The present invention relates to an apparatus for
preventing sound distortion in hearing aids. More
particularly, the present invention provides a hearing
aid which utilizes gain control circuitry at both a
preamplifier stage and an output stage to prevent
saturation of input and output amplifiers.
Distortion in the hearing aid art is defined as the
generation of added undesired sounds in the output
signal that are not present in the input signal. It is
believed that such distortion, that is, these additional
sounds, act as a type of masking noise for speech, both
by direct masking of low-level speech cues that fill in
the temporal structure of speech sounds, and by
degrading important amplitude cues. Peakclipping has
been used as a technique for limiting the amplitude of
the output stage of a standard hearing aid,
however, the peak-clipping technique often creates distortions
in the output stage of the hearing aid circuitry.
For the purposes of sound distortion analysis, a hearing
aid can generally be considered to consist of two primary
amplifying stages, a preamplifier stage and an output
amplifier stage. Fig. 1 shows an exemplary configuration of
a two stage hearing aid 10. As seen in Fig. 1, the
preamplifier stage 12 of hearing aid 10 includes an amplifier
14 having one input 16 connected to a microphone 18 via
coupling capacitor 20 and another input 22 connected to
ground. The amplifier 14 has a fixed gain which is set by
resistors 24 and 26. The output 28 of the preamplifier stage
12 is connected to a user adjustable volume control circuit 30
having an output 32 connected to the output stage 34 of the
hearing aid 10. The volume control circuit 30 has a
potentiometer 36 connected between the output 28 of the
preamplifier stage 12 and an input 38 of the output stage 34
via coupling capacitor 40. The output stage 30 includes an
amplifier 42 having one input 38 connected to the output 32 of
the volume control circuit 30. The amplifier 42 has a fixed
gain set by resistors 44 and 46 and has an output 48 connected
to a transducer, for example, speaker 50.
In the preamplifier stage, the amount of undistorted
amplification available is typically limited by the available
battery supply voltage. In conventional ear-level hearing
aids, the battery supply voltage is typically limited to 1.25
volts available from a zinc-air battery cell. If the input
sound level (amplitude) increases dramatically, the resulting
amplified signal at the output of the preamplifier stage tries
to exceed the available battery voltage and thus the
preamplifier saturates and the output signal becomes distorted
(that is, it clips).
Various amplifiers, such as class A and class D
amplifiers may be employed at the output stage. Such
amplifiers are subject to an overload effect when the input
sound level reaches certain thresholds. When using class A
amplifiers in the output stage, a signal delivered to the
output stage 34 from the preamplifier stage 12 increases as
the amplitude of the input sound level into the preamplifier
stage 12 increases. When the voltage at the output 28 of the
preamplifier 12 reaches the limits of the battery supply
voltage, no further amplification can take place. If the
input sound level at microphone 18 continues to drive the
preamplifier, the amplifier will saturate and distortion will
occur.
A similar overload effect may also occur when using class
D amplifiers in the output stage, though the saturation
mechanism is different. Using a class D amplifier, the output
stage 34 operates by producing a variable pulse-width
modulated signal across the transducer 50, for example, the
speaker coil. As either the input sound level or the amount
of system amplification is increased, the pulses eventually
merge into each other and the output signal reaches
saturation, thus causing distortion, for example, in the form
of peak-clipping. Typically, for a class D amplifier,
distortion begins at about 3 dB below maximum acoustic output.
Peak-clipping may be unintentional, such as when the
output amplifier is over driven, or peak-clipping may be
intentional, such as when the saturated sound pressure level
(SSPL) of a hearing aid is reduced by a peak-clipping circuit.
Saturation distortion that occurs due to over-driving or
output clipping in an amplifier should be distinguished from
low levels of distortion that can occur inside a hearing aid
with low input levels. Saturation distortion occurs when the
input level is so high that saturation is reached either in
the pre-amplifier stage or in the output stage or in both
stages. When this occurs, the waveform becomes highly
distorted. Even in instances where a hearing aid is
intentionally configured to produce low distortion at low
input levels, saturation distortion will occur at some point
as the input sound level is increased beyond the capability of
the battery, the amplifier stage, and the output stage.
The high distortion effects of saturation can be seen
graphically in Fig. 2 for a typical class D peak-clipping
hearing aid used in the hearing aid circuit of Fig. 1. The
peak acoustic gain of this hearing aid was 35 dB, the peak
saturated sound pressure level (SSPL) was 107 dB, and the
frequency response matrix slope (difference in acoustic gain
between peak and 500 Hz) was 10 dB. As seen in Fig. 2 a plot
of the harmonic distortion versus frequency for input sound
levels of 60, 70, 80 and 90 dB is provided. These input sound
levels correspond to soft speech, conversational speech, loud
speech and shouted speech, respectively. The distortion
performance graph shows that the level of distortion is low at
low input sound levels, for example, 60 dB and 70 dB, and is
in the area of 2 or 3 percent. When the input sound level is
increased, for example, to 80 dB, the hearing aid goes rapidly
into saturation and the level of distortion increases
dramatically, with the percentage of distortion peaking at
about 50 percent. At an input sound level of 90 dB, the
percentage of distortion continues to increase and typically
exceeds the 50 percent distortion plateau, especially in the
mid-frequencies, for example between 900 Hz and 2000 Hz.
The use of a compression circuit at the preamplifier
stage has been shown to slightly reduce the saturation
distortion of conventional hearing aids. Fig. 3
illustrates conventional hearing aid circuitry with a
compression circuit 52 connected to the preamplifier
stage 12, and Fig. 4 is a distortion performance graph
for the hearing aid shown in Fig. 3. As seen in Fig. 4,
even with a compression circuit at the preamplifier
stage, the percentage of distortion is still
significantly high when the input sound level increases
above the 80 dB level.
Therefore, a need exists for a hearing aid that responds
to high as well as low input sound levels to
substantially minimize the percentage of distortion in
the output signal of the hearing aid so as to provide a
person wearing the hearing aid with clear, audible
sound.
The present invention provides a non-distortion circuit
for a hearing aid which uses independent multiple
compression feedback loops to minimize sound distortion.
The circuit includes a preamplifier network having an
input connected to an input receiver, an output, and an
automatically adjustable gain. The preamplifier network
measures an output signal, which is preferably a
voltage, and automatically adjusts the gain in
response to the output signal. The circuit also includes
an output drive network having an input connected to the
preamplifier network output and an output connected to a
load, such as a transducer. Preferably, the output drive
network has an automatically adjustable gain that is
responsive to a measured signal at the output of the
network. The circuit may preferably include a volume
control circuit connected between the output of the
preamplifier network and the input of the output drive
network. Preferably, the volume control circuit has a
variable resistor, such as a potentiometer, connected in
a voltage divider configuration. The volume control
circuit permits the person wearing the hearing aid to
adjust the output volume of the hearing aid.
In the preferred embodiment, the hearing aid
preamplifier network includes an amplifier circuit
having an adjustable gain and a gain control circuit
connected in a feedback loop with the amplifier circuit.
This configuration forms a gain compression feedback
circuit which automatically adjusts the gain of the
amplifier circuit so as to prevent the amplifier circuit
from saturating.
The gain control circuit is connected to an output of
the amplifier circuit and is configured to automatically
adjust the amplifier circuit gain when a voltage on the
amplifier circuit output exceeds a predetermined
threshold voltage. The
predetermined threshold voltage is set to a value below
a voltage where the preamplifier network amplifier
circuit saturates. Preferably, the predetermined
threshold voltage is 7.8 mv(rms) input-referred which
typically corresponds to an 85 dB sound pressure level
acoustic input with a battery voltage of 1.25 volts.
The output drive network preferably includes an
amplifier circuit having an adjustable gain and a gain
control circuit connected in a feedback loop with the
amplifier circuit. This configuration also forms a gain
compression feedback circuit to automatically adjust the
gain of the output network amplifier circuit independent
of the preamplifier stage, so as to prevent the
amplifier circuit from saturating.
Preferably, the output drive network gain control
circuit is connected to an output of the output drive
network amplifier circuit and is configured to
automatically adjust the output network amplifier
circuit gain when a voltage on the amplifier circuit
output exceeds a predetermined threshold voltage. The
output network predetermined threshold voltage is set to
a value which is below a voltage where the output
network amplifier circuit saturates. Preferably, the
predetermined threshold voltage is 880 mv(rms)
output-referred when a class B push-pull amplifier
circuit or a class D pulse-width
modulated amplifier circuit is utilized in the output drive
network.
In an alternative embodiment, a non-distorting circuit
for a hearing aid is provided. In this embodiment, the
circuit includes a preamplifier stage having a first amplifier
circuit with an adjustable gain and a first gain control
circuit. The first amplifier circuit has an input connected
to a microphone and an output. The first gain control circuit
is connected to the output of the preamplifier stage and is
responsive to a voltage on the preamplifier stage output such
that when the voltage exceeds a predetermined threshold
voltage the gain of the first amplifier circuit is adjusted
The circuit also includes an output stage having an input
connected to the output of the preamplifier stage, and an
output connected to a transducer. The output stage has a
second amplifier circuit with a fixed gain, and a second gain
control circuit. The second gain control circuit is connected
to the output of the output stage and the first gain control
circuit. The second gain control circuit is responsive to a
voltage on the output of the second amplifier circuit, such
that when the second amplifier circuit output voltage exceeds
a predetermined threshold voltage the second gain control
circuit causes the preamplifier stage gain to change. The
predetermined threshold voltages for the preamplifier stage
and the output stage may be the same or they may differ.
These predetermined voltage thresholds are dependent upon the
voltage at which the respective stage saturates.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
Preferred embodiments of the invention are described
hereinbelow with reference to the drawings wherein:
Fig. 1 is a circuit diagram for a conventional hearing
aid; Fig. 2 is a graphical representation of the sound
distortion performance characteristics in the conventional
hearing aid of Fig. 1 at different input sound levels; Fig. 3 is a circuit diagram for a conventional hearing
aid with compression circuitry at the preamplifier stage; Fig. 4 is a graphical representation of the sound
distortion performance characteristics in the hearing aid of
Fig. 3 at different input sound levels; Fig. 5 is a circuit diagram for a hearing aid according
to an embodiment the present invention, illustrating
compression feedback loops connected to preamplifier and
output stages; Fig. 6 is an exemplary embodiment for a compression
feedback loop circuit according to the present invention,
illustrating a gain control circuit connected to a
preamplifier stage amplifier and a current controlled
resistor; Fig. 7 is a graphical representation of the sound
distortion characteristics in a hearing aid according to the
present invention; Fig. 8 is an unamplified time waveform of a test speech
fragment; Fig. 9 is a time waveform of the speech fragment of Fig.
8 at the output of the output stage of Fig. 3; Fig. 10 is a time waveform of the speech fragment of Fig.
8 at the output of the output stage of Fig. 5; and Fig. 11 is a circuit diagram for an alternative
embodiment of the hearing aid circuitry according to the
present invention.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
Generally, as described above, the present invention uses
multiple compression feedback loops to minimize the sound
distortion in hearing aids, especially when the input sound
level increases above a predetermined threshold.
As discussed above, signal clipping can occur at the
output of the preamplifier stage and at the output of the
output stage. The point at which the preamplifier output
clips is dependent upon the amplitude of the input signal
from the microphone, that is, the input sound level, the
preamplifier gain, and the battery voltage. Typically,
clipping occurs when the input sound level, also known as the
sound pressure level (SPL) reaches about 80 dB. Clipping at
the output stage is a function of the input sound level from
the microphone, the preamplifier gain, the battery voltage,
the level of attenuation provided by the volume control
circuit, and the gain of the output stage.
To illustrate, if the volume control circuit is set by
the user for minimum attenuation and the input signal from the
microphone increases in magnitude over time, the output of the
output stage will clip before the preamplifier stage output,
because of the gain of the output stage. On the other hand,
if the volume control circuit attenuation is adjusted so that
the amplitude of the input signal to the output stage is
reduced by the same value or a greater value than the gain of
the output stage, then the preamplifier stage will clip before
the output stage.
To overcome this problem and minimize clipping in the
hearing aid, the output of the preamplifier stage and the
output of the output stage are individually sensed and
controlled through compression. The compression thresholds
for both stages are preferably set as high as possible without
causing clipping. Typically, a compression ratio of 10:1 is
suitable.
Referring now to Fig. 5, one embodiment of the hearing
aid circuitry for minimizing distortion according to the
present invention is provided. As shown, the hearing aid 10
has a preamplifier stage 60 and an output stage 90. The
preamplifier stage is provided to increase the input signal
amplitude so as to improve the overall signal-to-noise ratio
(SNR) of the system.
The preamplifier stage 60 includes an amplifier 62 having
one input 64 connected to an input receiver, such as
microphone 66, via coupling capacitor 68, and another input 70
connected to ground. The amplifier 62 has an adjustable gain
set by fixed resistor 72 and variable resistor 74.
Preferably, the variable resistor is a current controlled
resistor responsive to a control current supplied by a gain
control circuit. The current controlled resistor has a
predetermined voltage-to-current transfer function
(transconductance) which is directly proportional to the
control current supplied by the gain control circuit. An
example of a suitable current controlled resistor is a
operational transconductance amplifier (OTA) model LM3080
manufactured by National Semiconductor Corporation.
The gain control circuit 76 is connected to the output 78
of amplifier 62 and to variable resistor 74. The gain control
circuit 76 measures or detects the voltage of the output
signal from the amplifier 62 and compares the measured voltage
with a predetermined threshold voltage. Preferably, the
predetermined threshold voltage is 7.8 mV(rms) input-referred.
If the measured voltage is greater than the threshold voltage,
then the gain control circuit 76 varies the resistance of
variable resistor 74 so as to reduce the gain of the
preamplifier stage amplifier 62. If the measured voltage is
less than the threshold voltage then the gain control circuit
generates a current that sets the variable resistor 74 for
maximum gain of amplifier 62.
The gain control circuit 76, the resistor 72, the
variable resistor 74, and the amplifier 62 form a preamplifier
compression feedback loop which controls the gain of the
amplifier 62. The preamplifier compression feedback loop is
provided to reduce the gain of the preamplifier stage 60 just
before the output signal of the amplifier 62 exceeds the
capabilities of the supply voltage, that is, prior to
amplifier saturation. Utilization of the compression feedback
loop causes the preamplifier stage amplifier 62 to amplify
within its linear region and thus prevents the amplifier from
saturating. Hence, saturation distortion, for example, peak-clipping
is limited or substantially minimized even when the
input sound level is high, for example, exceeds 85 dB.
The preamplifier stage 60 is typically followed by a user
adjustable volume control circuit 80 that permits a
practitioner or patient to adjust the output sound level of
the hearing aid 10 for maximum comfort. In the embodiment of
Fig. 5, a variable resistor, such as potentiometer 82, is
connected as a voltage divider to ground between an output 78
of the preamplifier stage 60 and an input 84 of the output
stage 90 via coupling capacitor 86.
The output stage 90 of hearing aid 10 includes an
amplifier 92 having an input connected to the output 84 of
volume control circuit 80. The output stage 90 also has an
adjustable gain set by fixed resistor 94 and variable resistor
96 and is provided to drive the hearing aid transducer in the
form of speaker 98. Gain control circuit 100 is connected to
the output 102 of amplifier 92 and to variable resistor 96.
Similar to the gain control circuit for the preamplifier
stage, the output stage gain control circuit 100 measures or
detects the voltage of the output signal from the amplifier 92
and compares the measured voltage with a predetermined
threshold voltage. Preferably, the threshold voltage is
880 mV(rms) output-referred when using a class B push-pull
amplifier circuit or a class D pulse-width modulated amplifier
circuit in the output stage. If the measured voltage is
greater than the threshold voltage, then the gain control
circuit 100 varies the resistance of variable resistor 96 so
as to reduce the gain of the output stage amplifier 92. If
the measured voltage is less than the threshold voltage then
the gain control circuit generates a current that sets the
variable resistor 96 for the maximum gain of amplifier 92.
The gain control circuit 100, the resistor 94, the
variable resistor 96, and the amplifier 92 form an-output
stage compression feedback loop that controls the gain of the
amplifier 92. The output stage compression feedback loop is
provided to reduce the gain of the output stage 90 just before
the output signal of the amplifier 92 exceeds the capabilities
of the supply voltage, that is, prior to amplifier saturation.
Utilization of the compression feedback loop causes the output
stage amplifier 92 to amplify within its linear region and
thus prevents the amplifier from saturating. Hence,
saturation distortion, for example, peak-clipping is limited
or substantially minimized even when the input sound level
exceeds 85 dB.
As described above, the compression feedback loops are
used to minimize the sound distortion in hearing aids,
especially when the input sound level increases. In addition,
the compression feedback loop provides a constant compression
ratio, for example, 10:1, so as to ensure a predictable output
signal amplitude from the preamplifier stage amplifier 62 and
the output stage amplifier 92 for any input signal amplitude
into the amplifier. As a result, numerous configurations for
the compression feedback loops may be used to achieve at least
these desired features.
An exemplary embodiment for the compression feedback loop
is shown in Fig. 6. For simplicity, the following description
will be for a compression feedback loop for the preamplifier
stage, however, this compression feedback loop may also be
utilized in the output stage. Further, the compression ratio
for either stage may be changed by using discrete components
having different characteristics and/or values.
In the embodiment of Fig. 6, the preamplifier stage
amplifier output is connected to a half-wave rectifier circuit
within gain control circuit 76. The half-wave rectifier
circuit 120 includes amplifier 122, PMOSFET transistor 124,
and capacitor 126. Although the rectifier circuit shown is
a half-wave rectifier, a full-wave rectifier circuit may also
be used. Further, capacitor 126 is a primary compensation
element for the loop and has a value that is chosen so its
delay characteristic is dominant over the time delay through
the loop. The output of the rectifier circuit is fed to a
comparator 128 that compares the voltage of the rectified
signal with the predetermined threshold voltage. If the
rectified signal voltage (Vo) is less than the threshold
voltage (Vth) then solenoid 130 in relay switch 132 is not
energized and the relay switch remains open. If the rectified
signal voltage (Vo) is greater than the threshold voltage (Vth)
then the output of the comparator 128 energizes the relay
solenoid 130 and closes relay switch 132, so as to enable
operation of the gain compression feature. When the relay
switch is closed, amplifier 134 acts as a difference amplifier
to subtract the output voltage V1 of logarithmic amplifier 136
from the output voltage V2 of logarithmic amplifier 138, and
to scale the result by a gain transfer factor (GT). The
output voltage V3 of difference amplifier 134 is summed with
the output voltage of logarithmic amplifier 140 by summing
amplifier 142. Amplifier 144 and operational transconductance
amplifier 146 form a feedback voltage-to-current converter.
The output voltage V6 of amplifier 144 controls operational
transconductance amplifier 148 to provide the desired current
to current-controlled resistor 74.
In essence, amplifiers 134 through 148 and their
associated discrete components operate as a compression
control signal processor that generates and provides the
desired current to control the variable resistor 74. As
noted above, the current controlled variable resistor 74
is preferably an operational transconductance amplifier
that changes the gain of the amplifier 62 as the current
increases or decreases. An example of a suitable
transconductance amplifier is the model LM3080
manufactured by National Semiconductor. A more detailed
description of the compression feedback loop can be
found in European application entitled "A COMPRESSION
AMPLIFIER", filed concurrently herewith, which is
assigned to the assignee hereof and is incorporated
herein in its entirety by reference.
The output increase (OI) in amplitude for the
compression feedback loops, for example, the output of
preamplifier stage amplifier 62 is defined by the
following equation:
OI = 20log10 |Vo | Vth
Where:
Vo is output voltage from the half wave rectifier; and Vth is the predetermined threshold voltage.
Fig. 7 provides a graphical representation of the
distortion performance characteristics for a hearing aid
utilizing multiple compression feedback loops. Figs. 8-10
provide a comparison between a test speech pattern (Fig. 8),
the output speech pattern of a conventional hearing with
compression at the preamplifier stage (Fig. 9), and the output
speech pattern of a hearing aid with compression at the
preamplifier and output stages (Fig. 10).
Referring now to Fig. 11 an alternative embodiment of the
hearing aid circuitry according to present invention is
provided. In this embodiment, a single timing capacitor 104
is used for each gain control circuit 76 and 100 instead of
multiple timing capacitors 126. In this alternative
embodiment, the output stage 90 has a fixed gain set by
resistors 94 and 106. Each stage is still independently
sensed by their respective gain control circuit 76 and 100,
but the amplitude of the output signal for each stage is
controlled by a single gain control circuit which is
preferably associated with the preamplifier stage 60. The
compression ratio for this configuration is also high, for
example, 10 to 1 (10:1), thus causing one stage to dominate
the compression action depending on the attenuation of the
volume control circuit 80.
Referring again to Fig. 5, in operation the input sound
level, whether it be soft speech, conversational speech, loud
speech and shouted speech is detected by the microphone 66 and
filtered and amplified by the preamplifier stage 60. The
amplified signal from the preamplifier stage passes through
the volume control circuitry where it may be attenuated
depending upon the setting of potentiometer 82. The output of
the volume control circuit is transferred to the output stage
90 for amplification. The output stage amplifies the signal
and drives the transducer, such as speaker 98.
As the input sound level is amplified, the gain control
circuit 76 senses or measures the voltage of the output signal
of the amplifier 62. If the voltage of the amplifier output
signal exceeds the predefined threshold voltage, preferably
7.8 mV(rms) input-referred, the gain of the amplifier 62 is
automatically decreased by adjusting the resistance of
variable resistor 74. As the output voltage of the amplifier
attempts to increase beyond the predetermined threshold
voltage, the resistance of the variable resistor 74 is
adjusted so that the amplifier continues to operate in the
linear region and thus inhibits the amplifier 62 from
saturating.
Similarly, the output voltage of the output stage
amplifier 92 is sensed or measured by gain control circuit
100. If the voltage of the amplifier output exceeds the
predefined threshold voltage, preferably 880 mV(rms) output-referred,
the gain of the amplifier is automatically decreased
by adjusting the resistance of variable resistor 96. As the
output voltage of the amplifier attempts to increase beyond
the predetermined threshold voltage, the resistance of the
variable resistor 74 is adjusted so that the amplifier
continues to operate in the linear region and thus inhibits
the amplifier 92 from saturating.
It will be understood that various modifications can be
made to the embodiments of the present invention herein
disclosed without departing from the spirit and scope thereof.
For example, various types of amplifiers configurations may be
utilized in the preamplifier and the output amplifier stages.
Therefore, the above description should not be construed as
limiting the invention but merely as exemplifications of
preferred embodiments thereof. Those skilled in the art will
envision other modifications within the scope and spirit of
the present invention as defined by the claims appended
hereto.