and QALY gains on dasatinib treatment were due to a
larger proportion of patients who achieved complete cytogenic response (CCyR).
Mean cost saving per patient over a lifetime horizon with dasatinib were Rubles (RUB)
1,364,220 versus imatinib and RUB 778,621 versus nilotinib. Limitations of the model
include a lack of direct comparative efficacy data at licensed doses, which precluded
formal indirect comparison. CONCLUSIONS: Dasatinib was a dominating strategy,
resulting in outcome gains (greater life expectancy and greater quality-adjusted life
expectancy) and cost saving compared both to nilotinib and high-dose imatinib in
CP-CML patients. Expanding access to new tyrosine kinase inhibitors for the treatment of CP-CML in Russia would ensure a greater choice of modern and effective
therapies.
PCN102
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF DIGITAL MAMMOGRAPHY IN A BREAST
CANCER POPULATION-BASED SCREENING PROGRAM
Comas M1, Arrospide A2, Mar J2, Roman R1, Sala M1, Hernandez C1, Castells X
1
Hospital del Mar-IMIM, CIBER de Epidemiología y Salud Pública (CIBERESP), Barcelona,
Spain; 2Hospital Alto Deba, Mondragon, Spain
OBJECTIVES: The introduction of digital mammography presents benefits at the
technological. However, there are doubts about its impact on the effectiveness of
breast cancer screening. The aim of this study was to analyze the cost-effectiveness of
the introduction of digital mammography in a population-based breast cancer screening program. METHODS: A discrete-event simulation model was implemented including the processes under a breast cancer screening program and the natural history of
breast cancer. The screening events included: invitation (biennial) of the target population (women aged 50–69 years), participation, screening test, confirmatory tests after
a positive mammography result, cancer diagnosis, and treatment. Natural history of
breast cancer included the following health states: no cancer, preclinical (nonsymptomatic) cancer, clinical (or symptomatic) cancer, and death. Natural history was
modeled as time until a change of health state, and health states were managed using
attributes in order to condition the sensitivities and specificities of the tests to the
current health state of the woman. Interval cancers were also detected according to
the health state. Digital and analogical mammography had the same sensitivity, but
different specificities were applied according to type of mammography and also initial
or successive screening. Cost-effectiveness was calculated under a 20-year screening
scenario and five simulations. RESULTS: Simulation started with a target population
of 28,020 women. Other 29,552 women were enrolled in the target population during
the simulated 20 years. This population resulted in 56,136 screening mammograms.
The number confirmatory tests needed was 1864 under analogical mammography and
1724 under digital screening. Screen-detected cancers were 344 with analogical screening and 312 with digital screening. The overall ICER was c349.14. CONCLUSIONS:
Results suggest that population-based breast cancer screening with digital mammography is cost-effective. It does not improve the results of conventional analogical
mammography, but it reduces the cost in confirmatory tests.
PCN103
COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS OF ADDING HPV VACCINATION TO
CERVICAL CANCER SCREENING PROGRAM IN HUNGARY
Vokó Z1, Nagyjanosi L2, Kalo Z1
1
Eötvös Loránd University, Budapest, Hungary; 2Syreon Research Institute, Budapest, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: Despite opportunistic and organized screening, mortality of cervical
cancer is still high in Hungary in international comparison. The study aimed to
13th Euro Abstracts
investigate the cost-effectiveness of including HPV vaccination in the preventive strategy of cervical cancer. METHODS: We developed an interactive Markov model based
on modeling disease progression. Data on prevalences, incidences, test characteristics,
efficacy of vaccination and of cancer treatments, and quality of life of cervical cancer
patients were taken from the scientific literature. Data on the costs of screening and
of cancer treatments were provided by the Hungarian National Health Fund. We
applied 5% discount rate for both cost and utility values. The effect of herd immunity
was taken into account in the model. GDP PPP exchange rate in 2009 was employed
to convert local currency to EUR (1 EUR = 158 HUF). RESULTS: We analyzed the
cost-effectiveness of different scenarios. In case of the most likely scenario to come
through—vaccination at age 12, coverage 80%, vaccine effectiveness against
HPV16/18 (responsible for 72% of cervical cancers caused by HPV) being 95%,
vaccine is efficient for at least 20 years, the effectiveness of the screening program is
not improved radically—the ICER for vaccination was c49,587/QALY compared to
no screening. CONCLUSIONS: As disease burden of cervical cancer is high in
Hungary, including HPV vaccination in the preventive strategy of cervical cancer
would result in a cost-effectiveness ratio below the implicit upper threshold (3× GDP/
capita = c49,986 in PPP).
PCN104
SOCIETAL COST SAVINGS IN METASTATIC NON-SMALL CELL LUNG
CANCER (NSCLC) IN FRANCE
Stanisic S1, Vergnenegre A2, Chouaid C3, Mueller E1, Walzer S4
1
Analytica International Inc., Loerrach, Germany; 2SIME, Limoges, France; 3Hôpital St. Antoine,
Paris, France; 4F. Hoffmann-La Roche Pharmaceuticals AG, Basel, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: Bevacizumab in combination with platinum-based chemotherapy
improves progression-free survival (PFS) over chemotherapy alone in advanced or
metastatic NSCLC. The aim of this analysis was to assess potential cost savings for
society derived from the clinical benefits of bevacizumab-based therapy in metastatic
NSCLC patients returning to work in France. METHODS: Indirect cost calculation
was performed using human capital approach in the population of progression free
metastatic NSCLC patients. Clinical outcomes in terms of PFS from the two bevacizumab phase III trials (Reck et al. 2009, Sandler et al. 2006) were applied to the
incidence cases of nonsquamous metastatic NSCLC patients in France, taking into
account only age groups eligible to work. Clinical experts were consulted to estimate
the percentage of PFS patients who return to work after the induction phase. It was
estimated that 20% of PFS patients, below 55 years of age and with performance
status 0–1 would maintain their prior employment status (60% part time, 40% full
time). Cost savings were analyzed for 1 year and 1.5 year time horizons applying
French labor costs. RESULTS: Indirect cost savings per patient returning to work were
c21,667 at year 1 and c39,001 at year 1.5. a change in employment pattern (40%
part time, 60% full time) led to an approximate 14% increase of savings for both
time horizons (c24,763 at year 1 and c44,573 at year 1.5). a 10% alteration of labor
cost in either direction resulted in cost savings that were 10% higher/lower. CONCLUSIONS: Bevacizumab-based therapy could result in considerable cost savings in
progression-free NSCLC patients. This societal economic benefit adds to the patients’
clinical benefit of increased survival outcomes.
PCN105
COST SAVINGS ASSOCIATED WITH BEVACIZUMAB-BASED THERAPY
IN PATIENTS WITH METASTATIC NON-SMALL CELL LUNG CANCER
(NSCLC) IN GERMANY
Schmidt E1, Bischoff HG2, Heigener DF3, Stanisic S1, Walzer S4
1
Analytica International Inc., Loerrach, Germany; 2Thoraxklinik Heidelberg GmbH, Hedelberg,
Germany; 3Krankenhaus Grosshansdorf, Grosshansdorf, Germany; 4F. Hoffmann-La Roche
Pharmaceuticals AG, Basel, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: First-line treatment of advanced or metastatic NSCLC patients with
bevacizumab demonstrated significantly improved progression-free survival (PFS) when
added to platinum-based chemotherapy (Reck 2009; Sandler 2006). The aim of this
analysis was to investigate whether this clinical benefit would translate into cost savings
due to reduced productivity losses in metastatic NSCLC patients who return to work
while treated with bevacizumab-based therapy in Germany. METHODS: Potential cost
savings were calculated on the basis of reduced productivity losses for patients returning
back to work during PFS periods of 1 and/or 1.5 years, applying the human capital
approach. The percentage of progression-free patients with ECOG performance status
0 and 1 was derived from the two bevacizumab phase III trials. Epidemiologic data as
well as country-specific employment rates were applied stepwise to estimate the metastatic NSCLC patient population eligible to work and employed at diagnosis. It was
assumed that 20% of progression-free patients would return to work after the induction
phase while maintaining their prior employment status (40% full time). Cost savings
related to productivity losses were calculated by applying German labor cost data to the
derived population of interest. Results were weighted according to prescribing patterns
of bevacizumab combination regimens (bevacizumab/cisplatin/gemcitabine or bevacizumab/carboplatin/paclitaxel). Sensitivity analyses were performed for employment patterns and labor cost. RESULTS: Mean cost savings were c21,171 at year 1 and c38,107
at year 1.5 per progression-free patient returning to work in Germany. a change in
employment pattern (60% full time) led to an approximate 14% increase of savings for
both time horizons (c24,195 at year 1 and c43,551 at year 1.5). a 10% alteration of
labor cost in either direction resulted in cost savings that were 10% higher/lower.
CONCLUSIONS: In addition to its PFS benefits bevacizumab-based therapy could result
in considerable cost savings in progression free metastatic NSCLC patients.
A271
PCN106
INDIRECT COST IN NON-SMALL CELL LUNG CANCER (NSCLC): A
SYSTEMATIC LITERATURE REVIEW
Schmidt E1, Stanisic S1, Neumann M1, Walzer S2
1
Analytica International Inc., Loerrach, Germany; 2F. Hoffmann-La Roche Pharmaceuticals AG,
Basel, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: Novel treatment options for NSCLC patients were shown to improve
survival outcomes. Thus, it is of interest whether published evidence can be found on
work productivity and employment consequences for this patient group and their
informal caregivers, and on respective indirect cost data. METHODS: A systematic
literature search from 1990 onward was performed using 19 bibliographic databases
available via DIMDI (German Institute of Medical Documentation and Information),
supplemented by searches for other publicly available sources such as abstracts at
major health economic and clinical conferences, HTAs, and further gray literature.
RESULTS: So far, published indirect cost data are elusive and rather limited to overall
lung cancer. In lung cancer, indirect cost accounted for the major portion of total
estimated cost, e.g., for Germany 78% (Ruff 2000) to 89% (Weißflog 2001). Indirect
costs per case seem to increase with stage. In an Australian study, overall stage IV
lung cancer patients had direct and indirect costs that were 19% higher than the
average (Bishop 2009). The only indirect cost information on advanced NSCLC was
reported by Romanus (2008) for the United States (mean wage loss per newly diagnosed end-stage IV NSCLC patient was $1697 [$126–$3371] in the first few months
after diagnosis) and by Perrone (2004) for Italy (mean productivity loss per patient
of c60,263). Employment rates of NSCLC patients were reported to be about 13%
of NSCLC stage IIIb or IV, treated with 2nd line chemotherapy in Italy (Gridelli 2007).
In the same population, the informal care given by the principal caregiver was the
main assistance cost item with average 3-month cost of c2368 representing 74% of
total assistance cost. CONCLUSIONS: The indirect cost burden of NSCLC has
scarcely been assessed so far and needs further quantitative investigation, particularly
in view of the use of new treatment options.
PCN107
FIRST-LINE TREATMENT OF METASTATIC NON-SMALL CELL LUNG
CANCER (NSCLC) WITH BEVACIZUMAB AND SOCIETAL COST
SAVINGS IN SPAIN
Stanisic S1, Castro Carpeño JD2, Walzer S3
1
Analytica International Inc., Loerrach, Germany; 2La Paz University Hospital, Madrid, Spain;
3
F. Hoffmann-La Roche Pharmaceuticals AG, Basel, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: Bevacizumab-based therapy as first-line treatment of advanced or
metastatic NSCLC is associated with longer progression-free survival (PFS) when
compared with chemotherapy alone (Sandler et al. 2006; Reck et al. 2009). This study
analyzes the implications of the clinical benefits of bevacizumab-based treatment for
the societal costs in Spain. METHODS: Clinical inputs (PFS) were obtained from two
clinical trials (E4599 and AVAiL) comparing a bevacizumab regimen (combined with
carboplatin/paclitaxel or cisplatin/gemcitabine) with chemotherapy alone. Percentage
of patients returning to work was estimated as 20% of all progression-free patients
with ECOG performance status 0–1 in the age of ≤55 years. PFS percentage was
applied to the incidence estimation for nonsquamous metastatic NSCLC in Spain after
applying specific employment rate. Indirect costs were calculated using the human
capital approach. Spanish labor costs available at EUROSTAT were applied after
inflating to 2009 values. Employment patterns were suggested by the clinical experts
(full time/part time), and were applied to the estimation of patients returning to work.
Time frames for the calculations were 12 months and 18 months. RESULTS: Average
cost saving per progression-free patient was c12,401 at 12 months and c22,322 at 18
months. Sensitivity analysis on changes in employment patterns from 40% full
time/60% part time to 60% full time/40% part time increased cost savings per patient
to c14,173 and c25,511 at 12 and 18 months, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Treatment with bevacizumab-based therapy results in the reduction of productivity losses
due to improved clinical benefits and hereby leads to considerable societal cost savings.
PCN108
SOCIETAL COST SAVINGS ASSOCIATED WITH BEVACIZUMAB-BASED
TREATMENT IN NON-SMALL CELL LUNG CANCER (NSCLC) PATIENTS
IN ITALY
Mueller E1, Nuijten M2, Ravera S3, Stanisic S1, Walzer S4
1
Analytica International Inc., Loerrach, Germany; 2Ars Accessus Medica, LG Jisp, Amsterdam,
The Netherlands; 3Roche S.p.A., Milano, Italy; 4F. Hoffmann-La Roche Pharmaceuticals AG,
Basel, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: The high societal cost of lung cancer derives mostly from productivity
losses associated with premature retirement and premature mortality (Weißflog et al.
2001). Bevacizumab-based therapy is associated with significantly improved progression-free survival (PFS) over chemotherapy alone in patients with advanced or metastatic NSCLC (Reck et al. 2009; Sandler et al. 2006), the most common form of lung
cancer. The aim of this analysis was to assess the potential cost savings for Italy
resulting from a higher number of progression-free metastatic NSCLC patients returning to work while treated with bevacizumab-based therapy. METHODS: Productivity
losses were calculated on the basis of number of days lost due to illness. Country labor
costs and employment rates were taken from EUROSTAT. It was assumed, based on
expert opinion, that 20% of progression-free patients with ECOG performance status
0–1 and eligible to work would go back to their original employment status after the
induction therapy. The percentage of PFS patients was calculated from two clinical
A272
trials (Reck et al. 2009; Sandler et al. 2006) at two time points from baseline: 12 and
18 months. PFS percentages were applied to the incidence estimations for metastatic
NSCLC in Italy. Incidence of nonsquamous metastatic NSCLC was estimated as 37%
of lung cancer incidence retrieved from GLOBOCAN. Sensitivity analysis was conducted varying the percentage of employment pattern (part time/full time) and the
labor cost. RESULTS: Bevacizumab-based therapy resulted in mean savings due to
reduced productivity losses per progression-free patient of c20,089 at 12 months and
c36,160 at 18 months. Changes in employment patterns, from 60% full time/40%
part time to 80% full time/20% part time, increased cost savings per patient to
c22,600 and c40,680 12 and 18 months, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Bevacizumab-based therapy results in societal cost savings due to improved PFS in metastatic
NSCLC patients.
PCN109
COMPARISON OF HOSPITALIZATION BURDEN BETWEEN
METASTATIC AND NON-METASTATIC MELANOMA PATIENTS IN A US
POPULATION
Ray S1, Tunceli O2, Kamat SA2, Ganguli A1
1
Abbott Laboratories, Abbott Park, IL, USA; 2HealthCore, Wilmington, DE, USA
OBJECTIVES: The clinical burden of melanoma patients worsens significantly upon
metastasis. However, little is known regarding how hospitalization burden changes upon
metastasis. This study compares the hospitalization burden between metastatic and
nonmetastatic melanoma patients in a geographically diverse commercially insured US
population. METHODS: Insurance claims (January 1, 2004–June 30, 2009) from the
HealthCore Integrated Research Database was used to identify patients aged ≥18 years
with ≥2 melanoma claims (ICD-9-CM 172.xx, V10.82). Two mutually exclusive cohorts
were formed: 1) metastatic melanoma (MM) cohort with ≥1 claim for metastasis (ICD9-CM 196.x-198.x), and 2) non-MM cohort comprising the remaining patients. The
first claims for MM and melanoma were the index claims for the respective cohorts.
Hospitalization burden was compared between the two cohorts based on four outcomes.
The rate of inpatient visits (per-patient-per-month [PPPM]), and the risk of first hospitalization from index claim, were compared using Poisson and Cox-proportional
hazards regression, respectively. The mean days to first hospitalization and the mean
length of stay (per-patient-per-month [PPPV] ) were compared using generalized linear
models. RESULTS: The study included 17,756 (mean age 54.4 years, 49.69% female)
non-MM patients and 636 (mean age 56.3 years, 41.04% female) MM patients. The
proportion of patients with ≥1 hospitalization was 2.4 times higher in the MM compared
to the non-MM cohort (45% vs. 19%, P < 0.01). Compared to the non-MM cohort,
the MM cohort had: four times higher PPPM inpatient visit rate (0.04 vs. 0.01, P <
0.001), threefold greater risk of first hospitalization (HR: 3.01; 95% CI: 2.61–3.46),
and shorter mean days to first hospitalization (35 days vs. 309 days, P < 0.001). The
mean days of inpatient visit (PPPV) were comparable (3.93 vs. 3.54, P = 0.32). CONCLUSIONS: The hospitalization burden in metastatic melanoma patients is significantly
higher than patients whose melanoma has not progressed to metastasis. Treatments that
improve progression-free survival may reduce this burden.
PCN110
RESOURCE UTILIZATION AND DIAGNOSTIC APPROACHES IN
NON-SMALL-CELL LUNG CANCER (NSCLC) ACROSS EUROPE:
EPICLIN-LUNG STUDY
Vergnenegre A1, Cruciani G2, Thomas M3, Guallar E4, Medina E5, Carrato A6
1
SIME, Limoges, France; 2Ravenna Hospital, Ravenna, Italy; 3Clinic for Thoracic Diseases,
University of Heidelberg, Heidelberg, Germany; 4Welch Center for Prevention,
Epidemiology, and Clinical Research, Baltimore, MD, USA; 5AstraZeneca Pharmaceuticals,
Madrid, Spain; 6Hospital Universitario Ramon y Cajal, Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: The EPICLIN-Lung study aims to provide information on NSCLC
clinical management across European countries. As part of this study, information on
resources associated with the diagnosis of NSCLC from first visit to final diagnosis
across Europe was collected and described. METHODS: The EPICLIN-Lung study
(NCT00831909) is a noninterventional prospective cohort study conducted in
Belgium, France, Germany, Greece, Italy, Portugal, Spain, and Turkey. Patients with
confirmed NSCLC attending a participating clinical department for the first time
between January and March 2009 were included. Information on the approach to
disease diagnosis was recorded at the first visit. Descriptive analyses were performed.
RESULTS: A total of 3500 patients were included in the analysis and 2691 (76.9%)
presented with symptoms at first visit. The mean age (SD) of patients was 64.5 (±
10.5) years. From first visit to final diagnosis, 3124 (89.3%) patients utilized healthcare resources including radiology (51.5%), general practitioner office (37.7%), other
resources (19.3%), oncology (19.0%), surgery (17.9%), emergency room (12.8%),
drug administration facilities (1.6%), and blood-specific resources (0.3%). The application of tests for diagnosis occurred in 96.0% of patients and included laboratory
tests (77.5%), bronchoscopy (73.9%), fine needle aspiration biopsy (26.5%), other
tests (20.5%), and biomarker determination (11.3%). Imaging technology was also
used in disease assessment with scanning the most frequently used technology (88.7%
of patients), followed by x-ray (65.9%), MRI/CT brain scan (39.5%), PET imaging
(34.1%), and other imaging tests (21.5%). CONCLUSIONS: The resource used from
first visit to final diagnosis of NSCLC is not uniform within the patient demographic
across Europe. In particular, biomarker determination was low but bronchoscopy and
laboratory tests were relatively high as was the use of imaging technology. a more
uniform approach in the use of these resources may improve the impact of current
treatments. More specific results will be presented at the meeting.
13th Euro Abstracts
PCN111
HEALTH-CARE RESOURCE UTILIZATION IN ADVANCED MELANOMA:
AN ANALYSIS FROM THE MELODY OBSERVATIONAL STUDY
Lorigan P1, Maio M2, Middleton M3, Testori A4, Bédane C5, van Baardewijk M6, Konto C7,
Dueymes A8, Lebbe C9
1
The Christie NHS Foundation Trust, Manchester, Cheshire, UK; 2University Hospital of
Siena, Siena, Italy; 3Churchill Hospital, Oxford, UK; 4Istituto Europeo di Oncologia, Milan,
Italy; 5Hopital Dupuytren, Limoges, France; 6Bristol-Myers Squibb, Brussels, Belgium;
7
Bristol-Myers Squibb, Paris, France; 8PAREXEL International, Semoy, France; 9Hopital Saint
Louis, Paris, France
OBJECTIVES: We conducted this study to document the health-care resource utilization associated with treatment of patients with advanced melanoma. METHODS:
MELODY (Melanoma treatment patterns and outcomes among patients with unresectable stage III or stage IV disease: a retrospective longitudinal survey) is an observational study managed at 31 centers in France, Italy, and the UK. Eligible patients
had attended at one of the sites with a diagnosis of unresectable stage III or IV melanoma between July 1, 2005 and June 30, 2006; data were retrieved from diagnosis
(no limit date) until 2008. The primary objective was to document the first-line treatments received by patients. Secondary objectives included ascertaining health-care
resource utilization related to up to three lines of treatment (anticancer and supportive
care). Data were collected from patients (n = 776) using a case-report form that
included information on hospitalizations, outpatient visits, hospice care, and adverseevent management (transfusions and concomitant medications including antiemetics
and growth factors). Resource use data were collected from patients (n = 606) that
received systemic treatment outside a clinical trial and/or supportive care. RESULTS:
Twenty-nine percent (176/606) of patients required medical management for treatment-related adverse events and 32% (195/606) were hospitalized while receiving
systemic treatment and/or supportive care with 25% of these having at least four
hospitalizations. The median duration of hospitalization was 17 days, with 25%
spending at least 29 days in hospital (may comprise multiple stays). The hospitalization rate was higher in patients receiving supportive care than those receiving anticancer treatment (86/170; 51% vs. 140/553; 25%), but median duration of hospitalization
was similar (15.0 vs. 14.5 days). Results by line of anticancer therapy and supportive
care will be presented. CONCLUSIONS: These results from MELODY suggest that
the systemic and palliative treatments used to manage advanced melanoma are associated with considerable resource utilization, highlighting the need for more effective
treatment options.
PCN112
PATIENT CHARACTERISTICS, MEDICATION USE, RESOURCE USE AND
MEDICAL COSTS AMONG PATIENTS WITH METASTATIC PANCREATIC
CANCER (MPC)
Oglesby A1, Lage M2
1
Amgen, Thousand Oaks, CA, USA; 2HealthMetrics Outcomes Research, Groton, CT, USA
OBJECTIVES: To examine the patient characteristics, cancer therapy use, and costs
among patients with mPC. METHODS: Subjects in the Marketscan Commerical
Claims and Encounters and Supplemental Medicare databases (July 1, 2004–June 30,
2008) were included if they received a diagnosis of metastastasis (ICD-9 codes:
197.x—199.x) on or after the first occurrence of PC (ICD-9 code: 157.x), had no
claims for other secondary metastases within 6 months of the initial mPC claim (e.g.
index date), and had continuous insurance coverage from 6 months prior through at
least 1 month post index. Outpatient cancer therapies and costs are described from
mPC index until loss to follow-up or end of the data collection period. RESULTS:
There were 4938 subjects with incident mPC included in the analysis. The mean age
at index date was 64.8 years (SD = 11.8) and 53.8% were male. Subjects were followed
an average of 8.3 months post index. Among patients with incident mPC, 53.3%
received outpatient chemotherapy with gemcitabine (76.4%) being the most commonly received therapy. 20.1% of mPC subjects received the targeted agent, erlotinib,
post-index, with 63.6% of its use occurring in combination with gemcitabine. Subjects
who received gemcitabine, received an average of 9.5 doses (SD: 8.8) over 108.9 days
(SD: 129.5). Subjects who received erlotinib, filled an average of 3.9 prescriptions (SD:
4.1) following mPC index. Post-metastases, 84.1% and 73.3% of subjects were hospitalized or visited the ER respectively. The mean cost per month of treating mPC
subjects was $16,192 (SD = $21,639), with the majority of these costs attributed to
inpatient stays (57.8%) and outpatient visits (35.0%). Outpatient cancer therapies
contributed 5.3% of the mean monthly cost post index. CONCLUSIONS: Gemcitabine was the predominant cancer therapy among subjects with incident mPC.
Outpatient cancer drugs constituted a small portion of the total mean monthly cost
of mPC.
13th Euro Abstracts
PCN113
TREATMENT PATTERNS AND OUTCOMES IN THE FRENCH COHORT
OF PATIENTS WITH UNRESECTABLE STAGE III OR STAGE IV
MELANOMA (MELODY STUDY): A RETROSPECTIVE LONGITUDINAL
SURVEY
Bédane C1, Leccia MT2, Sassolas B3, Mansard S4, Guillot B5, Mortier L6, Robert C7,
Saiag P8, Truchetet F9, Oukessou A10, Bregman B10, Lebbé C11
1
Hopital Dupuytren, Limoges, France; 2Hôpital Michallon, La Tronche, France; 3Hôpital
Morvan, Brest, France; 4Hôtel-Dieu, Clermont-Ferrand, France; 5Hôpital St-Eloi, Montpellier,
France; 6Hôpital Claude Huriez, Lille, France; 7Institut Gustave Roussy, Villejuif, France;
8
Hôpital Ambroise Paré, Boulogne-Billancourt, France; 9Hôpital Beauregard, Thionville,
France; 10Bristol-Myers Squibb, Rueil-Malmaison, France; 11Hôpital St-Louis, Paris, France
OBJECTIVES: Melanoma is the first mortality cause by skin cancer. The more
advanced stages prognosis is remaining poor. The MELODY study had as primary
objectives to describe the disease characteristics, treatment modalities/outcomes, and
resources use in patients with unresectable Stage III-Stage IV (UNRSIII-SIV) melanoma. METHODS: MELODY was a three-country (France, Italy, UK) longitudinal,
retrospective, observational survey. In the French cohort, 10 expert dermatology
departments had to register all melanomas seen between July 2005 and June 2006.
The UNRSIII-SIV cases, with minimum 2-month follow-up, were extracted for
detailed description of the disease characteristics, treatments (systemic, local, supportive care), and outcomes and resource use, until May 1, 2008 or death. RESULTS:
In France, 1224 patients (pts) were registered, in which 278 UNRSIII-SIV cases were
extracted. At initial diagnosis, 34/1224 pts (2.8%) were UNRSIII-SIV; 253 pts (91%)
received systemic treatment, while 230 (91%) had a chemotherapy of any line. In
first-line systemic (n = 249), 198 pts (80%) were treated outside clinical trials, in
whom 119 (60%) were on dacarbazine (D) and 35 (18%) on fotemustine (F) monotherapy; complete/partial response was noted for 21 pts (11%), with 2.9-month
median response duration, median of progression-free survival (PFS) was 2.8 months
(2.6; 3.5). In second line, 159 pts (57%) were treated, in whom 139 (87%) outside
of clinical trials, with 75 (54%) on F, and 16 (12%) on D; median PFS was 2.5 months
(2.1; 3.9). In case of systemic treatment/supportive care, there was a median of 20
(11; 30) hospitalization days (13 [6; 22] days for first line systemic) and 3 [1; 6]
outpatient visits (1.5 [1.0; 5.0] for first-line systemic). CONCLUSIONS: In the French
cohort of MELODY, chemotherapy treatments gave modest results in terms of complete/partial response and PFS, at a high cost of resource use, highlighting the unmet
medical need.
CANCER – Patient-Reported Outcomes Studies
PCN114
VISITING DOCTORS WITH MALIGNANT MELANOMA
1
1
1
1
2
Kívés Z , Boncz I , Kriszbacher I , Németh T , Sándor J
1
University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary; 2University of Debrecen, Debrecen, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: The incidence of malignant melanoma has been continuously growing;
however, early identification contributes significantly to its effective treatment. As a
prerequisite, the individual needs to see a specialist soon after the recognition of the
first symptoms. Therefore, the aim of our study is to disclose the factors and patient
attitude behind seeing a specialist in case of skin deformation in order to establish the
method for effective treatment. METHODS: Retrospective cross-sectional study was
carried out among patients in four cities (n = 280) who had been diagnosed with
malignant melanoma within 5 years. Besides sociodemographic data, the questionnaire
focused on the awareness and knowledge of the patient regarding melanoma, on risk
factors, the general attitude of seeing doctors, and that of delaying factors in respect
of melanoma. Single and multiple logistic regression were used in statistical analysis.
RESULTS: After the recognition of skin deformation, only half of the patients visit a
doctor within 1 year. The increase of latency (seeing a specialist more than 3 months
after the incidence of the first symptoms) was four to seven times more frequent among
those who demonstrate anxiety and distress, feel exposed to doctors, lie in the sun
without any control, lack awareness of the disease, and have a lower rate of social
support (P < 0.01). The study also revealed the shortages of primary care (e.g., insufficient examination, lack of information supply). Seeing a specialist in most of the
cases was motivated by external factors. CONCLUSIONS: To estimate the benefit of
developing programs focusing on health behavior and awareness building of the
prevalence and incidence of malignant melanoma instead of facilitating several preventive interventional projects based on the screening of the population.
PCN115
EVALUATION OF SUPPORT SERVICES TO COLORECTAL CANCER
PATIENTS IN MEXICO
Kuo KL1, Encarnacion V2, Monzalvo B2, Hernández-Cadena L3, Oderda G1, Brixner D1,
Zapata L4
1
University of Utah, Salt Lake City, UT, USA; 2Centro Integral Farmacéutico, Col. Cubitos,
Pachuca, Hidalgo, Mexico; 3Instituto Nacional de Salud Pública, Mexico, Cerrada Los Pinos y
Caminera, Cuernavaca Mor., Mexico; 4Guia Mark, Mexico City, D.F., Mexico
OBJECTIVES: To identify the association of sociodemographic, resource use, and
adverse events variables with adherence to measure the return on investment of a
patient education service for colorectal cancer patients taking capecitabine.
A273
METHODS: This was a prospective intervention of government patients in the
country of Mexico of any age, with colorectal cancer and capecitabine treatment. The
intervention group had access to a hot line, booklets, nutritional and psychological
support; control group patients did not. a structured ad-hoc questionnaire applied the
Morisky–Green Test to determine adherence to therapy via follow-up phone calls.
Associations between variables and adherence between intervention group and controls were assessed using chi-square test. Emergency rooms (ER) visits were the economic indicator to establish cost differences between groups. Power analysis was
conducted using PS Power and Sample Size Calculations version 3.0, January 2009.
RESULTS: A total of 220 patients were included in this study (mean age 58.4 [26 to
89] years), 121 intervention patients (48 responded to first call; 70% adherence) and
99 control patients (30 responded to first call; 57% adherence). If the true odds ratio
for adherence in intervention relative to control is 1.86, a power analysis projects
statistical significance with 290 intervention patients and 181 controls to reject the
null hypothesis with a probability (power) of 0.8. The reason for nonadherence “Does
not know administration regime” did show statistical significance (P = 0.019) between
the intervention (10% n = 2) and control group (47% n = 7). For ER visits related to
adverse events, the control group rate was 13.33% (n = 4) versus 2.32% (n = 1) in
the intervention group (P = 0.067). The cost for ER/day is $Mex 1,144.44 (USD
86.82). CONCLUSIONS: These preliminary results indicate that patients who receive
intervention services may have improved adherence to medication and therefore fewer
ER visits and costs. Continued enrollment will be able to determine true
significance.
PCN116
ANALYSIS OF THE EQ-5D QUESTIONNAIRE FOR PATIENTS WITH
ADVANCED HER2-POSITIVE GASTRIC CANCER (HER2+ AGC) BASED
ON THE TRASTUZUMAB FOR GASTRIC CANCER (TOGA) STUDY
Aultman R, Urspruch A
F. Hoffmann-La Roche Ltd., Basel, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: In the ToGA study, patients with HER2+ aGC (n = 584) who received
trastuzumab + chemotherapy achieved significantly improved overall survival compared to patients receiving chemotherapy alone (HR = 0.74 (95% CI 0.60; 0.91, P =
0.0046; van Cutsem et al. 2009). Since published utilities in gastric cancer are rare,
we report results of the EQ-5D analysis from ToGA here, particularly the obtained
utility for progression-free-survival (PFS). METHODS: The EQ-5D was provided to
patients at baseline and every 3 weeks until disease progression. The questionnaire
was completed by the patient prior to any study specific assessment or discussion with
their study care provider. Patients’ EQ-5D responses were scored using UK-tariffs,
according to the guidelines of the EuroQol group. Only fully completed questionnaires
were included. Mixed effects random slope models in SAS v8.2 were developed to
estimate the health state utility. The intercept and day of assessment were incorporated
as random effects. Covariance structures were assessed for goodness of fit using Akaike
Information Criteria. Secondary analyses that included a treatment indicator were
performed to explore a possible treatment effect. EQ-5D analysis of a patient subgroup
(with tumors highly expressing the HER2-protein, i.e., IHC3+ or IHC2+ and FISH+,
metastatic at screening, n = 431), was also conducted. RESULTS: The unstructured
covariance matrix was found to be the best fit and resulted into a PFS-utility of 0.73
(95% CI: 0.71; 0.75). The treatment effect was not found to be significant (P =
0.1542); i.e., no difference between the two treatment regimens was identified. Results
were confirmed for the subgroup. CONCLUSIONS: Although only HER2+ patients
were included in ToGA, the obtained utility value is in line with other published PFSutilities in aGC. Given the large patient numbers, 0.73 can be regarded as a robust
estimate of a patient-reported outcome. Further studies in aGC should attempt to
assess the utility in patients following disease progression.
PCN117
UTILITY ELICITATION STUDY IN THE UK GENERAL PUBLIC FOR LATE
STAGE CHRONIC LYMPHOCYTIC LEUKEMIA
Tolley K1, Goad C2, Yi Y2, Maroudas PA3, Thompson G3
1
Tolley Health Economics, Buxton, UK; 2Mapi Values, Bollington, UK; 3GlaxoSmithKline,
Uxbridge, UK
OBJECTIVES: In the UK, chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL) makes up 40% of all
leukemias in patients over 65 years. The objective of this UK-based study was to obtain
societal preferences for “progression-free” and “progressive” stages of late-stage CLL,
and selected treatment-related adverse events. METHODS: A utility study, using the
time-trade off (TTO) method, was conducted in the UK with 110 members of the
general public for a baseline disease state (before treatment), three primary disease
states (progression-free survival [PFS] response, PFS non-response, and disease progression) and four adverse event (AE) substates (PFS response with thrombocytopenia,
neutropenia or severe infection, and PFS non-response with severe infection). Disease
state vignettes were developed using literature and validated by expert CLL clinicians.
Face-to-face interviews were conducted by trained interviewers. The TTO scores were
converted into a utility value for each disease state and disutilities were calculated for
AEs. Visual analogue scale (VAS) scores were also obtained. RESULTS: All participants were included in the analysis. The mean utility scores from the TTO for the
primary disease states were: baseline: 0.549; PFS response: 0.671; PFS nonresponse:
0.394; and progression: 0.294. The mean TTO utility (disutility) scores for the AEs
were: PFS response with thrombocytopenia, neutropenia, or infection, 0.563 (−0.108),
0.508 (−0.163), 0.476 (−0.195), respectively; PFS nonresponse with infection, 0.333
(−0.061). The VAS results were in line with the TTO results. CONCLUSIONS:
A274
Overall, the utility was higher for the PFS state than for baseline, but decreased below
baseline in nonresponse and disease progression states. AEs had an important impact
on utility within the PFS response state. The severe infection AE appeared to have a
greater impact on patients responding to treatment compared to nonresponders, which
may be related to the quality of life which is already low for the latter.
PCN118
UTILITY VALUES FOR CHRONIC MYELOID LEUKAEMIA-CHRONIC
PHASE (CML-CP) HEALTH STATES FROM THE GENERAL PUBLIC IN
THE UNITED KINGDOM
Guest J1, Naik N1, Coombs J2, Gray L3, Jenkins A3
1
Catalyst Health Economics Consultants, Northwood, Middlsex, UK; 2Novartis, Florham Park,
NJ, USA; 3Novartis Pharmaceuticals UK Limited, Frimley, Surrey, UK
OBJECTIVES: To estimate utility values associated with CML-CP health states among
members of the general public in the UK. METHODS: Interviewer-administered time
trade-off utilities were elicited for four CML-CP health states related to risk of progression, from a random sample of 241 members of the general public from eight cities
across the UK, using health-state descriptions validated by clinicians and members of
the general public. Mean utility values with 95% confidence intervals (CI) were calculated for each health state. RESULTS: The respondents’ mean age was 45 years and
51% were female. Seven percent (n = 18) of respondents had a cancer at the time of
the interview which had been diagnosed for a mean 7.0 ± 6.5 years. The mean utilities
with 95% CI were: 0.72 (0.69; 0.75) for untreated chronic phase CML, 0.80 (0.79;
0.82) for hematologic response, 0.89 (0.87; 0.90) for cytogenetic response, and 0.94
(0.94; 0.95) for molecular response. The utility values for each state are significantly
different from one another (P < 0.001). The respondents’ preference values for any of
the states were not significantly affected by their demographics or whether they had
cancer. Nevertheless, the values elicited from respondents with cancer were lower than
those elicited from respondents who did not have cancer: 0.65 versus 0.73 for chronic
phase CML; 0.72 versus 0.81 for hematologic response; 0.83 versus 0.89 for cytogenetic response; and 0.89 versus 0.95 for molecular response. CONCLUSIONS: The
health states with poorer outcome (e.g., hematologic response) were associated with
a lower preference value than the state with the best outcome (i.e., molecular
response). The data demonstrate the impact that different treatment responses may
have on the health-related quality of life of patients with chronic phase CML and can
be used to estimate the outcomes of interventions in terms of quality-adjusted
life-years.
PCN119
COMPARISON OF EQ-5D SCORE BETWEEN TREATMENT WITH 4
CYCLES OF ANTHRACYCLINE FOLLOWED BY 4 CYCLES OF TAXANE
AND 8 CYCLES OF TAXANE FOR NODE POSITIVE BREAST CANCER
PATIENTS AFTER SURGERY: N-SAS BC 02 TRIAL
Shimozuma K1, Shiroiwa T1, Fukuda T2, Mori M3, Ohashi Y2, Watanabe T4
1
Ritsumeikan University, Kusatsu, Shiga, Japan; 2The University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan; 3Japan
Clinical Research Support Unit, Tokyo, Japan; 4Hamamatsu Oncology Center, Hamamatsu,
Shizuoka, Japan
OBJECTIVES: We investigated the effect of adjuvant chemotherapy regimens on
utility scores assessed by the EQ-5D instrument in a randomized controlled trial for
breast cancer patients after surgery. METHODS: In the National Surgical Adjuvant
Study of Breast Cancer-02 (N-SAS BC 02), 1060 patients were randomly assigned
to the following four chemotherapy groups: 1) four cycles of anthracycline (ADM
60 mg/m2 or EPR 75 mg/m2 + CPM 600 mg/m2, q3 wks x 4) followed by paclitaxel
(175 mg/m2, q3 wks x 4) (ACP); 2) four cycles of anthracycline followed by docetaxel
(75 mg/m2 q3, wks x 4) (ACD); 3) eight cycles of paclitaxel (175 mg/m2, q3 wks x 8)
(PTX); and 4) eight cycles of docetaxel (75 mg/m2, q3 wks x 8). The first consecutively
registered 300 women were the subjects of the present utility study. Utility scores were
assessed using the EQ-5D instrument at baseline, 3rd cycle, 5th cycle, 7th cycle, 7
months, and 1 year. The obtained data were analyzed using a linear mixed model with
baseline, time, group, and interaction between time and group as explanatory variables. RESULTS: Missing data was observed between 1.9 and 6.1% of cases depending on the time of measurement. The utility score was significantly lower in the DTX
group than in the ACP and ACD groups. In the DTX group, the mean utility score
was lowest at 7 months, and it tended to remain low for a long time. In a comparison
of the anthracycline and taxane groups, the anthracycline group had significantly
higher utility scores. There were no significant differences depending on the type of
taxane. The estimated mean utility scores were 0.81, 0.83, 0.79, and 0.76 (ACP, ACD,
PTX, and DTX group). CONCLUSIONS: The results of this study will be beneficial
not only for clinical decision-making but also for appropriate allocation of medical
resources.
PCN120
UTILITY AND WORK PRODUCTIVITY DATA FOR ECONOMIC
EVALUATION OF BREAST CANCER THERAPIES IN THE NETHERLANDS
AND SWEDEN
Lloyd A1, Quadri N1, Tamminga H2, Hövels A2
1
Oxford Outcomes Ltd., Oxford, UK; 2GlaxoSmithKline B.V, Zeist, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: Survival and quality of life (utility) are often the main measure of
benefit used in an economic evaluation. Additionally, some decision-makers will
consider benefits in terms of work productivity. The present study was designed to
estimate utilities and productivity loss for women with metastatic breast cancer (MBC)
13th Euro Abstracts
which is Human Epidermal Growth Factor Receptor 2 positive (HER 2+). METHODS:
Health-state vignettes describing MBC progressive disease, stable disease, and seven
grade 3/4 adverse events (diarrhea, fatigue, anemia, leukopenia, anorexia, decreases
in left ventricular ejection fraction [LVEF], and skin rash) were developed based on
interviews with women with MBC in the The Netherlands and Sweden and clinicians.
a general public sample rated the states (100 men and women in NL; 100 women
aged 50+ in Sweden) using the time trade off method. Women (161 The Netherlands,
52 Sweden) who were currently or recently treated for MBC were surveyed using the
Work Productivity and Activity Impairment scale regarding the impact of disease on
their ability to work. RESULTS: MBC progressive disease and stable disease were
rated more highly in Sweden (0.61, 0.81) than the The Netherlands (0.50, 0.69).
Utilities for toxicities ranged from 0.52 to 0.69 (Sweden), and 0.47 to 0.66 (NL). The
productivity survey identified that women currently receiving treatment reported that
their overall productivity was reduced by 69% (NL) and 72% (Sweden); while those
who had recently completed therapy reported reductions of 41% (NL) and 40%
(Sweden). CONCLUSIONS: This study captured utility and productivity data for the
The Netherlands and Sweden regarding the impact of HER 2+ MBC. Important differences in utilities emerged in the study which could impact cost-effectiveness estimates. The productivity survey demonstrated how the negative impact of breast cancer
on productivity persists after women have completed their treatment.
PCN121
CONFIRMATION OF BRIEF PAIN INVENTORY SHORT FORM (BPI-SF)
“WORST PAIN” ITEM CUT-POINT FOR THE ASSESSMENT OF PAIN
PROGRESSION IN CASTRATION-RESISTANT PROSTATE CANCER
(CRPC)
Regnault A1, Gater A2, Battersby C3, Meunier J1, Abetz L2
1
Mapi Values, Lyon, France; 2Mapi Values Ltd, Bollington, Cheshire, UK; 3AstraZeneca R&D
Alderley Park, Macclesfield, England, UK
OBJECTIVES: Previous studies in cancer patients have found scores of ≥5 on 11-point
pain scales to indicate pain that has a significant impact on patients’ lives. This study
sought to confirm the adequacy of a ≥5 cutpoint on the BPI-SF “worst pain” item for
defining pain progression in CRPC patients using data collected as part of a multinational phase III clinical trial. METHODS: Patients with a BPI-SF worst pain score ≥5
were compared with patients with a score <5 in terms of Functional Assessment of
Cancer Therapy—Prostate (FACT-P) subscales and total score and EQ-5D item scores.
Exploratory analyses were also conducted to investigate any potential differences
within designated regional subgroups of patients. All analyses were performed using
treatment-blinded data collected at the first post-baseline trial visit including the above
assessments (Week 12). RESULTS: A total of 464 patients completed the BPI-SF at
W12 (<5 n = 411, ≥5 n = 53). Mean FACT-P total scores for patients with a BPI-SF
worst pain score ≥5 were 24.5 points lower than for patients with a score <5 (91.1
vs. 115.6, P < 0.0001), indicating poorer well-being. Patients with BPI-SF worst pain
scores ≥5 consistently had lower scores for all FACT-P subscales (P < 0.0001) except
for social well-being. The magnitude of these differences, for all scales, was considerably greater than reported thresholds for meaningful difference. Results for EQ-5D
item scores were in a similar direction with significantly greater impairment reported
in patients with a BPI-SF worst pain score ≥5 compared with patients with a score <5
(P < 0.0001). Exploratory analyses also revealed similar results across all regional
subgroups of patients. CONCLUSIONS: Patient scores ≥5 on the BPI-SF “worst pain”
item are associated with significant and meaningful impairments in CRPC patients,
thus supporting the adequacy of this cutpoint as an appropriate definition of pain
progression in this population.
PCN122
DEVELOPMENT OF THE PATIENT-REPORTED VERSION OF THE
COMMON TERMINOLOGY CRITERIA FOR ADVERSE EVENTS
(PRO-CTCAE)
Basch E1, Reeve B2, Cleeland C3, Sloan J4, Schrag D5, Atkinson TM1, Mendoza T3, Hay J1,
Abernethy A6, Minasian L7, Kwitkowski V8, Trentacosti AM8, Burke L9, Sit L1, Bruner D10
1
Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center, New York, NY, USA; 2National Cancer Institute,
Bethesda, MD, USA; 3U.T.M.D. Anderson Cancer Center, Houston, TX, USA; 4Mayo Clinic,
Rochester, MN, USA; 5Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, Boston, MA, USA; 6Duke University,
Durham, NC, USA; 7National Cancer Institute, Rockville, MD, USA; 8U.S. Food and Drug
Administration, Silver Spring, MD, USA; 9Center for Drug Evaluation and Research, U.S.
Food and Drug Administration, Silver Spring, MD, USA; 10University of Pennsylvania,
Philadelphia, PA, USA
OBJECTIVES: The standard lexicon for reporting adverse events in National Cancer
Institute (NCI) sponsored clinical trials is the Common Terminology Criteria for
Adverse Events (CTCAE), which consists of 790 individual items. Currently, all
adverse events are reported by clinicians. However, multiple studies have found that
clinicians tend to underreport symptom severity and onset compared with patient
self-reports. In 2008, the NCI contracted a multi-institution consortium to develop
patient versions of CTCAE items and an electronic platform for capturing symptoms
from patients and reporting data to health care providers and researchers. METHODS:
A committee including clinical investigators, methodologists, patients, and representatives of NCI and FDA systematically identified CTCAE items with a subjective component amenable to patient reporting. Systematic review and analyses of publications
and existing symptom survey data sets and questionnaires were conducted to determine optimal formats for questions, response options, and terms for new PRO-CTCAE
items. RESULTS: 81 symptoms were identified in the CTCAE to be amenable to
patient reporting. The format and content of these items were found to be inappropri-
13th Euro Abstracts
ate for patient reporting in their current form, due to mixing of symptom attributes
within items and technical jargon. The committee determined that measured attributes
for each symptom should include frequency, severity, and activity interference. Questions and response options were standardized, along with plain language terms for
each symptom. a web-based platform was developed for administering the new PROCTCAE items. CONCLUSIONS: In response to a charge from the NCI, the PROCTCAE, a patient version of the CTCAE system, has been developed. The prototype
is undergoing testing to assess validity, usability, and logistical feasibility in a variety
of cancer care settings. The PRO-CTCAE system has the potential to enhance adverse
event reporting by integrating patient experiences and can foster consistency of data
collection methods across studies.
PCN123
DEVELOPMENT OF A COMPUTER-ADAPTIVE PATIENT REPORTED
OUTCOME TOOL FOR THE SCREENING FOR PSYCHO-ONCOLOGICAL
TREATMENT NEEDS
Gamper E, Meraner V, Giesinger J, Kemmler G, Oberguggenberger A,
Sperner-Unterweger B, Holzner B
Innsbruck Medical University, Innsbruck, Austria
OBJECTIVES: Diagnosis and treatment of cancer entail a considerable amount of
distress which in a large percentage of patients would require psychooncological treatment (POT). There is though a lack of precise and economic measures for assessing
the need for POT. Its detection in clinical routine often depends on procedural and
personnel conditions. The aim of the study was the development and implementation
of a patient-reported outcome tool for the screening of distress. a further aim is the
construction of a computer-adpative testing (CAT) version. METHODS: 115 breast
cancer outpatients attending the Department of Gynaecology at Innsbruck Medical
University were consecutively included in a pilot study. Logistic regression analysis
and ROC analyses identified the most predictive items from a set of questionnaires
(EORTC-QLQ-C30, HADS, and Hornheide Screening Instrument) and other additional questions. The development of the CAT screening tool comprises generating an
item bank, developing the CAT-algorithm and applying and implementing the CAT
in clinical practice. RESULTS: Data from 105 breast cancer patients (mean age 58.8,
SD 12.3) were analyzed. The EORTC QLQ-C30 scales Emotional Functioning and
Role Functioning as well as the yes–no question after psychiatric/psychological/psychotherapeutic treatment at any point in lifetime showed high predictive power with
regard to need for POT (AUC = 0.88; CI 95% 0.82–0.95). The generation of the item
bank resulted in 52 prelinimary items which will be subjected to further analyses.
CONCLUSIONS: The implementation of precise and effective measures for POT
needs is essential for providing comprehensive and high-quality cancer care. CAT
methodology contributes to the reduction of patient burden and assessment duration,
and increases efficiency as well as measurement precision.
PCN124
COMPUTER-ADAPTIVE TESTING OF FATIGUE IN ONCOLOGICAL
PATIENTS
Giesinger J1, Petersen M2, Groenvold M2, Gamper E1, Conroy T3, King M4, Luckett T4,
Arraras J5, Young T6, Verdonck-de Leeuw I7, Kemmler G1, Holzner B1
1
Innsbruck Medical University, Innsbruck, Austria; 2Bispebjerg Hospital, Copenhagen,
Denmark; 3Centre Alexis Vautrin, Vandoeuvre les Nancy, France; 4University of Sydney,
Sydney, Australia; 5Hospital of Navarre, Pamplona, Spain; 6Mount Vernon Cancer Centre,
Northwood, UK; 7VU University, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: Computer-adaptive testing (CAT) is an advanced method for measuring patient-reported outcomes. With help of an algorithm, CAT selects the items most
relevant for an individual patient from an item bank. Our study aim was the development of a CAT version of the EORTC QLQ-C30 Fatigue scale, its implementation in
a software package, and its use in daily clinical routine. METHODS: Our project is
part of a large project on CAT development conducted by the EORTC Quality of Life
Group. To set up an initial English fatigue item list, an extensive literature research
was performed. These items were refined through multistage expert reviews, translated
to German, Danish, Spanish, French, and Dutch, and filled in by a pilot patient sample
to collect feedback. In a next step, a large patient sample is recruited for all language
versions to gain data for development of the item bank and the CAT algorithm.
RESULTS: Literature research resulted in 588 fatigue items, from which 44 were
selected after comprehensive expert reviews. Based on feedback from 52 oncological
patients, wording and translation of several items were revised. Data have been collected from about 1200 patients. Preliminary results of the CAT-analysis will be
presented. CONCLUSIONS: By generating individually tailored item sets, CAT
reduces patient burden and assessment duration, and increases measurement precision.
In addition, electronic data capture increases data quality and reduces the amount of
human resources required for data collection.
PCN125
ECONOMIC AND PATIENT-REPORTED OUTCOMES OF OUTPATIENT
HOME-BASED VERSUS INPATIENT HOSPITAL-BASED CHEMOTHERAPY
FOR PATIENTS WITH COLORECTAL CANCER
Kang HY1, Joo EH1, Cho E1, Kim HS1, Kim SY2
1
Yonsei University, Seoul, South Korea; 2Korea University, Seoul, South Korea
OBJECTIVES: To compare the economic and patient-reported outcomes between
outpatient home-based and inpatient hospital-based chemotherapy in advanced
colorectal cancer patients. METHODS: A total of 80 patients from Severance Hospital
A275
in Seoul, Korea, who had stage III colorectal cancer and underwent home-based (n =
40) or hospital-based chemotherapy (n = 40) with a FOLFOX regimen between
January 2007 and April 2008 were enrolled. Patient satisfaction data were collected
by a self-administered questionnaire survey. Based on hospital charge records, average
cost (in 2008 Korean won) per chemotherapy session was estimated and compared
between home- and hospital-based chemotherapy from a societal perspective.
RESULTS: Patients receiving chemotherapy at home showed higher satisfaction with
their treatment (mean satisfaction score: 3.58 ± 0.15, 5-point Likert-type scale, with
a higher score indicating higher satisfaction) than did those treated at the hospital
(3.23 ± 0.21; P < 0.01). After adjusting for differences in baseline characteristics
between the two groups using multivariate analysis, those receiving home-based chemotherapy still showed significantly higher satisfaction than those undergoing hospital-based therapy (β = 0.271, P < 0.001). Additionally, home-based therapy reduced
the cost per chemotherapy session by 16.6%, compared with hospital-based treatment
(1,694,216 vs. 2,030,383 Korean won [KW], 1200 KW ≈ 1 US dollar). The largest
cost reduction was attributable to medical costs (−201,122 KW), followed by caregiver’s opportunity costs (−135,000 KW). CONCLUSIONS: Higher satisfaction and
lower economic cost for home-based chemotherapy suggests that home-based chemotherapy could be a popular and cost-effective treatment option for colorectal cancer
patients who are eligible for home-based chemotherapy.
PCN126
REVIEW OF PATIENT-REPORTED OUTCOMES IN PHASE II ONCOLOGY
CLINICAL TRIALS
Danheiser S1, Barkalow F1, Finnern HW2
1
Citeline, New York, NY, USA; 2Boehringer Ingelheim GmbH, Ingelheim, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Patients’ own assessment of the impact of anticancer therapy has been
considered important from a patient, physician, payor, and regulatory perspective.
Approximately 12% of all oncology clinical trials list at least one patient-reported
outcome (PRO) measure; 50% of these are phase II trials. Use and publication of PROs
results were systematically reviewed for breast, colorectal, ovarian, and non-small cell
lung cancer (NSCLC). METHODS: Citeline’s TrialTrove database was searched for
oncology trials that included PROs and were planned, ongoing or completed as of
October 2009. Specific trial factors examined include phase, disease type, location,
sponsorship, type of PRO instrument(s), and publication of PRO endpoint results.
RESULTS: Of the 5483 phase II trials retrieved for breast, colorectal, ovarian, and
NSCLC, 9% listed PROs. PRO measures were more frequently included in NSCLC
(13%) and ovarian cancer (10%) than in breast (7%) or colorectal (8%) cancer phase
II trials. Fifty-two percent of these trials were sponsored by industry, with 25% and
19% being sponsored by academic and cooperative groups, respectively. One-third of
the trials were conducted in the United States only. PROs were most frequently measured
with the EORTC and FACT series of questionnaires. Phase II PRO results were published 24%, 36% and 39% of the time for breast, ovarian, and NSCLC, respectively,
and only 18% of the time for colorectal cancer. This compares with an overall publication frequency for PRO trials (any end points) of 58% to 67% which was highest in
NSCLC. PRO results were published more frequently for trials conducted in Asia or
Europe. However, trial sponsorship did not impact publication frequency. CONCLUSIONS: PROs are infrequently assessed in phase II cancer trials. PRO measures were
most frequently included in NSCLC trials and sponsored by industry. PRO results were
published less frequently than other end points in these trials. Publication frequency
differed by tumor type and trial location.
PCN127
MINIMAL CLINICALLY MEANINGFUL DIFFERENCES FOR THE EORTC
QLQ-C30 AND EORTC QLQ-BN20 SCALES IN BRAIN CANCER PATIENTS
Maringwa J1, Quinten C1, King M2, Ringash J3, Osoba D4, Coens C1, Martinelli F1,
Cleeland C5, Flechtner H6, Gotay C7, Greimel E8, Taphoorn M9, Reeve B10,
Schmucker-Von Koch J11, Weis J12, Van Den Bent MJ13, Stupp R14, Bottomley A1
1
European Organisation for Research and Treatment of Cancer, Brussels, Belgium;
2
University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia; 3The Princess Margaret Hospital, Toronto, QC,
Canada; 4Quality of Life Consulting, West Vancouver, BC, Canada; 5U.T.M.D. Anderson
Cancer Center, Houston, TX, USA; 6University of Magdeburg, Magdeburg, Germany;
7
University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada; 8Medical University of Graz, Graz,
Austria; 9Medisch Centrum Haaglanden—Westeinde, Den Haag, The Netherlands;
10
National Cancer Institute, Bethesda, MD, USA; 11University of Regensburg, Regensburg,
Germany; 12University of Freiburg, Freiburg, Germany; 13AZ Rotterdam-Daniel Den Hoed
Kliniek, Rotterdam, The Netherlands; 14University Hospital CHUV, Lausanne, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to determine the smallest changes in healthrelated quality-of-life (HRQOL) scores in the European Organization for Research
and Treatment of Cancer quality of life questionnaire (EORTC QLQ-C30) and the
EORTC Brain Cancer Module (QLQ-BN20), which could be considered as clinically
meaningful in brain cancer patients. METHODS: World Health Organization (WHO)
performance status (PS) and the Mini Mental State Examination (MMSE) were used
as clinical anchors appropriate to related subscales to determine minimal clinically
important differences (MCID) in HRQOL change scores (range 0–100) in the EORTC
QLQ-C30 and QLQ-BN20. a threshold of 0.2SD (small effect) was used to exclude
anchor-based MCID estimates considered too small to inform interpretation.
RESULTS: Based on WHO PS, our findings support the following integer estimates
of the MCID for improvement and deterioration, respectively: physical functioning
(6, 9), role functioning (14, 12), cognitive functioning (8, 8), global health status (7,
4*), fatigue (12, 9), and motor dysfunction (4*, 5). Anchoring with MMSE, cognitive
A276
functioning MCID estimates for improvement and deterioration were (11, 2*) and
those for communication deficit were (9, 7). The estimates with asterisks were less
than the 0.2 SD threshold and were therefore excluded from our MCID ranges. Our
MCID estimates therefore range from 5 to 14. CONCLUSIONS: These estimates can
help clinicians to interpret the clinical relevance of changes in HRQOL over time and,
in conjunction with other measures of efficacy, help to assess the value of a health-care
intervention. The findings also indicate that more sensitive measures may be needed
to detect certain changes. Furthermore, the estimates can be useful in determining
sample sizes in the design of future clinical trials.
PCN128
EFFECTS AND MEDICAL COSTS OF A STRUCTURED PSYCHOSOCIAL
GROUP INTERVENTION FOR BREAST CANCER PATIENTS AFTER
SURGERY
Shimozuma K1, Shiroiwa T1, Sagara Y2, Tobata R2, Ueo H3, Kubota Y3, Hori T4,
Amano K4, Terada S5, Mori M6, Yajima T6, Kurahashi I7, Saito S8, Hosaka T9
1
Ritsumeikan University, Kusatsu, Shiga, Japan; 2Sagara Hospital, Kagoshima, Japan; 3Ueo
Breast Clinic, Oita, Japan; 4Shiga Medical Center for Adults, Moriyama, Shiga, Japan; 5Wakaba
Association, Kariya, Aichi, Japan; 6Japan Clinical Research Support Unit, Tokyo, Japan; 7The
University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan; 8Okayama University, Okayama, Japan; 9Tokai University,
Tokyo, Japan
OBJECTIVES: To clarify the details of psychosocial health status, the effects and
related costs of psychosocial group intervention in post-breast cancer surgery patients.
METHODS: Structured psychosocial group intervention (90 min/week × five sessions)
was conducted for 66 patients aged 20–79 years who were receiving breast cancer
treatment at three hospitals in Japan (intervention group). The intervention was
conducted 2 weeks to 3 months after radical surgery. HRQOL and psychosocial
function were investigated prospectively for outcome. The survey included 1) EORTC
QLQ-C30 for HRQOL; and 2) POMS, MAC scale, and a characteristic self-efficacy
scale for psychosocial function. It was conducted at registration, week 4 (group
therapy conclusion), and month 6. Prior to the intervention study, a group that fulfilled
the same eligibility criteria but did not receive psychosocial group intervention was
studied (n = 116; nonintervention group). The same outcomes were measured and
compared using multivariate analysis adjusted for disease stage, chemotherapy, and
hospital. Direct medical costs were obtained from receipt data, and information on
travel expenses, direct nonmedical costs, and indirect costs (productivity costs) were
collected simultaneously with the HRQOL survey. RESULTS: In HRQOL and psychosocial function, an intervention effect was seen in fatalism (MAC_F) only. In a
subgroup analysis by hospital, effects of cognitive function were seen in HRQOL
(EORTC_CF), tension-anxiety (POMS_TA), helplessness/hopelessness (MAC_H), and
fatalism (MAC_F). However, these effects were not seen at 6 months. Total medical
costs including indirect costs during the 6 months were ¥840,000 for the intervention
group and ¥750,000 for the nonintervention group. CONCLUSIONS: Structured
psychosocial group intervention for post-breast cancer surgery patients had a uniform
effect in improving HRQOL and psychosocial function. It is significant that a benefit
was obtained in the early postoperative period when HRQOL is most easily damaged.
Medical costs did not differ significantly between the groups.
PCN129
A DATABASE REVIEW OF PATIENT-REPORTED OUTCOME STUDIES IN
EORTC CANCER CLINICAL TRIALS
Bottomley A1, Quinten C1, Mauer M1, Taphoorn M2, Flechtner HH3, Koller M4,
Ghislain I1, Coens C1
1
European Organisation for Research and Treatment of Cancer, Brussels, Belgium; 2Medisch
Centrum Haaglanden—Westeinde, Den Haag, The Netherlands; 3Otto-von-Guericke
University Magdeburg, Magdeburg, Germany; 4University Hospital Regensburg, Regensburg,
Germany
OBJECTIVES: For the last two decades, QL has been increasingly assessed in the
EORTC. a detailed database review of all completed and ongoing EORTC QL studies
has been undertaken. METHODS: A database of all EORTC QL clinical trial protocols was established in 2000. This regularly updated database comprises all trials
where QL has been included as an end point. It summarizes details of closed and
ongoing trials, QL tools used, assessment timing, disease and treatment types, compliance, and published outcomes. These were examined and reported. RESULTS: The
database contains over 128 EORTC clinical trial protocols over a 15-year period
between 1995 and 2010 which included a QL component. This is an average of eight
new clinical trials with QL per year with only two having QL as a primary end point.
The QLQ-C30 was the instrument of choice in 85% of trials. In the last decade, 15
EORTC clinical groups have been recruiting patients. The majority of trials were
conducted by the radiotherapy, brain and breast groups. Over 20,000 patients, mostly
from Belgium, France, Germany, and the The Netherlands, have been entered into
closed and ongoing multinational trials. Typically, EORTC trials are conducted across
an average of 12 countries which include over 85 centers and often involve only a
single trial. Several early EORTC trials experienced lower than ideal compliance. This
presents a major challenge for the EORTC, but trials in the last 6 years have demonstrated significantly improved compliance. Most QL studies were published as separate
papers from the main clinical paper, and over 80% were published in high-impact
factor journals (IF > 12). CONCLUSIONS: QL is now a major component of cancer
clinical trials, an almost standard secondary end point. This suggests that researchers
in the European context increasingly acknowledge the importance of patient-reported
outcome assessments for evaluating cancer therapeutic modalities.
13th Euro Abstracts
PCN130
QUALITY OF LIFE, OUTCOMES, AND COSTS IN THE BELGIAN
POPULATION RECEIVING 90Y-ZEVALIN FOR NON-HODGKIN
LYMPHOMA: A STUDY FOR REIMBURSEMENT REVISION
Caekelbergh K, Moeremans K
IMS Health Consulting, Brussels, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: To compare hematological toxicity, costs, health-related quality of life
(HR-QOL), and outcomes observed in real life in the Belgian non-Hodgkin lymphoma
(NHL) population receiving 90Y-Zevalin, with model-predicted data at reimbursement on the basis of a clinical trial in heavily pretreated NHL. METHODS: Twelve
of the 13 centers trained for 90Y-Zevalin administration at the time of reimbursement
approval participated. All consecutive patients receiving 90Y-Zevalin for Rituximabrelapsed/refractory NHL were included in this 1-year, multicenter, prospective, observational study. QOL assessments, based on a generic (EQ-5D) and a disease-specific
(FACT-LYM) questionnaire, were performed at baseline (date of first administration
Rituximab), day 8, month 1, 2, and 3 after baseline. Costing (c, 2008) was based on
official tariffs and observed resource use. RESULTS: Over the 2-year recruitment
period, 30 patients were included. Only one1 patient received hematopoietic growth
factor prophylaxis. Hematological toxicity occurred in 79% of patients, but was
generally mild. Grade IV neutropenia was reported in 16% of patients (35% predicted), grade IV thrombocytopenia in 23% (9% predicted), and grade IV anemia was
not reported (4% predicted). EQ-5D as well as FACT-LYM assessments suggested no
significant changes in HR-Qol over the study period and no impact of hematological
toxicity on HR-Qol. The average total cost from the health-care payer perspective,
covering costs of drugs, drug administration setting, and prophylaxis, mounted to
c16,886 (Standard error 79 c). Hematological toxicity added c1191 (Standard error:
c528), constituting 7% of total costs (18,076 c). Observed costs were within 2% from
predicted costs. Median time to progression (TTP) was 11.7 months (6.8 months
predicted). CONCLUSIONS: This observational study confirmed the predicted tolerability profile, costs and outcomes associated with 90Y-zevalin in a real-life patient
population. Furthermore, the patient numbers treated with 90Y-Zevalin in real life
were lower than anticipated (maximum 100 predicted).
PCN131
HEALTH-RELATED QUALITY OF LIFE (HRQOL) IN CERVICAL CANCER:
CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE AND METHODOLOGICAL ISSUES
Siddiqui MK, Gupta J, Sehgal M
Heron Health Private Ltd., Chandigarh, India
OBJECTIVES: To assess the clinical use of HRQoL instruments in RCTs in cervical
carcinoma and evaluate pertinent methodological issues. METHODS: RCTs investigating HRQoL benefit of therapies in cervical carcinoma in adult females, published
in English language were included. Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials,
MEDLINE and EMBASE were searched from inception to 2010. Two reviewers
independently assessed the trials for inclusion and performed extraction. RESULTS:
Of the 96 RCTs identified, 13 RCTs met the inclusion criteria. Ten trials compared
different chemotherapy regimens in first- to third-line treatment. The most commonly
used QoL instrument was Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy (FACT-G) (46%
trials). Alternatively, cancer-specific European Organization for Research and Treatment of Cancer-Quality of Life Questionnaire-Core 30 (EORTC QLQ-30), SF-36, and
Linear Analogue Scale Assessment (LASA 100 mm) were used either alone or in
conjunction with the Brief pain Inventory (BPI). Only one trial reported HRQoL as a
primary objective. HRQoL results were presented adequately in 61% trials which were
analyzable. Statistically significant differences in HRQoL between treatment groups
were studied in 69% studies, but the clinically meaningful difference was examined
in only one study. Prognostic value of QoL was assessed in only two trials (15%).
Most widely observed methodological issues included lack of priori hypothesis (92%
studies) and lack of methods to deal with missing data (85%). Other issues included
lack of details on domain, variability in time points of administration of a tool, and
patient’s noncompliance, reported in ~60% studies. CONCLUSIONS: HRQoL is
included as an outcome in the studies investigating therapies in cervical carcinoma but
clinically meaningful interpretations of HRQoL results are rarely considered. The
methodological shortcomings in the assessment and analysis of HRQoL outcomes
should be examined further to derive clinically meaningful and correlating evidence.
PCN132
ERLOTINIB MAINTENANCE THERAPY FOR NON-SMALL CELL LUNG
CANCER PRESERVES QUALITY OF LIFE
Juhász E1, Kim JH2, Stelmakh L3, Cicenas S4, Klingelschmitt G5
1
Országos Korányi TBC, Budapest, Hungary; 2St. Vincent’s Hospital, Seoul, South Korea; 3I.P.
Pavlov State Medical University, St. Petersburg, Russia; 4Vilnius University, Vilnius, Lithuania;
5
F. Hoffmann-La Roche Pharmaceuticals AG, Basel, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: Maintenance therapy can delay progression and prolong survival in
metastatic non-small cell lung cancer (mNSCLC). The impact of treatments for
mNSCLC on patient quality-of-life (QoL) is an important consideration, as treatment
is noncurative and QoL in this population is already compromised. The SATURN
study demonstrated that, compared with placebo, erlotinib maintenance therapy
improved progression-free survival and overall survival by 41% and 23%, respectively. The impact of erlotinib maintenance therapy on QoL was also evaluated as a
secondary end point. METHODS: Patient QoL was assessed until disease progression
or withdrawal using the Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy-Lung (FACT-L)
questionnaire. Disease progression was assessed radiographically at regular intervals,
often diagnosed prior to symptomatic progression. Patient QoL was analyzed in terms
13th Euro Abstracts
of the time to symptom progression (TSP), time to deterioration (TTD) in trial
outcome index (TOI), and time to deterioration (TTD) in QoL. An exploratory analysis based on the time to analgesia and appearance of key symptoms (pain, cough, and
dyspnea) was also performed. RESULTS: FACT-L completion rates were above 90%
at almost all study visits. At baseline, QoL measures were similar between the two
treatment groups. Maintenance therapy with erlotinib did not negatively impact on
QoL, compared with placebo, as illustrated by comparable TSP (HR = 0.91 [0.74–
1.12], n = 785), TTD in TOI (HR = 1.06 [0.87–1.31], n = 781), or TTD in QoL (HR
= 0.96 [0.79–1.16], n = 776). Exploratory analysis of NSCLC-related symptomatology
showed that time to pain and time to analgesic use were significantly delayed in
patients receiving erlotinib compared with placebo (HR = 0.61 [0.42–0.88]; P =
0.0080 and HR = 0.66 [0.46–0.94]; P = 0.0199, respectively). There was also a
nonsignificant trend toward delayed time to cough and time to dyspnea (HR = 0.77
[0.49–1.21] and HR = 0.75 [0.48–1.17], respectively). CONCLUSIONS: Erlotinib
maintenance therapy significantly extends progression-free survival, without compromising patient QoL and with some improvement in symptoms.
PCN133
EPICLIN-LUNG STUDY: NON-SMALL-CELL LUNG CANCER (NSCLC)
PATIENT QUALITY OF LIFE AND HEALTH-STATE ASSESSMENT
Thomas M1, Cruciani G2, Vergnenegre A3, Guallar E4, Medina E5, Carrato A6
1
Clinic for Thoracic Diseases, University of Heidelberg, Heidelberg, Germany; 2Ravenna
Hospital, Ravenna, Italy; 3SIME, Limoges, France; 4Welch Center for Prevention,
Epidemiology, and Clinical Research, Baltimore, MD, USA; 5AstraZeneca Pharmaceuticals,
Madrid, Spain; 6Hospital Universitario Ramon y Cajal, Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: The aim of the EPICLIN-Lung study is to provide information on the
impact and overall resource burden of the diverse strategies used across Europe for
the management of NSCLC. Quality of life (QoL) and health state (HS) were determined by patient-reported outcome (PRO) questionnaires. METHODS: The EPICLIN-Lung study (NCT00831909) is a noninterventional prospective cohort study
conducted in Belgium, France, Germany, Greece, Italy, Portugal, Spain, and Turkey.
Patients with confirmed NSCLC attending a participating clinical department for the
first time between January and March 2009 were included. QoL and HS were assessed
at baseline (Visit 1) by the responses to the PRO questionnaires FACT-L (Functional
Assessment of Cancer Therapy-Lung) and EQ5D (EuroQoL-5D), respectively.
RESULTS: Patients (N = 1500) received the questionnaires at Visit 1. QoL data werer
available for 1500 patients and overall FACT-L mean score (±SD) was 93.4 (21.3).
HS data were available for a total of 1402 patients, overall EQ5D mean score (±SD)
was 63.3 (19.9). Mean scores (±SD) split by disease stage IIIb (FACT-L, n = 276;
EQ5D, n = 258) and IV (FACT-L, n = 694; EQ5D, n = 653) were 93.5 (20.1) and
91.3 (21.6) for FACT-L, respectively, and 64.2 (18.7) and 61.0 (20.5) for EQ5D,
respectively. Mean scores (±SD) split by age <80 (FACT-L, n = 1,428; EQ5D, n =
1,348) and age ≥80 (FACT-L, n = 61; EQ5D, n = 54) were 93.5 (21.4) and 92.9 (18.7)
for FACT-L, respectively, and 63.5 (19.9) and 60.4 (19.9) for EQ5D, respectively.
Mean scores (±SD) for patients with performance status 0, 1, 2, 3, and 4 were 100.9
(18.7), 94.3 (21.3), 84.9 (20.9), 84.4 (21.0), and 85.0 (20.4), respectively, for FACT-L
and 71.6 (17.6), 63.4 (19.3), 57.3 (17.9), 54.5 (21.3), and 55.0 (15.3), respectively,
for EQ5D. CONCLUSIONS: This study provides a robust utility that could be used
in the final analysis to assess the QoL and HS of NSCLC patients across Europe. More
mature results and analysis will be provided at the meeting.
PCN134
DEALING WITH CULTURALLY SENSITIVE QUESTIONS IN THE COURSE
OF TRANSLATING EORTC QUALITY-OF-LIFE GROUP
QUESTIONNAIRES
Kulis D1, Jeglikova P1, Greimel E2, Bottomley A1, Koller M3
1
EORTC, Brussels, Belgium; 2Medical University of Graz, Graz, Austria; 3University Hospital
Regensburg, Regensburg, Germany
OBJECTIVES: The Translation Unit of the EORTC is responsible for coordinating
new translations of HRQOL tools. According to the Translation Procedure described
in the Translation Manual, one step is pilot-testing, involving 10 to 15 patients who
comment on the new translation. This abstract’s aim is to review the difficulties in
translating sensitive issues (body image, death, etc.). METHODS: During the pilot
testing, patients are interviewed about the translation, filling in answer sheets. a report
with their comments is reviewed by the Translation Unit. All questions with comments
from at least two patients must be analyzed. The three possible reactions are to accept
new translations suggested by the patients, to reword the English item, and provide a
new translation or to provide no change (e.g., because the only solution would be to
delete the item). Fifteen reports of QLQ-MY20 translations were analyzed. RESULTS:
In the most recent 15 translations of QLQ-MY20, pilot-tested on 85 patients in 16
countries, there were five language versions that caused no problem and 10 that
received comments about offensiveness or disturbing nature of questions about body
image and future perspectives (especially in countries such as China, Hong Kong,
Thailand, Lebanon, where body image and death are taboos). All together, there were
82 comments about four items (giving 20 translated questions causing difficulties)
which required thorough analysis and discussion. Results of the analysis included
changing six translations (rewording, accepting patients’ suggestions), refusing five
suggestions (they deviated from the source too much) and leaving nine translations
without changes (since there were no suggestions and rewording was impossible).
CONCLUSIONS: Scales concerning sexual functions, body image, and future perspectives tend to raise concerns, especially in Asian and Arabic countries. However, such
A277
issues are resolved in the pilot-testing stage of the Translation Procedure through
discussions, and linguistic and medical analyses of both source and target items.
PCN135
IMPROVEMENT IN QUALITY OF LIFE OUTCOMES IN INTERFERONALPHA TREATED PATIENTS COMPARED TO SUNITINIB IN ADVANCE
OR METASTATIC RENAL CELL CARCINOMA
Goyal R1, Anand R1, Rai MK2
1
Value Edge Research Pvt Ltd., New Delhi, India; 2Cardiff Research Consortium, Capita India
Pvt. Ltd, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India
OBJECTIVES: The objective was to assess the improvement in quality-of-life outcomes with interferon-alpha compared to sunitinib in treatment-naïve advanced/metastatic renal cell carcinoma in patients. METHODS: Studies were retrieved from
Embase, Pubmed, Cochrane, and DARE databases using relevant search strategies.
Randomized controlled trials which compared IFN with sunitinib were included
according to prespecified inclusion/exclusion criteria. The quality-of-life (QoL) data
presented in the studies was independently extracted by two reviewers and differences
were reconciled by a third reviewer. All studies were critically appraised and data was
analyzed using STATA version 9.2. RESULTS: Of the 463 studies identified, three
studies met the inclusion criteria. FKSI-DRS index was reported in one study with
baseline and endpoint values as 29.55 and 27.4 with IFN-α and 29.74 and 29.4 with
sunitinib (P < 0.0001). FKSI-15 index was reported in two studies with mean baseline
and endpoint values as 46.1 and 42.1 with IFN-α and 46.45 and 45.3 with sunitinib
(P < 0.0001). FACT-G score was reported in one study. The baseline FACT-G score
was 81.25 with IFN-α and 82.3 with sunitinib. The endpoint FACT-G score was 76.8
with IFN-α and 82.3 with sunitinib (P < 0.0001). EQ-5D score was reported in two
of the included studies and was reported to be 0.76 and 0.73 as mean baseline and
endpoint score for IFN-α group and 0.76 and 0.76 for sunitinib group. EQ-VAS score
was reported in one study and was 71.43 and 68.7 as baseline and end point for IFN-α
group and 73.8 and 73.4 for sunitinib group. The overall survival rate and response
rate was better with sunitinib as compared to IFN-α. CONCLUSIONS: Improvement
in quality-of-life outcomes was better in patients treated with IFN-α as compared to
sunitinib at the end point. IFN-α continues to remain a treatment of choice despite of
limited efficacy and tolerability.
PCN136
QUALITY OF LIFE AFTER CHEMOTHERAPY IN BREAST CANCER: A
STUDY IN SOUTH OF IRAN
Ahmad Kiadaliri A1, Bastani P2
1
Lund University, Malmo, Sweden; 2Iran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to compare the impact of two common
treatment of breast cancer on quality of life in women with early stage of breast cancer.
METHODS: A double-blind cohort study was done in 100 breast cancer patients with
node positive that used 5-fluorouracil, doxorubicin, cyclophosphamide (FAC) or
docetaxel, doxorubicin, and cyclophosphamide (TAC) regimen as adjuvant therapies.
Patients were followed for 4 months since end of chemotherapy. Health-related quality
of life was assessed using questionnaire from European organization for research and
treatment of cancer (EORTC) QLQ-C30. Independent t-test analysis was used at the
significant level of 0.05 for analyzing the results. RESULTS: The mean of age was
49.2911.59 and 46.718.23 years old in TAC and FAC groups, respectively. In the end
of chemotherapy, QoL score were 64 and 68 in TAC and FAC groups, respectively
(P < 0.005). After 4 months, patients in TAC and FAC groups experienced 11.45 and
7.14 units improvement in QoL scores, respectively (P = 0.02). CONCLUSIONS:
Although, TAC had a more negative impact on QoL during chemotherapy, it created
a higher improvement than FAC during 4 months since end of treatment. These effects
on quality of life should be considered in making decision for providing and financing
cancer treatments in Iran.
PCN137
EMPLOYMENT STATUS AND WORK-RELATED DIFFICULTIES IN LUNG
CANCER SURVIVORS COMPARED WITH GENERAL POPULATION
Kim YA1, Yun Y1, Zo JI1, Shim YM2
1
National Cancer Center, Goyang-si, Gyeonggi-do, South Kore; 2Samsung Medical Center,
Seoul, South Korea
OBJECTIVES: Although improved lung cancer survival is likely to result in increased
lung cancer survivors, little was known about work situation among lung cancer
survivors. The purpose of this study was to investigate employment status and workrelated difficulties of lung cancer survivors compared with the general population.
METHODS: We enrolled 917 lung cancer survivors from two hospitals 12 months
after lung cancer surgery and 1000 volunteers from the general population. Multivariate logistic regression was used to identify the factors associated with work situation.
RESULTS: Employment decreased from 69.6% to 38.7% after cancer treatment. The
proportion of lung cancer survivors who remained working was significantly smaller
relative to that of the general population (63.5%) (adjusted odds ratio [aOR] = 2.59;
95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.91 to 3.51). In subgroup analyses, female survivors
over 65 years had unemployed after treatment (aOR = 89.24; 95%CI = 10.52 to
756.91) than at the diagnosis of cancer. Among cancer survivor who remained
employed after treatment (n = 284), 71.8% found no meaning of working and 15%
experienced decrease wages. CONCLUSIONS: This is the first study with the largest
number of patients investigating employment situation among lung cancer survivors
reported poorer employment status than the general population. Among cancer sur-
A278
vivors, specifically female survivors over 65 years had greater risk of work loss than
general population. These findings should help working people concerned about
employment after lung cancer.
CANCER – Health-Care Use and Policy Studies
PCN138
HEALTH-CARE COSTS ASSOCIATED WITH BREAST CANCER
MANAGEMENT
Cammarota S1, Citarella A1, Menditto E1, Putignano D1, Riegler S1, De Luca L1,
Malorni L2, De Placido S2, Arpino G2
1
CIRFF, Federico II University, Naples, Italy; 2Federico II University Hospital School of
Medicine, Naples, Italy
OBJECTIVES: To assess the outpatient direct costs related to early and metastatic
breast cancer (BC) management in Campania, a Southern Italy region. METHODS:
This is a retrospective cohort study based on clinical records from 457 general practitioners who managed an average of 630,000 inhabitants in Campania. Incident early
BC cases from 2005 to 2007 were identified and costs related to outpatients management were calculated until evidence of local recurrence or metastases (BC Event),
death, revocation or the end of the database (December 31, 2009). For those patients
who developed a BC event, costs for their disease management were further analyzed
from the time of the event until death, revocation, or the end of the database. Monthly
cost per patient was expressed in Euros. RESULTS: A total of 1529 patients with
early BC were identified in the database. Of these, 112 women developed a BC event
during the study period. At a median follow-up of 34 months, adjusted monthly
primary care cost per patient was c151.87 in the subset of women with early BC. For
those who experienced a BC event, at 24 months of follow-up, adjusted monthly
primary care cost per patient was almost doubled: c289.15 (P < 0.0001). Main causes
for this cost difference were related to increased number of specialists’visits, diagnostic
procedures, and laboratory test once a BC event developed. CONCLUSIONS: Outpatient’s management in women with metastatic BC is twice more expansive compared
to management of women with early BC. Reasons for this increase are mainly due to
increased frequency of imaging and diagnostic procedures in the metastatic BC subset.
However, our study underestimates the total costs for metastatic BC patients’ management because hospitalization and chemoptherapy costs are not included in our analyses. Based on our data, secondary and tertiary prevention strategies must be significantly
implemented in order to rationalize resource allocation.
PCN140
IMPROVING PATIENT ACCESS TO CANCER DRUGS IN INDIA: USING
ECONOMIC MODELING TO ESTIMATE A DRUG COST BASED ON
MEASURES OF SOCIETAL VALUE
Dranitsaris G1, Truter I1, Lubbe M2, Sriramanakoppa N3, Mendonca V3, Mahagaonkar S3
1
Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University (NMMU), Port Elizabeth, Eastern Cape, South
Africa; 2North-West University, Potchefstroom, South Africa; 3PharmARC Analytic Solutions,
Bangalore, India
OBJECTIVES: Cancer patients from lower-income countries such as India often have
limited access to modern medicines because of high costs. Using multiples of India’s
per capita GDP as the threshold for economic value as suggested by the World Health
Organization (WHO), decision analysis modeling was used to estimate a monthly cost
for a hypothetical new cancer drug that provides a 3-month survival benefit to patients
with metastatic colorectal cancer (mCRC). METHODS: A decision model was developed to simulate progression-free and overall survival in mCRC patients receiving
chemotherapy ± the new drug. Outcomes for cancer control and side effects were
obtained from randomized trials evaluating 1st and 2nd line chemotherapy in mCRC.
Costs for chemotherapy were obtained from both public and private hospitals in India.
Utility estimates measured as quality-adjusted life-years (QALY) were determined
from 24 oncology nurses using the Time Trade-Off technique. These data were then
used to estimate the monthly cost of the new drug using a threshold of $9300 per
QALY gained, which is three times the Indian per capita GDP, as recommended by
the WHO. RESULTS: The base-case analysis suggested that a monthly cost of $U.S.98
would be considered cost-effective from the Indian public health-care perspective. If
the drug were able to improve patient quality of life above the standard of care or
survival from 3 to 6 months, the monthly drug cost could increase to $U.S.170 and
$U.S.253 and offer the same value. CONCLUSIONS: The use of the WHO criteria
for estimating a country-specific drug price based on economic value for a developing
country is feasible. However, the challenge would be to identify an appropriate
threshold that would provide a balance between what patients/governments can afford
to pay and the commercial viability of the product in the reference country.
PCN141
TRANSPARENCY OF DRUG REIMBURSEMENT IN POLAND—ONCOLOGY
Kujawska A, Nogas G
Association CASPolska, Myslenice, Poland
OBJECTIVES: Increasing the level of transparency of decision-making process of
reimbursement for drugs used in oncology by facilitating online access to public
information and other information regarding the refund of cancer drugs in Poland
compared to solutions used in the world. METHODS: The project will develop a
comprehensive system to monitor the transparency of reimbursement decision-making
process in Poland consisting of: Guidelines and Clinical and Reimbursement Recom-
13th Euro Abstracts
mendations Database (WiRKliR database) whose purpose is to collect documents from
the Polish and selected countries of the clinical guidelines, registration, and decisions
about the recommendations and decisions regarding reimbursement for cancer drugs
and present information contained in them in a comprehensible and transparent.
Reimbursement monitoring which aims to carry out continuous monitoring of the
implementation of law and regulation in the field of oncology drug reimbursement
and the acquisition of complementary information about the cancer drugs in the
database WiRKliR. Reimbursement reports whose purpose is to discuss the issue of
transparency of reimbursement through the analysis of procedures drawn up and
applied by public authorities in dealing with citizens, with special emphasis on patients
and pharmaceutical companies in the reimbursement decision-making process and to
present the results of the various stages of our work. RESULTS: The most important
results of the project include: increased transparency of institutions involved in the
drug reimbursement decision-making process, the democratization of medical information, provide decision-makers Polish health-care system expertise, to increase
patient awareness about their rights and proposals for corrective actions (conclusions
and recommendations) for public administration in the area of the refund. CONCLUSIONS: A comprehensive monitoring system for civil funding allocation process in the
health-care system to counteract the imbalance of information.
PCN142
WHAT IS THE CURRENT R&D LANDSCAPE FOR METASTATIC BREAST
CANCER? AN INVESTIGATION INTO RECENT CLINICAL TRIAL
ACTIVITY
Scrutton HC, Samuels ER
Heron Evidence Development Ltd, London, UK
OBJECTIVES: A number of systemic therapies are available for the treatment of
metastatic breast cancer (MBC)—including hormonal therapies, chemotherapeutic
agents, and biologics—but long-term prognosis remains poor. There is a need for new
treatments that improve survival and are effective in a greater proportion of patients.
This research evaluates the recent clinical trial activity directed toward the treatment
of MBC. METHODS: MBC trials were identified through a systematic search of the
records within http://www.clinicaltrials.gov, using the search term “metastatic breast
cancer OR stage IV breast cancer OR advanced breast cancer.” Trials with a start
date from January 2008 onward were included and categorized by nature of intervention (new investigational agent, drug launched for indications other than breast cancer,
or approved breast cancer product); all trials that did not include a pharmaceutical
(biological or drug) were for an unsuitable indication, or that were suspended, terminated, or withdrawn were excluded. The remaining trials were evaluated for a number
of variables, including phase of development and product type. The overall number
of pharmaceuticals under investigation was also explored. RESULTS: The original
search term identified 2014 trials, 365 of which met the inclusion criteria. a large
proportion of these trials (41%) were evaluating products already approved for the
treatment of breast cancer. Of the remaining trials, 68% were investigating new
agents; the remainders were evaluating a product launched for an indication other
than breast cancer. There were a total of 116 new products under investigation,
although these were mainly at an early stage of development with just 8% of trials at
Phase III/IV. CONCLUSIONS: MBC is a key area of research, with a large number
of products in development. However, since the majority of clinical trials are at an
early stage, it will be some years before these products impact patient treatment.
PCN143
PRIMARY PREVENTION AS EXPANDED INDICATION TO MITIGATE
COMPETITION: A CASE STUDY
Nichols E, Wiederkehr DP, Doyle J
Quintiles Global Consulting, Hawthorne, NY, USA
OBJECTIVES: While there are several instances of products gaining expanded indications from secondary treatment to primary treatment/prevention, in some cases,
expanded indications appear to buffer the drug utilization from competitors. However,
the extent to which the later expanded indications impact the utilization of the product
across the lifecycle, including following loss of exclusivity, is not well understood. The
objective was to examine the prescribing volume of a drug throughout its lifecycle in
conjunction with the uptake of a novel class of drugs launched for similar indications
to examine the impact of the expanded primary treatment/prevention indications on
competition. METHODS: Tamoxifen and the aromatase inhibitors letrozole and anastrozole were selected as case products. All three drugs are FDA indicated for the
treatment of advanced breast cancer, yet tamoxifen is the only drug of the group FDA
indicated for the primary prevention of breast cancer. From January 1992 to April
2010, the volume of prescriptions (TRx) was collected monthly using SDI’s VONA
database and grouped according to class sales by active molecule. RESULTS: Generic
sales of tamoxifen maintained a high level after the 1998 approval for the primary
prevention indication of “reduction in breast cancer incidence in high-risk women”
despite competition within active breast cancer treatment indications from the aromatase inhibitors. While the aromatase inhibitors launched in the mid-1990s, their utilization did not begin to encroach on total tamoxifen prescriptions until the expiration
of exclusivity for tamoxifen’s prevention indication in 2003. CONCLUSIONS: This
preliminary analysis shows that the strategy of obtaining a later primary prevention
indication may help maintain utilization of a compound across the lifecycle. The
hypothesis that a prevention indication expansion could mitigate competition should
be further examined among products where primary prevention and primary treatment
indications have distinctly different dosages and/or branding and where the additional
indication is protected by extended exclusivity.
13th Euro Abstracts
PCN144
CURRENT CHEMOTHERAPY AND MONOCLONAL ANTIBODY USE
PATTERNS IN METASTATIC COLORECTAL CANCER IN WESTERN
EUROPE
Zhao Z1, Pelletier E2, Barber B3, Bhosle M4, Wang S1, Klingman D5, Gao SK3
1
Amgen, Newbury Park, CA, USA; 2IMS Health Incorporated, Watertown, MA, USA;
3
Amgen Inc., Thousand Oaks, CA, USA; 4IMS Health, Falls Church, VA, USA; 5IMS
Consulting, Falls Church, VA, USA
OBJECTIVES: Treatment outcomes improved in metastatic colorectal cancer (mCRC)
due to the introduction of the monoclonal antibodies (mAb) in combination with
chemotherapy. This study described current treatment patterns of chemotherapy and
mAbs in clinical practice in 4 EU countries. METHODS: This cohort study used
physician-surveyed data from the LifeLinkTM Oncology Analyzer Database for mCRC
patients in four EU countries (France, Germany, Italy, and Spain). All patients aged
≥21 years at mCRC diagnosis were included. Treatment patterns in 2009 were examined descriptively by lines of therapy. RESULTS: The study sample includes
2734 mCRC patients (61% male, median age category 61–70 years) with 862, 656,
567, and 649 from France, Germany, Italy, and Spain, respectively. In 1st-line, more
patients received FOLFOX-containing regimens than FOLFIRI-containing regimens in
Germany (42% vs. 30%) and Spain (25% vs. 16%), while in Italy and France, the
reverse was true (Italy: 34% FOLFIRI vs. 29% FOLFOX: France: 26% vs. 19%). In
2nd-line, more patients received FOLFIRI-containing regimens than FOLFOX-containing regimens in Germany (36% vs. 18%), Italy (29% vs. 14%), and Spain (34%
vs. 6%), while similar proportions of FOLFOX and FOLFIRI were used in France
(18% vs. 15%). In 1st line, Bevacizumab (Bmab) was administered to 44% of patients
in Italy, 42% in France, 37% in Germany, and 30% in Spain, while Cetuximab
(Cmab) use ranged from 14% in Spain to 7% in Italy. In 2nd-line, Bmab was used in
37% of the patients in Germany, 38% in France, 33% in Italy, and 30% in Spain,
while Cmab was used in 30% of the patients in Spain, followed by 26% in Italy, 20%
in Germany and 17% in France. CONCLUSIONS: FOLFOX- and FOLFIRI-based
regimens are common standard of care chemotherapies, and monoclonal antibodies
are routinely combined with these chemotherapies.
PCN145
INEQUALITIES IN GEOGRAPHICAL ACCESS TO ONCOLOGY SERVICES
IN GREECE AND THEIR IMPACT ON PATIENTS AND CARERS
Souliotis K1, Athanasakis K2, Palaka E3, Kyriopoulos II2, Golna C4, Kyriopoulos J2
1
University of Peloponnese, Corinth, Corinth, Greece; 2National School of Public Health,
Athens, Greece; 3Foundation of Economic and Industrial Research, Athens, Attica, Greece;
4
Roche Hellas SA, Athens, Greece
OBJECTIVES: Previous studies (NSPH 2008, 2009) demonstrated that clustering of
oncology resources exceeds the spatial concentration pattern of health-care services in
Greece, thus resulting to substantial cross-regional flows of cancer patients. The objective of this study was to assess the impact of geographic accessibility on patients when
selecting care and during treatment for cancer. METHODS: Face-to-face interviews
with 106 patients diagnosed with cancer from three specialized anticancer hospitals
(two Athens and one Thesaloniki). Questionnaire was designed by a specialized Delphi
panel of the NSPH to capture patient preferences. Median patient age was 54.5 years.
Data were analyzed using SPSS v.15.0. RESULTS: Patients across the board choose
their hospital on the basis of specialization (50%), physician reference (41.5%), and
hospital reputation (35.8%). Sixty-three percent of patients face access barriers, most
commonly cost of health-care services (44.3%), distance from place of residence
(37%), and demand on time (33%). 76.4% of patients return to place of residence at
treatment intervals and 43.4% immediately after treatment. To receive treatment,
23.6% stay at homes of relatives, 14.2% at hotels, and 1% in hospital-owned hospices. Fifty percent of patients undergo treatment cycles repeating every 15–30 days.
Patients travel predominately by own car (48.1%). 4.7% travel by taxi reimbursed by
their insurance fund and 1% by hospital ambulance. 84% of patients travel accompanied by one or more carers. At treatment intervals, only 8% of patients are supported by physicians at place of residence. CONCLUSIONS: Significant cross-regional
flows of cancer patients to access adequate treatment lead to substantial direct and
indirect costs for patients and their carers in a strained financial environment. Patients
also face significant gaps in integrated support during treatment intervals. a shift in
the organization of cancer services is essential for the system to be responsive to
expressed patient needs especially during treatment.
PCN146
HEALTH RESOURCE UTILIZATION OF SUBJECTS RECEIVING
DENOSUMAB AND ZOLEDRONIC ACID IN A RANDOMIZED PHASE 3
TRIAL OF ADVANCED BREAST CANCER PATIENTS WITH BONE
METASTASES
Body JJ1, von Moos R2, Stopeck A3, Qian Y4, Braun A4, Chung K4
1
Centre Hospitalier Universitaire Brugmann, Brussels, Belgium; 2Kantonsspital Graubünden,
Chur, Switzerland; 3University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ, USA; 4Amgen Inc., Thousand Oaks,
CA, USA
OBJECTIVES: Bone metastases occur in up to 75% of patients with advanced breast
cancer. Skeletal complications of bone metastases include pathologic fracture, spinal
cord compression, and surgery and radiation to bone. In a recently completed trial of
breast cancer patients with bone metastases, denosumab, a fully human monoclonal
anti-RANKL antibody, was superior to zoledronic acid (ZA) in delaying/preventing
A279
skeletal related events (SRE). METHODS: Eligible patients (N = 1026, denosumab;
N = 1020, ZA) received monthly subcutaneous denosumab 120 mg or intravenous
ZA 4 mg in a double-bind, double-dummy design. Health resource utilization (HRU)
data, excluding protocol-specified visits, were collected from all randomized patients
monthly through end of study (median duration 17 months, both groups). RESULTS:
Comparing patients who experienced any on-study SRE (n = 315, denosumab; n =
372, ZA) with patients without an on-study SRE, a greater proportion reported at
least one radiation oncology unit visit (22.9% vs. 8.7%), clinic visit (75.5% vs.
71.1%), and inpatient hospitalization (62.9% vs. 48.6%). The mean number of clinic
visits and inpatient hospitalizations was also greater for patients who experienced an
on-study SRE. A between-treatment group comparison of denosumab versus ZA
demonstrated that for patients with one or more clinic visits who experienced any
on-study SRE, the denosumab group had 10% fewer mean clinic visits compared with
the ZA group (15.5 vs. 17.2 visits). Additionally, mean radiation oncology clinic visits
were decreased by 32% in the denosumab compared with the ZA group (4.2 vs. 6.2
visits) and mean inpatient hospitalizations were decreased by 12% (3.7 vs. 4.2 hospitalizations). CONCLUSIONS: Regardless of treatment group, patients who had an
on-study SRE had greater HRU compared with patients not experiencing an on-study
SRE. In this study, among those with any on-study SRE, patients treated with denosumab had fewer clinic visits, radiation oncology unit visits, and inpatient hospitalizations compared to patients treated with zoledronic acid.
PCN147
MEDICAL RESOURCES UTILIZATION OF FIVE MOST PREVALENT
CANCERS IN TAIWAN (LUNG CANCER, LIVER CANCER, COLORECTAL
CANCER, GASTRIC CANCER, AND BREST CANCER): 2001~2007
Liu JS, Chen LT, Hsiao CF
National Health Research Institutes, Miaoli County, Taiwan
OBJECTIVES: We want to study the real cost structure of cancer treatment using the
National Health Insurance Research Database (NHIRD) from Taiwan. METHODS:
This study adopted a retrospective observational design and the data were retrieved
from the NHIRD, which is managed by the National Health Research Institutes
(NHRI). We used descriptive statistical methods to display data and time trend.
RESULTS: The number of patients with these five cancers showed an increasing trend
in these 7 years. Breast cancer had the highest annual increase (7.34%), followed by
colorectal cancer (3.75%). Lung cancer and breast cancer had the highest average
outpatient cost for each patient per year, while lung cancer, colorectal cancer, and
gastric cancer had the highest average inpatient cost for each patient per year. The
annual increase rates in the total cancer treatment cost for liver cancer, lung cancer,
colorectal cancer, gastric cancer, and breast cancer were 10.70%, 11.61%, 16.73%,
18.38%, and 17.21% respectively. We divided the cost structure of cancer treatments
into chemotherapy, hormone therapy, and supportive treatment. The highest percentages of chemotherapy and hormone therapy were for colorectal cancer (more than
95%) and for breast cancer (more than 11%). On average, the annual increase rates
in the cancer chemotherapy cost per patient for liver cancer, lung cancer, colorectal
cancer, gastric cancer, and breast cancer were respectively 3.59%, 3.66%, 9.86%,
16.78%, and 11.72%. CONCLUSIONS: This study showed a positive correlation
between annual cancer patient number and NHI reimbursement, and an increasing
trend for chemotherapy, hormone therapy, and supportive treatment. The results also
showed that the number of the total amount of NHI reimbursement and the drug
costs had increasing trends in these 7 years. This increased the financial burden of
cancer patients and may alter the allocation of NHI resources.
PCN148
IMAGING TESTS IN STAGING AND SURVEILLANCE OF EARLY BREAST
CANCER (EBC) IN ITALY—CHANGES IN ROUTINE CLINICAL PRACTICE
AND COSTS IMPLICATIONS
Cammarota S1, Menditto E1, Citarella A1, Putignano D1, Riegler S1, Arpino G2
1
CIRFF, Federico II University, Naples, Italy;, 2Federico II University Hospital School of
Medicine, Naples, Italy
OBJECTIVES: New imaging tests such as computed tomography (CT), [18F]fluorodeoxyglucose-positron emission tomography (FDG-PET) scanning, and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) are not recommended for staging or follow-up of asymptomatic
patients with EBC according to current guidelines. However, frequently these tests are
requested even in the absence of a clinical indication. The purpose of this study was
to evaluate how the availability of new imaging techniques has changed staging and
follow-up modalities in EBC patients and to estimate its cost implications. METHODS:
We analyzed clinical computerized information from 457 general practitioners assisting an average of 630,000 inhabitants of the Campania region in the south of Italy.
Incident EBC cases were selected and divided into calendar years from 2005 to 2008.
The mean number of diagnostic tests prescribed per patient (N/Pt) and the mean costs
per patient were evaluated during the first post-diagnosis year. The mean was compared between each year using one-way analysis of variance. Costs were expressed in
Euros (mean ± SD). RESULTS: We identified 576, 489, 474, and 497 newly diagnosed
cases of EBC in 2005, 2006, 2007, and 2008, respectively. Overall, there was a significant increase of the mean number of imaging tests prescribed per patient from
2005 to 2008 (P < 0.0001). No change of the mean number of mammograms, bone
scan, and chest x-ray requested per patient was observed. The mean costs per patient
also significantly increased from c354.96 ± 581.32 in 2005 to c546.78 ± 837.36 in
2008 (P = 0.004). CONCLUSIONS: CT, FDG-PET, and MRI employment for EBC
patients in daily clinical practice has been steadily growing over the past 4 years with
cost repercussions. However, there are no data to support their role in routine breast
A280
cancer staging or surveillance in asymptomatic patients. Further studies are needed to
characterize patients’ typology who deserve intensive staging and follow-up
procedures.
PCN149
DECIDING UPON NEW AND EXPENSIVE TECHNOLOGIES IN HEALTH
CARE: REAL OPTIONS ANALYSIS IN PROTON THERAPY
Grutters J1, Abrams K2, Deruysscher D3, Lambin P3, Pijls-Johannesma M3, Beutner E1,
Peters H1, Joore MA4
1
Maastricht University, Maastricht, Limburg, The Netherlands; 2University of Leicester,
Leicester—UK; 3MAASTRO Clinic, Maastricht, Limburg, The Netherlands; 4Maastricht
University Medical Center, Maastricht, Limburg, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: Radiotherapy with protons is a promising new treatment modality, for
which adoption decisions are being made worldwide. However, the investment costs
of proton therapy (PT) are high (roughly c90 million) and limited clinical evidence is
available. Also, previous studies have indicated that PT may be cost-effective, but show
considerable decision uncertainty. Consequently, it is unclear whether we should
adopt PT now, or wait for more information. Adoption involves a risk of facing high
sunk costs, while delay may impose opportunity losses because patients receive suboptimal treatment. Real options analysis (ROA), a technique originating from financial
economics, assists in making this trade-off. METHODS: We examined whether to
adopt PT, as compared to stereotactic body radiotherapy, in the treatment of stage I
non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC). Three options are available: adopt without
further research (AN); adopt and undertake a trial (AT); or delay and undertake a
trial (DT). The decision depends on the expected net gain of each option, which is
calculated by subtracting its total costs from its expected benefits. RESULTS: The
expected net gain of at and DT were positive, indicating that we should not decide to
adopt without further research (AN). Up to a sample size of 1000 patients, the
expected net gain of at was higher than DT, indicating that the best option was to
adopt and trial. The expected net gain of at was highest for a sample size of 450
patients, which is thus considered the optimal sample size. CONCLUSIONS: Based
on these results, we recommend to adopt PT in the treatment of stage I NSCLC, and
to perform a trial with 450 patients. We have shown that ROA provides a transparent
method of weighing the costs and benefits of all available options, to assist in decisionmaking upon new and expensive technologies.
PCN150
SYSTEMATIC LITERATURE REVIEW ON THE INTER AND INTRA
LABORATORY VARIABILITY OF MOLECULAR TESTING OF RESPONSE
TO TREATMENT OF CHRONIC MYELOID LEUKEMIA (CML) PATIENTS
AND THE ASSOCIATED COSTS AND COST-EFFECTIVENESS
Ratcliffe M1, Hudson PE1, Ossa D2
1
Phmr Consulting, London, UK; 2Novartis Pharma AG, Basel, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: During disease monitoring of patients with CML, for patients with a
complete response, residual leukemia can be assessed by real-time quantitative
polymerase chain reaction (RQ-PCR). There are several “home-brew” and commercially available BCR-ABL gene transcript detection methodologies in use, each
requiring internal validation for the specific laboratory and giving rise to laboratoryspecific data. Harmonization of results according to an international scale is underway, but use is limited for several technical reasons. Information is required for
decision makers on the accuracy and reproducibility of the tests and their costs
and cost-effectiveness. The objective of this study was to assess the quantity and
quality of such information. METHODS: English language systematic literature
review on the intra- and inter-laboratory variability for BCR-ABL molecular monitoring testing, inter-rater reliability across manual assays and the costs and cost-effectiveness of molecular testing in CML. RESULTS: From 88 papers retrieved for detailed
analysis, we found no studies which conducted a repeated test procedure on the same
patient sample using the same technical approach in the same laboratory. There are
a large number of studies which have compared alternative approaches using the same
patient sample in molecular monitoring in the same laboratory. Several well-conducted
studies have examined the variability of results from different laboratories in controlled environments. We found no studies which compared inter-rater reliability or
examined the costs or cost-effectiveness of molecular testing in CML. CONCLUSIONS: There is a reasonable body of evidence on certain aspects of analytical validity
for CML molecular testing, but other aspects of analytical validity and the costs and
economics of molecular diagnostics in CML appear to be an unresearched area.
Testing variability has potentially serious implications for patient outcomes and more
information for decision-makers to assess relative costs and cost-effectiveness is
required.
PCN151
TARGETED CANCER THERAPIES: PRICING, ACCESS, AND UPTAKE
1
2
Aggarwal S , Stevens CA
1
PAREXEL Consulting, Bethesda, MD, USA; 2PAREXEL Consulting, Waltham, MA, USA
OBJECTIVES: The oncology market has become one of the major focus areas for
pharmaceutical and biotech firms. As of March 2009, 15,752 of 39,747 Phase I, II,
and III trials listed on clinicaltrials.gov were related to cancer (approximately 40%).
This large interest in oncology stems from market success of cancer therapies launched
in the past decade and the existence of high unmet need to treat different types of
cancers. As the number of FDA approved cancer therapies increases, there is a need
to understand treatment patterns of these cancer drugs. METHODS: To understand
13th Euro Abstracts
the trends in usage and sales of cancer therapies, we analyzed the US market (sales
and prescription) 2005–2008 data for all FDA-approved cancer drugs. Drugs were
categorized as targeted cancer therapies, chemotherapies, monoclonal antibodies,
small molecules, branded, and generics. RESULTS: During the past 5 years, the usage
of both targeted cancer therapies and chemotherapy drugs has increased by high
double digit rates. From 2005 to 2008, the total prescriptions for targeted cancer
therapies and chemotherapies increased by 66% and 30%, respectively. While the
sales of both types of these drugs are expanding, the majority of sales growth is
attributed to an increasing uptake of targeted cancer drugs. The sales share of targeted
cancer therapies in the US oncology market increased from 36% in 2004 to 56% in
2008. Among targeted cancer therapies, majority (more than 75%) of uptake belongs
to monoclonal antibodies. CONCLUSIONS: The usage and sales trends show a significant increase in the use of cancer drugs. The high usage of targeted cancer therapies
versus chemotherapies shows the rapidly changing nature of cancer treatment
regimen.
PCN153
HOW DO HTA AGENCIES RECOGNIZE AND REWARD INNOVATION?
CASE STUDIES IN BREAST CANCER AND COLORECTAL CANCER
Shah K1, Mestre-Ferrandiz J1, Towse A1, Nash-Smyth E2, Ball D2, Grainger D3
1
Office of Health Economics, London, UK; 2Eli Lilly & Company, Indianapolis, IN, USA; 3Eli
Lilly & Company, Sydney, Australia
OBJECTIVES: This paper examines how different payers and health technology
assessment (HTA) agencies recognize and reward innovation, using treatments for
breast and colorectal cancer as case studies. METHODS: Breast and colorectal
cancer were chosen given the extent of clinical advancements to date and supporting
publicly available data. Sixteen cancer medicines across these two tumor types were
considered. For each medicine/indication, the reimbursement decision and the reasons
behind it were obtained from assessment reports published by the respective agencies
in Australia, Canada, England and Wales, France, and Scotland. RESULTS: Seventyseven decisions were reviewed (39 and 38 for breast and colorectal cancer, respectively). Twenty-four (62%) and 16 (42%) were positive for breast and colorectal
cancer, respectively, while 21% and 45% were negative. In general, HTA agencies
appear to consider advancements in breast cancer treatments as representing good
uses of health-care resources with some assessments yielding less positive or more
restrictive results. The majority of appraisals for newer colorectal cancer treatments
have failed to receive positive recommendations. CONCLUSIONS: We identified some
broad areas where differences of approach have led to different decisions. These relate
to the: 1) acceptability of surrogate end points (e.g., progression-free survival) in cases
where improvement in overall survival has not been established; 2) extent to which
agencies formally consider input from clinical and patient representative organizations
as part of their decision-making process; 3) methods used to assess medicines where
pivotal trial did not use a comparator reflecting standard therapy; and 4) mechanisms
for re-review or adopting performance-based risk-sharing arrangements following
rejection due to uncertain clinical and/or cost-effectiveness. Addressing these issues
may improve the likelihood of innovative medicines meeting reimbursement requirements, for breast and colorectal cancer as well as other therapeutic areas, thereby
increasing the overall health benefit from pharmaceutical development that accrue to
patients.
PCN154
A COMPARISON OF HTA RECOMMENDATIONS FOR CANCER
TREATMENT TECHNOLOGIES PUBLISHED BY AGENCY FOR HEALTH
TECHNOLOGY ASSESSMENT (AHTAPOL) AND NATIONAL INSTITUTE
FOR HEALTH AND CLINICAL EXCELLENCE (NICE)
Kiljan A, Kolasa K, Hermanowski T
Medical University of Warsaw, Warsaw, Poland
OBJECTIVES: The objective of this study was to compare HTA recommendations
for cancer drug technologies issued by both Agency for Health Technology
Assessment (AHTAPol) in Poland and National Institute for Health and Clinical
Excellence (NICE) in the UK. METHODS: The review of HTA recommendations
concerning cancer technologies published online in the period August 2007–June 2010
(AHTAPol) and March 2000–June 2010 (NICE) was performed. The classification of
HTA recommendations based on Raftery’s approach labeling them as positive, positive with major or minor restriction, and negative was conducted. Negative guidance
was categorized as clinical or nonclinical. Reasons for HTA recommendations for drug
technologies appraised by both AHTAPoL and NICE were compared. Contradictory
and noncontradictory recommendations were identified as well. RESULTS: A total of
149 drug technologies were appraised by AHTAPol, of which 39 concerned cancer
technologies (seven resubmissions). NICE published 136 drug appraisals, of which 59
related to cancer technologies (12 resubmissions). In total, 12 cancer drug technologies
were appraised by both AHTAPoL and NICE. Among them, there were nine contradictory and three noncontradictory pairs of guidance (two negative and one positive).
In the group of drug technologies appraised by both agencies, there were 42% and
67% positive HTA recommendations issued by AHTAPoL and NICE, respectively.
Negative recommendations based on nonclinical reasons prevailed in Poland (58%).
At the same time, there were as many positive recommendations with major restrictions (33%) as negative recommendations based on nonclinical reason (33%) in the
UK. The positive guidance without restriction constituted 8% and 17% of all appraisals for cancer drug technologies published by AHTAPol and NICE, respectively.
A281
13th Euro Abstracts
CONCLUSIONS: In a studied period, NICE published more positive recommendations for cancer drug technologies than AHTAPoL. The contradictory
recommendations prevailed in the group of drug technologies appraised by both
jurisdictions.
PCN156
KNOWLEDGE TRANSFER REGARDING CANCER SCREENING BASED ON
INTERESTS OF DIFFERENT TARGET POPULATIONS
Hamashima C
National Cancer Center of Japan, Tokyo, Japan
OBJECTIVES: To develop targeted leaflets regarding cancer screening guidelines that
take account the knowledge required by different target groups. METHODS: Before
developing leaflets, public interest data regarding cancer screening were collected by
the problem solving model (the so-called KJ method developed for field surveys in
Japan). The KJ method includes two steps: label making of information corresponded
to specific issues and grouping similar concepts. Contents of leaflets were edited based
on the results of the KJ methods but changed in the final version according to discussions at a committee meeting involving public members. We compared the results of
the KJ method and contents of the final version of the leaflets for the following groups:
cervical cancer screening targeted at 20-year-old subjects (first group), cervical cancer
screening targeted at subjects aged 30 years and older (second group), and
colorectal cancer screening targeted at subjects aged 40 years and older (third
group). RESULTS: Common interests among the three groups included targeting
cancer and screening methods. Although the KJ method revealed that the first
group expected broad information, in the final version of the leaflet, only basic information regarding participation in cancer screening programs remained. The final
versions in group 2 and 3 almost corresponded to the first interest of an actual plan
to participate in a screening program including details of the screening methods as
well as physical and financial burden expected. Although information regarding the
harm of cancer screening was initially included according to the results of the KJ
methods in the second and third groups, there was no expectation in the first group.
CONCLUSIONS: A targeted leaflet is a powerful tool to share knowledge regarding
cancer screening. We must understand the expectations of different target groups and
prepare appropriate leaflets that support the decision to take part in cancer
screening.
PCN157
REASONS FOR DISCONTINUATION OF HORMONAL THERAPY IN
BREAST CANCER PATIENTS ACROSS FIVE EUROPEAN COUNTRIES
Petrilla AA, Ferrufino CP
IMS Health, Falls Church, VA, USA
OBJECTIVES: Recent evidence suggests that many breast cancer patients discontinue
their hormonal therapy treatment regimen before the end of the recommended treatment period, but reasons for treatment discontinuation are not well understood.
Therefore, we examined reasons for hormonal therapy discontinuation in a European
treatment cohort of female breast cancer (BC) patients. METHODS: Female patients
ages 21+ with a diagnosis of BC between January 2006 and December 2008 were
identified within IMS Oncology AnalyzerTM which provides retrospective, cross-sectional, cancer-treatment data from 14 countries including France, Germany, Italy,
Spain, and the United Kingdom and encompasses over 60,000 de-identified BC patient
records from a physician panel of nearly 800 doctors in the EU5. Patients within the
EU5 with early-stage BC (stages I-IIIa) who received hormonal therapy and for whom
their physician provided a reason for discontinuing first course of therapy were
included in the study. Patients enrolled in clinical trials were excluded. Reasons for
discontinuation of therapy include course completion, progression of disease, stabilization of disease, adverse events, terminal outlook, poor performance, and patient’s
choice. RESULTS: 10,949 patients were identified. Approximately 57.2% discontinued their first course of hormonal therapy prior to course completion. Of these
patients, the top reasons for early discontinuation included progression of the disease
(59.5%), adverse events (21.7%) and patient choice (10.1%). Mean duration of
therapy for all patients was 95.4 months (range 45.5–152.1). Time to discontinuation
was significantly shorter for those who quit due to Aes than those who quit by choice
(36.2 months vs. 57.8 months, P < 0.0001). Of patients that discontinued due to AEs,
hot flushes (46.1%), pain (19.1%), and nausea and vomiting (14.0%) were the most
commonly reported events. CONCLUSIONS: This analysis in a real world setting
provides new insight into reasons for early discontinuation of hormonal therapy in
the EU5.
PCN158
TREATMENT DECISION CHANGE WITH 21-GENE RECURRENCE SCORE
IN PATIENTS WITH EARLY STAGE BREAST CANCER (ESBC): A
META-ANALYSIS
Chien R1, Hornberger J2
1
Cedar Associates LLC, Menlo Park, CA, USA; 2Cedar Associates LLC and Stanford
University, Menlo Park, CA, USA
OBJECTIVES: The 21-gene Recurrence Score® (RS) is a validated assay for estimating
a woman’s recurrence risk and chemotherapy benefit after the diagnosis of estrogen
receptor positive (ER+), ESBC. We conducted a meta-analysis of RS’s influence on
treatment recommendations/decisions in lymph node negative (LN-) disease.
METHODS: Literature was abstracted on cohort studies that reported the change in
the recommendation or actual use of adjuvant chemotherapy (CT) for patients with
ER+, LN-, ESBC before and after the RS. Outcomes evaluated were: treatment decision
change from 1) CT plus hormone therapy (HT) to HT-only or 2) HT-only to CT plus
HT. Actual treatment change was used when available. Reductions in the relative and
absolute CT use associated with the RS were computed with Review Manager (5
Version 5.0.24; Copenhagen: The Nordic Cochrane Centre, the Cochrane Collaboration 2008). The relative change in CT was calculated as a before-to-after ratio of
proportion of patients recommended or received CT, weighted by study sample size.
RESULTS: Seven published studies (n = 912 patients) were eligible for the metaanalysis. One was a prospective physician survey; six were retrospective chart reviews.
a total of 569 (62%) patients were recommended CT prior to RS testing. After RS
testing, 272 (30%) patients were recommended or received CT. In six of seven studies
(n = 652 patients) that reported a treatment change, 212 (32%) patients switched from
CT plus HT before RS to HT-only after RS. The absolute reduction in CT before and
after RS testing was 30% (95% CI [−39%, −21%]). The relative reduction in CT
before and after RS was 49% (95% CI [42%, 58%]). Estimates varied little when
analysis omitted a single study. Limitations include heterogeneity in study designs.
CONCLUSIONS: The meta-analysis shows consistent overall reduction in CT with
the use of RS.
CANCER – Conceptual Papers and Research on Methods
PCN160
THE ROLE OF PATIENT SELECTION CRITERIA IN IDENTIFYING
OVARIAN CANCER PATIENTS
Meyers J1, Mitra D1, Doan J2, Leeflang C3
1
RTI Health Solutions, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA; 2Genentech, Inc, South San
Francisco, CA, USA; 3IMS Health, Watertown, MA, USA
BACKGROUND: Retrospective claims databases are commonly used in outcomes
research. Since physician charts are rarely available to confirm diagnoses, care must
be taken when choosing patient populations. OBJECTIVES: To show how patient
selection criteria affects sample size and chemotherapy treatment rates using an
ovarian cancer (OC) population. METHODS: Patients were initially selected if
they met the following inclusion criteria: at least one diagnosis of OC (ICD-9-CM
codes 183.0x) between 1/1/2002 and 12/31/2007 (first OC diagnosis date termed
index), 6 months pre-index and 12 months post-index eligibility, and no OC diagnosis
in the 6 months pre-index. Additional criteria were imposed to further refine the
sample and assess variations in chemotherapy treatment rates. First, patients were
required to have at least two diagnoses of OC at least 14 days apart. Next, patients
were required to have both OC diagnoses on a record labeled as medical, surgical,
facility, or pharmacy (i.e., ancillary records were excluded). RESULTS: A total of
37,172 patients had at least one diagnosis of OC. Of those, 16,418 had 6 months
pre-index and 12 months post-index eligibility with no pre-index OC diagnoses. In
this population, 26% of patients received chemotherapy. When patients were also
required to have one additional OC diagnosis at least 14 days from index, the sample
size dropped to 7431 patients, of whom 47% received chemotherapy. When OC
diagnoses on ancillary records were excluded, a total of 6213 patients were identified,
of whom 52% received chemotherapy. CONCLUSIONS: Chemotherapy rates among
OC patients varied significantly by the sample selection criteria used. Care must be
taken to identify the correct patient sample in any retrospective database analysis since
selection criteria affect the appropriateness of the sample, and thus the study
results.
PCN161
DECISION-ANALYTIC MODELING IN CHRONIC MYELOID LEUKEMIA—A
SYSTEMATIC OVERVIEW
Rochau U1, Schwarzer R1, Sroczynski G1, Jahn B1, Wolf D2, Gastl G2, Siebert U1
1
UMIT—University for Health Sciences, Medical Informatics and Technology; Oncotyrol—
Center for Personalized Cancer Medicine, Hall, Tyrol, Austria; 2Medical University Innsbruck,
Innsbruck, Austria
OBJECTIVES: To provide an overview on published decision-analytic models evaluating various treatment strategies in chronic myeloid leukemia (CML). We sought to
describe and analyze the structural and methodological approaches used and to derive
recommendations for future CML models. METHODS: We performed a systematic
literature review in electronic databases (Medline/PreMedline, EconLit, EMBASE, and
others) to identify published studies evaluating CML treatment strategies using mathematical decision models. The models were required to compare different treatment
strategies and to comprise relevant clinical health outcomes such as life-years gained
or QALYs over a defined time horizon and population. We used standardized forms
for data extraction, description of study design, methodological framework, and data
sources. RESULTS: We identified 14 different decision-analytic modeling studies,
among which, 13 included economic evaluations. The modeling approaches varied
substantially and comprised decision trees, Markov models, Monte Carlo simulations,
and mathematical equations. Time horizons ranged from 2 years to lifetime. Health
outcomes included survival, life expectancy, and QALYs. Compared treatment strategies comprised bone or blood marrow transplantation, conventional chemotherapy,
interferon-alpha, and first-generation tyrosine kinase inhibitor (TKI) imatinib. None
of the models evaluated comprehensive personalized medicine strategies or second
generation TKI (e.g., nilotinib, dasatinib). Only few models were validated using
A282
independent data. CONCLUSIONS: We found several well-designed models for different CML treatment strategies. However, the quality of reporting varied substantially. We recommend that future models should include novel treatment options,
subgroup evaluations for a more personalized decision making, and validation using
independent data. Already available models with a short time horizon could be
updated with new survival data.
PCN162
EXTRAPOLATION IN TRIAL-BASED COST-EFFECTIVENESS MODELING:
IN SEARCH OF A STANDARD
Ekman M1, Charbonneau C2, Ramsberg J1, Jonsson L1, Sandin R3, Jonsson B4, Drummond
M5, Weinstein MC6
1
i3 Innovus, Stockholm, Sweden; 2Pfizer, Inc, New York, NY, USA; 3Pfizer Oncology,
Sollentuna, Stockholm, Sweden; 4Stockholm School of Economics, Stockholm, Sweden;
5
University of York, York, UK; 6Harvard School of Public Health, Boston, MA, USA
BACKGROUND: Extrapolation is often a key element in health economic modeling.
Although any model should use empirical data if possible, the effects of treatments
on long-term health outcomes are seldom observed within the follow-up time of a
clinical study. Extrapolation over a lifetime horizon will generally be required in
economic models where treatments have different cumulative survival at the end of
the clinical trial. Typically, a within-trial analysis of costs and health effects, in which
outcomes are truncated at the conclusion of the trial, will be overly conservative.
OBJECTIVES: The purpose of this study is to compare different methods of extrapolation in the context of examples concerning oncology, although the principles apply
across all therapeutic areas. METHODS: There is a set of standard assumptions
regarding extrapolation of survival data from clinical studies, ranging from very cautious (“stop-and drop”) to very optimistic (“continued benefit”). The impact of different assumptions regarding extrapolation is explored, and the implications are
discussed. CONCLUSIONS: The choice of extrapolation method has significant
impact on comparative clinical effects, costs, and cost-effectiveness. Based on our
findings and supporting examples, we propose the following: 1) Analysts should
perform and report results under a range of specific standard extrapolation assumptions to increase comparability across studies. 2) The choice of a base-case approach
in any particular study should be guided by knowledge about the biology of the indication under evaluation and the mechanism of action of the treatment. A case could be
made for a reference case method of extrapolation, but we believe that sensitivity
analysis across a standard set of possibilities is sufficient. Adherence to these modeling
practices will contribute to increased transparency in modeling and hence potentially
to a greater confidence among health-care decision-makers in the results from costeffectiveness analyses building on modeling and extrapolation.
PCN163
EXTENDING FIXED EFFECT MODELS TO CENSORED COST DATA
1
2
Baser O , Yuce H
1
STATinMED Research/University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA; 2New York City
College of Technology-CUNY/STATinMED Research, New York, NY, USA
OBJECTIVES: Challenges in analyzing cost data include addressing skewness in cost
distributions, observed and unobserved heterogeneity across samples, and even more
challenging complexities due to censoring. We combined generalized random effect
models with inverse probability weighted (IPW) estimation techniques to address those
challenges in a single model. METHODS: Generalized fixed effect models have been
used with weights that are calculated as inverse due to probability being uncensored.
The Gaussian family and log link function was chosen and we applied a test to see if
possibly censoring bias exists. We also calculated the deviation from the consistent
value if standard pooled ordinary least squares were used. RESULTS: A total of 4824
observations were used in the analysis. We obtained Medicare claim files for the 2
years following patients’ lung cancer diagnosis. Costs had high kurtosis and skewness.
Moreover, 30% of the cases were censored, and therefore, their annual costs were not
observed. The total cost of all care was $63,000 for the 2 years following a lung cancer
diagnosis and $57,000 for incomplete cases. Results significantly diverged from the
standard regression model (P = 0.000). CONCLUSIONS: This paper applied inverse
probability weighted estimation and fixed effect panel data models to an inception
cohort of patients newly diagnosed with lung cancer. Our findings suggest that standard regression models yield inconsistent estimators due to censoring bias. The IPW
least square estimation method removes that bias.
PCN164
THE ECONOMICS OF CHRONIC MYELOGENOUS LEUKEMIA: A
COMPARISON OF MODELING APPROACHES
Taylor MJ
University of York, York, UK
OBJECTIVES: Chronic myelogenous leukemia (CML) is a progressive disease which
arises from damage to the DNA of a stem cell in the bone marrow. This results in the
uncontrolled growth of white blood cells which, in turn, can lead to severe impairment
of an individual’s functioning. The National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) models the costs and benefits of medicines. The structure of these models
is not prespecified and wide variations are often observed, both in the model’s choice
of input parameters and in the structure of the modeling approach. While there is no
such thing as a “correct” model, it is important that different models are compared
and critiqued in order to identify any particular strengths and weaknesses of differing
approaches. METHODS: A review was undertaken, identifying existing published
13th Euro Abstracts
models for CML. The data sources and choice of inputs were compared across each
model and presented in a comparative table. Furthermore, the different approaches
to model structure were examined, and attempts were made to explore the consequences of each approach on the models, costs, effectiveness, and cost-effectiveness
findings. RESULTS: The approaches to modeling CML vary significantly between
different studies. While different data sources are utilitized in each model, this can
usually be explained by emerging data which were not available to other researchers.
However, the overall approach to modeling the disease varied considerably across
each study. Model structures and assumptions for long-term outcomes were key
drivers of the cost-effectiveness results in each model, but were often based on contrasting and contradicting approaches. CONCLUSIONS: This review has highlighted
significant variation in approaches to modelling CML. It is recommended that longterm follow-up from previously published trials should be used to predict the likely
outcomes associated with shorter-term outcomes, such as treatment response.
PCN165
INFLATION ANALYSIS AS A TOOL TO ASSESS COST-EFFECTIVENESS
OF CANCER TREATMENT
Eliseeva E, Apanasevich V, Solodyankina T
Vladivostok State Medical University, Vladivostok, Russia
OBJECTIVES: Cost-effectiveness of chronic diseases drug-therapy is estimated with
the help of various pharmacoeconomic analysis methods. Cost-effectiveness analysis,
cost minimization analysis, cost-utility analysis, and cost-effectiveness analysis are
used most often. We have proposed a modification of the cost-effectiveness analysis,
which makes possible to record patient’s losses during treatment. Inflation coefficient
K and its average value—Kmed may be more reliable tool in assessing the costeffectiveness of treatment of recurrent disease. METHODS: Formula evaluation of the
effectiveness can be expressed as Kt ¨T DC(M/Nt), where k—coefficient of effectiveness of treatment at time t DC—amount invested in the treatment of one person
M—number of patients in the beginning of treatment (original group) N—number of
patients at the time T t—regular interval, running on the account (month, day, year,
etc.) RESULTS: Analysis of the coefficient K shows a tendency to increase with an
increase in DC price for the treatment or—on decreasing the number of patients N,
remaining in the group. As the period t becomes longer, entire formula is decreasing
(inflation). The average coefficient k meaning is calculated according the formula
Kmed ¨T ∑ Kt/t. Coefficient shows the average cost of one free of recurrence
month in one patient from the group. The number of patients in group N decreases
as a disease recurs, which leads to Kmed increase because of reallocating funds spent
on chronic patients for the rest of patients. CONCLUSIONS: The study of economic
efficiency through inflationary coefficient K, we have proposed, is a sensitive method
for estimating treatment costs, and may prove to be a reliable tool for cost-effectiveness
analysis of chronic patient drug therapy.
PCN166
DEVELOPMENT OF A FLAG SYSTEM FOR THE COMPUTERIZED
DETECTION OF CANCER PATIENTS WITH ADDITIONAL TREATMENT
NEEDS BY MEANS OF THE “COMPUTER BASED HEALTH EVALUATION
SYSTEM” (CHES)
Holzner B1, Kemmler G1, Giesinger J1, Gamper E1, Oberguggenberger A1, Zabernigg A2,
Sperner-Unterweger B1
1
Innsbruck Medical University, Innsbruck, Tyrol, Austria; 2County Hospital Kufstein, Kufstein,
Tyrol, Austria
OBJECTIVES: Studies evaluating computer-aided routinely assessment of patientreported outcomes (PRO) suggest important benefits for physicians, patients, and their
treatment. This project’s aim was developing a flag system for computerized detection
of cancer patients with additional treatment needs. METHODS: The detection system
is part of the “Computer based Health Evaluation System (CHES),” a software for
the computerized collection, processing, and presentation of PRO data. The flag
system helps identify cancer patients with conspicuous subscale patterns. This includes
cutoff values (patients marked with orange or red buttons) and significant changes
over time (yellow deltas). The testing data set was derived from a longitudinal study
on QOL (assessed using the EORTC QLQ-C30) in chemotherapy patients at an
oncological outpatient unit. Several criteria of “relevant” changes were compared
regarding the prevalence of such changes in the study population and their statistical
significance on an individual patient level. RESULTS: QOL data of 167 cancer patients
were analyzed (on average 5.3 assessments per patient). The 75th and 90th percentile
showed to be useful cutoff values. Recommended thresholds of relevant QOL changes
appear to be unduly low when considering changes in the individual patient. Based
on empirical data, we suggest a modified criterion of relevant change for the EORTC
QLQ-C30 which appears clinically and statistically more meaningful. CONCLUSIONS: The developed flag system enables physicians to detect patient-reported health
deficits (e.g., fatigue) at one glance. However, more research involving various diagnostic groups is needed for a more profound empirical basis for developing refined
criteria.
13th Euro Abstracts
PCN167
INFORMING THE DECISION: IMPROVING GENERALIZABILITY BY
PARAMETERIZING RELEVANT INFORMATION IN THE ECONOMIC
EVALUATION OF TRASTUZUMAB IN EARLY BREAST CANCER
Joore MA1, Hoomans T2, Tjan-Heijnen V1, Seferina S1, Goettsch W3, Grutters J2
1
Maastricht University Medical Center, Maastricht, Limburg, The Netherlands; 2Maastricht
University, Maastricht, Limburg, The Netherlands; 3Health Insurance Council, Diemen,
Noord-Holland, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: To better inform decision-makers on how practice may deviate from
scientific evidence, and for which factors further research is particularly worthwhile,
through parameterizing factors that may impact the generalizability of economic
evaluations. METHODS: We modeled the long-term cost-effectiveness of trastuzumab
in early breast cancer. Based on a review, five real-world factors that could influence
the cost-effectiveness of trastuzumab in daily practice were identified: comparators,
patient consequences, clinical practice, patient mix, and professional use. To explore
the impact of these factors on (cost-)effectiveness, parameters were added to the model.
Parameter values, ranges, and distributions were based on literature and expert
opinion. Analyses were performed without (trial scope) and with real-world factors
included (decision scope). Cost-effectiveness acceptability curves were drawn and
value of information was analyzed. RESULTS: In the trial-scope analysis, the FinHer
regimen dominated the other two trastuzumab regimens, and was cost-effective compared to usual care (c1.845/QALY). In the decision-scope analysis, the HERA regimen
was most effective, amounting to c50.746/QALY gained compared to FinHer. At a
ceiling ratio of c30.000, the FinHer regimen was most likely to be cost-effective in
both analyses. However, this probability was higher in the trial-scope analysis (98%)
than in the decision-scope analysis (54%). Hence, the probability that in the real world
a wrong decision is made is considerably higher than suggested in the trial-scope
analysis. The parameter for which in the real world further research was most valuable
was the credibility of the FinHer regimen. CONCLUSIONS: Incorporating parameters
that improve generalizability is feasible, even in absence of evidence. Parameterizing
the uncertainty of these parameters provides an estimation of how likely it is for each
comparator to be cost-effective in the real world. Also, it informs decision-makers and
researchers for which parameters further research is most valuable, for instance, in
patient access schemes.
DIABETES/ENDOCRINE DISORDERS – Clinical Outcomes Studies
PDB1
HYPOGLYCEMIA-RELATED HEALTH-CARE UTILIZATION FOLLOWING
INITIATION OF INSULIN ASPART IN A VIAL/SYRINGE OR IN A
PREFILLED DISPOSABLE PEN (FLEXPEN®). ANALYSIS OF REAL-WORLD
UTILIZATION IN THE UNITED STATES
Aagren M1, Luo W2
1
Novo Nordisk Inc, Princeton, NJ, USA; 2Novo Nordisk Inc, Yardley, PA, USA
OBJECTIVES: Diabetes is a chronic and progressive disease that for many patients
requires initiation and intensification of insulin in order to sustain glycemic control
and thereby lower risk of long-term complications. Insulin intensification, however,
can have some negative consequences for patients in the form of increased risk of
hypoglycemic events. This analysis asks the question to what extent the administration
vehicle, prefilled pen versus vial and syringe, has an impact on the risk of hypoglycemic
events. METHODS: This is a retrospective database analysis comparing the incidence
of hypoglycemia-related health-care utilization between patients that were previously
naïve to short-acting insulin initiating the short-acting insulin analogue, insulin aspart
(IAsp), in either a vial or in a prefilled disposable pen (FlexPen®). Data were derived
from health-care claims for individuals with employer-sponsored primary or Medicare
supplemental insurance between 2004 and 2007. The analysis was conducted using
logistic regression technique controlling for age, gender, diabetes type, pre-index
hypoglycemic incidence, pre-index diabetes treatments, and daily consumption of
IAsp. Evaluation period was 12 months. RESULTS: The cohorts consisted of 5523
vial patients and 6065 FlexPen® patients. Mean age of the two cohorts were 53.6
and 56.2 years (P < 0.0001) in vial and FlexPen® groups, respectively. Fifty-one
percent and 54% (P = 0.05) of the populations were males. Generally, a larger proportion the FlexPen® versus the vial cohort were already on an insulin regimen (basal or
premix). Mean number of annual hypoglycemia-related health-care utilization incidence in the period following initiation of IAsp were 1.27 and 0.87 (P < 0.0001) for
vials and FlexPen®, respectively. After multivariate adjustment, the odds ratio of
hypoglycemic incidence with vials versus FlexPen® was 1.36 (CI: 1.20–1.54). CONCLUSIONS: After controlling for potential confounders, the incidence of hypoglycemia-related health-care utilization were 36% higher when initiating IAsp in a vial
compared to initiation with FlexPen®.
PDB2
HOSPITALIZATIONS FOR SEVERE HYPOGLYCEMIAS IN PATIENTS
WITH DIABETES MELLITUS IN SPAIN
Ramirez de Arellano A1, Lindner L2, Alvarez C3, Sanchez-Zamorano M1, De Rivas B3,
Badia X2
1
Bristol-Myers Squibb Iberia, Madrid, Spain; 2IMS Health, Barcelona, Spain; 3AstraZeneca,
Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: To estimate the number of hospitalizations for severe hypoglycemia
(SH) in patients with diabetes mellitus in Spain and assess the differences amongst
A283
regions. METHODS: A retrospective study was conducted using the hospital
Minimum Basic Data Set (CMBD) which collects up to 73% of all hospitalizations in
Spain. All hospitalization episodes of diabetic patients in which SH was the principal
or secondary diagnosis for hospitalization during 2007 were accounted for. a SH was
defined as a hypoglycemic episode which requires hospitalization. RESULTS: The
number of SH episodes as primary diagnosis was estimated at 8242 in relation to total
discharged patients with a diagnosis of DM2 (primary and secondary) at 496,660
patients (1.66% of total). When the number of SH as primary diagnosis is related to
the total number of discharged patients with a diagnosis of DM2 as the primary
diagnosis (23,343 patients), the percentage of episodes become 35.31%. The number
of SH as a secondary diagnosis for hospitalization was estimated at 17,302 episodes:
16,649 in patients with DM2 (96.2%) and 653 in patients with DM1 (3.8%). For
DM2 when SH as secondary diagnosis are added to primary diagnosis, the number
of episodes is 24,891, which means that hypoglycemia diagnosis accounts for 5.01%
of hospitalizations for DM2 patients (496,660 patients). Catalonia shows the highest
number of SH, with 1477 episodes as a primary diagnosis in DM2 patients (17.9%
of total) and 3836 episodes of SH as a secondary diagnosis in DM2 patients (23.0%
of total). CONCLUSIONS: Severe hypoglycemia represents a significant cause for
hospitalization for DM2 patients in Spain: incidence of 1.66% estimated in the overall
DM2 patients increases to 35.3% in the subpopulation of patients discharged for DM2
as primary diagnosis. There is a great variation in the incidence of severe hypoglycemia
between regions.
PDB3
EFFICACY AND SAFETY OF DIPEPTIDYL-PEPTIDASE 4 [DPP 4]
INHIBITORS IN TYPE 2 DIABETES: META-ANALYSIS
Park H, Kim YA, Rascati KL
The University of Texas at Austin, Austin, TX, USA
OBJECTIVES: To assess the efficacy and safety of dipeptidyl peptidase-4 (DPP-4)
inhibitors, including saxagliptin, sitagliptin, and vildagliptin, in type 2 diabetic
patients. METHODS: Meta-analysis was conducted for efficacy (Hemoglobin A1c and
weight) and safety outcomes (hypoglycemia and other adverse events). Both published
and unpublished randomized controlled trials (RCTs) for type 2 diabetic patients using
DPP-4 inhibitors were included. RCTs were selected if criteria included a duration of
at least 12 weeks and they compared DPP-4 inhibitors with placebo or other hypoglycemic medications. Two reviewers independently assessed trials for inclusion and
extracted data. Differences were resolved by consensus. RESULTS: Of 579 potentially
relevant articles identified, 118 were retrieved for detailed evaluation, and 52 met
inclusion criteria. DPP-4 inhibitors significantly reduced hemoglobin A1c compared
with placebo (weighted mean difference, −0.851% [95% confidence interval {CI},
−1.057% to −0.645%]) and were noninferior to other hypoglycemic agents (0.117%
[95% CI, −0.042% to 0.276%]). DPP-4 inhibitor increased weight compared with
placebo (0.186 kg [95% CI, 0.128 kg to 0.244 kg]), but the increase was not significantly different from other hypoglycemic agents. Also compared with placebo, DPP-4
inhibitors had an increased risk of hypoglycemia (odd ratio [OR], 1.430 [95% CI,
1.198–1.708]) and any adverse event (OR, 1.072 [95% CI, 1.003–1.145]). However,
the risk of experiencing hypoglycemia or any adverse event was significantly lower in
patients using DPP-4 inhibitors compared to other hypoglycemic agents (OR, 0.307
[95% CI, 0.247–0.381]; OR, 0.828 [95% CI, 0.765–0.896], respectively). a similar
result was also seen with serious adverse events (OR, 0.834 [95% CI, 0.699–0.996])
and GI adverse events (OR, 0.810 [95% CI, 0.715–0.917]) for DPP-4 inhibitors versus
other oral antidiabetic medications. CONCLUSIONS: DPP-4 inhibitors had similar
efficacy for hemoglobin A1c reduction and weight loss, and had a decreased risk of
hypoglycemia and other adverse events compared with other hypoglycemic agents.
PDB4
A CROSS-SECTIONAL STUDY ON GLYCEMIC CONTROL AND ADVERSE
EVENTS IN TYPE 2 DIABETES MELLITUS PATIENTS TREATED WITH
ORAL ANTIDIABETIC DRUGS IN CHINA
Hu SL1, Sun F2, Xu ZR3
1
Fudan University, Shanghai, China; 2Novo Nordisk (China) Pharmaceuticals Co., Ltd., Beijing,
China; 3The 306th Hospital of PLA, Beijing, China
OBJECTIVES: The study reported the utilization of oral antidiabetic drugs (OADs),
glycemic control, hypoglycemia, and adverse events of type 2 diabetes mellitus
(T2DM) patients with OADs therapy during their clinical visits in urban hospitals in
China. METHODS: The study was a cross-sectional survey conducted at 75 hospitals
in nine cities in China. There were 9577 T2DM patients with OADs therapy completed the questionnaires. The survey period was from December 3, 2008 to July 31,
2009. Patients’ self-report on their diabetes condition and the latest health examination was used to evaluate the diabetes management situation. Descriptive statistics
method was used for the analyses. RESULTS: A total of 51.1% of the patients were
male, the mean age (±SD) was 59.5 ± 12.7 years, and the mean duration of disease
(±SD) was 7.9 ± 6.3 years. The percentage of patients treated with biguanides, sulfonylurea, meglitinides, glitazones, α-glucosidase inhibitors, and others (including traditional Chinese medicine) were 78.4%, 65.1%, 14.0%, 12.6%, 31.1%, and 18.1%
respectively. Blood glucose control was inadequate, the mean HbA1c and fasting blood
glucose were 9.1 ± 2.4% and 9.4 ± 3.4 mmol/L, respectively. Only 7.9% of the
patients achieved the treatment target (HbA1c < 6.5%). There were 15.3% patients
who experienced hypoglycemia episodes in the last 4 weeks, the mean hypoglycemia
rates were 26.0/patient/year, of which major hypoglycemia rates were 7.8/patient/year,
and nocturnal hypoglycemia rates were 6.5/patient/year. There were 60.3% OADs
A284
patients who reported adverse events in the last 4 weeks, of which, 14.8% experienced
digestive symptoms, 8.9% with skin allergies, 22.2% with blurred vision, 4.0% with
liver and kidney damages. CONCLUSIONS: The majority of T2DM patients treated
with OADs in China had suboptimal glycemic control. The adverse events of OADs
treatment impose a high disease burden on patients. It underscores the urgent need
for new therapies in the prevention and management of diabetes.
PDB5
IMPROVING PATIENT KNOWLEDGE AND CLINICAL OUTCOMES
THROUGH A MEDICATION THERAPY MANAGEMENT (MTM) PROGRAM
Pinto SL, Howe JL, Partha G
University of Toledo, Toledo, OH, USA
OBJECTIVES: To examine the effectiveness of an employer-sponsored, pharmacistprovided medication therapy management (MTM) program by evaluating changes in
patient knowledge and clinical outcomes over 1 year in patients with diabetes.
METHODS: A prospective pre–post longitudinal study. Three 10-question knowledge
tests were developed collaboratively by an expert panel of clinical pharmacists and
researchers, as part of the MTM program. Throughout the duration of the program,
pharmacists administered the tests to City of Toledo employees and their dependents
with diabetes, at baseline, 6 months and 12 months. The tests were designed to assess
patients’ understanding of the causes, symptoms, and clinical goals associated with
diabetes, hypertension, and hyperlipidemia. Based on the test results, pharmacists were
able to tailor counseling sessions by educating patients based on the questions
answered incorrectly. Clinical data were simultaneously recorded at 3-month intervals
over 1 year, and included the following variables: A1c, systolic blood pressure (SBP),
and diastolic blood pressure (DBP). Data were analyzed with SPSS v16.0 using descriptive statistics, and Wilcoxin tests. RESULTS: One hundred and one patients enrolled
in the MTM program. Diabetes knowledge improved for 29 patients (58.00%; P <
0.001) after only 6 months. Hypertension test scores improved for 15 patients (65.22%;
P < 0.01) after 1 year. Of those patients, reductions in SBP and DBP toward goal were
seen in 11 (73.33%, P = 0.023) and 15 patients (100%, P = 0.001), respectively. Overall,
41 patients (56.16%; P = 0.042) reduced their A1c toward goal within 3 months; 22
patients (59.46%; P = 0.050) were able to decrease their SBP toward goal, whereas 24
patients (64.86%; P = 0.018) reduced their DPB toward goal after 12 months in the
program. CONCLUSIONS: This community pharmacy MTM program has effectively
shown that consistent patient education delivered by a clinical pharmacist can have a
positive impact on knowledge of disease for patients with diabetes while improving
clinical outcomes concomitantly.
PDB6
PERFORMANCES OF COMORBIDITY MEASURES IN HEALTH CARERELATED BEHAVIORS AND OUTCOMES IN TYPE 2 DIABETES
Ou HT, Balkrishnan R, Erickson SR, Bagozzi RP, Mukherjee B, Piette JD
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA
OBJECTIVES: To assess and compare the predictive and discriminative performances
of comorbidity indexes for health-care outcomes and evaluate comorbidity dimensionality using psychometric techniques. METHODS: The sample was type 2 diabetes in
the Medicaid setting from 2003 to 2007. The conceptual framework was based on
the Aday-Anderson’s Healthcare Utilization model. Four comorbidity indexes targeted
were the Charlson Comorbidity Index, Elixhauser Index (EI), Chronic Disease Score
(CDS), and Health-related Quality-of-Life Comorbidity Index (HRQL-CI). Three
types of outcomes were health-care behaviors, including physician treatment adherence and patient medication adherence, utilization and expenditures. Multiple regression analyses assessed the predictive performance of comorbidity index. The c statistic
(the area under the receiver operator curve) evaluated discriminative validity of the
comorbidity index. Confirmatory factor analysis identified comorbidity dimensionality. The SASTM, STATATM, and LISRELTM statistical software were utilized. RESULTS:
A total of 9832 patients were finally included, with mean age of approximate 45 years
and the majority of them was female (73%) and White (52%). The CDS demonstrated
the best performance in predicting physician treatment adherence and discriminating
medication adherence behavior. The CDS and HRQL-CI mental aspect index had
better predictive validity for medication adherence and similar discrimination for
physician treatment adherence. Diagnosis-driven indexes (e.g., EI) had better performances for health-care utilization and expenditures outcomes compared to medication-based index (CDS). A 7-factor pattern/dimensionality was noticed and it provided
best model fit and predictive performance across different health-care outcomes.
Individual comorbidity dimensions demonstrated differential impacts for a given
outcome. CONCLUSIONS: The CDS and HRQL-CI mental aspect index served as
better risk adjustment tools for studying health-care behaviors. Diagnosis-driven
indexes remained the first choice for health-care utilization and expenditures data.
Comorbidity index which accounts for comorbidity dimensionality provided better
risk adjustment and insightful knowledge regarding the impacts of different features
of comorbidities in predicting patient outcomes.
13th Euro Abstracts
PDB7
PREDICTORS FOR THE INITIATION OF A BASAL SUPPORTED ORAL
THERAPY (BOT) IN TYPE 2 DIABETIC PATIENTS UNDER REAL-LIFE
CONDITIONS IN GERMANY
Hammer H1, Dippel FW2, Kostev K3, Fuchs S4, Kotowa W4
1
Dr. Med. Harm Hammer, Bremen, Germany; 2Sanofi-Aventis Deutschland GmbH, Berlin,
Germany; 3IMS Health GmbH & Co. OHG, Frankfurt am Main, Germany; 4IMS Health
GmbH & Co. OHG, Nürnberg, Germany
OBJECTIVES: To assess the predictors for the initiation of a basal-supported oral
therapy (BOT) in type 2 diabetics (T2D) under real-life conditions in Germany.
METHODS: This historical cohort study included T2D who started an oral antidiabetic drug (OAD) treatment between January 1995 and June 2006 and whose records
were eligible at least 12 months before and 36 months after OAD initiation. Data
were extracted from a representative real-life database (IMS® Disease Analyzer). BOT
initiation was defined according to the ATC code of the European Pharmaceutical
Market Research Association, with A10C2 (NPH insulin) and A10C5 (long-acting
insulin analogues) prescribed additionally to OADs. The time-dependent rate of T2D
starting BOT was calculated by use of the Kaplan–Meier method. Univariate and
multivariate Cox regression analyses were applied to identify predictive associated
factors. RESULTS: A total of 9028 T2D on initial OAD therapy were included, of
whom 1450 patients have been switched to BOT during the observational period. The
probability of BOT initiation was associated with poor metabolic control, midlife age,
and OAD therapy before insulinization. The combined Cox regression analysis identified three groups of particular importance: group I (hazard ratio [HR] = 2.72; P <
0.001): HbA1c > 8%, age 51–60 years, and sulfonylurea (SU), alpha-glucosidase
inhibitor (AGI), or glinide (GLI) as last OAD prescribed, group II (HR = 2.62; P =
0.032): HbA1c > 8%, age ≤ 50 and pretreatment with at least three OADs, and group
III (HR = 2.10; P = 0.019): HbA1c > 8%, pretreatment with a combination of at least
three OADs and SU, AGI, or GLI as last OAD prescribed. The HbA1c threshold of
7.5% led to comparable results, although only group I reached significance. CONCLUSIONS: The probability of BOT initiation for T2D under real-life conditions in
Germany was associated with poor metabolic control, midlife age, and pretreatment
with SU, AGI, or GLI. This knowledge may help to identify patients who might benefit
from an early initiation of BOT.
PDB8
FACTORS ASSOCIATED WITH THE CHOICE OF FIRST INJETABLE
THERAPY AND 6-MONTH TREATMENT OUTCOMES IN PATIENTS
WITH TYPE 2 DIABETES: DATA FROM THE CHOICE STUDY IN
GERMANY
Reaney M1, Matthaei S2, Kiljanski J3, Arellano J1, Nicolay C4
1
Eli Lilly & Company Ltd., Surrey, UK; 2Diabetes Centre Quakenbrück, Quakenbrück,
Germany; 3Eli Lilly & Company Ltd., Warsaw, Poland; 4Eli Lilly & Company Ltd., Bad
Homburg, Germany
OBJECTIVES: CHOICE is an ongoing prospective, multicountry observational study
designed to evaluate time to significant treatment change among adults with type 2
diabetes (T2D) initiating injectable therapy in routine practice, and describing baseline
characteristics, clinical outcomes, and common adverse events over 24 months. Results
presented are from 6-month data analyses of the German sample. METHODS: Data
were collected at initiation of exenatide or insulin, and 3 and 6 months thereafter.
RESULTS: In Germany, 848 patients (394 exenatide, 454 insulin) were enrolled.
Multivariate logistic regression indicated that high BMI, hypoglycemia, and high triglyceride levels were associated with exenatide initiation, while increased age, high
blood glucose levels, and increased frequency of blood glucose monitoring were associated with insulin initiation. Significant treatment changes were made in 20.7% of
exenatide-treated and 29.7% of insulin-treated patients; corresponding discontinuation rates of initiated injectable therapy were 15.5% and 4.1%. At 6 months, mean
(SD) HbA1c change from baseline was −0.8% (1.4%) in the exenatide cohort (baseline
8.2%) and −1.6% (1.7%) in the insulin cohort (baseline 8.8%). 21.5% of patients
initiating exenatide achieved an HbA1c of <6.5% and 42.5% of <7.0%. Corresponding
values for patients initiating insulin were 17.7% and 41.7%, respectively. Mean body
weight changes were −3.7 kg in the exenatide cohort and +0.9 kg in the insulin cohort.
Gastrointestinal symptoms and hypoglycemic episodes were reported by 19.7% and
2.3% of patients in the exenatide cohort, respectively, and 2.5% and 11.3% of
patients in the insulin cohort. CONCLUSIONS: Differences between German patients
who initiated insulin and exenatide appear to reflect recommendations of the German
Diabetes Association and the German health-care authorities, with exenatide favored
when weight is high and hypoglycemia is experienced on oral therapy and HbA1c being
only modestly raised. Treatment outcomes were consistent with results of clinical trials
and both are important components of T2D care.
PDB9
LONG-TERM CLINICAL OUTCOMES OF EXENATIDE ONCE-WEEKLY
VERSUS INSULIN GLARGINE FOR THE TREATMENT OF TYPE 2
DIABETES PROJECTED USING THE CORE DIABETES MODEL
Timlin L1, Beaudet A2, Wilson B3, Bruhn D4, Boye KS5, Palmer JL2, Lloyd A6
1
Lilly, Windlesham, Surrey, UK; 2IMS Health, Allschwil, Basel-Landschaft, Switzerland; 3Lilly,
Basingstoke, Hampshire, UK; 4Eli Lilly & Company, Indianapolis, IN, USA; 5Lilly, Indianapolis,
IN, USA; 6IMS Health, London, United Kingdom
OBJECTIVES: This analysis aimed to determine the long-term incremental difference
in clinical outcomes for exenatide once-weekly (EQW) compared with insulin glargine.
13th Euro Abstracts
a 26-week, randomized, clinical trial in 456 patients with type 2 diabetes failing treatment with oral antidiabetic agents (OAD) was performed to compare EQW to insulin
glargine. EQW and insulin glargine were associated with (LS) mean decreases in HbA1c
(−1.47% and −1.31%), decreases in systolic blood pressure (−3.03 mmHg and
−0.63 mmHg), and changes in body weight (−2.6 kg and +1.4 kg) from baseline, respectively. METHODS: The published and validated CORE Diabetes Model (CDM) was used
to project clinical outcomes over patient lifetimes using the trial data. The model simulates
disease progression by combining 15 Markov-based submodels to determine the occurrence and time to onset of diabetes-related complications, life-years gained, and qualityadjusted life-years (QALYs). Standard CDM utility values for diabetes-related
complications and weight were included in the model. a discount rate of 3.5% was applied.
RESULTS: Treatment with EQW compared to insulin glargine was associated with a
higher life expectancy (11.91 vs. 11.81 years) and quality-adjusted life expectancy
(8.019 vs. 7.846 QALYs). The cumulative incidence of all diabetes-related complications was lower for EQW compared to glargine except for stroke and amputation due
to recurrent foot ulcer: congestive heart failure (31.25% vs. 32.44%), stroke (29.61%
vs. 29.50%), myocardial infarction (20.50% vs. 21.16%), angina (15.73% vs.
16.06%), peripheral vascular disease (12.61% vs. 12.73%), amputation recurrent
ulcer (1.22% vs. 1.19%). Moreover, EQW was associated with a longer mean time
to onset of first complication versus glargine (4.79 vs. 4.59 years). CONCLUSIONS:
Long-term projections based on the findings of a recent randomized controlled trial
indicate that EQW is likely to improve life expectancy and quality-adjusted life expectancy, reduce complication rates, and delay the time to onset of diabetes-related
complications compared with insulin glargine.
PDB10
PREVALENCE AND OUTCOME OF INSULIN ANALOGUE TREATMENT
COMPARING GERMANY, UK, AND FRANCE
Holz B, Schröder-Bernhardi D, Kostev K
IMS Health, Frankfurt, Germany
OBJECTIVES: New classes of antidiabetic medications have been introduced, but
details of their use are not well known. In Germany, several measures have been
undertaken to limit the usage of analogues in T1D and T2D patients. The aim was
to assess the usage patterns of short acting (SA) and basal analogue (BA) insulin in
primary care in Germany compared to UK and France. METHODS: Computerized
patient data from general medicine practices (IMS Disease Analyzer, 01/2007 to
12/2009) throughout Germany, UK, and France have been analyzed on treatment rates
and outcome. RESULTS: In 2009 10,792 insulin patients in France, 20,244 in UK,
and 103,238 in Germany were analyzed. The dominance of BA and SA insulins is
differing by country and diabetes type (Germany: SA insulins in T2D 40.8% vs. UK
95.8% and France 92.3%). Treatment of T1D with analogous insulins is in general
higher compared to T2D (Germany: 56.1% BA in T2D vs. 66.3% in T1D; 40.8% SA
in T2D vs. 74.3% in T1D). Usage share of analogous insulins increased over the 3-year
period in all three countries (T2D patients, Germany: BA usage 47.6% in 2007 vs.
56.1% in 2009; UK: 78.0% in 2007 vs. 83.0 % in 2009, France 82.2% in 2007 vs.
88.5% in 2009). The analysis of HbA1c values in UK and Germany revealed a higher
share of patients with uncontrolled HbA1c values (>7.0) for population treated with
analogues (70.8% in Germany) vs. human insulin (68.4%) vs. OAD (42.9%). Increase
hints to high unmet medical need in human insulin usage and shift to analogues.
CONCLUSIONS: Despite several health political measures in Germany favoring
human insulins over analogues, the prevalence of both SA and BA insulin usage for
diabetes patients continuously increased in Germany in line with UK and France from
2007 to 2009 to meet medical need by higher analogue usage.
PDB11
DRUG-USE PATTERNS OF INITIALLY PRESCRIBED INSULIN DETEMIR
AND INSULIN GLARGINE IN THE NETHERLANDS; A COMPARATIVE
ANALYSIS USING PHARMACY DATA FROM IADB.NL
Visser ST1, Vegter S1, Boersma C1, De Grooth R2, Postma MJ1
1
University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands; 2sanofi-aventis The Netherlands B.V.,
Gouda, Zuid Holland, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: Newer long-acting insulin analogs have shown to result in several treatment improvements if compared with NPH insulins. Promising results from clinical trials
require confirmation from observational settings reflecting potential “real-life” benefits.
Therefore, the current study aimed to evaluate trends in prescribing (uptake), treatment
adherence, and costs of (newer) insulin analogs (e.g., insulin detemir and insulin
glargine). METHODS: A drug-utilization analysis was conducted based on using dailypractice prescription data from IADB.nl (one of the databases available in the Mondriaan infrastructure), a dispensing database of 50 pharmacies, covering a Dutch population
of 500,000. Drug-utilization data were collected for a 7-year period (2000–2007). All
patients that received at least one prescription of an insulin analog—defined following
the “Anatomical Therapeutical Classification” (ATC) as “A10A”—were included for
this study. The prevalence and incidence of insulin use were both presented per 1000
population. Survival analysis was conducted to calculate the persistence on different
insulin analogs. RESULTS: Preliminary results show a fast increase in the proportion
of patients using the newer long-acting insulin analogs with 7% in 2003 to over 30%
in 2006. Among patients initiating these newer insulin analogs, use of insulin glargine
is more than two times higher compared to use of insulin detemir (507 vs. 190 starters
in 2006). Patients that initiated treatment with long-acting insulin analogs were significantly more adherent to insulin glargine compared to insulin detemir (exact figures will
be presented during the presentation). CONCLUSIONS: Current preliminary results
A285
show an increase in use of long-acting insulin analogs. Of these analogs, insulin glargine
is most often initiated and seems to be well-received by patients. Further results will be
presented based on a longer follow-up period including differences in HbA1c level
dependent dosing and trends in cost development for insulin analogs over time. Also,
the potential feature of “channelling” will be investigated.
PDB12
TIME TO OPIOID USE AMONG COMMERCIALLY-INSURED PATIENTS
WITH DIABETIC PERIPHERAL NEUROPATHIC PAIN WHO INITIATED
DULOXETINE VERSUS OTHER TREATMENTS—A PROPENSITY SCORE
APPROACH
Zhao Y1, Wu N2, Chen SY2, Fraser K2, Boulanger L2
1
Eli Lilly & Company, Indianapolis, IN, USA; 2United BioSource Corporation, Lexington, MA,
USA
OBJECTIVES: Diabetic peripheral neuropathic pain (DPNP) is often managed using
opioids which are subject to tolerance and dependence issues. Newer classes of medications have been approved for DPNP; however, published findings assessing utilization
of opioids following treatments with these agents are limited. This retrospective cohort
study compared the subsequent use of opioids between commercially insured DPNP
patients initiating duloxetine treatment versus other standard of care (SOC) therapies.
METHODS: DPNP patients aged 18 to 64 who initiated duloxetine or other SOC
treatments (tricyclic antidepressants, venlafaxine, gabapentin, pregabalin) between
March 1, 2005 and December 31, 2005 were selected. Initiation was defined as a
90-day period without available study medication. The initial dispense date for the
study medication was defined as the index date. Selected patients had no opioid pill
coverage during the 90 days prior to the index date, and no depression, neuralgia, or
epilepsy diagnosis in the 12-month pre-index period. Duloxetine and SOC patients
were matched via propensity scoring (1:1 ratio), controlling for demographics, comorbidities, prior health-care utilization and costs, and prior medication history. Opioid
utilization and health-care costs over the 12-month post-index period were compared
between study cohorts. RESULTS: A total of 113 patients in each of the duloxetine
and SOC cohorts were matched. Duloxetine-treated patients were less likely to use
any opioids versus SOC-treated patients (52.2% vs. 79.6%, P < 0.01) over the
12-month post-index period. Compared with SOC patients, duloxetine patients had,
on average, 110 days delay in opioid use, two fewer prescriptions dispensed, 32 fewer
days on opioids, and 2064 mg lower morphine equivalent dosage (all P < 0.01) over
the 12-month post-index period. Duloxetine patients also had significantly lower total
($19,408 vs. $30,470, P < 0.01) and outpatient costs ($7,606 vs. $15,272, P < 0.01).
CONCLUSIONS: Among commercially insured DPNP patients, duloxetine treatment
appears to be associated with delayed and reduced opioid utilization and lower healthcare costs than SOC therapies.
PDB13
DIAPS 79, PRELIMINARY REPORT OF AN OBSERVATIONAL STUDY OF
COSTS OF TYPE 2 DIABETES MELLITUS (T2DM) TREATMENT IN THE
BRAZILIAN PRIVATE HEALTH-CARE SYSTEM (PHS)
DIAPS79 study group1, Bahia L2, Eliaschewitz FG3, Franco L4, Hayashida CY5, Schaan BD6,
Forti A7, Cintra M2, Andrade PC8, Barbosa E8, Nita ME8, Rached R8
1
Diabetes Mellitus Type 2 in the Brazilian Private Health Care System DIAPS79, São Paulo,
SP, Brazil; 2MedInsight, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil; 3CPCLIN—Centro de Pesquisas Clínicas,
São Paulo, SP, Brazil; 4FMUSP, Ribeirão Preto, SP, Brazil; 5Hospital Santa Cruz, São Paulo, SP,
Brazil; 6Clínica Pró Gastro & UFRGS, Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil; 7Centro Integrado de Diabetes
e Hipertensão & UFCE, Fortaleza, CE, Brazil; 8Bristol-Myers Squibb Farmaceutica S/A, São
Paulo, SP, Brazil
BACKGROUND: Despite the progress of clinical trials, clinicians and decision-markers often lack knowledge on how to better promote health-care delivery to patients
with T2DM in clinical practice. Outcome research studies can provide effectiveness
and economic analysis in actual practice in order to improve clinical performance.
OBJECTIVES: To describe the resources used and the costs associated with outpatient
treatment of T2DM in the Brazilian PHS. METHODS: This is a cross-sectional analysis of 383 T2DM outpatients treated in five cities by various health plans. Data were
collected using info from the previous year by interviewing patients using a validated
questionnaire complemented by medical chart review. Direct costs included expenses
associated with medications, diagnostic tests, procedures, blood glucose test strips,
and health professional visits. Nonmedical direct costs included expenses with diet
products. Indirect costs were not assessed. RESULTS: The group had a mean age of
60.5 ± 9.6 years and a mean duration of diabetes of 12.2 ± 8.75 years. Annual outpatient cost of T2DM care was R$10,645.78 per patient, being R$9,534.58 for direct
medical costs and R$1,111.20 for nonmedical costs. Costs escalated as duration of
diabetes increased (R$8796.68 per patient <9 years vs. R$13,231.74 >19 years of
disease; P = 0.05). Those patients with associated microvascular and macrovascular
complications (n = 18%) have higher costs (R$15,755.12 per patient) compared to
those with microvascular (R$9178.38 per patient; n = 32.4%), macrovascular
(R$8726.13 per patient; n = 8.1%), or no complications (R$8246.53 per patient; n =
41.5%). Annual per patient expenses included medications (R$5542.94), blood
glucose home monitoring (R$1,014.62), private health professional visits (R$4,264.04),
and diet products (R$1,111.20). Health plans expenses per year were due to exams/
procedures (R$588.02 per patient), medications co-payment (R$1,029.00 per patient),
and health professional visits (R$734.12 per patient). CONCLUSIONS: The outpatient care costs assessed reveal that diabetes poses a serious social and economic
burden to patients and to Brazilian PHS.
A286
PDB14
HOSPITALIZATION ATTRIBUTED TO DIABETES MELLITUS AND ITS
COMPLICATIONS IN THE PRIVATE HEALTH-CARE SYSTEM IN
RIBEIRÃO PRETO REGION, BRAZIL
Rosa R1, Bahia L2, Monteiro R3, Asano E4, Nita ME4, Donato BM5, DIAPS79 study grou P6
1
UFRGS, Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil; 2MedInsight, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil; 3USP, Ribeirão Preto,
SP, Brazil; 4Bristol-Myers Squibb S/A, São Paulo, SP, Brazil; 5Bristol-Myers Squibb, Wallingford,
CT, USA; 6Diabetes Mellitus Type 2 in the Brazilian Private Health Care System DIAPS79,
São Paulo, SP, Brazil
INTRODUCTION: Studies about the impact of hospitalizations for diabetes in the
Private Health System are unknown in Brazil. OBJECTIVES: To estimate the dimension of hospitalization for diabetes mellitus (DM) and its complication in the private
health-care system in Ribeirão Preto (RP) region, São Paulo. METHODS: Hospitalization data from 26 private hospitals of RP region (26 cities) were collected from a
database of Social Medicine Department from São Paulo University (CPDH-Centro
de Processamento de Dados). These data comprised an average of 35,964 admissions
per year (2006–2007) of patients from 30 to 74 years old. Combinations of DM
prevalence and hospitalization relative risk for chronic complications and general
medical conditions (GMC) were added to DM first-listed hospitalizations (attributable
risk methodology). The chronic complications diagnoses were divided into five groups:
neurological disease, peripheral vascular disease (PVD), cardiovascular disease (CVD),
renal disease, and other diabete-related complications. RESULTS: From the whole
admissions, 6037 (17%) hospitalizations were attributed to DM (first-listed, chronic
complications, and GMC), 3520 (58.3%) women and 2517 (41.7%) men, 1145 (19%)
were from 30 to 44 years old patients, 2284 (38%) from 45 to 59, and 2607 (43%) from
60 to 74. DM as first-listed diagnosis accounted for 313 (5.2%) hospitalizations, chronic
complications for 2394 (39.6%), and GMC for 3330 (55.2%). CVD (5.3%) and PVD
(8.7%) represented 14% of all hospitalizations in the whole population, contrasting to
34.3% (20.9% and 13.4% respectively) in hospitalizations attributed to DM. Hospitalization rates were very similar between sex, except for cardiovascular disease (25% men vs.
18% women). Admissions due to DM represent 37% out of all hospitalizations for chronic
diseases (6478). They represent 28% for neurological diseases, 42% for PVD, 41% CVD,
and 20% for renal diseases. CONCLUSIONS: DM and its complications impose a
relevant burden to private health-care system in Ribeirão Preto region, especially for
PVD and DCV hospitalizations.
PDB15
WEIGHT CHANGE FOR PATIENTS WITH TYPE 2 DIABETES: SECULAR
TRENDS AND IMPACT OF DIFFERENT COMBINATIONS OF THERAPY
Morgan CL1, Poole CD1, Jenkins-Jones S1, Evans LM2, Currie CJ
1
Pharmatelligence, Cardiff, UK; 2University Hospital of Wales, Cardiff, Vale of Glamorga, UK;
3
Cardiff University, Cardiff, Wales, UK
OBJECTIVES: To describe the secular trend of weight gain for patients with type 2
diabetes and patterns of weight change associated with different diabetes therapy
regimens using data from general clinical practice. METHODS: Data were extracted
from the THIN database, where patients with type 2 diabetes were identified. The
secular trend in weight for patients with type 2 diabetes was plotted for each year
from 1995 to 2008 for both prevalent and for incident cases. Baseline weight at the
start of the treatment period was compared to absolute and relative weight at circa
6-, 12-, and 24-month periods and compared using the Wilcoxon signed rank test for
different treatment regimens. RESULTS: Mean, standardized prevalent weight
increased from 84.9 to 93.6 kg for males and from 75.2 kg to 82.1 kg for females
between 1995 and 2008. For incident cases, the respective figures were 89.6 kg to
96.6 kg for males and 78.4 kg to 85.7 kg for females. The total number of valid
therapy periods was 105,991, accounting for over 70 different regimen combinations.
There were 28 therapy combinations with a minimum of 50 observations which were
selected for analysis. Between baseline and 6, 12, and 24 months, there were significant
changes in weight for the majority of treatment regimens. The largest weight increase
at 12 months was for patients prescribed metformin, insulin, sulfonylurea, and thiazolidinedione (median increase of 4.9 kg [95% CI 1.5 to 7.4, P < 0.001]). The largest
weight decrease at 12 months patients prescribed metformin and exenatide with a
median decrease of −8.1 kg (95% CI −11.0 to −5.0, P < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS:
There was evidence of a secular trend of weight increase for patients with diabetes.
As the impact of weight increase upon vascular outcomes is clear, consideration should
be given to the affect that different treatment regimens have upon weight change.
PDB16
INSULIN GLARGINE IS ASSOCIATED WITH A LOWER INCIDENCE OF
DIABETIC FOOT SYNDROME AND MACROVASCULAR COMPLICATIONS
COMPARED TO NPH INSULIN IN TYPE 2 DIABETICS UNDER GERMAN
REAL-LIFE CONDITIONS
Siegmund T1, Dippel FW2, Kostev K3, Lauterbach S4, Fuchs S5, Kotowa W5
1
Städt. Klinikum München GmbH, Munich, Germany; 2Sanofi-Aventis Deutschland GmbH,
Berlin, Germany; 3IMS Health GmbH & Co. OHG, Frankfurt am Main, Germany; 4Apotheke
Rotes-Kreuz-Krankenhaus, Kassel, Germany; 5IMS Health GmbH & Co. OHG, Nürnberg,
Germany
OBJECTIVES: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the relationship between the
long-acting insulin analogue glargine (GLA) versus Neutral Protamine Hagedorn
insulin (NPH) regarding the incidence of diabetic foot syndrome (DFS), myocardial
infarction (MI), and ischemic stroke (IS) in type 2 diabetics (T2D) under real-life
conditions in Germany. METHODS: A historic cohort study based on a representative
German database (IMS® Disease Analyzer) included T2D who started a basal sup-
13th Euro Abstracts
ported oral therapy (BOT) with either GLA or NPH between July 2000 and September
2007 (index date) and who provided continuously documented data between 12
months before and 24 months after initiation of BOT. Data were collected from index
date until the occurrence of an event (DFS or MI/IS) or until August 2009. Duration
of therapy was ≥24 months to demonstrate a potential effect of insulins considered.
Therefore, the end points were measured as from the second year after index date.
The identification of the end points was according to ICD-10 codes (MI: I22 and I23;
IS: I63 and I64) or the original doctors texts (DFS). Kaplan–Meier curves were generated and compared by log-rank tests. Cox proportional hazard models were used to
estimate the adjusted hazard ratio (HR) for the incidence of DFS and MI/IS. RESULTS:
A total of 23,395 T2D fulfilled the inclusion criteria and started a BOT either with
GLA (n = 9,638) or with NPH (n = 13,757). After adjustment for demographic and
clinical variables, it could be demonstrated that GLA reduced the relative DFS risk by
64 % in T2D when compared to NPH (HR = 0.611; P = 0.0405). Furthermore, GLA
decreased the relative MI/IS-risk by 49 % (HR = 0.671; P = 0.0562). CONCLUSIONS:
When compared to NPH, GLA significantly reduces the risk of DFS in T2D under
real-life conditions. Additionally, a reduction of the macrovascular events MI/IS was
shown with GLA versus NPH. Prospective trials should be conducted to confirm these
results.
PDB17
GLYCATED HEMOGLOBIN AS A SURROGATE MARKER FOR THE
APPEARANCE AND PROGRESSION OF MACRO VASCULAR
COMPLICATIONS IN TYPE 2 DIABETES MELLITUS: SYSTEMATIC
REVIEW AND META-ANALYSIS
Weczorek A1, Marcisz A1, Rys P2, Skrzekowska-Baran I1, Plisko R1, Wladysiuk M1
1
HTA Consulting, Krakow, Poland; 2NovoNordisk, Warsaw, Poland
OBJECTIVES: We performed a systematic review and meta-analysis to examine the
association between HbA1c and the appearance and progression of macrovascular
complications (MVC) in T2DM. METHODS: The two electronic medical databases
(MEDLINE, CENTRAL) were searched to identify all papers reporting HbA1c level
and macrovascular complications in T2DM. Observational and randomized, controlled trials (RCTs) with at least 1 year of follow-up were included. Estimates were
made of the adjusted relative risk (or odds ratio) of complications for an increase in
HbA1c of 1%. If data were insufficient to calculate RR, the odds ratio (OR) was estimated. Weighted mean differences (WMD) in HbA1c level between the case group and
the control group were also calculated. RR (OR) was estimated for HbA1c increase of
1%. RESULTS: We identified 11 trials that fulfilled the inclusion criteria. Pooled data
from two randomized studies showed that RR of the incidence of stroke was 3.40
(95% CI: 1,77; 6.56), myocardial infarction (two studies): 3.19, (95% CI: 1.41; 7.24)
and the risk of extremity amputation or vascular surgery caused by peripheral vessels
(two studies): 2.12 (95% CI: 1.08; 4.16). The results were confirmed in observational
studies for stroke and myocardial infarction. No correlation was found between deaths
from cardiovascular disease and HbA1c increase: RR = 1.21, (95% CI: 0.64; 2.28), but
it was shown in observational studies: RR = 5.72 (95% CI: 0.76; 43.02). CONCLUSIONS: Relatively low number of studies and the number of observed macrovascular
complications impede unequivocal conclusions. However, the results of our systematic
review indicate a correlation between HbA1c level and appearance and progression of
MVC in T2DM, especially stroke, heart infarction, and peripheral vessel disease. Thus,
HbA1c might be considered a surrogate end point for MVC in T2DM, although influence of other factors (e.g., blood pressure, LDL cholesterol) should be considered.
DIABETES/ENDOCRINE DISORDERS – Cost Studies
PDB18
EVALUATION OF CLINICAL INERTIA IN DIABETES CARE OF
NON-INSULIN-DEPENDENT TYPE 2 DIABETIC PATIENTS
Font B1, Galera J2, Lahoz R3, Gambús G2, González Clemente JM4
1
Novartis Pharma, Barcelona, Spain; 2Novartis Pharma, Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain; 3Novartis
Farmacéutica S.A., Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain; 4Corporació Sanitària Parc Taulí, Sabadell,
Barcelona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Clinical inertia (CI) is usually defined as the absence of drug therapy
intensification in patients who fail to achieve the objectives of standard treatment.
This study aims to describe the CI associated with a noninsulinized patient population
with type 2 diabetes (DM2) in Spain. METHODS: Epidemiologic, retrospective, and
multicenter study conducted in primary and specialist care consultations from Spain.
Inclusion criteria were: adults with non-gestational DM2 and uncontrolled status
(HbA1c ≥ 7%), oral hypoglycemic therapy initiated at least 2 years before, and HbA1c
values available for a minimum period of three visits. Complete CI was defined as the
absence of hypoglycemic treatment intensification in all uncontrolled HbA1c values.
Partial CI was defined as the absence of intervention for at least one uncontrolled
HbA1c value. RESULTS: 1555 patients who met all inclusion criteria have been
included. Mean (SD) patients’ age was 64.7 ± 10.3 years and time from diagnosis was
9.2 ± 5.7 years. Seventy-four percent of patients presented abdominal obesity. Complete CI was estimated as 13.5%, while partial CI was observed in 31.4% of controlled
patients and 71.8% of uncontrolled patients. The mean changes of treatment were
1.0 ± 1.02 in controlled patients vs. 1.8 ± 1.2 in uncontrolled patients (P < 0.0001).
Significant factors statistically associated (P < 0.05) with current lack of glycemic
control were: obesity, sedentary lifestyle, hypertension, hyperlipidemia, total number
13th Euro Abstracts
of risk factors, and smoking status. Patients with ≥4 risk factors account for 71.7%
of current glycemic control group, while this value reached 84.3% in the uncontrolled
group (P < 0.0001). CONCLUSIONS: In one out of seven patients with DM2 and
poor glycemic control, none action to intensify treatment has been taken during the
past 2 years. Patients without current glycemic control have more than two times
higher clinical inertia than the controlled ones. Intensification of treatment is twice as
common in patients currently uncontrolled (85.1% vs. 44.9%).
PDB19
BUDGET IMPACT ANALYSIS OF SAXAGLIPTIN FOR THE TREATMENT
OF TYPE 2 DIABETES IN MEXICAN POPULATION AT PEMEX
Juarez-Garcia A1, Martinez-Rivera G1, Anaya P2, Donato BM3
1
Bristol-Myers Squibb, Mexico City, Mexico; 2AstraZeneca, Edo. de Méx., Mexico;
3
Bristol-Myers Squibb, Wallingford, CT, USA
OBJECTIVES: Diabetes affects approximately 8 million people in Mexico and is the
first cause of death in the country. Ninety percent of all diabetes is classified as type
II diabetes (T2DM). Saxagliptin, a DPP4 inhibitor, is one of a class of drugs orally
administered for treatment of T2DM. Petroleos Mexicanos (PEMEX) health-care
system covers approximately 43,977 patients diagnosed with T2DM. The objectives
of this study are to: 1) analyze the current utilization and expenditure for oral antidiabetics (OADs) by PEMEX; and 2) evaluate the budget impact of saxagliptin for
treatment of T2DM population. METHODS: An MS Excel-based budget impact
model of the total population diagnosed with T2DM in PEMEX was used. OAD usage
was based on the total amount purchased, by the Institution in 2009. The prices of
medications were taken from the published price listing by PEMEX (2009). The following OAD medications were included in the analysis: pioglitazone, rosiglitazone,
vildagliptin, and saxagliptin. Pharmaceutical expenses of OADs were considered
excluding other medical costs. The time horizon was 3 years and the assumptions of
the model including market dynamics were estimated by Bristol Myers Squibb. The
budget impact is reported in terms of additional annual total costs. Results are presented in US dollars with an exchange rate of $13.4 MXN. RESULTS: The usage of
saxagliptin in PEMEX represents savings to the institution of US$56,132 for the first
year of use, with increases in savings for year two and year three US$102,910 and
US$154,441 respectively. The impact of saxagliption on the budget was primarily
driven by the gradual substitution of pioglitazone, rosiglitazone, and vildagliptin with
saxagliptin over the 3-year of analysis. CONCLUSIONS: The budget impact of adding
saxagliptin as a treatment option for T2DM patients reveals that the accumulated
savings for PEMEX for the estimated timeframe is around US$ 313,485.
PDB20
A PHARMACOECONOMIC MODEL FOR ADJUVANT TREATMENT IN A
SMOKING CESSATION INTERVENTION IN PATIENTS WITH TYPE 2
DIABETES MELLITUS AND CHRONIC OBSTRUCTIVE PULMONARY
DISEASE
Kayadibinli M1, Durguner B1, Ulus P1, Ozdemir B2
1
Pfizer Pharmaceuticals, Istanbul, Turkey; 2Omega Contract Research Organization, Ankara,
Turkey
OBJECTIVES: The present model was aimed to demonstrate the annual cost of the
smoking-related diseases in patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus (DM) and chronic
obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), and to establish the budget that would be
saved with varenicline (nicotinic receptor partial agonist) reimbursement by the government. METHODS: The model was carried out in two contexts; the costs of the
smoking-related diseases and exacerbations in patients with type 2 DM and COPD
were estimated in smoking conditions, and varenicline use. The model was constructed
on a total of 900,000 type 2 DM patients and 106,410 COPD patients by assuming
approximately 3.8 million type 2 DM patients and 2.0 million COPD patients in
Turkey of which 23% and 48% were considered to be smokers, respectively.
RESULTS: According to the model, the ratio of patients willing to quit smoking was
estimated as 35% in type 2 DM group and 54% in COPD group. Of those, 20% (n
= 63,000) type 2 DM patients and 30% (n = 17,238) COPD patients were assessed
to use varenicline. The annual cost of the smoking-related diseases and exacerbations
was calculated as 72.40 million USD according to the 43,341 events; the unit direct
costs for myocardial infarcts, stroke, and congestive heart failure were calculated as
US$2,523.55, US$1,930.70, and US$1,412.33, respectively, in type 2 DM patients,
whereas it was US$1,567.55 in COPD patients. After varenicline use, the government
would save US$9.47 million per year by 5608 preventable events. Moreover, the
annual cost of varenicline was estimated to be US$23.46 million for 80,238 patients.
Accordingly, the total cost of the smoking-related diseases and exacerbations would
be US$13.99 million for the first year. CONCLUSIONS: Varenicline reimbursement
decreases the annual cost of the smoking-related diseases and exacerbations in patients
with type 2 DM and COPD.
PDB21
COMPARISON OF COSTS OF THE INSULIN TREATMENT OF TYPE 2
DIABETES MELLITUS WITH INSULIN GLARGINE AND INSULIN
DETEMIR
Álvarez Guisasola F1, Mauricio Puente D2, Garcia Coscolin T3, Rubio Terres C4
1
Center of Health La Calzada, Gijón, Asturias, Spain; 2Vilanovaxs Arnau Hospital, Lleida,
Spain; 3Sanofi-Aventis, Madrid, Spain; 4Health Value, Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Large published data suggested that some patients initiating with the
recommended once-daily detemir administration require twice-daily dosing to opti-
A287
mize blood glucose control; therefore, the clinical outcome in this selected population
was tested in a randomized controlled trial. The objective of this study is to compare
the costs of two treatments of type 2 diabetes mellitus (DM2): Insulin glargine
(glargine) and insulin detemir (detemir) in patients with DM2 not controlled with
OADs. METHODS: A costs analysis of the insulin treatment was carried out with
National Health System perspective. Costs with glargine or detemir linked to DM2
patients were calculated according to the administered doses in a clinical trial of 24
weeks of duration, which included 964 insulin-naive patients, with a DM2 average
duration of 10 years and average HbA1c = 8.7%. For both insulin, started dose was
0, 2 U/kg. The administration of a daily dose of glargine and two daily doses of
detemir led to similar average levels of glycosylated hemoglobin (−1.46 ± 1.09 and
−1.54 ± 1.11 %; P = 0.149). However, patients treated with glargine needed significantly minor insulin than those treated with detemir (43.5 vs. 76.5 U, P < 0.001).
RESULTS: The application of this model would be translated in minor daily costs for
glargine and concretely its use would suppose an annual cost of c814.52 opposite to
the c1461.5 of detemir. In consequence, utilization of glargine instead of detemir
would be associated with an annual saving of c647.13 for patient with DM2, which
supposes a saving of 44.2% with glargine opposite to detemir. CONCLUSIONS:
According to the present model, in the above mentioned population, insulin glargine
is a treatment of the DM2 associated with minor costs than insulin detemir.
PDB22
COST STUDY OF SELF-MONITORING BLOOD GLUCOSE THROUGH
GLUCOMETERS IN PATIENTS WITH DIABETES MELLITUS II IN SPAIN
Franch J1, Orozco D2, García A3, Coiduras A4, Buendía C5, Febrer L6, Lizan L7
1
CAP Raval Sud, Barcelona, Catalunya, Spain; 2Research Unit Alicante—San Juan, Alacant,
Spain; 3Primary Care Ciudad Real, Ciudad Real, Spain; 4SAP Esquerre, Barcelona, Catalunya,
Spain; 5EAP Sants, Barcelona, Catalunya, Spain; 6Bayer Healthcare, Barcelona, Spain;
7
Outcomes’10, Castellon, Spain
OBJECTIVES: The objective of this study is to determine the potential differences in
the economical impact for the National Health System (NHS) in Spain of using different glucometric systems for self-monitoring blood glucose (SMBG) in patients with
type II diabetes mellitus (DM II). METHODS: An economic model was built based
on three information sources: 1) literature review; 2) costs databases; and 3) expert
opinion. Six different glucometers were analyzed according to their codification characteristics and their corresponding strips package characteristics, leading to four different system possibilities: 1) autocoded/individual strip package; 2) manually coded/
individual strip package; and 3) autocoded/ collective strip package; and 4) manually
coded/collective strip package. The perspective was that of the NHS. RESULTS: With
more than 2 million people suffering from DM II in Spain, we calculated the impact
of glucometer miscoding relating it to cardiovascular episodes and glucose disorders
occurred. Also, collective strip package implied, due to shorter time of strip stability
after its opening, considerable strip waste especially in those patients with low frequency of SMBG recommendation. Results show that autocoded glucometers which
have individual package for strips safe c5 million (10%) versus those manually coded
and having individual strip package in diabetic patients’ management to the NHS;
versus those autocoded but with collective strip package, savings rise to c15 million
(24%) and versus those manually coded and with collective package the amount of
saving is of c22 million (31%). The one-way sensitivity analysis performed with the
most relevant variables confirmed this tendency. CONCLUSIONS: Glucometric
systems not requiring patient intervention for coding and with individual strip package
minimize the total cost of SMBG of type II diabetic patients in Spain.
PDB23
COST ANALYSIS FOR THE TREATMENT OF DIABETES MELLITUS IN
DIFFERENT HEALTH SECTORS OF HEALTH-CARE SYSTEM OF
PAKISTAN
Malik M, Hussain A, Khan J
Hamdard University, Islamabad, Punjab, Pakistan
OBJECTIVES: Despite the efforts made worldwide, data regarding the cost of care in
Pakistan are scarce. This study was aimed at assessing the direct costs incurred in the
treatment of diabetes and its variation among government, semi-government, and
private sectors of Islamabad, Pakistan. METHODS: It was a comparative cross-sectional study in which data was collected from patients by conveniently sampling. The
direct cost of treatment of diabetes was determined in terms of variables consultation
fee, cost of medicine, travelling cost, fees for laboratory test for glucose monitoring,
cost of home blood glucose monitoring device, and cost of strips used for home blood
glucose monitoring. RESULTS: The annual mean direct cost for government, semigovernment, and private sectors were Rs. 6481.73, Rs. 9785.25 and Rs. 27790.31,
respectively, while the monthly mean directs costs were Rs. 540.14, Rs. 815.43, and
Rs. 2315.85, respectively. The total direct cost of treatment of diabetes per month for
all health facilities was Rs. 986.61. It was found from the analysis that the mean costs
for individual variables were highest in the private sector as compared to semi-government and government sector. The consultation fee charged by the private sector is
much higher than the other two sectors. CONCLUSIONS: The private sector of Pakistan is incurring more cost for the treatment of diabetes mellitus. This difference in
cost among health sectors is a burden on the economic status of the country. Moreover, untreated diabetes or comorbidities increase the overall treatment cost and this
can affect the affordability of the patient.
A288
PDB24
DIRECT HEALTH CARE COSTS OF DIABETES MELLITUS IN HUNGARY
Vokó Z1, Nagyjanosi L2, Kalo Z1
1
Eötvös Loránd University, Budapest, Hungary; 2Syreon Research Institute, Budapest, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: Diabetes mellitus is responsible for a huge burden of disease. Our
objective was to estimate the direct health-care costs of patients with diabetes in
Hungary. METHODS: Real-world data were retreived from the National Health
Insurance Fund database. Diabetic patients were defined as persons who filled in a
prescription of oral antidiabetics (OAD) or insulin in Q3-Q4 2007. Study population
was divided into two groups depending on whether they were hospitalized for major
complications of diabetes in 2007–2008. Patients without hospitalization were further
divided into three subgroups according to the use of drugs (only OAD, only insulin,
OAD and insulin). In all subgroups, we estimated health-care costs for each cost item
by age group in the whole study group and among those who actually used a particular
service. Additionally, we took samples of patients who were hospitalized for specific
complications, and estimated health-care costs for the first and second year after the
occurrence of the complication. Hungarian Forint values were converted to Euros by
employing the 2008 GDP specific PPP exchange rate (1c = 157.64HUF). RESULTS:
Mean health-care cost of 521,545 diabetic patients was c2125 in 2008. It was c4016
for those with hospitalization for complications, c1533 for OAD users without complications, and c2847 for insulin users without complications. Fifty-three percent of
the total cost covered drug treatment and 27% acute hospital treatment; 26% of the
total drug cost was spent on OADs and on insulin. CONCLUSIONS: Health-care cost
of diabetes is already high in Hungary, especially care for its complications. Public
health-care cost of diabetes exceeds 0.65% of GDP and 13% of total direct public
health-care expenditure. Considering the burden of disease that manifests in premature
mortality, reduction in QoL, and high cost, and the epidemiological trends, diabetes
mellitus should be a public health priority in Hungary.
PDB25
RELATIONSHIPS OF QUALITY OF LIFE AND COSTS WITH CLINICAL
CHARACTERISTICS OF DIABETES PATIENTS
Cristiani M1, Scalone L2, Morsanutto A3, Moneghini M4, Cortesi PA2, Mantovani LG5
1
Charta Fondation, Milano, Italy; 2University of Milano—Bicocca, Monza, Italy; 3Friuli Venezia
Giulia Regional Health Autority, Trieste, Italy; 4University of Trieste, Italy; 5CIRFF, Federico II
University, Naples, Italy
BACKGROUND: Recent research suggests that direct medical costs and quality of
life in diabetes depends on number of diabetes-related complications. OBJECTIVES:
To analyze relationships of quality of life and medical costs with clinical characteristics
of diabetes mellitus patients. METHODS: A retrospective longitudinal cost of care
study was conducted; type 1 and 2 diabetic patients accessing at two hospitals in the
north-east area of Italy were recruited between October 2008 and March 2009. At
enrollment data on demographic, clinical status and QoL (EQ-5D) were collected.
Information on costs occurring during the previous 2 years was obtained from a chart
review: hospitalizations, specialist medical visits, diagnostic examinations, drugs, and
the main clinical parameters. Costs were quantified from the National Health Service
(NHS), by applying tariffs and prices valid in 2009. Data were analyzed with a multivariable linear regression model. RESULTS: A total of 411 valid patients (mean +
SD age = 64.1 + 12.7, 56.5% male) were enrolled: 15.9% had type 1, 83.4% type 2
diabetes, and 0.7% had other type of diabetes. Costs were on average c234.36/patientmonth; hospitalization accounted for the greatest proportion of costs (58.5%), followed by pharmacological therapies (32.6%) and diagnostic exams (8.9%). With
EQ-5D: VAS was on average + SD = 67.74 ± 16.71. Both Costs and HRQoL showed
a linear-positive (costs) and -negative (HRQoL) relationship with number of diabetesrelated complications (diabetic retinopathy, diabetic nephropathy, diabetic neuropathy, ischemic cardiopathy, vascular diseases, and diabetic foot), adjusting for age and
gender and type of diabetes. On the contrast, no relationship was found with type of
complications. CONCLUSIONS: Long-term complications carry a considerable
impact on medical cost and HRQoL. Although apparently costly, strategies aimed to
optimize the prevention of the onset of diabetic complications should be considered
as a potential investment to gain health and reduce costs in the long run.
PDB26
ECONOMIC BURDEN OF PAINFUL DIABETIC PERIPHERAL
NEUROPATHY IN KOREA
Ko KS1, Cha BY2, Kim CH3, Kwon HS2, Lee JH4, Park TS5, Won JC1, Park HJ6, Ko SK6
1
Inje University Sanggye Paik-Hospital, Seoul, South Korea; 2The Catholic University of Korea,
St. Mary’s Hospital, Seoul, South Korea; 3Sejong General Hospital, Bucheon-Si, Gyeonggi-do,
South Korea; 4Daegu Catholic University Medical Center, Daegu-City, South Korea;
5
Chonbuk National University Hospital, Jeonju Si, Jeollabuk-Do, South Korea; 6Pfizer
Pharmaceuticals Korea Ltd., Seoul, South Korea
OBJECTIVES: The painful diabetic peripheral neuropathy (DPN) is the most common
complication of diabetes. Despite the prevalence of painful DPN and its potential risk
of foot ulcer and amputation, there has been no study about painful DPN on economic
burden in Korea. This study was conducted to assess the patient-level economic burden
among subjects with painful DPN. METHODS: A cross-sectional multicenter study
was performed using a standardized questionnaire, to estimate recent 3-month healthcare and non-health-care cost, and productivity loss of diabetic patients. a total of
4000 patients were recruited from 40 hospitals between December 2009 and May
2010. Cost items mainly included health-care cost such as outpatient, pharmacy,
inpatient, and oriental medicine; non-health-care cost such as traffic expenses, nursing
cost, complementary, and alternative medicine. Cost included insurance-covered cost
13th Euro Abstracts
as well as patient’s out-of-pocket expenses during 3 months. To estimate productivity
loss due to morbidity, days away from work due to painful DPN were also investigated. RESULTS: Among 2681 diabetic patients completed questionnaire (response
rate = 67.0 %), 26.3% (n = 706) had painful DPN. Numbers of outpatient visit within
3 months were higher in patients with painful DPN compared to those in patients
without painful DPN, 3.79 ± 2.83 and 3.25 ± 2.36, respectively (P < 0.01). Total costs
over 3 months were also higher in patients with painful DPN than in those without
painful DPN (1,049,477 ± 1,549,446 and 721,933 ± 1,394,970 KRW, respectively,
P < 0.01); Median costs were higher among patients with painful DPN (656,585 vs.
421,668 KRW). Within 3 months, 8.2% and 43.5% of patients with painful DPN
had been away from work and reported the decreased work productivity, respectively.
CONCLUSIONS: Painful DPN increased health-care cost and decreased work productivity of diabetic patients in Korea.
PDB27
INDIRECT COSTS OF ILLNESS FOR DIABETES IN PORTUGAL
1
2
2
Gouveia M , Borges M , Costa J
1
Catholic University of Portugal, Lisbon, Portugal; 2University of Lisbon, Lisbon, Portugal
OBJECTIVES: As in so many other countries, diabetes is one of the largest health
problems faced by Portugal. Up to now, there have been no “cost of illness” studies for
diabetes in Portugal. This paper provides a contribution to fill that gap by estimating
the indirect costs of illness, more specifically the output loss due to short- and long-term
disability attributable to diabetes in Portugal. METHODS: The estimates are based on
the microdata of the 4th National Health Survey conducted in 2005/2006. An employment logit is estimated with covariates including age, gender, education levels, and
regional dummies as well as a dummy for diabetes and dummies for other relevant
health conditions for all people in the survey with ages between 20 and 74. a comparison
of the baseline labor market participation/employment estimates and model predictions
assuming zero diabetes prevalence provides the estimates for the labor market impact
of diabetes. The estimates are specified by age groups and gender. At this point, the
analysis uses microdata from the Labor Ministry, covering about 3 million workers, to
estimate gross wages and employer Social Security contributions by age and gender,
allowing us to use the human capital approach to put a value on the diabetes-induced
labor market nonparticipation. RESULTS: The nonemployment estimates generated by
the logit-based methodology are that diabetes reduces employment by 22,150 in a 4.6
million demographic group. The corresponding output loss is estimated to have been
c324 million. CONCLUSIONS: The output loss is one of the main costs of diabetes in
Portugal. Its amount is four times larger than the available estimates for diabetes’
attributable inpatient care in National Health Service hospitals.
PDB28
HEALTH INSURANCE COST OF DIABETES MELLITUS IN HUNGARY: A
COST OF ILLNESS STUDY
Gresz M1, Varga S2, Kriszbacher I2, Sebestyén A3, Boncz I2
1
National Health Insurance Fund Administration, Budapest, Hungary; 2University of Pécs,
Pécs, Hungary; 3National Health Insurance Fund Administration, Pécs, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: Diabetes is one of that chronic diseases in which the increase of the costs
cause financial problems for the National Health Insurance Fund in Hungary. Aim of
the study is the examination of it in a 5-year period from 2003 to 2008. METHODS:
The number of diabetic patients, the type of treatment services, the financial support,
and the costs were analyzed. Data were derived from the National Health Insurance
Fund Administration. RESULTS: Measuring by the medical ID, the numbers of patient
increased by 34% during 5 years. The numbers of case increased in the outpatient
services by 14% (from 213,790 to 243,960). The numbers of the hospital treatment day
decreased by 5% (3,342,857; 3,168,263) The day off work due to sickness and the cost
of it increased by 345% (from 8275c to 36,860c). While financial support of devices
for the measurement of blood sugar increased by 93% c4900 to c9400 and support of
insulin treatment increased 111%, than the increase of the number of insulin-treated
patients was only 46%, 91,920 (2003) and 134,617 (2008). Similarities were seen in
numbers (40%) and in costs (94%) in the noninsulin-treated patients from 195,662 to
274,886 and from c7900 to c15,300. The total change in financial support was 72%.
CONCLUSIONS: Increase in the number of diabetic patients was seen during this 5-year
period. The increase of the number in outpatient services was higher than in inpatient
services. The decrease in numbers of hospital bed could explain it. The economic crisis
could cause the growing in the numbers of day off work. The increase in the medical
financial support compared to the number of patients had to be mentioned, because it
could be caused by enhancement in the administration of the innovative medical products. Basic strategy should be found against health cost explosion.
PDB29
COST OF DIABETES MELLITUS TYPE 1 AND 2 STUDIES IN COUNTRIES
OF CENTRAL AND EASTERN EUROPE—A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW OF
THE LITARATURE
Kawalec P1, Czech M2
1
Jagiellonian University, Kraków, Poland; 2Novo Nordisk Pharma Sp z.o.o., Warsaw, Poland
OBJECTIVES: Despite the rapid development of pharmacoeconomics and outcomes
research in new countries joining European Union (EU), there is still scarcity of cost
of illness studies compared to old EU members. The aim of the study was to review
all studies concerning costs of diabetes type 1 and 2 and its complications in old and
new EU members. The following countries were taken into account: Slovenia, Poland,
Czech Republic, Hungary, Slovakia, Bulgaria, Romania, Lithuania, Latvia, and
13th Euro Abstracts
Estonia—as new EU members and remaining EU countries as old members.
METHODS: A systematic review of the following databases was conducted: Medline
(PubMed), Embase, Cochrane. In addition, NICE, INAHTA, HTAI, and ISPOR Internet pages were searched. The following key words were used: cost of illness diabetes
with name of a country or burden of illness diabetes with name of a country. Studies’
design, methods, scope, and results were compared. Direct and indirect costs were
considered separately, detailed costs’ categories and costs related to complications
were distinguished. Perspectives, time frames were taken into consideration and
current exchange rates for communication purposes were used. Studies published in
English language were included. RESULTS: Only 12 studies concerning cost of diabetes type 1 and 2 and their complications in new EU countries were found as compared to 67 from old EU members. On the side of new EU members, one study was
found in Lithuania and Bulgaria, three in Czech Republic, and seven in Poland. In old
EU countries, one study was found in Luxembourg and Greece, two in Austria,
Belgium, Finland, and Ireland, three in France and The Netherlands, seven in Spain
and Italy, eight in Great Britain, 13 in Sweden, and 16 in Germany. CONCLUSIONS:
Results of this review revealed the necessity of carrying out more studies concerning
cost of diabetes and its complications in new EU members.
PDB30
USE OF MEDICAL INFORMATION SYSTEM FOR ASSESSMENT OF THE
COST OF THERAPY OF DIABETIC FOOT PATIENTS IN RUSSIA
Matveev N1, Galstyan G2, Sergeeva S2, Dolotova D3
1
Nycomed Russia-CIS, Moscow, Russia; 2Scientific Center for Endocrinology, Moscow, Russia;
3
Russian State Medical University, Moscow, Russia
OBJECTIVES: Diabetic foot (DF) is one of the most important complications of
diabetes mellitus. If not treated properly, diabetic foot may often lead to infections,
amputations, and finally to disability. Unfortunately, only few studies of the cost of
diabetic foot treatment were available in Russia; most of the studies were completed
about 10 years ago. We suggested that the data of earlier studies could not reflect
present level of expenditures. Therefore, we launched a study of the cost of diabetic
foot treatment in present conditions. METHODS: We have analyzed the data of 146
inpatients treated in diabetic foot department at Scientific Centre for Endocrinology
(Moscow, Russia) in 2008–2009. The patients’ data were input into a specially
designed medical information system. The patients were sorted into three main groups:
1) diabetic polyneuropathy without diabetic foot (N = 37); 2) diabetic foot without
amputations (N = 58); and 3) patients with amputations due to diabetic foot (N =
51). To calculate the total cost of DF treatment, costs of diagnostic procedures, medicines, bandaging, surgical operations, and staying in the hospital were summed.
RESULTS: Mean cost of treatment of one DF patient was equal to 81,700 rubles
(US$2645), which is about 30% higher than previously reported figures. It is mainly
due to larger introduction of recombinant insulins into routine treatment of diabetic
patients. Mean cost of treatment of DF patients with amputations was significantly
higher than in those without amputations, mostly due to additional costs of surgical
treatment and longer stay in a hospital. Moreover, the mean cost of medicines for DF
patients with amputations was almost twice higher than for DF patients without
amputations. CONCLUSIONS: The cost of diabetic foot treatment in Russia increased
approximately 30% during last 10 years. The results will be used to assess costeffectiveness of various drug treatments of diabetic foot.
PDB31
THE IMPACT OF NEUROMONITORING ON THYROID SURGERY COSTS
1
1
2
3
Beccagutti G , Grifi M , Pantaleoni M , Dionigi G
1
Medtronic Italia, Sesto San Giovanni, Italy; 2IMS Health S.p.A, Milano, Italy; 3Università
dell’Insubria, Varese, Italy
OBJECTIVES: Damage to the recurrent laryngeal nerve (RLN) is one of the principal
reasons for malpractice claims against surgeons in otorhinolaryngology. Intraoperative
neuromonitoring (IONM), facilitating the identification of RLN, has been demonstrated to be a valid technical support to reduce intraoperative risks. Aim of this study
was to evaluate the additional hospitalization costs for thyroidectomy due to IONM,
against the mentioned clinical and administrative advantages. METHODS: The study
was performed in an experienced Italian University Hospital, in which the learning
curve for this technology is considered completed. Through a microcosting approach,
the thyroidectomy patient care process (with and without IONM) was costed considering direct costs only (staff time, consumables, equipment, drugs, operating room, and
general expenses) and according to the hospital perspective. Unit costs were collected
from hospital accounting and standard tariff lists. a differential analysis was performed to highlight additional resource consumption (time effort, consumables, technology equipment) due to IONM usage. To assess the impact of the technology on
hospital management, three scenarios were considered: 1) traditional thyroidectomy;
2) thyroidectomy with IONM in a high-volume setting (five procedures per week);
and 3) thyroidectomy with IONM in a low-volume setting (one procedure per week).
RESULTS: The cost for hospitalization for a traditional thyroidectomy was c3471. If
IONM is used, costs increase as follows: +7% in a high-volume setting (c3713) and
+9% in a low-volume setting (c3770). IONM therefore represents only the 6% to 7%
of the total hospitalization costs. CONCLUSIONS: IONM for thyroid surgery could
reduce the risk of RLN damages and of the consequent malpractice claims against a
very low impact on hospital budget, accounting only for the 7% of the hospitalization
costs for a thyroidectomy. Considering that IONM could be useful in all surgical
procedures where nerves are at risk, the economic impact could be even lower due to
a higher level of usage of the equipment.
A289
PDB32
COST-EFFECTIVENESS CONSEQUENCES OF OBESITY IN T2DM BY
INSULIN ANALOGUE THERAPY
Józsa Z1, Tóth E2, Nagy B2
1
Novo Nordisk Hungary Ltd., Budapest, Hungary; 2Healthware Ltd., Budapest, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: The available T2DM (type 2 diabetes mellitus) therapies attend with
weight gain, which affects for the disease outcomes in a very extent way. Weight gain
could worsen the long-term effect of insulin therapy (increased risk of insulin resistance, hypertension, dyslipidemia), which influences the total treatment cost. Longacting insulin analogue therapies (insulin detemir and glargine) offer improved
pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic properties compared to regular human
insulin. In a previous meta-analysis, detemir caused significant lower weight gain than
glargine (−2.04 kg after 6 months therapy). Our research aimed to determine the
effects of weight gain and calculate the total treatment cost. METHODS: On the basis
of a systematic literature review, we found many consequences, which could be obesity
related. Because of its important effect and bride prevalence, we analyzed the CHD
(coronary heart disease) risk changes related to the weight gain. We modified the 10
years risk—calculated with the UKPDS risk engine—with the effects of the weight gain
published in a meta-analysis. We aggregated the differences in natural outcomes
(number of avoided fatal and nonfatal events) and in monetary unit, based on realworld data. RESULTS: In our analysis, we assessed that insulin detemir-treated
patients—due to the favorable features regarding weight gain compared to glargine—
experience smaller (cca 2%) CHD risks. It means, for the current treated Hungarian
population, that there are 223 coronary (158 fatal of this) events avoidable in 10 years
horizon using detemir insulin instead glargine. The estimated savings of social insurance would be around 224 million HUF on the basis of a Hungarian burden of diabetes complication study. CONCLUSIONS: Obesity and weight gain-related aspects
should be priorized as the main international tendencies showed. It is not only necessary on the policy level, but also in “individual” level in the cost-effectiveness analysis
as well.
PDB33
EVALUATION OF COST AND CLINICAL OUTCOMES BY HBA1C AT
DIAGNOSIS USING VARIOUS DIABETES TREATMENT STRATEGIES
Lee LJ1, Klein RW2, Klein TM2, Furiak N2, Peltz G1, Bansal M2, Jackson JA3, Juneja R4
1
Eli Lilly & Company, Indianapolis, IN, USA; 2Medical Decision Modeling Inc., Indianapolis, IN,
USA; 3Lilly USA, LLC, Indianapolis, IN, USA; 4Indiana University, Indianapolis, IN, USA
OBJECTIVES: To examine the association of HbA1c at diagnosis with cost and clinical outcomes in patients with type 2 diabetes (T2D) using three different diabetes
treatment strategies. METHODS: An existing Monte Carlo diabetes model was used
to generate demographic and clinical characteristics for 10,000 random patients simulated from the time of T2D diagnosis. Fixed initial HbA1c values were assigned (range:
7–12%). Input distributions were derived from the literature, with diabetes complications occurring in: retinopathy, nephropathy, neuropathy, coronary heart disease, and
stroke. The diabetes-related costs, percentage of patients reaching HbA1c target
(<7%), complication events, and mortality over 10 years were evaluated using the
following treatment strategies: (S1) addition of oral antihyperglycemic agents (OHAs)
at 3-month intervals then starting insulin after 9 months; (S2) addition of OHAs at
6-month intervals then starting insulin after 2 years; and (S3) addition of OHAs only.
All treatment strategies began with metformin then sulphonylurea and/or thiazolidinedione were added if target was not reached. RESULTS: Diabetes-related costs
increased as initial HbA1c increased for all three strategies. S1 had the greatest increase
($5300–$7750) followed by S3 ($4200–$5250) per 1% HbA1c increase from 7% to
10%. S2 had the smallest rate of increase ($3350–$4950). S3 was the least costly until
HbA1c exceeded 10%; however, even at HbA1c of 8%, S3 had fewer patients ever
reaching target (S3 = 79% vs. S1 and S2 = 95% [standard errors, SE < 0.41%]). For
10,000 patients with initial HbA1c of 9%, the total counts of complications were: S1
= 4360; S2 = 4126; S3 = 5009 (SE < 67) with mortality rates of 42.5%, 41.9%, and
45.2% (SE < 0.56%), respectively. CONCLUSIONS: In this model, S2 had the lowest
complication rates and mortality in patients with T2D. Starting HbA1c affected S1
cost more than other strategies. Strategies with other treatments or alternative timing
strategies can be specified and analyzed using this model.
PDB34
THE ECONOMIC VALUE OF THE EASYPOD® ELECTRONIC
AUTOINJECTOR IN IMPROVING THE RESPONSE TO GROWTH
HORMONE (GH) IN CHILDREN WITH IDIOPATHIC GROWTH
HORMONE DEFICIENCY (IGHD): A COST-CONSEQUENCE ANALYSIS
Chatelain P1, Latour S2, Maetzel A3
1
Université Claude Bernard Lyon—Hôpital Femme Mère Enfant, Bron, France; 2Merck
Serono S.A., Geneva, Switzerland; 3Stratas Partners, Basel, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: Response to GH therapy in children with IGHD can be further optimized. To evaluate the economic benefit of injecting GH with easypod®, an electronic
autoinjector that objectively monitors drug administration, enabling differentiation of
poor adherers from low responders. METHODS: A discrete event simulation model
was developed to model continuous, intermittent (four injections/week) and discontinued GH usage in children with IGHD until final height. a cohort of children (age: 4–12
years, growth delay: −4.0– −2.5 standard deviation scores [SDS] at baseline) was
modeled to initiate GH (0.03 mg/kg/day). Annual height gains of 1.2 to 0.8 SDS in year
1 were assumed to be 30% and 60% lower in each subsequent year of continuous and
intermittent use, respectively. Baseline nonadherence was 9.3 persons per 100 person-
A290
years, of which 20% (1.86%) discontinued and the remainder used GH intermittently.
a one-time identification of nonresponders with GH dose increase of 50% was assumed
after month 6 for children with low growth gains. The model was validated against final
height gains observed in large international registries of children with IGHD. The rate
of poor adherence was reduced by 10% and 30% in sensitivity analyses. Cost of GH
was c32.80 per mg, and discounted at 3.5% per annum. RESULTS: The baseline cohort
was modeled to achieve near final height SDS of −1.0 (± 1.23) as observed in real-life
registries, effectively gaining 16.0 cm at a cost per cm gained of c3929. Identification
of low responders increased height gain to 17.3 cm at a cost per cm gained of c3987.
Growth gains were maximized at 18.2 cm at a cost per cm gained of c4073 when
identifying low responders and decreasing poor adherence by 30%. CONCLUSIONS:
Easypod® features can identify adherence profiles, allowing early recognition of low
responders, giving the potential to optimize final height gain and investment in GH
therapy in IGHD.
PDB35
COST-CONSEQUENCE ANALYSIS OF CSII VS. MDI: A CANADIAN
PERSPECTIVE
Sadri H1, Bereza BG2, Longo CJ3
1
Medtronic of Canada, Brampton, ON, Canada; 2University of Toronto, Toronto, ON,
Canada; 3McMaster University, Hamilton, ON, Canada
OBJECTIVES: Several studies have evaluated the ICER of CSII versus MDI over a
patients’ lifetime. However, decision-makers are also concerned with shorter time
horizons. As such, the annualized incremental cost and consequences of CSII versus
MDI may be informative to this audience. METHODS: An economic model was
developed using Excel spreadsheet. Deterministic data derived from various sources
including ICES Diabetes Atlas, Statistics Canada Population, and published literature
was used to determine the annualized costs and consequences of CSII versus MDI in
the Province of Ontario. RESULTS: Overall, the use of CSII for all type 1 diabetic
patients (T1DM) age 18–64 in the base-case analysis would result in savings associated
with the event reductions of $77,885,000 per year (95% CI: 55,920,148–123,835,211).
Assuming all T1DM patients switched to CSII, annual resource saving include: 63
fewer AMI (95% CI: 20.8–233.0), 23 fewer major amputations (95% CI: 6.4–133.9),
14 fewer blindness cases (95% CI: 3.6–224.5), 411 fewer dialysis years (range 329.2–
493.8), and 140 fewer hypoglycemia-related hospitalizations (range 112.3–168.5).
Additional investments in CSII would result in a net expenditure of $4,724,000.
However, extensive sensitivity analysis shows that there is a potential cost saving of
$26,689,000–$41,225,000 for the province in direct medical cost assuming all 48,000
T1DM patients adopted this technology. CONCLUSIONS: Use of CSII has demonstrated improved glycemic control compared to MDI. Additional health benefits
including reductions in AMI, amputations, cataract surgery, dialysis rates, and hypoglycemia-related hospitalization could potentially save the health-care system both
costs and precious resources. Sensitivity analyses suggest that under the most favorable
conditions, adoption of CSII would be a dominant strategy (saving $41,000,000/
annum in the steady state). This analysis underestimates the CSII benefits by ignoring
smaller benefits including minor amputations, costs associated with gangrene. Also,
the effects on patient’s HR-QoL and other socioeconomic benefits related to lost
productivity has not been calculated.
PDB36
LONG-TERM COST-CONSEQUENCE ANALYSIS OF EXENATIDE ONCE
WEEKLY VERSUS SITAGLIPTIN OR PIOGLITAZONE IN TYPE 2
DIABETES PATIENTS IN THE UNITED STATES
Aledort Gaebler J1, Samyshkin Y2, Guillermin ALG2, Lloyd A2
1
Amylin Pharmaceuticals, Inc., San Diego, CA, USA; 2IMS Health, London, UK
OBJECTIVES: Exenatide once-weekly (EQW) is a GLP-1 receptor agonist that controls glucose in patients with type 2 diabetes (T2DM) and is associated with weight
loss and improvement in cardiovascular risk factors such as blood pressure and lipids.
We estimated the long-term clinical and financial benefits of EQW compared to
sitagliptin or pioglitazone in the United States. Pending US approval and EQW price,
we conducted a cost-consequence analysis that excluded pharmacy costs. METHODS:
We used the CORE Diabetes Model, a validated computer simulation model of diabetes progression and treatment, to project lifetime clinical outcomes and complication
costs. Patient characteristics (mean age 52.5 years; diabetes duration 6 years; HbA1c
8.51%; body mass index 32.12 kg·m−2) and clinical data were derived from a phase
3 clinical trial comparing EQW to sitagliptin or pioglitazone against metformin
background. Compared to sitagliptin and pioglitazone patients, trial patients on EQW
had HbA1c improvement (0.63% and 0.32% points, respectively) and BMI reduction
(0.51 kg·m−2 and 1.77 kg·m−2). Health outcomes and complication costs were discounted at 3% per year. Sensitivity analyses were performed to determine how changes
in estimated values affected results. RESULTS: Compared to sitagliptin and pioglitazone, EQW increased life expectancy by 0.31 years (13.80 ± 0.18 vs. 13.50 ± 0.16)
and 0.14 years (13.80 ± 0.18 vs. 13.66 ± 0.18), respectively, and quality-adjusted
life-years (QALY) by 0.30 (9.49 ± 0.12 vs. 9.20 ± 0.11) and 0.21 (9.49 ± 0.12 vs.
9.28 ± 0.12). EQW was also associated with lower complication costs: Compared to
sitagliptin and pioglitazone, EQW saved US$1654 (US$55,385 ± 1781 vs. US$57,039
± 1848) and US$573 (US$55,385 ± 1781 vs. US$55,958 ± 1838) lifetime direct cost
per patient. In both cases, cost savings resulted mainly from lower cumulative incidence of cardiovascular diseases and neuropathic complications (e.g., ulcer, amputation). CONCLUSIONS: Over a patient’s lifetime, EQW is projected to improve health
and decrease complication costs compared with sitagliptin or pioglitazone. Incremental cost-effectiveness ratios will depend upon EQW price.
13th Euro Abstracts
PDB37
THE COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF SAXAGLIPTIN VERSUS NPH INSULIN IN
THE TREATMENT OF TYPE 2 DIABETES MELLITUS (T2DM) IN POLAND
Kolasa K1, Niewada M2, Puelles Fernandez de Troconiz J3, Townsend R4, McEwan P4
1
Bristol-Myers Squibb, Warsaw, Poland; 2HealthQuest sp z o.o., Warszawa, Poland;
3
Bristol-Myers Squibb, Braine l’Alleud, Belgium; 4CRC, Cardiff, UK
OBJECTIVES: To compare the cost-effectiveness of saxagliptin versus NPH insulin
as second-line therapy in combination with either metformin (MET) or sulphonylurea
(SU) after failure of monotherapy with MET or SU in a Polish setting. METHODS:
The perspective was the Polish National Health Fund using a published fixed time
increment, stochastic simulation model set to a 40-year time horizon. Disease progression was taken from the UKPDS 68 outcomes study. Relative effectiveness for change
in Hba1c, weight, and hypoglycemia was determined from published trials. Costs were
from published estimates and local data. Utilities were derived from UKPDS outcomes
supplemented with information from published sources for hypoglycemia-, weight-,
and injection-associated disutility. Costs and health-related effects were discounted
annually at 5% and 3.5%, respectively. RESULTS: When compared with insulin +
MET, saxagliptin + MET was associated with reduced severe hypoglycemia and less
weight gain, resulting in an incremental benefit of 0.13 quality-adjusted life-years
(QALYs) and an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of 27,454 zloty (PLN)
per QALY. Treatment with saxagliptin + SU was associated with a reduction in
symptomatic and severe hypoglycemia when compared with insulin + SU, leading to
an incremental benefit of 0.14 QALYs and an ICER of 24,663 PLN per QALY gained.
Key model drivers were: baseline HbA1c, treatment-associated weight gain, thresholds
for switching treatment, age, and disutility associated with weight gain, injection fear,
and hypoglycemia. The results were robust to various assumptions concerning inputs
and modeling parameters, with all ICERs < 50,000 PLN per QALY gained (GDP per
capita for 2009 was 30,000 PLN or c7300, based on 1 PLN = EUROS 0.243, June
2010). CONCLUSIONS: Saxagliptin is cost-effective as a second-line therapy in
combination with MET or SU in T2DM in the Polish setting. The availability of saxagliptin will provide T2DM patients with an additional treatment option to insulin.
PDB38
ADDITION OF INCRETIN-THERAPY TO METFORMIN IN TYPE-2DIABETES MELLITUS (T2DM): COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF LIRAGLUTIDE
VERSUS SITAGLIPTIN FROM THE PERSPECTIVE OF THE GERMAN
STATUTORY HEALTH INSURANCE (SHI)
Schlander M1, Mentrup S2, Lund N3
1
Institute for Innovation & Valuation in Health Care, Wiesbaden, Germany; 2Novo Nordisk
Pharma GmbH, Mainz, Germany; 3Novo Nordisk A/S, Soeborg, Denmark
BACKGROUND: The novel incretin analogue, once-daily liraglutide, mimics the
effect of endogenous glucagons-like peptide 1 (GLP-1). Liraglutide was found to be
significantly more effective than the DPP-4 inhibitor, sitagliptin (increasing the half-life
of GLP-1 by inhibiting its degradation by DPP-4), in lowering HbA1c and weight in
patients with T2DM (Pratley et al. 2010). OBJECTIVES: To compare, from a German
payer’s (SHI) perspective, the long-term clinical and cost-effectiveness of liraglutide
(1.2 mg or 1.8 mg OD) versus sitagliptin (100 mg OD), in combination with metformin, in T2DM patients, based on data from the randomized clinical trial (RCT) by
Pratley et al. 2010. METHODS: RCT data were used to populate the CORE Diabetes
Model (CDM), calibrated to clinical study baseline characteristics and background
mortality in a German diabetes population. Costing (direct costs only) was done from
the SHI perspective for year 2009. a discounting rate of 3% was used for costs and
clinical effects. For hypothetical cohorts of 1000 patients, each followed for 20 years,
liraglutide or sitagliptin were assumed to be maintained for 5 years and patients to
be subsequently switched to insulin. Consequences (costs and effects) were projected
over a 20-year time horizon. RESULTS: Estimated 20-year survival rates were higher
for liraglutide 1.8 mg (41.1%) and 1.2 mg (40.3%) compared to sitagliptin 100 mg
(39.5%), and cumulative costs were c47,436, c45,627, and c43,298, respectively.
Base-case ICERs were c37,163 per life-year gained for liraglutide 1.8 mg (or c48703
for 1.2 mg) versus sitagliptin, and c20,702 (or c20,870 for liraglutide 1.2 mg) per
QALY gained. Sensitivity analyses, including longer time horizons, different risk
(CDM base case, Framingham study, and UKPDS) cohorts, indicated robustness of
findings. CONCLUSIONS: Long-term projections combining RCT data with the
CDM indicate an acceptable to attractive cost-effectiveness of liraglutide compared to
sitagliptin (both plus metformin) according to currently prevailing standards.
PDB39
EFFECT OF VARYING MODELLING ASSUMPTIONS ON THE COSTEFFECTIVENESS OF LIRAGLUTIDE 1.2 MG (AS A COMPONENT OF
DUAL THERAPY) IN TYPE 2 DIABETES
Valentine WJ1, Chubb BD2, Smith IC2
1
Ossian Health Economics and Communications, Basel, Switzerland; 2Novo Nordisk,
Crawley, West Sussex, UK
OBJECTIVES: To compare the effect of different sets of modeling assumptions on the
cost-effectiveness of liraglutide 1.2 mg, as a component of dual therapy in type 2
diabetes. METHODS: Data from three published clinical trials were used as the basis
of the modeling analysis, comparing: liraglutide 1.2 mg versus rosiglitazone 4 mg,
both added to glimepiride (Marre 2009); liraglutide 1.2 mg versus glimepiride 4 mg,
both added to metformin (Nauck 2009); and liraglutide 1.2 mg versus sitagliptin
100 mg, both added to metformin (Pratley 2010). The published and validated CORE
Diabetes Model was used to simulate the progression of type 2 diabetes and predict
costs (in 2009 Pounds Sterling [£]) and quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs) over
13th Euro Abstracts
patients’ lifetimes. Duration of treatment was assumed to be 5 years, before switching
to a basal insulin regimen. Changes were made to the base-case assumptions. First,
the utility change per BMI unit gained (in patients with a BMI > 25 kg/m2) was
decreased from −0.01 to −0.0061. Second, the treatment duration was increased from
5 to 10 years. All other variables were kept constant. RESULTS: In the comparison
with rosiglitazone, liraglutide was associated with a base-case incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of £6226 per QALY gained, which increased to £7545 with BMI
utility changes and to £16,477 when the treatment duration was increased. Similar
increases were seen for comparisons with glimepiride (£13,257 (base case) to £25,343
(BMI utility change) and £38,368 (10-year treatment)) and sitagliptin (£9,851 [base
case] to £14,616 [BMI changes] and £17,089 [10-year treatment]). CONCLUSIONS:
Increasing the treatment duration and decreasing the impact of BMI on quality of life
increased the ICER of liraglutide versus comparators. Liraglutide was shown to be
cost-effective in dual therapy (assuming a threshold of £20,000 per QALY gained)
versus rosiglitazone and sitagliptin in all three scenarios (base case, BMI utility
changes, and 10-year treatment).
PDB40
THE ECONOMIC IMPORTANCE OF “METABOLIC MEMORY” IN THE
TREATMENT OF TYPE 2 DIABETES MELLITUS (T2DM) IN SWEDEN
Willis M1, He J2, Neslusan C2, Chicevic E3
1
IHE, Lund, Swedenl; 2Johnson & Johnson Pharmaceutical Services, LLC, Raritan, NJ, USA;
3
Janssen-Cilag EMEA, Prague, Czech Republic
OBJECTIVES: Analysis of the post-interventional follow-up of the UKPDS found that
the benefits of intensive therapy persisted even 10 years after the trial, a finding
consistent with “metabolic memory” (i.e., early metabolic status influences long-term
outcomes). We assessed the potential impact of “metabolic memory” on the costeffectiveness of intensive versus conventional care in Sweden. METHODS: We used
the Economic and Health Outcomes (ECHO)-T2DM model to simulate lifetime health
outcomes (including QALYs) and medical costs for 500 cohorts of 2000 newly diagnosed patients. In each cohort, patients were randomized to intensive or conventional
care and HbA1c treatment effects corresponding to the UKPDS study were applied
for the first 10 years. Consistent with findings from the follow-up study, HbA1c values
were assumed to converge by year 10. Subsequently, in the intensive care arm, “metabolic memory” effects (reduced risk for certain microvascular and macrovascular
events and mortality) were applied. Two sets of “metabolic memory” effects from the
UKPDS follow-up study were used: those observed in the sulfonylurea/insulin subsample and those observed in the metformin subsample. a scenario assuming no
“metabolic memory” effects was simulated for comparison. Unit costs were derived
from the Swedish literature (modeling studies and a regression analysis of inpatient
care costs based on administrative hospital data linked to the Swedish National
Diabetes Register). RESULTS: Including “metabolic memory” had a large effect on
the cost-effectiveness estimates. The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio declined from
SEK2,387,292 (~c250,000) without “metabolic memory” to SEK731,308 (~c75,000)
assuming effects from the sulfonylurea/insulin sample and to SEK445,425 (~c45,000)
assuming effects from the metformin sample. CONCLUSIONS: These results suggest
that good glycemic control early in the disease continuum may confer significant
medical cost savings over the long term. Evaluations of the cost-effectiveness of
intensive glycemic control in newly diagnosed patients should potentially consider the
health and cost consequences of “metabolic memory.”
PDB41
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF LIRAGLUTIDE IN PEOPLE WITH TYPE 2
DIABETES IN THE SLOVAK REPUBLIC
Ilavska A1, Uliciansky V2, Wrona W3, Lacka J4, Czech M5
1
ISPOR Slovakia Regional Chapter, Bratislava, Slovak Republic; 2Via medica, s.r.o., Košice,
Slovak Republic; 3HealthQuest sp z o.o., Warsaw, Poland; 4Novo Nordisk Slovakia s.r.o.,
Bratislava, Slovak Republic; 5Novo Nordisk Pharma Sp z.o.o., Warsaw, Poland
OBJECTIVES: This study aimed to assess cost-effectiveness of treatment with liraglutide added to a standard therapy with metformin (MET) or/and sulphonylurea (SU)
compared with rosiglitazone and exenatide. METHODS: Our study used a health
economic model (the CORE Diabetes Model) to project the long-term costs and clinical outcomes of liraglutide based on clinical data from LEAD-1 trial: liraglutide + SU
versus rosiglitazone + SU; and LEAD-6 trial: liraglutide + MET+/−SU versus exenatide
+ MET+/−SU. The analysis was performed from the Slovak health-care services payer’s
perspective in a 20-year time horizon. The analysis used health-state utility values
from published sources to assess the effect of treatment on QALYs. The unit costs of
treatment and complications were derived from published sources and official tariff
lists for health-care services paid by public payer. All figures are shown in EUR.
RESULTS: QALYs increased with liraglutide 1.2 mg + SU versus SU + rosiglitazone
4 mg by 0.203. Total costs increased by c2561 resulting in incremental costs per
QALY of c12,615. The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio for liraglutide 1.8 mg +
MET+/−SU versus exenatide 10 µg + MET+/−SU was estimated at c24,013 per QALY
gained (QALYs increased by 0.112). CONCLUSIONS: Using the CORE Diabetes
Model and data from the LEAD 1 and LEAD 6 trials treatment with liraglutide is a
cost-effective intervention compared with both rosiglitazone and exenatide. Sensitivity
analysis showed the results are only moderately changing when altering the key
parameters and assumptions.
A291
PDB42
INCRETIN-THERAPY IN ADDITION TO METFORMIN AND/OR
SULFONYLUREA FOR TYPE 2 DIABETES MELLITUS (T2DM): COSTEFFECTIVENESS OF LIRAGLUTIDE VERSUS EXENATIDE FROM THE
PERSPECTIVE OF THE GERMAN STATUTORY HEALTH INSURANCE
(SHI)
Schlander M1, Mentrup S2, Lund N3
1
Institute for Innovation & Valuation in Health Care, Wiesbaden, Germany; 2Novo Nordisk
Pharma GmbH, Mainz, Germany; 3Novo Nordisk A/S, Soeborg, Denmark
BACKGROUND: Unlike most other antihyperglycemic drugs, glucagon-like peptide
1 (GLP-1) receptor agonists have a glucose-dependent action and promote weight loss.
In a randomized clinical trial (RCT) over 26 weeks reported by Buse et al. (2009), the
novel GLP-1 agonist liraglutide (1.8 mg once daily, OD) was found to be significantly
more effective than exenatide (10 µg twice daily) in terms of HBA1c reduction.
OBJECTIVES: To compare, from a German payer’s (SHI) perspective, the long-term
clinical and cost-effectiveness of liraglutide (1.8 mg OD) versus exenatide (10 µg BID)
in T2D patients, based on data from the randomized clinical trial (RCT) by Buse et
al. 2009. METHODS: The CORE Diabetes Model (CDM) was applied using RCT
data. The model was calibrated to RCT baseline characteristics and background
mortality in a German diabetes population, applying epidemiological data from longterm studies including UKPDS and Framingham to project morbidity and mortality
of T2DM. Unit costs for direct costs were applied from an SHI perspective for year
2009. a discounting rate of 3% was used for costs and clinical effects. For hypothetical
cohorts of 1000 patients, each followed for 20 years, patients were assumed to be
maintained on liraglutide and exenatide, respectively, for 5 years and subsequently
switched to insulin. Costs and effects were projected over a 20-year time horizon.
RESULTS: Estimated 20-year survival rates were higher for liraglutide 1.8 mg once
daily (36.8%) compared to exenatide 10 µg administered twice daily (35.6%), and
cumulative costs were c46,308 (liraglutide) and c45,025 (exenatide), respectively.
Base-case ICERs were c16,632 per life-year gained for liraglutide versus exenatide,
and c11,606 for liraglutide versus exenatide per QALY gained. Sensitivity analyses
indicated robustness of findings. CONCLUSIONS: Long-term projections combining
RCT data with the CDM strongly suggest an acceptable to attractive cost-effectiveness
of liraglutide compared to exenatide according to currently prevailing standards.
PDB43
LONG-TERM COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF LIRAGLUTIDE VS.
SULPHONYLUREA IN POLAND
Niewada M1, Wrona W1, Czech M2, Schubert A2, Skrzekowska-Baran I2
1
HealthQuest sp z o.o., Warsaw, Poland; 2Novo Nordisk Pharma Sp z.o.o., Warsaw, Poland
OBJECTIVES: To assess the long-term cost-effectiveness of treatment with liraglutide on
top of standard therapy with metformin (MET) compared with sulphonylurea (SU) in
people with type 2 diabetes. METHODS: The extensively published and validated CORE
Diabetes Model was populated with the clinical data from LEAD 2: liraglutide + MET
versus SU + MET. The analysis was performed from the polish health-care services payer’s
perspective. a 20-year time horizon was chosen to reflect the costs and outcomes of diabetes as these are often only seen in the later stages of the disease. The analysis used
health-state utility values from published sources to assess the effect of treatment on
QALYs. The unit costs of treatment and complications were derived from published
sources or based on expert opinion survey and Polish official tariff lists for health-care
services paid by public payer. All figures are shown in EURO (1 EURO = 3.9 PLN).
RESULTS: QALYs increased with liraglutide 1.2 mg + MET versus SU + MET by 0.191.
Total costs increased by c3,349 resulting in incremental costs per QALY of c17,565. The
incremental cost-effectiveness ratio for liraglutide 1.8 mg + MET versus SU + MET was
estimated at c24,842 per QALY gained (QALYs increased by 0.207). Sensitivity analysis
showed the results to be moderately changing when altering the key parameters and
assumptions (for liraglutide 1.2 mg range from 12,944 to c30,275/QALY). CONCLUSIONS: Treatment with liraglutide is a cost-effective intervention compared with sulphonylurea and is likely to represent good value for money in Polish setting.
PDB44
THE COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF SAXAGLIPTIN VERSUS SULFONYLUREA
(SU) IN THE TREATMENT OF TYPE 2 DIABETES MELLITUS (T2DM) IN
GERMANY
Erhardt W1, Bergenheim K2, Townsend R3, Puelles Fernandez de Troconiz J4, McEwan P3
1
Bristol-Myers Squibb GmbH & Co. KGaA, München, Germany; 2AstraZeneca, Mölndal,
Sweden; 3CRC, Cardiff, UK, 4Bristol-Myers Squibb, Braine l’Alleud, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: This study evaluates the long-term economic consequences of saxagliptin
versus sulfonylurea (SU, glipizide) as second-line therapy when used in combination with
metformin (MET) after failure of monotherapy treatment with MET, in patients with
type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) in Germany. METHODS: A published discrete event
simulation model with a fixed time increment was used and set to a 40-year (life-) time
horizon. Disease progression was modeled using evidence from the UK Prospective
Diabetes Study (UKPDS 68). The treatment sequence matched that of published guidelines, and efficacy and safety data were derived from published sources. The model
assumes that quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs) are affected by complications and
hypoglycaemic events over a lifetime. As such costs and utility decrements for macroand micro-vascular complications, and adverse events such as severe hypoglycaemia are
included. Costs were specific to the German setting where SUs are generic. Costs and
effects were discounted annually at 3%. The perspective of the national sick funds was
taken, and recommendations from the Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health
Care (IQWiG) were considered. RESULTS: Treatment with saxagliptin + MET was
A292
associated with lower incidence of both symptomatic and severe hypoglycaemic events,
resulting in an incremental benefit of 0.12 QALYs and an incremental cost-effectiveness
ratio (ICER) of c13,931 per QALY gained. Modest reductions in all macro-vascular
and micro-vascular complications were seen in those receiving saxagliptin + MET
compared with SU + MET. Sensitivity analysis showed that treatment-related weight
changes, as a risk factor for complications, represent the most influential driver of costeffectiveness. CONCLUSIONS: Saxagliptin is associated with improved outcomes, a
lower incidence of hypoglycaemic events, and weight neutrality, when compared with
generic SU, at a cost that would likely be considered acceptable in the German setting.
PDB45
COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS OF SAXAGLIPTIN IN THE
TREATMENT OF DIABETES MELLITUS TYPE 2 IN SPAIN
Ramirez de Arellano A1, Brosa M2, Franch J3, Mauricio D4, Alvarez C5, Sanchez-Zamorano
M1, De Rivas B5
1
Bristol-Myers Squibb Iberia, Madrid, Spain; 2Oblikue Consulting, Barcelona, Spain; 3Red
GEDAPS, Barcelona, Spain; 4Hospital Universitario Arnau de Vilanova, Lerida, Spain,
5
AstraZeneca, Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Saxagliptin is indicated as an add-on combination therapy for adult
patients with diabetes mellitus type 2 (T2D) to improve glycaemic control in combination with metformin, a sulphonylurea (SU) or a thiazolidinedione (TZD). The objective
of this study was to evaluate the cost-effectiveness in Spain of saxagliptin when added
to metformin in comparison with SU plus metformin or TZD plus metformin.
METHODS: The analysis uses the Cardiff Long Term Model which simulates treatment
pathways of pharmacological treatment of T2D from initiation of treatment until death.
Efficacy and safety data are based on an indirect comparison of saxagliptin and SU and
TZD based on the similarity in safety and efficacy between saxagliptin and sitagliptin
demonstrated in a 18-week non-inferiority study (CV181,056). Available direct comparative trials between sitagliptin and TZDs and SUs are used to serve as data sources
to assign efficacy and safety parameters. Spanish costs are used as for macro and microvascular complications as well as adverse events such as severe hypoglycemia. Utility
decrements for ischemic heart disease, myocardial infarction, congestive heart failure,
stroke, blindness, end-stage renal disease, transplant, amputation and body mass index
are also accounted in the model. Health outcomes are measured in terms of QALYs,
assuming that the lifetime QALY is affected by complications, occurrence of hypoglycaemic episodes and weight changes. The perspective used is that of the Spanish Health
System. RESULTS: Saxagliptin as add on to metformin is cost-effective compared with
SU and TZD (ICER < c10,000). Extensive univariate sensitivity analysis shows that the
most influential factor is the weight variation, which increases with treatment with SU
and TZD whereas DPP-4 inhibitors have shown to be weight neutral. CONCLUSIONS:
The cost-effectiveness analysis shows that saxagliptin is cost-effective compared with
both SU and TZD in combination with metformin for the treatment of T2DM in Spain.
PDB46
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF NEW ANTIDIABETICS IN TYPE 2 DIABETES:
A REVIEW
Baytar S, Malhan S
Baskent University, Ankara, Turkey
OBJECTIVES: Although having substantial costs, the new antidiabetics for Type 2
diabetes treatment present more alternatives for glycemic control of the disease. To
evaluate their cost-effectiveness, the New Antidiabetics for Type 2 diabetes indexed
on PubMed, EMBASE databases and American Diabetes Association abstracts were
evaluated. METHODS: The cost-effectiveness of Type 2 diabetes based on the new
antidiabetics was analyzed through literature review. Searches were carried out in
PubMed, EMBASE and ADA abstracts to identify the articles published from 2008
to 2010, keying in the terms “cost-effectiveness” and “type 2 diabetes” with language
filtering, “English.” The language filter for “Turkish” was also used but no result was
achieved. Upon this filtration, the abstracts were reviewed to determine whether they
included antidiabetics. RESULTS: Ten full texts, seven abstracts and three peer
reviews were identified. In all studies, the cost-effectiveness of antidiabetics was
assessed using the validated CORE Diabetes Model, except for two based on the
Discrete Event Simulation Model. The outcomes from IMPROVE, PROactive,
PRESENT, UKPDS and PREDICTIVE trials were used. In these studies, biphasic
insulin aspart, exenatide, pioglitazone, insulin detemir, insulin glargine and sitagliptin
were all studied under different settings and against various comparators. Biphasic
insulin aspart versus human premix insulin was mostly found to be cost-effective in
certain studies. Exenatide versus insulin glargine was established to be likely costeffective in two studies. Pioglitazone was found to be dominant compared to rosiglitazone. Insulin detemir was established to be cost-saving in comparison with OAD or
NPH insulin, or insulin glargine. Sitagliptin was regarded as either cost-effective or
cost-saving compared to rosiglitazone. CONCLUSIONS: Different results in terms of
cost-effectiveness of various antidiabetics under certain settings and against varied
comparators were achieved. In future, demonstrated gains in QALYs will be found to
be essential for these antidiabetics to be regarded as cost-effective.
PDB47
THE COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF CONTINUOUS GLUCOSE MONITORING
IN TYPE 1 DIABETES PATIENTS IN THE NETHERLANDS
vanGenugten ML
Medtronic Trading NL BV, Heerlen, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: Continuous glucose monitoring (CGM) has been found to improve
glycemic control in type 1 diabetes in recent trials. The objective of this study is to
13th Euro Abstracts
assess the cost-effectiveness of CGM compared with self-monitoring of blood glucose
(SMBG) in type 1 diabetes patients, from a societal perspective in the The Netherlands.
METHODS: The analysis was performed using the CORE Diabetes model with inputs
for the The Netherlands. Clinical effectiveness of CGM in terms of lowering HbA1c
was taken from the GuardControl study. Costs of complications and complicationrelated days off work were based on data from Erasmus University Rotterdam. Annual
treatment costs were estimated using cost information from the Healthcare Insurance
Board. Costs and effects were discounted at 4% and 1.5%, respectively. a lifetime
horizon (60 years) was adopted for the analysis. a range of sensitivity analyses were
conducted. RESULTS: The total costs per patient over 60 years for the CGM arm
were c10,069 (73,348) higher than costs for the SMBG arm. Complication costs were
lower, and treatment costs were higher for the CGM compared to the SMBG arm.
Compared to the SMBG arm, 0.463 (3.063) QALYs were gained in the CGM group.
The cost per QALY gained was c21,731. Probabilistic sensitivity analyses showed that
this result is robust. CONCLUSIONS: At a willingness to pay threshold of c40,000
per QALY, CGM appears to be a cost-effective treatment option compared to SMBG
in patients with type 1 diabetes.
PDB48
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF 2 DIABETES HEALTH CARE PROGRAMMES
IN BELGIUM
Benoit K1, Borgermans L2, Annemans L3
1
Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium; 2Catholic University Leuven, Leuven, Belgium; 3Ghent
University—Brussels University, Ghent, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: A multifaceted quality improvement programme for the care of diabetes was implemented in two different Flemish regions (Aalst and Leuven) and with
slightly different modalities. The overall objective of the programmes was to improve
adherence to evidence-based guidelines on diabetes in primary care physicians. The
aim of this study was to assess the cost-effectiveness of the programs compared to
regular care in both regions. METHODS: Short-term effects of the programmes were
extrapolated to long-term hard endpoints, using the validated UKPDS Outcomes
Model, supplemented by two self-developed Markov models to account for benefits
on process parameters (screening for retinopathy and nephropathy). a simulation of
the evolution of patients was made over a time horizon of 25 years with cycles of 1
year, from a public health care payer perspective. Cost data of the different disease
states and extra direct medical costs due to intensified patient management were collected from literature and from the National Institute for Health and Disability Insurance. For the self developed Markov models, utility data for all states were obtained
from published studies and transition probabilities were obtained from local epidemiological studies and published trials. In the simulation, the intervention was
assumed to be implemented three times over the predicted life expectancy. Deterministic sensitivity analyses were performed on the combined results of outcome and
process parameters. RESULTS: At a cost of intervention of c185 (Aalst) and c284
(Leuven) per patient, the analyses show ICER’S for Aalst and Leuven of respectively
c15,206.70/QALY and c10,397.96/QALY. Sensitivity analyses show few influence of
changed input variables. CONCLUSIONS: When using a ratio of c30,000/QALY as
threshold of willingness to pay for health gain, the diabetes health care programmes
have an acceptable ICER in both regions.
PDB49
PHARMACOECONOMICS MODELING OF LONG TERM RESULTS OF
TYPE 2 DIABETES MELLITUS TREATMENT IN PATIENTS USING
MODERN INSULIN ANALOGUES IN CONTRAST TO ORAL
ANTIDIABETIC DRUGS OR DIET
Yagudina R, Kulikov AU, Arinina EE
Moscow Medical Academy, Moscow, Russia
OBJECTIVES: To analyze the effectiveness and safety of three treatment regimens,
and to project and compare long-term outcomes and costs of complications of type 2
diabetes mellitus (T2DM). METHODS: Data of 3678 patients (mean age 49.6 ± 0.19
years; 47% men; mean diabetes’s duration—6 years) included in “evaluation of diabetes mellitus complications” program were taken for mathematic simulation using
the validated Center for Outcomes Research (CORE) Diabetes Model. Patients were
randomly divided into three groups: insulin therapy (NovoMix® 30), oral antidiabetic
drugs (OAD; combination of glibenclamide + metformin in most cases) and diet. Life
expectancy, cumulative incidence of cardiovascular, ocular events and health care
costs were estimated over period duration—50 years. RESULTS: Estimated life expectancy was higher in insulin group compared with OAD and diet groups (17.2, 16.5,
and 16.0 years). The best QALY’s results were also achieved in insulin group (10.7,
10.2 and 9.9 years) due to decreased rates of myocardial infarction (morbidity/mortality), decompensated heart failure, ocular complications and diabetic retinopathy.
Higher direct costs for years of life gained in insulin group (1287, 1203, and 1180
thousands of rub.) were associated with concomitant decreasing of indirect costs
(362.7, 382.5, and 381.3 thousands of rub.). The costs for one patient with T2DM
per 1 year were nearly the same in three groups (95.9, 95.9, and 97.6 thousands of
rub.). CONCLUSIONS: use of the CORE Diabetes Model life expectancy, diabetes
complications, and costs favored insulin NovoMix® 30 therapies compared with
OAD or diet in treatment of T2DM.
13th Euro Abstracts
PDB50
ASSESSING THE INFLUENCE OF INCORPORATING SECONDARY
CARDIOVASCULAR EVENTS INTO A TYPE 2 DIABETES MELLITUS
(T2DM) COST-EFFECTIVENESS MODEL
McEwan P1, Evans LM2, Bergenheim K3
1
CRC, Cardiff, UK; 2University Hospital of Wales, Cardiff, Vale of Glamorga, UK;
3
AstraZeneca, Mölndal, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: Cost-effectiveness assessments in T2DM are commonly based on models
that predict only primary cardiovascular events. This study aimed to assess the implications
of incorporating secondary cardiovascular events on predicted cost-effectiveness.
METHODS: Routine UK hospital data, between 2000 and 2005, were analyzed to
quantify the cumulative incidence of first, second and third myocardial infarction (MI) or
stroke events in T2DM subjects. Adjustments were made for out of hospital mortality and
under-diagnosis of T2DM. Cardiovascular risk equations, used in a previously published
cost-utility model, were re-calibrated, using the ratio of primary plus subsequent event to
primary event, to predict subsequent MIs and strokes consistent with the observed UK
data. The cost-effectiveness analysis compared two treatment strategies: A: 1st line metformin; 2nd line DPP-4 inhibitor add-on; 3rd line sulphonylurea add-on. B: 1st line metformin; 2nd line sulphonylurea add-on; 3rd line thiazolidinedione add-on. RESULTS: Of the
1,124,846 T2DM patients identified, 55,868 and 65,436 experienced primary MI and
stroke events, respectively. There were 2159 (3.86%) and 185 (0.003%) second and third
MI admissions, and 5808 (8.88%) and 755 (0.012%) second and third stroke admissions,
respectively. Modelled risk multipliers of 1.04 for MI and 1.1 for stroke were required to
predict cumulative incidence consistent with the UK data. Incorporating subsequent events
had little impact on the cost-utility analysis with the ICER decreasing from £3129 to
£3105 per quality adjusted life-year. More noteworthy, was the impact on cost per life-year
gained, which decreased from £257,902 to £90,055, with subsequent events included.
CONCLUSIONS: The inclusion of subsequent cardiovascular events in models of T2DM
provides greater face validity but has little impact upon cost-effectiveness. Thus, economic
assessments of therapies that modify glycaemic control, using models that do not incorporate subsequent MI and stroke events, are not significantly biased.
PDB51
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF EXENATIDE VERSUS INSULIN GLARGINE
AND VERSUS BIPHASIC INSULIN ASPART FOR THE TREATMENT OF
TYPE 2 DIABETES IN PORTUGAL: A LONG-TERM HEALTH ECONOMIC
ANALYSIS
Palmer JL1, Pinto CG2, Duarte R3, Miguel L4, Gregor Z5
1
IMS Health, Allschwil, Basel-Land, Switzerland; 2Instituto Superior de Economia e Gestao,
Lisboa, Portugal; 3Portuguese Diabetic Association, Lisbon, Portuga; 4CISEP—ISEG/UTL,
Lisbon, Portugal; 5Eli Lilly & Company, Prague, Czech Republic
OBJECTIVES: Two recent multicenter, comparator-controlled, open-label, randomized,
parallel group clinical trials comparing exenatide with insulin glargine and with biphasic
insulin aspart provided evidence of the short-term clinical profile of exenatide. The
objective of this cost-effectiveness analysis was to use these results as the basis for longterm projections to estimate the clinical and economic outcomes associated with exenatide treatment versus insulin glargine and versus biphasic insulin aspart in Portuguese
health care setting. METHODS: The previously published and validated IMS Core
Diabetes Model was used to project the long-term clinical and cost outcomes for a cohort
defined as the intention-to-treat (ITT) population of patients in the H8O-MC-GWAA
and H8O-MC-GWAD clinical trials having a baseline BMI ≥ 35 kg/m2. Portuguesespecific direct medical costs data were used in the analysis to model outcomes over a
35-year time horizon from the National Health Service perspective. RESULTS: Exenatide was associated with ICERs of c61,637 per life-year gained and c17,222 per QALY
gained versus biphasic insulin aspart. Exenatide was also associated with ICERs of
c53,275 per life-year gained and c14,697 per QALY gained versus insulin glargine from
the National Health Service perspective. Results from 18 sensitivity analyses and two
BMI subgroup analyses indicated a limited impact of baseline BMI on the final results.
Results were sensitive to disutilities applied for excess BMI and nausea. Results were
also sensitive to assumed insulin daily doses (IU) for insulin glargine and biphasic insulin
aspart after the first year. CONCLUSIONS: The outcomes of this CEA and CUA were
that exenatide has been projected to improve life expectancy and quality-adjusted life
expectancy compared to both insulin glargine and to biphasic insulin aspart in patients
with type 2 diabetes failing OADs. Based upon these results exenatide could be considered good value for money in Portugal regardless of baseline BMI levels.
PDB52
LONG-TERM COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF LIRAGLUTIDE VS.
ROSIGLITAZONE IN THE CZECH REPUBLIC
Dolezal T1, Niewada M2, Rychna K3, Czech M4
1
Institute for Health Economics and Technology Assessment, Prague, Czech Republic;
2
HealthQuest sp z o.o., Warsaw, Poland; 3Novo Nordisk, Prague 6, Czech Republic; 4Novo
Nordisk Pharma Sp z.o.o., Warsaw, Poland
OBJECTIVES: To assess the long-term cost-effectiveness of treatment with liraglutide on
top of standard therapy with glimepiride (SU) compared with rosiglitazone in people with
type 2 diabetes. METHODS: The extensively published and validated CORE Diabetes
Model was populated with the clinical data from LEAD-1 trial: liraglutide + SU vs.
rosiglitazone + SU. The analysis was performed from the Czech health care services payer’s
perspective. a 20-year time horizon was chosen to reflect the costs and outcomes of diabetes as these are often only seen in the later stages of the disease. The analysis used health
state utility values from published sources to assess the effect of treatment on QALYs.
The unit costs of treatment and complications were derived from published sources or
A293
based on expert opinion survey and official tariff lists for health care services paid by
public payer (insurance company). All figures are shown in CZK and EUR (100 CZK =
3.94 EUR). RESULTS: QALYs increased with liraglutide 1,2 mg + SU vs. SU + rosiglitazone 4 mg by 0.236. Total direct costs increased by CZK 45,679 (c1800) resulting in
incremental costs per QALY of CZK 193,468 (c7623). The incremental cost-effectiveness
ratio for liraglutide 1.8 mg + SU vs. SU + rosiglitazone 4 mg was estimated at CZK
378,762 (c14,923) per QALY gained (QALYs increased by 0.270). Total costs (including
indirect costs) increased by CZK 44,028 (c1735) and CZK 100,301 (c3952) resulting in
an incremental cost per QALY gained of CZK 186,475 (c7347) and CZK 371,188
(c14,624), respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Treatment with liraglutide added to a sulphonylurea is a cost-effective intervention compared with adding rosiglitazone and is likely to
represent good value for money in the Czech Republic setting.
PDB53
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF PREGABALIN VERSUS USUAL CARE IN
REFRACTORY OUT-PATIENTS WITH PAINFUL DIABETIC PERIPHERAL
NEUROPATHY (PDPN) FOLLOWED IN PRIMARY CARE SETTINGS
de Salas-Cansado M1, Pérez C2, Navarro A3, Saldaña MT4, Rejas J5
1
TFS, Madrid, Spain; 2Pain Clinic, Hospital de la Princesa, Madrid, Spain; 34Primary Care
Health Centre Puerta del Ángel, Madrid, Spain; 4Primary Care Health Centre Raíces,
Castrillón, Asturias, Spain; 5Pfizer España, Alcobendas/Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Estimate the cost-effectiveness (CE) of Pregabalin (PGB) and Usual
Care (UC) in refractory outpatients with pDPN treated in usual medical practice in
Primary Care settings in Spain. METHODS: Data extracted from a 12-week noninterventional study were used in the CE analysis. Previously, PGB naïve patients
treated with UC or PGB, matched by age (+5 years), sex and pain intensity (+5 pts),
refractory (≥40 VAS-MPQ) to previous treatment were selected. Patients could switch
to PGB (monotherapy/add-on) or to UC other than PGB. Time horizon was 12 weeks.
Effectiveness was expressed as quality-adjusted life-years (QALY) gain. The CEA
included the perspectives of the NHS and society (2006), with results expressed as
incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER). Bootstrapping techniques (10,000 resamples) were used to obtain the probabilistic ICER, its 95% percentile confidence
interval (CI) and the CE acceptability curve. Univariate probabilistic sensitivity analysis was also performed. RESULTS: A total of 189 patients, 112 in PGB group and 77
in UC were identified. Compared with UC, PGB was associated with higher QALY
gain; 0.0406 ± 0.0343 versus 0.0285 ± 0.0350 (P = 0.598). Although drug costs were
higher for PGB (c262 ± 132 vs. c66 ± 66, P < 0.001), overall total costs (c1368 ±
1229 vs. c1258 ± 1474; P = 0.587), or health care costs (c628 ± 590 vs. c469 ± 420;
P = 0.134) were similar, although due its observational design and small sample size,
ICERs varied extensively from c5302 (95% CI: dominant; c144,105) for total costs
to c14,381 (dominant; c115,648) for health care costs and c39,592 (dominant;
c131,754) for drug costs. However, probabilistic analyses showed 79% to 84% of
ICERs were below the threshold of c30,000/QALY. CONCLUSIONS: This study
suggests that using PGB to treat refractory out-patients with pDPN in community
medical practice in Spain is cost-effective compared to UC in majority of patients. It
also highlights the burden of the disease and supports the availability of effective
treatments available for patients not achieving pain relief from older therapies.
PDB54
COMPARISON OF TREATMENT COSTS BETWEEN BASAL-SUPPORTED
ORAL THERAPY (BOT) WITH INSULIN GLARGINE (GLA) AND BOT
WITH INSULIN DETEMIR (DET) IN PATIENTS WITH TYPE 2 DIABETES
(T2D): ECONOMIC EVALUATION BASED ON THE RESULTS OF THE
INSULIN GLARGINE (LANTUS®) VERSUS INSULIN DETEMIR (LEVEMIR®)
TREAT-TO-TARGET (L2T3) STUDY
Schädlich PK1, Koltermann KC1, Dippel FW2, Hagenmeyer EG1, Häussler B1
1
IGES Institut GmbH, Berlin, Germany; 2Sanofi-Aventis Deutschland GmbH, Berlin, Germany
OBJECTIVES: To compare, from the perspective of Statutory Health Insurance (SHI)
in Germany, direct diabetes-related treatment costs (DTC) in T2D patients during the
first year after initiation of a BOT with either of the long-acting insulin analogues
GLA or DET, based on the results of a randomized controlled trial (RCT), the L2T3
study [1]. METHODS: According to the study protocol of the 24-week RCT, GLA
was administered once daily, DET [2] twice daily. The respective insulin consumption
was extrapolated to 52 weeks via logarithmic regression. Due to proof of non-inferiority in the L2T3 study, a cost-minimization analysis was conducted. DTC from the
SHI perspective comprised insulin consumption, test strips, needles and lancets. In the
base-case analysis, average values of all model parameters were applied. Taking a
conservative approach, it was assumed that needles were changed daily (disadvantage
for GLA). a new test strip and lancet were assumed for each blood glucose measurement. In comprehensive sensitivity analyses (impact analysis, analysis of extremes,
Monte Carlo simulation), the robustness of the base-case results was tested. RESULTS:
The base-case analysis revealed savings of c767 in annual DTC per patient when using
BOT with GLA (c1141) compared to DET (c1908). Of these savings, c517 (67%) fell
upon insulin, c214 (28%) upon test strips and c36 (5%) upon lancets. Savings in
favour of GLA turned out to be robust in the sensitivity analyses. Price and insulin
consumption of DET had the highest impact on these savings. CONCLUSIONS:
Initiation of a BOT with GLA in T2D patients after failure of oral antidiabetic therapy
alone may lead to substantial savings for SHI compared to BOT with DET.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT: This study was supported by Sanofi-Aventis Deutschland
GmbH, Berlin, Germany. [1] Swinnen et al. Diabetes Care 2010: doi:10.237/doc09–
2294 [2] In the treatment of T2D, in combination with oral medications, it is recommended to use DET once daily.
A294
PDB55
COMPARISON OF RESOURCE USE AND COSTS IN TYPE 1 DIABETES
PATIENTS TREATED WITH DIFFERENT LONG ACTING INSULINS IN A
BASAL-BOLUS REGIMEN IN GERMANY
Bierwirth RA1, Kostev K2, Dippel FW3, Fuchs S4, Kotowa W4
1
Ambulantes Diabteszentrum am Elisabeth-Krankenhaus, Essen, Germany; 2IMS Health
GmbH & Co. OHG, Frankfurt am Main, Germany; 3Sanofi-Aventis Deutschland GmbH,
Berlin, Germany; 4IMS Health GmbH & Co. OHG, Nürnberg, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Compare resource utilization and treatment costs with three different
basal insulins in type-1-diabetics (T1D). METHODS: A cohort study based on a representative database (IMS® Disease Analyzer) included T1D who had started an intensified conventional therapy (ICT) with NPH-insulin (NPH), insulin glargine (GLA) or
insulin detemir (DET) between July 2000 and February 2008 and whose data were
continuously documented at least 12 months before and 18 months after ICT initiation.
The variables age, gender, diabetes duration, HbA1c, Body Mass Index (BMI), insurance
status, geographical region and specification of the practice were collected. Diabetesrelated resource utilization (insulin, test strips, lancets, pens, needles, glucose i.v., glucagon, physician visits and hospitalization) and associated direct treatment costs
(excluding physicians visits and hospitalization) were determined for a time period of
12 months for patients receiving NPH, GLA and DET, respectively. The results were
adjusted applying a multivariate regression model. RESULTS: A total of 1218 T1D
received an ICT with NPH, 1079 with GLA and 443 with DET, respectively. The
unadjusted annual direct treatment costs were c1308 for NPH, c1512 for GLA and
c1729 for DET. After adjusting ICT with GLA showed economic advantages compared
to NPH (−c234/year; P < 0.0001) or DET (−c425/year; P = 0.2800). The consumption
of basal insulin and test strips was lower in patients treated with GLA compared to
NPH (−6.00 U/day; P = 0.3514 and −0.31 strips/day; P = 0.8291) or DET (−3.23 U/
day; P < 0.0001 and −0.59 strips/day; P = 0.0235). CONCLUSIONS: After adjustment
this analysis of German real-life data showed that ICT with GLA is related to lower
annual treatment costs than ICT with NPH or DET. In view of the equal clinical efficacy
as reported in several randomized clinical trials [1, 2] and the economic advantages,
GLA should be regarded as the favored therapeutic option in ICT for T1D in Germany.
PDB56
PHARMACOECONOMIC CONSEQUENCES OF LOSARTAN THERAPY IN
PATIENTS UNDERGOING DIABETIC END-STAGE RENAL DISEASE IN EU
AND USA
Citarella A, de Portu S, Cammarota S, Menditto E, Mantovani LG
CIRFF, Federico II University, Naples, Italy
OBJECTIVES: Diabetic nephropathy is the most frequent cause of End Stage Renal
Disease (ESRD). As ESRD incidence continuously increases, more resources are needed
for treatment. The objective was to evaluate the economic impact of losartan added to
the standard care administered to diabetic subjects with ESRD. The analysis has involved
more than 500 million inhabitants. METHODS: We used standard methods to conduct
an economic evaluation comparing the economic outcomes deriving from the administration of losartan added to standard care versus standard care alone in patients with
type 2 diabetes mellitus (DM) and nephropathy over 3.4 years. The study was conducted
from the perspective of the third-party payer hence. The clinical outcome data were
based on the results from the RENAAL trial. Direct medical costs are referred to the
purchase costs of losartan and the cost of hospitalizations. The costs were discounted
back at an annual rate of 3%. Also sensitivity analysis was performed. RESULTS:
RENAAL study established that losartan confers strong renal protection in patients with
DM and nephropathy. Losartan results into a cost saving in all countries considered: 3
c602.98/Italy, c4531.35/France, c3019.66/Germany, c3949.50/Switzerland and
c3855.50/USA per patient. Results are not sensitive to both clinical and economic
variables. CONCLUSIONS: In addition to the medical benefit, this analysis demonstrates the economic relevance of treatment with losartan in DM patients with
nephropathy.
PDB57
LOWER TREATMENT COSTS WITH INSULIN GLARGINE COMPARED
TO INSULIN DETEMIR IN TYPE 1 DIABETES PATIENTS TREATED WITH
A BASAL-BOLUS REGIMEN IN GERMANY
Wiesner T1, Schädlich PK2, Dippel FW3, Koltermann K2, Hagenmeyer EG2
1
MVZ Stoffwechselmedizin Leipzig, Leipzig, Germany; 2IGES Institut GmbH, Berlin, Germany;
3
Sanofi-Aventis Deutschland GmbH, Berlin, Germany
OBJECTIVES: To compare, from the perspective of Statutory Health Insurance (SHI)
in Germany, direct diabetes-related treatment costs in patients with type 1 diabetes
mellitus (T1DM) during the first year after the switch from Neutral Protamin Hagedorn insulin (NPH) to the respective long acting insulin in the course of a basal-bolus
insulin regimen (ICT) with insulin glargine or insulin detemir as the basal insulin
component. METHODS: Natural units of resource consumption incurred by basal
and bolus insulin, needles, lancets, and test strips were modelled over a period of 1
year in each of the two cost-minimization analyses, based on the results of two controlled clinical trials [1, 2]. Resources were valued in prices of 15 January 2010 relevant to SHI in the outpatient sector. In the base-case analyses, average values of all
the model parameters were applied. In comprehensive sensitivity analyses (impact
analysis, analysis of extremes, Monte Carlo simulation), the robustness of the basecase results was tested. RESULTS: In the base-case analyses, there were savings of
c378 or 15% and c311 or 14%, respectively, per patient and year obtained by insulin
glargine compared to insulin detemir. Savings in favour of GLA turned out to be
13th Euro Abstracts
robust in the sensitivity analyses. Even in the analyses of extremes, there were always
savings obtained by insulin glargine, irrespective of insulin detemir being given once,
once to twice, or twice daily. When simulating real-life conditions the savings obtained
by insulin glargine instead of insulin detemir were maintained. CONCLUSIONS:
Treatment of T1DM patients with insulin glargine as the basal insulin component of
an ICT may lead to substantial savings from the German SHI perspective as compared
to insulin detemir. [1] Pieber et al. Diabet Med 2007;24:635–42; [2] Heller et al. Clin
Ther 2009;31:2086–97.
PDB58
PHARMACOEPIDEMIOLOGICAL ASSAY AND COST-MINIMIZATION
ANALYSIS OF ORAL ANTIDIABETIC MEDICATIONS AND INSULINS IN
LITHUANIA
Kildonaviciute G, Stankunaite E, Kadusevicius E, Petraityte A
Kaunas Medical University, Kaunas, Lithuania
OBJECTIVES: To conduct pharmacoepidemiological research and cost-minimization
analysis of oral antidiabetic medications and insulins in Lithuania. METHODS: Medications were grouped according to the ATC classification system. Our research results
were reported in DDDs per 1000 inhabitants per day (DDD/TID). Calculations of
drug prices and total expenditures on antidiabetic medications were made by using
data from National Patient Funds Price List in 2006–2009 years. Reference pricing
methodology was used to accomplish our cost-minimization analysis. RESULTS:
Total consumption of hypoglycaemic agents increased by 33% from 21.54 DDD/TID
in 2006 to 28.72 DDD/TID in 2009. Utilization of insulin increased by 30% reaching
the value 9.43 DDD/TID in 2009 and oral antidiabetic medications increased by
35%—19.29 DDD/TID in 2009. Total expenditures on hypoglycaemic agents
increased by 23% from LTL 57.138 mlln in 2006 to LTL 70.531 mlln in 2009 (1EUR
= 3.4528LTL). Single DDD prices ranged from 0.70 LTL/DDD to 5.01 LTL/DDD of
oral antidiabetics, and from 5.67 LTL/DDD to 2.97 LTL/DDD for insulins. With reference to meta-analysis and NICE recommendations, considering the similar efficacy
and safety within drug classes, cost-minimization analysis using the reference-based
pricing could be implemented and total expenditures could be decreased by 27%
(saving LTL 19 mlln. yearly). CONCLUSIONS: Our findings suggest that implementation of reference-based pricing could be a strong fiscal measure helping to rationalize
increasing direct health care expenditures by 27%.
PDB59
HEALTH ECONOMIC EVALUATIONS COMPARING THE BASAL INSULIN
ANALOGUE GLARGINE (GLA) WITH NEUTRAL PROTAMINE
HAGEDORN (NPH) INSULIN IN INTENSIFIED INSULIN THERAPY (ICT)
IN PATIENTS WITH TYPE 1 DIABETES: A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW
Hagenmeyer EG, Koltermann KC, Schädlich PK, Häussler B
IGES Institut GmbH, Berlin, Germany
OBJECTIVES: To perform a systematic literature review of health economic evaluations comparing GLA with NPH as the basal component of an ICT in patients with
type 1 diabetes. METHODS: The search was performed between January 1, 2000 and
December 1, 2009 via Embase, Medline, the Cochrane Library, the databases of
German Medical Science and of DAHTA (Deutsche Agentur für Health Technology
Assessment), and abstract books of relevant scientific congresses. The inclusion of
retrieved studies was based on predefined criteria. The included studies were assessed
according to established methodological and quality aspects. RESULTS: A total of
seven health-economic evaluations from four different countries were included: six
modeling studies, all of them cost-utility analyses (CUA), and one cost-minimization
analysis (CMA) based on a claims data analysis. One CUA showed dominance of GLA
because of higher utilities and lower costs. The other five CUAs varied in their additional costs per quality adjusted life-year (QALY) gained for treatment with GLA
between c3.859 and c57.002 (incremental cost-effectiveness ratio, ICER). The CMA
revealed about c160 higher diabetes-specific costs per year for GLA in the German
Statutory Health Insurance (SHI) setting. All the included studies showed good quality
despite a few constraints. Nevertheless, they all contained enough explanatory power
to evaluate the effectiveness of GLA in comparison to NPH. CONCLUSIONS: Despite
some differences concerning evaluation methods (CUA or CMA), data sources (randomized controlled trial, claims data) and country specific conditions (pricing and
reimbursement situation) the identified health economic analyses showed high conformity concerning the main target parameter. Most of the studies (5 of 7) showed a
good to very good cost-effectiveness in favour of GLA compared to NPH depending
on the respective design of the health economic analysis chosen. ACKNOWLEDGMENT: This study was supported by Sanofi-Aventis Deutschland GmbH, Berlin,
Germany.
PDB60
HEALTH ECONOMIC EVALUATIONS COMPARING THE BASAL INSULIN
ANALOGUES INSULIN GLARGINE (GLA) AND INSULIN DETEMIR (DET)
IN INTENSIFIED INSULIN THERAPY (ICT) IN PATIENTS WITH TYPE 1
DIABETES: A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW
Hagenmeyer EG, Koltermann KC, Schädlich PK, Häussler B
IGES Institut GmbH, Berlin, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Due to limited health care resources economic evaluations of alternative drug treatment methods become more important, especially in chronic diseases
like diabetes mellitus. Therefore, a systematic literature review of health economic
evaluations comparing GLA with DET as the basal component of an ICT in patients
13th Euro Abstracts
with type 1 diabetes was performed. METHODS: The search was performed between
January 1, 2000 and December 1, 2009 via Embase, Medline, the Cochrane Library,
the databases of German Medical Science and of DAHTA (Deutsche Agentur für
Health Technology Assessment), and abstract books of relevant scientific congresses.
The inclusion of retrieved studies was based on predefined criteria. The included
studies were assessed according to established methodological and quality aspects.
RESULTS: A total of four health-economic evaluations from four different countries
were included: two modeling studies, comprising one cost-utility analysis (CUA) and
one cost-minimization analysis (CMA), as well as two claims data analyses, both
CMAs. Two of the CMAs show an economic advantage in favour of GLA vs. DET
and the third CMA showed cost neutrality between the basal insulin analogues. The
CUA showed an economic advantage for DET. CONCLUSIONS: Despite some differences concerning evaluation methods (CUA or CMA), data sources (randomized
controlled trial, claims data) and country specific conditions (pricing and reimbursement situation) the identified health economic analyses showed high conformity concerning the target parameters. Two of the studies showed an advantage in favour of
GLA compared to DET, the extent of which depended on the respective design of the
health economic analysis chosen. a systematic review to compare the health economic
outcomes of GLA and NPH-insulin was done separately. ACKNOWLEDGMENT:
This study was supported by Sanofi-Aventis Deutschland GmbH, Berlin, Germany.
PDB61
ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF LIRAGLUTIDE VS. ROSIGLITAZONE OR
EXENATIDE FOR TYPE 2 DIABETES MELLITUS IN BULGARIA
Ivanova A1, Petrova G1, Wrona W2, Valov V3, Czech M4
1
Medical University, Faculty of Pharmacy, Sofia, Bulgaria; 2HealthQuest sp z o.o., Warsaw,
Poland; 3Novo Nordisk Pharma EAD, Sofia, Bulgaria; 4Novo Nordisk Pharma Sp z.o.o.,
Warsaw, Poland
OBJECTIVES: In these cost-utility analyses CORE Diabetes Model and LEAD-1 and
LEAD-6 trials data were used to compare liraglutide (a glucagon-like peptide-1 receptor agonist) to rosiglitazone, both in combination with glimepiride, and to exenatide,
both with metformin and/or sulfonylurea. METHODS: The analyses were performed
from the health care services payer’s perspective. In the base-case analysis a time
horizon of 20 years has been chosen. The analysis compared patients treated with
liraglutide 1.2 mg or rosiglitazone 4 mg (LEAD-1) or liraglutide 1.8 mg or exenatide
10 µg b.i.d. (LEAD-6). The analysis used health state utility values derived from literature. The cost of treatment and complications were based on officially published
sources for medicines prices (www.mh.government.bg), for hospital charges (www.
nhif.bg) and verified by expert opinion survey (1 BGN = 0.51 EUR). RESULTS:
QALYs increased with liraglutide 1.2 mg by 0.252 (SD 0.129) years (LEAD-1). Total
costs increased by BGN7722 (c3948) resulting in an incremental cost per QALY
gained of BGN30,674 (c15,684). Based on LEAD-6 trial data liraglutide 1.8 mg
resulted in increase of 0.151 (SD 0.124) QALYs. Total costs increased by BGN4151
(c2122) with incremental cost BGN27,404 (c14,012) per QALY. CONCLUSIONS:
In Bulgarian health care system settings liraglutide added to standard treatment have
been shown to be cost-effective in comparison with rosiglitazone and exenatide for
type 2 diabetes.
PDB62
COST-UTILITY ANALYSIS OF SAXAGLIPTIN AS AN ADD-ON THERAPY
TO METFORMIN IN TYPE 2 DIABETES PATIENTS FROM THE BRAZILIAN
PRIVATE HEALTH SYSTEM
Eliaschewitz FG1, Asano E2, Nita ME2, Rached R2, Donato BM3
1
CPCLIN—Centro de Pesquisas Clínicas, São Paulo, SP, Brazil; 2Bristol-Myers Squibb S/A,
São Paulo, SP, Brazil; 3Bristol-Myers Squibb, Wallingford, CT, USA
OBJECTIVES: This is a cost-utility analysis of saxagliptin (treatment group) vs. thiazolidinediones (control group) as add-on therapy in type 2 diabeties (T2D) patients
not achieving appropriate glycaemic control with metformin, from the Brazilian
private health system (PHS) perspective. METHODS: A discrete event simulation
model based on UKPDS68 study was developed in order to simulate 40 years for a
cohort of 1000 patients. Safety and efficacy data were obtained from a systematic
review and meta-analysis of published literature. Epidemiological and costing data
were obtained from DIAPS79, an outcome study of the treatment patterns and costs
of T2D patients in the Brazilian PHS. Pharmaceutical costs were based on Brazilian
official factory price. Insulin plus metformin was defined as rescue therapy. An annual
discount rate of 5% was applied to both costs and benefits. Deterministic and probabilistic sensitivity analyses were conducted to assess the robustness of the results.
RESULTS: According to the model, the lipid profile benefits from thiazolidinediones
did not translate into long-term vascular benefits when compared to saxagliptin
(vascular fatal events risk reduction of −0.0034 vs. pioglitazone and −0.0053 vs.
rosiglitazone). Saxagliptin was dominant when compared to both pioglitazone and
rosiglitazone as the add-on therapy of choice to metformin (costs savings per patient
of R$3.874 vs. rosiglitazone and R$3.996 vs. pioglitazone; incremental 0.13 QALY
per patient vs. pioglitazone and 0.14 QALY per patient vs. rosiglitazone). In the
deterministic sensitivity analysis, HbA1c level was the most impactful parameter in
the model, but saxagliptin remained the dominant option in all cases. In the probabilisitc sensitivity analysis, saxagliptin had a greater than 90% probability of being
cost-effective for a willingness-to-pay of zero. CONCLUSIONS: Saxagliptin is associated with lower costs and increased quality-adjusted life expectancy compared to thiazolidinediones as add-on therapy in T2D patients failing to achieve adequate glycaemic
control on metformin monotherapy.
A295
DIABETES/ENDOCRINE DISORDERS – Patient-Reported Outcomes Studies
PDB63
LIRAGLUTIDE IN THE TREATMENT OF TYPE 2 DIABETES MIELLITUS—
ECONOMIC EVALUATION IN ROMANIAN SETTING
Ionescu D1, Niewada M2, Czech M3
1
Carol Davila University of Medicine and Pharmacy, Bucharest, Romania, 2HealthQuest sp
z.o.o., Warsaw, Poland, 3Novo Nordisk Pharma Sp z.o.o., Warsaw, Poland
OBJECTIVES: Our aim was to assess cost-utility ratios of liraglutide, a GLP-1 receptor agonist, in comparison with rosiglitazone, glimepiride and exenatide for type 2
diabetes in Romanian health care system settings. METHODS: The CORE Diabetes
Model and clinical data from LEAD-1 (liraglutide vs. rosiglitazone, both with
glimepiride, 1st case), LEAD-2 (liraglutide vs. glimepiride, both with metformin, 2nd
case) and LEAD-6 trial (liraglutide vs. exenatide, both with metformin and/or sulfonylurea, 3rd case) trials were used. The health care services payer’s perspective and
20-year time horizon have been chosen. Health state utility values and cost date were
based DRG Data from “Center for Research and Evaluation of Healthcare Services,”
Romania, CaNaMed National Catalog of Medicines Prices (official tariff lists) and
expert opinion. RESULTS: In the 1st case QALYs increased by 0.201 (SD 0.105) years
with liraglutide 1.2 mg and by 0.231 (SD 0.107) years with liraglutide 1.8 mg. Total
costs increased by c3266 and c5378 resulting in an incremental cost per QALY gained
of c16,209 and c23,282, respectively. In the 2nd case, liraglutide 1.2 mg resulted in
increase of 0.155 (SD 0.099) QALYs and liraglutide 1.8 mg 0.170 (SD 0.146) QALYs
with incremental cost per QALY gained of EUR 29,909 and EUR 38,830, respectively.
In the 3rd case QALYs increased by 0.125 (SD 0.102) years with liraglutide 1.8 mg,
total costs increased by c1898, an incremental cost was c15,123 per QALY. CONCLUSIONS: Based on efficacy data from clinical trials and validated model liraglutide
has been shown to be cost-effective when compared with rosiglitazone, glimepiride
and exenatide for the treatment of type 2 diabetes.
PDB64
TREATMENT PERSISTENCE AMONG PATIENTS INITIATING INSULIN
THERAPY WITH INSULIN DETEMIR IN A FLEXPEN® VERSUS NPH
INSULIN IN A VIAL. RETROSPECTIVE DATABASE ANALYSIS BASED ON
A LARGE US MANAGED CARE ORGANIZATION
Conner C1, Buysman E2, Liu F2, Aagren M3, Bouchard J4
1
Novo Nordisk, Seattle, WA, USA; 2i3 Innovus, Eden Prairie, MN, USA; 3Novo Nordisk Inc,
Princeton, NJ, USA; 4Novo Nordisk, Plaistow, NH, USA
OBJECTIVES: Persistence with respect to injectable therapy in type 2 diabetes is
known to impose a challenge to patients. One potential explanation is aversion to
injection and risk of hypoglycemic events. Insulin analogues have shown in clinical
trials to reduce the risk of hypoglycemic events versus human insulins, and insulin
injection using a pen device is generally perceived as less burdensome than administration via vial and syringe. METHODS: This retrospective data analysis compared
persistence between two types of basal insulin and administration: Neutral protamine
hagedorn, NPH, administered by vial and syringe and insulin detemir, IDet, administered by FlexPen®. Data were derived from health care claims between 2004 and 2009
from a large national US payer and included type 2 diabetes patients that initiated
either IDet FlexPen® or NPH in vials without any prescription fills for any insulin in
the previous 12 months. Patients were defined as being persistent to therapy as long
as they filled their prescription within the 80th percentile of days between fills adjusted
to reflect differences in pack sizes. RESULTS: The IDet FlexPen® cohort (n = 1082)
and the NPH vial cohort (n = 794) were of similar age (54.06 vs. 53.13, P = 0.134),
but IDet FlexPen® had a lower proportion of female patients than NPH vials (44%
vs. 55%, P < 0.001) and fewer treatment naïve patients (no pre-index OADs) (9% vs.
45%, P < 0.001). Persistency to therapy at 12 months after initiation was 23% and
13% (P < 0.001) for IDet FlexPen® and NPH vials, respectively. Average days of
persistence was 167 days for the IDet FlexPen® cohort and 123 days for NPH vials
(P < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Persistence to insulin therapy among type 2 diabetes
patients could be improved. This study suggests that insulin persistency may be
improved by initiating insulin using therapies associated with lower risk of hypoglycemic events and administering it in a pen.
PDB65
THE METHODOLOGICAL QUALITY AND EFFECTIVENESS OF
ADHERENCE INTERVENTIONS: A REVIEW OF DIABETES TYPE II
INTERVENTIONS
Wilke T1, Mueller S2, Groth A1
1
Institute for Pharmacoeconomics and Drug Logistics, University of Wismar, Wismar,
Germany; 2University of Wismar, Wismar, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Adherence interventions (AI) are an important part of the health care
provision situation on the ground. For ethical, clinical and health economic reasons,
it is vital to identify methodological characteristics of successful AI. The aim of this
review is to do this for AI focused on oral anti-diabetics (Diabetes type II). METHODS:
A comprehensive review of Diabetes type II AI effectiveness studies was conducted
[Strings: (oral hypoglycemic agents; oral anti-diabetic medications; diabetes; hyperglycemia; Biguanide; Metformin; Potassium channel inhibitors; Dipeptidyl peptidase-4
inhibitors) and (improvement; enhancement; pharmacy, pharmacist; doctors; interventions; programs; reminder; prevention; patient education)]. Only interventions aiming
to improve medication adherence/persistence were included. RESULTS: A total of
6977 contributions were identified; after detailed examination by two reviewers 15
publications evaluating 19 different AI were included. 10 AI were able to improve the
A296
adherence/persistence and eight were able to improve the blood glucose levels of
patients (double counting in three cases); five had no effect at all. Four dimensions of
the methodological quality of AI programs were identified: 1) measurement of adherence/persistence/clinical outcomes, 2) measurement of NA/NP causes, 3) use of effective/validated intervention measures; and 4) effective program evaluation. The authors
defined 5 detailed methodological requirements per dimension and, based on this,
developed a corresponding scoring model (MIN Score 0, MAX score 20). All 19 AI
programs were evaluated in the scoring model (average score 8.05): • Score <5: 3
AI—no adherence/blood glucose level improvement; • Score 5–9: 8 AI—6 with
improvement in both adherence and/or blood glucose levels; • Score >9: 8 AI—all
improved adherence and/or blood glucose levels. CONCLUSIONS: The scoring model
provides a starting point for the methodical evaluation of AI. However, further development and testing of both the elements and construction is needed for medical indications other than diabetes type II.
PDB66
THE 8-ITEM MORISKY MEDICATION ADHERENCE SCALE MMAS:
TRANSLATION AND VALIDATION STUDY OF THE MALAYSIAN
VERSION
Al-Qazaz HK1, Hassali MA1, Shafie AA2, Sulaiman SAS1, Sundram S3, Morisky DE4
1
Universiti Sains Malaysia, Minden, Penang, Malaysia; 2Universiti Sains Malaysia, Penang,
Penang, Malaysia; 3Hospital Balik Pulau, Balik Pulau, P.Penang, Malaysia; 4UCLA School of
Public Health, Los Angeles, CA, USA
OBJECTIVES: To translate the MMAS into the Malaysian language, and to examine
the psychometric properties of the Malaysian version of the MMAS among patients
with type 2 diabetes, including its validity and reliability. METHODS: After obtaining
permission, a standard “forward-backward” translation procedure was used to create
the Malaysian version of the MMAS from the original English version. a convenience
sample of 223 outpatients with type 2 diabetes was identified between May and September, 2009. All data were collected from the Penang General Hospital, Penang,
Malaysia. Instruments consisted of the Malaysian version of MMAS, the Malaysian
version of the old four-item Morisky scale and a sociodemographic questionnaire.
Medical records were reviewed for hemoglobin A1C (HbA1C) levels and other clinical
data. Reliability was tested for internal consistency using Cronbach’s α coefficient.
Validity was confirmed using convergent and known group validity. RESULTS:
Employing the recommended scoring method, the mean ± SD of MMAS scores was
6.13 ± 1.72. Moderate internal consistency was found, (Cronbach’s α = 0.675), the
test-retest reliability value by using Spearman’s rank correlation was 0.816 (P <
0.001). a positive correlation between the eight- and four-item MMAS was found (r
= 0.792; P < 0.01). For known group validity, a significant relationship between
MMAS categories and HbA1c categories (χ2 = 20.261; P ≥ 0.001) was found. The
MMAS sensitivity and specificity, with positive and negative predictive values were
77.61%, 45.37%, 46.84% and 76.56%, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: The MMAS
can be used for medication adherence measurement in diabetes. The findings of this
validation study indicate that the Malaysian version of the MMAS is a reliable and
valid measure of medication adherence which can now be used in clinical practice.
PDB67
FACTORS INFLUENCING VALUATION OF- AND WILLINGNESS TO
PARTICIPATE IN- A LIFESTYLE INTERVENTION: AN EXPLORATORY
CONJOINT ANALYSIS WITH DIABETES TYPE 2 PATIENTS
Van Gils PF1, Lambooij MS1, Struijs JN1, Flanderijn MH2, van den Berg M3, van den Berg B4
1
National Institute of Public Health and the Environment, Bilthoven, The Netherlands; 2Leids
UniversityMedical Centre, Leiden, The Netherlands; 3National Institute for Public Health and
the Environment (RIVM), Bilthoven, The Netherlands; 4University of York, York, UK
OBJECTIVES: The last decade several studies have proven that lifestyle interventions
can be effective for people with or at risk for diabetes. Because effectiveness of preventive interventions is affected by non-participation (adherence), it is important to
understand factors influencing people’s willingness to participate in a lifestyle intervention. Therefore, the aim of this exploratory analysis is to examine which factors of a
lifestyle program influence its valuation and willingness to participate. METHODS:
We used conjoint analysis to empirically examine associations between the factors that
influence participation and participants’ valuation of an intervention and participants’
willingness to participate in a lifestyle intervention. For this purpose participants
received a questionnaire with four hypothetical lifestyle interventions. They were
asked to value the hypothetical scenarios with a grade from “1” to “10” and furthermore they were asked if they would be willing to participate in these hypothetical
programs. Linear and logistic regression techniques were used for the analyses.
RESULTS: The factors “group activity,” “counselling,” and “receiving money” were
positively associated with the scores of the valuation of the programmes. Logistic
regression analysis showed that money was the only factor that was independently
associated with respondents’ willingness to participate in a lifestyle intervention.
Subgroup analysis showed that receiving an amount of money was not associated with
willingness to participate, but having to pay is negatively associated with participation
in the lifestyle intervention. CONCLUSIONS: It appeared that only financial disincentives were independently associated with willingness to participate in a lifestyle intervention. Our conjoint analysis results suggest that financial incentives, in the form of
bonuses, cannot be used to encourage people to participate in lifestyle interventions.
Financial incentives, in the form of payments might however discourage participation,
regardless of the content of the program.
13th Euro Abstracts
PDB68
HEALTH RELATED QUALITY OF LIFE (HRQL) AND EQ-5D UTILITIES IN
A TYPE 2 DIABETES (T2D) POPULATION: RESULTS FROM A SWEDISH
SURVEY
Sörngård H1, Lagging E2, Lindh A3, Jörgensen L1
1
AstraZeneca Nordic MC, Södertälje, Sweden; 2Stockholm Diabetic Patient Association,
Stockholm, Sweden, 3Husläkarna i Österåker, Åkersberga, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: To present HRQL data from a previously presented survey on T2D
patients’ perceived quality of care in Stockholm, Sweden. METHODS: A postal survey
including EQ-5D was distributed to 1000 members of the Stockholm Diabetic Patient
Association and 1000 patients from five primary health care centers. Patients were
randomly selected, >18 years, having a diabetes diagnosis. Analysis of variance was
used to test the statistical hypothesis that patients within each subgroup had equal
mean utility. RESULTS: Response rate was 65% (1319/2000 questionnaires). T2D
diagnose was reported for 961 respondents of which 858 completed the EQ-5D
questionnaire. Mean age 69 years, 48.5 % female, BMI 28.4 kg/m2, mean duration
of T2D 11.3 years. Overall, the mean (SD) utility was 0.765 (0.260) and the current
health status reported on the VAS scale was 0.727 (0.189). Patients without any
hypoglycemic episode the previous month had a utility of 0.799 while those with 1,
2–5 or >5 episodes reported 0.774, 0.687 and 0.633, respectively. More than one
hypoglycemic episode resulted in significantly lower utility compared to none or only
one episode (P < 0.0001). The utility of obese patients, 0.704, was significantly lower
than for patients of normal weight, 0.806, or overweight, 0.790 (P < 0.0001). The
utility of patients not considering themselves responsible for the management of their
T2D was significantly lower, 0.608, compared to patients taking a limited, 0.774, or
full, 0.759, responsibility (P = 0.0005). Patients considering themselves having insufficient knowledge to cope with their T2D reported a lower utility, 0.689, compared
to patients with sufficient knowledge, 0.789 (P < 0.0001). Male respondents had a
higher utility, 0.796, compared to females, 0.731 (P = 0.0002). CONCLUSIONS:
Experience of hypoglycemic episodes, obesity, gender, patients’ perception of personal
responsibility and perceived knowledge about type 2 diabetes has significant impact
on health related quality of life in patients with type 2 diabetes.
PDB69
UTILITY VALUES FOR DIABETES COMPLICATIONS
Donatti C, Lloyd A, Henry N, Grant D
IMS Health, London, UK
OBJECTIVES: Cost-utility analysis in diabetes requires utility estimates for diabetic
complications. Models frequently rely on UKPDS data. UK requirements for preference elicitation have changed since UKPDS publication. We conducted a systematic
review of the literature to identify utility values for diabetes complications suitable for
use in Health Technology Assessment (HTA). METHODS: A systematic search of
online databases was conducted using key words relating to diabetes, major complications, utility assessment and quality of life. Reference lists of identified citations were
reviewed. Studies reporting utility single-index measures in patients with any of 33
pre-specified diabetes related states were included: states considered were diabetic
complications and adverse events associated with anti-diabetic therapies (AEs). Papers
were qualitatively assessed: criteria included relevance of studied population to Type
1 or Type 2 diabetes, sample size, methodological quality and consistency with current
UK HTA guidelines. Comorbidity is common in diabetes: methodology papers
addressing combination of utility values were identified in a structured search and
reviewed. RESULTS: The search returned 3024 hits, 169 articles were reviewed and
32 publications were identified as suitable for review. Utility or disutility values suitable for UK HTA were obtained for 23 diabetes states. For 10 complications, including
late stage renal disease and some AEs, no utility value were identified that met UK
HTA criteria. There is no consensus in the literature on how utility measures should
be combined in patients with more than one complication. CONCLUSIONS: We
identified a set of utility values suitable for economic analysis for HTA in diabetes.
To further inform UK HTA, additional research should create robust utility values for
diabetic renal disease, and evaluate the empirical accuracy of alternative methods of
combining utility values in patients with multiple complications.
PDB70
MEASUREMENT OF HRQOL USING EQ-5D IN TYPE 2 DIABETES
MELLITUS PATIENTS TREATED WITH ORAL ANTI-DIABETIC DRUGS IN
CHINA
Li HC1, Chang JH2, Liu GG3
1
China Pharmaceutical University, Nanjing, China; 2Novo Nordisk (China) Pharmaceuticals
Co., Ltd., Beijing, China, 3Peking University, Beijing, China
OBJECTIVES: The study is to measure the health-related quality of life (HRQOL) in
type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) patients with oral anti-diabetic drugs (OADs) therapy
using the Chinese version of EQ-5D, and examine their health status. METHODS:
The study was a cross-sectional survey conducted at 75 hospitals in nine cities in
China. There were 9577 T2DM patients administered with OADs therapy completed
the questionnaires. The survey period was from December 3rd, 2008 to July 31st, 2009.
Patients evaluated their health status using five dimensions (5D) and a visual analog
scale (VAS). Descriptive statistics was used to describe patients’ demographic characteristics, duration of the disease, the frequency of 5D responses and VAS score. STATA
9.2 was used for the analyses. RESULTS: The mean age of patients (±SD) was 59.5
± 12.7 years. 51.1% were male. The mean body mass index (±SD) was 24.3 ± 3.4 kg/
m2. The mean duration of disease (±SD) was 7.9 ± 6.3 years. For the five dimensions
13th Euro Abstracts
of EQ-5D, the frequency of T2DM patients responding as having “some problem”
and “extreme problem” was 4.6% and 1.6% for mobility, 7.9% and 1.4% for selfcare, 13.9% and 1.7% for usual activities, 27.5% and 1.1% for pain/discomfort, and
26.6% and 1.3% for anxiety/depression, respectively. The mean VAS score (±SD) of
patients was 70.4 ± 15.1. CONCLUSIONS: The rates of T2DM patients with “some
problem” in pain/discomfort, and anxiety/depression were relatively high; rate with
“extreme problem” for usual activities was also higher than other dimensions. The
results of 5D were consistent with the low VAS score. These findings imply that there
was a significant impact on the health status of T2DM patients with OADs therapy
due to pain/discomfort, and anxiety/depression. It underscores the urgent need to
adopt effective measures toward prevention and control of diabetes to improve
patients’ quality of life.
PDB71
QUALITY-ADJUSTED LIFE-YEAR (QALY) WEIGHTS ASSOCIATED WITH
DIFFERENT SEVERITY LEVELS OF DIABETIC RETINOPATHY
Heintz E1, Bourghardt Peebo B2, Wiréhn AB3, Rosenqvist U4, Levin LÅ1
1
Linköping University, Linköping, Sweden; 2Ryhov County Hospital, Jönköping, Sweden;
3
Östergötland County Council, Linköping, Sweden; 4Motala Hospital, Motala, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: The objective of this study was to elicit quality-adjusted life-year
(QALY) weights for the different severity levels of diabetic retinopathy (DR) and to
evaluate the adequacy of using certain health-related quality of life (HRQoL) instruments for this purpose. METHODS: The study population comprises 151 patients
with diabetes (type 1 and 2) that either attended the eye clinic at Linköping University
Hospital or were registered at any of the two vision centrals in Östergötland County,
Sweden. Participants were interviewed over the phone using time trade-off (TTO)
questions, the EuroQol Health Questionnaire (EQ-5D), the Health Utilities Index
Mark III (HUI-3) and the National Eye Institute Visual Function Questionnaire (NEIVFQ-25). The effect of other variables than DR on QALY weights was investigated
using ANCOVA and the generic instruments were tested for correlation with NEIVFQ-25. RESULTS: The ranges of the QALY weights estimated with the three generic
instruments were for no DR, BR, PDR, maculopathy and legal blindness 0.81–0.88,
0.72–0.78, 0.75–0.82, 0.74–0.81 and 0.39–0.68 respectively. In general, the differences in QALY weights between the different severity levels were reduced when
adjusted for clinical characteristics and co-morbidities. The difference in QALY
weights between the patients with no DR and legal blindness was significant for all
instruments. The correlations between the results from NEI-VFQ-25 and TTO, EQ-5D
score, EQ-5D VAS and HUI-3 were 0.27, 0.31, 0.38 and 0.68 respectively. CONCLUSIONS: This study presents QALY weights for different severity levels of DR, which
can be used in cost-effectiveness analyses of interventions directed to DR. Of the
instruments we used, HUI-3 seems to be the most sensitive to changes in HRQoL due
to progression of DR.
PDB72
FURTHER DEVELOPMENTS OF THE QUALITY OF LIFE ASSESSMENT OF
GROWTH HORMONE DEFICIENCY IN ADULTS (QOL-AGHDA)
Twiss J1, Mckenna S1, Doward L1, Hána V2, Karbownik-Lewinska M3, Popovic V4, Pura M5,
Ribeiro-Oliveira A6, Koltowska-Häggström M7
1
Galen Research Limited, Manchester, UK; 2Charles University, Prague, Czech Republic;
3
Medical University of Lodz, Lodz, Poland; 4University Clinical Centre, Belgrade, Serbia;
5
National Institute of Endocrinology & Diabetology, Lubochna, Slovak Republic;
6
Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Belo Horizonte, Brazil; 7Pfizer Endocrine Care,
Sollentuna, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: The QoL-AGHDA is the first true quality of life (QoL) measure for
adult growth hormone deficiency and is widely used in clinical practice and trials. In
the UK NICE advises that scores on the QoL-AGHDA should be used to guide treatment selection. The scale has good psychometric properties and has been shown to
be responsive to changes in disease severity. The objective of the study was to adapt
the QoL-AGHDA for the Czech Republic, Poland, Serbia, Slovakia and Brazil.
METHODS: The adaptation in each country required three stages: Translation, cognitive debriefing and a validation survey. The dual panel translation method was used
to ensure the items were translated accurately and expressed in everyday language.
Cognitive-debriefing interviews with local patients assessed face and content validity.
The validation survey tested the psychometric properties of the new scales and
included the Nottingham Health Profile (NHP) as a comparator measure. RESULTS:
Validation data are not available for Slovakia. Mean scores on the new versions of
the QoL-AGHDA ranged from 6.2 to 11.8 (maximum possible = 25). Internal consistency ranged from 0.89–0.91 and test-retest reliability from 0.88–0.93. QoLAGHDA scores were statistically significantly related to; perceived general health and
level of fatigue in the Czech Republic, perceived physical activity and level of fatigue
in Poland and Serbia and to perceived general health and rated QoL in Brazil. Across
the countries mean correlations with NHP sections were (as expected) highest with
energy level and emotional reactions (correlations 0.68–0.83) and lowest with sleep
disturbance and pain (correlations 0.38–0.46). CONCLUSIONS: This study indicates
that (with the exception of Slovakia which requires further validation) the new language versions of the QoL-AGHDA meet the standards of the original UK version
and the other 9 existing versions. The new adaptations represent valid and reliable
tools for measuring QoL in international clinical trials.
A297
PDB73
THE PANORAMA PAN-EUROPEAN SURVEY: HYPOGLYCAEMIA
ASSOCIATED WITH DIFFERENT PHARMACOLOGICAL TREATMENTS
FOR TYPE 2 DIABETES
Simon D1, Bradley C2, Gönder-Frederick L3, Eschwège EM4, de Pablos-Velasco P5,
Vandenberghe H6, Bouzamondo H7, Parhofer KG8
1
Hôpital de la Pitié/INSERM U-1018, Paris, France; 2Royal Holloway, University of London,
Surrey, UK; 3University of Virginia Health System, Charlottesville, VA, USA; 4INSERM, Villejuif,
France; 5Dr Negrin Hospital, Las Palmas University, Las Palmas de Gran Canaria, Spain;
6
AstraZeneca, Zaventem, Belgium; 7Bristol-Myers Squibb, Paris, France; 8Klinikum der
Universität München, Munich, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Hypoglycaemia can be a side effect of glucose-lowering treatment in
patients with type 2 diabetes (T2D) that may counterbalance the beneficial effects of
diabetes control. PANORAMA is a large (n = 5156) pan-European cross-sectional
survey (NCT00916513) of patients assessing patient reported outcomes and glycaemic
control. This subgroup analysis compared rates of severe and non-severe hypoglycaemic events in patients taking different pharmacological treatment regimens.
METHODS: Patients with T2D were randomly or consecutively selected from medical
practices in eight countries. Patients were aged ≥40 years, with T2D diagnosed >1
year and a clinic medical record available >1 year. All patients received dietary/exercise
advice and most were also taking either oral antidiabetic drugs (OADs) and/or injectables (insulin and/or GLP-1 receptor agonists). Patients included in this subgroup
analysis had been taking the same pharmacological treatment regimen for ≥12 months.
Patient-reported frequency of severe (symptomatic episodes requiring external assistance) and non-severe hypoglycaemic episodes in the past year were examined.
RESULTS: In this subgroup analysis 3106 patients were evaluated including: 1346
taking only OADs without secretagogues; 1452 taking only OADs including secretagogues (sulphonylurea/glinides) and 308 on insulin alone. The percentages of patients
experiencing >1 non-severe hypoglycaemic episode in each treatment group were:
8.9% for patients taking OADs without secretagogues; 17.5% for patients taking
OADs including secretagogues and 47.4% for patients using insulin alone. The differences between these three treatment categories (pair-wise comparisons) were highly
significant (P < 0.001). The percentage of patients reporting ≥1 severe hypoglycaemic
episode was greater for OADs including secretagogues versus no secretagogues (3.0%
versus 1.3%; P = 0.011) and for insulin alone versus OADs including secretagogues
(13.7% versus 3.0%; P < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Among patients with T2D on
glucose-lowering medication, rates of non-severe and severe hypoglycaemic episodes
were lowest amongst patients treated with OADs not including secretagogues and
highest among patients treated with insulin alone.
PDB74
TYPE 2 DIABETES PATIENT PERSPECTIVES ON HYPOGLYCEMIA
1
2
3
Gwaltney C , Martin ML , Gruenberger JB
1
Brown University, Providence, RI, USA; 2Health Research Associates, Inc, Seattle, WA, USA;
3
Novartis, Basel, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: Understanding the perspectives of Type 2 Diabetes (T2D) patients on
hypoglycemia is important, in order to understand the burden of the disease and its
treatment, and to develop improved outcome measures. The goal of this project was
to identify key hypoglycemia-related concepts among T2D patients using qualitative
interviews. METHODS: Participants were 19 T2D patients who were prescribed: 1)
an oral anti-diabetic (OAD) and had been diagnosed with T2D in the past 3 years (n
= 11); 2) a sulfonylurea (SU) or thiazolidinedione (TZD) that caused weight gain,
following the failure of an OAD in the last year (n = 5); or 3) an incretin mimetic that
caused weight loss, following the failure of an OAD in the last year (n = 3). One-hour
in-person interviews were conducted using a semi-structured interview guide. Interviews were coded using ATLAS.ti software and code frequency was used to identify
key experiences. RESULTS: Patients were 54.4 years of age on average and 63% were
female. Tremor, sweating, and dizziness were the most commonly noted symptoms of
hypoglycemia; all five of the patients on an SU or TZD reported experiencing tremor.
Patients reported concerns about rare, severe events, such as passing out. Patients
generally did not report that their lives were substantially impacted by hypoglycemia,
but completing compensatory behaviors to prevent hypoglycemia emerged as an
important theme (keeping glucotabs in multiple locations, eating large meals). CONCLUSIONS: Hypoglycemia has a negative impact on patients with T2D. Many report
experiencing hypoglycemia symptoms, and, although T2D patients do not often report
anxiety about hypoglycemia, several reported concerns about the consequences of
severe events. Patients also engage in compensatory behaviors, which suggests that
avoiding hypoglycemia is important. Further refinement of the concepts associated
with the patient’s experience of hypoglycemia may yield new PRO instruments that
can be implemented in clinical trials with T2D patients.
PDB75
THE IMPACT OF PERCEPTIONS OF WEIGHT ON OVERALL HEALTHRELATED WELL-BEING IN EUROPEAN PATIENTS WITH TYPE 2
DIABETES MELLITUS (T2DM)
Traina SB1, Jamieson C2, Neslusan C1, Li R3, Dennis M3, Ho KF4
1
Johnson & Johnson, Raritan, NJ, USA; 2Johnson & Johnson, Fremont, CA, USA; 3Knowledge
Networks, Menlo Park, CA, USA; 4STAT-TU, Inc., Toronto, ON, Canada
OBJECTIVES: Maintaining a healthy weight is important in the management of
T2DM. We investigated the relationship between weight and patient concerns in relation to overall health-related well-being and function among those with T2DM.
A298
METHODS: This cross-sectional study was conducted in the UK, France (FR), and
Germany (DE), with data collected via a representative European online volunteer/
opt-in panel (called “MRops”). A 34-minute survey was fielded to 500 subjects with
T2DM who were currently receiving pharmacotherapy in each country (n = 1500)
from December 2007 to January 2008. Survey items asked about weight, concerns
about weight and health, and health-related well-being and function as assessed by
the SF-12® Health Survey. RESULTS: Based on self-reported height and weight, 85%
(UK), 71% (FR), and 86% (DE) were overweight or obese. Weight was noted as the
most important current health concern by 19% (UK), 19% (FR), and 21% (DE). Not
all respondents (88% (UK), 79% (FR), 82% (DE)) indicated a desire to lose weight.
More subjects with T2DM in DE were “very much” distressed (27%) by their weight
than subjects in UK and FR (both 18%). However, the percentage who were “very
much” worried about their health because of their weight (UK [20%], FR [14%], DE
[21%]) and “very much” embarrassed by their weight (UK [12%] FR [16%] DE
[11%]) was similar across countries. Health-related well-being and function, as
assessed by the SF-12®, was worse across all domains in those with higher body mass
index (BMI) and those with greater weight-related distress, worry, and embarrassment. CONCLUSIONS: Results indicate that elevated BMI and perceptions about
weight affect health-related well-being and function as assessed by the SF-12®. Therapeutic options that help people with T2DM to lose weight may have a positive impact
on patient lives.
PDB76
HEALTH RELATED QUALITY OF LIFE OF TYPE 2 DIABETES MELLITUS
PATIENTS IN THE BRAZILIAN PRIVATE HEALTH CARE SYSTEM: FIRST
RESULTS OF DIAPS79 STUDY
DIAPS79 study group1, Cintra M2, Bahia L2, Franco L3, Nita ME4, Rached R4
1
Diabetes Mellitus Type 2 in the Brazilian Private Health Care System DIAPS79, São Paulo,
SP, Brazil; 2MedInsight, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil; 3FMUSP/Ribeirão Preto, São Paulo, SP, Brazil;
4
Bristol-Myers Squibb S/A, São Paulo, SP, Brazil
BACKGROUND: Health-related quality of life (HRQoL) is a multidimensional
concept that provides insight regarding the impact of a disease from the patient’s
perspective and yield an important health outcome to evaluate treatment interventions
and quality of health care. OBJECTIVES: The goal of this study is to reveal HRQoL
of type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) patients treated in the Brazilian private health care
system. METHODS: A generic instrument to assess health status (EuroQol—EQ-5D),
commonly used in diabetic patients worldwide, was applied in 383 outpatients with
T2DM from five cities (Fortaleza, Porto Alegre, Rio de Janeiro, Ribeirão Preto e São
Paulo). Euroqol uses five dimensions to describe HRQoL states (mobility, self-care,
usual activities, pain/discomfort, anxiety/depression) and a visual analogue scale (VAS)
recorded by the patient and was measured during only one time during the visit to
the physician. RESULTS: The group was composed of 201 women and 182 men, aged
60.5 ± 9.6 years, mean BMI 29.1 kg/m2 and mean duration of diabetes of 12.2 ± 8.75
years. For the entire group, mean EQ VAS score was 75.15 ± 16.72, 24.5% reported
some problems with mobility, 4.2% with self-care, 17.5% problems in their usual
activities, 44.9% any pain/discomfort and 45.2% anxiety/depression. Mean EQ VAS
score decreased as diabetes duration increased (78.19 < 9 years vs. 73.26 > 19 years
of disease; P = 0.05). The patients without micro and macrovascular complications
(41.5%) had a higher VAS compared to those with these complications (18%) (VAS
77.5 vs. 70.19; P = 0.002). Retinopathy (VAS = 68.13) and heart failure (VAS = 67.05)
were conditions associated with lower EQ VAS scores. Regarding the type of treatment, VAS was lower in insulin-treated patients compared to oral agents users (VAS
= 76.59 vs. 71.54; P = 0,00004). CONCLUSIONS: A longer duration of diabetes, the
presence of chronic complications and the use of insulin showed a negative impact on
T2DM patient’s HRQoL.
PDB77
QUALITY OF TREATMENT OF DIABETES MELLITUS TYPE 2 IN THE
CZECH REPUBLIC
Dolezal T1, Kvapil M2, Petrikova A3
1
Institute for Health Economics and Technology Assessment, Prague, Czech Republic;
2
Czech Diabetes Society, Praha, Czech Republic; 3VFU Brno, Brno, Czech Republic
OBJECTIVES: Aim of this study was to evaluate the quality of medical treatment of
diabetes patients and its trends in the Czech Republic and to compare the findings
with the international research. Based on IDF prevalence of diabetes was 9,7% in
2007 and is expected to rise to 11,7% in 2025. METHODS: Data were extracted
from Czech cross-sectional studies from 2002 and 2007 and from European-based
studies. Follow-up of short term parameters of quality of health care (HbA1c, BMI,
blood pressure, lipids, treatment algorithms) which help to predict long-term incidence
of complications. Frequency of microvascular and macrovascular complications was
also assessed and the data were compared to statistics of the Czech Institute for Health
Information and Statistics. RESULTS: Concerning short-term parameters there is wide
variation accross European countries. We have not found significant differences
between CR and selected European countries although there is insufficient evidence
in revealing end-point values, e.g. HbA1c (7,7% in CR vs. 7,8% in Great Britain),
BMI (29,9 in CR vs. 28,7 CODE-2 study) and reaching of target HbA1c values
(36–42% in CR vs. 36% in CODE-2). 74% of Czech patients compared with 50%
European patients are treated with metformin. Percentage of patients using antihypertention drugs (83%) and hypolipidemics (63%) is similar in CR and the European
average. The diabetic patients are reaching the tagret therapeutic values only in minority of cases (31% in systolic blood pressure, 27% in total cholesterol and in 36% of
HbA1c). There is high prevalence of diabetic macrovascular and microvascular com-
13th Euro Abstracts
plications (CHD = 49%, stroke = 9,3%, nephropathy = 28,3%, retinopathy = 25%,
diabetic foot = 4,6%). CONCLUSIONS: This comparative analysis is the first example
of systematic evaluation of the quality of health care concerning diabetes patients in
CR. The future objective is to set proper quality indicators and follow them on continuous basis.
DIABETES/ENDOCRINE DISORDERS – Health Care Use & Policy Studies
PDB78
WILLINGNESS-TO-PAY FOR DIABETES DRUG THERAPY BASED ON
META-ANALYSIS RESULTS
Jendle J1, Torffvit O2, Ridderstråle M3, Ericsson Å4, Nilsen B4, Bøgelund M5
1
Faculty of Health Sciences, Örebro, Sweden; 2Department of Nephrology, Inst Clinical
Sciences, Malmö, Sweden, Sweden; 3Department of Clinical Sciences, Malmö, Sweden,
Sweden; 4Novo Nordisk Scandinavia AB, Malmö, Sweden; 5Incentive Partners, Birkerød,
Denmark
OBJECTIVES: This study aimed to investigate in people with type 2 diabetes (T2D)
the relative willingness-to-pay (WTP) for different diabetes drug therapies based on
outcomes of clinical trials with liraglutide. METHODS: WTP for diabetes drug
therapy of people with T2D was assessed by combining results from a meta-analysis
of liraglutide compared with other diabetes drug therapies in the liraglutide clinical
development program (LEAD) and a survey on WTP for important aspects of diabetes
medication in people with T2D. a meta-analysis of six randomised trials with 3967
subjects in the LEAD program compared efficacy and safety of liraglutide, a once-daily
human glucagon-like peptide-1 (GLP-1) analogue, vs. rosiglitazone, glimepiride,
insulin glargine, and exenatide. The WTP survey had 461 participants with T2D from
Sweden and used a discrete choice experiment methodology to evaluate convenience
and clinical effects of treatments in T2D. Results were converted from SEK to c (10.14
SEK/c). RESULTS: Combining meta-analysis and WTP results revealed that people
with T2D preferred liraglutide to all comparators. They were willing to pay an extra
c2.49/day for liraglutide 1.2 mg compared with rosiglitazone, c1.82/day compared to
glimepiride, c3.17/day compared to insulin glargine, and c0.74/day compared to
exenatide. For the comparisons with rosiglitazone, glimepiride and insulin glargine,
the largest component was based on the additional weight improvements with liraglutide. Compared to exenatide, the largest component of preference was administration of the drug. CONCLUSIONS: WTP for liraglutide by people with T2D was
noticeably higher compared to other standard therapies based on the clinical results
from the meta-analysis. Primary drivers were weight decrease (compared to rosiglitazone, glimepiride and insulin glargine) and administration (compared to exenatide).
In total, people were willing to pay up to c3.17/day more to use liraglutide 1.2 mg
rather than use other glucose lowering treatments.
PDB79
DURATION OF FIRST INSULIN THERAPY IN PREVIOUSLY
UNCONTROLLED TYPE 2 DIABETES: COMPARISON OF INSULINS
GLARGINE, DETEMIR AND NPH AND ASSOCIATION WITH GLYCEMIC
CONTROL
Hall GC1, McMahon AD2, Dain MP3, Home PD4
1
Grimsdyke House, London, UK; 2Glasgow University Dental School, Glasgow, UK;
3
Sanofi-Aventis, Paris, France; 4University of Newcastle upon Tyne, Newcastle upon Tyne,
UK
OBJECTIVES: The duration of treatment with NPH, as a first insulin medication in
type 2 diabetes is reported to be shorter than that of insulin glargine, with comparisons
of glargine and insulin detemir inconsistent. We investigated whether differences
remained after adjustment for potential confounders, including baseline HbA1c, and
which factors are associated with longer duration of use of first insulin. METHODS:
People on two or three oral glucose-lowering agents (OGLA) with poor glycaemic
control who started long-term insulin treatment (2000–2007) were grouped by insulin
type, NPH, glargine or detemir, and followed until a prescription for a different insulin
or a GLP-1 mimetic. Time to treatment change was compared between groups in a
Cox model adjusting for baseline characteristics: HbA1c, age, sex, year, time from
diagnosis, concomitant OGLA, glomerular filtration rate, cardio- and micro-vascular
medical history and cardiovascular risk factors. The association of this duration with
baseline characteristics and mean treatment HbA1c was investigated by univariate
analyses. All data came from THIN database of electronic UK primary care records.
RESULTS: The analysis included 1044 people started on glargine therapy; 187 on
detemir and 453 on NPH. Compared to glargine the adjusted hazard ratios for time
to treatment change were 1.78 (95%CI 1.43, 2.20) for detemir and 1.52 (1.29, 1.80)
for NPH. Lower mean HbA1c with any insulin type was associated with longer time
to change of regimen (Spearman rank correlation coefficient −0.30, P < 0.001). No
concomitant OGLA use, increasing age and time from diagnosis, decreasing BMI and
baseline HbA1c and heart failure were also associated with longer first insulin duration.
CONCLUSIONS: People who commenced insulin treatment with glargine remained
on their initial insulin for longer than those who initiated detemir or NPH after adjustment for potential confounders. Better glycaemic control resulted in a longer time to
change of insulin.
13th Euro Abstracts
PDB80
A CONTROLLED, PROSPECTIVE LONGITUDINAL, INTERVENTIONAL,
NATURALISTIC STUDY TO EVALUATE THE UNIQUE HEALTH CARE
PROGRAM “CONVERSATION MAP©” FOR TURKISH PATIENTS WITH
TYPE-2 DIABETES IN ONE GERMAN MAJOR CITY
Korolewa V, Kretschmer B, Clouth J
Lilly Deutschland GmbH, Bad Homburg, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Considering a cultural and epidemiological disparity between Turkish
and German type-2 diabetes patients in Germany, resulting in a health care gap, a
customised diabetes program for Turkish migrants is required. The objective was to
evaluate “Conversation Map©”, a unique health care education program for Turkish
migrants with type-2 diabetes in Germany. METHODS: Ninety-two Turkish patients
with poor German language skills were divided into interventional (IV, n = 44) and
control (C, n = 48) groups, 42 German (G) patients served as additional control group.
The IV group attended a structured once weekly, 2 hr “Conversation Map©” training
over 4 weeks in Turkish language. The two control groups had no intervention.
Sociodemographic data were recorded at baseline, and standardized questionnaires
assessing treatment, diabetes-knowledge (0–6; 6 = everything right), and therapy
adherence (“Essential Training Content (ETC)” 0–10; 10 = best) were applied at
baseline and after 4 weeks after training in the IV group. Baseline differences between
the groups and changes of data after 4 weeks compared to baseline were tested (paired
t-test, α = 0.05, two-sided). RESULTS: Ethnic groups were comparable on demographic data, whereas Turkish patients had lower education level (P < 0.001). 55%
of all Turkish patients (IV and C) were insulin-dependent and 63% were previously
not attending any diabetes-training. Baseline diabetes knowledge of Turkish patients
was significantly lower than in the German control group (IV 2.38, T 2.77, G: 4.10,
P < 0.001), as well as the ETC score (IV 6.37, C 5.92, G 7.98, P < 0.001). After
“Conversation Map©” training the Turkish group achieved significantly higher mean
knowledge- and ETC-score values compared to baseline (difference +70%, ETC:
+25%, P < 0.001) and were comparable to the German group. CONCLUSIONS: The
study demonstrated that the cultural sensitive training “Conversation Map©”, led to
a significant increase of disease-knowledge and therapy adherence, helping to improve
the health care situation of Turkish patients, with cost savings potential in the long
term.
PDB81
TIME TO ADD-ON MEDICATION USE FOR PATIENTS WITH TYPE 2
DIABETES MELLITUS (T2DM) WHO FAILED METFORMIN
MONOTHERAPY
Qiu Y1, Fu AZ2, Radican L1
1
Merck & Co., Inc., Whitehouse Station, NJ, USA; 2Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, OH, USA
OBJECTIVES: Add-on medications are recommended if target glycemic goals for
patients with T2DM are not achieved or sustained after initial metformin monotherapy. This study examined the time to add-on medication use after metformin
monotherapy failure in clinical practice. METHODS: Selected from a large US EMR
database between Janujary 1, 1997 and December 31, 2008, included patients had to
be aged ≥18 years with a diagnosis of T2DM who had HbA1c ≥ 7.0% or ≥ two fasting
blood glucose levels of 126 mg/dL or greater. Treatment failure was defined as HbA1c
≥ 7% (index date) after metformin monotherapy for at least 6 months. Baseline data
were extracted during 1 year prior to the index date. Time to add-on medication use
was time between index date to the first add-on medication use during follow-up and
was evaluated for the overall cohort and for three index HbA1c subgroups: <8%,
8–9%, and >9%. a Cox proportional hazard model was employed to determine
baseline clinical and demographic characteristics associated with shorter time to
add-on medication use. RESULTS: There were 12,566 patients meeting the inclusion
criteria; 8656, 2175 and 1735 had index HbA1c < 8%, 8–9% and >9%, respectively.
The overall mean (SD) age was 63 (12) years and 51% were female. The median time
to add-on medication use was 15.7 months overall and 17.0, 13.9 and 11.3 months
for patients with index HbA1c < 8%, 8–9% and >9%, respectively. Higher index A1c,
greater body mass index, higher Charlson comorbidity index, younger age, males,
lower LDL were significantly associated with shorter time to add-on medication use
(all P < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: This indicates, in US clinical practice, it takes over
a year for a diabetic patient who has suboptimal glycemic level after initial metformin
monotherapy to receive add-on medications. There is room through disease management so that patients who have failed metformin monotherapy, if eligible and appropriate, receive add on therapy sooner rather than later.
PDB82
PRESCRIBED DAILY DOSES OF ONCE-DAILY LIRAGLUTIDE IN THE
GERMAN STATUTORY HEALTH INSURANCE (SHI)
Schöffski O1, Mentrup S2, Lund N3
1
Friedrich-Alexander-Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg, Nuremberg, Germany; 2Novo Nordisk
Pharma GmbH, Mainz, Germany; 3Novo Nordisk A/S, Soeborg, Denmark
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the prescribed daily dose of liraglutide for patients in
German statutory health insurances. The novel once-daily incretin analogue, liraglutide, mimics the effect of endogenous glucagon-like peptide 1 (GLP-1). Liraglutide was
launched in Germany in July 2009 in a device allowing 3 different dosages (0.6 mg
for initial titration; and the two maintenance doses 1.2 and 1.8 mg). The defined daily
dose (DDD) was set by WHO at 1.2 mg. The prescribed daily dose (PDD) has not
been evaluated so far. METHODS: Sampled data from German statutory health
insurances (SHI) was provided by Insight Health (patient tracking data) for the period
from July 2009 to March 2010 (9 months) covering about 11% of all patients in
A299
German SHI. All patients with prescriptions of liraglutide were identified (n = 4,284).
Patients with only one prescription and less than 4 weeks between first and last date
of prescription were excluded to avoid overrepresented influence of low dosed therapy
starters (remaining patients: n = 2,118). Total number of prescribed pens was determined from first to second last prescription and total consumption in mg was calculated. Number of days between first and last prescription was determined and mean
average consumption in mg per day was calculated. RESULTS: The mean PDD of
liraglutide in 2118 patients was 1.28 mg. Sensitivity analyses including only patients
with longer periods of use showed decreasing average consumption; patients with at
least 10 weeks duration of treatment showed a mean daily dose of 1.25 mg. Stocking
effects (prescription before package is empty) could have driven the increase in average
use in the starting period and at the end of the calendar year. CONCLUSIONS: The
longer patients use liraglutide the lower the observed PDDs. The DDD of 1.2 mg is a
valid estimate for real life usage of liraglutide.
PDB83
TIME TO TREATMENT MODIFICATION AMONG PATIENTS WITH TYPE
2 DIABETES WHO INITIATED EXENATIDE OR INSULIN GLARGINE
Pawaskar M1, Bonafede M2, Johnson BH3, Fowler R3, Hoogwerf B4
1
Eli Lilly & Company, Indianapolis, IN, USA; 2Thomson Reuters, Cambridge, MA, USA;
3
Thomson Reuters, Washington, DC, USA; 4Lilly USA, LLC, Indianapolis, IN, USA
OBJECTIVES: To examine time to treatment modification for patients with type 2
diabetes (T2D) initiating treatment with exenatide BID or insulin glargine. METHODS:
A retrospective analysis was conducted using the Thomson Reuters Research Databases. Adult patients with T2D who initiated exenatide (N = 9197) or glargine (N =
4499) between October 1, 2006 and September 30, 2007 with 12 months pre- and
18 months post-index continuous enrollment were included. Treatment modification
was defined as the first event of change in the treatment and was classified further into
three types: intensification, switching or discontinuation of the index medication. The
2 cohorts were 1:1 propensity score matched on baseline demographics, clinical
characteristics, and prior health care utilization. Survival analysis was used to examine
time to treatment modification. RESULTS: Propensity score matching resulted in
inclusion of 3774 exenatide and 3774 glargine patients with a mean age of 57 years,
mean Deyo Charlson Comorbidity Index score of 1.6, and with proportionately more
males (54%) than females. All of the patients concomitantly used a non-index antidiabetes medication in post-index period. The 18-month discontinuation rates were
38.3% and 40.0% (P = 0.14) and the treatment intensification rates were 15.9% and
26% (P < 0.0001) for exenatide and glargine, respectively. Alternatively, 14.9% of
exenatide-treated patients switched therapies, compared to 10.0% of glargine-treated
patients (P < 0.0001). Glargine-treated patients were 33% more likely to modify
treatment than exenatide-treated patients (Hazard Ratio (HR): 1.33, P < 0.0001).
Glargine-treated patients were 72% more likely to intensify their treatment (HR =
1.72, P < 0.0001), 25% more likely to discontinue (HR = 1.25, P < 0.0001), and 29%
less likely to switch to new therapy (HR = 0.71, P < 0.0001) compared to exenatide.
CONCLUSIONS: This analysis showed that exenatide-treated patients were less likely
to modify their treatment suggesting potential longer durability with exenatide
therapy. Furthermore, exenatide-treated patients were less likely to discontinue or
intensify but more likely to switch their treatment than glargine-treated patients.
PDB84
MANAGEMENT OF ACROMEGALY IN CLINICAL PRACTICE
CONDITIONS IN SPAIN
Roset M1, Merino-Montero S1, Luque M2, López-Mondéjar P3, Salinas I4, Soto A5,
Bernal C6, Villabona C7, De Luis D8, Donnay S9, Pascual H10, Pérez-Luis J11
1
IMS Health, Barcelona, Spain; 2Hospital Universitario La Princesa Servicio de Endocrinología
y Nutrición, Madrid, Spain; 3Servicio de Medicina Interna-Endocrino. Hospital General
Universitario de Elche, Alicante, Spain; 4Servicio de Endocrinología y Nutrición. Hospital
Germans Trias i Pujol, Barcelona, Spain; 5Servicio de Endocrinología y Nutrición. Hospital
Universitario Virgen del Rocío, Sevilla, Spain; 6Servicio de Endocrinología y Nutrición Hospital
12 de Octubre, Madrid, Spain; 7Servicio de Endocrinología Hospital Universitario de Bellvitge,
Barcelona, Spain; 8Sección de Endocrinología y Nutrición Clínica, Unidad de Apoyo a la
Investigación, Valladolid, Spain; 9Unidad de Endocrinología y Nutrición de la Fundación
Hospital de Alcorcón, Madrid, Spain; 10Sección de Endocrinología y Nutrición Hospital
General Universitario Morales Meseguer, Murcia, Spain; 11Servicio de Endocrinología Hospital
Universitario de Canarias, Tenerife, Spain
OBJECTIVES: The goal of treating acromegaly is directed at removing the tumor,
preventing tumor re-growth and reducing long-term morbidity and mortality. For this
purpose, different health resources are necessary. This study evaluates the disease
resources and costs in Spain. METHODS: An epidemiological, prospective, naturalistic, multicentric study (30 endocrinologists) involving acromegalic patients with
micro (≤10 mm) or macro (>10 mm) adenomas was performed. Patients were categorised as Surgical Group (SG) (surgery in the 6 months before inclusion or during
follow-up period and somatostatin analogue (SA) treatment for <6 months during the
pre-surgery period) and Medical Treatment Group (MTG) (patients receiving SA
treatment for ≥6 months, with/without surgery following SA treatment). Resource data
were collected from standard visits during a 2-years period. RESULTS: The study
included 74 patients (56 SG and 18 MTG). Most patients were women (62%). The
mean (SD) age was 49 (14) years. The annual direct acromegaly cost per patient is
c9668 (c9223 SG vs. c11,054 MTG). The cost of illness was higher in patients with
macroadenoma than in microadenoma (c11,053 vs. c5809), and it is increased in
young patients (<40 years). Surgical procedures in acromegaly (involving hospitalization and complementary tests) constitute the 22% and 8% of the illness cost in SG
A300
and MTG patients. Additionally, hospitalizations in intensive care units (50% SG vs.
22% MTG patients), emergency visits (21% SG vs. 6% MTG) and the presence of
adenoma complications (73% SG vs. 44% MTG) constitute a source of cost increment
in these patients. Patients who accomplish with the most strict study clinical control
criteria (GH < 1.0 and IGF-1 < 100%) showed the lowest direct cost of illness (c6169
vs. c12,990). CONCLUSIONS: The economic cost of acromegaly is dependent on the
clinical control of the disease. Direct cost of illness is the half that the cost in non
controlled patients.
PDB85
APPROVAL AFTER REJECTION—AN INSIGHT IN HTA RE-EVALUATIONS
Sweeney N, Andreykiv M, Wiebinga C
Quintiles Consulting, Hoofddorp, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: To gain insight into the re-evaluation process of HTA agencies after
an initial rejection and identify the adaptations that led to the approval of re-submitted
dossiers. METHODS: Phase I: manual search of 57 health care agencies’ websites for
published diabetes-related assessments (January 2007-May 2010). Phase II: the two
most re-assessed drugs for which detailed information was available were selected for
further evaluation (insulin glargine and exenatide). For these drugs, all reports published prior to 2007 were also included. RESULTS: Phase I identified 117 relevant
single technology appraisals; 18 were re-evaluations. Six agencies performed re-evaluations of the same drug after an initial rejection: CADTH, CVZ, HAS, PBAC,
AHTAPol and SMC. To date, SMC evaluated 32 submissions for 13 anti-diabetic
drugs, PBAC published 20 (eight drugs), CADTH 13 (four drugs), CVZ 14 (four
drugs) and AHTAPol 10 (two drugs). In phase II insulin glargine (four re-submissions
to PBAC and 1 to CADTH) and exenatide (two re-submissions to PBAC, 1 to CVZ
and 1 to AHTAPol) were evaluated. It became clear that payers do focus on overall
cost. The approach that was chosen for those two drugs was to control overall cost
either by restricting access or by settling on a lower price. CVZ accepted exenatide
for reimbursement only after restricting access to a subgroup of obese type 2 diabetes
mellitus patients (with an ICER of c5.231). Instead of patient segmentation PBAC
insisted on lowering the price for both medications (rationale for insulin glargine being
concern that prescribing cannot be contained within the defined population).
AHTAPol limited exenatide reimbursement to 50% to control prescribing rates.
CONCLUSIONS: For the diabetes cases analyzed HTA agencies attempted to control
health care expenditure by either lowering drug costs or by narrowing the definition
of the target population, the latter inevitably allowing fewer patients access to the
drug.
PDB86
HEALTH TECHNOLOGY ASSESSMENT OF DIABETES COMPOUNDS:
THE POLISH PERSPECTIVE
Adalsteinsson JE1, Czech M2, Skrekowska-Baran I3, Jasik BM1
1
Novo Nordisk A/S, Copenhagen, Denmark; 2Department of Pharmacoeconomics, Medical
University of Warsaw, Warsaw, Poland; 3Novo Nordisk Pharma Sp, Warszawa, Poland
OBJECTIVES: The AOTM in Poland was established to give MoH in Poland advice
on reimbursement. The aim of this research is to create an overview of HTA reports
on diabetes compounds in Poland and the results of the decision making. METHODS:
A search was conducted on the webpage of AOTM (http://www.aotm.gov.pl) for HTA
reports on the following products: Rosiglitazon, Pioglitazon, Sitagliptin, Vildagliptin,
Saxagliptin, Exenatide, Liraglutide, Glargine, Detemir, Aspart, Glulisene and Lispro.
RESULTS: Of a total of 163 reports (published between 2007 and 2010), eight reports
in Polish language on diabetes were identified and assessed. Two reports can be viewed
as secondary assessment of regulatory safety discussions. The other six reports assessed
the implementation of new diabetes compounds with assessment of efficacy, safety
and cost-effectiveness of the drugs.Two reports assessed safety concerns associated
with the risk of cancer and concluded based on EMA and FDA research that no
increased risk was associated with these agents. Rosiglitazone and Sitagliptin were not
recommended for reimbursement due to availability of other treatments with similar
efficacy. Saxagliptin, Exenatide and Liraglutide got the recommendation to be reimbursed due to expected increase in QALYs. The final report was assessing Glulisene
which got the recommendation to temporary reimburse (2 years) provided that data
on hard endpoints (not specified in public report) and cost-effectiveness should be
delivered. CONCLUSIONS: Recommendation by AOTM is supported by assessment
of available RCTs, cost per life-year gained, cost per QALY, estimated budget impact
for 5 years and also in some cases reports from EMEA, FDA and other HTA agencies
(SMC, PBAC and CADTH). The AOTM’s recommendation is not obligatory for the
Polish Ministry of Health.
PDB87
STANDARDS FOR THE ASSESSMENT OF ANTIDIABETIC DRUGS—THE
IQWIG PERSPECTIVE
Schweikert B1, John J2, Ringborg A3, Erhardt W4, Bleckmann A5, Neubauer AS4
1
i3 Innovus, Aschheim, Germany; 2Helmholtz Zentrum München, Neuherberg, Germany; 3i3
Innovus, Stockholm, Sweden; 4Bristol-Myers Squibb, München, Germany; 5AstraZeneca,
Wedel, Germany
OBJECTIVES: A substantial number of new pharmaceutical treatment strategies have
been introduced for the treatment of diabetes mellitus type II. The availability of these
drugs for patients in different countries depends on the evaluation standards and
methods applied in the various phases of drug assessment. Objective of this research
was to review the requirements and criteria applied for the assessment of antidiabetic
13th Euro Abstracts
drugs along the regulatory process by EMA (Europe) and FDA (USA) for the assessment of efficacy and safety as well as for reimbursement decisions by NICE (England)
and IQWiG (Germany) and to compare their consistency, with a special focus on
IQWiG’s procedures. METHODS: A review of relevant current method documents
and reports on evaluations of antidiabetic drugs published by IQWiG was conducted.
These were compared with guidance documents issued by FDA, EMA and NICE with
respect to endpoints considered in diabetes and their definition, criteria for the type
of evidence, and potential comparators. RESULTS: Consistently, across all agencies
severe and non-severe hypoglycemias were considered highly relevant. There was,
however, a substantial heterogeneity in the definition of hypoglycaemias. The surrogate parameter HbA1C as primary endpoint was accepted by all agencies investigated
apart from IQWiG. In its assessments, evidence from randomized as well as from
observational studies was accepted by NICE. For safety evaluations preclinical studies
were taken into consideration by EMA and FDA in addition to randomized controlled
trials. IQWiG on the other hand focused exclusively on randomized controlled trials
for the assessment of effectiveness as well as safety. CONCLUSIONS: There is a
substantial variation of criteria applied and evidence considered relevant within the
assessment process of IQWiG compared to other agencies. This might lead to regional
variations in the availability of drugs. It is important to be aware of the different
requirements of agencies, when designing trials and planning market access.
PDB88
LEARNING FROM DISEASE MANAGEMENT PROGRAMMES: HOW
MEDICAL TREATMENTS AND QUALITY OF DIABETIC CARE (TYPE II)
IN GERMANY ARE DIRECTLY AND INDIRECTLY IMPROVED BY DMPS
Frenzel A1, Reuter A2
1
IMS Health GmbH & Co. OHG, Frankfurt, Germany; 2Freie Universität Berlin, Berlin,
Germany
OBJECTIVES: Disease Management Programmes (DMP) aim at improving care
quality by implementing standards for medical practices. In the case of Diabetes Mellitus Type II (DM II), care improvements can be assessed by the duration between the
first diagnosis and the occurrence of the first related complication. The aim of this
longitudinal study is to investigate the direct influence of the DMP-based treatments
on patient outcomes, measured as the postponement of diabetes related complications
in a large population of DM II patients. The study also investigates how DMP inscriptions of some patients of a medical practice indirectly influence patient outcomes of
DM II patients, who are not inscribed in a DMP, but are treated in the same practise.
We argue that this indirect effect is due to physicians’ learning from the DMP-based
treatments in their clinics. METHODS: Using consultation data from IMS Health
from a period of 25 years (1984–2009) a survival analysis is applied. The data set
includes 161,747 DM II patients from >1100 practices. Applying a Kaplan–Meier–
Method we test for direct effects of DMPs on patient outcomes. By pooling patients
by the registration year of the practice-leading physician and by focussing on their
quarterly consultation rate, we test for indirect effects of DMPs on patient outcomes.
RESULTS: The mean survival time (duration between first diagnosis and first complication) of the medical treatment of diabetics in a DMP is 14,82 years, differing significantly from the 15,76 years without a DMP. These tests are controlled for
following patient variables: sex, age, HbA1C, BMI and the insurance status. Learnings
from DMPs, indirectly affecting DM care, significantly postpone complications for
younger physicians and practices with fewer diabetics. CONCLUSIONS: Contributing
to assessments of DMPs, the study discusses policy implications, as it is shown that
care quality is improved by physicians learning from DMPs.
PDB89
PREDICTORS OF ROUTINE MONITORING OF DIABETES CARE AMONG
THE US NON-INSTITUTIONALIZED POPULATION: A RETROSPECTIVE
ANALYSIS OF THE MEDICAL EXPENDITURE PANEL SURVEY (MEPS) IN
2007
Zhao Y, Fonseca V, Campbell C, Shi L
Tulane University, New Orleans, LA, USA
OBJECTIVES: To examine the rate and predictors of diabetes monitoring in the US.
METHODS: This cross-sectional retrospective study was conducted on a representative, non-institutionalized sample of the US population, using the self-reported information from the 2007 Household Component (HC) of the MEPS. According to the
American Diabetes Association (ADA) 2007 practice guidelines, proper provider
monitoring is defined as at least two A1c tests, one eye and one foot examination
annually. Health status was measured by SF-12®Version2. a logistic regression model
was used to examine the predictors of proper monitoring. Differences in health status
and medical expenditures between patients with and without proper monitoring were
examined using t-tests. Estimates were weighted to the total population (WTP).
RESULTS: Among 1,747 (WTP: 19,320,394) patients with diabetes, 80.64% had at
least two A1c tests; 63.29% had an eye examination; and 67.51% had a foot examination. Thus, 63.36% patients (WTP: 14,065,289) received proper diabetes monitoring.
Older patients (OR:1.021, 95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.012–1.030), non-Hispanic
Caucasians compared with African American patients (OR: 1.236, 95% CI: 0.933–
1.636), patients with a higher education level (OR:1.211, 95% CI: 1.056–1.390),
insurance coverage (OR:2.216, 95% CI: 1.408–3.486), use of oral anti-diabetic drugs
(OR:2.935, 95% CI: 2.131–4.042) and insulin (OR:3.453, 95% CI: 2.477–4.814)
were more likely to undergo the proper monitoring. Well monitored patients had a
higher Mental Component Summary score (50.09 ± 0.37 vs. 48.51 ± 0.45, P < 0.05),
but a lower Physical Component Summary score (39.95 ± 0.34 vs. 42.28 ± 0.47, P <
13th Euro Abstracts
0.05) on the SF 12. Properly monitored patients spent significantly more on total
health care services (+$5243), outpatient visits (+$1023), and medications (+$1204),
respectively (all P-values<0.05). CONCLUSIONS: In the US, nearly 40% patients with
diabetes do not receive the proper diabetes monitoring controlling for racial and
socioeconomic disparities. Anti-diabetics/insulin use, mental/cognitive status, physical
health status, and health care expenditure may also interact with performing monitoring. Barriers and cost-benefit for long-term monitoring should be studied.
PDB90
IMPROVING PATIENT CARE: RESULTS FROM THE TEXAS NEWBORN
SCREENING PERFORMANCE MEASURES PROJECT
Tiwana SK1, Tanksley S2, Williams D2, Douglas M2
1
Health Partners, Bloomington, MN, USA; 2Texas Department of State Health Services,
Austin, TX, USA
BACKGROUND: Advances in screening technology have led to rapid expansion of
newborn screening as a public health initiative in the United States. Due to variation
across states in program implementation, there is a lack of standardization and
accountability, which can affect quality of care. Texas currently screens for 28 disorders. OBJECTIVES: The Texas Newborn Screening Performance Measures Project
was initiated with the objective of developing evidence-based performance measures
to improve quality, accountability and uniformity in the care. METHODS: A three
step approach was used for identification and development of key measures for seven most
critical disorders: systematic reviews; impact assessment; and feasibility assessment. Impact
assessments (likert scale) were based on National Quality Measures Clearinghouse™
(NQMC) criteria: scientific soundness, relevance, health importance, impact on quality of
care, and ability to address disparities in care. A likert scale was also used for feasibility
assessment on key aspects: data availability, ease of collection, infrastructure and human
resource needs, overall cost, and time constraints. RESULTS: A total of 50 performance
measures were supported by scientific evidence. Impact and feasibility assessments led
to the approval of 33/50 measures. “Time to initiate treatment” received the highest
scores on potential impact on patient outcomes (mean impact score 86.67/100, SD
1.5). Other measures with potentially high impact (score >80/100) were: compliance
with oral prophylactic medication and age at first Prevnar® vaccination in sickle cell
disease; screening of at-risk family members in fatty acid disorders; frequency of
growth assessments in congenital adrenal hyperplasia and phenylalanine levels in
phenylketonuria. “Time to treatment” for individual disorders was also ranked very
high on feasibility (mean feasibility score 88.67/100, SD 3.88). CONCLUSIONS: This
is one of the first efforts to identify and develop evidence-based performance measures
in newborn screening and can pave the way for system wide changes and development
of national guidelines.
PDB91
TREATMENT PATTERNS AND ACHIEVEMENT OF THERAPEUTIC
GOALS IN A COHORT OF TYPE 2 DIABETES MELLITUS PATIENTS
TREATED IN THE BRAZILIAN PRIVATE HEALTH CARE SYSTEM (PHCS):
INITIAL REPORTS OF DIAPS 79 STUDY
DIAPS79 study group1, Eliaschewitz FG2, Bahia L3, Cintra M3, Franco L4, Nita ME5, Rached R5
1
Diabetes Mellitus Type 2 in the Brazilian Private Health Care System DIAPS79, São Paulo,
SP, Brazil; 2CPCLIN—Centro de Pesquisas Clínicas, São Paulo, SP, Brazil; 3MedInsight, Rio de
Janeiro, RJ, Brazil; 4FMUSP, Ribeirão Preto, SP, Brazil; 5Bristol-Myers Squibb S/A, São Paulo,
SP, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: Investigate the type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) treatment practice and
achievement of therapeutic goals in a cohort of T2DM patients treated in the Brazilian
PHCS. METHODS: This is a cross-sectional analysis of 383 T2DM outpatients
treated in 5 cities covered by the PHCS. Data was collected using information from
the previous year by interviewing patients using a validated questionnaire complemented by medical chart review. Therapeutic goals suggested by the Brazilian Diabetes
Society were used as standard treatment. RESULTS: Mean age was 60.5 ± 9.6 years,
mean BMI 29.1 ± 5.3 Kg/m2 and mean duration of diabetes of 12.2 ± 8.75 years. The
frequency of associated arterial hypertension was 66.8% (n = 256); obesity 39% n =
144); dyslipidemia 69.6% (n = 267) and heart failure 5.5% (n = 21). Microvascular
complications were present in 32.4% (n = 124); 8.1% (n = 31) had macrovascular
complications; 18% (n = 69) had at least one micro and one macrovascular complication and 41.5% (n = 159) had no complications. Current treatment practice was: 3.6%
(n = 14) diet only; 30% (n = 115) monotherapy with oral anti-diabetic (OAD); 37.8%
(n = 145) combined therapy with more than one OAD agents; 23.2% (n = 89) combined therapy with insulin and 5.2% (n = 20) just insulin. The most prescribed drug
was metformin (41.4%), followed by insulin (19.1%), sulphonylureas (18.6%), DPP4
inhibitors (8.7%), TZDs (5.5%), and others (6.7%). Medications for dyslipidemia
was used by 47.5% (n = 178); cardiovascular drugs in 77.4% (n = 287) and antiobesity drugs in 4% (n = 15). Treatment targets were achieved in: 76.8% for systolic
and diastolic blood pressure (<130 × 85 mmHg), 19.5% for BMI < 25 kg/m2, 28%
for HDL cholesterol >55 women, 37.3% for HDL cholesterol >45 men and 28.2%
reached the goal for HbA1c (within normal range). Only 6.8% of the group (n = 26)
reached all the treatment targets. CONCLUSIONS: The national goals for glycemic
control, blood pressure and lipid levels are rarely achieved in real-world clinical
practice, even with the high use of medications.
A301
DIABETES/ENDOCRINE DISORDERS – Conceptual Papers & Research on
Methods
PDB92
CLINICAL AND ECONOMIC CONSEQUENCES OF THE
PHARMACOLOGICAL HYPOGLYCEMIC TREATMENT OF TYPE 2
DIABETES IN CROATIA
Saric T1, Benkovic V2, Poljicanin T3, Sekerija M3
1
Promeritus savjetovanje d.o.o, Zagreb, Croatia; 2Croatian Society for Pharmacoeconomics,
Zagreb, Croatia; 3Vuk Vrhovac University Clinic, Zagreb, Croatia
OBJECTIVES: Diabetes mellitus type 2 (T2DM) is a chronically progressive disease
and the treatment must be selected according to the pathophysiological phase of the
disease at the time the treatment is begun. The Croatian public diabetology sector
takes care of approximately 150,000 adults treated with oral hypoglycemic agents
(OHA) alone or in combination with insulin. Our objective was assessment of the
clinical and economic consequences of OHA treatment in T2DM from a Croatian
health care system perspective. METHODS: The target population defined for the
study was diabetic patients treated with OHA alone. Medication consumption was
quantified by using Pharmis and CroDiab data. a clinical expert panel provided
resource-use information not available in published literature or health care databases.
RESULTS: Current consumption data is showing that 62.8% patients are using OHA
as monotherapy. Within this group, majority is using either biguanides or sulphonylureas. Patients treated with sulphonylureas are represented with almost the same
percentage as those treated with biguanides (25% vs. 29%). Combination of two
OHA is used in 34.2% while 3% of patients are treated by triple therapy. The most
often choice in dual therapy is combination of biguanides and sulphonylureas while
biguanides, sulphonylureas and thiazolidinediones in combination as the most favourable treatment option in triple therapy. Biguanides are used as a one of OHA in 61%
of patients. CONCLUSIONS: Considering current clinical guidelines, lifetime benefits
of biguanides and facts that they are low-cost agent, relatively small proportion of
T2DM patients are treated with this agent in Croatia. Findings of this investigation
revealed real life pattern of T2DM treatment, which enables directing in better treating
and more cost-effective management in Croatia.
PDB93
THE RELIABILITY OF PROPORTION OF DAYS COVERED
CALCULATIONS USING DEFINED DAILY DOSE ESTIMATES
Levin R, Papademetriou E, Aubert RE
Medco Health Solutions, Franklin Lakes, NJ, USA
OBJECTIVES: Using a large, US administrative pharmacy claims database, calculate
proportion of days covered (PDC) using actual days supply, and compare estimated
PDC (ePDC) using days supply derived from drug-specific Defined Daily Dose (DDD)
criteria. METHODS: Continuously eligible patients filling non-insulin anti-diabetic
medication were targeted from a large sample of pharmacy claims during 2008 and
2009. Medications were grouped into ATC diabetes drug classes. Proportion of days
covered (PDC) was calculated as the number of days a patient had medication in their
possession divided by the number of days in the period. PDC was first calculated using
actual days supply, then ePDC was calculated using an estimated days supply from
DDD, strength, and pill quantity. The percent of patients adherent to therapy was
defined by a PDC > 0.80. The reliability of each method was assessed by Pearson
correlation coefficients and agreement above chance was assessed using Kappa statistics. RESULTS: Adherence was calculated for 163,750 patients taking non-insulin
anti-diabetics. Overall, the PDC was 0.69 and ePDC 0.57. The two measures were
also highly and significantly correlated (r = 0.73; P < 0.0001). The percent adherent
was 48.8% (PDC) and 34.4% (ePDC), (Kappa = 0.50; P < 0.0001). At the medication
class level, differences in PDC and ePDC ranged from 0.01 to 0.35, with correlation
coefficients ranging from 0.40 to 0.93. Differences in the percent adherent metric
ranged from −2.3 to 23.2, and kappa values from 0.22 to 0.89. CONCLUSIONS:
Applying DDD estimates for the purposes of diabetes adherence estimation when
lacking days supply values may provide reasonable estimates of adherence based on
results presented here. At the medication class level there is greater variability in the
reliability measures. Including claims from the U.S. only is a limitation of this analysis,
as local treatment patterns may vary, and DDD values were not available for all U.S.
medications.
PDB94
MARKOV AND MONTE-CARLO MODELS IN THE PROGRESSION OF
DIABETES MELLITUS: A LITTERATURE REVIEW TO IDENTIIFY THE
FACTORS INFLUENCING THE CHOICE OF THE TYPE OF MODEL
Renard L1, Borget I2
1
CRP-Santé, Strassen, Luxembourg; 2Institut Gustave Roussy, Villejuif, France
OBJECTIVES: Markov and Monte-Carlo (MC) models are often used to simulate
Diabetes Mellitus (DM) and its complications over time, but reasons to choose the
model type are poorly documented. a systematic literature review was performed to
identify factors influencing the choice of the model type. METHODS: Models simulating the progression of DM and its complications were selected from Medline and
Embase databases. Literature reviews, methodological articles and non original models
were excluded. Each full-paper selected went through a 31-item checklist via a doublereading process. a qualitative analysis was performed to evaluate the accuracy of the
model with the study question. RESULTS: Sixty-one models were selected, including
A302
42 Markov and 19 MC. Median time since publication was 6 years. Most models
concerned Type 2 DM (57%) and prevention or disease-management programs
(54%). In average, models had 11 states and 2.8 complications. MC were significantly
more used than Markov when both type 1 and 2 DM and a prevention or disease
management program were concerned. Models had, significantly, a higher number of
states and complications. The choice of the model type was shown to be influenced
by the number of DM and of complications considered. The justification to perform
a Monte-Carlo was more often documented than those to perform a Markov (74%
vs. 38%). The model was considered accurate with the study question in respectively
86% of Monte-Carlo and 64% of Markov. CONCLUSIONS: This study allowed to
statistically identify factors influencing the type of model used to simulate DM. It is
an interesting tool for modelers in their decision process to build a model. Information
such as data and time availability or financial context could not be collected.
PDB95
SIMPLIFICATION OF PATIENT LEVEL SIMULATIONS TO COHORT
MODEL FOR SCENARIO ANALYSIS
de Nigris E, Graham Roberts GR
Double Helix Consulting Group, London, UK
OBJECTIVES: In the last 15 years, models built to appraise health technologies have
grown in complexity to accurately reflect the natural history of disease and calculate
costs and benefits accordingly. The advantage of using patient level simulation models
(PSM) over cohort models (CM) is that CM may become unwieldy with thousands
of branches. This usually happens if the patient characteristics influence the risks of
complications and these vary over time, or if there are many comorbidities to take
into account and the risk of each complication is time dependent. In this case, a typical
Markov cohort may be unsuitable. However a PSM can take a long time to run in
order to produce results. Aim of this research is to present a case study where a PSM
is simplified with a Markov structure and to compare the results of the two models.
METHODS: We describe how a PSM for diabetes may be adapted to a CM, stating
all the limitations. RESULTS: Provided that the PSM gives similar answers to the CM,
the CM may be used as a surrogate for conducting complex sensitivity analysis (e.g.,
3-way analysis or tornado diagrams). The advantage is that this model would produce
results “instantaneously.” CONCLUSIONS: The adaptation of a PSM model to a
cohort model may be a desirable feature if the model is required by a non technical
audience. This is the case for “due diligence” models that are increasingly required by
investors to assess the value of assets that a pharmaceutical company considers to buy
or sell. Further research is needed to have a powerful test to assess whether the difference in results between a simplified CM model and the PSM are statistically
significant.
MUSCULAR-SKELETAL DISORDERS – Clinical Outcomes Studies
PMS1
HIGHER COMORBIDITIES IN PATIENTS WITH GOUT VS. WITHOUT
GOUT IN THE US GENERAL POPULATION: THE NATIONAL HEALTH
AND NUTRITION EXAMINATION SURVEY (NHANES) 2007–2008
Pandya BJ1, Zhu Y2, Choi H2
1
Takeda Pharmaceuticals International, Inc., Deerfield, IL, USA; 2Boston University of School
of Medicine, Boston, MA, USA
OBJECTIVES: While the comorbidity burden of gout in the US has been considered
substantial and may have been rising over the past decade, no contemporary national
data are available. We estimated the prevalence of major comorbidities in patients
with gout compared with those without gout based on a recent, nationally representative sample of US men and women (National Health and Nutrition Examination
Survey [NHANES] 2007–2008). METHODS: Using data from 5707 participants in
NHANES 2007–2008 (2797 men and 2910 women) aged 20 years and older, we
determined the prevalence of major comorbidities among individuals with gout,
including hypertension, renal impairment, nephrolithiasis, diabetes, myocardial infarction, heart failure, stroke, and obesity. We also compared the prevalence with those
without gout using age- and sex-adjusted logistic regressions. Case definitions of
comorbidities were based on an affirmative answer to a question asking if a physician
or a health professional had diagnosed the corresponding condition. RESULTS:
Among US adults with gout, 74% had hypertension, 53% obesity, 26% diabetes, 24%
nephrolithiasis, 14% myocardial infarction, 11% heart failure, 10% stroke, and 9%
renal impairment (Table). Prevalence of these comorbidities among individuals with
gout was substantially higher than among individuals without gout. Age- and sexadjusted odds ratios (95% confidence interval [CI]) were 4.19 (2.75–6.39) for hypertension, 2.35 (1–55–3.57) for obesity, 2.36 (1.49–3.73) for diabetes, 2.10 (1.39–3.18)
for nephrolithiasis, 2.37 (1.54–3.65) for myocardial infarction, 2.68 (1.88–3.83) for
heart failure, 2.02 (0.98 to 4.19) for stroke, and 3.50 (2.05–5.98) for renal impairment. CONCLUSIONS: These findings from the latest nationally representative
sample of US adults in NHANES 2007–2008 confirm that the prevalence of comorbidities among individuals with gout is substantial and considerably higher than
among individuals without gout.
13th Euro Abstracts
PMS2
DISABILITY OUTCOMES AND DOSE ESCALATION IN RHEUMATOID
ARTHRITIS PATIENTS TREATED WITH TUMOR NECROSIS FACTOR
BLOCKERS: A COMPARATIVE EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS
Schabert VF1, Bruce B2, Ferrufino CP1, Fries JF2, Globe D3, Harrison DJ3
1
IMS Health, Falls Church, VA, USA; 2Stanford University, Division of Immunology &
Rheumatology, Palo Alto, CA, USA; 3Amgen Inc., Thousand Oaks, CA, USA
OBJECTIVES: Previous cohort studies using US commercial insurance claims of
rheumatoid arthritis (RA) patients have observed higher dose escalation rates for
patients treated with tumor necrosis factor-α (TNF) blockers infliximab (INF) or
adalimumab (ADA) than for etanercept (ETN). However, such databases cannot be
used to determine whether dose escalation is associated with improved clinical outcomes. We compared functional disability and dosing history between patients treated
with TNF blockers using data from a large, prospective observational registry (Arthritis, Rheumatism, and Aging Medical Information System; ARAMIS) of RA patients
in the US. METHODS: ARAMIS enrolled adult physician-diagnosed RA patients.
Patients who met following inclusion criteria were selected: treated with a TNF
blocker for ≥9 months; had no biologics 6 months before index TNF treatment; and
reported a Health Assessment Questionnaire Disability Index (HAQ-DI) at index and
9–15 months after index. Self-reported dosing information was validated by telephone
follow-up, medical, billing, or retail pharmacy prescription records. Dose escalation
was defined as dosing above first ADA/ETN or third INF dose. Multivariate models
compared HAQ-DI change and dose escalation rates, controlling for variables that
differed among INF, ADA and ETN patients at index. RESULTS: Approximately 351
patients (93 INF, 40 ADA, 218 ETN) met study criteria. Subjects were mostly female
(83%), Caucasian (88%), and had mean disease duration of 18.9 years. HAQ-DI
change scores at 9–15 months did not differ by treatment (−0.10, −0.08, and −0.12
points for INF, ADA, and ETN, respectively; P = 0.52). Dose increases were observed
in 1.4% of ETN patients, as compared with 10.8% of INF (P < 0.001) and 12.5%
of ADA patients (P = 0.004, both vs. ETN). HAQ-DI change was associated with
pre-index HAQ-DI score and disease duration (both P < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: This
study showed dose escalation in fewer ETN than INF or ADA patients, but similar
improvements in functional disability.
PMS3
IMPROVEMENT IN EFFICACY AND SAFETY OUTCOMES AFTER
CERVICAL ARTHROPLASTY VERSUS STANDARD ANTERIOR CERVICAL
DISECTOMY AND FUSION (ACDF) SURGERIES: A META-ANALYSIS OF
PUBLISHED RCTS
Gill S1, Maetzel A2, Alvares L3, Birinyi-Strachan L3
1
Frenchay Hospital, Bristol, UK; 2Stratas Partners, Basel, ON, Switzerland; 3Medtronic
International Trading Sàrl, Tolochenaz, VD, Switzerland
BACKGROUND: Cervical arthroplasty has been used successfully worldwide for over
a decade in patients with cervical degenerative disc disease (CDDD). Several RCTs have
documented the clinical advantage of arthroplasty vs. fusion for this patient population.
Synthesis of outcomes from published RCTs is needed to consolidate the evidence-base
for arthroplasty in CDDD. OBJECTIVES: To examine current evidence of safety and
efficacy in the use of arthroplasty to treat CDDD and conduct a pooled analysis of high
level comparative outcomes for arthroplasty versus fusion. METHODS: A systematic
search of the PubMed, EMBASE, MEDLINE, CRD York, and Cochrane Library databases, plus hand searching of grey literature was undertaken in January 2010. RESULTS:
A total of 554 non-duplicate citations were retrieved. Only three studies of arthroplasty
versus fusion with 2 years follow-up met all inclusion criteria and were of reasonable
quality (according to GRADE criteria) to pool. a meta-analysis was conducted using
RevMan5 software (Cochrane 2008). Persons undergoing single-level arthroplasty had
significantly improved neurological success (RR 1.14, 95% CI [1.07, 1.21] P < 0.0001),
Neck Disability Index (NDI) success (RR 1.13, 95% CI [1.05, 1.22] P = 0.001) and
overall success (RR 1.22 95% CI [1.12, 1.33], P < 0.00001) at 2 years post surgery
compared to fusion. Secondary surgeries (any revision, removal, or re-operation of the
implant or supplemental fixation) after 2 years were also significantly lower with
arthroplasty (13/621) compared to fusion (39/592), [0.32 95% CI [0.17, 0.59) P =
0.0003]. Total number of patients undergoing reoperations at adjacent levels was lower
in arthroplasty-treated patients (9/621) vs. ACDF (17/592), however it was not statistically significant (P = 0.09). Given the small numbers of patients undergoing reoperations
at adjacent levels, longer term results are needed to increase precision of this estimate.
CONCLUSIONS: A formal pooled analysis of 2-year RCT data demonstrates clinically
significant improvements in efficacy and safety outcomes in CDDD patients who have
undergone arthroplasty versus standard fusion.
PMS4
NUMBER NEEDED TO TREAT FOR PATIENTS TO REPORT BROAD
RELIEF FROM THE BURDEN OF RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS WHEN
TREATED WITH CERTOLIZUMAB PEGOL PLUS METHOTREXATE
Strand V1, van Vollenhoven R2, Kvien T3, Combe B4, Khanna D5, Burmester G6, Nikai E7,
Coteur G7, Smolen JS8, Schiff MH9
1
Stanford University, Portola Valley, CA, USA; 2Karolinska University Hospital, Stockholm,
Sweden; 3University of Oslo, Oslo, Norway; 4Hôpital Lapeyronie, Montpellier, France;
5
University of California, Los Angeles, CA, USA; 6Charité University Hospital, Berlin,
Germany; 7UCB, Brussels, Belgium; 8Medical University of Vienna and Hietzing Hospital,
Vienna, Austria; 9University of Colorado School of Medicine, Denver, CO, USA
OBJECTIVES: To determine in patients with RA the number needed to treat (NNT)
to achieve minimum clinically important differences (MCIDs) in multiple patient
13th Euro Abstracts
reported outcomes (PROs) simultaneously following treatment with certolizumab
pegol (CZP) 200 mg + methotrexate (MTX), in the RAPID 1 and RAPID 2 trials.
METHODS: The proportions of patients reporting improvements ≥MCID in RAPID
1 (Week 24 and Week 52) and RAPID 2 (Week 24) were determined for the following
PROs: arthritis pain (0–100 mm visual analogue scale [VAS], MCID ≥ 10 mm), fatigue
(Fatigue Assessment Scale, 0–10 numeric rating scale, MCID ≥ 1 point), physical
function (Health Assessment Questionnaire-Disability Index, MCID ≥ 0.22 points),
patient’s global assessment of disease activity (PtGA, 0–100 mm VAS, MCID ≥
10 mm), and HRQoL (SF-36 physical and mental component summaries [PCS, MCS],
MCID ≥ 2.5 points). NNT to achieve improvements ≥MCID in at least 1, 2, 3, 4, 5,
or 6 out of the 6 considered PROs simultaneously with CZP + MTX compared with
PBO + MTX were also calculated. RAPID 1: NCT00152386; RAPID 2: NCT00160602.
RESULTS: The NNT to report clinically meaningful improvements in up to 5/6 PROs
following CZP + MTX treatment was very low; approximately 2–3 additional patients
after 24 weeks (RAPID 1 and RAPID 2). The NNT remained similar at 52 weeks
(RAPID 1). The NNT to report improvements in all 6 PROs was 5 additional patients.
In patients who achieved MCIDs in at least 5 of 6 PROs by Week 52, clinically
meaningful improvements were more likely to be reported in pain, fatigue, physical
function and PtGA than SF-36 PCS or particularly MCS. CONCLUSIONS: Patients
with active RA report meaningful and broad relief in PROs following treatment with
CZP. The low NNTs indicate that few patients need to be treated with CZP + MTX
to report relief from the multiple burdens of RA.
PMS5
PRIMARY ANTI-TNF FAILURES EXPERIENCE SUPERIOR CLINICAL
RESPONSES TO A SECOND ANTI-TNF AGENT THAN SECONDARY
FAILURES: ANALYSIS OF THE ALBERTA RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS
BIOLOGICS REGISTRY
Ohinmaa A1, Martin L2, Russell AS1, Barr S2, Sholter D1, Penney C2, Yan C3, Jacobs P3,
Maksymowych W1
1
University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada; 2University of Calgary, Calgary, AB, Canada;
3
Institute of Health Economics, Edmonton, AB, Canada
OBJECTIVES: A Provincial prospective observational cohort study observes consecutive Rheumatoid Arthritis (RA) patients starting anti-TNF therapy (infliximab, etanercept or adalimumab). We aimed to assess the impact of switching anti-TNF agents
at different time points. METHODS: Data in the registry is collected at baseline, 3
months, and every 6 months thereafter up to 3 years on patients receiving anti-TNF
agents. We grouped patients as infliximab or adalimumab starters, and etanercept
starters. Health-related quality of life was measured with the EQ-5D and single index
scores were calculated using US value sets. Clinical outcome measures assessed were
the HAQ and DAS28 scores. We analyzed the mean EQ-5D index score, the HAQ
score, and the DAS28 score over time within baseline starter groups according to the
time of switch of treatment. RESULTS: From 1222 patients in the registry, 649
patients had 27 months follow-up assessment and 76.7% remained on the first antiTNF. For these patients, significant improvement was observed by 3 months in the
EQ-5D (mean change 0.296, P < 0.001), the HAQ (mean change −0.822, P < 0.001)
and DAS28 (mean change −2.84 P < 0.001) that was sustained over the follow-up
period. Those who switched at 3 months (primary failures) had significantly responded
by the next measurement and the 27 months changes in outcomes were comparable
to non-switchers (all P < 0.01). Patients who failed the first anti-TNF after the 3-month
time point (secondary failures) obtained from 50% (HAQ) to 68% (EQ-5D) of the
mean change compared to non-switchers (P < 0.05). Switching from Infliximab or
adalimumab to etanercept or vice versa produced similar outcomes. CONCLUSIONS:
The results show that primary failures to anti-TNF show similar responses to patients
responding to their first anti-TNF agent. Secondary failures obtain about two-third of
the outcomes compares to no-switchers and primary failures. Longer follow up is
needed to see if the secondary failure patients can sustain the obtained
improvement.
PMS6
COMPARISON OF RECENTLY REGISTERED BIOLOGICAL DRUGS WITH
AVAILABLE THERAPIES IN RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS:
METHODOLOGICAL ISSUES TO CONSIDER FOR META-ANALYSIS
Péntek M1, Gulácsi L1, Érsek K1, Baji P1, Boncz I2, Orlewska E3, Brodszky V1
1
Corvinus University of Budapest, Budapest, Hungary; 2University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary;
3
Centre for Pharmacoeconomics, Warsaw, Poland
OBJECTIVES: Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is a chronic, progressive, disabling autoimmune disease. The first biologic drug (etanercept) for the treatment of RA was registered in 1998, the latest in 2009 (EMEA). Study design of randomized controlled trials
(RCT) of RA has changed in the past years, specially in point of reducing the time on
placebo. Our aim was to compare the efficacy, safety and tolerability of available
biologic drugs and to review the challenges of comparing RA studies with different
structures, taking the example of the lately registered drug certolizumab pegol.
METHODS: Systematic literature search was performed (closed on 16.08.2009) for
RCTs with minimum duration of 24 weeks, involving drugs that have been registered
for the treatment of RA after traditional disease modifying drug failure. Improvement
of symptoms by 20%, 50% and 70% (defined by the American College of Rheumatology, ACR), adverse events and withdrawals were considered as endpoints in the
metaanalysis. RESULTS: Altogether 14 RCTs (adalimumab 3, certolizumab pegol 2,
etanercept 2, infliximab 4, tocilizumab 2, golimumab 1) involving 6739 patients were
selected for the analysis. Efficacy of certolizumab pegol was superior to other drugs
at ACR20, 50 and 70 but heterogenity was observed at certain safety endpoints.
A303
Contrary to previous trials, patients on placebo not achieving ACR20 response at
week 16 were withrawn in the certolizumab pegol studies. Thus patient number in
the placebo group decreased dramatically for the remaining 8 weeks. To exclude this
bias, we compared only the active arms and there was no significant difference in
terms of safety and tolerability among the drugs. Analysis by patients years confirmed
this finding. CONCLUSIONS: Effectiveness and safety of recently registered biologic
drugs in RA are similar to the previous agents. Differences in protocol of former and
present RCTs should be carefully considered for the analysis.
PMS7
DETERMINANTS OF TNF INHIBITOR DOSE ESCALATION IN PATIENTS
WITH RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS
Baser O1, Gust C2, Wang L2, Xie L2
1
STATinMED Research/University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA; 2STATinMED Research,
Ann Arbor, MI, USA
OBJECTIVES: Switching among tumor necrosis factor-α inhibitor (TNFi) agents or
to another biologic is relatively common, but determinants of dose escalation are
largely unknown. Among individuals who are escalating the dose from their first TNFi,
we identified factors associated with the choice of dose escalation in a retrospective
analysis of medical and pharmacy claims and eligibility data. METHODS: Eligible
patients were ≥18 years of age, diagnosed with rheumatoid arthritis (RA, 2 diagnoses
≥2 months apart) from January 2003–March 2008, had initiated a new TNFi prescription after a 6-month biologic-free period and had at least 6 months of continuous
enrollment. Kaplan-Meier (KM) analysis and Cox regression were used to analyze
time to dose escalation. Multinomial logistic regression was used to determine factors
affecting dose escalation. RESULTS: A total of 11,903 (6.9%) of 173,533 RA patients
were identified. Among these patients, 16% (n = 1,903) after a mean of 261 days
escalated their dose. Comorbidity scores, such as the severity index for rheumatoid
arthritis (SIFRA) and Elixhauser, were higher for patients who escalated their dose.
The likelihood of escalating the dose was increased by female sex, younger age, and
baseline use of corticosteroids or cytotoxic agents. Baseline use of methotrexate raised
the likelihood of dose escalation (relative risk ratio, 1.58). CONCLUSIONS: After
initiating TNFi treatment, many RA patients failed to remain on therapy and escalated
doses or switched to a second TNFi or another biologic ~1 year. Factors influencing
whether patients increased their dose included gender, age, and use of certain agents
at initiation of the TNFi. a limitation of this study is that patients with <6 months of
TNFi treatment were not included.
PMS8
OCCURRENCE OF SECUNDARY HIP AND FEMUR FRACTURES
ACCORDING TO RISK FACTORS FOLLOW-UP 8 YEARS
Sebestyén A1, Lipp S1, Gresz M2, Varga S3, Oláh A3, Boncz I3
1
National Health Insurance Fund Administration, Pécs, Hungary; 2National Health Insurance
Fund Administration, Budapest, Hungary; 3University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study is to evaluate the occurrences of secundary hip
and femur fractures according to its different risk factors with follow up 8 years.
METHODS: In this retrospective study the data derive from the financial database of
the Hungarian National Health Insurance Fund Administration, based on the 10th
revision of the International Classification of Diseases (ICD) with ICD code S7200.
The patients included into the study had femur neck fracture and being discharged
from the hospital after the primary treatment in 2000. The patients with polytrauma
were excluded from the study. We evaluated data according to sex, age, type of
fracture, type of surgery, local complications, type of residence. RESULTS: A total of
3783 patients met selection criteria of primary femoral neck fracture. During the
postoperative 8 years 347 patents (9,2%) had secondary hip and femur fractures.
Average age of patient with primary hip fracture 78 years, with secundary hip fracture
80,6 years. We demonstrated the following incidence rate of secundary hip fractures
according to risk factors: Sex: female: 10,3%, male: 5,8%. Age groups: 60–69 y:
5,3%, 70–79 y: 7,5%, 80–89 y: 12,4%, 90 y-: 14,1%. Type of fracture: lateral: 6,9%,
medial 9,5%. Type of surgery: osteosynthesis: 8,5%, arthroplasty: 13,6%. Local
complications: yes: 10,6% no: 9%. Type of residence: capital 11,5%, village: 7,9%,
city: 10%, town: 8,2%. CONCLUSIONS: The secondary hip fracture rate increased
with the age of patients. The secondary hip fracture rate was the highest in female, in
patient with primary intracapsular femoral neck fracture, after arthroplasty, in patient
with local complication, in patient with capital residence. Many other factors can
influence this secondary hip fractur, which will be analyzed in our further studies.
PMS9
TREND OF HIP FRACTURE INCIDENCE IN BELGIUM BETWEEN 2000
AND 2007 AND FUTURE PROJECTIONS
Hiligsmann M1, Bruyère O1, Detilleux J1, Gillet P1, Parmentier Y2, Dercq JP2, Carton J3,
Reginster JY1
1
University of Liège, Liège, Belgium; 2INAMI, Brussels, Belgium; 3FPS Public Health, Brussels,
Belgium
OBJECTIVES: The primary aim of this study was to assess the incidence of hip
fractures in Belgium between 2000 and 2007 and to examine secular changes within
this period. a secondary aim was to estimate the expected number of hip fractures in
Belgium until 2050. METHODS: The incidence of hip fractures was determined using
the national database of hospital bills, which fully cover the annual hospital stays in
the whole of the country. Population data and projections were derived from official
sources. Logistic regression including year and age classes was performed for both
A304
genders to assess the secular change between 2000–2002 and 2005–2007. Hip fracture
projections were made until 2050, assuming the gender-specific secular change
observed between 2000–2007 will be maintained. RESULTS: A total of 113,101 hip
fractures were recorded in Belgium between 2000 and 2007, of which 76.4% occured
in women. The annual number of hip fractures increased from 13,512 in 2000 to
14,744 in 2007, with a more marked increase in men (+20.4%) than in women
(+5.7%). Between 2000–2002 and 2005–2007, the age-adjusted incidence of hip
fractures significantly decreased by 1.08% per year (95% CI: 0.78 to 1.38) in women,
but declined non-significantly by 0.30% per year (95% CI: −0.24 to 0.84) in men.
The female/male ratio of hip fractures decreased between these periods from 3.19 to
2.92 (P < 0.01). By the year 2050, the number of hip fractures is expected to increase
by 37.8% in women and by 110.0% in men. The female/male ratio would decrease
to 1.81. CONCLUSIONS: Despite a significant decrease in the age-adjusted incidence
of hip fractures in Belgian women and a non-significant decline in men, the number
of hip fractures is expected to substantially increase in Belgium. Appropriate public
health strategies are therefore needed and should also focus on populations of men.
PMS10
PREVALENCE OF GOUT IN THE US GENERAL POPULATION: THE
NATIONAL HEALTH AND NUTRITION EXAMINATION SURVEY
(NHANES) 2007–2008
Zhu Y1, Pandya BJ2, Choi H1
1
Boston University of School of Medicine, Boston, MA, USA; 2Takeda Pharmaceuticals
International, Inc., Deerfield, IL, USA
OBJECTIVES: While the disease burden of gout in the US has been considered substantial and may have been rising over the past decade, no contemporary national
data are available. We estimated the prevalence of gout based on a recent, nationally
representative sample of US men and women (National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey [NHANES] 2007–8). METHODS: Using data from 5707 participants
in NHANES 2007–8 (2797 men and 2910 women) aged ≥20 years, we estimated
overall, gender-specific, and age-specific prevalence of gout. During the home interview of NHANES, all participants were asked: “Has a doctor or other health professional ever told you that you had gout?” We estimated the number of individuals with
gout by applying our prevalence estimates to the corresponding 2008 US population
estimate of 214.8 million adults over age 18. RESULTS: Overall prevalence of gout
among US adults was 3.9%, which corresponded to an estimated 8.3 million individuals with gout. Prevalence of gout was 5.9% (6.1 million) among men and 2.0% (2.2
million) among women. Prevalence of gout increased with age, with the lowest (0.4%,
0.2 million) in those aged 20–29 years and the highest (12.6%, 1.2 million) in those
aged ≥80 years. Prevalence of gout among those aged <64 years was 2.7% and was
higher (9.8%) among those aged ≥65 years. Those ≥65 years corresponded to an
estimated 3.5 million adults with gout. CONCLUSIONS: These findings from the
latest nationally representative sample of US adults in NHANES 2007–2008 suggest
that the prevalence of gout is substantial, particularly among older (aged ≥65 years)
individuals. Additional confirmation studies are needed.
PMS11
LONGITUDINAL ASSESSMENT OF GOUT IN A LARGE SAMPLE OF
ITALIAN PATIENTS: PREVALENCE AND DISEASE MANAGEMENT IN
GPS OFFICES
Heiman F, Katz PM
BKL Consulting SRL, Milan, Italy
OBJECTIVES: The main goals of this retrospective study were to analyze the Prevalence of Gout in GPs offices in Italy and to describe the management of gouty patients
by the GPs in terms of types and number of Specialistic visits requests during 12
months of follow-up. METHODS: Data were obtained from CSD LPD, a General
Practitioner’s longitudinal database. Patients with at least one diagnosis of Gout from
January 2008 to December 2008 have been selected and followed-up for 12 months.
RESULTS: From 1.126.847 active patients, 17.241 had at least one diagnosis of gout,
resulting on a prevalence of 1.53% in the general population. Among the 17.241
patients only 1.42% had received a specialistic visit request related to gout; of these
the 42.8% were Reumatology visit requests, the 20.4% Ortopedics visits, the 8.1%
Nephrology visits. Comparing the group of patients with at least one visit request
related to gout (244) to the rest of the patients (16.997) in terms of specialistic visits
request (related to all kind of diagnosis) during follow-up period, it could be seen that
the group of 244 patients had received in average 4.5 specialistic visits request while
the rest of the patients had received 2.3 visit requests. CONCLUSIONS: During the
study we have identified a group of patients (244 patients 1,4% of the total) with at
least one specialistic visit request related to the diagnosis of Gout, and we assumed
that this group represents “Complicated patients” , maybe refractory to the therapy,
that GPs need to manage in cooperation with specialist physicians. On support of our
hypothesis the average number of specialistic visits (related to all kind of diagnosis)
among this group is significatively higher in comparison with the rest of the patients
(4.5 vs. 2.3).
PMS12
PROJECTION OF SURGICAL LOADS OF HIP AND KNEE
1
2
Gaiser S , Kapoun M
1
Heraeus Medical GmbH, Wehrheim, Germany; 2Hochschule Niederrhein, Krefeld, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Recent trends in the number of primary total hip arthroplasty (THA)
and total knee arthroplasty (TKA) in the US has suggested a massive future demand
for THA and TKA. It is unknown if this trend is the same in France as France has a
13th Euro Abstracts
slower growth rates in obesity compared to US. The purpose of our study was to
describe the recent trend of primary THA and TKA in France. METHODS: Registry
data on THA and TKA, collected between 2000 and 2006, were obtained from the
Agence technique de l’information sur l’hospitalisation (ATIF 2009). RESULTS: In
2006, approximately 139,000 hip replacements and 66,000 knee replacements were
performed in France. Hip procedures increased by 6% and knee procedures by 30%
since 2001. The economic burden associated with joint replacements is estimated
approx. 2 billion Euro in 2006. The mean cost for primary hip replacement in France
was c7,467 in 2006 and c8,690 for knee replacement procedures. Arthroplasties
represent the medical specialty with the highest expenses in France. In France, only
41% of knee replacements were cemented. This proportion is relatively low in comparison to others European countries. CONCLUSIONS: This trend could accelerate
in the near future due to changes in French demographics: increase of prevalence of
overweight and obese patients as well as population ageing. These two categories of
population have the highest incidence of joint replacement procedures. Obesity prevalence increases by 5% every year since 1997 to reach 12.4% of the total population
in 2006 and the elderly population will reach 30% of the French population by 2050.
In the context of the current financial crisis reducing unnecessary health care expenditure is inevitable. In the French market implant price represent 30% of hip replacement procedure and 38% for knee replacement.
PMS13
RECENT TRENDS IN NUMBERS OF PRIMARY HIP/KNEE
ARTHROPLASTIES PERFORMED IN GERMANY AND THE UNITED
KINGDOM
Gaiser S1, Kim S2
1
Heraeus Medical GmbH, Wehrheim, Germany; 2University of California, Davis, Sacramento,
CA, USA
OBJECTIVES: The number of primary total hip arthroplasties (THAs) and total knee
arthroplasties (TKAs) continues to increase steeply in the US. It is unknown if this
trend is the same in Germany and the United Kingdom (UK) as these populations age
and become heavier. The purpose of our study was to investigate recent trends of
primary THA and TKA in Germany and the UK. METHODS: We analyzed data from
the German Bundesgeschäftsstelle für Qualitätssicherung and the UK’s National Joint
Register. RESULTS: Between 2004 and 2008 in Germany, THAs increased 14% and
TKAs increased 32%. During the same time in the UK, there were 60% and 70%
increases in THAs and TKAs, respectively. In the UK, more TKAs than THAs have
been performed since 2005, and a similar trend is expected in Germany after 2010.
Nearly 20% of TKAs in Germany were performed on non-elderly patients (64 or
younger) and patient age distributions remained approximately the same over the
study period. In the UK, however, approximately 30% of TKAs were on non-elderly
patients and the proportion of non-elderly patients that underwent TKA has increased
every year. CONCLUSIONS: The number of arthroplasties in the US has increased
dramatically among non-elderly adults. We observed no increase in this patient group
in Germany but a slow and gradual increase in the UK. As obesity has risen over the
last decades, the US has experienced greater inclines in TKAs than THAs; the annual
number of TKAs is now twice that of THAs. Although the number of TKAs and the
number of THAs had been approximately the same in Germany and the UK, recent
trends suggest a growing gap due to a steeper rise in TKAs. Obesity, a strong risk
factor for TKA, may be a bigger contributor than aging to the recent growth in joint
arthroplasty.
PMS14
RECURRENT FRACTURES AFTER FIRST HIP FRACTURES AND
PREVENTION OF SECOND HIP FRACTURES IN JAPANESE WOMEN
Yamabe K1, Hagino H1, Sawaguchi T2, Endo N3, Nakano T4, Watanabe Y5, Abe M1, Ito Y1
1
Tottori University, Yonago, Japan; 2Toyama City Hospital, Toyama, Japan; 3Niigata University
Graduate School of Medicine and Dental Science, Niigata, Japan; 4Tamana Chuo Hospital,
Tamana, Japan; 5Teikyo University School of Medicine, Tokyo, Japan
OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to elucidate the incidence of recurrent
fractures and the current status of osteoporosis treatment within one year after the
first hip fracture. METHODS: This study was conducted for all female patients who
were 65 years or older who had experienced hip fracture due to trauma for the first
time and were treated within five geographic areas in Japan during the study period
(January 2006 to December 2007). The data on demographics, treatments, and health
outcomes were collected from medical records. a patient questionnaire was mailed to
every patient about the health outcomes. RESULTS: The analysis was conducted in
2330 patients (average age 83.6 years). During the one-year observational period 158
fractures occurred in 152 patients. The incidence for all fractures among patients with
first hip fracture was 71.7 (per 1000 person-year), and that for hip fracture was 36.7.
The relative risk of recurrent hip fracture was 4.4 for women aged 65 years and over
with first hip fracture. During this one-year period, anti-osteoporosis pharmacotherapy was performed in 437 patients (18.8%) while 1240 patients (53.2%) received no
treatment. CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrated the high risk of recurrent
fracture in patients with first hip fracture and inadequate treatment for fracture prevention after first hip fracture. Since hip fracture patients are the most plausible
candidates in the prevention of recurrent fractures, especially second hip fractures with
high burden, appropriate treatment of osteoporosis is essential.
13th Euro Abstracts
PMS15
FREQUENCY AND RISK FACTORS OF GOUT FLARES IN A LARGE
POPULATION-BASED COHORT OF INCIDENT GOUT
Rothenbacher D1, Primatesta P1, Ferreira A1, Cea Soriano L2, Garcia LA2
1
Novartis Pharma AG, Basel, Switzerland; 2CEIFE—Centro Español de Investigación
Farmacoepidemiológica, Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: To describe the frequency and risk factors of gout flares in a large
cohort of incident gout. METHODS: A cohort study was conducted in an UK general
practice database (The Health Improvement network (THIN)) in the study period
January 2000 through December 2008. All patients aged 20–89 years diagnosed with
incident gout between the years 2000–2007 were included; their history of flares
recorded over time. We studied the association between several factors and the number
of flares. a Cox proportional hazards model was used to identify determinants of risk
of first flare. RESULTS: The overall incidence rate of gout was 2.68 (95% confidence
interval (CI) 2.65–2.72) per 1,000 person-years, and 23,857 incident gout patients
(mean age 61.9 years) were included in this study. The incidence rate of a first flare
was 13.7 (95% CI 13.4–14.0) per 100 person-years. The proportion of patients with
at least one flare during the follow-up period (mean 3.8 years) was 36.9% (n = 8,806).
Male gender, alcohol consumption and history of cardiometabolic diseases were positively associated with number of flares (P < 0.001). The hazard ratio estimate of first
flare associated with antecedents of renal failure disorders was 1.33 (CI 95% 1.20–
1.48), 1.41 (CI 95% 1.26–1.58) for drinking more than 42 alcohol units per week,
and 1.22 (CI 95% 1.14–1.30) for a body mass index greater than 30 kg/m2. Also, a
higher risk of a first flare was associated with a history of ischemic heart disease, and
hypertension (HR: 1.12 (95% CI 1.06–1.19) and 1.15 (95% CI 1.10-1-20), respectively). CONCLUSIONS: Gout flares are the most common clinical manifestation in
patients suffering from gout disease. Male sex, modifiable life-style factors as well as
comorbid conditions are important independent risk factors for first flare.
PMS16
EARLY MORTALITY RATE OF BILATERAL HIP FRACTURES OVER 60 IN
HUNGARY
Sebestyen A1, Lipp S1, Boncz I2
1
Baranya County Health Insurance Fund, Pécs, Hungary; 2University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: The aim of the study is to analyze the early mortality rate after bilateral
hip and femur fractures over 60 in Hungary. METHODS: In this retrospective study
the data derive from the financial database of the National Health Insurance Fund of
Hungary. For the analysis we used code S7200 of the International Classification of
Diseases (ICD) tenth revision. The patients included into the study had femoral neck
fracture and being discharged from the hospital after the primary treatment in 2000.
The patients with polytrauma were excluded from the study. The follow up was 8
years. The patients were categorized according to sex, age, fracture type, surgical
methods, presence of accompanying diseases and day of hospital admission. We
analyzed the early mortality rate within 30 days after treatment of bilateral hip and
femur fracture. RESULTS: Altogether 347 patients were included into the study. The
national average of mortality was 7.5%. We demonstrated the following early mortality rate according to risk factors: Sex: male: 13.2%, female: 6.5%. Age groups:
60–69 y: 5.4%, 70–79 y: 5.9%, 80 y-: 8.9%. Type of fractures: femoral neck fractures: 4.2%, pertrochanteric fractures: 15.5%, femur fractures: 5.9%. Surgical techniques: arthroplasty: 3.1%, osteosynthesis: 7.8%. Accompanying diseases: yes: 8.1%,
no: 2.6%. Day of hospital admission: weekday: 7.4%, weekend: 7.7%. CONCLUSIONS: The early mortality rate increased with the age of patients. In the analysis
according to sex, type of fracture and presence of accompanying diseases we found
higher mortality in male, in patient with pertrochanteric fracture and in patient with
accompanying diseases. According to surgical intervention early mortality rate is
higher in patient with osteosynthesis. Many other factors can influence this mortality,
which will be analyzed in our further studies.
MUSCULAR-SKELETAL DISORDERS – Cost Studies
PMS17
BUDGET IMPACT OF NEW RHBMP-2 FORMULATION IN PATIENTS
UNDERGOING POSTEROLATERAL SPINAL FUSION PROCEDURES FOR
DEGENERATIVE DISC DISEASE IN RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL
(RCT)
McInnis MM1, Olchanski N1, Kemner JE2, Goss T1
1
Boston Healthcare Associates, Inc., Boston, MA, USA; 2Medtronic Spinal and Biologics,
Memphis, TN, USA
OBJECTIVES: A new formulation of recombinant human bone morphogenetic
protein-2 (rhBMP-2) on a Compression Resistant Matrix (CRM) evaluated in posterolateral spinal fusion (PLF) procedures for degenerative disc disease (DDD) has the
potential to improve clinical outcomes and decrease costs. The rhBMP-2/CRM pivotal
study demonstrated significant improvement in spinal fusion rates compared to procedures using iliac crest bone graft (ICBG), (Dimar 2009). This study evaluated the
likely budget impact of rhBMP-2/CRM on U.S. payer costs compared to ICBG procedures in PLF. METHODS: A budget impact model was developed to quantify clinical and economic outcomes for patients with single-level symptomatic DDD and the
U.S. payer costs of rhBMP-2/CRM in PLF procedures. The model results compare use
of rhBMP-2/CRM to the use of ICBG in these procedures. Both study arms use posterior supplemental fixation. The 24-month clinical data was derived from 463
A305
patients in the rhBMP-2/CRM pivotal study trial and included independent radiographic assessment of fusion success rates, re-surgery rates, and complications rates
(infections, bleeding, cardiovascular complications, GI complications). Payer costs and
clinical practice data were derived from published sources and from the 2007 Medicare Inpatient Standard Analytic File and inflated to 2010 costs using the medical care
component of the U.S. Consumer Price Index. RESULTS: The average 2-year costs
per patient treated with ICBG were $53,740. Comparatively, treating patients with
rhBMP-2/CRM is estimated to reduce average costs by 12% ($6,252) per patient.
Cost reductions were primarily driven by a reduction in subsequent surgeries. Fusion
rates at 2 years were greater in the rhBMP-2/CRM group compared to the ICBG group
(96% vs. 89% at p = 0.014). CONCLUSIONS: This budget impact model based on
RCT data demonstrates that the use of rhBMP-2/CRM in treatment of DDD patients
undergoing PLF procedures is associated with substantial cost savings to payers when
compared with traditional ICBG procedures.
PMS18
A BUDGET IMPACT MODEL FOR THE ECONOMIC ASSESSMENT OF
TOCILIZUMAB IN THE TREATMENT OF RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS
PATIENTS IN ITALY
Iannazzo S1, Zaniolo O1, Giuliani G2
1
Adres srl, Torino, Italy; 2Roche S.p.A., Monza, Italy
OBJECTIVES: A Budget Impact Model (BIM) was developed to assess the impact on
Italian National Health Service (NHS) expenditure caused by the use of tocilizumab
(TOC) , monoclonal antibody approved by EMA in early 2009, as a first-line biologic
treatment vs. traditional anti-TNFα therapies in the treatment of moderate to severe
rheumatoid arthritis (RA) patients. METHODS: A Markov model was used to simulate the progression of a cohort of RA patients through three lines of biologic treatments with anti-TNFα and TOC, palliative therapy and death. The horizon was 5
years. The target population was defined by the number of incident RA patients eligible to first-line biologic treatment based on Italian epidemiological and market data.
First-line TOC followed by a second- and a third-line anti-TNFα treatment was
compared a more traditional strategy based on anti-TNFα cycling. Direct medical
costs were considered: drug acquisition, administration and monitoring tests, according to current prices and tariffs. To estimate the relative effectiveness of use of economic resources, the average number of patients that can be treated with an
hypothetical annual budget of c1,000,000 was assessed. RESULTS: Italian RA
patients eligible to a first-line biologic therapy were estimated in 750 per year. Firstline TOC strategy induced a decrease of costs of c805,000 (−8.6% with respect to
anti-TNFα cycling), and c1,348,000 (−3.1%) at year 1 and year 5 respectively. The
average annual number of patients that can be treated with c1,000,000 was 75.7 at
year1 and 78.5 at year5 under the anti-TNFα cycling strategy, while it was 82.9 at
year 1 and 81.8 at year 5 with first-line TOC, with a 9.5% to 4.3% increase. CONCLUSIONS: The introduction of TOC among the biologic therapies available for
Italian RA patients represents a valuable option as it is expected to induce a reduction
in costs and a more efficient use of health care resources.
PMS19
THE INTRODUCTION OF A GERMAN ARTHROPLASTY REGISTER: COST
SAVINGS FOR THE HEALTH CARE SYSTEM
Held R1, Gaiser S2
1
Hochschule Niederrhein, Krefeld, Germany; 2Heraeus Medical GmbH, Wehrheim, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Worldwide the numbers of first use—implantations and revisions in
the hip—and knee arthroplasty are rising. In many countries corresponding arthroplasty—registers have been introduced in order to increase the quality of such operations. Arthroplasty—registers in countries like Sweden have been improving the
practical operations and both realizing significant cost savings at national level by
reducing the revision burden results. In Germany a similar arthroplasty—register has
not yet been introduced. METHODS: This study examines the trends in the German
health care system which influences the development of clinical numbers in the field
of arthroplasty and makes forecasts to 2020 on the basis of the BQS—data. In a
further step this study takes the experiences and the results of existing arthroplasty—
registers especially from Sweden into account and makes use of it for the situation in
Germany. The aim is to identify possible cost savings when introducing such a register
in Germany. RESULTS: The introduction of a German arthroplasty—register for hips
seems to make an important contribution to the quality of medical care. In addition
considerable cost savings on a national basis might be realized by reducing the revision
burden, which exceed the cost of an arthroplasty—register by far. CONCLUSIONS:
If the revision burden for hip arthroplasty could be reduced by one percentage point
cost savings of about c14–23 million per year could be realized. a reduction of about
50 per cent like in Sweden cost savings about c81–216 million per year could be
expected. The results of this study might be a basis of discussion among
policymakers.
PMS20
COST AND QUALITY OF LIFE IN PATIENTS WITH RHEUMATOID
ARTHRITIS IN SOUTH KOREA
Lee TJ1, Park BH1, Sohn HG1, Song YW2, Shin K2
1
Seoul National University, Seoul, South Korea; 2Seoul National University Hospital, Seoul,
South Korea
OBJECTIVES: This study aims to estimate health care cost and productivity loss and
to measure the quality of life in patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA), particularly
A306
by its functional class (FC) in the Korean health care setting. METHODS: RA-associated costs were estimated from a societal perspective. Health care cost was estimated
using data from National Health Insurance (NHI) Claims Database between January
1 and December 31, 2008. In order to estimate other health care costs, like traditional
medicine and physiotherapy, that are not covered under the NHI and non-health care
costs including transportation, health food and housekeeping services, face-to-face
interviews were conducted for 202 patients with RA in a large teaching hospital in
Seoul for 3 months starting from November 18, 2009. RA-related productivity loss
and quality of life using EQ-5D were also estimated from the survey. Factors associated with costs as well as quality of life in RA patients were indentified using multiple
regression and logistic regression. RESULTS: Total annual cost that RA patients
incurred in 2009 was estimated to be $1.6 billion, of which almost a half was attributable to productivity loss. As the function of RA patients deteriorates, annual per capita
cost showed an increasing trend (FC I: $3534, FC II: $6057, FC III: $6722, and FC
IV: $6856) while quality of life was lowered (FC I: 0.673, FC II: 0.502, FC III: 0.294,
and FC IV: 0.227). Annual per capita cost increased with the deterioration of function
(P < 0.05) and co-morbidity (P < 0.1). The quality of life was positively correlated
with functional class (P < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: RA patients not only incur high
health care cost but also suffer from significant productivity loss and reduced quality
of life in Korea. RA patients’ poor function is highly correlated with higher costs and
lower quality of life.
PMS21
THE ACUTE CARE COSTS OF OSTEOPOROSIS-RELATED FRACTURES
IN CANADA
Tarride JE1, Hopkins R1, Leslie WD2, Morin S3, Papaioannou A1, Adachi R1, Bischof M1,
Goeree R1
1
McMaster University, Hamilton, ON, Canada; 2University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, MB,
Canada; 3McGill University, Montreal, QC, Canada
OBJECTIVES: Osteoporosis is a prevalent disease, characterized by low bone mass
and increased fracture risk. In 1993 the economic burden of osteoporosis-related
fractures in Canada was $1.3 billion dollars, of which $437 million was acute care.
Our objective was to update the1993 acute care estimates for Canada for non-traumatic fractures. METHODS: We used national administrative databases from Canadian Institute for Health Information for fiscal-year ending March 31, 2008 for
Canadians over age 50. Data sources included the Discharge Abstract Database for
all acute care hospitalizations in Canada except Quebec; National Ambulatory Care
Reporting System for all same day surgery, emergency visits/ambulatory services in
hospital for Ontario. Both data sources were projected nationally using Statistics
Canada census data. Non traumatic fractures included hip, humerus, vertebral, wrist,
other sites (ribs/sternum, pelvis, trunk, clavicle, scapula, femur, patella, tibia/fibula),
and multiple sites (more than 1 of the preceding). Costs were based on resource
intensity weights for direct medical costs less physician billings. Physician fees billed
directly to provincial plans included visits in hospital, diagnostic and surgical interventions. RESULTS: Osteoporotic non-traumatic fractures were responsible for 57,404
acute care admissions, 112,749 emergency room visits, and 3,433 same day surgeries
in Canada in 2008. Hip fractures accounted for 50.3% of admissions, wrist fractures
accounted for 80.8% of same day surgeries, and emergency visits mostly occurred in
other sites (30.0%), wrist (29.7%) and hip fractures (22.9%). The cost of acute care
was estimated at $1.2 billion with hip fractures alone costing $619 million. CONCLUSIONS: Osteoporosis is a chronic disease that affects a large segment of the adult
population in Canada and increases the risk for expensive health care utilization for
Canadians. Since 1993, the acute care cost of osteoporosis-related fractures has risen
from $437 million to $1.2 billion dollars per year, which represents an increasing
economic burden for Canada.
PMS22
ECONOMIC BURDEN OF OSTEOPOROSIS-RELATED FRACTURE
HOSPITALIZATIONS IN FRANCE
Maravic M1, Vainchtock A2, Jouaneton B3, Tochon V4
1
Hôpital Léopold Bellan, Paris, France; 2HEVA, LYON, France; 3HEVA, Lyon, France; 4Amgen,
Neuilly Sur Seine, France
OBJECTIVES: To estimate the burden of post-menopausal osteoporosis-related fracture hospitalizations in France for acute and rehabilitation care. METHODS: Data
were obtained from the 2008 French Hospital National Database for women aged
≥50 years. For acute care, criteria were established according to ICD-10 codes related
to osteoporosis. As the rules of coding are not strictly followed in real practice, an
additional database analysis was performed to include stays related to surgical management of hip fractures. Duplicate hospitalizations were excluded. Among women
that were identified for acute care, we selected those who went in rehabilitation care
related specifically to osteoporosis. We assessed number of hospitalizations and
patients, proportion of surgical management, length of stay in acute care and number
of rehabilitation day and costs. Hospital costs were calculated according 2009 national
hospital tariff and 2000–2001 National Scale of Costs, respectively for acute and
rehabilitation care (2009c). RESULTS: There were 67,807 acute hospitalizations
(64,793 patients) and 1,359,863 days for rehabilitation care (31,458 patients) associated with osteoporosis-related fractures. In acute care, a total of 80% of the hospitalizations were associated with the surgical management of fractures and 89% of
them were transferred in rehabilitation care. The mean (SD) length of stay and days
of rehabilitation were 12 ± 8 days and 43 ± 31 days, respectively. The overall cost of
osteoporosis-related fracture hospitalizations was 415,429,993c for acute care, of
13th Euro Abstracts
which 6.5% was related to medical devices, and 331,755,797c for rehabilitation care.
The mean (SD) hospital cost including medical devices, was 6127c ± 2352c per stay
for acute care and 10,546c ± 7,869c per stay for rehabilitation care. CONCLUSIONS:
In 2008, osteoporosis-related fracture hospitalizations were associated with a substantial economic burden in France.
PMS23
BURDEN OF ILLNESS OF OSTEOPOROSIS IN AUSTRIA
1
2
3
4
5
6
Dimai H , Redlich K , Viernstein H , Siebert U , Schneider H , Mahlich J
1
Med Uni Graz, Graz, Austria; 2Med Uni Wien, Vienna, Austria; 3Uni Wien, Vienna, Austria;
4
UMIT—Univ. of Health Sciences, Medical Informatics & Technology, Hall, Austria; 5IWI,
Vienna, Austria; 6Austrian Economic Chamber, Vienna, Austria
OBJECTIVES: On the basis of current international prevalence, it can be estimated
that approximately 740,000 of people in Austria over 50 years are affected by osteoporosis, of whom around 617,000 are women. With a fracture rate of 19.7 fractures
per year per 10,000 inhabitants over the age of 65 years, Austria lies within the peak
for Europe. Within the framework of a burden of illness study we examined the
financial burden of osteoporosis in Austria. METHODS: We took both direct and
indirect costs into consideration. Direct costs encompass medical costs such as
expenses for pharmaceuticals, inpatient and outpatient medical care costs, as well as
other medical services (e.g., occupational therapies). Non medical direct costs include
transportation costs and medical devices (e.g., wheel chairs or crutches). Indirect costs
refer to costs of productivity losses due to absence of work. Moreover, we included
costs for early retirement and opportunity costs of informal care provided by family
members. While there exist similar studies for other countries (e.g., Germany), this is
the first comprehensive study for Austria. For our analysis, we combined data of both,
official statistics, expert estimates as well as unique patient surveys that are currently
conducted in the course of an international osteoporotic fracture study in Austria.
RESULTS: Our estimation of the total annual costs in the year 2008 imposed by
osteoporosis in Austria is c470 million. The largest fraction of this amount is incurred
by acute hospital treatment. Another significant figure, accounting for 20% of total
costs, is the opportunity cost of informal care. CONCLUSIONS: The financial burden
of osteoporosis in Austria is substantial. Economic evaluations of preventive and
therapeutic interventions for the specific context of Austria are needed to inform health
policy decision makers.
PMS24
OSTEOPOROSIS COSTS IN ITALY. INTERIM RESULTS OF THE BLOCK
STUDY
Veronesi C1, Adami S2, Iolascon G3, Nardi A4, Pietrogrande L5, Resmini G6, Rossini M2,
Tarantino U7, Tranquilli Leali P8, Trevisan C9, Buda S1, Intorcia M10
1
CliCon S.r.l. Health, Economics & Outcomes Research, Ravenna, Italy; 2Rheumatology Unit,
Dpt Medicine, University of Verona, Verona, Italy; 3Dpt. Orthopedics and Rehabilitation ,
Second University of Naples, Naples, Italy; 4SOS Dpt Patologia Osteoarticolare, Azienda
Sanitaria ULSS 18, Rovigo, Italy; 5Università degli Studi Polo San Paolo, Milano, Italy; 6Centre
for the Study of Osteoporosis and Metabolic Bone Disease, Section of Orthopaedic and,
Treviglio (BG), Italy; 7Division of Orthopaedics and Traumatology, Tor Vergata Foundation
University Hospital, University of Rome Tor Vergata, Rome, Italy; 8Orthopaedic Clinic,
Sassari University, Sassari, Italy; 9UO di Ortopedia Ospedale di Lovere, AO Bolognini,
Lovere (BG), Italy; 10Amgen (Europe) GmbH, Zug, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: Calculate the cost of osteoporosis in postmenopausal women after a
fracture-related hospitalization for over a 24 months follow-up period. METHODS:
Retrospective analysis of databases of 8 Italian Local Health Units (4 million beneficiaries). We included female patients (≥65 years) hospitalized for a typical osteoporotic
fracture or osteoporosis between January 1, 2000 and December 31, 2005. Data were
collected on hospitalizations, visits, medication and diagnostic tests in the 24 months
after the first hospitalization. Over this period, treatment compliance measured as
Medical Possession Ratio was calculated according to the proportion of days covered
by osteoporosis-related drug treatments and classified as low (≤80%) and high
(>80%). Relative unit costs for resource use were collected from DGRS, National
Tariffs and Drugs National Formulary. RESULTS: A total of 10,158 patients were
included (average age ± SD, 79.0 ± 7.5 years) (overall cost was c70.5 million for the
first hospitalization). Of these, 98% (n = 9978) were hospitalized for a typical osteoporotic fracture and 180 (2%) for osteoporosis. Most were hip fractures (5189 (52%);
76% of total costs). During 24 months follow-up, 6654 patients (66%) had resource
utilization data (overall cost was c15.0 million; average cost per patient was c2254).
Among all 9978 women with fracture, 21% (n = 2119) had a subsequent hospitalization for fracture (66% were hip) and this accounted for 89% of the c15.0 million
(11% other, diagnostic tests). Only 15% (n = 1470) of all evaluated patients received
osteoporosis-related drug treatment within the six months following discharge and
bisphosphonates were prescribed to 92.6% of them. Among bisphosphonate-treated
patients, 33% (n = 459) and 66% (n = 921) displayed a high and low compliance
level, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: In this database analysis, costs of osteoporosis
after a first hospitalization for fracture were relevant and mostly due to re-hospitalization for a new typical osteoporotic fracture, mainly at the hip site. Exposure and
compliance to osteoporosis treatment were suboptimal in this patient population.
13th Euro Abstracts
PMS25
DIRECT MEDICAL COSTS OF OSTEOARTHRITIS IN SPAIN
Darba J1, Restovic G2, Kaskens L2
1
Universitat de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain; 2BCN Health, Barcelona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Osteoarthritis (OA) is the most common musculoskeletal disease, with
around 1.6 million patients in Spain. The aim of this study was to determine health
care resource utilization and direct medical costs of patients suffering OA of the hip,
knee and wrist in Spain in 2009. METHODS: A cost-of-illness analyses was performed
to estimate direct medical costs of patients suffering OA. Prevalence data on OA by
the Spanish Society of Rheumatology showed a value of 18% for the Spanish population. a semi-structured questionnaire was sent to rheumatologists to collect data on
health care resource utilization and costs. Inpatient costs were considered from the
perspective of the public health care system. Direct medical costs included were
ambulatory, diagnostic tests, physiotherapy, surgery, drug and administration costs.
All costs referred to 2009. RESULTS: Patients diagnosed with OA of the hip, knee
and wrist in Spain were estimated to be 1.6 million in 2009. Total medical costs for
the Health Care System resulted as following: drug use 95c million, health care personnel 251c million, diagnostic tests 20c million, physiotherapy 93c million, surgery 105c
million and adverse effects due to OA medication 25c million. Due to demographic
changes and increasing prevalence, the number of patients is estimated to grow to 1.7
million with total costs of 717c million in 2014. CONCLUSIONS: Direct medical
costs for OA were estimated at 598c million for Spanish patients in 2009. Health care
personnel represented 43% of the total direct medical costs. Aging of the population,
development of new drugs and increasing patient expectations are likely to increase
the future economic impact of OA, which remains a major public health burden.
PMS26
HIP FRACTURES IN THE ELDERLY: COST OF ILLNESS STUDY UNDER A
PUBLIC HOSPITAL PERSPECTIVE IN RIO DE JANEIRO, BRAZIL
Fernandes RA1, Takemoto ML2, Araujo D2, Sauberman MV3
1
Instituto Nacional de Ciência e Tecnologia para Avaliação de Tecnologias em Saúde (IATS),
Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil; 2State University of Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil;
3
Hospital Municipal Lourenço Jorge, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: To assess direct medical costs associated to hospital treatment of hip
fractures in the elderly in a public hospital in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil and their association
with demographic and clinical variables. METHODS: Observational, prospective study
to assess resource utilization and direct medical costs associated to elderly hip fracture
hospitalization in 2007 and 2008, under the health care provider perspective. a standard
data collection instrument was used to register identified resources during prospective
medical charts review. The resource utilization was converted into Brazilian Real (BRL),
based on 2010 prices. Descriptive analysis of costs and resource utilization and their
association with clinical and demographic variables were performed. RESULTS: Eighty
two patients were included, 81.7% female, mean age of 76.96 years, hospitalization
mean time of 12.66 days. Median total costs per patient were 3,064.76 BRL (IC95%:
2,817.63–3,463.98). Clinical hospitalization and surgical procedure were responsible
for 65.61% and 24.94% of costs, respectively. Median costs for patients submitted to
surgical procedure until the fourth day of hospitalization were lower than median costs
for patients submitted after the fourth day (2,136.45 BRL and 3,281.45 BRL, respectively, P < 0.00001). A significant difference in average costs per type of surgical procedure was also observed. Variables sex, age over 80 years, fracture site and presence
of cardiovascular disease were not associated with statistically significant differences in
total costs. CONCLUSIONS: Clinical hospitalization and surgical procedure were the
main cost components observed. Higher cost associated to inpatient treatment of hip
fractures in patients who performed surgery after the fourth day of hospitalization added
to available evidence about an increased risk of mortality after this period reinforce the
need of priority establishment to treat elderly patients with hip fracture.
PMS27
ANALYSIS OF DIRECT MEDICAL AND NON-MEDICAL COSTS FOR CARE
OF RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS PATIENTS USING LARGE COHORT
DATABASE, IORRA
Igarashi A1, Kikuta K1, Tanaka E2, Hoshi D2, Inoue E2, Seto Y2, Nakajima A2,
Momohara S2, Taniguchi A2, Yamanaka H2, Tsutani K1
1
Tokyo University Faculty of Pharmacy, Tokyo, Japan; 2Tokyo Women’s Medical University,
Tokyo, Japan
OBJECTIVES: To examine annual direct medical & non-medical cost in large-scale
rheumatoid arthritis (RA) patient cohort (IORRA) in Japan. METHODS: From
patients’ perspective, we calculated direct medical (out-of-pocket costs to hospital &
pharmacy and cost for complementary & alternative medicine(CAM)) and non-medical costs (caregiving, transportation,self help devises, house modification) of RA
patients, participants of the 15–17th IORRA Studies in Oct. 2007- Oct. 2008. We
also assessed correlations between these costs and RA diseaseactivity, disability level
and QOL. RESULTS: Data from 5204 RA patients were extracted. Annual direct
medical costs were JPY132,000 (out-of-pocket to hospital, USD1 = JPY90), JPY84,000
(out-of-pocket to pharmacy) and JPY 146,000 (CAM)), respectively. Annual direct
non-medical costs were JPY105,000 (caregiving), JPY22,000 (transportation),
JPY30,000 (self help devises) JPY188,000 (house modification), respectively. Considering utilization rates for each cost component (hospital/pharmacy: 100%, CAM:
31.6%, caregiving: 10.5%, transportation: 100%, self help devices: 21.4%, house
modification: 21.4%). We assumed that annual medical/non-medical cost per RA
patient was JPY264,000 and JPY61,000, respectively. These costs increased progres-
A307
sively with worsening RA diseaseactivity, disability level, or QOL. For example,
patients with lower Eq-5D score (less than 0.5) spent more money than those with
higher one (more than 0.8). Average medical and non-medical costs among them were
JPY 30,802 vs. JPY17,887 and JPY229,519 vs. JPY19,536, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Heavy economic burden lies in RApatients and grows heavier as the disease
state is exacerbated using IORRA database. The results also suggest that the increase
in medical/non-medical cost may be suppressed by proactively controlling RA.
PMS28
COST-EFFICACY ANALYSIS OF TNF ALPHA ANTAGONISTS IN THE
TREATMENT OF RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS
Dominguez Gil-Hurlé A1, Costi Ruiz M2, Campo Sien C2
1
Hospital Clínico Universitario de Salamanca, Salamanca, Castilla y León, Spain; 2Abbott
Laboratories, Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Estimate the efficiency of Tumor Necrosis Factor α (TNFα) antagonists
in moderate to severe rheumatoid arthritis (RA). METHODS: The analysis, performed
from the Spanish Health Care System perspective, considers the annual cost of the drugs,
and their efficacy, measured through the number needed to treat (NNT) to gain an
additional patient who achieves ACR20, ACR50 and ACR70 response. Drug costs were
obtained from a Spanish database. Data relative to efficacy was derived from a metaanalysis, which evaluated the anti–TNFα drugs adalimumab (ADA), etanercept (ETA),
and infliximab (INF). Efficiency was estimated in terms of incremental cost-efficacy
ratios (ICER). RESULTS: Annual treatment cost per patient-year with ADA, ETA and
INF is of 13.116c, 12.314c, and 14.047c, respectively. Applying the: 1) ACR20 criteria,
the NNT with ADA, ETA, and INF were 4.2 (95% CI, 3.4–5.3), 6.5 (5.2–8.8), and 4,
5(3.4–6.8), respectively; 2) the ACR50 criteria, the NNT with ADA, ETA, and INF were
4.1 (3.4–5.1), 4.4 (3.7–5.5), and 6.6 (4.7–11.5), respectively; and 3) the ACR70 criteria,
the NNT with ADA, ETA, and INF were 5.7 (4.6–7.5), 6.8 (5.3–9.4), and 8.6 (5.8–
16.7), respectively. The incremental annual cost per additional patient who achieves
ACR20 response with ADA, ETA, and INF is of c54.871 (95% CI, c45,080–70,095),
c80,598 (c64,288–c107.999), and c63,329 (c47,268c–c95,923), respectively. The
incremental annual cost per additional patient who achieves ACR50 response with
ADA, ETA, and INF is of c53,368 (c44,407–c66,828), c54,596 (c45,691–c67,813),
and c93,072 (c65,451–c161,030), respectively. The incremental annual cost per additional patient who achieves ACR70 response with ADA, ETA, and INF is of c74,537
(c59,759–c99,025), and c83,661 (c65,481–c115,815), c120,652 (c81,242–c34,319),
respectively. CONCLUSIONS: The incremental cost per patient who achieves an
ACR20, ACR50, and ACR70 response is lower with ADA, though quite similar to ETA,
being with both (ADA and ETA) lower than with INF, in the Spanish setting.
PMS29
RETROSPECTIVE CHART REVIEW TO ASSESS COSTS RELATED TO
OSTEOPOROTIC FRACTURES IN SLOVENIA AND SERBIA
Wladysiuk M1, Wilk D1, Jedynasty K2, Bumbasirevic M3, Kozlevcar Zivec M4
1
HTA Consulting, Krakow, Poland; 2Amgen GmbH, Headquarters Office for CEE, Vienna,
Austria; 3Institute of Orthopedic Surgery and Traumatology at Clinical Center Serbia,
Beograd, Serbia; 4Ambulanta za osteoporozo Medicus, Ljubljana, Slovenia
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate direct medical costs of treatment for osteoporotic fractures
in Slovenia and Serbia from a public payer and patient perspective directly after fracture
and up to 1 year follow-up. METHODS: A medical chart review, examining medical
resources used to treat the 3 most common osteoporotic fractures (proximal femur,
vertebral and distal radius) in the first year after the event. Collection of data from 1
osteoporotic center in Slovenia and 3 in Serbia was carried out by local investigators
between December 2009 and March 2010. The treatment costs for each fracture type
from the public payer and patient perspective were calculated. The analysis was divided
into 2 parts: intervention directly after the fracture (including cost of hospitalization,
ambulatory visits, procedures, examinations, and medications) and follow-up for up to
1 year after the event (including costs of hospitalization, outpatient visits, examinations,
rehabilitation, medications and devices). RESULTS: A total of 240 patients aged >50
years with low-trauma fractures occurring within 5 years before study initiation were
included. Average annual costs of treatment of a proximal femur fracture in Slovenia
were estimated at c4727 (costs directly after fracture = c4088 and follow-up period =
c639) and in Serbia c3002 (c2359 and c642, respectively). The cost of treatment of a
vertebral fracture was c4319 in Slovenia (c3762 and c557, respectively) and in Serbia
c390 (c103 and c287, respectively). Treatment of the distal radius fracture was c1567
in Slovenia (c1046 and c521, respectively) and in Serbia c163 (c57 and c106, respectively). CONCLUSIONS: Treatment of proximal femur fractures vs. vertebral and distal
radius fractures generated the highest costs. The treatment costs were significantly higher
in Slovenia compared with Serbia. Large disparities between the costs of hospitalization
in both countries were the major reason for the observed differences.
PMS30
MEDICINE TREATMENT COST OF RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS BEFORE
AND AFTER TREATMENT WITH BIOLOGICAL DRUGS
Roux I, Lubbe M, Burger JR, Lamprecht J
North-West University, Potchefstroom, South Africa
OBJECTIVES: To investigate the medicine treatment cost of rheumatoid arthritis (RA)
before and after treatment with biological drugs in the private health care sector of
South Africa. METHODS: A quantitative retrospective drug utilization review was
performed on medicine claims data of a pharmacy benefit management company
(PBM) in South Africa. Data for a four-year period (January 1, 2005 to December 31,
A308
2008) were used to determine the medicine treatment cost of 141 RA patients before
and after treatment with biological drugs (namely infliximab, adalimumab and etanercept). [RSA Rand (R)/$US = 6.38112 (2005); 6.78812 (2006); 7.06926 (2007) and
8.27505 (2008)]. RESULTS: Biological drugs represented 81.43% of the total medicine treatment cost of RA patients (n = R25,432,294.04). Other medication (excluding
biological drugs) prescribed to RA patients before starting with biological items represented 8.86% (n = R2 254 330.44) of their total medicine treatment cost; those
prescribed after treatment with biological drugs, represented 3.91% (n = R992,533.62).
The number of prescriptions for other medication (excl. biological drugs), decreased
from the period before to the period after treatment with biological drugs from 6271
to 2120. The average number of the other medicine items (excl. biological) per prescription decreased from 2.79 ± 2.30 before to 2.35 ± 1.86 after treatment with
biological drugs. The average cost per biological drug (R8 073.61 ± 2 210.46) was
practically significantly (d > 0.8) higher than the average cost of other medication
prescribed before (R128.45 ± 155.93) and after (R198.66 ± 888.31) treatment with
biological drugs. CONCLUSIONS: Although biological drugs used in the treatment
of RA are very expensive, it seems that the number of other medication prescribed to
RA patients, as well as the average number of items per prescription decreased after
treatment therewith. Further research is needed to investigate future medicine treatment cost of RA patients treated with biological drugs.
PMS31
THE IMPACT OF CHANGES IN ADALIMUMAB, ETANERCEPT, AND
INFLIXIMAB DOSES ON THE COSTS OF TREATING RHEUMATOID
ARTHRITIS
Lawson RW1, Heatley RM1, Johnson KI1, Khandker RK2, Singh A2
1
Complete Market Access, Macclesfield, UK; 2Pfizer, Collegeville, PA, USA
OBJECTIVES: To review and analyze evidence on the changes in dose of adalimumab,
etanercept and infliximab over time in adult patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA)
and the associated impact on treatment costs. METHODS: MEDLINE, EMBASE and
NHS-EED were systematically searched to identify English language randomised controlled trials, cohort studies and observational studies published between January
1993 and December 2009. Conference abstracts were also hand searched from
EULAR (2002 onwards) and ACR (2006 onwards). Studies were selected using predefined criteria, using two independent reviewers. Data pertaining to dose change were
then analyzed through pair-wise, random effects meta-analyses carried out in a frequentist framework with heterogeneity assessed using the I2 statistic. Associated cost
data were extracted and the impact of change in dose on cost was investigated.
RESULTS: Forty-five articles met the selection criteria with 23 containing dose change
data and 26 containing cost data. a significantly greater proportion of patients on
infliximab had a dose escalation compared to those on etanercept (odds ratio 0.17
95% CI 0.07, 0.43; P < 0.001) or adalimumab (odds ratio 0.25 95% CI 0.2, 0.3; P
< 0.001). On average, 43.3% of infliximab patients, 7.3% of etanercept patients and
10.9% of adalimumab patients had their dose increased. RA related costs were on
average 36% higher in patients who had their infliximab dose increased compared to
4% in patients on etanercept. No suitable data for adalimumab were available.
CONCLUSIONS: A significantly greater proportion of infliximab patients required
dose escalation compared to etanercept and adalimumab patients. There is some
evidence to suggest that the escalation in dose required to maintain clinical benefit,
results in substantially higher costs of treating RA.
PMS32
MICRO-COSTING ANALYSIS AND TARIFF COMPARISON: THE
INTERSPINOUS PROCESS DEVICE CASE
Beccagutti G1, Corbo M1, Pantaleoni M2, Surace MF3
1
Medtronic Italia, Sesto San Giovanni, Milan, Italy; 2IMS Health S.p.A, Milano, Italy; 3Ospedale
di Circolo—Fondazione Macchi, Varese, Italy
OBJECTIVES: In Italy the recent update of the DRG system has led to evaluate the
effect on the diffusion of new therapies. The Interspinous Process Device (IPD) implantation represents an innovative strategy for different degenerative spinal pathologies
with potential clinical and economic advantages. The aim of this study is to evaluate
the hospitalization costs for IPD procedure according to a micro-costing approach and
to compare it with current regional DRG tariffs. METHODS: The project, conducted
from the hospital perspective, is performed in one pilot centre (Varese hospital),
regional benchmark for this kind of procedure in which learning curve is considered
completed. The cost analysis is based on the clinical pathway drawn up from the
information provided by the medical team. Resource use including staff time, diagnostic tests, drugs, consumables and technology equipment utilization are collected
from interviews to the team. Operating room costs, administrative and general costs
and follow up hospital resource consumption are derived from hospital accounting
data. Unit costs are collected either from hospital accounting or regional tariffs for
specialist services. RESULTS: The total average cost estimated for a patient submitted
to an IPD implantation is c5644, with an average LOS of 2.7 days. The average cost
for the implantation of 1 IPD is c4515, value assigned to increase to c7087 for multilevel approaches with the implantation of 2 devices in the same procedure (42% of
cases). Excluding general costs and the number of IPDs implanted, the main key cost
driver are consumables and devices (62%), and operating room costs (16%). CONCLUSIONS: The regional tariff of the DRG related to this procedure (Lombardia
Region, DRG 500, version 24) does not cover the hospitalization costs estimated,
especially for the multilevel approaches. This leads to consider the effects of current
reimbursement on the adoption of innovative therapy.
13th Euro Abstracts
PMS33
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF TOCILIZUMAB FOR THE MANAGEMENT OF
PATIENTS WITH ACTIVE RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS DESPITE PREVIOUS
DMARD THERAPY IN MEXICO
Carlos F1, Aguirre A2, Peláez-Ballestas I3
1
R a C Salud Consultores S.A. de C.V., México City, D.F., Mexico; 2R a C Salud Consultores
S.A. de C.V., Mexico City, D.F., Mexico; 3Hospital General de México, Secretaría de Salud,
Mexico City, D.F., Mexico
OBJECTIVES: Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is a chronic, progressive, inflammatory
disease that affects physical functioning and quality-of-life and is associated with
premature mortality and substantial economic burden. We aimed to assess costeffectiveness of tocilizumab added to disease-modifying antirheumatic drugs
(DMARD) in patients with active RA despite DMARD therapy from the Mexican
public health care system perspective. METHODS: Two models were designed to
compare tocilizumab 8 mg/kg every 4 weeks; infliximab 3 mg/kg (weeks 0, 2, 6, 14
and 22); etanercept 25 mg twice a week and adalimumab 40 mg every other week.
First model included only 6-month acquisition costs of drugs and infusion-related cost
for infliximab and tocilizumab; the second was a Markov model with four states
defined according to Disease Activity Score (DAS-28). Indirect comparison techniques
were needed to adjust American College of Rheumatology (ACR) responses rates
found in 10 clinical trials with biological agents. ACR70 at week 24 and overall days
spent in remission during 5 years were main outcomes. Unit costs of medications were
gathered from public bids; an expert panel was constituted to estimate 3-month
resource use by health state. All costs are expressed in 2009 US dollars. RESULTS:
First six-month costs were lower with tocilizumab (USD$4418) than with etanercept
(USD$5,020), infliximab (USD$5484) and adalimumab (USD$5655). Adjusted
ACR70 response rate was higher for tocilizumab than for anti-tumor necrosis factor
(TNF) agents: 26% vs. 19%, 18% and 12% for adalimumab, etanercept and infliximab, respectively. Markov model estimates show savings of USD$623 up to
USD$1321 per patient treated with tocilizumab instead of anti-TNF. Tocilizumab was
also associated with mean gains of 9, 12 and 20 days in remission compared to
etanercept, adalimumab and infliximab. CONCLUSIONS: When used instead of antiTNF agents, add-on treatment with tocilizumab brings both health benefits and costsavings for RA patients with inadequate response to previous DMARD therapy.
PMS34
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF GOLIMUMAB IN PSORIATIC ARTHRITIS
FROM THE UK PAYER PERSPECTIVE
Cummins E1, Asseburg C2, Prasad M3, Buchanan J4, Punekar Y5
1
McMaster Development Consultants Ltd., Glasgow, UK; 2ESiOR Ltd, Kuopio, Finland;
3
Merck & Co, Kenilworth, NJ, USA; 4Johnson & Johnson Pharmaceutical Services, LLC,
Malvern, PA, USA; 5Schering Plough, Welwyn Garden City, UK
BACKGROUND: Golimumab is a novel TNF-α inhibitor licensed to treat patients with
active PsA. Although its clinical efficacy has been proven in clinical trials, its costeffectiveness is yet to be established. OBJECTIVES: To estimate the cost-effectiveness
of golimumab among patients with active PsA from the UK NHS perspective.
METHODS: A decision analytic model was used to simulate progression of a hypothetical cohort of active PsA patients on golimumab and other TNF-α inhibitors as well as
palliative care. The clinical evidence was derived from clinical trials of TNF-α inhibitors
and compared using mixed treatment models. The primary outcome measure was
quality adjusted life-years (QALYs) estimated based on change in Health Assessment
Questionnaire (HAQ) and Psoriasis Area Severity Index (PASI) from baseline. The
annual acquisition cost of golimumab was assumed to be identical to annual cost of
other subcutaneous TNF-α inhibitors. The resource use costs and outcomes were discounted at 3.5% over a period of 40 years. The uncertainty surrounding important
variables was further explored using probabilistic sensitivity analyses (PSA). RESULTS:
TNF-α inhibitors were significantly superior to palliative care but comparable to each
other on Psoriatic Arthritis Response Criteria (PsARC), HAQ and PASI response. The
incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICERs) for golimumab compared to palliative care
was £16,811 for PsA patients and £16,245 for a subgroup of PsA patients with significant psoriasis. At an acceptability threshold of £30,000 per QALY, the probability of
golimumab being cost-effective is 89%. CONCLUSIONS: Once monthly, golimumab
is a cost-effective treatment alternative for patients with active PsA. With its patient
focussed attributes, golimumab is likely to offer additional choice in PsA treatment.
PMS35
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF TERIPARATIDE IN PATIENTS WITH
GLUCOCORTICOID-INDUCED OSTEOPOROSIS IN SWEDEN
Smolen LJ1, Gregor Z2, Barrett A3, Myrén KJ4, Toll A5
1
Medical Decision Modeling Inc., Indianapolis, IN, USA; 2Eli Lilly & Company, Prague, Czech
Republic; 3Eli Lilly & Company Ltd, Windlesham, Surrey, UK; 4Eli Lilly & Company,
Windlesham, UK; 5Eli Lilly Sweden AB, Solna, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: Glucocorticoid induced osteoporosis is the most common cause of
secondary osteoporosis. The objective of this study was to estimate the cost-effectiveness of teriparatide in patients with Glucocorticoid induced osteoporosis in Sweden.
METHODS: A cost-effectiveness analysis was developed to evaluate the direct medical
and tertiary care costs and clinical outcomes of an 18-month regimen of daily teriparatide in patients with glucocorticoid induced osteoporosis (GIO). a Monte Carlo
simulation was used to model the cost and effects of a simulated cohort of 100,000
patients with GIO treated with teriparatide compared to no teriparatide treatment.
The model simulated the course of events in 6-month cycles in individual patients over
a lifetime horizon. During each cycle the patients were at risk of experiencing clinical
13th Euro Abstracts
vertebral, hip and wrist fracture or death (either natural or excess mortality due to
fracture). Swedish data on fracture costs, utility reductions after fracture, fracture risks
and mortality rates were used. Uncertainty was investigated using one-way and probabilistic sensitivity analyses. Costs and utilities were discounted at annual discount rates
of 3%. RESULTS: The analyzed cohort comprised patients aged 69 years (80%
female) with a BMD T-Score of −2.5 SD and an historical vertebral fracture (5 years
previous) and an incident vertebral fracture. In the base-case analysis of this cohort
the costs in the teriparatide treatment group were 558,918 SEK per patient compared
to 552,026 SEK in the no teriparatide group. The cost per QALY gained of teriparatide
compared to no teriparatide was estimated to be SEK 25,000. The results were robust
under a wide range of assumptions. CONCLUSIONS: For the analyzed cohorts, the
base-case and one-way sensitivity analyses performed indicate that an 18-month
teriparatide regimen versus no treatment in patients with glucocorticoid induced
osteoporosis is cost-effective from the perspective of the Swedish payer.
PMS36
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF TOCILIZUMAB FOR THE MANAGEMENT OF
PATIENTS WITH ACTIVE RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS DESPITE PREVIOUS
DMARD THERAPY IN COSTA RICA
Carlos F
R a C Salud Consultores S.A. de C.V., México, D.F., Mexico
OBJECTIVES: Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is a chronic, progressive, inflammatory
disease that affects physical functioning and quality-of-life and is associated with
premature mortality and substantial economic burden. We aimed to assess the costeffectiveness of tocilizumab added to disease-modifying antirheumatic drugs
(DMARD) in patients with active RA despite DMARD therapy from the perspective
of public health care system in Costa Rica. METHODS: A decision analysis was
carried out to compare tocilizumab 8 mg/kg given every 4 weeks; infliximab 3 mg/kg
(weeks 0, 2, 6, 14) and 5 mg/kg (every 8 weeks from week 22); etanercept 25 mg
given twice a week and adalimumab 40 mg given every other week. The model
included acquisition costs of biological agents during first year of treatment besides
infusion-related costs for infliximab and tocilizumab. Indirect comparison techniques
were needed to adjust American College of Rheumatology (ACR) responses rates
found in 10 placebo-controlled clinical trials with biological agents used as add-on
therapy to DMARD. ACR70 response rate, which can be regarded as a close measure
of remission, was selected as primary efficacy outcome. Unitary costs were gathered
from the 2010 Official Price List of the Public Health Care System in Costa Rica. All
costs are expressed in 2010 US dollars. RESULTS: First-year costs for an average
70 kg weight patient were lower with tocilizumab (US$12,272) than with etanercept
(US$13,000), adalimumab (US$13,650) and infliximab (US$14,340). Adjusted
ACR70 response rate was higher for tocilizumab (26%) than for adalimumab (19%),
etanercept (18%) and infliximab (12%). Incremental cost per patient achieving an
ACR70 response with tocilizumab instead of anti-tumor necrosis factor (TNF) agents
were estimated at −US$9,100, −US$14,771 and −US$19,686 for etanercept, adalimumab and infliximab, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: When used instead of anti-TNF
agents, add-on treatment with tocilizumab brings both health benefits and cost-savings
for RA patients with inadequate response to previous DMARD therapy.
PMS37
THE COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF ABATACEPT IN COMBINATION WITH
METHOTREXATE FOR THE TREATMENT OF PATIENT WITH ACTIVE
RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS AFTER AN INADEQUATE RESPONSE TO
METHOTREXATE IN THE UNITED KINGDOM
Lebmeier M1, Pericleous L1, Drost P2, Dequen P3, Ouwens M4, Bergman G5, Baig H1
1
Bristol-Myers Squibb Pharmaceuticals Ltd, Uxbridge, Middlesex, UK; 2Bristol-Myers Squibb,
Braine-l’Alleud, Belgium; 3Mapi Values, Bollington, Cheshire, UK; 4Mapi Values, Houten, The
Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: Abatacept in combination with MTX has recently been granted a
positive opinion from the European Medicines Agency for use for the treatment of
moderate to severe active rheumatoid arthritis in adult patients who responded inadequately to previous therapy with one or more conventional disease-modifying antirheumatic drugs (cDMARDs) including methotrexate (MTX). This analysis explores
the cost-effectiveness of abatacept in this new indication. METHODS: A patientsimulation treatment-sequence economic model was constructed to estimate the incremental cost per quality adjusted life-year (QALY) for patients with RA in the United
Kingdom. Abatacept with MTX , followed by a sequence of DMARDs was compared
against a sequence of cDMARDs. Treatment-specific efficacy in terms of Health
Assessment Questionnaire (HAQ) was used to calculate the patient’s utility medical
resource use and cost over a lifetime. Mortality was HAQ dependent. The analysis is
performed from a National Health Service. Costs and outcomes were discounted at
3.5% each. RESULTS: Abatacept with MTX was estimated to yield 1.09 QALYs per
patient (6.42 vs. 5.33) over lifetime, compared to DMARDs. The total lifetime costs
associated with abatacept with MTX were £110,094 and total costs for cDMARDs
were £79,933 resulting in an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of £27,657
per QALY gained. Sensitivity analysis confirmed the robustness of the model findings.
CONCLUSIONS: This study has demonstrated that abatacept with MTX is a costeffective treatment option compared to cDMARDs for patients with rheumatoid
arthritis after an inadequate response to MTX.
A309
PMS38
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF RITUXIMAB VERSUS ALTERNATIVE
ANTI-TUMOR NECROSIS FACTOR (TNF) THERAPY AFTER PREVIOUS
FAILURE OF ONE ANTI-TNF AGENT FOR TREATMENT OF
RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS IN MEXICO
Carlos F
R a C Salud Consultores S.A. de C.V., México City, D.F., Mexico
OBJECTIVES: About 30% of patients treated with an anti-TNF agent failed to
achieve an improvement of 20% in American College of Rheumatology (ACR)
response. Recent clinical practice guidelines recommend the use of rituximab after
previous failure of one anti-TNF. This study aims to assess the cost-effectiveness of
rituximab compared to cycling between anti-TNF agents in this population from the
perspective of the public health care system in Mexico. METHODS: A decision analysis was carried out to compare 2 rituximab courses (1 course, consisting of 2 infusions
of 1 g each) given 6 months apart; infliximab 3 mg/kg (weeks 0, 2, 6, 14) and 5 mg/
kg (weeks 22, 30, 38 and 46); etanercept 25 mg twice a week and adalimumab 40 mg
every other week. Only direct medical costs cumulated during a one-year timeframe
were accounted for and these included acquisition cost of biologic drugs besides infusion costs for rituximab and infliximab. Primary efficacy outcome was defined as an
improvement of 70% in ACR response (ACR70), which is a close measure of remission. Indirect comparison techniques were used to adjust ACR responses rates found
in 9 clinical trials. Number needed to treat (NNT) to obtain an ACR70 was then
calculated. All costs are reported in 2009 US dollars (USD). RESULTS: For a 70 Kg
patient, annual mean costs were estimated at USD$13,025 for rituximab, USD$12,938
for infliximab, USD$12,226 for adalimumab and USD$10,850 for etanercept.
Adjusted ACR70 rates were higher in rituximab (12.4%) than in adalimumab (9.0%),
etanercept (8.2%) and infliximab (5.4%). Average cost to achieve an ACR70 was
lower with rituximab (USD$105,047) than with anti-TNF therapies, leading to savings
of USD$27,270; USD$30,797 and USD$134,543 compared to etanercept, adalimumab and infliximab, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: This study suggests that rituximab treatment after previous failure of one anti-TNF agent is a cost-effective strategy
compared to cycling between anti-TNF agents.
PMS39
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF RITUXIMAB VERSUS ALTERNATIVE
ANTI-TUMOR NECROSIS FACTOR (TNF) THERAPY AFTER PREVIOUS
FAILURE OF ONE ANTI-TNF AGENT FOR TREATMENT OF
RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS IN COSTA RICA
Carlos F
R a C Salud Consultores S.A. de C.V., México City, D.F., Mexico
OBJECTIVES: About 30% of patients treated with an anti-TNF agent failed to
achieve an improvement of 20% in American College of Rheumatology (ACR)
response. Recent clinical practice guidelines recommend the use of rituximab after
previous failure of one anti-TNF. This study aims to assess the cost-effectiveness of
rituximab compared to cycling between anti-TNF agents in this population from the
perspective of public health care system in Costa Rica. METHODS: A decision analysis was carried out to compare 2 rituximab courses (1 course, consisting of 2 infusions
of 1 g each) given 6 months apart; infliximab 3 mg/kg (weeks 0, 2, 6, 14) and 5 mg/
kg (weeks 22, 30, 38 and 46); etanercept 25 mg twice a week and adalimumab 40 mg
every other week. Only direct medical costs cumulated during a one-year timeframe
were accounted for and these included acquisition cost of biologic drugs besides infusion costs for rituximab and infliximab. Primary efficacy outcome was defined as an
improvement of 70% in ACR response (ACR70), which is a close measure of remission. Indirect comparison techniques were used to adjust ACR responses rates found
in 9 clinical trials. Number needed to treat (NNT) to obtain an ACR70 was then
calculated. All costs are reported in 2009 US dollars (USD). RESULTS: For a 70 Kg
patient, annual mean costs were estimated at US$15,040 for rituximab, US$14,340
for infliximab, US$13,650 for adalimumab, and US$13,000 for etanercept. Adjusted
ACR70 rates were higher in rituximab (12.4%) than in adalimumab (9.0%), etanercept (8.2%) and infliximab (5.4%). Average cost to achieve an ACR70 was lower
with rituximab (US$121,290) than with anti-TNF therapies, leading to savings of
US$30,377; US$37,247; and US$144,266 compared to etanercept, adalimumab and
infliximab, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: This study suggests that rituximab treatment after previous failure of one anti-TNF agent is a cost-effective strategy compared
to cycling between anti-TNF agents.
PMS40
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF DENOSUMAB COMPARED WITH GENERIC
ALENDRONATE IN THE TREATMENT OF POSTMENOPAUSAL
OSTEOPOROTIC WOMEN
Hiligsmann M, Reginster JY
University of Liège, Liège, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: Denosumab represents a new therapeutic opportunity for the treatment
of osteoporosis, that received a positive opinion from the European Committee for
Medical Products for Human Use in December 2009. This study aims to evaluate the
cost-effectiveness of denosumab compared with the most relevant alternative (i.e.
generic alendronate) in the treatment of postmenopausal osteoporotic women.
METHODS: The cost-effectiveness of treatment for 3-years with denosumab was
compared with generic alendronate using an updated version of a previously validated
Markov microsimulation model (Value Health 2009:12:687–96). The model was
A310
populated with relevant cost, adherence and epidemiological data for Belgium from a
health care perspective and the results were presented in cost (c2009) per qualityadjusted life-year (QALY) gained. Analyses were performed in populations (over 60
years) where osteoporosis medications are currently reimbursed in many European
countries, i.e. bone mineral density T-score is below or equal to −2.5 or presence of
prevalent vertebral fracture. Univariate and probabilistic sensitivity analyses were
conducted to assess the robustness of the results. RESULTS: The cost-effectiveness of
denosumab compared with generic alendronate was estimated at c38,875, c20,690
and c26,153 per QALY for women with T-score ≤−2.5 aged 60, 70 and 80 years,
respectively. The equivalent values were c37,856, c18,764 and c17,309 per QALY
for women with prevalent vertebral fractures. Discount rates, fracture risk and
patient’s adherence to generic alendronate were found to be particularly sensitive when
varied within the model. At 70 years of age, probabilistic sensitivity analyses showed
that the probability of the ICERs remaining below c40,000 is 84% in women with
prevalent vertebral fracture and 74% in those with T-score ≤−2.5, confirming the
cost-effectiveness of denosumab. CONCLUSIONS: This study suggests that denosumab is a cost-effective strategy (cost per QALY gained ≤c40,000) compared with
generic alendronate for the treatment of postmenopausal Belgian osteoporotic women,
aged 60 years and above.
PMS41
THE IMPACT OF MEDICATION ADHERENCE ON THE COST OF
OSTEOPOROSIS FRACTURES IN GERMANY: A MODELLING APPROACH
Stephens JM1, Brotherton SA1, Gitlin MD2, Steinle T3, Leidl R4, Kochevar JJ1
1
Kochevar Research Associates, Charlestown, MA, USA; 2Amgen (Europe) GmbH, Zug,
Switzerland; 3Amgen (Europe) GmbH, München, Germany; 4Ludwig Maximilian University,
Munich, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Current osteoporosis therapies can reduce the risk of fractures and
thus costs, but adherence to these medications is often poor. We estimated yearly
potential savings in fracture-related costs from improved adherence to osteoporosis
therapies in Germany from a societal perspective. METHODS: The model was a
deterministic cohort model estimating annual treatments and outcomes for German
women aged ≥50 years old in 2010 (n = 17,689,849), by f5 year cohorts. Demographic
parameters were drawn from government databases, medication prescription share
from industry databases, fracture incidence (hip, clinical vertebral, and non-hip, non
vertebral (NHNV)), medication adherence (medication possession ratio MPR, one
year intervals) and efficacy from published literature. As a base case we estimated
4.2% treated (n = 745,313) with oral bisphosphonates (94.6%), strontium (2.7%)
and raloxifene (2.6%); 54% with effective adherence (MPR > 50%). Fracture related
costs (excluding medication costs) included direct medical, long-term nursing care,
and work loss. The model parameters are adjustable, allowing real time calculation
of outcomes. We estimated current costs with 54% effectively adherent and 100%
effectively adherent. RESULTS: The model calculated total fracture-related costs for
all patients in 2010 at c4.4 billion (with 69.6% for direct medical costs, 20.2% for
long-term nursing care, and 10.2% for work loss). For the estimated 4.2% of treated
patients, the model calculated total fracture-related costs at c184.9 million. Increasing
the percentage of patients with effective adherence from 54% to 100% decreased costs
for hip (16.2%), vertebral (24.4%) and NHNV fractures (6.3%). CONCLUSIONS:
Adjustable parameters allow users to calculate yearly fracture-related costs and savings
for different economic perspectives and decision options. According to one run using
the above parameters, achieving full adherence to medication among women currently
treated for osteoporosis in Germany would reduce fractures, and cut down annual
fracture related costs by c27.8 million (15.1%).
PMS42
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF CERTOLIZUMAB PEGOL PLUS
METHOTREXATE OR AS MONOTHERAPY FOR THE TREATMENT OF
ACTIVE RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS IN THE UNITED KINGDOM
Purcaru O1, Taylor PC2, Emery P3, Palmer S4
1
UCB, Brussels, Belgium; 2Imperial College London, London, UK; 3University of Leeds, Leeds,
UK; 4University of York, York, UK
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of certolizumab pegol (CZP) either
as an add-on therapy to methotrexate (MTX) or as monotherapy versus other biological DMARDs, in the treatment of patients with active RA who did not respond
adequately to DMARDs, including MTX, in the United Kingdom (UK). METHODS:
A cost-utility model with a Markov structure was developed following BSR and NICE
guidelines. Comparators considered in the analysis were licensed and recommended
TNF-α inhibitors in England and Wales (etanercept [ETA], adalimumab [ADA] and
infliximab [IFX]), + MTX or as monotherapy (ETA and ADA only). Clinical efficacy,
history and resource use data came from published literature. Unit costs were taken
from routine sources/published references. Utilities were derived from EQ-5D data
collected in CZP RA clinical trials. Cost for CZP assumed the first 12 weeks free of
charge, as per the patient access scheme. Base-case analysis was conducted from the
NHS perspective, with lifetime horizon, costs and outcomes discounting rates of 3.5%.
Sensitivity analyses were conducted. RESULTS: Base-case analysis indicated that CZP
is cost-effective compared with all combination and monotherapies considered.
CZP+MTX dominated the comparators considered. CZP+MTX was associated with an
incremental gain in quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs) of 0.242, 0.065 and 0.458 when
compared with ADA+MTX, ETA+MTX and IFX+MTX, respectively. Total costs for
CZP+MTX were lower than comparator combination therapies by £451, £582 and
£10,016, respectively. CZP+MTX had the highest probability of being cost-effective of
13th Euro Abstracts
the TNF inhibitor + MTX therapies considered (at £20,000/QALY, 53.6% for
CZP+MTX, 25% for ETA+MTX, 21.2% for ADA+MTX, 0.2% for IFX+MTX).
Among monotherapies, CZP dominated ADA (QALY incremental gain: 0.215, total
costs lower by £2,352 vs. ADA). CZP was cost-effective below a willing-to-pay threshold
of £31,582/QALYs vs. ETA. CONCLUSIONS: This analysis indicates that CZP is a
cost-effective treatment for RA in the UK.
PMS43
COST-UTILITY AND MULTINOMIAL EXPECTED VALUE OF PERFECT
INFORMATION OF SEQUENCED TREATMENT WITH BIOLOGICS IN
MODERATE-TO-SEVERE RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS: ANALYSIS BASED
ON CLINICALLY MEANINGFUL RESPONSES
Soini EJ1, Hallinen T1, Kauppi MJ2, Vihervaara V3, Puolakka K4
1
ESiOR Ltd, Kuopio, Finland; 2Päijät-Häme Central Hospital, Lahti, Finland; 3Roche Oy, Espoo,
Finland; 4Lappeenranta Central Hospital, Lappeenranta, Finland
OBJECTIVES: To assess the cost-utility and multinomial expected value of perfect
information (mEVPI) of sequenced treatment with biologics in moderate-to-severe
rheumatoid arthritis (msRA) after failure of traditional disease modifying antirheumatic drug(s) (tDMARD). METHODS: A probabilistic, individual sampling (microsimulation) model was developed to compare ten different treatment sequences
among 3,000 hypothetical Finnish msRA patients in a lifetime scenario.
Adalimumab+methotrexate (MTX), etanercept+MTX or tocilizumab+MTX were
used as first biologics followed by up to three other biologics. Best supportive care
including tDMARDs was assumed to be used after exhaustion of treatment options
with biologics. Treatment with MTX alone was added as further comparator. The
clinical outcomes (no ACR50, ACR50 and ACR70 responses conditional to the use
of biologic drugs) were obtained from a recently published mixed treatment comparison and quality-adjusted life-years (QALY) were estimated based on disease severity
scores (HAQ) using a nonlinear equation: EQ5D = 0.82-0.11*HAQ-0.07*HAQ2.
Resource use was estimated from published references and valued with Finnish unit
costs (year 2009). Analyses were performed from payer perspective (productivity losses
were excluded) using 3% annual discount rate. RESULTS: Compared to MTX alone,
treatment with tocilizumab+MTX was more cost-effective than treatment with
etanercept+MTX. Both tocilizumab+MTX and etanercept+MTX dominated
adalimumab+MTX. An additional QALY gained with tocilizumab+MTX costs
c15,478 (mEVPI c1,258/patient) compared with MTX alone. An additional QALY
gained with tocilizumab+MTX followed by etanercept+MTX costs c35,543 (mEVPI
c748/patient) compared with tocilizumab+MTX. According to cost-effectiveness
acceptability frontier, only MTX alone, tocilizumab+MTX or tocilizumab+MTX followed by etanercept+MTX should be considered, if willingness to pay is c0–50,000
per QALY gained. With c30,000 per QALY gained, tocilizumab+MTX had 97.6%
probability of being cost-effective. The results were relatively robust in sensitivity
analyses. CONCLUSIONS: After tDMARD failure, tocilizumab+MTX or
tocilizumab+MTX followed by etanercept+MTX were the most cost-effective biologics for patients with msRA. mEVPI indicated that the value of additional research
information is low.
PMS44
IMPACT OF OBESITY IN WORKING ADULTS WITH ARTHRITIS IN
TERMS OF MEDICAL AND PRDUCTIVITY COSTS
Suh DC1, Kwon JW2, Kim CM3, Choi IS2, McGuire M2, Barone J2
1
School of Pharmacy, Rutgers University, Piscataway, NJ, USA; 2Rutgers University,
Piscataway, NJ, USA; 3Catholic University School of Medicine, Seoul, South Korea
OBJECTIVES: To measure the impact of obesity on annual medical and productivity
costs among working U.S. adults with arthritis. METHODS: We conducted a cross
sectional study using Medical Expenditure Panel Survey data from 2003–2007.
Working adults with arthritis (18–64 years old) were selected if they did not have
pregnancy, malignancy, kidney dialysis, immunodeficiency, low body mass index (BMI
< 18.5 kg/m2), or unemployed status. Patients with arthritis were identified by ICD-9
codes of 714–715 or via patient self-report. Obese and normal- weight were defined
as BMI of ≥30 kg/m2 or BMI of 18.5–<25 kg/m2, respectively. Loss of productivity
was estimated by loss of workdays due to illness or injury and standard hourly wage
by occupation. Medical costs were estimated using a generalized linear model with a
log link function and gamma distribution. Costs of productivity loss were calculated
using a two-part model to adjust for patients with zero costs. Using Oaxaca decomposition, differences in treatment costs between obese and normal-weight patients
were decomposed into two parts: a) differences in characteristics (endowments) across
groups, and b) differences between obese and normal parameters (coefficients). Costs
attributable to obesity were defined as the costs by coefficients component. All costs
were converted to 2009 U.S. dollars using price indices. RESULTS: Among the 7345
working adults with arthritis, prevalence of obesity and normal-weight was 24.8%
vs. 40.7%, respectively. The difference in medical costs between the groups was
US$2380 (95% CI: US$1934–2825) due to endowments and US$379 (95% CI:
US$367–392) due to coefficient components. Productivity loss costs in the obese
patients were higher, at US$46(95% CI: US$ 41–51) due to endowments and
US$441(95%CI: US$435–447) due to coefficient components. CONCLUSIONS: Use
of the Oaxaca decomposition method suggested that the economic burden, particularly productivity loss costs, of obesity in patients with arthritis was substantial,
adjusting for characteristics across groups.
13th Euro Abstracts
PMS45
PRODUCTIVITY COSTS IN PATIENTS WITH RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS
IN SOUTH KOREA
Kwon JM, Lee EK
SookMyung Women’s University, Seoul, South Korea
OBJECTIVES: The objectives of this study are to examine socio-demographic and
clinical characteristics of patients with rheumatoid arthritis(RA) and to estimate
productivity costs related to RA using data from the Fourth Korea National Health
and Nutrition Examination Survey conducted in 2007(KNHANES IV-1) and
2008(KNHANES IV-2). METHODS: A total of 7559 adults of working age(19 ≤ age
<65) were available for analyses, including 99 individuals with RA. Socio-demographic and clinical characteristics of subjects with RA were compared with those of
subjects without RA. Multiple logistic regression was used to estimate adjusted
employment rates of RA population. Percentage of work disability due to RA was
estimated using the difference between employment rates of general population
without RA and the adjusted employment rates of RA population. All statistical
analyses were performed with SURVEY procedure of SAS/STAT® 9.1. RESULTS: The
mean age of patients with RA was 50.2 years and 73.0% of them were female. Individuals with RA were older and had lower rates of subjective health awareness, higher
rates of activity limitation and lower employment rates than individuals without RA.
The percentage of sick leave due to RA was 2.5%. According to the results of multiple
logistic regression, subjects with RA were less likely to be employed than subjects
without RA (OR 0.63, 95% CI 0.41–0.97). The estimated percentage of work disability due to RA was 11.1%. By using the human capital approach, per capita productivity costs due to work disability were estimated to 3.6 million won($3594) per
year. CONCLUSIONS: In South Korea, the percentages of work disability and sick
leave for RA patients were lower than those reported in previous studies. Although
other aspects of productivity costs related to RA could not be analyzed, this study
could provide several important results concerning productivity costs in patients with
RA.
MUSCULAR-SKELETAL DISORDERS – Patient-Reported Outcomes Studies
PMS46
DOSING PROFILE COMPARISON BETWEEN PATIENTS WITH
FIBROMYALGIA INITIATING DULOXETINE AND PREGABALIN IN 2007:
A LARGE NATIONAL RETROSPECTIVE COHORT STUDY
Sun P1, Zhao Y2, Wu A3, Sun S4
1
Kailo Research Group, Indianapolis, IN, USA; 2Eli Lilly & Company, Indianapolis, IN, USA;
3
Kailo Research Group, Los Angeles, CA, USA; 4Kailo Research Group, Fremont, CA, USA
OBJECTIVES: To compare dosing profiles between duloxetine and pregabalin among
patients with fibromyalgia. METHODS: A retrospective cohort study was conducted
on a large U.S. administrative claims database to examine commercially insured
individuals aged 18 to 64 who had fibromyalgia and initiated (a 90-day clean period
before initiation) duloxetine or pregabalin in 2007. Continuous enrollment in the 12
months pre- and post-index periods and at least 30-day supply of duloxetine or pregabalin over the 1-year follow-up were required for all selected patients. Average daily
doses of all duloxetine or pregabalin prescriptions per person, average daily dose and
average daily costs in each of the first 12 prescriptions, percent of patients with
increased or decreased dose, and percent of daily dose change from previous prescription were compared between duloxetine and pregabalin cohorts. RESULTS: Both the
duloxetine (n = 1699) and pregabalin (n = 2560) cohorts had a mean age of 51~52
years. Duloxetine-treated patients had an average initial daily dose of 55.6 mg versus
159.8 mg for the pregabalin-treated patients. The average daily dose per patient was
55.7 mg for duloxetine and 195.4 mg for pregabalin. The average duloxetine daily
doses and daily costs ranged from 55.0 mg–60.2 mg and $3.9-$5.0 for the first 12
prescriptions and 159.8 mg–265.7 mg and $4.4–$5.0 for pregabalin. The percentages
of daily-dose changes from previous prescription were −5.4%~3.0% for duloxetine
and −1.0%~16.6% for pregabalin. Over the 1-year follow-up, both the percentages
of patients with a dose increase (17.3% for duloxetine vs. 51.8% for pregabalin, P <
0.01) and a dose decrease (24.8% for duloxetine vs. 10.0% for pregabalin P < 0.01)
were statistically different between cohorts. CONCLUSIONS: Among patients with
fibromyalgia, duloxetine and pregabalin initiators had very different dosing profiles.
The average daily dose for duloxetine was relatively stable over time, while pregabalintreated patients had significant dose escalation over the 12-month follow-up period.
PMS47
COMPARISON OF DOSING PATTERNS BETWEEN FIBROMYALGIA
PATIENTS WITH HIGH VERSUS LOW DULOXETINE OR PREGABALIN
COMPLIANCE
Zhao Y1, Sun P2, Sun S3, Wu A4
1
Eli Lilly & Company, Indianapolis, IN, USA; 2Kailo Research Group, Indianapolis, IN, USA;
3
Kailo Research Group, Fremont, CA, USA; 4Kailo Research Group, Los Angeles, CA, USA
OBJECTIVES: To compare dosing patterns between patients with fibromyalgia who
had high versus low duloxetine or pregabalin compliance, respectively. METHODS:
Using a large U.S. administrative claims database, commercially insured patients aged
18–64 who had fibromyalgia and initiated duloxetine or pregabalin in 2007 were
examined. Medication compliance was measured via medication possession ratio
(MPR), with MPR¡Ý (<) 0.8 as high (low) compliance. All patients selected had
A311
continuous enrollment in the 12-month pre- and post-index periods, at least 30 days¡−
supply of duloxetine or pregabalin in the 12-month post-index period, and were
classified into 4 mutually exclusive cohorts based on their initiation agents (duloxetine
vs. pregabalin) and compliance levels (high vs. low). Average daily doses of the first
8 prescriptions and duration between the initial dose and the first increased dose were
compared across cohorts. RESULTS: Compared to the low compliance patients,
patients with high compliance had significantly higher initial (duloxetine [N = 804 vs.
895]: 56.0 mg vs. 55.2 mg; pregablin [N = 710 vs. 1,850]: 164.9 mg vs. 157.9 mg)
and average (duloxetine: 57.0 mg vs. 54.6 mg; pregabalin: 216.8 mg vs. 187.1 mg)
daily doses (all P < .05). The average daily doses for the first 8 prescriptions ranged
from 55.0 mg–58.3 mg and 56.0 mg–60.6 mg for duloxetine high and low compliance patients, respectively, while the pregabalin-treated patients had 157.9 mg–238.8 mg
and 164.9 mg–248.3 mg, correspondingly. The duration from the initial dose to the
first dose increase was 263.5 vs. 161.1 days (P < .05) for the duloxetine high versus
low compliance patients and 268 vs. 135.4 days for the pregabalin high versus low
compliance patients, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Among patients with fibromyalgia, duloxetine and pregabalin initiators had different dosing patterns by compliance
levels. Both duloxetine- and pregabalin-treated patients with high compliance had
higher initial and average daily doses than those with low compliance. The average
daily dose remained stable over time for duloxetine, however, increased for pregabalin
for both compliance groups.
PMS48
PSYCHOMETRIC PROPERTIES OF THE GREEK MODIFIED HEALTH
ASSESSMENT QUESTIONNAIRE FOR ASSESSING PHYSICAL DISABILITY
IN RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS
Kontodimopoulos N1, Bozios P2, Raftakis I2, Elmatzoglou I2, Yfantopoulos J3, Niakas D1
1
Hellenic Open University, Patras, Greece; 2Asklipieio Voulas General Hospital, Voula,
Greece; 3National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, Athens, Greece
OBJECTIVES: To test basic psychometric properties (validity, reliability and responsiveness) of the Greek version of the Modified Stanford Health Assessment Questionnaire (MHAQ) for assessment of physical disability in rheumatoid arthritis (RA).
METHODS: The sample consisted of 120 RA patients (60.0% female, mean age 59.0)
starting on biological antirheumatic drugs. Outcome measures were the MHAQ, the
Disease Activity Score (DAS28) and the EQ-5D completed at baseline and at 3 months
post-intervention. Item response frequencies and ceiling/floor effects were examined.
Internal consistency reliability was assessed with Cronbach’s alpha. Construct validity
was examined by correlating baseline item and total scores of the MHAQ, with the
EQ-5D and DAS28. MHAQ items were also tested for their correlation with the
principal component. Effect sizes between MHAQ baseline and three-month data were
compared to respective values for the other outcomes for evidence of responsiveness.
RESULTS: Floor and ceiling effects for the eight MHAQ items ranged between
0–21.7% and 0.8–4.2% respectively, and the full range of responses was used in all
but one item. Cronbach’s alpha was 0.89 at baseline and 0.86 at three months post
intervention, indicating good internal consistency of the instrument. Moderate correlations were noted (Spearman’s ρ of 0.3 to 0.5) between most MHAQ and EQ-5D
domains, and between the overall scores, and strong correlations (ρ > 0.5) between
MHAQ and DAS28. Principal component analysis resulted in one factor explaining
57.1% of the total variance of the scale and all 8 items had high correlation coefficients
(range 0.561–0.862) with this principal component. Responsiveness was satisfactory
as the MHAQ effect size was 0.41, comparable to EQ-5D and DAS28 effect sizes
(0.46 and 0.33 respectively). CONCLUSIONS: Evidence has been provided to support
the reliability, validity and sensitivity to change of the Greek version of the MHAQ
in the evaluation of functional status of RA patients.
PMS49
PSYCHOMETRIC PROPERTIES OF THE RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS
DISEASE ACTIVITY INDEX (RADAI) IN A COMMUNITY POPULATION IN
THE US
Bharmal M1, Cascade E2
1
Quintiles, Rockville, MD, USA; 2iGuard, Inc, Rockville, MD, USA
OBJECTIVES: The Rheumatoid Arthritis Disease Activity Index (RADAI) was developed to provide an easy to use self-administered assessment of rheumatoid arthritis
(RA) to complement physician assessment. This study evaluates the psychometric
properties of a web administered version of the RADAI in a community sample in the
US. METHODS: A random sample of iGuard.org members in the US treated with
medications for RA completed the RADAI and a series of other questions related to
their disease. iGuard.org is a free medication monitoring service that is introduced to
patients through multiple sources including physician, pharmacy and online referrals.
Internal consistency of the RADAI was evaluated using Cronbach’s alpha and itemtotal correlations, and factor analysis was used to confirm the domain structure.
Convergent validity was established using correlations with patient global assessment
of pain and number of painful joints. RESULTS: A total of 153 RA patients completed
the study. The mean (SD) age of respondents was 52.7 (10.9) years, 71.2% were
females with 54.3% diagnosed with RA 1 to 5 years ago and 39.2% diagnosed 5 to
15 years ago. The mean (SD) RADAI score was 4.59 (2.16), patient global assessment
of pain was 52.11 (24.88) on a 100-point scale, and number of painful joints were
7.93 (4.22). RADAI items had good internal consistency with Cronbach’s alpha of
0.89 and all item-total correlations >= 0.56. Factor analysis confirmed one factor with
factor loadings of all the items on the factor of >= 0.57. As expected, RADAI scores
were significantly correlated with patient global assessment of pain (0.646; P < 0.0001)
A312
and number of patient joints (0.649; P < 0.0001). CONCLUSIONS: The study confirms the reliability and validity of a web administered version of the RADAI questionnaire in a US community sample. It is a useful measure to assess RA disease status for
patient recruitment in interventional studies and for observational study designs.
PMS50
PATIENTS’ STATED HEALTH-OUTCOME PREFERENCES FOR
CONFOUNDED PATIENT-REPORTED OUTCOME DOMAINS FOR
OSTEOARTHRITIS
Johnson FR, Gonzalez JM, Hauber AB
RTI Health Solutions, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA
BACKGROUND: Patient-reported outcome (PRO) instruments such as the WOMAC
Index of Osteoarthritis provide scores for outcomes that cannot be measured objectively. However, such scores do not necessarily indicate patients’ perception of the
relative importance of the domains and scales used in such instruments. OBJECTIVES:
To obtain valid estimates of patient preferences for osteoarthritis domains and potential adverse outcomes. METHODS: Residents of the United Kingdom aged 45 years
or older with a self-reported physician diagnosis of osteoarthritis (OA) completed a
web-enabled conjoint-analysis or discrete-choice experiment survey. Patients evaluated
10 pairs of hypothetical OA treatment-outcome profiles. Each hypothetical OA treatment was defined by 4 benefit attributes derived from the WOMAC instrument
(ambulatory pain, resting pain, stiffness, and daily activities) plus 3 adverse-event risk
attributes (bleeding ulcer, stroke, and coronary infarction). Choice-model parameter
estimates were obtained using random-parameters logit. RESULTS: A total of 294
subjects provided usable data. Valid parameter estimates should indicate that better
outcomes are preferred to worse outcomes. a main-effects choice model yielded correctly ordered, risk-level, preference-weight estimates for the 3 adverse-event attributes, but disordered severity estimates for all 4 PRO attributes. Implausible
combinations of ambulatory-pain and daily-activity levels may cause patients to focus
on only one of the attributes. a model that excludes the daily-activity attribute and
includes a dummy variable to account for implausible combinations yields correctly
ordered preference-weight estimates. An improvement in ambulatory pain from
25 mm to 0 mm on a 100 mm scale is approximately 1.7 times as important to
patients as the same improvement in resting pain. CONCLUSIONS: Confounding
among PRO domains can interfere with estimating valid preference weights and limit
researchers’ ability to populate a model based on PRO outcomes with a full set of
preference weights Controlling statistically for implausible outcome combinations
successfully corrects the effect of the confounding and yields plausible trade-off values.
PMS51
PATIENT PREFERENCES FOR SEVERE OSTHEOPOROSIS IN SPAIN: A
DISCRETE CHOICE EXPERIMENT
Darba J1, Restovic G2, Kaskens L2, Martinez E3
1
Universitat de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain; 2BCN Health, Barcelona, Spain; 3Nycomed
Pharma, Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: This study was designed to identify patient preferences for different
aspects of severe ostheoporosis (SO) treatments in Spain. METHODS: Main attributes
of SO treatments were determined from a review of the literature and consultations
with nurses and patients. The discrete choice experiment included 3 attributes: type
of drug administration, place of administration, plus a cost attribute in order to
estimate willingness to pay (WTP) for improvements in attribute levels. a pilot study
with 50 patients was carried forward to identify areas of misunderstanding. One
hundred sixty-six patients with a diagnosis of SO were presented with pairs of hypothetical treatment profiles with varied levels of type of administration, place of administration and cost. Questions were also included to collect socio-demographic data.
Data were analyzed using a random effects probit model. RESULTS: All attributes
had the expected polarity and all were significant predictors of choice. Patients were
willing to pay c183/month to have a subcutaneous injection once per day rather than
an intravenous injection once per year. Patients were also willing to pay c121/month
to have medical support when administering the drug treatment at home rather than
being admitted several hours to a hospital for drug administration. CONCLUSIONS:
Spanish SO patients have well-defined preferences among treatment attributes and are
willing to accept tradeoffs among attributes. Participants indicated that they are
willing to accept self medication with medical support rather than being admitted to
a hospital for several hours. The perspective of the patients should be taken into
account when making treatment decisions.
PMS52
PREFERENCES OVER BENEFITS AND RISKS ASSOCIATED WITH THE
USE OF NSAIDS: EVIDENCE FROM PATIENTS DIAGNOSED WITH
OSTEOARTHRITIS (OA) IN UK
Bridges JF1, Taylor SD2, Arden N3, Hauber AB4, Johnson FR4, Watson D2, Mavros P2,
Pellissier JM2, Peloso P5, Sen S2, Mohamed A4, Gonzalez JM4
1
Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD, USA; 2Merck & Co., Inc., Whitehouse Station, NJ,
USA; 3University of Southampton, Southampton, UK, UK; 4RTI Health Solutions, Research
Triangle Park, NC, USA; 5MRL, Whitehouse Station, NJ, USA
BACKGROUND: The premise of patients’ informed consent presupposes a preference
structure over treatment related outcomes. OBJECTIVES: To assess patient preferences for treatment-related benefits and risks associated with the NSAID use in the
management of OA and examine differences in patient preferences across patient
subgroups. METHODS: Eligible study participants, identified in a chronic disease
13th Euro Abstracts
panel in UK, were >44 yrs old with self-reported diagnosis of OA. Each patient was
randomized to receive one of four blocks of choice questions, each block consisting
of 10 choice tasks comparing different treatment profiles of benefits and risks consistent with NSAID use. Treatment profiles were defined by four benefits (ambulatory
pain, resting pain, stiffness, difficulty doing daily activities) and four medicationrelated risks (bleeding ulcer, stroke, heart attack, hypertension), each varying across
four clinically meaningful levels. Preference weights were estimated using mixed-effects
logistic regression models and were standardized in a 0–10 (low-high) importance
scale. Differences in patient preferences were assessed by stratifying age, hypertension
diagnosis, and use of proton pump inhibitors (PPI). RESULTS: For the 294 study
participants, average age was 59 years, 65% were female, 62% married, 56% diagnosed with OA > 4 years, 49% with hypertension, 76% on prescription OA medications and 36% on PPIs. Reductions in ambulatory pain (6.32; 95%CI:5.0–7.6) and
difficulty doing daily activities (6.32; 95%CI:5.0–7.6) were the most important benefit
attributes followed by resting pain (2.80; 95%CI:1.8–3.8) and stiffness (2.65;
95%CI:0.9–4.4). Incremental changes (3 percentage-point) in the risk of heart attack
or stroke were assessed as the most important risk outcomes (10.00; 95%CI:8.2–11.8;
and 8.90; 95%CI:7.3–10.5, respectively). a 2.5 percentage-point incremental change
in one-year ulcer risk (3.61; 95%CI:2.6–4.6) and the risk of hypertension (3.02;
95%CI:2.8–3.2) were valued less. The hypothesis of preferences homogeneity in
patient subgroups was not rejected. CONCLUSIONS: Patients diagnosed with OA
have well defined preferences over NSAID-related benefits and risks.
PMS53
QUALITY OF LIFE, PATIENTS’ PREFERENCES AND INFORMED
DECISION IN TREATING RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS IN GREECE
Karageorgopoulou K1, Seretis G1, Papachristou E1, Antoniadis C2, Aslanidis S3, Boki K4,
Boura P5, Boumpas D6, Ioakeimidis D7, Kandili A8, Sakkas L9, Settas L10, Solioti F11,
Tzanakakis M6, Tzioufas A12, Vassilopoulos D13, Tountas Y1
1
Centre for Health Services Research, Department of Hygiene and Epidemiology, Medical
School, University of Athens, Athens, Greece; 2Department of Rheumatology, Asklepieion
Voulas Hospital, Voula, Greece; 3B’Propaedeutic Department of Internal Medicine,
Rheumatology, Hippokration Hospital of Thessaloniki, Thessaloniki, Greece; 4Department of
Rheumatology, Sismanoglio General Hospital, Athens, Greece; 5Clinical Immunology Unit,
2nd Department of Internal Medicine, Hippokration Hospital of Thessaloniki, University of
Thessaloniki, Thessaloniki, Greece; 6Department of Rheumatology, Clinical Immunology and
Allergy, Medical School, University of Crete, Heraklion, Greece; 7Department of
Rheumatology, General Hospital of Athens, Athens, Greece; 82nd Department of Internal
Medicine, Hippokration General Hospital, Athens, Greece; 9Department of Rheumatology,
Thessaly University, School of Medicine and Hospital, Larissa, Greece; 10Rheumatology Unit,
1st Department of Medicine, AHEPA Hospital, University of Thessaloniki, Thessaloniki,
Greece; 11Euroclinic Hospital, Athens, Greece; 12Department of Pathophysiology, Medical
School, University of Athens, Athens, Greece; 13Hippokration General Hospital, Medical
School, University of Athens, Athens, Greece
OBJECTIVES: Rheumatoid Arthritis (RA) is a seriously debilitating disease affecting
almost 0.7% of the adult population in Greece. Treatment options include, besides
the conventional treatment with DMARDs, the use of newer biologic agents, which
are available in the hospital (intravenous-iv) or the outpatient setting (subcutaneoussc). Patients are usually perceived to be averse to the use of iv treatments that may be
essential to control their disease. We assessed quality of life, patients’ preferences,
participation in decision making, when selecting the appropriate treatment for RA,
and expected outcomes from the prescription medication. METHODS: Structured
face-to-face and telephone interviews were conducted among 290 patients taking
biologic agents. Patients were recruited from public hospitals (69.7%), office based
rheumatologists (22.8%) and private clinics (7.6%). Data were analyzed using SPSS
v17.0. RESULTS: Median patient age was 55 years. 3/4 of the sample were women
(74.8%). Approximately 1/3 of respondents reported they were not informed at all
on adverse events (28.9%), treatment duration (31.4%) and prognosis (24.5%). For
the greater part of the patients, the main source of information was their doctor.
Treatment decisions were reached by the physician without patients’ involvement in
most cases (70.6%). There was no statistically significant difference in patients’ satisfaction between iv and sc treatments, whereas 62% of patients on sc treatment would
be willing to switch to iv following their rheumatologist’s suggestion. Finally, “feeling
better overall” was rated as the most important expected outcome by 63,2%, followed
by reduced joint pain. Only 16% rated the long term remission of the disease as a
very important outcome. CONCLUSIONS: An important proportion of patients with
RA in Greece feel that they are not informed properly on treatment options, while
their expectations may be understated. To improve outcomes, it is essential that
rheumatologists overcome perceptions, inform and involve patients in the treatment
decision.
13th Euro Abstracts
PMS54
GAP BETWEEN PATIENT-REPORTED ESTIMATION ON FRACTURE RISK
AND THE WHO ASSESSMENT TOOL (FRAX®) IN POSTMENOPAUSAL
OSTEOPOROSIS
Pentek M1, Horváth C2, Érsek K1, Baji P1, Bors K3, Csupor E4, Furi J5, Hacsuncz M6,
Horváth B7, Kárpáti S8, Boncz I9, Korányi A10, Rápolthy I11, Tamási L12, Tóth E13,
Gulácsi L1, Brodszky V1
1
Corvinus University of Budapest, Budapest, Hungary; 2Semmelweis University, Budapest,
Hungary; 3Rehabilitation Hospital and Spa of Visegrád, Visegrád, Hungary; 4Budavár Local
Government Healthcare Service, Budapest, Hungary; 5Ferencváros Health Care Service,
Budapest, Hungary; 6Saint John’s Hospital, Budapest, Hungary; 7Thermal Spa Hospital,
Sopron-Balf, Hungary; 8Zugló Health Care Service, Budapest, Hungary; 9University of Pécs,
Pécs, Hungary; 10Saint Borbála Hospital, Tatabánya, Hungary; 11Health Care Service Centre II.
of Székesfehérvár, Székesfehérvár, Hungary; 12Saint Francis’ Hospital, Miskolc, Hungary; 13Flór
Ferenc County Hospital, Kistarcsa, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: The FRAX® model recently developed by the WHO calculates 10-year
probability of major osteoporotic and hip fracture, offering new basis for medical
decision making and health economic analysis in osteoporosis (OP). [http://www.shef.
ac.uk/FRAX/]. Patients’ ideas regarding fracture risk and longevity might influence
their perception of 10-year fracture risk data and compliance, and as a consequence,
successful implementation of FRAX® based thresholds in everyday OP care. Our aim
was to study whether FRAX® data differ from OP patients’ and attendant especialists’
self-estimations on fracture risk. We also assessed expectations on longliving which is
a crucial point to perceive the 10-year farcture risk projection of FRAX® relevant.
METHODS: In 2009 a cross-sectional survey was performed in 10 Hungarian rheumatology centres. Postmenopausal OP patients appearing on routine visit and switching to second line antiporotic drug were involved. Demographics, main clinical
characteristics were registered. Patients’ estimation on 10-year fracture risk and
longliving were surveyed. Physicians’ expectations on patients’ perspectives were likely
detected. FRAX® was calculated and matched with the estimations. RESULTS: 224
patients were involved, mean(SD): age 69.5(8.9)years, duration of OP care 6.7(5.1)
years, lumbar Tsc-3.17(0.82), femoral Tsc-2.69(0.87), 133(59.4%) patients had OP
fracture previously. Health status VAS was 59(17)mm. FRAX®-major OP fracture
was 26(15.7)%, patients estimated 32.7(25.8)%, physicians marked 29.9(21.4)%.
Results for hip fracture were: FRAX® 12.6(15.3)%, patients 26.7(25.3)%, physicians
21.5(19.1)% (P < 0.01). Patients’ expected to live until age 82.4(8.2)years, physicians’
estimation was nearly same (82.5, SD7 yrs). Less than 10-year survival was expected
by 42,4% and 33.7%, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Both patients and physicians
overestimate fracture risk, especially for hip. Patients often expect to live shorter than
the time-frame of the fracture risk projection. These aspects should be highly considered in health communication and also in the application of the FRAX® method in
clinical practice.
PMS55
ANALYSIS ON THE POSSIBLE ASSOCIATION BETWEEN RHEUMATOID
ARTHIRITIS AND DIABETES MELLITUS TYPE 2
Laires P1, Fonseca JE1, Garcia EB2
1
Faculty of Medicine, University of Lisbon, Lisbon, Portugal; 2BioEPI, Clinical and Translational
Research Center, Lisbon, Portugal
OBJECTIVES: Rheumatoid Arthritis (RA), a chronic inflammatory disease, may predispose to the development of Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus (T2DM). We aimed to
compare incidence rates of T2DM in RA versus non-RA populations and study the
influencing factors. METHODS: The study population consisted of participants in the
National Data Bank for Rheumatic Diseases (NDB), where patients with rheumatologic disorders completed semiannual questionnaires, from 1998 through 2008.
Osteoarthritis (OA) patients were used as controls. T2DM was determined based on
self-reports of disease and on the use of hypoglycemic medication. The association
between RA and T2DM was investigated using COX logistic regressions adjusted for
relevant clinical and demographic covariates. RESULTS: A total of 14,481 participants diagnosed with RA (79.5% female; mean age 58.1 years) and 3,441 participants
diagnosed with OA (84.5% female; mean age 63.6 years) were followed during 69,943
person-years. RA subjects had lower Body Mass Index (BMI) and less major comorbidities than controls. In patients with RA the T2DM incidence rate was 10 per 1000
person-years, while the incidence rate for OA was 15 per 1000 person-years. Both
rates are superior to most estimates calculated among the US population. However,
the covariate-adjusted risk of T2DM in patients with RA versus OA was not significant
(HR = 0.94; 95% CI: 0.79–1.12, p = NS). Male gender, age, BMI, non-caucasian
ethnicity, major comorbidities, low education level and prednisone intake were significantly associated with the incidence of T2DM. Some RA drugs had a clear protective role on TDM2, mainly methotrexate (19% risk reduction; p = 0.022) and
hydroxicloroquine (47% risk reduction; P < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: RA per se is
not associated with increased risk of T2DM. Both RA and OA are associated with
known TDM2 risk factors, such as BMI and some comorbidities, increasing the
incidence rates of TDM2. Some drugs for RA treatment have a significant protective
effect on the TDM2 risk.
A313
PMS56
DETERMINING THE OPTIMAL TIMING FOR TOTAL KNEE
REPLACEMENT
Ko Y1, Lo NN2, Yeo SJ2, Yang KY2, Yeo W2, Chong HC2, Thumboo J2
1
National University of Singapore, Singapore; 2Singapore General Hospital, Singapore
OBJECTIVES: Total knee replacement (TKR) is a commonly used surgical procedure
for patients with severe joint damage caused by arthritis; however, there remain difficulties in establishing criteria to define the optimal timing for TKR. The aim of this
study was to identify the preoperative threshold HRQoL scores that were associated
with better postoperative outcomes and those associated with greater improvement.
METHODS: Data were collected from 1715 patients undergoing TKR between 2001
and 2006. Patients were interviewed at baseline and at 6 months and 2 years after
surgery. At all three interview sessions, patients were asked to complete the ShortForm (SF-36) and the Oxford Knee Score (OKS). As physical function and pain have
been identified as the key domains in osteoarthritis, the OKS and the physical functioning (PF) and bodily pain (BP) scales of the SF-36 were selected as the outcome measures
of this study. Summary statistics were computed for preoperative, postoperative, and
improvement in outcome scores. Visual inspection of the simple error bar charts were
used to identify the threshold preoperative scores that were associated with better
postoperative scores and those associated with more improvement. RESULTS:
Patients with poorer preoperative HRQoL had worse postoperative outcomes but
experienced greater improvement after TKR compared to those with better preoperative HRQoL. The highest postoperative PF scores are associated with a preoperative
PF score of 50 points and above, whereas the baseline threshold OKS score was
between 35 and 40 points. a baseline PF score of <30 points and an OKS score of
>40 points are associated with the greatest improvement. No clear leveling off pattern
was observed in the BP scores. CONCLUSIONS: PF and OKS threshold scores associated with optimal outcomes of TKR were identified in this study. Future research is
needed to examine the predictive value of the scores identified in improving patients’
post-operative outcomes.
PMS57
HEALTH-RELATED QUALITY OF LIFE AFTER TOTAL KNEE
REPLACEMENT OR UNICOMPARTMENTAL KNEE ARTHROPLASTY IN
AN URBAN ASIAN POPULATION
Ko Y1, Narayanasamy S1, Wee HL1, Lo NN2, Yeo SJ2, Yang KY2, Yeo W2, Chong HC2,
Thumboo J2
1
National University of Singapore, Singapore; 2Singapore General Hospital, Singapore
OBJECTIVES: To examine health-related quality of life (HRQoL) following total knee
replacement (TKR) or unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA). METHODS:
Asian adult patients undergoing either TKR or UKA in a hospital of Singapore
between 2001 and 2006 were interviewed before surgery and 6 and 24 months postoperatively to obtain demographic information and HRQoL scores using the ShortForm (SF-36) and the Oxford Knee Score (OKS). RESULTS: Data were collected from
2243, 1715, and 1113 patients at baseline, 6, and 24 months, respectively. TKR
patients had a lower preoperative score than UKA patients on OKS and four subscales
of the SF-36 (p < 0.01). Both TKR and UKA patients’ OKS and SF-36 subscale scores
improved six months postoperatively except in the general health domain. SF-36 role
physical (RP) and bodily pain (BP) scores showed the most improvement (40.9 and
33.0 points in TKR and 36.9 and 31.4 points in UKA patients, respectively). The most
substantial improvements between baseline and two years after surgery were in the
physical domains of HRQoL (RP, BP, and physical functioning (PF)). In addition, in
both groups, five domains of SF-36 (RP, BP, PF, social functioning, and role limitations
due to emotional problems) reached the proposed minimal clinically important difference of ten points. TKR patients’ SF-36 and OKS scores were not significantly different
from those of UKA patients two year after surgery, except PF scores. Multiple regression analysis adjusting for sociodemographics showed that baseline scores were a
significant predictor of the postoperative scores of OKS and all SF-36 subscales (p <
0.01), whereas the type of surgery was not associated with the postoperative scores.
CONCLUSIONS: Both TKR and UKA patients experienced significant improvements
in HRQoL, particularly in the RP and BP domains. After controlling for potential
confounding variables, the type of surgery was not a significant predictor of patients’
postoperative HRQoL scores.
PMS58
CLINICAL OUTCOMES AND CHANGES IN QUALITY OF LIFE IN
WOMEN WITH OSTEOPOROSIS TREATED WITH TERIPARATIDE: 36
MONTH RESULTS OF THE FRENCH PATIENTS PARTICIPATING IN THE
EUROPEAN FORSTEO OBSERVATIONAL STUDY (EFOS)
Rajzbaum G1, Tcherny-Lessenot S2, liu-Leage S2, Gehchan N2, Barrett A3
1
Saint Joseph Hospital, Paris, France; 2Lilly France, Suresnes, France; 3Eli Lilly & Company Ltd,
Windlesham, Surrey, UK
OBJECTIVES: To describe back pain, and HRQoL in postmenopausal women with
osteoporosis treated with teriparatide (Forsteo®) in France. METHODS: European,
prospective, observational study of 36 months duration (18-month active treatment
phase and 18-month post-treatment follow up) in postmenopausal women with osteoporosis who initiated teriparatide. HRQoL measured by EQ-5D and back pain measured by a Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) and a questionnaire were collected at each
follow-up visit. RESULTS: Among 309 patients enrolled in France (18.8% of the total
EFOS cohort), 290 (94.5%) had any follow-up data, and 201 (65.0%) completed the
last post-treatment visit. At baseline, patients were 73.8 (7.4) years old (mean (SD)),
A314
98.6% of patients had 2 or more fractures after age 40 years, the mean (SD) number
of fractures was 4.2 (1.7) and median number was 4.0 (interquartile range 3.0–5.0).
During the study, the mean (SD) duration of treatment by teriparatide was 443 (203)
days; at the end of 17th month, 67.9% of patients were still on treatment. The main
reasons of treatment discontinuation were treatment completion (69.9%), adverse
events (14.5%), patient decision (14.0%), and physician decision (2.2%). Between
baseline and end of study, the rate of women with back pain decreased from 93.8%
to 83.3% and 57.1% had an improvement in the severity, mean (SD) back pain
intensity VAS decreased from 55.9 (24.8) to 35.0 (24.2), and mean (SD) EQ-5D VAS
increased from 52.6 (19.4) at baseline to 57.8 (21.4) at end of study. CONCLUSIONS:
French patients with severe osteoporosis treated with teriparatide in a routine setting
had an increase in quality of life and a decrease in back pain during the teriparatide
treatment period and post-treatment follow-up. The results should be interpreted in
the context of a non-controlled observational study.
PMS59
THE EFFECT OF TNF THERAPY, SOCIODEMOGRAPHIC AND CLINICAL
FACTORS ON SLEEP DISTURBANCES AND FATIGUE AMONG
RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS—RESULTS FROM THE NDB-PORTUGAL
COHORT
Marques R1, Chaves I1, Vasconcelos J1, Pedro S1, Rodrigues A1, Michaud K2, Wolfe F3,
Garcia E1
1
BioEPI, Clinical and Translational Research Center, Oeiras, Portugal; 2University of Nebraska
Medical Center, Omaha, NE, USA; 3National Databank for Rheumatic Diseases, Wichita, KS,
USA
BACKGROUND: The prevalence of sleep disturbances and fatigue among patients
with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is high. TNF therapy reduces disease activity and disability in RA, but few studies have analyzed the impact of TNF vs. traditional
DMARD therapy, sociodemographic and clinical factors on sleep and fatigue, in
prospective cohorts. OBJECTIVES: We assessed the effect of TNF therapy, sociodemographic and clinical factors on sleep disturbances and fatigue in RA patients.
METHODS: A total of 1,082 RA patients from the NDB-Portugal cohort participated
in this prospective study. Patients´ last observation was used. Univariate (UV) and
multivariate (MV) linear regression models (β, 95% CI) assessed the impact of the
following on sleep disturbances (measured by the sleep disturbance scale (VAS 0–10,
10 is worst) and the insomnia severity index (0–28, 28 is worst)) and fatigue (fatigue
scale (VAS 0–10,10 is worst)): traditional DMARD and TNF therapy, age, sex, education level, marital status, number of major comorbidities, RA duration, disability
(HAQ 0–3, 3 is worst), quality of life (VASQOL 0–1, 1 is better), emotional distress
(Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale—HADS 0–21, 21 is worst) and prednisone
use. RESULTS: In MV, TNF therapy seemed to decrease fatigue (−0.60 (−1.08, −0.11))
when compared to traditional DMARDs and although not statistically significant,
decreased sleep disturbances (−0.46 (−1.04, 0.13)) and insomnia (−0.22 (−1.16, 0.73)).
An increase in sleep disturbances was seen with worse HAQ (0.64 (0.25, 1.02)), lower
VASQOL: (−1.46 (−2.63, −0.28)), more anxiety symptoms: (0.19 (0.09, 0.29)) and
higher fatigue (0.26 (0.17, 0.36)). These results were also seen for insomnia and
fatigue. More sleep disturbances (0.18 (0.12, 0.25)) increased fatigue and higher
fatigue increased insomnia (0.39 (0.23, 0.54)). CONCLUSIONS: We found that the
use of TNF therapy improved fatigue when compared to traditional DMARDs. Higher
disability and worse quality of life increased sleep disturbances, insomnia and fatigue.
PMS60
TNF THERAPY REDUCES THE ODDS OF WORSENING DISABILITY
TRENDS IN RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS OVER AT LEAST 2 YEARS—DATA
FROM THE NDB-PORTUGAL COHORT
Pedro S1, Vasconcelos J1, Marques R1, Chaves I1, Rodrigues A1, Michaud K2, Wolfe F3,
Garcia E1
1
BioEPI, Clinical and Translational Research Center, Oeiras, Portugal; 2University of Nebraska
Medical Center, Omaha, NE, USA; 3National Databank for Rheumatic Diseases, Wichita, KS,
USA
OBJECTIVES: Many studies have identified predictors of the health assement questionnaire (HAQ), but few have evaluated the predictors of HAQ trends among RA
patients. To investigate the predictors of worsening disability trends compared to other
patterns among RA patients over at least 2 years. METHODS: A total of 646 RA
patients from the ongoing biannual NDB-Portugal cohort with at least four consecutive HAQ scores per patient during their follow-up were used.The proportion defined
by the number of 6-month positive increments in HAQ scores (worsening function)
divided by the total number of differences was computed per patient and used to define
a patient’ trend. The outcome was then defined as the presence of a trend of worsening
disability (when proportion >0.5). This meant that a patient’s tendency of worsening
was higher than their tendency of improving during their own follow-up. Univariate
(UV) and multivariate (MV) generalized estimating equations (GEE) were used to
study the predictors of a worsening disability trend. Age, education, disease duration,
paid work, retirement, number of total major comorbidities, SF-36 mental component,
RADAI, the VAS scales of sleep, fatigue and pain, the use of current TNF (with or
without concomitant DMARDs) vs. traditional DMARD therapy and steroids, were
used as possible predictors. RESULTS: A total of 26% patients had worsening disability trends. The UV analyses showed that all of the following factors were statistically relevant: age, educational level, number of major comorbidities, sleep disturbances
and fatigue, RADAI and the use of TNF therapy. The final MV model included pain
(OR: 1.003 (95%CI: (1.000; 1.005))), age (OR: 1.02 (1.01; 1.02)) and the use of TNF
13th Euro Abstracts
(OR: 0.94 (0.91; 0.97)). CONCLUSIONS: In our study, we showed that older age
and more pain predicted worsening HAQ disability trends. The use of TNF therapy
was the only factor that decreased the odds of having a worsening HAQ trajectory.
PMS61
RELATING OSTEOARTHRITIS AFFECTATION, FUNCTIONAL
DISABILITY AND QUALITY OF LIFE: A STRUCTURAL EQUATION
MODEL. THE EXPECT STUDY
Cordero J1, Darder A2, Santillana J3, Caloto T4, Nocea G4, Sanchez I4
1
Hospital Universitario La Princesa, Madrid, Spain; 2Hospital Arnau de Vilanova, Valencia,
Spain; 3Hospital Verge de la Cinta, Tortosa, Spain; 4Merck Sharp & Dohme, SA, Madrid,
Spain
OBJECTIVES: To establish a conceptual model which relates osteoarthritis (OA)
affectation, functional disability in daily activities, and Quality of Life (QoL).
METHODS: The present is an observational, cross-sectional, multicenter study. OA
presence/absence, by location, was clinically recorded. Disability was assessed with
the Health Assessment Questionnaire Disability Index (HAQ-DI), QoL through the
EuroQoL-5D questionnaire. Descriptives were used for sociodemographic and clinical
variables; relationship between OA, disability and QoL was estimated through Structural Equation Modeling (SEM). This multivariate analysis technique allows to
hypothesize multiple relationships among latent, unobserved variables and tests the
model with a equation system. RESULTS: A total of 965 OA patients were included
[mean age = 64 years (SD = 11); 75% women]. Mean body locations affected by OA
was 2.81 (median = 2; SD = 1.613). The most frequently affected locations were knees
(67% of the patients), lumbar (60%) and cervical (45%) spine. Regarding EuroQoL5D, most patients reported not having severe problems in the five areas assessed.
‘Other activities’ (mean = 1.172; SD = 0.957) and ‘reach’ (mean = 1.127; SD = 0.912)
were the HAQ-DI categories that showed higher disability. The SEM presented OA,
disability and QoL as latent, related variables. 92% of QoL was accounted for disability (R-squared = 0.92). The global model that depicts OA as causing disability,
and disability affecting QoL, has a marginal adjustment (CMIN/DF = 5.42; RMR =
0.026; RMSEA = 0.069). CONCLUSIONS: With the available data, the functional
disability can account for the decrease in QoL. Theoretically, OA is strongly related
with disability and QoL, but the model fails to fully explain this link. As statistical
techniques need good measurement models to correctly estimate relationships, standard clinical records seem insufficient for this purpose. Additional valid measurements
of OA affectation would be needed, to give evidence of its direct effect on disability
and QoL.
PMS62
CERTOLIZUMAB PEGOL MONOTHERAPY PROVIDES SUSTAINED
IMPROVEMENTS IN HOUSEHOLD PRODUCTIVITY AND DAILY
ACTIVITIES IN PATIENTS WITH ACTIVE RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS
OVER 2 YEARS
Strand V1, Purcaru O2, van Vollenhoven R3, Choy E4, Fleischmann R5
1
Stanford University, Portola Valley, CA, USA; 2UCB, Brussels, Belgium; 3Karolinska University
Hospital, Stockholm, Sweden; 4King’s Musculoskeletal Clinical Trials Unit, King’s College,
London, UK; 5University of Texas, Dallas, TX, USA
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the impact of certolizumab pegol (CZP) monotherapy on
household work and daily activities in RA patients over 2 years. METHODS: Patients
in the FAST4WARD Phase III trial were randomised to CZP 400 mg administered
every 4 weeks (Q4W) or placebo for 24 weeks. Those who completed or withdrew
at/after Week 12 were eligible to enter an open-label extension (OLE) study of CZP
400 mg Q4W. This analysis focuses on CZP completers who entered the OLE study
and had 2 years (100 weeks) of CZP exposure from baseline (BL). Household productivity and impact on family/social/leisure activities were assessed using the validated Work Productivity Survey (WPS-RA). Analyses were conducted on observed
data. FAST4WARD:NCT00548834; OLE:NCT00160693. RESULTS: Sixty-nine
CZP completers entered the OLE. At BL: mean disease duration: 9.5 years; mean
HAQ-DI: 1.42; mean DAS28-3(CRP): 5.76. Burden of RA on household productivity
at BL was substantial: mean 10.1 household work days missed/month, mean 12.1
household work days with reduced productivity/month, mean 5 days missed/month
of family/social/leisure activities. At Week 100, compared with BL, patients receiving
CZP monotherapy reported on average fewer household work days missed per month
(1.0 vs. 10.1), fewer days with reduced productivity in the home (1.1 vs. 12.1), reduced
interference of RA on household productivity (2.0 vs. 5.8 on a 0–10 scale), fewer
missed days of family/social/leisure activities (0.3 vs. 5.0). Improvements were seen as
early as Week 4 and were sustained until Week 100. Over 12, 52 and 100 weeks,
mean annualised cumulative gains from BL were 20.5, 108.4 and 199.3 household
work days, respectively, 25.1, 136.0 and 244.9 more productive days within the
household, and 11.9, 57.7 and 107.2 days gained of family/social/leisure activities.
CONCLUSIONS: CZP 400 mg Q4W monotherapy provides sustained improvement
in productivity within the home and in RA patients’ abilities to engage in family/social/
leisure activities.
13th Euro Abstracts
MUSCULAR-SKELETAL DISORDERS – Health Care Use & Policy Studies
PMS63
THE IMPACT OF THE DRUG CATEGORIZATION ON THE
PRESCRIPTION AND CONSUMPTION OF NONSTEROIDAL
ANTIINFLAMATORY DRUGS (NSAID)
Gatialová K, Petrová L, Bellová K, Majtás J, Foltan V
Faculty of Pharmacy, Comenius University, Bratislava, Slovak Republic
OBJECTIVES: This study deals with the impact of regulatory measures represented
by the drug categorization on the prescription and at the use of nonsteroidal and
antiinflammatory drugs (NSAID) and asses measures of the state health policy and
their application in the Slovak Republic within year 2009. METHODS: Analysis was
conducted with key data represented by the medicine name and code, name of registration decision owner, maximum price of producer and importer, final medicine price,
maximum copayment, prescription and indication restriction, the number of medicine
packages. As data sources were used The List of Drugs. Analysis of categorizations in
ATC group of drugs M01- NSAID, comparison of single changes and its significance.
RESULTS: In year 2009 were 9,087,217 medicine packages from the group of NSAID
expended. From this amount of medicine packages were 2,477,352 packages expended
during first quartal of 2009, which represents the highest consumption of all four
terms. The lowest consumption was noticed in period of second term reaching expenditure of only 2,020,514 medicine packages. Outstanding changes appeared by indometacine where prescription decreased from 9782 medicine packages to zero.
Lornoxicam has appeared in third term as new medicine in categorization and his
consumption increased to 3091 medicine packages in the fourth term. In all four terms
dominated the same drugs on first ten places of medicine consumption (ibuprofen,
diclofenac, nimesulid, combinations of ibuprofen, meloxicam, ketoprofen, flurbiprofen, piroxicam, naproxen, aceclofenac). CONCLUSIONS: Current state of categorization and functioning of professional bodies represent initial assumption of health
policy asserting. Patient registries are helping tool in assessing effectiveness of medicines and cost efficacy and should be legislated. There is a disadvantage of administrative burden. Patient co- payment has increasing tendency due to removing responsibility
for own health on patients.
PMS64
CONSUMPTION OF BISPHOSPHONATES FOR THE TREATMENT OF
OSTEOPOROSIS
Vytrisalova M, Blazkova S
Charles University, Faculty of Pharmacy, Hradec Kralove, Czech Republic
OBJECTIVES: The objective was to analyze trends in the consumption of bisphosphonates for the treatment of osteoporosis in 2002–2006. METHODS: The prescription-based database of the General Health Insurance Company of the Czech Republic
(VZP CR), the largest health insurance company of the Czech Republic that covers
about 65% of the Czech population, was used as the source of data from 2002–2006.
Health insurance is compulsory under Czech law. In 2002–2006, alendronate and
risedronate (in both once-daily and once-weekly formulations) were available for the
treatment of osteoporosis. The prescription of the two bisphosphonates is restricted
to specialists in internal medicine, orthopaedy, rheumatology, gynecology and endocrinology. RESULTS: In 2002–2006, as many as 63 251 (0.94%) and 21 064 (0.31%)
patients (insured persons) refilled at least one prescription for alendronate and risedronate, respectively. Men accounted for 3% of the bisphosphonate consumption.
The age of bisphosphonate consumers was 69 years (median). Bisphosphonates were
prescribed most often by physicians specializing in internal medicine, orthopaedy and
rheumatology. The mean alendronate and risedronate consumption rates were 5.2 and
1.5 defined daily doses (DDD)/1000 insured persons/day, respectively. Mean DDD per
year/patient was higher in women than in men (204 versus 186 for alendronate and
179 versus 172 for risedronate). The number of patients on alendronate increased by
83% from 2002 to 2006. CONCLUSIONS: Signals of inadequate osteoporosis treatment in the Czech population in 2002–2006 were found. The consumption of bisphosphonates is particularly low in men. The increasing consumption rates of alendronate
could be considered as a positive trend. The project was fully supported by grant No.
103107 (2007–2009) from the Charles University Grant Agency.
PMS65
RETROSPECTIVE OBSERVATIONAL DATABASE ANALYSIS OF TNF-Á
INHIBITOR SWITCHING PATTERNS IN PATIENTS IN THE UNITED
STATES WITH RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS IN TWO DISTINCT
“NATURALISTIC” TREATMENT SETTINGS USING A PRE-PROGRAMMED
DATA ANALYSIS TOOL
Chiappinelli R1, McNeeley B1, Byrd J2, Ollinger E2
1
HealthCore, Wilmington, DE, USA; 2Dymaxium, Inc, Toronto, ON, Canada
OBJECTIVES: Evaluate 12 month switch patterns among patients taking anti-TNFs
for rheumatoid arthritis (RA) in the context of validating a Rheumatoid Arthritis
Outcomes Analyzer (RAOA); a data analysis tool incorporating pharmacy, medical
claims, and member eligibility information. METHODS: The study was conducted
utilizing claims data from a two large commercial data sets: Cohorts #1 and #2.
Facilitated by the RAOA, medical and pharmacy claims were entered into two distinct
data sets for inclusion in the analysis. Patients were ≥18 years of age, received ≥ one
traditional (non-biologic) or biologic DMARD between January 2005 and December
2007, and had ≥ two RA diagnoses (ICD-9 CM 714.0X) ≥ two months apart. For the
switch analysis, patients had at least 18 months continuous eligibility; 6 months prior
to index date (initial anti-TNF) and treatment naïve, and 12 months post. RESULTS:
A315
A total of 2177 (Cohort #1) vs. 1113 (Cohort #2) patients entered the analysis. In
Cohort #1, 426 (19.6%) received adalimumab, 1123 (51.6%) received etanercept and
628 (28.8%) received infliximab as initial treatment. In Cohort #2, 355 (31.9%)
received adalimumab, 509 (45.7%) received etanercept and 249 (22.4%) received
infliximab. In both Cohorts, 75% were female. During the twelve months following
the index date, 161 (7.4%) vs. 91 (8.2%) switched to another biologic DMARD; 133
(6.1%) vs. 87 (7.8%) switched to another anti-TNF biologic and 28 (1.3%) vs. 4
(0.4%) to a non anti-TNF biologic DMARD. Twenty-seven (6.3%) vs. 44 (12.4%)
of patients in the adalimumab sub-group switched to an anti-TNF biologic compared
to 99 (8.8%) vs. 37 (7.3%) for etenercept and 7 (1.1%) vs. 6 (2.4%) for infliximab.
CONCLUSIONS: Analytic tools such as the RAOA will allow payers and policy
makers to better understand utilization and treatment patterns easily and quickly.
Replication and validation of outputs from these tools are important to establish the
precision of results.
PMS66
PENETRATION OF MONOCLONAL ANTIBODIES ONTO FINNISH
PHARMACEUTICAL MARKET
Kannisto HE1, Jormanainen V1, Happonen P2
1
Finnish Medicines Agency (Fimea), Helsinki, Finland; 2Finnish Medicines Agency (Fimea),
Kuopio, Finland
OBJECTIVES: Monoclonal antibodies (MAB) are biomedicines used for treatment of
cancer, rheumatoid arthritis, psoriasis and inflammatory intestinal diseases. Since the
first market entry in 1996 in Finland, their sales have increased continuously. We
describe the penetration of MABs onto the Finnish pharmaceutical market in 1996–
2009. METHODS: The sales of MABs (wholesale figures in million euros, c M) with
marketing authorization were extracted by calendar year from the market database
SLD Pharma (Finnish Pharmaceutical Data Ltd.) based on active substances. Annual
figures were converted into 2009 values with the annually-updated Finnish National
Pensions index (Social Insurance Institution). RESULTS: In 2009, the sales of the 17
MABs were c109 M or 5.6% of the total pharmaceutical market value (c1900 M).
On the hospital market (73% of MAB sales in 2009), however, the respective share
was 16% following a steady increase in 1999–2009. Up to the end of 2009, the overall
cumulative MAB sales exceeded c479 M. Infliximab showed the highest cumulative
sales of c120 M (entry in 1999). Adalimumab penetrated the market even more
rapidly, with cumulative sales of c109 M (entry in 2003), and became the most-sold
active substance in 2009 in Finland. The third MAB exceeding cumulative sales of
c100 M was rituximab (entry in 1998). In terms of first-year sales, adalimumab was
the most successful MAB, amounting to over c6 M. Bevacizumab achieved the secondhighest first-year sales (c1.8 M in 2005), while the third MAB exceeding c1 M sales
was ranibizumab (c1.7 M in 2007). CONCLUSIONS: The penetration of several
MABs onto the Finnish pharmaceutical market has been very successful within a short
period of time.
PMS67
CONJOINT ANALYSIS OF REDUCTION OF CO-PAYMENT RATE OF
NATIONAL HEALTH INSURANCE SYSTEM IN JAPAN
Igarashi A1, Kikuta K1, Hoshi D2, Tanaka E2, Yamanaka H2, Tsutani K1
1
Grad. Sch. of Pharm, University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan; 2Tokyo Women’s Medical
University, Tokyo, Japan
BACKGROUND: In Japanese national health insurance system, there is some limit
for monthly co-payment amount. In some diseases, AIDS, chronic renal failure with
dialysis and hemophilia, co-payment limits are additionally reduced. Patient groups
for myeloma, cervical cancer, hepatitis, chronic myelogenous leukemia and rheumatoid arthritis argued that co-payment reduction should be implemented to their diseases. OBJECTIVES: To conduct conjoint analysis to determine how people value
various factors of diseases in decision-making process for co-payment reduction.
METHODS: We determined six factors, i.e., influence for life-years/QOL (low/high),
availability for medicines (yes/no), number of patients (5,000/50,000/500,000),
disease duration (short/long) and out-of-pocket expense per 1 month (JPY10,000/
JPY100,000, USD1 = JPY90) and developed questionnaire. Ninety-six patterns are
reduced to 26, via orthogonal methods. a total of 1163 participants filled questionnaire via web survey system. We adopted panel-logit model to estimate odds ratios
for each factors. RESULTS: All 6 factors significantly influenced peoples’ decisionmaking process. Coefficient for each factors were as follows; out-of-pocket expense:
2.61 > influence for QOL: 0.976 > disease duration: 0.884 > influence for life-years:
0.831> number of patients: 0.105 > availability for medicines: −0.18, respectively.
Based on this estimation, when we consider characteristics of anti-rheumatoid biologics, more than 95% people think that out-of-pocket rate should be reduced. CONCLUSIONS: Various factors contribute to people’s attitude for co-payment reduction.
This quantitative result would be helpful for decision-making process in national
health insurance system.
A316
PMS68
PHYSICIANS’ STATED PREFERENCES OVER BENEFITS AND RISKS
ASSOCIATED WITH NSAID USE IN PATIENTS WITH OSTEOARTHRITIS
IN UNITED KINGDOM
Bridges JF1, Taylor SD2, Arden N3, Hauber AB4, Johnson FR4, Watson D2, Mavros P2,
Pellissier JM2, Peloso P5, Sen S2, Mohamed A4, Gonzalez JM4
1
Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD, USA; 2Merck & Co., Inc., Whitehouse Station, NJ,
USA; 3University of Southampton, Southampton, UK, UK; 4RTI Health Solutions, Research
Triangle Park, NC, USA; 5MRL, Whitehouse Station, NJ, USA
BACKGROUND: Treatments for symptom control in osteoarthritis (OA) confer
varying degrees of benefits alongside medication-related risks. Physicians’ preferences
over benefits and risks of NSAIDS are an important aspect of understanding clinical
practice. OBJECTIVES: To estimate physicians’ preferences over benefits and risks
associated with NSAID use in the management of OA and examine differences in
preferences between general practitioners (GPs) and specialists. METHODS: Participating physicians treated at least 10 OA patients per-month. Each physician was
randomized to receive one of four blocks of discrete-choice questions; each block
consisting of 12 paired choice tasks comparing treatment profiles. Treatment profiles
were defined by four benefits (ambulatory pain, resting pain, stiffness, difficulty doing
daily activities) and four medication-related risks (bleeding ulcer, stroke, heart attack,
hypertension), each varying across four clinically meaningful levels. Elicitation of
preferences was facilitated using standardized patient profiles systematically varying
by age, co-morbid conditions and clinically relevant risks of NSAIDs. Preference
weights were estimated using mixed-effects logistic regression and were standardized
on a 0–10 (low-high) importance scale. RESULTS: 477 physicians participated (61%
GPs, 39% specialists). Reductions in ambulatory pain and difficulty doing daily activities were the most important efficacy variables (6.45; 95%CI:4.8–8.2) followed by
eliminating resting pain (3.18; 95%CI:1.9–4.5) and stiffness (2.79; 95%CI:1.5–4.1).
Ambulatory pain was twice as important as resting pain or stiffness (P < 0.05). Risk
of heart attack was the most important medication-related risk outcome (10.00;
95%CI:7.6–12.4) followed by stroke (9.42; 95%CI:7.2–11.6), ulcer risk (4.62;
95%CI:3.5–5.7) and hypertension (3.25; 95%CI:3.2–3.4). There were no statistically
significant differences in preferences between GPs and specialists. CONCLUSIONS:
Ambulatory pain and the incremental risk of heart attack were the most important
NSAID-related attributes that influence physicians’ treatment choices. Preferences did
not vary between GPs and specialists. The findings confirm that benefit-risk tradeoffs
are important aspects in treament selection for OA management.
PMS69
ECONOMY OF NSAIDS IN THE MANAGEMENT OF OSTEOARTHRITIS:
SODIUM CHONDROITIN SULFATE VS. CONTROL GROUP
Taieb C, Pibourdin JM
Pierre Fabre, Boulogne, France
OBJECTIVES: Describe the potential economy of NSAIDs in a population of patients
with osteoarthritis newly-treated with a sodium chondroitin sulphate (SCS) versus a
control group. METHODS: The Disease Analyzer database (IMS), which collects
medical data from 1240 representative French GPs was used. The control group
consists of patient diagnosed with knee or hip osteoarthritis during the observation
period but not treated with symptomatic slow acting drugs for osteoarthritis throughout the study period, no during the year before the study or the following year.
RESULTS: In total, 944 patients were included, 472 per group. The characteristics of
both groups in terms of age, sex, time since diagnosis and type of osteoarthritis are
strictly the same. 80% of patients included suffer from osteoarthritis of the knee. a
total of 53.4% of patients included in study received one or more prescriptions for
NSAIDs during the year prior to their inclusion. Half of the patients in the SCS group
received at least one NSAID prescription during initiation or during the 1 year followup period. This % is significantly higher in the control group (64%; P < 0.01). 18%
of patients in the SCS group stopped their treatment with NSAIDs at the initiation of
SCS and did not resume it during the follow-up year, versus 11% in the control group.
This difference is significant (p = 0.01). Patients in the SCS group require significantly
fewer days of treatment with NSAIDs expressed in DDD than patients in the control
group: on average 49 days of treatment versus 64 (p = 0.01). CONCLUSIONS: One
of the public health goals set by health authorities—to reduce the incidence of iatrogenic complications (serious bleeding or gastroduodenal events) by 20% in osteoarthritic patients could be attained by a prescription of SCS. Indeed, this study highlights
the fact that, in actual use, patients in the SCS group are significantly less likely to use
NSAIDs (−22%).
PMS70
THE MANAGEMENT OF OSTEOARTHRITIS: ECONOMY OF NSAIDS
Taieb C, Pibourdin JM
Pierre Fabre, Boulogne, France
OBJECTIVES: To describe the use NSAIDs in a population of patients with osteoarthritis newly-treated (2009) by a symptomatic slow acting drugs for Osteoarthritis
(SYSADOA) METHODS: The Disease Analyzer database (IMS), which collects
medical data from 1240 representative French GPs was used. Patients over 50 y of
age were included over a period of one year where a diagnosis of osteoarthritis associated with the initiation of an SYSADOA prescription was identified in the DA database
(patient had been monitored for at least 6 months). RESULTS: In total, 3141 patients
were included in the study. The patient profile is similar regardless of the treatment
group considered (68% female, average age of 66, 50% patients the diagnosis dates
13th Euro Abstracts
from less than 1 year). The use of NSAIDs at the outset does not significantly differ
among the groups of patients (25%). About 30% of patients discontinue their NSAID
therapy upon initiation of treatment with SYSADOA. This proportion did not vary
significantly with the SYSADOA considered. More than 40% of patients discontinued
treatment with NSAIDs during the 6-month follow-up period. 20% of patients who
continued treatment with NSAIDs increased the dosage or duration of the NSAID
therapy. About 45% of patients benefited from a co-prescription of analgesics during
the initiation of treatment with SYSADOA. This rate did not significantly vary among
groups of patients. 21% of patients discontinued their treatment with analgesics after
initiation of treatment with SSAAO. This proportion did not vary significantly with
the SYSADOA considered. CONCLUSIONS: It is generally accepted that an economy
of 20% of NSAIDs has a major impact on public health. Regardless of the prescribed
SYSADOA, NSAID interruptions at initiation are approximately 30%, and nearly two
thirds of patients with co-prescriptions of NSAIDs at the start of treatment stop or
reduce this treatment within 6 months. The cost of complications related to antiinflammatory drugs would be around 150 million Euros.
MUSCULAR-SKELETAL DISORDERS – Conceptual Papers & Research on
Methods
PMS71
INDIRECT TREATMENT COMPARISON TO COMPARE EFFICACY IN
HEALTH ASSESSMENT QUESTIONNAIRE (HAQ) SCORE FOR BIOLOGIC
AGENTS WITH METHOTREXATE IN PATIENTS WITH RHEUMATOID
ARTHRITIS AND ACTIVE DISEASE DESPITE METHOTREXATE THERAPY
Lebmeier M1, Pericleous L1, Guyot P2, Baig H1, Christensen R3, Bergman G2, Taylor PC4,
Drost P5
1
Bristol-Myers Squibb Pharmaceuticals Ltd, Uxbridge, Middlesex, UK; 2Mapi Values, Houten,
The Netherlands; 3The Parker Institute: Musculoskeletal Statistics Unit (MSU), Copenhagen,
Denmark; 4Imperial College London, London, UK; 5Bristol-Myers Squibb, Braine-l’Alleud,
Belgium
OBJECTIVES: To compare the efficacy in terms of HAQ score between abatacept and
other biologic Disease Modifying Anti-Rheumatic Drugs (DMARDs) in patients with
rheumatoid arthritis taking concomitant methotrexate (MTX) who have inadequate
response to MTX (MTX-IR). METHODS: A systematic literature review identified
controlled trials investigating the efficacy of abatacept (3 studies), etanercept (2),
infliximab (3), adalimumab (2), certolizumab pegol (2) ritixumab (2), and tocilizumab
(1) in MTX-IR patients. The identified trials were comparable in design, included
patients, and concomitant treatment (MTX). Mixed treatment comparison analyses
were performed on HAQ change from baseline (CFB) at 24 and 52 weeks. Results
were expressed as difference in HAQ CFB score between treatments and expected
HAQ CFB and the 95% Credible Interval (CrI) per treatment at 24 and 52 weeks.
RESULTS: The analysis of HAQ CFB at 24 weeks showed that abatacept/MTX is
more efficacious than MTX monotherapy (−0.30, 95%CrI: −0.40; −0.19) and shows
small numeric differences versus other biologics/MTX (range: −0.11:0.08). The
expected mean HAQ CFB at 24 weeks for abatacept (−0.58) was superior to placebo
(−0.28) and comparable to all the alternative treatments (adjusted mean between −0.47
and −0.66). The findings at 52 weeks are in line with those at 24-weeks, although no
data was available for tocilizumab and golimumab. Scenario analyses confirmed the
robustness of the findings. CONCLUSIONS: All biologic DMARDs in combination
with MTX in the treatment of MTX-IR patients resulted in improvements from
baseline in HAQ score compared to MTX monotherapy at 24 and 52 weeks. All
biologic DMARDs in combination with MTX are expected to result in a comparable
improvement in HAQ score.
PMS72
INTERACTIVE ELECTRONIC INTERFACES (IEI): BRIDGING THE
COMMUNICATION GAP BY TRANSLATING ECONOMIC ANALYSIS
RESULTS TO DECISION-MAKERS EVERYDAY PRACTICE
Marinho M1, Schiola A2, Pimentel A2, Santoni N2, Teich V1, Clark LGO3
1
MedInsight-Evidências, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil; 2Bayer Healthcare, São Paulo, SP, Brazil,
3
MedInsight-Evidências, Campinas, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: Interfaces are interactive dashboards built with programs like Visual
Basic for Applications, Crystal Xcelsius or Java. We aimed to demonstrate how IEI
allow the translation of pharmacoeconomic studies’ results into understandable projections to decision makers. We present the economic evaluation of rivaroxaban in
the prevention of thromboembolic events as a case study. METHODS: A model evaluating rivaroxaban in patients undergoing total knee and hip replacement was used.
The model was adapted to different decision makers needs, namely Health Maintenance Organizations (HMO), hospitals, and physicians focused only on clinical outcomes. For each perspective, the following parameters could be customized: state
taxes, time horizon of the analysis, choice of comparator (enoxaparin, dabigatran or
both), duration of hospitalization, unit costs (drugs, treatment and diagnosis
resources), eligible population and market share of comparators over the following
five years. RESULTS: The IEI design for this case demonstrated that, under the perspective of an HMO with 200.000 lives, considering a base case where 80% of patients
are treated with enoxaparin and 20% with dabigatran, and replacing every year 10%
of enoxaparin cases with rivaroxaban would result in a budget impact of (-R$46,155)
in 4 years for knee and hip replacement cases. The potential impact for cost offsets
for the whole private system would be of (-R$8.3 million). Under the perspective of
13th Euro Abstracts
a hospital performing 50 knee and 50 hip surgeries every year, this potential for costoffsets would be of (-R$108,850). This would vary a lot for the perspective of HMOs
and hospitals of different sizes, as well as depending on the costs of each decision
maker, demanding constant customization of parameters. CONCLUSIONS: The use
of IEI makes the pharmacoeconomic studies results more intelligible to decision
makers, permitting them to foresee their actual application on a real practice, in different scenarios.
PMS73
LINKAGE OF ADMINISTRATIVE AND MEDICAL RECORDS DATABASES
FOR INVESTIGATING PHARMACEUTICAL USE AND OUTCOMES
Huse DM1, Bizier R1, Tomic K2
1
Thomson Reuters, Cambridge, MA, USA; 2Thomson Reuters, Washington, DC, USA
BACKGROUND: Use of electronic health care databases to examine pharmaceutical
use and effects faces limitations inherent in the source of data. Medical records document prescribing but not consumption of medication; administrative databases document dispensing but not the original intent of the prescriber. OBJECTIVES: To
evaluate a patient-level linked database of electronic medical records (EMR) and
administrative claim for use in measuring both prescribing and dispensing of pharmaceuticals. METHODS: Claims data from Thomson Reuters MarketScan database were
linked to the GE Centricity EMR database using probabilistic methods to overcome
the de-identification required of both databases under US privacy laws. Patient-level
records were matched based on demographic characteristics and calendar dates of
physician visits. Multiple visits were required to reduce the likelihood of mismatches.
The agreement between prescribing records in the EMR and claims for dispensing of
medication was explored in the context of self-administered medication for osteoporosis, including bisphosphonates and raloxifene. RESULTS: Using data from 2004–
2009, 219,529 patients were matched between the two data sources. Mean age was
43 years and 57% were female. We identified 2,331 patients whose medical record
showed new prescriptions for bisphosphonates or raloxifene (no evidence of use in
the prior 180 days). Pharmacy claims indicated these prescriptions were filled by 56%
of patients within 7 days, 75% within 30 days, and 86% within 90 days. CONCLUSIONS: It is to be expected that there will be some degree of noncompliance, hence
incomplete filling of prescriptions, as observed. The lag from dispensing to prescribing
among many patients is also consistent with use of samples for initial prescriptions.
Overall, the example of osteoporosis therapy shows consistency between prescribing
in EMR data and dispensing in claims data among a sample of probabilistically linked
patient records.
PMS74
CLAIMS-BASED SEVERITY INDEX FOR RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS FROM
HEALTH CARE CLAIMS DATA
Baser O1, Gust C2, Akin C3
1
STATinMED Research/University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA; 2STATinMED Research,
Ann Arbor, MI, USA; 3STATinMED Research/Brigham and Women’s Hospital, Ann Arbor,
MI, USA
OBJECTIVES: Controlling for disease severity in observational studies is crucial to
get an estimate with no selection bias. However, outcomes research studies using
claims data, contain no information about disease severity. Therefore, comorbid scores
are used for a proxy for the disease severity. There exists no severity score specific for
rheumatoid arthritis (RA). The goal of this study was to develop a severity index for
rheumatoid arthritis (SIFRA) for private health care claims data. METHODS: We
extracted the following variables related to rheumatoid arthritis from the claims data:
total number of synthetic disease-modifying anti-rheumatic drugs (DMARDs), total
number of biological DMARDs, tests for C-reactive protein (CRP) and erythrocyte
sedimentation rate (ESR) ordered, rehabilitation visits, rheumatology visits, Felty’s
syndrome and Sjogren’s syndrome, pulmonary, soft tissue nodules, joint surgery,
number of platelet counts and chemical panels ordered, and rheumatoid factors
testing. a linear regression model was used to create the severity score. The severity
score was compared with the rheumatoid arthritis medical records-based index of
severity (RARBIS) and currently-used comorbidity scores to proxy severity in outcomes research studies related with rheumatoid arthritis. RESULTS: According to the
Akaike Information Criterion (AIC), Bayesian Information Criterion (BIC), log likelihood function, R-squared values and average squared prediction error, SIFRA performed better than RARBIS, Charlson Comorbidity Score (CCI), Elixhauser
comorbidity score and Chronic disease score. Spearman correlation with RARBIS was
0.65 and significant. However, the correlation with the Charlson Comorbidity Index
(0.1, p = 0.6521), Elixhauser Index (0.15, p = 0.5312) and Chronic disease score (0.13,
p = 0.6011) were low and insignificant. CONCLUSIONS: Comorbidity scores (Charlson, Elixhauser or Chronic Disease Scores) commonly used in outcomes research are
inadequate to be proxy variable for RA patients. SIFRA, at least for rheumatoid
arthritis, controls for disease severity better than any other commonly used measure.
PMS75
MODELING OF RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS: A METHODOLOGICAL
APPROACH
Taylor MJ1, Righetti C1, Conway P2, Lebmeier M3
1
University of York, York, UK; 2Wyeth Pharmaceuticals, Maidenhead, UK; 3Bristol-Myers
Squibb Pharmaceuticals Ltd, Uxbridge, Middlesex, UK
OBJECTIVES: Reimbursement agencies like the United Kingdom (UK) National Institute for health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) use mathematical modelling to analyze
A317
the costs and benefits of health care technologies. The structure of these models is not
pre-specified, but dependent on the requirements of the decision problem on hand.
Various decision-analytic models have been developed to assess the potential clinical
and economic benefits of several RA treatment regimes, including anti-TNF agents
and early use of disease-modifying anti-rheumatic drugs (DMARDs). The main objective is to provide a guide on how to model treatment options for early rheumatoid
arthritis, in particular etanercept. Thus, it sought to address the methodological issues
relating to the choice of modeling technique. RESULTS: Previous analyses have used
a variety of modelling approaches to model treatment options for RA. The rationale
for the choice of model structure is rarely discussed in published studies and can affect
the results produced. Advances in the treatment of RA make it necessary to develop
a model which is flexible enough to account for different attributes (e.g. clinical remission, radiographic non-progression, and functional status), but does not increase the
complexity of the model to an amount where it becomes too difficult to populate it
with relevant data. Individual level models offer a solution to this problem by simulating the progression of each individual with different characteristics, where nonMarkovian distributions allow greater flexibility in modelling the timing of events.
Further, based on the characteristics of the disease, the model should assume independence between individuals, whilst, based on its treatment options, as assessment of
adequate treatment response is important, time should be modeled. CONCLUSIONS:
This work suggests that future analyses should use individual sampling models (e.g.
simulated patient-level Markov models) for modelling the costs and benefits of treatments for RA.
PMS76
A LONGITUDINAL COMPARISON OF MAPPING EQUATIONS DERIVED
FROM BASELINE AND POST-INTERVENTION DATA
Kontodimopoulos N1, Bozios P2, Elmatzoglou I2, Raftakis I2, Yfantopoulos J3, Niakas D1
1
Hellenic Open University, Patras, Greece; 2Asklipieio Voulas General Hospital, Voula,
Greece; 3National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, Athens, Greece
OBJECTIVES: Mapping from disease-specific to utility measures is a research area
gaining increasing attention. However, few studies have assessed the longitudinal
validity of mapping models and none, to our knowledge, have compared models
derived from baseline and post-intervention patient data. This study examined models
derived from time-differing patient data, for mapping the Modified Health Assessment
Questionnaire (MHAQ) on to the EQ-5D. METHODS: A total of 120 rheumatoid
arthritis patients (60.0% female, mean age 59.0) completed the MHAQ and EQ-5D
at baseline, and 3, 6 and 12 months after administration of an anti-TNFa or another
biological agent. OLS regression produced mapping equations from baseline and postintervention data. Model predictive ability and explanatory power were assessed by
root mean square error (RMSE) and adjusted R2 respectively. Pearson’s r and intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) assessed association and level of agreement between
predicted and reported utilities. RESULTS: R2 (baseline, 3, 6 and to 12 months) was
0.452, 0.418, 0.541 and 0.413 respectively, whereas prediction errors were 13.0%,
11.1%, 8.1% and 7.2%. All equations produced a range of scores comparable to
those achieved by the standard EQ-5D scoring algorithm, as well as strong correlations
and agreement between reported and predicted utilities. The baseline and 12-month
models appeared to under- and overestimate EQ-5D scores respectively, whereas the
6-month model generated the smallest differences, typically less than the minimally
important difference for the EQ-5D (0.03). CONCLUSIONS: Baseline data, which
typically corresponds to lower patient HRQOL, may give mapping equations with
compromised predictive ability, compared to models generated from post-intervention
data, and this study showed that this factor is worth examining when longitudinal
data are available. The next step in this line of research is to test QALY estimates and
cost-utility increments derived from baseline and post-intervention mapping
algorithms.
PMS77
THE DETERMINANTS OF SOCIAL ROLES AMONG RHEUMATOID
ARTHRITIS PATIENTS—DATA FROM THE NDB PORTUGAL COHORT
Chaves I1, Marques R1, Vasconcelos J1, Pedro S1, Rodrigues A1, Michaud K2, Wolfe F3,
Garcia E1
1
BioEPI, Clinical and Translational Research Center, Oeiras, Portugal; 2University of Nebraska
Medical Center, Omaha, NE, USA; 3National Databank for Rheumatic Diseases, Wichita, KS,
USA
BACKGROUND: An important consequence of rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is disability, traditionally assessed by the Health Assessment Questionnaire (HAQ), which
captures the physical component. Disability can also be evaluated by restricted performance of social roles and those predictors haven’t been extensively studied. OBJECTIVES: Determinants of social roles, among RA patients, as evaluated by paid work
and social functioning were studied. METHODS: A total of 1,140 RA patients from
the NDB-Portugal longitudinal cohort were analyzed. Univariate (UV) and Multivariate (MV) generalized estimating equations were used to assess whether the following
factors were determinants of paid work (1 = yes 0 = no, OR; 95%CI) and of SF-36
social functioning (0–100, 100 is best, β; 95%CI): age, sex, marital status, educational
level, number of people living in patient’s household, dependence on others, RA duration, number of major comorbidities, TNF, anxiolytic and/or antidepressant use,
HAQ, disease activity (RADAI), quality of life (VASQOL), pain, fatigue and sleep
disturbances (VAS scales, 0–10, 10 is worst). RESULTS: In MV analysis the odds of
having a form of paid work increased with higher education (1.17; 1.12, 1.22) and
better VASQOL (1.92; 1.15, 3.20) and decreased with higher age (0.91; 0.90, 0.93),
A318
longer disease duration (0.96; 0.94, 0.98) and worse HAQ (0.74; 0.60, 0.92). Social
functioning improved with better VASQOL (8.62; 3.32, 13.91), but worsened with
more comorbidities (−0.92; −1.49, −0.35), anxiolytic and/or antidepressant use (−5.33;
−7.68, −2.98), worse RADAI (−1.54; −2.80, −0.28), HAQ (−8.38; −10.51, −6.25) and
fatigue (−1.06; −1.48, −0.65). Furthermore, the mechanism by which RADAI affected
social functioning did not appear to be through pain (0.20; −0.43, 0.84), but through
HAQ as it absorbed 56% of the explanatory power of RADAI. CONCLUSIONS:
Performance of social roles was limited among RA patients with more HAQ disability,
and improved by better quality of life. Disease activity appeared to influence social
functioning through worse physical disability but not through pain.
PMS78
WORSE 6-MONTH BASELINE HAQ AND THE SELF-REPORTED
RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS DISEASE ACTIVITY INDEX PREDICT
IMPROVEMENT IN THEIR SCORES 6 MONTHS LATER, AMONG
RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS PATIENTS
Vasconcelos J1, Pedro S1, Marques R1, Chaves I1, Rodrigues A1, Michaud K2, Wolfe F3,
Garcia E1
1
BioEPI, Clinical and Translational Research Center, Oeiras, Portugal; 2University of Nebraska
Medical Center, Omaha, NE, USA; 3National Databank for Rheumatic Diseases, Wichita, KS,
USA
BACKGROUND: Disease activity and disability should be assesssed at each rheumatoid arthritis (RA) patient visit to monitor response to therapy. Disease activity has
been traditionally evaluated by the disease activity scale (DAS-28) and the ACR criteria, which depend on physicians, but few studies have analyzed short-term predictors
of the patient self-reported RA disease activity index-RADAI. Disability is routinely
assessed by the health assessment questionnaire (HAQ) whose long term predictors,
but not short-term, have been extensively studied. OBJECTIVES: To analyze whether
the 6-month baseline levels of HAQ and of RADAI and other factors predict change
at 6-month intervals. METHODS: RA patients from the biannual NDB-Portugal
cohort were used. For each patient, differences between two consecutive 6-month
intervals were computed for HAQ (0–3, 3 is worse) and RADAI (0–10, 10 is worse).
For each scale, a binary outcome was constructed based upon these differences, where
a positive increment meant worsening in function and disease activity. Patients’ observations whose increments were null were excluded. Univariate (UV) and multivariate
(MV) generalized estimating equations were used. Factors included age, sex, marital
status, disease duration, education level, number of major comorbidities, paid work
status and 6-month baseline HAQ and RADAI levels. RESULTS: MV analyses
revealed that the main predictors of HAQ were baseline HAQ: (OR: 0.49, 95% CI
0.44, 0.54), number of comorbidities (1.09 (1.05, 1.14)), and age (1.02 (1.01, 1.02));
For RADAI they were, baseline RADAI (0.69 (0.66, 0.73)), comborbidities (1.11
(1.07, 1.16)), and educational level (0.95 (0.93, 0.97)). CONCLUSIONS: Worse
baseline levels of HAQ and RADAI predicted their respective improvement 6-months
later. This could be due to optimization of treatment strategies when worse baseline
scores are detected, but whatever the reason, performing these two patient reported
outcomes are a quick and non-rheumatologist dependent way to improve patients’
disease status over 6-month intervals.
PMS79
USE OF PATIENT-REPORTED OUTCOMES IN ON-LINE COMMUNITIES
TO CONDUCT OBSERVATIONAL COMPARATIVE EFFECTIVENESS
RESEARCH: A PILOT STUDY IN RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS
Cascade E1, Bharmal M2
1
iGuard, Rockville, MD, USA; 2Quintiles, Rockville, MD, USA
OBJECTIVES: The demand for comparative effectiveness research (CER) data from
payers, physicians, and patients is significant, but the cost and time associated with
prospective randomized trials is a barrier to rapid decision-making. Use of patientreported outcomes (PROs) collected via on-line patient communities provides one
channel for rapid data collection, particularly in conditions such as rheumatoid arthritis (RA), where validated PRO instruments are available. METHODS: A random
sample of iGuard.org members in the US treated with non-steroidal anti-inflammatory
drug (NSAIDs), oral disease-modifying antirheumatic drugs (DMARDs), or biologics
for RA completed the Rheumatoid Arthritis Disease Activity Index (RADAI) and a series
of other questions related to their disease. iGuard.org is a free medication monitoring
service that is introduced to patients through multiple sources including physician,
pharmacy and online referrals. For this study, we report pilot baseline data on patientreported RADAI, pain, and joint counts across the three treatment groups to demonstrate use of on-line communities in supporting CER. RESULTS: A total of 153 RA
patients completed the study: 49 treated with NSAIDs only, 51 exposed to oral
DMARDs, and 53 exposed to biologics. The mean (SD) RADAI score was 4.59 (2.16).
Adjusting for age and gender and multiple comparisons, there were significant differences between the three treatment groups on RADAI scores (p = 0.0045) and patient
global assessment of pain (p = 0.0357) but not on the number of painful joints (p =
0.3512). The trend was towards patients on NSAIDs only having worse outcomes
compared to patients on biologics or patients on oral DMARDs. CONCLUSIONS:
This pilot study demonstrates the possibility of collecting baseline disease severity data
directly from patients using the RADAI, which is sensitive to detect differences by
treatment modality. The next step in the pilot program will be to investigate the
potential for capturing longitudinal disease progress information amongst patients in
on-line communities.
13th Euro Abstracts
RESPIRATORY-RELATED DISORDERS – Clinical Outcomes Studies
PRS1
RESPIRATORY SYNCYTIAL VIRUS PROPHYLAXIS IN SPECIAL
POPULATIONS
Paes BA1, Li A2, Lanctot KL2, Mitchell I3
1
McMaster University, Hamilton, ON, Canada; 2Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre,
Toronto, ON, Canada; 3University of Calgary, Calgary, AB, Canada
OBJECTIVES: To examine the pattern of palivizumab utilization and compliance in
infants with pre-existing disease within the Canadian Registry Database (CARESS).
METHODS: A prospective, registry of infants across 27 sites who received at least 1
dose of palivizumab during the 2006–2009 RSV seasons. Neonatal and demographic
data were collected from the parent/caregiver at enrollment. Data on palivizumab
utilization, compliance, and outcomes related to respiratory illness (RI) events were
collected monthly. Premature infants ≤35 completed weeks gestational age without
medical conditions who met standard approval criteria for palivizumab (Group 1)
were compared to those with underlying medical disorders who received prophylaxis
(Group 2). RESULTS: Group 1 (n = 3379) Group 2 (n = 489). Male: 56.8% versus
54.6% (P = 0.433). Average Enrollment Age (months) ± SD: 3.6 ± 3.4 versus 9.9 ±
8.8 (P = 0.000). Average GA (weeks) Mean ± SD: 31.0 ± 3.1 versus 37.1 ± 4.3 (P =
0.000). Average # injections ± SD: 3.6 ± 1.5 versus 3.7 ± 1.5 (P = 0.159). Hospitalization Rate (HR) for RI: 4.1% versus 9.2% (P = 0.000). RSV HR: 1.3% versus 2.7%
(P < 0.05). On average infants received 86.0% ± 28.3% of the expected number of
injections. Group 2 infants comprised Down syndrome (n = 118, 24.1%), upper
airway anomalies (n = 112, 22.9%), cystic fibrosis (n = 62, 12.7%), neuromuscular
impairment (n = 42, 8.6%), pulmonary (n = 38, 7.8%), multiple system disorders (n
= 34, 7.0%), cardiac (n = 17, 3.5%), immunocompromise (n = 8, 1.6%), and miscellaneous (n = 58, 11.9%). From 2006–2009, the proportion of Group 2 infants receiving prophylaxis increased 2-fold from 5.6% (69/1224) to12.2% (245/2016). Overall.
Group 2 infants were older at enrollment with more advanced GA and had significantly higher RI and RSV hospitalization rates. No serious adverse events directly
related to palivizumab occurred. CONCLUSIONS: Results imply that infants with
underlying medical disorders that are not approved for prophylaxis by advisory bodies
and current position statements are at greater risk for RSV infections and
hospitalization.
PRS2
CARESS: THE CANADIAN REGISTRY OF SYNAGIS (2006–2009)
1
2
2
3
Paes BA , Li A , Lanctot KL , Mitchell I
1
McMaster University, Hamilton, ON, Canada; 2Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre,
Toronto, ON, Canada; 3University of Calgary, Calgary, AB, Canada
OBJECTIVES: Palivizumab is used for respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) prophylaxis
in high risk children. Data on seasonality, risk factors, and outcomes are necessary to
evaluate the impact of palivizumab on the incidence of RSV infections, minimize health
care resources and identify which infant sub-sets are receiving prophylaxis.To determine current usage of palivizumab prophylaxis, compliance patterns, hospitalization
rate (HR) and outcomes in children at high-risk of respiratory syncytial virus (RSV)
infection through a Canadian Registry Database (CARESS). METHODS: A prospective, study of infants who received at least 1 dose of palivizumab in the 2006–2009
RSV seasons across 27 sites. Neonatal and demographic data were collected upon
enrolment. Parents/caregivers were contacted monthly for data on palivizumab utilization, compliance and outcomes related to any respiratory tract events. RESULTS: A
total of 4926 infants aged 2 days–47 months (mean = 5.4 months) were enrolled.
Participants were typically male (57.1%) and Caucasian (70.8%). Gestational age
(GA) was 32.2 ± 4.6 completed weeks. 3480 (70.6%) premature infants received
palivizumab (≤35 completed weeks GA), 403 (8.2%) required O2, 471 (9.6%) had
congenital heart disease and 572 (11.6%) were prophylaxed for other risk factors. On
average patients received 3.7 ± 1.5 injections, with 17,982 doses given overall. There
were no drug related serious adverse events.296 infants required 357 hospitalizations
for respiratory tract infections with a hospitalization rate of 6.0%. There were significant differences between indications for palivizumab (chi-square = 71.8, P < 0.005).
The overall RSV positive HR was 1.38%. Hospitalization rates were highest in infants
of aboriginal descent (15.0%, chi-square = 22.2, P < 0.005). Hospitalized infants had
a lower percentage of compliant injections (62.8% versus 68.6%, p = 0.003). CONCLUSIONS: The RSV HR in the 2006–2009 RSV seasons resembled several published
reports (range 1.3%–5.3%). RSV HR may be decreasing because of compliance with
palivizumab prophylaxis, variability in RSV epidemiology, hospital admission criteria
and preventive education.
PRS3
COMORBIDITY PROFILING OF COPD PATIENTS IN THE UNITED
KINGDOM PRIMARY CARE USING AN INCIDENCE BASED APPROACH
TO DETECT ASSOCIATIONS WITH THE DISEASE
Kiri VA
PAREXEL International, Uxbridge, London, UK
OBJECTIVES: Comorbidity is an important factor in any comparative assessment of
treatments associated with morbidity and mortality of patients. Many factor such as
age, gender and duration of a disease can influence the impact of comorbid diseases
on quality of life. In the health care setting (the primary source of data for most
observational studies), the decision to give a particular treatment to a particular
patient with a given disease is generally based on patient specific characteristics, the
most important of which is disease condition. Thus, confounding by indication/disease
13th Euro Abstracts
severity is a common source of bias. Consequently, failure to properly control for the
bias could lead to serious flaws in the study. METHODS: We used a novel approach
for identifying comorbidities associated with COPD by mapping the incident comorbidity patterns in the pre-COPD diagnosis period as well as over the course of the
disease using a retrospective cohort of patients aged 50+ in the UK General Practice
Research Database. Each patient was matched to another without COPD on year of
birth, sex, general practice and completed years of medical records up to at least a
year after the index date for COPD between 1990 and 1998. We identified 24,000
such pairs that also satisfied a requirement for at least one medical consultation and
at least one prescription for any drug in the year prior to the index date for COPD.
RESULTS: Based on trends in rate ratios, we found significant time-dependent associations between the incident COPD diagnosis and incident comorbid conditions such as
lung cancer, myocardial infarction, pneumonia, cardiac disorders, osteoporosis, fractures, skin bruises, psychiatric disorders and respiratory infections. CONCLUSIONS:
The results indicated interesting associations which could help improve our understanding of the natural history of COPD and its burden. This methodology can be
used to identify important comorbidities for effective comparative assessments.
PRS4
EFFECTIVENESS OF VARENICLINE COMPARED TO BUPROPION AND
NICOTINE REPLACEMENT THERAPY (NRT) FOR SMOKING CESSATION
IN TWO SMOKING SPECIALIZED UNITS OF THE SPANISH PRIMARY
CARE SETTING
Sicras-Mainar A1, Navarro-Artieda R2, Diaz-Cerezo S3, Sanz de Burgoa V4
1
Directorate of Planning, Badalona Serveis Assistencials, Badalona, Barcelona, Spain; 2Hospital
Universitari Germans Trias i Pujol, Barcelona, Spain; 3Complutense University of Madrid,
Madrid, Spain; 4Pfizer Spain, Alcobendas (Madrid), Spain
OBJECTIVES: The objective of this study was to estimate the effectiveness of varenicline, bupropion and nicotine replacement therapy (NRT) in smoking cessation in two
specialized smoking units belonging to primary care centers. METHODS: A multicenter longitudinal observational study was designed. Patient’s data were collected
retrospectively based on their clinical records. Patients over the age of 18, who initiated treatment of smoking cessation between January 1, 2006 and January 12, 2008
with varenicline, bupropion or NRT were included in the analysis. Patient’s follow-up
was conducted from time-baseline (day 1) and assessed at 6 and 12 months. Main
variables included in the study were: comorbidities, effectiveness (continuous abstinence) and pharmacological tolerability. Statistical analysis was performed by KaplanMaier survival curves; P < 0.05. RESULTS: A total of 957 smokers patients treated
with NRT (53.0%), bupropion (25.1%) and varenicline (21.9%) were included in the
analysis. The mean age of participants was 47.6 (11.3) years and 58.6% were men.
The average duration of smoking was 19.5 (6.7) years. At 6 months, 61.2% (95%
CI: 54.6–67.8%) of participants in the varenicline group were continuously abstinent
from smoking compared with 56.9% (95% CI: 50.6–63.2%) in the bupropion group
and 52.3% (95% CI: 48.0–56.6%) in the NRT group; p = 0.003. At 12 months, the
rate of continuous abstinence was 57.4% (95% CI: 50.7–64.1%) in the varenicline
group compared with 52.9% (95% CI: 46.6–59.2%) in the bupropion group and
47.1% (95% CI: 42.8–51.4%) in the NRT group; p = 0.002. Pharmacological tolerability was similar between groups except for symptoms of irritability which were
lower in the varenicline group: 4.3% compared to 8.3% in the bupropion group and
10.3% in the NRT group. CONCLUSIONS: Varenicline appeared to be an effective
and safety alternative compared with bupropion and NRT on smoking cessation in
the primary care setting.
PRS5
BUDESONIDE/FORMOTEROL PLUS TIOTROPIUM (BUD/FORM + TIO) VS.
SALMETEROL/FLUTICASONE PLUS TIOTROPIUM (SALM/FLU + TIO): A
SYSTEMATIC REVIEW AND ADJUSTED INDIRECT COMPARISON
BETWEEN TWO ALTERNATIVE TRIPLE TREATMENTS IN CHRONIC
OBSTRUCTIVE PULMONARY DISEASE (COPD)
Edwards SJ, Gray J
AstraZeneca UK Ltd, Luton, Bedfordshire, UK
OBJECTIVES: Use of triple therapy (long-acting beta2 agonist [LABA], inhaled corticosteroid [ICS] and long-acting muscarinic antagonist [LAMA]) for the treatment of
COPD has doubled in the UK over the past 5 years for all severities of the disease.
This research was designed to compare the two most commonly prescribed combination inhalers (BUD/FORM and SALM/FLU) as the basis of triple therapy with TIO,
the most widely used LAMA. METHODS: Systematic review of CENTRAL, EMBASE
and MEDLINE for randomised controlled trials (RCTs) in patients with COPD treated
with BUD/FORM+TIO or SALM/FLU+TIO was conducted in May 2010. Mixed
treatment comparison (MTC) using TIO as a common comparator was conducted
using a Bayesian Markov Chain Monte Carlo simulation. Fixed- and random-effects
models were explored with the preferred model selected based on the Deviance Information Criterion (DIC). Data was extracted from relevant trials on severe exacerbations (a composite of oral corticosteroids, hospitalizations and A&E visits due to
worsening symptoms). Summary effect estimate was calculated as odds ratio (OR)
with 95% credible interval (95% CrI) where OR < 1 favoured BUD/FORM+TIO and
OR > 1 favoured SALM/FLU+TIO. RESULTS: Of the 124 papers identified in the
literature search, 3 RCTs had comparable patient populations and were able to supply
data for analysis (1 BUD/FORM+TIO [N = 660] and 2 SALM/FLU+TIO [N = 301
and N = 60]). The exclusion of papers was based on not meeting all of the following
inclusion critieria: RCTs of the chosen comparators; COPD patient population;
reporting exacerbations; English-language full publication; and non-duplicates. When
A319
the fixed- and random-effects MTC models were compared the fixed-effects MTC had
the lowest DIC. The results indicate a 55% relative reduction in severe exacerbations
with BUD/FORM+TIO compared to SALM/FLU+TIO (OR 0.45, 95% CrI: 0.22 to
0.83). CONCLUSIONS: This MTC suggests that BUD/FORM-based triple therapy is
significantly more effective at reducing severe exacerbations than SALM/FLU-based
triple therapy.
PRS6
DEVELOPING AND APPLYING A STOCHASTIC DYNAMIC POPULATION
MODEL FOR CHRONIC OBSTRUCTIVE PULMONARY DISEASE
Hoogendoorn M1, Feenstra T2, Hoogenveen RT3, Al M1, Rutten-van Mölken MP1
1
Erasmus University, Rotterdam, The Netherlands; 2RIVM /UMCG, Bilthoven, The
Netherlands; 3National Institute for Public Health and the Environment (RIVM), Bilthoven,
The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: Modeling a chronic disease like COPD is useful to extrapolate (intermediate) treatment effects observed in short-term randomized trials to the medium or
long term. This study aimed to extend an existing dynamic population model of COPD
progression by including exacerbations and making the model stochastic. METHODS:
The COPD model starts with COPD prevalence in the Dutch population specified by
age, gender, disease severity (four severity stages) and smoking status. Each following
year the model simulates the changes in the prevalence and COPD-related health care
costs due to incidence, mortality and disease progression, i.e. annual decline in FEV1%
predicted.The structure was adjusted to include moderate and severe exacerbations
and the following input parameters were estimated by quantitative meta-analyses: the
frequency, case-fatality, lung function decline, quality of life loss and costs of exacerbations. The model was made stochastic by specifying probability distributions around
all important model parameters. The adapted model can be used to assess the impact
of interventions that influence COPD incidence, disease progression, frequency and/or
severity of exacerbations, mortality, quality of life or combinations of these effects. To
illustrate the potential use of the model, long- term costs and effects were projected
for four different COPD interventions, two on pharmacotherapy, one on smoking
cessation therapy and one on pulmonary rehabilitation. RESULTS: Compared to a
reference scenario representing minimal treatment, the cost-effectiveness of the four
interventions ranged from c6,100 to c12,200 per QALY gained. The probability of
the interventions to be cost-effective at a ceiling ratio of c20,000 varied from X to
Y%. CONCLUSIONS: The extended COPD model can provide policy makers with
information about long-term costs and effects of interventions over the entire chain,
from primary prevention to care for very severe COPD. Moreover it describes the
uncertainty of the outcomes.
PRS7
A COMPARISON OF CLINICAL EFFICACY AND SAFETY OF
CICLESONIDE WITH FLUTICASONE IN 1:1 AND 1:2 DOSE RATIOS IN
THE TREATMENT OF BRONCHIAL ASTHMA
Wojciechowski P, Stozek A, Rogoz A, Rys P, Wladysiuk M, Plisko R
HTA Consulting, Krakow, Poland
OBJECTIVES: This study compared efficacy and safety of ciclesonide (CIC) with
fluticasone (FP) in the treatment of bronchial asthma. METHODS: Comparison was
based on randomized controlled trials (RCTs) identified by means of systematic
review, carried out according to the Cochrane Collaboration guidelines. The most
important medical databases (EMBASE, MEDLINE, CENTRAL) were searched. Two
reviewers independently selected trials, assessed their quality and extracted data.
Meta-analysis of head-to-head trials was performed. RESULTS: Ten RCTs directly
comparing CIC vs. FP were identified and included in the analysis. Comparisons of
both interventions in 1:1 and 1:2 dose ratios were assessed in 8 and 5 trials, respectively. Efficacy of CIC was comparable to FP in both, 1:1 and 1:2 dose ratios with
respect to reduction in risk of asthma exacerbations, improvement in proportion of
symptom-free days, rescue medication-free days and improvement in asthma symptoms. Moreover, CIC and FP showed similar improvement in spirometric parameters.
Comparison between CIC and FP in 1:1 dose ratio revealed that treatment with CIC
was associated with statistically significant risk reduction of adverse events possibly
related to study medication (RR = 0.57 [0.39; 0.83]; NNT = 16.89 [10.24; 48.18])
and candidosis (RR = 0.31 [0.17; 0.56], NNT = 32.74 [22.23; 61.99]), while the
differences between groups were not significant for 1:2 dose ratio. There were no
statistically significant differences between CIC and FP in either dose ratio with respect
to the risk of any adverse events, upper respiratory tract infections, pharyngitis and
dysphonia. CONCLUSIONS: Ciclesonide is a therapeutic option for patients with
bronchial asthma showing comparable efficacy to fluticasone in both 1:1 and 1:2 dose
ratios and provides concomitant risk reduction of candidosis and adverse events
related to study medication.
PRS8
A COMPARISON OF CLINICAL EFFICACY AND SAFETY OF
CICLESONIDE WITH BUDESONIDE IN 1:1 AND 1:2 DOSE RATIOS IN
THE TREATEMENT OF BRONCHIAL ASTHMA
Wojciechowski P, Stozek A, Rogoz A, Rys P, Wladysiuk M, Plisko R
HTA Consulting, Krakow, Poland
OBJECTIVES: This study compared efficacy and safety of ciclesonide (CIC) with
budesonide (BUD) in the treatment of bronchial asthma. METHODS: Comparison
was based on randomized controlled trials (RCTs) identified by means of systematic
review, carried out according to the Cochrane Collaboration guidelines. The most
important medical databases (EMBASE, MEDLINE, CENTRAL) were searched. Two
A320
reviewers independently selected trials, assessed their quality and extracted data.
Meta-analysis of head-to-head trials was performed. RESULTS: Seven RCTs comparing CIC vs. BUD were identified and included in the analysis. Comparisons of both
interventions in 1:1 and 1:2 dose ratios were assessed in 3 and 4 trials, respectively.
CIC as compared with BUD in 1:1 dose ratio was associated with significant improvement in forced vital capacity (FVC) and peak expiratory flow (PEF) by spirometry
(WMD = 0.09 [0.03; 0.14] and WMD = 19.00 [2.37; 35.63], respectively) as well as
reduction in proportion of symptom-free days (p = 0.018). No statistically significant
differences between both drugs in 1:2 dose ratios were observed. CIC and BUD in
either dose showed comparable efficacy with respect to the risk of asthma exacerbation, improvement in symptoms of asthma and forced expiratory volume in 1 second
(FEV1). CIC-treated patients experienced less upper respiratory tract infections than
those treated with BUD in 1:1 dose ratio, however the difference was on the border
of statistical significance (RR = 0.65 [0.43; 0.99], NNT not significant). There were
no statistically significant differences between CIC and BUD in either dose ratio with
respect to risk of adverse events, adverse events related to study medication, pharyngitis and dysphonia. CONCLUSIONS: Ciclesonide provides an improvement in spirometric paramethers and reduction of asthma symptom-free days as compared to
budesonide in 1:1 dose ratio, while no differences were noticed between CIC and BUD
in 1:2 dose ratio. Safety profile of ciclesonide seems to be comparable with budesonide.
PRS9
QUALITY OF LIFE AND ECONOMIC IMPACT OF ASTHMA CONTROL IN
FRANCE AND SPAIN. FIRST RESULTS OF THE EU-COAST STUDY
Chouaid C1, Calvo Corbella E2, Com-ruelle L3, Brosa M4, Doz M5, Gueron B6
1
Hôpital St Antoine, Paris, France; 2Centro de Salud Universitario Pozuelo I. UAM., Madrid,
Spain; 3IRDES, Paris, France; 4Oblikue Consulting, Barcelona, Spain; 5CEMKA, Bourg La Reine,
France; 6GSK, London, England
OBJECTIVES: Current asthma management recommendations are based on the level
of asthma control rather than disease severity. The financial impact associated with
asthma control needs to be determined. The primary objective of this study was to
estimate quality of life and health care costs according to the patients’ level of asthma
control in France and in Spain. METHODS: An observational retrospective bottom-up
cost of illness study was conducted in adults patients with asthma. Investigators were
general practitioners. Asthma control was evaluated using the validated auto-test
Asthma Control Test (ACTTM) for a one month period and 2009 GINA’s asthma
control criteria for a three months period. Quality of life (QoL) was assessed using
EQ-5D profile. Costs (direct and indirect) were evaluated from a societal perspective.
RESULTS: 794 patients (France: 391; Spain: 403) were enrolled in the first quarterly
wave of the survey. Based on the ACT, asthma was determined to be well-controlled
(ACT ≥ 20) in 48.1% [IC 95%: 42.1%–54%] and 56.2% [IC95: 51.1%–61.2%] of
French and Spanish patients respectively. In both countries, EQ-5D scores were 0.9
and 0.7 in well-controlled and not well-controlled patients respectively (P < 0.0001).
Total costs of asthma were directly related to asthma control in both countries. The
average cost (Euros/month/patient) of well-controlled asthma was c28 (±36) in France
and c77 (±105) in Spain compared with c140 (±782) (p = 0.0009) and c252 (±380)
(p < 0.0001) respectively for not well-controlled asthma. Similar associations were
observed using the latest GINA’s criteria. CONCLUSIONS: We found strong associations between asthma control level, costs and QoL in patients with asthma. Achievement of good clinical control of asthma may result in a significant decrease of the
economic burden of asthma and a better health status in adults.
PRS10
TRENDS IN ANTI-ASTHMA MEDICATION USE IN DUTCH CHILDREN
FROM 1998 UNTIL 2007
Houweling LM, Penning FJ, Meijer WM
PHARMO Institute for Drug Outcomes Research, Utrecht, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: The prevalence of asthma has been reported to be increasing for
decades, but recent studies suggest a leveling off or even decrease in prevalence among
children. The objective of this study was to assess the trends in anti-asthma medication
use in Dutch children from 1998 until 2007. METHODS: From the PHARMO Record
Linkage System, an administrative database network of outpatient pharmacies, hospitals, and other settings, including data of ~4 million individuals in defined areas of
the The Netherlands, we assessed 1) the proportion of children aged 0–19 years with
at least one dispensing for short (SABA) or long-acting β2-antagonists (LABA), inhaled
glucocorticoids (ICS), fixed dose combinations (FDC) of LABA and ICS or leukotriene
receptor antagonists (LRTA) in the years 1998–2007 stratified by age groups, 2) the
proportion of users per type for each year and 3) the age distribution per medication
type for the year 2007. RESULTS: Overall prevalence of anti-asthma medication use
was approximately 7% and remained stable between 1998 and 2007. Prevalence was
highest among children aged 0–1 years and declined with increasing age. Over time,
the prevalence remained stable in all age groups, except for the youngest in which it
increased from 10% in 1998 to 19% in 2007. Use of ICS and LABA declined over
time (user proportions: −17% and −3%), against increased use of LABA-ICS FDC and
LRTA (+15% and +3%). Children <6 years made up relatively large proportions of
SABA and ICS users, while the older children were more dominant in the other medication types. CONCLUSIONS: This study provides a comprehensive overview of trends
in anti-asthma medication use in children showing no overall change in prevalence
over time. However, a change in type of medication was observed.
13th Euro Abstracts
RESPIRATORY-RELATED DISORDERS – Cost Studies
PRS11
COST ANALYSIS OF DIFFERENT PHARMACOTHERAPIES IN SUBJECTS
WITH CHRONIC OBSTRUCTIVE PULMONARY DISEASE IN THE PUBLIC
SECTOR OF HONG KONG
Lee KK1, Yu W2, Ko F3, Lee VW3, Chow DP3
1
Monash University Kuala Lumpur Sunway Campus, Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia; 2Princess
Margaret Hospital, Hong Kong, China; 3Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong
OBJECTIVES: To compare the impact of different pharmacotherapies on the cost of
exacerbation of COPD in public hospitals in Hong Kong. METHODS: This was a
retrospective study comparing the cost of management of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) in patients from a public hospital perspective in Hong Kong.
Institutional ethics approval was obtained. The patients were above 65 years with a
diagnosis of COPD of stage 3 or above based on the GOLD guideline. COPD was
defined based on ICD-9-CM codes. Two cohorts of patients were included: 1) Those
who received fluticasone propionate and salmeterol, plus ipratropium bromide and
salbutamol inhalation, and 2) Those who received ipratropium bromide and salbutamol, and beclomethasone inhalation. Patients were followed for 6 months before and
after medications. The date one of the therapies started was the index date. RESULTS:
A total of 75 patients were recruited over January to June 2008. All values are
expressed as mean ± SD. The number of emergency room visits and cost of visits
before and after the index date for both cohorts did not show a significant difference
(1.86 ± 2.5 days vs. 1.62 ± 1.93 days and HKD1061 ± 1442 vs. HKD924 ± 1102 for
cohort 1, 1.15 ± 1.28 days vs. 1.02 ± 1.29 days and HKD657 ± 730 vs. HKD582 ±
735 for cohort 2, p > 0.1). There was a trend of reduction in hospitalization days and
cost of stay before and after the index date for cohort 1 (although not reaching a
significant level) but not in cohort 2 (20.6 ± 28.4 days vs. 15.6 ± 18.8 days and
HKD68162 ± 93875 vs. HKD51662 ± 66278 for cohort 1, 11.1 ± 13.5 days vs. 10.2
± 13.2 days and HKD36730 ± 44604 vs. HKD33860 ± 43571 for cohort 2, p > 0.1).
CONCLUSIONS: A trend of reduction in hospital stay was demonstrated (although
not statistically significant) in patients after receiving combination therapy of fluticasone propionate and salmeterol plus ipratropium bromide and salbutamol. This is
consistent with earlier studies in other countries. a larger number of patients is
required to prove the significance of this finding.
PRS12
THE COST ANALYSIS OF BRONCHODILATOR PRESCRIPTIONS FOR
TREATMENT OF STABLE COPD IN UKRAINE
Tolubaiev V, Zalis’ka O
Danylo Halytsky Lviv National Medical University, Lviv, Ukraine
OBJECTIVES: To analyze the GP’s prescriptions of bronchodilators for managing the
patients with stable COPD, to compare the prescriptions with Ukrainian National
COPD Management Guidelines. And we estimated the annual costs for bronchodilators were used most frequently. METHODS: The analysis of prescription habits based
on data from outpatient personal medical cards of 103 patients with COPD (2nd
Municipal Clinic, Bila Tserkva, Ukraine), focused on bronchodilators as central medications for symptomatic treatment. Among 103 patients 15 were with mild COPD,
75 with moderate and 13 with severe (according to GOLD). The prescriptions for
regular treatment were compared with national guidelines. Annual medications costs
were calculated based on the number of medicines units for 24 hour bronchodilation
during a year, multiplied by the one unit price in UAH (1 EUR = 10.05 UAH).
RESULTS: Regular basis was prescribed to 87 patients. Among 87 prescriptions
13.7% were long-acting inhaled bronchodilators or combinations, 86.3% were shortacting inhaled bronchodilators, methylexanthines or combinations. Ranking to a
number of medicines were most frequently prescribed: 56.8% fixed combination
Ipratropium/Fenoterol, 10.2% Tiotropium, 9.1% Fenoterol, 7.9% Salbutamol.
Annual costs for these bronchodilators were: 1206.0, 6262.0, 1303.0 and 275.0 UAH,
respectively. CONCLUSIONS: The most frequently prescribed bronchodilator was
Ipratropium/Fenoterol. It’s available during decades and inexpensively. But its basis
requires triple daily medication, in consequence of that persistency rate might be
reduced with effectiveness reducing, respectively. Tiotropium ranked second in the
prescription frequency. It has duration of action of more than 24 hours, high effectiveness and safety levels but gets 6262.0 UAH annually. So the affordability of a bronchodilator is weighty criterion for Ukrainian GP’s prescriptions. But medications costs
must be scrupulously compared with effectiveness for their including to the national
formulary and reimbursement decision-making.
PRS13
ECONOMIC IMPACT OF NON-ADHERENCE TO GOLD GUIDELINES IN
COPD PATIENTS IN PRIMARY CARE IN SPAIN
Galera J1, Lahoz R1, Lleonart M1, Riera M1, Sicras-Mainar A2, Miravitlles M3
1
Novartis Pharma, Barcelona, Spain; 2Directorate of Planning, Badalona Serveis Assistencials,
Badalona, Barcelona, Spain; 3Hospital Clínic de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study is to analyze the economic impact of nonadherence to GOLD guidelines in COPD patients. METHODS: A retrospective analysis was carried out in a claim database. Patients ≥40 years-old with diagnosis of COPD
confirmed with spirometry (FEV1/FVC < 0.7) were eligible for this analysis. Patients
were classified into two groups according to whether they fulfill with therapeutics
recommendations by severity defined in GOLD guidelines (GOLD group) or those
who don’t fulfill (NO-GOLD group). Demographics, medical and use of resources
data were collected and direct and indirect costs were analyzed. a probabilistic mul-
13th Euro Abstracts
tivariate sensitivity analysis of avoided costs was carried out. All results are presented
annualized and costs expressed in c2009. RESULTS: A total of 1365 patients were
included, 79.5% males, mean (±SD) age was 71.4 (±10,3), mean FEV1 was 65.34%
and a COPD history of 5.5 (±2,9) years. Patients were divided into GOLD group and
NO-GOLD group and in stage II (FEV1 < 80% and ≥50%) and stage III (FEV1 < 50%
and ≥30%) for both groups. Total annual costs per patient were analyzed. Directs
costs analyzed were treatment, medical visits, emergency visits, hospital stay, laboratory, spirometry, radiology and oxigenotherapy. Indirect cost evaluated was sick leave.
Avoided costs between both groups will be analyzed, and confirmed with sensitivity
analysis. CONCLUSIONS: The results of this study will provide whether the adherence to the recommendations of the GOLD guidelines in COPD patients can lead to
significant savings to the Spanish health care system.
PRS14
THE POTENTIAL COST IMPACT OF USING A PEG HYDROGEL
SEALANT TO PREVENT AIR LEAKS AFTER LUNG RESECTION SURGERY
IN SPAIN
Ott M1, Larkin M2, Minshall M3
1
Covidien, Zurich, Switzerland; 2PRMA Consulting, Fleet, UK; 3Covidien, Fishers, IN, USA
OBJECTIVES: Persistent air leaks after lung resection surgery often lead to increased
complications including longer length of hospital stay and resulting treatment costs.
a PEG hydrogel sealant (PleuraSeal™) is used as an adjunct to standard closure of
pleural air leaks during lung resection surgery and has demonstrated shorter hospitalizations (1.7 fewer days; Wain JC et al, 2008, Conference Abstract) and more rapid
removal of chest tubes in a clinical study (Covidien, data on file) when compared with
standard closure (e.g. staples and sutures alone). Our study was designed to estimate
the potential cost offsets for using PleuraSeal™ compared with standard closure in
100 hypothetical patients from a Spanish hospital who had an air leak after lung
resection surgery using the cost offset from shorter hospital stays balanced against the
cost for PleuraSeal™. METHODS: We assumed the cost for PleuraSeal™ in Spain to
be c420 per treatment applied to all 100 hypothetical patients compared with no
added cost for standard closure. We then balanced the added cost for PleuraSeal™
with the reduction in number of hospital days and subsequent costs (c590/day [Varela
et al, 2006] @1.7 fewer days per patient) compared with standard closure and calculated the potential cost offset for PleuraSeal™. RESULTS: A Spanish hospital that
performs 100 lung resections with air leaks can expect to save c58,300, or approximately c583 per patient when compared to standard closure as patients who had air
leaks stayed in hospital an average of 1.7 days longer than those without air leaks.
CONCLUSIONS: The cost for PleuraSeal™ is completely offset by the shorter length
of hospital stay compared with standard closure inSpain. PleuraSeal™ is a compelling
option for Spanish hospitals that perform lung resection surgeries as the cost of the
treatment is completely offset by the reduction in air leaks and subsequent shorter
hospital stay.
PRS15
THE POTENTIAL COST IMPACT OF USING A PEG HYDROGEL
SEALANT TO PREVENT AIR LEAKS AFTER LUNG RESECTION SURGERY
IN ITALY
Ott M1, Larkin M2, Minshall M3
1
Covidien, Zurich, Switzerland; 2PRMA Consulting, Fleet, UK; 3Covidien, Fishers, IN, USA
OBJECTIVES: Persistent air leaks after lung resection surgery often lead to increased
complications. a PEG hydrogel sealant (PleuraSeal™) is used as an adjunct to standard
closure of pleural air leaks and has demonstrated shorter hospitalizations (1.7 fewer
days; Wain JC et al, 2008, Conference Abstract) when compared with standard of
care (e.g. staples and sutures alone). Our study was designed to estimate the potential
cost offsets for using PleuraSeal™ in 100 hypothetical patients with an air leak using
the cost offset from shorter hospital stays balanced against the cost for PleuraSeal™.
METHODS: We assumed the cost for PleuraSeal™ in Italy to be c420 per treatment
applied to all 100 hypothetical patients compared with no added cost for standard of
care. We then balanced the cost for PleuraSeal™ with the reduction in hospital days
and subsequent costs (c337/ thoracic ward day, a Brunelli et al, 2007), then calculated
the potential cost offset for PleuraSeal™. RESULTS: An Italian hospital that performs
100 lung resections with air leaks can expect to save c15,300, or approximately c153
per patient when compared to standard of care as patients who had air leaks stayed
in hospital an average of 1.7 days longer than those without air leaks. CONCLUSIONS: The cost for PleuraSeal™ is completely offset by the shorter length of hospital
stay compared with standard of care in Italy. PleuraSeal™ is a compelling option for
Italian hospitals that perform lung resection surgeries as the cost of the treatment is
completely offset by the reduction in air leaks and subsequent shorter hospital stay.
PRS16
PITFALLS IN THERAPEUTIC REFERENCE PRICING PRACTICE OF THE
MEDICATION OF ASTHMA
Kalo Z1, Abonyi-Tóth Z2, Bártfai Z3, Tímár G4, Vokó Z1
1
Eötvös Loránd University, Budapest, Hungary; 2RxPress Ltd, Budapest, Hungary; 3Elisabeth
Teaching Hospital Sopron, Sopron, Hungary; 4Syreon Research Institute, Budapest, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: Therapeutic reference pricing (TRP) is one of the most frequently
employed methods for cost-containment of pharmaceuticals. The Hungarian National
Health Insurance Fund (NHIF) applies TRP based on DDD, yet even the WHO objects
to using DDD in pricing and reimbursement decisions. Our objective was to compare
actual drug use to DDD and to evaluate whether TRP based on DDD could result in
A321
savings in the costs of maintenance medication and the total direct health expenditures
between asthma patients treated with Symbicort Turbuhaler (SYT) and Seretide Diskus
(SED). METHODS: Real world data for the analysis was derived from the NHIF
database. Actual drug use and average costs were compared in four groups (high dose
SYT, medium dose SYT, high dose SED and medium dose SED). Multiple linear
regression was employed to adjust data for the differences in gender and age distribution of patients. RESULTS: A total of 12,260 patients using SED and 15,539 patients
using SYT for asthma were involved into the analysis. Average drug use was lower in
both groups than DDD. Patients used 1.38–1.95 inhalations in both SED groups,
1.28–1.97 inhalations in the high dose SYT group, and 1.74–2.49 inhalations in the
medium dose SYT group. Although the daily therapeutic cost of medium dose SED
based on DDD would be much lower than the cost of SYT, no difference was found
in the actual cost of the maintenance therapy or the total medical costs. CONCLUSIONS: Our analysis provides evidence about the limitation of employing daily
therapy costs according to DDD for TRP. No relationship was found between the
daily therapeutic costs calculated using the NHIF methodology and costs of real drug
use, in real world TRP did not lead to the reduction of expenditures from the payer’
perspective. Potential confounding factors may limit the generalizability of
conclusions.
PRS17
COST OF CHRONIC OBSTRUCTIVE PULMONARY DISEASE: A HEALTH
CARE ADMINISTRATIVE DATABASES ANALYSIS
Fornari C1, Di Stasi F2, Blasi F3, Conti S1, Mantovani LG4, Merlino L5, Cesana G1
1
University of Milano—Bicocca, Monza, MB, Italy; 2Nycomed S.p.a., Milan, MI, Italy; 3University
of Milan—IRCCS Fondazione Ospedale Maggiore Policlinico Cà Granda, Milan, MI, Italy;
4
Federico II University of Naples, Naples, Italy; 5Regional Health Authority of Lombardy,
Milan, MI, Italy
OBJECTIVES: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) currently represents
the fifth leading cause of death worldwide and it’s estimated to rise to the third cause
by 2030. Few studies have estimated the burden of COPD. The aim of this study was
to evaluate consumption and cost of health care resources of severe COPD patients
in the general population from the Italian health care system perspective. METHODS:
Data were extracted from Healthcare Administrative Databases (HADs) of the region
of Lombardy, which covers a population of 9.2 million members. HADs related to
eligibility criteria, hospital admissions, pharmaceutical and outpatient claims have
been organized in a data warehouse using probabilistic record linkage. The study
included subjects aged more than 18 years that in 2003 had at least one hospitalization
with COPD as the main diagnosis or as the second one when the main was: pneumonia, respiratory or heart failure, pneumothorax and acute pulmonary heart disease.
Subjects were followed for two years collecting information on health care resource
and vital status. Severe and moderate exacerbations of COPD were respectively
defined as hospitalizations for COPD and as prescriptions of corticosteroids and/or
antibiotics after the index hospitalization. RESULTS: We selected 16,476 patients
with age mean 76 years and an average follow-up of 19 months. The 38% of patients
were women with mean age three years higher than men. Subjects with severe exacerbations had on average 4.4 moderate and 1.9 severe episodes after the index hospitalization. The mean annual cost for these patients was c11,824 (IC95%
11,554–12,079). Patients with only moderate exacerbations had on average 3.9 moderate exacerbations and the mean annual cost was c6413 (IC95% 6288–6549). Costs
were steady in time. CONCLUSIONS: The burden of COPD is important both in
frequency and cost; it requires an effort in programming new health services particularly devoted to aging population.
PRS18
HEALTH CARE COSTS OF INDIVIDUALS WITH AND WITHOUT COPD
IN SWEDEN
Jansson SA1, Stenling A2, Backman H1, Rönmark E1, Lindberg A1, Lundbäck B1
1
The OLIN Studies, Luleå, Sweden; 2AstraZeneca Nordic MC, Södertälje, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: This analysis estimates the health care costs (hospitalizations and
outpatient visits) due to respiratory and co-morbid diseases in a cohort of subjects
with and without COPD in Sweden. METHODS: A cohort of individuals was identified in earlier clinical examinations of the general population within the Obstructive
Lung Disease in Northern Sweden (OLIN) Studies. The cohort consisted initially of
993 subjects fulfilling criteria (GOLD) for COPD and an age- and gender matched
control group of same size without obstructive lung function impairment. Since 2005,
these subjects have been invited to yearly interviews and examinations. The participation rate has been high, above 85%. This analysis is based on resource use data collected in 2006 (n = 772 COPD, n = 802 non-COPD). Unit costs from the Northern
health care region price list of 2010 were used. RESULTS: The mean health care costs
of all diseases amounted to c1421 (median c236) annually per subject with COPD
compared to c1127 (median c169) for subjects without COPD (p = 0.16, nonparametric Mann-Whitney). The mean costs in relation to disease severity were
(GOLD criteria severity stage; p-value COPD vs. non-COPD): c1166 (mild; p = 0.66),
c1755 (moderate; p = 0.28), c2223 (severe+very severe; P < 0.01). a minor part of the
costs was attributable to respiratory diseases; 5.8% in non-COPD subjects and 10.5%
in subjects with COPD. Respiratory disease costs were statistically significantly higher
among subjects with COPD in all disease severity stages. CONCLUSIONS: The mean
annual health care costs were c294 (median c67) higher for subjects with COPD. The
difference in costs between subjects with severe+very severe COPD and subjects
without the disease was statistically significant.
A322
PRS19
ASSESSMENT OF THE CLINICAL AND ECONOMIC IMPACT OF AIR
LEAKS DURING POST-OPERATIVE PULMONARY SURGERY USING THE
MEDICARE POPULATION
Gemmen E1, Doyle J2, Smith BF3, Garvert W4, Proach J5, Long J5, Nagel MP6
1
Quintiles, Rockville, MD, USA; 2Quintiles Global Consulting, Hawthorne, NY, USA;
3
Quintiles Consulting, Durham, NC, USA; 4Quintiles, Falls Church, VA, USA; 5Triage
HealthCom, LLC, Lawrenceville, NJ, USA; 6Neomend, Inc., Irvine, CA, USA
OBJECTIVES: Estimate the clinical and economic impact to U.S. hospitals of air leaks
during post-operative pulmonary surgery using the Medicare Provider Analysis and
Review (MEDPAR) data set. METHODS: The 2008 The Medicare Provider Analysis
and Review (MEDPAR) data set contains records for 100% of Medicare beneficiaries
who use hospital inpatient services. For all stays with pulmonary surgery, length of
stay (LOS), total charges, and in-hospital mortality rates were compared between those
stays including an air leak vs. those stays without an air leak. Unadjusted results were
calculated using descriptive statistics (mean, median, frequencies, etc.) Adjusted results
were calculated using multivariate regression analysis while controlling for age and
gender. RESULTS: There were a total of 41,348 hospital inpatient stays with pulmonary surgery in the 2008 MEDPAR data set, of these 8,774 (21.2%) included air leak
and 32,574 (78.8%) of which did not. In the MEDPAR data set patients with pulmonary surgery stays including air leak had a similar age distribution to patients without
air leak, had a longer LOS on average (10.7 days vs. 7.2 days; P < .0001), had more
total charges ($78,830 vs. $63,528; P < .0001) and were nearly equally likely to die
during their stay (14.8% vs. 13.94%; p = 0.057). After adjusting for differences in
age and gender between the two groups, the incremental LOS and total charges due
to the presence of air leak is 3.4 days and $14,532 respectively. The total additional
economic impact of having an air leak after pulmonary surgery, estimated by applying
patient level adjusted charges to the incidence of air leak, is $127.5 million. CONCLUSIONS: The clinical and economic impact to U.S. hospitals of air leaks during or
following major pulmonary surgery is significant. The reduction of these air leaks
could save considerable hospital resources, payer dollars and patient lives.
PRS20
OUTCOMES ASSOCIATED WITH IATROGENIC PNEUMOTHORAX
1
2
Stemkowski S , Braxton JC
1
Lovelace Respiratory Research Institute, Kannapolis, NC, USA; 2Davidson College, Davidson,
NC, USA
OBJECTIVES: Iatrogenic pneumothorax occurs when air or gas becomes present in
the pleural cavity following medical treatment. Besides subjecting the patient to
unnecessary health risks, iatrogenic pneumothorax leads to an increased amount of
health care resources including observed through patient cost, length of stay, and
inpatient mortality. This research aims to quantify the incremental effects of iatrogenic
pneumothorax on these three outcomes. METHODS: Discharge records from Premier’s Perspective database of US inpatients who underwent inpatient pulmonary
surgery and were discharged in 2007 were examined. The definition of iatrogenic
pneumothorax consistent with ICD-9-CM code 512.1 was used to classify patients.
Chi-square tests were used to detect differences between iatrogenic pneumothorax
patients and non-iatrogenic pneumothorax patients for three outcomes. Multivariable
regression models were used to obtain more precise estimates of the incremental effects
of iatrogenic pneumothorax on outcomes while controlling for comorbidities, demographic variables and the patient’s primary treatment. RESULTS: A total of 112,827
patients were analyzed (8,482 with iatrogenic pneumothorax). Chi-square tests demonstrated that patients with iatrogenic pneumothorax were older (P < 0.0001), had
lower hospital costs (P < 0.0001), a shorter length of stay (P < 0.0001), and lower
mortality rate (P < 0.0001). Log linear modeling demonstrated iatrogenic pneumothorax increases patient costs by 10.49% (95%CI: 8.76%–12.23%). Negative binomial
models showed iatrogenic pneumothorax increases patients length of stay by 8.01%
(95% CI: 6.21%–9.82%), while no difference was found with respect to mortality.
CONCLUSIONS: The incremental effects of iatrogenic pneumothorax are shown to
significantly increase patient costs and length of stay but not inpatient mortality.
PRS21
BURDEN OF BRONCHIAL ASTHMA AND CHRONIC OBSTRUCTIVE
PULMONARY DISEASE IN RUSSIA
Omelyanovsky VV1, Avksentieva MV1, Derkach EV1, Tsfasman FM2, Sveshnikova ND1
1
Research Center for Clinical and Economic Evaluation and Pharmacoeconomics, Moscow,
Russia; 2Institute of Clinico-Economic Expertise and Pharmacoeconomics, RSMU, Moscow,
Russia
OBJECTIVES: to assess social and economic burden of a Bronchial asthma and
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease in Russian Federation. METHODS: “Cost
of illness” analysis was performed. Available data on epidemiology of bronchial
asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in the Russian Federation has been
analyzed. Experts were questioned to describe the common practice of treating patients
with bronchial asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Direct costs, indirect costs and intangible costs were calculated. RESULTS: According to the state
registration data, in 2007 the number of patients with bronchial asthma was 1.3
million and with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease— 2.4 million. The burden of
bronchial asthma incorporates direct costs (c220.9 million), indirect costs (c67.4
million) and intangible costs (c69.6 million). The burden of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease is c210.6 million, c212 million, c207 million for direct costs, indirect
costs and intangible costs respectively. Cost of BA and COPD is c987.8 million.
13th Euro Abstracts
CONCLUSIONS: According to the results of the analysis Bronchial asthma and
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease proved to be an important medical and social
problem in Russian Federation.
PRS22
COST OF COPD IN POLAND
Jahnz-Rozyk KM, Targowski T, From S, Faluta T, Borowiec L
Military Institute of Medicine, Warsaw, Poland
OBJECTIVES: About two million people suffer from COPD in Poland. The aim of
this study was to examine direct, mean costs of COPD in Poland under usual clinical
practice form societal perspective. METHODS: It was an observational retrospective
and prospective bottom-up-cost-of- illness study, based on a retrospective sample of
patients presenting with COPD. Total medical resources consumption of a sample of
COPD patients were collected in 2008 year trough physician—lung specialists. Direct
costs of COPD were evaluated based on data from different populations of five clinical
hospitals and eight ambulatory cares. Medical resource consumptions were categorized by investigators as usual COPD follow up and number and severity of exacerbations.Resources utilization and cost data are summarised as mean values per patient
per year; 95% confidence intervals were derived using percentile bootstrapping.
RESULTS: In patients studied, number of free –of- exacerbation days was 331, 1,
mean number of outpatient exacerbation was 1.27, mean number of exacerbations
requiring hospital was 0.24. Average total medical resource consumption of a COPD
patient per year was c1006.1. Among this cost c605 was directly related to treatment
of stable COPD (costs of drugs, additional exams, costs of medical visits, influenza
vaccination and home oxygen therapy), c105.3 to outpatient exacerbation, and c295.8
to exacerbation treated in hospital. CONCLUSIONS: The burden of COPD itself
appeared to be considerable magnitude from societal perspective in Poland. Overall,
the main cost drivers were inpatient care and prescription medication.
PRS23
COMPARISON OF DIFFERENT METHODS FOR ASSESSING
ATTRIBUTABLE COSTS: A CASE OF MEDICAL COSTS ATTRIBUTABLE
TO OBESE IN PATIENTS WITH ASTHMA
Suh DC1, Kim CM2, Choi IS3, Lee DH4, Jang SM5, Kwon JW3, Barone J3
1
School of Pharmacy, Rutgers University, Piscataway, NJ, USA; 2Catholic University School of
Medicine, Seoul, South Korea; 3Rutgers University, Piscataway, NJ, USA; 4Ewha Womans
Univ College of Medicine, Seoul, South Korea; 5Health Insurance Review Agency, Seocho-gu,
South Korea
OBJECTIVES: We compared two alternative methods (recycled prediction and Oaxaca-decomposition) to estimate medical costs attributable to obesity in US adults with
asthma. METHODS: This study used the 2003–2007 Medical Expenditure Panel
Survey to select asthma patients (18–64 years old), excluding patients with pregnancy,
malignancy, kidney dialysis, immunodeficiency, or low body mass index (BMI < 18.5
kg/m2). Obesity was defined as BMI >= 30 kg/m2. Medication costs were estimated
using a generalized linear model with a log-link function and gamma distribution. For
the recycled predictions method, predicted treatment costs for obese patients were
calculated assuming that obese patients were normal-weight, holding the distribution
of covariates obtained from the entire asthma patient sample. With Oaxaca-decomposition, average treatment costs for each group (obese vs. normal weight) were
estimated. The differences in average costs between the two groups were then estimated for two components: a) costs due to patient characteristics (endowments), and
b) costs due to obese/normal-weight parameters (coefficient), considered as costs
attributable to obesity. To compare the two methods, the difference in costs between
obese and normal-weight patients was simulated, after matching for patient demographic and clinical characteristics,. All costs were converted to 2009 US dollars using
price indices. RESULTS: The prevalence of obesity and normal-weight among 7340
asthmatic patients was 32.5% vs. 35.1%, respectively. In the recycled prediction
method, costs attributable to obesity were US$1798 (95%CI: US$1717–$1878). In
the Oaxaca-decomposition, the difference in medical costs between two groups consisted of US$1357 (95%CI: US$1252–$1462) due to endowments and US$1285 (95%
CI: US$1229–$1341) due to coefficient components (i.e. costs attributable to obesity).
The difference in costs from the simulation was US$1124 (US$1045–US$1203). CONCLUSIONS: Costs attributable to obesity obtained using Oaxaca-decomposition were
similar to those of the simulation method, but the costs obtained using the recycled
prediction method were higher than those of Oaxaca-decomposition and
simulation.
PRS24
LONG-TERM EFFECTIVENESS AND COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF SMOKING
CESSATION INTERVENTIONS IN PATIENTS WITH COPD
Hoogendoorn M1, Feenstra T2, Hoogenveen RT3, Rutten-van Mölken MP1
1
Erasmus University, Rotterdam, The Netherlands; 2RIVM /UMCG, Bilthoven, The
Netherlands; 3National Institute for Public Health and the Environment (RIVM), Bilthoven,
The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: We aimed to estimate the long-term (cost-)effectiveness of smoking
cessation interventions for patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
(COPD). METHODS: A systematic review was performed for randomized controlled
trials on smoking cessation interventions in COPD patients reporting the 12-month
biochemical validated abstinence rates. The different interventions were grouped into
four categories: usual care, minimal counseling, intensive counseling and intensive
counseling plus pharmacotherapy. For each category the average 12-months continu-
13th Euro Abstracts
ous abstinence rate and intervention costs were estimated. a dynamic population
model for COPD was used to project the long-term (cost-)effectiveness of one year
implementation of minimal counseling, intensive counseling and intensive counseling
plus pharmacotherapy for 50% of the smoking COPD patients compared to usual
care. Time horizon was 25 years. Uncertainty and one-way sensitivity analyses were
performed for variations in (the calculation of) the abstinence rates, the type of projection, intervention costs and discount rates. RESULTS: Nine studies were selected. The
average 12 months continuous abstinence rates were estimated to be 1.4% for usual
care, 2.6% for minimal counseling, 6.0% for intensive counseling and 12.3% for
pharmacotherapy. Compared to usual care, the costs per QALY gained for minimal
counseling, intensive counseling and intensive counseling plus pharmacotherapy were
c16,900, c8,200 and c2,400, respectively. Results were most sensitive to variations in
abstinence rates and discount rates. CONCLUSIONS: Compared to usual care intensive counseling and pharmacotherapy resulted in low costs per QALY gained with
ratios comparable to results presented for smoking cessation in the general population.
Compared to intensive counseling alone, intensive counseling plus pharmacotherapy
was cost saving and dominated the other interventions.
PRS25
A COST-UTILITY ANALYSIS FOR TIOTROPIUM BROMIDE IN THE LONG
TERM TREATMENT OF SPECIFIC SUBGROUPS OF ITALIAN COPD
PATIENTS
Zaniolo O, Iannazzo S, Carsi M
Adres srl, Torino, Italy
OBJECTIVES: The UPLIFT trial demonstrated in 5,993 patients with moderate to
very-severe chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) that 4 years of tiotropium
bromide were associated with improvements in lung function, quality of life, and
exacerbations compared with placebo. The aim of this study is the economic assessment of tiotropium when included in COPD routine care (RC) for specific groups of
Italian COPD patients. METHODS: A probabilistic patient-level simulation Markov
model was developed over a lifetime horizon, with one-year cycles and a 3.5% annual
discount rate. Patients were characterized by gender, age, height, smoking status and
FEV1. FEV1 time trend was modelled based on the decline recorded in UPLIFT. The
mortality of the general Italian population adjusted by smoking status and FEV1 was
adopted. Health utilities derived from published Italian studies, while their variation
from the UPLIFT. Exacerbation rates derived from an Italian observational prospective study and were adjusted for the relative risk (RR) reported in UPLIFT. Direct
sanitary costs were considered. Health care resource consumption for RC, exacerbations and SAEs derived from Italian observational studies and were valued according
to current price and tariffs. Cost-effectiveness was assessed for the overall cohort and
for subgroups of patients by age, sex, GOLD stage and smoking attitude. RESULTS:
In the whole cohort, patients treated with tiotropium gained an average (95%CI) 0.50
(−1.63– −6.27) LYs and 0.42 (−0.25– −3.05) QALYs with respect to RC. The incremental lifetime cost was c3,357 (−c10,669– −c29,820). The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) was c7,916 /QALY. In the subgroups analysis the ICER ranged
from a minimum of c6,627/QALY (females, GOLD III) to a maximum of c13,187/
QALY (age <65 y, GOLD IV). CONCLUSIONS: The inclusion of tiotropium in RC
for moderate to very severe COPD patients represents good value for money in Italy.
The analysis across subgroups demonstrated a good stability of the model.
PRS26
COST-EFFECTIVENESS AND BUDGET IMPACT ANALYSIS OF
MOMETASONE FUROATE AS MAINTENANCE TREATMENT IN
PATIENTS WITH MILD TO MODERATE ASTHMA FROM THE PUBLIC
PAYER PERSPECTIVE IN BRAZIL
Fernandes RA, Takemoto ML, Cukier FN, Guerra FC, Passos RB
ANOVA—Knowledge Translation, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: In the Brazilian public health care system, mometasone furoate (MF
DPI) is not available and budesonide/formoterol (BUD/FF DPI) association is responsible for 86.9% of pharmacy claims for asthma. This study aimed to conduct costeffectiveness and budget impact analysis (BIA) of MF versus BUD/FF for adult patients
with mild to moderate asthma from the public payer perspective. METHODS: A
decision tree was developed to compare MF and BUD/FF based on indirect comparison
once head-to-head studies were not available. The final FEV1 values were converted
into probabilities of hospitalization in the first two years in accordance with observational evidence of association between FEV1 and exacerbation requiring hospitalization. Only direct medical costs were considered and unit costs were obtained from
Brazilian official lists. BIA assumed pharmacy claims data from the Ambulatory
Information System as current scenario (Beclomethasone: 3.1%; BUD: 9.9%; BUD/
FF: 86.9%) and a 20% initial market share for MF in substitution to equivalent doses
of BUD/FF. RESULTS: Indirect comparison indicated 79 hospitalizations per 1000
patients for MF and 82 for BUD/FF during the first 2 years of treatment. Total cost
of treatment was 832BRL and 655BRL per patient for MF200 mcg twice a day (bid)
and MF400 mcg once a day and 840BRL for BUD/FF 400/12 mcg bid. These findings
indicated MF as cost-saving in the proposed scenario with ICER of −2.608BRL and
−61.959BRL per avoided hospitalization for MF200 mcg and MF400 mcg, respectively. The estimated budgetary impact for the first year showed a saving of
259,346,480BRL for MF 400 mcg and 10,919,299BRL for MF 200 mcg. CONCLUSIONS: MF is a clinically effective option to treat mild to moderate asthma and
indirect comparison showed its clinical and economic benefit when compared to the
most used anti-asthma medication in the Brazilian public setting. Further research to
A323
directly compare both medications and to measure finalistic outcomes alongside clinical trials is needed.
PRS27
COUNTRY ADAPTATION OF A HEALTH ECONOMIC MODEL: THE
CASE FOR ROFLUMILAST IN THE NETHERLANDS
Vemer P, Goossens LM, Rutten-Van Mölken MP
Erasmus University, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
BACKGROUND: The phosphodiesterase-4 enzyme (PDE4) inhibitor roflumilast is a
new treatment that targets the underlying inflammation associated with COPD. When
approved, roflumilast will be registered as an add-on to bronchodilator treatment in
adult patients with severe COPD, with a history of frequent exacerbations. a health
economic (HE) micro-simulation Markov model was used to support its submission
in the United Kingdom (UK). Pharmaceutical companies can save significantly on the
process of HE evidence development, if models can be adapted for use in more than
one country. OBJECTIVES: To transfer an existing UK HE model to the The Netherlands in order to calculate the cost-effectiveness (CE) of roflumilast in patients with
severe COPD from a societal perspective. METHODS: The model structure was
adapted to include production loss using the friction cost method, and to separate
heterogeneity from parameter uncertainty. All input parameters on health care use,
costs, utilities, and COPD epidemiology were obtained from Dutch sources, except
for the case-fatality rate of an exacerbation-related hospitalization. a direct comparison was made between a combination of a long-acting β2 agonist (LABA) plus
roflumilast (ROFLU) and LABA alone. a second, indirect comparison was between
LABA + ROFLU and LABA plus an inhaled corticosteroid (ICS). One-way and probabilistic sensitivity analyses were performed. RESULTS: From a societal perspective,
the incremental CE ratio (ICER) for LABA + ROFLU compared with LABA alone,
was c7900. The ICER of LABA + ROFLU versus LABA + ICS was c10,000. The
probability that LABA + ROFLU was cost-effective when compared with LABA alone
at a threshold of c20,000 versus LABA was 97%. Compared with LABA + ICS this
probability was 68.3%. CONCLUSIONS: The original UK model was suitable for
adaptation to the Dutch setting. The ICERs of roflumilast were below commonly
referred threshold values of a QALY.
PRS28
ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF FLUTICASONE PROPIONATE/
SALMETEROL COMBINATION THERAPY AND MONTELUKAST IN
ADULT PATIENTS WHO ARE SYMPTOMATIC ON SHORT-ACTING
BETA 2-AGONIST ALONE
Rely K1, Gonzalez SE2, Salinas GE3, Alexandre PK4
1
CEAHealthTech, Mexico City, D.F., Mexico; 2GlaxoSmithKline, Mexico City, D.F., Mexico;
3
Hospital Infantil de México Federico Gómez, Mexico City, D.F., Mexico; 4Johns Hopkins
University, Baltimore, MD, USA
OBJECTIVES: To estimate the incremental cost-effectiveness of SFC verus montelukast in adult patients with persistent asthma. METHODS: A decision-analytic model
was developed from a randomized, double-blind, double-dummy, 12-week clinical
trial were analyzed. Efficacy end points included, symptom-free days (SFDs) during
the 12-week period. The study assumed the Mexican health care perspective with costs
in 2010 US dollars, and hence only direct costs were included in the analysis. Direct
costs included those related to study drugs, emergency room department visits,
unscheduled physician visits, and rescue medication. The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER), which is the mean difference in average costs divided by the mean
difference in average effectiveness, was calculated for the effectiveness outcomes
(SFDs). Issue of uncertainty was addressed by means of a probabilistic Monte Carlo
simulation, which attributed stochastic distributions to model inputs. RESULTS:
Treatment with FSC resulted in a significantly greater improvement in the mean
percentage of symptom-free days compared with MON 48.9 and 21.7 respectively (p
0.001). In the base case, patients initiated on SFC displayed a 45% reduction in overall
cost as compared with patients initiated on MON US S186 versus $US258, respectively, respectively). SFC dominated the use of MON because of previously demonstrated lower incidence of Asthma exacerbations and rescue free days. Sensitivity
analyses determined that univariate changes in all model variables, including medication cost, and cost of treating exacerbation, did not impact overall results. a Monte
Carlo simulation analysis found that use of SFC remains the best overall treatment
strategy when taking into consideration the potential variance in all model assumptions. Compared with MON, SFC is estimated to be both more effective and more
economically favourable, with a probability of almost 92%. CONCLUSIONS: The
decision model indicated that use of SFC as treatment in patients with asthma should
result in lower overall treatment costs relative to the cost of MON.
PRS29
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF SALMETEROL/FLUTICASONE PROPIONATE
COMBINATION VERSUS LEUKOTRIENE MONTELUKAST FOR THE
CONTROL OF PERSISTENT ASTHMA IN CHILDREN
Rely K1, Gonzalez SE2, Alexandre PK3, Salinas GE4
1
CEAHealthTech, Mexico City, D.F., Mexico; 2GlaxoSmithKline, Mexico City, D.F., Mexico;
3
Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD, USA; 4Hospital Infantil de México Federico
Gómez, Mexico City, D.F., Mexico
OBJECTIVES: To assess the incremental cost-effectiveness of SFC compared with
MON for the control of persistent asthma in children. METHODS: We conducted an
economic evaluation on a 12-week prospective randomized open-label parallel-group
A324
comparison of SFC versus MON in children with symptomatic asthma receiving
inhaled corticosteroids and short-acting β2-agonists. Asthma-related medication,
unscheduled physician contacts and hospitalizations were collected prospectively. The
main effectiveness measure was percentage of asthma-controlled week with no shortacting β2-agonist use during the study period. The analysis was conducted from the
Mexican health care perspective using 2010 unit cost prices, and only direct costs were
considered, all costs are reported in US dollar. The model was made fully probabilistic
to reflect the joint uncertainty in the model parameters. RESULTS: Over the whole
treatment period, the median percentages of asthma-controlled weeks were 83.3% in
the SFC group and 66.7% in the MON group (SFC-MON difference, 16.7%; 95%
CI, 8.3–16.7; P < 0.001 in favor of SFC). The mean total cost of the SFC regimen was
US$186 compared with US$271 for the MON regimen. The SFC was the dominant
strategy (both more effective and less expensive) using the SFC was associated with
an incremental cost per additional asthma-controlled of $US (513). Probabilistic
sensitivity analysis tested numerous assumptions about the model cost and efficacy
parameters and found that the results were robust to most changes. CONCLUSIONS:
This analysis demonstrates that, compared with MON, SFC may be cost saving from
the Mexican health care perspective for the treatment of pediatric patients with
asthma. SFC provided a reduction in the number of severe exacerbations, frequent
asthma symptoms and rescue medication use. Incremental cost-effectiveness analysis
indicated the dominance of SFC because of both lower costs and greater efficacy.
PRS30
DISCREPANCY BETWEEN ANALYTIC APPROACHES IN THE CLINICAL
AND ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF THE SAME TRIAL: EXPERIENCE IN
COPD
Hoogendoorn M, Al M, Rutten-van Mölken MP
Erasmus University, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: Clinical and economic evaluations of the same trial often use different
statistical analyses and methods to handle missing data. This leads to different results
for the same health outcome. We aimed to study how the combination of multiple
imputation (MI) with frequently used advanced methods of clinical analysis affect
estimates of cost-effectiveness. METHODS: Data from a two-year RCT of an INTERdisciplinary COMmunity-based COPD management program (INTERCOM) versus
usual care were used. Five outcomes, SGRQ, EQ-5D, 6MWD, total and severe exacerbations measured at 4, 12 and 24 months or continuously (exacerbations) were
selected. These outcomes were re-analyzed using the same methods used in the clinical
paper, i.e. with repeated measurement analysis or negative bionomial regression, but
now after missing data have been imputed using MI. The resulting estimates were
compared with 1) the estimates in the original clinical paper before MI and 2) the
estimates obtained after MI based on simple averages before any further statistical
analyses based on maximum likelihood. RESULTS: A total of 175 patients were
included in the analysis of which 158 completed the trial. The cost difference of c2751
between INTERCOM and usual care was kept constant. The number of severe exacerbations avoided varied from 0.014 to 0.077 resulting in ICERs from c35,700 to
c196,500, depending on the approach used. The improvement in SGRQ ranged from
2.2 to 2.6 units, but the ICERs were all around c1000. The gain in QALYs varied
from 0.062 with an ICER of c44,400 to 0.085 with an ICER of c32,400 per QALY
gained. The probability that the INTERCOM program was cost-effective at a threshold value of c50,000 ranged from 56% to 74%. CONCLUSIONS: This study showed
that the combination of analytic approaches of the clinical and economic evaluations
does alter the cost-effectiveness ratios.
PRS31
SHOULD SALMETEROL/FLUTICASONE PROPIONATE (SAL/FP) BE
ADDED TO ROUTINE COPD TREATMENT WITH FENOTEROL/
IPRATROPIUM BROMIDE (FEN/IB)? PHARMACOECONOMIC
ASSESSMENT OF COPD TREATMENT BASED ON OBSERVATIONAL
RESEARCH (PHACTOR)
Denisov P1, Belevsky AS2, Chuchalin AG3, Tolkushin A4, Yagudina RI5, Kulikov A5,
Zinchuk I5
1
Worldwide Clinical Trials Co Ltd, Saint-Petersburg, Russia; 2Russian State Medical University,
Moscow, Russia; 3SRI of Pulmonology, Moscow, Russia; 4GlaxoSmithKline Russia, Moscow,
Russia; 5Moscow Medical Academy, Moscow, Russia
OBJECTIVES: To assess cost-effectiveness of adding SAL/FP to routine COPD treatment with Fen/IB. METHODS: Depersonalized patient database was created in multicenter observational research of severe and very severe COPD. Patients were
subdivided into two groups: 1- Fen/IB-based therapy without SAL/FP (N = 245); 2Fen/IB-based therapy with SAL/FP (N = 84). Prices of drugs were up to Q1 2010 for
Moscow city (from Farmexpert market monitoring). Unit cost of inpatient-day, outpatient-visit and emergency-visit was derived from Moscow city government regulation #290 from 04.2010 (about medicare). Direct medical costs within one year time
horizon were assessed as health care perspective was taken. RESULTS: Number of
COPD exacerbations per patient was 3.9 with and 6.8 without SAL/FP. Sum of yearly
direct medical costs was 31,607 RUB (c832) with and 55,179 RUB (c1452) without
SAL/FP. Incremental cost per one prevented exacerbation (ICER) was 1237 RUB
(c32.5). Average cost of treatment of one exacerbation was 8 056 RUB (c212). Results
were sensitive to unit cost of inpatient-day (25% increase leads to cost-saving in with
SAL/FP arm). Indirect cost inclusion lead to considerable cost-saving in with SAL/FP
arm (7952 RUB = c209). CONCLUSIONS: Adding SAL/FP to routine treatment of
severe and very severe COPD with Fen/IB is cost-effective.
13th Euro Abstracts
PRS32
REGIONAL DIFFERENCES AS A BASIS FOR SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS OF
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF SALMETEROL + FLUTICASONE PROPIONATE
(SAL/FP) VS. INHALED CORTICOSTEROIDS (MONO-ICS)
Demko IV1, Tolkushin A2, Yagudina RI3, Kulikov A3, Ogorodova LM4, Chuchalin AG5
1
Krasnoyarsk State Medical University, Krasnoyarsk, Russia; 2GlaxoSmithKline Russia, Moscow,
Russia; 3Moscow Medical Academy, Moscow, Russia; 4Siberian State Medical University,
Tomsk, Russia; 5SRI of Pulmonology, Moscow, Russia
OBJECTIVES: To assess cost-effectiveness of SAL/FP vs. mono-ICS in different
Russian regions using OPTIMA pharmacoeconomic model. METHODS: Description
and calculation steps of OPTIMA model were published in ISPOR Twelfth Annual
European Congress Research Abstract #PRS8. Variable region-specific input data:
drug prices and dosage proportion (from Farmexpert monitoring as of Q4 2009),
medical tariffs (from regional government regulations), GDP per capita and average
salary (from statistics service). Constant disease-specific data: frequency of controlled/
uncontrolled asthma in arms (from clinical trial), number of unscheduled resources
utilization and QoL in controlled and uncontrolled asthma (from prof. I.V.Demko’s
observational study). Fixed combination SAL/FP (Seretide) was compared with monoICS (Beclomethasone, Fluticasone and Budesonide). ICERs (cost per QALY) were
assessed for each 84 Russian regions. Regional WTP was assumed as three regional
GDP per capita. 1 EUR = 38 RUB. RESULTS: Weighted average monthly pharmacotherapy cost varied from 1410RUB (in Kostroma) to 3376RUB (in Tula) for SAL/FP,
and from 430RUB (in Kostroma) to 1524RUB (in Khanty-Mansi) for MonoICS. The
differences were driven by proportion of low/medium/high doses. Medical tariffs
varied dramatically as well: tariffs of outpatient visit varied from 107RUB (in Ivanovo
and Dagestan) to 975RUB (in Yamal-Nenets), bed-day cost varies from 500RUB (in
Kurgan) to 3123RUB (in Yamal-Nenets). GDP per capita were from 38110RUB (in
Ingush) to 928374RUB (in Tyumen); average salary—from 9 125 RUB (in Dagestan)
to 46480RUB (in Yamal-Nenets). SAL/FP was cost-saving (dominating) in 18 regions,
cost-effective in 62 regions (ICER < WTP; in this regions ICERs were from 3210RUB
(84EUR) to 639480RUB (16828EUR) per QALY), and disadvantageous (ICER >
WTP) in 4 regions (Ivanovo, Kabardino-Balkaria, Ingush, and Dagestan; mainly due
to low WTP). CONCLUSIONS: In general case SAL/FP was cost-effective in most
Russian regions, in some regions SAL/FP was cost-saving, and in few regions—not
cost-effective. To assess cost-effectiveness in particular cohort of patients additional
analyses are needed.
PRS33
ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF ILOPROST, EPOPROSTENOL AND
TREPROSTINIL FOR THE TREATMENT OF PULMONARY ARTERIAL
HYPERTENSION
Román A1, Barberà JA2, Escribano P3, Sala ML4, Febrer L5, Casado MA6
1
Hospital de la Vall d’Hebron, Barcelona, Catalunya, Spain; 2Hospital Clínic de Barcelona,
Barcelona, Catalunya, Spain; 3Hospital 12 de Octubre, Madrid, Spain; 4Hospital de la Santa
Creu i Sant Pau, Barcelona, Catalunya, Spain; 5Bayer Healthcare, Barcelona, Catalunya, Spain;
6
Pharmacoeconomics & Outcomes Research Iberia, Pozuelo de Alarcón , Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: To analyze the eficiency of three alternative treatments (inhaled iloprost (ILO), intravenous epoprostenol (EPO) and subcutaneous treprostinil (TRE)) for
patients suffering from pulmonary arterial hipertensión (PAH) iniciating therapy with
a prostanoid. METHODS: A Markov model was built to simulate a PAH patient
cohort in functional class III of the New York Heart Association (NYHA). The model
had four health states, those of the functional classes, plus death. Treatment changes
were allowed when patients worsened from class III to IV. Time horizon was three
years and transition cycles were of 12 weeks. Perspective was that of the National
Health System (NHS) in Spain. Data sources were: 1) literature review, 2) costs
databases and 3) expert opinion. Costs were expressed in euros 2009. Costs and effects
were discounted at a 3% rate following Spanish recommendations. Both, deterministic
and probabilistic analyses were performed to check for robustness of results.
RESULTS: At three years, results for initiating prostanoid therapy with ILO, EPO and
TRE were, respectively: total cost—c143,092, c430,271 and c360,387 -; efficacy—2.695 LYG, 2.729 LYG and 2.690 LYG -; —1.737 QALY, 1.780 QALY and
1.728 QALY -; mean cost per LYG—c53,092, c157,678 and c133,997; mean cost
per QALY—c82,376, c241,667 and c208,595 -. Incremental cost-effectiveness ratios
and cost-utility ratios of EPO vs. ILO were: >8.5Mc/LYG and >6.5Mc/QALY, and
vs. TRE were: >1.5Mc/LYG y > 1.3 Mc/QALY, much above the usually accepted
threshold in Spain of 30,000 c/LYG or QALY. ILO was dominant vs. TRE. Sensitivity
analyses confirmed these results. CONCLUSIONS: Initiating prostanoid therapy in
class III PAH patients with intravenous epoprostenol is slightly more efficacious than
the alternatives. At a three-year time horizon, inhaled iloprost shows to be the less
costly alternative for the NHS in Spain.
PRS34
IMPROVED PREDICTION OF FINDING COPD PATIENTS BY LUNG
FUNCTION PRE-SCREENING IN PRIMARY CARE
Thorn J1, Tilling B2, Lisspers K3, Jörgensen L4, Stenling A4, Stratelis G4
1
Sahlgrenska School of Public Health and Community Medicine, Gothenburg, Sweden;
2
Primary Care, Åtvidaberg, Sweden; 3Department of Public Health and Caring Sciences,
Uppsala, Sweden; 4AstraZeneca Nordic MC, Södertälje, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: To investigate if easily accessible pre-screening of individuals at risk
for COPD leads to a more accurate selection of patients for ordinary spirometry,
thereby improving the incidence of pathological test results. METHODS: Primary care
13th Euro Abstracts
patients at risk for COPD (aged 45 ≤ years ≤ 85, ≥15 pack years) were included. Lung
function (FEV1 and FEV6) was measured by copd-6 (mini-spirometer, Vitalograph),
followed by ordinary spirometry (COPD diagnosis FEV1/FVC post bronchodilation
ratio <70). Time consumed was recorded and costs calculated (national average nurse
wage). Univariate logistic regression and receiver operating characteristic (ROC)
curves were utilized. RESULTS: In all, 305 patients (21 centers in Sweden), females
57%, mean (standard deviation, SD) age 61.2 (8.4) years, FEV1/FVC 75.3 (10.2),
pack years 30.3 (11.5) were included. COPD was diagnosed in 83 patients (27.2%).
Copd-6 screening significantly predicted COPD by FEV1/FEV6 ratio. Patients with
COPD had a mean (SD) FEV1/FEV6 of 69.0 (9.1), patients without COPD 77.7 (9.6).
Sensitivity and specificity at a FEV1/FEV6 cut-off of 73.0 was 73.5% and 79.7%,
respectively; area under the ROC curve was 0.800. Cost of one copd-6 measurement
(~4 minutes) was SEK 19 (≈c2), while the cost for an ordinary spirometry (~33
minutes) was SEK 147 (≈c15). Without copd-6 pre-screening the cost of detecting one
COPD patient based on age and pack years was SEK 542 (≈c54). Use of copd-6
reduces the cost to SEK 283 (≈c28), but also results in an 8.4% lower COPD detection
rate due to copd-6 sensitivity limitations. CONCLUSIONS: Pre-screening with the
copd-6 mini-spirometer to select patients (≥45 years; ≥15 pack years) for ordinary
spirometry increased the frequency of detected COPD diagnoses from 27.2% to
73.5%. Although copd-6 sensitivity and specificity could be improved, its use in
primary care may reduce the costs of detecting COPD patients.
PRS35
ASSESSING THE COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF BECLOMETHASONE/
FORMOTEROL IN THE TREATMENT OF MODERATE TO SEVERE
PERSISTENT ASTHMA IN SPAIN
Darba J1, Restovic G2, Kaskens L2
1
Universitat de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain; 2BCN Health, Barcelona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: To estimates cost and effectiveness of beclomethasone/formoterol
extrafine, fluticasone/salmeterol and budesodine/formoterol in the treatment of moderate to severe persistent asthma in Spain. METHODS: A Markov model was developed
to represent the transition of a cohort of patients with moderate to severe persistent
asthma through different health states: patients free of symptoms, patients with exacerbations and patients without exacerbations. Efficacy data was obtained from observational studies. Deterministic results were estimated and a probabilistic sensitivity
analysis was conducted using statistical distributions in order to capture parameter
uncertainty in the decision model. Treatment costs were obtained from literature
review and a panel of clinical experts. Costs were referred to year 2009 and a time
horizon of 12 weeks was chosen. Results were presented as expected cost per QALY
and represented in cost-effectiveness acceptability curves (CEACs). RESULTS: In the
deterministic analysis, the expected cost per patient was greater in the fluticasone/
salmeterol cohort (c333) and the budesodine/formoterol cohort (c300) in comparison
with the beclomethasone/formoterol cohort (c292). The estimated effectiveness was
the same in the three cohorts. In the probabilistic analysis CEACs showed that the
probability that the treatment with beclomethasone/formoterol was more cost-effective than the treatment with fluticasone/salmeterol and budesodine/formoterol using
alternative values for the maximum value that the health service would be willing to
pay for an additional QALY gained was greater in the beclomethasone/formoterol
cohort. CONCLUSIONS: When beclomethasone/formoterol extrafine has been compared to fluticasone/salmeterol and budesodine/formoterol we may conclude that the
first one is a dominant strategy. Results from probabilistic sensibility analysis show
that the choice of optimal strategy is independent on the maximum that the health
service is prepared to pay per additional QALY gained because beclomethasone/formoterol extrafine has a greater probability of being cost-effective for all threshold
values.
RESPIRATORY-RELATED DISORDERS – Patient-Reported Outcomes
Studies
PRS36
ADHERENCE TO MEDICATION AND HEALTH-RELATED QUALITY OF
LIFE IN PATIENTS WITH COPD: SGRQ—AN ALTERNATIVE METHOD
TO IDENTIFY NONADHERENCE
Meszaros A, Agh T
Semmelweis University, Budapest, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: Medication adherence and health-related quality of life (HRQoL) are
important factors in determining success of drug treatments; although both have been
studied intensively, limited data is available on the association between these factors.
This study aimed: 1) to assess the relationship between adherence and HRQoL in
COPD patients using generic and disease specific instruments; and 2) to evaluate the
association between adherence and answers of SGRQ part 2-section 5 referring to
medication use. METHODS: The cross-sectional study included a post-bronchodilator
spirometry and completion of a self reported postal questionnaire. Information on
adherence (4-item Morisky Medication Adherence Scale) and HRQoL (generic:
EuroQol—EQ-5D, disease specific: St. George’s Respiratory Questionnaire—SGRQ)
were obtained. Multiple linear regression model was used to analyze the association
between HRQoL as dependent variable and disease severity (FEV1), age and adherence
as independent variables. Differences in answers of SGRQ part 2-section 5 between
adherence stages were analyzed with Pearson Chi-square test. RESULTS: A total of
A325
227 patients were included at baseline, 170 of them completed the study. The mean
age was 63.83 (SD = 11.24) years, there were slightly more female patients (58%). a
total of 32% (n = 55) of the participants reported themselves as high adherent, 26%
(n = 44) were medium, and 42% (n = 71) were low adherent. The mean EQ-5D score
was 0.55 (SD = 0.21) and the mean SGRQ total score was 56.22% (SD = 16.19).
HRQoL assessed with EQ-5D and SGRQ were neither significantly related to medication adherence. Both generic and disease-specific HRQoL were associated with age
and disease severity. We found significant association between the number of the
positive answers’ of SGRQ part 2-section 5 and adherence rate (Chi-square = 30.64
p = 0.000). CONCLUSIONS: The study showed no significant relationship between
adherence to medication and any HRQoL domain. Our results suggest that, SGRQ
part 2-section 5 could be suitable to estimate adherence in patients with COPD in
clinical practice.
PRS37
ASSOCIATION OF PATIENT-REPORTED INHALER SATISFACTION
WITH PHYSICIAN-PERCEIVED COMPLIANCE WITH ASTHMA
TREATMENT—RESULTS OF A CROSS-SECTIONAL STUDY IN FIVE
EUROPEAN COUNTRIES
Small M, Piercy J, Anderson P, Vickers A
Adelphi Real World, Macclesfield, Cheshire, UK
OBJECTIVES: It is hypothesised that patient satisfaction with the features of an
asthma inhaler directly influences compliance behaviour of asthma patients. This study
investigated the relationship between physician-reported compliance of 1400 asthma
patients with the degree of patient-reported satisfaction with their inhaler. METHODS:
Data were drawn from the Adelphi Disease Specific Programme (DSP) in Asthma, a
cross-sectional study of consulting patients undertaken in 2009. Data were collected
from physicians for each patient and collected directly from consenting patients. Key
factors analyzed were physician-reported perceptions of patient compliance on a 1–5
scale (where 1 is ‘not at all compliant’ and 5 is ‘fully compliant’) and data for patientreported satisfaction with their inhaler including specific device features associated with
convenience, dosing and inhaler mechanism. The results were tested against potential
confounders including age, gender, ethnicity and current asthma severity, to ensure the
relationship effect between compliance and satisfaction was distinct. RESULTS: There
was a significant relationship between the physician-reported level of compliance and
patient-reported satisfaction with their inhaler device. The investigators observed that
a better perceived level of compliance was directly associated with a higher level of
inhaler satisfaction (P < 0.001). Those inhaler features associated with convenience:
“built to last/will not break easily”; “easy to hold and carry,” “instructions are simple
and easy to follow,” and “no need to put the drug into the inhaler before use”
accounted for four of the top five drivers of overall satisfaction. CONCLUSIONS:
Patient satisfaction with features of their inhaler is an important factor in promoting
patient compliance. If physicians made particular effort to select an inhaler that satisfies
the patient, including attention to features associated with convenience, patient compliance with their asthma treatment would be expected to improve.
PRS38
SYMPTOMATIC COMORBIDITIES AND HEALTH-RELATED QUALITY OF
LIFE IN COPD IN THE EUROPEAN UNION
Langley PC1, Freedman D2, Wagner JS3
1
University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN, USA; 2Kantar Health, Princeton, NJ, USA; 3Kantar
Health, New York, NY, USA
OBJECTIVES: This study assesses the impact of high prevalence comorbidities
reported by persons with diagnosed COPD on their health related quality of life
(HRQoL). The focus is on (1) the quantitative impact of comorbidities on SF-6D utility
scores, and (2) the relative impact of symptomatic vs. non-symptomatic comorbid
disease states. METHODS: The study is based on data from the internet based 2008
National Health and Wellness Survey (NHWS) undertaken in the UK, France, Spain,
Germany, and Italy. The study identified 3103 persons with diagnosed COPD together
with the nine most frequently diagnosed comorbidities: pain, high blood pressure,
anxiety, high cholesterol, heartburn, insomnia, depression, migraine, and arthritis.
High blood pressure and high cholesterol are considered non-symptomatic comorbidities. The impact of these comorbidities on the SF-6D utility scores (range 0–1) is
estimated via an ordinary least squares regression model. All comorbidities enter as
categorical variables. The model includes a range of variables which have been shown
in previous studies to impact HRQoL. These include: sociodemographic factors, health
risk behaviors (BMI, alcohol use, smoking), and a series of country dummy variables
(Germany as reference category). RESULTS: The model demonstrates that for symptomatic comorbidites the impact on utility scores is substantial. All symptomatic
comorbidities are significant. Depression followed by pain experienced in the past 6
months have the greatest deficit impact (respectively −0.060; 95% CI −0.071 to −0.050
and −0.055; 95% CI −0.064 to −0.045). High blood pressure and high cholesterol are
not significant. CONCLUSIONS: Claims for the negative impact of COPD on HRQoL
should be seen in the context of a cluster of comorbid disease states; in particular the
high prevalence disease states such a pain, anxiety and depression.
A326
PRS39
QUALITY OF LIFE, PRODUCTIVITY LOSS, AND RESOURCE USE AMONG
EMPLOYED ADULTS AGED 40 TO 64 YEARS WITH CHRONIC
OBSTRUCTIVE PULMONARY DISEASE (COPD) IN THE UNITED STATES
(US) WORKFORCE
DiBonaventura M1, Paulose-Ram R2, Su J3, Mcdonald M2, Zou KH2, Wagner JS1, Shah H3
1
Kantar Health, New York, NY, USA; 2Pfizer Inc., New York, NY, USA; 3Boehringer
Ingelheim Pharmaceuticals, Inc., Ridgefield, CT, USA
OBJECTIVES: To examine quality of life, work productivity, and health care resource
use among employed adults ages 40 to 64 years with COPD. METHODS: Data were
obtained from the US 2009 National Health and Wellness Survey (NHWS), an internetbased questionnaire. All employed adults (full-time, part-time, or self-employed) ages
40–64 years with or without a self-reported diagnosis of COPD were included. Impact
on quality of life (using the mental (MCS) and physical component summary (PCS)
scores and health utilities from SF-12v2), work productivity and activity impairment
(using WPAI questionnaire), and resource use were analyzed. Multiple regression
analyses for normally-distributed outcomes and negative binomial regressions for
skewed outcomes were conducted. All models adjusted for demographic and patient
characteristics and were weighted to project to the US population. RESULTS: There
were 1,112 workers with COPD (mean age = 51.5 years) versus 18,912 workers
without COPD (mean age = 50.0 years). After adjusting for demographic and patient
characteristics, adults with COPD reported significantly lower mean levels of MCS
(46.8 vs. 48.5, P < 0.0001), PCS (45.6 vs. 49.2, P < 0.0001), and health utilities (0.71
vs. 0.75, P < 0.0001), than adults without COPD. Workers with COPD reported
significantly greater impairment while at work (presenteeism) (18.9% vs. 14.3%, P <
0.0001), overall work impairment (a combination of absenteeism and presenteeism)
(20.5% vs. 16.3%, P < 0.0001), and impairment in daily activities (23.5% vs. 17.9%,
P < 0.0001) than adults without COPD. Employed adults with COPD also reported
more mean ER visits (0.21 vs. 0.12, P < 0.0001) and more mean hospitalizations (0.10
vs. 0.06, P < 0.0001) in the previous six months than employed adults without COPD.
CONCLUSIONS: After adjusting for various demographic and patient characteristics,
employed adults with COPD reported significantly worse quality of life, work productivity, and health care resource utilization than employed adults without COPD.
These results highlight the substantial impact and burden of COPD in the US
workforce.
PRS40
EVALUATION OF SMOKING CESSATION DRUG USE AND OUTCOMES
IN THE NETHERLANDS
Overbeek JA1, Penning FJA1, van Spiegel PI2, Meerding WJ3, Smulders M1, Herings RMC1
1
PHARMO Institute for Drug Outcomes Research, Utrecht, The Netherlands; 2Slotervaart
Ziekenhuis, Amsterdam, The Netherlands; 3Pfizer bv, Capelle a/d IJssel, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: Several pharmacological therapies are available to help smokers quit.
We determined utilization and effectiveness of smoking cessation therapy (SCT) in
daily practice in the The Netherlands. METHODS: Subjects ≥18 years with a dispensing of varenicline, bupropion, nicotine or nortriptyline between March 2007 and
September 2008 were identified from the PHARMO RLS. Using an encrypted methodology, the corresponding non-person-identifiable dispensing IDs were linked to a
web-based system for patient-reported data collection: ePRO-LINK. Corresponding
pharmacists asked the subjects to participate in the study and complete a web-based
questionnaire on smoking history and cessation. RESULTS: Of 2,684 invited subjects,
612 were included in the analyses. Bupropion was the most frequently used SCT
during last quit attempt (35%), followed by varenicline (28%), bupropion + nicotine
(12%) and varenicline + nicotine (9%). Overall, 51% of patients also reported behavioural therapy. About 52% of varenicline and bupropion users, 42% of nicotine users
and 20–40% of patients using multiple drugs reported not to smoke at the time of
questionnaire. The median (IQR) number of days between time of questionnaire and
start date of last quit attempt ranged from 271 (104–432) for varenicline + bupropion
to 356 (205–518) for bupropion. The mean duration of drug use ranged from 42–53
days among SCT users who remained abstinent and from 19–42 days among SCT
users who relapsed. CONCLUSIONS: The results of this study show that up to 50%
of SCT users in daily practice quit smoking. More widespread use of these drugs in
combination with behavioural therapy will help to further decrease smoking
prevalence.
PRS41
FACTORS AFFECTING QUALITY OF LIFE (QOL) OF ASTHMATIC
PATIENTS IN SPAIN
Martinez-Moragon E1, Palop M2, de Diego A3, Serra J4, Caloto T5, Nocea G5, Sabater E6
1
Hospital de Sagunto, Valencia, Spain; 2Hospital Universitario La F, Valencia, Spain; 3Hospital
Universitario La Fe, Valencia, Spain; 4Hospital General de Vic, Barcelona, Spain; 5Merck Sharp
& Dohme, SA, Madrid, Spain; 6Pharmacoeconomics & Outcomes Research Iberia, Pozuelo,
Spain
OBJECTIVES: Understanding and identifying impaired QoL is now recognised as an
important component of asthma management.To assess QoL and factors influencing
it, in asthmatic patients in Spain. METHODS: Observational, multicenter study was
carried out in 40 Spanish pneumology units. Asthma diagnosed patients (according
to GINA) aged ≥18 were enrolled. Disease severity and treatment information were
investigator-reported, and socio-demographic data, symptoms, and QoL (self administered Mini Asthma Quality of Life Questionnaire ,Mini AQLQ) were patientreported. Optimal scaling methods for multivariate categorical data were conducted.
13th Euro Abstracts
RESULTS: A total of 536 patients were studied (mean age 54 years; 65% female).
Significant differences in Mini-AQLQ total scores were observed by disease severity
according to GINA: 4.3 (SD 1.3) for severe persistent, 4.9 (SD1.2) for moderate
persistent, 5.4 (SD 1.0) for mild persistent and 5.7 (SD1.0) for intermittent patients
(P < 0.0001). As per the final multivariate model (with MiniAQLQ total score as
dependent variable and after adjusting for all significant variables in the bivariate
analysis), reported QoL was better for patients from Northern and Central Spain as
compared with those from the South and the East (P < 0.0001), students and employed
patients as compared with housewives and unemployed (p = 0.001), for those who
had received information about the disease compared with those who did not (p =
0.004), for those with milder daytime symptoms (p = 0.001) and for patients with
higher education (p = 0.021). CONCLUSIONS: Modifiable factors such as symptom
control and adequate information about asthma can have a significant effect on
patients’ QoL.
RESPIRATORY-RELATED DISORDERS – Health Care Use & Policy Studies
PRS42
EFFECTS OF ASTHMA MANAGEMENT, SOCIOECONOMIC STATUS AND
MEDICATION INSURANCE CHARACTERISTICS ON EXACERBATION
FREQUENCY IN CHILDREN WITH ASTHMA
Ungar W1, Paterson JM2, Gomes T2, Bikangaga P1, Gold M1, To T1, Kozyrskyj A3
1
The Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto, ON, Canada; 2Institute for Clinical Evaluative
Sciences, Toronto, ON, Canada; 3University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada
OBJECTIVES: Asthma symptoms are adequately controlled in fewer than 25% of
asthmatic children. The objective was to identify the determinants of severe exacerbation resulting in Emergency Department visits or hospitalization related to health
status, socioeconomic status (SES) and drug insurance characteristics. METHODS: In
this retrospective cohort study, data were collected on 522 asthmatic children in
Toronto, Canada, regarding demographics, SES, drug plan characteristics, health
status, health resource use and symptoms. Baseline data were linked deterministically
to administrative data on asthma emergency visits and hospitalizations occurring in
the year following baseline. Multiple Poisson regression was conducted to identify
independent predictors of severe exacerbation in the full cohort and in a sub-group
with prescription drug insurance. RESULTS: Younger age, prior emergency visits,
nebulizer use, pet ownership, and receipt of asthma education, but no asthma action
plan, were significant determinants of more frequent exacerbation. In the full cohort,
children with high income adequacy had 28% fewer exacerbations than children with
low income adequacy. In the sub-group with drug insurance, girls had 26% fewer
exacerbations than boys, and children with food, drug or insect allergies had 52%
more exacerbations than children without such allergies. Children of families with
annual insurance deductibles greater than $90 had 95% fewer exacerbations. In addition, every percentage increase in the proportion of income spent out-of-pocket on
asthma medications resulted in a 14% increase in severe exacerbations. CONCLUSIONS: Asthma history, disease management factors and SES were important determinants of severe asthma exacerbation in children. In families with drug plans, the
magnitude of asthma medication cost-sharing as a proportion of household income,
rather than income alone, was a highly significant determinant of severe exacerbation.
This finding can inform drug policies aimed at reducing the negative consequences of
cost-sharing.
PRS43
COMPLIANCE TO GOLD GUIDELINES IN THE TREATMENT OF COPD:
APPROPRIATENESS AND POTENTIAL COST SAVING IN ITALY
Tomic R, Dellavedova E, Colangelo I
Novartis Farma S.p.A., Origgio, Italy
OBJECTIVES: Recent Italian studies showed that ICS-containing (Inhaled corticosteroids) drugs are prescribed to more than 50% of COPD patients regardless of disease
severity and treatment guidelines, creating unnecessary costs for NHS. This study aims
at assessing potential saving on drugs expenditure due to increased compliance to
GOLD guidelines. METHODS: Novartis Core-model framework was adapted to
Italian setting. Patient cohort was defined by applying prevalence rate of treated COPD
patients to Italian population (2.5% annual growth rate). Patients severity split and
treatment pattern are obtained by combining results of two Italian observational
studies (reflecting GPs and pneumologists setting), assumed to be constant over 5
years. Drugs considered: LAMA (Long-acting muscarinic antagonist), LABA (Longacting β2-agonist), Fixed-Dose Combination (LABA+ICS), SABA (Short-acting
β2-agonist), add-on ICS. Based on reimbursed net public price, daily treatment costs
for drugs are calculated. To calculate annual treatment cost, 50% compliance for all
drugs (except 30% for ICS) and annual discounting rate of 3.0% are assumed. Following GOLD treatment scheme, Mild and Moderate patients, receiving long-acting
bronchodilators and/or add-on ICS, were assigned respectively to SABA and LABA/
LAMA alone. Difference in drugs costs between current and modified treatment
pattern is calculated. RESULTS: Potential saving, calculated for Italy, was c160.2
million (36.4% of total drug costs) in year 1, and c793.4 million (36.4%) over 5 years.
Analysis was extended to regional populations, resulting in one-year savings of: c26
million in Lombardy, from c10 million to c15 million in Campania, Lazio, Sicily,
Veneto, Piedmont, Emilia Romagna, Apulia, Tuscany, from c3 million to c5 million
in Calabria, Sardinia, Liguria, Marche, Abruzzo, Friuli-Venezia Giulia, Trentino-Alto
Adige, and up to c2 million in Umbria, Basilicata, Molise, Aosta Valley. Results were
13th Euro Abstracts
compliance-sensitive. CONCLUSIONS: Adhering to GOLD guidelines, apart from
having patients treated appropriately, National/Regional Healthcare Systems could
save significant resources and re-allocate them in more rational manner.
PRS44
EFFECTIVENESS AND EFFICIENCY OF ME-TOO LISTS AS ILLUSTRATED
BY THE EXAMPLE OF INTRANASAL STEROIDS
Schoeffski O1, Becker B2
1
University Erlangen-Nuernberg, Nuernberg, Germany; 2Essex Pharma, Munich, Germany
OBJECTIVES: A me-too list has been implemented in a German KV (regional association of SHI-accredited physicians) with the intention of promoting cost-effective
prescribing behavior. The aim was to investigate whether the me-too list is an effective
steering tool. a mometasone-containing nasal spray (MHN) which has been listed as
a me-too, should be substituted by budesonide-containing nasal sprays (BHN),
because MHN therapy is assumed to be equally effective but more cost intensive than
BHN. MHN’s market share has declined after listing. METHODS: A retrospective
study of anonymized patient data was conducted from March to April 2009 in KV
North Rhine. ENT physicians documented patients which had received MHN for
minimum 12 months and who had then been switched to another intranasal steroid
(INS). Evaluation was done with descriptive statistics. RESULTS: A total of 676
patients documented by 76 physicians were eligible for the analysis. a total of 189
patients (28%) received MHN only; a switch to other INS was documented for 487
patients (72%). ENTs cited economic reasons for changing the INS in 86.4% of the
cases. Compared to other INS, the average number of consultations for MHN treatment and the administered dose of MHN, regardless of diagnosis, were lower, MHN
patients required refill prescriptions later, less co medication, and MHN generated
lower daily treatment costs in real-life. CONCLUSIONS: Reasons for switching from
MHN were economically. Therefore the me-too list has a heavy impact on prescription
behavior. Daily treatment costs of MHN were lower in real-life. Analysis based on
PDD (prescribed daily doses) showed that the economic effect of switching a patient
to another INS was far less than expected. For instance it was offset by a higher
number of consultations in association with the cheaper alternatives in more frequent
use. An economic evaluation with a precise quantification would be of major interest
in future.
PRS45
OPTIMIZATION OF GUIDELINES’ SUSTAINABILITY BY EVALUATING
FACTORS PREDICTING TREATMENT RESPONSE IN PATIENTS WITH
ALLERGIC RHINITIS
Koeberlein J1, Krajewski J1, Schaffert C1, Wieland R1, Moesges R2
1
University of Wuppertal, Wuppertal, Germany; 2University of Cologne, Cologne, Germany
OBJECTIVES: To assess predictive factors and risk profiles for treatment response in
patients with allergic rhinitis. It was the aim to create a platform giving support to
the development of interventions optimizing the daily use as well as the sustainability
of the existing national and international guidelines and therewith minimizing the
progression to severe chronic upper airway diseases. METHODS: For this purpose,
76,981 case reports of patients with allergic rhinitis from ten post-marketing-studies
in Germany were aggregated by the use of an IPD meta-analysis. The data pool was
examined in terms of significant predictive factors by univariat methods, logistic
regression and discriminant analysis. The predictive ability of the model was assessed
by a 10 fold crossvalidation. RESULTS: First, we investigated the data pool as a
whole, and the results showed that 20.6% of the patients did not respond to their
therapy. Especially patients who were treated according to current guidelines had a
higher risk of non-response (28% vs. 19.3%). Next, we examined the data pool in
terms of significant predictive factors resulting in non-response of patients receiving
an adequate guideline-conform therapy. The primary baseline determinants were a
positive history of allergy in the family, duration and severity of disease, the periodicity
of an allergen (perennial allergens) and concomitant diseases. Especially patients with
asthma as well as patients suffering from more than one concomitant disease had a
higher risk of non-response (32.4% and 34%). The main follow up determinants were
patient’s compliance, safety and the treatment process. a total of 63.4% of patients
with a poor compliance, which was enforced by an inadequate safety were nonresponder. CONCLUSIONS: These results support the findings of current clinical
trials describing a non-responder rate of about 20% and encourage efforts to optimize
guidelines as well as to achieve a sustainability of guidelines.
RESPIRATORY-RELATED DISORDERS – Conceptual Papers & Research on
Methods
PRS46
ADJUSTING FOR CHRONIC OBSTRUCTIVE PULMONARY DISEASE
(COPD) SEVERITY IN DATABASE RESEARCH: FEASIBILITY OF
DEVELOPING AND VALIDATING AN ALGORITHM
Goossens LM1, Baker CL2, Monz BU3, Zou KH2, Rutten-van Mölken MP1
1
Erasmus University, Rotterdam, The Netherlands; 2Pfizer, Inc, New York, NY, USA;
3
Boehringer Ingelheim GmbH, Ingelheim, Germany
OBJECTIVES: When comparing interventions through routine database research, it
is important to adjust for COPD severity. GOLD guidelines grade COPD severity
according to lung function (FEV1% predicted). Most databases lack data on lung
A327
function. Previous database research has approximated COPD severity using demographics and health care utilization. This study aims to derive an algorithm for COPD
severity using baseline data from a large, respiratory trial (UPLIFT). METHODS:
Several partial proportional odds logit models were used to estimate the probabilities
of being in GOLD stages II, III and IV. The predicted GOLD stage for each patient
was defined as the state with the highest predicted probability. The concordance
between the predicted and the observed (according to lung function) stage was assessed
with κ-statistics. Models were estimated in a random selection of 2/3 of all patients
enrolled in Western Europe (n = 2439) and validated in the remaining patients (n =
1259). The final model was re-estimated in a subsample with a balanced distribution
across severity stages. RESULTS: In the validation set, 47% were in stage II, 44% in
III, and 9% in IV. In the final model, a higher risk of more severe COPD was associated with being male, younger, lower BMI, and certain medications (long-acting and
short-acting bronchodilators, leukotriene modifiers, oral steroids), oxygen and having
quit smoking. No relationship was found between severity and co-morbidities, previous health care resource use (e.g. emergency room, hospitalizations) and inhaled
corticosteroids, xanthines, or mucolytics. The concordance between observed and
predicted disease states was generally poor (κ = 0.15) and only slightly better in the
balanced sample (κ = 0.22). CONCLUSIONS: Data from a well controlled trial setting
indicated that COPD severity cannot be reliably predicted from demographics and
health care use. This limitation should be considered when interpreting findings from
database studies, and additional research should explore other methods allowing to
account for COPD severity.
PRS47
USE OF PROPENSITY SCORE MATCHING, STANDARD REGRESSION
ANALYSIS AND INSTRUMENTAL VARIABLE METHOD IN OUTCOMES
RESEARCH STUDIES: A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS
Baser O1, Dysinger A2, Baser E2, Yuce H3
1
STATinMED Research/University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA; 2STATinMED Research,
Ann Arbor, MI, USA; 3New York City College of Technology-CUNY/STATinMED Research,
New York, NY, USA
OBJECTIVES: Propensity score matching and standard regression analysis are
common ways to control for baseline differences between comparative groups. They
control for observable factors. Instrumental variable approach controls not only for
observable factors but also unobservable factors. We compared the three methods and
showed that using more advanced techniques alters the estimated results in a significant way. METHODS: Using data from U.S. claims databases, the effect of treatment
on total health care expenditures among asthma patients was estimated. Reimbursement amounts were dollars paid by the health plan to the provider including patient
co-payments and deductibles. Doctors’ prescribing patterns were used as an instrumental variable for treatment choice. Propensity score matching was employed using
the nearest neighbor matching algorithm. Generalized linear model was used as an
alternative risk adjustment technique. RESULTS: Patients treated with control medication were younger, more likely to live in the northeast and south of the United States
and have a higher Charlson comorbidity score, Elixhauser score and chronic disease
score relative to patients treated with reliever medication. The difference between one
year health care costs for reliever and controller medication was $2,345 by propensity
score matching, $2,195 by generalized linear model, and $2,997 by instrumental
variable approach. The difference was statistically significant. CONCLUSIONS: After
adjusting for patient clinical and demographic characteristics, controller medication
was less costly than reliever medication. The choice of risk adjustment was important.
The technique that controlled for both observed and unobserved biases (instrumental
variable technique) provided a difference of almost 30% higher than the other
techniques.
PRS48
COMPARISON OF ECONOMETRIC MODELS FOR ESTIMATING COST
DIFFERENCES: OLS, GAMMA, AND QUANTILE REGRESSION
de Moor C1, Roberts M2, McQueeney K2, Blanchette C3
1
PPD Inc., Wilmington, NC, USA; 2Lovelace Respiratory Research Institute, Albuquerque,
NM, USA; 3Lovelace Respiratory Research Institute, Davidson, NC, USA
OBJECTIVES: Estimation of cost differences between groups has been assessed using
a variety of econometric techniques. Recent literature commonly uses ordinary least
squares (OLS) with log transformed costs or generalized linear models with a log link
function and gamma error distribution; however recommendations from the field of
econometrics suggest that quantile regression models may provide more informative
comparisons of health care cost data. The objective of this study was to compare three
econometric models for estimating health care cost differences. METHODS: The
econometric models were compared using a cross-sectional sample of patients hospitalized during 2007 for COPD exacerbations from Premier’s Perspective Comparative
Database, a population-based U.S. inpatient database. Admissions were classified into
two groups according to the presence of pneumonia. Total inpatient cost was regressed
on pneumonia status and confounders using: 1) OLS with log-transformed costs; 2)
generalized linear models with log link and gamma error; and 3) quantile regression
with comparisons at every 5th percentile. Cost differences were calculated by subtracting model based estimated costs between COPD patients with and without pneumonia. RESULTS: There were 69,841 COPD exacerbation admissions. Of these, 69,286
admissions had nonzero costs, and 6,840 (9.9%) had evidence of pneumonia. In the
OLS model, estimated costs were $3,949 (95%CI: $3,822–$4,076) higher in patients
with pneumonia; in the log-gamma model, the estimated costs were $4,442 (95%CI:
A328
$4,297–$4,587) higher; while the median quantile difference was $3,756 (95%CI:
$3,636–$3,876). The quantile regression differences ranged from a low of $2,078
(95%CI: $2,012–$2,145) for the 5th quantile to a high of $8,691 (95%CI: $8,395–
$8,987) for the 95th quantile. CONCLUSIONS: Results from econometric regression
models can vary greatly depending on model assumptions. Quantile regression results
provide a detailed picture of cost differences across the entire cost distribution, illustrating important non-uniformities of differences between groups.
PRS49
TESTING THE USABILITY AND LANGUAGE OF E-PRO TRANSLATIONS
DURING LINGUISTIC VALIDATION: COGNITIVE DEBRIEFING ON
E-DEVICE VS. PRINT OUTSCREENSHOTS
Grataloup G1, Fernandez N1, Dale P2, Muehlhausen W3
1
MAPI Institute, Lyon, France; 2GlaxoSmithKline, Middlesex, UK; 3Cardinal Health Research
Services, Hoechberg, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Electronic data collection is a prominent evolution in the PatientReported Outcomes (PRO) field. Developing translations for e-formats must involve
a rigorous methodology ensuring conceptual equivalence and cultural relevance across
languages. Ideally comprehension and acceptability of translations should be tested
using the actual e-device. For logistical reasons this may be challenging. Alternative
methods include testing of translations using print outs of screenshots. The translation
of an Asthma Diary into 20 languages was the opportunity to compare both methods.
METHODS: (1) Identification of the languages using e-device testing versus those
using screenshots; (2) comparison of the interview guides used for the respective testing
methods; and (3) analysis and comparison of the results. RESULTS: A total of 15
languages were tested on the e-device, 5 with screenshots. The interview guide used
to test the e-device contained linguistic considerations and questions on instructions
and use of the device. The interview guide for the screenshots was purely linguistic in
nature, so as not to confuse respondents with questions about the hypothetical use of
the e-device. In terms of linguistic observations no differences were seen between the
e-device and the screenshot testing methods. Feedback on the device usability differed
by country but also across regions. In most countries/languages observations were
made around the size of the font/screens and the device instructions. CONCLUSION:
Testing translations using the actual e-device not only provides comprehensive feedback on the language of the items, but also information on the practical use of the
device, and the interaction of both in the context of each country. Screenshot testing
can be considered an alternative in cases where e-device testing is difficult.
PRS50
EMPLOYING MULTI-ATTRIBUTE UTILITY THEORY TO DEVELOP THE
EXACT-U: A PREFERENCE-BASED MEASURE FOR COPD
EXACERBATION UTILITIES
Petrillo J1, Cairns J1, Revicki DA2
1
London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London, UK; 2United BioSource
Corporation, Bethesda, MD, USA
BACKGROUND: The EXACT (Exacerbations of COPD Tool) is a daily diary used
in clinical trials to evaluate frequency, severity, and duration of COPD exacerbations.
Reporting utilities from the EXACT allows a more accurate account of preference
change for economic evaluations than current methods. Multi-attribute utility theory
(MAUT) employs a series of equations to develop a function (MAUF) to report utilities. OBJECTIVES: To develop and validate an MAUF to estimate utilities from the
EXACT for use in UK cost-effectiveness studies. METHODS: EXACT-U is comprised
of 5 items with 3–5 levels each. Items and levels were grouped to form mixed-level
and corner health states. Development group was used for MAUF construction; separate Validation group was used to test functions. UK general public respondents valued
11 health states (including best/worst) using TTO from full health/dead over 10 years.
MAUF used the multiplicative model by: (1)-Calculating mean utility of each attribute
level; (2)- Calculating group disutilities for each level; (3)-Applying multiplicative
model to derive disutility function; and (4)-Converting disutility function to utility
function. Performance assessed by: number of inconsistencies predicted, mean absolute
error (MAE), and root mean squared error (RMSE). Models validated using a secondary analysis of a separate data set of EXACT patient data to test discriminant validity
(statistical significance) and responsiveness (standardized response mean (SRM)).
RESULTS: TTO interviews conducted with 400 respondents: 350 Development
group, 50 Validation group. Respondents were: 36 yrs old (13.5 SD), 39.2% male,
and 46.4% White British. MAUF reported MAE = 0.032, and RMSE = 0.170. Discriminant validity supported by utility differences by clinical severity: stable/acute (P
= 0.001); mild/moderate (p = 0.01); moderate/severe (p = 0.0001); and severe/very
severe (P = 0.14). Responsiveness by SRM was 0.52 (Day 3), 0.55 (Day 7), 0.66 (Day
10), and 0.76 (Day 13). CONCLUSIONS: The EXACT-U is a condition-specific
preference-based measure to report COPD exacerbation utilities with minimal error,
good discrimination, and good responsiveness.
13th Euro Abstracts
PRS51
ADVANCED PATTERN RECOGNITION METHODS FOR PREDICTING
TREATMENT RESPONSE IN PATIENTS SUFFERING FROM ALLERGIC
RHINITIS
Krajewski J, Koeberlein J
University of Wuppertal, Wuppertal, Germany
OBJECTIVES: The aim of the present analysis was to optimize the prediction of
treatment response in patients with allergic rhinitis. To determine an optimal prediction accuracy, we used different Pattern Recognition (PR) approaches and evaluated
their added value compared to standard predictive models as Logistic Regression, and
Linear Discriminant Analysis. METHODS: In order to optimize the prediction of
treatment response, 76,981 case reports of patient with allergic rhinitis from ten postmarketing-studies in Germany were analyzed by means of PR methodology. The
processing steps applied within this study are: (a) feature extraction (genetic algorithm
based synthetic feature calculation), (b) dimensionality reduction (correlation filter
based feature selection, wrapper based feature selection, Principle Component Analysis based feature transformation), (c) classification (Support Vector Machine, Decision
Tree, K-Nearest Neighbor, Random Forest, Artificial Neural Network, Bagging,
Boosting Logistic Regression, Linear Discriminant Analysis), and (d) validation (leaveone-sample-out cross validation). RESULTS: The AdaBoost Support Vector Machine
classifier with correlation filter based feature selection achieved the highest unweighted
mean recall rate (mean of sensitivity and specificity; URR) of 62.8%. The standard
Logistic Regression approach yielded 50.4% (−12.4%), the Linear Discriminant
Analysis 50.6% (−12.6%). CONCLUSIONS: In comparison to standard learning
schemes as e.g. Logistic Regression, and Linear Discriminant Analysis applying
advanced PR methods improves substantially the prediction of treatment response in
patients with allergic rhinitis. Due to the achieved added value and the superiority of
Pattern Recognition methods within several benchmarking studies, advanced PR
methods should be primarily considered for modeling and prediction tasks within the
field of pharmacoeconomics.
POSTER SESSION II
CONCEPTUAL PAPERS & RESEARCH ON METHODS – Clinical Outcomes
Methods
PMC1
BEST PRACTICES IN REPORTING OF PROSPECTIVE OBSERVATIONAL
STUDIES
Bharmal M, Viswanathan S, Gemmen E
Quintiles, Rockville, MD, USA
OBJECTIVES: Although a number of guidelines are available for the reporting of
clinical trials and interventional studies, there is limited consensus in the structure,
content and terminology associated with reporting of prospective non-interventional
observational studies. The objective of this study was to describe best practices in
reporting of observational studies based on a review of relevant guidelines for reporting data from clinical studies. METHODS: A systematic literature review was conducted and six relevant guidelines that could be adapted for reporting of results from
prospective non-interventional observational studies were identified. The guidelines
reviewed included the FDA guideline for abbreviated clinical study reports (CSR), the
EMEA guideline for CSR, the International Conference on Harmonization (ICH) E3
guideline for CSR, Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials (CONSORT) guideline
for pragmatic trials, the Strengthening the Reporting of Observational Studies in
Epidemiology (STROBE) guideline and the International Society for Pharmacoepidemiology (ISPE) guideline for safety reports. The structure, content, and terminology
used in the reporting template recommended by the various guidelines were analyzed.
RESULTS: There were substantial differences in the structure, content and terminology recommended by the six guidelines. For example, in contrast to all other guidelines, the CONSORT guidelines mention “Objectives” under “Methods” instead of
“ ‘Introduction.” Under the Results section, for reporting of unadjusted and adjusted
estimates from outcomes data, the STROBE guideline recommends its inclusion within
the Main Results section, whereas the CONSORT guideline recommends its inclusion
within the Outcomes and Estimation section. Some guidelines, especially those focusing on interventional studies, were more similar in content. CONCLUSIONS: Based
on the evaluation of similarities and differences in the guidelines, we propose a structure and template for reporting of prospective non-interventional observational
studies. Recommendations are also provided for adapting the proposed template based
on study objectives and design.
PMC2
ESTIMATING COST-EFFECTIVENESS BASED ON RESULTS OF
UNCONTROLLED CLINICAL TRIALS: OFATUMUMAB FOR THE
TREATMENT OF FLUDARABINE- AND ALEMTUZUMAB-REFRACTORY
CHRONIC LYMPHOCYTIC LEUKEMIA
Batty AJ1, Thompson GJ2, Maroudas PA2, Delea TE3
1
BresMed Health Solutions, Sheffield, UK; 2GlaxoSmithKline, Uxbridge, Middlesex, UK; 3Policy
Analysis Inc., Brookline, MA, USA
OBJECTIVES: Increasingly, innovative oncology drugs are licensed in settings where
randomised controlled trials (RCTs) are ethically and/or practically infeasible. The
13th Euro Abstracts
lack of an RCT makes formal technology assessment vs. alternative treatment (e.g.,
best supportive care [BSC]) challenging. In such instances, naïve indirect comparison
based on historical controls is typically employed. We present a method for estimating
outcomes for untreated patients when appropriate historical controls are not available,
by using data from non-responders in an uncontrolled trial. METHODS: Ofatumumab
was licensed for fludarabine- and alemtuzumab-refractory chronic lymphocytic leukaemia
(FA-Ref CLL) based on results of an uncontrolled trial (Hx-CD20-406). To evaluate the
cost-effectiveness of ofatumumab vs. BSC from the UK National Health Service perspective, a partitioned survival analysis model was developed. Progression free survival (PFS)
and overall survival (OS) for ofatumumab were estimated by fitting Weibull survival
functions to failure time data for all FA-Ref patients in Hx-CD20-406. Following a literature search, no suitable historical control representing BSC could be identified; therefore
hazard ratios for PFS and OS for BSC vs. ofatumumab were estimated by fitting Cox
regression models to data for non-responders vs. all FA-Ref patients. Costs and utilities
were taken from both published and unpublished sources. RESULTS: BSC patients
(approximated by non-responders) were estimated to achieve 4.7 months PFS, 11.3
months OS, 0.50 QALYs, and expected lifetime costs of £4,876. Ofatumumab patients
were estimated to reach 6.5 months PFS, 17.9 months OS, 0.77 QALYs, with expected
lifetime costs of £43,828. CONCLUSIONS: The novel approach presented permits a
practical alternative for estimating cost-effectiveness when neither an RCT nor appropriate historical control can be identified. Further research should be conducted using
established data sets to validate the methodology, and to address potential limitations,
e.g. unobserved differences between treatment groups, and potential benefits of treatment in patients classified as non-responders.
PMC3
A NOVEL APPROACH TO MATCHING ADJUSTED INDIRECT
COMPARISON ANALYSIS USING COMMON SAS 9.2 PROCEDURES
Malangone E1, Casciano R1, Sherman S1, Berenson K1, Stern L1, Di Lorenzo G2
1
Analytica International Inc., New York, NY, USA; 2University Federico II of Naples, Napoli,
Italy
OBJECTIVES: While randomized control trials (RCT) are the gold standard for drug
approval, there is often a lack of data directly comparing different treatment options.
An indirect comparison of the treatment effects may serve as a proxy for a head-tohead RCT, however, naively comparing treatments using published trial data without
adjusting for distribution differences in patient characteristics and prognostic factors
can result in misleading conclusions. a novel matched-adjusted approach to indirectly
compare absolute survival estimates (median overall survival (OS) or progression free
survival (PFS)) for competitive treatment options is presented. METHODS: This
proposed approach requires patient-level data for one of the treatments and summary
data of patient characteristics and survival outcomes for the comparator of interest.
Using this proposed method, the researcher would first decide on one or two matching
variables that are prognostic for survival, and apply a program involving an extension
of a common SAS 9.2 procedure, Proc Surveyselect, to select 1000 random repeated
sub-samples from the original population with the same distribution of matched
variables. The analysis also requires programming statements using ODS and survival
analysis procedures. The median OS or PFS estimates are computed for each bootstrapped sample and a 95% confidence interval (CI) is inferred around the mean of
the sampled survival estimates. These absolute survival estimates, based on the
adjusted population, can then be compared to the absolute survival estimates reported
in published literature of the comparator treatment. CONCLUSIONS: In the absence
of head-to-head RCT data, an adjusted indirect comparison accounts for observed
differences between populations making them more comparable and results in an effect
of treatment exposure on survival outcomes that is less likely due to confounders.
CONCEPTUAL PAPERS & RESEARCH ON METHODS – Cost Methods
PMC4
COST ESTIMATION IN HEALTH ECONOMIC EVALUATIONS IN
GERMANY: A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW
Merito M, Breitscheidel L, Eichmann F
Kendle GmbH, Munich, Germany
OBJECTIVES: The objectives of this study are: 1) to systematically review the methods
used in developing cost estimates in the recent German health economic literature;
and 2) to examine the methodological approaches in terms of analytical framework,
cost components, resource use and cost data sources in light of the national Institute
for Quality and Efficiency in Healthcare guidelines. METHODS: The MEDLINE
database was searched for studies published between 1-Jan-2006 and 31-Dec-2008
estimating direct and/or indirect costs of health care interventions in Germany.
Detailed information on the perspective of the analysis, time horizon, resource use
categories, costing approach, valuation of resource use, resource use and unit cost/
price data sources were systematically collected. RESULTS: The literature search
returned citations to 122 articles, of which 47 met the inclusion/exclusion criteria.
Nearly half of the selected articles (23) adopted the societal perspective and 21
(44.7%) the perspective of German Statutory Health Insurance funds. In nearly three
quarters of the studies (35) the time-horizon of the base-case analysis was no longer
than one year. Direct medical costs were reported in almost all articles; 25 studies
(53.2%) assessed only this cost category. Among the most common unit cost sources
of health care services were reimbursement fees for outpatient and hospital services,
together with market prices for drugs and medical devices, mentioned in 43 (91.5%)
A329
and 39 (83.0%) articles, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Although the variability in
the studies reviewed was very high, some common features emerged. Firstly, most cost
estimates focus on direct medical costs only. Secondly, a comprehensive list or at least
an exhaustive discussion of the relevant resource use is usually missing. Finally, the
time-horizon is often too short to capture all relevant cost drivers and the assessment
of the medical resource use not always consistent with the perspective of the
analysis.
PMC5
DEVELOPMENT OF A WEB-BASED SOFTWARE TOOL TO EVALUATE
THE ECONOMIC IMPACT OF LOST PRODUCTIVITY DUE TO
PREMATURE MORTALITY IN DEVELOPED AND EMERGING NATIONS
Marton JP2, Menzin JA1, Willke RJ2
1
Boston Health Economics, Inc., Waltham, MA, USA; 2Pfizer, Inc, New York, NY, USA
OBJECTIVES: Economic analyses that take a societal perspective need to incorporate
estimates of lost productivity due to premature death. Such estimates are likely to vary
substantially across countries, making it a challenge to assess the value of alternative
medical interventions on a global basis. Our goal was to develop a generic, web-based
software tool based on rigorous analytic methods that would enable researchers to
assess the expected discounted present value of lost productivity for persons who die
prematurely at various ages in selected developed and emerging nations. METHODS:
An analytic model framework was developed to estimate the expected discounted
present value of lost productivity due to premature mortality from a societal perspective using a human capital approach (with value attached to household work, as data
permitted). Key model inputs included life tables, labor force participation rates,
wages, and discount rates. Default input parameter values were based on each country’s national statistics, as available, or via generic “global” estimates when such data
were lacking. RESULTS: Model results were generated for 20 countries around the
world, and varied substantially based on patient age at death and the economic region
in which a country is located. For illustration purposes, the discounted present values
of lost productivity for a person who dies at age 25–29 in the US, Brazil, and Sweden
were estimated to be $US 945,162, 124,795, and 805,740, while the corresponding
values for those who die at age 45–49 were 622,248, 76,976, and 480,480. The webbased interface allows researchers to select the country of interest, modify default
values, and conduct sensitivity analyses. CONCLUSIONS: This generic web-based
software tool allows researchers to easily incorporate the value of lost productivity
due to premature mortality into economic analyses that take a societal perspective,
and provides estimates for many different developed and emerging countries.
PMC6
ASSESSING PRODUCTIVITY AND ACTIVITY IMPAIRMENT DUE TO
ILLNESS IN POLAND
Wrona W, Hermanowski T, Jakubczyk M, Golicki D, Macioch T
Department of Pharmacoeconomics, Medical University of Warsaw, Warsaw, Poland
OBJECTIVES: The inclusion of loss productivity costs in pharmacoeconomic studies
is still a subject of considerable debate. The aim of this study was to quantify the work
impairment due to general health status in Poland with the Productivity and Activity
Impairment: General Health (WPAI-GH) Questionnaire. METHODS: Data were
obtained from a survey that incorporated the WPAI-GH questionnaire and information on burden of care for a sick family member during computer-assisted personal
interview in a representative sample of the Polish general population aged more than
15 years. There were 2019 respondents in total, gathered in two waves in January
and May 2010. RESULTS: The total population comprised 795 subjects in paid jobs.
Subjects reported 4.5% work time missed (absenteeism) during the past 7 days.
Impairment while at work (presenteeism) amounted to 13.9% of total time. The
overall work productivity loss (absenteeism plus presenteeism) equalled 15.2%.
Impairment in performing daily activity was 15.6% in the past 7 days. Observed
percentages were in general higher in subject from the first wave of study (January
2010) than from second wave (May 2010)—differences did not reach statistical significance. The general tendency of a higher absenteeism and a lower presenteeism
values among men than among women were observed. CONCLUSIONS: Productivity
and Activity Impairment measured by WPAI-GH in the Polish population are similar
to these observed in other European countries and the U.S. Moderate differences
between values estimated in January and May suggest limited impact of seasonal
diseases such as influenza on productivity.
PMC7
TARIFF LISTS FROM SPANISH AUTONOMOUS COMMUNITIES: AN
ASSESSMENT OF ITS STRUCTURE, CONTENTS, AND TARIFF LEVELS
De Cock E1, Raluy M2, Rovira J3
1
United BioSource Corporation, Barcelona, Spain; 2United BioSource Corporation, London,
UK; 3Barcelona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: There exists no standardised list of unit costs (UC) for use in economic
evaluations in Spain. Tariffs published by the 17 Autonomous Communities (ACs)
are often used as a proxy for costs. We explored the structure and contents of AC
tariff lists and tariff ranges for common resource use items. METHODS: Current tariff
lists published in the Official Bulletins from 16 Spanish ACs were retrieved. Tariffs
for key health services in the following categories were extracted: specialist and A&E
visits, hospitalization, investigations, procedures, laboratory tests, and episodes of care
(DRGs). We qualitatively assessed structure and contents of tariff lists, item content
for selected items. Ranges, normal mean and weighted mean (according to
A330
demographic size of ACs) were calculated for selected tariffs. RESULTS: We observed
lack of consistency in structure and contents of tariff lists and in tariff levels, as
exemplified by: different categorization of services; incomplete listing of services; different terminologies; different levels of detail for common services (e.g. MRI: 2–127
options by body area and/or complexity); wide ranges of tariffs for most items (e.g.
specialist visit: c56–c191, general ward per diem: c82–c569, simple MRI: c120–c634).
Wide variations were also observed for other diagnostic investigations, (non-)surgical
procedures, laboratory tests and DRGs. CONCLUSIONS: Wide ranges in tariffs for
health resources commonly used in economic evaluations were identified across ACs,
with a difference between minimum and maximum values of at least factor 2. There
exists no evidence on how tariffs are calculated and if they reflect real cost. Available
AC tariffs should be used with caution and a simple or weighted average across AC
tariff lists may be used as proxies for nation-wide costs. Elaboration of a nation-wide
list would avoid possible bias from analysts in the selection of cost values to obtain
given results.
PMC8
BURDEN OF DISEASE AND ECONOMIC EVALUATION: ARE WE
INVESTIGATING WHAT IT REALLY MATTERS?
Catalá-López F1, Garcia-Altés A2, Álvarez-Martín E3, Gènova-Maleras R4, Morant-Ginestar
C4, Parada A5
1
Spanish Medicines and Healthcare Products Agency (AEMPS), Madrid, Spain; 2King’s College
London, London, UK; 3Rey Juan Carlos University, Madrid, Spain; 4Regional Health Council of
Madrid, Madrid, Spain; 5Agencia de Evaluación de Tecnología e Investigación Médicas
(AATRM), Barcelona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: We examined the association between economic evaluation studies
performed in Spain in 1983–2008 and the burden of disease in the population.
METHODS: Cross-sectional observational study. Electronic databases (Pubmed/
MEDLINE, SCOPUS, ISI Web of Knowledge, CRD, IME, IBECS) and reports from
public agencies were systematically reviewed. Inclusion and exclusion criteria and a
set of variables were defined to analyze the characteristics of the papers selected. Using
the Global Burden of Disease (GBD) study classification the following measures were
calculated: years of life lost (YLLs), years lived with disability (YLDs), disabilityadjusted life-years (DALYs), and mortality by cause. Correlation and linear regression
models were used. RESULTS: Cardiovascular diseases (15.7%), infectious and parasitic diseases (15.3%), and malignant neoplasms (13.2%) were the conditions most
commonly addressed. Accidents and injuries, congenital anomalies, oral conditions,
nutritional deficiencies and other neoplasms were the categories with a lowest number
of studies (0.6% from the total for each of them). The disease sub-categories most
prevalent in the studies were lower respiratory infections (5.7%), ischemic heart
disease (5.7%), hepatitis B and C (3.3%) and HIV/AIDS (3.1%). For GBD categories
(n = 20), a correlation was seen with: mortality 0.67 (p = 0.001), DALYs 0.63 (p =
0.003), YLLs 0.54 (p = 0.014), and YLDs 0.51 (p = 0.018). By diseases sub-categories
(n = 51), the correlations were low and non statistically significant. CONCLUSIONS:
There is a mild-moderate association of economic evaluations with the main causes
of burden of disease. For some conditions, the data show over or under-representation
of studies related to their burden generated. The burden of disease is a criterion that,
in combination with efficiency and equity, would allow to set recommendations to
guide debates on health research priority setting.
PMC9
A NEO-RICARDIAN APPROACH TOWARD DISCOUNTING
Parouty M, Boersma C, Postma MJ
University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands
BACKGROUND: The major focus of the history of economic thought has been
devoted to defining a scientific theory of value. An even harder task entails formulating
a theory of intertemporal value. Work on this theory date back to the birth of modern
economic thought. For example, some authors have argued that an intertemporal
utility based theory of value involves the explanation of a quantity which can be
directly observed and measured in terms of a quantity which cannot. Major current
debates on discounting therefore surround the need for a scientific definition and the
ethics towards intergenerational justice. OBJECTIVES: We investigate how several
current issues in discounting might be irrelevant by adopting a Neo-Ricardian view
of intertemporal value by recursively applying valuation of a commodity from value
of input commodities, thereby simplifying to the Physiocratic School. We further
investigate how our empirical model might be extended to current utilitarian philosophy. METHODS: We adopt a Sraffian approach and devise a pure value-growth
matrix that relies only on empirical data. We first derive a 2 × 2 matrix and then a 3
× 3 matrix. We use health effects, income and a third externality for the derivations.
RESULTS: It seems that the Neo-Riccardian approach provides the necessary requirements towards satisfying a scientific definition of intertemporal value and allows
extension of the classical framework of health and wealth with a 3rd dimension of
externalities. Furthermore, by redefining the pure growth term in our 2 × 2 matrix
with the Ramsey discount rate, our results simplify to current economic theory.
CONCLUSIONS: Although modern economic theory explains value from a utilitarian
viewpoint, it seems that it lacks robustness in explaining intertemporal value. Therefore, we suggest that the Sraffian School of economic thought should also be considered when attempting to formulate a discount rate for health effects, within a concept
of sustainable growth.
13th Euro Abstracts
PMC10
RELIABILITY OF MANUFACTURERS’ BUDGET IMPACT ESTIMATES IN
POLAND
Iwanczuk T, Szewczyk K, Zagorska A
Agency for Health Technology Assessment in Poland, Warszawa, Poland
OBJECTIVE: To verify the reliability of the methodology used in the manufacturers’
Budget Impact Analyses (BIAs) submitted in reimbursement dossier to Polish HTA
Agency, we compared public payer (National Health Fund—NHF) actual expenditures on selected drugs with their estimated costs. METHODS: BIAs of medicines
reimbursed for at least one year and assessed previously in Agency were selected for
the analysis. The BI estimated by the manufacturer in the first year after product’s
introduction to reimbursement was used. Estimated size of target population was
compared with the actual one. The actual data was obtained from the NHF. BIAs for
selected medicines were critically appraised to determine any variables that may have
affected its reliability. RESULTS: 20 BIAs met inclusion criteria and were included
into the study. Forty-five percent (9/20) of the BI expenditures were underestimated.
Median and mean difference between actual and estimated expenditure were 17,22%
and 30,25% respectively. The overestimation was found in 55% BIAs (11/20); median
= 262,26%, mean difference = 2267,25%. Population size was underestimated in 65%
(13/20) of the BIAs. Median and mean difference between actual and estimated population were 25,61% and 33,93% respectively. Overestimation of the population was
found in 35% (7/20) of the BIAs; median = 566,67%, mean difference = 573,28%.
The main factors that could influence differences between predictions and actual
spending were: underestimated (65%) or overestimated (35%) number of patients
eligible for treatment, overestimated (30%) or underestimated (25%) market share,
wrong assumption on 100% compliance (15%). CONCLUSION: The study has demonstrated large variances between predicted budget impact and actual expenditures on
drugs. It also revealed significant weaknesses in the quality of submitted BIAs, e.g.: errors
in calculations, very limited data provided by manufacturer that unable to complete revision and reproduce of figures in the calculation.
PMC11
ARE THRESHOLD RANGES FOR COST PER QALY A BARRIER TO
RESEARCH FOR LIFE EXTENDING TREATMENTS
Roberts G, de Nigris E
Double Helix Consulting Group, London, UK
As they are currently used thresholds for cost per QALY may provide a disincentive
for companies to invest in research for therapies that prolong life in conditions with
an already high treatment cost. Cost per QALY thresholds, although not the sole basis
for decision making are a major influence on whether a technology is considered
cost-effective by NICE. Discussions have centred on the most appropriate threshold
level and how its value should be determined. However a consequence of cost per
QALY thresholds that is not discussed is the impact they may have on future health
care research. The cost per QALY for renal dialysis has been estimated at £30,0001,
the higher end of what NICE considers acceptable. We have therefore reached the
ceiling for the cost of treating renal disease. Assuming that utility is not improved a
treatment that extends life will be at additional cost and have a cost per QALY greater
than £30,000. Manufacturers of health care technologies may consider that the risk
of not getting a product approved on cost-effectiveness grounds is not worth the
financial investment in its development. As health care costs continue to grow the
management costs of more conditions will exceed £20,000 per year and future
research may be stifled as manufacturers seek to develop products that replace rather
than add to current treatments. Since the background treatment cost would cancel out
in an incremental analysis a treatment could be more cost-effective than the one it
replaces but perversely can still be at an increased cost which raises the cost per QALY
of standard treatment above £20,000 or £30,000. As treatment costs for more conditions increase to threshold values (even if they are raised) manufactures may be advised
to consider realigning their portfolio and investment to other diseases.
PMC12
ASSESSMENT OF THE WORKLOAD REAL TIME DEDICATED TO EACH
PATIENT IN INTENSIVE CARE UNITS (ICU): PRELIMINARY RESULTS OF
THE CRRÉA STUDY
Garrigues B1, Lefrant JY2, Pribil C3, Bazin J4, Maurel F5
1
Centre Hospitalier du pays d’Aix, Aix-en-Provence, France; 2CHU de Nimes, Nimes,
France; 3GSK France, Marly le roi, France; 4CHRU de Clermont-Ferrand, Clermont-Ferrand,
France; 5IMS Health, Puteaux, France
OBJECTIVES: The objective of the CRRéa study is to assess the real daily cost of a
patient’s stay in ICU in France. We present here preliminary results regarding the
average time spent per patient by different health caregivers. METHODS: A prospective multicentric health economic study was performed in 23 ICUs of different French
hospitals randomly selected from the PMSI database (French National Hospital database). In a one day study, 5 adult patients were randomly selected among patients
with a simplified severity score ≥ 15 in each ICU. Data on all the resources used,
treatments administered, biological tests performed, etc. and time spent by different
health caregiver to take care of each patient over a 24 hour period (direct and indirect
interventions) were collected through a time and motion analysis method involving
the professionals themselves. RESULTS: A total of 109 patients (median age = 66
years, 65% males) of 22 intensive care units (15 polyvalent, 3 surgical and 4 medical
ICUs) were included. 104 of them were followed over 24 hours (there were 2 deaths
and 3 early withdrawals). On the day of the study, 84% of patients were mechanically
13th Euro Abstracts
ventilated with a median SOFA score = 6. The median cumulated time dedicated to
one patient by physicians, nurses and caregivers was 10h20 over the 24-hour period
(1h15 by physician, 6h08 by nurses and 2h57 by caregivers). CONCLUSIONS: The
median time of more than 10 hours directly dedicated to a patient is a key information
for the estimation of the real cost of one day stay in ICU
PMC13
METHODS AND IMPACT OF INCORPORATING MEDICATION
COMPLIANCE INTO PHARMACOECONOMIC EVALUATIONS
Park SY, Lee EK
SookMyung Women’s University, Seoul, South Korea
OBJECTIVES: This study aims to identify how medication compliance and/or persistence were assessed in the cost-effectiveness analysis, and what the impact was on
ICER(Incremental cost-effectiveness ratio). METHODS: Pharmacoeconomic studies
with compliance and/or persistence measures, had published from March 2005 to
February 2010, were searched through MEDLINE. Articles were included if they
integrated medication compliance and/or persistence into the economic analysis
model. We reviewed the target diseases, the model designs, and the impact of noncompliance on the treatment costs and effects. After that, the results were compared
with a previous review article of ISPOR MCP(Medication compliance and persistence
special interest group) had conducted in 2007. RESULTS: The search identified 77
articles, and 10 of them were selected. Even though the overall kinds of target diseases
were different, most of them were chronic diseases, which have remission and relapse
as common characteristics. Variety of modeling techniques such as decision-analysis
and Markov model, DES (Discrete event simulation) were used for the evaluations.
In decision-analysis models, the branches of decision trees represented different level
of compliance. In case of Markov models, transition probabilities assumed to be higher
for those patients who were non-persistent or non-adherent to treatment. Finally,
considering the effect of compliance and/or persistence, it may cause decrease of ICER
for new intervention. CONCLUSIONS: We found that incorporating compliance and/
or persistence into economic evaluations lead to favorable results to new intervention.
However, there was a lack of methodological rigor and consistency in definition.
Therefore, development of guidance is needed for measurement, analysis, interpretation, and application of compliance and persistence from variety of data sources.
PMC14
DISCOUNTING HEALTH EFFECTS: A REVIEW OF THE SYSTEM
Parouty M, Boersma C, Postma MJ
University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands
BACKGROUND: Discounting health effects remains a matter of great debate these
days. Currently, discussion focuses on whether health effects should be discounted at
the same rate as costs or not. High discount rates for health effects are impacting
negatively on the cost-effectiveness of screening and vaccination programs. Discounting health at a lower rate than wealth has however been argued to result in theoretical
inconsistencies and practical unnecessary delays in implementation of health programs. Many authors have therefore assumed that there is a one-to-one relationship
between health and wealth. OBJECTIVES: We investigate the rationality of several
assumptions involved towards current discounting procedures. We especially investigated the assumption of a one-to-one relationship between health and wealth.
METHODS: We performed a literature review to link the issues in current methods
of discounting health effects with the assumptions involved. Furthermore, we analyzed
other possible linkages of health rather than with wealth only. RESULTS: We noticed
that although income might depict the marginal substitution between all commodities,
it seems that externalities are not accounted for. Yet, research has shown that all forms
of economic growth exert intrinsically negative population health effects among the
communities that are most directly involved in the transformations which it entails.
This may obviously impact on valuation of health states and preferences, measured
using instruments as the EuroQol-5D. These arguments support differential discounting of health effects, and potential further extensions such as differential discounting
of life and quality. CONCLUSIONS: Although there might be a relationship between
wealth and health, it appears that externalities may play an additional role on the
quality of life. Therefore, it seems that we should regard the discounting problem of
health effects as an interlinked system, rather than an equation with only health and
wealth and allow differential discounting of, and potentially even within, health
effects.
PMC15
A NOVEL METHOD FOR COMBINING THREE CURRENT ESTIMATION
APPROACHES TO PHARMACEUTICAL PRICING
Sheng J, Malhotra M, Vincent L, Hoschander S, Doyle J
Quintiles Global Consulting, Hawthorne, NY, USA
Three of the more common methods of estimating the optimal price for prospective
pharmaceutical products are willingness-to-pay, value-based price appraisal, and reference price benchmarking assessments. Each method in itself, however, has inherent
limitations. The objective of this study is to present a novel technique in pharamceutical price estimation for arriving at an evidence based price-point. Willingness-to-pay,
as assessed through primary research, is limited by lack of knowledge of product prices
and the disconnect between respondent answers and real-life price acceptance. Valuebased price appraisals, utilizing cost-of-treatment models to estimate the price at which
new products are cost-effective relative to other options, are subject to error and
interpretation and are rarely taken at face value by stakeholders who drive price
A331
acceptance. Reference price benchmarking, looking to market analogues to gauge
appropriate price-points for new products, can be a good starting point but does not
take into account unique product differences, perceived or real, of new products. To
address gaps and weaknesses of any given individual method, our method of determining optimal product price uses all three pricing methodologies to triangulate on a
recommended price-point. Market analogues are used as a base-price starting point.
a value-based cost-of-treatment model is used to determine potential cost-savings that
can be offset in price. Finally, primary research is used to determine how to modify
that price based on perceived differences in the target product, and the how costsavings might be considered in price.
CONCEPTUAL PAPERS & RESEARCH ON METHODS – Databases &
Management Methods
PMC16
HOW DO THIN DEATH DATA COMPARE TO NATIONAL FIGURES FOR
EACH UK COUNTRY?
Blak BT, Hards M, Lee J
CSD EPIC, London, UK
OBJECTIVES: Primary care patient data are increasingly used for research and recording of death is important as it helps define end of follow-up and mortality may be a
study outcome. This study compared recording of death in a UK primary care database
with national death rates for England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland (NI).
METHODS: The annual number of deaths (1990 to 2008) for each country was
collected after the mortality recording quality threshold from The Health Improvement
Network (THIN) database. THIN holds longitudinal anonymised primary care
medical records from an increasing number of practices over time and currently
contains data from more than 450 practices throughout the UK. Annual age and
gender specific person time was estimated and multiplied with annual age, gender and
country specific death rates to derive the expected number of deaths. Observed deaths
divided by expected deaths provided the standardised mortality ratio (SMR) and
Byar’s approximation formula was applied to derive 95% confidence intervals (CI).
An SMR close to 1.0 indicates that recorded deaths are near national rates. RESULTS:
The average annual number of practices was 263.5 (standard deviation (SD):80.2) for
England, 18.8 (SD:8.5) for Wales, 33.6 (SD:17.0) for Scotland, and 14.0 (SD:7.6) for
NI. Average annual death rate per 1,000 population in THIN was 10.41 (SD:1.05)
overall, 10.38 (SD:1.02) in England, 11.25 (SD:1.45) in Wales, 11.03 (SD:1.54) in
Scotland and 8.29 (SD:0.77) in NI. The average annual SMR was 0.88 (SD:0.02)
overall, 0.88 (SD:0.02) in England, 0.94 (SD:0.05) in Wales, 0.94 (SD:0.10) in Scotland and 0.91(SD:0.07) in NI. CONCLUSIONS: The observed death rates were
slightly lower than expected (SMR < 1) over time and in each country, especially in
England. Social deprivation impacts death rates and as unadjusted for this could
explain some variation. Reasons for lower rates need to be investigated further.
PMC17
ASSISTANCE COST DEPENDING ON COMORBIDITY IN PRIMARY CARE
A SPANISH INTERREGIONAL LEVEL
Sicras-Mainar A1, Velasco-Velasco S2, Navarro-Artieda R3, Violan-Fors C4, Blanca-Tamayo
M2, Vega Martín M5, Prados-Torres A6
1
Directorate of Planning, Badalona Serveis Assistencials, Badalona, Barcelona, Spain;
2
Badalona Serveis Assistencials SA, Barcelona, Spain; 3Hospital Universitari Germans Trias i
Pujol, Barcelona, Spain; 4Jordi Gol i Gurina Primary Health Care Research Institute. IDIAP,
Barcelona, Spain; 5Son Llatzer Hospital, Palma de Mallorca, Spain; 6Health Sciences Institute
of Aragon, Zaragoza, Spain
OBJECTIVES: The objective of the study is to obtain behaviour of the cost’s relative
average weights of the assistance with the retrospective application of the Adjusted
Clinical Groups (ACG’s) in 16 teams of Primary Care with an attended population in
the clinical practice use. METHODS: Multicentre, retrospective study based on electronic records of patients seeking care during 2008 in the regions of Aragon, Balears
and Catalonia. Main measurements: universal variables (age, sex, health service-family
practice/paediatrics) and dependent variables: episodes and total cost (visits, diagnostic
test, referrals, drugs). The ACG case-mix System software (version 8.2; N = 106)
classified subjects into a single category for a given annual resource consumption. The
model of cost per each patient was established differencing the fix cost and the variable. Outlier patients were considered those surpassing T = Q3 + 1.5(Q3-Q1) =
c1778.6 for total cost expenditure. Log transformation of the dependent variable was
carried out to reduce skewness of the distribution and make it close to normal.
Explanatory power was calculated by coefficients of determination (R2). Statistical
software: SPSS, P < 0.05. RESULTS: The total number of the studied patients was
227,235 (intensity of use: 75.6%), with an average 4.5 ± 3.2 episodes. The age average
was of 44.1 ± 23.7 years, 56.6% women (13.5% paediatrics). The distribution of
costs was c148,657,137. The total unitary cost per patient/year c654.2 ± 851.7 (relative weights of reference). Patient’s case-mix: 57.2% of the study population was
grouped into 10 ACG. The explanatory power of the ACG classification system was
36.3% (Ln: 41.2%), P < 0,001. a total of 6.2% of patients were considered Outliers
(N = 14.066). CONCLUSIONS: The ACG are an acceptable system of classification
of patients in situation of clinical practice use. Some ACG classification categories
should be separeted due to the high outliers number.
A332
PMC18
MULTI-NATIONAL CHART REVIEW STUDIES IN EUROPE:
OPPORTUNITIES AND CHALLENGES
Payne KA1, Wasiak R2, Stein D1, Chancellor J3
1
United BioSource Corporation, Dorval, QC, Canada; 2United BioSource Corporation,
London, UK; 3Chancellor Health Economics Ltd, Beaconsfield, Buckinghamshire, UK
OBJECTIVES: In support of European pricing and reimbursement submissions,
country-specific health economic evidence is required. In the absence of patient-level
databases, multi-national, retrospective chart review studies can provide data related
to real-world patient characteristics, patterns of care, clinical outcomes and the natural
history of disease. METHODS: A critical review and qualitative analysis of six recent
multi-national chart review case studies designed to inform health economic questions
was performed to characterize common research aims, objectives, and design parameters, and to delineate main methodological, operational and analytic challenges.
RESULTS: Design challenges include defining an eligibility period sufficiently long to
obtain enough cases while accessing patterns of care that are current, sample size
determination and balancing the need for stable estimates of resource utilization with
the need to contain study costs, and delineating sampling frame methodology to minimize chart selection bias. Detailed treatment and clinical outcome data must be
weighed in the context of abstractor burden, and data collection methods should be
considered separately from data interpretation. a common case report form for multinational studies should allow local area treatment variation while maintaining consistency in data collection across health care settings. Operationally, knowledge of
country-specific ethics and privacy protection regulations for retrospective studies is
paramount as requirements are diverse and impact timelines differently. Successful
study execution is also dependent on the ability to rapidly identify and recruit clinical
sites representative of a broad range of clinical practice that also can provide sufficient
geographical coverage. CONCLUSIONS: Despite significant challenges, practical,
efficient, and scientifically sound approaches to the design and conduct of multinational chart review studies in support of health economic analyses are possible.
Main methodological and operational challenges can be identified across studies, thus
can be anticipated and planned for.
CONCEPTUAL PAPERS & RESEARCH ON METHODS – Modeling Methods
PMC19
THE THRESHOLD PRICING MODEL: NOT JUST ANOTHER COSTEFFECTIVENESS MODEL
Mladsi D1, Earnshaw S1, Akashi-Ronquest N1, Keith MS2
1
RTI Health Solutions, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA; 2Shire Pharmaceuticals, Wayne, PA,
USA
BACKGROUND: Threshold analysis as it is typically applied to cost-effectiveness
models is an extension of sensitivity analysis in which the threshold analysis may be
used to demonstrate the maximum price given different levels of health outcomes
resulting in cost-effectiveness. In these instances, the ICER is the primary result of the
model, and threshold analysis aids interpretation. As a result, the model is restricted
to the intended target indication, population, and line of therapy, reflecting key
development decisions that have already been made. In contrast, a threshold pricing
model, which is developed early in a drug’s development, is not attempting to evaluate
the drug’s cost-effectiveness. Instead, it is built to inform the development plan, pricing
strategy, and go/no-go investment decisions. OBJECTIVES: To outline the differences
in the underlying mathematical structure, inputs, and outputs of a threshold pricing
model compared with a traditional cost-effectiveness model, and to demonstrate its
application. METHODS: We present the algebraic manipulations required to convert
a decision-analytic model into one used for threshold pricing analysis. Using a hypothetical new pharmaceutical possessing two versions of a product profile, we demonstrate application of the threshold pricing model by generating a table of potential
value-based pricing estimates corresponding to the unique combinations of indication,
subpopulation, line of therapy, and comparator. We provide graphical depictions of
the lost value-based pricing opportunity (reflecting the lost opportunity for the new
product to address a greater unmet need) of development strategies that are not valuedriven. CONCLUSIONS: a threshold pricing model is a powerful tool for helping to
construct a value-driven development plan and a value-based pricing strategy. Constructed appropriately, threshold pricing models can be used to prioritize among
possible indications, identify target subpopulations, select the appropriate line of
therapy, and choose and clarify required performance against comparators.
PMC20
THE OPTIMAL NUMBER OF MONTE CARLO SIMULATIONS TO BE
PERFORMED IN PROBABILISTIC SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS: EMPIRICAL
EVIDENCE FROM ECONOMIC MODELS CONSTRUCTED FOR
SUBMISSION TO THE NATIONAL INSTITUTE FOR HEALTH AND
CLINICAL EXCELLENCE
Batty AJ1, Paulden M2
1
BresMed Health Solutions, Sheffield, UK; 2University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada
OBJECTIVES: Probabilistic Sensitivity Analysis (PSA) is a common technique to assess
uncertainty in economic models, with the majority of economic model publications
now containing some form of PSA. Historically the number of simulations performed
has been set at arbitrary levels (e.g. 1,000 simulations), however the aim of this
research is to rationalise the number of simulations performed, minimizing both
13th Euro Abstracts
wasted computational time and the risk of incorrect conclusions being drawn.
METHODS: The analysis investigates the number of simulations required in order for
a Cost-Effectiveness Acceptability Curve (CEAC) to remain stable at the periphery.
Secondary analyses focused on the number of simulations required to give reliable
estimates of the mean values in these (non-linear) models. In the UK the National
Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) require manufacturers to submit
PSA as part of the Single Technology Appraisal (STA) process. Models from different
contract research agencies that have been constructed in Microsoft Excel, for submission to NICE, were then used to generate 50,000 simulations per model. This data
was retrospectively analyzed to determine the number of simulations required such
that a cost-effectiveness acceptability curve would remain stable at the periphery (5th
and 95th percentiles). Secondary analyses focused on the number of simulations
required to give reliable estimates of the mean values in these (non-linear) models.
RESULTS: Preliminary analyses suggest that conventional numbers of simulations are
sufficient to estimate the CEAC at low levels of precision at the 5% and 95% limits and
generate the mean value. However this is not the case if high levels of precision are
required. CONCLUSIONS: Research in to the optimum number of Monte Carlo
Simulations allows analysts to ground the number performed in empirical data, and
suggests that accuracy can be achieved without spurious precision, wasted computing
time, or worse, unreliable/unstable conclusions.
PMC21
USING GROWTH IN THE COST-EFFECTIVENESS THRESHOLD TO
INFORM THE DIFFERENTIAL BETWEEN THE DISCOUNT RATES ON
COSTS AND HEALTH EFFECTS: REASON TO BE CAUTIOUS?
O’Mahony J
Erasmus University Medical Center, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
BACKGROUND: Differential discounting of the costs and effects of health care
interventions has been extensively debated. Proponents argue that a rising valuation
of health as incomes grow justifies discounting health effects at a lower rate than costs.
However, despite that fact that the impact of differential discounting is highly sensitive
to the difference between the two rates, little attention has been paid what the appropriate differential should be. The existing justification for the differential rests the
income and health elasticities of utility and income and health growth rates, all of
which are uncertain: estimates of the appropriate differential are speculative at best.
The discount differentials recommended by cost-effectiveness analysis advisory bodies
vary, being 1.5 percentage points in Belgium, 2.5 in the The Netherlands and 4.5 in
the UK prior to 2004. What has not been widely recognised is that the differential
should approximate the annual rate of growth in the cost-effectiveness threshold: this
has been shown in a simple model published in the literature in which decision makers
use a cost-effectiveness threshold in their reimbursement decision rule. ANALYSIS:
This link to threshold growth provides a more immediate alternative by which empirically determine the appropriate differential compared to the current estimates. While
cost-effectiveness thresholds are often not made explicit, there is no strong evidence
that they have risen in recent years. Indeed, there are reasons to expect thresholds to
remain constant or even decline, even if income growth is positive. CONCLUSION:
This consideration of the plausible discounting differential complements current theoretical debate over differential discounting. Growth in cost-effectiveness thresholds
provides an alternative basis for justifying the discount differential. Existing evidence
and expectations of threshold growth leads to conservative estimates of the discounting differential of at or near zero.
PMC22
REVENUE OPTIMIZATION MODEL TO OPTIMISE POSITION AND
INDICATION OF NEW LAUNCHES
Mukku S, McConkey D
Double Helix Consulting Group, London, UK
OBJECTIVES: To assess the impact on revenues from a new drug in different indications and at different positions within a treatment pathway. METHODS: The model
was developed by price modeling experts at Double Helix Consulting using a logical
flow developed over years. The model is tested by internal and external experts with
different products. RESULTS: Drugs that reach to market very rarely are released in
only a single indication, especially in chronic disease areas where there may be several
different illnesses with a related etiology but different presentation. This is exemplified
in the field of immunology and rheumatology, where several different drugs with a
similar MOA are being used to treat many conditions that are pathophysiologically
related. To explore the impact that multiple indications or use in different lines has
or will have on the pricing of a new therapeutic agent, Double Helix Consulting generated a revenue optimization model that can be used to establish the most likely price
point for a new drug given several different scenarios. This model will help in optimizing the best position and or indication for long term revenues from the drug. The
model uses EPI data, prevalence, incidence, number of competitors, prices of comparators, line of treatment and other inputs. The outputs include NPV over a chosen period
of time that can be sorted by line of treatment and indication. CONCLUSIONS: While
it is desirable for a drug to be indicated in the largest patient pool possible, such
actions can have serious negative consequences for the price at which payers are
willing to pay for the treatment. a larger patient pool makes the burden on the health
care provider significant if the drug is too expensive, and as a result can lead to significant price erosion or HTA rejection.
13th Euro Abstracts
PMC23
PROPOSED METHODS FOR CONDUCTING SENSITIVITY ANALYSES ON
THRESHOLD-DERIVED ESTIMATES OF VALUE-BASED PRICE AND
PRODUCT PROFILES FOR EARLY-STAGE DRUGS
Mladsi D1, Earnshaw S1, Akashi-Ronquest N1, Keith MS2
1
RTI Health Solutions, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA; 2Shire Pharmaceuticals, Wayne, PA,
USA
BACKGROUND: Established methods exist for evaluating the effects of uncertainty
around the model structure and parameters on the results generated by traditional
cost-effectiveness analyses (CEAs) and include one-way and probabilistic sensitivity
analyses (SAs). In contrast to the primary outcome of a traditional CEA—the ICER—
the primary outcomes of a threshold CEA conducted for a product early in development include (1) the value-based price opportunity given a hypothetical or target
product profile and (2) the magnitude of effect required to justify a target price.
Because the outputs of a threshold model pertain to a new drug or indication where
little or no data have been collected, and because the outputs are multiple, representing
the set of product attributes, including price, that will define drug value, there is a
need to explore the sensitivity of the results to factors that go beyond uncertainty. In
analyses that generate potential value-based price or product attribute levels, new
methods and applications of SA are required. METHODS: We present example
one-way and probabilistic SAs, highlighting problems in interpretation that arise when
traditional sensitivity analyses are applied to threshold models. We propose alternative
SA methods and analyses and present interpretations of results. a Pricing Contribution
Diagram is presented as a means of characterizing the extent to which each product
attribute (efficacy, safety, tolerability, quality of life, position in care pathway) influences the value-based price opportunity. Probabilistic SAs are presented to examine
the relationship between price (value-based and target) and individual product attributes, and the influence of uncertainty in other model inputs. CONCLUSIONS:
Traditional methods of conducting SA are insufficient when applied to the threshold
application of CEA. Instead, SAs specific to threshold models supporting decisions
regarding early stage development should be employed.
PMC24
LAST OBSERVATION CARRIED FORWARD (LOCF) VS. MIXED-EFFECTS
MODEL REPEATED MEASURES (MMRM): EMPIRICAL EVALUATION OF
TWO APPROACHES TO ANALYZING LONGITUDINAL DATA WITH
MISSING OBSERVATIONS
Jo H1, Gemmen E2, Bharmal M2
1
Quintiles, Parsippany, NJ, USA; 2Quintiles, Rockville, MD, USA
OBJECTIVES: To compare two statistical approaches for analyzing longitudinal data
with missing observations: 1)imputation using Last Observation Carried Forward
method (LOCF) and 2)Mixed-effects Model Repeated Measures method (MMRM) to
analyze the change from baseline in health-related quality of life (HRQoL) by medication adherence level. METHODS: HRQoL via SF-12 Health Survey and medication
adherence via a 5-level categorical response was measured monthly for one-year for
184 patients in a U.S. multiple sclerosis observational study. HRQoL was summarized
in two continuous variables: Physical Component Score (PCS-12) and Mental Component Score (MCS-12). Categorically collected medication adherence was converted
to numeric values and average compliance was calculated over a 1-year period then
categorized into two groups: ≥90% (GT90) or <90% (LT90) compliant. For validity
of compliance, patients who had completed at least 6 measurements during 1-year on
compliance question were included. LOCF used the last available change from baseline
to impute the missing values for early drop-out. MMRM is a likelihood-based
approach which models all actual observations jointly, with no attempt at imputation
for missing values. RESULTS: A total of 131 patients were included in this analysis.
The 12-month change from baseline in PCS-12 comparing patients with GT90 compliance vs. LT90 compliance using MMRM was 0.86 (p = 0.277) and using LOCF was
1.30 (p = 0.339). For MCS-12, the improvement among patients with GT90 compliance over LT90 compliance using MMRM was 2.04, while the corresponding
improvement using LOCF was 1.97. For MCS-12, only the MMRM method produced
statistically significant improvements (p-values: LOCF = 0.234, MMRM = 0.026).
CONCLUSIONS: MMRM and LOCF yielded not only different results but also different statistical significance in the 12-month change from baseline in MCS-12. Since
the approach to estimate and model is different between two methods, the pattern
and shape of data must be investigated to find the right method to produce valid
estimates.
PMC25
STATISTICAL DISTRIBUTIONS OF COST DATA IN PROBABILISTIC
SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS
Lacey L
Lacey Solutions Ltd, Skerries, Ireland
OBJECTIVES: It is generally agreed that calculation of means after non-linear data
transformations (e.g., log-transformation) does not result in a comparison of arithmetic means, and so is not appropriate for cost data in pharmacoeconomic evaluations.
This would seem to preclude the use of log-normal distributions for cost data in
probabilistic sensitivity analysis. The study objective was to investigate the statistical
properties of arithmetic mean costs. METHODS: Monte Carlo simulations were use
to investigate the statistical properties of arithmetic mean costs derived from an
underlying log-normal distribution, loge (X) ~ N(m,s2), where m = loge(c10), s = 1.5
(range 0.5 to 2.5). An underlying log-normal distribution was used because cost data
A333
are typically highly positively skewed. Microsoft Excel was used to perform the Monte
Carlo simulations generating 1,000 arithmetic means, each from a sample of N = 100,
for each value of s investigated. RESULTS: The distribution of arithmetic means
increased in positive skewness as s increased. For s ≥ 1.5, the distribution of arithmetic
means deviated considerably from normality. The level of skewness was greatly
reduced by use of the log-normal distribution. The Gamma distribution was similar
to the log-normal distribution in representing the distribution of arithmetic mean
costs. CONCLUSIONS: Log-normal distributions for arithmetic mean cost data may
have a role for use in probabilistic sensitivity analysis, although this needs further
investigation using cost data derived from actual studies.
PMC26
EXAMINATION OF TYPE I AND II ERROR RATES IN INTENTION-TOTREAT RANDOMIZED EXPERIMENTS: DO SUBJECTS NEED TO STAY IN
THE GROUP IN WHICH THEY WERE ASSIGNED?
Wasser T, Eisenberg D
HealthCore, Wilmington, DE, USA
OBJECTIVES: Intention-To-Treat (ITT) analysis is an established method used in
randomized experiments. However, analyzing data where crossover occurs (leaving
subjects in the control or treatment arms when they have crossed from one group to
another) prevents the true comparison of treatment and placebo effects. When subject’s crossover and ITT analysis methods are used, the true effect of the treatment
cannot be determined as data from many groups are included with treatment. The
purpose of this research is to determine Type I and II error rates computed by simulation results with and without crossover. METHODS: A simulation study was conducted to determine the impact of Type I and II error given six crossover percentages
(1, 3, 5, 7, 9 and 11%), four effect sizes of treatment based on standard deviation (ES
= 0.2, 0.4, 0.6 and 0.8 SD), and four sample sizes (n = 50, 100, 200 and 300). Simulations were conducted using “R” and included 1,000 replications for each sample size,
effect size and crossover combination. RESULTS: When ES were small (<0.2SD), Type
I error rates were below 1%. When ES were larger, and crossover increased Type I
rates increased above 4%. Large samples with high crossover and large ES had the
highest Type I rates. Type II error rates, which are perhaps more critical, were higher.
For 5% crossover, the Type II error rates were 2.4% and for 11% crossover 5.5%.
When the ES are very large statistical significance can be observed regardless of
crossover percent, even up to 11%. CONCLUSIONS: When crossover rates are low
and ES are small, researchers can abandon ITT analysis methods and analyze samples
as they were treated with little risk of additional Type I and II errors occurring. The
benefit of “as-treated” analysis is that the true treatment effect can be determined with
little risk of error.
CONCEPTUAL PAPERS & RESEARCH ON METHODS – Patient-Reported
Outcomes Studies
PMC27
VALUES FOR HEALTH STATES UNDER DIFFERENT LIFE DURATIONS
1
2
3
Scalone L , Milani S , Krabbe P
1
University of Milano—Bicocca, Monza (MI), Monza, Italy; 2University of Milan, Milano, Italy;
3
Radboud University Nijmegen Medical Centre, Nijmegen—The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: Recent research suggests that the value of health depends also on the
time of permanence in a health state. This would imply a more complex relationship
between quality and quantity of life than the standard linear relationship assumed in
the QALY model. To model whether and how life duration affects the value assigned
to health states. METHODS: A discrete choice analysis study was conducted comprising health-state scenarios added with a separate duration attribute. Health states were
described with the EQ-5D (mobility, self-care, usual activities, pain/discomfort,
anxiety/depression), having 3 levels of severity each. Duration was introduced as a
sixth domain with six levels (1, 5, 10, 15, 30, 50 years). Sixty choice sets were selected
with a Bayesian approach (Stolk et al., Value in Health, 2010). a sample of 209
undergraduate students self-completed the computerized response tasks. Data were
analyzed with a conditional logistic regression model. RESULTS: Main effects show
negative preferences towards problems with health domains and positive preference
toward longer duration. However, preferences are not linearly related with duration
(e.g., the next 41st year is valued less than the next 11th year), but a logarithm function
describes more accurately this relationship. Negative interactions are found between
health-states and duration. Trends of values for health states with increasing duration
are represented by diverging curves: when duration increases, the value assigned to
good states increases while the value assigned to bad states decreases. However, due
to the logarithm relationship with duration, the marginal (negative or positive) value
assigned to any state decreases as duration increases. CONCLUSIONS: Duration of
health states interacts with the value assigned to them and influences both direction
and marginal values through the different durations. Our results show that refinement
of the standard QALY framework can be amended.
A334
PMC28
CLINICIAN REPORTED OUTCOMES: ISSUES IN THE TRANSLATION
AND LINGUISTIC VALIDATION
Furtado T, Wild D
Oxford Outcomes Ltd, Oxford, Oxon, UK
OBJECTIVES: The use of Clinician Reported Outcomes (ClinROs) and cognitive
functioning measures in multi-national clinical trials is widespread, but the translation
of such measures has often been avoided, with trial managers preferring to keep the
measures in English. However, this approach is not ideal and recently the importance
of translating and linguistically validating ClinROs has been highlighted. The requirements for translating and linguistically validating ClinROs have not been well documented. Usually, they are translated with a PRO translation procedure (comprising
dual forward and back translations and subsequent review) with the addition of a
single clinician review. This study investigates the issues surrounding the translation
and linguistic validation of these ClinROs and cognitive functioning measures.
METHODS: A review was undertaken of translation reports from past projects,
including the MMSE and SCID (cognitive functioning measures), TNSN (clinician or
nurse guide for assessing neuropathy) 6 Minute Walk Test (6MWT) Worksheet, (guide
for clinicians to assess dyspnoea), and EORTC clinician scales. Examples of issues
from the translation process were gathered. RESULTS: Clinical review as part of the
translation process proved invaluable. Changes typically comprised alterations of
specific terminology.—a clinician should also be available to aid project coordinators
throughout the translation process.—Clinical review formed an essential role for
advising lead translators.—One project included dual clinician reviews; this was particularly valuable since changes could be verified between reviewers. CONCLUSIONS:
The translation and linguistic validation of ClinROs and cognitive functioning measures requires further research to determine the optimum methodology. This study
found that clinical review was of the utmost importance, and that ideally dual clinician
reviewers should be involved. Furthermore, translators should have experience of
translating documents intended for clinical use, to ensure they are familiar with the
terminology.
PMC29
USING DOZENS OF ATTRIBUTES WITHOUT INCREASING
RESPONDENT BURDEN: HOW TO ADAPT LATENT VARIABLE
MODELING FOR LINKING ATTRIBUTES ON SEPARATE CONJOINT
SURVEYS
Cole JC1, Dang J2
1
Covance Market Access Services, San Diego, CA, USA; 2University of California, Los
Angeles, Torrance, CA, USA
Conjoint analysis is a rigorous survey technique used to understand health care preferences in the pharmaceutical and medical device industries. In a traditional conjoint
study, respondents are presented with a complete profile of all of the combination of
attributes and features (or levels) for a particular product or service. However,
research involving a large number of attributes can be too burdensome for respondents
and has been shown to elicit inaccurate responses. This study describes a procedure
used to link attributes from two or more different conjoint surveys that share at least
one attribute. Linked latent conjoint modeling can lessen the burden on respondents
while allowing utility parameters to be estimated for a large number of attributes, all
on the same interval scale. Conjoint survey data were linked using a partial profile
design and parameters were calculated using maximum likelihood estimation for finite
mixture modeling. Several examples demonstrating the procedures used to link choice
based survey data are provided. In addition, results from a latent variable modeling
of the linked survey data are reviewed. Finally, to illustrate the flexibility of latent
conjoint analysis, continuous and categorical covariates were simultaneously estimated to demonstrate the usefulness of latent modeling of conjoint data.
PMC30
COGNITIVE DEBRIEFING METHODS IN TRANSLATION OF PROS: A
MULTI-NATIONAL
Furtado T, Gergovich KB, Wild D
Oxford Outcomes Ltd, Oxford, Oxon, UK
OBJECTIVES: Cognitive debriefing interviews are a key component of the translation
and linguistic validation of PROs and a necessity when a PRO is to be used as a
primary or secondary endpoint for an FDA label claim. The 2005 ISPOR principles
of good practice report describes the objectives of debriefing, but little discussion has
been undertaken into the methods for performing debriefing interviews as part of the
translation and linguistic validation process. This abstract presents a pilot test of
methodologies across countries. METHODS: A literature review was conducted on
cognitive debriefing methodology, and different approaches were pilot tested in 10
countries. Three methodologies were selected for pilot testing: 1) Retrospective
probing 2) Retrospective think aloud 3) Concurrent think aloud. RESULTS: The literature review highlighted the methodologies and pros and cons of different
approaches to cognitive debriefing, but no research was identified that addressed the
issues of particular relevance in the translation and linguistic validation process. All
three processes listed above proved suitable for a methodology for linguistic validation. The Think Aloud technique provided a true sense of the respondent’s understanding of the translation but its suitability was particularly subject to cultural and
individual differences. Questionnaires of a personal nature (e.g. those pertaining to
sex or bowel disorders) benefited from Retrospective Probing, since the patients could
respond hypothetically. The Retrospective Think Aloud technique elicited more information from some respondents, since it allowed them to discuss their personal experi-
13th Euro Abstracts
ence. Where the respondent had difficulty in understanding what was required of
them, modifying the interview style proved beneficial. CONCLUSIONS: A combination of Retrospective Probing and Retrospective Think Aloud proved to be the
optimum methodology across countries, but this was dependent on the culture,
patient, and the nature of the PRO being translated.
PMC31
CONSTRUCTION OF PRIMARY HUI3 PERSON-MEAN UTILITY SCORING
FUNCTION
Furlong W1, Feeny D2, Torrance G3
1
Health Utilities Inc., Dundas, ON, Canada; 2Kaiser Permanente Center for Health Research,
Portland, OR, USA; 3McMaster University, Toronto, ON, Canada
OBJECTIVES: To assess construction of the primary HUI3 scoring system.
METHODS: Mean visual analogue scale (VAS) and standard gamble (SG) scores were
collected in 2 face-to-face interview surveys: modeling survey (MS) for the PersonMean utility scoring model to calculate community utilities for health states; direct
survey (DS) for validation of the Person-Mean scoring model. Survey results are
assessed for completeness and consistency. Completeness is evaluated by response
rates and consistency by health state rankings. RESULTS: Completed interviews were
obtained from 65% of contacted eligible subjects. Demographic distributions are
similar to the underlying general population. There are 256 respondents in MS and
248 in DS. MS and DS respondents use 71% of HUI3 attribute levels in describing
their own health status. Each of the 8 HUI3 attributes are reported by 35 or more
respondents as being important in their preference measurements: pain (49%); vision
(37%); cognition (34%); emotion (28%); ambulation (28%); hearing (17%); dexterity
(17%); speech (7%). More than 70% of respondents focused on 2+ attributes. Other
important preference measurement factors are self-care ability (89% of respondents),
family life (76%), happiness of others (69%), ability to work current job (61%),
leisure activities (42%). 83% of respondents report the interviewing did not change
their opinions about the health states. Consistency of health state rankings by mean
VAS and SG scores between MS and DS was 100%: PH > MA > MB > MC > Dead
> Pits. MS had a missing data rate of 0.29% (17/5920) for VAS and 0.10% (1/1024)
for SG. CONCLUSIONS: The Person-Mean HUI3 utility function is founded on a
survey that was well-constructed in terms of community and attribute representation,
consideration of multiple attributes and day-to-day impacts, stable opinions, and
consistency of health state rankings. This evidence supports use of the primary HUI3
utility function for group-level analyses, such as allocation of societal resources.
PMC32
MINIMALLY IMPORTANT DIFFERENCE OF THE TREATMENT
SATISFACTION WITH MEDICINES QUESTIONNAIRE (SATMED-Q)
Rejas J1, Ruiz MA2, Pardo A2, Soto J1
1
Pfizer España, Alcobendas/Madrid, Spain; 2Universidad Autonoma de Madrid, Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Treatment satisfaction with drug therapies is an important patientreported-outcome (PRO) that may help clinicians to better impact in patient health
care. The Treatment Satisfaction with Medicines (SATMED-Q) questionnaire has
shown appropriate psychometric properties for exploring patient’s satisfaction with
medicines under routine medical practice in chronic health conditions. The Minimally
Important Difference (MID) of the instrument is still unknown. The goal of this
research was to determine the MID values of the SATMED-Q questionnaire for the
total score and domains. METHODS: The sample of patients (457, mean age 59 years,
53% male) used for testing psychometric properties was also used to assess MID
values. Item #14 of the TSQM scale was used as an anchor reference, since it explores
directly the satisfaction with medicines in a seven points ordinal response (from
extremely satisfied to extremely dissatisfied). Patients were classified into four categories according with responses in this item; extremely satisfied/dissatisfied, very satisfied/dissatisfied, satisfied/dissatisfied, nor satisfied/nor dissatisfied and comparisons
were carried out for the overall score and each domain of the SATMED-Q using
standardized scores. The mean differences in overall score (and domains) between the
neutral category and the satisfied/dissatisfied category were considered the values of
MID. Effect sizes (ES) were also computed. RESULTS: MID for total scoring was 13.4
(ES = 0.91), while the value for domains ranged from 10.3 (medical care domain, ES
= 0.43) to 20.6 (impact of daily living, ES = 0.85). Mean score differences in overall
scale and domains were significant between change in satisfaction categories with
respect item#14 with F values ranging from 9.7 to 74.1 (P < 0.001 in all cases).
CONCLUSIONS: The SATMED-Q demonstrated to be responsive to different levels
of patient’s satisfaction with therapy in chronically ill subjects. Attained MID was
13.4 pts for the overall normalized scoring scale and between 10.3 and 20.6 pts for
domains.
PMC33
ESTIMATING HEALTH STATE UTILITY VALUES FOR COMORBID
HEALTH CONDITIONS
Ara R, Brazier J
University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK
OBJECTIVES: Health state utility values (HSUVs) for comorbid health conditions
(CHC) are frequently estimated using data from single health conditions but there is
no consensus on the most appropriate method. The objective of the study is to comparing five techniques in a single data set. METHODS: We use EQ-5D data from the
Health Survey for England to compare results generated using the: additive, multiplicative and minimum methods, the adjusted decrement estimator (ADE), and a linear
regression model; a baseline of perfect health and an adjusted baseline obtained from
13th Euro Abstracts
individuals who indicate they have no chronic health condition. Results are compared
using mean errors (ME), root mean squared errors (RMSE) and the proportion of
values estimated within |0.05|. RESULTS: Using an age adjusted baseline, we found
the additive (and multiplicative) methods underestimate the majority of HSUVs
(ME:0.0781(0.0254); RMSE:0.1012(0.0651); 26%(56%) < |0.05|) while the minimum
(and ADE) overestimate the majority of HSUVs (ME:−0.0995(−0.0695);
RMSE:0.1214(0.0950); 20%(35%) < |0.05|). Although the simple linear model produced the most accurate results (ME:0.0001; RMSE:0.0598; 63% < |0.05|), there were
some substantial errors with 20% of errors greater than the minimum important
difference (|0.074|). When subgrouping by actual HSUV (range 0.350–0.917) we
found the magnitude and direction of errors in the estimated HSUVs are driven by
the actual HSUVs being estimated in addition to the technique used. In general the
HSUVs estimated using an adjusted baseline were more accurate than those obtained
using a baseline of perfect health. CONCLUSIONS: This study makes an important
contribution to the evidence in this area as it is the first to compare the five different
techniques in the same data set. While the simple linear model gave the most accurate
results, the model requires validating in external data and additional research exploring an alternative model specification is warranted.
PMC34
ISSUES IN THE TRANSLATION AND LINGUISTIC VALIDATION OF
CAREGIVER RATING SCALES REGARDING THE BEHAVIOR AND
DEVELOPMENT OF CHILDREN AND YOUNG PEOPLE
Furtado T, Wild D
Oxford Outcomes Ltd, Oxford, Oxon, UK
OBJECTIVES: Caregiver rating scales, intended to evaluate the behaviour of children
and young people, are frequently used in clinical trials involving youths. However, the
translation and linguistic validation of such scales can be problematic due to the differing
cultural markers of behaviour and development. This study aims to document the
problems that can occur, with the hope of facilitating future studies and producing
guidelines to avoid cultural compromises when such measures are developed.
METHODS: Past Oxford Outcomes projects, which included the translation of Caregiver Reported Outcomes, were evaluated to identify problematic items. These included
the Vineland-II and ABAS (behaviour development scales), ELDQOL (epilepsy and QoL
scale) and WFI-RS (functional impairment rating scale) among others. RESULTS:
Numerous cultural and linguistic issues became apparent, including the following:—
Many examples of sports and activities were used in the documents, which required
thorough cultural adaptation, e.g. types of games.—Logistical cultural differences were
marked, e.g. questionnaires mentioned children’s understanding of specific coins or
traffic signals, which vary culturally.—Some documents involved markers for identifying
speech development, such correct use of irregular verbs. These were problematic in other
cultures and speech development specialists were required to find suitable alternatives.—
More idiomatic expressions are used than in PROs developed for adults, e.g. “on the
go”; these cause difficulties in translation.—Items surrounding activities such as housework or helping look after siblings are not equivalent in some cultures due to differing
role expectations. CONCLUSIONS: The validation of caregiver reported outcomes
through interviews with caregivers was particularly important with these scales to ensure
cultural appropriateness in target languages. Physician or specialist input was sometimes
required to find culturally relevant alternatives. When such measures are created, culturally specific markers of behaviour should be avoided if possible.
PMC35
RECOMMENDATIONS ABOUT TRANSLATIONS IN THE FINAL FDA
GUIDANCE ON PRO MEASURES: WHAT HAS CHANGED AND WHAT
HAS REMAINED
Conway K1, Mear I2
1
MAPI Research Trust, Lyon, France; 2MAPI Institute, Lyon, France
OBJECTIVES: Almost four years were necessary to develop the final FDA guidance
on the use of PRO measures in clinical trials. Our objective is to compare how the
recommendations about translation and cultural adaptation evolved from the 2006
draft to the 2009 final guidance. METHODS: Both guidances were retrieved on the
FDA website and analyzed. RESULTS: Structure and content were modified. Recommendations on translation and cultural adaptation were moved to another section
within the Evaluating PRO Instruments Part: from “IV.D. Modification of an existing
instrument” to “III.G. PRO Instruments intended for specific populations”. As for
the content, the text in the body of the final guidance is more concise compared to
the draft. The novelty lies in the stipulation that the FDA will review the process used
to translate/culturally adapt the instruments. As a consequence, an appendix (section
VIII) was added in which the FDA explains which topics should be addressed in the
documents provided to the FDA for review: description of process used, patient
testing, rationale for decisions, copies of versions and evidence about validity. They
are however key points which did not change: the need for providing evidence that
content validity and other measurement properties are similar between all versions.
CONCLUSIONS: The recommendations are more concise and precise, especially the
expectations of the FDA. The FDA however does not indicate a preference for a
specific translation methodology. Interestingly patient testing is clearly indicated as a
key point of the process. The need for documenting all decisions is crucial and raises
the question of developing standardized system of reporting to structure the evidence
to be provided to the FDA. The last point of the Appendix is debatable as we anticipate
that it might add a burden in term of costs to provide evidence about the psychometrics
of all versions.
A335
PMC36
SYSTEMATIC REVIEW OF THE RESPONSIVNESS OF SF-36 HEALTH
SURVEY MEASURES TO EFFICACIOUS PHARMACEUTICAL THERAPIES
IN WELL-CONTROLLED CLINICAL TRIALS
Ware JE, Frendl DM
University of Massachusetts, Worcester, MA, USA
OBJECTIVES: To determine how often SF-36 Health Survey measures respond to
efficacious pharmaceutical treatment benefits in well-controlled clinical trials.
METHODS: We conducted a systematic review of randomized, double-blind, placebocontrolled trials published in 124 journals in 1995 through 2009 documenting differences between treatment groups for primary medical endpoints and any of the SF-36
component summaries, or eight subscale scores. Concordance was defined in terms of
agreement between primary clinical and SF-36 endpoints (both statistically significant
or both non-significant). RESULTS: A review of 2,020 identified clinical trials using
the SF-36 confirmed that 162 met study design criteria. For 133 of 162 trials (82.1%),
results for primary clinical endpoints and SF-36 measures were concordant. Among
the 107 trials achieving medical efficacy (primary endpoint), changes in one or more
SF-36 measures were also significant, as hypothesized, for 88 (82.2%). Similar patterns
were observed by therapeutic area; for example: rheumatology (29 of 30), neurology
(16 of 25), cardiovascular (15 of 18), pulmonary (11 of 13), psychiatry (8 of 10),
endocrine (7 of 9), and combined surgical specialties (9 of 9) studies demonstrated
concordance. In addition to evaluating characteristics of published reports and scoring
methods (subscales, summaries, utility scoring) this presentation will comment on
priorities for future studies of patient-reported outcomes (PROs) in evaluations of
pharmaceutical and other medical treatments. CONCLUSIONS: In support of their
validity as PROs, changes in SF-36 measurements agree with primary endpoints in
over 8 out of 10 well-controlled trials of pharmaceutical therapies published to date.
In support of pharmaceuticals’ efficacy, when a therapy positively impacted clinical
endpoints, it also improved health related quality of life quality of life in over 8 out
of 10 clinical trials published to date.
PMC37
DOES DATA COLLECTION FROM ONLINE COMMUNITIES RESULT IN
BIASED RESPONSE?
Vaccarino AL1, Sills TL1, Bharmal M2, Cascade E3, Kalali AH4, Evans KR1
1
OCBN, Toronto, ON, Canada; 2Quintiles, Rockville, MD, USA; 3iGUARD Inc, Rockville,
MD, USA; 4Quintiles CNS Therapeutics, San Diego, CA, USA
OBJECTIVES: Although the ability to interact with patients in an on-line environment
has expanded substantially over the past few years, many researchers are concerned
that participants may not be representative from a medication experience perspective
(i.e., biased towards complainers). The purpose of this study is to investigate patient
responses on treatment satisfaction using a validated PRO measure, the Treatment
Satisfaction Questionnaire for Medications (TSQM), collected through a survey of
patients with depression from an on-line community. METHODS: A random sample
of iGuard.org members treated with an antidepressant were invited to complete an
online version of the TSQM, a widely used validated 14-item generic treatment satisfaction instrument. iGuard.org is an online patient community that provides a free
medication monitoring service to patients. Non-parametric item response analyses
were performed to determine the relationship between scores on individual items and
total TSQM scores. RESULTS: Responses from 3641 patients were included in the
analyses. TSQM Global Satisfaction scores ranged from 0—100 suggesting a broad
spectrum of treatment satisfaction. Non-parametric Item Response analyses of raw
scores revealed that individual items of the TSQM discriminated differences in patient
satisfaction. That is, as total scores increased the probability of low scores on the
individual items decreased and the probability of higher scores increased. As expected,
patient satisfaction was related to reported side-effects, with those reporting sideeffects experiencing lower satisfaction with medication than those without reported
side-effects. CONCLUSIONS: The results from this analysis suggest that PRO survey
data collected through a random sample of members of the on-line patient community
iGuard.org can be representative of the spectrum of anticipated treatment satisfaction
responses. Continuing to explore the potential of direct data capture from on-line
patients will be important as researchers seek faster and cheaper alternatives to traditional physician-based recruitment.
PMC38
A COGNITIVE DEBRIEFING METHODOLOGY FOR ESTABLISHING
EQUIVALENCE DURING E-PRO MIGRATION
Doyle S, Wild D
Oxford Outcomes Ltd, Oxford, Oxon, UK
BACKGROUND: Most outcomes instruments have been developed and validated as
paper versions, but few have been migrated to electronic format. Migration to electronic delivery, without significantly altering format or text, qualifies as a minor
modification not requiring a full validation (Coons et al. 2009). However, this does
not mean that the two formats are perceived in the same way by patients. We aim
here to describe a methodology successfully used to establish equivalence between
paper and electronic PROs. METHODS: To demonstrate the equality of these different modes of data collection, we have used a combination of “think-aloud” and retrospective cognitive debriefing techniques, as well as usability testing. The debriefing
exercise is designed to assess whether the electronic device changes the way respondents interpret the questions or response options. The usability testing assesses
ease of use and identifies issues that may prohibit the use of the ePRO by the target
A336
population. We typically recruit between 10–20 patients in which half the participants
receive the ePRO first and the other half the paper version. Between administrations
participants complete a distraction task. Interviews are recorded and a content analysis
conducted to identify key issues. RESULTS: The mix of think-aloud and retrospective
probing has worked well in a number of studies across disease areas to ensure equivalence, high usability, and no unforeseen issues unique to ePRO such as screen glare
or difficulty holding a PDA device. Some patients have difficulty with the “thinkaloud” approach and so the retrospective probing is a useful check against issues not
spontaneously raised by the participant(s). CONCLUSIONS: Increased use of ePRO
questionnaires necessitates a robust methodology for demonstrating equivalence
during migration from paper versions. a mix of concurrent “think-aloud” and retrospective probing following completion of both PRO formats has shown to be a useful
method for establishing validity of electronic outcome measures.
PMC39
EXAMINING ITEM RESPONSE PATTERNS OVER TIME IN A HEALTH
PROFILE MEASURE USING US NATIONAL REPRESENTATIVE SAMPLES:
A MULTI-FACET MODEL APPROACH
Gu NY
Pharmerit North America, LLC, Bethesda, MD, USA
OBJECTIVES: To examine item response patterns over time using the SF-12v2TM from
a measurement perspective using US national representative samples. METHODS:
Four panel data with two-year repeated measures on each respondent were extracted
from the Medical Expenditure Panel Survey (MEPS). Respondents were included if
they were ≥18 years, had completed SF-12v2TM and, had at least one of the top ten
most prevalent health conditions identified using ICD-9-CM. Three-facet measurement
model was used to parameterize time as a distinct facet in the model, in addition to
person and item facets. Interactions between time and the twelve items were examined
at each time point in all panels. Goodness-of-fit of the items to the model was examined in repeated measures as well as in point-in-time measures. INFIT mean-square
(MnSq ≤ 1.40) was used as an item fit indicator. Cross-validations were conducted in
each disease groups. RESULTS: Four panels were comparable in their distributions in
health conditions, socio-demographics (mean ages were 52–53 years and, about
76–77% were white) and, sample sizes (2003–04, n = 2,124; 2004–05, n = 2,070;
2005–06, n = 2,148 and 2006–07, n = 2,329). Consistently in all panels, significant
time and item interaction biases were found at time 1, especially on mental health
items (P < 0.01). On the other hand, interaction biases between time and items at time
2 were not significant (p > 0.05). All items fit the model in repeated measures where
time was parameterized as a facet (INFIT MnSq ≤ 1.40). The mental health item “Have
you felt calm and peaceful?” consistently showed misfit in all point-in-time measures
(INFIT MnSq > 1.40). Similar findings were noted in sub-samples. CONCLUSIONS:
Findings from this study suggest consistent learned response patterns over time,
especially the responses to mental health item, which give rise to the importance of
inter-temporal health context in health measurement. Hence, cross-sectional health
measures should be interpreted with caution.
PMC40
ITEM CALIBRATION OF A GENERIC ROLE FUNCTIONING ITEM BANK
1
2
Anatchkova M , Bjorner J
1
University of Massachusetts Medical School, Worcester, MA, USA; 2National Research
Centre for the Working Environment, Copenhagen, Denmark
OBJECTIVES: Role functioning (RF) is a key component of social well-being and thus
an important outcome in health research. The aim of this study was to calibrate on a
common metric newly developed items assessing the impact of health on RF. The items
were developed based on review of the literature and focus group interviews and were
found to be sufficiently unidimensional for item response theory applications.
METHODS: Two thousand five hundred participants completed a battery of measures
including 77 items in a RF bank, covering the impact of health on family, occupational
and social role functioning. Each new item covered only one of the content areas.
Items were evaluated for potential DIF by demographic variables (gender, age, and
chronic condition) using a logistic regression approach. To estimate the item parameters for each domain on a common metric we used the generalized partial credit
model. Item fit was evaluated using the S-G2 index. Comparison of group mean bank
scores of participants with different self-reported general health status and chronic
conditions was used to test the external validity of the bank. RESULTS: After excluding items with DIF and poor fit the final item bank had a total of 64 items covering
4 general content areas of role functioning (family, social, occupational, generic).
Slopes in the bank ranged between 0.96 and 4.51; the mean threshold range was −0.66
to −1.80. Item bank based scores were significantly different for participants with and
without chronic conditions (F(4, 2488) = 31.48, P < 0.0001) and self-reported general
health (F(4, 2488) = 233.55, P < 0.0001). CONCLUSIONS: An item bank assessing
health impact on RF across 4 content areas has been successfully calibrated. Using
computerized adaptive assessment, respondents will only need to answer items regarding relevant roles, while IRT score estimation still allows for scoring all respondents
on the same common metric.
13th Euro Abstracts
PMC41
PREEMPTING DIFFICULTIES IN LINGUISTIC VALIDATION, THE USE OF
FACE VALIDATION TO CREATE MORE SOUND TRANSLATIONS
Gawlicki M1, Handa M2
1
Corporate Translations, Inc, East Hartford, CT, USA; 2Corporate Translations, Inc, Chicago,
IL, USA
OBJECTIVES: The process of linguistic validation is complex especially when working
with a variety of languages in widely divergent cultural settings. The ability to clearly
delineate concepts and synchronize wording within an instrument before the linguistic
validation process begins not only significantly improves the original instrument, but
also aids in optimizing its translatability, ensuring greater uniformity between multiple
linguistic adaptations and saving time and resources along the way. This paper seeks
to explain the benefits provided by the supplemental pre-translation process of face
validation. METHODS: As part of a case study, face validated questionnaires were
compared to the original homegrown versions of the corresponding instruments—
questionnaires that were already psychometrically validated were not eligible. Changes
that were made as a result of this analysis will be discussed in-depth to clarify difficulties that each issue would have created for the linguistic validation process had they
not been corrected. a cost benefit-analysis was also conducted to confirm the value of
this supplemental linguistic validation phase. RESULTS: While standard elements of
the linguistic validation process, such as concept elaboration, international harmonization, survey research expert review, in-country clinician review and cognitive debriefing all assist greatly in creating a quality translation, none of their benefits are a
substitute for face validation. Furthermore, cost-benefit analysis reveals that the preemption of linguistic or methodological issues prior to translation and the greater
uniformity obtained amongst multiple translations created through face validation
save time and money later on in the linguistic validation process, justifying the added
up-front costs. CONCLUSIONS: As the case studies confirm, taking steps to maximize
the translatability of a questionnaire prior to linguistic validation, through face validation in particular, is highly beneficial to the end-products and can also hasten overall
project completion and improve the quality of all language versions of the
instrument.
PMC42
TO WHAT EXTENT CAN TECHNOLOGY IMPROVE THE VALIDITY OF
CLINROS?
Wild D1, Langel K2
1
Oxford Outcomes Ltd, Oxford, Oxon, UK; 2CRF Health, Helsinki, Finland
OBJECTIVES: ClinROs are the most commonly observed endpoint in FDA approved
product labels but few have been adequately scrutinized in terms of their suitability
as endpoints. This study evaluates two widely used ClinROs (the Expanded Disability
Status scale (EDSS), and the Hamilton Rating scale for Depression (HAM-D)) and
provides an assessment on how migrating the measures onto an electronic platform
might be able to improve their validity and reliability. METHODS: A literature review
was conducted on both measures to evaluate the availability of information on their
content validity and reliability and validity. An assessment was made on how the
measures could be improved if they were to be migrated onto an electronic platform:
RESULTS: The EDSS has shown varying results for validity and inter-rater reliability
and it involves a complex scoring procedure. The migration of the EDSS onto an
electronic format would enable an automated scoring system which could improve its
validity. The HAM-D was found to be lacking in evidence of content validity and to
have some complexity in the scoring system. Transferring the HAM-D onto an electronic platform could simplify the scoring system which could improve its validity.
CONCLUSIONS: This study has highlighted some of the issues with validity and
reliability of two widely used ClinROs. The migration of ClinROs to an electronic
platform in addition to the ePRO migration cognitive debriefing and usability testing
might go some way to improving the clarity of ClinROs which may go some way to
improving the validity of the measures. It cannot however resolve all of the issues such
as lack of content validity and its impact would vary widely according to the complexity of the ClinRO itself.
PMC43
DATA POOLING OF PATIENT-REPORTED OUTCOMES IN CLINICAL
TRIALS: EVALUATION OF STATISTICAL TECHNIQUES FOR ASSESSING
MEASUREMENT EQUIVALENCE
Nixon M
Quintiles, Bracknell, Berkshire, UK
OBJECTIVES: This analysis describes the development, application and comparison
of three different approaches to evaluate measurement equivalence properties of a
patient reported outcome (PRO) questionnaire applied to two treatment groups for
gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD). The data used in this analysis was obtained
from an on-line patient community, iGuard.org. Patients using either of the two treatments were randomly invited to complete a measure of treatment satisfaction, the
Treatment Satisfaction Questionnaire for Medication (TSQM). METHODS: Three
statistical approaches were used to evaluate the measurement equivalence of the
TSQM across the two patient populations: 1) Classical Test Theory (CTT) to assess
the internal consistency of the TSQM items within each of the three factors using
Cronbach’s alpha; 2) Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA) using a special case of
structural equation modelling (SEM); and 3) Item Response Theory (IRT)—based
technique of Differential Item Functioning (DIF). RESULTS: All three statistical
methods indicated measurement equivalence had been achieved across the two treatment populations for all the three domains of the TSQM. The effectiveness and global
13th Euro Abstracts
satisfaction domains exhibited the strongest significant results amongst all three tests.
However, while the convenience domain exhibited strongly significant measurement
equivalence for the CTT, it only exhibited significant results for the SEM and DIF.
CONCLUSIONS: While all three methods indicated the same overall results, there is
some suggestion of differing sensitivity amongst the tests.
PMC44
EXPERTS’ JUDGEMENT ON PATIENT-CENTRED COORDINATED CARE
Mühlbacher AC, Juhnke C, Bethge S
Hochschule Neubrandenburg, Neubrandenburg, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Delivering care coordination services is often described as the key to
effectively meet patients’ needs and expectations. Patient empowerment and patient
participation is highly discussed and postulated, but there is a lack of knowledge of
how to design patient-centered coordinated care. This study intends to provide health
policy and decision-makers with a comprehensive assessment on experts’ priorities in
the relative value of different dimensions of coordinated care. METHODS: A questionnaire with 88 items was conducted with N = 251 health care experts. Exploratory
and confirmatory factor analysis was performed using SPSS©18. The number of factors
to be retained was controlled by Kaiser’s criterion (eigenvalues above 1), validation
of the scree plot, and the interpretability of the items. Cronbach’s alpha was used to
assess the internal consistency of the subscales identified. RESULTS: The exploratory
factor analysis leaded to 25 factors. After analyzing the screeplots and qualitative
results confirmatory factor analysis was computed for an 8 factor solution accounting
for 42,828 % of the total variance and with KMO of 0.723. Cronbach alpha reliability
coefficients were computed for each of the sub-scales and ranged between 0.849 and
0.745. Based on the existing literature and the analysis conducted, coordinated care
could be differentiated into eight dimensions: access, knowledge transfer, technical
care, interpersonal care, patient-centeredness, continuity, infrastructure and participation in social life. CONCLUSIONS: The aim of the study was to structure the key
attributes for future stated preference research. Differences in experts’ judgment and
patients’ perspective will be analyzed in upcoming research. If expectations of stakeholders are taken into account adequately, it can be assumed that this will increase
the motivation to participate in and the satisfaction with coordinated care
programs.
PMC45
GLOBAL INDUSTRY USE OF ELECTRONIC PATIENT-REPORTED
OUTCOME INSTRUMENTS: PRELIMINARY RESULTS FROM A 2010 EPRO
SURVEY
Bergstrom F1, McGinley D2, Ackerman S3, Cole J3
1
Covance Market Access Services, Gaithersburg, MD, USA; 2Covance, Conshohocken, PA,
USA; 3Covance Market Access Services, San Diego, CA, USA
OBJECTIVES: While eClinical Forum’s 2009 survey findings suggest that electronic
data capture (EDC) is used in 58% of clinical trials, little is known about the use of
electronic patient reported outcome (ePRO) technologies for data collection. The
purpose of this survey study was to describe the experiences and perceptions regarding
use of ePRO as reported by pharmaceutical, biotech, medical device, and other industry professionals. METHODS: Global industry professionals were invited to complete
a web-based survey fielded in early 2010. Participants were asked about their professional demographics, PRO and ePRO experiences, as well as challenges and advantages of using ePROs. Responses were analyzed descriptively. RESULTS: To date, 153
industry professionals completed the survey. Forty-four percent of respondents were
from pharmaceutical companies, followed by other (41%), biotech (10%) and medical
device (6%). Forty nine percent had previous PRO study experience among which
51% had prior ePRO experience. Among respondents using a PRO measure in an
international study, 43% used ePRO for data collection. Hand-held device (tablet,
PDA) was the most common ePRO technology (42%), followed by interactive webresponse (29%) or voice-response (29%). Reported advantages of ePROs include
accuracy of information collected (79%), increased compliance (73%), and ease of
use (64%); challenges include patient training (65%), study start-up costs (64%) or
time (54%), and patient burden (54%). Validation of PRO for EDC use was an
important factor when considering paper-based versus ePRO data collection (21%).
Among those responding, 26% indicated they used ePRO data collection in >50% of
their clinical trials, and 82% strongly agreed/agreed they would use ePRO in future
studies. CONCLUSIONS: Preliminary results from this survey suggest that among
those who use PRO measures in studies, the percent of industry professionals using
ePROs is similar to the overall percent of industry using EDC as a data collection
method in clinical trials.
PMC46
TRANSLATION AND LINGUISTIC VALIDATION OF PRO MEASURES:
RESPONSE OPTION ISSUES
Griffin AJ, Furtado T, Wild D
Oxford Outcomes Ltd, Oxford, Oxon, UK
OBJECTIVES: PRO measures use a variety of response scales/options. These vary
according to the type of measure, and can include frequency (time-based) scales,
severity (intensity) scales, visual analogue scales (VAS) and levels of agreement. The
translation and linguistic validation of response options can cause semantic or conceptual difficulties. This research aims to identify the issues raised during the translation of some response scales, with the aim of aiding the translatability of response
options. METHODS: Examples of issues in the translation and linguistic validation
of response options were collected from past Oxford Outcomes projects. Those
A337
response options which were problematic across PRO measures and languages were
evaluated. RESULTS: Numerous cultural and linguistic issues became apparent
throughout the translation process which require careful attention being paid to the
response options during the translation and linguistic validation process: /Some midscale words used in severity scales are particularly difficult to translate, e.g. rather,
somewhat. Two response options on a scale, e.g. rather confident, fairly confident can
be very small and unclear. /Frequency scales (how often . . .) are often translated as
“how many times,” in some languages (particularly Indian). When using “level of
agreement” scales the word “strongly” often proves problematic as some languages
find it difficult to express levels of agreement. CONCLUSIONS: Various issues with
response options were recognised during the linguistic validation of a considerable
number of PRO measures. a full translation and linguistic validation procedure can
help to overcome such problems, but care should be taken when choosing response
scales during the development of PRO measures. In general, response options, which
are particularly close in meaning, e.g. somewhat, rather, are usually more problematic
to translate than those with clear parameters, e.g. never, rarely, sometimes, often,
always.
PMC47
FURTHER INSIGHT INTO DESIGNING WEB-BASED PATIENT REPORTED
OUTCOMES FOR USE ON PERSONAL COMPUTERS IN GLOBAL
STUDIES
Tulkki-Wilke RK1, Bushnell D2, Martin ML3, Jewett G4
1
CRF Health, Helsinki, Finland; 2Health Research Associates, Inc, Mountlake Terrace, WA,
USA; 3Health Research Associates, Inc, Seattle, WA, USA; 4CRF Health, Lansdale, PA, USA
OBJECTIVES: Capturing patient-reported outcomes (PRO) via the web can be an
efficient tool in larger-population clinical studies. Enabling patients to use their own
computers means that web-based PROs are administered to patients on a wider variety
of screen sizes and resolutions. As indicated in the recent ISPOR ePRO Report by
Coons SJ, et al, this creates an issue of ensuring equivalency of the instruments across
all screen sizes. This research describes a practical approach for maintaining validity
of instruments when patients use their own computer. It aims to evaluate whether the
PRO is presented as intended on various screen sizes and browsers. The research also
takes into consideration variability of computer infrastructure in different geographical areas, as this is a major factor limiting web-based data collection. METHODS:
The EuroQoL EQ-5D was programmed for use on smaller screens and scaled up to
larger sizes and put into an ongoing usability testing study in the US, UK, Spain,
Finland, Singapore, and China for sufficient coverage of languages and technologies.
The sample size is 30 healthy volunteers. Screen sizes varied from small mini laptop
screens to large LCD screens (9″ to 24″). RESULTS: Early results show that the
questionnaire fits on all screens without a need for patients to scroll either in left-right
or up-down directions. On 15,4″ screen, the questionnaire occupies 71% of the screen
versus 57% on a 24″ display. The difference in relative size is 19%, which indicates
that the questionnaire remains usable even if the screen size increases by 56%. Further
results are forthcoming. CONCLUSIONS: As the presentation of the PRO is the same
on all screens, conducting psychometric validation may be more straightforward. In
addition, finding a method to ensure one PRO design works on all computers is a
major factor in conducting global studies efficiently.
PMC48
UPDATES AND INNOVATIONS IN ELECTRONIC PATIENT-REPORTED
DATA CAPTURE: A REVIEW OF THE EVOLUTION AND FUTURE
DIRECTIONS OF EPRO
Curry C
PHT Corporation, Boston, MA, USA
OBJECTIVES: In clinical trials, the capture of patient-reported outcome (PRO) data
has increased over the past decade. Regulatory guidelines, including the EMEA’s
concern of Health-Related Quality of Life (HRQL) measurements and the FDA’s
emphasis on PRO data to support labeling claims, have led to a greater inclusion of
PRO as clinical trial endpoints. As sponsors include more PRO measurements, many
turn to electronic PRO (ePRO) data capture. This presentation summarizes literature
from the last 9 years to report changes in the use of ePRO including projections for
future applications in clinical trials, disease management and health policy.
METHODS: This presentation is a synthesis of literature in peer reviewed journals
regarding ePRO from 2000 to 2010. Key search terms include “patient reported
outcomes”, “electronic patient reported outcomes”, “electronic diaries”, “interactive
voice response system”, “interactive web response system” and “digital pen”. The
literature review made use of meta-databases such as PubMed and Medline. RESULTS:
The use of ePRO has increased since a decade ago, due to greater movement in health
care towards electronic solutions and to regulatory emphasis on PRO collection in
clinical trials. The presentation will detail how ePRO is being used and provide a
synthesis of recommendations for future ePRO use based on the literature. The session
will examine the indications and therapeutic areas, population types, and applications
of ePRO within health care and will review evidence showing whether ePRO data
quality is higher than that of data captured using paper methods. CONCLUSIONS:
The presentation deals with the evolving questions of ePRO—projected limitations and
actual scope of experience with ePRO. Due to literature emphasis, the presentation will
focus on clinical trials but will also examine other health care fields such as disease
management and health policy. Attendees will learn about the evolution of ePRO and
forthcoming directions and receive a bibliography of current literature.
A338
PMC49
THE ROLE OF PATIENT-REPORTED OUTCOMES (PRO) AS PRIMARY
ENDPOINTS IN THE EVALUATION OF MEDICINES APPROVED WITH
PRO CLAIMS
Caron M, Emery MP
MAPI Research Trust, Lyon, France
OBJECTIVES: To review the drugs that used PRO as primary endpoints in the evaluation of their clinical efficacy and have been granted a PRO claim by the Food &
Drug Administration (FDA) or the European Medicines Agency (EMA). METHODS:
The PROLabels database, which centralizes medicinal products with a PRO claim,
was searched using the keyword “primary endpoint”. Only drugs approved between
January 1, 1995 and May 28, 2010 were included. RESULTS: A total of 303 (66%)
out of the 459 products included in the database were retrieved: four were removed
because of a withdrawal notice (all EMA), 15 because they were approved before
1995, and two others because the endpoints were not clearly specified. In total, 282
products were analyzed (71 approved in Europe). They represented 81 different indications, with 47 products having more than one indication. The most frequent indications were: Pain (25 products), Rheumatoid Arthritis (25), Menopause (18),
Parkinson’s disease (17), Epilepsy (15), Migraine disorders (13), Sleep disorders (12),
Rhinitis Allergic Perennial, Seasonal (12), and Ankylosing Spondylitis (10). In total,
140 different PRO endpoints were listed. Seventy-seven percent of them were symptoms (e.g. pain, bowel movement, heartburn symptoms, asthma symptoms, etc).
Function (e.g. physical function, functional impairment, etc) represented only 5.7%
of all endpoints. Health-related quality of life (HRQL) was a clear primary endpoint
in only two products: Duloxetine (Urinary Incontinence) and Alisade (Rhinitis Allergic
Perennial and Seasonal). Both approvals were granted by the EMA in 2008 (after the
first publication of the EMA and FDA guidances). CONCLUSIONS: Symptoms, as
measured by patients, are a key criterion in the evaluation of medicines. Unsurprisingly, pain is the main indication in which the highest number of products with a PRO
as a primary endpoint are approved. More sophisticated PRO endpoints, such as
function or HRQL, are used less often.
PMC50
TRANSLATION, LINGUISTIC VALIDATION AND ELECTRONIC
ADMINISTRATION IN THE INDIAN LANGUAGES: A CASE STUDY
HIGHLIGHTING THE SPECIAL DIFFICULTIES THAT EXIST AT THIS
INTERSECTION
Handa M1, Brandt B2, Hasegawa N1, McKown S1, Gawlicki M2
1
Corporate Translations, Inc, Chicago, IL, USA; 2Corporate Translations, Inc, East Hartford,
CT, USA
OBJECTIVES: Translation and linguistic validation of questionnaires for paper or
electronic administration require similar procedures. Both modalities share a common
difficulty: how to best utilize existing processes to accommodate Indian languages.
Working with Indian language instruments can be daunting, even without the compounded effect of managing both ePRO and linguistic validation together. This paper
seeks to enumerate the challenges associated with the intersection of Indian languages,
linguistic validation, and electronic administration and recommends the use of a
specialized checklist to avoid escalating potential difficulties. METHODS: A case
study was performed to explore the complexity of these processes. a Fibromyalgia
e-diary and corresponding paper diary were translated into four Indian languages and
three non-Indian languages with varying levels of linguistic difficulty. This allowed for
a multidimensional analysis of issues faced in translation for ePRO versus paper
administration, and translation for Indian versus non-Indian settings. RESULTS:
During linguistic validation, difficulties arise pertaining to font and formatting requirements, localization of colloquial terms and phrases and maintaining concept equivalency while respecting cultural appropriateness. Preparing an ePRO for use involves
thorough analysis of existing instrument versions and possible modification of instructions, response sets or questionnaire format to accommodate technology or screen size
limitations. a holistic approach of quality assurance should be employed, including
multiple rounds of proofreading. When preparing an Indian language for electronic
administration one must take even more care, accounting for the factors listed above
as well as considering software font-testing prior to production, and additional proofreading steps. CONCLUSIONS: Linguistic validation of ePRO questionnaires for use
in Indian settings presents special challenges. Evidence suggests that additional consideration must be exercised early on in order to avoid compounded difficulties and
delays later in the process. In such cases, the use of a checklist is recommended to
assist in preempting future difficulties within the project.
PMC51
CONCEPT ELABORATION—AN ESSENTIAL STAGE IN THE
TRANSLATION OF PRO MEASURES
Verjee-Lorenz A, Clayson D, Two R, Giovanaz M
PharmaQuest Ltd, Banbury, Oxfordshire, UK
The ISPOR Principles of Good Practice paper for the translation of patient-reported
outcome (PRO) measures describes concept elaboration within the scope of project
preparation and emphasises that the misinterpretation of items or concepts can result
if the step is not undertaken. However, the paper does not discuss how to correctly
perform concept elaboration or why it is an essential step in the translation process.
Translation companies often harmonise their own translations with each other, but
not with existing translations. Over time, a single measure may be translated by any
number of companies. Wording choices are often made by various translators and
project managers without prior guidance—this can lead to wide variations. a concept
13th Euro Abstracts
elaboration document approved by the developer provides consistent clarification and
guidance to promote harmonization across all language versions regardless of who is
carrying out the work. Inconsistent wording choices across language versions can be
due to misunderstandings as a result of ambiguous wording in the source text, misinterpretation of idioms or the influence of personal choice resulting in inconsistent use
of alternative phrases for terms that are not directly translatable. Concept elaboration
remedies these issues by providing a line-by-line analysis of the source text which
clarifies ambiguous wording, provides alternative wording for items with no direct
translation, recommends suitable equivalents of culture-bound concepts and provides
guidelines on nuance, tone, and emphasis. Concept elaboration ensures that the text
is fully understood by all translators before any translation work begins. It encourages
standardised decision making for every language and allows the developer to exercise
influence over the style and content of the translations even if they are unable to review
each translation individually. For studies including developer reviews, these reviews
should become more straightforward as the translations will have been carried out
according to the developer’s guidance.
PMC52
TREATMENT SATISFACTION WITH MEDICATION: A REVIEW OF
CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORKS AND APPLICATIONS
Bharmal M, Viswanathan S
Quintiles, Rockville, MD, USA
OBJECTIVES: The construct of treatment satisfaction with medication (TS-M) provides an avenue for incorporating the patients’ voice in treatment evaluation. In recent
years, due to the growing influence of the consumer in health care decisions, there
have been a substantial number of both generic and disease-specific TS-M instruments
developed. This study provides a review of the available TS-M measures and examples
of its applications. METHODS: A literature review was conducted using MEDLINE,
ISPOR Research Digest and Google Scholar to identify generic and disease-specific
TS-M instruments as well as any applications of these instruments. The review
included evaluation of research articles, abstracts, review articles, news articles and
editorials discussing instruments that measure TS-M. RESULTS: A total of 39 instruments that measure TS-M were identified. Out of the 39 instruments, four instruments
were generic in nature that could be used across therapy areas and included the three
versions of the Treatment Satisfaction Questionnaire for Medication (TSQM) (TSQM
v1.4, TSQM vII, TSQM-9) and the SATMED-Q. The rest of the 35 measures were
disease-specific TS-M instruments covering many diseases including migraine, pain,
HIV, diabetes, Crohn’s disease, oncology, osteoarthritis, men’s health and multiple
sclerosis. The instruments varied substantially in the number of items and domains
they covered and included anywhere from 6 items to 46 items. Treatment satisfaction
data has been used to inform clinician decision-making, support label claims, and for
supporting the marketing of drugs. For example, in the past decade, TS-M has been
used to support label claims for 17 products in Europe and in marketing effort of
drugs in many therapy areas including erectile dysfunction, heart disease and diabetes.
CONCLUSIONS: Treatment satisfaction with medication can be an important endpoint for product differentiation of novel treatments. Among the existing TS-M
instruments, researchers could benefit by identifying instruments that have been developed using psychometrically rigorous standards and procedures.
PMC53
COMPARISON OF METHODS FOR ITEM GENERATION AND
PRETESTING OF FIVE LYMPHOEDEMA-SPECIFIC HEALTH-RELATED
QUALITY OF LIFE QUESTIONNAIRES
Williams AE
Biomarin Europe Ltd, London, UK
OBJECTIVES: A systematic literature review identified four patient-reported outcome
(PRO) measures that have been used in the assessment of quality of life for patients
with upper limb lymphoedema. These are in addition to the author’s newly devised
questionnaire. However the developers had all used different methods to devise the
items with the final measures incorporating different items and domains. The objective
was to compare the methods that had been used and review in the light of available
guidance on best practice. METHODS: Review and tabulate the available information
on each PRO regarding its development. Key aspects of the evaluation included specificity of target population, source of item generation, number of initial items generated, drafting of item/question wording, pretesting and defining the domains.
RESULTS: Two of the five PROs had been developed to assess the quality of life of
patients with upper or lower limb lymphoedema decreasing the specificity of the target
population; two of the PROs did not use patients as the source for items relying on
clinicians; the number of items initially generated by the remaining three PROs were
98, 134 and 495, but none of the developers evaluated the point of saturation; different approaches were used for analyses of the items generated to create the initial draft
of items/questions; not all PROs were pretested. Number of domains ranged from two
to seven and number of items/questions in initial drafts ranged from 5 to 70. CONCLUSIONS: Each of the PROs measuring the same concept have been developed using
different methods of generating the items and pretesting an initial draft of the PRO.
To advance the field of measuring quality of life of lymphoedema patients, it will be
important to establish which PRO measure has the best validity, that is, best reflects
the impact of lymphoedema on their health and well-being.
13th Euro Abstracts
PMC54
TREATMENT SATISFACTION INSTRUMENTS FOR DIFFERENT
PURPOSES DURING A PRODUCT’S LIFECYCLE—KEEPING THE END IN
MIND
Rofail D1, Regnault A2, Taylor F1, Filonenko A3
1
Mapi Values Ltd, Bollington, Cheshire, UK; 2Mapi Values, Lyon, France; 3Bayer Schering
Pharma AG, Berlin, Germany
OBJECTIVES: There are three main parts during a product’s lifecycle when satisfaction instruments are particularly useful. These are to aid: 1) getting the product to the
market; 2) getting the market to the product; and 3) demonstrating value for health
care practitioners during daily clinical practice. This study investigates whether the
development and implementation of treatment satisfaction instruments during a product’s lifecycle are informed by their purpose. METHODS: A literature review was
performed between 2000 and 2010 using electronic databases (PUBMED, PsycINFO,
and EMBASE) and keywords such as “satisfaction” and “medication” or “drug” and
“questionnaire.” Relevant articles were reviewed in detail to extract information
regarding the satisfaction instrument used, its development and validation, and when
the instrument was used during a product’s lifecycle. Additional information was
collated including the type of studies the instruments were used in, clinical condition/
indication, type of data generated (e.g. descriptive), and whether satisfaction was
associated with other endpoints. RESULTS: Of 875 abstracts, 105 articles were
further considered. The review indicated similarities regarding the development and
validation of satisfaction instruments, such as using patient input to derive the items
and exploring classical measurement properties specific to the target population.
However, the specificities of the implementation of treatment satisfaction during the
three main stages of a product’s lifecycle were rarely considered. CONCLUSIONS:
The development and implementation of treatment satisfaction instruments during a
product’s lifecycle rarely consider the purpose. By “keeping the end in mind,” data
from treatment satisfaction instruments can help three key parts: 1) getting the product
to the market thus helping to generate evidence as part of an overall value proposition;
2) getting the market to the product; and 3) demonstrating the value to clinical practice. Furthermore, the development, validation and interpretation of scores from
treatment satisfaction instruments should be sensitive to the intended purpose.
CONCEPTUAL PAPERS & RESEARCH ON METHODS – Statistical Methods
PMC55
SYSTEMATIC REVIEW OF METHODS FOR META-ANALYSIS AND
INDIRECT COMPARISON USED IN EXISTING SYSTEMATIC REVIEWS
AND HTA REPORTS—RESULTS FROM THE FIRST PART OF EBAYESMET
PROJECT
Walczak J1, Borowiack E1, Kowalska M1, Nikodem M2, Zapalska A1
1
Arcana Institute, Cracow, Poland; 2CASPolska, Myslenice, Poland
OBJECTIVES: To collect information serve as a background for further activities of
the eBayesMet project. To perform assessment of the frequency of use the particular
statistical methods for meta-analyses and indirect comparisons in existing systematic
reviews and HTA reports. METHODS: Database of Reviews of Effectiveness (DARE)
was searched for relevant reviews published between January 2009 and March 2010.
RESULTS: The majority of meta-analyses were prepared by using direct statistical
methods (97%). The most popular expression about fixed model was that fixed effect
model with the Mantel-Haenszel was used (36%). In case of random model, information that method DerSimonian Laird was selected (38%) was used most often. Metaanalyses were prepared mostly based on randomized controlled trials (87%) and in
3% only on observational studies. In meta-analyses based on RCTs in 42% of cases
authors mentioned that to make strong conclusion more studies were needed. Employing Bayesian methods was generally very rare. For indirect comparisons six methods
were recognized and the most common type was MTC Bayesian Model (53%).
Observational studies were not included in any identified analysis. In 40% of the
review information indicating the need for additional studies was contained. CONCLUSIONS: Our systematic reviews demonstrates a wide range of approaches and
methods for conducting meta-analyses and indirect comparison used in current practice. The most popular approach for indirect comparison is Bayesian included network
and MTC (over 65%). However performed analysis indicated that Bayesian approach
is still marginal methods for performing direct comparison based on head to head
studies. Bayesian models have essential advantage: some additional data can be
included (as a prior distribution). This extra information can be for instance data from
observational studies. However it should be emphasized, that in the analyzed random
sample of systematic reviews studies other than RCT were included in only 13%.
PMC56
IMPROVED SURVIVAL CURVE FITS TO SUMMARY DATA FOR
ECONOMIC EVALUATIONS
Hoyle MW
University of Exeter, Exeter, UK
OBJECTIVES: Estimates of mean cost and quality-adjusted-life-years are central to
the cost-effectiveness analysis of health technologies. They are often calculated from
curve fits to overall survival and time on treatment, ideally by the method of maximum
likelihood applied to individual patient data. However, such data is often not available. Instead, curves are commonly fit to summary Kaplan-Meier estimators, either
by regression of the transformed estimator or by minimizing the sums of squares of
A339
differences between actual and fitted values. However, the tail of the estimator is often
uncertain due to small numbers of patients at risk, and the curve fits do not yield
estimates of the true uncertainty in survival times, which is a very important component of overall uncertainty in cost-effectiveness. Here, I describe a new, more accurate
method of fitting survival curves to summary survival data. METHODS: First, I
estimate the underlying individual patient data from the Kaplan-Meier estimator,
numbers of patients at risk and from other published trial-related information. The
fitted curve is then estimated by maximum likelihood given the estimated underlying
individual patient data. RESULTS: Simulation applied to individual patient data
shows that the method tends to give a more accurate curve fit than the traditional
methods of fitting to the Kaplan-Meier estimator. Furthermore, the curve fit is often
very similar to that derived by fitting to the underlying individual patient data by
maximum likelihood. The method naturally yields accurate estimates of the uncertainty in survival times. When applied to economic evaluations submitted to NICE,
the method often yields substantially improved estimates of cost-effectiveness compared to estimates based on fitting survival curves in the traditional manner. This
highlights the sensitivity of many cost-effectiveness analyses to curve fits. CONCLUSIONS: When only summary survival data is available, I recommend the method for
cost-effectiveness analysis.
PMC57
BIAS IS WORSE THAN NOISE: HANDLING MISSING DATA FOR
CONFOUNDERS IN OBSERVATIONAL STUDIES
Elkin EP, Exuzides AK, Pasta DJ, Miller DP
ICON Clinical Research, San Francisco, CA, USA
OBJECTIVES: Outcomes research often employs observational designs (e.g., disease
registries, administrative health care data sets, chart reviews). Researchers using observational data may find various amounts of missing data for confounders when analyzing the association between an exposure (such as treatment use) and an outcome (such
as an adverse event). This abstract examines the case when a potentially important
confounding variable has a large amount of missing data and compares the analytic
methods that may be used in this situation. METHODS: Strategies for handling
missing confounder information include: (1) ignore confounders with lots of missing
values; (2) exclude cases that are missing a confounder value; (3) impute a value for
the confounder; (4) include missing as a separate category in the analysis. Data from
a disease registry were used as the basis for simulations to compare the odds ratio for
risk of death in patients who received a treatment compared to those without treatment. Both a clinical measurement and a subjective physician assessment are known
to confound the relationship between treatment and death. RESULTS: The most
problematic pattern of missing data was informative missing data. In one simulation,
the clinical measurement was a strong predictor of death; however, it was disproportionately missing in patients who had died. The physician assessment predicted death
strongly among patients missing the clinical measurement, but only weakly in patients
not missing the clinical data. Different approaches to the missing confounder data
either exacerbated or ameliorated the problem. CONCLUSIONS: Excluding cases can
create misleading results due to selection bias. Combining all missing values into a
separate category can create data “noise” (i.e., classification error); however, this may
be the most transparent strategy and least likely to bias results. It is important to
include all cases and all potential confounders in the analysis of outcomes research
studies.
PMC58
SYSTEMATIC REVIEW OF STATISTICAL METHODS OF META-ANALYSIS
AND INDIRECT COMPARISON POTENTIALLY AVAILABLE TO USE IN
SYSTEMATIC REVIEWS—RESULTS FROM THE FIRST PART OF
EBAYESMET PROJECT
Walczak J1, Nikodem M2, Siedmiogrodzki K2, Zapalska A1, Borowiack E1
1
Arcana Institute, Cracow, Poland; 2CASPolska, Myslenice, Poland
OBJECTIVES: To collect information serve as a background for further activities of
the eBayesMet project. To identify statistical methods and approaches for performing
meta-analyses and indirect comparisons. To describe limitations and mathematical
background, to discuss advantages and disadvantages of identified methods.
METHODS: Databases such as MathSciNet, Medline and Cochrane Methodology
Group resources, textbooks, guidelines for preparing systematic reviews were
searched. We focused on papers with strictly mathematical descriptions of presented
methods. RESULTS: Eleven main statistical methods were identified. There were six
methods of meta-analysis (Inverse Variance, Mantel-Haenszel, DerSimonian-Laird,
Peto, Bayesian and Generalized Linear Mixed Models for direct comparison), and five
methods of indirect and mixed comparison (Bûcher, Minimal Squares, Lumley, Bayesian Mixed Treatment Comparison and Generalized Linear Mixed Models for indirect
comparison). Moreover, there are different variants of some of these methods. For
any type of analysis (direct, indirect, network, fixed, random, etc.) and any given data,
there is an adequate version of Bayesian method for performing estimation. We found
the Bayesian approach to be generally the most flexible.Analysis of precision and
credibility of all identified statistical methods of meta-analysis and indirect comparison
will be prepared in the next part of eBayesMet project. CONCLUSIONS: There are
several statistical methods for performing proper data analysis in any model. The
problem is with choosing optimal one for the given data set. On the other hand, all
methods are less reliable and accurate for samples of data, especially for small (or
zero) number of events in one or both arms. There is variety of statistical methods
combining direct and indirect evidence, from which the most flexible is Mixed
A340
Treatment Comparison using the Bayesian approach. Nevertheless, for each of these
methods there are specific assumptions which have to be satisfied in order to obtain
correct estimation.
CONCEPTUAL PAPERS & RESEARCH ON METHODS – Study Design
PMC60
INCLUSION OF CONFERENCE ABSTRACT DATA IN SYSTEMATIC
REVIEWS OF PHARMACOLOGIC INTERVENTIONS IN DIFFERENT
DISEASE AREAS
Zhang Y
Heron Evidence Development Ltd, Luton, England, UK
OBJECTIVES: Conference searching is a common part of systematic review methodology, this study investigates what proportion of study/trial data included in systematic
reviews of pharmacologic interventions is derived solely from data published in conference abstracts, for 3 different disease areas. METHODS: The Cochrane Library of
systematic reviews (SRs) was searched for SRs on pharmacologic interventions which
state that they include conference abstracts in their Specialized Registers and include
conference searching as part of the stated SR methods. Included studies lists of completed systematic reviews were reviewed and the total number of included studies and
the number of studies for which data was obtained only from conference abstracts
were extracted. In disease areas where a large number of SRs met the inclusion criteria,
the 10 most recently published SRs were selected. The following disease groups were
considered: psychological disease (depression and bipolar disorder), female cancers
(breast cancer and ovarian cancer), and arthritis (osteoarthritis and rheumatoid arthritis). RESULTS: 3/10, 9/10 and 4/10 SRs contained studies solely from conference
abstracts, for psychological disease, female cancers and arthritis respectively. For psychological disease 5% (5/226) of all studies included in 10 SRs came only from conference abstracts, for female cancers this was 14% (31/220) and for arthritis this was 14%
(33/232). CONCLUSIONS: The proportion of studies from conference abstracts only
included in SRs varies in the 3 examined disease areas. From these results, there is
some evidence to suggest that the disease area of the review should inform the decision
of whether to include conference searching as part of the protocol. To answer this
question more conclusively, a more expansive review of SRs should be conducted
covering a greater number of SRs and disease areas.
PMC61
MONITORING OF HEALTH ECONOMIC DATA IN CLINICAL TRIALS
Bharmal M, Viswanathan S, Gemmen E
Quintiles, Rockville, MD, USA
OBJECTIVES: Health care decision makers are increasingly requesting health economic (HE) data, both to support product approval and for marketing purposes.
Currently, there is limited information available to aid decisions surrounding the
clinical monitoring of HE endpoints when they are collected as part of a clinical trial.
It is necessary to understand the current level of monitoring activities surrounding HE
data and evolve best practices for monitoring such data. METHODS: To better
understand monitoring activities, a literature review was performed and qualitative
in-depth interviews were conducted with six clinical research associates (CRA) who
had experience collecting HE data as part of clinical trials in a range of therapy areas.
The literature review and interviews focused on understanding current clinical trial
monitoring practices, monitoring activities specific to HE data, the challenges faced
during monitoring and recommendations for the future. RESULTS: All CRAs interviewed reported working either with patient-reported outcome (PRO) measures—
quality of life questionnaires, patient diaries—and/or health care resource utilization
data, in different therapy areas. Data monitoring activities in clinical trials can include
a number of specific tasks ranging from full source data verification (SDV) to partial
SDV to just checking for accuracy, legibility and completeness. The most common
challenges in monitoring of HE data included incomplete questionnaires, misinterpretation of questionnaire data by the sites, and difficulty in SDV of health care resource
utilization data by the CRA. Recommendations for the future included optimizing
methods for documentation of health care resource utilization data, improving patient/
site training in PRO use, and selecting the type of PRO and mode of PRO administration based on the patient population being examined. CONCLUSIONS: Health economic endpoints are increasingly being used in clinical trials, and CRAs are becoming
familiar with PRO and health care resource utilization data. Monitoring activities for
HE data vary by the study design and type of data collected.
CARDIOVASCULAR DISORDERS – Clinical Outcomes Studies
PCV1
ESTIMATION OF STROKE-RELATED ADVERSE EVENTS, HEALTH CARE
UTILITY AND COST OF PATIENTS WITH NON-VALVULAR ATRIAL
FIBRILLATION
Wang L1, Baser O2
1
STATinMED Research, Ann Arbor, MI, USA; 2STATinMED Research/University of Michigan,
Ann Arbor, MI, USA
OBJECTIVES: To estimate mortality, health care utility and health care cost burden of
patients who suffered a stroke during the 180 days after diagnosis of non-valvular atrial
13th Euro Abstracts
fibrillation (NVAF) and compare it with patients who did not suffer a stroke.
METHODS: Based on 2005–2007 U.S. Medicare advantage insurance claim files,
patients aged 65 years and older who had 2 or more primary diagnoses for NVAF within
30 days of one another were selected. The 180-day follow-up event rates, health care
facility use and health care cost for patients with a stroke and those without were
compared. Risk adjustment was done by using the propensity score matching method
with the ProbChoiceTM algorithm. RESULTS: Out of patients identified with NVAF (n
= 18,575), 575 suffered a stroke during the 180 days after NVAF diagnosis. 94% (n =
541) did not have stroke during the baseline period (180 days before NVAF diagnosis).
Patients were not significantly different in terms of gender, region, and baseline comorbid conditions. After risk-adjustment for pre-specified covariates, mortality (7.14% vs.
2.09% P < 0.0001), outpatient emergency room (ER) visits (79.97% vs. 46.34% P <
0.0001), acute coronary syndrome (43 vs. 16/100 person years), transient ischemic
attack (73 vs. 4 /100 person years), major bleeding (85 vs. 4 /100 person years) and
myocardial infarction (32 vs. 9/100 person years) were all higher for patients who suffered a stroke compared to those who did not. Besides inpatient cost ($24,116 vs.
$20,828), risk-adjusted outpatient ER costs ($921 vs. $873) were also higher for stroke
patients. Overall risk-adjusted difference in health care costs is significant ($33,430 vs.
$16,375 P < 0.0001). CONCLUSIONS: Most of the adverse events analyzed were
higher for patients who suffered a stroke after NVAF relative to patients who did not.
Total health care utility and health care cost were also significantly increased.
PCV2
ESTIMATION OF ADVERSE EVENTS IN 3 MONTHS AFTER VENOUS
THROMBOEMBOLISM EVENT FOR MEDICARE PATIENTS WHO
UNDERWENT HIP FRACTURE SURGERY
Wang L1, Dysinger A1, Baser O2
1
STATinMED Research, Ann Arbor, MI, USA; 2STATinMED Research/University of Michigan,
Ann Arbor, MI, USA
OBJECTIVES: To estimate mortality, re-hospitalization and bleeding 180 days after
a venous thromboembolism (VTE) event in patients following hip fracture surgery and
to compare the outcomes with patients without VTE. METHODS: Based on 2004–
2006 national Medicare claims, all patients who underwent hip fracture surgery were
identified. a total of 180 days follow-up event rates for patients who had a VTE event
during their initial hospitalization were calculated. Events were compared between
patients who suffered a VTE event and those that did not. Risk adjustment was done
using propensity score matching (using the ProbChoiceTM algorithm) controlling for
baseline demographic and clinical characteristics between patients with and without
VTE. RESULTS: In patients who underwent hip fracture surgery (n = 77,743), 2.23%
had post-operative VTE events during their initial hospitalization. Almost 72.96% (n
= 1263) of these patients suffered deep vein thrombosis (DVT), 20.97% (n = 363) had
a pulmonary embolism (PE), and 6.07% (n = 105) had both DVT and PE. After
multivariate adjustment for pre-specified covariates, mortality was almost 50% higher
for patients with VTE compared to those without VTE. Differences in mortality rate
were more pronounced for PE patients, whom the event was associated with almost
two-fold. The VTE group was more likely to be re-hospitalized in one year (odds ratio:
1.18, p = 0.2720). Bleeding was 1.8 times higher (p = 0.0080). CONCLUSIONS: VTE
events during initial hospitalization for hip fracture surgery increased patients’ mortality, re-hospitalization and bleeding compared to patients with no VTE events.
PCV3
COMPARISON OF MORTALITY, HEALTH CARE UTILITY AND COST OF
PATIENTS WITH WARFARIN TREATMENT FOR NON-VALVULAR
ATRIAL FIBRILLATION VERSUS PATIENTS WITH OTHER TREATMENT
Wang L1, Baser O2
1
STATinMED Research, Ann Arbor, MI, USA; 2STATinMED Research/University of Michigan,
Ann Arbor, MI, USA
OBJECTIVES: To estimate the economic and clinical burden of patients who used
warfarin during the 180 days after diagnosis of non-valvular atrial fibrillation (NVAF)
and compare it with patients who did not use warfarin. METHODS: Based on
2005–2007 U.S. Medicare advantage insurance claim files, patients aged 65 years and
older who have had 2 or more primary diagnoses for NVAF occurring within 30 days
of one another were selected. The 180 days follow-up event rates, health care facility
use and cost were compared. Risk adjustment was done by using the propensity score
matching method with the ProbChoiceTM algorithm. RESULTS: In patients who
identified with NVAF (n = 18,575) 12,186 used warfarin during the 180 days after
NVAF diagnosis and 6,389 used other drugs or did not use any drugs. Patients were
significantly different in terms of age, gender, comorbid conditions and baseline
CHADS score. After risk-adjustment for pre-specified covariates, mortality (0.75% vs.
2.26%), outpatient emergency room (ER) visits (48.79% vs. 53.30%), acute coronary
syndrome (105 vs. 154 /100 person years), and myocardial infarction (61 vs. 112 /100
person years) were all lower for patients who had warfarin with non-valvular atrial
fibrillation. Even though drug cost is higher for the warfarin group ($1,687 vs.
$1,595), risk-adjusted outpatient ER costs ($756 vs. $861) were lower. Overall riskadjusted health care costs did not differ ($12,739 vs. $15,359). CONCLUSIONS:
Most of the adverse events analyzed were lower for patients who had warfarin after
non-valvular atrial fibrillation relative to patients who did not. However, the economic
burden of both groups of patients on the health care system was similar.
13th Euro Abstracts
PCV4
CLINICAL AND COST OUTCOMES OF VENOUS THROMBOEMBOLISM
IN PATIENTS WHO UNDERWENT MAJOR ORTHOPEDIC SURGERY
Baser O1, Wang L2, Xie L2
1
STATinMED Research/University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA; 2STATinMED Research,
Ann Arbor, MI, USA
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the effects of venous thromboembolism (VTE) occurring
within 30 days of hospital discharge after major orthopedic surgery on inpatient costs
and mortality within 1 year after initial hospitalization for the surgery. METHODS:
U.S. national Medicare data was used for this analysis. All patients who underwent
total hip replacement (THR) (n = 51,108) or total knee replacement (TKR) (n =
115,627) surgery were identified. VTE events were diagnosed within the first 30 days
and within 1 year post-discharge. Multivariate regression was used to control for
differences in baseline characteristics in patients with and without VTE events. Total
cost was measured as Medicare cost plus beneficiary out-of-pocket cost. RESULTS:
VTE occurred in 0.74% of patients undergoing THR. For patients with VTE versus
no VTE, mortality was higher (2.9% vs. 0.4%, P < 0.001). Medicare and total health
care cost, including the beneficiary cost share in 1 year, were not different for VTE
versus no VTE ($19,300 vs. $19,044, p = 0.817), but the beneficiary cost share was
higher for VTE ($3,274 vs. $1,966, P < 0.001). VTE occurred in 0.70% of patients
undergoing TKR. For patients with VTE versus no VTE, mortality was higher (2.5%
vs. 0.15%, P < 0.001). Total health care cost, including the beneficiary cost share in
1 year, was not different for VTE versus no VTE ($17,970 vs. $16,766, p = 0.142),
but the Medicare and beneficiary cost shares were both slightly higher for VTE ($3,274
vs. $1,966 and $2,650 vs. $1,630 for THR and TKR patients, respectively, P < 0.001).
CONCLUSIONS: VTE after major orthopedic surgery is associated with higher mortality compared with no VTE. VTE did not affect total health care costs in 1 year,
but beneficiary costs were higher. Risk-adjusted total, Medicare, and beneficiary health
care costs were significantly higher for major orthopedic surgery patients with VTE
(P < 0.001).
PCV5
COMPARISON OF ADVERSE EVENTS OF MEDICARE PATIENTS WHO
UNDERWENT KNEE REPLACEMENT SURGERY AND EXPERIENCED
VENOUS THROMBOEMBOLISM VERSUS NO VENOUS
THROMBOEMBOLISM
Wang L1, Dysinger A1, Baser O2
1
STATinMED Research, Ann Arbor, MI, USA; 2STATinMED Research/University of Michigan,
Ann Arbor, MI, USA
OBJECTIVES: To estimate re-hospitalization and bleeding rates during the 30 days
after a venous thromboembolism (VTE) event in patients who underwent knee replacement surgery and to compare the outcomes with patients who did not suffer VTE.
METHODS: Based on 2004–2006 national Medicare claims, all patients who underwent knee replacement surgery were identified. The 30 days follow-up event rates for
patients who had a VTE event during their initial hospitalization were calculated.
Events were compared between patients who suffered a VTE event and those who did
not. Risk adjustment was done using propensity score matching (using the ProbChoiceTM algorithm) controlling for baseline demographic and clinical characteristics
between patients with and without VTE. RESULTS: In patients who underwent total
knee replacement surgery (n = 104,952), 1.9% had post-operative VTE events during
their initial hospitalization. Almost 69% (n = 1377) of these patients had deep vein
thrombosis (DVT), 25% (n = 501) had pulmonary embolism (PE), and 6% (n = 119)
had both DVT and PE. The overall likelihood of mortality was four times higher for
VTE patients versus those without VTE (1.35% vs. 0.35%). Patients with VTE during
their initial hospitalization were more likely to be hospitalized in 30 days compared
to patients without an event during the same hospital stay (16.62% vs. 8.00%). In
30 days after the event, patients with VTE were more likely to have bleeding (9.31%
vs. 2.18%). CONCLUSIONS: VTE events during initial hospitalization for total knee
replacement surgery patients increased the adverse events compared with no VTE
events.
PCV6
OUTCOME OF ADVERSE DRUG REACTIONS REGISTERED WITH
INTENSIVE MONITORING SYSTEM
Mugosa S1, Todorovic Z2, Boskovic A3
1
School of Medicine, University of Montenegro, Podgorica, Montenegro; 2School of Medicine,
University of Belgrade, Belgrade, Serbia; 3Clinical Center of Montenegro, Podgorica,
Montenegro
OBJECTIVES: Adverse drug reactions (ADR) appear more frequently then what is
actually reported and registered. The aim was to establish intensive monitoring system
and to analyze ADR in hospitalized patients. METHODS: Prospective study covered
200 patients hospitalized in Cardiology Center, Clinical Center of Montenegro. ADR
were collected in the following way: patients were interviewed on the basis of the
symptoms list and any signs which could point to eventual ADR. Secondly, lab tests
and other available parameters were observed. RESULTS: At the time when interviews
took place, patients received on average 7.96 ± 2.63 medicines (2–17). In total, 67
patients (34%) had 75 ADR. Twenty-one ADR (28%) are classified as serious. Fiftyfour ADR have resulted in the recovery of the patient (72%), eight had as an outcome
prolonged hospitalization (11%), another 8 were life threatening (11%), while 5 ADR
(6%) were the cause of the hospitalization. The most frequent ADR which had as an
outcome admission to hospital were caused by digoxin (40%), prolonged hospital stay
A341
by furosemide (38%), while the most frequent registered ADR which were life threatening were caused by streptokinase (50%). CONCLUSIONS: Monitoring ADR in
patients using cardiovascular drugs is a matter of importance since this class of medicine is usually used by elderly patients with critical conditions and underlying
diseases.
PCV7
SPONTANEOUS REPORTING OF ADVERSE DRUG REACTIONS
INVOLVING HOSPITALIZED CARDIAC PATIENTS
Mugosa S1, Todorovic Z2, Boskovic A3
1
School of Medicine, University of Montenegro, Podgorica, Montenegro; 2School of Medicine,
University of Belgrade, Belgrade, Serbia; 3Clinical Center of Montenegro, Podgorica,
Montenegro
OBJECTIVES: Adverse drug reactions (ADR) in hospital are a significant cause of
morbidity and mortality. The aim is to analyze the ADR which have been collected
through doctors’ and medical technicians’ spontaneous reporting. METHODS: The
prospective study covered 655 patients hospitalized in Cardiology Center of Clinical
Center of Montenegro. ADR were collected by spontaneous reporting. According to
the criteria of World Health Organization, for every ADR causality assessment, severity, type, outcome, level of intervention and place of manifestation of ADR was
established. RESULTS: In the 6 month period of research at the Cardiology Center,
655 patients were hospitalized with the average age of 60.72 ± 11.36 years. With
spontaneous reporting, 22 patients had 22 ADR which were noted. Doctors reported
a statistically significant larger number of ADR (68%) than medical technicians
(32%), P < 0,01. Nine patients (41%) had serious ADR with the following outcome:
21 ADR were the cause of the hospitalization (22%), four ADR resulted in the
extended hospitalization (44%), and 3 were life threatening (33%). The most frequent
serious ADR were reported spontaneously by doctors and medical technicians and
were caused by streptokinase (33%). The most frequent symptoms which the patients
had as a consequence of ADR were: fainting (27%), headache (18%), weakness
(14%), vertigo (14%) and vomiting (9%). CONCLUSIONS: Considering increased
use of cardiovascular drugs and limitations in pre-marketing trials for drug safety
evaluation, post marketing evaluation of adverse drug reactions induced by this class
of medicinal products seems necessary.
PCV8
EVALUATION OF CLINICAL AND DIRECT ECONOMIC OUTCOMES
FOLLOWING AN ACUTE CORONARY EVENT AMONG PATIENTS WITH
SUBOPTIMAL HDL-C OR TRIGLYCERIDES ADMINISTERED EITHER
STATIN AND NIACIN EXTENDED-RELEASE OR STATIN
MONOTHERAPY
Cziraky MJ1, Quinlan S1, Quimbo RA1, Simko RJ2, Webb S2
1
HealthCore, Wilmington, DE, USA; 2Abbott Laboratories, Abbott Park, IL, USA
OBJECTIVES: To compare the risk of subsequent coronary event (SCE) and associated costs between patients maintaining statin monotherapy (SM) or augmenting with
niacin extended-release (NER) after an acute coronary event (ACE). METHODS:
Patients with an ACE between January 1, 2004 and March 31, 2009 were identified
(Index Date was defined as the earliest ACE). Patients age ≥18, ≥6 months eligibility
pre- and post-Index Date, ≥1 statin fill and no statin augmenting fill 6 months before
the Index Date, and sub-optimal baseline HDL-C (<40 or <50 mg/dL for men and
women) or triglyceride (>150 or >200 mg/dL for diabetic and non-diabetic) were
included. Cohorts were determined based on NER or SM fills within 6 months of the
Index Date (Cohort ID Period). Patients with alternative lipid agents or SCE during
the Cohort ID Period were excluded. Outcomes included SCE and event-related
medical costs. SCE risk was compared using Cox proportional hazards models, while
costs were compared via generalized linear models. Multivariate analyses controlled
for age, gender, health coverage, geography, co-morbidities, concomitant medications,
baseline lipids, and severity of initial ACE. RESULTS: A total of 1998 patients added
NER (n = 145) or maintained SM (n = 1,853) and met all study criteria. NER patients
were younger (57 ± 8 vs. 61 ± 11, P < 0.0001), less likely female (8% vs. 33%, P =
0.002), and had lower baseline LDL-C (81 ± 32 vs. 99 ± 41; P < 0.0001), HDL-C (34
± 7 vs. 40 ± 9; P < 0.0001), and triglycerides (185 ± 118 vs. 208 ± 131; P = 0.0290).
Compared to SM, NER patients had a 43% lower SCE risk (hazard ratio: 0.57,
95%CI: 0.35–0.94; P = 0.0274). Clinical findings corresponded with 56% reduction
in adjusted annual event-related costs compared to SM (0.44; 95% CI: 0.25–0.80 p
= 0.0068). CONCLUSIONS: Among patients requiring comprehensive lipid management, NER demonstrated lower SCE risk compared to SM, consequently reducing
annual event-related medical costs following an ACE.
PCV9
RATE OF SUBSEQUENT CORONARY EVENTS AND DIRECT ECONOMIC
OUTCOMES FOLLOWING AN ACUTE CORONARY EVENT BETWEEN
PATIENTS AUGMENTING STATIN TO FURTHER REDUCE LDL-C VS.
IMPROVING A COMPREHENSIVE LIPID PROFILE
Quinlan S1, Quimbo RA1, Simko RJ2, Cziraky MJ1, Webb S2
1
HealthCore, Wilmington, DE, USA; 2Abbott Laboratories, Abbott Park, IL, USA
OBJECTIVES: Compare the annual subsequent coronary event rate (ASCER) and
associated costs between patients initiating adjunct therapy with either niacin
extended-release (NER) for comprehensive lipid panel management or ezetimibe (EZE)
for continued LDL-C reduction after an acute coronary event (ACE). METHODS:
Patients with an ACE between January 1, 2004 and May 31, 2009 were identified
A342
(Index Date was defined as the earliest ACE). Patients age ≥18, ≥6 months eligibility
pre- and post-Index Date, ≥1 statin fill and no statin augmenting fill 6 months before
the Index Date, and sub-optimal baseline HDL-C (<40 or <50 mg/dL for men and
women) or triglyceride (>150 or >200 mg/dL for diabetic and non-diabetic) were
included. Cohorts were determined based on NER or EZE fills within 6 months of
the Index Date (Cohort ID Period). Patients with alternative lipid agents or coronary
event during the Cohort ID Period were excluded. Outcomes included ASCER and
event-related medical costs and were compared via generalized linear models. Multivariate analyses controlled for age, gender, health coverage, geography, co-morbidities, baseline lipids, and severity of initial ACE. RESULTS: A total of 328 patients
added NER (n = 145) or EZE (n = 183) and met all study criteria. NER patients were
less likely female (8% vs. 29%, P < 0.0001), had lower baseline LDL-C (81 ± 32 vs.
112 ± 40; P < 0.0001) and HDL-C (34 ± 7 vs. 40 ± 9; P < 0.0001). Age (57 ± 8 vs.
58 ± 10; P = 0.2020), Deyo-Charlson comorbidity index (0.6 ± 1.1 vs. 0.9 ± 1.4; P =
0.0923) and triglycerides (185 ± 118 vs. 199 ± 94; P = 0.2531) were not statistically
different. Compared to EZE, NER patients had a 57% decrease in ASCER (incidence
ratio: 0.43, 95%CI: 0.24–0.77). Clinical findings corresponded with 87% reduction
in adjusted annual event-related costs compared to EZE (0.13; 95% CI: 0.04–0.41).
CONCLUSIONS: Among patients requiring lipid management, adopting a comprehensive lipid approach demonstrated lower ASCER compared to further reducing
LDL-C, consequently reducing annual event-related medical costs following an ACE.
PCV10
ANALYSIS OF INAPPROPRIATE SHOCKS IN IMPLANTABLE
CARDIOVERTER DEFIBRILLATOR (ICD) DEVICES
Neophytou I1, LeReun C2, Diamantopoulos A1
1
Symmetron Ltd., London, UK; 2Independent Biostatistician, Carrigaline County, Cork, Ireland
OBJECTIVES: A side effect of implantable cardioverter defibrillator (ICD) devices is
inappropriate shocks. Shocks are painful, can potentially induce lethal arrhythmias
and cause severe psychological trauma to cardiac arrhythmic patients. The objective
of this study was to investigate the risk of inappropriate shocks in patients who receive
ICD therapy. METHODS: A comprehensive literature search was conducted to identify studies describing ICD therapy and reporting inappropriate shock data. The
analysis included studies of patients with implantation performed after 2002, having
a minimum study population of 50 participants and a minimum 12 month follow up
period. The database search was augmented by hand searching references of contemporary systematic reviews in the area of ICD therapy, to ensure all relevant studies
were captured. Patient numbers from the identified studies were pooled and summary
statistics were estimated. RESULTS: A total of 415 published articles were identified
via the database search. Following abstract and full text review, 32 studies were
included for data extraction and statistical analysis. a further 4 studies were included
from the systematic review hand search. The 36 studies provided a combined total of
807 patients. 16.2% (SD: 11.1) of patients experienced at least one inappropriate
shock, this was reduced to 15.3% with exclusion of paediatric studies. The median
duration of follow up was 2.6 years. The average number of inappropriate shocks per
year for all patients is 0.4 (SD: 0.4). The frequency of inappropriate shocks amongst
patients who experienced at least one inappropriate shock is 2.2 (SD: 1.7) per year.
In 11 studies that present detailed information on the nature of shocks 32.9% (SD:
22.9) of total shock events were recorded as inappropriate. CONCLUSIONS: A high
proportion of patients in recent trials experienced inappropriate shocks. Future development of ICD therapy should focus on the reduction of the inappropriate shock risk.
PCV11
PLATELET FUNCTION TESTS ARE HIGHLY VARIABLE WHEN USED TO
IDENTIFY PATIENTS RESISTANT TO CLOPIDOGREL
Beard K1, Folia C1, Liovas A2
1
Agro Health Associates Inc., Burlington, ON, Canada; 2AstraZeneca Canada Inc.,
Mississauga, ON, Canada
OBJECTIVES: Clopidogrel with aspirin is used to prevent thrombosis. However,
significant interpatient variability in platelet response to clopidogrel has been reported.
As many as 33% of patients are considered to be clopidogrel non-responders (NRs).
a recent meta-analysis has shown that clopidogrel resistance is associated with a 3.5fold increased risk of ischemic events. There are several platelet function assays (PFAs)
available to assess clopidogrel resistance, the gold-standard being light transmission
aggregometry (LTA). Other PFAs have been developed, including vasodilator-stimulated phosphoprotein phosphorylation (VASP), and VerifyNow® (VN), the latter being
a point-of-care assay. However PFAs are not frequently used in the clinical setting
since they are expensive, and time- and labour-intensive. It is of interest to compare
the reliability of various PFAs in the identification of clopidogrel NRs. METHODS:
A MEDLINE search was conducted (1966–2010) using the following MeSH terms:
Clopidogrel, Resistance, and Platelet Function Assay. Patient-based studies which
compared the proportion of clopidogrel NRs using different PFAs were retrieved.
RESULTS: Four studies were retrieved. Of these studies, 3 demonstrated significant
heterogeneity among PFAs in their assessment of clopidogrel responsiveness. The
proportion of clopidogrel NRs identified with the various PFAs ranged from 13%–
39%, 44%–69%, 35%–90%, and 69%–70% in the 4 studies respectively. CONCLUSIONS: The ability to identify clopidogrel NRs by different PFAs varies greatly
according to the assay used. In addition, LTA and VASP are associated with poor
quality control, expense and long turnaround times, and they are typically restricted
to specialized laboratories in research hospitals. The inability of current PFAs to
accurately assess clopidogrel resistance may place unidentified clopidogrel NRs at
13th Euro Abstracts
increased risk of ischemic events. The challenges and costs associated with such tests
may be eliminated by newer therapies which have less response variability than
clopidogrel.
PCV12
COMPARATIVE EFFICACY OF EZETIMIBE-STATIN COMBINATION
THERAPY AND STATIN MONOTHERAPY IN PATIENTS WITH
HYPERCHOLESTEROLEMIA: SYSTEMATIC REVIEW AND METAANALYSIS OF RANDOMISED CONTROLLED TRIALS
Tunceli K1, Lawson RW2, Sibbring GC2, McCormick AL2, Tershakovec AM3, Davies GM3,
Mikhailidis DP4
1
Global Health Outcomes, Merck, Whitehouse Station, NJ, USA; 2Complete Market Access,
Macclesfield, Cheshire, UK; 3Merch Research Laboratories, West Point and Upper Gwynedd,
PA, USA; 4Department of Clinical Biochemistry (Vascular Disease Prevention Clinics), Royal
Free Hospital Campus, University College London (UCL) Medical School, UCL, London, UK
OBJECTIVES: To review and analyze evidence for the comparative cholesterollowering efficacy of ezetimibe-statin combination therapy versus statin monotherapy
in adults with primary hypercholesterolemia. METHODS: MEDLINE, EMBASE, and
the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials were searched to identify parallelgroup, randomised controlled trials of ezetimibe-statin combination therapy versus
statin monotherapy, published between January 1993 and March 2010. Studies were
selected using predefined criteria including minimum treatment of 4 weeks. Two reviewers conducted screening of articles, critical appraisal and data extraction, with a third
reviewer resolving disagreements. Study quality was assessed using the Cochrane Collaboration “risk of bias” assessment tool. The difference between treatments in mean
percentage change from baseline in low-density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-C) and
proportion of patients attaining LDL-C treatment goal was analyzed. Data were combined by pair-wise, direct comparison random effects meta-analysis, with heterogeneity
assessed using the I2 statistic. RESULTS: Fifteen articles met selection criteria; 13
studies involving over 5000 patients could be included in the meta-analyses. Data on
simvastatin, atorvastatin and rosuvastatin were analyzed. There was a significantly
greater percentage reduction in LDL-C levels in patients treated with ezetimibe-statin
monotherapy compared with those treated with statin monotherapy (weighted mean
difference: 14.11% [95% CI: 16.13, 12.1], P < 0.001), similarly, a greater proportion
of patients achieved LDL-C goal when treated with ezetimibe-statin combination
therapy compared with those treated with statin monotherapy (odds ratio 2.38 [95%
CI: 1.89, 2.94], P < 0.001). The proportion of patients achieving LDL-C goal ranged
from 12–83% (median 60%) in ezetimibe-statin arms of studies and from 2–52%
(median 23%) in the statin monotherapy arms. CONCLUSIONS: The results indicate
that ezetimibe-statin combination therapy is significantly more effective in reducing
LDL-C levels than increasing the statin monotherapy dose, thereby enabling more
patients to achieve their LDL-C goal.
PCV13
META REGRESSION ANALYSIS TO INDIRECTLY COMPARE THE SAFETY
AND EFFICACY OF DALTEPARIN TO ENOXAPARIN FOR THE
PREVENTION OF VENOUS THROMBOEMBOLIC EVENTS (VTES) IN
TOTAL HIP REPLACEMENT (THR) SURGERY
Dranitsaris G1, Jelincic V1, Choe Y2
1
Augmentium Pharma Consulting, Toronto, ON, Canada; 2Eisai Inc, Woodcliff Lake, NJ, USA
OBJECTIVES: Patients undergoing elective THR surgery are at an increased risk for
VTEs. Even though dalteparin and enoxaparin have proven clinical effectiveness in
placebo controlled studies, there have been no head-to-head trials to assess comparative effectiveness. Meta-analytic techniques were used for an indirect statistical comparison on the safety and efficacy between dalteparin and enoxaparin in patients
undergoing THR surgery. METHODS: A literature search of major databases was
conducted from 1980 to 2009 for randomized placebo controlled trials evaluating
both agents in THR patients. Binary outcomes (e.g. VTE rates) for the LMWH group
relative to control group were statistically pooled using fixed or random effects models
in cases of significant heterogeneity. In trials where a common control was used,
indirect statistical comparisons between dalteparin and enoxaparin were performed
using meta regression analysis with active drug (dalteparin or enoxaparin) as the
primary independent variable. RESULTS: A total of nine placebo controlled enoxaparin (n = 5) and dalteparin (n = 4) trials met the inclusion criteria. The meta analysis
of all trial data showed that THR patients treated with enoxaparin or dalteparin had
a 54% VTE relative risk reduction compared to the placebo (RR = 0.46, p < 0.001).
This benefit was achieved without a significant increase in the risk for major bleeds
(RR = 1.14, p = 0.80), heparin induced thrombocytopenia (HIT) (RR = 0.83, p = 0.75)
or death (RR = 0.77, p = 0.61). The indirect statistical comparison was not able to
find significant differences between enoxaparin and dalteparin in terms of VTEs (p =
0.86), risk of major bleeds (p = 0.46), HIT (p = 0.75) and death (p = 1.0). CONCLUSIONS: The findings of the analysis suggest comparable safety and efficacy between
dalteparin and enoxaparin in THR patients. Therefore, treatment decisions should be
based on other considerations such as patient or physician preference, ease of administration and cost.
13th Euro Abstracts
PCV14
ASPIRIN USE IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH REDUCED MYOCARDIAL
INFARCTION IN ELDERLY WITH TYPE 2 DIABETES WITH OR
WITHOUT PRIOR HISTORY OF CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE
Sirois C, Moisan J, Grégoire JP
Laval University, Québec, QC, Canada
OBJECTIVES: Aspirin is recommended for prevention of myocardial infarction (MI)
in elderly with type 2 diabetes although the benefits of aspirin therapy have not been
well established in this population. We evaluated the association between aspirin use
and myocardial infarction (MI) among elderly newly treated with oral antidiabetes
drugs, according to whether or not they had prior history of cardiovascular disease.
METHODS: Using Quebec administrative databases, we conducted two nested casecontrol analyses within a population-based cohort of 39,680 individuals aged 66
years, newly treated with an antidiabetes drug, who had not used aspirin, antiplatelet
or anticoagulant drugs and had no MI in the year before cohort entry. In the first
analysis, eligible individuals had no previous cardiovascular disease recorded in the
database, whereas in the second analysis, eligible individuals had a known cardiovascular disease. Cases were patients who had a MI. For each case, we selected five
controls matched for age, year of cohort entry and sex using incidence density sampling. Exposure to aspirin was defined as current, past or none. Odds ratios (OR) of
MI were calculated using paired multivariate conditional logistic regression. RESULTS:
We identified 1101 cases of MI among the cardiovascular disease-free individuals.
Neither current [OR = 1.03 (95% CI: 0.82–1.28)] nor past users [0.95 (0.74–1.24)]
of aspirin had a significant different risk of MI than non users. There were 770 cases
of MI among those individuals with a prior history of cardiovascular disease. Compared with non users of aspirin, both past [1.72 (1.30–2.28)] and current users [1.33
(1.03–1.71)] had a significant higher risk of MI. CONCLUSIONS: These results
suggest that aspirin does not provide a cardiovascular protection to elderly individuals
with type 2 diabetes.
PCV15
META-REGRESSION APPROACH TO IDENTIFY THE EQUIVALENCE
DOSE RATIOS OF ROSUVASTATIN TO SIMVASTATIN AND
ATORVASTATIN
Jakubczyk M1, Perkowski P2, Paweska J1, Macioch T1, Niewada M1, Rdzanek M2, Faluta T2
1
HealthQuest sp z o.o., Warsaw, Poland; 2AstraZeneca Pharma Poland Sp. z o.o., Warsaw,
Poland
OBJECTIVES: To identify the equivalent hypolipidemic doses of rosuvastatin compared to atorvastatin and simvastatin. METHODS: A systematic review of clinical
trials was conducted. The percentage reduction of baseline LDL cholesterol was used
as a measure of clinical effectiveness. The weighted mean difference (WMD) of effectiveness between comparators and rosuvastatin (separately) was calculated using the
meta-regression approach, with logarithm of dosage ratio as an explanatory variable.
Due to the heterogeneous baseline levels of cholesterol, the random effects model was
used. As several observations came from single trials (various dosages of a given drug)
a correlation of error terms may result. In a simplified, benchmark analysis no correlations were assumed. In a full analysis it was assumed that: for two observations from
a single trial regarding different patients the covariance equals the common variance
of random-effects model; for two observations from a single trial with one group of
patients in common the covariance is further increased by the variance of the effect
for the shared group. Monte Carlo approach and Cholesky decomposition were used
to calculate confidence intervals of equivalent dosage ratios taking into account the
correlation of model estimates. RESULTS: In total 41 trials were found and used,
allowing for 78 single comparisons of rosuvastatin with atorvastatin, and 25 with
simvastatin. Dosage ratios of comparator to rosuvastatin used in the meta-regression
amounted to 1:1, 2:1, 4:1, and 8:1. The full analysis yielded WMD = −8.64 +
7.2*ln(dosage ratio) for atorvastatin and WMD = −15.94 + 7.55*ln(dosage ratio) for
simvastatin. Benchmark analysis gave similar results. Resulting equivalence ratios
amount to 3.32 for atorvastatin (95%CI: 2.93–3.79), and 8.26 (95%CI: 6.86–10.28)
for simvastatin. CONCLUSIONS: Meta-regression approach allows for equivalence
dosage analysis. Correlation issues need to be addressed for multiple treatment arms
in a single study. Rosuvastatin yields equivalent hypolipemic effect for lower dosages
than atorvastatin and simvastatin.
PCV16
THE EFFECT OF SITAXENTAN ON EXERCISE CAPACITY,
HEMODYNAMIC FUNCTION, AND HEALTH-RELATED QUALITY OF LIFE
IN ADULTS WITH PULMONARY ARTERIAL HYPERTENSION
Hwang LJ1, Liu X2, Teal SA3, Louie M1, Mychaskiw MA1
1
Pfizer Inc, New York, NY, USA; 2Aerotek, Houston, TX, USA; 3Pfizer Ltd, Tadworth,
Surrey, UK
OBJECTIVES: Pulmonary arterial hypertension (PAH) is progressive and fatal. Hemodynamic parameters, physical functioning (PF), and health-related quality of life
(HRQoL) worsen without treatment. The objective was to evaluate the distribution
of changes in exercise capacity, hemodynamic parameters, and HRQoL in PAH
patients treated with sitaxentan. Because cumulative distribution functions (CDFs)
characterize treatment effects beyond conventional statistical significance (which is
achievable in large studies with small changes that lack clinical meaning), this method
was employed. METHODS: Adult PAH patients (n = 178) received 12 weeks of randomized, double-blind treatment with placebo (n = 60) or sitaxentan 100 (n = 55) or
300 (n = 63) mg once daily. The primary outcome measure was change in percent of
A343
predicted peak VO2 (PVO2); 6-minute walk distance (6MWD) measured exercise capacity. Hemodynamic assessments included pulmonary and systemic vascular resistance
(PVR and SVR, respectively), pulmonary capillary wedge pressure (PCWP), and cardiac
index (CI). The Short Form-36 (SF-36) assessed HRQoL, including the PF domain. CDFs
plotted the cumulative percentage of patients against percentage (and, separately,
numeric) changes from baseline to week 12 in outcome measures. Kolmogorov-Smirnov
tests assessed differences in separation between CDFs for sitaxentan and placebo.
RESULTS: Significant differences between CDFs were observed for sitaxentan 300 mg
(but not 100 mg) vs. placebo for both numeric and percentage change in percent of
predicted PVO2 (P = 0.03). Significant differences occurred for sitaxsentan 100 and
300 mg vs. placebo for 6MWD, PVR, SVR, and CI (P < 0.02 for each); the PCWP
difference was significant only for percentage change at the 100-mg sitaxentan dose.
No differences occurred for the SF-36 PF domain. CONCLUSIONS: Using CDF
analysis incorporating the entire distribution of responses, sitaxentan significantly
improved percent of predicted PVO2 (by numeric and percentage changes, 300-mg
dose), 6MWD, PVR, SVR, CI, and PCWP (by percentage change, 100-mg dose), but
not the SF-36 PF domain in PAH patients.
PCV17
RESPONSE PROFILES OF SILDENAFIL CITRATE ON EXERCISE
CAPACITY, HEMODYNAMIC FUNCTION, AND HEALTH-RELATED
QUALITY OF LIFE IN CHILDREN WITH PULMONARY ARTERIAL
HYPERTENSION
Cappelleri JC1, Hwang LJ2, Mardekian J2, Mychaskiw MA2
1
Pfizer Inc, New London, CT, USA; 2Pfizer Inc, New York, NY, USA
OBJECTIVES: Pulmonary arterial hypertension (PAH) is an ultimately fatal condition
that may worsen hemodynamic parameters and contribute to diminished physical
functioning and health-related quality of life (HRQoL). Although these relationships
are well described in adults with PAH, they are not fully characterized in pediatric
populations. METHODS: Children (aged 1–17 years) with PAH received 16 weeks
of randomized, double-blind treatment with sildenafil citrate or placebo. The primary
outcome measure, peak VO2 (PVO2), assessed cardiopulmonary exercise capacity in
children developmentally capable of exercise. Secondary measures (for all patients)
included mean pulmonary arterial pressure (mPAP), pulmonary vascular resistance
index (PVRI), cardiac index (CI), and the Child Health Questionnaire-Parent Form
(CHQ). Cumulative distribution functions (CDFs) plotted the cumulative percentage
of patients against percentage changes (and also numeric changes) from baseline to
week 16 in outcome measures. RESULTS: Of 234 randomized and treated children,
106 were developmentally able to exercise; 148 to 221 provided non-exercise endpoint
data. Descriptive separation between CDFs was evident for sildenafil versus placebo
for percentage changes in PVO2, mPAP, PVRI, and CI. For example, 58 of 77 (75%)
sildenafil-treated children had increases in the percentage change in PVO2 versus 13
of 29 (45%) placebo-treated children. Descriptive separation between CDFs was not
evident for CHQ domains of physical function, bodily pain, behavior, general health,
and parental impact-time. Across all measures, an identical pattern of response profiles
was obtained when numeric (rather than percentage) changes were assessed. CONCLUSIONS: Cumulative distribution functions, which incorporate the entire distribution of responses, can enhance clinical interpretation of outcome measures. The
distribution of responses on PVO2, mPAP, PVRI, and CI for sildenafil was descriptively
more favorable compared with placebo, suggesting that sildenafil improves exercise
capacity and hemodynamic function in children with PAH. Further research should
elucidate the impact of disease and treatment on HRQoL in pediatric PAH.
PCV18
COMPARISON OF MIXED DYSLIPIDEMIAS AMONG HIGH
CARDIOVASCULAR RISK PRIMARY CARE PATIENTS: RESULTS OF A
POOLED ANALYSIS OF PRIMULA DATA FROM CANADA, SPAIN,
SWEDEN, AND THE UNITED KINGDOM
Ambegaonkar BM1, Bash LD1, Jameson K2, Marentette M3, Nocea G4, Pettersson B5,
Sazonov V1
1
Merck & Co., Inc., Whitehouse Station, NJ, USA; 2MSD Ltd., Hoddesdon, UK; 3Merck Frost
Canada Ltd, Kirkland, QC, Canada; 4Merck Sharpe & Dohme Ltd, Madrid, Spain; 5MSD,
Sollentuna, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: Dyslipidemias involving elevated low-density lipoprotein cholesterol
(LDL-C), low high-density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL-C), and/or high triglycerides
are correlates of cardiovascular disease (CVD). The degree to which risk persists after
lipid modifying therapy (LMT), and varies between high risk populations, has not
been well explored. We compare the prevalence of dyslipidemias§ before and after
LMT among high CVD risk patients in clinical practice. METHODS: This is a pooled
analysis of four observational, longitudinal, studies (PRIMULA) of primary care
patients in Canada, Spain, Sweden, and the United Kingdom, ≥35 years old who initiated LMT and continued therapy for >12 months. Data are reported for a total of
12,768 high cardiovascular risk patients, more than half of whom had diabetes mellitus (DM), nearly a third with a history of CVD, and the remainder with a 10-year
Framingham risk score (FRS) >20%. RESULTS: The majority (>95%) received statin
monotherapy as their initial LMT. At baseline, those with a history of CVD had the
lowest, and those with FRS > 20% the greatest prevalence of elevated LDL-C, elevated
TG, low HDL-C and elevated LDL-C coupled with low HDL-C and/or elevated TG.
After 12 months of follow-up, all high risk groups demonstrated improved lipid
profiles, though only among those with FRS > 20% did HDL-C improve. Persistent
dyslipidemia was most rampant among those with a FRS > 20% and least among
A344
those with a history of CVD. CONCLUSIONS: In each subgroup, there was a substantial improvement in LDL-C, while improvement of TG and HDL-C levels were
moderate and negligible, respectively. Despite LMT, both single and mixed dyslipidemias were prevalent among high risk patients, particularly among those with DM
and even more so among those with FRS > 20%. While the prevalence and persistence
of dyslipidemia varied between groups, observations suggest that all may benefit from
other types of LMT in addition to statins.
PCV19
EFFECTIVENESS OF ANTIHYPERTENSIVE AGENTS IN THE SECONDARY
PREVENTION OF VASCULAR EVENTS AMONG PATIENTS WITH
ISCHEMIC STROKE
Perreault S1, Cote R2, Dragomir A1
1
Université de Montréal, Montréal, QC, Canada; 2McGill University, Montreal, QC, Canada
OBJECTIVES: Antihypertensive agents (AH) have been shown to reduce the risk of
major cardiovascular (CVD) events. However, there is no large scale effectiveness
studies which have assessed the relationship between adherence to AH medications
and major CVD outcomes in high risk individuals that have suffered an ischemic
stroke. The aim of the study was to evaluate the relationship between AH drug adherence and vascular outcomes in a cohort of older patients hospitalized for an ischemic
stroke and discharged in the community. METHODS: A cohort of 14,227 patients
with ischemic stroke was reconstructed from RAMQ and Med-Echo databases. Eligible subjects were 65 years and older and treated with AH agents between 1999 and
2007. A nested case-control design was used to study major CVD outcomes. Every
case was matched for age and duration of follow-up. The adherence to AH drugs was
measured as the proportion of days’ supply of medication dispensed over a defined
period. Conditional logistic regression models were used to estimate the rate ratio of
vascular events adjusting for covariables. RESULTS: Mean patient age was 75 years,
54% were male, 23% had diabetes, and 47% had dyslipidemia, 38% had CAD, 6%
MI and 14% had atrial fibrillation. Adherence to AH agents ≥80% reduced the risk
of vascular events (RR: 0.70; 0.64–0.77) compared to the one of <80%. Male gender,
prior CVD, and non adherence to therapies for diabetes and dyslipidemia were risk
factors. CONCLUSIONS: Higher adherence to AH therapy is linked with a risk
reduction of vascular events among patients with ischemic stroke.
PCV20
COMPLIANCE WITH ANTIHYPERTENSIVE AGENTS AND THE ONSET
OF END-STAGE RENAL DISEASE
Perreault S, Roy L, Lessard M, Dragomir A
Université de Montréal, Montréal, QC, Canada
OBJECTIVES: The correlation between severity of hypertension and risk of end-stage
renal disease (ESRD) is well known. However, the impact of antihypertensive drug
adherence on primary prevention of chronic kidney disease (CKD) has never been
assessed. Our objective was to evaluate the impact of better adherence to antihypertensive (AH) therapy on ESRD. METHODS: A cohort of 208,128 patients was
reconstructed using RAMQ and MedEcho databases. Patients were eligible if they
were between 45 to 85 years of age, had a new diagnosis of hypertension and were
newly treated with AH drug between 1999 and 2007. a nested case-control design
was used to study the occurrence of ESRD. Every case of ESRD was matched for age
and duration of follow-up. Adherence level was assessed as a medication possession
ratio. Conditional logistic regression models were used to estimate the rate ratio of
ESRD adjusting for several covariables. RESULTS: Patients were at 65 years old and
42% male. The mean high adherence level (80%) to AH therapy was 90%. We identified 1026 cases with ESRD during follow-up. High adherence level (80%) to AH
therapy compared to lower adherence level (<80%) was associated with a reduction
of ESRD (RR: 0.81; 0.70–0.95). Risk factors for ESRD were CKD, gout, diabetes,
coronary artery disease, chronic heart failure and peripheral vascular disease. CONCLUSIONS: The study suggests that better adherence to AH therapy is associated
with risk reduction of new onset ESRD in hypertensive population.
PCV21
THE RELATIVE EFFECTIVENESS PROFILE OF DRONEDARONE USING
THE NUMBER NEEDED TO TREAT (NNT) APPROACH
de Sauvebeuf C1, Chicoye A1, Hohnloser S2
1
IMS Health, Puteaux, France; 2J.W. Goethe University Hospital, Frankfurt, Germany
Dronedarone is a new antiarrhythmic drug developed for the treatment of atrial fibrillation (AF). While numerous large cardiovascular (CV) clinical trials have assessed the
efficacy of different compounds on morbidity and mortality endpoints, dronedarone
is the first antiarrhythmic drug for AF for which a large randomized clinical trial
(ATHENA) was designed to assess morbidity/mortality endpoints. OBJECTIVES: To
perform an effectiveness analysis using the Number Needed to Treat (NNT) approach
to compare dronedarone with other CV drugs in avoiding major CV events (CV death,
CV hospitalization and stroke). METHODS: A literature search for 3 CV active
medications (statins, angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors, angiotensin receptor
blockers) was performed using PubMed from 1995 to present to identify clinical trials
with endpoints comparable to those of ATHENA. NNTs were calculated using hazard
ratios; different lengths of follow up were adjusted to one year, dividing each rate of
events by the study duration. RESULTS: Twenty clinical trials were identified as
having at least one endpoint comparable to ATHENA. Based on the ATHENA data,
the NNT per year of treatment with dronedarone to avoid one “CV death”, one “CV
hospitalization” and one stroke were 157, 11, and 172, respectively. Dronedarone
was associated with a lower NNT to avoid a “CV death” compared to ramipril
13th Euro Abstracts
(HOPE, NNT = 239), pravastatin (LIPID, NNT = 255), and simvastatin (HPS, NNT
= 325; 4S, NNT = 167), but a higher NNT vs. candesartan in selected chronic heart
failure patients (CHARM, NNT = 123). NNTs for dronedarone to avoid one “CV
hospitalization” and one stroke compared favorably to the other medications evaluated. CONCLUSIONS: Pressure on health care budgets emphasizes the need to demonstrate medical value, notably through NNTs which enable comparisons across
interventions. Dronedarone has morbidity/mortality data (“CV death”, “CV hospitalizations” and stroke) that compares favorably in terms of NNT to other CV therapies
within their respective trial patient populations.
PCV22
THE INFLUENCE OF METEOROLOGICAL FACTORS ON CEREBRAL
INFARCTION, INTRACEREBRAL HEMORRHAGE, SUBARACHNOID
HEMORRHAGE AND TRANSIENT ISCHEMIC ATTACK
Kriszbacher I1, Csoboth I1, Fülöp A2, Boncz I1, Köhalmi A1, Müller Á1, Bódis J1
1
University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary; 2National Meteorological Service, Budapest, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: We have investigated, whether the time of onset of an acute cerebrovascular event demonstrates a seasonal variation, and whether it is influenced by
meteorological factors. METHODS: We examined patients admitted to Neurology
Departments in Hungary between 2005 and 2007 with the diagnose of cerebral infarction, intracerebral hemorrhage, subarachnoid hemorrhage or transient ischemic attack
(n = 178,092). Data was collected from the database of the Hungarian National Health
Insurance Fund based on the International Classification of Diseases. Meteorological
data was retrieved from the National Meteorology Service. RESULTS: Meteorological
analysis showed, that an increase in average temperature on the previous day resulted
in a significant drop of intracerebral hemorrhage incidence during Spring, Summer
and Autumn (P < 0.01), while in case of cerebral infarction such decrease only
occurred during Summer and Winter (P < 0.01), and for transient ischemic attack,
only during Summer (P < 0.01).Examining atmospheric pressure, we found variations
in case of cerebral infarction, intracerebral hemorrhage and transient ischemic attack.
Morbidity rates of cerebral infarction increased during Summer, and decreased during
Winter, whenever average atmospheric pressure values on the preceding day were
higher (P < 0.01). Decrease in morbidity rates was observed for intracerebral hemorrhage and transient ischemic attack (P < 0.01). Considering relative humidity on the
previous day, a marked variation showed for cerebral infarction during Spring (P <
0.01), and for intracerebral hemorrhage during Summer (P < 0.01). No relationship
was found with subarachnoid hemorrhage. CONCLUSIONS: Results reveal, that the
occurrence cerebrovascular events shows typical variations depending on the season
of the year, while certain meteorological factors influence the development these also.
PCV23
DISCONTINUATION OF LOW-DOSE ACETYLSALICYLIC ACID
TREATMENT FOR SECONDARY PREVENTION OF CARDIOVASCULAR
OUTCOMES: INCIDENCE AND PREDICTORS
García Rodríguez LA1, Martín-Merino E1, Johansson S2
1
Spanish Centre for Pharmacoepidemiological Research (CEIFE), Madrid, Spain; 2AstraZeneca
R&D, Mölndal, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: To assess what proportion of patients treated with low-dose acetylsalicylic acid (ASA) for secondary prevention of cardiovascular events discontinue this
treatment, and to identify risk factors for discontinuation. METHODS: The Health
Improvement Network UK primary care database was used to identify individuals
aged 50–84 years with ≥2 prescriptions of low-dose ASA (75–300 mg/day) in 2000–
2007 (n = 35,639). The study cohort was followed from the first day after the initial
prescription until the earliest occurrence of one of the following: ASA discontinuation
(a period of ≥90 days after the last prescription would have been used up [assuming
full compliance], with no refill of the prescription during this time); death; diagnosis
of an alcohol-related condition or cancer; or the end of the study period. The mean
follow-up time was 2.5 years. RESULTS: Almost one-third of patients discontinued
low-dose ASA (n = 11,729; incidence: 13.1 per 100 person-years; 95% confidence
interval [CI]: 12.9–13.4). The incidence of discontinuation was higher in the first year
of follow-up (26.7 per 100 person-years; 95% CI: 26.1–27.3) than the rest of the
study period (6.8 per 100 person-years; 95% CI: 6.6–7.0). The risk of discontinuation
was 42–67% higher in patients with an initial indication of unstable angina, ischemic
heart disease or cerebrovascular disease than those with an initial indication of myocardial infarction. Current use of proton pump inhibitors (PPIs) was associated with
a significant reduction in the risk of discontinuation (odds ratio [OR]: 0.92; 95% CI:
0.87–0.98; compared with no PPI use). Individuals taking PPIs from the same time as
their ASA treatment were at particularly low risk of ASA discontinuation (OR: 0.74;
95% CI: 0.69–0.79). CONCLUSIONS: Discontinuation of low-dose ASA treatment
is common, especially in the first year of treatment. Concomitant PPI use reduces the
risk of ASA discontinuation.
PCV24
AN EPIDEMIOLOGICAL EVALUATION OF THE IMPACT OF
PERCUTANEOUS CORONARY INTERVENTIONS ON THE LENGTH OF
STAY AND MORTALITY OF PATIENTS HOSPITALIZED WITH ACUTE
CORONARY SYNDROMES
Chevalier P, Lamotte M
IMS Health Consulting, Brussels, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: Randomized clinical trial comparing percutaneous coronary interventions (PCI) and non-invasive treatment acute coronary syndromes mostly favour the
13th Euro Abstracts
invasive approach. The aim of this study was to assess whether in a real life setting
performing acute PCI would have an impact on outcomes as length of stay (LOS) and
mortality in patients hospitalized for acute coronary syndromes in Belgium.
METHODS: The average length of stay (LOS) and mortality among hospitalized
patients with acute coronary syndrome were estimated using the longitudinal IMS
Hospital Disease Database (year 2007), including data on 34.3% of Belgian hospital
beds. Stays were identified based on ICD-9 coding and split in ST-elevated Myocardial
infarction (STEMI ICD-9: 410 excluding 410.7), non-STEMI (ICD-9: 410.7-411.89)
and unstable angina (ICD-9: 411.1-411.8-413.0). Invasive procedures were identified
with ICD-9 codes corresponding to PCI (36.0). First stays in the calendar year were
examined. Comparisons were performed using a Wilcoxon non-parametrical test for
LOS and a Chi-square for mortality rates. RESULTS: In first hospitalizations, 3,420
STEMI, 2,070 non-STEMI and 954 unstable anginas were retrieved from the database,
with respectively 1,206, 504 and 28 of them being treated invasively. LOS of patients
undergoing PCI was significantly lower in STEMI (6.0 vs. 9.5 days; P < 0.001) and
non-STEMI (5.1 vs. 9.5; P < 0.001). Mortality in patients with PCI was lower in both
STEMI (3.5% vs. 17.2%; P < 0.001) and non-STEMI (0.8% vs. 6.2%; P < 0.001).
Although LOS and mortality in non-invasively treated patients were lower in hospitals
without a cathlab compared to hospitals with a cathlab, both parameters were significantly higher compared to PCI treated patients. CONCLUSIONS: Although information on the baseline characteristics of the different patients is limited, the findings of
this observational study seem to support randomized clinical trials. Treatment with
PCI decreases the LOS and the mortality significantly in patients with a myocardial
infarction.
A345
was respectively equal to 51 and 75 within the 2 subgroups, resulting in an incidence
of 0.54% in patients with hip replacement and 1.07% in patients with knee replacement. LOS of patients with a DVT/PE episode was more than twice as high after both
hip (34.2 vs. 15.9 days; P < 0.001) and knee (24.9 vs. 12.0 days; P < 0.001) replacement. CONCLUSIONS: The incidences of symptomatic DVT and PE reported in
clinical trials could be confirmed based on this retrospective search. The occurrence
of DVT/PE doubles LOS in patients undergoing hip or knee surgery.
PCV27
INCREASING PREVALENCE OF HYPERTENSION IN NIGERIA: A
SYSTEMATIC REVIEW FROM 1990 TO 2009
Ekwunife O, Aguwa CN
University of Nigeria, Nsukka, Enugu, Nigeria
OBJECTIVES: This study aimed at synthesizing population-based studies on prevalence of hypertension in Nigeria from 1990 to 2009. METHODS: Cochrane library
and PubMed were searched for similar reviews using filters for systematic review.
General databases as well as subject-specific databases were searched for primary
studies. Manuscripts of appropriate studies were retrieved. Quality assessment scale
was developed to assess the retrieved manuscript and only eligible studies were
selected. Formal meta-analysis was not conducted due to heterogeneity of data.
RESULTS: A total of 55 abstracts were identified, out of which 10 full manuscripts
were retrieved and used for systematic review. There was an increasing trend in prevalence of hypertension. Hypertension prevalence in rural areas increased from 18.7%
in 2003 to 22.4% in 2007. In urban areas, it increased from 23.4% in 1997 to 27.1%
in 2007. In studies that combined both rural and urban populations, prevalence of
hypertension increased from 14.5% in 1994 to 34.8% in 2003. There was gender
difference with respect to prevalence of hypertension as males had higher prevalence
of hypertension compare to females. CONCLUSIONS: Prevalence of hypertension
seems to be on the increase in Nigeria. There is a need to develop strategies to prevent,
treat, and control hypertension effectively in Nigeria.
PCV25
RISK OF STROKE AND PREVENTATIVE STEPS AMONG PATIENTS
DIAGNOSED WITH ATRIAL FIBRILLATION IN EUROPE
Gupta S1, Goren A2, Freedman D1
1
Kantar Health, Princeton, NJ, USA; 2Kantar Health, New York, NY, USA
OBJECTIVES: This study examined stroke risk and prevention among European
patients diagnosed with atrial fibrillation (AF). METHODS: Data were extracted from
the European 2008 National Health and Wellness Survey, an annual Internet survey
of self-reported health care attitudes and behaviors among 52,524 adults in Germany,
Spain, Italy, the UK, and France. Stroke risk was assessed with CHADS2, an index
summing the presence of congestive heart failure, hypertension, age of 75 years+,
diabetes mellitus, and history of prior stroke or transient ischemic attack (the latter
weighted twice). Low- (CHADS2 = 0), moderate- (1), and high- (2+) risk patients
reported on what steps, if any, they took to prevent stroke: low fat or low sodium
diet, regular exercise, smoking cessation, weight loss, blood pressure or cholesterol
reduction, and use of baby aspirin, aggrenox, coumadin/warfarin, plavix, or other
medications. RESULTS: Among 508 respondents diagnosed with AF (EU prevalence
of 0.97%), 198 (39%) were low, 158 (31.1%) moderate, and 152 (29.9%) high in
risk for stroke. Significant differences emerged in the use of any preventative steps
among low- (23.7%), moderate- (35.4%), and high- (57.2%) risk patients, P < 0.05.
High-risk patients were significantly more likely than the low-risk group to take every
preventative step except exercise—16.2% (low), 17.7% (moderate), 20.4% (high)—
and aspirin use—11.1% (low), 13.3% (moderate), 15.8% (high). For example, coumadin/warfarin use was higher among high- (21.1%) vs. moderate- (8.9%) and
low-risk (3.0%) patients, P < 0.05. CONCLUSIONS: In the EU, 42.8% of diagnosed
AF patients at high risk for stroke took no preventative steps, and no significant differences emerged between risk groups on regular exercise and aspirin use. Only 1 in
5 high-risk patients took coumadin/warafin, while many more could benefit from
prophylactic anticoagulation therapy. Higher risk correlated with higher prevention,
but there remains an unmet need for increased targeted treatment of high-risk AF
patients.
PCV28
CARDIOVASCULAR RISK FACTORS AMONG ASIAN INDIAN AND
WHITE ADULTS IN THE UNITED STATES
Mcdonald M, Zhou J, Rubinstein E, Mardekian J
Pfizer Inc, New York, NY, USA
OBJECTIVES: Current prevalence of cardiovascular risk factors are lacking among
Asian Indian adults. This study contributes to our knowledge by examining current
national estimates for hypertension, high cholesterol, diabetes and obesity among
Asian Indian and white adults aged 20 years and older, by gender and age group.
METHODS: Cross-sectional observational study design. Analysis of adults 20 years
and older surveyed in the National Health Interview Surveys (NHIS 2006–2008)
(Asian Indian, n = 707, white, n = 51,769). RESULTS: The age-standardized prevalence of hypertension among Asian Indian adults is 21%, significantly lower than the
27% prevalence among white adults. At 27%, high cholesterol is equally prevalent in
both populations. Diabetes is more prevalent among Asian Indian adults (15% vs.
7%). Asian Indian men have more than twice the rate of diabetes as white men, (17%
vs.7%), and Asian Indians aged 65 years and older have a higher prevalence of diabetes than older, white adults (28% vs. 17%). Obesity rates for Asian Indian adults
aged 20–39, 40–64, and 65+ are 10%, 16%, and 16%, respectively. Obesity rates for
white adults aged 20–39, 40–64, and 65+ are 26%, 34%, and 27%, respectively (p
< 0.0001 for all but 65+ obesity differences). CONCLUSIONS: The age-standardized
prevalence rate of high cholesterol is similar among Asian Indian and white adults.
Hypertension rates are lower among Asian Indians. The prevalence of diabetes is
higher in the Asian Indian population, disproportionately affecting men and older
adults. Targeted approaches for diabetes disease treatment and reduction are needed.
PCV26
AN EPIDEMIOLOGICAL EVALUATION OF THE INCIDENCE OF DEEP
VENOUS THROMBOSIS AND PULMONARY EMBOLISM IN PATIENTS
WITH HIP OR KNEE REPLACEMENT SURGERY AND OF ITS IMPACT ON
THE AVERAGE LENGTH OF STAY
Chevalier P, Lamotte M
IMS Health Consulting, Brussels, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: Recent clinical trials on the new anti-thrombotic agents have shown
that the incidence of symptomatic deep venous thrombosis (DVT) and pulmonary
embolism (PE) in patients undergoing hip or knee replacement ranges between 0.5
and 2%. This study aimed at assessing the real life incidence of DVT/PE after major
orthopaedic surgery in Belgian and the impact of these complications on the length
of stay based on a hospital disease database. METHODS: The incidence of DVT/PE
and the average length of stay (LOS) among patients hospitalized for hip or knee
replacement surgery were estimated using the longitudinal IMS Hospital Disease
Database (year 2007), including data on 34.3% of Belgian hospital beds. Stays were
searched based on ICD-9-CM codes corresponding to hip replacement (81.51-81.5281.53) and knee replacement (81.54-81.55). Occurrence of DVT/PE was identified
with ICD-9 codes 451.1-451.2-453.4. It was also checked whether selected patients
were administered low-molecular-weight heparin (LMWH). The impact of a DVT/PE
complication on LOS was assessed through a Wilcoxon non-parametrical test.
RESULTS: A total of 9377 stays with hip replacement and 6,978 stays with knee
replacement were retrieved in the database. More than 99.9% of the patients were
administered LMWH in both subgroups. The number of stays with a DVT/PE episode
PCV29
PREVALENCE, CHARACTERISTICS, AND IN-HOSPITAL OUTCOMES OF
METABOLIC SYNDROME IN ACUTE CORONARY DISEASE PATIENTS IN
OMAN
Al-Zakwani IS1, Al-Rasadi K1, Sulaiman K2, Panduranga P2
1
Sultan Qaboos University, Al-Khoudh, Oman; 2Royal Hospital, Muscat, Oman
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the prevalence, characteristics, and in-hospital outcomes
of metabolic syndrome (MS) in acute coronary syndrome (ACS) patients in Oman.
METHODS: Data were analyzed from 1,392 consecutive patients admitted to 15
hospitals throughout Oman with the final diagnosis of ACS during May 8, 2006 to
June 6, 2006 and January 29, 2007 to June 29, 2007, as part of Gulf RACE (Registry
of Acute Coronary Events). MS was defined, as stipulated by the recent ATP-III
guidelines, as having 3 or more of the following abnormalities: waist circumference
of ≥94 cm for men and ≥80 cm for women, high triglyceride levels (of ≥150 mg/dL
(1.7 mmol/L) or drug treatment), low high density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL-C)
levels (of <40 mg/dL (1.0 mmol/L) for men and <50 mg/dL (1.3 mmol/L) for females
or drug treatment), blood pressure (of ≥130 mmHg for systolic and/or ≥85 mmHg for
diastolic or drug treatment), and blood sugar (of ≥100 mg/dL (≥5.6 mmol/L) or drug
treatment). RESULTS: The overall prevalence rate of MS in ACS patients in Oman
was 66% with females being the majority (80% versus 57%; P < 0.001). MS was
associated with higher median body mass index scores (27 versus 24; P < 0.001),
diabetics (45% versus 19%; P < 0.001), hyperlipidemia (40% versus 23%; P < 0.001),
hypertension (62% versus 34%; P < 0.001), renal impairment (9.3% versus 3.4%; P
< 0.001), killip score >II (13% versus 8%; p = 0.004) and non-ST segment elevation
A346
myocardial infarction (78% versus 68%; P < 0.001). Even after multivariate adjustment, MS was still associated with higher risk of in-hospital heart failure (odds ratio
(OR), 1.37; 95% CI: 1.03–1.81; p = 0.028) and mortality (OR, 4.42; 95% CI:
1.25–15.5; p = 0.020). CONCLUSIONS: Prevalence of MS in ACS patients in Oman
is high and seen more in females than in males. Furthermore, MS was associated with
higher in-hospital heart failure and mortality.
PCV30
PREVALENCE AND CONTROL OF TRADITIONAL CARDIOVASCULAR
RISK FACTORS AND ANTICIPATED AVOIDABLE CORONARY
MORTALITY IN PRIMARY PREVENTION IN EUROPE: THE EURIKA
STUDY
Banegas JR1, Guallar E2, Borghi C3, Dallongeville J4, De Backer G5, Halcox JP6,
Massó-González EL7, Perk J8, Steg PG9, Rodríguez-Artalejo F1
1
Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Madrid, Spain; 2Welch Center for Prevention,
Epidemiology, and Clinical Research, Baltimore, MD, USA; 3Policlinico Universitario
Sant’Orsola, Bologna, Italy; 4Institut Pasteur de Lille, Lille, France; 5University of Gent, Gent,
Belgium; 6Cardiff University, Cardiff, UK; 7AstraZeneca Farmacéutica Spain S.A, Madrid, Spain;
8
Oskarshamns Hospital, Oskarshamn, Sweden; 9Université Paris VII—Denis Diderot, Paris,
France
OBJECTIVES: Despite the availability of the ESC European guidelines on cardiovascular prevention, considerable cardiovascular mortality remains throughout Europe.
The European Study on Cardiovascular Risk Prevention and Management in Daily
Practice (EURIKA) (NCT00882336) investigated the prevalence and degree of control
of main cardiovascular risk factors in primary prevention of cardiovascular disease
(CVD). METHODS: EURIKA was a cross-sectional study conducted simultaneously
in 12 European countries (n = 809 primary care and specialist physicians). Patients
aged ≥50 years who were free of clinical CVD, but had at least one risk factor as
defined by the 2007 European guidelines on cardiovascular prevention, were eligible
for inclusion. Data recorded included smoking status, body mass index, cholesterol
levels, blood pressure and presence of diabetes. Cardiovascular risk was assessed by
Systematic COronary Risk Evaluation (SCORE) methods. Attributable coronary mortality was calculated based on our prevalence estimates together with hazard ratios
for CVD-related mortality (from the Third National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey). RESULTS: In total, 7641 patients (mean age: 65 years; 48% male) were
evaluated. Of those aged <65 years, 27% had a SCORE-based absolute risk of CVD
of ≥5%. The prevalence of risk factors was 21.3% for current smoking, 71.9% for
hypertension, 55.4% for dyslipidemia, and 26.6% for diabetes. Control of risk factors
among patients receiving therapy was 49% (between country range: 40–61%) for
hypertension, 48% (26–74%) for dyslipidaemia and 40% (26–54%) for diabetes. The
adjusted excess mortality attributable to risk factors was 17% (14–25%) for current
smoking, 23% (21–25%) for hypertension, 26% (17–31%) for dyslipidaemia, and
30% (20–37%) for diabetes. CONCLUSIONS: The prevalence of traditional cardiovascular risk factors is high and their control is suboptimal. Traditional risk factors
such as hypertension, dyslipidaemia and diabetes are responsible for a large fraction
of the estimated coronary deaths that could be avoided through primary prevention.
PCV31
BLOOD PRESSURE CONTROL AND ANTIHYPERTENSIVE STRATEGY
DIFFERENCES ACCORDING TO PATIENTS AGE
Font B1, Galera J1, Lahoz R1, Muñoz G1, Sierra C2, Doménech M2, Coca A2
1
Novartis Pharma, Barcelona, Spain; 2Hospital Clínic de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: This study aims to determine the degree of blood pressure (BP) control
and the differences in therapeutic strategies adopted by physicians based on patients’
age and/or their functional status. METHODS: Multicenter and cross-sectional study
that included patients with essential hypertension attending primary or specialist care,
with at least one year of evolution. The study included 6453 patients, stratified into
three main groups: a (<65 years) = 2184; B (65–79 years) = 2079; and C (≥80 years)
= 2079. RESULTS: 51.3% of patients were male and mean (SD) age was 55.1 ± 7.5
years (group A), 71.4 ± 4.0 (B) and 83.7 ± 3.2 (C). 49.1% of patients were overweight.
Mean systolic BP values were 141.3 ± 15.6 (A), 142.0 ± 16.3 (B) and 142.3 ± 16.8
(C) mmHg, and mean diastolic BP values were 84.5 ± 10.1 (A), 81.5 ± 10.5, 79.9 ±
11.2 (C) mmHg. 33.5% of patients had type 2 diabetes mellitus and 59.1% dyslipidemia. The existence of previous cardiovascular (CVD) or renal disease has been
established in 38.9% of cases. The prevalence of CVD was 22.6% (A), 39.1% (B) and
55.9% (C). Target organ damage (TOD) was 26.7% (A), 40.8% (B) and 57.8% (C).
The Barthel index that measures a person’s daily functioning reflected that the oldest
group had a significantly higher level of moderate or severe dependence (P < 0.0001).
Patients with controlled BP were 29.4% (A), 25.5% (B) and 23.7% (C) (P < 0.0001).
Clinical inertia—the failure to intensify therapy in patients who do not achieve the
clinical objectives—reached 60.3% (A), 61.7% (B) and 66.2% (C) (p = 0.0002),
respectively. Global treatment compliance was 94.3%, and the difficulty for taking
the medication significantly increased with patients’ age (P < 0.0001). CONCLUSIONS: Older hypertensive patients have a poorer BP control but an increased clinical
inertia. These patients have higher prevalence of TOD and CVD, worse functional
status and worse treatment compliance.
13th Euro Abstracts
CARDIOVASCULAR DISORDERS – Cost Studies
PCV32
BUDGET IMPACT ANALYSIS OF PACLITAXEL DRUG ELUTING STENT
(DES) FOR THE TREATMENT OF LOWER LIMB PERIPHERAL ARTERIAL
DISEASE (PAD) IN FRANCE
Lopes S1, De Cock E2
1
Cook Medical, Bjaeverskov, Denmark; 2United BioSource Corporation, Barcelona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: The self-expandable paclitaxel DES represents a major development in
endovascular treatments for lower limb PAD. Clinical data show improved clinical
outcomes compared to bare metal stents (BMS). This budget impact analysis assessed
the impact of introducing reimbursement for a paclitaxel DES in France. METHODS:
An Excel-based model was developed to estimate the impact of a transition from BMS
to DES over a 5-year horizon (15% in 2011 to 35% in 2015). Hospital episode statistics were used to estimate the 2011–2015 patient population. The analysis was
conducted from the payer perspective and only direct costs of procedures were considered, based on GHM 2009 tariffs (stenting and revascularization) and LPPR tariffs
(BMS and grafts). The main outcome was target lesion revascularization (TLR) in the
superficial femoral artery (SFA) after primary stent placement: angioplasty, re-stenting,
or bypass surgery. TLR rates were based on the paclitaxel drug-eluting SFA stent
registry study and on BMS TLR rates reported in the literature (Years 1 and 2: 6%
and 9% for the DES; 16% and 22% for average BMS) and extrapolated for years 3
to 5. Net budget impact was expressed as the difference in cost between the scenario
where the DES is progressively adopted versus the status quo (patients treated with
BMS only). RESULTS: The base-case results show an incremental cost of c278,526
in year 1, which is more than offset by increasing cost savings in all subsequent years
(year 2: −c35,901; year 5: −c510,025), resulting in a cumulative 5-year net budget
impact of −c727,649. One-way sensitivity analyses on key inputs continued to show
cumulative 5-year cost savings. CONCLUSIONS: Reimbursement and consequent
adoption of the paclitaxel DES would result in cost savings for the French health care
payer, despite requiring an initial investment. This is due to savings associated with
fewer SFA revascularization events after the primary intervention.
PCV33
ESTIMATING THE FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS TO THE UK NHS OF
INTRODUCING COREVALVE ALONGSIDE MEDICAL MANAGEMENT
FOR THE TREATMENT OF SEVERE AORTIC STENOSIS
Watt M, Mealing S, Sculpher M, Eaton JN
Oxford Outcomes Ltd, Oxford, Oxon, UK
OBJECTIVES: Aortic Stenosis (AS) is a severe cardiovascular condition and treatment
often involves a major operation. For a subgroup of patients medical management
(MM) is the only treatment option due to procedural risk. A transcatheter aortic valve
implantation device “CoreValve,” is less invasive and allows for the implantation of
a replacement valve in this patient group. However, CoreValve is more expensive than
MM and introducing this technology into routine care would lead to an increase in
National Health Service (NHS) spending. We estimated this budgetary impact using
existing economic models. METHODS: In an Excel based Markov model CoreValve
was compared to MM for inoperable patients. Parameters were derived from published literature. Costs were taken from the most recent published sources. Decrements
were applied to age-specific EQ-5D population norms to generate QALYs. Incidence
estimates were derived from information in a large national database. Projected five
year uptake rates were provided by Medtronic. The outputs from the economic model
were used for all relevant parameters. Case mix estimates were elicited from a clinical
advisory board. RESULTS: Across all patients, the estimated incidence rate of AS was
165 per million, 40% of these patients were assumed to be inoperable, 66 per million.
The uptake rate of CoreValve in the inoperable group rose linearly from 0% to 50%
over 5 years. When all inoperable patients were treated with MM the total budgetary
cost was £13,454,000. When 50% of patients are treated with CoreValve and 50%
with MM, the total budgetary cost increases to £49,706,000. Thus, the total burden
to the NHS of 50% of inoperable patients receiving CoreValve would be £36,251,000.
With a more optimistic five year uptake rate (75%) this increases to £54,852,000.
CONCLUSIONS: Introducing CoreValve would result in an additional £36,251,000
being spent by the UK NHS.
PCV34
BUDGET IMPACT ANALYSIS OF PRIMARY TREATMENT OF
HYPERTENSION WITH CANDESARTAN/HYDROCHLOROTHIAZIDE OR
LOSARTAN/HYDROCHLOROTHIAZIDE IN THE MEXICAN SOCIAL
SECURITY INSTITUTE
Anaya P, López RJ, Polanco AC
AstraZeneca, Naucalpan, Mexico
OBJECTIVES: To calculate and compare costs of primary treatment of hypertension
with candesartan/hydrochlorothiazide (HCT) or losartan/HCT in the Mexican Social
Security Institute (IMSS). METHODS: An adaptation from Kjeldsen observational
study of 14,100 patients diagnosed with hypertension and the costs’ sub analysis of
Henriksson was made to have an approximation of incurred costs by IMSS when using
candesartan/HCT or losartan/HCT in the primary hypertension treatment and its
impact in reducing related cardiovascular events. First assumption for adaptation was
to use only costs of combined therapies with HCT since monotherapies are not
included in the IMSS formulary. Hospitalizations, laboratory tests and physician visits
resource consumption reported by Kjeldsen were multiplied by IMSS 2010 unit costs.
13th Euro Abstracts
An average of 3.35 years follow-up was used. IMSS population with hypertension was
estimated using the national prevalence of 30.8% (20 years and older) reported by
the National Health Survey of 2006, the proportion (70%) of the Mexican population
over 20 years old reported by the National Population Council and the number of
total IMSS affiliates. a 5% discount rate was applied to costs. Results are presented
in US dollars (exchange rate 13 MXN/dollar). RESULTS: Primary hypertension
annual treatment cost per patient including related cardiovascular events was $556.56
for patients treated with candesartan/HCT and $718.42 with losartan/HCT treatment.
Theoretical savings yield by candesartan/HCT are $161.86 per patient. Calculated
hypertension patients affiliated to the IMSS was 10 million. Average annual savings
given this population are $1.707 million for the institution with 1.8 million bed days,
4.4 million physician visits and 5.3 million laboratory tests avoided. CONCLUSIONS:
This analysis showed that the reduction of cardiovascular events with the use of
candesartan/HCT for treating primary hypertension could save $1.707 million to the
IMSS.
PCV35
THE BUDGET IMPACT ANALYSIS OF AMBRISENTAN IN 2ND LINE
TREATMENT OF ADULT PATIENTS WITH IDIOPATHIC, FAMILIAR OR
ASSOCIATED WITH CONNECTIVE TISSUE DISEASE PULMONARY
HYPERTENSION OF III NYHA STAGE
Kawalec P1, Holko P2, Krzyzanowska A3, Glogowski C3
1
Jagiellonian University, Kraków, Poland; 2Centrum HTA, Krakow, Poland; 3GSK Commercial
Sp. z o.o., Warsaw, Poland
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the costs of ambrisentan within therapeutic health
program in 2nd phase line treatment of adult patients with idiopathic, familiar or
associated with connective tissue disease pulmonary hypertension of III NYHA stage.
METHODS: The analysis compared two scenarios: existing and new. The existing
one assumed application of bosentan, iloprost, treprostinil or sildenafil in patients with
pulmonary hypertension of III NYHA stage in case of 1st line treatment with bosentan
or sildenafil failure. The new one included also administration of ambrisentan. Population’s abundance and market shares of drugs used in presented indication were estimated on the basis of PHPOL Registry. Cost data were collected from public payer’s
perspective (National Health Fund) in Poland and calculated in five years horizon.
Official ex factore price of Volibris® was provided by the producer. Cost analysis was
performed under assumption that ambrisentan would be financed within the framework of Catalogue of active substances used in therapeutic health programs. a range
of variables was checked in a sensitivity analysis. RESULTS: Introduction of ambrisentan to Catalogue of active substances used in therapeutic health programs and
administration in 2nd line treatment of adult patients with idiopathic, familiar or
associated with connective tissue disease pulmonary hypertension of III NYHA stage
brought savings from public payer’s perspective amounted to: 178,782PLN
(64,719PLN–342,497PLN) in first year, 385,054PLN (132,673PLN–769,277PLN) in
second year, 614,006PLN (203,224PLN–1,266,372PLN) in third year, 646,137PLN
(206,854PLN–1 366,336PLN) in fourth year and 674,573PLN (210,053PLN–
1,455,310PLN) in fifth following year. CONCLUSIONS: Treatment with ambrisentan
leads to savings from public payer’s perspective and constitutes substantial therapeutic
achievement (it is administered orally and only once a day unlike other drugs currently
used in presented indication).
PCV36
BUDGET IMPACT MODEL OF VENOUS THROMBOEMBOLISM
PREVENTION AFTER TOTAL HIP AND KNEE REPLACEMENT
Krysanov I1, Margieva A2, Omelyanovsky VV1, Malygina MA3
1
Research Center for Clinical and Economic Evaluation and Pharmacoeconomics, Moscow,
Russia; 2Institute of Clinico-Economic Expertise and Pharmacoeconomics, RSMU, Moscow,
Russia; 3Research institute of ambulance n.a. Sklifosovsky, Moscow, Russia
OBJECTIVES: The purpose of this study was to perform comparative pharmacoeconomic analysis of antithrombotic therapy with rivaroxaban (Xarelto®) and enoxaparin (Clexane®) in the conditions of real clinical practice of total hip (THR) and knee
(TKR) replacement. METHODS: The method of budget impact modeling was used.
RESULTS: At equal duration of venous thromboembolism (VTE) prophylaxis at THR
(35 days) rivaroxaban turned out to be more budget saving than enoxaparin by 2399
RUB (62.71c), reducing the quantity of complications cases (pulmonary embolism,
deep venous thrombosis, death) by 26 cases per one thousand patients. At various
duration of prophylaxis at THR—rivaroxaban (35 days) and enoxaparin (14 days)—
rivaroxaban application has also demonstrated budget savings by 100 RUB(2.63c)
thus reducing the quantity of complications by 74 cases per one thousand patients.
The results of comparison of two weeks VTE prophylaxis after TKR have shown the
most sizeable economy after rivaroxaban application by 7734 RUB(202.164c) and
simultaneous complications decrease by 92 cases per one thousand patients. CONCLUSIONS: Rivaroxaban demonstrated budget savings compared to enoxaparin at
all prophylaxis regiments at THR and TKR by reducing thrombosis complications.
A347
PCV37
BURDEN IMPACT OF ATRIAL FIBRILLATION (AF BI) IN RUSSIAN
FEDERATION
Kolbin A1, Tatarsky B2, Biserova I2
1
Saint Petersburg State University, Saint Petersburg, Russia; 2Almazov Federal Heart, Blood
and Endocrinology Centre, Saint Petersburg, Russia
OBJECTIVES: AF is a big problem of the Russian Health Care System because cardiovascular diseases are the leaders in the structure of morbidity and mortality. Systemic
statistics of AF and AF BI are unknown. Aim: To calculate the AF BI based on regional
data and extrapolate the received data for Russia. METHODS: Evaluation of AF
incidence and prevalence in dynamic (1995–2005) in the North-West region of Russia,
calculation of direct and indirect costs and perspective modeling. RESULTS: As
estimation—AF prevalence in Russia is 3.2/1000, incidence is 1,766/100,000, paroxysmal and persistent AF are increased from 0.6 to 1.8 and 0.25 to 0.6/1,000 accordingly. Hypertension (73%), ischemic hart disease (65.2%), diabetes (9%) occurred in
the first episode of AF. Hospitalization rate is increased by 66%, estimated rate is
1.23 mln. pts./year, and it’s length is 6.9 days on the average, AF lethality is 1%.
Disability rate is 40%, estimated amount of disability days is 3.3 mln/year. Calculated
hospitalization cost for one year is 11.35 bln RUR (~c298 mln), cost for out-patients’
day-service—29.6 mln RUR (~c778 ths) and cost of out-patient treatment for all
patients is no less than 32.5 bln RUR (c855 mln) including drugs cost—19.6 bln RUR
(Euro). Estimated surgery cost is 260 mln RUR (c6.8 mln). Undirected adjusted cost
is no less than 3 bln RUR (~c80 mln). CONCLUSIONS: AF BI in the Russian Federation leads to the biggest governmental, insurance and personal expenditures as compared to the developed countries. Annual BI AF without deficiancial GDP per person
is no less than c5.5 ths. Decreasing of AF BI can be particularly achieved in case of a
better pharmaceutical control of AF aimed at saving budget charges due to the less
hospitalization and surgeon rates.
PCV38
CLINICAL AND ECONOMICAL BENEFITS OF THE USE OF REMOTE
MONITORING WITH CARELINK® IN CENTRO MÉDICO NACIONAL “LA
RAZA”, IMSS MEXICO
Guevara M1, Cerezo O2, Quiroz ME3, Machado F4, Busca R5
1
National Medical Center (Instituto Mexicano del seguro Social) La Raza, Mexico City, D.F.,
Mexico; 2Oncology National Institute, Mexico City, D.F., Mexico; 3Medtronic Mexico, Mexico
City, D.F., Mexico; 4Medtronic LA, Miami, FL, USA; 5Medtronic International Trading Sàrl,
Tolochenaz, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: The majority of cardiac device recipients are routinely followed.
Implantable Cardioverter Defibrillators (ICDs) devices must be systematically and
continually monitored, with follow-up frequency adjusted for the patient’s underlying
medical condition, device-related issues, and patient preferences. In México, in CMNIMSS La Raza, the current implant rate for ICD is 5 per million (equating to 30 new
implants per year) and every year an average of 180 patients implanted with ICD are
attending follow-up visits at La Raza hospital in Mexico. This simulation provides
evidence to support the use of remote follow up and monitoring of ICDs via the
CareLink Network as an alternative to follow-up consultations in attending an outpatient clinic setting. METHODS: The simulation considers patients implanted with
ICD (without CareLink) will on average require 4 in-clinic follow-up consultations
per year whilst those with CareLink will only require 1 in-clinic follow-up consultation
(4–6 weeks post implant) and 3 remote follow-up consultations. Reviewing patient
data provided via the CareLink Network (remote monitoring consultation) requires
an average 8.4 minutes of cardiac physiologist time compared to 25.8 minutes for an
in–clinic follow-up consultation. RESULTS: For each patient per year the introduction
of a remote monitor to support device follow-ups, lead to a reduction in cardiac
physiologist time of 52.2 minutes equivalent to $17,970 MXP ($30,686 MXP without
CareLink versus $12,716 MXP on CareLink). The cost of a cardiac physiologist time
is $2630.00 MXP (per hour) equating to MXP 368.20 per remote follow-up versus
$1130.90 MXP per in-clinic follow-up. CONCLUSIONS: The use of CareLink can
potentially generate economic benefits for the health professional, institution, health
system and the patient.
PCV39
CLINICAL OUTCOMES AND COSTS OF A POCKET-SIZED
ULTRASOUND DEVICE FOR SCREENING FOR ABDOMINAL AORTIC
ANEURYSM IN ITALY
Patel PA1, Shah M2, D’Souza AO3, Min JK4
1
GE Healthcare, Barrington, IL, USA; 2Xcenda, Palm Harbor, FL, USA; 3Xcenda, Cincinnati,
OH, USA; 4Weill Medical College of Cornell University, New York, NY, USA
OBJECTIVES: To develop a model to assess the clinical and economic impact of a
pocket-sized ultrasound (PSU) versus standard ultrasound for abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) screening in Italy. METHODS: The model was developed from the
perspective of the Servizio Sanitario Nazionale, the national health care system in Italy,
during an 8-year time horizon for 65–74-year-old males who had smoked in their
lifetime. Our model assumed 100% of eligible males could be screened with the PSU,
as compared to 29% actually screened with standard ultrasound, and that screening
with a PSU would incur no additional cost. Model inputs were derived from major
clinical trials (4-year rates of mortality, aortic rupture, and elective and emergency
surgeries) and DRG reimbursement rates (costs). Model outputs of number of deaths,
ruptures and costs (2010 euros) were calculated. One-way sensitivity analyses were
conducted. RESULTS: A PSU strategy yielded a 33.8% (0.32% vs. 0.48%) and 46.6%
A348
(0.42% vs. 0.79%) reduction in rates of AAA-related mortality and rupture, respectively, as compared to the standard ultrasound strategy. During an 8-year follow-up
period, the higher cost of elective surgeries by the PSU strategy was partially offset by
lower rates and costs of emergency surgeries compared to the standard ultrasound
strategy. The higher screening rate with the PSU strategy resulted in a cost savings of
c17 per screened eligible male over 8 years (annualized c2/year). Sensitivity analyses
demonstrated reductions in deaths and aortic ruptures ranging from 17% to 50% and
2% to 73%, respectively, at a maximum cost-savings of c7 to c50, and only one
instance of an incremental cost of c3 per eligible patient over 8 years. CONCLUSIONS: Use of a PSU device to screen for AAA may reduce deaths, aortic ruptures,
and surgery costs with a savings of c2/year per screened eligible male.
PCV40
CLINICAL AND ECONOMIC IMPACT OF USE OF A POCKET-SIZED
ULTRASOUND DEVICE FOR HEART FAILURE HOSPITALIZATIONS IN
ITALY
Patel PA1, Shah M2, D’Souza AO3, Min JK4
1
GE Healthcare, Barrington, IL, USA; 2Xcenda, Palm Harbor, FL, USA; 3Xcenda, Cincinnati,
OH, USA; 4Weill Medical College of Cornell University, New York, NY, USA
OBJECTIVES: Patients hospitalized for Heart Failure (HF) continue to have high
re-admission and mortality rates in the 30 days following discharge. Cardiac parameters such as left ventricular function (LVF) and inferior vena cava (IVC) size are
predictors of mortality and readmission, and are presently assessed by 2-dimensional
echocardiography (2DE). Pocket-sized ultrasound (PSU) devices for LVF and IVC
assessment offer potential advantages of lower cost, increased availability, and portability as compared to 2DE. The study objective was to develop a model to assess the
clinical and economic impact of PSU versus 2DE for HF hospitalizations in Italy.
METHODS: The model was developed from an Italian hospital perspective, and
timeframe was during HF hospitalization to 30 days post-discharge. The clinical
scenario evaluated the impact of LVF assessment on mortality, while the economic
scenario incorporated the impact of IVC size on costs (2010 Euros). Our model
assumed 100% of PSU patients would undergo evaluation, as compared to only 68%
who currently undergo 2DE. We assumed abnormalities identified by PSU would
require subsequent 2DE evaluation while lack of abnormalities would not require
2DE. Model outputs of number of deaths, readmissions, and costs were calculated
using a sample of 186,000 HF hospitalizations. One-way sensitivity analyses were
conducted to evaluate the robustness of model outcomes. RESULTS: A PSU strategy
yielded a 19.1% (7.2% vs. 8.1%) reduction in the 30-day mortality rate, as compared
to the 2DE strategy, and a 33.4% (26.0% vs. 39.1%) reduction in 30-day readmissions leading to a cost savings of c55 million (c297/ HF admission). Models were
robust to changes in model inputs with reduction in deaths from 2–37%, and cost
savings from c63–315 per HF admission. CONCLUSIONS: Use of a PSU device to
visualize key cardiac parameters for HF hospitalizations in Italy may afford reduction
in deaths and cost-savings.
PCV41
COST COMPARISON STUDY IN ACUTE CORONARY SYNDROMES AND
ACUTE HEART FAILURE PATIENTS
Ondrackova B1, Parenica J2, Felsoci M2, Miklik R2, Horakova K2, Spinar J2, Sulcova A1
1
Masaryk University, Faculty of Medicine, Brno, Czech Republic; 2Faculty Hospital Brno, Brno,
Czech Republic
OBJECTIVES: To assess and compare direct in-hospital costs in patients hospitalized
with acute coronary syndromes (ACS; unstable angina or myocardial infarction), acute
heart failure (AHF) and acute coronary syndromes complicated by heart failure (ACS
with AHF) from health care payer perspective. METHODS: Patients hospitalized from
2005 to 2008 were classified in registry of Faculty Hospital Brno according to the
clinical characteristics. Direct in-hospital costs (flat rate of admission and stay; medication and procedures) were evaluated in total 965 ACS (73% male; 64.7 years; 54%
STEMI), 962 AHF (56% male; 70.8 years) and 808 AHF with ACS (62% male; 71.2
years; 61% STEMI) patients. The severity of disease was qualified as need of intensive
care (ICU days); the predictors of high cost were identified in all groups. (1c = 26CZK).
RESULTS: Mean in-hospital cost was 101658CZK/3910c in ACS pts (length-of-stay
5.6 days; 81% pts 2.3 ICU days; 0.3% died), 70201CZK/2700c in AHF pts (lengthof-stay 9 days; 48 % pts 4 ICU days; 11.4 % died) and 122340CZK/4705c in ACS
with AHF (length-of-stay 7.2 days; 92% pts 3.5 ICU days; 19.2% died). Percutaneous
coronary intervention with stenting (PCI) formed more than 80% of total cost in ACS
patients (performed in 78% pts.; 91% STEMI; 62% non-STEMI) and almost 60%
costs in ACS with AHF pts (performed in 66% pts; 84% STEMI; 39% non-STEMI);
antiarrhythmic interventions (incl. ICD, CRT BiV or PM device) made almost 50%
cost in AHF although carried out in 8.6% pts. CONCLUSIONS: According to inhospital costs patients with acute coronary syndromes complicated by heart failure
were the most costly with maximum need of intensive care. Since 26.7% pts were
transferred to other health care institution (e.g. 9% cardiosurgery) we expect the most
significant increase of total amount of direct in-hospital costs in comparison with ACS
(16.9% pts transferred) or AHF (11.5% pts transferred).
13th Euro Abstracts
PCV42
HOSPITALIZATION COSTS IN SOUTH KOREA FOR PATIENTS
WITHOUT IDENTIFIED RISK FACTORS FOR BLEEDING WHO HAVE
ACUTE CORONARY SYNDROMES WITH PLANNED PERCUTANEOUS
CORONARY INTERVENTION TREATED WITH PRASUGREL VS.
CLOPIDOGREL IN THE TRITON-TIMI 38 TRIAL
Mahoney E1, Wang K1, Yang BM2, Kim BRM2, Lee HY3, Chae IH4, Kang SY5
1
Mid America Heart Institute of Saint Luke’s Hospital, Kansas City, MO, USA; 2Seoul
National University, Seoul, South Korea; 3School of Public Health Seoul National University,
Seoul, South Korea; 4Seoul National University, Seongnam, South Korea; 5Eli Lilly &
Company, Korea, Gangna-gu, South Korea
OBJECTIVES: The TRITON-TIMI 38 Trial demonstrated that in patients with acute
coronary syndromes (ACS) undergoing planned percutaneous coronary intervention
(PCI), prasugrel compared to clopidogrel significantly reduced the rate of ischemic
events over up to 15 months of follow-up, though there was an increased risk of major
bleeding. Three risk factors for bleeding identified in the trial were a prior history of
stroke/TIA, age ≥75 years, and body weight <60 kg. Patient-level data from TRITON
was used to compare hospitalization costs in South Korea for patients without these
risk factors for bleeding, who were randomized to prasugrel vs. clopidogrel.
METHODS: Details regarding hospitalizations for all patients from 8 high enrolling
countries (US, Australia, Canada, Germany, Italy, Spain, UK, France; n = 3373 prasugrel, 3332 clopidogrel) were collected prospectively. The US diagnosis-related group
codes were assigned to all hospitalizations, to which 2009 South Korean unit costs
were applied. Estimates of incremental costs associated with PCI-associated periprocedural MIs and PCI- and CABG-associated bleeding events were added separately,
based on published U.S. data. RESULTS: Prasugrel was associated with a 17,723
KRW per patient increase in costs due to bleeding, and an 8,377 KRW decrease in
costs due to reduced periprocedural MI, during the index hospitalization. Per-patient
costs from hospitalization for MI (not involving revascularization) during the followup period were 291,022 KRW lower with prasugrel compared to clopidogrel, and
costs associated with revascularization hospitalizations during follow-up were
505,032 KRW lower. Costs from follow-up bleeding events were 52,082 KRW higher
for prasugrel, while aggregate hospitalization costs were 293,656 KRW lower. CONCLUSIONS: For ACS patients with planned PCI, the lower ischemic event rate with
prasugrel yields a reduction in overall hospitalization costs, despite increased costs
from bleeding. These results have implications for the cost-effectiveness of alternative
antiplatelet strategies for ACS patients undergoing PCI in South Korea.
PCV43
OFFSETTING ANNNUAL CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE-RELATED
MEDICAL AND PHARMACY COSTS BETWEEN PATIENTS CONTINUING
STATIN MONOTHERAPY OR AUGMENTING STATIN MONOTHERAPY
WITH NIACIN EXTENDED-RELEASE
Quimbo RA1, Simko RJ2, Cziraky MJ1, Webb S2
1
HealthCore, Wilmington, DE, USA; 2Abbott Laboratories, Abbott Park, IL, USA
OBJECTIVES: To compare cardiovascular disease (CVD) associated costs between
patients continuing statin (simvastatin 20 mg/day or equivalent) monotherapy (SM)
or receiving adjunct therapy with niacin extended-release (NER) for comprehensive
lipid management. METHODS: Secondary risk patients age ≥30 continuing SM or
augmenting statin therapy with NER between January 1, 2005-November 30, 2008
(index date) with ≥1 pre-index lipid panel (LDL-C < 100 mg/dL & HDL-C < 50 or
<55 mg/dL for men & women, respectively) and no hepatic dysfunction were included.
SM patients were matched 3:1 to NER patients based on prior exposure to statin. The
primary outcome was total (medical and pharmacy) annual CVD-related costs.
Medical and pharmacy costs consisted of inpatient, emergency room, and outpatient
expenditures associated with CVD and pharmacy charges for anti-hyperlipidemic
therapy. Outcome comparison between SM and NER and was conducted via generalized linear models via gamma distribution and log-link function. Multivariate analyses
controlled for age, gender, geography, co-morbidities, and baseline lipids. RESULTS:
A total of 728 patients were identified; 546 SM patients were matched to 182 NER
patients. Compared to SM, there was no difference in baseline LDL-C (P = 0.13) or
Deyo-Charlson co-morbidity Index scores (P = 0.77). Baseline HDL-C (35 ± 6 vs. 42
± 7; P < 0.0001) was lower and TG (190 ± 98 vs. 153 ± 76; P < 0.0001) was higher
among NER patients. While annual CVD-related pharmacy expenditure was higher
for NER [mean (95% CI), $2261 ($1991–$2587) vs. $1276 ($1186–$1373)], adjusted
and unadjusted medical costs were 69% (P = 0.0002) lower for NER ($542 ($378–
$799) vs. $1718 ($1373–$2149); P < 0.0001) vs. SM. Offsets in medical and pharmacy
costs resulted in total annual CVD-related costs between NER and SM (($2796
($2331–$3353) vs. $2988 ($2960–$3318); P = 0.5346). CONCLUSIONS: Therapy
augmentation with NER for comprehensive lipid management was associated with
reduced annual CVD-related medical expenditure leading to total annual CVD-related
costs compared to statin monotherapy.
PCV44
EVALUATION OF CLINICAL AND DIRECT ECONOMIC OUTCOMES
BETWEEN STATIN AND FENOFIBRATE AND STATIN MONOTHERAPY
FOLLOWING AN INITIAL ACUTE CORONARY EVENT
Simko RJ1, Quinlan S2, Quimbo RA2, Cziraky MJ2, Webb S1
1
Abbott Laboratories, Abbott Park, IL, USA; 2HealthCore, Wilmington, DE, USA
OBJECTIVES: Compare the risk of subsequent coronary event (SCE), cerebrovascular
event, and associated medical costs between patients maintaining statin monotherapy
(SM) or augmenting statin with fenofibrate (FF) after an acute coronary event (ACE).
13th Euro Abstracts
METHODS: Patients with an ACE between January 1, 2004 and May 31, 2009 were
identified (the Index Date was defined as the earliest ACE). Patients age ≥18, ≥6
months eligibility pre- and post-Index Date, ≥1 statin fill and no statin augmenting
fill 6 months before the Index Date, and ≥1 FF or SM fill 6 months after the Index
Date (Cohort ID Period) were included. Patients with fills for alternative statin augmenting therapies or SCE during the Cohort ID Period were excluded. The primary
outcome was SCE. Secondary outcomes were cerebrovascular event risk and eventrelated medical costs. Event risk was compared using Cox proportional hazards
models, while costs were compared via generalized linear models. Multivariate analyses controlled for age, gender, geography, co-morbidities, concomitant medications,
statin potency, and severity of initial ACE. RESULTS: A total of 24,625 patients added
FF (n = 399) or maintained SM (n = 24,226) 6-months after initial ACE while meeting
study inclusion/exclusion criteria. FF patients were younger (59 ± 10 vs. 65 ± 12, P <
0.0001), less likely female (27% vs. 34%, P = 0.002), and had shorter follow-up (358
vs. 443 days, P < 0.0001). FF patients had lower frequency of SCE (20%) vs. SM
(25%), with an unadjusted hazard ratio (HR) of 0.88 (95%CI: 0.71–1.10). a similar
directional trend was observed for cerebrovascular events (HR: 0.74; 95% CI: 0.40–
1.37). Multivariate analyses of SCE risk demonstrated consistent directional benefit
(HR: 0.93; 95% CI: 0.74–1.16). Clinical findings corresponded with 25% lower
adjusted annual event-related costs compared to SM (0.75; 95% CI: 0.57—0.97; p =
0.0306). CONCLUSIONS: The positive clinical benefits from this real-world analysis
provide evidence supporting ability of FF to reduce both SCE risk and event-related
medical costs following ACE.
PCV45
COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS OF ROSUVASTATIN VERSUS
ATORVASTATIN IN TURKEY: AN ANALYSIS BASED ON THE
SYSTEMATIC REVIEW OF PUBLISHED RANDOMIZED CLINICAL TRIALS
(RCTS)
Abaci A1, Kabakci G2, Oguz A3
1
Gazi University Faculty of Medicine, Ankara, Turkey; 2Hacettepe University Faculty of
Medicine, Ankara, Turkey; 3Goztepe Training and Research Hospital, Istanbul, Turkey
OBJECTIVES: The aims of study were 1)to determine equivalent dosages of
Rosuvastin(R) and Atorvastatin(A) in the treatment of dyslipidemia, and 2)to evaluate
cost-effectiveness of R vs. A. METHODS: The R and a arms of 29 RCTs with stable
dose treatments for minimum 6 weeks (n = 27.588) were included in the analysis. The
arms with periods after titration or switch were excluded. The effectiveness parameters
chosen were the pooled percent decrease in LDL-C, LDL/HDL, TC/HDL ratios and
10-years’ cardiovascular risk (CVR) based on Wilson equation. Only medication costs
were calculated for R and A, since other costs directly related with dyslipidemia were
assumed to be same. Dose-effect relationship was analyzed by plotting linear regression line for R and A, separately. Incremental Cost-effectiveness Ratios (ICER) were
calculated as added cost per percent decrease in lipid parameters and per absolute
reduction in 10-years’ CVR. RESULTS: Equivalent clinical effectiveness of R was
provided with 3.9-fold, 3.2-fold and 3.2-fold dosages of a in mg, in terms of percent
decrease in LDL-C, LDL/HDL and TC/HDL ratios, respectively. Absolute 10-years’
CVR reductions with R5-40 mg and A10-80 mg were 4.5–6.9% and 3.7–5.7%,
respectively. 1(R):2(A) dose pair was selected for cost-effectiveness analysis. The yearly
medication costs were as follows: R5 mg vs. A10 mg (c113.67** vs. c128.03),
R10 mg vs. A20 mg (c174.68 vs. 226.77c), R20 mg vs. A40 mg (c261.26 vs. 283.20c)
and R40 mg vs. A80 mg (c261.26 vs. c294.68). R dominated a with regards to ICER
for all effectiveness parameters. Sensitivity analysis proved that dominance of R was
stable when the model was run for extreme values for R and a in the literature.
CONCLUSIONS: In this analysis, R was found more efficacious than three times
higher dose of A. R is more cost-effective than a in reducing LDL-C level, LDL-HDL
and TC/HDL ratios and 10-years’ CVR reduction. **1 Euro = 1.9595TL
PCV46
COST STUDY OF CAREGIVING FOR PATIENTS WITH CHRONIC
SYMPTOMATIC HEART FAILURE IN SPAIN
Marti B1, Delgado J2, Oliva J3, Llano M4, Pascual P5, Comin J6, Grillo JJ7, Diaz Molina B8,
Culebras J9, Martínez de la Concha L10, Manito N11
1
Medtronic Iberia, Madrid, Spain; 2Hospital 12 de Octubre, Madrid, Spain; 3Univesidad de
Castilla La Mancha, Toledo, Spain; 4Hospital Universitario Marqués de Valdecilla, Santander,
Spain; 5Hospital Universitario Virgen de la Arrixaca, Murcia, Spain; 6Hospital del Mar (IMIM),
Barcelona, Spain; 7Hospital Universitario Nuestra Señora de la Candelaria, Santa Cruz de
Tenerife, Spain; 8Hospital Universitario Central de Asturias, Oviedo, Spain; 9Hospital
Universitario Insular, Las Palmas De Gran Canaria, Spain; 10Hospital Universitario Infanta
Cristina, Badajoz, Spain; 11Hospital de Bellvitge, Barcelona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: The objective of this study was to quantify, for the first time in a
Spanish population, the time and cost burden of informal care for patients with heart
failure. METHODS: A descriptive analysis of a multicenter, prospective observational
study was performed. Patients who met inclusion criteria were followed-up for a
period of 12 months, with 3 visits programmed at baseline, 6 months and 12 months.
a total of 9 Spanish hospitals were involved in the study. Baseline characteristics and
caregiver’s information were registered for every patient. Once identified total hours,
the replacement cost method was used. RESULTS: A total of 450 patients were
included, 76% men, mean age was 62.6 years. 66.1% were in NYHA class II, 32.7%
NYHA class III and 1.1% NYHA class IV. Prevalence of ischemic cardiopathy was
33.5%. Thirty-five percent of patients had an implantable device (ICD, RCT or
pacemaker). One-third needed support for daily activities. One-hundred and one
informal caregivers were identified, mean age of 57.6 years, mostly women (84.1%).
A349
Main relationship with caregiver was spouse/couple (74.2%), followed by son/daughter (16.6%). Number of weekly hours of caregiving was estimated at 42.5 hours
(39.46 hours for patients NYHA class II and 47.39 hours for patients NYHA class
III-IV) and shadow prices values from c9 to c12 per hour. Total costs associated to
informal caregiving increases between c19,897 and c26,530 (c18,466–c24,621 for
patients in NYHA class II and c22,178–c29,571 for patients in NYHA class III or
IV). CONCLUSIONS: Approximately one-third required support from an informal
caregiver, which represents a significant burden for society and often has not been
accounted for in economic evaluations of treatments for heart failure. Costs for
informal care appear to increase with worse disease severity as measured by NYHA
class.
PCV47
A NATIONAL SURVEY OF SOCIETAL COST OF ACUTE CORONARY
SYNDROME IN SOUTH KOREA
Kim J1, Lee T1, Lee E1, Kim J2, Yoo W3, Boo Y4
1
Seoul National University, Seoul, South Korea; 2Yuhan University, Seoul, South Korea;
3
Daegu Haany University, Seoul, South Korea; 4Eulji University, Seoul, South Korea
OBJECTIVES: Acute coronary syndrome (ACS) is a highly prevalent disease and the
third-leading cause of death in Korea, however the economic impact of ACS from
societal perspective has not been investigated. This study examined the national epidemiology and economic costs of ACS in Korea for 2009. METHODS: This study
used the societal cost of illness framework, consisting of epidemiology of ACS, direct
medical costs, direct non-medical costs, and indirect costs such as productivity lost
from morbidity and mortality of ACS. National-level health survey results and insurance claim databases were used to analyze annual health care utilization, hospitalization costs and outpatient costs of the total Korean population (48 million people).
Using a data mining technique, we identified medical claims with international classification of disease 10 codes for ACS over a one year period and estimated the costs
by a macro-costing method. RESULTS: Prevalence rate of ACS is estimated at 6.4
persons per 1000 population in 2009 and its mortality rate is 7.8% in 2008. During
2009, there were 309,384 patients who had at least 1 medical claim related to ACS.
The total societal cost of ACS in 2009 was estimated at $1.02 billion. Direct medical
cost for ACS was $380.3 million, which includes hospitalization cost of $318.8 million
and outpatient cost of $61.6 million. The direct non-medical cost, involving transportation cost and caregiver cost, was estimated at $10.1 million. Indirect costs associated
with morbidity and mortality of ACS were $627.2 million. CONCLUSIONS: The
study showed that the societal cost of ACS in Korea is markedly high, particularly the
indirect cost, followed by hospitalization cost. Early and effective management of the
disease is necessary to reduce mortality and morbidity of ACS. Findings of this study
suggest for further research to uncover ways to reduce the economic burden of ACS
in Korea.
PCV48
COST-OF-ILLNESS AND HEALTH-RELATED QUALITY OF LIFE IN
SUBARACHNOID HEMORRHAGE: GERMAN LONGITUDINAL STUDY
Winter Y1, Ringel F2, Spottke A3, Gharevi N4, Klockgether T3, Schramm J4, Urbach H5,
Meyer B2, Dodel R1
1
Neurology, Philipps University, Marburg, Germany; 2Neurosurgery, Klinikum rechts der Isar,
Technical University, Munich, Germany; 3Neurology, University of Bonn, Bonn, Germany;
4
Neurosurgery, University of Bonn, Bonn, Germany; 5Neuroradiology, University of Bonn,
Bonn, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH) is a cerebrovascular
disease with a high mortality and severe disability. Longitudinal studies investigating
health-economic burden and health-related quality of life (HRQoL) in SAH are scare
and only one previous study analyzed cost-driving factors. The objective was to evaluate HRQoL and first-year costs in German patients with aneurysmal SAH and to
identify cost-driving factors. METHODS: A total of 113 incident cases of aneurysmal
SAH treated in the Department of Neurosurgery and Neuroradiology at the University
of Bonn between January 2004 and December 2005 were eligible for the study. Clinical assessments (Hunt and Hess scale, Barthel Index), evaluation of HRQol (36-Item
Short Form Survey, EQ5D, EQ-VAS) and collection of cost data from societal perspective (health-economic questionnaires) were performed at discharge, and at 6 and 12
months follow-up. All costs are expressed in c (year 2009 values). Independent determinants of costs and HRQoL were identified using multiple regression analysis.
RESULTS: The total first-year costs were c38,300 (95%CI: 34,490–43,100) per
patient. Direct costs accounted for 58.7% of total costs and were mainly paid by the
health insurance (92.0%). The major cost-driving factors were younger age and worse
functional outcome (Barthel-Index). HRQol in SAH patients was considerably
reduced. At discharge, 92.2% of patients had moderate or severe problems on the
EQ-5D. The EQ-VAS at discharge was 57.8 ± 19.3 and increased by only 12–14%
after 12 months. Independent predictors of decreased HRQol were female gender,
severe disease, depression, lower level of education and the lack of a stable partnership.
CONCLUSIONS: Aneurysmal SAH is a cerebrovascular disease with considerable
health-economic burden and unfavourable long-term HRQoL outcome. Clinical trials
in SAH should include HRQol measures. Independent determinants of costs and
HRQol identified in this study should be considered in the health care programmes
aimed at increasing the HRQol in SAH survivors and decreasing health-economic
burden of SAH.
A350
PCV49
ESTIMATING THE COST OF ATRIAL FIBRILLATION IN GREECE
Athanasakis K, Karampli E, Ollandezos M, Kyriopoulos J
National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece
OBJECTIVES: Determine the health care resource use and costs attributable to Atrial
Fibrillation (AF) in Greece. METHODS: A multi-point data collection procedure,
based on patient records of 149 geographically distributed physicians, was used in
order to obtain the necessary data for the patient cost model. Patients were categorized
according to initial treatment strategy i.e. pharmacological treatment (rhythm control,
rate control) and non-pharmacological treatment. Cost categories included costs of
consultations, laboratory tests, AF-related medication, anti-thrombotic medication
and hospitalization due to AF recurrence, cardiovascular complications or drugrelated adverse events. Calculations were based on 2009 fees and prices from a thirdparty payer perspective. RESULTS: A total of 94.5% of treated patients were on a
pharmacological strategy (rhythm control: 56.2%, rate control: 38.3%) and the
remaining 5.5% had undergone non-pharmacological treatment, mainly catheter ablation (96% of cases). Mean annual direct cost of treatment per patient, was estimated
at c3184, c2095 and c6452 for AF patients under rhythm control, rate control and
non-pharmacological treatment respectively and at c2947 on average, regardless of
treatment strategy. Hospitalizations were the major cost drivers for patients under
rhythm control and for those under non-pharmacological treatment accounting for
up to 75.9% of total expenses. Laboratory tests were, also, an important cost driver
(the major for rate control patients), attributing from 15.5%—50.4%, (36.4% on
average) to total costs, followed by anti-thrombotic medication, ranging from 4.4%–
18.7% (12.3% on average) and consultations ranging from 3.1%–12.4% (9.1% on
average). AF-related medication was the smallest portion of expenses accounting for
1.0%–5.4% (4.2% on average) of total costs, across all groups of patients. CONCLUSIONS: Treatment of AF poses a significant health care burden accounting for
c275,873,173 annually or 1.3% of health care expenditure in Greece in 2009. Efforts
to reduce the main AF cost drivers and hence its economic impact on the health care
system, are necessary.
PCV50
THE COST OF ATRIAL FIBRILLATION IN SWEDEN
Davidson T, Husberg M, Janzon M, Levin LÅ
Linköping University, Linköping, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: Atrial fibrillation (AF) is the most common arrhythmic disease in
Sweden. Persons with AF have a significant increased risk of stroke and the main
treatment is therefore intended to prevent stroke by anticoagulation with warfarin or
acetylsalicylic acid. However, new anticoagulation treatments will soon challenge the
established treatments and there will be a need to know the cost of AF for costeffectiveness comparisons. In this study we estimate the cost of AF in Sweden 2010.
METHODS: All relevant costs are identified, quantified and valued. The focus in the
calculation is on the complications (ischemic- and hemorrhagic stroke, gastrointestinal
bleedings and other major bleedings) caused by AF and treatments intended to lower
the risks for ischemic stroke. a societal perspective is used, and therefore productivity
loss caused by morbidity is included. Patients with CHADS2 = 1 or higher are included.
RESULTS: In Sweden with 9,340,000 inhabitants, there are 118,000 patients with AF
and at least one more risk factor of stroke, which comprise 1.26% of the population.
Among the patients; 43.3% are treated with warfarin, 28.3% use acetylsalicylic acid
and 28.3% are assumed to have no anticoagulation treatment. The cost of AF in
Sweden is estimated at SEK 3.4 billion (c354 million and US$439 million) for 2010.
This equals SEK 29,000 (c3,023 and US$3,745) per AF patient and year. The highest
cost is caused by stroke, the second highest is the cost of monitoring the warfarin
treatment. As the prevalence of AF is expected to increase, the AF cost is expected to
rise in the future. CONCLUSIONS: AF causes high costs for the society. New treatments that could reduce the risk of stroke and be easily administered might have a
potential of being cost-effective.
PCV51
THE IMPACT OF ACQUIRED BRAIN DAMAGE IN TERMS OF
EPIDEMIOLOGY, ECONOMICS AND LOSS IN QUALITY OF LIFE
Mar J1, Arrospide A1, Begiristain JM2, Larranaga I2, Oliva J3
1
Hospital Alto Deba, Mondragon, Spain; 2Government of the Basque Country, San Sebastian,
Spain; 3University of Castilla la Mancha, Toledo, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Patients with acquired brain damage (ABD) have suffered a brain
lesion that interrupts vital development in the physical, psychological and social
spheres. The objectives of this study were to estimated its incidence and prevalence of
ABD, to calculate the associated cost of the care required and finally to assess the
HRQL. METHODS: A cross-sectional survey was carried out, in order to estimate
the incidence of ABD and its consequences in terms of costs and loss in quality of life
from the evolution of a sample of patients diagnosed with stroke and TBI. On the
other hand, a discrete event simulation model was built that enabled the prevalence
of ABD to be estimated. Finally, a calculation was made of the formal and informal
costs of ABD in the population of the Basque Country and Navarre (2,750,000
people). RESULTS: The cross-sectional study showed that the incidences of ABD
caused by stroke and TBI were 61.8 and 12.5 cases per 100,000 per year respectively,
while the overall prevalence was 657 cases per 100,000 people. The SF-36 physical
and mental component scores were 28.9 and 44.5. The economic burden was calculated to be c382.14 million per year, distributed between 215.27 and 166.87 of formal
and informal burden respectively. The average cost was c21,040 per person- year.
13th Euro Abstracts
CONCLUSIONS: The main conclusion of this study is that ABD has a high impact
in both epidemiological and economic terms as well as loss in quality of life. The
overall prevalence obtained is equivalent to 0.7% of the total population. The substantial economic burden is distributed nearly evenly between formal and informal
costs. The physical dimensions of quality of life are the most severely affected. The
prevalence-based approach showed adequate to estimate the population impact of
ABD and the resources needed to compensate the disability.
PCV52
COST OF MANAGING CHRONIC THROMBOEMBOLIC PULMONARY
HYPERTENSION TO MANAGED CARE
Said Q1, Martin B1, Joish V2, Gabriel P3, Kreilick C4, Seal B4, Williamson T4, Mathai S5
1
University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences, Little Rock, AR, USA; 2Bayer, Wayne, NJ, USA;
3
Zenith Healthcare solutions, Indianapolis, IN, USA; 4Bayer Healthcare Pharmaceuticals, Inc.,
Wayne, NJ, USA; 5Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD, USA
OBJECTIVES: To estimate direct medical costs and resource use of chronic thromboembolic pulmonary hypertension (CTEPH) patients. METHODS: Data were from a
managed care claims database (2004–09) using a retrospective cohort design. Criteria
to identify CTEPH patients were: >18 years old, >2 claims for PH (ICD-9:416.0,
416.8), with first claim occurring at least 6 months after a claim for pulmonary
embolism (PE), >1 claim for right heart catheterization (RHC) or echocardiogram
before the second PH claim, and continuously enrolled during the study period. Each
CTEPH patient was matched to 1 to 5 controls without CTEPH on age, sex, region
and payer type. Per-patient-per-month costs were contrasted between CTEPH patients
and controls using Wilcoxon rank sum test. RESULTS: A total of 146 cases and 558
controls were identified (mean age 64 yrs, 54.8% female, mean follow up of 22.2
months). Total monthly costs in the period prior to CTEPH diagnosis were higher for
CTEPH patients ($3895) than controls ($1177). Most common co-morbidities in
CTEPH patients were: Acute pulmonary heart disease (8.7%), symptoms involving
respiratory system and other chest symptoms (7.5%), other forms of chronic ischemic
heart disease (6.4%). After CTEPH diagnosis, CTEPH patients had significantly higher
monthly resource use and costs vs. controls: Total costs $6198 vs. $1579, Outpatient
visits 1.2 ($2193) vs. 0.8 ($780), inpatient visits, 2 ($3382) vs. 0.2 ($507), prescriptions 4.2 ($623) vs. 2.8 ($292), all p-values < 0.05. a higher proportion of CTEPH
patients had cardiovascular related prescriptions [CCBs (21.2% vs. 18.2%), diuretics
(46.6% vs. 29.2%, p = value), oral anticoagulants (56.9% vs. 11.7%), digoxin (8.9%
vs. 3.4%), ERAs (3.5% vs. 0.0%)], and procedures [echocardiography (22.6% vs.
4.8%), electrocardiography (43.2% vs. 24.9%), computerized tomography (17.1%
vs. 7.5%), using chi-square test all p-values < 0.05, except CCBs. CONCLUSIONS:
CTEPH patients used more resources vs. controls. Research is needed to identify
factors related to increased utilization.
PCV53
THE BURDEN OF ISCHEMIC HEART DISEASES AT A MAJOR CARDIAC
CENTER IN RIYADH, SAUDI ARABIA
Alsultan MS1, Osman AM1, Al-Mutairi M2
1
King Saud University College of Pharmacy, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia; 2Prince Sultan Cardiac
Centre, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
OBJECTIVES: Ischemic Heart Disease (IHD) is the leading cause of death worldwide,
including in Saudi Arabia. Cost of illness (COI) studies aiming to explore the burden
of IHD are missing in Saudi Arabia. Therefore, the objective of this study is to estimate
the direct medical costs associated with IHD at Prince Sultan Cardiac Center (PSCC),
a major Cardiac referral center in the country. METHODS: A prospective COI study
was conducted from April 2009 to June 2009 from the PSCC perspective. All patients
diagnosed or suspected having IHD at admission were included in the study. They
were followed up till discharge or performing CABG or changing diagnosis. Clinical
data were extracted from the patient computerized database and combined with the
unit cost of services (medication, procedures, bed utilization) to calculate direct
medical costs. RESULTS: A total of 205 patients were recruited and diagnosed with
stable angina (SA) (47.8%), unstable angina (USA) (24.4%), STEMI (19.5%) and
NSTEMI (8.3%). Most of the patients were male, Saudi, aged between 40–75 years.
87% of the patients had two or more co-morbidities and 32% of the patients were
obese. The average cost is 40,164 SAR/patient (US$10,710). Medication contributed
the lowest in the costs (3.2%). ACEI contributed only 0.17% in the total costs. Costs
associated to SA, USA, NSTEMI and STEMI were respectively 33,991; 35,107; 46,585
and 58,877 SAR/patient. The lowest hospital length of stay was 6.5 days with SA.
The average length of stay increased with the number of co-morbidities from 5.67 (no
co-morbidity) to 11.25 (6 co-morbidities). CONCLUSIONS: The study shows that
IHD is of high economic burden in the Kingdom. Among the 4 types of IHD studied,
the resource consumption associated to SA was the lowest in terms of costs and patient
hospital length of stay. Co-morbidities increased the hospital length of stay.
13th Euro Abstracts
PCV54
PATTERNS OF THERAPY, HEALTH CARE UTILIZATION, AND HEALTH
CARE COSTS IN PATIENTS WITH PULMONARY ARTERIAL
HYPERTENSION (PAH) INITIATING THERAPY WITH SILDENAFIL:
FINDINGS FROM RETROSPECTIVE ANALYSES OF ADMINISTRATIVE
HEALTH CARE CLAIMS DATA
Mychaskiw MA1, Berger A2, Mardekian J1, Oster G2
1
Pfizer Inc, New York, NY, USA; 2Policy Analysis Inc., Brookline, MA, USA
OBJECTIVES: To examine patterns of therapy, health care utilization, and health care
costs among PAH patients initiating therapy with sildenafil in a real-world setting.
METHODS: Patients aged ≥18 years with evidence of PAH (ICD-9-CM diagnosis
codes 416.0, 416.8) and ≥1 claims for sildenafil between June 1, 2005, and September
30, 2008 were identified from a large administrative health care claims database.
Patients with <6 months of pretreatment data were excluded. Patients were followed
from index date (first-noted sildenafil claim) until health plan disenrollment or end of
study (follow-up). Patterns of therapy with sildenafil were examined, including
numbers of prescriptions and associated therapy-days and compliance; the latter was
measured using medication possession ratio (MPR, ratio of total therapy-days to total
days of follow-up). For the subgroup of patients with ≥6 months of follow-up data,
health care utilization and costs were compared between the 6-month period preceding
and following the index date. RESULTS: Of 855 PAH patients identified who began
therapy with sildenafil and met study inclusion criteria (mean age, 53 years; 69%
women), 32% had comorbid lung conditions and 17% connective tissue disorders.
Over a mean duration of follow-up of 423 days (median, 357 days), patients averaged
6 prescriptions for sildenafil spanning 209 therapy-days (mean MPR = 0.78). Health
care utilization was largely unchanged between the 6-month preindex and postindex
periods. Mean costs of outpatient care decreased by $501 ($8321 vs. $7820 during
preindex); mean total health care costs increased by $4137 (95% CI, $38,815–
$42,952), primarily due to increased costs of PAH-related pharmacotherapy (including sildenafil) (P < 0.01 for all comparisons). CONCLUSIONS: PAH patients initiating
sildenafil therapy are relatively compliant with treatment. Although health care utilization is largely unchanged following initiation of sildenafil therapy, total health care
costs increase, primarily due to costs of PAH-related pharmacotherapy. Further
research is needed to better understand the real-world impact of sildenafil on patient
health outcomes.
PCV55
HEALTH CARE UTILIZATION AFTER PLATELET AGGREGATION
INHIBITORS
Löfroth E, Murén KJ, Bruce S
IMS Health, Stockholm, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: To analyze the annual health care utilization by patients dispensed
platelet aggregation inhibitors excluding heparin. METHODS: This was a retrospective longitudinal descriptive database study of the utilization of health care of patients
from the South-West region of Sweden (1.5 million inhabitants). All patients who were
dispensed platelet aggregation inhibitors, excluding heparin (N05AC) during 2007
and who had a cardiovascular principal diagnosis (chapter 9, ICD-10) were included
in the study. Only costs related to cardiovascular care (i.e. visits with a cardiovascular
diagnosis) were included. RESULTS: a total of 46,742 patients had at least one dispensed platelet aggregation inhibitor and at least one cardiovascular related health
care visit during 2007 in the South-West region of Sweden. a total of 15,779 had at
least one in-patient stay, 18,211 had at least one out-patient visit, and 28,432 had at
least one primary care visit. The total costs of in- and out-patient care, primary care,
and of platelet aggregation inhibitors, excluding heparin was 1.5 billion SEK. The
greatest cost contributor was in-patient care, a total of 1.2 billion SEK, 74,501 SEK
per patient in in-patient care. The total cost for out-patient care was 98 million SEK,
5371 SEK per patient. The total cost for primary care was 92 million SEK, 3223 SEK
per patient. The total drug cost was 43 million SEK, 912 SEK per patient. CONCLUSIONS: For those patients who had at least one health care visit and who were dispensed platelet aggregation inhibitors the drug cost amounted to less than 3% of the
total annual cost. In-patient care represented as much as 80% of the total annual
costs.
PCV56
RENAL MORBIDITY, MORTALITY, AND COSTS IN INDIVIDUALS
UNDERGOING INVASIVE CARDIAC CATHETERIZATION PROCEDURES
WITH LOW-OSMOLAR CONTRAST MEDIA: A LARGE RETROSPECTIVE
DATABASE ANALYSIS
Min J1, Ryan A2, Spalding J3
1
Weill Cornell Medical College, New York, NY, USA; 2GE Healthcare Clinical Data Services,
Princeton, NJ, USA; 3GE Healthcare, Barrington, IL, USA
OBJECTIVES: To investigate in-hospital hemodialysis (HD), length of stay (LOS),
mortality, and costs following use of low-osmolar contrast media (LOCM) in patients
undergoing invasive cardiac catheterization procedures. METHODS: This retrospective analysis used the Premier PerspectiveTM database, which contains patient-level
data. In-patient adults without prior HD who underwent invasive cardiac catheterization procedures with LOCM during 2007–2008 were studied (iohexol: n = 36,118,
iopamidol: n = 36,089, ioversol: n = 135,619). Propensity score weighted and multivariate logistic regression analyses were used. RESULTS: In-hospital HD rates were
low after exposure to any of the 3 LOCM (0.9% iohexol, 1.0% iopamidol, 1.0%
ioversol). Risk of HD did not differ between iopamidol and iohexol, but ioversol
demonstrated increased risk of HD compared to iohexol (adjusted Odds Ratio [OR]
A351
1.17, 95% CI 1.02–1.35) and iopamidol (adjusted OR 1.17, 95% CI 1.02–1.34). For
in-hospital mortality (2.1% iohexol, 2.3% iopamidol, 1.9% ioversol), no betweengroup differences were statistically significant. Similarly, all-cause 30-day readmission
rates (10.8% iohexol, 10.4% iopamidol, 10.6% ioversol) did not differ significantly
between the groups. Contrast-induced acute kidney injury-related 30-day readmission
rates were 0.2% in all 3 groups. There was no significant difference in the mean
adjusted LOS between the groups (6.2–6.3 days). Iohexol was associated with a significantly lower (P < 0.001) mean adjusted initial hospitalization cost ($21,591)
compared with either iopamidol ($23,482) or ioversol ($23,484) and with a significantly lower (P < 0.001) mean adjusted initial hospitalization cost post-procedure
($10,512) compared with either iopamidol ($11,393) or ioversol ($11,187). CONCLUSIONS: In this large cohort of hospitalized patients, in-hospital HD rates were
low after invasive cardiac catheterization procedures with LOCM. The risk of HD
was comparable with iohexol and iopamidol, while ioversol was associated with a
significantly higher risk. While in-hospital mortality rates, LOS, and all-cause 30-day
readmission rates did not differ significantly between the 3 LOCM, iohexol was
associated with significantly lower cost.
PCV57
COST ANALYSIS OF THE MEDICINE TREATMENT OF SOUTH AFRICAN
PATIENTS WITH METABOLIC SYNDROME
Burger JR, Serfontein JHP, Lubbe MS
North-West University, Potchefstroom, South Africa
OBJECTIVES: In the absence of data on the economic impact of the metabolic syndrome amongst South Africans, this study aims to investigate the direct cost of treatment associated with the syndrome using data from a South African Pharmacy Benefit
Management company (PBM). METHODS: A non-experimental, retrospective quantitative drug utilization review was performed using prescription claims data. Data for
a 4-year period (January 1, 2005 to December 31, 2008) were analyzed. The direct
costs of medicine treatment were computed by the addition of the medical scheme
contribution and the patient levy. All costs were respectively expressed in 2005, 2006,
2007 and 2008 $U.S. RESULTS: Prescription claims data for a total of 10,567 patients
in 2005; 12,123 in 2006; 12,769 in 2007 and 13,201 in 2008 with a diagnosis of
metabolic syndrome were included in the study. The total direct cost of medicine
treatment for these patients accounted for $7,921,831.10 in 2005, compared to
$9,290,773.29 in 2006, $9,780,931.85 in 2007 and $8,515,349.53 in 2008. These
costs represented 2.76% (N = $287,538,709.70) of all claims during 2005, compared
to 3.18% (N = $292,314,629.60) of claims in 2006, 3.58% (N = $273,086,935.30)
in 2007, and 3.87% (N = $220,144,319.80) in 2008. Private insurers contributed
90.91% (N = $7,921,831.10) towards the treatment of patients with metabolic syndrome in 2005, compared to 89.92% (N = $9,290,773.29) during 2006, 89.50% (N
= $9,780,931.85) in 2007 and 87.17% (N = $8,515,349.53) in 2008. Patients paid
on average $68.15 ± 106.18 (median $17.59) out-of-pocket for levies for 2005,
compared to $77.21 ± 110.54 (median $35.30) during 2006, $80.42 ± 98.43 (median
$49.15) in 2007 and $82.76 ± 96.64 (median $52.66) in 2008. CONCLUSIONS:
Results show that the costs associated with the metabolic syndrome contributes significantly towards the annual expenditure of the South African PBM. Private insurers
carry most of this burden, although out-of-pocket expenses for patients show an
increasing trend.
PCV58
SUBSTITUTION INFLUENCE FROM MARK DRUGS TO GENERICS IN THE
ARTERIAL HYPERTENSION THERAPEUTIC COMPLIANCE AND THE
DYSLIPEMIA IN A POPULATION SETTING
Sicras-Mainar A1, Navarro-Artieda R2
1
Directorate of Planning, Badalona Serveis Assistencials, Badalona, Barcelona, Spain; 2Hospital
Universitari Germans Trias i Pujol, Barcelona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: To determine the therapeutical compliance in subjects with amlodipine
and simvastatin substitution from mark to generic. Secondary objective: to know the
professional and patient opinion about its use. METHODS: Patient and methods:
Before-after design with control group, realized revision of the medical records, in six
centres of primary care. Participants: Patients ≥ 40 years initiating treatment of mark
drug (initial period) and after that had a substitution by generic (final period), between
January 2003 and June 2009. Study groups: arterial hypertension (amlodopine) and
Dislipemia (simvastatin). Main measures: Co-morbidity, compliance, treatment-time,
biochemistry objectives and professional-patients opinion (interviews). Continuation:
Beginning from the generic drug substitution date, each patient was (Minimum) one
year before with a mark drug and a year after with and generic (minim continuation/
patient: 24 months). RESULTS: A total of 1252 patients. Groups: 49.5% amlodipine;
50.5% simvastatin. Average age: 72.4 years; women: 48.9%. The ones treated with
amlodipine (comparing periods); show a better compliance (65.8% vs. 61.3%; p =
0.037) and arterial pressure control (48.5% vs. 45.8%; p = 0.039) with mark drugs.
With simvastatin, was 62.8% vs. 58.4%; p = 0.041 (cholesterol control: 66.5% vs.
60.6%; p = 0.032) respectively. Interviewed doctors: 73.6% prescribe generic and a
59.2% believe that both have the same efficacy. Interview patients: a 79.8% (CI:
74.3–85.3%) accepted substitution; a 55.3% (CI: 48.5–62.1%) received the appropriate information and 61.5% the different products confuse them. a 18.2% declare that
abandon treatment. CONCLUSIONS: In patients with amlodipine/simvastatin substitution from mark to generics, it was observed less treatment compliance light, with
minor consecution of control objectives. The realized interviews (professional/patients)
reaffirm the results.
A352
PCV59
COMPLIANCE INFLUENCE, PERSISTENCE AND THE BLOOD PRESSURE
CONTROL GRADE ASSOCIATED WITH THE INCIDENCE OF
CARDIOVASCULAR EVENTS AND THE SANITARY COSTS IN
CONSUMPTION OF FIXED-DOSES IN THE ARTERIAL HYPERTENSION
TREATMENT
Sicras-Mainar A1, Galera J2, Muñoz-Ortí G3, Navarro-Artieda R4
1
Directorate of Planning, Badalona Serveis Assistencials, Badalona, Barcelona, Spain; 2Novartis
Farmaceutica S.A., Barcelona, Spain; 3Hospital Universitari Germans Trias i Pujol, Barcelona,
Spain
OBJECTIVES: To determine the incidence of cardiovascular events (CVE) and the
sanitary costs in function of the compliance, persistence and blood pressure control;
comparing patients consuming fixed-doses (FD) in front of free-doses (FD) in the
treatment of HTA. METHODS: Observational-multicentric design. It was included
patients >30 years appertaining to six team of primary care and two hospitals, that
started pharmacological treatment for hypertension during 2006. It was established
two study groups: FD (IECA/diuretics; ARA II/diuretics) and FD (IECA + DIU; ARA
II + DIU, separately). Main measures: socio-demographics, co-morbidity, parameters,
Charlson-index, compliance, persistence and control therapeutical objects (criteria:
ESH-ESC). It was determined the accumulated incidence tax of CVE and a total-cost
model (differentiating: sanitary/direct; non-sanitary/indirect). The patients’ pursuit
was realized during two years. Statistic analysis: logistic regression, proportional risk
model of Cox and the ANCOVA, P < 0.05. RESULTS: It was recruited 1605 patients,
1.112 (69.3%) in FD and 493 (30.7%) in FD, P < 0.001; age average: 69.4 (12.2)
years; women: 55.5%. Patients in FD were associated with the isquemic cardiopathy
OR = 1.4 (CI of 95%: 1.1–2.0) and organic insufficiencies OR = 1.5 (IC of 95%:
1.2–2.1), P < 0.031. Patients in FD showed a better therapeutic compliance (77.6 vs.
71.9; P < 0.001) and treatment persistence at 24 months (62.1% [CI of 95%: 56.3–
67.9%] vs. 49.7% [CI of 95%: 38.5–60.9%]; P < 0.001. The optimum control of the
arterial pressure in FD was higher (48.9% [CI of 95%: 43.0–54.8%] vs. 46.7% [CI
of 95%: 35.6–57.8%]; P < 0.001). The accumulated incidence tax of vasculocerebral
accident in FD was 4.6% vs. 2.4%; p = 0.041. The total cost in FD was lower (c1650.7
vs. c1674.8; P < 0.001), in specialized care (c316.1 vs. c382.9; P < 0.001) and loses
of labour productivity (c44.5 vs. c88.4; P < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Treatment of
compliance and persistence for hypertension in FD improve the therapeutical control,
causing a reduction of CVE and total sanitary costs.
PCV60
COST OF ANALYSIS OF THE ADVERSE EFFECTS OF THE
ANTIARRYTHMIC DRUGS IN THE CLINCAL PRACTICE IN SPAIN
Pastor Fuentes A1, Moreno Reviriego S2, Garcia Coscolin T3, Pérez Alcántara F4
1
Universitary Hospital, Getafe, Madrid, Getafe, Madrid, Spain; 2Universitary Hospital La Paz,
Madrid, Madrid, Spain; 3Sanofi-Aventis, Madrid, Madrid, Spain; 4Oblikue Consulting,
Barcelona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Antiarrhythmic drugs (AADs) are considered the first-line treatment of
atrial fibrillation (AF). However, they present a high adverse effects (AEs) rate. The
aim of the present study is to know the health resources and the costs associated with
the management of AEs of main AADs. METHODS: The incidence of AE’s of main
AADs (amiodarone, sotalol, flecainide and propafenone) has been obtained from the
Summary of product characteristics or correspondent clinical trials. The use of health
resources associated with the management of the AEs has been evaluated by a panel
of cardiology experts. Finally, all these clinical data regarding AE’s incidence derived,
has been combined with economic data from the Spanish literature and e- salud
data,an Spanish database about health care costs. The study has been carried using
National Health System perspective. RESULTS: The most expensive AEs have been
pulmonary fibrosis: c2,177.49, cardiac events (mainly tachycardia or bradycardia):
c1,422.08, and endocrine disorders (as hyperthyroidism: c244.06c and hypothyroidsm: c239.06 c). When costs are analyzed in relation with the drug to which are
associated, results are as follow: sotalol has been associated with the highest costs:
c269.42, followed by flecainide: 132.25 c, and amiodarone: 127,82, whereas propafenone has been associated to the lowest cost: c48.09. However, although amiodarone
is not the AAD associated with the highest cost, considering current Spanish AADs
market, it is the one that has more economic repercussion. CONCLUSIONS: Current
AADs may cause AEs and their management is related to health resources consumption. Pulmonary and cardiac events have been associated to the major cost. Considering current clinical practice in Spain, amiodarone is the treatment that supposes a
major budget impact for the National Health Service.
PCV61
ECONOMICS ESTIMATION OF SIDE EFFECTS CORRECTION
ANTIHYPERTENSIVE MEDICAL PRODUCTS OF INHIBITORS-ACE IN
RUSSIAN HEALTH
Yagudina R1, Protsenko M2
1
Laboratory of Pharmacoeconomics, Moscow Medical Academy, Moscow, Russia; 2Moscow
Medical Academy named after I.M.Sechenov, Moscow, Russia
OBJECTIVES: To assess the cost of the basic course of pharmacotherapy of arterial
hypertension (AH) of inhibitors-ACE, direct costs associated with the correction of
side effects (SE), developing on the background of their application with further
pharmacoeconomics evaluation of inhibitors-ACE. METHODS: Cost analysis, modeling. a consideration of the basic price of therapy trade names (TN) inhibitors-ACE
INN: enalapril, lisinopril and the calculation of direct costs associated with correction
of SE in patients diagnosed with stage II AH. Medical patients’ route, the cost structure
13th Euro Abstracts
were modeled by questioning physicians, cardiologists of Institute of Gerontology,
Clinical Hospital ¹ 55, Moscow. The study takes into account the cost: symptomatic
therapy, specialist consultations, emergency care, hospital bed-days, laboratory and
instrumental manipulations. Data registered in RF TN obtained from the site www.
regmed.ru, information about prices—www.medlux.ru, www.cardioweb.ru. We took
into account recommendations of standards of care for patients with AH, developed
by Health Ministry of Russia. The cost of the basic course of pharmacotherapy and
PE are estimated at 30-day time period for 1 patient. Average daily dose the drugs
accounted for enalapril—5 mg/day, lisinopril—10 mg/day. RESULTS: The development of side effects (cough, arterial hypotension, allergies, headache, etc.) was the
cause of drug withdrawal enalapril in 5.3% of patients, lisinopril at 3.8% of patients.
The study calculated the cost of courses were the main pharmacotherapy TN lisinopril
and enalapril, ranging from 30 to 245 Rubles, corrective therapy—from 284 to 583
Rubles. In the economic evaluation of SE was the least expensive scheme with drug
enalapril, which is more advantageous from an economic position. CONCLUSIONS:
The economic analysis of side effects developing on the background of the basic course
of pharmacotherapy, is relevant assessment to improve the quality and credibility of
pharmacoeconomics studies of drugs.
PCV62
UPTAKE AND COSTS OF IMAGING MODALITIES IN PACEMAKERIMPLANTED AND NON-IMPLANTED PATIENTS
Busca MR1, Horin F2, Saal G3
1
Medtronic International Trading Sàrl, Tolochenaz, Switzerland; 2Medtronic, Inc., Minneapolis,
MN, USA; 3HealthEcon Write Ltd, Solihull, UK
OBJECTIVES: Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is considered the gold standard for
imaging of the brain, spinal cord, musculoskeletal system, and complex cardiac
malformations. However, pacemaker implant is a contraindication to MRI, and thus
a barrier to access in pacemaker-implanted patients for this essential diagnostic technology. An analysis of Medicare fee-for-service data was conducted to estimate the
difference in MRI uptake rates of pacemaker-implanted and non-implanted Medicare
benficiaries. METHODS: The data comprised the fee-for-service portion of the 2008
Medicare patient population. Two issues were examined: the prevalence of the diseases
for which MRI is the preferred imaging modality, and the uptake rates of all imaging
modalities for MRI-indicated beneficiaries with pacemaker implants compared with
those having no implants. For each of diseases for which MRI is the preferred modality
we also identified any trade-offs between lower MRI rates and higher rates for other
imaging modalities in pacemaker-implanted and non-implanted patients, and potential
cost implications substituting MRI with other imaging modalities. RESULTS: The
Medicare data indicated MRI uptake was nil in the pacemaker-implanted population
where 13% of patients without any implant received MRI in 2008 suggesting that
clinical practice is in line with the contraindication for MRI in pacemaker patients.
Consequently, uptake of other imaging approaches including CT, ultrasound, nuclear,
x-ray was greater in the MRI-indicated cohort of pacemaker patients (54%, 65%,
25%, 82%, respectively) compared to the similar non-implanted cohort (38%, 48%,
18%, 73%, respectively). It was estimated that access to MRI (i.e. patients implanted
with MRI-compatible pacemakers) would generate up to 21% reduced diagnostic
costs compared with no access to MRI (i.e. patients implanted with older generation
pacemakers). CONCLUSIONS: Increased access to the diagnostic superiority of MRI
may provide a more efficient allocation of diagnostic resources for pacemaker patients;
this increased access can be provided with the availability in the market of new pacemakers engineered for MRI compatibility.
PCV63
COST OF ABLATION PROCEDURES FOR ATRIAL FIBRILLATION:
RESULTS FROM THE AIAC SURVEY
Berto P1, Themistoclakis S2, Tritto M3, Aiac WGAA4
1
Pbe Consulting, Verona, Italy; 2Ospedale dell’Angelo, Mestre (VE), Italy; 3Istituto Clinico
Mater Domini, Castellanza (VA), Italy; 4Italian Society of Cardiac Pacing and Arrhythmology,
Roma, Italy
OBJECTIVES: As part of a broader HTA project on ablation procedures for atrial
fibrillation (A-AF), objective of this study was to quantify consumption of resources
and calculate cost of A-AF in comparison with current reimbursement in Italy.
METHODS: A questionnaire was sent to the Italian electrophysiology (EP) centres
identified by AIAC (Italian Society of Cardiac Pacing and Arrhythmology) to collect,
2008 data on: number of procedures; use of pre-post ablation diagnostics, consumables, electro-anatomic mapping, anaesthesia/analgesia, EP laboratory occupancy
time, staff employed; EP laboratory equipment; duration of hospitalization. Bottomup costing of resources was performed based on average costs from a sub-sample of
4 hospitals, national tariffs or published data. Average procedure cost was calculated
based on mathematical (m-mat) and geometrical (m-geo) means. Final endpoint was
the comparison between DRG-518 regional reimbursement values and full hospital
costs for ablation treatment. RESULTS: A total of 52/87 (60%) AIAC centres replied
to the questionnaire, reporting 33,745 EP procedures, of which 4,561 (13.52%) were
A-AF (min = 3; max = 1091; average = 88; SD = 159, median = 49; IQR = 22–81).
Production cost for A-AF amounted to c9455 (m-mat) and c8868 (m-geo): consumables (ablation and diagnostic catheters, transeptal needles, transeptal sheaths, and
other devices) accounted for 61% of total cost; hospital stay 15%; intra-procedural
costs (room occupancy, staff, anaesthesia and equipment) 20%; pre-procedural tests
4%. Difference of DRG-518 tariff vs. hospital incurred costs: m-mat c−4079 (−43%)
or m-geo c−3492 (−35%). Cost of production appears more under-remunerated in
Lazio (−54%), Lombardia (−46%), Veneto, Umbria (−45%). The imbalance was
13th Euro Abstracts
−42%/−44% when centres were grouped by the number of A-AF procedures performed. Total cost of A-AF (including 2 years post-procedure follow-up) was c10,163
(m-mat) or c9,632 (m-geo). Cost of follow-up represented only 8% on total cost of
A-AF. CONCLUSIONS: The cost of AF ablation procedures is significant and is
largely under-funded by the DRG tariff, which showed inadequate to remunerate
hospitals in all Italian Regions.
PCV64
COST CONSEQUENCES AND RESOURCE UTILIZATION IN
TRANSCATETHER AORTIC VALVE IMPLANTATION (TAVI) AS A
SUBSTITUTION FOR HIGH RISK SURGICAL PATIENTS
Webb PP1, Carroll GD1, Smith D2
1
Welsh Health Specialised Services Committee, Caerphilly, UK; 2Morriston Hospital,
Swansea, UK
OBJECTIVES: TAVI is a novel interventional procedure and is considered as an
alternative to surgery in high risk patients with severe aortic stenosis. For commissioning purposes, a cost consequences model was derived to look at the impact of
substituting TAVI for high risk conventional surgery patients. METHODS: The cost
consequence included hospital LOS on CITU, HDU and ward and pacemakers implantation costs. Twenty-five patients were retrospectively identified by clinicans with
TAVI experience who might have been eligible to receive TAVI in the previous year
of introduction of TAVI on the market. The patient specification was aligned with the
TAVI device CE marking criteria. The average TAVI patient cost was obtained from
a manufacturer sponsored economic model which used UK patient level data from
their sponsored registry. The hospital’s local database was used for unit costs. Costs
were calculated based on mean values for CITU (critical intensive care unit), HDU
(high dependency unit), ward and pacemaker implantation. We also calculated the
mean cost per case based on the total length of stay (LOS) for CITU, HDU ward and
pacemaker implants of each of the isolated AVR and AVR plus valvular disease (AVR
+ CABG) population. RESULTS: The total cost based on mean LOS values was
£21,460 for isolated AVR and £23,032 for AVR + CABG. The cost per TAVI case
based on total LOS was £24,721 compared to £49,982 for AVR + CABG. CONCLUSIONS: The cost consequence model was sensitive to long LOS on CITU and HDU
in the AVR plus CABG group. Using a cost consequences model TAVI was at worst
cost neutral and at best most likely to deliver substantial savings in this centre in this
well defined patient population. This finding is significant in assessment of the “real”
cost impact for substituting TAVI for high risk conventional surgery.
PCV65
HEALTH ECONOMIC ASSESSMENT OF FERRIC CARBOXYMALTOSE IN
PATIENTS WITH IRON DEFICIENCY AND CHRONIC HEART FAILURE IN
THE FAIR-HF TRIAL
Gutzwiller FS, Blank PR, Schwenkglenks M, Szucs TD
Institute of Pharmaceutical Medicine/ECPM, University of Basel, Basel, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: Chronic heart failure (CHF) is associated with poor quality of life
resulting from physical and psycho-social limitations. The FAIR-HF trial showed
clinical and quality of life benefits of iron deficiency treatment in CHF patients using
ferric carboxymaltose (FCM), an intravenous (i.v.) iron preparation. This study evaluated the cost-effectiveness of iron repletion using FCM in CHF patients, from the
perspectives of the statutory health insurance (Germany) and the National Health
Service (UK). METHODS: Using data from FAIR-HF, a randomized, double-blind,
controlled clinical trial (n = 459), per-patient costs and clinical effectiveness of FCM
were estimated. Economic assessment was based on published costs associated with
New York Heart Association (NYHA) functional classes. Effectiveness was assessed
as the number of QALYs gained, derived from EQ-5D scores. The ICER of FCM was
determined compared to placebo. Time horizon of this within-trial analysis was 24
weeks. RESULTS: In the FAIR-HF trial, NYHA classes were significantly improved
in the FCM group compared with placebo (P < 0.001). Estimated per-patient costs
(excluding iron costs) were c2625 and c2919 (Germany), and £4155 and £4621 (UK),
for FCM and placebo arms, respectively. Based on the reimbursed price for FCM in
Germany and UK (c28 and £19 per 100 mg iron) and the mean iron dosage of the
clinical study (1850 mg) plus administration costs, a net investment of c530 and £68
per patient would be required. FCM resulted in an estimated gain of 0.0254 QALYs
over the study period. The ICER of FCM ranged from c20,872 to £2,682 per QALY
gained for the FAIR-HF dosing regimen, compared to placebo. ICER-differences result
from disparities in administration and medication costs. CONCLUSIONS: From the
German and UK payers’ perspective, managing iron deficiency in CHF patients using
i.v. FCM can be considered cost-effective. Improved symptoms and better quality of
life contribute to economic benefits seen with FCM.
PCV66
ECONOMIC PERFORMANCE OF DABIGATRAN ETEXILATE FOR
PRIMARY VTE PREVENTION FOLLOWING TOTAL HIP AND KNEE
REPLACEMENT SURGERY IN ITALY
Zaniolo O, Pradelli L
Adres srl, Torino, Italy
OBJECTIVES: To estimate cost/effectiveness and cost/utility of dabigatran etexilate
(DBG) compared to standard care for the prevention of venous thromboembolism
(VTE) secondary to total hip replacement (THR) or total knee replacement (TKR) in
Italy. METHODS: A decision analytic, Markov-chain based model originally developed for the UK has been adapted to the Italian context. Clinical outcomes, including
A353
incidences of VTE and treatment-related adverse events, were extrapolated from headto-head, phase III trials of DBG vs. enoxaparin. For the other low molecular weight
heparins (LMWHs), indirect comparisons were performed on the basis of equal
effectiveness assumptions. The adaptation involved cost and demographic characteristics, leaving clinical and utility data unvaried. Costs are taken from national observational studies, where available. Otherwise, current prices and tariffs are applied.
Resources consumption where derived from practice guidelines or taken from those
estimated for the UK model. According to the prevalent national practice, extended
prophylaxis has been considered for both surgical procedures. Time horizon of the
analysis is patients’ lifetime. RESULTS: Compared to LMWHs, DBG is associated to
an expected increase of 0.019 LYs and 0.014 QALYs per THR patient and of 0.024
LYs and 0.019 QALYs per TKR patient. DBG-related cost is lower than competitors
in both procedures, with a mean difference ranging between c82 and c109 for THR,
and 100 and 135 for TKR, depending on the considered comparator. Higher acquisition costs for DBG are completely offset and inverted by avoided administration
expenses and, less importantly, by savings on VTE management. Probabilistic sensitivity analysis estimates that, for a willingness to pay threshold of £30,000 (~c33,500)/
QALY, DBG is associated to a probability of being cost/effective of about 98% for
THR and of 90% for TKR. CONCLUSIONS: On average DBG dominates LMWHs,
as it’s expected to be cost-saving and non-inferior in terms of efficacy and safety.
PCV67
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF FONDAPARINUX VS. ENOXAPARIN IN
NON-ST-ELEVATION ACUTE CORONARY SYNDROMES IN RUSSIA
Vorobyev PA1, Borisenko O1, Lesnicheva M1, Shiganov S2, Lomakin A3
1
Russian Society for Pharmacoeconomics and Outcomes Research, Moscow, Russia; 2Abakan
City Hospital, Abakan, Russia; 3GlaxoSmithKline Russia, Moscow, Russia
OBJECTIVES: To assess cost-effectiveness of fondaparinux versus enoxaparin in
patients with non-ST-elevation acute coronary syndrome in Russia. METHODS: A
decision tree model was created incorporating the outcomes associated with 2 antithrombotic approaches from OASIS-5 trial: enoxaparin (1 mg/kg every 12 hours)
versus fondaparinux (2.5 mg/day). Probabilities of complications (e.g., myocardial
infarction, stroke, major bleeding at 9, 30 and 180 days) were calculated. Data on
resource utilization (staff, drugs, materials, laboratory, and equipment), diagnosis and
treatment came from the hospital survey. Resources were valued in internal hospital
prices based on obligatory medical insurance tariffs (as of 2008). The incremental
cost-effectiveness ratio for fondaparinux per death avoided and per major bleeding
episode avoided versus enoxaparin was quantified. Sensitivity analysis was performed.
RESULTS: The cost analysis showed that fondaparinux would generate a cost saving
of 1634 RUR (c43), 1902 RUR (c50) and 2167 RUR (c57) per patient at 9, 30 and
180 days respectively. When cost and clinical results were extrapolated to costeffectiveness, fondaparinux was dominant (less costly and more effective in terms of
death avoided and major bleeding episode avoided). The sensitivity analysis proved
that costs of pharmacotherapy with fondaparinux and enoxaparin had the biggest
impact on results. CONCLUSIONS: Fondaparinux is a more cost-effective option
than enoxaparin in treatment of patients with non-ST-elevation acute coronary syndrome from the hospital perspective in Russia.
PCV68
POTENTIAL COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF A BIOMARKER TEST TO
RECLASSIFY PATIENTS WITH AN INTERMEDIATE RISK BASED ON THE
FRAMINGHAM RISK SCORE INTO A LOWER OR HIGHER CATEGORY
TO OPTIMIZE STATIN THERAPY
Burgers LT, Redekop WK, Severens JL
Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: The Framingham Risk Score is a well-accepted tool to estimate the
10-year risk of developing coronary heart disease (CHD). However, many patients
fall into the intermediate risk category. Improved discrimination within this category
is necessary to prevent CHD and side-effects of statins therapy efficiently. This economic evaluation calculated the potential lifetime cost-effectiveness of a novel biomarker test which helps to decide whether patients with an intermediate risk should
be treated with statins. METHODS: Prognosis of patients with an intermediate risk
was simulated with a Markov chain Monte Carlo model to estimate the potential
lifetime costs and effects (life-years (LY)) for three strategies: treat all with statins,
treat none with statins or use a test to select patients for statin treatment. Costs were
calculated for the The Netherlands using a health care sector perspective. Values for
all input parameter were derived from the literature. RESULTS: A strategy using a
perfect test for a 55-year old man would be slightly more expensive than the treat-none
option (c1966 vs. c1941) but less expensive than the treat-all option (c5374). The test
and the treat-all option would be equally effective (24.45 LY) and more effective than
the treat-none option (24.3 LY). An ICER of c170 versus treat-none indicates that it
is a biomarker test with great potential. Results were sensitive to uncertainties regarding model parameters such as the sensitivity, specificity and costs of the test, as well
as CHD risk, and the costs and effectiveness of statins. CONCLUSIONS: A test to
reclassify patients in the Framingham intermediate risk group into higher and lower
risk categories has the potential to optimize cost-effectiveness by preventing CHD and
reduce the risk of drug side-effects. Values used in this model (e.g., test sensitivity and
specificity) can be adjusted wherever needed to determine whether continued development of a biomarker is worthwhile.
A354
PCV69
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF EPLERENONE COMPARED WITH
SPIRONOLACTONE IN PATIENTS WITH HEART FAILURE AFTER
ACUTE MYOCARDIAL INFARCTION
Inês M1, Soares M2, Vitorino R1
1
Pfizer Portugal, Porto Salvo, Oeiras, Portugal; 2University of York, York, Yorkshire, UK
OBJECTIVES: Aldosterone blockers (AB) are recommended for use in heart failure
(HF) and HF post acute myocardial infarction (AMI) in patients with left ventricular
dysfunction. Although only eplerenone is licensed for post-AMI HF treatment, less
expensive spironolactone is used in some clinical settings. This study aims to evaluate
cost-effectiveness of eplerenone compared with spironolactone in Portuguese patients
with HF post-AMI. METHODS: A Markov model was developed to predict life-years
(LY), quality adjusted life-years (QALY) and associated costs of AB treatment over
patients life time. Estimates of all cause mortality relative risks were obtained via a
meta-regression of AB published trials. Transition probabilities were derived from
EPHESUS (Eplerenone Post-Acute Myocardial Infarction Heart Failure Survival
Study), adjusted by a Weibull function with meta-regression estimates. AB adverse
events (hyperkalemia, gynescomatia) rates were derived from a published meta-analysis. AB class effect was assumed regarding non-fatal hospitalization rates. Resource
use and discontinuation rates were elicited through a panel of six cardiologists with
extensive clinical experience. Unit costs and other cause mortality rate were extracted
from Portuguese official sources. Utilities were obtained using a regression model
published in the literature derived from EPHESUS EQ-5D data. Societal perspective
was adopted and both costs and effectiveness were discounted at 5%. RESULTS:
Average cost per patient for eplerenone and spironolactone treatment were c25,907
and c20,963, respectively. Average effectiveness gained with eplerenone was 0.44LY
and 0.41QALY, meaning the incremental cost-effectiveness ratios were c11,309/LY
and c12,040/QALY. Although indirect comparison of eplerenone with spironolactone
introduces some uncertainty for relative effectiveness and cost-effectiveness: probabilistic sensitivity analysis revealed eplerenone to be cost-effective in 59% of Monte
Carlo iterations at a willingness to pay of c35,000/QALY. CONCLUSIONS: Compared with spironolactone, eplerenone treatment in patients with HF post-AMI is
effective in reducing mortality, improving quality of life and is cost-effective by commonly used criteria in Portugal.
PCV70
COST SAVINGS OF ENOXAPARIN OVER UFH IN MEDICAL PATIENTS
IN CANADIAN HOSPITAL SETTING
Wakeford C1, Mittmann N2
1
sanofi-aventis Canada Inc., Laval, QC, Canada; 2Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre,
Toronto, ON, Canada
OBJECTIVES: Enoxaparin, a low molecular weight heparin, was approved for use in
medical patients in Canada in 2001, however, its use in hospitals has been relatively
low. Low utilization is thought to be due to the perception by hospital administration
of increased drug costs when compared to unfractionated heparin (UFH). Examination
of the cost of clinical events for thromboprophylaxis has demonstrated that enoxaparin may be cost savings. METHODS: A decision tree model was developed to the
compare clinical results of four thromboprophylaxis regimens: enoxaparin 40 mg once
daily, UFH 5000 International Units (IU) twice daily, UFH 5,000 IU three times daily
and no prophylaxis. The main clinical outcomes in the model included DVT, PE, major
bleeds, heparin-induced thrombocytopenia and death and were based on published
literature Recurrences of the first four endpoints were also modelled. Canadian treatment pattern data was based on one academic institution in Toronto, Canada. Costing
(2010 Canadian $) for each state was also developed for direct medical costs. Within
the model, parameters such as cost of thromboprophylaxis, number of patients, duration
of treatment, length of stay, among many other variables were varied to reflect a hospital
specific analysis. RESULTS: When combining clinical and economic data in a Canadian hospital setting, use of enoxaparin was cost-saving in a majority of situations.
In the reference case, a typical hospital setting switching from UFH to enoxaparin
resulted in an overall cost savings to the hospital, wherein a population of 1000 annual
medical patients would realize a savings of $90,000CAD. Sensitivity analysis showed
that enoxaparin was not cost savings when medically ill patients did not receive any
thromboprophylaxis. CONCLUSIONS: Enoxaparin is a clinically safe and efficacious
thromboprophylaxis regimen in medically ill patients. The model and follow-up analysis
demonstrate that it is also a cost-saving choice of thromboprophylaxis within the
Canadian hospital setting.
PCV71
IS COREVALVE A COST-EFFECTIVE TREATMENT FOR PATIENTS WITH
SEVERE AORTIC STENOSIS WHO SATISY ALL THE CRITERIA FOR
CONVENTIONAL AORTIC VALVE REPLACEMENT?
Eaton JN, Mealing S, Watt M, Sculpher M
Oxford Outcomes Ltd, Oxford, Oxon, UK
OBJECTIVES: Aortic Stenosis (AS) is a severe cardiovascular condition; the treatment
of which involves open surgery and cardiopulmonary bypass to replace the damaged
aortic valve (AVR). AVR is invasive and carries a significant risk for patients with a
high risk of perioperative mortality. Transcatheter aortic valve implantation using
“CoreValve,” is less invasive, allowing for the percutaneous implantation of a replacement valve in this patient group. However, the acquisition cost of CoreValve is greater
than AVR, therefore it is important to assess whether CoreValve is a cost-effective
alternative. METHODS: A 20-year Markov model was developed in Microsoft Excel.
13th Euro Abstracts
Treatment options were CoreValve and AVR with parameters derived from published
literature. Both products were assumed to have the same long term impact on mortality. All costs were taken from the most recent published sources. Decrements were
applied to age-specific EQ-5D population norms to generate QALYs. Extensive probabilistic and deterministic sensitivity analyses were performed to identify key costeffectiveness drivers. All costs and benefits were discounted at 3.5% p.a. RESULTS:
The model was very sensitive to changes in the short-term relative risk (RR) of mortality. In the base-case a short term RR of 0.57 was estimated from the available literature, the ICER was £25,229. However, the short-term mortality estimate for AVR
was highly uncertain. Assuming a 0.75 RR the ICER is £34,603 and at 1.0 the ICER
is £81,011. The model was also highly sensitive to changes in long term RR, device
cost and time horizon. Assuming a threshold value of £30,000 per QALY gained, the
probability that CoreValve is cost-effective is 0.54. CONCLUSIONS: Assuming that
the RR of short-term mortality is at least 0.67 CoreValve is a cost-effective alternative
for the treatment of severe AS in high risk patients.
PCV72
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF EXTENDED-RELEASE NICOTINIC ACID/
LAROPIPRANT AS MONOTHERAPY VERSUS EZETIMIBE
MONOTHERAPY IN PATIENTS WITH MIXED DYSLIPIDAEMIA IN
SCOTLAND
Jameson K1, Davies GM2, Ambegaonkar BM3, Sazonov V3, O’Regan C1
1
MSD Ltd., Hoddesdon, UK; 2Merck & Co., Inc., Upper Gwynedd, PA, USA; 3Merck & Co.,
Inc., Whitehouse Station, NJ, USA
OBJECTIVES: Although statins are the mainstay of cholesterol management in Scotland, there remains a group of patients who are ineligible for such treatment due to
contraindication or intolerance. This analysis estimates the cost-effectiveness of
extended-release nicotinic acid/laropiprant 2 g/40 mg (ERN/LRPT), versus ezetimibe
10 mg, as monotherapy for the treatment of mixed dyslipidaemia in Scotland in
patients not currently receiving statin therapy. METHODS: The analysis was based
on a previously published Markov model. Risk equations, based on the Framingham
Heart Study, were used to model CHD-event rates in patients with established CHD,
diabetes mellitus (DM) or a 10-year CHD-risk ≥20%. The model was run on a cohort
of 2976 patient profiles extracted from the General Practice Research Database. All
patients had abnormalities in low-density-lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-C ≥
2.0 mmol/L), high-density-lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL-C < 1.0 mmol/L [men],
1.2 mmol/L [women]) and triglycerides (TG > 1.7 mmol/L). ERN/LRPT efficacy data
were taken from the results of a published clinical trial, and ezetimibe data taken from
a meta-analysis of monotherapy trials. Results were reported as the cost per qualityadjusted life-year (QALY) gained. RESULTS: When compared to the use of ezetimibe,
ERN/LRPT led to an increase in both QALYs and costs across the three patient-risk
sub-groups. In patients with CHD, the base-case analysis estimated an incremental
cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of £7559. Base-case results in patients with DM and
patients facing a 10-year CHD risk ≥20% were £9,361 and £11,980, respectively.
ICERS in the majority of sensitivity analyses did not vary by more than +/− £3000
from the base case. CONCLUSIONS: When compared to ezetimibe, ERN/LRPT is
projected to be cost-effective for the management of lipids in patients for whom the
addition of statin is inappropriate or not tolerated, as reflected in the guidance issued
by the Scottish Medicines Consortium.
PCV73
ECOMOMIC EVALUATION OF COMBINATION THERAPY FOR
HYPERTENSION IN HIGH RISK PATIENTS IN SWEDEN
Brown R,1 Brede Y,3 Getsios D,2 Tambour M,4 Falvey H3
1
United BioSource Corporation, London, UK, 2United BioSource Corporation, Lexington,
MA, USA, 3Novartis Pharma AG, Basel, Switzerland, 4Novartis Sverige AB, Taby, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: The ACCOMPLISH trial demonstrated that an ACEi/CCB combination (benazepril/ amlodipine) significantly reduced cardiovascular events in high risk
hypertension patients compared to an ACEi/HCTZ combination (benazepril/ hydrochlorothiazide). ACCOMPLISH trial was the first to compare fixed dose combination
therapies and examine longer term outcomes in this patient population. This study
evaluated health and economic outcomes based on robust findings from ACCOMPLISH, and extended this analysis to an ARB/CCB combination (valsartan /amlodipine). METHODS: ACCOMPLISH evaluated over 11,500 patients with hypertension
at high risk for cardiovascular events. Trial data on cardiovascular events, diabetes,
and renal failure endpoints, compliance and dosing levels were used to populate a
compartmental cohort model which followed patients over 4 years. Cost data from
Sweden (reported in 2008 Euros) were assigned to acute events and follow-up care,
as well as hypertension-related treatment. a dose equivalency analysis of valsartan and
benazepril was used to assign appropriate drug costs for the extension of the analyses
to valsartan/amlodipine. The daily cost of benazepril/hydrochlorothiazide was c0.21,
c0.16 for benazepril/amlodipine, and ranged between c0.90 and c1.10 for valsartan/
amlodipine, depending on dose. All outcomes were discounted at 3% per annum.
RESULTS: Total costs over 4 years averaged c4554 per patient on benazepril/hydrocholorothiazide. With a lower drug cost and 45 fewer acute events per 1000 treated
patients, costs were c322 lower per patient on benazepril/amlodipine. Assuming same
outcome as for benazepril/amlodipine, valsartan/amlodipine was associated with
incremental drug costs of c963 per patient, and c693 in overall costs, resulting in a
cost per event avoided of c15,543. CONCLUSIONS: Based on the results of ACCOMPLISH, the combination of benzepril/amlodipine is clearly preferable to benazepril/
13th Euro Abstracts
hydrochlorothiazide. Using the ACCOMPLISH results for valsartan/amlodipine, it is
likely to have reasonably low costs per event avoided for the treatment of high risk
patients with hypertension in Sweden.
PCV74
ONE-YEAR COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF CYTOCHROME P450 2C19
GENOTYPE-GUIDED ANTIPLATELET THERAPY IN PATIENTS WITH
ACUTE CORONARY SYNDROMES IN THE UNITED KINGDOM
Charland SL1, Agatep B1, Malone D2, Stanek E1
1
Medco Health Services, Inc., Bethesda, MD, USA; 2University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ, USA
OBJECTIVES: Cytochrome P450 2C19 (CYP2C19) genotype has been shown to
affect cardiovascular (CV) outcomes for clopidogrel but not prasugrel. This study
evaluates the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of CYP2C19-guided vs.
routine antiplatelet therapy in acute coronary syndrome (ACS) patients in the UK.
METHODS: We constructed a literature-based, decision analytic, Markov model to
estimate the annual cost-effectiveness of CYP2C19-guided aspirin plus either clopidogrel or prasugrel therapy vs. no genotyping. Post-initial ACS CV events were based
on the TRITON-TIMI 38 study and genetic substudy. Cost data sources were:
National Health Service (NHS) reference cost for 2008–09—nonfatal MI and stroke,
CV death, intracranial hemorrhage, other life-threatening bleed, and minor bleed;
Drug Tariff 2009—drugs; www.genetic-health.co.uk/—CYP2C19 genotyping; or USbased reference pricing converted to £ using appropriate exchange rates -monthly CV
disease maintenance cost. Disease-state utilities were obtained from published sources.
The model allowed for clopidogrel/prasugrel discontinuation and aspirin monotherapy. Model sensitivity was assessed using 1-way analysis of parameters varied by
quartile or at least +/− 25%. RESULTS: The analysis demonstrated an increase in
incremental cost (£81); greater incremental QALY (0.05); and an ICER £1529/QALY
for CYP2C19 genotype-guided therapy over 12 months. The model was most sensitive
to monthly CV care cost, NFMI cost, proportion of patients on clopidogrel, and lifethreatening bleeding cost. The model was least sensitive to the cost of clopidogrel,
prasugrel, or CYP2C19 genotyping. CONCLUSIONS: The model-based ICER of
£1,529/QALY for the CYP2C19 testing strategy is significantly less than the UK
threshold of £20,000 that is considered good value. CYP2C19 genotype-guided clopidogrel or prasugrel therapy is cost-effective for up to 1 year in ACS patients in the
UK.
PCV75
CANADIAN COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS OF DRONEDARONE
VERSUS OTHER ANTI-ARRHYTMIC DRUGS IN PATIENTS WITH
PAROXYSMAL AND PERSISTENT ATRIAL FIBRILLATION
Nilsson J1, Åkerborg Ö1, Lindgren P1, Bascle S2
1
i3 Innovus, Stockholm, Sweden; 2Sanofi-Aventis, Paris, France
OBJECTIVES: Dronedarone is a novel anti-arrhythmic drug (AAD) that, unlike other
AADs, was shown to reduce cardiovascular hospitalizations or death in the ATHENA
clinical trial. In addition, dronedarone reduces AF recurrence, maintains rate control,
and has a favorable safety profile with low pro-arrhythmic and organ-toxicity profile.
The objective of this study was to construct a health economic model to assess the
cost-effectiveness of dronedarone vs. other AADs in a Canadian setting. METHODS:
A state transition model evaluated through patient-level simulation has been developed
using Microsoft Excel. It allows comparisons over varying time horizons and treatment durations, and consists of health states for: treatment, off treatment, symptomatic AF recurrences, stroke, acute coronary syndromes, coronary heart failure and
death. Transition probabilities were derived from the patient level data from the
ATHENA trial, and relative risks between dronedarone and three commonly used
comparators (amiodarone, sotalol and flecainide) identified by clinical experts were
derived from a mixed treatment comparison (systematic review) of published clinical
trials published between 1980 and 2009. Patients discontinuing treatments were
assumed to progress according to the rates in the standard of care arm of ATHENA.
Costs of monitoring and initiation were taken into account. Costs were applied to
each adverse event (AE) observed (Canadian Costs [C$] 2007). Effectiveness was
expressed as QALYs, using preference based utility weights for health states based on
published data. Discounting was 5% and a lifetime horizon was taken. RESULTS:
The model predicts higher quality adjusted survival for patients on dronedarone:
between 1.13 and 2.01 QALYs depending on comparator. In Canada, the resulting
ICERs (per QALY) are C$5600 compared to amiodarone, C$5300 compared to flecainide, and C$5300 compared to sotalol. Results were sensitive to differences in risk
of mortality between treatment groups. CONCLUSIONS: Dronedarone represents a
cost-effective treatment for patients with atrial fibrillation in Canada.
PCV76
COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS OF DRONEDARONE IN PATIENTS
WITH ATRIAL FIBRILLATION IN MEXICO: A WITHIN TRIAL ANALYSIS
BASED ON ATHENA TRIAL
Martinez E1, Lemus A2, Soto H3
1
Cardiology Hospital CMN Siglo XXI, Mexico City, D.F., Mexico; 2Sanofi-Aventis, D.F.,
Mexico City, Mexico; 3ESEA, Mexico City, D.F., Mexico
OBJECTIVES: To perform a cost-effectiveness analysis (CEA) for the use of dronedarone in patients with atrial fibrillation (AF) in order to prevent hospitalizations due
to cardiovascular events or death (HCED), from the public health care system perspec-
A355
tive in Mexico. METHODS: A CEA was made based on the clinical information from
the multicenter, randomized, clinical study ATHENA, where dronedarone was compared to placebo on top of standard treatment in patients with AF. Overall, 2301
patients were randomized to dronedarone, and 2327 to placebo. The primary clinical
endpoint was HCED. Only direct medical health care costs were calculated. The health
resource utilization was elicited from the ATHENA trial. The unit costs of each event
were obtained from the medical literature and/or validated by local experts, whenever
information was not available. Most of the cost information is based on IMSS (Social
Security) figures, and updated to year 2009 (1c = MX$17.05). a discount rate of 5%
was used. An incremental cost-effectiveness analysis was performed complemented by
a deterministic sensitivity analysis (DSA) to assess robustness of the model. RESULTS:
Patients randomized to dronedarone experienced 1190 events of HCED (average rate
0.51 [CI 95%: 0.47–0.55]) while patients in the placebo group had 1601 (average
rate 0.69 [CI 95%: 0.64–0.74]), or −415 events, 18% less hospitalizations (CI 95%:
12–25%) for the dronedarone group. The average cost per patient in the dronedarone
group was c3028 as compared to the placebo group of c2,941, yielding a cost difference of c87.4, and an avoided incremental cost per HCED of c477.00 of dronedarone
vs. the placebo group. The DSA shows the analysis is robust. CONCLUSIONS:
According to the ATHENA trial, dronedarone is a cost-effective treatment option for
the reduction of HCED from the Mexican perspective. Dronedarone’s value could be
enhanced if indirect costs averted from the decreased rates of HCED included.
PCV77
A SIMULATION MODEL TO ASSESS COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF STATINS
IN HIGH RISK PATIENTS WITH ELEVATED LDL-C IN SPAIN
Darba J1, Restovic G2, Kaskens L2, Tunceli K3, Plans P4
1
Universitat de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain; 2BCN Health, Barcelona, Spain; 3Merck,
Whitehouse Station, NJ, USA; 4Generalitat de Catalunya, Barcelona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study is to estimate cost-effectiveness of lowering lowdensity lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-C) with statin monotherapy in patients with
elevated LDL-C with two or more cardiovascular risk factors or either coronary heart
disease (CHD) in Spain. METHODS: A Markov model was developed to represent
the transition of a cohort of patients with elevated LDL-C or with CHD at risk of a
cardiovascular event (CVE) through four health states: patients with LDL-C, CVE,
death by CVE and death by other causes. Probabilities of a CVE in females and males
were determined, based on CHD risks estimated trough locally-adjusted Framingham
risk equations using data from the DORICA and PRIMULA study. LDL-C lowering
efficacy of statins, mortality, and health-state utilities were obtained from published
scientific literature. Cardiovascular risk factors included were age, systolic blood pressure, diabetes, smoking and high-density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL-C). Treatment
and CVE direct medical costs were obtained from a medication database and DRGs
for public hospitals in 2009 in Spain. Deterministic results were estimated and a
probabilistic sensitivity analysis was conducted. Results were expressed as expected
cost per quality adjusted life-years (QALYs) gained. RESULTS: In deterministic analyses, expected costs per patient per year at age of 40 were higher for patients with 2
or more cardiovascular risk factors who were not treated than those who were treated
(female: c41,300 vs. c40,106; male: c22,160 vs. c18,333). Effectiveness was higher
for treated patients in both genders (female: 0.17 QALY; male: 0.37 QALY). Similar
results were found for patients with CHD (female: c35,706 vs. c34,664, 0.10 QALY;
male: c16,892 vs. c16,073, 0.12 QALY). CONCLUSIONS: From the perspective of
the Spanish health care system, treatment with statin monotherapy is considered to
be cost-effective versus no treatment in female and male patients with 2 or more risk
factors or CHD.
PCV78
COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS OF IVABRADINE IN CHRONIC
STABLE ANGINA PATIENTS IN AN AUSTRIAN SETTING
Schwarz B1, Wild R2
1
Center for Public Health, Medical University Vienna, Baden bei Wien, Austria; 2Servier
Austria GmbH, Vienna, Austria
OBJECTIVES: High resting heart rate (HR) has been progressively accepted as a
modifiable cardiovascular risk factor. Ivabradine (ProcoralanÒ) is a specific HR lowering agent. This study aimed estimating the cost-effectiveness of ivabradine in stable
angina patients with a normal sinus rhythm and a resting HR above 70 beats per
minute (bpm) from the Austrian health care perspective: 1) versus generic diltiazem
when beta-blockers (BB) are contra-indicated or non tolerated; and 2) in combination
with generic atenolol versus generic atenolol alone. METHODS: A Markov chain
Monte Carlo stochastic simulation model was used to estimate the influence of HR
lowering in cardiovascular morbidity and mortality and its economic consequences.
Treatments considered are ivabradine, 7.5 mg twice a day, diltiazem, 240 mg once a
day and atenolol 50 mg once a day. HR distribution, survival and time to hospitalization were modelled as weibull functions. Events considered were acute myocardial
infarction, stroke, heart failure, death and revascularization procedures. Only direct
medical costs were included. Effectiveness was measured in quality-adjusted life-years
(QALYs). Time horizon was set at 20 years and discount rates for costs and effectiveness were 3%/year. RESULTS: The between-group difference in HR reduction was
−6.4 bpm and −8.8 bpm in favour of ivabradine strategy in targeted patient populations 1) and 2) respectively. Incremental ivabradine strategy cost was c6789 versus
generic diltiazem and c6749 versus generic atenolol. Incremental QALYs were 1.067
and 1.076 respectively. Incremental cost-effectiveness ratios for ivabradine strategy
were c5800/QALY and c6273/QALY. Deterministic sensitivity analyses showed that
A356
ivabradine strategy is cost-effective in both approaches in all cases at a willingness to
pay threshold of c22,000/QALY. CONCLUSIONS: In an Austrian setting, ivabradine
is a cost-effective treatment in stable angina patients with resting HR > 70 bpm.
PCV79
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF DRONEDARONE IN SOUTH KOREA
1
1
2
3
Jo MW , Kim SH , Choi Y , Kim J
1
University of Ulsan College of Medicine, Seoul, South Korea; 2sanofi-aventis Korea, Seoul,
South Korea; 3Pusan National University Yangsan Hospital, Yangsan, Gyeongnam, South
Korea
OBJECTIVES: Atrial fibrillation (AF) contributes for stroke, sudden death, heart
failure, markedly reduced exercise capacity and degraded quality of life. Therefore,
an effective treatment of AF is expected to reduce cardiovascular (CV) events and their
costs. In 2010, dronedarone has been approved by Korean FDA for risk reduction of
CV hospitalization in patients who are in sinus rhythm or who will be cardioverted
with relevant conditions. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the cost-effectiveness
of dronedarone compared with amiodarone in Korea. METHODS: We used the
Markov simulation model for AF patients consisting with health states for AF treatment, off-AF treatment, symptomatic AF recurrences, stroke, acute coronary syndromes, congestive heart failure and death. Transitional probability was obtained
from ATHENA trial and published literatures. Patient baseline, drug cost, initiation
and monitoring cost of AF treatment, disease state cost and adverse event cost were
obtained from national insurance claim database. The effectiveness of amiodarone vs.
dronedarone was drawn from results of mixed treatment comparison. Discount rate
for cost and effectiveness were applied as 5%. From the societal perspectives, we
evaluated cost for life-year gained (LYG) and quality adjusted life-years (QALYs) until
patients become 100 years old. Subgroup analysis and sensitivity analysis was performed to deal with uncertainty. RESULTS: In the base-case analysis, the incremental
cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of dronedarone versus Amiodarone was approximately
c2344/LYG (KRW 3.75 million, 1 Euro = 1600 KRW). Results were robust across
subgroups. The ranges of ICER in the sensitivity analysis were from around c1875 ~
c3750/LYG (KRW 3 to 6 million/LYG). Fifty percent of simulations in probabilistic
sensitivity analysis fall below a willingness-to-pay of about c3750 per QALYs (KRW
6 million per QALYs). CONCLUSIONS: These results showed that dronedarone is
to be cost-effective vs. amiodarone for AF patients in Korea.
PCV80
THE COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF AMLODIPINE BESYLATE VERSUS
PLACEBO FOR THE PREVENTION OF CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE IN
KOREA
Lee HY1, Park HJ2, Ko SK2
1
Seoul National University Hospital, Seoul, South Korea; 2Pfizer Pharmaceuticals Korea Ltd,
Seoul, South Korea
OBJECTIVES: Antihypertensive therapy is a well-established approach to reducing
the risk of cardiovascular disease (CVD). Amlodipine besylate, a calcium channel
blocker, has been shown to be an effective antihypertensive agent. The objective of
this study was to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of antihypertensive therapy with
amlodipine besylate for the prevention of CVD in Korea from a health care perspective
over a lifetime. METHODS: To estimate long-term cost and effects, a Markov model
consisting of nine health states was constructed: Healthy with hypertension, Angina,
Myocardial Infarction (MI), Post-MI, Stroke, Post-stroke, CHD death, CVD death,
non-CVD cause death. One health state to another can occur with a certain probability
at yearly intervals. The incidence of CVD was obtained from published local sources,
whereas the risk reductions associated with antihypertensive therapy were taken from
the medical literature, selected studies randomly assigned amlodipine besylate or
placebo and followed up for at least 1 year. Utility values for CVD and costs of
amlodipine besylate were drawn from published literature based on 2005 Korea
National Health and Nutritional Examination Survey (KNHANES) data, and Korean
pharmaceutical pricing lists, respectively. Costs for CVD were found in published
cost-of-illness studies based on local hospital charge data. Patient outcomes were
modeled for 45 years, and incremental cost-effectiveness ratios were calculated for
amlodipine besylate compared with placebo. RESULTS: For a 55-year-old patient
with hypertension, the incremental cost of amlodipine besylate compared with placebo
was 3,213,660 Korean won (KW) per patient, although the incremental effectiveness
of amlodipine besylate was 0.210 quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs) gained per
patient. Therefore, the incremental cost-effectiveness ratios associated with amlodipine
besylate were 15,288,941 KW/QALY, compared to no treatment. Sensitivity analyses
indicated these results to be robust. CONCLUSIONS: The results from the model
indicate that amlodipine besylate provides a cost-effective antihypertensive treatment
strategy for the prevention of CVD in Korea.
PCV81
THE COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS AND THE
COSTS OF USING THE LOW-MOLECULAR-WEIGHT HEPARINS AND
THE ORAL ANTICOAGULANTS FOR THE TREATMENT OF THE
VENOUS THROMBOEMBOLISM IN POLAND
Bochenek T, Nizankowski R
Jagiellonian University, Collegium Medicum, Krakow, Poland
OBJECTIVES: The currently recommended standard treatment of the venous thromboembolism (VTE) are the oral anticoagulants (OA) in the majority of patients and
the low-molecular-weight heparins (LMWH) in the selected subpopulations. The
13th Euro Abstracts
titration of the OA doses is difficult and often ineffective. The goal of this research
was to compare the OA and the LMWH in the VTE treatment in terms of effectiveness,
safety and cost-effectiveness. METHODS: The systematic review of the scientific literature comparing the VTE treatment with OA and LMWH was performed. Among
others, the resources of the Cochrane Library, the MEDLINE, the Embase and the
Biomed Central were searched. The metaanalysis of the reported treatment outcomes
was performed using the RevMan5® software. The cost analysis and the cost-effectiveness analysis were performed. The data on the costs of treatment of the VTE in
Poland were collected through the retrospective review of patient records obtained
from the three hospitals and the anticoagulation clinic in the Krakow area, the pharmaceutical reimbursement databases and the public payer’s charge tariffs for the
medical services. The modeling (decision tree) was performed using the TreeAgePro2009® software. RESULTS: The most important differences between the OA and
the LMWH were related to the better prevention of the VTE incidence and the better
prevention of the small bleedings. With respect to none of the assessed outcomes the
OA were better than the LMWH. Within a six month treatment period the Incremental
Cost-Effectiveness Ratio of avoiding the complication incidents was 49,865 zlotys
(c12,242) from the payer perspective and 3,609 zlotys (c887) from the patient perspective. CONCLUSIONS: The LMWH offer the better effectiveness and safety than the
OA but their cost-effectiveness is still limited by the relatively high prices of the
LMWH.
PCV82
COMMUNICATING COST-EFFECTIVENSS RATIOS TO DECISION
MAKERS—THE CASE OF SWEDISH NATIONAL GUIDELINES FOR
HEART DISEASES
Eckard N1, Janzon M2, Levin LÅ1
1
Linköping University, Linköping, Sweden; 2Linköping University, Linköping University
Hospital, Linköping, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: Despite the continuing interest in health economic research, we could
find no comprehensive and accessible data set on costs and effects, useful as practical
information for decision makers who must allocate scarce resources within the cardiovascular field. The objective of this study was to present the cost-effectiveness
league table, used in the Swedish national guidelines for heart disease and highlight
issues of importance when communicating and interpreting cost-effectiveness evidence
to decision makers. METHODS: A unique systematic literature search for the treatment of heart diseases was conducted. We then compiled all available cost-effectiveness ratios for different heart conditions and treatment strategies, in a so called league
table. All cost-effectiveness results were expressed as a cost per quality adjusted lifeyears (QALY) or life-year gained. The league table was broken down to illustrate how
health economic results may be communicated and made accessible to decision
makers. We have highlighted methodological issues when interpreting cost-effectiveness league tables by using implantable cardioverter defibrillators (ICDs) as an
example. RESULTS: More than 200 cost-effectiveness ratios were found and compiled
in the league table ranging from dominant to c950,000 per QALY. Using ICD as an
example we identified various problems when interpreting league table results. The
results are context specific, time dependant, comparator dependent, often based on
point-estimates giving a false sense of precision. CONCLUSIONS: League tables
provide a means of presenting cost-effectiveness evidence aiding decision makers with
valid information within a limited space. We have given examples and presented ways
of communicating cost-effectiveness results for e.g. target groups, focusing on how
information included in a cost-effectiveness league table may be interpreted and
conveyed and used as a tool in the decision-making process.
PCV83
PILOTING THE DEVELOPMENT OF A COST-EFFECTIVE EVIDENCEINFORMED CLINICAL PATHWAY: MANAGING HYPERTENSION IN
JORDANIAN PRIMARY CARE
Chalkidou K1, Lord J1, Obeidat N2, Alabbadi I3, Stanley A1, Bader R2, Momani A2,
O’Mahony R2, Qatami L2, Cutler D1
1
National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence, London, UK; 2Medicines Transparency
Alliance, Amman, Jordan; 3University of Jordan, Amman, Jordan
OBJECTIVES: The UK’s National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE)
and the Jordan office of the Medicines Transparency Alliance embarked on a pilot
project to design an evidence-based guideline for cost-effective pharmacological treatment of essential hypertension in Jordan. The project’s objectives were to directly
address a major health problem for Jordan by producing a guideline; and to delineate
the strengths and weaknesses of Jordan’s health care process to allow similar future
efforts to be planned more efficiently. METHODS: The pilot spanned a period of
approximately 8 months. Activities were overseen by local technical and guideline
development teams, as well as experts from NICE. NICE’s hypertension guidelines
and economic model were used as a starting point. Parameters in the economic model
were adjusted according to input and feedback from local experts with regards to
Jordanian physician and patient practices, resource costs, and quality of life estimates.
The results of the economic model were integrated with the updated available clinical
trial literature. RESULTS: The outputs of the economic model were used to inform
recommendations, in the form of a clinical algorithm. a report of the process and the
strengths and weaknesses observed was developed, and recommendations for improvements made. CONCLUSIONS: The pilot represented the start of what is intended to
be a health care process change for the country of Jordan. Issues emerged which can
inform strategies to ensure a more cohesive and comprehensive health care approach
13th Euro Abstracts
to the cost-effective use of appropriate drugs in managing chronic disease. The project
highlighted how countries with relevant experience in evidence-informed policy
making in health care can assist others in strengthening their decision-making systems.
PCV84
ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF IMPLANTABLE LOOP RECORDER IN THE
DIAGNOSIS OF SYNCOPE, UPDATE FROM THE SPANISH NATIONAL
HEALTH SYSTEM
García Baena I1, García García2 FJ2, Navascues R3, Marti B3
1
Universitat Pompeu Fabra, Barcelona, Spain, Barcelona, Spain; 2Subdirector Médico Área
Médica,, Las Palmas de Gran Canaria, , Spain; 3Medtronic Iberia, Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to evaluate costs and benefits of diagnosing
patients with syncope of unknown aetiology with implanted loop recorders compared
to clinical practice (conventional investigation) of an electrophysiology, from the
Spanish National Health System perspective. METHODS: Based on an economic
decision analysis model, the cost-effectiveness study analyses diagnostic yield results
from clinical practice versus Reveal DX®, with a time horizon of one year. Clinical
data and resource use was obtained from a randomised controlled trial and expert
opinion. Cost data was expressed in Euros 2010. a univariate sensitivity analysis was
carried out to analyze the robustness of the model by modifying the number of outpatient visits, the costs and the diagnostic yield for both strategies. RESULTS: The
incremental cost-effectiveness Ratio of Reveal DX® versus conventional investigation
was c3167 per additional diagnosis, resulting in a confidence interval of 95% of the
incremental cost-effectiveness ratio of c2335–c4867 per additional diagnosis made.
The results of the univariate sensitivity analyses did not change the main results from
our study. CONCLUSIONS: Reveal DX® in the diagnosis of syncope of unknown
aetiology after an initial evaluation is a cost-effective strategy compared to conventional diagnosis for the Spanish Health System, since it increases diagnostic yield at a
reasonable incremental cost.
PCV85
PRASUGREL VS. CLOPIDOGREL IN PATIENTS WITH ACUTE
CORONARY SYNDROME UNDERGOING PERCUTANEOUS CORONARY
INTERVENTION: A SPANISH MODEL-BASED COST-EFFECTIVENESS
ANALYSIS
Davies A1, Sculpher MJ2, Barrett A3, Valladares A4, Huete T4, Dilla T4
1
Oxford Outcomes (UK), Botley, Oxford, UK; 2The University of York, York, UK; 3Eli Lilly &
Company, UK, Windlesham, Surrey, UK; 4Eli Lilly & Company, Spain, Alcobendas, Madrid,
Spain
OBJECTIVES: In patients with acute coronary syndrome (ACS) undergoing percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI), the TRITON-TIMI 38 trial (TT38) demonstrated
that treatment with prasugrel vs. clopidogrel was associated with significantly reduced
rates of atherothrombotic events, though with increased risk of bleeding. The aim of
the analysis was to evaluate the long-term cost-effectiveness of a 12-month treatment
with prasugrel vs. clopidogrel in the trial population, excluding patients with prior
transient ischemic attack or stroke, from the perspective of the Spanish health care
system. METHODS: A Markov model was developed based on risk equations for
cardiovascular death, myocardial infarction (MI) or stroke, bleeding, and rehospitalization, derived from TT38 data (N = 13,608 patients). Cost variables included were
medication and hospitalizations costs. Hospital readmissions captured during TT38
in all patients from 8 countries (N = 6705) were assigned to Spanish diagnosis related
groups, and were modelled to accrue over the life-time horizon. Long term survival
and quality adjusted survival were estimated for the life-time of each patient.
RESULTS: At 12 months, a difference in drug costs between prasugrel and clopidogrel
of +c77 (branded clopidogrel) to +c460 (generic clopidogrel) per patient was partially
offset by hospital cost savings (−c97 per patient) due principally to reduced rates of
revascularization. In the longer-term, prasugrel was associated with higher total costs
(+c11 to +c395 per patient), life expectancy gains of 0.07 years, due primarily to the
reduced rate of MI, and 0.05 additional QALYs, resulting in incremental costs per
life-year saved and per QALY gained of c164 to c5718 and c216 to c7540, respectively. Probabilistic sensitivity analysis indicated that prasugrel has a 68% to 72%
probability of being more cost-effective than clopidogrel at a willingness to pay of
c30,000 per QALY. CONCLUSIONS: Among ACS-PCI patients, these results showed
prasugrel to be within the bounds of reasonable cost-effectiveness for Spain in comparison with clopidogrel.
PCV86
ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF DRONEDARONE IN TREATMENT OF
ATRIAL FIBRILLATION IN GREECE
Maniadakis N, Fragoulakis V, Athanasakis K, Kyriopoulos J
National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece
OBJECTIVES: Atrial Fibrillation (AF) is a common cardiac arrhythmia and a significant cause of morbidity and mortality worldwide. As it is necessary to maximize value
from the money spent in health care, an economic evaluation was undertaken to
compare a new therapy, Dronedarone, in relation to Amiodarone, Sotalol and
Propafenone already used in the Greek National Health Service (NHS) setting.
METHODS: An international Markov model was locally adapted. The model reflects
the management and the progression of AF patients through different health states in
the course of their life time, including stroke, post stroke, heart failure (HF), post-HF,
acute coronary symptom (ACS) post-ACS and death. Clinical and quality of life data
to populate the model were derived from a variety of relevant clinical studies and
A357
registries including: ATHENA, AFTER, DIONYSOS, AFFIRM and synthesizing
analyses undertaken by academic experts. Resource utilization and cost data were
derived by means of a large and representative panel of local experts, who utilized
patient data files and data which came from a sample of NHS hospitals. Data refer
to the year 2010 and all outcomes were discounted at a rate of 3.5%. The model is
probabilistic to account for uncertainly and mean estimates are reported with corresponding uncertainty intervals. RESULTS: Mean total treatment costs were: Dronedarone: c12,931 (95%UI: 12,065–c12,495); Amiodarone: c8893 (95%UI: c8685–c9100);
Sotalol: c6,185 (95%UI: c5901–c6509); Propafenone: c8433 (95%UI: c8229–c8642).
The incremental cost-per-life-year-gained with Dronedarone versus Amiodarone was:
c2236 (95%UI: 1897–c2615), versus Sotalol: c2576 (95%UI: c2442–c2822 and
versus Propafenone: c2718 (95%UI: c2497–c3395). The incremental cost-per-qualityadjusted-life-year gained with Dronedarone versus Amiodarone was: c3275 (95%UI:
2730–c3838), versus Sotalol: c4319 (95%UI: c4130–c4510) and versus Propafenone:
c3138 (95%UI: c2571–c4004). CONCLUSIONS: The newly available treatment
Dronedarone appears to be a cost-effective alternative to other already existing therapies, used in the management of Atrial Fibrillation patients in the Greek NHS.
PCV87
USING VALUE OF INFORMATION ANALYSIS IN COMBINATION WITH
AN EARLY STAGE MODEL OF COREVALVE FOR SEVERE AORTIC
STENOSIS TO INFORM FUTURE RESEARCH NEEDS
Mealing S, Watt M, Sculpher M, Eaton JN
Oxford Outcomes Ltd, Oxford, Oxon, UK
OBJECTIVES: Aortic Stenosis (AS) is a severe cardiovascular condition the treatment
of which often involves a major operation. For a subgroup of patients medical management (MM) is the only treatment option due to procedural risk. a transcatheter aortic
valve implantation device “CoreValve,” is a novel procedure, is less invasive and
allows for the implantation of a replacement valve in this patient group. Since information is not yet available on key clinical parameters, we modified an existing early stage
economic model to perform a value of information (VoI) analysis to informing the
prioritization of future research. METHODS: The underlying model used in the
analysis is a 10-year Markov model was developed in Microsoft Excel. Treatment
options were CoreValve and MM with parameters derived from published literature.
All costs were taken from the most recent published sources. Decrements were applied
to age-specific EQ-5D population norms to generate QALYs. a probabilistic sensitivity
was used to inform the global Expected Value of Perfect Information (EVPI) calculation. Deterministic one way analyses were used to select the variable groups and
individual parameters on which partial EVPI (EVPPI) calculations were performed.
Annual incident population estimates were derived from information in a large
national database. RESULTS: Assuming a decision horizon of 10 years, an annual
incident population of 4052 and a willingness to pay threshold of £30,000 per QALY
gained the EVPI is £11.3 million. EVPPI estimates were generated for costs, utilities,
overall survival (MM patients) and treatment effects. Of these, the VoI for baseline
mortality and long term mortality reduction were greatest (£21,364,000 and
£8,151,000 respectively). The VoI for all others was negligible CONCLUSIONS:
Further information on long term survival would have the greatest impact on decision
uncertainty. Thus, a new clinical trial may not be required and a registry may be more
appropriate.
PCV89
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF DRONEDARONE FOR THE TREATMENT OF
ATRIAL FIBRILLATION IN THE UK
Brereton NJ1, Craig AM2, Akehurst R3
1
BresMed Health Solutions, Sheffield, South Yorkshire, UK; 2Sanofi-Aventis, Guildford, Surrey,
UK; 3ScHARR, The University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of dronedarone for the treatment of
atrial fibrillation (AF) compared to current antiarrhythmic drugs (AADs), from a UK
NHS perspective. METHODS: A cost-utility analysis was performed, for which an
individual patient lifetime discrete event simulation model was constructed. The model
predicted a patient’s course for a treatment pathway based on the current National
Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) AF guidelines and compared treatment with amiodarone, sotalol and Class 1c agents to dronedarone. The model consisted
of seven AF-related events; AF recurrence, acute coronary syndromes, stroke, congestive
heart failure, treatment discontinuation, AF status change and mortality. Between events
patients resided in four health states; normal sinus rhythm, permanent AF with uncontrolled symptoms, permanent AF with controlled symptoms and death. Patient’s baseline
event risks were estimated from the non-active comparator arm of the ATHENA trial
then adjusted for treatment effects based on a mixed treatment comparison. Cost data
were elicited from existing literature and UK reference costs. Quality of life estimates
were based on data from the AFTER cohort. Cost-effectiveness was measured in cost
per quality adjusted life-year (QALY) gained. Costs and QALYs were discounted at
3.5%. One-way and probabilistic sensitivity analyses (PSA) were performed. RESULTS:
Dronedarone was shown to be cost-effective with incremental cost-effectiveness ratios
of £2,406 versus amiodarone, £1,911 versus sotalol and £18,737 versus Class 1c
agents. One-way sensitivity analysis showed that treatment effect on mortality was
the key driver of cost-effectiveness. PSA results estimated that dronedarone was costeffective at an acceptability threshold of £20,000 on 95% of occasions compared to
amiodarone and sotalol and on 60% of occasions compared to Class 1c agents.
CONCLUSIONS: The results of this analysis demonstrate that in the UK setting
dronedarone is a cost-effective treatment of AF compared to current AAD
treatment.
A358
PCV90
THE COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF ROSUVASTATIN VERSUS SIMVASTATIN
FOR THE PREVENTION OF CARDIOVASCULAR MORBIDITY AND
MORTALITY IN PATIENTS WITH HIGH BASELINE RISK—A SWEDISH
ECONOMIC EVALUATION BASED UPON THE JUPITER TRIAL
Olsson AG1, Jensen MM2, Gandhi SK3, Smolen L4, Paulsson T5
1
Linköping University Sweden, Linköping, Sweden; 2AstraZeneca, Lund, Sweden;
3
AstraZeneca LP, Wilmington, DE, USA; 4Medical Decision Modeling Inc., Indianapolis, IN,
USA; 5AstraZeneca Nordic MC, Södertälje, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: To assess the long-term cost-effectiveness of various doses of rosuvastatin (R) versus relevant doses of simvastatin (S) (R20 mg versus S40 mg (primary
analysis), R10 versus S20 and R10 versus S40) in a patient population with high risk
of cardiovascular events (10-year Framingham CVD risk ≥ 20%). METHODS: A
Monte Carlo simulation model was developed based on the JUPITER (Justification
for the Use of statins in Primary prevention: an Intervention Trial evaluating Rosuvastatin, NCT00239681) trial findings and includes modeling of cardiovascular events
and death over the lifetime of patients. The relative efficacy of S20, S40 and R10
compared with R20 (as observed in JUPITER) was estimated by computing relative
10-year Framingham cardiovascular event risks based on reported differences in Total
Cholesterol/High-Density Lipoprotein cholesterol ratio. Epidemiological data specific
for the Swedish setting were utilized to model post-event mortality and long-term
overall mortality in event-free patients. Incremental effectiveness was primarily measured as quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs) gained. Cost-effectiveness was assessed
based upon direct costs. All effects and costs (in 2008/09 Swedish unit prices) were
discounted at annual 3%. RESULTS: The model estimated that treating a cohort of
100,000 patients (66 years, 60% males) with R20 mg avoided 2642 CVD events over
lifetime compared with S40 mg. This translated into an estimated gain of 9515 years
in full health (QALYs). The incremental cost per QALY gained was SEK161,712
(16,434). The cost per QALY gained was SEK228,655 (c23,237) for R10 versus S20,
and SEK234,932 (c23,875) for R10 versus S40. Probabilistic sensitivity analyses supported base-case results. CONCLUSIONS: Treatment with rosuvastatin 10 and 20 mg
is cost-effective compared with relevant doses of simvastatin in the primary prevention
of CVD for patients with high baseline cardiovascular risk (10-year Framingham CVD
risk ≥ 20%).
PCV91
THE COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF ROSUVASTATIN VERSUS
ATORVASTATIN FOR THE PREVENTION OF CARDIOVASCULAR
MORBIDITY AND MORTALITY IN PATIENTS WITH HIGH BASELINE
RISK—A SWEDISH ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF THE JUPITER TRIAL
Olsson AG1, Jensen MM2, Gandhi SK3, Fox KM4, Paulsson T5
1
Linköping University Sweden, Linköping, Sweden; 2AstraZeneca, Lund, Sweden;
3
AstraZeneca LP, Wilmington, DE, USA; 4University of Maryland School of Medicine,
Monkton, MD, USA; 5AstraZeneca Nordic MC, Södertälje, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: To assess long-term cost-effectiveness of various doses of rosuvastatin
(R) versus relevant doses of generic atorvastatin (A) (R20 mg versus A40 mg (primary
comparison), R10 versus A20 and; R40 versus A80) in patients with a high risk of
CV events (10-year Framingham CVD risk ≥ 20%). METHODS: A Monte Carlo
simulation model was developed based on JUPITER (Justification for the Use of statins
in Primary prevention: an Intervention Trial evaluating Rosuvastatin, NCT00239681)
trial findings and modeled cardiovascular events and death over the lifetime of
patients. The relative efficacy of the A20, A40, A80, R10, and R40 mg compared to
R20 mg (as observed in JUPITER) were estimated by computing relative 10-year
Framingham cardiovascular event risks based on reported differences in Total Cholesterol/High-Density Lipoprotein cholesterol ratio. Epidemiological data specific for
the Swedish setting were utilized to model mortality. Incremental effectiveness was
primarily measured as quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs) gained. Cost-effectiveness
was assessed based upon direct costs. All effects and costs (2008/09 Swedish unit
prices) were discounted at annual 3%. An 80% price reduction was assumed for
generic versus branded statin. RESULTS: The model estimated that treating a cohort
of 100,000 patients (66 years, 60% males) with R20 avoided 1121 CVD events over
lifetime compared with atorvastatin 40 mg. This translated into an estimated gain of
4090 years in full health (QALYs). The estimated incremental cost per QALY gained
was SEK366,763 (c37,273). This estimate was SEK428,060 (c43,502) for R10 versus
A20, and SEK582,241 (c59,171) for R40 versus A80. Probabilistic sensitivity analyses
supported base-case results. CONCLUSIONS: Treatment with rosuvastatin 10 mg,
20 mg and 40 mg is cost-effective compared with relevant doses of generic atorvastatin
(20 mg, 40 mg, 80 mg, respectively) for the primary prevention of cardiovascular
events for patients with high baseline cardiovascular risk (10-year Framingham CVD
risk ≥ 20%) in Sweden.
PCV92
THE HEALTH AND ECONOMIC IMPACT OF SWITCHING FROM
ATORVASTATIN TO GENERIC SIMVASTATIN IN BELGIUM
Liew D1, Webb K2, Marbaix S3
1
The University of Melbourne, Fitzroy, Victoria, Australia; 2Pfizer Limited, Surrey, UK; 3Pfizer,
Bruxelles, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: Containing pharmaceutical budgets has encouraged generic prescribing
policies. Across Europe, many patients have been switched from atorvastatin to
generic statins, particularly simvastatin, but often at lower therapeutic doses. This
study sought to estimate the potential clinical and economic effect if policy-induced
13th Euro Abstracts
switching to first generation statins occurred in Belgium as per previously observed
patterns. METHODS: A Markov micro-simulation model was populated with 80
primary prevention Belgian patients from a 2007 observational study. Risks of firstonset cardiovascular disease (CVD) were estimated using a calibrated Framingham
risk equation. With a baseline of January 2010, follow-up was simulated for 20 years.
Decision analysis estimated the marginal effects of switching all patients from atorvastatin (weighted average daily dose [WADD] 20.7 mg) to simvastatin (WADD
31.6 mg). Dose-specific, lipid-modifying effects of the two statins, CVD costs and
utilities were sourced from published data. Annual discount rates of 3% and 1.5%
were applied to costs and health effects, respectively. RESULTS: Of the 80 subjects
on atorvastatin, 23 (28.9%) were predicted to develop CVD over 20 years. In the
switched-to-simvastatin group, the predicted number was 26 (32.0%), equating to a
“number needed to harm” of 32. Switching was estimated to lead to a net cost saving
of c581 per subject, but also a loss of 0.04 QALYs. These equated to an ICER of
c13,608 per QALY gained (atorvastatin vs. simvastatin). Sensitivity analyses indicated
the results to be robust. CONCLUSIONS: Our preliminary analyses indicate that there
would be an increase in the burden of CVD if Belgian patients are switched from
atorvastatin to generic simvastatin at non-equipotent doses, as has happened in neighbouring countries like The Netherlands. This study highlights the need to consider the
potential health and health economic impact of population-based switching policies.
PCV93
THROMBOPROPHYLAXIS AFTER TOTAL KNEE REPLACEMENT:
COST-UTILITY ANALYSIS OF RIVAROXABAN VERSUS ENOXAPARIN IN
SLOVAKIA
Lukac M1, Bielik J2, Lees M3, Tomek D4, Foltan V5
1
Slovak Medical University, Bratislava, Slovak Republic; 2Trencin University, Trencin, Slovak
Republic; 3Bayer, Uxbridge, UK; 4Slovak Society for Pharmacoeconomics, Bratislava, Slovak
Republic; 5Faculty of Pharmacy, Comenius University, Bratislava, Slovak Republic
OBJECTIVES: To estimate the cost-effectiveness of rivaroxaban against enoxaparin
for the prophylaxis of venous thromboembolism (VTE) in patients after total knee
replacement (TKR) in Slovakia from payer perspective. METHODS: Previously published cost-utility model based on results of large randomized controlled trial
(RECORD 3) has been adapted to Slovakian settings. In RECORD 3, patients received
12 days prophylaxis with rivaroxaban or enoxaparin. Rivaroxaban reduced total VTE
(composite: any DVT, non-fatal PE, all-cause mortality) by 49% versus enoxaparin
after 12 days prophylaxis. The model was divided into three parts: prophylaxis, postprophylaxis, and long-term complications. The first two parts represents acute phase
and were modeled as a decision tree. Third part represents the long-term complications
and was developed as a Markov model. The first part of the model is populated by
RECORD 3 trial, while published epidemiological and clinical data estimating the risk
of further VTE events and post-thrombotic syndrome beyond the trial period were
used in second and third part of the model. Local cost data was based on published
price lists, clinical guidelines, product labels and expert opinion. VTE related utilities
were used from literature. Effectiveness was measured in quality-adjusted life-years
(QALY). Time horizon was set at 5 years and payers perspective was used. Discount
rate was 5% per year for costs and effects according to valid Ministry of Health
(MoH) guidelines for health economic evaluation. One-way and probabilistic sensitivity analyses were performed. RESULTS: Rivaroxaban produced improved outcomes
(QALY) and cost savings of c28 per patient versus enoxaparin in Slovakian setting
(dominance). Probabilistic sensitivity analysis showed dominance of rivaroxaban compared to enoxaparin in more then 99% of cases. CONCLUSIONS: Prophylaxis of
VTE with rivaroxaban following TKR may improve health outcomes and reduce direct
medical costs when compared to enoxaparin in Slovakian setting.
PCV94
POTENTIAL COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF A BIOMARKER TEST TO
STRATIFY PATIENTS INDICATED FOR A CORONARY STENT
Burgers LT, Redekop WK, Severens JL
Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: Patients requiring a coronary stent can receive a bare-metal stent (BMS)
or a drug-eluting stent (DES), but both have their advantages and disadvantages. We
estimated the potential one-year cost-effectiveness of a test to decide which stent a
patient should receive based on the risk of restenosis after a BMS implantation.
METHODS: This study was performed as part of a Dutch large-scale five-year study
(“Circulating Cells”) now underway to identify blood biomarkers to facilitate the
prevention and treatment of coronary heart disease. a Markov chain Monte Carlo
model was developed to estimate costs and effectiveness for three strategies: DES for
all patients, BMS for all patients, and use of a test (80% sensitivity & 80% specificity).
Input values were based on the literature and expert opinion. Costs were calculated
according to the health care sector perspective. Scenario and sensitivity analyses were
performed to test the robustness of the results. RESULTS: The DES-for-all strategy
was the most effective (0.840 QALYs), followed by the test strategy (0.839) and the
BMS-for-all strategy (0.838). However, it was also more costly (c8189) than the other
two (test strategy, c7475; BMS, c6905). These results meant high incremental costeffectiveness ratios for the test and DES-for-all strategies. Implanting DES in all
patients would have an important budget impact (c46,000,000) for the The Netherlands, given 36,000 interventions annually. Various input parameters had an important influence on the results, including the sensitivity, specificity and costs of the test.
CONCLUSIONS: Both DES and BMS stents are often used for PCIs in the The
Netherlands. a stratifying test has the potential to reduce costs and still achieve accept-
13th Euro Abstracts
able effects. The impact of adopting a longer time horizon to capture very late stent
thrombosis needs to be examined. The model developed in this study will be used to
facilitate further development of the biomarker test.
PCV95
ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF LIFESTYLE INTERVENTION IN PRIMARY
PREVENTION OF CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE IN 60-YEAR-OLD MEN IN
STOCKHOLM, SWEDEN
Saha S1, Lindgren P2, Johansson P2, Gerdtham UG1
1
Lund University, Lund, Sweden; 2Karolinska Institute, Stockholm, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: To assess the cost utility analysis of lifestyle interventions (diet, physical activity and diet + physical activity) at primary care for person with high risk of
cardiovascular disease by using a Markov model. METHODS: A cost-utility analysis
was performed using a 10-state Markov model of CVD (cardiovascular disease) events
applied to a cohort of 60 year-old men from the county of Stockholm, Sweden. a
previously performed randomized controlled trial of dietary advice, physical exercise
and diet + physical exercise on middle aged men of Sweden (The Sollentuna study)
was used as effectiveness of intervention. The risk of having a CVD event in primary
care was taken from The Framingham Heart Study. Lifetime costs and health effects
(QALYs, quality-adjusted life-years) were estimated, in both a health care and societal
perspective with 3% discount rate. RESULTS: The model predicts physical exercise
to be the best option at zero willingness to pay and dietary advice the best if the
decision-maker willingness to pay is higher than 60,000 SEK per QALY (1 Euro =
10.74 SEK (2009). The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER), compared with no
intervention is 77,000 SEK/ QALY from a health care perspective and 57,000 SEK/
QALY from a societal perspective. CONCLUSIONS: Based on the model estimates,
dietary advice and physical exercise both are cost-effective interventions, and the
choice depends upon the decision-maker willingness to pay.
PCV96
PRIORITIZING FURTHER RESEARCH USING THE EXPECTED VALUE OF
PERFECT INFORMATION: APPLICATION TO VENOUS
THROMBOEMBOLISM PROPHYLAXIS POST TOTAL HIP REPLACEMENT
McCullagh LM1, Walsh C2, Barry M1
1
National Centre for Pharmacoeconomics, Dublin, Ireland; 2Trinity College Dublin, Dublin,
Ireland
OBJECTIVES: To estimate the expected value of perfect information (EVPI) associated with a lifetime Markov-model which evaluated the cost-effectiveness of rivaroxaban and dabigatran compared to enoxaparin for venous thromboembolism (VTE)
prophylaxis after total hip replacement (THR). To estimate the expected value of
perfect parameter information (EVPPI). To indentify the model parameter subset
whose uncertainty drives the decision uncertainty. To decrease the uncertainty, by
collecting additional data on this subset. To investigate the impact of threshold change
on the EVPI/EVPPI values. METHODS: EVPI was determined directly from PSA and
was calculated over the threshold c0–100,000/QALY. Population EVPI (PEVPI) was
calculated based on the 5464 THR procedures performed in Ireland in 2006 and the
ENDORSE-study which revealed that 64% of at risk surgical patients in Ireland
receive recommended VTE prophylaxis. The assumptions were; a 50% policy of
choice uptake rate, a 4% discount rate and a 10-year time horizon. Alternative
assumptions of 5 and 15 years were explored. EVPPI were calculated for the 3 parameter subsets using the 2-stage Monte-Carlo algorithm. RESULTS: Base-case analysis
indicated that rivaroxaban dominated. Probabilistic analysis (PSA) indicated that at
c45,000/QALY, the probability that rivaroxaban was the most cost-effective strategy
was 67%. The PEVPI was c15.62 million. Costs had the highest EVPPI (c12.43
million), followed by probabilities (c1.45 million) and preference weights (c1.44
million). The costs subset was most sensitive to threshold. Costs were updated with
a more detailed costing study. All analyses were repeated. Base-case analysis indicated
that rivaroxaban continued to dominate. The probability that rivaroxaban was the
most cost-effective strategy increased to 81%. PEVPI decreased to c4.59 million.
EVPPI for costs decreased to c2.13 million. EVPPI for probabilities and preference
weights were c1.03 million and c0.94 million respectively. CONCLUSIONS: This
study demonstrates the application of EVPI/EVPPI analyses to quantify and decrease
uncertainty associated with the choice of VTE prophylaxis after THR in the Irish
health care setting.
CARDIOVASCULAR DISORDERS – Patient-Reported Outcomes Studies
PCV97
AN EVALUATION OF ONCE- VERSUS TWICE-DAILY DOSING ON
PERSISTENCE WITH PRESCRIPTION MEDICATIONS IN
CARDIOVASCULAR PATIENTS
Bae JP1, Zagar A1, Dobesh PP2, Klepser DG2, Anderson J1, Tomlin ME1, McCollam PL1
1
Eli Lilly & Company, Indianapolis, IN, USA; 2University of Nebraska Medical Center, Omaha,
NE, USA
OBJECTIVES: To compare patient persistence with chronic-use prescription medications between once- (QD) and twice-daily (BID) dosing. METHODS: Using a large
claims database (MarketScan), prescription medications were defined as QD if ≥80%
of claims showed a quantity/day = 1 and as BID if ≥80% of claims had a quantity/
day = 2. Data for patients (18 years or older) with a first claim in 2007 were selected
for analysis and were further limited to 4 classes of medications frequently used by
A359
cardiovascular patients: antiplatelet, general cardiac, antihyperlipidemic, or antidiabetic medications. Persistence was measured by time-to-discontinuation (TTD),
defined as the number of days from the first prescription filled to the first gap of >30
days between exhausting the supplied medication and filling the next prescription. The
mean TTD with censoring at 365 days was estimated. a proportional hazards model
accounting for within-patient correlations in patients using multiple medications was
used to model the TTD. The model was stratified on medication class and adjusted
for baseline confounding variables (gender, age, Charlson Comorbidity Index).
RESULTS: A total of 1,077,936 patients were included, and the number of patientmedication combinations was 1,440,917 (QD: 1,384,565 and BID: 56,352). The
estimated mean TTD for BID compared to QD was −8% overall (P < 0.01) and −32%
for antiplatelet agents (P < 0.01), −22% for antihyperlipidemic agents (P < 0.01),
−10% for antidiabetic agents (P < 0.01), and 1% for cardiac agents (P < 0.05).
CONCLUSIONS: In this unique, recent, claims analysis, investigating multiple therapeutic classes of medications in a large database, persistence with antidiabetic, antihyperlipidemic, and antiplatelet agents was greater with QD compared with BID
dosing; however, a wide range in the differences in persistence between QD and BID
dosing was noted between therapeutic classes. Persistence may prevent subsequent
adverse events.
PCV98
IMPACT OF MEDICATION ADHERENCE ON HEALTH CARE
EXPENDITURES BY MEDICARE BENEFICIARIES WITH HEART FAILURE
Lopert R1, Shoemaker JS2, Stuart B3, Davidoff A3, Shaffer T3, Lloyd J2
1
Therapeutic Goods Administration, Canberra, Australia; 2University of Maryland Baltimore,
Baltimore, MD, USA; 3University of Maryland School of Pharmacy, Baltimore, MD, USA
OBJECTIVES: Various studies have sought to determine the impact of medication
adherence on medical expenditure among the elderly with chronic conditions. To date,
none have looked explicitly at adherence to treatment in cardiac failure, a common
condition in the elderly. This study had two aims: 1) to measure adherence to treatment for recommended heart failure medications, and 2) to assess whether better
adherence is associated with lower spending among Medicare beneficiaries.
METHODS: We used data from the 1997–2005 Medicare Current Beneficiary Survey
to track utilization rates for cardiac failure medications over three years in a nationally-representative sample of Medicare beneficiaries. The relationship between MPR
and Medicare costs was tested in a sequence of multivariate models with extensive
behavioral variables to control for healthy adherer bias and reverse causality.
RESULTS: Over 3 years, median MPR values were 0.77 for ACE-I/ARB users, 0.74
for beta blockers, 0.82 for diuretics and 0.74 for cardiac glycosides. Higher adherence
rates were consistently associated with lower Medicare spending in every model tested.
The estimated marginal effect of a 10 point increase in MPR for an ACE-I or ARB
was a reduction in cumulative 3-year Medicare spending of $390 (P < 0.05) in 2006
dollars. Similar increases in MPRs for beta blocker, diuretics, and cardiac glycosides
were associated with $861 (P < 0.01), $520 (P < 0.01) and $2318 (P < 0.01) in lower
Medicare costs respectively over three years. CONCLUSIONS: Higher levels of adherence to recommended CHF regimens by Medicare beneficiaries were associated with
lower cumulative Medicare spending over three years, with savings generally exceeding the cost of the drugs.
PCV99
COMPLIANCE AND PERSISTENCE WITH ANTIHYPERTENSIVES IN THE
NETHERLANDS; A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS WITH SPECIFIC FOCUS
ON RAAS INTERVENING AGENTS
Vegter S, Visser ST, Boersma C, Postma MJ
University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: Inaccurate use of chronic medication is associated with worse disease
prognosis and high health care costs. Differences in drug prices might be outweighted
by differences in costs due to compliance and persistence. The aim of this study was
to investigate compliance and persistence with antihypertensive agents acting on the
renin-angiotensin-aldosterone-system (RAAS). METHODS: A cohort study was conducted based on pharmacy dispensing records (IADB.nl). Subjects were included who
initiated treatment with either ACE-inhibitors (ACEi) or angiotensin receptor blockers
(ARBs) between 1999 and 2007. a standardized toolbox was used, Refill-Sequence
analyses (RS) measured persistence; Proportion of Days Covered analyses (PDC)
measured one-year compliance. Differences in persistence were adjusted for age,
gender and time of treatment initiation. RESULTS: A total of 27,544 patients initiated
treatment with ACEi; 8,649 patients initiated treatment with ARBs. Using a grace
period of 60 days, persistence with ARBs was better compared to ACEi, adjusted HR:
0.90 (95%CI: 0.84–0.96). Using a PDC cutpoint of 80%, one-year compliance with
ARBa was also better compared to ACEi, 83.9% vs. 86.3%, P < 0.01. Within ACEi’s,
differences in persistence between drugs were small. Within ARBs, persistence with
losartan or valsertan was higher compared to irbesartan or candesartan, adjusted HR:
0.82 (0.74–0.90). Compliance within ARBs however was similar for all drugs (P =
0.27). Results were consistent when other grace periods or PDC cutpoints were used.
CONCLUSIONS: Chronic users of ARBs were more compliant and persistent compared to users of ACEi. Differences in persistence within ARBs might be due to differences in drug tolerability and safety, but also due to differences in drug indications.
Further results will be presented further exploring these findings, as well as analyzing
differences in persistence between branded versus generic ACEi.
A360
PCV100
THE EFFECTS OF DOSING COMPLEXITY ON ADHERENCE WITH
PRESCRIPTION MEDICATIONS COMMONLY USED FOR
CARDIOVASCULAR PATIENTS
Bae JP1, Anderson J1, Zagar A1, Dobesh PP2, Klepser DG2, Tomlin ME1, McCollam PL1
1
Eli Lilly & Company, Indianapolis, IN, USA; 2University of Nebraska Medical Center, Omaha,
NE, USA
OBJECTIVES: To compare patient adherence with chronic-use prescription medications between once- (QD) and twice-daily (BID) dosing. METHODS: Using a large
claims database (MarketScan), prescription medications were defined as QD if ≥80%
of claims showed a quantity/day = 1 and were defined as BID if ≥80% of claims had
a quantity/day = 2. Data for patients (18 years or older) with the first claim in 2007
were selected for analysis and were further limited to 4 classes of medications frequently used by cardiovascular patients: antiplatelet, general cardiac, antihyperlipidemic, or antidiabetic medications. Adherence was measured by medication possession
ratio (MPR) defined as the number of days of medication supplied (between the first
prescription fill date and 365 days following)/365 days. a linear model (generalized
estimating equation) accounting for within-patient correlations in patients using multiple medications was used to model the MPR. The model was stratified on medication
class and adjusted for baseline confounding variables (gender, age, Charlson Comorbidity Index). RESULTS: A total of 1,077,936 patients were included, and the number
of patient-medication combinations was 1,440,917 (QD: 1,384,565 and BID: 56,352).
The mean MPR for BID compared to QD was −5% overall and −28% for antiplatelet
agents, −19% for antihyperlipidemic agents, −7% for antidiabetic agents, and 3% for
cardiac agents (P < 0.01 for all comparisons). CONCLUSIONS: This unique, recent,
claims analysis, which investigated multiple therapeutic classes of medications in a
large database, generally found lower adherence in BID dosing in medications frequently used by cardiovascular patients; however, a wide range in the MPR differences
between QD and BID dosing was observed between the therapeutic classes. Further
research is needed to investigate the relationship between dosing complexity and
therapeutic class of medications and subsequent patient adherence.
PCV101
THE IMPACT OF MEDICATION SWITCHES INDUCES BY MEDICATION
DISCOUNT CONTRACTS ON CHRONIC PATIENTS’ ADHERENCE
Groth A1, Mueller S2, Wilke T1
1
Institute for Pharmacoeconomics and Drug Logistics, University of Wismar, Wismar,
Germany; 2University of Wismar, Wismar, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Switching of medications due to non-medical grounds may be a critical
factor influencing patients’ medication-based adherence (NA). The aim of this analysis
is to examine the effects of medication switching on NA for hypertonic/diabetic (type
II) patients. Only switches between medications containing the same active ingredient
were examined. METHODS: Prescriptions filled at 5 German pharmacies over a
period of 2 years were analyzed. Patients who had filled prescriptions for at least 3
medications to control hypertonia (focus on Moxonidin—ATC-Code C02AC05) and/
or diabetes type 2 (focus on Metformin—ATC-Code A10BA02) were included. The
NA was calculated using the medication possession ratio (MPR); NA was defined as
MPR < 80%. The average MPRs obtained while using the original and the discount
products (before/after comparison) were compared using non-parametric tests for
independent samples (Wilcoxon-Tests). RESULTS: Of the 344 hypertonia sufferers,
253 received the active ingredient Moxonidin (NA patients’ percentage: 47.4%). In
68 cases, a switch to the discount product took place (NA percentage before switch:
46.4%). The percentage of NA patients was reduced to 39.1% after the switch. Of
the 726 diabetic patients, 518 patients received Metformin (NA: 49.4%). a total of
136 patients received a discount article after the discount contract was in place (NA
before switch: 42.7%). After the switch, the NA percentage increased to 66.2%.
CONCLUSIONS: In the case of hypertonia, medication switches had no significant
effect on the NA. By contrast, switchers receiving Metformin exhibited a substantial
increase in medication-based NA. In future, the focus of research in this area should
be to discover whether specific contracts concerning discount products (as, for
example, in the case of Metformin) are related to particularly negative adherence
effects and if so which factors influence such effects.
PCV102
ASSOCIATION BETWEEN KNOWLEDGE AND DRUG ADHERENCE IN
PATIENTS WITH HYPERTENSION IN QUETTA, PAKISTAN
Saleem F1, Hassali MA1, Shafie AA1, Bashir S2
1
Universiti Sains Malaysia, Penang, Malaysia; 2University of Sargodha, Sargodha, Punjab,
Pakistan
OBJECTIVES: Good adherence to long term management of chronic diseases such as
hypertension is very vital in order to prevent long term mortality and morbidity. There
are many factors associated with non-adherence to prescribed medications and one of
it is lack ok knowledge and awareness among patients towards the disease they are
suffering from. The aim of the present study is to evaluate the association between
patient’s knowledge to hypertension disease state management and medication adherence. METHODS: A cross-sectional study was undertaken with 385 established hypertensive patients who visited out patient departments in two public hospitals of Quetta
city, Pakistan. Besides the demographic and disease-related questions, two questionnaires (Hypertension Fact Questionnaire with 15 items for knowledge and Drug
Attitude Inventory with 10 items) were used for data collection. Descriptive statistics
and Spearman correlation were carried out by using SPSS version 16. RESULTS: Out
13th Euro Abstracts
of 385 patients (68.8% male; mean age: 39.02 ± 6.596), 236 (61.3%) of the patients
had moderate degree of knowledge about hypertension. a total of 249 (64.7%) were
categorized as poor adherent. Noticeably no patient was considered as good adherent
in the study. Correlation coefficient between total score of knowledge and total adherence was—0.170 (P < 0.001) indicating an inverse association between knowledge
scores and adherence level. CONCLUSIONS: Patient knowledge about hypertension
had weak relation with drug adherence in this cohort of study group. This is possibly
due to the dominancy of other factors influencing drug adherence such as perception
of patients towards disease and drug, income, education, age etc in this cohort of
study group. This calls attractive opportunities for further research on drug adherence
and also identifies the gaps in providing optimum health care to patients.
PCV103
COST IMPLICATION OF UNACCEPTABLE REFILL-BASED ADHERENCE
RATES OF ANTIHYPERTENSION TREATMENT IN THE SOUTH AFRICAN
PRIVATE HEALTH CARE ENVIRONMENT
Steyn R, Lubbe MS, Serfontein JHP, Smit R
North-West University, Potchefstroom, South Africa
OBJECTIVES: To investigate the cost implication of unacceptable refill-based adherence rates of antihypertensive treatment in the South African private health care
environment. METHODS: A non-experimental, retrospective drug utilization study
was conducted on medicine claims data of a pharmacy benefit management company
for hypertension patients for a four year period (January 1, 2005–December 31, 2008).
The refill-based adherence rate was calculated per trade name for all antihypertensive
medicine items that were prescribed more than once to 171,815 patients. The following equation was used: Refill–adherence rate = (total number of days of antihypertensive medicine items supplied—number of days supplied at last refill)/(date last
claimed—date first claimed). [RSA Rand (R)/$US = 6.38112 (2005); 6.78812 (2006);
7.06926 (2007) and 8.27505 (2008)]. RESULTS: An average refill-based adherence
rate of 82.8% ± 125.9 was obtained for 376,954 antihypertensive medicine items.
Approximately 54.5% of antihypertensive medicine items (n = 205,476) had acceptable refill-based adherence rates between 80% and 120%, 42.2% (n = 159153) had
unacceptably low refill-based adherence rates (less than 80%) and 3.3% (n = 12325)
had unacceptably high rates (more than 120%). Those with unacceptably low or
unacceptably high refill-based adherence rates accounted for respectively 24.3%
(R109,275,001) and 1.3% (R5 958,593.70) of the total cost (N = R448,883,473) of
all antihypertensive medicine items (n = 376,954). The following pharmacological
groups of antihypertensive drugs had on average unacceptable refill-based adherence
rates: diuretics (n = 114 623, 74.6% ± 131.7); central acting sympathetic nervous
system inhibitors (n = 5 094; 79.9% ± 112.6); sympathetic nervous blockers (n = 3
090; 76.3% ± 87.5). CONCLUSIONS: Since pharmacy records are generally computerised, the prospect of using a simple algorithm to assess compliance based on refill
patterns is enticing, particularly for monitoring the progress of patients with chronic
diseases.
PCV104
IMPACT OF POLICY-DRIVEN STATIN SWITCH PROGRAMS ON
ADHERENCE AND PERSISTENCE
Khalil C1, Folia C2, Liovas A3
1
University of Waterloo, Kitchener, ON, Canada; 2Agro Health Associates Inc., Burlington,
ON, Canada; 3AstraZeneca Canada Inc., Mississauga, ON, Canada
OBJECTIVES: Cardiovascular disease imposes a significant burden on patients and
society, and is associated with considerable costs to the health care system. Although
statins have been shown to reduce the risk of cardiovascular events, suboptimal adherence and poor persistence with therapy remains a common problem. The need to lower
health care costs has led to increased interest in policy-driven therapeutic substitution
programs for statins, however their impact on patient adherence and persistence is
often not considered. METHODS: A review of published literature describing the
impact of policy-driven statin switch programs on adherence and persistence was
conducted. PubMed search terms included: hydroxy-methyl-glutaryl-CoA Reductase
Inhibitors (MESH), and statin, therapeutic, generic, substitute, switch, persistence,
compliance, adherence (all fields); the search was limited to articles published in
English between 1989 to May 2010. Reference lists from selected papers were also
reviewed. RESULTS: 4 studies were identified. Following therapeutic substitution of
one statin for another, 20–25% of patients discontinued therapy within 6–12 months
(4 studies). Additionally, one study found that patients were 20% more likely to
discontinue treatment within the first year than those who did not switch. Furthermore, switching statins reduced adherence (i.e., probability of taking medication on
most days) by 12–33% (3 studies). One study showed that switching statins for
economic/ formulary reasons led to decreased filling and utilization of statin prescriptions overall. CONCLUSIONS: Low rates of adherence to statin therapy have been
documented, despite strong evidence of clinical benefit with sustained use. As a result,
many patients initiating statins may achieve limited clinical benefits from therapy
because of premature discontinuation. Policy-driven statin switch programs may
further contribute to problems with persistence and adherence. While therapeutic
substitution policies for statins may decrease drug plan costs, their impact on adherence and persistence may significantly affect patient outcomes and increase costs to
the health care system.
13th Euro Abstracts
PCV105
BLOOD PRESSURE PREDICTION MODEL FOR HYPERTENSIVE
PATIENTS AT SARABURI HOSPITAL IN 2009
Auamnoy T, Siemmai A, Tantipidoke R
Chulalongkorn University, Bangkok, Thailand
OBJECTIVES: 1. To compare means of calories burnt by exercise (exercise), compliance, eating behavior, hypertension knowledge, age and blood pressure (BP) between
gender and 2. To find correlations between exercise, compliance, eating behavior
score, hypertension knowledge, age and blood pressure. 3. To employ Hierarchical
Stepwise Multiple Regression Analysis (MRA) to predict blood pressure. METHODS:
A retrospective research by face to face interview and clinical outcomes were used to
investigate relationships between 6 variables and BP of random 200 hypertensive
patients at Saraburi Hospital 2009. RESULTS: Total (N) 200 (100%) patients were
mostly female 118 (59.00%) and 82 (41.00%) were male. The average age was 52.21
± 12.01 years, average exercise per week 2787.24 ± 141.61 kcal, average compliance
score 7.41 ± 1.93, average SBP and DBP were 150.24 ± 18.49 and 89.40 ± 9.15 Hgmm.
Cronbach’s Alpha coefficient of Sorofman’s Compliance scale for constructs “right
time” and “right amount” were 0.7978, and 0.7896 respectively, Auamnoy Eating
Behavior Scale was 0.7915. ANOVA confirmed that BP, compliance, hypertension
knowledge, age, exercise and eating behavior score between male and female were not
significantly different (p > 0.05). Pearson’s correlation confirmed that age, exercise
and compliance had significant negative correlation with DBP (r = −0.19, −0.43, −0.60
with p = 0.00, 0.00, 0.00 respectively). Age had significant positive correlation with
SBP however exercise and medical regimens compliance had significant negative correlation with SBP (r = 0.16, −0.81, −0.98 with p = 0.02, 0.00, 0.00 respectively). MRA
equation demonstrated the three most significant variables those predicted SBP and
DBP were: compliance (Beta = −0.90, −0.70), eating behavior (Beta = 0.82, 0.72) and
exercise (Beta = −0.11, −0.29) P = 0.00, 0.00, 0.00 R2 = 0.58, 0.55 respectively.
CONCLUSIONS: The more patients complied to medical regimens, with good eating
behavior and the more exercise the less patients’ blood pressure was.
PCV106
THE MISSING PIECE BETWEEN TREATMENT EXPERIENCE AND
INTENTION TO PERSIST: TESTING THE INTERNAL CONSISTENCY
RELIABILITY AND PREDICTIVE VALIDITY OF ACCEPTABILITY
Chretin S1, Viala-Danten M2, Van Ganse E3, Patrick D4, Arnould B2, Longin J1
1
Registrat–Mapi, Lyon, France; 2Mapi Values, Lyon, France; 3Hôpital Neurologique Pierre
Wertheimer, BRON Cedex, France; 4University of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA
OBJECTIVES: The ACCEPT© questionnaire is a self-administered generic acceptability instrument assessing how patients balance the advantages and disadvantages
of long-term chronic therapy. It is made of 2 parts: 1/ several characteristics of patient
experience with treatment giving an indication on which treatment attributes are
leading to intentions and adherence; 2/ a scale measuring acceptability of the treatment. Our objective was to test the internal consistency reliability and predictive
validity of the acceptability scale. METHODS: A survey was conducted in 60 community pharmacies. Patients treated with statin for more than 3 months were asked
to complete a preliminary version of the acceptability scale (3 items), as well as questions regarding their compliance with their statin medication. Compliant patients were
defined as those who reported never to forget to take their statin medication. Internal
consistency of the acceptability scale was assessed by Cronbach’s alpha. The statistical
independence between the 3 acceptability items and compliance was investigated by
chi-2 tests. The ability of the 3 acceptability items to detect non compliant patients
was evaluated by the area under the Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) curve.
RESULTS: Out of 443 patients included in the analysis, 28% have been treated for
1 to 3 years, and 54% for more than 3 years. 60% had no cardiovascular antecedent,
14% had an angina, 13% a prior myocardial infarction, 6% a prior stroke. 66%
declared they never forgot to take their statin medication. Cronbach’s alpha of the
acceptability scale was 0.70. The 3 items were statistically related to compliance
(p-chi2 < 0.0001). The area under the ROC curve was 0.69. CONCLUSIONS: The
acceptability scale showed satisfying preliminary results of reliability and predictive
validity. Further work is needed to validate the scale in other long-term treated populations and to evaluate its ability to predict persistence to treatment over time.
PCV107
VALUATION OF HEALTH STATE UTILITIES RELATED TO
CARDIOVASCULAR PREVENTION WITH ASPIRIN
Manson SC1, van Hanswijck de Jonge P1, Palsgrove A2, Gorelick PB3
1
United BioSource Corporation, London, UK; 2United BioSource Corporation, Bethesda,
MD, USA; 3University of Illinois College of Medicine, Chicago, IL, USA
OBJECTIVES: The primary aim of the study was to determine societal utility scores
for health states associated with events either benefiting from aspirin (myocardial
infarction, stroke, angina) or potentially caused by aspirin (GI bleeding). The secondary aim was to determine the societal disutility score of taking aspirin every day.
METHODS: Draft health states were developed based on a brief literature review and
exploratory and validation interviews with cardiovascular (n = 3) and stroke (n = 2)
specialists. The final health states were tested in a pilot study with members of the
general public (n = 6). In the main study, members of the general public (n = 90
Canadians; n = 86 Americans) completed a chained standard gamble (SG) interview,
a Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) rating task (0–100), the EQ-5D and a socio-demographic form. RESULTS: The samples were a reasonable match to the population of
Canada and the US in terms of demographics (48% female, 67% white) and quality
of life (rated by EQ-5D). Eight percent of participants had experienced one or more
A361
forms of CVD or stroke as described in the health states and 18% of participants were
taking daily preventive aspirin. In patients who were not taking aspirin, adding daily
aspirin to prevent CVD caused a decrement in utility of 0.018. Conversely, patients
who were taking daily aspirin reported an increase in utility of 0.021 compared to if
they were not taking aspirin. GI bleeding and transient ischemic attack were rated as
the states with the highest utility (0.79) followed by angina (0.71 stable, 0.66 unstable). Various stages of MI and stroke were considered least desirable (0.10–0.63).
CONCLUSIONS: The study highlights the benefit in utility that could be gained from
preventing cardiovascular and stroke events. It also demonstrates that the minor
burden of taking aspirin daily changes to a small incremental benefit in wellbeing in
participants already taking aspirin.
PCV108
METHODS FOR ESTIMATING HEALTH-STATE UTILITIES IN
PULMONARY ARTERIAL HYPERTENSION
Mychaskiw MA1, Berger A2, Mardekian J1, Hwang LJ1, Oster G2
1
Pfizer Inc, New York, NY, USA; 2Policy Analysis Inc., Brookline, MA, USA
OBJECTIVES: To compare health-state utility values obtained using three different
instruments administered to patients with pulmonary arterial hypertension (PAH)
enrolled in a randomized controlled trial of sildenafil. METHODS: Data for this study
were obtained from a large phase III clinical trial in which patients were randomized
to receive either sildenafil or placebo for 12 weeks. At each visit (baseline, weeks 1,
4, 8, and 12 of follow-up), patients were administered the Short Form-36 General
Health Survey (SF-36) and the EuroQol Health Survey (EQ-5D); additionally they also
were asked to provide a direct assessment of their current health state using a visual
analog scale (VAS). Responses to the SF-36 and EQ-5D were then converted to healthstate utility values using published algorithms. Patients were pooled across treatment
groups, and attention was focused on baseline values. Statistical significance of differences between these three estimates was ascertained using paired t tests. RESULTS:
There were a total of 274 patients across both treatment groups in the intent-to-treat
population. Proportions of 0–30, 31–60, and 61–100 health-state utility values were
0.4%, 22.6%, and 77.0% for SF-36; 16.2%, 9.6%, and 74.3% for EQ-5D; and 8.6%,
47.2%, and 44.2% for VAS, respectively. Mean (95% confidence intervals) healthstate utility values were 71.4 (69.6–73.1) for SF-36 (P < 0.01 vs. EQ-5D or VAS),
63.2 (60.2–66.3) for EQ-5D (P < 0.01 vs. VAS), and 59.0 (56.9–61.2) for VAS,
respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Ratings of current health by PAH patients are significantly worse with a single-item VAS scale than based on responses to the EQ-5D and
SF-36 health questionnaires. The EQ-5D appears to yield somewhat lower values than
the SF-36. Further research is needed to better understand the reason(s) for these
differences.
PCV109
SEVENTY-SEVEN HEALTH STATE UTILITIES ESTIMATED IN POLISH
CARDIAC PATIENTS
Zawodnik S, Golicki D, Hermanowski T
Department of Pharmacoeconomics, Medical University of Warsaw, Warsaw, Poland
OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to create a catalogue of SF-6D health state
utility values in the cardiovascular diseases, based on studies conducted in Polish
population using the SF-36 questionnaire. METHODS: Five databases: MEDLINE,
EMBASE, Cochrane Database, SCOPUS, Polish Medical Bibliography (Polska Bibliografia Lekarska; accessed on April 23, 2010) were systematically searched for SF-36
quality of life studies conducted in Polish cardiac patients. Only studies using original
key answer and with published complete data for eight SF-36 dimensions were
included. SF-6D utility scores were estimated based on SF-36 population data using
the method published by Ara and Brazier in 2009. RESULTS: We initially identified
31 studies using SF-36 in Polish cardiac patients. In 14 studies proper SF-36 scoring
algorithm was used and data for all eight domains were available. Data for 77 different
health states related to five cardiac disorders were extracted: acute coronary syndrome,
coronary artery disease, hypertension, atrial fibrillation and aortic valve disease. Each
health state was described as value of 8 dimensions of quality of life and was converted
to single-figure utility. Utility of acquired 77 health states ranged from 0.41 to 0.78.
CONCLUSIONS: A catalogue of 77 health state utilities derived in Polish cardiac
patients was estimated. It can be useful in pharmacoeconomic analyses conducted for
cardiologic health technologies and should support reimbursement decision making
in Poland.
PCV110
HOW PATIENTS’ EXPERIENCE COULD INFLUENCE THEIR
PREFERENCES TOWARD TREATMENT FOR ABDOMINAL AORTIC
ANEURYSM: RESULTS FROM THE PREFER STUDY
Scalone L1, Borghetti F2, Faggioli G3, Stella A3, Cortesi PA1, Mantovani LG4
1
University of Milano—Bicocca, Monza, Italy; 2University of Milan, Milano, Italy; 3Sant’Orsola
Malpighi Hospital, University of Bologna, Bologna, Italy; 4CIRFF, Federico II University, Naples,
Italy
OBJECTIVES: Factors influencing preferences towards treatment of abdominal aortic
aneurysm (AAA) were scarcely investigated. To identify how patients’ experience can
affect their preferences for treatment of AAA. METHODS: within a multicentre
Discrete-Choice-Study aimed to assess preferences toward AAA treatment the participant patients responded to 4 pair-wise choice sets comparing treatment options
obtained from a factorial combination of 6 characteristics: type of anaesthesia
(general vs. local); recovery time to everyday basic activities (2 vs. 4 days); risk of
A362
re-intervention at 5 years (7% vs. 15%); complexity of follow-up (with vs. without
CT examination); risk of major complications (2% vs. 5%); additional cost of intervention (c0 vs. c2000). Patients preferences were elicited before treatment (NAIF) and
after treatment with open surgery (OPEN) or endovascular procedure (EVAR). a
segmentation conditional logistic regression model was applied to estimate relative
importance (RI) assigned to each characteristic according to patients’ experience with
treatment. RESULTS: A total of 160 patients participated (aged 49–88 years, 91.7%
male) from 9 hospitals. Fifty-two percent were NAIF at enrolment. Overall, half
patients were treated with OPEN, half with EVAR. One most important characteristic,
risk of procedural major complications, was considered more important by NAIF and
EVAR than OPEN (RI = 31.7% and 22.0% vs. 11.0%). Additional costs were more
important to OPEN (RI = 38.3%) than NAIF (25.2%) and EVAR (19.5%). Local
anaesthesia was more important to EVAR (24.8%) than NAIF or OPEN (RI = 8.5%).
Risk of repeating the procedure was similarly important to treated patients (RI =
17.5%), less to NAIF (RI = 12.3%). Recovery time was more important to OPEN (RI
= 14.3%) and EVAR (RI = 10.3%) than NAIF (8.6%). Type of follow-up tests was
least important, with OPEN and NAIF preferring less complex tests (RI = 4–10%),
but EVAR preferring more complex tests (RI = 6%). CONCLUSIONS: Preferences
depend on experience, knowledge and expectancies. Understanding patients’ preferences can help physicians to optimize benefits of treatments.
PCV112
QUALITY OF LIFE AND DEPRESSION AMONG ADULTS WITH TYPE 2
DIABETES MELLITUS, HYPERTENSION, AND OBESITY
Grandy S1, Fox KM2
1
AstraZeneca LP, Wilmington, DE, USA; 2Strategic Healthcare Solutions, LLC, Monkton, MD,
USA
OBJECTIVES: Individuals with type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) are known to have
poorer quality of life and more depressive symptoms than those without diabetes, yet
the impact may be in part due to comorbid conditions. This study compared quality of
life and depression among adults with T2DM and comorbid hypertension (HTN) and
obesity with adults reporting T2DM only. METHODS: Respondents to the Study to
Help Improve Early evaluation and management of risk factors Leading to Diabetes
(SHIELD), a large US survey, self-reported their height, weight, and comorbid conditions, and completed the Short Form- 12 (SF-12) and Patient Health Questionnaire
(PHQ-9, depression assessment). Respondents reporting T2DM and HTN and obesity
(body mass index [BMI] ≥30 kg/m2) were identified and compared with a T2DM-only
group. RESULTS: Respondents with T2DM and comorbid HTN and obesity (n = 1292)
were similar to T2DM-only respondents (n = 349) in race, education, smoking, and
cardiovascular disease history (all p > 0.05), but were younger and were more likely to
be men and have lower income (P < 0.01). Respondents with T2DM, HTN and obesity
had significantly lower Physical and Mental Component Summary scores (37.3 and
50.9, respectively) than T2DM-only respondents (45.8 and 53.5, respectively, P <
0.0001). Mean PHQ-9 scores were significantly higher among T2DM respondents with
comorbid HTN and obesity (5.0 vs. 2.5, P < 0.0001), indicating greater depression
burden. Approximately 16.5% of respondents with T2DM, HTN and obesity had
moderate to severe depression (PHQ-9 scores ≥15), compared with 6.1% of respondents
with T2DM only (P < 0.0001). CONCLUSIONS: SHIELD respondents with T2DM,
HTN and obesity report a lower quality of both physical and mental health and more
depression symptoms than the T2DM-only group. More research is needed to determine
whether the poor quality of life and greater depression in this population affects selfmanagement of their diabetes and comorbid conditions.
PCV113
HEALTH-RELATED QUALITY OF LIFE OF PATIENTS UNDERGOING
PERCUTANEOUS CORONARY INTERVENTION COMPARED TO
HEALTHY SUBJECTS IN HONG KONG
Lee VW, Yan B, Choy A, Yeung S, Yu CM
The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Shatin, Hong Kong
OBJECTIVES: This study aimed to investigate the health-related quality of life
(HRQoL) of coronary heart disease (CHD) patients and healthy subjects in Hong
Kong. METHODS: This study was a one-year prospective cohort with two groups of
study populations, the patient group and healthy subject group. Thirty-three eligible
patients were recruited from Prince of Wales of Hospital. The HRQoL data using
Short-Form 36-item Health Survey (SF-36) were collected just after percutaneous
coronary intervention (PCI) (baseline) and one year post-PCI. Thirty-five healthy
subjects who were recruited from two elderly centres and parents of School of Pharmacy (SOP) students, were also interviewed by SF-36. This study consists of two parts.
In the first part, the HRQoL data of healthy subjects were compared with patients at
baseline and 1 year post-PCI respectively. In the second part, the improvement in
HRQoL of PCI patients at baseline and 1 year post-PCI was compared. RESULTS:
In the first part of study, healthy subjects had significantly (P < 0.05) higher scores in
role-physical (79.3 ± 36.6 vs. 53.8 ± 48.1), vitality (65.1 ± 23.8 vs. 49.5 ± 33.7) and
role-emotional (93.3 ± 15.8 vs. 72.7 ± 39.5) than the patients at baseline. Patients’
HRQoL returned to similar level with healthy subjects after 1 year of PCI treatment.
In the second part of the study, patients had significant (P < 0.05) improvements in
bodily pain (12.7 ± 30.3) and vitality (16.1 ± 33.1) after 1 year. CONCLUSIONS:
This study showed that the HRQoL of CHD patients was poorer than healthy population in Hong Kong, but returned to similar level as healthy population after 1 year of
PCI treatment. In addition, significant HRQoL improvements had been seen in patients
after 1 year of PCI, especially in bodily pain and vitality.
13th Euro Abstracts
PCV114
ABSENTEISM AND IMPAIRED QUALITY OF LIFE IN CHRONIC VENOUS
DISEASE IN ROMANIA
Alegre P1, Puskas A2, Giurcaneanu C3, Andercou A4, Jantet G5
1
Science Union et cie (Servier), Suresnes, France; 2Targu Mures, Romania; 3Bucarest,
Romania; 4Cluj, Romania; 5Paris, France
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the impact of chronic venous disease (CVD) on patients’
professional activity and its consequence on patients’ quality of life (QOL) in
Romania. METHODS: A large observational, multicentre, descriptive survey in CVD
was implemented in Romania in 2009. Impact of CVD on patients’ professional
activities and QOL were documented based on a patient self-administered questionnaire. The CIVIQ-14 was used to assess QOL (score 0 for very good to 100 for bad
QOL). Patient data were crossed with their general practitioner evaluations on the
severity of the disease. RESULTS: Out of 2542 screened patients, 2294 filled in the
questionnaire (90.2%). Among CVD patients, 7% had had hospitalization because of
the disease, while 7% had changed their professional activities or had lost working
days. Number of lost working days over the previous 5 years exceeded 1 week for
most (40% lost >1 week, 35% >1 month, 16% <1 week). Patients who lost less than
1 working week, between 1 week and 1 month and more than 1 month due to CVD
had a worsened QOL (respectively 28.71 ± 24.32, 31.4 ± 17.73 and 31.8 ± 16.69
CIVIQ-14 score) QOL scores paralleled the severity of CVD, going from 15.64 ±
14.94 in C0s patients (symptoms only, according to the CEAP) to 51.79 ± 30.43 in
C6 (patients with ulcer). The presence of pain decreased QOL (30.49 ± 19.04). QOL
scores associated to work absenteeism varied from 21.98 ± 15.05 to 49.49 ± 20.06
depending on absenteeism frequency (from 1 to 3 times respectively) CONCLUSIONS:
CVD generates an important negative professional impact in Romania with productivity losses. Quality of life impairment occurs from the first symptoms of CVD and it
is correlated to the work absenteeism duration and frequency. Three times out of work
is associated to a QOL score comparable to the one quoted between grades 4 and 5
of the CEAP classification.
PCV115
ASSESSMENT OF THE ASSOCIATION BETWEEN SUMMARY SYMPTOM
MEASURES AND HEALTH STATUS OF PATIENTS WITH ISCHEMIC
HEART DISEASE
Kaakeh R, Erickson SR
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA
OBJECTIVES: This study compared five methods of summarizing symptom data and
the association of these measures with the outcome health related quality of life
(HRQL) in patients who had experienced an acute coronary syndrome event (ACS).
METHODS: All patients listed in an ACS registry (treated for ACS and discharged
from a university affiliated hospital) during a 3 year period were mailed a questionnaire that assessed symptom status, demographics, cardiac functional status and
therapy, comorbidity, ACS type and HRQL (SF-8 and EQ-5D). The symptom survey
included 24 symptoms and measured the occurrence, frequency, and distress associated with each symptom during the previous four weeks. Symptom summary measures
included summed, averaged, and multiplicative (Symptom Product) values of each
symptom characteristic. Bivariate correlations and multivariate regression analysis
were used to assess the association of each symptom summary measure with HRQL,
controlling for other patient, disease, and treatment characteristics. RESULTS: A total
of 490 of 1217 patients (40%) responded. The mean age was 65.7 ± 11.3 years; 67.7%
male;94.0% Caucasian;PCS-8 53.7 ± 10.5; MCS-8 49.5 ± 9.5; and EQ-5D VAS 73.6
± 20.5. The Symptom Sum = 7.8 ± 4.9, Symptom Frequency Average = 2.5 ± 0.72,
Symptom Distress Average = 2.2 ± 0.8, Symptom Distress Sum = 18.6 ± 14.8, and
Symptom Product = 51.7 ± 48.3. Bivariate correlations demonstrated that the
Symptom Sum and Symptom Product had the highest correlation (>0.54) with the
HRQL domains, while Symptom Frequency Average was the lowest (0.24–0.33).
The same pattern was seen with the multivariate regression model. The model adjusted
R-square for the Symptom Sum and Symptom Product measures were higher than the
other measures, with the Symptom Product having the highest correlation. The
R-square values ranged for these two measures depending on the HRQL domain; PCS
(0.38–0.44), MCS (0.33–0.35), EQ-5D (0.34–0.39). CONCLUSIONS: Researchers
may consider using Symptom Sum or a Symptom Product measures when attempting
to summarize the association of symptoms with HRQL in ischemic heart disease
patients.
PCV116
QUALITY OF LIFE IN CHRONIC SYMPTOMATIC HEART FAILURE
PATIENTS IN SPAIN
Marti B1, Delgado J2, Oliva J3, Llano M4, Pascual P5, Comin J6, Grillo JJ7, Diaz Molina B8,
Culebras J9, Martínez de la Concha L10, Manito N11
1
Medtronic Iberia, Madrid, Spain; 2Hospital 12 de Octubre, Madrid, Spain; 3Univesidad de
Castilla La Mancha, Toledo, Spain; 4Hospital Universitario Marqués de Valdecilla, Santander,
Spain; 5Hospital Universitario Virgen de la Arrixaca, Murcia, Spain; 6Hospital del Mar (IMIM),
Barcelona, Spain; 7Hospital Universitario Nuestra Señora de la Candelaria, Santa Cruz de
Tenerife, Spain; 8Hospital Universitario Central de Asturias, Oviedo, Spain; 9Hospital
Universitario Insular, Las Palmas De Gran Canariaý, Spain; 10Hospital Universitario Infanta
Cristina, Badajoz, Spain; 11Hospital de Bellvitge, Barcelona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: To analyze, for the first time in a large Spanish population of heart
failure patients, quality of life according to NYHA class II, III or IV using generic
and specific quality of life questionnaires. METHODS: A descriptive analysis of a
13th Euro Abstracts
multicenter, prospective observational study was performed. Patients who met inclusion criteria were followed-up for a period of 12 months, with 3 visits programmed
at baseline, 6 months and 12 months. a total of 9 Spanish hospitals were involved in
the study. Questionnaires used to measure quality of life were: EQ-5D (generic questionnaire), Minessotta living with heart failure- MLWHF (specific questionnaire) and
Barthel Index (index of independence). RESULTS: A total of 450 patients were
included, 76% men, mean age was 62.6 years. 66.1% were in NYHA class II, 32.7%
NYHA class III and 1.1% NYHA class IV. Prevalence of ischemic cardiopathy was
33.5%. 35% of patients had an implantable device (ICD, RCT or pacemaker). Significant differences were observed in Barthel Index’s scores depending on class: class
I 97.6 ± 6.7 vs. Class III-IV 91.8 ± 14.6. Related to EQ-5D tariffs, individuals in class
II had a mean value of 0.8407 ± 0.1887 (out of 1), and mean VAS value of 60.6 ±
17.39 (out of 100). Individuals in NYHA class III or IV had a mean score of 0.6624
± 0.2848, and mean VAS value of 51.93 ± 17.15 (out of 100). In a MLWHF questionnaire analyses, patients in NYHA class II showed a mean score of 32.52 ± 20.69 while
patient in NYHA class III-IV showed a mean score of 50.44 ± 18.23. CONCLUSIONS: Our findings showed the results from the three questionnaires were generally
consistent with each other and values reported from other countries in the
literature.
PCV117
HEALTH-RELATED QUALITY OF LIFE IN PATIENTS WITH PULMONARY
ARTERIAL HYPERTENSION
Mychaskiw MA1, Berger A2, Mardekian J1, Hwang LJ1, Oster G2
1
Pfizer Inc, New York, NY, USA; 2Policy Analysis Inc., Brookline, MA, USA
OBJECTIVES: To characterize health-related quality of life (HRQoL) in patients with
pulmonary arterial hypertension (PAH) in relation to persons of similar age and gender
in the general United States (US) population. METHODS: Data were obtained from
a large phase III clinical trial in which patients (n = 274) were randomized to sildenafil
or placebo for 12 weeks. We characterized HRQoL using responses to the Short
Form-36 General Health Survey (SF-36) obtained at baseline; the SF-36 addresses eight
HRQoL domains: physical functioning (PF), role functioning–physical (RP), bodily
pain (BP), general health (GH), vitality (VT), social functioning (SF), role functioning–emotional (RE), and mental health (MH). Values for these eight domains were
then standardized to US population norms for persons aged 45–54 years (mean age
of patients in trial was 49 years). RESULTS: A total of 39% and 58% of patients
were designated at baseline as Functional Class (FC) II and III, respectively (<1% and
3% were designated as FC I and IV), with 75% women. Standardized mean scores
were 30.4 for PF, 27.9 for RP, 47.8 for BP, 34.2 for GH, 41.2 for VT, 38.9 for SF,
34.9 for RE, and 43.7 for MH. In comparison with the US population, whose mean
score for each domain = 50, PF, RP, GH, SF, and RE were all substantially worse for
PAH patients. Additionally MH and VT were marginally worse among PAH patients,
and BP was comparable to US norms. CONCLUSIONS: With the exception of bodily
pain and mental health, PAH patients have substantially poorer SF-36 scores than
their peers in the US general population, especially in terms of physical functioning,
role functioning-physical, role functioning-emotional, and general health.
PCV118
TO DETERMINE THE EFFECT OF DIFFERENT DOSES OF
POMEGRANATE ON BODY WEIGHT AND BLOOD PRESSURE
Malik M, Hussain A
Hamdard University, Islamabad, Punjab, Pakistan
OBJECTIVES: The aim of the present study was to evaluate the effect of 700 mg and
1400 mg pomegranate seed capsules on body weight and blood pressure for a period
of 60 days at time interval 7, 14, 21, 28, 45 and 60 days respectively. METHODS:
At the beginning of the study twenty four healthy human volunteers were selected.
On the basis of BMI two broader groups, i.e. group 1 taking 700 mg pomegranate
capsules and group 2 taking 1400 mg pomegranate capsules were designated and both
the groups were subdivided on the basis of diet control and exercise i.e. group1 (IA,
IB) and group 2(IIA, IIB). Group IA and IIA took pomegranate capsules without diet
and exercise while IB and IIB took the capsules with diet and exercise. Hypertensive
patients from these groups were included in both groups who were categorized and
evaluated separately and compared with normal individuals. RESULTS: The result of
investigation indicated that both doses of pomegranate seeds capsules had significantly
reduced the body weight and blood pressure profile (both systolic and diastolic) in all
groups when compared with their baseline values. However both doses caused equal
reduction of body weight and blood pressure as no significant difference was present
in both doses (p-value > 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: Thus on the basis of results obtained
after conducting our study it was concluded that pomegranate seed capsules have
established their efficacy and safety profile for obesity control and hypertension
management.
PCV119
SURVEY AT RETAIL PHARMACIES LEVEL ASSESSING QUALITY OF LIFE
OF VKAS PATIENTS
Delaitre O1, Haim M1, Samama CM2
1
Boehringer Ingelheim France, Paris, Ile de France, France; 2Hotel Dieu University Hospital,
Paris, Ile de france, France
OBJECTIVES: To measure how VKA’s patients assess their treatment in terms of
medication intake constraints, monitoring and psychological impact related to perceived risk. METHODS: Questionnaires to patients under VKAs for at least 3 months.
A363
Questionnaires were distributed through 150 retail pharmacies spread over all France
from November 2009 to March 2010. a random distribution of questionnaire was
made. RESULTS: 1094 questionnaires were administered. Study included 58% men
and 42% women aged >65 years for 72%; patients aged more than 75 years represented 43%. Patients were treated in majority by fluindione (82.3%) and for more
than 3 years (65.1%). Patients were treated in majority for cardiac rhythm disorder
(40%). More than ¾ (77%) of VKAs patients consider their treatment being a burden
even though being vital. Treatment is judged as being a constraint because of the
obligation to adapt dosages according to coagulation monitoring (42%), and due to
the necessity to contact their physician after each blood sample (25%). The requirement to permanently have a monitoring is considered as constantly reminding the
associated risk (65%), expectation of coagulation monitoring results generate anxiety
for more than ¼ of patients (27%). Majority of patients acknowledge that regular
blood sampling is a constraint (53%) and that the treatment would be more convenient without these constant blood samplings (60%). In parallel, 38% of patients
interviewed consider that the VKA treatment constraint is reinforced by the fact that
they cannot eat what they would like. Patient preference for a new treatment is in
priority: a treatment without regular blood sampling (62%); a treatment for which
the daily anticoagulant dosage does not need adaptation (60%). CONCLUSIONS:
Treatment by VKAs is perceived as burdensome and risky by a majority of patients
due to the constant monitoring required and the uncertainty of the good blood dosage.
CARDIOVASCULAR DISORDERS – Health Care Use & Policy Studies
PCV120
COMBINED MEDICATION CHOICE AND PATIENT PERSISTENCE IN
HYPERTENSION THERAPY: EVIDENCE OF REAL-LIFE EFFECTIVENESS
Molnár MP1, Dankó D1, Katona L2
1
Corvinus University of Budapest, Budapest, Hungary; 2Hungarian National Health Insurance
Fund Administration, Budapest, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: While hypertension treatment guidelines emphasize the medical benefits of combined medication choice, consumption patterns of antihypertensive drugs
raise worldwide several questions related to real-life therapeutic and cost-effectiveness.
Hungary has a relatively poor track record: international comparative studies show
Hungarian patients’ adherence to treatment to fall behind not only desirable targets
but also international average values. In our analysis, we start from the hypothesis
that medical benefits achievable through combined therapy are weakened through
inadequate patient adherence, and we investigate into the health loss caused to Hungarian patients by insufficient persistence in combined hypertension therapy. Our goal
is to determine how the real-life consumption patterns of combination hypertension
therapy impact real-life therapeutic effectiveness and cost-effectiveness. METHODS:
We use itemized prescription-level data from the Hungarian National Health Insurance Fund Administration’s (NHIFA) database. Our research covers patients whose
therapy was initiated during 2008 or 2009 with high-value fix-dosage (one-pill) and
non-fix-dosage (multiple-pill) angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitor (ACEI) and
calcium channel blocker (CCB) combinations, or angiotensin-receptor blocker (ARB)
and CCB combinations. RESULTS: Adherence to treatment is measured as persistence
on the initiating combination therapy. Firstly, ‘hard’ persistence (which does not allow
for add-on therapies) and ‘add-on’ persistence (which allows for additional active
substances being added to the therapy regime) are separately calculated, both for fixdosage and non-fix-dosage combinations. Secondly, if the initiating therapy is a fixdosage combination, parallel consumption of monocomponents is also analyzed.
Thirdly, we carry out a switch analysis to determine the active substances that patients
had been taking before receiving a fix-dosage combination, or take after abandoning
the fix dosage combined therapy. CONCLUSIONS: We hypothesize that substantial
societal loss is caused by patient non-adherence in hypertension treatment and clinical
advantages of combination therapies are significantly impaired. Our research will
deliver exact calculations for the extent of the societal loss.
PCV121
A SURVEY OF PHYSICIANS’ ATTITUDES TOWARD THE CONTROL OF
CARDIOVASCULAR RISK FACTORS. THE EURIKA STUDY.
Dallongeville J1, Banegas JR2, Guallar E3, Borghi C4, De Backer G5, Halcox JP6,
Massó-González EL7, Perk J8, Steg PG9, Rodriguez Artalejo F2
1
Institut Pasteur de Lille, Lille, France; 2Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Madrid, Spain;
3
Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD, USA; 4Policlinico Universitario Sant’Orsola,
Bologna, Italy; 5University of Gent, Gent, Belgium; 6Cardiff University, Cardiff, UK;
7
AstraZeneca Farmacéutica Spain S.A, Madrid, Spain; 8Oskarshamns Hospital, Oskarshamn,
Sweden; 9Centre Hospitalier Bichat-Claude Bernard, Paris, France
OBJECTIVES: Cardiovascular risk factors remain poorly controlled across Europe
despite clinical guidelines. The European Study on Cardiovascular Risk Prevention
and Management in Daily Practice (EURIKA) investigated the use of cardiovascular
risk assessments tools and guidelines, and explored factors limiting their use.
METHODS: Physicians (n = 806) from 12 European countries answered questions
regarding their work setting, their assessment of patients with cardiovascular risk
factors, and their use of risk calculation tools and clinical guidelines. RESULTS:
Participating physicians worked in primary care centres or outpatient clinics; 63.8%
were GPs. The majority (69.3%) reported using global risk calculation tools. Written
charts were the preferred method (69.9%), followed by software (33.0%). The most
popular tools were SCORE (European Society of Cardiology [ESC]; 52.4%),
A364
Framingham (16.9%) and the European Hypertension Chart (31.3%). Reasons for
not using risk tools included time constraints (60.8%), not being convinced of their
utility (22.1%) and lack of knowledge (20.0%). a high percentage of physicians
believed the algorithms have limitations (72.4%); 92.1% believed they lead to overlooking other risk factors and 69.3% believed they cannot be used to calculate risk
in elderly patients. The most commonly used clinical guidelines were those from the
ESC (CVD Prevention in Clinical Practice [56.3%] and Management of Arterial
Hypertension [29.9%]) or from local authorities (17%). In total, 12.9% of physicians
reported not using guidelines; reasons included the wide choice or uncertainty of which
to use (47.5%), time constraints (33.7%), lack of knowledge (27.7%) and a perception
that they are unrealistic (23.8%). CONCLUSIONS: Time constraints, perceived utility
and inadequate knowledge were common factors limiting the use of cardiovascular
risk evaluation tools and assessment guidelines. Better compliance with risk assessment
tools may reduce the high proportion of patients with poorly managed cardiovascular
risk factors.
PCV122
THE IMPACT OF A CLINICAL PHARMACIST INTERVENTION ON
LIPID-LOWERING IN A PRIMARY CARE SETTING
Triki N1, Shani S1, Rabinovich-Protter D2, Mossinson D2, Kokia E2, Greenberg D1
1
Ben Gurion University of the Negev, Beer-Sheva, Israel; 2Maccabi Healthcare Services,
Tel-Aviv, Israel
OBJECTIVES: The Adult Treatment Panel III guidelines suggest that the goal of lowdensity lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-C) in patients with both cardiovascular disease
and diabetes is <100 mg/dL. Many patients remain poorly controlled despite various
interventions in primary care, including statin therapy and health behavior modification. We evaluated the impact of adding a clinical pharmacist intervention to usual
care on LDL-C control and treatment costs in diabetic cardiac patients. METHODS:
We prospectively compared a clinical pharmacist intervention in 138 patients with a
matched control sample of 353 patients receiving usual care in Maccabi Healthcare
Services (MHS) in Israel. Patients with cardiovascular disease and diabetes and LDL-C
levels >100 mg/dL were identified from the MHS’s computerized database. The clinical
pharmacist reviewed patients’ clinical charts and discussed the recommendations to
improve hyper-lipidemic control with the patients’ primary-care practitioners. The
recommendations were given every three months for a one-year period. The primary
clinical endpoint was reaching LDL-C goal. Clinical outcomes and overall treatment
costs in both groups were evaluated at the end of the study year. RESULTS: During
the study year, 67% of the patients in the intervention group reached the LDL goal
vs. only 54% in the control group (p = 0.014). LDL target was reached three months
earlier in the intervention group as compared with control patients (0.710 year vs.
0.992 year, respectively; log-rank test: p = 0.015). However, at the end of the study
year, LDL target was maintained in approximately 50% of patients in both groups.
Overall treatment costs (physician visits, hospital and emergency room admissions,
lab tests, medications) were 14% lower in the intervention group and 11% higher in
the control group as compared to the year prior the intervention. CONCLUSIONS:
A clinical pharmacist intervention in high-risk patients may result in clinical improvements and lower treatment costs. These results demonstrate the high-value of clinical
pharmacist involvement in patient treatment.
PCV123
EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDY OF EUROPEAN CARDIOVASCULAR RISK
PATIENTS: DISEASE PREVENTION AND MANAGEMENT IN USUAL
DAILY PRACTICE—TURKISH RESULTS OF EURIKA STUDY
Abaci A
Gazi University, Ankara-on behalf of EURIKA Study Group, Turkey
OBJECTIVES: To assess management of cardiovascular risk factors (CVRF) in daily
clinical practice and to identify areas of potential improvement in primary prevention
of CVD. METHODS: A total 663 patients >50 years of age (59.4 ± 7.6 years; 47.2%
males) with at least one additional CVRF and 67 physicians (mean age: 40.7 ± 8.6
years; 82.1% males) were included from Turkey in the multicentre, multinational,
cross-sectional epidemiological EURIKA study (NCT00882336) conducted across
Europe. Management and control of classical, emergent and psycho-social CVRF, use
of CV risk assessment by the physicians as well as barriers for estimating and using
global cardiovascular risk scores were identified. RESULTS: Total CV risk assessment
in Turkish patients was stated to be performed by 48.5% of the physicians mostly by
chart (71.9%) and mainly for an advice on healthy lifestyle (84.4%) and to decide on
antihypertensive (78.1%) or lipid-lowering treatment (75.0%). Time constraint for
global CV risk evaluation was the main reason (73.5%) for the lack of assessment
identified by the physicians. a total of 514 patients (77.5%) were classified to have
high CV risk by the physicians using a local (7.6%) or the recent European Guidelines
on Cardiovascular Disease Prevention in Clinical Practice (ESC 2007) (80.0%).
Although global cardiovascular risk was said to be under control in 75.5% of the
patients, satisfying control of CV risk factors was evident in only 56.7% while the
overall percentage of the patients who were aware of their CV risk was 69.5%.
CONCLUSIONS: Apparently targets defined in guidelines are not sufficiently met and
there is clear need for better management of high risk patients. Development of better
structured and more realistic, simple and credible national guidelines adapted to suit
local medical and economic conditions should be encouraged.
13th Euro Abstracts
PCV124
IMPACT OF REGIONAL MEASURES IN THE SALES OF THE RENINANGIOTENSIN SYSTEM ANTAGONISTS IN SPAIN
Gimenez E, Garrido E, Lindner L, Sabater J, Vieta A
IMS Health, Barcelona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: To analyze the impact of regional measures in the sales of the reninangiotensin system antagonists in Spain. METHODS: Regional measures from each
of the 17 Spanish Autonomous Regions (AR) were identified by searching on health
services’ websites. a Regional Measurement Scale (RMS) in rational use of drugs
(RUD) was constructed. Values ranged from 0 to 24 considering the number and the
specificity of the applied politics. The 2009 market share of the Angiotensin-II Receptor Antagonists (AIIRA) vs. Angiotensin-Converting Enzyme (ACE) inhibitors was
analyzed. AR market shares and RMS correlations were calculated. Correlated AR
Market shares were adjusted according to the values of RMS using a linear regression
model for the AR with correlation between the RMS and the market shares. The
decrease in market share on the AIIRA by RMS point was determined by the slope
coefficient of the regression (β). RESULTS: Health plans, clinical guidelines, pharmacotherapeutic guides, health technology assessments and therapeutic newsletters, promoting the prescription of ACE inhibitors rather than AIIRA, were identified. In 14
out of 17 AR, the correlation between the RMS and the market shares was statistically
significant (r = 0.55, p = 0.004). Of these, three AR scored 0, five 1 to 10, four 10 to
20, and two 22 and 23 points respectively. a 0.52% decline in the market share AIIRA
was observed for each point in the RMS. The maximum impact observed in the market
share was 11.96%. Considering that the variability in the AIIRA market share was
24.1%, half of it was explainable by the establishment of RUD measures. CONCLUSIONS: Results support the fact that not only the establishment of regional measures
is important but also the way they are implemented.
PCV125
PROTEIN-C-REACTIVE AS A MARKER OF INFLAMMATION AND
CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE IN PATIENTS WITH SCHIZOPHRENIA: A
CROSS-SECTIONAL ANALYSIS OF A HEALTH CARE PROVIDER
ADMINISTRATIVE CLAIM DATABASE
Sicras-Mainar A1, Blanca Tamayo M2, Rejas J3, Navarro Artieda R4
1
Directorate of Planning, Badalona Serveis Assistencials, Badalona, Barcelona, Spain;
2
Department of Psychiatry, Badalona Serveis Assistencials, Badalona, Barcelona, Spain; 3Pfizer
España, Alcobendas/Madrid, Spain; 4Department of Clinical Documentation, Hospital
Germans Trias i Pujol, Badalona, Barcelona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Interest in cardiovascular diseases (CVD) in patients with schizophrenia has recently become growing among psychiatrists due to its documented incremental mortality for these causes. Identification of markers for such disorders seems,
therefore, reasonable. Serum Protein-C-Reactive (PCR) levels have been determined
as a marker of inflammation in individuals with CVD and/or at high risk for developing it. However, it is unknown the role of this protein in schizophrenics. Thus, the
goal of this research was to explore the use of PCR as a marker of inflammation and
CVD in patients with Schizophrenia. METHODS: A cross-sectional analysis of the
BSA administrative claim database was conducted including all men and women, >18
years, with a schizophrenia spectrum disorders (by DSM-IV criteria) diagnosis. PCR
measurement together with socio-demographics, evolution, medical history, 10-years
CVD risk (Framingham equation) and biochemistry data was extracted for analysis.
RESULTS: A total of 705 patients [53.0% men, 48.2 + 15.8 years (mean + SD), 5.9
+ 3.2 years of evolution, 79.7% on atypical drugs] met criteria for analysis. Mean
10-year CVD risk was high; 11.9% + 5.7% and mean PCR levels were 2.6 + 2.5 mg/L
with 30.4% showing values above normal’s (>3 mg/L). Unadjusted PCR slightly correlated with CVD risk; r = 0.171, P < 0.001. After adjusting by age, sex, evolution,
smoking and anti-inflammatory drugs treatment, PCR was linearly associated with
10-year CVD risk stratified by its level of risk (low, moderate, high/very high); respectively, 2.3 (95% CI: 2.1–2.5), 3.1 (2.6–3.5) and 3.7 (3.2–4.1) mg/L; F = 13.5, P <
0.001. Patients with known CVD showed also higher PCR levels; 3.7 (2.9–4.5) vs.
2.5 (2.4–2.7) mg/L, p = 0.008, and higher probability of values above normal’s; Odds
Ratio = 4.71 (2.01–11.04), P < 0.001. CONCLUSIONS: High PCR levels (above
normals) were associated with both known CVD and high/very high 10-year risk of
CVD event in patients with schizophrenia. Then, PCR might be a marker of inflammation and CVD in this psychiatric disorder.
PCV126
USE OF PROTON PUMP INHIBITORS (PPIS) IN ACUTE CORONARY
SYNDROME PATIENTS TREATED WITH CLOPIDOGREL IN GERMANY,
FRANCE, AND THE UNITED KINGDOM
Mccollam P1, Nasuti P2, Rex J2, Gaskin M2
1
Eli Lilly & Company, Indianapolis, IN, USA; 2IMS Health, London, UK
OBJECTIVES: There is controversy in the literature regarding the effects of concomitant use of proton-pump inhibitors (PPIs) potentially reducing the clinical effectiveness
of clopidogrel. Also in question is whether the effect occurs with all PPIs or only
omeprazole The purpose of this study is to assess the usage of PPIs in combination
with clopidogrel in Acute Coronary Syndrome (ACS) patients in the primary care
setting. METHODS: This was a retrospective study using IMS Disease Analyzer
databases in France, Germany and the UK. These longitudinal patient databases
provide information from continuing physician and patient interaction on consultations, diagnoses and treatments within primary care. RESULTS: From April 2008 to
April 2009, 57% of post-ACS clopidogrel patients also had a PPI prescribed (France
13th Euro Abstracts
54% and Germany 45%). An overall increase in co-prescribing of clopidogrel and
PPIs was observed in all countries from April 2006 to April 2009 except for France
where omeprazole co-prescribing decreased in 2008–2009. The most frequently prescribed PPI in combination with clopidogrel was omeprazole in all three countries
(58% in the UK, 36% in France and 65% in Germany) The second most frequently
used PPI was lansoprazole in the UK (36%), pantoprazole in Germany (21%) and
esomeprazole in France (28%). The proportion of clopidogrel patients who were
co-prescribed lansoprazole was 36% in the UK and only 11% in France and 2% in
Germany. CONCLUSIONS: Overall prescribing of PPIs with clopidogrel after ACS
is common in the UK, France and Germany. Since the publication of the OCLA study
in 2008 no decrease in concurrent prescribing of clopidogrel and omeprazole was
observed except in France. Revisions of national guidelines and the clopidogrel label
in 2009 may further affect prescribing of PPIs, and especially omeprazole, with clopidogrel in the future.
PCV127
INCREASING NURSE STAFFING LEVELS IN BELGIAN CARDIAC
SURGERY CENTERS: A COST-EFFECTIVE PATIENT SAFETY
INTERVENTION?
Van den Heede K1, Simoens S2, Vleugels A1, Sermeus W1
1
Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Leuven, Belgium; 2K.U. Leuven, Leuven, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: A previous study indicated that increasing nurse staffing levels in
Belgian general cardiac postoperative nursing units was associated with lower mortality rates. The aim of this study is to conduct a cost-effectiveness analysis of increasing
nurse staffing levels to the level of the 75th percentile in Belgian general cardiac postoperative nursing units from a hospital perspective. METHODS: The intervention was
an increase in the number of nursing hours per patient day to the 75th percentile for
nursing units staffed below that level. The comparator was a “do nothing” alternative.
Data on nurse staffing levels were extracted from the Belgian Nursing Minimum Data
set and data on in-hospital mortality from the Belgian Hospital Discharge Database.
The number of life-years gained was calculated by multiplying the number of avoided
deaths by the life expectancy of patients having a coronary artery bypass graft and
patients having heart valve procedures. To this effect, survival rates were derived from
the literature. National cost estimates for the year 2007 were used. Results were
expressed in the form of the additional costs per avoided death and the additional
costs per life-year gained. RESULTS: The costs of increasing nurse staffing levels to
the 75th percentile in Belgian general cardiac postoperative nursing units amounted to
c1,211,022. Such nurse staffing levels would avoid an estimated number of 45.9 (95%
CI: 22.0–69.4) patient deaths per year and generate 458.86 (95% CI: 219.93–693.79)
life-years gained annually. This corresponds with incremental cost-effectiveness ratios
of c26,372 per avoided death and c2,639 per life-year gained. Sensitivity analyses
indicated that the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio was robust to changes in input
parameters. CONCLUSIONS: Increasing nurse staffing levels appears to be a costeffective intervention as compared to other cardiovascular interventions.
PCV128
MODELING OF HEALTH SERVICE RESEARCH RESULTS WITH UPDATED
COST DATA—THE GERSHWIN STUDY EXAMPLE
Brüggenjürgen BH, Willich SN, McBride D
University Medicine Berlin, Charité, Berlin, Berlin, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Health services research is an expanding field of interest for recently
introduced medical technologies. Complementing efficacy results with effectiveness
data illustrates the clinical contribution of a new technology in the real-life setting.
With effectiveness results being relatively stable over time, the change in reimbursement and price decreases have a substantial impact on initial cost-effectiveness considerations. The three-year GERSHWIN study (GERman Stent Health outcomes
WIthin Normal practice) was designed to determine long-term clinical outcome and
economic consequences of Sirolimus-eluting stents (SES) versus bare-metal stents BMS
in the treatment of CAD from a societal prospective. Economic analysis resulted in
an ICER of c29,868 per avoided major adverse coronary events (MACE) based on
2003 to 2005 prices. Due to substantial price reductions, a remodelling with current
prices would increase applicability of results by decision-makers. METHODS: Complete intention-to-treat study data were valued and analyzed with 2009 prices for the
main cost drivers (hospital case rate, incremental stent cost and generic clopidogrel
price). Sensitivity analyses were conducted to evaluate the robustness of the results
and included a low- and high-cost scenario. RESULTS: Initial hospitalization costs
were c1157 higher per patient receiving SES, driven primarily by the incremental
acquisition cost for SES compared BMS. Follow-up direct costs were similar in both
groups of patients, however the indirect costs in SES patients were significantly lower.
Overall 36-month MACE-related costs were c283 not significantly higher in the SES
group (p = 0.62). The ICER based on 2009 cost data resulted in c5320 per MACE
avoided. Variation of incremental SES prices between c650 and c750 showed no
significant impact. CONCLUSIONS: Incorporating updated cost data can drastically
change the ICER generated from health services research projects. Modelling with
current cost data is an essential contribution for iterative cost-benefit assessment
procedures.
A365
PCV129
TELEHEALTH—EARLY EVALUATION FINDINGS
Beale S1, Tatlock S1, Wheeler K2, Ryan J2
1
University of York, York, North Yorkshire, UK; 2NHS, York, North Yorkshire, UK
OBJECTIVES: NHS North Yorkshire and York commissioned York Health Economics Consortium to carry out an evaluation of their recent Telehealth pilot involving
patients with long-term conditions. The findings from the evaluation will be used to
inform plans for the further rollout of Telehealth in North Yorkshire. METHODS:
Three approaches were employed: a questionnaire was used to obtain details about
the Telehealth experiences of users and their carers; Case Managers and Community
Matrons with Telehealth patients on their caseloads were interviewed about referral
criteria and the impact of Telehealth on their role and patient care; Health care
resource use data were analyzed. Some caution should be used when generalizing
findings due to the small sample size and the specific characteristics of pilot Telehealth
recipients. RESULTS: Forty-eight questionnaires were handed out and twenty
returned (42%). Overall, respondents were happy with Telehealth (90%). Results
showed that the installation process had been smooth (75%); individuals had received
sufficient tuition (95%); they were confident using the equipment (95%); and were
happy with the service received from the monitoring centre (95%). Telehealth gave
users peace of mind and helped them to manage their own health condition. However,
a number of users had experienced technical issues (during installation and when
taking daily measurements). Although there had been some teething problems, mainly
in relation to the installation process and the monitoring system, clinicians were
broadly supportive of Telehealth. There was a repeated view that individual patient
characteristics needed to be taken into account when identifying patients who would
benefit from Telehealth. The impact of Telehealth on health care resource use was
difficult to determine within the eight month timescale of the pilot. CONCLUSIONS:
Telehealth gives users peace of mind and helps them manage their health; however,
its impact on health care resource use is still unclear.
PCV130
PRACTICE PATTERNS AND QUALITY OF LIFE IN ACUTE CORONARY
SYNDROME PATIENTS IN 2008–2009: BASELINE RESULTS FOR AUSTRIA
FROM THE ANTIPLATELET TREATMENT OBSERVATIONAL REGISTRY II
(APTOR II)
Ammer M1, Paget MA2, Hronkova M3, Norrbacka K4, Eber B1
1
Klinikum der Kreuzschwestern Wels, Wels, Austria; 2Lilly France S.A., Suresnes Cedex,
France; 3Eli Lilly & Company, Vienna, Austria; 4Eli Lilly & Company, Vantaa, Finland
OBJECTIVES: This analysis aims to explore management of acute coronary syndromes (ACS) from acute event to hospital discharge in Austria, and to measure
Quality of Life (QoL) at discharge. METHODS: This 12-month international, prospective, observational study recruited ACS patients in selected hospitals undergoing
percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI), April 2008–March 2009, capturing practice patterns, resource use and QoL. RESULTS: A total of 148 ACS-PCI patients (out
of the 152 recruited) were eligible: median age 60 yrs (IQR 51–69), median weight
80 kg (IQR 70–89), 20% female, 28% Type II diabetics, and 17% prior myocardial
infarction (MI). Index diagnosis was: unstable angina or non-ST-elevation MI (UA/
NSTEMI)-44% and ST-elevation MI (STEMI)-56%. Almost all patients (96%)
received stents: 28% bare metal stents only, 70% drug eluting stents only and 2%
both. Time from start of ACS symptoms to PCI was ≤3 days in 86% of UA/NSTEMI
patients and ≤1 day in 98% of STEMI patients. Oral antiplatelet medications with
loading dose (LD) used: aspirin-97% and clopidogrel-91%. Clopidogrel LD was
administered in the ambulance-9%, previous hospital-10%, emergency room-41%,
CCU or ICU-31%, catheterization lab-5%, or other ward-5%. LD was administered
between 6 hours before to 6 hours after PCI in 82% of cases. The first clopidogrel
LD was 600 mg in 85% and 300 mg in 10% of cases and in-hospital maintenance
dose was 75 mg in 97%. At time of hospital discharge, 97% of the discharged patients
were prescribed clopidogrel (discharge dose 75 mg for all patients except one). QoL
in discharged patients was good: median EQ-5D health state index at 1.00 (IQR
0.81–1.00). CONCLUSIONS: These real life data reflect treatment patterns among
ACS patients managed by PCI in selected hospitals in Austria in 2008–2009. Timing
and place of loading of antiplatelet agents differ. The QoL of patients at discharge
was high.
PCV131
AN INTERNATIONAL COMPARISON OF DUAL ANTIPLATELET USE BY
STENT TYPE AT 6 MONTHS FOLLOWING HOSPITAL DISCHARGE
AFTER ACUTE CORONARY SYNDROME: RESULTS FROM THE
ANTIPLATELET TREATMENT OBSERVATIONAL REGISTRY II (APTOR-II)
Pavlides G1, Coufal Z2, Mohacsi A3, James S4, Zeymer U5, Paget MA6, Goedicke J7,
Norrbacka K8, Berkenboom G9
1
Onassis Cardiac Surgery Center, Kallithca, Greece; 2Bata’s Regional Hospital, Zlin, Czech
Republic; 3Hungarian Institute of Cardiology, Budapest, Hungary; 4Uppsala University
Hospital, Uppsala, Sweden; 5Herzzentrum Ludwigshafen, Ludwigshafen, Germany; 6Lilly
France S.A., Suresnes Cedex, France; 7Eli Lilly & Company, Hamburg, Germany; 8Eli Lilly &
Company, Vantaa, Finland; 9U.L.B Erasme Hospital Brussels, Brussels, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: Current European Society of Cardiology Guidelines recommend dual
antiplatelet therapy for 12 months for patients with acute coronary syndrome (ACS);
however, reimbursement for antiplatelet therapy differs by EU country and is dependent upon the use of bare metal (BMS) or drug-eluting (DES) stents during percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI). Dual antiplatelet (clopidogrel + aspirin) treatment
A366
patterns were assessed at 6 months following hospital discharge for patients who
received only BMS and for patients with at least 1 DES. METHODS: A prospective,
observational registry of 11 European countries grouped into 6 clusters recruited ACS
patients undergoing PCI from 2008–2009. Interventional cardiologists collected data
from ACS events up to hospital discharge, and primary care physicians and cardiologists collected 6-month data. RESULTS: Of 3042 eligible patients at baseline, 2964
(97%) had 6-month data, of which 2842 (96%) received a stent at index PCI. The
percentage of patients with at least 1 DES was 17% in the Czech Republic, 31% in
Germany, 33% in Austria-Hungary, 33% in Belgium-The Netherlands, 37% in the
Nordic countries, and 81% in Greece. The percentage of patients taking dual antiplatelet therapy at hospital discharge ranged from 93% in Belgium-The Netherlands
to 100% in Greece for BMS only and from 93% in Belgium-The Netherlands to 100%
in Czech Republic for patients with DES. At 6 months, the percentage of patients
taking dual antiplatelet therapy ranged from 45% in Czech Republic to 97% in Greece
for BMS-only patients and from 83% in Belgium-The Netherlands to 97% in Greece
for patients with DES. Aspirin use ranged from 89% to 100% across the countries
and type of stent. CONCLUSIONS: Use of DES versus BMS varied among the European countries. In patients with BMS, there was marked variability with clopidogrel
use at 6 months; whereas, in patients with DES, clopidogrel was used more frequently
and with less variability.
PCV132
AN INTERNATIONAL COMPARISON OF ANTIPLATELET USE AT 6
MONTHS FOLLOWING HOSPITAL DISCHARGE IN UA/NSTEMI AND
STEMI PATIENTS UNDERGOING PCI: RESULTS FROM THE
ANTIPLATELET TREATMENT OBSERVATIONAL REGISTRY II (APTOR-II)
Coufal Z1, Berkenboom G2, Pavlides G3, Mohacsi A4, James S5, Paget MA6, Goedicke J7,
Norrbacka K8, Zeymer U9
1
Bata’s Regional Hospital, Zlin, Czech Republic; 2U.L.B Erasme Hospital Brussels, Brussels,
Belgium; 3Onassis Cardiac Surgery Center, Kallithca, Greece; 4Hungarian Institute of
Cardiology, Budapest, Hungary; 5Uppsala University Hospital, Uppsala, Sweden; 6Lilly France
S.A., Suresnes Cedex, France; 7Eli Lilly & Company, Hamburg, Germany; 8Eli Lilly &
Company, Vantaa, Finland; 9Herzzentrum Ludwigshafen, Ludwigshafen, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Current European Society of Cardiology Guidelines recommend dual
antiplatelet therapy for 12 months for all patients with acute coronary syndrome
(ACS). The variations in antiplatelet treatment patterns at 6 months following hospital
discharge were assessed in patients with unstable angina (UA), non-ST-elevation
myocardial infarction (NSTEMI), and ST-elevation MI (STEMI) undergoing percutaneous intervention (PCI). METHODS: A prospective, observational registry of 11
European countries grouped into 6 clusters recruited acute coronary syndrome (ACS)
patients undergoing PCI from 2008–2009. Interventional cardiologists collected data
from ACS events up to hospital discharge, and primary care physicians and cardiologists collected 6-month data. RESULTS: Of 3042 eligible patients at baseline, 2964
patients (97%) had 6 month data; 51% of patients presented with STEMI and 49%
with UA/NSTEMI. The median age was 62 yrs. At 6 months following hospital discharge, the percentage of UA/NSTEMI and STEMI patients using clopidogrel, respectively, was 70% and 40% in the Czech Republic, 84% and 89% in Germany, 98%
and 99% in Greece, 78% and 81% in the Nordic countries, 93% and 94% in Austria
and Hungary, and 81% and 88% in Belgium and the The Netherlands. The percentage
of UA/NSTEMI and STEMI patients taking aspirin, respectively, was 98% and 99%
in the Czech Republic, 89% and 90% in Germany, 97% and 100% in Greece, 95%
and 93% in the Nordic countries, 94% and 96% in Austria and Hungary, and 91%
and 94% in Belgium and the The Netherlands. CONCLUSIONS: Use of clopidogrel
varied considerably between European countries at 6 months after discharge, whereas
the majority (≥90%) of patients continued to use aspirin. Results suggest that both
physician and patient education on continuing dual antiplatelet therapy may be
needed.
PCV133
PRACTICE PATTERNS AND QUALITY OF LIFE IN ACUTE CORONARY
SYNDROME PATIENTS IN 2008–2009: BASELINE RESULTS FOR
GERMANY FROM THE ANTIPLATELET TREATMENT OBSERVATIONAL
REGISTRY II (APTOR II)
Zeymer U1, Norrbacka K2, Paget MA3, Goedicke J4, Clouth J5
1
Herzzentrum Ludwigshafen, Ludwigshafen, Germany; 2Eli Lilly & Company, Vantaa, Finland;
3
Lilly France S.A., Suresnes Cedex, France; 4Eli Lilly & Company, Hamburg, Germany; 5Lilly
Deutschland GmbH, Bad Homburg, Hessen, Germany
OBJECTIVES: This analysis aims to explore management of acute coronary syndromes (ACS) from acute event to hospital discharge in Germany, and to measure
Quality of Life (QoL) at discharge. METHODS: This 12-month international prospective, observational study recruited ACS patients undergoing percutaneous coronary
intervention (PCI), April 2008–March 2009, capturing practice patterns, resource use
and QoL. RESULTS: 500 ACS-PCI patients (out of the 508 recruited) were eligible:
median age 63 yrs (IQR 53–72), median weight 82 kg (IQR 74–92), 23% female,
24% Type II diabetics, and 27% prior myocardial infarction (MI). Index diagnosis
was: unstable angina or non-ST-elevation MI (UA/NSTEMI)-53% and ST-elevation
MI (STEMI)-47%. Almost all patients (96%) received stents: 68% bare metal stents
(BMS) only, 29% drug eluting stents (DES) only and 3% both. Time from start of
ACS symptoms to PCI was 3 days or less in 91% of UA/NSTEMI patients and 1 day
or less in 97% of STEMI patients. Oral antiplatelet medications with loading dose
(LD) used: aspirin-86% and clopidogrel-93%. Clopidogrel LD was administered in
13th Euro Abstracts
the ambulance-7%, previous hospital-8%, emergency room-32%, CCU or ICU-23%,
catheterization lab-25%, other ward 5%. LD was administered just before or direct
after PCI in 79% of cases. The clopidogrel LD was 600 mg in 68% and 300 mg in
24% of cases and in-hospital maintenance dose (MD) was 75 mg in 98%. At time of
hospital discharge, 92% of discharged patients were receiving clopidogrel (discharge
dose 75 mg in all cases). QoL in discharged patients was good: median EQ-5D health
state index at 0.85 (IQR 0.73–1.00). CONCLUSIONS: These real life data reflect
treatment patterns among ACS patients managed by PCI in Germany in 2008–2009.
Timing and place of antiplatelet loading differ between patients. The QoL of patients
at discharge was high.
PCV134
THERAPEUTIC VERSUS ACTUAL MARKET SHARES FOR STATINS
Gorevski E, Bian B, Kelton C, Boone J, Guo JJ
University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, OH, USA
OBJECTIVES: This study estimated market shares for six statins based on 1) the
literature-determined lipid-lowering potential of the drugs, and 2) the distribution of
U.S. adults depending on the amount of lipid-lowering they required. Estimated
market shares were compared with actual market shares. METHODS: Two panels
(1999–2000 and 2001–2002) from the National Health and Nutrition Examination
Survey (NHANES) provided interview, demographic, and laboratory data for 3324
people >20 years of age who were not taking a statin. In accordance with the ATP III
Guidelines, coronary heart disease (CHD) and CHD-risk-equivalent events including
diabetes, other risk factors such as smoking and high blood pressure, and Framingham
scores to obtain 10-year risk estimates were identified and calculated, respectively for
each person, along with percentage LDL-C lowering required to reach his or her
LDL-C goal. Depending on the amount of lowering needed and on whether the
individual had a liver condition, hence, enhanced risk of rhabdomyolysis, a particular
statin or particular statins with equal probabilities were assigned to the individual;
e.g., a person without a liver condition requiring 50% lowering of LDL-C would be
assigned rosuvastatin or atorvastatin, each with probability = 0.5. RESULTS: Of 1643
men surveyed, 57.88% were in the lowest-risk group (0–1 risk factors); 14.36% were
in the highest-risk group (CHD or CHD-risk-equivalent). For the 1681 women, these
percentages were 73.11% and 11.30%, respectively. Of people needing a statin,
73.74% needed LDL-C lowering by <25%; only 1.16% required LDL-C lowering of
>60%. Therapeutic market shares were estimated at 20.11% (rosuvastatin); 18.94%
(atorvastatin); 17.89% (simvastatin); 16.96% (lovastatin); 13.05% (fluvastatin); and
13.05% (pravastatin). CONCLUSIONS: Actual market shares are significantly different from market shares based on lipid-lowering considerations. Explanations include
direct-to-consumer advertising; varying pricing strategies; and clinical trials for additional indications and subpopulations conducted only by the market leaders.
PCV135
CREATING AN EFFICIENT HOSPITAL PAYMENT SYSTEM
1
2
Baser O , Gust C
1
STATinMED Research/University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA; 2STATinMED Research,
Ann Arbor, MI, USA
OBJECTIVES: By creating incentives around quality and efficiency, there exists consideration to bundle hospital and physician payments around the episodes of inpatient
surgery. We provided current payments around surgical episodes including the degree
to which different types of providers are involved. In particular, we looked at the most
expensive procedure performed commonly on the elderly: coronary artery bypass graft
(CABG) surgery. METHODS: The study was based on complete national U.S. claims
data. Managed care patients were excluded (16% in 2005) from the study because
service provided to them was not consistently captured in the data set. We also
excluded patients who were less than 65 years of age or over 99, and those not enrolled
in the data set at the time of their procedures (4%). Also excluded were patients who
were nursing home residents before surgery. Patients undergoing CABG were identified using ICD-9 codes. Price-standardized payments from the date of admission for
the index procedure to 30 days post-discharge were determined and categorized by
payment type (hospital, physician, and post-acute care) and sub-type. RESULTS: The
average total payment around an inpatient surgery episode was $45,358 for CABG.
Hospital payments accounted for the largest of total payments (60% of the procedure),
followed by physician payments (13%). Diagnosis-Related Group (DRG) payments
and surgeon and anesthesia professional payments together accounted for 65% of
total payments. Among payment types potentially leveraged by bundled payments,
30-day readmissions accounted for 10% of total payments around surgical episodes.
Post-acute care, including home health care and extended care facilities, accounted for
7% of total payments. CONCLUSIONS: Payments for potentially mutable services,
including outlier payments, 30-day readmissions, and post-acute care are considerable
and might be reduced by incentives for hospitals and physicians to improve quality
and efficiency.
PCV136
ATRIAL FIBRILLATION MANAGEMENT PATTERNS IN GREECE
Karampli E, Athanasakis K, Ollandezos M, Kyriopoulos J
National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece
OBJECTIVES: Construct the disease management model for patients with Atrial
Fibrillation (AF) in Greece, according to initial therapeutic approach. METHODS:
The analysis was based on data from patient records of 149 geographically distributed
cardiologists, extracted via strictly structured questionnaire-based interviews. Partici-
13th Euro Abstracts
pants were requested to categorize patients according to initial AF approach, i.e.
pharmacological or non-pharmacological (interventional) treatment option. Discrete
sets of answers were provided for each patient group. RESULTS: A pharmacological
therapy was the initial treatment approach for 89.6% of patients (rhythm control:
59.5%, rate control: 40.5%), whereas 5.2% had initially undergone non-pharmacological therapy, mainly catheter ablation (96% of cases). The remaining 5.2% received
no treatment. Patients on rhythm control were mainly prescribed a Class-III (28.9%),
Class-Ic (28.9%) or Class-II anti-arrhythmic agent, whereas 13.4% received a combination. In the rate control group, the treatments of choice were b-blockers (37.0%)
and digoxin (24.2%). The majority of patients, also, received anti-thrombotic medication (89.0%, 91.3% and 100% for rhythm control, rate control and non-pharmacological treatment, respectively). The most frequently performed diagnostic procedures
across groups, on an annual basis, were INR monitoring (8.3–11.5 tests/year), echocardiogram (4.0–4.4), liver (1.8–2.0) and renal function tests (1.7–1.9) and Holter
monitoring (1.4–1.6). On average 4.3, 4.0 and 3.1 consultations/year with a cardiologist are necessary for the monitoring of patients on rhythm, rate control and nonpharmacological treatment respectively. Annual hospitalization rates for patients
under rhythm control were 20% due to AF recurrence, 13% due to cardiovascular
complications and 5.63% due to drug adverse reactions. For patients under rate
control, the corresponding percentages were 6%, 6.13% and 4% and for those under
non-pharmacological therapy 18.75%, 3% and 4.86% respectively. CONCLUSIONS:
Pharmacological rhythm control appears to be the prevailing initial AF treatment
option in Greece. AF management requires an intense monitoring pattern, given that
it can lead to increased frequency of hospitalizations.
PCV137
A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW ON DISEASE BURDEN AND UNMET NEEDS
FOR VENOUS THROMBOEMBOLISM IN HOSPITALISED MEDICAL
PATIENTS IN EUROPE SHOWS UNDER-UTILIZATION OF PREVENTIVE
THERAPIES
Khoury H1, Welner S1, Kubin M2, Folkerts K2, Haas S3
1
BioMedCom Consultants inc., Dorval, QC, Canada; 2Bayer Schering Pharma AG,
Wuppertal, Germany; 3Technical University Munich, Munich, Germany
OBJECTIVES: To assess the incidence of venous thromboembolism (VTE) and current
practice patterns for VTE prophylaxis in hospitalised acutely ill medical patients in
Europe. METHODS: A systematic literature search was conducted in major databases
on the epidemiology and treatment practices of VTE prevention among adult patients
treated in hospital for major medical conditions. Relevant studies published between
1999 and April 2010 were captured. RESULTS: Thirty-five multinational and country-specific studies were retrieved, including randomized clinical trials, registry and
chart audits, meta-analyses, and cross-sectional, retrospective, prospective, and observational studies. Among patients admitted for an acute medical illness, the incidence
of VTE diagnosed during hospitalization ranged from 3.01% (mean hospital stay: 4.5
days) to 15% (day 14 from index hospitalization). While clinical guidelines recommend pharmacological VTE prophylaxis to all patients hospitalised for an acute
medical illness who are bedridden, a clear identification of specific risk groups who
would benefit from VTE prevention is lacking. In the majority of studies captured,
prophylaxis was underused among medical inpatients (all diseases); 33% to 82% of
all patients hospitalised for acute medical illnesses did not receive any VTE prophylaxis. Furthermore, among patients who did receive prophylaxis, a considerable proportion received medication that was not in agreement with guidelines, due to short
duration, suboptimal dose, or inappropriate type of prophylaxis. Of all prescriptions,
low molecular weight heparin was the most widely prescribed anticoagulant. In most
cases, the duration of VTE prophylaxis did not exceed hospital stay duration, and
varied between 5 and 33.8 days (mean duration). CONCLUSIONS: VTE imposes a
substantial burden among hospitalised medical patients. Despite the proven efficacy
of prophylaxis, utilization remains suboptimal among medical patients at risk for
VTE, stressing the necessity for improved or easier access to proven preventive therapies among these patients.
CARDIOVASCULAR DISORDERS – Conceptual Papers & Research on
Methods
PCV138
MEASUREMENT PROPERTIES OF PEAK VO2 IN CHILDREN WITH
PULMONARY ARTERIAL HYPERTENSION
Cappelleri JC1, Hwang LJ2, Mardekian J2, Mychaskiw MA2
1
Pfizer Inc, New London, CT, USA; 2Pfizer Inc, New York, NY, USA
OBJECTIVES: Although the 6-minute walk test (sub-maximal exercise test) historically has been used to evaluate the effect of pharmacologic intervention in adults with
pulmonary arterial hypertension (PAH), it was not widely regarded as appropriate for
children at all ages. Thus, Peak VO2 (maximal exercise test) was used in a pediatric
PAH trial (A1481131) to evaluate the effect of treatment. As this is the first large
controlled trial using the Peak VO2 endpoint in this population, we investigated its
performance in terms of correlational analyses. METHODS: Relationships between
change in Peak VO2 and other endpoints were evaluated using correlation coefficients
and regression analyses with the data from the 16-week randomized, placebo-controlled, clinical trial of sildenafil assessing Peak VO2 at both baseline and week 16 in
106 evaluable pediatric patients. a Bland-Altman plot was used to assess the reliability
of screen and baseline visit data. RESULTS: The intraclass correlation was 0.79 for
A367
the screening and baseline visit Peak VO2 data. Additionally, agreement between these
visits was supported by a Bland-Altman plot. Correlations of percentage changes in
Peak VO2 from baseline with the change from baseline in the Physician Global Assessment (overall and for sildenafil doses) and in World Health Organization Functional
Class (WHO FC, with baseline of I and III/IV) correlated well (correlations of ≥0.40)
and were responsive to change, while the low correlation with the Subject Global
Assessment (0.12) suggested influence by factors associated with child and parental
proxy response and instrument administration. Percentage changes in Peak VO2 gave
no real association (0.04) with the Family Cohesion of the Child Health Questionnaire. CONCLUSIONS: In pediatric PAH, Peak VO2 measurements exhibited good
reliability. Improvements in Peak VO2 were shown to be associated with improvements in qualitative clinical endpoints, including WHO FC and physician global
assessment.
PCV139
INTEGRATING PATIENT PREFERENCES IN EFFICIENCY FRONTIER
ANALYSES USING THE ANALYTIC HIERARCHY PROCESS
Hummel JM, Steuten L, Van Til J, Ijzerman MJ
University Twente, Enschede, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: In comparative effectiveness research and economic evaluations, benefits of technologies are measured using multiple outcomes measures. Information
lacks however about the importance of these endpoints for patients. We propose a
new methodology to integrate patient weighted outcomes in a cost-efficiency frontier.
We illustrate this methodology by means of an efficiency frontier analysis of five
alternative treatments of patients with equinovarus deformity poststroke. METHODS:
The Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) is a technique for multi-criteria analysis. The
AHP supported 140 patients to prioritize the outcome measures of treatments of
equinovarus deformity poststroke, and 10 professionals to prioritize the treatments
regarding the outcome measures. These outcome measures include functional outcomes, risk and side effects, comfort, daily effort, cosmetics, and impact of the treatment. Sensitivity analysis is based on bootstrapping of the participants’ priorities.
Relative costs include the device related costs and the care related costs of the treatments. RESULTS: The overall effectiveness of soft-tissue surgery (.41) is ranked first,
followed by orthopedic footwear (.18), ankle-foot orthosis (.15), surface electrostimulation (.14), and finally implanted electrostimulation (.12). Implanted electrostimulation (.35) and soft-tissue surgery (.34) are considered to be most expensive, followed
by surface electrostimulation (.26), orthopedic footwear (.03) and ankle-foot orthosis
(.02). Based on these priorities of the treatments’ overall effectiveness and costs, an
efficiency frontier was drawn that includes decision uncertainty. CONCLUSIONS:
The results suggest that the cost-effectiveness of implanted electrostimulation and
surface electrostimulation are unfavourable. This new methodology for efficiency
frontier analysis allows decision makers to integrate the outcomes about the diverse
values and costs of health care technology, and can be applied broadly. It is particularly suitable in the field of early technology assessment, since the AHP supports a
systematic estimation of priors about the effectiveness of alternative treatments.
PCV140
HOSPITAL QUALITY INDEX AND ITS USE ON RATES OF VENOUS
THROMBOEMBOLISM
Baser O1, Akin C2, Wang L3, Dysinger A3
1
STATinMED Research/University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA; 2STATinMED Research/
Brigham and Women’s Hospital, Ann Arbor, MI, USA; 3STATinMED Research, Ann Arbor,
MI, USA
OBJECTIVES: We used the composite quality index (CompQualTM) to examine the
association between venous thromboembolism (VTE) events and hospital quality for
patients who underwent major orthopedic surgery. METHODS: Using the empirical
Bayes approach to combine mortality rates with information on hospital volume at each
hospital, we created an index to weight observed mortality according to how reliable it
is estimated, with remaining weight placed on hospital volume (CompQualTM scoring
algorithm). Then, using a national database, all patients who underwent major orthopedic surgery were identified. Rates for patients who had a VTE event during their initial
hospitalization were calculated. By using the algorithm, every provider in the Medicare
data set was ranked according to their quality. Multivariate regression was used to see
the effect of quality on VTE event rates. RESULTS: We obtained a sample that included
2,745 patients in the VTE group. After controlling for patients’ demographic and
clinical factors, VTE events in low quality hospitals were almost 2.5 times higher than
VTE events in high quality hospitals (p = 0.000). We also compared the ranking with
only volume and only for hospitals. Our combined measure to rank the hospital was
more effective and explained more variation than the individual measures (pseudo
R-square: 0.46 for composite score, 0.15 for volume only, 0.09 for mortality only).
CONCLUSIONS: Using national Medicare data for patients with VTE, we found that
a simple composite measure was a strong predictor of subsequent performance for
operations. In this regard, it was more effective than individual measures. Such measures would be useful to help patients and payers identify low quality hospitals for
major surgery. Any policy implementation that would decrease the variation in hospital quality would have a direct effect on the rates of VTE events.
A368
PCV141
A NOVEL METHOD FOR ESTIMATING THE EFFECTS OF ADHERENCE
TO ANTIHYPERTENSIVES AND DURATION OF DRUG ACTION ON
CARDIOVASCULAR RISK
Lowy A, Brede Y
Novartis Pharma AG, Basel, Switzerland
Most patients miss occasional doses of antihypertensive treatment. The consequent
loss of blood pressure (BP) control, and thus increased cardiovascular risk, may be
mitigated by prescribing “forgiving” drugs that have a duration of antihypertensive
effect beyond the 24-hour dosing interval. However, the consequences of missed doses
for cardiovascular outcomes, and additional impact of duration of drug action, have
not been evaluated quantitatively. We developed a method to quantify the chain of
factors linking adherence and duration of drug action with outcomes; an important
consideration given that adherence and hence BP reduction in real-world clinical
practice are typically much lower than in randomised controlled trials. The method
involves simulating 256-day dosing histories for 1250 individuals, incorporating realistically distributed gaps in dosing based on a study of electronically monitored dosing
records from 4783 hypertensive patients in clinical trials. Percentage adherence is
adjusted by altering the proportion of doses missed while preserving a realistic distribution of gap length. Systolic BP (SBP) reduction for each patient is estimated, with
rises and falls according to the individual’s dosing behaviour. By averaging SBP reductions over time and individuals, population mean SBP reduction is estimated. Cardiovascular disease (CVD) risk over, for example, 10 years may then be predicted using
the Framingham Risk Equation, with baseline characteristics from NHANES 2005–
2006 (average data: age 65.2 years; 52.9% women; SBP 155.95 mmHg; total cholesterol 5.41 mmol/L) and baseline absolute 10-year CVD risk of 27.0%. The method
allows variable inputs including adherence level (%), rate of loss of antihypertensive
effect when treatment is interrupted (mmHg/day), rate of BP reduction when treatment
is (re)started (mmHg/day) and SBP-lowering effect of uninterrupted treatment
(mmHg). In conclusion, we describe a novel method that allows quantification of the
effects of treatment adherence and antihypertensive drug forgiveness on clinical outcomes (i.e. SBP and CVD risk reduction).
PCV142
AN APPLICATION OF IMPUTATION TECHNIQUES TO IMPROVE DATA
AVAILABILITY FROM ELECTRONIC MEDICAL RECORDS
Exuzides A, Colby C
ICON Clinical Research, San Francisco, CA, USA
OBJECTIVES: Analytic data sets based on electronic Medical Records (eMRs) offer
long and detailed patient follow-up, large sample sizes, and a rich set of variables.
However, the existence of a particular variable within an eMR is no assurance of
actual data availability for all patients. Patients may receive lab tests irregularly or
miss visits. Reporting standards can vary within an eMR system, creating large
numbers of patients with missing data. We present details from a three step imputation
process to improve eMR data availability from an observational study of hypertension
outcomes. METHODS: We used an analytic data set comprised of 227,257 patients
from 10 participating medical centers. One important element of the study was the
computation of a cardiovascular risk score based on 11 demographic and clinical
variables available from eMRs. However, only 43,676 patients (19%) had complete
data for all 11 variables. To increase the sample size of patients with complete data
for all 11 variables, we used three imputation techniques: we first allowed for lab and
blood pressure values to be carried forward to replace missing values; we then augmented a missing diabetes status with pharmacy data by using diabetes-specific medications to indicate a positive diabetes history; and, finally, we applied a multiple
imputation (MI) technique, based on a Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC)
approach, implemented using SAS® PROC MI. RESULTS: After application of the
three data imputation techniques, the sample size of patients with complete or imputed
data for all 11 variables increased to 75,209 (33%). This amounts to a substantial
increase (72%) in the number of patients with all critical variables available to be used
for further analysis. CONCLUSIONS: Proper application of imputation techniques,
including MI, can yield a substantial increase in the number of patients available for
analysis.
GASTROINTESTINAL DISORDERS – Clinical Outcomes Studies
PGI1
A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW OF THE DIAGNOSTIC ACCURACY OF
SEROLOGIC TESTS IN THE DIAGNOSIS OF CELIAC DISEASE
Costa V1, Chandra KM2, McCurdy B1, Ieraci L3, Levin L1
1
Ontario Ministry of Health and Long-term Care, Toronto, ON, Canada; 2McMaster
University, Hamilton, ON, Canada; 3Toronto Health Economics and Technology Assessment
(THETA) Collaborative, Toronto, ON, Canada
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of IgA (immunoglobulin A) and
IgG serologic tests in the diagnosis of celiac disease including anti-tissue transglutaminase (tTG) antibody, anti-deamidated gliadin peptide antibody (DGP), anti-endomysial antibody (EMA), and anti-gliadin antibodies (AGA). METHODS: A systematic
review of the peer-reviewed literature was conducted to identify studies that evaluated
the sensitivity and specificity of serologic celiac disease tests using small bowel biopsy
as the gold standard. The patient population consisted of untreated, undiagnosed
subjects with symptoms consistent with the disease. Pooled estimates of sensitivity and
13th Euro Abstracts
specificity were calculated using a bivariate, binomial generalized linear mixed model
(SAS 9.2) which takes into account the negative correlation between sensitivity and
specificity. Statistical significance was defined by p-values less than 0.05, where “false
discovery rate” adjustments were made for multiple hypothesis testing. RESULTS: In
total, 17 studies were eligible for the analysis. The pooled analysis showed that IgA
tTG has a sensitivity of 92.1% (95% CI 88.0, 96.3), compared to 89.2% (83.3, 95.1,
p = 0.12) for IgA DGP, 85.1% (79.5, 94.4, p = 0.07) for IgA EMA, 74.9% (63.6,
86.2, p = 0.0003) for IgA AGA. Combining more than one serologic test slightly
increased the sensitivity, 95.1% (92.2, 98%, p = 0.039 vs. IgA tTG). The pooled
sensitivity of IgG DGP was 88.4% (95% CI: 82.1, 94.6), 44.7% (30.3, 59.2, p =
0.0003) for IgG tTG, and 69.1% (56.0, 82.2, p = 0.34) for IgG AGA. Specificity
ranged from 90.1% to 93.9% and was similar among the different tests. The quality
of the evidence according to the GRADE Working Group criteria was considered
“moderate” for IgA tTG and EMA, “low” for IgA DGP and test combinations, and
“very low” for IgA AGA. CONCLUSIONS: The evidence available suggests that IgA
tTG has a higher accuracy than other serologic tests. Combining more than one
serologic test contributes little to the diagnostic accuracy.
PGI2
IS THERE ANY DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE EFFECTS OF THERAPY
WITH PEGINTERFERON-ALPHA-2A VERSUS STANDARD-DOSE
PEGINTERFERON-ALPHA-2B? A META-ANALYSIS COMPARING BOTH
TREATMENTS PLUS RIBAVIRIN IN GENOTYPE 1/4 CHRONIC HEPATITIS
C VIRUS (HCV) INFECTION PATIENTS
Barros FMR1, Cheinquer H2, Borges LG3, Santos E3
1
Hospital Português de Beneficência em Pernambuco and Hospital das Clínicas—UFPE,
Recife, Brazil; 2Hospital das Clínicas da Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul, Porto
Alegre, Brazil; 3Roche Brazil, São Paulo, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: Until recently, few head-to-head trials evaluated the efficacy of peginterferon-alpha-2a versus peginterferon-alpha-2b and none meta-analysis was available
so far. In 2010, a meta-analysis performed by Awad et al was able to demonstrate
that peginterferon-alpha-2a was more efficacious in achieving sustained virological
response as compared to peginterferon-alpha-2b. McHutchison 2009, one of the
studies included in the meta-analysis, evaluated two different doses of peginterferonalpha-2b (standard-dose: 1,5 mcg/kg; low-dose: 1,0 mcg/kg), raising doubts about
possible negative impact of lower dose on the analysis results.We aim to compare
treatment outcomes in genotypes 1/4 HCV infection treated with peginterferon-alpha2a versus peginterferon-alpha-2b at standard-dose (per package insert) both plus ribavirin in order to assess efficacy, performing a systematic review and meta-analysis of
published randomized controlled trials (RCTs). METHODS: An extensive search
through main medical information databases (MEDLINE, Cochrane Library, Embase
and Lilacs) and specialized websites was conducted on the second trimester of 2010.
We aim to indentify RCTs which evaluate treatment efficacy of peginterferon-alpha-2a
versus standard-dose peginterferon-alpha-2b both plus ribavirin for HCV treatment
in genotypes 1/4 patients not co-infected with HIV. According to heterogeneity test,
a fixed or a random-effect model was adopted. RESULTS: Only 6 papers out of 623
found (databases citation without duplicates plus manual searches) met our inclusion
criteria: 1)Ascione, 2009; 2)Rumi, 2009; 3)McHutchison, 2009; 4)Yenice, 2006; 5)
Scotto, 2008; 6)Berak, 2007. For genotypes 1/4 chronic HCV infection patients,
peginterferon-alpha-2a showed higher SVR as compared to standard dose of peginterferon-alpha-2b: 42.09% versus 33.44% (RR = 1.10, IC 95% 1.006–1.202, assuming a fixed-effect framework). CONCLUSIONS: According to these results, no
significant impact on already published meta-analysis results was observed when lower
dose peginterferon-alpha-2b patients were excluded from the analysis. In summary,
peginterferon-alpha-2a is more effective in treating genotypes 1/4 HCV infected
patients as compared to standard-dose peginterferon-alpha-2b, both in association
with ribavirin.
PGI3
EFFICACY OF ANTIBIOTICS AND PROBIOTICS IN MANAGEMENT OF
POUCHITIS; A META-ANALYSIS
Abdollahi M1, Nikfar S2, Darvish Damavandi M3
1
Faculty of Pharmacy; and Pharmaceutical Sciences Research Center, Tehran University of
Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran; 2Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Faculty of Pharmacy
and Food & Drug Laboratory Research Center, Iran MOH, Tehran, Iran; 3Faculty of Science,
National University of Singapore, Singapore
OBJECTIVES: Pouchitis is the most frequent long-term complication of ileal pouchanal anastomosies (IPAA) surgery for ulcerative colitis (UC) which is a nonspecific
inflammation of the ileal reservoir. Its clinical frequency varies depending on the definition and the follow up but is approximately 50% after a decade. Antibiotics and
probiotics are currently the most widely accepted treatment in pouchitis patients.
Objective of this study was to meta-analyze efficacy of probiotics and antibiotics in
the management of pouchitis. METHODS: All databases specially Pubmed, Web of
Science, Scopus, Cochrane, and Google Scholar were searched between 1965 and
December 2009, and relevant controlled clinical trials were extracted, reviewed, and
validated according to the study protocol. The outcome of interest was defined by a
pouchitis disease activity index (PDAI) < 7. Thirteen clinical trials were included in
the meta-analysis. RESULTS: Pooling of the results from eight trials yielded a relative
risk (RR) of 5.33 with a 95% CI of 2.12–13.35 and a significant RR (P = 0.0004) in
the treatment group in comparison with the placebo group. Summary RR for clinical
improvement in 6 trials was 14.17 with a 95% CI of 1.19–168.93 (P = 0.036) in
13th Euro Abstracts
efficacy of VSL#3 (all doses) comparing to placebo and slightly more effective for
VSL#3 (6 g/day) comparing to placebo with RR of 20.35 with a 95% CI of 6.16–
67.22 (P < 0.0001). Efficacy of antibiotics comparing to placebo showed a summary
RR of 2.68 with a 95% CI of 0.4–17.99 and P = 0.3107 for clinical improvement in
three trials. The summary RR for efficacy of ciprofloxacin comparing to metronidazole
was 0.68 with a 95% CI of 0.44–1.06 (P = 0.8913). CONCLUSIONS: In conclusion,
alongside the benefit of probiotics and antibiotics in the management of pouchitis,
effects of probiotics and antibiotics on pouchitis vary according to different mixtures
of microorganisms strains in probiotics and different spectrums of antibiotics.
PGI4
PREVALENCE AND INCIDENCE OF HEPATITIS A IN A UNITED STATES
MANAGED CARE CLAIMS DATABASE
Changolkar AK1, Eisenberg D2, Misurski DA1
1
GlaxoSmithKline, Philadelphia, PA, USA; 2HealthCore, Wilmington, DE, USA
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the prevalence and incidence of hepatitis a in a managed
care population, segmented by a range of characteristics including age, gender, geography, and health insurance plan. METHODS: This was an observational retrospective cohort study utilizing medical and pharmacy claims data for January 1, 2005
through December 31, 2008 from the Impact National Managed Care Database
(Benchmark Database). The index date was defined as the date of the first and only
diagnostic claim for hepatitis a within the intake period. All prevalence results reported
below are per 100,000 and incidence is presented as per person years. RESULTS: Out
of a total of 94,985,124 subjects in the database, females and males were represented
equally (51% and 49% respectively). The 45–64 year age group had the greatest
percentage of subjects. The prevalence of hepatitis a among men and women were
almost equal (9 and 8, respectively). The 45–54 years age group had the highest hepatitis a prevalence (4) followed by the 25–34, 35–44, and 55–64 age groups (3 for each
group). The largest hepatitis a prevalence rate was from the northeast region (7) followed by the south (6). In the 2005–2008 timeframe, hepatitis a prevalence was similar
in each year (4). Incidence rates across age, region and specific zip codes in person
years were less than 1 person per year. The incidence was slightly higher in males.
Among three digit zip codes, the zip codes “100” showed higher incidences each year
with higher prevalence. CONCLUSIONS: In a large commercially insured US population, we observed similar prevalence rates of hepatitis a for males and females. The
disease was most prevalent in the 45–54 years age group. The northeast had the
highest prevalence rate from 2005–2008.
GASTROINTESTINAL DISORDERS – Cost Studies
PGI5
A BUDGET IMPACT ANALYSIS OF THE HEPATITIS C TREATMENT
WITH PEGYLATED INTERFERON IN BRAZIL
Fonseca M, Araújo GTBD
AxiaBio, São Paulo, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: Cost-effectiveness analyses of new hepatitis C drugs have been used to
select and approve drugs that should be financed by the public health care system.
However there are still a huge amount of uncertainties within these studies. The fact
of having pharmacoeconomic and budget impact data of these new pharmacological
alternatives will help to select the most efficient alternative. With this, the objective is
to perform a budget impact analysis (BIA) of the treatment with pegylated interferon
(pegIFN), alfa-2a or alfa-2b, plus ribavirin in, economically active genotype I patients,
aging from 30 to 59 years, with chronic hepatitis C (CHC). METHODS: An interactive model has been designed from the inputs obtained from the medical literature.
Both strategies have been considered as therapeutic equivalents, without significative
difference in side effects, and as having the same price. RESULTS: The number of
patients with CHC evaluated in the model has been of 355,611, 15.2% between 30
and 39 years, 13% between 40 and 49 years and 9% between 50 and 59 years,
mimicking the Brazilian population and with an average weight of 70.6 kg. The duration of treatment was 48 weeks, with virologic response measured in weeks 2.4,12.24
and 48. a total of 91% and 99.8% of the patients receiving pegIFN alfa-2a or alfa-2b,
respectively achieved sustained virological response at 72 weeks. Total cost was R$
4,012,531,131.29 and R$3,752,238,973.99 for the treatment with pegIFN alfa-2a +
RIB and pegIFN alfa-2b + RIB, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Although cost-effectiveness analysis appears to be favorable to pegIFN alfa-2a + RIB, a BIA seems to
favour pegIFN alfa-2b + RIB due to its better predictability in the 12nd week of treatment. In this case, the treatment with pegIFN alfa-2b + RIB (in comparison with
pegIFN alfa-2a + RIB) is an efficient strategy.
PGI6
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF MR ELASTOGRAPHY FOR DIAGNOSING
LIVER FIBROSIS: PRELIMINARY THRESHOLD ASSESSMENT
Lee DW1, Palathinkara V1, Dekoven M2
1
GE Healthcare, Waukesha, WI, USA; 2IMS Health, Falls Church, VA, USA
OBJECTIVES: MR Elastography (MRE) is a non-invasive test under clinical trial
evaluation for effectiveness in helping diagnose liver fibrosis. This study estimated the
accuracy needed for MRE to be cost-neutral from a US payer’s perspective.
METHODS: We constructed a decision-analytic model comparing diagnostic costs
under two scenarios for patients with suspected liver fibrosis: 1) biopsy, or 2) MRE
followed by biopsy when the MRE test was positive. We conducted a targeted litera-
A369
ture review and consulted with a leading hepatologist and pathologist to identify the
appropriate procedure codes associated with liver biopsy; we assumed MRE would
be reimbursed using CPT-4 code 74,181 (magnetic resonance (eg., proton) imaging,
abdomen; without contrast material(s)). We assigned the appropriate allowable
charges to the identified procedure codes using the 2010 Medicare Physician Fee
Schedule. Finally, we assumed negative predictive values (NPV) of 0.8, 0.9 and 0.95,
and that patients with a false-negative MRE ultimately received a biopsy. RESULTS:
The cost of a liver biopsy was $1424 (ultrasound $164, surgical $881, pathology
$347, laboratory $32) and the cost of an MRE (without contrast) was $946 (hospital
setting) or $666 (non-hospital setting). In a hospital setting, MRE is potentially cost
saving if the test-negative rate is greater than 83%, 74% and 70% for NPVs of 0.8,
0.9 and 0.95, respectively. In a non-hospital setting, MRE can reduce diagnostic costs
when more than 58%, 52% and 49% or patients have negative MRE results for the
corresponding NPV values. CONCLUSIONS: The cost of liver biopsy is substantial
as compared to MRE. MRE offers the potential of reducing the cost of diagnosing
liver fibrosis by avoiding unnecessary biopsies. Cost saving potential increases with
MRE’s negative predictive value and negative test rate.
PGI7
ECONOMIC BURDEN OF OPIOID INDUCED CONSTIPATION IN SPAIN
1
2
1
1
Guijarro P , Alonso-Babarro A , Viqueira A , Fernandez G
1
Pfizer Spain, Alcobendas, Madrid, Spain; 2La Paz Hospital, Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: To analyze the use of health care resources and the associated costs in
patients with opioid induced constipation (OIC). METHODS: An observational,
retrospective, multicenter study was carried out in Spanish National Health System
hospitals. All patients were free of constipation at baseline and received opioids for
at least 2 months. In order to determine patient resource utilization, a review of the
patient records and patient-interviews were performed to all patients diagnosed with
OIC. Patients were evaluated depending on response to oral treatment for OIC. The
observation period was 2 months. The unit costs were obtained from Spanish databases (c 2009). RESULTS: A total of 744 patients were included. Patients had a mean
(SD) age of 64.2 (13.4) and 48% were male. During the study period, 46.6% of the
patients developed OIC. Most of these were treated first with oral laxatives exclusively
(67.7%), 63.8% responded to the treatment and 36.2% did not. Of the total number
of patients with OIC, 61.5% required a visit to health care services. Forty-four patients
required a visit to the Emergency Room (ER) and 26 were hospitalized with a median
length of stay of 3 days. Overall mean total cost (SD) of constipation management
was c271.08 (c621.22). Resource utilization in responders to oral laxatives was statistically significant lower than in non-responders. a higher percentage of non-responders required health care visits, ER visits, and hospitalizations (P < 0.001). The mean
cost (SD) for each responder was c115 (c230) compared to c442 (c810) for each
non-responder (P < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: OIC increases health care resource
utilization particularly in patients with a poor response to oral laxatives. The economic
burden of OIC was 3.8 times higher in non-responders than in responders.
PGI8
HIDDEN COSTS OF ROTAVIRUS DISEASE—A RETROSPECTIVE
MATCHED ANALYSIS OF HOSPITAL EPISODE STATISTICS (HES) DATA
Morgan C1, Adlard NE2, Carroll SM2
1
Cardiff Research Consortium Ltd, CARDIFF, UK; 2Sanofi Pasteur MSD, Maidenhead, UK
OBJECTIVES: To determine the impact of rotavirus (RV) disease as a secondary
diagnosis on hospital length of stay (LOS) and cost for children under five years of
age in England. METHODS: The study was based on Hospital Episodes Statistics for
England 2001–2007 using a matched cohort design. Admissions with a secondary
diagnosis of RV were extracted and matched by age, year of admission and, where
relevant, therapeutic procedure, to other admissions from HES with the same primary
diagnosis. Primary admissions were classified as potentially related or unrelated to
RV. LOS was compared using the paired Wilcoxon test. RESULTS: Of 2126 admissions with a secondary diagnosis of RV, 707 (33.3%) had no other secondary diagnoses. Of these, 385 admissions were matched for primary diagnosis to controls.
Median LOS for admissions was 2.0 days (Inter-Quartile Range [IQR] 1.0–4.0), mean
(sd) 3.2 (4.1) compared with median 1.0 (IQR 0.0–1.5), mean 1.4 (sd 3.5) for control
admissions (p-value < 0.001). Median cost/admission was £771 (IQR £604–£1090),
mean cost was £1105 (sd £1064) compared with median £650 (IQR £564–£1090),
£902 (sd 1004) (p-value < 0.001). a total of254/385 admissions were defined as
unrelated to RV. For these admissions, median LOS was 2.0 days (IQR 1.0–4.25),
mean 3.7 (sd 4.5) compared with median 1.0 (IQR 0.0–2.0), mean 1.6 (sd 4.0) for
control admissions (p-value < 0.001). Median cost/admission was £918 (IQR £564–
£1090), mean £1132, (sd £1132) compared with median £771 (IQR £564–£1090),
mean £980 (sd £1187), (p-value < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: As a secondary diagnosis
in HES, RV has a significant incremental impact on LOS and cost. Variations in testing
and reporting of RV mean that HES data may significantly under represent the overall
burden of RV disease. This implies that standard modelling methodologies may
underestimate the true burden of RV disease in the context of health care acquired
infection.
A370
PGI9
HOSPITAL COST FOR TREATMENT OF PATIENTS WITH PEPTIC ULCER
BLEED (PUB) IN SWEDEN—DATA FROM THE KPP (COST PER PATIENT)
DATABASE
Sörngård H1, Sverdén Eklund E2, Söderlund C2, Marschall HU3
1
AstraZeneca AB, Södertälje, Sweden; 2Södersjukhuset, Stockholm, Sweden; 3Karolinska
Unviersitetssjukhuset, Stockholm, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: Treatment with esomeprazole or placebo was investigated in patients
with PUB (NCT00251979). In all, 102 of 764 patients from 16 countries in Europe,
Asia and Africa were Swedish. Following successful endoscopic hemostasis, patients
were randomized to 72 hours intravenous esomeprazole or placebo with subsequent
oral esomeprazole 40 mg for 27 days. Rebleeding was the primary variable and
occurred in 7.2% and 12.9% in the esomeprazole and placebo group, respectively.
The objective of this study was to describe hospital costs in Sweden for patients with
and without rebleeding. METHODS: The KPP database includes 60% of all Swedish
episodes of somatic in-hospital care and reports total hospital costs. Six out of the 12
participating Swedish hospitals utilize KPP. Here, individual cost data was collected
and matched with the in-hospital episode and the study definition of rebleeding.
RESULTS: Data was collected from all 60 patients in the six KPP reporting clinics.
Information structure and level of detail varied considerably between clinics, why only
total costs are reported. Six patients (10%) were defined as rebleeders, and accounted
for 20% of the total costs for all patients. The mean total cost/patient was SEK 39,822
(median 29,082, range: 10,377–263,520) for all patients without rebleeding and SEK
88,928 (median 82,273, range: 52,464–160,090) for all patients with rebleeding (c1
= SEK9.84). The mean cost per patient without rebleeding varied between clinics from
SEK 14,791 to 45,636. CONCLUSIONS: Hospital costs for patients with PUB vary
considerably. The cost of patients with rebleeding was more than double that of
patients without rebleeding, and in all the 10% of patients who rebled accounted for
20% of the total hospital costs. In conclusion, a treatment which successfully prevents
rebleeding is important not only from a clinical perspective, but also from a cost point
of view to reduce hospital costs.
PGI10
MODELLING THE IMPACT OF TREATMENT WITH ENTECAVIR ON
HEALTH CARE COSTS OF CHRONIC HEPATITIS B IN FRANCE
Zambrowski JJ1, Ratziu V2, Bourlière M3, Pol S4, Zarski JP5, Woolmore A6, Bregman B7,
Sahraoui S7, Bronowicki JP8
1
Service de Droit & Economie de la santé—Faculté des sciences pharmaceutiques et
biologiques—Université Paris Descartes Paris, France, 2Service Hépato-Gastro-Entérologie,
Hôpital de la Pitié-Salpêtrière, Paris, France, 3Hôpital St-Joseph, Marseille, France, 4Hôpital
Cochin, Paris, France, 5Clinique Universitaire d’Hépato-Gastroentérologie—CHU de
Grenoble, Grenoble, France, 6Monitor Group France, Pairs, France, 7Bristol-Myers Squibb,
Rueil-Malmaison, France, 8Service Hépato-Gastro-Entérologie, Centre Universitaire de
Nancy-Brabois, Vandoeuvre-les-Nancy, France
OBJECTIVES: Chronic hepatitis B (CHB) treatment necessitate, according to European guidelines, to use potent antiviral agents with optimal resistance profiles.
Increased health care financial burden means physicians, payers and decision makers
need to evaluate CHB treatment cost-effectiveness. This model aims to estimate the
medical cost savings of treating nucleoside-naïve CHB patients with a potent antiviral
agent, from a French payer’s perspective. METHODS: CHB was simulated using a
disease-state transition model with states defined as mild fibrosis (Ishak F0/F1), significant
fibrosis (F2–F4), advanced fibrosis/cirrhosis (>F4) and complicated states (decompensated
cirrhosis (DC), hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC), liver transplant and death) based on
available natural history data. The model assumed a 5-year entecavir treatment and
30-year follow-up and was based on available clinical data. The transition probabilities
between states increased with detectable viral load levels and varied by HBeAg status.
Direct medical costs included CHB and liver complications management. The primary
model output is the estimated cost avoided per patient per day of treatment, compared to
no treatment in nucleoside-naïve CHB patients. RESULTS: Progression to HCC, liver
transplant or death was estimated at 76% for untreated patients compared to 31%
for entecavir patients, while the progression to DC, HCC, liver transplant or post-liver
transplant resulted in annual costs/patient of c9,718 [95% confidence interval (CI):
8,260; 11,175], c5,066 [4,306; 5,826], c87,105 [74,039; 100,171] and c19,421
[16,508; 22,335], for 2008, respectively. Cost of not treating CHB patients was
estimated at c16.4/day (average over patient lifetime). Entecavir treatment translated
into specific patient benefit with an estimated cost saving of c1.2/day of entecavir
treatment (95% CI: −9.6; 4.6). CONCLUSIONS: Treatment of CHB using a potent
antiviral agent with high genetic barrier to resistance, such as entecavir, is costeffective as associated with improved clinical outcomes and lower health care costs
compared with no treatment.
PGI11
RISK FACTORS AND COSTS ASSOCIATED TO NSAIDS THERAPIES IN
ITALY: AN ADMINISTRATIVE DATABASE ANALYSIS
Berti A1, Rossi E1, Sacripanti C2, Poluzzi E2, De Rosa M1
1
Cineca, Casalecchio di Reno (BO), Italy; 2Università di Bologna, Bologna, Italy
OBJECTIVES: Describe treatment patterns of NSAIDs, risk factors for gastrointestinal
injuries and associated costs. METHODS: Prescriptions of reimbursed NSAIDs in
2007 were selected from ARNO database and analyzed for 12 months in 23 Italian
Local Health Units. Intensity of NSAID use and co-medications were analyzed. Cluster
analysis and risk stratification were performed to assess the influence of risk factor in
NSAID prescriptions and gastroprotective (GP) co-medications. Risk factor analysis
13th Euro Abstracts
was based on prescribing limitative AIFA (Agenzia Italiana del FArmaco) note 1 for
GP: presence of chronic NSAID treatment, age ≥60 years, concomitant antithrombotics, cortisonics and/or previous gastric events. RESULTS: Among 1,028,100 new
NSAIDs recipients (76% of overall treated) 31% received nimesulide, 33% diclofenac,
20% ketoprofen, 13% ibuprofen, 12% COX2i and 10% piroxicam. NSAID prevalence appeared increased with age, whereas decreased in >80 years except for ibuprofen. Fifty-eight percent of patients <60 yo received <40 posologic units/year.
Meanwhile, 62% of patients ≥60 yo received >80 posologic units/year. Patients on
ibuprofen + COX2i seemed to have more risk factors (at least 2 risk factors consistent
with AIFA prescribing note 1 in >33% of patients treated with COX2i or ibuprofen)
in comparison with <30% for those treated with the other NSAIDs (P < 0.001).
Moreover, ibuprofen, COX2i and diclofenac showed statistically significant higher
frequency of GP co-medication (16%) compared to other NSAIDs, (<13%, P < 0.001).
Drug expenditure varied among treatments. Nimesulide and COX2i were associated
with the highest NSAIDs + GP total costs/year, respectively 167 and 212 euros.
Despite the high frequency of GP co-medications with ibuprofen and diclofenac, lower
expenditures were observed, 138 and 118 euros, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: This
analysis showed that cost for gastroprotective co-medications were higher than the
cost of NSAIDs alone. However, NSAIDs + GP expenditure differed among NSAID
treatment groups.
PGI12
ECONOMIC CONSEQUENCES OF POORLY CONTROLLED PATIENTS
WITH GASTROESOPHAGEAL REFLUX DISEASE IN GERMANY, ITALY
AND SPAIN
Darba J1, Restovic G2, Kaskens L2, Plans P3
1
Universitat de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain; 2BCN Health, Barcelona, Spain; 3Generalitat de
Catalunya, Barcelona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to estimate the implications of poorly
controlled GERD for patients and the economic implications for health care providers
and employers in Germany, Italy and Spain. METHODS: Based on population figures,
prevalence and incidence for GERD and its implications and cost data, the number
of patients with poorly treated GERD and their implications, as well as the economic
consequences for health services and employers were calculated for each country.
RESULTS: The amount of patients with poorly treated GERD that have severe
esophagitis are estimated to be 740,364 in Germany, 240,559 in Italy and 225, 054
in Spain per year. The number of patients with Barrett’s oesophagus are estimated to
be 29,678 in Spain, 19,327 in Germany and 10,079 in Italy. The number of patients
with adenocarcinoma are around 483 patients in Germany, 142 in Spain, and 53 in
Italy. Costs for poorly treated GERD patients for the health services were estimated
to be c18 million for Spain, c12 million for Germany and c7 million for Italy. Absenteeism and presenteeism costs due to poorly controlled GERD for employers were
almost none. CONCLUSIONS: Costs for complications in patients with poorly controlled GERD added costs for health care systems for all three countries but almost
no extra costs were found for employers.
PGI13
MODELING THE LONG TERM CONSEQUENCES OF SUPPRESSING
VIRAL REPLICATION IN CHRONIC HEPATITIS B: A COSTEFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS OF ENTECAVIR (BARACLUDE®) IN TURKEY
Lescrauwaet B1, Saylan M2, Malhan S3, Öksüz E3, Korkmaz M3, Kursun E3, Eminsoy G3
1
Bristol-Myers Squibb, Braine-l’Alleud, Belgium; 2Bristol-Myers Squibb, Istanbul, Turkey,
Turkey; 3Baskent University, Ankara, Turkey
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of entecavir(ETV) vs.lamivudine(LVD)
in the treatment of nucleoside-naive CHB patients and vs. adefovir(ADV) in LVD
refractory CHB patients in Turkey. METHODS: A decision-tree model compared cost
and effect of treating CHB patients over a 10-year period. Treatment effect in terms
of viral load(VL) reduction predicted risk of long-term liver complications. Two CHB
patient populations were studied: 1) nucleoside-naïve patients treated for 2 years with
ETV(0,5 mg/day) vs. LVD(100 mg/day) and ADV as salvage therapy in case of LVD
resistance; and 2)LVD- refractory patients treated for 10 years with ETV(1 mg/day)
vs. ADV(10 mg/day). Effectiveness was measured as LYS and QALY. Efficacy data
were obtained from pivotal trials, relative-risk estimations were derived from the
R.E.V.E.A.L.-HBV Study cohort. a Turkish health care payer perspective was considered and a 3% discount rate was used for costs and outcomes. RESULTS: In the
cohort of HBeAg(+/−) CHB patients, net incremental drug cost of ETV was higher
compared to LVD. However, ETV was associated with a lower projected number of
liver events (−73 and −55CC events, −43 and −33HCC events respectively, −8DC
events in each cohort) compared with LVD. In nucleoside-naïve HBeAg(+) patients,
ETV compared with LVD and ADV as salvage therapy gained 0.82LYS and
0.68QALYs at an incremental cost of 5384TL(6571TL/LYS and 7865TL/QALY). In
nucleoside-naïve HBeAg(-) patients, ETV generated 0.66LYS and 0.55QALY at an
incremental cost of 7257TL(11039TL/LYS and 13,203TL/QALY). In LVD-refractory
patients, ETV generated 0.48LYS and 0.40QALY with a saving of 14,117TL
(−29,416TL/LYS and −35,178TL/QALY). CONCLUSIONS: This cost-effectiveness
analysis suggests that in the Turkish health care system, ETV is a cost-effective treatment option compared with LVD in the treatment of naïve CHB patients. In LVD
refractory patients, ETV is a cost-saving treatment option relative to LVD with ADV
as salvage therapy. Cost-benefits with ETV therapy are explained lower overall CHB
treatment costs due to slower disease progression rate and avoidance of resistance
associated with LVD.
13th Euro Abstracts
PGI14
COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS ON THE USE OF TEGASEROD
COMPARED TO STANDARD THERAPY IN PATIENTS WITH IRRITABLE
BOWEL SYNDROME WITHIN AN INSTITUTIONAL SETTING IN MEXICO
Briones B, Garcia F
Novartis Farmaceutica S.A., Mexico City, DF, Mexico
OBJECTIVES: Irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) is a functional gastrointestinal disorder
prevalent in up to 35% of the adult population in Mexico, thus rendering high costs
for health institutions. Tegaserod, a 5-HT4 receptor agonist approved for the treatment
of IBS, could potentially render a beneficial economic impact. An economic evaluation
was performed to assess the economic impact of treating IBS patients with tegaserod
in comparison to standard therapy in an institutional setting in Mexico. METHODS:
A cost-effectiveness analysis was performed within an institutional setting (Mexican
Institute of Social Security, IMSS). The drug comparator used was butylhyoscine, as
it is the recommended standard therapy available in the National Formulary, as
published in the institution’s IBS clinical guidelines. Resource utilization data was
obtained from previous studies; physician consults, drug usage, laboratory tests,
endoscopic procedures, non-endoscopic diagnostic procedures, and surgical procedures were used for the analysis; a triangular probability distribution was used. Efficacy data was obtained from published meta-analysis studies. The source of the unit
costs was the institution, current for 2009. Discount rate was not used because the
time horizon was for 1 year. a probabilistic sensibility analysis was obtained through
a Monte Carlo simulation with 100,000 iterations in the weakest parameters.
RESULTS: The expected annual cost with standard therapy was $19,431.92 per
patient in local currencies (Mexican Pesos, MXP), as compared to $18,394.68 with
tegaserod therapy. Tegaserod was more effective than the standard therapy. Probabilistic sensibility analysis showed the same conclusions, regardless of the variability in
resource utilization and efficacy. CONCLUSIONS: From an institutional perspective
in Mexico, tegaserod is a cost-effective therapeutic option (dominant) for the treatment
of IBS in comparison with the current standard therapy featured in the National
Formulary.
PGI15
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF SEROLOGIC TESTING FOR DIAGNOSING
CELIAC DISEASE
Chandra KM1, Costa V2, Blackhouse G1, Goeree R1
1
McMaster University, Hamilton, ON, Canada; 2Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care,
Toronto, ON, Canada
OBJECTIVES: To assess the cost-effectiveness of tests for diagnosing celiac disease
(CD). The following tests were assessed: biopsy; endomysial antibody (EMA); antigliadin antibody (AGA); deaminated gliadin peptide (DGP); tissue transglutaminase
(TTG); and panel of tests. METHODS: A decision analysis was constructed to
compare costs and outcomes based on sensitivity, specificity and prevalence estimates
from a primary systematic literature review. Study results were pooled using a bivariate, binomial, generalized linear mixed model (SAS 9.2). The target population was
adults and children experiencing symptoms consistent with CD. Biopsy was assumed
to have sensitivity and specificity of 1 since it is considered the gold standard. In
serologic testing strategies the positive cases (true or false) were assumed to be confirmed with biopsy. a family physician consult was incurred with serologic testing and
a gastroenterologist consult was incurred with biopsy. The outcome of the analysis
was expected costs and false negatives (FN). Costs were reported in 2010 CAD$. All
analyses were performed using TreeAge Pro Suite 2009. RESULTS: Four strategies
made up the efficiency frontier; IgGTTG, IgATTG, EMA and biopsy. All other strategies were either strictly or extendedly dominated. IgGTTG was the least costly and
least effective strategy ($178.95, 0.1553 FNs). Biopsy was the most costly and most
effective strategy ($396.60, 0 FNs). The cost per FN avoided moving from IgGTTG
to the other strategies sequentially on the efficiency frontier were $293, $369, $1401
for EMA, IgATTG and biopsy respectively. One-way sensitivity analyses did not
change the ranking of strategies. CONCLUSIONS: All testing strategies with biopsy
were cheaper than biopsy alone however they also resulted in more FNs. If a decision
maker’s willingness to pay to avoid a FN result is $1401 or greater, then biopsy alone
is the most cost-effective strategy. Otherwise, either IgGTTG, IgATTG or EMA is the
most cost-effective strategy.
PGI16
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF ON-TREATMENT MONITORING OF HBSAG
LEVELS TO PREDICT RESPONSE TO PEGINTERFERON-ALPHA-2A FOR
HEPATITIS B TREATMENT UNDER THE PUBLIC PAYER PERSPECTIVE
IN BRAZIL
Ferreira PRA1, Borges LG2, Santos E2
1
Universidade Federal de São Paulo, São Paulo, SP, Brazil; 2Roche Brazil, São Paulo, SP, Brazil
BACKGROUND: Chronic hepatitis B (CHB), affects 350–400 million people worldwide, being associated with increased risk of liver failure and approximately 300,000
cases of hepatocellular carcinoma per year. Treatment with pegylated interferon (48
weeks) is associated with the possibility of sustained disease remission, with no need
for maintenance with any other drug. Furthermore, on-treatment monitoring of
HBsAg can predict response to peginterferon–alfa-2a (Lau 2009). Currently, only
entecavir is available for HBeAg-positive chronic hepatitis B cirrhotic patients under
Brazilian Public Healthcare System. OBJECTIVES: To compare costs and outcomes
of on-treatment monitoring of HBsAG levels during peginterferon–alfa-2a therapy
versus standard entecavir treatment of CHB under Brazilian Public Healthcare System
perspective. METHODS: To project disease progression, a Markov model was built
A371
based on clinical stages of CHB. a stopping rule was applied to peginterferon–alfa-2a
scenario at week 12 based on efficacy results from Lau 2009: if HBsAg > 20000 UI/
ml, treatment is switched to 2nd line treatment (tenofovir). Medical resources related
to each stage were obtained from Castelo, 2007. Efficacy of entecavir was obtained
from Veenstra, 2007 & 2008. Tenofovir was also available as 2nd line treatment for
entecavir scenario. Discount rate for costs and outcomes was 5%, according to Brazilian guidelines for HTA. Costs were reported in 2010 Brazilian Reais (US$1 ≈ $Brz1.8).
RESULTS: Assuming a lifetime perspective, expected costs and outcomes for peginterferon-alfa-2a were: $Brz 38,605, 15.37 LYs and 13.64 QALYs. For entecavir: $Brz
39,630, 15.20 LYs and 13.41 QALYs. Cost-effectiveness analysis estimated an ICER
of (-$Brz37,614/LYs) and (-$Brz15,556/QALYs) for peginterferon-alfa-2a, being the
dominant therapy. CONCLUSIONS: Considering on treatment monitoring of HBsAg,
findings suggest that peginterferon–alfa-2a shows higher clinical responses and is a
cost saving therapy for the management of CHB patients in the Brazilian Public
Healthcare System.
PGI17
COULD AN INNOVATIVE SURGICAL PROCEDURE SUCH AS STAPLED
HEMORRHOIDOPEXY BE COST-EFFECTIVE AND EVEN COST-SAVING
IN UK CLINICAL PRACTICE?
Ribaric G1, Kofler J1, Jayne DG2
1
Ethicon Endo-Surgery (Europe) GmbH, Norderstedt, Germany; 2St. James’s University
Hospital, Leeds, England
OBJECTIVES: Stapled hemorrhoidopexy (SH) offers several benefits over conventional excisional hemorrhoidectomy, which makes it attractive to patients with symptomatic prolapsing piles, yet its provision remains disparate. a full economic evaluation
of stapled hemorrhoidopexy was undertaken to establish its cost-effectiveness and take
into consideration recent literature on clinical outcomes to show that the SH procedure
can become cost-saving compared to CH (conventional hemorrhoidectomy).
METHODS: A cost–utility analysis was undertaken to compare the use of SH with
CH.The analysis used a probabilistic, cohort-based decision tree within a 1-year timehorizon. Costs were analyzed from hospital and UK NHS perspective and utility was
calculated using Quality Adjusted Life-years (QALY). Sensitivity analyses were used
to show how variation in the clinical parameters affects cost-effectiveness. RESULTS:
The decrease in time in the operating theatre and shorter hospital stay with SH led to
a cost saving of £27 per procedure compared to CH on a hospital level. From the
NHS perspective the total treatment costs inclusive of the cost of recurrent prolapse,
led to an incremental cost of £33 after one year. Calculation of QALYs induced an
incremental QALY of 0.0076 and showed an ICER of £4,316, which is a highly costeffective result. Sensitivity analysis taking into account recent publications showed
that the SH procedure becomes cost saving with a reduction in recurrence rate of
prolapse from 10% to 5% or a 50% reduction in re-surgery rate. CONCLUSIONS:
Stapled hemorrhoidopexy is a cost-effective procedure with an incremental costeffective ration (ICER) of £4136. Furthermore the analysis also showed that stapled
hemorrhoidopexy could even be cost-saving in UK clinical practice. This economic
analysis, in line with the 2007 NICE guidance, supports its widespread
implementation.
PGI18
ECONOMICS OF A SYMPTOM BASED PATIENT MANAGEMENT
APPROACH FOR GASTRO-ESOPHAGEAL REFLUX DISEASE (GERD),
USING GERDQ, COMPARED TO AN INVASIVE APPROACH USING
GASTROSCOPY AND PH-METRY
Jonasson C1, Langkilde LK2, Hatlebakk JG3
1
AstraZeneca AS, Oslo, Norway; 2Wickstrøm & Langkilde ApS, Vejle, Denmark; 3University
of Bergen, Bergen, Norway
OBJECTIVES: In Norway, proton pump inhibitor (PPI) therapy for GERD can only
be reimbursed for patients with a diagnosis verified by gastroscopy or pH-metry. The
purpose of this study (NCT00842387) was to evaluate the economic aspects of an
alternative, structured treatment pathway based on GerdQ—a validated PRO tool for
the diagnosis and treatment decisions in GERD. METHODS: Two treatment pathways in patients presenting with reflux, but no alarm symptoms were evaluated in an
open randomized, parallel-group 8 week study. In the New Structured Pathway (NSP)
diagnosis and treatment were based on GerdQ scores dividing patients into high
impact GERD (treated with esomeprazole 40 mg), medium impact GERD (treated
with generic PPI) and low probability of GERD (treated at the physician’s discretion).
In the Ordinary Clinical Pathway (OCP), the physician was kept blinded to the GerdQ
score and diagnosis was based on findings at gastroscopy or, if needed, pH-metry.
Treatment was given according to normal clinical practice. Direct medical cost was
estimated based on diagnostic procedures, medication and unscheduled health care
visits. RESULTS: Treatment success with NSP diagnostic method was not inferior to
OCP. The response rates were 86.5% and 80.1%, respectively. The health economic
evaluation could thus be performed as a cost-minimization analysis. More patients in
the NSP arm were treated with esomeprazole 40 mg than in the OCP arm (28.4% vs.
10.2%); however, fewer health care visits and diagnostic procedures were seen. The
average direct medical cost in the NSP arm was c51 per patient (NOK 410) compared
with c390 (NOK 3139) in the OCP arm. CONCLUSIONS: By integrating the New
Structured Pathway into clinical practice, direct health care resource use may be
reduced without any loss in clinical effectiveness.
A372
GASTROINTESTINAL DISORDERS – Patient-Reported Outcomes Studies
PGI19
PRESCRIPTION RATES AND ADHERENCE TO PROTON PUMP
INHIBITOR THERAPY AMONG PATIENTS WHO REQUIRE LOW-DOSE
ACETYLSALICYLIC ACID FOR CARDIOVASCULAR PREVENTION
Sörstadius E1, Herlitz J2, Nauclér E3, Naesdal J1
1
AstraZeneca, Mölndal, Sweden; 2Sahlgrenska University Hospital, Göteborg, Sweden;
3
AstraZeneca R&D, Göteborg, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: Low-dose acetylsalicylic acid (ASA; 75–325 mg daily) is a mainstay of
cardiovascular (CV) prevention. However, some patients taking low-dose ASA may
experience upper gastrointestinal (GI) symptoms that are associated with poor adherence to and discontinuation of low-dose ASA. Established gastroprotective strategies,
e.g. concomitant proton pump inhibitor (PPI) therapy, may ameliorate these symptoms
and thus improve low-dose ASA adherence. METHODS: This subanalysis of a multinational, observational, non-interventional study (NCT00681759) conducted in the
United States, Canada and France assessed PPI prescription rates (one-time retrospective survey) and daily PPI adherence rates (prospective 3-month eDiary phase) in adult
patients with increased GI risk who had been prescribed low-dose ASA for management of CV risk. Here, increased GI risk was defined as a history of peptic ulcer and/
or complications or additional antiplatelet use (clopidogrel, ticlopidine, dipyridamole).
RESULTS: A total of 195 of the 1770 patients in the survey were identified as having
increased GI risk (history of peptic ulcer and/or complications, n = 109; concomitant
antiplatelet therapy, n = 74; both factors, n = 12); 119 (61%) of whom were not
prescribed a PPI. a total of 340 patients entered the eDiary phase, of whom 110 were
prescribed a PPI before the first diary day; of these, 79 patients were prescribed a daily
PPI for the 3-months. Among these patients, fewer than half (n = 37) took >75% of
prescribed daily PPIs. Almost one-third (n = 25) did not take their prescribed daily
PPI at all during the 3-month phase. CONCLUSIONS: PPI prescription and adherence
rates are low among patients with increased GI risk receiving low-dose ASA for CV
risk management. Strategies that deliver gastroprotection with improved adherence
rates during low-dose ASA therapy in patients with increased GI risk may be
warranted.
PGI20
MEDICATION ADHERENCE AND PERSISTENCE IN THE TREATMENT OF
ULCERATIVE COLITIS: ANALYSES WITH THE RAMQ DATABASE
Lachaine J1, Beauchemin C1, Hodgkins P2, Yen L2
1
University of Montreal, Montreal, QC, Canada; 2Shire Pharmaceuticals, Wayne, PA, USA
OBJECTIVES: Non-adherence with oral mesalazines has a significant impact on treatment outcome which is one of the most important predictors for relapse in ulcerative
colitis. The objective of this study was to assess adherence and persistence with oral
mesalazines, particularly to analyze whether adherence with oral mesalazines is linked
to the use of once daily high strength Mezavant® compared to more frequent dosing
and/or low strength oral mesalazines. METHODS: A retrospective prescription claims
analysis of a random sample of patients from the Quebec provincial public health plan
(RAMQ) database was conducted. New users of a mesalazine formulation during the
period from January 2005 to December 2009 and with no diagnosis of Crohn’s disease
were eligible for inclusion in the analysis. Treatment adherence was estimated using
medication possession ratio over a one-year period. For the analysis of persistence to
treatment, patients were considered non-persistent if they had not used the mesalazines
medication for a period of twice the median duration of prescriptions. Proportion of
patients who were persistent was estimated at 3-, 6-, and 12 months after index
prescription. RESULTS: The mean age of the study sample was 55.7 years (SD = 18.2)
and the proportion of males and female were similar (48.8% vs. 51.2%). The proportion of patients ≥80% compliant on the mesalazine long acting formulation
(Mezavant®) (46.3%) was significantly higher compared with all other mesalazine
formulations (1.6% to 26.0%) (P < 0.001). The proportion of patients who were
persistent at 12 months on Mezavant® (70.2%) was higher when compared with those
on any other mesalazine formulations (14.5% to 42.6%) (P < 0.001). Similar trends
were observed at all time points examined. CONCLUSIONS: Results of these prescription claims analyses indicate that adherence and persistence to mesalazine formulations are relatively poor, however improved adherence and persistence are observed
with the long acting formulation (Mezavant®).
PGI21
RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN PATIENT PREFERENCES FOR 5-ASA
THERAPIES AND SELF-REPORTED ADHERENCE
Hodgkins P1, Swinburn P2, Solomon D1, Yen L1, Dewilde S2, Lloyd A2
1
Shire Pharmaceuticals, Wayne, PA, USA; 2Oxford Outcomes Ltd, Oxford, Oxfordshire, UK
OBJECTIVES: The effectiveness of 5-aminosalicylic acid (5-ASA) therapy for mild to
moderate ulcerative colitis (UC) is commonly affected by poor medication adherence.
The present study was designed to determine if adherence behaviour could be
explained by differences in patient preferences for 5-ASA therapies. METHODS: A
discrete choice experiment (DCE) survey was used to explore patient preferences for
different aspects of oral 5-ASA therapy. The DCE survey captured trade-offs that
patients were willing to make and was based on a literature review, clinician interviews, and in-depth interviews with UC patients (followed by cognitive debriefing).
Six attributes were identified: Ease–of–swallowing, Number of administrations per
day, Number of pills (per administration), Symptom flare resolution; Likelihood of
flare occurrence and Cost (to estimate willingness-to-pay (WTP) for improvements in
13th Euro Abstracts
attributes). Adherence behaviour was assessed using the Modified Morisky Scale.
Participants (mild to moderate UC patients, n = 400) in the UK, US, Germany, and
Canada were recruited through specialist patient recruitment agencies and the survey
was administered via the internet, following IRB approval. Data were analyzed using
the conditional logit procedure. RESULTS: Clinical effectiveness was most highly
valued by participants independent of country of origin (e.g. reduction in annual flare
risk to 10%: WTP = £78.81 per month) and a return to normal bowel functioning
with mucosal healing (WTP = £29.24). Significant interaction terms identified that
people who reported good adherence placed greater value on symptom control compared with self reported poor adherers to therapy (P = 0.011). CONCLUSIONS: Data
suggest that the most highly valued aspect of therapy was effectiveness. Therefore,
patients may adhere to a medication better if they place greater value on its ability to
effectively treat their UC. Furthermore, these data suggest a possible avenue for physicians to explore with their patients to improve adherence to the treatment regimen by
highlighting the risk-benefit profile of 5-ASAs in the treatment of UC.
PGI22
MAPPING PAC-QOL SCORES ONTO THE EQ-5D
1
1
2
Parker M , Haycox A , Dubois D
1
University of Liverpool Management School, Liverpool, UK; 2Patient Value Solutions,
Huldenberg, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: The clinical trial programme for Prucalopride, a selective and high
affinity 5-HT4 receptor agonist, incorporated a constipation specific HRQoL measure
(PAC-QOL) and SF-36 but not EQ-5D. a mapping relationship was developed to link
EQ-5D to PAC-QOL using established algorithms linking EQ-5D and SF-36.
METHODS: Trial responses (n = 5488) on a common patient data set enabled an
empirical link to be established between the SF-36 and PAC-QOL which was extended
to EQ-5D through the established algorithm. Having established this relationship a
range of functional forms for mapping PAC-QOL onto EQ-5D were tested ranging
from a simple linear relationship to more complex mapping structures incorporating
quadratic and interactive terms. RESULTS: The relationship between PAC-QOL and
EQ-5D was generally good. The estimated equation for deriving EQ-5D from
PAC-QOL in its’ simplest linear functional form was: EQ-5D = 97.7–9.8 (PAC-QOL).
This implies that a one point change in PAC-QOL overall score would lead to a 9.8%
change in EQ-5D. As expected, the mapping was largely limited to the upper health
states of EQ-5D given that chronic constipation by itself is unlikely to lead to the
severest forms of disability. This initial regression analysis displayed elements of nonlinearity and hence a more complex analysis was undertaken which incorporated
square and interaction terms. This new functional form facilitated a more accurate
relationship to be established between PAC-QOL and EQ-5D. CONCLUSIONS:
Mapping is required whenever a preference based generic HRQoL measure is not
directly collected in clinical trials. Very limited theoretical guidance is available to
structure such analyses and therefore empiricism largely rules. However by testing the
robustness of the results to different assumptions and functional forms a robust
mapping can be developed. This process was employed here to convert PAC-QOL
into EQ-5D utility scores for incorporation into Cost Utility analyses.
PGI23
IDENTIFYING ENDPOINTS FOR IRRITABLE BOWEL SYNDROME (IBS)
CLINICAL TRIALS: INCORPORATING THE PATIENT’S VOICE
Fehnel SE1, Ervin CM1, Lewis BE2, Carson RT3, Johnston JM2
1
RTI Health Solutions, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA; 2Ironwood Pharmaceuticals,
Cambridge, MA, USA; 3Forest Research Institute, Jersey City, NJ, USA
OBJECTIVES: 1) Identify a comprehensive set of symptoms experienced by patients
with irritable bowel syndrome with constipation (IBS-C), and 2) Identify the most
important symptoms for measurement in clinical trials for IBS-C. METHODS: Two
iterative sets of in-depth interviews were conducted in different US cities, with a total
of 27 participants meeting modified Rome II criteria for IBS-C. a semi-structured
interview guide was used, beginning with a series of open-ended questions to elicit all
relevant symptoms, followed by interviewer probes to fully understand the relationships among the concepts. Multiple rating and ranking methods were used to develop
a subset of IBS-C symptoms of greatest importance to patients. For example, participants were asked to identify their most bothersome IBS-C symptoms, as well as those
in which they would most like to see an improvement with treatment. RESULTS:
When asked to describe their IBS-C symptoms, patients reported 54 potentially distinct
concepts: 8 abdominal symptoms, 12 bowel symptoms, 31 additional physical symptoms (e.g., nausea, headache), and 3 emotional issues (e.g., irritability, depression).
Some symptom terms were highly related (e.g., abdominal pain and stomach ache)
and others could be considered consequential to IBS-C (e.g., hemorrhoids, vomiting).
Results of the subsequent rating and ranking tasks suggest that abdominal pain,
abdominal discomfort, bloating, stool frequency, stool consistency, straining, and
incomplete evacuation were distinct and represent patients’ most bothersome symptoms. Further, according to the patients, improvements in these symptoms would
constitute an improvement in IBS-C overall. CONCLUSIONS: Patient input is vital
to identify the full spectrum of symptoms and to determine an optimal set of clinical
trial endpoints. Within and across the two separate rounds of interviews, participants
consistently reported the importance of abdominal pain, abdominal discomfort, bloating, stool frequency, stool consistency, straining, and incomplete evacuation, demonstrating concept saturation and supporting the measurement of these symptoms in
IBS-C clinical trials.
13th Euro Abstracts
PGI24
A PILOT STUDY OF PATIENT PREFERENCES FOR MID-THERAPY
ASSESSMENT TIMING IN CHRONIC HEPATITIS C TREATMENT
Kauf T1, Nelson DR1, Schelfhout J1, Zeigler L1, Bhula M1, Grant WC2
1
University of Florida, Gainesville, FL, USA; 2James Madison University, Harrisonburg, VA,
USA
OBJECTIVES: For many courses of therapy, assessments of treatment effectiveness
are used to inform treatment continuation decisions. If a “mid-therapy” assessment
(MTA) is positive, the patient is indicated to continue treatment; if negative, treatment
may be discontinued. Using expected utility theory, we demonstrated previously that
the availability and timing of such assessments may influence patients’ treatment initiation decisions. We conducted a pilot study among chronic hepatitis C (CHC) patients
to examine preferences over MTA timing and treatment initiation. METHODS: A
stated preference survey was developed and pre-tested among 10 community volunteers and then administered to 49 CHC patients. The survey described two MTAs for
CHC treatment: one at 4 weeks (rapid virologic response, RVR) and the other at 12
weeks (early virologic response, EVR). Test characteristics varied between the two
MTAs, but the decision algorithm (stated above) was held constant. Multiple response
formats were used to elicit preferences across MTA and treatment initiation. Results
are summarized as means and proportions. RESULTS: Average age was 54.6 yrs;
55.1% were male; 32.7% were treatment-naïve; 67.3% reported their general health
as good or better. Three subjects failed to answer one or more MTA or treatment
choice questions. More subjects had previously heard of EVR compared to RVR
(43.8% vs. 14.3%, p > 0.01). Given a choice between MTAs, 55.3% of subjects
indicated a preference for RVR. Treatment utilizing RVR was somewhat or strongly
preferred by 57.4% of subjects, and 61.2% said they would choose RVR if only one
test was available. However, more subjects responded that they would accept treatment with EVR than with RVR 60.9% vs. 55.3% (difference not significant). CONCLUSIONS: Patients with CHC consistently indicated MTA preferences that are at
odds with current treatment guidelines. Further research is needed to understand the
relationship between MTA preference and treatment initiation.
PGI25
CHILD AND PARENT REPORTS OF SYMPTOMS OF IRRITABLE BOWEL
SYNDROME WITH CONSTIPATION (IBS-C): RESULTS OF QUALITATIVE
INTERVIEWS
Arbuckle R1, Lewis BE2, Carson R3, Abetz L1, Johnston JM2
1
Mapi Values Ltd, Bollington, Cheshire, UK; 2Ironwood Pharmaceuticals, Cambridge, MA,
USA; 3Forest Research Institute, Jersey City, NJ, USA
OBJECTIVES: The Rome III criteria define pediatric irritable bowel syndrome with
constipation (IBS-C) as abdominal pain or discomfort associated with constipation
symptoms. Historically, few pediatric IBS-C trials have used symptom measures that
were developed with patient input. This study aimed to develop pediatric IBS-C
symptom measures through qualitative interviews with children with IBS-C and their
parents/caregivers. METHODS: Children diagnosed with IBS-C (aged 6–8 [n = 10],
9–11 [n = 10] and 12–17 [n = 10]) and their parents were interviewed. Thematic
analysis of interview transcripts identified concepts. Age appropriate items and
response options, developed to measure each concept, were reviewed by expert clinicians. RESULTS: IBS-C symptoms identified as being bothersome to children included:
abdominal symptoms such as abdominal pain (“stomach hurts”) and bloating
(“tummy like a balloon”), and bowel symptoms such as infrequent bowel movements
(“don’t go often”), difficulty defecating (“it won’t come out”), straining on defecation
(“have to push hard”), rectal pain during defecation (“butt hurts”), hard stools (“hard
and bumpy”), large stools (“it’s like a log”), and a feeling of incomplete evacuation
(“some that won’t come out”). Saturation was achieved for the above concepts.
Parents relied on behavioural signs of IBS-C (such as inactivity or irritability) and the
child telling them about symptoms when assessing their child’s condition. In general
the majority of parents and children agreed in their reports of symptoms, though there
were some minor inconsistencies. CONCLUSIONS: Consistent with guidelines for
patient-reported outcomes, these results were used to develop age-appropriate questions to measure both abdominal and bowel symptoms. The instrument is currently
undergoing testing to assess patient understanding and relevance. Results from qualitative interviews with children with IBS-C suggest abdominal and bowel symptoms are
both important and bothersome to pediatric IBS-C patients and should be included in
treatment assessments.
PGI26
PREVALENCE AND IMPACT IN WORK PRODUCTIVITY OF GASTROESOFAGEAL REFLUX DISEASE (GERD) IN PRIMARY CARE PATIENTS
WITH UPPER GASTROINTESTINAL (GI) SYMPTOMS. THE GREEK
GERDQ STUDY
Rokkas T1, Panitti E2, Nikas N2
1
Henry Dunant Hospital, Athens, Attiki, Greece; 2AstraZeneca, Athens, Greece
OBJECTIVES: GERD is a common condition in daily clinical practice associated with
reduced quality of life and impact on productivity. The aims of the current study were
to estimate the prevalence of GERD in primary care by using a novel diagnostic tool
(GerdQ questionnaire) and to assess the impact of the disease in productivity.
METHODS: The Greek GerdQ study was a cross-sectional, single-visit, epidemiological study in patients presenting to their physician with upper GI symptoms. Data on
patients’ demographics, medical/GI history and upper GI symptoms were recorded by
the investigators. All subjects completed the GerdQ, and those scored ≥ 8 also completed the WPAI-GERD questionnaire for the evaluation of GERD impact on produc-
A373
tivity. RESULTS: Overall 889 (887 evaluable) patients were enrolled by 91 primary
care physicians. 47% of patients were male. Mean (± SD) age was 51 (17) years with
37.5% of patients presenting no previous history of GI tract disorders. The most
prevalent GI symptoms in the week prior to study visit were heartburn, regurgitation
and belching, presenting a high frequency (≥2 days/week or daily) in 62.4%, 47% and
50.2% of the patients, respectively. Antisecretory treatment was reported by 62% of
patients. Based on GerdQ, 71.8% patients had GERD (GerdQ score ≥ 8) while 45.1%
of them were suffering from disrupting disease (GerdQ impact score ≥ 3). Mean (±
SD) absenteeism due to GERD was 2.3 (4.9) hours/week with a mean (± SD) of 11.8
(9.6) additional hours/week lost due to presenteeism. The observed reduction in daily
life productivity was 37.4%. CONCLUSIONS: These data suggest that in Greece,
GERD is a highly prevalent condition in primary care patients with upper GI symptoms, posing a significant burden to patients in terms of reduced productivity both in
work and in daily life.
PGI27
STRUCTURED MANAGEMENT STRATEGY BASED ON THE GERDQ
QUESTIONNAIRE VERSUS USUAL PRIMARY CARE FOR
GASTROESOPHAGEAL REFLUX DISEASE: META-ANALYSIS OF FIVE
EUROPEAN CLUSTER RANDOMIZED TRIALS
Ponce J1, Garrigues V1, Agréus L2, Tabaglio E3, Gschwantler M4, Guallar E5, Tafalla M6,
Nuevo J6, Hatlebakk JG7
1
Hospital Universitario La Fe, Valencia, Spain; 2Karolinska Institute, Stockholm, Sweden;
3
Società Italiana Medicina Generale, Firenze, Italy; 4Wilhelminenspital, Wien, Austria; 5Welch
Center for Prevention, Epidemiology, and Clinical Research, Baltimore, MD, USA;
6
AstraZeneca, Madrid, Spain; 7University of Bergen, Bergen, Norway
OBJECTIVES: Gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) has substantial impact in
primary care, but the optimal approach to management is uncertain. a structured
management strategy may improve the diagnosis and therapeutic management of
GERD, but individual studies may be limited by their focus on local strategies that
may not be valid for other countries. METHODS: We conducted a meta-analysis of
five cluster randomised clinical trials comparing a new management strategy with
usual care in patients with GERD conducted in Austria, Italy, Norway, Spain and
Sweden (NCT00842387). The intervention strategy was based on the self-administered validated GerdQ questionnaire to stratify adult patients with classical symptoms
of GERD (heartburn or regurgitation) according to the frequency and impact of
symptoms. The most effective acid-suppressive therapy (esomeprazole 40 mg once
daily) was used only in patients with the highest GerdQ symptom impact score (≥3).
The primary outcome was non-response to treatment defined as a total GerdQ score
≥ 8 at the end of follow-up. Odds ratios for the primary outcome were combined using
a random effects model. RESULTS: A total of 2400 patients were enrolled and average
follow-up ranged from 4 to 18 weeks. The odds ratios for lack of treatment response
with the structured management strategy compared with usual care ranged from 0.22
to 0.84, across studies. The random-effects combined odds ratio for non-response to
treatment was 0.56 (95% CI 0.22–0.90; p = 0.001), with significant between-study
heterogeneity (p < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Stratification of patients according to the
GerdQ questionnaire, using a locally adapted primary care management strategy for
GERD significantly increased the likelihood of a response to treatment compared to
usual clinical practice, although significant between-country heterogeneity suggests
that GERD management can still be improved.
PGI28
HEALTH-RELATED QUALITY OF LIFE IN OPIOID INDUCED
CONSTIPATION PATIENTS IN SPAIN
Guijarro P1, Viqueira A1, Alonso-Babarro A2, Fernandez G1
1
Pfizer Spain, Alcobendas, Madrid, Spain; 2La Paz Hospital, Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: To analyze the impact of opioid induced constipation (OIC) on
patients’ health related quality of life (HRQoL). METHODS: An observational, multicenter study was carried out in Spain. All patients were free of constipation at
baseline and received opioids for at least 2 months. The impact of OIC on patients’
HRQoL was determined in a cross-sectional phase of the study. Patients were evaluated depending on response to oral treatment for OIC. HRQoL was assessed by the
following tools: the Spanish version of the EuroQoL (EQ-5D) and EuroQoL Visual
Analogue Scale (EQ-VAS). The CVE-20 questionnaire and a specific question were
used to assess the perceived health status related to constipation. RESULTS: Patients
with OIC showed a mean (SD) overall CVE-20 score of 48.0 (18.6), the time spent
defecating and discomfort caused by a bloated stomach were highly rated in the
general physical dimension (56.4% in both items). Laxative dependence was the most
rated item (51.9%) in the social dimension. Regarding general QoL, EQ-5D, the
dimension in which patients were more affected was the pain/discomfort dimension
(89.7%). Mean EQ-VAS score (SD) was 51.3 (19.3), mean EQ-5D VAS tariff (SD)
was 0.45 (0.25) and mean EQ-5D TE tariff (SD) was 0.38 (0.40). Overall, responders
to oral laxatives showed a better HRQoL than non-responders. The CVE-20 questionnaire score in responders was higher than in non-responders (50.8 vs. 40.6, respectively, P < 0.001). Regarding general QoL, the EQ-5D anxiety/depression was the only
dimension significantly more affected in non-responders (p = 0.003). Accordingly,
responders obtained statistically significant higher EQ-VAS score (SD), 53.0 (18.9) vs.
45.5 (18.4) (p = 0.004). CONCLUSIONS: OIC is one of the most distressing opioid
adverse events and as such, has a negative impact on HRQoL. The differences
observed in the CVE-20 and EQ-VAS scores between responders and non-responders
are statistically significant and may also have a clinical impact.
A374
GASTROINTESTINAL DISORDERS – Health Care Use & Policy Studies
PGI29
PPI GENERAL PRACTITIONERS’ PRESCRIBING IN THE TREATMENT OF
ACID-RELATED DISORDERS: THE IMPACT OF GENERIC PPI LAUNCH
INTO THE PHARMACEUTICAL MARKET IN ITALY
Cammarota S1, Sarnelli G2, Citarella A1, Menditto E1, Riegler S1, Bruzzese D2, Cuomo R2
1
CIRFF, Federico II University, Naples, Italy; 2Federico II University Hospital School of
Medicine, Naples, Italy
OBJECTIVES: To investigate the phenomenon of PPI switching in the acid related
disorders treatment in an Italian primary care setting during 2005–2008 (before and
after PPIs’ patents expired) and to estimate the costs of health care resources consumption associated with this phenomenon. METHODS: Retrospective cohort study was
performed analyzing data from 127 GPs of Naples in the south of Italy. PPI users for
ARD treatment within each study year were selected from source population. Switchers were defined patients changing from one PPI to another within each study year.
Multivariate logistic regressions were used to assess the potential predictors of PPI
switching and to investigate the factors influencing the direction of the switch. Cost
was expressed as Euro 2008 per PPI user. RESULTS: The phenomenon of PPI switching rose from 13.0% in 2005 to 16.7% in 2008 with a peak of 18.8% in 2006.
Calendar years, long-term treatments and GERD diagnosis were positive predictors
of PPI switching. All years analyzed (versus 2005) were associated with switching to
lansoprazole while the 2008 year was strongly associated with switching to omeprazole and pantoprazole. Very long-term treatment (>11 pack/years) group accounted
for 66.3% of the total primary care cost. Switchers increased primary care costs by
c61.1 compared with no switchers, reaching an incremental cost of c133.1 per useryear in the case with more than 1 switch. CONCLUSIONS: In Italy the launch of
generic PPIs in the national market generates the increasing amount of chronic treatments and therapeutic substitution that will probably have had a negative impact on
the total savings on PPIs, achievable by the introduction of generic products. Policy
rules favouring generic PPIs prescribing can often influence physicians’ decision to
select the appropriate treatment for each patient.
PGI30
ASSESSMENT OF FEASIBILITY OF THE METHODOLOGICAL APPROACH
DESCRIBED IN THE MODEL FOR THE REGULATION OF
REIMBURSEMENT PRICES IN GERMANY
Aidelsburger P1, Benkert D1, Neumann A2, Niebuhr D3, Wasem J2
1
CAREM GmbH, Sauerlach, Germany; 2University of Duisburg-Essen, Essen, Germany;
3
University of Applied Sciences Fulda, Fulda, Germany
OBJECTIVES: The generic drug market within the statutory health insurance (SHI)
in Germany is affected by price regulations like fixed amounts or rebats. Legal amendments led to an increasing importance of price discounts with uncertain impact on
pharmaceutical supply of the patients. To assure a justifiable price for the pharmaceutical companies and high quality a model has been developed by the Federal
Association of Medicines Manufacturers e. V. (BAH) for the regulation of reimbursement prices, e.g. cost-benefit based price corridors. Aim of the study is to test the
described methods for feasibility. METHODS: The prior published methods for the
development of reimbursement price corridors are applied and tested for feasibility by
use of the indication Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease (GERD). The methods intend
the derivation of one or more corridors following a defined decision algorithm based
on primary and secondary benefit criteria. Therefore a systematic assessment of benefits of proton pump inhibitors (PPIs), H2-Blockers and sucralfat is the foundation of
further decisions concerning the number of corridors to consider. Several methodical
approaches for the definition of height of each corridor are tested. RESULTS: PPIs
are more effective than H2-Blocker or sucralfat concerning primary benefit endpoints.
The assessment is based on secondary literature for financial and time reasons that
will be relevant when implementing the model in real decision problems, too. Based
on the results of the benefit assessment two corridors were implemented into the
model. The height of each corridor can be derivated by use of angles as well as by
other mathematical parameters like mean, quartiles etc. Both approaches show specific
limitations. CONCLUSIONS: The feasibility of the reported concept can be shown.
Several limitations, e.g. assessment of benefits based on secondary literature should
be considered. Use of angles or mathematical parameter should be discussed with
decision makers before implementation.
PGI31
EVALUATING THE POST OPERATIVE PRESCRIBING PRACTICES FOR
APPENDICITIS IN PUBLIC HEALTH FACILITIES IN PAKISTAN
Malik M, Hussain A, Abassi N, Khan J
Hamdard University, Islamabad, Punjab, Pakistan
OBJECTIVES: To investigate the pattern of prescribing practices for postoperative
appendicitis in public health facilities. METHODS: The study population consisted
of the largest public hospital Federal Government Services Hospital (Polyclinic) from
Punjab, Pakistan; Islamabad. a sample of 100 prescriptions of post operative appendicitis was collected from the public hospital. RESULTS: A total of 13.3% prescriptions out of 100 contain 2 drugs, 40% contains 3 drugs, 40 % contains 4 drugs &
6.7% contains 5 dugs. Only 6.7% prescriptions contain drugs prescribed by generic
while 93.3% prescriptions were not prescribed by generic name. a total of 3.3%
prescriptions contain no antibiotics, 76.6% prescriptions contain 1 antibiotic, while
20% prescriptions contain 2 antibiotics. On the other hand 23.3% prescription does
13th Euro Abstracts
not contain any injection, 10% prescriptions contain 2 injections, 23.3% prescriptions
contain 3 injections, while 43.3% prescriptions contain 4 injections. One hundred
percent of prescribers suggested that standard treatment guidelines and essential drug
list should be available and updated regularly in hospital and must be strictly followed.
a total of 33.3% of prescribers think the essential drug list should be properly regulated and updated should by the hospital management, 33.3% prescribers think by
Ministry of Health while 33.3% prescribers thinks it is the duty of Hospital pharmacist. This difference was noted with respect to age of the prescriber (p = 0.020) in the
prescribing practice of physicians in the public health facility. CONCLUSIONS: The
major reasons for irrational drug use in case of post operative appendicitis were due
to polypharmacy, overuse of antibiotics and injection and lack of standard treatment
guidelines in the hospital. Thus the extent of irrational drug use in the public sector
calls for in-depth investigation of the system factors and motivations that underlying
these problems in the practice and the development of interventions that target the
causative factors of inappropriate prescribing practice in Pakistan.
GASTROINTESTINAL DISORDERS – Conceptual Papers & Research on
Methods
PGI32
USING DATA ENVELOPMENT ANALYSIS TO ESTABLISH THE
EFFECTIVENESS EVALUATION OF DRUGS
Wu ML
Taichung Veterans General Hospital, Taichung City, Taiwan
OBJECTIVES: The development and research in pharmaceutical industry has constantly created new listing drugs which provide more therapeutic effect and lower
side-effects than former drugs, but the price become more expensive relatively. In order
to balance the trade-off between medical quality and cost reduction, hospitals have
to make the decision-making between the former drugs and the new listing drugs,
which have similar therapeutic effectiveness. In this regard, the most primary issue in
this research to solve is to establish a more objective and efficient decision-making
analysis that consider both effectiveness and cost for the drugs which have the similar
therapeutic effect. METHODS: We use data envelopment analysis (DEA) to solve this
problem, We screen six critical factors, daily drug expenses, drug profits, side-effect,
consumption, patent duration and lead time. Evaluation of relative efficiency of the
option with DEA method must be built on the relative performance data of every
input or output attributes of each decision-making unit. RESULTS: This study uses
four kinds of proton pump inhibitors (PPI) for effectiveness evaluation (the code A,
B, C, D drugs to replace its original name), first according to definition of the factors
to collect relevant data. We use the DEA method to treat these data, Drug a in the
DEA method analysis results is the most effective (6.6542E-06), Drug D is the second
(4.2381E-06), Drug B is the third (2.1165E-06) and Drug C is the worst (1.2786E-06).
CONCLUSIONS: Through this research model, we transfer complex decision-making
goals into various measurable or comparable factors that can compare the relative
importance. The evaluation result may not let all decision-makers and users to adopt
at all. But it is more comprehensive and objective to evaluate the effectiveness of
decision-making models than that in the past.
INDIVIDUAL’S HEALTH – Clinical Outcomes Studies
PIH1
EMERGENCY CONTRACEPTION FOR UNINTENDED PREGNANCY: ROLE
OF ULIPRISTAL, A NOVEL PROGESTERONE RECEPTOR MODULATOR
Aggarwal A
Heron Health Private Ltd, Chandigarh, India
OBJECTIVES: Unintended pregnancies represent a global health problem with over
80 million annual pregnancies. These are associated with an increased risk of morbidity and a considerable impact on women’s quality-of-life. Globally, 38% of all pregnancies are unintended resulting in 42 million induced abortions and 34 million
unintended births. This corresponds to 43% of all child-births worldwide. a novel
drug “Ulipristal” was introduced in Europe in May 2009 with efficacy beyond 72
hours after unprotected coitus. The objective of this review was to determine the safety
and efficacy profile of ulipristal compared to levonorgestrel. METHODS: A number
of databases (PUBMED, EMBASE, POPLINE, CENTRAL and clinicaltrials.gov) were
searched and the citations screened to identify randomised controlled trials (RCTs)
reporting efficacy and safety outcomes of ulipristal. Grey literature was searched to
identify the cost associated with unintended pregnancies. Summary-statistics (Random-Effects: DerSimonian-Laird) were used to assess pregnancy and adverse-events
outcomes. RESULTS: Seven RCTs were identified and only two reported pregnancy
outcomes. In a pooled analyses when compared to levonorgestrel, ulipristal showed
better efficacy results in preventing pregnancy following unprotected coitus on day 1
and day 3 (Day 1, RR = 0.435, [95%CI:0.148, 1.279] and Day 3, RR = 0.376,
[95%CI:0.110, 1.283]). However, these results were non-significant. Conversely, subgroup analysis showed that if administered on day 2, this trend was reversed with
administration of levonorgestrel being associated with fewer pregnancies (RR = 1.309,
[95%CI: 0.572, 2.996]). The frequency of adverse events like nausea, headache,
fatigue and dizziness was similar with both the drugs. Unintended pregnancies were
found to be associated with huge costs that amounted up to US$ 5 billion in US during
13th Euro Abstracts
2002 and £335 million in UK during 2001. CONCLUSIONS: Ulipristal appears as
effective as levonorgestrel in preventing unintended pregnancies with similar safety
profile. Substantial cost-savings can be expected with appropriate awareness programs
about emergency contraceptives among women.
PIH2
PEDIATRIC INTENSIVE CARE UNIT (PICU) ADMISSIONS FOR
RESPIRATORY SYNCYTIAL VIRUS (RSV) INFECTION IN THE ERA OF
PALIVIZUMAB PROPHYLAXIS
Paes BA1, Butt M1, Janes M2, Symington A2, Elliott L2, Steele S1
1
McMaster University, Hamilton, ON, Canada; 2McMaster Children’s Hospital, Hamilton, ON,
Canada
OBJECTIVES: To examine the characteristics of patients admitted to PICU with RSV
infection following provincial approval of RSV prophylaxis in June 2002. Secondly, to
determine if patients had received palivizumab and document incurred morbidities.
METHODS: A retrospective, hospital medical records review of all PICU admissions
for RSV infection from January 1, 2003 to December 31, 2009. RSV infection was
identified by ICD codes and cases were confirmed by RSV IFA test, culture, or PCR.
Data was collected on baseline demographics, underlying disease, criteria for hospitalization, type of respiratory illness and management, complications and palivizumab
prophylaxis. Group 1 patients (≤2 years) were compared to Group 2 (>2–18 years).
RESULTS: A total of 181 patients were admitted with RSV infection over 7 years.
Group 1 (n = 152); Group 2 (n = 29) had a mean admission age in months (SD); 3.7
(5.7) versus 59.9 (37.7). Majority (79.6%) Group 1 versus only 20.7% Group 2 (P
< 0.001) had no underlying disease. 97.4% versus 93.1% were admitted with respiratory distress and most had bronchiolitis; 88.8% versus 55.2 % (P < 0.001), decreased
oxygen saturation; 77% versus 75.9% and inability to maintain intake; 75.7% versus
44.8% (P < 0.01). Fifty percent versus 41.3% required mechanical ventilation and
81.6% versus 69.0% received antibiotics. Median days (range) in PICU was 5 (1–73)
versus 2 (1–36). Median length of hospital stay days (range) was 9 (1–113) versus 7
(1–64) (P < 0.05). The overall RSV positive, PICU hospitalization rate was 5.7%.
There were few complications: respiratory (2.8%); concurrent bacterial sepsis (5.5%).
Only 3.3% children had received prophylaxis. 1 death was attributed to RSV infection. CONCLUSIONS: Majority of admissions comprised infants ≤2 years of age.
63.3% were ≥36 weeks gestation without underlying disease and in total 88.4% would
not qualify for prophylaxis. Current Canadian RSV prophylaxis guidelines have significantly impacted PICU admission rates in high-risk infants.
PIH3
PARENTERAL ALANYL-GLUTAMMINE IN CRITICALLY ILL PATIENTS: A
BAYESIAN META-ANALYSIS OF PUBLISHED TRIALS
Pradelli L1, Zaniolo O1, Iannazzo S1, Eandi M2
1
Adres srl, Torino, Italy; 2University of Torino, Torino, Italy
OBJECTIVES: Glutamine, although abundant in human tissue, can become conditionally essential in clinical conditions with hyper-catabolism and glutathione depletion
(burns, pancreatic necrosis, surgical complications), but has not been added to parenteral nutrition solutions for a long time, for its alleged non-essentiality and the low
solubility and stability in aqueous solutions, which have been solved by conjugation
with alanine. In 2002 a meta-analysis of available trials conducted with alanylglutamine dipeptide revealed significant reductions of mortality, infections and ICU length
of stay. Since then, data from other trials have become available. Aim of the present
study is to update the treatment effect estimates by means of a series of Bayesian
random effects models. METHODS: We searched EMBASE and Medline for clinical
trials of standard total parenteral nutrition (TPN) vs. TPN + parenteral alanylglutamine in critically ill patients reporting hospital mortality, relative ICU-incident infection rate, and relative hospital length of stay. For each outcome, a series of Bayesian
random effects models was specified, in which the treatment effect observed in the
individual trials is assumed to be drawn from a common distribution and expressed
as a relative risk or duration. RESULTS: Outcomes from 15 trials and 781 patients
were retrieved. The main models, i.e. simple hierarchy random effects models with
neutral priors, estimate a relative mortality of 0.70 (95% CrI: 0.46–0.97), a relative
infection rate of 0.71 (95% CrI: 0.49–0.97), and a relative length of stay of 0.91 (95%
CrI: 0.76–1.00). Secondary analyses indicated some heterogeneity in the magnitude
and reliability of the benefits in sub-groups of the wider critically ill patient population.
The incorporation of prior knowledge leads to significantly more precise estimates and
permits to obtain comfortable reliability even on subgroup-specific treatment effects
estimates. CONCLUSIONS: In conclusion, the available evidence supports a highly
credible beneficial effect of alanylglutamine on mortality, infections and hospital
length of stay in ICU-admitted critically ill patients.
PIH4
COMPARING THE MODEL PREDICTED VACCINE IMPACT AGAINST
ROTAVIRUS HOSPITALIZATION WITH OBSERVED DATA IN BELGIUM
Standaert B1, Strens D2, Van Bellinghen LA3, Van Vlaenderen I2
1
GlaxoSmithKline Biologicals, Wavre, Belgium; 2Deloitte, Diegem, Belgium; 3Deloitte, Brussels,
Belgium
OBJECTIVES: In reimbursement files models estimate the events avoided over time
with new interventions. Simulations are performed in the absence of long-term observational data. In this study observed hospitalization data prior- and post-rotavirus
vaccination in Belgium were compared to predicted (i.e. modeled) results after 1,2 and
3 years. METHODS: A Markov cohort model estimated over time the number of
A375
hospitalizations potentially avoided with rotavirus vaccination in Belgium. We
adjusted the model to the observed vaccine coverage and to RotarixTM vaccine efficacy
from clinical trials. The obtained modeling results were compared with observed data
collected from 9 Belgian hospitals (2 years pre- and 3 consecutive years post-vaccination). The outcomes of both studies are expressed as a percentual decrease in hospitalizations for 2 age-groups (<2 and <5 years old), after each year post-vaccination.
The differences are presented in absolute and relative (%) differences for each subsequent year post-vaccine launch. RESULTS: The observed data provided slightly better
outcomes than the modeled results. After 1 year the absolute difference in decrease of
hospitalizations between observed and modeled data was 3% (11%) for both agegroups. After 2 years the absolute differences were 3.5% (6%) and 6% (12%) for the
2 y and 5 y age-group respectively. In the last observation year the absolute differences
were respectively 2.8% (4%) and 9.3% (13%). CONCLUSIONS: Compared with the
observed data the model estimates are conservative. The more favorable observational
results are explained by the indirect vaccine effect on non-vaccinated age-groups which
is not captured by the static model. The relatively better model fit in the <2 y old with
increasing time is explained by the accumulated vaccine impact over time: from 26%
(1st year) to 68% (3rd year). Rotarix is a trademark of the GlaxoSmithKline group of
companies.
PIH5
PHARMACOEPIDEMIOLOGICAL BURDEN OF PREGNANCY IN BELARUS
Gavrilenko L, Romanova I, Kozhanova I
Belarusian State Medical University (BSMU), Minsk, Belarus
OBJECTIVES: Application of medicines during pregnancy is a challenge of clinical
pharmacology. We have analyzed priorities of physicians while choosing medications
in the course of various diseases during pregnancy and adherence of pregnant women
to the appointed treatment in Belarus. METHODS: It was prospective multi-center
cross-sectional epidemiological research. We interviewed 1334 pregnant women and
619 physicians with diverse specialties in 6 regions of the country using a structured
questionnaire from January to December 2009. All questionnaires have undergone
statistical analysis. RESULTS: We found that 34.5% of the pregnant women who
took part in questioning have had chronic diseases. Medical products were prescribed
for 91.7% (1223) women. a total of 23.8% of them have received more than 5 medical
products. Vitamins and drugs with microcells (magnesium, iodine, iron and calcium),
herbal drugs (valerian, leonurus and eleutherococcus) were in the lead in structure of
prescription. 91,8% of the pregnant women took all prescribed medicines. 7.7% (103)
women took antibacterial medicines following recommendations of the doctor. a total
fo 365 women (27.3%) took medicines without prescription (625 cases). Non-prescribed drugs during pregnancy had mostly been recommended by family or friends
(24.1% of women) and pharmacists in drugstores (24.1%). CONCLUSIONS: Pregnant women in Belarus are active consumers of medicines (vitamins, microcells, herbal
drugs, bioadditives) themselves and with doctors’ prescription. The widespread use of
medicines indicates an increased need for documentation and education about the
safety of medicines in the course of pregnancy. Application of these medications
creates additional financial burden (in addition to necessary medicines and products),
and it does not necessarily positively influence health. Educational programs for
pharmacists, doctors and pregnant women are necessary for improvement of drug
administration.
PIH6
IMPACT OF ROTAVIRUS VACCINATION ON ACUTE GASTROENTERITIS
RELATED EMERGENCY ROOM VISITS IN CHILDREN ≤FIVE YEARS OLD
IN BELGIUM
Morel T1, Strens D1, Raes M2, Standaert B3
1
Deloitte, Diegem, Belgium; 2Jessa Ziekenhuis, Hasselt, Belgium; 3GlaxoSmithKline Biologicals,
Wavre, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: Belgium is one of the few countries to implement rotavirus vaccination
within its universal paediatric immunization programme. This study was designed to
measure the impact of rotavirus vaccination on acute gastroenteritis (AGE) related
emergency room (ER) visits in children aged ≤5 years in Belgium. METHODS: A
retrospective observational study was performed across 11 Belgian participating
centres. Each centre provided an anonymised list of all ER visits of children aged ≤5
years during the periods June 2004–May 2006 (pre-vaccine period) and June 2007–
May 2009 (post-vaccine). a sample of 7620 ER visits (3699 pre-vaccine; 3921 postvaccine) was randomly selected from the 180,253 ER visits reported. Patient
demographics and information on the reason for ER visit were collected from all
randomly selected visits. If the visit was AGE-driven, additional data were collected
on vaccination status, symptoms, tests performed, treatment, and visit outcome.
RESULTS: The proportion of AGE-driven ER visits was 11% in the 2-year pre-vaccine
period (N AGE-driven visits/Total N ER visits = 412/3,699). After insignificant change
to 10.5% during the 1st year after vaccine introduction (N = 208/1,977), this proportion significantly declined to 8.2% (26.6% reduction; p-value < 0.001) in the 2nd year
(N = 159/1,944). a strong seasonal effect exists in the proportion of AGE-driven ER
visits on the total number of ER visits, peaking in February and March. The number
of patients who needed to be hospitalised because of AGE declined over time (from
a yearly average of 94 pre-vaccine to 62 and then 44 in the 2 consecutive years post
vaccine introduction). Oral and IV rehydration are the most commonly used treatments. Their use also declined after vaccine introduction. CONCLUSIONS: A significant decline in AGE-driven ER visits and subsequent hospitalizations was observed in
Belgium after introduction of a universal mass vaccination program against rotavirus.
AGE cases appeared less severe.
A376
PIH7
BODY COMPOSITION CHANGES IN THE PREOPERATIVE PERIOD AND
AFTER SURGERY
Hock M, Domány B, Garai J, Kránicz J, Kriszbacher I, Boncz I, Bódis J
University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: Our aim was to examine the changes of body composition in the
perioperative period. METHODS: The authors examine the body composition of 11
postmenopausal women (Total Body Water (TBW), Extracellular Water (EW), Intracellular Water (IW), Fat Mass (FM), Fat Free Mass (FFM)) 1month and 1 day before
as well as 1day and 1 month after the operation. The performed operations were
anterior colporrhaphy with or without posterior colporrhaphy or enterocele repair.
Preoperative medical preparation ordered the use of oral (1 mg estriol/die; T. Ovestin)
and local (U. Ovestin; 1 mg/g estriol) estrogen for a month. Fluid replacement was
adequate as ordered for patients with first-degree severity (average operative load,
prohibition of fluid intake is not longer than 6–12 hours, maximum blood loss is
250–500 ml) during the operation and in the postoperative period. Body composition
parameters were measured by MF HUMAN—IM SCAN Master 1.0. The statistical
data were calculated according to mean, standard deviation, median, range, Fisher’s
exact test, Student’s t-test methods and the results were considered to be significant
at P < 0,05. RESULTS: The mean age of the subjects was 59.4 years (8.58 SD, median
57 years, range 48–72 years), the average number of preceding pregnancies was 3.33
(1.68 SD) with 2,46 deliveries (1.46 SD). In the preoperative period (between the 1st
and the 2nd measurements) a significant decrease (p = 0,056) was found in EW. In
comparison of the 2nd and the 3rd measurements a significant decrease (ECW p = 0,027;
TBW p = 0,04; FM p = 0,019; FFM p = 0,019) was observed except for the parameters
of ICW (p = 0,15). Between the 1st and 30th day after the surgery changes in findings
were not significant (ECW p = 0,81; TBW p = 0,83; FM p = 0,5; FFM p = 0,3; ICW
p = 0,616). CONCLUSIONS: The results suggest that body composition changes in
the perioperative period should be followed.
PIH8
CHANGES IN PELVIC FLOOR MUSCLE FUNCTION DURING THE
PERIOPERATIVE PERIOD OF COLPORRHAPHY
Hock M, Domány B, Rácz S, Garai J, Kránicz J, Kriszbacher I, Boncz I, Bódis J
University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: Our goal was to follow up the changes of pelvic muscle function during
the perioperative period. METHODS: Fifteen women in postmenopausal period were
included in the study. The surgical management included anterior colporrhaphy with
or without posterior colporraphy or enterocele repair. Preoperative medical preparation ordered the use of oral (1 mg estriol/die; T. Ovestin) and local (U. Ovestin; 1 mg/g
estriol) estrogen for a month. The mean age of the subjects was 59.4 years (8.58 SD,
median 57 years, ranging from 48 to 72 years), the average number of preceding
pregnancies was 3.33 (1.68 SD) with 2,46 deliveries (1.46 SD). The pelvic muscle
function was measured 1 month before (at the beginning of the preoperative preparation), 1 day before and 1 month after the operation. The following factors were
measured: pelvic floor muscle activity, ability to relax and differences between left and
right sides. The measurement of muscle parameters was performed by intravaginal
surface EMG equipment. The statistical data were calculated according to mean,
standard deviation, median, range, Fisher’s exact test, Student’s t-test methods and
the results were considered to be significant at P < 0.05. RESULTS: In the preoperative
period (from the 1st to the 2nd measurement) a significant recovery (p = 0.03) was
found in the ability to relax pelvic floor muscle. In comparison of the 2nd and the 3rd
measurement a significant decrease occurred in the average muscle activity (p = 0.054)
and on the left (p = 0.034) side. The difference in the results of the 1st and the 3rd
measurement was even more significant (p = 0.005), there was a 20.8% average muscle
activity decrease during this period. CONCLUSIONS: The results suggest to follow
up the function of pelvic floor muscles in the perioperative period of colporrhaphy,
and if it is necessary to begin the proper physiotherapeutic treatment.
INDIVIDUAL’S HEALTH – Cost Studies
PIH9
COST COMPARISON OF MIDWIFE-LED VERSUS OTHER MODELS OF
CARE FOR CHILDBEARING WOMEN FROM THE PRIVATE PAYER
PERSPECTIVE IN BRAZIL
Takemoto ML, Fernandes RA, Passos RB, Cukier FN, Tolentino ACM
ANOVA—Knowledge Translation, Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: Efficacy of midwife-led models of care (MLMC) has been already
assessed in a Cochrane systematic review (Hatem 2008) but there is a lack of cost
comparisons in Brazil. This study aims to compare costs and consequences of MLMC
versus other models of care (OMC) for women with low or mixed risk of complications from the private payer perspective. METHODS: Efficacy data was obtained from
Hatem 2008 which compared MLMC with OMC including models centered in obstetricians, family doctors or shared models. As major maternal and neonatal events had
not shown statistically significant differences between groups, efficacy of both models
was considered similar. Significant differences in favor of MLMC (analgesia, episiotomy, instrumental birth, etc.) were used only for cost estimation. Resource use was
obtained through local published data and input from clinical experts. Only direct
medical costs related to the delivery room setting were considered. Unit costs were
obtained from Brazilian official sources. RESULTS: Risk Ratios for regional analgesia
13th Euro Abstracts
(RR = 0.81) and episiotomy (RR = 0.82) were selected as important for the adopted
setting. The current episiotomy rates in Brazil varied from 76.20% to 94.50% due to
differences between studies and regional analgesia rate was 99.40% in the only identified study. The incremental estimated costs for one additional episiotomy and analgesia were 42.82 BRL and 359.95 BRL, respectively. For each 1000 deliveries in the
private setting, 137 to 170 episiotomies and 179 analgesias would be prevented with
the adoption of MLMC, resulting in cost savings of 70,274 to 71,685 BRL. CONCLUSIONS: MLMC has shown similar efficacy and safety profiles when compared with
OMC and our findings indicated potential cost savings with MLMC in the Brazilian
private system. Further researches including other clinical outcomes, longer follow-up
and complications as results of medical interventions could result in higher savings
for the private payer.
PIH10
TREATMENT AND COST FOR PATIENTS WITH ENDOMETRIOSIS IN
THE UNITED KINGDOM
Wasiak R1, Manson S1, Ryan J2, Petri JC3
1
United BioSource Corporation, London, UK; 2Bayer Schering Pharma AG, Newbury, UK;
3
Bayer Schering Pharma AG, Berlin, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Endometriosis is defined by the growth of endometrial tissue outside
the uterine cavity. It is a common and debilitating benign gynecological condition
affecting mainly reproductive-age women with prevalence estimated between
7%–10% of women. The purpose of this study was to understand the cost associated
with endometriosis in a secondary care setting in the UK. METHODS: A retrospective
analysis was performed using secondary care data from the Cardiff and Vale National
Health Service Hospitals Trust including 411 patients diagnosed with endometriosis.
a supplementary postal survey was completed by a subset of 80 patients. Data included
information on hospital stays, surgical procedures, prescriptions, as well as survey
data on primary care treatment, quality of life and productivity loss. Patients were
classified into surgical or clinical diagnosis groups depending on type of diagnosis:
laparoscopy/laparotomy, or clinician’s assessment only. RESULTS: For hospital visits
with endometriosis as primary diagnosis, patients with a surgical diagnosis (n = 89)
experienced an average hospital stay duration of 0.4 days (SD = 0.7) compared to 2.2
days (SD = 3.4) for patients with a clinical diagnosis (n = 322). The average cost per
hospital visit was £871 (surgical group) and £1525 (clinical group). Patients with
clinical diagnosis also had more GP visits in the 6 weeks prior to their hospital visit
(mean 2.0 (SD = 2.9) vs. 1.4 (SD = 1.4)). The most common endometriosis-specific
pharmacotherapy used in a secondary setting was GnRH agonists (22%) followed by
progestins (11%) and oral contraceptives (10%) with drug use in the surgical group
exceeding that of the clinical group. Patient utility as measured by the EQ-5D was
similar for surgically and clinically diagnosed patients (0.70, SD = 0.32 vs. 0.71, SD
= 0.27). CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrates that there are substantial costs
involved in treating patients in a secondary care setting, with a different pattern of
endometriosis-related costs for patients without a confirmed diagnosis of
endometriosis.
PIH11
SOCIETAL IMPACT OF DIARRHEA IN YOUNG CHILDREN IN THE
NETHERLANDS
Wolleswinkel J1, Speets A1, Hovels AM2
1
Pallas, Health Research and Consultancy, Rotterdam, The Netherlands; 2GSK, Zeist, The
Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: Diarrhoea is one of the most common childhood diseases. This study
examined the medical resources use and societal impact related to diarrhoea in young
children in the The Netherlands. METHODS: In 2007 an Internet survey questionnaire on childhood diseases was administered to a representative sample of parents
with children aged <5 years. The survey covered socio-demographic data, characteristics of the most recent disease episode, medical resources use, productivity loss by
the caregivers, and travel-related costs. Data were available for 2425 respondents.
This study focused on diarrhoea episodes. Diarrhoea was defined as symptoms and/
or diagnosis of diarrhoea only or diarrhoea in combination with symptoms of fever
and/or vomiting; i.e. diarrhoea without concomitant diseases. RESULTS: In total 128
episodes of diarrhoea were reported. In 27% of these episodes a general practitioner
had been consulted, in 2% a paediatrician, and in 4% an emergency department had
been visited. In 59% of the diarrhoea episodes no medical doctor was consulted.
Hospital admission occurred in 3% of the cases (mean duration 2 days). Over-thecounter drugs were bought in 41% of the episodes. In 17% of the diarrhoea episodes
caregivers lost days from a paid job (mean 16.4 hours per episode; SD 15.8). In 19%
of the episodes parents reported productivity loss at work during their child’s illness
(mean 6.3 hours per episode; SD 5.9). Leisure time loss was reported in 29% of the
episodes (mean 2.3 hours per episode; SD 2.5). The mean costs were estimated to be
c208,- per diarrhoea episode, of which 23.3% direct medical costs, 10.3% direct
non-medical, and 66.4% indirect non-medical costs. CONCLUSIONS: The medical
and economic burden of diarrhoea is considerable to individual families as well as to
society in the The Netherlands. This study has filled a gap in the knowledge base on
the impact of diarrhoea on society.
13th Euro Abstracts
PIH12
GOLD STAGE AND DURATION OF HOSPITAL ADMISSION DETERMINES
SIZE AND STRUCTURE OF COPD RELATED DIRECT MEDICAL COSTS
IN ELDERLY
Jakovljevic M1, Lazic Z2, Jankovic S1, Verhaeghe N3, Annemans L4
1
The Medical Faculty University of Kragujevac, Kragujevac, Serbia; 2Clinical Center Kragujevac,
Kragujevac, Serbia; 3Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium; 4Ghent University—Brussels
University, Ghent, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: COPD cost of illness assessment and its dependence on GOLD stage
or duration of hospital admission. METHODS: The sample consisted of 186 elderly
COPD patients. Chest physicians conducted follow-up and financial data were
obtained from administrative registry. Time horizon was one year and Health Insurance Fund perspective was selected. Included clinical endpoints were disease exacerbation and hospital admission. Economic data included all inpatient COPD-related
medical goods and services consumption, and outpatient drug utilization. We excluded
medical costs which did not arise from COPD. RESULTS: An average elderly COPD
patient imposed c1745.41 of costs annually to the national health care budget. Severity
grade (GOLD stage) and duration of all hospital admissions were significantly and
directly correlated with overall cost. Expenses structure per year was: c14.54 outpatient care, c126.97 inpatient drug consumption, c377.98 hospital admission (Intensive
Care Unit admissions and specialist consultations included in daily price), c133.5
imaging diagnostics, c111.43 laboratory analysis, c26.67 therapeutic interventions,
c70.32 consumables, c884 outpatient drugs consumption. Most expenses originating
from drug acquisition were due to antibiotics prescribed for curing infections and
mucolitics and antihistamine drugs consumption. Average number of hospitalizations
per person was 1.45 with a duration of 12.84 days. Fifteen persons deceased. Average
number of outpatient visits was 2.71 per person. CONCLUSIONS: Overall burden
of COPD is mostly driven by outpatient drug consumption and exacerbations leading
to hospital admissions. Relative relevance of drug acquisition expenses in our country
is higher than in high-income societies, because of still significantly lower human
labour wages in the area. Pattern of diagnostic procedures requested and ATC drug
classes consumed remains similar and comparable in most countries. More in-depth
research of indirect COPD attributable costs e.g. lost productivity, absentism, premature death etc, will be needed in the future.
PIH13
PATTERNS AND COSTS OF HOSPITALIZATIONS IN ELDERLY
PATIENTS IN RIO DE JANEIRO, BRAZIL
Takemoto ML, Fernandes RA, Passos RB, Tolentino ACM, Cukier FN, Takemoto MM,
Moretti AIP
ANOVA—Knowledge Translation, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: Ageing population implies greater demand of hospital services and
consequent health care costs. This study aims to describe patterns of hospitalization
and estimate hospitalization costs for aged patients in public hospitals in the city of
Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. METHODS: Retrospective analysis of Rio de Janeiro hospital
admissions for elderly people (aged ≥60 years) as reported in Brazilian Hospital
Information System (SIH/DATASUS) database from January 1st to December 31st
2007. The costs informed in the database represent federal reimbursement values for
hospitalizations placed in public hospitals in the city. Admissions were categorized
according to ICD-10 groups and age categories. RESULTS: 287,972 hospital admissions were identified for all ages in the city in 2007 and 24.3% were for patients ≥60
years (70,077). The five more common reasons for hospitalization were cardiovascular
diseases (22.4%), cancer (17.5%), mental and cognitive disorders (11.2%), gastrointestinal (9.3%) and respiratory diseases (7.6%). The in-hospital mortality rate was
14.76% for all causes. When disease groups were analyzed, infectious and respiratory
diseases had the higher mortality rates (38.6% and 38.3%, respectively). The mean
length of stay was 14.3 days and the average cost for elderly patients hospitalizations
was 960,62 BRL. The total amount paid for hospitalization of elderly patients in 2007
was 67,317,348 BRL, 30.7% of all hospitalization costs. CONCLUSIONS: The findings showed the significant contribution of the elderly to public hospital expenditures
with leading causes of admission including cardiovascular diseases, cancer and mental
and cognitive disorders. Additionally, the higher in-hospital mortality rate was seen
for preventable diseases. These results reinforce the need of prevention strategies
among the elder population for targeted conditions.
PIH14
COST-BENEFIT OF FLUCONAZOLE FOR VAGINAL CANDIDIASIS
1
2
1
Sura MV , Avksentieva MV , Gostishev R
1
Institute of Clinico-Economic Expertise and Pharmacoeconomics, RSMU, Moscow, Russia;
2
Research Center for Clinical and Economic Evaluation and Pharmacoeconomics, Moscow,
Russia
OBJECTIVES: To perform cost-benefit analysis of fluconazole for VC in Russia.
METHODS: Willingness-to-pay (WTP) for treatment of vaginal candidiasis was
assessed. 240 women took part in the survey. a special questionnaire was designed to
reveal women’s preferable methods of antifungal drug application and WTP for fluconazole in comparison with other drugs. Women were proposed: 1) to chose the
preferable method of drug application; 2) to chose the preferable drug among 4
options with similar efficacy but different methods of application and price (no concrete drug names were mentioned, only prices and costs of treatment and application
methods); and 3) to give the maximal affordable price for treating vaginal candidiasis.
RESULTS: More than 60% of women preferred oral treatment once with the mean
A377
costs of therapy 350 rubles ($11) among 4 proposed alternatives. The median WTP
for antifungal therapy was 500 rubles ($16) (range from 50 to 5000 rubles, $1.6–
161.0) that is less than real cost of treatment with original fluconazole preparation.
The cost-benefit ratio (WTP/cost of treatment) was 1.30 (range 0.09–20.6). CONCLUSIONS: Fluconazole is a cost-benefit alternative for VC treatment.
PIH15
ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF DARBEPOETIN ALFA (ARANESP)
COMPARED TO EPOETIN ALFA (ERYPO) AND EPOETIN BETA
(NEORECORMON) IN THE TREATMENT OF CHEMOTHERAPY-INDUCED
ANEMIA (CIA) IN AUSTRIA
Walter E1, Ribnicsek E2, Kutikova L3
1
Institut fuer Pharmaoekonomische Forschung, Vienna, Austria; 2Amgen, Vienna, Austria;
3
Amgen (Europe) GmbH, Zug, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: Anemia is a common side effect observed in patients receiving myelosuppressive chemotherapy [1]. The purpose of this pharmacoeconomic analysis was
to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of the long-acting erythropoiesis-stimulating agent
(ESA) darbepoetin alfa (DA) 500 mcg once every 3 weeks (Q3W) and 150 mcg weekly
(QW), and short-acting ESAs epoetin-alfa (EA) 40,000 IU QW, epoetin-beta (EB)
30,000 IU QW and 3-times weekly (TIW) for the treatment of CIA. METHODS: A
cost-consequence model was constructed using a decision-analysis tree. The treatment
period considered was based on 12 weeks and was aligned with routine chemotherapy
regimen administration. Model inputs included: medical treatment, outcomes, and
health care service utilization from published clinical trials and summary of product
characteristics recommendation. Effectiveness of therapeutic alternatives was determined by comparing hemoglobin response rates. Costs included direct medical
costs(intervention drug, inpatient and outpatient) and transportation costs. Costs
presented reflect 2010 data. The analysis was performed from the perspective of the
Austrian health care system. RESULTS: The average expected direct costs per patient
were c3,675 for DA Q3W, c3830 for DA QW, c4290 for EA QW, c4240 for EB QW
and c4745 for EB TIW. Cost-savings associated with DA Q3W were 4% relative to
DA QW, 14% to EA QW, 13% to EB QW and 23% to EB TIW. The cost per hemoglobin response rate (therapeutic success) amounted to c5035 for DA Q3W, c5247
for DA QW, c6309 for EA QW, c6235 for EB QW and c6977 for EB TIW. CONCLUSIONS: In the treatment of CIA among cancer patients in Austria, darbepoetin
alfa Q3W and QW are projected to provide more efficient use of health care resources
compared to alternative treatment strategies such as epoetin-alfa and epoetin-beta. [1]
Ludwig et al. Eur J Cancer 2004;40:2293–306.
PIH16
SURGICAL REPAIR OF ANTERIOR VAGINAL WALL PROLAPSE USING
PROLIFT AND COLPORRHAPHY. A COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS
FOR A THIRD LEVEL HOSPITAL IN MEXICO
Nasciben V1, Zanela OO2, Cabra HA2, Rodriguez S2
1
Johnson & Johnson, Sao Paulo-SP, Brazil; 2Johnson & Johnson Medical, Mexico City, D.F.,
Mexico
OBJECTIVES: Estimate the clinical and economic outcomes of the surgical repair of
anterior vaginal wall prolapse using Prolift® vs. colporrhaphy to assess its costeffectiveness under a third level hospital perspective in Mexico. METHODS: A multistate Markov model was developed to assess the evolution of a patient with anterior
vaginal wall prolapse under a conventional surgical repair strategy (colporrhaphy) and
a mesh grant (Prolift®) after 2, 4, 10 and 20 years. a specialist panel was conducted
to collect current clinical practice, resource utilization and complication data. After
the first surgical prolapse repair, the base-case patient could face two additional
surgeries if prolapse relapsed. Two scenarios were modeled to compare the clinical
and economic impact of Prolift® as second line treatment; the mesh grant was the
assumed third line treatment for both scenarios. The effectiveness variable was the
objective recurrence (failure) rate. Clinical data, transition probabilities and mortality
rates were taken from published sources. Only direct medical costs were considered,
and cost data was retrieved from IMSS official cost list. The price of Prolift® was
internally estimated. Results are expressed as 2010 inflation-adjusted Mexican pesos
(MXN) and MXN/QALY for ICERs. a 4.5% discount rate was used for costs and
outcomes. RESULTS: Total costs for year 1 were higher for the Prolift® strategy
($75,688 vs. $74,544), but yielded an overall 22% complication reduction. For year
2, total costs were lower for Prolift® ($81,675 vs. $104,007), yielding better outcomes
(0.04 incremental QALYs), thus being a dominant strategy (−$528,682/QALY). For
the following years, Prolift® showed to be a consistent cost-saving alternative vs.
colporrhaphy: ICERs for years 4, 10 and 20 were −$273,598/QALY, −$29,942/QALY
and −$1,212/QALY. CONCLUSIONS: Findings suggest Prolift® is a safe and costeffective alternative to treat anterior vaginal wall prolapse when compared to colporrhaphy. Savings are due to lower failure and complication rates.
PIH17
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF SEASONAL INFLUENZA VACCINATION IN
PREGNANCY IS DEPENDENT ON VACCINATION EARLY IN FLU
SEASON
Myers ER1, Misurski DA2, Swamy GK1
1
Duke University, Durham, NC, USA; 2GlaxoSmithKline, Philadelphia, PA, USA
OBJECTIVES: To estimate the impact of vaccination timing on the cost-effectiveness
of seasonal influenza vaccination in pregnancy for prevention of disease in women
and infants under 6 months of age. METHODS: We constructed an open cohort
A378
Markov simulation of US pregnant women and infants under 6 months of age for 1
calendar year, from July 1 through June 30. National statistics on live births and infant
mortality were used to generate probabilities of delivery and infant death based on
gestational age. Each week, women entered the cohort with new pregnancies, and left
by delivery; infants entered by delivery and left by death or reaching 6 months of age.
Annual influenza-attributable rates of outpatient visits and hospitalizations for pregnant women and infants were obtained from the literature, and adjusted to weekly
incidences using CDC data on influenza-positive respiratory isolates. In the base case,
we assumed vaccination would begin in calendar week 40, be administered at routine
prenatal visits across all gestational ages, and continue throughout the rest of the year,
with vaccine efficacy of 73% for prevention of maternal flu and 63% for prevention
of flu in infants under 6 months. Costs and maternal utilities were obtained from
previously published analyses; we used published parental utilities for relevant infant
health states. RESULTS: Base-case cost-effectiveness was $65,112/QALY gained.
Fifty-six percent of the reduction in morbidity was attributable to prevention of disease
in infants, and all of this benefit was accrued by vaccination within the first 4 weeks
of vaccine availability. CONCLUSIONS: Vaccination of pregnant women against
seasonal influenza is cost-effective, with much of the benefit derived from prevention
of infant disease. Vaccination is most efficient when the majority of pregnant women
are vaccinated within 4 weeks of vaccine availability.
PIH18
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF COMBINATION THERAPY WITH
DUTASTERIDE AND TAMSULOSIN FOR THE TREATMENT OF
MODERATE TO SEVERE BENIGN PROSTATIC HYPERPLASIA IN SPAIN
Antoñanzas F1, Cozar JM2, Brenes F3, Molero JM4, Fernández-Pro A5, Palencia R6,
Martín I6, Huerta A6
1
Universidad de la Rioja, Logroño, La Rioja, Spain; 2Hospital Universitario Virgen de las
Nieves, Granada, Spain;, 3Centro de Atención Primaria Llefià (ABS6), Badalona, Spain;
4
Centro de Salud San Andrés, Madrid, Spain; 5Centro de Salud de Menasalbas, Menasalbas,
Toledo, Spain; 6GlaxoSmithKline, Tres Cantos, Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of the combination therapy with
dutasteride and tamsulosin (D+T) as initiation treatment versus tamsulosin (T), considered the standard of care, in the treatment of moderate to severe benign prostatic
hyperplasia (BPH) in Spain. METHODS: A semi-Markov model was developed using
4-year and 35-year time horizons. Data were obtained from the CombAT and literature review, and the analysis was made from the National Healthcare Service perspective. Effectiveness was measured in terms of reduction of acute urinary retention
(AUR) events and/or BPH-related surgeries and quality adjusted life-years (QALYs).
Health care resources were defined by an experts’ panel, and unitary costs were
obtained from published Spanish sources and expressed in 2010 Euros. The model
calculates costs, AURs and/or surgeries, and QALYs related to each therapy. Costs
and effectiveness outcomes were discounted at 3.0%. One-way and probabilistic
sensitivity analyses were conducted to test the robustness of the model. RESULTS:
Combination therapy with D+T improves patients’ outcomes. At 4 years, D+T patients
have a 9.9% reduction in AURs and/or surgeries over T, reaching 43.9% at 35 years.
At 4 and 35 years, total costs related to T treatment add up to 1,373.90c and
5,187.37c, and total costs related to D+T are 2,184.43c and 8,630.99c, respectively.
Therefore, at 4 years, treatment with D+T presents an additional cost of 81.66c per
AUR and/or surgery avoided and 14,023.32c per QALY gained compared to T. At
35 years, results were 79.10c per AUR and/or surgery avoided and 8,750.15c per
QALY gained. Sensitivity analyses showed that results are robust. CONCLUSIONS:
Given the assumptions, combination treatment with D+T not only represents a more
effective alternative versus T due to the reduction in AURs and/or surgeries, but also
is a cost-effective treatment in patients with moderate to severe BPH in Spain.
PIH19
TRENDS IN COST-EFFECTIVENESS STUDIES OF HIGH BUDGET IMPACT
DRUGS
Aggarwal S1, Stevens CA2
1
PAREXEL Consulting, Bethesda, MD, USA; 2PAREXEL Consulting, Waltham, MA, USA
OBJECTIVES: The recently made coverage decisions by UK’s NICE, Scotland’s SMC
and the allocation of $1.1Billion for comparative effectiveness research by the United
States, are strong indicators of trends in pricing and reimbursement that are likely to
be observed in the future. To gain an additional insight into these trends, we analyzed
the cost-effectiveness studies for the top 10 highest selling drugs (~$80–95B worldwide
sales). METHODS: The Top 10 drugs were selected based on their worldwide sales.
For this analysis, we segmented these drugs into categories as primary care, specialty,
small molecules, biologics, therapy areas and availability of generic alternatives. We
analyzed the cost-effectiveness studies that were published in peer-reviewed journals.
Search was conducted using generic names of the drugs and the phrase “cost-effectiveness” in abstract of the published study. RESULTS: During 2003–2008, the
number of published studies on “cost-effectiveness” have increased by more than
30%. Almost half of the published studies belong to—Remicade, Plavix and Enbrel.
There is a large variability in CERs for same drugs for different indications, in some
cases also varying by biomarkers. Primary care drugs had lower and less variable CERs
than specialty drugs. Variations also exist in methodology used by different groups in
modeling cost-effectiveness, especially for time horizon and comparator. Majority of
primary care drugs were modeled for a time horizon of 35–40 years or lifetime to
demonstrate cost-effectiveness. Among the top 10 drugs, quetiapine and erythropoietin had the highest variability across different studies, and atorvatstatin, salmetrol/
13th Euro Abstracts
fluticasone and clopidogrel had the most consistent ICER values across studies. CONCLUSIONS: This analysis shows the range, variability and methods used for calculation of ICER values for these high budget impact drugs and provides lessons for
executives and policy makers.
PIH20
EXPLORATORY COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS OF THE ANTERIOR
REPAIR OF THE PELVIC ORGAN PROLAPSE COMPARING ANTERIOR
COLPORRHAPHY (CONVETIONAL SURGERY) VERSUS PROLIFT® MESH,
UNDER THE BRAZILIAN PRIVATE PAYER PERSPECTIVE
Nasciben V
Johnson & Johnson, Sao Paulo-SP, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: To assess the cost-effectiveness of the anterior repair of the Pelvic organ
prolapse (POP) with Prolift® versus the colporrhaphy (COLP), under private payer
perspective, in Brazil. METHODS: A multi-state Markov model was developed to
assess the evolution of a patient with anterior vaginal prolapse after COLP and
Prolift® after 2, 4, 10 and 20 years. a panel of specialist was conducted to obtain the
local practice and to collect the complication rates. Only direct medical costs were
considered (SIMPRO, 2010; CBHPM 5th Ed). Clinical data, transition probabilities
and mortality rates were taken from published sources (IBGE, 2008; Jia, X 2007).
The base-case patient could face up to three surgical repairs if prolapse relapsed. Two
scenarios were modeled to compare the clinical and economic impact of Prolift® as
second line treatment; mesh grant was the assumed third line treatment for both
scenarios. Discount rate of 5% for costs and outcomes was taken following the Brazilian HTA guidelines (Vianna, 2007). One-way sensitivity analysis was conducted to
assess the robustness of the results. RESULTS: The total costs for the first year were
higher for Prolift® (R$8119 versus R$4777; incremental R$3342). For the 2nd year
the difference in the total costs reduced (R$8659 vs. R$7435; additional R$1223)
with better outcomes for Prolift® (incremental QALYs: 0.04) with ICER ranging from
R$19,099 (non discounted) to R$33,207 (discounted). For the next years the ICERs
reduced, showing long term benefits of the adoption of Prolift®. For the fourth year
ICER ranging from R$419 to R$532, 10th year from R$578 to R$827 and for the
20th year ranging from R$832 to R$1291, for non discounted and discounted results.
CONCLUSIONS: Findings suggest Prolift® as a cost-effective intervention, under the
Brazilian private payer perspective.
PIH21
IS ROUTINE IMMUNIZATION OF ELDERLY WITH THE 13-VALENT
PNEUMOCOCCAL CONJUGATE VACCINE LIKELY TO BE CONSIDERED
AS COST-EFFECTIVE?
Rozenbaum MH1, Hak E2, van der Werf TS3, Postma MJ2
1
Rijksuniversiteit Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands; 2University of Groningen,
Groningen, The Netherlands; 3University Medical Centre Groningen (UMCG), Groningen,
The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: To estimate the cost-effectiveness in relation to the efficacy of PCV-13
among elderly (both the total population and those at increased risk) aged 65 years
and older for the The Netherlands, for various levels of efficacy assumed. METHODS:
Our previously published cost-effectiveness model was updated to include, age-specific
epidemiological data and health care utilization and costs for a hypothetical cohort
of elderly aged over 65 years of the population of the The Netherlands. This cohort
was followed twice- once as unvaccinated and once as a vaccinated cohort- over a
time period of 5 years. Outcome measures included costs, life-years (LYs), qualityadjusted life-years (QALYs) and cost-effectiveness ratios (CERs). All analyses were
performed from a societal perspective. RESULTS: Vaccination remained well below
the c80,000 per LY except if the vaccine was only assumed to be protective against
bacteraemic pneumonia with a relatively low effectiveness (40%) in combination with
a high vaccine price (c65) and indirect effects of serotype replacement would largely
offset the direct effect of vaccination. For various assumptions, introduction PCV-13
(assuming a 60% efficacy against invasive and non invasive disease due to vaccine
serotypes, and a cost of c50 per vaccinated person) the incremental cost-effectiveness
ratio varies over from cost-saving to c50,676 per LY. More probable scenarios generated cost-effectiveness ratios which would be labeled as cost-effective. CONCLUSIONS: In the The Netherlands, vaccination with PCV-13 is likely to be considered
cost-effective both for the total and for the high-risk population over 65 years of age
from a societal perspective over a five-year time horizon. The main limitation of this
study was the uncertainty regarding the share of pneumococcal related pneumonia.
PIH22
EVALUATING THE COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF CERVICAL CANCER
SCREENING AND HUMAN PAPILLOMAVIRUS VACCINATION
STRATEGIES USING A MATHEMATICAL MODEL
Taylor DC1, Pawar V1, Gilmore K1, Sanon M1, Kruzikas D2, Kohli M3, Arondekar B4,
Demarteau N5, Weinstein M6
1
i3 Innovus, Medford, MA, USA; 2Lovelace Respiratory Research Institute, Kannapolis, NC,
USA;, 3i3 Innovus, Burlington, ON, Canada; 4GlaxoSmithKline, Philadelphia, PA, USA;
5
GSKbio, Wavre, Belgium; 6Harvard School of Public Health, Boston, MA, USA
OBJECTIVES: To assess the cost-effectiveness of various cervical screening strategies
in a cohort of 12-year-old US women with (V) and without (NV) a human papillomavirus (HPV) 16/18 vaccine with efficacy against vaccine and non-vaccine oncogenic
HPV types. METHODS: A lifetime Markov model simulating the progression of HPV
infection and subsequent cervical disease (cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN),
A379
13th Euro Abstracts
cervical cancer, and death) was developed. Thirty cervical screening strategies were
investigated, including the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists’
recommendation: screening women every 2 years starting at age 21 years, increasing
to 3 years following three consecutive negative tests after age 29 (denoted “21/2–3”).
Other strategies varied initial screening age (16, 21, or 25 years) and screening frequency before and after age 30 years (every 1, 2, 3, 4, or 5 years). Vaccination was
assumed to provide 95% efficacy against CIN2+ due to types 16/18 and 37.4% efficacy against CIN2+ excluding co-infections due to HPV types 16/18 (extrapolated to
efficacy against infection). The primary outcome was incremental cost-effectiveness
ratio (ICER) per quality-adjusted life-year (QALY) gained. Full screening compliance
and vaccination coverage were assumed; all outcomes discounted at 3% per year.
RESULTS: The 25/5–5NV strategy (every 5 years starting at age 25 years, without
vaccination) was least costly. No other screening scenario without vaccination was
cost-effective. The 25/5–5V strategy was cost-effective compared with the 25/5–5NV
strategy ($9,000/QALY). Other non-dominated strategies (25/3–4V, 25/2–3V, and
25/1–2V) produced ICERs above $100,000 per QALY. CONCLUSIONS: Model
results suggest initiating screening at age 25 with a 5-year frequency in the presence
of HPV vaccination is cost-effective compared with increasing screening frequency
without vaccination or lowering the age of screening initiation. Increasing HPV vaccination in 12-year-old women would allow for less frequent screening initiated at
older ages, constituting an efficient use of health care resources.
PIH23
COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS OF 5-ALPHA REDUCTASE
INHIBITORS IN PATIENTS WITH BPH AND AN ELEVATED PSA IN
SWEDEN
Sobocki P1, Björkstedt K1, Svedman C2
1
GlaxoSmithKline, Solna, Sweden; 2Karolinska Institute, Stockholm, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: Dutasteride and finasteride are indicated for treatment of BPH and
both agents have demonstrated efficacy as risk reduction (RR) of PCa. The present
work assesses the cost-effectiveness of the combined effect of each drug on BPH
progression and RR of PCa, in the treatment of BPH patients with a risk of developing
prostate cancer (PSA ≥ 3). METHODS: A previously validated Markov model was
populated to simulate the cost-effectiveness of treatment with dutasteride or finasteride
in men with BPH and a PSA-level ≥3. Equal effect was assumed of the two drugs on
BPH progression, and an indirect comparison was performed to compare RR effect on
PCa for dutasteride (the REDUCE trial) and finasteride (the PCPT trial). Due to different
study design and populations in the two trials, an adjustment was made to the REDUCE
trial results to match the PCPT trial design. Data on incidence, costs and quality-of-life
for BPH and PCa were retrieved from registries, publications and expert opinions. The
outcome is presented as incremental cost per QALY and results were presented in c2009.
Extensive sensitivity analyses were performed to present the uncertainties in the results.
RESULTS: Estimated RRR of clinically detectable PCa in REDUCE was 33.3%–73%,
depending risk level chosen as trigger for detection of PCa, compared to 19% for
finasteride. Incremental cost per QALY gained was estimated at c28,970 with the most
conservative risk reduction of 33%. Sensitivity analysis gave a range from c4,940 to
c54,200 per QALY. Results were most sensitive to changes in level of risk-reducing
benefit of PCa and quality-of-life weights attributed to the diagnosis of PCa. CONCLUSIONS: Use of dutasteride to reduce the risk of PCa and BPH progress is expected
to be cost-effective compared to finasteride when used in 60-year-old men with BPH
and PSA ≥ 3.
PIH24
INDIRECT COSTS OF PREGNANCY, PARTURITION AND PUERPERIUM
IN POLAND
Szkolut S1, Jakubczyk M1, Hermanowski T2
1
Medical University of Warsaw, Warsaw, Poland; 2Department of Pharmacoeconomics,
Medical University of Warsaw, Warsaw, Poland
OBJECTIVES: The aim was to estimate the indirect costs of absenteeism generated
by women during pregnancy and in post-natal period. The secondary objective was
to quantify the indirect costs in relation to the maternity benefits and examine the
shares of absenteeism caused by pregnancy, childbirth, and puerperium in a total
disease-related absenteeism in Poland. METHODS: The indirect costs of pregnancy
were estimated using human capital approach. Social Insurance Office reports on the
disease-related absenteeism in Poland in the years 2006–2008 were used as a data
source. The sickness benefits (equal to wages) were used to estimate the indirect costs
of monthly absence. Indirect costs were compared with the forecasted production
value to be generated by a child in a life-time horizon (discounted with a rate of 5%,
accounting for survival probabilities, changing wages and rate of activity rate).
RESULTS: The pregnancy, parturition and puerperium related absenteeism represented in years 2006–2008 successively 15.1%, 15.8% and 16.7% of the total diseaserelated absenteeism in Poland. The cost of absenteeism during pregnancy, childbirth
and puerperium in 2006 amounted to c242 million (1c = approx. 4.10 PLN), and in
2 successive years increased by an average of c66 million yearly. Indirect cost associated with maternity leaves in years 2006–2008 amounted to c267.7 million, c341.8
million, and c441.6 million respectively. The total indirect costs of pregnancy in years
2006–2008 achieved an average of c651.1 million. The indirect cost related with single
pregnancy was estimated at c1650 representing only 3.5% of future estimated production value generated by a child (c47,083). CONCLUSIONS: However pregnancy is
obviously not an illness, the indirect costs thereof can be calculated and should be
used when evaluating the impact of family-friendly policies. The indirect costs are
negligible comparing to future benefits.
PIH25
THE IMPACT OF EMPLOYEES WORK ABSENTEEISM DUE TO CARE FOR
A SICK PERSON ON PRODUCTIVITY IN POLAND
Wrona W, Hermanowski T, Jakubczyk M, Czech M
Department of Pharmacoeconomics, Medical University of Warsaw, Warsaw, Poland
OBJECTIVES: The work absenteeism due to care for a sick person can be considered
as indirect costs of illness. This study aimed at assessing the global burden of caring
for the ill on productivity in Poland. METHODS: Data were obtained from a survey
that incorporated information on a burden of caring for the sick and the WPAI-GH
questionnaire during computer-assisted personal interview in a representative sample
of the Polish general population aged more than 15 years. There were 2019 respondents, gathered in two waves in January and May 2010. Human capital approach was
used with GDP per capita as a measure for the monetary value of a time unit (c4.2
per hour). RESULTS: The final population comprised 795 employees among whom
167 respondents (21%) took care for a sick person in the last 12 months—78 (10%),
74 (9%), and 19 (2%) responders took care for a child, other family member and
non-family member, respectively. On average a respondent spent 9 hours a day (h/d)
taking care of a sick person for an average period of 21 days (11 h/d for 14 d caring
for a child; 7 h/d for 23 d caring for other family member; 13 h/d for 22 d caring for
non-family member). These 9 hours were reduced working time (3,4 h) and off-work
activities (5.6 h). Estimated productivity lost equals c303 on average per year for
individuals looking after the ill and c11 on average per year for each employee.
CONCLUSIONS: Caring for the sick, mostly family members, influences working
time of Polish employees. Productivity loss of a single employee has a moderate impact
on production, but in global scale or in specific health condition it might be perceived
as an important factor modifying indirect costs of illness.
PIH26
DEVELOPMENT OF A SEGMENTATION MODEL TO IDENTIFY HEALTH
CARE DEMAND AND RELATED COSTS ATTRIBUTABLE TO
POPULATION’S CHARACTERISTICS
Madotto F1, Fornari C1, Riva MA1, Scalone L1, Ciampichini R2, Bonazzi MC1, Cesana G1
1
University of Milano—Bicocca, Monza (MB), Italy; 2Charta Foundation, Milan, Italy
OBJECTIVES: The assessment of individuals’ demand and related costs can guide to
allocate health care resources and improve access to health care. We created a segmentation demand model and we estimated health care costs and their determinants
within specific and distinguished groups of general population. METHODS: The
target population included subjects living in an area of northern Italy registered at one
Local Healthcare Unit in 2005 (1,031,684 subjects). On the basis of clinical judgments
and literature, we identified eight different segments: subjects unknown to HS, maternity and infancy, elderly, people with one chronic disease (CD), people with more
CDs, people with probable or not severe CDs, subjects with acute event, healthy
people. To describe these groups and their health demand, we used demographic and
health care demand data (hospital admissions, drug’s prescriptions, medical specialist
visits, diagnostic tests) from administrative databases available at the Lombardy
Health System (HS). These were merged adopting probabilistic record linkage
(DENALI Data Warehouse) to optimize correct matching of data. RESULTS: Overall,
health care cost c834 million in 2005 (c809 per-capita). Healthy people were 53% of
the sample and cost c180 per-capita. Next more frequent subjects were those with
one CD (14%) and cost c916 per-capita, then those with more CDs (13%) who cost
c3457 per-capita. Hospitalizations were the cost driver in 5 segments (maternity and
infancy, elderly, one CD, more CDs, acute event), accounting for 42–89% of total
costs. Diagnostic tests and medical visits contributed to 42–45% of total costs among
healthy subjects and those with probable CD. Drugs accounted for 24% of costs of
sample. CONCLUSIONS: This pioneer demand segmentation model shows an
example of how merging different administrative databases makes possible understanding effects of their characteristics on health care demand and costs. Research is
encouraged to improve model and study specific variants that can be applied in different health care contexts.
INDIVIDUAL’S HEALTH – Patient-Reported Outcomes Studies
PIH27
ADHERENCE TO PRESCRIPTION MEDICATIONS IS HIGHER WITH USE
OF A GENERAL PRACTITIONER
Goren A1, DiBonaventura M1, Gupta S2, Wagner JS1, Freedman D2
1
Kantar Health, New York, NY, USA; 2Kantar Health, Princeton, NJ, USA
OBJECTIVES: Non-adherence to treatment regimens results in risks and health care
costs due to increased emergency care. One reason for non-adherence, especially with
multiple prescriptions, may be the lack of coordination of care among multiple specialists (Cutler & Everett, 2010). Assuming that general/family practitioners (GPs) help
coordinate patient care, the current study examined the impact on adherence of visiting a GP. METHODS: Adherence data from the European 2008 National Health and
Wellness Survey (a self-reported online survey sampling respondents from the UK,
France, Germany, Italy, and Spain) were analyzed, with ANOVAs or negative binomial regressions (for resource utilization), as a function of seeing a GP (yes/no) crossed
with number of prescriptions (1–2, 3–4, and 5+). Adherence, the main outcome, was
a Morisky Score ranging from 0 (perfect adherence) to 4 (low adherence). Health
care resource utilization measures included number of hospitalizations and visits to
the emergency room (ER) in the past six months. RESULTS: There were 17,690
A380
respondents (of 53,524 total) using 1–2 (n = 6,434), 3–4 (5,529), or 5+ (5,727) prescription medications for symptomatic conditions. Adherence was higher among those
who saw a GP in the past 6 months (M = 1.19, SD = 1.24, n = 14,802) vs. those who
did not (M = 1.36, SD = 1.29, n = 2,888), P < 0.001, and higher among those with
a higher number of prescriptions (for 5+, 3–4, and 1–2: Ms = 0.99, 1.26, and 1.38;
SDs = 1.18, 1.26, and 1.27, respectively), P < 0.001. Hospitalizations were lower
among GP visitors (M = 0.30, SD = 2.39) than non-visitors (M = 0.34, SD = 2.07), P
< 0.001, ER visits were lower among GP visitors (M = 0.32, SD = 1.20) than nonvisitors (M = 0.33, SD = 2.09), P < 0.001, and both were significantly higher among
those with more prescriptions, ps < 0.001. The benefits of a GP were largely independent of number of medications. CONCLUSIONS: Among European patients taking
prescriptions, visiting a GP was associated with greater adherence and lower health
care resource utilization.
PIH28
WHY DO PATIENTS NOT ADHERE TO PRESCRIBED MEDICATION
REGIMES? RESULTS OF TWO GERMAN SURVEYS
Wilke T1, Mueller S2
1
Institute for Pharmacoeconomics and Drug Logistics, University of Wismar, Wismar,
Germany; 2University of Wismar, Wismar, Germany
OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study is to answer the following questions: 1) How
high is the self-reported nonadherence (NA) of German patients with the need to regularly take medication? and 2) Which factors capable of explaining this self-reported
NA can be identified by multivariate analysis? METHODS: Two cross-sectional
surveys (phone survey with 1177 patients; face-to-face in-depth survey with 340
patients in 17 German pharmacies) were conducted. Self-reported NA was measured
by the generic Morisky scale (either as 4 items or 8 item MMAS). Identification of
explanatory factors was conducted on the basis of multivariate logistic regression
analysis (including the calculation of additive risks by dichotomization of significant
explanatory factors). RESULTS: 1) Approximately 35–40 % of the patients can be
described as non-adherent (38.8 %/35.3 %); 2a) Survey 1: Only a few socio-demographic factors are able to explain the NA (chronic disease, some aspects of age, and
low number of required medications to take); and 2b) Survey 2: Most results of the
first survey can be replicated. However, intentional NA explanations have considerably more influence: positive medication belief, a positive mood, and a good patientdoctor relationship reduce the NA risk. Furthermore, patients who are easily able to
recognize the correct medication on the basis of the identification of the packaging
have a significantly reduced NA probability. When additive risk is considered, patients
who are chronically ill but display no other risk factors have an NA probability rate
of 10.4 %, for patients displaying all identified risk factors this rate increases to 93.9
%. CONCLUSIONS: Our surveys are the largest and most detailed to have been
conducted in Germany concerned with the theme of medication-based NA. Our results
show that approximately one-third of patients can be classified as non-adherent.
Intentional NA factors explain the NA considerably better than do socio-economic
factors.
PIH29
RETROSPECTIVE EVALUATION OF THE IMPACT OF COST-SHARE
INCREASES FOR SPECIALTY MEDICATIONS ON ADHERENCE AND
PERSISTENCE
Kim YA1, Prasla K2, Rascati K3, Goel NS2, Dunlop D4, Knisely E4, Godley PJ2
1
The University of Texas at Austin, Austin, TX, USA; 2Scott & White Health Plan, Temple,
TX, USA; 3University of Texas, College of Pharmacy, Austin, TX, USA; 4Novartis
Pharmaceuticals Corporation, East Hanover, NJ, USA
OBJECTIVES: A regional health plan implemented a specialty pharmacy benefit with
increased copayment/coinsurance for specialty medications. Our objective was to
measure and compare the change in adherence and persistence after implementation
of the specialty benefit. METHODS: Pharmacy claims for patients who chronically
used anti-inflammatory, immunosuppressant, cancer, and multiple sclerosis medications were assessed. The intervention group consisted of those whose out-of-pocket
cost-share for specialty medications increased by at least $25 (per 30-day fill), and the
control group consisted of those whose out-of-pocket amounts did not change. Adherence, defined by proportion of days covered (PDC), was measured every 3 months for
12 months before and after the copay change. Paired t-tests compared the adherence
in the pre- vs. post-periods. Individual growth model analysis evaluated the changes
in adherence throughout the time periods. Cox regression analysis determined the
difference in persistence between groups after the copay change, controlling for age,
gender, copay level, group, and pre-period persistence. RESULTS: There were 237
patients in the intervention group and 211 patients in the control group. The PDC
results varied by drug type; adherence decreased after the copay change in the intervention group for patients on anti-inflammatory, immunosuppressant, and multiple sclerosis medications, but remained consistent for patients on antineoplastics. The growth
model showed a small, but statistically significant decrease in PDC of 0.01 after copay
changes (P = 0.014). The Cox regression analysis indicated that the estimated risk of
discontinuing therapy increased for patients in the intervention vs. control groups
(hazard ratio = 2.35, 95% CI: 1.43–3.58). CONCLUSIONS: The move to the specialty
pharmacy benefit allows for closer scrutiny of specialty utilization by pharmacists who
actively monitor utilization and access. Despite the minimal adherence decrease and
significant persistence changes, the results indicated relatively more stability with the
use of specialty medications than that reported with copayment/coinsurance increases
for traditional pharmaceutics.
13th Euro Abstracts
PIH30
PERSISTENCE TO POSTMENOPAUSAL OSTEOPOROSIS (PMO)
TREATMENTS IN A REGION OF SPAIN
Sicras-Mainar A1, Navarro-Artieda R2, Gutierrez L3, Sorio F3, Intorcia M3
1
Directorate of Planning, Badalona Serveis Assistencials, Badalona, Barcelona, Spain; 2Hospital
Universitari Germans Trias i Pujol, Barcelona, Spain; 3Health Economics Department, Amgen
S.A, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Women with PMO are most often treated with bisphosphonates (BPs),
as well as with strontium ranelate (SR) and raloxifene (RLX). However, a high percentage of patients are not persistent after 1 year of therapy, which can compromise
treatment effectiveness (Imaz I, Osteoporos Int 2010) and thus increase the risk of
fractures. The objective was to estimate the persistence to PMO treatments in a region
of Spain (Catalonia) representative of the Spanish population. METHODS: This
database analysis included women with PMO from 6 primary care centers, aged ≥50
years who initiated BPs (alendronate, ibandronate, risedronate), SR or RLX between
January 1, 2004 and June 30, 2008. Patients with cancer, other bone diseases, hospitalization >30 days or <1 year follow-up data were excluded. Persistence was measured
at 1, 2 or 3 years according to prescriptions dispensed at office-based pharmacies.
Three patients’ cohorts were analyzed: patients with ≥1 year (cohort 1), ≥2 years
(cohort 2) and ≥3 years (cohort 3) follow-up. Patients with no access to medication
for >1 month were considered non-persistent and a switch to another PMO treatment
was considered a discontinuation. In a secondary analysis, switch was not considered
a discontinuation. Statistics were performed using Kaplan-Meier methodology.
RESULTS: A total of 3,049 patients (mean age ± SD; 68.3 ± 9.7 years) were included
in cohort 1; 30% were persistent after 1 year (95%CI:27.5–32.5). In cohort 2 (n =
2698; 68.9 ± 9.3 years) persistence was 35% (CI:32.6–36.2) and 16% (CI:13.6–19.2)
after 1 and 2 years respectively. In cohort 3 (n = 2163; 68.4 ± 9.5 years) persistence
was 36% (CI:33.9–37.9), 20% (CI:18.3–21.7) and 9% (CI:5.9–12.1) after 1, 2 and
3 years, respectively. The results were similar by drug and frequency of administration,
and also when switch was not considered a discontinuation. CONCLUSIONS: In this
Spanish population of postmenopausal women with osteoporosis, persistence to treatment was poor, even when a switch was not considered a discontinuation.
PIH31
STATIC AND DYNAMIC BALANCE EXAMINATION ON STABILOMETER
DURING PREGNANCY
Hock M, Pálfi T, Kránicz J, Kriszbacher I, Boncz I, Bódis J
University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: Our study focused on revealing difficulties in maintaining balance
during pregnancy. METHODS: Balance testing was performed on 150 volunteers (50
healthy pregnant, 50 pathologically pregnant, 50 healthy young non—pregnant
women). One hundred pregnant women were allocated into 4 subgroups based on
physical activity performed prior to and during pregnancy. During stabilometer measurements static balance was examined with Romberg test while dynamic balance with
5 programs on a stabilometer. Statistical data were calculated according to mean,
standard deviation and T-test while the results were considered to be relevant at P <
0,05. RESULTS: Average results of Romberg test were worse in groups of pregnant
women compared to non-pregnant women although the difference was not significant.
Concerning the subgroups: those who had previously been involved in professional
sports and were healthy and physically active during pregnancy performed better on
the open–eye test (P < 0,05) compared to pathologically pregnant patients. Between
the second and third trimesters of healthy pregnancies no significant results were found
in Romberg test while a significant difference was detected (P < 0,05) in the performance of the 5th exercise of the dynamic balance test. Regarding the 5 programs on
the stabilometer examining dynamic balance non-pregnant women performed all
exercises significantly better (P < 0,05) than healthy pregnant women. However when
compared to pathologically pregnant women apart from the exercises No.2 the result
showed a significant difference (P < 0,05). Concerning the same exercises healthy
pregnant women performed significantly better (P < 0,05) in exercises No.1 and No.4.
Pregnant women who had previously been and remained physically active during
pregnancy performed the exercise of moving the centre of body weight in a significantly shorter time than those who were inactive and hospitalised. CONCLUSIONS:
Statistical analysis of data proves that physical activity (especially professional sports)
prior to becoming pregnant and physical activity during pregnancy have positive
effects.
PIH32
TREATMENTS TO PREVENT PROSTATE CANCER AND THEIR IMPACT
ON HEALTH RELATED QUALITY OF LIFE
Lloyd A1, Kerr C1, Rowen D2, Maslen T3, Brazier J2
1
Oxford Outcomes Ltd, Oxford, UK; 2University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK; 3GlaxoSmithKline
UK Ltd, Uxbridge, UK
OBJECTIVES: Treatments to prevent prostate cancer are associated with side effects
and the impact of these on health related quality of life (HRQL) should be considered
in any assessment of cost-effectiveness. However our systematic review identified a
lack of robust data. a prospective assessment of the impact of side effects was undertaken using generic and condition-specific measures of HRQL. METHODS: Participants were recruited from an online panel. Men over 55, with either erectile
dysfunction (ED), loss of libido, gynecomastia or ejaculatory disorders (without other
chronic disease such as renal failure, diabetes, multiple sclerosis etc), and an age
matched control group completed assessments of symptom severity and HRQL
(EQ-5D and Sexual QoL survey—SQoL-3D). Both HRQL measures can provide
13th Euro Abstracts
utility estimates. Regression models (tobit, OLS, Censored least absolute deviation)
were used to estimate specific changes in HRQL associated with the side effects.
RESULTS: Many participants reported more than one symptom, with ED most
common (n = 139); reduced libido (n = 99); ejaculatory disorder (n = 98), and gynecomastia (n = 20). From the OLS regression EQ-5D and SQoL-3D disutilities were
estimated for ED (−0.042; −0.075); reduced libido (−0.053; −0.047); ejaculatory disorder (−0.046; −0.028), and gynecomastia (−0.045; −0.037) respectively. EQ-5D and
SQoL-3D were weakly correlated (r = 0.296). CONCLUSIONS: The condition-specific
and generic estimates indicate the impact of prostate-related preventative treatment
on HRQL. While the magnitude of disutilities is similar the poor correlation between
the two measures suggests they are measuring different aspects of HRQL. The value
of condition-specific versus generic methods for estimating utilities will be discussed.
PIH33
PSYCHOMETRIC VALIDATION OF AN ABBREVIATED VERSION OF THE
SEXUAL FUNCTION QUESTIONNAIRE (ASFQ)
Williams K, Abraham L, Symonds T
Pfizer Ltd, Sandwich, Kent, UK
OBJECTIVES: The Sexual Function Questionnaire (SFQ-28) is a well established and
validated self-reported screening and outcomes measure of female sexual dysfunction
(FSD). In order to reduce patient burden and focus on symptoms of FSD, two domains
(partner and enjoyment) have been removed to create an abbreviated version (ASFQ).
The objective of this study was to ensure that the removal of these domains had not
changed the psychometric properties of the measure. METHODS: Forty seven premenopausal women with diagnosed female sexual arousal disorder (FSAD), primarily
cognitive arousal difficulties, completed the ASFQ, the Women’s Sexual Distress
Questionnaire (WSDQ), an FSAD daily diary and a meaningful benefit question
(MBQ) as part of a double-blind, placebo-controlled, 3-way crossover trial. Baseline
data were used to assess internal consistency and convergent validity (with the FSAD
diary). Known groups validity (comparing those with high versus low levels of distress
on the WSDQ at end of treatment) and responsiveness of the arousal domains of ASFQ
were also assessed. RESULTS: The ASFQ domains demonstrated excellent internal
consistency with Cronbach’s alpha ranging from 0.73 to 0.89. All ASFQ domains
showed excellent convergent validity with the respective items on the FSAD diary.
Excellent known groups validity was demonstrated for the desire and arousal cognitive
domains with those with higher distress scores showing poorer scores on these dimensions of the ASFQ. Moderate effect sizes were observed in the arousal domains for
those who indicated they had a meaningful improvement in their arousal disorder
during the trial. CONCLUSIONS: The results confirm that the removal of two
domains from the SFQ-28 has not impacted on its psychometric properties or responsiveness. The ASFQ is recommended for use in studies where patient burden needs to
be minimized.
PIH34
CONTENT VALIDITY OF THE BENIGN PROSTATIC HYPERPLASIA
IMPACT INDEX (BII): RESULTS FROM CONCEPT ELICITATION AND
COGNITIVE INTERVIEWS
Naegeli A1, Martin ML2, Kingery LR3, Viktrup L1
1
Eli Lilly & Company, Indianapolis, IN, USA; 2Health Research Associates, Inc, Seattle, WA,
USA; 3i3 Research, Basking Ridge, NJ, USA
OBJECTIVES: The objective of this qualitative interview study was to assess the
content validity of the BII in a sample of men with signs and symptoms of BPH using
concept elicitation (CE) and cognitive interviewing (CI) methods. METHODS: Fifty
men with BPH participated in the study; 27 completed the CEs and 23 completed the
CIs. CEs were semi-structured asking subjects to describe the BPH symptoms they
experience and how symptoms impact their life. CIs were semi-structured, asking
subjects to describe their 1) difficulties completing the BII; 2) understanding of item
meaning and terminology; 3) understanding of response options; and 4) ability to
respond appropriately to the specified recall period. All interviews were audio recorded
and transcribed. Data was analyzed using Atlas.ti. a saturation table was used to
identify when no new concepts were forthcoming. Inter-rater agreement (IRA) was
evaluated by having three coders independently dual-code 3 (11%) transcripts. Consistency of coding was characterized by agreement in the identification of concepts,
and agreement in assignment of codes. RESULTS: Saturation of concepts was reached
by the completion of 21 CE interviews. High agreement on coding consistency was
achieved at 69.4 to 89.4% for identification of concepts, and 87.8 to 96% for assignments of codes. The BII was shown to be readily understandable and easily completed
in a short period of time, and supported by the qualitative results as measuring the
relevant impacts related to BPH. CONCLUSIONS: The BII shows strong evidence of
content validity and provides an assessment of disease-related, clinically meaningful
impacts of BPH symptoms and treatment outcomes in BPH studies.
PIH35
DEMONSTRATING CONCEPTUAL EQUIVALENCE ACROSS MULTIPLE
CULTURES: TRANSLATION AND LINGUISTIC VALIDATION OF THE
IPAQ
Arnold BJ1, Kimel M2, Goddard A3, McCormack J2, Parks-Vernizzi E1, Dhar J1, Pleil A4
1
FACIT.org Translations, Elmhurst, IL, USA; 2United BioSource Corporation, Bethesda, MD,
USA; 3Pfizer Ltd, Sandwich, Kent, UK; 4Pfizer Inc, San Diego, CA, USA
OBJECTIVES: Translation and linguistic validation of patient reported outcomes
(PRO) measures is an essential component of research methodology in preparation
A381
for multinational clinical trials. The Injection Pen Assessment Questionnaire (IPAQ)
is a dyadic (parent and child together) or self-report of ease of use and preference tool
that allows objective and normative comparisons across and between injection pens
used to administer human growth hormone (hGH). The purpose of this work was to
translate and linguistically validate the IPAQ, which was developed in English in the
United States, for use in 7 countries: Czech Republic, Germany, The Netherlands,
Slovakia, Sweden, Turkey and United Kingdom. METHODS: The IPAQ was translated according to industry standard methodology. Five parent-child dyads (children
8 to 18 years old) per country completed the respective translated questionnaire and
participated in a cognitive interview. Interviews were conducted using a standardized
guide to assess the relevance, understandability, and appropriateness of the wording
of the translations. Qualitative analyses were performed to ensure equivalence and
that the content validity of the IPAQ was maintained across language versions.
RESULTS: The study sample consisted of 35 parent-child dyads who use injection
devices to administer hGH (42.8% male). Mean age of the children was 12 years. The
sample consisted of patients who speak 7 languages collectively. All IPAQ items were
well understood and proved relevant to the patients in this sample. Of interest, terms
such as, “cartridge”, “needle guard” and “injecting the medicine” were understood
similarly by participants across countries. CONCLUSIONS: The results indicate the
IPAQ translations were conceptually equivalent to the English source version and
easily understood by the target population in all countries. We consider these translations acceptable for PRO assessment in international research, clinical practice and
clinical trials.
PIH36
PATIENT SATISFACTION WITH FOLLITROPIN ALFA PREFILLED PEN IN
WOMEN UNDERGOING OVARIAN STIMULATION: ELABORATION AND
VALIDATION OF VENUSF QUESTIONNAIRE
Espallardo O1, Ruiz-Balda J2, Carrera M2, Caballero J3, Polanco C1, Bruna I4, Hernández
C5, Cuadrado C6, Carrillo E7, Ordóñez D7, García-Velasco J8, Serna J8, Galera F9, Zafra
J10, Caballero P11, Hernández E3, Fuente A12
1
Merck Serono, Madrid, Spain; 2Hospital Universitario Doce de Octubre, Madrid, Spain;
3
Clínica FIV, Madrid, Spain; 4Hospital de Madrid Montepríncipe, Madrid, Spain; 5Fundación
Jiménez Díaz, Madrid, Spain; 6Hospital Universitario La Paz, Madrid, Spain; 7Hospital Ruber
Internacional, Madrid, Spain; 8IVI Madrid, Madrid, Spain; 9Instituto Madrileño de Fertilidad,
Madrid, Spain; 10Hospital General Universitario Gregorio Marañón, Madrid, Spain; 11Clínica
Tambre, Madrid, Spain; 12Instituto Europeo de Fertilidad, Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: To elaborate and validate a questionnaire on patient satisfaction with
the follitropin alfa prefilled pen, compared with previously used injectable gonadotropins, in women undergoing ovarian stimulation. METHODS: VENUsf questionnaire
with 14 items was constructed after a four-stage process (concept identification and
item generation; item review by an expert on female infertility; patients interview; and
editing of questionnaire according to interviews results) in which both experts on
health outcomes research and fertility professionals and patients were involved. a
post-authorization observational study (non-randomised patients, national setting)
was undergone in order to validate the questionnaire. After assessing sample adequacy
(Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin index and Bartlett’s test of sphericity), Rasch analysis (infit and
outfit statistics) provided a reduced version of the questionnaire. Its psychometric
properties were assessed: feasibility (omitted response and time to fulfil it), variability
(floor and ceiling effects), validity (factor analysis and nonparametric tests) and reliability (Cronbach’s alpha). RESULTS: Initial questionnaire (14 items and 6 additional
questions) was answered by 91.1% of sample (n = 107) in an average of 5.04 minutes
(SD = 3.3). Statistical correlation was observed between scores from two dimensions
of questionnaire and overall treatment satisfaction, as well as variables Number of
previous treatments, Time since last treatment and Minutes required to prepare pen.
Rasch analyses yield 9 items in the final version of the questionnaire. This process was
confirmed by sample adequacy (KMO = 0.72, statistically significant value of Bartlett’s
test of sphericity) and reliability parameters (Cronbach’s alpha = 0.78). CONCLUSIONS: The reduced version of the questionnaire VENUsf a feasible, valid and reliable
tool for assessing patient satifaction with follitropin alfa prefilled pen in women
undergoing ovarian stimulation.
PIH37
DISPENSED MEDICATIONS LABELING IN MALAYSIA: VIEWS FROM
GENERAL PUBLIC
Al-Haddad M, Hassali MA
Universiti Sains Malaysia, Penang, Malaysia
OBJECTIVES: To assess the perceptions of the general public in Malaysia about the
importance of drug labeling. METHODS: A cross sectional study using pre-validated
questionnaire was undertaken with a convenient sample of general public in the State
of Penang, Malaysia. All data was analyzed using SPSS for Windows version 12.0.
Inferential statistics were used whenever appropriate at alpha value of 0.05 or less
considered significant. RESULTS: A total of 365 respondents had participated in the
survey. Majority of them agreed that drug labeling is important to any person dispensing medicines (74.8%), caretakers (76.26%), health care professionals (77.8%) and
patients (80.6%). Besides, they believed that it is important to ensure all drug labels
are not vaguely claimed to improve quality of life (54.2%). Majority of respondents
agreed that incorrect dosage instructions on the drug label would result in worsening
the quality of life (73.2%). Majority of respondents (58.4%) believed that drug labeling is highly important to ensure safe and effective drug use. Majority also expected
that all drug products and controlled medicines should be labeled with product name
(97.5%), active ingredients (78%), date of manufacture and expiry (87%), and dosage
A382
(95%). From their past experience, 21% of them mentioned that they seldom get their
drugs labeled whereas 14% of the total respondents were not sure whether they get
their drugs labeled or not. In this study, gender, age, and level of education showed
significant associations with most responses (P < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: General
public in Malaysia are aware about the importance of drug labeling and about one
fifth of the population surveyed rarely receive their medicines labeled appropriately.
Therefore, decision makers have to strictly enforce the existing drug labeling requirements for dispensed medications.
PIH38
STUDY OF THE DEGREE OF SATISFACTION OF PATIENTS WITH
URINARY DISORDERS, EVOCATIVE OF BPH
Perrin P1, Auges M2, Taieb C2
1
Lyon Sud, Pierre Benite, France; 2PFSA, Boulogne, France
OBJECTIVES: Patient satisfaction, in response to a treatment, is an element of the
medical service rendered. We quantified the satisfaction of patients treated medically
for urinary disorders. METHODS: A pragmatic cohort (France, Italy, and Portugal)
of 420 patients treated with Serenoa Repens, α-blocker or 5 α-reductase inhibitor,
was followed-up for 6 months. RESULTS: A total of 175 patients were evaluated.
Satisfaction was expressed as the differential between the expectation of the patients
recorded before the start of treatment and the status declared at 6 months. In addition
a binary (yes/no) question regarding general satisfaction was used as the primary
evaluation criterion. We observed positive satisfaction in 61.7% of subjects in terms
of the “effort or force needed to start urinating”, 51.1% for the “size and force of
the stream of urine”, 54.35% for “sensation of not emptying the bladder after urinating”, 52.38% for “interrupting the flow”, and 50% for the “need to urinate”. We
observed negative satisfaction in 68.18% of subjects with respect to the progression
of “getting up in the night to urinate”. At 6 months, the response to the general
satisfaction question confirms these initial results—indeed, nearly 98% of subjects
were satisfied with the treatment of their BPH. We did not see any significant difference
between the 3 treatment groups. CONCLUSIONS: The individualised expectation of
the patient will undoubtedly be one of the major preoccupations of the next few
decades. Medical treatment for BPH is accompanied by a satisfaction that is compatible with long term compliance with the treatment by the patient.
PIH39
PATIENTS WITH URINARY DISORDERS, EVOCATIVE OF BPH WHAT
ARE THEIR EXPECTATIONS?
Taieb C1, Auges M1, Perrin P2
1
PFSA, Boulogne, France; 2Lyon Sud, Pierre Benite, France
OBJECTIVES: The individualised expectations of the patient will undoubtedly be one
of the major preoccupations in the next few decades to guarantee optimal treatment
through compliance. METHODS: A pragmatic, European cohort (France, Italy, and
Portugal) of 420 patients presenting with urinary disorders, evocative of BPH, was
followed-up over 6 months. a questionnaire regarding expectations was handed out
at the first consultation. RESULTS: A total of 317 patients were evaluated. The
symptoms that 30.7% of patients wished to see improved with the highest priority
were “getting up in the night to urinate”, then for slightly less than 20%, “sensation
of not emptying the bladder after urinating”. Amongst the symptoms that patients
were the least concerned about were “the effort or force needed to start urinating”
for 23% of responders, then “the interruption of the flow of urine” for 16% and the
“size and force of the stream of urine”. “Getting up in the night” was the principal
complaint in all 3 countries (39% in France, 26 and 25% in Italy and Portugal), similarly “the effort or force needed to start urinating” is the symptom that preoccupies
the patients the least in France and Italy, the “size and force of the stream of urine”
preoccupies the Portuguese the least. Nearly 90% of the Italians claimed that they
would only be satisfied if they never had to get up in the night again, (35% for the
French, 50% for the Portuguese). Overall, 60% of the subjects questioned said that
they would be satisfied if they were “markedly” improved. CONCLUSIONS: The
expectation of patients in the treatment of BPH is very important, and undoubtedly
difficult to satisfy entirely. These results are probably due to the fact that our population was composed of patients that had been diagnosed recently.
PIH40
METHODOLOGICAL CONSIDERATIONS WHEN ASSESSING WORK
PRODUCTIVITY (WP) AND ACTIVITIES OF DAILY LIVING (ADL)
OUTCOMES IN MULTINATIONAL CLINICAL TRIALS IN WOMEN WITH
HEAVY AND/OR PROLONGED MENSTRUAL BLEEDING (HPMB)
TREATED WITH ESTRADIOL VALERATE/DIENOGEST (E2V/DNG)
Wasiak R1, Filonenko A2, Stull DE1, Kreif N1, Raluy M1, Ryan J3, Jeddi M4, Uhl-Hochgräber
K2, Vanness D5
1
United BioSource Corporation, London, UK; 2Bayer Schering Pharma AG, Berlin, Germany;
3
Bayer Plc, Newbury, UK; 4Bayer Inc., Toronto, ON, Canada; 5University of Wisconsin
School of Medicine and Public Health, Madison, WI, USA
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the effect of E2V/DNG, an oral contraceptive, on WP
(presenteeism) and ADL outcomes in HPMB sufferers using an appropriate analytical
strategy. METHODS: This was a post-hoc analysis of patient-reported outcomes from
two multicenter, randomized, placebo-controlled trials in North America and Europe/
Australia that evaluated the efficacy of E2V/DNG in women with HPMB. Data were
collected using a modified Work Productivity and Activities Impairment questionnaire.
WP and ADL outcomes were measured on a 10-point Likert scale. The analytical
13th Euro Abstracts
strategy was developed to determine and apply the most appropriate statistical methodology given the data and methodological challenges, including highly-skewed, incomplete, multi-country data, unbalanced enrolment across countries, and the auto-regressive
nature of the outcomes. The analyses progressed from descriptive statistics to Bayesian
regression in several sequential steps. The underlying model chosen for Bayesian analyses
was simultaneous equation modeling to incorporate temporal aspects and potential
cross-country heterogeneity. RESULTS: The data set included 416 patients (E2V/DNG,
n = 265; placebo, n = 151) across 12 countries. In all analytical approaches, E2V/DNG
vs. placebo treatment showed significantly positive effects on WP and ADL at a magnitude of a one-point change on the Likert scale (based on linear regression analysis). In
Bayesian analyses, Gamma distribution yielded a better model fit (DIC = 2129.01 vs.
2460.12 for normal distribution [presenteeism] and DIC = 2313.33 vs. 2640.36 [ADL]).
The average treatment effect on presenteeism for Gamma distributed models was −0.82
(95%CI: −1.37, −0.34) at treatment day 84 and −1.06 (95%CI: −1.67, −0.56) at treatment end (EOT; day 196). The average treatment effect on ADL was −1.07 (95%CI:
−1.70, −0.52) at day 84 and −1.09 (95%CI: −1.63, −0.62) at EOT. CONCLUSIONS:
E2V/DNG has a statistically significant and positive impact on presenteeism and ADL
impairment. The robustness of these findings was confirmed by the application of several
methodological approaches, with Bayesian analyses appropriately dealing with identified
methodological challenges.
PIH41
USE OF QUALITATIVE RESEARCH TO IDENTIFY DETERMINANTS OF
PERSISTENCE FOR ANTI-OSTEOPOROTIC TREATMENTS
Alegre P1, Arnould B2, Spizak C2, Marrel A2
1
Science Union et cie (Servier), Suresnes, France; 2Mapi Values, Lyon, France
OBJECTIVES: A large proportion of patients are non-adherent to anti-osteoporotic
treatments within 12 months of initiation. In the health psychology literature, several
behavioural models have been developed to explain non-adherence, most notably the
Health Belief Model (HBM). Based on these, our study aimed to explore determinants
of persistence (i.e., continuation) with anti-osteoporotic treatments. METHODS: A
psychologist carried out face-to-face interviews with patients who had taken antiosteoporotic treatment for 2 years. Interviews were based on a guide including questions on beliefs and experiences with osteoporosis and its treatment. Saturation was
reached with 16 patients providing over 95% of information. Content analysis of
interview transcripts was performed to highlight criteria that determine intentions
regarding treatment continuation. RESULTS: Through patient interview analysis,
determinants with an effect on persistence were categorized either as barriers or facilitators. While general health behaviour was identified in both type of determinants,
barriers to persistence included: Disease perceived as non-severe (“osteoporosis is not
a severe disease, perhaps not a disease at all”); Treatment side-effects (“there are
side-effects, I suffer from allergies, I am hesitant to take treatment”) and Constraints
(“you have to take treatment every day”; “you have to wait 2 hours after dinner before
taking treatment”). Facilitators included: Perceived benefits (“my treatment works,
bone mineral density results are good”); Habit/maintenance (“I take my treatment
because I am used to it, I do not question it”) and Relationship with doctor (“I have
confidence in my doctor”). CONCLUSIONS: Results are consistent with the health
psychology models, in particular the HBM. They add new concepts to HBM. Results
suggest that areas for improvement in persistence in osteoporosis lay in beliefs about
disease and treatment efficacy, rather than treatment convenience.
PIH42
THE USE OF PATIENT-REPORTED OUTCOME MEASURES FOR DRUG
APPROVAL IN KOREA
Park IS, Lee EK
SookMyung Women’s University, Seoul, South Korea
OBJECTIVES: Patient-Reported Outcomes(PRO) is the information on treatment
evaluations that comes directly from a patient. PRO is derived from every endpoint
from patient reports. These reports have been recorded in a patient diary or other
reporting systems. PRO is an important tool for measuring the impact of diseases,
treatments, health and social polices like pharmacoeconomic polices. The objective of
this study is to determine the level and nature of the use of PRO compared to other
endpoints for Korea’s approved new drugs. METHODS: A survey has been conducted
for 121 newly approved products in Korea during the period of 2005 to 2009. Different survey forms were prepared for each product. Each survey form provided
information on products and clinical trials: title, objectives, types of endpoints, types
of PRO and the information on PRO sent by e-mail to the manager of each pharmaceutical company. RESULTS: Primary endpoints were measured in 200 clinical trials
whereas secondary endpoints were measured in 183 clinical trials. The two both
studied 111 products. For PRO, a primary endpoint was reported in 33(14.6%) trials
and a secondary has been reported in 66(25.1%) trials. For Clinician-reported outcomes, the figures were 104(46.0%) and 108(41.1%), respectively. For Laboratory/
device endpoints, the figures were 89(39%) and 89(33.7%), respectively. For 11
products, PROs have been used as the only type of endpoint. About 40 percent of
PROs have been used as primary and secondary endpoints in clinical trials for drug
approval during the last five years(2005~2009). However, the results of the PRO
secondary endpoints have not been reflected in product labeling. CONCLUSIONS:
PRO has been used as a useful endpoint that can be employed in clinical trials for the
development and evaluation of new drugs. Therefore, it is necessary to develop PRO
instruments and guidelines to evaluate Korean patients’ PRO for Koreans and clinical
trials at home.
A383
13th Euro Abstracts
PIH43
USE OF QUALITY-ADJUSTED LIFE-YEARS FOR THE ESTIMATION OF
EFFECTIVENESS OF SCREENING PROGRAMMES: A SYSTEMATIC
REVIEW
Aäklin S1, Räsänen P2, Laitinen R1, Kovanen N1, Autti-Rämö I3, Sintonen H4, Roine RP5
1
National Institute for Health and Welfare (THL), Helsinki, Finland; 2Helsinki and Uusimaa
Hospital Group, Group Administration and National Institute for Health and Welfare (THL),
Helsinki, Finland; 3The Social Insurance Institution, Helsinki, Finland; 4University of Helsinki,
Dept. of Public Health and National Institute for Health and Welfare, Helsinki, Finland;
5
Helsinki and Uusimaa Hospital Group, Helsinki, Finland
OBJECTIVES: To identify and characterise studies that have used quality-adjusted
life-years (QALYs) based on actual measurements of patients’ health-related quality
of life (HRQoL) as an indicator of effectiveness of screening programmes. METHODS:
Systematic search of the literature until March 2010, using several electronic databases. Initial screening of articles was based on abstracts, and evaluation of full-text
articles was done independently by at least two of the authors. The final inclusion
decision was based on consensus. RESULTS: The search identified 1610 articles. The
use of QALYs in evaluation of screening programmes has expanded in recent years
as 617 of the articles had been published between 2007 and 2010, while the corresponding figure between 1966 and 2010 was 993. Based on review of abstracts, 431
full-text articles were obtained for closer inspection. Of the reviewed full-text articles,
78 reported QALYs based on patient-derived data using a valid HRQoL assessment.
The most frequently used method was Time Trade-Off (55%) followed by Standard
Gamble (21%) and EQ-5D (26%). The most frequently studied medical conditions
were malignant diseases (22%) followed by cardiovascular diseases (19%). The majority of the studies came from the USA (46%) or the UK (27%). All studies employed
some kind of modelling with the Markov model being the most prevalent type (62%).
Most articles (71%) concluded that the screening programme studied was cost-effective. Most of the studies included in the review were of high quality, but there were
still a lot of variation as to which outcome measures were chosen, and only few studies
reported incremental analysis. CONCLUSIONS: The use of QALYs in the evaluation
of cost-effectiveness of screening programmes has expanded during the last few years.
However, only a minority of studies have employed actual patient- derived HRQoL
data.
PIH44
THE INFLUENCE OF INDIVIDUAL FACTORS ON PELVIC PAIN AND
QUALITY OF LIFE IN ENDOMETRIOSIS
Koppán Á1, Oehmke F2, Hámori J1, Kriszbacher I1, Vranics I1, Garai J1, Bódis J1, Boncz I1,
Tinneberg HR2, Koppán M1
1
University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary; 2University of Giessen, Gießen, Germany
OBJECTIVES: The aim of the study was to assess potential individual factors influencing the efficacy of combined surgical and medical therapy, as well as quality of life
and pain scores in endometriosis patients with pelvic pain. METHODS: In a prospective study we used a specifically designed questionnaire among patients suffering from
persistent pelvic pain and undergoing laparoscopy followed by GnRH analogue
therapy. The questionnaire gathered information on the following groups of variables:
age, marital status, education, reproductive and medical history including previous
pregnancies and parity, knowledge of accompanying pelvic disorders, regular sport
activity, concurrent cigarette smoking, as well as general quality of life estimates
including self-image. Pelvic pain was scored using a visual analogue scale. RESULTS:
Eighty-one patients were eligible and willing to participate by filling out the questionnaires before surgery and upon completing medical therapy. After cessation of therapy,
53.0% of patients reported absence of pain. Among these, 11.6% were smokers,
corresponding to 35.7% of all smokers in the study. However, 56.7% of non-smoker
participants reported a positive outcome that proved to be significantly larger than
the ratio of pain-free smoker participants (p = 0.02). Improvement in quality of life
was reported by 73.7% of all patients, and only 9.4% of them were smokers. Fourteen
patients among regular exercisers and 33 patients among those without physical activity reported the effectiveness of painkillers for pelvic pain, corresponding to 45,1%
and 66% of these subgroups, respectively (P < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: Based on our
results, we can conclude, that regular smoking might have a disadvantageous impact
on the success rate of combined surgical and medical therapy for endometriosis related
pelvic pain. Also, it appears that painkillers might be less effective among endometriosis patients performing regular daily sport activities, and, thus it might impose them
to an unnecessary burden of possible side effects.
PIH45
HEALTH-RELATED QUALITY OF LIFE (HRQOL) OF FERTILE WOMEN
USERS OF CONTRACEPTIVE METHODS
Perulero N1, Roset M1, Gómez MÁ2, Dueñas JL3, Lete I4, Lertxundi R5, Pérez-Campos E6,
de la Viuda E7, Sánchez-Borrego R8
1
IMS Health, Barcelona, Spain; 2Centro de Planificación Familiar, Alicante, Spain; 3Hospital
Universitario Virgen Macarena, Sevillaý, Spain; 4Hospital Santiago Apóstol, Vitoria, Spain;
5
Clínica Euskalduna, Bilbao, Spain; 6Hospital General de Requena, Valencia, Spain; 7Hospital
Universitario de Guadalajara, Guadalajara, Spain; 8Clínica Diatros, Barcelona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Women’s choices of contraceptive method are largely affected by the
safety and efficacy of contraceptive methods as well as by change in women’s quality
of life. The SEC-QoL questionnaire has been recently elaborated and validated in
fertile women users of contraceptive methods in Spanish population. METHODS:
Observational, prospective, multicenter study involving 41 contraceptive gynaecolo-
gist and GPs. Three patients’ groups were identified at baseline visit: 1) Fertile women
users of efficacy contraceptive methods; 2) Fertile women users of non-efficacy contraceptive methods but will begin to use efficacy contraceptive methods; 3) Fertile
women user of non efficacy contraceptive methods. All women were ≥18 years. Follow
up and final visit was at 4 month since baseline visit. Socio-demographic and clinical
information was gathered. The specific questionnaire SEC-QoL (19 items) was administered. RESULTS: A total of 453 women were included. Mean (SD) age was 29.3
(7.7). The most frequently used contraceptive methods were: pill (43% A), inconsistent
condom (79% B and 63% C). The factorial analysis confirmed a total of 5 dimensions
(social/daily activities, menstrual and breast symptoms, psychological and sexual
dimension). HRQoL according to SEC-QoL score was higher (better HRQoL) in
group a (59.2) than in group B (46.6) and C (49.8) (P < 0.01). Considering a and B
groups, HRQoL (SEC-QoL total score) was better in women with low bleeding
intensity, low pain, and low androgenic and breast symptoms (P < 0.01). No differences were shown according to days between menstrual intervals. Hormonal contraceptive method users showed better HRQoL (61.2) than women using other method
(53.3) (P < 0.05). Both, in group a and B an increase in HRQoL was shown in the
final visit, being statistically significant in all dimensions of SEC-QoL questionnaire
in Group B (P < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: SEC-QoL is a valid and reliable specific
measure to assess HRQOL in fertile women users of contraceptive methods, in routine
clinical practice and clinical studies.
PIH46
A SUBJECTIVE APPROACH TO FACTORS INFLUENCING RECOVERY
AMONG MEN WHO ARE ACTIVE IN THE LABOR MARKET
Benkő B, Tancsics D, Boncz I, Kriszbacher I, Rébék-Nagy G, Warta V, Éliás Z
University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: The survey was meant to find out how much importance males attribute to various factors including patients’ compliance, faith and financial resources,
physicians’ expertise and personality, nurses’ attitudes, relatives’ and God’s help and
the appropriate medication. Another major aim was to reveal any possible differences
between males’ and females’ attitudes to the factors listed and any gender specific
differences in the evaluation of individual factors and their relationship with background variables such as health as a value, past major disease or operation, subjective
health status, age, education. METHODS: In the non-randomised research quantitative approach was used to investigate males’ personal opinions concerning recovery.
The cross-sectional examination included a survey administered in three workplaces.
The target population included employees 18–65 years of age. There were 188 questionnaires distributed of which n = 147 were assessable, which included n = 73
completed by males. RESULTS: There was a significant difference concerning the
importance attributed to relatives’ (p = 0.000,), faith (p = 0.005) and God’s help (p =
0.005). Males considered the role of these factors as less important. Those judging
their own health status very bad or quite bad thought that financial resources would
have a great impact on recovery. This opinion was significantly characteristic among
males with lower levels of education. Physicians’ personality was regarded as less
important by males than by females. CONCLUSIONS: There was no significant difference detected between the two genders with regard to the priority order of the
examined factors including patients’ compliance, physicians’ expertise and patients’
financial resources. Age proved to have a strong influence on evaluating the different
factors.
INDIVIDUAL’S HEALTH – Health Care Use & Policy Studies
PIH47
LONG-TERM EFFECTS OF CHILDREN PNEUMOCOCCUS VACCINATION:
AN AGENT BASED APPROACH
Zauner G1, Miksch F2, Popper N1, Endel G3, Schiller-Frühwirth I3, Breitenecker F2
1
Dwh Simulation Services, Vienna, Austria; 2Vienna University of Technology, Vienna, Austria;
3
Main Association of Austrian Social Security Institutions, Vienna, Austria
OBJECTIVES: Dynamical modeling and simulation of the epidemical influence of
infant immunization with PCV7 against pneumococci induced serious disease and time
depending behavior of carrying rates of the pathogens in nasopharynx using an agent
based approach. METHODS: The implemented strategy is a multi agent based model
approach with detailed implementation of individual social contacts and direct person
to person transmission of the pneumococcal bacteria. To test the influence of different
vaccination strategies and the induced non linear effects like herd immunity effects
and serotype replacement, strongly influencing the over all effectiveness, additional
assumptions are made. Instead of 90 known pneumococcal pathogens only 2 relevant
classes are modeled: the serotypes included in the vaccine and others. The dynamic
model is simulated over a long period (25 years) to find out long term effects for stability tests. Additionally population dynamics are integrated because of their influence
on long time behavior. Induced change in the demographic shape of the population
combined with knowledge of different carrier rates depending on the persons age lead
to extra effects on immunization. RESULTS: For standard immunization program
implementation as advocated by EPAR/EMEA the direct influence of the immunization
including herd immunity and serotype replacement is measured. For basic simulation
runs with realistic parameters for Austria a decrease of 30% of serious diseases is
measured. Results for serotype replacement (40–60%) are calculated. In contradiction
to other modeling methods this values are dynamically generated by the simulation
and no input parameters. CONCLUSIONS: Agent based modeling leads to detailed
A384
information on behavior of the pathogen distribution for all age groups and their
changes over time and is thereby a real extension to classical static decision tree based
methods in HTA. The used validated simulation system is dealing with transparent
parameters and is better understandable for decision makers in HTA.
PIH48
ANTIDEPRESSANT PRESCRIBING TO PATIENTS AGED 18 YEARS AND
YOUNGER: A PHARMACOEPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDY
Truter I
Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University (NMMU), Port Elizabeth, Eastern Cape, South
Africa
OBJECTIVES: Antidepressants carry an increased risk of suicidality in children,
adolescents and young adults. The primary aim was to determine antidepressant
prescribing and cost to patients aged 18 years and younger in a South African private
health care sector patient population. METHODS: A retrospective, cross-sectional
pharmacoepidemiological study was undertaken on prescription data of a private
pharmacy group in South Africa for 2009. The study focused on antidepressant prescribing. No diagnoses were available. a total of 814540 antidepressants were prescribed, of which 12549 were prescribed to patients aged 18 years or younger.
RESULTS: A total of 4269 patients (53.74% females) received an average of 2.94 (SD
= 3.31) antidepressants over the year. The total cost of antidepressant prescribing was
R1 581480, with an average cost of R126.02 per product (item). Two-thirds (66.67%)
of antidepressants were prescribed to patients from 12 to 18 years of age. Selective
serotonin re-uptake inhibitors (SSRIs) accounted for 55.91% of antidepressant prescribing, followed by tricyclic antidepressants (32.32%), together accounting for
79.49% of antidepressant cost. Lithium was only prescribed to 1.04% of patients in
this age group. The highest average cost was for serotonin and noradrenaline re-uptake
inhibitors (R322.94 per product), selective mono-amine oxidase inhibitors (R177.20)
and SSRIs (R155.52). Tablets were the preferred dosage form. The most frequently
prescribed active ingredients were imipramine (19.77%), escitalopram (14.60%),
citalopram (14.09%) and fluoxetine (13.92%), together accounting for 62.38% of
prescribing frequency. CONCLUSIONS: Diagnoses were not available, therefore only
prescribing trends could be investigated. Fluoxetine generally has a favourable riskbenefit balance (prescribed “off label”), yet it only had a prescribing frequency of
13.92% in this study. Active ingredients such as escitalopram and citalopram are not
preferable in this age group. The risk of prescribing antidepressants in children,
adolescents and young adults should be balanced against the clinical need.
PIH49
PRESCRIBING PATTERNS OF SELECTIVE SEROTONIN RE-UPTAKE
INHIBITORS AND SELECTIVE SEROTONIN AND NORADRENALINE
RE-UPTAKE INHIBITORS IN CHILDREN AND ADOLESCENTS IN A
SOUTH AFRICAN PRIVATE PRACTICE SETTING
Van Schalkwyk K, Truter I
Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University (NMMU), Port Elizabeth, Eastern Cape, South
Africa
OBJECTIVES: There has been much controversy over the prescribing of selective
serotonin re-uptake inhibitors (SSRIs) and selective serotonin and noradrenaline reuptake inhibitors (SNRIs) regarding their safety and efficacy in patients younger than
19 years with limited guidelines to prescribers from South African authorities. The
primary aim was to investigate the prescribing patterns of SSRIs and SNRIs to children
and adolescents, younger than 19 years, in a primary practice setting in a South
African patient population. METHODS: Data from 2009 of patients younger than
19 years who were prescribed antidepressants belonging to a private medical aid
scheme were retrospectively analyzed. RESULTS: There were 440 patients younger
than 19 years receiving antidepressant drugs accounting for 6.20% of patients of any
age receiving antidepressant therapy. SSRIs and SNRIs were prescribed to 50.68% of
these patients. Female patients were prescribed SSRIs and SNRIs most frequently
(62.33%). The average age of patients was 14.21 (SD = 3.05) years while the majority
of patients were older than 12 years (77.13%). Fluoxetine was prescribed most frequently (36.50%), followed by citalopram (22.14%) and escitalopram (17.15%). The
total cost of SSRIs and SNRIs amounted to R81201.69. Escitalopram accounted for
30.28% of the cost while fluoxetine only accounted for 11.11% of the cost. Venlafaxine accounted for 6.32% of prescriptions although being contraindicated in this
patient population. Paroxetine accounted for 5.96% of prescriptions although its use
is not recommended due to possible suicidality side effects. a total of 72.65% of
patients received drug therapy for less than 6 months while 41.26% of patients
received a single prescription for an SSRI or SNRI. General practitioners prescribed
67.76% of prescriptions while psychiatrists only prescribed 14.96%. CONCLUSIONS: The prescribing of these agents to children and adolescents needs to be further
investigated using retrospective data which include clinical information and studies
conducted over a longer time period.
PIH50
MATERNAL MORTALITY RATE IN INDIA: A COMPREHENSIVE
LITERATURE REVIEW
Guri S, Kumar J, Saini P, Ghasolia D
JRDS ePharma Health Pvt Ltd, Dehli, India
OBJECTIVES: Maternal mortality rate in India: a comprehensive literature review.
METHODS: Information was retrieved from websites of World Health Organization,
Pubmed and grey literature retrieved using key terms like maternal mortality, MMR
13th Euro Abstracts
etc. The relevant prevalence data were extracted and compiled. RESULTS: The maternal mortality rate (MMR) is maternal death per 100,000 live births in one year. WHO
estimates show that out of the 529,000 maternal deaths globally each year,
136,000(25.7%) are contributed by India. According to registrar general of India
estimates for the year 2000, MMR for India was 407/100,000 live births. The trend
has not changed significantly in the last 5 years. In the Armed Forces the scenario is
very encouraging with a MMR of 36 per 100,000 live births. In 1980, India reported
about 677 maternal deaths per 1, 00,000 live births but in 2008, this was down to
254 deaths. MMR has reduced by 4% a year since 1990. High MMR was reported
in Hindu (573) than Muslims (384) and in Illiterate people (574) (1994). India has
climbed from bottom to 127th place in the MMR ratings, above Pakistan and just
below Nepal. Hemorrhage (25.6–38%) ranks first as the cause of maternal death,
followed by anemia (14–24%) sepsis (13–16%), toxemia of pregnancy (11.9%), abortions (8–9%) and obstructed labor (6.2–10%) while other causes together total
35.3%. Tamil Nadu has taken initiatives to improve maternal health services leading
to reduction in maternal mortality from 380 in 1993 to 90 in 2007 due to increased
rate of institutional deliveries from 20% in 1971 to 97.7% in 2007. CONCLUSIONS:
A consistent decline in the maternal mortality rate has been observed in India but it
attributes to a few states. Initiatives need to be taken by government in regard to
proper facility in hospitals, efficient supply of blood, and iron containing medicines.
PIH51
AN ESTIMATE OF COSTS AND BENEFITS OF ALTERNATIVE METHODS
OF DELIVERY: AN EMPIRICAL ANALYSIS IN AN ITALIAN HOSPITAL
Pizzo E
Imperial College London, London, UK
OBJECTIVES: The recent large increase in caesarean sections (CSs) in Europe seems
not to be completely justified: CS is practiced independently of epidemiological evidence. This work analyzes costs and benefits effectively involved in alternative
methods of delivery- vaginal delivery (VD), with and without epidural analgesia, and
planned caesarean. METHODS: The empirical analysis has been conducted in an
Italian University hospital, through direct collection of data, questionnaires and interviews to patients and staff. a logistic regression has been used to model the probability
of the event “delivery with planned caesarean section” occurring as a function of a
set of clinical and socio-economic characteristics of the women. a micro–costing
analysis has been used to assess the direct health costs, following an activity–based
costing approach. From a societal perspective we consider also the indirect and the
intangible costs of each method. Patients’ wellbeing is measured through appropriate
anonymous instruments—the State-Trait Anxiety Inventory, the Italian Questionnaire
of Pain and the Childbirth Perception Questionnaire- to measure the changes in clinical
and psychological dimensions due to the delivery experience. RESULTS: The results
confirm the hypothesis that CS is widely performed for non-medical reasons (Osborn,
1995). The analysis shows that CS is, on average, more expensive than VD, but the
difference is marginal if we take into account the opportunity-cost of labour time.
CONCLUSIONS: Since CS is generally reimbursed more than VD to cover the supposed higher costs of surgery, differences between the real costs and the DRG tariffs
may induce opportunistic behaviour in terms of clinical practice. We show that, in
general, VD with analgesia provides better results both in terms of costs and, but the
final effect of its introduction is not clear: it may reduce the frequency of inappropriate
caesarean sections, but it may also increase the costs due to complications
PIH52
EVALUATING THE PERCEPTION OF HOSPITAL PHARMACIST TOWARD
THEIR CURRENT CLINICAL ROLE IN HEALTH CARE SYSTEM OF
PAKISTAN
Azhar S1, Hassali A2, Izham M1
1
Universiti Sains Malaysia, Penang, Malaysia; 2Discipline of Social & Administrative Pharmacy,
Universiti Sains Malaysia, Pinang, Palau Pinang, Malaysia
OBJECTIVES: To investigate hospital pharmacists’ perception towards their current
clinical role in Pakistan’s health care system. METHODS: The study population
consisted of hospital pharmacists from three cities of Punjab, Pakistan; Islamabad,
Faisalabad and Lahore. a sample of 116 hospital pharmacists was selected from
government hospitals from these three cities. RESULTS: At least 77.6% of the hospital
pharmacists involved in patient counseling in Pakistan. Although they are willing to
take personal responsibility to resolving any drug related problem but pharmacist (n
= 98, 84.5%) conveyed that their current role is more focusing towards the record
keeping of hospital pharmacy. Only (n = 67, 57.8%) of the pharmacist expressed that
they are involve in making and designing of hospital formulary. In this case significant
difference was noted with respect to age (p = 0.020) and gender (p = 0.056).As far as
experience with other health care profession is concern, only (n = 60, 51.7%) of the
respondents were agreed of having collaborative relationship with other health care
professional. Moreover only (n = 65, 56.0%) of the hospital pharmacist agreed regarding their suggestion taken into consideration by physician. CONCLUSIONS: The
findings suggest that the hospital pharmacists in Pakistan do have concerns about their
present professional role but they are facing significant barriers in terms of increasing
clinical services. Moreover, pharmacists need to be proactive in collaboration with
other health care professionals. This paves the way for the concept of pharmaceutical
care in health care system of Pakistan.
13th Euro Abstracts
PIH53
DO HIGH-INCOME GROUPS IN PAKISTAN UNDERSTAND THE
CONCEPT OF GENERIC MEDICINES?
Jamshed SQ1, Hassali MA1, Ibrahim MIM1, Shafie AA1, Babar ZUD2
1
Universiti Sains Malaysia, Minden, Penang, Malaysia; 2University of Auckland, Auckland,
Malaysia
OBJECTIVES: High income groups in Pakistan resort to private health care settings
for consultations and treatment modalities but only 5% of them have Social Health
insurance coverage. As 77% of medicine expenditures are out-of-pocket payments in
Pakistan, it is imperative to assess the understanding, perception, and attitude of this
privileged group towards cost-effective alternatives. METHODS: In order to have an
in depth evaluation of the issue qualitative methodology was adopted. a combination
of purposive and snowball sampling was used to conduct face-to-face semi-structured
interviews, which were then audio-taped, and transcribed verbatim. As sample size in
qualitative research revolves around the attainment of point of saturation, no new
themes emerged after the interview of 8 respondents. RESULTS: Thematic content
analysis identified four major themes; appropriate knowledge of generic medicines,
negative perception towards generic medicines, negative attitude towards generic
medicines, and future recommendations which should be directed towards the maintenance of quality and efficacy of generic alternatives. Interestingly, all the respondents
managed to explain generic medicines with reference to patent expiry. Regarding
perception all of them expressed negative views and considered quality and safety as
questionable domains in generic medicines. All the respondents cited negative concerns
towards generic medicine utilization and harbored the notion that “low cost relates
compromised quality.” Majority of the respondents expressed that future strategies
should be directed towards educated high income group to build confidence for generics and this should be possible until and unless the local manufacturers in Pakistan
make themselves compliant with WHO Good Manufacturing Practices (GMP). CONCLUSIONS: The respondents showed excellent understanding towards generic medicines. They exhibited negative concerns and attitudes towards generic medicine
utilization. Still there is room for improvement, provided the confidence is built in
consumers regarding generic medicines quality and efficacy, which in turn will pave
the way for their quality utilization.
PIH54
METFORMIN FOR THE TREATMENT OF CHILDHOOD OBESITY: A
SYSTEMATIC REVIEW AND META-ANALYSIS
Bouza C, Gutierrez L, Lopez-Cuadrado T
Instituto de Salud Carlos III, Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Childhood obesity associates with significant morbidity and premature
death; its prevalence has increased greatly during the past three decades; and it is
recognized as a worldwide public health problem. However, the efficacy of treatments
for childhood obesity remains unclear. In recent years the use of metformin, an insulin
sensitizer, has aroused a great interest for the treatment of obesity in adults. Our aim
was to assess the efficacy and safety of metformin for childhood obesity. METHODS:
Systematic review of literature and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials in
obese subjects age ≤19 years without diabetes or other morbidities. Structured electronic searches of published studies until March 2010 were performed. Changes in
the Body Mass Index (BMI) were considered our main outcome measure of efficacy
whereas metabolic parameters such as insulin levels, glucose, HOMA, lipid profile and
leptin levels were considered as secondary outcomes. Safety parameters included
adverse events and losses from adverse effects. Individual studies were graded using
published methodologies. Pooled estimates of effect and confidence intervals were
derived using a fixed effects model and tested for heterogeneity. Consistency across
studies was evaluated by means of the I-square statistic. RESULTS: Seven trials met
the inclusion criteria. All trials compared metformin with placebo and used behavioural co-interventions. Average follow-up was six months. Though with small sample
sizes, methodological quality of trials was adequate. Meta-analysis showed that compared to placebo, metformin provided a significant decrease in BMI (−1.90 (−3,−.8).
No statistical significant differences were found in secondary outcomes. Main adverse
effects were digestive, no serious adverse events were reported. CONCLUSIONS:
Available evidence suggests that, added to behavioural interventions, metformin is a
relatively safe and effective treatment for childhood obesity in the short term. Further
research with longer follow-up periods is needed to solve this important health issue.
Partially supported by Spanish National I+D Program.
PIH55
BPH PATIENTS TREATED WITH PHYTOTHERAPY: RESULTS AT 6
MONTHS
Perrin P1, Auges M2, Taieb C2
1
Lyon Sud, Pierre Benite, France; 2PFSA, Boulogne, France
OBJECTIVES: Assess the impact of the treatment of urinary disorders of the lower
urinary tract related to benign prostatic hypertrophy (BPH) using medical treatment
under actual conditions of use. METHODS: A pragmatic cohort of 420 patients
treated medically, was followed up for 6 months, using several validated questionnaires: IPSS, MSF4, and SF12. RESULTS: 267 patients treated with Serenoa Repens
were evaluated, the mean age was 64.3 ± 8.6 years, and on average the diagnosis had
been made 18 months previously. At 6 weeks, the IPSS was significantly improved in
this group (P < 0.0001). This improvement in the IPSS score between 6 weeks (11.98
± 5.11) and inclusion (14.58 ± 5.65) was 2.6 points. An improvement was also
observed at 3 months. At 6 months, the p-value was also significant (P < 0.0001). The
improvement in the IPSS score between 6 months (8.20 ± 4.12) and inclusion (14.65
A385
± 7.01) was 6.6 points. The physical dimension (50.97 ± 6.45 at inclusion) of the SF12
improved significantly (P < 0.001) from the 6th week (52.63 ± 5.20), an improvement
that was confirmed at 6 months (53.21 ± 5.16) (P < 0.001) in comparison with inclusion (49.09 ± 6.58). The mental dimension (50.9 ± 7.04 at inclusion) of the SF12
improved significantly (P < 0.001) from the 6th week (52.16 ± 7.31), an improvement
that was confirmed between 5.45 and 6 months (52.50 ± 6.69) (P < 0.001) in comparison with inclusion (47.09 ± 10.82). The MSF4 was unchanged. CONCLUSIONS:
We observed an improvement in the IPSS score from the 6th week; this statistical
improvement was confirmed by a significant clinical improvement in the 6th month.
This favourable progression is consistent with the improvement observed for both
dimensions of the SF12.
PIH56
COMPARATIVE PRICING AND REIMBURSEMENT ANALYSIS BETWEEN
BULGARIA AND THE CZECH REPUBLIC
Peev S1, Petrikova A2, Petrova G1, Stoimenova A1
1
Medical University Sofia, Faculty of Pharmacy, Sofia, Bulgaria; 2VFU Brno, Brno, Czech
Republic
OBJECTIVES: Comparison of regulatory rules and procedures for pricing and reimbursement of pharmaceuticals between Bulgaria and the Czech Republic (CR).
METHODS: Medicine laws, health insurance laws, corresponding regulations stating
the pricing and reimbursement procedures were reviewed. Special emphasis was
devoted to the requirements for pharmacoeconomic evidences in the procedures.
RESULTS: Both countries apply the reference pricing system for prescription medicines and the CR is among the 8 reference countries for Bulgaria, while the opposite
is not the case. In Bulgaria the lowest reference price for ex-factory price setting is
used, while the CR employs the average among the three lowest prices. There is also
a regressive margin scale in both countries applied. In Bulgaria margins are stated for
wholesalers and retailers separately, while in the CR they are negotiated between
wholesalers and retailers. In both countries health insurance is obligatory. In the CR
there are 11 insurance companies and in Bulgaria—only one fund. In Bulgaria reimbursement is in the form of positive drugs lists. For reimbursement of pharmaceuticals
in the CR a complex external and internal referencing is employed and evaluation of
innovativeness is necessary. There are 111 internal therapeutic groups defined at the
4th ATC level (e.g. statins). The reimbursement base is set as the cheapest price of
medicine in the group in all 27 EU countries. There is a bonus of maximum 30% if
a medicine shows superiority. In Bulgaria the reimbursement level is defined as the
cheapest price per DDD for every INN. Both countries require pharmacoeconomic
evidences, but there are guidelines in the CR, while Bulgaria applies only criteria for
evaluation. CONCLUSIONS: We consider the Czech system more flexible and providing freedom for the manufacturers and distributors due to its negotiating practice and
therapeutic level of reimbursement, but the process is more prolonged.
PIH57
CHALLENGES IN THE ADHERENCE AND ADOPTION OF
INTERNATIONAL GUIDELINES: A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW OF THE
ADHERENCE TO THE HEALTH CARE INFECTION CONTROL
PRACTICES ADVISORY COMMITTEE (HICPAC) GUIDELINES FOR THE
APPROPRIATE USE OF VANCOMYCIN IN CHILDREN
Bouza C, Lopez-Cuadrado T, Saz-Parkinson Z
Instituto de Salud Carlos III, Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: One of the most pressing problems faced by health care services is the
increasing prevalence of antimicrobial resistance to vancomycin, an important antimicrobial for the treatment of infections caused by gram-positive pathogens in the
severely ill patient. Inappropriate use of vancomycin encompasses serious public health
consequences linked to the development of resistant species. In 1995, the HICPAC
developed guidelines that delineated specific criteria for appropriate vancomycin use
to reduce the improper use of antimicrobials and improve patient safety. Our aim was
to evaluate and summarize the level of compliance of clinical practices with the
HICPAC guidelines by assessing the appropriateness of vancomycin therapy for hospitalized critically ill children. METHODS: Systematic review of literature (Jan 1996Feb 2010) and meta-analysis of studies performed in subjects aged 0–18 years.
Structured electronic and manual searches were performed. The main outcome
measure was the proportion of vancomycin prescribed appropriately according to the
HICPAC guidelines. Appropriate/inappropriate uses were subdivided into several categories. Summary rate ratios and confidence intervals were estimated using a fixed
effects model and tested for heterogeneity. Furthermore, we explored the potential
reasons for non-adherence to guidelines. RESULTS: From 24 candidate studies, 13
publications met the inclusion criteria. Meta-analysis showed that in only 21% of
patients (95%CI: 18%–23%), vancomycin prescribing and dispensing practices were
consistent with the recommendations. Non-adherence to HICPAC guidelines included
surgical prophylaxis, empirical use and length of therapy. Lack of awareness, lack of
agreement, lack of outcome expectancy and inertia of previous practice, emerge as
specific reasons for non-adherence. CONCLUSIONS: This study reveals that adherence to international guidelines is far from optimal with a variety of potential barriers
that undermine the process. Because physician adherence is critical in translating
recommendations into improved outcomes, there is an urgent need for strategies aimed
at improving physician compliance with guidelines to optimize antibiotics utilization.
Supported by the Spanish National I+D Program (STPY 1346/09).
A386
INDIVIDUAL’S HEALTH – Conceptual Papers & Research on Methods
PIH58
HEALTH AND ECONOMY: A GOVERNMENTAL PERSPECTIVE,
NATIONAL ACCOUNTING MODEL FOR ASSESSING INVESTMENTS IN
ROTAVIRUS VACCINATION
Connolly M1, Schey C1, Standaert B2
1
Global Market Access Solutions, St Prex, Switzerland; 2GlaxoSmithKline Biologicals, Wavre,
Belgium
OBJECTIVES: The WHO repeatedly stresses the importance of human capital and
investing in health as a determinant of future economic growth. We describe a health
care investment model that reflects the government perspective attributed to investing
in rotavirus vaccination in Egypt, and how changes in morbidity and mortality influence government expenditure (education, health, allowances) over many generations.
METHODS: The model applies a generational accounting approach for estimating
the inter-temporal fiscal impact of policy changes. It accounts for direct fiscal transfers
between age cohorts and the State during different life stages—childhood, school-age,
working-age, and retirement—while simultaneously accounting for rotavirus medical
costs, and how rotavirus mortality and morbidity influence government fiscal transfers. Costs are expressed in Egyptian Pounds (EGP; 1c = 7EGP). The model is constructed using Egyptian life tables, rotavirus related and unrelated health care costs,
employment earnings adjusted for age and social parameters. The model compares
vaccinated and unvaccinated cohorts against rotavirus using discounted net tax revenues (gross taxes—transfers). RESULTS: Based on variations in rotavirus vaccine
price, the model predicts health service savings mostly attributable to averting rotavirus treatment costs that could be achieved within 3–5 years and reaching EGP178
million obtained at year-5. The discounted net tax revenue between vaccinated and
unvaccinated cohorts was EGP5.2 billion and EGP27.3 billion at year 25 and 50,
respectively. Investing in rotavirus vaccination represented a 15% rate of return for
government at year-50. Long-term government net tax revenues were insensitive to
vaccine prices, although sensitive in short-term. CONCLUSIONS: Health investment
models are complementary to conventional economic evaluations of health care technologies. But they illuminate how government accounts, tax revenues, and expenditures are influenced by investing in health care programs. Investing in rotavirus
vaccination could deliver early cost-offsets associated with reduced health care expenditure. It could increase future government net tax revenue attributed to lives saved.
PIH59
PUBLIC HEALTH ECONOMICS—AN EMERGENT SUBDISCIPLINE?
1
2
3
3
Ehlers L , Kruse M , Højgaard B , Søgaard J
1
Health Economics & Management, Institute of Business Studies, Aalborg University,
Denmark, Aalborg, Denmark; 2Centre for Applied Health Services Research, University of
Southern Denmark, Odense, Denmark; 3DSI Danish Institute for health services Research,
Copenhagen, Denmark
BACKGROUND: Are we witnessing the beginning of the development of a new subdiscipline of health economics? The purpose of the paper is to outline the main theoretical arguments for the establishment of a new research tradition on “public health
economics” combining public economics with health economics. METHODS: The
results from a systematic literature search in PubMed and NHSEED on the term
“public health economics” were presented and discussed at a workshop at the Danish
public health conference in Nyborg September 22, 2009. Among the invited participants were health economists, public health researchers, HTA-advisors, econometricians, and decision makers. RESULTS: Three main theoretical arguments were
identified: 1) There is a need for developing new methods for the economic evaluation
of public health interventions. 2) Economic evaluation of health care may be seriously
misleading if public health research is ignored. 3) The entire health economic research
tradition may benefit from encompassing a more socioeconomic model of health.
CONCLUSIONS: There is limited tradition yet for health economists and researches
within public health to work together and meet regularly, no scientific journal specifically oriented towards public health economics, and no textbook in health economics
that include research from all these related areas. Thus, the research environment is
to some extent characterised by lack of cooperation, which may constitute an obstacle
for the development of a consistent and coherent line of economic research in the field
of public health.
PIH60
ESTIMATING THE CROSS-SECTIONAL NUMBER AND GESTATIONAL
AGE AT BIRTH DISTRIBUTION OF INFANTS FOR ECONOMIC AND
HEALTH IMPACT ANALYSIS
Myers ER1, Misurski DA2, Swamy GK1
1
Duke University, Durham, NC, USA; 2GlaxoSmithKline, Philadelphia, PA, USA
OBJECTIVES: In order to estimate the size of the population of infants at risk for
seasonal influenza because of ineligibility for vaccination, we developed a method for
estimating the cross-sectional number of infants under 6 months of age at any point
in time. METHODS: Data on the monthly number of deliveries at gestational ages
23–42 weeks for 2006 (the most recent available) from from publicly accessible birth
certificate data from the US National Center for Health Statistics (NCHS) were used.
The number of deliveries at each gestational age each calendar week were derived
based on the number of days in each month. Conditional probabilities for survival for
each week after birth were derived from the linked birth and death certificate data set
from 2006 for each gestational age. The number of infants younger than 6 months
13th Euro Abstracts
with a given gestational age at birth at any point in time was calculated using the
following formula: Number of infants (gestational age) born (current week) + Number
of infants (gestational age) born (current week-1)*1 week survival (gestational age)
+ . . . Number of infants (gestational age) born (current week-25)*26 week survival
These results were then summed for gestational ages 23–42 weeks to obtain the total
number of infants. Separate calculations were performed for single pregnancies, twins,
and higher order multiples. RESULTS: In 2006, the average number of infants 0–6
months of age in any given week was 1.98 million, with seasonal variation reflecting
seasonal variability in deliveries. CONCLUSIONS: Estimates of the number of infants
within a given age range alive at a given point in time can be derived from routinely
collected administrative data. These estimates, together with estimates of the number
of pregnant women, can be used for evaluation of interventions targeting pregnant
women and infants.
PIH61
CALIBRATION OF A DISCRETE EVENT SIMULATION MODEL OF
NATURAL HISTORY OF HPV-RELATED DISEASES
Quon P1, Vanness DJ1, Kansal A1, Hillemanns P2, Remy V3, Quilici S3
1
United BioSource Corporation, Bethesda, MD, USA; 2Hannover Medical School, Hanover,
Germany; 3Sanofi Pasteur MSD, Lyon, France
OBJECTIVES: Develop a mathematical model simulating the clinical and economic
impact of different cervical cancer screening options for German females alongside
HPV vaccination. METHODS: We developed a discrete event simulation (DES)
model, describing the natural history of cervical cancer and genital warts for five
categories of HPV types (HPV 16, 18, 6/11, other high risk and other low risk). To
fit German epidemiological data, we manually calibrated model parameters for natural
history to match a number of calibration targets including genital warts incidence by
age, cervical cancer incidence and mortality by age, prevalence of HPV type by age,
and distribution of HPV types by disease stage. The model also calibrates against
prevalence of CIN by age as reported in previous HPV disease models. The fit of model
outputs to calibration targets was represented by a calibration score computed using
normalized residuals weighted by the quality of the available data (e.g., prioritizing
epidemiological data over model results). Our model employs lognormal distributions
for time to progression and two-piece exponential distributions for time to regression,
enabling us to simulate the long separation in peak times between HPV infection,
cervical cancer precursors and cancer incidence. RESULTS: Predicted type-specific
HPV-prevalence and disease incidence are close to epidemiological data. HPV prevalence differed from reported prevalence by <1.55% for each 5 year age group for HPV
16, 18, and other high risk HPV. The model predicted genital warts incidence of 159
per 100,000 (target: 167), cervical cancer incidence of 17.7 per 100,000 (target: 15.5),
cervical cancer mortality incidence of 4.3 per 100,000 (target: 4.1), and agreed well
with incidence age distributions. CONCLUSIONS: We developed an individual-based,
fully calibrated model that is ready for cost-effectiveness analysis of cervical cancer
vaccination and screening strategies. Time-to-event distributions, an inherent feature
of DES, facilitate realistic modelling of disease progression.
PIH62
ESTIMATING THE CROSS-SECTIONAL NUMBER AND GESTATIONAL
AGE DISTRIBUTION OF PREGNANT WOMEN FOR ECONOMIC
ANALYSIS
Myers ER1, Misurski DA2, Swamy GK1
1
Duke University, Durham, NC, USA; 2GlaxoSmithKline, Philadelphia, PA, USA
OBJECTIVE: To develop a method for estimating the cross-sectional number of
pregnant women, distributed by gestational age for cost-effectiveness and budget
impact analysis. METHODS: We obtained data on the monthly number of deliveries
at gestational ages 20–42 weeks for years 2003 through 2006 (the most recent available) from publicly accessible birth certificate data from the US National Center for
Health Statistics (NCHS). Estimates of the number of deliveries at each gestational
age each week were derived based on the number of days in each month, under the
assumption that deliveries were randomly distributed throughout the month. Cohorts
of women who became pregnant during the same calendar week were constructed
using the following formula: Deliveries at 20 weeks (calendar week X) + Deliveries at
21 weeks (calendar week X+1) +. . . . Deliveries at 42 weeks (calendar week X+22).
This procedure was repeated for each week from January 2003 through July 2006.
Estimates of the number of pregnancies between 6 and 20 weeks were generated by
applying gestational age-specific loss rates from a large prospective cohort study of
early pregnancy. RESULTS: Over the 3.5 year period, there were approximately 2.5
million pregnant women ranging from 6 to 42 weeks gestational age in the US; the
mean weekly number increased from 2.5 to 2.6 between 2003 and 2006. There was
also substantial seasonal variation in singleton pregnancies, with the highest number
of pregnant women observed in March and April of each year, but no seasonal variation in multiple gestations. CONCLUSIONS: Routinely collected data on births allows
estimation of the number of pregnant women at any point in time. Such data, in
conjunction with estimates of probabilities of delivery and pregnancy and neonatal
complications, can be useful for cost-effectiveness and budget impact analyses of
interventions during pregnancy.
A387
13th Euro Abstracts
PIH63
TURKISH CULTURAL ADAPTATION AND VALIDATION OF GLASGOW
HEALTH STATUS INVENTORY
Oksuz E, Malhan S, Tekin R, Yilmaz F, Baytar S
Baskent University, Ankara, Turkey
OBJECTIVES: The Glasgow Health Status Inventory, (GHSI) measures the effect of
a health problem on the quality of life of a person and allows cross-comparison among
many health conditions, among different health interventions, and among demographic and cultural subgroups. The GHSI contains 18 health status questions, which
ask specific questions about how the health problem has affected their quality of life.
This study aims to adapt the GHSI into Turkish culture and check the reliability and
validity of the inventory culturally. METHODS: The original instrument was translated and back translated by two independent translators. a small sample consisting
of 40 people was used to check the initial comprehension and factibility. Cronbach’s
Alfa was used to assess reliability and factor analysis to assess dimensionality. The
EuroQol questionnaire and corresponding Visual Analogue Scales were used for
concurrent validity. RESULTS: A total of 163 people participated in this study. 52%
of them were female, 48% of them were male. Mean age was 24.3. The internal
consistency coefficient (Cronbach’s alpha) of GHSI was 0.86. Factor analysis of the
scale revealed that it was composed of four factors with Eigenvalues >1.0, accounting
for 62.2 % of the total variance. Correlations were moderate with EuroQol and VAS.
CONCLUSIONS: The culturally adapted GHSI has good validity and reliability,
making it a potentially useful outcome measure in the determining the effect of health
problems on the quality of life of people in Turkey.
PIH64
A CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK FOR A PATIENT REPORTED
OUTCOMES MEASURE OF ATTITUDES TOWARD COMPLEMENTARY
AND ALTERNATIVE MEDICINE IN MENOPAUSE
Bunsiriluck S, Williamson EM, Donyai P
Reading University, Reading, UK
OBJECTIVES: Menopause may cause hot flashes, night sweats, mood swings and
other symptoms. Although hormone replacement therapy (HRT) is prescribed in
severe cases, it is not suitable for all women, and increasing numbers of women refuse
or discontinue HRT because of side effects, or real or perceived health risks. The use
of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) in menopause has been increasing,
with women perceiving CAM as safer than HRT, but this is not supported by clinical
evidence. Biased decisions occur when an individual’s cognition is affected by factors
that include attitudes, preferences, and moods. Cognitive bias affecting women’s
perception of CAM can impact on decisions and ultimately CAM usage in the menopause. Yet, no validated questionnaire exists to measure attitudes towards CAM in
menopause, in line with accepted patient reported outcome (PRO) methodology. Our
aim was to develop a conceptual framework of attitudes to CAM in the menopause
to inform the development of a PRO tool. METHODS: A systematic review of the
literature was conducted April-May 2010 using Medline and PsycINFO databases
with the MESH terms attitude, menopause, complementary therapy, and perception.
a total of 122 papers were retrieved, with 91 excluded on the basis of abstract review
and 13 after full-text analysis, resulting in 19 studies suitable for inclusion. The papers
were analyzed in line with qualitative review methodology to produce a number of
themes that were later grouped together to produce the dominant categories.
RESULTS: A conceptual framework was developed to reflect attitudes to CAM in the
menopause. The dominant categories of perception related to menopausal symptoms,
optimism about CAM, pessimism about HRT, cure-control with CAM, and relationship with physician. CONCLUSIONS: This research has identified key domains relevant to women’s attitudes towards CAM in the menopause, from which a relevant
PRO instrument could be developed.
PIH65
USING A GENERALIZED ADDITIVE MODEL TO EXAMINE THE
RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN BODY MASS INDEX AND HEALTH-RELATED
QUALITY OF LIFE IN THE ELDERLY POPULATION—RESULTS FROM
THE POPULATION-BASED GERMAN KORA-AGE STUDY
Hunger M, Thorand B, Döring A, Peters A, Schunk M, Holle R
Helmholtz Zentrum München—German Research Center for Environmental Health
(GmbH), Neuherberg, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Numerous cross-sectional studies reported that high body mass index
(BMI) is associated with poorer health-related quality of life (HRQL), while only few
studies also provide evidence for impaired HRQL in underweight individuals. Our
objective was to investigate the nonlinear relationship between BMI and HRQL in an
elderly general population sample using semiparametric regression methods.
METHODS: We analyzed data from 4562 individuals aged 65 years or older, living
in the region of Augsburg, Southern Germany. The data come from the KORA-Age
study which is based on a postal follow-up of individuals who participated in the
population-based MONICA/KORA surveys S1-S4. Health-related quality of life was
measured using the German EQ-5D index. For our multivariable regression analyses,
we used a generalized additive model (GAM) to estimate the functional form of the
relationship between BMI and HRQL after adjusting for confounding factors.
RESULTS: We found a significant nonlinear (inverse U-shaped) relationship between
BMI and HRQL after adjusting for gender, age, sociodemographic factors and comorbid conditions. The maximum HRQL was observed at a BMI of about 25 kg/m2. Our
estimates indicate that going from a BMI of 25 to 35 is associated with a EQ-5D
utility loss of about 5.2 units (corresponding to 0.28 of standard deviation). On the
other hand, underweight individuals with a BMI of 18 had an average impairment of
5.8 units compared to a BMI of 25. Subgroup analyses showed that the inverse
U-shaped relationship is more pronounced in individuals ≥75 years than in individuals
aged 65–74 years. In particular, the effect of low BMI on HRQL is more important
in the older age group. CONCLUSIONS: Generalized additive models are an adequate
method to estimate the nonlinear relationship between BMI and HRQL in the elderly
population. With increasing age, low BMI has similar impairments in HRQL as
overweight.
PIH66
IDENTIFYING APPROPRIATE COMPARISON GROUPS IN GLOBAL
PREGNANCY REGISTRIES
Albano JD1, Roberts SS2, Brown VD3
1
Kendle International Inc., Durham, NC, USA; 2University of North Carolina, Wilmington,
Wilmington, NC, USA; 3Kendle International Inc., Wimington, NC, USA
BACKGROUND: Pregnancy exposure registries are valuable for studying the teratogenicity of drugs used in the post-marketing setting. However, their limited sample
size and potential for selection bias can make data interpretation challenging. While
enrolling an internal comparison group is ideal, this is often not feasible. To ease these
limitations, pregnancy registries commonly use a population-based background rate
as the primary comparison group. OBJECTIVES: The objectives of this research are
to evaluate appropriate population-based birth defect surveillance systems, cohorts,
and other studies from a variety of geographic areas and to systematically assess their
utility as a comparison group for global pregnancy exposure registries. RESULTS:
Among the 14 studies evaluated, study designs include observational cohort studies,
case control studies, population-based surveillance registries, and population-based
active surveillance systems. Catchment areas are somewhat diverse geographically and
range in scope from a metropolitan city, single state/province, or individual country,
to multi-national/multi-continental networks of organizations contributing to a single
data source. All identified studies have been ongoing for at least a decade. Studies
range in size from several thousand participants in total to more than 1 million participants enrolled annually. Data reporters vary and include patients, physicians, and
other health care personnel. Some studies ascertain infant outcome and birth defect
status at the time of birth only, while others involve pediatricians and include followup for one to several years. CONCLUSIONS: There are many potential sources of
comparison data for overall birth defect rates; however, the sources vary greatly in
design, data collection methods, birth defect coding systems, clinical review procedures, and equation for calculating birth defect prevalence rate. Utilizing a populationbased background rate can be useful, but care should be taken in selecting an
appropriate comparison group. The differences between the individual pregnancy
registry and the population-based comparator should be evaluated and recognized.
NEUROLOGICAL DISORDERS – Clinical Outcomes Studies
PND1
INDIRECT COMPARISON OF ADVERSE EVENTS AND DROPOUT RATES
FOR EARLY PARKINSON’S DISEASE (PD) MONOTHERAPY TRIALS:
PRAMIPEXOLE, ROPINIROLE AND RASAGILINE
Zagmutt FJ1, Tarrants ML2
1
Vose Consulting, Boulder, CO, USA; 2Teva Pharmaceuticals, Kansas City, MO, USA
OBJECTIVES: Pramipexole, Rasagiline, and Ropinirole are approved for monotherapy in early PD. Understanding the comparative safety profiles of these products can
be important information to choose an optimal therapy. As no direct comparisons of
the safety profile of these products are available, our objective was to perform an
indirect comparison of Adverse Events (AEs) and Dropout Rates (DRs). METHODS:
Articles were selected and reviewed via Cochrane Guidelines. Placebo-controlled randomized clinical trials were eligible for review. Data collected for analysis included
total AEs, Cognitive, Gastrointestinal (GI), and Sleep/Fatigue AE categories and
dropout rates. We used indirect meta-analysis to calculate the pooled Relative Risk
(RR) of each product against placebo, and then used pairwise comparisons. Frequentist and Bayesian methods were used to compare sensitivity of findings. RESULTS:
208 studies were identified and reviewed, 6 were determined eligible via established
criterion. The RRs and [95%CIs] from the fixed-effects model for Rasagiline, Pramipexole, and Ropinirole respectively were total AEs: .97 [.87, 1.07], 1.05 [1.00, 1.1],
1.07 [1.00, 1.14]; Cognitive: .78 [.43, 1.44], 5.56 [2.35, 13.13], 1.56 [.83, 2.94]; GI:
.9 [.49, 1.63], 2.00 [1.57, 2.53], 2.43 [1.81, 3.27]; Sleep/Fatigue: .84 [.53, 1.35], 1.63
[1.35, 1.97], 3.24 [2.08, 5.05]; and DR: .60 [.39, .91], 1.01 [.66, 1.56], 1.77 [1.14,
2.76]. AEs were no worse than placebo for all Rasagiline AEs and for Ropinirole
cognitive AEs. DRs for Rasagiline were significantly lower than placebo. Rasagiline
had the lowest RRs with ≥90% confidence for all categories. Results were comparable
across statistical models tested. CONCLUSIONS: This indirect treatment comparison
suggests that subjects with early PD treated with Rasagiline have less risk for adverse
events and treatment dropouts than patients treated with Pramipexole or Ropinirole.
Ropinirole exhibits the highest risk for GI AEs, Sleep/Fatigue AEs and DRs, while the
risk for Cognitive AEs is higher for Pramipexole.
A388
PND2
THE INFLUENCE OF PARENTERAL NUTRITION ON THE PLASMA
PROTEIN BINDING OF THERAPEUTIC DRUGS
Salih M, Bahari MB, Abd AY, Shafie AA
Universiti Sains Malaysia, Minden, Penang, Malaysia
OBJECTIVES: Parenteral nutrition (PN) is used in various clinical situations.
However, some interactions might occur with drugs that are administered concurrently with PN. Therefore, this search reviews the potential interactions of PN with
therapeutic drugs (mainly antiepileptics), especially in respect to the plasma proteinbinding of the drug. METHODS: The articles related to the topic were identified
through the Medline and PubMed. Full text of the articles were then traced from the
Universiti Sains Malaysia (USM) library subscribed databases, including Wiley-Blackwell Library, Cochrane Library, EBSCOHost, OVID, ScienceDirect, SAGE Premier,
Scopus, SpringerLINK, and Wiley InterScience. The articles from journals not listed
by USM library were traced through inter library loan. RESULTS: There were interactions between PN and drugs, including antiepileptics. Several guidelines were designed
for the management of illnesses such as traumatic brain injuries or cancer patients,
involving the use of PN and antiepileptics. Moreover, many studies demonstrated the
in vitro and in vivo PN-drugs interactions, especially with antiepileptics. CONCLUSIONS: Alteration in the drug-free fraction result from PN-drug (i.e. antiepileptics)
interactions may necessitate scrupulous reassessment of drug dosages in patients
receiving these therapies. This reassessment may be particularly imperative in certain
clinical situations characterized by hypoalbuminemia (e.g., burn patients).
PND3
EFFICACY AND TOLERABILITY OF INTERFERON-BETA IN ALL TYPE OF
MULTIPLE SCLEROSIS
Nikfar S1, Abdollahi M2, Rahimi R3
1
Faculty of Pharmacy, Tehran University of Medical Sciences and Food & Drug Laboratory
Research Center, MOH, Tehran, Iran; 2Faculty of Pharmacy; and Pharmaceutical Sciences
Research Center, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran; 3Faculty of Traditional
Medicine, and Pharmaceutical Sciences Research Center, Tehran University of Medical
Sciences, Tehran, Iran
OBJECTIVES: The aim of this meta-analysis was to evaluate the efficacy and tolerability of IFN β for maintenance of remission in MS. METHODS: Pubmed, Scopus, and
Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials were searched for studies investigated
efficacy and/or tolerability of interferon β (IFN β) in MS. Data were collected from
1966 to 2009 (up to July). RESULTS: Nine randomized placebo controlled clinical
trials met our criteria and were included. Summary relative risk (RR) for at least one
relapse including all types of MS and all types of IFN β was 0.86, a significant RR
(95% CI: 0.76–0.97). Summary RR for at least one relapse in secondary progressive
MS (SPMS) patients received all types of IFN β was 1.11(95% CI: 0.79–1.55). RR
for at least one relapse in RRMS patients received all types of IFN β was 0.77(95%
CI: 0.57–1.05). RR for at least one relapse in SPMS patients received IFN β-1b was
0.93 (95% CI: 0.75–1.14). RR for at least one relapse in patients with all types of
MS received IFN β-1a was 0.97 (95% CI: 0.57–1.67) and for IFN β-1b was 0.92
(95% CI: 0.85–1). The summary RR for discontinuing because of adverse events in
nine trials was 2.76, a non-significant RR (95% CI: 1.97–3.89, P < 0.0001). The
summary RR death in three trials was 1.53 (95% CI: 0.45–5.15). RR for suicides or
suicide attempts in five trials was 0.86 (95% CI: 0.41–1.79). RR for different adverse
events of all types of IFN β comparing to placebo in all types of MS including flu-like
symptoms, injection site reactions, injection site inflammation, myalgia, leucopenia,
lymphopenia, increased alanine aminotransferase were significant except for depression that its RR was non-significant. CONCLUSIONS: It can be concluded that INF
β’s effectiveness in MS is dependent to administration of different kind of interferon
β and type of MS.
NEUROLOGICAL DISORDERS – Cost Studies
PND4
BUDGET IMPACT ANALYSIS OF NATALIZUMAB FOR MULTIPLE
SCLEROSIS TREATMENT IN BRAZIL: A 5-YEAR PROJECTION
Ferreira Da Silva AL1, Finkelsztejn A1, Ribeiro R2, Polanczyk CA1
1
Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul (UFRGS), Porto Alegre, Brazil; 2Hospital de Clínicas
de Porto Alegre, Porto Alegre, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: To estimate the annual and 5-year budgetary impact of including
natalizumab in the Brazilian public health care system drug formulary for the treatment of relapsing remitting multiple sclerosis (MS). METHODS: Brazilian public
health care system perspective was adopted. The baseline scenario comprised four
treatment options available in Brazil in the year 2009, and its corresponding market
shares: 1) interferon beta 1A intramuscular (23%); 2) interferon beta 1A subcutaneous
(32%); 3) interferon beta 1B (23%); and (4) glatiramer acetate (22%). Data were
retrieved from the Brazilian health system database. a claims data based approach was
used to estimate the baseline population size, which was estimated to be 6935 patients.
In addition to the base-case scenario, three alternative scenarios were created to
estimate the budgetary impact of including natalizumab to the drug formulary at 3
possible market shares: 3%, 10% or 22%. Costs for currently available treatments
comprised average purchase prices paid by the Brazilian government in 2009. The
adopted natalizumab dose cost was R$,652 (c1660), obtained from public data issued
by the Brazilian’s regulatory health agency (ANVISA). Costs were adjusted for 4%
13th Euro Abstracts
annual inflation. No discounts were considered. Sensitivity analysis was performed.
RESULTS: Base-case costs for treatment of MS within a 5-year period were
R$1280,698,041 (c582,135,473). Relative to this value, at 3% market share, the
inclusion of natalizumab produced a 6% (R$78,858,437/c35,844,744) increase in
expenditures. At 10% market share, the corresponding expenditures increased 9%
(R$108,902,983/c49,501,356). At 22% market share, there was an increase of 13%
in total costs with MS treatment (R$161,903,806/c73,592,639). CONCLUSIONS:
Entry of natalizumab into the market is likely to result in a significant increase in MS
treatment costs for the Brazilian health care system. However, this must be weighted
against the need for new treatment options as well as potential savings from better
disease control rates.
PND5
BUDGET-IMPACT MODEL TO TEST EFFECTS OF CHANGING
RUFINAMIDE TIER STATUS FROM A PAYER PERSPECTIVE
Powers A1, Faria C1, Buchner D1, Shaul A2, Cragin L3
1
Eisai, Inc., Woodcliff Lake, NJ, USA; 2United BioSource Corporation, Bethesda, MD, USA;
3
United BioSource Corporation, Lexington, MA, USA
OBJECTIVES: Lennox-Gastaut Syndrome (LGS) is an epileptic encephalopathy characterized by intractable seizures of many types. LGS has its onset in early childhood,
and often persists into adulthood. It is estimated that the prevalence of LGS among
children and adults with epilepsy is 6.5% and 1.5%, respectively. This budget impact
model was developed to help US payers make informed decisions regarding the addition of rufinamide for the management of LGS. To analyze overall budget impact of
changing rufinamide from tier 3 to tier 2 status for a large U.S. payer. METHODS:
The budget impact model was constructed based upon the indicated population for
rufinamide, which is children 4 years and older and adults (18+) requiring adjunctive
treatment of seizures associated with LGS. The model follows patients over three years
and estimates the direct health care costs associated with LGS treatment before and
after the introduction of rufinamide. The three main categories of data inputs informing the model include: plan population inputs, treated prevalence inputs, and treatment and cost inputs. The base-case model results are based on data derived from
published literature, publicly available data sources, or assumptions. The results are
presented as follows: total costs over 3 years, cost per member per year (PMPY), cost
per treated member per year (PTMPY), cost per member per month (PMPM), and
cost per treated member per month (PTMPM). RESULTS: Assuming a one million
member plan and a discount rate of 3% shifting rufinamide from tier 3 to tier 2
resulted in $1,001 in additional total costs over 3 years. This translates to a change
in a PTMPY of $1.00 and a PTMPM of $0.13. PMPY and PMPM were not notably
affected. CONCLUSIONS: Based on this analysis changing rufinamide from tier 3 to
tier 2 does not exhibit a significant cost increase.
PND6
VALUE OF BUDGET IMPACT ANALYSIS BASED ON EPIDEMIOLOGIC
DATA: INSIGHTS FROM MULTIPLE SCLEROSIS IN SAO PAULO, BRAZIL
Ferreira Da Silva AL1, Filkelsztejn A1, Ribeiro R2, Polanczyk CA1
1
Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul (UFRGS), Porto Alegre, Brazil; 2Hospital de Clínicas
de Porto Alegre, Porto Alegre, Brazil
BACKGROUND: Despite its relatively low prevalence in Brazil, multiple sclerosis (MS)
is responsible for significant health care expenditures for the public health care system.
OBJECTIVES: To compare actual MS treatment expenditures and expected expenditures
based on an epidemiological projection. METHODS: We retrieved actual treated prevalence and treatment costs from Brazil’s public health system database for the city of Sao
Paulo, in 2009. Then, current prevalence of MS for the city of Sao Paulo was estimated
based on the best epidemiological evidence available, a prevalence study conducted in
1997, which reported a prevalence of 15/100,000 inhabitants. Data were analyzed comparing actual and potential expenditure related to drug treatments, assuming that 85%
of prevalent cases comprised the relapsing form of MS. RESULTS: We retrieved the total
number of doses for each one of the available treatment options for MS in the city of São
Paulo for the year 2009 (interferon beta-1A, interferon beta-1B and glatiramer acetate).
Considering the expected number of doses required to treat one patient for one year with
each treatment option, we estimated the number of patients covered within one year of
treatment to be 1,319 patients. This corresponds to an estimated treated prevalence of
11.9 cases per 100,000 inhabitants, considering the estimated population for the year
2009 (11,037,593 inhabitants). Actual costs incurred for the city of Sao Paulo in 2009
with the treatment of MS were R$40,993,666/c18,633,484. Assuming a prevalence of
15/100,000 inhabitants, 1,666 cases of MS would be expected in the city, of which 1,416
would be relapsing MS. Their treatment would require R$43,811,800/c19,914,454.
CONCLUSIONS: There are marginal differences between treated and expected prevalence
of relapsing MS in the city of Sao Paulo. This indicates that local programs for MS
diagnosis and treatment are successful. Likewise, current budget impacted analyses based
on epidemiologic information seems accurate.
PND7
ECONOMIC IMPACT OF PERSISTENCE TO DISEASE MODIFYING
THERAPIES FOR THE TREATMENT OF MULTIPLE SCLEROSIS
Szkurhan AR1, Dembek C2, Malik S1, Agarwal SS2, Rajagopalan K2, Rashid N1
1
Dymaxium, Inc, Toronto, ON, Canada; 2Biogen Idec GmbH, Wellesley, MA, USA
OBJECTIVES: Multiple sclerosis (MS) is a chronic incurable disease with a progressive
course. Studies have demonstrated that disease progression can be slowed by treatment
with disease modifying therapies (DMTs). Poor DMT adherence is associated with a
13th Euro Abstracts
higher risk of relapse, lower quality of life and higher medical costs. The adherence
measure, persistency, refers to the duration a patient continues with therapy. This
study aims to evaluate the non-pharmacy medical costs associated with the persistency
of DMT’s in patients with MS. METHODS: A decision-analytic model was designed
using persistency rates, health care resource use and costs from the published literature. The model evaluated the medical costs associated with the persistence, switching,
and discontinuation rates of patients on interferon β1a IM, interferon β1b SC, and
interferon β1a SC over a 2-year time horizon. Using 6-month intervals in the model,
patients could switch to a comparator treatment, discontinue treatment, or persist/
remain on their current treatment, and would incur the non-pharmacy medical costs
associated with each. For patients who switched treatments, the model assumed an
equal probability of switching to the three remaining DMTs. The model also assumed
that patients who discontinued therapy would initiate on a different therapy after one
month of discontinuing. The overall medical costs related to persisting on treatment,
switching treatment or discontinuing treatment were calculated for all treatment arms.
RESULTS: Based on the results from the model, an annual per-patient medical cost
of $7423 was observed for interferon β1a IM patients, showing a medical cost advantage over patients on interferon β1b SC ($8144; 8.9%), and interferon β1a SC ($7552;
1.7%). CONCLUSIONS: MS is a lifelong disease that requires continuous treatment.
The results of this model show that interferon β1a IM is a cost-saving treatment for
the medical costs associated with MS patients on disease modifying therapies.
PND8
THE POTENTIAL COST IMPACT OF USING A PEG HYDROGEL
SEALANT COMPARED WITH FIBRIN SEALANT TO PREVENT CEREBRAL
SPINAL FLUID LEAKS AFTER CRANIAL SURGERY IN THE UK
Ott M1, Grieve J2, Larkin M3, Minshall M4
1
Covidien, Zurich, Switzerland; 2University College London, London, UK; 3PRMA Consulting,
Fleet, UK; 4Covidien, Fishers, IN, USA
OBJECTIVES: Cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) leak is an unavoidable consequence of
cranial surgery with leak rates between 0% to 25% and resulting costs ranging from
£9,000 to £36,000. The use of polyethylene glycol (PEG) hydrogel dural sealant as
an adjunct to sutured closure has been shown to reduce CSF leak rates as compared
with sutures alone in cranial procedures (GR Cosgrove et al, 2007). Our hypothetical
analysis applied the potential cost offsets of using PEG hydrogel sealant as an adjunct
to sutured closure in 200 cranial procedures assuming CSF leak rates of 4.5% (9/200)
(GR Cosgrove et al, 2007), compared with 10% (20/200) for fibrin sealant (JA Grotenhuis, 2005). METHODS: The incremental additional cost for treating CSF leaks
using total patient costs for those with CSF leaks (£25,253) compared to those without
CSF leaks (£10,497) was estimated at £14,756 in a Dutch study (JA Grotenhuis,
2005). We applied this CSF leak cost to estimate potential UK hospital cost offsets
on 200 hypothetical cranial patients using PEG hydrogel sealant (£300/treatment),
compared with fibrin sealant (£133/treatment) on all 200 patients. RESULTS: Use of
a PEG hydrogel sealant compared with fibrin sealant could potentially save £137,611
(or £688/patient) for a hospital that performed 200 cranial surgery procedures using
a PEG hydrogel sealant compared with using fibrin sealant on all 200 procedures.
CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrates the potential economic advantages of using
a PEG hydrogel sealant in cranial procedures. Future clinical direct comparative
studies would be beneficial to confirm these findings and understand the possible
economic advantages for other types of dural surgeries.
PND9
ASSESSMENT OF DISEASE BURDEN ASSOCIATED WITH EPILEPSY IN
HUNGARY, BASED ON A CROSS-SECTIONAL QUESTIONNAIRE SURVEY
OF 100 PATIENTS
Érsek K1, Mikudina B1, Arányi Z2, Juhos V3, Baji P1, Péntek M1, Brodszky V1, Gulácsi L1
1
Corvinus University of Budapest, Budapest, Hungary; 2Semmelweis University, Budapest,
Hungary; 3St. István and St. László Hospital, Budapest, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: Epilepsy is the second most frequent neurological disease among
adults; approximately 50–60 thousand people suffer from epilepsy in Hungary. With
our survey we aimed to assess the cost of illness from a societal viewpoint as well as
the quality of life associated with epilepsy in Hungary. METHODS: We conducted a
cross-sectional questionnaire survey of 100 consecutive patients in 2 epilepsy centres
in Hungary in collaboration with epilepsy specialists. The self-developed questionnaire
consisted of general and disease-specific parts to determine costs associated with
epilepsy. Questions related to basic demographic characteristics, disease progression
and health and social services used in the past 12 months, disease-associated nonmedical services, as well as the productivity losses of epilepsy. Two generic quality of
life questionnaires, EQ-5D and SF-36 were also used. RESULTS: A total number of
100 patients were assessed (60% female). The average age was 36.7 years (SD. 12.5),
average disease duration was 15 years (SD. 12). Quality of life calculations resulted
in mean of 0.83 (SD. 0.24) in EQ-5D, 74 (SD. 16) in VAS scale and 72.3 (SD. 20.2)
in SF-36. Cost-of-illness calculations were carried out and direct (15%) and indirect
costs (85%) were determined. The annual total cost of epilepsy per capita was estimated to be a mean of c5179 (SD. c10,822) with the human resource method, while
c2,552/capita/year (SD. 8659) by the friction cost method. CONCLUSIONS: Comparing the 100 patients’ data with data from previous EQ-5D based population-sample
survey shows that quality of life among people with epilepsy was lower than among
the average Hungarian population. We found significant correlation (at P < 0.05)
among all of the quality of life results and the yearly total costs (calculating both with
human capital and friction cost methods).
A389
PND10
LONG-TERM DISABILIY COST IN TUBEROUS SCLEROSIS COMPLEX
(TSC) IN BRAZIL
Valentim J
Novartis, Sao Paulo, SP, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: To estimate long-term disability costs associated with tuberous sclerosis complex, a rare multisystem genetic disease, in Brazil. METHODS: Literature
review for TSC long-term disability and economic burden was performed (Pubmed,
LILACS, SciELO, CRDs). Cost estimation was limited to epilepsy (most prevalent TSC
disorder). Cost of lost productivity in patients since epilepsy onset in childhood and
carried in adulthood as well as caregivers’ productivity costs were estimated. The
Human Capital Method was adopted and potential lost working years estimated till
an active age of 65 years. It was assumed a caregiver for all ages. Average income,
unemployment rate due to epilepsy, productivity growth and epidemiology data were
obtained from the literature and from the Brazilian Institute of Geography and Statistics. Mean annual productivity cost per patient, total productivity cost per patient
and the total productivity burden of TSC-related epilepsy were calculated. Costs were
estimated in 2008 Reals and discounted at 5%. Univariate sensitivity analysis was
conducted for epidemiology data, employment status rate, productivity growth, discount rate and time horizon. RESULTS: Productivity loss was 47, 30 and 65 years
for epilepsy onset in childhood and adulthood and caregivers, respectively. The discounted and not discounted mean annual productivity cost per patient were R$1,970
and R$11,323, total productivity cost per patient R$97,882 and R$691,150 and total
productivity burden of TSC-related epilepsy in Brazil R$1,568,965,961 and
R$11,078,536,271, respectively (1Euro = 3.24Reals). Results were sensitive to all the
parameters varied in the sensitivity analysis, especially discount rate. CONCLUSIONS: TSC-related epilepsy is a chronic disorder associated with loss of productivity
with a significant economic burden in Brazil. Although significant, the economic
burden related to productivity loss is expected to be even higher since there are still
costs deriving from absenteeism of patients and caregivers when employed looking for
health services to be included in further analysis.
PND11
NURSE COSTING SURVEY FOR THE MANAGEMENT OF ADVERSE
EVENTS IN PATIENTS WITH MULTIPLE SCLEROSIS TREATED WITH
DISEASE-MODIFYING DRUGS IN THE UK
Perard R, Parkes L
1
Merck Serono Limited, Feltham, UK
OBJECTIVES: To determine the costs and medical resource use for the management
of injection-site reactions (ISRs) and flu-like symptoms (FLS) associated with injectable
disease-modifying drugs (DMDs) used to treat patients with relapsing–remitting multiple sclerosis (RRMS) in the UK. METHODS: A survey was carried out amongst
NHS nurses to understand the management of adverse events occurring with injectable
DMD use. Data were collected via a postal questionnaire. Responses were compiled
for the frequency and duration of side-effects, support received and medical consultations required for adverse event management. The unit costs were derived from the
Personal Social Services Research Unit, the Office for National Statistics and the British
National Formulary. Once all parameters and unit prices were characterised with
conservative approaches for missing data (e.g. no GP consultation mandatory before
antibiotics prescription), computations were processed to determine means and standard deviations (SDs). RESULTS: In total, 19 NHS nurses managing significant
numbers of patients with MS for different primary care trusts participated in the
costing survey. On average, the nurses reported that patients experienced 27 ISRs per
year of those 33% experienced ISRs only at treatment start while 21% experienced
ISRs continuously during the year. Seventy-four percent experienced FLS only at
treatment start and 11% continuously. The average cost for the management of ISRs
per year was £187 (SD £209) equivalent to an average cost of £7 per event. The
average cost for the management of FLS per year was £166 (SD £144) equivalent to
an average cost of £6 per event. CONCLUSIONS: This is the first UK study to provide
data on the costs associated with management of ISRs and FLS occurring with injectable DMDs. These data, alongside prevalence estimates, enabled us to calculate the
costs of managing adverse events associated within DMDs in an economic model.
PND12
EUROPEAN-HUNTINGTON’S DISEASE BURDEN STUDY (EURO-HDB)—
PRELIMINARY RESULTS FOR ITALY AND FRANCE
Dorey J1, Toumi M2, Clay E1, Tedroff J3, Squitieri F4, De Nicola N4, Verny C5
1
Creativ Ceutical, Paris, France; 2University Claude Bernard Lyon 1, Lyon, France;
3
NEUROSEARCH, Ballerup, Denmark; 4Neurogenetics and Rare Disease Centre, Pozzilli,
Italy; 5Neurology Unit CHU, Angers, France
OBJECTIVES: Huntington’s disease (HD) is a rare neurodegenerative disease leading
to sustained disability and poor health-related quality of life (HRQOL). As new treatments are in development for HD, data on the burden of disease are required. This
study evaluated patient health status, patient and caregiver HRQoL and costs in HD.
METHODS: Euro-HDB is a European cross-sectional survey being conducted in eight
European countries. Self-reported questionnaires were completed by patients and caregivers. The patient questionnaire includes the Huntington Self-Assessment Instrument,
a specific tool that assesses clinical characteristics, HRQoL and health care resource
utilization. The EQ5D questionnaire and the SF36 Survey are also included. RESULTS:
To date, 201 patients have been enrolled in France and 124 in Italy.
All levels of disease severity are represented. Average annual costs from societal
A390
perspective are c5,325 (±9588), c18,045c (±34487) and c41,716 (±35211) at mild,
moderate and severe stages respectively in France; c3,125 (±4319), c8,457 (±18374)
and c5,069 (±11747) in Italy. Associated EQ-5D utilities are respectively 0.79 (±0.18),
0.39 (±0.37), −0.11 (±0.3) in France; 0.59 (±0.44), 0.39 (±0.42), 0.25 (±0.44) in Italy.
The primary cost driver is productivity loss. In France, hospitalization and nursing
home costs are the main components of direct costs. For more severely affected patients,
medical resource utilization diminishes while caregiver involvement increases significantly (the shift is greater in Italy than France). Physical, mental and social HRQoL
domains are all seriously affected. CONCLUSIONS: Euro-HDB is the first study to
comprehensively assess the cost and HRQOL burden of HD. The 1:5 cost ratio
(Italy : France) is consistent across most of the cost items, suggesting that differences in
health care systems, access to health care and cultural attitudes towards caring for
patients at home have a large impact on a country’s overall costs. Results suggest that
HD has greater impact on HRQOL than Parkinson’s disease and Alzheimer’s disease.
PND13
A PROSPECTIVE STUDY OF THE FINANCIAL COSTS OF MULTIPLE
SCLEROSIS AT DIFFERENT STAGES OF THE ILLNESS IN IRAN
Khanizadeh H1, Izham M1, Akmal A1, Nikkhah K2, Ebrahimzadeh S2, Moshiri Tabrizi H3
1
University Sains Malaysia, Penang, Malaysia; 2Mashhad University of Medical Sciences,
Mashhad, Khorasan, Iran; 3UKM, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
The economic burden of Multiple Sclerosis (MS) on society and the individuals concerned is not known. Documenting such costs is essential for several reasons: costs of
illness is a key factor of optimal disease management policies, knowledge of cost is
useful for allocating research and development. The aim of our study as the first
pharmacoeconomic investigation in Iran was to estimate the costs of multiple sclerosis
according to severity of disease. Total, direct and indirect costs were compared in 160
patients divided into three groups categorized by disease severity: stage I Expanded
Disability Status Scale (EDSS < 2.5), stage II (EDSS 3–4.5) and stage III (EDSS > 5).
The majority of these patients (94%) developed relapsing- remitting MS. a minority
of the patients (0.2–4%) developed secondary progressive and primary progressive
MS. Cost evaluation was performed from the societal perspective and covered the
one-year period. The study was carried out at the Division of Neurology at Ghaem
Hospital and MS association in Mashhad in northeast of Iran and was approved by
the local ethics committee. The mean total cost/patient for one year was estimated at
$27,095, $27,997and $31,662 for stage I, II and III, respectively. Both direct and
indirect costs increased with MS progression. For indirect cost the main item was
productivity loss. The mean extra medicine (treatments for MS symptoms and adverse
effects of medications) cost/patient for one year was calculated at $19,036. This study
confirms that MS represents a high economic burden to patients and society, with
direct costs greatly exceeding indirect costs. As costs increase with disease progression,
treatment efforts should focus on patients in the early stages of MS. Disease support
system that monitors a variety of common progressive signs for the MS individuals is
a key element of a management program as well.
PND14
SOCIO-ECONOMIC ASPECTS OF TESTING FOR NEUTRALIZING
ANTIBODIES IN MS PATIENTS ON INTERFERON BETA TREATMENT IN
AUSTRIA: A COST OF ILLNESS STUDY
Walter E1, Brennig C1, Schöllbauer V1, Mair W2, Deisenhammer F3
1
Institute for Pharmaeconomic Research, Vienna, Austria; 2Biogen Idec GmbH, Vienna,
Austria; 3University Hospital Innsbruck, Innsbruck, Austria
OBJECTIVES: According to EU-guidelines testing all patients on interferon-beta
(IFNb) for presence of neutralizing antibodies (NAB) is recommended irrespective of
clinical course and stop IFNb or switch to alternatives in patients who developed
persistent NAB; based on the fact that development in persistently NAB-positive
patients equals that of placebo-treated patients. Economic impact of NAB-testing in
MS-patients has not been explored yet. METHODS: This analysis estimated the
economic impact of NAB-testing versus not testing during IFNb treatment in MSpatients (n = 3590) on Austria’s health care system. a cost of illness model (decision
tree combined with an integrated Markov model, time horizon 5 years), based on the
cohort of IFNb-treated patients was performed. Two alternatives were compared:
Cost-effectiveness of NAB-testing versus no NAB-testing. The NAB-testing arm
allowed switching to alternative therapies whereas no-NAB-testing did not. Direct
costs comprised all treatment-costs of symptoms due to MS. Indirect costs were not
included. All costs represent data from 2010 (discounted at 5%p.a). Clinical data and
resource use were determined by literature/experts. Efficacy assessment was based on
the outcome measure “relapses avoided.” RESULTS: Total discounted costs for all
Austrian MS-patients on IFNb-therapy (incl. testing) from a health care system’s
perspective amount to c187,764,180 for 5 years. Total costs for all MS-patients
without testing amount to c176,331,610. The difference of costs between tested
patients, and therefore switching, and not tested patients values c11,432,570. Considering all IFNb-treated patients and a time horizon of 5 years 1400 relapses can be
avoided. Testing for NAB leads to costs per relapse avoided of c24,383p.a. versus
c27,569p.a. when no tests are done resulting in a difference of c3,186 per patient in
favour of NAB-testing. CONCLUSIONS: General NAB-testing in MS-patients on
IFNb-therapy is reasonable and cost-effective. Patients switching to effective and more
expensive alternatives do not account for higher health care costs. Furthermore, less
relapses increase QoL.
13th Euro Abstracts
PND15
PATIENT CHARACTERISTICS AND CHARGES ASSOCIATED WITH
EMERGENCY DEPARTMENT VISITS AMONG PATIENTS WITH A
DIAGNOSIS OF RESTLESS LEGS SYNDROME
Meyers J, Candrilli S
RTI Health Solutions, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA
OBJECTIVES: Restless legs syndrome (RLS) affects 2 to 15% of the US population.
Limited data exist on patient characteristics and charges associated with emergency
department (ED) visits among patients with RLS. METHODS: Data from the 2007
Healthcare Cost and Utilization Project’s Nationwide Emergency Department Sample
were used. Patients were selected for inclusion if they had a diagnosis of RLS (ICD9-CM code 333.94). Study measures included patient demographics and charges
associated with the ED visit. Study measures were reported separately for patients
with a primary versus secondary RLS diagnosis. Among patients with a secondary
RLS diagnosis, the most common primary diagnoses were reported. RESULTS: A total
of 6133 patients with a primary RLS diagnosis and 140,931 patients with a secondary
RLS diagnosis were identified. Common primary diagnoses among patients with a
secondary RLS diagnosis included respiratory symptoms (7.0%), general symptoms
(4.6%), and pneumonia (3.7%). Mean (Std. Err.) age was 54.5 (0.6) years among
patients with a primary diagnosis and 64.0 (0.3) years among patients with a secondary diagnosis. In both cohorts, over two-thirds of patients were female, the most
common geographic regions were the South and Midwest, and Medicare was the most
common primary payer (41.0% of patients with a primary diagnosis and 59.3% of
patients with a secondary diagnosis). Over 90% of patients with a primary diagnosis
had a routine discharge compared to only 26.6% of patients with a secondary diagnosis, and most patients with a secondary diagnosis were admitted to the facility as
an inpatient. Mean (Std. Err.) charges were $816 ($48) for patients with a primary
diagnosis and $2,043 ($62) for patients with a secondary diagnosis. CONCLUSIONS:
This nationally representative study suggests that patients admitted to the ED with
RLS accrue substantial costs during their visit. Further research is needed to more fully
assess the total economic burden of the disease.
PND16
MODELING THE CLINICAL AND ECONOMIC IMPLICATIONS OF
GALANTAMINE IN THE TREATMENT OF MILD TO MODERATE
ALZHEIMER’S DISEASE IN GERMANY
Guo S1, Hernández L1, Wasiak R2, Gaudig M3
1
United BioSource Corporation, Lexington, MA, USA; 2United BioSource Corporation—
Europe, London, UK; 3Janssen-Cilag, Neuss, Germany
OBJECTIVES: A reimbursement policy issued by the Federal Joint Committee in
Germany to reassess the benefit of cholinesterase inhibitors every six months in order
to receive continued coverage by the Statutory Health Insurance triggered an additional need to periodically assess the cost-benefit of galantamine in the treatment of
mild-to-moderate Alzheimer’s disease (AD). An economic model specifically designed
for the purposes of such an assessment was developed using the most up-to-date
IQWiG guidelines for cost-benefit assessment. METHODS: The model uses a discrete
event simulation to predict the course of AD through changes in cognition, behavioral
disturbance, and function over time, and compare the costs and benefits of galantamine versus no-drug treatment and ginkgo biloba. Clinical data were mainly derived
from analyses of pooled data from clinical trials. Epidemiological and cost data were
obtained from literature and public data sources. Costs (2009 c) from the perspective
of the German Statutory Health Insurance were used. Both costs and benefits were
discounted at 5%. Sensitivity analyses were performed to assess the robustness of the
model outcomes. RESULTS: Over a 10-year period, galantamine on average delays
time to severe stage of the disease by 3.57 and 3.36 months, compared to no-drug
treatment and ginkgo biloba, respectively. Galantamine also reduces time spent institutionalized by 2.34 and 2.21 months, compared to no-drug treatment and ginkgo
biloba, respectively. The use of galantamine is projected to yield net savings of c3,978
and c3,972 per patient compared to respective treatments. CONCLUSIONS: Our
analyses suggest that compared to no-drug treatment and ginkgo biloba, treatment
with galantamine not only improves clinical benefits, but also achieves savings in
health care costs associated with care for patients with mild-to-moderate AD in
Germany.
PND17
MEMANTINE DELAYS THE ADMISSION OF ALZHEIMER’S DISEASE
PATIENTS TO NURSING HOME: COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS IN
FRANCE
Touchon J1, Lachaine J2, Beauchemin C2, Crochard A3, Rive B3, Bineau S3
1
Gui de Chauliac Hospital, Montpellier, France; 2University of Montreal, Montreal, QC,
Canada; 3Lundbeck SAS, Issy-Les-Moulineaux, France
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate in the French setting the cost-effectiveness of memantine
as adjunct therapy to Cholinesterase inhibitors (ChEI) compared to ChEI monotherapy in Alzheimer’s disease (AD) patients. METHODS: A cost-effectiveness analysis
employed a 3-state Markov model (“non-institutionalized,” “institutionalized” and
“dead”) and compared the treatment alternatives in terms of time to nursing home
admission, Quality Adjusted Life-years (QALYs), and costs over a 7-year time horizon.
Annual transition probabilities between states were derived from two observational
cohort studies: Lopez et al 2009 (US) for institutionalization probabilities and Helmer
et al 2001 (FR) for death probabilities. Costs were valued from health care system
and societal perspectives, and included cost of AD medications (French National
13th Euro Abstracts
Health Insurance database, 2009), costs of care in community and in institution
(French National Assembly on AD management, report 2005). Results were reported
in EUR 2009. Health-related utilities were obtained from preceding published economic evaluations in AD (Getsios et al 2001). Costs and QALYs were discounted at
annual rates of 0% (base-case analysis), 3% and 5%. Deterministic and probabilistic
sensitivity analyses were carried out to test the robustness of model assumptions.
RESULTS: Over the seven-year time horizon, patients treated with ChEI monotherapy
spent on average 41.6 months before institutionalization. Overall costs were c72,469
(health care system perspective) or c89,735 (societal perspective). QALYs were estimated at 2.36. Memantine as adjunct therapy to ChEI was associated with a longer
time to nursing home of 8.9 months, QALYs gains of 0.19 and a cost saving of c5900
(health care system perspective) or c2200 (societal perspective), i.e. a dominant treatment scenario versus ChEI monotherapy. CONCLUSIONS: This economic evaluation
suggest that, from both a health care system and a societal perspective, memantine as
adjunct therapy to ChEI is a cost-effective strategy in the management of AD patients
compared with ChEI monotherapy.
PND18
48-HOUR INFUSION OF METHYLPREDNISOLONE IS A COST-EFFECTIVE
INTERVENTION FOR TRAUMATIC SPINAL CORD INJURY
Schwartz G, Ruiz C, Ferreira JC, Rotstein OD, Hoch JS, Coyte PC
University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada
OBJECTIVES: Methylprednisolone sodium succinate (MP) is an acute therapeutic
option for traumatic spinal cord injury (SCI). a pivotal multicentre randomized control
trial reported modest functional improvements and increased clinical complications
associated with an extended dose regimen of MP for 48 hours (48h-MP) versus a
limited dose regimen of MP for 24 hours (24h-MP), resulting in clinical ambiguity
between 48h-MP and 24h-MP. Concerning the health care burden imposed by this
devastating form of neurotrauma, an economic assessment comparing the benefits
either MP regimen imparts has never been reported. We performed a cost-effectiveness
analysis (CEA) of 48h-MP compared with 24h-MP to determine their impact on direct
health care costs for this patient population. METHODS: A decision tree model,
incorporating motor improvement and complication frequencies reported by the Third
National Acute Spinal Cord Injury Study and utility scores (QALYs) obtained from
an Australian cohort, measured outcomes and effects at 6 and 12 months post-injury.
Survival data, direct health care expenditures and complication costs associated with
SCI and MP intervention were obtained from published epidemiological and survey
data. CEA was performed from the health care payer’s perspective, discounted at a
rate of 4% annually with a lifetime horizon. Distributions of the incremental costeffectiveness ratio between the interventions were determined by Monte Carlo simulation. The model was validated with sensitivity analyses by varying costs and outcome
comparators. RESULTS: As a result, 48h-MP dominates 24h-MP, providing higher
QALYs at lower costs. The lower costs associated with 48h-MP intervention was
$35,703 per patient lifecycle. Earlier motor improvement maintained at 1-year postinjury was a key variable favouring 48h-MP intervention, despite complications associated with this dosing regimen. CONCLUSIONS: To conclude, 48h-MP is the
cost-effective intervention for SCI in comparison to 24h-MP, wherein the former
results in modestly improved motor function, an effect which is maintained up to at
least 1-year post-injury.
PND19
A LONG-TERM COST-EFFECTIVENESS MARKOV MODEL COMPARING
DISEASE MODIFYING TREATMENTS IN PATIENTS WITH RELAPSING
REMITTING MULTIPLE SCLEROSIS IN GERMANY
Plesnila-Frank C1, Putzki N2, Eheberg D1, Limmroth V3, Katsarava Z4, Patel SN5
1
IMS Health GmbH & Co. OHG, Munich, Germany; 2Cantonal Hospital, St.Gallen,
Switzerland; 3Kliniken der Stadt Köln, Cologne, Germany; 4Universitätsklinikum, Essen,
Germany; 5Biogen Idec GmbH, Ismaning, Germany
OBJECTIVES: To conduct a German economic evaluation of natalizumab compared
to other disease modifying drugs (DMD) in relapsing-remitting Multiple Sclerosis (MS)
from a societal perspective. METHODS: A Markov model was designed to compare
costs and outcomes of Natalizumab (Nb), other DMD (interferon-beta, glatiramer
acetate) and best supportive care (BSC). The expanded disability status scale (EDSS)
and the line of treatment were used to define the distinctive Markov States. Transition
probabilities for progression, treatment switches and withdrawals were derived from
clinical studies and literature. German real-life treatment data of MS-patients under
DMD were collected retrospectively (N = 554) and used to validate assumptions and
conduct sensitivity analyses. Cost data and quality of life estimates were taken from
a European burden of MS study. a time horizon of 30 years and annual discount rates
of 3% for costs and outcomes were chosen. RESULTS: Treatment with Nb resulted
in 8.13 avoided relapses over 30 years, and in 2.36 avoided relapses under other DMD.
After 30 years, the proportion of surviving patients at a low state of disease (incl.
EDSS 4) was 59% for the Nb group, 31% for the other DMD and 8% for patients
in the BSC group. The average MS related costs over 30 years were estimated at
c847,160 for Nb, c816,139 for other DMD, and c627,701 for BSC. Cost per quality
adjusted life-year (QALY) was c60,938 for Nb, c64,481 for other DMD and c53,911
for BSC. The incremental cost-effectiveness of Nb compared to other DMD was
c24,919 per QALY. CONCLUSIONS: MS is a resource intense disease due to its
chronic course and its severe impact on patients’ daily life. Long term analysis suggests
that even treatment without DMD is expensive and leads to considerable inferior
clinical outcomes. Treatment with DMD improves the situation of patients, with
Natalizumab showing the highest efficacy and best cost-effectiveness ratio.
A391
PND20
IS ROPINIROLE-PROLONGED RELEASE A COST-SAVING TREATMENT
OPTION IN PARKINSON’S DISEASE?
Novak A1, Boomsma M2
1
Anovák-Services, Apeldoorn, Gelderland, The Netherlands; 2GlaxoSmithKline bv Nederland,
Zeist, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: Parkinson’s Disease (PD) is both a chronic and progressive neurodegenerative disorder. a 24-hour prolonged release tablet (PR) of the dopamine agonist
ropinirole was introduced next to three daily doses of ropinirole immediate release
(IR). a randomized controlled trial (PREPARED) was conducted, comparing ropinirole-IR with ropinirole-PR. Ropinirole-PR significantly improved the off-time and this
analysis assesses the costs-effectiveness of the ropinirole-PR in PD patients who are
not adequately controlled on L-dopa compated to ropinirole-IR. METHODS: A
Markov-health-state-transition model was used with health states combining off-time
≤25% and >25% per day, Hoehn & Yahr stages 2–5 and problematic dyskinesias.
Time horizons are 5 years and lifelong. Costs and effects were discounted by 4% and
1,5% respectively. Healthcare perspective was taken, covering direct costs related to
medication, consults, nursing and patient care including informal care, based on an
ongoing Dutch observational study in PD (IMPACT study). Clinical outcomes from
the PREPARED-trial are extrapolated based on literature assumptions. Results are
presented as incremental costs and QALY’s gained. Both univariate and probabilistic
sensitivity analyses (PSA) were performed. RESULTS: Ropinirole-PR was associated
with lower L-dopa use, less off-time and less problematic dyskinesias. This resulted
in incremental QALY gains of 0.125 and 0.336 over respectively 5 years and lifetime.
The health care costs per H&Y-stage increased with disease severity and amounted
c916, c1,492, c11,295 and c11.295 for stage 2 to 5 over 6 months. Treatment with
ropinirole-PR was more costly than ropinirole-IR with a difference of c7.266 over 5
years and c17.773 over lifetime. Treatment with ropinirole-PR however reduced
medical costs by c8,059 over 5 years and c69,532 over lifetime compared with ropinirol-IR, mainly due to reduced dyskinesia occurrence. Sensitivity analysis confirmed
the robustness of the model. CONCLUSIONS: Patient-functioning and quality of life
were improved with ropinirole-PR realizing cost-savings to the health care budget as
compared to treatment with ropinirole-IR.
PND21
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF TRANSDERMAL PATCH (ROTIGOTINE) IN
PATIENTS WITH PARKINSON DISEASE IN MEXICO
Aguirre A, Benitez A, Bierschwale H
UCB MEXICO, Mexico City, D.F., Mexico
BACKGROUND: Parkinson’s Disease (PD) is a central nervous system disorder
caused by progressive deterioration of brain areas that produce dopamine. Oral
dopaminergic therapies control the symptoms of the disease, but these require three
or more times daily doses, so it is associated with poor compliance or adherence,
which affects the overall efficacy and costs in health. OBJECTIVES: To analyze the
cost-effectiveness of rotigotine versus pramipexole in patients with PD in Mexico.
METHODS: We conducted an economic evaluation. The alternatives to compare were
rotigotine 4, 6, 8 and 12 mg administered once daily versus pramipexole 3 mg/d and
another scenario versus pramipexole 4.5 mg/d. The perspective is the Mexican Social
Security Institute. The model included the cost of drug acquisition and management
of adverse events (AE) for a 22 weeks period. The measure of efficacy was compliance
or adherence to treatment, as a direct comparison study of rotigotine versus pramipexole demonstrated non-inferiority between the two alternatives. RESULTS: The
compliance rate for rotigotine was 81% vs. 61% pramipexole. The costs were
US$748, US$920, US$1113 and US$1701 for rotigotine 4, 6, 8 and 12 mg/d respectively, compared with US$670 and US$967 for pramipexole 3 and 4.5 mg/d. The cost
per successfully treated patient was lower for rotigotine 4, 6 and 8 mg/d (US$923,
US$1 136 and US$1374, respectively) than with pramipexole 4.5 mg/d (US$1585).
Rotigotine 4, 6, 8 and 12 mg/d were found to be a highly cost-effective strategy
compared with pramipexole 3 and 4.5 mg/d, according to WHO criteria. CONCLUSIONS: The results of this analysis suggest that the use of rotigotine in patients with
PD, represents a highly cost-effective strategy or cost saving for the public health
institutions in Mexico. Rotigotine is an innovative alternative for easy administration
(transdermal).
PND22
COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS COMPARING BRIDION®
(SUGAMMADEX) WITH NEOSTIGMIN AND SPONTANEOUS RECOVERY
IN THE REVERSAL OF NEUROMUSCULAR BLOCKADE INDUCED BY
ROCURONIUM/VECURONIUM
Ozdemir O1, Bahar M2, Aypar U3, Askar F4, Gura M5
1
Yorum Consultancy Co. Ltd., Istanbul, Turkey; 2Istanbul University Cerrahpaþa Medical
Faculty, Istanbul, Turkey; 3Hacettepe University Medical Faculty, Ankara, Turkey; 4Ege
University Medical Faculty, Izmir, Turkey; 5Goztepe Training and Research Hospital, Istanbul,
Turkey
OBJECTIVES: This study aimed to compare the cost-effectiveness (CE) of Bridion®
(sugammadex) with neostigmine and spontaneous recovery (SR) approach in the
reversal of neuromuscular blockade (NMB) induced by rocuronium/vecuronium,
during anesthesia. METHODS: CE analysis (CEA) was performed by solving back
the decision tree that included pathways starting with residual NMB and followed by
hypoxia and pulmonary complications defined as “aspiration, atelectasis and/or pneumonia” in patients, in whom NMB was induced by rocuronium/vecuronium. Bridion
was compared with neostigmine and SR approach. Primary analysis parameters that
A392
were used as denominators in the calculation of incremental CE ratios (ICER) are
decreased frequencies of mild hypoxia, severe hypoxia and pneumonia. RESULTS:
Frequencies of residual NMB were estimated as 51.2% 44.6% and 0.4% in SR,
neostigmine and Bridion groups, respectively. Hypoxia rate was calculated as 27.4%
and 11.4% in patients with and without residual NMB. Frequencies of pneumonia
were 17.2% and 5.9% in patients with and without residual NMB. Percentage of
patients without any complication was found to be 88.0% in Bridion group, while it
was 73.8% and 75.7% in SR and neostigmine groups. The costs of complications
were 126.45c and 114.56c in SR and neostigmine groups, while it was only 34.93c in
Bridion® group. When medication cost was added, the total cost rose to 114.62c in
Bridion® group, which was still lower than the total costs of SR and neostigmine
groups. The rate of severe hypoxia was estimated as 7.9% in Bridion® group, while
it was 13.5% and 12.7% in SR and neostigmine groups, respectively. Pneumonia was
seen in 1.2% of the patients in Bridion® group, while the frequencies of pneumonia
were 9.4% and 8.3% in SR and neostigmine groups. CONCLUSIONS: Bridion® was
found to be dominant to both SR and neostigmine groups, in terms of decrease in
frequencies of hypoxia and pulmonary complications.
PND23
COST-EFFECTIVENESS EVALUATION OF LEVODOPA/CARBIDOPA/
ENTACAPONE IN TREATMENT OF PARKINSON DISEASE
Yagudina R, Kulikov AU, Serpik VG
Moscow Medical Academy, Moscow, Russia
OBJECTIVES: To conduct pharmacoeconomic evaluation of Levodopa/Carbidopa/
Entacapone (LCE) compared to standard therapy in Parkinson disease treatment.
Standard therapy was presented by Levodopa and Carbidopa. METHODS: The costeffectiveness study was carried conducted. Effectiveness was measured in DALYs.
Time horizont for cost-effectiveness analysis was 2 years. a 3% discount rate was
used. 1 EUR = 40 RUB. RESULTS: LCE provided benefits in effectiveness compared
to standard therapy. LCE reduced days incapacity index twice from 44 to 21 days.
Two year pilot study showed that LCE provided 0,83 DALY, than standard therapy
presented 0,5 DALY. Also administration of LCE reduced daily Levodopa dose on
68 mg. Total annual costs for LCE therapy were 158 938 (3 974 EUR) RUB. Standard
therapy total costs varied from 129 113 RUB (3 228 EUR) to 145 422 RUB (3 636
EUR) yearly according to disease progression grade. Indirect costs, including GDP
losses due to temporary disability and payments for temporary disability, were 14 372
RUB (359 EUR) for LCE and 30 113 RUB (753 EUR) for standard therapy. The costeffectiveness ratio for LCE was 191 492 RUB (4 787 EUR) per DALY, than for
standard therapy it was 258 326 RUB (6 458 EUR) per DALY. CONCLUSIONS: LCE
demonstrates lower cost-effectiveness ratio (191 492 RUB) compared to standard
Parkinson disease therapy (258 326 RUB), therefore LCE has an advantage over
standard therapy in terms of pharmacoeconomic evaluation.
PND24
THE IMPACT OF COHORT SELECTION ON COST-EFFECTIVENESS
RESULTS IN MULTIPLE SCLEROSIS
Becker RV1, Dembek C2
1
Russell Becker Consulting, Chicago, IL, USA; 2Biogen Idec GmbH, Wellesley, MA, USA
OBJECTIVES: Adherence to cost-effectiveness analytic guidelines requires careful
assessment of clinical trial results to ensure the most appropriate cohort data selection.
This study examines the impact of cohort selection on the results of the Goldberg, et
al. 2009 cost-effectiveness study of disease-modifying therapies (DMTs) in multiple
sclerosis (MS). METHODS: Using intent–to-treat (ITT) two-year data from pivotal
trials, Goldberg compared cost per relapse avoided of first-line DMTs. However, there
are important differences in the ITT cohorts among the trials. Due to lower than
expected subject drop-out rates, the interferon beta-1a IM (INF-b-1a-IM) trial was
able to meet its primary endpoint with a reduced sample size and a decision was made
to terminate the trial early. This resulted in almost half of the 301 ITT (or “allpatient”) cohort being on study drug for less than two years. a second, “two-year”
172 patient cohort consisted of patients who had completed two years on drug
therapy. Goldberg used the INF-b-1a-IM “all-patient” cohort in his cost study. To
test the impact of this cohort selection, we recreated Goldberg’s model using the “allpatient” relapse rate (0.67 for INF-b-1a-IM vs. 0.82 for placebo) and then substituted
the “two-year” cohort data (relapse rate of 0.61 for INF-b-1a-IM vs. 0.90 for placebo)
and compared results. RESULTS: This study’s cost per relapse avoided was 45% lower
for INF-b-1a-IM while the results for the other DMTs were comparable to those
reported by Goldberg. Ranked from most to least cost-effective, the model results were
$77,980 for INF-b-1a-IM, $80,121 for interferon beta-1a SC, $86,572 for interferon
beta-1b, and $87,767 for glatiramer. CONCLUSIONS: Our analysis demonstrates the
importance of cohort selection in cost-effectiveness analyses in MS. By selecting
comparable cohort data from patients who had completed at least two years on study
drug, we found that INF-b-1a-IM had the lowest cost per relapse avoided of all firstline DMTs.
PND25
ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF NATALIZUMAB IN THE TREATMENT OF
RELAPSING REMITTING MULTIPLE SCLEROSIS IN 4 EUROPEAN
COUNTRIES
Brennig C, Walter E, Schöllbauer V
Institute for Pharmaeconomic Research, Vienna, Austria
OBJECTIVES: Multiple sclerosis (MS) is an inflammatory, neurodegenerative condition of central nervous system with prevalence of 1 Million worldwide (age at first
13th Euro Abstracts
manifestation 20–40 years). MS may lead to permanent disability and early retirement
even in young adults. The purpose of this analysis was to provide an economic assessment of relapsing-remitting MS-treatment with Natalizumab versus Interferons and
Copolymer in 4 European countries (Austria, Czech Republic, Slovakia, Slovenia).
METHODS: The analysis was performed using a Markov model. The model allows
a treatment switch due to relapse. Efficacy assessment was based on the outcome
measure “relapse-free patients”. Costs were captured for the year 2010. Resource use
was determined from results of a survey conducted by the Austrian MS Society and
accurately reflects the therapeutic approach. Resource use of Czech Republic, Slovakia
and Slovenia was determined via country-specific research. Where country specific
data could not be captured, Austrian data was adjusted via Purchasing Power Parities
(PPP). The study time horizon was 2 years. The analysis was performed from the
perspective of the health care system of the 4 European countries. RESULTS: In Czech
Republic the average cost of the therapy algorithm Natalizumab amount to c33,835
per patient within the time horizon of 2 years versus c22,896 (Interferon) and c21,256
(Copolymer). a patient successfully treated with Natalizumab accounts for c56,525
compared to c70,190 (Interferon) and for c87,555 (Copolymer). In Slovakia a relapsefree patient values c60,357 (Natalizumab) versus c58,043 (Interferon) and c19,921
(Copolymer). a relapse-free patient in Slovenia values c59,108 (Natalizumab) versus
c66,202 (Interferon) and c84,207 (Copolymer). In Austria a relapse-free patient values
c58,423 (Natalizumab) versus c71,906 (Interferon) and c89,591 (Copolymer). CONCLUSIONS: In Czech Republic, Slovenia, and Austria, treatment of MS with Natalizumab is more cost-effective than Interferon resp. Copolymer 1 therapy. Switching to
effective and more expensive alternatives does not account for higher health care costs.
PND26
MEDICO-ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF LACOSAMIDE ADJUNCTIVE
THERAPY IN THE TREATMENT OF PATIENTS WITH REFRACTORY
EPILEPSY IN SCOTLAND AND SPAIN
Benhaddi H1, Gunn A1, Ferro B2
1
UCB Pharma S.A., Brussels, Belgium; 2UCB Pharma S.A., Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: To calculate and compare the incremental cost-utility ratios for standard antiepileptic drug (AED) therapy with and without adjunctive lacosamide in
patients with uncontrolled partial-onset seizures. METHODS: The model simulated
the treatment pathway of a hypothetical cohort of 1000 patients over 2 years from
the perspectives of the National Health Service (NHS) in Scotland and the Spanish
Healthcare System (SNS) in 2008. a decision tree was split into four phases of six
months each during which patients can become seizure free, experience a seizure
reduction (responder defined as ≥50% reduction in seizures), or withdraw due to
non-response. The standard therapy arm included carbamazepine, lamotrigine, levetiracetam, topiramate, and valproate. The likelihood of being in a particular health
state has been estimated from clinical data. The cost of general practitioner visits,
outpatient visits, hospitalizations and emergency department visits were included.
Costs and utility values attached to various health states were taken from the published
literature. RESULTS: Lacosamide adjunctive therapy was associated with 6730
avoided seizures and a gain of 38 quality adjusted life-years (QALYs), compared to
the standard therapy arm within the two-year timeframe. Treatment with lacosamide
was associated with a cost of £113 and c107 per seizure avoided, and £20,017 and
c22,771 per QALY gained versus standard therapy in Scotland and Spain, respectively.
Results calculated for 6-, 12- and 18-month follow-up showed respective incremental
cost-utility ratios of £23,479, £21,422 and £20,998 in Scotland, and c23,771, c20,703
and c21,778 in Spain. Using a willingness-to-pay threshold of £30,000 per QALY,
80% of the simulations in Scotland and 74.2% in Spain fell below this value after 2
years of treatment. CONCLUSIONS: Lacosamide was shown to be a cost-effective
adjunctive treatment in patients with uncontrolled partial-onset epilepsy in Scotland
and Spain.
PND27
COST UTILITY ANALYSIS OF ORPHAN DRUGS: CASE STUDY OF
DUODENAL LEVODOPA INFUSION VERSUS STANDARD TREATMENT
IN PATIENTS WITH ADVANCED PARKINSON’S DISEASE IN SWEDEN
Willis M1, Gradl B2
1
IHE, Lund, Sweden; 2Abbott Products Operations AG, Allschwil, Switzerland
BACKGROUND: Advanced Parkinson’s disease (APD) severely impacts the quality
of life (QoL) for both patients and their caregiver and is associated with high health
care and societal costs. The treatment options for those patients are limited. Duodenal
levodopa infusion (DLI), an orphan drug, has shown to restore symptom control and
to improve QoL substantially for both patients and their carers. OBJECTIVES: To
evaluate the cost-utility of DLI versus standard treatment (including oral treatment
and subcutaneous dopamine agonists) in patients with advanced PD in Sweden.
METHODS: A stochastic Markov-based simulation model was developed. Health was
described by 12 health states reflecting 4 categories of “OFF” time and 3 severity
stages as measured by the Hoehn & Yahr scale. The clinical effect for both treatment
arms was derived from published clinical trials; costs and QoL utilities were taken
from an interim analysis of the ongoing DAPHNE study. The base case simulated 5
years with costs/effects discounted by 3%. The societal perspective was adopted.
RESULTS: The model estimated an improvement from 0.68 to 1.30 QALYs and a
cost increase from 1,410,643 (c147,108) to SEK 1,674,295 (c174,603) for DLI versus
standard treatment, leading to an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of
around SEK 420,000 (c43,800) per QALY gained. The ICER for nearly 90% of the
cohorts fell below SEK 655,000 (c68,306), the willingness-to-pay threshold often cited
13th Euro Abstracts
for Sweden [1]. Sensitivity analysis was associated with ICERs ranging up to SEK
900,000 (c93,856) per QALY gained. CONCLUSIONS: Due to the data limitations,
HE modeling in the orphan drug setting is challenging. Analysis could be performed
as requested by Sweden’s Dental and Pharmaceutical Benefits Agency (TLV), however,
providing evidence that health benefits can provide good value for money even for an
orphan population. DLI received a positive reimbursement recommendation by the
TLV. [1] Persson U, Hjelmgren J (2003).
PND28
COST-UTILITY ANALYSIS OF ROTIGOTINE TRANSDERMAL PATCH IN
EARLY-STAGE PARKINSON’S DISEASE IN SCOTLAND
Benhaddi H, Gunn A
UCB Pharma S.A., Brussels, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of rotigotine transdermal patch as
monotherapy in early-stage Parkinson’s disease (PD) compared to ropinirole and other
dopamine agonists (DA) from the NHS perspective in Scotland. METHODS: a decision-analytic model was developed, based on treatment of an early-stage PD patient
(Hoehn and Yahr-stage 2); treatment arms were rotigotine, ropinirole, and a DA
practice comparator including ropinirole, cabergoline and pramipexole. 5-year and
10-year time horizons were considered for patients who remained on monotherapy
only. The economic evaluation is a cost-utility analysis with health outcomes expressed
in Quality Adjusted Life-years (QALY) gained in 2006. Costs relating to drug acquisition, PD severity, falls, occurrence of motor complications and other complications/
adverse events/co-morbidities were considered in the model. Efficacy and safety data
were estimated with a meta-analysis. Quality of life was measured using EQ-5D. Data
on medical resource use was obtained via expert interviews and literature review.
Costs and effects were discounted at the rate of 3.5%. RESULTS: After 5 years, treatment with rotigotine transdermal patch resulted in an estimated 2.30 QALYs, slightly
higher than with ropinirole (2.26) and the DA practice comparator (2.27). 10-year
outcomes were 3.22, 3.17 and 3.17 QALYs for rotigotine, ropinirole and DA practice
comparator, respectively. Total costs for rotigotine, ropinirole and DA practice comparator were £34,748, £37,694 and £36,459 respectively after 5 years and £79,477,
£84,120 and £81,631, respectively after 10 years. With a willingness-to-pay of
£20,000 per QALY gained, there is a 90% probability that rotigotine is cost-effective
relative to ropinirole, and a 85% probability of cost-effectiveness relative to the DA
practice comparator for both 5-year and 10-year time horizons. CONCLUSIONS:
Based on the model, rotigotine may be considered a dominant strategy over ropinirole
and DA practice comparator in the treatment of early-stage PD at 5-year and 10-year
time horizons.
PND29
COST-UTILITY ANALYSIS OF RIZATRIPTAN VERSUS (GENERIC)
SUMATRIPTAN IN SWEDEN
Lundberg J1, Golden WM2, Insinga RP3
1
MSD Sweden, Sollentuna, Sweden; 2Merck & Co., Inc., Whitehouse Station, NJ, USA;
3
Merck & Co., Inc., Upper Gwynedd, PA, USA
OBJECTIVES: In 2005 the Swedish pharmaceutical benefits board published a review
concluding that rizatriptan 10 mg was one of the most cost-effective triptans for
treating migraine, although efficacy differences among the triptan class were generally
small. However, since the review, the price of sumatriptan has declined due to generic
product entry. In this study, we sought to investigate the cost-effectiveness of rizatriptan versus generic sumatriptan. METHODS: A published Canadian decision-analytic model (Thompson et al., Pharmacoeconomics 2005) was adapted to estimate
treatment costs and effects of rizatriptan 10 mg versus (generic) sumatriptan in a single
migraine attack over a 24-hour time-frame in Sweden. Values modified from the
published model were the substitution of Swedish health care and productivity costs,
and updated data on 2-hour and 2–24 hour pain freedom (including results from more
recent head-to-head trials of the comparators). As both sumatriptan 50 mg and
100 mg are marketed in Sweden, and have comparable efficacy profiles, averaged data
for the two doses were used as a comparator to rizatriptan 10 mg. RESULTS: From
a societal perspective, including both health care and productivity costs, the comparison of rizatriptan 10 mg versus (generic) sumatriptan resulted in cost-savings of ~ 5
SEK, and greater QALYs for rizatriptan 10 mg. Inclusion of health care costs only,
yielded a cost-effectiveness ratio for rizatriptan vs. sumatriptan of 343,929 SEK/
QALY. CONCLUSIONS: Given the data and assumptions used, in a single attack
model, rizatriptan 10 mg was found to have a cost-effectiveness ratio compared to
(generic) sumatriptan within the range typically regarded as cost-effective in Sweden.
These findings suggest that there is reason to explore the cost-effectiveness of pharmaceutical and other medical interventions with large differences in acquisition cost
even though efficacy differences may appear to be small.
PND30
COST-UTILITY ANALYSIS OF LACOSAMIDE ADJUNCTIVE THERAPY IN
THE TREATMENT OF PARTIAL-ONSET SEIZURES IN EPILEPTIC
PATIENTS IN BELGIUM
Simoens S1, Dedeken P2, De Naeyer L2, Benhaddi H2
1
K.U. Leuven, Leuven, Belgium; 2UCB Pharma S.A., Brussels, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: This study aims at evaluating the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio
(ICER) for lacosamide compared with standard therapy alone from the perspective of
the Belgian health care payer in 2010. METHODS: A decision tree simulating the
treatment pathway of a hypothetical cohort of 1,000 patients over two years was split
A393
into four phases of six months each during which patients can become seizure free,
experience a seizure reduction (defined as ≥50% reduction in seizures), or withdraw
due to non-response. The antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) included in the standard therapy
arm were extracted from the pivotal trials and included carbamazepine, lamotrigine,
levetiracetam, topiramate and valproate. Health state probabilities, seizure frequency
and utility values were taken from lacosamide trials or from the literature. Costs of
general practitioner visits, outpatient visits, hospitalizations and emergency department visits were included. Resource use was estimated by a Belgian panel of eight
neurologists. Costs were discounted at a rate of 3% and consequences at a rate of
1.5%. RESULTS: Over a 24-month period, standard AED therapy plus lacosamide
led to a reduction of 7 seizures, an increase of 0.038 quality-adjusted life-years, and
a cost decrease of c3619 per patient as compared with standard therapy alone. Results
were also calculated for a 6-, 12- and 18-month follow-up. Lacosamide plus AED
therapy dominated versus standard therapy alone. Using a willingness to pay of
c30,000 per quality-adjusted life-year, the net monetary benefit of standard antiepileptic drug therapy plus lacosamide amounted to c4,754. The probability of standard
AED therapy plus lacosamide being cost-effective was 97.3% at 6 months, 99.8% at
12 months, 99.9% at 18 months, and 100% at 24 months. CONCLUSIONS: In
epileptic patients who are difficult to treat with other AEDs, standard AED therapy
plus lacosamide appears to be a cost-effective alternative.
NEUROLOGICAL DISORDERS – Patient-Reported Outcomes Studies
PND31
IMPACT OF AN ADHERENCE PROGRAM, RUN AS A TELEPHONE
INTERVENTION ON COMPLIANCE WITH SUBCUTANEOUS
INTERFERON Â-1A FOR MULTIPLE SCLEROSIS PATIENTS USING A
MAIL-ORDER PHARMACY
Papademetriou E1, Levin R1, Tuennermann M2, Lammers V2, Aubert RE1
1
Medco Health Solutions, Franklin Lakes, NJ, USA; 2Europa Apotheek Venlo B.V., Venlo, The
Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: Quasi-experimental analysis to determine the effect of an opt-in telephone intervention on adherence in patients using subcutaneous interferon β-1a,
which is indicated for relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis. Drop-out reasons, sideeffects, and expectations of therapy are described. METHODS: Customers of a mailorder pharmacy that services Germany who ordered subcutaneous interferon β-1a
were targeted for enrollment in a free program that included an initial counseling call,
optional e-mail reminders for the next doctor’s consultation and prescription, and
ongoing counseling calls. Patients enrolled in the program for at least 6-months were
included in the analysis and compared to patients that did not enter the program over
the same time period. Proportion of days covered (PDC) was calculated for each group
and compared using analysis of variance. Enrollees in the program were administered
a questionnaire at the initial welcome call addressing their expectations of therapy,
and again during each counseling call regarding their compliance behavior, and side
effects. RESULTS: Patients in the adherence program showed an unadjusted PDC
8.2% higher than the control, F(1.247) = 13.44, p = 0.0003. One program patient
switched drugs compared to six control group patients. a total of 21% of enrolled
subjects reported missing at least one dose. Side-effects included pain/inflammation at
the site of injection (24.41%), fatigue (20.73%), headaches (17.06%), and flu-like
symptoms (9.71%). Exacerbations were reported by 15.7% of patients. Patients’ had
expectations that therapy would prolong the distance between exacerbations (23.36%)
and slow the progression of disability due to the disease (21.28%). CONCLUSIONS:
Actively recruiting patients into an optional adherence program significantly increased
the compliance rate for relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis patients using subcutaneous interferon β-1a. Side effects experienced by enrolled patients were consistent with
the package insert. Limitations include a potential bias between patients that agree to
the program vs. those that do not, as well as the lack of additional questionnaire data
from the control group.
PND32
INFLUENCE OF AGE ON REFILL-ADHERENCE RATES OF ANTIEPILEPTIC DRUGS IN SOUTH AFRICA
Van Zyl T, Lubbe MS, Serfontein JHP, Rakumakoe DM
North-West University, Potchefstroom, South Africa
OBJECTIVES: To investigate the possible influence of age on the refill-based adherence rates of anti-epileptic drugs. METHODS: A retrospective drug utilization review
was performed on medicine claims data of a pharmacy benefit management company
in South Africa. Refill-based adherence rates were calculated for 64,457 anti-epileptic
drugs that were prescribed more than once during a four-year period (January 1, 2005
to December 2008). The refill-based adherence rate was calculated per trade name by
using the following equation: Refill-Adherence rate = (total number of days of antiepileptic drugs supplied—days supplied at the last refill)/(date last claimed—date first
claimed). [RSA Rand (R)/$US = 6.38112 (2005); 6.78812 (2006); 7.06926 (2007) and
8.27505 (2008)]. RESULTS: Only 30.5% (n = 19 635) of anti-epileptic drugs had
refill-adherence rates between between 90% and 110%. The majority of anti-epileptic
drugs (58.9%; n = 37 962) had refill-adherence rates below 90% that accounted for
39.2% (n = R 57 599 838) of the total cost of all anti-epileptic drugs (N = R146 863
755) included in these calculations. Anti-epileptic drugs with refill-adherence rates
>110% (10,7%; n = 6 860) accounted for 6.7% (R9 782 864) of the total cost of all
anti-epileptic drugs. The average refill-adherence rate decreased with nearly 10% from
A394
93.7% in age group 1 (0 ≤ 12 years) to 83.3% in age group 5 (older than 65 years).
In general the lowest average refill-based adherence rates were obtained with medicine
items containing phenobarbitone and vitamin B1 (52.0% ± 37.8); phenobarbitone
(63.5% ± 47.2); primidone metabolites (69.7% ± 47.2%); clonazepam (77.8% ±
184.8) and carbamazepine (80.9% ± 151.1) CONCLUSIONS: Most of the anti-epileptic drugs had unacceptable low refill-adherence rates. Refill-adherence rates of
anti-epileptic drugs decreased with an increase in the age of patients.
PND33
REFILL-ADHERENCE RATES OF ANTIPARKINSON MEDICATION IN THE
PRIVATE HEALTH CARE SECTOR OF SOUTH AFRICA
Van der Merwe S, Lubbe MS, Du Plessis JM, Bekker E
North-West University, Potchefstroom, South Africa
OBJECTIVES: To investigate the prevalence of unacceptable refill-based adherence
rates with antiparkinson medicine items. METHODS: A retrospective drug utilization
study was performed on medicine claims data of a pharmacy benefit management
company in South Africa during January 1, 2005 until December 31, 2008. Refillbased adherence rates were calculated for 8 768 antiparkinson medicine items that
were prescribed more than once during a four-year period (January 1, 2005 to December 2008). The refill-based adherence rate was calculated per trade name by using the
following equation: Refill-Adherence rate = (total number of days of antiparkinson
medicine items supplied—days supplied at the last refill)/(date last claimed—date first
claimed). (RSA Rand(R)/$US = 6.8595 on 31 Dec. 2007). [RSA Rand (R)/$US =
6.38112 (2005); 6.78812 (2006); 7.06926 (2007) and 8.27505 (2008)] RESULTS: A
majority of antiparkinson medicine items (53.50%, n = 4,691) had unacceptably low
refill-adherence rates below 90%, that accounted for 41.62% (n = R16,398,512.00)
of the total cost (N = R39,402,898.20) of all antiparkinson medicine items included
in this study. Only 36.78% (n = 3225) of antiparkinson medicine items had acceptable
refill-adherence rates between 90% and 110%. Those with unacceptable high refilladherence rates accounted for 9.72% (n = 852) of all antiparkinson medicine items
and represented 6.5% (n = R2,574,597) of the total cost. No practical significant
difference in the average refill-adherence rates was found between male (93.99% ±
186.99) and female (90.83% ± 175.21) patients. Biperidien, carbidopa/levodopa, and
levodopa/benserazide containing products had on average unacceptable low refilladherence rates (<90%). CONCLUSIONS: Although poor obedience to treatment
schedules adds up to aggravation of Parkinson’s disease leading to death and amplified
health care cost, it seems that the refill-adherence rate of antiparkinson medicine items
is not very favourable
PND34
A PSYCHOMETRIC EVALUATION OF THE REVISED SCOPA DIARY
CARD IN PARKINSON’S DISEASE PATIENTS
Buck PO1, Castelli-Haley J1, White RE1, Rendas-Baum R2, White MK2
1
Teva Neuroscience, Kansas City, MO, USA; 2QualityMetric Incorporated, Lincoln, RI, USA
OBJECTIVES: The Scales for Outcomes in Patients with Parkinson’s disease Diary
Card (SCOPA-DC) is a daily diary designed to measure motor impairment in Parkinson’s disease (PD) patients with fluctuating symptoms. Previous qualitative research
evaluated the content validity of the SCOPA-DC in the US and expanded it to measure
non-motor symptoms. The current research examined the psychometric properties of
the revised SCOPA-DC. METHODS: A sample of adults age 30 and older with selfreported doctor-confirmed PD were recruited, screened, and consented online from a
Knowledge Networks panel. Eligible patients were mailed a study packet that contained the revised SCOPA-DC as well as a training video. The revised SCOPA-DC
included 7 non-motor items: fatigue, memory, anxiety, pain, difficulty swallowing,
frequent urination, and sweating. The diary was completed 7 times per day for 3
consecutive days. Consistent with the original SCOPA-DC, 3-day scores were calculated for each item. Higher scores indicated greater symptom severity. RESULTS: A
total of 101 PD patients completed and returned the revised SCOPA-DC. The sample
was 50.5% male and had been diagnosed with PD for an average of 7.4 years. Frequency distributions showed little missing data (approximately 1.0%), although items
were generally right-skewed. Fatigue (29.4) and walking (28.7) had the highest mean
scores; sweating (7.3) and difficulty swallowing (9.7) had the lowest mean scores.
Factor analysis supported a 3-factor solution: mobility, physical functioning, and
psychological functioning. These factors demonstrated good internal consistency
(alpha = 0.83–0.87) and correlations with health-related quality of life instruments
were suggestive of construct validity. CONCLUSIONS: In this US sample of PD
patients with varied disease severity, the revised SCOPA-DC exhibited good psychometric properties, including evidence of reliability and validity. Furthermore, patients
reported that the revised SCOPA-DC was clear and easy to complete. The revised
SCOPA-DC holds promise for measuring a broad spectrum of fluctuating motor and
non-motor PD symptoms.
PND35
COMPARISON OF ANALYIC HIERARCHY PROCESS AND CONJOINT
ANALYSIS METHODS IN ASSESSING TREATMENT ALTERNATIVES IN
STROKE REHABILITATION
Ijzerman M1, Bridges JF2, Van Til J1
1
University of Twente, Enschede, The Netherlands; 2Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore,
MD, USA
OBJECTIVES: There has been increasing interest novel HTA methods that will incorporate patient preferences in a more transparent and scientifically valid way. The
fundamental problem of the assessment of benefits in HTA is the identification,
13th Euro Abstracts
ranking and valuation of multiple health care outcomes. We used two multi-criteria
methods to rank and value five different treatments in stroke rehabilitation. Analytic
Hierarchy Process (AHP) stems from operations research and is increasingly being
used in health care to weigh patient-reported endpoints. Conjoint analysis (CA) is a
stated preference method that often takes the discrete choice format. In CA, hypothetical scenarios are used to generate part-worth utilities for attributes. METHODS: To
determine the clinical decision context and related criteria, a paper-and-pencil questionnaire was conducted among a sample of Dutch physiatrists united in a stroke
interest group. From the lists of criteria (e.g. clinical benefit, impact of treatment) an
expert panel defined the AHP decision structure as well as the conjoint analysis survey
format. Finally, the complete questionnaire including the AHP and CA survey was
sent out to 184 patients with ankle-foot impairments. Eventually, 89 patients completed both surveys. RESULTS: On average, the prediction of preferred treatment on
a group level is similar for both AHP and CA. However. on an inidividual level there
seems to be more variation in treatment preference. Using AHP weights, a vast majority preferred soft-tissue surgery where most patients preferred orthopedic shoes if CA
weights were used. This may have been caused by labelling effects of the attributes.
CONCLUSIONS: Both methods have there pros and cons in ranking and valuing
patient-reported endpoints. Of the methods AHP is relatively easy to apply. In prediction of overall outcome, both methods perform equally. However, for individual
treatment preference we observed some differences. It may be concluded that the
decision structure, framing and labelling of the treatment attributes are more important than the specific elicitation method used.
PND36
HEALTH STATUS COMPARISON BETWEEN STABLE PARKINSON’S
DISEASE PATIENTS AND THOSE EXPERIENCING OFF-TIME
Buck PO1, White RE1, Castelli-Haley J1, Rendas-Baum R2, White MK2
1
Teva Neuroscience, Kansas City, MO, USA; 2QualityMetric Incorporated, Lincoln, RI, USA
OBJECTIVES: End-of-dose wearing-off is commonly experienced by Parkinson’s
disease (PD) patients who have used dopaminergic therapy for several years. Although
investigations of wearing-off have traditionally focused on motor fluctuations, it is
increasingly recognized that non-motor symptoms also vary between periods of “ON”
(when PD symptoms are minimized due to medication) and “OFF” (when PD symptoms return). This study characterizes the self-reported health status of PD patients
who experienced OFF-time as compared to those who were stable. METHODS:
Recruited from an online panel maintained by Knowledge Networks, adults with
self-reported doctor-confirmed PD were screened, consented, and completed a crosssectional survey. Frequency of OFF-time was measured using the Unified Parkinson’s
Disease Rating Scale Part IV. Demographics, PD-specific characteristics, the 9-item
Wearing-off Questionnaire (WOQ-9), the Short Form-12v2 (SF-12), and the Parkinson’s Disease Questionnaire-8 (PDQ-8) were also assessed. RESULTS: Data were
available for 165 PD patients (mean age = 66.6 years; 52.7% male; mean time from
diagnosis = 7.1 years). Twenty-five (15%) of the patients reported experiencing no
OFF-time on a typical day and were classified as stable; the remaining 85% reported
experiencing OFF-time. There were few significant differences between the two groups
in terms of demographics and PD history. Compared to those experiencing OFF-time,
stable patients reported fewer motor and non-motor wearing-off symptoms based on
the WOQ-9 (P < 0.05), as well as better health on the Physical and Mental Component
Summary scores of the SF-12 (P < 0.05) and the Summary Index score of the PDQ-8
(P < 0.01). CONCLUSIONS: PD patients who experienced at least some OFF-time
on a typical day reported worse overall physical and mental well-being than stable
patients. Furthermore, both motor and non-motor wearing-off symptoms differed
between the two patient groups. Additional research to understand the consequences
of OFF-time would be useful, especially as it pertains to non-motor symptoms.
PND37
PATIENT AND PHYSICIAN GLOBAL PERCEPTION OF LEVODOPA/
CARBIDOPA/ENTACAPONE VS. LEVODOPA/CARBIDOPA IN PATIENTS
WITH PARKINSON’S DISEASE EXPERIENCING EARLY WEARING-OFF
Ruyra J1, Balañá M1, Lahoz R1, Hernandez B2, Tolosa E2
1
Novartis Farmacéutica S.A., Barcelona, Spain; 2Hospital Clínic de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: To compare patients’ and physicians’ global perceptions of Parkinson’s
disease (PD) in two treatment groups: levodopa/carbidopa/entacapone (LCE) vs.
levodopa/carbidopa (LC). METHODS: Multicentre, double-blind, randomised phase
IV study. Ninety-five PD patients with early wearing-off (WO) and deterioration of
activities of daily living (ADLs) were randomised to receive LCE (n = 46) or LC (n =
49) with a 3-month follow-up. Patient and physician global perception of PD was
assessed at the end of the study. The PDQ-39 quality of life (QoL) questionnaire, and
the longitudinal course of PD using the different parts of UPDRS (part I, part II, part
III, and IV) were evaluated along the study. Differences between health improvement
by patient and physician were analyzed by the Mann Whitney U-test. The mean differences from baseline to final visit in PDQ-39 and in UPDRS (part I, II, IIII IV) score
were analyzed by an ANCOVA model. RESULTS: Mean (SD) age was 66.4 ± 8.6
years and 50.0% were women. Half percent of patients showed stage II according to
the Hoehn and Yahr classification. Patient global perception showed a significant
better score in the LCE than in LC group (−0.9 ± 1.0 LCE and −0.4 ± 1.17 LC, p =
0. 0291). Similar results were obtained by the physician (−0.3 ± 0.8 vs. −0.4, p = 0.
0017). The adjusted mean differences in the PDQ-39 showed a trend for a higher
improvement in QoL in the LCE group (6.3 ± 20.4 vs. 0.81 ± 15.6), although did not
reach statistical significance. The UPDRS evaluation showed a significant higher
13th Euro Abstracts
response in part II and III (p = 0.0078 and p = 0.0072, respectively). a trend to better
results for the LCE group was observed in part I and IV. CONCLUSIONS: Levodopa/
carbidopa/entacapone shows a significant better patient and physician global perception in the LCE treatment group vs. LC group in PD patients with early WO and
ADLs deterioration.
PND38
DIFFICULTIES IN IDENTIFYING THE ORIGINAL SOURCE
QUESTIONNAIRE FOR USE IN TRANSLATIONS: THE ADAS-COG CASE
STUDY
Anfray C1, Giroudet C1, Berne C2, Acquadro C2
1
MAPI Institute, Lyon, France; 2MAPI Research Trust, Lyon, France
OBJECTIVES: Since its development in the 80’s, variations of the Alzheimer’s Disease
Assessment Scale-Cognitive subscale (ADAS-Cog), a Clinician-Reported Outcome
(ClinRO) measure, have been used to monitor disease progression and treatment
efficacy in Alzheimer’s disease. The objective of this study was to identify all versions
used as a basis for translation in Mapi Institute projects and to take stock of existing
translations. METHODS: The review was based on all ADAS-Cog translation projects
performed by Mapi Institute. RESULTS: Sixteen projects were identified representing
a total of 70 languages and 219 translations. Translations were based on 11 source
versions which differed in terms of content (number of items, order of items and
instructions), and format. The number of items ranged from 11 to 15. Four studies
used 13 items, but only in two cases the same items were used although in a different
order. Four studies used 12 items: only two studies used the same items (with a different list of words for the Word Recognition Task), but again in a different order.
Format and instructions differed in all cases. In most projects the source version
provided by the sponsor was a single document mixing instructions with the rater and
response forms. Only in 3 cases the original consisted in a separate instruction manual
and response forms. With regard to available translations, more than one translation
was identified in 56 of the 70 available languages and in one language (Swedish) as
many as 7 translations. CONCLUSIONS: The abundance of different versions of the
same questionnaire both in its original US English form as in translations makes
comparisons between studies or pooling of data difficult for both researchers and
users. In the light of FDA’s recent PRO guidance it would be beneficial to demand
the same scientific rigor when using ClinROs in international studies.
PND39
RESPONSIVENESS OF THE MULTIPLE SCLEROSIS INTERNATIONAL
QUALITY OF LIFE QUESTIONNAIRE TO EXPANDED DISABILITY
STATUS SCALE SCORE CHANGES IN PATIENTS WITH MULTIPLE
SCLEROSIS: MONTH 12 RESULTS FROM AN INTERNATIONAL
OBSERVATIONAL STUDY
Auquier P1, Fernandez O2, Butzkueven H3, Flachenecker P4, Idiman E5, Pelletier J1,
Stecchi S6, Verdun di Cantogno E7, Issard D7, Simeoni MC1
1
Timone University Hospital, Marseille, France; 2Hospital Regional Universitario Carlos Haya,
Málaga, Spain; 3Royal Melbourne Hospital, Melbourne, Australia; 4Neurological Rehabilitation
Center Quellenhof, Bad Wildbad, Germany; 5Dokuz Eylül University, Ýzmir, Turkey; 6UO
Riabilitazione e Sclerosi Multipla, Bologna, Italy; 7Merck Serono S.A., Geneva, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: Quality of life (QoL) is an important measure that is often overlooked
in the assessment of multiple sclerosis (MS). The MS International QoL (MusiQoL)
questionnaire is a validated, MS-specific instrument. This study aimed to assess the
responsiveness of the MusiQoL questionnaire to changes in Expanded Disability
Status Scale (EDSS) scores in patients with MS. METHODS: In this ongoing,
24-month, multicentre, observational study, MusiQoL and EDSS scores were recorded
at baseline (BL) and at 6-month intervals. The primary endpoint is change in MusiQoL
index score from BL to month 24 (including effect size). Secondary endpoints include
change in MusiQoL index score from BL to month 12 and change in MusiQoL scale
scores. RESULTS: Of 600 patients enrolled, 474 had evaluable BL and month-12
EDSS and MusiQoL index data. At BL, mean (SD) EDSS score was 2.9 (1.9); mean
(SD) MusiQoL index score was 68.5 (14.4); and mean (SD) MusiQoL scale scores
ranged from 59.9 (24.8) to 85.4 (18.5). At month 12, 68 patients (14.3%) had a worse
EDSS score than that recorded at BL. Mean (SD) change in MusiQoL index score was
0.48 (10.99) overall, and −1.00 (9.88) in “worsened” patients; effect sizes were 0.03
and −0.08, respectively. Changes from BL to month 12 in MusiQoL scale scores were
mostly small. However, there were larger (mean [SD]) decreases in some subscales at
month 12 for “worsened” patients: “Activities-of-daily-living” (−4.20 [18.07]); “Relationship-with-family” (−5.14 [23.43]); ‘Sentimental-and-sexual-life’ (−4.11 [17.56]);
and ‘Relationship-with-health care-system’ (−3.56 [14.11]). Effect sizes were −0.17,
−0.25, −0.14 and −0.21 respectively. Conversely, the mean (SD) change in ‘Symptoms’
score was 5.36 (17.27) at month 12 for ‘worsened’ patients (effect size: 0.24). CONCLUSIONS: As expected, most MusiQoL scores decreased over 12 months in patients
with worsening EDSS scores, indicating poorer QoL and confirming the utility of the
MS-specific MusiQoL in rating QoL.
A395
PND40
QUALITY OF LIFE OF CAREGIVERS IN HUNTINGTON’S DISEASE—FIRST
RESULTS FROM EURO-HDB STUDY
Dorey J1, Clay E1, Aubeeluck A2, Verny C3, Aballea S1, Squitieri F4, Toumi M5
1
Creativ Ceutical, Paris, France; 2University of Nottingham, Derby, UK; 3Neurology Unit
CHU, Angers, France; 4Neurogenetics and Rare Disease Centre, Pozzi, Italy; 5University
Claude Bernard Lyon 1, Lyon, France
OBJECTIVES: Huntington’s disease (HD) is a rare neurodegenerative disease leading
to sustained disability for patients and poor quality of life (QoL) for patients as well
as caregivers. This study investigated the impact of HD on caregivers’ QoL and its
drivers. METHODS: The European HD burden study (Euro-HDB) is an ongoing
cross-sectional survey among HR patients and their caregivers in six countries (France,
Italy, Germany, UK, Sweden and Spain). The Huntington’s disease Quality of Life
Battery for Carers (HDQoL-C) short-version, a previously validated questionnaire by
Aubeeluck A. and Buchanan H., was administered. Pearson correlations with generic
HR-QOL (SF36, EQ5D) and the specific HR-QOL in HD for patients (HQOLI) were
evaluated. The determinants of caregiver QOL among drivers among patients’ clinical
characteristics (voluntary movement disorders, chorea, depression/anxiety, psychotic
disorder, cognition, temper) were studied by regression analysis adjusting on age, sex
and occupational categories. The relationship between QOL of patients and caregivers
were also explored. RESULTS: To date, 201 caregivers in France and 124 in Italy
have been enrolled. For France (respectively Italy) 6% (12%) were completely unsatisfied by their overall QOL and 7% (5%) were totally satisfied. HDQoL-C scores were
poorly correlated with generic caregiver HR-QOL: correlation equaled 0.31 for EQ5D
utility and varied between 0.04 and 0.45 for the eight domains of SF36. Correlation
was quite high (0.59; P < 0.01) between HDQoL-C and HQOLI. Drivers of caregiver’s
QoL were voluntary movement disorders (p = 0.049), depression/anxiety (p = 0.02),
psychotic disorder (p = 0.01) and cognition (p = 0.01). Temper and chorea were not
drivers of caregivers’ QOL independently of other clinical characteristics. CONCLUSIONS: Caregivers QOL worsens as the patient clinical characteristics deteriorate
especially voluntary movement disorders, depression/anxiety, psychotic disorders and
cognition disorders. Patients and caregiver QoL was indirectly correlated via patient
clinical scores. The potential impact on caregiver QOL should be considered in evaluations of innovative HD treatments.
PND41
THE IMPACT OF PAIN SEVERITY AND FREQUENCY ON HRQOL IN THE
BIG 5 EUROPEAN UNION COUNTRIES
Langley PC1, Liedgens H2
1
University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN, USA; 2Gruenenthal GmbH, Aachen, Germany
OBJECTIVES: This study assesses, for an estimated EU pain population of 50 million
patients, the impact of pain severity and frequency on three dimensions of health
related quality of life (HRQoL): the SF-12 MCS and PCS scores and (ii) the SF-6D
absolute utility scores. METHODS: The study is based on data from the internet based
2008 National Health and Wellness Survey undertaken in the UK, France, Spain,
Germany and Italy. This study identified 11,000 respondents (1 in 5 of the estimated
big 5 EU countries) who had experienced pain in the last month. The assessment of
the quantitative impact of pain status on HRQoL is estimated via three single equation
generalized linear (ordinary least squares) models which estimate the impact of pain
on PCS, MCS and utility scores. The model includes a range of variables which have
been shown in previous population studies to impact HRQoL. These include: sociodemographic factors, health risk behaviors, comorbidity status, medication utilization,
duration of medication utilization and satisfaction with care. The experience of pain
is captured by a combination of severity and frequency categorical variables.
RESULTS: Pain has a substantial impact on all three of the dimensions of HRQoL
considered here. Compared to the reference category (mild pain experienced weekly
or less) the presence of severe, daily pain has a substantial impact on SF-12 PCS scores
(−13.85 points); SF-12 MCS scores (−4.72); and SF-6D utilities (−0.147). There is a
marked gradient on scores by severity and frequency of pain experience. The impact
of pain on HRQoL is more significant than the impact of socio-demographic characteristics, health risk factors, comorbidities and the experience of pain medication.
CONCLUSIONS: The presence of moderate and severe pain imposes a significant
burden on persons reporting pain in the big 5 EU countries; the burden increases the
greater the frequency and severity.
PND42
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN SOME INDICATORS INFLUENCING THE
QUALITY OF LIFE OF PEOPLE WITH DOWN’S SYNDROME LOOKED
AFTER IN THE FAMILY AND PARENTAL QUALIFICATION IN
CONNECTION WITH A STUDY CARRIED OUT IN HUNGARY
Harjánné Brantmüller É1, Máté O1, Pál K1, Nagy I1, Kriszbacher I1, Boncz I1, Sándor J2
1
University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary; 2University of Debrecen, Debrecen, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: The aim of the study was to survey some objective and subjective
indicators determining the quality of life of people with Down’s syndrome (DS), born
between 1975 and 2005, looked after in their families in the Southern-Transdanubian
region of Hungary. The relationship between the parental level of education and the
above factors was explored. METHODS: On the basis of the VRONY database
(National Registry of Congenital Anomalies) health visitors contacted families looking
after DS people (N = 107), and conducted anonymous, questionnaire surveys in
2008–2009. Reading was examined from school-age (N = 79), drawing and writing
was examined depending on age. RESULTS: The abilities under examination moved
A396
on a wide range. The increase of the mother’s educational level is in significantly positive relationship with the DS person’s computing (khi2 = 14,314, p = 0,026), drawing/
writing (khi2 = 21,027, p = 0,002) and reading (khi2 = 22,169, p = 0.001) performance. It has a favourable effect on the development of the basic self-supporting skills
(khi2 = 25,571, P < 0.001), and the DS person’s social connections. The majority of
those lacking friends live with mothers with the lowest qualification (khi2 = 9.799, p
= 0.02). The level of happiness was measured on a four-grade scale. Owing to a mental
retardation of medium gravity, surveying was carried out in an indirect way, by
questioning the parents. The higher parental qualifications associated with happier DS
people (khi2 = 17,344, p = 0.008). The parents’ educational levels are correlated (r =
0.609, P < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: More qualified parents provide supportive environment rich in stimuli. Higher level of development reduces the DS person’s dependence on others, increases their self-estimation, the level of happiness and through this
the quality of life improves. It means a smaller burden on the health care system, the
society and the family. However the professionals taking part in family support must
be reminded that not every family can perform special child educational tasks independently, and they need more intensive family support.
NEUROLOGICAL DISORDERS – Health Care Use & Policy Studies
PND43
IMPACT OF MEMANTINE TREATMENT INITIATION ON
PSYCHOTROPICS USE: ANALYSES WITH THE RAMQ DATABASE
Lachaine J1, Beauchemin C1, Legault M2, Bineau S3
1
University of Montreal, Montreal, QC, Canada, 2Lundbeck Canada Inc., Montreal, QC,
Canada; 3Lundbeck SAS, Issy-Les-Moulineaux, France
OBJECTIVES: Behavioural and psychological symptoms of dementia such as aggressiveness, agitation and psychosis are common and very distressful for Alzheimer’s
disease patients and their caregivers. Their occurrence leads to an increased use of
psychotropic medications. Memantine treatment has demonstrated significant benefit
on these symptoms in the experimental setting of randomized clinical trials. The
objective of this study was to assess the impact of memantine treatment initiation on
the use of psychotropic medications in real life practice. METHODS: A retrospective
prescription claims analysis was conducted using the Quebec provincial public health
plan (RAMQ) database. Data on medical and pharmaceutical services were obtained
for the period from January 2004 to March 2009 for a random sample of patients
who received at least one scripts of memantine. Trends in the proportion of patients
using psychotropic drugs, antidepressants, neuroleptics, and anti-anxiety agents were
estimated one year before and after the first prescription of memantine. RESULTS:
Data were obtained from the RAMQ for a total of 2,007 patients. The study sample
was 82.2 years old on average (SD = 7.6), with 67.6% of female. Proportion of
patients using a psychotropic drug in the year preceding the initiation of memantine
increased by 58.5%, from a proportion of 0.450 to 0.713 while this proportion only
increased by 3.5% (0.713 to 0.738) in the year following the memantine initiation.
The increase in proportion of users of antidepressants, neuroleptics, and anti-anxiety
agents before and after initiation of memantine were 48.3% (0.239 to 0.354) vs. 2.8%
(0.354 to 0.364), 112.1% (0.219 to 0.465) vs. 1.9% (0.465 to 0.474) and 41.3%
(0.175 to 0.247) vs. 1.5% (0.247 to 0.250) respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Results of
this prescription claims analysis indicate that the increasing rate of psychotropic drugs,
antidepressants, neuroleptics, and anti-anxiety agents use significantly decrease after
the initiation of memantine.
PND44
HEALTH RELATED QUALITY OF LIFE DEFICITS IN MULTIPLE
SCLEROSIS: A POPULATION CONTROL ANALYSIS
Langley P1, Wagner JS2, Gupta S3
1
University of Minnesota, Tucson, AZ, USA; 2Kantar Health, New York, NY, USA; 3Kantar
Health, Princeton, NJ, USA
OBJECTIVES: Existing assessments of the health related quality of life (HRQoL) in
patients with multiple sclerosis have focused on persons with the disease. What has
not been assessed is the extent to which the presence of multiple sclerosis generates
HRQoL deficits compared to the general population. METHODS: Data are from the
internet-based 2008 National Health and Wellness Survey in the UK, France, Spain,
Italy and Germany. a total of 53,524 respondents completed the survey form, of whom
308 indicated they had a diagnosis of multiple sclerosis. Respondents completed the
SF-12 generic HRQoL instrument. The analysis is based on the summary mental
component scores (MCS), physical component scores (PCS) and health state utilities
from the SF-6D items derived from the SF-12 instrument. a multivariate analysis (using
ordinary least squares) was undertaken with the MCS, PCS and SF-6D utilities as
dependent variables. The independent variables included a binary variable for the
presence/absence of multiple sclerosis, socio-demographic characteristics, health risk
factors (e.g., body mass index), country dummy variables and the Charlson Comorbidity Index (CCI). RESULTS: Persons reporting multiple sclerosis had substantially
lower PCS scores (32.19 vs. 48.66; t = 24.60); MCS scores (39.78 vs. 46.53; t = 10.18)
and utility scores (0.57 vs. 0.72; t = 23.57). In the multivariate modeling, the deficit
associated with the presence of multiple sclerosis was substantially greater than any
other independent variable in the PCS (−12.07; 95% CI: −14.02 to −10.12) and utility
models (−0.11; 95% CI: −0.13 to −0.09). The utility decrement in the SF-6D model
attributed to multiple sclerosis far outweighed the utility deficits attributable to the
other independent variables. CONCLUSIONS: Compared to the non-multiple sclero-
13th Euro Abstracts
sis population, there are substantial HRQoL deficits associated with the diagnosis of
multiple sclerosis. These deficits are substantial and far outweigh those attributable
to socio-demographic characteristics, health risk factors and the presence of
comorbidities.
PND45
MANAGEMENT OF DRUG RESISTANT EPILEPSIES: HTA REPORT FOR
THREE ITALIAN REGIONS
Lopatriello S1, Berto P1, Canevini MP2, Colicchio G3, Rubboli G4, Spreafico R5, Tassi L6,
Tinuper P7
1
Pbe Consulting, Verona, Italy; 2Università degli Studi- Azienda Ospedaliera San Paolo,
Milano, Italy; 3Policlinico Gemelli, Roma, Italy; 4Ospedale Bellaria, Bologna, Italy; 5Fondazione
I.R.C.C.S. Istituto Neurologico Carlo Besta, Milano, Italy; 6Azienda Ospedaliera Niguarda,
Milano, Italy; 7Università di Bologna, Bologna, Italy
OBJECTIVES: Management of drug-resistant epileptic patients includes different surgical alternatives. The target patient (i.e. resistant to at least 2 anti-epileptic drugs)
may undergo neurosurgery or Vagal Nerve Stimulation (VNS). Scope of this work
was to estimate hospital costs for neurosurgery and VNS and compare with Regional
funding. METHODS: Investigated phases were: Non-Invasive Diagnostics-NID,
Invasive-ID, Neurosurgery Intervention-NI or VNS-I, FollowUP-FUP, in 6 referral
centres. Average/patient cost was estimated by microcosting; resource consumption
by questionnaire; unit costs valued by full hospital costs (staff, operating-room, hospital-stay), outpatient-tariffs (diagnostics), market-prices (drugs, devices) at 2010
values. RESULTS: NID-phase: c5070/adult (c3516-c7356) and c4382/child. Ranges
reflect variability of hospital-stay and staff time; 79% of total cost is due to diagnostics. DI-phase costs c15,900/adult (37%) and c16,261/child (44%). The cost range
for adults (c14,098-c17,702) reflects variability of invasive video-EEG protocols.
Regional funding is under-remunerative. Considering individual procedures, videoEEG costs c3,406/adult (cost driver: staff workload); invasive-video-EEG c34,790
(driver: electrodes). For children, video-EEG costs c3,063 and invasive-video-EEG
c27,619; lower values are due to higher seizures frequency and shorter duration of
recordings. Neurosurgery intervention cost is c16,230/adult and c18,894/child. For
adults, variability (c14,730-c18,513) depends on the duration of intervention, number
and cost of staffs. Intervention cost is similar in the three Regions and hospital imbalance is the result of under-funding by regional tariffs. VNS insertion cost is c24,543/
adult (c3,518 for the intervention). Under-remuneration by tariffs is confirmed, even
considering regional extra-tariffs for the device. Global treatment path for an adult
(NID + intervention + FUP 5°yrs) amounts to c23,571-NI and c33,373-VNSI; for a
child c20,066-NI. Regional data: Lombardy, c23,571-NI and c32,244-VNSI, for
Lazio c25,571-NI and c34,176-VNSI, for Emilia Romagna c22,886-NI and c34,871VNSI. CONCLUSIONS: Funding of the management of resistant epilepsies in the
target patient appears insufficient to cover costs actually incurred by Italian hospitals,
irrespective of organization and Regional funding.
NEUROLOGICAL DISORDERS – Conceptual Papers & Research on Methods
PND46
NON-LOCAL PATIENT-LEVEL DATA FOR COST-EFFECTIVENESS
ADAPTATION TO THE SWEDISH ENVIRONMENT
Chowdhury CA1, Cuche M2, Nilsson M3, de Bustamante MM1, Lukasik KD1,
Castañeda EC1
1
Insight Strategy Advisors, New York, NY, USA; 2Merck Serono S.A., Geneva, Switzerland;
3
Merck AB, Stockholm, Sweden
BACKGROUND: Currently, data-access barriers exist throughout key European
health-technology assessment countries, including Sweden. Patient registries are of
limited use due to frequent lapses in data integrity, completeness and limitations
around access to these data. Additionally, data-protection legislation often prohibits
the use of existing data from providers and insurance funds. These limitations hinder
the development of longitudinal health-technology assessments required to evaluate
the cost-effectiveness of new and existing therapeutics. OBJECTIVES: To explore the
opportunities and limitations of applying non-local, longitudinal, patient-level treatment and outcomes data to the Swedish environment. METHODS: A large, longitudinal, patient-level treatment and outcomes data set (>55 million US patients from
>90 health insurance plans) from the USA was used to create a sample of patients
with multiple sclerosis who were undergoing treatment with disease-modifying drugs.
Patient outcomes were evaluated with regard to the extent to which patients were
adherent to therapy. Based on adherence levels, patient tendency to use incremental
health care system resources was assessed. Adaptation to the local Swedish environment was performed by incorporating or acknowledging customary aspects of the
Dental and Pharmaceutical Benefits Board (Tandvårds-och läkemedelsförmånsverket)
cost-benefit analysis. Costs of outcomes, specifically interventions as a result of nonadherence, were based on Swedish cost-estimates from prior independent research.
CONCLUSIONS: When performing a cost-effectiveness analysis, incorporation of
patient-level data from another country invokes caveats on the results, including differences in access to care, cultural attitudes and social beliefs. However, in the absence
of accessible local data, complete and sufficient data from another country (e.g., the
USA) can serve as a surrogate. This may limit the broad acceptance of the study’s
results; however, it provides quantitatively supported and customized results based
upon a robust data set, upon which health care decision-makers can derive resource
allocation and prescribing decisions.
A397
13th Euro Abstracts
PND47
APPLICATION OF THE KANO METHODOLOGY FOR EVALUATING
MIGRAINE TREATMENT EXPECTATIONS AMONG PATIENTS TREATED
BY NEUROLOGISTS IN SPAIN: THE MIGREXX STUDY
Matias J1, Nocea G2, Caloto T2
1
Hospital Universitario San Carlos, Madrid, Spain; 2Merck Sharp & Dohme, SA, Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: To classify the characteristics and properties of the pharmacological
treatments among migraine patients treated by neurologists in Spain. Patients are
becoming increasingly implicated in treatment decisions. Expectations in relation to
therapy largely condition satisfaction with the results obtained. METHODS: Multicenter, cross-sectional study in adult patients with at least one prescription of antimigraine drugs within the last year. The protocol was approved by the CREC of La
Princesa University Hospital (Madrid). Sociodemographic, and clinical characteristics
of patients, as well as questions regarding their expectations with regard to migraine
treatments and evaluation of the importance of their attributes are documented. Using
a treatment expectations questionnaire and applying Kano methodology, sixteen treatment attributes were classified as: Must-be, One-dimensional, Attractive, Indifferent,
Reverse or Questionable. Patients were required to give informed consent. RESULTS:
68 neurologists included 174 patients diagnosed with migraine (mean age 39 years;
75% women). None of the attributes were considered “Must-be”. The attributes
considered by most patients to be “One-dimensional” were the absence of long-term
adverse effects (55%), to allow work/study activities (50%), to allow social and family
relationship (50%), achievement of symptoms relief (47%) and pain relief (44.3%).
The attributes considered “Attractive” by most patients were: achievement of rapid
symptoms and pain relief (54%), and achievement of total disappearance of the pain
(53.4%). The attributes that led to a greater dissatisfaction were the occurrence of
long-term adverse effects, not to allow work activity or studies and not to achieve
pain relief. The three attributes that led to a greater satisfaction were achievement of
total disappearance of the symptoms and the pain, and rapid pain relief. CONCLUSIONS: The expectations regarding a medical treatment significantly influence the satisfaction reached with the outcome of such treatment. a better knowledge of patient’s
expectations can lead to a greater satisfaction associated with treatment outcomes.
PND48
MODIFIED LAST OBSERVATION CARRIED FORWARD IS A SUPERIOR
METHOD OF IMPUTATION
DeGryse R, Lei X, Fainaru I, Turkel C
Allergan, Inc., Irvine, CA, USA
OBJECTIVES: To compare imputation methods using PREEMPT (Phase III REsearch
Evaluating Migraine Prophylaxis Therapy) clinical data. METHODS: Data were
analyzed from two phase 3 studies of onabotulinumtoxinA in chronic migraine
(ICHD-II migraine and ≥15 headache days/month). Each study included a 24-week,
randomized, double-blind, parallel-group, placebo-controlled phase, followed by a
32-week, open-label onabotulinumtoxinA treatment phase. The prespecified method
of imputation of missing data (ie, <20 days of diary data in a 28-day period) was
modified last observation carried forward (mLOCF), which estimated missing data by
iteratively multiplying the subject’s most recent count by the subsequent average
change rate across treatments. We compared mLOCF with last observation carried
forward (LOCF), baseline observation carried forward (BOCF), mLOCF withintreatment (mLOCFw), and observed data (without imputation). Simulations to predict
known data were analyzed using mLOCF, LOCF, and BOCF. RESULTS: 1384 adults
were randomized (PREEMPT1: onabotulinumtoxinA [n = 341], placebo [n = 338];
PREEMPT2: onabotulinumtoxinA [n = 347], placebo [n = 358]). 1026 (74%) of the
subjects had no missing monthly counts during the double-blind phase (PREEMPT1:
onabotulinumtoxinA [n = 242], placebo [n = 248]; PREEMPT2: onabotulinumtoxinA
[n = 258], placebo [n = 278]). Each imputation method (mLOCF, LOCF, BOCF,
mLOCFw) and observed data generated a similar statistically significant betweengroup difference for the primary efficacy endpoint of headache-day counts at Week
24 in PREEMPT2 (P < 0.001). Similar results were observed within PREEMPT1 (P <
0.02). Compared to LOCF and BOCF, mLOCF was superior at predicting known
values of headache-day counts in simulations that randomly set observed scores to
missing, as demonstrated by least-squared errors of imputed minus actual counts.
CONCLUSIONS: PREEMPT treatment differences were similar (and statistically significant) using each imputation method, likely due to low dropout rates within each
treatment group. Compared to LOCF and BOCF, mLOCF was superior at predicting
known data.
SENSORY SYSTEMS DISORDERS – Clinical Outcomes Studies
PSS1
META-ANALYSIS OF PARTIALLY HYDROLYZED 100%-WHEY FORMULA
VERSUS EXTENSIVELY HYDROLYZED FORMULAS IN THE PREVENTION
OF ATOPIC DERMATITIS
Iskedjian M1, Szajewska H2, Spieldenner J3, Farah B4, Berbari J4, Navarro V5
1
PharmIdeas Research and Consulting Inc., Oakville, ON, Canada; 2Medical University of
Warsaw, Warsaw, Poland; 3Nestlé Nutrition Institute, Vevey, Switzerland; 4PharmIdeas
Research and Consulting Inc., Ottawa, ON, Canada; 5PharmIdeas Europe SAS, Lyon, France
OBJECTIVES: The incidence rates of atopic dermatitis (AD) and relative risks (RR)
associated to a brand of partially hydrolyzed 100% whey formula manufactured by
Nestlé (PHF-W) and to extensively hydrolyzed formulas (EHF-Whey or Casein) were
reported for the prevention of AD in infants who are not exclusively breastfed.
METHODS: Szajewska et al. had previously undertaken a meta-analysis determining
the incidence rates and RRs of PHF-W compared to cow’s milk formula (CMF) and
EHF but details were not for provided for PHF-W vs. EHF. This analysis sheds light
on the latter comparisons and extends the analyses to 3-month cycles from birth to
36-months of age. Included were any relevant randomized controlled trials comparing
the use of PHF-W with CMF or EHF for the prevention of allergies. The primary
outcomes of interest were the incidence, cumulative incidence and period prevalence
of any allergic manifestations and AD in particular. Of 84 retrieved citations, 15
studies were included for analysis of which 6 studies pertained to PHF-W vs. EHF.
All efficacy data were converted into inputs for a spreadsheet decision-analytic economic model based on 3-month cycles by applying weights derived from the Szajewska
et al. meta-analysis and calculating them at 3-month intervals for input into an economic model. RESULTS: The analysis sample included 557, 559 and 580 patients for
PHF-W, EHF-Whey and EHF-Casein, respectively. a RR of 0.75 [0.54,1.05] at 0–12
months and 0.80 [0.63,1.02] at 0–36 months was obtained for PHF-W vs. EHF-Whey
while a RR of 1.06 [0.74,1.53] at 0–12 months and 1.13 [0.87,1.47] at 0–36 months
was determined for PHF-W vs. EHF-Casein. All efficacy data were adapted into
3-month indicators. CONCLUSIONS: It appears that the efficacy of PHF-W falls
within the range of the other two extensively hydrolyzed formulas.
SENSORY SYSTEMS DISORDERS – Cost Studies
PSS2
USE OF INCREASED DOSAGES OF BIOLOGICS IN PLAQUE PSORIASIS
AND POTENTIAL SAVINGS BY TREATING HIGH-DOSE PATIENTS WITH
USTEKINUMAB INSTEAD—A BUDGET IMPACT MODEL
Klesse M, Wolbring F
Janssen-Cilag GmbH, Neuss, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Evaluation of real-life dosing of biologics in plaque psoriasis in
Germany and the potential savings by treating patients with ustekinumab instead of
using higher doses of TNF-alpha-inhibitors. METHODS: Based on an online survey
among 100 dermatologists (DocCheck Medical Services, December 2009) the use of
biologics and their dosing distribution for the treatment of plaque psoriasis was evaluated. The proportion of patients receiving maintenance dosages according to label and
those receiving a higher dose were evaluated for each biologic separately. a budget
impact model was created estimating potential savings by treating patients with
ustekinumab according to label (45 mg in patients ≤100 kg body weight and 90 mg
in patients >100 kg body weight) instead of high dose TNF-alpha-inhibitors in terms
of annual medication costs. In this model, costs of the current usage pattern of biologics were estimated using German pharmacy prices (source: Lauer-Taxe, version June
1, 2010, most economical pack size). RESULTS: In most cases biologic treatments are
used according to the respective labels. In some instances, deviating dosages are used:
14% of adalimumab-treated patients receive an increased dosage of 40 mg every week
or 80 mg eow, and more than 15% of etanercept-treated patients receive 50 mg twice
weekly or another deviating dosage as maintenance therapy. 27% of infliximabtreated patients receive maintenance injections more frequently than every 8 weeks or
receive an increased dosage per injection. In Germany, assuming 80% of those highdose-TNF-alpha-inhibitor-treated patients are treated with ustekinumab instead, this
would result in savings of approximately c18 million per year. If induction costs of
ustekinumab are considered additionally, still c13 million could be saved within one
year. CONCLUSIONS: Using ustekinumab instead of high dosages of TNF-alphainhibitors for treatment of plaque psoriasis can generate significant savings in medication costs in Germany.
PSS3
EPIDEMIOLOGY, COSTS AND QUALITY OF LIFE IN PATIENT WITH
SEVERE CHRONIC HAND ECZEMA
Cortesi PA1, Scalone L1, De Pità O2, Gallo R3, Angelini G4, Cristaudo A5, Girolomoni G6,
Lotti T7, Ayala F8, Cannavò SP9, Cottoni F10, Lisi P11, Peserico A12, Pigatto P13, Mantovani
LG14, Belisari A15, Giannetti A16
1
University of Milano—Bicocca, Monza, Italy; 2Istituto Dermopatico dell’Immacolata
(IDI)-IRCCS, Roma, Italy; 3Di.S.E.M., University of Genoa, Genova, Italy; 4University of Bari,
Bari, Italy; 5Istituto Dermatologico San Gallicano IRCCS, Roma, Italy; 6University of Verona,
Verona, Italy; 7University of Florence, Firenze, Italy; 8University Federico II of Naples, Napoli,
Italy; 9University of Messina, Messina, Italy; 10University of Sassari, Sassari, Italy; 11University of
Perugia, Perugia, Italy; 12University of Padua, Padova, Italy; 13University of Milan, Milano, Italy;
14
CIRFF, Federico II University, Naples, Italy; 15CHARTA Foundation, Milano, Italy; 16University
of Modena, Modena, Italy
OBJECTIVES: Some research has shown that Hand Eczema is often work-related,
widespread, potentially disabling and costly disease, but misdiagnosed and mistreated.
Severe Chronic Hand Eczema (CHE) can be particularly burdensome. We aimed to
assess prevalence, costs and HRQoL in patients with severe CHE. METHODS: A
naturalistic, multicentre, epidemiologic and cost-of-illness study is being conducted in
14 Italian dermatological centers. HE patients aged ≥18 years are being enrolled
through a 6-month period. The following data are being collected: socio-demographic,
clinical (severity, chronicity and responsiveness to treatment with topical potent corticosteroids) and, among chronic, severe and refractory patients, data on HRQol
A398
(EQ-5D and the condition specific Dermatitis-Life-Quality-Index (DLQI)), direct and
indirect costs, from the societal perspective. RESULTS: A preliminary sample of 305
patients (mean age + SD = 41.4 + 14.9, 38.2% male) were enrolled. Two hundred
fifty five patients (83.6%) had CHE and of these the 27.8% were severe. Overall,
20.0% of the enrolled patients were chronic, severe and refractory to therapy. DLQI
mean + SD sum score was 10.38 + 5.98. With EQ-5D 92.7% of patients reported
moderate or severe pain/discomfort, 70.9% problems with usual activities, 58.2%
anxiety/depression and 40% problems with self-care. VAS mean + SD = 61.96 + 21.48.
On average hospitalization cost c87.90/patient-month, travels due to CHE cost
c69.54/patient-month, specialist visit costs c52.81/patient-month, other products
(gloves, gauze bandage, vacuum cleaner, cosmetics) costs c35.70/patient-month, diagnostic exam costs c20.77/patient-month, non pharmacological therapy (emollients,
galenic products, soap, UV-ray) cost c15.65/patient-month and pharmacological
therapy cost c9.22/patient-month. Patients lost a mean + SD 4.35 + 8.68 workdays/
patient-month for reasons attributable to their condition. CONCLUSIONS: most of
the patients in the Italian centers of dermatology have CHE and a fifth are severe and
refractory to therapy. Patients with severe CHE and refractoriness to therapy have
poor HRQoL and high costs. a correct diagnosis and treatment is necessary to efficiently manage this condition.
PSS4
COST-OF-ILLNESS IN PATIENTS WITH CHRONIC HAND ECZEMA:
RESULTS FROM A MULTI-CENTRE STUDY IN GERMANY
Augustin M1, Purwins S1, Diepgen T2, Posthumus J3, Kuessner D3
1
University Clinics of Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany; 2University Heidelberg, Heidelberg,
Germany; 3Basilea Pharmaceutica, Basel, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: It is assumed broadly that the costs caused by chronic hand eczema
(CHE) are significant. However, there is a lack of cost-of-illness studies on CHE. The
objective of this study is, therefore, to determine the direct and indirect costs of chronic
hand eczema under routine conditions overall and in different treatment stages in
Germany. METHODS: The survey was conducted in 24 outpatient practices and
clinics across Germany. Patients with CHE refractory to potent topical treatments and
insured by statutory health insurances were eligible. Patient characteristics and
resource use were directly gathered from patients and physicians. Costs were evaluated
from the societal perspective. Four treatment stages were defined: only topical treatments (stage I), additionally photo therapy (II), systemic therapy (III) and inpatient
treatment (IV). Bivariate associations between costs and treatment stage were assessed.
RESULTS: A total of 223 CHE patients enrolled in the study. The yearly direct and
indirect costs per patient are c1742 (SE: c139) and c386 (c83), respectively. a total
of 63.2% of patients were treated only with topical treatments; additionally 15.7%
with photo therapy, 11.7% with systemic treatments. a total 9.4% of all patients were
admitted to hospitals. The total costs increase with treatment stage I-IV (P < 0.001):
c1044 (c85), c2307 (c145), c2697 (c461) and c8407 (c991), respectively. Accordingly, costs also correlated with clinical severity. CONCLUSIONS: CHE patients
refractory to topical steroids incur marked costs to the society. The costs are increasing
disproportionately with escalating treatment stages, especially in patients admitted to
hospitals. Hence, new and innovative treatments may help to reduce the societal costs
of CHE.
PSS5
COST OF GLAUCOMA IN THE UNITED KINGDOM ACCORDING TO
THE UK GPRD
Salmon J1, Lafuma A2, Robert J2, Berdeaux G3
1
Oxford Eye Hospital, Oxford, UK; 2CEMKA-EVAL, Bourg la Reine, France; 3Alcon France,
Rueil-Malmaison, France
OBJECTIVES: The objective of this analysis was to estimate the total budget dedicated
to glaucoma care according to the UKGPRD and to identify factors associated with
high costs. METHODS: Data were extracted on patients treated on the National
Health Service with a diagnosis of ocular hypertension or glaucoma, or treated with
topical intraocular lowering treatment, surgery or laser for glaucoma. The budget was
estimated from resources consumed in 2008 and included glaucoma drugs, laser,
surgery, hospitalization, specialist and general practitioner (GP) visits. In-patient
resources were estimated from the Hospital Episode Statistics. Results were expressed
in GBP, 2008. Factors associated with high cost were identified using linear stepwise
regression. National extrapolation was performed according to the relative size of the
GPRD to the UK general populations. RESULTS: Details of 33,441 patients were
extracted, which suggests that about 510,000 patients were treated in the NHS in UK
in 2008. The Mean age was 74.2 years, and 47.3% were male. The initial diagnosis
was made at 67.8 years. Older patients, longer time since diagnosis, a higher number
of previous treatments, a higher number of treatment switches in the previous one
year period and use of laser/surgery were associated with a higher annual cost. Spending varied little between regions. Annual drug spending was £91.2 million on inpatient care, £4.4 million on drug prescription renewal (not specific to the glaucoma
drug). Visits to the GP cost £34.8 million and visits to the eye specialist was >£54.0
million although the latter figure is likely to be an under estimate (GPRD underreported eye doctor care). CONCLUSIONS: The 2008 expenditures to care for glaucoma were >£185 million with no regional differences. Three factors were strongly
associated with high costs: time since diagnosis, treatment changes, and rescue treatment. This analysis suggests that longer treatment persistence is likely to be associated
with cost saving.
13th Euro Abstracts
PSS6
COST OF ILLNESS OF PSORIASIS—A 1-MONTH PROSPECTIVE STUDY
IN SOUTHERN SWEDEN
Ghatnekar O1, Ljungberg A2, Lundqvist T2, Svensson Å3, Wirestrand LE4
1
The Swedish Institute for Health Economics, Lund, Skåne, Sweden; 2Abbott Scandinavia AB,
Solna, Sweden; 3University of Lund, Malmö, Sweden; 4Kristianstad Hospital, Kristianstad,
Sweden
OBJECTIVES: Published cost-of-illness studies of psoriasis in Sweden are not available. This study estimates the societal cost of psoriasis care in a defined Swedish patient
population. METHODS: A prevalence-based prospective recruitment of patients visiting two dermatology clinics in Sweden between September and December 2009 was
performed. Patients collected resource utilization of health care contacts, treatment,
travelling distance and time, and productivity loss (human capital approach) during
1 month (Swedish unit prices, 2009). RESULTS: A total of 164 patients (49% males)
were included; average age 52, 76% plaque psoriasis with PASI 5.7, DLQI 7.7 and
EQ-5D utility weight 0.71. The mean total cost per patient-month was c994. Main
cost drivers were outpatient visits (OP) and light therapy (49%), biological drugs
(20%) and productivity loss (22%). When patients were stratified according to treatment strategy, total costs (fraction of patients) for topical treatment only (TT; 34%)
was c369, light therapy (LT; 24%) c1274, traditional systemic treatment (TST; 26%)
c1085 and biological systemic treatment (BST; 16%) c1709 per patient-month. Main
cost drivers in each treatment strategy were: OP (56%) in TT, OP (78%) in LT,
productivity loss (40%) in TST and biological drugs (71%) in BST. There was no
clear relationship between clinical (PASI) or subjective (DLQI) severity estimations
and costs. CONCLUSIONS: In this study the cost-of-illness for a psoriasis patient
amounts to almost c1000/month, with great variation depending on treatment strategy. Despite the 1200 difference in drug cost for TST vs. BST, total cost per month
differed by c600 because of offsets from improved productivity and reductions in OP
and topical treatment. As expected, biologically treated patients had higher costs but
lower severity probably due to the treatment effectiveness. The relationship between
costs and severity is complex, probably due to the selected study period and differences
in effect between strategies.
PSS7
THE ECONOMIC COST OF TREATING PATIENTS WITH AGE-RELATED
MACULAR DEGENERATION IN SPAIN
Darba J1, Kaskens L2
1
Universitat de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain; 2BCN Health, Barcelona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Wet macular degeneration associated with age (wet-AMD) is the
leading cause of legal blindness in Spain in people over 55. The aim of this study is
to determine health care resource utilization and mean costs per patient with wet-AMD
in 2009. METHODS: A micro-costing analyses was performed to estimate direct
medical costs of patients with wet-AMD. Patient level data was obtained from different public hospitals in Spain and ophthalmologists were surveyed with a semi-structured questionnaire to obtain treatment patterns. Inpatient costs were considered from
the perspective of the public health care system. Treatments under study were pegaptanib, verteporfin, ramibizumab and bavacizumab. Although bevacizumab in Spain is
not approved for wet-AMD, it was used off-label in the hospital. Direct medical costs
considered were drug costs, administration cost, doctors’ visits, nurse time, ophthalmologist time, anaesthetics, ambulant hospital care, external consultation, surgery and
treatment of adverse effects. All costs are referred to 2009. RESULTS: Mean cost per
patient treated with wet-AMD represented the following cost for the public health
care system: c7290 for pegaptanib, c5810c for verteporfin, c8650 for ramibizumab
and c3110 for bevacizumab. We also estimated that in Spain 180,000 people over 50
years have wet-AMD in 2009. CONCLUSIONS: Pharmacological treatments for
wet-AMD are photo dynamic therapy with verteporfin, pegaptanib, verteporfin and
ramibizumab, with the last one having the highest medical costs. The aging of the
population and development of new drugs will probably increase the future economic
impact of AMD, which remains a major health care burden.
PSS8
PREDICTIVE FACTORS OF GLAUCOMA TREATMENT COST IN
GERMANY
Lorenz K1, Wolfram C1, Claus V2, Plesnila-Frank C2, Verboven Y3, Pfeiffer N1
1
Universitätsmedizin Mainz, Mainz, Germany; 2IMS Health, München, Germany; 3Alcon
Research Ltd., Puurs, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: To describe total costs and factors predicting cost in Germany for
glaucoma disease states: ocular hypertension (OHT), and early (EARLY), moderate
(MOD) and advanced (ADV) glaucoma. METHODS: A 5-year retrospective analysis
collected health care utilization, clinical parameters, treatment(s) used and reasons for
treatment change. Disease states defined by the European Glaucoma Society were
applied. Costs for health care resources were based upon the German EBM/OPS code
for ambulatory visits/procedures, diagnosis-related groups for hospital procedures and
the Rote Liste for medication. Factors predicting cost were identified using stepwise
backward multiple linear regression, entry criterion a = 0.2. RESULTS: A total of 154
patients (27 OHT, 43 EARLY, 35 MOD, 49 ADV) were enrolled from 15 centers
across 5 German regions. Average age was 67 ± 11 and 57% were female. Number
of years since diagnosis was 9.0 ± 5.7, 8.7 ± 4.6, 8.7 ± 4.1 and 13.2 ± 8.3 years for
OHT, EARLY, MOD and ADV, respectively. Total costs, for patients with OHT,
EARLY, MOD or ADV, were c226 ± 117, c423 ± 647, c493 ± 385, and c808 ± 877,
respectively. Most costs were due to medication (c121 ± 99, c217 ± 150, c245 ± 161,
c340 ± 193) and hospital interventions (c32 ± 101, c115 ± 538, c154 ± 285, c367 ±
13th Euro Abstracts
811). Other costs included consultations (c54, c63, c64, c58) and examinations (c19,
c26, c26, c26). Factors predicting high cost (R2 = 0.6426) were the number of hospital
interventions, treatment switches, disease state changes, current disease state and issues
with ocular burning, stinging or aching affecting daily activities. For glaucoma patients
having 0, 1, 2 or ≥3 treatment switches this gave total costs of c273 ± 108, c320 ±
231, c511 ± 462 and c932 ± 950, respectively. Medication costs were c177, c187,
c268 and c368, and interventional procedure costs were c0, c50, c166 and c478,
respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Glaucoma treatments (medication and interventional
procedures) are the key cost drivers in management of glaucoma in Germany. Avoiding
treatment switches, disease progression and interventional procedures should have an
impact on the cost of glaucoma care.
PSS9
COSTS OF GLAUCOMA IN SWEDEN—A PILOT STUDY
1
2
3
4
1
Svensson J , Berdeaux G , Bergstrom A , Forsby M , Ghatnekar O
1
IHE, Lund, Sweden; 2Alcon France, Rueil-Malmaison, France; 3Skåne University Hospital,
Lund, Sweden; 4Pygargus AB, Sävedalen, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: To estimate the cost of treatment of glaucoma in Sweden and cost by
treatment change. METHODS: Two private ophthalmologic clinics in southern
Sweden were chosen for a retrospective chart review. Longitudinal data from patients
older than 18 years was extracted from digitalized medical records. a glaucoma
diagnosis (ICD-10: H40) and prescription of glaucoma treatment (ATC: S01E) were
used as search terms to identify patients. Data on outpatient visits, glaucoma related
pharmaceuticals and laser surgery was collected for the period 2004-01-01 to 200906-30. Unit prices from official sources in year 2008. Health care provider costs
incurred during year 2008 were stratified according to the number of treatment
changes. RESULTS: A total of 815 patients with pharmacological treatment were
included in the analysis. Mean age was 77.6, 63% were female, 39% had ocular
hypertension (OHT), 55% primary open angle glaucoma (POAG) and 6% other
glaucoma diagnosis. Mean direct medical cost per patient during 2008 was c393. The
cost per patient varied depending on diagnosis and number of treatment changes since
2004. Costs for patients diagnosed with OHT, POAG and other glaucoma was c341,
c423 and c477, respectively. Patients diagnosed with POAG ranged from c350 (no
change in treatment) to c540 (3 or more changes). Patients with OHT ranged from
c301 (no changes in treatment) to c613 (3 or more changes). Costs were approximately equally split between outpatient visits and drugs regardless of diagnosis or
treatment changes. Regression analysis also revealed that costs were significantly
influenced by years since diagnosis and clinic of enrolment. CONCLUSIONS: The
annual cost of glaucoma treatment in Sweden is estimated to c393 in 2008. Costs
increase with number of treatment changes but also depend on diagnosis, years since
diagnosis and clinic of enrolment. This is in line with other studies.
PSS10
CLINICAL AND COST-EFFECTIVENESS EVALUATION OF A LOW
FRICTION AND SHEAR PRODUCT IN THE MANAGEMENT OF
PATIENTS AT RISK OF SKIN BREAKDOWN WITHIN A HOSPITAL
SETTING
Ingram A1, Smith G2
1
NHS Innovations London, London, UK; 2St Mary’s Hospital, Isle of Wight, Newport, UK
OBJECTIVES: To determine the clinical and cost-effectiveness of the low friction
ParafrictaTM products to reduce pressure ulceration on pre-existing skin breakdown
within a hospital setting. METHODS: Patients admitted to the participating hospital
wards who had a Waterlow score ≥15 and were unable to reposition independently,
were offered the Parafricta products. Assessments of their level of ulceration and
outcome were made over a 3-month period prior to the use of Parafricta products and
then for a further three months during which Parafricta products were used. RESULTS:
A total of 650 patient cases were assessed. Of these, 204 patient cases met the inclusion
criteria in the three months prior to Parafricta use and 165 patient cases during
Parafricta use. The results demonstrated that, in patients at risk of skin breakdown,
there was a statistically significant reduction in the number of patients who developed
ulceration with the use of Parafricta products (16% reduction; p = 0.0286). In addition, the number of patients who were ulcer-free on admission but who developed
ulceration and then went on to improve or completely heal before discharge was also
statistically significant (41% increase; p = 0.0065). Fewer patients admitted with
ulceration deteriorated on the Parafricta products (21% reduction; p = 0.0012). The
results were used to build a cost-effectiveness model and locally derived costs for
length of stay, wound dressings and mattresses, as well as the additional cost of the
Prafricta products were applied to determine the overall costs savings that would result
from the reduction in ulceration on Parafricta products. The base-case model indicated
a saving of over £63,000 per 100 incidences. CONCLUSIONS: The results of this
evaluation support the conclusion that Parafricta products in an acute inpatient
environment have a significant role to play in the avoidance of skin breakdown, and
that they constitute an intervention that is both clinically effective and
cost-effective.
A399
PSS11
THE COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF A NEW GEL FORMULATION OF
CALCIPOTRIOL/BETAMETHASONE DIPROPIONATE FOR THE
TREATMENT OF SCALP PSORIASIS IN NORWAY
Holm MV1, Ekman M2, Ryttov J3
1
LEO Pharma, Ballerup, Denmark; 2i3 Innovus, Stockholm, Sweden; 3LEO Pharma, Marlow,
UK
OBJECTIVES: The study examines the cost-effectiveness of calcipotriol 50 mcg/g plus
betamethasone dipropionate 0.5 mg/g in combination in a new convenient gel formulation for the treatment of scalp psoriasis compared to existing alternatives in Norway.
METHODS: A decision analytic model with a time horizon of 16 weeks was developed. The perspective chosen is that of the Norwegian health care system. Responders
to treatment were defined as cleared or almost cleared and efficacy was derived from
two clinical trials. Relapse rates were estimated from data in the literature. The alternative treatments were betamethasone dipropionate gel and calcipotriol gel, comparators
in the clinical trials, matched to marketed formulations in Norway. Costs of medical
therapy and follow-up management in scalp psoriasis in 2009 were taken from the
Norwegian Medicines Agency and hospital price lists. The outcomes were measured
in QALYs derived from SF-36 collected in one of the clinical trials. RESULTS: The
overall cost for calcipotriol liniment treatment added up to 2340 NOK over 16 weeks
and for calcipotriol/betamethasone dipropionate gel 1497 NOK and betamethasone
dipropionate liniment 1407 NOK (1 NOK = 0.127 EUR). The treatment associated
with the best outcome was calcipotriol/betamethasone dipropionate gel, generating a
gain in change from baseline over 16 weeks of 0.0111 QALYs while calcipotriol generated 0.0091 QALYs and betamethasone dipropionate 0.0106 QALYs. The analysis
showed that calcipotriol/betamethasone dipropionate gel is a dominant treatment
compared to calcipotriol. The ICER was 180,000 NOK per QALY gained compared
to betamethasone dipropionate. The probabilistic sensitivity analysis showed a probability of calcipotriol/betamethasone dipropionate gel being cost-effective of 82% at
a WTP of 400,000 NOK compared to betamethasone dipropionate. CONCLUSIONS:
The new gel formulation of calcipotriol/betamethasone dipropionate indicated for the
treatment of scalp psoriasis is a cost-effective alternative to both calcipotriol liniment
and to betamethasone dipropionate liniment in a Norwegian health care setting.
PSS12
ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF RANIBIZUMAB IN THE TREATMENT OF
AGE-RELATED MACULAR DEGENERATION IN GREECE
Maniadakis N, Athanasakis K, Fragoulakis V, Tsiantou V, Kyriopoulos J
National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece
OBJECTIVES: To investigate the cost-effectiveness of ranibizumab in relation to
verteporfin photodynamic therapy (PDT), pegaptanib sodium and best supportive care
(BSC) for the treatment of Age-Related Macular Degeneration (AMD) at varying
disease states in the Greek health care setting. METHODS: A six-state Markov model
was constructed according to patient visual acuity in the better seeing eye. Data on
effectiveness were derived from randomized controlled trials comparing the outcomes
of ranibizumab 0.5 mg administered over a 2year period (8 injections in the first year
of treatment, 6 in the second) versus other alternative comparators for the treatment
of AMD patients with predominantly classic (PC) lesions and versus BSC and pegaptanib for those with minimally classic (MC) or occult lesions. Resource utilization
reflected the Greek health care setting and was defined via a panel of experts. Economic and clinical outcomes were estimated over a 10year timeframe from the perspective of a third-party payer (social insurance fund), discounted at 3.5% per annum.
RESULTS: the estimated mean 10-year direct treatment cost in the ranibizumab arm
ranged from c24,844 to c32,931 with a projected benefit of 4.50–4.74 Quality
Adjusted Life-years, depending on type of lesion. For PC lesions, the cost per QALY
gained with ranibizumab was estimated at c10,037, c19,152 and c3,759 relative to
PDT, BSC and pegaptanib, respectively. The corresponding ratios for patients with
MC lesions were c28,201/QALY and c19,018/QALY for ranibizumab relative to BSC
and pegaptanib, whereas for patients with occult lesions were estimated at c23,976/
QALY and c39,696/QALY respectively. The probability of ranibizumab being costeffective at the c30,000/QALY threshold was 92.6%, 83.0% and 100% (PC lesions),
67% and 87% (MC) and 75% and 42% (occult) for the above presented ICERs.
CONCLUSIONS: ranibizumab may be a cost-effective option for the treatment of
AMD compared to selected alternatives in the Greek health care setting.
PSS13
COSTS AND EFFECTS OF FIXED COMBINATION THERAPIES IN OPEN
ANGLE GLAUCOMA
Wickstrøm J1, Centofanti M2, Johnson M3
1
Wickstrøm & Langkilde, Vejle, Denmark; 2Fondazione G.B Bietti-IRCCS, Università di Roma
Tor Vergata, Roma, Italy; 3Allergan, Inc., Marlow, UK
OBJECTIVES: Using data from a recently published head to head clinical trial comparing the efficacy and safety of the fixed combination bimatoprost/timolol (BTFC,
Ganfort®) versus fixed combination latanoprost/timolol (LTFC, Xalacom®), the
objective was to investigate the cost-effectiveness of BTFC versus LTFC in 10 European countries. METHODS: A model was developed to evaluate the cost-effectiveness
of BTFC versus LTFC taking a health care perspective including only direct health care
costs. Efficacy data originated from a recent head to head trial of BTFC and LTFC.
Outcomes where measured as percentage reduction in intraocular pressure (IOP) from
baseline and percentage of patients achieving >15% and >20% reduction in IOP from
baseline, respectively. Safety was not included in the base-case analyses as no significant
A400
differences were found in the tolerability of BTFC and LTFC in the clinical study.
National unit costs were applied. The time horizon of the model was 3 months. Sensitivity analyses were performed to test the results responsiveness to changes in key input
parameters. RESULTS: Significantly more BTFC patients experienced >15% and
>20% reduction in IOP compared to LTFC (p = 0.003, P < 0.001). Furthermore,
3-month health care costs for patients treated with BTFC were lower or comparable
to those of LTFC in the 10 studied countries. Results were largely insensitive to
changes in key parameters. The cost-effectiveness analyses revealed that BTFC was
less costly and more effective than LTFC in 8 out of the 10 studied countries (Spain,
Italy, Germany, UK, The Netherlands, Norway, Sweden and Denmark) and more
effective at equal health care costs in France and Finland. Therefore, BTFC was a
dominating treatment strategy in all countries. CONCLUSIONS: BTFC is an effective
treatment strategy in terms of lowering IOP and is a cost-effective treatment strategy
for patients with glaucoma.
PSS14
PHARMACOECONOMICS OF INNOVATIVE MEDICINES FOR
TREATMENT OF PSORIASIS IN UKRAINE
Zalis’ka O, Mandrik O
Danylo Halytsky Lviv National Medical University, Lviv, Ukraine
OBJECTIVES: The objective of this study is to determine the daily and yearly cost
per treatment of innovative biological preparations. In Ukraine live 46 millions inhabitans and the appearance of psoriasis is approximately 2%, 920,000 psoriasis patients.
It is supposed that at 15–20% appearance of middle and severe of psoriasis there are
138,000–184,000 patients in Ukraine with degree of the illness. Adult patients with
moderate to severe plaque form of psoriasis who have not clinical responce for other
systematic therapies, including cyclosporine, metotrexate and PUVA, or when patients
are contraindicated for these therapies or are intolerant of them. METHODS: Only
direct medical cost were calculated from Ukrainian database “Compendium” on
01.05.2010. Annual treatment costs were calculated based on recommended dosesd
as per Ukrainian Guidelines from 2007. The costs are presented using third-party
payer’s perspective, i.e. direct cost to the health system is only considered. In the
analysis there were three strategies of treatment compared: infliximab, adalimumab
and ustekinumab. We used the clinical data of infliximab, adalimumab, ustekinumab
from published clinical trials (IMPACT, ADEPT, PHOENIX 1). The cost-effectiveness
analysis from the payer perspective was conducted. RESULTS: The costs for first year
of therapy of infliximab per patient with PASI 75 response are 221998,4 UAH (1 USD
= 7.92 UAH), of adalimumab—815443,2 UAH, and of ustekinumab −235224,0 UAH.
In model the cost-effectiveness ratios (average cost per one unit PASI 75response)
amounted to US$454 for infliximab, US$1745—adalimumab, US$362—ustekinumab.
CONCLUSIONS: The cost-effectiveness analysis shows that ustekinumab is more
cost-effective vs. other innovative biologics for severe psoriasis treatment in Ukraine.
PSS15
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF USTEKINUMAB VS. INFLIXIMAB FOR SEVERE
PSORIASIS
Omelyanovsky VV1, Avksentieva MV1, Sura MV2, Zorin N2, Hailov P3, Hailov N3
1
Research Center for Clinical and Economic Evaluation and Pharmacoeconomics, Moscow,
Russia; 2Institute of Clinico-Economic Expertise and Pharmacoeconomics, RSMU, Moscow,
Russia; 3NICEE, Moscow, Russia
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate cost-effectiveness of ustekinumab vs. infliximab for severe
psoriasis in Russia. METHODS: Cost-effectiveness analysis was performed. The evidence of efficacy and safety of biologic agents was analyzed. Incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) was calculated for both biologic agent vs. placebo. Drug costs
were taken into account. Achievement of PASI 75 was considered to be expected
outcome, data about efficacy was extracted from clinical trials. RESULTS: There were
no trials with direct comparison of ustekinumab and infiximab. Data from separate
trials showed that efficacy of ustekinumab was a little lower than infliximab at 10–12th
and 24–28th weeks of treatment. On the contrary at 50–52th week of therapy
ustekinumab becomes a little more effective than infliximab. Both biologic agents were
generally well tolerated in most patients. Calculation of expected costs showed that
ustekinumab was cheaper than infliximab if similar periods of follow-up are analyzed.
At 10–12th weeks of therapy ICER for ustekinumab vs. placebo was a little higher
than ICER for infliximab vs. placebo. At 24–28th and 50–52th weeks of therapy ICER
vs. placebo was lower for ustekinumab. CONCLUSIONS: Ustekinumab is an appropriate alternative to infliximab for patients with severe psoriasis.
PSS16
ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF A 100% WHEY-BASED, PARTIALLY
HYDROLYZED INFANT FORMULA IN THE PREVENTION OF ATOPIC
DERMATITIS AMONG FRENCH CHILDREN
Iskedjian M1, Dupont C2, Spieldenner J3, Kanny G4, Raynaud F5, Farah B6, Haschke F3
1
PharmIdeas Research and Consulting Inc., Oakville, ON, Canada; 2Hôpital Saint Vincent de
Paul, Paris, France; 3Nestlé Nutrition Institute, Vevey, Switzerland; 4Centre Hospitalier
Universitaire de Nancy, Nancy, France; 5Université Paris-Descartes, Paris, France; 6PharmIdeas
Research and Consulting Inc., Ottawa, ON, Canada
OBJECTIVES: A pharmacoeconomic analysis was performed to determine costs,
consequences and cost-effectiveness of a specific brand of partially hydrolyzed 100%
whey formula manufactured by Nestlé (PHF-W), in the prevention of atopic dermatitis
(AD) in “at risk” children when compared to standard cow milk formula (CMF) in
France. METHODS: An economic model depicting treatment pathways, resource
13th Euro Abstracts
utilization and costs associated with the treatment of AD in healthy “at risk” French
newborns who were not exclusively breastfed was constructed for a 12-month time
horizon, including an initial six months of formula consumption. Model inputs were
based on the literature, official formularies and expert opinion, including outcomes
from a meta-analysis. The treatment pathways included a dietary management
approach, a medical treatment approach and a combination thereof. The final
outcome was the expected cost per avoided case of AD, yielding an incremental cost
per avoided case (ICER) of AD for PHF-W vs. CMF. Outcomes were presented from
three perspectives: the French Ministry of Health (MOH), the subject’s family and
society (SOC). a secondary analysis compared PHF-W to extensively hydrolyzed
formula (EHF) in prevention. RESULTS: A total of 11,291 AD cases were expected
to be avoided by selecting PHF-W over CMF in a birth cohort of 156,649 at risk
infants. The base-case analyses yielded expected ICERs of c2684, -c1474 (savings)
and c1210 from the MOH, family and SOC perspectives, respectively. Cost drivers
were the formula from the MOH perspectives, time loss from the family perspective,
and formula but also to a lesser extent time loss from the SOC perspective. PHF-W
yielded approximately 81Mc savings against EHF in the secondary analysis. One-way
and probabilistic sensitivity analyses confirmed the robustness of the model.
CONCLUSIONS: Under a range of assumptions, this analysis has established the
cost-effectiveness of PHF-W in the prevention of AD among French infants.
PSS17
ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF A 100%-WHEY BASED PARTIALLY
HYDROLYZED FORMULA IN THE PREVENTION OF ATOPIC
DERMATITIS AMONG DANISH CHILDREN: PRELIMINARY ANALYSES
Iskedjian M1, Spieldenner J2, Jarvi A3, Farah B4, Navarro V5
1
PharmIdeas Research and Consulting Inc., Oakville, ON, Canada; 2Nestlé Nutrition Institute,
Vevey, Switzerland; 3Nestlé Sverige AB, Helsingborg, Sweden; 4PharmIdeas Research and
Consulting Inc., Ottawa, ON, Canada; 5PharmIdeas Europe SAS, Lyon, France
OBJECTIVES: A pharmacoeconomic analysis was undertaken to determine costs,
consequences and cost-effectiveness of a brand of partially hydrolyzed 100% whey
formula manufactured by Nestlé (PHF-W), in the prevention of atopic dermatitis (AD)
in “at risk” children when compared to extensively hydrolyzed formula (EHF-Whey
or Casein) in Denmark. METHODS: Based on a 6-month time horizon for formula
consumption, an economic model was developed synthesizing treatment pathways,
resource utilization and costs associated with the treatment of AD in healthy “at risk”
Danish newborns who were not exclusively breastfed. The cost of formula was
retrieved from market surveys while other model inputs were obtained from the literature. a meta-analysis of 6 studies that compared the efficacy of PHF-W (557 patients)
and EHF (559 and 580 patients for EHF-Whey and EHF-Casein) yielded RR of
0.75[0.54,1.05] at 0–12 months and 0.80[0.63,1.02] at 0–36 months for PHF-W vs.
EHF-Whey and RR of 1.06[0.74,1.53] at 0–12 months and 1.13[0.87,1.47] at 0–36
months for PHF-W vs. EHF-Casein. Given the evidence for non-significant differences
between PHF-W and EHF, the analytic approach amounted to a cost-minimization
analysis reporting the difference in formula acquisition costs. In the base case, it was
assumed that infants consumed the formula of choice for the full 6 months. In a
sensitivity analysis, subjects consuming PHF, EHF-Whey or EHF-Casein who developed AD symptoms were switched to EHF-Whey, EHF-Casein or EHF-Whey, respectively. RESULTS: Savings per child receiving formula of DKK 17,033 were generated
for PHF-W vs. EHF-Whey while savings of DKK 16,974 were observed for PHF-W
vs. EHF-Casein. The sensitivity analysis yielded a cost saving of DKK 16,800 with
PHF-W. CONCLUSIONS: Under a range of assumptions, this analysis demonstrated
the cost-saving nature of PHF-W vs. both types of EHF in the prevention of AD among
Danish infants. Further sensitivity analyses, including multivariate, are planned for
confirmation of results.
PSS18
ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF A 100% WHEY-BASED, PARTIALLY
HYDROLYZED INFANT FORMULA IN THE PREVENTION OF ATOPIC
DERMATITIS AMONG SPANISH CHILDREN
Iskedjian M1, Navot Falcó S2, Spieldenner J3, Casas Ramisa R4, Claver Monzón A2,
González Enseñat MA2, Farah B5, Berbari J5
1
PharmIdeas Research and Consulting Inc., Oakville, ON, Canada; 2Hospital Sant Joan de
Déu, Manresa, Spain; 3Nestlé Nutrition Institute, Vevey, Switzerland; 4Clínica Pediátrica
Nevot-Casas, El Prat de Llobregat, Barcelona, Spain; 5PharmIdeas Research and Consulting
Inc., Ottawa, ON, Canada
OBJECTIVES: A pharmacoeconomic analysis was undertaken to determine costs,
consequences and cost-effectiveness of a specific brand of partially hydrolyzed 100%
whey formula manufactured by Nestlé (PHF-W), in the prevention of atopic dermatitis
(AD) in “at risk” children when compared to standard cow milk formula (CMF) in
Spain. METHODS: Based on a 12-month time horizon (including 6 months of formula
consumption), an economic model was developed synthesizing treatment pathways,
resource utilization and costs associated with the treatment of AD in healthy “at risk”
Spanish newborns who were not exclusively breastfed. Model inputs were retrieved
from the literature, official formularies and expert opinion, including outcomes from
a meta-analysis. The treatment pathways considered a dietary management approach,
a medical treatment approach and a combination thereof. The final outcome was the
expected cost per avoided case of AD, yielding an incremental cost per avoided case
(ICER) of AD for PHF-W vs. CMF. Outcomes were presented from three perspectives:
the Spanish Ministry of Health (MOH), the subject’s family and society (SOC). a
secondary analysis compared PHF-W to extensively hydrolyzed formula (EHF) in
13th Euro Abstracts
prevention. RESULTS: The expected number of avoided AD cases by selecting PHF-W
over CMF was 2,787 cases in a birth cohort of 38,661 at risk infants. The base-case
analyses generated expected ICERs of c1921, -c1102 (savings) and c785 from the
MOH, family and SOC perspectives, respectively. Cost drivers were formula from the
MOH perspectives and time loss from the family perspective, with formula and to a
lesser extent time loss for the SOC perspective. PHF-W yielded approximately c10.7
million savings against EHF in the secondary analysis. One-way and probabilistic
sensitivity analyses confirmed the robustness of the model. CONCLUSIONS: Under
a range of assumptions, this analysis has established the cost-effectiveness of PHF-W
in the prevention of AD among Spanish infants.
PSS19
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF AGE-RELATED MACULAR DEGENERATION:
A MODEL
Visser MS1, Amarakoon S2, Dorrestijn N2, Missotten T2, Busschbach J1
1
Erasmus University Medical Center, Rotterdam, The Netherlands; 2Rotterdam Ophthalmic
Institute, Rotterdam, Zuid-Holland, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: Bevacizumab (Avastin) is a promising and low cost treatment of agerelated macular degeneration. Effectiveness and cost-effectiveness might be related to
the frequency of injections of bevacizumab in the treatment. The standard frequency
is 4 weeks, while it is uncertain whether lower frequencies lead to different cost and
effects. METHODS: 170 patients were randomized to 3 treatment frequencies; 4, 6,
and 8 week intervals between injections. Follow up was 1 year. Vision was measured
with the Snellen chart, which health states have been valued for QALY analysis. We
developed a 6 states Markov model with a 12 weeks cycle and a 6-year time-horizon.
The model included one death state, and five states defined by visual acuity(VA) in
the better seeing eye: VA >20/40, ≤20/40 to >20/80, ≤20/80 to >20/200, ≤20/200 to
>20/400 and ≤20/400. RESULTS: At time of the (interim) analyses, 72 patients had
completed the full follow up. The ‘6 weeks’ frequency compared with ‘4 weeks’ shows
a negative ICER of c6.406, with c1,024 less costs and 0.16 more QALY’s. The ‘8
weeks’ frequency compared to the 4 weeks frequency shows also a negative ICER of
c28,032, with c1.543 less costs and 0,06 more QALY’s. When looking at 6 and 8
weeks, the ‘8 weeks’ has lower costs but is also less effective, with an ICER of c4.946.
Most uncertainty related to utilities and transition probabilities, while cost contributes
relatively less to the uncertainty of the outcomes. CONCLUSIONS: Compared with
4 weeks frequency, the 6 and 8 weeks frequency were dominant, whereas the 8 weeks
frequency has an ICER in the south west quadrant.
PSS20
COST-UTILITY ANALYSIS OF A PRN (AS NEEDED) TREATMENT
SCHEDULE WITH RANIBIZUMAB (LUCENTIS®) IN WET AMD BASED
ON CLINICAL EVIDENCE
Moeremans K1, Gerlier L1, Mitchell P2, Gallagher M3, Vincze G3
1
IMS Health Consulting, Brussels, Belgium; 2University of Sidney, Westmead, NSW, Australia;
3
Novartis Pharma AG, Basel, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: To assess whether evidence-based cost-utility of PRN-dosing with
ranibizumab (Lucentis®, RBZ-PRN) in age-related macular degeneration (AMD) is
comparable to RBZ-PRN cost-utility estimated previously based on clinical data from
monthly and quarterly regimens. METHODS: A 10-year MS-Excel Markov model
with 5 visual acuity (VA) levels and 1 death state predicts VA in patients treated with
RBZ-PRN, RBZ quarterly (RBZ-Q), RBZ monthly (RBZ-M), Visudyne® photodynamic therapy (PDT) or best supportive care (BSC). Transition probabilities, adverse
events and treatment frequencies were provided by newly available PRN-trials
(SUSTAIN, MONT BLANC) + available trials covering other comparators (ANCHOR,
MARINA, PIER, EXCITE, TAP). Comparability of populations and treatment effects
(linear regressions) determined trial data pooling. Final analyses included pooled data
sets (RBZ-PRN and RBZ-Q) or multiple single-trial data sets (other comparators).
Secondary analysis included indirect comparison versus pegaptanib sodium (PGB).
Two-year treatment duration was followed by BSC. Costs (2009, UK health care
payer, 3.5% discount) were obtained from literature and expert opinion; utilities
(3.5% discount) from a time-trade-off study. One-way and probabilistic sensitivity
analyses (SA) covered variability in efficacy, costs, treatment frequency and utilities.
RESULTS: Due to lower than predicted injection frequency, clinical trial-based costutility of RBZ-PRN was better than predicted cost-utility. Evidence-based cost-utility
ranged from £4,414/QALY to £20,489/QALY versus BSC and from dominance to
£2,383/QALY versus PDT. RBZ-PRN was dominant versus RBZ-Q and versus PGB
(secondary indirect analysis). RBZ-M was slightly more effective but not cost-effective
versus RBZ-PRN. The result was most sensitive to time horizon (2–10 y), cost of
blindness and treatment duration (1–3 y) but conclusions remained throughout 1-way
SA. Assuming a threshold of £30,000/QALY, the probability that RBZ-PRN is costeffective ranged from 68% to 97% versus different comparators. CONCLUSIONS:
RBZ-PRN using the SUSTAIN and MONT-BLANC re-treatment criteria is costeffective compared to other therapies for wet-AMD and represents the most costeffective use of RBZ.
A401
PSS21
AN ECONOMIC ANALYSIS OF TACROLIMUS OINTMENT
MAINTENANCE USE (TWICE WEEKLY) VERSUS STANDARD USE IN
PATIENTS WITH MODERATE TO SEVERE ATOPIC DERMATITIS IN
NORWAY AND FINLAND
Chambers C1, Bentley A2, Wickstrøm J3
1
Astellas Pharma Europe Ltd, Staines, UK; 2Abacus International, Bicester, Oxfordshire, UK;
3
Wickstrøm & Langkilde ApS, Vejl, Syddanmark, Denmark
OBJECTIVES: The objective of this study was to determine the cost-effectiveness of
tacrolimus ointment used twice weekly as a maintenance treatment regimen compared
to a standard treatment regimen using tacrolimus twice daily in both adults and
children with moderate to severe atopic dermatitis (AD) in Norway and Finland.
METHODS: A decision analytic approach was used to compare costs and outcomes
of two alternative management strategies for AD over a 12 month treatment period
for the UK, which was adapted for Norway and Finland. Efficacy data were used from
two randomised controlled trials where maintenance use of tacrolimus ointment
(0.1% in adults and 0.03% in children applied twice weekly) was applied to previously
affected areas compared to standard use (twice daily application) to treat disease
exacerbations. Utility data were derived from a published source and cost data were
taken from public list prices and tariffs in the two countries, Norway and Finland to
generate cost/QALY. Sensitivity analyses were performed to test the degree of uncertainty around the results. RESULTS: The twice weekly maintenance use of tacrolimus
ointment resulted in fewer days in disease flare and improved quality of life versus
standard treatment with tacrolimus ointment in both adults and children with moderate to severe AD. The twice weekly regimen was cost-saving compared with the
standard regimen in both Norway and Finland. Sensitivity analyses demonstrated that
results were largely insensitive to change. CONCLUSIONS: Twice weekly maintenance treatment of moderate and severe AD in both adults and children using tacrolimus ointment improves health outcomes at a lower cost when compared with the
reactive treatment strategy using tacrolimus ointment.
PSS22
INDIRECT COSTS OF INFORMAL CARE FOR ONE EPISODE OF ACUTE
OTITIS MEDIA IN GERMANY
Jochum D, Knoll S
GlaxoSmithKline GmbH & Co. KG, Munich, Germany
Indirect costs are not only generated by sick people themselves, but often occur due
to sick children needing informal care by parents or other informal care givers. Informal care givers are relatives or friends, not being paid for their services and thereby
experiencing work, leisure time and productivity loss. Indirect costs induced by informal care givers are rarely included in CEA, although being part of societal cost.
OBJECTIVES: This study quantified the indirect costs of an informal care giver caused
by a sick child suffering from an episode of acute otitis media (AOM) in Germany.
METHODS: Using a German access panel questionnaires were sent out to households
with children <5years. The following indirect costs referring to the most recent AOM
episode of any child were covered: hours of work absence and related costs for
mothers, fathers and grandparents; loss of leisure time; productivity loss caused by
solicitousness; work loss compensation by colleagues. RESULTS: A total of 68.3% of
all parents experienced 7–29 hours of work loss (59.3/9.3% mothers/fathers) per
episode, grandparents 14 hours (2%). While 40% of parents experienced paid and
28% unpaid work loss, grandparents being retired caused only unpaid productivity
losses. Leisure time loss was experienced by all informal caregivers and an average
was calculated across the total population accounting for c47.39. Indirect costs per
AOM episode across the total population were in average c411.40 (Sum of: c152.51
paid, c161.89 unpaid work loss, c209.07 productivity, c47.39 leisure time loss;
Subtraction of: c45.72 paid, c113.74 unpaid work compensation by a colleague).
CONCLUSIONS: Indirect costs are mainly included in health economic (HE) analyses
as paid work loss. For Germany paid work loss only accounted for 38% of total
indirect costs referring to an AOM episode. Further detailed studies are needed to
better understand the influence of different indirect cost categories across disease areas.
SENSORY SYSTEMS DISORDERS – Patient-Reported Outcomes Studies
PSS23
THE USE AND MISUSE OF ANTIBIOTICS FOR UPPER RESPIRATORY
TRACT INFECTION
Alawadhi FK
Ministry of Health, UAE, Sharjah, United Arab Emirates
OBJECTIVES: To measure the influence of introducing guidelines to doctors and
educational leaflets to patients on reducing the level of prescribed antibiotics. To
investigate the effect of factors such as socio-demographic characteristics, signs, symptoms and patient self management. METHODS: Research was conducted in two busy
clinics, one in Dubai and one in Sharjah. a set of guidelines for the treatment of sore
throat were extracted from the SIGN guidelines (Appendix 3). The set of guidelines
was explained to the General Practitioners individually. The guidelines were accompanied by a covering paper which explained why and where the guidelines were
produced. The researcher was based in the nursing room and approached patients
suffering from a sore throat. These patients were given the educational leaflet and a
brief explanation of what the leaflet included. The length of explanation depended on
whether the patient could read or not. They were then asked a set of questions prior
A402
to their visit to General Practitioner. Study population I: Before the implementation
of guidelines and the educational leaflet. Study population II: After the implementation
of guidelines and the educational leaflet. Cross-sectional analysis and descriptive
analyses was performed using the Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS).
RESULTS: The total number of antibiotic prescriptions for patients suffering from
U.R.T.I. including sore throat was significantly reduced in the intervention group
(67% reduction). CONCLUSIONS: A multi-dimensional interventional approach for
reducing antibiotic prescription in U.A.E. clinics resulted in a significant positive
outcome. The significant reduction in antibiotic prescriptions indicates the willingness
of physicians to follow guidelines and the willingness of patients to respond to educational information.
PSS24
QUALITY OF LIFE IN OCULAR HYPERTENSION AND PRIMARY OPEN
ANGLE GLAUCOMA
Wolfram C1, Lorenz K1, Shlaen R2, Verboven Y3, Pfeiffer N1
1
Universitätsmedizin Mainz, Mainz, Germany; 2IMS Health, Munich, Germany; 3ALCON
Couvreur NV, Puurs, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: To estimate the impact of ocular hypertension (OHT)/primary openangle glaucoma (POAG) on health status and quality-of-life. METHODS: Classification of disease state followed European Glaucoma Society guidelines. Health status
was based upon the Health Utility Index Mark 3 (HUI3) The National Eye Institute
25-Item Visual Function Questionnaire (NEI-VFQ-25) was self-administered. Utility
scores were compared to a normal population matched by age and gender. Differences
in health impact and quality-of-life between the different disease states were assessed.
RESULTS: 154 patients were enrolled (27 OHT, 43 early, 35 moderate, 49 advanced
POAG) from 15 centers in Germany, 137 were diagnosed 35 years ago. Average age
was 67 ± 11 and 57% were female. 23% of patients had cardiovascular co-morbidity,
45% history of cataract, 45% hypertension, 18% diabetes, and 10% hypotension.
Differences in baseline characteristics were seen for age (60, 63, 69, 72 years), history
of cataract (24%, 25%, 54%, 62%), employment status (43%, 24%), and hypotension (14%, 0%, 14%, 15%). The HUI3 score for OHT, early, moderate and advanced
POAG was 0.87 ± 0.09, 0.85 ± 0.15, 0.75 ± 0.23 and 0.58 ± 0.32, respectively. There
was no difference in the health utility score for patients with OHT, early POAG and
the normal population. Patients with moderate and advanced POAG were lower by
0.06 ± 0.24 and 0.19 ± 0.28, significantly different from OHT and early POAG (P <
0.01). The NEI-VFQ-25 for OHT and early POAG gave ocular symptoms and mental
health the lowest scores. For moderate POAG the lowest scores were for driving,
ocular symptoms, mental health, role limitation and peripheral vision. For advanced
POAG, all domains, except color vision, were affected. CONCLUSIONS: Disease
progression in glaucoma affects not only vision, but also quality-of-life. Whereas OHT
and early POAG have little effect on quality-of-life, moderate and advanced POAG
do. These findings can improve doctor-patient relationships, addressing quality-of-life
issues for different glaucoma disease states.
PSS25
MAPPING THE IMPACT OF DRY EYE ON EVERYDAY LIFE (IDEEL)
QUESTIONNAIRE TO A PREFERENCE BASED UTILITY INDEX
Acaster S1, Verboven Y2, Berdeaux G3, Lloyd A1
1
Oxford Outcomes Ltd, Oxford, UK; 2ALCON Couvreur NV, Puurs, Belgium; 3Alcon
France, Rueil-Malmaison, France
OBJECTIVES: The aim of the current study was to develop an algorithm to map the
symptom domain of the Impact of Dry Eye on Everyday Life (IDEEL) questionnaire
to a preference based utility index. METHODS: Data from an IDEEL psychometric
validation study including 210 participants (130 dry eye patients, 32 Sjogren’s patients
and 48 controls) were used to estimate the algorithm. Participants completed the
IDEEL, EQ-5D and SF-36 at 2 time points; the first time point was used to estimate
the algorithm and the second to validate the algorithm. The mapping work was
preceded by determining bivariate correlations between the IDEEL items and each
utility index (EQ-5D and SF-6D), and then examining the sensitivity of each index to
variability in dry eye severity. Initial items were selected based on levels of missing
data, floor and ceiling effects and correlations with the utility index. Items were then
included in an OLS regression model with age and gender interaction terms. Following
the item analysis the same procedures were applied to a domain level analysis.
RESULTS: Based on the criteria outlined above, the SF-6D was selected as the utility
index for the mapping algorithm. The final OLS regression model contained 2 IDEEL
symptoms items and age, and explained 28% of the variance in SF-6D utility values;
root mean squared error (RMSE) = 0.105. As the SF-6D data included few bounded
or censored estimates Tobit and CLAD models were not estimated. The validation
data set demonstrated a significant correlation between the predicted and observed
SF-6D utility values (r = 0.53, p < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: This algorithm forms a
good basis to estimate utility values from the IDEEL for inclusion in cost-effectiveness
analysis.
PSS26
REVIEW OF UTILITIES IN ATOPIC DERMATITIS
Mladsi D
RTI Health Solutions, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA
OBJECTIVES: To identify and review published utility estimates in atopic dermatitis
(AD), and to catalogue the methods of utility assessment, patient populations studied,
and economic evaluations incorporating the utility estimates. METHODS: A system-
13th Euro Abstracts
atic search and review of the published literature, including health technology assessments, in AD was performed. Utility search terms were those recommended by NICE
in the UK Publications were limited to English language only, from 1999 through
2010. RESULTS: Fourteen studies presenting 15 different sets of utility data in AD
(one study used two separate methods to generate estimates) were identified. These
14 studies are summarized in 11 separate publications (one health technology assessment describes three otherwise unpublished utility studies). All studies but one present
utility estimates (vs changes in utility). Two studies present a single utility estimate
for AD. One study presents utility estimates for controlled vs. uncontrolled AD. All
other studies present utility estimates by AD severity (e.g., clear, mild, moderate,
severe), although only two studies link AD severity directly to IGA scores. Two studies
present utility estimates for children. AD utilities have been collected or applied in
economic evaluations in Canada, Germany, Sweden, the UK, and the US. Utilities in
AD have been collected directly using SG, TTO, VAS (with the VAS results being
converted into utilities for use in economic evaluations using an algorithm that reflects
attitudes towards risk), and using the EQ5D. Three studies have generated utility
estimates based on applying two separate published algorithms to SF-12 or SF6D data.
Five sets of utility data have been used in economic evaluations. CONCLUSIONS:
There are several published studies presenting utility estimates in AD; however, they
vary greatly in terms of methods employed. Economic evaluations in AD, the results
of which are sensitive to uncertainty in utility inputs, have relied on various
estimates.
PSS27
COSMETI QOL: A TOOL FOR ASSESSING QUALITY OF LIFE IN
COSMETIC DERMATOLOGY
Taieb C1, Sibaud V2
1
PFSA, Boulogne, France; 2Eau Thermale Avene, Lavaur, France
OBJECTIVES: The assessment of quality of life (QoL) in dermatology is becoming
increasingly popular as demonstrated by the creation and development of numerous
questionnaires for the principal diseases of the skin. Paradoxically, although cosmetic
dermatology is rapidly developing, there is no questionnaire to assess the impact of
these products on the QoL of the women that use them. There was therefore a need
for the creation of the Cosmeti QoL. METHODS: The questionnaire was developed
using rigorous methodology in accordance with international standards in terms of
quality of life. a literary review and face-to-face interviews were conducted to identify
the concepts that preoccupied women over 25 years of age. Twenty-two items were
identified after the first transcription; this was reduced to 12 items after an initial
analysis making it easier to use. a representative population of 1002 French women
aged 25 years and over, was put together by the CSA Santé institute using the quota
method. They were given the Cosmeti QoL; the lower the score the better the Qol.
RESULTS: The questionnaire is easy to use, good comprehension of the questions was
observed. The Cosmeti QoL score is correlated to age. An improved QoL is seen in
women who frequently use a moisturizing cream (13.7 vs. 14.23, P < 0.001). Sensitive
skin resulted in poorer QoL (14.77 vs. 13.34 P < 0.001), the frequency of episodes
of sunburn during childhood also reduced the QoL (14.96 vs. 13.86 P < 0.001). In
the population over 65 years of age, the QoL was superior in women who claimed to
use cosmetic, anti-wrinkle, or moisturizing products on a regular basis. CONCLUSIONS: The Cosmeti QoL scale, which is essentially based on the women’s point of
view, is a valid, pertinent, and well accepted tool enabling the assessment of quality
of life perceived through the skin.
PSS28
DEVELOPMENT OF AN INSTRUMENT MIRRORING PATIENT AND
PHYSICIAN PERCEPTION OF PSORIASIS SEVERITY AND TREATMENT
EFFECT
Roborel de Climens A1, Marant C1, Arnould B1, Bachelez H2, Bagot M2, Beaulieu P3,
Joly P4, Jullien D5, Le Maitre M6, Ortonne JP7, Paul C8, Contreras L9, Thibout E9
1
Mapi Values, Lyon, France; 2Saint Louis Hospital, Paris, France; 3Private Practice, Pontoise,
France; 4Charles Nicolle’s Hospital, Rouen, France; 5Hospices civils de Lyon, Lyon University,
Lyon, France; 6Private Practice, Caen, France; 7University of Nice Sophia Antipolis, Nice,
France; 8Paul Sabatier University, Toulouse, France; 9Abbott France, Rungis, France
OBJECTIVES: No consensus on definition of plaque psoriasis severity currently exists.
Although standard measures of psoriasis severity are commonly used in clinical practice, they are not consistent and rarely based on patient assessment. The objective was
to develop an instrument assessing patient and physician perceptions of psoriasis
severity and treatment effect. METHODS: Semi-directive exploratory interviews were
conducted with 20 patients with mild to severe plaque psoriasis, and with 20 dermatologists. Interviews’ transcripts were analyzed to extract and organise into models
the criteria used by patients and physicians to evaluate psoriasis severity and treatment
benefit. Items were generated using patient words for each concept considered relevant
by both patients and dermatologists. The instrument was developed in parallel for
patients and for physicians, tested for relevance and comprehension on 5 patients and
5 physicians, and revised accordingly. The new version was tested on 5 new patients
and 5 new physicians and revised to create a pilot version. a dermatologist advisory
board was involved at each step of the instrument development. RESULTS: The test
instrument consisted in 31 items including area involvement, lesion location, signs and
symptoms (frequency, duration of lesions, joint involvement), treatment history,
quality of life impact, rapidity and duration of treatment benefit, and patient satisfaction. The instrument was globally well-accepted by patients and physicians; few
modifications were made. a 32-item pilot version resulted from the comprehension
13th Euro Abstracts
tests. CONCLUSIONS: The instrument constitutes a single tool to assess both patient
and physician perceptions of psoriasis severity and treatment effect. The availability
of a shared instrument may improve treatment decision-making, reconciliating patient
and physician perceptions. An observational study with 100 dermatologists and 561
patients is planned to assess agreement between patient and clinician perceptions;
scoring and psychometric properties will also be validated.
PSS29
INTERNATIONAL CO-VALIDATION OF A NEW INTERNATIONAL
QUALITY OF LIFE INSTRUMENT SPECIFIC TO PHYSICAL APPEARANCE:
BEAUTYQOL
Beresniak A1, de Linares Y2, Auquier P3, Krueger GG4, Talarico S5, Tsutani K6,
Walkiewicz B7, Berger G8
1
Data Mining International, Geneva, Switzerland; 2L’Oréal Research International, Asnieres sur
Seine, France; 3University of Medicine, Marseille, France; 4University of Utah, Salt Lake City,
UT, USA; 5Federal University of Sao Paulo, Sao Paulo, Brazil; 6University of Tokyo, Tokyo,
Japan; 7Stowarzyszenie Lekarzy Dermatologów Estetycznych, Warszawa, Poland; 8University
Pierre & Marie Curie, Paris, France
OBJECTIVES: This research has been driven by the need for a quality of life (QoL)
instrument that specifically assesses physical appearance. The BeautyQol instrument
is a multi-dimensional, self administered questionnaire, which has been in development for over three years in 16 languages. METHODS: In the item generation phase,
semi directive interviews were conducted in 309 subjects. In the second phase an
acceptability study was conducted on 874 subjects in France, UK, Germany, Spain,
Sweden, Italy, Russia, USA, Brazil, Japan, India (Hindi and English) China and South
Africa (Zulu, Sotho and English). In the third phase, a total of 3231 subjects were
recruited. to complete the BeautyQoL questionnaire, a skin clinical checklist, SF-36
and a socio-demographic questionnaire. a re-test has been carried out at 8 days on a
subgroup of 652 subjects. The database was randomly divided into two subgroups
and analyzed using a Rash analysis. Psychometric properties, construct validity, reproducibility, internal and external consistency were tested. RESULTS: From the item
generation phase, 62 questions were selected. General acceptability was very good in
the 16 cultures, with a very low rate of no answers. The validation phase reduced the
questionnaire in 44 questions structured in five dimensions explaining 76.7% of the
total variance: Social Life, Self confidence, Psychological life, Vitality and Seduction.
Internal consistency was high (Cronbach alpha coefficients between 0.932 and 0.978).
Reproducibility at 8 days was satisfactory in all dimensions. External validity testing
revealed that BeautyQol scores correlated significantly with all SF-36 scores except
for Physical Function. Mean completion time was 7 minutes (median:5 minutes).
CONCLUSIONS: These results demonstrate the validity and reliability of the BeautyQol questionnaire as the very first international instrument specific to physical
appearance. It is expected that BeautyQoL will be an instrument that will measure
QoL affected by cosmetic products, techniques and agents that alter physical
appearance.
PSS30
DISCREPANCY IN PATIENT AND PHYSICIAN GLOBAL ASSESSMENTS
OF DERMATOLOGIC DISEASES
Tabolli S, Spagnoli A, Sampogna F, Pagliarello C, Abeni D, Paradisi A
IDI IRCCS Rome, Rome, Italy
OBJECTIVES: To investigate discrepancy in the perception of dermatologic diseases
(DD) severity between patients and physicians. METHODS: A descriptive study was
performed: 2459 patients with DD rated their level of disease severity on a five level
scale: very mild, mild, moderate, severe, very severe (PtGA). Physician global assessment (PhGA) was performed on the same scale. Fifty three physicians were involved
in an out-patient setting for three weeks (March 2010) in a dermatologic research
hospital, Rome, Italy. RESULTS: Patients were predominantly females (59%), with
an high education and the majority were employed; mean age was 45.9 ± 18.5 for
females and 44.5 ± 18 for males. No discrepancy between PhGA and PtGA was
observed in 37% of cases; PtGA under-rated compared to the physician in 35%; and
PtGA over-rated relative to the physicians in 28%. Statistically significant differences
were observed between PtGA and PhGA in each of the five levels of judgement (P <
0.001). Higher percentages of patients, in respect to physicians, reported very mild,
severe and very severe evaluations. Physicians tended to overestimate for mild and
moderate levels. Differences were observed between male and female physicians in the
severity judgement, reaching a statistically significant difference for the very mild level
(P < 0.001) where females were more represented. CONCLUSIONS: The perceived
severity disease in DD was different between patients and physicians and it was different in patients in respect to sex. Only for very mild DD there was a difference in
PhGA between males and females, with males underestimating the severity.
PSS31
VISION-RELATED QUALITY OF LIFE INSTRUMENTS (QOL) AFTER
REFRACTIVE CATARACT SURGERY
Tugaut B1, Meunier J1, Viala-Danten M1, Arnould B1, Berdeaux G2
1
Mapi Values, Lyon, France; 2Alcon France, Rueil-Malmaison, France
OBJECTIVES: To review the available vision-related QoL instruments that could be
used to investigate the consequences of refractive cataract surgery, in particular the
benefit of spectacle independence. METHODS: A literature review was undertaken
on PubMed and Embase databases using keywords “Refractive Surgical Procedures”,
A403
“Refractive Errors”, “Refractive”, “Questionnaire”, and “QoL”. Questionnaires were
selected if they were developed for cataract or refractive surgery, based on the reading
of the manuscript abstract. a further search was performed on PubMed, Embase and
ProQolid databases to obtain information on development and psychometric validation of the questionnaires. Authors were contacted by email if missing data were
identified from the published literature. Main characteristics of the questionnaires
were described including number of items, targeted population, mode of administration, response scale, languages, and number of publications. Development methodology was reviewed (literature review, clinician input, patient input and comprehension
test). Psychometric properties were examined (e.g. domain description, scoring algorithm, internal consistency, clinical validity, reproducibility, responsiveness). The
above characteristics were then examined in light of the US FDA’s “Guidance for
Industry Patient-Reported Outcome Measures: Use in Medical Product Development
to Support Labeling Claims”. RESULTS: A total of 141 abstracts were reviewed and
14 questionnaires were identified. Four instruments had both a solid development
methodology and good psychometric properties: the CatQuest (Cataract Questionnaire), the NEI-RQL-42 (US National Eye Institute Refractive Error QoL instrument-42), the NEI-VFQ-25 (US National Eye Institute Visual Function
Questionnaire-25) and the RSVP (Refractive Status and Vision Profile). When including the ability to assess vision-related QoL with the benefit of not wearing glasses, it
appeared that the NEI-RQL-42 was one of the best candidates, although the benefits
of spectacle independence could be more deeply explored. CONCLUSIONS: According to this literature review, the NEI-RQL-42 could be considered as one of the best
instruments to capture refractive vision-related QoL consequences after cataract
surgery.
PSS32
THE EXPERIENCE OF EXTERNAL GENITAL WARTS AND GENITAL
HERPES ON QUALITY OF LIFE
Langley PC1, Freedman D2, Wagner JS3, Gupta S2
1
University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN, USA; 2Kantar Health, Princeton, NJ, USA; 3Kantar
Health, New York, NY, USA
OBJECTIVES: Estimates of the lifetime prevalence of external genital warts (EGW)
and genital herpes in the European Union range from 0.47% to 1.52% and 0.59%
to 1.43% respectively. The aim here is to assess, for the first time, the impact of the
experience on current health related quality of life at the general population level.
METHODS: Data are from the 2008 National Health and Wellness Survey. This is
an internet-based survey carried out in the UK, France, Spain, Italy and Germany.
From a total of 53,524 respondents, 521 indicated they had experienced EGW and
520 genital herpes. Only 63 had experienced both conditions. The regression analysis
is based on health state utilities (score 0–100) from the SF-6D. The independent
variables included binary variables for the presence/absence of EGW and genital
herpes, socio-demographic characteristics, health risk factors (e.g., body mass index)
and the Charlson Comorbidity Index (CCI). RESULTS: The experience of EGW and
genital herpes had a substantial negative impact on utility scores. The impact was
significant at conventional decision levels: EGW—2.47 (95% CI: −3.58–−1.36), genital
herpes −3.52 (95%CI: −4.63–−2.71) and EGW and genital herpes −5.00 (95%CI:
1.76–8.25). The impact of EGW and genital herpes experience was similar to the
negative impact of BMI for persons who were underweight, obese and morbidly obese
and the CCI (−2.53;95%CI: −2.65–−2.41). Age, education and income all had a positive and significant impact on HRQoL. CONCLUSIONS: This is the first time the
lifetime experience of two of the most prevalence sexually transmitted infections (STIs)
on current HRQoL has been assessed. The results point to the continuing impact of
this experience, with herpes having a marginally greater impact than EGWs. The
HRQoL deficit is most apparent for those who have experienced both STIs.
SENSORY SYSTEMS DISORDERS – Health Care Use & Policy Studies
PSS33
REAL-LIFE DOSING OF BIOLOGICS IN PLAQUE PSORIASIS—A GERMAN
SURVEY
Klesse M, Wolbring F
Janssen-Cilag GmbH, Neuss, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Evaluation of use, dose distribution, and dosing rationale of biologic
treatments in plaque psoriasis within private practices and hospitals in Germany.
METHODS: Fully structured Online Questionnaire using Umfragecenter® software.
Panel participants were selected by DocCheck Medical Services using their MediAccess
Pool. Survey was done in December 2009. 100 dermatologists (60 in private practices,
40 in hospitals) were included in the survey. Inclusion criterion: currently treating at
least two psoriasis patients with biologics, at least one patient on adalimumab, etanercept or infliximab. RESULTS: Each surveyed dermatologist treated approximately
100 psoriasis patients per quarter. In private practice about 10% of these patients
were treated with a biologic, while in hospitals about 23% received biologic treatment.
About 40% of the patients receiving a biologic suffered from psoriatic arthritis as
well. Distribution of the different biologics used was as follows: etanercept 37%,
adalimumab 33%, infliximab 20%, and ustekinumab 10%. Only minor differences
in those proportions were observed between private practices and hospitals. In about
80% of all cases, used dosing for each biologic conformed to the respective label. In
other cases, increased dosages were observed, for example: 12% of adalimumab
patients received 40 mg weekly, 17% of etanercept patients being treated longer than
A404
24 weeks received a 50 mg BIW maintenance dose, and 23% of infliximab patients
received infusions every 6 weeks. Reasons for dose increase included higher severity
of disease, longer disease duration, loss of efficacy, overweight, joint involvement,
higher number of previous systemic therapies received. CONCLUSIONS: Real-life
dosing of psoriasis biologics does not always conform to the posology recommended
in the product label, especially for high need patients. About 20% of patients being
treated with a TNF-alpha-inhibitor seem to need a higher non-standard dose.
PSS34
THE IMPACT OF POTENTIAL PILL SPLITTING ON GENERIC AND
BRANDED FINASTERIDE UPTAKE
Nichols E, Wiederkehr DP, Doyle J
Quintiles Global Consulting, Hawthorne, NY, USA
OBJECTIVES: Finasteride is indicated for the treatment of male pattern hair loss at
1 mg strength and for male symptomatic benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH) at 5 mg
strength. While the male pattern hair loss indication exclusivity does not expire until
2013, the BPH indication expired in 2006. Patients have been known to purchase
generic finasteride in 5 mg strength and split the pills into quarters as a less expensive
alternative to the branded 1 mg dose. The objective was to examine the uptake of
generic finasteride in relation to the prescribing volume of branded finasteride for the
treatment of male pattern hair loss to determine the impact of potential pill splitting
on generic uptake and branded prescribing volume. METHODS: Generic and branded
finasteride were selected as case products. From 1992 to 2010 the volume of prescriptions (TRx) were collected monthly using SDI’s VONA databases and grouped according to branded and generic sales. RESULTS: Sales of generic finasteride significantly
accelerated immediately after launch. The compound average growth rate (CAGR) of
TRx of branded 5 mg finasteride between 1992 and 2006 was 23.29%. Meanwhile,
the CAGR of generic 5 mg finasteride from 2006 to 2010 was 96.17%, signaling an
aggressive growth trend. Interestingly, the sales of branded 1 mg finasteride were not
impacted as they maintained steady growth with a CAGR of 2.49% over the four
years since generic launch. CONCLUSIONS: One hypothesis as to the immediate
growth of generic finasteride after launch can be attributed to pill splitting; much of
the volume increase was due to patients purchasing the much less expensive generic
5 mg finasteride and quartering the pills. However, if pill splitting did occur, it did
not appear to impact sales of branded 1 mg finasteride as demonstrated by a maintained steady growth in TRx. This suggests that patients who pill split may not have
been prior users of branded 1 mg finasteride.
PSS35
COST COMPARISON OF PATIENTS WITH CHRONIC HAND ECZEMA
COVERED BY STATUTORY VS. OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH INSURANCES
IN GERMANY
Diepgen T1, Augustin M2, Purwins S2, Posthumus J3, Kuessner D3
1
University Heidelberg, Heidelberg, Germany; 2University Clinics of Hamburg, Hamburg,
Germany; 3Basilea Pharmaceutica, Basel, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: In Germany, patients with chronic hand eczema (CHE) can either be
treated within the statutory health insurance system, or if CHE is suspected to be
work-related CHE in the system of occupational health insurances. The study objective
was to analyze the cost of CHE between both systems. METHODS: The survey was
conducted in 24 practices in the statutory health insurance system and 2 specialized
centers of the occupational health insurances. Patients with CHE refractory to potent
topical treatments were included. Patient characteristics/status and resource use were
elicited from patients and physicians. Costs were evaluated from the societal perspective (using insurance specific tariffs). Regression models were employed to compare
the direct and indirect costs across both data sets. RESULTS: A total of 223 patients
in the statutory health system and 87 patients in the occupational health insurance
system were included in this study. The patients’ severity was similar across both
samples. The yearly direct and indirect costs per patient are c1742 and c386 in the
statutory health insurance system as well as c3309 (c2534 according to statutory
health insurance tariff) and c3422 in the occupational health system. The indirect
costs are more pronounced among patients with work-related CHE. a comparison of
direct and indirect costs reveal higher costs for patients covered by occupational health
insurances (P < 0.01); however, no cost differences between both systems can be
detected after controlling for treatment stage and tariff differences. CONCLUSIONS:
Differences in the costs between both systems can be explained by different treatment
mixes, as direct costs are similar across treatment stages. As a result of longer absences
from work, the indirect costs of patients with work-related CHE are higher. This may
lead to the use of more effective and costly treatment strategies in this patient group.
PSS36
ECONOMIC ANALYSIS OF CATARACT SURGERY IN EUROPE: AN
ANALYSIS OF HOSPITAL DATABASES AVAILABLE IN 11 COUNTRIES
Doz M1, Lafuma A1, Berdeaux G2
1
CEMKA-EVAL, Bourg la Reine, France; 2Alcon France, Rueil-Malmaison, France
OBJECTIVES: Cataract surgery is one of the most efficacious medical strategies and
one of the most frequently performed operations in developed countries. Organization
for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) collects information on this
topic but their data are not updated often. The aim of this survey was to estimate the
number and costs of cataract surgeries performed in 14 European countries and the
potential costs associated with astigmatism. METHODS: Cataract surgery numbers
were estimated from available databases. Costs associated with cataract surgery were
13th Euro Abstracts
based on official tariffs of local health care systems. The number of surgeries and the
costs per 100 000 people were estimated for each country to allow comparisons.
Astigmatism related costs were also explored. This survey was carried out in 14
European countries: Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Greece,
Ireland, Italy, the The Netherlands, Portugal, Spain, Sweden, and the UK. RESULTS:
Information was fully available in 10 countries and partly available in OECD statistics.
Cataract surgery rates were in the range of 444 to 1,006 operations per 100,000
people in the countries with complete information. All the countries were using a DRG
system for costs and tariffs. Costs of operations were highly variable, depending on
complications, type of surgery, and surgical setting (outpatient or inpatient). Average
cost of surgery ranged across the countries from c875 to c2000. Average cost per
inhabitant was estimated at between c5 and c15 per year. Astigmatism associated
costs are never taken into account. CONCLUSIONS: Cataract surgery is performed
in a large part of the European population with variations across countries. Further
research needs to be conducted to explain differences between countries.
PSS37
CATARACT SURGERY GUIDELINES IN EUROPE: A LITERATURE REVIEW
AND DOCUMENT SEARCH IN 15 COUNTRIES
Jeanbat V1, Lafuma A1, Berdeaux G2
1
CEMKA-EVAL, Bourg la Reine, France; 2Alcon France, Rueil-Malmaison, France
OBJECTIVES: Cataract surgery is one of the most efficacious medical strategies and
one of the most frequently performed operations in developed countries. The aim of
this survey was to establish an assessment of the available guidelines for cataract
surgery in Europe. METHODS: The search was performed with a two steps design.
a classical literature search was performed using the method elaborated by the French
Haute Autorité de Santé directly through the Internet. a second step was to interview
local experts to identify grey literature in local languages that could be available
through local health authorities or medical societies. This survey was carried out in
15 European countries: Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany,
Greece, Ireland, Italy, the The Netherlands, Portugal, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, and
the UK. RESULTS: The classical literature search identified 15 documents that could
be considered as guidelines on cataract surgery. They were mainly written in English;
only one originated in Europe. General guidelines (n = 9) considered the initial checkup and indications for cataract surgery, surgical techniques and follow-up. Specific
guidelines were found covering the type of implants (n = 1), surgical technique (n =
1) and the anaesthesia technique (n = 4). This latter group was mainly extracted from
the Cochrane database. The second step of the research identified 10 local guidelines
in 7 European countries. These guidelines were rarely complete (n = 2) and envisaged
some specific aspects of the operation (n = 8) or the implants (n = 2). CONCLUSIONS:
Guidelines on cataract surgery are available at an international level but are rarely
provided at a country level in Europe.
SENSORY SYSTEMS DISORDERS – Conceptual Papers & Research on
Methods
PSS38
USE OF CALL CENTRE METHODOLOGY TO COLLECT QUALITY OF
LIFE (QOL) DATA IN A CLINICAL TRIAL: A CASE STUDY OF PATIENTS
WITH DIABETIC MACULAR EDEMA (DME)
Loftus J1, Pleil A2, Li J2, Wallace S3
1
Pfizer Ltd., Walton, UK; 2Pfizer Inc, San Diego, CA, USA; 3Quintiles Ltd, UK, Livingston,
Scotland, UK
OBJECTIVES: QoL data collected in clinical trials traditionally involves self-report
or face to face interviewer-administered questionnaires. The former may result in
missing data/errors; the latter requires trained interviewers, possibly adding variability
to the data collected (when multiple sites are involved) or bias in terms of social
desirability. To improve the quality of data collected in a clinical trial for DME, we
employed a centralised call centre methodology. METHODS: QoL data were collected
in a large multicenter trial, NCT00605280, evaluating the safety and efficacy of
pegaptanib sodium in patients with DME. An interface between the trial database and
the independent call centre was established. Once subjects entered the trial, subject
identifier, status and visit history were automatically generated and the call centre
agent received subject contact and visit details directly from the trial database. The
agent contacted the subjects to schedule interviews at the appropriate time points. Five
call backs were allowed per call to ensure questionnaire completion. All QoL responses
were recorded directly into the call centre database. The status of the QoL visit
information and completions were sent to the trial database weekly. RESULTS: The
two QoL measures (National Eye Institute Visual Function Questionnaire 25 and
EuroQol Group’s EQ-5D questionnaire) had high completion rates; 99.8% of completed interviews included both questionnaires (57% successfully completed on initial
attempt, 23% on the second attempt of contacting the subject). Only 4% of data were
missing; 26 minutes was the average completion time. CONCLUSIONS: This call
centre methodology resulted in high questionnaire completion and little missing data.
This approach demonstrates robustness and offers a feasible alternative for questionnaire administration, particularly in visually impaired people. Administration in the
subject’s home maybe advantageous and centralised interviewers (instead of site interviewers) potentially reduced the variability in questionnaire response. Further research
comparing methods is indicated.
13th Euro Abstracts
POSTER SESSION III
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Consumer Role in Health Care
PHP1
ORPHAN DRUGS: DOES SOCIETY VALUE RARITY?
Desser A, Kristiansen IS
University of Oslo, Oslo, Norway
OBJECTIVES: A general societal preference for prioritizing treatment of rare diseases
over common ones could provide a justification for accepting higher cost-effectiveness
thresholds for orphan drugs. We attempt to determine whether such a preference
exists. METHODS: We surveyed a random sample of 1547 Norwegians aged 40–67.
Respondents chose between funding treatment for a rare versus common disease and
completed a person trade-off (PTO) exercise between the diseases for each of two
scenarios: 1) identical per person costs, and 2) higher costs for the rare disease. Diseases were described identically with the exception of prevalence. Respondents were
randomized to either no information or different amounts of information about
disease severity (severe vs. moderate) and expected benefits of treatment (high vs. low).
All respondents rated five statements concerning equity attitudes on a Likert-scale.
RESULTS: A total of 68% of respondents agreed completely with the statement “rare
disease patients should have equal right to treatment regardless of costs.” Faced with
trade-offs, 11.3% of respondents favored treating the rare disease, 24.9% the common
disease and 64.8% expressed indifference. When the rare disease entailed a higher
opportunity cost, results were 7.4%, 45.3% and 47.3%, respectively. Framing (“extra
funding” vs. “replace patients”) and amount of information about severity and treatment effectiveness had a small impact on preferences. CONCLUSIONS: Although
there is strong support for general statements expressing a desire for equal treatment
rights for rare disease patients, that support evaporates when individuals are faced
with opportunity costs.
PHP2
THE HTA PUZZLE: VALUES, PRIORITIES, TECHNOLOGY
AFFORDABILITY, AND PATIENT AND COMMUNITY PREFERENCES.
HOW CAN WE MAKE IT LL FIT TOGETHER?
Grainger D1, Kelly M2, Skilbeck M2, Srikanthan S2
1
Eli Lilly & Company, Sydney, Australia; 2Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu, Melbourne, Victoria,
Australia
OBJECTIVES: This research considers how mature health technology assessment
(HTA) systems incorporate patient and community preferences and priorities into
decision-making processes. This presentation examines the policy rationale for
increased patient and community involvement, as well as providing case studies to
illustrate different approaches to community focused HTA practices. Effective options
for patient and community engagement will also be covered. METHODS: Qualitative
semi-structured interviews with key stakeholders in six developed countries: Australia,
Canada, England, France, Germany, and Scotland. a literature review was also undertaken to assess current HTA systems across the six countries. RESULTS: There was
significant variation across countries in terms of implementation, organization, and
prioritization. This study revealed two different, but parallel, considerations that are
important in HTAs: The ‘consumer perspective’ offers insight into variations in health
outcomes of technologies being assessed, as well as providing detail beyond what is
captured by QALY assessments in relation to community values, preferences, and
priorities. Secondly, the ‘community perspective’ takes a broader societal approach to
examine values, access, use, affordability of new technologies. CONCLUSIONS: An
understanding of these two ‘HTA puzzle pieces’ is required for the establishment of
governance and participation processes that will enable well defined consumer and
community roles in HTA, and will lead to more systematic approaches to the integration of patient perspectives. Findings from this research suggest there is a strong need
to consider a wider perspective of patient engagement in health policy and delivery,
of which HTA is but one part.
PHP3
THE VALUE OF PATIENT PERSPECTIVES IN THE DRUG DEVELOPMENT
LIFECYCLE
Versnel J1, Watch J2, Jack O2, Sparrowhawk K2
1
Cambridge, London, UK; 2PriceSpective LLC, London, UK
OBJECTIVES: Research was undertaken to determine the impact and value of soliciting patient viewpoints at key stages within the drug development lifecycle. METHODS:
Interviews were held with representatives from the biopharmaceutical, regulatory and
pricing and reimbursement sectors to identify the value and impact attributed to
patient perspectives. Additionally, surveys of European patient organizations and
patients with airways disease provided insight into their attempts to influence treatment decisions, which could affect market uptake. RESULTS: Industry ngagement
with patients was often reactive and linked to the identification of factors which may
impact on the success of a product. Earlier consultation may help the biopharmaceutical industry to optimise product development or assist key go/no-go decisions. Whilst
there is a harmonised regulatory process that engages patient organizations through
the European Medicines Agency, patient viewpoints or quality of life data seldom
influence access or pricing and reimbursement decisions in the main European
markets. Numerous examples were cited where this has led to political lobbying and
emotive decision making and a more transparent process involving patients may help
A405
to ensure decisions are based on clinical and cost-effectiveness. Involving patients in
the drug development lifecycle has the potential to improve health outcomes and
reduce health expenditure associated with poor management, often related to noncompliance. The earlier patients are involved, the greater the potential to avert or
minimise factors that could affect commercial success and return on investment.
CONCLUSIONS: For the biopharmaceutical industry, the value of patient perspectives lies as part of a risk-mitigation strategy to provide greater insight and control
over factors that affect market success. For regulators and payers, the value lies in the
potential to improve health outcomes and reduce health care budgets.
PHP4
POST HEALTH CARE REFORM PERCEPTIONS IN THE US: CONSUMER
PULSE SURVEY
Mooney P1, Janssens S2
1
Deloitte Consulting, Boston, MA, USA; 2Deloitte Consulting, Diegem, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: In March 2010, President Barak Obama signed the Patient Protection
and Affordable Care Act (PPACA), which radically changed the health care landscape
in the United States. We carried out a survey to gauge consumers’ opinion about the
U.S. health care system after the PPACA was signed into the U.S. law. METHODS:
We commissioned Harris Interactive to conduct a nationally representative telephone
survey of 1,019 adults from the U.S. between May 21–24. Respondents were questioned on their current insurance coverage status, their knowledge about the PPACA,
and their perception of the reform. Data were weighted to be representative of the
total U.S. adult population in terms of age, sex, geographic region and race. The survey
has a sampling error of ±3% at 95% confidence level. RESULTS: 84% of all adults
surveyed have an health insurance; 96% of adults 65 years old and above have health
insurance. Overall, while 36% of all adults surveyed think they will be “better off”
as a result of the reform; 43% think they will become “worse off”. 61% of respondents said they are “very knowledgeable” or “somewhat knowledgeable” about the
PPACA; 54% of adults surveyed who rated themselves as “very knowledgeable” think
they will be “worse off” as a result of the bill. Adults surveyed anticipate an increase
in tax (76%), hospital and physician prices (65%), health insurance cost (65%) and
cost of medications (54%). CONCLUSIONS: According to the survey, while the
majority of consumers are satisfied with their current health care coverage, many have
concerns about potential changes from PPACA. Concerns include health insurance
coverage, access to quality health care and potential cost increase. In addition, the
majority of consumers said that they are at least somewhat knowledgeable about
PPACA.
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Diagnosis Related Group
PHP5
PATIENT DISCHARGE FROM INTENSIVE CARE UNITS WITHIN AND
BETWEEN HOSPITALS IN HUNGARY
Varga S1, Gresz M2, Kriszbacher I1, Oláh A1, Betlehem J1, Sebestyén A3, Ágoston I1, Boncz I1
1
University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary; 2National Health Insurance Fund Administration,
Budapest, Hungary; 3National Health Insurance Fund Administration, Pécs, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: In our earlier study we found that measured by the number of cases
(patients), the market share of intensive therapy was analyzed in Hungary and was
found between 0.84% and 1.80% during a 14-year period (1995–2008). The discharge of patient not needing intensive therapy is obligated. The aim of the study was
to analyze patient discharge. METHODS: Data were derived from the National
Health Insurance Fund Administration. The two types of patient discharge were
analyzed during a 9-year period, the discharges from intensive care unit within the
same hospital and between different hospitals from 2000 to 2008. RESULTS: Compared to the total discharges the within and between hospitals discharges changed
between 70.6% (2000) and 77.3% (2005) during the 9 years (2000–2008). Within
hospital discharge started from 65.2% (2000) and the highest value was 73.0%
(2006). Between hospitals discharged changed between 2.9% (2006) and 5.4%
(2000). The sum of the two types discharge steadily increased from 70.6% (2000) to
77.3% (2005) in the first 6 years and after a linear descending it finished on 74.7%
in 2008. Within hospital discharge increased from 65.2% (2000) to 73.0% (2006)
and decrease to 69.6% until 2008. Between hospitals discharges decreased from 5.4%
(2000) to 4.3% (2001), but it were steady from 2002 to 2005 (4.5%–4.8%). In 2006
a sudden decrease happend to 2.9% and after it the values were 3.3%–3.2% in the
last 2 years. The mean of the within hospital discharges were 70.5% while the between
hospitals discharges were 4.2%. CONCLUSIONS: In Hungary between 2000 and
2008 the discharges of the patients from the intensive care units to other hospital
departments were 70.5%. The majority (94.38%) of the discharged patients was
treated in the same hospital and only a minor proportion (5.62%) were moved to
other hospitals.
A406
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Disease Management
PHP6
ROUTINE OF PATIENTS’ REDIRECTION IN THE HUNGARIAN PRIMARY
CARE
Lipp S1, Boncz I2, Gresz M3, Varga S2, Oláh A2, Marada G2, Sebestyén A1
1
National Health Insurance Fund Administration, Pécs, Hungary; 2University of Pécs, Pécs,
Hungary; 3National Health Insurance Fund Administration, Budapest, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study is to analyze the GPs’ routine of redirection. We
reveals which diagnoses induce the most frequent redirection cases to specialists, which
specialties are the most frequently targeted and how the distance from the nearest
outpatient unit influences the GPs’ practice. METHODS: The analysis is based on the
monthly reports (B300 form of the Hungarian Naional Health Insurance Fund Administration (OEP) of 701 general practitioners. Study covers the years 2008 and 2009,
14 million visits of 952 thousand inhabitants of South-Transdanubian Region of
Hungary. GPs’ redirection routine is measured by the redirection rate, which shows
the number of redirections related to the number of GP visits (%). RESULTS: The
population of the region decreased by 0.8% over the years 2008–2009, however the
number of GP visits increased by 12%. The surplus is mainly due to the H1N1 vaccination campaign and the rise of cardiovascular diseases and respiratory diseases of
allergic origin. The average redirection rate was 10%. 76% of the GPs’ surgeries are
located not farther than 15 km from the nearest outpatient unit, and 62% not farther
than 15 km from a hospital. The distance from the nearest outpatient unit influences
the redirection rate, but this impact is not determining. The most frequently needed
specialties are rheumatology, cardiology, pulmonology and orthopedics. GPs direct
their patients of 0–14 years to specialists more rarely than patients of 15 years or
above and also the referred diagnoses vary between the two age groups. CONCLUSIONS: The redirection rate is lower on case of young patients and higher on case of
adult, and elderly patients. While young patients get to specialists mainly due to acute
and chronic respiratory diseases (many of them have allergic origin), orthopaedic
malformations or simply health monitoring, adult patients have cardiovascular, rheumatic, and endocrine problems.
PHP7
AN EXPLORATORY STUDY EVALUATING THE PREPAREDNESS OF
PRACTICING COMMUNITY PHARMACISTS IN MALAYSIA FOR
MANAGEMENT ROLES
Al-Haddad M, Hassali MA
Universiti Sains Malaysia, Penang, Malaysia
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the preparedness of the community pharmacists in the
State of Penang in six main management functions: Accounting, finance, human
resource management, marketing management, planning, and directing. METHODS:
A cross-sectional study design was carried out with a total of 100 community pharmacists practicing in the State of Penang, Malaysia. a pre-validated questionnaire,
containing 3 sections was used as data collection tool. All data was analyzed using
SPSS for Windows version 13.0. Inferential statistics were used whenever appropriate
at alpha value of 0.05 or less considered significant. RESULTS: A total of 50 pharmacists successfully responded to the survey. When respondents were asked about the
percentage of time spent in actual management functions, 42% of them responded
that their time is being spent on actual management functions. More than 60% of
community pharmacists said that most of the time, they undertake tasks in accounting,
finance, human resource management, marketing management, planning, and directing. When respondents were compared in terms of their demographics, the time
overseas graduates showed better preparation and performance of management functions compared to local graduates. CONCLUSIONS: The findings of this study
showed that most of the community pharmacists understand and undertake the
management functions in running their community pharmacy business. Furthermore
the findings suggested that local pharmacy graduates were less prepared to undertake
various management functions compared to their overseas graduated counterparts.
PHP8
INTERVENTIONS TO REDUCE HOSPITAL READMISSIONS IN THE
ELDERLY
Linertová R1, García-Pérez L1, Vázquez-Díaz JR2, Lorenzo-Riera A3, Sarría-Santamera A4
1
Fundación Canaria de Investigación y Salud (FUNCIS), Las Palmas de Gran Canaria, Spain;
2
University Hospital of Canary Islands, Santa Cruz de Tenerife, Spain; 3Primary Care Services
of Gran Canaria, Las Palmas de Gran Canaria, Spain; 4Agency for Health Technology
Assessment, Carlos III Institute of Health, Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Unplanned hospital readmissions of elderly people present an increasing burden for health systems. This could be, theoretically, reduced by adequate
preventive interventions. However, there is uncertainty about the effectiveness of different types of interventions. The objective of this systematic review was to summarise
available evidence on the effectiveness of interventions to reduce the risk of unplanned
readmissions in patients of 75 years and older and to determine the role of home care
components. METHODS: We searched studies in MEDLINE, CINAHL, CENTRAL
and seven other electronic databases up to October 2007 and updated the search in
MEDLINE up to October 2009. Clinical trials (randomized or controlled) evaluating
the effectiveness of an intervention to reduce readmissions in elderly patients compared
to a control group were selected. Quality was assessed by the SIGN tool. The extracted
information was presented in text and tables. RESULTS: Thirty-two clinical trials
were included and divided into two groups: in-hospital interventions (17 studies) and
13th Euro Abstracts
interventions with home follow-up (15 studies). Three studies from the first group and
seven from the second group found positive effects of the evaluated intervention on
readmission outcome. CONCLUSIONS: Most of the evaluated interventions did not
have any effect on readmissions of elderly patients. However, those interventions that
comprised some kind of home care seem to be more likely to reduce readmissions in
the elderly.
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Drug/Device/Diagnostic Use &
Policy
PHP9
BUDGET IMPACT ANALYSIS OF ORPHAN DRUGS IN BELGIUM:
ESTIMATES FROM 2008 TO 2013
Denis A1, Mergaert L1, Fostier C1, Cleemput I2, Simoens S3
1
Yellow Window Management Consultants, Antwerp, Belgium; 2Belgian Health Care
Knowledge Centre, Brussels, Belgium; 3K.U. Leuven, Leuven, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: This study aims to calculate the impact of orphan drugs on the Belgian
drug budget in 2008 and to forecast its impact over the following five years.
METHODS: The 2008 budget impact was calculated by triangulating information
derived from multiple Belgian data sources, including Ministerial Decrees, figures
published by the National Institute for Health and Disability Insurance, and reimbursement files submitted to the Drug Reimbursement Committee. The 2008–2013
budget impact analysis was based on three scenarios reflecting different levels of
growth in the number of registered orphan drugs in the European Union, the number
of drugs reimbursed in Belgium, and the average annual cost per patient per drug in
Belgium. The price year was 2008. RESULTS: At the end of 2008, 31 different orphan
drugs were approved for reimbursement in Belgium for 35 different indications. The
annual number of Belgian patients treated varied between 1 and 1080 patients per
orphan drug. The cost per patient per year ranged from c4600 to c411,000 between
orphan drugs. The orphan drug budget impact amounted to c66.2 million (or 5% of
the Belgian hospital drug budget) in 2008. The impact would increase to c130–c204
million in 2013, depending on the scenario. CONCLUSIONS: The analysis showed
that the budget impact of orphan drugs in Belgium is substantial and rising, thereby
putting pressure on total drug expenditure. This static analysis measured orphan drug
costs only, assuming that other components of health expenditure do not change over
time. Policy options to address the rising budget impact include pricing linked to return
on investment, risk-sharing arrangements and re-appraisal of orphan drug status if
additional indications are approved.
PHP10
DOES THE MARKET SHARE OF GENERIC MEDICINES INFLUENCE THE
PRICE LEVEL? A EUROPEAN ANALYSIS
Dylst P, Simoens S
K.U. Leuven, Leuven, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: This study aims to investigate the relationship between the market
share of generic medicines and the medicine price level in European off-patent pharmaceutical markets. METHODS: Data on medicine volumes and on medicine values
for a basket of 35 active substances were derived from IMS Health. Ex-manufacturer
medicine prices were calculated by dividing market value by market volume. The
analysis was limited to medicines in immediate-release, oral, solid dosage forms. The
included countries were Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Germany, France, Italy, the The
Netherlands, Spain, Sweden and the United Kingdom, which constitute a mix of
countries with low and high generic medicines market shares. Data were available
from June 2002 until March 2007. RESULTS: Market value has seen a substantial
decrease in high generic market share markets (−26.6%), while the decrease in low
market share markets was marginal (−0.06%). Market volume has risen in both high
generic market share markets (+29.27%) and low market share markets (+27.40%)
but the cause of rise is different for the two markets. In low generic market share
markets, the rise was caused by the increased use of generic medicines while in high
market share markets the rise was driven by the increased use of generic medicines
and a shift of use from originator to generic medicines. In high generic market share
markets, medicines prices have dropped by −43.18% and in low market share markets
by −21.56%. CONCLUSIONS: The extent to which price competition from generic
medicines leads to price reductions appears to vary according to the market share of
generic medicines. High market share markets of generic medicines have seen a larger
decrease in medicine prices than low market share markets. Countries need thus to
create an environment which stimulates the generic medicines use and so increases the
market share.
PHP11
NEW AND IMPROVED: DEFINING INNOVATION FOR HEALTH
TECHNOLOGY POLICY
Davis C, Menon D
University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada
OBJECTIVES: Both individuals and society stand to benefit from encouraging health
technological innovation—individual patients through quicker access to promising
technologies, and society through the development of a competitive life sciences sector.
The “Innovation Pass” (UK) and the “Critical Path Initiative” (US) are 2 examples of
current health policies aimed at promoting innovation. However, there does not seem
to be a clear agreement on what constitutes innovation. The objective of this project
13th Euro Abstracts
was to identify existing definitions of innovation, values inherent in innovation initiatives, and important considerations for the development of policies to promote innovation of health technologies. METHODS: A literature search of bibliographic databases
including PubMed, EMBASE, Web of Science, Centre for Reviews and Dissemination
databases, National Library of Medicine Gateway, EconLit and the New York
Academy of Medicine Grey Literature collection was conducted for the period January
2005 to April 2010. The search terms were intended to capture concepts of “innovation” and “policy” in the health technology (drugs, devices, etc,) sector. Two researchers reviewed titles and abstracts of over 4500 references identified; 200 papers were
retrieved for full review. Key components of innovation were extracted and summarized in tabular form to identify trends and emerging themes. RESULTS: System
disrupting, development of relationships and improvement on current practice are
examples of components of, or criteria for defining, health technology innovation.
Thematic concepts that emerged during the review include innovative health technology as a novelty and as a mechanism for achieving some benefit or good (broadlydefined) at various levels of the health system. CONCLUSIONS: Based on the variety
of definitions in the literature, lack of a common understanding of innovation may
result in policy incoherence. The use of a consistent and unambiguous definition
provides a solid framework from which to develop policy that is measurable, meaningful and, therefore, has a greater chance of being effective.
PHP12
PHYSICIANS VIEWS ON BIOMEDICAL TECHNOLOGY IN GREECE
1
1
1
1
2
Tsiantou V , Skroumpelos A , Mylona K , Athanasakis K , Konstantinopoulos O ,
Kyriopoulos J1
1
National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece; 2Sotiria Hospital, Athens, Greece
OBJECTIVES: Given the significant impact of biomedical technology on health, the
present study aims at identifying the accessibility to certain biomedical technologies
and factors affecting its use and diffusion, in Greece. METHODS: A strictly structured
questionnaire was designed and sent to a sample of 388 internists and GPs over 50
years old, stratified by geographical area and employment sector. Participants were
asked a) to evaluate on a 1 to 10 point scale patient access to selected biomedical
technologies and the degree to which selected factors affect their decision to use the
above interventions and b) to rank certain factors effect on the diffusion of biomedical
technologies. RESULTS: The response rate was 76%. The statistical analysis revealed
that the most accessible biomedical technologies were ultrasonography (9.4), PSA
(9.38), cardiac enzymes (8.99), MRI and CT (8.86), and mammography (8.83). The
most important factors affecting participants’ decision to use a technology were the
treatment outcome (9.23), the disease severity (9.11) and the appropriateness of the
technology for each condition (8.27) while factors such as health system and patient
cost were proved less influential. 68.1% of participants claimed delays in the diffusion
of biomedical technology in Greece, identifying as major barriers economic and specialized human resources deficiencies. CONCLUSIONS: Based on our results, higher
access was observed to technologies related to neoplasms and cardiovascular diseases,
which represent the main causes of morbidity and mortality in Greece. Furthermore,
our findings support the view that when it comes to use a technology physicians are
mostly concerned with the clinical effectiveness of an intervention and less with its
impact on health care expenditures. Finally, the major diffusion barriers identified in
this study show a suboptimal resource allocation practice, stressing the need for
measures to be taken in this direction in order to enhance diffusion of biomedical
technologies in Greece.
PHP13
IMPLEMENTATION OF THE TRANSPARENCY DIRECTIVE IN HUNGARY
1
2
Kalo Z , Nagyjanosi L
1
Eötvös Loránd University, Budapest, Hungary; 2Syreon Research Institute, Budapest, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: Transparency Directive (TD) of the European Union aims to ensure
the transparency of procedures for the pricing and reimbursement of medicinal products by Member States. TD proposes strict timelines for the pricing and reimbursement
process and indicates the necessity of objective and verifiable criteria for decisions and
the availability of remedies for negative decisions. Our objective was to compare the
routine process of pharmaceutical pricing and reimbursement with the TD in Hungary.
METHODS: We analyzed official resolutions of 29 pricing and reimbursement submissions by the National Health Insurance Fund (NHIF) between January and June
2008. In 14 cases the NHIF granted reimbursement, in 15 cases the reimbursement
claim was rejected. We calculated the time period between the submission of the
reimbursement dossier and the official decision. We assessed the consistency of applying objective and verifiable criteria in positive or negative decisions. RESULTS: The
average time period for pricing and reimbursement procedure was 172 days (min: 43
days; max: 534 days). We could not justify the consistency of employing objective and
verifiable criteria in the pricing and reimbursement resolutions of innovative pharmaceuticals. CONCLUSIONS: The pharmaceutical pricing and reimbursement process
in Hungary is neither transparent nor predictable. There are several open pricing and
reimbursement submissions without resolution for long period. Although we could
analyze only cases with resolution, the time period for pricing and reimbursment
decision was still longer in several cases than 90 + 90 days recommended by TD. The
appropriate use of scarce public health care resources could not be justified in case of
positive decisions and there is no remedy for negative reimbursement decisions. TD
has been implemented only partially in Hungary.
A407
PHP14
THE JOINT COMMITTEE FOR NEW DRUGS EVALUATION IN SPAIN: 6
YEARS OF EXPERIENCE
Collar J
Pharmacoeconomics & Outcomes Research Iberia, Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: The Joint Committee for New Drugs Evaluation (JCNDE) was established in 2003 to improve efficiency in drug evaluation in Spain. Five Regional Drug
Evaluation Centres are part of it and have common Standard Operating Procedures
(SOPs) which are regularly updated and improved. The objective of this study was to
analyze the drugs innovation degree scores assigned by the JCNDE and timing between
the new drug commercialization and the JCNDE evaluation. METHODS: The JCNDE
SOPs define a stepwise procedure with 4 key criteria for new drug innovation ratings:
efficacy, safety, convenience and drug cost. The drug innovation scores range from 0
(insufficient experience with the drug) to 4 (relevant therapeutic improvement). The
drug evaluation results were gathered from JCNDE reports and from the Regional
Drug evaluation centre reports. The time period analyzed was from 2004 to 2009.
RESULTS: Ninety drug evaluations were held, considering 86 different drugs and 11
evaluations for a new drug indication for the same drug. Seventy-eight (87%) of the
evaluations were negative (scores 0–1), not finding any 0 in the last 2 years of the
study. Ten and 2 evaluations were scored as 2 and 3 respectively. None of the drugs
assessed were considered a relevant therapeutic improvement compared to the existing
options. Five drugs not reimbursed were evaluated. Median time since commercialization to evaluation was 6 months (IQR: 2–11 months) and 32 drug evaluations were
held before up to a maximum of 3 months after commercialization. CONCLUSIONS:
The JCNDE has been an efficient instrument to develop new drug assessments in the
Primary Care setting for the Regional Health Systems in Spain. Most of the assessments held have been negative. At present, health-economics arguments are basically
focused on the daily treatment cost comparisons. About 1/3 of the evaluations are
started before drug commercialization.
PHP15
DRUG COMPARATOR DIFFERENCES IN THE THERAPEUTIC BULLETINS
IN SPAIN: THE JCNDE EXPERIENCE
Collar J
Pharmacoeconomics & Outcomes Research Iberia, Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: The Spanish Joint Committee for New Drugs Evaluation (JCNDE) was
created in 2003 and is formed by 5 Regional Drug Evaluation Centres. JCNDE has
common Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) to unify drug assessments and where
the comparators availability is a key issue. Each individual Drug Evaluation Centre
has its own new drug therapeutic bulletin to spread information between their health
professionals. The objective of this study was to quantify the uniformity degree
through the drug bulletins and the degree of heterogeneity reflected in the drug costs.
METHODS: New drug therapeutic bulletins of the 5 members of the JCNDE were
reviewed between 2006 and 2009. Each drug assessed by the JCNDE was tracked to
identify which members reported it in their bulletins. Comparative drugs included in
the bulletins were also registered to find potential heterogeneity amongst the JCNDE
members. Daily/monthly treatment costs described were included in the study database. RESULTS: Fifty-seven drug evaluations were recorded, forty (70%) were published by at least 3 members of the JCNDE, and only 12 were published by all of
them. Andalusia, Basque Country and Catalonia are the most active members, with
12–14 new drugs published per year. In all the bulletins were identified some differences in the comparators used for each new drug assessed. Andalusia and Catalonia
tend to include more comparators. The highest level of heterogeneity is observed in
drugs of diabetes treatment. Most of the drug costs reported were very similar. Only
one disagrement between the JCNDE was identified in the drug innovation rating.
CONCLUSIONS: JCNDE has made advances to unify drug assessment in Spain.
Nevertheless, health-economics arguments are still focused on drug treatment cost
comparisons. The comparators found in the drug bulletins are slightly different
amongst the regions. Future SOPs version ought to improve these two weak points.
PHP17
ACCESSIBILITY TO ORPHAN DRUGS IN JAPAN—HAS THE ORPHAN
DESIGNATION SYSTEM CONTRIBUTED?
Tomita N1, Kodama T2, Inagaki A1
1
Keio University, Kanagawa, Japan; 2National Institute of Public Health, Saitama, Japan
OBJECTIVES: To promote the research and development of drugs for rare diseases,
like other countries, orphan designations have been granted to pharmaceuticals in
Japan since 1993. We investigated the accessibility of orphan drugs in Japan by
comparing the accessibility of orphan designated and marketing authorised drugs in
the EU and the US. METHODS: The present study used the data available until the
November 30, 2009 from the European Medicines Agency, US Food and Drug
Administration and National Institute of Biomedical Innovation. The International
Nonproprietary Names (INNs) were used for comparing authorised orphan designated drugs in Japan, the EU and the US. RESULTS: A total of 228 products had
been granted orphan designation, of which 142 (62%) obtained marketing authorization in Japan, which is equivalent to 122 in INNs. Meanwhile, the number of authorised orphan-designated medicines in INNs in the EU and the US was 57 and 198,
respectively. Of the total 287 authorised orphan-designated pharmaceuticals in INNs
in these 3 regions, 165 were inaccessible in Japan through the orphan designation
system. Among such drugs, 25 (15%) were authorised orphan designated in both the
EU and the US, 15 (9%) were authorised orphan designated in the EU alone and 125
(76%) were authorised orphan designated in the US alone. CONCLUSIONS: We
A408
observed that the orphan designation system in Japan has achieved certain results for
increasing the accessibility of necessary drugs to patients suffering with rare diseases.
However, several drugs are still not available in Japan, partly because of the difference
in definitions of orphan disease among the 3 regions. To increase the accessibility to
orphan drugs, further policy interventions should be considered.
PHP18
SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE FOR THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN
PHARMACEUTICAL BUDGET OF HEALTH INSURANCE FUND AND THE
POLITICAL ELECTION CIRCLES IN HUNGARY
Boncz I1, Sebestyén A2
1
University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary; 2National Health Insurance Fund Administration, Pécs,
Hungary
OBJECTIVES: There is a continuous problem in Hungary—and assumable in many
other countries—with planning the health insurance pharmaceutical budget. In
Hungary there is a substantial gap between the planned and the actual budget resulting
in an overspending of the planned pharmaceutical budget. The aim of our study is to
analyze the gap between the planned and the actual health insurance pharmaceutical
budget. METHODS: Data were derived from the nationwide administrative data set
of the National Health Insurance Fund Administration (OEP), the only health care
financing agency in Hungary. We analyzed the difference between the planned and
the actual pharmaceutical budget of OEP between 1994 and 2006. Outcome (overspending rate) is measured with the following formula: the difference between the
planned and the actual budget is divided with the planned budget. RESULTS: During
the period of 1994–2006 we found significant overspending of pharmaceutical budget
of OEP which varied between 3.4–36.6% of actual pharmaceutical expenditures. The
peak of overspending showed a 4 years circle with the highest figures in 1994 (21,5%),
1998 (32.1%), 2002 (36.6%) and 2006 (30.4%). These 4 calendar years correspond
with the time of national political (parliamentary) elections. CONCLUSIONS: We
found the highest overspending of the Hungarian pharmaceutical budget in the years
of national political elections. It is a scientific evidence for the political influence of
the health insurance pharmaceutical budget. The overspending does not relate to any
specific political parties or governments because it was a general phenomenon in
Hungary between 1994–2006.
PHP19
ANALYSIS OF THE GREEK PHARMACEUTICAL MARKET: THE
FRAMEWORK, THE FACTS AND THE TRENDS (1998–2008)
Vitsou E1, Souliotis K2, Caporis X3
1
Foundation of Economic and Industrial Research, Athens, Greece; 2Cival Ervants Security
Fund, Athens, Greece; 3MSD Greece, Athens, Greece
BACKGROUND: The Greek economy is being called upon to manage one of the
highest proportions of public debt versus GDP in the European Union and the Euro
zone. In turn, the health care sector is subject to the distortions of the Greek public
sector, as there is no official method of measuring and evaluating the services being
provided. OBJECTIVES: The objective of this analysis was both to interpret the
development of pharmaceutical expenditure, based on the most significant changes in
the pricing and reimbursement system, as well as to evaluate the institutional changes
based on their effectiveness. METHODS: The analysis reflects the evolution of pharmaceutical expenditure and interprets the changes in the regulatory framework that
took place in Greece from 1998–2008. It should be noted that there is significant
confusion around the actual level of pharmaceutical expenditure, as the data provided
for 2003–2007 (provisional data) from the National Statistical Service of Greece are
not in agreement with OECD’s data. Following a more careful analysis of the data,
numerous questions arise with respect to their reliability, as there is no explanation
for the apparent rate of change with regard to the factors that could influence expenditure (e.g. changes in the pricing or reimbursement system). Therefore the actual level
of pharmaceutical expenditure is also in question. RESULTS: After analyzing the price
changes in the top 100 selling pharmaceutical products in Greece, throughout the
indicated period, it became obvious that the cause of increasing pharmaceutical
expenditure cannot be attributed to increasing prices, but to other factors mainly
associated with over-consumption. CONCLUSIONS: Finally, taking into account the
intense pressures on public financing of the health care system, it is important for any
future measures to constrain costs to be based on reliable and accurate data and to
target the entirety of the system.
PHP20
QUALITY ASSURANCE OF FOURTH HURDLE CONCERNING TO
MEDICAL DEVICES
Tesar T1, Babela R2
1
UNION health insurance fund, Bratislava, Slovak Republic; 2St.Elizabeth University of Health
and Social Sciences, Bratislava, Slovak Republic
OBJECTIVES: The Slovak guidelines for economic evaluation, although appearing to
be generic, have been written focusing on pharmaceuticals. The objective of this study
was to analyze the quality of submitted economic studies and related critical appraisals
process and to develop a policy-relevant, publicly available Slovak critical appraisal
checklist for improving the quality of economic evaluation for reimbursement submission of dossiers concerning to medical devices. METHODS: We created a working
group to review previously submitted economic evaluations and related critical
appraisals in order to identify potential technical and methodological problems. The
working group consisted of two independent academic experts who scrutinized previous submissions and critical appraisals concerning to medical devices between 2007–
13th Euro Abstracts
2010. RESULTS: Evidence suggests that the methods of economic evaluation can be
equally applied to drugs and devices in general. However, there are several specific
methodological issues that require more attention if reliable and informative evaluations of devices are to be conducted. These issues are underestimated within the Slovak
Republic. It is well known that expenditures for medical devices do not result in the
most cost-effective outcomes. Economic evaluations of medical devices are mandatory
but the quality of evaluations and critical appraisals are poor. Our analysis shows that
the simplified questionnaire, which is currently used for the critical appraisal process
within Slovakia should be replaced by a new Slovak critical appraisal checklist, which
will be detailed enough to address the specific problems in the local economic evaluations process. CONCLUSIONS: The transparent method of technology assessment
can improve the consistency of reimbursement decisions making related to medical
devices in Slovakia. Therefore in addition to the available Slovak health economic
evaluation guidelines a detailed checklist for appraisal processes specific for medical
devices have to be prepared. The economic evaluation of devices raises additional
challenges and the current Slovak guidelines overlook several issues.
PHP21
EARLY ACCESS: ANALYSIS OF THE FRENCH ATU SYSTEM
1
1
1
2
Hensen M , Heemstra HE , Meijboom MJ , Doreau C
1
Pharmerit International, Rotterdam, The Netherlands; 2Consultant, Antibes, France
OBJECTIVES: The French cohort ATU provides early access to medicines for serious
or rare diseases prior to marketing authorization (MA) for groups of patients. This
study determines the length of time of patient access before MA for different types
and classes of products subject to a cohort ATU. METHODS: All medicines subject
to a cohort ATU between 1994 and 2009 were obtained from the website of Afssaps.
Products which were never authorized were excluded. Time from initiation of a cohort
ATU to marketing authorization was determined. Subgroup analyses were performed
for orphan products, products developed by small and medium enterprises (SMEs),
and products in major indication classes. RESULTS: 87 products matched the inclusion criteria. Products were available on average 23 (range 0–121) months prior to
MA. Orphan drugs (N = 13;15%) and non-orphan drugs were available 19 months
(2–74) and 24 (0–121) months before MA respectively. Drugs developed by SMEs (N
= 5;6%) were available on average 34 (9–59) months before MA, while drugs developed by larger companies were available 22 (0–121) months before MA. Blood
products (ATC = B;N = 10;11%) were available on average 53 (2–121) months before
MA, and anti-infectives (ATC = J;N = 31;36%) 15 (0–70) months, followed by 13
(1–74) months for oncology products (ATC = L;N = 19;21%). The average length of
time before MA decreased from 21.4 between 1994 and 2003 to 3.7 between 2004
and 2008. CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrates that the cohort ATU provides
access to medicines several months before MA and has been used primarily by larger
pharmaceutical companies. The length of time of access before MA differs by indication and type of product and has been shorter in recent years. Price level and indication
should reflect future authorized indications and price. The lower than expected
number of orphan drugs subject to a cohort ATU may be the result of more frequent
use via the nominative ATU or in clinical trials.
PHP23
ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF TELEHEALTH/TELEMEDICINE AND
COST-EFFECTIVENESS ARGUMENT AMONG KEY DECISION-MAKERS
Shepelev J, Guhl A, Vekaria R, Gbenedio T
GfK HealthCare, London, UK
OBJECTIVES: To gather insights into global (5EU, US, emerging markets) national
policy & key decision-makers’ beliefs & perceptions on current and future landscape
as well as impact and value of telehealth/telemedicine initiatives within health care
programmes from health economic perspectives. METHODS: Both primary and secondary research was used for this study. Literature reviews with compilation of all
relevant and up-to-date information including data in local languages. Primary
research focused on market specifics where clarification and market insights were
required (such as MOH, budget-holder’s organizations, Public Health Institutions,
senior health care professionals). RESULTS: Benefits for improving both accessibility
and quality of health care through telehealth/telemedicine have vast potential. These
initiatives require substantial investment, whereas human and financial resources are
limited. It is important to demonstrate economic viability, in addition to technical and
clinical evaluations, in order to understand the optimal conditions under which new
telehealth/telemedicine programmes should be unfolded. Traditionally, cost-effectiveness analysis is used to evaluate telehealth/telemedicine programmes. Such an approach
is represented only by monetary differentials (fixed, variable, marginal, and direct and
indirect costs) and has numerous limitations due to the lack of available data as well
as constant changes in technological progress. As discovered, it is imperative to add
a range of different analytical techniques to traditional cost analyses. Other factors—
such as perception and investment choices, quality of health care provision, consumer
choice and political environment—should be taken into consideration. CONCLUSIONS: To understand the criteria national leaders use, and the supporting evidence
they require, to allocate monetary resources for innovative telehealth/telemedicine
programmes—traditional monetary analysis is not enough and we recommend two
supplementary approaches: societal and perceptual analysis. This will allow further
insights on views and value that telehealth/telemedicine initiatives deliver—and the
priority within health care programmes—in order to reveal the willingness to pay
among key decision-makers.
13th Euro Abstracts
PHP24
CRITICAL ASSESSMENT OF BELGIAN REIMBURSEMENT DOSSIERS OF
ORPHAN DRUGS
Denis A1, Mergaert L1, Fostier C1, Cleemput I2, Hulstaert F2, Simoens S3
1
Yellow Window Management Consultants, Antwerp, Belgium; 2Belgian Health Care
Knowledge Centre, Brussels, Belgium; 3K.U. Leuven, Leuven, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: This study aims to conduct an assessment of reimbursement dossiers
of orphan drugs in Belgium. First, a qualitative analysis reviews the evidence submitted
in reimbursement dossiers of all orphan drugs. Second, an in-depth analysis compares
the clinical evidence submitted to the European Medicines Agency with the Belgian
reimbursement dossiers for selected orphan drugs. METHODS: A qualitative analysis
examined all reimbursement dossiers of orphan drugs that have been submitted in
Belgium between January 2002 and June 2008. The following information was
extracted from each dossier: description of the orphan drug; indication; reimbursement status; therapeutic value and needs; budget impact; and number of registered
indications. For selected orphan drugs, an in-depth analysis extracted and compared
information about the clinical trials, their primary endpoints and results from the
following data sources: European Medicines Agency documents (i.e. the marketing
authorization application file, the European Public Assessment Report and the
Summary of Product Characteristics); and the Belgian reimbursement dossiers.
RESULTS: Reimbursement was awarded to the majority of orphan drugs. In addition
to the official criteria, other arguments such as the price, employment, patient population, funding of diagnostic tests by the company seemed to play a role in the reimbursement decision. Despite the low number of patients, randomized controlled trials were
conducted for many orphan drugs. Budget impact analyses were simplistic and did
not consider the impact across multiple indications. Also, some differences were
observed in the clinical evidence submitted to the European Medicines Agency and
the Belgian reimbursement authorities. CONCLUSIONS: There is substantial variation in the evidence that is submitted to the Belgian authorities in the context of an
orphan drug reimbursement dossier. Also, some differences have been noted in the
clinical evidence reported in European Medicines Agency documents and the evidence
included in Belgian reimbursement dossiers of orphan drugs.
PHP25
DOES HUMAN MEDICINES DEVELOPMENT IN THE EUROPEAN UNION
ADDRESS GLOBAL AND REGIONAL HEALTH CONCERNS?
Catalá-López F1, Garcia-Altés A2, Álvarez-Martín E3, Gènova-Maleras R4,
Morant-Ginestar C4
1
Spanish Medicines and Healthcare Products Agency (AEMPS), Madrid, Spain; 2King’s College
London, London, UK; 3Rey Juan Carlos University, Madrid, Spain; 4Regional Health Council of
Madrid, Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Our aim was to investigate whether efforts to develop innovative
medicines in the European Union (EU) are focusing on the most relevant conditions
from a global public health perspective. METHODS: We reviewed the information
on new medicinal products approved by centralised procedure (from 1995 to 2009),
available for the public in the European Commission Register of medicinal products
and the European Public Assessment Reports (EPAR) from the European Medicines
Agency. We included morbidity-mortality data for each disease group, according to
the World Health Organization Global Burden of Disease project. We evaluated the
association between authorised medicinal products and burden of disease measures
(disability-adjusted life-years [DALYs]) in the EU and worldwide. RESULTS: We
considered 520 marketing authorizations for medicinal products and 338 active ingredients. New authorizations were seen to increase over the period analyzed. There was
a positive, high correlation between DALYs and new medicinal products development
(ρ = 0.619, P = 0.005) in the EU, that was moderate for middle-low income countries
(ρ = 0.497, P = 0.030) and worldwide (ρ = 0.490, P = 0.033). In the EU, the most
neglected conditions (related to their attributable health losses) were neuropsychiatric
diseases, cardiovascular diseases, respiratory diseases, sense organ conditions or digestive diseases, while globally they were perinatal conditions, respiratory infections,
sense organ conditions, respiratory diseases, or digestive diseases. CONCLUSIONS:
Our findings suggest that the development of new medicinal products is higher in some
diseases than in others. Pharmaceutical industry and decision-makers are invited to
consider the implications of this imbalance establishing work plans that allow for
setting future priorities from a public health perspective.
PHP26
DEVELOPMENT OF SYSTEMATIC PROCESS MAPS TO ENABLE
COMPARISON BETWEEN DIFFERENT HTA AND DECISION MAKING
SYSTEMS: THE FIRST STEP TO BENCHMARKING
Pichler FB1, Allen N2, Salek S2, Liberti L1
1
CMR International Institute for Regulatory Science, London, UK; 2Cardiff University, Cardiff,
UK
OBJECTIVES: The current variability in European health technology assessment and
decision-making leads to uncertainty about how to measure efficiency and hampers
adoption of new best-practice initiatives, such as the EUnetHTA Joint Action. In
addition, such variability in organization makes comparison of the activities and
outcomes of these systems problematic. The objective of this study was to develop a
systematic process-mapping methodology to both clarify how these systems were
organised and to enable comparison between the systems. METHODS: The process
maps were designed from the point of view of the path that a new medicine takes
from market authorization to market access. Key decision and evaluation gateways
A409
occurring within the process and key activities, such as provision of scientific advice,
were overlaid onto the process maps to further illuminate and contrast the different
systems. RESULTS: The systems of eleven countries were mapped and common
processes identified. Considerable differences in the systems were detected, including
the extent of independence of appraisal, pricing and decision making bodies. However,
despite differences in organization and sequence, the general path that a new medicine
undertakes from registration to reimbursement was broadly similar. CONCLUSIONS:
The process maps are a useful tool for the comparative visualization of the process of
registration to reimbursement for new medicines. This methodology enables the identification of milestones that can be used to establish a benchmarking programme for
the purpose of comparative performance evaluation between different countries. It is
envisaged that benchmarking of HTA and decision-making agencies will lead to both
process improvement and increased understanding of the costs and benefits of making
changes in the systems under evaluation—as has been the case for our previous activities benchmarking the drug regulatory authorities.
PHP27
COMPARISON OF THE USE OF PRESCRIBED MEDICATIONS BETWEEN
QUEBEC RESIDENTS COVERED BY PUBLIC AND PRIVATE DRUG
INSURANCE: THE REMED REGISTRY
Blais L1, Cyr MC1, Perreault S1, Moisan J2, Bérard A1, Lalonde L1, Rahme E3
1
Université de Montréal, Montréal, QC, Canada; 2Laval University, Québec, QC, Canada;
3
McGill University Health Centre, Montreal, QC, Canada
OBJECTIVES: To describe the use of medications among Quebec (Canada) residents
covered by private drug insurance and to compare with Quebec residents covered by
the public drug insurance plan. METHODS: Persons aged less than 65 years with
private drug insurance were recruited in community pharmacies and medical clinics
between 2007 and 2010 and were included in a computerized registry called reMed.
Patient’s identification, private drug plan information and socio-demographic variables were gathered at recruitment. Data related to prescriptions dispensed in community pharmacies are transferred to reMed bi-monthly from the community
pharmacies’ computer services providers. We compared the 10 most prevalent medication classes dispensed (using the AHFS classification) and the average drug cost
between reMed participants and Quebec residents covered by the public drug insurance plan. RESULTS: In 2008, 2 211 reMed participants filled at least one prescription
in a community pharmacy. Participants were 43 years old on average, 31% were male,
19% were current smokers and 46% were overweight or obese. In 2008, analgesics/
antipyretics, psychotherapeutic agents and antilipemic agents were the three most
dispensed classes of medications among reMed participants and Quebec residents with
public drug insurance. Despite that 8 of the 10 most prevalent classes of medications
were in common between patients with public and private drug insurance, the average
cost of medications was 22% lower among patients with public drug insurance
($37.92 versus $46.42 per prescription). CONCLUSIONS: Patients with private and
public drug insurance were found to have a similar distribution of medications dispensed in community pharmacies. However, we found that patients covered by the
public drug insurance plan paid on average their medications 22% less than patients
covered by a private drug insurance plan.
PHP28
THE COLLECTION AND USE OF “REAL WORLD” DATA: INDUSTRY
VIEWS
Devlin N1, Peperell K2, Gillen D3, Radway-Bright EL4
1
Office of Health Economics, London, UK; 2pH Associates, Marlow, UK; 3Pfizer, Surrey, UK;
4
Association of the British Pharmaceutical Industry, London, UK
OBJECTIVES: ‘Real world’ data can improve understanding of the cost-effectiveness
of health care technologies and are likely to become increasingly important in decisions
affecting patient access and in drug development. However little is known about the
investment industry currently makes in these studies, or their impact on HTA. The
aim of this study was to examine industry views on the relevance and impact of ‘real
world’ data on HTA and on the relative advantages and disadvantages of conducting
these studies in the UK. METHODS: Survey of British pharmaceutical companies.
RESULTS: Responses were received from 31 British pharmaceutical companies, covering most of the larger companies in terms of market share. Three quarters of these
reported they were engaged in collecting real life data of some kind in the UK. Data
collection efforts were more common for health service costs, resource use and treatment pathways; clinical outcomes; burden of disease; and patient outcomes data. The
collection of data on patients’ ability to work; patient costs; and impacts on patients’
caregivers/family was less common. The availability of local expertise on HTA was a
leading factor in choosing to undertake such studies in the UK; other important factors
were the perceived importance of local data to NICE; and the influence of NICE on
HTA decisions in other markets, particularly elsewhere in Europe. The main barrier
to conducting studies in the UK was cost and perceived difficulty in obtaining ethics
consent and NHS approval. Views on whether ‘real world’ evidence influenced NICE
decisions were somewhat equivocal. However, participants felt that real world data
were likely to be more important in providing evidence on health outcomes in chronic
conditions, to track outcomes over longer time periods than is feasible in clinical trials,
and for cancer and ‘orphan’ medicines. CONCLUSIONS: While industry recognises
the value of ‘real world’ evidence, there are barriers to conducting such studies in the
UK.
A410
PHP29
THE EFFECTS OF NICE APPRAISALS ON PRESCRIBING AND COSTSHARING BEHAVIOR IN THE US
Sepulveda B, Doyle J
Quintiles Consulting, Hawthorne, NY, USA
OBJECTIVES: As US health care increasingly looks towards proven clinical effectiveness for reimbursement decisions, we hypothesized that HTAs published by NICE
would influence drug prescribing and patient cost-sharing expenditures in the US
according to the nature of the published guidance. The primary objective was to
determine whether trends in prescription volume (TRx) and the proportion of drug
costs paid out-of-pocket (%OPC) of 10 drugs appraised by 7 HTAs since 2007.
METHODS: Seven NICE HTAs since 2007, evaluating a total of 10 drugs, were
analyzed. Six drugs were freely encouraged for utilization (lenalidomide, entecavir,
tenofovir, donezepil, galantamine, rivastigmine), two were approved for restricted
populations (cinacalcet, naltrexone) and the use of two of the drugs was restricted for
all populations (telbivudine, memantine). TRx, and OPC as a percent of average retail
price were collected quarterly for the same duration pre- and post-HTA until April
2010 using SDI’s VONA and VOPA databases. Statistical analyses were performed
using one-way ANOVA; statistically significant results had P < 0.05. RESULTS:
Comparing the periods before and after HTA publication, three drugs with positive
guidance showed significant increases in prescription volume (P < 0.05). However,
two drugs with advised use for restricted populations, and one with a negative guidance also showed significant increases. Interestingly, two drugs with positive guidance
showed significant decreases in TRx. Only entecavir showed a significant decrease in
%OPC, while all others failed to show a significant difference. CONCLUSIONS:
NICE HTAs decisions appear to be associated with mixed effects on prescription
utilization and expenditures in the United States. Though prescribing behavior was
changed in the periods analyzed, further research is warranted to determine the true
nature of that change. With increased cost-sharing in the health care environment in
the US, it will be interesting to monitor the forces that might precipitate changes in
OPC, whether related to HTA publications or not.
PHP30
VANCOMYCIN UTILIZATION EVALUATION IN A TEACHING HOSPITAL
BETWEEN FEBRUARY 2007 AND MAY 2008 IN IRAN
Soleymani F
Tehran University of Medical Science, Tehran, Iran
OBJECTIVES: Increasing antimicrobial resistance is now a major problem in the
world. Especially wide spectrum antibiotics resistance germs like vancomycin-resistant
enterococci (VRE) should be dealt as soon as possible as an emergency conflict. Our
study tries to reveal the amount of inappropriate use of vancomycin in a teaching
hospital. METHODS: The study was conducted in a university hospital between
February 2007 and May 2008. The hospital has 15 specialty and 5 subspecialty wards.
a comprehensive questionnaire was designed. We random selected inpatients who
received vancomycin. RESULTS: Forty four out of 45 patients had inappropriate
indication and dose of vancomycin (97.7%). The most usage of vancomycin was
recorded in hematology—oncology ward (71.11%) and then Intensive Care Unit
(8.16%). Leukemia’s including Acute Myelogenous Leukemia (AML) and Acute Lymphoblastic Leukemia (ALL) were the most common reason of admission among
patients. Cultures were negative (8.88%) despite great clinical evidence of infection.
CONCLUSIONS: Vancomycin inappropriate use was high compared to other countries and it could be concerned as an area for implement educational and regulatory
strategies by health policy makers to deal. However more detailed researches are
needed to reveal the other aspects of this problem. Implementation of antibiotic
protocols and standard treatment guidelines are recommended.
PHP31
THE COMMERCIAL EFFECTS OF REFORMULATIONS OF EXISTING
DRUGS
Sepulveda B, Vincent L, White C
Quintiles, Hawthorne, NY, USA
OBJECTIVES: Given the high cost of creating a complete NME, it is not surprising
that sixty percent of NDAs submitted to the FDA during the 1990s were for drugs
based on an existing molecule (FDA, 2004). These products generally use three strategies for life cycle management (LCM): chemical reformulation, new drug combinations, or delivery reformulation, often resulting in an enhanced efficacy, safety, and
compliance profile due to improved potency, tolerability, and duration of action. The
objective of this study is to investigate the commercial effect of these LCM strategies.
METHODS: Retail sales and prescription volume (TRx) of well-known reformulations (venlafaxine to desvenlafaxine, citalopram to escitalopram, trazodone extendedrelease, and paroxetine controlled-release) and reformulated combinations (esomeprazole/naproxen and fluticasone/salmeterol) were analyzed. Annual sales and TRx data
were obtained since 2002 using SDI VONA. RESULTS: Interestingly, the two branded
combination products analyzed had significant increases in TRx and in sales (P < 0.05)
annually after the patent expiration of their original components, which showed
significant annual decreases in sales and TRx (P < 0.05). The four reformulated
products showed smaller changes than the combination products sales and TRx
increases in the new branded products. Similarly, the utilization and sales decreases
of the original components were smaller in the reformulated products than in the
combinations. CONCLUSIONS: Given the higher cost of branded drugs, their unfavorable tier placement by payers with respect to their generic counterparts and the
increased pressure to reduce drug spending, it may not be surprising that reformulated
13th Euro Abstracts
generic products still enjoy sustained utilization. However, the premium for combination products that may increase patient adherence has not deterred utilization according to the present findings.
PHP32
EFFECTIVENESS OF ANTIBACTERIAL THERAPY OPTIMIZATION BY
CLINICAL PHARMACOLOGISTS
Eliseeva E1, Lozinskaya L2, Solodovnikov V3, Gainullina Y3
1
Vladivostok State Medical University, Vladivostok, Russia; 2City Hospital #2, Vladivostok,
Russia; 3Territory Fund of Compulsory Medical Insurance, Vladivostok, Russia
OBJECTIVES: antimicrobials are vital medicines, although their excessive use leads
to resistance. Impact of clinical pharmacologists on the rational use of antibiotics is
worth scientific interest. The aim of the research: to analyze the dependence of the
antibiotic therapy rationality on clinical pharmacologist’s administrative authority.
METHODS: Segment of Territory Fund of Compulsory Medical Insurance database
was analyzed including 51,128 informational units. Primarily we analyzed indications
for separate antibiotis administration. Then rationality of antibiotic therapy according
to nosologic classification was analyzed: pneumonia, chronic obstructive lung disease,
acute cystitis, chronic pyelonephritis. The next step was a randomized analysis of
antibacterial therapy rationality in three polyclinic groups. A clinical pharmacologist
participated in antibiotic administrations in the 1st group of polyclinics. There was
no clinical pharmacologist in the 2nd group. Clinical pharmacologist with administrative authority controlled antimicrobials administration in the 3rd group. RESULTS:
Low rationality of inhibitor-protected aminopenicillins, ciprofloxacin, cefazolin use
(64.82%, 23.39% and 1.77%) was revealed. At the same time inhibitor-protected
penicillin’s administration frequency has increased in 1.5 times, and amoxicillin
administration frequency has decreased in 5 times. It was found that the difference
had been reliable only in the analysis of 2 groups: the first group of polyclinics (without
clinical pharmacologist) and the 3rd group (participation of authorized clinical pharmacologist) (P = 0.046). The least rational antibiotic’s administration was noted in
patients with erysipelas (54.5%) and most rational antibacterial therapy was given to
patients with acute cystitis (94.1%). Difference in physician’s preferences is reliable
(P = 0.037) only comparing the 1st and the 3rd groups of policlinics. CONCLUSIONS: The highest rate of the rational antibacterial therapy was registered in polyclinics and nosologies if clinical pharmacologist with administrative authorities had
participated in antibiotic therapy. Our research makes it possible to substantiate
additional administrative authorities for a clinical pharmacologist. Authorized clinical
pharmacologists will promote to enhance rationality of antibacterial therapy.
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Equity and Access
PHP33
RATIONING IN PRACTICE- EQUITY IN WAITING TIMES FOR ELECTIVE
SURGERY IN SWEDEN
Tinghög G, Andersson D
Linköping University, Linköping, Östergötland, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: Health care can be rationed by various mechanisms. In publicly funded
health care systems referring patients to waiting lists is a common administrative way
to ration care. However, there is little systematic knowledge on how rationing through
waiting time actually affects access to care among different socioeconomic groups.
And since rationing through waiting lists most often is done implicitly rather than
explicitly there is an obvious risk that less powerful groups of patients get discriminated, resulting in a longer waiting time before being treated. The overall objective of
this study was to explore the association between patients’ socioeconomic status,
ethnical background and waiting time within non-acute surgical specialities.
METHODS: Days on waiting list was used as dependant variable in a multiple regression model. This data was collected from the county council of Östergötland in
Sweden (N = 4634). Data on disposable income, ethnicity and workforce activity were
retrieved from national registers. RESULTS: Examining disposable income as a potential predictor, we found that lower disposable income was significantly associated with
longer waiting time in orthopedics (P = 0.05) and general surgery (P = 0.05). In
orthopedics, the lowest income group waited on average 28% longer than the highest
income group. Examining ethnicity as a potential predictor, the only significant association found was in gynecology where patients with foreign origin surprisingly waited
on average 40% shorter than patients with Swedish origin. For workforce activity,
we found that patients excluded from the workforce were significantly associated with
longer wait in ophthalmology. CONCLUSIONS: Our results reveal horizontal
inequalities in access within several non-acute surgical specialties. However, the mere
association between socioeconomic factors and inequalities in waiting times cannot
alone support judgements about inequity. Hence, there is both a descriptive and
normative question that needs to be assessed when investigating the reasonableness
of rationing by waiting time.
PHP34
PATIENT ACCESS TO INNOVATIVE MEDICINES IN HUNGARY
1
1
1
2
Botlik O , Kalotai Z , Dessewffy Z , Kalo Z
1
Novartis Hungary, Budapest, Hungary; 2Eötvös Loránd University, Budapest, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: Patient access to innovative medicines has critical importance from the
societal perspective, pharmaceutical innovation contributes to increase in health
capital. Delay in the pricing and reimbursement process limits the access of patients
13th Euro Abstracts
to new medicines. Our goal was to determine the time period between the registration
and reimbursement date in Hungary. METHODS: We selected all newly reimbursed
pharmacy drugs between January 2004 and April 2010 and looked for the date of
registration and reimbursement in public websites and Bulletins of EMEA/EMA,
National Institute of Pharmacy and National Health Insurance Fund. We excluded
hospital only medicines and drugs with special reimbursement budget from the analysis due to the lack of transparency of reimbursement dates in publicly available data
sources. RESULTS: 106 newly reimbursed innovative medicines between January
2004–April 2010 were included into the analysis. The average time period between
registration and reimbursement was 677 days. CONCLUSIONS: Hungary joined the
European Union in May 2004 and implemented the EU Transparency Directive. Time
to reimbursement of innovative medicines in Hungary is significantly longer than the
recommended 90 + 90 days for pricing and reimbursement process set by Transparency Directive. The pricing and reimbursement process in Hungary takes more time
than in 15 European countries included in the EFPIA Patients W.A.I.T. indicator
database (from 101 to 403 days). Acceleration of patient access to innovative medicines is highly recommended in Hungary.
PHP35
THE IMPACT OF THE HOSPITAL FUNDING SYSTEM ON THE RANGE
OF THE EXPENSIVE DRUGS AVAILABLE IN FRENCH AND ENGLISH
HOSPITALS
Gridchyna I, Aulois-Griot M, Maurain C, Bégaud B
Université Victor Segalen Bordeaux 2, Bordeaux, France
OBJECTIVES: In French and English hospitals, there are a lists of drugs financed out
of scope of casemix-based payment system that are Payment by Result (PbR) and
“Tarification à l’activité” (T2A). We examined a difference in the range of these drugs
in both countries. METHODS: In the study were included the drugs registered on the
list “en sus” in French system, the drugs from the high cost drugs list (HCD) and from
the oncology regimens list in English system. The information is available in official
sources. The number and overlap of entities excluded from the casemix-based payment
system in two countries were determined, as well as similarity rate. RESULTS: 210
entities are financed out of scope of casemix-based payment system in England and
101 in France. 69% (145/210) of entities excluded from PbR are not on the list “en
sus”. Around 36% (36/101) of entities excluded from T2A are not on the English
lists. There are 65 entities common for both lists; 51% (33/65) are from ATC class L
(antineoplastic and immunomodulating agents). Four ATC classes have none common
drugs. The aim of the list in two systems is fair reimbursement of the expensive drugs
within the casemix-based payment system. In French system this list is used also to
improve the access to the expensive and innovative drugs. So, 50% (73/145) of the
entities excluded from PbR and not included on the list “en sus” are on another list
in French system, the retrocession list. CONCLUSIONS: There is a difference in the
range of drugs financed out of scope of casemix-based payment system in French and
English hospitals. More drugs are excluded from the casemix-based payment system
in England, but it does not facilitate access to new drugs.
PHP36
THE AVAILABILITY AND FUNDING OF ORPHAN DRUGS IN BOSNIA
AND HERZEGOVINA IN COMPARISON WITH NEIGHBORING
COUNTRIES
Catic T, Bajramovic A
Society for Pharmacoeconomics and Outcomes Research in Bosnia and Herzegovina,
Sarajevo, Bosnia
OBJECTIVES: The aim was to examine the current availability and funding of orphan
drugs in both entities of B&H and compare the obtained data with neighboring
countries (Croatia, Serbia and Montenegro) and the EU. METHODS: We have analyzed the current published list of medicines in B&H and neighboring countries. We
have compared the drugs that have the status of orphans according to the Orphanet
report. RESULTS: In BiH there are no lists of orphan drugs while some of them are
included in the list of chemotherapeutic agents and drugs for specific diseases (RS).
Only Croatia has made a special list of expensive medicines containing drugs for
treatment of hereditary enzyme deficiency. All countries have imatinib reimbursed.
Only in the RS and Serbia thalidomide is reimbursed, and Serbia has listed sildenafil,
zinc acetate and busulfan. Present practice in all countries is that patients apply
individualy for orphan drugs reimbursement approval to HIFs. CONCLUSIONS: In
order to improve access to orphan drugs it is necessary to adopt a national policy
which will be harmonized with the EU. Decisions on the reimbursement must be based
on real possibilities and it is necessary to implement appropriate registries for future
resource allocation decissions.
PHP37
THE IMPACT OF UNIVERSAL COVERAGE ON EQUITY IN HEALTH CARE
FINANCE AND FINANCIAL RISK PROTECTION IN THAILAND
Prakongsai P
International Health Policy Program (IHPP), Nonthaburi Province, Thailand
OBJECTIVES: To assess the impact of achieving universal coverage (UC) on equity
in health care finance and on financial risk protection from expensive medical care
costs for Thai households. METHODS: Secondary data analyses using nationally
representative household surveys conducted by National Statistical Office, the Socioeconomic Survey 2000 (prior to UC) and 2002–2006 (after UC) to analyze changes
in progressivity of overall health care finance and different health financing sources.
A411
The share of households facing catastrophic health expenditure in the poorest and
richest income quintiles prior to and after achieving UC was also assessed. RESULTS:
The financing of the Thai health care system became more equitable after the UC
policy was implemented. Improved financial risk protection after achieving UC was
observed due to the comprehensive benefit package and literally free at point of services. The Kakwani index value for overall health care finance changed from −0.0038
(regressive) in 2000 to positive (progressive) values of 0.0014, 0.0342 and 0.0406 in
2002, 2004 and 2006, respectively. The share of households facing catastrophic
spending on health decreased from 5.4% in 2000 to 2.0% in 2006. The 1st (poorest)
quintile experienced a 77.5% reduction in the proportion of households facing catastrophic health expenditure, while there was a 41% reduction in the share of households in the 5th (richest) quintile. CONCLUSIONS: Factors contributing to equitable
health finance are: the increasing share of progressive financing sources in particular
direct tax; the decreasing share of the regressive out-of-pocket payments for health.
Using general taxation to finance the poor and the informal sector not only helps reach
universal coverage, it is also the most progressive financing source. Various factors
contribute to the low incidence of catastrophic heath expenditure: comprehensive
benefit package covering almost all health services which are free at point of use, and
well-functioning primary care providers.
PHP38
HOW EQUITABLE OF HEALTH SERVICE USE AND GOVERNMENT
SUBSIDIES IN THAILAND AFTER ACHIEVING UNIVERSAL COVERAGE?
Prakongsai P
International Health Policy Program (IHPP), Nonthaburi Province, Thailand
OBJECTIVES: To assess trends of equity in health service use and distribution of
government subsidies to ambulatory services and hospitalization across income gradients of the Thai population prior to and after implementation of the universal coverage (UC) policy in 2002 and explained how such equity has been achieved. METHODS:
Secondary data analyses using nationally representative household surveys conducted
by National Statistical Office, the Health and Welfare Survey (HWS) 2001 (prior to
UC) and 2003–2007 (after UC) to analyze equity in health service use at different
health care levels and the distribution of government subsidies for health. The analytical approach employed a standard method for health equity analysis of the large scale
household surveys proposed by O’Donnell et al. RESULTS: Outpatient and inpatient
service use of the Thai health systems were both pro-poor before achieving UC in
2002 due to various government interventions in extending health insurance coverage
and countrywide distribution of health service infrastructure, and the significant
increase in human resource production. After the UC policy implementation, the propoor service utilization was further progressed. Overall, public subsidies for health
were found to be pro-poor for both outpatient and inpatient services with the concentration indexes of −0.226, −0.186 and −0.180, in 2003, 2006 and 2007, respectively. District health provider networks, in particular health centres, district and
provincial hospitals are the major determinants of the pro-poor distribution of service
utilization and public subsidies, due to their geographical proximity and better access
by the poor. A comprehensive benefit package and the provision of services that are
free at the point of use resulted in the pro-poor benefit incidence. CONCLUSIONS:
The pro-poor outcome is the result of an availability of functional primary care at the
district level, and implementation of the UC policy which focuses on contracting
primary care networks at the district level.
PHP39
A COMPARISON OF GENERIC AND ORIGINATOR BRAND DRUG PRICES
BETWEEN JORDAN AND THE UNITED KINGDOM
El-Dahiyat F1, Kayyali R1, Alabbadi I2
1
Kingston University, London, UK; 2University of Jordan, Amman, Jordan
OBJECTIVES: The study aimed to compare the retail prices of generics and originator
brand for five drugs between Jordan and United Kingdom and to investigate the relation between number of generics available, retail price of originator and generic (s)
and the effect of time in the market on these prices. METHODS: Prices of originators
and generics and the number of generics available in each market were obtained from
the Jordanian Food and Drug Administration, Royal Pharmaceutical Society of Great
Britain, British National Formulary and Chemist & Druggist generics list. The prices
were converted to British Pounds expressed per one dose unit. All data was tabulated
in spreadsheets; prices were compared between the two countries at different preset
times. RESULTS: The generics of all drugs investigated appeared in the Jordanian
market before patent expiry of their originator worldwide due to lack of patency regulations in Jordan at the launch time of drugs under investigation (before 2004). Unlike
the UK, the prices of originator drugs in Jordan did not change when the first generic
was introduced to the market. The price of generic drugs have dropped dramatically
in the UK at time of first generic launch approximately by 90% compared to 15% in
Jordan. There was no apparent correlation between the numbers of generics available
or the number of years of first generic being in the market and the prices of the drugs
investigated in both countries. The current prices of all investigated drugs in Jordan
are higher than the UK particularly for the generics. CONCLUSIONS: Although much
lower income per capita in Jordan, generic drugs are more expensive than the equivalent prices of same drugs in the UK
A412
PHP40
REIMBURSEMENT RECOMMENDATION PROCESS IN BRAZIL: CITEC
SUBMISSIONS PROFILE
Araújo GTBD, Fonseca M
AxiaBio, São Paulo, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: To access and understand the main characteristics of the Reimbursement submission process and HTA recommendations in Brazil. METHODS: This is
a crossed analysis of secondary data displayed by the Brazilian new technology incorporation committee (CITEC) regarding the quantity and characteristics (disease, submitter, type of health technology, and year of submission) of the submitted protocols
versus quantity and characteristics of the recommended health technologies. RESULTS:
In 3 years of existence, 216 Health technologies (mean of 48 submissions per year) were
appraised by the commission resulting in 22 positive recommendations and XX Negative
recommendations. For the reconvened Health technologies, the median time from submission and recommendation was 1 year. Oncology and Rheumatology are the main
submissions groups by disease (12% and 11%, respectively) and Hepatology and
Rheumatology are the most recommended groups by disease (18% and 14% respectively). Manufacturers are the main submitters (74%), followed by the own federal
government. 5% of the submissions was made by mixed submitters that can be chacterized by research partnerships between manufacturers, academia and government.
CONCLUSIONS: This finds suggests that the conduction of HTA recommendation
and adoption process is already a reality in Brazil and the decisions are based not
anymore only in political issues but are strongly based on clinical and economical
issues too. As a new process in the country, modifications as time to response and
establishment of a Brazilian ICER during the next years can improve the results for
CITEC and submitters.
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Formulary Development
PHP42
CURRENT AND FUTURE USE OF PHARMACOECONOMIC AND
OUTCOMES RESEARCH DATA IN DECISION-MAKING IN THE USA
Holtorf AP1, Keskinaslan A2, Biskupiak J3, Brixner D4
1
Health Outcomes Strategies GmbH, Basel, Switzerland; 2Novartis Pharma AG, Basel,
Switzerland; 3University of Utah College of Pharmacy, Salt Lake City, UT, USA; 4University of
Utah, Salt Lake City, UT, USA
OBJECTIVES: To understand how PEOR data are used in decision making today and
how this may change in future. The methodology and quantity of Pharmacoeconomics
and Outcomes Research (PEOR) has advanced considerably over the last decade. With
increasing utilization of health care, prioritization becomes unavoidable and PEOR
evidence should be increasingly valuable to supplement efficacy and safety data for
reimbursement and access decisions. METHODS: An internet based survey with 30
items was conducted among decision makers from the USA in April 2010. RESULTS:
The 76 respondents represented organizations with national (54%), regional (32%) or
local coverage (14%). Membership varied from 50,000 to 100million with a median of
500,000. While 70% of the respondents claimed that PEOR data are used regularly,
only 5% indicated coverage by the bylaws of their organizations, and 66% of the users
indicated that there is no quality standard for PEOR being used by the organization.
The majority of the respondents expected increasing use of PEOR in the future (77%).
Organizational requirements to such adoption included ‘more HEOR expertise’, better
definitions and standards of methods, in-house data analysis expertise, and regular reevaluation. Outcomes based evidence is increasingly used in contracting (37%) and 73%
expected an increased use in future with the perceived value of reduced financial and
clinical risk. CONCLUSIONS: PEOR is used often in decision making in the USA.
However, few organizations defined quality criteria for PEOR. There is a consistent
expectation that there will be an increasing use of this data, along with a concern
regarding a lack of expertise to evaluate this information in their organizations.
Improved standards for quality control of such evidence are needed. Another survey will
be targeted to the systems and decision makers in selected European countries to
compare the utilization of PEOR in the different decision making environments.
PHP43
ASSESSING THE ADDED VALUE OF NEW DRUGS: A
MULTIDIMENSIONAL APPROACH
Paladio N, Sunyer B, Almazan C, Solà-Morales O
Catalan Agency for Health Technology and Research, Barcelona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: In November 2008, the Program for the Assessment, Monitoring and
Reimbursement of High Complexity Drugs (PASFTAC) took effect in Catalonia and
the Committee for the Assessment of Hospital Use Drugs (CAMUH) was consequently
appointed to give recommendations on medicines use. Our aim is to develop a tool
that embraces the multidimensional aspects of added value in drug assessment.
METHODS: A qualitative approach (adapted expert panel) has been used. Participants included decision makers, health economists, experts on bioethics, clinicians and
pharmacists. A previous detailed review of literature was conducted for the topic under
discussion. RESULTS: Several dimensions and items were identified and discussed in
a single meeting. Main identified dimensions included efficacy, safety and cost-effectiveness as well as clinical relevance of outcomes, unmet therapeutic needs, ethics, and
cost-oportunity. Individual interviews were further conducted. Discussion and rating
of dimensions and items within these will be performed in a second meeting. A pilot
test will be conducted after a minimum of 10 drugs are assessed by the CAMUH
(expected by September 2010). CONCLUSIONS: In a context of limited evidence
13th Euro Abstracts
dimensions other than classical efficacy, safety and cost-effectiveness need to be considered at the time of assessing added value. This new tool will contribute to that task
and standardize the process at a local level.
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Health Care Costs &
Management
PHP44
APPLICATION OF PERATO’S PRINCIPLE TO UNDERSTAND COST
DRIVERS IN HEALTH CARE
Long S1, Misra A2
1
Thomson Reuters, Cambridge, MA, USA; 2Thomson Reuters, Washington, DC, USA
OBJECTIVES: To determine if Pareto’s principle (also known as the 80–20 rule) applies
to health care expenditures in the US, and to describe the patients and treatments
considered to be “cost drivers.” METHODS: The study population consisted of persons
<65 years that were continuously enrolled in the Thomson Reuters MarketScan Commercial Database during the years 2004–2008. Individuals were rank ordered highest
to lowest according to their 2008 health care expenditures and assigned to the Cost
Driver (CD) Cohort if their costs were within the 80% cumulative sum of the overall
total expenditures. Clinical and cost characteristics were compared between 2004 and
2008 using Compound Annual Growth Rates (CAGR). RESULTS: 2008 total expenditures were $27.5M among 4.2M covered lives; the CD cohort represented 27% of the
overall study population. Mean annual expenditures in the CD Cohort were $15,581
(16.1% CAGR). Outpatient services, inpatient services, and outpatient pharmaceutical
prescriptions represented 42%, 29% and 28% of total expenditures in 2008. From 2004
to 2008, pharmaceutical expenditures grew 23% CAGR, while outpatient and inpatient
expenditure growth was 15% and 13% respectively. Drivers of medical service expenditures in the CD group were visits related to osteoarthritis, renal failure, vaginal deliveries, bone and joint disorders, and low back pain. Drivers of outpatient pharmaceutical
expenditures in the CD group were antihyperlipidemics, gastrointestinal drugs, antidepressants, antidiabetic agents, and anticonvulsants. CONCLUSIONS: In a large US
database of commercially insured persons, 27% of individuals were accountable for
80% of health care costs incurred during the year 2008. Payers should consider targeted
interventions for their cost driver populations; for example, intense targeted programs
aimed at reducing obesity could yield large cost offsets since much of the incurred costs
were for treatment of conditions that are sequelae of obesity.
PHP45
COSTS OF CARE UNDER A HEALTH CARE PLAN IN THE LAST 5 YEARS
OF LIFE OF BENEFICIARIES—DATA FROM THE REAL WORLD
Reis Neto J, Stefani S
CAPESESP/CAPESAUDE, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: To examine, in the ‘real-world’ scenario of a Brazilian health care plan,
the effect of proximity to death in beneficiaries on health expenditure during the last
5 years of life. METHODS: Retrospective analysis from data stored on the computerised system of the health care plan of 1897 beneficiaries who died between January
2007 and June 2009. The outpatient and hospital health services in the year of death
and in the 4 preceding years were examined. The analysis was restricted to total direct
costs with medical-hospital care. The variables (demographic, clinical and costs) were
subjected to statistical treatment considering a confidence interval of 95%. RESULTS:
Out of a total of 1897 deaths analyzed, the majority were male (60.4%) and were
aged 60 or over (77.0%). The overall mean age of the deceased was 70.6 years (CI95%
69.9–71.4). The cost over the 60 months of the study was US$64,427,852. This total,
66.8% was reimbursed in the year of death and the clinical admissions corresponded
to 89.2% of the total. Among the main causes of death, neoplasia and chronic diseases
had a heavier influence on expenditure. CONCLUSIONS: The rise in spending on
health appears to be directly associated with the effect of increased age together with
a second factor considered to be important, the proximity to death. It is estimated
that in 2050 Brazil will have a population of 64 million individuals aged 60 or over,
representing one of the main challenges to the adequate allocation of resources. This
study suggests that the costs in the last year of life should be considered in the projections for spending on health care, in the same way as the ageing factor. One of the
alternatives that appears to be important at the end of life is palliative care.
PHP46
COSTS OF TREATING TERMINAL PATIENTS IN DIFFERENT BELGIAN
HEALTH CARE SETTINGS
Simoens S1, Kutten B2, Menten J2
1
K.U. Leuven, Leuven, Belgium; 2University Hospitals Leuven, Leuven, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: This study aims to measure the costs of treating terminal patients in
Belgian hospitals and in nursing homes from the health care payer perspective. Also,
this study compares the costs of palliative care with those of usual care. METHODS:
A multi-centre, retrospective cohort study enrolled patients in acute wards and in
palliative care units from a representative sample of hospitals and from a representative sample of nursing homes. Health care costs included fixed costs and charges
relating to medical fees, pharmacy and other charges. Data sources consisted of
hospital and nursing home accountancy data and patient invoice data. The price year
was 2007/2008. RESULTS: Six hospitals and nineteen nursing homes participated in
the study, generating a total of 327 patients. Mean hospital costs per patient per day
amounted to c391 (± c156). Mean hospital costs of patients receiving usual care in
an acute ward (c340 ± 143) exceeded costs of palliative care in an acute ward (c283
13th Euro Abstracts
± 109) (P = 0.025). Mean nursing home costs amounted to c3243 (±2700) per patient
during the final month of life. Mean nursing home costs per patient of c3822 (±3232)
for patients receiving usual care were higher than costs of c2456 (±2117) for patients
receiving palliative care (P = 0.068). CONCLUSIONS: This study suggests that palliative care models in acute hospital wards and in nursing homes need to be supported
because such care models appear to be less expensive than usual care and because
such care models are likely to better reflect the needs of terminal patients.
PHP47
EFFICIENCY IN DRUG PRESCRIPTION MEASURED BY THE
APPLICATION OF ADJUSTED CLINICAL GROUPS IN THIRTEEN
SPANISH PRIMARY CARE CENTRES
Sicras-Mainar A1, Velasco-Velasco S2, Llopart-López JR2, Navarro-Artieda R3,
Blanca-Tamayo M2
1
Directorate of Planning, Badalona Serveis Assistencials, Badalona, Barcelona, Spain;
2
Badalona Serveis Assistencials SA, Barcelona, Spain; 3Hospital Universitari Germans Trias i
Pujol, Barcelona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: To measure the efficiency of pharmacy resources utilization in 13
Primary Care centres by the retrospective application of Adjusted Clinical Groups (ACG)
in a usual clinical practice setting. METHODS: Retrospective study carried out on the
basis of the clinical records from all the attended patients along the year 2008. Main
variables: age, sex, case-mix/episodes, visits, pharmacy costs, 13 centres, physician and
service (Family Medicine or Paediatrics). ACG grouper (Starfield and Weiner, Johns
Hopkins University, n = 106) classifies each patient in a unique category of similar
resource consumption. A Receiver Operating Characteristics (ROC-area under the
curve) analysis was done to assess the predictive value of the model. The Efficiency Index
(EI) was obtained as the quotient between the observed and the expected pharmacy
costs according to ACG distribution (indirect standardization). The statistical package
SPSS was used (P < 0.05). RESULTS: A total of 227,235 patients were included. Average
number of episodes 4.5 ± 3.2 and visits 8.1 ± 8.2; mean age: 44.1 ± 23.7 years; and
55.6% of males. Intensity of utilization: 77.4%. Costs of drug prescription: c70.6 millions (47.6% of the total costs). Mean cost was c310.8 ± 681.2. ROC curve analysis
for episodes: 0.588 (p = 0.001); sensibility: 37.3%, specificity: 73.1% and intra-class
correlation coefficient C: 0.732 (P < 0.001). The EI for each centre was analyzed, P <
0.0001. Furthermore, differences between family physicians and paediatricians were
observed (range: 0.55–1.46), P < 0.001. CONCLUSIONS: Results show a wide variability in the costs of pharmacy within centres and physicians. ACG provide an adjusted
approximation to efficiency in pharmacy costs. Efficiency must not be considered as an
isolated dimension of quality. The determination of the El could lead to a better knowledge of the prescription profile from individual physicians and/or primary care teams.
PHP48
ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF HEALTH CARE INTERVENTIONS DURING
MORE THAN 25 YEARS IN SPAIN (1983–2008)
Catalá-López F1, Garcia-Altés A2
1
Spanish Medicines and Healthcare Products Agency (AEMPS), Madrid, Spain; 2King’s College
London, London, UK
OBJECTIVES: Economic evaluation has been promoted as a tool to guide decisionmaking processes regarding health care resources’ allocation and in the adoption of
health care technologies. We analyzed the evolution and the main characteristics of
economic evaluations of health care interventions done during the period 1983–2008
in Spain. METHODS: Observational descriptive study. We performed a systematic
review in the main bibliographic databases (PubMed/MEDLINE, SCOPUS, ISI Web of
Knowledge, CRD, IME, IBECS) and manually through Internet in journals and public
reports. There were predefined inclusion and exclusion criteria, and a set of variables
to analyze the characteristics of the selected reports. RESULTS: In total, 477 studies
fulfilled inclusion criteria. Some of the studies characteristics were: cost-effectivenes
analysis (62.5%), decision analysis techniques (34.0%), heath care system perspective
(42.1%), therapeutic interventions (70.0%) and non explicit financing (44.0%). The
geographical distribution for Spanish regions of the first authors was: Catalonia
(29.3%), Community of Madrid (23.7%), Andalusia (6.7%) and Region of Valencia
(6.3%). a total of 50.9% of the principal authors were employed at hospital centers.
The most commontly disease conditions were: cardiovascular diseases (15.7%), infectious and parasitic diseases (15.3%) and malignant neoplasms (13.2%). a total of 82.2%
of the reports provided recommendations guide for decision making. CONCLUSIONS:
An increasing number of studies was observed. Identified reports combined heterogeneity in the quality of the information brought with regard to analysis methods, data
sources, type of interventions, or disease conditions. It is suggested to do more efforts
for improving the quantity and quality of reports in public health interventions.
PHP49
INFLUENCE OF THE CHRONIC DISEASE IN HEALTH RESOURCES USE:
ECONOMICS CONSECUENCES AND RISK STRATIFICATION
Sicras-Mainar A1, Navarro-Artieda R2, Baulenas-Parellada D3, Frías-Garrido X3, Perez S3
1
Directorate of Planning, Badalona Serveis Assistencials, Badalona, Barcelona, Spain; 2Hospital
Universitari Germans Trias i Pujol, Barcelona, Spain; 3Directorate of Primary Care. Badalona
Serveis Assistencials SA, Barcelona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: The Chronic disease are ones of high prevalence, duration and slow
progression, its cure could not be predicted clearly or will never be. In general, are
related to lifestyles and population that is older. To determine the direct sanitary cost
depending on chronic comorbidity grade (risk) in patients attended in a primary care
A413
setting (PC). METHODS: Retrospective multicentre design. Patients over 14 years
were included, pertaining at 6 PC teams that demand assistance during year 2008.
Main measures: sociodemographics, risk/casuistic/comorbidity, Charlson index (severity) and direct cost models. The chronic comorbidity was classified beginning from
Adjusted Clinical Groups. It was obtained the Resources Utilization Bands (RUB) per
patient (rank: 1- healthy user to 5- high morbidity). The complexity/comorbidity was
grouped in 10 categories (6 expert forum). Fixed/semi fixed cost were considered
(functioning: salary, services, purchases) and variable (tests, referrals, drugs). Explanation power calculation: determination coefficient (R2). It was made an ANOVA analysis for the correction (age, sex, comorbidity) of the models (procedure: Bonferroni).
SPSSWIN program; P < 0.05. RESULTS: A total of 69,653 patients, age-average: 47.6
± 18.8 years; women: 54.1%; high morbidity: 4.8%; chronic disease: 3.8 ± 2.3 and
total cost: c51.3 million (fixed cost: 12.3%). The 35.4% (n = 24,670; CI: 34.5–36.3%)
showed ≥5 chronic disease. Binary correlations: comorbidity-BUR: 0.716; cost-comorbidity: 0.596; age-comorbidity: 0.429; P < 0,001. Osseo-muscular illness (38.1%),
mental (31.6%) and cardiovascular (30.4%) were the same frequencies, P < 0.001.
The unitary average of the cost corrected was of c736.74 ± c921.97, with comorbidity
ranks between: 1 = 309.62; 5 = 842.99; 10 = c2,354.05, respectively, P < 0.001.
Predictive model (R2): age = 25.7%; age-sex = 26.5%; age-sex-comorbidity = 60.3%,
of the cost. Women showed more comorbidity. CONCLUSIONS: Chronic comorbidity is associated with a sanitary cost increase. The number of comorbidities explains
the major part of the cost. Patient knowledge of risk/complexity enable us doing different strategies of preventive/cure intervention. KEY WORDS: comorbidity, cost,
resource use, risk.
PHP50
FRAGMENTED HEALTH CARE SYSTEM—SOLVING THE JIGSAW PUZZLE
1
1
2
3
3
Miksch F , Urach C , Popper N , Weisser A , Endel G
1
Vienna University of Technology, Vienna, Austria; 2Dwh Simulation Services, Vienna, Austria;
3
Main Association of Austrian Social Security Institutions, Vienna, Austria
OBJECTIVES: Austria’s health insurance system is divided into 13 sickness funds.
Each fund has its own fee structure with individual names and codes for every procedure performed in an outpatient setting. Outpatient setting includes general practitioners, specialists, ambulatories and institutes. Each sickness fund has general
contracts for GPs and specialists while each institute has its own contract. These
contracts partly include procedures that are not comparable with any procedures of
other sickness funds. Some sickness funds pay physicians and institutes different fees
for same procedures. Moreover, the payment depends on the number of procedures
performed by a physician or institute within a certain period of time. In order to
evaluate procedure data, the so called meta-fee-structure, a set of pre-defined, standardized procedures that are mapped by individual fee-structures, was developed.
METHODS: Given data with frequencies and costs of procedures for every sickness
fund we are going to propose methods for examining and compare these data: Comparing the cumulative costs, frequencies, the average rates for procedures and the rates
for different institutes and physicians paid by different sickness funds. All methods
are then applied on real data in the field of radiology. RESULTS: By using this process
with real world data it is possible to show the potential of these methods, lacks in
data quality and the limitations of the meta-fee structure. Furthermore it is possible
to point out proposals where procedure costs should be examined more closely and
maybe health care costs could be reduced. CONCLUSIONS: Due to the heterogeneous
health care system of Austria there is a wide variety of issues to be addressed when
analyzing data. Although the proposed methods are very general they have to be
adapted to the actual problems. Knowledge about data origin is crucial when choosing
methods to get high quality results.
PHP51
ROUTINE REPLACEMENT OF PERIPHERAL INTRAVENOUS CATHETER
VERSUS CLINICALLY INDICATED REPLACEMENT: A COST
COMPARISON STUDY FROM THE PUBLIC PAYER PERSPECTIVE
Tolentino ACM, Takemoto ML, Fernandes RA, Passos RB, Cukier FN
ANOVA—Knowledge Translation, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: IV catheterization is the most common invasive procedure among
hospitalized patients and the widest practiced to prevent complications is routine
replacement of the catheter (RCC) in fixed intervals. a meta-analysis (Webster 2008)
showed no significant differences in terms of efficacy from RCC and replacement only
when clinically indicated (RCI). This study aims to compare costs and consequences
of RCC versus RCI from the public payer perspective. METHODS: Efficacy data was
obtained from Webster 2008 which showed no clinical benefits of RCC over RCI.
Data from the Brazilian Hospital Information System (SIH/DATASUS) from January
1–December 31, 2009 was used to define the annual number of admissions of adult
patients in public hospitals wards, assuming RCC as the current practice (no ICU
patients included). The mean length of stay (LOS) and the mean time to replacement
(TTR) were used to calculate the number of replacements in each scenario. Resource
utilization was estimated through published data and unit costs were obtained from
Brazilian official price lists. RESULTS: A total of 8,985,758 hospitalizations were
identified in the database in 2009 with mean LOS of 5.53 days (132.66 hours).
According to a published randomized clinical trial included in Webster 2008, mean
TTR for RCC and RCI was 66.5 and 90.6 hours, respectively, resulting in average
1.99 and 1.46 replacements per hospitalization in each setting. The estimated cost of
replacement was 2.54BRL (nursing time and medical supplies). For all admissions, the
total cost for RCC and RCI was 45,556,510BRL and 33,438,277BRL. The estimated
A414
savings were 12,118,232BRL/year for the public health care system or 1,348BRL/year
per 1,000 admissions. CONCLUSIONS: RCI has shown similar efficacy when compared to RCC with fewer costs. The cost difference was mild in magnitude but when
extrapolated to a large-scale perspective these results reinforce the need of evidencebased decision making and rational resource allocation.
PHP52
HIGH AND INTENSIVE UTILIZERS IN HEALTH CARE—A STRATEGIC
CHALLENGE FOR MEDICAL SUPPLY IN THE COMPULSORY HEALTH
INSURANCE
Schoenermark MP1, Beindorff N2, Kielhorn H1
1
Hannover Medical School, Hannover, Germany; 2Schönermark.Kielhorn and Collegen,
Hannover, Germany
OBJECTIVES: In Germany, the financing mechanism aggravates the cost issue of so
called high-utilizers. So far, there were no care management concepts as the mostly
multimorbid, complex medical conditions were judged as individual, non-influenceable
cases. We developed a method to reveal issues in treatment and care of this special
insurance population to increase efficiency. METHODS: The most critical challenge for
insurance companies lies in the identification of relevant insured, in order to specifically
target the high effort of control and management. In this project we analyzed the secondary data of the members of a German insurance company in the course of four years.
Based on this we first differentiated high-utilizers from average-utilizers. In the following
we deflected by which means existing care management concepts could be complemented. Based on the longterm data observation we developed a prognostic model to
predict future high-utilizers. RESULTS: High-utilizers were defined as the 5% most
expensive insurance-members, who generated 50% of total spending. We distinguished
high-utilizers who caused the main costs in one specific care sector (pharmaceuticals and
hospital) and patients who caused costs in multiple sectors (transsectoral). In addition,
ultra high-utilizers were considered separately due to their extreme cost provocation.
While it is possible to manage the first two groups by a combination or extension of
existing cost reduction measures and care approaches such as disease management
programs, ultra high-utilizers should be addressed by an individual and specifically
developed case management. CONCLUSIONS: This segment of insured demands a
stringent, integrated approach in order to efficiently employ the available financial
resources. This study aims to explain a practical system for the controlling and management of expenses caused by high-utilizers based on our conclusion that the early identification and the specific management of high-utilizers in health care holds high financial
potential and targeted programs are promising for care optimization.
PHP53
COST ANALYSIS OF ANKARA UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF MEDICINE
HOSPITALS
Esatoglu AE1, Agirbas I1, Doganay P1, Goktas B1, Akbulut Y1, Ozatkan Y2, Toruner M2,
Gok H2, Atasoy KC2, Ugurluoglu E1, Cakir SU2, Okten I2
1
Ankara University Faculty of Health Sciences, Ankara, Turkey; 2Ankara University Faculty of
Medicine, Ankara, Turkey
OBJECTIVES: The purpose of this study was to determine the unit cost of the main
production centers of Ankara University Faculty of Medicine Hospitals in 2008.
METHODS: Expenses and costs of the two hospitals of Ankara University (Ibni Sina
and Cebeci Hospitals) were obtained from the Hospital Information System and
Revolving Fund distributed to the main production centers by using a step-down
allocation method with five allocation steps. Unit costs were calculated in the last step.
To determine the cost for outpatient and inpatient units, the data from the fifth allocation including the number of outpatients and inpatients as well as the number of
inpatient days was used. RESULTS: The total cost of Ibni Sina Hospital (a 931-bed
facility) and Cebeci Hospital (a 1153-bed facility) were calculated as c55,137,708.41
and c49,709,800.84 respectively. In Ibni Sina Hospital, among outpatient units, Dept.
of Hematology had the highest, while the Aphaeresis Unit had the lowest cost. As to
the inpatient unit costs, Dept. of Internal Diseases had the highest, and Dept. of Ear,
Nose and Throat had the lowest cost. In Cebeci Hospital, Dept. of Algology had the
highest outpatient unit cost, and Consultation-Liaison Psychiatry had the lowest
outpatient unit cost. In terms of number of inpatients, Dept. of Pediatrics had the
highest, while the Aphaeresis Unit had the lowest unit cost. Nuclear Medicine Department had the highest cost, while the Aphaeresis Unit had the lowest clinic unit cost
with respect to inpatient hospital days. CONCLUSIONS: The results of this study
show that the unit costs of outpatient clinics are higher in the departments of internal
medicine compared to the departments of surgery whereas the reverse is true for
inpatient clinics. Being aware of unit costs in a large-size hospital would improve
strategic decision-making process including effective financial management, health
care service planning and human resources management.
PHP54
BUDGET IMPACT OF ORPHAN DRUGS IN DENMARK COMPARED TO
OTHER EUROPEAN COUNTRIES
Heemstra HE, Hensen M, Meijboom MJ
Pharmerit International, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: Budget impact (BI) of orphan drugs (ODs) has increased over the past
10 years as more ODs entered the market since the introduction of the EU Regulation
on Orphan Medicinal Products. The aim of this study is to determine the BI of ODs
in a selection of countries where a large number of authorized ODs are reimbursed.
METHODS: Public data on OD expenditure in Denmark was collected. The BI was
13th Euro Abstracts
calculated per product for the period 2005–2009. Subgroup analyses were performed
for different types of treatment setting and ATC classes. The results of Denmark were
compared to data collected for France (total OD costs for 2002–2009 specified per
treatment setting) and for Belgium (budget estimates per product for 2008). RESULTS:
Total BI of ODs in Denmark increased from 20.3Mc for 13 reimbursed ODs out of
22 (59%) authorized ODs in 2005 to c58.3M for 41 out of 60 (68%) authorized ODs
in 2009. Highest costs were for oncology drugs (57%–67% of total BI in 2005–2009)
and for metabolism drugs (19%–30% in 2005–2009). Outpatient drugs accounted
for 0.01% (2005) to 1.55% (2009) of total BI of ODs. In France, 34 ODs were
reimbursed in 2008 and the BI increased from c71M in 2002 to c496M in 2008. In
2008, the BI represented 1.8% of the total value of drugs sold. The situation in
Belgium is comparable as the total BI of ODs was c66.2M in 2008 representing 2%
of total reimbursed drug costs. CONCLUSIONS: Although cost per patient is relatively high, total BI for a country is still modest as a result of lower volumes used.
The results show a consistent picture for OD expenditure across different health care
systems. Budget restrictions are not widely used for ODs but this might change when
the anticipated increase in BI of ODs becomes more apparent.
PHP55
INVESTIGATING THE IMPACT OF R&D INVESTMENT AND POLICY ON
INNOVATIVE PERFORMANCE IN EUROPE
Trevor NC, Tang M, Samuels ER
Heron Evidence Development Ltd, London, UK
OBJECTIVES: At the 2000 Lisbon Summit, the European Council set the quantitative
target to increase R&D investment in all EU countries to 3% GDP by 2010. Today,
there is growing emphasis on innovation in R&D, particularly in the development of
pharmaceuticals, with the European Innovation Scoreboard (EIS) publishing annual
ranking of the 27 EU member states to track and benchmark innovation performance.
This work aims to explore the potential relationship between R&D investment and EIS
innovation performance. In addition, the impact of national or regional innovation
plans/policy will be considered. METHODS: The EIS innovation performance results
for 2009 (based on data from 2005) were identified as the primary measure of innovation performance. The EIS includes 7 dimensions to accommodate the diversity of
innovation processes and models that occur in varying national contexts. Eurostat data
were used to identify the R&D investment in 2005. In order to identify the importance
of R&D investment (%GDP) to EIS position, a simple quantitative linear regression was
conducted. Supplementary qualitative literature searches were conducted to identify
national and regional innovation plans and policies. RESULTS: The simple linear regression revealed a significant (P < 0.00005) relationship between R&D investment and
position within the EIS innovation performance, with R&D investment explaining 72%
of the scoreboard results. However, other dimensions have a noteworthy effect on
innovation performance, since although the UK was identified as an innovation leader
(along with Denmark, Finland, Germany, and Sweden), the UK ranks only 8th in terms
of %GDP R&D investment. In this case, the presence of a national plan for innovation,
alongside other factors, has led to high innovative performance. CONCLUSIONS:
Although R&D has a significant effect on innovation performance, other dimensions
also have a noteworthy effect. For example, the presence of national plans for innovation
may aid a country in gaining innovation leader status.
PHP56
SERVICES FOR WHICH PHARMACISTS MAY LEVY A FEE: PHARMACIST
INITIATED THERAPY (PIT)
Truter I1, Lubbe MS2, Butler N3, Nazer DP4, Gous AG5, Bayever DN6, Naidoo P7, Naidoo
M8, Tlala V9, Putter S10
1
Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University (NMMU), Port Elizabeth, Eastern Cape, South
Africa; 2North-West University, Potchefstroom, South Africa; 3University of the Western
Cape, Bellville, Western Cape, South Africa; 4Tswane University of Technology, Pretoria,
Gauteng, South Africa; 5University of Limpopo, Medunsa, Limpopo, South Africa; 6University
of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, Gauteng, South Africa; 7University of KwaZulu-Natal,
Durban, KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa; 8Rhodes University, Grahamstown, Eastern Cape,
South Africa; 9South African Pharmacy Council, Pretoria, Gauteng, South Africa;
10
Management Sciences for Health, Pretoria, Gauteng, South Africa
OBJECTIVES: The primary aim was to determine the extent of provision of Pharmacist Initiated Therapy (PIT) services in pharmacies in South Africa and the time it takes
to provide this service. METHODS: A national research project was undertaken
during 2008 by the South African Pharmacy Council on the services for which a
pharmacist may levy a fee. The focus of this study is on one component of the larger
study, namely the PIT service. RESULTS: A total of 369 pharmacies provided PIT
services, and 3133 PIT services (cases) were measured. The majority were delivered
by community (retail) pharmacies (95.79%). The PIT service was divided into three
phases: Phase I (pre-administration procedure), Phase II (preparation and labelling of
the prescribed medicine) and Phase III (provision of information and instructions to
the patient to ensure the safe and effective use of medicine). Phase I was performed
in 98.21% of cases, Phase II in 97.19% of cases and Phase III in 91.67% of cases.
Pharmacists mostly delivered all three phases themselves (over 70% of cases). The
weighted average time it took for a PIT service to be delivered was 199.02 seconds
(just under 3.5 minutes) (SEM = 5.57 seconds). The weighted average time in community pharmacies was slightly less (192.82 seconds) compared to 312.15 seconds in
private institutional pharmacies. The time taken was dependent on the number of
items dispensed. The weighted average time taken was 160.76 seconds if there was 1
item dispensed, 220.31 seconds for more than 1 and equal to 2 items dispensed, and
327.19 seconds if more than 2 items were dispensed. a pharmacist may currently
13th Euro Abstracts
charge a fee of R35.00 for this service. CONCLUSIONS: PIT is an important service
that pharmacists deliver where the need exists. It is recommended that pharmacists be
encouraged to counsel patients thoroughly when delivering a PIT service.
PHP57
AN ANALYSIS OF DRUG COST CONTAINMENT POLICY AT A
HOSPITAL IN SOUTHERN THAILAND
Sae Wong AK, Kunthavaporn S, Junchareon N
Songkhla Hospital, Muang, Songkhla, Thailand
OBJECTIVES: To examine drug cost containment policy implemented at a hospital in
southern Thailand. METHODS: This study was a retrospective, pre-post policy intervention descriptive design. During the fiscal years of 2005 and 2009, various drug cost
containment strategies, including generic substitution for any drug group and a successful treatment guideline for orthopedic drugs, were adopted at a hospital in southern
Thailand. Drug expenditures across those fiscal years were examined. The expenditure
proportions between drugs listed and unlisted in National Essential Drug List were
calculated. Cost-saving analysis of all generic substitution was conducted. Since the
treatment guideline for orthopedic drugs was available in the hospital, their expenditures
were also examined. RESULTS: Total drug expenditures had increased with decreasing
rate across the study years. It increased by 47.15% from year 2005 to 2006, 43.19%
from year 2006 to 2007, 21.17% from year 2007 to 2008 and 2.17% from year 2008
to 2009. The expenditures of essential drugs in the National Drug List were accounted
for 61.64%, 56.62%, 54.38%, 48.67% and 50.94% across those study periods, respectively. Results showed that generic drug substitution policy reduced overall drug expenditures by 34.33%, or 7.66 million baths from year 2008. In 2009, only 11 items of
generic drug substitution for branded-name drugs could reduce drug expenditures by
13.33%, or 4.73 million bahts which reflected annual cost-saving about 25.95 million
bahts. In the same year, a result showed that the implementation of orthopedic drug
guideline reduced drug expenditures by 5.53% or 2.10 million bahts. CONCLUSIONS:
The study indicated that treatment guideline and generic drug substitution policies could
control relatively high amount of drug expenditures at a hospital in southern Thailand.
Hospital administrators should consider to continue these policies.
PHP58
ANNUAL HEALTH INSURANCE REIMBURSEMENT OF DENTAL CARE IN
HUNGARY
Marada G1, Nagy Á1, Sebestyén A2, Benke B1, Kriszbacher I1, Boncz I1
1
University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary; 2National Health Insurance Fund Administration, Pécs,
Hungary
OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to asess the annual health insurance reimbursement of of dental health service in Hungary. METHODS: The assessment base
of the study was the annual reports of National Health Insurance Fund Administration
(OEP). Only the data collected from the services in conctractual relationship with the
OEP and delivered in 2008 were evaluated. Dental care services are organised in different levels: general dental service, specialist dental care, special dental care on university level and inpatient departments. Our study covers primary, outpatient and
hospital dental care. RESULTS: Dental care was supplied by 3378 general and specialist dental care services until the end of 2008. For the hospital treatment of more serious
cases 17 inpatient department is available with 154 patient beds. Within the period
of examination (2008) 7.6 million cases or rather 23.6 million interventions were
carried out. The health insurance expenditures of the OEP for outpatient dental care
was 23.9 billion forints (c85,18 million). The total health insurance reimbursement
of dental care (including primary, outpatient and hospital care) was 24.92 billion
Hungarian forints (c88.82 million) in 2008. CONCLUSIONS: The health insurance
reimbursement of dental care services in Hungary is approximately 2% of the total
health insurance expenditure of OEP.
PHP59
EVOLUTION OF PUBLIC EXPENDITURE WITH PHARMACEUTICAL
CARE IN BRAZIL DURING THE PERIOD 2005–2008
Aurea AP, Garcia LP, de Magalhaes LCG, de Almeida RF, dos Santos CF
Institute for Applied Economic Research, Brasilia, DF, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: There is a known concern of health researchers and public managers in
Brazil with the population’s access to medicines. We quantified the public expenditure
on medicines in Brazil, during the period of 2005 to 2008. METHODS: The expenditure
on medicines comes from a data warehouse of the Ministry of Planning, Budget and
Management that stores the information concerning any purchase made by the Brazilian
Federal Government. We also computed the amounts transferred to official laboratories
to produce medicines. Information on the states, Federal District and municipalities
came from the Information System on Public Health Budget (SIOPS). RESULTS: In the
period 2005 to 2008, the public spending with drugs rose from US$ 1.8 billion to US$
2.0 billion in real terms, with an average annual growth equivalent to 3%. The average
spending in this period was US$ 1.8 billion. Most of the spending on medicines is
attributed to the Federal Government, with values exceeding US$ 835 million per year.
Just under half of the expenditure is given to states and municipalities. Considering only
the federal spending, the “strategic component” represents the largest share, with participation from 56%–64% in the period. This result is expected, since the Ministry of
Health is responsible for funding all the medicines from the “strategic component” of
pharmaceutical care which includes, among others, the antiretroviral drugs and blood
products. The amounts of transfers to official laboratories ranged between 20–25% of
drug costs. CONCLUSIONS: The expenditure for those pharmaceutical care programs
A415
whose purchases are centralized at the federal Ministry of Health, didn’t show a significant increase in the period of 2005–2008. Rather, the evidence suggests relative stability
of procurement of medicines from pharmaceutical care programs under the Federal
Government’s responsibility in this period.
PHP60
HEALTH INSURANCE SUBSIDY OF SPA TREATMENT IN HUNGARY
1
1
2
2
Domján P , Zsigmond E , Ágoston I , Boncz I
1
University of Pécs, Zalaegerszeg, Hungary; 2University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: The aim of our study is to calculate the average health insurance reimbursement of spa treatment according to counties in Hungary. METHODS: Data were
derived from the Hungarian National Health Insurance Fund Administration (OEP) and
covers the fiscal year of 2007. These data was analyzed in the light of different value of
its average point. The Hungarian spa financing method is based on relative system,
which is depending on the treatment’s price. We calculated the average health insurance
subsidy per of spa treatment (HIS/STN) as an indicator of average health insurance
reimbursement of a single spa treatment. RESULTS: In 2007 the number of spa treatment was 8,160,438 and the full treatment expenditure of subsidy was 4.34 billion HUF
(US$25,632 million). The average value of (HIS/STN) was 540,000 HUF (US$3124).
Two outlier points are the region of North Hungarian Plan (different from average HIS/
STN value was −6.76%) and region of North Transdanubia (different from average
HIS/STN value was 12.47%). The other regions performed similar outcomes ratio
between 1.33% and 2.95%. CONCLUSIONS: The main cause of the two outlier
regions is the inadequat structure of Spa services. Less people visit to North Transdanubian Region, because the number of spa facilities isn’t significant, but these thermal
baths are significant, which price is higher. The North Hungarian Plan attracts a lot of
patients with lower price. The result if the price is lower, the subsidy will be lower
because of the financing system is based on relative method.
PHP61
MARKET ACCESS AGREEMENTS IN EUROPE: TYPOLOGY AND
RATIONALE
Toumi M1, Jaroslawski S2, Lamure M3
1
University Claude Bernard Lyon 1, Rhone Alpes, France; 2Creativ Ceutical, Paris, Ile de
France, France; 3University Claude Bernard Lyon 2, Rhone Alpes, France
OBJECTIVES: Achieving Market Access for new products has become complex for
pharmaceutical companies. Faced with growing expenditure, health care authorities
accept or propose various Market Access Agreements (MAA) (risk-sharing/performance-based/commercial schemes) but often with little experience and knowledge. We
performed in-depth analysis of their design and we formulate recommendations to
stakeholders. METHODS: MAA is a formalized compromise between payers and
industry to achieve: Price and Reimbursement, HTA recommendation and Formulary
listing. We reviewed published and grey literature from major health insurers in
France, Italy, Germany and UK. We conceptualize MAA typology according to the
nature of uncertainty perceived by stakeholders and their motivations. RESULTS: We
identified above 30 MAAs and classified them as follows: 1) Value for money not
questioned: a) Conditional Market Access Agreement: Evidence development
agreement→Aim: address actual uncertainty; b) Health Outcome Boostering Agreement: Disease Management Initiative→Aim: improve competitive advantage; 2) Value
for money questioned: a) Cost Containment Agreement: Basic commercial
agreement→Aim: reduce/control drug bill; b) Health Outcomes Agreement: Value
based agreement→Aim: link payment to performance. Motivations of public payers:
Main: Buy health production; Other: Control expenditure; Improve ICER of expensive
products; Prevent media coverage of negative decision; Provide patient access; Expand
benefits basket. Motivations of the industry: Main: Achieve Market Access for a
product at high price in all markets; Other: Mitigate development failure; Reassure
share holders; Improve company publicity; Fulfil requirements of authorities. In UK
the design of MAA was a direct consequence of formalized HTA, in Italy there was
no apperent rationale. CONCLUSIONS: Commonly used nomenclature needs to be
revisited. Applying our typology framework should allow health care payers and the
industry to design and implement MAAs rationally and with transparence. MAAs in
UK are a direct repercussion of a not favorable primary HTA.
PHP62
VALUE OF CONGRESS ABSTRACTS OF COST-EFFECTIVENESS STUDIES
FOR DECISION MAKERS
Karray S1, Jaroslawski S1, Dzbek J2, Altin S3, Gerber A3, Toumi M4
1
Creativ Ceutical, Paris, Ile de France, France; 2Jagiellonian University, Kraków, Małopolskie,
Poland; 3Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care (IQWiG), Cologne, Germany;
4
University of Lyon, Lyon, France
OBJECTIVES: ISPOR, iHEA, and HTAi regularly organize congresses in the field of
health economics. Given the number of abstracts accepted each year it is crucial to assess
their credibility and how results of cost-effectiveness analyses differ across meetings.
METHODS: We collected all abstracts published 2007–2009 at ISPOR (International
and Europe), HTAi and iHEA meetings. Abstracts on cost comparison, cost of treatment, cost benefit, cost consequences, cost-effectiveness, cost minimization and cost
utility analyses were reviewed in depth according to a reading grid which allowed
extraction of essential information that could enable evidence-based decision-making in
health policy. This included e.g. availability of key methodological parameters, involvement of the industry in authorship and details of conclusions. RESULTS: We analyzed
5488 abstracts from ISPOR, 1410 from HTAi and 1969 from iHEA. Our preliminary
A416
results show that cost-effectiveness studies constituted 15%, 12% and 7% of all
abstracts presented at ISPOR, iHEA and HTAi respectively. Non-drug technologies
ranged from 11% at ISPOR to nearly 30% for HTAi and were excluded. 32% of analyses used best standard of care as comparator and 10% did not specify the comparator.
Approx. Twenty percent of abstracts did not report discount rates, 28% the nature of
costs included in analysis and 10% the time horizon. a total of 52% of analyses reported
results as a point estimate of cost per QALY. 15% of abstracts submitted to ISPOR
were not co-authored by the industry, 50% at HTAi and above that at iHEA. Analyses
which judged the assessed drug to be cost-effective, cost-saving or dominant made up
82%, 70% and below 50% at ISPOR, HTAi and iHEA respectively. CONCLUSIONS:
ISPOR is a congress preferred by the industry and a high proportion of abstracts
reported favourable conclusions. This trend diminished for HTAi and further for iHEA.
The quality of abstracts is not satisfactory for informed decision-making.
PHP63
THE ECONOMIC IMPACT OF THE INITIATION OF PRESCRIPTION
CONTROL IN THE GREEK SOCIAL SECURITY FUNDS
Kousoulou F1, Argyri S1, Karapanos N2
1
Ministry of Employment and Social Security, Athens, Greece, 2Ministry of Health and Social
Solidarity, Athens, Greece
OBJECTIVES: Due to the financial crisis Greece was forced to implement hard cost
containment measures almost in all fiscal sectors. The objective of the study is to investigate the economic impact emerging from the initiation of controls in prescriptions,
implemented in the Greek social security funds as of 1st January 2010 to 30th April
2010. METHODS: The data derive from the drug reimbursement database of the three
biggest social security funds of Greece from January to April 2010 comparing with the
same period of the previous year. The three security funds of the analysis cover about
90% of the greek population with almost 10 million fully insured members. The security
funds in scope were the following: IKA which covers the private sector with 6.3 million
insured members; OPAD covering the public sector with 1.5 million insured members;
OGA for agriculture with 2 million insured patients. RESULTS: In the first four-month
period of 2010 form the initiation of the prescription control system the pharmaceutical
expenditure was the following: for IKA c747 million in comparison to 716 million the
same period in 2009, difference of 4.25%, for OPAD 172 million for 2010 whilst in
2009 the expenditure was 203 million, with savings of 15% and for OGA in 2010 was
310 million and the same period in 2009 the amount reimbursed for medicines was
c288 million with 7.64% growth. It should be highlighted that although for IKA and
OGA the pharmaceutical expenditure is higher in 2010 in comparison to 2009, still the
growth of expenditure follows a downward slope, 2008–2009 14.82% for IKA and
11.64% for OGA respectively. CONCLUSIONS: The new cost containment measures
implemented in the greek health care sector started presenting results. Other cost containment implemented measures were price cuts for all medicinal products in May 2010
and reduced supply prices for sanitary products.
PHP64
VALUE BASED PRICING IN THE UK: A PRICE-QUANTITY MODEL
ASSESSMENT
Pisa P
University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, Midlothian, UK
OBJECTIVES: In the wake of the 2007 Office of Fair Trading (OFT) Pharmaceutical
Price and Regulation Scheme (PPRS) market study there is a debate whether the UK
should switch to a value-based pricing (VBP) scheme. The OFT VBP system has its aim
to price pharmaceuticals in line with their clinical effectiveness. METHODS: The switch
from the traditional PPRS system to a VBP scheme in the UK was investigated with
regards to the two main PPRS objectives: cost containment and value for money. This
was carried out by modifying and applying a price quantity setting model (Das, 1980)
to fit the UK pharmaceutical market and investigate the capital labour ratio of a firm.
The model uses the assumptions that Von Neumann-Morgenstern 4 utility axioms are
satisfied, the PPRS profit cap is binding and that the price set in the VBP scheme is
efficient. RESULTS: This paper finds that a traditional PPRS, compared to a VBP system,
might cause overinvestment in capital in proportion to labour resulting in higher than
necessary production cost, also called the Averch-Johnson effect. The incentive to
overinvest in capital is found to lie in the link between capital and the profit cap. We
show that manipulating the profit cap by adding non-producing capital, i.e. rate-basepadding, is only incentivised when marginal productivity of capital is smaller than the
cost of capital, net the capital allowance. The VBP effect on cost-containment is found
to be ambiguous; if current pharmaceuticals are priced below what is warranted by their
clinical effectiveness, cost may actually increase. CONCLUSIONS: This paper finds that,
based on a price-quantity model assessment, a VBP system should be introduced. It
would increase social welfare by pricing pharmaceuticals equal to the benefit they
provide, and thus allocate NHS resources to their best possible use.
PHP65
VALUE BASED PRICING IN THE UK: A SURVEY-BASED APPROACH
Pisa P
University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, Midlothian, UK
OBJECTIVES: A survey was carried out to investigate the economical impact of a
switch from the traditional Pharmaceutical Price Regulation Scheme (PPRS) system to
a value-based pricing scheme (VBP), as proposed by the Office of Fair Trading (OFT).
The OFT VBP system has its aim to price pharmaceuticals in line with their clinical
effectiveness. METHODS: Interviews were carried out with experts from the industry,
13th Euro Abstracts
academia and the government comparing the traditional PPRS with the proposed VBP
system. The interviews focused on the regulatory effectiveness, competition, launch
delays, pharmaceutical pricing, risk-sharing agreements and uncertainty premium of
the two systems. a systematic literature review was also carried out for all the above
mentioned topics. RESULTS: In the interviews the current PPRS system was seen as
very beneficial with high transparency and stability, nevertheless lacking mechanisms
promoting price competition when compared to the VBP system. The main concern
with a switch to a VBP system was the risk of a global price lock-in. Since the UK is
directly or indirectly influencing pricing decisions within about 25% of global pharmaceutical consumption, the industry might delay drug launch in the UK, to maintain
global pricing flexibility (e.g. in the adjuvant setting). Risk-sharing agreements were
found to be one possible solution to maintain global price flexibility for the industry,
while ensuring the NHS pays a fair price. The interviewed were unanimous about
establishing an organization separate from any political influences needs to handle the
pricing decision to avoid conflicting incentives. It was suggested to offer a price
premium for pharmaceuticals with well documented cost-effectiveness. a premium
would incentivise the industry and reduce reimbursement decision uncertainty. CONCLUSIONS: This survey indicates that a transparent and stable pricing process with
proper risk-sharing agreements would increase the probability of a successful implementation of a VBP system in the UK.
PHP66
AN ASSESSMENT OF THE VARIATION IN ACCEPTED ICERS BY DISEASE
TYPE: RESULTS FROM FOUR HTAS
Ternouth AM, Chapman M, Modha R
Heron Evidence Development Ltd, Luton, UK
OBJECTIVES: HTAs are frequently required to assess different treatment regimes for
different disease types. Frequently, technology appraisal decisions are based on the
ICERs estimated from economic models. The aim of this study was to identify any trends
in accepted ICER thresholds by disease type. METHODS: All published technology
appraisals since April 2005 were downloaded from PBAC, SMC, CADTH, and NICE
websites. Appraisals were categorised by disease type according to BNF categories. The
manufacturer’s base-case ICERs were extracted and compared across accepted submissions by disease type. RESULTS: Eighteen CADTH, 122 SMC, 81 PBAC and 122 NICE
appraisals were identified. For PBAC and SMC, the accepted ICER level (<$75,000 and
<£30,000, respectively) was consistent across >90% of the disease categories. However,
accepted ICERs for malignant disease cluster at a higher level (up to $200,000 for PBAC
and up to £63,000 for the SMC). Additionally, age related macular degeneration for
PBAC, and severe osteoporosis, Lennox-Gastaut syndrome, plaque psoriasis, and hyperammonaemia for the SMC have treatments with accepted ICERs outside the typical
range. Data is limited for CADTH, although Crohn’s disease and hepatitis B are exceptional in having treatments with accepted ICERs >$80,000. Complex data from NICE
is qualitatively assessed in light of data from the other HTAs. Whilst most accepted
ICERs were below £30,000, selected submissions for malignant disease were accepted
above this commonly assumed threshold. CONCLUSIONS: Across disease types,
accepted ICERs tend to cluster beneath a common threshold. However, submissions for
treatments of malignant disease and immunosuppression have a greater chance of
acceptance at higher ICERs than submissions for other disease categories. Rare diseases
may also have a higher limit for ICER acceptance.
PHP67
HAS THE QUALITY AND OUTCOMES FRAMEWORK INFLUENCED
PRIMARY CARE DATA RECORDING?
Blak BT, Lee J, Hards M, Sedani T
CSD EPIC, London, UK
OBJECTIVES: The Quality and Outcomes Framework (QOF) was introduced in the
UK in April 2004. The scheme financially rewards practices for providing quality care
and this is evaluated based on electronic medical records. This study therefore evaluated whether data recording changed after QOF was introduced. METHODS: Patients
were selected from The Health Improvement Network (THIN) database, which holds
longitudinal anonymised primary care records from >450 UK practices. Patients were
grouped according to whether they ever had ≥1 of 15 chronic QOF diseases. Percentages of patients with ≥1 general practice (GP) visit, smoking status, blood pressure
(BP) and weight record were estimated throughout nine 12-month time periods
(January 4, 2000-January 4, 2009). T-tests compared mean percentages before and
after QOF introduction (January 4, 2004). RESULTS: Percentage of QOF patients
ranged from 26.6% to 32.9% over time and non-QOF patients from 67.1% to 73.4%.
The average percentage of QOF patients with a GP visit was 80.5% (standard deviation (SD):3.2) before QOF and 84.5% (SD:0.9) after QOF (p = 0.086). These percentages were 57.5% (SD:3.5) and 62.0% (SD:0.6) (p = 0.082) for non-QOF patients.
The average percentages for smoking recording were 26.8% (SD:12.9) versus 55.9%
(SD:3.0) (p = 0.018) for QOF patients and 10.9% (SD:4.8%) versus 22.3% (SD:2.9)
(p = 0.010) for non-QOF patients. For BP recording, 53.6% (SD:6.7) versus 68.1%
(SD:4.8) (p = 0.013) for QOF patients and 20.5% (SD:2.9) versus 24.2% (SD:0.9) (p
= 0.084) for non-QOF patients. For weight recording, 25.5% (SD:5.4) versus 40.4%
(SD:3.2) (p = 0.006) for QOF patients and 9.8% (SD:1.7) versus 14.8% (SD:1.7) (p
= 0.004) for non-QOF patients. CONCLUSIONS: Overall, the proportion of GP visits
and clinical recording increased after QOF was introduced, although there was no
evidence of a difference for GP visits or BP in non-QOF patients. This suggests that
QOF influenced recording, especially the recording of the evaluated clinical measures
for patients with chronic QOF diseases.
13th Euro Abstracts
PHP68
THE USE OF HEALTH ECONOMICS TERMINOLOGY IN CLINICAL
PUBLICATIONS: BRIDGING THE GAP FROM CLINICAL EFFECTIVENESS
TO COMPARATIVE EFFECTIVENESS
Reich S
PAREXEL, Hackensack, NJ, USA
OBJECTIVES: As the demands of the current regulatory climate and US Health Care
Reform call for greater outcomes-based evidence in health care, the scientific literature
is increasingly incorporating pharmacoeconomic data into peer-reviewed clinical publications in order to demonstrate value to payer audiences. Data from clinical outcomes and cost studies are increasingly finding their way into traditional clinical
papers and review articles. It has been observed that variations may exist in the use
of health outcomes data and terminology. The purpose of this presentation will be to
demonstrate how clearer and more consistent terminology can be integrated into
scientific publications and other vehicles in order to more effectively communicate
economic and clinical outcomes information. METHODS: Using specific examples
from clinical publications, the presentation will: Identify and analyze common terms
used for communicating health economic and outcomes research information to
determine; If they have multiple and/or unclear meanings; How they are being used
to convey information; Define the specific meaning of these terms, using language that
is understandable to all stakeholder audiences; Provide examples/case studies demonstrating how more uniform and consistent definitions can be integrated into payerfocused clinical publications RESULTS: An overview of the findings regarding how
to address specific areas of confusion and inconsistency will be provided. CONCLUSIONS: The results will reiterate the need for clear and consistent terminology in
communicating value in clinical publications.
PHP69
MOBILE MEDICAL RECORD—A LIFE SAVING TOOL
Friedman N, Goldberg A
Ben Gurion University of the Negev, Beer-Sheva, Israel
BACKGROUND: An emergency services team is launched to treat a man who collapsed in the street. The team takes John Doe’s mobile phone, and within seconds
retrieves the required clinical parameters from his Mobile Medical Record (MMR)
thus providing a life-saving treatment suited to his personal health condition. Have
the necessary clinical parameters, required at emergency situations, ever been examined in order to best match both emergency situations and cellular technology?
OBJECTIVES: Characterization of the clinical parameters which assemble an MMR
in the context of saving life and propose a model for an MMR in emergency medicine.
METHODS: Characterization of the essential emergency medicine clinical parameters
in the context of life-saving treatments, through interviews with prehospital and
hospital experts in emergency medicine. Supported by a Cellular multimedia expert,
analysis of the results in order to incorporate the clinical parameters into the cellular
world as an MMR. RESULTS: Emergency medicine teams chose individual and
specific clinical parameters in a certain order of appearance from the general medical
record which should assemble, in their opinion, emergency medicine MMR. MMR
was chosen by the emergency medicine treatment teams as one of their preferred
communication method among the possible communication methods presenting a
patient medical record in the context of life-saving treatment. CONCLUSIONS: The
MMR model, if applied correctly, will provide the emergency medicine treatment
teams an available, reliable, homogeneous database of real time clinical parameters
adapted to life-saving conditions. The MMR model represents a conceptual revolution
of taking out the medical record from the caregiver and transferring it to the patient,
which can be constantly at hand at any given time or place. By doing so, the MMR
contributes and becomes integrated with the leading approaches in the world of
medicine supporting a patient-centered care policy.
PHP70
CURRENT TRENDS IN HEALTH TECHNOLOGY INCORPORATION (HTI)
IN BRAZIL: INSIDE THE NATIONAL HEALTH SYSTEM’S (NHS) BLACK
BOX
Teich V1, Costa ALMA1, Cunha TMB1, Clark LGO2
1
MedInsight-Evidências, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil; 2MedInsight-Evidências, Campinas, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: We aimed to evaluate the trends of submissions and recommendations
received and emitted by the Brazilian Commission on Health Technology Incorporation (CITEC) during the process of adoption/exclusion of technologies on the country’s Public Health System and to critically appraise this process and to analyze the
challenges this commission faces in responding to the increased demand for incorporation of new technologies. METHODS: All submissions on health technologies made
to CITEC and the respective responses obtained between 2003 and 2010 were
reviewed. They were classified by field of interest, origin of request and type of
response. RESULTS: During the selected period CITEC received 222 proposals for
technology incorporation and produced 83 recommendations. We identified an
increase in submissions after 2007. From 2003 to 2006, only 39 requests were submitted on total. After 2007, an average of 49 submissions per year was made. The main
fields were endocrine and metabolic disorders (12%), Oncology (11%) and Rheumatology (11%), but the percentage of responses in these fields was low (34%, 8% and
28% respectively). More than 70% of the submissions were commissioned by the
Industry (162), but only 27% of these were answered. However, almost all submissions sent directly by the Ministry of Health were answered (94%). Among recommendations from CITEC, 53% were favorable to the incorporation of the new
A417
technology and 30% were contrary to it, 17% were cancelled submissions. Adopted
technologies were mainly for hepatitis (14%), endocrine and metabolic disorders
(11%) and genetic disorders (11%). CONCLUSIONS: Although there isn’t a clear
definition of priorities for the incorporation of new technologies by the Brazilian
Ministry of Health, it is possible to map trends in the recommendations issued by
CITEC. It is of the utmost importance to achieve greater disclosure of the criteria for
selection of technologies for incorporation by the Commission.
PHP71
PREDICTING OUTCOMES AMONG PATIENTS WITH PROLONGED
MECHANIC VENTILATION: A DISCRIMINATION MODEL BASED ON
LONGITUDINAL HEALTH INSURANCE REGISTRATION AND CLAIMS
DATA
Lu HM1, Chen L1, Hung MC2, Wang JD2, Lin MS3, Yan YH3, Chen CR3, Fan PS3, Kuo KN1
1
National Health Research Institutes, Zhunan, Taiwan; 2National Taiwan University, Taipei,
Taiwan; 3Chia-Yi Christian Hospital, Chiayi, Taiwan
OBJECTIVES: To identify patients with low survival probability among those with
prolonged mechanical ventilation (PMV; >=21 days of use) under the Taiwan National
Health Insurance (NHI), and explore the length of their time free of inpatient mechanical ventilation (MV) and MV-related hospital expenses during the four years following
PMV. METHODS: This is a retrospective cohort study using death certificates data
and longitudinal NHI data for a national representative sample of 25,482 new PMV
patients in 1998–2003. Logit regression was used to determine factors associated with
3-month, 6-month, 1-year and 2-year survival. Explanatory factors included hospital
characteristics, and individual demographics, socioeconomic conditions, diseases at
the PMV onset, and diseases causing hospital care use within the year before PMV.
The probability cutoff was set at 10% for identifying patients with low survival likelihood and suitable as targets of advocating less intensive care. RESULTS: Five disease
types had high prevalence, and were significantly associated with lower survival:
septicemia, neoplasm, shock, acute and unspecific renal failure, and chronic renal
failure. Each had an odds ratio <0.65 (p < 0.001). Non-alcohol-related liver disease
was also a significant problem. Each survival model had a C-statistic >= 0.7. At the
10% probability cutoff, 1.5%, 5.1%, 11.9% and 21.8% of PMV patients were identified as negative cases for 3-month, 6-month, 1-year and 2-year survival. The negative
predictive values were 86.5%, 86.1%, 89.4%, and 91.8%, respectively. During the
four years after PMV, 75% of these patients had 25 or fewer days free of MV-related
hospital care, and more than 50% of them spent at least 10,800 dollars (2010 USD)
on MV-related hospital care. CONCLUSIONS: This discrimination model has acceptable performance. It helps in selecting potential targets for advocating less intensive
care, and also generates more empirical evidence on prognosis that can facilitate
patient-clinician and family-clinician communication.
PHP72
ANALYSIS THE AVERAGE SOJOURN TIME AND BOTTLENECK AFTER A
DISASTER IN HOSPITALS
Sakata K1, Kobayashi D2, Matsui M1
1
The University of Electro-Communications, Chofu, Tokyo, Japan; 2The University of
Electro-Communications, Minato-ku, Tokyo, Japan
OBJECTIVES: The purpose of this study is to consider the average sojourn time of
patients figure out hospital’s function after a disaster striking. METHODS: This study
explores the average sojourn time of patients and bottleneck in hospitals in the region
defined by this study. Especially, we focus on three days after a disaster striking the
region. We defined three scenarios. • Scenario I:Hospital No.II ceases to function two
days from disaster strikes. • ScenarioII:Hospital No.II ceases to function one day from
disaster strikes. • ScenarioIII:ScenarioIII is the same scenario as the scenario I, but
considering transport from break down hospital (hospital No.2) to hospitals in operation. Patient’s arrival interval λand treatment time µ are equal to the data of Hanshin
earthquake. With the use of those scenarios, we analyze the average sojourn time of
patients and bottleneck with a queuing approach, critical path method and little’s law.
In addition to that, we make Cumulative flow graph to analyze bottleneck. RESULTS:
Comparing scenario I and scenario III, the average sojourn time of general hospital of
scenario III is longer than scenario I, although scenario III has more choices. It reveals
considering transport from break down hospitals to hospitals in operation extends the
average sojourn time. We observed bottleneck in case of changing patient’s arrival
interval λ by making cumulative flow graph. This study shows cumulative flow graph
reveals status of hospital’s function after a disaster. CONCLUSIONS: The results
confirm that the average sojourn time of patients increase in case of changing hospital,
Braess’s paradox and cumulative flow graph reveals status of hospital’s function after
a disaster.
PHP73
CONTENT OF HOME PHARMACIES IN SERBIA
1
2
2
2
Paut Kusturica M , Sabo A , Tomic Z , Stilinovic N
1
A.D. Sanitarija, Novi Sad, Serbia; 2Faculty of Medicine, Novi Sad, Serbia
OBJECTIVES: To get insight into the amount, structure and financial aspects of
medicines in home pharmacies as well as learning about the population’s attitudes,
habits and knowledge concerning self-medication. METHODS: This survey was conducted in the first half of 2010. on a sample of 50 families on the territory of Novi
Sad, Serbia. The families were chosen randomly and the data were collected by using
the standardized questionnaire and checking the inventory of medicines. RESULTS:
The average number of packets in home pharmacies per a family is considerable (13
A418
packets). The most widely kept medicines are medicines for the central nervous system
(21%), the disorders in the digestive system and metabolism (16.7%) and medicines
for the diseases of the respiratory system (14.5%). Nearly three-fourths of opened
packets were not entirely consumed. a large number of medicines in home pharmacies
(79%) was obtained self initiatedly and many of them were beyond their expiry date
(9.5%). a total of 25% of the financial means for those medicines was provided from
health insurance funds. The total cost of medicines in home pharmacies per a family
in Serbia was c25.13. a total of 72% of that amount was paid by the patients
themselves. Pharmacoeconomic indicators in certain groups of medicines show that
the largest percentage of the financial means for home pharmacies in Serbia is spent
on the medicines for gastrointestinal problems and metabolism disorders (17%).
CONCLUSIONS: Based on the analyzed data, self-medication, that is, unreasonable
use of medicines, is a big problem in Serbia. The use of these medicines involves the
risk of inadequate treatment of the illness, frequent occurrence of side-effects which
sometimes requires additional treatment, which only increases the expenses for both
the patients and health funds. Therefore, it is necessary to closely monitor the issuing
of prescriptions as well as educate the population.
PHP74
PRIMARY HEALTH CARE AND POTENTIALLY AVOIDABLE
ADMISSIONS: A 10-YEAR ASSESSMENT FROM THE PERSPECTIVE OF A
HEALTH CARE PLAN
Reis Neto J, Tovar C
CAPESESP/CAPESAUDE, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: To examine the evolution of the rate of admissions for ambulatory
care sensitive conditions in beneficiaries of a health care plan, monitoring of access to
the health system and its performance and identifying strategies that will enable the
improvement of the health situation of the population and the appropriate allocation
of resources. METHODS: Retrospective analysis of 212,360 hospital admissions,
occurring between 1999 and 2008, among beneficiaries of a health care plan, resident
in Brazil. The outcome of the study was the proportion of admissions for primary
care sensitive conditions, identified by ICD-10. The proportion of these admissions in
relation to the total hospital admissions was established, as well as the quotient for
the number of hospital admissions and the population, either total or by age group
and specific causes, besides hospital direct costs. The significance was tested and
estimates of the rates were defined based on their 95% confidence intervals. RESULTS:
Admissions for primary care sensitive conditions accounted for 55,307 of 212,360
admissions reimbursed by the health plan (26.0%). The rate of admission for primary
care sensitive conditions fell by 28.0% during the period (from 347.6 to 250.3 per 10
thousand). The most frequent cause was gastroenteritis (30.9%), followed by arterial
hypertension (13.6%), cerebrovascular diseases (9.6%), heart failure (8.1%), kidney
and urinary tract infections (6.8%), diabetes mellitus (5.8%) and angina pectoris
(5.5%). The mean annual expenditure on admissions was R$15,232,494 against
R$51,440,680 for other conditions (22.8%). CONCLUSIONS: The reduction
observed in the rate of admissions for primary care sensitive conditions suggests possible improvements in primary health care. Further actions and strategies could reduce
the number of avoidable admissions and contribute to the financial balance of the
health care plan.
PHP75
EVALUATION OF THE IMPACT OF INPATIENT CLINICAL PHARMACY
SERVICES ON THE QUALITY AND COST OF PHARMACOTHERAPY IN
INTERNAL MEDICINE WARDS
Pitakthum S
Songkhla Hospital, Songkhla, Thailand
OBJECTIVES: The purpose of this longitudinal descriptive study was to evaluate the
influence of interventions by clinical pharmacists on processes, outcomes of care and
economical outcomes. METHODS: The patients who were hospitalized at internal
medicine wards, Songkhla hospital during October 1, 2008-September 30, 2009 were
recruited to this study. The core set of clinical pharmacy services were admission drug
histories, drug protocol management, adverse drug reaction management, drug information, medical rounds and patient discharge counseling. The clinical pharmacists
collected patients’ data, pharmacists’ interventions, direct drug cost-saving and activities on a specific designated form. The data was processed on a computerized database.
Clinical pharmacist interventions were counted and classified and analyzed to determine the influence on the quality and cost of pharmacotherapy. Descriptive statistics
were used in data analysis. RESULTS: At the end of the study period the following
were found: a total of 3796 patients were recruited. Clinical pharmacy services on
internal medicine wards contribute to maximizing the pharmacotherapeutic effect and
rationalization of drug therapy in 609 patients (16.0%), increase medication safety in
338 patients (8.9%) and reducing drug expenditures in 575 patients (15.1%). Costsaving from reconciling process was US$12,682 and cost-saving from pharmacists’
interventions were US$6,298. The frequent type of interventions was maximizing the
pharmacotherapeutic effect (40.8%), rationalization of drug therapy (30.3%) and
minimizing the risk for developing adverse drug effects (28.9%), respectively. The top
two of drug related problems found in cardiovascular drugs (30.5%) and antibiotic
drugs (24.8%), respectively. CONCLUSIONS: The results of this study indicate that
inpatient clinical pharmacy services on internal medicine wards contribute to rationalization of drug therapy, increase medication safety and reduced the direct expenditures on medications. Therefore, future studies should include multiple sites such as
in a general surgical department and clinical pharmacy services should be
continued.
13th Euro Abstracts
PHP76
ALLOCATION OF A SINGLE BUDGET FOR HEALTH CARE,
PROFESSIONAL EDUCATION, AND RESEARCH
Gandjour A
Pennington Biomedical Research Center/Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge, LA, USA
OBJECTIVES: Funding for health care programs competes with funding for professional
education (ie, implementation of health care programs) and funding for research to
reduce uncertainty around program cost-effectiveness. No study has yet shown how to
allocate a combined budget for health care, professional education, and research. Previous work did not consider the fundamental idea that interventions with an acceptable
incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) for an adoption decision may not be acceptable any more once implementation decisions are made simultaneously. Furthermore,
previous work did not consider that cost-effectiveness of research is conditional upon
the programs chosen for adoption and implementation. The purpose of this work is to
present a sequential process to allocate a combined budget with the goal to maximize
health. METHODS: Development of a 3-step allocation process to maximize health
based on a single budget for health care, professional education, and research RESULTS:
As a first step, a league table approach determines which programs would be funded if
the combined budget were spent just on adoption. The second step analytically determines a new (lower) threshold ICER which maximizes health by discontinuing programs
above the new threshold and investing in implementing programs below the threshold.
The third step considers cost-effectiveness of research to reduce uncertainty around
program cost-effectiveness. In order to fund this research, the threshold ICER for adoption plus implementation has to be reduced further. In order to maximize health, ICERs
of research studies need to equal the newly defined threshold ICER for adoption plus
implementation. CONCLUSIONS: A 3-step allocation process is able to maximize
health based on a single budget for health care, professional education, and research.
Compared to a programming approach the proposed approach yields a closed-form
analytical solution and is able to consider that research decisions are conditional upon
adoption and implementation choices.
PHP77
DIRECT CONTRACTS ON PATENT-PROTECTED PHARMACEUTICALS
IN GERMANY: MOTIVES OF SICK FUNDS AND PHARMACEUTICAL
COMPANIES
Neurohr C, Huebner S, Ernst F, Welte R
GlaxoSmithKline GmbH & Co. KG, Munich, Germany
OBJECTIVES: To investigate the motives of both contracting parties, sick funds and
pharmaceutical companies, to enter into direct contracts on patent-protected pharmaceuticals in the outpatient sector in Germany. METHODS: A systematic literature
review was performed in March 2010 to identify contracts on patent-protected pharmaceuticals in Germany. Standard literature databases such as Pubmed and EMBASE,
different market research databases and the ‘Lauer-Taxe’, the official German price
registry for pharmaceuticals were utilised. We included only officially reported contracts.
a detailed market analysis was conducted to identify the motives of the identified contracts. RESULTS: The number of direct contracts has been recently increasing. a total
of 116 contracts were found. Formally, they are all rebate contracts due to German law.
However, they include risk-sharing (n = 6), cost-sharing (2), added value (5) and simple
rebate contracts (103). For sick funds, major motives were cost cutting, positioning
within the market, attracting the “right” members, improving the medical treatment
and right coding. Pharmaceutical companies show several motives that can be clustered
into proactive and reactive motives: Proactive motives were: gaining access to reimbursement beyond standard coverage, funding of managed care concepts, bridging a time gap
until market entry of a successor, maintaining the attractiveness after patent expiration
as well as shaping the market access environment. Reactive motives were: rebate contracts of competitors, limitations and exclusions from reimbursement by the federal joint
committee as well as reacting to attempts by sick funds and Associations of Statutory
Health Insurance Physicians to control drug expenditures. CONCLUSIONS: Direct
contracting on patent-protected pharmaceuticals seems to play a increasing role in the
strategic considerations of pharmaceutical companies and sick funds.
PHP78
A TALE OF FOUR COUNTRIES: COMPARING REIMBURSEMENT
SUBMISSION REQUIREMENTS IN IRELAND, ENGLAND, WALES AND
SCOTLAND
Rycroft C1, Pearson I1, Khan S2, Heyes A1
1
RTI Health Solutions, Manchester, UK; 2RTI Health Solutions, Research Triangle Park, NC,
USA
OBJECTIVES: Requirements for a Health Technology Assessment (HTA) submission vary
within the UK (England and Wales [National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence
(NICE)], Scotland [Scottish Medicines Consortium (SMC)], and Wales [All Wales Medicines Strategy Group (AWMSG)]) and the Republic of Ireland (National Centre for
Pharmacoeconomics [NCPE]). The objective of this study is to determine whether the
likelihood of reimbursement in these markets is linked to HTA submission requirements.
METHODS: Dossier requirements issued by NCPE, NICE, SMC and AWMSG were
compared, and a checklist of requirements compiled. We investigated 20 interventions
most recently reviewed by the NCPE, and recorded the recommendations for these compared with those issued by NICE, SMC and AWMSG. RESULTS: Economic analysis is
key for an NCPE submission, although there are no specific requirements or template for
the clinical data. Requirements for NICE are the most stringent; SMC and AWMSG have
similar requirements. Of 20 interventions reviewed by NCPE, 11 (55%) were reimbursed
13th Euro Abstracts
under the Community Drugs Scheme. Of these, 2 treatments were reimbursed after a price
reduction, 2 were borderline, and 1 treatment was cost-effective under the General Medical
Services scheme but not the Drugs Payment Scheme. Of the 11 products reimbursed by
NCPE, 5 were recommended by NICE (45%), 6 by SMC (55%) and 1 by AWMSG (9%).
Not all of the 11 treatments were reviewed by NICE, SMC and/or AWMSG. Furthermore,
2 of the 11 treatments have been withdrawn in Scotland, England and Wales. Limited
clinical/economic data was the reason for the one non-recommendation by the SMC. a
more detailed analysis will be presented. CONCLUSIONS: Although requirements for
HTA submissions vary between countries, demonstrating cost-effectiveness is a key factor
for reimbursement in all markets investigated.
PHP79
REFINING INPATIENT PSYCHIATRIC FACILITY REIMBURSEMENT:
LESSONS FROM OTHER MEDICARE PROSPECTIVE PAYMENT SYSTEMS
Pierce CA, Jones NA, Brocketti JJ
The Resource Group, Richfield, OH, USA
OBJECTIVES: The Inpatient Psychiatric Facility Prospective Payment System (IPF
PPS) is the youngest of the Medicare PPSs. Inpatient Psychiatric Facilities (IPFs) were
excluded from the acute care inpatient diagnosis-related groups (DRG) system as it
was thought to be a poor predictor of resource use for psychiatric patients. Although
the IPF PPS was to include a patient classification system to reflect the differences in
resource use and costs among IPFs, it was implemented without an associated assessment tool. This project reviews Medicare PPSs in which diagnosis is not an adequate
predictor of resource use; compares data collected via the related assessment instruments, and discusses applicability to the IPF PPS. METHODS: The Medicare prospective payment systems were evaluated and the relevant systems isolated. The systems’
defining criteria were defined and the related assessment instruments explored for
identifying measures. RESULTS: Under the current IPF PPS, Medicare pays for the
per diem costs associated with furnishing covered inpatient psychiatric services via a
nationally established base rate adjusted by geographic, facility and patient factors.
Patient characteristics are limited to seventeen Medicare severity-diagnosis related
groups (MS-DRGs), age, length of stay and certain co-morbidities but, unlike home
health, skilled nursing and rehabilitation facility systems, do not account for functional
status or other contributors to resource consumption. CONCLUSIONS: Patients in
IPFs may vary in care needs despite common MS-DRG classification, thus require
different resources. With limited ability to adjust beyond primary diagnosis, the
current IPF PPS may misalign facility payment and expenses, ultimately impacting
access to care. By analyzing other Medicare PPSs policy makers may positively contribute to the refinement of this newest system.
A419
prescription is allowed in 20 countries of all 27 European countries and in all 50 US states.
The generic substitution by pharmacists is allowed in 21 European countries (mandatory
in 8) and in all US states (mandatory in 14). Despite the high increase from 2002, generics
market share in Portugal is still below the European average, furthermore with a slowdown
in its growth since 2005. The doctors prescribed 39.1% of drugs by brand name with no
permission for substitution in 2009. The simulations generated savings of c120.4 million
(50.8 for the NHS and c69.6 million for patients), less 11.1% of the medicines expenditure
covered by the RPS. CONCLUSIONS: The market shares observed seem to reflect the
different legislative frameworks. In Portugal, despite the growing share of generics, there
is still a large potential market with significant opportunities of additional savings for the
health system and patients, and may contribute to a higher pharmaceuticals accessibility
as well to maximize therapeutic adherence.
PHP82
ASSESSMENT OF PHARMACEUTICAL EXPENDITURE TRENDS IN
PORTUGAL—PRICING AND REIMBURSEMENT POLICY
Teixeira I, Mendes Z
CEFAR—Center for Health Evaluation Studies, Lisboa, Portugal
OBJECTIVES: The Stability and Growth Pact approved by the Portuguese Government in 2010 limits the annual growth of public expenditure in 1% for drugs reimbursed in outpatient sector. Considering the 10.4% increased in pharmaceutical
expenditure from the National Health Service (NHS) in the first 4 months of 2010,
this study aims to identify the main factors of expenditure growth and implications
of legislative modifications in Portugal. METHODS: We have considered the policy
changes concerning pricing and reimbursement and analyzed the database that
includes sales from Portuguese community pharmacies and drugs prescription data.
The statistical analysis of monthly data by product was performed with Statistical
Analysis System (SAS), version 8.2. RESULTS: The new legislation approved in June
2009, that establishes the generics reimbursement at 100% for pensioners whose
income is below the national minimum wage was responsible for more c20.4 million
of NHS spending in 2010. The special reimbursement regimes had also contributed
positively for this trend: for example, the reimbursement rate raise for some antiasthmatics (from 37% to 69%) was responsible for c5.1 million (10.3%) of NHS
expenditure increase. Nevertheless c10.7 million (21.5% of NHS expenditure growth)
are explained by the top 10 branded drugs recently reimbursed (5 oral antidiabetics
and 1 insulin). The reform in reimbursement system approved for July 2010 also
predicts major changes in the expenditures trends. CONCLUSIONS: The legal framework has a high impact in pharmaceuticals expenditures trends, and consequently in
public financial burden and patient co-payments. The different policy measures
adopted should be assessed on a periodic basis in order to monitor the market dynamics and to identify the strategies that support the sustainable expenditure growth.
PHP80
EFFECTS OF REFERENCE PRICING AND TENDER CONTRACTS IN
GERMANY
Volmer T1, Fieke H2
1
TV Healthcare Consulting, Hamburg, Germany; 2University Muenster, Muenster, Germany
OBJECTIVES: The therapeutic reference price (RP) system in Germany is regarded as
a successful mechanism to reduce pharmaceutical spending. However, later introduced
price directed measures such as the so-called payer contracts (pharmaceutical tender
contracts (TC) interact with the reference price mechanism. The aim of this paper is to
compare and analyze the effects of both instruments on pharmaceutical price, volume
and expenditure for substances at the period around loss of exclusivity. METHODS: a
group of frequently prescribed drugs with patent expiry between the years of 2001 and
2008 are investigated and the sales and unit data in the statutory health insurance system
are analyzed for a period one year before and two year post patent expiry. RESULTS:
The data show for the group with reference price and no tender contract (RP+/TC-) and
with no reference price but tender contracts (RP-/TC+) similar level for the sales but
significantly higher volume data for the first group. In the first year post patent expiry
there seams to be a significant drop of sales and volume 9–12 month post patent expiry—
a period, when usually the reference price is set. The figures for the groups with tender
contracts (TC+) show a more steadily decline post patent expiry. The group RP+/TC+
is in terms of cost containment (sales decline) the most prominent one. If no regulation
takes place, sales and volume increases even post patent expiry. CONCLUSIONS: Reference pricing and tender contracts are two cost containment measures, which are equally
effective if applied alone, and which have additional impact, when applied together.
PHP83
EFFECTS OF COST-CONTAINMENT METHODS TO DRUG PRICE LEVEL
IN EUROPE
Ligeti I, Komáromi T
Healthware Ltd, Budapest, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: Due to the dynamic increase of pharmaceutical expenditure in the last
decade different cost-containment method has been introduced by the European public
insurance companies. The cost-effective drug reimbursement system might influence
the price level either in a direct or an indirect way, so the pricing strategy should be
based on demand drivers and on factors of the regulatory environment as well. The
goal of this analysis was to identify the effect the certain reimbursement solutions and
local market characteristic on average price level of the predefined submarket.
METHODS: Before the statistical analysis we have built a comprehensive, standardized and continuously updated international drug database based on official sources
which supported the analysis trough getting wider access to data’s. Because of the
expected domestic introduce of international reference price system, we handled it
with an extra attention among the explanatory variables. RESULTS: The variance of
international pharmaceutical price level by the examined submarket found to be
remarkable which can be explained by the difference product supply and the different
apply of cost-containment methods of price regulation. CONCLUSIONS: The most
effective way to curb the increased expenditure by the patient and the public insurance
companies seems to be international reference price system; however the effect of this
method differs across the countries.
PHP81
EFFECTS OF THE POTENCIAL GENERIC SUBSTITUTION IN PORTUGAL.
DOES REGULATION MATTERS?
Teixeira I1, Guerreiro J1, Mendes Z1, Montenegro C2
1
CEFAR—Center for Health Evaluation Studies, Lisboa, Portugal; 2Associação Nacional das
Farmácias, Lisboa, Estremadura, Portugal
OBJECTIVES: Considering the pharmaceutical expenditure trend and the current economic and social context in Portugal, this study aims to: 1) analyze the national and
international policy environments in Europe and US, concerning INN prescription and
generic substitution, and 2) calculate the effect of generic substitution in Portugal, in terms
of savings for the NHS and patients. METHODS: We conducted an international legislation review and generics market data. We estimated annual savings under the assumption
of gradual increase in generics market share, and considering the difference between
branded and generic medicines prices for each group of the Reference Price System (RPS).
The database includes sales from Portuguese community pharmacies. RESULTS: The INN
PHP84
A PROPOSAL FOR CLASSIFICATION OF PUBLIC FUNDING
RESTRICTIONS
Wilk NM
Arcana Institute, Krakow, Malopolskie, Poland
OBJECTIVES: Increasingly difficult situation of health care systems forces decision
makers to limit access to publicly funded drugs compared to registration conditions.
To keep the transparency, the decisions to deny health intervention to some group of
patients have to be publicly justified—simple intuition is not enough. The objective is
to present initial classification and details of methods to generate public funding
restrictions. METHODS: A pool of public funding decisions has been identified
through search of internet websites of the institutions that recommend or actually
make public funding decisions. The specific conditions restricting the access were
identified, grouped and further analyzed together with their justification if available.
RESULTS: All restrictions generally aim to optimize the performance of the decision
A420
in regard to public funding criteria. The following main types of restrictions were
identified either because of the target public funding parameter affected or because of
the reasoning: a) “because of lack of evidence”; b) “because it is the only effective
treatment” (rule of rescue); c) “to improve efficacy”; d) “to improve efficacy-safety
relation”; e) “to improve effectiveness”; f) “to improve cost-effectiveness”; and g) “to
limit budget impact”. CONCLUSIONS: The limiting conditions should be perceived
as tools to enable positive public funding decision when the current scope of financing
is just behind the hypothetical threshold. Exploring and further analyzing methods
and aspects concerning generating public funding restrictions is important for: 1)
decision makers, so they be more aware of the consequences and impact of their
decisions on the people/patients they serve, and could make more transparent decisions; 2) HTA analysts, to focus their interest on the subsequent use of HTAs to help
decision makers identify all potential options to rationally limit funding; 3) Market
Access managers, so they used the identified mechanisms and methods to better foresee
the public funding decisions concerning their drugs.
PHP85
ASSESSING PUBLIC ACCOUNTABILITY OF KOREAN DRUG
REIMBURSEMENT DECISION PROCESS
Cho E, Kang M
Yonsei University, Seoul, South Korea
OBJECTIVES: Since economic evaluation has been enforced to be considered for new
drug reimbursement decisions in 2007, the structure and constituents of decision body,
“Drug Reimbursement Evaluation Committee”, as well as the pharmacoeconomics
report guideline promulgated by Health Insurance Review Assessment have been
modified in Korea. These changes reflect deficiency in systematic adoption of economic
evaluation and discontent among stakeholders. Recently, the fair and reasonable
process and criteria have been highly emphasized at every level of policy administration in developed countries with concerns of increasing public demands for sustainable
public practices and political acceptance of the importance of public accountability.
Now, imminent practical task is how to connect the conceptual framework and feasible practice for publicly accountable drug reimbursement decisions. METHODS:
Using theoretical structure of public accountability published in the European Governance Paper, we analyzed qualifications of drug reimbursement policy as ‘accountability’ and appraised the public accountability. We also performed interviews with
ten key stakeholders from democratic, constitutional and learning perspectives. And
then, recent reimbursement decision papers on two new drugs were analyzed to
examine concrete shape of the accountability forums. RESULTS: Following scope of
improvement would be suggested: (1) Clear and reasonable standards for coverage
decision; (2) relevance of the standards to population’s health needs and health equity
impacts; (3) disclosure of data used for decision, procedure and results to public; and
(4) the procurement of due process of challenging decisions. CONCLUSIONS: Given
value pluralism in democratic liberalism, it is matter of course that formal or procedural justice is given prominence. Conclusively, an explicit discussion for formal criteria and procedure is the essential component of the ongoing policy process.
Accountable drug policy administration is impossible without accountable policy
process which is impossible without transparent criteria for all decision stages.
PHP86
SUCCESSFUL IMPLEMENTATION OF COVERAGE WITH EVIDENCE
DEVELOPMENT SCHEMES: PRACTICAL EXPERIENCES IN SEVERAL
WESTERN JURISDICTIONS
Theunissen KA1, Delwel G2, Evers SM1, Goettsch W2, Severens H3, Hoomans T1
1
Maastricht University, Maastricht, Limburg, The Netherlands; 2Health Care Insurance Board
(CVZ), Diemen, The Netherlands; 3University Maastricht & Erasmus University Rotterdam,
Maastricht, The Netherlands
BACKGROUND: In Western jurisdictions, coverage with evidence development (CED)
is seen as a promising scheme for linking coverage decisions on innovative health technologies with the generation of additional evidence. Nonetheless, the implementation of
such CED schemes is not guaranteed to be successful, with issues arising around both
evidence generation and (dis)continued coverage of technologies. OBJECTIVES: This
qualitative study aims to explore the practical experiences with CED schemes for technology coverage. METHODS: Semi-structured interviews were conducted with key
stakeholders involved in the decision making process about reimbursement of health
technologies in Australia, Belgium, Ontario (Canada), France, Germany, Galicia (Spain),
Sweden, UK and USA. The questionnaire for the interview was developed on the basis
of comprehensive literature review and expert opinion, addressing issues related to the
aim of CED, initial assessment/appraisal, evidence development, re-assessment/reappraisal and coverage for technologies. RESULTS: CED schemes vary widely in the
evidence generation, time frame, the regulation and funding of research, and the involvement of stakeholders in the CED process. This variation is caused by the structure and
financing of health services delivery, the aim of CED, and the type of health technology.
The CED process is often non-transparent, particularly relating to the selection of
technologies and the re-assessment/re-appraisal for coverage (dis)continuation. (Dis)
continued coverage of technologies is often primarily driven by the pressures from
patients, health professional and health institutions to provide access to innovative
technologies or public opinion. CONCLUSIONS: The successful implementation of
CED schemes requires: a) a transparent (analytic) framework for the selection of health
technologies and the generation of additional evidence; b) a clear legal authority to regulate evidence generation, time frame and research budget; c) a structural involvement of
stakeholders in the process of CED; and d) a priori clear end points for the re-assessment/
re-appraisal and technology coverage.
13th Euro Abstracts
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Health Care Research &
Education
PHP87
THE ROLE OF VALUE OF INFORMATION ANALYSIS IN HEALTH CARE
RESEARCH PRIORITY SETTING: A THEORETICAL CASE STUDY
Corro Ramos I, Rutten-van Mölken MP, Al MJ
Erasmus University, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
BACKGROUND: The Dutch reimbursement procedure for expensive hospital drugs
requires the submission of a baseline cost-effectiveness analysis together with a
research plan for the period of temporary reimbursement in order to estimate the
real-life cost-effectiveness after 4 years. In this situation, a Value-of-Information (VOI)
analysis might identify the critical parameters that need to be studied in such outcome
study. OBJECTIVES: To identify when a VOI analysis alongside sensitivity analyses
is warranted, and when such VOI analysis will not impact the decision making process.
METHODS: We used a hypothetical Markov model with three groups of parameters:
costs, utilities and transition probabilities. We studied different configurations of input
parameters, forcing the outcomes into different directions on the CE-plane. For each
input configuration we performed a multivariate sensitivity analysis (MSA) and a
probabilistic sensitivity analysis (PSA). In the MSA, sensitivity was measured as percentage change from baseline INMB. Additionally, we analyzed the expected value of
perfect information (EVPI) and the expected value of partial perfect information
(EVPPI). Analyses were done for a range of threshold ICERs. RESULTS: For each
situation it was possible to predict the shape (but not the absolute value) of the EVPI
curve based on the PSA findings. When the PSA plot covered both northern quadrants,
MSA and EVPPI came to the same ranking of the groups of parameters. When the
outcomes were in the northeast quadrant the ranking differed: MSA indicated costs
as most important parameters, for EVPPI this was utilities. When outcomes where in
the southwest quadrant, costs were most important in MSA and EVPPI. For both
other quadrants, MSA and EVPPI were close to zero for all groups. CONCLUSIONS:
Whether MSA and EVPPI come to a different priority setting for future research
depends both on the threshold ICER and on the location of results on the
CE-plane.
PHP88
STAKEHOLDER PERCEPTIONS OF CLINICAL DRUG TRIALS
1
2
Murphy LM , Maguire W
1
University of Tasmania/Manukau Institute of Technology, Auckland, New Zealand;
2
University of Tasmania, Hobart, Australia
OBJECTIVES: To identify stakeholder perceptions of sponsored clinical trials in a
publically funded New Zealand hospital, and then to identify the similarities and
differences in perceptions across these stakeholder groups. The stakeholders are: 1)
participants involved in clinical trials; 2) management and the multidisciplinary team;
3) the larger South Auckland community; 4) government and decision makers; and 5)
the pharmaceutical industry. METHODS: We use purposive sampling to select representatives of the stakeholder groups, which provides 109 respondents. We gather data
using focus groups, in-depth interviews, telephone interviews and surveys. RESULTS:
Many of the respondents represent more than one stakeholder group. While there is
consensus across the stakeholders on some costs and benefits such as developing safe
medicines and collecting useful data there are marked differences in perceptions in
other areas, such as those indicated below. Most stakeholders perceive the risk of
adverse reactions as the greatest cost to trial participants but the participants themselves do not regard this as significant. Pharmaceutical representatives, management
and the multidisciplinary team feel that gaining access to new medicines motivates
people to participate in a trial. Trial participants feel that the support is more important to them than the medication. Most researchers and staff believe trial involvement
increases their job satisfaction, motivation, knowledge and skills while a few have
concerns that sponsor control leads to the loss of their flexibility and independence
Generally there is a perception that New Zealand based clinical trials assist in the
process of obtaining registration and subsidization of new drugs in New Zealand.
However, this perception may be erroneous as location of trials is apparently not
considered in the drug registration process. CONCLUSIONS: We find that most
stakeholders are satisfied with the conduct of clinical trials in New Zealand and they
believe the benefits outweigh the costs.
PHP89
PERCEPTION OF PHARMACO-EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDIES BY
PHYSICIANS AND MOTIVATION TO PARTICIPATE: FRENCH
SITUATION
Schmidely N1, Bonhomme C1, Veysseyre H2, Nechadi S2, Longin J2
1
Bristol-Myers Squibb, Rueil Malmaison, France; 2REGISTRAT-MAPI, Lyon, France
OBJECTIVES: Recent development of Health Technology Assessment worldwide
increased requirement for real world data (e,g, risk management plans, drugs utilization). Primary non-interventional research (NIR) involving physicians able to enrol
patients is a means to generate such data. One key challenge of NIRs is the capacity
to reflect real life conditions by providing unbiased estimations of physicians’ behaviours and patients outcomes in large representative samples. Participation of physicians is often an issue when conducting NIRs. Lack of understanding of scientific value
of NIRs, compared to clinical trials, is often assumed to be the major reason for
reluctance to participate. Our objective was to better understand perception of, motivation to participate in and expectation from participation in NIRs by physicians.
13th Euro Abstracts
METHODS: A survey was conducted in France on representative samples of 196
psychiatrists, 221 cardiologists and 250 general practitioners. Demographic characteristics were used to check representativeness. Perception of NIRs’ scientific interest,
motivation criteria and expectations were assed and analyzed using descriptive statistics. RESULTS: >70% of physicians are convinced that NIRs are of scientific interest
and provide reliable information on drug utilization in real life conditions. However,
10–15% are not convinced, 10–20% don’t have any opinion. Motivation relates to
interest for scientific objective and studied disease (>90%), scientific rigour and credibility of partners (IRB review, scientific committee, sponsor) (>70%). NIRs requested
by Health Authorities are not incentive. Physicians appreciate contributing to improving knowledge about drugs (>80%). >70% consider NIRs a challenging opportunity
to compare their behaviour to their peers’. All (>90%) are interested in receiving
results. 49% and 89% think results should be available within 6 and 12 months
respectively. CONCLUSIONS: NIRs are recognized as a rigorous scientific tool by a
majority of physicians. Motivation to participate is based on all scientific components
of NIR. Results are expected in short term timeframe.
PHP90
THE EFFECT OF THE 2007 HOSPITAL REFORM ON THE NUMBER OF
PSYCHIATRIC BEDS IN HUNGARY
Oberfrank F1, Donka-Verebes É2, Boncz I3
1
Institute of Experimental Medicine (IEM)., Budapest, Hungary; 2Integra Consulting zRt.,
Budapest, Hungary, 3University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: The new act on developing of the Hungarian health care system—came
into effect on the 1st of April 2007 cut the number of hospital beds significantly in
Hungary and the National Institute of Psychiatry and Neurology (OPNI) was closed.
The aim of our paper is to analyze the effect of the 2007 Hungarian health care reform
on the number of psychiatric hospital beds. METHODS: Data were derived from the
nationwide administrative data set of the National Health Insurance Fund Administration (OEP), the only health care financing agency in Hungary. The number of both
acute and chronic care hospital beds was evaluated before and after 1st of April 2007.
RESULTS: The 2007 act on developing of the Hungarian health care system cut the
total number of acute care hospital beds by 15.631 (26 %) from 59.846 to 44.215
(from 59,2 to 43,7 beds per 10000 inhabitants) and increased the total number of
chronic care hospital beds by 7.069 (35 %) from 20.100 to 27.169. The number of
acute psychiatric beds was reduced from 3.644 beds to 2.750 (−894 or −24,5%
decrease). At the same time, the number of chronic care psychiatric beds was increased
from 4.898 beds to 5.091 (193 or +3,9% increase). Altogether, 701 psychiatric beds
were eliminated from the Hungarian health care system. CONCLUSIONS: Although
the total number of chronic care hospital beds was increased by 35 % within the
Hungarian health care reform in 2007, the Hungarian health care system lost 701
psychiatric care hospital beds without any reasonable consideration or explanation.
PHP91
REGIONAL DIFFERENCES IN NUMBER OF PSYCHIATRIC BEDS IN
HUNGARY FOLLOWING THE 2007 HEALTH CARE REFORM IN
HUNGARY
Oberfrank F1, Donka-Verebes É2, Boncz I3
1
Institute of Experimental Medicine (IEM), Budapest, Hungary; 2Integra Consulting zRt.,
Budapest, Hungary, 3University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: The new act on developing of the Hungarian health care system—came
into effect on the 1st of April 2007 cut the number of hospital beds significantly in
Hungary and the National Institute of Psychiatry and Neurology (OPNI) was closed.
The aim of our paper is to analyze the effect of 2007 Hungarian health care reform
on the number of psychiatric care hospital beds at regional level. METHODS: Data
were derived from the nationwide administrative data set of the National Health
Insurance Fund Administration (OEP), the only health care financing agency in
Hungary. We carefully review the formal legislation and informal background papers
related to this issue. The number of hospital beds was evaluated before and after 1st
of April 2007. RESULTS: We found significant regional differences in the number of
acute care psychiatric beds according to counties in Hungary. The number of acute
psychiatric hospital beds per 10,000 inhabitants was the highest in the following
counties: Békés 4.56; Szabolcs-Sz-B 4.18; Komárom-E 3.67; Budapest 3.56. The
number of acute psychiatric hospital beds per 10,000 inhabitants was the lowest in
the following counties: Zala 1.69; Somogy 1.50; Heves 1.48; J-N-Szolnok 1.36; Vas
1.13. CONCLUSIONS: Following the 2007 hospital bed reform in Hungary, there is
a 4 times differences in the number of acute care psychiatric beds among the Hungarian counties. We did not find any reasonable consideration or explanation behind that
fact.
PHP92
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF KNOWLEDGE TRANSLATION METHODS
1
2
3
Worbes-Cerezo M , Linertová R , Serrano-Aguilar P
1
CIBER de Epidemiología y Salud Pública (CIBERESP), Santa Cruz de Tenerife, Spain;
2
Fundación Canaria de Investigación y Salud (FUNCIS), Las Palmas de Gran Canaria, Spain;
3
Servicio Canario de la Salud, Santa Cruz de Tenerife, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Given the increased use of interventions of knowledge translation to
change clinical practice, it is necessary to evaluate their effectiveness and cost-effectiveness. In this systematic review we synthesized scientific evidence on the costeffectiveness of knowledge translation methods in health professionals. METHODS:
We searched studies in MEDLINE and EconLit databases up to March 2010. Com-
A421
plete economic evaluations based on clinical trials of knowledge translation in primary
and specialized health care were selected, if published in English, Spanish, German or
Italian. The primary outcome was the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio. Quality of
the economic evaluations was assessed by the check-list by Drummond et al. The
extracted information was presented in text and tables. RESULTS: Eighteen economic
evaluations met the inclusion criteria. The knowledge translation interventions were
aimed at different areas, like prescription, diagnostics, treatment, counselling and
clinical practice guidelines. Thirteen studies were cost-effectiveness analyses, and five
were cost-utility analyses. The effectiveness measures used in the cost-effectiveness
studies are mainly intermediate results, while the cost-utility studies use mainly the
QALYs (quality-adjusted life-years). The perspective mostly used was the one of health
care system. Training/education is the intervention most frequently assessed followed
by feedback, academic detailing, software support and distribution of educational
materials; eight studies combined two or more methods. Most of the interventions are
effective in knowledge translation, i.e. fulfil the function for which they have been
designed. CONCLUSIONS: Although the scientific evidence suggests that the knowledge translation interventions are effective, most of them are relatively costly, and
therefore less cost-effective. Those interventions that require less resources or can be
applied in different areas at low cost, should be developed and implemented.
PHP93
DOES THE PACKAGE DESIGN MATTER? THE INFLUENCE OF OTC
PACKAGE DESIGN ON PATIENTS’ DRUG KNOWLEDGE
Wilke T1, Neumann K2, Mueller S2, Loder T3
1
Institute for Pharmacoeconomics and Drug Logistics, University of Wismar, Wismar,
Germany; 2University of Wismar, Wismar, Germany; 3Pharmacy Lux 99, Hürth, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Objective of this study is to discover whether OTC package designs
differ in their ability to transfer drug safety related information to pharmacy customers. The research was intended to answer two questions: 1) how well (in terms of
speed and accuracy) do customers comprehend the relevant medical information on
packages? 2) do alternative package designs cause significantly different levels of
comprehension?. METHODS: Face-to-face interviews with 452 customers of 17
German pharmacies were conducted. In each of three sequential experiments (one
OTC brand per experiment), each of the participants was shown two packages of the
same brand (Paracetamol/Bisacodyl) and asked three drug-related questions per
package. Multivariate linear regression analysis was used to identify the factors
capable of explaining the accuracy of the answers (first outcome; quality) and the
speed with which the answers were made (second outcome; time). The different abilities of the three package designs to transfer information correctly and rapidly were
compared by descriptive statistics. The significance of the differences was tested by
Wilcoxon tests. RESULTS: Older people, those with physiological problems, people
not in a good mood, and those with a poor doctor-patient relationship, or a lack of
trust in medicines in general answered the questions with a significantly higher number
of mistakes and/or needed significantly longer to do so. When compared to two other
package designs, one of the tested designs proved itself to be superior in quality and
time. CONCLUSIONS: 1) There exist significant differences between patient groups
in their ability to comprehend medical information; specific patients do not understand
medical information on packages in a sufficient way. 2) The design of a medication
package can measurably influence the quality and speed of information transfer to
pharmacy customers. An optimized package design is a source of added value from a
drug safety point of view.
PHP94
IS IT COST-EFFECTIVE TO CHANGE THE BEHAVIOR OF HEALTH CARE
PROFESSIONALS?
Kusel J, Costello S, Haynes S, Brooks-Rooney C
Costello Medical Consulting Ltd., Cambridge, UK
BACKGROUND: Despite adequate literature on the effectiveness of behaviour change
strategies for physicians, there is little information on whether these strategies are
cost-effective. OBJECTIVES: To review the current literature on the cost-effectiveness
of behaviour change policies for health care professionals. METHODS: A search of
the MEDLINE database and of reference lists was performed up to May 2010.
RESULTS: Twelve economic evaluations, assessing sixteen interventions in total, were
identified. These were performed in either Europe or Australia. All but one evaluation
had a control group, which received either no intervention (5) or a standard, less
labour intensive intervention (7) (One evaluation had two phases and therefore two
control groups). The type of control group had no association with whether the
strategy was deemed cost-effective or not. Seven of the policies were deemed costeffective by the authors (remuneration, telemarketing, outreach, training sessions (3),
distance learning), six were deemed not (outreach (4), training session, courier delivery
of guidelines) and three reported increased benefits with increased costs but did not
conclude whether this was cost-effective (outreach (2), training session). Three studies
actually reported decreased costs with the test intervention over control, two of which
were due to decreased hospital referrals. Of those behaviour change policies not
deemed cost-effective, 50% had minimal or no increase in effect and the other 50%
had a very significant increase in costs. CONCLUSIONS: Not all strategies were found
to be cost-effective, which highlights the necessity of this type of analysis before major
behaviour change policies are implemented. Multiple studies found that there were
increased benefits with increased costs. With no defined threshold as to what makes
a behaviour change policy cost-effective, the discussion is open to debate as to whether
these benefits are worth the increased costs.
A422
PHP95
THE DOS AND DON’TS IN PAYER COMMUNICATION. A QUALITATIVE
RESEARCH ACROSS FIVE EUROPEAN COUNTRIES
Guhl AK1, Gbenedio T1, Vekaria R1, Shepelev J1, Kolominsky-Rabas P2
1
GfK HealthCare, London, UK; 2Centre for Health Technology Assessment (HTA) and
Public Health (IZPH), University of Erlangen-Nurnberg, Erlangen, Germany
OBJECTIVES: National authorities across Europe implement both controls and incentives to influence the supply and demand of pharmaceuticals and medical devices.
Today, greater emphasis is placed on increasing efficiency in the resources spent on
health care via tighter controls on pricing and reimbursement regulations. Companies
increasingly face the challenge to communicate their value propositions towards
payers adequately. We investigated in 5 European countries (D,F,UK,NL,I) if companies meet payers expectations and also asked for suggestions how companies could
improve. METHODS: A questionnaire was developed, validated and translated into
the local language. Some questions were specific to the national health care system.
In total 20 face—to- face interviews were conducted with decision makers at various
levels. All interviews were recorded. RESULTS: The expectations among payers across
Europe with regard to industry communication vary widely. The emphasis lies in the
presentation of scientific data with more focus on clinical rather than economic data.
Some of the interviewees revealed some poor examples and mistakes made by companies, others gave us insights into what an “ideal” communication platform with the
industry could look like on a national level. CONCLUSIONS: The results showed
that even in Europe there is a huge variety how to communicate with payers from an
industry perspective. Cultural and health care system specifics need to be taken into
account to develop successful payer communication strategies.
PHP96
SENSE OF COHERENCE—AS MEDIATING FACTOR IN REMAINING
EMPLOYED IN HEALTH CARE PROFESSION
Roznár J, Oláh A, Tóth Á, Betlehem J, Boncz I, Müller Á, Jeges S
University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: To prove the hypothesis that sense of coherence has a significant
mediating role in keeping career in health care. METHODS: Our database: students
in the programme of nursing (n = 203) versus randomly selected sample of students
studying in other programmes (n = 196); and health care professionals (n = 96) vs. a
randomly selected sample of people employed elsewhere but not in health care (n =
741). Anonym self-completed questionnaires were used: Antonovsky’s SOC scale validated on Hungarian sample; Hennenhofer’Heil’s vegetative lability test and a health
self-estimation scale. Used statistical methods: variance analysis and multinomial
logistic regression. RESULTS: According to the ANOVA and post hoc tests, global
sense of coherence of students studying in health care programmes was significantly
lower (p < 0,001) than that of those students studying in other programmes; the results
of health care professionals did not significantly differ from the control sample. The
highest SOC were scored by those health care professionals who were studying besides
working. According to the indicators of state of health the health self-estimation of
health care students was significantly lower than that of those participating in other
programmes (based on the post hoc t-tests, P < 0,05) however, between the two
samples of employees there was no significant difference. We have proved with multinominal logistic regression models that SOC and the state of health are mostly
influenced by physical activity. CONCLUSIONS: Our hypothesis has been confirmed
by the results. Relatively more health care students with a high SOC are employed in
the health care. This could be the explanation for the phenomenon that health care
students have lower SOC compared to those studying in other programmes but in
both groups of employees there is no difference concerning SOC. This proves the
importance of enhancement of SOC among health care students, which can be primarily achieved by augmenting physical activity.
PHP97
TRAINING OF PHARMACEUTICAL SALES REPRESENTATIVES IN
REGARD TO CHANGES IN HEALTH CARE POLICY IN GERMANY
Benkert D1, Saile C1, Schauer S1, Kossmann B1, Wasem J2, Aidelsburger P1
1
CAREM GmbH, Sauerlach, Germany; 2University of Duisburg-Essen, Essen, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Due to rapid changes in health policy in Germany there is a need for
actors in health care system for constant training about the system. Aim of the present
study is to assess different teaching methods using the example of training pharmaceutical sales representatives concerning effectiveness assessment as performed by
several institutions in Germany. METHODS: Two learning approaches are compared.
“Health Consultant (HC)” is a training program teaching pharmaceutical sales representatives in health policy topics using traditional training methods like talks and
discussions. Second approach is an e-learning program. Participants were interviewed
by questionnaires about their learning preferences. RESULTS: Evaluation of the HC
training program shows, that the traditional teaching method is well accepted. Learning success was confirmed by subjective valuation. Most participants report a demand
for a more flexible and individual learning approach that is compatible to their everyday work. E-learning programmes could meet these criteria. CONCLUSIONS: Further
studies are necessary to evaluate the learning success of both methods. Evaluation
instruments are already developed. The dimensions that should be included are motivation, workloads and structure of learning unit.
13th Euro Abstracts
PHP98
COST-EFFECTIVENESS METHODOLOGIES OF STRATEGIES THAT AIM
TO CHANGE THE BEHAVIOUR OF HEALTH CARE PROFESSIONALS
Kusel J, Costello S, Brooks-Rooney C, Hamer N
Costello Medical Consulting Ltd, Cambridge, UK
BACKGROUND: As the cost-effectiveness of strategies that aim to change the behaviour of physicians has not been widely studied, it is unclear whether a standard
methodology is being utilised for measuring cost-effectiveness in this situation.
OBJECTIVES: To review the current literature on the methodologies used in costeffectiveness evaluations of behaviour change policies for health care professionals.
METHODS: A search of the MEDLINE database and of reference lists was performed
up to May 2010. RESULTS: Twelve relevant evaluations, from ten publications, were
identified; two discussed costs and benefits separately and were therefore not classed
as true cost-effectiveness evaluations. Of the remaining ten, seven were based on
randomised controlled trials, two used a model without empirical data and one was
a prospective cohort study. Eight of the ten evaluations utilised health outcomes as
the main effectiveness measure, five of which used life-years (LY) or quality-adjusted
LYs gained. The ten cost-effectiveness evaluations measured: implementation cost per
LY or health outcome gained (6); total policy cost per LY gained (2); implementation
cost per percent change in prescribing (1) and percent change in health outcome per
pound (1). Nine took a health care provider perspective; one took a societal perspective that included patient expenditure. There was no agreement between the ten evaluations as to whether physician time should be included in the cost analysis or not (yes
(3), no (4), not stated (3)). Only two evaluations considered a time frame beyond 1
year and took into account that future implementations would be required to maintain
the behaviour change. Discounting of values was utilised by these evaluations (3%
per year), and by 1 other study (percent not stated). CONCLUSIONS: More robust
evaluations are required, with health outcomes assessed as LYs for comparison purposes. Future evaluations must consider timeframe, discounting, societal costs and
costs due to physician time.
PHP99
FIRST-IN-THERAPY PRODUCTS AND REQUIREMENTS FOR
SUCCESSFUL HTA ASSESSMENT
Xia AD, Oraro T
Heron Evidence Development Ltd., London, UK
OBJECTIVES: To determine the necessary requirements of a first-in-therapy product
to support positive HTA review. METHODS: An initial broad search was conducted
to identify first-in-therapy products launching in recent years into disease areas with
no alternative treatments. The products identified were eculizumab for paroxysmal
nocturnal hemoglobinuria (PNH), pregabalin for fibromyalgia, vigabatrin for infantile
spasms, tetrabenazine for tardive dyskinesia (TD) and chorea of Huntington’s disease,
pirfenidone for idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (IPF), and amifampridine for LambertEaton myasthenic syndrome (LEMS). These products were then examined within
NICE, SMC, NCPE, PBAC and CADTH websites, and information collated on clinical
endpoints, HTA comparators and assessment outcomes to provide an understanding
of the requirements of first-in-therapy products for positive review. RESULTS: Of the
drugs selected, 4 were assessed by HTA bodies. Due to a lack of alternative therapies,
all but one product assessed carried out trials against placebo. Clinical endpoints were
based either on metrics agreed upon by KOLs, quality of life measures, or both. Out
of the seven drugs studied, only vigabatrin received positive recommendation due to
strong trial data and inclusion of an active symptomatic comparator. a number of
first-in-therapy products were actually rejected by HTAs in select countries. Pregabalin
was rejected due to unconvincing trial data despite a favourable cost per QALY and
eculizumab was rejected due to too high an incremental cost per QALY. CONCLUSIONS: We can conclude that based on the products assessed, first-in-therapy products
do not typically receive special consideration when assessed by HTA bodies. An active
comparator, use of recognized endpoints and the quality of data remain as important
requirements for positive review. Furthermore, demonstrated cost-effectiveness is
required even in a novel disease area, thus, it will be necessary to evaluate this earlier
in development. More focused studies need to be carried out to ascertain this trend
on a country-by-country basis.
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Health Technology Assessment
Programs
PHP100
EVALUATION OF ACCEPTANCE AND REJECTION RATES OF ORPHAN
DRUGS ACROSS SIX HTA AGENCIES
Jäkel A1, Alnwick K2
1
Heron Evidence Development Ltd, Stopsley, UK; 2Heron Evidence Development Ltd,
London, UK
OBJECTIVES: Many orphan drugs receive market authorization, however an assessment of cost-effectiveness is usually required before these drugs can be reimbursed.
Recent research has explored the differences between HTA bodies in their rates of
acceptance/rejection of orphan drugs. The objective of this study was to consider the
relative weight of economic and clinical reasons for rejecting orphan drug submissions
to HTA agencies. METHODS: Six HTA websites (NICE, SMC, NCPE, CEDAC,
PBAC, AWMSG) were searched for summary guidance on 71 licensed orphan drugs
identified from a search of the Orphanet website. RESULTS: Of 53 total non-approved
13th Euro Abstracts
submissions, in 53% of cases a high ICER was reported in the summary of guidance
as a reason for rejection. In about 30% of these cases, the high drug cost was specified
as the driver of the high ICER. The lack of a robust economic case was mentioned in
45% of rejections. Limited evidence of clinical benefit was shown in 43% of cases.
Other reasons included inadequate type or quality of clinical data (21%) and nonacceptance of clinical positioning (11%). In 45% of cases the rejections were largely
due to economic reasons; 6% of cases were not accepted due primarily to clinical
reasons and in 49% of rejections the criticisms related to both the economic and
clinical evidence. Uncertainty in the evidence was reported as a problem in most negative recommendations. CONCLUSIONS: Only slightly over half of the orphan drug
HTA submissions to these agencies are explicitly rejected primarily on the basis of a
high ICER. Most HTA rejections are due to a combined lack of robust economic and
clinical evidence. This suggests that collecting the right kind of data and presenting a
solid case that accounts adequately for any uncertainty is at least as important as
meeting trial endpoints and choosing an optimal price.
PHP101
EVALUATION OF ACCEPTANCE AND REJECTION RATES OF ORPHAN
DRUGS ACROSS SIX HTA BODIES
Oraro T, Alnwick K
Heron Evidence Development Ltd., London, UK
OBJECTIVES: Orphan drugs (ODs) face numerous difficulties in demonstrating their
value through rigorous HTA processes. HTA bodies may therefore choose to take into
consideration the special circumstances of treatments for orphan indications, either
formally or informally. The objective of this study was to examine the decisions made
on ODs by six English-speaking HTA bodies, and assess potential trends between
agencies. METHODS: AWMSG, CEDAC, NCPE, NICE, PBAC and SMC HTA websites were searched for completed OD assessments (identified via Orphanet website)
as of April 2010, and data extracted on the recommendations. Recommendations with
restrictions were categorised as approvals. Comparisons were made to published
approval rates for drug submissions as a whole. RESULTS: Of the 71 ODs selected,
55 were assessed by at least one HTA body. The proportion of positive recommendations for orphan treatments was lower than published approval rates for general
(orphan and non-orphan) HTA drug submissions in most bodies. NICE approved
67% completed OD submissions, versus approximately 87% of drugs overall.
However, PBAC recommended 60% of ODs compared to 54% of drugs as a whole.
Decisions also varied substantially between agencies. CEDAC had the highest proportion of rejections (73%), compared to NICE, which rejected 33%. There was also
variation in decisions made on specific treatments. Sutent, for example, with an orphan
designation for renal cell carcinoma, was accepted by AWMSG, CEDAC and SMC,
while it received a negative recommendation from NCPE, NICE and PBAC. CONCLUSIONS: The willingness to assess ODs varies widely by agency and drug, as do
resultant approval rates. HTA agencies are far more likely to reject OD submissions
than non-orphan drugs as a whole. However given the differences in their remit to
assess ODs, direct comparisons should be interpreted with caution. Further research
is needed to explore the reasons behind these differences in HTA agency decisions.
PHP102
A SURVEY OF HTA RESEARCH METHODS AND TRENDS IN EUROPE
ISPOR HTA SIG Research Methods/Principles Working Group
ISPOR, Lawrenceville, NJ, USA
OBJECTIVES: To describe research methods and key issues in the HTA process in
Europe. METHODS: Representatives from HTA bodies globally were recruited by
members of the ISPOR HTA SIG Research Methods/Principles Working Group to
complete a 45-minute on-line survey consisting of 48 items within 4 topics related to
1) organizational information and process; 2) primary HTA methodologies and importance of attributes; 3) HTA application and dissemination; and 4) quality of HTA
including key issues. Data were reported for Europe. RESULTS: The survey was
completed by 11 European countries including Austria, Denmark, France, Germany,
Hungary, Italy, The Netherlands, Portugal, Spain, Sweden, and Switzerland. Top
reasons technologies were evaluated included perceived impact on patient outcomes,
potential cost, and prevalence of the condition. The most common methodologies used
were cost/economic analyses, systematic reviews & meta-analyses, clinical trials, modeling, and comparative analyses. The most important attributes (in order) were effectiveness, efficacy, safety, cost-effectiveness, and budget impact. While quality of life
was frequently assessed by >74% of European respondents, it was not listed as an
attribute of top importance. Only 24% repeat/update the assessment at regular intervals. For 82% a different organization makes the final decision on coverage, only
partially relying on the report. The most common educational background for decision
makers was physician-specialist. Stakeholders are allowed to review the report and
are involved in assessments >50% of the time, and in the final decisions ~35% of the
time. Key issues/trends included early assessment of technologies with mechanism for
conditional coverage, increasing regional interest in HTA, reassessment/horizon scanning, and link between theory and practice in HTA. CONCLUSIONS: This survey of
representatives within HTA and reimbursement bodies provides current insight into
the state of HTA research methods in Europe. Future research could expand the results
to specifically address Eastern European countries, Asia, and other emerging markets.
A423
PHP103
NICE GUIDANCE: AN ANALYSIS OF LEVELS OF RESTRICTION BY
DISEASE AREA
Mesa OA1, Venus A2, Lebmeier M1, Davis M1, Jones C1
1
Bristol-Myers Squibb Pharmaceuticals Ltd, Uxbridge, Middlesex, UK; 2Bristol-Myers Squibb
Pharmaceuticals Ltd, Princeton, NJ, USA
OBJECTIVES: To assess the outcomes of NICE’s guidance in totality and different
disease areas. METHODS: A list of NICE Guidance published between 2007 to the
end of 2009 was identified using HTAinSite™. We classified these recommendations
into; ‘recommended’, ‘restricted’ and ‘not recommended’, and calculated the percentages. We then analyzed these recommendations according to disease areas; ‘cardiovascular/metabolics’, ‘mental health’, ‘infectious diseases’, muscoskeletal conditions’,
‘oncology’, and ‘others’. RESULTS: In 2007, NICE assessed 25 drugs, 31 in 2008 and
18 in 2009. Of these, in 2007 NICE recommended 8 drugs (31%) for all eligible
patients, restricted 13 (53%), and did not recommend 4 (16%). In 2008, 3 (10%)
were recommended, 21 (68%) were restricted, and 7 (22%) were not recommended.
Finally, in 2009, 2 (11%) treatments were recommended, while 11 (61%) received
restricted recommendations and 5 (28%) were not recommended. Between 2007 and
2009 NICE completed 7 appraisals in ‘cardiovascular/metabolics’ of which 4 received
a full recommendation, while in ‘mental health’ 2 out of 2 were fully recommended.
In contrast, in ‘infectious diseases’, 1 out of 5 was fully recommended. In ‘muscoskeletal conditions’ only 1 out of 21 were recommended (17 restricted and 3 not recommended) while in ‘oncology’ only 1 out of 23 received a full recommendation (13
restricted, 9 not recommended). In the ‘others’ group, 4 out of 12 received a recommendation (6 restricted, 2 not recommended). If manufacturers had not proposed
Patient Access Schemes (PAS) the proportion of guidance not recommended in 2009
would be 44%. CONCLUSIONS: Appraisal outcomes have become more restrictive
over time. Furthermore, low cost primary care therapeutics are more likely to receive
a positive NICE recommendation than high cost speciality care interventions.
PHP104
DESIGNING EUROPEAN GUIDELINES FOR HEALTH OUTCOMES AND
COST-EFFECTIVENESS ASSESSMENTS: THE ECHOUTCOME EUROPEAN
COMMISSION PROJECT
Beresniak A1, Auray J2, Duru G3, Medina-Lara A4, Praet J5, Sambuc R6, Tarricone R4,
Torbica A4, De Wever A5, Lamure M7
1
Data Mining International, Geneva, Switzerland; 2Cyklad Group, Rilleux la Pape, France;
3
Cyklad Group, rilleux la Pape, France; 4Bocconi University, Milano, Italy; 5Université Libre de
Bruxelles, Brussels, Belgium; 6Université de la Mediterrannee, Marseille, France; 7University
Claude Bernard Lyon 1, Paris, France
OBJECTIVES: Over the last decade the National Institute of Clinical Excellence in
the UK has published guidelines for health technology assessments (HTA) that includes
recommendations on health outcomes and cost-effectiveness assessments. In Europe,
this has opened the opportunity for countries to either propose their own guidelines
or use the British ones. The ECHOUTCOME project is an interdisciplinary European
research platform funded by the seventh Framework Program of the European Commission with the aim of designing new European guidelines in Health Outcomes and
Cost-Effectiveness assessments. METHODS: This three years project is structured in
three phases. Phase 1 aims to conduct a pan-European survey of HTA organizations
and health outcomes use in the 27 European countries. Multiple correspondence and
cluster analyses will be carried out to study the potential similarities and divergences
across Europe. The objective of Phase 2 is to test the robustness and underlying
assumptions such as reproducibility, neutrality to risk, constancy of time-trade-off
rate, utility independence, etc. on QALYs, DALYs and HYEs measures. This testing
will be conducted in the general population (n = 300 per country) in Belgium, France,
Italy and UK. Phase 3 aims to propose new approaches in Health Outcomes and
Cost-Effectiveness analyses. RESULTS: The main deliverable of the ECHOUTCOME
project will be new European Guidelines for assessing Health Outcomes and conducting Cost-Effectiveness assessments. Of particular interest will be the recommendations
on the practical usefulness of QALYs, DALYs and HYEs based on the experimental
validation of their underlying assumptions. CONCLUSIONS: The ECHOUTCOME
project is the first European validation study of health outcomes measures. This work
will produce guidelines for public health decision-making in the 27 European
countries. The ECHOUTCOME outcomes will enhance the debate and increase the
understanding that will improve the knowledge of existing Health Outcomes
and Cost-Effectiveness techniques and will promote new approaches for
decision-making.
PHP105
HOW CAN THE USE OF PREDICTIVE BIOMARKERS LEAD TO POSITIVE
HTA RECOMMENDATIONS?
Trevor NC1, Alnwick K2
1
Heron Evidence Development Ltd, London, UK; 2Heron Evidence Development Ltd, Luton,
UK
OBJECTIVES: The popularity and availability of biomarkers has rapidly increased in
recent years, thanks to innovative advances in pharmacogenomics. Predictive biomarkers
have high potential value in HTA as they may increase the observed efficacy and costeffectiveness of treatments. This study reviews, in selected major markets worldwide,
the impact of currently available predictive biomarkers on HTA in the context of the
agency’s evidence requirements. METHODS: A broad review of biomarker tests used
in HTA submissions in Europe, Australia, Canada, and the US was conducted; the
A424
outcome of the HTA recorded and the impact of the biomarker test on the submission
outcome was graded as high, medium or low according to its influence on the final
decision. These findings were summarised, and 6 drugs were selected as case studies in
order to identify key lessons relating to the risks, consequences, and ethical considerations of Diagnostic/Treatment partnering. RESULTS: The review identified five biomarkers in the five treatment areas of: HIV, Gastrointestinal stromal tumour (GIST),
Non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC), Colorectal cancer (CRC), and Breast cancer.
Markers Her2 and K-RAS had a high impact in all included submissions, with 100%
and 63% of these submissions resulting in a positive recommendation. In contrast,
marker EGFR had a lower impact (not mentioned in 4 out of 10 submissions), with
60% of these submissions being approved, and 40% rejected. The agencies most likely
to reject a surrogate-outcome submission were PBAC (Australia) and SMC (Scotland)
with rejection rates of 57% and 66% respectively, whereas CADTH accepted 100% of
included submissions. CONCLUSIONS: Findings indicate firstly that substantially different evidence requirements exist between HTA bodies in the markets considered (e.g.
differing accuracy acceptability thresholds, prospective/retrospective analysis and the
importance of cost-effectiveness), and secondly there are several ethical considerations
to the selection or deselection of patients for treatment.
PHP106
HTAINSITE: A DATABASE OF NICE SUBMISSIONS AND DECISIONS
Howard S, Harper C, Poppe P
Abacus International, Bicester, Oxon, UK
OBJECTIVES: HTAinSite is an on-line, subscription-based database of all NICE
Technology Appraisals (TAs). It includes information relating to submitted evidence,
appraisal process and final decision and enables assessment of associated trends.
METHODS: An academic steering group designed and agreed the data extraction
protocol. a team of reviewers conducted the initial data extraction, which was validated by a second reviewer. Historical extraction is complete, with on-going TAs
extracted on a monthly basis. RESULTS: A total of 181 TAs have been extracted to
date, 5 of which were terminated, resulting in 176 complete TAs relating to 326 technologies. Of these, 53% were awarded a restricted decision, 32% were fully recommended and 16% rejected. Of the three most commonly appraised disease areas (cancer,
cardiovascular (CVS), central nervous system (CNS); CVS technologies were least commonly rejected by NICE (3% vs. 21% for cancer and 17% for CNS). Of the four most
commonly used assessment groups (Sheffield, York, Southampton and Birmingham);
technologies assessed by Sheffield were most commonly rejected (28%) and those by
York were least commonly rejected (4%). Technologies supported by a patient submission were less commonly rejected than those without (15% vs. 29%). a total of 35 TAs
(20%) resulted in an appeal, no appeals were upheld entirely, all appeals were upheld
partially. HTAinSite also allows detailed analysis of individual TAs and cross-comparison between TAs as well as identifying trends between submitted evidence (acquisition
costs, budget impact, cost-effectiveness and clinical effectiveness) and final outcome.
These additional analyses will be further explored in the poster and preliminary results
will also be updated. CONCLUSIONS: HTAinSite is a useful tool for anyone interested
in understanding the relationship between submitted evidence and ultimate NICE
decision. The HTAinSite format may be useful for other HTA bodies, depending on
the public availability of relevant information.
PHP107
ECONOMIC EVIDENCE REQUIREMENTS: COMPARISON BETWEEN HTA
AGENCIES AND IMPLICATIONS FOR MANUFACTURERS
Balvanyos J, Alnwick K, Proudfoot C
Heron Evidence Development Ltd., London, UK
OBJECTIVES: Mathematical models are required by decision makers to provide
insight into pharmcoeconomic benefits associated with a product. It is therefore
essential that manufacturers understand economic evidence requirements when submitting an application to a Health Technology Assessment (HTA) agency. METHODS:
A literature search of economic recommendations from the following HTA agencies
was conducted: CADTH (Canada), HAS (France), IQWiG (Germany), NICE
(England), PBAC (Australia), PHARMAC (New Zealand) and SMC (Scotland).
RESULTS: Cost-effectiveness analysis is considered the most relevant analytical technique across the English-speaking agencies with a preference for QALY-based analysis,
in contrast to IQWiG which does not consider QALYs and utilities as central to their
methods. Unlike other HTA agencies assessed, the French agency HAS does not currently require cost-effectiveness modelling in its decision-making process. EQ-5D is
the most commonly used utility instrument, NICE being the most prescriptive agency
in this regard. However, utilities mapped from disease-specific quality of life measures
may be accepted and agencies such as PBAC and IQWiG express no formal preference
between instruments. The third-party payer is the most commonly required perspective
adopted across the English-speaking agencies while IQWiG and PBAC recommend a
societal perspective in addition to the payer’s perspective. This trend towards a
broader, societal perspective may, however, be limited by uncertainties around measurement of wider costs. Sensitivity analyses are required by all agencies to explore
uncertainty in the model. NICE and CADTH both favor a probabilistic approach
while PBAC prefers univariate and multivariate analyses. Other agencies expect the
manufacturer to justify their approach and choice. CONCLUSIONS: The recommendations of IQWiG and PBAC differ from the other selected agencies. Uniquely, in
France the pharmaeconomic case is considered separately from the HTA process by
the French Health Economists Association. These differences between agencies should
be considered when planning evidence generation activities to support economic model
development.
13th Euro Abstracts
PHP108
CLINICAL EVIDENCE REQUIREMENTS: COMPARISON BETWEEN SEVEN
HTA AGENCIES AND IMPLICATIONS FOR DRUG MANUFACTURERS
Balvanyos J, Alnwick K, Proudfoot C
Heron Evidence Development Ltd., London, UK
OBJECTIVES: Health Technology Assessment (HTA) agencies require various types
and qualities of evidence for clinical effectiveness evaluations due to differences in
health care systems and policies. It is essential for manufacturers to understand these
requirements when submitting an application to each individual HTA agency.
METHODS: A literature search of clinical recommendations from the following HTA
agencies was conducted for comparison: CADTH (Canada), HAS (France), IQWiG
(Germany), NICE (England), PBAC (Australia), PHARMAC (New Zealand) and SMC
(Scotland). RESULTS: The choice of the optimal comparator is crucial to the outcome
of the HTA. Almost all agencies prefer comparison versus the most frequently used
interventions except for PBAC which requires comparison to the interventions most
likely to be displaced. All HTA agencies are cautious in their interpretation of surrogate outcomes (SO) and require manufacturers to provide evidence linking the SO
to final patient-relevant outcomes. PBAC has notably developed a framework for
assessing SOs and the impact of these on uncertainty in HTA submissions. Most
agencies except for NICE clearly state their position on the definition and the use of
SOs. All agencies recognize the value of observational studies in reflecting real-world
situations and providing long-term data although RCTs provide the key evidence on
comparative effectiveness. Systematic reviews (SR) of clinical evidence are essential to
present comparative effectiveness relative to all comparators. Contrary to most agencies, HAS prefers SRs but does not require them and bases its assessments mainly on
pivotal clinical trials provided by the manufacturer. NICE and IQWiG also differ from
the other agencies as they perform in-house SR in addition to the manufacturer’s.
CONCLUSIONS: The differences between agency requirements are subtle and mean
that manufacturers need to put together a solid clinical evidence package needing very
little adaptation to meet the seven country requirements.
PHP109
RELATIVE EFFECTIVENESS ASSESSMENT OF PHARMACEUTICALS
Kleijnen S1, George E2, Goettsch W1, d’Andon A3, Osi ska B4, Corbacho B5
1
College voor Zorgverzekeringen, Diemen, The Netherlands; 2National Institute for Health
and Clinical Excellence, London, UK; 3Haute Autorité de Santé, Saint-Denis La Plaine Cedex,
France; 4Agency of Health Technology Assessment in Poland, Warsaw, Poland; 5Andalusian
Agency for Health Technology Assessment, Seville, Spain
OBJECTIVES: The EUnetHTA Joint Action (2010–2012) is a joint initiative by EU
Member States and the European Commission to advance European collaboration on
health technology assessment (HTA). Part of the EUnetHTA Joint Action aims at
reviewing methods used for the relative effectiveness assessment (REA) of pharmaceuticals and to develop, apply and field-test tools and methods. As a first step towards
this goal, objectives, processes and methodologies used for REA by HTA organizations
across Europe and other countries are summarised. This overview is crucial for the
development of shared or common methodologies to be used in future REA across
Europe. METHODS: Data were captured with a standardised data abstraction form.
Data were initially abstracted from different types of literature (peer reviewed, grey
literature, EU and national reports etc.). Where there were gaps in the data, telephone
interviews were arranged with a relevant person at the respective HTA or reimbursement agency. RESULTS: Most European countries carry out some form of REA,
however the definitions of the assessments in general are not consistent with the definition by the Pharmaceutical Forum. In addition the scope (inclusions of benefit-risk
analysis and/or a cost-effectiveness analysis), the process (timing, involvement of
stakeholders and separation of assessment and appraisal phase) and the purpose
(inform clinical decision-making, reimbursement and/or for pricing decision-making)
of the assessments vary as well as the methods (such as inclusion of surrogate endpoints, composite endpoints and quality of life data and extrapolation of efficacy
data). Most agencies publish a guideline for the methodology used for REA however
few publish them in English. CONCLUSIONS: A considerable number of European
countries carry out REAs. However, the purpose and the methodology used vary
across Europe. The reasons behind these differences need to be considered in the
development of a common European methodology for REA.
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Population Health
PHP110
PHYSICIANS’ VIEWS OF THE RELATIVE IMPORTANCE OF SELECTED
MEDICAL INNOVATIONS ON THE GREEK POPULATION HEALTH
STATUS
Athanasakis K, Karampli E, Kyriopoulos J
National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece
OBJECTIVES: To identify the pharmaceutical and medical innovations that contributed
mostly to the improvement of Greek population health status during the last three
decades, according to physicians’ views. METHODS: Building on the methodology by
Fuchs and Sox, a questionnaire based survey was conducted on a representative sample
of 500 Greek internists and general practitioners aged ≥50 years old. The study questionnaire was formulated by a panel of experts, with the use of the Delphi method and
included one list of 22 pharmaceutical and a second list of 20 medical innovations.
Physicians were asked to identify the seven more important and seven least important
13th Euro Abstracts
innovations, with regard to their impact on patients’ health status. RESULTS: Response
rate was 78%. The seven most important pharmaceutical innovations reported were
Angiotensin Converting Enzyme (ACE) inhibitors and angiotensin II antagonists, inhaled
steroids and β2-agonists, statins, proton pump inhibitors and H2-antagonists, novel
antibiotics, antiviral drugs for hepatitis and C and calcium channel blockers. The seven
most important technological innovations were: magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and
computed tomography scanning (CT), balloon angioplasty with stents, Coronary Artery
Bypass Graft (CABG), gastrointestinal endoscopy, Human Immunodeficiency Virus
testing, mammography and Prostate-Specific Antigen (PSA) testing. In both cases, innovations that ranked higher were used to treat high-prevalence diseases with a significant
contribution on the burden of disease for the Greek population. In addition, innovations
that contributed to improvements in disease diagnoses and management were also
ranked higher. CONCLUSIONS: the epidemiological profile of the population, the
effectiveness of each innovation in terms of clinical effectiveness as well as health-related
quality of life, and the utility of the innovation in everyday clinical practice constitute
important determinants of the physicians’ opinions regarding the relative importance of
medical innovations on the health status of the Greek population.
PHP111
PREDICTING PREVENTIVE CARE SERVICE UTILIZATION IN A UNITED
STATES POPULATION
Partha G1, Vaidya V1, Howe J2, Ferrell M1
1
University of Toledo, Toledo, OH, USA; 2The University of Toledo, Toledo, OH, USA
OBJECTIVES: To analyze and predict trends in utilization of preventive care services
in a United States population using a national database. Several national reports and
evidence in literature indicate disparities in the utilization of preventive care services
but only few have predicted utilization patterns of preventive care services. METHODS:
The 2007 Medical Expenditure Panel Survey (MEPS), a national probability sample
survey of the ambulatory civilian US population, was analyzed to determine demographic patterns of utilization. Utilization of blood pressure screening, cancer screening (mammography, colonoscopy/sigmoidoscopy, pap smear and breast), cholesterol
and dental checkup and flu vaccination were used as the dependent variables while
age, gender, race/ ethnicity, annual income insurance status and perceived health status
were used as independent variables. Descriptive statistics were used to describe the
population; univariate chi-squared analysis was used to determine group differences
for the categorical variables. Multivariate logistic regression model was built to predict
odds of utilization of services. All analyses were carried out using SAS v9.1. RESULTS:
Utilization of preventive care services was found to be high for blood pressure (n =
17,959, 89.0%) and cholesterol (n = 14,956, 94.7%) checkup and low for flu vaccination (n = 30,964, 21.2%). Significant chi square differences in utilization of preventive
care services were found for most of the dependent variables (P < 0.001), save for
colonoscopy/sigmoidoscopy screening. Regression model showed that young women
(20–30 years) with higher income were more likely to obtain breast exams (OR =
10.584; CI = 4.312–25.980) compared with young women earning lower income
(<$20,000). Odds of utilization were nearly similar for all races. However, Hispanics
were more likely to obtain a colonoscopy/sigmoidoscopy (OR = 3.069; CI = 2.216–
4.250) compared with non-Hispanics. The uninsured generally had lower odds of
utilization across almost all preventive care services. CONCLUSIONS: This study was
successful in identifying age, race, income and insurance status-related disparities and
in predicting preventive care service utilization in a US population.
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Prescribing Behavior &
Treatment Guidelines
PHP112
ANALYSIS OF PHARMACISTS’ INTERVENTIONS OF ELECTRONIC
PRESCRIPTIONS AT SULTAN QABOOS UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL IN
OMAN
Al-Rashdi IS, Victoria M, Susan S, Al-Zakwani IS
Sultan Qaboos University, Al-Khoudh, Oman
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the number and types of pharmacists’ interventions of
electronic prescriptions at Sultan Qaboos University (SQU) hospital in Oman.
METHODS: This was a prospective study where interventions on electronic prescriptions over one-year (2009) at SQU hospital were evaluated. a standard data collection
form was used to capture the data related to drug choice and drug regimen. Clinical
relevance was defined as to whether efficacy or toxicity was either improved or
reduced. Clinical relevance was based on the judgments of at least two pharmacists.
Analyses were performed using descriptive statistics. RESULTS: A total of 1,123
interventions were recorded out of 186,353 prescriptions (intervention rate/prescription = 0.6%) and 454,654 items (intervention rate/item = 0.25%) dispensed. During
the year, only 3% of the interventions were administrative (absence of doctor’s signature/wrong patient’s card) while 97% were clinical. The clinical interventions were
categorized into drug regimen (n = 886; 74%) and drug choice (n = 313; 26%). Almost
62% (n = 547) of the problems associated with drug regimen were related to wrong
doses. The three most common drug choice issues included wrong formulations (n =
107; 34%), wrong drug (n = 62; 20%) and deletion (n = 62; 20%). Efficacy improved
in 52% (n = 588) of the cases, avoided toxicity in 29% (n = 324) and avoided unnecessary exposure in 19% (n = 211). Interventions prevented organ damage in 1.7% (n =
20) of the cases, major in 17% (n = 188), moderate in 49% (n = 550) and minor in
32% (n = 364). The mean time (±SD) spent per prescription was 11 ± 9 minutes.
A425
CONCLUSIONS: The data show that out-patient pharmacists play an important role
in drug safety and optimization of pharmaceutical care.
PHP113
LEVELS OF MEDICATION USE AMONG GERIATRIC PATIENTS IN
ACUTE GERIATRIC CARE SETTINGS IN AUSTRIA
Koenig C1, Tschapeller B2, Perner P2, Pils K3, Sommeregger U4, Fruehwald T5, Dovjak P6,
Pinter G7, Boehmer F3, Huf J3, Siber H3, Scala M8, Stoiser E8, Kleindienst R9, Hartweger A10,
Haid M11, Krippl P12, Hohl V13, Wehrmann A14, Reisinger W15, Reif-Gintl T16, Mueller W17,
Gaugeler R18, Macho A19, Habacher W1, Beck P1, Mrak P20
1
Joanneum Research, Graz, Austria; 2JOANNEUM RESEARCH, Graz, Styria, Austria; 3SMZ
Sophienspital, Vienna, Austria; 4KH Hietzing mit NZ Rosenhügel, Vienna, Austria; 5KH—
Hietzing mit NZ Rosenhügel, Vienna, Austria; 6LKH Gmunden, Gmunden, Austria; 7LKH
Klagenfurt, Klagenfurt, Austria; 8Albert Schweitzer Klinik, Graz, Austria; 9LKH Laas,
Koetschach, Austria; 10LKH Rottenmann, Rottenmann, Austria; 11Marienkrankenhaus Vorau,
Vorau, Austria; 12LKH Fuerstenfeld, Fuerstenfeld, Austria; 13LKH Voitsberg, Voitsberg, Austria;
14
KH Goettlicher Heiland, Vienna, Austria; 15Herz-Jesu-Krankenhaus, Vienna, Austria; 16KH
Barmherzige Brueder, Vienna, Austria; 17KH der Elisabethinen, Klagenfurt, Austria;
18
Oeffentliches KH Waiern/Feldkirchen, Feldkirchen, Austria; 19Hartmannspital, Vienna,
Austria; 20LKH Hoergas, Gratwein, Austria
OBJECTIVES: Adequate levels of medication are critical among elderly patients given
the existence of co-morbidities and impaired levels of functioning. Using patient data
collected via a web-based information system, we investigated the average number of
items prescribed to geriatric patients treated in Acute Geriatric and Remobilisation
Units (AG/R) in Austria between January 2008 and December 2009. We investigated
the association of age with medication levels and assessed whether treatment in an
AG/R led to changes in levels of medication. METHODS: The standardised data set
developed by QiGG was made available by AG/Rs using the geriatric module of the
online information system “Healthgate BARS”. We assessed patients’ medication data
including number of prescribed items at admission and discharge. Baseline characteristics (including age) were assessed. Additionally, changes in medication prescriptions
during the stay were documented. RESULTS: Data from 14,923 stays were analyzed.
Patients were prescribed a mean of 8.4 agents (±3.6) at admission which was significantly reduced to a mean of 8.0 (±3.35) at discharge after a mean length of stay of
18.9 (±14.1) days. a reduction in levels of medication was observed among all age
groups (young-old: −74, middle-old: 75–84, oldest-old: 85+).The oldest old had the
lowest mean number of prescriptions at both admission (8.1 ± 3.4) and discharge (7.6
± 3.1). There was an overall increase in documented changes to prescriptions (either
in number or type of medications) during this period from 61.1% to 80.1%. CONCLUSIONS: The observed reductions in levels of medication across all analyzed
groups during (in-patient) stays in AG/Rs, as well as the documented changes in
prescriptions, may suggest increased awareness both of over-prescription and the
necessity of adequate medication levels in special geriatric care.
PHP114
DERIVING DOCTORS’ PRESCRIBING PATTERNS FROM HEALTH CARE
CLAIMS: AN INSTRUMENTAL VARIABLE ANALYSIS
Baser O1, Wang L2, Xie L2, Dysinger A2, Gust C2, Yuce H3, Baser E2
1
STATinMED Research/University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA; 2STATinMED Research,
Ann Arbor, MI, USA; 3New York City College of Technology-CUNY/STATinMED Research,
New York, NY, USA
OBJECTIVES: Both observed and unobserved bias in observational claims data are
controlled with instrumental variable approach. However, it is difficult to find a valid
instrument that is strongly correlated with treatment choice but not directly correlated
with outcomes. In this paper, we derived doctors’ prescribing patterns from the claims
data and examined their validity. METHODS: Based on U.S. claims data, we assigned
patients a unique doctor based on the greatest number of office visits during the 6
months pre-index period. For each physician, and for each 6-month calendar block
of time, we estimated the physician preference as the time-varying proportion of
patients treated with selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) and serotonin–
norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors (SNRIs) during that interval. We applied Shea’s
partial R-square method, the Anderson canonical correlation, and Cragg-Donald tests
to check if doctors’ prescribing patterns were weak instruments. RESULTS: Tests
showed that doctors’ prescribing patterns are a valid and strong instrument for outcomes research studies. We showed that patients were more likely to be prescribed
generic SSRIs relative to non-generic SSRIs if doctors’ prescribing patterns favored
generic prescription (p = 0.000). Similarly, patients were less likely to be in the SSRIs
group if doctors’ prescribing patterns favored SNRI prescriptions (p = 0.000). We
showed that the treatment coefficient on the adherence model that does not control
for the unobserved bias was 10% lower than the one that uses the instrumental variable method. CONCLUSIONS: Doctors’ prescribing patterns are important factors
for prescription decisions. Any outcomes research models such as compliance, adherence or treatment effect studies should incorporate these patterns. Models that fail to
control for these variables might contain omitted variable bias.
PHP115
THE INCORPORATION OF ECONOMIC EVIDENCE IN THE DUTCH
CLINICAL PRACTICE GUIDELINES
Tan SS, Hakkaart-van Roijen L
Erasmus Universiteit Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: Because economic evaluations aim to decrease practice variations and
advocate (cost)-effective interventions, their use in the formulation of practice
A426
guidelines for prevention and treatment has gained attention in many developed
countries. The objective of our study was to investigate to what extent clinical practice
guidelines consider cost-effectiveness and budget impact according to the most recent
economic evidence. METHODS: We carried out systematic literature reviews of economic evaluations on the five most important medications by means of expenditures
in the The Netherlands in 2007 (cholesterol-lowering drugs, antihypertensives, proton
pump inhibitors, long-acting bronchodilators/ inhaled corticosteroids and antidepressants). Consequently, we compared the economic evidence to the recommendations
of the relevant clinical practice guidelines. RESULTS: Eleven clinical practice guidelines were determined to be relevant for the medications under consideration.
Although the recommendations of each of these guidelines are largely in agreement
with the most recent economic evidence, 9/11 guidelines hardly considered the costeffectiveness of medications. The guidelines ‘Cardiovascular Risk Management’
(2006) and ‘Anxiety Disorders’ (2003) systematically regarded cost-effectiveness, but
their recommendations are not based on the most recent economic evidence. Only the
guideline ‘Cardiovascular Risk Management’ (2006) considered budget impact to take
accessibility and affordability constraints into account when considering cost-effectiveness. CONCLUSIONS: Limited or no attention to economic evidence does not
necessarily lead to ‘wrong’ recommendations. However, the consideration of costeffectiveness and budget impact in clinical practice guideline development is needed
to increase clinician compliance, which in turn could ensure accessibility, affordability
and quality of care in national health care systems. Furthermore, their consideration
could harmonise national guidelines with reimbursement decisions. Engaging an economic expert in the guideline development process could contribute to the integration
of the most recent economic evidence in clinical practice guidelines.
PHP116
ANALYSIS OF ANTICOAGULATION BRIDGING THERAPY IN
ORTHOPEDIC PATIENTS: REAL WORLD ANALYSIS
Baser O1, Wang L2, Dysinger A2
1
STATinMED Research/University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA; 2STATinMED Research,
Ann Arbor, MI, USA
OBJECTIVES: We assessed the real-world anticoagulation thromboprophylaxis patterns in patients undergoing major orthopedic surgery. METHODS: A retrospective
study (January 1, 2005–December 31, 2007) was conducted using a large hospital
database linked with outpatient claims. Patients’ demographics, and clinical and
provider characteristics were compared using Chi-square testing and standardized
differences. Risk-adjusted event rates were estimated using the Poisson regression
model. RESULTS: The linked database is comprised of 2280 enrollees, of whom 1769
met the eligibility criteria. A total of 1552 patients received anticoagulant venous
thromboembolism (VTE) prophylaxis; 264 of these patients received a combination
of low molecular-weight heparin and warfarin. Of these patients, 105 (40%) were
switched between the two monotherapies, whereas 159 (60%) received bridge (overlapping) prophylaxis. VTE and major bleeding events were significantly lower for
bridged patients. However, duration of bridging varied widely. CONCLUSIONS:
Although there is a benefit with longer duration of therapy, duration of anticoagulation bridging therapy varies widely and does not appear to be consistent with published guidelines.
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Quality of Care
PHP117
EMERGENCY NURSES AND PHYSICAL EXAMINATIONS—WHOSE
DUTY?
Fuller N, Marton-Simora J, Betlehem J, Oláh A, Boncz I, Nagy G
University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: In the Hungarian emergency departments (EDs) it became necessary
to hire nurses with wider competencies but there is no a nationally unified policy and
training for them. Our aim was to determine the knowledge about the physical
examinations of nurses working at EDs with the different scope of practices (triage
nurses, departmental heads of nurses, general nurses). METHODS: Twenty-three
Hungarian emergency departments was examined, a questionnaire was completed by
the departments’ nurses (n = 301) and physicians (n = 159). SPSS 16.0 software was
used for statistical analysis, khi-square test was used to determine correlations.
RESULTS: A total of 71.5% of nurses have learned in some way the physical examinations wich did not present significant difference between the groups determined by
nurses’ scope of practice (p = 0,228). Triage nurses and the departmental heads of
nurses examine significantly more times for example the cardiovascular system (P <
0.001) and touch the stomach (p = 0.032) than departments’ general nurses. Emergency physicians would make the nurses done more diagnostical duties than they
presently do in everyday practice for example examining the cardiovascular system (P
< 0.001) and the chest (p = 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Even majority of emergency
nurses have learned in some way the physical examinations, they admitted a low rate
of usage in the everyday practice. In contrary, physicians would place the physical
examinations among the tasks of nurses possessing adequate qualification, thus extension of the competencies of nurses is necessary.
13th Euro Abstracts
PHP118
PERCEPTION OF PHARMACISTS SALES REPRESENTATIVES BY
PHYSICIANS
Jocic DD1, Krajnovic DM2, ZIvanovic DM3, Kernican LA2
1
Pharmacy “Kumodraz II”, Belgrade, Serbia; 2Faculty of Pharmacy, Belgrade, Serbia; 3Institution
of Health Care Facilities for Serbian Railway Workers, Belgrade, Serbia
OBJECTIVES: Pharmacists as sales representatives influence on prescribing physicians. This research is focused on their characteristics valued by physicians to improve
their communication and the effectiveness of cooperation. METHODS: The sample
includes 203 physicians from Central Serbia: 78 general practitioners, 125 specialists,
72 males and 131 females. It was used the scale of attitudes on pharmacists sale
representatives regarding the provision of drug information. The instrument includes
20 items and the five-point Likert type scale. RESULTS: The results show correlations
between the following variables: the impression of responsible pharmacist when visiting physicians is in a positive correlation with proper terminology used by pharmacist
(r = 0.650, p < 0.01), the argued presentation of preparations (r = 0.652, p < 0.01),
the systematic exposure of drug materials (r = 0.626, p < 0.01), concise information
(r = 0.583, p < 0.01), and visual eye contact during presentation (r = 0.648, p < 0.01);
the impression of incompetence was positively correlated to fearful pharmacist performance (r = 0.654, p < 0.01) and uncertainty in an interaction with physicians (r =
0.792, p < 0.01), and negatively correlated to an argued information on preparation
(r = −0.523, p < 0.01). CONCLUSIONS: The results show a correlation between
pharmacists’ characteristics as sales representatives observed by physicians. Pharmacists as sales representatives proved competence and responsability only in assertive
communication, as well as in concise and argued presentation with a live visual eye
contact as essential for nonverbal communication.
PHP119
ROLE OF QUALITY IMPROVEMENT FOR MANAGEMENT OF SURGICAL
BLEED COMPLICATIONS (SBCS)
Mohandas A1, Foley K2, Rupnow MF3, Nash D4, Doria C1
1
Thomas Jefferson University, Philadelphia, PA, USA; 2Thomas Jefferson University,
Newtown, PA, USA; 3Ethicon, Inc, Somerville, NJ, USA; 4Jefferson School of Population
Health, Philadelphia, PA, USA
OBJECTIVES: Many different methods exist for managing surgical bleeding complications (SBCs) and reducing transfusions during procedures. The techniques utilized are
dependent on institutional policies, resulting in highly variable clinical and economic
outcomes between different institutions. Our objective was to review the current literature on the quality and costs of SBC interventions to prevent and manage transfusions during surgeries and provide recommendations on future directions for quality
improvement of SBCs. METHODS: A comprehensive review was conducted using
Ovid, Pubmed and Scopus databases with the following keywords: quality improvement (QI), blood loss, transfusion, hemostasis and costs. Inclusion criteria included
English language, publication between 1999 and 2010, and studies where the key
words were the primary endpoints. a total of 1331 abstracts were reviewed. RESULTS:
A variety of blood loss prevention techniques were identified including autologous
transfusion, pharmacological and non-pharmacological interventions. Studies suggest
that bleed prevention (BP) algorithms incorporating a combination of interventions in
the pre, peri and post-operative periods have the greatest potential to minimize transfusions. Most studies assessing the economic impact of BP interventions did not
include the cost of staff time, other resources beyond blood acquisition cost and longer
term complications. The exclusion of these components may underestimate the actual
costs of transfusions and may have implications in assessing true cost-effectiveness of
BP interventions. Consensus exists that transfusions can and should be prevented
during surgery, yet there’s a lack of agreement on the optimal use of interventions for
blood loss management. CONCLUSIONS: Wide agreement on the necessity of avoiding transfusion exists, yet proven methods for minimizing SBCs are underused. Multifaceted algorithms for minimizing SBCs show promising results where they have been
used. Future QI projects should focus on reducing variation in practices through the
development of evidence based standards and guidelines for the effective use of BP
interventions.
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Regulation of Health Care
Sector
PHP120
DESCRIPTION AND EVALUATION OF THE KNOWLEDGE OF THE
BRASILIA POPULATION FOR THE POLITICS OF ECONOMIC MEDICINE
REGULATION IN BRAZIL
Araújo MAM, Rebelo FM, Alaver RT, Freitas PDC
ANVISA, Brasilia, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: The primary objective was to evaluate the knowledge of the drugstore
consumers from the Pilot Plan Plano Piloto and workers of ANVISA, for the regulation
of prices of medicines. The specific objectives were to assess the knowledge of the
populations on PMC, different price of generic medicines, estimate monthly expenses
of the two samples and a preliminary comparative analysis between the two samples.
METHODS: The study developed is a cross descriptive and analytical study. Based in
the application of different questionnaires for to assess the knowledge about regulation
of prices of medicines and consumption habits of consumers interviewed in the door
of the drugstore and workers of ANVISA. The research was conducted by sampling
13th Euro Abstracts
according to the location of the drugstore and in accordance with the area of capacity
in the workers of ANVISA. RESULTS: There were interviewed 105 consumers in
drugstores and 140 workers of ANVISA. When asked about the existence of market
regulation of drugs, 51.43% and 87.14% of drug users and employees of ANVISA,
respectively, said there is regulation of these products. About the PMC, the knowledge
was 20.00% of respondents in pharmacies and 57.86% of the employees of ANVISA.
Despite of the relative knowledge of PMC, only 01 of the respondents knew where
consumers search the PMC, and the employees of ANVISA, 29 knew the sources of
research. Although the poor knowledge on the regulation of prices, 84.76% of consumers interviewed considered this activity exerted by the government as important.
CONCLUSIONS: Although the population consider important that the prices of
medicines are regulated by the government, the knowledge of the regulation is small,
even on the tools of consumer protection.
PHP121
INSPECTION OF THE PHARMACEUTICAL COMPANIES IN IRAN BY
INSPECTION SOFTWARE
Radmanesh R1, Nikfar S2
1
Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Faculty of Pharmacy, Tehran, Iran; 2Tehran University
of Medical Sciences, Faculty of Pharmacy and Food & Drug Laboratory Research Center,
Iran MOH, Tehran, Iran
OBJECTIVES: This study was investigating of costs and consequences of two manual
and computerized systems for management of information during 2008–2009 for
inspection of pharmaceutical industries in Iranian Drug Regulatory Affairs.
METHODS: To compute costs of processes following items had been considered: Cost
of filling and archiving, data collecting (person-hour), reporting (person-hour), transport, software, hardware (main server computer, pocket computer), stationeries. To
evaluate the efficacy following outputs and outcomes was considered: Time of information recovering, ability of ranking, preventing of data missing, capacity building
and tracking and monitoring. RESULTS: The cost of running the new system is 35,000
US Dollars. Cost of education in new method and conventional are 5000 and 1000
US Dollars respectively. Cost of inspection in computerized management of information system (MIS) is decreased to 250 US Dollars from 600 US Dollars for each
inspection process. Alongside capacity of system is increased by arming to fast processing method, time of information recovering diminished to 1 working day instead of
3 days, preventing of data missing from 80% to 95% in new one, tracking and monitoring took 7 working days to applied, but new MIS changed that to 1 working day.
Ranking of pharmaceutical industries is now available for Iranian Drug Regulatory
Affairs after establishment of new inspection system by computer-based MIS. CONCLUSIONS: It seems that beside overhead cost of new computerized system that is
more than conventional method; considering capacity building; due to decreasing the
cost of inspection and increasing of outputs and outcomes indicators, the new system
is more efficient.
PHP122
COMPETITIVENESS OF HUNGARY IN INTERNATIONAL CLINICAL
TRIALS
Kalo Z1, Kovacs G2, Nagyjanosi L2, Nagyistok S2
1
Eötvös Loránd University, Budapest, Hungary, 2Syreon Research Institute, Budapest, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: Patients, health service providers, payers and the society also gain from
intensive clinical trial participation, however the majority of benefits are intangible.
According to a recent survey Hungary generates 0.15% of the GDP from clinical trials
and related activities, therefore the economic importance of this area is acknowledged
by the Hungarian government. The clinical trial activity is traditionally strong in the
country, however the growth rate of clinical trials is lower than in other CentralEastern European countries. Our objective was to explore how Hungary can improve
its competitiveness in attracting clinical trials. METHODS: We conducted a literature
review, searched for publicly available documents and interviewed key stakeholders
in Hungary to explore potential fields for intervention. RESULTS: We identified seven
key target areas for intervention to improve the competitiveness of Hungary in clinical
trials: the simplification of legal framework for clinical trial related activities, development of infrastructure at main potential sites, organizational development with special
focus on SMOs, the simplification of rules and processes for financing clinical trials,
investment into developing databases to support the set-up of clinical trials, and finally
the marketing promotion of Hungary and its sites to sponsors of clinical trials. CONCLUSIONS: The area of international clinical trials is a very competitive market.
Hungary can strengthen its market position, if legislators, competent authorities and
management teams of investigational sites—by acknowledging the professional and
financial benefits of these studies—support the successful implementation of clinical
trials in coordinated actions.
PHP123
PHARMACY NETWORK DEVELOPMENT DURING ECONOMIC
TRANSITION IN POLAND
Tuszyska M, Hermanowski TR, Feliksiak H
Medical University of Warsaw, Warsaw, Poland
OBJECTIVES: To analyze the effects of liberalization of regulations, concerning
establishment of pharmacies and pharmacy points in Poland after 1989. METHODS:
The data on the number of pharmacies and pharmacy points, used for the analysis were
collected by mail survey completed by all regional pharmaceutical supervision authorities. Population data were sourced from the statistical yearbook of Poland. RESULTS:
A427
During economic transition Poland was one of few European Union countries, where
the number of pharmacies was not regulated within a given area. Therefore, their
numbers increased rapidly, reaching 12.153 private pharmacies and 1.397 private
pharmacy points in 2009. This means that in 2009 one pharmacy served 3.127 people.
Before privatization process started in 1989, all retail pharmacies were managed by a
state-owned enterprise “Cefarm”. Since then, the regulations have changed and the
number of pharmacies started to grow. The main reasons of this trend was a regulation
stipulating that permission to establish a pharmacy can be granted to any private or
legal person, disregarding professional education of that person. Pharmacy owner was
only required to employ a qualified pharmacist, responsible for managing the pharmacy. Another major institutional change was introduced by the Pharmaceutical Law,
voted October 10, 1991, which authorized establishment of pharmacy points. In spite
of the general trend, in some poor provinces of Poland the number of pharmacies
decreased. June 1, 2010, European Court of Justice ruled that the right to own and
operate a pharmacy may be reserved exclusively for pharmacists and that demographic
or geographic criteria may be used in the process of issuing permits to operate pharmacies. CONCLUSIONS: Currently, the Polish Ministry of Health has to propose
amendments to the Pharmaceutical Law, implementing the above mentioned
criteria.
PHP124
DESCRIPTION OF THE PRICING AND REIMBURSEMENT SYSTEM IN THE
CZECH REPUBLIC
Petrikova A1, Dolezal T2, Lamka J3, Klimes J4
1
VFU Brno, Brno, Czech Republic; 2Institute for Health Economics and Technology
Assessment, Prague, Czech Republic; 3Charles University, Prague, Czech Republic; 4Charles
University, Hradec Kralove, Czech Republic
OBJECTIVES: To investigate changes realized in the Czech pricing and reimbursement
system since January 2008 and to describe the current development of this system.
METHODS: We described the legal framework defining the Czech system (Act No.
48/1997 Coll. as amended by the Act No. 261/2007 Coll. on Public Health Insurance)
as well as evaluation of the current system from the literature and reports provided
by the State Institute for Drug Control (SUKL). RESULTS: In order to increase transparency according to EU Transparency Directive and to set fairly-defined deadlines
the competencies for the pricing and reimbursement system were merged from Ministries of Finances and Ministry of Health (MoH) under one responsible institution—
SUKL. The pricing rules were fully changed—the maximum price is set based as the
mean value of all available ex-factory prices in the reference countries (Estonia, France,
Italy, Lithuania, Hungary, Portugal, Greece and Spain). The reference reimbursement
system contains 251 reference groups of therapeutically interchangeable products with
similar clinical efficacy and safety (should be updated annually by MoH). Medicinal
products included in one reference group have the main common therapeutic indication in the same reimbursement level which is calculated on the basis of retail prices
in all EU countries. The cheapest price for equipotent dose is chosen and re-counted
according to local pharmacy and wholesaler margins and value added taxes. In compliance with new legislation the pharmacoeconomic criteria (cost-effectiveness evaluation
and budget impact analysis) should be taken into account. There is possibility of extra
bonus of basic reimbursement for better efficacy, safety, dosing schedule, compliance,
etc. CONCLUSIONS: The system has gone through dramatic changes in last two years
and some aspects are still facing challenges. Although the new system should reassessed
all medicines covered in the country till 2008, currently there are only 20% revised
(April 2010).
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Risk-Sharing/Performance-Based
Scheme/Agreements
PHP125
TRENDS IN UK-BASED PATIENT ACCESS SCHEMES: FINANCIAL-BASED
VERSUS OUTCOMES-BASED AGREEMENTS
Woods RM, Johnson KI
Complete Market Access, Macclesfield, Cheshire, UK
OBJECTIVES: Whilst patient access schemes (PAS) are not a new concept, they are
clearly receiving increasing attention. The first notable PAS, devised to improve access
to beta interferons for multiple sclerosis, was an outcomes-based scheme designed to
overcome uncertainty in long-term clinical and cost-effectiveness. It is the nature of
the uncertainty that drives the design of PAS, but is there a trend towards which
schemes are more popular? We analyzed the design of published PAS employed in the
UK in order to determine if outcomes-based or financial-based schemes predominate.
METHODS: Published PAS were identified from health technology assessment websites (e.g. the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence and Scottish Medicines Consortium), literature searching of ISPOR conference abstracts, and searching
of ‘patient access scheme’ or ‘risk-sharing scheme,’ using internet search engines. PAS
identified were categorised as financial-based (price- or volume-based agreements) or
outcomes-based schemes. Desk research was the performed to identify the preference
for each type of scheme, in terms of uptake by UK Primary Care Trusts. RESULTS:
Seventeen published PAS were identified from the literature search, from 2002 until
2010. Categorization of PAS as financial-based versus outcomes-based showed that
schemes were balanced, but favoured financial-based schemes (59% versus 41%,
respectively). The uptake of financial-based schemes was found to be higher than
outcomes-based schemes due to administrative burden posed by schemes which rely
A428
on the measurement and reporting of clinical outcomes. CONCLUSIONS: PAS were
pioneered by the beta interferon outcomes-based scheme for multiple sclerosis, 2002.
Since then, published UK-based schemes favour price or volume-based schemes, a
trend illustrated by two of the three newest schemes published in 2010. The simplicity
of financial-based agreements, combined with poor health care system uptake of
outcomes-based schemes and the demand for value-based pricing, suggests that this
trend is set to continue.
PHP126
PATIENT ACCESS SCHEMES (PAS) IN THE UK COMING OF AGE: WHAT
IMPACT WILL THEY HAVE ON OTHER EU COUNTRIES LIKE ITALY?
Kirpekar S, Mallinson M, White R, Gannedahl A
Double Helix Consulting Group, London, UK
OBJECTIVES: Although patient access schemes (PAS) have historically been implemented for high-cost oncology drugs, recent schemes for chronic diseases like rheumatoid arthritis (RA) have been seen in the UK. This study tries to understand how
the shift in PAS from being accepted by payers only for short-term oncology drugs to
those for chronic diseases like RA in the UK will influence the situation in Italy, where
PAS are known to be widespread. METHODS: This study used qualitative telephone
interviews to analyze trends in the UK (n = 7) and Italy (n = 7). Interviews were
conducted in tertiary hospitals as well as local, regional and national level reimbursement authorities involving financial and clinical stakeholders, and key individuals in
the implementation of the scheme. Importance of a number of variables affecting new
PAS was ranked. RESULTS: Budget-holders in both markets were seen to be sceptical
about the impact on long-term budgets due to the move towards PAS for chronic
conditions. Of the 14 stakeholders interviewed, 9 said that such schemes in chronic
conditions might help companies access markets with lesser clinical evidence on the
basis of the class-effect of the drugs and the risk-sharing nature of the schemes. Monitoring of the outcomes on implementation was thought to be crucial. CONCLUSIONS: In Italy, increase in PAS for chronic diseases will help drug companies bring
drugs to the market earlier. On the other hand, the payers will see this as an increased
burden on their budgets as it will mean funding longer term treatment. Also, due to
recent issues with monitoring of outcomes in PAS in the UK, their future needs reconsideration. This move of PAS towards chronic conditions is expected to increase
the impact that post-marketing monitoring will have on market access for expensive
‘me-too’ drugs in the EU.
PHP127
ADOPTING A FINANCIAL RISK-SHARING SCHEME FOR NEW
TECHNOLOGIES ADDED TO THE NATIONAL LIST OF HEALTH
SERVICES IN ISRAEL: STAKEHOLDERS’ STATED INCENTIVES AND
DISINCENTIVES
Hammerman A, Feder-Bubis P, Greenberg D
Ben Gurion University of the Negev, Beer-Sheva, Israel
OBJECTIVES: To explore major stakeholders’ incentives and disincentives to adopt
a financial risk-sharing mechanism regarding budget-impact estimates of adopting new
technologies in the Israeli National List of Health Services (NLHS). According to the
proposed scheme, HMOs will be partially compensated by the pharmaceutical and
medical device industry if actual use of a technology is substantially higher than what
was projected and allocated. On the other hand, HMOs will partially refund the
government for budgets allocated to specific technologies that were not fully used.
These unused budgets will be used for adopting other technologies in subsequent years.
METHODS: Using a semi-structured protocol, we interviewed major stakeholders
involved in the process of updating the NLHS (N = 31). Interviewees included government officials, senior managers in the country’s four HMOs, pharmaceutical industry
executives, and health economists. We inquired into the interviewee’s view towards
our proposed risk-sharing mechanism, and their opinion on the other stakeholders’
incentives to accept or object the proposed scheme. RESULTS: Our interviews revealed
a wide range of incentives, disincentives, and barriers for adopting the risk-sharing
mechanism. There was no consensus on what would be the different stakeholders’
incentives and disincentives for adopting the proposed mechanism, even within the
various stakeholders groups themselves. Most interviewees from the HMOs and the
pharmaceutical industry supported the proposed risk-sharing agreement. Among government officials, the Ministry of Finance decision-makers tended to object to the
proposed mechanism, while Ministry of Health executives usually supported the
scheme, but believed that the pharmaceutical industry will not support this risksharing agreement. CONCLUSIONS: Since the success of implementing a risk-sharing
mechanism depends mainly on its perception as a win-win situation for all stakeholders, we recommend that decision-makers consider the different incentives and disincentives exposed in our interviews, when implementing such a mechanism.
HEALTH CARE USE & POLICY STUDIES – Beyond Drug Interventions
PHP128
THE USE OF HEALTH PROMOTION INITIATIVES BY MUNICIPALITIES
IN BELGIUM. A RETROSPECTIVE OBSERVATIONAL STUDY
Verhaeghe N, Barbe T, Annemans L
Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: Growing attention is currently given to preventive health care. Prevention can decline the appearance of several diseases and as a consequence lead to a
13th Euro Abstracts
decrease of health care expenses. The aim of this study was to evaluate if municipalities
in Belgium currently are using intervention strategies for optimizing the health behavior of citizens. Special attention was given to what extent certain high-risk groups are
reached. METHODS: The design consisted of a retrospective observational design.
The general services or—if existing—the sports services of 570 Belgian cities (308 in
the Flanders and 262 in the Walloon region) were invited by e-mail to participate in
the study. After the first mailing, another two mailings were performed. The data were
collected using an online questionnaire with closed questions. PASW Statistics 18 was
used for statistical analysis. RESULTS: The response rate in the Flemish region and
Walloon region was respectively 57.47% and 16.41%. In Flanders, 94.9% of respondents reported that they organize health promotion initiatives, while in Wallonia this
percentage was 65.1%. Most common organized initiatives in the Flanders region
were sport (74.4%) and social welfare (46.4%) initiatives. In Wallonia most common
initiatives were prevention of disease/vaccination (45.3%) and sport (44%). Both in
Flanders and Wallonia, initiatives concerning mental health were little organized. In
general, the initiatives aimed at certain high-risk groups such as persons with mental
health problems, older and disabled persons were scarce. On the level of municipal
policy lack of appropriate financing was reported as the most common barrier for not
organizing preventive strategies. CONCLUSIONS: On the level of municipal policy
reinforcement of the value of preventive strategies concerning health promotion with
appropriate financing is required. When organizing preventive initiatives, special attention to reach certain high-risk groups will be needed.
PHP129
ATTITUDES OF HUNGARIAN POPULATION TOWARD CO-PAYMENTS
1
2
1
2
Baji P , Pavlova M , Gulacsi L , Groot W
1
Corvinus University of Budapest, Budapest, Hungary; 2University of Maastricht, Maastricht,
The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: The issue of the introduction of co-payments is a great policy challenge
in most of the Central-Eastern European countries. This is also the case in Hungary,
where visit fee was introduced for health care services in 2007, and abolished one year
later as a result of a referendum. The aim of our study is to identify different types
of attitudes towards patient payments, and answer why visit fee was so unpopular
among Hungarian population. METHODS: 8 focus-group discussions with health
care consumers and physicians and 7 in-depth interviews with policy makers were
conducted in Hungary during the summer 2009 on the attitude of patient payments
in health care. RESULTS: Based on the transcripts and questionnaires filled in by all
respondents during the focus group discussions and interviews three different groups of
attitude were identified. The group of “Supporters” support the introduction of patient
payments with the aim of controlling the unnecessary use of services. The group of
“Undecided” concern patient payments as an opportunity to provide additional resource
for health care system by paying for “extra-better-quality services”. “Sceptics” strongly
refuse the idea of patient payments mainly referring to ethical issues. Consumers mainly
belong to the group of “Undecided”, while one part of the physicians belongs to “Supporters”, the other part to “Sceptics”. Policy makers are all belong to the group of
“Supporters”. CONCLUSIONS: Before the implementation of patient payments,
mapping of population’s attitude is inevitable. In Hungary the failure of the introduction of visit fee can be explained by different expectations of health care consumers.
They are not against to pay for health care services, but expecting better quality of
provided services in return.
PHP130
TRENDS IN COST CONTAINMENT MEASURES
Mukku S, Klein Lankhorst E, Edathodu AS
Double Helix Consulting Group, London, UK
OBJECTIVES: In the current economic climate health authorities are finding ways to
control spending. a popular measure is the introduction of cost containment strategies
for pharmaceuticals to lessen the burden of cost of drugs. The objective of this research
was to analyze the importance of different cost containment measures that payers use
in selected markets. The research extends to analyze the gaps between the policies on
paper and the extent these are interpreted and executed in practice. METHODS:
Interviews were conducted with payers at the national, regional and local level in
selected European and non-European markets. RESULTS: All countries utilise different measures to control spending on pharmaceuticals. The measures that are used by
markets include: internal therapeutic referencing, international price referencing,
generic substitution, risk-sharing agreements, budget caps, profit caps, index pricing,
price cuts, rebates and price volume agreements. The critical finding from the research
was that although combinations of measures are included in the national and regional
policies, in reality their interpretation and execution varies substantially. For example,
Spain uses internal referencing and price referencing at the national level, regions apply
price discounts and rebates. Similarly, in the The Netherlands a preferred drug policy
is introduced, which means that health insurers can now choose a preferred drug for
reimbursement, which is usually the cheapest option of the reference basket. If the
patient does not want this product, they have to pay the full price of the other product.
Another European country which has become the recent focus is Germany; where
price regulation will become dominant in the near future. There are uncertainties on
achievable prices of drugs, one reason being there is lack of sophisticated systems in
place that can monitor these measures. CONCLUSIONS: There are currently many
developments in the area of cost containment of pharmaceuticals which will have a
profound effect on the pharmaceutical industry.
13th Euro Abstracts
PHP131
THE USE OF ECONOMIC EVALUATION IN A MEDICAL DEVICE
COMMISION OF AN ITALIAN TEACHING HOSPITAL
Alello A, Bassotto F, Filippi C, Fratucello A, Ghirlanda G, Marini P, Scroccaro G, Fantelli V
Azienda Ospedaliera Universitaria Integrata di Verona, Verona, Italy
OBJECTIVES: In order to control Medical Devices (MDs) purchasing process and to
rationalize the MDs evaluation process, the Verona Hospitals (2 accounting for 1.700
beds), have set up a Medical Devices Committee (MDC). MDC members, who have
expertise in a broad range of disciplines, evaluate MDs according to Health Technology Assessment (HTA) criteria. This study is concerned with the use of economic
evaluations in policy decision making of MDC. METHODS: We developed a DataBase to record all economic evidences considered by MDC from January 2009 to April
2010 for each MD evaluated: health economics analysis in literature (cost-effectiveness, cost-to-cost etc), cost information (price, costs impact etc) and Disease Related
Group (DRG) simulation. We verified also the presence and costs of current alternative
treatments. RESULTS: Among 37 MDs evaluated 30 technologies had at least a
current alternative treatment in Hospital formulary (81.1%); MDC always considered
at least the price of MDs, costs impact of introducing a new MD and costs when
compared with alternative/current treatments (100%). For 23 MDs the management
office individuated the DRG value (62.2%) and for 12 of them (32.4%) verified
whether DRG covered direct costs. Only for 4 MDs (10.8%) was possible finding at
least an economic study in literature (2 cost-effectiveness analysis and 2 cost-to-cost
analysis). CONCLUSIONS: At the moment the decisions taken by the MDC mainly
focused on the clinical benefits, on the comparison of costs vs. alternative treatments
and on the incidence of the DM cost on the DRG tariff. The economic evidences
seldom influence the opinion of MDC, most of all because the clinical value of DM
is not always supported by economic evidences. Recently, technology application form
has been modified including questions about the potential savings derived by the new
technology, economic studies (also not published) and Budget Impact analysis.
PHP132
VALUE OF MULTI-CRITERIA DECISION ANALYSIS IN EARLY
ASSESSMENT OF MEDICAL DIAGNOSTIC DEVICES
Ijzerman MJ, Hummel J
University Twente, Enschede, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: Multicriteria decision analytic (MCDA) techniques are a powerful tool
in evaluating health care interventions where multiple, often competing, factors need
to be considered. The analytic hierarchy process (AHP) is one such technique. We
have applied AHP to evaluate medical diagnostic technologies as to support product
development and market access. The main objective of this study is to show feasibility
of AHP in terms of applicability and outcome. We therefore have studied the expected
performance of the Photoacoustic Mammoscope (PAM), a new imaging device for
detection of breast cancer based on photoacoustic imaging. METHODS: Before starting the study we defined different diagnostic and screening scenarios for the PAM
including criteria that are important in the acceptance of the device. We finally defined
four strategies including mammography, ultrasound and MRI imaging. The Analytic
Hierarchy Process (AHP) analysis was then used to identify the relative importance
of evaluation criteria, and to identify the relative performance of four different breast
cancer imaging techniques. RESULTS: According to the expert panel the most important criterion in the design of a diagnostic breast imaging device is sensitivity (overall
weight was 54%). Factors that mainly determine the performance on sensitivity are
the visualization of mass margins, mass shape and vascularization. Second most
important criterion was safety. CONCLUSIONS: From an early assessment of photoacoustic imaging it may be concluded that the potential clinical performance justifies
further development and implementation of PAM. However, further research on the
use of AHP in medical product development is required. We present and discuss some
ideas to further integrate clinical evidence into MCDA using Bayesian techniques as
well as sensitivity analyses on the model inputs.
PHP133
PERSONALIZED PHARMACOTHERAPY AND ANALYSIS OF
EXTEMPORANEOUS DOSAGE FORMS FOR CHILDREN IN UKRAINE
Maynych Y, Zalis’ka O
Danylo Halytsky Lviv National Medical University, Lviv, Ukraine
OBJECTIVES: Pharmacotherapy of children requires the use of drugs for individual
preparation of personalized treatment. Medications extemporal manufacturing
approach allows for Personalized Medicine. The use of extemporaneous preparations
to precisely match the appropriate concentration of drug forms, volume and available
dosage forms for komplayensu, extemporaneous medicines do not contain stabilizers,
preservatives, it is important for children with allergic diseases. METHODS: The
ABC—analysis was conducted of 3525 prescription extemporaneous preparations
which were made in 8 pharmacies specialized of Western Ukraine regions for 2007–
2009. RESULTS: The total list of pediatric formulations consisted of 106 items.
Determined that the practical range of medicines includes 7 extemporaneous dosage
forms, including solutions of 45% solutions, ointments 23% and 12% suspensions et
al. Revealed that the production of extemporaneous preparations seasonal influences.
Increasing production of liquids, powders at the time of respiratory exacerbation in
children. Distinguished set of extemporaneous preparations, which are often assigned
practical pediatrician in Ukraine: protargol drops—when rhinitis, cough mixture,
powder eufilinu with glucose—with bronchitis, Foenuculi water—with flatulence,
pepsin solution with hydrochloric acid—in violation of appetite, anestezynum suspen-
A429
sion; dexamethasone ointment, betamethasone ointment—for allergies vitamin
powder. Determined extemporaneous medicines for children, which have no analogues in industrial production—a solution of pepsin with hydrochloric acid, dexamethasone ointment, paste Lassara with oil Plum; diazolinum powder with calcium
gluconate and glucose—from allergies, suppositories with cocoa butter and levomitsetinum—with diarrhea, Foenuculi water—with flatulence in newborns and infants.
CONCLUSIONS: Using drugs extemporal medicines, namely those that have no
industrial counterparts, to ensure individualized pharmacotherapy children pick up
the dose, volume of product, and prevent undesirable side reactions, especially for
treatment of chronic diseases in children with allergic manifestations and provide a
personalized therapy in pediatric practice.
PHP134
IMPACT OF BLEEDING-RELATED CONSEQUENCES ON LENGTH OF
STAY (LOS) AND HOSPITAL COSTS IN PATIENTS UNDERGOING
SURGERY IN FRANCE
Lafuma A1, Ye X2, Torreton E1, Bastide P3, Arnaud A3
1
CEMKA-EVAL, Bourg la Reine, France; 2Ethicon, a Johnson & Johnson Company, Somerville,
NJ, USA; 3Ethicon, Inc, Issy les Moulineaux, France
OBJECTIVES: The objectives of this study were to estimate the incidence, costs and
length of stay (LOS) of bleeding-related consequences in various surgical procedures
in France. METHODS: A retrospective analysis was conducted using the national
Diagnosis Related Group (DRG) database (PMSI). Patients with surgical procedures
in 2008 were identified based on DRGs. For each DRG, the rate of bleeding-related
consequences was estimated. For DRGs with an incidence of bleeding-related consequences over 10%, age and gender-adjusted hospital LOS and costs were examined
among patients with (WB) and without bleeding related consequences (WoB). The
rates of hospitalizations exceeding the expected LOS (derived from PMSI) between
WB and WoB surgeries were compared using multivariate logistic regression.
RESULTS: Of the 88 different DRGs in French database, 24 (a total of 321,657
hospitalizations) had an incidence of bleeding-related consequences over 10%, ranging
from 10.3% to 25.3%. DRGs with higher rates were transplantations, cardiac and
major orthopedic surgery, vascular and solid organ surgery. Age and gender adjusted
mean LOS for WB patients was 3.38 days longer (+26.5%) compared with WoB
patients (P < 0.001). Average adjusted costs were estimated at c12,087 per WB stays
versus c10,086 per WoB stays, corresponding to a 19.9% increase (P < 0.001). The
rate of hospitalizations exceeding the expected LOS was respectively 42.3 % and
37.0% for WB and WoB hospitalizations (P < 0.001). WB hospitalizations were
approximately 10% more likely to exceed expected LOS compared to WoB (OR =
1.09, 95% CI: 1.07–1.11, P < 0.001), after adjusting for patient characteristics.
CONCLUSIONS: This study characterizes the increased hospital LOS and cost among
patients with bleeding-related consequences in France. In particular, the excess LOS
than expected DRG LOS presents significant financial burden related to bleeding
consequences for hospitals. Awareness of potential clinical and economic impacts of
bleeding-related consequences provides important framework for understanding the
value of blood-conservation strategies.
PHP135
THE EXAMINATION OF THE CHRONIC STRESS
1
1
1
1
2
1
1
Müller Á , Józsa R , Gál N , Betlehem J , Sándor J , Roznár J , Boncz I , Kriszbacher I1,
Sebestyén A3, Oláh A1
1
University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary; 2University of Debrecen, Debrecen, Hungary; 3National
Health Insurance Fund Administration, Pécs, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: We examined the effects of chronic stress with modelling different shift
work schedules in animal experimental model. METHODS: Internationally most
frequently used night shift schedules were applied in three groups of animals
(4DL/3LD; 8DL/6LD; 2DL/2LD) beside a group kept in normal LD cycle (12 hour
light-L/12 hour dark-D = control group). Groups were divided in two parts, one of
them were exposed to CMS. Degree of anxiety was evaluated in light-dark box. Differences between groups according to variables (sex, lighting regimens and CMS) and
time spent in light, number of changing compartments and latency of changing dark
to the light section were examined with multiple one-way analysis of variance. Plasma
concentrations of corticosterone and testosterone were measured after 4 weeks of
exposure to stress procedures, concentrations were determined by radioimmunoassay.
RESULTS: In groups kept under different lighting schedules compared to control
group, significant differences were found: animals kept in 4DL/3LD (p = 0.05, p =
0.079 /nearly significant/ p = 0.011) and 2DL/2LD (p = 0.025, p = 0.001, p = 0.045)
schedules spent less time in light, latency increased, while no statistically significant
differences were found in 8DL/6LD group in any of the variables (p = 0.113, p =
0.118, p = 0.45). We found that groups kept in different lighting schedules and
exposed to chronic stress kept their circadian rhythm (corticosterone: p = 0,095—
border line statistical significance; testosterone: p = 0.004), while groups kept in different lighting schedules but not exposed to chronic stress lost circadian rhythms
(corticosterone: p = 0.071 for 12-hour component; testosterone: p > 0.20). CONCLUSIONS: According to light-dark box test and hormonal examinations it seems, that
shifts different than normal light/dark regimen lead to anxiety also without CMS, and
may have been harder load than the CMS procedure. Group 8DL/6LD shows the
closest approximations of parameters observed in LD group suggesting that this
schedule applied in shift work is less harmful to health, and provides the best way of
regeneration.
A430
INFECTION – Clinical Outcomes Studies
PIN1
COST AND QUALITY OF LIFE ISSUES ASSOCIATED WITH PROTEASE
INHIBITOR-BASED COMBINATION THERAPY TO TREAT HEPATITIS C
Carter J1, Gao X1, Stephens JM1, Rustgi V2, Haider S3
1
Pharmerit North America, LLC, Bethesda, MD, USA; 2Georgetown University Medical
Center, Fairfax, VA, USA; 3Pfizer Inc., New London, CT, USA
OBJECTIVES: To systematically analyze the literature to assess the economic and
health-related quality of life (HRQoL) impact of adverse events (AEs) related to the
addition of protease inhibitors (PI) to standard of care (SOC) for the treatment of
hepatitis C (HCV). METHODS: A literature search (2000-Present) was conducted to
identify and analyze clinical trials for PI triple therapy (PITT = PI + SOC) and SOC
(PEGIFN/RBV for 48 weeks). HRQoL and safety data were synthesized by study
design, sample characteristics, and AEs. Economic and resource use data were synthesized in an economic analysis of AEs in PITT vs. SOC. Costs (2009) were derived
from published literature. RESULTS: Twenty-three SOC and 7 PITT trials were identified. Statistically significant (p = or <0.05) changes from baseline were most often seen
in trials of SOC in the following domains: vitality, depression, physical limitations,
and fatigue. The following 4 PITT-related AEs could be linked to HRQoL domains:
anemia and depression were linked to fatigue and vitality, and headache and rash were
linked to physical limitations. In terms of economic impacts, the costs to manage a
PITT-related episode of anemia, depression, diarrhea, and rash were $4825, $2837,
$566, and $633, respectively. The average AE cost in PITT ranged from $1732 to
$3578. Corresponding costs in SOC ranged from $1608 to $2229. The treatment
costs of PITT-related AEs were 30% (range 8–60%) higher than the cost of treating
SOC-related AEs. CONCLUSIONS: The costs to manage PITT-related AEs appear
higher than the costs of SOC-related AEs. Since PITT is associated with higher AE
rates, it can also be expected to result in worse HRQoL. Gaps in symptom burden
assessment with existing instruments also exist. Future studies should incorporate the
economic burden of AEs and the appropriate use of HCV-validated instruments to
capture potential HRQoL differences among treatment strategies.
PIN2
ESTIMATED IMPACT OF SUSTAINED VIROLOGICAL RESPONSE (SVR)
ON LIFE EXPECTANCY, QUALITY-ADJUSTED LIFE-YEARS (QALYS) AND
LIFETIME COSTS IN CHRONIC HEPATITIS C (CHC) PATIENTS
Cure S1, Bianic F1, Cawston H1, Dartois L1, Zhang H2
1
i3 Innovus, Uxbridge, Middlesex, UK; 2Johnson & Johnson Pharmaceutical Services, LLC,
Raritan, NJ, USA
OBJECTIVES: The World Health Organization considers hepatitis C a global burden.
CHC is a curable disease since patients achieving SVR can remain virus-free. We
evaluated CHC treatment for efficacy (SVR) and long-term effects on reduction of
disease progression to advanced stages, improvement in quality of life, and reduction
of health care costs. The objective was to estimate the burden of disease and impact
of SVR in CHC patients on lifetime life-years (LY), QALYs and costs using a Markov
model and published literature. METHODS: A systematic literature review identified
publications reporting the cost-effectiveness of antiviral therapies in CHC (November
2009). PubMed, CRD and Health Technology Assessment reports were searched. We
selected all cost-effectiveness (CE) studies with a similar Markov structure including
eight health states (SVR, mild/moderate CHC, compensated and decompensated cirrhosis, hepatocellular carcinoma [HCC], liver transplant and death). CE inputs were
used to populate a Markov model to estimate average lifetime benefits and costs
associated with SVR and non-SVR. Age of entry in the model was 40 years. Costs
were updated to 2008 Great Britain Pounds (GBP). Discount rates for costs and
outcomes were 3.5%. RESULTS: 893 unique references were retrieved and 14 articles
met the inclusion criteria. Compared to non-SVR patients, the SVR group was consistently associated with more LYs (18.33, range [18.05;18.53] versus 17.49, range
[16.17;18.51]) and more QALYs (15.81, range [14.8;17.87] versus 13.25, range
[11.9;14.03]). Lifetime costs associated with non-SVR patients (£20,406, range
[£7,186;£41,383]) were also consistently higher than with SVR patients (£11,156,
range [£5,449;£14,582]). CONCLUSIONS: Using this model, the SVR group was
consistently associated with longer life expectancy and more QALYs. Complications
avoided by reaching SVR were associated with reduced lifetime CHC costs. It will be
important to account for these correlations with lifetime benefits and costs when the
values of an antiviral treatment in CHC are evaluated.
PIN3
PRESCRIBER INFLUENCE ON THE PREVALENCE OF POTENTIAL
ANTIRETROVIRAL DRUG-DRUG INTERACTIONS ON PRESCRIPTIONS
IN SOUTH AFRICA
Katende-Kyenda NL1, Lubbe MS2, Serfontein JHP2, Truter I3
1
Walter Sisulu University, Mthatha, Eastern Cape, South Africa; 2North-West University,
Potchefstroom, South Africa; 3Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University (NMMU), Port
Elizabeth, Eastern Cape, South Africa
OBJECTIVES: The purpose was to determine the prevalence of potential drug-drug
interactions (DDIs) between antiretroviral (ARV) drugs on prescriptions prescribed by
general practitioners and specialists in South Africa and the evaluation of the prescribed daily doses (PDDs) of the interacting drugs. METHODS: A quantitative,
retrospective drug utilization study was performed on 49,995, 81,096 and 88988 ARV
prescriptions claimed through a South African pharmacy benefit management
13th Euro Abstracts
company during 2005 to 2007. Potential DDIs between ARVs were identified and
classified according to a clinical significance rating. The clinical significance ratings of
potential DDIs are described in three degrees of severity, identified as major, moderate
and minor as described by Tatro. (RSA Rand(R)/$US = 6.8595 on 31 December 2007).
RESULTS: Antiretroviral drugs represented 0.91% of all drugs (N = 59 971 226)
claimed during the three years at a total cost of N = R 5 758 783 544 (1.92%). The
average cost of antiretroviral prescriptions decreased with 4.19% from 2005 (R524.40
± R178.79) to 2007 (R502.41 ± R161.19). ARV prescriptions prescribed by general
practitioners with potential DDIs and PDDs not according to recommended ARV
dosing increased dramatically from 12.33% in 2005 to 24.26% in 2007. Those prescribed by specialists increased from 15.46% in 2005 to 35.30% in 2006 and
decreased to 33.16% in 2007. The highest percentage of ARV prescriptions with
potential DDIs and PDDs not according to the recommended ARV dosing guidelines
were identified in ARV regimens between lopinavir/ritonavir at PDD 1066.4 mg/264 mg
and efavirenz at PDD 600 mg prescribed to patients 19 to 45 years. These regimens
were mostly prescribed by general practitioners as compared to specialists. CONCLUSIONS: There is need for more education of prescribers to be aware of the potential
medication-prescribing errors associated with highly active antiretroviral therapy
which could lead to treatment failures, development of resistance and DDIs.
PIN4
IMPACT OF MMRV MASS VACCINATION WITH OR WITHOUT A
CATCH UP PROGRAM ON THE INCIDENCE OF VARICELLA
COMPLICATIONS IN FRANCE
Ouwens M1, Littlewood K1, Sauboin C2, Tehard B3, Alain S4, Denis F5, Boelle PY6
1
Mapi Values, Houten, The Netherlands; 2GlaxoSmithKline Biologicals, Rixensart, Belgium;
3
Laboratoire GlaxoSmithKline, Marly le Roi, France; 4French National Cytomegalovirus
Reference Center, Limoges, France; 5CHU Dupuytren, Limoges, France; 6Université Pierre et
Marie Curie, Paris, France
OBJECTIVES: Varicella complications place a large burden on health care resources,
however, varicella is preventable by mass vaccination with MMRV. The impact on
complications of three MMRV programs were explored. METHODS: An age-structured dynamic model compared natural and breakthrough varicella following mass
vaccination, to current cases. Age-specific complication rates (neurologic, cutaneous,
pulmonary, other) were applied per case. MMRV replaced 80% of MMR over 1 year
(basecase) compared to 100% of MMR with a catch-up in 11–13 year-olds (‘catch
up’). In an ‘optimal’ scenario, MMR coverage increased from 90% to 95% (1st dose)
and 60% to 90% (2nd dose), MMRV replaced 100% MMR within 1 year with a
catch-up in 10 year-olds. RESULTS: MMRV decreased varicella incidence and caused
an age shift, however, many post-vaccination cases were breakthrough cases, believed
to be milder and require less resource use. Prior to MMRV: highest varicella incidence
(per million-person-years of total population) was among 1–4 year-olds (7,482 cases),
with 355 complications (age-specific complication rate: 4.75%). Basecase: highest
incidence among 10–14 year-olds (907 natural, 633 breakthrough), with 54 complications (age-specific rate: 3.53%); 85% lower versus 1–4 year-olds. ‘Catch-up’: highest
incidence among 15–24 year-olds (161 natural, 398 breakthrough), with 49 complications (age-specific rate: 8.82%); 86% lower versus 1–4 year-olds. ‘Optimal’: highest
incidence among 15–24 year-olds (22 natural, 80 breakthrough), with 9 complications; 97.5% lower versus 1–4 year-olds. Assuming breakthrough cases have 10% of
complications of natural cases, the incidence in the basecase, catch-up and optimal
scenarios becomes: 34, 18 and 3 complications respectively. Despite greater risks of
complications in older age groups, the reduction in varicella cases significantly reduced
the incidence of complications. The ICER remained below c16,000 (direct costs).
CONCLUSIONS: Mass varicella vaccination is predicted to significantly reduce varicella and complication cases. As many vaccine era cases will be breakthrough; burden
to patients and health care systems may be reduced further.
PIN5
HOW LONGITUDINAL PATIENT RECORDS CAN HELP PUBLIC HEALTH
AUTHORITIES IN THE MANAGEMENT OF RAPIDLY GROWING
EPIDEMICS? THE EXPERIENCE OF FLU A/H1N1 IN FRANCE
Toussi M, Pertus D, Antonio M, Robain M
CSD, Boulogne, Billancourt, France
OBJECTIVES: In the context of an epidemic, public health authorities need to have
real time information of the disease propagation to make appropriate and timely
decisions. We present our experience in using centralized electronic patient records in
the early detection and follow-up of Flu A/H1N1 epidemic in France. METHODS:
We used Longitudinal Patient Data (LPD), which is a dynamic centralized database
of more than 1.3 million anonymous patient records uploaded regularly by a network
of 1300 representative general practitioners and pediatricians in France. The trends
of seasonal influenza, Flu A/H1N1 and flu-like syndrome diagnoses are traced and
compared with the reports published by Sentinel Network, a group of trained physicians set up by public authorities. RESULTS: The trends of seasonal influenza, Flu A/
H1N1, and flu-like syndrome obtained from LPD database show a very close similarity
with those published by Sentinel Network (Pearson’s correlation coefficient = 0.97).
The seasonal pattern of the incidence of influenza and flu-like syndrome were less
similar between 2009 and 2008 (Pearson’s correlation coefficient = 0.60), which can
be explained by an over declaration of all kinds of flu by the doctors during the second
half of 2009. There was also a close similarity between seasonal Flu, approved Flu A/
H1N1, and flu-like syndrome trends with a peak incidence in late November 2009.
CONCLUSIONS: The LPD data matched very closely the results published by the
13th Euro Abstracts
official Sentinel Network. The advantage of the LPD data is that its trends are available
almost in real time, whereas the active reporting of the doctors of Sentinel Network
is done on a weekly basis. However, the LPD trends lack of geographical precision
because of the censorship of the post codes of patient during the de-identification
process. We recommend a combined use of LPD and Sentinel Networks in the follow
up of future epidemics.
PIN6
A MULTIVARIATE MODEL: PREDICTORS OF DISEASE PROGRESSION IN
HIV/AIDS PATIENTS IN WESTERN NEW YORK
Voltz C1, Castleman C2, Purdy C2, Magar R3
1
Aids Community Services of Western New York, Buffalo, NY, USA; 2AHRM Inc., Buffalo,
NY, USA; 3AHRM Inc., Raleigh, NC, USA
OBJECTIVES: The medical care of HIV/AIDS patients is becoming increasingly
complex involving a host of issues including medication management, co-infections,
cardiovascular risk factors and patient characteristics. This analysis used a set of
patient characteristics and treatment patterns to explore potential predictors of HIV
progression. METHODS: Aids Community Services of Western New York provides
primary medical care services to approximately 600 HIV/AIDS patients yearly in
WNY. A total of 1128 patients, receiving care from August 2006 through June 2010
were included in the analysis. The patient characteristics, health indicators, medication
information and risk factors were used as potential predictors of disease progression.
Disease progression was measured by the surrogate endpoints of CD4 counts and
CD4/CD8 ratio values. a mixed model with a repeated structure was fit to the data
set (with a significance level of 0.05). RESULTS: The patient population was comprised of 757 men and 371 women; the average age of the population was 44 years.
The population sampled was predominantly Caucasian, African American and Hispanic (39%, 39%, and 19%). The most common HIV medications administered to
these patients were ritonavir, a tanofovir/emtricitabine combination, atazanavir and
a lopinavir/ritonavir combination. The most common risk factors in this population
were male with male sex, heterosexual sex and IV Drug use (27%, 15%, and 9%).
For the multivariate model utilizing the CD4 counts as the outcome variable, only
medications and cardiovascular risk factors were significant predictors. For the multivariate model utilizing the CD4/CD8 ratio as the outcome variable, only the HIV
risk factors and medications were significant predictors. Both models achieved global
statistical significance. CONCLUSIONS: The management of HIV/AIDS is an increasingly complex problem which requires constant advances in both research and practice. This exploratory analysis was able to identify significant relationships between
patient characteristics, treatment patterns and measures of disease progression.
INFECTION – Cost Studies
PIN7
BUDGET IMPACT MODEL FOR CATCH-UP PROGRAM WITH 13 VALENT
PNEUMOCOCCAL CONJUGATE VACCINE IN CHILDREN UNDER 5
YEARS OLD IN THE AUTONOMOUS REGION OF MADRID (RM)
Picazo J1, Gil de Miguel A2, Mendez C3, Guijarro P3, Garcia L3
1
University Complutense of Madrid, Madrid, Spain; 2Rey Juan Carlos University, Alcorcon,
Madrid, Spain; 3Pfizer Spain, Alcobendas, Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Madrid Health Authorities decided the introduction of Pneumococcal
Conjugate Vaccine (PCV) as systematic use for infants in November 2006 (3 + 1
pattern; 2, 4, 6 + 18 months). Recently, a flawless transition to PCV13 has been
recommended. This study was aimed to assess the budget impact of an additional
catch-up vaccination strategy from the age of 19 to 60 months. METHODS: A oneyear budget impact model has been developed stratifying population by age groups
(19 to 24, 25 to 36, 37 to 48 and 49 to 60 months) and diseases (IPD and Non-IPD).
Clinical data, PCV13 serotype coverage and disease related costs were based on
published data. Model was built up under regional health care system perspective and
assumed 80% of coverage for PCV13. Indirect effect was not considered. All costs
were expressed in c2010. RESULTS: The model predicts that the implementation of
a catch-up vaccination program with PCV13 in the RM would be a cost saving
measure in infant groups from 19 to 36 months due to disease burden reduction caused
by the 6 PCV13 additional serotypes. Globally, 49.6% of IPD, 58.9% of OMA
and 47.1% of out-patient pneumonia cases would be prevented in these groups.
CONCLUSIONS: Based on this health economic evaluation, the inclusion of a catchup program with PCV13 in the RM would be an efficient measure. Model results
showed that a PCV13 catch-up dose would have a high impact on pneumococcal
disease prevention, avoiding its related costs.
PIN8
COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS OF PEGINTERFERON (ALFA-2B)
WITH RIBAVIRIN COMPARED WITH PEGINTERFERON (ALFA-2A) WITH
RIBAVIRIN FOR THE TREATMENT OF CHRONIC HEPATITIS C
Omelyanovsky VV, Avksentieva MV, Krysanov I, Ivakhnenko O
Research Center for Clinical and Economic Evaluation and Pharmacoeconomics, Moscow,
Russia
OBJECTIVES: Combination therapy with pegylated interferon with ribavirin is the
standard of care for the treatment of chronic hepatitis C infection. This analysis
compares the cost efficacy of of combined antiviral therapy with peginterferon
alfa—2b with ribavirin compared peginterferon alfa—2Ü with ribavirin for treatment
A431
at patients with a hepatitis C infection counting for 1 patient. METHODS: A decision
analysis model was constructed from the viewpoint of a managed care organization
to compare Peg-2b plus RBV (1.5 mcg per kilogram per week plus RBV 1000 mg per
day) and Peg-2a plus RBV (180 mcg per week plus RBV 1000 mg per day). For
purposes of this analysis, distribution on genotypes and treatment duration and efficacy data were obtained from the published literature. The positive predictive value
was calculated for each treatment group for genotype 1, which is determined from
the values for early virologic response and sustained viral response. Genotype 2 and
genotype 3 were assumed to be treated for 24 weeks. RESULTS: Antiviral therapy of
combined antiviral therapy with peginterferon alfa—2b with ribavirin is economically
more favourable in comparison with therapy in a combination peginterferon alfa—2Ü
with ribavirin and taking into account efficiency of treatment the difference indicator
makes c3293 thousand on 1 patient. CONCLUSIONS: Antiviral therapy of combined
antiviral therapy with peginterferon alfa—2b with ribavirin is economically more
favourable in comparison with therapy in a combination peginterferon alfa—2Ü with
ribavirin and taking into account efficiency of treatment the difference indicator makes
c3293 thousand on 1 patient.
PIN9
ESTIMATED HEALTH AND ECONOMIC IMPACT OF QUADRIVALENT
HPV TYPES 6, 11, 16, 18 VACCINE IN JAPAN USING A TRANSMISSION
DYNAMIC MODEL
Yamabe K1, Abe M1, Singhal PK2, Kamae I3
1
Banyu Pharmaceutical Co.,Ltd, Tokyo, Japan; 2Merck & Co., Inc., West Point, PA, USA; 3Keio
University Graduate School of Health Management, Fujisawa, Japan
BACKGROUND: The quadrivalent (6,11,16,18) HPV vaccine has been approved in
many countries for prevention of cervical cancer, vulvar/vaginal pre-cancers, and
genital warts in women age 9 to 26 years. OBJECTIVES: To assess the health and
economic impact of the quadrivalent (6,11,16,18) HPV vaccine in Japan. METHODS:
A published mathematical model of the transmission dynamics of HPV infection and
disease was adapted for Japan. Model inputs were used from Japan or the Asia/Pacific
region when available; otherwise, the default values in the original model were used.
Maintaining current cervical cancer screening practices in Japan, we evaluated two
strategies: routine vaccination of females by age 12 (S1), and S1 combined with a
temporary (5 years) female catch-up program for age 12–24 years (S2). The vaccine
coverage rates were 80% for the routine and 50% for the catch-up vaccination programs. RESULTS: The most effective strategy was S2. Using this strategy over 100
years in the population of Japan, the estimated cumulative percent reduction in incident HPV 6/11/16/18-related genital warts-female, genital warts-male, cervical
intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) grade 1, CIN 2/3, and cervical cancer cases was 90%
(2,113,723 cases), 86% (2,082,637 cases), 72% (263,406 cases), 71% (1,328,366
cases), and 58% (323,145 cases), respectively. The cost-effectiveness ratios were US$
12,434 (weekly dominated), and US$ 12,058 per quality-adjusted life-years (QALY)
gained for S1 and S2 compared with no vaccination, respectively. CONCLUSIONS:
In Japan, vaccination of females age 12–24 years with a quadrivalent (6,11,16,18)
HPV vaccine can reduce the incidence of cervical cancer, CIN, and genital warts at a
cost per QALY ratio within the range typically regarded as cost-effective.
PIN10
COST VERSUS DRG REVENUE IMPLICATIONS OF TREATING A
PATIENT WITH VENTILATOR-ASSOCIATED PNEUMONIA (VAP) WITH
DORIPENEM VERSUS IMIPENEM IN GERMANY
De Cock E1, Gast C2, Berndt K3, Kubitz N3
1
United BioSource Corporation, Barcelona, Spain; 2Private Consultant, Seattle, WA, USA;
3
Janssen-Cilag GmbH, Neuss, Germany
OBJECTIVES: A Phase III study of doripenem versus imipenem in VAP (DORI-10)
has shown a statistically significant reduction in length of stay (LOS) and mechanical
ventilation (MV) duration with doripenem. This study estimated expected hospital
cost versus G-DRG payment for a patient treated with doripenem versus imipenem.
METHODS: From both DORI-10 trial arms, and for nine categories of post-randomization MV duration, we obtained percentages of patients per group and median LOS
by type of ward (ICU with vs. w/out MV, general ward). One clinical expert provided
ICD and OPS codes for four likely patient profiles, and another expert on intensive
care severity (TISS/SAPS). Using the Muenster Webgrouper, we determined G-DRG
weights when simultaneously varying MV duration and intensive care severity (8–890
code). Per treatment arm and for each MV subgroup, the appropriate G-DRG weight
was selected based on the selected profile, total MV duration, 8–980 code, and total
LOS. Using the distribution of patients by category, a weighted G-DRG was calculated
for each arm, and G-DRG weight was multiplied by the 2010 base value (c2936) to
yield expected G-DRG payment. Within each arm, we calculated cost per MV category
(hospital per diem plus antibiotic therapy) as well as a weighted cost. RESULTS:
Expected cost for a patient receiving doripenem was c30,183 vs. c32,549 for imipenem. Expected revenue reduction ranged from c2084 to c2428 across 4 scenarios. Net
budget impact of the introduction of doripenem ranged from −c85 to c282, showing
that revenue reduction may be more than offset by cost reduction. CONCLUSIONS:
For a patient receiving doripenem instead of imipenem, reduced hospitalization costs
more than offset reduced G-DRG revenue in a wide range of cases. In addition, less
time on the ventilator can improve patient outcomes (including quality-of-life), and
frees up ICU bed-days, allowing more patients to be treated.
A432
PIN11
COSTS OF QUANTIFERON TB-GOLD VERSUS TUBERCULIN SKIN TEST
IN SPANISH HEALTH CARE WORKERS
Linertová R1, Alvarez-León EE2, García-Pérez L1, Serrano-Aguilar P3
1
Fundación Canaria de Investigación y Salud (FUNCIS), Las Palmas de Gran Canaria, Spain;
2
Complejo Hospitalario Universitario Insular Materno-Infantil, Las Palmas de Gran Canaria,
Spain; 3Servicio Canario de la Salud, Santa Cruz de Tenerife, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Health care workers are a population at risk of Latent Tuberculosis
Infection (LTI), which is usually detected by the Tuberculin Skin Test (TST). In vitro
immunological tests such as QuantiFERON-TB Gold® (QFT-G) have been recently
recommended for LTI screening in health care workers. We compared direct and
indirect costs of two LTI screening strategies among health care workers in Spain:
TST and QFT-G. METHODS: This was a comparative cost study conducted from a
societal perspective, using data on costs and results from a prospective observational
study carried out in a Spanish public hospital, where the 2 screening alternatives were
concurrently applied to a cohort of 134 health care workers. RESULTS: In a base-case
analysis, the costs of the QFT-G test amounted c42.5 per screened health care worker
and those of the TST c39.5. Both tests varied in their cost structure: in the case of
TST, most of the total costs (70%) were indirect costs, basically time spent by the
participants, whereas QFT-G was more expensive in terms of fungible material, which
meant 50% of the total costs. The results are sensitive to the hourly wages of the
participants and to the estimation of the time spent by them in the tests. CONCLUSIONS: This cost study showed that, in the conditions of Spanish health care system,
the societal costs of the new QFT-G are comparable to those of the TST; however,
their cost structures vary considerably. Therefore, these results could change if applied
in other countries with different relation between salaries and prices.
PIN12
PSEUDOMONAS AERUGINOSA RELATED BURDEN ON CYSTIC
FIBROSIS PATIENTS: COMPARING HEALTH CARE COSTS AND
RESOURCE UTILIZATION ACROSS AGE GROUPS
Sansgiry S1, Joish V2, Boklage S2, Goyal RK1, Seal B2, Sethi S3
1
University of Houston, Houston, TX, USA; 2Bayer, Wayne, NJ, USA; 3University at Buffalo,
SUNY, Buffalo, NY, USA
OBJECTIVES: To determine if the average cost of medical care among cystic fibrosis
(CF) patients with Pseudomonas aeruginosa (PA) infection is different across agegroups. METHODS: Data were derived from MarketScan claims database, which
captures person-specific direct medical utilization, expenditures, and enrollment from
approximately 150 payers. a retrospective cross-sectional study design was used. CF
subjects with an initial claim for a PA infection were identified using international
classification of diseases diagnosis codes of 277.0 and 482.1, respectively. Demographic information from administrative claims and health care utilization and costs
from medical and pharmacy claims were extracted for 12 months pre and post initial
PA claim. All resource use and costs were annualized and compared across 7 agegroups with parametric (ANOVA) and Duncan’s post-hoc tests using SAS version 9.2.
RESULTS: A total of 347 CF subjects with PA infection met the study criteria with
mean age 19.9 (SD: 15.4) years and 47.8% females. a monotonic trend of increasing
(P < 0.05) overall post period costs was observed across the 7 age-groups. Example,
children 0–4 years had the lowest (P < 0.05) overall post costs of $31,569 (median =
$22,887) vs. $95,024 (median = $36,783) for adults 45–64 years. a similar trend with
the exception of age group 30–44, was observed with PA-related costs as well. Mean
and median per patient per year PA-related costs were lowest in children 0–4 years
($12,472, $3,572) compared to the oldest age-group of 45–64 years ($26,673,
$3,311). In general, total prescription claims and outpatient visits, and PA-related
inpatient visits increased with increasing age groups. Among children, PA-related
prescription claims were statistically higher. For example, mean PA-related prescription claims were 1.4 vs. 3.8 in the 0–4 vs. 15–19 groups (P < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS:
Overall and PA-related health care resource use and costs tended to vary across age
groups. Future research needs to explore the underlying reasons for this trend.
PIN13
LONG-TERM ECONOMIC AND CLINICAL BURDEN OF COMPLICATED
INVASIVE MENINGOCOCCAL DISEASE: EVIDENCE FROM A UNITED
STATES MANAGED CARE POPULATION
Karve S1, Misurski D2, Miller J3, Davis KL1
1
RTI Health Solutions, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA; 2GlaxoSmithKline, Philadelphia, PA,
USA; 3GlaxoSmithKline Biologicals, King of Prussia, PA, USA
OBJECTIVES: There is a paucity of data on the long-term (i.e., post-hospital discharge) economic and clinical burden of invasive meningococcal disease (IMD) and
its related complications among IMD survivors. The objective of this study was to
compare health care utilization and costs between IMD survivors with and without
related complications. METHODS: We conducted a retrospective cohort analysis of
the Ingenix Impact database (1997–2009). Patients with an inpatient admission for
IMD (ICD-9-CM: 036.x) and continuous health plan enrollment for ≥6 months before
and ≥12 months after the initial IMD hospitalization were selected. Patients were
further classified based on the presence (complicated IMD) or absence (uncomplicated
IMD) of a diagnosis code for relevant clinical sequelae (identified based on literature
review and clinical expertise) during the 12-month follow-up period. Health care
utilization and costs (in 2009 US$) incurred during the 12-month follow-up period
were compared between patients in the complicated and uncomplicated IMD groups
using univariate and multivariable regression analyses. RESULTS: Among 343 IMD
13th Euro Abstracts
patients identified, stroke (14.3%), seizure (11.7%) and hearing loss (10.5%) were
the most commonly observed complications, with 34.1% experiencing ≥1 complication. Significant differences in health care utilization and costs were observed, with
the largest between-group difference in follow-up costs being for inpatient services
(mean [95% CI]: $72,512 [$6,439] for complicated cases vs. $24,679 [$1,234] for
uncomplicated IMD; P < 0.001). Large differences were also observed for rehabilitative services ($24,405 [$21,418] vs. $159 [$116]; P < 0.05) and total health care costs
($97,854 [$9,248] vs. $32,239 [$1,611]; P < 0.001). Risk of re-hospitalization following discharge from the initial IMD admission was higher among complicated IMD
patients (hazard ratio = 1.69 [95% CI] = 1.04–2.74) vs. uncomplicated cases. CONCLUSIONS: Driven mainly be the need for repeat hospitalization, the presence of
serious complications in cases of IMD increased health care utilization and costs by
almost 3 fold compared to uncomplicated cases during 12 months post-diagnosis.
PIN14
COST-OF-ILLNESS OF CANDIDEMIA IN KOREA
1
2
3
4
5
5
Peck KR , Han SH , Chang HH , Jung SI , Oh JJ , Ko SK
1
Samsung Medical Center, Seoul, South Korea; 2Yonsei University College of Medicine,
Seoul, South Korea; 3Kyungpook National University Hospital, Daegu, South Korea;
4
Chonnam National University Hospital, Gwangju, South Korea; 5Pfizer Pharmaceuticals
Korea Ltd, Seoul, South Korea
OBJECTIVES: This study sought to estimate the direct medical costs associated treating candidemia in Korea. METHODS: This incidence based, cost-of-illness study
collected retrospective data of 200 patients in 4 tertiary hospitals. The cost data targeted for adult patients (≥19 years) diagnosed as candidemia through blood culture.
We assessed the costs attributable to candidemia by examining resources utilization
during candidemia treatment period. The medical costs were calculated by multiplying
quantity of resource utilization by unit cost of according resource. RESULTS: The
enrolled patients were 54.0% male, average 65.3 yrs old. The average length of stay
attributable to candidemia was 16.3 days. After 6 weeks follow up, only 2 patients
were relapsed, otherwise all-cause mortality rate was 66.0%. The estimated average
direct medical costs of candidemia were KRW 4,723,160. The resources consisted of
hospitalization (KRW 1,308,521, 27.7%), medication (KRW 1,310,739, 27.8%), lab
test (KRW 489,818, 10.4%), imaging test (KRW 157,633, 3.3%), procedure/surgery
(KRW 113,774, 2.4%) and other medical treatment (KRW 1,342,675, 28.4%). The
main occupied costs were those of hospitalization, medication and when other medical
treatment resources (e.g, hemodialysis, blood transfusion) were utilized, the costs
tended to sensitively increase. According to admission type, costs for ICU (SICU: n =
24, KRW 8,837,825, MICU: n = 51, KRW 6,914,280) were higher than those for
general ward (n = 125), KRW 3,039,167. Analysis by baseline disease/condition
revealed that the costs for transplant (n = 8, KRW 10,070,472), HIV/AIDS (n = 2,
KRW 25,426,018) were higher than others (cancer: n = 103, KRW 3,658,142, central
catheterization: n = 101, KRW 5,554,520, surgery: n = 68, KRW 5,050,941). The
costs for C.albicans (n = 90) were KRW 3,878,166 and for non C.albicans (n = 110)
were KRW 5,414,518. CONCLUSIONS: This study is significant in that it estimated
cost-of-illness of candidemia by examining the health resources consumption and
assessing the costs attributable to candidemia.
PIN15
THE ECONOMIC BURDEN OF SURGICAL SITE INFECTION USING
THERAPEUTIC ANTIBIOTIC UTILIZATION MEASURE—COMPARISON
OF TWO TIME PERIODS
Patkar AD1, Magee G2, Vaughn B1, Edmiston CE3, Vardireddy N2
1
Ethicon, Inc, Somerville, NJ, USA; 2Premier, Inc, Charlotte, NC, USA; 3Froedtert Hospital,
Milwaukee, WI, USA
OBJECTIVES: Significant attention is being focused on reducing surgical site infections (SSI) in the US and numerous national initiatives have been put into place to
achieve measurable reductions. The purpose of the study was to examine the economic
impact of therapeutic antibiotic (TA) utilization as an indicator of postoperative SSI
between two time periods. METHODS: Premier inpatient database was utilized for
assessing length of stay (LOS) and costs. Two time periods identified, 2005–2008
(period 1) and 2009 (period 2) with 1,138,989 patients discharged in 2005–2008 and
305,073 discharged in 2009. The patients with non-SSI nosocomial infections were
excluded. TA usage was determined by the antibiotic administration after day 4 of
surgery (TA utilization rate: 0.61% in 2005–2008; 0.75% in 2009). Multivariate
analysis used to assess the effects of using TA on LOS and total costs outcomes.
RESULTS: Patients receiving TA had significantly higher LOS and costs for both time
periods (P < 0.001). Average LOS for patients receiving TA was 12.2 and 12.6 for
periods 1 and 2 respectively. Mean post-surgical LOS was 9.8 and 10.0. Patients not
receiving TA had average LOS of 4.6 and 4.6 in periods 1 and 2 and mean postsurgical LOS was 3.9 and 3.8 for periods 1 and 2. Mean (SD) total costs for TA
patients were significantly higher, $28,601 ($31,892) in period 1 and $32,751
($38,194) in period 2, compared to $15,336 ($33,406) and $15,412 ($20,311) for
patients not receiving TA. Predictors for significantly higher risk of TA use included
General Surgery, Non-cardiac Thoracic procedures, bed-size under 500 or Rural, and
Staples or Non-absorbable sutures usage. CONCLUSIONS: These findings suggest
minimal impact on the SSI economic burden indicated by similar trends in antimicrobial utilization, costs and LOS over time. Further studies are warranted assessing the
role of innovative technology to improve patient outcomes while reducing antibiotic
utilization and LOS.
13th Euro Abstracts
PIN16
HEALTH CARE UTILIZATION AND COSTS ASSOCIATED WITH
HEPATITIS A IN A US COMMERCIALLY INSURED POPULATION
Eisenberg D1, Changolkar A2, Misurski D2
1
HealthCore, Wilmington, DE, USA; 2GSK, Philadelphia, PA, USA
OBJECTIVES: While the economic burden associated with acute hepatitis a outbreaks
studied, the impact on health care utilization and associated cost has not been examined over one year in a commercially insured population. METHODS: An observational, retrospective study using HealthCore Integrated Research Database (HIRDSM)
medical and pharmacy claims (January 1, 2004–December 31, 2009) was conducted.
Index date was assigned based on the first medical claim for hepatitis a (intake period
January 1, 2005—December 31, 2008). The control group did not have hepatitis. The
index date assigned was of the hepatitis a match. Subjects had continuous plan eligibility for ≥12 months pre- and post-index. Descriptive statistics, including t-tests and
chi-square analyses were used. RESULTS: Comparisons (n = 2331 for each cohort)
were significant (p < 0.01). Post-index inpatient hospitalization occurred for 482
(20.7%) hepatitis a patients and 193 (8.3%) controls. Associated mean costs (+SD)
were $5,401 (+/−$30,567) and $1,929 (+/−$23,282), respectively. Emergency room
(ER) services occurred in 382 (16.4%) hepatitis a subjects versus 277 (11.9%) controls. Mean costs were $231 (+/−$816) and $139 (+/−$604), respectively. The mean
number of outpatient services for the hepatitis a group was 21.5 (+/−22.1) versus 14.7
(+/−18.2) for controls with associated mean costs of $4,985 (+/−$14,936) and $2,948
(+/−$14,624), respectively. The mean number of physician visits were 9.1 (+/−9.9) and
5.5 (+/−7.4) for each group, respectively [mean costs = $1185 (+/−$3712) and $675
(+/−$2183)]. There were 20.13 (+/−24.1) and 19.37 (+/−24.5) pharmacy claims with
mean costs of $2255 (+/−$5828) and $1420 (+/−$2656), in the hepatitis a and controls. Mean total associated costs were $14,056 (+/−$42,666) and $7,111 (+/−
$30,519) in the hepatitis a and controls. CONCLUSIONS: In the 12-month post-index
period hepatitis a patients had greater total health care utilization and costs compared
to controls suggesting hepatitis a is associated with an increase in health care utilization and costs.
PIN17
IMPACT OF YELLOW FEVER OUTBREAKS IN BRAZIL, 2000–2009
Ramos CG, Ferreira Da Silva AL
Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sol, Porto Alegre, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the health and economic impact of the expansion of YF
virus in Brazil in the period of 2000–2009. METHODS: The perspective of study was
the public health care system. We evaluated the direct costs of hospitalization and YF
vaccine. Data source was the public official national information on YF cases and YF
vaccination from Brazilian Ministry of Health. We assumed that all cases required
hospitalization and that all fatalities required intensive care unit (ICU) hospitalization
and dialysis. All values were referent to December of 2009. The values of hospitalization by yellow fever, five days ICU hospitalization and five days dialysis paid by public
health system were, respectively, R$174.45 (c79.3); R$2393.60 (c1088) and R$ 557.1
(c253.23). RESULTS: During the evaluated period, YF virus circulation was detected
in eight states previously YF free. There were 320 cases of YF with lethality rate of
46.5%. The cumulative population vaccinated was 90,906,675 individuals. The YF
related hospitalization cost was R$ 495,478.30 (c225,217.41) and YF vaccine cost
was R$89,997,608 (c40,908,003.75) within the 10 year period evaluated. CONCLUSIONS: Even in areas with susceptive population there were few cases of yellow fever.
However, the significant clinical impact of the disease was due to its high lethality.
Despite the severity of yellow fever, hospitalization costs were modest in the study
period. The main cost was with the vaccine, the only form of prevention and control
of disease. Thereby, it is necessary to evaluate the financial impact of vaccinating the
areas that still have no evidence of the yellow fever virus, since there seems to be an
expansion tendency of YF virus circulation to the country as a whole and the vaccination could prevent YF cases and deaths.
PIN18
A PILOT COST-OF-ILLNESS STUDY ON LONG TERM COMPLICATIONS/
SEQUELAE FOLLOWING ACUTE OTITIS MEDIA (AOM) IN BELGIUM
Strens D1, Dhooge I2, Knerer G3, Van Vlaenderen I1
1
Deloitte, Diegem, Belgium; 2Ghent University Hospital, Ghent, Belgium; 3GlaxoSmithKline
Biologicals, Wavre, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: A study was carried out to assess the economic burden associated with
complications and/or long -term sequelae of AOM. This pilot study was done to assess
feasibility to extend to a larger sample. METHODS: A retrospective patient chart
review was performed in one Belgian center to obtain data on medical consumption
related to the management of complications/sequelae of AOM. Data were collected
for 10–15 years from the first AOM event onwards. Patients were eligible if they were
between 10 and 20 years old with minimum 9 years of follow up data available and
experienced a complication of AOM. Data on demographics, occurrence and type of
complication, management of AOM, complications and sequelae were collected per
year. Direct costs were calculated by multiplying each item of resource use with its
unit cost (2010 in c) using the Belgian public health care payer’s perspective. Average
(SD) yearly cost per patient, average yearly cost pre-complication, average cost during
the year of complication, average yearly cost post-complication were calculated.
RESULTS: Twenty-five patients were recruited in this pilot study. Complications were
chronic suppurative OM with cholesteatoma, chronic perforation of the tympanic
membrane and sensorineural hearing loss. The average yearly cost per patient was
A433
c966(SD:1579) with following components; hearing aid devices (c381(SD:1356)),
hospitalizations (c298(SD:250)), outpatient procedures (c121(SD:107)), visits (c91
(SD:183)), tests (c48(SD:46)) and drugs (c25(SD:89)). a complication occurred on
average 5.3 years (SD: 2.9) after the first AOM event. Average annual cost pre-complication was c232(SD:218), with outpatient procedures as main cost drivers. Average
cost of complication per annum was c2808(SD:4827), average yearly cost postcomplication was c1593(SD:3366). As from occurrence of complication onwards costs
are mainly driven by hospitalizations and hearing aid devices. CONCLUSIONS: Long
term complications/sequelae of AOM result in considerable costs for the health care
payer, mainly driven by hospitalizations, and hearing aid devices.
PIN19
HEPATITIS C BURDEN IN RUSSIA
Omelyanovsky VV, Avksentieva MV, Krysanov I, Ivakhnenko O
Research Center for Clinical and Economic Evaluation and Pharmacoeconomics, Moscow,
Russia
OBJECTIVES: To assess social and economic burden of a hepatitis Ñ infection in
Russian Federation. METHODS: Cost of illness analysis was performed. Available
data on epidemiology of hepatitis C infection in Russian Federation has been analyzed.
Experts were surveyed to describe common practice of treating patients with acute
and chronic hepatitis C. Costs of medical care were calculated from the health care
system point of view. RESULTS: State registration of hepatitis C infection has been
launched in 1994. The incidence of acute hepatitis C is decreasing while there is
increase in chronic hepatitis C new cases. Number of people with asymptomatic virus
carriage was increasing till 2001 and has been slowly decreasing since then. There is
no data about hepatitis C prevalence in Russia. Expected economic burden was calculated on the basis of several assumptions: 1) only new cases of chronic hepatitis C
are treated; 2) all new cases of acute hepatitis C are hospitalized, all new cases of
chronic hepatitis C get hospital treatment first, then out-patient treatment; 3) and only
15 % of all patients with chronic hepatitis C receive treatment with pegylated interferons and ribavirin reimbursed from national health care system. CONCLUSIONS:
Based on these assumptions expected economic burden of hepatitis C infection in
Russian Federation is about c0,16 million.
PIN20
PSEUDOMONAS AERUGINOSA RELATED ECONOMIC BURDEN
STRATIFIED BY COMORBIDITY IN CYSTIC FIBROSIS PATIENTS
Sansgiry S1, Joish V2, Boklage S2, Goyal RK1, Seal B2, Sethi S3
1
University of Houston, Houston, TX, USA; 2Bayer, Wayne, NJ, USA, 3University at Buffalo,
SUNY, Buffalo, NY, USA
OBJECTIVES: To determine if the average cost of medical care among cystic fibrosis
(CF) patients post Pseudomonas aeruginosa (PA) infection is different for those with
underlying comorbid conditions. METHODS: MarketScan claims database which
captures person-specific direct medical utilization, expenditures, and enrollment from
approximately 150 payers was used to conduct a retrospective cross-sectional study.
CF subjects with an initial claim for a PA infection were identified using international
classification of diseases diagnosis codes of 277.0 and 482.1, respectively. Demographic information from administrative claims and health care utilization and costs
from medical and pharmacy claims were extracted for 12 months post initial PA claim.
All resource use and costs were annualized and compared among subjects with comorbidity and the overall sample using SAS version 9.2. RESULTS: Of the 347 CF subjects
with PA infection that met the study criteria, 79% had multiple co-morbidities, 67%
had pancreatic insufficiency, followed by chronic sinusitis (19%), CF-related diabetes
(13%), bronchiectasis (7%), and osteoporosis (5%). Subjects had a mean age of 20
years (SD 15.4) and 47.8% were females. As compared to an average CF subject,
those with multiple co-morbidities had significantly higher (P < .05) overall pharmacy
claims (mean 39 vs. 44) and cost (mean $20,673 vs. $24,121, median $17,121 vs.
$22,344). Overall cost in subjects with CF-related diabetes (mean = $66,364 and
median = $60,759) and osteoporosis (mean = $88,703 and median = $55,686) was
significantly (P < 0.05) greater as compared to an average CF subject (mean = $51,821
and median = $36,046). Among CF-related diabetic subjects and osteoporosis subjects,
significantly (P < 0.05) higher outpatient visits and pharmacy claims and higher
inpatient costs contributed to overall increase in health care costs compared to the
average CF subject. CONCLUSIONS: Overall post-PA infection medical care costs
were higher in comorbid cohorts compared to the overall CF sample. Future research
needs to determine cost-effectiveness of PA infection treatment for among these comorbid conditions.
PIN21
EMPIRIC ANTIBIOTIC PRRESCRIBING IN SUBJECTS WITH INFLUENZA
IN A UNITED STATES COMMERCIALLY INSURED POPULATION
Misurski DA1, Lipson D2, Changolkar AK1
1
GlaxoSmithKline, Philadelphia, PA, USA; 2GlaxoSmithKline, King of Prussia, PA, USA
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate empiric antibiotic prescribing and associated costs in commercially insured members with seasonal influenza. METHODS: This retrospective
analysis was conducted using Impact National Benchmark Database pharmacy,
medical, and confinement claim data (01/01/2004 through 12/31/2009). The index
date was defined as the first influenza (ICD-9:487.xx) claim, within the intake period
(01/01/2005 through 11/30/2009). Subjects had continuous eligibility for ≥12 months
prior to and one month after the index date. We used the first influenza event only.
Subjects with a pre-index diagnosis requiring antibiotic treatment were excluded.
A434
Influenza subjects with an antiviral claim within one day pre- and one day post-index
and/or an antibiotic claim within three days pre- and three days post-index were
identified. Subjects with a secondary respiratory infection within the two week postindex period were identified via ICD-9 codes. RESULTS: The study cohort included
270,057 members with influenza (51.8% male; mean age 31.6 years). Antibiotics were
prescribed in 63,358 (23.5%) of subjects (42,374 [15.7%] received an antibiotic only;
20,984 [7.8%] received both an antiviral and an antibiotic). The majority of subjects
with influenza (157,447 [58.3%]) did not receive an antiviral. Among subjects receiving antibiotic treatment, 98.9% did not have a follow-up coded respiratory bacterial
infection within two weeks. The mean antibiotic costs were $66.15 and $42.71 for
subjects with and without a secondary bacterial respiratory infection, respectively.
Antibiotic usage in influenza subjects without a secondary bacterial respiratory infection accounted for approximately $2.7M (2009 US$). CONCLUSIONS: Almost all
subjects with influenza receiving antibiotic treatment did not have a secondary bacterial respiratory condition. The cost associated with the empiric prescribing of antibiotics was considerable. Furthermore, over half the subjects with influenza did not receive
antiviral therapy. As our study only allowed for one case per subject the total cost
associated with empiric antibiotic prescribing in subjects with influenza is likely an
underestimate.
PIN22
A NOVEL APPROACH FOR ESTIMATING THE VALUE OF ENTECAVIR
THERAPY FOR NUCLEOSIDE-NAÏVE CHRONIC HEPATITIS B PATIENTS
IN SPAIN
Ramirez de Arellano A1, Fernandez-Rodriguez C2, Andrade R3, Clemente G4, Sola R5,
Wells J6, Rentero P1
1
Bristol-Myers Squibb Iberia, Madrid, Spain; 2Hospital Fundación Alcorcón, Madrid, Spain;
3
Hospital Virgen de la Victoria, Malaga, Spain; 4General Hospital Gregorio Marañon, Madrid,
Spain; 5Hospital del Mar (IMIM), Barcelona, Spain; 6Monitor Group, London, UK
OBJECTIVES: Prescribers, payers and health care decision-makers operating in
diverse health care settings are increasingly examining the value of innovative treatments. The analysis aims at estimating the relative value of the two preferred first-line
oral antiviral treatment options for chronic hepatitis B (CHB) according to the EASL
guidelines: entecavir (ETV) and tenofovir (TDF) from a Spanish payer’s perspective.
METHODS: Hepatitis B disease was simulated using a health-state transition model
with disease-states defined as mild disease (Ishak F0/F1), fibrosis (F2–F4) and advanced
fibrosis/cirrhosis (>F4), and complicated disease-states (decompensated cirrhosis,
hepatocellular carcinoma, liver transplant and death) based on available natural
history data. The value of treatment-specific attributes on disease progression/regression was estimated from clinical practice data in real world settings in terms of lifetime
events and costs avoided. Treatment attributes included: additional testing requirements at treatment initiation and required renal function monitoring; adverse events
per product labelling; reversal of fibrosis; and treatment intensification in case of
suboptimal viral suppression to avoid potential resistance. a 5-year treatment duration
was assumed. Primary model output is the estimated cost avoided per-patient per day
of treatment, associated with the clinical attributes of ETV compared to TDF in the
treatment of nucleoside-naïve HBeAg-positive and -negative CHB patients. RESULTS:
The daily cost of antiviral therapy for a CHB patient was estimated at c13.2 for ETV
compared to c9.6 with TDF. Lifetime treatment cost avoided due to ETV’s clinical
attributes was quantified at c3.6 [95% confidence: interval: 2, 5.2] per day of therapy.
CONCLUSIONS: Estimating total treatment cost-avoidance associated with specific
clinical attributes is a novel approach in assessing the value of treatment options. ETV
exhibits the characteristics of a favourable CHB treatment option, which directly
translates into economic and therapeutic added value.
PIN23
DIFFERENTIAL PRICING POLICY AND ITS IMPACT ON TREAMENT
COSTS OF VISCERAL LEISHMANIASIS IN THE BRAZILIAN PUBLIC
HEALTH SYSTEM
Marinho DS1, Romero CNP1, Cechinel MP2, Martins EV1, Morel CM1
1
Oswaldo Cruz Foundation, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil; 2Brazilian Ministry of Health, Brasília, Brazil
BACKGROUND: Visceral leishmaniasis (VL) (“Kalazar”) is an important public
health issue in Brazil. The guidelines of Brazilian Ministry of Health set up pentavalent
antimony as the first line treatment, and amphotericin (deoxicolate and liposomal) as
the second line treatment of VL. There are evidences that liposomal amphotericin (LA)
and amphotericin deoxicolate (AD) present similiar efficacy, but LA has a better safety
profile. Unfortunately, its price has been the principal barrier to its usage by public
health system. OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the impact of differential pricing policy of
LA in the Brazilian public health system. METHODS: The global amount spent on
medicines from 2007 to 2009 by the Ministry of Health on the different types of
treatment was retrieved from the Brazilian sanitary surveillance system. The following
associated costs were also analyzed: hospital care and professional services; laboratorial tests (potassium, urea, creatinine and transaminases); and loss of working days
(average daily income). This information allowed us to perform the cost analysis of
the different therapeutic options. RESULTS: The differential pricing policy for LA
implemented in 2008 allowed a cost reduction of 76.8% (from US$5.881 to US$590
per treatment) enabling the Ministry of Health to double the number of patients
treated with LA. The associated costs of hospitalization and loss of productivity by
patients are higher with AD than with LA, but the total cost of LA treatment (medication + associated costs) is still 11.3% to 27% higher. CONCLUSIONS: In a societal
perspective it was shown that a substantial price reduction of a safer drug enhanced
13th Euro Abstracts
its use and distribution by the Ministry of Health. It became also evident that the
policy of differential pricing is an effective way to promote access to an efficient and
safer treatment of VL, a disease that mainly affects the poor.
PIN24
IMPACT OF APPROPRIATE PRESCRIBING OF ANTIBIOTICS ON
TREATMENT OUTCOMES, DAYS OF PATIENT HOSPITALIZATION AND
COSTS OF ANTIBIOTIC TREATMENT IN HOSPITALS IN LESOTHO
Adorka MKB1, Serfontein JHP2, Lubbe MS2, Gous AGS3
1
National University of Lesotho, Roma, Lesotho; 2North-West University, Potchefstroom,
South Africa; 3University of Limpopo, Pretoria, South Africa
OBJECTIVES: The primary aim of this study was to determine the possible impact
of appropriate prescribing of antibiotics on treatment outcomes, days of patient
hospitalization and costs related to antibiotic treatment. METHODS: Data from case
notes of all inpatients on antibiotic treatment and all antibiotic prescriptions from
outpatient departments were collected from June 15 to July 15, 2006 at 5 government
and mission hospitals in Lesotho. All prescriptions were classified into categories of
appropriateness based on their conformities to criteria developed from principles of
antibiotic prescribing. Analyses were further conducted to determine the possible
impact that appropriate prescribing may have on treatment outcomes, days of patient
hospitalization and costs of antibiotic treatments. RESULTS: A total of 307 inpatients
and 867 outpatient prescriptions were assessed. Total frequencies of prescribed antibiotics were 584 and 1073 for inpatients and outpatients respectively. For inpatients
antibiotics were most often prescribed for skin and soft tissue (31.7%) and respiratory
tract (28.9%) infections. Outpatients received most antibiotics for respiratory tract
(42.0%) and skin and soft tissue infection (21.9%) respectively. Of the 307 inpatient
prescriptions 41.6% were appropriately written for either empiric treatment or prophylaxis of infections while 57.1% did not conform to antibiotic prescribing principles. a majority (81.0%) of outpatient prescriptions were in line with the prescribing
principles. Inpatient antibiotic prescribing patterns based on principles of antibiotic
prescribing have had a positive impact on treatment outcomes, days of hospitalization
and costs of antibiotic treatment. In outpatients prescribing of antibiotics based on
principles of antibiotic prescribing failed to show any significant impact on costs of
antibiotics. Due to geographical challenges the outcome for treatment could not be
determined for outpatients. CONCLUSIONS: Rational prescribing had a positive
impact on treatment outcomes.
PIN25
SEASONAL INFLUENZA VACCINATION OF HEALTHY, WORKING-AGE
ADULTS: A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW OF ECONOMIC INVESTIGATIONS
Gatwood J1, Meltzer M2, Messonnier M2, Prosser LA1
1
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA; 2Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,
Atlanta, GA, USA
OBJECTIVES: To assess cost-benefit and cost-effectiveness studies examining seasonal
influenza vaccination in the healthy, working-age population of the United States (US).
METHODS: A systematic review of economic evaluations investigating the costbenefit or cost-effectiveness of vaccinating healthy adults was conducted on articles
published between January 1990 and January 2010. Studies considered for inclusion
in this review were identified using Medline, Embase, Econlit, and Google Scholar (n
= 11). The source and appropriateness of parameters (epidemiological data, probabilities, and costs), the designs employed, and the sufficiency of sensitivity analysis were
considered during the review. RESULTS: Seven studies were identified as appropriate
for this review. Key inputs of the selected studies included influenza or ILI attack rates,
outpatient visits averted, total vaccination costs, and lost workdays. All studies were
conducted in the US and from the societal perspective; three were randomized, clinical
trials and the remaining four constructed economic simulation models to compare
vaccination to antivirals or no intervention. Results ranged from net savings of $69.19
to net costs of $85.89 per vaccination (4 studies) and from $103.95 to $1004.85 per
episode of influenza averted (1 study). Only 2 studies reported cost-effectiveness ratios;
these ranged from $6,930 to $50,510 per quality-adjusted life-year gained. Nearly all
of the studies conducted sensitivity analysis; results were most sensitive to variation
in wage rates, levels of worker productivity, the cost and effectiveness of vaccination,
and the rate of illness. CONCLUSIONS: This systematic review found that seasonal
influenza vaccination of healthy, working-age adults is generally not cost saving,
requiring an investment to generate health benefits. The decision to vaccinate such a
group will depend upon the societal and payer valuation of those benefits.
PIN26
EARLY VS. LATE DETECTION OF HIV IN UK: COST CONSEQUENCE
STUDY
Mesa OA1, Mason N1, Zah V2
1
Bristol-Myers Squibb Pharmaceuticals Ltd, Uxbridge, Middlesex, UK; 2ZRx Outcomes
Research Inc, Toronto, ON, Canada
OBJECTIVES: Identifying budgetary implications and opportunities for earlier detection versus late detection of HIV (CD4 cell count less than 200/µl) in the 1 through
5 year term following diagnosis. In 2009, there were 90,468 HIV positive individuals
not accounting for unreported HIV positive cases (in 2008, estimated additional 24%).
Late detection HIV patients account for 32% from the total. METHODS: A literature
review was conducted using MEDLINE, Cochrane Library, EMBASE and CRD for
guidelines and clinical trials published 1995–2010 in UK, England, Scotland, Wales,
Northern Ireland, USA, Canada, Australia, Norway and EU-26. We extrapolated UK
13th Euro Abstracts
population breakdown, survival rates, average costs of triple and quadruple HAART
(Highly Active Antiretroviral Therapy) therapy, inpatient, outpatient care costs—HIV
related HRG costs and excess cost ratio due to late presentation. Study follows standard good modeling practices by discounting, adjusting for survival, and considering
multiple time horizons for analyses. UK data sources include: BHIVA, NHS, HPA and
SOPHID. RESULTS: From 1995–2010 literature review yielded 126 publications
related to late detection, of which 18 were included in our study design. The number
of publications has rapidly increased over the last 12 months. Preliminary results
suggest that 10% of HIV detection shift from late to early detection (2655 patients
or 3.2% of Late HIV detection) would result in £20.3 million conservative savings
just in the first year (keeping index multiplier scalar for HIV spread rate at zero). Over
5-year term, such annual shift would result in 708.25 life-years saved or £14.2 million
in additional savings. CONCLUSIONS: Enhanced testing to achieve earlier detection
and initiation on HAART could potentially reduce overall costs of HIV medical care.
Further research is required to determine additional budgetary implications of HIV
comorbidity patterns.
PIN27
COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS OF HPV VACCINATION AGAINST
CERVICAL CANCER IN YOUNG ADULT WOMEN IN ITALY
La Torre G1, Gabutti G2, Cristoforoni P3, Bonanni P4, Amunni G4, Costa S5, Capri S6
1
Sapienza University of Rome, Rome, Italy; 2University of Ferrara, Ferrara, Italy; 3National
Institute for Cancer Research, IST Genova, Genova, Italy; 4University of Florence, Florence,
Italy; 5St. Orsola-Malpighi University Hospital, Bologna, Italy; 6Cattaneo-LIUC University,
Castellanza, Varese, Italy
OBJECTIVES: Human papillomavirus (HPV) has been implicated as a causal factor
in cervical cancer (CC), the second most common cancer among women worldwide.
Prophylactic vaccination against HPV-16/18 has been shown to be highly effective in
preventing HPV related infections and pre-cancerous lesions. The aim of this study
was to determine the potential clinical and economic impact of combining CC screening programme with HPV vaccination programme with the bivalent HPV-16/18
vaccine in women aged 25 (when CC screening starts) compared to screening alone.
METHODS: A Markov cohort model was adapted to the Italian setting. The model
replicates the HPV infection natural history leading to CC and includes the effect of
screening and vaccination. Based on the latest results of the PATRICIA clinical trial
for the bivalent vaccine, the vaccine efficacy includes cross-protection against nonvaccine HPV types 31/33/35/39/45/51/52/56/58/59. The vaccine efficacy in naïve girls
and HPV-exposed women (>17-years old) was differentiated. Lifetime protection and
90% vaccination coverage were assumed. Costing was analyzed from the perspective
of the Italian health care system. Main outcomes are lifetime costs, QALYs, CC cases,
deaths and ICER. Both costs and effects were discounted at 3% annually to calculate
the ICER. RESULTS: The model shows that, compared to screening alone, vaccinating
a single cohort of 330,000 women aged 25 would prevent over a lifetime 696 CC
cases and 316 CC deaths (undiscounted) of which 131 and 59 respectively are due to
cross-protection, with a discounted ICER of c33,918 per QALY gained. The ICER
remains under the cost-effective threshold defined by the WHO (between 1 and
3xGDP/capita). CONCLUSIONS: Under the assumptions of the model, extending
vaccination to young adult women post-HPV exposure could lead to a substantial
reduction in CC and remains cost-effective in Italy compared with screening alone.
Cross-protection would play an important role in this reduction.
PIN28
IMPACT OF METHODOLOGICAL CHOICES AND ASSUMPTIONS IN
ECONOMIC EVALUATIONS OF ROTAVIRUS VACCINATION
Millier A1, Aballea S1, Petrou S2, Quilici S3
1
Creativ Ceutical, Paris, France; 2University of Oxford, Oxford, England; 3Sanofi Pasteur
MSD, Lyon, France
OBJECTIVES: Rotavirus is the leading cause of severe gastroenteritis in children under
5 years. Two vaccines are currently available: RotaTeq® (Merck/Sanofi Pasteur MSD)
and Rotarix® (GSK). Published economic models on rotavirus vaccination have produced contradicting results. We reviewed and critically appraised existing economic
models. METHODS: The literature search covered worldwide cost-effectiveness
models of RotaTeq® and Rotarix® published or presented at conferences until
October 2009. We extracted information on model structures, input data (epidemiology, vaccine efficacy, utilities, vaccination costs) and results. RESULTS: We identified
44 publications referring to distinct cost-effectiveness analyses.18 used cost per QALY
as primary outcome, providing 22 incremental cost-utility ratios (ICURs) for highincome countries. Thirteen ICURs came from health authorities and 9 from manufacturers. While some European studies predicted cost-savings from societal perspective,
the ICUR was estimated at up c160,000 per QALY for the UK, from NHS perspective.
5 of 13 analyses from health authorities reported ICURs below c30,000 per QALY
gained, compared to 7 of 9 studies from manufacturers. There were many differences
between models, such as perspective, epidemiological inputs, vaccine efficacy and
vaccination costs. However differences in results were mainly driven by assumptions
related to estimation of QALYs: utility values, duration of symptoms, inclusion of
quality of life burden for caregivers and for cases without medical attention. CONCLUSIONS: Results of cost-effectiveness analyses are highly variable due to uncertainty surrounding epidemiological inputs, and most importantly to assumptions for
deriving QALYs. Different choices were attributable to different value judgments, and
to the difficulty of measuring and valuing quality of life in children, which lead to a
situation where neither manufacturers nor health authorities obtained valid utilities.
A435
There is currently no valid reference case for cost-utility analyses in paediatrics. More
open communication and expertise sharing between authorities and manufacturers
could lead to more reliable analyses.
PIN29
A DYNAMIC MODEL TO EVALUATE THE COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF
10-VALENT PNEUMOCOCCAL CONJUGATE VACCINE IN TAIWAN
Chang CJ1, Wu BS2, Wu CL1, Lin YJ1, Fann SJ3
1
Chang Gung University, Taoyuan, Taiwan; 2National Yang-Ming University, Taipei, Taiwan;
3
Academia Sinica, Taipei, Taiwan
OBJECTIVES: Streptococcus pneumonia is associated with two invasive diseases
(meningitis and bacteremia) and non-invasive disease (pneumococcal pneumonia),
which has caused high morbidity and mortality in infants and the elderly in Taiwan.
a cost-effectiveness analysis of pneumococcal conjugate vaccine (PCV 10) in Taiwan
was conducted using transmission-dynamic model. METHODS: As static pharmacoeconomic model fails to account for vaccination-induced herd-immunity, we developed an age-structured multi-compartment dynamic model to estimate both economic
and clinical impact of universal PCV10 vaccination over 10-year time horizon under
health care system’s perspective in Taiwan. Model parameters such as economic and
clinical burden of pneumococcal diseases in Taiwanese population, vaccine efficacy,
utilities and demographic parameters were captured by retrospective population-based
National Health Insurance Reimbursement Database (NHIRD), published sources,
unpublished data, and assumptions made in consultation with clinical experts. Univariate sensitivity analyses were conducted to test the robustness of model parameters.
RESULTS: Assuming a four-dose schedule and 90% of vaccination coverage for both
vaccines, universal infant vaccination with PCV10 would prevent 133 cases of IPD,
122,476 cases of pneumococcal pneumonia and 3,857 deaths, an equivalent of 93,393
life-years and leads to a net medical cost savings of NT$ 6,047.4 million, compared
to no vaccination. At the current proposed price of NT$2,700 for PCV10, the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) is expected to be cost-effective with NT$106,362
(US$3,324) per life-year gained. The program’s cost-effectiveness results are highly
sensitive to the vaccine price and number of doses while not sensitive to uncertainty
in disease incidence and costs of treatment. CONCLUSIONS: Universal pediatric
PCV10 vaccination in Taiwan is estimated to have considerable impact on reducing
the burden of pneumococcal diseases and expected to be cost-effective in payer’s
perspective compared to no vaccination.
PIN30
ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF DAPTOMYCIN AS FIRST-LINE THERAPY
VERSUS DAPTOMYCIN AS RESCUE THERAPY AFTER VANCOMYCIN OR
LINEZOLID FAILURE IN GRAM-POSITIVE BACTEREMIA TREATMENT
Lahoz R1, Galera J1, Font B1, Gil Parrado S1, Soengas C1, Grau S2
1
Novartis Pharma, Barcelona, Spain; 2Hospital del Mar (IMIM), Barcelona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: To assess the efficiency of daptomycin as first-line therapy (D) versus
daptomycin as rescue therapy after failure of vancomycin (V+D) or linezolid (L+D) in
gram-positive bacteremia treatment. METHODS: A cost-effectiveness analysis comparing the three therapeutic alternatives (D, V+D and L+D) was performed using data
from a previous observational study (EUCORE). In the present sub-study, data on 19
(D), 33 (V+D) and 19 (L+D) bacteremic patients were analyzed. Effectiveness was
measured in terms of cure or clinical improvement. Costs were gathered from “BOT”
and “e-salud” Spanish databases. Direct costs (medication and hospitalization) due to
bacteremia were included. Costs are expressed in 2009 Euros. Patients were observed
until either end of daptomycin therapy or exitus. a probabilistic multivariate sensitivity
analysis was carried out. Dispersion was estimated using bootstrap (three alternative
scenarios were considered in the simulations: 50%, 25% and 10% of the estimated
dispersion) and Monte Carlo simulations were performed for both costs (log-normally
distributed) and effectiveness (normally distributed) measures. RESULTS: Effectiveness figures: D: 84.2% (95%CI: 60.4%–96.6%); V+D: 87.9% (95%CI: 71.8%–
96.6%); L+D: 68.4% (95% CI: 43.5%–87.4%); pvalue = 0.206 (Chi2). Average costs
per treated patient: D: c6672.8 (95%CI: 4076.8–9268.8); V+D: c9786.6 (95%CI:
7,124.7–12,448.5); L+D: c12,190.4 (95%CI: 8,693.2–15,687.7); pvalue < 0.001
(Kruskal-Wallis). Cost-Effectiveness Incremental Ratios: c53,478.8 (D versus V+D)
and −c6,639.5 (D versus L+D) per additional cured patient. Sensitivity analysis results:
D versus V+D: D is efficient with lower costs (in 41.2%–77.9% of the simulations)
and dominant (22.1%–38.0%); D versus L+D: D is dominant (44.6%–99.6%) and
efficient with lower costs (0.4%–30.0%). CONCLUSIONS: Daptomycin as first-line
therapy is mainly a dominant alternative when compared to daptomycin as rescue
therapy after linezolid failure, showing better clinical results with lower associated
costs. Daptomycin as first-line therapy does not show significant differences in effectiveness when compared to daptomycin as rescue therapy after vancomycin failure,
but it shows significantly lower costs.
PIN31
PHARMACOECONOMIC MODELING USING THE 13-VALENT
PNEUMOCOCCAL CONJUGATE VACCINE IN GERMAN ADULTS
Claes C1, Pletz MW2, van der Linden M3, Welte T2, Graf von der Schulenburg J-M1
1
Leibniz University of Hannover, Hannover, Germany; 2Medical School Hannover (MHH),
Hannover, Germany; 3Universitaetsklinikum Aachen, Aachen, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Vaccination with the 23-valent pneumococcal polysaccharide vaccine
(PPV23) is the current standard in Germany for diagnosis defined risk groups (age
5–59 years) and for seniors (≥60 years). a redefinition of this recommendation
A436
following market authorization of the 13-valent pneumococcal conjugate vaccine
(PCV13) for adults might be considered. Thus, this study analyzes potential costeffectiveness of an adult vaccination with PCV13 from the point of view of the German
social health insurance. METHODS: In a cross-sectional steady state Markov model,
efficacies of the vaccines on invasive pneumococcal diseases (IPD), and communityacquired pneumonia (CAP, treated in either a hospital or a nonhospital setting) were
calculated. a steady state is defined as a setting in which the whole population (including new entrants) is vaccinated as recommended. The modeling of PPV23 and PCV13
distinguished between risk groups and both vaccines were compared to non-vaccination. Data on PCV13 were derived from published results on the 7-valent pneumococcal conjugate vaccine (PCV7). The effectiveness of individual pneumococcal
vaccination of adults was adjusted for expected herd immunity effects of a pediatric
vaccination with PCV. Utilization of health care services and unit costs were taken
from publicly accessible data bases. RESULTS: Compared to PPV23, PCV13 revealed
the potential to avoid a greater number of yearly cases and deaths due to IPD and
CAP in Germany. For PCV13 it can be expected that monetary savings, resulting e.g.
from less hospitalization, compensate the costs of the vaccination program. The
preliminary version of the model concludes that the cost-benefit ratio is 1.16, i. e. c1
spend on vaccination saves c1.16 treatment cost. CONCLUSIONS: Our model shows
that the health economic benefit of an immunization of adults with PCV13 can be
expected to be higher than that of PPV23.
PIN32
ECONOMIC IMPACT OF THE 10-VALENT PNEUMOCOCCAL NONTYPEABLE HEMOPHILUS INFLUENZAE PROTEIN D CONJUGATE
VACCINE (PHID-CV) IN A COHORT OF NEWBORN IN HONG KONG
Lee KK1, Hon EK2, Lee VW2, So TM3, Chow DP2
1
Monash University Kuala Lumpur Sunway Campus, Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia; 2Chinese
University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, China; 3Princess Margaret Hospital, Hong Kong, China
OBJECTIVES: To examine the health and economic impact of PHiD-CV in the public
sector of Hong Kong compared to no vaccination. METHODS: A Markov analytical
model modified from the recent Cost-effectiveness Cohort Model for Synflorix (COSY
Model by HE-group, GCRD, GSK bio, Wavre, Belgium, 2010) was used for the
analysis of the outcomes of vaccination. The cohort model simulates in a birth cohort
of 82,100 newborns the disease process of invasive disease (ID) (meningitis and
bacteremia), community acquired pneumonia (CAP), and acute otitis media (AOM)
over life-time caused by S pneumoniae and Non-typeable H influenzae (NTHi) within
‘monthly’ cycles. Superimposed on the disease process is integrated in the model its
disease management expressed in hospitalization rates, medical visits, and specific
interventions such as myringotomies. The epidemiology and disease management is
Hong Kong specific. The study was performed from a health care payer’s perspective.
RESULTS: The study shows for a 4-dose regimen of PHiD-CV compared to no vaccination over a period of 100 years: a gain of 234 quality-adjusted-life-years (QALY);
an avoidance of 16 cases of IPD, 873 cases of pneumonia, 26,746 cases of AOM and
25,885 sequelae. Using a 5% discount for cost and benefits, cost/QALY gained was
estimated to be HKD261,492. CONCLUSIONS: With GDP per capita of Hong Kong
being HKD233,060 in 2009, our study results suggest PHiD-CV vaccination is costeffective in providing protection to the people of Hong Kong based on the WHO
recommended thresholds for cost-effectiveness.
PIN33
THE POTENTIAL PUBLIC HEALTH BENEFIT OF PNEUMOCOCCAL
CONJUGATE VACCINES: EXAMPLE OF THE CZECH REPUBLIC
Dolezal T1, Skoupá J2, Mrkvan T3, Topachevskyi O4
1
Institute for Health Economics and Technology Assessment, Prague, Czech Republic;
2
Pharma Projects s.r.o., Prague, Czech Republic; 3GlaxoSmithKline, Prague, Czech Republic;
4
GlaxoSmithKline Biologicals, Wavre, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate cost-effectiveness of routine pneumococcal vaccination
with 10-valent pneumococcal non-typeable Haemophilus influenzae protein-D vaccine
(PHiD-CV) compared with 13-valent pneumococcal conjugate vaccine (PCV-13) and
no vaccination. METHODS: A Markov cohort model with a 100-year time horizon
was developed to project the impact of vaccination on the incidence of pneumococcal
and non-typeable Haemophilus Influenzae (NTHi) infections in children and adults.
Data Sources: Czech Republic-specific epidemiological and demographic data and data
from other country sources. Base-case assumptions include estimates of pneumococcal
and NTHi infection rates as well as vaccine efficacy based on published literature.
Model inputs: payer perspective, 80% vaccine coverage, no herd protection and a (3
+ 1) vaccination schedule. One-way sensitivity analyses performed to assess the impact
of changes in key model assumptions. RESULTS: PHiD-CV and PCV-13 are projected
to prevent more cases of invasive disease (89 and 92 respectively) and pneumonia
hospitalizations (738 and 760 respectively) compared with no vaccination. PHiD-CV
and PCV-13 are projected to prevent additional GPP/ENT visits due to acute otitis
media (AOM) (7851 and 3838 respectively) compared with no vaccination strategy.
The total number of cases of invasive disease was comparable for both vaccines but
PHiD-CV is estimated to prevent more than 14 000 cases of AOM in comparison
with PCV-13. Vaccinating a birth cohort with PHiD-CV is expected to generate 75.5
more QALYs and 5.9 LYG compared to PCV-13. Under vaccine price parity assumptions, estimated total savings for health care system are 10.2 mil CZK or 395.6 k EUR
for PHiD-CV compared to PCV-13 respectively. Sensitivity analyses indicate that
AOM efficacy and incidence of AOM related GPP/ENT visits have biggest impact on
results. CONCLUSIONS: Overall, PHiD-CV is expected to have better quality of life
13th Euro Abstracts
impact than PCV-13. Under price parity assumptions, PHiD-CV dominates PCV-13
because it also has a larger cost offsets.
PIN34
A CONTINUOUS-TIME ECONOMIC MODEL TO EVALUATE
RALTEGRAVIR USE STRATEGIES IN TREATMENT-NAIVE HIV-1
PATIENTS IN PORTUGAL
Chaudhary MA1, Elbasha EH1, Pereira R2, Kumar RN3
1
Merck & Co., Inc., North Wales, PA, USA; 2Merck Sharp & Dohme, Lda., Lisbon, Portugal;
3
Merck & Co., Inc., Whitehouse Station, NJ, USA
OBJECTIVES: In contrast to commonly used discrete-time Markov models, we developed a more realistic continuous-time multi-stage Markov model to evaluate long-term
clinical and economic outcomes of raltegravir in treatment naïve HIV-1 patients.
METHODS: The multi-stage cost-effectiveness model incorporating 3 lines of therapy
was developed using differential equations and was solved in Mathematica® 6.0. The
analysis was conducted from the perspective of the National payer in Portugal. a
typical patient enters the model in a given health state, transitions to another health
state, can develop acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS)/ coronary heart
disease (CHD)/other adverse events or die. Eighteen health states were defined based
on CD4 and HIV RNA levels. We used the maximum likelihood method to estimate
matrices of instantaneous transition rates corresponding to the efficacy of the included
therapies. Six multi-stage treatment strategies depicting clinical practice in Portugal
were evaluated. The model outputs included projected number of AIDS and CHD
events, life expectancy and incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICER). The model
was evaluated for internal and external validity and extensive sensitivity analyses were
conducted. RESULTS: The predicted prevalence of patients in different health states
over time provided a good fit to the clinical trial data. Strategies where raltegravir was
included in the initiating therapy followed by an NNRTI or PI based regimen against
efavirenz or PI based initiating therapies followed by raltegravir resulted in longer
undiscounted life expectancy [20.07 Yrs. vs. 18.88 Yrs] and demonstrated costeffectiveness [ICERs: c1,078–c33,406/QALY]. CONCLUSIONS: Continuous-time
Markov modeling based on transition matrices estimated using robust statistical
methodology is a more realistic and sound approach. Results suggest initiating therapy
on raltegravir generated lower costs and higher survival versus saving the drug for
later lines of therapy in Portugal.
PIN36
ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF AZITHROMYCIN COMPARED WITH
OTHER ANTIBIOTICS FOR COMMUNITY-ACQUIRED PNEUMONIA AND
SINUSITIS TREATMENT
Sveshnikova ND1, Omelyanovsky VV2, Khachatryan G1, Ilkovitch J3
1
Institute of Clinico-Economic Expertise and Pharmacoeconomics, RSMU, Moscow, Russia;
2
Research Center for Clinical and Economic Evaluation and Pharmacoeconomics, Moscow,
Russia; 3Research Institute for Pulmonology of Pavlov’ State Medical University,
Saint-Petersburg, Russia
OBJECTIVES: To assess clinical efficacy and economic effectiveness of Azithromycin
compared with other antibiotics for community-acquired pneumonia (CAP) and sinusitis treatment. METHODS: Decision tree was used to calculate costs of antibiotic
treatment. The chance nodes included treatment failures and introduction of secondline therapy or hospitalization. Transition probabilities were obtained from clinical
trials. Preferred antibiotics for comparison with azithromycin(extended release, 2.0
g.) and for second-line treatment were chosen by experts in a survey. Medical care
costs were derived from Moscow mandatory medical insurance system. Costs of the
medications were obtained from consumer prices database. Sensitivity analysis was
carried out. RESULTS: Clinical efficacy was equal. Costs of CAP treatment were 4390
rub (142.14$) for Amoxycillin and clavulanic acid, 5386 Rub ($174.39) for Cefuroxime axetil and 4053 Rub ($131.23) for Azithromycin. Costs of sinusitis treatment
were 3637(117.76), 3728 (120.71) and 3570 rub ($115,59) for Amoxycillin and
clavulanic acid, Cefuroxime axetil and Azithromycin respectively. CONCLUSIONS:
Azithromycin is more efficient option for CAP and sinusitis treatment than Cefuroxime
axetil and Amoxycillin and clavulanic acid in Russia.
PIN37
HEALTH ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF CONJUGATE PNEUMOCOCCAL
VACCINES IN LATIN AMERICAN COUNTRIES
Gomez JA1, Naranjo LT2, Knerer GX3
1
GlaxoSmithKline, Victoria, Buenos Aires, Argentina; 2GlaxoSmithKline, Panama City, Panama;
3
GlaxoSmithKline, Wavre, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: To simulate the potential benefits of implementing infant vaccination
with the 10-valent pneumococcal & non-typeable Haemophilus influenzae (NTHi)protein D conjugate vaccine (PHiD-CV) or the 13-valent pneumococcal conjugate
vaccine (PCV13) in Latin American countries. METHODS: Vaccine impact was
assessed using a Markov cohort model for Mexico, Brazil, Chile, and Colombia. The
model simulates the burden of pneumococcal- and NTHi-related diseases (Invasive
Disease (ID), Community Acquired Pneumonia (CAP) and Acute Otitis Media (AOM))
in a birth cohort followed over a lifetime. Epidemiology, disease management and
costs are country-specific. Vaccination schemes (3 + 1) at 90% coverage & price parity
were compared to no intervention. Future QALYs and costs discounted at 3.5%, using
the health care payer perspective are presented. RESULTS: Mortality impact on ID
and CAP for the two vaccines is projected to be comparable under base-case conditions
which include minimum assumptions of NTHi infection rates. Vaccines are predicted
13th Euro Abstracts
to reduce 12.8 to 39.0 deaths (PCV13) and 12.4 to 37.3 deaths (PHiD-CV) per
100,000 vaccinated children. The model predicts that PHiD-CV will prevent 93 to
494 additional Myringotomies and 651 to 8,314 additional AOM cases per 100,000
vaccinated children, when compared with PCV13. Medical costs averted are estimated
similar for ID and CAP. The model predicts that PHiD-CV will prevent 48 to 116%
more AOM associated costs to the health care system over lifetime than PCV13. In
the scenarios analyzed, both vaccines are cost-effective but PHiD-CV generates more
QALYs gains (range 0.04%–14.5%) and is cost saving (range 1.88–12.54%) compared to PCV13. CONCLUSIONS: The model shows both vaccines would significantly reduce the clinical & economic burden of Pneumococcal disease and are
cost-effective for Latin American countries. Nevertheless, due to its greater impact on
AOM-related cases and costs, PHiD-CV would generate more QALY gains and is
cost-saving to the health care system compared to PCV13.
PIN38
AN ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF THE PEDIATRIC VACCINATION
SCHEDULE IN THE UNITED STATES
Clements KM1, Misurski DA2, Miller J3, Skornicki ME1, Hill GJ1, McGarry L1
1
i3 Innovus, Medford, MA, USA; 2GlaxoSmithKline, Philadelphia, PA, USA; 3GlaxoSmithKline
Biologicals, King of Prussia, PA, USA
OBJECTIVES: To estimate the cost-effectiveness of the recommended US pediatric
vaccination schedule from a public health perspective. METHODS: An Excel-based
cost-effectiveness calculator was constructed for the current pediatric vaccine schedule
including: diphtheria, tetanus, and pertussis (DTaP), measles, mumps, and rubella
(MMR), polio, hepatitis A, hepatitis B, haemophilus influenza B (Hib), varicella,
pneumococcal, adolescent meningococcal, influenza, human papillomavirus (HPV)
and rotavirus vaccines. Estimates of the incremental direct medical costs and qualityadjusted life-years (QALYs) for vaccination versus no vaccination were obtained from
published literature. Where estimates were not available, a decision tree was constructed to model QALYs gained per vaccinated child. The tree includes branches for
disease incidence pre- and post-vaccine introduction, case-fatality, and permanent,
serious sequelae. 2008–2009 vaccination coverage and 2009 prices were used to
estimate vaccine costs. Estimates of lifetime costs and QALYs per vaccinated child,
discounted at 3% annually, were applied to a US birth cohort, assuming direct effects
only. Costs are expressed in 2009 US$. Incremental costs and QALYs for individual
vaccines and the whole schedule were evaluated. The model assessed schedule completion with single disease vaccines as well as completion with two different pentavalent
combination vaccines (DTaP, polio, Hib or DTap, polio, hepatitis B) plus single
disease vaccines. RESULTS: Regardless of how the current pediatric vaccine schedule
is completed, annual estimated cost savings range between $13.8 billion to $14.3
billion. DTaP, MMR, polio, Hib and HPV are cost-saving, as are both pentavalent
vaccines. Other single-disease vaccines add cost but contribute to a total of 1.4M
QALYs gained per year. CONCLUSIONS: The current US pediatric vaccine schedule
is estimated to be cost-saving and to provide substantial benefits in quality-adjusted
survival. Use of combination vaccines increases the savings. Neither herd immunity
nor indirect costs were considered in the model; their inclusion likely would increase
the estimated cost savings.
PIN39
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF NUCLEIC ACID TEST SCREENING IN BLOOD
DONATION FOR HIV IN BRAZIL
Araújo MAM1, Soares DP1, Garcia GC1, Martins ACM2
1
ANVISA, Brasilia, Brazil; 2ANS, Brasilia, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: To build a Markov Model that is able to assess the cost-effectiveness
of adding NAT to the HIV screening strategy at the Brazilian public health system.
METHODS: A mathematical model was made of the transfusion chain from donors
to recipients of blood in Brazil. The annual number of avoided HIV transmissions was
estimated with the window-period incidence model. The natural history of the whole
blood receptors is described by a Markov model. RESULTS: The incremental costeffectiveness ratio—ICER of using NAT instead of ELISA concurrently to another
ELISA in Brazilian public health system is R$666.493,56 per QALY. The Brazilian
gross domestic product per capita is R$18.315,50. CONCLUSIONS: The Markov
Model built is consistent and shows that, despite the narrower window period, at
current costs, NAT is not cost-effective for HIV screening of donated blood in Brazil.
Given that the NAT kit is already being produced in-house, the price per kit can be
adjusted to achieve a better ICER.
PIN40
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF PNEUMOCOCCAL VACCINATION AMONG
INFANTS IN RUSSIA: ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF THE
PNEUMOCOCCAL 7-VALENT CONJUGATE VACCINE
Omelyanovsky VV, Krysanov I, Ivakhnenko O
Research Center for Clinical and Economic Evaluation and Pharmacoeconomics, Moscow,
Russia
OBJECTIVES: Cost-effectiveness analysis of 4 dose (3 + 1) schedule of the conjugate
pneumococcal 7-valent vaccine (PCV-7) in infants in the Russian Federation.
METHODS: Costs associated with Streptococcus pneumoniae infection were calculated in a modeled cohort of children 0–5 years old with and without vaccination with
PCV-7. Key parameters in the model included: number of children in the age of 0–5
years in the country; incidence of diseases caused by S. pneumoniae; the data about
efficacy of PVC-7. Costs of vaccination, medical care costs and economic losses of a
A437
society were taken into account from the societal point of view. Time horizon was 5
years in the model. RESULTS: Expected cost of vaccination program is c0.469 million.
Implementation of vaccination with PCV-7 will decrease direct medical costs of care
for S. pneumoniae infection by c0.516 million. Societal economic losses will decrease
by c0.975 million. Thus benefit amount of the PCV-7 vaccination program in a cohort
of 0–5 years old children will be c1022 million. CONCLUSIONS: Vaccination with
PCV-7 is an efficient program in Russia.
PIN41
ADAPTATION OF A TRANSMISSION DYNAMIC MODEL FOR THE
QUADRIVALENT HPV VACCINE TO GERMANY
Schobert D1, Schmitter S2, Remy V3, Schöffski O4
1
Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg, Nürnberg, Germany; 2Sanofi Pasteur MSD GmbH, Leimen,
Germany; 3Sanofi Pasteur MSD, Lyon, France; 4Friedrich-Alexander-Universität ErlangenNürnberg, Nuremberg, Germany
OBJECTIVES: The impact of the HPV(6,11,16,18) vaccine to 12-year-old girls has
been assessed in Germany by using a static model. However this kind of model cannot
consider a change in HPV infection rate over time, as observed with high coverage
rates. Further, this model does not adequately reflect the recommendation in Germany
to vaccinate 12 to 17-year-old-girls. a transmission dynamic model was developed for
the USA to include these features. Our objective was the adaptation of this model to
Germany to precise the assessment of HPV-vaccination impact. METHODS: In a first
step we assessed the transferability of the model structure to Germany. In a second
step we checked input parameters for transferability and identified parameters for
adaptation. For the identified parameters, we performed a comprehensive literature
research, supplemented by expert opinions to determine German-specific values. The
model was manually calibrated to fit observed data in Germany. Calibration parameters were number of annual cases of genital warts and cervical cancer as well as
deaths due to cervical cancer to reflect the entire time span of occurrence of HPVrelated diseases. RESULTS: The US model structure is also applicable to the German
context. Components of the model that had to be adapted include demographics (e.g.
mortality), screening participation, treatment and vaccination strategies, sexual behaviour, health utility and economic input parameters. In case no German-specific data
could be found, we used data from the UK and the US. Annual number of incidental
genital warts was calibrated easily and fits well with observed data. However, changes
in a variety of parameters were necessary for calibration of cervical cancer cases and
related deaths. CONCLUSIONS: After its successful adaptation, this transmission
dynamic model can be used for a far more realistic estimation of the clinical and
economic impact of HPV vaccination in the German context.
PIN42
THE COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF 13-VALENT PNEUMOCOCCAL
CONJUGATE VACCINE (PCV13) COMPARED WITH 10-VALENT
PNEUMOCOCCAL CONJUGATE VACCINE (PCV10) IN TAIWAN
Chang CJ1, Wu DBS2, Wu CL1, Strutton D3, Hwang S3, Huang VWH4, Rubin J5, Gilmore K5
1
Chang Gung University, Taoyuan, Taiwan; 2National Yang-Ming University, Taipei, Taiwan;
3
Pfizer Limited, Collegeville, PA, USA; 4Pfizer Limited, Taipei, Taiwan; 5i3 Innovus, Medford,
MA, USA
BACKGROUND: Streptococcus pneumonia causes invasive diseases as meningitis and
bacteremia and non-invasive diseases as pneumonia and acute otitis media (AOM),
leading to high morbidity and mortality in infants and the elderly worldwide.
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of universal infant vaccination with
13-valent pneumococcal conjugate vaccine (PCV13) compared with PCV10 in
Taiwan. METHODS: A Markov model was developed to evaluate the potential public
health and economic impact of PCV13 versus PCV10 when used as routine vaccination of infants in Taiwan with 4 doses at 2, 4, 6, and 12–15 months of age over a
10-year time horizon. We included both direct and potential indirect benefits of the
vaccine from societal perspective. Direct effectiveness of PCV13 and PCV10 is estimated from clinical trial data while indirect effectiveness is estimated from U.S. surveillance data. Epidemiology, serotype, medical, and non-medical cost are from Taiwan
CDC report, and retrospective Taiwan-population-based insurance database. Other
model parameters were captured by published sources, unpublished data, and assumptions made in consultation with clinical experts. Probabilistic sensitivity analyses was
performed to test the robustness of model assumptions. RESULTS: At vaccination
price (PCV13 cost used current PCV7 price of NT$3,200 (US$ 98) and PCV10
NT$2,700 (US$ 83), our model predicts that, compared to PCV10, universal infant
PCV13 vaccination would avoid 2,215 cases of IPD, approximately 12,473 and
14,018 cases of hospitalized and non-hospitalized pneumonia, 246,578 cases of AOM;
prevent 207 deaths from IPD and 85 deaths from hospitalized pneumonia; resulting
in 4,596 life-years saved, and 3,359 QALYs gained. Comparing PCV13 to PCV10
results in NT$ 187,462 (US$ 5,768) per life-year saved and cost of NT$ 253,307 (US$
7,794) per QALY gained from the societal perspective. CONCLUSIONS: Universal
pediatric PCV13 vaccination in Taiwan is estimated to reduce the burden of pneumococcal disease and expected to be cost-effective from the societal perspective compared
with PCV10.
A438
PIN43
A COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS OF ANTIMICROBIAL THERAPY OF
BLOODSTREAM INFECTIONS TREATMENT IN INTENSIVE CARE UNIT
Omelyanovsky VV, Protsenko DN, Derkach EV, Sveshnikova ND
Russian State Medical University, Moscow, Russia
OBJECTIVES: According to the recent international data, the incidence of bloodstream catheter—associated infections is 3–8% in the structure of hospital- acquired
infections in the intensive care units (ICU) and the leading cause of them are Gram
positive bacteria. In this study we conducted comparative analysis of clinico—economic effectiveness of daptomycin (dapto) vs. vancomycin (vanco) usage in treatment
of patients with MRSA catheter—associated infection in the ICU. METHODS: “Decision Tree” pharmacoeconomic model was built based on results of international clinical studies and data of routine practice treatment of bloodstream infections in Moscow
clinics. Two variants of antibacterial treatment of patients with catheter-associated
infections differing on starting products (dapto or vanco) were assessed. If the first
line of therapy was ineffective, patients switched over to the second line therapy covering resistant strains—meropenem and fluconazole. Direct and indirect medical costs
were assessed: cost of antibiotics and additional medical treatment, antibacterial
diagnostic, laboratory and cost of bed-days in ICU and therapeutic department. Costs
were based on official data on hospital medical service in municipal Moscow clinics
and purchasing price on medical products from price list of the biggest Russian pharmaceutical distributors. Clinical recovery was considered as efficacy with the goal to
evaluate cost-effectiveness ratio (CER) of two groups (CERdapto and CERvan accordingly). RESULTS: Better clinical efficacy in daptomycin group resulted in lower—
needs to change antibiotic in catheter—associated infection treatment in the ICU in
comparison to vancomycin group. In spite of the higher price of drug, average cost
of successfully treated patient by daptomycin (CERdapto) was 227,887 RUR/pt in
compare with CERvan 235,032 RUR/pt. Exchange rate is 1USD = 30 RUR. CONCLUSIONS: Good cost-effectiveness ratio in comparison to vancomycin supports use
of daptomycin as the first line antibacterial therapy in bloodstream catheter—associated infections.
PIN44
COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS OF 1 YEAR PEGINTERFERON
ALFA-2A VERSUS 4 YEARS ENTECAVIR FOR THE TREATMENT OF
HBEAG-POSITIVE CHRONIC HEPATITIS B IN CHINA
Chen W
Fudan University, Shanghai, China
OBJECTIVES: The objective of the study was to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of 1
year peginterferon alfa-2a compared to 4 years entecavir for the treatment of HBeAgpositive chronic hepatitis B in China. METHODS: A Markov health-state model was
designed to evaluate the direct medical costs and outcomes (life-years and QALYs
gained) of treating HBeAg-positive chronic hepatitis B in China. The model included
10 health states—Chronic hepatitis B (CHB), HBeAg seroconversion, HBsAg loss,
CHB with resistance, Compensated cirrhosis, Decompensated cirrhosis, Hepatocellular carcinoma, Liver transplant, Post-liver transplant and death. The model incorporates a maximum analysis time horizon of 80 years with yearly cycles. The clinical
and quality of life data were obtained from published literature and re-confirmed
based on a questionnaire survey from a clinical expert panel of 20 hepatitis B specialists. From the perspective of China’s health insurance system, cost data was calculated
based on the published literature about economic burden of chronic hepatitis B. a
discounting rate at 3% was used to discount utilities and medical costs happened at
different years. a univariate sensitivity analysis was performed to understand the key
drivers and general sensitivity of the model. RESULTS: The model results showed that
the utilization of 1 year peginterferon alfa-2a treatment for HBeAg-positive CHB can
prolong 0.32 QALYs, compared to the 4 years entecavir treatment (16,394 QALYs
vs. 16,074 QALYs). The total cost per patient treated with peginterferon alfa-2a was
US$22,221, and US$19,989 for patient treated with entecavir. The discounted incremental cost per QALY gained for pegainterferon alfa-2a was US$6965. CONCLUSIONS: The results of the model suggest that 1 year pegainterferon alfa-2a improves
health outcomes in a cost-effective manner compared with 4 years entecavir in the
treatment of HBeAg-positive chronic hepatitis B in China.
PIN45
COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS OF TREATMENT OF CHRONIC
HEPATITIS C PATIENTS WITH PEGINTERFERON ALFA-2A OR
PEGINTERFERON ALFA-2B BOTH PLUS RIBAVIRIN IN SPAIN
Ventayol-Bosch P1, Rubio-Terrés C2, García-Samaniego J3, Planas R4, Solà-Lamoglia R5,
Romero-Gómez M6, Diago-Madrid M7, Crespo-García J8, Calleja-Panero JL9,
Turnes-Vázquez J10
1
Hospital Universitario Son Dureta, Palma de Mallorca, Spain; 2HealthValue, Madrid, Spain;
3
Hospital Carlos III, CIBEREHD, Madrid, Spain; 4Hospital Germans Trias i Pujol, CIBEREHD,
Barcelona, Spain; 5Hospital del Mar (IMIM), Barcelona, Spain; 6Hospital Universitario de
Valme, CIBEREHD, Sevilla, Spain; 7Hospital General Universitario de Valencia, Valencia, Spain;
8
Hospital Universitario Marqués de Valdecilla, Santander, Spain; 9Hospital Universitario Puerta
de Hierro, Madrid, Spain; 10Complejo Hospitalario de Pontevedra, Pontevedra, Spain
OBJECTIVES: To estimate long-term cost-effectiveness of treatment of chronic hepatitis C (CHC) patients with peginterferon alfa-2a (180 mcg/week) versus peginterferon
alfa-2b (1.5 mcg/kg/week) both in combination with ribavirin (800–1400 mg/day)
from the Spanish National Healthcare System perspective. METHODS: A metaanalysis of head-to-head randomized trials of peginterferon alfa-2a and peginterferon
13th Euro Abstracts
alfa-2b both plus ribavirin, evaluating sustained virological response (SVR) has been
recently published. It showed RR = 1.11 (95%CI 1.04–1.19) for all genotypes, RR =
1.21 (95%CI 1.03–1.42) for G-1/4, and RR = 1.11 (95%CI 1.02–1.22) for G-2/3. a
Markov model with 7 health states was developed to simulate the disease progression
of adult patients with CHC for a lifetime horizon. Efficacy, in terms of SVR, was
calculated from the meta-analysis, showing a better SVR rate for peginterferon alfa-2a
than for peginterferon alfa-2b: the absolute differences were of 6.0%; 7.6%; and 8.7%
for all genotypes, G-1/4 and G-2/3 respectively. Transition probabilities and health
states utilities were obtained from published literature. Health direct costs of peginterferon + ribavirin (48 weeks for G-1/4 and 24 weeks for G-2/3) and of disease
complications were collected from Spanish databases and studies ([c] 2010). The
annual discount rate was 3.5% for costs and outcomes. RESULTS: Each patient
gained 0.469, 0.600 and 0.685 life-years (LY) and 0.155, 0.198 and 0.227 qualityadjusted life-years (QALY) with peginterferon alfa-2a in comparison with peginterferon alfa-2b, for all genotypes, G-1/4 and G-2/3 respectively. The savings per patient
treated with peginterferon alfa-2a were c705, c672 and c1900, for all genotypes,
G-1/4 and G-2/3, respectively. Peginterferon alfa-2a was the dominant treatment
strategy (lower costs and higher efficacy than peginterferon alfa-2b treatment).
CONCLUSIONS: Treatment of patients with chronic hepatitis C with peginterferon
alfa-2a + ribavirin is a cost-effective strategy in comparison with peginterferon alfa-2b
+ ribavirin for all genotypes, G-1/4 and G-2/3.
PIN46
KIOVIG FOR PRIMARY IMMUNODEFICIENCY: REDUCED INFUSION AND
DECREASED COSTS PER INFUSION
Connolly M1, Simoens S2
1
Global Market Access Solutions, St Prex, Switzerland; 2K.U. Leuven, Leuven, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: Kiovig is a new, ready-to-use 10% liquid immunoglobulin preparation
that is medically indicated for the treatment of primary immunodeficiency. This study
aims to conduct an economic evaluation which compares the intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIg) preparations Kiovig, Multigam, and Sandoglobulin from the Belgian
societal perspective. METHODS: Given that three prospective studies have observed
no difference in outcomes, a cost-minimization analysis considered the differences in
costs that can arise from these immunoglobulin products. a decision-analytic model
simulated immunoglobulin treatment over a one-year time horizon. Cost items
included immunoglobulin costs, pharmacy administration and nursing costs, miniforfait paid for hospital infusion, costs of adverse events, and lost productivity. Cost
data were identified from published sources and Belgian hospital administrators. a
probabilistic sensitivity analysis explored the impact of parameter uncertainty. The
price year was 2009. RESULTS: Costs per infusion cycle in adult primary immunodeficiency patients were c1.046 (95% confidence interval: c1.006–1.093) with Kiovig;
c1.102 (c1.064–1.147) with Multigam; and c1.147 (c1.108–1.193) with Sandoglobulin. The average cost savings per infusion with Kiovig as compared to Multigam and
Sandoglobulin amounted to c56 and c101 per infusion. CONCLUSIONS: Treatment
costs with Kiovig were shown to be lower as compared to other IVIgs in Belgium.
Reduced costs per infusion were attributed to lower costs associated with treating
adverse events and the opportunity cost of nursing time and time off work for working
adults.
PIN47
COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS OF PNEUMOCOCCAL VACCINES IN
TAIWAN
Chang CJ1, Wang PC2, Huang YC3, Wu BS4, Wu CL1, Topachevskyi O5, Jung W6
1
Chang Gung University, Taoyuan, Taiwan; 2Cathay General Hospital, Taipei, Taiwan; 3Chang
Gung Memorial Hospital, Taoyuan, Taiwan; 4National Yang-Ming University, Taipei, Taiwan;
5
GlaxoSmithKline Biologicals, Wavre, Belgium; 6GlaxoSmithKline, Singapore, Singapore
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate cost-effectiveness of pneumococcal non-typeable Haemophilus Influenza protein D conjugate vaccine(PHiD-CV), 7-valent pneumococcal
conjugate vaccine(PCV7), and PCV13 in Taiwan. METHODS: An age-compartmental, deterministic, static cohort model simulated in a 198,733 birth cohort the disease
process of invasive disease(ID, meningitis and bacteremia), community acquired
pneumonia(CAP), and acute otitis media(AOM) over life-time. The model was developed by GlaxoSmithKline and adapted with local data. For base-case analysis for all
vaccines, a 4-dose(3 + 1) schedule was assumed with 95% vaccine coverage. Cost and
outcomes were analyzed from health care payer perspective with 3% discount rate.
Herd protection on ID, limited cross protection against 6A and 19A, minimal estimation of NTHi(non-typeable Haemophilis Influenzae) infection rates in ID and CAP
were assumed for base case. Costs for PHiD-CV, PCV7 and PCV13 were assumed
parity at 3200 New Taiwan Dollar(NTD). Epidemiological and cost data were
obtained from local disease burden study. Vaccine efficacy data were obtained from
published sources. One way and probabilistic sensitivity analyses were conducted.
RESULTS: Compared with PCV7, PHiD-CV is expected to prevent additional cases
of 1 ID, 2,291 CAP and 63,597 AOM, with 548 additional quality-adjusted lifeyears(QALY) gained with total saving of NTD 69,347,211. Compared with PCV13,
PHiD-CV is expected to prevent less cases of 4 ID and 264 CAP, but expected to
prevent additional 45,111 AOM cases. PHiD-CV is expected to provide additional
181 QALY gained with total saving of NTD 14,532,124 compared to PCV13. Sensitivity analyses show the results are most sensitive to the changes of AOM related
parameters, but when the AOM related parameters were changed up to +/− 20%,
PHiD-CV is still cost-saving to PCV7 and PCV 13. CONCLUSIONS: PHiD-CV is
expected to provide more QALYs with potential saving of total health care cost
13th Euro Abstracts
compared with PCV7 and PCV13. At price parity, PHiD-CV is cost-saving to PCV7
and PCV13 in Taiwan.
PIN48
PHARMACO-ECONOMICS OF ANTIBIOTICS
Simoens S
K.U. Leuven, Leuven, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: Antibiotics have made a significant contribution to improving patient
health, but policy makers and health care payers are concerned about the costs of
antibiotics in addition to their effectiveness. This study aims to assess the value of
antibiotics by examining published incremental cost-utility ratios of antibiotics.
METHODS: Evidence was derived from cost-utility analyses of antibiotics included
in the Tufts-New England Center Cost-Effectiveness Analysis Registry through September 2009. For each cost-utility analysis, the following variables were examined:
publication year, target population, intervention type, country of patient sample,
disease classification, prevention stage, funding source, study perspective, discounting,
sensitivity analysis, incremental cost-utility ratio, and methodological quality. Evidence of the value of antibiotics was summarized by calculating median incremental
cost-utility ratios and frequency distributions. Associations between incremental costutility ratios on the one hand and the prevention stage, study perspective and methodological quality were examined by means of the Mann-Whitney U-test for ordinal
variables. RESULTS: The analysis included 85 incremental cost-utility ratios from 23
cost-utility analyses. The findings showed that 38.8% of incremental cost-utility ratios
related to dominant antibiotics; 45.9% referred to antibiotics that improved effectiveness, but also increased costs; and 15.3% related to dominated antibiotics. The median
ratio was c748 per quality-adjusted life-year. Using threshold values of c20,000 per
quality-adjusted life-year and c50,000 per quality-adjusted life-year, the probability
that an antibiotic provides value for money was 64% and 67%, respectively. No
statistically significant association was observed between incremental cost-utility ratios
and the prevention stage (p = 0.119), study perspective (p = 0.285) or methodological
quality (p = 0.146). CONCLUSIONS: The current evidence base suggests that the
majority of antibiotics provide value for money.
PIN49
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF PEGINTERFERON ALPHA-2A PLUS
RIBAVIRIN FOR TREATING CRONIC HEPATITIS C VIRUS INFECTION
COMPARED WITH NO TREATMENT IN MEXICO
Carlos F1, DeHesa2
1
R a C Salud Consultores S.A. de C.V., México City, D.F., Mexico; 2Hospital de
Especialidades Centro Médico Nacional Siglo XXI, Instituto Mexicano del Seguro Social,
Mexico City, D.F., Mexico
OBJECTIVES: Prevalence of hepatitis C virus infection is approximately 2.2–3.0%
worldwide (130–170 million people). a persistent infection develops in up to 85% of
these patients, leading to chronic hepatitis C (CHC), a condition associated with
serious liver-related complications. We aimed to perform an economic evaluation of
peginterferon alpha-2a (PEG-IFN alpha-2a) plus ribavirin (RBV). METHODS: We
developed a Markov model with 40 annual cycles to project cumulative cost and
quality-adjusted life-years (QALY) for two identical cohorts of patients aged 40 years.
One cohort received PEG-IFN alpha-2a 180 mcg per week plus daily doses of
1200 mg of RBV during 48 weeks for genotype 1/4 or 24 weeks for genotype 2/3.
The other cohort did not receive any antiviral treatment. The analysis was performed
under the perspective of national public health care system. Only direct medical costs
were accounted for; these included acquisition cost of antiviral drugs and medical
attention for health states incorporated into the model. Costs (expressed in 2010
Euros) and QALY were discounted at an annual rate of 5%. Transition probabilities
and utility scores were gathered from published literature and cost data was based on
local sources and experts’ opinion. RESULTS: Average discounted costs were estimated at c15,626 for PEG-IFN alpha-2a plus RBV and at c17,350 when no antiviral
treatment is given to CHC patients, leading to overall savings of c1724 per patient.
Without antiviral treatment, 9.9 QALY per patient are expected. There is a gain of
2.2 QALY for patients who are treated. Results are robust to variations in model
parameters. PEG-IFN alpha-2a plus RBV was both more effective and less costly than
no treatment in more than half of the simulations performed in a probabilistic sensitivity analysis. CONCLUSIONS: PEG-IFN alpha-2a plus RBV is a dominant strategy
compared to given no antiviral treatment to CHC patients in Mexico.
PIN50
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF PEGINTERFERON ALPHA-2A VERSUS
PEGINTERFERON ALPHA-2B FOR TREATMENT OF CHRONIC HEPATTIS
C INFECTION IN MEXICO
Carlos F1, DeHesa2
1
R a C Salud Consultores S.A. de C.V., México City, D.F., Mexico; 2Hospital de
Especialidades Centro Médico Nacional Siglo XXI, Instituto Mexicano del Seguro Social,
Mexico City, D.F., Mexico
OBJECTIVES: Prevalence of hepatitis C virus infection is approximately 2.2–3.0%
worldwide (130–170 million people). A persistent infection develops in up to 85% of
these patients, leading to chronic hepatitis C (CHC), a condition associated with
serious liver-related complications. Current standard of treatment includes Peginterferon (PEG-IFN) alpha plus ribavirin (RBV). We aimed to compare two different
options of PEG-IFN alpha. METHODS: We developed a Markov model with 40
annual cycles to project cumulative cost and quality-adjusted life-years (QALY) for
A439
two identical cohorts of moderate CHC patients without cirrhosis aged 40 years. One
cohort received PEG-IFN alpha-2a 180 mcg per week and the other received PEG-IFN
alpha-2b 1.5 mcg/Kg weekly, both combined with daily doses of 1,200 mg of RBV
during 48 weeks for genotype 1/4 or 24 weeks for genotype 2/3. The analysis was
performed under the perspective of national public health care system. Only direct
medical costs were accounted for; these included acquisition cost of antiviral drugs
and medical attention for health states incorporated into the model. Costs (expressed
in 2010 Euros) and QALY were discounted at an annual rate of 5%. Transition
probabilities and utility scores were gathered from published literature and cost data
was based on local sources and experts’ opinion. RESULTS: Average discounted costs
were estimated at c16,854 for PEG-IFN alpha-2a plus RBV and at c18,247 for
PEG-IFN alpha-2b plus RBV, leading to overall savings of c1,393 per patient when
PEG-IFN alpha-2a is used. Discounted QALY were 12.29 for PEG-IFN alpha-2a and
12.17 for PEG-IFN alpha-2b. Results are robust to variations in model parameters.
CONCLUSIONS: PEG-IFN alpha-2a plus RBV is a dominant strategy compared to
given PEG-IFN alpha-2b treatment to CHC patients in Mexico.
PIN51
UPDATING THE COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF ROTAVIRUS VACCINATION
IN THE NETHERLANDS
Rozenbaum MH1, Hak E1, Wilschut JC1, Postma MJ2
1
University of Groningen, Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands; 2University of Groningen,
Groningen, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: To investigated the most important factors responsible for the large
differences in previously estimated cost-effectiveness ratios and to update the costeffectiveness of rotavirus vaccination in the The Netherlands applying assumptions
resulting from 2 consensus meetings with national and international experts in the
field, from academia, clinical environments, industry and health policy. METHODS:
We constructed a decision analytic model to compare the expected net costs and health
benefits over a period of 5 years in two hypothetical cohorts of 180,000 children
(approximating the Dutch birth cohort), one being vaccinated and one unvaccinated.
The base-case analysis reflected the most likely—but also overall conservative—estimate of cost-effectiveness from the societal perspective. Robustness of the base-case
result was investigated in sensitivity and scenario analyses. RESULTS: In the base-case
analysis, it was estimated that approximately 59,495 RVGE cases would occur, resulting in 11,453 GP visits and 3,238 hospitalizations. With vaccination, approximately
34,000 cases of RVGE cases are averted corresponding to a total QALY gain of 167.
Assuming a total cost of vaccination of c75, vaccination would result in cost-effectiveness of c30,540 per QALY gained (c152 per case averted). Results were sensitive
to the number of deaths due to RVGE, inclusion of potential herd protection, inclusion
of QALY decrements of care givers, further potential tender price reduction and the
exact discount rate used. CONCLUSIONS: Our economic analysis indicates that a
potential national immunization programme against rotavirus can be considered costeffective if applying a threshold of c50,000 per QALY for the The Netherlands.
PIN52
AN ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF RALTEGRAVIR FOR THE TREATMENT
OF ANTIRETROVIRAL-NAIVE HIV-1 INFECTED PATIENTS IN HUNGARY
Erdesz D1, Nagy L1, Brandtmuller A1, Kiss Z1, Chaudhary MA2, Kumar RN3, Elbasha EH2
1
MSD Hungary Ltd., Budapest, Hungary; 2Merck Research Laboratories, North Wales, PA,
USA; 3Merck & Co., Inc., Whitehouse Station, NJ, USA
OBJECTIVES: Raltegravir (Merck & Co., Inc.) is an inhibitor of HIV type 1 (HIV-1)
integrase, and is the first drug in a new class of therapy known as the integrase inhibitors. Raltegravir has already shown to be cost-effective in HIV treatment experienced
patients in Hungary. The objective of the current study is to assess if the first line use
of raltegravir is cost-effective compared to its use in rescue therapy from the Hungarian
public payer perspective. METHODS: First line use of raltegravir was evaluated versus
a protease inhibitor (PI) using a Markov model. Raltegravir was also included as a
3rd line therapy within the model arm that initiates on a PI. The Markov process
comprised a three stage continuous-time model representing successive HIV therapies
over a patient’s life-time. Patients moved between 18 health states—based on CD4
and HIV RNA levels. Patients progressed to the next stage after they either failed
current therapy or discontinued for toxicity reasons. At any time, patients could
develop acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS), suffer from a coronary heart
disease (CHD) event and/or experience other adverse events. Mortality was also
captured in the model. RESULTS: The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) for
initiating therapy with raltegravir versus using it as a rescue therapy was 4,075 million
HUF per quality adjusted life-year gained (QALY), equivalent to $16,830/QALY. The
model predicted lower cumulative incidence of CHD in the raltegravir arm versus the
PI arm. (15.1% versus 16.1%). The model predicted that patients initiating on raltegravir therapy have longer life expectancy than patients starting with PI treatment
over a 50-year time horizon (18.74 versus 17.17 years). CONCLUSIONS: Our long
term economic model suggests that it is cost-effective to use raltegravir early in HIV
therapy versus in patients who have experienced multiple failures.
A440
PIN53
COST-UTILITY ANALYSIS OF NEW PNEUMOCOCCAL CONJUGATE
VACCINES IN THE REGIONAL IMMUNIZATION PROGRAM OF THE
AUTONOMOUS REGION OF MADRID—IMPACT ON INVASIVE
PNEUMOCOCCAL DISEASE
Picazo J1, Mendez C2, Oyagüez I3, Casado MA3, Guijarro P2
1
University Complutense of Madrid, Madrid, Spain; 2Pfizer Spain, Alcobendas, Madrid, Spain;
3
Pharmacoeconomics & Outcomes Research Iberia, Pozuelo de Alarcón, Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: The inclusion of conjugate pneumococcal vaccines to the Regional
Immunization Program avoids cases, among others, of invasive pneumococcal diseases
caused by serotypes of Streptococcus pneumoniae contained in the vaccines. Research
objective was to assess efficiency of conjugate pneumococcal vaccine- 13 valent
(PCV13) versus 10 valent (PCV10), under National Health System perspective.
METHODS: A cost-utility model was developed to estimate cost per quality adjusted
life-year (QALY) associated to primary bacteriemic, empyema, meningitis and bacteriemic pneumonia with vaccine administration in the Autonomous Region of Madrid.
The estimation of cases to avoid and serotype coverage was based on epidemiologic
information available at regional level. Additionally to direct protection, the model
considers the potential indirect effect on the general population. One-way sensitivity
analyses were performed, including parameters with most uncertainty. RESULTS:
PCV13 yields 224 QALYs versus 70 QALYs with PCV10. The incremental ratio is
c16,908/QALY gained. Deterministic sensitivity analysis showed that model results
are robust, parameter that most influence on the results was vaccine indirect effect.
Reducing PCV13 vaccine schedule from 4 to 3 doses was a dominant strategy.
CONCLUSIONS: The inclusion of PCV13 is a cost-effective strategy versus PCV10.
a 3 doses schedule of PCV13 is a dominant option, being a cost-saving measure for
the National Healthcare System.
PIN54
COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSES (CEA) OF LOPINAVIR/RITONAVIR
(LPV/R) AND ATAZANAVIR PLUS RITONAVIR (ATV + RTV) REGIMENS
FOR ANTIRETROVIRAL (ARV) NAÏVE HIV-1 INFECTED PATIENTS
BASED ON CASTLE 48-WEEK STUDY: APPLICATION TO SWEDEN
Simpson K1, Baran R2, Woodward C3, Dietz B4
1
Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, SC, USA; 2Abbott Laboratories, Abbott
Park, IL, USA; 3Abbott Laboratories, Sinking Springs, PA, USA; 4Abbott GmbH & Co. KG,
Ludwigshafen, Germany, Germany
No differences in viral load (VL) or CD4+ count at 48 weeks were reported for the
CASTLE study. However, total cholesterol (TC) levels were elevated in 7% and 18%
of subjects receiving ATV + RTV and LPV/r, respectively. These measures can predict
outcomes which affect the future cost of HIV in the Swedish health system. OBJECTIVES: To compare the incremental cost-effectiveness (ICER) and budget impacts for
a population similar to those enrolled in the CASTLE study for Sweden. METHODS:
Using a previously published Markov model of HIV disease and 2009 cost data from
Sweden, we compared the cost/QALY and budget impact of the two ARV regimens.
Daily drug costs were 160,52 SEK for ATV + RTV and 147,87SEK for LPV/r. Costing
for other health care resources used a health systems perspective with 2009 inputs
from www.fass.se and published literature. Costs and QALYs were discounted by 3%
when calculating ICERs. RESULTS: The CHD risk favored ATV + RTV, resulting in
a life expectancy increase of 0.031 QALYs (11 days). The cost-effectiveness ratio for
ATV + RTV for Sweden was 1.251.545 SEK /QALY gained. Three times the Swedish
GDP in 2008 was 886,670 SEK. Thus the modeled ICER exceeds the WHO criteria
for cost-effectiveness by 40%. Sensitivity analysis showed the model was mainly
sensitive to ARV price. Five and 10 years per-patient savings for subjects on the
LPV/r regimen were estimated to be 21,314 SEK and 32,564 SEK, respectively.
CONCLUSIONS: Selection of an ATV + RTV based regimen in an ARV-naïve population with a CHD risk similar to subjects in the CASTLE study does not appear to be
a cost-effective use of scarce resources for the cost structure seen in Sweden. The costs
associated with the very small added CHD risk incurred by LPV/r treatment are more
than offset by its short and long term cost savings.
PIN55
RISK SCORES PREDICTING RESOURCE USE OF HEPATITIS C PATIENTS
IN GERMANY—AN ANALYSIS OF SICK FUND CLAIMS DATA
Tomeczkowski J1, Slawik L1, Guthoff-Hagen S2, Schreder H1, Fleischmann J1
1
Janssen-Cilag GmbH, Neuss, Germany; 2Sgh-Consulting, Hamburg, Germany
OBJECTIVES: To compare costs for hepatitis C patients by analyzing retrospective
sick fund claims data. METHODS: A representative panel of 1,193,464 patients from
several national governmental sick funds were analyzed for 2008. These claims data
include all direct medical costs from hospitals, materials in the outpatient sector and
medication (covering 60% of sick fund full costs). Selection criteria for patients were
at least one confirmed out- or inpatient diagnosis for acute or chronic hepatitis C
(ICD-10 GM B17.1 and B18.2). The sample was divided into two groups, those
treated with pegylated Interferon/Ribavirin ((peg)INF/Rib) (standard of care for
chronic hepatitis C patients according to German guidelines) and those without
(identified by ATC Code L03AB and J05AB04). Of these patients all ICD-10 diagnoses
were grouped by the DxCG software to hierarchical condition categories in order to
calculate risk scores predicting resource use. The expected cost at the average for all
insured persons analyzed in this German sick fund panel is represented by a risk score
of 2.2. Risk scores and co-morbidities were compared with the sick funds average
means. RESULTS: A total fo 2628 hepatitis C patients were identified (0.2% of the
13th Euro Abstracts
panel), 245 with and 2383 without (peg)INF/Rib therapy (treatment rate 9.3%).
Sixty-two percent of patients with hepatitis C suffered from at least 11 co-morbidities
(risk score 8.5), while only 27% of all other patients from the panel suffered from at
least 11 co-morbidities. Further analyses revealed additional pharmacy costs of
c12,200,- for patients treated with (peg)INF/Rib compared to those without. The risk
score for the second year after treatment was 5.7 for (peg)INF/Rib-treated versus 8.7
for (peg)INF/Rib-untreated patients. CONCLUSIONS: A diagnosis of hepatitis C is
associated with high numbers of co-morbidities and high risk scores. Results suggest
that treatment lowers risk scores but keeping them substantially above mean.
INFECTION – Patient-Reported Outcomes Studies
PIN56
REFILL-BASED ADHERENCE RATES OF ANTIRETROVIRAL MEDICATION
USING RETROSPECTIVE MEDICINE CLAIMS DATA: A COST ANALYSIS
Paterson T, Lubbe MS, Serfontein JHP, Du Plessis JM
North-West University, Potchefstroom, South Africa
OBJECTIVES: To determine the refill-based adherence rates and to compare the costs
associated with an under- or over supply of antiretroviral medication. METHODS: A
non-experimental, quantitative retrospective drug utilization review was performed
on medicine claims data from one pharmacy benefit management company. The study
population were selected from all patients (N = 15 901) who received more than one
prescription for antiretroviral medication during a 36 consecutive month period (1
January 2005 to December 2007). An overall refill-based adherence rate was calculated by using the following equation: Refill-based adherence rate = (total days of
antiretroviral items supplied—days supplied at the last refill)/(date last claimed—date
first claimed). (RSA Rand(R)/$US = 6.8595 on 31 December 2007). RESULTS: Refillbased adherence rates were calculated for 41 967 antiretroviral drugs. Less than 50%
(n = 17 267; 41.15%) of all antiretroviral drugs had acceptable adherence rates
(between 90% and 110%). Antiretroviral drugs with adherence rates below 90%
(possibly under-supplied) (n = 7243; 17.26%), accounted for 14.30% (n = R15 829
876.53) of the total cost of all antiretroviral drugs (N = R110 728, 214.00) while
those that were possibly over-supplied (n = 17,454; 41.59%) accounted for 25.60%
(R28 347 266.48). CONCLUSIONS: The calculated refill adherence rates indicated
that most antiretroviral drugs were either possibly over- or under-supplied for the
specific treatment period.
PIN57
EVALUATION OF MEDICATION ADHERENCE IN PATIENTS RECEIVING
ANTIRETROVIRAL THERAPY (ART) IN MAITAMA DISTRICT HOSPITAL,
ABUJA NIGERIA
Agu KA1, Okojie O2, Omonaiye O1, Oqua D1, King RC3, Onuoha C1, Muhammadu I1,
Iyaji PG1
1
Howard University PACE Center, Abuja, FCT, Nigeria; 2University of Benin, Benin, Edo,
Nigeria; 3Howard University PACE Center, Washington, DC, WA, USA
OBJECTIVES: ART has dramatically increased the life expectancy of HIV-infected
patients and its adherence has been strongly correlated with viral suppression, reduced
rates of resistance, an increase in survival, and improved quality of life. The study
evaluated medication adherence, the association of medication adherence with occupation and educational status and identified possible causes of non-adherence in HIVinfected patients after 6 months on ART. METHODS: In a cross-sectional survey,
medication adherence of 118 HIV-infected patients was evaluated using a self-administered study-specific 16-items questionnaire after 6 months on ART. Patients’ selfreport adherence assessment method was used. Chi square statistics was used to test
the association of adherence with occupation and education at 95% CI. RESULTS:
The mean age of the 118 HIV-infected ART patients was 33.89 (95%CI, 29.63–38.15)
years; and majority (82.2%) were between the ages of 26–45 years; 60.2% were
females, 80.5% attained secondary education at the least, while 77.1% employed. All
participants reported being counselled on the benefits of ART and medication adherence at ART initiation. On assessment of participants’ knowledge of the benefits of
ART and medication adherence, 92.2% reported correctly, 2.9% reported wrongly
that ART is a cure for HIV while 4.9% did not respond. Medication adherence level
reported among participants was 79.1%. Educational status was not associated with
adherence (p > 0.05) unlike the occupational status which was associated with adherence (P < 0.05). The major reasons reported for non-adherence were busy at work or
school (33.1%), forgetfulness (15.5%), fasting (12.0%), and travelled or moved away
from home (10.6%). CONCLUSIONS: The medication adherence level among participants was somewhat poor compared to the desired value of >95%; occupational
status was associated with adherence unlike the educational status. Consequently,
busy at work or school was a major reason for non-adherence to medication. Routine
evaluation of medication adherence and intervention in clinical practice is
recommended.
13th Euro Abstracts
PIN58
REPORT ON A PILOT STUDY OF THE SIMPILL REALTIME MEDICATION
ADHERENCE SYSTEM IN TUBERCULOSIS PATIENTS IN CAPE TOWN,
SOUTH AFRICA
Green D1, Tsodzo C2
1
Liberty Health Holdings, Hout Bay, South Africa; 2Ruhr-Universität Bochum, Bochum,
Germany
OBJECTIVES: SIMpill is a medication adherence management system using cellular
networks to provide real-time information about, and support to, patients on long
term medication. The SIMpill system is described in detail. METHODS: A pilot was
carried out from July 1, 2006 to April 12, 2007 in Cape Town, South Africa. Patients
diagnosed with Tuberculosis were taken onto the pilot as they arrived at the clinics
until the desired number of patients was achieved. Contrary to the standard DOTS
protocol, patients were allowed to self medicate either at their homes or their places
of work, supported by the SIMpill system. RESULTS: Of the 155 TB patients enrolled
in the pilot study the following results were recorded: 12 patients (8%) did not have
adequate documentation of outcomes at the end of the pilot and are excluded from
the data. One patient (0.8%) was recorded as a sputum positive treatment failure.
Seven patients (3.3%) interrupted their treatment whilst four patients transferred to
other clinics or died during the pilot study. a total of 131 patients (91.6% including
unrelated interruptions, 94.2% excluding unrelated interruptions) were recorded as
successful treatments. This is contrasted with the background treatment success rate
under the DOTS regimen of 76.4% at the same time in the same communities.
CONCLUSIONS: It is concluded that the SIMpill system is practical to implement,
could dramatically improve treatment success in TB patients and warrants further
study, both in TB and other conditions.
PIN59
DEVELOPMENT OF A SPECIFIC QUESTIONNAIRE TO ASSESS
TREATMENT ADHERENCE OF PATIENTS WITH HCV INFECTION:
ADHEPTA STUDY
Martín-Suárez JM1, Martín-Escudero V2, Pérez-Álvarez R3, Alcántara-Benítez R4, Castellano
G5, de Cuenca B6, Turnes-Vázquez J7, Moreno D8, Delgado-Fernández M9, ÁlvarezGonzález MA10, Testillano-Tarrero M11, Castro-Iglesias MA12, Tural C13, Planas R13,
Lara N14, Solà-Lamoglia R15
1
Hospital de Gran Canaria Dr. Negrín, Las Palmas de Gran Canaria, Spain; 2Roche Farma,
Madrid, Spain; 3Hospital Universitario Central de Asturias, Oviedo, Spain; 4Hospital Clínico
Virgen de la Victoria, Málaga, Spain; 5Hospital Universitario 12 de Octubre, Madrid, Spain;
6
Hospital Infanta Cristina, Madrid, Spain; 7Complejo Hospitalario de Pontevedra, Pontevedra,
Spain; 8Hospital de Móstoles, Madrid, Spain; 9Hospital Carlos Haya, Málaga, Spain; 10Hospital
Sant Joan de Deu Manresa, Barcelona, Spain; 11Hospital de Cruces, Barakaldo, Spain;
12
Hospital Universitario de a Coruña, a Coruña, Spain; 13Hospital Germans Trias i Pujol,
CIBEREHD, Barcelona, Spain; 14Health Economics Outcomes Research, IMS Health S.A.,
Barcelona, Spain,; 15Hospital del Mar (IMIM), Barcelona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Treatment adherence is a key issue in chronic infectious diseases such
as Chronic Hepatitis C (CHC). The aim of the study was to develop two valid and
feasible disease specific questionnaires to assess adherence to treatment of CHC
monoinfected patients and HCV/HIV co-infected patients. METHODS: Questionnaires development was carried out in two phases. In the first phase, a literature review
was performed in order to identify factors closely related to treatment adherence. By
means of a focus group, disease experts selected the items considered most likely to
affect adherence from the initial list, then the chosen items underwent a qualitative
analysis and were rephrased to make them suitable for inclusion in a questionnaire.
The first version of the questionnaires was completed by 18 patients (8 monoinfected
and 10 co-infected) in order to evaluate the comprehension of questions, response
categories, questionnaires applicability and the patients’ opinion on the proposed
questionnaires design. The questionnaires are currently being validated in the second
phase, an ongoing prospective study including 1120 patients. RESULTS: The two
questionnaires developed for monoinfected and for co-infected patients contained 11
and 13 questions, respectively. Both questionnaires included two questions related to
treatment adherence and questions about reasons of non-adherence. To date 843
patients have been included in the prospective study; 71.9% are male, 77.1% are
monoinfected patients, 22.9% co-infected and 63.0% of patients have baseline
RNA-HCV > 800.000 UI/ml (62.1% monoinfected and 66.1% co-infected). The HCV
genotype distribution is 74.8% G-1/4 and 25.7% G-2/3. The HIV positive patients
receiving ART Therapy are 91.2%. CONCLUSIONS: The two disease specific questionnaires developed to assess adherence to treatment showed feasibility and good
comprehension by patients with HCV monoinfection and with HCV/HIV co-infection,
respectively. Further validation is ongoing in a prospective study.
PIN60
CLINICAL PROFILE AND ADHERENCE PATTERN OF ANTI-RETROVIRAL
THERAPY OF PEOPLE LIVING WITH HIV/AIDS REGISTERED AT
DISTRICT ANTI RETROVIRAL THERAPY CENTRE, UDUPI DISTRICT
Singh UP, Nayak GC, Singh S, Rath S, Bihan A, Kumar M
Manipal College of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Manipal, India
OBJECTIVES: To find out the number of people infected with AIDS, the age group
that was badly hit by this disease, the number of deaths and most important of all
the adherence shown by the patient to the treatment regimen. METHODS: Study
subjects: All the people living with HIV/AIDS who were started on Anti Retroviral
Therapy at the District ART Centre, Udupi District from 1st July, 2008 to 31st June,
A441
2009. Case files were reviewed from medical records section and required data was
collected and analyzed using SPSS 11.5 version. RESULTS: Study included 946 cases
of which majority were males 534 and 815 were in the age-group of 15–49. 836 were
residents of Udupi District. CONCLUSIONS: All of them were started on ART and
have been on treatment for atleast 3 months. More than 90% of the patients had
adherence of more than 95%.
PIN62
AN ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF HIBMENCY VACCINATION FOR THE
PREVENTION OF HEMOPHILUS INFLUENZAE TYPE B AND NEISSERIA
MENINGITIDIS TYPES C AND Y
Taylor MJ1, Saxby RC1, Abu-Elyazeed RR2, Misurski DA3
1
University of York, York, UK; 2GlaxoSmithKline, King of Prussia, PA, USA; 3GlaxoSmithKline,
Philadelphia, PA, USA
OBJECTIVES: Since the introduction of conjugate vaccines against Haemophilus
influenza type b (Hib) and Streptococcus pneumonia, Neisseria meningitis is the
leading cause of infant bacterial meningitis. HibMenCY is a new combination vaccine
being developed for protection against meningococcal groups C and Y (MenCY) and
Hib. This analysis compared the cost-effectiveness of a four dose HibMenCY vaccination strategy (2, 4, 6 and 12 months) to Hib vaccination (2, 4, 6 and 12 months) and
to no Hib or MenCY vaccination from a public health perspective. METHODS: A
Markov model was used to simulate lifetime events, predicting the likelihood of
disease with and without specific vaccinations. Costs and health consequences were
built into the model to allow the prediction of lifetime costs and quality-adjusted
life-years (QALYs). The model was populated with published data throughout, and
one-way sensitivity analyses were undertaken when there was uncertainty about key
parameter values. a discount rate of 3% annually was applied. RESULTS: For HibMenCY vaccination relative to Hib alone, 13 additional cases per 100,000 treated
patients would be prevented, resulting in an additional 104 QALYS saved. The additional HibMenCY vaccine program cost over Hib alone was $6.61M resulting in a
cost/QALY of $63,701. For HibMenCY vaccination relative to no Hib or MenCY
vaccination, 61 cases of meningitis were prevented per 100,000 treated patients,
resulting in an additional 467 QALYS saved. The additional HibMenCY vaccine
program cost was $3.14M resulting in a cost/QALY of $6738. CONCLUSIONS:
When accounting for the ability of the HibMenCY vaccine to prevent infection from
both pathogens this intervention is estimated to be highly cost-effective. If only the
incremental benefit of MenCY is considered, the intervention would result in a better
cost/QALY than that reported for several widely implemented vaccine strategies. Thus
infant HibMenCY vaccination is expected to be a cost-effective strategy that provides
substantial health benefits.
PIN63
PATIENT PREFERENCES FOR BENEFITS, RISKS, AND WEIGHT OF
EVIDENCE ASSOCIATED WITH HEPATITIS B TREATMENTS
Mohamed A1, Johnson FR1, Hauber AB1, Lescrauwaet B2, Masterson A2
1
RTI Health Solutions, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA; 2Bristol-Myers Squibb, 1420
Braine—L’Alleud, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: To elicit patient preferences for benefits, risks, and weight of evidence
associated with hepatitis B treatments. METHODS: Adults in 5 countries (France,
Germany, Spain, Italy, and Turkey) with a self-reported physician diagnosis of hepatitis B completed a web-enabled, choice-format, conjoint-analysis survey. The survey
presented patients with a series of 12 trade-off questions, each including a pair of
hypothetical hepatitis B medication profiles. Each profile was defined by how long the
medicine has been studied (weight of evidence), chance that the medicine will work
well for 5 years (long-term efficacy), 5-year fracture risk, 5-year risk of kidney disease,
and cost. Trade-off questions were based on predetermined experimental design with
known statistical properties. Random-parameters logit was used to estimate a preference weight for each attribute level and the mean relative importance of each attribute.
RESULTS: 560 subjects completed the survey. Patients actively traded between efficacy, side-effect risks, and weight of evidence among the hypothetical hepatitis B
medication profiles. On an importance-weight scale where 0 is the least important
outcome and 10 is the most important outcome, the 5-year risk of kidney disease was
the most important attribute to patients over the range of levels included in the survey
[95% CI: 7.8–12.2]. The remaining attributes were ranked in decreasing order of
importance as: chance that the medicine will work well for 5 years (8.9 [95%CI:
7.1–10.7]), how long the medicine has been studied (8.2 [95%CI: 7.6–8.8]), and
5-year fracture risk (5.8 [95%CI: 3.6–8.0]). CONCLUSIONS: Although long-term
efficacy is important to hepatitis B patients, the 5-year risk of kidney disease,in particular, also influence patients’ treatment choices. Patients are willing to make tradeoffs between efficacy, side-effect risks, and weight of evidence among hepatitis B
treatments.
PIN64
HERPES ZOSTER AND POST-HERPETIC NEURALGIA: CONSIDERATIONS
FOR A PROSPECTIVE, CROSS-SECTIONAL, PATIENT REPORTED
OUTCOMES STUDY
Carroll S1, Gater A2, Abetz L2, Demuth D3, Smith F3, Mannan A1
1
Sanofi Pasteur MSD, Maidenhead, Berkshire, UK; 2Mapi Values Ltd, Bollington, Cheshire, UK;
3
Adelphi Real World, Bollington, Cheshire, UK
OBJECTIVES: The pain and discomfort associated with Herpes Zoster (HZ) and
Post-Herpetic Neuralgia (PHN) can have a substantial negative impact on patients’
A442
Health-Related Quality of Life (HRQoL). To inform the design of a large-scale prospective study of the patient-reported impact of HZ and PHN in the UK, a review of
published prospective studies was conducted. METHODS: A targeted literature review
was conducted in MEDLINE® to identify prospective studies investigating the impact
of HZ and PHN from the patient’s perspective. Searches were limited to studies
published in English between April 2000 and April 2010. The adequacy of these
studies in quantifying the burden of HZ and PHN was critically assessed. RESULTS:
Only a small number of published prospective studies (n = 6) designed to investigate
the impact of HZ or PHN from patients’ perspectives were identified; one of which
was conducted in the UK. The HRQoL burden associated with HZ and PHN was
highlighted in the studies reviewed albeit a number of key points were noted. First,
the burden of HZ and PHN has not been compared to HRQoL estimates for the
general population or to those with comparable acute or chronic conditions, thereby
making interpretation difficult. Furthermore, studies conducted to date have not
accounted for the variations in pain and HRQOL burden at different stages of HZ
presentation. Finally, from the studies reviewed, the pain experienced by patients with
HZ and PHN is managed with a wide variety of products. However, until now no
formal assessment of patient satisfaction with these products has been conducted.
CONCLUSIONS: Although it is known that HZ and PHN can have a negative impact
on HRQOL, limitations in previous research can be noted. In order to address these
concerns, a large-scale UK-based prospective study is currently being conducted.
PIN65
IMPACT OF HERPES ZOSTER AND POSTHERPETIC NEURALGIA ON
PATIENTS’ QUALITY OF LIFE
Chassany O1, Gaillat J2, Hanslik T3, Bourhis Y4, Launay O5, Mann C6, Rabaud C7,
Rogeaux O8, Strady C9, Bouhassira D10
1
Assistance Publique-Hopitaux de Paris, Paris, France; 2CHR Annecy, Pringy, France; 3Hôpital
Ambroise Paré, Boulogne-Billancourt, France; 4REGISTRAT-MAPI, Lyon, France; 5Groupe
hospitalier Cochin—Saint-Vincent de Paul, Paris, France; 6Hôpital Saint-Eloi, CHU de
Montpellier, Montpellier, France; 7CHU de Nancy—Hôpitaux de Brabois, Vandoeuvre les
Nancy, France; 8CH de Chambéry, Chambéry, France; 9CHU de Reims, Reims, France;
10
Hôpital Ambroise Paré, Boulogne-Billancourt, France
OBJECTIVES: Incidence and severity of herpes zoster (HZ) increase with age. Postherpetic neuralgia (PHN) is its most common complication. The study objective was to
assess the impact of HZ and PHN on daily life and quality of life (QoL) as perceived
by the patient. METHODS: A 12-month, longitudinal, observational study conducted
on patients aged ≥50 years with acute HZ (eruptive phase), included by a representative sample of 644 French general practitioners (GP) between June 2007 and June
2008. Demographic and disease characteristics and treatment procedures were collected by the GP at the inclusion and at 3, 6 and 12 months. PHN and QoL assessments were performed by telephone interview of patients, at regular time points over
12 months, using comprehensive and validated questionnaires. RESULTS: a total of
1358 patients met the selection criteria and 1032 completed the follow-up. Mean age
was 67.7 ± 10.7 years (62.2% female). Mean time between rash onset and HZ diagnosis was 2.6 ± 3.0 days. Most patients (94.1%) were treated with antiviral drugs.
PHN prevalence at inclusion, 3, 6, and 12 months was 79.6%, 11.6%, 8.5%, and
6.6% respectively. Mean Zoster Brief Pain Inventory (ZBPI) interference score (range
= 0–10 worse) at inclusion, 3, 6 and 12 months was 3.1 ± 2.4, 2.9 ± 2.3, 2.5 ± 2.1,
2.7 ± 2.3 respectively, with main impact on general activity, sleep and mood. Throughout the 12-month study period, patients with persistent PHN presented lower scores
on the physical (e.g. at 12 month: 39.7 ± 13.7) and mental (43.6 ± 11.3) component
summaries of the 12-item short-form health survey (SF-12) than the patients without
PHN, respectively 46.0 ± 10.6 and 47.8 ± 10.5. Moreover, univariate analysis found
that among predictive factors at inclusion for PHN were a ZBPI score ≥5 (P < 0.001)
and a low SF-12 physical component summary (P < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: This
large cohort study confirms the HZ and PHN impact on daily life and quality of life,
in spite of prompt diagnosis and antiviral treatment.
PIN66
EVALUATION OF HEALTH-RELATED QUALITY OF LIFE (HRQOL) IN
PATIENTS RECEIVING ANTIRETROVIRAL THERAPY IN MAITAMA
DISTRICT HOSPITAL, ABUJA NIGERIA
Agu KA1, Okojie O2, Omonaiye O1, Oqua D1, King RC3, Onuoha C1, Muhammadu I1,
Iyaji PG1
1
Howard University PACE Center, Abuja, FCT, Nigeria; 2University of Benin, Benin, Edo,
Nigeria; 3Howard University PACE Center, NW, WA, USA
OBJECTIVES: HIV-infected patients demonstrate a health-related quality of life
(HRQoL) lower than that of the general population. The goals of antiretroviral
therapy (ART) include the improvement of HRQOL in addition to the reduction of
symptoms, suppression of the virus, and enhancement of survival. The study evaluated
HRQoL of HIV-infected patients at months 0 and 6 of receiving ART; and compared
the HRQoL index of male and female participants. METHODS: The HRQoL of a
cohort of 150 HIV-infected patients was evaluated at months 0 and 6 of receiving
ART using SF-36 health survey form. Wilcoxon’s signed ranks test was used to
compare the HRQoL index between two groups of data. All reported P values were
2-sided, and P < 0.05 was used to determine statistical significance. RESULTS: The
mean age of the 150 patients at initiation of antiretroviral treatment was 34.30 (95%
CI, 32.96–35.64) years; and 59.3% were females. At 6 months follow-up, 118
(78.7%) ART patients who met the 6th month medication refill appointment were
evaluated for HRQoL. Before commencing ART, the mean HRQoL of participants
13th Euro Abstracts
was 71.22 (95%CI, 68.00–74.44) which increased significantly to 90.83 (95%CI,
88.49–93.17) at 6 months follow up on ART (P < 0.05). The change across all the
HRQoL domains in the SF-36 instrument was also statistically significant (P < 0.05)
except for the domains of role limitation due to emotional problems, social functioning
and pain (p > 0.05). Difference in the HRQoL index of male and female gender at
months 0 and 6 was not statistically significant (p > 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: There
was a significant improvement in the mean HRQoL of the participants after 6 months
of ART; the difference between HRQoL index of male and female participants was
not significant. Routine evaluation of HRQoL in clinical practice is highly recommended as long-term outcome may be different.
INFECTION – Health Care Use & Policy Studies
PIN67
MODELING G-DRG REVENUE WHEN HOSPITALIZATION DURATION
FROM CLINICAL TRIALS IS AVAILABLE: THE CASE OF DORIPENEM
VERSUS IMIPENEM IN TREATING VENTILATOR-ASSOCIATED
PNEUMONIA (VAP) IN GERMANY
De Cock E1, Gast C2, Berndt K3, Kubitz N3
1
United BioSource Corporation, Barcelona, Spain; 2Axio Research Acquisition Co. LLC,
Seattle, WA, USA, 3Janssen-Cilag GmbH, Neuss, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Since the introduction of G-DRGs, hospitals have become increasingly
concerned about impact of changes in clinical practice on hospital costs and revenue.
We developed an algorithm to estimate expected G-DRG payment by drug, when
length-of-stay (LOS) data from clinical trials are available. We compared results with
a scenario where only median values by trial arm are available. METHODS: G-DRG
attribution is driven by MV duration and intensive care severity score. From a Phase
III trial comparing doripenem and imipenem (DORI-10), we determined nine categories of MV duration (ranges based on MV hours resulting in higher-paying G-DRGs).
Using the Muenster Webgrouper, we obtained G-DRG weights when simultaneously
varying MV duration and intensive care severity (15 levels) for four clinical profiles.
For the nine categories and by drug, we obtained percentage patients per group and
median LOS by type of ward using. Per category, the appropriate G-DRG weight was
selected based on: chosen profile, total MV duration, intensive care severity, and total
LOS. Using distribution of patients by category derived from DORI-10, a weighted
G-DRG was calculated for each arm, and multiplied by the 2010 base value to yield
expected G-DRG payment. RESULTS: G-DRG revenue ranged from c2,578 to c8,575
(across 4 scenarios) to c136,164 for MV ≥ 1800 hours. Using trial-based median LOS
values, expected G-DRG revenue is c30,397 (all scenarios), with no difference in
G-DRG revenue in both trial arms. When using the categories approach, expected
revenue reduction when using doripenem instead of imipenem ranged from c2,084 to
c2,451. CONCLUSIONS: A G-DRG revenue analysis helps to better understand net
impact of introducing a new drug on a hospital’s budget. When LOS data (including
MV) vary by drug and data from clinical studies are available, a classification
approach enables more refined G-DRG revenue estimates as opposed to using median
values by drug.
PIN68
EFFECT OF THE ANTIBIOTICS USE MONITORING PROGRAM FOR THE
ACUTE UPPER-RESPIRATORY INFECTIONS DISEASE IN KOREAN
CLINICS
Choi SE1, Park KH1, Lim EA1, Kim SK2
1
Seoul National University, Seoul, South Korea; 2Health Insurance Review & Assessment
Agency, Seoul, South Korea
OBJECTIVES: Overuse of antibiotics has been focused for the public health and
pharmaceutical expenditure in Korea. National Health Insurance introduced the antibiotics use monitoring program in 2002. This program includes a monitoring the
antibiotics prescription rates of medical institutes, a feedback to prescribers, and a
report to the public via website. This study aims to evaluate the impact of this program
on the antibiotics prescription rates for the acute upper-respiratory infections (URI)
in Korea. METHODS: We assessed the antibiotics prescription rates for the acute URI
(J00-J06) of individual medical institutes from 2002 to 2008. Data was extracted from
NHI outpatient’s claims database and the first quarter data of each year were selected
to avoid seasonal variation. To evaluate the effect of program, we assumed the early
change of prescription rate during 2002–2003 as a baseline, and compared it with
every year variations of the prescription rate for 2004–2008. Generalized Estimation
Equation (GEE) model was constructed to investigate the changes in antibiotics prescription. RESULTS: Data included about 49 million claims from 13,211 clinics
(94.5% of all acute URI claims and 70.5% of all clinics in 2008). Prescription rate
declined from 72.8% to 55.1% during 2002–2008. The analysis showed that the
antibiotics use monitoring program reduced 6.11% of antibiotics prescription rate per
clinic annually (OR: 0.62, 95% CI: 0.61, 0.64, P < 0.0001). The reduced antibiotics
prescription estimate was average 4.5 million a year. CONCLUSIONS: After monitoring system introduced, the antibiotics prescription rates for acute URI patients have
continuously decreased in the clinics.
13th Euro Abstracts
PIN69
OUTPATIENT ANTIBIOTIC USE IN PRIMARY HEALTH CARE IN NIS
REGION
Kodela B1, Velickovic-Radovanovic R2, Petrovic J2, Mitic R2, Aleksic G1
1
Pharmaceutical Institution of Nis, Nis, Serbia; 2Clinical Centre, Nis, Serbia
OBJECTIVES: Monitoring of antibiotic prescribing promotes rational use of drugs,
reduces costs and slows down the development of resistance. The purpose of this study
was to evaluate the prescribing of antibiotics in PHC of Niš region, during 2005–2009
and to identify the practice of drug overuse, under-use or inappropriate use.
METHODS: The data on outpatient use of antibacterials for systemic use was
obtained by retrospective study and expressed as the number of defined daily doses
per 1000 inhabitants per day (DDD), according to WHO anatomic therapeutic chemical classification and DDD measurement methodology. The City Pharmacy Department provided automatic reports on antibiotics prescribed by physicians for certain
diagnoses in the Nis region over the 2005–2009 period. RESULTS: In the same period,
outpatient antibiotic use in Nis region increased by 9.02% (22.83/ 25.96 DID). The
most commonly prescribed drugs were semi-synthetics penicillins (9.67/10.00 DDD)
and macrolides (3.05 /4.90 DDD). The greatest increase in antibiotics prescriptions
was noted in azithromycin (0.26/0.70 DID, by 164%). Out of the total number of
antibiotics, 70.5% prescriptions were made for treatment of URIs. Pharingitis ac. (J02)
was the most common indication for prescription of antimicrobial medicines
(45.26%). Amoxicillin (33%) and cephalexin (35%) were most commonly prescribed
antibiotics for this indication. The total number of antibiotics prescriptions was
increased by 14% while the cost was increased by 28% compared to 2005. CONCLUSIONS: Outpatient antibiotics use in Niš is high compared to the majority of European
countries, which indicates the need for additional educational programs and monitoring of microbiological sensitivity in future. The received results will be the basis for
further evaluation of the rationality of use of antibiotics in primary health care.
PIN70
COST EQUITY ANALYSIS OF MALARIA MANAGEMENT: A PILOT
STUDY IN THE AFRICAN SETTING
Espinoza MA1, Griffin S1, Cookson R2
1
Centre for Health Economics, York, UK; 2Department of Social Policy and Social Work,
York, UK
OBJECTIVES: To study the equity efficiency trade-off between decisions made based
on maximization of health benefits averaged for the whole population and decisions
made considering the distribution of benefits across socio economic groups of the
population. METHODS: Cost-equity analysis nested in a CEA where ten different
strategies for the management of patients with suspected non-complicated malaria
were compared, in the African setting. Access to health clinics, access to treatment
and adherence to the treatment were considered to vary between socio economic
groups. a further hypothetical therapeutic alternative associated with 100% adherence
for all groups was incorporated. Probabilistic sensitivity analysis was performed to
reflect the uncertainty around parameter values. Inequality in the distribution of
benefits was estimated for each strategy using Concentration Indices (CI). The opportunity cost was estimated comparing the most cost-effective alternative against the
most cost-equitable strategy in terms of health benefits forgone to achieve a certain
number of equality units. RESULTS: The most equitable strategy was also the most
efficient for thresholds between US$137 and US$375 per DALY averted. Differences
in equity of DALY burden between strategies were small (range CI units: 0.061–0.096)
meaning the opportunity cost of choosing the most equitable strategy for threshold
values outside of that range were relatively high, e.g. at US$400/DALY averted the
opportunity cost was 0.11 DALYs per percentage point reduction in the CI. CONCLUSIONS: Equity concerns can be incorporated in the economic evaluation offering
an estimation of the trade-off between efficiency and equity. Collection of information
about access, adherence, effectiveness and costs according to socioeconomic group is
required, but also information on prevalence for appropriate calculation of CI.
PIN71
CLINICAL AND ECONOMIC BURDEN OF PEDIATRIC INFLUENZA IN
NINE EUROPEAN COUNTRIES
Rycroft C1, Leeuwenkamp O2, Heikkinen T3, Principi N4, Herz J5, Moren S6, Beard S7
1
RTI Health Solutions, Manchester, UK; 2Formerly MedImmune Ltd, Cambridge, UK; 3Turku
University Hospital, Turku, Finland; 4University of Milan, Milan, Italy; 5AstraZeneca, Zaventem,
Belgium; 6MedImmune, LLC, Gaithersburg, MD, USA; 7RTI Health Solutions, Sheffield, UK
OBJECTIVES: Seasonal influenza incurs a substantial clinical and economic burden
in infants, children, and adolescents. The objectives of this literature review were to
assess the reported incidence and complications of virologically-confirmed paediatric
influenza, and to evaluate the extent of health care utilization, absenteeism, direct
health care costs, and societal costs in nine European countries: the United Kingdom,
Germany, Italy, Spain, France, Sweden, the The Netherlands, Finland, and Austria.
METHODS: A structured literature search (January 1970-March 2009) of PubMed,
EMBASE, and the Cochrane Library was conducted. Data on influenza burden in
children (aged ≤15 years) were extracted from 43 publications. Of these, 13 articles
presented data on virologically-confirmed influenza. Pooled data from these 13 studies
are presented. RESULTS: Data varied widely between countries. Median incidence of
confirmed influenza was 15.4% but ranged from 1.1 to 33.0% (n = 6 studies) in
children aged ≤15 years. This wide range in incidence resulted from differences
between studies in influenza confirmation methods, age groups, and influenza seasons.
Complications due to influenza were frequently reported (e.g., acute otitis media
A443
[range 0–40% [n = 7 studies]], pharyngitis [range 31–48% [n = 3 studies]]). In one
study, a 3-fold increase in direct medical costs (c189–c206 vs. c59 [2004 costs]) was
observed. In another study of children aged ≤1 year, hospitalization was reported to
be the main driver of disease-related direct medical costs with hospitalization rates of
about 20%. Of children with confirmed influenza, 28–55% used antibiotics (n = 6
studies) and 76–86% required antipyretics or symptomatic treatment (n = 5 studies).
Confirmed influenza in children was associated with 3–12 days’ absence from school/
daycare (n = 5 studies), and 1.3–6.3 days’ parental absence from work (n = 6 studies).
CONCLUSIONS: The clinical and economic burden of virologically-confirmed paediatric influenza in Europe appears to be significant as revealed by incidence and
associated morbidity and costs. This study was funded by MedImmune, LLC.
PIN72
BRAZILIAN STD/AIDS PROGRAMME: EXPENDITURE ON
ANTIRETROVIRAL DRUGS AND EPIDEMIC INDICATORS DURING THE
PERIOD 2004–2008
Aurea AP, Garcia LP, de Magalhaes LCG, dos Santos CF, de Almeida RF
Institute for Applied Economic Research, Brasilia, DF, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: The Brazilian STD/AIDS Programme stands out for ensuring universal
and free access to antiretroviral drugs. We estimated the Federal expenditure on
antiretroviral drugs of the Brazilian STD/AIDS Programme, during the period 2004–
2008, and compared it to epidemic indicators of the Brazilian population. METHODS:
The expenditure on antiretroviral drugs comes from a data warehouse of the Ministry
of Planning, Budget and Management that stores the information concerning any
purchase made by the Brazilian Federal Government. The epidemiological indicators
of AIDS are derived from the Brazilian STD/AIDS Programme, which combines data
from different national information systems. RESULTS: The expenditure on antiretroviral drugs rose from US$144.416.113,57 in 2004, to US$333.050.295,64, in 2008.
In Brazil, from January 2004 to June 2008, there were 148.852 cases of AIDS
reported, which corresponds to an incidence rate of approximately 20 cases per 100
thousand inhabitants. In the period from 2004 to 2007 there were 44.381 deaths due
to AIDS in Brazil, representing a crude mortality ratio of about 6 deaths per 100
thousand inhabitants. CONCLUSIONS: The use of antiretroviral drugs increases the
survival of patients with HIV/AIDS and reduces the mortality rate. Despite the stability
of AIDS incidence and mortality coefficients over the analyzed period, the expenditure
increased, which can be due to an increase in coverage and range of drugs offered. As
the resources are limited, it is important to understand the magnitude of the consumption as well as the mechanisms of purchase in order to improve the supply of antiretroviral drugs.
VA3
FACTORS INFLUENCING THE DECISION TO BE VACCINATED
AGAINST H1N1 IN GREECE
Athanasakis K, Zavras D, Kyriopoulos J
National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece
OBJECTIVES: In view of the 2009 emergence of Influenza a (H1N1) and the declaration of a phase 6 pandemic by WHO, Greece established a voluntary vaccination
program for the entire country population. The aim of the present study was to
investigate factors affecting individuals’ decision to participate. METHODS: We conducted repeated weekly telephone surveys until a random sample of 12,639 households stratified according to place of residence (geographical area and level of
urbanization) was formulated. The interviews were based on a strictly structured
questionnaire designed for the purpose of the study. a logistic regression analysis was
conducted in order to identify the factors that influence individuals’ decision to be
vaccinated against H1N1. The Hosmer–Lemeshow criterion was used to check the
model’s goodness of fit. RESULTS: Higher levels of personal education (Odds Ratio:
0.61) and income (OR: 0.42) were associated with a negative decision to participate
to the vaccination program. However, when an interaction term between the two
variables was used, individuals of both higher education and income were more likely
to have participated in the program (OR: 1.26). On the contrary, increased levels of
concern/fear for the H1N1 and increased confidence to the personal/family physician,
both measured in a 5-point Likert scale, showed a positive relationship. The Hosmer–
Lemeshow goodness of fit test statistic was 0.98 suggesting satisfactory fit of the
model. CONCLUSIONS: In Greece, a country where less than 5% of the total population participated to the voluntary vaccination program against H1N1, socioeconomic
status, as expressed through income and education, the role of the family physician
and the personal attitude towards H1N1 were important factors for a positive decision. In the case of similar future efforts, these variables should be taken into account,
in order to facilitate focused interventions.
PIN73
FACTORS AFFECTING THE DECISION TO RECEIVE VACCINATION FOR
INFLUENZA VIRUS H1N1
Zavras D1, Kyriopoulos J2
1
National School of Public Health, Athens, Attiki, Greece; 2National School of Public Health,
Athens, Greece
OBJECTIVES: The objective of this study was to determine factors affecting the
population’s decision to get vaccinated against the influenza H1N1 virus. METHODS:
Data for this study was obtained from a Panhellenic survey, organized by the National
School of Public Health of Greece. The sample (n = 12,639) was drawn from strata
of various degrees of urbanization and geographical region. The primary outcome of
the survey was the intent to get vaccinated for H1N1; logistic regression was used to
A444
identify significant potential determinants. RESULTS: The decision of vaccination for
influenza virus H1N1 was associated with factors related to education, income, interaction between education and income, gender, trust to Public Health Organizations
and perceptions about the health effects of influenza virus H1N1. Individuals of higher
education and income, do not intend to get vaccinated. This also holds for individuals
who express low degree of trust to or believe that the H1N1 virus is not a serious
threat to human health. CONCLUSIONS: We identified several socioeconomic and
demographic factors affecting individual intent to get vaccinated for H1N1. Personal
beliefs about the health effects of H1N1 virus and trust to Public Health Organizations
were also significant predictors of vaccination intent.
PIN74
PARENTS’ DILEMMA WHETHER OR NOT TO VACCINATE THEIR
CHILDREN AGAINST INFLUENZA A (H1N1)
Tsiantou V1, Zavras D2, Kyriopoulos J1
1
National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece; 2National School of Public Health,
Athens, Attiki, Greece
OBJECTIVES: In April 2009, WHO announced the emergence of Influenza a (H1N1)
and a phase 6 pandemic was declared a few months later. Vaccination was identified
as an effective measure in order to eliminate the pandemic and ensure public health.
The aim of the present study was to investigate the factors affecting parents’ decision
to vaccinate their children. METHODS: A telephone survey was conducted in a random
sample of 12,639 households stratified by geographical area using a strictly structured
questionnaire designed for the purpose of the study. The survey lasted from October
2009 to January 2010. a logistic regression analysis was conducted in order to identify
the factors that influence parents’ decision to vaccinate their children. The Hosmer–Lemeshow criterion was used to check the model’s goodness of fit. RESULTS: A total of
3585 households were eligible and were included in the analysis. Education, income,
concern about H1N1 and trust to the CDC were statistically significant. According to
the analysis the higher the levels of education (OR 0.64) and income (OR 0.80) of the
parents the lower the probability to vaccinate their children. However, the interaction
term between education and income showed a positive relationship between these and
the dependent variable. The greater the concern about H1N1 and the trust to the CDC
the higher the probability for the parents to vaccinate their children. The Hosmer–Lemeshow goodness of fit test statistic was 0.52 suggesting satisfactory fit of the model.
CONCLUSIONS: Based on our results concerns about the H1N1 and trust on the CDC
were influencing positively the decision for vaccination. The negative relationship
between education and income and parents’ decision for vaccination was interesting and
need further investigation. Results can explain the low vaccination rates against H1N1
in Greece and can be used by policy makers to improve future vaccination campaigns.
PIN75
ESTIMATION OF PATIENTS WITH ANTIRETROVIRAL THERAPY
POTENTIALLY USED FOR HIV PREVENTION (POST-EXPOSURE
PROPHYLAXIS, MOTHER-TO-CHILD TRANSMISSION PROPHYLAXIS) IN
GERMANY
Tomeczkowski J1, Guthoff-Hagen S2, Biteeva I1, Kruppert S3, Stoll M4
1
Janssen-Cilag GmbH, Neuss, Germany; 2Sgh-Consulting, Hamburg, Germany; 3IMS Health
GmbH & Co. OHG, Frankfurt/Main, Germany; 4Medical University of Hanover (MHH),
Hannover, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Determine the number of patients who received antiretroviral therapy
(ART) potentially prescribed for prevention of HIV infection in Germany in 2008.
METHODS: A representative panel of 1,193,464 patients from different nationwide
operating governmental sick funds were analyzed for 2008. Patients with a confirmed
diagnosis of HIV (ICD-10: B20–24: 64,8%; R75: 0,9%; U85: 0,6%; U60–61: 14,9%;
Z21: 18,8%) were included. In addition, an IMS pharmacy panel (LRx) with 26,815
patients who had received ART identified by ATC Code J05C (Tenofovir was excluded
because of use in Hepatitis) in October 2008 to September 2009 were analyzed (54%
of all patients with ART-prescriptions). RESULTS: Sick funds: 927 patients with HIV
diagnosis were identified (0.08% of the panel), 548 received an ART (treatment rate
59.1%). Pharmacies: 46% of patients received an ART prescription in 4 quarters,
16.9% in 3 quarters, 12.1% in 2 quarters and 24.9% in 1 quarter. 17.5% received
prescriptions only on 1 day while of these patients 12% did not have any other ART
prescription at least 4 months before or after the analysis period. Patients who received
prescriptions on 1 day only, were younger, more often female and received more often
Lopinavir/Ritonavir compared to patients who received prescriptions on more days.
When extrapolating the numbers to the German governmentally insured population
and comparing the numbers from sick funds of patients with a confirmed diagnosis
receiving ART with patients who received an ART from pharmacies, about 30% of
patients with ART prescription could not be matched to a confirmed diagnosis.
CONCLUSIONS: Thirty percent of patients received ART prescriptions without confirmed HIV diagnosis. Twelve percent of patients received ART prescriptions on one
day only. Since these patients were younger, more often female and received agents
more often used in prophylactic regimens, we assume that prescription of ART for
prevention or post-exposure prophylaxis is likely in this group.
PIN76
THE USE OF ECONOMIC ANALYSIS IN VACCINE EXPERT REVIEWS
Jacobs P
Institute of Health Economics, Edmonton, AB, Canada
OBJECTIVES: Since the beginning of the new millennium, prices of vaccines have
been increasing significantly, reflecting decades of research and development. As they
13th Euro Abstracts
have done with pharmaceuticals, governments have begun to incorporate economic
considerations into scientific reviews. Vaccines fall into the public health category,
whose ethic differs historically from that in the pharmaceutical market. The purpose
of this paper is to review how countries have incorporated economics into the scientific
vaccine review process. METHODS: We contacted experts in countries which had
scientific review committees according to the VENICE website, and the USA, Australia, New Zealand, and Hong Kong. We asked a series of questions regarding the
structure of the review process, the role of economics, and the economic criteria used.
RESULTS: We obtained information from ten countries which used economics in their
vaccine scientific reviews. In terms of structure, reviews fell into two groups—those
which incorporated economics into the scientific review (GB, FI, FR, HK, NL, NZ, US)
and those which separated economic and clinical considerations (SW, AU). The criteria
used in economic studies followed the pharmaceutical guidelines in all instances. CONCLUSIONS: Pharmaco-economics has grown up in the world of pharmaceuticals, not
in the public health arena. The ethics in these two arenas differ. Certain elements—epidemiological considerations, herd immunity, long effect times—are relevant to vaccines.
Using pharmacoeconomic rules for vaccines may not create a level playing field.
INFECTION – Conceptual Papers & Research on Methods
PIN77
DO WE ADEQUATELY MODEL THE BENEFIT OF ROTAVIRUS
VACCINATION OVER TIME?
Standaert B1, Gomez J2, Acosta-Rodriguez C3, Debrus S1
1
GlaxoSmithKline Biologicals, Wavre, Belgium; 2GlaxoSmithKline Biologicals, Buenos Aires,
Argentina; 3GlaxoSmithKline, Philadelphia, PA, USA
OBJECTIVES: Models estimating the impact of rotavirus vaccines over time use
vaccine efficacy (VE) results from clinical trials measured at different time points. The
formula to calculate VE measures diarrhea events observed in the vaccinated arm
divided by events in the non-vaccinated arm during certain periods. Two problems
occur: 1) the control arm builds up its own natural immunity over time: VE measured
by the formula is therefore the net vaccine effect (NVE) that decreases as soon as the
rate of infection increases; 2) natural immunity should be considered in the vaccinated
arm as well as a booster phenomenon whereas this is generally omitted. How much
will the cost-effectiveness result be impacted if natural immunity in the vaccinated arm
is considered by improving the NVE-value over time? METHODS: A markov cohort
model is used to measure the cost-effectiveness of vaccinating children at 2 and 3
months against rotavirus infection in a country such as Panama as an example. The
HE-model considers the health authority perspective, a life time horizon, and an
annual discount rate of 3% on cost and effect. In sensitivity analysis the NVE decrease
is varied over time post-vaccination from an annual linear 15% decrease to equal
value post-2 doses. The outcome measure is the change in cost-effectiveness result in
function of the variation in NVE-decrease. RESULTS: With the 15% decrease in NVE
the QALY gain is 0.0124/person, the extra cost $2.46, and the ICER = $199/QALY
gained. Improving the NVE to no decrease post-2 doses results in a QALY gain of
0.0132 (+6%), an extra-cost of $0.98 (−99%), and an ICER reduction to $74/QALY
gained. CONCLUSIONS: Assuming sustained VE over time because of natural immunity in the vaccinated arm improves the economic results -especially the costs data.
The gain will mainly occur post-disease peak after 2 years.
PIN78
ECONOMIC IMPACT OF INFLUENZA EPIDEMICS: MODELLING
INTERACTIONS OF INFECTIONS, TREATMENT PATHWAYS AND
REIMBURSEMENT
Einzinger P1, Zauner G2, Gyimesi M1, Schiller-Frühwirth I3, Pfeffer N3
1
Vienna University of Technology, Vienna, Austria; 2Dwh Simulation Services, Vienna, Austria;
3
Main Association of Austrian Social Security Institutions, Vienna, Austria
OBJECTIVES: Infectious diseases spread through social contacts and affect people of
all age groups. Traditional epidemic models consider these effects with the use of
differential equations, contact networks or explicit modelling of households and
workplaces. However past modelling studies did not implement structures of the
health service system, like service providers (e.g. physicians) and their reimbursement.
Therefore we investigate the integration of an epidemic contact model for influenza
into a framework for modelling treatment pathways and reimbursement of service
providers. METHODS: The model framework is of object-oriented and agent based
type. It incorporates patients and providers as spatially distributed agents. When
patients develop diseases they search for service providers and treatment through a
central health market, which in general returns one of the nearest providers of
requested type. Each disease is connected to the possible treatment pathways and
health services that a patient with the specific disease will go through. In the study we
incorporate influenza epidemics occurring at specified time intervals. These epidemics
spread through contacts of the agents modelled by a small-world network. Patients
get immune after recovering and therefore one epidemic cannot infect them twice. The
model calculates reimbursement from consumed health provider services and drugs.
RESULTS: Modeled epidemics show the well-known behaviour of SIR-type models.
Reduced capacity of service providers provokes that many patients do not consult
them due to queuing effects. The model maps the development of costs over time
plausibly. Different prescription probabilities of neuraminidase inhibitors influence the
course of the epidemic only marginally. CONCLUSIONS: The integration of epidemic
models with models of health service processes and reimbursement can lead toward
13th Euro Abstracts
a broader understanding of the influence of epidemics on health care systems. It is
possible to investigate feedback of health service structure changes and reimbursement
decisions on prevalence and effects of infectious diseases.
PIN79
IS IT POSSIBLE TO OBTAIN WILLINGNESS-TO-PAY ESTIMATES IN
EUROPE? A VALIDITY TEST OF STATED PREFERENCES FOR
HEPATITIS-B TREATMENTS
Johnson FR1, Mohamed A1, Hauber AB1, Lescrauwaet B2
1
RTI Health Solutions, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA; 2Bristol-Myers Squibb,
Braine—L’Alleud, Belgium
BACKGROUND: Because health care is highly insured in Europe, many discretechoice experiment (DCE) researchers have concerns about the feasibility of obtaining
valid willingness-to-pay (WTP) estimates. OBJECTIVES: To test the validity of WTP
estimates obtained from patient DCE data in 5 countries. METHODS: Adults with a
self-reported physician diagnosis of hepatitis B in 4 European countries (France,
Germany, Spain, and Italy) and Turkey completed a web-enabled, DCE. The survey
presented patients with a series of 12 trade-off questions, each including a pair of
hypothetical hepatitis-B treatments described by efficacy, two side-effect risks, weight
of evidence, and cost. All the subjects saw cost levels of c0, c10, and c25. Half the
subjects evaluated an additional cost level of c75 and half the subjects evaluated an
additional cost level of c150 per month. RESULTS: 664 subjects completed the survey.
About 15% of subjects refused to accept any tradeoffs between costs and outcome
attributes, while the remainder perceived no significant difference between costs of c0
and c10. The difference in importance weights between the highest cost levels in each
treatment arm was significantly different (P < 0.000). The importance weight of one
additional euro in cost of c25 or greater was negative, highly significant, and equal
in both arms (p = <0.000). Compared to a treatment with 70% probability of achieving no detectable virus after 5 years and no side-effect risk, the increase in value to
patients of a hypothetical treatment that has 95% effectiveness, 1% 5-year fracture
risk, and 1% 5-year risk of kidney disease is an additional c34 (c17–c51) per month.
CONCLUSIONS: We obtained DCE responses in a split-sample test of cost sensitivity
that were consistent with theoretical requirements. Results suggest that it is possible
to obtain valid WTP estimates in a properly motivated European DCE.
MENTAL HEALTH – Clinical Outcomes Studies
PMH1
THE EFFICACY OF DONEPEZIL AND MEMANTINE FOR TREATING
BEHAVIOURAL AND PSYCHOLOGICAL SYMPTOMS OF DEMENTIA
(BPSD) IN PATIENTS WITH ALZHEIMER’S DISEASE: SYSTEMATIC
REVIEW AND META-ANALYSIS
Orme M1, Mitchell S2, Lockhart I3, Collins S2
1
ICERA consulting Ltd, Swindon, Wiltshire, UK; 2Abacus International, Bicester, Oxfordshire,
UK; 3Pfizer Limited, Tadworth, Surrey, UK
OBJECTIVES: Behavioral and psychological symptoms of dementia (BPSD) in
Alzheimer’s disease (AD) greatly increase caregiver burden and often trigger nursing
home placement. a systematic review of double-blind randomized controlled trials
(RCTs) was conducted to compare the ability of donepezil and memantine to manage
BPSD in AD. METHODS: MEDLINE, EMBASE, Cochrane Library, and hand
searches identified 4739 citations, of which 16 studies had Neuropsychiatric Inventory
(NPI) data suitable for meta-analysis (6 memantine and ten donepezil trials). All trials
were placebo-controlled, and no head-to-head comparisons of the two drugs were
identified. a random-effects meta-analysis was conducted using AD severity subgroups
to investigate heterogeneity between trials. Thereafter meta-regression was conducted
using study level covariates as potential predictors of between-treatment weighted
mean difference (WMD) in NPI score. RESULTS: Unadjusted random effects metaanalysis of all 16 RCTs found significant between-study heterogeneity (all studies I2 =
64.4%; donepezil vs. placebo WMD −1.84, 95%CI −3.57, −0.10, I2 = 61%; memantine monotherapy vs. placebo WMD −1.19, 95% CI −3.70, 1.32, I2 = 68.7%; memantine + AChEI combination therapy vs. placebo WMD −1.68 95% CI −5.70, 2.33, I2
= 80.4%). Meta-regression that stratified studies into four AD severity groups measured by Mini-Mental State Exam (MMSE) (severe 0–9, moderately-severe 10–14,
moderate 15–20 and mild 21–26) and controlling for age at baseline, found these
covariates accounted for most (59.85%) of the between-study variance. Using this
meta-regression model, the pooled NPI score for donepezil showed significant
improvement compared to placebo (MD −1.50; 95% CI −2.63, −0.36) whereas this
was not the case for memantine vs. placebo (MD −1.25; 95% CI −2.63, 0.13). CONCLUSIONS: Donepezil was associated with significant improvement in the management of BPSD in AD patients compared to placebo, whereas memantine failed to show
a significant improvement versus placebo in the management of these symptoms.
A445
PMH2
COMPARING ALL-CAUSE MEDICATION DISCONTINUATION WITH
DEPOT AND ORAL ANTIPSYCHOTICS IN MATCHED COHORTS OF
PATIENTS WITH SCHIZOPHRENIA: A 12-MONTH OBSERVATIONAL
STUDY
Brnabic AJ1, Kelin K1, Ascher-Svanum H2, Kadziola Z3, Montgomery W4
1
Eli Lilly & Company, Sydney, NSW, Australia; 2Eli Lilly & Company, Indianapolis, IN, USA;
3
Eli Lilly Regional Operations Ges.m.b.H, Vienna, Austria; 4Eli Lilly & Company, West Ryde,
NSW, Australia
OBJECTIVES: To assess the all-cause medication discontinuation rate in matched
cohorts of patients with schizophrenia at risk of nonadherence who were initiated on
depot or oral antipsychotics and followed over 12 months. METHODS: At study
entry, outpatients with schizophrenia from Australia, Mexico, Romania, and Taiwan
were switched, due to clinician-perceived medication non-adherence risk, from their
current oral antipsychotic to either a depot or different oral antipsychotic in this
12-month, prospective observational study. Patients were compared on all-cause medication discontinuation rates, defined as a switch from the initiated medication or its
augmentation with another antipsychotic. Patients initiated on depot were matched
with those initiated on any oral antipsychotic, using full optimal and nearest neighbour
(greedy) matching algorithms. The Rank-based Mahalanobis metric was chosen as the
distance based on propensity score plus other relevant covariates, with country and
antipsychotic class used for exact matching. RESULTS: Based on the full optimal 1:1
matching, only 40 of the 43 original depot initiators were matched to a corresponding
oral initiator. After matching, there were no statistically significant differences between
the depot and oral cohorts on any of the study entry covariates examined. During the
12-month study, 20% of depot patients discontinued their initial medication, compared with 40% of oral patients (survival curve comparison, p = 0.025; Hazard Ratio
= 0.33 [0.12, 0.92], p = 0.033, NNT = 6 [3,-34]). No statistically significant differences
were found between the two groups on other assessed outcomes, including hospitalization, length of stay, and quality of life and disease severity measures. CONCLUSIONS:
Systematic matching of patients initiated on depot with those initiated on oral antipsychotics showed that the oral-initiated patients were statistically significantly more
likely to discontinue their medication. Findings highlight the importance of systematic
matching of patient cohorts when comparing treatment outcomes in observational
studies.
PMH3
DETERMINANTS OF PSYCHIATRIC HOSPITAL ADMISSION IN
SCHIZOPHRENIA
Olfson M1, Marcus S2, Ascher-Svanum H3, Faries D3
1
Columbia University Medical Center, New York, NY, USA; 2Penn Social Policy & Practice,
Philadelphia, PA, USA; 3Eli Lilly & Company, Indianapolis, IN, USA
OBJECTIVES: Hospital admission is a common and costly event in schizophrenia. An
analysis of phase 1/1A CATIE clinical trial data assessed various patient socio-demographic and clinical characteristics in relation to risk of psychiatric hospital admission.
METHODS: We followed 1460 study participants from baseline until first schizophrenia-related hospital admission, study medication discontinuation, or 18 months. Stepwise Cox regression models assessed the adjusted hazard ratio (AHR) of hospital
admission by baseline patient socio-demographic and clinical characteristics.
RESULTS: In 869 person-years of follow-up, 203 patients were hospitalized. The adjusted
hazards of hospital admission were not significantly related to patient socio-demographic
characteristics. Increased risk of admission was linked to early age (<17 years) of first
antipsychotic treatment (AHR: 2.09; 95%CI: 1.45–3.02), psychiatric hospital admission
in past year (AHR: 2.92; 95%CI: 2.18–3.90), and DSM-IV alcohol (AHR: 1.55; 95%CI:
1.15–2.08) and drug (AHR: 1.50; 95%CI: 1.13–2.00) use disorders in the past 5 years.
Severe (5–7) as compared with mild (1–3) baseline global clinical severity (AHR: 1.51;
95%CI: 1.03–2.23) (CGI-I), high (>20) as compared with low (7–15) positive symptoms
(AHR: 1.53; 95%CI: 1.08–2.16) (PANSS-positive subscale), and low (0–2.2) as compared
with high (>3.1) social function (AHR: 1.47; 95%CI: 1.04–2.08) (Heinrichs-Carpenter
QLI) were related to significantly increased risk of hospital admission. As compared with
olanzapine treatment assignment, quetiapine (AHR: 2.12; 95%CI: 1.37–3.27), perphenazine (AHR: 1.64; 95%CI: 1.02–2.65), and ziprasidone (AHR: 2.67; 95%CI: 1.62–4.39),
though not risperidone (AHR: 1.40; 95%CI: 0.89–2.21), were also associated with
increased hospital admission risk. Self-rated physical health (SF-12 PCS) and drug attitudes
(DAI) were not significantly related to risk. CONCLUSIONS: In the treatment of schizophrenia, efforts to lower hospital admission risk should focus on patients with early
onset disorders, recent inpatient admissions, severe positive symptoms, high global
clinical severity, poor social function, and comorbid substance use disorders and should
select an appropriate antipsychotic medication.
PMH4
A PHASE IV STUDY OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF QUETIAPINE
EXTENDED RELEASE 600 MG ONCE A DAY TO CONTROL THE
SYMPTOMS OF MANIC PHASE OF BIPOLAR DISORDER: THE EMMY
TRIAL
Segovia M1, Polanco AC1, Anaya P1, López RJ1, Gutiérrez D2
1
AstraZeneca, Naucalpan, Mexico; 2National Institute of Psychiatry, D.F., Mexico
OBJECTIVES: To assess the efficacy of a 600 mg/day dose of Quetiapine Extended
Release administrated once a day at evening as monotherapy or in combination with
lithium or valproate for 21 days. METHODS: A multi-center phase IV study was
designed to assess the efficacy of quetiapine extended release 600 mg per day either
as monotherapy or combined therapy with lithium and valproic acid in the treatment
A446
of patients with mania associated to Bipolar Disorder assessed by change in the Young
Mania Rating Scale (YMRS) score and Clinical Global Impression (CGI) score from
inclusion to day 21. Quality of life and safety/tolerability were measured with the
Euro Quality of Life 5D (EQ5D), Work Productivity and Activity Impairment, Barnes
Akathisia Rating Scale, Simpson-Angus Scale, physical examinations, adverse events,
change of weight and other adverse events of special interest. The efficacy analysis
was based on the modified intention-to-treat population, that included all patients
who received study medication and who had a YMRS assessment at inclusion and at
least one YMRS valid assessment after inclusion resulting in a total of 88 patients.
RESULTS: YMRS total score reduction in 21 days was 20.55 points (95% CI,
22.82–18.27); P < 0.0001. CGI total score decreased in 2.41 units, (95% CI, 2.69–
2.13); P < 0.0001. The EQ5D index increased 0.21 points (95% CI, 0.16–0.27) P <
0.0001. The EQ5D Visual Analog Scale increased 23.49% (95% CI, 16.36%–
30.61%); P < 0.0001. CONCLUSIONS: Overall results shown in this study demonstrate an improvement in the control of patients in maniac phase of bipolar disorder
with an increase in Quality of Life.
PMH5
ESTABLISHING THE COMPARATIVE EFFICACY OF ALZHEIMER’S
DISEASE THERAPY THROUGH SYSTEMATIC REVIEW AND
COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS
Modha R1, Wieffer H2, Pietri G2, Pueschner F3, Gaudig M3
1
Heron Evidence Development Ltd, London, UK; 2Heron Evidence Development Ltd, Luton,
UK; 3Janssen-Cilag GmbH, Neuss, Germany
OBJECTIVES: For therapeutic augmentation of impaired cholinergic transmission in
Alzheimer Disease (AD), Acetylcholine-Esterase-inhibitors (ACHE-I; galantamine,
donepezil, rivastigmine) are approved therapies in mild to-moderate AD. The NMDA
receptor partial antagonist (memantine) is licensed for therapy of moderate–severe
AD. In order to inform clinical decision-making about efficacy, safety and broader
non-cognitive outcomes, we identified evidence from comparative and non-comparative studies. METHODS: A comprehensive search was conducted on Medline,
Embase, conference abstracts and the Cochrane Library aimed to identify all randomised, placebo controlled trials (RCTs) reporting efficacy and/or safety outcomes
and randomised, controlled comparative trials. In a second step, trials with drug
dosing outside the approved European Summary of Product Characteristics were
excluded. Eligibility of trials was assessed by two blinded reviewers; quality of trials
were assessed by CONSORT. Meta-analyses were performed, reporting fixed and
random effects using comparative analytical techniques. RESULTS: Fifty—eight
studies fulfilled the inclusion criteria. In 45 trials, ACHE-I were tested against placebo,
in 9 trials against another ACHE-I. For memantine, 9 placebo-controlled trials were
identified. In most trials, patients were treated between 12–30 weeks; 9 RCTs reported
longer-term outcomes, up to 24 months. After critical appraisal, 33 studies were
included in further analyses. Meta-analysis of effects on cognition (ADAS-cog, MMSE,
SIB) showed superiority of at least one ACHE-I versus placebo at the 3 months, 6
months and longer-time timepoint. Results for memantine indicated non-significant
improvement at any assessed timepoint. Behavioural outcomes were less well reported
but showed superiority versus placebo for galantamine and memantine measured by
the Neuropsychiatric Inventory Scale. CONCLUSIONS: There is abundant evidence
for the efficacy, safety and tolerability of ACHE-Is in the treatment of patients with
mild to moderate AD. Data for improved behavioural functioning is limited though
available for galantamine and memantine.
PMH6
INCREASING ADMINISTRATIVE PREVALENCE OF ATTENTION-DEFICIT/
HYPERACTIVITY DISORDER (ADHD) IN GERMANY: EVIDENCE FROM
NORDBADEN, 2003 TO 2008
Schlander M1, Schwarz O1, Trott GE1, Banaschewski T2, Scheller W3, Viapiano M4,
Bonauer N4
1
Institute for Innovation & Valuation in Health Care, Wiesbaden, Germany; 2University of
Heidelberg, Mannheim, Germany; 3Verband der Ersatzkassen (vdek), Stuttgart, Germany; 4KV
Baden-Wuerttemberg, Karlsruhe, Germany
BACKGROUND: In our age and gender specific analyses for calendar year 2003, we
observed an administrative prevalence rate of ADHD in Nordbaden (a region in the
South-West of Germany with a population of >2.7 million) of 0.53%, with a peak
among 9-year old boys at 8.43%. From 2003 to 2008, methylphenidate prescriptions
(defined daily doses, DDDs) in Germany increased 2.65-fold, raising concern about
potentially inappropriate use. OBJECTIVES: To establish a longitudinal ADHD
patient database and to assess changes of ADHD administrative prevalence rates by
age and gender during the period from 2003 to 2008, in order to lay the foundation
for further analyses of treatment and prescribing patterns. METHODS: The complete
claims database of the organization of physicians registered with statutory health
insurance [SHI] (Kassenaerztliche Vereinigung, KV) in Nordbaden/Germany was
available for analysis, covering the total regional population enrolled in SHI (>2.2
million). Age and gender specific 1-year prevalence rates of ADHD were determined
for years 2003 through 2008. RESULTS: During the 6-year period under study, the
overall one-year ADHD prevalence rate increased from 0.53% to 0.90%. ADHD
(hyperkinetic disorder: ICD-10, F90.0, F90.1) prevalence rates were highest in the age
group 6–12 years (peak [2008] among nine-year-old children, 9,55%; boys, 12,31%),
increasing continuously during the observation period (a) age group 6–12: from
4.75% (boys, 6.91%; girls, 2.46%) to 7.62% (boys, 10.44%; girls, 4.66%); (b) age
group 13–17: from 1.73% (boys, 2.66%; girls, 0.75%) to 3.78% (boys, 5.69%; girls,
13th Euro Abstracts
1.74%); adults (age >18 years): from 0.04% (males, 0.05%; females, 0.03%) to
0.14% (males, 0.18%; females, 0.10%). CONCLUSIONS: German methylphenidate
prescription growth outpaced the increase in ADHD diagnoses from 2003 to 2008.
Further research seems warranted and has been initiated with regard to the underlying
dynamics of physician group involvement, coexisting conditions, utilization patterns
(treatment duration, intensity, switches), and regarding economic implications.
PMH7
USING DRUG DISPENSING DATA TO STUDY THE VALIDITY OF
PARASKAVEDEKATRIAPHOBIA
Pechlivanoglou P, Rozenbaum MH, Le HH, Postma MJ, Vegter S
University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: From tales of Christian tradition to essays of 17th century physicians,
Friday has been identified as a day of ill luck. Amongst all Fridays of the year however
the one coinciding with the 13th day of the month is known to be associated with
extreme misfortune. Therefore, the fate of persons born on Friday the 13th (F13)
warrants investigation. We investigated the effect of being born on Friday the 13th
on the prevalence of a) cancer; b) diabetes; c) mental health disorders; and d) sexual
disorders. METHODS: Persons born on Friday the 13th were identified from a drug
utilization database. To control for seasonal variation and time-trends, persons born
on Friday the 6th and Friday the 20th were selected as controls. Differences in prescription prevalences were analyzed using multivariate logistic regression. RESULTS:
A total of 4202 cases and 8987 controls were identified. The number of cases was less
than expected based on the number of controls (expected number 4396, P < 0.01),
suggesting a survival disadvantage for F13 cases. Age (32.8 ± 22.6 vs. 32.7 ± 23.0)
and gender (53.1% vs. 53.3% female) were similar. Multivariable logistic regression
showed no increase in prescription prevalences for F13 cases (P > 0.1 for all drug
classes). Exploratory analyses showed that F13 cases being prescribed antipsychotics
were younger than controls (P = 0.03) and diabetic cases were more often male (P =
0.04). CONCLUSIONS: Although attenuating effects of survivor selection bias cannot
be ruled out, the current study found no scientific basis for paraskavedekatriaphobia
in relation to drug utilization. Significant differences in age and gender for specific
subgroups may be attributed to the multiple comparison issue. Results will be presented on interaction effects of Friday the 13th coinciding with full-moon (n = 154)
and good Friday (n = 113).
PMH8
EXCESS MORTALITY RISK IN PATIENTS WITH PSYCHOSIS
HOSPITALIZED IN JAPANESE NATIONAL MENTAL HOSPITALS
Inagaki A1, Nakagawa A2, Fuwano S3, Itoh T4, Tsukada K4, Urata J5
1
Keio University, Fujisawa, Kanagawa, Japan; 2National Center of Neurology and Psychiatry,
Kodaira, Tokyo, Japan; 3Fuwano Clinic, Jouetsu, Niigata, Japan; 4Kohnodai Hospital,
International Medical Center, Ichikawa, Chiba, Japan; 5Sakuragaoka Memorial Hospital, Tama,
Tokyo, Japan
OBJECTIVES: To examine the standardized mortality ratio (SMR) in inpatients with
schizophrenia and related psychosis. METHODS: To compare the mortality risk in
Japanese with psychosis with that of the general population, we utilized two large
studies, called “the JESS2000” and “the JESS2000 Follow-up Study.” In the JESS2000
study, 2,309 psychotic patients who had been hospitalized in Japanese national mental
hospitals as of September 1, 2000 were included. In the JESS2000 Follow-up Study,
the JESS2000 patients were followed up and those who had died as of September 1,
2005 were identified retrospectively. The expected number of deaths was calculated
by multiplying the number of patients in each gender- and age-specific subgroup by
the mortality rate derived from the Japanese abridged life table and adding all of the
figures in each of these subgroups. The SMR was calculated by the observed number
of deaths, identified in the JESS2000 Follow-up Study, divided by the expected
number. RESULTS: Of 2309 original samples, 56.3% were male. On September 1,
2000, the mean age (SD) was 52.0 (14.6) years. The mean duration of hospitalization
was 10.3 (12.0) years. The mean age at onset of psychosis was 23.7 (7.9) years. The
deaths of 204 patients were confirmed as of September 1, 2005. Of these 204 deceased
patients, 13 committed suicide, 6 died from accidents and 148 died of natural causes.
No information regarding cause of death for the remaining 16 patients could be
obtained. The expected numbers of deaths in this cohort was 100.67. Therefore the
SMR for all causes in this cohort was estimated at 2.03 or more. CONCLUSIONS:
Our findings were similar to the results of the systematic review by Saha et al., which
reported the SMR for schizophrenia as 2.58.
MENTAL HEALTH – Cost Studies
PMH9
BUDGET IMPACT ANALYSIS OF SERTINDOLE IN THE TREATMENT OF
SCHIZOPHRENIA IN POLAND
Walczak J, Augusty ska J, Sołtys E, Nogas G
Arcana Institute, Cracow, Poland
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the financial consequences of sertindole reimbursement for
the Polish National Health Fund (NHF) budget. METHODS: Budget impact analysis
was performed in a 3-year time horizon from two perspectives of NHF and a patient.
Costs of oral antipsychotic drugs and EKG test of patients treated with sertindole were
included. Two future scenarios were estimated: 1) with reimbursement of sertindole,
and 2) without sertindole reimbursement. Target population was estimated using
13th Euro Abstracts
Polish epidemiological and statistical data, and a systematic review (proportion of
patients treated with antipsychotic drugs who withdrew because of adverse events).
Current and predicted market shares were assessed on the basis of present sales level
data. RESULTS: In the first scenario, NHF expenditures on atypical antipsychotic
drugs will increase by: 13 mln PLN in 2010, 20 mln PLN in 2011 and 26 mln PLN
in 2012. In the second scenario of no sertindole reimbursement NHF expenditures on
atypical antipsychotic drugs will increase by: 11 mln PLN in 2010, 18 mln PLN in
2011 and 23 mln PLN in 2012. From patient’s perspective, expenditures will increase
in 2010–2012 by 0.9 mln PLN 1.3 mln PLN and 1.7 mln respectively in scenario with
sertindole reimbursement, while in a second scenario costs will increase in 2010–2012
by 1.1 mln PLN, 1.6 mln PLN and 2.0 mln PLN respectively. The 2009 weighted
average exchange rate of Polish National Bank was c1 = PLN 4.3273. CONCLUSIONS: Reimbursement of sertindole would result in a minor increase in Polish NHF
expenditures. Simultaneously, it would enlarge the scope of accessible therapies for
patients intolerant to at least one other antipsychotic agent.
PMH10
COST SAVING POTENTIAL OF GENERIC SUBSTITUTION: THE CASE OF
ANTIDEPRESSANTS
van der Westhuizen E, Burger JR, Lubbe MS, Serfontein JHP
North-West University, Potchefstroom, South Africa
OBJECTIVES: Generic medicines are generally considerably less expensive than
branded products and their endorsement can lead to substantial savings in costs. The
main objective of the study was to calculate potential cost savings that can be generated by generic substitution of antidepressants within the private health care sector of
South Africa. METHODS: Data on computerised medicine claims of patients receiving
one or more antidepressants during three consecutive years (i.e. 2004, 2005 and 2006)
were elicited from a South African pharmaceutical benefit management company. a
non-experimental, quantitative, retrospective drug utilization review was conducted
and data were analyzed using the Statistical Analysis System® programme. Potential
cost savings defined as the collective amount that could be saved annually by substituting the average price of innovator active substances for that of generic equivalent(s)
were computed for criteria-eligible substances in the study population. All costs are
expressed in $U.S. RESULTS: A total of 292,071 items (N = 5,982,869) on 273,673
prescriptions (N = 5,213,765) at a total cost of $8,652,289.48 (N = $207,316,483.10)
were included in the study. Generic products constituted 58.7% (n = 292,071) of all
antidepressants claimed, at a total cost of 28.2% (N = $207,316,483.10) of all
incurred costs. With total substitution of the average price of all criteria-eligible
innovators, a potential saving of 9.3% (N = $8,652,289.48) of the actual antidepressant cost over the study period, was calculated. CONCLUSIONS: In developing
countries with limited health care budgets, such as South Africa, generic substances
can be cost-saving treatment alternatives. Health care professionals, third-party
payers, and patients all have fundamental roles to play in order to encourage greater
use of generics. Medicine expenditure can thereby be reduced and access to scarce
resources increased, in order to meet the pressing health care needs within South
Africa.
PMH11
BUDGET IMPACT ANALYSIS OF AMISULPRIDE IN TREATMENT OF
SCHIZOPHRENIA IN POLAND
Wilk D1, Rutkowski J1, Dziewiatka M1, Lis J2, Glasek M2, Plisko R1
1
HTA Consulting, Krakow, Poland; 2Sanofi-Aventis Poland, Warszawa, Poland
OBJECTIVES: To estimate the impact of amisulpride continued reimbursement in
schizophrenia treatment on payer’s budget in Poland. METHODS: The analysis was
performed in 5-year time horizon from the payer (National Health Fund, NHF)
perspective and payer + patient perspective. Only costs of medicines were included.
On the base of IMS Health Poland sale data for years 2005–2010 linear regression
was conducted to predict consumption and prevalence of antipsychotics in Poland.
Cost data of medicines were obtained from Ministry of Health and medicine portals
in case of lack of reimbursement. One-way sensitivity analysis were performed for the
key input parameters. RESULTS: From the payer perspective, cost of amisulpride is
approximately c7.13 million in 2010 and c9.15 million in 2014 and it represents from
4.62% in 2010 to 4.28% in 2014 of the total cost of schizophrenia treatment estimated at approximately c154.22 million in 2010 and c213.87 million in 2014. From
the payer + patient perspective, cost of amisulpride is approximately c7.26 million in
2010 and c9.32 million in 2014 and it represents from 4.01% in 2010 to 3.85% of
the total cost of schizophrenia treatment estimated at approximately c181.11 million
in 2010 and c241.81 million in 2014. Increase of NHF and patients expenses is related
to an increase of antipsychotics sales over a span of the next five years caused by
expanding awareness of schizophrenia and the importance of treatment. CONCLUSIONS: Our findings suggest that the cost of treatment with amisulpride are at a
reasonable level and represent a small proportion of the total costs of schizophrenia
treatment both from the payer perspective and common payer + patient perspective.
The declining trend in the share of amisulpride cost in total cost of schizophrenia is
noticeable. Amisulpride is an alternative therapeutic option of schizophrenia treatment
in Poland and its reimbursement from public funds is justified.
A447
PMH12
COST IMPACT OF INITIATING PREGABALIN TREATMENT IN SWEDISH
PATIENTS WITH GENERALIZED ANXIETY DISORDER
Myrén KJ1, Löfroth E1, Sandelin R2
1
IMS Health, Stockholm, Sweden; 2Pfizer, Sollentuna, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: To compare the health care costs 6 months prior to and 6 months after
initiation of pregabalin in generalized anxiety disorder (GAD) patients in Sweden.
METHODS: This was a retrospective longitudinal database study of GAD patients from
the South-West region of Sweden (1.5 million inhabitants). Individual patient data on
health care visits (outpatient, inpatient, primary care), costs, mortality and diagnoses
were included from year 2000. Data from the Swedish Prescribed Drug Register were
included from July 1, 2005 until December 31, 2007. Patients with a GAD (ICD-10
F41.1) diagnosis and who initiated pregabalin treatment in 2006 were included. Health
care utilization was measured six months before and six months after pregabalin initiation. Patients with 2 or more prescriptions of benzodiazepines six months prior to
pregabalin initiation were categorized as benzodiazepine patients. Non-parametric statistical tests (Mann-Whitney) were used for the cost and resource use comparisons.
RESULTS: A total of 149 patients met the inclusion criteria, of whom 99 used benzodiazepines prior to pregabalin treatment. The number of in-patient (P < 0.05) and
primary care (P < 0.05) visits significantly decreased in the 6-month period following
pregabalin initiation. There was also a statistically significant reduction (p = 0.0004) in
overall health care costs from SEK 71,000 (c7,408) to SEK 45,000 (c4,695). Among
the benzodiazepine users (n = 99), the number of in-patient visits (p = 0.0213), days in
hospital (p = 0.0026) and primary care visits (p = 0.0121) were all statistically significantly reduced following pregabalin initiation. The reduction in total cost (from SEK
79,000 to SEK 43,000; c8,243 to c4,486) among the users of benzodiazepines was also
statistically significant (p = 0.0001). The decrease in total cost, in all patients as well as
benzodiazepine treated, was to a large extent explained by the decrease in in-patient
costs. CONCLUSIONS: Initiating treatment with pregabalin in GAD patients significantly reduced health care utilization and costs during the following 6 months.
PMH13
COSTS ASSOCIATED WITH ANTIPSYCHOTIC MEDICATIONS FOR
PATIENTS WITH A BIPOLAR DIAGNOSIS AT CLINICALLY
RECOMMENDED DOSES
Stafkey-Mailey D1, Richards K2, Rascati K3, Ott CA4, Goddard A5, Alvir J6, Sanders K6,
Mychaskiw MA6
1
University of South Carolina, Columbia, SC, USA; 2University of Texas at Austin, Austin,
TX, USA; 3University of Texas, College of Pharmacy, Austin, TX, USA; 4Purdue University,
Indianapolis, IN, USA; 5Indiana University, Indianapolis, IN, USA; 6Pfizer Inc, New York, NY,
USA
OBJECTIVES: There is accumulating evidence of sub-therapeutic second-generation
antipsychotic (SGA) dosing for patients diagnosed with bipolar disorder, leading to
suboptimal control of disease and higher overall treatment costs. The objectives of
this study were to identify Medicaid bipolar patients receiving clinically effective doses
of SGAs and compare their medical costs. METHODS: Patients with bipolar disorder
taking an oral SGA (aripiprazole, olanzapine, quetiapine, risperidone or ziprasidone)
were identified in Medicaid claims databases (2005–2008) from 8 US states. Patients
were followed for 18 months (6-month pre-index period during which patients did
not receive an SGA, followed by a 12-month post-index utilization period to determine
total costs). For patients on recommended dosing, costs were compared using a generalized linear model with a gamma distribution and log-link function. Baseline
covariates (age, gender, race, pre-index costs, Charlson co-morbidity score, and specific psychiatric co-morbidities) were adjusted for. Ziprasidone-treated patients comprised the reference group. RESULTS: A total of 2446 patients met inclusion criteria,
with 45% (N = 1102) taking clinically effective doses by day 61 of their follow-up
period. Patients on quetiapine had the lowest percentage of effective dosing at 26%
(N = 280/1072). Other results were aripiprazole 77% (N = 336/448), olanzapine 52%
(N = 118/226), risperidone 50% (N = 238/474), and ziprasidone 58% (N = 130/226).
Regression analyses indicated that mental health-related prescription costs (P < 0.01)
and all-prescription costs (P < 0.01) were statistically significantly lower for the risperidone group compared to the ziprasidone group. There were no significant differences between the groups for total mental health-related costs or total all-cause costs
(includes prescription and medical services). CONCLUSIONS: Less than half of the
patients in this sample were prescribed clinically recommended doses 2 months after
their initial start. Among patients using recommended doses, while those on risperidone had lower prescription costs, there were no significant differences for total costs
compared to patients taking ziprasidone.
PMH14
COST ANALYSIS OF ADVERSE EVENTS ASSOCIATED WITH
TREATMENT OF BIPOLAR DISORDER: A COMPARISON BETWEEN
ARIPIPRAZOLE AND OLANZAPINE IN THE SPANISH HEALTH SYSTEM
Ramirez de Arellano A1, Rubio-Terrés C2, Baca E3, Riesgo Y4, Luque J1, Mena E5
1
Bristol-Myers Squibb Iberia, Madrid, Spain; 2HealthValue, Madrid, Spain; 3Hospital
Universitario Puerta de Hierro, Madrid, Spain; 4Bristol-Myers Squibb Iberia, Malaga, Spain;
5
Otsuka Pharmaceuticals, Barcelona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: This study investigates the health care costs of adverse events (AE)
associated with treatment of bipolar disorder with two atypical antipsychotics (AA):
aripiprazole (ARI) and Olanzapine (OLA). METHODS: It was performed a cost
analysis through a markov model considering the following health states: no existence
A448
of adverse events (NAE); extrapyramidal symptoms (EPS); weight gain (WG); and
sexual dysfunction (SD). The transition probabilities amongst health states were
estimated from two different meta-analysis of clinical trials and from a retrospective
Spanish study. The health care costs associated to each health state were obtained
from a published Spanish study. It was used the minimum acquisition cost per mg. of
the mean daily dose, for each AA, which is regarded as a relevant efficiency criterion
in Hospital Pharmacy Departments. The time horizon applied in the analysis was 12
months. a probabilistic sensitivity analysis was performed for all the variables involved
in the analysis via Monte Carlo simulations. All costs were inflated to 2009 costs using
Spanish Health System pay and prices index. RESULTS: In comparison with OLA, the
treatment with ARI generates annual average cost savings per patient of c−688.70 ±
21.69 (CI 95% −614.52; −729.18). In the most unfavourable scenario for ARI, that in
which we assumed that ARI may have a similar rate of sexual dysfunction than that of
quetiapine (i.e. the lowest rate amongst AA) the costs savings per patient would be
c–270,94 ± 17,11 (CI 95% −237,20; −303,48). CONCLUSIONS: The results of this
analysis show that patients treated with aripiprazole demonstrate lower adverse events
costs in comparison to olanzapine. This difference may generate significant cost
savings to the Spanish health system in the treatment of patients affected by bipolar
disorders. The robustness of the results was tested via a probabilistic sensitivity
analysis.
PMH15
REAL-WORLD TREATMENT PATTERNS AND HEALTH CARE RESOURCE
UTILIZATION IN GENERALISED ANXIETY DISORDER (GAD): A
RETROSPECTIVE UNITED STATES DATABASE ANALYSIS
Locklear J1, Wade S2, Palmer LA3, Järbrink K4, Toghanian S4
1
AstraZeneca Pharmaceuticals, Wilmington, DE, USA; 2Wade Outcomes Research and
Consulting, Salt Lake City, UT, USA; 3Thomson Reuters, Washington, DC, USA;
4
AstraZeneca R&D, Mölndal, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: Real-world treatment patterns and health care resource utilization for
patients with GAD in the United States are not fully defined. METHODS: Data from
the 2003–2007 Thomson Reuters MarketScan® Commercial Claims and Encounters
and Medicare Supplemental and Coordination of Benefits databases were utilised for
analysis. For the current analysis, participants with a diagnosis of GAD (ICD-9 CM
300.02) between January 1, 2004 and December 31, 2006 were included. The sample
was divided into the following five subgroups: patients receiving non-pharmacological
treatment, first-line therapy only, first-line + augmentation within 90 days of index
prescription, first-line + switch within 90 days of index prescription and second-line
therapy only. Additionally, GAD patients were compared with healthy controls
without GAD or other mental health conditions. RESULTS: In total, 23,553 GAD
patients (mean age range: 41.6–48.1 years; 56.1–68.6% female across the five groups)
were included (non-pharmacological, n = 7055; first-line only, n = 6538; first-line +
augmentation, n = 903; first-line + switch, n = 1953; second-line only, n = 7104).
Paroxetine was the most commonly used first-line treatment at index (first-line cohorts:
48%, 42%, 41%, respectively). In the second-line only cohort, a benzodiazepine
(37%) or second-line SSRI/SNRI (27%) were the most commonly used agents at index.
Benzodiazepines were the most commonly prescribed agents for augmentation of, or
switching from, first-line treatments (augmentation 52%, switch 44%). Overall, GAD
patients had higher health care utilization and significantly higher total health care
costs versus healthy controls (mean per patient: $8058 vs. $2938, P < 0.0001). On
average, GAD patients incurred an additional $425/month in direct health care costs
in the 1-year post-index period versus healthy controls. CONCLUSIONS: The realworld management of GAD is both complex and costly. Paroxetine was the mostwidely used first-line treatment for GAD. Benzodiazepines were the most widely used
agents for augmentation of, or switching from, first-line treatments, and for secondline therapy. Total health care costs were 2.7 times higher for GAD patients compared
with healthy controls.
PMH16
THE ECONOMIC AND HUMANISTIC BURDEN OF ILLNESS IN
GENERALISED ANXIETY DISORDER (GAD): A RETROSPECTIVE
DATABASE ANALYSIS IN EUROPE
Toghanian S1, DiBonaventura M2, Järbrink K1, Locklear J3
1
AstraZeneca R&D, Mölndal, Sweden; 2Kantar Health, New York, NY, USA; 3AstraZeneca
Pharmaceuticals, Wilmington, DE, USA
OBJECTIVES: There is a paucity of published evidence estimating the economic and
humanistic burden of illness in GAD. We report results of a retrospective database
analysis examining the burden of GAD in Europe. METHODS: Data were derived
from the European (France, Germany, UK, Italy, Spain) National Health and Wellness
Survey database for 2008. The database captures information from adults (≥18 years)
and is representative of the adult population in each country. Respondents reporting
a diagnosis of GAD were propensity-score matched 1:1 to non-GAD controls on
country, age, gender and employment status. Data were extracted on GAD medication
use, resource utilization (emergency room visits, hospitalizations and health care
provider visits) and work productivity (using the Work Productivity and Activity
Impairment questionnaire) to calculate direct and indirect costs. Health-related quality
of life (HRQoL) was derived using SF-12 mental and physical summary scores. Utilities were derived from SF-6D preference scores and used to calculate cost per qualityadjusted life-year (QALY). RESULTS: Of 53,524 respondents, 3,669 were assigned
to the GAD group. GAD respondents accrued considerably higher direct (medication
and health care resources) plus indirect (work productivity loss) costs (per person/
13th Euro Abstracts
year) versus controls across pooled European countries (c5,308.80 vs. c2,441.10; P
< 0.0001) and for each country (France c6,083.70 vs. c2,896.30; Germany c12,797.00
vs. c4,876.10; UK c4,021.70 vs. c2,011.20; Italy c3,514.50 vs. c1,869.60; Spain
c5,051.70 vs. c1,954.80; P < 0.0001 vs. controls within each country). Direct costs
were driven by hospitalizations and psychologist/psychiatrist visits. Total costs
increased with GAD severity from c4,094.00 for respondents with mild GAD to
c7,753.10 for those with severe GAD. HRQoL was significantly poorer for GAD
versus non-GAD respondents (P < 0.0001). Costs/QALY increased with GAD severity
from c6,795 for mild GAD to c15,286 for severe GAD. CONCLUSIONS: The economic and humanistic burden of illness of GAD across Europe is considerable and
increases with the severity of disease.
PMH17
COST OF ATTENTION DEFICIT/HYPERACTIVITY DISORDER IN
GERMANY
Braun S1, Zeidler J1, Linder R2, Ahrens S2, Manouguian MS2, Greiner W3
1
Leibniz University of Hannover, Hannover, Germany; 2Scientific Institute of Techniker
Krankenkasse for Benefit and Efficiency in Health Care, Hamburg, Germany; 3University of
Bielefeld, Bielefeld, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Data concerning costs of patients with Attention deficit/hyperactivity
disorder (ADHD) are scarce in Germany. Aim of this claims data analysis was to
examine the costs of ADHD from the perspective of the statutory health insurance.
METHODS: Nation-wide claims data of a major statutory health insurance fund was
used to evaluate the overall and ADHD-related costs of ADHD-patients in 2008. All
costs for outpatient care, inpatient care, pharmaceuticals, rehabilitation, occupational
therapy as well as devices and aids, and sick leave payments were analyzed. To calculate ADHD-related costs the overall health care costs of the identified ADHDpatients were compared to an age and gender matched control group. RESULTS:
Based on the used identification algorithm 30,264 ADHD-patients were identified.
Mean overall costs of c3802 in the year 2008 were incurred from the health insurance
perspective. c1704 (45%) were incurred by occupational therapy as well as devices
and aids, and c779 (20%) were due to inpatient care; c751 (20%) resulted from
outpatient care. Costs for pharmaceuticals were c483 (13%) and for rehabilitation
were c35 (≤1%). Costs for sick leave payments came to c50 (1%). The matched
control group contains 404,565 patients. Compared to this control group the incremental mean costs of ADHD-patients were EUR 2,744. EUR 1,214 of these resulted
from occupational therapy as well as devices and aids, c586 from inpatient care and
c517 from outpatient care. Mean additional costs for pharmaceuticals in the ADHDgroup were c367. CONCLUSIONS: The major cost driver in ADHD from a health
insurance perspective in Germany is occupational therapy as well as devices and aids.
PMH18
THE COSTS OF DEPRESSION IN SWITZERLAND
1
2
Tomonaga Y , Szucs TD
1
Institute of Social and Preventive Medicine, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland;
2
Institute of Pharmaceutical Medicine/European Center of Pharmaceutical Medicine,
University of Basel, Basel, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: To investigate the burden of depression in the Swiss population. The
costs for the management of depressive patients will be analyzed for different severity
classes of disease, based on the Hamilton depression rating scale, over a period of 12
months following diagnosis. METHODS: A prospective, multicentre, non-interventional study in psychiatrist practices was carried out. Patients who have been diagnosed with depression in the last three years were included. Patient’s characteristics
and resource utilization in the first twelve months after diagnosis were collected. Costs
analysis, subdivided in direct and indirect costs, was performed for three depression
classes (mild, moderate, severe), according to the Hamilton depression score (HAMD17). Costs were also extrapolated to the national level. RESULTS: A total of 556
patients were included. Hospitalization and hospitalization days were directly correlated with disease severity (P < 0.001). Medical resource utilization linked to depression and antidepressant treatments were also correlated to disease status. Severe
patients reported a significantly higher number of workdays lost and were significantly
more often in disability insurance. Total direct costs per person, mainly due to hospitalization costs, were CHF 4,823 for mild, CHF 13,251 for moderate, and CHF
22,138 for severe depressions. Indirect costs, mainly due to workdays lost, resulted in
CHF 11,892 for mild, CHF 17,267 for moderate, and CHF 22,710 for severe depressions. Extrapolation at national level resulted in a total burden of about CHF 11
billion. CONCLUSIONS: The burden of depression in Switzerland was estimated to
be around CHF 11 billion. Costs of depression were directly related to disease severity.
However, since many depressions remain unreported and since this analysis only
included individuals between 18 and 65 years of age, it is reasonable to suppose that
the total burden of depression may be even greater.
PMH19
BURDEN OF ILLNESS OF TREATMENT RESISTANT DEPRESSION
McInnis MM1, Halseth MJ2, Cyr P1, Howland RH3, Bockstedt Santiago L2, Goss T1
1
Boston Healthcare Associates, Inc., Boston, MA, USA; 2Medtronic, Inc., Minneapolis, MN,
USA; 3University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine Western Psychiatric Institute and Clinic,
Pittsburgh, PA, USA
OBJECTIVES: Major depressive disorder (MDD) is a leading cause of disability,
morbidity, and mortality worldwide. The lifetime prevalence in the US is 17%. Treatment resistant depression (TRD) is generally defined as failure to achieve remissions
13th Euro Abstracts
despite adequate treatment. About 30% of patients do not achieve remission after 4
different antidepressant treatment trials (Rush et. Al., 2006). a few studies have
examined the economic burden of TRD, but none have investigated the cost associated
with more chronic and extensive forms of TRD characterized by non-response to four
or more treatment trials. The objective of this study is to compare the direct medical
expenditures of TRD patients to chronic MDD patients. METHODS: Patients with
chronic MDD (defined as 2 or more years of continuous treatment) and patients with
very severe TRD (defined as switching, augmentation, or addition of at least four
qualifying therapies) were identified in the PharMetrics Patient-Centric Database.
Medical resource utilization (MRU) and payer costs per patient per year enrolled in
the plan were compared. Patients were matched on duration of enrollment, length of
depression, medications taken, and age. Statistical significance was assessed using
Student’s t-tests. RESULTS: The average medical expenditures per TRD (n = 31,803)
patient per year enrolled was $12,260 compared to $7,619 for non-TRD chronic
MDD patients (n = 50,092) (p < 0.001), representing 60.9% higher costs per year.
The differences in annual medical expenditures per TRD patient were primarily driven
by higher medical and pharmacy MRU (number of services per patient) relative to the
chronic MDD group (70.3 vs. 107.6, p < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Our results demonstrate that TRD patients accrued significantly higher per patient medical costs than
MDD patients due to higher medical resource use. These findings suggest that more
effective non-pharmacological alternative interventions are needed.
PMH20
IMPACT AND COSTS OF HOSPITALIZATION IN SCHIZOPHRENIA
1
2
2
3
Zeidler J , Slawik L , Fleischmann J , Greiner W
1
Leibniz University of Hannover, Hannover, Germany; 2Janssen-Cilag GmbH, Neuss,
Germany; 3University of Bielefeld, Bielefeld, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Data concerning impact and costs of hospitalization in patients with
schizophrenia are scarce in Germany. Aim of this claims data analysis was to examine
the impact and costs of hospitalization in schizophrenia from the perspective of a
major statutory health insurance fund. METHODS: A nation-wide database was used
to evaluate the impact and related costs of hospitalization in schizophrenia (ICD-10
F20.x) between 2004 and 2006. All hospitalised patients were identified based on
claims data and schizophrenia related costs for outpatient care, inpatient care, medications, rehabilitation, occupational therapy, and sick leave payments were analyzed
before, during and after the hospitalization. RESULTS: Data from 4126 hospitalised
patients were available, with 46% being female and a mean age of 42 years. Mean
length of the index hospitalization was 45.9 days and mean health insurance costs of
c9366 incurred during the index hospitalization. In the 3 months before the index
hospitalization, average costs of c297 and in the 3 months after the index hospitalization costs of c2322 incurred for outpatient care, inpatient care, medications, rehabilitation, occupational therapy, and sick leave payments. 42.5% of the patients had at
least one rehospitalization after the index hospitalization and mean costs of c8710
incurred during the first rehospitalization. In the 4 weeks before the first rehospitalization average costs of c1310 and in the 3 months after the rehospitalization costs of
c2834 incurred. With any further rehospitalization costs for the inpatient care itself
are decreasing slightly but overall costs for schizophrenia related medical care before
and after the event are increasing. CONCLUSIONS: Impact and costs of hospitalization in schizophrenia are significant, especially if the costs before and after hospitalization were taken into account. Rehospitalizations are a frequent event in schizophrenia
care with high impact on costs. Further studies including the predictors of hospitalization are needed.
PMH21
SOCIETAL COSTS OF BIPOLAR DISORDER—THE CASE OF SWEDEN
1
2
3
2
4
Ekman M , Granström O , Omerov S , Jacob J , Landén M
1
i3 Innovus, Stockholm, Sweden; 2AstraZeneca Nordic MC, Södertälje, Sweden; 3Northern
Stockholm Psychiatry, Stockholm, Sweden, 4Gothenburg University, Göteborg, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: To investigate the health care resource utilization and costs for Swedish
bipolar disorder patients. METHODS: Registry data on socio-demographics and
disease-related resource use during 2006–2008 was collected for 1846 patients with
bipolar disorder. Health care visits and hospitalizations were obtained from the
Northern Stockholm psychiatric clinic, while data on pharmaceuticals and sick leave
were obtained from the national pharmaceutical registry and the Swedish social insurance agency, respectively. Community care data was obtained from the Swedish
quality registry for bipolar disorder (BipoläR). Indirect costs were valued according
to the human capital method. Costs across mood episodes (manic, depressive, and
unspecified) as well as remission were calculated. a patient for which >70 days had
passed since the last new episode or inpatient visit, was defined as being in remission.
RESULTS: The mean annual cost per patient with bipolar disorder was estimated at
c24,300 (SEK 242,810) in 2009 prices, of which 23% represented direct treatment
costs. The costs per month for active bipolar disorder were c6800 during depression,
c6300 during mania, EUR 6,100 during unspecified episodes, and c1500 for patients
in remission. a patient who was not hospitalized during 2006–2008 generated a mean
annual cost of c18,900, whereas a patient who was hospitalized at least once every
year 2006–2008 generated mean annual costs of c67,600. CONCLUSIONS: Societal
costs for bipolar disorder were more than 3.5 times higher for patients who were
admitted at least once per year in 2006–2008 compared to those who were not hospitalized. Monthly costs during a depressive or manic episode were more than 4 times
higher than during remission. Attempts to prevent mood episodes by means of effective
treatment may not only decrease patient suffering, but also have the potential to
dramatically reduce the societal cost of illness.
A449
PMH22
RESULTS OF THE GERMAN IDA STUDY—ASSESSING THE FINANCIAL
IMPACT OF INFORMAL CARE AMONGST COMMUNITY LIVING
DEMENTIA PATIENTS
Schwarzkopf L1, Kunz S1, Wunder S2, Marx P3, Lauterberg J4, Gräßel E5, Holle R1
1
Helmholtz Zentrum München—German Research Center for Environmental Health
(GmbH), Neuherberg, Germany; 2AOK-Bayern /die Gesundheitskasse, Nürnberg, Germany;
3
Pfizer Deutschland GmbH, Berlin, Germany; 4Federal Association of the AOK, Berlin,
Germany; 5University Hospital Erlangen, Erlangen, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Rising life expectancy is associated with increasing prevalence of
dementia in European countries. With progressing disease severity patients’ call on
health care services and social support grows. Several studies stress the burden
imposed on family members caring for dementia-patients. However, empirical data
assessing the economic value of informal care compared to health insurance expenditures is scarce. Within the cluster-randomized IDA study health care service utilization
and informal caregiving time were assessed for 383 community living individuals
suffering from mild to moderate dementia. METHODS: To examine costs from a
health insurance perspective administrative data on all types of services provided were
collected and valued with corresponding administrative prices over a three-year
period. Patients’ caregivers reported in yearly interviews the hours daily dedicated to
the patient in care and supervision. The time provided for informal caregiving was
valued by applying hourly wages of a nursing service and a domestic help respectively.
Total costs and cost components were calculated from societal perspective and payers’
point of view and analyzed by relevant subgroups. RESULTS: Caring for a homedwelling dementia-patient amounts annually to around c47.000 from societal perspective with informal care covering nearly 80% of this sum. For a patient with moderate
dementia values assigned to informal care are approximately 70% higher than for a
person with mild dementia. Health insurance has to spend c10,000 for an average
dementia-patient per year, with services for long-term care representing the most costly
part. CONCLUSIONS: Informal care is the major cost component in care for dementia, and it is strongly rising with disease progression. Changes in family structures and
traditional living arrangements thus pose an enormous challenge regarding the future
organization of dementia care. To maintain today’s care-setting, concepts fostering
community-based dementia care and support to family caregivers need to be further
developed.
PMH23
COSTS OF A COMMUNITY SUPPORT PROGRAM FOR DEPRESSION:
RESULTS FROM THE BEAT THE BLUES (BTB) TRIAL
Jutkowitz E1, Pizzi LT1, Gitlin L1, Foley K2, Chernett N1, McCoy M3, Dennis M1
1
Thomas Jefferson University, Philadelphia, PA, USA; 2Thomas Jefferson University,
Newtown, PA, USA; 3Center in the Park, Philadelphia, PA, USA
OBJECTIVES: Literature on the costs of community support programs is scant. Beat
the Blues (BTB) is a home support program for depression which involves trained
social workers who meet with participants to identify care management concerns,
make referrals and linkages, provide depression education, develop tailored action
plans to accomplish identified behavioral goals and enhance engagement in pleasurable
activities, and teach stress reduction techniques for managing daily stressors (e.g., deep
breathing). The primary objective of this study is to assess the cost of implementing
BTB in African American elders with depressive symptoms. METHODS: The cost
analysis is piggybacked onto the parent BTB trial, which employs randomized twogroup experimental design (treatment vs. control). Candidates are screened twice for
depressive symptoms (PHQ-9 score > 5) to determine eligibility. Participants are
randomly assigned to intervention or waitlist control. BTB is administered over 4
months with assessments in both groups at baseline and 4-months. Cost components
comprise 4 main categories (Screening, Intervention Delivery, Supervision, and Other).
Senior center management and social workers (interventionists) kept detailed logs of
time spent conducting each component. The cost of conducting the intervention was
calculated as the time spent performing each task multiplied by wage rate of the
individual who performed the task. Non-time related cost (material and mileage) was
also calculated. RESULTS: A total of 166 participants received the intervention.
Average cost of BTB was $342 per person. The most costly aspect of BTB per person
was cost of program delivery ($275), followed by materials ($48).The least costly
aspect of the intervention was time spent supervising interventionists ($9). CONCLUSIONS: This study informs decision makers about the resources required for depression community support interventions, which are not typically reimbursable through
private or public health care programs. Results can also inform decision making
regarding the costs of such interventions in relation to pharmacological treatments.
PMH24
HEALTH CARE UTILIZATION OF MAJOR DEPRESSIVE DISORDER
PATIENTS
Myrén KJ, Löfroth E, Dahlberg E
IMS Health, Stockholm, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: To analyze the health care utilization by patients diagnosed with major
depressive disorder (MDD). METHODS: This was a retrospective longitudinal
descriptive database study of the utilization of health care by patients with MDD from
the South-West region of Sweden (1.5 million inhabitants). All patients who were
diagnosed with MDD (ICD-10 F32 or F33) during 2007 were included in the study.
All costs from health care visits when an MDD was the primary diagnose were
included as well as all cost from all dispensed antidepressant (ATC N06A) drugs.
RESULTS: A total of 37,445 patients had at least one health care visit with an MDD
A450
diagnoses during 2007 in the South-West region of Sweden. Sixty-two percent of the
patients had at least one visit to the primary care, 35% had been treated as out-patient,
9% had been treated by private physician, and 7% had been treated by in-patient
care; 73% had at least one dispensed drug. The total health care cost, including drug
cost, was 683 million SEK. 35% were from drugs and 23%, 26%, 14%, and 1% were
from in-patient, out-patient, primary, and private care. During 2007 the average drug
cost per patient, who utilize the current treatment, was 8847 SEK for drugs. The
average cost for in-patient care was 64,576 SEK and 13,859 SEK for out-patient care.
For primary and private care the average cost was 4268 SEK and 1342 SEK. CONCLUSIONS: The cost for antidepressant drugs was the largest part of the total health
care cost for MDD, 35%. The in-patient care was the greatest cost per patient. The
relevant question is what mix of drugs should be prescribed in order to minimize the
total health care cost. Further research needs to be preformed.
PMH25
COMPARISON OF ESCITALOPRAM VS. CITALOPRAM AND
VENLAFAXINE IN THE TREATMENT OF MAJOR DEPRESSION IN SPAIN:
CLINICAL AND ECONOMIC CONSEQUENCES
Sicras-Mainar A1, Blanca-Tamayo M2, Gimeno-de la Fuente V3, Salvatella-Pasant J3,
Navarro-Artieda R4
1
Directorate of Planning, Badalona Serveis Assistencials, Badalona, Barcelona, Spain;
2
Badalona Serveis Assistencials SA, Barcelona, Spain; 3Lundbeck España SA, Barcelona, Spain;
4
Hospital Germans Trias i Pujol, CIBEREHD, Barrcelona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Population based study to determine clinical consequences and economic impact of using escitalopram (ESC) vs. citalopram (CIT) and venlafaxine (VEN)
in patients initiating treatment for a new episode of major depression (MD), in real-life
conditions of outpatient practice. METHODS: Observational, multicenter, retrospective study conducted using computerized medical records (administrative databases)
of patients treated in six primary care centers and two hospitals between January 2003
and March 2007. Study population: patients >20 years of age diagnosed with a new
episode of MD who initiate treatment with ESC, CIT or VEN, and whithout any
antidepressant treatment within the previous 6 months, who were followed for 18
months or more. Main variables: socio-demographic variables, remission, comorbidity, annual health care costs (medical visits, diagnostic and therapeutic tests, hospitalizations, emergency room and psychoactive drugs prescribed) and non-health care
costs (productivity loss at work). Statistical analyses: logistic regression and ANCOVA
models. RESULTS: A total of 965 patients (ESC = 131; CIT = 491; VEN = 343) were
included. ESC-treated patients were younger, with a higher proportion of males, and
a lower specific comorbidity (P < 0.01). ESC-treated patients achieved higher remission
rates (58.0%) compared to CIT (38.3%) or VEN (32.4%) patients (P < 0.001) and
had lower productivity work ESC (37.9 days) vs.CIT (32.7 days) or vs. VEN (43.8
days), p = 0.042. No differences in average/unit costs of psychoactive drugs were
observed between the ESC and CIT groups (c294.7 vs. c265.2), with higher costs seen
in the VEN group (c643.0), p = 0.003. In the corrected model, total (health care and
non-health care) costs were lower with ESC (c2276.2) vs. CIT (c3093.8), p = 0.047
and VEN (c3801.2), p = 0.045. CONCLUSIONS: ESC appears to be dominant in the
treatment of new MD episodes when compared to CIT and VEN, resulting in higher
remission rates and lower total costs.
PMH26
COST ANALYSIS OF METHADONE MAINTENANCE THERAPY (MMT)
PROGRAM IN MALAYSIA
Abdul Ghani N, Shafie AA, Hassali MAA
Universiti Sains Malaysia, Penang, Malaysia
OBJECTIVES: To analyze the cost of MMT treatment for patient with substance use
disorder. METHODS: This was a retrospective study involving 185 opiate dependence
patients who were receiving MMT treatment program in Malaysian’s government
hospitals starting December 2005 until February 2010. The study was done from the
provider perspective using activity based costing that includes both capital and variable cost associated with MMT program. RESULTS: Most of the respondents were
male (99%) with mean age of 38.5 years. Most (72.5%) of them were Malay and
50.5% working in semi or unskilled manual job with basic salary less than MYR1000
(US$312). Most (99.5%) were smoker with history of heroin addiction of more than
10 years. The median length of MMT treatment was 14 months. Fifty-seven percent
of the patients were suffering from chronic disease. The capital cost for MMT program
was US$8013.16 and the variable cost of providing a month of treatment per patient
was US$50.43. Approximately 47.19% of this was for methadone and personnel cost
accounted for 31.94%. The variable cost was statistically higher (P < 0.05) in patients
present of chronic disease. CONCLUSIONS: This study estimated the variable cost
of MMT treatment per patient in Malaysia (US$50.43/month) is less expensive
compare USA (US$220/month, Jones et al., 2009). These cost data may be useful to
policymakers and researchers for further developing the program.
PMH27
RECENT TRENDS IN PSYCHIATRIC PRESCRIPTION DRUG SPENDING
1
2
Mark T , Long S
1
Thomson Reuters, Washington, DC, USA; 2Thomson Reuters, Cambridge, MA, USA
OBJECTIVES: To describe new data on recent trends in U.S. psychiatric prescription
drug spending and utilization over the period 2003 to 2008 and to understand drivers
of those new trends. METHODS: SAMSA Spending Estimates were coupled with
MEPS data to examine trends in mental health drug spending and utilization through
2005. 1997–2008 Thomson Reuters MarketScan Commercial Claims data were used
13th Euro Abstracts
to decompose spending where: Total Expenditures = Price X Quantity, and ΔCost/
Enrollee = ΔCost/Day X ΔDays/User X ΔUsers/Enrollees. The following drugs were
included in the analysis: Antidepressants, Antipsychotics, Stimulants, and Anxiolytic/
Sedative/Hypnotics. RESULTS: The average annual growth rate in mental health
prescription drug spending dropped from 28% in 1998 to 3% in 2008. The rate of
growth has stayed below 10% since 2005, and was negative in 2007. For persons
with private insurance, the average annual expenditure growth rate overall was 6%
during the years 2001–2008, where 2% was attributable to days/user, 2% was due
to users per population, and 2% was due to cost/day. In contrast for the years
1997–2001, the average growth rate overall was 18%, where 3% was attributable to
days/user, 7% was due to users per population, and 8% was due to cost/day.
CONCLUSIONS: Mental health prescription drug spending growth has slowed in
recent years. This is due primarily to slower growth in additional users and slower
price growth. The lower price growth is mainly due to generic entries starting in 2005,
particularly within the antidepressant drug class.
PMH28
EFFECT OF PREGABALIN ON COSTS AND CONSEQUENCES IN
PATIENTS WITH REFRACTORY SEVERE GENERALIZED ANXIETY
DISORDER AND CONCOMITANT SEVERE SYMPTOMS OF DEPRESSION
IN DAILY MEDICAL PRACTICE
Rejas J1, Carrasco JL2, Alvarez E3, Olivares JM4, Vilardaga I5, Pérez M6, Lopez Gomez V6
1
Pfizer España, Alcobendas/Madrid, Spain; 2Department of Psychiatry, Hospital Clínico San
Carlos, Madrid, Spain; 33Department of Psychiatry, Hospital de la Santa Creu i San Pau,
Barcelona, Spain; 4Hospital Meixoeiro, Complejo Hospitalario Universitario, Vigo, Spain;
5
Department of Biometric and Statistics, European Biometric Institute, Barcelona, Spain;
6
Department of Neuroscience, Medical Unit, Pfizer Spain, Alcobendas, Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: To analyze the clinical and economic effects of the use of Pregabalin
(PGB) in patients with refractory severe Generalized Anxiety Disorder (GAD) and
severe concomitant depressive symptoms in daily medical practice. METHODS: Data
were obtained from a post-hoc analysis of a 6-month, prospective, non-interventional
study conducted in outpatient psychiatric clinics to ascertain the impact of broadening
GAD diagnostic criteria. This before-after study included PGB naïve patients above
18 years, with GAD (using DSM-IV criteria), refractory to anxiolytics for a minimum
of 3 months, severe symptoms of anxiety (HAM-A > 24) and depression (MADRS >
35), who received flexible doses of PGB either as monotherapy or add-on, per psychiatrist judgment. Changes in HAM-A and MADRS and responders rates (reduction
> 50% of baseline scoring) were the study end-points, together with health care
resources utilization and corresponding costs. RESULTS: A total of 159 patients
[69.2% women, mean age 45.9 (12.6) years] fulfilled criteria for analysis. Ninety
percent or more patients were previously exposed to benzodiazepines and/or antidepressants [mean 2.7 (1.3) drugs]. Adding PGB [mean dose: 223.1 (126.3) mg/day]
reduced both anxiety and depressive symptoms, respectively, in HAM-A and MADRS
scales, by −57.9% (from 35.5 + 5.8 to 14.8 + 9.4; P < 0.001, effect size: 3.57) and
−58.1% (from 39.4 + 4.3 to 16.5 + 10.3; P < 0.001, effect size: 5.33). As a result,
responder rates were 63.1% and 62.9%, respectively. Costs reductions in medical
visits [−c1022 (−1,376; −669), P < 0.001] and hospitalizations [−c144 (−245;−44), p
= 0.005], offset the higher incremental drug cost of PGB treatment [c353 (292; 415),
P < 0.001] showing statistically reduction of health care costs; −c619 (−1,040;−197),
p = 0.004. CONCLUSIONS: The use of Pregabalin resulted in both clinical and
economic benefits in patients with severe refractory GAD and concomitant severe
depressive disorder. Patients experienced a significant improvement in their anxiety
and depression symptoms, improvements which were associated with significant
decreases in health care costs.
PMH29
COST-CONSEQUENCE ANALYSIS OF ARIPIPRAZOLE IN
SCHIZOPHRENIA IN SPAIN: DIABETES AND CORONARY HEART
DISEASE PROJECTIONS (STAR STUDY)
Ramirez de Arellano A1, Rubio-Terrés C2, Baca E3, Riesgo Y4, Luque J1, Mena E5
1
Bristol-Myers Squibb Iberia, Madrid, Spain; 2HealthValue, Madrid, Spain; 3Hospital
Universitario Puerta de Hierro, Madrid, Spain; 4Bristol-Myers Squibb Iberia, Malaga, Spain;
5
Otsuka Pharmaceuticals, Barcelona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Patients with schizophrenia experience elevated rates of morbidity and
mortality, largely due to an increased incidence of cardiovascular disease and diabetes.
The STAR study showed that the metabolic side effects of aripiprazole treatment are
less than that experienced by those receiving standard-of-care (SOC) antipsychotic
treatment (olanzapine, queatipine or risperidone). This study estimates the difference
in direct and indirect cost-consequences of diabetes and coronary heart disease (CHD)
in schizophrenia patients treated with aripiprazole or SOC. METHODS: On the basis
of the results provided by the STAR study, risks for diabetes and CHD were projected
over a time horizon of 10 years in the Spanish setting using the Stern and Framingham
models. The comparators were aripiprazole versus SOC. The prevalence and costs
(direct and indirect) of diabetes and CHD were obtained from Spanish sources. All
costs were inflated to 2009 costs using the Spanish Health System pay and prices
index. RESULTS: The number of avoided diabetes cases (23.4 cases per 1,000 treated
patients) in patients treated with aripiprazole compared to SOC was associated with
estimated total (direct and indirect) cost saving of c27,798,018 over 10 years for the
Spanish population. Similarly, with aripiprazole the number of avoided CHD events
(3.7 events per 1,000 treated patients) yields an estimated total cost saving of
c4,173,818 over 10 years. CONCLUSIONS: Compared with SOC, aripiprazole
13th Euro Abstracts
treatment can significantly reduce the number of diabetes and CHD events. As a
consequence, it can provide considerable reductions in the health and economic
burden to schizophrenia patients and health care services in the Spanish setting due
to its favourable metabolic profile.
PMH30
ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF AGOMELATINE IN MAJOR DEPRESSIVE
DISORDERS IN IRELAND
Alegre P1, Lacey L2, McAuliffe A3
1
Science Union et cie (Servier), Suresnes, France; 2Larry Lacey Consultant, Dublin, Ireland;
3
Servier Ireland, Dublin, Ireland
OBJECTIVES: A cost-utility analysis of a new antidepressant, agomelatine (Valdoxan®) compared to generic fluoxetine and sertraline in the treatment of adult Major
Depressive Disorders (MDD) was performed from the societal perspective and that of
the Irish Health Service Executive (HSE). For each of these two perspectives, a separate
analysis was performed for two different drug schemes: General Medical Services
scheme (GMS) and the Drug Payments scheme (DP). METHODS: A Markov model
was developed with health states for well, depressive episode, remission and death.
The model also incorporated sleep disorders, discontinuation rates, discontinuation
symptoms and adverse drug reactions. The time horizon of the analysis was two years.
Remission, relapse and discontinuation rates as well as frequencies of the different
clinical parameters were obtained from head-to-head comparative trials. Utility/disutility estimates were obtained from the literature. Costs (euros 2009) and effects were
discounted at 4% per annum after year 1. RESULTS: From the societal perspective,
agomelatine was dominant over both generic comparators in both drug schemes. From
the HSE perspective, agomelatine was cost-effective compared to the two comparators
in both drug schemes. One-way sensitivity analysis showed that the results were robust
to uncertainty in model parameters. Probabilistic sensitivity analysis demonstrated
that for a willingness-to-pay threshold of c45,000/QALY, agomelatine was costeffective compared to the two comparators in more than 93% of cases for both drug
schemes CONCLUSIONS: From the societal perspective, agomelatine was dominant
over generic fluoxetine and sertraline for the treatment of adult MDD in Ireland. From
the Irish HSE perspective, agomelatine was cost-effective compared to the two comparators with high probability.
PMH31
THE COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF ARIPIPRAZOLE IN PATIENTS WITH
BIPOLAR I DISORDER IN THE UK
Lebmeier M1, Dudley E1, Pericleous L1, Treur M2
1
Bristol-Myers Squibb Pharmaceuticals Ltd, Uxbridge, Middlesex, UK; 2Pharmerit BV,
Rotterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: To explore the cost-effectiveness of aripiprazole in UK patients with
bipolar I disorder (BPD). METHODS: A Markov state transition model was developed
to estimate the cost-effectiveness of aripiprazole, post-olanzapine, compared with
risperidone or quetiapine, the most commonly used atypicals in the UK after olanzapine. Modelling was undertaken from a UK NHS perspective using discount rate of
3.5%. The time horizon of the model was 5 years (NICE BPD Guideline). The model
incorporated an acute manic phase and relapse prevention phase. Response to therapy
(at least a 50% reduction in Young-Mania Rating Scale) and discontinuation in the
acute phase were based on an indirect comparison of trials in acute manic treatment.
Probabilities of experiencing a new manic or depressive episode or discontinuing
treatment in the relapse prevention phase were informed by a network meta-analysis.
Quetiapine (at time of analysis) and risperidone are not indicated for relapse prevention in the UK; those patients were switched to lithium. Outpatient, hospitalization
and drug costs were included based on published sources. a probabilistic sensitivity
analysis (PSA) was used to examine uncertainty. RESULTS: Key drivers in the model
are cost and quality-of-life reduction associated with acute mania. Aripiprazole is more
effective than quetiapine in the acute phase and than lithium in the relapse prevention
phase. Therefore, used post-olanzapine, aripiprazole gains 0.025 quality adjusted
life-years (QALYs) and saves £3,995 compared with quetiapine and gains 0.01 QALYs
and saves £607 compared with risperidone. Results from the PSA demonstrate 92%
confidence that aripirazole is cost-effective versus quetiapine, and 61% confidence
versus risperidone when using a threshold of £30,000 per QALY. CONCLUSIONS:
Aripiprazole used post-olanzapine in the treatment of BPD is a cost-effective use of
NHS resources compared with quetiapine and risperidone.
PMH32
ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF AGOMELATINE IN MAJOR DEPRESIVE
DISORDERS IN HUNGARY
Alegre P1, Nagy B2, Nagy J2
1
Science Union et cie (Servier), Suresnes Cedex, France; 2GKI-EKI Healthcare Research
Institute Ltd, Budapest, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: A cost-effectiveness analysis of a new antidepressant, agomelatine
(Valdoxan®) compared to duloxetine in the treatment of Major Depressive Disorders
(MDD) in adults was performed in a Hungarian setting from a societal perspective
and the National Health Insurance Fund (NHIF) perspective. METHODS: A Markov
model was adapted with health states for well, depressive episode, remission and
death. The model also incorporated sleep disorders, discontinuation rates, discontinuation symptoms and adverse drug reactions (incl. constipation, diarrhoea, dyspepsia,
headache, nausea, somnolence, and sexual dysfunction). The time horizon was set to
two years. An indirect comparison was run based on a meta-analysis of duloxetine
A451
from a literature review to document clinical parameters unavailable from completed
trials. a prospective cost of illness study in Hungary implemented in 2009 documented
direct and indirect costs of MDD. Utilities for each health state and disutilities for
each clinical event were taken from the literature. The discount rate was 5% per year
RESULTS: From the societal perspective, agomelatine was cost-saving and more effective than duloxetine. From the NHIF perspective, agomelatine resulted in 0.037
QALYs gained compared to duloxetine with 5073 HUF as additional direct costs. One
way sensitivity analyses showed that the results were robust to most parameter
changes. From a societal perspective, agomelatine dominates duloxetine in 75% of
cases and is cost-effective in 91% of cases at a willingness-to-pay threshold of 7 million
HUF/QALY. From the NHIF perspective, agomelatine is cost-effective versus duloxetine in more than 90% of cases. CONCLUSIONS: In a Hungarian setting, agomelatine is dominant from a societal perspective and cost-effective from a NHIF perspective
versus duloxetine. These results are robust, confirmed by sensitivity analyses.
PMH33
ADJUNCTIVE ANTIPSYCHOTICS IN PATIENTS WITH MAJOR
DEPRESSIVE DISORDER IN TURKEY: A HEALTH ECONOMIC
PERSPECTIVE
Isik E1, Dilbaz N2, Savas H3, Gönül AS4, Saylan M5, Postema R6, Loze JY7, Drost P8, Treur M6
1
Gazi University Medical Faculty, Ankara, Turkey; 2Ankara Numune Research & Training
Hospital, Ankara, Turkey; 3Gazientep University Medical Faculty, Gazientep, Turkey; 4Ege
University Medical Faculty, Izmir, Turkey; 5Bristol-Myers Squibb, Istanbul, Turkey; 6Pharmerit
Europe, Rotterdam, The Netherlands; 7Otsuka Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd., Rueil-Malmaison,
France; 8Bristol-Myers Squibb, Braine-l’Alleud, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: Major Depressive Disorder (MDD) is a chronic illness associated with
major burden on Quality-of -Life (QoL) and health care resources. a recent study
estimated annual cost being c282 per European inhabitant. Adjunctive treatments with
aripiprazole, quetiapine and olanzapine have demonstrated efficacy in patients with
MDD that respond insufficiently to antidepressant treatment. The objective is to
estimate the cost-effectiveness of adjunctive therapies in depressive patients failing to
respond to antidepressant therapy in Turkey. METHODS: An economic model was
built simulating MDD patients between major depressive episodes (MDEs) and remission over lifetime. During MDEs, patients were treated with adjunctive aripiprazole,
quetiapine or olanzapine. Patients who did not respond at 6 weeks switched to subsequent treatment lines. Comparative effectiveness between aripiprazole, quetiapine
and olanzapine, was imputed using an indirect comparison combining 6-week published studies. Resource use data and unit costs were obtained from Turkish studies.
RESULTS: Over life-time, aripiprazole patients spent less time in MDEs compared to
quetiapine (7,7 weeks) and olanzapine (7.5 weeks). Compared to Quetiapine, patients
with aripiprazole showed improvement in QoL (+0.045 QALY) at incremental direct
cost of 421TL. Compared to olanzapine, patients with aripiprazole dominated,
meaning improvement of QoL (+0.042 QALY) respectively, at lower direct cost (-32
TL), despite higher drug costs. Sensitivity analyses estimated a 87% likelihood that
aripiprazole improved QoL at a comparable cost verus quetiapine and 88% versus
olanzapine. CONCLUSIONS: This is the first lifetime health-economic model in
Turkey taking patient heterogeneity into account when assessing QoL and costs of
different adjunctive strategies in MDD. These results indicate that adjunctive treatment
with aripiprazole provides health benefits at lower costs compared to quetiapine and
olanzapine, in patients with MDD.
PMH34
COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS OF RISPERIDONE LONG-ACTING
INJECTION IN SCHIZOPHRENIA: 24-MONTH DATA FROM CZECH
REPUBLIC
Skoupá J
Pharma Projects s.r.o., Prague, Czech Republic
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate 24 months cost-effectiveness of risperidone long-acting
injection (RLAI) in patients with schizophrenia enrolled in the electronic-Schizophrenia Treatment Adherence Registry (e-STAR) from Czech Republic. This evaluation is
a follow-up of 12 months data presented at the European ISPOR congress (Athens
2008). METHODS: e-STAR is an international 24-month, prospective, observational
study in patients with schizophrenia who commenced RLAI treatment (based on SmPC
indication). Analyzed data covered one year of retrospective (prior to RLAI initiation)
vs. 24 months of prospective observation. a total of 607 patients have completed the
24 months study. Assessed direct costs were: hospitalization (duration and frequency),
antipsychotic medication and co-medication all from the payer’s perspective in 2009
prices. Efficacy parameters included GAF (Global Assessment of Functioning) and
CGI-S (Clinical Global Impression-Severity) scores. RESULTS: Mean annual costs/
patient increased form c2173 (1 Euro = 26 CZK) in the retrospective period to c4270
during the first and 4453 during the second years of observation. Mean cost drivers
were hospitalization (63% of total retrospective costs) and antipsychotic medication
(90% and 91% of total prospective costs). Costs of RLAI could not be fully offset by
significant reductions in hospitalization (both frequency and duration) and co-medication. Improvements in GAF and CGI scores seen at the first treatment year were
maintained during year 2 of assessment. Overall GAF changed from 49.6 (baseline)
to 74.6 (at 24 month), CGI decreased from baseline 4.61 to 2.96 (24-month). Costeffectiveness (costs/clinically relevant change in parameters) could also be maintained.
More than one-third of patients achieved disease remission, resulting in acceptable
incremental c850/patient in remission. CONCLUSIONS: Switching to risperidone
long-acting injection in patients with treatment failure, non-compliance or intolerance
A452
of current antipsychotic medication is cost-effective despite higher costs of antipsychotic medication. Positive clinical and economic results persisted over 24 months.
PMH35
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF MEMANTINE IN THE TREATMENT OF
MODERATE AND SEVERE ALZHEIMER’S DISEASE PATIENTS WITH
AGITATION, AGGRESSION AND PSYCHOSIS—THE UK EXAMPLE
Rive B1, Grishchenko M1, Guilhaume C1, Katona C2, Lamure M3, Livingston G2, Toumi M4,
Francois C1
1
Lundbeck SAS, Issy-Les Moulineaux, France; 2University College London, London, UK;
3
University Claude Bernard Lyon 1, Paris, France; 4University Claude Bernard Lyon 1, Lyon,
France
OBJECTIVES: To assess the cost-effectiveness of memantine in moderate and severe
AD patients who exhibit agitation/aggression and psychotic symptoms (APS) from the
UK National Health Service and Personal Social Services perspective. METHODS:
The cost-utility analysis was based on 5-year Markov cohort simulations. The model
evaluated the impact of memantine on time to Full-Time-Care (FTC), QualityAdjusted-Life-Years (QALYs) and costs, in pre-FTC patients compared with standard
care, i.e. no pharmacotherapy or background treatment with acetylcholinesterase
inhibitors. FTC was defined based on locus of care and patient’s physical and functional dependency status. Transition probabilities, baseline characteristics, resource
utilization volumes, health utility weights and mortality rates were derived from the
4.5-year London and South-East Region (LASER-AD) epidemiological study. Effectiveness estimates came from a meta-analysis of six large randomised clinical trials.
Costs covered routine patient management, hospitalization, social community services,
institutionalization, and medications. Results were reported in EUR (GBP), 2009. The
model underwent extensive stochastic and one-way sensitivity analyses, testing the
model assumptions and changes in input parameters. RESULTS: Over five years,
patients receiving standard care spend on average 78.8 weeks in the pre-FTC state.
Overall costs in this group were c117,960 (£98,810). QALYs were estimated at 1.49
(30% of full health). Memantine was associated with a longer time-to-FTC of 11.2
weeks, QALY gains of 0.07 and cost-savings of c5930 (£4970). Lower costs in the
memantine group were due to prolonged pre-FTC period. Memantine was more effective and less costly strategy relative to standard care in 99.98% of simulations. The
estimated benefits and cost savings were almost twice higher than those previously
estimated in all moderate and severe AD patients, largely due to enhanced efficacy of
memantine in APS patients, who, when left untreated, rapidly deteriorate. CONCLUSIONS: The model showed that memantine yielded higher benefits at no additional
costs relative to its alternative.
PMH36
ECONOMIC EVALUATION ANALYSIS IN THE TREATMENT OF BIPOLAR
DISORDER WITH ARIPIPRAZOLE AND OTHER ATYPICAL
ANTIPSYCHOTIC DRUGS IN SPAIN
Ramirez de Arellano A1, Rubio-Terrés C2, Baca E3, Riesgo Y4, Luque J1, Mena E5
1
Bristol-Myers Squibb Iberia, Madrid, Spain; 2HealthValue, Madrid, Spain; 3Hospital
Universitario Puerta de Hierro, Madrid, Spain; 4Bristol-Myers Squibb Iberia, Malaga, Spain;
5
Otsuka Pharmaceuticals, Barcelona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: This analysis investigates the relative efficiency in the treatment of BD
with the use atypical antipsychotics (AA): aripiprazole (ARI); olanzapine (OLA);
quetiapine (QUE); risperidone (RIS); and ziprasidone (ZIP). METHODS: our analysis
takes into consideration the treatment cost of AA and the impact on hospitalization
costs associated with each AA. Mean daily dose of each AA, length of treatment and
the probability of hospitalization for each AA were obtained from a retrospective
study (90 days of follow-up) in 6,162 BD patients (Jing et al. 2009). The minimum
acquisition cost per mg. of the mean daily dose, for each AA, is regarded as an efficiency criterion in Hospital Pharmacy Departments. The cost per day of hospitalization (c347.90) and the length of hospitalization associated to BD (18.1 days;
14.5–21.7) were obtained from a Spanish study. RESULTS: after 90 days of follow-up,
hospitalization rates were higher with OLA (8.7%), QUE (8.5%), RIS (8.6%) and
ZIP (10.2%) in comparison with ARI (5.9%; 5.8%; 5.7%; 6.5%, respectively). The
treatment of BD with ARI gave rise to the following cost savings per patient, in relation
to other AA: c149.31 ARI versus OLA; c33.42 ARI versus QUE; c19.45 ARI versus
RIS; and c242.22 ARI versus ZIP. a sensitivity analysis tested the following variables:
minimum daily dose for each AA; maximum daily dose for each AA; length of treatment with AA; and probability of hospitalization for each AA. The sensitivity analysis
confirms the cost savings associated with aripiprazole, with the only exception of
risperidone where the cost saving per patient is almost neutral (c−2.89). CONCLUSIONS: using the criterion of cost rationalization based upon the minimum acquisition
cost per mg. aripiprazole may have economic benefits over other AA in terms of lower
psychiatric treatment costs and lower total health care costs in the Spanish NHS.
PMH37
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF ANTIPSYCHOTICS FOR THE TREATMENT
OF RELAPSE PREVENTION FOR SCHIZOPHRENIA: THE SPANISH
PERSPECTIVE
García-Ruiz A1, Perez Costillas L2, Montesinos Galvez A2, Alcalde de Hoyos J1,
Garcia-Agua i Soler N1
1
Malaga University, Malaga, Spain; 2Carlos Haya Hospital, Malaga, Spain
OBJECTIVES: To assess the efficiency of the drugs used to reduce relapses in schizophrenia, taking into account costs and effectiveness (measured as QALY). METHODS:
13th Euro Abstracts
The National Health Care System perspective and a 1 year temporal horizon have
been used. Taking into account the last NICE review on schizophrenia1, four fundamental aspects related with schizophrenia management were analyzed: relapse rates,
treatment discontinuation due to intolerable side effects, treatment discontinuation
due to other reasons and stable patients (where the probability of remission, EPS
syndrome, weight gain, glucose intolerance and diabetes were analyzed). The health
care direct costs corresponding to the drug acquisition costs have been analyzed
together with the costs of the side effects considered, the cost of the complications
(diabetes) and the costs of hospitalary relapses (stay and drug cost) updated with data
from Spanish Ministry of Health (2008). a Monte Carlo simulation was performed
to obtain the cost-effectiveness ratio (euros/QALY). RESULTS: Paliperidone ER presents the lower total costs (c3060) compared to the other strategies (risperidone =
c3206; haloperidol = c3220; olanzapine = c3903; amisulpride = c4281; aripiprazole
= c4719). Paliperidone ER presents the higher efficacy (QALY) compared to the other
strategies (Paliperidone ER = 0.7573; risperidone = 0.7335; haloperidol = c0.7230;
olanzapine = c0.7474; amisulpride = c0.7320; aripiprazole = c0.7379). With these
results, we can conclude that all the strategies are dominated by Paliperidone ER with
a C/E ratio of 4073 (risperidone = 4382; haloperidol = 4461; olanzapine = 5.235;
amisulpride = 5.827; aripiprazole = 6.421) CONCLUSIONS: At a willingness-to-pay
of c30,000 per QALY all the drugs considered are cost-effective in Spain. However,
the most efficient (more net benefic, monetary (euros) and in health—QALYs) vs.
Haloperidol are: paliperidone ER, followed by risperidone, olanzapine, amisulpride
and aripiprazole.
PMH38
A COST UTILITY ANALYSIS OF FIRST LINE ANTIPSYCHOTICS FOR THE
PREVENTION OF SCHIZOPHRENIA RELAPSE IN THE UNITED KINGDOM
Jones MA, Meier GC
AstraZeneca UK Ltd, Luton, England
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of eight first line antipsychotics in
the prevention of schizophrenia relapse, from a UK National Health Service and
Personal Social Services perspective. METHODS: A Markov model, similar to that
used by the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence in the Schizophrenia
(update) guideline (published March 2009), was developed to assess the cost per
QALY gained for amisulpride, aripiprazole, haloperidol, olanzapine, paliperidone,
quetiapine (XL), risperidone and zotepine. Clinical parameters were populated with
data from mixed treatment comparisons. Patients entered the model in remission and
could remain in remission, relapse, move to next line of therapy due to side effects,
or discontinue for other reasons. Utilities for schizophrenia in remission and relapse
were taken from a direct utility elicitation study conducted in a UK population. Disutilities for side effects were captured. Resource use and unit costs (reference year 2009)
were taken from published sources and a 10 year time horizon was adopted. Probabilistic results were derived from 10,000 model simulations. RESULTS: The deterministic analysis showed quetiapine (XL) to yield the most QALYs and lowest overall
treatment costs. Model outcomes were supported by the probabilistic analysis but
results were characterised by uncertainty. In one scenario, drug costs for all comparators bar quetiapine (XL) were set to zero. Quetiapine (XL) generated 7.051 QALYs
compared to a range of 6.930–6.972 for other medications. Overall treatment costs
for quetiapine (XL) were £153,104 compared to £155,766-£167,329 for other medications. Thus it was still the dominant strategy. CONCLUSIONS: The additional
benefit of Quetiapine (XL) in terms of schizophrenia relapse prevention results in it
being the most cost-effective of the antipsychotics assessed. Clinical efficacy is the key
driver of cost-effectiveness in relapse prevention, hence generic antipsychotics should
not be recommended based upon drug costs alone. Further long term trials of antipsychotics are required to reduce uncertainty.
PMH39
THE COST-UTILITY OF AGOMELATINE IN MAJOR DEPRESSIVE
DISORDER IN POLAND
Golicki D, Paja˛k K, Dbrowska A, Niewada M
HealthQuest sp z o.o., Warsaw, Poland
OBJECTIVES: a cost-utility analysis of agomelatine, a treatment of major depressive
disorders in adults, was performed from the Polish public payer’s perspective (the
National Health Fund). Agomalatine was compared with the most commonly used
antidepressants in Poland, i.e. generic sertraline and generic venlafaxine. METHODS:
The analysis with a time horizon of 2 years is based on a Markov model. The onemonth cycle model included the following health states: depression episode, remission,
well and death. It also incorporated sleep disorders, discontinuation rates, discontinuation symptoms and adverse drug reactions. The clinical parameters for compared
drugs were extracted from head-to-head clinical trials. Utility and disutility estimates
were derived from a systematic literature review. Only direct costs have been considered in order to be consistent with Polish pharmacoeconomic guidelines. Costs and
effects were discounted at 5% and 3.5% per annum at year 1 respectively. RESULTS:
The benefit of agomelatine over sertraline or venlafaxine was estimated at 0.005
QALY. This effectiveness was associated with the additional costs of 491 PLN and
149 PLN for agomelatine compared to sertraline and venlafaxine, respectively. The
corresponding agomelatine incremental cost-utility ratios (ICURs) were therefore
92,000 PLN/QALY and 28,000 PLN/QALY. Sensitivity analysis demonstrated that
agomelatine ICUR remained below the three times GDP per capita threshold (33,347
PLN for 2008) in 79.7% and 88.4% of the cases compared with sertraline and venlafaxine, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: From the Polish public payer’s perspective,
13th Euro Abstracts
agomelatine is a cost-effective treatment of major depressive disorders compared to
generics of sertraline and venlafaxine.
PMH40
COST-UTILITY ANALYSIS (CUA) OF SERTINDOLE IN THE TREATMENT
OF SCHIZOPHRENIA IN POLAND IN GENERAL POPULATION OF
SCHIZOPHRENIC PATIENTS AND POPULATION OF PATIENTS
INTOLERANT TO AT LEAST ONE OTHER ANTIPSYCHOTIC AGENT: A
FIVE-YEAR MARKOV MODEL
Walczak J, Stelmachowski J, Obrzut G, Nogas G
Arcana Institute, Cracow, Poland
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate a cost-utility of sertindole compared with commonly used
antipsychotic drugs in Poland: haloperidol and risperidone in the treatment of general
population of schizophrenic patients and with risperidone in a group of patients
intolerant to at least one other antipsychotic agent. METHODS: Cost-utility Markov
model was constructed in five-year time horizon. Clinical effectiveness was assessed on
the basis of RCTs, meta-analyses, observational studies and systematic reviews. The
measures of effectiveness in the CUA were quality adjusted life-years (QALY) and lifeyears gained (LYG). Direct medical costs were calculated from perspective of two payers
(Polish National Health Fund and patient). Cost of: oral antipsychotic treatment, inpatient care, primary health care, specialist care and adverse events treatment (extrapyramidal symptoms, sedation and weight gain) were included. Discount rates of 5% for
costs and 3.5% for benefits were used. Utilities and disutilities associated with AEs and
relapse were derived from published literature. RESULTS: In general population of
schizophrenic patients cost per QALY/LYG gained, using sertindole instead of risperidone is 97,396/26,585 PLN (c22,507/6,144) respectively; cost per QALY/LYG gained,
using sertindole instead of haloperidol, is 82,132/20,670 PLN (c18,980/4,777) respectively. In population intolerant to at least one other antipsychotic agent sertindole
dominates risperidone (sertindole is less expensive and more effective considering both
QALY/LYG gained). The sensitivity analysis indicated the robustness of the results.
Obtained results are placed below the acceptability threshold (3xGDP per capita in
Poland) which is about 105,500 PLN (c24,380). The 2009 weighted average exchange
rate of Polish National Bank was c1 = PLN 4.3273. CONCLUSIONS: Treatment of
schizophrenia with sertindole is a cost-effective strategy in comparison with risperidone and haloperidol therapy. In a group of patients intolerant to at least one other
antipsychotic agent sertindole compared to risperidone is dominant strategy.
PMH41
COST-UTILITY ANALYSIS OF ESCITALOPRAM VERSUS CITALOPRAM IN
MAJOR DEPRESSIVE DISORDER IN ISRAEL
Leshno M1, Ben-Amnon Y2, Brignone M3, Marteau F4, Hansen K3
1
Faculty of Management, Tel-Aviv, Israel; 2Lundbeck Israel Ltd., Petach-Tikva, Israel;
3
Lundbeck SAS, Issy-les-Moulineaux cedex, France; 4Lundbeck SAS, Issy-les-Moulineaux
cedex, France
OBJECTIVES: A recent meta-analysis has shown that escitalopram, a selective inhibitor of serotonin reuptake, is one of the best choices when starting a treatment of
moderate to severe major depressive disorder (MDD), with a favourable balance
between efficacy and tolerability. Our objective was to perform an economic evaluation of escitalopram versus citalopram in Israel. Citalopram is available as a generic
drug and is included in the National Health Basket. METHODS: A decision tree model
was used to assess the cost-utility of escitalopram versus citalopram in first-line treatment of MDD. The model also accounted for second-, third- and fourth-line treatments for patients not responding to therapy, with an overall time horizon of 12
months. The analysis adopted a Health Maintenance Organization perspective. The
main outcomes were quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs) and costs associated with
local health care resource use (including drug use, and hospitalizations due to depression or suicide attempt). One-way and two-way sensitivity analyses were performed
with the following parameters: probabilities of remission after initial and subsequent
treatment, probabilities of relapse, suicide attempt and suicide-related death, number
of hospitalization days due to a suicide attempt, costs of initial and subsequent treatments and utility values. In addition, we used a Monte Carlo simulation. RESULTS:
Compared to citalopram, escitalopram was more effective in terms of QALYs at a
small incremental cost. The average QALYs of patients treated with escitalopram and
citalopram were 0.728 and 0.720 respectively. The average cost of patients treated
with escitalopram and citalopram were c105 and c63 respectively. The incremental
cost-utility ratio was c5,150 (NIS23,875) per QALY. The variation of remission rates
had the most influence on this ratio in the sensitivity analyses. CONCLUSIONS: This
local economic evaluation shows that compared to citalopram, escitalopram should
be the preferred option in depression in Israel with an acceptable cost per QALY.
PMH42
UTILIZATION OF ANTIDEPRESSANTS IN SLOVAKIA
1
1
2
1
3
Bellová K , Gatialová K , Foltanova T , Petrová L , Bielik J
1
Comenius University, Bratislava, Slovak Republic; 2Faculty of Pharmacy, Bratislava, Slovak
Republic; 3AD University, Tren ín, Slovak Republic
OBJECTIVES: The main objective was to evaluate the consumption of antidepressants, it s utilization as the basic aspect of the quality of life and to analyze the using
of the original drugs or generics and to show the pharmacoeconomical impact of this
group of drugs considering to it s financial costingness. METHODS: We used the
analysis of consumption trend of antidepressants and the analysis of the trend of prices
of antidepressants. We compared the original and generic market with antidepressants
A453
in Slovakia, we monitored and compared the prices for DDD and we evaluate the impact
of new generics on the prices of originals as well. RESULTS: The consumption of
antidepressants has increased because of increasing number depression illnesses which
could be continually treated by modern antidepressants since successful treatment
depends on relaps prevention. Such outcome could be reached by usage of the latest
antidepressants with good compliance (escitalopram, venlafaxine, mirtazapin). Since
2005 the consumption (packages sold) of antidepressant increased by 29% whereas
the sales value stagnated as result of declining price. The price for daily recommended
dosage decreased by 52.7% (from c0.80 in 2001 to c0.38 in 2008). This was influenced mainly by the increasing number of generics medicaments which pushed the
price down. In 2009 the price of original antidepressants fall by 26.4% as reason of
generic molecules. Based on long-term surveys the similar trend could be expected also
in the future. CONCLUSIONS: The utilization of antidepressants lead to better
quality of life. From the pharmacoeconomical view, the development of new molecules
goes hand in hand with the decrease of invalidation, decrease of the cost for hospitalization, as well as increase people ‘s ability to take care about themselves. On the
other hand, the generic substitution leads to increase of the amount of treated patients.
PMH43
HEALTH CARE UTILIZATION OF PATIENTS WITH DEPRESSION
BEFORE AND AFTER INTIATING DULOXETINE
Shi N1, Durden E2, Cao Z1, Torres A3, Happich M4
1
Thomson Reuters, Cambridge, MA, USA; 2Former Employee of Thomson Reuters, currently
with Covance Market Access Services Inc., San Diego, CA, USA; 3Thomson Reuters,
Washington, DC, USA; 4Eli Lilly & Company, Bad Homburg, Hessia, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Evaluate health care utilization among depressed patients before and
after initiating duloxetine. METHODS: Depressed adults treated with duloxetine
during January 1, 2006-September 30, 2007 were identified from the General Practice
Research Database. All-cause health care utilization in the 12-months before and after
treatment initiation was compared for patients and for the subset of patients with
pre-period unexplained pain (UPain). Generalized Estimating Equation models were
used to identify factors associated with the pre-post differences in hospitalization rates.
Covariates included age, gender, pre-period comorbid conditions and medication use.
RESULTS: A total of 909 patients were identified (mean age = 49.6; female = 67.7%),
and 45% experienced UPain. Three-quarters of patients were prescribed a SSRI and
11% were untreated with antidepressants before initiating duloxetine. Among
patients, the rate of hospitalization was higher in the pre-period compared to the
post-period (20.7% vs.16.5%, p = 0.006). There were no significant pre-post differences in the rates of accident & emergency visits, specialist referrals, or analgesic use.
Among patients with UPain, fewer were hospitalized (26.2% vs. 19.1%, p = 0.003)
or received analgesic in the post-period (77.0% vs. 71.7%, p = 0.015). Multivariate
analysis confirmed fewer patients experienced hospitalization after duloxetine initiation. All depressed patients with pre-period anxiolytic use (OR = 0.70, 95% CI,
0.50–0.97, p = 0.033) or UPain patients with pre-period anticonvulsant use (OR =
0.44, 95% CI, 0.21–0.91, p = 0.026) experienced a decreased hospitalization rate after
initiating duloxetine and the magnitude of change was larger than that for patients
not receiving these medications. All depressed patients with pre-period alcohol/drug
dependence (OR = 1.83, 95% CI, 1.01–3.30, p = 0.045) and sleep disorder (OR =
1.65, 95% CI, 1.05–2.59, p = 0.031) had an increase in the hospitalization rate from
the pre- to post-period, while those without the conditions had a decreased hospitalization rate. CONCLUSIONS: Hospitalization rates were lower following duloxetine
initiation among depressed patients. Pre-period alcohol/drug dependence, sleep disorders, anxiolytic and anticonvulsant use were associated with the pre-post difference
in the hospitalization rate.
PMH44
AN OBSERVATIONAL STUDY OF THE BURDEN OF INFORMAL
CAREGIVERS TO OUT-PATIENTS WITH SCHIZOPHRENIA SPECTRUM
DISORDERS
Flyckt L1, Granström O2, Löthman A3, Jörgensen L2, Koernig T2
1
Norra Stockholms Psykiatri, Danderyd, Sweden; 2AstraZeneca Nordic MC, Södertälje,
Sweden; 3Psykiatricentrum Väst, Bromma, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: The lifetime emotional, social, and financial consequences experienced
by individuals with schizophrenia spectrum disorders have significant effects on their
families. Therefore, it is essential to increase the knowledge and awareness of the
informal caregiver burden. Here, the purpose was to study objective burden (time and
money spent), as well as subjective burden (care-related quality of life) of informal
caregivers to patients with schizophrenia spectrum disorders. METHODS: Patients
with schizophrenia spectrum disorders and their closest informal caregivers were
recruited and patient- and caregiver-related characteristics and variables related to the
provision of formal care were assessed. The subjective burden was assessed using the
CarerQol. The objective burden was assessed prospectively during four weeks with
daily recordings by the caregiver using diaries of the money and time spent on the
patient. Data was analyzed using descriptive statistics. RESULTS: One-hundred and
seven patients (53% females; mean age 43 ± 11 years) from nine centers in Sweden,
and 118 of their closest informal care-givers (67% females; mean age 58 ± 15 years)
entered the study. The mean (standard deviation, SD) GAF for the patients was 52
(11). Subjective burden (CarerQol VAS) correlated positively to GAF. The mean (SD)
time spent on caring for relatives with schizophrenia spectrum disorders was 22 (36)
hours per week. Half of this (11 hours) was “stand-by” time and another 5 hours
were spent on household work. Caregivers’ mean (SD) monthly expenses in support
A454
of their relatives with schizophrenia were c292 (424), which corresponds to approximately 14% of the mean gross income of caregivers. Large expenditure items were
groceries, clothes, rent and travel. CONCLUSIONS: The objective burden adds halftime to an ordinary fulltime job (time spent on care) and additionally reduces gross
incomes with approximately 14% (money spent on care) for informal caregivers to
patients with schizophrenia spectrum disorders.
MENTAL HEALTH – Patient-Reported Outcomes Studies
PMH45
DISCONTINUATION OF DIFFERENT ANTIPSYCHOTIC MEDICATIONS
AFTER DISCHARGE FROM ACUTE CARE FOR PERSONS WITH
SCHIZOPHRENIA
Boaz TL1, Becker M1, Andel R1, Van Dorn R1, Choi J2, Sikirica M3
1
University of South Florida, Tampa, FL, USA; 2Ortho-McNeil Janssen Scientific Affairs, LLC,
Titusville, NJ, USA; 3Ortho-McNeil Janssen Scientific Affairs, LLC, Bethesda, MD, USA
OBJECTIVES: To examine risk of discontinuation of antipsychotics following discharge from acute care settings in Florida for Medicaid-enrolled persons with schizophrenia. METHODS: Medicaid claims, enrollment data, and community services data
from the state mental health authority from 2004–2008 were used. Demographics,
diagnosis, service history during the year before admission to acute care (hospitals and
crisis units), and post-discharge psychopharmacologic treatment were obtained.
Persons who received antipsychotic monotherapy and had a discharge diagnosis of
schizophrenia were included. Cox proportional hazards regression estimated risk of
post-discharge discontinuation of antipsychotics (formulary restrictions were not considered). Second-generation antipsychotics (SGAs) were examined individually; oral
first-generation antipsychotics (FGAs) and depot FGAs were each considered as a
group. Demographics, pre-admission service history, length of stay, and pre-discharge
length of time receiving medication were control variables. Data were right-censored
at end of Medicaid enrollment, end of data availability, or death. RESULTS: Participants (N = 6365) were 42.7 ± 11.2 (mean ± SD) years old; 61% male; 34% white.
Mean ± SD length of acute care stay was 11.0 ± 19.7 days. Median length of time
receiving medication post-discharge was 45 days. With risperidone long-acting therapy
(RLAT) as reference, depot and oral FGAs had highest risk of discontinuation (hazard
ratio [HR] = 2.49, P < .0001 and HR = 1.68, P = .0005), respectively. Risk was also
elevated for oral SGAs aripiprazole (HR = 1.65, P = .0012), ziprasidone (HR = 1.46,
P = .0191), olanzapine (HR = 1.43, P = .0202), and quetiapine (HR = 1.35, P = .0434),
except for oral risperidone and clozapine. Fewer months receiving pre-discharge
medication (HR = 1.04, P < .0001), black race (HR = 1.39, P < .0001), history of
involuntary commitment (HR = 1.28, P < .0001), and more pre-admission acute care
services (HR = 1.13, P = .0053) were associated with higher risk of discontinuation.
CONCLUSIONS: Persons with schizophrenia taking oral and depot FGAs were at
highest risk for discontinuation of medication after discharge from acute care. Those
taking oral SGAs (except risperidone and clozapine) also may have higher risk of
discontinuation than patients taking RLAT.
PMH46
ADHERENCE RATES OF INJECTABLE VS. ORAL RISPERIDONE FOR
PATIENTS WITH SCHIZOPHRENIA
Rascati KL, Kim DN
The University of Texas at Austin, Austin, TX, USA
OBJECTIVES: Non-adherence to antipsychotic therapy can lead to increased risks of
relapse and rehospitalization. Long-acting injectable antipsychotics have been shown
to be effective and well-tolerated, with increasing evidence of a potential benefit on
adherence. At the time of this study, only one long-acting injectable atypical antipsychotic entity—risperidone—was approved for patients with a diagnosis of schizophrenia. The objective of this study was to determine the medication adherence rates of
Medicaid patients treated with either 1) oral risperidone only, or 2) long-acting injectable risperidone +/− oral risperidone. METHODS: Texas Medicaid prescription claims
data from January 2006 to December 2008 were analyzed for patients with schizophrenia. Records were assessed for a period of 18 months (6-month pre-index period
with no antipsychotics plus 12-month post-index period). a medication possession
(MPR) ratio of ≥80% was considered adherent. RESULTS: A total of 1313 patients
met inclusion criteria, and less than half, 48% (N = 626) had an MPR of at least 80%.
Of the patients on long-acting injectables +/− oral risperidone, 60% (N = 96/160) were
adherent with their regimen versus 46% (530/1153) for patients taking only oral
risperidone. a logistic regression analysis adjusting for demographic covariates
(gender, race, age) showed that patients on injectable +/− oral medications were about
80 percent more likely to be adherent (OR = 1.82, 95% CI = 1.29–2.55; p = 0.0006)
than patients on oral medication alone. There were no statistically significant differences in any of the demographic characteristics between the two groups. CONCLUSIONS: Overall, about half of the patients did not meet the definition for medication
adherence (MPR ≥ 80%) one-year after their index date. Long-acting injectable risperidone had a higher rate of adherence compared to oral risperidone alone. With the
release of newer atypical long-acting injections (paliperidone and olanzapine), future
studies comparing adherence rates of these antipsychotic agents are needed.
13th Euro Abstracts
PMH47
MEDICATION COMPLIANCE AND HEALTH CARE COSTS OF TYPE II
DIABETICS WITH SCHIZOPHRENIA NEWLY STARTING
HYPOGLYCEMIC THERAPY
Cheng JS, Shih YT
National Health Research Institutes, Zhunan Town, Miaoli County, Taiwan
OBJECTIVES: Schizophrenia has been found to be associated with poor medication
compliance, and a higher prevalence of diabetes. Once a hypoglycemic therapy is
started, appropriate compliance to the therapy is crucial for good glycemic control.
This study aimed to compare hypoglycemic therapy medication compliance, and
health care costs after the initiation of the therapy, between type II diabetics with
schizophrenia versus those without schizophrenia. METHODS: This study used the
claims database of the National Health Insurance program. Enrollees who began oral
hypoglycemic therapy in 2001–2002 (the index date), and had been diagnosed with
schizophrenia and refilled at least one prescription of antipsychotic(s) in the year prior
to the index date were included in the study (the case group). Enrollees without
schizophrenia who began oral hypoglycemic therapy in 2001–2002 were selected from
a randomly selected sample of the enrollees (the comparison group). Good medication
compliance was defined as an medication possession ratio (MPR) ≥ 0.8. Ordered
logistic models were adopted to assess associations between factors with medication
compliance. RESULTS: There were 1196 and 3188 subjects in the case group and
comparison group, respectively. Forty-one percent of the case group and 30% of the
comparison group were good compliant. The cost of hypoglycemic therapy was significantly higher in the case group, while the total diabetes-related cost was not significantly different between the two groups. The regression results indicated that
comorbid schizophrenia was correlated with a higher likelihood of good compliance.
In a subgroup analysis of diabetics with schizophrenia, good compliance to antipsychotics in the previous year was significantly associated with a greater probability of
being better compliant with hypoglycemic therapy. CONCLUSIONS: Diabetics with
schizophrenia, compared with those without such a condition, were more compliant
in their hypoglycemic therapy, and had higher cost of hypoglycemic therapy in the
first year of the therapy.
PMH48
IMPACT OF ONCE-DAILY DOSING ON DRUG DISCONTINUATION OF
PATIENTS WITH SCHIZOPHRENIA
Kalo Z1, Nemeth A2, Jozwiak-Hagymasy J3
1
Eötvös Loránd University, Budapest, Hungary; 2National Centre for Psychiatry, Budapest,
Hungary; 3Syreon Research Institute, Budapest, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: According to evidence from scientific literature the ease of administration, such as once-daily dosing, improves the adherence and persistance of patients
with the pharmaceutical therapy. Adherence and persistance are key success factors
in the treatment of schizophrenic patients, as drug discontinuation or non-adherence
increase the risk of relapse, which eventually results in reduced quality adjusted lifeyears and increased cost of care by more acute hospitalization episodes. Our objective
was to analyze the impact of once-daily dosing vs. twice daily dosing on the discontinuation rate of pharmaceutical therapy among patients with schizophrenia.
METHODS: Our real world analysis is based on aggregated data from the Hungarian
National Health Insurance Fund database. We selected adult patients (between 18–65
years) on quetiapine therapy with F20 schizoprenia ICD-10 code between January and
March 2008. We compared the one-year discontinuation rate among once-daily vs.
twice daily quetiapine users. Discontinuation was defined as no prescribed antipsychotic medication in the N05A ATC group between May—July 2009. RESULTS:
After 1 year 23.4% in the once-daily group compared to 27.2% in the twice-daily
group discontinued the pharmaceutical therapy. Once-daily dosing reduced the relative risk of discontinuation by 13.9%. (χ2 test: p = 0,017). The absoluate risk reduction
was 3.8% (NNT = 26.5). CONCLUSIONS: Our analysis indicates that once-daily
dosing reduces the risk of drug discontinuation among schizophrenic patients. Short
time-horizon, potential selection bias and confounding factors may limit the generalizability of our conclusions. Long-term observational study with multiple regression
analysis based on anonimized individual patient records can confirm the validity of
our findings.
PMH49
ANTIDEPRESSANT UTILIZATION, ADHERENCE AND HEALTH CARE
SPENDING IN THE UNITED STATES: THE CASE OF MDD PATIENTS
2000–2007
Lin HC1, Erickson S2, Smith D1, Balkrishnan R2
1
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA; 2University of Michigan,
College of Pharmacy, Ann Arbor, MI, USA
OBJECTIVES: Innovative antidepressants such as SSRIs and SNRIs have been widely
adopted. However, the differences in patient antidepressant adherence and associated
health care spending across patient factors and antidepressant choice needed further
research. This study was trying to understand how patient factors and antidepressant
choice influenced medication adherence and associated health care expenditure.
METHODS: A retrospective cross-sectional study was conducted using the 2000–
2007 Medical Expenditure Panel Survey (MEPS) database. a multiple OLS regression
was used to examine MDD patient’s antidepressant adherence measured by proportional days covered (PDC). a two-part model was implemented to study the impact
of MDD patient factors and antidepressant choice on associated health care expenditure. RESULTS: Linear regression models indicated that patient gender, ethnicity and
13th Euro Abstracts
health insurance status were associated with differential levels of antidepressant adherence and associated health expenditure. Hispanic ethnicity was associated with
decreased antidepressant adherence compared to non-Hispanic white (β = 12.53, P <
0.05) and other ethnicities (β = 28.27, P < 0.01). Patient who were covered by public
insurance had better PDC compared to uninsured patients (β = 16.23, P < 0.05).
Patient who were covered by private insurance spent more on MDD-specific drug
compared to uninsured patients (β = 0.36, P < 0.05). Higher antidepressant adherence
was associated with higher MDD-specific drug expenditure (β = 0.03, P < 0.01). Use
of innovative antidepressants such as SSRIs and SNRIs was associated with an increase
in MDD-specific drug expenditure. CONCLUSIONS: Differences in antidepressant
adherence and health care spending across patient factors could have important policy
implications for drug formularies and health disparities. Solutions for gaps between
optimal and suboptimal health care for patient mental health caused by systematic
differences in sociological factors need to be well tailored. We need policy makers to
be engaged in designing effective policy interventions to improve patient medication
adherence, and to fund cost-effectiveness studies to improve patient outcomes and in
turn, reduce associated health expenditure.
PMH50
TRENDS IN ANTIDEPRESSANT UTILIZATION, AND ASSOCIATED
LABOR MARKET PARTICIPATION AND QUALITY OF LIFE OUTCOMES
IN THE UNITED STATES: 2004–2007
Lin HC1, Erickson S2, Smith D1, Balkrishnan R2
1
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA; 2University of Michigan, College of Pharmacy,
Ann Arbor, MI, USA
OBJECTIVES: Innovative antidepressants have been widely adopted. However, the
differences in patient factors and antidepressant use, and associated patient health and
work outcomes were not jointly studied. This study was trying to understand how
patient factors and antidepressant utilization were associated with patient employment
durations and quality of life. METHODS: A retrospective cross-sectional study was
conducted using the 2004–2007 Medical Expenditure Panel Survey (MEPS) database.
Proportional hazard duration models were used to examine MDD patient’s employment duration. Linear regression models were implemented to study the impacts of
MDD patient factors and antidepressant utilization on associated patient physical and
mental health status. RESULTS: Differences in employment duration across several
patient factors were found. Cox proportional hazard model showed that, compared
to uninsured patients, MDD patients covered by private insurance had a lower level
of hazard of job termination (hazard ratio = 0.15, P < 0.01). Patients who were in
better physical health conditions had a lower level of hazard of job termination
(hazard ratio = 0.96, P < 0.01). Results from OLS regressions showed that, compared
to patient without antidepressant pharmacotherapy for MDD treatment, patients who
took innovative antidepressants such as SSRIs/SNRIs and other newer ones had a huge
increase in MCS (β = 11.35, P < 0.01). In addition, better antidepressant adherence
was significantly associated with an increase of MCS (β = 0.10, P < 0.01). CONCLUSIONS: This study suggested that effective policy interventions were needed for
improving medication adherence, and the design of prescription drug benefit within
health insurance should be tailored considering its associations with patient factors
and related improvement in health status according to the findings of this study. We
need policy makers to be engaged in designing effective policy interventions to improve
patient medication adherence, which may in turn improve patient health status and
labor market participation.
PMH51
HEALTH STATUS AND COST OF CARE IN PATIENTS WITH DEMENTIA
IN GERMANY
Reese JP1, Heßmann P1, Seeberg GM1, Baum E1, Rieke J2, Müller MJ3,
Balzer-Geldsetzer M1, Dodel R1
1
Phillips University Marburg, Marburg, Germany; 2Office-based neurologist, Giessen,
Germany; 3Vitos Clinic for Psychiatry and Psychotherapy Marburg, Marburg, Germany
OBJECTIVES: To assess cost-of-illness and patient-relevant outcomes in patients with
dementia in different settings in the German health system. METHODS: 600 patients
with dementia were recruited at 1) a university hospital; 2) general practitioners; 3)
office-based neurologists; 4) a regional psychiatric hospital; and 5) in long-term care
facilities. Socio-demographic, economic and clinical parameters were assessed using a
standardized questionnaire. Disease severity was measured by means of the Minimental Status Examination (MMSE) and the Alzheimer’s Disease Assessment Scale. Neuropsychiatric status was assessed with the Geriatric Depression Scale, the
Neuropsychiatric Inventory and the Alzheimer’s Disease Cooperative-Study-Activities
of Daily Living. Patient’s quality of life was reported by the patient and also by the
caregiver (employing the EuroQol and the QoL-AD instruments). RESULTS: For an
interim analysis, 278 patients (180 female, 98 male) were available. Mean age was
78.2 yrs and mean disease duration was 4.5 yrs (SD 3.9). On average, care was needed
for 3.0 yrs (SD 3.1). Cognitive impairment was severest in institutionalized patients
(MMSE 12.2 pts SD 8.2) compared to the mean of all patients (MMSE 16.9 Pts).
Mean EQ VAS values were 60.5 pts (SD 20.2). Disease-specific QoL-AD health status
mean was 30.2 (SD 5.6). Health status was rated highest in long-term care facilities
(EQ VAS) and at office-based neurologists (QoL-AD). In all severity stages patients
rated their own health status (Qol-AD) better than their relatives. The costs of antidementia drugs were c45,000 per 3 months. Memantine accounted for 61%. a total
of 41% of the patients received Memantine whereas 45% of the patients received no
anti-dementia medication. CONCLUSIONS: Health status is considerably impaired
in patients with dementia and their caregivers. Interestingly, caregivers often appraise
A455
patients’ Quality of life worse than the patients themselves. Altogether, our results
indicate a considerable under-supply with anti-dementia drugs.
PMH52
A SHORT 12-ITEM ZARIT BURDEN INVENTORY FOR THE ASSESSMENT
OF DEMENTIA CAREGIVERS AS OBTAINED BY ITEM RESPONSE
THEORY
Ballesteros J1, Santos B1, González-Fraile E2, Muñoz-Hermoso P2, Dominguez-Pachón A3,
Martín-Carrasco M4
1
University of the Basque Country, UPV/EHU, CIBERSAM, Leioa, Spain; 2Instituto de
Investigaciones Psiquiátricas-IIP, Bilbao, Spain; 3Hospital Aita Menni, Arrasate-Mondragón,
Spain; 4Clínica Psiquiátrica Padre Menni, Pamplona, Spain
OBJECTIVES: The Zarit Burden Inventory (ZBI) is a 22-item self-report scale frequently used to asess patients’ caregiver burden on several dimensions. As a multidimensional instrument the interpretation of its total score is sometimes unclear. Our
aim was to obtain a short-ZBI unidimensional scale based on Item Response Theory
(IRT) approaches. METHODS: The validation sample comprised 246 caregivers of
patients diagnosed with dementia and recruited for an ongoing multi-center randomized clinical trial on the efficacy of psychoeducational interventions (EDUCA-2 trial).
The pre-randomization 22-item ZBI was analyzed according to the Samejima’s graded
response model to select the more informative items. The dimensionality of the scale
was further tested with Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA). Finally, discriminant
validity was assessed by Receiving Operator Characteristic (ROC) analysis and the
Area Under the Curve (AUC) contrasting the short scale total score against the psychological distress criterion evaluated with the General Health Questionnaire 28-item
at 5/6 cut-off. RESULTS: A 12-item short-ZBI was selected. It covered 87% of the
total 22-item ZBI information and showed appropriate item curve characteristics
according to the Samejima’s model. The short-ZBI had an internal reliability of 0.89
(Cronbach’s alpha), and was compatible with a unidimensional latent structure for
the burden construct (CFI = 0.99; RMSEA = 0.05). According to the GHQ-28 cut-off
131 caregivers (53% of the total sample) could be considered at high risk for developping psychological distress. The discriminant validity of the short-ZBI scale against
that criterion was good (AUC = 0.84, 95% CI = 0.79 to 0.89) and not significantly
different from the parental 22-item ZBI (p = 0.85). CONCLUSIONS: We have found
good psychometric properties for the short-ZBI scale derived from IRT. Its unidimensionality might be important to enhance its interpretation. Further psychometric
studies, mainly on its sensitivity to change are now warranted.
PMH53
FACTOR STRUCTURE OF A SOCIAL SUPPORT SCALE FOR
ADOLESCENTS TREATED FOR SUBSTANCE USE DISORDER
Ciesla J, Yao P
Northern Illinois University, DeKalb, IL, USA
OBJECTIVES: The literature indicates that social support is protective of relapse for
adolescents treated for substance use disorder (SUD). Unfortunately, no standard
measure of social support exists. The objective of this research is to use factor analysis
to elucidate the underlying factor structure of a 14-item social support scale for use
in outcomes assessment in this treatment population. METHODS: Subjects are 517
adolescents discharged from primary substance abuse treatment from 2004–2008. The
data is from research conducted between 6 and 12 months post discharge via a 234item questionnaire that included the 14-item social support scale. The scale has questions that assess the degree to which the adolescent’s social contacts conform to norms
of positive behavior and therefore foster non-use and recovery. The response rate was
62 percent. RESULTS: The factorability of the scale was assessed by Keiser-MeyerOlkin statistic (it was 0.727, > the recommended 0.6) and by Bartlett’s test of sphericity which was significant (x2 = 1066.89, p = 0.00001). The scale was decomposed by
principal component factor analysis and three factors emerged. Initial Eigen values
explained 65.6, 23.1 and 11.3 percent of the variance, respectively. Final factor solutions were examined using varimax, oblimin and promax rotations with 3, 4, 5 & 6
solutions, respectively. a three-factor solution via promax explaining 99 percent of
the variance emerged as the best solution although results were similar using the other
rotations. Factor 1 yielded ten items that are attributes of a peers’ potential to be
positive a or negative influence and thus supportive of recovery. The three items in
Factor 2 related to emotional dimensions of social support. Factor 3 contained two
items indicating a recovering adolescent’s ability to seek-out and establish positive
social contacts. CONCLUSIONS: This scale is useful as a standard measure of social
support which is an important aspect of treatment success.
PMH54
USE OF THE ANALYTIC HIERARCHY PROCESS TO PRIORITIZE
PATIENT-RELEVANT ENDPOINTS OF ANTIDEPRESSANT TREATMENT
van Manen JG1, Hummel JM1, Ijzerman MJ1, Volz F2, Gerber A2, Danner M2
1
University Twente, Enschede, The Netherlands; 2Institute for Quality and Efficiency in
Health Care (IQWiG), Cologne, Germany
OBJECTIVES: In deciding about coverage of new medical technology, multiple clinical outcomes are used to support reimbursement claims. Neither the real world value
nor the relevance of these outcome measures for patients is systematically assessed.
Hence, there is growing interest in the use of patient-reported outcome measures.
Multi-criteria decision analysis, like the analytic hierarchy process (AHP), is a technique to elicit patient preferences. In the present study we used AHP to prioritize
patient relevant endpoints related to the use of antidepressants in major depression.
A456
METHODS: Patient relevant endpoints of treatment (remission of depression,
response to treatment, no relapse, serious adverse events, adverse events, social function, anxiety, pain, cognitive function) were prioritized using pairwise comparisons of
these outcomes. In two separate groups, twelve patients and seven experts judged on
a 9 point scale the relative importance of pairs of two outcome measures. The geometric mean of these judgments was used to derive weighting factors for the outcome
measures (scale 0–1). RESULTS: Of all outcome measures, patients rated response to
treatment highest (0.32), while experts rated remission of depression highest (0.48).
Adverse events were all rated lowest by patients as well as by experts, and diseasespecific quality of life domains such as social function (0.11 & 0.09), anxiety (0.12
& 0.05) and cognitive function (0.13 & 0.06) were rated in between. CONCLUSIONS: The most important outcome measures according to the patients are, in order
of decreasing importance: response, cognitive function, no anxiety, social function, no
relapse, no adverse events, and remission. The AHP appears to be suitable in gaining
an overview of the importance of patient relevant outcome measures. An additional
advantage of AHP is that the group discussions offer insight in the question why the
endpoints are important.
PMH55
THE SUBJECTIVE WELL-BEING UNDER NEUROLEPTIC SCALE SHORT
FORM (SWN-K20) AND THE SF-36 AS QUALITY OF LIFE MEASURES IN
SCHIZOPHRENIC PATIENTS
Sanjuán J1, Haro J2, Maurino J3, Diez T4, Ballesteros J5
1
University of Valencia, CIBERSAM, Valencia, Spain; 2Parc Sanitari Sant Joan de Deu,
CIBERSAM, Sant Boi de Llobregat, Spain; 3AstraZeneca, Madrid, Spain; 4AstraZeneca,
Zaventem, Brussels, Belgium; 5University of the Basque Country, UPV/EHU, CIBERSAM,
Leioa, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Outcomes research in patients with schizophrenia should take into
account the subjective interpretation of the mood and physical changes accompanying
medication. Those changes influence the behavioural response to treatment and ultimately the patient’s clinical outcome as mediated by his treatment compliance. Our
aim was to assess the relationship between a specific well-being measure, the SWN-K20
that presents a general and 5 specific measurement subdomains (mental functioning,
social integration, emotional regulation, physical functioning, and self-control), and
the 8 domains of the SF-36 v1 as a general quality of life measure. METHODS: The
validation sample for this study comprised 97 patients diagnosed with schizophrenia
and who were rated as clinically stable at the moment of the study (1 week test-retest
intraclass correlation coefficient for clinical symptoms = 0.96). The patients were
recruited as part of a multicenter psychometric trial to validate the SWN-K20 in
Spanish. The associations between the domains of the SWN-K20 and the SF-36 were
evaluated by the Spearman’s rank correlation test. RESULTS: All correlations among
domains were positive and most were statistically significant (p < 0.05). As expected
the bodily pain domain of the SF-36 presented the lower correlations with the
SWN-K20 (rho range of 0.10 to 0.25), whereas the other 7 domains correlated significantly with the total SWN-K20 score (rho range 0.49 to 0.60, all p < 0.001).
Overall the largest correlations were obtained between the SWN-K20 and the SF-36
domains of general health (rho = 0.53), mental health (rho = 0.60), and vitality (rho
= 0.54). CONCLUSIONS: The positive but nevertheless moderate correlations
observed between a specific well-being scale, as the SWN-K20, and a general quality
of life scale, as the SF-36, supports the inclusion of specific and diagnose-tailored
instruments for outcome assessments of patients with schizophrenia.
PMH56
INNOVATIONS IN COMBINING PATIENT REPORTED OUTCOMES WITH
COGNITIVE TESTING DATA TO STREAMLINE AND LEVERAGE
REAL-TIME DATA COLLECTION
Curry C
PHT Corporation, Boston, MA, USA
OBJECTIVES: Understand features of an electronic device that allow a marked
improvement in the quality of collected data; the importance of improved data quality
leading to enhanced patient safety and drug labeling; populations best suited for paired
PRO and cognitive measurement technologies; important practical considerations for
implementation in clinical trials including training and compliance; the potential for
using real-time parallel data for adverse event safety monitoring. METHODS: This
session discusses using ePRO and biometric technology for parallel data capture
emphasizing advantages, disadvantages, execution, and ways to leverage these data.
The session will review PRO and cognitive testing technologies, including comparisons
of devices that combine physiological measures with a patient interface with systems
that use separate PRO input and biometric devices. RESULTS: Assessing a treatment’s
ability to enhance or prohibit reduction of cognitive processing efficiency is an emerging study in the pharmaceutical industry. Case studies examine how the use of cognitive function tests in combination with ePRO can enhance the data collection so drug
effects otherwise unidentified can be determined. The speaker will discuss the future
of ePRO combined with biometric measurements as a standard of clinical research.
CONCLUSIONS: Clinical trial endpoints can involve collection of physiologic and
patient-reported outcome data; a combination of subjective and objective data. Electronic forms of information capture assure trial efficiencies including edit checks and
shorter time to database lock. ePRO provides time-stamped, legible and complete data
from subjects. Biometric devices capture the physiological measurements. Typically,
cognition data have been collected from patients separately from PRO data during
clinical trials, increasing respondent burden and risk of error such as transposing
13th Euro Abstracts
manually entering data. The use of ePRO and biometric devices, evolution of data
transmission technology, and greater technologic sophistication of consumers, provide
an opportunity for parallel electronic data capture, simultaneously capturing and
transmitting physiologic and PRO parameters in clinical studies.
PMH57
REVIEW OF CO-MORBIDITY OF EATING AND BODY DYSMORPHIC
DISORDERS
Faragó E, Pakai A, Dér A, Oláh A, Boncz I, Németh K
University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: Our intention was to investigate the prevalence of Eating Disorder and
Body Dysmorphic Disorder in patients diaghnosed with depression, anxietay and
borderline personality disorder by gender, using controll groups. METHODS: The
reserach was 2009 at the Department of Phsyciatry of Szigetvár Hospital (Hungary).
Eating Disorder Inventory was used. a self-made questionnaire aimed the body mass,
body height and several demographic data. Inclusion criteria: ones between 18 and
50 years age, and according to BNO F32-F34 (depression), F41 (anxiety), F6030
(borderline personality disorder) diagnoses. Control group: participants with age
between 18 and 50 years like that, who do not stand under a psychiatric treatment.
The statistical analysis consisted of two sample T test, χ2-probe. RESULTS: The target
group’s number was 82, the control group 85. In the “The feeling of the insufficiency”
(P < 0.001), “Interpersonal distrust” (P < 0.005), “Interoceptive consciousness” (P <
0.001) scales, the members of the control group from all three psychiatric patient
groups reached a significantly lower score away. In the “Bulimia” scale there was a
significantly lower score in the control group as well than the borderline in a group
(P < 0.005), and here I found a significant difference between the members of two
psychiatric groups: the anxious group reached a lower score, compared with the
borderline group (P < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: The three psychiatric patient groups
did not attain the threshold value onto one of the eating disturbances relevant scales
neither There is not a direct, causal contact between the examined psychiatric clinical
pictures. The men’s higher result achieved on the „Bulimia” scale relates rather onto
the binge eating disorder.
PMH58
MODELING PROGRESSION IN DEMENTIA: ASSESSING THE
PERFORMANCE OF FIVE CLINICAL MEASURES IN SPANISH SUBJECTS
AND CAREGIVERS
Darba J1, Kaskens L2, Lacey L3, McLaughlin T4
1
Universitat de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain; 2BCN Health, Barcelona, Spain; 3JANSSEN
Alzheimer Immunotherapy, Dublin, Ireland; 4Alzheimer Immunotherapy Research &
Development, Dublin, Dublin, Ireland
OBJECTIVES: The primary objective of this analysis was to compare five different
clinical measures and their impact on economic modelling. Clinical measures compared are the Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE), the Cognitive Component
Score (CCS), the Functional Component Score (FCS) the Behaviour Component Score
(BCS), and the Dependence Scale (DS). METHODS: The MMSE, CCS, FCS, BCS and
DS were compared in their ability to explain variation in clinical outcomes, economicand other utilized resources, caregiver burden (Zarit Scale) and caregiver QoL
(EQ-5D) using univariate (Pearson correlations) and multivariate (linear regression)
analyses. Data on subjects and caregivers was obtained from multiple centres in Spain.
RESULTS: In total 394 subjects, males and females aged 50 to 93 years old with mild
cognitive impairment to severe dementia were included in this study. CCS, FCS, BCS
and DS were moderately correlated with MMSE, with Pearson correlations ranging
from −0.26 for BCS to −0.56 for CCS. These four clinical measures were also moderately correlated with medical costs, Zarit Scale and EQ-5D while MMSE was not.
These measures also performed better in explaining variation in medical costs, Zarit
Scale and caregivers’ EQ-5D. MMSE performed better explaining variation in the
number of concomitant conditions and caregiver time (hours per day). CONCLUSIONS: The CCS, FCS, BCS and DS are better predictors in modelling AD progression
on a higher number of variables including medical costs, caregivers’ burden and
caregivers QoL than the MMSE.
PMH59
EVALUATION OF THE EFFECT OF ARIPIPRAZOLE ON QUALITY OF
LIFE IN PATIENTS WITH SCHIZOPHRENIA IN A PROSPECTIVE,
MULTICENTRE, OPEN-LABEL STUDY
Bervoets C1, Constant E2, Sabbe B1, Morrens M1, Vansteelandt K3, De Patoul A4, Pitsi D5,
Halkin V6, Loze JY7, Peuskens J8
1
University Antwerp, Antwerp, Belgium; 2UC Louvain, Bruxelles, Belgium; 3KU LEUVEN,
Kortenberg, Belgium; 4BMS, Bruxelles, Belgium; 5BMS, Bruxxelles, Belgium; 6Bristol-Myers
Squibb, Braine-l’Alleud, Belgium; 7Otsuka Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd., Rueil-Malmaison, France;
8
KULeuven, Leuven, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: Aripiprazole has been claimed to have a beneficial effect on cognition
with an emphasis on verbal functioning in schizophrenic patients. a prospective,
multicenter, open-label study of Aripiprazole was set to evaluate the effect on quality
of life, in relation to illness severity and cognitive functioning of a treatment with
aripiprazole in schizophrenic patients. METHODS: A total of 363 schizophrenic
patients from 18 to 65 years, treated with different typical and atypical antipsychotics
or had no previous treatment, were switched to aripiprazole after a 2 week washout
period. Quality of life was assessed by use of the Quality of Life Enjoyment and
Satisfaction Questionnaire (QLESQ) at 3 separate test moments in a 12 weeks period.
A457
13th Euro Abstracts
At the same time, verbal cognitive function was assessed with the California Verbal
Learning Test (CVLT) and the Verbal Fluency test (VF). The Clinical Global Impression-Severity (CGI-S) was assessed as well at the same visits. Statistical analysis was
done using SAS 9.2 with the PROC MIXED module for mixed effects repeated measures analysis. RESULTS: A mixed models analyses on the QLESQ scores showed
significant effects for CGI-S in all subscores but “ school “ (p = 0,1485) and for the
verbal cognitive measures only in subscores “leisure “ for CVLT-LTFR (p = 0,0002).
CONCLUSIONS: The observed difference over time in QLESQ values is dependent
on the CGI-S score which contributes mostly to the prediction of the QLESQ outcome.
Verbal cognitive outcome was not predictive . These findings are not in agreement
with other publications reporting an independent contribution of both measures on
quality of life. As the study was open-label, interpretation of the results should be
approached with some caution.
PMH60
QUALITY: A NON-INTERVENTIONAL STUDY EVALUATING QUALITY
OF LIFE IN SCHIZOPHRENIC PATIENTS TREATED WITH ATYPICAL
ANTIPSYCHOTICS, IN THE AMBULATORY SETTING. A 9-MONTH,
OBSERVATIONAL, MULTICENTRIC PROSPECTIVE STUDY
Peuskens J1, Tomas M2
1
University Psychiatric Centre Catholic University Leuven, Kortenberg, Belgium; 2AstraZeneca
Belgium, Brussels, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: The QUALITY study evaluated Quality-of-Life in schizophrenic
patients treated with atypical antipsychotics (AAPs) in the ambulatory setting.
METHODS: Patients (18–65 years-old) diagnosed with schizophrenia and had started
treatment with one AAP before visit-1 (minimum: 4-weeks, maximum: 8-weeks) were
enrolled into this Belgian study. At visit-1 patients’ demographics and medical history
were recorded with follow-up visits after 3-, 6- and 9-months. At each visit, patients
completed the Subjective Well-being under Neuropletic treatment short form (SWNK), while investigators assessed the Positive and Negative Symptom Scale (PANSS-8)
and the Global Assessment of Functioning (GAF). RESULTS: A total of 121 patients
(mean age 36.7 ± 10.8, 75.2% male) were enrolled with the main AAP treatments
risperidone (31.4%), apripirazole (23.1%), quetiapine (20.7%). At baseline, the associations between the SWN-K subscales and age, gender, positive/negative PANSSscores, Schizophrenia-subtype or treatment-subgroups were small. Mental-functioning
and physical-functioning subscales were significantly correlated with negative PANSSscores, as was the emotional-regulation subscale with gender. The majority of changes
from baseline in the SWN-K subscale scores were between −0.5 and +0.5 (range: −1.8
to 1.6). Most mean changes were positive, suggesting that patients felt better compared
to baseline. PANSS-8-score changes were slightly negative, suggesting decreases in
symptom severity. 57.5% of patients showed symptom remission (PANSS-8-score ≤
3 after 6 months-of-treatment).GAF scores increased (study end: 8.2 ± 16.0) indicating
improvement in the patient’s global functioning. By the study end, the number of
hospitalizations and addictive substance use had decreased. Patients with more severe
negative symptoms considered their mental- and physical-functioning better and men
were more satisfied than women with their emotional-regulation. Few patients had
sufficient disease insight; most patients had a vague notion or did not see that they
were ill. CONCLUSIONS: The patients’ well-being seemed to improve slightly during
the study without differences between the treatments. Patients having more severe
negative symptoms considered their mental and physical functioning better at the
study end.
PMH61
PRODUCTIVITY LOSS AMONG PATIENTS WITH MOOD DISORDERS
1
1
2
2
1
Bouwmans C , Rutten F , François C , Danchenko N , Hakkaart-van Roijen L
1
Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands; 2Lundbeck SAS, Issy-lesMoulineaux, France
OBJECTIVES: Mood disorders are generally associated with a high level of productivity loss and a substantial economic burden. The aim of this study was to measure the
impact of mood disorders on productivity in terms of absence from work, at-work
productivity loss, and job performance among patients in the The Netherlands.
METHODS: Patients meeting DSM-IV criteria for depressive disorder, dysthymic
disorder, panic disorder (with or without agoraphobia), social phobia and generalised
anxiety disorder were included from a large naturalistic trial in 7 Dutch mental health
care centres. The short form of the Health and Labour Questionnaire (SF-HLQ) was
used to assess absenteeism (days absent from work), presenteeism (at-work productivity loss) and job performance (on a 3-point scale ranging from ‘not impeded’ to ‘very
much impeded’). ANOVA analyses and t-tests were performed to explore differences
between socio-demographic groups. RESULTS: Of the total 702 patients, two thirds
were in paid employment. Over 3 months, 55% reported long-term absenteeism (>2
weeks), with a mean of 73 work days lost per patient, and 13% patients reported a
shorter-term absenteeism (<2 weeks), with a mean of 33 work days lost per patient.
Women were absent from work for a longer (99 days) than men (46 days) (P < 0.005).
Presenteeism accounted for a 12% productivity loss in terms of working time lost.
The number of days at work while impeded by health problems was numerically
higher in men than in women (7.4 vs. 5.6, p > 0.05). Overall, 31% of the patients
had difficulties in job performance when at work. CONCLUSIONS: Mood disorders
are associated with impairment of patients’ productivity in terms of absence from
work, presenteeism and difficulties in job performance The study demonstrated a
tendency towards lower absenteeism and higher presenteeism in men compared to
women.
MENTAL HEALTH – Health Care Use & Policy Studies
PMH62
TRENDS IN ANTIDEPRESSANTS AND ANXIOLYTICS DRUG USAGE IN
CROATIA AND SLOVENIA
Vitezic D1, Kucan M2, Vitezic M3, Mrsic Pelcic J4
1
University of Rijeka Medical School and University Hospital Centre Rijeka, Rijeka, Croatia;
2
JADRAN Galenski laboratorij, Rijeka, Croatia; 3University of Rijeka Medical School and
Orthopedic Hospital Lovran, Lovran, Croatia; 4University of Rijeka, Rijeka, Croatia
OBJECTIVES: The objective of this study is to analyze antidepressants and anxiolytics
drugs usage (ATC subgroups: N06A and N05B) in two mid European, neighbouring
countries, Croatia and Slovenia, for the 9-year period, from 2000 to 2008. Further,
the aim was to identify the generic drugs usage in each country, the price for DDD
for original and generic drugs, and to identify the most prescribed drugs in each drug
group. METHODS: The data have been obtained from the International Medical
Statistics database for Croatia and Slovenia. Drugs usage is presented in defined daily
doses per 1000 inhabitants per day (DDD/1000) according to the WHO Methodology.
Financial expenditure data are presented in Euros. An average cost per DDD was
calculated for each drug group. RESULTS: In 2008, the total usage of antidepressants
was higher in Slovenia (42.7 DDD/1000 inhabitants/day) than in Croatia (22
DDD/1000 inhabitants/day), and it increased in both countries during the investigated
period. The total usage of anxiolytics is more than 3 times higher in Croatia (67.4
DDD/1000 inhabitants/day) than in Slovenia (22.2 DDD/1000/inhabitants/day). The
total usage of anxiolytics decreased in Slovenia in 2008 in comparison with prescriptions in 2000, while it increased in Croatia for 44.3% during the same period. The
rate of generic prescriptions among antidepressants during the investigated period was
higher in Croatia, i.e. in Croatia 73.6% of all prescribed antidepressants were generics
in 2008, while in Slovenia 33.5%. CONCLUSIONS: Drugs prescription patterns are
different comparing Croatia and Slovenia. a possible reason for relatively higher usage
of anxiolytics and lower usage of antidepressants in Croatia could be depression
treatment with anxiolytics. This indicates the need for a more thorough analysis and
the introduction of national drugs guidelines for rational prescribing, monitoring and
evaluation especially anxiolytics. Although the generic drugs usage in the mentioned
groups is relatively high, it should be further supported and promoted.
PMH63
ANTIPSYCHOTIC PRESCRIBING TO THE ELDERLY: A TWO-YEAR
COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS
Truter I
Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University (NMMU), Port Elizabeth, Eastern Cape, South
Africa
OBJECTIVES: Antipsychotic medicines are commonly prescribed to elderly patients.
These patients are at an increased risk of adverse drug events because of age-related
pharmacodynamic and pharmacokinetic changes. The primary aim of the study was
to determine antipsychotic prescribing patterns and cost to patients aged 60 years and
older in a private health care sector primary care patient population in 2008 and 2009.
METHODS: A retrospective, exposure-cohort drug utilization study was conducted
on prescription data of a pharmacy group in South Africa for 2008 and 2009. No
diagnoses were available. All records for antipsychotics (MIMS category 1.5) for
patients 60 years and older were extracted for analysis. RESULTS: A total of 1 800
patients in 2008 and 3 086 patients in 2009 received 7 877 and 14 538 antipsychotic
products at a sales value of R2 785 896 and R4 928 127, respectively. The average cost
per antipsychotic product was R353.67 in 2008 and R338.98 in 2009. Most patients
were female (61.78% in 2008 and 57.87% in 2009). Tablets were the preferred dosage
form. Risperidone (37.55% in 2008, and 38.20% in 2009), quetiapine (27.56% and
28.88%) and olanzapine (10.91% and 10.24%) together accounted for more than
75% of antipsychotics prescribed to the elderly. a high percentage of atypical antipsychotics (84.23% in 2008 and 85.14% in 2009) were prescribed. Differences were
observed between 2008 and 2009 with respect to the prescribing frequency of the
atypical antipsychotics (chi2 = 32.624; d.f. = 6; p < 0.0001). CONCLUSIONS: Prescribing patterns were relatively similar in both years. The dosages and duration of
treatment of antipsychotics should be investigated in relation to the diagnoses for
which they are prescribed. It is recommended that diagnoses be included in databases
and also that qualitative studies be conducted to determine possible side effects experienced by patients.
PMH64
HEALTH CARE ORGANIZATIONS/SERVICES CLUSTERING: EXAMPLE OF
PCTS IN ENGLAND
Millier A1, Toumi M2, Lamure M3, Aballea S1, Flostrand S1, Hansen K4
1
Creativ Ceutical, Paris, France; 2University Claude Bernard Lyon 1, Lyon, Rhone Alpes,
France; 3University Claude Berard Lyon 1, Villeurbanne, Rhone Alpes, France; 4Lundbeck
SAS, Issy-les-Moulineaux cedex, France
OBJECTIVES: England has 152 Primary Care Trust (PCT) each having its own
characteristics, and prescription patterns. As a consequence, PCT formulary lists
differ, creating an additional hurdle for patient access to innovative medicines, often
referred to as the post-code lottery. The objective of this study was to segment these
PCTs in groups with homogeneous attitudes towards patient access for innovative
drugs in Mental Health (MH) using a clustering analysis. METHODS: We collected
all available information about the PCTs through public sources and the OneKey +
database. We identified 62 variables per PCT and classified them in 5 groups: profile
A458
of population, economic & financial information, organization, prescription pattern
and patient management. We first ran a principal component analysis on quantitative
variables and then a multiple correspondence analysis on qualitative variables, in order
to get individuals coordinates of PCTs on several axes on which they were projected.
We then merged the results, and ran an analysis to create PCTs clusters. RESULTS:
We identified 5 clusters of PCTs with differentiated, homogeneous attitude towards
innovative drugs. Cluster 1 focused on MH disorders with GP-level decision-making,
cluster 2 focused on MH disorders and contained high-prescribing physicians, cluster
3 had low recognition of MH disorders, cluster 4 had low recognition but offered a
high level of care while cluster 5 was focused on cost containment. The clusters also
varied in population size from 1.2 M to 23.9 M. CONCLUSIONS: As this work was
rather innovative it was validated by local pharmaceutical sales and marketing organization. The cluster approach proposed was endorsed by account managers’ pragmatic experience in the field and correlated well with their experience of obtaining
access for their innovative MH drugs. This study helped to improve our understanding
of the UK landscape in patient access for innovative drugs in MH.
PMH65
EFFECTIVENESS OF PHARMACEUTICAL THERAPY OF ADHD
(ATTENTION-DEFICIT/HYPERACTIVITY DISORDER) IN ADULTS—A
HEALTH TECHNOLOGY ASSESSMENT
Benkert D1, Krause KH2, Wasem J3, Aidelsburger P1
1
CAREM GmbH, Sauerlach, Germany; 2Ludwig Maximilian University, Munich, Germany;
3
University of Duisburg-Essen, Essen, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) is a neurobehavioral
developmental disorder, that is characterized by hyperactivity and impulse control
disorder. In Germany pharmaceutical therapy is approved for children and adolescents
solely. Therefore, treating adult patients with ADHD complies with off-label use of
stimulants. Aim of this Health Technology Assessment is to examine the clinical
effectiveness, cost-effectiveness, ethical-social and legal aspects of pharmacotherapy
(stimulants, antidepressants, norepinephrine reputake inhibitors) of adult ADHD
patients. METHODS: A systematic literature research is conducted in relevant electronic literature databases. Studies matching the ex ante defined inclusion criteria are
assessed systematically and qualitatively according to methodical standards by two
reviewers. Due to heterogeneity of included studies no meta-analysis is performed.
RESULTS: Nine randomised controlled trials (RCT), five systematic reviews, three
economic and two studies concerning legal aspects are included. All RCT show
improvement regarding ADHD symptoms (hyperactivity, impulsivity). Response rates
vary between 7 % and 42 % in the control group and 17 % to 59,6 % in the intervention group. The studies use primarily investigator and self-rated questionnaires
such as the ADHD Rating Scale, the Conners Scales and the Clinical Global Impression
as outcome parameters for the core symptoms of ADHD. Some studies show a larger
improvement of the ADHD symptoms by a flexible dose approach. The systematic
reviews demonstrate statistically significant improvement in symptoms of ADHD
compared to placebo and other medications. The effect sizes for stimulants are somewhat higher than for non-stimulants. Adult ADHD patients cause higher annual direct
and indirect costs than matched controls. The average medical costs are reported with
1.262 US-Dollar in 1998 and 1.673 US-Dollar in 2001. CONCLUSIONS: Methodological limitations of the RCT are the short study duration and the high drop-out
rates. Further research is needed to determine the cost-effectiveness of medical treatment of adult ADHD patients.
PMH66
PREVALENCE OF AFFECTIVE DISORDERS IN SOUTH-WEST REGION OF
SWEDEN
Löfroth E, Myrén KJ, Bruce S, Dahlberg E
IMS Health, Stockholm, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: To determine the prevalence of affective disorders (section F3 in
ICD-10) in South-West region of Sweden. METHODS: This was a retrospective
longitudinal descriptive database study of the utilization of health care of patients
from the South-West region of Sweden (1.5 million inhabitants). All patients who were
diagnosed with affective disorders between 2001 and 2007 in the South-West region
of Sweden were included in the study. The patients were diagnosed in primary-, in- and
out-patient care. RESULTS: A total of 138,194 patients were diagnosed with at least
one type of affective disorder. This corresponded to a prevalence of 9% in the population of South-West region in Sweden. 89 percent (123,524 patients) of the total sample
were diagnosed with major depressive disorder (F32) followed by recurrent depressive
disorder (F33) at 14% (19,944 patients). Bipolar affective disorder (F31) was diagnosed in 5% of the patients (6932) and unspecified mood (affective) disorder (F39)
was diagnosed in 4% of the patients (5,431). The prevalence of the different diagnoses
were 8 percent for depressive episode, 1 percent for recurrent depressive disorder, 0.5
percent for bipolar affective disorder, 0.4% for unspecified mood (affective) disorder.
CONCLUSIONS: Depressive episode was by far the most common of the affective
disorders diagnosed, with a prevalence of 8 percent. a question remains whether the
prevalence for bipolar is underestimated as this study found it to be 0.5%. The
expected prevalence for bipolar disorder is 1 percent of the population. One plausible
explanation could be that bipolar patients are classified with other codes than F31 in
the South-West region of Sweden.
13th Euro Abstracts
PMH67
FACTORS ASSOCIATED WITH ANTIPSYCHOTICS USE AMONG
COMMUNITY-DWELLING OLDER PERSONS WITH DEMENTIA
Rhee Y1, Shega J2, Csernansky J1
1
Northwestern University, Chicago, IL, USA; 2University of Chicago, Chicago, IL, USA
OBJECTIVES: Despite the use of antipsychotics to treat dementia patients, the efficacy
of the treatment is not well established. We examine factors associated with antipsychotics use among community-dwelling older persons with dementia. METHODS:
We used data from The Aging, Demographics, and Memory Study (ADAMS) to assess
dementia severity and service use from 2002 to 2004. We used logistic regressions to
identify factors associated with antipsychotic use; N = 307. RESULTS: Among older
persons with dementia living in community (weighted sample = 207,544), 7.8%
(weighted sample = 16,272) took any antipsychotic medications; 69.1% were female,
70.7% were white, and 21.8% were African American. The average age was 85 years.
Physical functions were measured by the number of ADL (average. 2.9) and number
of IADL (mean 3.6). The most frequent primary diagnoses were Alzheimer’s disease
(74.3%), vascular dementia (16.0%) and other dementia (9.8%).The most frequently
prescribed antipsychotics were: risperidone (58.0%), quetiapine (15.4%), and haloperidol (7.7%). Of those taking an antipsychotic, 86.0% were diagnosed with
Alzheimer’s dementia. We used the Neuropsychiatry Inventory (NPI) for behavior
problems (delusions, hallucinations, agitation/aggression, depression, apathy, elation,
anxiety, disinhibition, irritability/lability, and aberrant motor behavior). We evaluated
severity of dementia using the Clinical Dementia Rating Scale (CDR).Communitydwelling older persons with dementia are significantly more likely to receive antipsychotics if they were agitated (OR = 3.4, P < 0.05), had disinhibition (OR = 4.6, P <
0.05), or had greater dementia severity (OR = 1.9, P < 0.01). Also, Medicaid recipients
were significantly more likely to receive antipsychotic medications (OR = 5.4, P <
0.01). Participants were significantly less likely to be medicated with antipsychotics if
they had vascular dementia (OR = 0.09, P < 0.05) or the caregivers were clinically
depressed (OR = 0.2, P < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: Community-dwelling older persons
with dementia are more likely to receive antipsychotics if caregivers report behavior
problems, the dementia is more advanced, and the patient has Medicaid coverage.
Persons with vascular dementia are less likely to be treated with antipsychotics.
PMH68
TREATMENT DISCONTINUATION IN A LOCAL MENTAL HEALTH CARE
SYSTEM IN GERMANY FROM THE PATIENTS’ AND HEALTH CARE
PROVIDERS’ PERSPECTIVE
Pueschner F1, Diewald V2, Schoul A3, Fleischmann J1
1
Janssen-Cilag Germany, Neuss, Germany; 2Rhein Kreis Neuss, Neuss, Germany;
3
YouGovPsychonomics, Cologne, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Treatment discontinuation in psychiatric care is a major cause for the
deterioration of mental health problems. This study assessed reasons for treatment
discontinuation of patients suffering from schizophrenia or depression in a local
mental health care system in Germany. METHODS: A retrospective survey was performed to assess how coordination of care through mental health care providers in
the Rhein-Kreis-Neuss region (Germany) is organized. Within this survey reasons for
treatment discontinuation were explored from the perspective of providers and
patients. 88 providers of care (60 institutions) and 30 patients diagnosed with schizophrenia and 17 patients diagnosed with major depression were interviewed using indepth face-to-face interviews. Additionally providers were qualitatively interviewed
on strategies to prevent discontinuations. RESULTS: Providers were asked to rank
pre-specified reasons for treatment discontinuation according to their occurrence
(often, occasionally, seldom, never). 38.8 % ranked non-adherence to medication as
often, 38.1 % waiting times for next treatment. 25.6 % identified problems in the
patient’s social environment as being often a reason for treatment discontinuation,
23.7 % mentioned revolving doors effects, 19.3 % resistance to therapy and 12.3 %
lack of communication between providers. Patients diagnosed with schizophrenia
(mean age 45 years; mean duration of illness 16 years) and depression (mean age 45
years; mean duration of illness 13 years) indicated that they consider discontinuation
or actually discontinue treatment when there is a lack of social integration or when
there is no reaction of providers to articulated problems with treatments. In response
to an open question on suggestions for improvement, providers recommended better
cross-sectoral coordination, earlier start of treatment and early return to normal daily
living as appropriate measures. CONCLUSIONS: From the subjective perspective of
providers and patients a variety of causes seem to influence treatment discontinuation.
More research into specific interventions to improve treatment adherence is needed.
PMH69
INFLUENCE OF WAITING TIME IN A LOCAL MENTAL HEALTH CARE
SYSTEM IN GERMANY FOR CARE IN PATIENTS DIAGNOSED WITH
SCHIZOPHRENIA OR DEPRESSION
Fleischmann J1, Diewald V2, Schoul A3, Pueschner F1
1
Janssen-Cilag Germany, Neuss, Germany; 2Rhein Kreis Neuss, Neuss, Germany;
3
YouGovPsychonomics, Cologne, Germany
OBJECTIVES: To assess if patients suffering from schizophrenia or depression are
affected by waiting times for the next treatment in a mental health care system in
Germany. METHODS: Aa retrospective survey was performed to assess coordination
of care through providers engaged in the care for patients with schizophrenia or major
depression in the Rhein-Kreis-Neuss region (Germany). One parameter for evaluating
quality of coordination is the occurrence of waiting times, emerging when patients are
A459
13th Euro Abstracts
transferred from one point of care to the next with treatment continuation potentially
being delayed. 88 providers of care (60 institutions), 30 patients diagnosed with
schizophrenia and 17 patients diagnosed with depression were surveyed through indepth interviews. The total number of questions was 56 for providers, and 54 questions for patients. RESULTS: A total of 56% of patients diagnosed with schizophrenia
(mean age 45 years, mean duration of illness 16 years) experience waiting times when
transferred to an outpatient rehabilitation center, 50% while being transferred to an
institution of assisted working or to a place of sheltered living (33%). Patients diagnosed with major depression (mean age 45 years; mean duration of illness 13 years)
experience waiting times when transferred to an institution of assisted working (63%),
to an outpatient rehabilitation center (57%) or to a psychotherapist (56%). Providers
experience waiting times when they transfer patients to psychotherapists (55%). a
total of 40% of patients diagnosed with schizophrenia and 58% of patients diagnosed
with major depression perceive waiting times as heavily constraining, affecting their
treatment and care, and potentially leading to a setback in their treatment progress.
Providers see capacity constraints as main reason for waiting times. CONCLUSIONS:
This study describes waiting times in coordination of mental health care between
different providers as a problem. Potential negative effects on treatment success show
the need for optimization.
MENTAL HEALTH – Conceptual Papers & Research on Methods
PMH70
TURKISH CULTURAL ADAPTATION AND VALIDATION OF THE
ALCOHOL DEPENDENCE SCALE
Malhan S, Oksuz E, Yilmaz F, Tekin R, Baytar S
Baskent University, Ankara, Turkey
OBJECTIVES: The Alcohol Dependence Scale (ADS) is a quantitative measure of the
severity of alcohol dependence consistent with the concept of the alcohol dependence
syndrome. The 25 items cover alcohol withdrawal symptoms, impaired control over
drinking, awareness of a compulsion to drink, increased tolerance to alcohol, and
salience of drink-seeking behavior. This study aims to adapt the ADS questionnaire
into Turkish culture and check the reliability and validity of the questionnaire culturally. METHODS: The original instrument was translated and back translated by two
independent translators. For psychometric measures, a small sample was used to check
the initial comprehension and factibility. Cronbach’s Alfa was used to assess reliability
and factor analysis to assess dimensionality. The EuroQol questionnaire and corresponding Visual Analogue Scales were used for concurrent validity. RESULTS: A total
of 200 students between the ages of 19–28 were participated in the study. Mean age
was 22. The internal consistency coefficient (Cronbach’s alpha) of ADS was 0.92.
Factor analysis of the scale revealed that it was composed of six factors with Eigenvalues >1.0, accounting for 74 % of the total variance. Correlations were moderate
with EuroQol and VAS. CONCLUSIONS: The culturally adapted Alcohol Dependence Scale has good validity and reliability. The instrument is likely to be suitable
for the evaluation of alcohol dependence of people in Turkey.
PMH71
THE APPLICABILITY OF THE QALY AS EFFECT MEASURE IN CRIMINAL
YOUTHS
Schawo S, Hakkaart L
Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, Zuid Holland, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: In health economics, cost-effectiveness analyses are performed based
on standardized established methods expressing outcomes in terms of costs per quality-adjusted life-year (QALY). In the field of care for criminal youth, interventions are
increasingly drawn into the medical domain and towards reimbursement protocols so
that a common cost-effectiveness measure becomes a necessity. However, cost-effectiveness of these interventions has so far not been expressed in terms of cost per QALY,
but in terms of clinical measures. The aim of this study is to explore the applicability
of the QALY as effect measure of interventions for criminal youth. METHODS: The
112 juvenile delinquents between 12 and 18 years included in this study were recruited
at the start of Functional Family Therapy (FFT) from five mental health institutions
in The Netherlands. Treatment efficacy was assessed using clinical outcome measures
SDQ, YSR, CBCL, and PACS. Quality of life was measured using EuroQol EQ-5D.
Data was analyzed to determine whether quality of life and clinical outcome measures
show a significant correlation. Dutch population EQ-5D data was consulted to determine whether EQ-5D sufficiently captures differences between criminal and noncriminal groups. RESULTS: Comparison between groups of criminal and non-criminal
youths yielded no significant differences for juvenile delinquents or their parents.
Correlation between several clinical outcome measures and EQ-5D scores of delinquent youths has been found suggesting that EQ-5D captures some differences in
criminal behaviour. CONCLUSIONS: The study confirms the expected correlation
between several classical forensic effect measures and general health economics outcomes, but several aspects were not reflected by the QALY. Furthermore, the QALY
measure insufficiently distinguishes between criminal and non criminal groups. We
suggest further research before considering the application of the QALY as an effect
measure for delinquent youths.
PMH73
IMPACT OF PLACEBO RUN-IN PERIOD ON RELATIVE TREATMENT
EFFECT IN GENERALIZED ANXIETY DISORDER (GAD)
Sharma R, Arora M, Ubhadiya B
Heron Health Private Ltd, Chandigarh, India
BACKGROUND: High placebo response is observed in trials measuring subjective
outcomes as in the case of GAD. This contributes to investigational drug failure owing
to lack of differentiation between intervention and control group. Placebo run-in is
frequently used to eliminate early responders however this has been criticised on the
ground that it favours the active treatment. OBJECTIVES: To test the hypothesis that
“The use of placebo run-in overestimates the treatment effect in placebo-controlled
trials conducted in GAD”. METHODS: The Medline and EMBASE databases were
searched to retrieve randomised, placebo-controlled trials conducted in adult GAD
patients. Citations were screened on the basis of title and abstract and full text article
of citations meeting eligibility criteria were sourced for detailed evaluation. Following
this, citations reporting relevant outcomes were extracted using a pre-defined extraction grid. Clinically relevant dichotomous outcomes: CGI-Improvement response,
HAM-A response, and HAM-A remission were extracted. Considering heterogeneity
among studies included, the random effects meta-analysis was performed in STATA
9.0 using a standard meta-analysis approach. Results are presented as odds ratios with
a 95% confidence interval. RESULTS: The literature search retrieved 1133 citations
of which 41 were included following detailed evaluation (23 used placebo run-in
phase). The point estimate for the relative treatment effect was similar (confidence
interval overlap widely) irrespective of the use of placebo run-in phase (OR: 2.13 with
run-in vs. 2.19 without run-in). Results were similar when individual outcomes were
analyzed separately (HAM-A response OR: 2.17 vs. 2.14; CGI-I response OR: 2.20
vs. 2.13; HAM-A remission OR: 1.98 vs. 2.05). CONCLUSIONS: Irrespective of
outcomes considered, there was no statistically significant difference in the effect size
between trials involving placebo run-in phase compared to those that did not. Our
results do not support the hypothesis that the inclusion of placebo run-in overestimates
the relative treatment effect in GAD.
SYSTEMIC DISORDERS/CONDITIONS – Clinical Outcomes Studies
PSY1
DEVELOPMENT OF A CO-MORBIDITY SCALE IN PATIENTS WITH
CHRONIC LYMPHOCYTIC LEUKEMIA
Carbonell F1, De La Serna J2, Giraldo P3, Lopez A4, Rios E5, Perulero N6, Castro-Gomez AJ7
1
Consorci Hospital General Universitari Valencia, Valencia, Spain; 2Hospital Universitario 12
de Octubre, Madrid, Spain; 3Hospital Universitario Miguel Servet, Zaragoza, Spain; 4Hospital
Universitari Vall d’Hebron, Barcelona, Spain; 5Hospital Virgen de Valme, Sevilla, Spain; 6IMS
Health, Barcelona, Spain, 7Roche Spain, Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: The study aimed to develop a standardized scale for co-morbidity
assessment in Chronic Lymphocytic Leukaemia (CLL) patients to support physicians
for selecting the optimal treatment according to the patient co-morbidity profile.
METHODS: The co-morbidity scale was developed in four steps: a literature review
to assess the existence of other scales and define the scale content; consensus meetings
with five CLL experts to determine the content, format and weighting factor for each
co-morbidity; a pilot study of 10 CLL patients to assess the scale feasibility; a meeting
to agree the final version RESULTS: The literature review did not identify any existing
scale but six papers related to assessment of CLL co-morbidities were selected. These
allowed the initial selection of 21 diseases. In the expert meeting, the scale was reduced
to 13 co-morbidities, with major impact on CLL treatment selection. Some additional
variables (age, patient dependence and ECOG performance status) were added. Subsequently, the final list of co-morbidities. variables and response options were agreed.
The experts applied a weight factor to each co-morbidity, from 1 (minimal importance) to 3 (very important). a pilot study of 10 patients, using an electronic version
of the scale, resulted in some changes but confirmed the scale’s feasibility. The final
scale includes three sections. Part 1, the Functional Vital Scale, and a global assessment
of the patient (not included in the global score). Part 2, the Co-morbidity scale, including 11 co-morbidities weighted from 0 to 2 and scored from 0 (absence) to 2 (severe
co-morbidity). Part 3, CLL alerts, is descriptive and includes the presence of splenectomy and hypogammaglobulinemia. CONCLUSIONS: The co-morbidity scale is a
tool to support the clinician in the selection of the optimal treatment for CLL patients.
Further research is required to validate the scale and assess its benefits.
PSY2
THE USE OF ETANERCEPT FOR TREATMENT OF PSORIASIS IN REAL
CLINICAL PRACTICE—NON-INTERVENTION OBSERVATIONAL STUDY
Dolezal T1, Klimes J2
1
Institute for Health Economics and Technology Assessment, Prague, Czech Republic;
2
Charles University, Faculty of Pharmacy, Hradec Kralove, Czech Republic
OBJECTIVES: Biologic treatment for severe forms of psoriasis proved to be effective
and safety treatment in clinical trials. However, these drugs comprise a great financial
burden. Therefore, we examined etanercept for treatment of severe forms of psoriasis
in real clinical practice. METHODS: This was a prospective cohort non-interventional
study of phase IV in real clinical practice which included 149 patients enrolled for 6
months. Patients’ data were collected via electronic questionnaire. Clinical data (PASI
score and BSA index), direct cost (inpatient and outpatient care, diagnostics, joint
replacement etc.) and on QoL (expressed with EQ-5D and DLQI) were collected by
A460
dermatologists. Results were evaluated in months 0, 3 and 6 of etanercept treatment.
RESULTS: Average patients’ age was 46.74 years (21–75 years), average time from
diagnosis was 24.5 years. Occurrence of psoriatic arthritis was 31.7%. 14.6% of
patients were work disabled and 16.3% reported incapacity to work with average
duration of 44.3 days in previous 6 months. Previous biologic treatment: 46.6% of
patients were naive, 16.8% were after previous failure and 36.5% were after successfully finished treatment with biologics within 6 previous months. Within the observation in 0, 3 and 6 months BSA index decreased from 27.12 to 18.64 to 11.47% and
PASI score from 13.69 to 8.09 to 4.97. Utility measured according to EQ-5D increased
from 0.7674 to 0.8344 and 0.859 and DLQI index decreased from 10.74 to 6.33 and
4.24 in months 0, 3 and 6. Percentage of patients required inpatient care decreased
from 25.8 to 5.0 to 0.66%, additionally average length of stay had shortened from
15.9 to 11 days. CONCLUSIONS: Significant clinical effect was observed within 3
and 6 months of etanercept treatment. QoL was increased in vast majority of patients.
Treatment with etanercept decreased other costs associated with psoriasis—inpatient
care (frequency and length).
PSY3
CLINICAL AND ECONOMIC OUTCOMES OF ZICONOTIDE
NEUROMODULATION IN ITALIAN CANCER PATIENTS
Zaniolo O1, Carsi M1, Bellini R2
1
Adres srl, Torino, Italy; 2Ospedale Santo Spirito—Casale Monferrato, Casale Monferrato,
Italy
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the cost/effectiveness of ziconotide for the spinal neuromodulation of cancer pain in real clinical practice, from the third payer point of view.
METHODS: Clinical and resources consumption data related to intrathecal neuromodulation for severe complex pain in progressing cancer patients followed by one
Italian centre were collected. The observation spanned from implantation to exitus or
drop-out. Change in Numeric Rating Scale Pain Intensity (NRSPI) is the primary
outcome of the analysis and the base of the evaluation of number of days with controlled pain (at least 30% reduction). Secondary outcome measures are Karnofsky
index, Pain Management Index, Edmonton Symptom Assessment Scale score and
Bowel Function Index. Collected consumption data include drugs, visits, port maintenance, and pump recharge and amortization. Current Italian prices, real practice
acquisition and remuneration costs are applied. RESULTS: Between January 2006 and
August 2009, 19 patients received intrathecal ziconotide (N: 8) or morphine (N: 11).
Both groups showed a statistically significant reduction in NRSPI score after 1 week
(Z:−33,9% vs. M:−10,6%), 2 weeks (Z:−47,9% vs. M:−22,1%), and 3 weeks (Z:−
52,1% vs. M:−26,1%) from implantation, with markedly higher reductions in
ziconotide patients, although the difference was statistically significant only for the
first time point. Patients receiving ziconotide lived significantly more days with controlled pain (74% vs. 40%; P < 0,05). Secondary endpoints showed similar trends.
Average weekly cost is about c240 for ziconotide and c120 for morphine; the main
cost driver is pharmaceutical cost (respectively 82% and 65% of the total). Higher
ziconotide acquisition costs are partially offset by minor expenses for adjuvant therapies. The incremental cost for one further day with controlled pain resulted of c50.
CONCLUSIONS: Ziconotide permits effective treatment of extremely difficult-tomanage pain, with improvement of the tolerability and a mild increment of cost, as
compared to intrathecal therapy without ziconotide.
PSY4
BIOLOGICAL AGENTS FOR THE TREATMENT OF NAIL PSORIASIS: A
SYSTEMATIC REVIEW OF THE LITERATURE
Naci H1, Green J2, Prasad M3, Fleurence R4
1
United BioSource Corporation, London, UK; 2United BioSource Corporation, Lexington,
MA, USA; 3Merck & Co, Kenilworth, NJ, USA; 4United BioSource Corporation, Bethesda,
MD, USA
OBJECTIVES: To systematically review the efficacy of biologics for nail psoriasis in
plaque psoriasis and psoriatic arthritis. METHODS: MEDLINE and EMBASE were
searched using predefined terms: “psoriasis”, “psoriatic arthritis”, “parapsoriasis”,
“psoriasis vulgaris”, “infliximab”, “adalimumab”, “alefacept”, “etanercept”, “golimumab”, and “ustekinumab”. Abstracts from ISPOR, AAD, BAD, EADV, WCD, and
EULAR from 2006 to 2009 were reviewed. Studies reporting both comparative and
non-comparative findings from at least one biologic of interest were included if they
reported the nail psoriasis severity index score (NAPSI), resolution, or remission.
RESULTS: Thirteen studies were included. Golimumab and infliximab were assessed
in randomized controlled trials (RCTs). In a RCT of infliximab, the % reduction
(indicating improvement) from baseline NAPSI was significantly greater with infliximab than with placebo at weeks 10 and 24, with the reduction maintained at 50
weeks. a similar response through 24 weeks was observed in a RCT of golimumab,
in which reductions from baseline NAPSI increased over time, from 14 to 24 weeks.
The third comparative study evaluated adalimumab, etanercept, and infliximab in an
observational study, favoring infliximab. The remaining studies reported findings for
single-arms and examined infliximab (3 studies), alefacept (3 studies), adalimumab (3
studies), and etanercept (1 study). At follow-up periods ranging from 12 to 72 weeks,
these studies reported modest reductions in NAPSI scores for infliximab, etanercept,
alefacept, and adalimumab. CONCLUSIONS: Comparative studies demonstrated that
golimumab and infliximab appeared to be effective treatment options for nail psoriasis. Infliximab also has evidence supporting long-term efficacy at 50 weeks. Evidence
from non-comparative studies supported the findings of the comparative evidence and
suggested that there may be moderate nail improvement associated with adalimumab,
13th Euro Abstracts
alefacept, and etanercept. No quantitative synthesis of the data could be performed,
mainly due to the paucity of comparative evidence. Further studies are warranted to
understand the comparative efficacy of biologic treatments for nail psoriasis.
PSY5
A MARKOV MODEL TO ESTIMATE THE EFFECT OF CANAKINUMAB ON
THE PROGRESSION OF AA AMYLOIDOSIS IN PATIENTS WITH
CRYOPYRIN-ASSOCIATED PERIODIC-FEVER SYNDROMES (CAPS)
Gauthier A1, Jiang Y1, Roberts D2, Warburton J2, Hawkins PN3, Lachmann HJ3
1
Amaris Consulting UK, London, UK; 2Novartis Pharmaceuticals UK Limited, Surrey, UK;
3
National Amyloidosis Centre, University College London Medical School, Royal Free
Hospital, London, UK
OBJECTIVES: CAPS is a spectrum of rare inherited autoinflammatory syndromes. It
is an ultra-orphan disease affecting approximately 70 patients in the UK. CAPS
patients are at increased risk of developing AA amyloidosis (AA) and subsequent
end-stage renal failure (ESRF). This study aimed to model the impact of a new treatment, canakinumab, on the progression of AA in patients with CAPS. METHODS:
A Markov model was developed which comprised four health states: CAPS, CAPS
with AA, CAPS with ESRF and dead. Based on the literature, 25% of CAPS patients
are thought to develop AA over their lifetime. The risks of ESRF and death in patients
with AA were obtained from published observational studies and life expectancy in
CAPS patients with ESRF was based on expert opinion. Excess mortality in CAPS for
reasons other than AA was estimated from rheumatoid arthritis, another systemic
inflammatory disease. Treatment efficacy for canakinumab was obtained from the
results of a pivotal clinical trial. The model was run for a typical adult patient and a
typical paediatric patient and assumed that AA was not present at treatment initiation.
RESULTS: Assuming a UK CAPS population of 70 patients, if canakinumab was initiated at the age of 4 years, a total of 18 AA and 8 ESRF cases would be avoided, and
patients would gain 13.7 years of life on average compared to those not treated with
canakinumab. Assuming treatment initiation at the age of 38 years (estimated mean
age at diagnosis), a total of 11 AA and 4 ESRF cases would be avoided and patients
would gain 10.3 years of life on average. CONCLUSIONS: Based on a model estimating the progression of AA in CAPS, treatment with canakinumab is associated with a
gain of 10 to 14 life-years due to a reduced incidence of AA and ESRF.
PSY6
THE ICATIBANT OUTCOME SURVEY: A PROSPECTIVE STUDY OF
SAFETY AND EFFECTIVENESS OF ICATIBANT IN A ‘REAL WORLD’
SETTING IN PATIENTS WITH HEREDITARY ANGIOEDEMA
Maurer M1, Aberer W2, Amat LM3, Karon-Klefbom M4, Malmenäs M4, Bouillet L5,
Kanny G6, Martin L7, Coppere B8, Longhurst H9, Fain O10, Launay D11, Gompel A12,
Bork K13, Greve J14, Yann O15, Rubio-Sotes M16, Sala A17, Lleonart R18,
Hernando de Larramendi C19, Hernandez D20
1
Charité—Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Germany, 2Medical University of Graz, Graz, Austria,
3
Hospital Santa Maria, Lleida, Spain, 4Shire Human Genetic Therapies, Inc, Danderyd,
Sweden, 5CHU Grenoble, Grenoble, France, 6CHU Nancy, Nancy, France, 7CHU Angers,
Angers, France, 8CHRU Lyon, Lyon, France, 9Barts and the London Hospital, London, UK,
10
Hopital Jean Verdier, Bondy, france, 11CHRU Lille, Lille, france, 12CHU Hotel-Dieu, Paris,
France, 13Universitatsklinik, Mainz, Germany, 14Klinik und Poliklinik fur Hals-NasenOhrenheilkunde, Essen, Germany, 15CHU Hopital de la Cote de Nacre, Caen, France,
16
Hospital Universitario Gregorio Maranon, Madrid, Spain, 17Hospital Vall D’Hebron,
Barcelona, Spain, 18Hospital Bellvitge, L’Hospitalet de Llobregat, Spain, 19Hospital Marina
Baixa, Vila Joiosa, Spain, 20Hospital Le Fe, Valencia, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Icatibant, a specific bradykinin-B2 receptor antagonist, is approved for
symptomatic treatment of acute attacks of HAE in adults with C1-esterase-inhibitor
deficiency. Although no treatment-related serious adverse events were reported during
randomized clinical trials with icatibant in HAE, a study of outcomes in normal clinical practice is important since bradykinin-B2 receptor antagonism is a new therapeutic
approach. The Icatibant Outcome Survey (IOS) is an international, multicentre, prospective observational study designed to provide further information on the safety and
effectiveness of icatibant in an unselected patient population. METHODS: The study
population is all patients receiving icatibant outside of the blinded controlled studies.
After obtaining approval from local Institutional Review Board or Ethics Committees,
treating physicians are invited to enrol consenting patients and to participate in the
study. a series of survey forms are used to record baseline data relating to relevant
medical history and demographic information at study entry; details of previous HAE
attacks, icatibant administration and outcomes; hematological, liver function and
plasma lipid status; and any adverse events. Routine data entry occurs electronically
via a secure link and participating physicians are encouraged to update records for
each patient at 6-monthly intervals. Any serious adverse events will be notified immediately in accordance with normal pharmacovigilance practice. Data harvested from
the database will be summarised and scrutinised by an independent Steering Committee. RESULTS: Data collection commenced in July 2009 and the first analysis was
done early 2010. CONCLUSIONS: The Icatibant Outcome Survey will provide
further prospective data on safety and outcomes of use of this novel drug for acute
treatment of HAE attacks in a ‘real world’ setting.
13th Euro Abstracts
SYSTEMIC DISORDERS/CONDITIONS – Cost Studies
PSY7
AN ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF RECOMBINANT ACTIVATED FACTOR
VIIA ROOM TEMPERATURE STABLE IN THE MANAGEMENT OF
HEMOPHILIA PATIENTS WITH INHIBITORS IN SERBIA
Plun-Favreau J1, Dimitrov DG2, Cel M3, Lukic J4
1
Novo Nordisk, Zurich, Switzerland; 2Novo Nordisk s.r.o., Praha, Czech Republic; 3Novo
Nordisk Pharma Sp z.o.o., Warsaw, Poland; 4Novo Nordisk Pharma d.o.o. Beograd, Belgrade,
Serbia
OBJECTIVES: Recombinant activated factor VIIa room temperature stable (rFVIIa
RTS) enables immediate access to treatment, which may lead to more rapid bleeding
control and require less product compared to original rFVIIa, leading to cost savings
despite the greater cost of rFVIIa RTS. The total annual cost of managing mild/moderate bleeds in one average hemophilia patient with high titre, high responding inhibitors
by original rFVIIa and rFVIIa RTS was examined. METHODS: Only main medications costs were compared from the public payer perspective. Resource utilization and
clinical outcomes were based on a review of international literature. Excel based
budget impact model (BIM) was developed to assess the financial consequences of
treating bleeding episodes with rFVIIa compared to current treatment practices.
Cohort of individuals in BIM can be followed sequentially from bleed initiation, taking
into consideration first-line efficacy, switching to other products, re-bleeds and bleed
cessation. RESULTS: Patients with rFVIIa RTS were treated on an outpatient or home
basis. First-line and second-line efficacy was assumed to be 92% for original rFVIIa
and rFVIIa RTS. An early treatment with rFVIIa was associated with a lower incidence
of re-bleeds compared to delayed treatment 5.2% vs. 13.7% and therefore with less
product usage 2.1 vs. 2.3 doses per treatment line. Total annual costs per patient from
initiation to cessation in the current treatment environment was CSD 12.58 million
(c0.12 million). One-way sensitivity analyses showed that at price of rFVIIa RTS from
0% to 16% premium introduction of this new form can deliver savings for the Serbian
health care budget due to immediate patients’ access to the treatment. If not literature
but current real life treatment patterns are considered savings can reach 56%. CONCLUSIONS: rFVIIa room temperature stable (RTS) in comparison to the original
rFVIIa represents cost-saving first-line treatment option for the Serbian health care
system.
PSY8
BUDGET IMPACT OF THE USE OF HYDROMORPHONE ONCE DAILY IN
CHRONIC PAIN PATIENTS IN THE GERMAN HEALTH CARE SYSTEM—
AN UPDATE
Fleischmann J, Wimmer A, Kubitz N
Janssen-Cilag, Neuss, Germany
OBJECTIVES: The budget impact of treating patients with severe chronic cancer and
non-cancer pain with OROS®hydromorphone once-daily was determined in the
German health care system. METHODS: An existing Excel® based hypothetical
budget impact model (Fleischmann et al. 2008) calculating the cost consequences of
using strong opioids (WHO step III) was updated using new market data (2009) and
current prices (2010 public prices). The model has a one year time horizon adopting
the perspective of the social health insurance accounting for costs of opioids, breakthrough pain and adverse events. Patient numbers are calculated using data from
literature; adverse event rates are based on literature findings. Comparators included
sustained-release morphine (twice-daily), controlled-release oxycodone (twice-daily),
hydromorphone (twice-daily), transdermal fentanyl and transdermal buprenorphine.
Initial prescription share of OROS® hydromorphone was 3.7% (2009). This share was
hypothetically extended to 5%. It was assumed that this increase in prescription is
gained by switching patients from their previous oral medication to OROS® hydromorphone. Titration and maintenance dosing schemes taken from previous analyses
are used to model the switch. Morphine equivalences were chosen according to SmPC.
RESULTS: The number of patients treated was estimated to be 810,608 per year. The
model predicted that the expansion of OROS® HM would lower the per patient drug
cost from c592.28 to c590.88. Due to generic entry drug cost per patient was considerably lower than in the previous version of the model (c679.52). The model also
predicts that if the prescription share of OROS® HM increased to 5% the total budget
for strong opioids would decrease by c1,135,086. CONCLUSIONS: Our analysis
suggests that under current circumstances our finding from 2008 that extending the
use of OROS® hydromorphone to treat patients with severe chronic pain will reduce
the overall budget spent on strong opioids is still valid.
PSY9
THE ADMINISTRATION OF LIQUID INTRAVENOUS
IMMUNOGLOBULINS IN SPAIN: A BUDGET IMPACT ANALYSIS TO
ESTIMATE COSTS DUE TO AN INCREASING PRIVIGEN PENETRATION
Darba J1, Restovic G2, Kaskens L2, de Agustin T3
1
Universitat de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain; 2BCN Health, Barcelona, Spain; 3CSL Behring,
Esplugues de Llobregat, Spain
OBJECTIVES: To assess the economic impact for the Spanish health care system of
the substitution of Flebogamma by Privigen in the Spanish market setting for liquid
intravenous immunoglobulins (IVIGs) in 2009. METHODS: A budget impact model
was developed with analyses based on Spanish data on disease prevalence, population
forecasts, drug use, health care resource utilization and market shares. Data was
obtained by literature research and consulting a panel of local clinical experts. The
A461
perspective of the Spanish health care system was considered and a 5-year time horizon
was evaluated. All costs referred to 2009 and a discount rate of 3% was applied.
Indications of IVIGs included in this study were replacement therapy, immunomodulation and allogeneic bone marrow transplantation. Sub-indications of these primary
indications were also considered distinguishing between children and adolescents vs.
adults. IGIV treatments considered were Kiovig, Octagamocta, Flebogamma and
Privigen. Direct medical annual costs per patient for each (sub-)indication were estimated before and after the substitution by Privigen. RESULTS: The target population
for IVIG treatment was estimated to be 5743 in 2009, increasing to 6926 in 2014.
Total costs for the next 5 years with the actual market share were estimated at c565
million. a minimum increase in Privigen’s market share from 2% in the first year up
to 12% in the fifth year- was considered. Under these circumstances, the estimated
costs were c563c million which represents a saving of c2 million for the Spanish health
care system. CONCLUSIONS: An increase of Privigen’s market share in Spain is likely
to decrease the budget utilization of the health care system within the next 5 years.
Savings are the result of less drug and administration costs per treated patient.
PSY10
A BUDGET IMPACT MODEL TO INVESTIGATE POTENTIAL COST
SAVINGS ASSOCIATED WITH IMPROVEMENTS IN THE SAFETY
PROFILE OF STRONG OPIOID ANALGESICS
Ruff L1, Plich A1, Liedgens H2
1
Medaxial Group, London, UK; 2Gruenenthal GmbH, Aachen, Germany
OBJECTIVES: The use of strong opioid analgesics to treat severe chronic pain is
associated with adverse events (AEs) and treatment discontinuations, which can
increase the overall cost of treatment. New interventions with more favourable safety
profiles could reduce these costs. An economic model was constructed to investigate
the potential budget savings associated with the introduction of an intervention with
increased tolerability to a formulary. METHODS: A prevalence-based, deterministic
budget impact model with a five-year time horizon was developed from the perspective
of a UK health care budget-holder. The model takes into account drug acquisition,
AE and discontinuation costs associated with the five most frequently-used strong
opioid analgesics (WHO step 3) in the UK. Cost and usage data were derived from
the British National Formulary, market research studies and physician interviews. AE
and discontinuation rates were derived from published studies. RESULTS: In a theoretical population of 100,000 individuals, the model estimated that 205 patients
experienced severe chronic pain and subsequently received strong opioid analgesics.
The overall annual cost of treating these patients with currently-available strong
opioid analgesics was estimated to be £152,426, 62% of which was spent managing
AEs and discontinuations. Over five years, the model showed that if 50% of patients
received an alternative strong analgesic which reduces the number of AEs and discontinuations by 25% (compared to currently-used strong opioid analgesics), there would
be 198 fewer AEs and 58 fewer discontinuations. This would result in a cost saving
of £51,985. CONCLUSIONS: The cost of managing AEs and discontinuations is a
significant contributor to the overall treatment cost associated with strong opioid
analgesics. New treatments with improved safety profiles may reduce the economic
burden of managing AEs and discontinuations associated with the use of strong opioid
analgesics. This may partially or even completely offset any potential increase in
acquisition costs.
PSY11
COSTS OF SUPPORTIVE CARE (SC) FOR THE TREATMENT OF
MYELODISPLASTIC SYNDROME (MDS) IN BRAZIL: AN ANALYSIS FROM
THE PRIVATE PAYER’S PERSPECTIVE
Clark O1, Teich V2, Pereira ML3, Faleiros E1, Clark LGO1
1
MedInsight-Evidências, Campinas, Brazil; 2MedInsight-Evidências, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil;
3
Janssen-Cilag, São José dos Campos, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: MDS is a rare hematological disease, that affects the production of
blood cells. One of the goals of the treatment is to maintain the blood-cell count in
near-normal levels. The means to achieve this are done mainly with the use of hematopoietic- growth factors and transfusions. Our objective was to determine the costs
of this supportive treatment under the private payers perspective in Brazil, for patients
with intermediate risk (INT) MDS. METHODS: We adapted the National Comprehensive Cancer Network (NCCN) for INT MDS decision tree to the reality of the
Health care system in Brazil. Then, we calculated the costs for each branch of the tree,
according to the local prices. We also simulated the total costs for a cohort of 100
patients, distributed in the branches according to the expected epidemiology. We
assumed an horizon of one year of treatment. RESULTS: The mean cost of SC for
MDS was US$45,006/ patient/ year. This value can vary from US$33,368 to
US$104,210, according to the patients’ characteristics and types of treatments used.
Overall, patients requiring the use of immunotherapy, with anti-tymocyte globulins
were associated with the highest costs. Those achieving disease stabilization solely
with the use of erythropoietin were associated with the lowest costs. CONCLUSIONS:
The SC of SMD is associated with a mean cost of US$45,000/patient/year in Brazil.
New treatments have the potential to change this scenario if they can diminish the
requirements for the costliest supportive procedures.
A462
PSY12
REAL-LIFE BUDGET IMPACT (BI) OF PARENTERAL IRON TREATMENT
OF IRON DEFICIENCY ANEMIA/SYNDROME (IDA/IDS) IN SWITZERLAND
Brock E1, Braunhofer P2, Troxler J3, Schneider H1
1
HealthEcon AG, Basel, Switzerland; 2Vifor Pharma International, Glattbrugg, Switzerland;
3
Vifor AG, Villars-sur-Glane, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: IDA/IDS is common in pregnancy, postpartum, inflammatory bowel
disease, chronic kidney disease, chronic heart failure, menorrhagia/hypermenorrhagia,
cancer and following surgery. We estimate the BI associated with substituting iron
sucrose (standard) with ferric carboxymaltose (new treatment), which allows for the
application of higher dosages in a shorter time. The analysis adopted the perspective
of the Swiss mandatory health insurance (MHI) covering the above indications and is
based on real-life data to verify the hypothetical BI estimated prior to launch.
METHODS: Resource use (no. of patients, dosage per application, no. of applications)
was based on recent primary data (Polyquest Prescriber Analysis, Anemia Patient
Record Study in Switzerland). Personnel costs were estimated using the Swiss Tarmed
fee-for-service reimbursement system. Drug costs and costs of materials used were
based on official tariffs (Spezialitätenliste, MiGeL). Real-life IMS sales data of both
products were used to verify the BI model. RESULTS: Ferric carboxymaltose was
associated with cost savings of 30–44% compared to iron sucrose based on costs of
CHF 101/ 210/ 420 and CHF 144/ 375/ 721 per 200/ 500/ 1000 mg treatment cycle,
respectively. This leads to cost savings of CHF 15–33 million per year to the Swiss
MHI across all indications in the first 3 years post-launch, due to reductions in personnel costs. Ferric carboxymaltose was shown to be cost-saving in all indications except
dialysis (due to flat-fee reimbursement). Sensitivity analyses showed the amount of
cost savings to be sensitive to changes in the number of inpatients (10–20% of total)
treated with intravenous iron (due to flat-fee reimbursement). CONCLUSIONS: Treating IDA/IDS involves substantial costs to the Swiss MHI. Substitution of iron sucrose
with ferric carboxymaltose may help to reduce these due to reduced personnel costs.
This novel type of real-life BIA will be of increasing interest as conditional reimbursement increases.
PSY13
COST IMPACT FROM INITIATING PREGABALIN TREATMENT IN
PATIENTS WITH REFRACTORY NEUROPATHIC PAIN
Myrén KJ1, Löfroth E1, Sandelin R2
1
IMS Health, Stockholm, Sweden; 2Pfizer, Sollentuna, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: To compare the health care costs 6 months prior to and 6 months after
initiation of pregabalin in difficult-to-treat neuropathic pain (NeP) patients.
METHODS: This was a retrospective longitudinal database study in NeP patients
from the South-West region of Sweden (1.5 million inhabitants). Individual patient
data from the 1st of January 2000 on health care visits (outpatient, inpatient, primary
care), costs, mortality and diagnoses were included. Data from the Swedish Prescribed
Drug register were included from July 1, 2005 until December 31, 2007. Difficult-totreat NeP was defined as patients with a NeP diagnosis in 2006, who had had 2
prescriptions of at least three pain medications during one year from the index diagnosis date. The patients should also have had two or more prescriptions of pregabalin
preceded by at least a six months pregabalin naïve period. RESULTS: A total of 462
difficult-to-treat NeP patients met the above criteria and were included in the analyses.
There was a statistically significant reduction in NeP related costs (visits registered
with a NeP diagnosis) after initiation of pregabalin (p = 0.0042 Mann-Whitney). The
mean per patient NeP related costs were SEK17,684 (c1,845) 6 months before and
SEK10,642 (c1,110) 6 months after pregabalin initiation. The mean non-NeP related
costs before treatment (SEK46,095; c4,809) did not differ significantly from the
non-NeP costs after treatment (SEK 51,632; c5,387), p = 0.8016. The number of
NeP-related in-patient visits, primary care visits and the number of days in hospital
decreased significantly (p = 0.0475, p = 0.0129, p = 0.0179, respectively) after treatment with pregabalin. CONCLUSIONS: Initiation of pregabalin significantly reduced
the NeP related health care costs in the 6-month period following initiation. Of note
was the non significant difference in non-NeP related costs, probably reflecting the
on-going costs associated with management of the patients’ concurrent conditions, eg,
diabetes.
PSY14
REAL-WORLD USE OF DULOXETINE FOR CHRONIC LOW BACK PAIN:
TREATMENT PATTERN AND COSTS
Ivanova JI1, Birnbaum HG2, Kantor E2, Schiller M2, Swindle R3
1
Analysis Group, Inc., New York, NY, USA; 2Analysis Group, Inc., Boston, MA, USA; 3Eli Lilly
& Company, Indianapolis, IN, USA
OBJECTIVES: Examine the real-world role of duloxetine versus other treatment for
chronic low back pain (CLBP). METHODS: Study sample was selected from a U.S.
privately-insured claims database (2004–2008). Selection criteria: ages 18–64 years,
had a low back pain (LBP) diagnosis (per HEDIS specifications) with a subsequent
CLBP-qualifying diagnosis recorded 90 days or more after the initial LBP diagnosis.
Duloxetine-treated patients had ≥1 duloxetine prescription within 6 months after
CLBP diagnosis, no prior duloxetine claim, and continuous eligibility ≥12 months
before first LBP diagnosis and ≥6 months after index duloxetine prescription (study
period). 553 duloxetine-treated patients were matched to a total of 553 control
patients who initiated another non-surgical LBP treatment based on propensity score
and time from first LBP diagnosis to treatment initiation. a subset (n = 103 each) of
matched employees was also analyzed. McNemar tests were used to compare LBP
13th Euro Abstracts
treatment rates. Bias-corrected bootstrapping was used to compare direct (medical and
drug) costs from third-party payer perspective and employee indirect (workloss) costs.
RESULTS: During the 6-month study period, matched duloxetine-treated patients had
significantly lower rates of other pharmacological therapy than controls (e.g., 56.2%
vs. 64.9% narcotic opioids, p = 0.002; 34.9% vs. 49.5% NSAIDs; P < 0.001) and
non-invasive therapy (28.8% vs. 38.5% chiropractic therapy; 25.5% vs. 35.4% physical therapy; 17.5% vs. 28.4% exercise therapy; all P < 0.001). Duloxetine-treated
patients versus controls had numerically lower back surgery rates (2.2% vs. 3.8%, p
= 0.117) and similar direct costs ($7658 vs. $7439, p = 0.812). Among CLBP employees, duloxetine-treated employees versus controls had lower rates of other non-surgical
therapy, numerically lower back surgery rates (0% vs. 3.9%, p = 0.125), lower total
direct and indirect costs ($5227 vs. $7229, p = 0.042), and numerically lower indirect
costs ($1806 vs. $2664, p = 0.053). CONCLUSIONS: Duloxetine treatment in CLBP
patients/employees versus other non-surgical treatment was associated with reduced
rates of non-surgical therapies and numerically lower surgery rates without increased
costs.
PSY15
CONSTIPATION RELATED TO OPIOID THERAPY: A COST-OF-ILLNESS
AND PREVALENCE DATABASE STUDY IN THE BRAZILIAN PRIVATE
SETTING
Takemoto ML1, Fernandes RA1, Passos RB1, Colombini-Netto M2, Bertola-Neto A2,
Almeida GR3, Monteiro R3
1
ANOVA—Knowledge Translation, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil; 2Axismed Gestão Preventiva da
Saúde, São Paulo, SP, Brazil; 3Pfizer, São Paulo, SP, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: To estimate the prevalence of constipation concomitant to opioid
treatment and related resource utilization and costs from the private payer perspective.
METHODS: Patients on opioid therapy were identified from a longitudinal insurance
claims database consisting in 1,057,033 individuals for a period of 35 months. An
algorithm was used to identify patients on opioid therapy with coincident constipation-related claims according to ICD-10 codes, targeted procedures and opioid use
criteria. Resource utilization and costs were determined for these individuals and
compared with patients on opioid therapy without constipation, without opioid
therapy with constipation and without both conditions. Results were compared using
ANOVA with a significance level of 0.05 and are presented per individual per month.
RESULTS: A total of 23,313 patients were classified as opioid treated patients (2.21%
of total population) and 6,678 had events related to constipation (29.03% of the
opioid population). Compared with opioid treated patients without constipation,
incremental mean total costs per month per patients with the condition were 261.18
BRL (P < 0.001). The average cost per month for opioid-related constipation patients
was 787.84 BRL, significantly higher than patients on opioid therapy without constipation (526.66 BRL), with no opioid therapy but constipated (284.47 BRL) and
without both (90.17 BRL) (P < 0.001 for all comparisons). Patients with claims related
to both conditions had significantly more days in hospital per month (0.25 vs. 0.497,
P < 0.001), outpatient office visits (1.04 vs. 1.59, P < 0.001), outpatient procedures
(4.69 vs. 14.05, P < 0.001) and tests and therapies (31.95 vs. 36.66, P < 0.001) than
did patients without opioid-related constipation claims. CONCLUSIONS: The economic burden of patients with constipation events coincident with opioid treatment
is significantly higher when compared to all other groups. Constipated patients
without opioid therapy had also higher costs than those free of both conditions. These
results indicate that reducing opioid-induced constipation has potential cost savings
for the health care system.
PSY16
CHANGES IN SELF-REPORTED PAIN SCORES ASSOCIATED WITH
DULOXETINE VERSUS OTHER ANTIDEPRESSANTS AMONG PATIENTS
WITH MAJOR DEPRESSIVE DISORDER IN THE UNITED STATES
VETERANS AFFAIRS HEALTH CARE NETWORK
Liu J1, Zhao Y2, Happich M3, Shi L1
1
Tulane University, New Orleans, LA, USA; 2Eli Lilly & Company, Indianapolis, IN, USA; 3Eli
Lilly & Company, Windlesham, UK
OBJECTIVES: This study compared self-reported pain scores among patients with
major depressive disorder (MDD) in the U.S. Veterans Affairs (VA) health system
treated with duloxetine versus other antidepressants. METHODS: The electronic
medical records between October 1, 2004 and October 31, 2008 were obtained from
the VA Veterans Integrated Service Network 16 data warehouse. All patients treated
with either duloxetine monotherapy or other antidepressants (non-duloxetine) were
selected. The first dispense date of the index agent was defined as the index date. All
patients must have: 1) 1 + prior MDD diagnosis (ICD-9-CM: 296.2 or 296.3); 2) no
prior diabetes (ICD-9-CM: 250.xx) or bipolar (ICD-9-CM: 296.4x-296.8x) diagnosis;
and 3) self-reported pain score measured within 60 days both before the index date
(baseline pain score) and after the last dispense date of the index antidepressants
during the 12-month post-index period. The non-duloxetine-treated patients were
matched to the duloxetine-treated patients via propensity scoring (1:1 ratio), controlling for demographics, comorbidities, prior opioid use, prior health care utilization,
and baseline pain scores. Opioid utilization and pain scores over the 12-month postindex period were examined between cohorts. RESULTS: The study sample included
210 duloxetine- and 210 non-duloxetine-treated patients. Significantly less duloxetinetreated patients than non-duloxetine-treated patients used opioids (20.1%; vs. 34.3%,
p = .002) over the 12-month post-index period. Both cohorts had similar morphineequivalent opioid daily use and pain scores during the follow-up period. Controlling
for baseline pain scores and medication duration, duloxetine-treated patients had 1.58
13th Euro Abstracts
points (p = 0.007) lower pain score than non-duloxetine-treated patients among
individuals who had any opioid use during the 12-month post-index period. CONCLUSIONS: Among similar VA patients with MDD, patients treated with duloxetine
were associated with lower opioid use than those treated with other antidepressants.
Among individuals with any opioid use over the 12-month post-index period, duloxetinetreated patients had better pain scores than non-duloxetine-treated patients.
PSY17
ECONOMIC OUTCOMES ASSOCIATED WITH HYDROXYUREA
ADHERENCE AMONG PEDIATRIC MEDICAID ENROLLEES WITH SICKLE
CELL DISEASE
Candrilli S1, O’Brien SH2, Balkrishnan R3
1
RTI Health Solutions, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA; 2The Research Institute at
Nationwide Children’s Hospital, Columbus, OH, USA; 3University of Michigan, College of
Pharmacy, Ann Arbor, MI, USA
OBJECTIVES: Although not approved for use in pediatrics, hydroxyurea has been
shown to decrease painful vaso-occlusive events and hospitalizations (HU) in children
with sickle cell disease (SCD), a genetic hematologic disorder primarily affecting
people of African descent. However, few data exist on the use of HU, and adherence
to treatment, in real-world settings. This study assessed the extent to which children
with SCD are adherent with prescribed HU therapy and the association between HU
adherence and economic outcomes in this population in a real-world setting.
METHODS: Insurance claims of North Carolina Medicaid program enrollees (June
1999-August 2008) were analyzed. Inclusion criteria were ≥1 claims with a diagnosis
for SCD (i.e., ICD-9-CM 282.6, 282.6x), ≥2 HU prescriptions in the year following
HU initiation, ≤18 years old at the time of HU initiation, and continuous Medicaid
enrollment for ≥12 months prior to and following HU initiation. Adherence was
measured using the medication possession ratio (MPR), with MPR > 0.8 considered
adherent. Multivariable models were estimated to assess the association between HU
adherence and economic outcomes (e.g., inpatient costs) in the first year of HU therapy.
RESULTS: A totla of 159 subjects (55% female, mean age [SD] 11.3 [4.4] years) met all
inclusion criteria. The mean MPR was 0.63, with 41% of subjects adherent. Multivariable
models revealed that in the year following HU initiation, adherence was associated with
a reduction in all-cause (-$3.695, p = 0.0003) and SCD-related (-$3.002, P < 0.0001)
total, inpatient (-$2172, p = 0.001; -$1815, P < 0.0001, respectively), ER (-$314, P <
0.0001; -$202, p = 0.002, respectively), outpatient (-$951, P < 0.0001; -$541, p = 0.005,
respectively), and vaso-occlusive event-related (-$3639, P < 0.0001) costs, and an increase
in all-cause (+$239, p = 0.014) and SCD-related pharmacy (+$198, P < 0.0001) costs.
CONCLUSIONS: Adherence to HU among pediatric SCD patients may be suboptimal
and improving adherence to HU therapy among these patients may reduce the economic burden of the illness.
PSY18
DIRECT MEDICAL COSTS OF LIQUID INTRAVENOUS
IMMUNOGLOBULINS IN CHILDREN, ADOLESCENTS AND ADULTS IN
SPAIN
Darba J1, Restovic G2, Kaskens L2, de Agustin T3
1
Universitat de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain; 2BCN Health, Barcelona, Spain; 3CSL Behring,
Esplugues de Llobregat, Spain
OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study is to determine health care resource utilization
and direct medical costs in patients treated with intravenous immunoglobulins (IVIGs)
in Spain in 2009. METHODS: A cost-of-illness analyses was performed to estimate
direct medical annual costs of patients treated with IVIGs. Prevalence data was
obtained from the Spanish Primary Immunodeficiency registry. a semi-structured questionnaire was used to collect data on health care resource utilization and target population distribution. Inpatient and outpatient costs were considered from the perspective
of the public health care system. Hospital costs considered were ambulatory-, ward-,
premedication-, drug- and administration costs. All costs referred to 2009. In medical
practice, IVIG doses depend on a patient’s weight and age. Therefore separate analyses
were conducted for children and adolescents vs. adults. RESULTS: Patients with
replacement therapy were estimated to be 4192 (724 children and adolescents vs. 3450
adults) for 2009. Patients with immunomodulation were estimated to be 1378 (244
children and adolescents vs. 1134 adults) and patients with an allogeneic bone marrow
transplantation were estimated at 172 (30 children and adolescents vs. 142 adults ).
Mean annual costs for children and adolescents were c6283 with Privigen, c6292 with
Kiovig, c6946 with Flebogamma and c6559 with Octagamocta. For adults estimations
were c17,078 with Privigen, c17,103 with Kiovig, c18,095 with Flebogamma and
c17,423 with Octagamocta. CONCLUSIONS: Direct medical costs for IVIGs were
estimated to be c6.9 million for children and adolescents and c84.8 million for adult
patients. Drug costs represented 94% of the total direct medical costs. In the context
of limited health care resources, the choice for a certain IVIG treatment depends on
individual patient characteristics and cost considerations.
PSY19
PREDICTORS OF DULOXETINE TREATMENT INITIATION AMONG
PATIENTS WITH DIABETIC PERIPHERAL NEUROPATHIC PAIN IN
SOUTH CENTER VETERANS AFFAIRS HEALTH CARE NETWORK IN
THE UNITED STATES
Shi L1, Liu J1, Zhao Y1, Zhao Y2
1
Tulane University, New Orleans, LA, USA; 2Eli Lilly & Company, Indianapolis, IN, USA
OBJECTIVES: To explore predictors of duloxetine initiation versus other standard of
care (SOC) treatments for patients with diabetic peripheral neuropathic pain (DPNP)
A463
in the Veterans Affairs (VA) health system. Duloxetine was not on the VA national
drug formulary. METHODS: The electronic medical records from January 2004 to
December 2008 were requested from the Veterans Integrated Service Network 16 data
warehouse. All patients selected initiated either duloxetine or SOC (tricyclic antidepressants [TCAs], venlafaxine, gabapentin, pregabalin) over the study period, with the
first dispense date of the index agent as the index date. All patients must have at least
1 prior DPNP diagnosis (ICD-9-CM: 250.6x or 357.2), but no prior depression (ICD9-CM: 296.2, 296.3, 300.4, 309.1, 311.0), fibromyalgia (ICD-9-CM: 729.1), or
neuralgia (ICD-9-CM: 729.2) diagnosis. Logistic regressions were used to examine the
predictors of initiating duloxetine versus SOC controlling for demographics, comorbidities, prior pain level, and prior SOC or opioid use. RESULTS: The analytical
sample included 2675 (215 duloxetine and 2460 SOC) patients. Prior use of gabapentin (odds ratio [OR] = 13.66, 95% confidence interval [CI]: 9.70–19.24, TCAs (OR
= 5.40, 95% CI: 3.73–7.82), or venlafaxine (OR = 3.67, 95% CI: 1.67–8.06) was
strongly associated with duloxetine initiation. Patients comorbid with anxiety, cerebrovascular disease, or substance abuse were 1.08 (95% CI: 1.40–3.08), 0.44 (95%
CI: 1.01–2.07), and 1.11 (95% CI: 1.10–4.03) times more likely to initiate duloxetine,
respectively. Prior opioid users were 1.47 (95% CI: 1.02–2.12) times as likely to initiate duloxetine as those with no prior opioid use. Patients with self-reported severe
pain were 1.66 (95% CI: 1.11–2.50) times as likely to initiate duloxetine as those with
no reported pain. CONCLUSIONS: DPNP patients in the VA health care system who
initiated duloxetine appeared to have prior SOC use, more comorbid conditions, prior
substance abuse or opioid use, and higher pain level.
PSY20
SYSTEMIC LUPUS ERYTHEMATOSUS (SLE) IS COSTLY FOR THE
HEALTH CARE SYSTEM AND WORKPLACE: A SYSTEMATIC
LITERATURE REVIEW
Doria A1, Grandfils N2, Maurel F2, Rudge H3
1
University of Padova, Padova, Italy; 2IMS Health, Paris, France; 3GlaxoSmithKline, Uxbridge,
Middlesex, UK
OBJECTIVES: To summarise the state of knowledge of the economic impact of SLE
and to gather information to implement a European study on costs of SLE care.
METHODS: A systematic review of the literature was undertaken in the ECONLIT,
EMBASE, Medline and EMBR databases for full papers relating to the objectives. Key
words included SLE, cost, resource, economic, productivity, absenteeism, employment
and work disability. Papers were excluded if they were not in English, French, Spanish,
Italian or German language. RESULTS: Thirty relevant research papers (relating to
13 different studies) were included. These studies were conducted in Canada, China,
Germany, UK and US and used retrospective and prospective methods. Data were
mainly obtained from the hospital care setting over a one-year study period. The main
resources reported were physician and emergency visits, as well as inpatient hospital
stays (of which SLE flares and infections were the main causes). Annual direct costs
(converted to December 2009 Euros) ranged from c2,879 (Canada) to c14,873 (US),
with indirect costs of c1,214 (US/UK/Canada, friction method) to c45,668 (US, labour
market activity method). Indirect costs accounted for at least 38% of the total costs
when both market and non-market work was valued. Higher disease activity was
reported as a predictor of higher direct and indirect costs. Greater damage, more flares
and nephritis were also found to predict higher direct costs whilst worse physical and/
or mental status predicted higher indirect costs. Only one study focussed on the cost
of flares. CONCLUSIONS: SLE is costly for the health care system and workplace.
However, there is a lack of data on the cost of SLE flares and little recent European
data relating to the cost of SLE care. HGS/GSK funded.
PSY21
THE IMPACT OF COMORBIDITY ON INFLAMMATORY BOWEL DISEASE
HEALTH COSTS
Lepore V1, D’Ettorre A1, Graziano G1, Martinelli D2, Tafuri S3, Tognoni G1
1
Consorzio Mario Negri Sud, Santa Maria Imbaro, Chieti, Italy; 2Apulia Regional
Epidemiological Observatory, Foggia, Italy; 3Apulia Regional Epidemiological Observatory,
Bari, Italy
OBJECTIVES: To quantify the direct costs (hospitalizations and prescription drugs)
of the caring strategies for the Inflammatory Bowel Disease (IBD). METHODS: All
cases of the major types of IBD, Crohn’s disease (CD) and ulcerative colitis (UC),
occurred in Apulia between 2002 and 2006 were in the study. The patients were
identified through a record linkage procedure among three different regional health
databases. Multivariate Poisson regression accounting for over-dispersion was used to
assess the average annual direct costs per person. Results were reported, separately
for the two diseases, as Incidence Rate Ratios (IRR) with 95% confidence intervals.
RESULTS: The cohort consisted of 2,700 cases of CD and 4902 cases of UC. We
estimated the average annual costs per person in patients with CD to be equal to 7,153
Euros for hospitalizations and to c2107 for prescription drugs. In patients with UC
the average annual costs per person was of c6317 and c2277 for hospitalizations and
prescription drugs, respectively. Surgical to medical DRGs ratio for both diseases was
1:5 and the ATC codes relative to intestinal anti-inflammatory, proton pump inhibition, anti-inflammatory/anti-rheumatic and corticosteroids products, represented the
40% of all prescriptions. Overall, the analyses showed, both for DC and CU, that the
Charlson Comorbidity Index (CCI) was the only variable associated with the direct
costs i.e. a significant increase in the costs (p-value < 0.0001) was found according to
the severity of the CCI. In particular, it was noted that a worse clinical condition
before disease onset (CCI before index date) was predictive of larger costs especially
A464
in the case of UC. CONCLUSIONS: These preliminary results show that this innovative cost estimation, obtained with this carefully controlled use of population wide
databases, is a valuable alternative to traditional analyses obtained with ad hoc
designed and less representative protocols.
PSY22
INDIRECT COSTS OF OBESITY IN POLAND
Warowny M, Macioch T, Hermanowski T
Medical University of Warsaw, Warsaw, Poland
OBJECTIVES: Obesity is becoming to be treated like a worldwide epidemic. In Poland
about 10.6% employees are obese. The objective of the studies was to estimate the
indirect costs of obesity among Polish society. METHODS: Human Capital Approach
method was used in costs quantifying. Data were collected from obese Polish employees. Work Productivity and Activity Impairment General Health questionnaire was
used to estimate absenteeism and presenteeism in obese population. Indirect cost for
general population was calculated on the basis of gross value added per employee in
2008. Central Statistical Office (GUS) data were used to identify obese epidemiology
in employed population. Values are presented in Euro (exchange rate: 1 EUR = 4.10
PLN). RESULTS: Data from 96 people were analyzed (mean age = 41.7 years, 34.4%
men, average BMI = 34.2 kg/m2). Overall work impairment due to health problems
in questioned population was estimated at 36.3%, with 11.8% of work time missed
due to health problems. Taking into consideration that based on GUS data near 1.5
million employees are obese total indirect costs of obesity in Poland in the year 2008
were estimated at c10,5 billion representing 0.9% of gross domestic product. Absenteeism costs accounted for less than 1/3 of this costs (c3.4 billion) while pressenteism
costs were estimated at amount of c7.0 billion. We didn’t find any correlation between
BMI score and work impairment due to health problems (Pearson r = 0,15).
CONCLUSIONS: Previously estimated direct medical costs of obesity (without obesity
related diseases) covered by public payer were quantified at 4 million EUR in the year
2008. We’ve found that indirect costs of lost productivity due to obesity are substantial
to polish economy. However we conclude that not obesity itself but obesity related
diseases generate most of indirect costs.
PSY23
COST OF POMPE DISEASE IN POLAND IN 2008 AND 2009
Baran A, Czech M, Hermanowski T
Medical University of Warsaw, Warsaw, Poland
OBJECTIVES: The objective of this review is to estimate the direct and indirect costs
of Pompe disease. METHODS: Direct and indirect cots were estimated based on a
questionnaire (consisting of 108 questions) measuring costs specific for Pompe disease
and a survey concerning the enzyme replacement therapy created for the research. The
direct costs of Pompe disease were estimated from the patient`s social and the public
health care system payer (National Health Fund) perspectives. While estimating indirect costs human capital approach methodology was used taking into consideration
absence from work due to the illness, lost time and salaries of the members of the
family taking care of the patients. The analysis was done in a 2-year time span.
RESULTS: In the research 80% of Pompe disease population were studied (N = 16).
Indirect costs constituted 3% of the total cost (c17,959,67 per patient in the period
of 2 years). The highest component of the amount was the cost of the income lost by
the members of the families taking care of the patients; 96% of the total direct costs
were the direct medical costs (c550,975.03 per patient in the period of 2 years). The
main direct medical cost determinant is the enzyme therapy (c543,350.47)-constituting
99% of the total direct medical costs. CONCLUSIONS: Providing patients with the
prompt access to the enzyme replacement therapy result in lowering future indirect
and direct costs: smaller number of patients taking disability pension, lower cost of
medical equipment used by patients and higher productivity of patients able to work.
Additionally there is a need to introduce an unusual and untypical approach in Health
Technology Assessment.
PSY24
COST OF CARE FOR CHRONIC MYELOID LEUKEMIA (CML) IN
PATIENTS EXPERIENCING RESISTANCE AND/OR INTOLERANCE TO
IMATINIB FROM THE PUBLIC HEALTH SYSTEM PERSPECTIVE IN
MEXICO
Hernández-Rivera G1, Aguayo Á2, Cantu-Rodríguez O3, Cervera E4, Gomez-Almaguer D3,
Gutiérrez H3, Lopez-Hernández M5, Martínez D2, Oropeza P6, Rico E7, Donato BM8,
Juarez-Garcia A1, Vargas-Valencia J9
1
Bristol-Myers Squibb, D.F., Mexico; 2Instituto Nacional de Ciencias Médicas y Nutrición
Salvador Zubirán, Mexico, D.F., Mexico; 3Hospital Universitario Dr. José Eleuterio González,
Monterrey, NL, Mexico; 4Instituto Nacional de Cancerología, Mexico, D.F., Mexico; 5Centro
Médico Nacional 20 de Noviembre ISSSTE, Mexico, D.F., Mexico; 6Hospital General de
Zona 8 IMSS, Mexico, D.F., Mexico; 7Hospital General Regional 110 IMSS, Guadalajara, JAL,
Mexico; 8Bristol-Myers Squibb, Wallingford, CT, USA; 9Econopharma Consulting S. A. de C.
V., Mexico City, Mexico, Mexico
OBJECTIVES: To estimate the cost of care for CML in patients with resistance and/
or intolerance to imatinib from the public perspective in Mexico METHODS: Retrospective study of 208 patients diagnosed with CML, ≥18 years of age, treated with
imatinib and having at least 12 months follow-up with final contact in the past three
months, whom were attended at 6 tertiary level public hospitals in Mexico. Cost of
care data captured includes drug costs (chemotherapy and imatinib), inpatient visits,
toxicity treatment, and medical monitoring (labs studies, outpatient visits and other
13th Euro Abstracts
drugs costs). Costs are estimated on a monthly basis and are classified according to
the presence of failure (toxicity or resistance to imatinib). Descriptive statistics on the
use of resources are reported. RESULTS: At diagnosis of CML, 95% of patients were
in chronic phase and 5% in accelerated phase. Fifty-five percent were female, with a
mean age of 48.30. Defining treatment failure as any imatinib dose adjustment, increasing if resistance (lack of hematological and/or cytogenetic response) or reduction if
intolerance (toxicity), 84.7% of patients failed initial treatment with imatinib. The
median time to imatnib dose adjustment was 5.1 months. The average monthly cost of
diagnosis and treatment prior to receiving imatinib was estimated US$2,210.54 ($2461–
$2808); the average monthly cost during treatment of imatinib and prior to failure was
estimated US$2793 ($1612–$3125). The average monthly cost after failure increased to
US$4706.18 ($3642–$5770), which represents an increment of 68.5% (t-test P < 0.001).
The cost drivers of the increase are primarily: 1) inpatient visits, which increase from
US$180 pre-failure to USD$367 post-failure, and 2) resources used in medical monitoring and CML treatment, which increase from US$3678 pre-failure to US$4338 postfailure per month. CONCLUSIONS: Once patients are resistant or intolerant to
imatinib, their cost of treatment increases through additional demand for medical
resources at Mexican public health care institutions.
PSY25
A PHARMACOECONOMIC EVALUATION OF ROMIPLOSTIM (NPLATE)
FOR THE TREATMENT OF CHRONIC IMMUNE THROMBOCYTOPENIA
(ITP)
Brosa M1, Arocho R2, Gutierrez L2, Kutikova L3
1
Oblikue Consulting, Barcelona, Spain; 2Amgen, Barcelona, Spain; 3Amgen (Europe) GmbH,
Zug, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: To assess treatment costs per overall platelet response with
romiplostim+concurrent treatment vs. placebo+concurrent treatment in chronic adult ITP,
from a national payer perspective in Spain. METHODS: Platelet response was defined as
a platelet count of ≥50×109/L. Overall platelet response rates to romiplostim and placebo
were used for the analysis and derived from two parallel clinical trials in splenectomized
and non-splenectomized ITP patients [1]. All patients were allowed to enter on concurrent
ITP medication (danazol, corticosteroids, azathioprine) and receive rescue medication (eg,
intravenous immunoglogulins). Treatment costs were calculated over the 24-week clinical
trial period and included intervention, rescue medication and management of bleedingrelated events. Costs were based on the 2009 national reimbursement list. Mean treatment
cost per response was calculated for overall population, and for splenectomized and nonsplenectomized patients. RESULTS: Cost per response was substantially lower for romiplostim compared to placebo. Overall response rate was 83% for romiplostim and 7% for
placebo (splenectomized patients 79% vs. 0%, non-splenectomized patients 88% vs. 14%,
respectively). Mean treatment costs were c15,781 for romiplostim and c8,111 for placebo
(splenectomized patients c15,436 vs. c10,263, non-splenectomized patients c16,125 vs.
c5,958, respectively). Cost per response with romiplostim was c19,013 compared to
c115,871 with placebo (splenectomized patients c19,539 vs. infinite cost/response, nonsplenectomized patients c18,324 vs. c42,557, respectively). The main cost-offsets were
due to reduced immunoglobulin rescue use. CONCLUSIONS: Romiplostim represents an
efficient use of health care resources in both splenectomized and non-splenectomized ITP
patients for the Spanish health care system, leading to a significant improvement in managing a disease with a limited number of existing effective therapies. [1] Kuter et al. Lancet
2008;371:395–403.
PSY26
A RETROSPECTIVE STUDY TO EVALUATE THE MORBIDITY PROFILES
AND THERAPEUTIC COST OF PATIENTS WITH CHRONIC PAIN IN
URBAN AREA
Sicras-Mainar A1, Navarro-Artieda R2, Villoria-Morillo J3, Esquivias-Escobar A4
1
Directorate of Planning, Badalona, Barcelona, Spain; 2Hospital Germans Trias i Pujol,
CIBEREHD, Barcelona, Spain; 3Medicxact, Alpedrete, Madrid, Spain; 4Grünenthal Pharma SA,
Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Chronic pain is gaining importance as a major cost factor in health
care. To gather information about analgesic pharmacotherapy of patients with chronic
pain and perform cost estimations to guide future cost-effectiveness research in the
area. METHODS: Data from patients aged above 44 years suffering from any chronic
condition and receiving regular analgesic pharmacotherapy (≥6 months) who attended
health care facilities within the area of Badalona during 2008 were collected in a
retrospective study. Morbidity profiles were defined according to treatment setting
(pain unit, hospital), WHO analgesic stage (1–2 versus 3), and a raw cost model based
on resource use and work absenteeism was applied. Patients attending the pain unit
or the hospital were considered undertreated if they were on stage 1–2 analgesics.
Multiple regression was used to compare costs between undertreated and non-undertreated patients among those attending the pain unit or the hospital. RESULTS: Just
410 out of 18,157 patients ascertained (2.3%) were on stage 3 analgesics. Direct
health care costs were greater in patients on Step 3 analgesics (mean [SD]: 5,505.6
[5,046.4] ) than in patients on Steps 1 and/or 2 analgesics (c2,407.4 [2,436.2]), but
not indirect costs (c258.5 [1,578.4] vs. c279.5 [1,423.6], respectively). Of patients
attended in the pain unit and the hospital, 2.3% and 20.1%, respectively, were considered undertreated. Regression analyses revealed even greater costs in the subgroup
of undertreated patients. CONCLUSIONS: Conclusion: Stage 3 analgesics are barely
used. Up to one-fifth of patients may be undertreated, and prompted greater costs
than those judged as properly treated. Regression analyses did not clarify what proportion of their cost excess was attributable to undertreatment.
13th Euro Abstracts
PSY27
A HEALTH ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF THE SWITCH OF
ERYTHROPOIESIS-STIMULATING AGENTS (ESAS) IN PATIENTS WITH
RENAL FAILURE UNDERGOING HEMODIALYSIS
Chevalier P1, Lamotte M1, Leenaerts P2
1
IMS Health Consulting, Brussels, Belgium; 2Ziekenhuis Oost-Limburg, Genk, Limburg,
Belgium
OBJECTIVES: Different erythropoiesis-stimulating agents (ESAs) are used to correct
anaemia in hemodialyzed patients. There is conflicting evidence on whether the dose
needed to obtain the same hemoglobin level differs between ESAs. This study assessed
the changes in ESA dose and the differences in cost of treatment when patients were
switched from epoetin beta (EB) to darbepoetin alfa (DA). METHODS: A monocentre retrospective chart review was performed. All hemodialysis patients switched
from EB to DA during the first week of January 2008. The dose conversion from EB
to used was 200 IU:1 µg based on the European DA label. In patients dialyzed for at
least 9 months at conversion, ESA dose and hemoglobin level were collected 3 months
prior (baseline) to 12 months after conversion. The ratio “average weekly ESA dose/
average weekly hemoglobin level”, the average weekly ESA-drug-related cost per
patient (Belgian public payer’s perspective), the average weekly dose of ESA and the
average weekly hemoglobin were compared for the baseline period vs. weeks 14–26
and 40–52 post-switch using the Wilcoxon signed rank test. RESULTS: Out of 144
screened patients, 96 were eligible and survived without renal transplantation until
week 52. The ratio “average weekly ESA dose/average weekly hemoglobin level”
decreased from 611 IU/g/dL to respectively 359 IU/g/dL and 348 IU/g/dL in the
defined post-switch periods (P < 0.0001), without any change in average hemoglobin.
a substantial reduction in drug cost was observed after switch (from c66.8 to c53.6
and c52.8/week). The average weekly ESA dose decreased from baseline to post-switch
from 7230 IU to 4203 IU and 4137 IU (P < 0.0001). Both ESA dosing and hemoglobin
were stabilised after a 13-weeks titration period post-switch. CONCLUSIONS:
Switching patients from EB to DA resulted in a significant decrease of the ESA dose
needed to obtain the same hemoglobin level. This significant decrease in dosage
resulted in a substantial decrease in drug costs.
PSY28
COST OF INHIBITOR DEVELOPMENT IN PATIENTS WITH SEVERE
HEMOPHILIA A IN SPAIN
Lucía JF1, Romero JA2, Febrer L3, Trabal I3, Sabater J4, Lindner L4
1
Hospital Miguel Servet, Zaragoza, Aragón, Spain; 2Hospital Universitario La Paz, Madrid,
Madrid, Spain; 3Bayer Healthcare, Barcelona, Spain; 4IMS Health, Barcelona, Catalunya, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Risk and consequences of inhibitor (antibodies) development in
patients with hemophilia are the main safety issue in patients treated with recombinant
drugs, due to its impact on health and quality of patient’s life. The objective of this
study is to quantify the economical impact of treating A-hemophiliac patients developing inhibitors against factor VIII (FVIII) for the National Health System (NHS) in
Spain. METHODS: An economical model was built as a decision tree allowing assigning the resource use to handle inhibitor development and its associated cost in different
patient groups according to its age, treatment pattern and response profile. Data was
obtained from a literature review and validated by an experts’ panel. a one-way
sensitivity analysis was performed to check for results robustness. RESULTS: The
mean annual cost per patient suffering from severe hemophilia a developing inhibitors
against FVIII in Spain was c567,518 (EUR 2009), 99% due to pharmacological costs.
Results show an important variability, from c166,845 to c2,408,486 depending on
the type of patient: its age related to its weight and adequate treatment dosage, its
inhibitors’ titer (low or high-titer) and its treatment (on demand or to eradicate inhibitors). The number of bleeding episodes was the variable with the greatest impact on
results. According to population data and illness incidence, a 5% increase on the risk
of inhibitor development implies a new case per year in Spanish population and,
therefore, an expenditure of more than half a million Euro for the NHS. CONCLUSIONS: This study analyzes for the first time the cost of inhibitors’ development
among patients with severe hemophilia a treated with recombinant FVIII from the
perspective of the Spanish NHS. Results show that treatments to overcome this safety
issue represent an important economical burden, so that strategies preventing from
inhibitor development should be implemented in this population.
PSY29
DARBEPOETIN ALFA VERSUS EPOETIN ALFA FOR TREATMENT OF
CHEMOTHERAPY-INDUCED ANEMIA: A HEALTH ECONOMIC
EVALUATION
Finek J1, Holubec L1, Wiesnerova A1, Pav Z1, Dusek L2
1
Teaching Hospital and Medical Faculty of Charles University, Plzen, Czech Republic;
2
Masaryk University Brno, Brno, Czech Republic
OBJECTIVES: Erythropoiesis-stimulating proteins (ESPs) are used in the treatment of
chemotherapy-induced anemia (CIA) with the aim of improving quality of life and
reducing the need for blood transfusions. a retrospective analysis based on data from
a single institution compared costs and effectiveness of two ESPs, epoetin alfa and
darbepoetin alfa, in consecutively treated patients over a 2-year period. METHODS:
Data from all patients treated for CIA between January 1, 2007 and December 31,
2008 with one of the two ESPs—epoetin alfa- (40 000 IU once weekly) or darbepoetin
alfa- (500 µg every 3 weeks)—were analyzed. Total and per patient costs and costs
per clinical response (hemoglobin ≥ 11 g/dL) were calculated, based on drug acquisition costs for the ESPs. RESULTS: A total of 161 patients were treated with epoetin
A465
alfa (799 doses; mean 4.96 doses per patient) and 52 with darbepoetin alfa (94 doses;
mean 1.81 doses per patient). Total and per-patient costs were 8,682,226 CZK
(c331,003.66) and 54,461 CZK (c2076.29) for epoetin alfa versus 2,578,984 CZK
(c98,321.92) and 49,596 CZK (c1,890.81) for darbepoetin alfa. The response rate
was higher (58% vs. 47%, not statistically significant), and the mean cost per treatment response was lower, with darbepoetin alfa, at 85,966 CZK (c3,277.39) versus
115,763 CZK (c4,413.38) for epoetin alfa. CONCLUSIONS: Our results indicate that
darbepoetin alfa is associated with lower drug acquisition costs than epoetin alfa, as
well as a lower cost per treatment response, for treatment of CIA.
PSY30
ONE-YEAR-LONG TREATMENT OF FAILED BACK SURGERY SYNDROME
WITH SPINAL CORD STIMULATION: COSTS AND BENEFITS IN THE
ITALIAN CONTEXT (PRECISE STUDY)
Beccagutti G1, Zucco F2, Lavano A3, De Rose M3, Poli P4, Fortini G5, Demartini L6, De Simone
E7, Menardo V8, Cisotto P9, Meglio M10, Grifi M1, De Santo T11, Costantini A12
1
Medtronic Italia, Sesto San Giovanni, Italy; 2Azienda Ospedaliera Salvini, Garbagnate
Milanese, Italy; 3Università Magna Grecia, Catanzaro, Italy; 4Azienda Ospedaliera Universitaria
Pisana, Pisa, Italy; 5Azienda Ospedaliero Universitaria Ospedale di Circolo e Fondazione
Macchi, Varese, Italy; 6IRCCS Fondazione Salvatore Maugeri, Pavia, Italy; 7A.O.R.N. “S.G.
Moscati”, Avellino, Italy; 8A.S.O. “S. Croce e Carle, Cuneo, Italy; 9Ospedale “S. Maria di Cà
Foncello”, Treviso, Italy; 10Policlinico Gemelli, Roma, Italy; 11Medtronic Italia, Roma, Italy;
12
Ospedale Clinicizzato “SS Annunziata”, Chieti, Italy
OBJECTIVES: Spinal Cord Stimulation (SCS) is considered to be an effective therapy
for patients affected by Failed Back Surgery Syndrome refractory to conventional
medical management (CMM). PRECISE Study aims to evaluate the costs and clinical
benefits of SCS (plus CMM) versus CMM alone on a 2-year horizon in Italy. Here
12-months results are reported. METHODS: PRECISE Study is an observational,
pre-post, multi-centre study. Eighty patients were enrolled to be screened for SCS and,
if responders, to be implanted. Health care and non-health care resources use and
costs, clinical outcomes and HR-QoL data were collected before and after the implantation. The 12-months data was analyzed and compared to pre-implantation results.
Mean monthly resources use, costed in euros 2008, was evaluated according to three
perspectives: patient, National Healthcare System (NHS), Society. RESULTS: Seventytwo (90%) patients responded to screening and were implanted. Out of them, 62
(mean age 57; 61% female) completed the 12-months follow-up; ten patients discontinued the therapy for: therapy failure (10%), complications/technical issues (60%),
other reasons (30%). SCS significantly reduced pain, and improved function and
HR-QoL: mean pain intensity decreased from 7.4 ± 1.3 to 4.4 ± 2.5 (pain Numerical
Rating Scale), 53 patients (85%) experienced an improvement in function measured
with Oswestry Disability Index and EQ-VAS increased from 37 to 59. The mean utility
score was 0.49 (baseline: 011). Patient’s monthly out-of-pocket expenditure halved
from c161.45 to c80.04. Excluding upfront costs (screening and implantation), total
NHS monthly per-patient expenditure diminished from c163.77 to c100.17, Society
monthly per-patient expenditure from c461.89 to c253.27. Including them, NHS
and Societal monthly costs per-patient were c1,318.30 and c1,471.40, respectively.
CONCLUSIONS: SCS with CMM is more effective than CMM alone in controlling
pain and improving HR-QoL. Excluding the upfront costs related to the implantation,
SCS allows a reduction in resources consumption and productivity losses from all the
possible perspectives of analysis (patient, NHS, Society).
PSY31
POSACONAZOLE VS. FLUCONAZOLE OR ITRACONAZOLE FOR THE
PREVENTION OF FUNGAL INFECTIONS IN CANCER PATIENTS WITH
PROLONGED NEUTROPENIA: A COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS
Dranitsaris G
Augmentium Pharma Consulting, Toronto, ON, Canada
OBJECTIVES: Invasive fungal infections (IFI) remain a clinical concern in hematological cancer patients with prolonged neutropenia because they are major cause of
morbidity and mortality. As a result, the guidelines of the International Society of
Infectious Diseases recommend adequate prophylaxis while the patient remains neutropenic. In this study, a cost-effectiveness analysis was conducted to measure the
economic value of posaconazole as an alternative to fluconazole or itraconazole when
used to prevent IFI in this patent population. METHODS: A decision analysis model
was developed using clinical and economic data from randomized comparative trials,
the economic literature and from expert opinion. The data were then used to estimate
the incremental cost per life-year saved with oral posaconazole prophylaxis relative
to fluconazole or itraconazole from the Canadian provincial health care system perspective. The base-case results were then tested with an extensive sensitivity analysis
which evaluated extremes in the incidence of IFI as well as variations in their cost of
management. RESULTS: The base-case findings revealed that prophylaxis with
posaconazole provides at least comparable efficacy and an overall cost savings of
approximately $4260 per patient. Despite variations in the base-case parameters, the
sensitivity analysis suggested stability in the primary findings. Posaconazole was associated with an overall cost savings (range = $1765 to $5118) and at least comparable
benefit. Optimal cost-effectiveness was obtained when the drug was able to avoid more
invasive Aspergillus infections. CONCLUSIONS: Prophylaxis with posaconazole in
neutropenic hematological cancer patients is not only cost-effective but also cost
saving. The economic benefits were due to the drug’s ability to reduce the incidence
of high cost fungal infections, particularly Aspergillus species.
A466
PSY32
THE COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF ELTROMBOPAG FOR THE TREATMENT
OF CHRONIC ADULT IMMUNE THROMBOCYTOPENIC PURPURA (ITP)
IN IRELAND
Hanley RM1, Redmond S1, Thompson G2
1
GlaxoSmithKline, Dublin, Ireland; 2GlaxoSmithKline, Uxbridge, UK
OBJECTIVES: Immune thrombocytopenia (ITP) is a rare autoimmune disorder characterised by low platelet counts resulting in symptoms that are usually minor, e.g.
petechiae. However, patients with very low platelet counts face the risk of serious,
but rare, bleeds, e.g. intracranial hemorrhage. The study objective was to estimate the
cost-effectiveness of treating two groups of chronic adult ITP patients (refractory to
splenectomy and where splenectomy is contraindicted) with oral eltrombopag versus
romiplostim or rituximab from an Irish health care payer perspective. METHODS: A
Markov model with a four week model cycle, two year time horizon and seven health
states was used. In one arm, patients were treated with eltrombopag and in the other
romiplostim or rituximab. Patients began in either the ‘controlled platelet’ or ‘uncontrolled platelet’ health states. Response rates from clinical trials (eltrombopag and
romiplostim) and a published literature review (rituximab) determined whether
patients were controlled or not. Controlled patients experienced a higher level of utility
and lower risk of transitioning to bleed health states. Utilities (using the SF-36v2) for
controlled/uncontrolled platelet levels were from the eltrombopag pivotal trial, RAISE.
Utility for bleeds and costs were taken from the literature. Costs and benefits were
discounted by 4%. RESULTS: The model estimated that eltrombopag dominates
romiplostim, i.e. cost savings of c13,000 and c18,000 with an incremental QALY of
0.1 and 0.03 for patients who are refractory to splenectomy and where splenectomy
is contraindicated respectively. This result was driven by the fact that eltrombopag is
less expensive, does not incur wastage or administration costs and has slightly better
durable response rates compared to romiplostim. Eltrombopag is not cost-effective
compared to rituximab for both groups of patients because rituximab is significantly
less costly than eltrombopag with comparable response rates. CONCLUSIONS: The
economic model showed that eltrombopag dominates romiplostim but is not costeffective versus rituximab.
PSY33
EARLY STAGE ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF PHARMACOGENOMICBASED DIAGNOSTICS IN CHRONIC MYELOID LEUKEMIA
Gaultney J1, Sanhueza E2, Janssen JJWM3, Redekop WK1, Uyl-De Groot C1
1
Institute for Medical Techonology Assessment (iMTA), Rotterdam, The Netherlands;
2
Facultad de Medicina Universidad Católica de Chile, Santiago, Chile; 3VU University Medical
Center, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: Uncertainty regarding the effectiveness of tyrosine kinase inhibitors
(TKIs) for treatment of chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) has resulted in difficulty for
some appraisal committees to recommend second-line TKIs. Implementation of pharmacogenomic-based diagnostics may facilitate individualized treatment with TKIs and
improve overall treatment effectiveness. The objective of this economic evaluation was
to estimate the potential cost-effectiveness of a companion diagnostic that predicts
treatment response in CML patients eligible for dasatinib and nilotinib. METHODS:
A decision analytic model was created to assess the cost-effectiveness of individualized
treatment with dasatinib and nilotinib using a companion diagnostic test relative to
current care (i.e., treat all patients with dasatinib until progression or no response,
then treat with nilotinib). Transition probabilities and utility values were taken from
published RCTs. The cost analysis included costs of treatment, response monitoring
and the companion diagnostic. Scenario analyses were conducted to assess the impact
of unavailable or highly uncertain values. RESULTS: Total costs and effects for the
base-case analysis were c99,011 and 1.84 progression-free LYs (PF-LYs) and 1.63
QALYs with the companion diagnostic strategy after a 2-year time horizon. In the
current care situation, total costs and effects were c100,904 and 1.74 PF-LYs and
1.61 QALYs. The companion diagnostic was the dominant strategy with a savings of
approximately c4,000/PF-LY or c2,000/QALY. Scenario analyses revealed that the
cost-effectiveness of the companion diagnostic is sensitive to time to response, time to
progression and comparative effectiveness between dasatinib and nilotinib. CONCLUSIONS: Treatment of CML patients eligible for second-line TKIs using a companion
diagnostic may be cost-effective. More precise estimates for uncertain or unavailable
parameters should be incorporated when available. This case demonstrates the use of
economic evaluation methods at early stages of technology development for internal
decision-making and communicating the potential value of pharmacogenomic-based
diagnostics to stakeholders.
PSY34
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF TAPENTADOL PROLONGED-RELEASE (PR)
COMPARED TO OXYCODONE AND MORPHINE IN PATIENTS WITH
CHRONIC MODERATE TO SEVERE NON-CANCER PAIN IN SWEDEN
Hertel N1, Ikenberg R1, Fricke FU1, Liedgens H2
1
IMS Health GmbH & Co. OHG, Nuremberg, Germany; 2Gruenenthal GmbH, Aachen,
Germany
OBJECTIVES: To assess the cost-effectiveness of tapentadol compared to oxycodone
and morphine as 1st line strong opioid therapy in chronic non-cancer pain (CNCP)
patients in Sweden. METHODS: A Markov transition state model over one year with
cycle times of one month was built. Four health states were defined: ‘occurrence of
adverse events (AEs) with need for medical treatment’, ‘withdrawal due to AEs’,
‘response to therapy’ and ‘death’. If patients did not adequately respond to tapentadol
13th Euro Abstracts
or comparators or withdrew, switching to alternative 2nd line opioid (oxycodone,
morphine or transdermal fentanyl) was considered. After initiating 3rd line therapy,
patients could stay on this therapy or die according to morbidity rate. Data regarding
efficacy, tolerability and utility values (EQ-5D) were derived from clinical trials and
published literature. Switch rates to subsequent opioid therapies and resource consumption were estimated by clinical experts. Costs were calculated from the societal
perspective. Direct costs were calculated based on official Swedish prices/tariffs, indirect costs were calculated based on figures obtained from the literature and current
wage rates. Costs and benefits were not discounted in base-case calculation. Impact
of selected parameters on the results was evaluated in one-way sensitivity analyses
(OWSA). RESULTS: Mean annual total costs per patient amount to 242,583 SEK
(Swedish krona) for tapentadol vs. 247,813 SEK for oxycodone and 246,093 SEK for
morphine. Tapentadol generates 0.4712 QALYs compared to 0.4518 QALYs for
oxycodone and 0.4535 QALYs for morphine. More QALYs generated in the model
reflect tapentadol’s better tolerability profile than comparators. Cost parameter comprising physician visits, co-medications and non-drug therapy costs revealed highest
impact in OWSA. CONCLUSIONS: Tapentadol, once approved, will generate more
QALYs at lower costs than oxycodone and morphine. Tapentadol appears to be the
favourable treatment option in the 1st line therapy of CNCP patients in Sweden from
a societal perspective.
PSY35
THE COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF DULOXETINE IN THE TREATMENT OF
FIBROMYALGIA IN THE UNITED STATES
Beard S1, Le TK2, Zhao Y2, Roskell N3
1
RTI Health Solutions, Sheffield, UK; 2Eli Lilly & Company, Indianapolis, IN, USA; 3RTI Health
Solutions, Manchester, UK
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of duloxetine for the management
of fibromyalgia assessed from the perspective of a health care payer in the United
States. METHODS: A Markov model was used to evaluate the economic and clinical
advantages in controlling fibromyalgia pain symptoms, considering duloxetine as an
additional treatment option. The standard treatment sequence was defined based on
clinical guidelines including tricyclic antidepressants (TCAs), second-generation antidepressants (based on SNRIs), anticonvulsants, and opioid therapies. The model
included 2 levels of pain response (a ≥30% and ≥50% change from baseline, using a
standard 11-point severity scale). Clinical efficacy and discontinuation data were taken
from a systematic literature review and mixed treatment comparison, including both
placebo and active controlled trials. Utility data were linked to pain severity using
trial-based EQ5D data. Discounting was applied at 3.0% per year. RESULTS: The
introduction of duloxetine resulted in additional symptom-controlled months (SCMs),
defined as the amount of time at a ≥30% response level, and quality-adjusted life-years
(QALYs), over a 2-year time horizon. First-line treatment resulted in an additional
665 SCMs and 12.3 QALYs, with a cost of $582,911 ($877 per SCM and $47,560
per QALY). Second-line treatment resulted in an additional 460 SCMs and 8.7
QALYs, with a cost of $143,752 ($312 per SMC and $16,565 per QALY). a costeffectiveness frontier analysis suggested that second-line duloxetine is likely to be the
most cost-effective option, however, in sensitivity analyses, the cost-effectiveness of
first-line duloxetine improved when assumptions around continued treatment switching for long-term drop-outs were relaxed. CONCLUSIONS: There is currently a
significant unmet need for patients with poorly controlled fibromyalgia where pain is
a predominant symptom. These analyses show that the introduction of duloxetine into
the standard treatment sequence for fibromyalgia can provide additional patient
benefits, which are cost-effective when compared to commonly adopted thresholds.
PSY36
ASSESSING THE COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF PRIMARY PROPHYLAXIS
FOR THE TREATMENT OF SEVERE HEMOPHILIA A
Axelsen F1, Miners A2
1
Baxter Healthcare SA, Zurich, Switzerland; 2London School of Hygiene and Tropical
Medicine, London, UK
OBJECTIVES: The objective of this analysis was to understand the economic consequences of different products in primary prophylaxis in severe hemophilia A patients.
Miners’ (2002, 2009) hemophilia economic Markov model was revised to compare
two different factor VIII products—a full-length recombinant FVIII (Advate) and a B
domain-deleted recombinant FVIII (BDDrFVIII) (Refacto AF). Based on documented
differences in half life in a pharmacokinetic cross-over license study [1] with results
submitted to EMA[2], this research evaluated the amount of clotting factor required
to maintain the patient factor VIII trough levels above 1%. If a product has a shorter
half-life, more clotting factor is required to prevent factor VIII levels falling below the
minimum trough level. METHODS: The same basic model structure of Miners’
hemophilia economic Markov model was used to analyze the effects of differences in
half-life in an Italian economic country setting, full-length recombinant FVIII (Advate)
half-life 13.3 hours at a list price of c0.75 per IU versus BDDrFVIII (Refacto AF)
half-life 11.2 hours at a list price of c0.69 per IU. The model considers the amount
of factor required to prevent trough clotting factor levels from falling below 1%.
RESULTS: The analysis estimated that the mean expected, discounted lifetime (70
years) cost of primary prophylaxis in a severe hemophilia A patient was c0.88 million
less using full length recombinant FVIII (Advate) when compared to a BDDrFVIII
(Refacto AF), assuming a 2.1 hour shorter half-life; i.e. equal to over c12,500 in cost
savings per patient per year. CONCLUSIONS: This analysis shows that prophylaxis
therapy using full-length recombinant FVIII (Advate) may be cost saving compared to
13th Euro Abstracts
BDDrFVIII (Refacto AF) based on the difference in half-life reported, even if BDDrFVIII has a lower price per IU. [1] Recht et al. Hemophilia 2009:1–12; [2] EMA
Assessment report Refacto AF. London March 2009. http://www.ema.europa.eu/
humandocs/PDFs/EPAR/Refacto/refactoaf-H-232-II-59-68-AR.pdf
PSY37
COST-EFFECTIVENESS AND BUDGET IMPACT ANALYSIS OF OROS
HYDROMORPHONE IN PATIENTS WITH CHRONIC CANCER PAIN
FROM THE PUBLIC PAYER PERSPECTIVE IN BRAZIL
Fernandes RA1, Takemoto ML1, Guerra FC1, Passos RB1, Pereira ML2, Morais AD2
1
ANOVA—Knowledge Translation, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil; 2Janssen-Cilag, São Paulo, SP,
Brazil
OBJECTIVES: To conduct cost-effectiveness and budget impact analysis (BIA) of
OROS hydromorphone versus CR morphine and CR oxycodone for moderate to
severe cancer pain from the public payer perspective in Brazil. METHODS: A decision
tree followed by a Markov Model with a 12 month time horizon was developed with
data from the Phase III trial Hanna 2008. The achievement of mild pain (worst pain
scores < 4) was considered as outcome. Only direct medical costs were considered and
unit costs were obtained from Brazilian official lists. For the BIA, 10% of currently
used CR morphine daily doses was substituted for equivalent OROS hydromorphone
doses. The same rational was adopted for CR oxycodone comparison. Univariate
deterministic sensitivity analyses showed that the results remained consistent through
model parameters variation. RESULTS: OROS hydromorphone showed 1.66 additional months in mild pain per patient per year when compared to both CR morphine
and CR oxycodone. Annual treatment costs were 2.401 BRL, 1.256 BRL and 5.114
BRL for OROS hydromorphone, CR morphine and CR oxycodone respectively. The
incremental cost-effectiveness ratio was 689 BRL per additional month in mild pain
per patient per year, when OROS hydromorphone was compared to CR morphine.
Versus CR oxycodone, OROS hydromorphone was more effective with fewer costs,
being cost saving (ICER -1,634 BRL). BIA results showed that the substitution of 10%
of current utilization of CR morphine for OROS hydromorphone and CR oxycodone
would result in a budgetary impact of 118,722 BRL and 347,295 BRL, respectively.
CONCLUSIONS: OROS hydromorphone is cost saving when compared to CR oxycodone and is more cost-effective than CR oxycodone when both are compared to
the current scenario of chronic cancer pain treatment with CR morphine, with a lower
budgetary impact.
PSY38
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF GOLIMUMAB IN ANKYLOSING SPONDYLITIS
FROM THE UK PAYER PERSPECTIVE
Muszbek N1, Punekar Y2, Buchanan J3, Prasad M4, Vioix H1, Brown R1
1
United BioSource Corporation, London, UK; 2Schering Plough, Welwyn Garden City, UK;
3
Johnson & Johnson Pharmaceutical Services, LLC, Malvern, PA, USA; 4Merck & Co,
Kenilworth, NJ, USA
OBJECTIVES: Golimumab is a novel TNF-α inhibitor for treatment of patients with
severe active ankylosing spondylitis (AS). This study evaluated the cost-effectiveness
of golimumab and its appropriate comparators in the treatment of AS from UK
National Health Service perspective. METHODS: A Markov model with an initial
decision tree was developed to simulate the progression of a hypothetical cohort of
active AS patients for 20 years. The primary outcome measure was quality-adjusted
life-years (QALYs) estimated using Bath Ankylosing Spondilytis Functional Index
(BASFI) whereas the primary response measure was ≥50% improvement in Bath
Ankylosing Spondilytis Disease Activity Index (BASDAI) at 12 weeks. Direct costs
including medication costs and AS management costs were included. Golimumab was
compared with conventional treatment and other TNF-α inhibitors. Costs and outcomes were discounted at 3.5%. RESULTS: All TNF-α inhibitors were superior to
conventional treatment and comparable to each other on BASDAI response. The
incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) for golimumab was £15,353 per QALY
compared to conventional treatment. The probability of golimumab being cost-effective at a threshold of £30,000/QALY was 92%. Compared to etanercept and adalimumab, golimumab generated marginally more QALYs at marginally more costs.
CONCLUSIONS: Golimumab may be considered as a cost-effective treatment alternative for patients with AS. With comparable costs and efficacy to other TNF-α inhibitors, golimumab’s position in the treatment pathway is likely to be driven by patient
and physician choice.
PSY39
REAL-WORLD COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF BORTEZOMIB IN RELAPSED
OR REFRACTORY MULTIPLE MYELOMA IN THE NETHERLANDS
Gaultney J1, Franken M1, Huijgens PC2, Sonneveld P3, Uyl-De Groot C1, Redekop WK1
1
Institute for Medical Techonology Assessment (iMTA), Rotterdam, The Netherlands; 2VU
University Medical Center, Amsterdam, The Netherlands; 3Erasmus University Medical
Center, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: The Dutch reimbursement policy for expensive inpatient medicines
requires outcomes research after four years of temporary reimbursement. Based on a
retrospective study, we explored the cost-effectiveness of bortezomib for relapsed/
refractory multiple myeloma in Dutch daily practice. METHODS: Detailed clinical
data from a real-world cohort of 72 patients treated with bortezomib and 67 patients
never treated with bortezomib were collected from medical records. Validity of the
incremental cost-effectiveness was assessed by comparing baseline prognosis between
bortezomib and non-bortezomib patients. Clinical effectiveness was evaluated by
A467
comparing Kaplan-Meier survival estimates. Costs of resource use from a hospital
perspective were based on patient-level data. RESULTS: Prognostic factors for bortezomib patients were significantly different compared to non-bortezomib patients.
Incremental analyses for bortezomib versus non-bortezomib patients were therefore
not performed. Total mean costs and median survival from start of relapsed/refractory
treatment for bortezomib patients were c84,042 and 33.2 months. Bortezomib
accounted for 21% of total costs among these patients. For non-bortezomib patients,
total mean costs and median survival from start of relapsed/refractory treatment were
c54,435 and 21.6 months. The proportion of patients still in follow-up at the end of
data collection was slightly higher in bortezomib versus non-bortezomib patients
(51% vs. 46%). Total mean costs for bortezomib patients did not differ significantly
when excluding patients still in follow-up. For non-bortezomib patients, total mean
costs differed significantly when excluding patients still in follow-up, mainly due to
high costs of lenalidomide treatment, stem cell transplants and inpatient hospital stays.
CONCLUSIONS: Our real-world data challenged the assessment of the incremental
cost-effectiveness of bortezomib versus other treatments in the indication of relapsed/
refractory multiple myeloma. It was possible to estimate the cost and effects for
bortezomib patients in daily practice to determine the real-world value. Data synthesis
incorporating effectiveness for the relevant comparator might facilitate estimation of
a valid ICER.
PSY40
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF PREGABALIN VERSUS USUAL CARE IN
REFRACTORY OUT-PATIENTS WITH NEUROPATIC PAIN FOLLOWED
IN PRIMARY CARE SETTINGS
de Salas-Cansado M1, Pérez C2, Saldaña MT3, Navarro A4, Rejas J5
1
Trial Form Support Spain, Madrid, Spain; 2Pain Clinic, Hospital de la Princesa, Madrid, Spain;
3
Primary Care Health Centre Raíces, Castrillón, Asturias, Spain; 4Primary Care Health Centre
Puerta del Ángel, Madrid, Spain; 5Pfizer España, Alcobendas/Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Estimate the cost-effectiveness of Pregabalin (PGB) versus Usual Care
(UC) in refractory out-patients with Neuropathic Pain (NeP) treated according to
usual medical practice in Primary Care settings (PCS) in Spain. METHODS: Data
extracted from a 12-week non-interventional prospective study conducted to ascertain
the cost of NeP were used. PGB naïve patients treated with UC or PGB, matched by
age (+5 years), sex and pain intensity (+5 pts), refractory (≥40VAS-McGill) to previous
treatment during the prior 6 months, were selected in a 1:1 ratio. Patients could switch
to PGB (monotherapy/add-on) or to UC (non-narcotics, opiates, antidepressants and/
or anticonvulsants). Time horizon was 12 weeks. Effectiveness was quality-adjusted
life-years (QALY) gain. Perspectives of the National Health Service (NHS) and society
(2006) were included, and expressed as an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER).
Bootstrapping techniques (10,000 re-samples) were used to obtain the probabilistic
ICER, its 95% percentile confidence interval (CI) and the cost-effectiveness acceptability curve. RESULTS: A total of 160 patient-pairs were extracted. Compared with
UC, PGB was associated with significantly higher QALY gain; 0.0374 ± 0.0367 vs.
0.0224 ± 0.0313 (P < 0.001). Notably, although drug costs were higher for PGB (c251
± 125 vs. c104 ± 121, P < 0.001), its QALY gain did not incur a higher overall total
cost (c1335 ± 1302 vs. c1387 ± 1489; P = 0.587), nor higher health care costs (c529
± 438 vs. c560 ± 672; p = 0.628). In fact, the ICER was dominant for total and health
care costs, with CIs respectively, dominant-c17,268, and dominant-c6,508. ICER for
drug costs was c10,672/QALY (dominant-c19,858). The 99% of the re-samples were
below the threshold of c30,000/QALY. CONCLUSIONS: Versus usual care in the
community medical setting, pregabalin is highly cost-effective in the treatment of
refractory NeP patients. The high indirect costs and increased health care costs associated with the treatment of refractory patients, which offset higher cost of pregabalin,
highlight the economic burden of the condition on society.
PSY41
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF BIOLOGICS IN PSORIASIS IN TWO LA
COUNTRIES—COMPARISON WITH THE EUROPEAN EXPERIENCE
Alandete JC
Janssen-Cilag, Bogota, Colombia
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate cost-effectiveness of biologics used in patients with psoriasis in Colombia and Peru. METHODS: We estimated direct costs of etanercept,
adalimumab, ustekinumab and infliximab based on their labels for first/induction year
and second/maintenance year (EUR1 = COL$2340 = SOL$357). For etanercept we
considered two induction schemes: 50 mg weekly 52 weeks-D1- and 100 mg 12 weeks
followed by 50 mg 40 weeks-D2-. Effectiveness was evaluated as 75% reduction in
Psoriasis Area and Severity Index-PASI 75- from meta-analysis presented by Hawkins
et al. in the 14th International ISPOR: infliximab = 80%; ustekinumab = 69%; adalimumab = 59%; etanerceptD2- = 52%; etanerceptD1 = 39%. Infliximab and
ustekinumab effectiveness were not significantly different. However, both were significantly superior to etanercept (D1 and D2). RESULTS: In Colombia, Ustekinumab was
dominant (c29.012 in 2 years) generating cost savings of −c4.416 vs. etanerceptD1;
−c7.411 vs. adalimumab; −c8.119 vs. etanerceptD2 and −c25,340 vs. infliximab; with
higher or same effectiveness than the other biologics used in that country. In Peru, all
the options were more effective and more costly than the standard of care (etanerceptD1). The ICER per patient with PASI 75 of etanerceptD2, adalimumab,
ustekinumab and infliximab, compared to etanerceptD1 were c21.654; c19,860,
c13,036 and c29,008, respectively. Then, the efficiency frontier was formed by etanerceptD1, ustekinumab and infliximab. Given evidence shows the last two products
do not have effectiveness significant differences, ustekinumab became the dominant
A468
option. An additional analysis was done supposing that infliximab’s effectiveness was
superior to ustekinumab’s. The ICER per patient with PASI 75 between these products
was c220,352 in Colombia and c50,989 in Peru. These values were higher than
Colombian and Peruvian health systems’ willingness to pay per PASI 75 (c40.334 and
c29,242, respectively), calculated based on average effectiveness and costs of biologics.
CONCLUSIONS: In the studied LA countries, Ustekinumab resulted the most costeffective biologic, even being cost-saving in Colombia. These results corroborate those
observed in European countries.
PSY42
COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS OF BIOLOGICS IN THE TREATMENT
OF MODERATE TO SEVERE PSORIASIS IN THE PUBLIC HEALTH CARE
SYSTEM OF BRAZIL
Morais AD, Ribeiro F
Janssen-Cilag, São Paulo, SP, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: To compare treatment costs and cost-effectiveness results for biologics
approved for the treatment of moderate to severe psoriasis from the perspective of a
public payer in Brazil. METHODS: Annual treatment costs were calculated based on
the number of vials used, as defined in the label for each biologic, and from the price
per vial. The prices of etanercept, adalimumab and infliximab were obtained from
purchase disclosures by the Brazilian Ministry of Health. As ustekinumab, the latest
biologic approved for psoriasis, has not yet been purchased by that Ministry, its list
price after deducting the mandatory discount for government sales (22.85%) was
considered. The effectiveness of each treatment was defined by a recent metanalysis
as the PASI75 response at the primary endpoint for each drug. The average patient
weight was assumed at 70 kg. RESULTS: Ustekinumab has the lowest treatment cost
across the biologics in both induction and maintenance years with the least number
of vials used. With a total of 4 applications during a maintenance year, ustekinumab
has the lowest treatment cost, followed by infliximab (55% more expensive), adalimumab (62% more expensive) and etanercept (75% more expensive). Combining the
cost and effectiveness results, ustekinumab has the lowest cost per response, followed
by infliximab (44% less cost-effective), adalimumab (104% lesss cost-effective) and
etanercept (152% less cost-effective). CONCLUSIONS: With the lowest treatment
cost, ustekinumab is an important treatment option in moderate to severe psoriasis.
When comparing the cost-per-response across biologics, ustekinumab is further differentiated from the remaining biologics. Ustekinumab represents a rare situation in
Brazil combining the lowest treatment cost and a high effectiveness result.
PSY43
ECONOMIC ANALYSIS OF RITUXIMAB IN COMBINATION WITH
CYCLOPHOSPHAMIDE, VINCRISTINE AND PREDNISOLONE IN THE
TREATMENT OF PATIENTS WITH ADVANCED FOLLICULAR
LYMPHOMA IN PORTUGAL
Pereira C1, Negreiro F2, Silva C2
1
Roche Farmacêutica Quimica, Portugal, Amadora, Portugal, 2Eurotrials—Consultores
Científicos, Lisbon, Portugal
OBJECTIVES: Evaluate costs and benefits of rituximab in combination with cyclophosphamide/vincristine/prednisolone chemotherapy regimen (R-CVP) versus CVP alone in
previously untreated patients with indolent non-Hodgkin lymphoma (NHL).
METHODS: Cost-effectiveness (Life-years Gained—LYG) and cost-utility analysis
(Quality Adjusted Life-years—QALYs) were performed for a time horizon of 10 years
according to a Markov economic model with three health states (“progression free
survival”, “progression” and “death”) and monthly cycles. Data from a phase III clinical
trial (Marcus R. et al 2007) was used and expanded in the model to include unpublished
53-month median follow-up data. Survival after first-line therapy was estimated from
the Scotland and Newcastle Lymphoma Group registry data and utilities were derived
from a UK study. Resource consumption was estimated by a Portuguese expert panel.
Costs were calculated from the Portuguese Health System perspective through official
data with prices updated to 2010. Only direct medical costs were considered. Costs and
consequences were discounted at 5% per annum. Deterministic and probabilistic sensitivity analyses were performed around assumptions on the time horizon, costs, utilities
and excess mortality rate due to progression applied in the base-case analysis. RESULTS:
The 10-year base-case analysis showed a lower total cost per patient with CVP alone
(c88,373) versus R-CVP (c89,899). Life expectancy and quality-adjusted life expectancy
per patient were higher with R-CVP (6.361 and 4.166, respectively) versus CVP alone
(5.557 and 3.438, respectively), representing increases of 0.804 in LYG and 0.728 in
QALYs gained. The incremental cost per QALY gained was c2097 (base-case) and
c6006 considering a lifetime horizon (25 years). The sensitivity analyses confirmed the
robustness of the model. CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrates that the combination R-CVP in previously untreated NHL patients improves life expectancy and is a
cost-effective alternative to CVP in Portugal.
PSY44
COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF A LIDOCAINE PLASTER RELATIVE TO
GABAPENTIN AND PREGABALIN IN THE TREATMENT OF POSTHERPETIC NEURALGIA IN SPAIN
Nuijten M1, Hidalgo A2, Obradovic M3, Liedgens H3
1
Ars Accessus Medica/Erasmus University Rotterdam, Jisp, The Netherlands; 2Castilla-La
Mancha University, Toledo, Spain; 3Gruenenthal GmbH, Aachen, Germany
OBJECTIVES: To assess the cost-effectiveness of using a lidocaine 5% medicated
plaster in the treatment of post-herpetic neuralgia (PHN) compared with gabapentin
13th Euro Abstracts
and pregabalin from the perspective of the payer in Spain. METHODS: A Markov
model was constructed to calculate the cost-effectiveness of gabapentin, pregabalin
and lidocaine plaster in terms of the cost per quality-adjusted life-year (QALY) gained
when used over a six-month time horizon in patients with PHN. The model structure
allowed for differences in costs, utilities and transition probabilities between the initial
30-day run-in period and maintenance therapy. Transition probabilities were based
on the comparative and long-term clinical trials identified through a systematic literature review. Missing data, including resource utilization, were obtained from a Delphi
panel, and cost data were obtained from the official price/tariffs lists. Utilities were
derived from the literature and were supplemented and validated by the Delphi panel.
RESULTS: The total cost of treatment with the lidocaine plaster was c1414 per patient
at a daily consumption of 1.1 plasters, compared with c1100 for gabapentin (average
dosage 2100 mg/day during maintenance phase), and c1348 for pregabalin (average
dosage 488 mg during maintenance phase). Lidocaine plaster generated 0.428 QALYs,
compared with 0.339 for gabapentin, and 0.399 for pregabalin. Lidocaine plaster
therefore had an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio of c3525/QALY gained relative
to gabapentin at generic price, and c742/QALY relative to pregabalin. Scenario analyses and extensive one-way sensitivity analyses on all parameters including the time
horizon confirmed the robustness of the results. CONCLUSIONS: The lidocaine 5%
plaster is a highly cost-effective treatment for PHN in Spain.
PSY45
PREGABALIN IS A COST-EFFECTIVE MEDICINE FOR REFRACTORY
NEUROPATHIC PAIN IN SWEDEN
Sandelin R1, Prettyjohns M2, Lister SP2
1
Pfizer, Sollentuna, Sweden, Sweden; 2Cardiff Research Consortium Ltd, Cardiff, UK
OBJECTIVES: Patients refractory to older therapies for neuropathic pain (NeP) have few
remaining therapeutic options. To demonstrate pregabalin’s value to decision-makers, this
study evaluates the cost-utility of pregabalin in the treatment of patients with refractory
neuropathic pain in Sweden, from a health care and societal perspective. METHODS: A
discrete event simulation (DES) model was constructed to compare pregabalin with usual
care. Pain profiles were generated for the pregabalin and usual care cohorts using clinical
data from a synthesis of five non-randomised pregabalin studies in treatment-refractory
patients. Utility data were generated from a UK survey of patients with NeP, which were
used in a recent successful Health Technology Assessment (HTA) of pregabalin in the UK
[1]. Cost data were generated from the Swedish TLV’s product price database, a national
NeP register, and a regional register study. Indirect costs were estimated from published
sources. One-way, and probabilistic sensitivity analyses (PSA), evaluated uncertainty in
the model’s output. RESULTS: The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) for pregabalin compared to usual care was 51,616 SEK/c5,364 (123,993 SEK/c12,886 excluding
indirect costs). One-way sensitivity analyses confirmed the clinical input data as the main
driver of the model; even considerable changes to all other input parameters had only a
modest effect on the ICER. The PSA generated an ICER of 41,634 SEK/c4,327 (with
indirect costs included), suggesting that the model is relatively insensitive to the combined
variation in all input parameters; this is evident in the ICER scatter, in which the costeffectiveness pairs are tightly grouped. CONCLUSIONS: Our study found pregabalin to
be highly cost-effective compared to usual care in Swedish treatment-refractory patients.
Moreover, the PSA showed pregabalin’s favourable cost-effectiveness to be robust in all
modelled scenarios, with an ICER well below a conservative threshold of 347,495 SEK /
c36,113/£30,000. [1] Scottish Medicines Consortium (SMC). Pregabalin re-submission,
advice issued May 2009.
PSY46
INDIRECT COSTS OF MODERATE AND SEVERE FORMS OF PSORIASIS
IN CZECH REPUBLIC: CALCULATION BASED ON SELF REPORTED
QUESTIONNAIRE
Klimes J1, Dolezal T2
1
Charles University, Faculty of Pharmacy, Hradec Kralove, Czech Republic; 2Institute for
Health Economics and Technology Assessment, Prague, Czech Republic
OBJECTIVES: Patients with moderate to severe forms of psoriasis reveal lower quality
of life. This QoL deterioration comes together with their productivity loss and disability. Therefore, we calculated indirect costs, from societal perspective, of psoriasis
in Czech Republic. METHODS: This calculation was based on 6 months-retrospective
self-reported questionnaire. We included 179 patients with psoriasis, aged 18–62 years
either at working status, partly-disabled or fully-disabled. For calculation of indirect
costs we included costs associated with absenteeism (number of missed workdays) and
costs associated with disability pension. We used friction costs approach (FCA) with
defined friction period of 6 months (130 workdays). The height of average monthly
income in year 2009, c851.3 and height of average monthly partly-disability pension
and fully-disability pension c229.44 and c365.61, respectively were used for calculation. Indirect costs were expressed as mean value per one patient with moderate to
severe form of psoriasis per one year—2009. Clinical data (PASI score, BSA index and
QoL) were collected by dermatologists. RESULTS: Average patients’ age was 45.34
years (23–62 years), average time from diagnosis was 23.9 years. Mean BSA index
and PASI score were 26.78% and 13.32, respectively. Occurrence of psoriatic arthritis
was 34.1%. Percentage of fully-disabled and partly-disabled patients was 9.5 and
6.1%, respectively. 18.4% of patients reported incapacity to work with average duration of 28.8 workdays in previous 6 months. Mean costs associated with absenteeism,
partly-disability pension and fully-disability pension were c214, c168 and c414,
respectively. CONCLUSIONS: By using friction cost approach total mean indirect
costs of patients with moderate to severe forms of psoriasis were c796 per patient per
year. The height of indirect costs was correlated with PASI score, BSA index and QoL.
13th Euro Abstracts
PSY47
VARIATION IN PRIMARY CARE CONSULTATION COSTS AMONG
NON-CANCER PATIENTS TREATED WITH CHRONIC OPIOID
ANALGESIA IN THE UNITED KINGDOM
Poole CD1, Conway P2, Baxter G2, Currie CJ3
1
Pharmatelligence, Cardiff, UK; 2Grunenthal Ltd., Stokenchurch, UK; 3Cardiff University,
Cardiff, Wales, UK
OBJECTIVES: Chronic pain affects around five million people in the UK. Noninjectable, strong opioid analgesia is increasingly being used to manage chronic pain
but this requires careful management to avoid common adverse effects. This study
aimed to characterise variation in primary care consultation costs as a function of
analgesic stability among patients treated with long-term, non-injectable opioids.
METHODS: Cases with at least 6-months’ observation prior to opioid analgesia and
no history of cancer were extracted from The Health Improvement Network database
(THIN), a source of anonymised patient-level data from UK general practice. The
number of different, strong opioid drugs (British Pain Society defined) prescribed to
each patient during their first year of chronic opioid analgesia was used a proxy
measure of analgesia stability. Primary care consultations were costed using a standard
tariff at £UK2007. RESULTS: A total of 21,261 cases were studied, of which 54%
were female and the mean age at initiation of opioid analgesia was 62 years (sd 11).
Prior to initiating strong opioid analgesia the annual, average, total cost of consultations with primary care health practitioners was £188 (95%CI £184 to £191). After
initiation of opioid analgesia, patients treated with a single drug incurred annual
consultation costs of £546 (£537 to £554) per year on average, and these costs
increased sharply with each additional opioid: £706 (£686 to £726), £836 (£789 to
£884), and £975 (£818 to £1132; pANOVA < 0.001) for two, three, and four or more
opioids, respectively. The majority of consultations (84%) were with general practitioners in the surgery. CONCLUSIONS: The occurrence of persistent pain was associated with a considerable increase in the rate and the related financial cost of
consultations with health professionals in primary care. Furthermore, a substantial
cost gradient was evident among patients who failed to be managed with stable opioid
monotherapy during their first year of opioid analgesia.
PSY48
RESOURCE USE AND COSTS OF THE GASTRIC BYPASS SURGERY
VERSUS CLINICAL TREATMENT FOR OBESE PATIENTS WITH
COMORBIDITIES UNDER THE BRAZILIAN PRIVATE HEALTH CARE
SYSTEM
Nasciben V
Johnson & Johnson, Sao Paulo, SP, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: To assess use of resources and costs of the surgical versus clinical
treatment for obese patients with comorbidities, under the Brazilian private health
care system. METHODS: In order to estimate the differences of resource use and costs
related to surgery versus clinical treatment one panel of specialists was conducted to
raise up the resources necessaries for the treatment from pre-operatory evaluation to
the last medical visit after 5 years. For the clinical treatment group we assumed a
conservative scenario where the complications are not considered. a micro costing
technique based on public price lists was applied to value the resources from the panel
considering only direct medical costs. a discount rate of 5% was assumed. RESULTS:
For the first year the total costs per patient for the surgically treated group were
R$14,547, for the open approach and R$31,415 for the laparoscopic approach (preoperatory assessment R$2,009, inpatient costs R$2,728 versus R$2,493, procedure
R$7,233 versus R$24,478, complications R$323 versus R$181 and the clinical follow
up R$2,254 for both) and for the clinical treated group the total costs per patient was
R$7,545 where R$5,062 occurred due to the obesity management (diet, consults, and
drugs for weight management) and R$2,488 for comorbidities (drugs, consults and
exams for Diabetes TII, hypertension and hypercholesterolemia). After the first year
the surgically treated group had R$1690 of annually costs for the follow up versus
R$3290 for the clinical treatment group. After 5 years the total costs were R$22,284
and R$39,153 for open and laparoscopic surgery and R$19,217 for the clinical treatment. CONCLUSIONS: Findings suggest that gastric bypass can reduce the use of
resources and costs related to the management of obese patients, under the Brazilian
private health care system.
SYSTEMIC DISORDERS/CONDITIONS – Patient-Reported Outcomes
Studies
PSY49
PATIENTS PREFERENCES IN OVERWEIGHT AND OBESITY THERAPY
WITH DISCRETE CHOICE EXPERIMENTS
Mühlbacher AC, Bethge S
Hochschule Neubrandenburg, Neubrandenburg, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Overweight is associated with increased risk of morbidity, mortality
and appears to adversely affect health-related quality of life (HRQOL). Though
advances in obesity therapy can be observed, the long-lasting outcome is dissatisfying.
This study aims to investigate patients’ preferences of overweight and obesity therapy
in the setting of rehabilitation. METHODS: Qualitative and quantitative methods
were applied to identify key attributes. Literature review, focus groups (N = 44) and
expert interviews (N = 5) were conducted to elicit relevant attributes and endpoints.
a total of 64 possible therapy items were surveyed (N = 201) using a classic rating
A469
scale in 5-point Likert format. Psychometric tests (frequency, factor analysis, reliability
tests) were used to verify the structure of relevant attributes. Discrete choice experiments were developed using a fractional factorial design in fold over method. For
statistical data analysis, we used a random effect logit models for the DCE. Finally a
self-administered survey, measuring preferences, was conducted in Germany in 2009
(n = 110). RESULTS: A total of 110 patients responded of which 51,82% were male,
mean age 53,05 years, mean BMI 33,54 kg/m2 (SD 7,73) answered the questionnaire.
The highest relevance for the respondents’ selection was the aspect of care coordination (Item 6: Coefficient 1.473; SE 0.185) and individual therapy (Item 4: Coefficient
1.446; SE 0.188). The aspect of infrastructure of care was less relevant in the discrete
choice experiment. All included attributes lead to significant coefficients. CONCLUSIONS: Weight reduction therapy should enable patients to receive a structured,
coordinated and predefined therapy that is individualized based on personal needs,
behaviour and circumstances. Patients are willing to abandon infrastructural quality
for getting better coordination, structure in there therapy. Further research is needed
to distinguish the possible interpretations of the presented preference dimensions, the
possibility of including them into weight loss programs and to take notice of heterogeneity within patient population in weight loss programs.
PSY50
HEALTH-RELATED QUALITY OF LIFE, HEALTH UTILITIES, AND WORK
PRODUCTIVITY ASSOCIATED WITH SPECIFIC OBESITY-RELATED
COMORBIDITIES
Goren A1, Gupta S2, DiBonaventura M1, Freedman D2
1
Kantar Health, New York, NY, USA; 2Kantar Health, Princeton, NJ, USA
OBJECTIVES: The study assessed whether, beyond general risks from obesity-related
comorbidities, specific comorbidity types were associated differentially with impairments to health-related quality of life and work productivity. METHODS: Data were
from the European 2008 National Health and Wellness Survey of German, Spanish,
Italian, UK, and French adults. Logistic regressions identified significant predictors of
presence vs. absence of obesity (BMI ≥ 30) among 62 medical conditions, for 52,206
respondents with valid BMI data (of 53,524 total). Significant predictors were then
submitted to a principal component analysis (PCA) to identify obesity-related components accounting for the most variance. Conditions loading most highly on the resulting components were used to predict the following outcomes for all 10,391 obese
respondents, using multiple regressions: physical (PCS) and mental (MCS) component
summary scores from the SF-12v2 quality of life instrument, health utilities (SF-6D),
and percentage overall work impairment (WPAI). Comparisons were against obese
respondents with none of the PCA-identified conditions, controlling for the other
conditions. RESULTS: Logistic regressions identified 35 obesity predictors that
reduced to 9 PCA components with one condition loading prominently on each:
hypertension, high cholesterol, arthritis, angina, thyroid condition, diabetes, chronic
bronchitis, psoriasis, and urinary incontinence. All conditions except psoriasis predicted PCS reductions ranging from 1.22 (with presence of angina) to 9.02 (arthritis),
ps < 0.001. All except diabetes and angina, and arthritis and hypertension (associated
with MCS increases), predicted MCS reductions ranging from 0.70 (cholesterol) to
4.11 (incontinence), ps < 0.05. All except angina predicted health utilities reductions
ranging from 0.011 (hypertension) to 0.077 (incontinence), ps < 0.001. Among 5,242
employed respondents, all except angina and psoriasis predicted overall work impairments of 2.11% (hypertension) to 12.48% (bronchitis), ps < 0.05. CONCLUSIONS:
Obese EU respondents differed significantly in quality of life and productivity impairments, based on both presence and specific types of comorbidities. These findings can
help guide interventions among obesity-related conditions.
PSY51
STATED PREFERENCES OF PHYSICIANS AND CHRONIC PAIN
SUFFERERS IN THE USE OF CLASSICAL STRONG OPIOIDS
Chancellor J1, Martin M2, Liedgens H3, Baker MG4, Müller-Schwefe GH5
1
Chancellor Health Economics Ltd, Beaconsfield, Buckinghamshire, UK; 2i3 Innovus, Uxbridge,
Middlesex, UK; 3Gruenenthal GmbH, Aachen, Germany; 4European Federation of
Neurological Associations, Helensburgh, UK, 5German Pain Association, Göppingen,
Germany
OBJECTIVES: Treating chronic pain involves difficult trade-offs between the goals of
pain relief and avoidance of side-effects, but evidence is scarce on relative perspectives
of physicians and pain sufferers. We studied each group’s preferences concerning
classical strong opioids in France, Germany, Italy, Spain, Sweden and the UK.
METHODS: In online, discrete choice experiments (DCE), chronic pain sufferers (n
= 242) and physicians (n = 270) chose between hypothetical profiles or an opt-out in
15 choice tasks. Profile descriptions were based on attributes elicited in focus groups
with 84 sufferers and semi-structured interviews with 11 physicians. Models were
specified by multinomial logit and individual respondent part-worths were estimated
by hierarchical Bayesian regression. RESULTS: All main-effects, but no interactions,
were significant. Sufferers ranked nausea, pain impact, energy, alertness and constipation; and physicians ranked pain response, CNS effects, nausea, dosage form and
constipation in descending order of importance. Sufferers were unwilling to incur
severe side-effects to relieve pain, opting out in approximately half of the choice tasks,
while physicians were always willing to trade between profiles. The models predicted
physicians’ choices well but those of pain sufferers less so. No age, sex or country
effects were seen but stronger preferences were expressed by the minority (15%) of
physicians treating non-cancer pain, and by the 55% of sufferers who had ever discontinued chronic pain medication and the 41% who reported extreme pain and
A470
discomfort in EQ-5D profile responses. Sufferers’ mean pain scores on an 11-point
Likert scale were 4.0, 5.7 and 8.6 on their best, average and worst days, respectively.
CONCLUSIONS: Online DCEs provide a practical means to compare preferences
between physicians and patients, whose concerns overlap substantially but are
expressed differently. Sufferers balance pain relief and side-effects. Their refusal to
trade between undesirable profiles mirrors high reported rates of treatment
discontinuation.
PSY52
DEVELOPMENT AND CONTENT VALIDATION OF A MULTICENTRIC
CASTLEMANS DISEASE SYMPTOM SCALE
Teschendorf B1, Vernon M2, O’Quinn S2, van Rhee F3
1
Johnson & Johnson, Malvern, PA, USA; 2United BioSource Corporation, Bethesda, MD,
USA; 3Myeloma Institute for Research and Therapy University of Arkansas for Medical
Sciences, Little Rock, AR, USA
OBJECTIVES: Multicentric Castleman’s Disease (MCD) is a rare lymphoproliferative
disorder characterized by generalized lymphadenopathy and systemic symptoms such
as fever, night sweats, fatigue, or loss of appetite. While many of these symptoms can
best be assessed through patient-report there currently is no validated MCD PatientReported Outcome (PRO) instrument available to evaluate symptom severity and
response to treatment. The purpose of this study was to develop an MCD Symptom
Scale and assess its content validity through cognitive debriefing interviews.
METHODS: A 16-item MCD PRO was developed through literature review, expert
clinician input, and qualitative work with 12 patients diagnosed with MCD. Subsequent cognitive debriefing was used to evaluate the content validity of the PRO with
additional MCD patients (N = 10) 6 male, 4 female, mean age 44 years. Study procedures were IRB approved, participants provided written informed consent, interviews were conducted using a discussion guide, audio-recordings were transcribed,
and data were analyzed using qualitative analysis software (Atlas.ti). RESULTS:
Emergent discussion of symptoms demonstrated that all MCD symptoms experienced
by patients are evaluated in the PRO. Symptom experience was variable by patient,
supporting the 24-hour recall period for capturing patient-reported symptom severity.
All items were consistently understood by participants, who were able to select a
response using a 5-point response scale to represent their symptom severity experience.
CONCLUSIONS: The MCD Symptom Scale content was found to be comprehensive.
Design elements, including response options and recall period were suitable, and
content validity was confirmed. The instrument was deemed acceptable for inclusion
in clinical trials. Psychometric testing is ongoing.
PSY53
ORGANIZATION OF ACUTE PAIN SERVICE (APS) IN THE HUNGARIAN
HOSPITAL SETTING
Németh F1, Brünner S1, Oláh A2, Pakai A2, Dér A2, Boncz I2, Gerdesics V2, Németh K2
1
Kanizsai Dorottya Kórház, Nagykanizsa, Hungary; 2University of Pécs, Pécs, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: In our hospital nearly 5000 operations are performed yearly. Based on
document analysis, the most frequently mentioned complaint was postoperative pain
in 48 hours following the surgery. There was no Acute Pain Service (APS) in our
institution, neither existed a standardized professional protocol for executing postoperative analgesia. Our aim was to organize APS, wide-spread all over the world but
hardly known in Hungary. METHODS: Our longitudinal, qualitative examination
was carried out in May 2008. We investigated the data of patients regarding pain and
analgesia at five operating departments via not self-filled questionnaires and document
analysis. Patients’ actual pain was measured before and 4th and 24th hours after the
surgical intervention by visual analogue scale. The analgetics received after surgery
were documented and compared to application patterns of each department. During
evaluation T- and Chi-square probes, and variance analysis were used. RESULTS:
Mean age of the examined sample (n = 130) is 52 years. Mean of the pain scale of
examined patients is 3,98, higher than the internationally recommended, thus expected
value of 3. Significant correlation was found (P < 0.05) between operating departments
and applying frequency of analgetics used, as well as with mean values of the pain
scale. Most often used medications are: noraminophenazon, tramadol and nalbuphin
products. There is significant difference between pain values of patients operated at
departments of surgery and laryngology (p = 0.048), urology and laryngology (p =
0.036), and surgery and traumatology (p = 0.014). CONCLUSIONS: A perceptual
form has been developed for regular documentation of pain values measured during
resting and physical activity, beside the vital parameters, medications exhibited and
the side-effects. Acute Pain Service (APS) has been introduced in our institution and
standardized professional protocol has been elaborated for performing postoperative
analgesia in accordance with preventive approach.
PSY54
THE DETERMINANTS OF HRQOL FOR PERSONS TAKING
PRESCRIPTION PAIN MEDICATIONS: EVIDENCE FOR THE EUROPEAN
UNION
Langley PC1, Liedgens H2
1
University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN, USA; 2Gruenenthal GmbH, Aachen, Germany
OBJECTIVES: This study assesses the quantitative impact of the experience of pain
on HRQoL for persons taking prescription pain medications in the UK, France, Spain,
Germany and Italy. METHODS: The study is based on data from the internet based
2008 National Health and Wellness Survey undertaken in the big 5 EU countries. This
study identified some 4,503 respondents out of 11,419 who had experienced pain in
13th Euro Abstracts
the last month and who had reported taking prescription pain medications. The assessment of the quantitative impact of pain status on HRQoL for the sub-group of pain
respondents is estimated via three single equation generalized linear (ordinary least
squares) models which estimate the impact of pain on PCS, MCS and utility scores.
The model includes a range of variables which have been shown in previous population studies to impact HRQoL. These include: socio-demographic factors, health risk
behaviors, comorbidity status, medication utilization, duration of medication utilization and satisfaction with care. The experience of pain is captured by a combination
of severity and frequency categorical variables. RESULTS: The impact of pain severity
and frequency on HRQoL for those taking prescription pain medications is substantial. Compared to mild pain experienced less than weekly, the impact of severe daily
pain is to reduce the PCS score by −14.65 points, the MCS score by −4.60 points and
utilities by −0.15. Severe pain 4–6 times a week has an impact of −0.11 on utility and
daily moderate pain −0.08. Overall, the impact of pain is attenuated by reduced severity and frequency. The impact of pain on HRQoL is substantially greater than the
impact of comorbidities, duration of medication utilization, socio-demographic and
health risk factors. CONCLUSIONS: Persons reporting utilizing prescription pain
medications continue to experience substantial deficits in the impact of pain severity
and frequency on HRQoL in the major EU countries.
PSY55
QUALITY OF LIFE OF OVERWEIGHT AND OBESE PATIENTS SEEKING
CARE AT A PHARMACEUTICAL CARE SERVICE IN VENEZUELA
Bastardo Y1, Alfonzo N2
1
Central University of Venezuela, Caracas, Venezuela; 2Proveeduria Farmacéutica IPP UCV,
Caracas, Venezuela
OBJECTIVES: The purpose of this study was to describe health-related quality of life
(HRQL) of overweight and obese patients seeking care at the Pharmaceutical Care
Service of the Proveeduría Farmacéutica IPP-UCV. METHODS: A convenience sample
of 49 patients, ranging in age from 18 to 83 years was surveyed using a written
questionnaire from February 2010 to May 2010. HRQL was measured using EuroQol
comprising the health states descriptive system (EQ-5D) and visual analogue scale
(EQ-VAS) as a general instrument. RESULTS: The sample consisted of 42 females
and 7 males. The sample had a mean age of 48.55 years (s.d. 15.25 years). The mean
weight of patients was 82.88 kg (s.d. 18.24). The mean body mass index (BMI) of
the patients was 31.99 kg/m2 (s.d 5.77). Thirty-eight patients (77.6%) reported no
exercising regularly. Thirty-four patients (69.4%) reported some problems with mobility. Seven patients (14.3%) reported some problems with self-care. Thirty-eight
patients (77.6%) reported some problems with usual activity. Twenty-five (51%)
patients reported some problems and 18 (36.7%) reported extreme problems with
pain. Nineteen subjects (38.8%) reported extreme problems and 17 reported some
problems with anxiety. CONCLUSIONS: Study limitations include the sample size
and the use of a convenient patient sample. Overall, this exploratory study demonstrates that nearly all aspects of HRQL are adversely affected in overweight and obese
patients seeking care at a pharmaceutical care service in Venezuela.
PSY56
SYSTEMIC LUPUS ERYTHEMATOSUS (SLE): UNDERSTANDING THE
BURDEN
Schneider M1, Schmeding A2, Carnarius H3, Ager M4, McWade V4
1
Heinrich-Heine-University Düsseldorf, Düsseldorf, Germany; 2GlaxoSmithKline, Munich,
Germany; 3GlaxoSmithKline, Hamburg, Germany; 4GlaxoSmithKline, London, UK
OBJECTIVES: To assess knowledge of the burden of SLE on patients. METHODS:
A Medline search was conducted to identify relevant articles published between 2000
and 2010 in English or non-English language. Search criteria were SLE/lupus plus one
or more of the following terms: QoL; patient perspective; patient burden of illness/
disease; family impact/burden; prognosis; self; employment/work impact; patient(s)
and psychological impact; patient(s) and physical impact; psychological impact;
patient(s) and daily living/functionality; patient(s) and fatigue; impact on social life;
patients and functioning; compared with rheumatoid arthritis/RA. Prospective studies
involving ≥100 patients diagnosed with SLE were incorporated into the analysis. To
focus on the burden of SLE in adult patients, studies in juvenile patients were excluded,
as were economic analyses, studies relating to the development of HRQoL tools and
studies of non-pharmacological interventions. RESULTS: The search identified 4244
articles, 62 of which met the criteria for incorporation into the analysis. Studies
involved a mean of 460 patients with SLE (range: 100–4,603). SLE was shown to
affect all aspects of patients’ lives, including physical and mental health, happiness
and relationships. Common symptoms include fatigue (50–92%), pain (71–89%),
sleep disturbance (56–88%) and neuropsychiatric symptoms (28–80%), which all
influence HRQoL and work ability. Unemployment is highly prevalent among patients
with SLE (26–54%) and can impact further on patients’ HRQoL. While most patients
with SLE (94–100%) report unmet needs primarily reflecting physical, daily living and
psychological concerns, physicians appear to place more emphasis on clinical and
laboratory features. However, clinical measures of disease activity and organ damage
are poor indicators of HRQoL. Few studies examined the effect of SLE treatment on
HRQoL. CONCLUSIONS: SLE has a considerable impact on HRQoL and ADL. To
improve understanding and raise awareness of the burden of SLE, further research is
needed.
13th Euro Abstracts
PSY57
WILLINGNESS TO PAY FOR OBESITY PHARMACOLOGY
Doyle S1, Lloyd A1, Birt J2, Curtis B2, Godbey K2, Ali S3
1
Oxford Outcomes, Oxford, UK; 2Eli Lilly & Company, Indianapolis, IN, USA; 3University of
York, York, UK
OBJECTIVES: Several different treatments for obesity have been licensed for use by
FDA/EMA, but health insurers and other payers typically refuse to support access to
them. Thus, patients are left to bear significant out of pocket costs for obesity treatment. This study aims to assess preferences and willingness to pay (WTP) for obesity
medications amongst patients seeking weight loss in the United States and United
Kingdom. METHODS: An online WTP survey was developed based on a literature
review, expert clinician interviews, and profiles of available obesity therapies. Obese
participants recorded their demographics, weight history, and indicated their preference for hypothetical, paired-choice weight loss treatments which varied across 7
attributes. RESULTS: A total of 502 participants (N = 251 US; N = 251 UK) completed
the survey (73.5% female; 47.7 years of age). The mean Body Mass Index of the
sample was 37.12 kg/m2 (±4.63). All treatment attributes were significantly important
except “time to noticeable weight loss” (P < 0.001). Corrected for purchasing power
parity, the combined country sample was willing to pay £6.40 per month per % of
body weight reduction; £0.68 per % reduction in long-term health risk; £18.12 for a
one-pill-per-day treatment vs. a daily injection (£14.79 for a three pill per day
regimen); £7.34 for a treatment that required only small changes in lifestyle versus
large changes in diet and exercise (£29.37 for one that required no changes). Participants were also willing to pay £15.05 per month for a treatment that avoided gastrointestinal upset or a 5 point increase in blood pressure. CONCLUSIONS: Participants
placed a lot of value on weight loss and avoiding changes to their lifestyle (i.e. diet/
exercise), and much less value on reducing long terms risks to health. Avoiding side
effects was also valued highly.
SYSTEMIC DISORDERS/CONDITIONS – Health Care Use & Policy Studies
PSY58
AVAILABILITY OF AND ACCESS TO ORPHAN DRUGS: AN
INTERNATIONAL COMPARISON OF PHARMACEUTICAL TREATMENTS
FOR PULMONARY ARTERIAL HYPERTENSION, FABRY DISEASE,
HEREDITARY ANGIOEDEMA AND CHRONIC MYELOID LEUKEMIA
Blankart CR1, Stargardt T2, Schreyögg J3
1
Helmholtz Zentrum München, Muenchen, Germany; 2Helmholtz Zentrum München,
Neuherberg, Germany; 3Munich University, Munich, Germany
OBJECTIVES: To identify differences in the availability of orphan drugs and in patient
access to them in eleven pharmaceutical markets: Australia, Canada, England, France,
Germany, Hungary, the The Netherlands, Poland, Slovakia, Switzerland and the US.
METHODS: Four rare diseases were selected for analysis: pulmonary arterial hypertension, Fabry disease, hereditary angioedema and chronic myeloid leukaemia. Indicators for availability were defined as the indications for which orphan drugs had been
authorized in the treatment of these diseases, the application date and the date upon
which these drugs received market authorization in each country. Indicators of patient
access were defined as the outcomes of technology appraisals, the extent of coverage
provided by health care payers and the price of the drugs in each country. RESULTS:
Most drugs included had received market authorization in all countries, but the range
of indications for which they had been authorized differed by country. The broadest
range of indications was found in Australia, and the largest variations in indications
were found for PAH drugs. Authorization process speed, the time between application
and market authorization, was fastest in the US with an average of 362 days followed
by the EU (394 days). The highest prices for the included drugs were found in Germany
and the US, and the lowest in Canada, Australia and England. Although the prices of
all of the included drugs were high compared to those of most non-orphan drugs,
most of the insurance plans in our country sample provided 100%coverage for authorized drugs after a certain threshold. CONCLUSIONS: Although the present study
showed some variations in selected indicators of availability and access to orphan
drugs, virtually all of the drugs in question were available and accessible in our sample.
Substantial copayments in the US and Canada, however, represent barriers to patient
access, especially in the case of expensive treatments.
PSY59
ACCESSIBILITY AND UTILIZATION OF BORTEZOMIB IN DUTCH DAILY
PRACTICE
Blommestein H, Franken M, Uyl-De Groot C
Erasmus University, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: The Dutch government introduced in 2002 policy regulations to
provide additional financing for expensive inpatient pharmaceuticals. In 2006 the
policy was revised after signals of ‘zipcode prescribing’ of trastuzumab (Herceptin®).
The aim of this study is to examine national and regional utilization of the expensive
drug bortezomib (Velcade®) and investigate whether accessibility issues exist in Dutch
daily practice. In 2004 bortezomib received market approval and in 2006 it was added
to the expensive drug list for the indication of multiple myeloma. METHODS: Our
longitudinal study investigated sales data (excluding trial use) from 2004 to 2009 and
compared these figures with an estimation of the prevalence of patients with multiple
myeloma. Prevalence was estimated from incidence figures of the The Netherlands
Comprehensive Cancer Centres. We calculated the percentage of patients treated with
A471
bortezomib at both national and regional level. In addition, interviews with hematologists were conducted investigating potential prescription barriers for bortezomib.
RESULTS: At the national level, utilization gradually increased from treating 2% of
the patients to 17%, indicating a long adjustment period. Furthermore, underutilization might still be present since utilization is lower than 27%, which is the estimated
percentage of eligible patients by the professional group. In 2009, regional utilization
ranged from 12% to 24%. Even though interviews revealed that hematologists were
aware of the high treatment costs, they did not experience absolute prescription barriers. CONCLUSIONS: Utilization of bortezomib is increasing and accessibility has
improved in the The Netherlands. However, the trend indicates a long adjustment
period. Although hematologists did not experience absolute barriers, the indication of
underutilization and residual regional differences might point towards accessibility
issues in the The Netherlands, despite the policy revisions.
PSY60
RESULTS FROM A COMPREHENSIVE LITERATURE REVIEW OF
HUTCHINSON-GILFORD PROGERIA SYNDROME (HGPS): MORE
RESEARCH IS NEEDED?
Guri S, Kumar J, Ghasolia D, Sharma Y, Saini P, Baghla G
JRDS ePharma Health Pvt Ltd, Dehli, India
OBJECTIVES: Results from a comprehensive literature review of hutchinson-gilford
progeria syndrome (HGPS): more research is needed? METHODS: Information was
retrieved from websites of World Health Organization, Pubmed, clinicaltrials.gov and
relevant grey literature using key words like Progeria, HGPS etc. Data regarding
prevalence rate and current treatment options were obtained and complied. RESULTS:
Progeria is an extremely uncommon genetic condition (ICD-10.E34.8), wherein symptoms resembling aspects of aging are manifested at early age. To our knowledge, only
four clinical trials are in-process and results are waiting. No randomized clinical trial
has been reported till date. The prevalence rate of Progeria is approximately 1 per 4
million births. a total of 150 cases have been reported since 1886 and 40 cases are
living currently. The p.G608G LMNA mutation is the most commonly reported mutation. Around 95% of patients are Caucasians and male to female ratio is anticipated
as 1.5:1. Symptoms of the disease start appearing at an age of 6–12 months. The
patients demonstrate a life expectancy of average 13 years (range: 7–27 years). Death
largely occurs due to cardiovascular abnormalities. New treatment options include
Farnesyltransferase inhibitor (FTI) (ABT-100) which is presently under clinical study
conducted by Progeria Research Foundation (PRF). FTI has shown positive results in
previous studies on animals. Clinical trials are in process evaluating Lonafarnib,
Zoledronic Acid, and Pravastatin in retarding the process of aging in Progeria patients.
Growth hormone treatment in a few patients has also shown growth in height by 10%
and in weight by 50%. Improvement in joint stiffness and BMR has been observed
with Physical therapy and occupational therapy. CONCLUSIONS: The pace of
research in this area has increased in recent years. Extensive genetic research can play
a vital role in the early treatment of this disease.
PSY61
RISK OF SURGICAL PROCEDURES IN THE INFLAMMATORY BOWEL
DISEASE. ADMINISTRATIVE DATABASES AS A RESOURCE OF
KNOWLEDGE
Lepore V1, D’Ettorre A1, Graziano G1, Scaccianoce G2, Vacca M1, Tognoni G1
1
Consorzio Mario Negri Sud, Santa Maria Imbaro, Chieti, Italy; 2“Umberto I” Hospital,
Altamura, Bari, Italy
OBJECTIVES: To provide a comprehensive epidemiological profile of patients
affected by Inflammatory Bowel Disease (IBD), and to assess the risk of preventable
intestinal surgical procedures. METHODS: All cases of IBD identified in validated
administrative databases of the Apulia region (about 4 millions inhabitants) in the
period 1998–2006 were included in the study, and qualified by a record linkage
process in terms of index clinical conditions and surgical procedures. Crohn’s disease
(CD) and Ulcerative Colitis (UC), were considered separately in the analysis. Similarly,
the surgical procedures coded according to the ICD9-CM were analyzed as a whole
group, as well as separately for small and large intestine and rectum. Multivariate
logistic regression was used to assess the risk to undergo surgery. Results were reported
as Odds Ratios (OR) with 95% confidence intervals. RESULTS: We identified 11,991
cases of IBD (4,279 and 7,712 for CD and UC, respectively). Intestinal surgery was
more frequent in patients aged 18–64 years, in males and in subjects with CD. In the
multivariate logistic regression the risk of any intestinal surgical procedure was higher
for CD then UC patients (83%), in males vs. females (41%) and in 40–64 age class
vs. older people (30%). Only in the case of UC, the youngest age class (0–17 years)
had a major risk to undergo surgery of rectum (p-values 0.001). Furthermore, in the
youngest age group (0–17 years) the difference between CD and UC risk to undergo
any intestinal surgery was much less than adult age classes. No important differences
were detected in the risk of at least one intestinal operation across the Apulia.
CONCLUSIONS: The routine availability of a comprehensive, detailed, reliable
system of record-linked databases allows to monitor timely risk of severe surgical
procedures thus favoring the adoption of well targeted and updated health policy
measures.
A472
PSY62
HEALTH TECHNOLOGY ASSESSMENT FOR RARE DISEASES: A
MARKOVIAN MODEL FOR FABRY DISEASE (FD) CONSIDERING ENZYME
REPLACEMENT THERAPY(ERT)
Vinhas de Souza M1, Schwartz I2
1
Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul/UFRGS, Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil; 2Universidade
Federal do Rio Grande do Sul/UFRGS and HCPA, Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: Evaluate, using a markovian probabilistic model, the development of
renal disease in Fabry Disease(FD), comparing the probability of developing the different stages of renal disease in those with FD using Enzyme replacement therapy
(ERT) with those not using ERT. METHODS: A model with pre-defined 3 possible
stages was used for patients with FD and renal dysfunction. Progression to a different
stage or having a stable disease were possible. Less severe ‘stages’ could only migrate
to more severe ‘stages’. Three year time cycles were used. The probabilities ERT x
without ERT were compared. RESULTS: Probabilities between the 2 arms: 1)The
probability of having proteinuria only and being stable in 3 y was 56% in those treated
versus 48% in those untreated; 2)Also for those with proteinuria only, with ERT the
probability of progressing to renal impairment in 3 y was reduced, to 24% compared
to 32% in those untreated; and 3)For those receiving ERT already with renal impairment, but not in dialysis, the probability of postponing the dialysis in 3 y time was
not modified. CONCLUSIONS: This model did show a relevant improvement with
ERT for those that were treated at initial stages of renal disease (the subgroup with
proteinuria only). For this group the probability of remaining in a less severe stage of
the disease in a 3 y time, postponing renal impairment was significant for those using
ERT. This was only a preliminar model, considering that the maintenance of less
severe states of renal disease postpone the need for dialysis in this sub-group, aspects
such as quality of life will be added in order to do a more complete evaluation. This
model was build considering clinical outcomes, something new on rare diseases. The
discussion on how to evaluate and on the value of ‘classical modeling’ in rare diseases
are still an on going issue with a lot to be elucidated.
PSY63
WORK AND DAILY ACTIVITY IMPAIRMENT IN PATIENTS WITH
DIGITAL ULCERS (DUS)—RESULTS FROM THE DUO REGISTRY
Hunsche E1, Denton C2, Krieg T3, Guillevin L4, Schwierin B1, Matucci-Cerinic M5
1
Actelion Pharmaceuticals Ltd., Allschwil, Switzerland; 2Royal Free Hospital, London, UK;
3
University of Koln, Koln, Germany; 4University Paris, Paris, France; 5University of Florence,
Florence, Italy
BACKGROUND: Digital ulcers (DU) are difficult to heal, and can lead to severe,
disabling complications. The DUO Registry is an international, multi-centre, observational study to assess outcomes in patients with DU disease associated with Scleroderma. OBJECTIVES: To assess the impact of DU on patients’ work, daily activities,
and dependency. METHODS: A work and daily activities assessment questionnaire
was completed by the patients at enrollment visit into the DUO registry from April
2008 to April 2010. An overall score measuring the impairment in daily activities and
in work was calculated. In addition, the number of hours of help needed was determined. Overall mean (SD) as well as stratified analyses by number of DU were performed. RESULTS: At the cut-off date for this analysis, 1770 questionnaires were
received from patients enrolled in the registry. The questionnaire was completed by
71% (n = 1250), of which 35% patients were employed. The majority of patients
completing the questionnaire were female (82%) with a mean age of 54 years. Problems associated with DU reduced the ability of patients to perform regular daily
activities by 52% (SD 30). More than 50% of the patients needed help due to their
DU during the previous month, with an average of 7 hours (SD 29) of paid help and
36 hours (SD 101) of unpaid help. The productivity of patients working was reduced
by 40% (SD 31). Patients with one or more DU present at enrolment and completing
the questionnaire (72% of all completers) were more impaired in their daily activities
(38%, 52%, 55%, 63% for patients with 0, 1, 2, ≥3 DUs, respectively) and work
(32%, 40%, 41%, 47% for patients with 0, 1, 2, ≥3 DU, respectively). CONCLUSIONS: DU impose a significant burden on patients’ by impacting their daily life and
ability to work as shown in patients enrolled in the DUO Registry.
PSY64
SEQUENCE OF TREATMENT IN IMMUNE THROMBOCYTOPENIA (ITP)
PATIENTS: RESULTS OF A MEDICAL RECORD REVIEW FROM EIGHT
HOSPITALS IN SPAIN
Sanz MÁ1, Jarque I1, Yuste VJ2, Julià A3, Gómez RV4, García CG5, Mateos MV6, Montero
EO7, Páramo JA8, Mathias SD9
1
University Hospital La Fe, Valencia, Spain; 2University Hospital La Paz, Madrid, Spain;
3
University Hospital Vall d’Hebron, Barcelona, Spain; 4C. H. U. a Coruña, a Coruña, Spain;
5
H. U. 12 de Octubre, Madrid, Spain; 6H. Clínico Salamanca, Salamanca, Spain; 7H. U.
Germans Trias i Pujol, Badalona, Spain; 8Clínica Universidad de Navarra, Pamplona, Spain;
9
Health Outcomes Solutions, Winterpark, FL, USA
OBJECTIVES: To better understand current practice patterns and determine how
current practice fits recently published guidelines, a treatment sequencing analysis of
ITP patients in Spain was conducted. METHODS: A retrospective chart review of
patients diagnosed with ITP was undertaken at 8 hospitals in Spain, collecting demographic and clinical data, drug treatment (up to fifth line) and its duration. Thrombopoetin-receptor agonists were not available at the time of the review. RESULTS:
Data on 60 patients [90% (n = 54) with baseline platelet counts <30 × 109/L and 10%
(n = 6) <50 × 109/L with bleeding episodes] were available. Patients were 54.4 ± 20.7
13th Euro Abstracts
(SD) years of age, 63% female, and 6.0 ± 7.2 (SD) years since diagnosis. The most
common first-line treatment was corticosteroids (n = 39, 65%), followed by intravenous immunoglobulins (IVIg; n = 19, 32%). The mean duration of first-line treatment
with corticosteroids was 28.2 ± 39.0 (SD) days. The most common sequence of treatment for patients initially treated with corticosteroids was administration of four
additional courses with corticosteroids (18/39, 46%), followed by alternation between
IVIg and corticosteroids until the fifth-line of treatment (7/39, 18%). Of the 19
patients with initial IVIg, 5 (26%) received corticosteroids in the 4 remaining treatments, 5 (26%) continued with IVIg, and 4 (21%) alternated corticosteroids and IVIg.
In total, 41 patients (68%) received ≥2 treatments with corticosteroids and 10 (17%)
received treatments other than corticosteroids and IVIg (3 patients received azathioprine, 3 rituximab, 2 platelet transfusions, 1 anti-D immunoglobulin, 1 danazol and
1 mycophenolate mofetil). CONCLUSIONS: Patterns of treatment of ITP in Spain
usually followed recently introduced recommendations from international consensus
guidelines. However, in most patients, corticosteroid treatment was given repeatedly,
which exceeds current recommendations, i.e., rapidly tapering corticosteroid dose and
stopping after 4 weeks. Future research is needed with a larger sample size, to explore
the place of splenectomy in treatment sequencing, and better understand the role of
combination therapy.
SYSTEMIC DISORDERS/CONDITIONS – Conceptual Papers & Research on
Methods
PSY66
WEB VERSUS FACE-TO-FACE (FTF) ADMINISTRATION OF A HEALTH
UTILITY SURVEY IN THE GENERAL PUBLIC: RESULTS FROM A TIME
TRADE-OFF (TTO) SURVEY ON IDIOPATHIC THROMBOCYTOPENIC
PURPURA (ITP)
Szende A1, Schaefer C2, Brazier J3
1
Covance, Leeds, West Yorkshire, UK; 2Covance, Gaithersburg, MD, USA; 3University of
Sheffield, Sheffield, UK
OBJECTIVES: Web-based administration of health utility interviews offers the potential to recruit larger, more representative samples with reduced time and costs compared to FTF administration. This analysis compared health utilities elicited through
web vs. FTF administration. METHODS: Six distinct ITP health states were included
in a TTO and visual analogue scale (VAS)-based health utility valuation, which was
administered FTF (n = 63) and via web (n = 359) to members of the UK general public.
The Wilcoxon rank-sum test was used to compare utilities between methods. The
interaction between administration method and respondent characteristics was
assessed by regression analyses on each pair of health utilities. An additional analysis
of exclusion criteria was conducted from least strict to most strict. RESULTS: Demographic characteristics in the FTF and web survey were generally comparable to the UK
general population 2001 census data. The mean time to complete the TTO survey was
10.2 minutes in the FTF and 9.9 minutes in the web survey. Valid TTO response rates
were higher in the FTF sample (85% to 96%) compared to the web sample (58% to 80%)
across health states. Higher proportions of web respondents reported that the TTO
exercise was ‘very’ or ‘somewhat unclear’ (17 % vs. none) or that all or most decisions
were difficult to make (41% vs. 30%) compared to the FTF sample. Utilities were statistically significantly lower in the web vs. the FTF survey (P < 0.05). TTO scores were sensitive
to the selection of exclusion criteria. The variation in TTO scores was smaller among FTF
vs. web respondents. VAS ratings were similar across the two administration methods and
less sensitive to exclusion criteria selection. CONCLUSIONS: Our study highlighted
trade-offs between the advantages and challenges of web administration. More
research is warranted to further improve data quality in web-based utility surveys.
PSY67
PREDICTING EQ-5D UTILITIES FROM NEUROPATHIC PAIN SCORES:
COMPARING INDIRECT MAPPING OF PREDICTED ITEM RESPONSES
WITH DIRECT MAPPING OF SCORES
Gu NY1, Bell C2, Ji X1, Carter J1, Botteman M1, Van Hout BA3
1
Pharmerit North America, LLC, Bethesda, MD, USA; 2GlaxoSmithBell, Research Triangle
Park, NC, USA; 3University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK
OBJECTIVES: To predict EQ-5D utilities from neuropathic pain scores using indirect
mapping of pain scores to EQ-5D item responses subsequently converted into utilities
or direct mapping of pain scores into utilities. METHODS: Mappings were based on
baseline data from three longitudinal surveys of adults (n = 2,719) who had ≥3 months
of painful diabetic peripheral neuropathy (pDPN) or post-herpetic neuralgia (PHN),
were receiving pain medications, and completed EQ-5D and pain questionnaires. In
indirect mapping, ordered logit regression was used to predict and simulate EQ-5D
responses using the following predictors: age, gender, and pain scores ranging from 0
(“no pain”) to 10 (“pain as bad as you can imagine”). Utilities were computed based
on predicted responses using a U.S. algorithm. In direct mapping, OLS regression was
used to directly predict utilities using the same predictors. Cross-validations were
conducted separately in pDPN and PHN respondents. Comparisons were made
between actual and estimated values on mean utilities, mean square/absolute errors
(MSE/MAE). RESULTS: Both estimated utilities were consistent with actual values
along the increment/decrement of the pain scores. Direct mapping explained 29% of
the variance and had an estimated mean utility close to the observed data [0.594 (MSE
= 0.31; MAE = 0.148)]. Indirect mapping resulted in lower mean utility [0.588 (MSE
= 0.054; MAE = 0.184)] but its distribution was more consistent with the actual values.
13th Euro Abstracts
Higher MSEs found in indirect mapping were mostly pronounced in lower utilities
(<0.2). Predicted utilities were slightly higher than actual values when population
average was used for input (0.3–3%). Similar findings were noted in sub-samples.
CONCLUSIONS: Both methods produced robust results. Compared to direct
mapping, indirect mapping better represents the EQ-5D’s descriptive information,
although with higher MSE/MAE. This research provides algorithms for estimating
EQ-5D item responses and utilities on the basis of pain scores in absence of direct
utility evidence. Further investigation using out-of-sample predictions is encouraged.
PSY68
HEPATITIS C-SPECIFIC QUALITY OF LIFE IS NOT PROPERLY
MEASURED BY EXISTING INSTRUMENTS
Duracinsky M, Armstrong AR, Lalanne C, Chassany O
Assistance Publique-Hopitaux de Paris, Paris, France
OBJECTIVES: Measures commonly used in Hepatitis C (HCV) Health-Related
Quality of Life (HRQL) research were investigated to determine whether they effectively encompass the disease-specific experience of HCV. METHODS: Important
HCV HRQL dimensions were identified via a review of qualitative and quantitative
literature. Medline and Embase were interrogated for appropriate studies. Quality and
relevance of HCV HRQL studies were assessed against FDA and EMEA guidelines.
The review facilitated construction of a conceptual framework of HCV HRQL. The
framework was compared against HRQL measures used in HCV research, including
the SF-36, Hepatitis Quality of Life Questionnaire (HQLQ), Chronic Liver Disease
Questionnaire (CLDQ), Liver Disease Symptom Index (LDSI 2.0), and Hepatitis B
Quality of Life instrument (HBQOL). RESULTS: Numerous dimensions encompassing
the HCV HRQL experience were not adequately represented by common measures.
Absent from the measures were consideration of treatment adherence and management,
and management of side effects; HIV/HCV co-infection issues; drug addiction; resilience
and coping; contagiousness and transmission-related issues; illness uncertainty and
unpredictability; and changes in body image. HCV dimensions needing further attention
were liver disease severity; psychiatric complications including emotional volatility;
cognitive impairment during daily activity; sexual dysfunction; the multidimensional
nature of stigma; and fatigue variability. CONCLUSIONS: The disease-specific experience of HCV is not fully addressed by any single existing measure. An HCV HRQL
instrument that is sensitive to the identified dimensions and issues would be of considerable benefit. Such a measure would help health care providers plan individual
interventions for problematic HRQL domains, as well as improve patient monitoring
during treatment and clinical research trials, and contribute to determining the value
and efficacy of treatment programs.
URINARY/KIDNEY DISORDERS – Clinical Outcomes Studies
PUK1
CONTRAST-INDUCED NEPHROPATHY IN PATIENTS WITH CHRONIC
KIDNEY DISEASE UNDERGOING COMPUTED TOMOGRAPHY: A
COMPARATIVE SAFETY META-ANALYSIS OF RANDOMIZED
CONTROLLED TRIALS
Catalá-López F1, Arana E2
1
Spanish Medicines and Healthcare Products Agency (AEMPS), Madrid, Spain; 2Fundación
Instituto de Investigación en Servicios de Salud, Valencia, Spain
OBJECTIVES: We conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis comparing the
incidence of contrast-induced nephropathy (CIN) in patients at risk with chronic
kidney disease (CKD) undergoing computed tomography (CT). METHODS: Randomized controlled clinical trials designated to evaluate the nephrotoxicity related to
iso-osmolar contrast media (IOCM) compared to low-osmolar contrast media
(LOCM) were searched in the following electronic databases: PubMed/MEDLINE,
EMBASE, ISI Web of Knowledge and Virtual Health Library (BVS-BIREME), as well
as abstracts presented at related scientific societies meetings. Prior to data extraction,
definitions of nephrotoxicity were established. We applied a random effects model of
DerSimonian and Laird, with heterogeneity (Q statistic), publication bias (Egger and
Begg test) and sensitivity analyses. RESULTS: Five studies were included with 716
randomized patients. When CIN was defined as increased serum creatinine (SCr) ≥
25%, the relative risk (RR) was 0.71 (CI95% 0.40 to 1.26)—in favor of IOCM—and
when it was defined as SCr ≥ 0.5 mg/dL it showed a RR 1.48 (CI95% 0.37 to 5.87)—
favoring LOCM—in the four studies used this criterion. CONCLUSIONS: In patients
with CKD undergoing CT there is a similar risk of CIN with the administration of
any contrast media studied. CIN incidence depends on the chosen criteria and is lower
with the definition of SCr ≥ 0.5 mg/dL at 24–72 h.
PUK2
COMORBIDITY EFFECT ON HOSPITAL READMISSION RATES IN
PATIENTS WITH RENAL FAILURE
Rhee Y1, Walker DR2, Inglese G2
1
Northwestern University, Chicago, IL, USA; 2Baxter Healthcare Corporation, McGaw Park,
IL, USA
OBJECTIVES: To examine the effects of comorbidities on the hospital readmission
rate in renal failure (RF) patients on dialysis. METHODS: We used 2005–2007 U.S.
MarketScan claims database to identify RF patients under 64 years old. RF dialysis
patients were identified using ICD-9 and CPT codes. RF patients had to be continuously eligible for at least 6 months after the initial dialysis diagnosis date (index dates).
A473
Comorbidity scores were measured by the Charlson Comorbidity Index (CCI). We
identified readmission rates to the hospital within 15 days after the index date.
ANOVA tests and logistic regression were performed to compare outcomes by CCI.
RESULTS: A total of 6117 patients were diagnosed with RF. Among those who initiated dialysis treatment, 13.9% and 86.1% were treated with peritoneal dialysis and
hemodialysis, respectively. Over half of all patients were male (55.2%) and the average
age was 52.4 years. The most frequent comorbid conditions were hypertension
(69.1%), diabetes (34.5%), congestive heart failure (CHF) (26.3%), and anemia (26.4
%). Most patients had low (78%, score < = 3) or moderate (12.0%, score 4–5) CCI
scores. 7.2% of patients had a score of 6–7 and 125 (2.0%) had a score > 8. Older
patients had significantly more severe CCI scores (P < 0.001). The average age in the
moderate and severe co-morbidity groups was 51.7 and 57.4 years old, respectively.
a total of 1.3% of RF dialysis patients were readmitted to the hospital within 15 days.
Their readmission rates were significantly associated with the CCI score (P < 0.001).
Patients over age 50 were significantly more likely to readmit to the hospital (P <
0.001). Those with a higher CCI score were more likely to readmit to the hospital
within 15 days (moderate group OR. 3.0, P < 0.001, very high group OR 4.04, P <
0.001). CONCLUSIONS: For patients with RF, the presence of severe comorbid
physical conditions was significantly associated with hospital readmission within 15
days.
PUK3
ASSESSMENT OF COMORBIDITIES IN PATIENTS WITH OVERACTIVE
BLADDER (OAB) DISORDER: AN ELECTRONIC MEDICAL RECORD (EMR)
DATA ANALYSIS
Asche C1, Kim J2, Chakravarti P3, Andersson KE4
1
University of Utah College of Pharmacy, Salt Lake City, UT, USA; 2University of Utah, Salt
Lake City, UT, USA; 3Novartis Pharmaceuticals, East Hanover, NJ, USA; 4Wake Forest
University Baptist Medical Center, Winston-Salem, NC, USA
OBJECTIVES: To compare OAB patients to non-OAB patients by assessing their
pre-existing comorbidities prior to their OAB diagnosis or first OAB treatment.
METHODS: This retrospective cohort study used the General Electric (GE) Centricity
EMR database. The study subjects were from between January 1, 1996 to March 30,
2007. The index date for OAB patients was defined as the date of their first prescription for an antimuscarinic agent or a diagnosis for OAB identified by ICD-9 codes.
The index date of non-OAB subjects without diagnosis or pharmacy claim was defined
as a year after the first activity date in the EMR. Subjects ≥18 years old were included
and had 395 days of continuous enrollment before and after the index date. Non-OAB
subjects were matched to OAB subjects on 1:1 propensity score matching based on
age, body mass index (BMI) and gender at baseline. Two linear regressions were
constructed using the outcome variables of the Charlson Comorbidity Index (CCI),
using ICD-9 codes, and the Chronic Disease Score (CDS), using prescribed drugs,
respectfully. RESULTS: There were 38,739 OAB subjects [mean age 61.18 (SD:13.26)
years; 85.67% women] and 38,739 matched non-OAB subjects [mean age 61.17 (SD:
13.24) years; 85.70% women]. Patients with OAB had higher mean CCI and
CDS than subjects without OAB [(CCI: 1.17 vs. 1.11 (p-value < 0.001); CDS:
2.95 vs. 1.74 (p-value < 0.001)]. After controlling for other covariates, the linear
regressions (n = 22,544) showed that OAB patients had higher CCI and CDS than
subjects without OAB by 0.037 (p-value < 0.001) and by 0.881 (p-value: < 0.001),
respectively. CONCLUSIONS: This study determined that pre-existing comorbidities
were more prevalent in OAB patients than in non-OAB patients. These comorbidities
should to be taken into account when making the decision on the most appropriate
treatment option for each individual patient.
PUK4
A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW OF IMMUNOSUPPRESSIVE REGIMENS IN
LOWER IMMUNOLOGICAL RISK RENAL TRANSPLANT RECIPIENTS
Kang MH, Kim HJ, Ko RK, Ko SK
Pfizer Pharmaceuticals Korea Ltd., Seoul, South Korea
OBJECTIVES: In this study, we conducted a systematic review of three immunosuppressive regimens in lower risk renal transplantation and compared their efficacy.
METHODS: MEDLINE were searched and two independent reviewers assessed
studies. We limited the search to English, Randomized controlled trial, Human and
publication between January 1, 1999~May 31, 2010. Studies which were conducted
with adult renal transplant patients (>18 years) with lower immunological risk were
included. Sirolimus + steroid regimen with 3 months cyclosporine, and CNI (Calcineurin inhibitor: cyclosporine or tacrolimus) regimen with MMF and steroid were
eligible for inclusion. a total of 434 studies were retrieved from MEDLINE firstly. By
reviewing title, abstracts and full text, 10 studies were eligible for the inclusion finally.
As outcome data, we extracted patient survival and graft survival. RESULTS: There
was no head-to-head clinical trial which compared the three regimens concurrently.
But results from 2 studies shows trend of higher patient and graft survival with low
dose CNI regimen than standard dose cyclosporine. ELITE-Symphony Study illustrated patient and graft survival of 96.5% and 89.3% for standard dose cyclosporine,
98.2% and 93.1% for low dose cyclosporine, 97.2% and 94.2% for low dose tacrolimus at 1 year. And CAESAR Study showed 97.1% and 92.4% for standard dose
cyclosporine, 97.8% and 94.5% for low dose cyclosporine at 1 year. 5 reports from
‘Rapamune Maintenance Regimen Study’ showed outcomes for sirolimus based
regimen during 5 years. At 1 year, patient and graft survival were 98.1% and 97.2%
and decreased thereafter. One study of tacrolimus based regimen reported 2-year
A474
patient and graft survival of 92.9% and 92.4% for biopsy arm, 97.9% and 94.1%
for control arm. Both of the treatment arms were standard dose tacrolimus regimen.
CONCLUSIONS: Three of immunosuppressive regimens are considered to have
similar efficacy in short-term patient and graft survival in lower immunological risk
renal transplant patients.
PUK5
CLINICAL AND DEMOGRAPHIC CHARACTERISTICS OF PATIENTS IN
RENAL REPLACEMENT THERAPY IN SÃO PAULO, BRAZIL
Takemoto ML, Fernandes RA, Passos RB, Tolentino ACM, Takemoto MM, Moretti AIP,
Cukier FN
ANOVA—Knowledge Translation, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil
OBJECTIVES: This study aims to describe clinical and demographic characteristics
of end-stage renal disease (ESRD) patients on renal replacement therapy in the São
Paulo state, Brazil. METHODS: Cross-sectional analysis of São Paulo renal replacement therapy claims as reported in Brazilian Ambulatory Information System (SIA/
DATASUS) database in January 2009. Repeated records were excluded using identification code, age, sex, and first treatment date as compatibility criteria. The following
variables were investigated: diseases associated to ESRD, anemia, glucose levels, HCV,
HbSAg, HIV, urea reduction ratio (URR), vascular access, and type of renal replacement therapy. RESULTS: A total of 18,360 patients were identified among 18,886
available claims, with a mean age of 54.23 years (SD = 15.53) and 57.7% male.
Among 8,305 patients for whom secondary ICD-10 codes in addition to those related
to renal failure itself were available, the more frequent conditions associated to ESRD
were diabetes mellitus (17.5%), hypertension (26.4%) and glomerulonephritis
(8.81%). Continuous Ambulatory Peritoneal Dialysis (CAPD) was the therapeutic
strategy for 9.9% of patients compared to hemodialysis in 90.1%. 58.4% of all
patients had hemodialysis vascular access and 50.9% had URR > 65%. Prevalence of
positive HCV, HbSAg and HIV serology tests was 4.3%, 0.9% and 0.6%, respectively.
Anemia and glucose levels > 126 were present for 45.4% and 19.6% of patients. The
total amount paid for renal replacement therapy procedures in January 2009 in São
Paulo state was 36,073,377 BRL. CONCLUSIONS: Although diabetes and hypertension renal complications can be prevented, they accounted for 43.9% of all conditions
related to renal disease among the studied population. The findings also indicate that
CAPD is still underused in Brazilian health care public system compared to other
countries, as reported by previous local studies.
PUK6
POST RENAL TRANSPLANT PATIENT SURVIVAL AND THE COMBINED
ADVERSE EFFECT OF POOR RENAL FUNCTION AND NEW ONSET
DIABETES MELLITUS
McEwan P1, Baboolal K2
1
CRC, Cardiff, UK; 2Cardiff and Vale NHS Trust, Cardiff, UK
OBJECTIVES: A major challenge in the field of renal transplantation is to prolong
patient survival. Previous studies have demonstrated that renal function at 1 year is a
major determinant of long term patient survival. Furthermore, the development of
new onset diabetes after transplantation identifies patients at high risk of cardiovascular events and mortality. This study aims to quantify any additive effect of impaired
renal function and elevated glucose levels at 1 year post transplant on patient mortality. METHODS: Consecutive renal transplants from a single UK transplant centre
over a 10 year period were analyzed using multivariate logistic regression in SPlus 8;
the risk of patient mortality was assessed after stratification by renal function (measured by glomerular filtration rate (GFR)) and impaired fasting glucose levels.
RESULTS: Data were available on 307 patients with fasting glucose and GFR measurements at 1 year post transplant. Overall 37% (n = 114) had a GFR of less than
40 mL/minute and of these, 24% (n = 27) had fasting glucose levels greater than
7 mmol/L. After adjusting for age, sex and donor factors patients with fasting glucose
greater than 7 mmol/L and a GFR less than 40 mL/minute had a mortality odds ratio
of 5.47 (P < 0.01) compared to those with glucose levels less than 5.6 mmol/l and a
GFR greater than 40 mL/minute. CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrates that the
development of impaired fasting glucose post transplants is associated with a 35%
increase risk of mortality and the development of new onset diabetes associated with
a 2-fold increased risk. Our study further suggests that there is a negative synergistic
effect of deteriorating renal function and progressive impaired glucose regulations on
patient survival. Consequently, therapeutic strategies that could both improve GFR at
one year and the incidence of diabetes might be expected to improve long term patient
survival.
URINARY/KIDNEY DISORDERS – Cost Studies
PUK7
THE PHARMACY BUDGET IMPACT OF EXTENDING REIMBURSEMENT
OF LANTHANUM CARBONATE TO TREATMENT OF
HYPERPHOSPHATEMIA (>1.78 MMOL/L) IN PATIENTS WITH CHRONIC
KIDNEY DISEASE PRE-DIALYSIS IN FRANCE AND THE UNITED
KINGDOM
Campbell J1, Tao CY1, Keith MS2, Leahy KJ1, Russo L2
1
i3 Innovus, Medford, MA, USA; 2Shire Pharmaceuticals, Wayne, PA, USA
OBJECTIVES: To examine the pharmacy budget impact (PBI) of extending reimbursement of non-calcium lanthanum carbonate (LC) to treatment of hyperphosphatemia
13th Euro Abstracts
(serum phosphorus > 1.78 mmol/L) in patients with chronic kidney disease pre-dialysis
(CKD-ND) in France and the UK over five years. METHODS: The treated prevalence
of CKD-ND and hyperphosphatemia, and the use of pharmacologic therapies, were
estimated using published literature and EU nephrologist surveys. Drug costs were
estimated from published sources. Market share changes were estimated from market
research. Base-case analyses assumed complete medication compliance. Annual PBI
was calculated as the difference in total drug costs between scenarios with and without
the reimbursement extension for LC. Alternate scenarios and deterministic sensitivity
analyses were also estimated. RESULTS: A small percentage of CKD-ND patients,
14,500 (7%) and 64,600 (14.6%), are estimated as hyperphosphatemic in France and
the UK, respectively. Of these patients, 81% in France versus 30% in the UK are
estimated to receive phosphate binder therapy. CKD-ND market share for LC is
estimated at 12% in France and 1–2% in the UK. The label extension, adding hyperphosphatemic CKD-ND patients, is estimated to increase LC use primarily at the
expense of calcium-based phosphate binders. The annual PBI from the label extension
is estimated to grow over Years 1–5 from 0 to c1.1 M in France; and to be <£25,000
in Years 1–5 in the UK. Results are most sensitive to LC market share changes postlabel extension. CONCLUSIONS: The number of CKD-ND patients with hyperphosphatemia (>1.78 mmol/L) eligible for LC treatment is minimal in France and the UK.
Assuming complete compliance, the annual PBI after 5 years of a label extension for
LC to CKD-ND patients is estimated to be c1.1 M in France and <£25,000 in the
UK. Calcium is the predominant therapy in CKD-ND; however, adding LC may result
in a low pharmacy budget impact.
PUK8
BUDGET IMPACT ANALYSIS OF ALISKIRENO IN TYPE 2 DIABETES
PATIENTS WITH HYPERTENSION AND NEPHROPATHY IN THE
MEXICAN INSTITUTE OF SOCIAL SECURITY
García-Contreras F1, Nevarez A1, Olvera K2
1
Mexican Institute of Social Security, Mexico, D.F., Mexico; 2Novartis, Mexico, D.F., Mexico
OBJECTIVES: To determine the budget impact of Losartan + Aliskiren versus Losartan in type 2 diabetes patients with hypertension and nephropathy in the Mexican
Institute of Social Security (IMSS). METHODS: An annual budget impact analysis of
the use of aliskiren in the treatment of diabetic nephropathy in the IMSS was made
considering four scenarios: a) Losartan + Aliskireno; b) Losartan; c) real prevalence
of diabetic nephropaty and d) estimated prevalence of diabetic nephropaty. The source
of epidemiologic data was the Health National Survey (ENSA 2006). Information
source to estimate health benefits was AVOID study. Costing was performed through
the technique of microcosting for replacement therapy with hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis. The use of resources was the standard IMSS supportive care, costs are
in 2009 USD. There was no discount rate considered due to annual temporal horizon.
a probabilistic and non-probabilistic sensitivity analysis was performed. RESULTS:
Aliskiren alternative prevents the use of dialysis in the real scenario of 5,946 patients,
with expected savings of $ 95,461,538.46 USD, while in the estimated alternative
prevents dialysis in 11.765 with expected savings of $188,846,153.85 USD. CONCLUSIONS: Aliskiren use investment prevents up to 11,765 patients requiring dialysis
with savings for the health sector of more than 188 million USD.
PUK9
REAL-LIFE DOSING OF ERYTHROPOIESIS-STIMULATING AGENTS
(ESAS) IN CHRONIC KIDNEY DISEASE (CKD)-ASSOCIATED ANEMIA:
BUDGET IMPACT
Walsh CM1, Bilton R1, Robinson JE2
1
Complete Medical Group, Macclesfield, UK; 2BioTrends Research Group, Exton, PA, USA
OBJECTIVES: Effective management of chronic kidney disease (CKD)-associated
anaemia has been established for all erythropoiesis-stimulating agents (ESAs). The aim
of this study was to establish the real-life doses and comparative costs of both shortacting ESAs and the newer longer-acting ESAs, darbepoetin alfa and the continuous
erythropoietin receptor activator (C.E.R.A), and to forecast the impact of a change in
current prescribing practice on health care budgets in Europe. METHODS: a retrospective chart review of CKD-associated anaemia management in 1014 pre-dialysis
and 1016 dialysis patients was carried out by 261 nephrologists across the UK, Italy,
Germany, Spain and France, between August 2008 and September 2009. Data collected on ESA dosing were used to populate a UK budget impact model comparing
current prescribing practice with specific focus on C.E.R.A and darbepoetin alfa, over
a five-year time horizon. Data on the number of patients, ESA market shares, and unit
drug costs were derived from UK sources. RESULTS: The average monthly doses of
ESAs in the combined five European markets (5EU) were as follows: epoetin alfa
(pre-dialysis, 19,350 International Units (IU); dialysis, 35,404 IU); epoetin beta (predialysis, 18,230 IU; dialysis, 36,789 IU); darbepoetin alfa (pre-dialysis, 107 µg; dialysis, 169 µg); C.E.R.A (pre-dialysis, 98 µg; dialysis, 150 µg). The model based on UK
doses showed, that after five years, an increase in the use of C.E.R.A to 40% would
reduce the overall ESA budget for CKD-associated anaemia by 15% compared to
current prescribing practice. CONCLUSIONS: Based on real-life data, an increase in
C.E.R.A prescribing may result in a cost-saving for the management of CKD-associated anaemia in the UK. This model can be applied to other European markets to
forecast the local impact of a change in current prescribing practice.
13th Euro Abstracts
PUK10
GENERIC AZATHIOPRIN FOR KYDNEY TRANSPLANT PATIENTS—
ANALYSIS OF COST SAVINGS
Georgieva SS1, Stoimenova A2, Petrova GI2
1
Aleksandrovska Hospital, Sofia, Bulgaria; 2Medical University, Faculty of Pharmacy, Sofia,
Bulgaria
OBJECTIVES: To analyze the cost savings after an introduction of the generic version
of azathioprin for patients with transplanted kidney. METHODS: Prospective observational study of the cost of pharmacotherapy of patients was performed during
2009–2010. It was collected information for 121 patients previously treated with the
originator and transferred to the generic medicines. The patient sample was systematized according to patient age, gender, additional medicines used for main therapy,
and monthly cost of pharmacotherapy. RESULTS: The average monthly cost of the
combined immunosuppressing therapy when the original product was included was
c320.99 and after the introduction of the generic version it became c311.29. On the
other hand the monthly cost of the therapy only with azathioprin changed from c6.71
to c5.78 per patient per month. The patients’ number varies among 121 to 96 during
different months due to the drop out. After the introduction of the generic version 7
patients were switched to another immunosuppressive agent, while for the originator
the corresponding figure is 2 patients. For the switched patients the cost of pharmacotherapy did not increase. CONCLUSIONS: In spite of the contradictory introduction of generic versions of immunosuppressors, due to their narrow therapeutic index
the drop out of the patients is not higher and the savings for the health care system
are possible.
PUK11
A COST EVALUATION OF PERITONEAL DIALYSIS AND HEMODIALYSIS
IN THE TREATMENT OF ESRD IN SÃO PAULO, BRAZIL
Ferraz MB1, Mendes de Abreu M2, Walker DR3, de Castro Cintra Sesso R1
1
Universidade Federal de São Paulo, Sao Paulo, SP, Brazil; 2Universidade Federal de Sao
Carlos, Sao Carlos, SP, Brazil; 3Baxter Healthcare Corporation, McGaw Park, IL, USA
OBJECTIVES: ESRD patient survival is similar for hemodialysis (HD) and peritoneal
dialysis (PD). In Brazil, access to dialysis is universal, although the resources consumed
and their costs are poorly understood. We compare the resources used for the treatment of patients undergoing HD or PD who are covered by public insurance.
METHODS: A one-year prospective study comparing resource use and total costs of
prevalent patients treated with HD (n = 210) and PD (n = 194) was conducted in 5
dialysis units in Sao Paulo, Brazil. Inclusion criteria: ≥18 years of age and clinically
stable on chronic dialysis. The study period was April 2007 to February 2009. Data
were obtained at baseline, 6 and 12 months using surveys and medical records. Cost
categories included hospitalizations, diagnostic and therapeutic procedures, medications, professional fees, transportation, and lost productivity (current homemakers
who stopped working due to dialysis). Government reimbursement rate was used as
a proxy for the direct costs related to the act of dialysis (maintenance). The study took
the societal perspective. RESULTS: Approximately 50% of HD and 48% of PD
patients were female (p = 0.75); 54% and 58% were white (p = 0.48); mean age was
55.2 and 60.6 (P < 0.001); 62% and 71% had diabetes (p = 0.0528); and 59% and
55% had coronary heart disease (p = 0.37), respectively for HD and PD. Overall
average costs per patient-year of follow up was US$23,283 for HD and US$23,285
for PD patients. The average annual cost per patient-year, per category, for HD and
PD were respectively, US$11,774 and US$14,058 for maintenance dialysis costs;
US$9,208 and US$7,559 for medications; US$94 and US$43 for hospitalization,
US$796 and US$487 for travel costs and $US323 and $264 for current homemakers
lost income due to dialysis. CONCLUSIONS: Mean annual total cost of PD and HD
are nearly identical, even though the former were significantly older and more
diabetic.
PUK12
THE ECONOMIC IMPACT OF RENAL GRAFT FAILURE: A COST
ANALYSIS IN A UK SETTING
Sun Y1, Cerri K2
1
London School of Economics and Political Science, London, UK; 2Bristol-Myers Squibb,
Braine-l’Alleud, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: Compared to dialysis, kidney transplantation is a highly cost-effective
choice for most patients with ESRD. Post transplantation, a key objective is to maintain a functioning graft. When graft failure occurs, the majority of patients return to
dialysis. This study is performed to assess the cost of renal graft failure in a UK setting.
METHODS: A model was built using data from the UK renal registry (2007–2008)
to estimate the number of graft failures occurring in the first year after transplantation.
Costs for procurement, transplantation, and for the treatment of graft failure, were
derived from the result of a systematic review. This study adopted an investment
perspective—all the medical resource used from organ procurement to the treatment
of graft failure were taken into consideration. RESULTS: In the UK, the cost of renal
graft failure was approximately £58,847 when taking account the medical resource
used from an investment point of view (including transplantation cost, immunosuppressive medication cost and resource to treat post transplantation adverse events for
graft failure patients). The post graft failure cost was £28,179. The most important
cost contributors are dialysis cost, transplantation cost and post transplantation
immunosuppressive medication cost. CONCLUSIONS: Estimating the economic
impact of graft loss should take into account the cost of management of patients post
graft failure, as well as previous medical investment that is lost with the graft (includ-
A475
ing costs associated with procurement of the organ and transplantation). Improvements in the management of renal transplant patients are needed to reduce the risk
of graft loss and the economic burden of graft failure to the health care system.
PUK13
INCIDENCE AND COST OF HOSPITALIZATIONS FOR ACUTE URINARY
RETENTION ATTRIBUTABLE TO BENIGN PROSTATE HYPERPLASIA IN
FRANCE
Cotté FE1, Torreton E2, Lafuma A3
1
GlaxoSmithKline, Marly le Roi, France; 2CEMKA-EVAL, Paris, France; 3CEMKA-EVAL, Bourg
la Reine, France
OBJECTIVES: Acute urinary retention (AUR) is one of the most significant complications of long-term benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH) and often leads to prostate
surgery. AUR also represents an important and feared event that needs to be quantified
from an economic perspective as well as from the viewpoint of BPH patients.
METHODS: French hospital information program (PMSI) databases from 2005 to
2008 were used to assess the number of hospitalizations for AUR and their management among males ≥50 years old presenting with a diagnosis of BPH. Number of
patients concerned and rates of re-hospitalizations and deaths due to AUR were
estimated using the linking system of the PMSI. Cost estimation was performed for
the year 2008 adopting the Sickness Funds perspective. RESULTS: During the 4-year
period, AUR frequency increased to 38,914 hospitalizations (+20.5%, +8.2%, +1.2%
compared with 2005, 2006 and 2007, respectively). In 2008, mean length of stay was
5.5 ± 6.9 days and decreased of 6.6% within the study period. Proportion of stays
referred by emergency department was 28.8% (14.1%, 20.6%, 25.3% in 2005, 2006
and 2007, respectively). 26,581 males were concerned by at least one AUR (+15.4%,
+5.9%, +0.0% compared with 2005, 2006 and 2007, respectively) of whom 32.6%
were concerned by a recurrence (28.9%, 30.7%, 31.4% in 2005, 2006 and 2007,
respectively). Mean age was 74.1 years (SD:10.4) (stable over the period) and 232
patients (0.9%) deceased during their hospitalization in 2008. Mean cost per patient
in 2008 was c2400 (c2663 vs. c1997 in public and private hospitals, respectively).
Global cost of hospitalizations for RAU was estimated at c93.4 million (67.2% in
public hospitals). CONCLUSIONS: AUR attributable to complicated BPH globally
increased but tend to become stable in 2008. However, proportion of emergency
utilization and recurrent stays amplified. Despite appropriate available therapies,
prevention of BPH complications remains suboptimal.
PUK14
HEALTH CARE COST OF RENAL REPLACEMENT THERAPY IN
HUNGARY
Kalo Z1, Kiss Z2, Gerendy P2, Nagyjanosi L3, Vokó Z1
1
Eötvös Loránd University, Budapest, Hungary; 2National Health Insurance Fund
Administration, Budapest, Hungary; 3Syreon Research Institute, Budapest, Hungary
OBJECTIVES: Annual cost of renal replacement therapy is an important benchmark
for public reimbursement of all health care services. The last report was presented
more than 10 years ago in Hungary, so our objective was to calculate the current
annual cost of waiting listed dialysis and renal transplantation. METHODS: We
selected all waiting listed or renal transplanted patients between July 2004 and March
2008. Resource utilization of all health care services with public reimbursement per
patient in Q1 2008 were aggregated by linking claims records with anonimised patient
IDs. We calculated health care costs of waiting listed and renal transplanted patients.
Results were adjusted to gender, age and onset of ESRD by multivariate regression
analysis. a total of 135 HUF/USD GDP specific PPP exchange rate was employed to
convert results into USD. 2008 cost calculations were compared to results of the 1997
analysis. RESULTS: A total of 2209 patients were selected to the analysis. 3 year cost
of waiting listed dialysis and renal transplantation was US$110,742 and US$87,420
respectively. Renal transplantation is cost-saving within 2 years compared to dialysis.
CONCLUSIONS: Between 1997 and 2008 the 3-year cost of waiting listed dialysis
increased by 60.3%, 3-year cost of renal transplantation increased by 96,8% without
correction for inflation. In real values the health care costs waiting listed dialysis and
renal transplantation is reduced by 26.7% and 10,0%. During this period the costcontainment measures of the National Health Insurance Fund were successful.
PUK15
RESOURCE USE AND COSTS OF PATIENTS UNDERGOING DIALYSIS IN
BELGIUM
Caekelbergh K1, Lamotte M1, Dratwa M2, Bogaert AM3, Bouman K4, Laplante S5
1
IMS Health Consulting, Brussels, Belgium; 2CHU Brugmann, Brussels, Belgium; 3AZ St
Elisabeth, Zottegem, Belgium; 4ZNA Middelheim, Antwerpen, Belgium; 5Baxter Healthcare
Corporation, Braine l’Alleud, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: This study was conducted to identify and compare resources and costs
used by dialysis patients in Belgium. METHODS: The records of 130 patients undergoing dialysis were retrospectively reviewed to identify direct medical and non-medical
resources used over year 2006. Data collected: baseline medical characteristics, dialysis-related information and resources used (hospitalizations, ambulatory care, medication, transport). Official tariffs were used for costing. RESULTS: Patients were
hospitalized 1.5 ± 1.7 times for 18.1 ± 29.1 days. Laboratory tests were performed
more frequently in hemodialysis (HD) patients than in peritoneal dialysis (PD) patients
(295.6 ± 137.7 vs. 120.1 ± 75.5; P < 0.0001). Patients on HD took more medications
(12.4 ± 3.7 vs. 10.7 ± 4.3; P = 0.0254). 79% of patients received EPO (average dose:
10,587 ± 14,114 IU). Patients on PD had more ambulatory consultations (9.7 ± 8.8
A476
vs. 4.6 ± 8.9; P = 0.0029) and interventions (5.8 ± 11.1 vs. 0.7 ± 1.1; P = 0.0042).
Only 11.6% of PD patients used an ambulance or transport organized by the dialysis
center/sickness fund, compared with 67.8% for HD. The estimated annual cost for
the public payer (PP) was c72,350 per HD and c55,343 per PD patient (i.e., 31%
more). As in 2006 there were approximately 6400 patients on dialysis (90% on HD,
10% on PD), the PP total cost is estimated to be around c452 million (2.45% of 2006
health care budget). The dialysis procedure was the main cost driver (66% of costs)
being 27% more expensive for HD. Hospital and ambulatory services were respectively 28% and 45% more expensive for HD. CONCLUSIONS: The economic burden
of dialysis is important in Belgium. Considering that survival of PD patients is at least
as good as that of HD patients and that home-treatment reduces exposure to hospital
pathogens, PD represents good value for money and should be considered in more
patients.
PUK16
COST OF ILLNESS ASSOCIATED WITH RENAL TRANSPLANTATION
AND DIALYSIS IN END STAGE RENAL DISEASE IN THE UNITED
STATES
Srivastava K, Sharma S, Ahuja A, Taneja A
Heron Health Private Ltd, Chandigarh, India
OBJECTIVES: A patient suffering from end stage renal disease (ESRD) has two treatment options, lifelong dialysis or renal transplantation. The aim of this review is to
determine economic cost of illness associated with renal transplantation and dialysis
in ESRD in the United States (US). METHODS: The information was retrieved from
databases including Medline, EMBASE, United States Renal Data System (USRDS),
WHO and relevant grey literature. Studies reporting data for cost associated with
transplantation and dialysis in ESRD in the US were included. RESULTS: In 2007,
hemodialysis (HD) was initiated in 99,886 patients, peritoneal dialysis (PD) in 6376
patients and transplantation in 2500 patients in the US. Total Medicare costs associated with these were $17.6 billion for HD, $949 million for PD and $1.9 billion for
transplantation (USRDS 2009). Unadjusted average annual Medicare expenditure
(2004 US$) for PD and HD as first modalities was $53,277 and $72,189 respectively
(Shih 2005). Patients with HD were twice as likely to be hospitalised over a 12-month
period compared to matched PD patients. The median health care costs associated
with hospitalization were $173,507 for HD patients vs. $129,997 for PD patients
(Berger 2009). The mean length of stay was significantly less for PD with 6.57 days
(P < 0.0001) vs. 7.25 days for HD (Walker 2009). The mean cost of treating S. aureus
bacteraemia in HD patients, including readmissions and outpatient costs, was $24,034
per episode (Engemann 2005). Over a 25 year time horizon, renal transplantation
resulted in significant cost savings with a cost of $376,577/patient and life expectancy
of 7.4 years compared to $568,670/patient and life expectancy of 6.7 years with long
term dialysis (Quinn 2007). CONCLUSIONS: Renal transplantation results in significant cost savings compared to long term dialysis. The total health care costs associated
with hemodialysis are higher compared to peritoneal dialysis.
PUK17
PATIENT CO-MORBIDITIES AFFECT THE COST OF DIALYSIS PATIENTS
IN BELGIUM
Laplante S1, Walker DR2, Caekelbergh K3, Lamotte M3, Dratwa M4, Bogaert AM5,
Bouman K6
1
Baxter Healthcare Corporation, Braine l’Alleud, Belgium; 2Baxter Healthcare Corporation,
McGaw Park, IL, USA; 3IMS Health Consulting, Brussels, Belgium; 4CHU Brugmann, Brussels,
Belgium; 5AZ St Elisabeth, Zottegem, Belgium; 6ZNA Middelheim, Antwerpen, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: This analysis was done to assess if co-morbidities influence the public
payer (PP) cost of dialysis patients in Belgium. METHODS: The data from a cost
study (retrospective chart review of 130 Belgian patients undergoing dialysis in 2006)
was analyzed a posteriori. Baseline medical characteristics were used to compute the
Charlson co-morbidity score (CCMS). Costs included: dialysis procedure and medical
management (i.e., hospitalizations, outpatient visits and procedures, laboratory and
imaging tests, and transport). Multivariate analyses were performed with the logarithmic transformation of costs as the dependent variable and CCMS, dialysis modality
(hemodialysis: HD or peritoneal dialysis: PD) and gender as the independent variables.
The regression model was weighted by number of patient months in the study. CCMS
was categorized as low (<4), moderate (4–5), high (6–7) and very high (> = 8).
RESULTS: All 3 variables had a significant impact on costs. Total costs to the PP were
16% higher for HD than for PD patients (p = 0.0039) and were 13% higher in women
than in men (p = 0.0207). The costs in patients with a very high CCMS were 21%
higher than those with a low or moderate score (p = 0.0072 and p = 0.0094 respectively) and 10.7% higher than those with a high score, but this latter difference did
not reach statistical significance (p = 0.1160). The differences were larger when excluding the cost of dialysis procedure and considering medical management only, but only
reached statistical significance or patients having a very high CCMS score vs. low or
moderate CCMS (p = 0.0036 and 0.0056 respectively). CONCLUSIONS: This analysis showed that patient co-morbidities have a significant impact on medical management and total costs of dialysis patients. It is therefore important to take this into
consideration when studying the costs of dialysis patients, especially if a total cost
approach (i.e., procedure plus medical management) is taken.
13th Euro Abstracts
PUK18
COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS OF TIMELY VERSUS LATE DIALYSIS
REFERRAL AFTER RENAL TRANSPLANT FAILURE IN SPAIN
Villa G1, Fernández-Ortiz L1, Cuervo J1, Rebollo P1, Sánchez-Álvarez E2, Ortega F2
1
BAP Health Outcomes Research, Oviedo, Spain; 2Hospital Universitario Central de Asturias,
Oviedo, Spain
OBJECTIVES: Complications due to late dialysis referral after graft loss involve higher
medical costs, together with a worsened health status and higher mortality rates. The
efficiency of timely (TDR) versus late dialysis referral (LDR) after renal transplant failure
is evaluated for the Spanish case. METHODS: A Markov model was developed and 6
health states were defined: hemodialysis (HD), peritoneal dialysis (PD), transplant (TX),
late referral hemodialysis (LRHD), late referral peritoneal dialysis (LRPD) and death
(D). a hypothetical cohort of patients aged 45 was observed during 40 years, considering
age-dependent mortality rates. Transition probabilities were estimated using data from
the Spanish Nephrology Society registry. Costs (in 2009 EUR) were obtained from a
comprehensive literature review and included both direct (DC) (medical and nonmedical) and indirect costs (IC) (lost labor productivity due to mortality and morbidity).
Effectiveness was measured in terms of Quality Adjusted Life-years (QALYs). Health
utilities were estimated from a proprietary database. a discount rate of 3.5% was
considered for both cost and effectiveness figures. All the model parameters were supported by an expert panel. Incremental Cost-Effectiveness Ratios (ICERs) and Net
Health Benefits (NHBs) were computed. a willingness-to-pay threshold of c35,000/
QALY was taken into account. Both univariate and Monte Carlo multivariate sensitivity
analyses were performed. RESULTS: The ICER was c27,385/QALY (IC not included)
and c34,051/QALY [IC included], providing NHBs of (0.08) [0.01]. TDR yielded 0.37
additional QALY/patient. The multivariate sensitivity analysis showed that TDR was
efficient in (54%) [53%] and dominant in (28%) [27%] of the simulations. The probability of accepting TDR was (55%) [50%]. CONCLUSIONS: TDR is an efficient
scenario when compared to LDR, providing a greater number of QALYs with yet an
affordable increase in costs. Our results, however, raise the debate on the suitability of
the willingness-to-pay threshold as a rigid decision tool.
PUK19
ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF ALISKIREN IN TYPE 2 DIABETES AND
HYPERTENSION PATIENTS WITH NEPHROPATHY IN MEXICO
Nevarez A1, García-Contreras F1, Olvera K2
1
Mexican Institute of Social Security, Mexico City, D.F., Mexico; 2Novartis, Mexico City, D.F.,
Mexico
OBJECTIVES: To determine the most cost-effective alternative between a) Losartan,
and b) Losartan + Aliskiren in type 2 diabetes and hypertension patients with microalbuminuria in the Mexican Institute of Social Security. METHODS: A complete
economic evaluation was performed from institutional perspective, using a Markov
model as analytical tool with semi-annual cycles and follow up until death, with
transversal analyses at 10, 15 and 20 years. Simulating a cohort with a 53 years old
patient with type 2 diabetes, hypertension, and microalbuminuria and using a discounting rate of 5% in costs and effectiveness. One assumption is that all patients
that require dialysis receive it. Proportion of patients who have not received dialysis,
as well as survival and quality of life were considered as effectiveness end points.
Transition probabilities were obtained from AVOID study and IMSS information.
Resource use was obtained from IMSS data and costs are considered in 2009 USD.
Probabilistic and non-probabilistic sensitivity analysis was performed. RESULTS:
Keeping a patient in stages prior to dialysis at 20 years of follow-up requires an
investment of $19,647 with Losartan and $18,774 with Losartan + Aliskiren. After
14 years of follow up, Aliskiren + Losartan is dominant versus the use of Losartan.
CONCLUSIONS: Aliskiren + Losartan is a cost-saving alternative if administered for
prolonged periods, being the most effective regardless the period of monitoring and
effectiveness measurement used.
PUK20
THE COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF LANTHANUM CARBONATE VS.
SEVELAMER HYDROCHLORIDE IN PATIENTS WITH END-STAGE RENAL
DISEASE
Park H1, Rascati KL1, Keith MS2, Hodgkins PS2, Smyth MD3, Goldsmith D4, Akehurst RL5
1
The University of Texas at Austin, Austin, TX, USA; 2Shire Pharmaceuticals, Wayne, PA,
USA; 3Shire Pharmaceuticals, Basingstoke, UK; 4Guy’s Hospital London, London, UK; 5The
University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK
OBJECTIVES: To assess the cost-effectiveness between two non-calcium binders,
lanthanum carbonate (LC) and sevelamer hydrochloride (SH), in end-stage renal
disease (ESRD) patients previously treated with calcium-based binders. METHODS:
A Markov model was developed to estimate incremental costs for three health outcomes: 1) quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs), 2) Life-years saved (LYS) and 3) percent
who successfully met serum phosphorus (SP) level goals (3.5–5.5 mg/dl) between the
two non-Ca binders. The model incorporated patient-level data from a randomized
head-to-head crossover study which compared the reduction of SP using fixed doses
of LC for 4 weeks. For this analysis the model included patients previously treated
with calcium-based binders. The ‘intent-to-treat’ (ITT) population and the ‘completer’
population were assessed. Baseline risks of cardiovascular disease (CVD), overall
mortality, and CVD mortality were derived from a large US epidemiological study.
Utilities, costs and relative risks of CVD were derived from published sources. Patient
outcomes were modeled for 10 years, and incremental cost-effective ratios (ICERs)
were calculated for LC relative to SH. Clinical and economic outcomes were dis-
13th Euro Abstracts
counted at 5% per year. Deterministic and probabilistic sensitivity analyses (PSA) were
performed to test the model robustness. RESULTS: Using clinical results of patients
previously treated with a calcium-based binder, for the ITT population, the ICERs
were $24,724/QALY, $15,053/LYS and $6,700/additional success (i.e., SP goal
achievement), respectively. For patients who completed the randomized controlled
trial, the ICERs of LC compared with SH were $15,285/QALY, $9,337/LYS and
$8,265/additional success respectively. The PSAs indicated a 61.9% and 85.8% probability of LC being cost-effective at the $50,000/QALY threshold, for the ITT population and completer populations, respectively. Sensitivity analyses support the
robustness of the model results. CONCLUSIONS: LC is a cost-effective strategy
compared to SH in ESRD patients previously treated with calcium-based binders.
PUK21
LONG-TERM COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF SIROLIMUS BASED REGIMEN
COMPARED WITH CALCINEURIN INHIBITOR BASED REGIMENS IN
LOWER IMMUNOLOGICAL RISK RENAL TRANSPLANT RECIPIENTS IN
KOREA
Kang MH1, Song HJ2, Park SY2, Kang SH2, Ko SK1, Lee EK2
1
Pfizer Pharmaceuticals Korea Ltd, Seoul, South Korea; 2SookMyung Women’s University,
Seoul, South Korea
OBJECTIVES: The calcineurin inhibitor (CNI) based regimens have improved shortterm patient and graft survival. However, the nephrotoxicity of CNI has limited the
long-term improvement of outcomes. Recently, sirolimus, a novel class of immunosuppressant, got an approval in Korea. In this report, the cost-effectiveness of sirolimus
based regimen compared with CNI based regimens was evaluated especially in the
lower immunological risk renal transplant patients under Korea health care system.
METHODS: A Markov model was developed to simulate costs and outcomes of a
renal transplant recipient for 20 years with 5% discount rate in the societal perspective. Health states were defined as patient with graft survival, patient with graft failure,
patient with regraft survival, patient with regraft failure and patient death. Quality
adjusted life-years (QALYs) were taken as effectiveness parameter. Efficacy data were
obtained from systematic review of immunosuppressive regimens in lower immunological risk renal transplant recipients. And the additional benefits of mTOR inhibitor
(including sirolimus), reduced nephrotoxicity and lower relative risk to the incidence
of malignancy, were reflected in the model. Utility weights were obtained from published literature. Costs were calculated by the Korean public institutional data and
clinical expert opinions. Sensitivity analyses were performed on crucial parameters.
RESULTS: Sirolimus based regimen costs KRW 130,067,696 for the 8.94QALYs for
20 years treatment duration, whereas KRW 140,185,240 for 8.67 QALYs for tacrolimus based regimen, and KRW 131,136,664 for 8.56 QALYs for cyclosporine based
regimen. Sirolimus based regimen was shown to be dominant over the others, as it
was more efficacious in QALYs and less costly. The sensitivity analysis showed that
the results were quite robust across most parameters. CONCLUSIONS: Sirolimus
based regimen is expected to be superior in the clinical effectiveness and cost-saving
in lower risk renal transplant recipients compared with the most frequently prescribed
CNI regimens in Korea.
PUK22
HEALTH ECONOMIC ASPECTS OF USING SERUM CYSTATIN C FOR
EARLY DETECTION OF CHRONIC KIDNEY DISEASE IN TYPE 2
DIABETICS IN GERMANY
Walter E1, Lennartz L2, Hofmann W3, Herget-Rosenthal S4
1
Institute for Pharmaeconomic Research, Vienna, Austria; 2Abbott GmbH & Co. KG,
Wiesbaden, Germany; 3Klinikum München, München, Germany; 4Rotes Kreuz Krankenhaus,
Bremen, Germany
OBJECTIVES: Diabetic nephropathy is a serious and common complication in diabetic patients; however the onset and the course can be favourably influenced by
appropriate therapy when detected early. Current recommendations include testing of
creatinine based estimation of glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) and for microalbuminuria. Due to substantial limitations of creatinine, cystatin C (cysC) has been
proposed as alternative marker for early detection of (chronic kidney disease) CKD.
METHODS: We developed a Cost-Utility Model to simulate the long-term consequences and disease progression for diabetic patients using serum cysC instead of
Creatinine for monitoring of kidney function. Markov modelling techniques were used
to estimate incidence of complications and disease progression, and Monte Carlo
simulation accounted for uncertainty. The model includes 11 health states to describe
the disease progression and occurrence of adverse events. Probabilities were derived
from clinical and epidemiological studies. The cohort definition was adapted from the
UKPDS study. Direct medical costs from published sources were used and expressed
in 2009 Euro from the payer’s perspective. QALYs and total costs were projected over
a life-time horizon and discounted at 5% p.a. RESULTS: Early detection of CKD with
cysC leads to lifetime costs of c52,950 and 14.19 QALYs (c3,732 per QALY). Detection with Creatinine amounts to c64,912 and 12.82 QALYs (c5,063 per QALY). Cost
saving amounts to c11,962 per patient and a QALY gain of 1.37; these arise due to
slower disease progression and reduced complications. The cumulative incidence of
complications was estimated to be lower for cysC than Creatinine (−15%). Early
detection with cysC leads to a decreased number of patient-years (14%-points) spent
in ESRD, due to a later onset. Probabilistic sensitivity analyses demonstrated the
robustness of the model. CONCLUSIONS: The economic benefit of using cysC is
substantial, due to reduction in complications and disease progression as well as lower
long-term costs.
A477
PUK23
ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF DIFFERENT TREATMENT MODALITIES IN
ACUTE KIDNEY INJURY
De Smedt D1, Elseviers M2, Lins R2, Annemans L3
1
University Ghent, Ghent, Belgium; 2University of Antwerp, Wilrijk, Belgium; 3Ghent
University—Brussels University, Ghent, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: Major controversy exists regarding the optimal treatment strategy in
Acute Kidney Injury (AKI). The purpose of this study was to assess the incremental
cost-effectiveness of continuous (CRRT) versus intermittent renal replacement therapy
(IRRT) and conservative (CONS) AKI treatment in Belgium. METHODS: An area
under the curve model was used, whereby patients are simulated using time-to-event
data (survival analysis), combined with daily direct medical costs. Data were derived
from the multi-centre SHARF4 study in which the three treatment modalities for AKI
were compared. a time horizon of 2 years, starting from the admission to the hospital,
was considered. Utility data were obtained from SF-36 assessment at 2 years and from
literature data on in-hospital utility. RESULTS: Analyses indicated that mortality
rates, cost and length of stay differed significantly between treatment mode during
hospitalization. The mortality rate and the cost per day during the post-discharge
follow-up period showed no significant difference between the treatment modes.
Utility values, which improved gradually after admission to the hospital, revealed no
significant differences between the three treatment strategies. Conservative treatment
was associated with a 2-year cost of c34,090 and 0.49 QALYs. The CRRT was the
most expensive therapy with a cost of c51,664 leading to 0.52 QALYs. The cost and
QALYs associated with IRRT were c43,711 and 0.46. The ICER of CRRT versus
IRRT was c131,604/QALY, while the ICER of CRRT versus CONS amounted to
c651,318/QALY. Additionally the conservative treatment dominated IRRT. Sensitivity analysis—tornado diagram—confirmed the robustness of the results. CONCLUSIONS: This study has indicated that the most expensive treatment (CRRT) associated
with an incremental cost of approximately c7952 generates only a minor increase in
QALYs of 0.06 compared to IRRT. Additionally the results revealed that IRRT was
dominated by CONS. From a health economic perspective conservative therapy seems
to be the preferred treatment strategy.
PUK24
A COST-UTILITY ANALYSIS OF CINACALCET IN SECONDARY
HYPERPARATHYROIDISM (SHPT) IN FIVE EUROPEAN COUNTRIES
Iannazzo S1, Pradelli L1, Chiroli S2
1
Adres srl, Torino, Italy; 2Amgen (Europe) GmbH, Zug, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: A probabilistic patient-level Markov model was developed to simulate
lifetime clinical and economic outcomes of the cinacalcet treatment in secondary
hyperparathyroidism (SHPT) patients. We present the adaptation of this model to five
European countries: Italy, Spain, Portugal, Czech Republic and Switzerland.
METHODS: In the simulation the treatment with cinacalcet influences the trend in
time of individual parathyroid hormone (PTH), serum calcium (Ca) and phosphorous
(P) levels, based on the OPTIMA study. Published correlations between these levels,
mortality and morbidity (CV events, fractures, and parathyroidectomies) were incorporated as well as local epidemiologic and cost data for dialysis, drugs and events
management. Simulation horizon was patient lifetime; standard treatment (vitamin D
sterols and phosphate binders) and cinacalcet plus standard treatment were compared.
The effectiveness was measured as life expectancy (LE) and quality-adjusted life
expectancy (QALE). Health Utility Indexes derived from literature and took into
account dialysis, CV events and fractures. RESULTS: The simulated mean LE extension was 1.20 life-years (LY) in Italy, 1.1 LY in Spain, 1.18 LY in Portugal, 1.10 LY
in Czech Republic and 1.40 LY in Switzerland. QALE increase was 0.89, 0.82, 0.89,
0.80 and 1.01 quality-adjusted life-years (QALY) in the same countries, respectively.
The lifetime average cost increase, calculated not taking into account the cost for
dialysis, was c28,161 in Italy, c23,878 in Spain, c27,932 in Portugal, CZK 836,914
(corresponding to c32,751) in Czech Republic and CHF 48,908 (c34,630) in Switzerland. The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) was c23,473/LY and c31,616/
QALY in Italy, c21,789/LY and c29,270/QALY in Spain, c23,680/LY and c31,249/
QALY in Portugal, CZK 759,600/LY (approx. c29,726/LY) and CZK 1,042,643/
QALY (approx. c40,802/QALY) in Czech Republic and CHF 34,858/LY (approx.
c24,682/LY) and CHF 48,310/QALY (approx. c34,207/QALY) in Switzerland. CONCLUSIONS: Cinacalcet treatment could be considered a cost-effective treatment of
SHPT in all the countries analyzed. Results seem more homogeneous in the three
southern countries.
PUK25
USING GENETIC POLYMORPHISM AS A STRATEGY TO ESTIMATE THE
POTENTIAL COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF PHARMACOLOGICAL CCR5
BLOCKADE IN DIALYSIS PATIENTS
Vegter S1, Muntinghe FL2, Verduijn M3, Boeschoten EW4, Dekker FW5, Navis G6,
Postma MJ1
1
University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands; 2University Medical Centre
Groningen (UMCG), Groningen, The Netherlands; 3Leiden University Medical Center,
Leiden, The Netherlands; 4Hans Mak Institute, Naarden, The Netherlands; 5Clinical
Epidemiology, Leiden, The Netherlands, 6Division of Nephrology, Groningen, The
Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: Pharmacological interventions that are of benefit in non-dialysis populations have thus far been disappointing in dialysis patients. Since clinical trials are
expensive and time-consuming, adjunct strategies are needed to support decision
A478
making in prioritization of tracks for drug development. Genetic association studies
may provide such a strategy when a genotype is associated with a well-defined molecular and functional phenotype. Previously an association with better survival was found
in incident dialysis patients with systemic inflammation and a deletion variant of the
CC-chemokine receptor 5 (CCR5Δ32). Thus, we hypothesized that pharmacological
CCR5 blockade could protect against inflammation associated mortality and estimated if such a treatment would be cost-effective. METHODS: Ascreen-and-treat
strategy was modelled in which patients were screened for the CCR5Δ32 polymorphism and patients with the wild-type genotype and high inflammation status were
treated with CCR5 antagonists. a decision-analytic Markov model was used. Costs,
utilities and clinical data on the association between CCR5 polymorphisms and
mortality were all gathered from a single prospectively followed dialysis cohort
(NECOSAD, n = 413). Univariate and probabilistic sensitivity analyses were performed. RESULTS: Pharmacological CCR5 blockade in patients with CCR5 wild-type
and high inflammation status decreased mortality (RR = 0.61) and improved the
probability of renal transplantation (RR = 2.41). The cost-effectiveness of the screenand-treat strategy was c18,557 per life-year gained and c21,896 per quality-adjusted
life-year (QALY) gained. The main drivers of the cost-effectiveness were the costs of
pharmacological CCR5 blockade and the reduction in relative risk of mortality.
Threshold analyses were performed for these two parameters. CONCLUSIONS: Pharmacological blockade of the CCR5 receptor in inflamed dialysis patients can be
incorporated in a potential cost-effective genetic screen-and-treat program. This study
illustrates the potential of genetic association studies in drug-development programs,
as a new source of Mendelian randomized evidence from an observational setting.
PUK26
THE INFLUENCE OF FUTURE UNRELATED COSTS ON COSTEFFECTIVENESS ESTIMATES: TREATMENT OF HYPERPHOSPHATEMIA
WITH LANTHANUM CARBONATE IN PRE-DIALYIS PATIENTS WITH
CHRONIC KIDNEY DISEASE
Vegter S1, Tolley K2, Keith M3, Postma MJ1
1
University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands; 2Tolley Health Economics, Buxton,
UK; 3Shire Pharmaceuticals, Wayne, PA, USA
OBJECTIVES: A long-standing controversy in health-economics is whether future
unrelated costs should be included in cost-effectiveness analyses. This discussion is
relevant in Chronic Kidney Disease (CKD) for treatments that delay progression
towards dialysis and prolong survival. In this study, we determined the influence of
future unrelated costs on the cost-effectiveness of the non-calcium based phosphate
binder lanthanum carbonate (LC) when used as second-line treatment for hyperphosphatemia in predialysis patients. METHODS: Time-dependent Markov models were
constructed; cohorts of 1000 patients were followed lifelong. Patients not reaching
target serum phosphate (SP) levels on first-line calcium based phosphate binders (CB)
were treated with LC. This strategy was compared with continued CB treatment.
Patient-level data were pooled from two clinical trials, one in predialysis and one in
dialysis. Reductions in SP levels delayed progression towards dialysis and prolonged
survival. RESULTS: For the predialysis cohort, 544 did not achieve target SP levels
(<4.6 mg/dl) on CB treatment, and 230 were eligible for LC treatment. Of these, 43
(18.8%) now responded to an 8 week trial of LC. Compared with continued CB
treatment, 150 life-years and 101 QALYs were gained with LC. Considerable future
unrelated costs were accrued due to prolonged survival while on dialysis. Including
these unrelated costs, the cost-effectiveness of second-line LC treatment was £17,150/
QALY. Excluding future unrelated costs, net health care cost-savings were estimated
due to delayed progression towards dialysis. The net monetary benefit of LC treatment
rose from £1302 to £4558 upon exclusion of future unrelated costs. CONCLUSIONS:
Second-line treatment of hyperphosphatemia with LC in predialysis CKD patients is
cost-effective irrespective of whether future unrelated costs are included. However,
this analysis demonstrates the substantial impact of these costs on the cost-effectiveness ratio. We recommend cost-effectiveness guidelines used for reimbursement purposes should specify exclusion of future unrelated costs in the base case, with inclusion
in sensitivity analysis.
PUK27
TIME SAVINGS WITH Q4W (ONCE-MONTHLY) C.E.R.A.: A TIME AND
MOTION STUDY CONDUCTED IN HEMODIALYSIS CENTRES IN FIVE
EUROPEAN COUNTRIES
Raluy M1, Irgl H2, De Cock E1
1
United BioSource Corporation, Barcelona, Spain; 2F. Hoffmann-La Roche Ltd., Basel,
Switzerland
BACKGROUND: Governments across Europe are increasingly focused on controlling
rising health care costs. Within this context, a major challenge for hemodialysis centres
is to maximise efficiencies while maintaining high standards of care. OBJECTIVES:
The aim of this study was to document health care personnel time for anaemia management in maintenance therapy for both shorter-acting erythropoiesis-stimulating
agents (ESA) and a continuous erythropoiesis receptor activator (C.E.R.A.) once
monthly (Q4W), and model time savings following the introduction of Q4W C.E.R.A.
in five European countries. METHODS: A multinational, multicentre time and motion
study has been conducted in 16 centres across Germany, France, Italy, Poland and
Spain. The time spent on frequent anaemia management-related tasks (preparation,
distribution, injection, record-keeping) was recorded in each centre by trained observers. Time/pt/session was used to calculate time/pt/year, time/centre/year and for modelling potential time savings with a 100% uptake of C.E.R.A. RESULTS: Numbers of
13th Euro Abstracts
ESA injections/pt/year, weighted by type of ESA, frequency and route of administration, ranged from 53–148. The mean uptake of C.E.R.A. Q4W across 16 centres was
29% (7–56%). The mean annual reduction in the number of ESA administrations
following conversion to C.E.R.A. was 76 (41–136). Estimated observed time/pt/year
ranged from 38–310 min for ESA and 6–68 min for C.E.R.A. Assuming a 100%
uptake of Q4W C.E.R.A. maintenance therapy, annual time savings/centre for frequent anaemia management tasks would be 84% (79–91%) in Germany, 78% (74–
86%) in France, 88% (87–88%) in Italy, 85% (78–88%) in Poland and 77%
(69–84%) in Spain. CONCLUSIONS: Substantial annual time savings on frequent
anaemia management-related tasks were consistently found in hemodialysis centres
across five European countries with a 100% uptake of Q4W C.E.R.A. maintenance
therapy. This provides the opportunity to re-focus health care resources, at a critical
time point in the dialysis procedure, on other important CKD care tasks in order to
improve overall pt care.
PUK28
THE ECONOMIC BURDEN OF POST-TRANSPLANT EVENTS IN RENAL
TRANSPLANT PATIENTS (PORTRAIT STUDY) IN A SINGLE UK CENTRE
McEwan P1, Baboolal K2, Cerri K3
1
CRC, Cardiff, UK; 2Cardiff and Vale NHS Trust, Cardiff, UK; 3Bristol-Myers Squibb,
Braine-l’Alleud, Belgium
OBJECTIVES: There is a paucity of information available regarding the prevalence
of post-transplant events and resource utilization associated with such events in renal
transplant patients in real-life treatment settings. The PORTRAIT study aims to
describe the health care resources used and to estimate the cost of managing posttransplant patients using observational data from transplant databases and physician
questionnaires from transplant centres across Europe. This abstract describes the
preliminary results from a single UK centre. METHODS: A pilot retrospective observational study was undertaken in which resource usage over a three year period,
calculated from Healthcare Resource Groups (HRGs), was employed to derive costs,
with results stratified by glomerular filtration rate (GFR) status at one year post
transplant. Comparison of costs was undertaken using the non-parametric MannWhitney test. RESULTS: There were 879 renal transplant patients who had a recorded
GFR measurement at one year post transplant. Overall 130 (14.8%) had a GFR of
<30 mL/min/1.73 m2; 535 (60.1%) had a GFR between >30 and ≤60 mL/min/1.73 m2
and 214 (24.3%) had a GFR > 60 mL/min/1.73 m2. Overall three-year HRG derived
costs were significantly lower in the >60 mL/min/1.73 m2 group at £497 (SD = £111)
compared to both the 30–60 and <30 mL/min/1.73 m2, at £1,323 (SD = £1245, p =
0.025) and £1448 (SD = 1726, p = 0.01) respectively. CONCLUSIONS: This study
provides evidence that post-transplant resource usage in a real-life treatment setting
(assessed using HRG tariffs) is approximately three times higher in those patients with
lower post transplant GFR. Therefore management strategies that promote renal
function post transplant are likely to provide important resource savings. An ongoing
database and physician questionnaire study has been implemented to confirm these
observations using a bottom-up costing approach.
URINARY/KIDNEY DISORDERS – Patient-Reported Outcomes Studies
PUK29
CHARACTERIZING THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN HEALTH UTILITY IN
KIDNEY TRANSPLANT RECIPIENTS IN UK AND US WITH DIFFERENT
LEVELS OF KIDNEY FUNCTION
Neri L1, McEwan P2, Cerri K3, Baboolal K4
1
Saint Louis University, St. Louis, MO, USA; 2CRC, Cardiff, UK; 3Bristol-Myers Squibb,
Braine-l’Alleud, Belgium; 4Cardiff and Vale University Health Board, Cardiff, UK
OBJECTIVES: Little data is available describing the relationship between quality of
life and levels of kidney function in renal transplant patients. We sought to assess the
relationship between health utility and renal impairment in US and UK kidney transplant (KTX) recipients. METHODS: Data was obtained from KTX patients enrolled
at the kidney transplant facilities of the Renal Unit at the Cardiff and Wales NHS
Trust in Cardiff, UK (n = 209) and Saint Louis University Hospital, St. Louis, MO (n
= 233). General linear models were used to estimate adjusted EQ-5D means across
CKD stages (K/DOQI classification). Partial Spearman’s correlation was used to evaluate trend across CKD classes. We adjusted all models for age, gender, time since
transplant and diagnosis of diabetes. We adjusted for center effect by including the
variable indicating the center of enrollment and the appropriate interaction term in
the model. RESULTS: Mean age of KTX recipients was 52.7 and 49.1 years and mean
time since transplant was 5.6 and 3.3 years in the UK and US cohorts respectively.
After adjustment, EQ-5D scores resulted as follows in UK and US samples respectively:
CKD 1–2, 0.74 and 0.87; CKD 3, 0.69 and 0.88, CKD 4, 0.61 and 0.82; CKD 5,
0.39 and 0.79. The trend across CKD classes was statistically significant in both
samples (UK: ρ = −0.24, P < 0.01; US: ρ = −0.19, p = 0.03). Center effect was statistically significant and mainly explained by inclusion of recipients with failed graft on
dialysis in the UK sample. CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrates a significant and
independent relationship between levels of post transplant renal impairment and
health utility. Management strategies that maximize post transplant renal function
will have important implications for patients’ quality of life.
13th Euro Abstracts
PUK30
MAPPING THE OVERACTIVE BLADDER QUESTIONNAIRE-SHORT FORM
(OABQ-SF) TO EQ-5D PATIENT PREFERENCES IN PATIENTS WITH
OVERACTIVE BLADDER IN SPAIN
Villacampa-Aubá F1, Ruiz MA2, Arlandis-Guzmán S3, Errando-Smet C4, Lizarraga I5, Rejas J6
1
Department of Urology, Hospital 12 de Octubre, Madrid, Spain; 2Universidad Autonoma de
Madrid, Madrid, Spain; 3Department of Urology, Hospital Universitario La Fe, Valencia, Spain;
4
Department of Urology, Fundación Puigvert, Barcelona, Spain; 5Medical Unit, Pfizer España,
Alcobendas, Madrid, Spain; 6Pfizer España, Alcobendas/Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: To develop a mapping algorithm to transform the Overactive Bladder
questionnaire-Short Form (OABq-SF) questionnaire responses into EQ-5D derived utilities in patients with OAB in Spain. METHODS: The culturally adapted Spanish versions
of OABq-SF and EQ-5D questionnaires were self-administered on two occasions 3
months apart to a set of patients of both genders, above 18 years, diagnosed of OAB
according with standard criteria and a score > 8 in the OAB-V8 scale and able to
understand PRO instruments written in Spanish. Patients were recruited consecutively
in clinics of Urology all over the country. Linear correlations between symptoms severity
and health-related quality-of-life (HRQoL) domains of the OABq-SF and EQ-5D (VAS
and TTO-tariffs) were computed. a combined score of both domains of OABq-SF was
used to obtain a unique scoring per patient, although mapping was developed for both
combined and separated punctuations of the OABq-SF using regression modelling.
RESULTS: A total of 199 OAB patients (58.4 years, 74% women, 99% Caucasian,
37% workers and 36% primary schooling) from 18 urological clinics were evaluated.
Utility values ranged from 1 to 0.01; mean value = 0.7623 (SD = 0.2292) and median
= 0.79. Correlations with EQ-5D were −0.282 and −0.301 for the severity of symptoms
domain at baseline an after 3 months of a medical intervention, and 0.329 and 0.369
for the HRQoL domain, respectively. Pearson coefficients for combined scoring were
−0.331 and −0.351, respectively. All coefficients were significant at P < 0.001 level.
Observed relation between utilities and combined score followed a linear although
heterocedastic pattern. Utilities distribution was clearly positively skewed with benign
utilities prevailing. CONCLUSIONS: Utilities values for Spanish patients with OAB
were mostly mild to moderate in the 0–1 range. a utility map was obtained for different
levels of scoring in the OABq-SF questionnaire, which is useful to derive Qualityadjusted Life-year gain in economic evaluations.
PUK31
PSYCHOMETRIC VALIDATION OF THE SPANISH VERSION OF THE
OVERACTIVE BLADDER QUESTIONNAIRE SHORT-FORM (OABQ-SF) TO
ASSESS SEVERITY OF SYMPTOMS AND PATIENT HEALTH RELATED
QUALITY OF LIFE IN SUBJECTS WITH OVERACTIVE BLADDER
Arlandis-Guzmán S1, Ruiz MA2, Errando-Smet C3, Villacampa-Aubá F4, García-Vargas M5,
Arumi D6
1
Department of Urology, Hospital Universitario La Fe, Valencia, Spain; 2Universidad
Autonoma de Madrid, Madrid, Spain; 3Department of Urology, Fundación Puigvert,
Barcelona, Spain; 4Department of Urology, Hospital 12 de Octubre, Madrid, Spain; 5Health
Outcomes Research Department, Corporate Affairs and Market Access Unit, Pfizer Spain,
Alcobendas, Madrid, Spain; 6Pfizer Inc., Madrid, Spain, Alcobendas, Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: To carry out the psychometric validation of the Spanish version of the
self-administered OABq-SF questionnaire, a tool measuring severity of symptoms and
health-related quality of life (HRQoL) of patients with symptomatic overactive
bladder (OAB). METHODS: The culturally adapted Spanish version of OABq-SF was
administered on two occasions separately 3 months to a set of patients of both genders,
above 18 years old, diagnosed of OAB according with standard criteria and a score
> 8 in the OAB-V8 scale and able to understand PRO instruments written in Spanish.
Patients were recruited consecutively in clinics of Urology all over the country. Feasibility, internal consistency (Cronbach’s alpha), test-retest reliability, structure of
instrument, criteria and construct validity and responsiveness were examined using
classic test theory statistics. Minimally Important Difference (MID) was also calculated. RESULTS: Data from 199 OAB patients (58.4 years, 74% women, 99%
Caucasian, 37% workers and 36% primary schooling) from 18 urological clinics were
evaluated. Floor and ceiling effect ranged between 0.5% and 31.2%, and missing items
was below 1%. Cronbach’s alphas attained 0.795 and 0.923 for severity and HRQoL
domains. These two instrument domains showed to be one-dimensional with explained
variances above 50% in both domains, which correlated moderately with EQ-5D
[−0.335 and +0.405, respectively (P < 0.01 in both cases)] and with self-perceived
general valuation symptoms of OAB. a significant change in OABq-SF domains scoring
[−23.3 (−26.0; −20.6) and +17.1 (14.7; 19.5), P < 0.001 in both cases (effect sizes:
1.34 and 1.50)] were observed after a 3-month medical intervention. MID values were,
respectively, 6.6 and 8.1 for severity and HRQoL domains. CONCLUSIONS: The
Spanish version of OABq-SF demonstrated strong reliability, validity and responsiveness psychometric properties to be used in the measurement of severity and Healthrelated Quality of life symptoms of OAB.
PUK32
CONTENT VALIDITY OF A PATIENT-REPORTED URINARY URGENCY
RATING SCALE: RESULTS OF A COGNITIVE INTERVIEW STUDY
Chen WH1, Notte S1, Marshall TS2, Lee M2, Hakimi Z3, Revicki DA1
1
United BioSource Corporation, Bethesda, MD, USA; 2Astellas Pharma Global
Development—US, Deerfield, IL, USA; 3Astellas Pharma Global Development—EU, AC
Leiderdorp, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: The Patient Perception of Intensity of Urgency Scale (PPIUS) measures the
urgency severity of urinary episodes, and was developed based on the definition of urgency
A479
presented by the International Continence Society (ICS) (Abrams et al. 2002) as well as
recommendations from the Committee for Proprietary Medical Products (CPMP) (EMA
2002). The PPIUS is a single item scale with five levels of urgency severity, from “No
urgency” to “Urge incontinence,” each with its definition provided. While the PPIUS has
been used in previous trials, its content validity has not been established in overactive
bladder (OAB) patients. The objective of this study was to determine comprehensibility
and understanding of the scale through cognitive interviews with OAB patients.
METHODS: Forty-one OAB patients participated in a non-interventional study
assessing reproducibility of the PPIUS by completing a three-day micturition diary
each week for three consecutive weeks. Following successful completion of the testretest study, twelve participants were selected to participate in a 30-minute in-person
interview discussing their experience with the PPIUS. Interviews were conducted by a
trained interviewer and followed a semi-structured guide with think-aloud approach.
RESULTS: N = 12; mean (SD) age = 61.6 (13.5) years; 66.7% Caucasian; 91.7%
female; mean (SD) years with symptoms = 5.8 (4.6); 83.3% reported medication use
for treatment. Nine participants found it simple to choose a PPIUS rating for each of
their daily micturition episodes. Most agreed with the definitions provided for the
ratings of “No urgency” (n = 9), “Mild urgency” (n = 7), “Moderate urgency” (n =
8), “Severe urgency” (n = 9) and “Urge incontinence” (n = 9). Three suggested distinction between daytime and nighttime episodes could be made clearer. CONCLUSIONS:
Content validity of the PPIUS was supported by the results of the cognitive interviews.
PPIUS was well understood and the urgency definitions were generally accepted.
Participants found the diary easy to complete and did not have difficulty selecting their
ratings.
PUK33
TEST-RETEST RELIABILITY AND ACCLIMATION EFFECT OF PATIENT
PERCEPTION OF INTENSITY OF URGENCY SCALE (PPIUS) FOR
OVERACTIVE BLADDER
Chen WH1, Notte S1, Marshall TS2, Lee M2, Hakimi Z3, Revicki DA1
1
United BioSource Corporation, Bethesda, MD, USA; 2Astellas Pharma Global
Development—US, Deerfield, IL, USA; 3Astellas Pharma Global Development—EU, AC
Leiderdorp, The Netherlands
OBJECTIVES: A three-day micturition diary has been designed to capture information
on the number of urinary and incontinence episodes in overactive bladder (OAB)
patients. Within the diary is the Patient Perception of Intensity of Urgency Scale
(PPIUS), which captures the urgency associated with each episode. The PPIUS is a
single item with five levels of urgency severity: “No urgency,” “Mild urgency” “Moderate urgency,” “Severe urgency,” and “Urge incontinence.” The objective of this
study was to assess the test-retest reliability and acclimation effect of the PPIUS.
METHODS: OAB patients were recruited from five sites in the US for a non-interventional two-visit study. At the Screening Visit, participants were trained on how to
complete the three-day diary at home for three consecutive weeks. In the diary, participants recorded the time of each micturition, a corresponding PPIUS rating, and
whether the episode was accompanied by incontinence. Participants and clinicians
completed overall treatment effect (OTE) questions at the Final Visit asking whether
their bladder condition had changed since the Screening Visit. RESULTS: N = 39;
mean age = 59.1 years; 69.2% Caucasian; 82.1% female; mean (SD) years with
symptoms = 6.7 (6.78); 94.9% reported medication use for treatment. The mean
number of micturitions per 24-hours = 10.5, mean number of incontinence episodes
per 24-hours = 1.8; mean level of urgency severity = 1.9. There were 34 (87.2%) and
35 (89.7%) stable patients as defined by OTE-Patient and OTE-Clinician, respectively.
Using Weeks 2 and 3 data from stable patients, the intra-class correlation (ICC) was
0.95 and the Spearman correlation was 0.89. The difference between the average
ratings of any two weeks was non-significant using paired t-test. CONCLUSIONS:
The PPIUS demonstrated excellent test-retest reliability as evidenced by ICC = 0.95.
Acclimation effect was not observed in the PPIUS, as evidenced by non-significant
differences in the average ratings across three weeks.
PUK34
PSYCHOMETRIC VALIDATION OF THE SPANISH VERSION OF THE
TREATMENT BENEFIT SCALE (TBS) FOR ASSESSING SUBJECTIVE
OUTCOMES IN TREATING PATIENTS WITH OVERACTIVE BLADDER
Errando-Smet C1, Ruiz MA2, Villacampa-Aubá F3, Arlandis-Guzmán S4, García-Vargas M5,
Arumi D6
1
Department of Urology, Fundación Puigvert, Barcelona, Spain; 2Universidad Autonoma de
Madrid, Madrid, Spain; 3Department of Urology, Hospital 12 de Octubre, Madrid, Spain;
4
Department of Urology, Hospital Universitario La Fe, Valencia, Spain; 5Health Outcomes
Research Department, Corporate Affairs and Market Access Unit, Pfizer Spain, Alcobendas,
Madrid, Spain; 6Pfizer Inc., Madrid, Spain, Alcobendas, Madrid, Spain
OBJECTIVES: To carry out the psychometric validation of the Spanish version of the
self-administered TBS scale, a tool assessing subjective outcomes in the treatment of
subjects with overactive bladder (OAB). METHODS: The culturally adapted Spanish
version of TBS was administered at the end-of-trial visit after 3 months of a medical
intervention for OAB. Responses to the instruments were recorded in a set of patients
of both genders, above 18 years old, diagnosed of OAB according with standard
criteria and a score > 8 in the OAB-V8 scale, and able to understand PRO instruments
written in Spanish. Patients were recruited consecutively in clinics of Urology all over
the country. Scale variability, criteria, known-groups and construct validity and
responsiveness (effect size) were examined using classic test theory statistics. RESULTS:
Data from 199 OAB patients (58.4 years, 74% women, 99% Caucasian, 37% workers
and 36% primary schooling) from 18 urological clinics were evaluated. The 2.5% of
A480
patients did not fill in the scale, only 31% greatly improved, 57% improved, 10% did
not changed and 2% worsened during medical intervention. TBS correlated moderately with clinical judgement of change; 0.749, P < 0.001, and also, linearity was
observed, with changes at end-of-trial visit in both domains of the OABq-SF; Flineal =
23.02, P < 0.001 and Flineal = 31.02, P < 0.001. TBS was able to differentiate groups
of patients with different levels of change in symptoms severity and health-related
quality of life of the OABq-SF questionnaire; F = 8.09, P < 0.001 and F = 10.5, P <
0.001, respectively, with effect sizes between 1.69 and −0.44. CONCLUSIONS: The
Spanish version of TBS scale demonstrated strong validity and responsiveness psychometric properties to be used in the subjective assessment of outcomes related with
treatment of OAB.
URINARY/KIDNEY DISORDERS – Health Care Use & Policy Studies
PUK35
PATIENTS WITH BPH: RESULTS AT 6 MONTHS FOLLOWING
TREATMENT WITH PHYTOTHERAPY VERSUS OTHER TREATMENTS
Taieb C1, Auges M1, Perrin P2
1
PFSA, Boulogne, France; 2Lyon Sud, Pierre Benite, France
OBJECTIVES: Assess the impact of the treatment of urinary disorders of the lower
urinary tract (LUT) suggestive of benign prostatic hypertrophy (BPH) using medical
13th Euro Abstracts
treatment under actual conditions of use. METHODS: A pragmatic cohort of 420
patients (France, Italy, and Portugal) treated medically, was followed up for 6 months,
using 3 questionnaires: IPSS, MSF4 and SF12. RESULTS: 366 patients under medical
treatment were assessed. 267 patients were treated with phytotherapy, versus 80
patients on “other treatments”. At inclusion, the patients treated with Serenoa repens
versus “other treatments” were different on the following characteristics: Age (P =
0.0047), time since diagnosis (p = 0.006), country (P < 0.0001), IPSS score (P =
0.0087), physical dimension of the SF12 (P = 0.0071). The “change from baseline”
for the scores of the IPSS and SF12 self-assessment questionnaires between the 2
treatment groups was comparable. a generalized linear model adjusted for age, time
since diagnosis, country, IPSS score, and the physical dimension of the SF12 score at
inclusion was used, making the 2 treatment groups comparable. We observed an
improvement in the IPSS score from 6 weeks. We were not able to demonstrate a
significant difference between the 2 treatment groups concerning the “change from
baseline” of the IPSS score (P = 0.7288). The same applies to the analyses at 3 and 6
months where the p-values were 0.2047 and 0.0947 respectively. We did not observe
any statistical difference in the scores for the 2 dimensions of the SF12 between the
2 treatment groups. CONCLUSIONS: We observed an improvement in the IPSS and
SF12 scores from 6 weeks. This improvement was not significantly different between
the 2 treatment groups. Under actual conditions of use, the various medical treatments
gave similar improvements.