Closed
Description
Description
Currently, all form themes are located into symfony/twig-bridge. This has some major drawbacks:
- Download all themes when you only want to use one
- No autoconfiguration from Flex
- Impossible to create theme specific
FormType- Bootstrap 5 inline radio/checkbox and switches need a class hack to work while with a SwitchType things are easier
- Testing is complicated
Example
I propose to extract all form themes except form_div_layout.html.twig and form_table_layout.html.twig into the symfony/ux repository or a dedicated one (symfony/form-theme, symfony/ui ?) and split each themes into individual packages
symfony/ux-theme-bootstrapsymfony/ux-theme-tailwindsymfony/ux-theme-foundation- etc ...
Here is an exaustive list of benefits that this could bring:
- Require only the desire form theme (
composer req symfony/ux-theme-bootstrap) - Recipes from Flex (autoconfiguring
twig.form_themesorwebpack.config.js, updatepackages.jsonetc ...) - Custom FormType (SwitchType for Bootstrap)
- Simplify maintenance (split tests which are a mess, see [RFC] Simplify form theme testing for external packages #49775)
- New form themes from the community