The AllMusic review by Stephen Cook stated: "On 1955's Dream of You ... Merrill found reconciliation, sounding both melodramatic and swinging within Gil Evans' darkly spacious, yet economical arrangements. Suitably, torchy ballads are prominent. ... The programmatic quality of Merrill's coyly sensual voice and Evans' slightly askew, bubbling reeds and languid rhythm conjure up dramatic, balmy southern scenes á la Tennessee Williams."[1]
- "People Will Say We're in Love" (Oscar Hammerstein II, Richard Rodgers) - 2:34
- "By Myself" (Howard Dietz, Arthur Schwartz) - 3:23
- "Any Place I Hang My Hat Is Home" (Harold Arlen, Johnny Mercer) - 4:10
- "I've Never Seen" (Don Marcotte) - 3:33
- "He Was Too Good to Me" (Lorenz Hart, Rodgers) - 3:01
- "A New Town Is a Blue Town" (Richard Adler, Jerry Ross) - 3:09
- "You're Lucky to Me" (Eubie Blake, Andy Razaf) - 3:25
- "Where Flamingos Fly" (John Benson Brooks, Harold Courlander, Elthea Peale) - 2:44
- "Dream of You" (Jimmie Lunceford, Michael Morales, Sy Oliver) - 2:53
- "I'm a Fool to Want You" (Frank Sinatra, Joel Herron, Jack Wolf) - 4:06
- "I'm Just a Lucky So and So" (Mack David, Duke Ellington) - 3:08
- "Troubled Waters" (Sam Coslow, Arthur Johnston) - 3:14
- 1992 bonus tracks (Arranged by Johnny Richards)
- "Alone Together" (Master Take) (Dietz, Schwartz) - 3:11
- "Alone Together" (Alternate Take) - 3:10
- "Glad to Be Unhappy" (Hart, Rodgers) - 2:50
- "This Is My Night Cry" (Bill Sanford, Phil Medley) - 3:06
- "How's the World Treating You?" (Alternate Take) (Boudleaux Bryant, Chet Atkins) - 2:57
- "How's the World Treating You?" (Master Take) - 2:56
- 1992 Reissue
- Michael Lang - supervisor
- Will Friedwald - music research
- Kiyoshi "Boxman" Koyama - tape research
- Andrew Nicholas - remastering
- Peter Pullman - liner notes
- Cliff Preiss - additional production assistant