[go: up one dir, main page]

CN101738601B - System and method for measuring speed of locomotive based on radar near field echo power spectrum characteristics - Google Patents

System and method for measuring speed of locomotive based on radar near field echo power spectrum characteristics Download PDF

Info

Publication number
CN101738601B
CN101738601B CN2009102192170A CN200910219217A CN101738601B CN 101738601 B CN101738601 B CN 101738601B CN 2009102192170 A CN2009102192170 A CN 2009102192170A CN 200910219217 A CN200910219217 A CN 200910219217A CN 101738601 B CN101738601 B CN 101738601B
Authority
CN
China
Prior art keywords
speed
locomotive
antenna
measurement
center
Prior art date
Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
Expired - Fee Related
Application number
CN2009102192170A
Other languages
Chinese (zh)
Other versions
CN101738601A (en
Inventor
吴兆平
苏涛
许磊
武容伟
梁中英
Current Assignee (The listed assignees may be inaccurate. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the list.)
Xidian University
Original Assignee
Xidian University
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by Xidian University filed Critical Xidian University
Priority to CN2009102192170A priority Critical patent/CN101738601B/en
Publication of CN101738601A publication Critical patent/CN101738601A/en
Application granted granted Critical
Publication of CN101738601B publication Critical patent/CN101738601B/en
Expired - Fee Related legal-status Critical Current
Anticipated expiration legal-status Critical

Links

Images

Landscapes

  • Radar Systems Or Details Thereof (AREA)

Abstract

本发明公开了一种基于雷达近场回波功率谱特征的机车速度测量系统及方法,主要解决现有技术对机车速度测量误差大和不稳定的问题。本发明的测量系统,包括选择采样率模块、频谱重心法预估速度模块、速度校正模块和抗天线波束角度误差模块。选择采样率模块选择当前速度对应的采样率,以保证后续模块中测量速度的相对误差满足测速精度要求,频谱重心预估速度模块预估计出机车的速度,该预估计的机车速度分别通过速度校正模块和抗天线波束角度误差模块进行一次和二次校正,得到对机车速度的最终估计结果。本发明具有运算量小、稳定性好、且测速精度高的优点,可用于机车测速多普勒雷达对机车速度的精确测量。

Figure 200910219217

The invention discloses a locomotive speed measurement system and method based on radar near-field echo power spectrum characteristics, and mainly solves the problems of large error and instability in locomotive speed measurement in the prior art. The measurement system of the present invention includes a sampling rate selection module, a frequency spectrum center of gravity method estimation speed module, a speed correction module and an antenna beam angle error resistance module. Select the sampling rate module to select the sampling rate corresponding to the current speed to ensure that the relative error of the measurement speed in the subsequent modules meets the speed measurement accuracy requirements. The spectral center of gravity estimation speed module pre-estimates the speed of the locomotive, and the pre-estimated locomotive speed is corrected by speed The module and the anti-antenna beam angle error module perform primary and secondary corrections to obtain the final estimation result of the locomotive speed. The invention has the advantages of small calculation amount, good stability and high speed measurement precision, and can be used for accurate measurement of the speed of the locomotive by the locomotive speed measurement Doppler radar.

Figure 200910219217

Description

基于雷达近场回波功率谱特征的机车速度测量系统及方法Locomotive speed measurement system and method based on radar near-field echo power spectrum features

技术领域 technical field

本发明属于雷达近场测量技术领域,具体的说是一种机车速度测量方法,用于在复杂的机车电磁环境、不同的铁路路基环境、雷达天线波束较宽和天线波束方向存在误差等不利条件下,稳定并精确的实现对机车速度的测量。The invention belongs to the technical field of radar near-field measurement, and specifically relates to a locomotive speed measurement method, which is used in complex locomotive electromagnetic environments, different railway subgrade environments, wide radar antenna beams, and errors in antenna beam directions. Under this condition, the measurement of the speed of the locomotive can be realized stably and accurately.

背景技术 Background technique

目前,在我国的铁路系统中,机车速度的测量主要是依靠光电传感器,这种光电测速设备是通过测量机车车轮或者一个刚性轴的转数来获得机车的速度值。光电传感器的原理简单,容易实现,但是这种测速方法在车轮打滑、空转、以及车轮直径因磨损而发生改变的情况下都会出现一定的系统偏差,不能满足高精度和高可靠性的要求。另外,由于磁悬浮列车没有车轮,因此,传统的光电测速设备无法测量磁悬浮机车的速度。正是由于这个问题的存在,采用雷达微波传感技术以非接触方式对机车速度进行测量成为了一种较好的选择。At present, in my country's railway system, the measurement of locomotive speed mainly relies on photoelectric sensors. This photoelectric speed measuring device obtains the speed value of the locomotive by measuring the number of revolutions of the locomotive wheels or a rigid shaft. The principle of the photoelectric sensor is simple and easy to implement, but this method of speed measurement will have a certain system deviation when the wheel slips, idling, and the diameter of the wheel changes due to wear, and cannot meet the requirements of high precision and high reliability. In addition, since the maglev train has no wheels, the traditional photoelectric speed measuring equipment cannot measure the speed of the maglev locomotive. Because of this problem, it is a better choice to use radar microwave sensing technology to measure the locomotive speed in a non-contact manner.

多普勒测速雷达是雷达微波传感技术的应用之一,它利用微波相对于路基运动时所产生的多普勒效应对机车进行测速,具有所必要的抗恶劣环境的性能,又由于在不同环境下电磁波的传播速度几乎不变,使得这种方法具有高的精确度和稳定性。Doppler speed measuring radar is one of the applications of radar microwave sensing technology. It uses the Doppler effect generated when microwaves move relative to the roadbed to measure the speed of locomotives. It has the necessary performance against harsh environments. The propagation speed of electromagnetic waves is almost constant in the environment, which makes this method have high accuracy and stability.

德国的型号为DRS05的机车测速雷达就是利用电磁波相对于路基运动时产生的多普勒效应对机车进行测速的。该雷达考虑到单天线测速容易受到路基函数的影响,从而采用了图1所示的单端双天线结构,使用双天线的波束交点K作为速度的估计值。如图1所示,在理想情况下,两个天线频谱的交点很清晰,位置是稳定的,此时,无论用最大值、还是用交点来估算速度都是无偏的。但在实际情况下,两个天线的频谱曲线会发生类似图中阴影部分那样的变化,包络的最大值向左移动,且有很大起伏,此时,用最大值方法估计的速度就偏小。不过,从统计的角度看,可认为两个天线波束经历了同样的路基函数起伏,由于当两个天线同时扫过同一路基函数时,两个天线回波功率谱的交点K不会像最大值那样左右漂移,它与理想交点一致,如图1所示。DRS05雷达就是基于路基函数并不影响交点K的位置这一特征来测速的,该技术的最大的好处就是剔除了路基函数的影响,因而测速精度比单天线的高。但是,由于对交点K的精确估计难度比较大,DRS05雷达的测速精度虽然有所提高,但测速误差还是比较大。The German model DRS05 locomotive speed measuring radar uses the Doppler effect generated when the electromagnetic wave moves relative to the roadbed to measure the speed of the locomotive. Considering that the single-antenna speed measurement is easily affected by the roadbed function, the radar adopts the single-ended dual-antenna structure shown in Figure 1, and uses the beam intersection point K of the dual-antenna as the estimated value of the speed. As shown in Figure 1, under ideal conditions, the intersection point of the spectrum of the two antennas is clear and the position is stable. At this time, no matter whether the maximum value or the intersection point is used to estimate the speed, it is unbiased. But in reality, the spectral curves of the two antennas will change like the shaded part in the figure, and the maximum value of the envelope will move to the left with large fluctuations. At this time, the speed estimated by the maximum value method will be biased. Small. However, from a statistical point of view, it can be considered that the two antenna beams have experienced the same ups and downs of the roadbed function, because when the two antennas sweep the same roadbed function at the same time, the intersection point K of the echo power spectrum of the two antennas will not be like the maximum value Drifting left and right like that, it coincides with the ideal intersection point, as shown in Figure 1. The DRS05 radar measures speed based on the fact that the roadbed function does not affect the position of the intersection point K. The biggest advantage of this technology is that the influence of the roadbed function is eliminated, so the speed measurement accuracy is higher than that of a single antenna. However, due to the difficulty of accurately estimating the intersection point K, although the speed measurement accuracy of the DRS05 radar has been improved, the speed measurement error is still relatively large.

虽然理论上多普勒测速雷达能够克服传统方式的缺点,稳定可靠,并能提供精确的测量精度,但实际上由于受机车电磁环境、地理环境、雷达天线波束宽度和雷达天线安装角度误差等因素的影响,多普勒机车测速雷达测量的机车速度精度不高且容易受到雷达本身安装误差的影响,同时,也不能有效地克服不同路基环境引起的测速误差。Although theoretically the Doppler speed measuring radar can overcome the shortcomings of the traditional method, is stable and reliable, and can provide accurate measurement accuracy, but in fact, due to factors such as the electromagnetic environment of the locomotive, the geographical environment, the beam width of the radar antenna, and the error of the installation angle of the radar antenna, etc. Influenced by Doppler locomotive speed measuring radar, the accuracy of the locomotive speed measured by the Doppler locomotive speed measuring radar is not high and is easily affected by the installation error of the radar itself. At the same time, it cannot effectively overcome the speed measurement error caused by different roadbed environments.

发明内容 Contents of the invention

本发明的目的在于克服上述多普勒测速雷达测量机车速度的不足,提出了一种基于雷达近场回波功率谱特征的机车速度测量系统及方法,以避免雷达测速精度容易受到机车电磁环境、不同路基环境、波束天线宽度和雷达天线安装角度误差诸多因素的影响,提高测量精度。The purpose of the present invention is to overcome the deficiency of above-mentioned Doppler speed measuring radar measuring locomotive speed, has proposed a kind of locomotive speed measurement system and method based on radar near-field echo power spectrum feature, in order to avoid radar speed measuring accuracy being easily affected by locomotive electromagnetic environment, The influence of many factors such as different roadbed environment, beam antenna width and radar antenna installation angle error improves the measurement accuracy.

为实现上述目的,本发明的测量系统,包括To achieve the above object, the measurement system of the present invention includes

选择采样率模块,用于选择采样率,以保证测量速度值的相对误差满足机车测速要求,并将所选的采样率数据送给频谱重心法预估计速度模块;The sampling rate selection module is used to select the sampling rate to ensure that the relative error of the measured speed value meets the requirements of the locomotive speed measurement, and sends the selected sampling rate data to the pre-estimated speed module of the spectral center of gravity method;

频谱重心法预估速度模块,用于预估计雷达的两个天线各自的回波功率频谱重心位置对应的机车速度,并将两个天线对应的预估计速度送入速度校正模块;The spectral center of gravity method estimated speed module is used to estimate the locomotive speed corresponding to the center of gravity position of the echo power spectrum of the two antennas of the radar in advance, and sends the estimated speed corresponding to the two antennas to the speed correction module;

速度校正模块,用于对两个天线对应的预估计速度进行校正,得到单个天线对机车速度的无偏估计,并将两个天线各自校正后的速度送入抗天线波束角度误差模块;The speed correction module is used to correct the estimated speed corresponding to the two antennas, obtain the unbiased estimation of the speed of the locomotive by a single antenna, and send the corrected speeds of the two antennas to the anti-antenna beam angle error module;

抗天线波束角度误差模块,用于对雷达的两个天线波束中心的角度偏差带来的测速误差进行校正,实现对机车速度的无偏测量,得到最终的速度测量结果。The anti-antenna beam angle error module is used to correct the speed measurement error caused by the angle deviation of the two antenna beam centers of the radar, realize the unbiased measurement of the locomotive speed, and obtain the final speed measurement result.

为了实现上述目的,本发明的测量方法如下:In order to achieve the above object, the measuring method of the present invention is as follows:

(1)选择采样率为最大采样率的十分之一进行采样,对采样数据进行FFT运算,分别得到前天线和后天线的回波功率频谱;(1) Select the sampling rate to be one-tenth of the maximum sampling rate for sampling, and perform FFT operation on the sampling data to obtain the echo power spectrum of the front antenna and the rear antenna respectively;

(2)利用下式分别计算前后天线的回波功率包络对应的频谱区域内的重心,(2) Use the following formula to calculate the center of gravity in the spectrum region corresponding to the echo power envelope of the front and rear antennas respectively,

ff bb == ΣΣ ff ii EE. ii ΣΣ EE. ii ,, -- -- -- 11 ))

其中,Ei为回波功率频率fi对应的功率幅度,fi为回波功率频率,它在最小和最大频率范围(fmin,fmax)内取值;Wherein, E i is the power amplitude corresponding to the echo power frequency f i , and f i is the echo power frequency, which takes values within the minimum and maximum frequency ranges (f min , f max );

(3)将步骤(2)估计的前后天线的重心对应的速度乘以校正因子k,分别得到采用前后天线的回波功率谱对机车速度的初次无偏估计,校正因子的求解公式为(3) Multiply the speed corresponding to the center of gravity of the front and rear antennas estimated in step (2) by the correction factor k to obtain the initial unbiased estimation of the locomotive speed using the echo power spectrum of the front and rear antennas respectively. The solution formula of the correction factor is

kk == coscos αα ·&Center Dot; ΣEΣE (( θθ ii )) ΣΣ coscos θθ ii ·· EE. (( θθ ii )) ,, -- -- -- 22 ))

式中,α是天线的波束中心方向与水平面夹角,θi为离散化的天线波束方向与水平面的夹角,θi在天线3dB波束宽带范围内,即(θmin,θmax)内取值,E(θi)为天线在波束角度θi上的增益;In the formula, α is the angle between the beam center direction of the antenna and the horizontal plane, θ i is the angle between the discretized antenna beam direction and the horizontal plane, and θ i is within the 3dB beam broadband range of the antenna, that is, within (θ min , θ max ) value, E(θ i ) is the gain of the antenna at the beam angle θ i ;

(4)通过下式对前天线的初次无偏估计速度进行二次校正,得到前天线对机车速度的最终测量结果,(4) Perform secondary correction on the initial unbiased estimated speed of the front antenna by the following formula to obtain the final measurement result of the locomotive speed by the front antenna,

vv AA == 11 22 λλ ·· ff dd 11 ·· tgtg 22 αα 11 ++ 11 -- -- -- 33 ))

其中,λ为发射波波长,α1为前天线的波束中心方向与水平面的夹角,fd1为前天线的初次无偏估计速度对应的频率;Among them, λ is the wavelength of the transmitted wave, α 1 is the angle between the beam center direction of the front antenna and the horizontal plane, and f d1 is the frequency corresponding to the initial unbiased estimated speed of the front antenna;

(5)通过下式对后天线的初次无偏估计速度进行二次校正,得到后天线对机车速度的最终测量,(5) Perform secondary correction on the initial unbiased estimated speed of the rear antenna by the following formula to obtain the final measurement of the locomotive speed by the rear antenna,

vv BB == 11 22 λλ ·&Center Dot; ff dd 22 ·· tgtg 22 αα 22 ++ 11 -- -- -- 44 ))

其中,α2为后天线的波束中心方向与水平面的夹角,fd2为后天线的初次无偏估计速度对应的频率;Among them, α2 is the angle between the beam center direction of the rear antenna and the horizontal plane, and f d2 is the frequency corresponding to the initial unbiased estimated velocity of the rear antenna;

(6)将前天线和后天线的最终测量速度取平均值,得到对当前时刻机车速度的最终测量结果,(6) average the final measurement speeds of the front antenna and the rear antenna to obtain the final measurement result of the locomotive speed at the current moment,

vv == vv AA ++ vv BB 22 ;; -- -- -- 55 ))

(7)根据步骤(6)测量的当前时刻的机车速度,按照机车要求的测速相对误差选择下一时刻的采样频率,并对该采样的数据进行FFT运算,分别得到前天线和后天线的在下一时刻的回波功率频谱;(7) According to the locomotive speed at the current moment measured in step (6), select the sampling frequency at the next moment according to the relative error of the speed measurement required by the locomotive, and perform FFT calculation on the sampled data to obtain the following values of the front antenna and the rear antenna respectively Echo power spectrum at a moment;

(8)循环执行步骤(2)至步骤(7),实现对机车速度的实时测量。(8) Steps (2) to (7) are cyclically executed to realize real-time measurement of the speed of the locomotive.

本发明与现有技术相比具有以下优点:Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following advantages:

(1)本发明采用估计的回波功率包络重心作为机车的预估计速度,并采用校正因子对该预估计速度进行校正,比用一般的幅值最大法和未做校正处理时估计的速度更加稳定和准确;(1) The present invention adopts the estimated center of gravity of the echo power envelope as the pre-estimated speed of the locomotive, and uses a correction factor to correct the pre-estimated speed, compared with the speed estimated when the general amplitude maximum method and the correction process are not done more stable and accurate;

(2)本发明分别对前后天线的初次无偏估计速度进行二次校正并取平均,校正了由天线存在安装误差或存在使用过程中引起的位置偏移误差引起的测速误差,得到的速度更加稳定和准确;(2) The present invention carries out secondary correction and average to the initial unbiased estimated velocity of front and back antennas respectively, has corrected the velocity measurement error that causes by the installation error of antenna or the position offset error that causes in use process, and the velocity that obtains is more accurate stable and accurate;

(3)本发明由于按照机车要求的测速相对误差选择下一时刻的采样频率,使得测量速度的相对误差基本不变,在速度比较低的情况下,该方法估计的速度误差远小于采用固定采样率测量的速度误差;(3) The present invention selects the sampling frequency of the next moment due to the relative error of speed measurement required by the locomotive, so that the relative error of the measurement speed is basically unchanged. The speed error of the rate measurement;

(4)实测数据表明本发明的平均测速精度小于0.16%。(4) The measured data shows that the average velocity measurement accuracy of the present invention is less than 0.16%.

对本发明的目的、特征、优点可通过如下附图和实例详细描述。The purpose, features and advantages of the present invention can be described in detail by the following drawings and examples.

附图说明 Description of drawings

图1是德国的型号为DRS05的机车测速雷达结构和原理图;Figure 1 is a structure and principle diagram of a German locomotive speed measuring radar model DRS05;

图2是本发明的测速系统框图;Fig. 2 is a block diagram of the speed measuring system of the present invention;

图3是本发明的使用的机车测速雷达结构图;Fig. 3 is the structural diagram of the locomotive speed measuring radar used in the present invention;

图4是本发明的测速过程图;Fig. 4 is a speed measuring process figure of the present invention;

图5是采用现有最大值法估计的机车速度实测曲线图;Fig. 5 is the measured curve diagram of locomotive speed estimated by existing maximum method;

图6是采用本发明的频谱包络重心法估计的机车速度实测曲线图;Fig. 6 is the actual measurement graph of the locomotive speed that adopts spectrum envelope center of gravity method estimation of the present invention;

图7是分别采用前后天线的回波数据测量的机车速度实测曲线图;Fig. 7 is the actual measurement curve diagram of the locomotive speed measured by the echo data of the front and rear antennas respectively;

图8是对图7的测量结果校正后的机车速度实测曲线图。Fig. 8 is a curve diagram of actual measurement of locomotive speed after correction of the measurement result of Fig. 7 .

具体实施方式 Detailed ways

下面结合附图详细说明本发明的内容和效果。The content and effects of the present invention will be described in detail below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.

参照图2,本机车速度测量系统包括选择采样率模块、频谱重心法预估速度模块、速度校正模块和抗天线波束角度误差模块。Referring to Fig. 2, the locomotive speed measurement system includes a module for selecting a sampling rate, a module for estimating speed by spectral center of gravity method, a speed correction module and an anti-antenna beam angle error module.

所述的选择采样率模块,用于选择采样率,以保证测量速度值的相对误差满足机车测速要求,并将所选的采样率数据送给频谱重心法预估计速度模块。传统的快速傅里叶变换运算的频率分辨率是固定的,根据频率分辨率决定速度分辨率的关系,通过FFT运算得到的测速误差是绝对的,也就是说,机车速度低时相对误差大,而速度高时相对误差小,这和机车测速系统要求的相对测速误差相悖。本模块将机车速度按照由大到小分为10档,每档速度对应一个采样频率,在采样点数不变的条件下,找出当前的测量速度值对应的速度档,选取该速度档的采样率作为下一时刻的采样率,以满足相对测速精度的要求。The sampling rate selection module is used to select the sampling rate to ensure that the relative error of the measured speed value meets the requirements of the locomotive speed measurement, and send the selected sampling rate data to the pre-estimated speed module of the spectral center of gravity method. The frequency resolution of the traditional fast Fourier transform operation is fixed, and the relationship between the speed resolution is determined by the frequency resolution. The speed measurement error obtained by the FFT operation is absolute, that is to say, the relative error is large when the speed of the locomotive is low. However, the relative error is small when the speed is high, which is contrary to the relative speed error required by the locomotive speed measurement system. This module divides the speed of the locomotive into 10 gears from large to small, and each speed corresponds to a sampling frequency. Under the condition that the number of sampling points remains unchanged, find out the speed gear corresponding to the current measured speed value, and select the speed gear for sampling The rate is used as the sampling rate at the next moment to meet the requirements of relative speed measurement accuracy.

所述的频谱重心法预估速度模块,用于预估计雷达的前后天线各自的回波功率频谱重心位置对应的机车速度,并将前后天线对应的预估计速度送入速度校正模块。机车测速雷达的回波功率的频谱曲线是受到路基反射面的变化、机车振动和噪声因素影响的一个起伏并且不对称的包络,直接采用最大值作为天线中心频率的估计值会有很大的误差。为减小测速误差,本模块采用估计的频谱重心来预估计机车速度,即:通过相对频谱宽度r%找到回波功率包络的频谱区域,求出该区域内的频谱重心作为机车速度的预估计值。因为回波功率频谱曲线的重心偏低,所以用频谱重心法对中心频率的预估计值比真值偏小,不准确,需要在速度校正模块进行校正;The speed estimation module of the spectral center of gravity method is used to predict the locomotive speed corresponding to the center of gravity of the echo power spectrum of the front and rear antennas of the radar, and send the estimated speed corresponding to the front and rear antennas to the speed correction module. The spectrum curve of the echo power of the locomotive speed measuring radar is a fluctuating and asymmetrical envelope affected by the change of the roadbed reflective surface, locomotive vibration and noise factors, directly using the maximum value as the estimated value of the antenna center frequency will have a large error. In order to reduce the error of speed measurement, this module uses the estimated center of gravity of the spectrum to predict the speed of the locomotive, that is, find the spectrum area of the echo power envelope through the relative spectrum width r%, and obtain the center of gravity of the spectrum in this area as the prediction of the speed of the locomotive estimated value. Because the center of gravity of the echo power spectrum curve is low, the pre-estimated value of the center frequency using the spectral center of gravity method is smaller than the true value, which is inaccurate and needs to be corrected in the speed correction module;

所述的速度校正模块,用于对两个天线对应的预估计速度进行校正,得到单个天线对机车速度的初次无偏估计,并将前后天线各自校正后的速度送入抗天线波束角度误差模块。雷达回波功率的频谱曲线是一个偏离真实速度对应频谱的不对称包络,而且重心偏小,本发明采用频谱重心估计的机车速度和真实机车速度之比为常数的回波功率谱特征,将校正因子乘以频谱重心法预估计的速度得到对机车速度的初次无偏估计。由于天线存在安装角度误差和机车振动引起的位置误差,会对单个天线测速精度有影响,本模块的测速结果需要在抗天线波束角度误差模块进行二次校正。The speed correction module is used to correct the pre-estimated speeds corresponding to the two antennas, obtain the initial unbiased estimate of the speed of the locomotive by a single antenna, and send the corrected speeds of the front and rear antennas to the anti-antenna beam angle error module . The spectrum curve of the radar echo power is an asymmetric envelope that deviates from the frequency spectrum corresponding to the real speed, and the center of gravity is too small. The present invention adopts the echo power spectrum feature that the ratio of the locomotive speed estimated by the frequency center of gravity and the real locomotive speed is constant, and the The correction factor is multiplied by the speed estimated by the spectral center of gravity method to obtain the first unbiased estimate of the locomotive speed. Due to the installation angle error of the antenna and the position error caused by the vibration of the locomotive, it will affect the speed measurement accuracy of a single antenna. The speed measurement results of this module need to be corrected twice in the anti-antenna beam angle error module.

所述的抗天线波束角度误差模块,用于对雷达的前后天线波束中心的角度偏差带来的测速误差进行校正,实现对机车速度的无偏测量,得到最终的速度测量。由于多普勒机车测速雷达的天线在安装时总存在安装角度误差,在机车运行过程中天线也会有随机车振动而产生位置误差,这导致天线波束中心方向与地面的夹角和真实夹角之间存在一定的偏差,给机车速度的测量造成了一定的误差。本发明利用图3所示的具有双天线的多普勒雷达,分别对速度校正模块的速度初次无偏估计进行二次校正,实现对机车速度的无偏测量,得到最终的速度测量。The anti-antenna beam angle error module is used to correct the speed measurement error caused by the angle deviation of the front and rear antenna beam centers of the radar, so as to realize the unbiased measurement of the locomotive speed and obtain the final speed measurement. Since the antenna of the Doppler locomotive speed measuring radar always has an installation angle error during installation, the antenna will also have a position error due to random vehicle vibration during the locomotive operation, which leads to the angle between the center direction of the antenna beam and the ground and the real angle There is a certain deviation between them, which causes a certain error in the measurement of the locomotive speed. The present invention utilizes the Doppler radar with dual antennas shown in FIG. 3 to perform secondary corrections on the primary unbiased estimation of the speed of the speed correction module, so as to realize the unbiased measurement of the locomotive speed and obtain the final speed measurement.

参照图4,本机车速度测量方法包括如下步骤:With reference to Fig. 4, this locomotive speed measurement method comprises the steps:

步骤1,选择采样率为最大采样率的十分之一进行采样,对采样数据进行FFT运算,分别得到前后天线的回波功率频谱。由于首次测量机车速度时没有对机车速度的先验信息,故假设机车刚刚启动,因而取系统最小的采样率作为本时刻的采样率,即用最大采样率的十分之一进行采样。Step 1: Select the sampling rate to be one-tenth of the maximum sampling rate for sampling, and perform FFT operation on the sampled data to obtain the echo power spectrum of the front and rear antennas respectively. Since there is no prior information on the speed of the locomotive when the speed of the locomotive is measured for the first time, it is assumed that the locomotive has just started, so the minimum sampling rate of the system is taken as the sampling rate at this moment, that is, one-tenth of the maximum sampling rate is used for sampling.

步骤2,利用下式分别计算前后天线的回波功率包络对应的频谱区域内的重心,Step 2, use the following formula to calculate the center of gravity in the spectrum region corresponding to the echo power envelope of the front and rear antennas, respectively,

ff bb == ΣΣ ff ii EE. ii ΣΣ EE. ii ,,

其中,Ei为回波功率频率fi对应的功率幅度,fi为回波功率频率,它在最小和最大频率范围(fmin,fmax)内取值,这里的回波功率包络对应的频谱区域,是用频谱相对宽度r%进行选择,Among them, E i is the power amplitude corresponding to the echo power frequency f i , and f i is the echo power frequency, which takes values in the minimum and maximum frequency ranges (f min , f max ), where the echo power envelope corresponds to The spectral region of is selected with the relative width r% of the spectrum,

rr %% == 22 tanthe tan αα ·&Center Dot; sinsin θθ nnn 22

式中,θnn为天线的3dB波束宽度,α是天线波束中心位置与水平面的夹角。In the formula, θ nn is the 3dB beam width of the antenna, and α is the angle between the center position of the antenna beam and the horizontal plane.

步骤3将步骤2估计的两个天线的频谱重心对应的速度乘以校正因子k,分别得到前后天线对机车速度的初次无偏估计。Step 3: Multiply the speed corresponding to the spectral center of gravity of the two antennas estimated in Step 2 by the correction factor k to obtain the initial unbiased estimation of the locomotive speed by the front and rear antennas respectively.

校正因子的求解过程如下:The process of solving the correction factor is as follows:

设定频谱重心估计的机车速度对应的频率为fb,则Set the frequency corresponding to the locomotive speed estimated by the spectral center of gravity as f b , then

ff bb == ΣΣ ii 22 vv λλ coscos θθ ii ·&Center Dot; EE. (( θθ ii )) ΣΣ ii EE. (( θθ ii )) == ΣΣ ii 22 λλ coscos θθ ii ·&Center Dot; EE. (( θθ ii )) ΣΣ ii EE. (( θθ ii )) vv

其中,v为机车真实速度为,λ为天线发射电磁波波长,θi为离散化的天线波束方向与水平面的夹角,E(θi)为天线在角度θi上的增益,Among them, v is the real speed of the locomotive, λ is the wavelength of the electromagnetic wave emitted by the antenna, θ i is the angle between the discretized antenna beam direction and the horizontal plane, E(θ i ) is the gain of the antenna at the angle θ i ,

根据天线波束中心位置与水平面的夹角α和频谱重心估计的机车速度对应的频率fb,将机车真实速度与频谱重心测量的速度的比值表示为:According to the angle α between the antenna beam center position and the horizontal plane and the frequency f b corresponding to the locomotive speed estimated by the spectrum center of gravity, the ratio of the real speed of the locomotive to the speed measured by the spectrum center of gravity is expressed as:

kk == coscos αα ·&Center Dot; ΣEΣE (( θθ ii )) coscos θθ ii ·· EE. (( θθ ii ))

上式即校正因子,是一个常数,也是机车测速多普勒雷达天线回波功率谱的一个特征,它说明利用该校正因子对频谱重心估计的机车速度进行校正能得到更准确的机车测量速度。The above formula is the correction factor, which is a constant and is also a feature of the echo power spectrum of the Doppler radar antenna for locomotive speed measurement. It shows that using this correction factor to correct the locomotive speed estimated by the center of gravity of the spectrum can obtain a more accurate measurement speed of the locomotive.

步骤5通过下式对前天线的初次无偏估计速度进行二次校正,得到前天线对机车速度的最终测量结果:Step 5: Perform secondary correction on the initial unbiased estimated speed of the front antenna by the following formula to obtain the final measurement result of the locomotive speed by the front antenna:

vv AA == 11 22 λλ ·· ff dd 11 ·· tgtg 22 αα 11 ++ 11

其中,α1为前天线的波束中心方向与水平面的夹角,fd1为前天线的初次无偏估计速度对应的频率。Among them, α 1 is the angle between the beam center direction of the front antenna and the horizontal plane, and f d1 is the frequency corresponding to the initial unbiased estimated velocity of the front antenna.

步骤6通过下式对后天线的初次无偏估计速度进行二次校正,得到后天线对机车速度的最终测量:Step 6. Perform secondary correction on the initial unbiased estimated speed of the rear antenna through the following formula to obtain the final measurement of the locomotive speed by the rear antenna:

vv BB == 11 22 λλ ·&Center Dot; ff dd 22 ·&Center Dot; tgtg 22 αα 22 ++ 11

其中,α2为后天线的波束中心方向与水平面的夹角,fd2为后天线的初次无偏估计速度对应的频率。Among them, α 2 is the angle between the beam center direction of the rear antenna and the horizontal plane, and f d2 is the frequency corresponding to the initial unbiased estimated velocity of the rear antenna.

步骤7将前天线和后天线的最终测量速度取平均值,得到对当前时刻机车速度的最终测量结果:Step 7 averages the final measured speeds of the front antenna and the rear antenna to obtain the final measurement result of the locomotive speed at the current moment:

vv == vv AA ++ vv BB 22 ..

步骤8根据步骤7测量的当前时刻的机车速度,按照机车要求的测速相对误差选择下一时刻的采样频率,并对该采样的数据进行快速傅立叶变换运算,分别得到前天线和后天线的在下一时刻的回波功率频谱。Step 8: According to the locomotive speed at the current moment measured in step 7, select the sampling frequency at the next moment according to the relative error of the speed measurement required by the locomotive, and perform fast Fourier transform operation on the sampled data to obtain the next The echo power spectrum at time.

步骤9循环执行步骤2至步骤8,实现对机车速度的实时测量。Step 9 executes step 2 to step 8 in a loop to realize real-time measurement of locomotive speed.

本发明的效果可以通过以下实测数据进一步的说明:Effect of the present invention can be further illustrated by the following measured data:

图5是采用现有最大值法估计的机车速度实测曲线图,图6是采用本发明的频谱包络重心估计的机车速度实测曲线图,从图5和图6的比较可见,采用现有的最大值法估计的机车速度方差很大,也不稳定,而本发明的采用的频谱重心估计的机车速度的方差比较小,也很稳定,估计精度高。Fig. 5 is the measured curve diagram of the locomotive speed estimated by the existing maximum value method, and Fig. 6 is the measured curve diagram of the locomotive speed estimated by the spectrum envelope center of gravity of the present invention, as seen from the comparison of Fig. 5 and Fig. 6, adopting the existing The variance of the locomotive speed estimated by the maximum value method is large and unstable, while the variance of the locomotive speed estimated by the spectrum center of gravity adopted in the present invention is relatively small, stable and has high estimation accuracy.

图7是分别采用前天线和后天线的回波数据测量的机车速度实测曲线图,图8是对图7的测量结果校正后的机车速度实测曲线图。由图7可见,校正前,采用前后天线的回波数据的测量结果存在偏差,这是由于前后天线的波束指向角度误差引起的;由图8可见,经过校正后,两个天线对应的测量速度重合在一起,实现了对波束角度误差的校正,因而对机车速度估计更加平稳,更加准确。Fig. 7 is a curve diagram of actual measurement of locomotive speed measured by using the echo data of front antenna and rear antenna respectively, and Fig. 8 is a curve diagram of actual measurement of locomotive speed after the measurement result of Fig. 7 is corrected. It can be seen from Figure 7 that before correction, there is a deviation in the measurement results of the echo data of the front and rear antennas, which is caused by the beam pointing angle error of the front and rear antennas; it can be seen from Figure 8 that after correction, the corresponding measurement speed of the two antennas Together, the correction of the beam angle error is realized, so the estimation of the speed of the locomotive is more stable and more accurate.

在机车测速雷达中,采用对机车行驶距离的测量误差作为衡量机车测速雷达测速精度,如表所示。In the locomotive speed measurement radar, the measurement error of the locomotive travel distance is used as the measurement accuracy of the locomotive speed measurement radar, as shown in the table.

表1本发明对前后天线实测的7个不同路段的样本数据的处理结果Table 1 The processing results of the present invention to the sample data of 7 different road sections measured by the front and rear antennas

通过表1中的数据可看出,本发明所提出的方法对机车速度的测量很准确,最大的测量误差不超过0.16%。It can be seen from the data in Table 1 that the method proposed by the present invention is very accurate in measuring the speed of the locomotive, and the maximum measurement error does not exceed 0.16%.

综上,本发明充分考虑到机车测速雷达的实际应用问题,根据雷达近场回波功率频谱曲线的特征,通过频谱重心预估计机车的速度,再对该预估计的速度进行初次校正和二次校正得到对机车速度的精确估计不但测速精确,而且很稳健,实际运行情况良好。In summary, the present invention fully considers the practical application of the locomotive speed measuring radar, according to the characteristics of the radar near-field echo power spectrum curve, pre-estimates the speed of the locomotive through the center of gravity of the spectrum, and then performs primary correction and secondary correction on the pre-estimated speed. The accurate estimation of the locomotive speed obtained by calibration is not only accurate in speed measurement, but also very robust, and the actual operation is in good condition.

Claims (4)

1.一种基于雷达近场回波功率谱特征的机车速度测量系统,包括:1. A locomotive speed measurement system based on radar near-field echo power spectrum features, comprising: 选择采样率模块,用于选择采样率,以保证测量速度值的相对误差满足机车测速要求,并将所选的采样率数据送给频谱重心法预估计速度模块;The sampling rate selection module is used to select the sampling rate to ensure that the relative error of the measured speed value meets the requirements of the locomotive speed measurement, and sends the selected sampling rate data to the pre-estimated speed module of the spectral center of gravity method; 频谱重心法预估速度模块,用于预估计雷达的两个天线各自的回波功率频谱重心位置对应的机车速度,并将前后天线对应的预估计速度送入速度校正模块;The spectral center of gravity method estimated speed module is used to estimate the locomotive speed corresponding to the center of gravity position of the echo power spectrum of the two antennas of the radar in advance, and sends the estimated speed corresponding to the front and rear antennas to the speed correction module; 速度校正模块,用于对前后天线对应的预估计速度进行校正,得到单个天线对机车速度的初次无偏估计,并将两个天线各自校正后的速度送入抗天线波束角度误差模块;The speed correction module is used to correct the estimated speed corresponding to the front and rear antennas, obtain the initial unbiased estimate of the speed of the locomotive by a single antenna, and send the corrected speeds of the two antennas to the anti-antenna beam angle error module; 抗天线波束角度误差模块,用于对雷达的前后天线波束中心的角度偏差带来的测速误差进行校正,实现对机车速度的无偏测量,得到最终的速度测量结果。The anti-antenna beam angle error module is used to correct the speed measurement error caused by the angle deviation of the front and rear antenna beam centers of the radar, realize the unbiased measurement of the locomotive speed, and obtain the final speed measurement result. 2.一种基于雷达近场回波功率频谱特征的机车速度测量方法,包括如下过程:2. A method for measuring the speed of a locomotive based on radar near-field echo power spectrum features, comprising the following processes: (1)选择采样率为最大采样率的十分之一进行采样,对采样数据进行FFT运算,分别得到前天线和后天线的回波功率频谱;(1) Select the sampling rate to be one-tenth of the maximum sampling rate for sampling, and perform FFT operation on the sampling data to obtain the echo power spectrum of the front antenna and the rear antenna respectively; (2)利用下式分别计算前后天线的回波功率包络对应的频谱区域内的重心,(2) Use the following formula to calculate the center of gravity in the spectrum region corresponding to the echo power envelope of the front and rear antennas respectively, ff bb == ΣΣ ff ii EE. ii ΣΣ EE. ii -- -- -- 11 )) 其中,Ei为回波功率频率fi对应的功率幅度,fi为回波功率频率,它在最小和最大频率范围(fmin,fmax)内取值;Wherein, E i is the power amplitude corresponding to the echo power frequency f i , and f i is the echo power frequency, which takes values within the minimum and maximum frequency ranges (f min , f max ); (3)将步骤(2)估计的前后天线回波功率谱的重心对应的速度乘以校正因子k,分别得到采用前后天线的回波功率谱对机车速度的初次无偏估计,校正因子的求解公式为(3) Multiply the speed corresponding to the center of gravity of the front and rear antenna echo power spectra estimated in step (2) by the correction factor k to obtain the initial unbiased estimation of the locomotive speed using the echo power spectra of the front and rear antennas respectively, and the solution of the correction factor The formula is kk == coscos αα ·&Center Dot; ΣEΣE (( θθ ii )) ΣΣ coscos θθ ii ·&Center Dot; EE. (( θθ ii )) ,, -- -- -- 22 )) 式中,α是天线的波束中心方向与水平面夹角,θi为离散化的天线波束方向与水平面的夹角,θi在天线3dB波束宽带范围内,即(θmin,θmax)内取值,E(θi)为天线在波束角度θi上的增益;In the formula, α is the angle between the beam center direction of the antenna and the horizontal plane, θ i is the angle between the discretized antenna beam direction and the horizontal plane, and θ i is within the 3dB beam broadband range of the antenna, that is, within (θ min , θ max ) value, E(θ i ) is the gain of the antenna at the beam angle θ i ; (4)通过下式对前天线的初次无偏估计速度进行二次校正,得到利用前天线对机车速度的最终测量结果,(4) Perform secondary correction on the initial unbiased estimated speed of the front antenna by the following formula to obtain the final measurement result of the locomotive speed using the front antenna, vv AA == 11 22 λλ ·&Center Dot; ff dd 11 ·&Center Dot; tgtg 22 αα 11 ++ 11 -- -- -- 33 )) 其中,λ为发射波波长,α1为前天线的波束中心方向与水平面的夹角,fd1为前天线的初次无偏估计速度对应的频率;Among them, λ is the wavelength of the transmitted wave , α 1 is the angle between the beam center direction of the front antenna and the horizontal plane, and f d1 is the frequency corresponding to the initial unbiased estimated speed of the front antenna; (5)通过下式对后天线的初次无偏估计速度进行二次校正,得到利用后天线对机车速度的最终测量,(5) Perform a secondary correction on the initial unbiased estimated speed of the rear antenna by the following formula to obtain the final measurement of the locomotive speed using the rear antenna, vv BB == 11 22 λλ ·&Center Dot; ff dd 22 ·&Center Dot; tgtg 22 αα 22 ++ 11 -- -- -- 44 )) 其中,α2为后天线的波束中心方向与水平面的夹角,fd2为后天线的初次无偏估计速度对应的频率;Among them, α2 is the angle between the beam center direction of the rear antenna and the horizontal plane, and f d2 is the frequency corresponding to the initial unbiased estimated velocity of the rear antenna; (6)将前后天线对应的最终测量速度取平均值,得到对当前时刻机车速度的最终测量结果;(6) average the final measurement speeds corresponding to the front and rear antennas to obtain the final measurement results of the locomotive speed at the current moment; vv == vv AA ++ vv BB 22 -- -- -- 55 )) (7)根据步骤(6)测量的当前时刻的机车速度,按照机车要求的测速相对误差选择下一时刻的采样频率,并对采样的数据进行FFT运算,分别得到前天线和后天线的在下一时刻的回波功率频谱;(7) According to the locomotive speed at the current moment measured in step (6), select the sampling frequency at the next moment according to the relative error of the speed measurement required by the locomotive, and perform FFT calculation on the sampled data to obtain the front antenna and the rear antenna respectively in the next Echo power spectrum at time; (8)循环执行步骤(2)至步骤(7),实现对机车速度的实时测量。(8) Steps (2) to (7) are cyclically executed to realize real-time measurement of the speed of the locomotive. 3.根据权利要求2所述的机车速度测量方法,其特征在于步骤(2)中所述的频谱区域,是用频谱相对宽度r%进行选择,3. the locomotive speed measuring method according to claim 2 is characterized in that the spectrum region described in the step (2) is to select with the relative width r% of the spectrum, rr %% == 22 tanthe tan αα ·· sinsin θθ nnn 22 -- -- -- 66 )) 式中,θnn为天线的3dB波束宽度,α是天线波束中心位置与水平面的夹角。In the formula, θ nn is the 3dB beam width of the antenna, and α is the angle between the center position of the antenna beam and the horizontal plane. 4.根据权利要求2所述的机车速度测量方法,其特征在于步骤(7)中所述的选择下一时刻的采样率,是将机车速度按照由大到小分为10档,每档速度对应一个采样频率,在采样点数不变的条件下,找出当前的测量速度值对应的速度档,选取该速度档的采样率作为下一时刻的采样率。4. the locomotive speed measurement method according to claim 2, is characterized in that the sampling rate of the selection next moment described in the step (7) is that the locomotive speed is divided into 10 gears according to from large to small, each gear speed Corresponding to a sampling frequency, under the condition that the number of sampling points remains unchanged, find out the speed gear corresponding to the current measured speed value, and select the sampling rate of this speed gear as the sampling rate at the next moment.
CN2009102192170A 2009-11-27 2009-11-27 System and method for measuring speed of locomotive based on radar near field echo power spectrum characteristics Expired - Fee Related CN101738601B (en)

Priority Applications (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN2009102192170A CN101738601B (en) 2009-11-27 2009-11-27 System and method for measuring speed of locomotive based on radar near field echo power spectrum characteristics

Applications Claiming Priority (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN2009102192170A CN101738601B (en) 2009-11-27 2009-11-27 System and method for measuring speed of locomotive based on radar near field echo power spectrum characteristics

Publications (2)

Publication Number Publication Date
CN101738601A CN101738601A (en) 2010-06-16
CN101738601B true CN101738601B (en) 2012-06-20

Family

ID=42462322

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
CN2009102192170A Expired - Fee Related CN101738601B (en) 2009-11-27 2009-11-27 System and method for measuring speed of locomotive based on radar near field echo power spectrum characteristics

Country Status (1)

Country Link
CN (1) CN101738601B (en)

Families Citing this family (11)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN102004246B (en) * 2010-09-10 2012-08-15 浙江大学 Fault diagnosis and reading speed correction method of antenna included angle deviation of train vehicle-mounted radar speed sensor
DE102012200139A1 (en) * 2012-01-05 2013-07-11 Robert Bosch Gmbh Method and device for wheel-independent speed measurement in a vehicle
CN103743403A (en) * 2014-01-22 2014-04-23 中国船舶重工集团公司第七〇五研究所 Calculating method of single-frequency signal reverberation center
CN104635231B (en) * 2015-02-12 2017-07-18 西安电子科技大学 Locomotive radar velocity measurement method based on adaptive Kalman filter
CN105372649A (en) * 2015-11-03 2016-03-02 黄中瑞 Railroad locomotive speed measurement method based on adaptive double-path sampling filtering
CN105334511A (en) * 2015-11-03 2016-02-17 周青松 Railroad locomotive velocity measurement method based on extraction of Doppler signal frequency
CN108802716B (en) * 2017-12-29 2020-04-21 西安电子科技大学 Ranging Method of Frequency Modulated Continuous Wave Landing Radar Based on Center of Gravity Correction
CN109597060B (en) * 2018-12-07 2021-06-25 北京敏视达雷达有限公司 Radar speed measurement method and device
CN109738697B (en) * 2019-01-24 2021-02-26 中国电子科技集团公司第二十九研究所 Frequency measurement method based on finite point discrete spectrum correction
CN112881990B (en) * 2021-01-15 2024-01-16 陕西长岭电子科技有限责任公司 Doppler radar speed resolving method based on antenna near field test
CN113835071B (en) * 2021-10-19 2024-08-06 中安锐达(北京)电子科技有限公司 Method for correcting azimuth beam center of mechanically-swept radar based on signal processing angle

Citations (1)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN2783345Y (en) * 2004-12-15 2006-05-24 包振峰 Digital cameback speed test radar

Patent Citations (1)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN2783345Y (en) * 2004-12-15 2006-05-24 包振峰 Digital cameback speed test radar

Non-Patent Citations (2)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Title
姬冰冰等.《机车测速雷达的稳健算法研究》.《中国雷达》.2008,(第4期),全文. *
孙多等.《机车多普勒测速雷达波束方向校正方法》.《火控雷达技术》.2009,第38卷(第1期),全文. *

Also Published As

Publication number Publication date
CN101738601A (en) 2010-06-16

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
CN101738601B (en) System and method for measuring speed of locomotive based on radar near field echo power spectrum characteristics
CN104635231B (en) Locomotive radar velocity measurement method based on adaptive Kalman filter
CN105556332B (en) The dispersion correction of fmcw radar in pipeline or pipe
CN110531328B (en) A method for estimating beam center pointing error of spaceborne ring-sweep radar
CN105005040B (en) Radar angle measurement method
CN106199582B (en) Method applied to indoor two-frequency CW radar human body locating and tracking
CN102707275B (en) Digital processing method of altimeter of linear frequency modulation continuous wave radar
CN102967855B (en) Signal processing method for improving background subtraction technology in different-place continuous calibration RCS (Radar Cross-Section) measurement
CN103412301B (en) Metrewave radar angle measurement method
CN107678003A (en) Object detection method and device under a kind of ground wave radar sea clutter background
CN101937077B (en) Measuring method of bi-static forward-looking and squinting synthetic aperture radar Doppler center frequency
CN102004246B (en) Fault diagnosis and reading speed correction method of antenna included angle deviation of train vehicle-mounted radar speed sensor
CN105974390B (en) Ji Sao metre wave radars mass centre angle-measuring method based on doppler information
CN105974389A (en) Mechanic scan meter-wave radar monopulse angle measuring method based on iterative processing
CN104215946A (en) Sky wave and ground wave hybrid radar echo spectrum simulating method
CN105259537B (en) Doppler spectral center frequency estimation method based on frequency displacement iteration
CN103487798A (en) Method for measuring height of phase array radar
CN108535719A (en) CW with frequency modulation landing radar speed-measuring method based on the correction of Doppler frequency spectrum center of gravity
CN106526553A (en) General and accurate SAR satellite azimuth ambiguity performance analysis method
CN103364783A (en) Moving target radial velocity non-fuzzy estimation method based on single-channel SAR (synthetic aperture radar)
CN204789618U (en) Ultrasonic wave wind speed measuring device
CN103217669B (en) Sub-range profile offset deviation-based satellite borne SAR (Synthetic Aperture Radar) ionosphere calibration method
CN103412302B (en) Multiple carrier frequency MISO radar target locating method based on priori knowledge
CN102141611A (en) Method for rapidly determining Doppler fuzzy number of squint synthetic aperture radar
Xu et al. Comparison of speed over ground estimation using acoustic and radar Doppler sensors

Legal Events

Date Code Title Description
C06 Publication
PB01 Publication
C10 Entry into substantive examination
SE01 Entry into force of request for substantive examination
C14 Grant of patent or utility model
GR01 Patent grant
CF01 Termination of patent right due to non-payment of annual fee
CF01 Termination of patent right due to non-payment of annual fee

Granted publication date: 20120620

Termination date: 20151127