User:Guerillero/ACE2018

6 Seats means 6 or less supports and the rest Neutral/oppose.

Questions

Questions from Guerillero

Thank you for running for the hardest and most thankless job on the project. I am rehashing most of my 2015 questions because I don't think that these issues have been resolved over the past three years. Enjoy!

Current Disputes and Cases

2. What are your standards for banning someone from the project compared to a topic ban or some lesser sanction?

4. Nearly every case involves violations of the civility policy in some way, shape, or form. At one time, a remedy called a "Civility Parole" existed but it fell out of vogue. Today, the only tools in the current Arbitrator's toolboxes to deal with civility issues are interaction bans, topic bans, and site bans. What new and creative ways would you bring to the table to solve this problem?

6. Do you believe that the Super Mario Problem exists? How would you fix it?

8. Do you see value in Admonishments and Warnings as remedies at the end of a case?

Insider Baseball

2. Does the workshop serve as a useful portion of a case?

Thoughts

These are my intial thoughts. I asked some questions because I am not 100% locked in with these.

Support

• AGK (talk · message · contribs · page moves · edit summaries · count · api · logs · block log · email)

  AGK fills the NYB/Institutional Memory slot on my bingo sheet. He is someone I haven't always agreed with but I know that he is trying to do his best for the community.

• Courcelles (talk · message · contribs · page moves · edit summaries · count · api · logs · block log · email)

  Courcelles is my top choice this year for arbcom.

• Drmies (talk · message · contribs · page moves · edit summaries · count · api · logs · block log · email)

  Drmies's first time as an arb went well. He has taken a year off and now seems ready to go.

• GorillaWarfare (talk · message · contribs · page moves · edit summaries · count · api · logs · block log · email)

  GW has always been a great member of the committee. If she thinks that she can handle the workload then she is a lock.

• Kelapstick (talk · message · contribs · page moves · edit summaries · count · api · logs · block log · email)

  K-Stick was a very good arb for his first term. I am happy to support him for a second.

• SilkTork (talk · message · contribs · page moves · edit summaries · count · api · logs · block log · email)

  SilkTork impressed me as an arb during his last tenure and I look forward to 2 more years of him in the arb space

Neutral

• DGG (talk · message · contribs · page moves · edit summaries · count · api · logs · block log · email)

  A fine arb, but I would like people to have a year off before their next term.

• Isarra (talk · message · contribs · page moves · edit summaries · count · api · logs · block log · email)

  I like Isarra. Her work on turning Winter into Timless deserves all the praise. Her answers to the questions are, if you read through the performance art, top quality. But, she is leaning into the absurd a bit too much. Sad face.

• Mkdw (talk · message · contribs · page moves · edit summaries · count · api · logs · block log · email)

  A fine arb, but I would like people to have a year off before their next term.

Oppose

• Joe Roe (talk · message · contribs · page moves · edit summaries · count · api · logs · block log · email)

  Keen, but needs more experience.

• Lourdes (talk · message · contribs · page moves · edit summaries · count · api · logs · block log · email)

  Keen, but needs more experience.

Yikes

• Fred Bauder (talk · message · contribs · page moves · edit summaries · count · api · logs · block log · email)
• Robert McClenon (talk · message · contribs · page moves · edit summaries · count · api · logs · block log · email)