Abstract
We discuss natural limitations on motor performance caused by the time delay required for feedback signals to propagate within the human body or mechanical control systems. By considering a very simple delayed linear servomechanism model, we show there exists a best possible speed-accuracy trade-off similar to Fitts’ law that cannot be exceeded when delay is present. This is strictly a delay effect and does not occur for the ideal case of instantaneous feedback. We then examine the performance of the vector integration to endpoint (VITE) circuit as a model of human movement and show that when this circuit is generalized to include delayed feedback the performance may not exceed that of the servomechanism with an equal delay. We suggest the existence of such a limitation may be a ubiquitous consequence of delay in motor control with the implication that the index of performance in Fitts’ law cannot arbitrarily large.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Admon-Snir H, Segev I (1993) Signal delay and input synchronization in passive dendritic structures. J Neurophysiol 70: 2066–2085
Bullock D, Grossberg S (1988) Neural dynamics of planned arm movements: emergent invariants and speed-accuracy properties during trajectory formation. Psychol Rev 95: 49–90
Bullock D, Grossberg S (1989) VITE and FLETE: neural modules for the trajectory formation and postural control. In: Hershberger W(eds) Volitional action. North-Holland, Amsterdam, pp 253–297
Bullock D, Grossberg S (1991) Adaptive neural networks for control of movement trajectories invariant under speed and force rescaling. Hum Mov Sci 10: 3–53
Bullock D, Grossberg S (1992) Emergence of tri-phasic muscle activation from the nonlinear interactions of central and spinal neural network circuits. Hum Mov Sci 11: 157–167
Bullock D, Cisek P, Grossberg S (1998) Cortical networks for control of voluntary arm movements under variable force conditions. Cereb Cortex 8: 48–62
Beamish D, Bhatti SA, MacKenzie IS, Wu J (2006a) 50 years later: a neurodynamic explanation of Fitts’ law. J R Soc Interface 3: 649–654
Beamish D, MacKenzie IS, Wu J (2006b) Speed-accuracy trade-off of planned arm movements with delayed feedback. Neural Netw 19: 582–599
Beamish D, Peskun C, Wu J (2005) Critical delay for overshooting in planned arm movements with delayed feedback. J Math Biol 50(1): 22–48
Barrett NC, Glencross DJ (1989) Response amendments during manual aiming movements to double-step targets. Acta Psychol 70: 205–217
Burke D, Gracies JM, Mazevet D, Meunier S, Pierrot-Deseilligny E (1994) Non-monosynaptic transmission of the cortical command for voluntary movement in man. J Physiol 480: 191–202
Cabrera JL, Milton JG (2002) On-off intermittency in a human balancing task. Phys Rev Lett 89: 158702
Cabrera JL, Milton JG (2004) Human stick balancing: tuning Levy flights to improve balance control. Chaos 14: 691–698
Cabrera JK, Borman R, Eurich C, Ohira T, Milton JG (2004) State-dependent noise and human balance control. Fluct Noise Lett 4: L107–L117
Carr CE, Konishi M (1988) Axonal delay lines for time measurement in the owl’s brainstem. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA 85: 831–8315
Cisek P, Grossberg S, Bullock D (1998) A cortico-spinal model of reaching and prioprioception under multiple task constraints. J Cogn Neurosci 10: 425–444
Contreras-Vidal JL, Grossberg S, Bullock D (1997) A neural model of cerebellar learning for arm movement control: cortico-spino-cerebellar dynamics. Learn Mem 3: 475–502
Fitts PM (1954) The information capacity of the human motor system in controlling the amplitude of movement. J Exp Psychol 47: 381–391
Fitts PM (1964) The information capacity of discrete motor responses. J Exp Psychol 67: 103–112
Grossberg S, Kuperstein M (1986) Neural dynamics of adaptive sensory-motor control: Ballistic eye movements. Elseview/North-Holland, Amsterdam
Hale J (1977) Theory of functional differential equations. Springer, New York
Hartzell EJ, Dunbar S, Beveridge R, Cortilla R (1983) Helicopter pilot response latency as a function of the spatial arrangement of instruments and controls. In: George FL (ed.) Proceedings of the 18th annual conference on manual control, Dayton, pp 345-364
Hollerback JM, Moore SP, Atkeson CG (1986) Workspace effect in arm movement kinematics derived from joint interpolation. In: Gantchev G, Dimitrov G, Gatev P (eds) Motor Control Plenum Press New York, pp 197–208
Insperger T (2006) Act-and-wait concept for continuous-time control systems with feedback delay. IEEE Trans Control Syst Technol 14: 974–977
ISO (2002) Reference Number ISO 9241-9:2000(E): Ergonomic requirements for office work with visual display terminals (VTDs)-part 9-requirements for non-keyboard input devices. International Organization for Standardization
Keele SW, Posner MI (1968) Processing of visual feedback in rapid movements. J Exp Psychol 77: 155–158
Kvalseth TO (1977) A generalized model of temporal motor control subject to movement constraints. Ergonomics 20: 41–50
Kvalseth TO (1981) Information capacity of two-dimensional human motor responses. Ergonomics 24: 573–757
Leonard CT (1998) The neuroscience of human movement. Mosby-Year Book, Inc., St. Louis
Macdonald N (1989) Biological delay systems: linear stability theory. Cambridge University Press, London
Macefield G, Gandevia S (1992) Peripheral and central delays in the cortical projections from the human truncal muscles. Brain 115: 123–135
MacKenzie IS (1989) A note on the information-theoretic basis for Fitts’ Law. J Motor Behav 21: 323–330
MacKenzie IS (1991) Fitts law as a performance model in human-computer interaction. Doctoral dissertation, University of Toronto
MacKenzie IS (1993) Lag as a determinant of human performance in interactive systems. In: Proceedings of the ACM conference on huma factors in computing systems. INTERCHI ’93, pp 488-493
MacKenzie IS, Soukoreff RW (2004) Towards a standard for pointing device evaluation, perspectives on 27 years of Fitts’ law research in HCI. Int J Hum-Comput Stud 61: 751–789
Miall RC (1996) Task dependent changes in visual feedback control: a frequency analysis of human manual tracking. J Motor Behav 28(2): 125–135
Miall RC, Wolpert DM (1996) Forward models for physiological motor control. Neural Netw 9: 1265–1279
Milton JG (1996) Dynamics of small neural populations. CRM Monograph Series, vol 7, American Mathematical Society, Providence
Moreau L, Sontag E (2003) Balancing at the edge of stability. Phys Rev Lett 68: 020901
Pauvert V, Pierot-Deseilligny E, Rothwell JC (1998) Role of spinal premotoneurons in mediating corticospinal input to forearm motoneurons in man. J Physiol 508.1: 301–312
Sabatini BL, Reghr WG (1996) Timing of neurotransmission at fast synapses in the mammalian brain. Nature 384: 170–172
Stratford KJ, Tarczy-Hornoch K, Martin KAC, Bannister NJ, Jack JJB (1996) Excitatory synaptic inputs to spiny stellate cells in cat visual cortex. Nature 382: 258–261
Tunik E, Frey SH, Grafton ST (2005) Virtual lesions of the anterior intraparietal area disrupt goal-dependent on-line adjustments of grasp. Nature Neuroscience 8: 505–511
Widder DV (1971) An introduction to transform theory. Academic Press, New York
Woodworth RS (1899) The accuracy of voluntary movement. Psychol Rev 3:1-119 (monograph supplement)
Wu J (2001) Introduction to neural dynamics and signal transmission delay. De Gruyter series in nonlinear analysis and applications, vol. 6. Walter de Gruyter
Ugawa Y, Genba-Shimizu K, Kanazawa I (1995) Electrical stimulation of the human descending motor tracts at several levels. Can J Neurosc 22: 36–42
Zelaznik HN, Hawkings B, Kisselburgh L (1983) Rapid visual feedback processing in single aiming movements. J Motor Behav 15: 217–236
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Beamish, D., Bhatti, S., Wu, J. et al. Performance limitations from delay in human and mechanical motor control. Biol Cybern 99, 43–61 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00422-008-0235-z
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00422-008-0235-z