[go: up one dir, main page]

CN111324036B - A method for quantifying the diagnosability of time-varying systems under the influence of bounded disturbances - Google Patents

A method for quantifying the diagnosability of time-varying systems under the influence of bounded disturbances Download PDF

Info

Publication number
CN111324036B
CN111324036B CN202010062123.3A CN202010062123A CN111324036B CN 111324036 B CN111324036 B CN 111324036B CN 202010062123 A CN202010062123 A CN 202010062123A CN 111324036 B CN111324036 B CN 111324036B
Authority
CN
China
Prior art keywords
time
varying
fault
spacecraft system
vector
Prior art date
Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
Active
Application number
CN202010062123.3A
Other languages
Chinese (zh)
Other versions
CN111324036A (en
Inventor
王大轶
李文博
刘文静
刘成瑞
张香燕
李佳宁
韩洪波
Current Assignee (The listed assignees may be inaccurate. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the list.)
Beijing Institute of Spacecraft System Engineering
Original Assignee
Beijing Institute of Spacecraft System Engineering
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by Beijing Institute of Spacecraft System Engineering filed Critical Beijing Institute of Spacecraft System Engineering
Priority to CN202010062123.3A priority Critical patent/CN111324036B/en
Publication of CN111324036A publication Critical patent/CN111324036A/en
Application granted granted Critical
Publication of CN111324036B publication Critical patent/CN111324036B/en
Active legal-status Critical Current
Anticipated expiration legal-status Critical

Links

Classifications

    • GPHYSICS
    • G05CONTROLLING; REGULATING
    • G05BCONTROL OR REGULATING SYSTEMS IN GENERAL; FUNCTIONAL ELEMENTS OF SUCH SYSTEMS; MONITORING OR TESTING ARRANGEMENTS FOR SUCH SYSTEMS OR ELEMENTS
    • G05B13/00Adaptive control systems, i.e. systems automatically adjusting themselves to have a performance which is optimum according to some preassigned criterion
    • G05B13/02Adaptive control systems, i.e. systems automatically adjusting themselves to have a performance which is optimum according to some preassigned criterion electric
    • G05B13/04Adaptive control systems, i.e. systems automatically adjusting themselves to have a performance which is optimum according to some preassigned criterion electric involving the use of models or simulators
    • G05B13/042Adaptive control systems, i.e. systems automatically adjusting themselves to have a performance which is optimum according to some preassigned criterion electric involving the use of models or simulators in which a parameter or coefficient is automatically adjusted to optimise the performance

Landscapes

  • Engineering & Computer Science (AREA)
  • Health & Medical Sciences (AREA)
  • Artificial Intelligence (AREA)
  • Computer Vision & Pattern Recognition (AREA)
  • Evolutionary Computation (AREA)
  • Medical Informatics (AREA)
  • Software Systems (AREA)
  • Physics & Mathematics (AREA)
  • General Physics & Mathematics (AREA)
  • Automation & Control Theory (AREA)
  • Control Of Position, Course, Altitude, Or Attitude Of Moving Bodies (AREA)
  • Test And Diagnosis Of Digital Computers (AREA)

Abstract

一种有界干扰影响下时变系统可诊断性量化方法,属于空间技术领域。本发明将状态空间描述的航天器系统转换为时间堆栈动态模型,使系统的可诊断性量化问题转化为全对称多胞形的相似度计算问题,给出了系统故障可检测性与可隔离性的数学定义,并通过豪斯多夫距离对故障的可诊断性(包含可检测性与可隔离性)进行量化。本发明方法与现有方法相比,不仅将航天器系统模型由现有的时不变模型推广到时变模型,而且仅需知道干扰的边界而无需明确其具体形式,更加符合实际工程需求,便于设计人员操作执行。A method for quantifying the diagnosability of a time-varying system under the influence of bounded interference belongs to the field of space technology. The invention converts the spacecraft system described in the state space into a time stack dynamic model, so that the diagnosability quantification problem of the system is transformed into the similarity calculation problem of a fully symmetric polytope, and the detectability and isolation of system faults are given. The mathematical definition of , and the diagnosability of faults (including detectability and isolation) are quantified by Hausdorff distance. Compared with the existing method, the method of the invention not only extends the spacecraft system model from the existing time-invariant model to the time-varying model, but also only needs to know the boundary of the interference without clarifying its specific form, which is more in line with the actual engineering needs. It is convenient for designers to operate and execute.

Description

一种有界干扰影响下时变系统可诊断性量化方法A method for quantifying the diagnosability of time-varying systems under the influence of bounded disturbances

技术领域technical field

本发明涉及一种有界干扰影响下时变系统可诊断性量化方法,属于空间技术领域。The invention relates to a method for quantifying the diagnosability of a time-varying system under the influence of bounded interference, and belongs to the field of space technology.

背景技术Background technique

随着投资规模以及系统复杂程度的不断提升,对于航天器系统自主故障诊断的精度和速度提出了更加严苛的要求。一方面,直接提出具有更高性能的诊断算法,来满足实际工程中对故障诊断的具体要求;另一方面,通过量化系统的故障可诊断性,从根本上提高航天器系统的自主诊断能力。With the continuous improvement of investment scale and system complexity, more stringent requirements are put forward for the accuracy and speed of autonomous fault diagnosis of spacecraft systems. On the one hand, a diagnostic algorithm with higher performance is directly proposed to meet the specific requirements of fault diagnosis in practical engineering; on the other hand, by quantifying the fault diagnosability of the system, the autonomous diagnostic capability of the spacecraft system is fundamentally improved.

故障可诊断性是系统本身所具备的一个固有属性,是衡量故障检测和隔离难易程度的一种重要指标。可诊断性主要包括可检测性与可隔离性两个部分。通常,可诊断性评价又可以分成:定性评价与定量评价。其中,定性评价是从故障能否被检测或是能否被隔离的角度来考虑问题。与定性评价不同,定量评价结果反映了系统故障能够被检测或是被隔离的难易程度,而后者能够为航天器系统的硬件配置与诊断算法优化,提供更多的必要可观测信息。Fault diagnosability is an inherent property of the system itself, and it is an important indicator to measure the difficulty of fault detection and isolation. Diagnosis mainly includes two parts: detectability and isolation. Generally, diagnostic evaluation can be divided into: qualitative evaluation and quantitative evaluation. Among them, the qualitative evaluation considers the problem from the perspective of whether the fault can be detected or isolated. Different from qualitative evaluation, quantitative evaluation results reflect the ease with which system faults can be detected or isolated, and the latter can provide more necessary observable information for the optimization of hardware configuration and diagnostic algorithms of spacecraft systems.

现阶段对系统可诊断性量化的研究已经取得了一定的成果。然而,已有基于K-L散度、巴氏距离以及方向相似度的可诊断性量化研究成果均是针对线性时不变系统模型开展具体研究工作,且没有考虑或仅考虑已知分布形式的噪声影响。实质上,在许多工程实践中,例如空间技术领域,通常仅能知道系统干扰(包括噪声)的上下界,而无法掌握其具体的统计特性;同时,也可以将系统的模型不确定性描述成具体形式未知但有界的干扰。综上所述,研究有界干扰影响下时变系统可诊断性的量化方法,具有更加重要的理论研究意义和实际应用价值。At this stage, the research on the quantification of system diagnosability has achieved certain results. However, the existing quantitative research results of diagnosability based on K-L divergence, Babbitt distance and directional similarity are all specific research work on linear time-invariant system models, and do not consider or only consider the influence of noise in known distribution forms. . In essence, in many engineering practices, such as the field of space technology, usually only the upper and lower bounds of system interference (including noise) can be known, but its specific statistical characteristics cannot be grasped; at the same time, the model uncertainty of the system can also be described as The exact form is unknown but bounded disturbance. To sum up, it is of more important theoretical research significance and practical application value to study the quantification method of the diagnosability of time-varying systems under the influence of bounded disturbance.

发明内容SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

本发明解决的技术问题是:克服现有技术的不足,提出了一种有界干扰影响下时变系统可诊断性量化方法,将状态空间描述的航天器系统转换为时间堆栈动态模型,使故障系统的可诊断性量化问题转化为全对称多胞形的相似度计算问题,给出了系统故障可检测性与可隔离性的数学定义,并通过豪斯多夫距离对故障的可诊断性(包含可检测性与可隔离性)进行量化。本发明方法与现有方法相比,不仅将航天器系统模型由现有的时不变模型推广到时变模型,而且仅需知道干扰的边界而无需明确其具体形式,更加符合实际工程需求,易于设计人员操作执行。The technical problem solved by the present invention is: overcoming the deficiencies of the prior art, a method for quantifying the diagnosability of a time-varying system under the influence of bounded interference is proposed, which converts the spacecraft system described in the state space into a time-stack dynamic model, so that the failure The quantification problem of system diagnosability is transformed into the similarity calculation problem of fully symmetric polytope, and the mathematical definition of system fault detectability and isolation is given, and the diagnosability of faults is determined by Hausdorff distance ( Including detectability and isolation) for quantification. Compared with the existing method, the method of the invention not only extends the spacecraft system model from the existing time-invariant model to the time-varying model, but also only needs to know the boundary of the interference without clarifying its specific form, which is more in line with the actual engineering needs. Easy for designers to operate and execute.

本发明的技术解决方案是:一种有界干扰影响下时变系统可诊断性量化方法,包括如下步骤:The technical solution of the present invention is: a method for quantifying the diagnosability of a time-varying system under the influence of bounded interference, comprising the following steps:

S1,基于模型标准化处理方法和等价空间变换处理方法建立航天器系统的时变等价空间模型;S1, establish a time-varying equivalent space model of the spacecraft system based on the model standardization processing method and the equivalent space transformation processing method;

S2,根据所述航天器系统的时变等价空间模型,建立故障集合;S2, establishing a fault set according to the time-varying equivalent space model of the spacecraft system;

S3,利用所述航天器系统的时变等价空间模型和故障集合,根据第一预设条件判别故障是否可检测;若可检测,则进入S4;否则,结束;S3, using the time-varying equivalent space model and the fault set of the spacecraft system, according to the first preset condition to determine whether the fault can be detected; if it can be detected, then enter S4; otherwise, end;

S4,利用所述航天器系统的时变等价空间模型,通过豪斯多夫距离来计算可检测性度量值;S4, using the time-varying equivalent space model of the spacecraft system to calculate the detectability metric value through the Hausdorff distance;

S5,利用所述航天器系统的时变等价空间模型和故障集合,根据第二预设条件判别故障是否可隔离;若可隔离,则进入S6;否则,结束;S5, using the time-varying equivalent space model and the fault set of the spacecraft system, according to the second preset condition to determine whether the fault can be isolated; if it can be isolated, then enter S6; otherwise, end;

S6,利用所述航天器系统的时变等价空间模型,通过豪斯多夫距离来计算可隔离性度量值,用于优化航天器系统配置和故障诊断算法,实现航天器系统健康状态的在轨监测。S6, the time-varying equivalent space model of the spacecraft system is used to calculate the isolation metric value through the Hausdorff distance, which is used to optimize the spacecraft system configuration and fault diagnosis algorithm, so as to realize the stability of the spacecraft system health status. track monitoring.

进一步地,所述航天器系统的时变等价空间模型为vs(k)ys-vs(k)Hus(k)us=vs(k)F(k)fs+vs(k)E(k)ds;其中,vs(k)为航天器系统的时变等价向量,fs为航天器系统故障的时间堆栈向量,ys、us和ds分别为航天器系统输出、控制输入和有界干扰的时间堆栈向量,Hus(k)、F(k)和E(k)为相应维数的时变系数矩阵。Further, the time-varying equivalent space model of the spacecraft system is v s (k)y s -v s (k)H us (k)u s =v s (k)F(k)f s +v s (k)E(k)d s ; where v s (k) is the time-varying equivalent vector of the spacecraft system, f s is the time stack vector of the spacecraft system failure, y s , u s and d s are respectively are the time stack vectors of spacecraft system outputs, control inputs and bounded disturbances, and Hus (k), F(k) and E(k) are time-varying coefficient matrices of corresponding dimensions.

进一步地,所述故障集合为

Figure BDA0002374818490000031
其中,fi表示第i个故障向量;Fi(k)表示矩阵F(k)对应向量fi所在的行;bm表示由m个单位区间[-1,1]组成的单位盒子,即表示m维的区间向量。Further, the fault set is
Figure BDA0002374818490000031
Among them, f i represents the ith fault vector; F i (k) represents the row of the matrix F(k) corresponding to the vector f i ; b m represents the unit box composed of m unit intervals [-1, 1], that is Represents an m-dimensional interval vector.

进一步地,所述第一预设条件为:当且仅当Ps(k)Fi(k)fi≠0,故障可检测;其中,Ps(k)为由时变等价向量组成的航天器系统时变等价空间集合。Further, the first preset condition is: if and only if P s (k)F i (k)f i ≠0, the fault can be detected; wherein, P s (k) is composed of time-varying equivalent vectors The time-varying space-equivalent set of spacecraft systems.

进一步地,所述可检测性度量值为

Figure BDA0002374818490000032
其中,
Figure BDA0002374818490000033
为有向的豪斯多夫距离,具体而言,
Figure BDA0002374818490000034
表示故障fi所对应时变全对称多胞形
Figure BDA0002374818490000035
与无故障所对应时变全对称多胞形cNF(k)之间的有向豪斯多夫距离,
Figure BDA0002374818490000036
表示无故障所对应时变全对称多胞形cNF(k)与表示故障fi所对应时变全对称多胞形
Figure BDA0002374818490000037
之间的有向豪斯多夫距离;wi→NF和wNF→i为对应的有向豪斯多夫距离所占比例,且wi→NF+wNF→i=1、wi→NF≥0、wNF→i≥0;
Figure BDA0002374818490000038
Figure BDA0002374818490000039
给出,cNF(k)由cNF(k)={vs(k)E(k)ds:ds∈bm}给出。Further, the detectability metric is
Figure BDA0002374818490000032
in,
Figure BDA0002374818490000033
is the directed Hausdorff distance, specifically,
Figure BDA0002374818490000034
represents the time-varying fully symmetric polytope corresponding to the fault f i
Figure BDA0002374818490000035
is the directed Hausdorff distance to the time-varying fully symmetric polytope c NF (k) corresponding to the fault-free,
Figure BDA0002374818490000036
represents the time-varying fully symmetric polytope c NF (k) corresponding to no fault and the time-varying fully symmetric polytope corresponding to the fault f i
Figure BDA0002374818490000037
The directed Hausdorff distance between the NF ≥ 0, w NF→i ≥ 0;
Figure BDA0002374818490000038
Depend on
Figure BDA0002374818490000039
Given, c NF (k) is given by c NF (k) = {v s (k)E(k)d s :d s ∈ b m }.

进一步地,所述第二预设条件为:当且仅当

Figure BDA00023748184900000310
时,故障fi与故障fj之间可隔离。Further, the second preset condition is: if and only if
Figure BDA00023748184900000310
When , the fault f i and the fault f j can be isolated.

进一步地,所述可隔离性度量值为

Figure BDA00023748184900000311
其中,
Figure BDA00023748184900000312
表示故障fi所对应时变全对称多胞形
Figure BDA00023748184900000313
与故障fj所对应时变全对称多胞形
Figure BDA00023748184900000314
之间的有向豪斯多夫距离;
Figure BDA00023748184900000315
表示故障fj所对应时变全对称多胞形
Figure BDA00023748184900000316
与故障fi所对应时变全对称多胞形
Figure BDA00023748184900000317
之间的有向豪斯多夫距离;wi→j和wj→i表示对应的有向豪斯多夫距离所占比例,且wi→j+wj→i=1、wi→j≥0、wj→i≥0。Further, the isolation metric is
Figure BDA00023748184900000311
in,
Figure BDA00023748184900000312
represents the time-varying fully symmetric polytope corresponding to the fault f i
Figure BDA00023748184900000313
The time-varying fully symmetric polytope corresponding to the fault f j
Figure BDA00023748184900000314
the directed Hausdorff distance between;
Figure BDA00023748184900000315
represents the time-varying fully symmetric polytope corresponding to the fault f j
Figure BDA00023748184900000316
The time-varying fully symmetric polytope corresponding to the fault f i
Figure BDA00023748184900000317
The directed Hausdorff distances between the j ≥ 0, w j→i ≥ 0.

本发明与现有技术相比的优点在于:The advantages of the present invention compared with the prior art are:

①本发明专利不再要求系统干扰的具体统计特性已知,仅需要知道系统干扰的上下界,并利用集元分析方法可以给出系统可诊断性的量化结果,而且基于该量化结果可以指导系统配置与诊断算法的优化设计,这更加符合实际工程需求,易于实现;①The patent of the present invention no longer requires the specific statistical characteristics of the system interference to be known, only the upper and lower bounds of the system interference need to be known, and the quantitative results of the system diagnosability can be given by using the set element analysis method, and the system can be guided based on the quantitative results. Optimized design of configuration and diagnosis algorithms, which are more in line with actual engineering needs and are easy to implement;

②本发明专利能够实现非统计意义下基于时变等价空间模型的可诊断性量化,具有更广的使用范围、足够的灵活性和更强的适用性,将提升系统自主诊断能力的工作重点前移到设计阶段,可以为火星、小行星等后续深空探测任务背景型号的方案设计与相关单机产品的研制提供技术储备;②The patent of the present invention can realize the quantification of the diagnosability based on the time-varying equivalent space model in the non-statistical sense, has a wider range of use, sufficient flexibility and stronger applicability, and will improve the work focus of the system's self-diagnosis ability Moving forward to the design stage can provide technical reserves for the design of background models for subsequent deep space exploration missions such as Mars and asteroids and the development of related stand-alone products;

③本发明专利可以推广应用到大规模复杂工业控制、飞行控制、装备制造、电力等大型工业设备,对上述设备的健康状态实现在线监测;本发明专利提出的可诊断性量化指标,可以作为优化目标,指导上述大型设备中硬件配置与软件算法的评价与设计,这在国内具有广泛的需求。③The patent of the present invention can be extended and applied to large-scale industrial equipment such as large-scale complex industrial control, flight control, equipment manufacturing, electric power, etc., to realize online monitoring of the health status of the above-mentioned equipment; The goal is to guide the evaluation and design of the hardware configuration and software algorithm in the above-mentioned large-scale equipment, which has a wide range of needs in China.

具体实施方式Detailed ways

下面结合具体实施方式对本发明进行进一步解释和说明。The present invention will be further explained and illustrated below in conjunction with specific embodiments.

一种有界干扰影响下时变系统可诊断性量化方法,包括如下步骤:A method for quantifying the diagnosability of a time-varying system under the influence of bounded interference, comprising the following steps:

S1,基于模型标准化处理方法和等价空间变换处理方法建立航天器系统的时变等价空间模型;S1, establish a time-varying equivalent space model of the spacecraft system based on the model standardization processing method and the equivalent space transformation processing method;

S2,根据所述航天器系统的时变等价空间模型,建立故障集合;S2, establishing a fault set according to the time-varying equivalent space model of the spacecraft system;

S3,利用所述航天器系统的时变等价空间模型和故障集合,根据第一预设条件判别故障是否可检测;若可检测,则进入S4;否则,结束;S3, using the time-varying equivalent space model and the fault set of the spacecraft system, according to the first preset condition to determine whether the fault can be detected; if it can be detected, then enter S4; otherwise, end;

S4,利用所述航天器系统的时变等价空间模型,通过豪斯多夫距离来计算可检测性度量值;S4, using the time-varying equivalent space model of the spacecraft system to calculate the detectability metric value through the Hausdorff distance;

S5,利用所述航天器系统的时变等价空间模型和故障集合,根据第二预设条件判别故障是否可隔离;若可隔离,则进入S6;否则,结束;S5, using the time-varying equivalent space model and the fault set of the spacecraft system, according to the second preset condition to determine whether the fault can be isolated; if it can be isolated, then enter S6; otherwise, end;

S6,利用所述航天器系统的时变等价空间模型,通过豪斯多夫距离来计算可隔离性度量值,用于优化航天器系统配置和故障诊断算法,实现航天器系统健康状态的在轨监测。S6, the time-varying equivalent space model of the spacecraft system is used to calculate the isolation metric value through the Hausdorff distance, which is used to optimize the spacecraft system configuration and fault diagnosis algorithm, so as to realize the stability of the spacecraft system health status. track monitoring.

具体如下:details as follows:

一、基于模型标准化处理方法和等价空间变换处理方法建立航天器系统的时变等价空间模型;1. Establish a time-varying equivalent space model of the spacecraft system based on the model standardization processing method and the equivalent space transformation processing method;

航天器系统一般可以描述成如下所示的时变离散状态空间模型:A spacecraft system can generally be described as a time-varying discrete state-space model as follows:

Figure BDA0002374818490000051
Figure BDA0002374818490000051

其中:k表示第k个时刻;x(k)、u(k)和y(k)分别为系统的状态向量、输入向量和输出向量;f(k)为故障向量;d(k)为系统的有界干扰,且

Figure BDA0002374818490000052
其中di(k)表示向量d(k)的第i个元素,等价于||d(k)||≤dmax;矩阵A(k)、Bu(k)、C(k)、Du(k)、Bd(k)、Dd(k)、Bf(k)和Df(k)分别为相应的系数矩阵。Where: k represents the kth moment; x(k), u(k) and y(k) are the state vector, input vector and output vector of the system, respectively; f(k) is the fault vector; d(k) is the system bounded interference of , and
Figure BDA0002374818490000052
where d i (k) represents the ith element of the vector d(k), which is equivalent to ||d(k)|| ≤d max ; matrices A(k), B u (k), C(k) , D u (k), B d (k), D d (k), B f (k) and D f (k) are the corresponding coefficient matrices, respectively.

选取窗口长度为s,按时间序列对系统模型(1)进行迭代,得到系统模型(1)从k-s+1(k≥s-1)时刻到k时刻的解析冗余方程:The window length is selected as s, and the system model (1) is iterated according to the time series, and the analytical redundancy equation of the system model (1) from time k-s+1 (k≥s-1) to time k is obtained:

ys-Hus(k)us=H(k)x(k-s+1)+F(k)fs+E(k)ds (2)y s -H us (k)u s =H(k)x(k-s+1)+F(k)f s +E(k)d s (2)

其中,ys、us和ds分别为航天器系统输出,控制输入和有界干扰的时间堆栈向量;Hus(k)、H(k)、F(k)和E(k)为相应维数的系数矩阵,具体形式为:Among them, y s , u s and d s are the spacecraft system output, control input and time stack vector of bounded disturbance, respectively; Hus (k), H(k), F(k) and E(k) are the corresponding The coefficient matrix of the dimension, the specific form is:

Figure BDA0002374818490000053
Figure BDA0002374818490000053

Figure BDA0002374818490000054
Figure BDA0002374818490000054

其中:向量us,ds和fs与ys具有相同的结构,矩阵F(k)和E(k)分别通过将矩阵Hus(k)中的{Bu,Du}替换为{Bf,Df}和{Bd,Dd}得到。where: the vectors u s , d s and f s have the same structure as y s , and the matrices F(k) and E(k) are obtained by replacing {B u , D u } in the matrix Hus (k) with { B f , D f } and {B d , D d } are obtained.

对于解析冗余方程(2),ys-Hus(k)us表示航天器系统的动态行为;H(k)x(k-s+1)、Ffs和Eds分别表示状态向量、故障向量和有界干扰向量。解析冗余方程(2)可以视为航天器系统时变模型(1)的动态行为在时间序列(k-s+1,k-s+2,…,k)内的静态表现。For the analytical redundancy equation (2), y s -H us (k) u s represents the dynamic behavior of the spacecraft system; H(k)x(k-s+1), Ff s and Ed s represent the state vector, Fault vectors and bounded disturbance vectors. The analytical redundancy equation (2) can be regarded as the static representation of the dynamic behavior of the spacecraft system time-varying model (1) in the time series (k-s+1, k-s+2,...,k).

根据等价空间变换原理,在公式(2)的等号两边同时左乘矩阵H的等价向量vs,即vsH=0,则可以得到According to the principle of equivalent space transformation, by simultaneously left-multiplying the equivalent vector v s of the matrix H on both sides of the equal sign of formula (2), that is, v s H=0, we can get

vs(k)[ys-Hus(k)us]=vs(k)F(k)fs+vs(k)E(k)ds (3)v s (k)[y s -H us (k)u s ]=v s (k)F(k)f s +v s (k)E(k)d s (3)

称航天器系统时变等价向量vs(k)的集合Ps(k)={vs(k)|vs(k)Hus(k)=0}为时变等价空间集合。The set P s (k)={v s (k)|v s (k)H us (k)=0} of the time-varying equivalent vector v s (k) of the spacecraft system is called a time-varying equivalent space set.

二、根据步骤一所述航天器系统的时变等价空间模型,建立故障集合:2. Establish a fault set according to the time-varying equivalent space model of the spacecraft system described in step 1:

取时间序列f=(f[t-n+1],f[t-n+2],…,f[t])T,令fi表示在时间序列下故障的具体形式;Θi表示故障fi在所有时序下故障具体形式,即fi∈ΘiTake the time series f=(f[t-n+1], f[t-n+2],...,f[t]) T , let f i represent the specific form of the fault under the time series; Θ i represents the fault fi has a specific form of failure under all time series , that is, fi ∈Θ i .

由公式(3)可知,发生故障fi时,有vs(k)[ys-Hus(k)us]=M(k)ds+Ni(k),其中Ni(k)=vs(k)Fi(k)fi,M(k)=vs(k)E(k)。因此,每一个故障都可以由多个集合表示,具体形式为:It can be seen from formula (3) that when a fault f i occurs, there is v s (k)[y s -H us (k)us ]=M(k) d s + N i (k), where N i (k )=vs( k )Fi( k )fi, M( k )=vs( k )E(k). Therefore, each failure can be represented by multiple sets in the form:

Figure BDA0002374818490000061
Figure BDA0002374818490000061

其中,

Figure BDA0002374818490000062
表示故障fi的所有集合。不失一般性,为了简化分析,假设有界干扰d(k)为单位盒子,即dmax=1,此时ds为m阶单位盒子。实质上,对于任意盒子ds,vs(k)E(k)ds+vs(k)Fi(k)fi总能化成M(k)bm+N(k)的形式,其中bm为m阶单位盒子,M(k)与N(k)为维数恰当的已知时变系数矩阵。in,
Figure BDA0002374818490000062
represents all sets of faults fi . Without loss of generality, in order to simplify the analysis, it is assumed that the bounded interference d(k) is a unit box, that is, d max =1, and d s is an m-order unit box at this time. In essence, for any box d s , v s (k)E(k)d s +v s (k)Fi ( k )fi can always be transformed into the form of M( k )b m +N(k), where b m is a unit box of order m, and M(k) and N(k) are known time-varying coefficient matrices with appropriate dimensions.

综上所述,每一个故障都可以表示为多个时变对称多胞形的集合。未发生故障fi时,fi≡0;此时,

Figure BDA0002374818490000063
为描述包括无故障以及故障fi在内情况的所有全对称多胞形集合。显而易见,无故障时系统全对称多胞形的集合
Figure BDA0002374818490000064
为一个包含原点的全对称多胞形
Figure BDA0002374818490000071
值得注意的是,由于不同的故障有可能会对系统产生相同的影响,故不同的集合
Figure BDA0002374818490000072
Figure BDA0002374818490000073
有可能存在交集。为了区分不同时序下的不同故障,将时间序列下故障的全对称多胞形表示为:To sum up, each fault can be represented as a collection of multiple time-varying symmetric polytopes. When no fault f i occurs, f i ≡ 0; at this time,
Figure BDA0002374818490000063
to describe the set of all fully symmetric polytopes including no faults and faults fi. Obviously, the set of fully symmetric polytopes of the system when there is no fault
Figure BDA0002374818490000064
is a fully symmetric polytope containing the origin
Figure BDA0002374818490000071
It is worth noting that since different failures may have the same impact on the system, different sets of
Figure BDA0002374818490000072
and
Figure BDA0002374818490000073
There may be an intersection. In order to distinguish different faults under different time series, the fully symmetric polytope of faults under time series is expressed as:

Figure BDA0002374818490000074
Figure BDA0002374818490000074

三、利用所述航天器系统的时变等价空间模型和故障集合,根据第一预设条件判别故障是否可检测;若可检测,则进入步骤4;否则,结束:3. Use the time-varying equivalent space model and the fault set of the spacecraft system to determine whether the fault can be detected according to the first preset condition; if it can be detected, go to step 4; otherwise, end:

针对时变等价空间模型(3),其可检测性的判别条件为:For the time-varying equivalent space model (3), the discriminant conditions for its detectability are:

对于特定时间序列下的故障形式fi∈Θi,当且仅当Ps(k)Fi(k)fi≠0时,故障fi可检测。For a failure form f i ∈Θ i under a specific time series, the failure f i is detectable if and only if P s (k)F i (k)f i ≠0.

四、利用所述航天器系统的时变等价空间模型,通过豪斯多夫距离来计算可检测性度量值;4. Using the time-varying equivalent space model of the spacecraft system to calculate the detectability metric value through the Hausdorff distance;

故障可检测性量化的核心在于给出可测信息与系统故障以及有界干扰之间的内在关联关系。The core of fault detectability quantification is to give the intrinsic relationship between measurable information and system faults and bounded disturbances.

由公式(3)可知,系统的动态行为vs(k)[ys-Hus(k)us]同时受系统状态故障向量F(k)fs和有界干扰向量E(k)ds的耦合影响。换言之,系统可测量ys和us在发生故障前后的差距越大,则实现故障检测的难度越小。It can be seen from formula (3) that the dynamic behavior of the system v s (k)[y s -H us (k)u s ] is simultaneously affected by the system state fault vector F(k)f s and the bounded disturbance vector E(k)d The coupling effect of s . In other words, the greater the difference between the system's measurable y s and us s before and after a fault occurs, the less difficult it is to achieve fault detection.

对于可检测的故障fi,由公式(5)可以得到相应的全对称多胞形

Figure BDA0002374818490000075
则故障fi的可检测性度量值的计算公式如下:For the detectable fault f i , the corresponding fully symmetric polytope can be obtained from equation (5)
Figure BDA0002374818490000075
Then the calculation formula of the detectability metric value of fault fi is as follows:

Figure BDA0002374818490000076
Figure BDA0002374818490000076

其中,

Figure BDA0002374818490000077
为有向的豪斯多夫距离,具体而言,
Figure BDA0002374818490000078
表示故障fi所对应时变全对称多胞形
Figure BDA0002374818490000079
与无故障所对应时变全对称多胞形cNF(k)之间的有向豪斯多夫距离,
Figure BDA00023748184900000710
表示无故障所对应时变全对称多胞形cNF(k)与表示故障fi所对应时变全对称多胞形
Figure BDA00023748184900000711
之间的有向豪斯多夫距离;wi→NF和wNF→i为对应的有向豪斯多夫距离所占比例,且wi→NF+wNF→i=1、wi→NF≥0、wNF→i≥0;
Figure BDA0002374818490000081
Figure BDA0002374818490000082
给出,cNF(k)由cNF(k)={vs(k)E(k)ds:ds∈bm}给出。in,
Figure BDA0002374818490000077
is the directed Hausdorff distance, specifically,
Figure BDA0002374818490000078
represents the time-varying fully symmetric polytope corresponding to the fault f i
Figure BDA0002374818490000079
is the directed Hausdorff distance to the time-varying fully symmetric polytope c NF (k) corresponding to the fault-free,
Figure BDA00023748184900000710
represents the time-varying fully symmetric polytope c NF (k) corresponding to no fault and the time-varying fully symmetric polytope corresponding to the fault f i
Figure BDA00023748184900000711
The directed Hausdorff distance between the NF ≥ 0, w NF→i ≥ 0;
Figure BDA0002374818490000081
Depend on
Figure BDA0002374818490000082
Given, c NF (k) is given by c NF (k) = {v s (k)E(k)d s :d s ∈ b m }.

五、利用所述航天器系统的时变等价空间模型和故障集合,根据第二预设条件判别故障是否可隔离;若可隔离,则进入步骤六;否则,结束;5. Use the time-varying equivalent space model and the fault set of the spacecraft system to determine whether the fault can be isolated according to the second preset condition; if it can be isolated, go to step six; otherwise, end;

对于时变等价空间模型(3),其可隔离性的判别条件为:For the time-varying equivalent space model (3), the discriminant condition for its isolation is:

在特定时间序列下的故障形式fi∈Θi,当且仅当

Figure BDA0002374818490000083
则故障fi与故障fj之间可隔离;其中,Ps(k)={vs(k)|vs(k)Hus(k)=0}表示s阶的时变等价空间。The failure form f i ∈Θ i under a specific time series if and only if
Figure BDA0002374818490000083
Then the fault f i and the fault f j can be isolated; among them, P s (k)={v s (k)|v s (k) Hus (k)=0} represents the time-varying equivalent space of order s .

六、利用所述航天器系统的时变等价空间模型,通过豪斯多夫距离来计算可隔离性度量值:6. Using the time-varying equivalent space model of the spacecraft system, calculate the isolation metric value by the Hausdorff distance:

同理,针对可检测的两个故障fi和fj,由公式(5)可以得到相应的全对称多胞形

Figure BDA0002374818490000084
Figure BDA0002374818490000085
得到故障fi和fj之间可隔离性度量值的计算公式为:Similarly, for the two detectable faults f i and f j , the corresponding fully symmetric polytope can be obtained from formula (5).
Figure BDA0002374818490000084
and
Figure BDA0002374818490000085
The calculation formula to obtain the measure of isolation between faults f i and f j is:

Figure BDA0002374818490000086
Figure BDA0002374818490000086

其中,

Figure BDA0002374818490000087
表示故障fi所对应时变全对称多胞形
Figure BDA0002374818490000088
与故障fj所对应时变全对称多胞形
Figure BDA0002374818490000089
之间的有向豪斯多夫距离;
Figure BDA00023748184900000810
表示故障fj所对应时变全对称多胞形
Figure BDA00023748184900000811
与故障fi所对应时变全对称多胞形
Figure BDA00023748184900000812
之间的有向豪斯多夫距离;wi→j和wj→i分别表示对应的有向豪斯多夫距离所占比例,且wi→j+wj→i=1、wi→j≥0、wj→i≥0。in,
Figure BDA0002374818490000087
represents the time-varying fully symmetric polytope corresponding to the fault f i
Figure BDA0002374818490000088
The time-varying fully symmetric polytope corresponding to the fault f j
Figure BDA0002374818490000089
the directed Hausdorff distance between;
Figure BDA00023748184900000810
represents the time-varying fully symmetric polytope corresponding to the fault f j
Figure BDA00023748184900000811
The time-varying fully symmetric polytope corresponding to the fault f i
Figure BDA00023748184900000812
The directed Hausdorff distances between the →j ≥0, w j→i ≥0.

利用本发明专利得到的有界干扰影响下时变系统可检测性与可隔离性量化结果,可以用于优化航天器系统配置和故障诊断算法,实现航天器系统健康状态的在轨监测。The quantification results of the detectability and isolation of the time-varying system under the influence of bounded interference obtained by the patent of the present invention can be used to optimize the configuration of the spacecraft system and the fault diagnosis algorithm, and realize the on-orbit monitoring of the health state of the spacecraft system.

七、下面以一个具体实施例来说明本发明的工作原理和具体步骤:Seventh, the working principle and concrete steps of the present invention are described below with a specific embodiment:

针对如下考虑界干扰影响的时变多输入多输出系统状态空间模型:For the following time-varying MIMO system state space model considering the influence of bounded disturbances:

Figure BDA0002374818490000091
Figure BDA0002374818490000091

其中:in:

Figure BDA0002374818490000092
Figure BDA0002374818490000093
||d1(k)||≤0.1,||d2(k)||≤0.2,||d3(k)||≤0.1。
Figure BDA0002374818490000092
Figure BDA0002374818490000093
||d 1 (k)|| ≤0.1, ||d 2 (k)|| ≤0.2, ||d 3 (k)|| ≤0.1.

考虑k=1时刻,取使残差故噪比最大的等价向量

Figure BDA0002374818490000094
其中,矩阵S和U由矩阵
Figure BDA0002374818490000095
特征值分解得到,即
Figure BDA0002374818490000096
UUT=I,VVT=I,Σ=[S 0];
Figure BDA0002374818490000097
为矩阵S-1UTPsF(PsF)TUS-1最大特征值所对应的特征向量。Considering the moment k = 1, take the equivalent vector that maximizes the residual error-to-noise ratio
Figure BDA0002374818490000094
where the matrices S and U are determined by the matrix
Figure BDA0002374818490000095
The eigenvalue decomposition is obtained, that is,
Figure BDA0002374818490000096
UUT = I, VVT = I, Σ = [ S 0];
Figure BDA0002374818490000097
is the eigenvector corresponding to the largest eigenvalue of the matrix S -1 U T P s F(P s F) T US -1 .

考虑时间窗口长度s=3,假设发生常值偏差性故障,具体形式为θ=[1.7 1.71.7]T;此时,系统的可检测性与可隔离性量化结果,具体如表1所示。其中,NF所在列表示故障的可检测性量化结果FDf(fi,k),i=1,…,4;其余数值为对应故障之间的可隔离性量化结果FIf(fi,fj,k),i,j=1,…,4。Considering the time window length s = 3, it is assumed that a constant deviation fault occurs, and the specific form is θ = [1.7 1.71.7] T ; at this time, the quantification results of the detectability and isolation of the system are shown in Table 1. . Among them, the column of NF represents the quantification result of fault detectability FD f (fi , k ), i =1,...,4; the remaining values are the quantification result of isolation between corresponding faults FI f (fi ,f j ,k),i,j=1,...,4.

表1常值偏差性故障的可诊断量化结果(θ=[1.7 1.7 1.7]T,

Figure BDA0002374818490000098
)Table 1 Diagnosable quantification results of constant deviation faults (θ=[1.7 1.7 1.7] T ,
Figure BDA0002374818490000098
)

Figure BDA0002374818490000099
Figure BDA0002374818490000099

从表1可知:不同故障的可检测性差异较大,可检测性从高到低的排序为:f1>f2>f4>f3;所有故障两两之间均具有可隔离性,f1与f2之间的可隔离性最好(4.118)。It can be seen from Table 1 that the detectability of different faults varies greatly, and the order of detectability from high to low is: f 1 >f 2 >f 4 >f 3 ; The isolation between f 1 and f 2 is the best (4.118).

本发明说明书中未作详细描述的内容属本领域技术人员的公知技术。The content not described in detail in the specification of the present invention belongs to the well-known technology of those skilled in the art.

Claims (3)

1. A method for diagnosably quantifying a time-varying system under the influence of bounded interference, comprising the steps of:
s1, establishing a time-varying equivalent space model of the spacecraft system based on a model standardization processing method and an equivalent space transformation processing method;
s2, establishing a fault set according to the time-varying equivalent space model of the spacecraft system;
s3, judging whether the fault can be detected or not according to a first preset condition by using the time-varying equivalent space model and the fault set of the spacecraft system; if so, go to S4; otherwise, ending;
s4, calculating a detectability metric value through a Hausdorff distance by using a time-varying equivalent space model of the spacecraft system;
s5, judging whether the fault can be isolated or not according to a second preset condition by using the time-varying equivalent space model and the fault set of the spacecraft system; if so, go to S6; otherwise, ending;
s6, calculating an isolatability measurement value through a Hausdorff distance by using the time-varying equivalent space model of the spacecraft system, and optimizing the configuration and fault diagnosis algorithm of the spacecraft system to realize the on-orbit monitoring of the health state of the spacecraft system;
the time-varying discrete state space model of the spacecraft system is as follows:
Figure FDA0002676046800000011
wherein: k represents the kth time; x (k), u (k), and y (k) are the state vector, input vector, and output vector of the system, respectively; f (k) is a fault vector; d (k) is the bounded interference of the system, and
Figure FDA0002676046800000012
wherein d isi(k) The i-th element representing the vector d (k), equivalent to | | d (k) | purple≤dmax(ii) a Matrices A (k), Bu(k)、C(k)、Du(k)、Bd(k)、Dd(k)、Bf(k) And Df(k) Respectively corresponding coefficient matrixes;
the time-varying equivalent space model of the spacecraft system is vs(k)ys-vs(k)Hus(k)us=vs(k)F(k)fs+vs(k)E(k)ds(ii) a Wherein v iss(k) Is a time-varying equivalent vector of the spacecraft system, fsTime stack vector, y, for spacecraft system failures、usAnd dsTime stack vectors, H, for spacecraft system output, control input and bounded interference, respectivelyus(k) F (k) and E (k) are time-varying coefficient matrices of corresponding dimensions;
the set of faults is
Figure FDA0002676046800000021
Wherein f isiRepresenting the ith fault vector; fi(k) Representing the corresponding vector f (k) of the matrix FiThe row in which it is located; bmIs represented by m unit intervals [ -1,1 [)]A unit box is formed, namely an m-dimensional interval vector is represented;
the first preset condition is as follows: if and only if Ps(k)Fi(k)fiNot equal to 0, fault detection; wherein, Ps(k) The method comprises the steps of (1) forming a spacecraft system time-varying equivalent space set consisting of time-varying equivalent vectors;
the detectability metric is
Figure FDA0002676046800000022
Wherein,
Figure FDA0002676046800000023
x is a directed hausdorff distance, and is used to explain the concrete form of the hausdorff distance formula, and in particular,
Figure FDA0002676046800000024
indicates a fault fiCorresponding time-varying fully-symmetrical multi-cell shape
Figure FDA0002676046800000025
Time-varying fully symmetrical multi-cell c corresponding to no faultNF(k) The directed hausdorff distance there between,
Figure FDA0002676046800000026
representing time-varying fully symmetric polytope c corresponding to no faultNF(k) And represents a fault fiCorresponding time-varying fully-symmetrical multi-cell shape
Figure FDA0002676046800000027
Directed hausdorff distance in between; w is ai→NFAnd wNF→iIs the proportion of the corresponding directed Hausdorff distance, and wi→NF+wNF→i=1、wi→NF≥0、wNF→i≥0;
Figure FDA0002676046800000028
By
Figure FDA0002676046800000029
Give a result ofNF(k) From cNF(k)={vs(k)E(k)ds:ds∈bmGiving.
2. The method of claim 1, further comprising determining the amount of diagnosability of the time-varying system under the influence of the disturbanceThe chemical conversion method is characterized in that the second preset condition is as follows: if and only if
Figure FDA00026760468000000210
Time, fault fiAnd fault fjCan be isolated.
3. The method of claim 2, wherein the isolatability metric value is
Figure FDA00026760468000000211
Wherein,
Figure FDA0002676046800000031
indicates a fault fiCorresponding time-varying fully-symmetrical multi-cell shape
Figure FDA0002676046800000032
And fault fjCorresponding time-varying fully-symmetrical multi-cell shape
Figure FDA0002676046800000033
Directed hausdorff distance in between;
Figure FDA0002676046800000034
indicates a fault fjCorresponding time-varying fully-symmetrical multi-cell shape
Figure FDA0002676046800000035
And fault fiCorresponding time-varying fully-symmetrical multi-cell shape
Figure FDA0002676046800000036
Directed hausdorff distance in between; w is ai→jAnd wj→iRepresents the proportion of the corresponding directed Hausdorff distance, and wi→j+wj→i=1、wi→j≥0、wj→i≥0。
CN202010062123.3A 2020-01-19 2020-01-19 A method for quantifying the diagnosability of time-varying systems under the influence of bounded disturbances Active CN111324036B (en)

Priority Applications (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN202010062123.3A CN111324036B (en) 2020-01-19 2020-01-19 A method for quantifying the diagnosability of time-varying systems under the influence of bounded disturbances

Applications Claiming Priority (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN202010062123.3A CN111324036B (en) 2020-01-19 2020-01-19 A method for quantifying the diagnosability of time-varying systems under the influence of bounded disturbances

Publications (2)

Publication Number Publication Date
CN111324036A CN111324036A (en) 2020-06-23
CN111324036B true CN111324036B (en) 2020-11-20

Family

ID=71167239

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
CN202010062123.3A Active CN111324036B (en) 2020-01-19 2020-01-19 A method for quantifying the diagnosability of time-varying systems under the influence of bounded disturbances

Country Status (1)

Country Link
CN (1) CN111324036B (en)

Families Citing this family (3)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN111966073B (en) * 2020-07-20 2021-07-13 北京控制工程研究所 A Model-Based Robustness Verification Method of Spacecraft Control System
CN113376496B (en) * 2021-05-21 2022-04-05 南京航空航天大学 Self-coupling transformer rectifier diode fault diagnosis method based on Hausdorff distance
CN115495271A (en) * 2022-06-27 2022-12-20 中国人民解放军海军航空大学 A Quantitative Evaluation Method of Fault Diagnosis Based on Maximum Mean Difference

Citations (9)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN102735435A (en) * 2012-06-18 2012-10-17 北京控制工程研究所 Method for determining fault diagnosability of momentum wheel based on relevance model
CN103697915A (en) * 2013-12-24 2014-04-02 北京控制工程研究所 Diagnostic evaluation method considering disturbing influence for satellite sensor fault
CN104571087A (en) * 2014-12-26 2015-04-29 北京控制工程研究所 Diagnostic determination method for spacecraft control system under influence of noise
CN104571088A (en) * 2014-12-26 2015-04-29 北京控制工程研究所 Satellite control system multi-objective optimization method based on fault diagnosability constraint
CN107516169A (en) * 2017-08-29 2017-12-26 上海航天控制技术研究所 A kind of closed-loop control system diagnosticability evaluation method
CN107544460A (en) * 2017-09-05 2018-01-05 北京控制工程研究所 Consider the diagnosticability quantization method of spacecraft control non-fully failure of removal
CN107608333A (en) * 2017-09-05 2018-01-19 北京控制工程研究所 A kind of diagnosticability appraisal procedure based on equivalent depression of order
CN107703911A (en) * 2017-09-05 2018-02-16 北京控制工程研究所 A kind of diagnosability analysis method of uncertain system
CN108181917A (en) * 2018-01-02 2018-06-19 佛山科学技术学院 A kind of spacecraft attitude control system fault diagnosability quantitative analysis method

Family Cites Families (1)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
KR101189697B1 (en) * 2010-08-31 2012-10-10 서울대학교산학협력단 Fault detector and detecting method for attitude control system of spacecaft

Patent Citations (9)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN102735435A (en) * 2012-06-18 2012-10-17 北京控制工程研究所 Method for determining fault diagnosability of momentum wheel based on relevance model
CN103697915A (en) * 2013-12-24 2014-04-02 北京控制工程研究所 Diagnostic evaluation method considering disturbing influence for satellite sensor fault
CN104571087A (en) * 2014-12-26 2015-04-29 北京控制工程研究所 Diagnostic determination method for spacecraft control system under influence of noise
CN104571088A (en) * 2014-12-26 2015-04-29 北京控制工程研究所 Satellite control system multi-objective optimization method based on fault diagnosability constraint
CN107516169A (en) * 2017-08-29 2017-12-26 上海航天控制技术研究所 A kind of closed-loop control system diagnosticability evaluation method
CN107544460A (en) * 2017-09-05 2018-01-05 北京控制工程研究所 Consider the diagnosticability quantization method of spacecraft control non-fully failure of removal
CN107608333A (en) * 2017-09-05 2018-01-19 北京控制工程研究所 A kind of diagnosticability appraisal procedure based on equivalent depression of order
CN107703911A (en) * 2017-09-05 2018-02-16 北京控制工程研究所 A kind of diagnosability analysis method of uncertain system
CN108181917A (en) * 2018-01-02 2018-06-19 佛山科学技术学院 A kind of spacecraft attitude control system fault diagnosability quantitative analysis method

Non-Patent Citations (3)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Title
Fault section location method using wide area centralized structure based on modified hausdorff distance;Zhao Jianwen等;《2017 IEEE Conference on Energy Internet and Energy System Integration》;20171231;全文 *
基于Hausdorff距离的动态系统故障可诊断性评价;符方舟等;《中国自动化学会、济南市人民政府.2017中国自动化大会》;20171231;第32-36页 *
复杂动态系统的实际非完全失效故障的可诊断性评估;符方舟等;《自动化学报》;20171231;第43卷(第11期);全文 *

Also Published As

Publication number Publication date
CN111324036A (en) 2020-06-23

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
CN111324036B (en) A method for quantifying the diagnosability of time-varying systems under the influence of bounded disturbances
CN108052770B (en) Long-span bridge girder performance early warning method considering time-varying effect
CN103472820B (en) Method for diagnosing propulsion system failure based on partial least squares algorithm
AU2020103881A4 (en) A Diagnosis Method of Train Body Assembly Deviation in the Manufacturing Process of High-Speed Train
CN104376231B (en) Based on the damnification recognition method for improving approximate Bayes's calculating
CN108875178B (en) Sensor arrangement method for reducing structural modal identification uncertainty
CN102759573B (en) Based on the construction damage positioning of frequency change and the appraisal procedure of degree of injury
CN107273609A (en) One kind is based on Kriging model gear drive reliability estimation methods
CN114091600B (en) A data-driven satellite-related fault propagation path identification method and system
CN107168063B (en) A Soft Sensing Method Based on Selective Partial Least Squares Regression of Integrated Variables
CN108427400B (en) A fault diagnosis method for aircraft pitot tubes based on neural network analytical redundancy
WO2019001025A1 (en) Sensor deployment method for simultaneous acquiring local deformation and overall modal information of structure
CN104123463A (en) Time domain identification method of random dynamic loads
CN114925526A (en) Structural modal parameter identification method combining multi-working-condition response
CN111609805A (en) Diagnosis method of tunnel structure state based on section curvature of fully distributed strain measuring point
CN103884776B (en) A kind of method improving random damage Locating Vector Methods monitoring result accuracy
CN111274543A (en) Spacecraft system anomaly detection method based on high-dimensional space mapping
CN104571087B (en) Spacecraft control diagnosability determination method under a kind of influence of noise
CN107703911B (en) A Diagnosis Analysis Method for Uncertain Systems
CN104678989B (en) The state aware optimization method of fault diagnosability is improved under a kind of noise circumstance
CN105651537B (en) A kind of truss structure damage real-time monitoring system of high susceptibility to damage
Li et al. Robust method of multiple variation sources identification in manufacturing processes for quality improvement
CN108170648A (en) A kind of nongausian process monitoring method returned based on given data
CN115267409A (en) Power equipment fault detection method, device and equipment
CN112101731B (en) Sewage plant online fault monitoring method based on mixed kernel typical correlation analysis

Legal Events

Date Code Title Description
PB01 Publication
PB01 Publication
SE01 Entry into force of request for substantive examination
SE01 Entry into force of request for substantive examination
GR01 Patent grant
GR01 Patent grant