CN117786614B - Real-time flood forecast rainfall error correction method and device considering time lag influence - Google Patents
Real-time flood forecast rainfall error correction method and device considering time lag influence Download PDFInfo
- Publication number
- CN117786614B CN117786614B CN202311813855.1A CN202311813855A CN117786614B CN 117786614 B CN117786614 B CN 117786614B CN 202311813855 A CN202311813855 A CN 202311813855A CN 117786614 B CN117786614 B CN 117786614B
- Authority
- CN
- China
- Prior art keywords
- sequence
- runoff
- rainfall
- error
- time
- Prior art date
- Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
- Active
Links
Classifications
-
- Y—GENERAL TAGGING OF NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS; GENERAL TAGGING OF CROSS-SECTIONAL TECHNOLOGIES SPANNING OVER SEVERAL SECTIONS OF THE IPC; TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER USPC CROSS-REFERENCE ART COLLECTIONS [XRACs] AND DIGESTS
- Y02—TECHNOLOGIES OR APPLICATIONS FOR MITIGATION OR ADAPTATION AGAINST CLIMATE CHANGE
- Y02A—TECHNOLOGIES FOR ADAPTATION TO CLIMATE CHANGE
- Y02A10/00—TECHNOLOGIES FOR ADAPTATION TO CLIMATE CHANGE at coastal zones; at river basins
- Y02A10/40—Controlling or monitoring, e.g. of flood or hurricane; Forecasting, e.g. risk assessment or mapping
Landscapes
- Management, Administration, Business Operations System, And Electronic Commerce (AREA)
Abstract
本发明公开了一种考虑滞时影响的实时洪水预报降雨误差修正方法及装置,所述方法包括:收集历史不同洪水场次的实测降雨和出口断面径流资料,计算流域平均汇流时间;将实测计算的面平均降雨量序列作为流域水文模型的输入,得到模拟径流序列,结合实测径流序列计算径流误差序列;采用ARMA模型对径流误差序列进行分析,得到预测序列,从而得到新的径流误差序列;计算水文模型输出模拟径流对面平均降雨的滞后灵敏度,得到滞后灵敏度矩阵;基于新的径流误差序列、滞后灵敏度矩阵,依据最小二乘原理计算面平均降雨误差,修正面平均降雨量序列,利用修正后的面平均降雨量进行径流模拟预报。该方法解决滞时导致的降水误差修正不足,提高洪水预报精度。
The present invention discloses a method and device for correcting rainfall errors in real-time flood forecasts that considers the influence of time lag. The method comprises: collecting measured rainfall and outlet section runoff data of different historical floods, and calculating the average confluence time of the basin; using the measured and calculated surface average rainfall sequence as the input of the basin hydrological model to obtain a simulated runoff sequence, and calculating the runoff error sequence in combination with the measured runoff sequence; using the ARMA model to analyze the runoff error sequence to obtain a prediction sequence, thereby obtaining a new runoff error sequence; calculating the hysteresis sensitivity of the simulated runoff output by the hydrological model to the surface average rainfall, and obtaining a hysteresis sensitivity matrix; based on the new runoff error sequence and the hysteresis sensitivity matrix, calculating the surface average rainfall error according to the least squares principle, correcting the surface average rainfall sequence, and using the corrected surface average rainfall to perform runoff simulation forecasting. The method solves the insufficient correction of precipitation errors caused by time lag and improves the accuracy of flood forecasting.
Description
技术领域Technical Field
本发明涉及一种实时洪水预报中降雨误差的修正方法,属于洪水预报实时校正技术领域。The invention relates to a method for correcting rainfall errors in real-time flood forecasting, and belongs to the technical field of real-time correction of flood forecasting.
背景技术Background Art
洪水预报作为减轻洪水风险的主要非结构性措施,从实践角度被工程技术人员和管理者广泛采用。如何进一步保证洪水预报的准确性一直是水文预报人员关注的主要问题。然而,由于输入数据、模型结构和模型参数估计的不确定性,预报结果通常不够准确,这促使研究人员从多个角度进一步提高预测精度,包括实时误差修正技术的发展。Flood forecasting, as the main non-structural measure to mitigate flood risks, is widely adopted by engineering technicians and managers from a practical perspective. How to further ensure the accuracy of flood forecasting has always been a major concern for hydrological forecasters. However, due to the uncertainty of input data, model structure and model parameter estimation, the forecast results are usually not accurate enough, which has prompted researchers to further improve the prediction accuracy from multiple perspectives, including the development of real-time error correction technology.
降水作为水文模式预报的主要驱动输入,其观测数据的不确定性是洪水预报不确定的重要来源。通过最小化降水不确定性来提高洪水预报的准确性已成为实时洪水预报误差修正的重要研究内容。基于动态系统响应曲线法的降水误差修正技术,其通过建立降水输入与模型输出的系统响应关系,依据模式输出计算误差反向求解降水输入误差进而修正降水,能够有效地提高洪水预报精度。Precipitation is the main driving input of hydrological model forecasts, and the uncertainty of its observation data is an important source of uncertainty in flood forecasts. Improving the accuracy of flood forecasts by minimizing precipitation uncertainty has become an important research topic in real-time flood forecast error correction. The precipitation error correction technology based on the dynamic system response curve method can effectively improve the accuracy of flood forecasts by establishing a system response relationship between precipitation input and model output, and reversely solving the precipitation input error based on the model output calculation error to correct the precipitation.
然而,该方法在实际应用过程中,忽略了实际流域由于汇流作用造成的降雨与径流的滞后响应关系。这种实际存在的滞后响应关系会导致误差修正的信息缺失,具体表现为最新监测的降水观测数值无法得到修正,并进而影响洪水预报更新效果。因此,如何在充分考虑实际流域降雨和径流滞后关系的基础上,通过降雨误差修正来提高洪水预报精度,是实施洪水预报误差修正技术领域亟需解决的问题。However, in the actual application of this method, the hysteresis response relationship between rainfall and runoff caused by the confluence effect in the actual basin is ignored. This actual hysteresis response relationship will lead to the lack of information for error correction, which is specifically manifested in that the latest monitored precipitation observation values cannot be corrected, and thus affects the update effect of flood forecast. Therefore, how to improve the accuracy of flood forecasting through rainfall error correction based on the full consideration of the hysteresis relationship between rainfall and runoff in the actual basin is an urgent problem to be solved in the field of flood forecast error correction technology.
发明内容Summary of the invention
发明目的:针对现有技术的不足,本发明提出了一种考虑滞时影响的实时洪水预报降雨误差修正方法及装置,能够充分考虑到实际流域中降雨-径流形成的时滞特征,解决由于滞时导致的降水误差修正的不足,有助于提高实施洪水预报精度。Purpose of the invention: In view of the shortcomings of the prior art, the present invention proposes a real-time flood forecast rainfall error correction method and device taking into account the influence of time lag, which can fully consider the time lag characteristics of rainfall-runoff formation in the actual basin, solve the shortcomings of precipitation error correction caused by time lag, and help improve the accuracy of flood forecasting.
技术方案:一种考虑滞时影响的实时洪水预报降雨误差修正方法,包括以下步骤:Technical solution: A real-time flood forecast rainfall error correction method considering the effect of time lag, comprising the following steps:
(1)收集流域历史不同洪水场次的实测降雨资料和出口断面径流资料,计算面平均降雨量,统计不同场次面平均雨量雨峰时刻与相应径流过程的洪峰时刻之间的时间差,计算时间差的平均值得到流域平均汇流时间步长δ;(1) Collect the measured rainfall data and outlet runoff data of different flood events in the basin history, calculate the average rainfall, count the time difference between the peak time of the average rainfall in different events and the peak time of the corresponding runoff process, and calculate the average time difference to obtain the average confluence time step δ of the basin;
(2)将基于流域实时监测降雨数据计算得到的面平均降雨量序列P=[p1,p2,…,pm]作为流域水文模型的输入,pm表示第m个面平均降雨量,利用流域水文模型得到模拟径流序列Qc=[qc1,qc2,…,qcn],qcn表示第n个模拟径流,n>m,再基于实时监测的实测径流序列Qo=[qo1,qo2,…,qom]计算径流误差序列ΔQ=Qo-Qc=[qo1-qc1,qo2-qc2,…,qom-qcm]=[Δq1,Δq2,…,Δqm];(2) The surface average rainfall sequence P = [p 1 ,p 2 ,…,p m ] calculated based on the real-time monitoring rainfall data of the basin is used as the input of the basin hydrological model, where p m represents the mth surface average rainfall. The simulated runoff sequence Qc = [qc 1 ,qc 2 ,…,qc n ] is obtained using the basin hydrological model, where qc n represents the nth simulated runoff, n>m. Then, based on the measured runoff sequence Qo = [qo 1 ,qo 2 ,…,qo m ] monitored in real time, the runoff error sequence ΔQ = Qo-Qc = [qo 1 -qc 1 ,qo 2 -qc 2 ,…,qo m -qc m ] = [Δq 1 ,Δq 2 ,…,Δq m ] is calculated;
(3)采用移动自回归平均模型ARMA对径流误差序列进行分析,得到预测径流误差序列[Δqm+1,Δqm+2,…,Δqm+δ],整合原始径流误差序列与预测序列得到新的径流误差序列ΔQ'=[Δq1+δ,Δq2+δ,…,Δqm+δ];(3) The ARMA model is used to analyze the runoff error sequence and obtain the predicted runoff error sequence [Δq m+1 , Δq m+2 , …, Δq m+δ ], and the original runoff error sequence is integrated with the predicted sequence to obtain a new runoff error sequence ΔQ' = [Δq 1+δ , Δq 2+δ , …, Δq m+δ ];
(4)对面平均降雨量序列P中每个降雨量施加扰动,连同原面平均降雨量序列,作为流域水文模型的输入,计算输出相应的模拟径流,计算模拟径流序列对于面平均降雨量的滞后灵敏度,得到滞后灵敏度矩阵S;(4) Apply disturbance to each rainfall in the area average rainfall sequence P, together with the original area average rainfall sequence, as the input of the basin hydrological model, calculate and output the corresponding simulated runoff, calculate the lag sensitivity of the simulated runoff sequence to the area average rainfall, and obtain the lag sensitivity matrix S;
(5)基于新的径流误差序列ΔQ'、滞后灵敏度矩阵S,依据最小二乘原理计算面平均降雨误差序列ΔP=[Δp1,Δp2,…,Δpm],根据ΔP修正面平均降雨量序列P,将修正后的面平均降雨量序列输入流域水文模型重新进行径流模拟预报。(5) Based on the new runoff error sequence ΔQ' and the lagged sensitivity matrix S, the surface average rainfall error sequence ΔP = [Δp 1 , Δp 2 , …, Δp m ] is calculated according to the least squares principle. The surface average rainfall sequence P is corrected according to ΔP, and the corrected surface average rainfall sequence is input into the basin hydrological model to re-simulate the runoff forecast.
进一步地,所述步骤(1)中,利用泰森多边形法计算面平均降雨量。Furthermore, in step (1), the average rainfall on the surface is calculated using the Thiessen polygon method.
进一步地,所述步骤(2)中,流域水文模型采用新安江模型。Furthermore, in step (2), the watershed hydrological model adopts the Xin'anjiang model.
进一步地,所述步骤(3)中,ARMA模型表示为:Furthermore, in step (3), the ARMA model is expressed as:
式中:j为自回归阶数,k为移动平均阶数,φi为自回归系数,为移动平均系数,εt和εt-i为t时刻和t-i时刻满足高斯分布的白噪声,Δqt-i为第t-i个径流误差。Where: j is the autoregressive order, k is the moving average order, φ i is the autoregressive coefficient, is the moving average coefficient, ε t and ε ti are white noises that satisfy Gaussian distribution at time t and time ti, and Δq ti is the ti-th runoff error.
进一步地,自回归阶数j和移动平均阶数通过AIC准则来确定,表示为:Furthermore, the autoregressive order j and the moving average order are determined by the AIC criterion, expressed as:
AIC=Nln(MSE)+2KAIC=Nln(MSE)+2K
式中:N为实际样本数,K为模型参数个数,MSE为均方误差。Where: N is the actual number of samples, K is the number of model parameters, and MSE is the mean square error.
进一步地,所述步骤(4)包括:Furthermore, the step (4) comprises:
对面平均降雨量序列P=[p1,p2,…,pm]中的p1施加扰动项dp1得到序列P+dp1=[p1+dp1,p2,…,pm],将两个降雨序列分别作为流域水文模型的输入,得到模拟径流Qc(P)=[qc1,qc2,…,qcn]和输出径流序列对于面平均降雨p1的滞后灵敏度为: Apply the disturbance term dp 1 to p 1 in the average rainfall sequence P = [p 1 ,p 2 ,…, pm ] to obtain the sequence P+dp 1 = [p 1 +dp 1 ,p 2 ,…, pm ], and use the two rainfall sequences as the input of the basin hydrological model to obtain the simulated runoff Qc(P) = [qc 1 ,qc 2 ,…,qc n ] and The lag sensitivity of the output runoff series to the area average rainfall p 1 is:
对面平均降雨量序列P=[p1,p2,…,pm]中的p2施加扰动项dp2得到序列P+dp2=[p1,p2+dp2,…,pm],将两个降雨序列分别作为流域水文模型的输入,得到模拟计算径流Qc(P)=[qc1,qc2,…,qcn]和输出径流序列对于面平均降雨p2的滞后灵敏度为: Apply the disturbance term dp 2 to p 2 in the average rainfall sequence P = [p 1 ,p 2 ,…, pm ] to obtain the sequence P+dp 2 = [p 1 ,p 2 +dp 2 ,…, pm ], and use the two rainfall sequences as the input of the basin hydrological model to obtain the simulated runoff Qc(P) = [qc 1 ,qc 2 ,…,qc n ] and The lag sensitivity of the output runoff series to the area average rainfall p2 is:
重复上述步骤,直至输出径流序列对于面平均降雨量序列中的所有数值的滞后敏感度计算完成,最终得到滞后灵敏度矩阵S:Repeat the above steps until the hysteresis sensitivity calculation of the output runoff sequence to all values in the surface average rainfall sequence is completed, and finally the hysteresis sensitivity matrix S is obtained:
进一步地,所述步骤(5)中,依据最小二乘原理计算降水误差序列ΔP,表达式为:Furthermore, in step (5), the precipitation error sequence ΔP is calculated according to the least squares principle, and the expression is:
ΔP=(STS)-1STΔQ'ΔP=(S T S) -1 S T ΔQ'
利用求解的面平均降雨误差序列对原始面平均降雨量序列进行修正:The original surface average rainfall sequence is corrected using the solved surface average rainfall error sequence:
P'=P+ΔP=[p1+Δp1,p2+Δp2,…,pm+Δpm]P'=P+ΔP=[p 1 +Δp 1 , p 2 +Δp 2 ,…, p m +Δp m ]
P'为修正后的面平均降雨量序列。P' is the corrected surface average rainfall series.
本发明还提供一种考虑滞时影响的实时洪水预报降雨误差修正装置,包括:The present invention also provides a real-time flood forecast rainfall error correction device taking into account the influence of time lag, comprising:
平均汇流时间计算模块,用于收集流域历史不同洪水场次的实测降雨资料和出口断面径流资料,计算面平均降雨量,统计不同场次面平均雨量雨峰时刻与相应径流过程的洪峰时刻之间的时间差,计算时间差的平均值得到流域平均汇流时间步长δ;The average confluence time calculation module is used to collect the measured rainfall data and outlet section runoff data of different flood events in the basin history, calculate the average rainfall, count the time difference between the peak time of the average rainfall in different events and the peak time of the corresponding runoff process, and calculate the average value of the time difference to obtain the average confluence time step δ of the basin;
径流误差序列计算模块,用于将基于流域实时监测降雨数据计算得到的面平均降雨量序列P=[p1,p2,…,pm]作为流域水文模型的输入,pm表示第m个面平均降雨量,利用流域水文模型得到模拟径流序列Qc=[qc1,qc2,…,qcn],qcn表示第n个模拟径流,n>m,再基于实时监测的实测径流序列Qo=[qo1,qo2,…,qom]计算径流误差序列ΔQ=Qo-Qc=[qo1-qc1,qo2-qc2,…,qom-qcm]=[Δq1,Δq2,…,Δqm];a runoff error sequence calculation module, for using the surface average rainfall sequence P = [p 1 ,p 2 ,…, pm ] calculated based on the real-time monitoring rainfall data of the watershed as the input of the watershed hydrological model, wherepm represents the mth surface average rainfall, and using the watershed hydrological model to obtain the simulated runoff sequence Qc = [qc 1 ,qc 2 ,…,qc n ], whereqc n represents the nth simulated runoff, n>m, and then calculating the runoff error sequence ΔQ = Qo-Qc = [qo 1 -qc 1 ,qo 2 -qc 2 ,…,qo m -qc m ] = [ Δq 1 ,Δq 2 ,…,Δq m ] based on the real-time monitored measured runoff sequence Qo = [qo 1 ,qo 2 ,…,qo m ];
径流误差序列预测更新模块,用于采用移动自回归平均模型ARMA对径流误差序列进行分析,得到预测径流误差序列[Δqm+1,Δqm+2,…,Δqm+δ],整合原始径流误差序列与预测序列得到新的径流误差序列ΔQ'=[Δq1+δ,Δq2+δ,…,Δqm+δ];The runoff error sequence prediction and update module is used to analyze the runoff error sequence using the moving autoregressive average model ARMA to obtain the predicted runoff error sequence [Δq m+1 ,Δq m+2 ,…,Δq m+δ ], and integrate the original runoff error sequence with the predicted sequence to obtain a new runoff error sequence ΔQ'=[Δq 1+δ ,Δq 2+δ ,…,Δq m+δ ];
滞后灵敏度计算模块,用于对面平均降雨量序列P中每个降雨量施加扰动,连同原面平均降雨量序列,作为流域水文模型的输入,计算输出相应的模拟径流,计算模拟径流序列对于面平均降雨量的滞后灵敏度,得到滞后灵敏度矩阵S;The hysteresis sensitivity calculation module is used to apply disturbance to each rainfall in the surface average rainfall sequence P, together with the original surface average rainfall sequence, as the input of the basin hydrological model, calculate and output the corresponding simulated runoff, calculate the hysteresis sensitivity of the simulated runoff sequence to the surface average rainfall, and obtain the hysteresis sensitivity matrix S;
降雨误差修正模块,用于基于新的径流误差序列ΔQ'、滞后灵敏度矩阵S,依据最小二乘原理计算面平均降雨误差序列ΔP=[Δp1,Δp2,…,Δpm],根据ΔP修正面平均降雨量序列P,将修正后的面平均降雨量序列输入流域水文模型重新进行径流模拟预报。The rainfall error correction module is used to calculate the surface average rainfall error sequence ΔP = [Δp 1 , Δp 2 , …, Δp m ] based on the new runoff error sequence ΔQ' and the lag sensitivity matrix S according to the least squares principle, correct the surface average rainfall sequence P according to ΔP, and input the corrected surface average rainfall sequence into the basin hydrological model to re-carry out runoff simulation forecast.
本发明还提供一种计算机设备,包括:一个或多个处理器;存储器;以及一个或多个程序,其中所述一个或多个程序被存储在所述存储器中,并且被配置为由所述一个或多个处理器执行,所述程序被处理器执行时实现如上所述的考虑滞时影响的实时洪水预报降雨误差修正方法的步骤。The present invention also provides a computer device, comprising: one or more processors; a memory; and one or more programs, wherein the one or more programs are stored in the memory and are configured to be executed by the one or more processors, and when the programs are executed by the processors, the steps of the real-time flood forecast rainfall error correction method considering the effect of time lag as described above are implemented.
本发明还提供一种计算机可读存储介质,其上存储有计算机程序,所述计算机程序被处理器执行时实现如上所述的考虑滞时影响的实时洪水预报降雨误差修正方法的步骤。The present invention also provides a computer-readable storage medium having a computer program stored thereon, and when the computer program is executed by a processor, the steps of the real-time flood forecast rainfall error correction method considering the time lag effect as described above are implemented.
与现有技术相比,本发明具有以下有益效果:Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following beneficial effects:
本发明克服了目前基于动态系统响应曲线进行洪水预报降雨误差修正时,由于未考虑降雨径流滞时关系导致的降水修正不完全的不足,对于完善基于动态系统响应曲线的实施洪水预报理论,提高实时洪水预报精度具有重要意义。The present invention overcomes the deficiency of incomplete precipitation correction caused by failure to consider the rainfall-runoff lag relationship when correcting rainfall errors in flood forecasts based on dynamic system response curves. This invention is of great significance for perfecting the theory of implementing flood forecasting based on dynamic system response curves and improving the accuracy of real-time flood forecasting.
附图说明BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
图1为本发明的一种考虑滞时影响的实时洪水预报降雨误差修正方法的流程图。FIG1 is a flow chart of a method for correcting rainfall errors in real-time flood forecasting taking into account the influence of time lag according to the present invention.
具体实施方式DETAILED DESCRIPTION
下面结合附图对本发明的技术方案作进一步说明。The technical solution of the present invention is further described below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.
如图1所示,一种考虑滞时影响的实时洪水预报降雨误差修正方法,包括以下步骤:As shown in FIG1 , a real-time flood forecast rainfall error correction method considering the time lag effect includes the following steps:
步骤(1),搜集流域历史不同洪水场次的实测降雨资料和出口断面径流资料,计算面平均降雨量,统计不同场次面平均雨量雨峰时刻与相应径流过程的洪峰时刻时间差,计算时间差的平均值得到流域平均汇流时间步长δ;Step (1), collect the measured rainfall data and outlet section runoff data of different flood events in the basin history, calculate the average rainfall, count the time difference between the peak time of the average rainfall in different events and the peak time of the corresponding runoff process, calculate the average value of the time difference to obtain the average confluence time step δ of the basin;
本发明实施例中,搜集大坡岭流域1991-2010年历史不同洪水场次的13个雨量站的小时实测降雨资料和出口断面径流资料,采用泰森多边形法计算面平均降雨量,统计不同场次面平均雨量雨峰时刻与相应径流过程的洪峰时刻时间差,计算该时间差的平均值得到流域平均汇流时间步长δ为9小时。In an embodiment of the present invention, hourly measured rainfall data and outlet section runoff data of 13 rain gauges in different historical flood events in the Dapoling Basin from 1991 to 2010 are collected, and the surface average rainfall is calculated using the Thiessen polygon method. The time difference between the peak time of the surface average rainfall in different events and the peak time of the corresponding runoff process is counted, and the average value of the time difference is calculated to obtain the basin average confluence time step δ of 9 hours.
步骤(2),基于实时监测降雨数据计算得到面平均降雨量序列P=[p1,p2,…,pm],m为实时监测降雨的个数,P一般为时间序列,即P由第一个时刻面平均降雨量p1至第m个时刻面平均降雨量pm构成,该序列也称为面平均降雨量序列或面平均降雨序列,将P输入流域水文模型,得到计算径流(也称为模拟径流)序列Qc=[qc1,qc2,…,qcn],n为计算径流的个数,n>m,通过流域水文模型,可以由已知的降水(1~m)计算模拟得到过去(1~m)和未来(m~n)一段时间的径流,其中[qcm,qcm+1,…,qcn]为预报径流,基于实时监测的实测径流序列Qo=[qo1,qo2,…,qom]计算径流误差序列ΔQ=Qo-Qc=[qo1-qc1,qo2-qc2,…,qom-qcm]=[Δq1,Δq2,…,Δqm];Step (2): based on the real-time monitoring rainfall data, the surface average rainfall sequence P = [ p1 , p2 , ..., pm ] is calculated, where m is the number of real-time monitoring rainfalls. P is generally a time series, that is, P is composed of the surface average rainfall at the first moment p1 to the surface average rainfall at the mth moment pm . This sequence is also called the surface average rainfall sequence or the surface average rainfall sequence. P is input into the watershed hydrological model to obtain the calculated runoff (also called simulated runoff) sequence Qc = [ qc1 , qc2 , ..., qcn ], where n is the number of calculated runoffs, n>m. Through the watershed hydrological model, the runoff for a period of time in the past (1 to m) and the future (m to n) can be calculated and simulated from the known precipitation (1 to m), where [ qcm , qcm +1 , ..., qcn ] is the predicted runoff. The measured runoff sequence based on real-time monitoring is Qo = [ qo1 , qo2 , ..., qom ] Calculate the runoff error sequence ΔQ = Qo-Qc = [qo 1 -qc 1 ,qo 2 -qc 2 ,…,qo m -qc m ] = [Δq 1 ,Δq 2 ,…,Δq m ];
实时校正表示收集观测的面平均雨量后,立即运行模型,模拟径流,同时通过过去的监测径流(1~m)修正模型,达到更新未来计算径流(m~n)的过程,整个操作的时间点就是在m处,1~m为过去,m~n为未来。Real-time correction means that after collecting the observed average rainfall, the model is immediately run to simulate the runoff. At the same time, the model is corrected through the past monitored runoff (1~m) to achieve the process of updating the future calculated runoff (m~n). The time point of the entire operation is at m, 1~m is the past, and m~n is the future.
本发明实施例中,流域水文模型采用新安江模型,以19960707号洪水为例,将基于实时监测降雨数据计算得到的面平均降雨量P=[p1,p2,…,p52]作为新安江模型输入,利用模型计算得到模拟径流Qc=[qc1,qc2,…,qcn]。实时监测的实测径流为Qo=[qo1,qo2,…,qo52],计算实测径流与模拟径流之间的差作为径流误差:ΔQ=Qo-Qc=[qo1-qc1,qo2-qc2,…,qo52-qc52]=[Δq1,Δq2,…,Δq52],部分计算结果见表1。In the embodiment of the present invention, the basin hydrological model adopts the Xin'anjiang model. Taking the 19960707 flood as an example, the surface average rainfall P = [p 1 , p 2 , …, p 52 ] calculated based on the real-time monitoring rainfall data is used as the input of the Xin'anjiang model, and the simulated runoff Qc = [qc 1 , qc 2 , …, qc n ] is calculated by the model. The measured runoff monitored in real time is Qo = [qo 1 , qo 2 , …, qo 52 ], and the difference between the measured runoff and the simulated runoff is calculated as the runoff error: ΔQ = Qo-Qc = [qo 1 -qc 1 , qo 2 -qc 2 , …, qo 52 -qc 52 ] = [Δq 1 , Δq 2 , …, Δq 52 ], and some calculation results are shown in Table 1.
表1面平均降雨量、模拟径流、实测径流、径流误差序列Table 1. Average rainfall, simulated runoff, measured runoff, and runoff error series
步骤(3),采用移动自回归平均模型ARMA对径流误差序列进行分析,得到预测径流误差序列[Δqm+1,Δqm+2,…,Δqm+δ],整合原始径流误差序列与预测序列得到新的径流误差序列ΔQ'=[Δq1+δ,Δq2+δ,…,Δqm+δ];Step (3), using the moving autoregressive average model ARMA to analyze the runoff error sequence, obtain the predicted runoff error sequence [Δq m+1 , Δq m+2 , …, Δq m+δ ], integrate the original runoff error sequence with the predicted sequence to obtain a new runoff error sequence ΔQ' = [Δq 1+δ , Δq 2+δ , …, Δq m+δ ];
由于流域平均汇流时间δ的存在,t时刻的面平均雨量pt在t+δ及之后的时刻才会对计算径流产生影响,这就是所谓的滞后响应。因此在通过计算径流误差反推面平均雨量误差时,修正1~m时刻的面平均降水,那就需要1+δ~m+δ的径流误差,由于实测径流只观测到m时刻,因此仅有1+δ~m的径流误差可通过计算得到,而m+1~m+δ的部分可通过ARMA预测得到。Due to the existence of the average runoff time δ in the basin, the surface average rainfall pt at time t will not affect the calculated runoff until t+δ and later, which is the so-called delayed response. Therefore, when the surface average rainfall error is inferred by calculating the runoff error, the surface average precipitation at time 1 to m is corrected, which requires a runoff error of 1+δ to m+δ. Since the measured runoff is only observed at time m, only the runoff error of 1+δ to m can be calculated, while the part of m+1 to m+δ can be obtained through ARMA prediction.
其中,ARMA模型表示为:Among them, the ARMA model is expressed as:
式中:j为自回归阶数,k为移动平均阶数,φi为自回归系数,为移动平均系数,εt和εt-i为t时刻和t-i时刻满足高斯分布的白噪声;Where: j is the autoregressive order, k is the moving average order, φ i is the autoregressive coefficient, is the moving average coefficient, εt and εti are white noises satisfying Gaussian distribution at time t and time ti;
整合原始径流误差序列与预测序列是指两个序列拼接在一起,并从中得到我们需要的部分即从Δq1+δ起至Δqm+δ。Integrating the original runoff error sequence with the predicted sequence means splicing the two sequences together and getting the part we need from them, i.e., from Δq 1+δ to Δq m+δ .
本发明实施例中,采用ARMA模型对径流误差序列进行分析,得到预测径流误差序列[Δq53,Δq54,…,Δq61],拼接原始径流误差序列与预测序列得到新的径流误差序列ΔQ'=[Δq10,Δq11,…,Δq61]。In the embodiment of the present invention, the ARMA model is used to analyze the runoff error sequence to obtain a predicted runoff error sequence [Δq 53 , Δq 54 , …, Δq 61 ], and the original runoff error sequence and the predicted sequence are concatenated to obtain a new runoff error sequence ΔQ'=[Δq 10 , Δq 11 , …, Δq 61 ].
本发明基于AIC准则确定自回归阶数j和移动平均阶数k,不同的(j,k)组合得到不同的ARMA模型表达式,不同表达式对于ΔQ=[Δq1,Δq2,…,Δqm]有不同的拟合度(通过MSE均方误差表现),通过AIC最小(拟合度最高)来确定(j,k)的最佳组合。AIC准则表示为:The present invention determines the autoregressive order j and the moving average order k based on the AIC criterion. Different (j, k) combinations obtain different ARMA model expressions. Different expressions have different fits for ΔQ=[Δq 1 , Δq 2 ,…, Δq m ] (expressed by MSE mean square error). The best combination of (j, k) is determined by minimizing AIC (highest fit). The AIC criterion is expressed as:
AIC=Nln(MSE)+2KAIC=Nln(MSE)+2K
式中:N为实际样本数,K为模型参数个数,MSE为均方误差。Where: N is the actual number of samples, K is the number of model parameters, and MSE is the mean square error.
本发明实施例中,基于AIC准则确定自回归阶数j=3和移动平均阶数k=1,AIC计算值为449.29,基于ARMA模型预测多步径流误差[Δq53,Δq54,…Δq61]=[31.43,70.41,102.84,125.84,134.45,130.23,117.09,100.87,86.79],拼接原始径流误差序列与预测序列得到新的径流误差序列ΔQ'。In the embodiment of the present invention, the autoregressive order j=3 and the moving average order k=1 are determined based on the AIC criterion, the AIC calculated value is 449.29, and the multi-step runoff error [Δq 53 ,Δq 54 ,…Δq 61 ]=[31.43,70.41,102.84,125.84,134.45,130.23,117.09,100.87,86.79] is predicted based on the ARMA model. The original runoff error sequence and the predicted sequence are concatenated to obtain a new runoff error sequence ΔQ'.
步骤(4),对面平均降雨量序列中每个降雨量施加扰动,连同原面平均降雨量序列,作为流域水文模型的输入,利用模型计算输出相应的模拟径流,计算模拟径流序列对于面平均降雨量的滞后灵敏度,得到滞后灵敏度矩阵S;Step (4), applying disturbance to each rainfall in the surface average rainfall sequence, together with the original surface average rainfall sequence, as the input of the basin hydrological model, using the model to calculate the corresponding simulated runoff output, calculating the lag sensitivity of the simulated runoff sequence to the surface average rainfall, and obtaining the lag sensitivity matrix S;
具体而言,首先,对于面平均降雨序列P=[p1,p2,…,pm]中的p1施加扰动项dp1(如0.001)得到序列P+dp1=[p1+dp1,p2,…,pm],将两个降雨序列分别作为流域水文模型(本实施例中为新安江模型)的输入,利用模型得到对应的模拟径流Qc(P)=[qc1,qc2,…,qcn]和根据下式输出径流序列对于面平均降雨p1的滞后灵敏度为: Specifically, first, a disturbance term dp 1 (such as 0.001) is applied to p 1 in the area average rainfall sequence P = [p 1 , p 2 , …, p m ] to obtain the sequence P + dp 1 = [p 1 + dp 1 , p 2 , …, p m ], and the two rainfall sequences are respectively used as inputs of the basin hydrological model (the Xin'anjiang model in this embodiment), and the corresponding simulated runoff Qc (P) = [qc 1 , qc 2 , …, qc n ] and According to the following formula, the hysteresis sensitivity of the output runoff series to the average rainfall p 1 is:
相应地,对于面平均降雨序列P=[p1,p2,…,pm]中的p2施加扰动项dp2(如0.001)得到序列P+dp2=[p1,p2+dp2,…,pm],将两个降雨序列分别作为新安江模型的输入,得到对应的模拟径流Qc(P)=[qc1,qc2,…,qcn]和再根据下式输出径流序列对于面平均降雨p2的滞后灵敏度为: Correspondingly, the disturbance term dp 2 (such as 0.001) is applied to p 2 in the area average rainfall sequence P = [p 1 ,p 2 ,…, pm ] to obtain the sequence P+dp 2 = [p 1 ,p 2 +dp 2 ,…, pm ], and the two rainfall sequences are used as the input of the Xin'anjiang model to obtain the corresponding simulated runoff Qc(P) = [qc 1 ,qc 2 ,…,qc n ] and Then, according to the following formula, the hysteresis sensitivity of the runoff sequence to the average rainfall p2 is:
重复上述步骤,直至输出径流序列对于面平均降雨序列中的所有数值的滞后敏感度计算完成,最终得到滞后灵敏度矩阵S:Repeat the above steps until the hysteresis sensitivity calculation of the output runoff sequence to all values in the surface average rainfall sequence is completed, and finally the hysteresis sensitivity matrix S is obtained:
本发明实施例中,滞后灵敏度矩阵S的具体计算结果见表2。In the embodiment of the present invention, the specific calculation results of the lag sensitivity matrix S are shown in Table 2.
表2滞后灵敏度矩阵STable 2 Hysteresis sensitivity matrix S
步骤(5),基于新的径流误差序列ΔQ'、滞后灵敏度矩阵S,依据最小二乘原理计算面平均降雨误差ΔP=[Δp1,Δp2,…,Δpm],修正面平均降雨P;将修正后的面平均降雨输入流域水文模型重新进行径流模拟预报。Step (5), based on the new runoff error sequence ΔQ' and the lagged sensitivity matrix S, the surface average rainfall error ΔP = [Δp 1 , Δp 2 , ..., Δp m ] is calculated according to the least squares principle, and the surface average rainfall P is corrected; the corrected surface average rainfall is input into the basin hydrological model to re-simulate the runoff forecast.
依据最小二乘原理计算降水误差ΔP,表达式为:The precipitation error ΔP is calculated based on the least squares principle, and the expression is:
ΔP=(STS)-1STΔQ'ΔP=(S T S) -1 S T ΔQ'
利用求解的面平均降雨误差对原始面平均降雨量进行修正:P'=P+ΔP=[p1+Δp1,p2+Δp2,…,pm+Δpm],其中P'为修正后的面平均降雨;将修正后的面平均降雨作为新安江模型输入,重新运算模型,得到新的模拟预报径流过程Qu。所得降雨误差ΔP、修正后的面平均降雨量P'以及新的模拟预报径流Qu结果见表3。The original surface average rainfall is corrected using the solved surface average rainfall error: P' = P + ΔP = [p 1 + Δp 1 , p 2 + Δp 2 , …, p m + Δp m ], where P' is the corrected surface average rainfall; the corrected surface average rainfall is used as the input of the Xin'anjiang model, and the model is recalculated to obtain a new simulated forecast runoff process Qu. The obtained rainfall error ΔP, the corrected surface average rainfall P' and the new simulated forecast runoff Qu are shown in Table 3.
表3降雨误差ΔP、修正后的面平均降雨量P’以及新的模拟预报径流QuTable 3 Rainfall error ΔP, corrected surface average rainfall P’ and new simulated runoff forecast Qu
本实施例中采用洪水预报常用的指标确定性系数NSE以及洪峰相对误差来评价该方法的校正效果。实测径流序列为Qo=[qo1,qo2,…,qon],相应的模拟径流序列为Qc=[qc1,qc2,…,qcn],确定性系数NSE计算如下:In this embodiment, the deterministic coefficient NSE and the relative error of the flood peak, which are commonly used indicators in flood forecasting, are used to evaluate the correction effect of the method. The measured runoff sequence is Qo = [qo 1 ,qo 2 ,…,qo n ], and the corresponding simulated runoff sequence is Qc = [qc 1 ,qc 2 ,…,qc n ], and the deterministic coefficient NSE is calculated as follows:
式中是实测径流的均值。In the formula is the mean of the measured runoff.
实测径流序列的峰值为qop,模拟径流序列的峰值为qcp,洪峰相对误差计算如下:The peak value of the measured runoff sequence is qop , the peak value of the simulated runoff sequence is qcp , and the relative error of the peak value is calculated as follows:
本实施例的确定性系数、洪峰相对误差计算结果见表4。The calculation results of the coefficient of certainty and relative error of flood peak in this embodiment are shown in Table 4.
表4校正前后的确定性系数、洪峰相对误差评价结果Table 4 Evaluation results of the coefficient of certainty and relative error of flood peak before and after correction
根据表4的结果,可以看到采用本发明提出的校正方法对降水误差进行修正后,径流模拟预报精度得到了显著提升:确定性系数由0.95提升至0.98,洪峰相对误差由-14.49%减少至-4.71%。According to the results in Table 4, it can be seen that after the correction method proposed in the present invention is used to correct the precipitation error, the runoff simulation forecast accuracy is significantly improved: the certainty coefficient is increased from 0.95 to 0.98, and the relative error of the flood peak is reduced from -14.49% to -4.71%.
基于和方法实施例相同的技术构思,本发明另一实施例还提供一种考虑滞时影响的实时洪水预报降雨误差修正装置,包括:Based on the same technical concept as the method embodiment, another embodiment of the present invention further provides a real-time flood forecast rainfall error correction device considering the influence of time lag, comprising:
平均汇流时间计算模块,用于收集流域历史不同洪水场次的实测降雨资料和出口断面径流资料,计算面平均降雨量,统计不同场次面平均雨量雨峰时刻与相应径流过程的洪峰时刻之间的时间差,计算时间差的平均值得到流域平均汇流时间步长δ;The average confluence time calculation module is used to collect the measured rainfall data and outlet section runoff data of different flood events in the basin history, calculate the average rainfall, count the time difference between the peak time of the average rainfall in different events and the peak time of the corresponding runoff process, and calculate the average value of the time difference to obtain the average confluence time step δ of the basin;
径流误差序列计算模块,用于将基于流域实时监测降雨数据计算得到的面平均降雨量序列P=[p1,p2,…,pm]作为流域水文模型的输入,pm表示第m个面平均降雨量,利用流域水文模型得到模拟径流序列Qc=[qc1,qc2,…,qcn],qcn表示第n个模拟径流,n>m,再基于实时监测的实测径流序列Qo=[qo1,qo2,…,qom]计算径流误差序列ΔQ=Qo-Qc=[qo1-qc1,qo2-qc2,…,qom-qcm]=[Δq1,Δq2,…,Δqm];a runoff error sequence calculation module, for using the surface average rainfall sequence P = [p 1 ,p 2 ,…, pm ] calculated based on the real-time monitoring rainfall data of the watershed as the input of the watershed hydrological model, wherepm represents the mth surface average rainfall, and using the watershed hydrological model to obtain the simulated runoff sequence Qc = [qc 1 ,qc 2 ,…,qc n ], whereqc n represents the nth simulated runoff, n>m, and then calculating the runoff error sequence ΔQ = Qo-Qc = [qo 1 -qc 1 ,qo 2 -qc 2 ,…,qo m -qc m ] = [ Δq 1 ,Δq 2 ,…,Δq m ] based on the real-time monitored measured runoff sequence Qo = [qo 1 ,qo 2 ,…,qo m ];
径流误差序列预测更新模块,用于采用移动自回归平均模型ARMA对径流误差序列进行分析,得到预测径流误差序列[Δqm+1,Δqm+2,…,Δqm+δ],整合原始径流误差序列与预测序列得到新的径流误差序列ΔQ'=[Δq1+δ,Δq2+δ,…,Δqm+δ];The runoff error sequence prediction and update module is used to analyze the runoff error sequence using the moving autoregressive average model ARMA to obtain the predicted runoff error sequence [Δq m+1 ,Δq m+2 ,…,Δq m+δ ], and integrate the original runoff error sequence with the predicted sequence to obtain a new runoff error sequence ΔQ'=[Δq 1+δ ,Δq 2+δ ,…,Δq m+δ ];
滞后灵敏度计算模块,用于对面平均降雨量序列P中每个降雨量施加扰动,连同原面平均降雨量序列,作为流域水文模型的输入,计算输出相应的模拟径流,计算模拟径流序列对于面平均降雨量的滞后灵敏度,得到滞后灵敏度矩阵S;The hysteresis sensitivity calculation module is used to apply disturbance to each rainfall in the surface average rainfall sequence P, together with the original surface average rainfall sequence, as the input of the basin hydrological model, calculate and output the corresponding simulated runoff, calculate the hysteresis sensitivity of the simulated runoff sequence to the surface average rainfall, and obtain the hysteresis sensitivity matrix S;
降雨误差修正模块,用于基于新的径流误差序列ΔQ'、滞后灵敏度矩阵S,依据最小二乘原理计算面平均降雨误差序列ΔP=[Δp1,Δp2,…,Δpm],根据ΔP修正面平均降雨量序列P,将修正后的面平均降雨量序列输入流域水文模型重新进行径流模拟预报。The rainfall error correction module is used to calculate the surface average rainfall error sequence ΔP = [Δp 1 , Δp 2 , …, Δp m ] based on the new runoff error sequence ΔQ' and the lag sensitivity matrix S according to the least squares principle, correct the surface average rainfall sequence P according to ΔP, and input the corrected surface average rainfall sequence into the basin hydrological model to re-carry out runoff simulation forecast.
应理解,本发明实施例中的考虑滞时影响的实时洪水预报降雨误差修正装置可以实现上述方法实施例中的全部技术方案,其各个功能模块的功能可以根据上述方法实施例中的方法具体实现,其具体实现过程可参照上述实施例中的相关描述,此处不再赘述。It should be understood that the real-time flood forecast rainfall error correction device taking into account the influence of time lag in the embodiment of the present invention can implement all the technical solutions in the above-mentioned method embodiment, and the functions of its various functional modules can be specifically implemented according to the methods in the above-mentioned method embodiments. The specific implementation process can refer to the relevant description in the above-mentioned embodiments, which will not be repeated here.
本发明还提供一种计算机设备,包括:一个或多个处理器;存储器;以及一个或多个程序,其中所述一个或多个程序被存储在所述存储器中,并且被配置为由所述一个或多个处理器执行,所述程序被处理器执行时实现如上所述的考虑滞时影响的实时洪水预报降雨误差修正方法的步骤。The present invention also provides a computer device, comprising: one or more processors; a memory; and one or more programs, wherein the one or more programs are stored in the memory and are configured to be executed by the one or more processors, and when the programs are executed by the processors, the steps of the real-time flood forecast rainfall error correction method considering the effect of time lag as described above are implemented.
本发明还提供一种计算机可读存储介质,其上存储有计算机程序,所述计算机程序被处理器执行时实现如上所述的考虑滞时影响的实时洪水预报降雨误差修正方法的步骤。The present invention also provides a computer-readable storage medium having a computer program stored thereon, and when the computer program is executed by a processor, the steps of the real-time flood forecast rainfall error correction method considering the time lag effect as described above are implemented.
本领域内的技术人员应明白,本发明的实施例可提供为方法、装置(系统)、计算机设备或计算机程序产品。因此,本发明可采用完全硬件实施例、完全软件实施例、或结合软件和硬件方面的实施例的形式。而且,本发明可采用在一个或多个其中包含有计算机可用程序代码的计算机可用存储介质(包括但不限于磁盘存储器、CD-ROM、光学存储器等)上实施的计算机程序产品的形式。It will be appreciated by those skilled in the art that embodiments of the present invention may be provided as methods, devices (systems), computer equipment or computer program products. Therefore, the present invention may take the form of a complete hardware embodiment, a complete software embodiment, or an embodiment combining software and hardware. Moreover, the present invention may take the form of a computer program product implemented on one or more computer-usable storage media (including but not limited to disk storage, CD-ROM, optical storage, etc.) containing computer-usable program codes.
本发明是参照根据本发明实施例的方法的流程图来描述的。应理解可由计算机程序指令实现流程图中的每一流程以及流程图中的流程的结合。可提供这些计算机程序指令到通用计算机、专用计算机、嵌入式处理机或其他可编程数据处理设备的处理器以产生一个机器,使得通过计算机或其他可编程数据处理设备的处理器执行的指令产生用于实现在流程图一个流程或多个流程中指定的功能的装置。The present invention is described with reference to a flow chart of a method according to an embodiment of the present invention. It should be understood that each process in the flow chart and a combination of processes in the flow chart can be implemented by computer program instructions. These computer program instructions can be provided to a processor of a general-purpose computer, a special-purpose computer, an embedded processor or other programmable data processing device to produce a machine, so that the instructions executed by the processor of the computer or other programmable data processing device produce a device for implementing the functions specified in one or more processes in the flow chart.
这些计算机程序指令也可存储在能引导计算机或其他可编程数据处理设备以特定方式工作的计算机可读存储器中,使得存储在该计算机可读存储器中的指令产生包括指令装置的制造品,该指令装置实现在流程图一个流程或多个流程中指定的功能。These computer program instructions may also be stored in a computer-readable memory that can direct a computer or other programmable data processing device to work in a specific manner, so that the instructions stored in the computer-readable memory produce a product including an instruction device that implements the functions specified in one or more processes of the flowchart.
这些计算机程序指令也可装载到计算机或其他可编程数据处理设备上,使得在计算机或其他可编程设备上执行一系列操作步骤以产生计算机实现的处理,从而在计算机或其他可编程设备上执行的指令提供用于实现在流程图一个流程或多个流程中指定的功能的步骤。These computer program instructions may also be loaded onto a computer or other programmable data processing device so that a series of operational steps are executed on the computer or other programmable device to produce a computer-implemented process, whereby the instructions executed on the computer or other programmable device provide steps for implementing the functions specified in one or more processes in the flowchart.
Claims (9)
Priority Applications (1)
Application Number | Priority Date | Filing Date | Title |
---|---|---|---|
CN202311813855.1A CN117786614B (en) | 2023-12-27 | 2023-12-27 | Real-time flood forecast rainfall error correction method and device considering time lag influence |
Applications Claiming Priority (1)
Application Number | Priority Date | Filing Date | Title |
---|---|---|---|
CN202311813855.1A CN117786614B (en) | 2023-12-27 | 2023-12-27 | Real-time flood forecast rainfall error correction method and device considering time lag influence |
Publications (2)
Publication Number | Publication Date |
---|---|
CN117786614A CN117786614A (en) | 2024-03-29 |
CN117786614B true CN117786614B (en) | 2024-09-13 |
Family
ID=90382963
Family Applications (1)
Application Number | Title | Priority Date | Filing Date |
---|---|---|---|
CN202311813855.1A Active CN117786614B (en) | 2023-12-27 | 2023-12-27 | Real-time flood forecast rainfall error correction method and device considering time lag influence |
Country Status (1)
Country | Link |
---|---|
CN (1) | CN117786614B (en) |
Citations (1)
Publication number | Priority date | Publication date | Assignee | Title |
---|---|---|---|---|
CN113034853A (en) * | 2021-03-02 | 2021-06-25 | 成都正和德能风险管理咨询有限公司 | Flood forecast early warning analysis method and system |
Family Cites Families (5)
Publication number | Priority date | Publication date | Assignee | Title |
---|---|---|---|---|
US10962682B2 (en) * | 2015-12-15 | 2021-03-30 | Wuhan University | System and method for forecasting floods |
CN106875060B (en) * | 2017-02-20 | 2021-04-23 | 宁波市水利水电规划设计研究院有限公司 | Flood real-time correction method based on global automatic optimization algorithm |
CN109102110B (en) * | 2018-07-23 | 2022-03-22 | 云南电网有限责任公司临沧供电局 | Method and device for predicting short-term output of runoff small hydropower station |
US11507861B2 (en) * | 2019-05-06 | 2022-11-22 | Sweetsense, Inc. | Machine learning techniques for improved water conservation and management |
EP4094085A1 (en) * | 2020-01-21 | 2022-11-30 | Abb Schweiz Ag | Method and system for improved current sensor |
-
2023
- 2023-12-27 CN CN202311813855.1A patent/CN117786614B/en active Active
Patent Citations (1)
Publication number | Priority date | Publication date | Assignee | Title |
---|---|---|---|---|
CN113034853A (en) * | 2021-03-02 | 2021-06-25 | 成都正和德能风险管理咨询有限公司 | Flood forecast early warning analysis method and system |
Also Published As
Publication number | Publication date |
---|---|
CN117786614A (en) | 2024-03-29 |
Similar Documents
Publication | Publication Date | Title |
---|---|---|
CN101864750B (en) | Multi-model meta-synthesis flood forecasting system and forecasting method thereof | |
CN108445435B (en) | An on-line evaluation method for the error of an electric energy meter verification device | |
CN117057513B (en) | Intelligent park is with control management system based on internet | |
CN103207948B (en) | Based on the wind energy turbine set anemometer wind speed missing data interpolating method of wind speed correlativity | |
CN113792939B (en) | Electric energy meter reliability prediction method and device based on mixed Weibull distribution | |
CN106529145A (en) | Bridge monitoring data prediction method based on ARIMA-BP neural network | |
CN110186533B (en) | High-precision river mouth short-term tide level forecasting method | |
CN106097146A (en) | A kind of meter and the Wind turbines short term reliability Forecasting Methodology of running status | |
WO2020118586A1 (en) | Energy consumption prediction method and device | |
CN103984986B (en) | The self study arma modeling ultrashort-term wind power prediction method of real time correction | |
CN108693496A (en) | A kind of intelligent electric energy meter error predictor method based on parameter degeneration equation | |
CN111814964A (en) | Air pollution treatment method and storage medium based on air quality forecast | |
CN113626767B (en) | Fan electricity limiting identification method, system, equipment and storage medium | |
CN116823067B (en) | Method and device for determining water quality cleaning state of pipe network and electronic equipment | |
Arsenault et al. | An efficient method to correct under-dispersion in ensemble streamflow prediction of inflow volumes for reservoir optimization | |
CN105449667B (en) | A kind of generating and transmitting system Reliability Prediction Method | |
CN111753965A (en) | A method and system for automatic adjustment of river flow based on deep learning | |
CN118094312A (en) | A method, device, equipment and medium for identifying gross error data of dam deformation | |
CN116485035A (en) | An ultra-short-term probabilistic prediction method of wind power based on adaptive overall performance optimization | |
CN117786614B (en) | Real-time flood forecast rainfall error correction method and device considering time lag influence | |
CN110956330A (en) | A method and system for predicting transmission line losses based on multi-dimensional influences | |
CN116629010B (en) | A random process-based degradation model confirmation and its experimental design method | |
CN117521907A (en) | Photovoltaic power generation power interval prediction method considering photovoltaic output and meteorological elements | |
CN117200223A (en) | Day-ahead power load prediction method and device | |
CN115169496A (en) | BVAR model-based construction period bank slope deformation prediction method |
Legal Events
Date | Code | Title | Description |
---|---|---|---|
PB01 | Publication | ||
PB01 | Publication | ||
SE01 | Entry into force of request for substantive examination | ||
SE01 | Entry into force of request for substantive examination | ||
GR01 | Patent grant | ||
GR01 | Patent grant |