[go: up one dir, main page]

CN101859146B - Satellite fault prediction method based on predictive filtering and empirical mode decomposition - Google Patents

Satellite fault prediction method based on predictive filtering and empirical mode decomposition Download PDF

Info

Publication number
CN101859146B
CN101859146B CN2010102287440A CN201010228744A CN101859146B CN 101859146 B CN101859146 B CN 101859146B CN 2010102287440 A CN2010102287440 A CN 2010102287440A CN 201010228744 A CN201010228744 A CN 201010228744A CN 101859146 B CN101859146 B CN 101859146B
Authority
CN
China
Prior art keywords
function
model
satellite
delta
centerdot
Prior art date
Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
Expired - Fee Related
Application number
CN2010102287440A
Other languages
Chinese (zh)
Other versions
CN101859146A (en
Inventor
沈毅
张迎春
王振华
Current Assignee (The listed assignees may be inaccurate. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the list.)
Harbin Institute of Technology Shenzhen
Original Assignee
Harbin Institute of Technology Shenzhen
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by Harbin Institute of Technology Shenzhen filed Critical Harbin Institute of Technology Shenzhen
Priority to CN2010102287440A priority Critical patent/CN101859146B/en
Publication of CN101859146A publication Critical patent/CN101859146A/en
Application granted granted Critical
Publication of CN101859146B publication Critical patent/CN101859146B/en
Expired - Fee Related legal-status Critical Current
Anticipated expiration legal-status Critical

Links

Images

Landscapes

  • Management, Administration, Business Operations System, And Electronic Commerce (AREA)
  • Control Of Position, Course, Altitude, Or Attitude Of Moving Bodies (AREA)

Abstract

一种基于预测滤波和经验模态分解的卫星故障预测方法,涉及空间卫星的安全运行及故障预测方法,解决了传统卫星故障预测与诊断方法存在受噪声影响严重、无法对故障趋势进行准确预测的问题,具体过程如下:一,利用卫星非线性姿态动力学关系,采用预测滤波的方法对卫星控制系统误差进行估计,得到系统模型误差项;二,对步骤一获得的系统模型误差项进行经验模态分解,得到前n阶本征模态函数IMF分量和残差分量;三,利用时间序列分析方法建立关于步骤二获得的残差分量的故障趋势的模型,完成微小和缓变故障的预报和检测。用于卫星姿态控制系统的故障诊断领域。

A satellite fault prediction method based on predictive filtering and empirical mode decomposition, which involves the safe operation of space satellites and fault prediction methods, and solves the problem that traditional satellite fault prediction and diagnosis methods are seriously affected by noise and cannot accurately predict fault trends The specific process is as follows: 1. Using the nonlinear attitude dynamics relationship of the satellite, the error of the satellite control system is estimated by the method of predictive filtering, and the error item of the system model is obtained; 2. The error item of the system model obtained in step 1 is empirically modeled State decomposition to obtain the first n-order intrinsic mode function IMF components and residual components; third, use the time series analysis method to establish a fault trend model for the residual components obtained in step 2, and complete the prediction and detection of small and slowly changing faults . It is used in the field of fault diagnosis of satellite attitude control system.

Description

A kind of satellite failure Forecasting Methodology based on predictive filtering and empirical modal decomposition
Technical field
The present invention relates to the safe operation and the failure prediction method of Aerospace Satellite, be specifically related to a kind of satellite attitude control system failure prediction method based on predictive filtering and empirical modal decomposition.
Background technology
Attitude of satellite control is to obtain and keep satellite in aspect-stabilized method and process.Present high precision three-axis attitude stabilization satellite during operate as normal, generally adopts the main topworks of momenttum wheel as attitude control system in orbit, realizes control to the attitude of satellite by the momentum-exchange between momenttum wheel and the satellite.The reliability of momenttum wheel will directly influence the feasibility and the reliability of the attitude control of whole satellite.The current method that mainly is based on hardware redundancy for the fault diagnosis and the reconstruct of satellite attitude control system, this satellite posture control system for complexity is far from being enough.
Safe operation and failure prediction to satellite adopts the predictive filtering method at present, the predictive filtering method is a kind of method of estimation that is applicable to the nonlinear system with unknown input or model error, the non-linear Proctor Central that the viewpoint that its thought source is controlled in Lu from system proposes, on this basis, Crassidis and Markley have proposed a kind of new Real-Time Filtering algorithm according to the least model error criterion---and predictive filtering (Predictive Filtering, PF).Predictive filtering is exported the model error of real-time estimating system by comparing and measuring output and prediction, thereby the correction wave filter state is realized the estimation to time of day.Because predictive filter has the ability of estimation model sum of errors system state simultaneously, domestic Li Ji, a big vast battle-axe used in ancient China have been incorporated into fault diagnosis field by fault being considered as a kind of special model error with the predictive filtering method.The noise that exists in the estimated result of predictive filtering can influence diagnosis performance, can adopt the low-pass filter method to suppress high frequency noise, but because characteristic the unknown of noise, the method that adopts the low-pass filter method to suppress noise often lost efficacy, cause and to make accurate prediction to fault, be unfavorable for further research ensuing fault detection and diagnosis.If can accurately predict, before taking place, fault, can improve the feasibility and the reliability of the attitude control of whole satellite to the estimation of time of day to satellite failure.
Summary of the invention
There is serious, the problem that can't accurately predict fault trend affected by noise in the present invention in order to solve the conventional satellite failure prediction method, and a kind of satellite failure Forecasting Methodology of decomposing based on predictive filtering and empirical modal is provided.
Detailed process of the present invention is as follows:
Step 1: utilize satellite nonlinear attitude kinetics relation, adopt the method for predictive filtering that the satellite control system error is estimated, obtain system model error term;
Step 2: the system model error term that step 1 obtains is carried out the empirical modal decomposition, E rank eigenmode state function IMF component and residual component before obtaining;
Step 3: utilize Time series analysis method to set up the model of the fault trend of the residual component that obtains about step 2, finish the forecast and the detection of small gentle change fault.
The present invention is according to the nonlinear attitude kinetics relation of satellite, fault amount and model uncertainty sum are considered as model error, compare with low-pass filter disposal route in the past, can eliminate The noise effectively, utilize predictive filtering method estimation model error, the model error estimated value that predictive filtering obtains is carried out the empirical modal decomposition, obtain its several in solid model attitude component and trend component, improved precision of prediction, utilize Time series analysis method that the trend of fault is predicted, can be to gradual early stage, small fault forecasts accurately and detects that method is concisely effective.The fault diagnosis field that is used for satellite attitude control system.
Description of drawings
Fig. 1 is the process flow diagram based on the satellite failure Forecasting Methodology of predictive filtering and empirical modal decomposition; Fig. 2 is embodiment three process flow diagrams; Predictive filtering estimated result when Fig. 3 for pitch axis gradual fault takes place; Fig. 4 is the empirical modal decomposition result of yaw axis (non-fault); Fig. 5 is the empirical modal decomposition result of pitch axis (gradual fault); Fig. 6 is the empirical modal decomposition result of wobble shaft (non-fault); Predicting the outcome of gradual fault takes place for pitch axis in Fig. 7; Fig. 8 predicts the outcome for yaw axis generation micromutation fault.
Embodiment
Embodiment one: a kind of satellite failure Forecasting Methodology based on predictive filtering and empirical modal decomposition, detailed process is as follows:
Step 1: utilize satellite nonlinear attitude kinetics relation, adopt the method for predictive filtering that the satellite control system error is estimated, obtain system model error term;
Step 2: the system model error term that step 1 obtains is carried out the empirical modal decomposition, E rank eigenmode state function IMF component and residual component before obtaining;
Step 3: utilize Time series analysis method to set up the model of the fault trend of the residual component that obtains about step 2, finish the forecast and the detection of small gentle change fault.
Empirical mode decomposition method (Empirical Mode Decomposition, EMD) be a kind of new signal decomposition method that proposed by scholar Huang E in 1998, can utilize the variation of signal internal time yardstick to do the parsing of energy and frequency, with signal be launched into solid model state function in several (Intrinsic Mode Function, IMF).Be different from and use the classic method of solid form window for the boundary basis function, the basis function of EMD extracts from signal and obtains, and promptly uses IMF to do substrate.And IMF must satisfy following condition:
1) in whole function, the number of extreme point equates with the number that passes through zero point or differs 1;
2) be zero by the defined envelope local mean value of local extremum envelope at any time.
Wherein, in first condition and the traditional gaussian stationary process narrow frequency range require similar.Second condition is a new idea: globality is required to change into the locality requirement, make instantaneous frequency can not cause unnecessary rocking because of the existence of asymmetric waveform.The EMD and the HHT that rely on these two conditions to make up are considered to handle forcefully adaptive approach non-linear, non-stationary signal, be in recent years to based on the linearity of Fourier transform and the important breakthrough of stable state analysis of spectrum, and obtained using widely.Utilize the empirical mode decomposition method can be adaptive with the composition of signal decomposition for different instantaneous frequencys, thus the noise contribution adaptively in the erasure signal.
The forecast model of setting up fault trend is the main contents of fault forecast.Autoregressive model (Autoregressive model, AR model) is a kind of common model in the time series analysis.Advantages such as it is simple that the AR model has modeling, and calculated amount is little.The above AR model of single order is applicable to stochastic process stably, and single order AR model has m>different characteristic of 1 model wherein with AR (m), and as the special case of AR model, single order AR model can be predicted nonstationary random process.
Basic thought of the present invention is major part or a kind of important component that fault is considered as the system model error, utilize the model error item of satellite nonlinear attitude kinetics relation design predictive filter estimating system, utilize empirical mode decomposition method that estimated result is handled then, so that can diagnose the small gentle change initial failure of satellite attitude control system.
The objective of the invention is to be achieved through the following technical solutions: the model error item that utilizes satellite nonlinear attitude kinetics relation design predictive filter estimating system, estimated result is carried out empirical modal to be decomposed, obtain some rank IMF and trend term, utilize Time series analysis method to set up the model of trend term, carry out the forecast and the detection of small gentle change fault.
The present invention compared with prior art has following advantage:
1) failure prediction method proposed by the invention utilizes empirical mode decomposition method, compares with the low-pass filter disposal route, can more effectively eliminate The noise, extracts the tendency information of fault amount.
2) fault failure prediction method proposed by the invention is utilized empirical mode decomposition method, and signal is divided into the residual component of several IMF and non-stationary, sets up the AR model on this basis, can improve precision of prediction.
3) the present invention forecasts the fault amount and detects, and directly compares based on the diagnostic method of threshold value, can improve the responsive ability for gradual early stage, small fault.
Embodiment two, present embodiment are further specifying embodiment one, utilize satellite nonlinear attitude kinetics relation in the step 1, adopt the method for predictive filtering the satellite control system error to be estimated the process that obtains system model error term is:
Set the model error of satellite control system and be made up of satellite executing mechanism fault and model uncertainty, the measurement equation of predictive filtering system and real system is respectively:
State equation:
x · ( t ) = f [ x ( t ) ] + g [ x ( t ) ] d ( t )
y ~ k = c [ x ( t k ) ] + v k
The predictive filtering equation is:
x ^ ( t ) = f [ x ^ ( t ) ] + g [ x ^ ( t ) ] d ^ ( t )
y ^ ( t ) = c [ x ^ ( t ) ]
X (t) ∈ R wherein sBe state vector,
Figure GDA0000078196520000045
Be the estimated value of state vector, f ∈ R sBe function of state that can be little,
Figure GDA0000078196520000046
Be known model error distribution matrix,
Figure GDA0000078196520000047
Be the measurement functions vector,
Figure GDA0000078196520000048
Be the estimation of unknown error, the measurement of real system is output as discrete form,
Figure GDA0000078196520000049
Be shown in t kMeasured value constantly, v k∈ R mBe the measurement noise, and set v kBe that average is zero, covariance matrix is Q ∈ R M * mWhite Gaussian noise;
Constantly will measure function at t+ Δ t and carry out Taylor expansion, obtain:
y ^ ( t + Δt ) = y ^ ( t ) + z [ x ^ ( t ) , Δt ] + Λ ( Δt ) S [ x ^ ( t ) ] d ( t )
Δ t=t wherein K+1-t kIt is the sampling period; This sampling period is normal value, y (t+ Δ t)=y K+1, matrix
Figure GDA00000781965200000411
I element be:
z i [ x ^ ( t ) , Δt ] = Σ k = 1 p i Δt k k ! L k f ( c i )
P wherein iDifferential exponent number when occurring d (t) in the Taylor expansion first,
Figure GDA00000781965200000413
Be c iK rank Lie derivative;
Matrix Λ (Δ t) is a diagonal matrix, and its diagonal element is:
λ ii = Δt p i p i ! , i=1,2,…,m
Matrix S [ x ^ ( t ) ] ∈ R m × q , The element that its i is capable is:
s i = { L g 1 [ L f p i - 1 ( c i ) ] , L , L g q [ L f p i - 1 ( c i ) ] } , i=1,2,…,m
Get performance index function:
J [ d ( t ) ] = 1 2 { y ~ ( t + Δt ) - y ~ ( t + Δt ) } T Q - 1 { y ~ ( t + Δt ) - y ~ ( t + Δt ) } + 1 2 d T ( t ) Wd ( t )
W ∈ R wherein Q * qBe positive semidefinite weighting matrix, adopt the gradient optimizing algorithm that performance index are optimized, the estimated value that obtains the model error item is:
d ^ ( t ) = - { [ Λ ( Δt ) S ( x ^ ) ] T Q - 1 Λ ( Δt ) S ( x ^ ) + W } - 1 [ Λ ( Δt ) S ( x ^ ) ] Q - 1 [ z ( x ^ , Δt ) - y ~ ( t + Δt ) + y ^ ( t ) ] .
Because the estimated value of model error item
Figure GDA0000078196520000053
Contain bigger noise component, can not be directly used in fault diagnosis, be necessary to carry out next step and handle.
Embodiment three, present embodiment are to the further specifying of concrete enforcement one, and the process of E rank eigenmode state function IMF component and residual component was before step 2 obtained:
The estimated value of initialization system model error item is Time t=1,2 ..., N,
Step a, IMF decomposable process initialization: n=1, and satisfy relational expression
Figure GDA0000078196520000055
Set up, wherein r N-1(t) be remaining residual error function after (n-1) inferior decomposition;
Step b, screening process initialization: k=1, and satisfy relational expression h N (k-1)(t)=r N-1(t) set up, wherein h N (k-1)(t) be through the survival function after the k-1 time screening during the n time IMF decomposes;
Step c, obtain the estimated value of system model error term according to screening sequence Survival function h after screening through the k time in the remaining residual error function of decomposing through the n time intrinsic mode function Nk(t);
Steps d, the survival function h that adopts the judgement of standard deviation criterion to obtain Nk(t) whether satisfy the condition of eigenmode state function, promptly
Figure GDA0000078196520000057
Whether less than threshold value T, 0.2≤T≤0.3;
Judged result is for being, execution in step e, and judged result is not for, and then k=k+1 returns execution in step c,
Step e, the n time intrinsic mode function IMF component c of acquisition n(t)=h Nk(t);
Step f, obtain the estimated value of system model error term
Figure GDA0000078196520000058
Remaining residual error function through the n time intrinsic mode function decomposition r n ( t ) = d ( t ) - Σ α = 1 n c α ( t ) ;
Step g, make n=n+1, return execution in step b, E rank eigenmode state function IMF component and residual component before satisfying n=E and obtaining.
Embodiment four, present embodiment are that step c obtains the estimated value of system model error term according to screening sequence to the further specifying of concrete enforcement three
Figure GDA0000078196520000061
Survival function h after screening through the k time in the remaining residual error function of decomposing through the n time intrinsic mode function Nk(t) process is:
Step c1, the survival function h after utilizing cubic spline function to obtain in the residue trend function that system model error term d (t) decomposes through the n time intrinsic mode function to screen through the k-1 time N (k-1)(t) upper and lower enveloping curve;
Step c2, the described survival function h of calculating N (k-1)(t) upper and lower enveloping curve is at time t=1, and 2 ..., the average in the N
Figure GDA0000078196520000062
Step c3, obtain the estimated value of system model error term Survival function after screening through the k time in the residue trend function of decomposing through the n time intrinsic mode function h nk ( t ) = h n ( k - 1 ) ( t ) - m ‾ n ( k - 1 ) ( t ) .
Embodiment five, present embodiment are to the further specifying of concrete enforcement three, and among the step f system model error term x (t) are carried out 4 intrinsic mode functions and decompose, and obtain 4 eigenmode state function component IMF1, IMF2, IMF3 and IMF4:{c 1(t), c 2(t), c 3(t), c 4(t) }; And acquisition is through the remaining residual error function r of 4 intrinsic mode function decomposition 4(t).
Embodiment six, present embodiment are further specifying concrete enforcement one, utilize Time series analysis method to set up the model of the fault trend of the residual component that obtains about step 2 in the step 3, finish the forecast of small gentle change fault and the process of detection and be:
Residual component as the trend signal, is set up its autoregressive model, and expression formula is:
r(t)=a 1r(t-1)+a 2r(t-2)+…+a pr(t-p)+ε(t)
Wherein, r (t) is the time series of residual error function, and p is a model order, a iBe model parameter, ε (t) is a white noise sequence;
Observed reading is r (0), r (1) ..., r (N), the order of forecast model are p, get following system of equations by the autoregressive model expression formula:
r ( p ) = a 1 r ( p - 1 ) + a 2 r ( p - 2 ) + . . . + a p r ( 0 ) + ϵ ( p ) r ( p + 1 ) = a 1 r ( p ) + a 2 r ( p - 1 ) + . . . + a p r ( 1 ) + ϵ ( p + 1 ) · · · r ( N ) = a 1 r ( N - 1 ) + a 2 r ( N - 2 ) + . . . + a p r ( N - p ) + ϵ ( N )
Order:
R = r ( p ) r ( p + 1 ) · · · r ( N ) , A = a 1 a 2 · · · a p ,
B = r ( p - 1 ) r ( p - 2 ) · · · r ( 0 ) r ( p ) r ( p - 1 ) · · · r ( 1 ) · · · · · · · · · · · · r ( N - 1 ) r ( N - 2 ) · · · r ( N - p ) , Δ = ϵ ( p ) ϵ ( p + 1 ) · · · ϵ ( N )
Then the matrix form of following formula is:
R=BA+Δ
The least square solution of model parameter is:
A=(B TB) -1B TR
Obtain the model parameter A of autoregressive model, utilize model parameter A to carry out failure prediction and detection.
The above AR model of single order is applicable to stochastic process stably, and single order AR model has and the different characteristic of AR (m) (m>1) model, and as the special case of AR model, single order AR model can be predicted nonstationary random process.
Set forth the specific embodiment of the present invention below by satellite executing mechanism Fault Diagnosis Simulation example:
Execution in step one: estimate topworks's fault amount with the predictive filtering method.
Dynamic (dynamical) state equation form of the attitude of satellite and discrete measurement equation are as follows:
x · 1 ( t ) = ( I y - I z I x ) x 2 x 3 + ( 1 I x ) T x + ( 1 T x ) f x ( t ) x · 2 ( t ) = ( I x - I z I y ) x 1 x 3 + ( I I y ) T y + ( 1 T y ) f y ( t ) x · 3 ( t ) = ( I x - I y I z ) x 1 x 2 + ( I I z ) T z + ( 1 I z ) f z ( t )
y ~ ( t k ) = x ( t k ) + v ( t k )
In the formula, state variable x (t) is the attitude angular velocity of satellite, I x, I y, I zBe the main shaft inertia of satellite, f x(t), f y(t), f z(t) be actuator momenttum wheel fault.According to the predictive filtering theory, obtain the Fault Estimation amount and be:
f ( t ) = - { [ Λ ( Δt ) S ( x ^ ) ] T Q - 1 Λ ( Δt ) S ( x ^ ) + W } - 1 ·
[ Λ ( Δt ) S ( x ^ ) ] Q - 1 [ z ( x ^ , Δt ) - y ~ ( t + Δt ) + y ^ ( t ) ]
Wherein
z ( x ^ , Δt ) = ( I y - I z I x ) x ^ 2 x ^ 3 + ( 1 I x ) T x ( I z - I x I y ) x ^ 1 x ^ 3 + ( I I y ) T y ( I x - I y I z ) x ^ 1 x ^ 2 + ( I I z ) T z Δt , Λ ( Δt ) = 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 Δt ,
S ( x ^ ) = 1 I x 0 0 0 1 I y 0 0 0 1 I z
With pitch axis generation slope when the t=19.6s is the gradual fault f of actuator of 0.004Nm/s yBe example, the Fault Estimation result of each as shown in Figure 3, wherein, three curves of Fig. 3 respectively are x, y, three change in coordinate axis direction of z (driftage, pitching, wobble shaft) Fault Estimation value, horizontal ordinate express time, unit is second, and ordinate is represented the Fault Estimation value, and unit is a Newton meter.Owing to there is bigger noise contribution in the estimated result, can't be directly used in fault diagnosis, must handle to extract fault signature signal.
Execution in step two: the predictive filtering result is carried out empirical modal decompose, obtain several IMF and residual component.
For avoiding the fault signature of mass loss rates gyro, promptly carry out an empirical modal through 128 samplings and decompose.Empirical modal decomposes to the 4th layer can be finished.
When the t=19.6s pitch axis breaks down, the empirical modal decomposition result of yaw axis (non-fault) Fault Estimation amount is Fig. 4, Fig. 5 is the empirical modal decomposition result of the Fault Estimation amount of pitch axis, and Fig. 6 is the empirical modal decomposition result of wobble shaft (non-fault) Fault Estimation amount.Fig. 4, Fig. 5, Fig. 6 are respectively driftage, pitching and lift-over three axis signals of gathering are carried out the result that empirical modal decomposes, each figure is respectively the residual component after 1,2,3,4,5 rank IMF (interior solid model state function) component and the decomposition from top to bottom, the horizontal ordinate express time, unit is second, ordinate is represented IMF component or residual component, and unit is a Newton meter.
Execution in step three: set up the AR model of residual component, carry out failure prediction and detection.
With the forecast model of single order AR model, utilize aforementioned the least square estimation method to obtain the model parameter value of AR model as residual component.Predicting the outcome of driftage, pitching and wobble shaft as Fig. 7.Fig. 7 is for to the described example of Fig. 3 (pitch axis breaks down when the t=19.6s), the x that adopts the inventive method to obtain, y, three change in coordinate axis direction of z (driftage, pitching, wobble shaft) Fault Estimation value, the horizontal ordinate express time, unit is second, and ordinate is represented the Fault Estimation value, and unit is a Newton meter.Adopt suitable threshold (0.02Nm), can realize detecting in advance small, initial failure.
In addition, also can verify the validity of failure prediction method proposed by the invention by small mutation failure.When t=20s, the yaw axis fault of undergoing mutation, amplitude is 0.01Nm, the failure prediction result of then driftage, pitching, wobble shaft such as Fig. 8.Fig. 8 is when 20s, when yaw axis generation amplitude is the mutation failure of 0.01N.m, and the x that adopts the inventive method to obtain, y, three change in coordinate axis direction of z (driftage, pitching, wobble shaft) Fault Estimation value, horizontal ordinate express time, unit is second, and ordinate is represented the Fault Estimation value, and unit is a Newton meter.
Above-mentioned fault diagnosis result can be verified the validity of failure prediction method proposed by the invention.

Claims (6)

1.一种基于预测滤波和经验模态分解的卫星故障预测方法,其特征在于具体过程如下:1. a satellite failure prediction method based on predictive filtering and empirical mode decomposition, is characterized in that concrete process is as follows: 步骤一:利用卫星非线性姿态动力学关系,采用预测滤波的方法对卫星控制系统误差进行估计,得到系统模型误差项;Step 1: Estimate the error of the satellite control system by using the nonlinear attitude dynamic relationship of the satellite, and use the method of predictive filtering to obtain the error term of the system model; 步骤二:对步骤一获得的系统模型误差项进行经验模态分解,得到前E阶本征模态函数IMF分量和残差分量;Step 2: Perform empirical mode decomposition on the error item of the system model obtained in step 1 to obtain the IMF component and residual component of the former E-order eigenmode function; 步骤三:利用时间序列分析方法建立关于步骤二获得的残差分量的故障趋势的模型,完成微小和缓变故障的预报和检测。Step 3: Use the time series analysis method to establish a model of the fault trend of the residual component obtained in Step 2, and complete the prediction and detection of small and slowly changing faults. 2.根据权利要求1所述的一种基于预测滤波和经验模态分解的卫星故障预测方法,其特征在于步骤一中利用卫星非线性姿态动力学关系,采用预测滤波的方法对卫星控制系统误差进行估计,得到系统模型误差项的过程为:2. a kind of satellite fault prediction method based on predictive filtering and empirical mode decomposition according to claim 1, it is characterized in that utilize satellite nonlinear attitude dynamics relation in the step 1, adopt the method for predictive filtering to satellite control system error The process of estimating and obtaining the error term of the system model is: 设定卫星控制系统的模型误差由卫星执行机构故障和模型不确定性组成,其非线性状态方程和量测方程分别为:It is assumed that the model error of the satellite control system is composed of satellite actuator failure and model uncertainty, and its nonlinear state equation and measurement equation are respectively: 状态方程:Equation of state: xx ·&Center Dot; (( tt )) == ff [[ xx (( tt )) ]] ++ gg [[ xx (( tt )) ]] dd (( tt )) ythe y ~~ kk == cc [[ xx (( tt kk )) ]] ++ vv kk 预测滤波方程为:The prediction filter equation is: xx ^^ (( tt )) == ff [[ xx ^^ (( tt )) ]] ++ gg [[ xx ^^ (( tt )) ]] dd ^^ (( tt )) ythe y ^^ (( tt )) == cc [[ xx ^^ (( tt )) ]] 其中x(t)∈Rs为状态向量,
Figure FDA0000078196510000015
为状态向量的估计值,f∈Rs为可微的状态函数,
Figure FDA0000078196510000016
为已知的模型误差分布矩阵,
Figure FDA0000078196510000017
为测量函数向量,d(t)∈Rq为未知的模型误差,
Figure FDA0000078196510000018
为其估计值,
Figure FDA0000078196510000019
表示在tk时刻的实际系统的量测输出,为离散形式,vk∈Rm为测量噪声,并设定vk是均值为零、协方差矩阵为Q∈Rm×m的高斯白噪声;
where x(t)∈R s is the state vector,
Figure FDA0000078196510000015
is the estimated value of the state vector, f∈R s is a differentiable state function,
Figure FDA0000078196510000016
is the known model error distribution matrix,
Figure FDA0000078196510000017
is the measurement function vector, d(t)∈R q is the unknown model error,
Figure FDA0000078196510000018
for its estimated value,
Figure FDA0000078196510000019
Indicates the measurement output of the actual system at time t k in discrete form, v k ∈ R m is the measurement noise, and v k is set to be Gaussian white noise with zero mean and covariance matrix Q ∈ R m×m ;
在t+Δt时刻将量测函数进行泰勒展开,得到:Taylor expand the measurement function at time t+Δt to get: ythe y ^^ (( tt ++ ΔtΔt )) == ythe y ^^ (( tt )) ++ zz [[ xx ^^ (( tt )) ,, ΔtΔt ]] ++ ΛΛ (( ΔtΔt )) SS [[ xx ^^ (( tt )) ]] dd (( tt )) 其中Δt=tk+1-tk是采样周期;该采样周期为常值,y(t+Δt)=yk+1,矩阵
Figure FDA0000078196510000021
的第i个元素为:
Among them, Δt=t k+1 -t k is the sampling period; the sampling period is a constant value, y(t+Δt)=y k+1 , the matrix
Figure FDA0000078196510000021
The i-th element of is:
zz ii [[ xx ^^ (( tt )) ,, ΔtΔt ]] == ΣΣ kk == 11 pp ii ΔtΔt kk kk !! LL kk ff (( cc ii )) 其中pi为泰勒展开式中首次出现d(t)时的微分阶数,
Figure FDA0000078196510000023
为ci的k阶李导数;
Where p i is the differential order when d(t) appears for the first time in the Taylor expansion,
Figure FDA0000078196510000023
is the k-order Lie derivative of ci ;
矩阵A(Δt)为对角矩阵,其对角元素为:Matrix A(Δt) is a diagonal matrix whose diagonal elements are: λ ii = Δt p i p i ! , i=1,2,…,m λ i = Δt p i p i ! , i=1,2,...,m 矩阵 S [ x ^ ( t ) ] ∈ R m × q , 其第i行的元素为:matrix S [ x ^ ( t ) ] ∈ R m × q , The elements of the i-th row are: s i = { L g 1 [ L f p i - 1 ( c i ) ] , L , L g q [ L f p i - 1 ( c i ) ] } , i=1,2,…,m the s i = { L g 1 [ L f p i - 1 ( c i ) ] , L , L g q [ L f p i - 1 ( c i ) ] } , i=1,2,...,m 取性能指标函数:Take the performance index function: JJ [[ dd (( tt )) ]] == 11 22 {{ ythe y ~~ (( tt ++ ΔtΔt )) -- ythe y ~~ (( tt ++ ΔtΔt )) }} TT QQ -- 11 {{ ythe y ~~ (( tt ++ ΔtΔt )) -- ythe y ~~ (( tt ++ ΔtΔt )) }} ++ 11 22 dd TT (( tt )) WdWd (( tt )) 其中W∈Rq×q为正半定加权矩阵,采用梯度优化算法对性能指标进行优化,得到模型误差项的估计为:Where W∈R q×q is a positive semidefinite weighting matrix, and the gradient optimization algorithm is used to optimize the performance index, and the estimation of the model error term is obtained as: dd ^^ (( tt )) == -- {{ [[ ΛΛ (( ΔtΔt )) SS (( xx ^^ )) ]] TT QQ -- 11 ΛΛ (( ΔtΔt )) SS (( xx ^^ )) ++ WW }} -- 11 ·&Center Dot; [[ ΛΛ (( ΔtΔt )) SS (( xx ^^ )) ]] QQ -- 11 [[ zz (( xx ^^ ,, ΔtΔt )) -- ythe y ~~ (( tt ++ ΔtΔt )) ++ ythe y ^^ (( tt )) ]] ..
3.根据权利要求2所述的一种基于预测滤波和经验模态分解的卫星故障预测方法,其特征在于步骤二得到前E阶本征模态函数IMF分量和残差分量的过程为:3. a kind of satellite fault prediction method based on predictive filtering and empirical mode decomposition according to claim 2, it is characterized in that step 2 obtains the process of preceding E order eigenmode function IMF component and residual component as: 设定系统模型误差项估计值为
Figure FDA00000781965100000210
时间t=1,2,…,N,
Set the estimated error term of the system model to be
Figure FDA00000781965100000210
Time t=1, 2, ..., N,
步骤a、IMF分解过程初始化:n=1,且满足关系式
Figure FDA00000781965100000211
成立,其中rn-1(t)为第(n-1)次分解后剩余的残差函数;
Step a, IMF decomposition process initialization: n=1, and satisfy the relation
Figure FDA00000781965100000211
Established, where r n-1 (t) is the residual function remaining after the (n-1)th decomposition;
步骤b、筛选过程初始化:k=1,且满足关系式hn(k-1)(t)=rn-1(t)成立,其中hn(k-1)(t)为第n次IMF分解中经过第k-1次筛选后的剩余函数;Step b, initialization of the screening process: k=1, and the relation h n(k-1) (t)=r n-1 (t) is satisfied, where h n(k-1) (t) is the nth time The remaining function after the k-1th screening in the IMF decomposition; 步骤c、根据筛选程序获取系统模型误差项估计值
Figure FDA00000781965100000212
经过第n次本征模态函数分解的剩余的残差函数中经过第k次筛选后的剩余函数hnk(t);
Step c. Obtain the estimated value of the error term of the system model according to the screening procedure
Figure FDA00000781965100000212
The residual function h nk (t) after the kth screening of the remaining residual functions after the nth eigenmode function decomposition;
步骤d、采用标准偏差准则判断获得的剩余函数hnk(t)是否满足本征模态函数的条件,即
Figure FDA0000078196510000031
是否小于阈值T,0.2≤T≤0.3;
Step d, using the standard deviation criterion to judge whether the obtained residual function h nk (t) satisfies the condition of the intrinsic mode function, namely
Figure FDA0000078196510000031
Whether it is less than the threshold T, 0.2≤T≤0.3;
判断结果为是,执行步骤e,判断结果为否,则k=k+1,返回执行步骤c,If the judgment result is yes, execute step e, if the judgment result is no, then k=k+1, return to execute step c, 步骤e、获得第n次本征模态函数IMF分量cn(t)=hnk(t);Step e, obtaining the nth intrinsic mode function IMF component c n (t)=h nk (t); 步骤f、获取系统模型误差项估计值经过第n次本征模态函数分解的剩余的残差函数 r n ( t ) = d ^ ( t ) - Σ α = 1 n c α ( t ) ; Step f. Obtain the estimated value of the error term of the system model The remaining residual function after the nth eigenmode function decomposition r no ( t ) = d ^ ( t ) - Σ α = 1 no c α ( t ) ; 步骤g、令n=n+1,返回执行步骤b,直到满足n=E获得前E阶本征模态函数IMF分量和残差分量。Step g, set n=n+1, return to step b, until n=E is satisfied to obtain the IMF component and residual component of the first E order intrinsic mode function.
4.根据权利要求3所述的一种基于预测滤波和经验模态分解的卫星故障预测方法,其特征在于步骤c根据筛选程序获取系统模型误差项估计值
Figure FDA0000078196510000034
经过第n次本征模态函数分解的剩余的残差函数中经过第k次筛选后的剩余函数hnk(t)的过程为:
4. a kind of satellite fault prediction method based on predictive filtering and empirical mode decomposition according to claim 3, is characterized in that step c obtains system model error term estimated value according to screening procedure
Figure FDA0000078196510000034
The process of the residual function h nk (t) after the k-th screening of the remaining residual functions after the n-th eigenmode function decomposition is:
步骤c1、利用三次样条函数获取系统模型误差项估计值经过第n次本征模态函数分解的剩余趋势函数中经过第k-1次筛选后的剩余函数hn(k-1)(t)的上、下包络曲线;Step c1, using the cubic spline function to obtain the estimated value of the error term of the system model The upper and lower envelope curves of the residual function h n(k-1) (t) after the k-1 screening in the residual trend function of the n-th eigenmode function decomposition; 步骤c2、计算所述剩余函数hn(k-1)(t)上、下包络曲线在时间t=1,2,…,N内的均值
Figure FDA0000078196510000036
Step c2, calculating the mean value of the upper and lower envelope curves of the residual function h n(k-1) (t) at time t=1, 2, ..., N
Figure FDA0000078196510000036
步骤c3、获取系统模型误差项估计值经过第n次本征模态函数分解的剩余趋势函数中经过第k次筛选后的剩余函数
Figure FDA0000078196510000038
Step c3. Obtain the estimated value of the error term of the system model The residual function after the kth screening in the residual trend function after the nth eigenmode function decomposition
Figure FDA0000078196510000038
5.根据权利要求3所述的一种基于预测滤波和经验模态分解的卫星故障预测方法,其特征在于步骤f中对系统模型误差项的估计值
Figure FDA0000078196510000039
进行4次本征模态函数分解,获得4个本征模态函数分量IMF1、IMF2、IMF3和IMF4:{c1(t),c2(t),c3(t),c4(t)};并获得经过4次本征模态函数分解的剩余的残差函数r4(t)。
5. a kind of satellite fault prediction method based on predictive filtering and empirical mode decomposition according to claim 3 is characterized in that in the step f, to the estimated value of system model error term
Figure FDA0000078196510000039
Decompose the intrinsic mode function four times to obtain four intrinsic mode function components IMF1, IMF2, IMF3 and IMF4: {c 1 (t), c 2 (t), c 3 (t), c 4 (t )}; and obtain the remaining residual function r 4 (t) after four eigenmode function decompositions.
6.根据权利要求3所述的一种基于预测滤波和经验模态分解的卫星故障预测方法,其特征在于步骤三中利用时间序列分析方法建立关于步骤二获得的残差分量的故障趋势的模型,完成微小和缓变故障的预报和检测的过程为:6. a kind of satellite fault prediction method based on predictive filtering and empirical mode decomposition according to claim 3 is characterized in that in step 3, utilizes time series analysis method to set up the model about the fault tendency of the residual error component that step 2 obtains , the process of completing the prediction and detection of small and slowly changing faults is: 将残差分量作为趋势信号,建立其自回归模型,表达式为:The residual component is used as a trend signal, and its autoregressive model is established, and the expression is: r(t)=a1r(t-1)+a2r(t-2)+…+apr(t-p)+ε(t)r(t)=a 1 r(t-1)+a 2 r(t-2)+...+a p r(tp)+ε(t) 其中,r(t)为残差函数的时间序列,p为模型阶次,ai为模型参数,ε(t)为白噪声序列;Among them, r(t) is the time series of the residual function, p is the model order, ai is the model parameter, ε(t) is the white noise sequence; 观测值为r(0),r(1),…,r(N),预测模型的阶次为p,由自回归模型表达式得如下方程组:The observed values are r(0), r(1), ..., r(N), and the order of the prediction model is p. The following equations are obtained from the expression of the autoregressive model: rr (( pp )) == aa 11 rr (( pp -- 11 )) ++ aa 22 rr (( pp -- 22 )) ++ .. .. .. ++ aa pp rr (( 00 )) ++ ϵϵ (( pp )) rr (( pp ++ 11 )) == aa 11 rr (( pp )) ++ aa 22 rr (( pp -- 11 )) ++ .. .. .. ++ aa pp rr (( 11 )) ++ ϵϵ (( pp ++ 11 )) ·&Center Dot; ·&Center Dot; ·&Center Dot; rr (( NN )) == aa 11 rr (( NN -- 11 )) ++ aa 22 rr (( NN -- 22 )) ++ .. .. .. ++ aa pp rr (( NN -- pp )) ++ ϵϵ (( NN )) 令:make: RR == rr (( pp )) rr (( pp ++ 11 )) ·&Center Dot; ·&Center Dot; ·&Center Dot; rr (( NN )) ,, AA == aa 11 aa 22 ·&Center Dot; ·&Center Dot; ·&Center Dot; aa pp ,, BB == rr (( pp -- 11 )) rr (( pp -- 22 )) ·&Center Dot; ·&Center Dot; ·· rr (( 00 )) rr (( pp )) rr (( pp -- 11 )) ·· ·· ·· rr (( 11 )) ·&Center Dot; ·· ·&Center Dot; ·· ·&Center Dot; ·&Center Dot; ·· ·&Center Dot; ·· ·&Center Dot; ·· ·&Center Dot; rr (( NN -- 11 )) rr (( NN -- 22 )) ·· ·· ·· rr (( NN -- pp )) ,, ΔΔ == ϵϵ (( pp )) ϵϵ (( pp ++ 11 )) ·· ·&Center Dot; ·&Center Dot; ϵϵ (( NN )) 则上式的矩阵形式为:Then the matrix form of the above formula is: R=BA+ΔR=BA+Δ 模型参数的最小二乘解为:The least squares solution for the model parameters is: A=(BTB)-1BTR获得自回归模型的模型参数A,利用模型参数A进行故障预报和检测。A=(B T B) -1 B T R Obtain the model parameter A of the autoregressive model, and use the model parameter A to carry out fault prediction and detection.
CN2010102287440A 2010-07-16 2010-07-16 Satellite fault prediction method based on predictive filtering and empirical mode decomposition Expired - Fee Related CN101859146B (en)

Priority Applications (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN2010102287440A CN101859146B (en) 2010-07-16 2010-07-16 Satellite fault prediction method based on predictive filtering and empirical mode decomposition

Applications Claiming Priority (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN2010102287440A CN101859146B (en) 2010-07-16 2010-07-16 Satellite fault prediction method based on predictive filtering and empirical mode decomposition

Publications (2)

Publication Number Publication Date
CN101859146A CN101859146A (en) 2010-10-13
CN101859146B true CN101859146B (en) 2011-11-30

Family

ID=42945103

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
CN2010102287440A Expired - Fee Related CN101859146B (en) 2010-07-16 2010-07-16 Satellite fault prediction method based on predictive filtering and empirical mode decomposition

Country Status (1)

Country Link
CN (1) CN101859146B (en)

Families Citing this family (27)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN102542159B (en) * 2011-12-08 2014-10-08 北京空间飞行器总体设计部 Method for predicting state of on-orbit spacecraft
CN102789235B (en) * 2012-06-18 2014-12-17 北京控制工程研究所 Method for determining reconfigurability of satellite control system
CN103364024B (en) * 2013-07-12 2015-10-28 浙江大学 Based on the sensor fault diagnosis method of empirical mode decomposition
CN104750086B (en) * 2013-12-26 2017-05-24 清华大学 Fault and state estimation method and fault and state estimation device
CN103840970B (en) * 2014-01-24 2017-09-15 珠海多玩信息技术有限公司 A kind of method and device for obtaining service operation state
CN103825576B (en) * 2014-03-14 2016-09-21 清华大学 The polynomial filtering fault detection method of nonlinear system
CN103973263B (en) * 2014-05-16 2017-02-01 中国科学院国家天文台 Approximation filter method
CN104020671B (en) * 2014-05-30 2017-01-11 哈尔滨工程大学 Robustness recursion filtering method for aircraft attitude estimation under the condition of measurement interference
CN104267732B (en) * 2014-09-29 2017-07-28 哈尔滨工业大学 Flexible satellite high stability attitude control method based on frequency-domain analysis
CN104571088B (en) * 2014-12-26 2018-01-05 北京控制工程研究所 Satellite control system Multipurpose Optimal Method based on fault diagnosability constraint
CN105574166A (en) * 2015-12-16 2016-05-11 上海卫星工程研究所 Fault dictionary based satellite fault diagnosis method
CN105371836B (en) * 2015-12-18 2018-09-25 哈尔滨工业大学 Mixed type signal of fiber optical gyroscope filtering method based on EEMD and FIR
CN106767898B (en) * 2016-11-17 2019-04-09 中国人民解放军国防科学技术大学 A Method for Detecting Minor Faults in Satellite Attitude Measurement System
CN106742068B (en) * 2016-12-07 2019-01-04 中国人民解放军国防科学技术大学 A method of diagnosis satellite attitude control system unknown failure
CN107609685A (en) * 2017-08-22 2018-01-19 哈尔滨工程大学 It is a kind of based on floating motion when go through the job safety phase forecast system of enveloping estimation
CN107830996B (en) * 2017-10-10 2020-11-03 南京航空航天大学 A method for fault diagnosis of aircraft rudder surface system
CN108877272B (en) * 2018-08-02 2020-12-22 哈尔滨工程大学 A vehicle navigation system and navigation method based on destination state
CN110209190B (en) * 2019-03-01 2022-05-20 苏州纳飞卫星动力科技有限公司 Satellite nominal orbit unbiased flight control method
CN110703596B (en) * 2019-08-01 2021-04-23 中国科学院力学研究所 A primary star attitude prediction method and system for a star-arm coupled system
CN111783286B (en) * 2020-06-16 2024-11-01 中国人民解放军国防科技大学 Fault trend ratio and feature selection-based micro fault diagnosis method and system
CN112949683B (en) * 2021-01-27 2023-02-07 东方红卫星移动通信有限公司 Intelligent fault diagnosis and early warning method and system for low-earth-orbit satellite
CN112924996B (en) * 2021-01-28 2023-11-03 湖南北斗微芯产业发展有限公司 Method, equipment and storage medium for enhancing Beidou time sequence analysis reliability
CN113189624B (en) * 2021-04-30 2023-10-03 中山大学 Self-adaptive classification multipath error extraction method and device
CN114155117B (en) * 2021-11-09 2025-03-25 江南大学 A filter fault diagnosis method for power converters in multiple operating modes
CN114063456B (en) * 2021-11-15 2023-06-02 哈尔滨工业大学 Fault Prediction and Early Warning Method Using Autoregressive Model and Kalman Filter Algorithm
CN115131943B (en) * 2022-07-07 2023-10-31 杭州申昊科技股份有限公司 Acousto-optic linkage early warning method based on deep learning
CN116954070B (en) * 2023-06-28 2024-11-05 北京空间飞行器总体设计部 Diagnosis and reconstruction integrated design method for spacecraft autonomous diagnosis and reconstruction process

Citations (4)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN101082494A (en) * 2007-06-19 2007-12-05 北京航空航天大学 Self boundary marking method based on forecast filtering and UPF spacecraft shading device
CN101464125A (en) * 2009-01-20 2009-06-24 西安交通大学 Vertical rotation axis partial contact rubbing detection method
CN101481019A (en) * 2009-02-20 2009-07-15 华中科技大学 Fault tolerant observing method of sensor for satellite attitude control system
CN101590918A (en) * 2009-06-19 2009-12-02 上海微小卫星工程中心 Method for automatic fault diagnosis of satellite and diagnostic system thereof

Family Cites Families (2)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
US7451021B2 (en) * 2003-05-06 2008-11-11 Edward Wilson Model-based fault detection and isolation for intermittently active faults with application to motion-based thruster fault detection and isolation for spacecraft
FR2866423B1 (en) * 2004-02-13 2006-05-05 Thales Sa DEVICE FOR MONITORING THE INTEGRITY OF THE INFORMATION DELIVERED BY AN INS / GNSS HYBRID SYSTEM

Patent Citations (4)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN101082494A (en) * 2007-06-19 2007-12-05 北京航空航天大学 Self boundary marking method based on forecast filtering and UPF spacecraft shading device
CN101464125A (en) * 2009-01-20 2009-06-24 西安交通大学 Vertical rotation axis partial contact rubbing detection method
CN101481019A (en) * 2009-02-20 2009-07-15 华中科技大学 Fault tolerant observing method of sensor for satellite attitude control system
CN101590918A (en) * 2009-06-19 2009-12-02 上海微小卫星工程中心 Method for automatic fault diagnosis of satellite and diagnostic system thereof

Non-Patent Citations (1)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Title
张筱磊等.《EMD 在卫星姿态控制系统未知故障诊断中的应用》.《华中科技大学学报(自然科学版)》.2009,第37卷(第增刊I期),204-206页. *

Also Published As

Publication number Publication date
CN101859146A (en) 2010-10-13

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
CN101859146B (en) Satellite fault prediction method based on predictive filtering and empirical mode decomposition
CN107608335B (en) Data driving method for fault detection and fault separation of unmanned aerial vehicle flight control system
CN105843073B (en) A kind of wing structure aeroelastic stability analysis method not knowing depression of order based on aerodynamic force
CN104443427B (en) Aircraft tremor prognoses system and method
CN102208028B (en) Fault predicting and diagnosing method suitable for dynamic complex system
CN101982732B (en) A Microsatellite Attitude Determination Method Based on ESOQPF and UKF Master-Slave Filter
CN102393864B (en) Method for optimizing reliability of harmonic gear used for space vehicle based on fault physics
CN103940433B (en) A kind of satellite attitude determination method based on the self adaptation square root UKF algorithm improved
CN107590317A (en) A kind of generator method for dynamic estimation of meter and model parameter uncertainty
CN103676918B (en) A kind of satellite executing mechanism method for diagnosing faults based on Unknown Input Observer
CN101661530A (en) Method for acquiring steady-state equivalent wind speed and generated power in wind power station based on correlation analysis
Xu et al. Damage detection of wind turbine blades by Bayesian multivariate cointegration
CN104063569A (en) Equipment residual life predicting method based on EMD denoising and fading memory
Wang et al. Time series prediction of e-nose sensor drift based on deep recurrent neural network
CN106200377A (en) A kind of method of estimation of flying vehicles control parameter
CN117035001A (en) Conversion force sensor temperature compensation method based on Kriging interpolation
CN107577902B (en) UKF-based airplane fatigue structure residual life prediction method
CN116485031A (en) Method, device, equipment and storage medium for predicting short-term power load
CN110362902B (en) Single-source dynamic load identification method based on interval dimension-by-dimension analysis
CN113408057B (en) High-precision off-line estimation method for aircraft airflow angle based on EM algorithm
Li et al. Using a single column model (SGRIST1. 0) for connecting model physics and dynamics in the Global-to-Regional Integrated forecast SysTem (GRIST-A20. 8)
Zhang et al. Ensemble square root filter assimilation of near-surface soil moisture and reference-level observations into a coupled land surface-boundary layer model
CN109084751A (en) A kind of high energy efficiency attitude of satellite based on box particle filter determines algorithm
CN115688865A (en) Industrial soft measurement method for long and short term memory network for flue gas of desulfurization process
CN107732940A (en) A kind of parameters of power system stabilizer Optimum Experiment method based on ADPSS

Legal Events

Date Code Title Description
C06 Publication
PB01 Publication
C10 Entry into substantive examination
SE01 Entry into force of request for substantive examination
C14 Grant of patent or utility model
GR01 Patent grant
CF01 Termination of patent right due to non-payment of annual fee

Granted publication date: 20111130

CF01 Termination of patent right due to non-payment of annual fee