Skip to main content
In: The Matter of Mimesis, ed. M. Bol and E.C. Spary (Brill, 2023), pp. 381-416.


This is an open access chapter distributed under the terms of the CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 license.
La route des succédanés. Les remèdes exotiques, l’innovation médicale et le marché des substituts au XVIe siècle (Revue d'histoire moderne et contemporaine 66/3 (2019)). This article explores the history of exotic drugs through a central... more
La route des succédanés. Les remèdes exotiques, l’innovation médicale et le marché des substituts au XVIe siècle (Revue d'histoire moderne et contemporaine 66/3 (2019)).

This article explores the history of exotic drugs through a central but often ignored issue: the use of substitutes. It does so by comparing how differently plants originating from the « East » and plants originating from the Americas lent themselves to be replaced in the practice and imaginary of sixteenth-century apothecaries. It examines the values, desires and tensions that apothecaries in Italy and Iberia inscribed in the act of substitution and the substances behind it.
In Helen Ann Curry, Nicholas Jardine, James A. Secord, and E.C. Spary, eds., Worlds of Natural History (Cambridge University Press, 2018). A closer look at the involvement of Italian apothecaries in sixteenth-century natural history and... more
In Helen Ann Curry, Nicholas Jardine, James A. Secord, and E.C. Spary, eds., Worlds of Natural History (Cambridge University Press, 2018).

A closer look at the involvement of Italian apothecaries in sixteenth-century natural history and collecting, and their contribution to that emerging field of expertise.
Research Interests:
In Physician, Polity and Pen in Early Modern Europe, ed. A. Kinzelbach, J.A. Mendelsohn, R. Schilling (The History of Medicine in Context, ed. A. Cunningham and O. Grell; Routledge, 2019).
Research Interests:
This article examines the role of testing and innovation in sixteenth-century Italian pharmacy. I argue that apothecaries were less concerned with testing drugs for efficacy or creating novel products than with reactivating an older... more
This article examines the role of testing and innovation in sixteenth-century Italian pharmacy. I argue that apothecaries were less concerned with testing drugs for efficacy or creating novel products than with reactivating an older Mediterranean pharmacological tradition and studying the materials on which it relied. Their practice was not driven by radical experimentation but by a “culture of tweaking”–of minute operational changes to existing recipes and accommodation of their textual variants–which was rooted in the guild economy fostering incremental over radical innovation and in a humanist reevaluation of past autorities. Workshop practice was also increasingly driven by a new ideal of staying true to nature fostered by the period’s botanical renaissance. This led to an emphasis on ingredients over processes in the shop, and found clearest expression in the elaboration of a taxonomic “language of truth” that helped apothecaries discern between authentic and inauthentic materia medica and harness their sincerity in lieu of testing effectiveness.
The epistolary exchanges of early modern natural history have long been of interest to historians of science, as they reflect the dynamic nature of the emergent discipline better than the printed volumes of natural history. Less... more
The epistolary exchanges of early modern natural history have long been of interest to historians of science, as they reflect the dynamic nature of the emergent discipline better than the printed volumes of natural history. Less attention, at least until recently, has been paid to the unfinished pieces, the cryptic marginalia, and the practical notes that more often than not accompanied letters. Lists of specimens sent or requested were among the new tools at the naturalist's disposal for dealing with a scientific world increasingly populated by objects. This essay seeks to reconstruct the genealogy of specimen lists by focusing on little-known apothecaries in northern Italy: the individuals traditionally held to be social counterparts to these modest strings of words. It seems that the operations at the back of the shop and the literature generated by the centuries-old drug and spice trades may have been a more defining influence on early modern naturalists than the humanist practices of indexing and commonplacing that were concurrently embraced by Italian studiosi.
This is an introduction to the world of artisanal contacts of the Flemish botanist Carolus Clusius (1526‒1609) within the context of Venice and the Veneto. Despite Clusius’s renowned generosity and openness to exchanges with tradesmen and... more
This is an introduction to the world of artisanal contacts of the Flemish botanist Carolus Clusius (1526‒1609) within the context of Venice and the Veneto. Despite Clusius’s renowned generosity and openness to exchanges with tradesmen and empirically-educated naturalists in continental Europe, his direct interactions with apothecaries from the Veneto, and indeed from the Italian peninsula, seem to have been very limited. This article considers some of the reasons for this discrepancy, advancing the thesis that behind Clusius’s disinterest in these individuals lay different natural historical interests and a different conception of exotic nature.
"This is an introduction to the world of artisanal contacts of the Flemish botanist Carolus Clusius (1526‒1609) within the context of Venice and the Veneto. Despite Clusius’s renowned generosity and openness to exchanges with tradesmen... more
"This is an introduction to the world of artisanal contacts of the Flemish botanist Carolus Clusius (1526‒1609) within the context of Venice  and the Veneto. Despite  Clusius’s renowned generosity and openness to exchanges with tradesmen and empirically-educated naturalists in continental Europe, his direct interactions with apothecaries from the Veneto, and indeed from the Italian peninsula, seem to have been very limited. This article con- siders some of the reasons for this discrepancy, advancing the thesis that behind Clusius’s disinterest in these individuals lay different natural historical interests and a different conception of exotic nature.
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
Interview for the Ottoman History Podcast (Interviewer: Nir Shafir). Starting in the fifteenth century, medical doctors from the Italian peninsula began accompanying Venetian consular missions to cities in the Mamluk and Ottoman empires.... more
Interview for the Ottoman History Podcast (Interviewer: Nir Shafir).

Starting in the fifteenth century, medical doctors from the Italian peninsula began accompanying Venetian consular missions to cities in the Mamluk and Ottoman empires. These doctors treated not only Venetian consular officials, but also local artisans and rulers. In this podcast, Valentina Pugliano discusses the experiences of these travelling doctors both in the Italian peninsula and in the Middle East. We explore their interactions with the local population and their effect on the medical ecology of the Middle East as well as the sources we use to write such histories. Together, the experiences of these doctors point to the connected histories of medicine and science in the early modern Mediterranean.

Listen to the podcast here! https://soundcloud.com/ottoman-history-podcast/venetian-physicians-in-the-ottoman-empire-valentina-pugliano
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
MEDICINE, ENVIRONMENT AND HEALTH IN THE EASTERN MEDITERRANEAN WORLD 1400-1750 Christ’s College, University of Cambridge Monday 3 and Tuesday 4 April 2017 Organized by Valentina Pugliano (Cambridge) and Nükhet Varlık (Rutgers-Newark)... more
MEDICINE, ENVIRONMENT AND HEALTH IN THE EASTERN MEDITERRANEAN WORLD 1400-1750

Christ’s College, University of Cambridge
Monday 3 and Tuesday 4 April 2017

Organized by Valentina Pugliano (Cambridge) and Nükhet Varlık (Rutgers-Newark)

Generously sponsored by the Wellcome Trust and Christ's College, Cambridge

This conference will offer, for the first time, a comprehensive picture of medicine and healing in the eastern Mediterranean and the Near East, ca. 1400-1750. While a considerable body of scholarship exists on Islamic and Byzantine science and medicine and their influence on the medieval Latin West, the state of medical theory and practice in the following centuries has been comparatively neglected and often spoken of in terms of intellectual stagnation and decline. The conference aims to challenge this narrative and reveal the continued vitality of knowledge making and transfer across the eastern Mediterranean world. Taking as our focus the politically heterogeneous southern Europe and eastern Mediterranean, the Mamluk Kingdom, and the Ottoman Empire, we will reconstruct the healthscape of this region in the early modern period, exploring its medical unity and disunity and the human and environmental factors that played a part in it.

With an introductory lecture by Professor Peregrine Horden, Royal Holloway University of London.

Please register here: https://www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/medicine-environment-and-health-in-the-eastern-mediterranean-world-1400-1750-tickets-32272100722

Registration: Full £50 (per day £25); Students £25. Buffet lunch and refreshments included. We can provide support to book overnight accommodation in college for attendees who wish to do so. For any query, please contact Valentina Pugliano (vp261@cam.ac.uk)
Research Interests:
CALL FOR PAPERS MEDICINE, ENVIRONMENT AND HEALTH IN THE EASTERN MEDITERRANEAN WORLD, 1400-1750. 3-4 April 2017, Cambridge UK Organised by Valentina Pugliano (Cambridge) and Nukhet Varlik (Rutgers-Newark) This conference aims to offer,... more
CALL FOR PAPERS

MEDICINE, ENVIRONMENT AND HEALTH IN THE EASTERN MEDITERRANEAN WORLD, 1400-1750.

3-4 April 2017, Cambridge UK

Organised by Valentina Pugliano (Cambridge) and Nukhet Varlik (Rutgers-Newark)

This conference aims to offer, for the first time, a comprehensive picture of medicine, environment and health in the eastern Mediterranean and the Near East, ca. 1400-1750. While a considerable body of scholarship exists on Islamic and Byzantine science and medicine and their influence on the medieval Latin West, the state of medical theory and practice in the following centuries has been comparatively neglected and often spoken of in terms of intellectual stagnation and decline. The conference aims to challenge this narrative and reveal the continued vitality of knowledge making and transfer across the eastern Mediterranean world. Taking as our focus the politically heterogeneous southern Europe and eastern Mediterranean, the Mamluk Kingdom, and the Ottoman Empire, we aim to reconstruct the healthscape of this region in the early modern period, exploring its medical unity and disunity and the human and environmental factors that played a part in it.
Research Interests:
European History, Greek History, Jewish Studies, Ottoman History, Medieval History, and 30 more
The Bolognese physician Ulisse Aldrovandi (1522-1605) is well known to both historians of science and of art for his active interest in natural history and for his generous patronage of several Italian and German artists, such as the... more
The Bolognese physician Ulisse Aldrovandi (1522-1605) is well known to both historians of science and of art for his active interest in natural history and for his generous patronage of several Italian and German artists, such as the Veronese Jacopo Ligozzi and the Frankfurt-born Cornelius Schwindt. For more than fifty years, the naturalist relied on his so-called ‘artistic workshop’ for the preparation of hundreds of drawings, watercolours, woodcuts, and engravings portraying the plants, animals, and minerals that filled his museum of nature and provided the raw material for his botanical and zoological studies. Upon embarking on his career of artistic patron as early as the 1560s, Aldrovandi began thinking about the relationship between painting and botanical knowledge, between the art of representation and the truth of nature. Little known, however, is that he also began to ponder more specifically about pigments and colours, leaving scattered notes as well as full essays that speak of his significant fascination for the subject. This paper will investigate these writings and Aldrovandi’s ‘colour sensiblity’, focusing in particular on an unpublished manuscript which, entitled De coloribus, yet bears little relation to the pseudo-Aristotelian treatise of the same name. We will find the naturalist interested not so much in the materiality of pigment production, as in the history of colours, their variety and their tradition in the literature of ancients and moderns. Colours were appreaciated for their aesthetic and symbolic value. They were also thought to provide one of the most reliable signs for the correct identification of natural specimens. We will discuss the naturalist’s understanding of colours through the twofold filter of art collecting and consumerism, and of the epistemological accuracy that science required of art.
Damascus, 29 August 1542. Cornelio Bianchi, physician to the Venetian Consul, returns to his lodgings in his nation's fondaco after attending a local court hearing. Once there, he fetches his journal and summarizes the morning's... more
Damascus, 29 August 1542. Cornelio Bianchi, physician to the Venetian Consul, returns to his lodgings in his nation's fondaco after attending a local court hearing. Once there, he fetches his journal and summarizes the morning's unpleasant events. The presiding Ottoman judge (kadı) had just settled an accusation of misconduct presented against him by a resident 'Turk', by ordering the foreign doctor to pay 8 maidini in 'forced alms' or, as Bianchi computed, Lire 1 soldi 12. The claim concerned the payment for a standard purgative treatment Bianchi had ordered for his patient at the consular apothecary's, a laxative drink made with dates and two syrups. Whereas the Turk claimed the doctor had pocketed the money meant for the apothecary and demanded reimbursement, Bianchi believed the real reason for the quarrel to be his own unwillingness to enter into a contract of cure (patto di guarir) with the man. As a 'French disease' sufferer, the latter probably promised an undesirably long and uncertain case. Bianchi followed this entry with a 'Resolution': never again to treat 'Turks or Moors or similar scoundrels'. This vow was destined to be short-lived, however, and Damascene Muslims continued to form part of his clientele alongside Christians and Jews. Similarly, his commitment to contracts remained low.
In Helen Ann Curry, Nicholas Jardine, James A. Secord, and E.C. Spary, eds., Worlds of Natural History (Cambridge University Press, 2018). A closer look at the involvement of Italian apothecaries in sixteenth-century natural history and... more
In Helen Ann Curry, Nicholas Jardine, James A. Secord, and E.C. Spary, eds., Worlds of Natural History (Cambridge University Press, 2018). A closer look at the involvement of Italian apothecaries in sixteenth-century natural history and collecting, and their contribution to that emerging field of expertise.
This article examines the role of testing and innovation in sixteenthcentury Italian pharmacy. I argue that apothecaries were less concerned with testing drugs for efficacy or creating novel products than with reactivating an older... more
This article examines the role of testing and innovation in sixteenthcentury Italian pharmacy. I argue that apothecaries were less concerned with testing drugs for efficacy or creating novel products than with reactivating an older Mediterranean pharmacological tradition and studying the materials on which it relied. Their practice was not driven by radical experimentation but by a "culture of tweaking"-of minute operational changes to existing recipes and accommodation of their textual variants-which was rooted in the guild economy fostering incremental over radical innovation and in a humanist reevaluation of past autorities. Workshop practice was also increasingly driven by a new ideal of staying true to nature fostered by the period's botanical renaissance. This led to an emphasis on ingredients over processes in the shop, and found clearest expression in the elaboration of a taxonomic "language of truth" that helped apothecaries discern between authentic...
Famed for his collection of drawings of naturalia and his thoughts on the relationship between painting and natural knowledge, it now appears that the Bolognese naturalist Ulisse Aldrovandi (1522–1605) also pondered specifically color and... more
Famed for his collection of drawings of naturalia and his thoughts on the relationship between painting and natural knowledge, it now appears that the Bolognese naturalist Ulisse Aldrovandi (1522–1605) also pondered specifically color and pigments, compiling not only lists and diagrams of color terms but also a full-length unpublished manuscript entitled De coloribus or Trattato dei colori. Introducing these writings for the first time, this article portrays a scholar not so much interested in the materiality of pigment production, as in the cultural history of hues. It argues that these writings constituted an effort to build a language of color, in the sense both of a standard nomenclature of hues and of a lexicon, a dictionary of their denotations and connotations as documented in the literature of ancients and moderns. This language would serve the naturalist in his artistic patronage and his natural historical studies, where color was considered one of the most reliable signs f...